identifier
stringlengths 11
32
| pdf_url
stringlengths 17
4.62k
⌀ | lang
stringclasses 120
values | error
stringclasses 1
value | title
stringlengths 2
500
⌀ | source_name
stringlengths 1
435
⌀ | publication_year
float64 1.9k
2.02k
| license
stringclasses 3
values | word_count
int64 0
1.64M
| text
stringlengths 1
9.75M
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
https://openalex.org/W2969759929
|
https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/11/17/1978/pdf?version=1566473194
|
English
| null |
Temporal Evolution of Corn Mass Production Based on Agro-Meteorological Modelling Controlled by Satellite Optical and SAR Images
|
Remote sensing
| 2,019
|
cc-by
| 16,955
|
Received: 11 June 2019; Accepted: 2 August 2019; Published: 22 August 2019 Received: 11 June 2019; Accepted: 2 August 2019; Published: 22 August 2019 Abstract: This work aims to provide daily estimates of the evolution of popcorn dry masses at
the field scale using an agro-meteorological model, named the simple algorithm for yield model
combined with a water balance model (SAFY-WB), controlled by the Green Area Index (GAI), derived
from satellite images acquired in the microwave and optical domains. Synthetic aperture radar (SAR)
satellite information (σ◦VH/VV) was provided by the Sentinel-1A (S1-A) mission through two orbits
(30 and 132), with a repetitiveness of six days. The optical data were obtained from the Landsat-8
mission. SAR and optical data were acquired over one complete agricultural season, in 2016, over a
test site located in the southwest of France. The results show that the total dry masses of corn can be
estimated accurately (R2 = 0.92) at daily time steps due to a combination of satellite and model data. The SAR data are more suitable for characterizing the first period of crop development (until the
end of flowering), whereas the optical data can be used throughout the crop cycle. Moreover, the
model offers good performances in plant (R2 = 0.90) and ear (R2 = 0.93) mass retrieval, irrespective
of the phenological stage. The results also reveal that four phenological stages (four to five leaves,
flowering, ripening, and harvest) can be accurately predicted by the proposed approach (R2 = 0.98;
root-mean-square error (RMSE) = seven days). Nevertheless, some important points must be taken
into account before assimilation, namely the SAR signal must be corrected with respect to thermal
noise before being assimilated, and the relationship estimated between the GAI and SAR signal must
be performed over fields cultivated without intercrops. These results are unique in the literature and
provide a new way to better monitor corn production over time. Keywords: remote sensing; Sentinel-1; SAR; SAFY–WB; crop production; maize remote sensing remote sensing remote sensing remote sensing Temporal Evolution of Corn Mass Production Based
on Agro-Meteorological Modelling Controlled by
Satellite Optical and SAR Images Frédéric Baup 1,*
, Maël Ameline 1,2
, Rémy Fieuzal 3, Frédéric Frappart 4
, Samuel Corgne 5
and Jean-François Berthoumieu 2 www.mdpi.com/journal/remotesensing Frédéric Baup 1,*
, Maël Ameline 1,2
, Rémy Fieuzal 3, Frédéric Frappart 4
, Samuel Corgne 5
and Jean-François Berthoumieu 2 Frédéric Baup 1,*
, Maël Ameline 1,2
, Rémy Fieuzal 3, Frédéric Frappart 4
, Samuel Corgne
and Jean-François Berthoumieu 2 2
Association Climatologique de Moyenne-Garonne et du Sud-ouest, Aérodrome d’Agen,
47520 Le Passage, France 3
Airbus-Defense & Space; 31 Rue des Cosmonautes, 31400 Toulouse, France 4
LEGOS (Laboratoire d’Etudes en Géophysique et Océanographie Spatiale), University of Toulouse,
14 avenue Edouard Belin, 31400 Toulouse, France 5
LETG (Littoral, Environnement, Télédétection et Géomatique), University of Rennes, 35000 Rennes, Fra
*
Correspondence: frederic baup@cesbio cnes fr; Tel : +33 561 626 344 5
LETG (Littoral, Environnement, Télédétection et Géomatique), University of Rennes, 35000 Rennes, France
*
Correspondence: frederic.baup@cesbio.cnes.fr; Tel.: +33-561-626-344 *
Correspondence: frederic.baup@cesbio.cnes.fr; Tel.: +33-561-626-344 *
Correspondence: frederic.baup@cesbio.cnes.fr; Tel.: +33-561-626-344
1. Introduction Identifying the effective management of agricultural land is essential in order to achieve high
socio-economic performance while limiting environmental impacts and ensuring the sustainability of
resources. Through these direct and indirect effects on many surface balances (carbon, nitrogen, water,
or energy), crops appear as the central element of agro-systems, with their development testifying
to the interactions between the edaphological and climatic conditions being closely dependent on Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978; doi:10.3390/rs11171978 www.mdpi.com/journal/remotesensing 2 of 21 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 cultural practices (tillage, fertilizer, irrigation, and residue management) [1–4]. The quantification of
the advantages or disadvantages associated with the implemented cultural practices then involves
the achievement of a balance sheet based on monitoring the cultures, by targeting the key integrative
variables (e.g., leaf area index, biomass, and yield) [5–7]. In this context, the use of satellite imagery
combined with a crop functioning model constitutes a useful tool for diagnosis at a landscape scale. p
g
g
p
The recent launch of the Sentinel-1, Sentinel-2, and Landsat-8 satellite missions has opened the
way to new opportunities for the combined use of data acquired in visible, infrared, and microwave
wavelengths [8–10]. In the past, the lack of near-synchronous acquisition of optical and synthetic
aperture radar (SAR) image time series during the same agricultural season restricted the possibilities
of joint signal analysis to a limited number of studies [11–13]. The majority of the studies were then
based on a few images, with the analyses of the satellite signals being often temporally and/or spatially
separated, which made a comparison of the sensitivity and dynamic observed for contrasting surface
states difficult. Nevertheless, these studies provide interesting study cases of the possibilities of using
these data in a context of monitoring agricultural areas, with various issues, ranging from land cover
classification [14] to the monitoring of crop or soil parameters [15–17], the detection of specific cultural
practices [18–20], or damage concerning crops [21]. Vegetation indices derived from optical image reflectance are often used for monitoring the
photosynthetic activity of vegetation during the phenological cycle [22] or to estimate biophysical
parameters such as the leaf area index (LAI) or the fraction of absorbed photosynthetically active
radiation (FAPAR). 1. Introduction Hence, the approaches aiming at modeling the crop cycle at a regional scale were
primarily based on the assimilation of optical images [22–27] into a simple agro-meteorological model,
such as GRAMI [28], Aquacrop [29], or the simple algorithm for yield model combined with a water
balance model (SAFY-WB) [30,31]. The limits encountered by the use of optical reflectance/indices are inherent to the image
specificities, with, for instance, saturation of the indices when the vegetation becomes dense, or
with a lack of observation during cloudy periods. The synthetic aperture radar (SAR) data then
constitute an alternative, providing information about substitution by targeting the same ([32,33]) or
complementary ([16,34]) variables as those derived from optical imagery. The combined use of optical
and SAR images to constraint models remains original and stays confined to a limited number of
studies; however, they have all demonstrated the interest of this kind of approach for improving crop
monitoring [16,32,33,35,36]. Moreover, to the best of our knowledge, the monitoring of the popcorn
variety has never been performed using satellite radar data in order to estimate the time courses of its
masses and phenological stages. In this context, the objective of this study is to estimate the evolution of popcorn dry masses at a
field scale, as well as the daily temporal resolution using an agro-meteorological model (SAFY-WB)
controlled by the Green Area Index (GAI) derived from satellite optical and SAR images. The remainder
of this paper is structured as follows: the materials (site description, satellite and ground data, and
model) and method are first presented (Section 2). Section 3 presents the results on mass simulations
performed by the model controlled by GAI, derived from satellite data (combined use of SAR and
optical images), followed by a discussion in Section 4. The discussion evaluates the capacity of inferring
corn phenological stages throughout the crop cycle, as well as their associated masses (ear, plant, and
total masses). Moreover, the impact of (1) the SAR signal processing (speckle filtering and thermal
noise removal), and (2) the intercrops’ influences on SAR signal and masses retrieval are discussed. 2.1. Site Description The studied area is located in the southwest of France (Figure 1), near the city of Toulouse, in
the Occitanie region (43.49◦N 0.93◦E). This area is characterized by a temperate climate. It is highly
anthropized, and mainly comprises seasonal crops, grasslands, forests, and urban areas. Among the 3 of 21
e, in the
hi hl Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
The studied area is
O
i
i
i
(43 49 different crop species, this work focused on eight corn fields dedicated to popcorn production. The
areas of the corn fields ranged from 2.6 to 30.6 ha (13.8 ha on average). anthropized, and mainly comprises seasonal crops, grasslands, forests, and urban areas. Among the
different crop species, this work focused on eight corn fields dedicated to popcorn production. The areas
of the corn fields ranged from 2.6 to 30.6 ha (13.8 ha on average). Figure 1. Location of the studied fields of popcorn, together with the swathes of Sentinel 1 (S1-A; orbits
132 and 30) and Landsat-8. The fields used for calibration (F4) and validation (F1, F2, and F3) are
represented by yellow and green circles, respectively. Fields F5 to F8 belong to the same working farm
and are used to study the spatial distribution of the production at a working-farm scale. The weather
station is shown by the blue cross. Figure 1. Location of the studied fields of popcorn, together with the swathes of Sentinel 1 (S1-A;
orbits 132 and 30) and Landsat-8. The fields used for calibration (F4) and validation (F1, F2, and F3) are
represented by yellow and green circles, respectively. Fields F5 to F8 belong to the same working farm
and are used to study the spatial distribution of the production at a working-farm scale. The weather
station is shown by the blue cross. igure 1. Location of the studied fields of popcorn, together with the swathes of Sentinel 1 (S1-A; orbits
32 and 30) and Landsat-8. The fields used for calibration (F4) and validation (F1, F2, and F3) are
epresented by yellow and green circles, respectively. Fields F5 to F8 belong to the same working farm
nd are used to study the spatial distribution of the production at a working-farm scale. The weather
tation is shown by the blue cross. Figure 1. Location of the studied fields of popcorn, together with the swathes of Sentinel 1 (S1-A;
orbits 132 and 30) and Landsat-8. 2.1. Site Description The fields used for calibration (F4) and validation (F1, F2, and F3) are
represented by yellow and green circles, respectively. Fields F5 to F8 belong to the same working farm
and are used to study the spatial distribution of the production at a working-farm scale. The weather
station is shown by the blue cross. igure 1. Location of the studied fields of popcorn, together with the swathes of Sentinel 1 (S1-A; orbit
32 and 30) and Landsat-8. The fields used for calibration (F4) and validation (F1, F2, and F3) ar
epresented by yellow and green circles, respectively. Fields F5 to F8 belong to the same working farm
nd are used to study the spatial distribution of the production at a working-farm scale. The weathe
tation is shown by the blue cross. Figure 1. Location of the studied fields of popcorn, together with the swathes of Sentinel 1 (S1-A;
orbits 132 and 30) and Landsat-8. The fields used for calibration (F4) and validation (F1, F2, and F3) are
represented by yellow and green circles, respectively. Fields F5 to F8 belong to the same working farm
and are used to study the spatial distribution of the production at a working-farm scale. The weather
station is shown by the blue cross. 2.2.2. Ground Data Ground data were collected over four fields (identified as ID F1, F2, F3, and F4 in Figure 1). They concerned agricultural practices (e.g., irrigation, sowing, tillage, and harvesting) and vegetation
parameters (crop height, main phenological stages, biomass, dry matter, and water content). The
surface soil roughness was considered stable during the time after sowing because no tillage events
occurred until harvest. Therefore, it was assumed that surface soil roughness changes had no significant
impact on the optical and SAR signals. Fields F5 to F8 were used to study the spatial distribution of
the production at the working farm scale in Section 3.3 (no ground data were available for these fields). F1 and F4 belong to one working farm, and the others belong to the second working farm. These fields were sown during March and April and were harvested at the end of September
and in early October 2016, as indicated in Table 1. Throughout the crop season, at least six vegetation
measurements were performed for each field. Each measurement was composed of five plants of corn,
from which the above-ground biomass was directly weighed in situ. Then, the total aboveground dry
mass (TDM) was measured after crop drying (the samples were put in an oven for 48 h at 65 ◦C). The
water content was finally derived from the difference between the total biomass and TDM. For these
measurements, the ears and the rest of the plant (leaves and stems) were separated, giving access to
the ear dry mass (EDM) and the plant dry mass (PDM), respectively. Table 1. Dates of the sowing, harvest, and vegetation measurements of the four studied fields. The
temporal reference is given in day of year (doy) for 2016, and also in ◦C day, according to an agronomic
point of view. Table 1. Dates of the sowing, harvest, and vegetation measurements of the four studied fields. The
temporal reference is given in day of year (doy) for 2016, and also in ◦C day, according to an agronomic
point of view. Data Pre-Processing The SAR images were processed in ground range-detected (GRD) mode, with an incidence angle
ranging from 29.1◦to 46.0◦[10]. The S1-A images were pre-processed (radiometric calibration, thermal
noise, range doppler terrain correction, and re-sampled at 10 × 10 m2 spacing) from the Google Earth
engine website, so as to obtain the sigma-naught ratio (σ0
VH/VV), the best index for monitoring the
vegetative part of corn, from the Sentinel-1 data [35,37]. Optical images were acquired by the sensor OLI onboard of Landsat 8 in four narrow spectral
bands, ranging from 0.45 to 0.89 µm, which correspond to the blue, green, red, and near-infrared
domains. They were processed using the level 2A processor, named “multi-sensor atmospheric
correction and cloud screening” (MACCS), and are available free of charge from Theia Land Data
Services (https://www.theia-land.fr/en/). After preprocessing, only 10 images could be used over the
fields (between days 90 and 290), because of cloud cover (mean temporal repetitiveness of 21 days
instead of 16 in the nominal value). In the following, these images were used to derive the GAI. Acquisition Calendar
Acquisition Calendar Acquisition Calendar
Satellite data were acquired throughout a seasonal crop period, from March to October 2016. The
SAR data (51 images from orbit 30 (25) and 132 (26)) were acquired at C-band (at VV and VH
polarizations) by the Sentinel 1A (S1-A) platform (freely available at Hub https://scihub.copernicus.eu/)
whereas, the 18 optical data were acquired by Landsat-8 Operational Land Imager (OLI) sensor (Figure
2)
Satellite data were acquired throughout a seasonal crop period, from March to October 2016. The SAR data (51 images from orbit 30 (25) and 132 (26)) were acquired at C-band (at VV and VH
polarizations) by the Sentinel 1A (S1-A) platform (freely available at Hub https://scihub.copernicus.eu/),
whereas, the 18 optical data were acquired by Landsat-8 Operational Land Imager (OLI) sensor
(Figure 2). Remote Sens. 2019, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW
4 of 22 Figure 2. Time course of optical (Landsat-8 OLI) and synthetic aperture radar (SAR; orbit 30 and 132)
acquisition during the cultivation cycle of popcorn (April to October) in 2016. The cloud cover rate over
the fields is mentioned for the optical data (black circle). Figure 2. Time course of optical (Landsat-8 OLI) and synthetic aperture radar (SAR; orbit 30 and 132)
acquisition during the cultivation cycle of popcorn (April to October) in 2016. The cloud cover rate
over the fields is mentioned for the optical data (black circle). Figure 2. Time course of optical (Landsat-8 OLI) and synthetic aperture radar (SAR; orbit 30 and 132
acquisition during the cultivation cycle of popcorn (April to October) in 2016. The cloud cover rate ove
the fields is mentioned for the optical data (black circle). Figure 2. Time course of optical (Landsat-8 OLI) and synthetic aperture radar (SAR; orbit 30 and 132)
acquisition during the cultivation cycle of popcorn (April to October) in 2016. The cloud cover rate
over the fields is mentioned for the optical data (black circle). Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 4 of 21 2.2.2. Ground Data Field ID
Date of
Sowing
Date of Harvest
(doy/◦C day)
Number of
Samples
Date of Sampling (doy/◦C day)
F1
102
278/2453
7
(133/214, 148/352, 169/599, 195/985,
215/1299, 232/1574, 266/2095)
F2
104
281/2264
6
(133/201, 169/586, 195/971, 215/1285,
232/1561, 266/2081)
F3
87
273/2261
6
(133/292, 169/677, 195/1063,
215/1377, 232/1652, 266/2173)
F4
102
278/2453
7
(133/214, 148/352, 169/599, 195/985,
215/1299, 232/1574, 266/2095) Figure 3 presents an example of temporal dynamics of the dry masses (TDM, EDM, and PDM),
crop water content, and phenological stages from the in-situ data processed for field F3 (Figure 1). The TDM starts increasing from emergence, to reach its maximum (17.97 t·ha−1) just before harvest. The allocation of the mass to the ear starts from about 1000 ◦C day, and its dry mass reaches about
12 t·ha−1 a few days before measurement. The water content, strongly correlated with the biomass 5 of 21
location
ew days Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
tarts increasing from em
f h
h (R2 mean = 0.95, not shown here), starts from 94% at emergence, and then decreases significantly
from flowering, to reach about 25% at harvest (41% was measured a few days before harvest, whereas
vegetation continued to strongly dry). Considering the measurements, the mass of the grain represents
an average of 77% of the EDM at harvest day. The maximum height of this variety of corn ranged from
1.60 to 1.80 m, depending on the studied field. efore measurement. The water content, strongly correlated with the biomass (R mean 0.95, not
hown here), starts from 94% at emergence, and then decreases significantly from flowering, to reach
bout 25% at harvest (41% was measured a few days before harvest, whereas vegetation continued to
trongly dry). Considering the measurements, the mass of the grain represents an average of 77% of the
EDM at harvest day. The maximum height of this variety of corn ranged from 1.60 to 1.80 m, depending
n the studied field. Figure 3. Temporal evolution of the crop water content (in blue), total dry masses of the corn (TDM; in
red), divided into the following two components: ear dry mass (EDM; in green) and plant dry mass
(PDM; in black). These measurements are performed for field F3. The vertical dashed red line
represents the harvest date. Figure 3. 2.2.2. Ground Data Temporal evolution of the crop water content (in blue), total dry masses of the corn (TDM;
in red), divided into the following two components: ear dry mass (EDM; in green) and plant dry
mass (PDM; in black). These measurements are performed for field F3. The vertical dashed red line
represents the harvest date. igure 3. Temporal evolution of the crop water content (in blue), total dry masses of the corn (TDM; in
ed), divided into the following two components: ear dry mass (EDM; in green) and plant dry mass
PDM; in black). These measurements are performed for field F3. The vertical dashed red line
epresents the harvest date. Figure 3. Temporal evolution of the crop water content (in blue), total dry masses of the corn (TDM;
in red), divided into the following two components: ear dry mass (EDM; in green) and plant dry
mass (PDM; in black). These measurements are performed for field F3. The vertical dashed red line
represents the harvest date. The meteorological data (i.e., air temperature, solar radiation, relative humidity, wind speed, and
ainfall) were registered at semi-hourly time steps by one weather station (Figure 1). They were used to
The meteorological data (i.e., air temperature, solar radiation, relative humidity, wind speed,
and rainfall) were registered at semi-hourly time steps by one weather station (Figure 1). They
were used to derive the daily reference evapotranspiration (ET0) according to the FAO (Food and
Agriculture Organization) method, and were used as the input variables of the agro-meteorological
model (Figure 4). 2.3. The Agro-Meteorological Model The Agro-Meteorological Model
The photosynthetically active fraction of solar radiation absorbed by the plants is proportional to
GAI and Rg, according to the Beer-Lambert law (Equation (5)): model, named SAFY-WB (simple algorithm for yield estimates coupled
), was used to simulate the time courses (with a daily time step) of the
PARdoy = 0.47 × Rg ×
1 −e(−0.6×GAIdoy)
. (5) upled
f the
(5) popcorn masses (total, plant, and ear masses), GAI, and evapotranspiration. The model, detailed in the
literature [30,31], requires the following meteorological input variables: the global solar radiation, air
temperature, precipitation, and potential evapotranspiration (Figure 4). Only the main processes of the
vegetation growth model are presented hereinafter
The leaf production and leaf senescence are controlled by a growing degree-day function. During
the leaf growing period, a fraction of the daily DM production is allocated to the leaf production (LP)
thanks to an empirical parameterization proposed by the authors of [39], in Equations (6) and (7): portional to the absorbed photosynthetically active radiation, according
ency, and a stress coefficient related to the meteorological conditions
iterature [38], in Equations (1)–(4)):
𝑇𝐷𝑀
𝑇𝐷𝑀
∆𝑇𝐷𝑀
(1)
PRTdoy = max
0, Pla × e(Plb×P Tempdoy)
,
(6)
LPdoy = TDM × PRTdoy∗SLAdoy,
(7) oportional to the absorbed photosynthetically active radiation, according
iency, and a stress coefficient related to the meteorological conditions
PRTdoy = max
0, Pla × e(Plb×P Tempdoy)
,
(6) ding
tions
(6) )
(7) erature [38], in Equations (1)–(4)):
LPdoy = TDM × PRTdoy∗SLAdoy,
(7) 𝑇𝐷𝑀𝑑𝑜𝑦= 𝑇𝐷𝑀𝑑𝑜𝑦−1 + ∆𝑇𝐷𝑀𝑑𝑜𝑦,
(1)
re, Pla and Plb (empirical parameters) drive the partitioning to the leaves. 𝑇𝐷𝑀𝑑𝑜𝑦= 𝑇𝐷𝑀𝑑𝑜𝑦−1 + ∆𝑇𝐷𝑀𝑑𝑜𝑦,
where, Pla and Plb (empirical parameters) drive the partitioning to the leaves. with, ∆𝑇𝐷𝑀𝑑𝑜𝑦= 𝐸𝐿𝑈𝐸 × 𝑃𝐴𝑅𝑑𝑜𝑦× 𝑆𝑐,
(2)
𝐺𝐴𝐼𝑑𝑜𝑦= 𝐺𝐴𝐼𝑑𝑜𝑦−1 + ∆𝐺𝐴𝐼𝑑𝑜𝑦,
(3)
The senescence occurred at a prescribed rate, when the air temperature accumulated from plant
emergence (P Tempdoy) reached a crop-specific threshold (given by its variety). A temperature-stress
function affected the DM production, considering a 2-degree polynomial specified by an optimal value
(30 ◦C) and two extreme values (6 and 42 ◦C), beyond which the corn growth stopped ([40]). with, ∆𝐺𝐴𝐼𝑑𝑜𝑦= ∆𝑇𝐷𝑀× 𝑆𝐿𝐴𝑑𝑜𝑦× 𝑃𝐿𝐼𝑑𝑜𝑦,
(4)
where ELUE represents the effective light use efficiency, SLA the specific leaf area, PLI the partitioning
to leaf index, Sc the stress coefficient of water and temperature, and doy the day of the year. 2.3. The Agro-Meteorological Model The agro-meteorological model, named SAFY-WB (simple algorithm for yield estimates coupled
with a water balance model), was used to simulate the time courses (with a daily time step) of the
popcorn masses (total, plant, and ear masses), GAI, and evapotranspiration. The model, detailed in the
literature [30,31], requires the following meteorological input variables: the global solar radiation, air
temperature, precipitation, and potential evapotranspiration (Figure 4). Only the main processes of the
vegetation growth model are presented hereinafter. The TDM and GAI are proportional to the absorbed photosynthetically active radiation, according
to the effective light use efficiency, and a stress coefficient related to the meteorological conditions
(relationship adapted from the literature [38], in Equations (1)–(4)): TDMdoy = TDMdoy−1 + ∆TDMdoy,
(1)
with, ∆TDMdoy = ELUE × PARdoy × Sc,
(2)
GAIdoy = GAIdoy−1 + ∆GAIdoy,
(3)
with, ∆GAIdoy = ∆TDM × SLAdoy × PLIdoy,
(4) TDMdoy = TDMdoy−1 + ∆TDMdoy,
(1) (1) with, ∆TDMdoy = ELUE × PARdoy × Sc,
(2)
GAIdoy = GAIdoy−1 + ∆GAIdoy,
(3) (2) (3) with, ∆GAIdoy = ∆TDM × SLAdoy × PLIdoy,
(4) with, ∆GAIdoy = ∆TDM × SLAdoy × PLIdoy,
(4) (4) 6 of 21
of 22 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
Remote Sens. 2019, 11, x FOR P where ELUE represents the effective light use efficiency, SLA the specific leaf area, PLI the partitioning
to leaf index, Sc the stress coefficient of water and temperature, and doy the day of the year. y
p
p
(
)
g
(
g
Organization) method, and were used as the input variables of the agro-meteorological model (Figure
4). Figure 4. Temporal evolution of the climatic data used as the input of the agro-meteorological model (Rg,
ET0 rainfall and T
)
Figure 4. Temporal evolution of the climatic data used as the input of the agro-meteorological model
(Rg, ET0, rainfall, and Tmean). Figure 4. Temporal evolution of the climatic data used as the input of the agro-meteorological model (Rg,
ET
rainfall and T
)
Figure 4. Temporal evolution of the climatic data used as the input of the agro-meteorological model
(Rg, ET0, rainfall, and Tmean). ET0, rainfall, and Tmean). 2.3. 2.4. Methodology
2.4. Methodology The methodology used to simulate the different masses from the model driven by satellite data is
given in Figure 5. gy
The methodology used to simulate the different masses from the model driven by satellite data i
given in Figure 5. Figure 5. Methodology used to estimate TDM, PDM, and EDM from a combination of satellite images,
the SAFY-WB model, and ground data. Figure 5. Methodology used to estimate TDM, PDM, and EDM from a combination of satellite images,
the SAFY-WB model, and ground data. Figure 5. Methodology used to estimate TDM, PDM, and EDM from a combination of satellite images,
he SAFY-WB model, and ground data. Figure 5. Methodology used to estimate TDM, PDM, and EDM from a combination of satellite images,
the SAFY-WB model, and ground data. The satellite data were first preprocessed following different steps according to their waveleng
domain, as described in Section 2.2.1: Data Processing. The green area indices were then derived fro
both optical and radar images (GAIopt and GAISAR). The satellite data were first preprocessed following different steps according to their wavelength
domain, as described in Section 2.2.1: Data Processing. The green area indices were then derived from
both optical and radar images (GAIopt and GAISAR). The satellite data were first preprocessed following different steps according to their waveleng
omain, as described in Section 2.2.1: Data Processing. The green area indices were then derived fro
oth optical and radar images (GAIopt and GAISAR). The satellite data were first preprocessed following different steps according to their wavelength
domain, as described in Section 2.2.1: Data Processing. The green area indices were then derived from
both optical and radar images (GAIopt and GAISAR). p
g
(
)
GAIopt was generated through the BVNet tool (Biophysical Variables Neural NETwork), develope
by the authors of [43]. This tool combines a radiative transfer model (SAIL + PROPSPECT = PROSAIL
p
g
p
GAIopt was generated through the BVNet tool (Biophysical Variables Neural NETwork), developed
by the authors of [43]. This tool combines a radiative transfer model (SAIL + PROPSPECT = PROSAIL)
and artificial neural networks (ANNs). The radiative transfer model was first used to constitute a
training dataset, with the constraint of estimating reflectance (from 400 to 2500 nm) for a wide range of
conditions regarding the crop biophysical variables. 2.3. The Agro-Meteorological Model The photosynthetically active fraction of solar radiation absorbed by the plants is proportional to
GAI and Rg, according to the Beer-Lambert law (Equation (5)):
The formalism of this model is based on a limited number of parameters (six have been defined
as target parameters through the sensitivity study described by the authors of [31]), which allow
for combining the model with the remotely sensed data. Four of them describe the development
stages of the crop, as follows: partitioning to the leaf parameters (PlA and PlB) is effective during the
growth phase (Equations (6) and (7)), while the cumulative temperature, which induces senescence
and the rate of senescence (Stt and Rs), is used to describe the last phenological stages. Parameter D0
(corresponding to a few days after the emergence of corn) and the effective light use efficiency (ELUE)
are related to agricultural practices (Equation (2)). Four phenological stages are simulated by the model, as follows: four to five leaves, flowering,
ripening, and harvest. They are derived from D0, from the day on which the EDM starts growing,
when GAI starts decreasing, and when GAI reaches 0, respectively. 7 of 21
owering
ng whe Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
Four phenological
i
i
d h
t T This type of approach has previously been validated for the monitoring of the crop cycle of wheat,
corn, and sunflower, using only optical images [23,30,41], and for soybean, sunflower, and grain corn
using both optical and SAR images [16,35,42]. GAI starts decreasing, and when GAI reaches 0, respectively. This type of approach has previously been validated for the monitoring of the crop cycle of whea
corn, and sunflower, using only optical images [23,30,41], and for soybean, sunflower, and grain cor
using both optical and SAR images [16,35,42]. 2.4. Methodology
2.4. Methodology 2019, 11, 1978 8 of 21 CGAI =
s
N−1
GAImea
X
0<ti<2500
[GAIsim(ti) −GAImea(ti)]2,
(9)
CTDM =
s
N−1
TDMmea
X
0<ti<2500
[TDMsim(ti) −TDMmea(ti)]2,
(10)
C = sum
GAImea
−1 × CGAI
TDMmea
−1 × CTDM
,
(11) CGAI =
s
N−1
GAImea
X
0<ti<2500
[GAIsim(ti) −GAImea(ti)]2,
(9) (9) CTDM =
s
N−1
TDMmea
X
0<ti<2500
[TDMsim(ti) −TDMmea(ti)]2,
(10) (10) C = sum
GAImea
−1 × CGAI
TDMmea
−1 × CTDM
,
(11) (11) where GAIsim or TDMsim correspond to the values simulated by the model at time (ti), GAImea and
TDMmea are the values obtained from the measurements (satellite or ground), and N represents the
amount of data collected between sowing (0 ◦C day) and harvest (2500 ◦C day). where GAIsim or TDMsim correspond to the values simulated by the model at time (ti), GAImea and
TDMmea are the values obtained from the measurements (satellite or ground), and N represents the
amount of data collected between sowing (0 ◦C day) and harvest (2500 ◦C day). Table 2. Definition and domain of variation of the six target parameters, namely: the crop-specific
parameters (PlA, PlB, Stt, and Rs) and the field-specific parameters (D0 and ELUE). Parameter
Definition
Domain of Variation
Unit
PlA
Partition-to-leaf function
0.05–0.5
-
PlB
Partition-to-leaf function
10−5–10−2
-
Stt
Temperature sum for senescence
0–2000
◦C day
Rs
Rate of senescence
0–105
◦C
D0
Day0
90–250
day
ELUE
Effective light-use efficiency
0.5–6
g.MJ−1 In our case, the calibration/validation steps were performed from the data acquired from field
F4 (Figure 1) and fields F1, F2, and F3, respectively. These steps consist of comparing the simulated
TDM, PDM, and EDM to the measured values. Field F4 was chosen for calibration because it is flat,
it is managed with conventional practices in contrast to others (tillage and no intercrop), and the
culture is homogeneous. Hence, the results of the calibration were not affected by the local slope of
the field, the heterogeneity of the culture, or the presence of an intercrop. The calibration step was
performed for one field, reproducing how the agricultural decision-makers operate (they based their
recommendations on the data collected in a field considered representative of an agricultural region). 2.4. Methodology
2.4. Methodology As proposed by the authors of [30,31], the four parameters describing the developmental stages
of the crop were estimated during the calibration (PlA, PlB, Stt, and Rs) step and remained constant for
the validation. Two parameters were optimized (using a simplex method) during the calibration and
validation for each field, i.e., those related to the agricultural practices (namely, D0 and ELUE). g
p
y
Finally, a production map was generated at a working farm scale (six fields, representing 101 ha),
in order to analyze its spatial distribution, by considering three target simulation outputs, namely:
total, ear, and plant masses. 2.4. Methodology
2.4. Methodology Artificial neural networks were then trained on
the dataset estimated from PROSAIL (considering reflectance as the input variable, and GAI, FAPAR,
and fCover as the output). Regarding GAI, the domain of validity of such an approach ranges between
0 and 6 m2·m−2. The trained ANNs were finally applied to the satellite images, using green, red, and
near-infrared reflectances. Such an approach has been validated in the South-West of France using
optical images provided by Formosat-2, Spot-4, and Landsat-8, on independent ground measurements,
showing an accurate performance with a correlation of 0.92 and a root mean square error (RMSE) of
0.4 m2·m−2 for corn in the literature [41]. These good performances led us to use this approach to
derive the GAI of popcorn from optical imagery. GAISAR are empirically derived from the sensitivity of the SAR signals to the GAI, from a
non-linear regression (Equation (8)) valid from 0 to 1000 ◦C day. Among the tested SAR configurations
(σ◦VH, σ◦VH/VV, and σ◦VV), the best performances were obtained with σ◦VH/VV (R2 = 0.97; RMSE =
0.28 m2·m−2). After a 1000 ◦C day, the quality of the relationship was strongly degraded, as σ◦VH/VV
saturated and remained at a high value until harvest, whereas the GAI decreased during senescence,
as shown in the literature [35]. GAISAR = 52.92 × e0.55×σ0
VH/VV
(8) (8) Once generated, GAISAR and/or GAIopt were combined to the measured TDM (TDMmea), in order
to control the model during the steps of calibration and validation. This step aims at optimizing
the target parameters inside their domains of variation to minimize the bi-objective cost function
(Table 2) [23,31,41]. The bi-objective cost function (Equation (11)) is based on the relative root mean square errors,
considering the satellite derived green area index (GAImea) and using the measured total dry mass dry
as reference (Equations (9) and (10)): Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
8 of 21 Remote Sens. 3.1. Model Calibration Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field (F4—Figur
Figure 6. Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field igure 6. Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field (F4—Figure
). The dry masses are divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM). GAISAR and
GAIopt are displayed by grey crosses or circles, respectively. Simulations of GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM
re represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and black lines, respectively. Figure 6. Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field
(F4—Figure 1). The dry masses are divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM,
and EDM). GAISAR and GAIopt are displayed by grey crosses or circles, respectively. Simulations of
GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. igu e 6. Co
pa iso s be
ee
e si
u a e
a
easu e
asses o
e ca ib a io
ie
(
igu
). The dry masses are divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM). GAISAR and
GAIopt are displayed by grey crosses or circles, respectively. Simulations of GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM
re represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and black lines, respectively. Figure 6. Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field
(F4—Figure 1). The dry masses are divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM,
and EDM). GAISAR and GAIopt are displayed by grey crosses or circles, respectively. Simulations of
GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. Table 3. Values of the crop-specific parameters (PlA, PlB, Stt, and Rs) and the field-specific parameters
(D0 and ELUE) derived from the calibration step. Table 3. Values of the crop-specific parameters (PlA, PlB, Stt, and Rs) and the field-specific parameters
(D0 and ELUE) derived from the calibration step. Parameter
Value
PlA
0.08
PlB
3.0 × 10−3
Stt
1361
Rs
3569
D0
142
ELUE
3.98 Parameter
Value
PlA
0.08
PlB
3.0 × 10−3
Stt
1361
Rs
3569
D0
142
ELUE
3.98 Table 4. 3.1. Model Calibration Figure 6 presents the results of the calibration step and compares the temporal evolutions of
the simulated and observed GAI and DM along the crop cycle, from sowing (0 ◦C day) to harvest
(about 2500 ◦C day). The obtained values of the crop-specific parameters (PlA, PlB, Stt, and Rs) and the
field-specific parameters (D0 and ELUE) are presented in Table 3. The temporal trends of the GAI and DM (TDM, EDM, and PDM) were globally well reproduced. All of the biophysical variables were simulated with good performances, as demonstrated by the
values of the determination coefficient, which were higher than 0.96 for the simulation of GAI, TDM,
EDM, and TDM (Table 4). 9 of 21
st (about
and the Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
500 °C day). The obta Figure 6. Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field (F4—Figure
1). The dry masses are divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM). GAISAR and
GAIopt are displayed by grey crosses or circles, respectively. Simulations of GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM
are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and black lines, respectively. Figure 6. Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field
(F4—Figure 1). The dry masses are divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM,
and EDM). GAISAR and GAIopt are displayed by grey crosses or circles, respectively. Simulations of
GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. Figure 6. Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field (F4—Figure
1). The dry masses are divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM). GAISAR and
GAIopt are displayed by grey crosses or circles, respectively. Simulations of GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM
are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and black lines, respectively. Figure 6. Comparisons between the simulated and measured masses for the calibration field
(F4—Figure 1). The dry masses are divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM,
and EDM). GAISAR and GAIopt are displayed by grey crosses or circles, respectively. Simulations of
GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines respectively igure 6. 3.1. Model Calibration Statistical performances estimated for Green Area Index (GAI), Ear Dry Mass (EDM), Plant Dry
Mass (PDM), and Total above ground Dry Mass (TDM) retrievals during the calibration step of the model. Target Output
n
R2
a
b
RMSE
rRMSE (%)
GAI
9
0.99
0.97
−0.08
0.08
10.58
EDM
7
0.96
0.99
−0.05
0.82
27.65
PDM
7
0.97
0.95
0.10
0.45
14.48
TDM
7
0.96
0.96
0.12
1.17
19.35 Figure 6 also shows that the GAI, derived from optical or SAR reflectances, was quite stable and
exhibited a similar pattern during the first phenological stages (between 0 and 500 ◦C day). It was not
significantly affected by soil moisture change (as a result of irrigation and/or rainfall) when the surface
was still mainly bare (just after sowing). This result confirms the pertinence of using the ratio of SAR
backscattering coefficients (σ◦VH/VV) instead of using simple co- or cross-polarization (σ◦VV or σ◦VH)
to derive the GAI (the latter being much more affected by soil moisture changes, as demonstrated by
the authors of [44]). During the growing period (between 500 and 1000 ◦C day), the GAI derived from the SAR or optical
images exhibited a similar trend, but was not completely the same. This point has a limited impact on
the simulation, as the agro-meteorological model was not able to produce so much vegetation variation
during the growing period. This approach is thus robust enough to be not significantly affected
by the difference in GAI retrieval until flowering (1000 ◦C day), contrary to empirical approaches
in which a small change in the backscattering coefficient induces a proportional change in the GAI Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 10 of 21 retrieval [45–47]. From the end of flowering to the harvest, only GAI derived from optical data was
assimilated, as the SAR signal saturated and was not sufficiently sensitive to senescence [35,37,48,49]. 3.2. Model Validation—Mass Retrieval Figure 7 shows the comparison between the simulated masses (TDM, EDM, and PDM) and those
measured in-situ (data used for calibration, displayed by black crosses in the figure, are not used to
calculate the statistical performances of the model retrieval). The performances were good for the three
parameters (R2 > 0.90 and rRMSE < 30%; Table 6, with TNR). The results show that the model was able
to simulate the masses over the full range of mass values (up to around 20 t·ha−1). Nevertheless, the
results show that the model was not able to reproduce the behavior of one specific point (surrounded
in Figure 7a,c). This point was associated with lower in situ values than those for the simulated ones. This is explained by the falling of leaves, which occurred just before harvest (around 2100 ◦C day). This
phenomenon, illustrated in Figure 8, was not simulated by the model. Consequently, the simulation
overestimated the total dry mass. Remote Sens. 2019, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW
11 of 22
7a,c). This point was associated with lower in situ values than those for the simulated ones. This is
explained by the falling of leaves, which occurred just before harvest (around 2100 °C day). This
phenomenon, illustrated in Figure 8, was not simulated by the model. Consequently, the simulation
overestimated the total dry mass. (a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 7. Comparisons between the measured and simulated dry masses of ear (EDM) (a), plant (PDM)
(b), and the total (TDM) (c). Black and red crosses represent the points used for calibration and
validation, respectively. Only red crosses were used to calculate statistical performances. Black dashed
lines represent a confidence interval of ±10% around the trend line (red line). Figure 7. Comparisons between the measured and simulated dry masses of ear (EDM) (a), plant
(PDM) (b), and the total (TDM) (c). Black and red crosses represent the points used for calibration and
validation, respectively. Only red crosses were used to calculate statistical performances. Black dashed
lines represent a confidence interval of ±10% around the trend line (red line). (a) (b) (b)
(c) (c) Figure 7. Comparisons between the measured and simulated dry masses of ear (EDM) (a), plant (PDM)
(b), and the total (TDM) (c). Black and red crosses represent the points used for calibration and
validation, respectively. Only red crosses were used to calculate statistical performances. 3.2. Model Validation—Mass Retrieval Black dashed
lines represent a confidence interval of ±10% around the trend line (red line). Figure 7. Comparisons between the measured and simulated dry masses of ear (EDM) (a), plant
(PDM) (b), and the total (TDM) (c). Black and red crosses represent the points used for calibration and
validation, respectively. Only red crosses were used to calculate statistical performances. Black dashed
lines represent a confidence interval of ±10% around the trend line (red line). The values of the field-specific parameters (D0 and ELUE) are given in Table 5 for the eight studied
fields (F1 to F8). The spread of D0 was in accordance with the different dates of sowing, whereas the
values of ELUE (optimized around 4 g.MJ−1) were consistent with the literature [41]. The values of the field-specific parameters (D0 and ELUE) are given in Table 5 for the eight studied
fields (F1 to F8). The spread of D0 was in accordance with the different dates of sowing, whereas the
values of ELUE (optimized around 4 g.MJ−1) were consistent with the literature [41]. The values of the field-specific parameters (D0 and ELUE) are given in Table 5 for the eight studied
fields (F1 to F8). The spread of D0 was in accordance with the different dates of sowing, whereas the
values of ELUE (optimized around 4 g.MJ−1) were consistent with the literature [41]. The values of the field-specific parameters (D0 and ELUE) are given in Table 5 for the eight studied
fields (F1 to F8). The spread of D0 was in accordance with the different dates of sowing, whereas the
values of ELUE (optimized around 4 g.MJ−1) were consistent with the literature [41]. 11 of 21 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 Table 5. Values of the field-specific parameters (D0 and ELUE) derived from the validation step. Parameter
F1
F2
F3
F4
F5
F6
F7
F8
D0 (DoY)
150
157
137
143
104
133
132
144
ELUE (g.MJ−1)
4.32
4.40
3.93
3.79
3.14
3.67
3.73
4.12
mote Sens. 2019, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW
12 of 22
Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry masses
were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of
the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. 3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm
3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm
3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm Once validated, the method was applied at a field scale for one working farm composed of six fields
of corn (Figure 9). The approach allowed for the estimation of biomass production just after harvest
(TDM, EDM, and PDM) for all of the considered fields. In our case, the total annual production ranged
from 11.11 to 16.70 t.ha−1. The results also show that the ear masses differed between the fields, ranging
from 48 t for the lower production (field F7) to 335 t for the highest production (field F2). At the scale of
the working farm, an amount of 1492 t of corn was produced, distributed as 510 t of plant and 982 t of
ears. Once validated, the method was applied at a field scale for one working farm composed of six
fields of corn (Figure 9). The approach allowed for the estimation of biomass production just after
harvest (TDM, EDM, and PDM) for all of the considered fields. In our case, the total annual production
ranged from 11.11 to 16.70 t·ha−1. The results also show that the ear masses differed between the fields,
ranging from 48 t for the lower production (field F7) to 335 t for the highest production (field F2). At the scale of the working farm, an amount of 1492 t of corn was produced, distributed as 510 t of
plant and 982 t of ears. Once validated, the method was applied at a field scale for one working farm composed of six fields
of corn (Figure 9). The approach allowed for the estimation of biomass production just after harvest
(TDM, EDM, and PDM) for all of the considered fields. In our case, the total annual production ranged
from 11.11 to 16.70 t.ha−1. The results also show that the ear masses differed between the fields, ranging
from 48 t for the lower production (field F7) to 335 t for the highest production (field F2). At the scale of
the working farm, an amount of 1492 t of corn was produced, distributed as 510 t of plant and 982 t of
ears. Figure 9. Map of corn masses simulated at harvest for a working farm. TDM, EDM, and PDM were
provided from the simulation controlled by the SAR and optical satellite data. Figure 9. Map of corn masses simulated at harvest for a working farm. 3.2. Model Validation—Mass Retrieval Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry masses
were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of
the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the last
measurements, acquired around 2100 °C day. Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry
masses were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed
red, green, and black lines, respectively. The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the
last measurements, acquired around 2100 ◦C day. Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry masses
were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of
the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the last
measurements, acquired around 2100 °C day. 3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm
3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm
3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm 3.2. Model Validation—Mass Retrieval The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the last
measurements, acquired around 2100 °C day. Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry
masses were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed
red, green, and black lines, respectively. The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the
last measurements, acquired around 2100 ◦C day. mote Sens. 2019, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW
12 of 22
Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry masses
were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of
the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the last
measurements, acquired around 2100 °C day. Table 5. Values of the field-specific parameters (D0 and ELUE) derived from the validation step. Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry masses
were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of
the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the last
measurements, acquired around 2100 °C day. Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry
masses were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed
red, green, and black lines, respectively. The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the
last measurements, acquired around 2100 ◦C day. Figure 8. Comparisons between simulated and measured masses for the validation field (F1). Dry masses
were divided into total, plant, and ear dry masses (TDM, PDM, and EDM, respectively). Simulations of
the GAI, TDM, PDM, and EDM are represented by a continuous grey line, and dashed red, green, and
black lines, respectively. The falling of leaves just before harvest is clearly visible in the last
measurements, acquired around 2100 °C day. 4.1. Can Corn Phenological Stages Be Accurately Inferred?
4.1. Can Corn Phenological Stages Be Accurately Inferred? Some of the main phenological stages were simulated by the model at different steps. The
phenological stage “four to five leaves” was derived from the estimate of D0, whereas the day of
flowering was determined when the derivative of the function where PRT was equal to zero (Equation
(6)). Ripening was given by Stt, and the day of harvest was defined when the simulated GAI decreased
to reach zero. These stages are very important in crop management, as they trigger nutrient uptake,
e.g., nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium [50], and water consumption for grain production [51,52]. Some of the main phenological stages were simulated by the model at different steps. Th
phenological stage “four to five leaves” was derived from the estimate of D0, whereas the day
flowering was determined when the derivative of the function where PRT was equal to zero (Equatio
(6)). Ripening was given by Stt, and the day of harvest was defined when the simulated GAI decreased
reach zero. These stages are very important in crop management, as they trigger nutrient uptake, e.g
nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium [50], and water consumption for grain production [51,52]. Following these assumptions, the model accurately reproduced the main phenological stages on
average (R2 = 0.98 and RMSE = seven days on average; Figure 10). Nevertheless, the first stage (four to
five leaves) was less accurate because of the difficulty in detecting the emergence of the crop from the
satellite images acquired at a 10- or 20-m spatial resolution. During the first phenological stages, both
the soil and vegetation contributed to the signal, and the small variation in the vegetation masses did
not significantly affect the satellite signal at this spatial resolution (> 20 m). Thus, it is very difficult
to simulate the difference in crop development at the beginning of the growing period. Moreover,
the dates of the phenological stages were estimated from the images taken on the day that the in-situ
measurements were performed. In reality, the phenological stage covers a period of a few days around
the date of observation. This phenomenon, not taken into account by the model, induces some offset
between the day of the observed and simulated phenological stages. Following these assumptions, the model accurately reproduced the main phenological stages o
average (R2 = 0.98 and RMSE = seven days on average; Figure 10). 4.1. Can Corn Phenological Stages Be Accurately Inferred?
4.1. Can Corn Phenological Stages Be Accurately Inferred? Nevertheless, the first stage (four t
five leaves) was less accurate because of the difficulty in detecting the emergence of the crop from th
satellite images acquired at a 10- or 20-m spatial resolution. During the first phenological stages, both th
soil and vegetation contributed to the signal, and the small variation in the vegetation masses did n
significantly affect the satellite signal at this spatial resolution (> 20 m). Thus, it is very difficult
simulate the difference in crop development at the beginning of the growing period. Moreover, the date
of the phenological stages were estimated from the images taken on the day that the in-sit
measurements were performed. In reality, the phenological stage covers a period of a few days aroun
the date of observation. This phenomenon, not taken into account by the model, induces some offs
between the day of the observed and simulated phenological stages. Figure 10. Comparison between the dates of the four simulated and observed phenological stages of corn
(four to five leaves, flowering, ripening, and harvest). Figure 10. Comparison between the dates of the four simulated and observed phenological stages of
corn (four to five leaves, flowering, ripening, and harvest). Figure 10. Comparison between the dates of the four simulated and observed phenological stages of corn
(four to five leaves, flowering, ripening, and harvest). Figure 10. Comparison between the dates of the four simulated and observed phenological stages of
corn (four to five leaves, flowering, ripening, and harvest). Flowering and ripening were closely grouped in time and well detected, as they are mainly dri
y the variety of the crop (taken into account in the model). Flowering and ripening were closely grouped in time and well detected, as they are mainly driven
by the variety of the crop (taken into account in the model). Flowering and ripening were closely grouped in time and well detected, as they are mainly dri
y the variety of the crop (taken into account in the model). Flowering and ripening were closely grouped in time and well detected, as they are mainly driven
y the variety of the crop (taken into account in the model). Finally, the date of harvest was always well reproduced. In the formalism of the model, the date o
harvest was simulated when GAIsim reverted to zero after ripening. 3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm
3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm
3.3. Mapping the Production of Corn over One Working Farm TDM, EDM, and PDM were
provided from the simulation controlled by the SAR and optical satellite data. Figure 9. Map of corn masses simulated at harvest for a working farm. TDM, EDM, and PDM were
provided from the simulation controlled by the SAR and optical satellite data. Figure 9. Map of corn masses simulated at harvest for a working farm. TDM, EDM, and PDM were
provided from the simulation controlled by the SAR and optical satellite data
Figure 9. Map of corn masses simulated at harvest for a working farm. TDM, EDM, and PDM were
provided from the simulation controlled by the SAR and optical satellite data. Figure 9. Map of corn masses simulated at harvest for a working farm. TDM, EDM, and PDM were
provided from the simulation controlled by the SAR and optical satellite data. 12 of 21
13 of 22 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
Remote Sens 2019 11 x FOR 4. Discussion
4. Discussion 4.1. Can Corn Phenological Stages Be Accurately Inferred? 4.1. Can Corn Phenological Stages Be Accurately Inferred? 4.3. What Is the Impact of the SAR Preprocessing Algorithm?
.3. What Is the Impact of the SAR Preprocessing Algorithm? The Sentinel-1 signal preprocessing algorithms differ from one institute to another, namely:
openSarToolkit (FAO [53]), Google Earth Engine [54], S1tilling (available at http://tully.ups-tlse.fr/
koleckt/s1tiling, version of May 2019). The main preprocessing steps involved in this algorithm are
illustrated in Figure 11. p
f
p
g
g
The Sentinel-1 signal preprocessing algorithms differ from one institute to another, namely
penSarToolkit
(FAO
[53]),
Google
Earth
Engine
[54],
S1tilling
(available
at
http://tully.ups-tlse.fr/koleckt/s1tiling, version of May 2019). The main preprocessing steps involved in
his algorithm are illustrated in Figure 11 Figure 11. Main steps involved in the preprocessing radar signal, according to the algorithm used by
FAO (OpenSar toolkit), Google (GEE; Google Earth Engine), and the French national space institute:
CNES (S1-Tiling). Figure 11. Main steps involved in the preprocessing radar signal, according to the algorithm used by
FAO (OpenSar toolkit), Google (GEE; Google Earth Engine), and the French national space institute:
CNES (S1-Tiling). igure 11. Main steps involved in the preprocessing radar signal, according to the algorithm used by
AO (OpenSar toolkit), Google (GEE; Google Earth Engine), and the French national space institute:
NES (S1-Tiling). Figure 11. Main steps involved in the preprocessing radar signal, according to the algorithm used by
FAO (OpenSar toolkit), Google (GEE; Google Earth Engine), and the French national space institute:
CNES (S1-Tiling). All of the algorithms integrate the steps of border noise removal [55], and radiometric and
eometric correction [56]. The two main differences concern the application or not of thermal noise
emoval (TNR) and of the speckle filter [57]. The impacts of these two algorithms in terms o
ackscattering coefficients and biomass estimates are investigated in the two following subsections. All of the algorithms integrate the steps of border noise removal [55], and radiometric and
geometric correction [56]. The two main differences concern the application or not of thermal noise
removal (TNR) and of the speckle filter [57]. The impacts of these two algorithms in terms of
backscattering coefficients and biomass estimates are investigated in the two following subsections. 4.3.1. Impact of the Speckle Filter on the Backscattering Coefficient at the Field Scale Figure 12 compares the σ◦VH/VV (median value) extracted at a field scale along the crop growing
season, over all the popcorn fields, with or without applying a 3 × 3 window adaptive Lee filter. With
respect to the mean, the signals were strongly correlated with the y = x regression line (R2 = 0.99). 4.2. Can Vegetation Mass Be Retrieved Irrespective the Phenologic Stage?
2. Can Vegetation Mass Be Retrieved Irrespective the Phenologic Stage? As illustrated in Figure 7, the biomass can be accurately retrieved up to a couple of days before
harvest. Nevertheless, in some particular cases, the model did not properly simulate the total masses
just before harvest. These differences can be explained by the falling of the leaves of the corn during
this period (phenomenon already observed for soybean in the literature [16]), which is not simulated by
the model. Consequently, simulations strongly overestimated the total masses, particularly ear masses
(Figure 7c), probably inducing an overestimation of the grain yield (not checked in our study because
of the lack of yield data). To overcome this limitation, the falling of leaves should be implemented
in the model by using a temperature function, for example, as this phenomenon cannot be observed
on radar or optical signals [35,37]. This improvement will be useful for other crops whose leaves fall
during certain phenological stages, e.g., grain maize, soybean, and rapeseed. As illustrated in Figure 7, the biomass can be accurately retrieved up to a couple of days before
harvest. Nevertheless, in some particular cases, the model did not properly simulate the total masses jus
before harvest. These differences can be explained by the falling of the leaves of the corn during this
period (phenomenon already observed for soybean in the literature [16]), which is not simulated by the
model. Consequently, simulations strongly overestimated the total masses, particularly ear masses
Figure 7c), probably inducing an overestimation of the grain yield (not checked in our study because o
he lack of yield data). To overcome this limitation, the falling of leaves should be implemented in the
model by using a temperature function, for example, as this phenomenon cannot be observed on radar
or optical signals [35,37]. This improvement will be useful for other crops whose leaves fall during
ertain phenological stages, e.g., grain maize, soybean, and rapeseed. 4.1. Can Corn Phenological Stages Be Accurately Inferred?
4.1. Can Corn Phenological Stages Be Accurately Inferred? The decrease of GAIsim was driven b
a non-linear function governed by the GAI, assimilated during senescence and just after harvest. Th
date of harvest can be thus accurately estimated when the satellite data are numerous enough to contro
Finally, the date of harvest was always well reproduced. In the formalism of the model, the date
of harvest was simulated when GAIsim reverted to zero after ripening. The decrease of GAIsim was
driven by a non-linear function governed by the GAI, assimilated during senescence and just after
harvest. The date of harvest can be thus accurately estimated when the satellite data are numerous
enough to control this non-linear function (this is our case). Nevertheless, the simulated date of harvest
could have been less accurate if the satellite images were missing during this period. Given that the 13 of 21
ave been Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
his non linear function model was only controlled by optical data during this period, the quality of the results was strongly
correlated with cloud cover. To overcome this limitation, the formalism of this process could be revised
by using a threshold for grain humidity, for example, instead of using GAIsim. This threshold, defined
as approximately 32–35%, could be provided by seed-producers for each corn variety. ess accu ate i t e sate ite i
ages we e
issi g du i g t is pe iod. Give
t at t e
ode was o
y
controlled by optical data during this period, the quality of the results was strongly correlated with
cloud cover. To overcome this limitation, the formalism of this process could be revised by using a
hreshold for grain humidity, for example, instead of using GAIsim. This threshold, defined as
approximately 32–35%, could be provided by seed-producers for each corn variety. 4.3. What Is the Impact of the SAR Preprocessing Algorithm?
.3. What Is the Impact of the SAR Preprocessing Algorithm? ontrary to pure pixels, mixels contain multiple constituents within a single pixel (corn, forest, bare soil,
ver etc ) which can blur the value of backscattering coefficients to some extent These two combined effects—median instead of mean, and shape of the field—explain the slight
scattering of the backscattering coefficients (RMSE = 0.18dB) observed in Figure 12. ver, etc.), which can blur the value of backscattering coefficients to some extent. These two combined effects—median instead of mean, and shape of the field—explain the slight
cattering of the backscattering coefficients (RMSE = 0.18dB) observed in Figure 12. Figure 12. Comparison of the backscattering coefficient (σ°VH/VV) extracted at a field scale (between 0 and
1000 °C day), with or without considering a 3 × 3 window adaptive Lee filter. Black and blue crosses
represent the backscattering coefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. Figure 12. Comparison of the backscattering coefficient (σ◦VH/VV) extracted at a field scale (between
0 and 1000 ◦C day), with or without considering a 3 × 3 window adaptive Lee filter. Black and blue
crosses represent the backscattering coefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. igure 12. Comparison of the backscattering coefficient (σ°VH/VV) extracted at a field scale (between 0 and
000 °C day), with or without considering a 3 × 3 window adaptive Lee filter. Black and blue crosses
epresent the backscattering coefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. Figure 12. Comparison of the backscattering coefficient (σ◦VH/VV) extracted at a field scale (between
0 and 1000 ◦C day), with or without considering a 3 × 3 window adaptive Lee filter. Black and blue
crosses represent the backscattering coefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. Figure 13b,d,f presents the effects of the filter on the estimates of EDM, TDM, and PDM compare
the simulation performed using no filtered backscattering coefficients (at the date of the groun
easurements). The relationships estimated between the masses could be considered quite similar fo
DM, TDM, and PDM, except for some points surrounded by red ellipsoids. Figure 13b,d,f presents the effects of the filter on the estimates of EDM, TDM, and PDM compared
to the simulation performed using no filtered backscattering coefficients (at the date of the ground
measurements). The relationships estimated between the masses could be considered quite similar for
EDM, TDM, and PDM, except for some points surrounded by red ellipsoids. 4.3. What Is the Impact of the SAR Preprocessing Algorithm?
.3. What Is the Impact of the SAR Preprocessing Algorithm? This
result confirms that the application of a speckle filter has few impact on the SAR signal values extracted 14 of 21
g
g
ter. With
99) Thi 14 of 21
g
g
ter. With
99) Thi Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
eason, over all the popc at the field scale, as this filter conserves the mean value inside a homogenous area [57]. Nevertheless,
the backscattering ratio is not exactly the same because (1) the median values are displayed in Figure 12
(not the mean values), and (2) some fields have a too much of an elongated shape to apply the adaptive
Lee filter properly. The only assumption of the filter is that the sample mean and variance of a pixel are
equal to its local mean and variance, based on the pixels within a fixed neighborhood surrounding
it [57]. When the studied fields have too much of an elongated shape (in the azimuth or range direction
of the image), the neighborhood around one pixel is composed of a mixed-pixel (defined as a mixel). Contrary to pure pixels, mixels contain multiple constituents within a single pixel (corn, forest, bare
soil, river, etc.), which can blur the value of backscattering coefficients to some extent. esult confirms that the application of a speckle filter has few impact on the SAR signal values extracted
t the field scale, as this filter conserves the mean value inside a homogenous area [57]. Nevertheless, the
ackscattering ratio is not exactly the same because (1) the median values are displayed in Figure 12 (not
he mean values), and (2) some fields have a too much of an elongated shape to apply the adaptive Lee
lter properly. The only assumption of the filter is that the sample mean and variance of a pixel are
qual to its local mean and variance, based on the pixels within a fixed neighborhood surrounding it
57]. When the studied fields have too much of an elongated shape (in the azimuth or range direction of
he image), the neighborhood around one pixel is composed of a mixed-pixel (defined as a mixel). 4.3. What Is the Impact of the SAR Preprocessing Algorithm?
