relative_rank int64 0 0 | win_prob float64 0 0 | title stringlengths 32 37 | abstract stringclasses 1
value | full_text stringlengths 107 36.7k | review stringlengths 107 36.7k | source stringclasses 1
value | review_src stringlengths 37 42 | criteria_count dict | dimension_scores dict | overall_score float64 0 6 | thinking_trace stringclasses 1
value | prompt stringclasses 1
value | prompt_length int64 0 0 | conversations listlengths 2 2 | year int64 2k 2.03k |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02827-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 3 Date: 14 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Rachid Eduardo Noleto da Nobrega Oliveira
Reviewer's report:
The ethics committee text provided for the patients is in Chinese. Unfortunately, I do not speak
or rea... | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 3 Date: 14 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Rachid Eduardo Noleto da Nobrega Oliveira
Reviewer's report:
The ethics committee text provided for the patients is in Chinese. Unfortunately, I do not speak
or rea... | BMC | 12893_2025_2827_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0.25,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.75,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.25
} | 1.25 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with\nCPAM: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 3 Date: 14 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Rachid Eduardo Noleto da Nobrega Oliveira\nReviewer's report:\nThe ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02827-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 3 Date: 21 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Paolo Scanagatta
Reviewer's report:
Manuscript Title: Effects Of Pulmonary Infection On Total Thoracoscopic Surgery In Children
With Congenital Pulmonary Airway Mal... | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 3 Date: 21 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Paolo Scanagatta
Reviewer's report:
Manuscript Title: Effects Of Pulmonary Infection On Total Thoracoscopic Surgery In Children
With Congenital Pulmonary Airway Mal... | BMC | 12893_2025_2827_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 17,
"praise": 7,
"presentation_and_reporting": 13,
"results_and_discussion": 7,
"suggestion_and_solution": 17,
"total": 31
} | {
"criticism": 0.06451612903225806,
"example": 0.03225806451612903,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.0967741935483871,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5483870967741935,
"praise": 0.22580645161290322,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.41935483870967744,
"results_and_discussion": 0.22580645161290322,
"suggestion_an... | 2.16129 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with\nCPAM: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 3 Date: 21 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Paolo Scanagatta\nReviewer's report:\nManuscript Title: Effects Of ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02827-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 4 Date: 17 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Fazl# Yanik
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
Thank you for the revised article.
The revised article can be accepted now. | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 4 Date: 17 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Fazl# Yanik
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
Thank you for the revised article.
The revised article can be accepted now. | BMC | 12893_2025_2827_ReviewerReport_V4_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with\nCPAM: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 4 Date: 17 Feb 2025\nReviewer: Fazl# Yanik\nReviewer's report:\nDear authors,\nThank you for the r... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02827-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 4 Date: 17 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Paolo Scanagatta
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your detailed revisions and for addressing the reviewers' comments
comprehensively. Your updates hav... | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 4 Date: 17 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Paolo Scanagatta
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your detailed revisions and for addressing the reviewers' comments
comprehensively. Your updates hav... | BMC | 12893_2025_2827_ReviewerReport_V4_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.125,
"praise": 0.625,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.125,
"results_and_discussion": 0.125,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.125
} | 1.125 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with\nCPAM: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 4 Date: 17 Feb 2025\nReviewer: Paolo Scanagatta\nReviewer's report:\nDear Authors,\nThank you for ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02827-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 4 Date: 19 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors are thanked to have submitted their interesting work to the journal. The strength of
the article consists in the correct methodology and the wid... | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 4 Date: 19 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors are thanked to have submitted their interesting work to the journal. The strength of
the article consists in the correct methodology and the wid... | BMC | 12893_2025_2827_ReviewerReport_V4_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 18
} | {
"criticism": 0.05555555555555555,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1111111111111111,
"materials_and_methods": 0.05555555555555555,
"praise": 0.2222222222222222,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.1111111111111111,
"results_and_discussion": 0.16666666666666666,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.1666... | 0.888889 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with\nCPAM: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 4 Date: 19 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors are thanked to have submitted their interestin... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02827-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 4 Date: 19 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Rachid Eduardo Noleto da Nobrega Oliveira
Reviewer's report:
The authors have reviewed the requested corrections, and the article is now ready for acceptance. | Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with
CPAM: A Retrospective Study
Version: 4 Date: 19 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Rachid Eduardo Noleto da Nobrega Oliveira
Reviewer's report:
The authors have reviewed the requested corrections, and the article is now ready for acceptance. | BMC | 12893_2025_2827_ReviewerReport_V4_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Pulmonary Infection on Thoracoscopic Surgery Outcomes in Children with\nCPAM: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 4 Date: 19 Feb 2025\nReviewer: Rachid Eduardo Noleto da Nobrega Oliveira\nReviewer's report:\nThe ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your valuable article, and it is my pleasure to review the manuscript entitled
“... | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your valuable article, and it is my pleasure to review the manuscript entitled
“... | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 8,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 26
} | {
"criticism": 0.038461538461538464,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3076923076923077,
"praise": 0.07692307692307693,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.07692307692307693,
"results_and_discussion": 0.15384615384615385,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.19230769230769232
} | 0.846154 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025\nReviewer's repor... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Tutkun Talih
Reviewer's report:
The study is well designed and carefully written.
The images are appro... | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Tutkun Talih
Reviewer's report:
The study is well designed and carefully written.
