Datasets:

JerMa88
/

BMC_Medicine_Peer_Reviews

title stringlengths 32 37	abstract stringclasses 1 value	full_text stringlengths 117 61.6k	review stringlengths 117 61.6k	source stringclasses 1 value	review_src stringlengths 37 41	criteria_count dict	dimension_scores dict	overall_score float64 0 5	conversations listlengths 2 2	year int64 2k 2.03k
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03982-7	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 0 Date: 17 Oct 2024 Reviewer's report: I read with interest the descriptive study, "Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups" by Zhang et al. The research team perfo...	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 0 Date: 17 Oct 2024 Reviewer's report: I read with interest the descriptive study, "Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups" by Zhang et al. The research team perfo...	BMC	12916_2025_3982_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf	{ "criticism": 1, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 1, "materials_and_methods": 12, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 2, "results_and_discussion": 1, "suggestion_and_solution": 6, "total": 19 }	{ "criticism": 0.05263157894736842, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.05263157894736842, "materials_and_methods": 0.631578947368421, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.10526315789473684, "results_and_discussion": 0.05263157894736842, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.3157894736842105 }	1.210526	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and\nSubgroups\nVersion: 0 Date: 17 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI read with interest the descriptive study, \"Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signa...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03982-7	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 0 Date: 15 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: I am reviewing a manuscript titled "Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups" submitted for publication by Dr. Zhang and colle...	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 0 Date: 15 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: I am reviewing a manuscript titled "Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups" submitted for publication by Dr. Zhang and colle...	BMC	12916_2025_3982_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf	{ "criticism": 9, "example": 30, "importance_and_relevance": 2, "materials_and_methods": 47, "praise": 5, "presentation_and_reporting": 19, "results_and_discussion": 11, "suggestion_and_solution": 29, "total": 86 }	{ "criticism": 0.10465116279069768, "example": 0.3488372093023256, "importance_and_relevance": 0.023255813953488372, "materials_and_methods": 0.5465116279069767, "praise": 0.05813953488372093, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.22093023255813954, "results_and_discussion": 0.12790697674418605, "suggestion_a...	1.767442	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and\nSubgroups\nVersion: 0 Date: 15 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI am reviewing a manuscript titled \"Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in P...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03982-7	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: On review, the authors have addressed my major concerns and criticism. There are couple of small corrections to the discussion I would recommend: Page 21, Line 403 "don’t dire...	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: On review, the authors have addressed my major concerns and criticism. There are couple of small corrections to the discussion I would recommend: Page 21, Line 403 "don’t dire...	BMC	12916_2025_3982_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf	{ "criticism": 3, "example": 5, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 6, "results_and_discussion": 2, "suggestion_and_solution": 6, "total": 10 }	{ "criticism": 0.3, "example": 0.5, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 0.1, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.6, "results_and_discussion": 0.2, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.6 }	2.3	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and\nSubgroups\nVersion: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nOn review, the authors have addressed my major concerns and criticism. There ...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03982-7	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 1 Date: 29 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: I am pleased to review the revised manuscript “Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension Subgroups.” As I have mentioned previously, investig...	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 1 Date: 29 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: I am pleased to review the revised manuscript “Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension Subgroups.” As I have mentioned previously, investig...	BMC	12916_2025_3982_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf	{ "criticism": 2, "example": 4, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 8, "praise": 2, "presentation_and_reporting": 9, "results_and_discussion": 1, "suggestion_and_solution": 7, "total": 21 }	{ "criticism": 0.09523809523809523, "example": 0.19047619047619047, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0.38095238095238093, "praise": 0.09523809523809523, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.42857142857142855, "results_and_discussion": 0.047619047619047616, "suggestion_and_solution": 0....	1.571429	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and\nSubgroups\nVersion: 1 Date: 29 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI am pleased to review the revised manuscript “Distinct Airway Mycobiome Sign...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03982-7	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 2 Date: 07 Feb 2025 Reviewer's report: On re-review, the authors have addressed my major concerns and criticism. The issues with association/causation has been addressed . I appreciate the authors attention to deta...	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 2 Date: 07 Feb 2025 Reviewer's report: On re-review, the authors have addressed my major concerns and criticism. The issues with association/causation has been addressed . I appreciate the authors attention to deta...	