.3. What Is the Impact of the SAR Preprocessing Algorithm? p
p
y
p
These points correspond to the simulations performed in field F4, the more elongated field of the
tudy, namely: 420 m long by 70 m wide on average (Figure 1). This size must be compared with the
ative spatial resolution of the SAR data, which is 20 m (in the range direction) by 22 m (in the azimuth
irection). This means that a maximum of three pixels are pure along the range direction. For this field,
he median backscattering coefficients (σ°VH/VV) were superior when the filter was applied. The
verestimation of σ°VH/VV induced an overestimation of the associated GAISAR and thus justified the
igher simulations of the dry masses, as observed in Figure 13b,d,f. This phenomenon was not as
ronounced on others fields, as they were larger and had a more regular rectangular shape. These points correspond to the simulations performed in field F4, the more elongated field of
the study, namely: 420 m long by 70 m wide on average (Figure 1). This size must be compared with
the native spatial resolution of the SAR data, which is 20 m (in the range direction) by 22 m (in the
azimuth direction). This means that a maximum of three pixels are pure along the range direction. For
this field, the median backscattering coefficients (σ◦VH/VV) were superior when the filter was applied. The overestimation of σ◦VH/VV induced an overestimation of the associated GAISAR and thus justified
the higher simulations of the dry masses, as observed in Figure 13b,d,f. This phenomenon was not as
pronounced on others fields, as they were larger and had a more regular rectangular shape. 4.3.2. Impact of Thermal Noise Removal (TNR) on Backscattering Coefficients and on Mass Retrieval 2. Impact of Thermal Noise Removal (TNR) on Backscattering Coefficients and on Mass Retrieval Figure 14 shows the influence of the thermal noise removal on the backscattering coefficient
acquired at VH polarization, according to the acquisition orbit (30 or 132). The thermal noise comes
from the electronic circuits and is one of the major sources of noise in microwaves. It mainly affects
the signal when the signal to noise ratio (SNR) is low. Given that the cross-polarization signal is
less powerful for corn than the co-polarization [35,37], this phenomenon mainly affects the cross 15 of 21 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 polarization states. In the case of corn, the results of Figure 14 show that this correction can reach 2 dB
in the worst case, when the VH decreases to −24 dB. Conversely, this correction is weak (less than
0.5 dB) when the HV signal becomes greater than −16 dB. emote Sens. 2019, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW
16 of 22 Figure 13. Comparison of simulated EDM (a,b), PDM (c,d), TDM (e,f) with and without considering the
thermal noise removal (left column) or the speckle filter (right column). Figure 13. Comparison of simulated EDM (a,b), PDM (c,d), TDM (e,f) with and without considering
the thermal noise removal (left column) or the speckle filter (right column). gure 13. Comparison of simulated EDM (a,b), PDM (c,d), TDM (e,f) with and without considering the
ermal noise removal (left column) or the speckle filter (right column)
Figure 13. Comparison of simulated EDM (a,b), PDM (c,d), TDM (e,f) with and without considering
the thermal noise removal (left column) or the speckle filter (right column). p
g
.2. Impact of Thermal Noise Removal (TNR) on Backscattering Coefficients and on Mass Retrieval
In VV polarization, there is no significant difference with or without the thermal noise removal, a
the SNR is superior to the one obtained using VH signal (results not shown here). . Impact of Thermal Noise Removal (TNR) on Backscattering Coefficients and on Mass Retrieval
In VV polarization, there is no significant difference with or without the thermal noise removal, a
he SNR is superior to the one obtained using VH signal (results not shown here). Figure 14 shows the influence of the thermal noise removal on the backscattering coefficient
quired at VH polarization, according to the acquisition orbit (30 or 132). The thermal noise comes from
e electronic circuits and is one of the major sources of noise in microwaves. 2. Impact of Thermal Noise Removal (TNR) on Backscattering Coefficients and on Mass Retrieval It mainly affects the signal
hen the signal to noise ratio (SNR) is low. Given that the cross-polarization signal is less powerful for
rn than the co-polarization [35,37], this phenomenon mainly affects the cross polarization states. In the
se of corn, the results of Figure 14 show that this correction can reach 2 dB in the worst case, when the
H decreases to −24 dB. Conversely, this correction is weak (less than 0.5 dB) when the HV signal
comes greater than −16 dB. In VV polarization, there is no significant difference with or without the thermal noise removal, as
e SNR is superior to the one obtained using VH signal (results not shown here). The impact of the thermal noise on mass retrieval (EDM, PDM, and TDM) is illustrated in
Figure 13a,c,e. In this figure, the masses simulated using the GAISAR derived from the backscattering
signal corrected from the thermal noise (x-axes) are presented, versus those simulated without the
thermal noise (y-axes). The results show that the performances for mass retrieval were strongly
degraded when the TNR was not considered (Table 6). The relative errors exceeded 58%, whereas
they were lower than 30% when the radar signal was corrected for thermal noise. Moreover, the
mean coefficients of determination decreased on average from 0.91 to 0.72. This phenomenon can be
explained by the fact that σ◦VH was overestimated when not corrected for thermal noise, especially
when the signal was low, as illustrated in Figure 14. This phenomenon was particularly well marked
during the first phenological stages of the crop, just after sowing, when soil was still bare and dry. The
overestimation of σ◦VH directly impacted the value of D0 because the model wrongly considered that 16 of 21 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 the vegetation started growing early in the season. Consequently, D0 decreased, and the duration of
the crop cycle lengthened until harvest. This led to an overestimation of the simulated masses (EDM,
PDM, and TDM) compared to the ground measurements. emote Sens. 2019, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW
17 of 22 Figure 14. Comparison of backscattering coefficient extracted at a field scale (VH polarization), with or
without considering the thermal noise correction. Black and blue crosses represent the backscattering
oefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. Figure 14. Comparison of backscattering coefficient extracted at a field scale (VH polarization), with or
without considering the thermal noise correction. 2. Impact of Thermal Noise Removal (TNR) on Backscattering Coefficients and on Mass Retrieval Black and blue crosses represent the backscattering
coefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. T bl
6
St ti ti
l
f
f th
i
i
(EDM PDM
d TDM)
ith
ith
t igure 14. Comparison of backscattering coefficient extracted at a field scale (VH polarization), with or
without considering the thermal noise correction. Black and blue crosses represent the backscattering
oefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. Figure 14. Comparison of backscattering coefficient extracted at a field scale (VH polarization), with or
without considering the thermal noise correction. Black and blue crosses represent the backscattering
coefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. oe icie ts acqui ed i
o bit 3 a d 30, especti e y
he impact of the thermal noise on mass retrieval (EDM, PDM, and TDM) is illustrated in Fi
e In this figure, the masses simulated using the GAISAR derived from the backscattering si
coefficients acquired in orbit 132 and 30, respectively. Table 6. Statistical performances of the mass inversion (EDM, PDM, and TDM) with or without
considering the thermal noise removal and speckle filter. TNR—thermal noise removal. he impact of the thermal noise on mass retrieval (EDM, PDM, and TDM) is illustrated in F
. In this figure, the masses simulated using the GAISAR derived from the backscattering s
Table 6. Statistical performances of the mass inversion (EDM, PDM, and TDM) with or without
considering the thermal noise removal and speckle filter. TNR—thermal noise removal. he impact of the thermal noise on mass retrieval (EDM, PDM, and TDM) is illustrated in Fi
. In this figure, the masses simulated using the GAISAR derived from the backscattering si
Table 6. Statistical performances of the mass inversion (EDM, PDM, and TDM) with or without
considering the thermal noise removal and speckle filter. TNR—thermal noise removal. he impact of the thermal noise on mass retrieval (EDM, PDM, and TDM) is illustrated in Fi
. In this figure, the masses simulated using the GAISAR derived from the backscattering si
Table 6. Statistical performances of the mass inversion (EDM, PDM, and TDM) with or without
considering the thermal noise removal and speckle filter. TNR—thermal noise removal. ected from the thermal noise (x-axes) are presented, versus those simulated without the therm
se (y-axes). The results show that the performances for mass retrieval were strongly degraded whe
TNR was not considered (Table 6). 2. Impact of Thermal Noise Removal (TNR) on Backscattering Coefficients and on Mass Retrieval The relative errors exceeded 58%, whereas they were lower tha
% when the radar signal was corrected for thermal noise. Moreover, the mean coefficients
ermination decreased on average from 0.91 to 0.72. This phenomenon can be explained by the fa
σ°VH was overestimated when not corrected for thermal noise, especially when the signal was low
lustrated in Figure 14. This phenomenon was particularly well marked during the first phenologic
ges of the crop, just after sowing, when soil was still bare and dry. The overestimation of σ°VH direct
acted the value of D0 because the model wrongly considered that the vegetation started growin
y in the season. Consequently, D0 decreased, and the duration of the crop cycle lengthened unt
vest. This led to an overestimation of the simulated masses (EDM, PDM, and TDM) compared to th
und measurements. n
R2
a
b
RMSE
rRMSE
with TNR and without speckle filter
EDM
19
0.93
0.87
0.11
1.07
28.70
PDM
19
0.90
0.65
0.16
0.59
15.67
TDM
19
0.92
0.85
0.14
1.77
23.56
with TNR and with speckle filter
EDM
19
0.95
0.96
0.08
0.94
25.32
PDM
19
0.68
0.65
0.92
1.23
32.74
TDM
19
0.95
0.92
1.09
1.46
19.44
without TNR
EDM
19
0.94
1.81
0.57
2.19
58.57
PDM
19
0.36
0.99
3.34
3.72
98.77
TDM
19
0.87
1.65
4.02
4.46
59.40
.4. What Is the Impact of an Intercrop? a
e
i
e
o a
o e e i
a io
o
round measurements.
4.4. What Is the Impact of an Intercrop? round measurements. 4.4. What Is the Impact of an Intercrop? Table 6. Statistical performances of the mass inversion (EDM, PDM, and TDM) with or without
considering the thermal noise removal and speckle filter. TNR—thermal noise removal. n
R²
a
b
RMSE rRMSE
with TNR and without speckle filter
EDM
19
0.93 0.87 0.11
1.07
28.70
PDM
19
0.90 0.65 0.16
0.59
15.67
TDM
19
0.92 0.85 0.14
1.77
23.56
with TNR and with speckle filter
EDM
19
0.95 0.96 0.08
0.94
25.32
PDM
19
0.68 0.65 0.92
1.23
32.74
TDM
19
0.95 0.92 1.09
1.46
19.44
EDM
19
0.94 1.81 0.57
2.19
58.57
Intercrops play a major role in the quality of mass estimates. As illustrated in Figure 15, intercrops
strongly affected the signal σ0
VH/VV at the beginning of the corn cycle (between 0 and 500 ◦C day). In our case, these crops were mainly composed of beans (Vicia faba L.). They were sown at the end of
the year (before October–November) and were mechanically and chemically destroyed in May–June
2016, when corn began vegetative development. To restrain the impact of the SAR signal on the
simulations, only σ0
VH/VV higher than −7.5 dB was assimilated (level defined by the intersection of the
black and green curves in Figure 15 at the bottom). The GAIopt estimated from the optical data was not
affected by the presence of this crop, as it was undergoing senescence (Figure 15, at the top). At this
stage, the color of the crop was close to the bare soil color (yellow, brown), and the BVnet algorithm
(used to invert the GAIopt) considered the reflectance to be the same as that observed for bare soil. Consequently, the algorithm simulated a GAI close to 0. 17 of 21
ently, the Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978
p
GAIopt) considered the r Figure 15. Temporal evolution of the GAIopt (a) and backscattering ratio 𝜎𝑉𝐻/𝑉𝑉
0
(b) according to the
presence of intercrops (beans) inside the corn plot. Figure 15. Temporal evolution of the GAIopt (a) and backscattering ratio σ0
VH/VV (b) according to the
presence of intercrops (beans) inside the corn plot. igure 15. Temporal evolution of the GAIopt (a) and backscattering ratio 𝜎𝑉𝐻/𝑉𝑉
0
(b) according to the
presence of intercrops (beans) inside the corn plot. Figure 15. a
e
i
e
o a
o e e i
a io
o
round measurements.
4.4. What Is the Impact of an Intercrop? Temporal evolution of the GAIopt (a) and backscattering ratio σ0
VH/VV (b) according to the
presence of intercrops (beans) inside the corn plot. Without precaution, the impact of intercrops could affect the empirical function used to estimate
he GAI from the SAR signals (Equation (8)). Figure 16 illustrates the impact of intercrops on the
elationship estimated between GAI and 𝜎𝑉𝐻/𝑉𝑉
0
. With intercrops, 𝜎𝑉𝐻/𝑉𝑉
0
strongly increased (until −5 dB)
whereas the GAI of the corn remained low (less than 0.5 m2.m−2). It is thus very important to remove
parcel with intercrops to estimate this relationship. Without precaution, the impact of intercrops could affect the empirical function used to estimate
the GAI from the SAR signals (Equation (8)). Figure 16 illustrates the impact of intercrops on the
relationship estimated between GAI and σ0
VH/VV. With intercrops, σ0
VH/VV strongly increased (until
−5 dB), whereas the GAI of the corn remained low (less than 0.5 m2·m−2). It is thus very important to
remove a parcel with intercrops to estimate this relationship. Remote Sens. 2019, 11, x FOR PEER REVIEW
19 of 22 Figure 16. Impact of the presence of an intercrop on the empirical relationship estimated between σVH/VV
0
and the GAI of corn. Figure 16. Impact of the presence of an intercrop on the empirical relationship estimated between
σ0
VH/VV and the GAI of corn. Figure 16. Impact of the presence of an intercrop on the empirical relationship estimated between σVH/V
0
and the GAI of corn. Figure 16. Impact of the presence of an intercrop on the empirical relationship estimated between
σ0
VH/VV and the GAI of corn. 5. Conclusions
5. Conclusions The aim of this work was to estimate the temporal evolution of popcorn dry masses (ear, plant, and
total amount) at a field scale using an agro-meteorological model (SAFY-WB) controlled by GAI
derived from optical (GAIopt) and synthetic aperture radar (SAR) (GAIsar) satellite images and total dry
masses (TDM) measured in-situ. The aim of this work was to estimate the temporal evolution of popcorn dry masses (ear, plant,
and total amount) at a field scale using an agro-meteorological model (SAFY-WB) controlled by GAI,
derived from optical (GAIopt) and synthetic aperture radar (SAR) (GAIsar) satellite images and total
dry masses (TDM) measured in-situ. Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 18 of 21 The results show that once calibrated for one field, the total dry masses were accurately simulated
with a daily time step in the range 0 to 20 t·ha−1 (R2 = 0.92; rRMSE = 23%). The simulated TDM must
be nevertheless corrected from the underestimation trend, by applying a scaling factor equal to 1.17
(TDMsim = 0.85.TDMmeas + 0.14) in order to obtain accurate absolute values. Moreover, the use of
the model permitted separating the TDM into ear and plant dry masses (EDM and PDM) with good
performances (R2 > 0.90). The approach also permitted accurate simulation (seven days of offset)
of the following four phenological stages: four to five leaves, flowering, ripening, and harvest. The
Discussion section pointed out some important points to consider for a good estimate of dry masses of
corn during the preprocessing steps. In our study case, it was not wise to apply a speckle filter to the
SAR data (because of the specific shape of some of the fields), whereas it was important to apply the
thermal noise removal in order to obtain an accurate simulation of the dry masses. From an agronomic point of view, the results have shown that new agricultural techniques (with
intercrop management) significantly affects the SAR signal, which becomes unusable for establishing
the relationship with GAI during the first phenological stages of the crop. This phenomenon was not
observed when plots of corn were cultivated traditionally without intercrops. This work could be extended to larger areas governed by heterogeneous climatic conditions. In this case, a dense network of weather stations is required to control the agro-meteorological model
with local climatic measurements (wind, temperature, radiation, etc.). References 1. Béziat, P.; Ceschia, E.; Dedieu, G. Carbon balance of a three crop succession over two cropland sites in South
West France. Agric. For. Meteorol. 2009, 149, 1628–1645. [CrossRef] 1. Béziat, P.; Ceschia, E.; Dedieu, G. Carbon balance of a three crop succession over two cropland sites in South
West France. Agric. For. Meteorol. 2009, 149, 1628–1645. [CrossRef] 2. Ceschia, E.; Beziat, P.; Dejoux, J.; Aubinet, M.; Bernhofer, C.; Bodson, B.; Buchmann, N.; Carrara, A.; Cellier, P.;
Di Tommasi, P.; et al. Management effects on net ecosystem carbon and GHG budgets at European crop sites. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2010, 139, 363–383. [CrossRef] 2. Ceschia, E.; Beziat, P.; Dejoux, J.; Aubinet, M.; Bernhofer, C.; Bodson, B.; Buchmann, N.; Carrara, A.; Cellier, P.;
Di Tommasi, P.; et al. Management effects on net ecosystem carbon and GHG budgets at European crop sites. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2010, 139, 363–383. [CrossRef] 3. Hansen, E.; Djurhuus, J. Nitrate leaching as influenced by soil tillage and catch crop. Soil Tillage Res. 1997, 41,
203–219. [CrossRef] 3. Hansen, E.; Djurhuus, J. Nitrate leaching as influenced by soil tillage and catch crop. Soil Tillage Res. 1997, 41,
203–219. [CrossRef] 4. Ward, P.; Flower, K.; Cordingley, N.; Weeks, C.; Micin, S. Soil water balance with cover crops and conservation
agriculture in a Mediterranean climate. Field Crop. Res. 2012, 132, 33–39. [CrossRef] 5. Bastiaanssen, W.G.; Molden, D.J.; Makin, I.W. Remote sensing for irrigated agriculture: Examples from
research and possible applications. Agric. Water Manag. 2000, 46, 137–155. [CrossRef] 6. Kalluri, S.; Gilruth, P.; Bergman, R. The potential of remote sensing data for decision makers at the state, local
and tribal level: Experiences from NASA’s Synergy program. Environ. Sci. Policy 2003, 6, 487–500. [CrossRef]
S
l
S
S C
d
G
S
l
d G
l
f
l 6. Kalluri, S.; Gilruth, P.; Bergman, R. The potential of remote sensing data for decision makers at the state, local
and tribal level: Experiences from NASA’s Synergy program. Environ. Sci. Policy 2003, 6, 487–500. [CrossRef]
7. Seelan, S.K.; Laguette, S.; Casady, G.M.; Seielstad, G.A. Remote sensing applications for precision agriculture:
A learning community approach. Remote Sens. Environ. 2003, 88, 157–169. [CrossRef] and tribal level: Experiences from NASA s Synergy program. Environ. Sci. Policy 2003, 6, 487–500. [CrossRef]
7. Seelan, S.K.; Laguette, S.; Casady, G.M.; Seielstad, G.A. Remote sensing applications for precision agriculture:
A learning community approach. Remote Sens. Environ. 2003, 88, 157–169. [CrossRef] 8. 5. Conclusions
5. Conclusions Moreover, the limitation in
GAISAR retrieval could be overcome by using a lower frequency signal to control the model, similar to
that offered by ALOS-2 PALSAR sensors (L-band). Author Contributions: F.B.: writing—original draft preparation, methodology, analysis and supervision; M.A.:
software, validation and reference data; F.B. R.F., F.F. and S.C.: writing—review and editing; F.B. and J.-F.B.:
funding acquisition. Funding: This research is part of the PRECIEL project, funded by ACMG, Agralis, Nouvelle-Aquitaine Region,
European Union, and CESBIO, and certified by Agri Sud-Ouest Innovation. Funding: This research is part of the PRECIEL project, funded by ACMG, Agralis, Nouvelle-Aquitaine Region,
European Union, and CESBIO, and certified by Agri Sud-Ouest Innovation. Funding: This research is part of the PRECIEL project, funded by ACMG, Agralis, Nouvelle-Aquitaine Region,
European Union, and CESBIO, and certified by Agri Sud-Ouest Innovation. Acknowledgments: We are very grateful to the farmers involved (the Nataïs society, M. Labedan, the domain of
Villeneuve, M. Darrieux), and to Sylvaine Laburthe for her valuable English proofreading. Acknowledgments: We are very grateful to the farmers involved (the Nataïs society, M. Labedan, the domain of
Villeneuve, M. Darrieux), and to Sylvaine Laburthe for her valuable English proofreading. Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest. Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest. Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest. References Drusch, M.; Del Bello, U.; Carlier, S.; Colin, O.; Fernandez, V.; Gascon, F.; Hoersch, B.; Isola, C.; Laberinti, P.;
Martimort, P.; et al. Sentinel-2: ESA’s Optical High-Resolution Mission for GMES Operational Services. Remote Sens. Environ. 2012, 120, 25–36. [CrossRef] 9. Roy, D.P.; Wulder, M.A.; Loveland, T.R.; Woodcock, C.E.; Allen, R.G.; Anderson, M.C.; Helder, D.; Irons, J.R.;
Johnson, D.M.; Kennedy, R.; et al. Landsat-8: Science and product vision for terrestrial global change research. Remote Sens. Environ. 2014, 145, 154–172. [CrossRef] 19 of 21 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 10. Torres, R.; Snoeij, P.; Geudtner, D.; Bibby, D.; Davidson, M.; Attema, E.; Potin, P.; Rommen, B.; Floury, N.;
Brown, M.; et al. GMES Sentinel-1 mission. Remote Sens. Environ. 2012, 120, 9–24. [CrossRef] 11. Baghdadi, N.; Boyer, N.; Todoroff, P.; El Hajj, M.; Bégué, A. Potential of SAR sensors TerraSAR-X,
ASAR/ENVISAT and PALSAR/ALOS for monitoring sugarcane crops on Reunion Island. Remote Sens. Environ. 2009, 113, 1724–1738. [CrossRef] 12. Fieuzal, R.; Baup, F.; Marais-Sicre, C. Monitoring Wheat and Rapeseed by Using Synchronous Optical and
Radar Satellite Data—From Temporal Signatures to Crop Parameters Estimation. Adv. Remote Sens. 2013, 2,
162–180. [CrossRef] 13. Fieuzal, R.; Baup, F.; Marais-Sicre, C. Sensitivity of TERRASAR-X, RADARSAT-2 and ALOS Satellite Radar
Data to Crop Variables. In Proceedings of the Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium (IGARSS),
Munich, Germany, 22–27 July 2012; pp. 3740–3743. 14. McNairn, H.; Champagne, C.; Shang, J.; Holmstrom, D.; Reichert, G. Integration of optical and Synthetic
Aperture Radar (SAR) imagery for delivering operational annual crop inventories. ISPRS J. Photogramm. Remote Sens. 2009, 64, 434–449. [CrossRef] 15. Betbeder, J.; Fieuzal, R.; Philippets, Y.; Ferro-Famil, L.; Baup, F. Contribution of multitemporal polarimetric
synthetic aperture radar data for monitoring winter wheat and rapeseed crops. J. Appl. Remote Sens. 2016, 10,
026020. [CrossRef] 16. Betbeder, J.; Fieuzal, R.; Baup, F. Assimilation of LAI and Dry Biomass Data from Optical and SAR Images
into an Agro-Meteorological Model to Estimate Soybean Yield. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Appl. Earth Obs. Remote Sens. 2016, 9, 2540–2553. [CrossRef] 17. Zribi, M.; Le Hégarat-Mascle, S.; Ottlé, C.; Kammoun, B.; Guerin, C. Surface soil moisture estimation from
the synergistic use of the (multi-incidence and multi-resolution) active microwave ERS Wind Scatterometer
and SAR data. Remote Sens. Environ. 2003, 86, 30–41. [CrossRef] 18. Battude, M.; Al Bitar, A.; Brut, A.; Tallec, T.; Huc, M.; Cros, J.; Weber, J.-J.; Lhuissier, L.; Simonneaux, V.;
Demarez, V. References Modeling water needs and total irrigation depths of maize crop in the south west of France using
high spatial and temporal resolution satellite imagery. Agric. Water Manag. 2017, 189, 123–136. [CrossRef] 19. Fieuzal, R.; Duchemin, B.; Jarlan, L.; Zribi, M.; Baup, F.; Merlin, O.; Hagolle, O.; Garatuza-Payan, J. Combined
use of optical and radar satellite data for the monitoring of irrigation and soil moisture of wheat crops. Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. 2011, 15, 1117–1129. [CrossRef] y
y
20. Sicre, C.M.; Baup, F.; Fieuzal, R. Determination of the crop row orientations from Formosat-2 multi-temporal
and panchromatic images. ISPRS J. Photogramm. Remote Sens. 2014, 94, 127–142. [CrossRef] 21. Yang, H.; Chen, E.; Li, Z.; Zhao, C.; Yang, G.; Pignatti, S.; Casa, R.; Zhao, L. Wheat lodging monitoring using
polarimetric index from RADARSAT-2 data. Int. J. Appl. Earth Obs. Geoinf. 2015, 34, 157–166. [CrossRef] 22. Haboudane, D. Hyperspectral vegetation indices and novel algorithms for predicting green LAI of crop
canopies: Modeling and validation in the context of precision agriculture. Remote Sens. Environ. 2004, 90,
337–352. [CrossRef] 23. Claverie, M.; Demarez, V.; Duchemin, B.; Hagolle, O.; Ducrot, D.; Marais-Sicre, C.; Dejoux, J.-F.; Huc, M.;
Keravec, P.; Béziat, P.; et al. Maize and sunflower biomass estimation in southwest France using high spatial
and temporal resolution remote sensing data. Remote Sens. Environ. 2012, 124, 844–857. [CrossRef] p
g
24. Fang, H.; Liang, S.; Hoogenboom, G.; Teasdale, J.; Cavigelli, M. Corn-yield estimation through assimilation of
remotely sensed data into the CSM-CERES-Maize model. Int. J. Remote Sens. 2008, 29, 3011–3032. [CrossRef] 25. Liu, J.; Pattey, E.; Miller, J.R.; McNairn, H.; Smith, A.; Hu, B. Estimating crop stresses, aboveground dry
biomass and yield of corn using multi-temporal optical data combined with a radiation use efficiency model. Remote Sens. Environ. 2010, 114, 1167–1177. [CrossRef] 26. Lobell, D.B.; Asner, G.P.; Ortiz-Monasterio, J.; Benning, T.L. Remote sensing of regional crop production in
the Yaqui Valley, Mexico: Estimates and uncertainties. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2003, 94, 205–220. [CrossRef] 26. Lobell, D.B.; Asner, G.P.; Ortiz-Monasterio, J.; Benning, T.L. Remote sensing of regional crop production in
the Yaqui Valley, Mexico: Estimates and uncertainties. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2003, 94, 205–220. [CrossRef]
27. Moulin, S.; Bondeau, A.; Delécolle, R. Combining agricultural crop models and satellite observations: From
field to regional scales. Int. J. Remote Sens. 1998, 19, 1021–1036. [CrossRef] 27. Moulin, S.; Bondeau, A.; Delécolle, R. Combining agricultural crop models and satellite observations: From
field to regional scales. References Int. J. Remote Sens. 1998, 19, 1021–1036. [CrossRef] 28. Maas, S.J. GRAMI: A Crop Growth Model that Can Use Remotely Sensed Information; ARS—U.S. Department of
Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service: Weslaco, TX, USA, 1992; Volume 91, 78p. 29. Hsiao, T.C.; Heng, L.; Steduto, P.; Rojas-Lara, B.; Raes, D.; Fereres, E. AquaCrop—The FAO Crop Model to
Simulate Yield Response to Water: III. Parameterization and Testing for Maize. Agron. J. 2009, 101, 448–459. [CrossRef] [CrossRef] 20 of 21 20 of 21 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 30. Duchemin, B.; Fieuzal, R.; Rivera, M.A.; Ezzahar, J.; Jarlan, L.; Rodriguez, J.C.; Hagolle, O.; Watts, C. Impact
of Sowing Date on Yield and Water Use Efficiency of Wheat Analyzed through Spatial Modeling and
FORMOSAT-2 Images. Remote Sens. 2015, 7, 5951–5979. [CrossRef] 31. Duchemin, B.; Maisongrande, P.; Boulet, G.; Benhadj, I. A simple algorithm for yield estimates: Evaluation
for semi-arid irrigated winter wheat monitored with green leaf area index. Environ. Model. Softw. 2008, 23,
876–892. [CrossRef] 32. Dente, L.; Satalino, G.; Mattia, F.; Rinaldi, M. Assimilation of leaf area index derived from ASAR and MERIS
data into CERES-Wheat model to map wheat yield. Remote Sens. Environ. 2008, 112, 1395–1407. [CrossRef] 32. Dente, L.; Satalino, G.; Mattia, F.; Rinaldi, M. Assimilation of leaf area index derived from ASAR and MERIS
data into CERES-Wheat model to map wheat yield. Remote Sens. Environ. 2008, 112, 1395–1407. [CrossRef]
33. Fieuzal, R.; Baup, F.; Sicre, C.M. Estimation of corn yield using multi-temporal optical and radar satellite data into CERES-Wheat model to map wheat yield. Remote Sens. Environ. 2008, 112, 1395–1407. [CrossRef]
33. Fieuzal, R.; Baup, F.; Sicre, C.M. Estimation of corn yield using multi-temporal optical and radar satellite
data and artificial neural networks. Int. J. Appl. Earth Obs. Geoinf. 2017, 57, 14–23. [CrossRef] 33. Fieuzal, R.; Baup, F.; Sicre, C.M. Estimation of corn yield using multi-temporal optical and radar satellite
data and artificial neural networks. Int. J. Appl. Earth Obs. Geoinf. 2017, 57, 14–23. [CrossRef] 34. Baup, F.; Villa, L.; Fieuzal, R.; Ameline, M. Sensitivity of X-Band (σ0, γ) and Optical (NDVI) Satellite Data to
Corn Biophysical Parameters. Adv. Remote Sens. 2016, 5, 103–117. [CrossRef] 35. Ameline, M.; Fieuzal, R.; Betbeder, J.; Berthoumieu, J.F.; Baup, F. Estimation of Corn Yield by Assimilating
SAR and Optical Time Series into a Simplified Agro-Meteorological Model: From Diagnostic to Forecast. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Appl. Earth Obs. Remote Sens. 2018, 11, 4747–4760. [CrossRef] 36. References Rinaldi, M.; Satalino, G.; Mattia, F.; Balenzano, A.; Perego, A.; Acutis, M.; Ruggieri, S. Assimilation
of COSMO-SkyMed-derived LAI maps into the AQUATER crop growth simulation model. Capitanata
(Southern Italy) case study. Eur. J. Remote Sens. 2013, 46, 891–908. [CrossRef] 37. Veloso, A.; Mermoz, S.; Bouvet, A.; Le Toan, T.; Planells, M.; Dejoux, J.-F.; Ceschia, E. Understanding the
temporal behavior of crops using Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2-like data for agricultural applications. Remote
Sens. Environ. 2017, 199, 415–426. [CrossRef] 38. Monteith, J.L.; Moss, C.J.; Cooke, G.W.; Pirie, N.W.; Bell, G.D.H. Climate and the efficiency of crop production
in Britain. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci. 1977, 281, 277–294. [CrossRef] 39. Maas, S.J. Parameterized Model of Gramineous Crop Growth: I. Leaf Area and Dry Mass Simulation. Agron. J. 1993, 85, 348–353. [CrossRef] 40. Sánchez, B.; Rasmussen, A.; Porter, J.R. Temperatures and the growth and development of maize and rice:
A review. Glob. Chang. Biol. 2014, 20, 408–417. [CrossRef] [PubMed] 41. Battude, M.; Al Bitar, A.; Morin, D.; Cros, J.; Huc, M.; Sicre, C.M.; Le Dantec, V.; Demarez, V. Estimating
maize biomass and yield over large areas using high spatial and temporal resolution Sentinel-2 like remote
sensing data. Remote Sens. Environ. 2016, 184, 668–681. [CrossRef] 42. Fieuzal, R.; Sicre, C.M.; Baup, F. Estimation of Sunflower Yield Using a Simplified Agrometeorological Model
Controlled by Optical and SAR Satellite Data. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Appl. Earth Obs. Remote Sens. 2017, 10,
5412–5422. [CrossRef] 43. Baret, F.; Hagolle, O.; Geiger, B.; Bicheron, P.; Miras, B.; Huc, M.; Berthelot, B.; Niño, F.; Weiss, M.; Samain, O.;
et al. LAI, fAPAR and fCover CYCLOPES global products derived from VEGETATION. Remote Sens. Environ. 2007, 110, 275–286. [CrossRef] 44. Oh, Y. Quantitative retrieval of soil moisture content and surface roughness from multipolarized radar
observations of bare soil surfaces. IEEE Trans. Geosci. Remote Sens. 2004, 42, 596–601. [CrossRef] 45. Gao, S.; Niu, Z.; Huang, N.; Hou, X. Estimating the Leaf Area Index, height and biomass of maize using HJ-1
and RADARSAT-2. Int. J. Appl. Earth Obs. Geoinf. 2013, 24, 1–8. [CrossRef] 46. Macelloni, G.; Paloscia, S.; Pampaloni, P.; Marliani, F.; Gai, M. The relationship between the backscattering
coefficient and the biomass of narrow and broad leaf crops. IEEE Trans. Geosci. Remote Sens. 2001, 39,
873–884. [CrossRef] 47. Pinter, P.J., Jr.; Hatfield, J.L.; Schepers, J.S.; Barnes, E.M.; Moran, M.S.; Daughtry, C.S.T.; Upchurch, D.R. Remote Sensing for Crop Management. Photogramm. Eng. Remote Sens. References 2003, 69, 647–664. [CrossRef] 48. Ban, Y. Orbital effects on ERS-1 SAR temporal backscatter profiles of agricultural crops. Int. J. Remote Sens. 1998, 19, 3465–3470. [CrossRef] 49. Joseph, A.T.; van der Velde, R.; O’Neill, P.E.; Lang, R.; Gish, T. Effects of corn on C- and L-band radar
backscatter: A correction method for soil moisture retrieval. Remote Sens. Environ. 2010, 114, 2417–2430. [CrossRef] 50. O’Keeffe, K. Maize Growth & Development; State of New South Wales through NSW Department of Primary
Industries; NSW Department of Primary Industries: Orange, Australia, 2009; ISBN 978-0-7347-1955-3. 21 of 21 21 of 21 Remote Sens. 2019, 11, 1978 51. Çakir, R. Effect of water stress at different development stages on vegetative and reproductive growth of
corn. Field Crop. Res. 2004, 89, 1–16. [CrossRef] 51. Çakir, R. Effect of water stress at different development stages on vegetative and reproductive growth of
corn. Field Crop. Res. 2004, 89, 1–16. [CrossRef] 52. Denmead, O.T.; Shaw, R.H. The Effects of Soil Moisture Stress at Different Stages of Growth on the
Development and Yield of Corn1. Agron. J. 1960, 52, 272–274. [CrossRef] 53. Vollrath, A.; Lindquist, E.; Jonckheere, I.; Pekkarinen, A. Open Foris SAR Toolkit-Free and Open Source
Command Line Utilities for Automatized SAR Data Pre-Processing. In Proceedings of the Living Planet
Symposium 2016, Prague, Czech Republic, 9–13 May 2016; Volume 740, p. 31, ISBN 978-92-9221-305-3. y
p
g
p
y
p
54. Gorelick, N.; Hancher, M.; Dixon, M.; Ilyushchenko, S.; Thau, D.; Moore, R. Google Earth Engine:
Planetary-scale geospatial analysis for everyone. Remote Sens. Environ. 2017, 202, 18–27. [CrossRef] 55. Miranda, N.; Hajduch, G. Masking “No-Value” Pixels on GRD Products Generated by the Sentinel-1 ESA IPF. Issue 2.1, Reference MPC-0243. 2018, p. 14. Available online: https://sentinel.esa.int/documents/247904/
2142675/Sentinel-1-masking-no-value-pixels-grd-products-note (accessed on 21 August 2019). 55. Miranda, N.; Hajduch, G. Masking “No-Value” Pixels on GRD Products Generated by the Sentinel-1 ESA IPF. Issue 2.1, Reference MPC-0243. 2018, p. 14. Available online: https://sentinel.esa.int/documents/247904/
2142675/Sentinel-1-masking-no-value-pixels-grd-products-note (accessed on 21 August 2019). 56. Miranda, N.; Meadows, P.J. Radiometric Calibration of S-1 Level-1 Products Generated by the S-1 IPF. Technical
Note; Reference ESA-EOPG-CSCOP-TN-0002, Issue 1. 2015. Available online: https://sentinel.esa.int/
documents/247904/685163/S1-Radiometric-Calibration-V1.0.pdf (accessed on 21 August 2019). 56. Miranda, N.; Meadows, P.J. Radiometric Calibration of S-1 Level-1 Products Generated by the S-1 IPF. Technical
Note; Reference ESA-EOPG-CSCOP-TN-0002, Issue 1. 2015. Available online: https://sentinel.esa.int/
documents/247904/685163/S1-Radiometric-Calibration-V1.0.pdf (accessed on 21 August 2019). p
g
57. Lee, J.S. 2.
Denmead, O.T.; Shaw, R.H. The Effects of Soil Moisture Stress at Different Stages of Growth on
Development and Yield of Corn1. Agron. J. 1960, 52, 272–274. [CrossRef] © 2019 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access
article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution
(CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). References Refined filtering of image noise using local statistics. Comput. Graph. Image Process. 1981, 15, 380–389. [CrossRef] 57. Lee, J.S. Refined filtering of image noise using local statistics. Comput. Graph. Image Process. 1981, 15, 380–389. [CrossRef] © 2019 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access
article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution
(CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). © 2019 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access
article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution
(CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
|
https://openalex.org/W2089470281
|
https://periodicos.ufes.br/geografares/article/download/154/80
|
Portuguese
| null |
Ontologia do espaço e movimento de renovação crítica da Geografia: o desafio da diferença ontológica
|
Geografares/Geografares : Revista do Mestrado e do Departamento de Geografia, Centro de Ciências Humanas e Naturais, Universidade Federal do Espirito Santo
| 2,009
|
cc-by
| 9,029
|
I – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E
MOVIMENTO DE RENOVAÇÃO
CRÍTICA DA GEOGRAFIA: SOBRE
A DETERMINAÇÃO SOCIAL DO
SER DO ESPAÇO. O objetivo do presente texto consiste em pro-
blematizar a reflexão ontológica sobre o espa-
ço no bojo do movimento de renovação crítica
que a geografia conheceu, notadamente, a par-
tir da década de 1970. Em recente contribuição dedicada à ontologia
na geografia MARTINS (2007, p. 34), destaca
os autores considerados os principais protago-
nistas da “escassa literatura brasileira dedicada
direta ou explicitamente ao tema”: Armando
Corrêa da Silva, a quem é atribuído pioneiris-
mo em relação ao tema; Milton Santos; Antô-
nio Carlos Robert Moraes; e Ruy Moreira. A
indicação destes autores por Martins sinaliza,
como será evidenciado no que segue, um as-
pecto relevante sobre o tema na geografia: a
relação entre o movimento de renovação crí-
tica do pensamento geográfico e a instauração
de um projeto ontológico de determinação
social do ser do espaço, sob inspiração domi-
nante - ainda que heterodoxa - no horizonte
filosófico marxiano e seu modus operandi em
relação à ontologia. Diante da amplitude do tema, que integra de
modo inequívoco a esfera da determinação
teórica do objeto da geografia cabe, antes de
tudo, delimitar o escopo da abordagem que
se propõe desenvolver. Nesse sentido o texto
destaca dois atributos considerados funda-
mentais, quais sejam: (i) a determinação social
do ser do espaço como perfil predominante da
ontologia do espaço na renovação crítica da
geografia; (ii) a negligência - por parte dos
teóricos da geografia que abordaram o tema
- para com o sentido da diferença ontológica
enquanto atributo fundamental a toda investi-
gação ontológica. Uma observação prévia deve, desde já, ser
trazida à tona. Questionar, no presente texto,
a determinação social do ser do espaço vi-
gente de modo privilegiado na ontologia em
geografia, não significa assumir, de antemão,
uma negação refratária à legitimidade e rigor
próprios deste viés. Tampouco visa depreciar
os avanços substantivos – certamente os mais
relevantes – para o avanço da ontologia na te-
oria geográfica que derivam desta perspectiva. A rigor a reflexão que se propõe desenvolver
no que segue somente é possível desde o hori-
zonte de determinação social do ser do espaço
geográfico e, nesse sentido, é tributária das
contribuições seminais que o conquistaram. ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E MOVIMENTO
DE RENOVAÇÃO CRÍTICA DA GEOGRAFIA:
O DESAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA Luis Carlos Tosta dos Reis
Doutor em Geografia pela UFRJ
Professor no Departamento de Geografia da UFES I – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E
MOVIMENTO DE RENOVAÇÃO
CRÍTICA DA GEOGRAFIA: SOBRE
A DETERMINAÇÃO SOCIAL DO
SER DO ESPAÇO. O vínculo entre a abordagem explícita da on-
tologia do espaço na geografia e o movimento
de renovação crítico/radical é marcante numa
obra que foi considerada, por toda uma gera-
ção, como verdadeiro símbolo da transição
entre os paradigmas teorético-quantitativo e
a renovação crítico-radical. Trata-se da Jus-
tiça Social e a Cidade, de David HARVEY
(1980[1973]), que, no início da década de
1970, chamava à atenção dos geógrafos sobre
a necessidade de se pensar acerca da natureza
do espaço, nos seguintes termos: GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009 • 111 que se considera fundamental para evidenciar
o modo com o qual o pensamento de Marx
irá imprimir, de forma indelével, sua marca
na ontologia do espaço na geografia. Trata-se
da assimilação da “dimensão social” como o
conteúdo quiiditativo que determina tanto o
Ser enquanto tal, como, por extensão, a deter-
minação do ser do espaço. De fato, em geral,
as contribuições que abordam tematicamente
a ontologia do espaço a partir do movimento
de renovação crítica da geografia estabelecem
a equivalência ontológica entre espaço e so-
ciedade, através da qual esta, a sociedade, é
assumida como noção equivalente ao próprio
Ser. Esse enquadramento permite reconhecer
o perfil dominante da reflexão ontológica na
geografia crítica como encerrando, fundamen-
talmente, uma “onto-socio-logia” do espaço
de inspiração marxista. “O argumento é ontológico, procuran-
do resolver a questão: o que é o espa-
ço? (...). O problema da correta concei-
tuação do espaço é resolvido através
da prática humana em relação a ele. Em outras palavras, não há respostas
filosóficas para as questões filosóficas
que surgem sobre a natureza do espa-
ço – as respostas estão na prática hu-
mana. A questão “o que é o espaço?”
é, além disso, substituída pela questão
“o que é isso que as diferentes práticas
humanas criam, fazendo uso de distin-
tas conceituações de espaço? [...]. A
compreensão [...] do tema forma-es-
paço-processo social requer entender
como a atividade humana cria a neces-
sidade de conceitos espaciais específi-
cos, e como a prática social e cotidiana
resolve, com aparente tranqüilidade e
perfeição, os mistérios filosóficos pro-
fundos relativos à natureza do espaço
e às relações entre o processo social e
as formas espaciais” (HARVEY, 1980
[1973], p. 5 grifo nosso). (...) Não se trata, aqui, de cometer a reprodução de
uma idéia generalizada e reducionista, criti-
cada com propriedade por MOREIRA (2000;
2007, p. I – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E
MOVIMENTO DE RENOVAÇÃO
CRÍTICA DA GEOGRAFIA: SOBRE
A DETERMINAÇÃO SOCIAL DO
SER DO ESPAÇO. Mais con-
cretamente especificadas, cada
uma dessas dimensões exis-
tenciais abstratas ganha vida
como um constructo social que
molda a realidade empírica e é
simultaneamente moldado por
ela. Assim a ordem espacial da
existência humana provém da
produção (social) do espaço, da
construção de geografias huma-
nas que refletem e configuram o
ser no mundo. (...). O modo como
esse nexo ontológico de espaço-
tempo-ser
é
conceitualmente
especificado e recebe um senti-
do particular na explicação dos
eventos e ocorrências concretos
é a fonte geradora de todas as te-
orias sociais, sejam elas críticas
ou outras.” (SOJA, 1993, p. 35). A citação acima dá o que pensar sobre o perfil
da reflexão ontológica do espaço na teoria da
geografia. Preliminarmente chama à atenção
que Sebag, o autor citado por Milton San-
tos, refere-se, a rigor, estritamente ao ser em
relação com o tempo, não ao ser em relação
com a sociedade (ou à “realidade social”). A
conexão e equivalência estabelecida entre ser
e sociedade deve ser creditada exclusivamen-
te ao geógrafo - sob o impulso da influência
do horizonte de pensamento de Marx no que
diz respeito à esfera ontológica da teoria. Ou-
tro ponto diz respeito ao recurso à noção de
totalidade, enquanto totalidade social¸ como
meio para conduzir o nexo entre ser e socie-
dade total, como se o Ser possuísse uma qua-
lidade ôntica, ou qualquer alteridade ontica-
mente determinável, tal como, por exemplo, o
somatório dos entes que integram a sociedade
concreta em suas “múltiplas determinações”,
que permitisse à linguagem estabelecer uma
tal comparação do Ser com outro(s) ente(s). Assim, o recurso à noção de totalidade, qua-
lificada, então, a partir do ser social configura
um meio através do qual o Ser converte-se, de
súbito, na teoria geográfica, em equivalente à
sociedade.1 A citação acima pode ser assumida
como síntese da perspectiva usual que a on-
tologia do espaço tem sido, via de regra, pro-
blematizada na geografia, encerrando, nestes
termos, o que se propôs designar sob o rótulo
de “onto-socio-logia” do espaço geográfico. Trata-se da descoberta ontológica seminal da
corrente crítico-radical na geografia, qual seja,
descobre-se que “a sociedade é o seu espa-
ço geográfico e o espaço geográfico é a sua
sociedade” (MOREIRA, 2007, p. 27). I – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E
MOVIMENTO DE RENOVAÇÃO
CRÍTICA DA GEOGRAFIA: SOBRE
A DETERMINAÇÃO SOCIAL DO
SER DO ESPAÇO. 1 No fundo, essa perspectiva de
reflexão ontológica reproduz o
“princípio ontológico” elemen-
tar do marxismo, ou, a rigor, o
tipo de tratamento ontológico
básico ao pensamento de Marx,
que será formalmente indicado
no que segue, qual seja, o “real”,
enquanto pronome do “Ser” en-
quanto tal é “um” ser social, isto
é, a ontologia marxiana é, em
última instância, uma ontologia
do ser social ( LOPARIC, 1990,
p. 100; p. 103; p. 152; LUKÁCS,
1979a). Se a indicação formal da
abordagem marxista (ou marxia-
na) típica da temática ontológica
pode ser enunciada de maneira
tão simples e direta, o mesmo
não ocorre com suas conseqüên-
cias para a elaboração e deter-
minação ontológica dos objetos
no seio de ciências específicas,
como no caso da ontologia do
espaço na geografia. representativa da abordagem levada a termo
por vários teóricos que, em igual medida, esta-
belecem de modo explícito a equivalência en-
tre ser e sociedade como fio condutor da onto-
logia do espaço, de forma tão explícita quanto
revela a citação abaixo: “Tudo, porém, tem início na realidade
social, como escreveu Sebag (1972, p. 62): ‘A primazia do ser vem do fato de
que ele jamais é acabado e essa incon-
clusão se resolve no tempo’. Se saímos
da totalidade social é somente para
tornar a ela. (...). O ser é a sociedade
total, o tempo são os processos, e as
funções, assim como as formas são a
existência”(SANTOS, 1988, p. 27; gri-
fo nosso). Esta perspectiva de elaboração da ontologia
do espaço perpassa toda a contribuição teórica
de Milton Santos, como atesta sua vigência na
última grande obra de teoria geral em geogra-
fia do autor, a saber, A Natureza do Espaço,
na qual, mesmo sob pujante pluralidade epis-
temológica, o geógrafo recorre a Sartre para
determinar o Ser, enquanto tal, a partir da so-
ciedade, nos seguintes termos: “Se o ser é a
existência em potencia, segundo Sartre, e a
existência é o ser em ato, a sociedade seria as-
sim o Ser e o espaço a Existência” ( SANTOS,
1996, p. 96). 2 “Assim como o espaço, o
tempo e a matéria delineiam e
abrangem as qualidades essen-
ciais do mundo físico, a espa-
cialidade, a temporalidade e o
ser social podem ser vistos como
as dimensões abstratas que, em
conjunto, abarcam as facetas da
existência humana. I – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E
MOVIMENTO DE RENOVAÇÃO
CRÍTICA DA GEOGRAFIA: SOBRE
A DETERMINAÇÃO SOCIAL DO
SER DO ESPAÇO. 37), segundo a qual o marxismo en-
cerraria a fundamentação filosófica exclusiva
do movimento de renovação crítica da geogra-
fia. Contudo o que está em foco na presente
reflexão não é a heterotopia epistemológica
que caracterizou este momento de renovação
do pensamento geográfico, nem mesmo o
fundamento ontológico implícito de contri-
buições inspiradas noutras matrizes, como,
por exemplo, a fenomenologia, o existencia-
lismo, o estruturalismo, o pós-estruturalismo,
ou, ainda, a diversidade heterodoxa no seio do
próprio marxismo. O que está em foco, aqui, é
o modo com o qual se efetivou explicitamente
a abordagem temática da ontologia do espaço
na geografia. É sob esse sentido estrito, o úni-
co aqui considerado, que se propõe reconhe-
cer a vigência de uma efetiva onto-socio-logia
do espaço de inspiração predominantemente
“marxista” ou “marxiana”, nos termos que
serão apresentados no que segue – a despei-
to, mesmo, da pluralidade epistemológica dos
autores e obras que problematizaram o ser do
espaço geográfico. “Uma ontologia é uma teoria do que
existe. Dizer, por isso, que alguma coi-
sa tem status ontológico é dizer que
existe. Marx desenvolve em seu traba-
lho certas suposições fundamentais a
respeito do modo pelo qual a realidade
está estruturada e organizada. Ollman
o diz deste modo: ‘os pilares gêmeos
da ontologia de Marx são sua concep-
ção da realidade como uma totalidade
de partes internamente relacionadas e
sua concepção dessas partes como re-
lações abertas, de tal modo que cada
uma em sua plenitude pode represen-
tar a totalidade’ (OLLMAN, 1972 apud
HARVEY, 1980[1973], p. 248 - 249). O questionamento ontológico acerca
do espaço é, assim, formalmente explicitado
por David Harvey, revelando, desde então, a
nítida influência do pensamento marxiano no
que diz respeito à esfera ontológica da teoria
da geografia. Não obstante, o que cabe trazer
à tona é, sobretudo, o elemento substantivo, Nesse sentido pode-se recorrer ao pensamento
de Milton Santos, cuja contribuição ao tema
pode ser considerada, nos seus traços gerais, • GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009
112 “O conteúdo corporificado, o ser já
transformado em existência, é a socie-
dade já embutida nas formas geográ-
ficas, a sociedade transformada em
espaço (...) . A sociedade seria o ser, e
o espaço seria a existência” (SANTOS,
1988, p. 27; grifo nosso). II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. 4 O seu alvo principal [da crítica
marxiana] será a tese comum a
toda filosofia tradicional, de que
as representações, seja as dos
sentidos seja as da razão são
o acesso primário ao ente e ao
ser do ente. No lugar da filosofia
da representação, Marx oferece
uma teoria materialista de aces-
so ao ente e da sociedade, base-
ada no tratamento dialético do
processo de trabalho”. (...)“Por
trabalho, Marx (com Engels)
entende, a ‘atividade sensível
concreta’ da ‘força de trabalho’(
esse é o seu conceito ontológico
básico), que produz (e esse é o
‘primeiro ato histórico’ dos ho-
mens) meios para a satisfação
de necessidades ‘fixas’ da vida
material, em primeiro lugar, a
da fome, ou, como Marx gosta de
dizer, do estômago” (LOPARIC,
1990, p. 97 – 98). (...) Em Marx
o “verdadeiro fundamento, o ser
do ente, como diria Heidegger,
é o trabalho vivo”. (LOPARIC,
1990, p. 100).(...). É bem sabido
que o marxismo nunca conseguiu
produzir uma teoria satisfatória
do conhecimento. A maior difi-
culdade para tanto reside justa-
mente na concepção pragmatista
que Marx faz da generalidade
dos conceitos”.ii O que é isto – a diferença ontológica? O propósito deste tópico é esclarecer tanto o
sentido desta questão quanto a simplicidade
de sua resposta, qual seja: é a diferença irre-
dutível, intransponível, entre Ser e ente. A as-
similação desta diferença representa, sugere-
se, um passo fundamental à radicalização dos
princípios que, em geral, norteiam a ontologia
do espaço na teoria geral da geografia. “Quem tenta resumir teoricamente a
ontologia marxiana, encontra-se dian-
te de uma situação paradoxal. Por um
lado, qualquer leitor sereno de Marx
não pode deixar de notar que todos os
seus enunciados concretos, se inter-
pretados corretamente (isto é, fora dos
preconceitos da moda), são entendidos
– em última instância – como enuncia-
dos diretos sobre um certo tipo de ser,
ou seja, são afirmações ontológicas. Por outro lado, não há nele nenhum
tratamento autônomo de problemas
ontológicos; ele jamais se preocupa
em determinar o lugar desses proble-
mas no pensamento, em defini-los com
relação à gnoseologia, à lógica, etc.,
de modo sistemático ou sistematizan-
te” (LUKÁCS, 1979, p. 11). Antes, contudo, de expor a importân-
cia – incontornável - da diferença ontológica
para o “método” na pesquisa em ontologia é
preciso fazer uma consideração prévia. I – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E
MOVIMENTO DE RENOVAÇÃO
CRÍTICA DA GEOGRAFIA: SOBRE
A DETERMINAÇÃO SOCIAL DO
SER DO ESPAÇO. Essa
perspectiva é, em essência, compartilhada por
teóricos da geografia que, de forma explícita,
problematizaram a ontologia do espaço na ge-
ografia, dentre outros, SOJA (1993[1988])2;
MORAES (1982); SILVA (1982; 1983); MO-
REIRA (2002; 2004; 2007)3. 3 No caso das contribuições de
MORAES (1982) e SILVA (1982;
1983) é marcante a influência
da inspiração da ontologia do
ser social conforme problema-
tizada por LUKÁCS, através da
problemática do metabolismo
homem-meio/homem-espaço(...) Seria oportuno questionar se, dentre as conse-
qüências da predominância da determinação
social do Ser - típica da influência do pen-
samento de Marx – não deve ser creditada a
pálida preocupação na geografia em relação à
especificidade e método próprios da investiga-
ção ontológica, pois, a rigor, o que em geral
prevalece na reflexão ontológica na geografia
é, como foi sucintamente indicado, a assimila-
ção de princípios ontológicos (Ser ≈ Socieda-
de; Sociedade ≈ ser do espaço), eles próprios Em outra passagem a equivalência entre ser e
sociedade é diretamente estabelecida nos se-
guintes termos: GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009 • 113 GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009 • 113 não submetidos a exame. Há, ressalta-se, uma
distinção fundamental que precisa ser dimen-
sionada. Entre, por um lado, a filiação a deter-
minado viés de fundamentação ontológica e,
por outro lado, uma efetiva investigação onto-
lógica, que leve em consideração os métodos e
premissas próprios à ontologia, há – é preciso
enfatizar – uma diferença abissal. O viés que,
assim, acabou por predominar no impulso ini-
cial da reflexão sobre a ontologia do espaço,
à reboque da instauração do movimento de
renovação crítico-radical da geografia, bem
como seus desdobramentos subseqüentes
mais recentes, acaba por reproduzir o tipo de
tratamento dispensado à reflexão ontológica
no seio originário do pensamento do próprio
Marx: fluência do pensamento marxiano, como é o
caso, em geral, do contexto teórico em que se
desenvolve a origem da problematização da
ontologia do espaço na geografia. Dentre es-
sas lacunas destaca-se, como será abordado no
que segue, a dificuldade de assimilar e levar
às últimas conseqüências o significado da di-
ferença ontológica na ontologia do espaço em
geografia. I – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E
MOVIMENTO DE RENOVAÇÃO
CRÍTICA DA GEOGRAFIA: SOBRE
A DETERMINAÇÃO SOCIAL DO
SER DO ESPAÇO. (...) Esta perspectiva fundamen-
ta, em parte, a reflexão onto-
lógica de alguns textos de Ruy
Moreira sobre o tema: “A geo-
graficidade é o modo de expres-
são dessa essência metabólica
– a hominização do homem pelo
homem através do trabalho – em
formas espaciais concretas de
existência, algo que difere nos
diferentes recortes de território
da superfície terrestre. É o ser
em sua totalidade geográfica
concreta. ( MOREIRA, 2004b,
p. 34). • GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009
114 II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. Isto se verifica
em razão da natureza mesma da experiência
de pensamento do Ser, pois, O desafio da diferença ontológica constitui,
a rigor, o desafio que o pensamento de Hei-
degger representa a toda teoria científica mo-
derna, que aspire restituir o sentido da funda-
mentação do ser do ente que constitui o setor
de objetividade do real ao qual dedica suas
pesquisas. A diferença ontológica é, conforme
indicado acima, uma coisa simples: o Ser não
é o ente! Contudo, a exposição formal da idéia
não se confunde, por um lado, com a experiên-
cia de pensamento da diferença ontológica e,
tampouco, com repercussão desta experiência
na elaboração teórica. Há, nesse ínterim, um
longo caminho de pensamento. De acordo com
DUBOIS (2005, p. 86), a diferença ontológica
foi explicitamente nomeada por Heidegger em
1929, no texto “Da essência do fundamento”. Embora não tenha sido denominada, enquanto
tal, em Ser e Tempo (1927), o “sentido”, por
assim dizer, “metodológico” da diferença on-
tológica, vigora, perpassando, toda a obra do
filósofo, sendo exposta, de forma contunden-
te, já desde o primeiro parágrafo de sua obra
magna, nos seguintes termos: O desafio da diferença ontológica constitui,
a rigor, o desafio que o pensamento de Hei-
degger representa a toda teoria científica mo-
derna, que aspire restituir o sentido da funda-
mentação do ser do ente que constitui o setor
de objetividade do real ao qual dedica suas
pesquisas. A diferença ontológica é, conforme
indicado acima, uma coisa simples: o Ser não
é o ente! Contudo, a exposição formal da idéia
não se confunde, por um lado, com a experiên-
cia de pensamento da diferença ontológica e,
tampouco, com repercussão desta experiência
na elaboração teórica. Há, nesse ínterim, um
longo caminho de pensamento. De acordo com
DUBOIS (2005, p. 86), a diferença ontológica
foi explicitamente nomeada por Heidegger em
1929, no texto “Da essência do fundamento”. Embora não tenha sido denominada, enquanto
tal, em Ser e Tempo (1927), o “sentido”, por
assim dizer, “metodológico” da diferença on-
tológica, vigora, perpassando, toda a obra do
filósofo, sendo exposta, de forma contunden-
te, já desde o primeiro parágrafo de sua obra
magna, nos seguintes termos: “O Ser é categorialmente diferente
dos tipos de entidades com as quais
interagimos na vida quotidiana, (...),
questões ontológicas são questões
sobre o Ser enquanto tal, não podem
ser abordadas da mesma maneira que
questões ônticas, questões sobre enti-
dades particulares. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. Trata-
se, aqui, de indicar a relação inextrincável en-
tre a “proposição” da diferença ontológica e o
pensamento de Martin Heidegger. A este res-
peito cabe citar a passagem de uma contribui-
ção recente que ressalta a importância da dife-
rença ontológica como o legado fundamental
do pensador: “A conquista do pensamento da dife-
rença ontológica será, para sempre, o
legado de Martim Heidegger. Podemos
esquecer ou propositalmente enterrar
o resto de sua obra, mas já não será
possível esquecer que Ser e ente são
diferentes, dramaticamente diferentes,
ontologicamente diferentes. De qual-
quer sorte, não somos os primeiros,
nem os únicos, em fazer este reconhe-
cimento, o próprio Deleuze assim o
faz notar em uma nota antológica de
DR [Diferença e Repetição]” (CRAIA,
2003, p. 80; grifo nosso). (...) a ‘atividade filosófica’ não
ocupa, em Marx, nenhum lugar
essencial. Para ele, a filosofia
deve ser superada realizando-se,
na prática, a identidade entre o
pensar e o ser. Isso se fará por
um só caminho para o qual não
há alternativas: via dissolução
revolucionária de todas as clas-
ses particulares pelo proletaria-
do, classe universal (LOPARIC,
1990, p. 104 -105) De modo semelhante, Loparic fez
observar que, não obstante se reconheça Marx
como pensador de primeira linha, que legou
contribuições decisivas que combinam a análi-
se histórica e conceitual de maneira genial, sua
rejeição à representação abstrata, como ele-
mento próprio da filosofia tradicional, trouxe,
também, repercussões quanto à assimilação de
determinadas esferas de seu pensamento, den-
tre elas, a esfera ontológica4. É a partir deste
quadro que, sugere-se, irão emergir lacunas no
modo de elaboração da ontologia nos campos
da pesquisa científica em que predomina a in- • GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009
114 ontologia do espaço na geografia, nas quais de
forma tão acintosa se consuma a assimilação
da sociedade – um ente, sem dúvida! – en-
quanto conteúdo quiiditativo com o qual se
efetiva a determinação do ser do espaço – um
outro ente, sem dúvida! -, bem como do pró-
prio Ser – o absolutamente outro em relação
ao ente? Na geografia se dá, entretanto, um
impulso de determinação ôntica ao Ser que
impregna, antecipadamente, todo comporta-
mento reflexivo (o questionamento teórico
incluso) referido ao Ser, seja ele elaborado na
esfera pré-científica da vida cotidiana ou na
esfera da pesquisa científica. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. filosófico na compreensão do problema
do ser consiste em: não determinar a
proveniência do ente como um ente,
reconduzindo-o a um outro ente, como
se o ser tivesse o caráter de um ente
possível. (HEIDEGGER, 1999, p. 32). No caso da geografia, o problema a ser tra-
balhado não é propriamente a ausência de
reflexão ontológica, mas, prioritariamente, o
caráter contumaz da vertente dominante, ins-
pirada na “onto-socio-logia” marxista que, por
seu predomínio quase exclusivo, acaba por se
auto-instituir e, dessa forma, restringe, quando
não oblitera, a possibilidade de radicalizar a
fundamentação ontológica estabelecida. Contudo, deve ser observado que o estado da
arte acerca da ontologia do espaço prevalente
na geografia não deve ser apreendido como
uma limitação (ou deficiência) exclusiva à es-
fera da teoria geral dessa ciência, mas, antes,
manifesta uma dificuldade inerente à proble-
matização ontológica em geral – o que inclui,
necessariamente, a problematização ontológi-
ca que se desenvolve no seio da(s) ciência(s)
moderna(s). Heidegger indicou, de maneira
cabal, essa lacuna ao asseverar que “sem dúvi-
da, até hoje, em toda ontologia, o ‘Ser’ é pres-
suposto, mas não como conceito disponível,
não como o que é procurado’ (HEIDEGGER,
1999, p. 33-34). Contudo, deve ser observado que o estado da
arte acerca da ontologia do espaço prevalente
na geografia não deve ser apreendido como
uma limitação (ou deficiência) exclusiva à es-
fera da teoria geral dessa ciência, mas, antes,
manifesta uma dificuldade inerente à proble-
matização ontológica em geral – o que inclui,
necessariamente, a problematização ontológi-
ca que se desenvolve no seio da(s) ciência(s)
moderna(s). Heidegger indicou, de maneira
cabal, essa lacuna ao asseverar que “sem dúvi-
da, até hoje, em toda ontologia, o ‘Ser’ é pres-
suposto, mas não como conceito disponível,
não como o que é procurado’ (HEIDEGGER,
1999, p. 33-34). Note-se, entretanto, que não se está cometen-
do o acinte de colocar em xeque, aqui, a legi-
timidade da tese segundo a qual a sociedade
seja constitutiva do ser do espaço geográfico
e, nesse sentido, encerre uma dimensão indis-
pensável – ainda que a mais indispensável - ao
seu entendimento. Uma coisa é reconhecer o
caráter constitutivo da sociedade em relação
ao ser do espaço – e vice-versa; outra, con-
tudo, radicalmente distinta, ou melhor, onto-
logicamente distinta, é determinar o Ser e o
ser do espaço, a partir da sociedade. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. “De fato, o “ser” não pode ser conce-
bido como ente; enti non additur ali-
qua natura: o “ser” não pode ser de-
terminado, acrescentando-lhe um ente. Não se pode derivar o ser no sentido
de uma definição a partir de concei-
tos superiores nem explicá-lo através
de conceitos inferiores. Mas será que
com isso se pode concluir que o “ser”
não oferece mais nenhum problema? De forma alguma. Daí pode-se apenas
concluir que o “ser” não é um ente. Por isso, o modo de determinação do
ente, legítimo dentro de certos limites –
como a definição da lógica tradicional
que tem seus fundamentos na antiga
ontologia – não pode ser aplicado ao
ser” (HEIDEGGER, 1999[1927], p. 29). “... estaremos constantemente tentados
a tratar o questionamento ontológico
como se fosse uma questão ôntica, ou
seja, como se dissessem respeito a uma
entidade entre outras, e pudessem ser
suficientemente explicadas reportan-
do-a a alguma outra entidade possí-
vel, como se o Ser tivesse o caráter de
um ente entre os outros entes”. (RÉE,
1999, p. 12). Do exposto, se observado desde uma pers-
pectiva que contemple o sentido da diferença
ontológica, a forma que o debate ontológico
assumiu na geografia – via de regra exterior
ao sentido da diferença ontológica – desconsi-
dera um pressuposto de base, apontado como
verdadeiro pré-requisito sem o qual toda e
qualquer investigação teórica de cunho onto-
lógico fica, de antemão, “atravessada”, qual
seja, o ser dos entes, seja qual for o ente, não
“é”, não pode ser, um outro ente. A este respei-
to o filósofo é categórico: Nisso resume-se a relevância da noção de di-
ferença ontológica: reconhecer que Ser não
“é” um ente, nem pode ser determinado segun-
do o modo de determinação que é usualmente
imputado aos entes. O que dizer, a partir do ao
exposto, das inúmeras formulações acerca da Ontologia do espaço e
movimento de renovação crítica
da geografia: O desafio da
diferença ontológoca “O ser dos entes não “é” em si mes-
mo um outro ente. O primeiro passo GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009 • 115 mesmo: de uma fundação filosófica. Como concebê-la? (DUBOIS, 2005, p. 123 – 124). filosófico na compreensão do problema
do ser consiste em: não determinar a
proveniência do ente como um ente,