The images are appro... | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0.3333333333333333,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0.6666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.6666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Tutku... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Hilmi Yazici
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Congratulations on your effort in this research. The top... | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Hilmi Yazici
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Congratulations on your effort in this research. The top... | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 15,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 14,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 11,
"total": 30
} | {
"criticism": 0.16666666666666666,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.03333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.03333333333333333,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4666666666666667,
"results_and_discussion": 0.13333333333333333,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.36666666666666664
... | 1.7 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Hilmi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following points below
-Wh... | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following points below
-Wh... | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V1_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 12,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 10,
"total": 23
} | {
"criticism": 0.13043478260869565,
"example": 0.043478260869565216,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.17391304347826086,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5217391304347826,
"praise": 0.043478260869565216,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.17391304347826086,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2608695652173913,
"suggestion_... | 1.782609 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Anwar... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 01 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report: | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 1 Date: 01 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 01 Feb 2025\nReviewer's repor... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 2 Date: 11 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Hilmi Yazici
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your revisions. There are still some issue... | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 2 Date: 11 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Hilmi Yazici
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your revisions. There are still some issue... | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 9,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 7,
"total": 13
} | {
"criticism": 0.3076923076923077,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.15384615384615385,
"materials_and_methods": 0.46153846153846156,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.6923076923076923,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5384615384615384
} | 2.153846 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 2 Date: 11 Feb 2025\nReviewer: Hilmi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 2 Date: 12 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
The responses are satisfactory. | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 2 Date: 12 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
The responses are satisfactory. | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V2_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 2 Date: 12 Feb 2025\nReviewer: Anwar... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 2 Date: 12 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
I decided acceptance, because the manuscript was well revised. | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 2 Date: 12 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
I decided acceptance, because the manuscript was well revised. | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 2 Date: 12 Feb 2025\nReviewer's repor... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02826-8 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 3 Date: 19 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Hilmi Yazici
Reviewer's report:
Well done. No more comments | Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of
surgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis
Version: 3 Date: 19 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Hilmi Yazici
Reviewer's report:
Well done. No more comments | BMC | 12893_2025_2826_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of the efficiency of a prophylactic increasing blood pressure before the end of\nsurgery to reduce bleeding after gastrectomy: a propensity score–matched analysis\nVersion: 3 Date: 19 Feb 2025\nReviewer: Hilmi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02819-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 0 Date: 14 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
see the uploaded file | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 0 Date: 14 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
see the uploaded file | BMC | 12893_2025_2819_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis\nof Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 0 Date: 14 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nsee the uploaded file",
"role": "assistant"
}
... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02819-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 0 Date: 16 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Reviewer comments to authors
Overall, this is a clear and well-written manuscript. The authors make a systematic contribution
to the research literatu... | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 0 Date: 16 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Reviewer comments to authors
Overall, this is a clear and well-written manuscript. The authors make a systematic contribution
to the research literatu... | BMC | 12893_2025_2819_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 8,
"presentation_and_reporting": 8,
"results_and_discussion": 8,
"suggestion_and_solution": 7,
"total": 19
} | {
"criticism": 0.15789473684210525,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.10526315789473684,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3157894736842105,
"praise": 0.42105263157894735,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.42105263157894735,
"results_and_discussion": 0.42105263157894735,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.36... | 2.210526 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis\nof Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 0 Date: 16 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nReviewer comments to authors\nOverall, this is a cle... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02819-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 0 Date: 21 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Review of the Manuscript:
Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis of
Randomized Controlled Trials
Adherence... | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 0 Date: 21 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Review of the Manuscript:
Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis of
Randomized Controlled Trials
Adherence... | BMC | 12893_2025_2819_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 16,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 13,
"suggestion_and_solution": 14,
"total": 42
} | {
"criticism": 0.09523809523809523,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.07142857142857142,
"materials_and_methods": 0.38095238095238093,
"praise": 0.07142857142857142,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.11904761904761904,
"results_and_discussion": 0.30952380952380953,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3... | 1.380952 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis\nof Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 0 Date: 21 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nReview of the Manuscript:\nEfficacy of Metronidazole... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02819-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 1 Date: 04 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your thorough revisions. All my concerns have been addressed adequately, and
the manuscript is now suitable for publication. | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 1 Date: 04 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your thorough revisions. All my concerns have been addressed adequately, and
the manuscript is now suitable for publication. | BMC | 12893_2025_2819_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis\nof Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 1 Date: 04 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for your thorough revisions. All my concer... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02819-7 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 1 Date: 10 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Reviewer comments to authors
I have reviewed the authors' revised manuscript. I have no further comments on the revised
manuscript. | Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis
of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 1 Date: 10 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Reviewer comments to authors
I have reviewed the authors' revised manuscript. I have no further comments on the revised
manuscript. | BMC | 12893_2025_2819_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of Metronidazole in Reducing Pain After Hemorrhoidectomy: A Meta-Analysis\nof Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 1 Date: 10 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nReviewer comments to authors\nI have reviewed the au... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02813-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 3 Date: 20 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
I applaud the authors for this well conducted study.
However, the results section is very heterogeneous. It is like mixing apples and oranges. I see
that a reduction... | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 3 Date: 20 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
I applaud the authors for this well conducted study.
However, the results section is very heterogeneous. It is like mixing apples and oranges. I see
that a reduction... | BMC | 12893_2025_2813_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0.2857142857142857,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5714285714285714,
"praise": 0.2857142857142857,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.14285714285714285,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.14285714285714285
} | 1.428571 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and\nmeta-analysis\nVersion: 3 Date: 20 Jun 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI applaud the authors for this well conducted study.\nHowever, the ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02813-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 3 Date: 21 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Hui-Min Li
Reviewer's report:
1. What standard is used for nail placement accuracy? According to most literature, the Gertzbin
Robbins classification is used, Group A: screw... | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 3 Date: 21 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Hui-Min Li
Reviewer's report:
1. What standard is used for nail placement accuracy? According to most literature, the Gertzbin
Robbins classification is used, Group A: screw... | BMC | 12893_2025_2813_ReviewerReport_V3_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.125,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.625,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.125,
"results_and_discussion": 0.25,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.375
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and\nmeta-analysis\nVersion: 3 Date: 21 Sep 2024\nReviewer: Hui-Min Li\nReviewer's report:\n1. What standard is used for nail placement ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02813-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 6 Date: 01 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript was revised according to the reviewers comments | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 6 Date: 01 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript was revised according to the reviewers comments | BMC | 12893_2025_2813_ReviewerReport_V6_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and\nmeta-analysis\nVersion: 6 Date: 01 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe manuscript was revised according to the reviewers comments",
... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02813-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 6 Date: 08 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Yu-Ning Peng
Reviewer's report: | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 6 Date: 08 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Yu-Ning Peng
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2813_ReviewerReport_V6_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and\nmeta-analysis\nVersion: 6 Date: 08 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Yu-Ning Peng\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02813-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 6 Date: 19 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
1. Rich research literature and clear categorization: the study involves more related studies and
is categorized more meticulously, reflecting a broad understanding ... | Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and
meta-analysis
Version: 6 Date: 19 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
1. Rich research literature and clear categorization: the study involves more related studies and
is categorized more meticulously, reflecting a broad understanding ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2813_ReviewerReport_V6_R7.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0.2857142857142857,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.42857142857142855,
"materials_and_methods": 0.42857142857142855,
"praise": 0.14285714285714285,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.42857142857142855,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2857142857142857
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Accuracy in navigated percutaneous sacroiliac screw fixation: a systematic review and\nmeta-analysis\nVersion: 6 Date: 19 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\n1. Rich research literature and clear categorization: the study inv... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02817-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute
kidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
In the manuscript, “Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for acute renal
fail... | Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute
kidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
In the manuscript, “Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for acute renal
fail... | BMC | 12893_2025_2817_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 8,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 12
} | {
"criticism": 0.16666666666666666,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.08333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6666666666666666,
"praise": 0.25,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.16666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0.16666666666666666,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.16666666666666666... | 1.666667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute\nkidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China\nVersion: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\n... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02817-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute
kidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China
Version: 1 Date: 20 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Comment 1: I recommend that the authors replace "acute renal failure" with "dialysis-requiring
acu... | Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute
kidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China
Version: 1 Date: 20 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Comment 1: I recommend that the authors replace "acute renal failure" with "dialysis-requiring
acu... | BMC | 12893_2025_2817_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 20,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 9,
"results_and_discussion": 8,
"suggestion_and_solution": 12,
"total": 29
} | {
"criticism": 0.06896551724137931,
"example": 0.034482758620689655,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.10344827586206896,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6896551724137931,
"praise": 0.034482758620689655,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3103448275862069,
"results_and_discussion": 0.27586206896551724,
"suggestion_... | 1.931034 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute\nkidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China\nVersion: 1 Date: 20 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\n... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02817-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute
kidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China
Version: 2 Date: 15 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
my comments have been responded appropriately | Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute
kidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China
Version: 2 Date: 15 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
my comments have been responded appropriately | BMC | 12893_2025_2817_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of a clinical prediction model for dialysis-requiring acute\nkidney injury following heart transplantation: a single-center study from China\nVersion: 2 Date: 15 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\n... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02820-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 1 Date: 23 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for giving me the opportunity of reading your paper.