BMC	12916_2025_3982_ReviewerReport_V2_R3.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 2, "presentation_and_reporting": 1, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0, "total": 3 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 0.6666666666666666, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0 }	1	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and\nSubgroups\nVersion: 2 Date: 07 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nOn re-review, the authors have addressed my major concerns and criticism. The...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03982-7	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 2 Date: 10 Feb 2025 Reviewer's report: The authors have addressed my comments.	Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and Subgroups Version: 2 Date: 10 Feb 2025 Reviewer's report: The authors have addressed my comments.	BMC	12916_2025_3982_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0, "total": 1 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0 }	0	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Distinct Airway Mycobiome Signature in Patients with Pulmonary Hypertension and\nSubgroups\nVersion: 2 Date: 10 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have addressed my comments.", "role": "assistant" } ]	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03976-5	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles among postmenopausal women in China Version: 0 Date: 08 Sep 2024 Reviewer's report: In their manuscript, Sun and colleagues estimate the fraction of stroke (overall, ischemic, hemorrhagic, and subarachnoid hemorrhagic att...	Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles among postmenopausal women in China Version: 0 Date: 08 Sep 2024 Reviewer's report: In their manuscript, Sun and colleagues estimate the fraction of stroke (overall, ischemic, hemorrhagic, and subarachnoid hemorrhagic att...	BMC	12916_2025_3976_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 3, "example": 4, "importance_and_relevance": 1, "materials_and_methods": 14, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 8, "suggestion_and_solution": 4, "total": 26 }	{ "criticism": 0.11538461538461539, "example": 0.15384615384615385, "importance_and_relevance": 0.038461538461538464, "materials_and_methods": 0.5384615384615384, "praise": 0.038461538461538464, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0.3076923076923077, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.1...	1.346154	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles\namong postmenopausal women in China\nVersion: 0 Date: 08 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nIn their manuscript, Sun and colleagues...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03976-5	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles among postmenopausal women in China Version: 0 Date: 16 Sep 2024 Reviewer's report: Thank you for reviewing this manuscript! The authors examined population-attributable fractions of stroke and its subtypes associated wit...	Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles among postmenopausal women in China Version: 0 Date: 16 Sep 2024 Reviewer's report: Thank you for reviewing this manuscript! The authors examined population-attributable fractions of stroke and its subtypes associated wit...	BMC	12916_2025_3976_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf	{ "criticism": 5, "example": 4, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 7, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 10, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 12, "total": 37 }	{ "criticism": 0.13513513513513514, "example": 0.10810810810810811, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0.1891891891891892, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.2702702702702703, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.32432432432432434 }	1.027027	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles\namong postmenopausal women in China\nVersion: 0 Date: 16 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for reviewing this manuscript...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03976-5	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles among postmenopausal women in China Version: 1 Date: 18 Dec 2024 Reviewer's report: I appreciate the efforts of Sun et al. to address my comments on their manuscript calculating the of risk of stroke (overall and by subty...	Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles among postmenopausal women in China Version: 1 Date: 18 Dec 2024 Reviewer's report: I appreciate the efforts of Sun et al. to address my comments on their manuscript calculating the of risk of stroke (overall and by subty...	BMC	12916_2025_3976_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 3, "importance_and_relevance": 1, "materials_and_methods": 2, "praise": 2, "presentation_and_reporting": 3, "results_and_discussion": 1, "suggestion_and_solution": 4, "total": 14 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0.21428571428571427, "importance_and_relevance": 0.07142857142857142, "materials_and_methods": 0.14285714285714285, "praise": 0.14285714285714285, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.21428571428571427, "results_and_discussion": 0.07142857142857142, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.2...	1.142857	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Socioeconomic variations in the proportions of stroke attributable to reproductive profiles\namong postmenopausal women in China\nVersion: 1 Date: 18 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI appreciate the efforts of Sun et al. ...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03973-8	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Research prioritisation in preparedness for and response to outbreaks of high-consequence pathogens: a scoping review Version: 0 Date: 09 Jan 2025 Reviewer: Amesh A. Adalja Reviewer's report: I think this paper is interesting and straight forward providing good information on how this process occurs. One thing ...	Title: Research prioritisation in preparedness for and response to outbreaks of high-consequence pathogens: a scoping review Version: 0 Date: 09 Jan 2025 Reviewer: Amesh A. Adalja Reviewer's report: I think this paper is interesting and straight forward providing good information on how this process occurs. One thing ...	