reconduzindo-o a um outro ente, como
se o ser tivesse o caráter de um ente
possível. (HEIDEGGER, 1999, p. 32). II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. Mas isto já é
tarefa da ontologia, mais propriamen-
te das ontologias regionais, que devem
proceder ao levantamento das estrutu-
ras fundamentais do ser dos entes estu-
dados pela ciência e, com base nelas, à
formação dos conceitos primários cor-
respondentes, que determinam o senti-
do essencial dos respectivos domínios
científicos. A investigação ontológica
é como que o nível de direito, em que
deve entroncar a investigação empíri-
ca”. (BLANC, 1998, p. 19). torial), porquanto focaliza sua reflexão onto-
lógica sobre o ser de um ente (“objeto”) parti-
cular, o espaço geográfico. A distinção acima
indicada não pode amparar o perfil dominante
que a ontologia assumiu na geografia porque,
a rigor, a necessidade de considerar a dife-
rença ontológica, enquanto especificidade da
abordagem temática do Ser, está implicada no
próprio modo de questionamento ontológico –
isto é, no procedimento de investigação onto-
lógico – seja qual for o escopo da investigação
ontológica, isto é, seja referida ao Ser, enquan-
to tal, ou ao ser de um ente em particular. Além disso, cabe frisar que a assimilação da
diferença entre Ser e ente corresponde a uma
demanda intrínseca à tarefa de fundamentação
ontológica no âmbito de toda ciência moder-
na. Trata-se, mesmo, de uma exigência ao
pensamento teórico em qualquer disciplina,
seja essa exigência abafada ou não. É preci-
so, pois, redimensionar a importância de se
desenvolver a problemática ontológica como
um atributo fundamental à pesquisa científica. Essa demanda integra, a propósito, a própria
constituição da ciência, como é evidenciado
na passagem abaixo: Com base no exposto a tarefa da ontologia
do espaço na geografia, enquanto ontologia
“regional” seria, formalmente, desde a assi-
milação do sentido da diferença ontológica
proceder ao levantamento das estruturas fun-
damentais do ser do espaço. Esse projeto de
auto-fundação que, no plano formal, poderia
ser levado a cabo possui, entretanto, de acor-
do com o próprio caminho do pensamento de
Heidegger, uma questão prévia a ser resolvida,
que condiciona o rigor de todo seu desenvolvi-
mento posterior, qual seja, a questão do senti-
do do Ser. Isso se dá em caráter irremediável,
pois, “Toda ciência parte de conceitos fun-
damentais, que articulam a compre-
ensão prévia da região ôntica, sobre
a qual vai incidir a sua investigação
empírica. Ora, na experiência pré-
científica está já presente uma com-
preensão dos domínios do ser e das
diversas regiões, em que eles se sub-
dividem. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. Tampou-
co a “deliberação” de se conceber a geografia
como ciência social que, enquanto tal, lança
mão de uma teoria social como método de in-
terpretação, exime a tarefa de levar em conta a
necessidade de fundamentação ontológica de
acordo com os parâmetros considerados nes-
te tópico. Conceber uma disciplina científica
enquanto tributária de uma teoria social ou na-
tural, etc..., constitui um procedimento que se
efetiva em nível estritamente gnosiológico e,
desse modo, permanece destituído de estatuto
e legitimidade ontológicos. Só uma investiga-
ção de cunho ontológico pode fornecer uma
autêntica fundamentação ontológica. Como foi indicado no tópico precedente, pre-
valece, no bojo da problematização do ser do
espaço na geografia o seguinte malabarismo
ontológico: a sociedade (a dimensão social)
foi (e continua a ser) “colocada” ou, mais
propriamente, pressuposta enquanto noção
equivalente ao próprio Ser e, assim, o ser do
espaço também é ontologicamente determi-
nado a partir da sociedade (dimensão social). Ora, a sociedade é um ente e, enquanto tal,
não pode ser “empregada” para determinar o
Ser de outro ente tal como, no caso, o espaço,
nem, tampouco, o Ser mesmo, enquanto tal. Contudo, este “malabarismo ontológico” não
deve ser considerado como uma limitação ou
“deficiência” de ordem metodológica pontual
à geografia, pois, Não caberia também, aqui, a fim de salvaguar-
dar ou legitimar a propriedade da reflexão on-
tológica dominante na geografia (ser ≈ socie-
dade), aludir à diferença de escopo, ou, mais
apropriadamente, de âmbitos diferenciados de
pensamento - entre, por um lado, a filosofia,
como ontologia “geral” que tematiza o “Ser”;
e, por outro lado, a teoria geral da geografia
como ontologia “regional” (no sentido de se- “Não se trata de um problema de com-
petência ou procedência, mas sim de
tematizar o que o cientista, orientado
por sua preocupação positiva, a maior
parte do tempo só entrevê: o ser de seu
objeto. A auto-fundação da ciência
tem necessidade de uma clarificação,
de um alargamento, de uma conside-
ração que tome o fundamento por si • GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009
116 conhecimento por ela fornecido, então
a garantia do seu real progresso só
pode ser obtida através da elucidação
e conseqüente legitimação dos seus
conceitos fundamentais. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. Trata-se, não obstante, de reconhecer que, se
o Ser é inacessível a toda ontologia que se de-
senvolva sob o modo de determinação concei-
tual típica da lógica tradicional, o que inclui a
determinação do(s) ente(s) enquanto objeto(s)
da(s) ciência(s) moderna(s), está destruída,
por extensão, a legitimidade de se desenvol-
ver ontologias regionais no seio mesmo das
ciências particulares. Por essa razão, também,
a determinação social do ser do espaço e do
Ser, enquanto tal, levada a termo no âmbi-
to da teoria geral da geografia, não deve ser
considerado como um problema restrito a uma
disciplina particular. A limitação da reflexão
ontológica que perpassa o seio das ciências
modernas corresponde a um fenômeno muito
mais amplo, que envolve - em última instân-
cia - um problema de âmbito civilizatório, a
saber: o modo dominante de representação
do real que sustentou a realização histórico-
ontológica da civilização ocidental européia. Heidegger designa tal fenômeno como Meta-
física – entendida, evidentemente, não como
uma disciplina da filosofia, mas como o pro-
cesso realização histórica do esquecimento
do Ser em favor do ente, esquecimento este
que perpassa e sustenta, num processo histó-
rico milenar, a realização do mundo ocidental. Sua origem remete à eclosão do pensamento
filosófico que originou o “mundo grego”. A
ciência moderna bem como a técnica moderna
são decorrências históricas fundamentais da Nesse sentido o “esquecimento” do Ser e, por
conseguinte, do sentido da diferença ontoló-
gica no âmbito da fundamentação teórica das
ciências modernas não configura uma “lacu-
na” ocasional. A rigor a ciência moderna é, em
seu estado “normal”, o lócus por excelência de
realização da metafísica, no sentido do proces-
so histórico-civilizatório acima indicado e, en-
quanto tal constitui a matriz de elaboração do
esquecimento do Ser, uma fonte de represen-
tação do real que promove este esquecimento. Ora, a diferença ontológica não pode ser assi-
milada sem o contra-ponto entre ser e ente! Daí
a dificuldade de se desenvolver, no seio das
ciências modernas, uma abordagem ontológi-
ca cuja radicalidade contemple de modo sufi-
ciente o sentido do ser dos entes que integram
a diversidade dos objetos da pesquisa cientí-
fica a partir da diferença ontológica. A deter-
minação onto-sócio-lógica do espaço na teoria
geográfica, considerada na primeira parte do
texto, é, em grande parte, conseqüência deste
enquadramento da ciência moderna em rela-
ção à proveniência historial do esquecimento
do Ser. [5] Consulte-se a esse respeito,
dentre tantas obras de Heideg-
ger, Introdução à Metafísica. Rio
de Janeiro: Editora Tempo Bra-
sileiro, 1969. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. É desta compreensão já vei-
culada pela atitude pré-científica, que
a investigação científica extrai os seus
conceitos fundamentais (por exem-
plo: mundo, natureza, espaço, tempo,
etc...), adaptando-os, a fim de servirem
de guia para uma exploração objetiva
das diversas regiões ônticas. Significa
isto que os conceitos fundamentais da
ciência não possuem uma evidência
intrínseca, visto que foram obtidos de
uma compreensão do ente dado, que
ela mesma não foi objeto de elucida-
ção. Ora, se dos conceitos primários
de uma ciência depende o alcance do “Por mais rico e estruturado que possa
ser o seu sistema de categorias, toda
ontologia permanece, no fundo, cega
e uma distorção de seu propósito mais
autêntico se, previamente, não houver
esclarecido, de maneira suficiente, o
sentido do ser, nem tiver compreen-
dido esse esclarecimento como sua
tarefa fundamental” (HEIDEGGER,
1999[1927] , p. 36; grifo nosso). Assim, toda ciência que tematiza seu
“objeto” na constituição de seu ser, deve ser
precedida por um esclarecimento prévio acer-
ca do sentido do Ser. A tematização do Ser
do espaço na ontologia em geografia deveria,
assim, como em toda ontologia regional, ser
precedida por um esclarecimento prévio acer- Ontologia do espaço e
movimento de renovação crítica
da geografia: O desafio da
diferença ontológoca GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009 • 117 ca do sentido do Ser. esquecimento metafísico do Ser que se con-
solida a transformação do homem em sujeito
e do mundo em objeto, necessária a constitui-
ção do mundo e do conhecimento científico
modernos. O cogito ergo sum do pensamento
cartesiano representa a fundação filosófica ori-
ginária da modernidade e, por extensão, a ins-
tauração da relação sujeito-objeto como con-
dição privilegiada – senão unívoca - através
da qual o conhecimento científico irá dispor
(colocar) o real como função da subjetividade
moderna (DUBOIS, 2005, p. 134-135). Entrementes, a tarefa fornecer subsídios à fun-
damentação das ciências na constituição das
ontologias regionais, visada por Heidegger em
Ser e Tempo, foi, ulteriormente, abandonada
pelo próprio filósofo, a reboque do célebre
“aborto” desta obra. Este abandono reflete,
pontualmente, a constatação da impossibilida-
de de acesso lógico-categorial ao Ser e, por-
tanto, de sua problematização sob a arquite-
tura proposta em Ser e Tempo. Isso, contudo,
não significa que a questão do Ser, bem como
as questões levantadas em Ser e Tempo acer-
ca da fundamentação das ciências modernas,
tenham perdido a relevância ou tenham sido,
enquanto questões, preteridas pelo filósofo. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. Dessa forma, no caso da geografia, a
determinação social do ser do espaço repre-
senta uma limitação à ontologia na geografia,
antes do mais, por fornecer uma abordagem (e
resolução) ôntica(s) a um questionamento on-
tológico, a saber: “o que é o espaço?” Isso já
é uma decorrência da ontologia do espaço na
geografia não contemplar o sentido da diferen-
ça ontológica e, assim, permanecer ao modo
do esquecimento do Ser. O sentido do Ser per-
manece inacessível à ontologia do espaço na
geografia. Impera, por conseguinte, no âmbito
da ontologia em geografia, uma concepção de
espaço (homem, natureza, enfim, de todos os • GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009
18 118 gura dela mesma senão na certeza do
sujeito da representação, pensando-se
ele mesmo e assim colocando-se como
fundamento de toda objetividade. Ser
quer dizer: subjetividade. (...). Ser só
é aqui na forma unilateral da repre-
sentação, que estende seu reino até o
seio do ente, ao mesmo tempo em que
o ‘homem’, sob a figura do sujeito da
representação, coloca-se no centro
do ente. Isso a que remete, portanto,
a ciência moderna, é a determinação
do sentido do ser como subjetividade
representante, todo ente só adquirindo
sua constância objetiva a partir do re-
presentar próprio ao sujeito (Descar-
tes). (DUBOIS, 2005, p. 134-135). entes investigados por essa disciplina) típica
da Metafísica. Sobre o assunto na geografia
ver MOREIRA (1998, p. 341). O cogito ergo sum do pensamento cartesiano
representa a fundação filosófica originária da
modernidade e, por extensão, a instauração
da relação sujeito-objeto como condição pri-
vilegiada – senão unívoca - através da qual o
conhecimento científico irá dispor (colocar) o
real como função da subjetividade moderna. Na reflexão “onto-socio-lógica” do espaço da
geografia se dá, de forma explícita, a exaspe-
ração metafísica do projeto ontológico car-
tesiano típico da ciência moderna em geral,
que condiciona a equivalência entre verdade
e subjetividade moderna, obstáculo que a dia-
lética marxista não pode superar, porquanto
fundamentalmente tributária da concepção de
homem enquanto sujeito da história. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. Há que se
ter em conta, nesse sentido, que a Assim, sob o cânon do conhecimento científi-
co moderno estabelecido sob a relação sujeito
x objeto enquanto condição de possibilidade
de sua efetivação, o Ser dos próprios entes -
convertidos em objetos da pesquisa científica
– torna-se inacessível às ciências modernas na
exata medida em que ele é inacessível ao mo-
delo de representação lógico-conceitual, do
qual as ciências modernas são, em sua essên-
cia, tributárias. De acordo com o autor supra-
citado, o Ser dos entes se tornou incontornável
e inacessível às ciências, “ (...) verdade própria à pesquisa cien-
tífica [moderna] é a certeza; a pesqui-
sa visa se assegurar de seu objeto; tem
em mira a certeza quanto ao objeto. [...]. O quê pode ser o fundamento de
tal projeto de objetividade? Manifesta-
damente, nada além do que o próprio
projeto tal qual se dá a representar o
ente como objeto, isto é, o próprio su-
jeito dessa representação, co-posto no
fundamento de toda posição de obje-
to, assegurando-se ele mesmo em sua
própria certeza. Esse sujeito insigne,
a partir do qual o ente em totalidade
toma forma de objeto, é o próprio ho-
mem como sujeito da representação,
levado a se assegurar de si mesmo e de
seu mundo – de objetos. Representar
significa: colocar diante de si o ente
de tal modo que ele não seja senão
desse modo, reunido na totalidade de
sua constância calculável, a partir de
um sujeito que está no fundamento da
representação como certeza de si, co-
posto ao fundamento de toda represen-
tação. [...]. Ser significa [ no âmbito
das ciências modernas]: condição de
possibilidade de objeto. Mas, por sua
vez, essa condição não se auto-asse- GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009 • 119
Ontologia do espaço e
movimento de renovação crítica
da geografia: O desafio da
diferença ontológoca
“...não porque elas não seriam tribu-
tárias de uma fundação ontológica de
seus objetos, mas justamente porque
elas se mantêm no circulo auto-insti-
tuinte e auto-assegurador da objetivi-
dade, como única possibilidade de ma-
nifestação do ente. (...) A objetividade
é somente um modo de presença (de
ser), historicamente determinado, do
ente. Compreender isto é já se manter
num regime outro do pensamento, para
o qual a dominação unilateral dessa
figura do ser torna-se uma questão. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. Uma questão, e não o motivo de uma
recusa, como se a figura risível de um
pensamento que se colocasse ‘contra a
ciência’ pudesse ter o mínimo de senti-
do. Mas então, trata-se de preservar, e
de exercer, um pensamento outro que
não o pensamento calculante-objeti- “...não porque elas não seriam tribu-
tárias de uma fundação ontológica de
seus objetos, mas justamente porque
elas se mantêm no circulo auto-insti-
tuinte e auto-assegurador da objetivi-
dade, como única possibilidade de ma-
nifestação do ente. (...) A objetividade
é somente um modo de presença (de
ser), historicamente determinado, do
ente. Compreender isto é já se manter
num regime outro do pensamento, para
o qual a dominação unilateral dessa
figura do ser torna-se uma questão. Uma questão, e não o motivo de uma
recusa, como se a figura risível de um
pensamento que se colocasse ‘contra a
ciência’ pudesse ter o mínimo de senti-
do. Mas então, trata-se de preservar, e
de exercer, um pensamento outro que
não o pensamento calculante-objeti- Ontologia do espaço e
movimento de renovação crítica
da geografia: O desafio da
diferença ontológoca GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009 • 119 vante, precisamente aquele que Heide-
gger denomina de pensamento medi-
tante (DUBOIS, 2005, p. 136). vante, precisamente aquele que Heide-
gger denomina de pensamento medi-
tante (DUBOIS, 2005, p. 136). Para corresponder a este apelo torna-se neces-
sário ao pensamento teórico de cunho ontoló-
gico desenvolver uma perspectiva de proble-
matização do Ser alternativa à representação
lógica, o que não significa, note-se, orientar-
se no sentido do “ilógico”, mas redefinir a
própria tarefa do pensamento ontológico. De
acordo com DUBOIS (2005, p. 121) importa,
sobretudo, problematizar a inquestionabilida-
de da objetividade como condição unívoca do
conhecimento científico moderno se efetivar. No bojo desta tarefa de pensamento “as ciên-
cias são retomadas a partir da história do ser,
essencialmente na figura de sua instauração
moderna”, redimensionando a questão do Ser,
reconduzindo-a a sua proveniência historial
originária, o que irá trazer à tona a questão ter-
minal do pensamento de Heidegger, qual seja,
a questão pela essência da técnica (DUBOIS,
2005, p. 135). Para corresponder a este apelo torna-se neces-
sário ao pensamento teórico de cunho ontoló-
gico desenvolver uma perspectiva de proble-
matização do Ser alternativa à representação
lógica, o que implica redefinir a própria tare-
fa do pensamento. De acordo com DUBOIS
(2005, p. II – ONTOLOGIA DO ESPAÇO E O DE-
SAFIO DA DIFERENÇA ONTOLÓGICA
NA GEOGRAFIA. 121) tem-se em foco a virada a partir
da qual o pensamento de Heidegger torna-se,
fundamentalmente, uma “meditação históri-
ca” que problematiza a inquestionabilidade da
objetividade como condição unívoca do co-
nhecimento científico moderno se efetivar. No
bojo desta meditação “as ciências são retoma-
das a partir da história do ser, essencialmente
na figura de sua instauração moderna”, redi-
mensionando a questão do Ser, reconduzindo-
a a sua proveniência historial originária, o que
irá trazer à tona a questão terminal do pensa-
mento de Heidegger, qual seja, a questão pela
essência da técnica. Nesses termos, III – CONSIDERAÇÕES FINAIS O presente texto trouxe à tona o tema da onto-
logia do espaço na geografia e propôs proble-
matizá-lo, basicamente, no contexto do movi-
mento de renovação crítica da geografia. “... a tarefa do pensamento não é mais
de fundação, ele deve tentar questionar
essa estranha inquestionabilidade. Ele
não pode fazê-lo, no que o concerne,
senão ao lado das ciências, e sem ja-
mais pretender dominá-las”(...) A partir da explicitação da determinação social
do espaço como modo privilegiado de funda-
mentação ontológica do espaço no bojo da re-
novação crítica da geografia, foi sublinhando
a principal lacuna que, sugere-se, carece ser
problematizada de acordo com a radicalidade
que lhe é própria, sob pena de restringir, senão
obliterar, o avanço da reflexão ontológica na
teoria da geografia: trata-se da necessidade de
contemplar o sentido da diferença ontológica
no exercício teórico de fundamentação da on-
tologia do espaço na geografia. Questionar este triunfo [inquestioná-
vel da ciência] é colocar a pergunta
pela origem da razão, que remonta
ainda mais longe do que a determina-
ção do momento cartesiano, na histó-
ria do ser: trata-se da interrogação da
essência da técnica”(DUBOIS, 2005,
p. 135) Na reflexão “onto-socio-lógica” do espaço da
geografia se dá, de forma explícita, a exaspe-
ração metafísica do projeto ontológico car-
tesiano típico da ciência moderna em geral,
que condiciona a equivalência entre verdade
e subjetividade moderna, obstáculo que a dia-
lética marxista não pode superar, porquanto
fundamentalmente tributária da concepção de
homem enquanto sujeito da história. Trazer à tona o desafio da assimilação da di-
ferença ontológica na ontologia do espaço da
geografia traduz-se, conforme observado, no
desafio de assimilar a contribuição distintiva
que o pensamento de Martin Heidegger repre-
senta sobre o tema. No décimo capítulo de Por
Uma Geografia Nova, intitulado Uma Tentati-
va de Definição de Espaço, Milton Santos res-
salta, diante da árdua tarefa de determinação
teórica do espaço geográfico, a necessidade de • GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009
120 considerar a definição do espaço sob uma du-
pla acepção: por um lado enquanto categoria
histórica (dotada de universalidade relativa)
e categoria universal (imanente). Ambas as
acepções são indispensáveis ao esforço de de-
finição do espaço, não sendo, portanto, mutu-
amente excludentes, mas, ao contrário, forte-
mente inter-relacionadas. A transformação da
acepção do espaço como categoria histórica é
fruto, fundamentalmente, da transformação do
conteúdo histórico do objeto assim considera-
do. III – CONSIDERAÇÕES FINAIS Além disso, mesmo a acepção do espaço
enquanto categoria universal não é imutável,
pois sua definição variará em função dos avan-
ços filosóficos e científicos. É em relação a
esta última característica do exercício teórico
de definição do espaço que deve ser dimensio-
nada a relevância da assimilação da diferença
ontológica, leia-se, do pensamento de Heideg-
ger, para a tarefa de fundamentação ontológica
da teoria da geografia. perspectiva ontológica, ainda que deva ser
resguardada a diferença de escopo da aborda-
gem: enquanto em Milton SANTOS (1996)
a técnica é elevada à condição de elemento
fundamental à ontologia do espaço, em HEI-
DEGGER (2002) a questão da técnica assinala
uma alternativa de elaboração não-metafísica
de pensar (o Ser). Tal como sublinhou CRAIA
(2003, p.73), no pensamento tardio de Heide-
gger a “questão da técnica é, de algum modo,
a questão que interroga o sentido do Ser. As-
sim, trata-se da questão fundamental de Hei-
degger – do sentido do Ser – transformada na
própria questão da técnica”. Assim, no pensa-
mento deste filósofo, “a questão da técnica só
encontra seu sentido sobre o fundo do ques-
tionamento do Ser”. (CRAIA, 2003, p.73). As possibilidades que o diálogo entre, por um
lado, o pensamento do filósofo sobre a essên-
cia da técnica e, por outro lado, a proposta do
geógrafo de formular a ontologia do espaço a
partir da noção de técnica, constituem, contu-
do, alvitre para um diálogo vindouro. Não obstante, a ausência do sentido da di-
ferença ontológica permanece uma lacuna
aberta no debate teórico dessa disciplina, em
grande medida como conseqüência do caráter
insidioso da determinação social do ser do es-
paço enquanto perfil dominante da ontologia
em geografia – fechada à auto-reflexão de seu
fundamento. A determinação social do ser do
espaço constitui, mesmo, um ciclo auto-insti-
tuinte de fundamentação que, na bibliografia
corrente, não possibilita, nos termos com os
quais é estabelecido, abertura para liberar ou-
tras possibilidades de elaboração ontológica
acerca do ser do espaço e redimensionar essa
temática na teoria da geografia. Redimensio-
nar não significaria, evidentemente, desconsi-
derar a magnitude e a importância da noção de
produção social do espaço, tal como tem sido
usualmente empregada na teoria geral da geo-
grafia, mas radicalizá-la sob uma perspectiva
alternativa, que contém fontes de reflexões
alternativas e pouco desenvolvidas acerca da
natureza do espaço na geografia. Ontologia do espaço e
movimento de renovação crítica
da geografia: O desafio da
diferença ontológoca _____________ . Ser e Tempo. Rio de Janei-
ro: Editora Vozes, 1999. 2v. IV – REFERÊNCIAS BIBLIOGRÁFICAS (org.) Geografia: Teoria e Crítica. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Vo-
zes. 1982. 236p. p.65-74. ________ De Quem é o Pedaço? Espaço e
Cultura. São Paulo: HUCITEC, 1985, 162p. SOJA, E. W. Geografias Pós-Modernas. A rea-
firmação do espaço na teoria social crítica. Rio
de Janeiro: Jorge Zahar Editores, 1993, 324p. MOREIRA, R. Realidade e Metafísica nas Es-
truturas Geográficas Contemporâneas, in: Re-
descobrindo o Brasil 500 Anos Depois. P. 341
– 360, Rio de Janeiro: Bertrand Brasil, 1998. Resumo: O artigo aborda a ontologia do espa-
ço como tema da teoria da geografia no con-
texto do movimento de renovação crítica que
esta ciência conheceu a partir da década de
1970. Para tanto ele problematiza o significa-
do da determinação social do espaço geográfi-
co enquanto modo dominante da ontologia do
espaço na geografia, submetendo a perspec-
tiva em tela à noção de diferença ontológica,
enquanto atributo inerente à peculiaridade do
modo de investigação ontológico. ___________ . A Diferença e a Geografia. O
ardil da identidade e a representação da dife-
rença na Geografia. GEOgraphia. Niterói:
PPGEO-UFF. Ano I, no. 1.,1999. ___________ . A Diferença e a Geografia. O
ardil da identidade e a representação da dife-
rença na Geografia. GEOgraphia. Niterói:
PPGEO-UFF. Ano I, no. 1.,1999. ___________ Marxismo e geografia: a geo-
graficidade e o diálogo das ontologias. GE-
Ographia. Niterói: PPGEO-UFF, Ano VI, no. 11, p.21-37, 2004b __________ Para onde vai o pensamento
geográfico? São Paulo: Editora Contexto,
2006. 191p. Palavras-chave: ontologia do espaço; renova-
ção crítica da geografia. IV – REFERÊNCIAS BIBLIOGRÁFICAS BLANC, M. de Faria. Estudos Sobre o Ser. Lisboa: Fundação Calouste Gulbenkian, 1998. 339 p. BLANC, M. de Faria. Estudos Sobre o Ser. Lisboa: Fundação Calouste Gulbenkian, 1998. 339 p. CRAIA, E. C. P. Gilles Deleuze e a Questão
da Técnica. 2003. Tese de Doutorado. Cam-
pinas: UNICAMP. 356p. DUBOIS, C. Heidegger. Introdução a uma
leitura. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Jorge Zahar,
2005. 244 p. HARVEY, D. A Justiça Social e a Cidade. São
Paulo: Editora HUCITEC, 1980 [1973].291p. HEIDEGGER, M. A “Questão da Técnica”. in: Ensaios e Conferências. Rio de Janeiro:
Editora Vozes, 2002[1954]. 269p. p.11 – 38. _____________ . Para quê poetas? In: Cami-
nhos da Floresta. Lisboa: Fundação Calouste
Gulbenkian, 2002[1977]. 453p. p.307-367. _____________ . Para quê poetas? In: Cami-
nhos da Floresta. Lisboa: Fundação Calouste
Gulbenkian, 2002[1977]. 453p. p.307-367. Nesse sentido é importante assinalar as pos-
sibilidades que o diálogo entre Milton San-
tos e Heidegger acerca da questão da técnica
pode oferecer, na medida em que, em ambos
a técnica passa a ser problematizada sob uma _____________ . Ser e Tempo. Rio de Janei-
ro: Editora Vozes, 1999. 2v. GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009 • 121 SANTOS, M. A Natureza do Espaço. Téc-
nica e tempo, razão e emoção. São Paulo:
HUCITEC, 1996. 308p. LOPARIC, Z. Heidegger Réu (um ensaio so-
bre a periculosidade da filosofia). São Paulo:
Editora Papirus, 1990. 254p. ___________ . Metamorfoses do Espaço
Habitado. São Paulo: HUCITEC, 1988. 124p. LUKÁCS, G. A Ontologia do Ser Social. Os
Princípios Ontológicos Fundamentais de
Marx. São Paulo: Livraria Editora Ciências
Humanas, 1979a. 174p. SILVA, Armando Corrêa da. “O Espaço como
Ser: uma auto-avaliação crítica”. In: Geogra-
fia: Teoria e Crítica. Moreira, R. (org). Rio de
Janeiro: Editora Vozes, 1982. 236p. p.75-92. MARTINS, E. R. Geografia e Ontologia: o
fundamento geográfico do ser. In: GEOUSP
– Espaço e Tempo, São Paulo, no 21, pp. 33
– 51, 2007. MARTINS, E. R. Geografia e Ontologia: o
fundamento geográfico do ser. In: GEOUSP – Espaço e Tempo, São Paulo, no 21, pp. 33
– 51, 2007. ________. “As categorias como fundamentos
do conhecimento geográfico”. In: Seminá-
rio “Filosofia e Geografia”. Rio de Janeiro:
AGB-Rio, 1983. MORAES, A. C. R. “Em Busca da Ontologia
do Espaço”. In: Moreira, R. (org.) Geografia:
Teoria e Crítica. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Vo-
zes. 1982. 236p. p.65-74. MORAES, A. C. R. “Em Busca da Ontologia
do Espaço”. In: Moreira, R. Palavras-chave: ontologia do espaço; renova-
ção crítica da geografia. __________ “O Espaço e o contra-espaço:
as dimensões territoriais da sociedade civil e
do Estado, do privado e do público na ordem
espacial burguesa”. In: Território, territó-
rios (ensaios sobre o ordenamento terri-
torial). Rio de Janeiro: Editora Lamparina,
2007a[2002]. Abstract: The article approaches the space’s
ontology as geography’s theory subject in
geography’s critical renewal movement that
this science knew since 70’s decade. To do so
will be questioned, the meaning of space’s so-
cial determination as the dominant perspective
of the ontology of space in the geographical
theory, submitting to this bias to the notion of
ontological difference, while fundamental at-
tribute of ontological research. _________ . Pensar e Ser em Geografia. São
Paulo: Editora Contexto, 2007b. 188p. RÉE, J. Heidegger. São Paulo: Editora Unesp,
1999. 64p. Key-words: space ontology; geography’s criti-
cal renewal movement. • GEOGRAFARES, nº 7, 2009
122
|
https://openalex.org/W3022368257
|
https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-02941616/document
|
English
| null |
Co-benefits and Trade-Offs From Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity: A Case Study With the FAN Agent-Based Model
|
Frontiers in sustainable food systems
| 2,020
|
cc-by
| 13,130
|
To cite this version: Hugo Fernandez-Mena, Graham K. Mac Donald, Sylvain Pellerin, Thomas Nesme. Co-benefits and
Trade-Offs From Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity: A Case Study With the FAN Agent-
Based Model. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 2020, 4, pp.41. 10.3389/fsufs.2020.00041. hal-02941616 Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License Co-benefits and Trade-Offs From
Agro-Food System Redesign for
Circularity: A Case Study With the
FAN Agent-Based Model Hugo Fernandez-Mena 1,2,3,4*, Graham K. MacDonald 3, Sylvain Pellerin 1 and
Thomas Nesme 2 1 INRAE, UMR ISPA 1391, Bordeaux, France, 2 Bordeaux Sciences Agro, University of Bordeaux, UMR ISPA 1391, Bordeaux,
France, 3 Department of Geography, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada, 4 Montpellier SupAgro—Institut Agro,
University of Montpellier, UMR ABSys, Montpellier, France Realizing more sustainable food, feed, and bioenergy systems will require interventions
such as increased recycling of nutrients and coordination of biomass flows among farms. Innovative tools to explore the co-benefits and trade-offs of improving flow circularity in
agro-food systems at different scales are needed to better understand the efficacy of
these sustainability solutions. Here, we applied the FAN (“Flows in Agro-food Networks”)
agent-based model to simulate contrasting scenarios of material flows locally in a
small farming region of France. These scenarios aim to enhance: (1) best management
practices at the farm scale; (2) organic material recycling and biogas production
collectively across the agricultural landscape; and (3) system redesign toward complete
local circularity through crop and livestock symbiosis, fewer livestock, and elimination
of external inputs. Scenario simulation outcomes are assessed in terms of their degree
of circularity and food production. We find that best management practices at the farm
scale and collective solutions for recycling (organic fertilization and anaerobic digestion)
substantially improved the degree of circularity by tightening the local nitrogen (N) cycle
without affecting food production. Among other co-benefits, changes in farm rotations
to feed livestock locally increased the degree of circularity without appreciably impacting
food production. The maximum circularity scenario showed considerable potential to
mitigate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, however, they involved large trade-offs
with food production that were even more pronounced with fewer livestock animals. Although regulating livestock numbers combined with eliminating chemical fertilizers
was the most effective at mitigating GHG emissions, when applied simultaneously it
substantially impacted food and bioenergy production. Such trade-offs for soil fertility
demonstrate the importance of coupling crops and livestock for reaching self-sufficient
circular systems. Our study illustrates how the FAN agent-based model can be applied
to account for multiple types of interactions involved in transitions toward circularity
in local agro-food systems, including the potential for co-benefits, and unintended
consequences of interventions. HAL Id: hal-02941616
https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-02941616v1
Submitted on 17 Sep 2020 L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers. Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License ORIGINAL RESEARCH
published: 28 April 2020
doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2020.00041 Received: 31 January 2020
Accepted: 26 March 2020
Published: 28 April 2020 Received: 31 January 2020
Accepted: 26 March 2020
Published: 28 April 2020 Keywords: material flows, circular economy, recycling, bioeconomy, agroecology Edited by:
Agustin Del Prado,
Basque Centre for Climate
Change, Spain Reviewed by:
Le Noë Julia,
University of Natural Resources and
Life Sciences Vienna, Austria
Inacio de Barros,
Brazilian Agricultural Research
Corporation (EMBRAPA), Brazil *Correspondence:
Hugo Fernandez-Mena
hugo.fernandez-mena@supagro.fr *Correspondence:
Hugo Fernandez-Mena
hugo.fernandez-mena@supagro.fr Specialty section:
This article was submitted to
Agroecology and Ecosystem Services,
a section of the journal
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 INTRODUCTION alternative farming practices and material exchanges. Although
few studies have estimated outputs from different food sectors
of the from a complex farming population, including feed
and wastes chains in a region, we need to better account
for the interactions between farms and with their upstream
and downstream partners, to be able to evaluate food systems
circularity (de Boer and van Ittersum, 2018; Tseng et al., 2019). Current agricultural resource use and its impacts on non-
agricultural ecosystems is a major contributor to pushing
the Earth system beyond its safe operating space (Tilman
and Clark, 2014; Campbell et al., 2017). New strategies and
regulations are needed to tackle agriculture’s pressure on natural
resources including land, water, nutrients, and climate (Foley
et al., 2011; Carlson et al., 2016). With a shift toward more
intensive agricultural production in some regions, increasingly
specialized farms rely on imported synthetic fertilizers that drive
global nutrient imbalances and create complex international
dependencies (Lassaletta et al., 2014), particularly for feed crop
and livestock production (Van Zanten et al., 2018). However,
alternatives can be found at the local scale, particularly if
agricultural supply chains move toward close-looped systems
that reduce dependence on external inputs (Davis et al.,
2016) and recycle nutrients locally (Metson et al., 2016). Reducing agricultural pressure on natural resources can be
achieved through a better use of local biomass materials (e.g.,
feed and forage for livestock as well as organic wastes as
fertilizers), by applying circular economy and bioeconomy
principles (Golembiewski et al., 2015; El-Chichakli et al., 2016). Stronger circularity through local material exchanges among
farms is essential to better use and recycle local resources while
minimizing losses. Scenarios examining whole farming regions
can provide an improved understanding of the positive or
negative impacts of applying such circular strategies that can
better inform agro-ecological transitions and policies to enhance
farming systems sustainability. Agent-based models can be a useful tool to simulate
different agents’ behaviors under alternative scenarios toward
sustainability (Alonso-Betanzos et al., 2017). For example,
characterizing the agro-food system as a network of interacting
agents can help to represent alternative scenarios of biomass
materials management. INTRODUCTION Although there is a large literature on
agent-based models applied to land use systems (Matthews et al.,
2007), very few studies have applied agent based simulations to
study alternative scenarios of materials management in agro-
food systems at the local scale (Gaube et al., 2009; Bichraoui
et al., 2013; Grillot et al., 2018). To our knowledge, agent-
based models have not been used yet to simulate alternative
scenarios of material exchanges concerning crops, livestock,
wastes, and bioenergy all together. Simulation models combined
with alternative scenarios of material exchange can help to
assess the circularity of farming systems to better understand the
benefits and trade-offs of implementing alternative material flow
strategies among farms on the same landscape (Fernandez-Mena
et al., 2016). In this study, we aimed to simulate alternative scenarios of
material flows across a single farming region. To do so, we
applied the FAN (“Flows in Agro-food Networks”) model to
a case study of a small farming region in southwest France. A short description of the FAN agent-based model and its
key indicators is provided in Section The FAN Model Brief
Description and Indicators Presentation. The Ribéracois is the
region used as case study and its characteristics are presented
in Section The Ribéracois Case Study. The scenarios examined
in the simulations, described in Section Scenario Design, were
designed in an additive manner, i.e., including previous step
implementations while addressing a new issue at each step: (i)
the business as usual (BAU) situation; (ii) best management
practices at the farm scale; (iii) optimizing material exchanges;
(iv) enhancing bioenergy production; (v) enhancing crop-
livestock symbiosis; and (vi) maximizing circularity; scenarios
(v) and (vi) also involve reductions in livestock numbers. We
also hypothesized about potential effects that these “leverage”
factors could present across the scenarios. With the objective
of assessing the system performance, we used a series of food
production and circularity indicators incorporated in the FAN
model, described in Section The FAN Model Brief Description
and Indicators Presentation. To advance scenarios assessment of a farming circular
economy, improved estimates of food production and the
environmental performance linked to changing material flows
in the agro-food system locally are needed. Several studies
have analyzed the impacts of farming systems transitions to
agroecology at the plot or the farm scale (Pelzer et al., 2012;
Marchand et al., 2014; Giuliano et al., 2016; Wery et al., 2018). Citation: Fernandez-Mena H, MacDonald GK,
Pellerin S and Nesme T (2020)
Co-benefits and Trade-Offs From
Agro-Food System Redesign for
Circularity: A Case Study With the
FAN Agent-Based Model. Front. Sustain. Food Syst. 4:41. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2020.00041 April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 1 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. INTRODUCTION Yet, fewer studies have tried to go further and evaluate farming
systems at larger local scales, such as in small agricultural
regions (Le Noë et al., 2017; Billen et al., 2018). On the one
hand, some large scale studies focused on a single sector of the
agro-food system (e.g., bioenergy) or a specific type of farming
system within the region studied. Examples of such approaches
include the assessment of sustainable bioenergy production
(Toop et al., 2017; Vega-Quezada et al., 2017; Fan et al., 2018;
Cobo et al., 2019); the assessment of dairy farming in different
European regions (Acosta-Alba et al., 2012; Prado et al., 2013);
the exchanges between specialized arable and bovine farms in a
region of France (Moraine et al., 2017a,b); and nutrient dynamics
of crop-livestock farming systems in Africa (Manlay et al., 2002;
Tittonell et al., 2009; Giller et al., 2011). On the other hand,
other studies have assessed diverse types of production systems
across a single farming region, such as the scenario assessment
of the Montérégie region in Canada (Mitchell et al., 2015), the
California Nitrogen Assessment (Tomich and Scow, 2016), and
a life-cycle assessment (LCA) of a French catchment (Avadí
et al., 2016). However, such broader approaches typically did not
quantify precisely multiple farm properties for the simulation of Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org Livestock Production to explore and assess opportunities for a circular economy
in small farming regions, such as the “Ribéracois”, which
we refer to as a “district” herein. At this scale, FAN may
help to unravel interactions concerning material exchanges in
farming activities by simulating recycling flows and assessing
their degree of circularity. The FAN model mechanisms and
submodels are described following the ODD (Overview, Design
concepts, and Details) protocol for agent-based models in
Fernandez-Mena et al. (2019). The model script, the Ribéracois
dataset and the scenarios parametrization are available in
Fernandez-Mena (2017a). Forage production is estimated in FAN as the addition of
grass, silage maize and legume forage production. Livestock
production was calculated taking into account the number of
adult animals on each farm and their fattening and reproduction
ratio according to the standardized feed rations in France (Devun
and Guinot, 2012). As we were informed by the extension
services in the Southwest of France during informal interviews
(see Section The Ribéracois Case Study) that forage intake per
ruminant could slightly vary among farms, a threshold is set to
−10% of the average forage ratio and a maximum was set to
+10% of this value. In FAN, both feed and forage requirements
are expected to be satisfied, first, by inner farm production,
second, by exchanges with others farms through after local feed
stocking and processing, and, third, with global market imports
if needed. (
)
The FAN model simulates, on an annual time-step, different
agro-food system activities in the following order: crop
fertilization;
crop
production;
feed
exchanges;
livestock
production; food processing; food waste and by-products
exchanges; and, bioenergy production. The materials exchanged
include organic and chemical fertilizers, feed, straw, food,
by-products, and wastes. The agents involved in the network
exchanges are farms and their upstream or downstream partners
in small farming regions, such as feed and fertilizer suppliers,
food industries, waste processors, and anaerobic digesters. The
mechanisms involved in material exchanges selects a probable
exchange between two agents based on a stochastic algorithm,
after evaluating the whole local combinations of agents willing
to exchange a specific material. The combinations are ranked
through an equation taking into account: (i) the distance between
the agents; (ii) the quantity demanded and supplied; and, (iii)
the preference coefficient chosen by the simulator for a specific
material use (e.g., use manure for fertilization vs. anaerobic
digestion; use grass for animal feeding vs. anaerobic digestion;
etc.). Local Flows and Transportation Local Flows and Transportation
Estimating the number of local flows provides a proxy for the
degree of local cooperation in material exchange among farms
that is necessary as part of increased network circularity. In the
FAN model, materials are assumed to be transported by truck
from one farm to another, or between farms and their partners. We proposed “local flows” as a network indicator representing
exchanges between two agents within the Ribéracois district. We
considered that each local flow stops when the corresponding
material is used and transformed to produce either food or
energy, while exchanges inflowing from or outflowing to the
global market were not included. Local flows were aggregated
according to their final uses as follows: (i) local fertilization flows
including manure, digestates and sewage sludge applied to soils;
(ii) energy flows including manure, grass and food processing
wastes allocated to anaerobic digesters; as well as three flows
allocated to animal requirements: (iii) feed flows; (iv) forage
flows; and (v) straw flows for bedding. The FAN Model Brief Description and
Indicators Presentation The FAN Model Brief Description and
Indicators Presentation “Flows in Agro-food Networks” (FAN) is an agent-based model
that simulates and assesses farming activities based on processing
and exchanging agricultural materials. FAN is a theoretical tool April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 2 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. Livestock Production A fidelity variable can be used to preserve a percentage of
agent exchanges for the following simulated year and accelerate
calculations. A radius of action can be set to limit the exchanges
of certain biomass materials (e.g., 10 km for fresh manure,
60 km for grass fodder, etc.). In order to create scenarios of
exchanges, users can modify a certain number of parameters in
FAN, presented in Table S1. Finally, FAN includes a series of
indicators, explained in detail in the following sections, which
serve to assess alternative scenarios in terms of food production
and systems circularity. Bioenergy Production
l f
d gy
Input materials for digestion are chosen in a proportion similar
to the average feedstock composition in France that limits food-
crop-based materials. This average digestible feedstock contains
68% manure, 17% green biomass (considered to be grass in
FAN), and 15% food processing wastes, including cereal, milk,
fruit and vegetable wastes (ADEME, 2013). Animal manure
is the most important ingredient in the feedstock and was
considered to be the limiting factor for maximizing anaerobic
digestion without compromising food-crop-based materials,
following recommendations in France. Therefore, the anaerobic
digester capacity in Ribéracois was calculated according to
the total animal manure in the district, estimated as 225,210
tons of feedstock (ADEME, 2013). The bioenergy produced
was calculated proportionally to the methane potential of the
materials used in the feedstock: 42 m3 of biogas, with 34% of
electric yield equivalent to 85.73 kWh of electricity per ton of
digested feedstock. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org Crop Production In FAN, crop yields vary with nitrogen (N) applications to
soils that is consider to be the single limiting factor for crop
production. N crop uptake is considered to drive crop yield
through a linear relationship until a plateau of maximum yields. Given that N is typically overused at present, maximum yields
are assumed to be the current yields observed in this case-
study. Initial soil N application were set to the observed fertilizer
application in Ribéracois. Fertilized crop rate is adjusted in
scenario simulations according to calculated farm N budgets and
N availability. N fertilization needs were estimated at the farm
scale by summing the N needs of all crop categories within
the farm: cereals, oilseeds, fruits and vegetables, silage maize. However, grass, legume forage, and pulse crops were considered
not to require fertilization in our simulations due to biological
N fixation. April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 3 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. Greenhouse Gas Emissions The N balance includes inflows (N from chemical fertilizers,
organic fertilizers, digestates, and sewage sludge) and outflows (N
in harvested crops, N leaching, as well as losses of N-N2O and
N-NH3+NOx). All catch-crops were assumed to reduce 50% N
leaching (Valkama et al., 2016). These values were individually
calculated for each farm annually and then aggregated to obtain
a whole N balance of the district. In addition, since our
scenarios were oriented toward maximizing the local circularity
of fertilization, two indicators of organic N participating to this
circuity are proposed: The net greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are estimated including
both on- and off-site emissions linked to changes implemented in
the scenarios, such as the emissions induced by material truck
transportation, chemical fertilizer and feed off-site production
as well as avoided emissions induced by bioenergy production. To estimate emissions in FAN, a simple soil mineralization
model is applied (Hénin and Dupuis, 1945; I.P.C.C., 2006). Tier 1 default values are used for emissions from farming and
the ADEME (2017) database is used for truck, biogas and
feed imports emissions. In the net GHG estimation (expressed
in CO2-equivalence), emissions are considered to be positive,
whereas C stored in soils and CO2 avoided are considered to be
negative. Farm machinery and buildings are not included since
they are considered to be invariable among scenarios. Grasslands
C net sequestration capacity are assumed to be equivalent to those
of European grasslands, following Chang et al. (2016). Although
emissions induced by producing the food or feed elsewhere
to compensate for lower production in the study area are not
considered, an efficiency food production ratio in kg of protein
or MJ of food energy per CO2-equivalent are calculated for
each scenario. =
Nmanure + Ndigestates + Nsewage sludge + Nfixation
Nmineral fertiliser+ Nmanure + N digestates + Nsewage sludge + Nfixation
;
(1)
Norg exchanged % = Norganic exchanged applied
Ntotal applied
;
(2) (2) “N orgapplied%” accounts for all non-mineral sources in the total N
added to soils, whereas “N orgexchanged%” takes into account only
the part of organic N that was exchanged between two agents
before being used for fertilization. The first indicator accounts
for the degree of N circularity in the region, since only organic
sources are produced locally; whereas the second accounts for
the effort performed to recycle these nutrients by exchanging
materials between farms. Indicators Relative Score We
utilize
a
multi-criteria
assessment
to
compare
the
performance of the different scenarios through a relative
score obtained for key production and circularity indicators. FIGURE 1 | Geography of the “Ribéracois” district. On the left, location of the district in Dordogne, France. On the right, map of the district and key agents in FAN. Farms are represented by circles colored with their type (green for arable; blue for dairy; red for beef cows; purple for mixed cattle; black for mixed crop-livestock;
yellow for horticultural; orange for monogastrics; and gray for ovine and caprine). Squares represent food industries (yellow: feed collectors; blue: milk industries;
green: fruits and vegetables industry; red: slaughterhouse). FIGURE 1 | Geography of the “Ribéracois” district. On the left, location of the district in Dordogne, France. On the right, map of the district and key agents in FAN. Farms are represented by circles colored with their type (green for arable; blue for dairy; red for beef cows; purple for mixed cattle; black for mixed crop-livestock;
yellow for horticultural; orange for monogastrics; and gray for ovine and caprine). Squares represent food industries (yellow: feed collectors; blue: milk industries;
green: fruits and vegetables industry; red: slaughterhouse). FIGURE 1 | Geography of the “Ribéracois” district. On the left, location of the district in Dordogne, France. On the right, map of the district and key agents in FAN. Farms are represented by circles colored with their type (green for arable; blue for dairy; red for beef cows; purple for mixed cattle; black for mixed crop-livestock;
yellow for horticultural; orange for monogastrics; and gray for ovine and caprine). Squares represent food industries (yellow: feed collectors; blue: milk industries;
green: fruits and vegetables industry; red: slaughterhouse). April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 4 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. Farm types
Number of farms
in ribéracois
Mean UAA
(ha)
Stand. Indicators Relative Score dev of
UAA (ha)
Total number of
livestock animals
% Cereal area
% Oilseeds
area
% Pulses area
% Silage
maize area
% Other
forages area
% Grass
area
% Fruits & vegetables
area
Dairy farms
53
96.5
74.3
115.6
26.0
3.3
0.2
17.7
10.5
42.8
1.0
Meat cattle farms
91
66.0
71.0
112.8
12.7
2.1
0.0
2.3
3.6
77.7
0.9
Mixed cattle farms
7
151.1
50.3
197.0
14.2
0.0
0.0
8.5
2.0
74.2
0.0
Ovine & caprine farms
76
34.7
73.0
181.4
16.5
0.7
0.0
3.0
12.9
63.9
0.0
Monogastric farms
37
31.6
38.6
1932.0
51.6
0.0
0.0
0.0
1.4
34.3
1.0
Arable farms
291
69.6
59.4
11.6
60.1
19.2
0.5
0.1
1.3
12.3
0.0
Mixed farms
208
62.0
74.1
62.5
41.3
10.7
0.3
2.3
3.2
38.3
0.0
Horticultural farms
72
6.6
11.0
0.5
16.6
24.2
0.0
0.0
0.00
0.00
56.1
Farm types
% Milk cows
% Adult meat
cattle
% Calves
% Milk sheep goats
% Meat adult
sheep goats
% Goat kids
% Sows pigs
% Pigs
% Fattening
pigs
% laying
hens
% Meat poultry
Dairy farms
45.2
28.9
18.7
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
3.7
3.4
Meat cattle farms
0.0
61.1
31.0
0.0
2.6
0.4
0.0
0.0
0.0
3.0
2.0
Mixed cattle farms
15.8
61.1
23.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Ovine caprine farms
0.8
7.1
1.9
43.3
15.9
28.7
0.0
0.0
0.0
1.4
0.9
Monogastric farms
0.0
0.5
0.2
0.0
0.2
0.0
2.6
1.5
2.9
0.3
91.7
Arable farms
0.6
46.2
15.4
0.0
8.6
8.6
0.0
0.0
0.0
15.6
4.9
Mixed farms
4.2
47.0
18.3
1.6
7.2
6.4
0.0
0.0
0.0
5.7
9.6
Horticulture farms
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
100.0
0.0
The partition of land use in the district is shown in the first table and partition of livestock animals is in the second table. UAA stands for Utilized Agricultural Area of the whole farm. The relative score is calculated for the three types of production
indicators (crop production, livestock production, and bioenergy
production) and for the four key system circularity indicators
(feed autonomy, bioenergy production, N cycle closing, and
GHG mitigation potential). Relative scores range from 0 to 10
and are calculated as an equivalence of the relative scenario
performances on each indicator. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org Indicators Relative Score The percentage of organic N
for fertilization and the legumes autonomy are used as a proxy
to calculate the relative score for closing the N cycle. A second
calculation is made for the cumulative score across the seven
indicators presented, assuming that all indicators count equally. The Ribéracois Case Study Ribéracois has a total area of around 1,000 km2, with
approximately 500 km2 of utilized agricultural area (UAA), a
mean altitude of 80 m, an annual rainfall of around 800 mm,
and an average annual temperature of 12.3◦C. It is located in
Dordogne département of the Nouvelle-Aquitaine administrative
region, in the southwest of France (Figure 1). For comparison,
the surface area of the Ribéracois district is of the same order of
magnitude as the average county in the U.S. (1,610 km2). Data on agricultural land use and livestock units per
farm type were collected from the agricultural census of the
French Ministry of Agriculture (Agreste, 2013). In addition, a
validation process was conducted by contrasting actual farm
practices to adapt the FAN model (Garcia, 2016), helping to
confirm the main principles of exchange mechanisms simulated
in FAN. Farming practices related to animal feed rations,
distance of biomass exchanges, and organic fertilization have
been further explored based on interviews with agronomists
from the local extension services (Chambre d’Agriculture de
la Dordogne) and compared with regional statistics (Agreste,
2014; Groupe Régionale d’Expertise Nitrates (GREN), 2016). We
consulted with local farming cooperatives, dairy industries, and
slaughterhouses on the destination of crop and animal flows and
therefore on the production of organic wastes (Garcia, 2016). Finally, the feedstock composition for anaerobic digestion has
been contrasted with digesters recently constructed in the areas
nearby (based on personal communications with managers of
Chambre d’agriculture de Dordogne). g
g
In Ribéracois, the agricultural census registered 835 farms
with a diversity of farming activities, with a large population
of specialized farms and only some exceptions of mixed crop-
livestock farms. Crop production is focused on arable crops,
especially cereals, oilseeds, and silage maize for forage. Only a
few farms focus on horticultural production (Table 1). Livestock
is highly diversified and includes substantial cattle production,
specialized in beef or in dairy production, followed by numerous
farms breeding small ruminants (ovine and caprine) and some
monogastric livestock production of pork and poultry. A number
of upstream and downstream partners of farms operate across
the district by sourcing raw materials, as well as transforming
and trading farming products. The Ribéracois Case Study These partners include three large
companies that collect cereals and process feed, two milk and
cheese industries, two slaughterhouses, several small fruits and
vegetables industries, four wastewater treatment plants, and some Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 5 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. FIGURE 2 | Hypothesized effects of the leverage factors (boxes) on key indicators of the system performance (circles). Arrows represent interactions between
leverage factors and system performances. Green arrows stand for positive effects, red arrows for negative effects and light blue for unknown effects. FIGURE 2 | Hypothesized effects of the leverage factors (boxes) on key indicators of the system performance (circles). Arrows represent interactions between
leverage factors and system performances. Green arrows stand for positive effects, red arrows for negative effects and light blue for unknown effects. exchanging organic fertilizer materials among farms (Nowak
et al., 2015); (iv) setting up biogas plants in the district (Mao
et al., 2015); (v) enhancing the production of local feed and forage
(Bonaudo et al., 2014; Lemaire et al., 2014); (vi) reducing livestock
populations (Leip et al., 2015); and (vii) removing chemical
fertilizers (Bouwman et al., 2017). Although all these drivers may
enhance a component of the system’s circularity through better
environmental performance, they are also interconnected and
may have co-benefits or trade-offs in terms of other indicators
and whole system performance (Figure 2). projects of anaerobic digesters construction. Although farming
activities in Ribéracois are quite diversified, they are challenged
by relatively inefficient nutrient and biomass management. High
N fertilization rates for arable crops are applied overall the
district (∼160 kg N·ha−1·year−1), similar to other regions in
France (Agreste, 2014). This high rates lead to high N losses
through various pathways. The southern part of the Ribéracois,
where arable crops are predominant, has been classified as a
Vulnerable Zone by the EU Nitrate Directive since 2015 (DREAL,
2016). Livestock producers are affected by the high volatility of
input prices due to overall deficit in soybean (imported mainly
from South America) and alfalfa (imported from the north of
France) to meet livestock requirements. Green, renewable energy
production through anaerobic digestion is strongly pushed by
local authorities, both at farm and collective scales. Based on the leverage factors, we designed contrasting
scenarios to be applied in the Ribéracois region, ranging
from relatively simple transition steps to more complex
transformations. The Ribéracois Case Study The scenario design follows an additive
manner,
i.e.,
each
scenario
applied
the
changes
already
implemented in the previous one. These are built following
the “Efficiency, Substitution and Redesign” framework (ESR),
which has already been applied to agricultural systems transition
toward an agroecological sustainability (Lamine, 2011; Wezel
et al., 2014). “Efficiency-like” solutions are considered in
designing the “Best management practices” scenario that
implement
management
recommendations
to
improve
fertilizer input and animal feed use efficiency. “Substitution-
like” solutions are used to design scenarios based on local
collective solutions through exchanges, without modifying
the farm structures. In a complete “Redesign” perspective,
external supplies of feed and fertilizer are removed and farm
structure (land-use and livestock population) is modified
(Figure 3). Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org Scenario Design In order to design our scenarios, we considered several circular
flows, both at the farm scale through agro-ecological practices
and at the local scale via flows among farms and their partners. Therefore, we hypothesized that a series of “leverage” factors
could be used to achieve circularity both at the farm and at the
district scale with synergies for environmental performance of
agriculture. According to the literature, a series of levers were
selected for their potential benefits, as developed below. They are:
(i) reduction of nutrient losses to the environment by adjusting
fertilization rates to crop requirements and by using catch crops
(Valkama et al., 2016); (ii) reduction of protein intake in cattle
feed rations (Edouard et al., 2016; Pellerin et al., 2017); (iii) April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 6 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. FIGURE 3 | Scenarios explored in the Ribéracois case study using the FAN model. The S5b scenario is Crop-Livestock Symbiosis and the S6b Scenario is Maximum
Circularity. The scenarios are designed in an additive manner, i.e., each scenario applied the changes already implemented in the previous one. FIGURE 3 | Scenarios explored in the Ribéracois case study using the FAN model. The S5b scenario is Crop-Livestock Symbiosis and the S6b Scenario is Maximum
Circularity. The scenarios are designed in an additive manner, i.e., each scenario applied the changes already implemented in the previous one. We hypothesized that greater environmental benefits would
accrue in scenarios that require more profound agro-food system
changes (i.e., for “Redesign-like” scenarios). The scenarios are
built in the FAN model by changing specific parameters and
coefficients of the model (Table 2), as detailed in Fernandez-
Mena et al. (2019). A brief scenario description is given as follows: on top of using best management practices, all farms are
predisposed
to
exchange
materials
with
their
partners
to
meet
their
fertilizer
nutrient
demands. In
addition,
the
FAN
preference
coefficient
for
using
manure
and
sewage sludge as organic fertilizers are increased to the
maximum level. S4. The implementation of “biogas” (BIOGAS) production
plants up to their maximum potential. In this scenario, exchanges
are maximized and 10 anaerobic digester units are simulated to
ferment biomass materials in order to produce electricity from
biogas (CH4 + CO2). Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org Scenario Design Consequently, farms are forced to exchange
their manure with the digesters, getting back similar amounts of
nitrogen as digestates to fertilize soils. Then, farms may offer their
digestates surplus to other farms in the network. FAN coefficients
are adapted to facilitate flows with digesters, including manure,
grass, and food wastes materials. Note that our approach develops
bioenergy scenarios by respecting the important principle of
using plant biomass in priority for human food, as described by
de Boer and van Ittersum (2018). g
S1. The “Business As Usual” (BAU) situation represents the
current farming practices, its production and environmental
impacts. It is considered as the baseline situation. Its parameters
were set to FAN default values, presented in Table S1. Although
there was a project of anaerobic digester construction in the
district in 2016 (Garcia, 2016), we did not consider any anaerobic
digestion in the baseline and following scenarios. S2. The adoption of “Best Management Practices” (BMP) at
the farm scale. In this scenario, farms aimed to reduce their
environmental pressure by applying some basic management
interventions that are commonly recommended by agrarian
extension agencies (Baumgart-Getz et al., 2012). In particular, the
N fertilizer application rate was adjusted to crop requirements
plus some unavoidable losses including N volatilization and
moderate N leaching (overdose coefficient of 1.3). Farms are also
required to use catch crops in order to additionally reduce N
losses through leaching. Animal diets are adjusted by slightly
reducing protein feed intake according to protein use efficiency
recommendations (Edouard et al., 2016; Pellerin et al., 2017),
expecting improved nutrient use efficiency. S5a. A complete “Crop-Livestock symbiosis” (C-L Symb.)