I believe your paper shows that compared to ... | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 1 Date: 23 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for giving me the opportunity of reading your paper.
I believe your paper shows that compared to ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2820_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0.2222222222222222,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5555555555555556,
"praise": 0.1111111111111111,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2222222222222222,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2222222222222222
} | 1.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the\nrepair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures\nVersion: 1 Date: 23 Jun 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02820-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 1 Date: 26 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Vertebroplasty is a very effective surgical procedure for osteoporotic vertebral fractures. It is
widely us... | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 1 Date: 26 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Vertebroplasty is a very effective surgical procedure for osteoporotic vertebral fractures. It is
widely us... | BMC | 12893_2025_2820_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0.125,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.25,
"praise": 0.75,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.25,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.125
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the\nrepair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures\nVersion: 1 Date: 26 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nVertebrop... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02820-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 2 Date: 07 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
I am pleased to review the paper entitled "Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous
vertebral ce... | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 2 Date: 07 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
I am pleased to review the paper entitled "Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous
vertebral ce... | BMC | 12893_2025_2820_ReviewerReport_V2_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 11
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.09090909090909091,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.18181818181818182,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5454545454545454,
"praise": 0.2727272727272727,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.18181818181818182,
"results_and_discussion": 0.18181818181818182,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.181... | 1.636364 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the\nrepair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures\nVersion: 2 Date: 07 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI am plea... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02820-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 2 Date: 08 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
This study aims to investigate the impact of bone cement distribution on the efficacy of
vertebral compress... | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 2 Date: 08 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
This study aims to investigate the impact of bone cement distribution on the efficacy of
vertebral compress... | BMC | 12893_2025_2820_ReviewerReport_V2_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.14285714285714285,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.14285714285714285,
"materials_and_methods": 0.42857142857142855,
"praise": 0.14285714285714285,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.42857142857142855,
"results_and_discussion": 0.42857142857142855,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5... | 2.285714 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the\nrepair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures\nVersion: 2 Date: 08 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThis stud... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02820-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 4 Date: 15 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Excellent! It is recommended to accept publication. | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 4 Date: 15 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
Excellent! It is recommended to accept publication. | BMC | 12893_2025_2820_ReviewerReport_V4_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the\nrepair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures\nVersion: 4 Date: 15 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nExcellent... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02820-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 4 Date: 15 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
good#Accept | Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the
repair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures
Version: 4 Date: 15 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
good#Accept | BMC | 12893_2025_2820_ReviewerReport_V4_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical effect analysis of unilateral percutaneous vertebral cement distribution in the\nrepair of osteoporotic thoracolumbar vertebral compression fractures\nVersion: 4 Date: 15 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\ngood#Acce... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02821-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement
after Breast-Conserving Surgery
Version: 3 Date: 29 Jul 2024
Reviewer: Badria Aljohani
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript titled "Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume
Replacement after Breast-Conser... | Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement
after Breast-Conserving Surgery
Version: 3 Date: 29 Jul 2024
Reviewer: Badria Aljohani
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript titled "Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume
Replacement after Breast-Conser... | BMC | 12893_2025_2821_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 6,
"importance_and_relevance": 11,
"materials_and_methods": 23,
"praise": 7,
"presentation_and_reporting": 23,
"results_and_discussion": 14,
"suggestion_and_solution": 36,
"total": 52
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.11538461538461539,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.21153846153846154,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4423076923076923,
"praise": 0.1346153846153846,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4423076923076923,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2692307692307692,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.69230... | 2.307692 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement\nafter Breast-Conserving Surgery\nVersion: 3 Date: 29 Jul 2024\nReviewer: Badria Aljohani\nReviewer's report:\nThe manuscript titled \"C... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02821-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement
after Breast-Conserving Surgery
Version: 3 Date: 28 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Alberto Rancati
Reviewer's report:
Exciting report, Congratulations to the authors.
just two observations: integration of the ADM into the tissue and why volum... | Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement
after Breast-Conserving Surgery
Version: 3 Date: 28 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Alberto Rancati
Reviewer's report:
Exciting report, Congratulations to the authors.
just two observations: integration of the ADM into the tissue and why volum... | BMC | 12893_2025_2821_ReviewerReport_V3_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement\nafter Breast-Conserving Surgery\nVersion: 3 Date: 28 Sep 2024\nReviewer: Alberto Rancati\nReviewer's report:\nExciting report, Congratu... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02821-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement
after Breast-Conserving Surgery
Version: 4 Date: 18 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Hyukjai Shin
Reviewer's report:
After breast conservation surgery using sheet-shaped ADM, the degree of volume reduction after
radiation therapy was measured u... | Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement
after Breast-Conserving Surgery
Version: 4 Date: 18 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Hyukjai Shin
Reviewer's report:
After breast conservation surgery using sheet-shaped ADM, the degree of volume reduction after
radiation therapy was measured u... | BMC | 12893_2025_2821_ReviewerReport_V4_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 12
} | {
"criticism": 0.08333333333333333,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4166666666666667,
"praise": 0.16666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.16666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3333333333333333
} | 1.166667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical Progression Following Acellular Dermal Matrix Use for Volume Replacement\nafter Breast-Conserving Surgery\nVersion: 4 Date: 18 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Hyukjai Shin\nReviewer's report:\nAfter breast conservation su... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02815-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 0 Date: 09 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The article provides a review of a rare injury pattern. The authors have put significant effort
into searching the literature and presenting their finding... | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 0 Date: 09 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The article provides a review of a rare injury pattern. The authors have put significant effort
into searching the literature and presenting their finding... | BMC | 12893_2025_2815_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 8,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 14,
"total": 26
} | {
"criticism": 0.07692307692307693,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.15384615384615385,
"materials_and_methods": 0.19230769230769232,
"praise": 0.07692307692307693,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3076923076923077,
"results_and_discussion": 0.15384615384615385,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.53... | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a\nsystematic review\nVersion: 0 Date: 09 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe article provides a review of a rare injury pattern. ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02815-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 0 Date: 10 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Mohammed Elmajee
Reviewer's report: | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 0 Date: 10 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Mohammed Elmajee
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2815_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a\nsystematic review\nVersion: 0 Date: 10 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Mohammed Elmajee\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02815-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 0 Date: 12 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This study aims to raise awareness about midshaft clavicle fractures associated with ipsilateral
ACJ injuries and to provide insights into their diagnosis,... | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 0 Date: 12 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This study aims to raise awareness about midshaft clavicle fractures associated with ipsilateral
ACJ injuries and to provide insights into their diagnosis,... | BMC | 12893_2025_2815_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 7,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 13
} | {
"criticism": 0.15384615384615385,
"example": 0.07692307692307693,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.23076923076923078,
"materials_and_methods": 0.38461538461538464,
"praise": 0.23076923076923078,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5384615384615384,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.23... | 1.846154 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a\nsystematic review\nVersion: 0 Date: 12 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThis study aims to raise awareness about midshaft clavicl... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02815-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The revision has adequately addressed previous concerns. The study is well-conducted and
informative. Well done. I recommend to accept. The paper is relev... | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The revision has adequately addressed previous concerns. The study is well-conducted and
informative. Well done. I recommend to accept. The paper is relev... | BMC | 12893_2025_2815_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 5
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.4
} | 1.6 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a\nsystematic review\nVersion: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe revision has adequately addressed previous concerns. ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02815-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This revision is a substantial improvement to the previous version. With a few more changes,
I believe the article may be publishable.