BMC	12916_2025_3973_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 1, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 1, "materials_and_methods": 1, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 1, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 1, "total": 3 }	{ "criticism": 0.3333333333333333, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333, "materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333, "praise": 0.3333333333333333, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.3333333333333333 }	2	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Research prioritisation in preparedness for and response to outbreaks of high-consequence\npathogens: a scoping review\nVersion: 0 Date: 09 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Amesh A. Adalja\nReviewer's report:\nI think this paper is...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03973-8	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Research prioritisation in preparedness for and response to outbreaks of high-consequence pathogens: a scoping review Version: 0 Date: 20 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: Studies such as this are important and add pieces to the puzzle to ultimately help us prepare for the next inevitable public health threat. The pap...	Title: Research prioritisation in preparedness for and response to outbreaks of high-consequence pathogens: a scoping review Version: 0 Date: 20 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: Studies such as this are important and add pieces to the puzzle to ultimately help us prepare for the next inevitable public health threat. The pap...	BMC	12916_2025_3973_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 3, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 5, "presentation_and_reporting": 1, "results_and_discussion": 1, "suggestion_and_solution": 2, "total": 5 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.6, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.2, "results_and_discussion": 0.2, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.4 }	2.4	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Research prioritisation in preparedness for and response to outbreaks of high-consequence\npathogens: a scoping review\nVersion: 0 Date: 20 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nStudies such as this are important and add pieces...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03969-4	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 0 Date: 19 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: Duan et al examined the association between smoking-related gut microbiota alteration (represented by smokin...	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 0 Date: 19 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: Duan et al examined the association between smoking-related gut microbiota alteration (represented by smokin...	BMC	12916_2025_3969_ReviewerReport_V0_R6.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 1, "materials_and_methods": 9, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 2, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 2, "total": 18 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.05555555555555555, "materials_and_methods": 0.5, "praise": 0.05555555555555555, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.1111111111111111, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.1111111111111111 }	0.833333	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related\ndiseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses\nVersion: 0 Date: 19 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nDuan et al...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03969-4	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 0 Date: 24 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: The study design is unclear. The authors initially describe the work as a systematic review. However, they p...	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 0 Date: 24 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: The study design is unclear. The authors initially describe the work as a systematic review. However, they p...	BMC	12916_2025_3969_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf	{ "criticism": 6, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 8, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 2, "total": 11 }	{ "criticism": 0.5454545454545454, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0.7272727272727273, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.18181818181818182 }	1.454545	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related\ndiseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses\nVersion: 0 Date: 24 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe study ...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03969-4	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 0 Date: 29 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: Shankuan Zhu's team utilised population databases to deeply investigate the relationship between smoking and...	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 0 Date: 29 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: Shankuan Zhu's team utilised population databases to deeply investigate the relationship between smoking and...	BMC	12916_2025_3969_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 4, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 11, "materials_and_methods": 19, "praise": 3, "presentation_and_reporting": 10, "results_and_discussion": 5, "suggestion_and_solution": 16, "total": 32 }	{ "criticism": 0.125, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.34375, "materials_and_methods": 0.59375, "praise": 0.09375, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.3125, "results_and_discussion": 0.15625, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.5 }	2.125	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related\ndiseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses\nVersion: 0 Date: 29 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nShankuan Z...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03969-4	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 0 Date: 04 Dec 2024 Reviewer's report: I enjoy reading this manuscript. I have the following comments for consideration. 1. Could the authors justi...	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 0 Date: 04 Dec 2024 Reviewer's report: I enjoy reading this manuscript. I have the following comments for consideration. 