through local feed and forage production is added to S4
(maximized exchanges and biogas). In this scenario, crop
production is adjusted to meet the local livestock feed
requirement of all the farms. As a consequence, if a forage
deficit exists, cereal crops are converted to grasslands in order to
compensate such deficit. Similarly, if any concentrate feed deficit
exists—in particular in pulses—cereal crop areas are converted to
pulses. Cereals were chosen because they are the most common
crop in the area. S3. The fostering of material “exchanges” (EXCH) between
farms and their partner network for better closing nutrient
cycles, including local forage and organic fertilizers. Here, April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 7 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. Expected results compared to previous scenario Expected results compared to previous scenario (Livestock /2) silage maize surface reduced to compensate forage surplus
cereal extra compensating forage surplus S6a. A system with maximum circularity is implemented
in the “Max. Circularity” scenario, where no external inputs
to the system are allowed. Therefore, all the previous circular
implementations are retained, for exchanging, producing biogas
and locally feeding livestock, and, in addition to this, chemical
fertilizers
are
no
longer
available,
rendering
the
system
fully self-sufficient. land use and livestock number of each farm type are used to
create a synthetic population of farms. The size of farms is
simulated following a normal distribution centered to the mean
and standard deviation of the total area. Then, land use and
livestock numbers are distributed proportionally to the obtained
size, following the real proportion on each farm type. Other farm
partners, such as food industries, slaughterhouses and wastewater
treatment stations, are located spatially in the FAN map by using
their geographical location in the district. Anaerobic digesters
are created following a homogeneous spatial distribution of their
digestion capacity. y
Two alternatives are explored for the last two scenarios: S5b. Livestock are reduced to half of the initial population
for all animal species. In addition, all principles of local feed
and forage presented in S5a are also applied (C-L Symb. + L/2). Unused silage maize for forage is reduced and replaced by cereals. Grasslands are not modified. Case Study Initialization In total, we launched 30 simulations of each scenario by running
each until its 5th year. In order to initialize the Ribéracois district in FAN, a synthetic
farm population is created based on the average features of the
different farm types (Table 1). Farms are classified according
to their main agricultural production into different farm types. The number of farm types, their total area and the average RESULTS S6b. In the “Max. Circularity + L/2” scenario, livestock
are reduced to half of the initial population and maximum
circularity is applied, therefore, implementations of S5b and S6a
are applied together. Here, we discuss the FAN simulation results estimated through
the various indicators presented above and their relative scores. These indicators covered food and energy production and
circularity. The indicators were calculated in annual units as
a result of a 5 years’ simulation with 30 repetitions for each
scenario. We start by presenting the results of each of the
indicators in detail and then the relative score multi-criteria
assessment that summarize the whole simulation performance. Scenario Design TABLE 2 | Specifications of scenarios in the FAN model and their expected results. Scenario
Changes in variables and agents attributes
Expected results compared to previous scenario
S1
BAU
No change
Observed fertilization rates 160 (kg N·ha−1·year−1)
All coefficient with default values = 0.5
-
S2
BMP
N fertilization dose = N crop needs * overdose coefficient (1.3)
Pulses protein reduction to reach 14% of N in feed
Catch crops reducing N leaching 50%
Reduced fertilizer inflows
Adjusted soybean inflows
Drastically reduced N losses
S3
EXCH
S2 +
manure (and digestates) fertilization preference coefficient = 0.9
chemical fertilizer preference coef = 0.1 disposition to exchange = 100
Reduced fertilizer inflows
Increased local flows and circularity
Higher CO2 emissions by truck transportation
S4
BIOGAS
S3 +
number of anaerobic digesters = 10 with a capacity of digestion f (total manure)
grass digestion preference coef = 0.9
fruits veg wastes digestion preference coef = 0.9
Enhanced bioenergy prod. Increased local flows and circularity
Higher CO2 emissions by truck transportation
Lower GHG emissions
S5a
C-L Symb. S4 +
grass extra surface compensating forage deficit
pulses extra surface compensating pulses deficit
cereals surface reduced for grass and pulses
Lower GHG emissions
Decreased feed inflows
Increased local flows
Increased circularity
Lower GHG emissions
S6a
Max. Circularity
S5a +
No N chemical fertilizer
Lower yields
Eliminated fertilizer inflows
Increased circularity
Lower GHG emissions
S5b
C-L Symb. + (L/2)
S5a +
(Livestock /2) silage maize surface reduced to compensate forage surplus
cereal extra compensating forage surplus
Lower meat production
Lower GHG emissions
S6b
Max. Circularity
+ (L/2)
S6a +
(Livestock /2) silage maize surface reduced to compensate forage surplus
cereal extra compensating forage surplus
Lower crop yields
Eliminated fertilizer inflows
Lower GHG emissions TABLE 2 | Specifications of scenarios in the FAN model and their expected results. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org Local Flows Overall, the number of total local flows increased from the
baseline to the last scenario, especially when implementing April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 8 Fernandez-Mena et al. Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity FIGURE 4 | GAMA platform display for local fertilization flows in Ribéracois in two contrasted scenarios: BAU situation on the left and Maximum Circularity on the
right. Farm typologies are represented by colored circles: green for arable farms; black for mix farms; red for beef cattle farms; blue for dairy cattle farms; purple for
mix cattle farms; gray for ovine and caprine farms; orange for monogastric farms and yellow for horticultural farms. Wastewater treatment station are presented in
large blue circles; anaerobic digesters in gray triangles and feed collectors in yellow squares. Material flows are presented in lines joining supplier and demander
agents: manure for fertilization flows are in black lines; manure for digestion flows are in brown lines; digestates flows are in orange lines; sewage sludge flows are in
blue lines and chemical fertilizer flows in purple lines. Note that manure for digestion returns from digesters to the supplying farm before this farm shares outflows of
any surplus digestates to other farms. FIGURE 4 | GAMA platform display for local fertilization flows in Ribéracois in two contrasted scenarios: BAU situation on the left and Maximum Circularity on the
right. Farm typologies are represented by colored circles: green for arable farms; black for mix farms; red for beef cattle farms; blue for dairy cattle farms; purple for
mix cattle farms; gray for ovine and caprine farms; orange for monogastric farms and yellow for horticultural farms. Wastewater treatment station are presented in
large blue circles; anaerobic digesters in gray triangles and feed collectors in yellow squares. Material flows are presented in lines joining supplier and demander
agents: manure for fertilization flows are in black lines; manure for digestion flows are in brown lines; digestates flows are in orange lines; sewage sludge flows are in
blue lines and chemical fertilizer flows in purple lines. Note that manure for digestion returns from digesters to the supplying farm before this farm shares outflows of
any surplus digestates to other farms. However, N chemical fertilizer increases when reducing livestock
in C-L Symb. + L/2 since the area under crops with strong N
demand such as cereals increases. Local Flows The N from animal excreta
(collected in barns) allocated to crop fertilization only satisfied
half of crop requirements, however, it was initially reduced with
protein intake, and finally proportionally reduced to livestock
heads in C-L Symb. + L/2 and Max. Circularity + L/2 scenarios. The N fixed by legumes is particularly remarkable when crop-
livestock symbiosis is applied, fostering pulse production. In
the BIOGAS scenario, the N added by digested green biomass
and food processing wastes behaves as a new input of N to the
system not mobilized in the previous scenarios. Finally, sewage
sludge inflows do not play an important role in the overall N
inputs. Concerning N outputs, N crop uptake varied firstly when
changing land-use in C-L Symb, by adding pulses to the system
that fixed N from the atmosphere. These pulses are reduced in
C-L Symb + L/2 since they are no longer needed. As shown in
crop production results, N inputs in scenarios without chemical
fertilizers are not enough to satisfy N crop demand for maximum
yields. Nitrogen leaching is very high in the BAU scenario, but
steps taken in BMP are effective to reduce N losses. In fact, best
management practices have a dual effect on N losses: on the
one hand, N fertilization rates are adjusted to crop needs and,
on the other hand, catch crops are implemented to reduce N
leaching. Volatilization losses (as NH3 and NOx produced during anaerobic digestion and crop livestock symbiosis (Figure S1). Local fertilization flows (corresponding to both manure and
sewage sludge) increased considerably in the EXCH scenario,
up to 450 local flows in the Max. Circularity scenario,
where organic manure is the only option for fertilizing soils
(Figure 4). However, the number of fertilization flows is reduced
when livestock populations are reduced (L/2), since flows for
animal requirements are numerous. Local food waste flows
(corresponding to both energy and animal requirements) slightly
increase when implementing digestion. The number of feed grain
flows decrease when crop and livestock integration are applied
(C-L Symb.) since this integration occurs mainly at the farm scale. Although straw flows increase with crop livestock integration,
local forage does not change as there is enough forage production
area. Finally, when reducing livestock population, because there
is enough forage within each farm, forage exchanges are no
longer needed. Nitrogen Cycle Results for N inputs to soils show the highest chemical fertilizer
use in the BAU scenario, whereas fertilizer use exhibits a strong
decrease when adjusting fertilization to crop needs in the BMP
scenario, as well as in the remaining scenarios (Figure 5). After EXCH scenario, N chemical fertilizer remains low, since
organic fertilization is privileged through preference coefficients. April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 9 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. FIGURE 5 | Nitrogen flows from FAN scenarios output, in Mega-grams of N per year. N inputs to the system are on the left and N outputs (crop uptake and losses) on
the right. Scenarios names follow those in Figure 3 and Table 2. FIGURE 5 | Nitrogen flows from FAN scenarios output, in Mega-grams of N per year. N inputs to the system are on the left and N
the right. Scenarios names follow those in Figure 3 and Table 2. FIGURE 6 | N indicators from FAN scenario outputs, expressed as a
percentage of total N. “N orgapplied%” accounts for all organic sources of N
added to soils, whereas “N orgexchanged%,” takes into account only the part of
organic N that is exchanged between two agents before being used for
fertilization, see Equation 1, Equation 2. Scenarios names are in Figure 3 and
Table 2. and indirect emissions remain a small proportion of N in
any scenario, they have a considerable impact on greenhouse
gas emissions. Across the progressive implementation of scenarios, the
relative importance of organic N in total inputs to soils increases
(Figure 6). The fact of adding more N to the system through
the digestion of green biomass and food processing wastes after
the BIGOAS scenario, and the addition of pulses fixing N in C-L
Symb., is important in this process. Still, when mineral fertilizers
are an option for farms, its use reaches at least half of the total N
inputs to soils. In scenarios where N organic fertilization is the
only option (i.e., Max. Circularity), the total N available in the
district is inadequate to satisfy total crop N demand plus losses to
the environment, therefore limiting crop yields. Greenhouse Gas Emissions Greenhouse Gas Emissions
FAN simulations results show that GHG from on- and off-
site emissions (in CO2−eq.) decrease substantially from BAU
to the final scenario (Figure 7). The BMP and ECH scenario
substantially reduce the GHG emissions by lowering chemical
fertilizer use and the emissions associated with their synthesis
and losses after application (N2O). In BIOGAS, anaerobic
digesters help to reduce most of CH4 emissions from manure
storage, significantly improving the balance, despite higher CO2
emission from truck transportation. The symbiosis of crops and
livestock in C-L Symb through manure recycling for fertilization
as well as local feed sources exhibit lower greenhouse gas
emissions than previous scenarios, thanks to the elimination of
imported feed. The larger GHG emissions sources were from
livestock and N management, in particular CH4 produced by
both enteric fermentation and manure storage and N2O from
fertilizer application. These emissions are substantially reduced FIGURE 6 | N indicators from FAN scenario outputs, expressed as a
percentage of total N. “N orgapplied%” accounts for all organic sources of N
added to soils, whereas “N orgexchanged%,” takes into account only the part of
organic N that is exchanged between two agents before being used for
fertilization, see Equation 1, Equation 2. Scenarios names are in Figure 3 and
Table 2. manure storage and fertilizers application) increase considerably
when anaerobic digestion is applied, due to higher ammonia
emissions, approaching one third of total N applied to soils (Ni
et al., 2012), but they are reduced according to lower organic
inputs when reducing livestock. Finally, although N2O direct Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 10 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. FIGURE 7 | Emissions from on- and off-site emissions (positive) and C stored expressed as CO2 avoided (negative), from FAN scenario outputs (in kg of
CO2-equivalence per year). Scenarios names are in Figure 3 and Table 2. FIGURE 7 | Emissions from on- and off-site emissions (positive) and C stored expressed as CO2 avoided (negative), from FAN scenario outputs (in kg of
CO2-equivalence per year). Scenarios names are in Figure 3 and Table 2. a lack of N local inputs, as shown in Figure 5. Therefore, crops
with high N needs (i.e., cereals, oilseeds, fruits and vegetables)
decreased their production to around half of their initial values. Livestock Production Results showed that livestock production (Figure S4) remains
constant until scenarios where livestock populations are halved
(C-L Symb. + L/2; Max. Circularity + L/2). In these final
two scenarios, pig and poultry production are reduced to
half of the value observed in the baseline scenarios. However,
livestock reduction does not affect ruminant meat production
in the same way because these ruminants benefit from
a higher forage availability that, in turn, increases animal
productivity for both milk and meat. Therefore, we observed
an interesting compensation for meat production from beef
in C-L Symb. + L/2 and Max. Circularity + L/2 scenarios. Greenhouse Gas Emissions Yet, pulses and grass were not affected since they are not
fertilized with chemical sources in FAN, assuming that there
is enough N through biological fixation. Cereal production
decreased in Crop-Livestock Symbiosis scenarios (C-L Symb)
when incorporating more pulses in crop rotations at the expense
of cereals, but cereals increased in the scenario reducing livestock
(C-L Symb. + L/2) replacing silage maize, which is no longer
necessary to feed fewer livestock. Although pulse production
increased when integrating crops and livestock (C-L Symb), there
are no changes in grass and legume forage areas as there is
enough of these products to meet animal forage requirements in
the district. when reducing livestock and removing chemical fertilizers at
the same time. Eliminating chemical fertilizer is more efficient
than reducing livestock, therefore Max. Circularity performs
better than C-L Symb+ L/2 where N application to arable land
increased. Finally, C storage by grasslands plays an important role
in mitigating the CO2 balance by compensating for CH4 enteric
fermentation emissions. Surprisingly, the Max. Circularity + L/2
scenario presented a remarkably low net C balance, estimated at
about 12.8 Gg of CO2 eq. per year. When comparing CO2 emissions to food produced in
terms of calories and protein, the progressive pattern across
the scenarios is maintained (Figure S2). Initially, emissions
are reduced in BMP by reducing N losses and some feed
imports. Then, anaerobic digestion implementation in EXCH
and BIOGAS scenario also presents a difference with previous
scenarios in terms of efficiency, even though there is higher
truck transportation for transporting materials. Surprisingly,
we observed that just removing chemical N fertilizer is more
efficient than just reducing livestock on GHG mitigation
potential. Finally, the Max. Circularity + L/2 scenario exhibited a
considerably lower GHG budget. Feed and Forage Balance Reducing local dependency on external feed and forage was
possible by better integrating crop and livestock production
at the farm scale, by applying changes in the crop rotations
to fulfill livestock district requirements and eventually by
reducing livestock population at the district scale. Results
show that cereals and oilseeds were always in surplus after
feeding animals in the district (Figure S5). However, their
production decreased in scenarios with crop-livestock symbiosis
due to the competition for land with pulses, and also in
scenarios without chemical fertilizers due to depression of
crop yields with limited N inputs to soils. On the contrary,
cereal balance increased in scenarios with reduced livestock
population when silage maize was replaced by cereals. Feed
by-products exhibited a small deficit when anaerobic digestion
was implemented due to the competition induced by biogas
plants for these materials. Pulse deficit was reduced through
the crop-livestock integration by adding more pulses to the
rotations in the C-L Symb. scenario, which increased the
circularity of the system and autonomy. Concerning forage,
results show that after local exchanges, exchanges inside farms in
Ribéracois always satisfied the minimum livestock requirements. In addition, forage was much more available (even without
silage maize) in scenarios with reduced livestock population,
potentially explaining the higher beef cattle productivity
mentioned earlier. Relative Score Multi-Criteria Assessment
We first analyze the relative score of the scenarios across each of
the indicators (Figure S7), which is detailed below: • Crop production: while crop production did not vary across
the first four scenarios that did not involve modifying farm
land-use, some scenarios strongly impacted crop yields, in
particular when chemical fertilizers are eliminated (Max. Circularity), which was exacerbated by livestock reduction
(Max. Circularity + L/2). • Crop production: while crop production did not vary across
the first four scenarios that did not involve modifying farm
land-use, some scenarios strongly impacted crop yields, in
particular when chemical fertilizers are eliminated (Max. Circularity), which was exacerbated by livestock reduction
(Max. Circularity + L/2). y
• Livestock production: animal production remained constant
across all the initial scenarios, even without chemical
fertilizers, until the scenarios where livestock population was
halved on farms. • Bioenergy production: energy production is maximized in
the BIOGAS scenario. Nevertheless, since manure is they
main component of the anaerobic digestion feedstock, FIGURE 8 | Cumulated relative score in food production and circularity indicators of the scenarios. Bioenergy Production Note that even if crop production is lower in the scenario
without chemical fertilizers, FAN assumes that livestock in
Ribéracois are fed in priority to crop food transformation,
and when needed, by importing external feed and forage to
meet animal minimum requirements (Fernandez-Mena et al.,
2019). Bioenergy Production
FAN estimates the total capacity of anaerobic digesters at
225,210 tons of substrate for digestion in the BIOGAS scenario
(Figure S6). This capacity dropped to half when livestock
population is reduced due to lower manure availability, which
is the limiting factor of digestible biomass in our simulations. Biogas production was over 9,042,148 m3 in the BIOGAS scenario
and decreased to half of that value when reducing livestock
population. The biogas produced in the BIOGAS scenario
corresponded to 18.4 GWh of electricity, without taking into
account the associated heat production. Considering an annual
electricity consumption of 4,679 kWh per household in France,
bioenergy production in the Ribéracois could satisfy the demands
of 3,942 households, which represents almost one third of the
Ribéracois’ total human population. Crop Production Simulation results showed that crop production was unaffected
in the first four scenarios (Figure S3), because no changes were
applied to land use or fertilizer availability. However, N uptake
in crops is reduced in scenarios with no chemical fertilizer (Max. Circularity), especially when reducing livestock (+ L/2), due to April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 11 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. Feed and Forage Balance Although it decreased when livestock is reduced C-L Symb. + 1/2, it reached its maximum in both scenarios without
chemical fertilizers. • GHG mitigation: progressively improved from the base-line
situation to the last scenario (Max. Circularity + L/2) that
presented the best GHG balance (detailed further in this
section), except for the C-L Symb. + 1/2. System redesign in the Max. Circularity scenarios illustrate
the impact that fundamentally rethinking our agro-food systems
could have for enhancing circularity and therefore minimizing
the environmental impacts of farming. Nevertheless, some of
these scenarios were considerably less productive not only for
crop and livestock production but also for bioenergy. Important
tradeoffs arose when decreasing livestock and removing chemical
fertilizers, highlighting the importance of organic fertilization
from livestock manure for the development of a circular
agriculture. The trade-offs for organic management would be
even more pronounced in farming regions specialized in crop
production but may be lower in regions with high livestock
densities. In our simulations, the livestock density in Ribéracois
measured in Livestock Units (LU) after Eurostat (2013), was, on
average, 0.62 LU/ha, slightly lower than the European average of
0.8 LU/ha for 2016 (Eurostat, 2019). The cumulated relative scores are a useful approach for
comparing the performance across different scenarios (Figure 8). The baseline score in the BAU scenario had a relatively high
ranking for both crop and livestock and performed relatively
well in feed autonomy based on the relatively low livestock
density, and relatively high grass-fed rations currently present
in the Ribéracois. Scores increased progressively with the
implementation of interventional scenarios, both through farm
efficiency changes in BMP and collective solutions through
farm network changes in EXCH and BIOGAS scenarios. The
improvements of these three scenarios mainly concern nutrient
management practices and recycling flows that helped to
increase the N cycle coupling and reduce GHG emissions by
increasing the number of flows in the network. In addition,
BIOGAS produced the maximum bioenergy extractable from
farming wastes. The crop-livestock symbiosis implemented in C-
L Symb. by locally filling feed deficits (in this case for pulses)
helped to increase feed autonomy and also provided GHG
mitigation (linked to reduction on external feed). The Max. Circularity scenario obtained a similar score as in C-L Symb.,
thanks to a strong GHG mitigation potential, even though
crop production decreased. Feed and Forage Balance Scenarios names are presented in Figure 3 and Table 2. ive score in food production and circularity indicators of the scenarios. Scenarios names are presented in Figure 3 and Table 2. April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 12 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. bioenergy production is substantially reduced when livestock
populations are halved. More precisely, material exchanges in FAN are quantified and
have a direct geographic dimension (including truck distance
transportation and other spatial components of the farm
network). The crop, livestock, and bioenergy submodels are
particularly useful to estimate food and energy production. In
addition, the GHG balance, the N balance and the number
of flows provide relatively straightforward indicators of the
potential environmental outcomes of increased circularity at the
regional scale. • Feed and forage autonomy: livestock in the Ribéracois are not
particularly dense on the landscape and therefore local forage
typically satisfies local livestock demand. However, changes
in the crop rotations helped to fulfill livestock requirements
in terms of pulses, that are currently imported, as it was
implemented in the C-L Symb. scenario and those afterwards. • Number of local flows (degree of cooperation): these are
substantially increased in the EXCH scenario, facilitating
material exchanges across the study area. It reaches its
maximum in the BIOGAS scenario. However, the number of
flows was reduced in scenarios where livestock populations
are halved. Although the BMP scenario was very effective at reducing
N losses at the farm scale, we observed that scenarios
involving more material exchanges (i.e., EXCH, BIOGAS and C-
L Symb) proved to be a good compromise for increasing the
circularity of the system through the coordination of agents
without radically modifying farming systems. Actually, only
relatively small land-use changes via pulse crop introductions
were necessary to connect crop and livestock in symbiosis
(C-L Symb) in Ribéracois. Although local feed rations were
approached based on the average in France and assumed to be
optimized to meet livestock nutrition requirements, their global
impact could be improved by substituting cereals and silage
by grass and food wastes in a “low-cost livestock approach”
(Van Zanten et al., 2018). • N cycle closing: it increased progressively in the scenarios
through fertilization and feeding rations adjustment and
recycling by maximizing exchanges, introducing food industry
wastes and locally producing legumes for animal feeding. Feed and Forage Balance Even though GHG mitigation was
improved when combined reducing livestock populations and
eliminating chemical fertilizers, the redesign scenarios performed
better without reducing livestock as animals helped to sustain
crop production and bioenergy. The application of our scenarios in Ribéracois may be
discussed in terms of feasibility and facilitation. Despite the
insights provided by our analysis, a key limitation is that no
economic cost calculations are implemented, in part due to the
fact that monetary values could change depending on public
subsidies, such as those existing for biogas production in many
countries (Börjesson and Ahlgren, 2012; Sun et al., 2014; Appel
et al., 2016). In FAN simulations, however, economic data
is implicit in the mechanisms underlying the exchanges even
though there is no actual cost analysis, as discussed in more
detail by Fernandez-Mena et al. (2019). We assumed that for
implementing these practices and innovations famers will need
support by public and engagement of private institutions. We proposed several system circularity indicators that are
easy to calculate through the application of a N balance, a C
balance, a feed and forage balance and a count of number of
flows. Indicators present limitations since several assumptions
were made, in particular for N and C cycle. For instance, once
losses were subtracted, all N was assumed to be available for Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 CONCLUSIONS crops and all catch-crops were assumed to performed identically. In the C balance, some emissions factors could be more precise
to soils and materials, in particular for digestates volatilization. Avoided emissions by biogas production in France were quite
low since nuclear power is the main source of electricity and
would be around four times greater if references for Europe
were considered instead (European Environment Agency, 2018). In addition, the average of C net sequestration in European
grasslands is a discussed value that may vary among grasslands
(Chang et al., 2017; Conant et al., 2017) and was assumed
to be performed identically in scenarios where livestock were
reduced. Finally, we calculated a relative score from these
indicators that facilitated the comparison of scenarios and the
understanding of their trade-offs. Nonetheless, this score was
relative to the performance among the current scenarios and was
cumulated considering that all scores counted the same, although
production indicators may be considered to be more important. In this study, we applied a network approach using FAN to
examine system-wide outcomes of multiple types of scenarios
with
varying
degrees
of
system
transformation. Overall,
we verified our hypotheses that circularity and therefore
environmental performance can be improved along a gradient of
scenarios requiring progressive management interventions. Our
analysis provides a “proof of concept” for the implementation of
circular scenarios in a French agro-food system, giving an insight
based on multiple system components and indicators regarding
how different sustainability solutions across a farming region
could result in very different outcomes. Simulations from agent-
based models like FAN could in turn help to inform the design
of agricultural and environmental policies and regulations,
particularly those that seek to bring about more fundamental
changes in circular agro-food systems. p
y
p
A first step toward circularity will involve efforts on farmer
individual behavior toward a more efficient nutrient management
at the farm scale by choosing local materials, reasoning
fertilization and feeding ratios and using catch crops. For that,
farmers may be supported by independent agronomists and
monitored by regulations penalizing nutrients overuse. Recycling
for fertilization, bioenergy and local animal feeding need an
important collective coordination. This coordination could be
supported by the private farming sector either through collective
engagements in groups, or by individuals connected through
new digital technologies. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This study was part of HF-M doctoral dissertation at University
of Bordeaux (Fernandez-Mena, 2017b). The work was funded
by Bordeaux Sciences Agro (University of Bordeaux) and INRA
(currently INRAE), Division of Environment and Agronomy. HF-M received financial support from Labex COTE (University
of Bordeaux, France) and Agreenium consortium. The data about
farming systems were collected thanks to the French National
Research Agency (ANR) as part of the Investissements d’avenir
program (reference: ANR-10-EQPX-17—Center d’accès sécurisé
aux données—CASD). CONCLUSIONS Open source and private initiatives
could focus on geo-locating farms on the landscape, informing
their material needs and facilitating better communication
among other farmers seeking to meet different types of material
requirements. On top of that, biogas production through
anaerobic digestion requires specific knowledge and important
capital investment in equipment that may be supported by
public subsidies and technical assistance. The leverages that
substantially increased circularity were also those requiring
the most fundamental farm transformations, i.e., livestock
reduction and chemical fertilizers elimination. Nevertheless,
both scenarios together present important tradeoffs for overall
agro-food system productivity. Paradoxically, current food
consumption tendencies in western countries may encourage
these two opposed levers (Seconda et al., 2017; Christensen
and Denver, 2018), either by eliminating animal proteins in
diets or by promoting organic farm management. Larger-scale
simulations may take into account human diets to more fully
explore the compromises involved between changes in livestock
populations and availability of organic fertility management
in croplands. DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT The FAN model and the Ribéracois datasets used in this study are
available on Fernandez-Mena (2017a). Complementary data are
available in request to the corresponding author. SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL The Supplementary Material for this article can be found
online
at:
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fsufs. 2020.00041/full#supplementary-material AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS SP,
TN,
and
GM
were
co-supervisors
of
HF-M
Ph.D. project. They were listed according to their participation on
this article. DISCUSSION We demonstrate how the FAN model can be applied as a
useful tool for simulating exchanges and for anticipating co-
benefits or unintended consequences under different scenarios. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 13 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. ADEME (2013). Bilan National des Projets Biogaz. Réalisé par J. Thual. Consulted
on 1/03/2017. Available online at: https://www.ademe.fr/sites/default/files/
assets/documents/bilan__national__methani~sation.pdf
ADEME (2017). Base Carbone ADEME. Version 2.17.0. Available online at: http://
www.bilans-ges.ademe.fr/
Agreste (2013). Recensement Agricole 2010. Available online at: http://agreste.
agriculture.gouv.fr/page-d-accueil/article/agreste-donnees-en-ligne (accessed
April 28, 2019). REFERENCES (2017b). Modelling biomass and nutrient flows in agro-food
systems at the local scale: scenario simulation and assessment in a French
case-study (Ph.D. thesis). University of Bordeaux, Bordeaux, France. Billen, G., Le Noë, J., and Garnier, J. (2018). Two contrasted future scenarios
for the French agro-food system. Sci. Total Environ. 637, 695–705. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.05.043 Fernandez-Mena, H., Gaudou, B., Pellerin, S., MacDonald, G. K., and
Nesme, T. (2019). Flows in Agro-food Networks (FAN): An agent-based
model to simulate local agricultural material flows. Agric. Syst. 102718. doi: 10.1016/j.agsy.2019.102718 Bonaudo, T., Bendahan, A. B., Sabatier, R., Ryschawy, J., Bellon, S., Leger, F., et al. (2014). Agroecological principles for the redesign of integrated crop–livestock
systems. Eur. J. Agron. 57, 43–51. doi: 10.1016/j.eja.2013.09.010 Fernandez-Mena, H., Nesme, T., and Pellerin, S. (2016). Towards an Agro-
Industrial Ecology: a review of nutrient flow modelling and assessment tools
in agro-food systems at the local scale. Sci. Total Environ. 543, 467–479. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2015.11.032 Börjesson, M., and Ahlgren, E. O. (2012). Cost-effective biogas utilisation–A
modelling assessment of gas infrastructural options in a regional energy system. Energy 48, 212–226. doi: 10.1016/j.energy.2012.06.058 Bouwman, A., Beusen, A., Lassaletta, L., Van Apeldoorn, D., Van Grinsven, H., and
Zhang, J. (2017). Lessons from temporal and spatial patterns in global use of N
and P fertilizer on cropland. Sci. Rep. 7:40366. doi: 10.1038/srep40366 j
Foley, J. A., Ramankutty, N., Brauman, K. A., Cassidy, E. S., Gerber, J. S., Johnston,
M., et al. (2011). Solutions for a cultivated planet. Nature 478, 337–342. doi: 10.1038/nature10452 Campbell, B. M., Beare, D. J., Bennett, E. M., Hall-Spencer, J. M., Ingram,
J. S., Jaramillo, F., et al. (2017). Agriculture production as a major
driver of the Earth system exceeding planetary boundaries. Ecol. Soc. 22. doi: 10.5751/ES-09595-220408 Garcia, M. (2016). Analyse de flux de matières et de nutriments entre les fermes et ses
partenaires dans deux cas d’études en France: le Ribéracois et les Vosges. Mémoire
fin d’études (ENSAT Toulouse), réalisé à l’INRA de Bordeaux-Aquitaine. Carlson, K. M., Gerber, J. S., Mueller, N. D., Herrero, M., MacDonald, G. K.,
Brauman, K. A., et al. (2016). Greenhouse gas emissions intensity of global
croplands. Nat. Clim. Change. 7, 63–68. doi: 10.1038/nclimate3158 Gaube, V., Kaiser, C., Wildenberg, M., Adensam, H., Fleissner, P., Kobler, J.,
et al. (2009). Combining agent-based and stock-flow modelling approaches in
a participative analysis of the integrated land system in Reichraming, Austria. Landsc. Ecol. 24, 1149–1165. REFERENCES Acosta-Alba, I., Lopéz-Ridaura, S., van der Werf, H. M. G., Leterme,
P.,
and
Corson,
M. S. (2012). Exploring
sustainable
farming
scenarios
at
a
regional
scale:
an
application
to
dairy
farms
in
Brittany. Work. More
Sustain. Agri-Food
Ind. Main
Find. Food
LCA
2010
Conf. Bari
Italy
28,
160–167. doi:
10.1016/j.jclepro.2011. 11.061 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 14 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. Agreste (2014). Analyse de Résultats de l’enquête Pratiques Culturales Grandes
Cultures et Prairies 2011. Available online at: http://46.29.123.56/IMG/pdf/
dossier21_fertilisation.pdf (accessed May 05, 2017 ). Edouard, N., Hassouna, M., Robin, P., and Faverdin, P. (2016). Low degradable
protein supply to increase nitrogen efficiency in lactating dairy cows
and reduce environmental impacts at barn level. Animal 10, 212–220. doi: 10.1017/S1751731115002050 Alonso-Betanzos, A., Sánchez-Maroño, N., Fontenla-Romero, O., Polhill, J. G.,
Craig, T., Pérez, J. B., et al. (2017). Agent-Based Modeling of Sustainable
Behaviors. Cham: Springer. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-46331-5 El-Chichakli, B., von Braun, J., Lang, C., Barben, D., and Philp, J. (2016). Five
cornerstones
of
a
global
bioeconomy. Nature
535,
221–223. doi: 10.1038/535221a Appel, F., Ostermeyer-Wiethaup, A., and Balmann, A. (2016). Effects of the
german renewable energy act on structural change in agriculture–the case of
biogas. Util. Policy 41, 172–182. doi: 10.1016/j.jup.2016.02.013 European Environment Agency (2018). Overview of Electricity Production and Use
in Europe. Eurostat (2013). Glossary: Livestock Unit (LSU). Consulted on 5/10/2019. Avadí, A., Nitschelm, L., Corson, M., and Vertès, F. (2016). Data strategy
for
environmental
assessment
of
agricultural
regions
via
LCA:
case
study of a French catchment. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 21, 476–491. doi: 10.1007/s11367-016-1036-6 Eurostat (2019). Agri-Environmental Indicator - Livestock Patterns. Consulted
on 5/10/2019. Fan, W., Dong, X., Wei, H., Weng, B., Liang, L., Xu, Z., et al. (2018). Is it true that
the longer the extended industrial chain, the better the circular agriculture? A
case study of circular agriculture industry company in Fuqing, Fujian. J. Clean. Prod. 189, 718–728. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2018.04.119 Baumgart-Getz, A., Prokopy, L. S., and Floress, K. (2012). Why farmers adopt
best management practice in the United States: a meta-analysis of the adoption
literature. J. Environ. Manage. 96, 17–25. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2011.10.006 j j
Fernandez-Mena, H. (2017a). “FAN Model Dataset”, Mendeley Data, v1. Available
online at: http://dx.doi.org/10.17632/sytdc5yscj.1 Bichraoui, N., Guillaume, B., and Halog, A. (2013). Agent-based modelling
simulation for the development of an industrial symbiosis-preliminary results. Procedia Environ. Sci. 17, 195–204. doi: 10.1016/j.proenv.2013.02.029 Fernandez-Mena, H. REFERENCES doi: 10.1007/s10980-009-9356-6 Chang, J., Ciais, P., Viovy, N., Soussana, J.-F., Klumpp, K., and Sultan, B. (2017). Future productivity and phenology changes in European grasslands for
different warming levels: implications for grassland management and carbon
balance. Carbon Balance Manag. 12, 11. doi: 10.1186/s13021-017-0079-8 Giller, K. E., Tittonell, P., Rufino, M. C., van Wijk, M. T., Zingore, S., Mapfumo,
P., et al. (2011). Communicating complexity: Integrated assessment of trade-
offs concerning soil fertility management within African farming systems to
support innovation and development. Methods Tools Integr. Assess. Sustain. Chang, J., Ciais, P., Viovy, N., Vuichard, N., Herrero, M., Havlík, P., et al. (2016). Effect of climate change, CO2 trends, nitrogen addition, and land-cover and
management intensity changes on the carbon balance of European grasslands. Glob. Change Biol. 22, 338–350. doi: 10.1111/gcb.13050 Agric. Syst. Land Use 104, 191–203. doi: 10.1016/j.agsy.2010.07.002 Giuliano, S., Ryan, M. R., Véricel, G., Rametti, G., Perdrieux, F., Justes, E.,
et al. (2016). Low-input cropping systems to reduce input dependency and
environmental impacts in maize production: a multi-criteria assessment. Eur. J. Agron. 76, 160–175. doi: 10.1016/j.eja.2015.12.016 Christensen, T., and Denver, S. (2018). “Do Danish consumers prefer an
organic vegetarian meal or a non-organic meaty alternative? Evidence from
a choice experiment,” in Paper at: International Food Marketing Research
Symposium (Bournemouth). Golembiewski, B., Sick, N., and Bröring, S. (2015). The emerging research
landscape on bioeconomy: What has been done so far and what is essential
from a technology and innovation management perspective? Innov. Food Sci. Emerg. Technol. 29, 308–317. doi: 10.1016/j.ifset.2015.03.006 Cobo, S., Levis, J. W., Dominguez-Ramos, A., and Irabien, A. (2019). Economics of
enhancing nutrient circularity in an organic waste valorization system. Environ. Sci. Technol. 53, 6123–32. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.8b06035 Grillot, M., Vayssières, J., and Masse, D. (2018). Agent-based modelling
as a time machine to assess nutrient cycling reorganization during
past
agrarian
transitions
in
West
Africa. Agric. Syst. 164,
133–151. doi: 10.1016/j.agsy.2018.04.008 Conant, R. T., Cerri, C. E., Osborne, B. B., and Paustian, K. (2017). Grassland
management impacts on soil carbon stocks: a new synthesis. Ecol. Appl. 27,
662–668. doi: 10.1002/eap.1473 Davis, S. C., Kauneckis, D., Kruse, N. A., Miller, K. E., Zimmer, M., and
Dabelko, G. D. (2016). Closing the loop: integrative systems management
of waste in food, energy, and water systems. J. Environ. Stud. Sci. 6, 11–24. doi: 10.1007/s13412-016-0370-0 Groupe Régionale d’Expertise Nitrates (GREN) (2016). de la Nouvelle-Aquitaine. Available online at: http://www.nouvelle-aquitaine.developpement-durable. gouv.fr/le-groupe-regional-d-expertise-nitrates-gren-a1768.html
(accessed
April 10, 2018). REFERENCES Hénin, S., and Dupuis, M. (1945). Essai de bilan de la matière organique du sol,
Dudod. ed. de Boer, I. J., and van Ittersum, M. K. (2018). Circularity in Agricultural Production. Wageningen: Wageningen University & Research. I.P.C.C. (2006). IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories,
Prepared by the National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme, Eggleston. Hayama: IGES. Devun, J., and Guinot, C. (2012). Alimentation des bovins: rations Moyennes et
Autonomie Alimentaire. Collection Résultats. CR 0, 005. DREAL (2016). Quelles sont les zones vulnérables en Nouvelle-Aquitaine? Available online at: http://www.nouvelle-aquitaine.developpement-durable. gouv.fr/quelles-sont-les-zones-vulnerables-en-nouvelle-a1766.html (accessed
October 10, 2017). Lamine, C. (2011). Transition pathways towards a robust ecologization of
agriculture and the need for system redesign. Cases from organic farming and
IPM. J. Rural Stud. 27, 209–219. doi: 10.1016/j.jrurstud.2011.02.001 April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 15 Agro-Food System Redesign for Circularity Fernandez-Mena et al. Lassaletta, L., Billen, G., Grizzetti, B., Garnier, J., Leach, A. M., and Galloway, J. N. (2014). Food and feed trade as a driver in the global nitrogen cycle: 50-year
trends. Biogeochemistry 118, 225–241. doi: 10.1007/s10533-013-9923-4 multi-criteria assessment tool derived from DEXi. Ecol. Indic. 18, 171–182. doi: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2011.11.019 multi-criteria assessment tool derived from DEXi. Ecol. Indic. 18, 171–182. doi: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2011.11.019 Prado, A. D., Mas, K., Pardo, G., and Gallejones, P. (2013). Modelling the
interactions between C and N farm balances and GHG emissions from
confinement dairy farms in northern Spain. Sci. Total Environ. 465, 156–165. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2013.03.064 Le Noë, J., Billen, G., and Garnier, J. (2017). How the structure of agro-food
systems shapes nitrogen, phosphorus, and carbon fluxes: The generalized
representation of agro-food system applied at the regional scale in France. Sci. Total Environ. 586, 42–55. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.02.040 Seconda, L., Baudry, J., Allès, B., Hamza, O., Boizot-Szantai, C., Soler, L.-G., et al. (2017). Assessment of the sustainability of the Mediterranean diet combined
with organic food consumption: an individual behaviour approach. Nutrients
9:61. doi: 10.3390/nu9010061 Leip, A., Billen, G., Garnier, J., Grizzetti, B., Lassaletta, L., Reis, S., et al. (2015). Impacts of European livestock production: nitrogen, sulphur,
phosphorus and greenhouse gas emissions, land-use, water eutrophication
and biodiversity. Environ. Res. Lett. 10:115004. doi: 10.1088/1748-9326/10/11/1
15004 Sun, D., Bai, J., Qiu, H., and Cai, Y. (2014). Impact of government subsidies
on household biogas use in rural China. Energy Policy 73, 748–756. doi: 10.1016/j.enpol.2014.06.009 Lemaire, G., Franzluebbers, A., de Faccio Carvalho, P. C., and Dedieu, B. (2014). REFERENCES Integrated crop–livestock systems: strategies to achieve synergy between
agricultural production and environmental quality. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 190,
4–8. doi: 10.1016/j.agee.2013.08.009 Tilman, D., and Clark, M. (2014). Global diets link environmental sustainability
and human health. Nature 515, 518–522. doi: 10.1038/nature13959 Tittonell, P., Van Wijk, M., Herrero, M., Rufino, M., de Ridder, N., and Giller,
K. (2009). Beyond resource constraints–Exploring the biophysical feasibility of
options for the intensification of smallholder crop-livestock systems in Vihiga
district, Kenya. Agric. Syst. 101, 1–19. doi: 10.1016/j.agsy.2009.02.003 Manlay, R. J., Chotte, J.-L., Masse, D., Laurent, J.-Y., and Feller, C. (2002). Carbon,
nitrogen and phosphorus allocation in agro-ecosystems of a West African
savanna: III. Plant and soil components under continuous cultivation. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 88, 249–269. doi: 10.1016/S0167-8809(01)00220-1 cosyst. Environ. 88, 249–269. doi: 10.1016/S0167-8809(01)00220-1 Tomich, T. P., and Scow, K. M. (2016). The California Nitrogen Assessment:
Challenges and Solutions for People, Agriculture, and the Environment. Oakland,
CA: University of California Press. Mao, C., Feng, Y., Wang, X., and Ren, G. (2015). Review on research achievements
of biogas from anaerobic digestion. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 45, 540–555. doi: 10.1016/j.rser.2015.02.032 Toop, T. A., Ward, S., Oldfield, T., Hull, M., Kirby, M. E., and Theodorou, M. K. (2017). AgroCycle–developing a circular economy in agriculture. Energy
Procedia 123, 76–80. doi: 10.1016/j.egypro.2017.07.269 Marchand, F., Debruyne, L., Triste, L., Gerrard, C., Padel, S., and Lauwers, L. (2014). Key characteristics for tool choice in indicator-based sustainability
assessment
at
farm
level. Ecol. Soc. 19:46. doi:
10.5751/ES-06876-
190346 Tseng, M.-L., Chiu, A. S., Chien, C.-F., and Tan, R. R. (2019). Pathways and
barriers to circularity in food systems. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 143, 236–237. doi: 10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.01.015 Matthews, R. B., Gilbert, N. G., Roach, A., Polhill, J. G., and Gotts, N. M. (2007). Agent-based land-use models: a review of applications. Landsc. Ecol. 22, 1447–1459. doi: 10.1007/s10980-007-9135-1 Valkama, E., Lemola, R., Känkänen, H., and Turtola, E. (2016). “Catch crops as
universal and effective method for reducing nitrogen leaching loss in spring
cereal production: a meta-analysis,” in Presented at the EGU General Assembly
Conference Abstracts, 1934. Metson, G. S., MacDonald, G. K., Haberman, D., Nesme, T., and Bennett, E. M. (2016). Feeding the corn belt: opportunities for phosphorus recycling in US
agriculture. Sci Total Env. 542, 1117–1126. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2015.08.047 Van Zanten, H. H., Herrero, M., Van Hal, O., Röös, E., Muller, A., Garnett, T., et al. (2018). Defining a land boundary for sustainable livestock consumption. Glob. Change Biol. 24, 4185–4194. REFERENCES doi: 10.1111/gcb.14321 Mitchell, M., Bennett, E., Gonzalez, A., Lechowicz, M., Rhemtulla, J., Cardille,
J., et al. (2015). The Montérégie Connection: linking landscapes, biodiversity,
and ecosystem services to improve decision making. Ecol. Soc. 20:15. doi: 10.5751/ES-07927-200415 Vega-Quezada, C., Blanco, M., and Romero, H. (2017). Synergies between
agriculture and bioenergy in Latin American countries: a circular economy
strategy for bioenergy production in Ecuador. New Biotechnol. 39, 81–89. doi: 10.1016/j.nbt.2016.06.730 Moraine,
M.,
Duru,
M.,
and
Therond,
O. (2017a). A
social-ecological
framework for analyzing and designing integrated crop–livestock systems
from
farm
to
territory
levels. Renew. Agric. Food
Syst. 32,
43–56. doi: 10.1017/S1742170515000526 Wery, J., Affholder, F., Belhouchette, H., Bergez, J.-E., Blazy, J. M., and Thérond,
O. (2018). Farm-Centered Integrated Modelling for the Design of Sustainable
Agricultural Systems. Pl-I-01. Agroscope. Moraine, M., Mélac, P., Ryschawy, J., Duru, M., and Therond, O. (2017b). A participatory method for the design and integrated assessment of
crop-livestock
systems
in
farmers’
groups. Ecol. Indic. 72,
340–351. doi: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.08.012 Wezel, A., Casagrande, M., Celette, F., Vian, J.-F., Ferrer, A., and Peigné, J. (2014). Agroecological practices for sustainable agriculture. A review. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 34, 1–20. doi: 10.1007/s13593-013-0180-7 ,
,
g
,
,
,
,
, J
,
,
,
g
, J (
)
Agroecological practices for sustainable agriculture. A review. Agron. Sustain. Dev. 34, 1–20. doi: 10.1007/s13593-013-0180-7 Ni, K., Pacholski, A., Gericke, D., and Kage, H. (2012). Analysis of ammonia losses
after field application of biogas slurries by an empirical model. J. Plant Nutr. Soil Sci. 175, 253–264. doi: 10.1002/jpln.201000358 Conflict of Interest: The authors declare that the research was conducted in the
absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a
potential conflict of interest. Nowak, B., Nesme, T., David, C., and Pellerin, S. (2015). Nutrient recycling
in organic farming is related to diversity in farm types at the local
level. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 204,
17–26. doi:
10.1016/j.agee.2015. 02.010 Copyright © 2020 Fernandez-Mena, MacDonald, Pellerin and Nesme. This is an
open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted,
provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the
original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic
practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply
with these terms. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org REFERENCES Pellerin, S., Bamière, L., Angers, D., Béline, F., Benoit, M., Butault, J.-P., et al. (2017). Identifying cost-competitive greenhouse gas mitigation potential of
French agriculture. Environ. Sci. Policy 77, 130–139. Pelzer, E., Fortino, G., Bockstaller, C., Angevin, F., Lamine, C., Moonen, C., et al. (2012). Assessing innovative cropping systems with DEXiPM, a qualitative April 2020 | Volume 4 | Article 41 Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems | www.frontiersin.org 16
|
https://openalex.org/W2802220410
|
https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:0256da7b-2f5d-45f9-ba33-03d53569f5af/files/mcf052ffd13e53457bc03a2e850ca2ed4
|
English
| null |
Better governance, better access: practising responsible data sharing in the METADAC governance infrastructure
|
Human genomics
| 2,018
|
cc-by
| 10,668
|
Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40246-018-0154-6 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40246-018-0154-6 Open Access Better governance, better access: practising
responsible data sharing in the METADAC
governance infrastructure Madeleine J. Murtagh1*, Mwenza T. Blell2, Olly W. Butters1, Lorraine Cowley1, Edward S. Dove3, Alissa Goodman4,
Rebecca L. Griggs5, Alison Hall6, Nina Hallowell7, Meena Kumari8, Massimo Mangino9, Barbara Maughan9,
Melinda C. Mills7, Joel T. Minion1, Tom Murphy4, Gillian Prior10, Matthew Suderman5, Susan M. Ring5,
Nina T. Rogers11, Stephanie J. Roberts1, Catherine Van der Straeten12,13, Will Viney14, Deborah Wiltshire15,
Andrew Wong11, Neil Walker16 and Paul R. Burton1 Abstract Background: Genomic and biosocial research data about individuals is rapidly proliferating, bringing the potential for
novel opportunities for data integration and use. The scale, pace and novelty of these applications raise a number of
urgent sociotechnical, ethical and legal questions, including optimal methods of data storage, management and
access. Although the open science movement advocates unfettered access to research data, many of the UK’s
longitudinal cohort studies operate systems of managed data access, in which access is governed by legal and ethical
agreements between stewards of research datasets and researchers wishing to make use of them. Amongst other
things, these agreements aim to respect the reasonable expectations of the research participants who provided data
and samples, as expressed in the consent process. Arguably, responsible data management and governance of data
and sample use are foundational to the consent process in longitudinal studies and are an important source of
trustworthiness in the eyes of those who contribute data to genomic and biosocial research. Methods: This paper presents an ethnographic case study exploring the foundational principles of a governance
infrastructure for Managing Ethico-social, Technical and Administrative issues in Data ACcess (METADAC), which are
operationalised through a committee known as the METADAC Access Committee. METADAC governs access to
phenotype, genotype and ‘omic’ data and samples from five UK longitudinal studies. Findings: Using the example of METADAC, we argue that three key structural features are foundational for practising
responsible data sharing: independence and transparency; interdisciplinarity; and participant-centric decision-making. We observe that the international research community is proactively working towards optimising the use of research
data, integrating/linking these data with routine data generated by health and social care services and other
administrative data services to improve the analysis, interpretation and utility of these data. The governance of these
new complex data assemblages will require a range of expertise from across a number of domains and disciplines,
including that of study participants. Human-mediated decision-making bodies will be central to ensuring achievable,
reasoned and responsible decisions about the use of these data; the METADAC model described in this paper provides
an example of how this could be realised. Keywords: Data ethics, Data governance, Data access, Data Access Committee (DAC), Governance,
Participant involvement, Ethnography, Qualitative research, Interdisciplinarity * Correspondence: Madeleine.Murtagh@newcastle.ac.uk
1Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article .Murtagh@newcastle.ac.uk
stle upon Tyne, UK
is available at the end of the article
© The Author(s). 2018 Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to
the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver
(http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated. Open science and drivers for data sharing Expectations surrounding how research data should be
shared are based on international commitments to using,
and re-using, publicly funded research and its outputs for
the public good [4]. Data sharing is also supported by re-
search funding agencies internationally through their pol-
icies on open science (https://www.nwo.nl/en/policies/open
+science/data+management,
http://www.allianzinitiative. de/en/archive/research-data/principles.html, [5–10]). Scien-
tific benefits of data sharing are seen to include verification,
replication and the ability to pool analyses, as well as poten-
tial cost savings [9–13]. Some of the drive for shared data
use comes from patients and publics themselves: already,
many rare disease patients advocate for greater sharing of
genomic and clinical data; the quantified-self movement
promotes and facilitates sharing of data from wearables [14,
15]; citizen scientists demand to access clinical and other
randomised controlled trials data and have filed legal claims
to realise those demands [16]. International policy positions
research data and samples as a public good which can only
be fully realised by their wide and appropriate use [17],
though some types of research data such as that generated
by commercial companies (e.g. pharmaceutical companies)
sit outside this definition. Indeed, some have gone even fur-
ther to argue that not sharing research data is a breach of
participant, patient and public rights and is itself a harm
[18]. While the open science movement advocates unfet-
tered access to research practices and the data produced by
them, when those data are individual-level human data, ac-
cess and re-use must be managed within relevant legal and
ethical requirements, taking account of specific agreements
together with the reasonable expectations of the research
participants who provided those data and samples. These
requirements, agreements and expectations are embodied
in the consents that study participants, or their guardians if
they are minors, give at the outset of the study and, often,
for new collections or sub-studies But consent is a process, one which does not finish
with the receipt of information and the signing of a
form. Ethical approval for studies using broad consent
includes mechanisms to ensure that those consents are
respected and the expectations inherent in them are
maintained, for example, explicitly stating which bodies
can approve data and sample access. © The Author(s). 2018 Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to
the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver
(http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated. Page 2 of 12 Page 2 of 12 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Data sharing, longitudinal studies and the consent
process Data sharing, longitudinal studies and the consent
process Genomic and biosocial research data about humans con-
tinue to proliferate, bringing with them questions about
who should be able to store, hold and use which data and
samples, for which purposes and with what safeguards. The research data landscape is changing with new forms
of research data becoming available (e.g. next-generation
sequencing, epigenetic and other ‘omics’ data [1, 2]) and
existing data being increasingly accessible for research (e. g. via linkage of administrative, environmental or health-
care data to research data [3]). This complexity will only
increase as new informatics technologies that enable
citizen-generated
data
(e.g. social
media,
direct-to-
consumer genetic testing and wearable sensors) become
available to combine with research resources in novel ways. To date, the majority of genomic and biosocial research
data made available for sharing in the UK have been de-
rived originally from publicly funded research studies:
longitudinal studies [19–21] (e.g. birth cohorts, house-
hold panel studies, other population and disease-based
biobanks, clinical trials); survey and other social science
datasets; and case-control studies, including case series
collected/generated for research purposes and typically
compared to a research-generated control group (e.g. Wellcome Trust Case Control Consortium [22]). In longitudinal studies, the focus of this paper, it is not
possible to foresee all possible research uses at the out-
set of a study. Data and samples may be used for long
after their collection, sometimes decades afterwards. For
studies whose raison d’etre is the provision of a scientific
resource for which public good is the intended outcome
and impact, renewed consent for each and every new
research use would not only be unwieldy but would
impede that aim. Instead, broad consent (within specific
stipulations reflecting contemporary social values and
scientific practice) are sought for future uses of the data
and samples collected. In the UK, under the Human
Tissue Act 2004 (https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/
2004/30/contents) and Health Research Authority, the
principles and contents of information given to study
participants in consent and participant information
documentation for different forms of data and samples
are prescribed [23, 24]. Open science and drivers for data sharing Appropriate, respon-
sible data management and governance of the uses of
those data and samples are foundational to this ongoing
consent process in longitudinal studies and an important
source of their trustworthiness in the eyes of individuals
who have contributed data and continue to permit its
storage and use. While trust is crucial for ensuring public
support for research generally, for longitudinal studies, this
requirement is particularly acute as ongoing research par-
ticipation is vital to the longevity, productivity and impact
of those studies. Research participants quite reasonably
expect that their privacy (including confidentiality) will be
protected and that uses of the data and samples they con-
tribute will fall within agreed and anticipated parameters. Data Access Committees
While Research Ethics Committees (RECs, also called In-
stitutional Review Boards or Research Ethics Boards) Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Page 3 of 12 Page 3 of 12 interpret the ethical, legal and social frameworks within
which studies are conducted and determine how data and
samples may be used, data access permissions in the UK
are governed by a hierarchy of regulatory processes and
bodies depending on the data’s sensitivity and potential
disclosivity (the ease and precision with which individuals
may be identified). Light-touch administrative processes
manage low-dimensional data with a low risk of disclosure
or other participant harms. Data Access Committees
(DACs) manage more complex or higher-risk data access. Key assessment criteria for determining the release—and
access route—of such data include (1) consistency with
original ethical approval, including consents and informa-
tion materials and the stated aim of the data collection,
and the risk of identification of individual participants; (2)
issues that may directly concern individual participants,
such as the risk of identifying a previously unknown dis-
ease or strong disease determinant which may warrant
clinical action, or the risk of bringing a long-standing
study into disrepute; (3) unreasonably damaging the intel-
lectual property of the project, or otherwise undermining
the effort invested by its investigators or data custodians
(often more than one generation of researchers). rules for legitimate access. These are generally rapid mecha-
nisms for access, notwithstanding any additional time re-
quired for online training upon registration to a data
repository (e.g. UKDA training in data management [24])
or additional administrative processes for managing cost re-
covery. Open science and drivers for data sharing The data released by these mechanisms are those
for which there is deemed to be a low risk of individual dis-
closure and which are considered not to raise additional
ethical issues. Some data will only ever be made available in
secure privacy-protected settings—where researchers travel
to the data location (e.g. secure air-gapped data centres) or
send the analysis to the data (e.g. DataSHIELD) and receive
back only the analytical outcomes [26]. Use of finite re-
sources such as blood, urine or other biological samples will
always require additional oversight for legal (e.g. Human
Tissue Act 2004 requirements), ethical and scientific rea-
sons and because each use of samples necessarily precludes
future uses of those samples and therefore must be judged
more carefully. Classes of research data which are potentially sensitive,
insofar as they are disclosive and/or raise particular ethical
concerns (e.g. incidental/secondary findings), require add-
itional access oversight. Beyond the character of the data
themselves, some research uses of data are also potentially
controversial and may thereby raise ethical issues and po-
tential harms for research participants themselves, or for
the longitudinal studies of which they are a part. Some
types of research are particularly likely to raise issues of po-
tential participant and/or study harms, e.g. those involving
potentially stigmatising issues, such as mental health, sexu-
ality, criminality and certain diseases, or those in which re-
searchers are perceived to make a commercial gain. Particular forms of or combinations of data also raise risks
of disclosure. That individuals can be identified within a
genetic dataset has been demonstrated methodologically
[27, 28], but only where there is a reference sample/se-
quence available [29]. For most practical applications iden-
tification
is
unlikely,
though
this
may
change
with
increasing availability of commercial genotyping. Identifica-
tion of individuals via phenotype data, though less certain
than genetic identification, is easier to enact if large num-
bers or certain classes of variables are combined in analyses
(e.g. place of residence if defined too narrowly, minority
ethnicity, disability, rare disease status) or, as in longitudinal
studies, repeated measures are available. Research questions
which further combine genotypic and phenotypic data and/
or samples may increase the potential for disclosure of indi-
vidual identity. Whether the important issue for disclosure
is one of identifying the individual per se (i.e. Open science and drivers for data sharing that a particu-
lar individual belongs to a longitudinal study) or whether it
is about identifying the individual and information about
them is an empirical question that requires further examin-
ation. Where there are higher risks of disclosure or the
proposed research raises other potential harms, online DACs may consider any risks which may impact the
individual participant or otherwise breach their expecta-
tions, thereby provoking them to withdraw from a study. In addition to the above criteria, some DACs assess the
quality of the science or potential public benefit for all
applications, and nearly all committees assess the quality
and potential benefit of the science when there is a re-
quest for use of a finite resource (e.g. blood samples). Across the research/scientific community in the gen-
omic, health and social sciences, there is a strong con-
sensus that the application of all such criteria (when
applied in a proportionate and transparent manner) is
good for society and ‘good for science’ [25]. Results: the METADAC infrastructure u
:
a
u
u
The METADAC infrastructure hosts a Data Access Com-
mittee (the METADAC Access Committee) governing
access to the complex and sensitive genotypic and pheno-
typic classes of data and biological samples (see Table 1)
generated by five longitudinal studies in the UK [37]: the
National Child Development Study (a.k.a. 1958 Birth Co-
hort) [38], 1970 Birth Cohort Study (BCS70) [39], English
Longitudinal Study of Ageing (ELSA) [40], Millennium
Study [41] and Understanding Society (UK Household
Longitudinal study) [42, 43]. It also acts as an appeals
committee to one other longitudinal study (TwinsUK). METADAC has become the UK’s only independent,
multi-study data and sample access infrastructure for lon-
gitudinal studies. The 3-year METADAC pilot brought to-
gether, under one infrastructure, a number of separate
data and sample access structures. Meetings to review ap-
plications are held at six-weekly intervals, primarily as
teleconferences and twice annually through face-to-face
meetings, when other planning and policy development
workshops also occur. Administratively, the METADAC
Secretariat manages logs and performs a quality audit of
all incoming applications. The Secretariat serves as the
hub for all METADAC communication and interactions
with and between stakeholders. Three key structural
features provide the foundation for practising responsible
data sharing: independence and transparency; interdisci-
plinarity; and participant-centric decision-making. These
features are realised in the access assessment criteria by
which the METADAC Access Committee makes its
decisions (see Table 2). Methods In this paper, we present an ethnographic case study [30]
exploring the foundational principles of one infrastructure
for Managing Ethico-social, Technical and Administrative
issues in Data ACcess (METADAC), i.e. the ethics and pol-
icy oversight of data access. The METADAC infrastructure
(that is, the METADAC Access Committee and associated
work of the pilot project described below) aims to put into
practice the tenets of responsible data sharing [31, 32] and,
in particular, operationalises incorporation of study partici-
pant voices and perspectives in access decision-making. The case study approach allows an in-depth consideration
of a particular instance of practice, or ‘case’. As Stake [33]
describes, the case study is ‘the study of the particularity
and complexity of a single case, coming to understand its
activity within important circumstances’ (p. 6). Case studies
may involve a range of methods, the prime criteria being
those most able to elicit in-depth, rather than summary,
understandings of the object of study; in this case qualita-
tive methods. The analysis in this case study here was in-
formed by a qualitative ethnographic evaluation study
conducted alongside the METADAC pilot. The ethno-
graphic evaluation included observations of METADAC
committee meetings (n = 16) and policy development work-
shops (n = 4) from June 2016 to October 2017. Meetings
were observed by JTM. Twenty-seven interviews were con-
ducted by JTM from March to August 2017 with 18 in-
ternal
METADAC
stakeholders
(committee
members,
funders, study representations, technical review team mem-
bers) and 9 METADAC applicants (from 31 invitations). In-
ternal stakeholders were asked about METADAC processes
and policies. Applicants were asked about their experience
of the application process. Meeting observations and inter-
view transcripts were coded thematically using the constant
comparative approach [34] and following the steps pro-
vided by Braun and Clarke [35] for organising analysis with-
out the imposition of a specific epistemic framework. This
approach involves researchers familiarising themselves with
the data corpus (e.g. the interview data in this study), gener-
ating initial codes and then developing, reviewing and de-
fining themes. Having identified our themes using this
approach, we took a constructivist-interpretivist approach
to interpret the themes, i.e. ‘particular actors, in particular Data access governance in the UK g
In the UK, access to data and samples—the ‘resources’ of
longitudinal and other research studies—is operationalised
by a networked series of independent data repositories and
independent data governance infrastructures, though some
longitudinal studies successfully operate in-house or par-
tially in-house governance and data issue mechanisms. Governance of access permissions (ethics and policy over-
sight) and governance of data issue (technical governance)
may be managed jointly or by separate infrastructures. Each
of these governance infrastructures is designed to ethically,
legally, efficiently and securely manage access (permissions
and/or distribution) to research resources of varied levels of
complexity and sensitivity. For many UK longitudinal stud-
ies, data can be accessed online by bona fide researchers
and are governed by end-user licences. Access decisions
may also be made based on algorithms and straightforward Page 4 of 12 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Page 4 of 12 registration and end-user licencing are not sufficient safe-
guards. Decisions about complex societal values are ultim-
ately not amenable to a simple algorithmic approach
whether derived heuristically or, for example, via machine
learning. We argue that a human-mediated review and
decision-making process are then required. Moreover, we
argue that study participants must be central to this
decision-making, seeing through to its conclusion the on-
going consent dialogue initiated in consent and participant
information, procedures and documents. places, at particular times, fashion meaning out of events
and phenomena through prolonged, complex processes of
social interaction involving history, language and action’
and ‘that to understand this world of meaning one must in-
terpret it’ [36]. We present this analysis with representative
extracts from the interviews and description derived from
the observational notes of the meetings. Independence and transparency y
One way of safeguarding the right to privacy and the right
to benefit from science is to ensure a robust and independ-
ent data access process, especially for the most complex
and sensitive research resources. The METADAC process
has promoted fair, consistent and transparent practices of
data access, including making these openly available on its
website. An independent mechanism for access, particularly
for more complex and sensitive data and sample access,
supports these processes. The importance of independence
is recognised by funders, for example, Wellcome’s recent
Longitudinal Population Studies Strategy [8], and reflected
in its criteria for funding longitudinal studies: Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Page 5 of 12 Table 1 Classes of data and their access regulation
Data type and sensitivity
Data available
from
Governance
Data distribution
Class 1 Low risk survey/phenotype-only data, e.g. social, economic, psychological and health
data. UK Data
Archive
Requires registered access—online (clickable)
end-user licences. Data is distributed by the
UK Data Archive. Class 2 Low sensitivity genetic-only data, e.g. genome-
wide single nucleotide polymorphism [SNP]
data generated from a standard chip with no
phenotype information except gender and a
coarse measure of area of residence. European
Genome-
phenome
Archive (EGA)
Requires application to the Sanger DAC,
administrative decision based on algorithm of
criteria for access. Data are distributed by
the EGA. Class 3 Potentially disclosive survey/phenotype-only
data, e.g. small geographic area. Requires
application to a study-based Data Access Com-
mittee made up of study investigators and
study technical staff. Study DAC
Data may be issued on special licence or may
be accessible only in on or off-site data safe
havens. Data is distributed, or the
data safe haven hosted,
by the study. Class 4 New forms of genetic-only data, e.g. exome se-
quence and epigenetic data, are reviewed by
METADAC until their ethical implication/sensi-
tivity is established. METADAC
Application requires review and approval from
the METADAC Access Committee. Application
includes signed agreement to conditions of
use. Data use is monitored annually. Data are distributed by
the EGA. Class 5 Genetic-only data with known ethical issues,
e.g. incidental findings risk in exome data. METADAC
Application requires review and approval from
the METADAC Access Committee. Application
includes signed agreement to conditions of
use. Data use is monitored annually. Data are distributed by
the EGA. Class 6 Biological samples. Use of biological samples
will always require additional oversight for
ethical and scientific reasons. Independence and transparency METADAC
Application requires independent scientific
review and approval from the METADAC
Access Committee. Samples are issued by the
relevant study under
Material Transfer
Agreements. Class 7 Any combination of Classes 1 to 6, e.g. individual-level phenotype data linked to geno-
type data or samples, is potentially more disclo-
sive than any one class of data alone. METADAC
Application requires review and approval from
the METADAC Access Committee. Application
includes signed agreement to conditions of
use. Data use is monitored annually. Combined datasets are
issued on unique IDs and
distributed by the study
and EGA. Class 8 Non-research data. High risk when multiple
variables are combined. Various
Certain administrative datasets, e.g. education and criminal records, are available
for research via the Administrative Data
Research Network. Individual-level health data
is available for research via NHS Digital)
Various Table 1 Classes of data and their access regulation
Data type and sensitivity
D Table 1 Classes of data and their access regulation Certain administrative datasets, e.g. education and criminal records, are available
for research via the Administrative Data
Research Network. Individual-level health data
is available for research via NHS Digital). If it is not possible to fully inform participants about
how their data could be used, it is essential that
robust governance is in place, for example, ensuring
there is an independent, accountable decision-making
body that can provide assurances that data are being
used and linked appropriately and responsibly. (p.6). Samples are issued by the
relevant study under
Material Transfer
Agreements.