Specifically:
1. Abs... | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This revision is a substantial improvement to the previous version. With a few more changes,
I believe the article may be publishable.
Specifically:
1. Abs... | BMC | 12893_2025_2815_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 8,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 8,
"total": 15
} | {
"criticism": 0.2,
"example": 0.13333333333333333,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0.06666666666666667,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0.13333333333333333,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5333333333333333
} | 1.933333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a\nsystematic review\nVersion: 1 Date: 27 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThis revision is a substantial improvement to the previou... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02815-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Mohammed Elmajee
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for revising your work, it is a slightly better version than the one before. | Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a
systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Mohammed Elmajee
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for revising your work, it is a slightly better version than the one before. | BMC | 12893_2025_2815_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Midshaft clavicle fractures with associated ipsilateral acromioclavicular joint injuries: a\nsystematic review\nVersion: 1 Date: 31 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Mohammed Elmajee\nReviewer's report:\nThanks for revising your wor... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02822-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Neutrophil Percentage-to-Albumin Ratio as a Predictor of Conservative Treatment Failure
in Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Cohort Study
Version: 0 Date: 02 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Fabio Cesare Campanile
Reviewer's report:
This case-control study explores the potential role of the Neutrophil Percentage-to-Albumi... | Title: Neutrophil Percentage-to-Albumin Ratio as a Predictor of Conservative Treatment Failure
in Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Cohort Study
Version: 0 Date: 02 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Fabio Cesare Campanile
Reviewer's report:
This case-control study explores the potential role of the Neutrophil Percentage-to-Albumi... | BMC | 12893_2025_2822_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 7,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 32,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 7,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 9,
"total": 43
} | {
"criticism": 0.16279069767441862,
"example": 0.023255813953488372,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.046511627906976744,
"materials_and_methods": 0.7441860465116279,
"praise": 0.023255813953488372,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.16279069767441862,
"results_and_discussion": 0.06976744186046512,
"suggestio... | 1.44186 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Neutrophil Percentage-to-Albumin Ratio as a Predictor of Conservative Treatment Failure\nin Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Cohort Study\nVersion: 0 Date: 02 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Fabio Cesare Campanile\nReviewer's ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02822-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Neutrophil Percentage-to-Albumin Ratio as a Predictor of Conservative Treatment Failure
in Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Cohort Study
Version: 0 Date: 11 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Ana González-Castillo
Reviewer's report:
Congratulations on your work and contribution to science with new information that may be
v... | Title: Neutrophil Percentage-to-Albumin Ratio as a Predictor of Conservative Treatment Failure
in Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Cohort Study
Version: 0 Date: 11 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Ana González-Castillo
Reviewer's report:
Congratulations on your work and contribution to science with new information that may be
v... | BMC | 12893_2025_2822_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.42857142857142855,
"materials_and_methods": 0.8571428571428571,
"praise": 0.2857142857142857,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.14285714285714285,
"results_and_discussion": 0.42857142857142855,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2857142857142857
} | 2.428571 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Neutrophil Percentage-to-Albumin Ratio as a Predictor of Conservative Treatment Failure\nin Acute Cholecystitis: A Retrospective Cohort Study\nVersion: 0 Date: 11 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Ana González-Castillo\nReviewer's r... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02802-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to
updated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management
Version: 0 Date: 03 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Julie Wecsler
Reviewer's report: | Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to
updated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management
Version: 0 Date: 03 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Julie Wecsler
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2802_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to\nupdated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management\nVersion: 0 Date: 03 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Julie Wecsler\nRevie... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02802-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to
updated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management
Version: 0 Date: 08 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Richard K. Orr
Reviewer's report:
I congratulate the authors for providing an excellent summary of the available lite... | Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to
updated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management
Version: 0 Date: 08 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Richard K. Orr
Reviewer's report:
I congratulate the authors for providing an excellent summary of the available lite... | BMC | 12893_2025_2802_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 15,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 22
} | {
"criticism": 0.22727272727272727,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.13636363636363635,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6818181818181818,
"praise": 0.09090909090909091,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.045454545454545456,
"results_and_discussion": 0.045454545454545456,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.... | 1.318182 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to\nupdated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management\nVersion: 0 Date: 08 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Richard K. Orr\nRevi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02802-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to
updated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management
Version: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I like the comprehensive analysis of the history of axillary surgery in breast cancer.
I think the chart with... | Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to
updated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management
Version: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I like the comprehensive analysis of the history of axillary surgery in breast cancer.