1. Could the authors justi...	BMC	12916_2025_3969_ReviewerReport_V0_R5.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 3, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 6, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 1, "results_and_discussion": 2, "suggestion_and_solution": 1, "total": 16 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0.1875, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0.375, "praise": 0.0625, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.0625, "results_and_discussion": 0.125, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.0625 }	0.875	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related\ndiseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses\nVersion: 0 Date: 04 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI enjoy re...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03969-4	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 1 Date: 07 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: The author has addressed all my concerns. However, there are still minor details that require revision. 1.Th...	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 1 Date: 07 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: The author has addressed all my concerns. However, there are still minor details that require revision. 1.Th...	BMC	12916_2025_3969_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 1, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 2, "materials_and_methods": 1, "praise": 2, "presentation_and_reporting": 1, "results_and_discussion": 1, "suggestion_and_solution": 3, "total": 7 }	{ "criticism": 0.14285714285714285, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.2857142857142857, "materials_and_methods": 0.14285714285714285, "praise": 0.2857142857142857, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.14285714285714285, "results_and_discussion": 0.14285714285714285, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.428...	1.571429	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related\ndiseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses\nVersion: 1 Date: 07 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe author...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03969-4	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 1 Date: 11 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: The authors' responses to my questions are reasonable.	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 1 Date: 11 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: The authors' responses to my questions are reasonable.	BMC	12916_2025_3969_ReviewerReport_V1_R6.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0, "total": 1 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0 }	0	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related\ndiseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses\nVersion: 1 Date: 11 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe author...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03969-4	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: The authors have addressed all my concerns. I do not have further comments.	Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related diseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses Version: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: The authors have addressed all my concerns. I do not have further comments.	BMC	12916_2025_3969_ReviewerReport_V1_R5.pdf	{ "criticism": 1, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 1, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0, "total": 2 }	{ "criticism": 0.5, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0.5, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0 }	1	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Smoking-related gut microbiota alteration is associated with obesity and obesity-related\ndiseases: results from two cohorts with sibling comparison analyses\nVersion: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe author...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03978-3	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production of Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands Version: 0 Date: 15 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: The current work is to raise awareness of multiple outcome event prediction, and present clinical examples wh...	Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production of Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands Version: 0 Date: 15 Nov 2024 Reviewer's report: The current work is to raise awareness of multiple outcome event prediction, and present clinical examples wh...	BMC	12916_2025_3978_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 2, "materials_and_methods": 5, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 2, "results_and_discussion": 4, "suggestion_and_solution": 3, "total": 12 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.16666666666666666, "materials_and_methods": 0.4166666666666667, "praise": 0.08333333333333333, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.16666666666666666, "results_and_discussion": 0.3333333333333333, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.25 }	1.416667	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production\nof Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands\nVersion: 0 Date: 15 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe current...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03978-3	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production of Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands Version: 0 Date: 09 Dec 2024 Reviewer: Ulrich Mansmann Reviewer's report: I do congratulate the authors for this comprehensive and needed paper. There are m...	Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production of Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands Version: 0 Date: 09 Dec 2024 Reviewer: Ulrich Mansmann Reviewer's report: I do congratulate the authors for this comprehensive and needed paper. There are m...	BMC	12916_2025_3978_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf	{ "criticism": 5, "example": 5, "importance_and_relevance": 2, "materials_and_methods": 26, "praise": 3, "presentation_and_reporting": 9, "results_and_discussion": 10, "suggestion_and_solution": 11, "total": 57 }	{ "criticism": 0.08771929824561403, "example": 0.08771929824561403, "importance_and_relevance": 0.03508771929824561, "materials_and_methods": 0.45614035087719296, "praise": 0.05263157894736842, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.15789473684210525, "results_and_discussion": 0.17543859649122806, "suggestion_...	