Combined datasets are
issued on unique IDs and
distributed by the study
and EGA.
Various Table 2: METADAC assessment criteria As users of the resources return de-
rived datasets and code for variable creation, rapid as-
sessment of the ethical/governance implications of the
uses and governance of new forms of data (e.g. exome
sequencing and epigenetic data) is actioned, and the pa-
rameters for onward use are established through consen-
sus. But of course, independent does not mean detached. Having representatives from the studies at the table is
vital and enables the Access Committee to ensure that
the particularities of the study are taken into account
and that their future uses are optimised. METADAC has
a responsibility to the ongoing ‘health and wellbeing’ of
the studies and their participants and not simply to fa-
cilitate the exploitation of their data and samples. Fourth, METADAC enables learning across the studies
under its remit, sharing good practice but also providing
leverage to change practice. For example, one of the
studies under METADAC governance, Understanding
Society (the UK Household Longitudinal study), has
been able to extend the availability of its genetic data
resource internationally. The governance of multiple
studies made it evident that Understanding Society’s
historical restrictions on international access to its data
were not a fundamental feature of longitudinal studies in
the UK—other studies had no such restrictions. The exist-
ence of international access practices in the other studies
under METADAC enabled the study directors to reassure
their stakeholders that extending their access practices to
harmonise with those of others was safe, proportionate
and ethically acceptable. In short, there has been a virtu-
ous circle of learning amongst METADAC studies. samples. The METADAC Access Committee is chaired by
a social scientist with ethics expertise (MJM), and its dep-
uty chair (NW) has bioscience and bioinformatics expert-
ise. The TRT is chaired (PRB) by a biomedical scientist
with data science expertise. The ethnographic study demonstrated that each of the
contributors to the METADAC Committee brings par-
ticular understandings and perspectives which contrib-
ute richness to collaborative decision-making but that
these are understandings that are not rigidly bound, with
many members contributing across these domains. Study-facing committee members, currently two mem-
bers of longitudinal studies not governed by METADAC,
bring (i) embedded and embodied subjective experience of
longitudinal studies and thereby of study participants’ rea-
sonable expectations, and (ii) insights into the project pro-
posals that are not coloured by specialist knowledge of the
same field. Table 2: METADAC assessment criteria 1. The application has been submitted by bona fide researchers (using
the MRC definition [21]). 2. The application does not risk producing information that may allow
individual study participants to be identified. 2. The application does not risk producing information that may allow
individual study participants to be identified. 3. The application does not violate (or potentially violate) any of the
ethical permissions granted to the study and/or any of the consent
forms signed by the participants or their guardians. Four additional benefits of independent, multi-study
access processes are clear and go beyond the values and
norms of fair, transparent and ethical practice. First, in
the competitive academic environment in which most
researchers work, data ‘hugging’ or hoarding—real or
perceived—by researchers internal to a study can result
in constraints on sharing [44–46]. Independent access
processes, be they via registered access [47] or DACs,
support data accessibility. Second, study-independent,
multi-study access bodies can facilitate data discovery. Year-on-year increases in applications and approvals
through METADAC (a 2.5-fold increase over the first
24 months of operation) are a testament to the increas-
ing international interest in the use of UK longitudinal g
y
p
p
g
4. The application addresses topics that fall within the acknowledged
remit of the project, as understood by participants. p
j
y p
p
5. There is no significant risk that the application might upset or
alienate study members or of reducing their willingness to
continue as active participants. 6. There is no significant risk that the application might harm
individuals in the study, or the study as a whole. 7. The application does not require access to a depletable finite
resource (whole blood extracted DNA, blood, saliva and urine). OR The quality of the science has been reviewed formally by
independent external reviewers (agreed by METADAC) and has
been judged to merit the use of finite biological samples. NB:
Applications for finite bio-samples are seen as being in competition
with other potential future uses of those samples, and therefore the
quality of the science is reviewed formally. q
y
y
8. Includes a high quality plain language summary—following
METADAC guidance. 8. Includes a high quality plain language summary—following
METADAC guidance. Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Page 6 of 12 Page 6 of 12 studies and demonstrate the role of METADAC in enab-
ling access to study resources. Table 2: METADAC assessment criteria While researchers may be carried along by the
importance and interest of a particular exploration (it an-
swers an interesting research question), study-facing mem-
bers are more likely to see each application ‘anew’ and spot
where concerns may be raised for participants. We elabor-
ate this contribution further below. Committee members with legal and ethical expertise
bring (i) knowledge of relevant laws and regulation (par-
ticularly data protection law, access, consent and issues
around data privacy and biomedical research); (ii) under-
standing of the ethical norms, values and principles
underpinning decision-making and their implications for
protecting and promoting the rights, interests and wel-
fare of participants, researchers and the broader commu-
nity; and (iii) awareness of the remit and purpose of
DACs as well as ensuring the clarity and transparency of
METADAC practices and the documentation which
seeks to explain them. Biomedical scientists bring (i) an awareness of meth-
odology, used not to judge the science but instead to
understand whether variables requested are ‘necessary
and reasonable’; (ii) understanding of the biomedical
background to research, to judge the likely potential for
incidental or secondary findings in research which at
first glance may not raise clinically actionable findings;
and (iii) awareness of related published material or simi-
lar data resources that may assist applicants in carrying
out research. Table 2: METADAC assessment criteria Moreover, researchers ap-
plying to METADAC are signposted to other similar
studies and are able to make data and/or sample access
applications to multiple studies simultaneously. Third,
an independent committee allows determinations to be
made about new uses of data and samples out-with the
natural tendency of studies to be risk-averse regarding
their own resource. As users of the resources return de-
rived datasets and code for variable creation, rapid as-
sessment of the ethical/governance implications of the
uses and governance of new forms of data (e.g. exome
sequencing and epigenetic data) is actioned, and the pa-
rameters for onward use are established through consen-
sus. But of course, independent does not mean detached. Having representatives from the studies at the table is
vital and enables the Access Committee to ensure that
the particularities of the study are taken into account
and that their future uses are optimised. METADAC has
a responsibility to the ongoing ‘health and wellbeing’ of
the studies and their participants and not simply to fa-
cilitate the exploitation of their data and samples. Fourth, METADAC enables learning across the studies
under its remit, sharing good practice but also providing
leverage to change practice. For example, one of the
studies under METADAC governance, Understanding
Society (the UK Household Longitudinal study), has
been able to extend the availability of its genetic data
resource internationally. The governance of multiple
studies made it evident that Understanding Society’s
historical restrictions on international access to its data
were not a fundamental feature of longitudinal studies in
the UK—other studies had no such restrictions. The exist-
ence of international access practices in the other studies
under METADAC enabled the study directors to reassure
their stakeholders that extending their access practices to
harmonise with those of others was safe, proportionate
and ethically acceptable. In short, there has been a virtu-
ous circle of learning amongst METADAC studies. studies and demonstrate the role of METADAC in enab-
ling access to study resources. Moreover, researchers ap-
plying to METADAC are signposted to other similar
studies and are able to make data and/or sample access
applications to multiple studies simultaneously. Third,
an independent committee allows determinations to be
made about new uses of data and samples out-with the
natural tendency of studies to be risk-averse regarding
their own resource. Interdisciplinarity Because no individual or group can possibly hold know-
ledge of all aspects of research, research ethics and gov-
ernance [48], the METADAC Access Committee is
comprised of committee members with social, biomedical,
ethical, legal and clinical expertise and individuals with
study-facing expertise. Committee meetings also include,
as observers, study PIs or study representatives, funder
representatives and members of the Technical Review
Team (TRT) who support the decision-making. The
METADAC Secretariat and the ethnographic observer
(JTM) also attend meetings. Where appropriate, the com-
mittee also takes advantage of third-party specialist know-
ledge, particularly where an applicant seeks to use finite Social scientists bring (i) methodological expertise to as-
sess the aims, feasibility and study designs being proposed;
(ii) understanding of social and environmental contexts
when and where data were collected and their potential im-
pact; (iii) awareness of issues that may give rise to ethical or
public concern, often reframing scientific descriptions which
uncover simplistic or paternalistic assumptions which may
trigger participant concerns; and (iv) experience of working
with other epidemiological and longitudinal studies. Page 7 of 12 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 In the ethnographic evaluation, the diversity of the
committee was seen to produce higher quality reflection
and analysis on matters of concern [49]. Participants de-
scribed that hearing perspectives from other fields im-
proved their own critical thinking. But, as Fitzgerald and
Callard [50] put it: ‘There are two current certainties in
… interdisciplinary research: everyone wants to do it,
and no one quite knows how’ (p.23). While the benefits
of multi-, inter- or transdisciplinary working in data gov-
ernance are still emerging and deserve careful documen-
tation, for METADAC, there appears to be some clear
benefits, particularly in supporting a rounded approach
that takes account of a plurality of perspectives in com-
ing to consensual decisions. That is not to suggest that
consensus is necessarily or always straightforward; it re-
quires work. It is not simply multiple perspectives from
distinct disciplines that are brought to bear in decision-
making (not least because some members already span
disciplines), but also multiple standpoints or subject po-
sitions [51, 52]; more colloquially, we say people ‘wear
many
hats’. Individuals
taking
part
in
METADAC
decision-making inhabit and draw upon multiple subject
positions:
researcher/researched,
data
custodian/data
producer, etc. Interdisciplinarity We argue that it is these multiple subject
positions which are important in decision-making pre-
cisely because they call upon the different interests,
commitments and expectations which are central to en-
suring decisions made about data and sample access are
coherent with, and respect the contributions made by,
study participants. Clinicians bring understanding of (i) both the serious-
ness and treatability of genetically influenced illnesses;
(ii) the sometimes blurred boundaries between research
and clinical practice, highlighting the complexities and
impact of communicating uncertainties to patients and
their families, especially in the contexts of interpreting
genetic variants and reporting unlooked for findings;
and (iii) a working appreciation of negotiating meaning-
ful informed consent to genetic testing with patients
when results may not be predicted or imminent. The TRT provides practical insight on the affordances
of the studies and a broad evaluation of disclosure risk
and incidental finding risk, based on a knowledge of the
size of the dataset, prevalence and heritability of the
condition and issues that will require further detailed
discussion in committee. The TRT includes individuals
with expertise about the study data and other resources. They offer the Access Committee insight into what data
resources are available, the format and affordances of
those resources and, for example, whether there are spe-
cific technical or other restrictions on their use. Study PIs/representatives bring a strong awareness of
the field generally and their own studies in particular; the
availability and relevance of data, any weaknesses in the
data (e.g. a low response rate in a particular questionnaire)
and other relevant data not known to the applicant—
whether from a new wave or from another longitudinal
study with similar data. Similarly, funders contribute un-
derstanding of strategic and policy direction nationally
and internationally. In practice, any member may bring a
contribution from many of these types. Discussion: participant-centred decision-making
Engaging the perspectives of stakeholder communities
within research and involving them in decision making are
lauded for meeting ethical expectations and norms as well
as for its (potential) pragmatic outcomes, improving the
alignment of research with societal values and the relevance
of research outputs or their translation [48]. Engagement is
variously understood as a form of democracy, an act of re-
spect and an acknowledgement of human rights [53–59]. Interdisciplinarity It might be plausible to construct
an algorithm to identify certain classes of research as sen-
sitive, and indeed for one of the studies under METADAC
oversight, there is a specific list of research topics and
types which are restricted. Specifically, the 1958 Birth
Cohort explicitly restricts studies of the genetics of
intelligence, sexuality and criminality. This stipulation is
based on information provided to nurses during their for-
mal training for taking samples from study participants. While not included in the information material given to
study participants during consent, which are always the
foundation of legitimate access requests, a previous com-
mittee determined that nurses might reasonably have been
expected to communicate those exceptions to at least
some study participants, and therefore, these continue to
be respected. A list of restricted variables has been identi-
fied, but decisions about how and whether the research
purposes proposed for their use are acceptable and ap-
proval granted are often more complicated than simple
yes/no determinations. A level of interpretation and
judgement is necessary, one which requires human
decision-making. outputs as a result. As we argue elsewhere, engagement
brings study participants closer to the research but also
brings the research and researchers closer to them [48]. In
the case of longitudinal studies, there is a long history of
study participant involvement in decision-making. The
Avon
Longitudinal
Study
of
Parents
and
Children
(ALSPAC) has an advisory panel comprised of study partic-
ipants and has included on its ethics committee original co-
hort participants (now nearing 26 years of age) for the past
decade and parent members for much longer [63]. ALSPAC study participant members now number half of
the ethics committee and their involvement in ethical
decision-making is normalised and embedded. In META-
DAC, the need for multiple perspectives, met through the
interdisciplinary constitution of its Access Committee,
demands the inclusion of study-facing participants. By
incorporating study-facing members, METADAC was seen
by members and observers of the committee as contribut-
ing new and valuable voices to discussions about data ac-
cess and use and expanding how Data Access Committees
have historically functioned: They’re the ones who have insights, that nobody else
has, on the anxieties, the concerns, the hopes about
how their data will be used, so they absolutely need to
be represented. Interdisciplinarity In Braidotti’s vision of affirmative ethics [60, 61], the under-
standing that ‘we are all in this together’ even if we are ‘not
one and the same’ [62] places upon science an injunction
to work with the communities, public and research partici-
pants who are both the basis and beneficiaries of science. Of course, study participants are already at the centre of
longitudinal studies; it is only with their permission and
with their contributions of data and samples that the stud-
ies endure. Respecting those contributions means that
participant-centredness must do more than simply consider
them research subjects. Engaging study participants in
meaningful decision-making is both an ethical and practical
solution, enabling alignment with participant expectations,
social norms and values and, arguably, improving study This
rich
mix
of
participants
brings
to
bear
perspectives and understandings which support inde-
pendent and transparent decision-making. During the
ethnographic evaluation that has run in parallel to the
formation of METADAC, internal stakeholders have fre-
quently highlighted the value of having a range of discip-
linary expertise in the Access Committee: A multi-disciplinary approach is really vital so that we
have both the technical expertise, ethical expertise,
social sciences expertise, so that all those elements
can be brought to one place to determine what is the
optimal approach. (from evaluation interview with
METADAC Committee member) If there are ethical issues, there is someone who is a
specialist in that and who’s thinking about it and
brings issues up if they need to be discussed …there
are lots of different people on [METADAC] from lots
of different backgrounds and disciplines ... So there
are different people thinking about these things. (from evaluation interview with METADAC Technical
Review Team member) (from evaluation interview with METADAC Technical
Review Team member) Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Page 8 of 12 Page 8 of 12 injunction that participants (in her report, patients) should
not be ‘surprised’ by the uses of their data and samples
also holds true for METADAC. Assessment criterion 5
(Table 2) is called upon in METADAC Access Committee
meetings in the form of two questions: (1) Would the re-
search proposed by an applicant be likely to upset or
alienate participants? and (2) Would the research breach
the reasonable expectations of participants? It is via these
questions that issues of potential sensitivity and contro-
versy may be addressed. Study participant involvement in decision-making Study participant involvement in decision making
An ethnographic (observational) study of a predecessor to
the METADAC Committee identified, during access deci-
sions, repeated consideration of what the participant or
public might ‘think’ of a particular application for data use
[44]. In that DAC, however, understanding of participant’s
voice was hypothetical only, because no participants or
other study-facing members were involved in DAC
decision-making and no empirical account of their views
was available (e.g. in qualitative studies of their expecta-
tions of involvement). The METADAC infrastructure
addresses this absence by including two study-facing
members who are themselves participants of longitudinal
studies. To avoid conflicts of interest, these study-facing
members are independent of the studies for which META-
DAC provides oversight. This decision was taken to avoid
the assumption that study-facing members directly repre-
sent the study population. While two committee members
cannot feasibly represent the individual interests of tens of
thousands of study participants, the aim is to ensure that
the embodied, material and emotional experience of being
a study participant is incorporated into data governance Interdisciplinarity (from evaluation interview with
METADAC Committee member) Participant-centredness can, of course, take many
forms: it can be agonistic or it can be solidaristic; it can
be prescribed or it can be negotiated [64]. In scientific
contexts, participatory activities can range from unidir-
ectional communication and outreach, through various
levels of involvement in decision-making, to participant
control, as in citizen science endeavours. Each has ad-
vantages and limitations. In METADAC, which requires
understanding and expertise from many perspectives in
order
to
make
responsible
decisions,
participant-
centredness takes three forms: (1) respecting study par-
ticipant expectations, (2) involving study participants in
decision-making roles and (3) communicating the results
of access decisions to participants (and others) in a for-
mat that is clear and accessible, for example, in plain
language summaries. Plain language summaries METADAC has avoided treating study-facing mem-
bers’ views as ‘non-expert’. Involvement of study partici-
pants in decision-making roles requires active work to
ensure it is meaningful; a learning process that means
that the contributions of these study participant mem-
bers deepen as their knowledge and understanding of
governance issues grow. Pre-meetings are held with all
new members of the METADAC, whatever their back-
ground, and continue for study-facing members as often
as they wish, to create a space for longer discussion of
applications and other issues that is typically available in
a 90-min committee meeting. After each committee
meeting, informal debrief sessions are hosted to make
sure that any uncertainties are resolved, wider observa-
tions can be aired and suggestions made. Active chairing
in committee meetings and an inclusive culture facili-
tates all committee members to express their positions. The Secretariat acts as the first point of call when re-
solving practical problems, and the Access Committee
as a whole can be used to develop insights into particu-
lar areas of procedure or policy. Although plain language summaries (PLSs), or ‘lay sum-
maries’, are an expectation of communication of much
research—and most funders now require these for their
applications—researchers often do not communicate
their work in ways which are clear or accessible to non-
expert audiences. METADAC owes a duty to communi-
cate the outputs of their contributions to the partici-
pants of those studies for which it provides oversight
and to their funders. PLSs are published on the META-
DAC website [1]. Development of PLS policy, processes
and guidance, therefore, has been taken seriously, and
METADAC’s study-facing committee members assess
each PLS according to guidance provided to applicants
[65]. As a reflection of the care by which PLSs are
reviewed, and to ensure data use is transparent to study
participants and the wider community, many applicants
are asked to improve their PLS. While guidance is read-
ily available, time-poor researchers do not always fully
absorb the instructions or do not recognise the import-
ance attached to PLSs by METADAC. The chief reason
applicants are asked to revise their applications is on the
basis of inadequate descriptions of their research. Even within the acknowledged limitations above, deci-
sions made with study-facing members create different
outcomes to those made without their insight and ex-
perience. Limitations This ethnographic case study was informed by the evalu-
ation of the METADAC pilot. As such, it represents
findings at an interim stage of METADAC’s develop-
ment and should be read with this limitation in mind. The ethnographic methods used here provide a deep
understanding of a phenomenon. Though they are not
statistically generalizable, the findings, as expected of
qualitative studies employing quality criteria for rigour
and trustworthiness, can be considered theoretically
generalizable to cognate settings. Study participant expectations Participant expectations of longitudinal research are cen-
tral to METADAC’s access decisions. Criterion 5 (Table 2)
seeks to ensure that there is no significant risk of upsetting
or alienating participants. While this is an instrumental
value, in that it seeks to reduce loss to a study or studies,
it is also primarily a value-based position aimed at respect-
ing the participation and on-going commitment of study
participants. Though in a cognate context, Caldicott’s Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Page 9 of 12 In this way, decision-making in METADAC occurs with
study participants as part of an ongoing, collaborative
and negotiated process. decision-making. In this pilot phase of METADAC, devel-
opment of study-facing members’ involvement is assisted
by involving individual study participants who also happen
to have active research careers in the social sciences. decision-making. In this pilot phase of METADAC, devel-
opment of study-facing members’ involvement is assisted
by involving individual study participants who also happen
to have active research careers in the social sciences. Plain language summaries For example, the embodied sense of discomfort
or unease from the participant perspective (or indeed
from other members) warrants greater scrutiny of appli-
cations by the Access Committee and can and does en-
courage different decisions to be made. Some areas of
sensitivity are not easily exposed through schematic,
algorithmic or technical evaluation. We call upon study-
facing members to scrutinise areas of uncertainty, along
with other members, to articulate a range of potential
study participants’ responses in order to highlight poten-
tial risks and harms of any given application and to an-
ticipate how even well-intentioned research outcomes
can produce harms, including those caused by sensatio-
nalised media reactions. Some of this reasoning can be
messy and speculative; it stays with the troubling or
unforeseen parts of an application and tries to consider
how the expectations of science may align with or com-
promise those of study participants. In this regard,
study-facing members bring a unique perspective and
position to the committee. But they do more than this. In the METADAC, the study-facing members have been
central in developing policy, particularly as new forms of
data become available. Deep and often lively discussions
during METADAC development workshops become the
basis of policy and processes (e.g. recent access policy
developed for exome sequence data and epigenetic data). Conclusions: future considerations for data and
samples access At present, there is a strong strategic investment in en-
suring not only the optimisation of research data use,
but also of routine data generated by health and social
care services and other administrative data services. Moving forward, the international research community
is proactively working towards creating a world in which
all such sources of data can, where beneficial, be inte-
grated, linked and jointly interpreted; this potential has
been demonstrated in the UK in projects such as The
Farr Institute, the Administrative Data Research Net-
work, Connected Health Cities, the pan-London Health
Information
Exchange
and
the
Medical
Research Page 10 of 12 Page 10 of 12 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Council’s Health Data Research UK initiative [3, 66–69]. The aims of such initiatives and the enhanced data util-
ity they provide are three-fold: (1) to better use data to
directly inform front-line clinical care and public health,
(2) to enhance the evidence base for health and social
care planning and strategic development and formally
evaluate key initiatives in these domains and (3) to en-
hance the quality and scope of research in health sci-
ence, bioscience and the social sciences. Given the
desirability of such aims and current investment by gov-
ernments and funders, it is inevitable that over the next
decade, DACs are going to have to deal with increasingly
large volumes of data generated from the health, social
care and other administrative data sources. time health service data to enable rapid clinical re-
sponses for diagnosis or management. If both the re-
search community and health and social care services
are to be ready when the new data start flowing, there is
a need for experts across all the domains and disciplines
relating to data access and sharing, including study
participants and users of health, social care and other
services, to have worked through all of these issues. Human-mediated decision-making bodies will undoubt-
edly be central to ensuring the trustworthiness of the
most sensitive of those data, and achievable, reasoned
and responsible decisions about their use. The META-
DAC model we describe here provides a template for
such future governance. Competing interests p
g
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Ethics approval The evolution of DACs that can deal jointly and effect-
ively with all of the criteria and rules applying to rou-
tinely collected health, social care or administrative data
and all of those already applied in dealing with research
data will be an equivalent challenge but of a much
higher order. This will particularly prove to be the case
when DACs have to start considering data generated
and interpreted in real time; indeed, many new applica-
tions of health data in the future will require that re-
search data from individuals can be combined with real- The ethnographic study was initially granted ethical approval by the
Faculty of Health Sciences Research Ethics Committee (FREC) at the
University of Bristol (no. 33242), before being transferred and re-
approved by the Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Humanities and
Social Sciences, Newcastle University. Funding The METADAC is funded jointly by the Medical Research Council (MRC), the
Wellcome Trust and the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) -MR/
N01104X/1 & MR/N01104X/2 - and is supported by the Wellcome Trust and
MRC funded Fostering new Opportunities for Researchers via Wider Access
to Research Data and Samples (58FORWARDS) study - 108439/Z/15/Z. The
ethnographic study identified is similarly funded, though no funder played a
role in the design of the study or in the collection, analysis and
interpretation of the data. Abbreviations bb e at o s
ALSPAC: Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children; DAC: Data Access
Committee; METADAC: Managing Ethico-social, Technical and Administrative
issues in Data ACcess; NHS: National Health Service; PLS: Plain language
summary; REC: Research Ethics Committee; TRT: Technical Review Team;
UKDA: UK Data Archive Acknowledgements
Th
h
ld lik g
The authors would like to thank all members of METADAC, past and present,
for their contributions to the review of data access applications and to the
development of policy and procedures. The authors would like to thank all members of METADAC, past and present,
for their contributions to the review of data access applications and to the
development of policy and procedures. Availability of data and materials Data generated by the ethnographic study are not publicly available
because the small membership (current and past) of the METADAC
combined with public availability of their names on the METADAC website
makes it readily possible to identify individuals. Conclusions: future considerations for data and
samples access At least some DACs in the future are going to have to
be able to deal simultaneously, and effectively, with the
data access criteria they already apply to research data
and the laws, rules and regulations applicable, in the
UK, to National Health Service (NHS), social care and
administrative data (e.g. education, criminal records, na-
tional statistics). Whether research DACs evolve to deal
with NHS data (or as gatekeepers for NHS data), taking
account of the real risk of identification of at least some
individuals, even after pseudonymisation and similar
privacy-protecting mechanisms, will demand a profound
change in perspective. In addition, governing these data
will create a substantive additional workload and a need
to rapidly explore and develop appropriate systems
shortcuts and technological solutions to some aspects of
the assessment. Empirical evidence demonstrates that
DACs face serious challenges when a new class of data
suddenly becomes available: part of the argument for
creating METADAC was that a predecessor DAC was
not set up and therefore not able to deal effectively with
newly available genomic data. METADAC and several
studies under it have had to work hard (and rapidly) to
modify the systems and structures for releasing conven-
tional SNP-based genome-wide association data to deal
with full DNA sequence data and with methylation
data—even though many of the principles are unaltered. Other studies, not part of METADAC, have invested ex-
tensive time in considering how—if at all—to manage
and govern new data classes such as data generated via
social media or image data. Authors’ contributions MJM conceived the METADAC, and all authors (except MTB, OWB and JTM)
contributed to the development of the METADAC infrastructure, application
review process and/or development of policy and procedure. MJM also
conceived the ethnographic study. The study protocol was developed by
MJM, JTM and SJR. Recruitment and data collection were conducted by JTM,
with data analysis completed by MJM, JTM and SJR. MJM wrote an initial
draft of the manuscript, to which all authors provided feedback and
approved the final version. References Chan A-W, Song F, Vickers A, Jefferson T, Dickersin K, Gøtzsche PC,
Krumholz HM, Ghersi D, Van Der Worp HB. Increasing value and reducing
waste: addressing inaccessible research. Lancet. 2014;383(9913):257–66. 42. Buck N, McFall S. Understanding society: design overview. Longitudinal and
Life Course Studies. 2011;3(1):5–17. 13. Gøtzsche PC. Why we need easy access to all data from all clinical trials and
how to accomplish it. Trials. 2011;12(1):249. 43. Benzeval M, Davillas A, Kumari M, Lynn P. Understanding society: the UK
household longitudinal study biomarker user guide and glossary. Vancouver: Institute for Social and Economic Research, University of
Essex; 2014. 14. Nafus D, Sherman J. Big data, big questions| this one does not go up to 11:
the quantified self movement as an alternative big data practice. International journal of communication. 2014;8:11. 44. Murtagh MJ, Turner A, Minion JT, Fay M, Burton PR. International data
sharing in practice: new technologies meet old governance. Biopreservation
and biobanking. 2016;14(3):231–40. 15. Prainsack B. Personalized medicine: empowered patients in the 21st
century? Vancouver: NYU Press; 2017. 16. Geraghty KJ. ‘PACE-Gate’: when clinical trial evidence meets open data
access. London, England: SAGE Publications Sage UK; 2016. 45. Murtagh MJ, Thorisson GA, Wallace SE, Kaye J, Demir I, Fortier I, Harris JR,
Cox D, Deschênes M, LaFlamme P. Navigating the perfect [data] storm. Norsk epidemiologi. 2012;21(2):203–9. 17. Organisation for Economic C-o, Development: OECD principles and
guidelines for access to research data from public funding. Vancouver:
OECD Pub; 2007. 46. Lowrance WW: Access to collections of data and materials for health
research. A report to the Medical Research Council and the Wellcome Trust
London: MRC and Wellcome Trust 2006. 18. Jones KH, Laurie G, Stevens L, Dobbs C, Ford DV, Lea N. The other side of
the coin: harm due to the non-use of health-related data. Int J Med Inform. 2017;97:43–51. 47. Dyke SOM, Kirby E, Shabani M, Thorogood A, Kato K, Knoppers BM. Registered
access: a ‘triple-A’approach. Eur J Hum Genet. 2016;24(12):1676–80. 19. UK_Data_Service. www.ukdataservice.ac.uk. Accessed 22 Apr 2018. 48. Murtagh MJ, Minion JT, Turner A, Wilson RC, Blell M, Ochieng C, Murtagh B,
Roberts S, Butters OW, Burton PR. The ECOUTER methodology for
stakeholder engagement in translational research. BMC medical ethics. 2017;18(1):24. 20. Department_of_Education. Summary of Longitudinal Surveys. https://assets. publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_
data/file/444794/DFE-RR458_Summary_of_longitudinal_surveys.pdf. Accessed 22 Apr 2018. 49. Murtagh M, Roberts SJ, Minion J, JT. METADAC (Managing Ethico-social,
Technical and Administrative issues in Data ACcess). References genomes by surname inference. Science. 2013;339(6117):321–4 1. METADAC [www.metadac.ac.uk - Accessed 5 Jan 2018]. 30. Harrison H, Birks M, Franklin R, Mills J. Case study research: foundations and
methodological orientations. In: Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung/Forum:
Qualitative Social Research; 2017. 2. European_Genome-Phenome_Archive. www.ebi.ac.uk/ega/home. Accessed
22 Apr 2018. 3. Administrative Data Research Network [https://adrn.ac.uk/ - Accessed 5 Jan 2018]. Administrative Data Research Network [https://adrn.ac.uk/ - Accessed 5 31. Knoppers BM. Framework for responsible sharing of genomic and health-
related data. HUGO J. 2014;8(1):3. 4. Pilat D, Fukasaku Y. OECD principles and guidelines for access to research
data from public funding. Data Science Journal. 2007;6:OD4–OD11. 32. Framework for Responsible Sharing of Genomic and Health-Related Data. https://www.ga4gh.org/docs/ga4ghtoolkit/rsgh/Framework-Version-
10September2014.pdf. Accessed 5 Jan 2018. 5. Guidelines to the rules on open access to scientific publication and open
access to research data in Horizon 2020 [http://ec.europa.eu/research/
participants/data/ref/h2020/grants_manual/hi/oa_pilot/h2020-hi-oa-pilot-
guide_en.pdf]. 10September2014.pdf. Accessed 5 Jan 2018. 33. Stake RE. The art of case study research. Vancouver: Sage; 1995 34. Glaser BG. The constant comparative method of qualitative analysis. Soc
Probl. 1965;12(4):436–45. 6. Understanding Patient Data [https://understandingpatientdata.org.uk/ -
Accessed 5 Jan 2018]. 35. Braun V, Clarke V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol. 2006;3(2):77–101. 7. National Institutes of Health Data Sharing Policies [https://grants.nih.gov/
policy/sharing.htm - Accessed 5 Jan 2018]. 36. Schwandt TA. Constructivist, interpretivist approaches to human inquiry. Handbook of Qual Res. 1994;1:118–37. 8. Longitudinal Population Studies Strategy [https://wellcome.ac.uk/sites/default/
files/longitudinal-population-studies-strategy_0.pdf - Accessed 5 Jan 2018]. 37. METADAC Studies [https://www.metadac.ac.uk/studies-2/ - Accessed 5 Jan 2018]. 9. Munafò MR, Nosek BA, Bishop DV, Button KS, Chambers CD, du Sert NP,
Simonsohn U, Wagenmakers E-J, Ware JJ, Ioannidis JP. A manifesto for
reproducible science. Nature Human Behaviour. 2017;1:0021. 38. Power C, Elliott J. Cohort profile: 1958 British Birth Cohort (national ch
development study). Int J Epidemiol. 2005;35(1):34–41. 39. Elliott J, Shepherd P. Cohort profile: 1970 British birth cohort (BCS70). Int J
Epidemiol. 2006;35(4):836–43. 39. Elliott J, Shepherd P. Cohort pro
Epidemiol. 2006;35(4):836–43. 10. Ioannidis JP. How to make more published research true. PLoS Med. 2014;
11(10):e1001747. 40. Steptoe A, Breeze E, Banks J, Nazroo J. Cohort profile: the English
longitudinal study of ageing. Int J Epidemiol. 2012;42(6):1640–8. 11. Ross JS, Krumholz HM. Ushering in a new era of open science through data
sharing: the wall must come down. JAMA. 2013;309(13):1355–6. 41. Connelly R, Platt L. Cohort profile: UK millennium Cohort study (MCS). Int J
Epidemiol. 2014;43(6):1719–25. 12. Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Received: 15 January 2018 Accepted: 6 April 2018 Received: 15 January 2018 Accepted: 6 April 2018 28. Masca N, Burton PR, Sheehan NA. Participant identification in genetic
association studies: improved methods and practical implications. Int J
Epidemiol. 2011;40(6):1629–42. 29. Gymrek M, McGuire AL, Golan D, Halperin E, Erlich Y. Identifying personal
genomes by surname inference. Science. 2013;339(6117):321–4. Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. Page 11 of 12 Page 11 of 12 Page 11 of 12 Author details
1
l 25. Burton PR, Banner N, Elliot MJ, Knoppers BM, Banks J. Policies and strategies
to facilitate secondary use of research data in the health sciences. Vancouver: Oxford University Press; 2017. 1Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK. 2University of Cambridge,
Cambridge, UK. 3University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK. 4University College
London Institute of Education, London, UK. 5University of Bristol, Bristol, UK. 6PHG Foundation, Cambridge, UK. 7University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. 8University of Essex, Colchester, UK. 9King’s College London, London, UK. 10NatCen, Brentwood, London, UK. 11University College London, London, UK. 12Imperial College London, London, UK. 13Ghent University Hospital, Ghent,
Belgium. 14Goldsmiths, University of London, London, UK. 15UK Data Archive,
University of Essex, Colchester, UK. 16NIHR Bioresource, Cambridge, UK. 26. Gaye A, Marcon Y, Isaeva J, LaFlamme P, Turner A, Jones EM, Minion J, Boyd
AW, Newby CJ, Nuotio M-L. DataSHIELD: taking the analysis to the data, not
the data to the analysis. Int J Epidemiol. 2014;43(6):1929–44. 27. Homer N, Szelinger S, Redman M, Duggan D, Tembe W, Muehling J,
Pearson JV, Stephan DA, Nelson SF, Craig DW. Resolving individuals
contributing trace amounts of DNA to highly complex mixtures using
high-density SNP genotyping microarrays. PLoS Genet. 2008;4(8):
e1000167. References In: European Biobank
Week. Vienna: European, Middle Eastern & African Society for
Biopreservation and Biobanking; Biobanking and Biomolecular Resources
Research Infrastructure - European Research Infrastructure Consortium; 2016 21. Medical_Research_Council. Cohort Directory. https://mrc.ukri.org/research/
facilities-and-resources-for-researchers/cohort-directory/. Accessed 22 Apr
2018. 22. Burton PR, Clayton DG, Cardon LR, Craddock N, Deloukas P, Duncanson A,
Kwiatkowski DP, McCarthy MI, Ouwehand WH, Samani NJ. Genome-wide
association study of 14,000 cases of seven common diseases and 3,000
shared controls. Nature. 2007;447(7145):661–78. 50. Fitzgerald D, Callard F. Social science and neuroscience beyond
interdisciplinarity: experimental entanglements. Theory, Culture & Society. 2015;32(1):3–32. 51. Davies B, Harré R. Positioning: the discursive production of selves. J Theory
Soc Behav. 1990;20(1):43–63. 24. HRA Consent decision tools [http://www.hra-decisiontools.org.uk/consent/
index.html - Accessed 5 Jan 2018]. Page 12 of 12 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 Murtagh et al. Human Genomics (2018) 12:24 52. Harré R, Moghaddam FM. The self and others: positioning individuals and
groups in personal, political, and cultural contexts. Vancouver: Greenwood
publishing group; 2003. 53. Kim SY, Wall IF, Stanczyk A, De Vries R. Assessing the public’s views in
research ethics controversies: deliberative democracy and bioethics as
natural allies. Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics. 2009;4(4):3–16. 54. Gottweis H, Gaskell G, Starkbaum J. Connecting the public with biobank
research: reciprocity matters. Nat Rev Genet. 2011;12(11):738–9. 55. Winickoff DE. From benefit sharing to power sharing: partnership
governance in population genomics research. UC Berkeley: Center for the
Study of Law and Society Jurisprudence and Social Policy Program; 2008. Retrieved from https://escholarship.org/uc/item/845393hh. Retrieved from https://escholarship.org/uc/item/845393hh. 56. Stirling A. Power, truth and progress: towards knowledge democracies in
europe. Future Directions For Scientific Advice In. 2015:133. 56. Stirling A. Power, truth and progress: towards knowledge de 57. Solberg B: Biobank consent models—are we moving toward increased
participant engagement in biobanking? Journal of Biorepository Science fo
Applied Medicine 2015, 3:23–33. 58. Rial-Sebbag E, Cambon-Thomsen A: Governing biobanks through a
European infrastructure. In: Ethics, Law and Governance of Biobanking. Springer; 2015: 139–151. 59. O'Doherty K, Einsiedel E. Public engagement and emerging technologies. Vancouver: UBC Press; 2012. 60. Braidotti R: Transpositions: on nomadic ethics: polity; 2006. 61. Braidotti R: On putting the active back into activism. New Formations 2010,
68(68):42–57. 62. Aspirations of a posthumanist [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNIYOKfRQks]. 63. Minion JT, Butcher F, Timpson NJ, Murtagh MJ. The ethics conundrum in
Recall by Genotype (RbG) research: perspectives from birth cohort
participants. bioRxiv. 2017:124636. 64. Dean RJ. Beyond radicalism and resignation: the competing logics for
public participation in policy decisions. Policy & Politics. 2017;45(2):213–30. 65. METADAC Plain Language Summary Guidance. https://www.metadac.ac.uk/
files/2017/06/v1.0-Plain-language-guidance-for-METADAC-applications.pdf. Accessed 5 Jan 2018. 66. The Farr Institute. http://www.farrinstitute.org/. Accessed 5 Jan 2018. 67. Connected Health Cities. https://www.connectedhealthcities.org/. Accessed
5 Jan 2018. 68. London Information Exchange. https://www.digitalhealth.net/2015/03/
london-information-exchange-on-way/. Accessed 5 Jan 2018. london-information-exchange-on-way/. Accessed 5 Jan 2018. 69. MRC Health Data Research UK. https://www.mrc.ac.uk/about/institutes-units-
centres/uk-institute-for-health-and-biomedical-informatics-research/. Accessed 5 Jan 2018.