I think the chart with... | BMC | 12893_2025_2802_ReviewerReport_V1_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6666666666666666,
"praise": 0.6666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to\nupdated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management\nVersion: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI like the ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02802-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to
updated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management
Version: 1 Date: 20 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for inviting me to review the paper. Wu et al. summarize the axillary management
for patients with ... | Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to
updated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management
Version: 1 Date: 20 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for inviting me to review the paper. Wu et al. summarize the axillary management
for patients with ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2802_ReviewerReport_V1_R8.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 5,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 7,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 15
} | {
"criticism": 0.2,
"example": 0.3333333333333333,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.06666666666666667,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4,
"praise": 0.06666666666666667,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4666666666666667,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.4
} | 1.933333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Axillary lymph node metastasis in breast cancer: from historical axillary surgery to\nupdated advances in the preoperative diagnosis and axillary management\nVersion: 1 Date: 20 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThank you f... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02804-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity
One-year After Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 28 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Mohamed Hany
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following points below
-The discussion on how obesity alters respiratory function could benefit from m... | Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity
One-year After Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 28 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Mohamed Hany
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following points below
-The discussion on how obesity alters respiratory function could benefit from m... | BMC | 12893_2025_2804_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 7,
"materials_and_methods": 13,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 8,
"suggestion_and_solution": 17,
"total": 31
} | {
"criticism": 0.12903225806451613,
"example": 0.03225806451612903,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.22580645161290322,
"materials_and_methods": 0.41935483870967744,
"praise": 0.06451612903225806,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.12903225806451613,
"results_and_discussion": 0.25806451612903225,
"suggestion_... | 1.806452 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity\nOne-year After Surgery\nVersion: 2 Date: 28 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Mohamed Hany\nReviewer's report:\nDear Authors, please address the fol... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02804-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity
One-year After Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 14 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript provides a valuable investigation into the effects of sleeve gastrectomy on
pulmonary function and physical activity. However, the manuscript ca... | Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity
One-year After Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 14 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript provides a valuable investigation into the effects of sleeve gastrectomy on
pulmonary function and physical activity. However, the manuscript ca... | BMC | 12893_2025_2804_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 4,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 14,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 10,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 14,
"total": 27
} | {
"criticism": 0.037037037037037035,
"example": 0.14814814814814814,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.14814814814814814,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5185185185185185,
"praise": 0.1111111111111111,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.37037037037037035,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2222222222222222,
"suggestion_an... | 2.074074 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity\nOne-year After Surgery\nVersion: 2 Date: 14 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe manuscript provides a valuable investigation into the eff... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02804-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity
One-year After Surgery
Version: 3 Date: 29 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed previous reviewer comments with substantial revisions,
strengthening the discussion on obesity-related respiratory changes, lean bod... | Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity
One-year After Surgery
Version: 3 Date: 29 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed previous reviewer comments with substantial revisions,
strengthening the discussion on obesity-related respiratory changes, lean bod... | BMC | 12893_2025_2804_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity\nOne-year After Surgery\nVersion: 3 Date: 29 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have addressed previous reviewer comments with su... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02804-0 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity
One-year After Surgery
Version: 3 Date: 29 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Mohamed Hany
Reviewer's report:
Thabk you for addressing comments. | Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity
One-year After Surgery
Version: 3 Date: 29 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Mohamed Hany
Reviewer's report:
Thabk you for addressing comments. | BMC | 12893_2025_2804_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Sleeve Gastrectomy on Pulmonary Function Tests and Physical Activity\nOne-year After Surgery\nVersion: 3 Date: 29 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Mohamed Hany\nReviewer's report:\nThabk you for addressing comments.",... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02791-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 0 Date: 24 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Interesting and well written article.
However, I would suggest Authors to cite and discuss recent relevant literature, such as:
Congenital nonvascular neck masses: a retrospe... | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 0 Date: 24 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Interesting and well written article.
However, I would suggest Authors to cite and discuss recent relevant literature, such as:
Congenital nonvascular neck masses: a retrospe... | BMC | 12893_2025_2791_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.14285714285714285,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2857142857142857,
"praise": 0.14285714285714285,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2857142857142857,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.14285714285714285
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center\nExperience\nVersion: 0 Date: 24 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nInteresting and well written article.\nHowever, I would suggest Authors to c... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02791-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 0 Date: 25 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Thangaraj Mohanapriya
Reviewer's report:
1) In Materials and methods, the term neoplasm in"history of cervical neoplasm" - Can be
changed to a better terminology to represent cysts.
... | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 0 Date: 25 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Thangaraj Mohanapriya
Reviewer's report:
1) In Materials and methods, the term neoplasm in"history of cervical neoplasm" - Can be
changed to a better terminology to represent cysts.
... | BMC | 12893_2025_2791_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 8,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 11
} | {
"criticism": 0.09090909090909091,
"example": 0.09090909090909091,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5454545454545454,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.7272727272727273,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5454545454545454
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center\nExperience\nVersion: 0 Date: 25 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Thangaraj Mohanapriya\nReviewer's report:\n1) In Materials and methods, the term neop... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02791-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
hello
thank you fpr this original paper
cysts in juvenile patients its a very special topic
this improved paper is sufficient for publication
authors present their own experi... | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
hello
thank you fpr this original paper
cysts in juvenile patients its a very special topic
this improved paper is sufficient for publication
authors present their own experi... | BMC | 12893_2025_2791_ReviewerReport_V1_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 4 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center\nExperience\nVersion: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nhello\nthank you fpr this original paper\ncysts in juvenile patients its a v... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02791-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This study is considered a valuable investigation that analyzes pediatric cervical cysts from a
surgical perspective with the large number of cases.
Upon reading the abstract... | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This study is considered a valuable investigation that analyzes pediatric cervical cysts from a
surgical perspective with the large number of cases.
Upon reading the abstract... | BMC | 12893_2025_2791_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 7,
"praise": 7,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 14
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.14285714285714285,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.14285714285714285,
"results_and_discussion": 0.07142857142857142,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2857142857142857
} | 1.642857 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center\nExperience\nVersion: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThis study is considered a valuable investigation that analyzes pediatric ce... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02791-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 1 Date: 24 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
kindly view the attached manuscript for comments.
Best regards. | Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center
Experience
Version: 1 Date: 24 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
kindly view the attached manuscript for comments.
Best regards. | BMC | 12893_2025_2791_ReviewerReport_V1_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Main Features and Treatments of Cervical Cysts in Children from a Single-center\nExperience\nVersion: 1 Date: 24 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nDear authors,\nkindly view the attached manuscript for comments.\nBest regar... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02805-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 24 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Your manuscript provides a detailed and insightful meta-analysis of robotic surgery (RS) versus
laparoscopic surgery (LS) for recta... | Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 24 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Your manuscript provides a detailed and insightful meta-analysis of robotic surgery (RS) versus
laparoscopic surgery (LS) for recta... | BMC | 12893_2025_2805_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 7,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.25,
"materials_and_methods": 0.25,
"praise": 0.125,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0.625,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.875
} | 2.375 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review\nand Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 3 Date: 24 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nYour manuscript provides a detail... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02805-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 30 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author,
I read with great interest the work titled “Comprehensive Meta-Analysis of Robotic Surgery
versus Laparoscopic Surgery... | Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 30 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author,
I read with great interest the work titled “Comprehensive Meta-Analysis of Robotic Surgery
versus Laparoscopic Surgery... | BMC | 12893_2025_2805_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 9,
"example": 4,
"importance_and_relevance": 7,
"materials_and_methods": 35,
"praise": 6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 24,
"results_and_discussion": 16,
"suggestion_and_solution": 26,
"total": 65
} | {
"criticism": 0.13846153846153847,
"example": 0.06153846153846154,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1076923076923077,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5384615384615384,
"praise": 0.09230769230769231,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.36923076923076925,
"results_and_discussion": 0.24615384615384617,
"suggestion_an... | 1.953846 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review\nand Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 3 Date: 30 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nDear Author,\nI read with great i... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02805-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 4 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all comments, and the manuscript is now ready for publication. I
appreciate their effort and dedication ... | Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 4 Date: 31 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all comments, and the manuscript is now ready for publication. I