1.245614	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production\nof Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands\nVersion: 0 Date: 09 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Ulrich Mansmann\nRev...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03978-3	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production of Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands Version: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: my comments are well addressed.	Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production of Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands Version: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: my comments are well addressed.	BMC	12916_2025_3978_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 1, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0, "total": 1 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 1, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0 }	2	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production\nof Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands\nVersion: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nmy comments...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03978-3	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production of Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands Version: 1 Date: 02 Feb 2025 Reviewer: Ulrich Mansmann Reviewer's report: Many thanks for this important and timely paper. The use of prediction models to i...	Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production of Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands Version: 1 Date: 02 Feb 2025 Reviewer: Ulrich Mansmann Reviewer's report: Many thanks for this important and timely paper. The use of prediction models to i...	BMC	12916_2025_3978_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf	{ "criticism": 3, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 4, "materials_and_methods": 13, "praise": 4, "presentation_and_reporting": 6, "results_and_discussion": 3, "suggestion_and_solution": 6, "total": 20 }	{ "criticism": 0.15, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.2, "materials_and_methods": 0.65, "praise": 0.2, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.3, "results_and_discussion": 0.15, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.3 }	1.95	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: A Decision-Analytical Perspective on Incorporating Multiple Outcomes in the Production\nof Clinical Prediction Models: defining a taxonomy of risk estimands\nVersion: 1 Date: 02 Feb 2025\nReviewer: Ulrich Mansmann\nRev...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03952-z	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 0 Date: 08 Oct 2024 Reviewer's report: This is a large scale multinational study of psychiatric sequelae of COVID-19. The paper is clearly written, the methods are reasonable and thoroughly described. A ...	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 0 Date: 08 Oct 2024 Reviewer's report: This is a large scale multinational study of psychiatric sequelae of COVID-19. The paper is clearly written, the methods are reasonable and thoroughly described. A ...	BMC	12916_2025_3952_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf	{ "criticism": 7, "example": 4, "importance_and_relevance": 4, "materials_and_methods": 9, "praise": 5, "presentation_and_reporting": 2, "results_and_discussion": 8, "suggestion_and_solution": 5, "total": 38 }	{ "criticism": 0.18421052631578946, "example": 0.10526315789473684, "importance_and_relevance": 0.10526315789473684, "materials_and_methods": 0.23684210526315788, "praise": 0.13157894736842105, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.05263157894736842, "results_and_discussion": 0.21052631578947367, "suggestion_...	1.157895	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A\nmultinational cohort study\nVersion: 0 Date: 08 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis is a large scale multinational study of psychiatric sequelae ...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03952-z	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 0 Date: 21 Oct 2024 Reviewer's report: This study used data from five countries and investigated the short-, medium, and long-term risks of psychiatric and neuropsychiatric disorders following COVID-19 i...	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 0 Date: 21 Oct 2024 Reviewer's report: This study used data from five countries and investigated the short-, medium, and long-term risks of psychiatric and neuropsychiatric disorders following COVID-19 i...	BMC	12916_2025_3952_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 2, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 6, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 1, "results_and_discussion": 5, "suggestion_and_solution": 0, "total": 15 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0.13333333333333333, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0.4, "praise": 0.06666666666666667, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.06666666666666667, "results_and_discussion": 0.3333333333333333, "suggestion_and_solution": 0 }	1	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A\nmultinational cohort study\nVersion: 0 Date: 21 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis study used data from five countries and investigated the shor...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03952-z	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024 Reviewer's report: Authors should provide an abbreviated description of the databases they accessed across countries and are they comparable (e.g., do they represent diverse patients ...	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024 Reviewer's report: Authors should provide an abbreviated description of the databases they accessed across countries and are they comparable (e.g., do they represent diverse patients ...	