|
https://openalex.org/W4285059537
|
https://www.epj-conferences.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226401009/pdf
|
English
| null |
Two-wavelength digital holographic interferometry for unambiguous range extended measurements in fluid mechanics
|
EPJ web of conferences
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 5,206
|
1 Introduction mechanical systems (MEMS) fabrication, ultraprecise
manufacture, research in ophthalmology etc. [2] For fast occurring phenomena, where the nature and
properties of the fluid must be studied without
disturbances from the observer, non-contact optical
methods such as digital holographic interferometry
present themselves as reliable, fast and accurate
techniques. Such technique require nonetheless that the
liquid under study to be transparent or semi-transparent,
in order for the optical rays to pass through and be
recorded. Phase imaging holographic interferometry
provides high flexibility and means for highly sensitive
measurement of phenomena with optical path variations. In this paper, an off-axis two-wavelength digital
holographic interferometry technique for resolving the
issue of phase unwrap ambiguity for the case of a
resistor is presented. When the object we measure has sudden profile
changes that go beyond the range limit allowed for a
specific wavelength, a phase ambiguity arises. If this
ambiguity isn’t solved in the phase unwrapping process,
it will give faulty result, not mapping the true profile of
the phenomenon we are looking at. The phase is
proportional to the surface profile (when trying to image
surface profiles from reflection), to the integral of the
refractive index for transparent media, otherwise it is
linked to the wavelength via respective formula. [3]
Two-wavelength interferometry offers an alternative
solution to solve the phase ambiguity problem. [3] Interferometric methods offer very high precision
measurements which lie in the range of the nanometric
scale [1]. One clear advantage is the fast numerical
reconstruction. Two-wavelength interferometry offers an alternative
solution to solve the phase ambiguity problem. [3] Digital holographic interferometry is being used
more and more due to its clear advantages over the
conventional holographic technique. Probably the most
important advantage lays in its power to acquire and
process images/information in real time. It offers the
possibility of easily acquiring images through CCD
cameras, complex and fast numerical processing, storage
of large data, numerical image reconstruction and real
time presentation of the phenomena. Digital holographic
interferometry finds a very wide range of applications,
notably in medical imaging where the study of biological
specimens has been made easier and better. The range of
application is quite wide, in industrial and scientific
applications, notably in quality control in micro-electro- This method enables a fast and efficient way of
imaging the phase profile for a multitude of applications. Two-wavelength digital holographic interferometry for
unambiguous range extended measurements in fluid
mechanics Gramoz Çubreli1,2*, Pavel Psota2, Ahmad Kouta1, Petra Dančová1
and 1Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Technical University of Liberec, Studentská 2, 461 17 Liberec 1, Czech Republic
2Faculty of Mechatronics, Informatics and Interdisciplinary Studies, Technical University of Liberec, Studentská 2, 461 17
Liberec 1, Czech Republic Abstract. Non-contact optical methods such as digital holographic interferometry are highly
suitable in measurements where the phenomena is fast, performed in transparent or semi-transparent
environment and mustn’t be obstructed as when applying local contact techniques. Such specific
application can be studying dynamic events during transonic and supersonic blade flutter. Fast,
sensitive and rather easy access to the phase information make these techniques very attractive in
the study of phase objects/phenomena. However, since light’s phase is bounded to a repetitive cycle
of 2π radians, the range of measurement is limited to one cycle of the phase, limiting applications to
small gradient phenomena. This paper presents a new interesting way of by-passing this limitation,
while still keeping noise values low, by introducing a second laser with a close value wavelength,
giving rise to a new interferometric pattern with an extended unambiguous range of measurement. Image acquisition is done simultaneously for both wavelengths and all reconstructions are digitally
performed. The principle and preliminary results are included in this paper. * Corresponding author: Gramoz Çubreli gramoz.cubreli@tul.cz EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022) EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022) EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022)
EFM 2021 https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226401009 EFM 2021 © The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
ses/by/4.0/). 2
Principle
interferometry Fig.1. Graphical
representation
of
the
difference
of
the measurement range covered by smaller (𝜆1, 𝜆2) and larger
(𝜆𝑠𝑦𝑛𝑡ℎ) wavelength. [9] In single-wavelength technique, when the object of
investigation is thicker than the laser wavelength (in our
case the temperature range that can be mapped surpasses
the range of measurement) used for research, the phase
gets wrapped and suffers from 2π ambiguities. The range
of measurement is directly connected to the wavelength. Let the change in refractive index that the wave
experiences while passing through a heat field be
expressed as 𝜑(𝑥, 𝑦), then the interference pattern on the
CCD camera is proportional to: For smaller wavelengths, the range decreases, while for
longer wavelengths it increases [4]. Longer wavelengths
produce fewer fringes, reducing the number of 2π
ambiguities [9]. Phase has a periodicity of 2π radians and
the phase of light can be expressed as a multiple of this
2π periodicity. The repetitive nature of light propagation
as wave in the form of a sinusoidal wave makes the
range of clear unambiguous measurement to be limited
to one cycle of repetition, i.e. one wavelength. Due to
Nyquist criteria, the real range of unambiguity is limited
to a half-wavelength [10]. In other words, the wrapping
is a direct consequence of the 2π periodicity of the
𝑎𝑟𝑐𝑡𝑎𝑛 function used to extract the phase profile from
the light that is being measured [4,11]. During the phase
unwrapping process, the absolute phase difference
between points of measurement in time and space must
be less than the value of π radians for a better
unwrapping [12]. There are cases when the difference is
much higher, causing multiple wrapping simultaneously. Care must be taken when dealing with such situations. 𝐼(𝑥, 𝑦)~ cos [2𝜋𝜑(𝑥, 𝑦) ( 1
𝜆1
−1
𝜆2
)]
(1) (1) , which leads to what is called the synthetic wavelength
(or equivalent/beat wavelength) [13,14]: 1
𝛬𝑒𝑞
= 1
𝜆1
−1
𝜆2
= 𝜆2 −𝜆1
𝜆1𝜆2
⇒𝛬𝑒𝑞= 𝛬12 =
𝜆1𝜆2
|𝜆2 −𝜆1|
( (2) From (2), it can be seen that the smaller the
difference in the dominator, the larger the synthetic
wavelength will be. This implies that, if the two lasers
have a smaller difference in wavelengths, then the new
range of unambiguous measurement will increase. 1 Introduction It makes it possible to measure in real time phenomena
that cause large phase changes without ambiguity. Thus,
by using two lasers or more, the range of unambiguity
can be increased compared to using a single laser [1]. The disadvantage of this technique is that any noise
present in the phase profile of any of the wavelengths
will get amplified by a magnification factor equal to one
of the synthetic wavelength [4]. Off-axis configuration
spatially separates the holographic images away from the
undiffracted zero order. [5,6] EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022)
EFM 2021 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022) https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226401009 Two-wavelength interferometry can be used in many
areas of optical metrology, such as for the measurement
of the thickness and surface profile/inspections of
objects [3]. It can be used in research dealing with
samples having large topographical changes and
biological samples [7]. unambiguous measurement can be extended at the cost
of increasing noise by the factor of the ratio between the
synthetic/equivalent
wavelength
and
the
shortest
wavelength 𝛬𝑒𝑞/𝜆1, thus decreasing the sensitivity of the
technique for the same factor. In length measurement,
this is reflected as increase of uncertainty measurement. [1,4] Due to its extended unambiguity range, high-speed
acquiring and large field of view, the method will be
applied for investigation of high-speed flow in planar
blade cascades, namely for studying dynamic events
during transonic and supersonic blade flutter. Fig.1. Graphical
representation
of
the
difference
of
the measurement range covered by smaller (𝜆1, 𝜆2) and larger
(𝜆𝑠𝑦𝑛𝑡ℎ) wavelength. [9] In
interferometry,
specifically
phase-shifting
interferometry, at least three intensity maps are needed
to resolve the phase map, while in two-wavelength
interferometry it is six but can be decreased to two. [8] 2
Principle
interferometry [5,9] For the case of multiple-wavelength interferometry,
the synthetic wavelength can be defined as [15,6]: 𝛬𝑒𝑞=
𝜆1𝜆𝑛
|𝜆𝑛−𝜆1|
(3) (3) The sole idea of using a two-wavelength technique
comes from the limitations mentioned above. In two-
wavelength or multiple-wavelength interferometry, the
unambiguous range of measurements gets extended by
what is called the synthetic wavelength [1,11]. The
general graphical concept representation is shown in the
following fig.1. , where subscript 𝑛 represents the number of lasers used. , where subscript 𝑛 represents the number of lasers used. 3 Unwrapping Phase unwrapping has been extensively studied and
adapted for many different applications. Different
techniques that require phase unwrapping process are
magnetic resonance [16], x-ray crystallography [17],
synthetic aperture radar (SAR) [18] etc. A requirement that must be fulfilled for such optical
technique is that the optical path from all beams must be
the same. This condition can create some difficulties in
the building of the optical setup, and sometimes it can
turn out to be expensive [2]. Hence, appropriate
geometrical setup must be found in order to
accommodate this condition. There exist many different techniques to extract the
phase distribution from the fringe pattern, such as phase-
shifting profilometry, Fourier transform profilometry,
windowed Fourier transform profilometry etc. Highest
resolution and accuracy are provided through the first A disadvantage of this technique is that, despite
ambiguity being solved (reduced), the range of 2 2 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022)
EFM 2021 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022) https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226401009 large phase changes (in the case of profile measurements
coming from high discontinuities) can be studied. The
simplest one is the Gray-code temporal phase
unwrapping. Other techniques, for example that use
additional wrapped phase maps that differ from their
fringe order to unwrap temporally the phase map, can be
categorized
into
three
groups:
multiwavelength
(heterodyne), multifrequency (hierarchical) and number-
theoretical approach. A detailed review over these three
techniques has been published, according to which, this
group outperforms the Gray-code algorithm in accuracy,
pattern efficiency and unambiguous range. [8] technique, phase-shifting profilometry [19]. Phase-
shifting interferometry is not suitable for measuring
dynamic phenomena because it requires at least three
holograms to be recorded in order to solve the equations
to retrieve the coefficients [11]. Phase unwrapping process has some requirements
when it comes to the noise and the discontinuity the
phase might have. The easiest way is usually to use one
of the 2π phase unwrapping algorithms, but in certain
cases not the same algorithms are valid for different
kinds of wrappings. Unwrapping algorithms usually are
heavy computational wise and can be subject of failure
where the object or phenomena under study has large
irregularities. 3 Unwrapping The interference pattern on the CCD camera can also
be expressed as [11,10]: In the cases when the phenomena is restricted to a
small confinement in the image, the edge of the image
where no change has occurred can be chosen as the
starting
point
for
phase
unwrapping,
since
interferometric measurement require at least one point
where the phase change is known. [11] 𝐼(𝑥, 𝑦) = 𝐴(𝑥, 𝑦) +
+ ∑𝐵𝑖(𝑥, 𝑦) cos{𝜑𝑙(𝑥, 𝑦) + 2𝜋𝑓𝑙𝑥}
2
𝑙=1
=
= 𝐴(𝑥, 𝑦) +
+𝐵1(𝑥, 𝑦) cos{𝜑1(𝑥, 𝑦) + 2𝜋𝑓1𝑥+ 2𝜋𝑓1𝑦} +
+𝐵2(𝑥, 𝑦) cos{𝜑2(𝑥, 𝑦) + 2𝜋𝑓2𝑥+ 2𝜋𝑓2𝑦} (4) The basic idea of phase unwrapping consists on
dividing the phase image into horizontal line, which are
then unwrapped pixel by pixel by adding or subtracting
the offset (2π radians) when necessary. This is done
separately for each of the lines. Once this is done, the
same process happens, but vertically. At the end the
phase image will be unwrapped in 2D [12]. , where 𝐴(𝑥, 𝑦) is the background intensity and pattern
brightness, 𝐵(𝑥, 𝑦) is the intensity modulation and 𝑓1, 𝑓2
are the carrier frequencies. This is known as spatial
carrier frequency interferometry. The relation between
the interference phase and the refractive index variation
is given in (5). If we assume no variation of the
refractive index 𝑛 in the direction of propagation, then
the integral simplifies in multiplication only: By having the difference of the two wrapped phase
profiles created from both wavelengths, a new wrapped
phase profile arises. This new phase profile ‘’belongs’’
to a much greater wavelength, which we called
previously as the synthetic wavelength. The synthetic
wavelength is used to resolve the ambiguity by detecting
the average phase shift (by calculating the fringe order)
while using the lower laser wavelength to measure the
temperature. 𝜑(𝑥, 𝑦) = 2𝜋
𝜆∫∆𝑛(𝑥, 𝑦, 𝑧)𝑑𝑠
𝐿
= 2𝜋
𝜆∆𝑛(𝑥, 𝑦)𝐿
(5) (5) , where 𝑑𝑠 denotes the differential distance along the line
of integration 𝐿. The wrapped phase is extracted by: Based on the dependence of the path, there are path
dependent and path independent phase unwrapping
techniques. In path dependent techniques, image
processing is used to detect the edges and the phase
ambiguities, and from that to calculate the offset that
must be added or subtracted, while in path independent
techniques the regions where error could be caused are
eliminated before the phase unwrap process starts. 3 Unwrapping [9] 𝜑(𝑥, 𝑦) = arg{𝐼(𝑥, 𝑦)} = arctan (
𝐼𝑚{𝐼(𝑥,𝑦)}
𝑅𝑒{𝐼(𝑥,𝑦)})
(6) (6) (6) The basic idea of unwrapping consists of shifting
back to its place each phase jump by adding or
subtracting integer multiples of 2π radians, in order to
draw the phase as a continuous function (without the
jumps, causing this characteristic sawtooth/triangle form
of the phase), which can be expressed as: Spatial phase unwrapping, from its name, uses the
relationship between the phase information of the spatial
neighboring pixels [19,20]. There exist different kinds of
spatial unwrapping algorithms, notably the Goldstein’s
method, Flynns’ method etc. 𝜃(𝑥, 𝑦) = 𝜑(𝑥, 𝑦) + 2𝜋𝑁(𝑥, 𝑦)
(7) (7) Determining
the
fringe
order
from
spatial
neighboring pixels is not possible in the spatial phase
unwrapping since it is based on the information that
neighboring pixels have. The main idea is to retrieve as fast and accurately
possible the fringe order term 𝑁(𝑥, 𝑦) for each of the
pixels of the camera. We can make of use the extended
range of unambiguous measurement from the synthetic
wavelength and the accurate measurement of single
wavelength phase that doesn’t suffer from noise
amplification to unwrap the original phase profile. There
are several ways of how to do it and different technique
corresponding to different applications. The most
straightforward way of unwrapping is to make use of the
synthetic phase profile in order to extract the average The necessity of temporal phase unwrapping plays in
when we need to unwrap a general phase map with large
discontinuities. The fact that each pixel is unwrapped
independently from its neighbor makes that any present
noise in one of the pixels not to spread to other pixels
during the process of unwrapping. There are also
different
kinds
of
temporal
phase
unwrapping
algorithms, and the advantage of using temporal
unwrapping stands from the fact that phenomena with 3 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022) https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226401009 EFM 2021 Fig.2. The two-wavelength lensless measuring system:
LAS-laser, FS-fiber splitter, DIF-diffuser, MA-measured area,
OB-object of investigation, RB-reference beam, CAM-camera . phase shift (fringe order). 3 Unwrapping By making use of the average
operator 〈
〉 the procedure can be mathematically
represented as: 𝑁= 𝑟𝑜𝑢𝑛𝑑(
〈𝜑𝑠𝑦𝑛𝑡ℎ
𝛬𝑒𝑞
𝜆2 〉−〈𝜑2〉
2𝜋
)
(8) 𝑁= 𝑟𝑜𝑢𝑛𝑑(
〈𝜑𝑠𝑦𝑛𝑡ℎ
𝛬𝑒𝑞
𝜆2 〉−〈𝜑2〉
2𝜋
)
(8) (8) Other unwrapping procedures are for example the
hierarchical temporal phase unwrapping which uses one
of the wavelength’s phase map, usually the one with the
shortest wavelength. It unwraps the phase map with the
help of additional wrapped phase maps which have
different fringe orders. Temporal processing is for
relatively slowly developing phenomena. It is worth saying that, for any kind of phase
unwrapping algorithm, if the process is successful, the
final accuracy will be identical. The difference between
hierarchical and multiwavelength unwrapping lays in
that that the first uses one of the wavelengths for the
process of unwrap, while the later uses the synthetic
wavelength to start the process of unwrapping. [14] Fig.2. The two-wavelength lensless measuring system:
LAS-laser, FS-fiber splitter, DIF-diffuser, MA-measured area,
OB-object of investigation, RB-reference beam, CAM-camera . Fig.2. The two-wavelength lensless measuring system:
LAS-laser, FS-fiber splitter, DIF-diffuser, MA-measured area,
OB-object of investigation, RB-reference beam, CAM-camera . Two lasers of wavelengths 𝜆1 = 773𝑛𝑚 and 𝜆2 =
780𝑛𝑚 were employed for the measurement. According to (2), this gives rise to a synthetic
wavelength of 𝛬𝑒𝑞= 86134.28𝑛𝑚 The information that was measured from both
wavelengths is retrieved in the reconstructed phase field. Both phase information have different dimensions in the
Fourier spectrum, thus they must be cropped and resized
in order to be used for the obtention of the synthetic
phase field. This means that the size of pixels in both
fields must be the same. This is achieved by resizing one
of the phase fields, using the equation: 5 Results and discussion Fig.3. Reconstructed phase field map at some time instant. ∆𝜉2
′ = 𝜆1
𝜆2
∆𝜉2
(9) (9) , where ∆𝜉2 denotes the sampling interval before
compensation. Linear
interpolation
between
neighbouring pixel values is adopted to determine the
value of the compensated pixel. , where ∆𝜉2 denotes the sampling interval before
compensation. Linear
interpolation
between
neighbouring pixel values is adopted to determine the
value of the compensated pixel. 4 Optical setup represents the corrected phase map coming
from 𝜆2 based on (7). The phase field that had 2π jumps
is now corrected and represents visually a continuous
phase map. a)
b)
Fig.7. a) Synthetic phase field map at some time instant and b)
phase profile run across the phase field. Fig.7. represents the fictional synthetic phase map
which the CCD camera would have “seen” if a laser with
wavelength 𝛬𝑒𝑞would have been used. In our case, since
M 2021 a)
b)
Fig.4. a) Reconstructed phase field map at some time instant
from 𝜆1 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase
field horizontally and vertically through the origin axis. a)
b)
Fig.6. a) Corrected phase field map at some time instant from
𝜆2 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase field
horizontally and vertically through the origin axis a)
b)
Fig.6. a) Corrected phase field map at some time instant from
𝜆2 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase field
horizontally and vertically through the origin axis a) a) b) b) b) b) Fig.4. a) Reconstructed phase field map at some time instant
from 𝜆1 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase
field horizontally and vertically through the origin axis. Fig.6. a) Corrected phase field map at some time instant from
𝜆2 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase field
horizontally and vertically through the origin axis Fig.6. represents the corrected phase map coming
from 𝜆2 based on (7). The phase field that had 2π jumps
is now corrected and represents visually a continuous
phase map. a)
b)
Fig.5. a) Reconstructed phase field map at some time instant
from 𝜆2 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase
field horizontally and vertically through the origin axis. a) a)
b)
Fig.7. a) Synthetic phase field map at some time instant and b)
phase profile run across the phase field. a) b) b) b) Fig.5. a) Reconstructed phase field map at some time instant
from 𝜆2 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase
field horizontally and vertically through the origin axis. Fig.4. and fig.5. represent the reconstructed phase
field map for each of the wavelengths. The background
is masked out and only the physical field of view is
shown. 4 Optical setup Fig.3. Reconstructed phase field map at some time instant. Fig.2. represents the experimental lensless Fourier
optical setup used to conduct this experiment. Two fiber
coupled DFB (distributed feedback) laser diodes having
different wavelengths are used. Light is split into the
reference (RB1, RB2) and object beams (OB1, OB2) by
means of fibersplitters. The object beams are combined
and are collimated by a lens to then fall onto the diffuser. Scattered light from the diffuser passes through the
measured area (MA) to combine with reference beams
and be recorded by the camera (CAM). Both reference
beams form angles with respect to the axis of
propagation. It is these angles that introduce the spatial
carrier frequencies that make it possible to separate
phase information. Fig.3. represents the reconstructed phase field map
recorded by the CCD camera at some time instant. Each
recorded phase field is represented in a conjugated pair. The introduction of spatial carriers through the
introduction of the angle between each of the reference
wave and the axis of propagation has introduced enough
separation so that the set of conjugated phase pairs don’t
overlap and can be filtered out confidently (i.e. off-axis
arrangement). Any of the identical but conjugated pair
carries the same valuable phase information used for
further analysis. Any sudden change of the color red-
blue indicates a 2π jump. 4 4 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022)
EFM 2021 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022) https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226401009 a)
b)
Fig.4. a) Reconstructed phase field map at some time instant
from 𝜆1 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase
field horizontally and vertically through the origin axis. a)
b)
Fig.5. a) Reconstructed phase field map at some time instant
from 𝜆2 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase
field horizontally and vertically through the origin axis. Fig.4. and fig.5. represent the reconstructed phase
field map for each of the wavelengths. The background
is masked out and only the physical field of view is
shown. For different wavelengths, the camera “sees”
different phase values, thus making the profile look
different as what is seen from the other wavelength The
a)
b)
Fig.6. a) Corrected phase field map at some time instant from
𝜆2 and b) plot of the phase profile run across the phase field
horizontally and vertically through the origin axis
Fig.6. 6 Conclusions Through the phase field map of either 𝜆1 or 𝜆2, the
refrative index distribution can be obtained via (5)
assuming a 2D distribution field of the refractive index. A distribution of the refractive index at some instant is
shown in fig.8. Notice that digital holographic
interferometry is able to detect very small changes in the
refractive index cause by external influence (in this case
heat gradient). This paper introduces a new approach to measure
dynamic processes in fluid mechanics using lensless
Fourier digital holographic interferometry with extended
dynamic range. The investigation specifically deals with
measuring the temperature field created from a resistor. The temperature is estimated through the optical phase,
which was captured by a CCD camera. The captured
phase is wrapped due to 2π limitations coming from the
bounded nature of light and the two-wavelength
technique deals in solving the phase ambiguity and
determining the absolute phase values. This paper introduces a new approach to measure
dynamic processes in fluid mechanics using lensless
Fourier digital holographic interferometry with extended
dynamic range. The investigation specifically deals with
measuring the temperature field created from a resistor. The temperature is estimated through the optical phase,
which was captured by a CCD camera. The captured
phase is wrapped due to 2π limitations coming from the
bounded nature of light and the two-wavelength
technique deals in solving the phase ambiguity and
determining the absolute phase values. Through the determination of the refractive index,
many
other
important
parameters
such
as
the
temperature, density, fluid velocity etc. can be
determined. This allows for the study of fluid and gases
and phenomena related to. An interesting application of
such technique could prove useful for the study of
shockwaves around blade cascade in wind tunnels. Flow
in wind tunnels are supersonic and demonstrate high
levels of pressure and velocities. Such high gradients
cause many fold wrapping of the phase. The use of a
two-wavelength technique could therefore help in
studying e.g. dynamic events during transonic and
supersonic blade flutter. A key factor in this investigation is the use of two
wavelengths and the recording of digital holograms from
both wavelengths in one shot. We showed that the
spectral separation of the phase information from both
wavelengths can be achieved when the hardware of the
experimental arrangement (angles of the reference
waves) is properly adjusted [11]. 4 Optical setup For different wavelengths, the camera “sees”
different phase values, thus making the profile look
different as what is seen from the other wavelength. The
phase profile was plotted for both phase field maps,
passing by the origin axis for both horizontal and vertical
profiles. Clear phase jumps can be seen in the horizontal
cut of fig.4. as indicated in fig.4.b) while the phase
profile across the vertical cut of the phase field is
smoother and no noticeable jump can be observed. Fig.7. a) Synthetic phase field map at some time instant and b)
phase profile run across the phase field. Fig.7. represents the fictional synthetic phase map
which the CCD camera would have “seen” if a laser with
wavelength 𝛬𝑒𝑞 would have been used. In our case, since
the heat gradient wasn’t high, the synthetic phase map
manifests itself with relatively smooth flat profile. It is
worth noting that even the synthetic phase map can
present phase jumps if the range of measurement is
exceeded. The synthetic phase map however obscures
phenomena that cause relatively small phase changes. 5 5 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022)
EFM 2021 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022) https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226401009 a)
b)
Fig.8. a) Refractive index field map at some time instant and
b) refractive index profile run across the field. a)
b)
Fig.9. a) Reconstructed temperature field map 𝑇(𝑥, 𝑦) at some
time instant and b) temperature profile run across the field. a) a) b) b) Fig.9. a) Reconstructed temperature field map 𝑇(𝑥, 𝑦) at some
time instant and b) temperature profile run across the field. Fig.8. a) Refractive index field map at some time instant and
b) refractive index profile run across the field. References [1] Meiners-Hagen, K., Schödel, R., Pollinger, F. &
Abou-Zeid, A. Multi-wavelength interferometry
for length measurements using diode lasers. Meas. Sci. Rev. 9, 16–26 (2009). g
p
g
(
)
[15] Kreis,
T. Handbook
of
Holographic
Interferometry: Optical and Digital Methods. Handbook of Holographic Interferometry:
Optical and Digital Methods (Wiley, 2004). doi:10.1002/3527604154. [2] Guo, T., Li, F., Chen, J., Fu, X. & Hu, X. Multi-
wavelength phase-shifting interferometry for
micro-structures measurement based on color
image processing in white light interference. Opt. Lasers Eng. 82, 41–47 (2016). [16] Chavez,
S.,
Xiang,
Q. S. &
An,
L. Understanding phase maps in MRI: a new
cutline phase unwrapping method. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging 21, 966–977 (2002). [3] Turko, N. A., Eravuchira, P. J., Barnea, I. &
Shaked, N. T. Simultaneous three-wavelength
unwrapping using external digital holographic
multiplexing module. Opt. Lett. Vol. 43, Issue
9, pp. 1943-1946 43, 1943–1946 (2018). [17] Momose, A. Recent Advances in X-ray Phase
Imaging. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 44, 6355–6367
(2005). [18] Pritt, M. D. Phase unwrapping by means of
multigrid techniques for interferometric SAR. IEEE Trans. Geosci. Remote Sens. 34, 728738
(1996). [4] Turko, N. A. & Shaked, N. T. Simultaneous
two-wavelength phase unwrapping using an
external module for multiplexing off-axis
holography. Opt. Lett. 42, 73–76 (2017). (
)
[19] Yin, W. et al. High-speed three-dimensional
shape measurement using geometry-constraint-
based number-theoretical phase unwrapping. Opt. Lasers Eng. 115, 21–31 (2019). [5] Parshall, D. & Kim, M. K. Digital holographic
microscopy
with
dual-wavelength
phase
unwrapping. Appl. Opt. Vol. 45, Issue 3, pp. 451-459 45, 451–459 (2006). [20] Lu, L., Jia, Z., Luan, Y. & Xi, J. Reconstruction
of isolated moving objects with high 3D frame
rate based on phase shifting profilometry. Opt. Commun. 438, 61–66 (2019). [6] Jaedicke, V. et al. Multiwavelength phase
unwrapping and aberration correction using
depth filtered digital holography. Opt. Lett. 39,
4160–4163 (2014). [21] K, H. & F, C. Two-wavelength interferometry:
extended range and accurate optical path
difference analytical estimator. J. Opt. Soc. Am. A. Opt. Image Sci. Vis. 26, 2503 (2009). [7] Khmaladze, A., Kim, M. & Lo, C.-M. Phase
imaging of cells by simultaneous dual-
wavelength reflection digital holography. Opt. Express 16, 10900 (2008). [8] Zuo, C., Huang, L., Zhang, M., Chen, Q. &
Asundi,
A. Temporal
phase
unwrapping
algorithms for fringe projection profilometry: A
comparative review. Opt. Lasers Eng. 85, 84–
103 (2016). [9] Warnasooriya, N. & Kim, M. K. 6 Conclusions The difference between
the measured phase fields yields in a synthetic phase that
has significantly larger dynamic range of measurement
[21]. Such range covers large changes of the measured
quantity as it was demonstrated in our investigation. However, the synthetic phase is more influenced by
noise. By combining the synthetic phase and the phase
obtained from the single wavelength, we can achieve the
same accuracy as single wavelength technique but with a
significantly higher range of measurement. This method
is applicable to dynamic processes in fluid mechanics
and could be applied for further studies of dynamic
events during transonic and supersonic blade flutter in
wind tunnels. Fig.9. represents the temperature change field
calculated by making use of 𝜆2. It was calculated using
the following mathematical relation : 𝑇(𝑥, 𝑦) = 𝜆2 ∙𝜑(𝑥, 𝑦)
2𝜋𝐿𝑑𝑛
𝑑𝑇
(10) (10) , where 𝐿= 20𝑚𝑚 is the estimated object length and
𝑑𝑛
𝑑𝑇= −0.9617 ∙10−6 ℃−1 [15] is the change of
refractive index per unit temperature. But, this temperature was measured as a reference to
the starting temperature 𝑇0 = 20℃ in our case. Thus, the
absolute temperature can be calculated as: The advantages of such technique are its simplicity,
fast acquisition, processing and displaying results, even
in real time and in combination with the two-wavelength
technique the unambiguous range of measurement is
considerably increased without amplifying the noise. 𝑇𝑎𝑏𝑠(𝑥, 𝑦) = 𝑇0 + 𝑇(𝑥, 𝑦)
(11) (11) 𝑇𝑎𝑏𝑠(𝑥, 𝑦) = 𝑇0 + 𝑇(𝑥, 𝑦) 6 6 https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226401009 EPJ Web of Conferences 264, 01009 (2022) EFM 2021 processes in fluid mechanics. in 5-6th Thermal
and Fluids Engineering Conference (TFEC) -
American Society of Thermal and Fluids
Engineers (Begell House Publishers, Inc.,
2021). Acknowledgment This research was supported by the Ministry of
Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic
– program Inter-Excellence, project No. LTAUSA19036. This research was supported by the Ministry of
Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic – program Inter-Excellence, project No. LTAUSA19036. [14] [14] Wagner, C., Osten, W. & Seebacher, S. Direct
shape measurement by digital
wavefront
reconstruction
and
multi-wavelength
contouring. Opt. Eng. 39, 79–85 (2000). References Quantitative
Phase
Imaging
Using
Multi-Wavelength
Optical Phase Unwrapping. Adv. Lasers Electro
Opt. (2010) doi:10.5772/8668. [10] Onodera, R. & Ishii, Y. Two-wavelength
interferometry that uses a Fourier-transform
method. Appl. Opt. 37, 7988–7994 (1998). pp
p
(
)
[11] Psota, P., Doleček, R., Lédl, V. & Vít, T. Dynamic interferometric measurement with
extended
unambiguity
range
in
flow
measurement. EPJ Web Conf. 180, 02087
(2018). [12] Cheng, Y.-Y. & Wyant, J. C. Two-wavelength
phase shifting interferometry. Appl. Opt. 23,
4539–4543 (1984). [13] Psota, P., Cubreli, G., Kredba, J., Stasik, M. &
Ledl, V. Two wavelength digital holographic
interferometry for investigation of dynamic 7
|
https://openalex.org/W2314805453
|
https://revistas.uepg.br/index.php/uniletras/article/download/673/1289/4832
|
Portuguese
| null |
ROMANCEIRO DA INCONFIDENCIA: PODER E LITERATURA
|
Uniletras
| 2,009
|
cc-by
| 7,288
|
Romanceiro da Indonfi dência: power and
literature Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan
* Resumo: Este artigo tem como objetivo principal analisar o livro Romanceiro da Inconfi dência,
de Cecília Meireles, sob duas perspectivas, a literária e a jurídica. Isso porque a obra, para além de
retomar literariamente um episódio da história do Brasil, também, indiretamente, empreende uma
discussão em torno da questão jurídica na colônia (por extensão à perda das liberdades individuais
em períodos ditatoriais). Procuramos, pois, dar ênfase aos aspectos da obra que tratam da oposição
entre liberdade e opressão, tendo como ponto de fundo as Ordenações Filipinas. p
p
Palavras-chave: Direito. Literatura. Cecília Meireles. Abstract: This article has as main objective to analyze the book of Cecília Meireles, Romanceiro
da Inconfi ência, from two perspectives, the Literary and jurisdictions. That’s because the poem
incorporates a fact of the story of Brazil, and indirectly initiates a discussion around the issues in
separate legal Colony (for extensive loss of individual freedoms in dictatorial periods). We seek,
therefore, give emphasis to aspects of the poem dealing with oposio between freedom and tyranny,
having as a background the Ordernações Filipinas. Keywords: Law. Literature. Cecília Meireles. Doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.5212/Uniletras.v.31i1.181199 Doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.5212/Uniletras.v.31i1.181199 CDD. 801 * Doutor em Letras.Universidade do Norte do Paraná. E-mail: celso.pagnan@unopar.br Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 1 Introdução O presente artigo se insere em um projeto mais amplo que é o de
propor uma pesquisa em torno das relações que podem ser estabelecidas entre
o texto literário e o jurídico em três frentes principais: a presença do direito
positivo em diferentes obras literárias, a recorrência a técnicas literárias na
redação de códigos jurídicos e a consequente semelhança entre os processos
interpretativos, de ambos os universos, por parte do leitor. Embora a ênfase
da pesquisa seja a análise da primeira frente, as outras duas serão recorren-
tes. O corpus compreende a análise de três obras: Canaã (1902), de Graça
Aranha, Romanceiro da Inconfi dência (1953), de Cecília Meireles, e Os sinos
da agonia (1974), de Autran Dourado. Os três livros encerram questões de
ordem jurídica. Enquanto os dois últimos versam, direta ou indiretamente, a Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan respeito da devassa causada pela Inconfi dência mineira, o primeiro trata de
um julgamento de uma moça negra, pobre, acusada de infanticídio. Aqueles
recuperam, pois, o contexto das Ordenações Filipinas, especialmente o livro
V, ao passo que Canaã tem como referência o Código Penal da República,
promulgado em 1890. O que se pretende é analisar e comparar até que ponto
os textos literários refl etem as codifi cações jurídicas, e como são meios de
levar o leitor a refl etir sobre a organização social, sobre o que é justo e o que
é a democracia. Podemos estabelecer uma distinção até certo ponto óbvia: Literatu-
ra é fi cção, e Direito meio de produzir as normas para o convívio social no
mundo real. Também é bastante óbvio que um escritor, para produzir um texto
literário, tende a se basear na realidade (ainda que lhe seja permitido criar um
mundo todo fantasioso, surreal, o ponto de apoio, a referência, será sempre o
mundo real). O jurista ou o legislador, por sua vez, para produzir um artigo
de lei, observa a necessidade de acordo com o que ocorre na realidade. O
que intermedeia o papel de ambos, escritor e jurista, é a linguagem. Segundo
Roland Barthes (2001), Direito e Retórica (literatura) têm origens comuns. No mundo clássico grego, em um julgamento sobre a propriedade de terras,
recursos próprios da literatura foram utilizados para persuadir os litigantes. Há outros diversos exemplos que poderiam ser lembrados. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 1 Introdução Assim, a despeito
dos objetivos pragmáticos serem diferentes, direito e literatura teriam vários
pontos de contato. Há, nas letras, diversos pontos estabelecidos entre literatura
e psicanálise, literatura e história, literatura e sociologia, mas faltava uma
relação mais direta entre literatura e direito. Tal movimento desde os anos 70
se tornou comum nos EUA, e, no Brasil, tem se verifi cado o desenvolvimento,
embora tímido, de uma aproximação entre os campos. Godoy (2008) explicita os pontos de contato estabelecidos ao longo
dos últimos quarenta anos entre Direito e Literatura, bem como demonstra os
fundamentos que nortearam tal aproximação. O argumento básico é que há
diversas obras literárias que problematizam deliberadamente tal aproximação. Apenas como exemplo, podemos citar O processo, de Franz Kafka, que analisa
os efeitos da burocracia e das leis na vida dos indivíduos. É preciso sempre ter
em mente dois pontos essenciais: “[...] literatura é uma instituição social que
utiliza, como meio de expressão específi co a linguagem – que é criação social”. (WELLEK; WARREN, 1955, p. 117). Assim também se apresenta o Direito,
que tem uma função social óbvia e se expressa por meio de uma linguagem. A
partir desse ponto, é que os defensores da aproximação entre Direito e Litera- Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 182 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura tura desenvolve sua argumentação. Em particular Dworkin (2007), para quem
o processo hermenêutico da literatura se aproxima e muito da hermenêutica
jurídica. Em outros termos, os textos jurídico e literário são letra morta até o
momento em que passam pela interpretação; o segundo se presta à refl exão
da sociedade, ao passo que o primeiro à ordenação dessa mesma sociedade. Ambas as ações mediadas pela linguagem. E se a interpretação nem sempre é
a mesma, a explicação se encontra nas condições contextuais. Tanto um texto
literário, quanto uma norma jurídica podem sofrer modifi cações interpretativas
conforme o momento, conforme o local, evidentemente que se respeitando os
limites fornecidos pelo texto. A sociedade é bastante complexa e a literatura tem como uma de suas
funções a interpretação da realidade, ainda que por meio de um olhar limitado
que é a do escritor individual. Ainda assim, ao construir personagens díspa-
res, tem essa função facilitada tendo em vista que quer expressar os diversos
discursos sociais. Dessa feita, o estudo literário é realizado, quase que por
imposição, por meio da interdisciplinaridade. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 2 Romanceiro: uma visão jurídica A carreira literária de Cecília Meireles se dá com a publicação de
Espectros, em 1919, mas sua maturidade como poetisa se concretiza em 1939,
com o livro Viagens. Basicamente, procurou escrever poemas que abordassem
questões existenciais, a efemeridade da vida, a afi rmação da espiritualidade,
enfi m temas sem conotação essencialmente político-social, como ocorre com
outros poemas. Por esse motivo, a publicação de Romanceiro da Inconfi dên-
cia em 1953 deve ter causado estranheza a quem acompanhava sua produção
poética, isso porque se trata de um livro de caráter político, ainda que o tempo
fugidio esteja bem presente ao longo dos romances do livro. Até pelo título, é
possível perceber essa intenção política e a própria temática do livro, ou seja,
a Inconfi dência ou Conjuração mineira, que se deu em fi ns do século XVIII,
mais precisamente em 1789. Na verdade, a narrativa do poema se inicia bem antes dessa data; faz
referência à descoberta do ouro e de pedras preciosas nas Minas Gerais, à época
ainda ligada à Capitania de São Paulo, tematiza também um pouco a vida do
comendador João Fernandes, responsável pela extração de diamantes em Tijuco
(atual Diamantina) e que se casou com uma negra alforriada chamada Chica
da Silva, também referida no poema; o ponto alto do livro é a Inconfi dência,
com ênfase ao momento da delação, busca e captura dos inconfi dentes e as
respectivas punições. Evidente que a autora não analisa ou tematiza todos os pormenores,
mesmo porque estamos diante de uma obra literária e não de um estudo
histórico, mas procura captar o que a história desses acontecimentos legou
para a posteridade, até para seguir um dos pontos fortes de sua produção que
é a captação da essência da vida. Conforme diz a própria Meireles (2005, p. XXV): “A obra de arte não é feita de tudo – mas apenas de algumas coisas
essenciais”. Os romances seguem uma ordem cronológica ainda que fragmentada. Mesmo assim, é possível estabelecer relações entre a visão que se expressa
no texto e os acontecimentos históricos. Por exemplo, verifi cam-se o ciclo do
ouro e o do diamante. Em ambos, temos a dicotomia principal sob a qual se
assenta o texto: escravidão e liberdade. 1 Introdução O direito, por sua vez, tende a
congregar a média discursiva dos anseios sociais, uma vez que uma lei é criada
a partir das discussões envolvendo setores diversos da sociedade, representada
pelos deputados, senadores e juristas. Ora, considerando essa pluralidade de
ideias tanto na concepção legislativa quanto no processo criativo literário,
subentende-se a defesa dos valores democráticos. O foco do presente artigo é o Romanceiro da Inconfi dência, de Cecília
Meireles. Escrito em 1953, tal livro se insere no interregno de duas ditaduras,
quando se imaginava que o país poderia solidifi car sua democracia. O Brasil
estivera sob ditadura até 1945, tendo à frente o presidente Getúlio Vargas. Ironicamente, no ano da publicação do livro, o presidente, então eleito, era
o próprio Getúlio Vargas. Desse modo, fi ca sugerido quão frágil era ainda
essa democracia. Dessa feita, queremos demonstrar que a arte, em particular
a literatura, podem estar a serviço da defesa e da manutenção de uma ordem
democrática. O método para estabelecer as relações entre o contexto vigente,
as leis expressas e as obras literárias é o comparativo. É bem verdade que
teremos como base não uma relação mecânica, causal, e sim dialética, que
estabeleça o diálogo entre as duas áreas da sociedade. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 183 Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura O livro V, das Ordenações Filipinas, em seu Título 6, trata sobre os
crimes de lesa-majestade. Basicamente, apresenta-se a legislação sobre o cri-
me de traição ao Rei e ao Estado, considerado o pior crime se pode cometer. Interessante que em seguida compara-se esse crime à lepra, posto que tanto a
doença quanto o crime não teriam cura de fato. Em seguida, passa a enumerar
os oito tipos de traição. O que nos interessa mais de perto é o quinto tipo: “O
quinto, se algum fi zesse conselho e confederação contra o Rey e se Stado, ou
tratasse de se levantar contra elle, ou para isso desse ajuda, conselho e favor.”
(ORDENAÇÕES, 2009, p. 1153). Em seguida, as Ordenações passam a tratar das penalidades para esse
crime de lesa-majestade. Resumidamente, trata do confi sco dos bens, da morte
para sempre (apesar da tautologia, a ideia era enfatizar que tudo o que se con-
quistara, como honra, bens, títulos, perderia valor, incluindo os descendentes
homens) e do degredo. E sendo o commettedor convencido por cada hum delles, será condena-
do que morra morte natural cruelmente e todos os seus bens que tiver
no tempo da condenação, serão confi scados para a Coroa do Reino,
postoque tenha fi lhos, ou outros descendentes, ou ascendentes, havidos
antes, ou depois de ter commetido, tal malefício. (ORDENAÇÕES,
2009, p. 1154) Para compor os vários momentos da história das Minas, a autora
escolheu o gênero romance. São 85 com métrica e ritmo irregulares. Isso é,
embora predominem as redondilhas (de cinco ou sete sílabas), há também
versos com quatro, seis, oito, dez sílabas. Há também poemas nomeados por
cenários e falas. Os primeiros para ambientar a cena, mostrar ao leitor onde se
passa a história, é como em uma peça de teatro na qual o autor explica como
deve ser preparada a cena. Quanto à fala, presta-se ao leitor para ter contato
mais direto com as explicações e comentários do narrador. Tais cenários, que situam os ambientes, e as falas, em que se tecem
comentários diversos sobre o que se narra, se prestam ao eu que narra, o qual
se revela distante dos acontecimentos; narra como quem recupera o passado e
faz uma leitura desse mesmo tempo. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 2 Romanceiro: uma visão jurídica Escravidão de negros e também dos
colonos, subjugados às leis de Portugal, às Ordenações Filipinas; e liberdade,
o sonho desejado e arquitetado desde o início, na fi gura do negro Chico Rei,
por exemplo, que queria liberdade para ele e para seus pares, e a liberdade
almejada pelos conjurados na segunda metade do século XVIII. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 184 1 Todas as demais referências ao livro pertencem à mesma edição: MEIRELLES, Cecília. Romanceiro
da Inconfi dência. 3ª. ed. Rio de Janeiro: Nova Fronteira, 2005 Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Por exemplo, na fala inicial é como se o
eu do poema, passeando pela Ouro Preto atual, buscasse inspiração e marcas
para entender o passado, descobrir nos interstícios da história, aspectos que
permitam uma interpretação sob olhar moderno. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 185 Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan Aqui, além, pelo mundo,
Ossos, nomes, letras, poeira... Onde, os rostos? Onde, as almas? Nem os herdeiros recordam
Rastro nenhum pelo chão. (2005, p. 5)
1 Em conferência proferida em 1955, exatamente na cidade de Ouro
Preto. sobre o livro publicado há dois anos, a autora diz ter se sentido impelida
a escrever sobre o tema, eram como fantasmas a invadir sua vida, como se
pedissem para que ela contasse a história do que ocorrera em Minas. A própria
explicação do porquê escrever sobre o tema tem um quê de literário, fantasioso. Ainda assim, revela um importante aspecto: o fato de que algumas histórias
simplesmente não terminam; seu signifi cado ecoa nas construções, na memória
coletiva, na imagem construída de um herói nacional como Tiradentes. E é a
partir dessas considerações que inicia os romances: O passado não abre sua porta
e não pode entender a nossa pena. mas, nos campos sem fi m que o sonho corta
vejo uma forma no ar subir serena:
vaga forma, do tempo desprendida. É a mão do Alferes, que de longe acena. (2005, p. 11) É, pois, da perspectiva de alguns personagens da história das Minas,
particularmente da Inconfi dência, que o eu lírico faz suas considerações e
propõe questionamentos, cujas respostas cabe ao leitor buscar. Em vários
momentos, interrompe a narração para tecer algum comentário ou analisar
um acontecimento, como, por exemplo, ocorre no Romance III. O conde jurou no Carmo
Não fazer mal a ninguém. (Vede agora pelo morro
Que palavra o Conte tem! Casas, muro, gente afl ita
No fogo rolando vêm!) (p. 23) 186 Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura A estrofe se refere ao Conde de Assumar, Dom Pedro Miguel de
Almeida Portugal, que governou com mão de ferro a Capitania de São Paulo
e das Minas do Ouro até 1721, quando Minas foi ofi cialmente desmembrada
da Capitania de São Paulo e tornou-se independente. O trecho também revela
a preocupação da autora em poetizar a história das Minas não apenas em seu
momento emblemático, que foi a devassa dos Inconfi dentes, e sim mostrar
como a região foi construída e que personagens contribuíram para isso. Além
disso, ao contar a história de Minas, o leitor percebe que não foi nada idílica, e
sim marcada por traições, roubos e desmandos dos poderosos para enriquecer
ainda mais. Com efeito, entre os romances I e XIX, o leitor toma contato com
alguns personagens importantes da história das Minas. Além do próprio
Conde de Assumar que é referido no Romanceiro como traidor ao dizer que
nada faria contra revoltosos de 1720, e no entanto manda atear fogo em suas
casas no distrito de Vila Rica (Ouro Preto), conforme se verifi ca na estrofe
citada acima. Essa revolta é explicada pelos historiadores como uma de tantas a
respeito dos impostos sobre a extração do ouro e também sobre as leis portu-
gueses que regulamentavam o extrativismo, as quais eram excludentes. Felipe
dos Santos, líder da Revolta, foi enforcado e esquartejado, como seria também
o Alferes Joaquim da Silva Xavier, o Tiradentes, por ocasião da Inconfi dência. Embora parecidos, os episódios não têm o mesmo signifi cado, uma vez que
Felipe era português de origem e não liderara a revolta com fi ns emancipatórios. De qualquer modo, o caso é referido para anunciar o que veria depois e para
ilustrar uma prática comum na corrida pelo ouro nas Minas Gerais. Morreu Felipe dos Santos
E, por castigo exemplar,
Depois de morto na forca,
Mandaram-no esquartejar! (p. 24) Morreu Felipe dos Santos
E, por castigo exemplar,
Depois de morto na forca,
Mandaram-no esquartejar! (p. 24) E adiante, no mesmo Romance V: Dentro do tempo há mais tempo,
E, na roca da ambição,
Vai-se preparando a teia
Dos castigos que virão: Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 187 Há mais forcas, mais suplícios
Para os netos da traição. (p. 24) Os casos de revolta são muitos. 2 A partir de 1740, era preciso um contrato com a Coroa Portuguesa para explorar o ouro ou os diaman-
tes nas Minas Gerais. “Coube o primeiro contrato para extração dos diamantes a João Fernandes de
Oliveira. [...] A arrematação abrangeu um período de 4 anos, de 1º de janeiro de 1740 a 31 de dezembro
de 1743”. (HOLANDA, org., 1993, p. 395). Esse João Fernandes era o pai do João relatado no poema;
fi cou como contratador (explorador de diamantes) entre 1758 e 1771, quando o Marquês de Pombal,
para evitar roubos, criou a Real Extração e extinguiu os contratos. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Do mesmo modo que a Coroa por-
tuguesa exige o pagamento do quinto do que é extraído em pedras preciosas
e ouro, os escravos e trabalhadores contratados, quando podem, desviam seu
quinhão. O narrador relembra o caso, por exemplo, do Chico - Rei, um escravo
que procurara lutar contra a escravidão e a submissão negra de maneira mais
sutil, sem necessariamente pegar em armas. Primeiro, começara a esconder
ouro pelo corpo e, aos poucos, foi juntando o sufi ciente para comprar sua carta
de alforria. Procurou alforriar diversos companheiros dessa forma. Em outras
palavras, roubava para comprar o que haviam lhe roubado: sua liberdade. De-
pois, associou-se à Igreja, e passou a dar dinheiro para a construção da igreja
dedicada à Santa Ifi gênia, princesa da Núbia (Etiópia), que teria se convertido
ao cristianismo por infl uência das pregações de São Mateus. Santa Ifi gênia levanta o facho,
Procura a mina do Chico-Rei:
Negros tão dentro da serra negra
Que a Santa negra quase os não vê. (p. 33) Adiante, a partir do Romance XIII, narra-se a vida de Chica da Silva,
escrava alforriada que veio a se casar com o Contratador João Fernandes,
2
homem poderoso do Tijuco (hoje Diamantina). O objetivo é mostrar que a
ordem portuguesa não era inteiramente respeitada, uma vez que havia a proi-
bição do casamento entre homens livres, brancos e negros escravos. Mesmo
assim, Fernandez desafi ou as leis do seu tempo para casar-se com Chica da
Silva, imortalizada em fi lmes, novelas, ainda que nem sempre retratada da
maneira mais próxima da realidade. Outro objetivo é referir-se, mais uma vez,
à maneira imperialista de lidar com o extrativismo. Fernandes é interpelado
pelo próprio governador das Minas, D. José Luis de Meneses, que governou
a Capitania entre 1768 e 1773, para cobrar-lhe os impostos devidos. Porém, o Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 188 188 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura que se procura revelar é que, na verdade, o governador vem para expropriar
Fernandes de seus bens, a mando do Marquês de Pombal. Fala o conde de má morte:
– Ordens são, que hoje recebo... Fala o Conde mui fi ngido:
– Padece por vós meu zelo:
De um lado, o dever de amigo,
Mas, de outro, a lealdade ao Reino... Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura João Fernandes não responde:
Ouve e recorda em silêncio
O que lhe dissera a Chica,
Em tom de pressentimento. Como as palavras se torcem,
Conforme o interesse e o tempo! (p. 55) Fala o Conde mui fi ngido: – Padece por vós meu zelo: De um lado, o dever de amigo, Mas, de outro, a lealdade ao Reino... João Fernandes não responde: Ouve e recorda em silêncio O que lhe dissera a Chica, Em tom de pressentimento. Conforme o interesse e o tempo! (p. 55) Fernandes foi enviado de volta a Portugal, sem mais voltar ao Tijuco. Morreu em Lisboa no ano de 1779. Trata-se, portanto, de outra situação que contextualiza os tempos
das Minas, da extração, do engano, da cobiça, da traição. O Romance XIX
encerra esse primeiro momento do livro e serve como prenúncio daquilo que
irá se narrar doravante, que, segundo a perspectiva do narrador, será ainda
mais terrível. O livro na verdade não faz uma reavaliação crítica do que se passou em
Minas. Toma como ponto de apoio a história ofi cial que foi sendo construída
a partir de um estudo de Joaquim Norberto, intitulado História da conjuração
mineira, de 1873, e no início da República, em 1890, com a ofi cialização do
dia 21 de abril como dedicado ao Tiradentes. Por outro lado, Meireles usou o
termo inconfi dência no lugar de conjuração, sabendo-se que o primeiro denota
uma falta de fé, uma descrença dos súditos, da perspectiva dos colonizadores
portugueses, ao passo que o segundo denota uma conspiração que indica uma
insatisfação da perspectiva do colonizado. Os historiadores concordam que a insurreição não foi exatamente um
processo bem articulado, feito por letrados, mas antes por pessoas descontentes
com a forma de governar de Portugal. Tal descontentamento encontrou no Al-
feres Joaquim Xavier uma síntese e um divulgador, posto que colaborou para
angariar novos adeptos e formar uma ampla rede de aliança. Também por isso, Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 189 Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan e por sua menor força política, acabou sofrendo muito mais no processo ao ser
condenado à forca e a ser esquartejado como era de praxe à época. O mesmo
castigo de Felipe dos Santos em 1720, conforme previa os itens dispostos no
livro V das Ordenações fi lipinas. Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Outro aspecto que confi rma a obediência do livro aos preceitos erigi-
dos é que Joaquim Norberto colaborou para a construção do mito Tiradentes
relacionando-o à fi gura de Jesus Cristo, traído por um dos seus. Também o
alferes, conforme a história construída, fora traído por um dos inconfi dentes,
Joaquim Silvério. Diz Norberto: Retirou-se o alferes desconsoladíssimo do palácio e em caminho
encontrou-se com o seu mau gênio. Como querendo patentear-se mais
seu amigo do que o mesmo vice-rei, que era da escola do visconde de
Barbacena acerca dos sagrados deveres da amizade, avisou-o o coronel
Joaquim Silvério que tivesse conta em si, que se retirasse, pois que o
vice-rei, informado de suas práticas, andava com grande cuidado sobre
ele, e mais dia menos dia seria preso. Era o beijo do Iscariota! Com
a bolsa recheada do preço da traição vinha sentar-se Judas à mesa de
Jesus Cristo. (SILVA, apud SERELLE, 1999, p. 191). Não queremos ir contra os documentos e o discurso de historiadores
que comprovaram a participação de Silvério para o início da devassa, apenas
discutir a perspectiva que norteou a autora de o Romanceiro. Melhor negócio que Judas
Fazes tu, Joaquim Silvério:
Que ele traiu um simples alferes. Recebeu trinta dinheiros... – e tu muitas coisas pedes:
Pensão para toda a vida,
Perdão para quanto deves,
Comenda para o pescoço,
Honras, glórias, privilégios. E andas tão bem na cobrança
Que quase tudo recebes! (p. 100) Melhor negócio que Judas
Fazes tu, Joaquim Silvério:
Que ele traiu um simples alferes. Recebeu trinta dinheiros... – e tu muitas coisas pedes:
Pensão para toda a vida,
Perdão para quanto deves,
Comenda para o pescoço,
Honras, glórias, privilégios. E andas tão bem na cobrança
Que quase tudo recebes! (p. 100) Embora haja essa imagem de Silvério/Judas, ao que parece, porém,
Joaquim Silvério não teria participado, com efeito, da Inconfi dência, e sim Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 190 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura ouvido falar pela boca de um e de outro e, sobretudo, pela boca do próprio
Tiradentes, que, segundo consta, era muito falastrão. 3 De qualquer modo, em apoio a essa associação entre Cristo libertador
dos homens, Tiradentes libertador do Brasil, traídos ambos, mortos ambos,
há o fato de que o processo que defl agrou a devassa contra os inconfi dentes
se iniciou na Semana Santa de 1789. 3 “A sua atenção (do Tiradentes) dirigiu-se principalmente àqueles que tinham motivos específi cos de
queixa contra a administração portuguesa, destacando-se, entre eles, os devedores do Erário Régio. Foi
assim que a notícia do levante [...] chegou ao conhecimento do Coronel Silvério dos Reis, contratador
que devia grossas somas à Fazenda Real”. (HOLANDA, org., 1993, p. 400. Cf. Inquietação revolucio-
nária no Sul: conjuração mineira). 4 Ibidem, p. 404. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Uma coincidência bem utilizada pelos
republicanos positivistas. Nos romances XX e XXI, com que inicia a narração dos acontecimen-
tos em torno da conjuração, vemos a contextualização dos aspectos culturais
e fi losófi cos que deram o rumo à insurreição e do próprio modus vivendi da
intelectualidade da época. Os ideais iluministas, de valorização do raciocínio, da busca de novos
conceitos, de liberdade de pensamento, foram absorvidas e divulgadas entre os
intelectuais brasileiros e particularmente entre os inconfi dentes. Nada, porém,
de modo tão aprofundado uma vez que não havia imprensa no Brasil (o que,
como se sabe, viria a ocorrer com a chegada de D. João VI ao Brasil em 1808,
quando foi fundada a imprensa régia). Assim sendo, todo livro ou material
deveria ser impresso em Portugal, sob a supervisão do governo imperial, por
esse motivo as ideias francesas, inglesas, alemãs sobre liberdade, preponde-
rância da razão, reforma político-econômica, enfi m, que visavam à construção
do sujeito esclarecido encontraram eco aqui, mas sem grande aprofundamento
pelas próprias condições locais. Em resumo, “[...] não foi uma insurreição de
letrados [a despeito da participação de poetas árcades, como Cláudio Manuel
da Costa e Alvarenga Peixoto], mas de homens descontentes visando a sacudir
o jugo português”. 4 No “Romance XXI ou das idéias”, o leitor tem um painel geral desse
contexto, além de novos comentários do narrador: Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 191 Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan Os estudantes que partem. Os doutores que regressam. (Em redor das grandes luzes,
há sempre sombras perversas. Sinistros corvos espreitam
pelas douradas janelas.)
E há mocidade! E há prestígio. E as idéias. (p. 65) Na literatura, houve uma proximidade com esse movimento, excluin-
do-se a preocupação cientifi ca. Embora o arcadismo seja caracterizado como
um movimento alienado pela temática bucólica e por retomar temas e motivos
da Grécia clássica, o fato é que no período tivemos a publicação de importantes
textos. O mais famoso é o poema Cartas chilenas, atribuído a Tomás Antonio
Gonzaga, em que critica, indiretamente, o então governador das Minas, Luís
da Cunha Menezes (1783-1788), além de um poema lírico, Marília de Dirceu,
em que Gonzaga celebrizou versos amorosos dirigidos à sua amada, Maria
Joaquina Dorothéa de Seixas, a Marília. Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Ainda que seja uma obra poética, uma
obra baseada na imaginação do poeta, é possível acompanhar, pela leitura dos
poemas do livro, a trajetória do relacionamento entre Gonzaga e Joaquina, in-
clusive o rompimento, quando o poeta é preso acusado de ser um inconfi dente
e degredado para Moçambique. No continente africano, Gonzaga reconstruiu
sua vida e casou-se com a fi lha de um mercador de escravos. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Isso tudo é narrado em romances aqui e ali. Isso tudo é narrado em romances aqui e ali. No Brasil, o Arcadismo se desenvolveu muito mais em Minas, graças
exatamente à extração do ouro, que deu à Capitania certa riqueza e propiciou
a formação de uma elite intelectual. Pois bem, após os romances XX e XXI em que expõe esse contexto
todo, o narrador nos romances seguintes trata dos eventos que, em sequência,
culminaram na inconfi dência, busca/captura, devassa, degredo e morte de
vários acusados, em especial do Tiradentes. A começar pela morte em 1788
daquele que seria o sucessor de D. Maria I, a louca. Seu fi lho, o príncipe D. José Francisco, morre doente. No entanto, conforme sugere o narrador, apoiado
nas conjecturas da época, o príncipe que poderia trazer paz à Colônia por suas
ideias libertárias talvez tenha sido assassinado: Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 192 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Já plangem todos os sinos,
Pelo Príncipe, que é morto. Como um fi lho de Rainha
Pode assim morrer tão moço? Dizem que foi de bexigas;
De veneno – dizem outros –
Que lhe deram os ministros
Para o não verem no trono. Triste ano para a esperança,
Este ano de 88! (p. 72) Já plangem todos os sinos,
Pelo Príncipe, que é morto. Como um fi lho de Rainha
Pode assim morrer tão moço? Dizem que foi de bexigas;
De veneno – dizem outros –
Que lhe deram os ministros
Para o não verem no trono. Triste ano para a esperança,
Este ano de 88! (p. 72) Com isso, não haveria outro caminho que não a luta dos colonos. Reúnem-se, cria-se a bandeira, palavras de ordem se resumem no princípio
da liberdade, pessoas são chamadas a participar, conspira-se por todo lugar. A
dicotomia central do livro pode ser facilmente visualizada: opressão/escravidão
versus liberdade. Todo o processo se intensifi ca nos romances XXVI e XXVII em que o
leitor, embora saiba já o que vai acontecer ao alferes Joaquim da Silva Xavier,
é levado a passear pelas Gerais para também sonhar a liberdade que poderia
resolver o problema do sofrimento e da pobreza dos colonos explorados pela
Coroa portuguesa. Conforme procuramos explicar anteriormente, há uma dicotomia bem
visível em trechos específi cos e no poema como um todo. Trata-se da oposi-
ção entre liberdade e a opressão, a escravização de corpos e pensamentos. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Isso tudo é narrado em romances aqui e ali. O
romance seguinte, o XXVIII, colabora para o movimento geral do texto ao
mostrar uma das armas do status quo: a traição, personifi cada na fi gura de
Joaquim Silvério. Como alento, a História repudia essa arma e glorifi ca os
que lutaram do outro lado: (No grande espelho do tempo,
cada vida se retrata:
os heróis, em seus degredos
ou mortos em plena praça;
– os delatores, cobrando
o preço das suas cartas...) (p. 89) (No grande espelho do tempo,
cada vida se retrata:
os heróis, em seus degredos
ou mortos em plena praça;
– os delatores, cobrando
o preço das suas cartas...) (p. 89) Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 193 Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan No “Romance XXXVII ou de maio de 1789”, temos a narração da cap-
tura de Tiradentes. Durou muitos dias, até ser preso no dia 10. Interessante que
no mesmo mês de maio, na França, os iluministas conseguiram arregimentar
a população que se insurgiu contra o clero, contra o despotismo, e Tiradentes
era preso, de certa forma abandonado pelos seus pares. – Minas da minha esperança,
Minas do meu desespero! Agarram-me os soldados,
como qualquer bandoleiro. Vim trabalhar para todos,
e abandonado me vejo. Todos tremem. Todos fogem. A quem dediquei meu zelo? (p. 107) Pergunta-se o próprio Joaquim da Silva Xavier. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Pergunta-se o próprio Joaquim da Silva Xavier. A literatura engajada tem como ponto central a refl exão sobre as
injustiças sociais e como fundamento último a tentativa de transformação
dessa mesma sociedade pela força da palavra. Cecília Meireles, apesar de ter
produzido uma obra sem esse objetivo, no Romanceiro, ela seguiu o preceito. Claro que a transformação da sociedade brasileira não depende unicamente de
um livro, de um escritor, mas sem dúvida que a força do conjunto pode levá-la
a ser menos injusta. A indignação perpassa todo o Romanceiro, mas tem como
ponto alto o Romance XLIII, em que o narrador transcreve como teria sido a
linha de raciocínio para punir exemplarmente um, enquanto aos outros foram
concedidos abrandamento ou mesmo encerramento do processo. Esse um, o
Tiradentes, assim padeceu por não ter quem o protegesse de fato: Esse que todos acusam,
sem amigo nem parente,
sem casa, fazenda ou lavras,
metido em sonhos de louco,
salvador que se não salva,
pode servir de resgate. É o alferes Tiradentes. (p. 122) Esse que todos acusam,
sem amigo nem parente,
sem casa, fazenda ou lavras,
metido em sonhos de louco,
salvador que se não salva,
pode servir de resgate. É o alferes Tiradentes. (p. 122) 194 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Salvador que se não salva, mais uma vez o discurso evoca a fi gura
de Cristo, que dizia salvar a todos, mas não pôde livrar-se da crucifi cação. A
mitifi cação de Tiradentes, a despeito de outros terem igualmente lutado pela
liberdade, como Frei Caneca no início do século XIX, também enforcado, é
retomada pelo discurso poético para ratifi car tanto o mito como o princípio da
libertação. Essa mesma construção do mito pela palavra poética é analisada
pelo próprio poema. Isso é, o narrador reconhece a persuasão da palavra bem
empregada, ainda mais pela boca de quem é proferida. Assim se forjam palavras,
Assim se engendram culpados;
Assim se traça o roteiro
De exilados e enforcados:
A língua a bater nos dentes... Grandes medos mastigados. (p. 128) A devassa atinge também os poetas conjurados. O Romance XLIX
especula sobre a morte de Cláudio Manuel da Costa (1729-1789). Era juiz de
direito, fora secretário da Capitania de Minas Gerais e tinha algumas posses. Apesar de bem estabelecido e gozando de prestígio na sociedade colonial,
simpatizou-se pelo movimento inconfi dente; mas, ao ser preso e interrogado,
foi encontrado morto no dia 4 de julho na cela da Casa dos Contos, aonde
fora levado dois dias antes. O narrador sugere ao leitor todas as possibilidades
em torno de sua morte: teria se enforcado, fora assassinado com um punhal,
deram-lhe veneno com a comida ou ainda nem morrera nesse dia, talvez tenha
achado outro corpo em seu lugar e ele fugido com a ajuda do sertanista Inácio
Pamplona para lugar ignorado e nunca mais localizado. Ofi cialmente, o poeta
se suicidou; o poema quer, no entanto, mostrar que nem sempre a voz da au-
toridade é a verdadeira, que nem todo discurso ofi cial é necessariamente fi el
aos fatos. Ainda que Cláudio Manuel da Costa tenha de fato morrido no dia
quatro, a ideia é, pois, discutir como uma verdade pode se impor pela força
da palavra, e pela força da posição social de quem diz. Por aqui passou Pamplona,
[...]
Passou como um fugitivo,
e levava ao lado um vulto. Por aqui passou Pamplona,
[...]