appreciate their effort and dedication ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2805_ReviewerReport_V4_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.666667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review\nand Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 4 Date: 31 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have addressed all co... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02805-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 4 Date: 01 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
acceptable revisions | Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 4 Date: 01 Feb 2025
Reviewer's report:
acceptable revisions | BMC | 12893_2025_2805_ReviewerReport_V4_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Robotic versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Rectal Cancer: An Updated Systematic Review\nand Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 4 Date: 01 Feb 2025\nReviewer's report:\nacceptable revisions",
"role"... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02808-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record
Version: 1 Date: 20 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors present single-institution retrospective data highlighting a discrepancy in EHR
utilization between male and female surgeons across multiple surgical specialties. I applaud
the authors for... | Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record
Version: 1 Date: 20 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors present single-institution retrospective data highlighting a discrepancy in EHR
utilization between male and female surgeons across multiple surgical specialties. I applaud
the authors for... | BMC | 12893_2025_2808_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 11,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 24
} | {
"criticism": 0.041666666666666664,
"example": 0.041666666666666664,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.08333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4583333333333333,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.08333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0.125,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.20833333333333... | 1.041667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record\nVersion: 1 Date: 20 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors present single-institution retrospective data highlighting a discrepancy in EHR\nutilizatio... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02808-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record
Version: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Well done and interesting study. In particular, I think the presence of analysis of the provider
efficiency tracking tool strengthens the findings that the differences seen between genders is not
due ... | Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record
Version: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Well done and interesting study. In particular, I think the presence of analysis of the provider
efficiency tracking tool strengthens the findings that the differences seen between genders is not
due ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2808_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 6
} | {
"criticism": 0.16666666666666666,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.16666666666666666,
"materials_and_methods": 0.16666666666666666,
"praise": 0.16666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0.16666666666666666,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.833333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record\nVersion: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nWell done and interesting study. In particular, I think the presence of analysis of the provider\neffic... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02808-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record
Version: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for taking the time to revise. | Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record
Version: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for taking the time to revise. | BMC | 12893_2025_2808_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record\nVersion: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for taking the time to revise.",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02808-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record
Version: 2 Date: 05 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Heather J. Logghe
Reviewer's report:
The article explores gender differences in time spent with the EHR. While more extensive
literature exist on this topic among other medical specialities, it is one of the ... | Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record
Version: 2 Date: 05 Feb 2025
Reviewer: Heather J. Logghe
Reviewer's report:
The article explores gender differences in time spent with the EHR. While more extensive
literature exist on this topic among other medical specialities, it is one of the ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2808_ReviewerReport_V2_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0.375,
"praise": 0.625,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.125,
"results_and_discussion": 0.125,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.75 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The gender gap in academic surgery: the electronic health record\nVersion: 2 Date: 05 Feb 2025\nReviewer: Heather J. Logghe\nReviewer's report:\nThe article explores gender differences in time spent with the EHR. While... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02809-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 2 Date: 04 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Julien Hasselmann
Reviewer's report:
Well-organized and relevant meta-analysis. The manuscript needs linguistic editing.... | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 2 Date: 04 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Julien Hasselmann
Reviewer's report:
Well-organized and relevant meta-analysis. The manuscript needs linguistic editing.... | BMC | 12893_2025_2809_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0.2222222222222222,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5555555555555556,
"praise": 0.1111111111111111,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4444444444444444,
"results_and_discussion": 0.3333333333333333,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3333333333333333
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing\nAbdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 2 Date: 04 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Julien Hasselmann\nRevi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02809-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 2 Date: 08 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors
Overall, the meta-analysis seems sound and well-conducted, however, the reporting can be
improved a... | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 2 Date: 08 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors
Overall, the meta-analysis seems sound and well-conducted, however, the reporting can be
improved a... | BMC | 12893_2025_2809_ReviewerReport_V2_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 23,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 17,
"results_and_discussion": 7,
"suggestion_and_solution": 22,
"total": 61
} | {
"criticism": 0.04918032786885246,
"example": 0.03278688524590164,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3770491803278688,
"praise": 0.03278688524590164,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2786885245901639,
"results_and_discussion": 0.11475409836065574,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.360... | 1.245902 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing\nAbdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 2 Date: 08 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nDear authors\n... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02809-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 03 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Julien Hasselmann
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for addressing my comments. I am fully satisfied with your answers and ch... | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 03 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Julien Hasselmann
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for addressing my comments. I am fully satisfied with your answers and ch... | BMC | 12893_2025_2809_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing\nAbdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 3 Date: 03 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Julien Hasselmann\nRevi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02809-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 25 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Since the previous reviewer has already described the statistical methods, I would like to present
some question... | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 25 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Since the previous reviewer has already described the statistical methods, I would like to present
some question... | BMC | 12893_2025_2809_ReviewerReport_V3_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 12
} | {
"criticism": 0.08333333333333333,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.25,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.4166666666666667
} | 1.083333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing\nAbdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 3 Date: 25 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nSince the prev... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02809-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 30 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Tiago Filipe Santos Cunha
Reviewer's report:
I would like the congratulate the authors for selecting this interesting to... | Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing
Abdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Version: 3 Date: 30 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Tiago Filipe Santos Cunha
Reviewer's report:
I would like the congratulate the authors for selecting this interesting to... | BMC | 12893_2025_2809_ReviewerReport_V3_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 5,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 7,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5555555555555556,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0.7777777777777778,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.1111111111111111,
"results_and_discussion": 0.3333333333333333,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2222222222222222
} | 2.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Role of Wound Protectors in Preventing Surgical Site Infection in Patients Undergoing\nAbdominal Surgery: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials\nVersion: 3 Date: 30 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Tiago Filipe Santos Cun... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02794-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 1 Date: 25 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a retrospective review of patients from two separate institutions who have undergone
esophagectomy for esophageal cancer and their ri... | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 1 Date: 25 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a retrospective review of patients from two separate institutions who have undergone
esophagectomy for esophageal cancer and their ri... | BMC | 12893_2025_2794_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 7,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 37
} | {
"criticism": 0.08108108108108109,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.13513513513513514,
"praise": 0.05405405405405406,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.1891891891891892,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.16216216216216217
} | 0.621622 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-\ncenter retrospective clinical study\nVersion: 1 Date: 25 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis is a retrospective review of patients ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02794-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 1 Date: 26 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Shuang Li et al. showed that the nomogram, which incorporates six key factors, effectively
predicts the risk of PPIs and can serve as a valua... | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 1 Date: 26 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Shuang Li et al. showed that the nomogram, which incorporates six key factors, effectively
predicts the risk of PPIs and can serve as a valua... | BMC | 12893_2025_2794_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0.4444444444444444,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2222222222222222,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0.2222222222222222,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2222222222222222,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.1111111111111111
} | 1.555556 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-\ncenter retrospective clinical study\nVersion: 1 Date: 26 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nShuang Li et al. showed that the nomogram, ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02794-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 1 Date: 29 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Maohui Chen
Reviewer's report:
Due to the complexity and difficulty of esophagectomy, the incidence of postoperative
pulmonary complications is relat... | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 1 Date: 29 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Maohui Chen
Reviewer's report:
Due to the complexity and difficulty of esophagectomy, the incidence of postoperative
pulmonary complications is relat... | BMC | 12893_2025_2794_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 6,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 8,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 22
} | {
"criticism": 0.2727272727272727,
"example": 0.09090909090909091,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.045454545454545456,
"materials_and_methods": 0.36363636363636365,
"praise": 0.09090909090909091,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.09090909090909091,
"results_and_discussion": 0.09090909090909091,
"suggestion_... | 1.181818 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-\ncenter retrospective clinical study\nVersion: 1 Date: 29 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Maohui Chen\nReviewer's report:\nDue to the complexi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02794-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 2 Date: 07 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have answered my questions, but still require some clarification.