BMC	12916_2025_3952_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf	{ "criticism": 1, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 1, "materials_and_methods": 5, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 2, "results_and_discussion": 1, "suggestion_and_solution": 4, "total": 15 }	{ "criticism": 0.06666666666666667, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0.06666666666666667, "materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.13333333333333333, "results_and_discussion": 0.06666666666666667, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.26666666666666666 }	0.933333	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A\nmultinational cohort study\nVersion: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nAuthors should provide an abbreviated description of the databases...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03952-z	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024 Reviewer's report: I thank the authors for thoroughly addressing my comments. I am satisfied with their answers and revisions.	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024 Reviewer's report: I thank the authors for thoroughly addressing my comments. I am satisfied with their answers and revisions.	BMC	12916_2025_3952_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 2, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0, "total": 2 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0 }	1	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A\nmultinational cohort study\nVersion: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI thank the authors for thoroughly addressing my comments. I am sa...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03952-z	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 1 Date: 13 Dec 2024 Reviewer's report: I have no further comments.	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 1 Date: 13 Dec 2024 Reviewer's report: I have no further comments.	BMC	12916_2025_3952_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf	{ "criticism": 1, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0, "total": 1 }	{ "criticism": 1, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0, "praise": 0, "presentation_and_reporting": 0, "results_and_discussion": 0, "suggestion_and_solution": 0 }	1	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A\nmultinational cohort study\nVersion: 1 Date: 13 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI have no further comments.", "role": "assistant" } ]	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03952-z	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 1 Date: 08 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: The manuscript “Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study” outlines a study that includes data from elect...	Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study Version: 1 Date: 08 Jan 2025 Reviewer's report: The manuscript “Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A multinational cohort study” outlines a study that includes data from elect...	BMC	12916_2025_3952_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf	{ "criticism": 1, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 1, "praise": 1, "presentation_and_reporting": 1, "results_and_discussion": 1, "suggestion_and_solution": 1, "total": 3 }	{ "criticism": 0.3333333333333333, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333, "praise": 0.3333333333333333, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333, "results_and_discussion": 0.3333333333333333, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.3333333333333333 }	2	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID-19 within two years: A\nmultinational cohort study\nVersion: 1 Date: 08 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe manuscript “Psychiatric and neuropsychiatric sequelae of COVID...	2,025
Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03958-7	Reviewed - bmc_medicine	Title: Effect of a Single-dose Denosumab on Mineral Homeostasis in Infertile Men: Insights from a Pilot Intervention Study and a Randomized Controlled Trial Version: 0 Date: 08 Oct 2024 Reviewer: Jan Št#pán Reviewer's report: Previously, the authors reported that a single injection of denosumab may be used to improve ...	Title: Effect of a Single-dose Denosumab on Mineral Homeostasis in Infertile Men: Insights from a Pilot Intervention Study and a Randomized Controlled Trial Version: 0 Date: 08 Oct 2024 Reviewer: Jan Št#pán Reviewer's report: Previously, the authors reported that a single injection of denosumab may be used to improve ...	BMC	12916_2025_3958_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 6, "praise": 4, "presentation_and_reporting": 4, "results_and_discussion": 1, "suggestion_and_solution": 2, "total": 11 }	{ "criticism": 0, "example": 0, "importance_and_relevance": 0, "materials_and_methods": 0.5454545454545454, "praise": 0.36363636363636365, "presentation_and_reporting": 0.36363636363636365, "results_and_discussion": 0.09090909090909091, "suggestion_and_solution": 0.18181818181818182 }	1.545455	[ { "content": "Please review this paper.", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Title: Effect of a Single-dose Denosumab on Mineral Homeostasis in Infertile Men: Insights\nfrom a Pilot Intervention Study and a Randomized Controlled Trial\nVersion: 0 Date: 08 Oct 2024\nReviewer: Jan Št#pán\nReviewer's rep...	2,025

End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

BMC Medicine Peer Reviews

This dataset contains peer reviews from BMC, standardized to match the format of the pawin205/PeerRT dataset.

Dataset Structure

Each record contains the following attributes:

relative_rank: Default value (0).
win_prob: Default value (0.0).
title: Title of the paper.
abstract: Abstract of the paper.
full_text: Full text of the paper (or review text if unavailable).
review: The peer review text.
source: Source of the data ('BMC').
review_src: Original filename of the review.
criteria_count: Dictionary containing counts of specific criteria in the review (e.g., criticism, praise).
dimension_scores: Dictionary containing scores for various dimensions.
overall_score: Computed overall score (reward value).
thinking_trace: Placeholder (empty).
prompt: Placeholder (empty).
prompt_length: Placeholder (0).
conversations: List of dictionaries representing the conversation (User/Assistant format).
year: Year of publication (if available).

Usage

from datasets import load_dataset

dataset = load_dataset("JerMa88/BMC_Medicine_Peer_Reviews")
print(dataset['train'][0])

Downloads last month: 14

: (See dataset viewer)