Passou como um fugitivo,
e levava ao lado um vulto. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 195 Prof. Dr. – Quem compra este par de esporas
que eram do poeta Gonzaga? Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Celso Leopoldo Pagnan
passou como um fugitivo:
e talvez seu companheiro
fosse o Doutor Cláudio, oculto. (p. 141) E mais adiante: Ai, palavras, ai, palavras,
Que estranha potência, a vossa! (p. 148) No Romance LV, o leitor tem contato exatamente com a história do
Dirceu, isto é, Tomás Antonio Gonzaga (1744-1810), autor do mais famoso
poema lírico da época, Marília de Dirceu, dedicado à jovem Maria Joaquina
Dorothéa de Seixas, com quem sonhava em se casar, mas foi impedido pelo
degredo a que foi condenado por sua participação na Conjuração mineira. Assim como Cláudio, era homem das leis; tentou livrar-se da condenação. Foi enviado para Moçambique onde deveria cumprir 10 anos de degredo, ou
seja, em 1802 poderia retornar ao Brasil, no entanto esqueceu-se de sua Ma-
rília para, ironicamente, casar-se com a fi lha de um comerciante de escravos,
chamada Juliana Mascarenhas de Sousa. A ironia, claro, reside no fato de
Gonzaga participara de um movimento libertário, mas não se importou em ter
como sogro alguém que mantinha a roda da história colonialista. A história de
Gonzaga é retomada no Romance LXV, antecedido por um cenário. O caso é
poetizado até o Romance LXXIII. Fala-se sobre o degredo em Moçambique,
sobre a expropriação de seus bens, das doenças, da vida difícil, do casamento
com Juliana, sobre a decepção amorosa de Maria Dorothéa, porém o objetivo
principal é outra vez retomar a ideia da efemeridade do tempo, tema recorrente
na obra de Cecília Meireles. No caso de Gonzaga, de todos os seus bens, o
narrador diz ter lhe sobrado um par de esporas de prata. Trata-se, antes de
uma metáfora: o sonho dourado, o sonho da liberdade virou prata, perdeu-se;
no entanto, as esporas servem para dar movimento a um cavalo, fazê-lo trotar,
ir adiante. Assim é o tempo, assim é a vida. O tempo é inexorável, vivemos o
hoje, que vira ontem, e com esse fi cam os sonhos, os desejos, os projetos de
vida pessoal e coletiva. O que fi ca são poucas coisas. – Quem compra este par de esporas
que eram do poeta Gonzaga? Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 196 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura – Já ninguém sonha ir tão longe,
que hoje são duras escarpas
esses caminhos de fl ores
de antigos campos da Arcádia... (p. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura 183) Além dos dois poetas citados, ainda um terceiro participou da Incon-
fi dência: Alvarenga Peixoto (1744-1792). Também condenado ao degredo em
Angola, morreu vitimado de uma febre maligna meses depois do início de sua
pena. Narra-se sua história a partir do Romance LXXV, com destaque para sua
esposa Dona Bárbara Eliodora, também poetisa, mas cujos textos se perderam
no tempo. Era conhecida por ser uma mulher de grande beleza física e fi el aos
princípios do marido. Teria escrito um poema em homenagem à fi lha, Maria
Ifi gênia, também lembrada pelo Romanceiro, no Romance LXXVII: Triste menina a que estuda
com tão penoso cuidado... Tratada como Princesa,
para quem estranho reinado? Vai ver sua mãe demente,
vai ver seu pai degredado... (p. 217) Quase no fi m, narra-se a loucura e a morte de D. Maria I, que se
deu em 1816. Era a rainha à época da Inconfi dência e fi cara louca em 1792. Por esse motivo, seu fi lho D. João tornou-se o príncipe regente, mais tarde
aclamado como D. João VI, que veio ao Brasil em 1808, fugindo das guerras
napoleônicas. Todo o episódio é muito signifi cativo para marcar o fi m de uma
era e o início de outra. Como se sabe, a Conjuração mineira não foi o único
movimento para tornar a colônia portuguesa independente, mas, pela cons-
trução mítica de Tiradentes, entre outros fatores, tornou-se a mais importante. Não é por acaso que no dia 21 de abril, lembra-se sua morte como homenagem
aos que lutam por liberdade. Excluindo as fi guras religiosas, como santos e
Jesus Cristo, Tiradentes é a única personalidade da história a quem se dedica
um feriado no Brasil. Todos os outros feriados comemoram feitos coletivos,
como o 7 de setembro ou o 15 de novembro. Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 197 Prof. Dr. Celso Leopoldo Pagnan 198
Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1,p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 Uniletras, Ponta Grossa, v. 31, n. 1, p. 181-199, jan./jun. 2009 3 Conclusão O artigo, por fazer parte de pesquisa mais ampla, não deve apresentar
ainda uma conclusão defi nitiva. Mesmo porque há um objetivo mais amplo
que é o de discutir de que modo um texto literário se relaciona com o universo
jurídico. Aqui, fi zemos apenas alguns apontamentos iniciais, mas que sugerem
tal foco. Ainda assim é possível mostrar que o poema, ao se encerrar com uma
fala aos inconfi dentes mortos, revela uma espécie de alento. O tempo passou,
o sonho não se realizou para os conjurados, mas a ideia permaneceu, essa é a
essência de tudo. E é essa essência, o sonho da liberdade, a despeito de uma
ordenação ainda pouco justa com a coletividade, que fi ca nas calendas do
tempo, matéria da poesia de Cecília Meireles. E aqui fi camos
todos contritos,
a ouvir na névoa
o desconforme,
submerso curso
dessa torrente
do purgatório... Quais os que tombam,
em crime exaustos,. quais os que sobem,
purifi cados? (p. 239) Referências
BARTHES, Roland. A aventura semiológica. S. Paulo: Martins Fontes, 2001. DWORKIN, RONALD. O Império do direito. 2. ED., S. PAULO: MARTINS FONTES, 2007. GODOY, Arnaldo Sampaio de Moraes. Direito & Literatura. Porto Alegre: Do Advogado,
2008. HOLANDA, Sérgio B. de (org.). História geral da civilização brasileira:A época Colonial. Administração, Economia, Sociedade. Inquietação revolucionária no Sul: conjuração mineira. 7. ed., Tomo I, 2º vol., Rio de Janeiro: Bertrand Brasil, 1993, p. 394-405. MEIRELES, Cecília. Romanceiro da inconfi dência. 3. ed. Rio de Janeiro: Nova Fronteira,
2005
ORDENAÇÕES FILIPINAS. Disponível em Referências BARTHES, Roland. A aventura semiológica. S. Paulo: Martins Fontes, 2001. DWORKIN, RONALD. O Império do direito. 2. ED., S. PAULO: MARTINS FONTES, 2007. GODOY, Arnaldo Sampaio de Moraes. Direito & Literatura. Porto Alegre: Do Advogado,
2008. GODOY, Arnaldo Sampaio de Moraes. Direito & Literatura. Porto Alegre: Do Advogado,
2008. HOLANDA, Sérgio B. de (org.). História geral da civilização brasileira:A época Colonial. Administração, Economia, Sociedade. Inquietação revolucionária no Sul: conjuração mineira. 7. ed., Tomo I, 2º vol., Rio de Janeiro: Bertrand Brasil, 1993, p. 394-405. MEIRELES, Cecília. Romanceiro da inconfi dência. 3. ed. Rio de Janeiro: Nova Fronteira,
2005 ORDENAÇÕES FILIPINAS. Disponível em Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura Romanceiro de Inconfidência poder e literatura <http://www.ci.uc.pt/ihti/proj/fi lipinas/l5p1153.htm> Acesso em 01 jun. 2009, p. 1152-
1155 SCHWARTZ, Germano. A constituição, a literatura e o direito. Porto Alegre: Do Advo-
gado, 2006. SCHWARTZ, Germano. A constituição, a literatura e o direito. Porto Alegre: Do Advo-
gado, 2006. SILVA, Joaquim Norberto de Sousa. História da Conjuração Mineira. Rio de Janeiro: Imprensa
Ofi cial, 1948. Apud SERELLE, Márcio. No início da História da Conjuração Mineira: o fato
e a fi cção na construção da obra de Joquim Norberto de Sousa Silva. Gragoatá. Niterói, n. 6, p. 177-195, 1. sem. 1999, p. 191. TRINDADE, André; SCHWARTZ, Germano (coord.). Direito e Literatura - O Encontro
Entre Themis e Apolo. Curitiba: Juruá, 2008 WELLEK, René; WARREN, Austin. Teoria da literatura. Lisboa: Europa-América,
1955. Recebido para publicação em 18 jun. 2009
Aceito para publicação em 03 nov. 2009 199
|
https://openalex.org/W3119949431
|
https://bmcoralhealth.biomedcentral.com/track/pdf/10.1186/s12903-020-01375-1
|
English
| null |
Selected salivary parameters in children with idiopathic nephrotic syndrome: a preliminary study
|
BMC oral health
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 8,314
|
Abstract Background: Disturbances in the levels of serum constituents occurring in chronic renal diseases can be reflected in
the saliva composition. The aim of this study was to assess some selected salivary components in children suffering
from idiopathic steroid-sensitive nephrotic syndrome (iNS). Methods: A case–control study was performed on iNS and healthy participants. In unstimulated mixed saliva, pH,
buffer capacity, total protein, α-amylase, peroxidase, calcium, magnesium, inorganic phosphate, fluoride, urea, uric
acid and salivary flow rate were measured. Oral condition was assessed using dmft, DMFT, API and GI indices, usage
of fluoride specimens and frequency of tooth brushing. Statistical analysis was performed by Shapiro–Wilk, Brown-
Forsythe, Student’s t, ANOVA, Tukey’s and Pearson’s chi-square tests, Pearson’s and Spearman’s correlations, logistic
regression and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. Results: The study involved 94 participants of both genders aged 4–17 (47 cases in relapse or remission phase of
iNS and 47 controls) who were treated in the clinic of pediatric nephrology or outpatient dental clinic. Neither group
differed in the number of caries-affected primary and permanent teeth, gingival condition or use of fluoride speci‑
mens. The iNS group presented lower levels of magnesium (0.41 ± 0.34 vs. 0.60 ± 0.38 mg/dL, P < 0.05) and fluoride
(0.15 ± 0.10 vs. 0.21 ± 0.10 ppm, P < 0.01) and higher contents of urea (35.19 ± 15.55 vs. 25.21 ± 10.78 mg/dL, P < 0.01)
and uric acid (2.90 ± 1.23 vs. 2.34 ± 1.04 mg/dL, P < 0.05) than the controls. In the iNS participants with relapse, a
higher peroxidase activity and lower magnesium content than in the remission phase were found. ROC analysis
showed a weak discriminatory power of these salivary constituents for the differentiation of participants with and
without disease (accuracy from 66.0 to 67.0%, area under the ROC curve (AUC) from 0.638 to 0.682) and the relapse
and remission phases (accuracy 70.2% and 68.1% and AUC 0.717 and 0.675, respectively). Conclusions: Levels of urea, uric acid, magnesium and fluoride in saliva can be associated with the course of iNS. Salivary levels of peroxidase and magnesium can be related to the phase of the disease. However, the measurements
of these parameters cannot be useful as a noninvasive tool in diagnosing iNS and the phase of the disease. Keywords: Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome, Salivary components, Children Keywords: Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome, Salivary components, Children Selected salivary parameters in children
with idiopathic nephrotic syndrome:
a preliminary study Urszula Kaczmarek1* , Alina Wrzyszcz‑Kowalczyk1 , Katarzyna Jankowska1 , Katarzyna Prościak2 ,
Monika Mysiak‑Dębska1 , Iwona Przywitowska1 and Irena Makulska2 Urszula Kaczmarek1* , Alina Wrzyszcz‑Kowalczyk1 , Katarzyna Jankowska1 , Katarzyna Prościak2 ,
Monika Mysiak‑Dębska1 , Iwona Przywitowska1 and Irena Makulska2 © The Author(s) 2021. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which
permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the
original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or
other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line
to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory
regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this
licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativeco
mmons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Background Nephrotic syndrome is a common chronic glomeru-
lar disease occurring in childhood [1, 2]. This disease
can be caused by minimal-change nephrotic syndrome,
focal
segmental
glomerulosclerosis,
membranous *Correspondence: urszula.kaczmarek@umed.wroc.pl; ukaczm@tlen.pl
1 Department of Conservative Dentistry and Pedodontics, Wroclaw
Medical University, Krakowska 26, 50‑425 Wrocław, Poland
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article *Correspondence: urszula.kaczmarek@umed.wroc.pl; ukaczm@tlen.pl
1 Department of Conservative Dentistry and Pedodontics, Wroclaw
Medical University, Krakowska 26, 50‑425 Wrocław, Poland
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12903-020-01375-1 Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12903-020-01375-1 Study designh The presented case–control study is a part of the project
that included clinical examination of oral health parame-
ters, sociodemographic questionnaires and assessment of
selected salivary components in idiopathic steroid-sensi-
tive nephrotic syndrome (iNS) patients and controls. The two types of primary idiopathic nephrotic syn-
drome are recognized as follows: steroid-sensitive (the
most common) and steroid-resistant types. The long-
term prognosis for steroid-sensitive cases regarding
kidney function is good, but steroid-resistant cases con-
stitute a future risk of chronic or end-stage renal disease. However, even the steroid-sensitive type can have a fre-
quently relapsing course requiring the administration of
alternative immunosuppressive agents [1, 2, 4, 5]. The iNS participants were treated in the Department
and Clinic of Pediatric Nephrology, and controls were
healthy outpatients attending the dental clinic at the
Department of Conservative Dentistry and Pedodontics
of Wroclaw Medical University, Poland. The examina-
tions were performed from May 2018 to April 2019. The
detailed data on oral health parameters and questionnaire
items were published earlier [16]. In this paper, we used
only several basic oral health parameters, which could
potentially influence the studied salivary components.h pp
g
Whole saliva is a mixture of the secretion of the major
and minor salivary glands, gingival crevicular fluid,
mucosal transudate, desquamated epithelial cells, bac-
teria, viruses and fungi and other cellular components. Some salivary constituents are synthesized by salivary
glands, while others originate from the blood through
transcellular, passive intracellular diffusion and active
transport, paracellular routes by extracellular filtration
within the salivary glands or through the gingival crev-
ice [6–8]. Therefore, salivary constituents of serum origin
can reflect the abnormalities in the blood composition
associated with systemic diseases [9, 10]. In patients with
chronic kidney disease (CKD), higher contents of urea,
uric acid and creatinine in saliva were found [11–13]. Salivary levels of cortisol, nitrite, uric acid, sodium, chlo-
ride, pH, amylase, and lactoferrin have been reported
to be markers related to end-stage renal disease [14]. An elevated level of phosphate in saliva was proposed
as a biomarker for the initiation of treatment of hyper-
phosphatemia, which is an important contributor to
cardiovascular calcification in chronic renal failure [14,
15]. Therefore, saliva analysis could be used as a nonin-
vasive alternative to plasma analysis for the diagnosis
and monitoring of patients with CKD. © The Author(s) 2021. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which
permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the
original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or
other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line
to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory
regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this
licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativeco
mmons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 2 of 10 Page 2 of 10 nephropathy, genetic disorders and secondary diseases
linked to infections, drugs, and neoplasia; however,
the disease can also be idiopathic. The disease involves
immune dysregulation, systemic circulating factors, or
inherited structural abnormalities of the podocyte [2, 3]. The study aimed to evaluate selected protein and non-
protein salivary components in children with idiopathic
steroid-sensitive nephrotic syndrome compared to
healthy controls. We also compared the levels of salivary
parameters between the patients in the remission versus
relapse phases of the disease. In addition, we assessed the
potential usefulness of the studied salivary constituents
as markers discriminating diseased and nondiseased chil-
dren. The null hypothesis has been assumed that there
are no differences in the studied salivary constituents
between iNS patients and controls. nephropathy, genetic disorders and secondary diseases
linked to infections, drugs, and neoplasia; however,
the disease can also be idiopathic. The disease involves
immune dysregulation, systemic circulating factors, or
inherited structural abnormalities of the podocyte [2, 3]. Clinical and biochemical symptoms of the disease
result from proteinuria (mostly albuminuria), which
exceeds the possibility of compensatory mechanisms
in the body. An abnormality of the permselectivity bar-
rier of the glomerular capillary wall, which is unable to
restrict the loss of protein, causes the loss of protein with
urine. Hypoalbuminemia and hyperlipidemia are found
in the blood. Study designh However, in the
case of nephrotic syndrome, it is indefinite whether the
abnormality of capillary permeability is restricted to the
glomerular capillary wall or can involve other capillaries,
including those in the salivary glands. l
The STROBE guidelines for case–control studies were
followed [17]. Clinical symptoms can include edema of the
legs and face, ascites, weight gain, feeling very tired, not
feeling hungry, and foamy or bubbly urine [1].h Statistical analysis
Th
i The clinical oral examination was carried out with the
use of artificial light, a plain mirror and a ball-ended den-
tal probe (WHO CPI probe). This process included the
assessment of the number of primary and permanent
caries-affected teeth (dmft and DMFT values) accord-
ing to World Health Organization criteria (WHO) [19],
oral hygiene using the Approximal Plaque Index—API by
Lange et al., 1974 [20] and gingival condition according
to the Gingival Index—GI, by Löe and Silness, 1963) [20]. Additional oral health parameters had been analyzed
previously [16]. The consistency of the obtained results with a normal
distribution was verified with the use of the Shapiro–
Wilk test and the homogeneity of variance using the
Brown–Forsythe test. The quantitative continuous vari-
ables with distributions that were not significantly differ-
ent from normal are presented as the mean and standard
deviation, and the qualitative variables are presented as
numbers and percentages. Significant between-group dif-
ferences in the mean values of the variables with a normal
distribution were verified using Student’s t-test, ANOVA
and Tukey’s test. The association between variables was
tested with the chi square Pearson’s test and Spearman’s
or Pearson’s correlation coefficients. Logistic bivari-
ate and multivariate regression analyses for dependent Questionnaire items Data on gender, age, frequency of toothbrushing, use of
fluoridated toothpaste and topical professional applica-
tion of fluoride specimens, and diet were reported by the
parents of the participants. The detailed questionnaire
items were published earlier [16]. Salivary parametersh The following salivary parameters were assessed: pH (by
potentiometric method), buffer capacity (BC, by titra-
tion method), total protein (P, by Lowry’s et al. method)
[21], α-amylase (Amy, by the assay kit based on Cara-
way’s method), salivary peroxidase (SPO, by Nbs-SCN−
method) [22], calcium (Ca, by the assay kit based on the
formation of the chromogenic complex between calcium
ions and o-cresolphthalein), magnesium (Mg, by the
assay kit based on the reaction of magnesium with xylidyl
blue-I), inorganic phosphate (iPh, by the assay kit based
on the formation of the chromogenic complex of ammo-
nium molybdate with phosphate), fluoride (F, by the ionic
selective electrode Orion 9609), urea (U, by the assay kit
based on urease activity), and uric acid (UA, by the assay
kit based on uricase activity). Assessment of selected components in the blood p
Venous blood samples were collected from ill subjects
after an overnight fast. After centrifugation, the protein,
albumin, urea, uric acid, calcium, magnesium, inorganic
phosphate, total cholesterol, triglycerides and creatinine
were measured in plasma using an automated standard-
ized multichannel analyzer (Konelab 30i; Thermo Fisher
Scientific Inc., bioMerieux, Marcy l’Etoile, France). The
estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) was also
determined [23]. The blood tests were performed on the
same day as salivary sample collection. Participantsh The recruited participants (n = 110), both genders, were
between the ages of 4 and 17. Nevertheless, 9.1% (n = 10)
of the parents refused to consent to the study, and 5.4%
(n = 6) of the children refused to be examined. Finally, 94
participants were enrolled in the study. Half of them were
patients suffering from iNS and were either in remission
(n = 26) or in the relapse phase of the disease (n = 21),
being treated in the Clinic of Pediatric Nephrology, and
the remaining participants were healthy (n = 47). The
inclusion criteria for the iNS patients were the disease
diagnosed at least two years earlier than this study and
no other acute systemic diseases present at that moment. The iNS phase was recognized by clinical symptoms and
laboratory blood tests. The control group included clinically healthy partici-
pants (n = 47) who were outpatients of the dental clinic
without a history of impaired renal function or pro-
teinuria or acute or chronic systemic diseases (based on
medical interviews of a parent and a child’s health record Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 3 of 10 book) and at the age range and gender corresponding to
the iNS patients. 2 h after breakfast. The child sat with the head bent
down and the mouth open and deposited saliva by spit-
ting into a graded test tube that was stored on crushed
ice. The salivary flow rate was calculated as ml/min (V)
based on the measurement of the volume of the collected
saliva sample and the time needed for its collection. The
saliva samples were centrifuged for 15 min at a speed of
3500 rpm before the biochemical assays. All participants involved in the study had to provide
written informed consent from a parent (in addition to
a separate written consent from participants age 16 and
over), be willing to undergo the oral clinical examination
and salivary sample collection, and had to respond to
questionnaire items. Participants who did not meet the
inclusion criteria were excluded from the study. Ethics approval Approval to conduct the study was obtained from the
Bioethics Committee of Wroclaw Medical Univer-
sity (permission no. KB-343/2016). All parents of the
recruited participants provided their written consent to
participate in the study, and the participants were willing
to submit to the investigation. Participation in the study
was voluntary and anonymous, and the collected data
were treated confidentially. Sample size estimation Sample size determination was based on a t-test for inde-
pendent groups using a special computer program [18]. The expected difference between means for the two
groups for salivary urea content was set at 10.0 (variance
equal to 220). The power of the test was set at 90%, and
the confidence level was set at 95%. With such assump-
tions, the required sample size for each group was equal
to n = 47. Oral health parametersh The iNS patients and healthy participants did not differ
significantly with regard to the number of caries-affected
primary and permanent teeth (dmft + DMFT) and com-
ponents (dt + DT, mt + MT and ft + FT), API value and
GI score, usage of fluoridated dentifrice and topical pro-
fessional application of fluoride specimens. However, the
iNS group showed a significantly lower mean number
of filled primary and/or permanent teeth (P < 0.001) and
less frequent tooth brushing, that is, less than twice a day
(P < 0.05) (Table 1). Salivary sample collectionh The mixed saliva was collected after rinsing the mouth
with distilled water without external stimulation at least Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 4 of 10 Page 4 of 10 The iNS patients at the time of the examination were
taking various medications depending on their condition,
and they were on diets containing low salt, fat, and cho-
lesterol and rich in protein, fruits, and vegetables, unlike
the controls. variables (presence or absence of the disease) and inde-
pendent variables (salivary parameters) were carried out. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis
was used to evaluate the diagnostic potential of selected
salivary constituents to classify the iNS participants com-
pared to controls and the patients with relapse compared
to remission. The overall results were assessed by the area
under the ROC curve (AUC) and the cutoff values, which
were determined based on the best trade-off between
sensitivity and specificity. The level of significance was
set at P < 0.05. All analyses were computed with Statistica
13 software (PL StatSoft). iNS Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome, dmft number of decayed, missing due to caries and filled primary teeth, DMFT number of decayed, missing due to caries and
filled permanent teeth, dt number of decayed primary teeth, DT number of decayed permanent teeth, mt number of missing primary teeth, MT number of missing
permanent teeth, ft number of filled primary teeth, FT number of filled permanent teeth, API approximal plaque index, GI gingival index, P-value level of statistical
significance Distribution of the participants Ninety-four participants were included in the study;
half of them suffered from idiopathic steroid-sensitive
nephrotic syndrome, and the remaining participants were
healthy. The first episode of the disease occurred between
the ages of 4 and 15 (mean 3.8 ± 3.0 years old). The dura-
tion of the disease at the time of the examination ranged
from 2 to 15 years (mean 6.4 ± 4.0 years), and the number
of relapses ranged from 1 to 15 (mean 3.8 ± 2.9). Salivary parametersh The participants suffering from iNS revealed signifi-
cantly lower concentrations of magnesium (P < 0.05) and
fluoride (P < 0.01) and higher urea (P < 0.01) and uric acid
(P < 0.05) compared with the controls. The patients in the
relapse phase presented a higher SPO level and lower
magnesium content than those in the remission phase of
the disease, and both subgroups showed a lower content The mean age of the iNS patients was 9.6 ± 3.9 years
and that of healthy participants was 10.8 ± 3.7 years and
did not vary substantially (P > 0.05). Table 1 Characteristics of the studied participants Table 1 Characteristics of the studied participants Table 1 Characteristics of the studied participants
iNS Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome, dmft number of decayed, missing due to caries and filled primary teeth, DMFT number of decayed, missing due to caries and
filled permanent teeth, dt number of decayed primary teeth, DT number of decayed permanent teeth, mt number of missing primary teeth, MT number of missing
permanent teeth, ft number of filled primary teeth, FT number of filled permanent teeth, API approximal plaque index, GI gingival index, P-value level of statistical
significance
*Significant difference at P < 0.05
**Significant difference at P < 0.001
iNS
Control
P-value
n
%
n
%
Gender
Male
25
53.2
18
38.3
0.147
Female
22
46.8
29
61.7
Age (years)
Mean ± SD
9.6 ± 3.9
10.8 ± 3.7
0.142
Number of caries-affected primary and/or permanent
teeth (dmft + DMFT)
Mean ± SD
4.6 ± 3.5
6.0 ± 4.1
0.126
Primary and/or permanent decayed teeth (dt + DT)
Mean ± SD
3.5 ± 3.2
2.4 ± 2.4
0.095
Primary and/or permanent missing teeth (mt + MT)
Mean ± SD
0.02 ± 0.1
0.2 ± 0.8
0.543
Primary and/or permanent filled teeth (ft + FT)
Mean ± SD
1.1 ± 1.6
3.5 ± 3.6
< 0.001**
API (%)
Mean ± SD
54.0 ± 35.7
43.4 ± 27.6
0.108
GI
Mean ± SD
0.7 ± 1.0
0.3 ± 0.6
0.050
Tooth brushing
Twice a day
37
78.7
44
93.6
0.026*
Once a day or every few days
10
21.3
3
6.4
Dentifrice
Fluoridated
43
91.5
42
89.4
0.603
No fluoride
4
8.5
5
10.6
Topical professional application of fluoride specimens
Yes
16
34.0
17
36.2
0.541
No or does not know
31
66.0
30
63.8 Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 5 of 10 of fluoride and higher urea and uric acid levels than the
controls (Table 2). Moreover, the patients in the relapse
phase revealed a higher SPO level and a lower concen-
tration of magnesium than the healthy participants. Bivariate logistic regression showed that out of all ana-
lyzed salivary variables considered separately, only levels
of salivary urea, uric acid, magnesium and fluoride were associated with the disease. In the multivariate regres-
sion model (where salivary variables were considered
together as independent variables), the levels of salivary
urea and magnesium revealed significant associations
with the presence of the disease (Table 3). cient, OR odds ratio, V salivary flow rate, BC buffer capacity, P total protein, Amy α-amylase, SPO peroxidase, Ca calcium, Mg magnesium, iP
oride, U urea, UA uric acid, P-value level of statistical significance ression coefficient, OR odds ratio, V salivary flow rate, BC buffer capacity, P total protein, Amy α-amylase, SPO peroxidase, Ca calcium, Mg m
h t
F fl
id
U
UA
i
id P
l
l
l f t ti ti
l i
ifi b logistic regression coefficient, OR odds ratio, V salivary flow rate, BC buffer capacity, P total protein, Amy α amyla
inorganic phosphate, F fluoride, U urea, UA uric acid, P-value level of statistical significance ression coefficient, OR odds ratio, V salivary flow rate, BC buffer capacity, P total protein, Amy α amylase, SPO peroxidase, Ca calcium, Mg m
osphate, F fluoride, U urea, UA uric acid, P-value level of statistical significance b logistic regression coefficient, OR odds ratio, V salivary flow rate, BC buffer capacity, P total protein, Amy α-amylase, SPO peroxidas
inorganic phosphate, F fluoride, U urea, UA uric acid, P-value level of statistical significance *Significant effect at P < 0.05
**Significant effect at P < 0.01 *Significant effect at P < 0.05 Serum parametersh discriminate the diseased and nondiseased participants. The accuracy for these variables ranged from 66.0 to
67.0%, and the AUC ranged from 0.638 to 0.682 (Fig. 1). Similarly, the salivary levels of SPO and magnesium
turned out to be weak markers to distinguish the partici-
pants with relapse from the remission phase of the dis-
ease because the accuracy was 70.2% and 68.1% and the
AUC was 0.717 and 0.675, respectively (Fig. 2). discriminate the diseased and nondiseased participants. The accuracy for these variables ranged from 66.0 to
67.0%, and the AUC ranged from 0.638 to 0.682 (Fig. 1). Similarly, the salivary levels of SPO and magnesium
turned out to be weak markers to distinguish the partici-
pants with relapse from the remission phase of the dis-
ease because the accuracy was 70.2% and 68.1% and the
AUC was 0.717 and 0.675, respectively (Fig. 2). The iNS patients demonstrated considerably higher mean
levels of total cholesterol and triglycerides in the plasma
than the reference range. Several individuals revealed
concentrations of protein, uric acid, urea and inorganic
phosphate, total cholesterol, triglycerides, creatinine and
eGFR values that exceeded the upper limit of the refer-
ence ranges. In the relapse phase, compared with the
remission phase of the disease, lower concentrations of
protein, albumin, and calcium and higher contents of
total cholesterol and triglycerides were found (Table 4). Table 1 Characteristics of the studied participants BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 6 of 10 Page 6 of 10 Table 1 Characteristics of the studied participants However, ROC
curve analysis indicated that the salivary levels of magne-
sium, fluoride, urea and uric acid were weak classifiers to Table 2 Comparison of salivary parameters between the iNS and control participants
iNS Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome
Significant difference at P < 0.05 between a–a, d–d, f–f, g–g, n–n and o–o
Significant difference at P < 0.01 between b–b, c–c, e–e, h–h, i–i, k–k, l–l and m–m
Studied groups
iNS
Control n = 47
Remission n = 26
Relapse n = 21
Total n = 47
Salivary parameters
Mean ± SD
Mean ± SD
Mean ± SD
Mean ± SD
Flow rate (ml/min)
0.41 ± 0.26
0.48 ± 0.30
0.44 ± 0.27
0.46 ± 0.19
pH
7.27 ± 0.71
7.28 ± 0.70
7.28 ± 0.70
7.50 ± 0.50
Buffer capacity (mmol/L)
6.67 ± 5.83
4.95 ± 2.87
5.90 ± 4.78
4.56 ± 2.45
Total protein (mg/ml)
1.09 ± 0.62
1.24 ± 0.47
1.16 ± 0.56
1.00 ± 0.47
α-amylase (J/ml)
114.7 ± 135.1
95.4 ± 36.6
106.10 ± 103.00
113.36 ± 82.00
Peroxidase (mIU/ml)
0.45 ± 0.50e
0.66 ± 0.44e,g
0.54 ± 0.48
0.46 ± 0.31 g
Calcium (mg/dL)
3.27 ± 1.52
2.93 ± 1.7
3.12 ± 1.45
3.38 ± 2.15
Magnesium (mg/dL)
0.50 ± 0.38f
0.31 ± 0.26f,h
0.41 ± 0.34a
0.60 ± 0.38a,h
Inorganic phosphate (mg/dL)
10.34 ± 3.68
11.71 ± 3.50
10.95 ± 3.63
10.33 ± 3.86
Fluoride (ppm)
0.15 ± 0.11i
0.15 ± 0.09 k
0.15 ± 0.10b
0.21 ± 0.10b,i,k
Urea (mg/dL)
33.57 ± 16.36 l
37.18 ± 14.64 m
35.19 ± 15.55c
25.21 ± 10.78c,l,m,
Uric acid (mg/dL)
2.64 ± 1.09n
3.24 ± 1.34o
2.90 ± 1.23d
2.34 ± 1.04d,n,o Table 2 Comparison of salivary parameters between the iNS and control participants Table 3 Logistic regression analysis for the presence or absence of the disease as dependent variable
b l
i ti
i
ffi i
t OR dd
ti
V
li
fl
t
BC b ff
it
P t t l
t i
A
l
SPO
id
C
l i
M
i
iPh
Salivary parameters (independent variables
included into regression model)
Results of bivariate logistic regression
for dependent variable presence or absence
of the disease
Results of multivariate logistic
regression for dependent variable:
presence or absence of the disease
b
OR
p
b
OR
P-value
V
− 0.304
0.738
0.730
1.348
0.299
0.366
pH
− 0.628
0.533
0.092
1.832
0.605
0.385
BC
0.121
1.128
0.114
3.148
1.147
0.060
P
0.632
1.882
0.137
8.278
2.114
0.135
Amy
− 0.001
0.999
0.704
2.710
0.997
0.261
SPO
0.499
1.647
0.347
30.662
3.423
0.106
Ca
− 0.079
0.924
0.495
3.540
1.264
0.213
Mg
− 1.449
0.235
0.021*
1.098
0.093
0.013*
iPh
0.046
1.047
0.416
2.512
0.921
0.352
F
− 6.024
0.002
0.009**
1.006
0.006
0.082
U
0.056
1.058
0.001***
2.912
1.069
0.004**
UA
0.441
1.554
0.022*
4.755
1.559
0.127 Table 3 Logistic regression analysis for the presence or absence of the disease as dependent variable n analysis for the presence or absence of the disease as dependent variable Kaczmarek et al. Relationship of studied constituents in blood and salivaii We did not find any significant correlation between oral
health parameters and levels of the studied salivary com-
ponents in either group of participants. We did not find any significant correlation between the
same parameters in saliva and blood in the iNS par-
ticipants, except for a trend of a positive significant Fig. 1 ROC curves and cutoff values for salivary parameters those showed significant difference between the iNS patients and controls. Mg
magnesium, ROC receiver operating characteristic, AUC the area under the ROC curve Fig. 1 ROC curves and cutoff values for salivary parameters those showed significant difference between the iNS patients and controls. Mg
magnesium, ROC receiver operating characteristic, AUC the area under the ROC curve Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 7 of 10 Fig. 2 ROC curves and cutoff values for salivary parameters those showed significant difference between the iNS patients with remission and
relapse. Mg magnesium, ROC receiver operating characteristic, AUC the area under the ROC curve Fig. 2 ROC curves and cutoff values for salivary parameters those showed significant difference between the iNS patients with remission and
relapse. Relationship of studied constituents in blood and salivaii Mg magnesium, ROC receiver operating characteristic, AUC the area under the ROC curve Table 4 Blood laboratory data in children with remission and relapse of the disease
iNS Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome eGFR estimated Glomerular Filtration Rate
Blood parameters
Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome participants
Remission
n = 26
Relapse
n = 21
Total
n = 47
Reference range
Mean ± SD (min–max)
Mean ± SD (min–max)
Mean ± SD (min–max)
Protein (g/dL)
6.74 ± 0.95a (4.0–8.2)f
4.96 ± 0.81a (3.5–6.7)
5.94 ± 1.26 (3.5–8.2)f
5.7–8
Albumin (g/dL)
4.14 ± 0.76b (2.1–5.1)
2.55 ± 0.64b (1.4–3.6)
3.43 ± 1.06 (1.4–5.1)
3.5–5.2
Urea (mg/dL)
26.3 ± 7.2 (11–44)f
29.8 ± 15.0 (10–72)f
27.9 ± 11.3 (10–72)f
11–43
Uric acid (mg/dL)
4.86 ± 1.24 (2.7–7.9)f
5.43 ± 1.84 (3.5–10.7)f
5.11 ± 1.55 (2.7–10.7)f
Girls: 2.6–6.0
Boys: 3.5–7.2
Calcium (mg/dL)
9.74 ± 0.60c (8.3–10.6)
9.13 ± 0.84c (7.4–10.4)
9.47 ± 0.77 (7.4–10.6)
8.8–10.8
Magnesium (mg/dL)
1.97 ± 0.21 (1.6–2.6)
2.05 ± 0.19 (1.6–2.3)
2.01 ± 0.21 (1.6–2.6)
1.45–2.6
Inorganic phosphate (mg/dL)
4.75 ± 0.64 (3.5–5.8)f
4.79 ± 0.94 (3.2–7.7)f
4.77 ± 0.77 (3.2–7.7)f
2.5–5
Total cholesterol (mg/dL)
206 ± 63d (122–347)f
387 ± 108d (240–659)f
285 ± 124 (122–659)f
< 170
Triglycerides (mg/dL)
134 ± 125e (40–677)f
276 ± 190e (135–969)f
199 ± 172 (40–969)f
2–9 years < 75
10–17 years < 90
Creatinine (mg/dL)
0.59 ± 0.17 (0.32–1.09)f
0.64 ± 0.12 (0.67–0.92)
0.62 ± 0.15 (0.32–1.09)f
0.3–1.0
eGFR (ml/min/1.73m2)
128.02 ± 18.42 (98.25–160.6)f
121.11 ± 21.16 (87.28–187.69)f
124.19 ± 20.32 (87.28–187.69)f
2–12 years 140 ± 30
13–21 years 126 ± 22 Table 4 Blood laboratory data in children with remission and relapse of the disease Table 4 Blood laboratory data in children with remission and relapse of the disease correlation of uric acid (r = 0.377, P = 0.051) in patients
in the remission phase of the disease (Table 5). salivary components between the iNS and healthy par-
ticipants. We demonstrated that the disease is associ-
ated with significantly lower magnesium and fluoride
concentrations and higher urea and uric acid contents in
unstimulated mixed saliva. Discussionh This preliminary study evaluated selected salivary com-
ponents in pediatric patients with idiopathic steroid-
sensitive nephrotic syndrome. The null hypothesis was
rejected, as there were differences in some studied iNS is characterized by complex abnormalities in blood
tests and treatment by steroids, immunosuppressants or
cytostatics, and dietary regimens, which may be reflected Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 8 of 10 Page 8 of 10 Table 5 Pearson correlation coefficients of the studied
constituents in blood and saliva in iNS participants
iNS Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome, P total protein, Ca calcium, Mg magnesium,
iPh inorganic phosphate, U urea, UA uric acid, r Pearson correlation coefficient, p
level of statistical significance
o A trend to significant difference at P < 0.05
Parameter
Remission
n = 26
Relapse
n = 21
Total
n = 47
P
r = -0.007
r = -0.102
r = -0.125
p = 0.974
p = 0.659
p = 0.402
Ca
r = 0.196
r = -0.262
r = 0.017
p = 0.338
p = 0.251
p = 0.911
Mg
r = -0.189
r = -0.261
r = -0.245
p = 0.356
p = 0.267
p = 0.101
iPh
r = 0.075
r = -0.082
r = -0.003
p = 0.717
p = 0.733
p = 0.986
U
r = -0.207
r = -0.203
r = -0.167
p = 0.310
p = 0.377
p = 0.261
UA
r = 0.377
r = -0.153
r = 0.105
p = 0.051o
p = 0.508
p = 0.482 Table 5 Pearson correlation coefficients of the studied
constituents in blood and saliva in iNS participants oxygen species (ROS) and reduce the effects of oxidative
stress. Human saliva is rich in antioxidant compounds
that comprise enzymes (e.g., peroxidase) and small mol-
ecules (e.g., uric acid). Salivary peroxidase is secreted by
the acinar cells of salivary glands and catalyzes the oxi-
dation of thiocyanate ions by hydrogen peroxide, thus
preventing toxic accumulation of H2O2 [32]. Salivary per-
oxidase was suggested to be one of the salivary biomark-
ers in children with chronic kidney disease, but its level
did not differ from that of the controls [33]. Our data
also did not reveal any significant difference in SPO lev-
els between all children with nephrotic syndrome and the
healthy controls. Discussionh However, the participants in the relapse
phase of the disease revealed a significantly higher SPO
level than those in the remission phase and the controls. Serum uric acid is associated with many systemic con-
ditions, including kidney and metabolic disorders. High
uric acid levels have been found to be associated with
a significant rapid decline in eGFR and can be consid-
ered a potential modifiable factor of chronic kidney dis-
ease progression [34]. In addition, uric acid is known as
a scavenger of oxyradicals, a chelator of metal ions and
an important antioxidant in plasma. Moreover, a corre-
lation between uric acid concentrations in the saliva and
plasma was noticed, and thus salivary uric acid can be
used for monitoring the status of hyperuricemia [35]. We
obtained a significantly higher concentration of salivary
uric acid in iNS participants than in the controls, and
some were higher in children with relapse than in those
in the remission phase of the disease. iNS Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome, P total protein, Ca calcium, Mg magnesium,
iPh inorganic phosphate, U urea, UA uric acid, r Pearson correlation coefficient, p
level of statistical significance
o A trend to significant difference at P < 0.05 in the saliva composition. Unfortunately, we could not
compare our results with those of others because data
in the literature are scarce and concern the excretion of
endogenous proteins (albumin, transferrin, IgG1, and
IgG4) [24], salivary cortisol concentration [25] and sali-
vary cytokines [26]. Salivary gland secretion in unstimulated conditions
can be reflected by the measurements of flow rate, total
protein concentration, and salivary α-amylase activity to
some extent. Salivary α-amylase, which is produced by
the salivary glands, is the main protein in the saliva and
constitutes up to 50% of the total salivary protein [27]. However, we did not observe any significant differences
in these parameters between the iNS patients and the
controls. Therefore, undisturbed salivary gland activ-
ity could be suggested. Polak et al. [26] found a lower
total protein concentration in the saliva of children with
steroid-sensitive nephrotic syndrome than in the control
group. The elevated level of salivary urea was observed in
patients with chronic kidney disease and was correlated
with its blood content [36]. Our data showed only a
trend of such a relationship. Discussionh However, we noticed a sig-
nificantly higher concentration of urea in the saliva of the
iNS children than in the healthy children, and there was
no difference between the patients with relapse and those
in remission. Patients with nephrotic syndrome can exhibit calcium
homeostasis disturbance, which is assigned to the loss of
various plasma proteins and minerals in urine and ster-
oid therapy [37]. Significantly lower total calcium con-
tent in the serum was found in pediatric patients with
steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome compared with
the controls, which, in addition, was lower in the relapse
phase than in the complete remission phase [38]. Our
results did not reveal any significant difference in salivary
calcium between the iNS children and the controls or
between patients with relapse and those in the remission
phase of the disease. The salivary buffer capacity acts as an important factor
in controlling the pH of the oral environment. The buffer
capacity of saliva involves three major systems: carbonic
acid/bicarbonate, phosphate, and protein [28]. We did
not find any significant difference in the levels of pH,
buffer capacity, or inorganic phosphate between the iNS
and healthy participants. Several studies have emphasized the pathophysi-
ological importance of oxidative stress in patients with
nephrotic syndrome and its influence on the response of
these patients to therapy [29–31]. Antioxidants can neu-
tralize the negative effects of free radicals and reactive A study on serum magnesium showed a significantly
lower level in nephrotic syndrome patients than in
controls. It has been deduced that the measurement of Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 9 of 10 and permanent teeth and gingival condition, which
potentially could affect the studied salivary components. Future long-term prospective investigations are needed
to elucidate the possible impact of the disease course and
treatment on the levels of salivary constituents in iNS
patients. and permanent teeth and gingival condition, which
potentially could affect the studied salivary components. serum magnesium in children with acute nephropathy
could be useful for early diagnosis and improving ther-
apy [39]. Similarly, our results showed a significantly
lower salivary magnesium concentration in the iNS
children than in the controls and a lower magnesium
level in patients with relapse than in those in remission. f
Future long-term prospective investigations are needed
to elucidate the possible impact of the disease course and
treatment on the levels of salivary constituents in iNS
patients. Funding This study was supported by a grant from the Wroclaw Medical University,
Poland (Grant No. ST-B010.16.044). The funding body played no role in the
study design, data collection, analysis and interpretation, and manuscript
writing. This study has some limitations. We evaluated only
selected salivary parameters and thus could not fully
characterize all potential changes in the salivary compo-
nents. Moreover, we did not compare the same studied
components in the saliva and the blood in all participants. The strength of the study was that the iNS and healthy
participants subjected to the investigation did not differ
significantly in the number of caries-affected primary Conclusions
h
h l Within the limitations of the study, it may be stated that
the levels of urea, uric acid, magnesium and fluoride in
saliva were associated with disturbances occurring in
the course of idiopathic steroid-sensitive nephrotic syn-
drome. Salivary levels of peroxidase and magnesium can
be related to the phase of the disease. However, their
measurements cannot serve as a noninvasive tool in diag-
nosing iNS and the phase of the disease. The sources of fluoride intake are diet and the fluo-
ride compounds used for caries prevention, such as
fluoridated water, fluoride supplements, and fluori-
dated toothpaste and mouth rinses when swallowed. The elimination of absorbed fluoride occurs almost
exclusively through the kidney [41]. The excretion
of fluoride is lower if the patient suffers from chronic
renal failure, which leads to higher concentrations of
fluoride in the serum and bone [42]. All participants in
this study consumed drinking water with a low natural
content of fluoride (< 0.3 ppm), and similar propor-
tions of iNS and healthy participants declared the use
of fluoridated dentifrice and professional topical appli-
cation of fluoride specimens. We found a significantly
lower concentration of fluoride in the saliva in the iNS
group than in the controls.if Abbreviations
DMFT D
i DMFT: Decay, missing and filled permanent teeth; dmft: Decay, missing and
filled primary teeth; API: Approximal Plaque Index; GI: Gingival Index; eGFR:
Estimated glomerular filtration rate; V: Salivary flow; BC: Buffer capacity; P: Total
protein; Amy: α-Amylase; SPO: Salivary peroxidase; Ca: Calcium; Mg: Magne‑
sium; iPh: Inorganic phosphate; F: Fluoride; U: Urea; UA: Uric acid; WHO: World
Health Organization; CKD: Chronic kidney disease; iNS: Idiopathic nephrotic
syndrome; ROC: Receiver operating characteristic; AUC: The area under the
ROC curve. Authors’ contributions AWK, KJ, MMD and IP performed the oral clinical examination, collected the
questionnaire data and salivary samples. KP performed the medical examina‑
tion and gathered the blood parameters. IM performed medical examination
and drafting. UK designed the study, performed analysis and interpretation of
the data, drafted and edited the manuscript. All authors read and approved
the final manuscript. Consent for publication Consent for publication
Not applicable. However, despite the significant differences in mean
magnesium, fluoride, urea and uric acid levels between
the iNS and healthy participants, ROC curve analysis
revealed that the discriminatory power of these vari-
ables for the differentiation of children with and without
disease was weak. Similarly, salivary levels of peroxidase
and magnesium were weak tests to identify iNS patients
in the relapse phase of the disease. This finding indicates
that the studied salivary parameters cannot be used as
markers accurately differentiating iNS and healthy par-
ticipants and those with relapse of the disease.h Discussionh An elevated serum phosphate level in nephrotic syn-
drome was found to be associated with the severity of
the disease regardless of eGFR value and age [40]. How-
ever, no significant difference in serum phosphorus was
found between patients with steroid-resistant nephrotic
syndrome and the controls or between patients in com-
plete remission and those with relapse [38]. Our data
did not reveal any significant difference in the content
of inorganic phosphate in the saliva between the iNS
and healthy participants or in relation to the phase of
the disease. Availability of data and materials Availability of data and materials The datasets used and analyzed during the current study are available from
the corresponding author on request. Ethics approval and consent to participate The study protocol was approved by the Bioethics Committee of Wroclaw
Medical University (Permission No. KB-343/2016) in accordance with the Dec‑
laration of Helsinki. Participation in the study was voluntary and anonymous,
and the collected data was treated confidentially. Written informed consent
was obtained from a parent or guardian for participants under 16 years old. Competing interests The authors declare that have no competing interests related to this study. References 26. Polak D, Borovitz Y, Clyman-Levy D, Klein Y, Bernfeld N, Davidovits M,
Davidovich E. Salivary cytokines in children with nephrotic syndrome versus
Healthy children: a comparative study. J Clin Med. 2020;9(9):2691. 1. Eddy AA, Symons JN. Nephrotic syndrome in childhood. Lancet Lond Engl. 2003;369:629–39. 1. Eddy AA, Symons JN. Nephrotic syndrome in childhood. Lancet Lond Engl. 2003;369:629–39. 2. Pasini A, Benetti E, Conti G, Ghio L, Lepore M, Massella L, Molino D, Peruzzi L,
Emma F, Fede C, Trivelli A, Maringhini S, Materassi M, Messina G, Montini G,
Murer L, Pecoraro C, Pennesi M. The Italian Society for Pediatric Nephrology
(SINePe) consensus document on the management of nephrotic syndrome
in children: Part I—diagnosis and treatment of the first episode and the first
relapse. Ital J Pediatr. 2017. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13052-017-0356-x. 2. Pasini A, Benetti E, Conti G, Ghio L, Lepore M, Massella L, Molino D, Peruzzi L,
Emma F, Fede C, Trivelli A, Maringhini S, Materassi M, Messina G, Montini G,
Murer L, Pecoraro C, Pennesi M. The Italian Society for Pediatric Nephrology
(SINePe) consensus document on the management of nephrotic syndrome
in children: Part I—diagnosis and treatment of the first episode and the first
relapse. Ital J Pediatr. 2017. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13052-017-0356-x. 27. Noble RE. Salivary alpha-amylase and lysozyme levels: a non-invasive tech‑
nique for measuring parotid vs submandibular/sublingual gland activity. J
Oral Sci. 2000;42:83–6. 28. Bardow A, Moe D, Nyvad B, Nauntofte B. The buffer capacity and buffer
systems of human whole saliva measured without loss of CO2. Arch Oral
Biol. 2000;45:1–12. i
relapse. Ital J Pediatr. 2017. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13052-017-0356- p
p
g
3. Shin JI, Kronbichler A, Oh J, Meijers B. Nephrotic syndrome: genetics,
mechanism, and therapies. Biomed Res Int. 2018;2018:6215946. https://doi. org/10.1155/2018/6215946. 29. Dogra G, Ward N, Croft KD, Mori TA, Barrett PH, Herrmann SE, Irish AB, Watts
GF. Oxidant stress in nephrotic syndrome: comparison of F(2)-isoprostanes
and plasma antioxidant potential. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2001;16:1626–30. 4. Mühlig AK, Lee JY, Kemper MJ, Kronbichler A, Yang JW, Lee JM, Shin JI, Oh J. Levamisole in children with idiopathic nephrotic syndrome: clinical efficacy
and pathophysiological aspects. J Clin Med. 2019;8(6):860. https://doi. org/10.3390/jcm8060860. 30. Kamireddy R, Kavuri S, Devi S, Vemula H, Chandana D, Harinarayanan S,
James R, Rao A. Oxidative stress in pediatric nephrotic syndrome. Clin Chim
Acta. 2002;325:147–50. 31. Reddy P, Sindgikar P, Shenoy RD, Shenoy V. Oxidative stress in childhood
steroid sensitive nephrotic syndrome and its correlation with DNA damage. References Calcium and vitamin D metabo‑
lism in pediatric nephrotic syndrome; an update on the existing literature. Int J Pediatr. 2015;3(21):103–9. 37. Esmaeeili M, Azarfar A, Hoseinalizadeh S. Calcium and vitamin D metabo‑
lism in pediatric nephrotic syndrome; an update on the existing literature. Int J Pediatr. 2015;3(21):103–9. 13. Bilancio G, Cavallo P, Lombardi C, Guarino E, Cozza V, Giordano F, Palladino G,
Cirillo M. Saliva for assessing creatinine, uric acid, and potassium in nephro‑
pathic patients. BMC Nephrol. 2019;20(1):242. https://doi.org/10.1186/s1288
2-019-1437-4. 38. Sharma S, Dabla PK, Kumar M. Status of metabolic bone disease in pediatric
steroid resistant nephrotic syndrome: study from North India. Ann Clin Lab
Res. 2018;6:235. https://doi.org/10.21767/2386-5180.100235. 14. Arregger AL, Cardoso EML, Tumilasci O, Contreras N. Diagnostic value of
salivary cortisol in end stage renal disease. Steroids. 2008;73:77–82. 39. Teslariu O, Mititelu-Tarţău L, Stârcea M, Crenguţa IM, Nechifor M. Magne‑
sium in pediatric nephrotic syndrome. Rev Med Chir Soc Med Nat Iasi. 2016;120:818–23. 15. Savica V, Calò LA, Granata A, Caldarera R, Cavaleri A, Santoro D, Monardo
P, Savica R, Muraca U, Bellinghieri G. A new approach to the evalua‑
tion of hyperphosphatemia in chronic kidney disease. Clin Nephrol. 2007;68:216–21. 40. Sexton DJ, Kinsella SM, Eustace JA. Serum phosphate varies with degree of
proteinuria in nephrotic syndrome and is associated with elevated pulse
wave velocity. J Nephrol. 2013;26:540–54. 16. Kaczmarek U, Wrzyszcz-Kowalczyk A, Jankowska K, Prościak K, Mysiak-
Dębska M, Przywitowska I, Makulska I. Oral health conditions in children
with idiopathic nephrotic syndrome: a cross-sectional study. BMC Oral
Health. 2020;20(1):213. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12903-020-01197-1. 41. World Health Organization. Basic methods for assessing renal fluoride
excretion in community prevention programmes for oral health. World
Health Organization, 2014. https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/112662. Accessed 25 Oct 2020. 17. STROBE Statement. Strengthening the reporting of observational studies in
epidemiology. STROBE checklists, Version 4 as published in Oct/Nov 2007. Checklist for case-control studies. http://www.strobe-statement.org/index
.php?id=available-checklists. Accessed 15 Dec 2020. 42. National Kidney Foundation: Fluoride intake in chronic kidney disease. National Kidney Foundation. New York, USA, 2008. https://www.kidney.org/
sites/default/files/docs/fluoride_intake_in_ckd.pdf. Accessed 28 Oct 2020. 18. Select statistical services. Comparing two means—sample-size. https://
select-statistics.co.uk/calculators/sample-size-calculator-two-means/. Accessed 18 Oct 2020. Acknowledgements The authors thank the children and adolescents and their parents for partici‑
pation in the study. Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Kaczmarek et al. BMC Oral Health (2021) 21:17 Page 10 of 10 Page 10 of 10 Received: 31 August 2020 Accepted: 20 December 2020 24. Neuhaus TJ, Shah V, Barratt TM. Salivary excretion of endogenous proteins in
nephrotic syndrome in children. Pediatr Nephrol. 1997;11:411–4. y
25. Carlotti AP, Franco PB, Elias LL, et al. Glucocorticoid receptors, in vitro steroid
sensitivity, and cytokine secretion in idiopathic nephrotic syndrome. Kidney
Int. 2004;65(2):403–8. References Int J Contemp Pediatr. 2016;3:768–72. 5. Noone DG, Iijima K, Parekh R. Idiopathic nephrotic syndrome in children. Lancet Lond Engl. 2018;392:61–74. 6. Arunkumar S, Arunkumar JS, Burde KN, Shankuntala GK. Developments in
diagnostic applications of saliva in oral and systemic diseases—a compre‑
hensive review. J Sci Inov Res. 2014;3:372–87. 32. Battino M, Ferreiro MS, Gallardo I, Newman HN, Bullon P. The antioxidant
capacity of saliva. J Clin Periodontol. 2002;29:189–94. 33. Maciejczyk M, Szulimowska J, Skutnik A, Taranta-Janusz K, Wasilewska A,
Wiśniewska N, Zalewska A. Salivary biomarkers of oxidative stress in children
with chronic kidney disease. J Clin Med. 2018;7(8):209. 7. Humphrey SP, Williamson RT. A review of saliva: normal composition, flow,
and function. J Prosthet Dent. 2001;85:162–9. 7. Humphrey SP, Williamson RT. A review of saliva: normal composition, flow,
and function. J Prosthet Dent. 2001;85:162–9. 8. Mittal S, Bansal V, Garg S, Arteja G, Bansal S. The diagnostic role of saliva—a
review. J Clin Exp Dent. 2011;3:314–20. 34. Tsai CW, Lin SY, Kuo CC, Huang CC. Serum uric acid and progression
of kidney disease: a longitudinal analysis and mini-review. PLoS ONE. 2017;12(1):e0170393. 34. Tsai CW, Lin SY, Kuo CC, Huang CC. Serum uric acid and progression
of kidney disease: a longitudinal analysis and mini-review. PLoS ONE. 2017;12(1):e0170393. 9. Malamud D. Saliva as a diagnostic fluid. Dent Clin N Am. 2011;5:159–78. 10. Nagler RM. Saliva analysis for monitoring dialysis and renal function. Clin
Chem. 2008;54:1415–7. 35. Riis JL, Bryce CI, Matin MJ, Stebbins JL, Kornienko O, van Huisstede L,
Granger DA. The validity, stability, and utility of measuring uric acid in saliva. Biomark Med. 2018;12:583–96. 11. Nagarathinam AE, Kumar TD, Kumar AR, Vasanthira K, Laksmi RS, Jayant
VS. Salivary urea and creatinine as a diagnostic marker of chronic kidney
disease—review. J Dent Med Sci. 2017;16:95–100. 36. Lasisi TJ, Raji YR, Salako BL. Salivary creatinine and urea analysis in patients
with chronic kidney disease: a case control study. BMC Nephrol. 2016;1:10. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12882-016-0222-x. 36. Lasisi TJ, Raji YR, Salako BL. Salivary creatinine and urea analysis in patients
with chronic kidney disease: a case control study. BMC Nephrol. 2016;1:10. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12882-016-0222-x. 12. Renda R. Can salivary creatinine and urea levels be used to diagnose chronic
kidney disease in children as accurately as serum creatinine and urea levels? A case–control study. Ren Fail. 2017;39:452–7. 37. Esmaeeili M, Azarfar A, Hoseinalizadeh S. Author details
1 21. Lowry OH, Rosebrough NJ, Farr AL, Randall RJ. Protein measurement with
the Folin phenol reagent. J Biol Chem. 1951;193:265–75. 1 Department of Conservative Dentistry and Pedodontics, Wroclaw Medical
University, Krakowska 26, 50‑425 Wrocław, Poland. 2 Department and Clinic
of Pediatric Nephrology, Wroclaw Medical University, Borowska 213,
50‑556 Wrocław, Poland. p
g
22. Mansson-Rahemtulla B, Baldone DC, Pruitt KM, Rahemtulla F. Specific assays
for peroxidases in human saliva. Arch Oral Biol. 1986;31:661–8. for peroxidases in human saliva. Arch Oral Biol. 1986;31:661–8. 23. Schwartz GJ, Muñoz A, Schneider MF, Mak RH, Kaskel F, Warady BA, Furth 23. Schwartz GJ, Muñoz A, Schneider MF, Mak RH, Kaskel F, Warady BA, Furth
SL. New equations to estimate GFR in children with CKD. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2009;20:629–37. SL. New equations to estimate GFR in children with CKD. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2009;20:629–37. Received: 31 August 2020 Accepted: 20 December 2020 Received: 31 August 2020 Accepted: 20 December 2020 Publisher’s Note
S
N Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in pub‑
lished maps and institutional affiliations. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in pub‑
lished maps and institutional affiliations. 19. World Health Organization. Oral health surveys—basic methods. 5th edn;
2013. http://www.who.int/oral_health/publications/9789241548649/en/. Accessed 20 Oct 2020. 20. Wolf HF, Rateitschak EM, Rateitschak KH, Hassel TM. Periodontologie. In:
Rateitschak KH, Wolf HF, editors. Color atlas of dental medicine. 3rd ed. New
York: George Thieme Stuttgart; 2005. p. 68–9.
|
W4385550032.txt
|
https://jnanobiotechnology.biomedcentral.com/counter/pdf/10.1186/s12951-023-02009-8
|
en
|
Correction: Detection of β-amyloid aggregates/plaques in 5xFAD mice by labelled native PLGA nanoparticles: implication in the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease
|
Journal of nanobiotechnology
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 359
|
Govindarajan and Kar Journal of Nanobiotechnology
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12951-023-02009-8
Journal of Nanobiotechnology
(2023) 21:251
Open Access
CO R R E C T I O N
Correction: Detection of β-amyloid
aggregates/plaques in 5xFAD mice by labelled
native PLGA nanoparticles: implication in the
diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease
Karthivashan Govindarajan1 and Satyabrata Kar1*
Correction: Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2023)
21:216
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12951-023-01957-5
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations.
Following publication of the original article [1], the
authors identified an error in the figure citation. The
change is highlighted in bold typeface.
“Pearson’s “r” values obtained as a function of time
(Fig. 5A-G)” should be replaced with “Pearson’s “r” values
obtained as a function of time (Fig. 6A-G)”.
“The original article [1] has been corrected”.