For question 4, the authors should explicitly state if both tho... | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 2 Date: 07 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have answered my questions, but still require some clarification.
For question 4, the authors should explicitly state if both tho... | BMC | 12893_2025_2794_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6,
"praise": 0.3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.9 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-\ncenter retrospective clinical study\nVersion: 2 Date: 07 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have answered my questions, but... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02794-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Maohui Chen
Reviewer's report:
The authors responsibly made the appropriate revisions. This study has a definite clinical
relevance worthy of publica... | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Maohui Chen
Reviewer's report:
The authors responsibly made the appropriate revisions. This study has a definite clinical
relevance worthy of publica... | BMC | 12893_2025_2794_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-\ncenter retrospective clinical study\nVersion: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Maohui Chen\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors respons... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02794-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 2 Date: 14 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Authors revised it well.
No additional comments. | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 2 Date: 14 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Authors revised it well.
No additional comments. | BMC | 12893_2025_2794_ReviewerReport_V2_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-\ncenter retrospective clinical study\nVersion: 2 Date: 14 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nAuthors revised it well.\nNo additional com... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02794-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have adequately addressed my concerns. | Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-
center retrospective clinical study
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have adequately addressed my concerns. | BMC | 12893_2025_2794_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A nomogram for postoperative pulmonary infections in esophageal cancer patients: a two-\ncenter retrospective clinical study\nVersion: 3 Date: 24 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have adequately addressed my co... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02810-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 4 Date: 02 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting study on the use of local (LA) vs general anesthesia (GA) for
thyroidectomy. I congratul... | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 4 Date: 02 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting study on the use of local (LA) vs general anesthesia (GA) for
thyroidectomy. I congratul... | BMC | 12893_2025_2810_ReviewerReport_V4_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 7,
"materials_and_methods": 18,
"praise": 6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 10,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 12,
"total": 44
} | {
"criticism": 0.09090909090909091,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1590909090909091,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4090909090909091,
"praise": 0.13636363636363635,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.22727272727272727,
"results_and_discussion": 0.13636363636363635,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.272... | 1.431818 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in\nUganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial\nVersion: 4 Date: 02 Apr 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis is an in... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02810-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 4 Date: 04 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review the manuscript entitled “Euthyroidectomy Under Local
Versus General Ane... | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 4 Date: 04 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review the manuscript entitled “Euthyroidectomy Under Local
Versus General Ane... | BMC | 12893_2025_2810_ReviewerReport_V4_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 8,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.1111111111111111,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.8888888888888888,
"praise": 0.1111111111111111,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2222222222222222,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.4444444444444444
} | 2.111111 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in\nUganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial\nVersion: 4 Date: 04 Apr 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02810-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 5 Date: 10 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the thoughtful response to all reviewer comments. I have no additional concerns
about the paper. | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 5 Date: 10 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the thoughtful response to all reviewer comments. I have no additional concerns
about the paper. | BMC | 12893_2025_2810_ReviewerReport_V5_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in\nUganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial\nVersion: 5 Date: 10 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02810-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 5 Date: 17 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have made some revisions, but the article is still flawed with its sample size to detect
a differen... | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 5 Date: 17 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have made some revisions, but the article is still flawed with its sample size to detect
a differen... | BMC | 12893_2025_2810_ReviewerReport_V5_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0.25,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.25,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.25,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.25
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in\nUganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial\nVersion: 5 Date: 17 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors h... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02810-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 6 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Review: Euthyroidectomy under local versus general anesthesia in health camp settings in
Uganda: a randomized p... | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 6 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Review: Euthyroidectomy under local versus general anesthesia in health camp settings in
Uganda: a randomized p... | BMC | 12893_2025_2810_ReviewerReport_V6_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 7,
"total": 18
} | {
"criticism": 0.05555555555555555,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.05555555555555555,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5555555555555556,
"praise": 0.05555555555555555,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.16666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0.1111111111111111,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.388... | 1.388889 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in\nUganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial\nVersion: 6 Date: 11 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nReview: Euthy... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02810-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 6 Date: 12 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Appreciate the thoughtful revisions. I do not have any additional concerns with the paper and
feel it is reason... | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 6 Date: 12 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Appreciate the thoughtful revisions. I do not have any additional concerns with the paper and
feel it is reason... | BMC | 12893_2025_2810_ReviewerReport_V6_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in\nUganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial\nVersion: 6 Date: 12 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nAppreciate th... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02810-2 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 6 Date: 14 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Although I cannot find a tracked changes version of the manuscript for this round of review, I
do not think the... | Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in
Uganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial
Version: 6 Date: 14 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Although I cannot find a tracked changes version of the manuscript for this round of review, I
do not think the... | BMC | 12893_2025_2810_ReviewerReport_V6_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 7,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 13
} | {
"criticism": 0.23076923076923078,
"example": 0.15384615384615385,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5384615384615384,
"praise": 0.07692307692307693,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.15384615384615385,
"results_and_discussion": 0.07692307692307693,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.30... | 1.538462 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Thyroidectomy Under Local Versus General Anesthesia in Health Camp Settings in\nUganda: A Randomized Prospective Equivalence Single-Blind Controlled Trial\nVersion: 6 Date: 14 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nAlthough I ca... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02795-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 1 Date: 03 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Congratulations to the authors for their efforts. Here are some ideas and comments for reference:
1.In... | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 1 Date: 03 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Congratulations to the authors for their efforts. Here are some ideas and comments for reference:
1.In... | BMC | 12893_2025_2795_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.14285714285714285,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.8571428571428571,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.42857142857142855,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2857142857142857,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.7142857142857143
} | 2.428571 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic\nMetastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 1 Date: 03 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nCong... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02795-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 1 Date: 05 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This manuscipt titled “Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting
Lymphatic Met... | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 1 Date: 05 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
This manuscipt titled “Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting
Lymphatic Met... | BMC | 12893_2025_2795_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 6,
"materials_and_methods": 17,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 15,
"results_and_discussion": 9,
"suggestion_and_solution": 23,
"total": 33
} | {
"criticism": 0.030303030303030304,
"example": 0.06060606060606061,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.18181818181818182,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5151515151515151,
"praise": 0.09090909090909091,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.45454545454545453,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2727272727272727,
"suggestion_a... | 2.30303 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic\nMetastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 1 Date: 05 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThis... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02795-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 2 Date: 13 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The author has made the necessary revisions based on the suggestions; however, the references
are some... | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 2 Date: 13 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The author has made the necessary revisions based on the suggestions; however, the references
are some... | BMC | 12893_2025_2795_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic\nMetastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 2 Date: 13 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02795-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 2 Date: 18 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The author has answered all my questions and I have no further questions. | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 2 Date: 18 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The author has answered all my questions and I have no further questions. | BMC | 12893_2025_2795_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic\nMetastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 2 Date: 18 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02795-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 3 Date: 27 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The author has answered all my questions and I have no further questions. | Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic
Metastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study
Version: 3 Date: 27 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The author has answered all my questions and I have no further questions. | BMC | 12893_2025_2795_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Preoperative Inflammatory Markers and Tumor Markers in Predicting Lymphatic\nMetastasis and Postoperative Complications in Colorectal Cancer: A Retrospective Study\nVersion: 3 Date: 27 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02797-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope
Level in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery
Version: 1 Date: 28 Mar 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
In the material and method section, the sample selection method of the research, when the data
collection phase was carried... | Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope
Level in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery
Version: 1 Date: 28 Mar 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
In the material and method section, the sample selection method of the research, when the data
collection phase was carried... | BMC | 12893_2025_2797_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.6666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.6666666666666666
} | 1.666667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope\nLevel in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery\nVersion: 1 Date: 28 Mar 2024\nReviewer's report:\nDear authors,\nIn the material and meth... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02797-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope
Level in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery
Version: 1 Date: 07 May 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope
Level in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery
Version: 1 Date: 07 May 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2797_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope\nLevel in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery\nVersion: 1 Date: 07 May 2024\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02797-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope
Level in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 23 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear author/authors;
Thank you for the detailed corrections. There are some minor correction suggestions;
1-statistical p values in the ... | Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope
Level in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery
Version: 2 Date: 23 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear author/authors;
Thank you for the detailed corrections. There are some minor correction suggestions;
1-statistical p values in the ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2797_ReviewerReport_V2_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 6,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.6,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope\nLevel in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery\nVersion: 2 Date: 23 Jul 2024\nReviewer's report:\nDear author/authors;\nThank you for the... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02797-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope
Level in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery
Version: 4 Date: 08 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear author/s, corrections for the recommendations have been made appropriately. | Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope
Level in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery
Version: 4 Date: 08 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear author/s, corrections for the recommendations have been made appropriately. | BMC | 12893_2025_2797_ReviewerReport_V4_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Rosenthal Effect-Based Nursing Intervention on Self-Care Ability and Hope\nLevel in Patients Undergoing Breast Surgery\nVersion: 4 Date: 08 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nDear author/s, corrections for the reco... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02798-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 0 Date: 09 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Hesham Sheir
Reviewer's report:
1- Introduction (Background):
- Well written with clear gap of knowledge justifies performing this study.
2- Patients and methods:
- Description of the perio... | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 0 Date: 09 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Hesham Sheir
Reviewer's report:
1- Introduction (Background):
- Well written with clear gap of knowledge justifies performing this study.
2- Patients and methods:
- Description of the perio... | BMC | 12893_2025_2798_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 7,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 14
} | {
"criticism": 0.07142857142857142,
"example": 0.14285714285714285,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.07142857142857142,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2857142857142857,
"praise": 0.21428571428571427,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0.42857142857142855,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.... | 2.071429 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?\nVersion: 0 Date: 09 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Hesham Sheir\nReviewer's report:\n1- Introduction (Background):\n- Well written with clear ga... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02798-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 0 Date: 12 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to review this paper. This is an interesting study that
examines the appropriate timing of surgery for esophageal atresia. However, the study... | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 0 Date: 12 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to review this paper. This is an interesting study that
examines the appropriate timing of surgery for esophageal atresia. However, the study... | BMC | 12893_2025_2798_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0.3333333333333333,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4444444444444444,
"praise": 0.1111111111111111,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2222222222222222,
"results_and_discussion": 0.1111111111111111,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.1111111... | 1.666667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?\nVersion: 0 Date: 12 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for giving me the opportunity to review this paper. This is an interesting... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02798-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 0 Date: 16 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Toru Shimizu
Reviewer's report:
General comments:
The authors included only successful one-stage anastomosis and excluded these two-stage cases.
And the average gap was 1.77 cm. How do they... | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 0 Date: 16 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Toru Shimizu
Reviewer's report:
General comments:
The authors included only successful one-stage anastomosis and excluded these two-stage cases.
And the average gap was 1.77 cm. How do they... | BMC | 12893_2025_2798_ReviewerReport_V0_R8.pdf | {
"criticism": 6,
"example": 15,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 7,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 11,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 37
} | {
"criticism": 0.16216216216216217,
"example": 0.40540540540540543,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.1891891891891892,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2972972972972973,
"results_and_discussion": 0.10810810810810811,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.10810810810810811
} | 1.27027 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?\nVersion: 0 Date: 16 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Toru Shimizu\nReviewer's report:\nGeneral comments:\nThe authors included only successful one... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02798-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 0 Date: 17 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Krystian Toczewski
Reviewer's report:
Dear All,
thank you for the opportunity to review this study.
This is a manuscript on timing of EA repair. Strong sides of this study are sample size,... | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 0 Date: 17 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Krystian Toczewski
Reviewer's report:
Dear All,
thank you for the opportunity to review this study.
This is a manuscript on timing of EA repair. Strong sides of this study are sample size,... | BMC | 12893_2025_2798_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 9,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 9,
"total": 38
} | {
"criticism": 0.10526315789473684,
"example": 0.23684210526315788,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.02631578947368421,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2631578947368421,
"praise": 0.02631578947368421,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.13157894736842105,
"results_and_discussion": 0.07894736842105263,
"suggestion_a... | 1.105263 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?\nVersion: 0 Date: 17 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Krystian Toczewski\nReviewer's report:\nDear All,\nthank you for the opportunity to review t... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02798-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 1 Date: 01 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Hesham Sheir
Reviewer's report:
Thanks. I find that all previous recommendations were fulfilled appropriately. | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 1 Date: 01 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Hesham Sheir
Reviewer's report:
Thanks. I find that all previous recommendations were fulfilled appropriately. | BMC | 12893_2025_2798_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.3333333333333333,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?\nVersion: 1 Date: 01 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Hesham Sheir\nReviewer's report:\nThanks. I find that all previous recommendations were fulfi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02798-9 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 1 Date: 07 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review this paper. This study provides an interesting analysis
of the appropriate timing for surgery in esophageal atresia. However, I have signific... | Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?
Version: 1 Date: 07 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review this paper. This study provides an interesting analysis
of the appropriate timing for surgery in esophageal atresia. However, I have signific... | BMC | 12893_2025_2798_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 7,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 13
} | {
"criticism": 0.3076923076923077,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.23076923076923078,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5384615384615384,
"praise": 0.23076923076923078,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.15384615384615385,
"results_and_discussion": 0.07692307692307693,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.153... | 1.692308 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Does thoracoscopic repair of type C esophageal atresia require emergency treatment?\nVersion: 1 Date: 07 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for the opportunity to review this paper. This study provides an interesti... | 2,025 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.