References
Govindarajan K, Kar S. Detection of β-amyloid aggregates/plaques in 5xFAD
mice by labelled native PLGA nanoparticles: implication in the diagnosis of
Alzheimer’s disease. J Nanobiotechnol 2023;21:216. https://doi.org/10.1186/
s12951-023-01957-5
The online version of the original article can be found at https://doi.
org/10.1186/s12951-023-01957-5
*Correspondence:
Satyabrata Kar
skar@ualberta.ca
1
Departments of Medicine (Neurology), Centre for Prions and Protein
Folding Diseases, Neuroscience and Mental Health Institute, University of
Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2M8, Canada
© The Author(s) 2023. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use,
sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and
the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this
article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included
in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will
need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The
Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available
in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.
|
|
https://openalex.org/W1966723896
|
https://bmccancer.biomedcentral.com/counter/pdf/10.1186/1471-2407-14-788
|
English
| null |
Obesity is a significant risk factor for breast cancer in Arab women
|
BMC cancer
| 2,014
|
cc-by
| 6,651
|
RESEARCH ARTICLE Open Access * Correspondence: nelkum@hotmail.com
1Division of Clinical Epidemiology, Sidra Medical and Research Centre, Doha,
Qatar
4Department of Biostatistics, Epidemiology, and Scientific Computing,
KFSH&RC, MBC#03, KSA, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © 2014 Elkum et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited. The Creative Commons Public Domain
Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article,
unless otherwise stated. Obesity is a significant risk factor for breast
cancer in Arab women Naser Elkum1,4*, Taher Al-Tweigeri2, Dahish Ajarim2, Ali Al-Zahrani14, Suad M Bin Amer3 and Abde her Al-Tweigeri2, Dahish Ajarim2, Ali Al-Zahrani14, Suad M Bin Amer3 and Abdelilah Aboussekhra3 Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Abstract Background: Breast cancer (BC) is the most common malignancy and the leading cause of cancer-related death
amongst women worldwide. The risk factors of this disease are numerous, and their prevalence varies between
racial and ethnic groups as well as geographical regions. Therefore, we sought to delineate the association of
socio-demographic, reproductive and life-style related risk factors with breast cancer in the Arab population. Methods: Unmatched case-control study was conducted in the kingdom of Saudi Arabia using 534 cases of
histologically confirmed breast cancer and 638 controls. Controls were randomly selected from primary health care
visits and were free of breast cancer. Unconditional logistic regression analysis was performed to estimate odds
ratios (ORs) and to examine the predictive effect of each factor on risk for BC. All study participants were
interviewed by trained interviewers at hospital (cases) or at primary health care centers (controls). Results: A total of 1172 women were eligible for this study, of which 281 (24.0%) were aged ≤35 years, 22.9%
illiterate, 43.6% employed, 89.5% married, and 38.1% were obese. Grade III tumors constituted 38.4% of cases. Tumor stage I was 7.5%; II, 50.7%; II, 30.9%; IV, 11.1%. We have shown strong association between breast cancer
among Arab females and obesity (OR =2.29, 95% CI 1.68-3.13), positive family history of breast cancer (OR =2.31,
95% CI 1.60 – 3.32), the use of hormonal replacement therapy (OR =2.25, 95% CI 1.65 – 3.08), post-menopause
(OR =1.72, 95% CI 1.25 – 2.38), lack of education (OR =9.09, 95% CI 5.88 – 14.29), and never breastfeed (OR =1.89,
95% CI 1.19 – 2.94). Conclusion: These results indicate the presence of classical risk factors established in the western countries, and
also some specific ones, which may result from genetic and/or environmental factors. Thereby, these findings will
be of great value to establish adequate evidence-based awareness and preventative measures in the Arab world. Keywords: Breast cancer, Obesity, Risk factors, Epidemiology, Arab women * Correspondence: nelkum@hotmail.com
1 Background is characterized by high aggressiveness, poor clinicopatho-
logic features and early onset [7-9]. Indeed, breast cancer
cases tend to be found in younger women with median
age of 47 years as compared to 63 in industrialized nations,
and with advanced stage of the disease [3,9,10]. Young age
at onset of breast cancer correlates with a worse prognosis
irrespective of the menopausal status, since age remains a
risk factor among premenopausal women [11]. Breast cancer is the most common malignancy and the
leading cause of cancer-related death amongst women
worldwide [1,2]. Similarly, in the kingdom of Saudi Arabia
(KSA), breast cancer is currently the most common malig-
nancy among females [3-5]. It represents 23% of the total
number of cancer cases in the kingdom. The incidence of
this disease is witnessing a gradual increase with total can-
cer cases diagnosed at an average annual age standardized
rate (ASR) of 15.6/100,000 [6]. Breast cancer among Saudis A number of breast cancer-related etiological factors
have been identified [12-15]. These include genetic, re-
productive, environmental and socioeconomic risk fac-
tors [16]. In addition, it is becoming increasingly evident
that obesity, young age at menarche, late age at first
child, short period of lactation and being physically in-
active are important risk factors for developing breast Page 2 of 10 Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 cancer in different countries. Furthermore, geographical,
racial and ethnic distributions also have major effects on
the incidence and the pathophysiology of the disease
[1,17-21]. Notably, studies in developed countries with
high prevalence of established risk factors showed that ap-
proximately 50% of breast cancer risk is attributable to the
established factors [22]. However, the vast majority of
these factors were identified and their effects were studied
only on western populations. Furthermore, the Gail model
on breast cancer risk assessment has been developed in
order to predict the number of cancers likely to develop
within cohorts of white American women with specific
risk factors [23-25]. Therefore, in order to design mean-
ingful prevention strategies, it is very important to identify
these factors for each population and geographical loca-
tion, and to understand the reasons of the observed differ-
ences. At present, there is no data available on the breast
cancer risk factors for the Arab population. Histological features of breast cancer cases in KSA Histological features of breast cancer cases in KSA g
In the present study we made use of 534 cases of histolog-
ically confirmed breast cancer and 638 controls. The age
at diagnosis of the breast cancer cases ranged from 22 to
75 years with a mean of 43.6 (SD =8.3) years. While 49.7%
of cases were premenopausal, 50.3% of cases were post-
menopausal (Table 1). Tumors were of different stages
and grades. Tumor stage I was 7.5%; II, 50.7%; II, 30.9%;
IV, 11.1%. Figure 1 presents the distribution of age at diag-
nosis of breast cancer patients according to different clas-
ses of tumor stage left/right. The results show early mean
age of diagnosis with advanced stage. Grade II and III tu-
mors represented 56.7% and 38.4% of cases, respectively
(Table 1). Furthermore, while Her-2 was negative in 54.6%
of cases, ER-negative and PR-negative tumors represented
32.4% and 41.2% of cases respectively (Table 1). Interest-
ingly, a significant association was observed between ER
status and the menopausal status. Indeed, while 19.6% of
premenopausal patients had ER-negative tumors, only Study population The study cases were female patients with histological-
confirmed primary breast cancer. We started interviewing
patients, in the Oncology Department at King Faisal
Specialist Hospital & Research Center (KFSH&RC) Riyadh. The controls were Saudi women aged 18 years or older,
who visited the primary health care and were cancer free. Volunteers were enrolled in the study during the same cal-
endar period as cases, from all Saudi provinces. Controls
were randomly selected and approached while waiting
for their doctor’s appointment. Nearly 96% of women
approached for the study chose to participate. KFSH&RC
is a tertiary care facility and serves as the main referring
center for the whole Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA). Therefore, it is conceivable that the cancer pattern seen at
KFSH&RC is a reflection to that seen in the whole coun-
try. This survey was carried out between June 2007 and
August 2012. The study conformed to the principles
outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved
by the Research Ethics committee (Office of Research
Affairs) at King Faisal Specialist Hospital & Research
Center, RAC-2031091. Background Therefore, in
an attempt to identify and better define these risk factors
for breast cancer among Arab women, we initiated the
present case-control study. menstrual and reproductive history included age at me-
narche, menopausal status, age at menopause, pregnancy,
and duration of breastfeeding for each live birth. Body
height and weight were measured in light indoor clothing
without shoes. Obesity was assessed using BMI cutoffs standard cri-
teria; BMI between 18.5 and 24.9 was considered normal,
25 to 29.9, overweight, and equal to or higher than 30, was
considered obese. The education level was stratified into
three categories: illiterate, primary or high school educa-
tion and university studies. Data analysis
F
i Frequencies
of categorical variables for cases and
controls were computed. Tumor characteristics were
cross-tabulated
between
pre-menopause
and
post-
menopause and differences were assessed using χ2 test. Unconditional logistic regression analysis was per-
formed to estimate odds ratios (ORs) and to examine
the predictive effect of each factor on risk for breast
cancer. Multiple logistic regressions were fitted to adjust
for age (≤35 years vs. >35 years), BMI (lean, overweight,
obese), marital status (single, ever married), menopause
status (pre-menopause, post-menopause), HRT use (yes/
no), age at menarche (<13 years vs. ≥13 years), breastfeed-
ing (yes/no), and education levels (illiterate, primary/high
school, higher education). Median age at menarche and
median age at menopause were chosen as cutoffs values
for categorical. For ordered categorical variables, P-value
for linear trend was reported. All statistical assessments
were two-sided and considered significant with p-value
<0.05. Data analysis was carried out using SAS© software
(version 9.4; SAS Institute, Cary, NC). Data collection All study participants were interviewed by trained inter-
viewers at hospital (cases) or at primary health care cen-
ters (controls). A structured questionnaire was used to
elicit detailed information on demographic factors, men-
strual and reproductive history, hormone use, dietary
habits, prior disease history, physical activity, tobacco and
alcohol use, and family history of cancer. Information on Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Page 3 of 10 12.9% of postmenopausal cases had ER-negative tumors
(p =0.0037) (Table 1). Breast cancer sociodemographic risk factors
A total of 1172 women were eligible for this study, of
which 281 (24.0%) were aged ≤35 years, 22.9% illiterate,
43 6%
l
d 89 5%
i d
d 38 1%
b
Table 1 Tumor characteristics of the study cases
Parameter
Total (%)
N = 534
Pre-menopause
n =266
Post-menopause
n =267
p-value
Laterality
0.6945
Left
275 (51.5)
133 (24.9)
142 (26.7)
Right
250 (46.8)
129 (24.1)
120 (22.6)
Bilateral
9 (1.7)
4 (0.75)
5 (0.94)
Stage Left
0.9483
I
14(5.0)
7 (2.5)
7 (2.5)
II
147 (52.5)
73 (26.1)
74 (26.5)
III
90 (32.1)
42 (15.0)
48 (17.2)
IV
29 (10.4)
13 (4.7)
16 (5.7)
Stage Right
0.0945
I
26 (10.2)
15 (5.9)
11 (4.4)
II
123 (48.2)
67 (26.4)
56 (22.1)
III
76 (29.8)
39 (15.4)
36 (14.2)
IV
30 (11.8)
9 (3.6)
21 (8.3)
Grade
0.5207
I
25 (4.9)
15 (3.0)
10 (2.0)
II
285 (56.7)
141 (28.2)
143 (28.6)
III
193 (38.4)
91 (18.2)
100 (20.0)
ER
Negative
173 (32.4)
104 (19.6)
69 (12.9)
Positive
312 (58.4)
139 (26.2)
170 (32.0)
0.0037
Unknown
49 (9.2)
21 (3.9)
28 (5.3)
PR
Negative
220 (41.2)
120 (22.6)
98 (18.5)
Positive
265 (49.6)
123 (23.2)
141 (26.6)
0.1091
Unknown
49 (9.2)
21 (3.9)
28 (5.3)
Her_2
Negative
162 (54.6)
86 (29.3)
74 (25.2)
Positive
132 (44.4)
77 (26.2)
54 (18.4)
0.5072
Unknown
3 (1.0)
1 (0.34)
2 (0.68)
Missing a pre-menopausal patient. Table 1 Tumor characteristics of the study cases However, there was no significant difference between
cases and controls regarding family history of other cancer
(p =0.9653) (Table 2). Figure 2 shows significant associations between BMI
and each of education, employment status and marital
status. Illiterate, unemployed and married women had sig-
nificantly higher mean BMI (P < 0.0001). Education levels
showed high association with marital status and employ-
ment in our population (P < 0.0001). Breast cancer life style risk factors Alcohol is not available in KSA due to religion issues and
therefore its consumption is not a risk factor for this popu-
lation. Likewise, cigarette smoking was not a common prac-
tice among Arab females. Indeed, only 29.8% of cases and
28.8% of controls ever smoked. However, this difference
was not statistically significant (p =0.6995) (Table 2), sug-
gesting that cigarette smoking was not a risk factor for
breast cancer in this population. 12.9% of postmenopausal cases had ER-negative tumors
(p =0.0037) (Table 1). Obesity is a significant breast cancer risk factor in the
Arab population It became clear that obesity plays a major role in develop-
ment and spread of breast cancer [26,27]. To elucidate the
impact of this important risk factor on the Arab popula-
tion, we investigated the link between breast cancer and
obesity among cases and controls. Table 2 shows clear
difference between patients and controls according to
their BMI. The proportion of overweight/obese (BMI ≥25)
females was significantly higher among breast cancer pa-
tients (75.8%) than among healthy controls (61.3%) (OR
=1.74 and p <0.0001). This clearly shows that obesity is
a significant risk factor for breast cancer among Arab
women. Data collection Among illiterate
women, only 2.8% were working and 96.5% were married;
whereas among highly educated women, 87.3% were
employed and 80.4% were married (Figure 3). Furthermore, Table 2 shows significant difference in
education and occupation between cases and controls. Indeed, while higher proportion (50.9%) of breast cancer
females had received primary education as compared to
controls (41.9%), only 12.4% of cases had completed
post-high school education as compared to controls
46.0%. This indicates that lower level of education was
associated with a significant increased risk of breast can-
cer in the Arab population (p <0.0001). In line with this,
74.2% of the enrolled patients never worked as com-
pared with control subjects (57.8%), indicating that un-
employment is significantly related to breast cancer
development (OR =3.94, 95% CI 3.05 – 5.09) (Table 2). Moreover, significant difference was found between cases
and controls regarding marital status (p <0.0001), with the
marriage representing a risk factor in this population
(Table 2). Breast cancer reproductive risk factors Table 3 shows that 49.7% of Arab breast cancer patients
were pre-menopausal. However, more patients (50.3%)
were post-menopausal as compared to controls (23.5%). This difference was highly significant (p <0.0001), showing
high breast cancer risk among post-menopausal females. Most of the Arab females (70.0% cases and 92% controls)
reached menopause after 45, and the age at menopause
was observed to be associated with increased risk. Indeed,
the odds of the risk are 80% lower in women who had
menopause after 45 years of age (OR =0.20, P =0.0001). Table 3 shows also that as many as 64.1% of Arab breast
cancer patients have used hormonal replacement therapy
(HRT) as compared to controls (47.7%), indicating that
the use of HRT doubled the chances of developing breast Breast cancer sociodemographic risk factors A total of 1172 women were eligible for this study, of
which 281 (24.0%) were aged ≤35 years, 22.9% illiterate,
43.6% employed, 89.5% married, and 38.1% were obese. Family history of breast cancer, the marital status, educa-
tion and occupation of breast cancer patients as well as
healthy controls were investigated as sociodemographic
risk factors of breast cancer among Arabs in KSA. Inter-
estingly, higher proportion of cases (21.9%) than controls
(11.4%) reported positive family history of breast cancer
with high significance (OR =2.18, 95% CI 1.58 – 2.99). Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788 Page 4 of 10 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Figure 1 Least square means of age at diagnosis of breast cancer by stage. Figure 1 Least square means of age at diagnosis of breast cancer by stage. Figure 1 Least square means of age at diagnosis of breast cancer by stage. When the menopausal status of cases was taken into
consideration, we have found 74.7% of pre-menopausal
patients were either overweight or obese, while only
58.5% of premenopausal controls exhibited BMI ≥30
with (OR =2.47, p <0.0001), indicating two-half fold in-
crease in breast cancer risk among obese premenopausal
patients (Table 2). In the post-menopausal females, obese
women have 66% increase chance of breast cancer com-
pared to lean post-menopause (Table 2). cancer (OR =1.96, p <0.0001). On the other hand, no sig-
nificant difference was found between cases and controls
regarding breast feeding (p =0.8739) as well as age at me-
narche in univariate analysis (p =0.0767) (Table 3). Independent breast cancer risk factors among Arabs Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that fac-
tors that were independently associated with breast can-
cer are obesity (OR =2.29, 95% CI 1.68-3.13), positive
family history of breast cancer (OR =2.31, 95% CI 1.60 –
3.32), HRT use (OR =2.25, 95% CI 1.65 – 3.08), post-
menopause (OR =1.72, 95% CI 1.25 – 2.38), late age of
menarche (OR =1.30, 95% CI 0.99 – 1.72), never breast-
feed (OR =1.89, 95% CI 1.19 – 2.94), and lack of educa-
tion (OR =9.09, 95% CI 5.88 – 14.29) (Table 4). Discussion Identification of risk factors and women at high risk for
developing breast cancer is highly important for prevent-
ing the development of the disease. Owing to the paucity
of such data among Arab females, we decided to assess
here the strength of association between recognized socio-
demographic, reproductive and anthropometric risk fac-
tors for breast cancer among Arabs in KSA. This is the
first case-control epidemiological investigation on breast Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Page 5 of 10 Page 5 of 10 Table 2 Socio-demographical characteristics of the Saudi breast cancer cases and controls
Socio-demographic characteristics
Cases number (%)
Control number (%)
OR 95% confidence intervals
P-value
Age, years
< 0.0001
≤35
80 (15.0)
201 (31.5)
1
> 35
454 (85.0)
437 (68.5)
2.61 (1.95 – 3.49)
Family History of Breast Cancer
117 (21.9)
72 (11.4)
2.18 (1.58 – 2.99)
< 0.0001
Family History of Cancer
221 (41.4)
262 (41.3)
1.01 (0.80 – 1.27)
0.9653
Education Level
< 0.0001
Illiterate-no schooling
183 (36.7)
76 (12.1)
1
1 – 12 years
254 (50.9)
264 (41.9)
0.40 (0.29 – 0.55)
> 12 years
62 (12.4)
290 (46.0)
0.09 (0.06 – 0.13)
Ever Married (no)
23 (4.3)
100 (15.7)
0.24 (0.15 – 0.39)
< 0.0001
Never Worked
368 (74.2)
263 (42.2)
3.94 (3.05 – 5.09)
< 0.0001
Ever Smoke (yes)
158 (29.8)
181 (28.8)
1.05 (0.82 – 1.36)
0.6995
BMI, kg/m2
All
< 0.0001
Lean
129 (24.2)
247 (38.7)
1
Overweight
157 (29.4)
193 (30.3)
1.56 (1.15 – 2.10)
Obese
248 (46.4)
198 (31.0)
2.40 (1.81 – 3.18)
Pre-Menopause
< 0.0001
Lean
67 (25.4)
201 (41.5)
1
Overweight
86 (32.6)
148 (30.6)
1.74 (1.19 – 2.56)
Obese
111 (42.1)
135 (27.9)
2.47 (1.70 – 3.58)
Post-Menopause
0.1191
Lean
60 (22.5)
45 (30.2)
1
Overweight
70 (26.2)
42 (28.2)
1.25 (0.73 – 2.15)
Obese
137 (51.3)
62 (41.6)
1.66 (1.02 – 2.70)
Abbreviations: OR odds ratio, BMI body mass index. Lean: BMI (18.5 - 24.9); Overweight: BMI (25 - 29.9); Obese: BMI (≥30). Table 2 Socio-demographical characteristics of the Saudi breast cancer cases and controls
Socio-demographic characteristics
Cases number (%)
Control number (%)
OR 95% co ocio-demographical characteristics of the Saudi breast cancer cases and controls Abbreviations: OR odds ratio, BMI body mass index. Lean: BMI (18.5 - 24.9); Overweight: BMI (25 - 29.9); Obese: BMI (≥30). Abbreviations: OR odds ratio, BMI body mass index. Discussion Lean: BMI (18.5 - 24.9); Overweight: BMI (25 - 29.9); Obese: BMI (≥30). observed between the development of the disease and
the presence of other types of cancer in the family. cancer risk factors in KSA. We have found that many
established risk factors are also associated with breast can-
cer among Arab females, and therefore coincide with re-
sults of Western populations in this regard. Among the
well-established risk factors of breast cancer, only obesity,
positive family history of breast cancer, use of hormonal
replacement therapy, education and employment status
were significantly associated with higher risks of breast
cancer in this population. Using BMI as reference, we found 75.8% of the cases had
abnormal weight. Obesity was found to be associated with
breast cancer. Overweight/Obese women exhibit more
than 2-fold increased risk of breast cancer (OR =2.29)
compared to women with normal BMI. Our data support
the concept that obesity is a strong risk factor for the dis-
ease, which is consistent with previous reports on different
populations in various regions [26,31]. In the Arab popu-
lation, breast cancer risk was significantly higher among
females who were overweight or obese both pre- and
post-menopausal (OR =2.73 and OR =2.22 respectively;
p <0.0001). On the other hand, obesity was shown to play
a protective effect against developing breast cancer in pre-
menopausal Caucasian females [26], while other studies
have shown no association between obesity and breast can-
cer risk [29]. This discrepancy may have several explana-
tions,
including
the
implication
of
genetic
and/or In the present study, we have shown that family his-
tory of breast cancer is an independent predictor of
breast cancer. Women with a positive family history of
breast cancer showed about threefold increased risk of
breast cancer (OR =2.31, p <0.0001). This parallels what
has been previously reported in various populations in
different geographical regions [28,29]. This also reflects
the role of genetic and epigenetic modifications at im-
portant genes such as BRCA1 and BRCA2 in the predis-
position to the disease [30]. However, no association was Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788 Page 6 of 10 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Figure 2 Least square means of BMI according to various breast cancer risk factors. igure 2 Least square means of BMI according to various breast cancer risk factors. Discussion environmental factors in the obesity-related development
of the disease or physical inactivity. Generally, people in
the Gulf countries are physically inactive and spend their
leisure time in sedentary activities [32]. Therefore, appro-
priate measures need to be taken by the healthcare plan-
ners to prevent weight gain and obesity that will probably
be more cost effective than the treatment of breast cancer
and related complications. Furthermore, preventive life-
style interventions should be targeted at lowering over-
weight in Arab women. increase the risk of breast cancer for women who were
treated for at least 5-years [33,34]. Our data show that
using HRT doubles the chance of developing the disease
among Arab females. Breast cancer among Arab females is significantly re-
lated with the level of education. Indeed, lack of educa-
tion was an independent risk factor for breast cancer
and was 6 times more common among illiterate females
as compared to the highly educated ones, and the risk
decreases as the level of education increases. Women
with higher education might have healthier lifestyle,
which could play a key role in preventing the disease. We have also observed positive association between
HRT and breast cancer; confirming the fact that use of
HRT increases breast cancer risk. Previous studies have
concluded that combinations of estrogen-progesterone Our results showed that breastfeeding has a protective
effect against breast cancer development. Cases were less Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788 Page 7 of 10 Page 7 of 10 http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Figure 3 The proportion of married and employed women by education levels. Figure 3 The proportion of married and employed women by education levels. Median values were used as cutoff point for age at menopause and age at menarche.
Abbreviation: OR odds ratio. Discussion Table 3 Reproductive characteristics of Saudi breast cancer cases and controls
Parameter
Cases number (%)
Controls number (%)
OR 95% confidence intervals
P-values
Menopausal Status
< 0.0001
Pre-menopause
264 (49.7)
484 (76.5)
1
Postmenopausal
267 (50.3)
149 (23.5)
3.29 (2.56 – 4.22)
Age at menarche (years)
0.0767
< 13
379 (70.9)
422 (66.1)
1
≥13
155 (29.1)
216 (33.9)
0.80 (0.62 – 1.03)
Breastfeeding
0.8739
No
38 (8.0)
38 (8.0)
1
Yes
440 (92.1)
457 (92.0)
0.96 (0.60 – 1.54)
Use of hormonal replacement therapy
< 0.0001
No
191 (35.9)
329 (52.3)
1
Yes
341 (64.1)
300 (47.7)
1.96 (1.55 – 2.48)
Age at menopause (years)
0.0001
< 45
67 (30.0)
7 (8.0)
1
≥45
156 (70.0)
81 (92)
0.20 (0.09 – 0.46)
Median values were used as cutoff point for age at menopause and age at menarche. Abbreviation: OR odds ratio. Table 3 Reproductive characteristics of Saudi breast cancer cases and controls Page 8 of 10 Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Page 8 of 10 Table 4 Factors independently associated with Saudi breast cancer women - multiple logistic regression
Parameters
All
Pre-menopausal
Post-menopause
OR (95% CI)
BMI, kg/m2
Lean, (18.5 – 24.9)
1
1
1
Overweight/Obese (≥25)
2.29 (1.68 – 3.13)
2.73 (1.79 – 4.18)
2.22 (1.32 – 3.72)
Family history of breast cancer
-
No
1
1
Yes
2.31(1.60 – 3.32)
5.04 (3.09 – 8.21)
Age at menarche (years)
-
-
< 13
1
≥13
1.30 (0.99 – 1.72)
Use of HRT
No
1
1
1
Yes
2.25 (1.65 – 3.08)
1.73 (1.13 – 2.67)
2.45 (1.53 – 3.92)
Menopausal Status
-
-
Pre-menopause
1
Post-menopause
1.72 (1.25 – 2.38)
Breastfeeding
No
1
1
Yes
0.53 (0.34 – 0.84)
0.20 (0.08 – 0.50)
Education Level
Illiterate
1
1
1
Primary/High School
0.40 (0.28 – 0.58)
0.11 (0.06 – 0.27)
0.73 (0.44 – 1.20)
Higher education
0.11 (0.07 – 0.17)
0.03 (0.01 – 0.07)
0.21 (0.10 – 0.45)
Model adjusted for age (≤35 years vs. >35 years), BMI (lean, overweight/obese), marital status (single, ever-married), menopause status (pre-menopause, post-menopause),
HRT use (yes/no), age at menarche (<13 years vs. ≥13 years), breastfeeding (yes/no), and education levels (illiterate, primary/high school, higher education). All variables in
the model are categorical. Abbreviations: OR odds ratio, CI confidence interval, BMI body mass index. Discussion Table 4 Factors independently associated with Saudi breast cancer women - multiple logistic regression
Parameters
All
Pre-menopausal
Post-menopause
OR (95% CI)
BMI, kg/m2
Lean, (18.5 – 24.9)
1
1
1
Overweight/Obese (≥25)
2.29 (1.68 – 3.13)
2.73 (1.79 – 4.18)
2.22 (1.32 – 3.72)
Family history of breast cancer
-
No
1
1
Yes
2.31(1.60 – 3.32)
5.04 (3.09 – 8.21)
Age at menarche (years)
-
-
< 13
1
≥13
1.30 (0.99 – 1.72)
Use of HRT
No
1
1
1
Yes
2.25 (1.65 – 3.08)
1.73 (1.13 – 2.67)
2.45 (1.53 – 3.92)
Menopausal Status
-
-
Pre-menopause
1
Post-menopause
1.72 (1.25 – 2.38)
Breastfeeding
No
1
1
Yes
0.53 (0.34 – 0.84)
0.20 (0.08 – 0.50)
Education Level
Illiterate
1
1
1
Primary/High School
0.40 (0.28 – 0.58)
0.11 (0.06 – 0.27)
0.73 (0.44 – 1.20)
Higher education
0.11 (0.07 – 0.17)
0.03 (0.01 – 0.07)
0.21 (0.10 – 0.45)
Model adjusted for age (≤35 years vs. >35 years), BMI (lean, overweight/obese), marital status (single, ever-married), menopause status (pre-menopause, post-menopause),
HRT use (yes/no), age at menarche (<13 years vs. ≥13 years), breastfeeding (yes/no), and education levels (illiterate, primary/high school, higher education). All variables in
the model are categorical. Abbreviations: OR odds ratio, CI confidence interval, BMI body mass index. Table 4 Factors independently associated with Saudi breast cancer women - multiple logistic regression Post-menopause Model adjusted for age (≤35 years vs. >35 years), BMI (lean, overweight/obese), marital status (single, ever-married), menopause status (pre-menopause, post-menopause),
HRT use (yes/no), age at menarche (<13 years vs. ≥13 years), breastfeeding (yes/no), and education levels (illiterate, primary/high school, higher education). All variables in
the model are categorical. Abbreviations: OR odds ratio, CI confidence interval, BMI body mass index. which is a tertiary care facility that serves as the main
referring center for the whole Kingdom of Saudi Arabia,
cases were collected from different regions of the coun-
try. This may constitute a bias as to the origin of the pa-
tients/controls. Furthermore, controls were all recruited
from hospitals. Our sample size of 534 cases and 638
controls may seem rather small for such studies. An-
other limitation is that BMI, which may change with
time, was measured only once for both patients and
controls. likely than controls to have breastfeed (OR =0.51). This
finding is consistent with the results of many other stud-
ies [29,35-37]. Discussion Further investigations are recommended
to understand the underlying mechanisms of the influ-
ence of breastfeeding on breast cancer. It is well established that breast cancer risk increases
with early age at menarche [16]. Surprisingly, we ob-
served an inverse association between early age at me-
narche and breast cancer risk. Similar result has been
recently reported in the Chinese population [38]. This
suggests that early age at menarche represents a protect-
ive factor in these populations. This may be due to gen-
etic and/or environmental factors. References 1. Jemal A, Bray F, Center MM, Ferlay J, Ward E, Forman D: Global cancer
statistics. CA Cancer J Clin 2011, 61(2):69–90. 28. Collaborative Group on Hormonal Factors in Breast Cancer: Familial breast
cancer: collaborative reanalysis of individual data from 52
epidemiological studies including 58,209 women with breast cancer and
101,986 women without the disease. Lancet 2001, 358(9291):1389–1399. 2. Youlden DR, Cramb SM, Dunn NA, Muller JM, Pyke CM, Baade PD: The 2. Youlden DR, Cramb SM, Dunn NA, Muller JM, Pyke CM, Baade PD: The
descriptive epidemiology of female breast cancer: an international
comparison of screening, incidence, survival and mortality. Cancer
Epidemiol 2012, 36(3):237–248. 29. Hadjisavvas A, Loizidou MA, Middleton N, Michael T, Papachristoforou R,
Kakouri E, Daniel M, Papadopoulos P, Malas S, Marcou Y, Kyriacou K: An
investigation of breast cancer risk factors in Cyprus: a case control study. BMC Cancer 2010, 10:447. 3. El Saghir NS, Khalil MK, Eid T, El Kinge AR, Charafeddine M, Geara F, Seoud M,
Shamseddine AI: Trends in epidemiology and management of breast cancer
in developing Arab countries: a literature and registry analysis. Int J Surg
2007, 5(4):225–233. 30. el El-Harith HA, Abdel-Hadi MS, Steinmann D, Dork T: BRCA1 and BRCA2
mutations in breast cancer patients from Saudi Arabia. Saudi Med J 2002,
23(6):700–704. 4. Ravichandran K, Al-Zahrani AS: Association of reproductive factors with
the incidence of breast cancer in Gulf Cooperation Council countries. East Mediterr Health J 2009, 15(3):612–621. 4. Ravichandran K, Al-Zahrani AS: Association of reproductive factors with
the incidence of breast cancer in Gulf Cooperation Council countries. East Mediterr Health J 2009, 15(3):612–621. 31. Deglise C, Bouchardy C, Burri M, Usel M, Neyroud-Caspar I, Vlastos G,
Chappuis PO, Ceschi M, Ess S, Castiglione M, Rapiti E, Verkooijen HM: Impact
of obesity on diagnosis and treatment of breast cancer. Breast Cancer Res
Treat 2010, 120(1):185–193. 5. Al-Hamdan N, Ravichandran K, Al-Sayyad J, Al-Lawati J, Khazal Z, Al-Khateeb
F, Abdulwahab A, Al-Asfour A: Incidence of cancer in Gulf Cooperation
Council countries, 1998-2001. East Mediterr Health J 2009, 15(3):600–611. 5. Al-Hamdan N, Ravichandran K, Al-Sayyad J, Al-Lawati J, Khazal Z, Al-Khateeb
F, Abdulwahab A, Al-Asfour A: Incidence of cancer in Gulf Cooperation
Council countries, 1998-2001. East Mediterr Health J 2009, 15(3):600–611. 32. Mabry RM, Reeves MM, Eakin EG, Owen N: Evidence of physical activity
participation among men and women in the countries of the Gulf
cooperation council: a review. Consent adverse prognostic factor in premenopausal patients with breast cancer. Clin Breast Cancer 2002, 3(1):65–72. adverse prognostic factor in premenopausal patients with breast cancer. Clin Breast Cancer 2002, 3(1):65–72. Written informed consent was obtained from the patient
for the publication of this report and any accompanying
images. 12. Rosner B, Colditz GA, Willett WC: Reproductive risk factors in a prospective
study of breast cancer: the Nurses’ Health Study. Am J Epidemiol 1994,
139(8):819–835. 13. Kelsey JL, Gammon MD, John EM: Reproductive factors and breast cancer. Epidemiol Rev 1993, 15(1):36–47. Conclusions In conclusion, among other risk factors, obesity increases
the breast cancer risk in pre- and post-menopause Arab
women. Given the fact that obesity is common among this
population, there is a need for education campaigns publi-
cizing obesity as an important risk factor for breast cancer
and encouraging Arab females to exercise and pursue
healthy lifestyle. Finally, this study showed for the first time a number of
risk factors associated with incidence of breast cancer
among Arab women. The strongest associations were fam-
ily history of breast cancer, obesity, use of HRT, being
post-menopause, illiterate, and having never breastfeed. Our study had limitations commonly seen in this type
of studies. While cases were only from one hospital, Page 9 of 10 Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Page 9 of 10 Received: 24 February 2014 Accepted: 17 October 2014
Published: 29 October 2014 26. Majed B, Moreau T, Senouci K, Salmon RJ, Fourquet A, Asselain B: Is obesity
an independent prognosis factor in woman breast cancer? Breast Cancer
Res Treat 2008, 111(2):329–342. 27. Amadou A, Hainaut P, Romieu I: Role of obesity in the risk of breast
cancer: lessons from anthropometry. J Oncol 2013, 2013:906495. Authors’ contributions 16. Dumitrescu RG, Cotarla I: Understanding breast cancer risk – where do
we stand in 2005? J Cell Mol Med 2005, 9(1):208–221. NE participated in the conception and overall supervision of the study, handled
data management, data analysis, and wrote the manuscript. TT and DA selected
cases, reviewed medical records, and editing of the manuscript; AAZ and SM
conceived of the study and participated in its coordination; AA participated in
the study conception, data interpretation and developing and writing of the
manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final version of the
manuscript. 17. Thompson D, Easton D: The genetic epidemiology of breast cancer
genes. J Mammary Gland Biol Neoplasia 2004, 9(3):221–236. 18. Bray F, McCarron P, Parkin DM: The changing global patterns of female
breast cancer incidence and mortality. Breast Cancer Res 2004, 6(6):229–239. 19. Parkin DM, Bray F, Ferlay J, Pisani P: Global cancer statistics, 2002. CA Cancer J Clin 2005, 55(2):74–108. 20. McPherson K, Steel CM, Dixon KM: ABC of breast diseases. Breast cancer-
epidemiology, risk factors, and genetics. BMJ 2000, 321(7261):624–628. epidemiology, risk factors, and genetics. BMJ 2000, 321(7261):624–628. 21. Perera NM, Gui GP: Multi-ethnic differences in breast cancer: current
concepts and future directions. Int J Cancer 2003, 106(4):463–467. Competing interests 14. Kelsey JL, Horn-Ross PL: Breast cancer: magnitude of the problem and
descriptive epidemiology. Epidemiol Rev 1993, 15(1):7–16. The authors declare they have no competing interests. 15. Lipworth L: Epidemiology of breast cancer. Eur J Cancer Prev 1995, 4(1):7–30. Acknowledgements We are very grateful to the administration of the Research Centre and the
Research Advisory Council (RAC) for their continuous support. We would also
thank Ingrid Osmond for her proofreading of the manuscript and helpful
comments. This work was performed under the RAC proposal # 2031091. Grant
sponsor: King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology (KACST # APR-24-32). 21. Perera NM, Gui GP: Multi-ethnic differences in breast cancer: current
concepts and future directions. Int J Cancer 2003, 106(4):463–467. 22. Sprague BL, Trentham-Dietz A, Egan KM, Titus-Ernstoff L, Hampton JM,
Newcomb PA: Proportion of invasive breast cancer attributable to risk
factors modifiable after menopause. Am J Epidemiol 2008, 168(4):404–411 23. Euhus DM: Understanding mathematical models for breast cancer risk
assessment and counseling. Breast J 2001, 7(4):224–232. Author details
1 1Division of Clinical Epidemiology, Sidra Medical and Research Centre, Doha,
Qatar. 2Department of Medical Oncology, KFSH&RC, Oncology Centre,
MBC#64, KSA, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 3Department of Molecular Oncology,
KFSH&RC, MBC # 03, KSA, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 4Department of Biostatistics,
Epidemiology, and Scientific Computing, KFSH&RC, MBC#03, KSA, Riyadh,
Saudi Arabia. 1Division of Clinical Epidemiology, Sidra Medical and Research Centre, Doha,
Qatar. 2Department of Medical Oncology, KFSH&RC, Oncology Centre,
MBC#64, KSA, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 3Department of Molecular Oncology,
KFSH&RC, MBC # 03, KSA, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 4Department of Biostatistics, 24. van Asperen CJ, Jonker MA, Jacobi CE, van Diemen-Homan JE, Bakker E,
Breuning MH, van Houwelingen JC, de Bock GH: Risk estimation for
healthy women from breast cancer families: new insights and new
strategies. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2004, 13(1):87–93. Epidemiology, and Scientific Computing, KFSH&RC, MBC#03, KSA, Riyadh,
Saudi Arabia. 25. Jacobi CE, de Bock GH, Siegerink B, van Asperen CJ: Differences and
similarities in breast cancer risk assessment models in clinical practice:
which model to choose? Breast Cancer Res Treat 2009, 115(2):381–390. Received: 24 February 2014 Accepted: 17 October 2014
Published: 29 October 2014 Received: 24 February 2014 Accepted: 17 October 2014
Published: 29 October 2014 References Obes Rev 2010, 11(6):457–464. 6. Al-Madouj A, Eldali A, Al-Zahrani A: Ten-Year Cancer Incidence Among
Nationals of the GCC States 1998–2007. Riyadh: Corperation Council States;
2011. 6. Al-Madouj A, Eldali A, Al-Zahrani A: Ten-Year Cancer Incidence Among
Nationals of the GCC States 1998–2007. Riyadh: Corperation Council States;
2011. 7. Ezzat AA, Ibrahim EM, Raja MA, Al-Sobhi S, Rostom A, Stuart RK: Locally
advanced breast cancer in Saudi Arabia: high frequency of stage III in a
young population. Med Oncol 1999, 16(2):95–103. 33. Beral V: Breast cancer and hormone-replacement therapy in the Million
Women Study. Lancet 2003, 362(9382):419–427. 34. Collaborative-Group-on-Hormonal-Factors-in-Breast-Cancer: Breast cancer
and hormone replacement therapy: collaborative reanalysis of data from
51 epidemiological studies of 52,705 women with breast cancer and
108,411 women without breast cancer. Lancet 1997, 350(9084):1047–1059. 8. Ibrahim EM, Ezzat AA, Rahal MM, Raja MM, Ajarim DS: Adjuvant
chemotherapy in 780 patients with early breast cancer: 10-year data
from Saudi Arabia. Med Oncol 2005, 22(4):343–352. 35. Kumar, Babita N, Singh M, Malik JS, Kalhan M: Breastfeeding reduces breast
cancer risk: a case-control study in north India. Int J Prevent MEd 2014,
5(6):791–795. 9. Elkum N, Dermime S, Ajarim D, Al-Zahrani A, Alsayed A, Tulbah A, Al Malik
O, Alshabanah M, Ezzat A, Al-Tweigeri T: Being 40 or younger is an
independent risk factor for relapse in operable breast cancer patients:
the Saudi Arabia experience. BMC Cancer 2007, 7:222. 36. Newcomb PA, Storer BE, Longnecker MP, Mittendorf R, Greenberg ER, Clapp
RW, Burke KP, Willett WC, MacMahon B: Lactation and a reduced risk of
premenopausal breast cancer. N Engl J Med 1994, 330(2):81–87. 10. Najjar H, Easson A: Age at diagnosis of breast cancer in Arab nations. Int J
Surg 2010, 8(6):448–452. 11. Dubsky PC, Gnant MF, Taucher S, Roka S, Kandioler D, Pichler-Gebhard B,
Agstner I, Seifert M, Sevelda P, Jakesz R: Young age as an independent 37. Kotsopoulos J, Lubinski J, Salmena L, Lynch HT, Kim-Sing C, Foulkes WD,
Ghadirian P, Neuhausen SL, Demsky R, Tung N, Ainsworth P, Senter L, Eisen 11. Dubsky PC, Gnant MF, Taucher S, Roka S, Kandioler D, Pichler-Gebhard B,
Agstner I, Seifert M, Sevelda P, Jakesz R: Young age as an independent Page 10 of 10 Page 10 of 10 Elkum et al. BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 Elkum et al. References BMC Cancer 2014, 14:788
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2407/14/788 A, Eng C, Singer C, Ginsburg O, Blum J, Huzarski T, Poll A, Sun P, Narod SA:
Breastfeeding and the risk of breast cancer in BRCA1 and BRCA2
mutation carriers. Breast Cancer Res 2012, 14(2):R42. 38. Xu YL, Sun Q, Shan GL, Zhang J, Liao HB, Li SY, Jiang J, Shao ZM, Jiang HC,
Shen NC, Shi Y, Yu CZ, Zhang BN, Chen YH, Duan XN, Li B: A case-control
study on risk factors of breast cancer in China. Arch Med Sci 2012,
8(2):303–309. doi:10.1186/1471-2407-14-788
Cite this article as: Elkum et al.: Obesity is a significant risk factor for
breast cancer in Arab women. BMC Cancer 2014 14:788. A, Eng C, Singer C, Ginsburg O, Blum J, Huzarski T, Poll A, Sun P, Narod SA:
Breastfeeding and the risk of breast cancer in BRCA1 and BRCA2
mutation carriers. Breast Cancer Res 2012, 14(2):R42. 38. Xu YL, Sun Q, Shan GL, Zhang J, Liao HB, Li SY, Jiang J, Shao ZM, Jiang HC,
Shen NC, Shi Y, Yu CZ, Zhang BN, Chen YH, Duan XN, Li B: A case-control
study on risk factors of breast cancer in China. Arch Med Sci 2012,
8(2):303–309. doi:10.1186/1471-2407-14-788
Cite this article as: Elkum et al.: Obesity is a significant risk factor for
breast cancer in Arab women. BMC Cancer 2014 14:788. Submit your next manuscript to BioMed Central
and take full advantage of:
• Convenient online submission
• Thorough peer review
• No space constraints or color figure charges
• Immediate publication on acceptance
• Inclusion in PubMed, CAS, Scopus and Google Scholar
• Research which is freely available for redistribution
Submit your manuscript at
www.biomedcentral.com/submit Submit your next manuscript to BioMed Central
and take full advantage of:
• Convenient online submission
• Thorough peer review
• No space constraints or color figure charges
• Immediate publication on acceptance
• Inclusion in PubMed, CAS, Scopus and Google Scholar
• Research which is freely available for redistribution
Submit your manuscript at
www.biomedcentral.com/submit
|
https://openalex.org/W2913182623
|
https://www.redalyc.org/journal/5704/570463757017/570463757017.pdf
|
Portuguese
| null |
An integrative review of the methods used for cortisol assessment in clinical studies investigating the association between Blood Pressure and Cortisol Hormone
|
Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção
| 2,019
|
cc-by
| 9,147
|
RESUMO Justificativa e Objetivos: A Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica (HAS) é uma condição de saúde que representa um problema de saúde públi-
ca mundial e sua relação com o hormônio cortisol ainda não está amplamente esclarecida. Dessa forma, esse estudo teve como objetivo
identificar na literatura, as circunstâncias de existência de associação entre a HAS com o hormônio cortisol e os métodos clínicos utilizados
para esta relação. Métodos: Realizou-se revisão Integrativa da Literatura, a partir de 17 artigos científicos publicados entre 2013 e 2017
identificados nas bases de dados EMBASE e PubMed, com os descritores hypertension e hydrocortisone, no idioma inglês. Resultados:
Verificou-se associação da HAS com o aumento do cortisol na idade a partir de 62 anos, aumento de sódio na dieta, o hábito não ingerir
o desjejum, aumento do consumo de cafeína, síndrome metabólica, obesidade, excesso de catecolaminas e alguns tipos de hormônios e
biomarcadores. Os métodos clínicos mais utilizados para esta relação foram os testes de associação, feitos com a função renal e/ou cardíaca,
síndrome metabólica, estresse, doenças crônicas associados com a avaliação de exames laboratoriais. Conclusão: Os resultados indicaram
associação entre o cortisol e a Hipertensão no avançar da idade e estilo de vida, sendo os testes de associação os métodos mais utilizados. Descritores: Hipertensão. Cortisol. Hidrocortisona. Análises Clínicas. Cuidados de saúde. ARTIGO DE REVISÃO An integrative review of the methods used for cortisol
assessment in clinical studies investigating the association
between Blood Pressure and Cortisol Hormone Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão
integrativa sobre as associações e os métodos de análises clínicas Hipertensión Arterial Sistémica y la Hormona Cortisol: una revisión integrativa
sobre las asociaciones y los métodos de análisis clínicos https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275
Recebido em: 25/06/2018
Aceito em: 05/11/2018
Disponível online: 17/01/2019
Autor Correspondente:
*Ernandes Gonçalves Dias
ernandesgdias@yahoo.com.br
Av. José Alves Miranda, 500 - Alto São João,
Mato Verde/MG, Brasil. CEP: 39527-000 *Ernandes Gonçalves Dias,1 http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4126-9383
Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim,1 http://orcig.org/0000-0003-4126-9383
Silvana Martins Mishima,1 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3936-7729
Eugênia Velludo Veiga,1 https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3677-0210
Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani,2 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3418-9134
Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi,1 http://orcid.org/0000-0003-2364-5787 https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275
Recebido em: 25/06/2018
Aceito em: 05/11/2018
Disponível online: 17/01/2019
Autor Correspondente:
*Ernandes Gonçalves Dias
ernandesgdias@yahoo.com.br
Av. José Alves Miranda, 500 - Alto São João,
Mato Verde/MG, Brasil. CEP: 39527-000 https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275
Recebido em: 25/06/2018
Aceito em: 05/11/2018
Disponível online: 17/01/2019
Autor Correspondente:
*Ernandes Gonçalves Dias
ernandesgdias@yahoo.com.br
Av. José Alves Miranda, 500 - Alto São João,
Mato Verde/MG, Brasil. CEP: 39527-000 ¹Universidade de São Paulo, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brasil. 2Laval University, Quebec, Qc, Canadá. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção
ISSN: 2238-3360
reciunisc@hotmail.com
Universidade de Santa Cruz do Sul
Brasil Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção
ISSN: 2238-3360
reciunisc@hotmail.com
Universidade de Santa Cruz do Sul
Brasil Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção
ISSN: 2238-3360
reciunisc@hotmail.com
Universidade de Santa Cruz do Sul
Brasil Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção
ISSN: 2238-3360
reciunisc@hotmail.com
Universidade de Santa Cruz do Sul
Brasil Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção
ISSN: 2238-3360
reciunisc@hotmail.com
Universidade de Santa Cruz do Sul
Brasil Gonçalves Dias, Ernandes; Augusto Bardaquim, Vanessa; Martins Mishima, Silvana; Velludo
Veiga, Eugênia; Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Cecília; do Carmo Cruz Robazzi, Maria Lucia
An integrative review of the methods used for cortisol assessment in clinical studies
investigating the association between Blood Pressure and Cortisol Hormone
Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, vol. 9, no. 1, 2019, -March, pp. 87-95
Universidade de Santa Cruz do Sul
Brasil
DOI: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Gonçalves Dias, Ernandes; Augusto Bardaquim, Vanessa; Martins Mishima, Silvana; Velludo
Veiga, Eugênia; Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Cecília; do Carmo Cruz Robazzi, Maria Lucia
An integrative review of the methods used for cortisol assessment in clinical studies
investigating the association between Blood Pressure and Cortisol Hormone
Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, vol. 9, no. 1, 2019, -March, pp. 87-95
Universidade de Santa Cruz do Sul
Brasil Available in: https://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=570463757017 How to cite
Complete issue
More information about this article
Journal's webpage in redalyc.org
Scientific Information System Redalyc
Network of Scientific Journals from Latin America and the Caribbean, Spain and
Portugal
Project academic non-profit, developed under the open access initiative Scientific Information System Redalyc
Network of Scientific Journals from Latin America and the Caribbean, Spain and
Portugal
Project academic non-profit, developed under the open access initiative How to cite
Complete issue
More information about this article
Journal's webpage in redalyc.org Project academic non-profit, developed under the open access initiative PUBLICAÇÃO OFICIAL DO NÚCLEO HOSPITALAR DE EPIDEMIOLOGIA DO HOSPITAL SANTA CRUZ E PROGRAMA
DE PÓS GRADUAÇÃO EM PROMOÇÃO DA SAÚDE - DEPARTAMENTO DE BIOLOGIA E FARMÁCIA DA UNISC ARTIGO DE REVISÃO ¹Universidade de São Paulo, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brasil.
2Laval University, Quebec, Qc, Canadá. Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as associações e os métodos de
análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em: <https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemio-
logia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 INTRODUCTION cles of the vessels, through the stimulation of the Sympa-
thetic Nervous System (SNS) or RAAS, which can increase
plasma levels of cortisol.2,14 Systemic Arterial Hypertension (SAH) is the major
concern for the health public policies worldwide. SAH is
highly prevalent, affecting approximately 10% to 25% of
the general population. However, it remains underdiag-
nosed and poorly controlled, with high rates of morbidity
and mortality being an important risk factor for heart
and / or kidney diseases and stroke.1-4 p
Different methods have been used in clinical and
scientific evaluations in different populations, and the
most common is the anthropometric and hemodynamic
tests. In view of the above and due to the particularities
and limitations of each research methods, it is necessary
to investigate the clinical methods used to evaluate the
associations between cortisol and SAH, the relationship
of which appears to be potentially harmful to health.14,16
In addition, it is expected that this study may con-
tribute to increase the knowledge and orientation of new
studies in this subject. Therefore, the objective of this
study was to identify in the literature, through scientific
evidence, the circumstances of existence of association
between SAH and the hormone cortisol, and the clinical
methods used for such evaluation. Different methods have been used in clinical and
scientific evaluations in different populations, and the
most common is the anthropometric and hemodynamic
tests. In view of the above and due to the particularities
and limitations of each research methods, it is necessary
to investigate the clinical methods used to evaluate the
associations between cortisol and SAH, the relationship
of which appears to be potentially harmful to health.14,16 The Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone System (RAAS)
and the Hypothalamic-Hypophysis - Adrenal (HPA) axis,
responsible for the regulation of blood pressure (BP),
were reported to play an important role in the patho-
physiology of SAH, and the glucocorticoid (cortisol)
and mineralocorticoid (aldosterone) hormones are the
respective effectors of these pathways.5,6 In addition, it is expected that this study may con-
tribute to increase the knowledge and orientation of new
studies in this subject. Therefore, the objective of this
study was to identify in the literature, through scientific
evidence, the circumstances of existence of association
between SAH and the hormone cortisol, and the clinical
methods used for such evaluation. In fact, increased circulating or intracellular gluco-
corticoids levels are common and frequently associated
with SAH. RESUMEM Justificación y objetivos: La Hipertensión Arterial Sistémica (HAS) es una afección de salud que representa un problema de salud pública
mundial y su relación con la hormona cortisol aún no se conoce ampliamente. Por lo tanto, el presente estudio tuvo como objetivo
identificar en la literatura la asociación entre la HAS, la hormona cortisol y los métodos clínicos utilizados para evaluar esta relación. Métodos: Se realizó una revisión integradora de la literatura, basada en 17 artículos científicos publicados entre 2013 y 2017 identificados
en las bases de datos EMBASE y PubMed, con los descriptores hipertensión e hidrocortisona en idioma inglés. Resultados: Hubo una
asociación de HAS con aumento de cortisol a la edad de 62 años, aumento de sodio en la dieta, falta de desayuno, aumento del consumo
de cafeína, síndrome metabólico, obesidad, exceso de catecolaminas, algunos tipos de hormonas y biomarcadores. Los métodos clínicos más
comúnmente utilizados para esta relación fueron las pruebas de asociación, realizadas con función renal y / o cardíaca, síndrome metabólico,
estrés, enfermedades crónicas asociadas con la evaluación de pruebas de laboratorio. Conclusión: Los resultados indicaron una asociación
entre el cortisol y la HAS con el avance de la edad y el estilo de vida. Además, las pruebas de asociación fueron los métodos más utilizados. Palabras clave: Hipertensão. Cortisol. Hidrocortisona. Analisis clinico. Cuidados de la salud. INTRODUCTION Cortisol is the main endogenous human gluco-
corticoid, secreted mainly in response to adrenocortico-
tropic hormone (ACTH), through the HPA axis. Additionally,
cortisol is also known as the stress hormone, being influen-
ced by a variety of biological or environmental factors.7-11 ABSTRACT Background and Objectives: Systemic Arterial Hypertension (SAH) is a health condition that represents a global public health problem
and its relation with the hormone cortisol is not yet widely understood. Thus, the present study aimed to identify in the literature the
association among the SAH, the hormone cortisol and the clinical methods used to evaluate this relationship. Methods: An integrative
literature review was carried out, based on 17 scientific articles published between 2013 and 2017 identified in the databases EMBASE
and PubMed, with the descriptors hypertension and hydrocortisone in English language. Results: There was an association of SAH with Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] Páginas 01 de 09
não para fins de citação Páginas 01 de 09
não para fins de citação Exceto onde especificado diferentemente, a matéria publicada neste periódico é licenciada
sob forma de uma licença Creative Commons - Atribuição 4.0 Internacional. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Exceto onde especificado diferentemente, a matéria publicada neste periódico é licenciada
sob forma de uma licença Creative Commons - Atribuição 4.0 Internacional. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE AND CORTISOL HORMONE
Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi. increased cortisol at the age of 62 years, increased sodium in the diet, not eating breakfast, increased caffeine consumption, metabolic
syndrome, obesity, excess catecholamine’s, some types of hormones, and biomarkers. The most commonly used clinical methods for this
relationship were association tests, performed with renal and / or cardiac function, metabolic syndrome, stress, chronic diseases associa-
ted with the evaluation of laboratory tests. Conclusion: The results indicated an association between cortisol and SAH with advancing age
and lifestyle. Moreover, the association tests were the most used methods. Keywords: Hypertension Cortisol Hydrocortisone Clinical analysis Health care Keywords: Hypertension. Cortisol. Hydrocortisone. Clinical analysis. Health care. Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as as-
sociações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em:
<https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] METHODS This Integrative literature review, which is conside-
red as an instrument of the Evidence Based Practice (EBP),
focus on clinical practice. Based on guiding question,
data collection enables the elaboration of a summary of
the results of all studies included in the analysis.17,18
The steps used in this integrative review were: 1)
identification of the subject and selection of the hypo-
thesis or question of the research; 2) determination of
criteria for the databases search; 3) determination of in-
clusion and exclusion criteria of the studies; 3) definition
of the information to be extracted from the studies; 4)
data evaluation; 5) interpretation of results and 6) syn-
thesis of knowledge.17 This Integrative literature review, which is conside-
red as an instrument of the Evidence Based Practice (EBP),
focus on clinical practice. Based on guiding question,
data collection enables the elaboration of a summary of
the results of all studies included in the analysis.17,18 Acute or chronic increase in serum cortisol levels
has been associated with increased BP, hyperglycemia,
and endothelial dysfunction, which may be associated
with cardiovascular risk. Cortisol is involved in the phy-
siological regulation of BP by modulating the vasocons-
trictor response via α 1 - adrenergic receptors through
the action of catecholamine.12-13 The steps used in this integrative review were: 1)
identification of the subject and selection of the hypo-
thesis or question of the research; 2) determination of
criteria for the databases search; 3) determination of in-
clusion and exclusion criteria of the studies; 3) definition
of the information to be extracted from the studies; 4)
data evaluation; 5) interpretation of results and 6) syn-
thesis of knowledge.17 Among the factors related to the prevalence of
SAH in Brazilian adults, there are socio-demographic,
behavioral, morbidities, biochemical and anthropometric
alterations. One of the behavioral factors that is involved
in the increase of the BP is the consumption of alcohol,
which directly influences the heart, in the smooth mus- To address the study and the scope of the proposed Páginas 02 de 09
não para fins de citação Páginas 02 de 09
não para fins de citação goal, based on the PICO strategy, the following clinical
question was formulated: Which clinical methods are
being used to verify the association between Blood Pres-
sure and the Hormone cortisol? METHODS P: population from clinical
studies; I: cortisol assessment; C: no comparison factor,
O: association between cortisol and BP levels.19 For the step of full text analysis, a specific instru-
ment was developed to extract and analyze data from
the included studies. The tool comprised the following
items: (1) publication, authors, journal and country; (2)
objective of the study; (3) methods (study design, popu-
lation, cortisol and BP assessment, other variables mea-
sured); and (4) Results. This stage was performed by four
collaborators divided into two independent groups and
reviewed by two reviewers, who reviewed and validated
the data that were compiled. The results were compared
and discussed, if necessary, until consensus. The included texts met the following criteria: com-
plete articles, available free of charge in journals indexed
in the EMBASE and PubMed databases, peer reviewed,
with a description of clinical studies in humans, with
mandatory evaluation of BP and biochemistry assessment
of cortisol, published in the last five years (2013 to 2017). Selected articles were written in English. Articles that did
not evaluate the direct association between cortisol and BP
levels or those studies that were performed in patients with
adrenal tumors or under corticoid treatment were excluded. RESULTS The reviewed articles were published in scientific
journals related to SAH and cardiovascular diseases
(35.0%) and endocrinology (35.0%), as well as some mul-
tidisciplinary ones (30.0%). The number of publications
was distributed over the years, 2013 (6.0%), 2014 (23.0%),
2015 (35.0%), 2016 (18.0%) and 2017 (18.0%). North Ame-
rica was the region with the largest number of articles
(29.0%), followed by Europe (23.0%); Asia (24.0%); South
America (12.0%) and Africa (12.0%). In the EMBASE database, the following descriptors
were used: hypertension / AND ‘hydrocortisone’ AND
‘human’ AND (2013: py OR 2014: py OR 2015: py OR 2016:
py OR 2017: py) AND ‘article’ / it AND (‘clinical article’ /
of OR ‘clinical protocol’ / of OR ‘controlled study’ / of OR
‘major clinical study’ AND ([english] / lim OR), resulting
in a previous selection of 212 articles. In the Pub Med
database the following Medical Subject Heading (MeSH)
terms were used for the searches: “Hypertension”
[Mesh] AND “Hydrocortisone / analysis” [Mesh] AND
(“2012/11/03” [PDA]: “2017/11/01 “[PDat] AND” humans
“[MeSH Terms]), with a pre-selection of 49 articles. The articles that were excluded (n = 244) from the
study did not correspond to the proposed theme, since
they were: referring to children, adolescents, obesity,
stem cells, different types of diseases (Cushing’s Syn-
drome, Ophthalmology, hearing aid, diabetes mellitus,
tumors and occupational diseases), as well as different
types of therapies, diets, drugs and surgeries. The next step consisted of reading the title and the
abstracts, and then the retained articles were submitted
to full reading and detailed analysis. In the search and
selection of articles, the strategy recommended by the
PRISMA group was adopted as shown in the PRISMA
Flowchart (Figure 1).20 After the full text reading, more four articles were
excluded; three because they were related to patients
with adrenal tumor and one that did not evaluate the
association between cortisol and BP. Figure 1. Flowchart of the selection of the studies, according to the PRISMA model.20 Figure 1. Flowchart of the selection of the studies, according to the PRISMA model.20 Figure 1. Flowchart of the selection of the studies, according to the PRISMA model.20 Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as as-
sociações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as as-
sociações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em:
<https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 RESULTS Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em:
<https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Páginas 03 de 09
não para fins de citação AN INTEGRATIVE REVIEW OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE AND CORTISOL HORMONE
Ernandes Gonçalves Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi. AN INTEGRATIVE REVIEW OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE AND CORTISOL HORMONE
Ernandes Gonçalves Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi. untry
date
. USA, 201721
urnal of
n
.. South
n Research
et al., India,
esearch
ina, 201624
od Pressure
al. Japan,
rinol. Metab. Objective
It is known that decreased renal 11-beta
dehydrogenase type 2 (11β-HSD2) activities,
reflected by an increased urinary free cortisol
to cortisone ratio (UFF/UFE), is associated with
having SAH (HTN). Objective were of determine
if reduced 11β-HSD2 activity is also associated
with having resistant HTN. To evaluate the relationship between emotional
distress, silent myocardial ischemia (SMI) and
double product (systolic BP (SBP) x heart rate). Triage of salivary and serum levels of cortisol
and enzymatic activities of CK-BB, LDH and lipid
profile in patients with stroke or diseases related
to biomarkers for early non-invasive prevention
of stroke. To investigate the influence of environmental
and inflammatory factors on metabolic diseases
(obesity, type 2 diabetes, SAH and chronic kidney
disease). To determine separately the effect of the HPA
axis and the renin-angiotensin aldosterone
system (RAAS) on SAH in a general population. Methods (study design, population, cortisol
and BP assessment, other variables measured). • Comparative clinical study. •Patients with Resistant SAH (RHTN) (n = 55) and with controlled SAH (n = 38). • Cortisol: 24 hour urine free for cortisone, (UFF/UFE). Method gas chromatography
and mass spectrometry. •BP: auscultatory method. Other measures: All subjects underwent biochemical evaluation, including 24-hour
UFF / UFE measurement. •Cross-sectional study. •Individuals of bi-ethnic cohorts from two South African sectors (n = 378). •Cortisol: Serum was collected before 09 h. (Method of assessment: ECLIA -Elecsys
2014, Roche Basel, Switzerland). •BP: double product of 24 h. Other measures: depressive symptoms, blood count, 24-hour electrocardiogram (ST
depression). RESULTS •Comparative cross-sectional clinical study. •Adult male subjects (n = 8), divided into four groups: healthy normal, ischemic stroke,
SAH and type II diabetes. •Cortisol: serum and saliva. Method not described. Analysis: kit BIOLINE (England). •BP: not described how it was measured. SAH was defined as BP ≥140 / 90 mm Hg. Other measures: serum glucose levels, total cholesterol (TC), triglycerides (TG), low
density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-c), high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-c),
enolase specific neuron activity, cortisol, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and creatine
kinase (CK-BB) were measured in saliva and serum samples. •Cross-sectional study. •Patients with essential SAH (n = 178). •Cortisol: serum. Method of analysis electrochemiluminescence. •BP: Essential SAH was defined as an average BP ≥140 / 90 mmHg on at least two
different occasions without any evidence of secondary hypertension. Other measures: Fasting serum samples to plasma glucose levels, serum lipids, serum
creatinine, glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) and anthropometric measures. •Population study. •Japanese adults (n = 859) enrolled in the Iwaki study of 2014
and without SAH or steroid treatment. •Cortisol: serum, chemiluminescent enzyme immunoassay method. •BP: 30 minutes after arrival and after at least 10 minutes of rest, auscultatory method. Other measures: plasma aldosterone, ACTH, and plasma renin activity. Anthropometric
data, fasting glucose, glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c), lipidic profile, uric acid (UA), urea
nitrogen and creatinine. Results
The 24-hour UFF was 13.6 ± 11.8 Vs. 14.3 ± 10.7 μg / 24 h and the
UFE was 64.9 ± 36.3 vs. 76.1 ± 44 μg / 24 h, so that the UFF / EFU was
0.22 ± 0.16 Vs. 0.19 ± 0.09 in RHTN versus the control group. This
relationship was not associated with age, race, and gender and body
mass index. The double product was positively associated with central obesity
in all sexual groups and with cortisol in black men (P <0.05). Central
obesity was related to cortisol. There was a significant increase in total serum and salivary cortisol
(p <0.001) and LDL-c (p <0.01) in stroke and in hypertensive and
diabetic patients compared to the control group. Serum cortisol levels were significantly higher in subjects whose
eGFRcr-cys<90 ml/min/1.73 m2 than subjects whose eGFRcr-cys>90
ml/min/1.73 m2. Age, systolic blood pressure, and serum total
cholesterol, uric acid, cortisol levels were significantly associated with
eGFRcr-cys, serum levels of creatinine and cystatin C. However serum
cortisol level was negatively correlated with eGFRcr-cys in subjects
with essential SAH. Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as associações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa
Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em: <https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 RESULTS The association of hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis and the
renin-angiotensin aldosterone system (RAAS) were significantly to
be associated with SAH prevalence and cortisol activity in a Japanese
population. Methods (study design, population, cortisol
and BP assessment, other variables measured). Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as associações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa
Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em: <https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Páginas 04 de 09
não para fins de citação AN INTEGRATIVE REVIEW OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE AND CORTISOL HORMONE
Ernandes Gonçalves Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi. et al. Spain,
nd Behavior
USA, 201526
Medicine
et al. 201527
crinology
al. Italy,
t et al. USA,
Behavior
al. Japan,
n. Res. Public
To study the differences in cortisol on
awakening (CAR) and in the global secretion
of morning cortisol among hypertensive and
normotensive elderly patients and to investigate
the relationship between CAR and cognitive
performance. To determine whether the serum cortisol-
-cortisone ratio (F / E ratio) is associated with BP
in patients after significant weight loss (≥ 15% of
baseline weight). To study the relationship between long-term
cortisol levels and MetS in HIV-infected patients. To evaluate if the rhythm of salivary cortisol
production is affected by variables (such as
age, gender, Metabolic Syndrome (MetS) and
estrogen-progestogen therapy) in adults from
the community. To compare circulating cortisol levels as well as
cardiovascular risk factors and the perceived
stress among women who do not eat breakfast
and those who routinely do this meal. To compare the physiological and psychological
effects of a forest therapy program of relaxation
and stress management in middle-aged men
with activities of daily living on a normal day. •Comparative cross-sectional clinical study. •Older adults (n = 58). •Cortisol: saliva, measured by immunoassay method. •BP: method of measurement not described. SAH was defined as SBP ≥ 140 mmHg,
DBP mm 90 mmHg or on antihypertensive use. Other measures: cognitive performance. •Longitudinal intervention study for weight reduction. •Men with severe obesity, no diabetic (n=43), who participated in a weight control program. RESULTS •Cortisol: serum by mass spectrometry. Subsequently established cortisol-cortisone ratio (F/E). • BP: method of measurement not described. Other measures: anthropometric data. •Comparative cross-sectional clinical study. •HIV-infected patients (n = 126) and healthy controls (n = 191). •Cortisol: hair cortisol analyzed by the ELISA technique. •BP: method of measurement not described. Other measures: anthropometric data fasting glucose, insulin, lipid profile CD4 + cell
count and HIV RNA. •Cross-sectional study. •Adults (n = 120) from the community. •Cortisol: salivary, measured by immunoassay assay method; was collected 7 salivary
samples: the first on awakening (F(0)) and 6 more (F(1.5), F(5), F(6), F(10), F(11.5) and F(14))
over the next 14 hours. Daily cortisol secretion was evaluated computing the Area Under
the Curve (AUC (F0) (→) (F14)); the F (14) /F(0) ratio was calculated of cortisol rhythm. •BP: method of measurement not described. SAH was defined as SBP ≥130 mmHg,
PAD 85 mmHg, or in use of medication. Other measures: anthropometric and metabolic data for MetS classification. •Cross-sectional observational study. •Premenopausal women. •Cortisol: salivary, evaluated by immunoassay method. Not having breakfast (n = 30)
or breakfast eater (n = 35). •BP: measured twice, with 1-minute interval, after 5 minutes of rest. Other measures: anthropometric and body composition data, stress questionnaires. •Before and after clinical study. •Men between 40 and 73 years (n = 17). •Cortisol: serum. Method not described. •BP: isolated measure (before and after intervention). Other measures: urinary adrenaline, serum creatinine, questionnaires: semantic
differential, mood state. Hypertensive participants had lower morning cortisol secretion. No
differences were observed in CAR. A reduced-magnitude CAR was
related to poorer cognitive / executive function in hypertensive and
normotensive participants, but at a slower processing speed only in
normotensive participants. Being treated with antihypertensive for a
longer period of time was related to a CAR of greater magnitude and
better performance in the executive function. The basal F/E ratio tended to be associated with baseline diastolic
blood pressure (DBP) and the change in serum F/E ratio correlated
with change in DBP. The change in F/E ratio also tended to be
associated with change in systolic BP. The characteristic of MetS in the HIV group was elevated systolic BP
(52.7%), followed by reduced HDL cholesterol (43.9%) and hypertri-
glyceridemia (42.9%). The of enlarged waist circumference (14.3%) yet
elevated blood glucose levels (13.2%) was less frequent. RESULTS There was a
higher risk of MetS in patients with HIV with lower hair cortisol levels. Hair cortisol levels were not significantly different between patients
with HIV and healthy controls. The association of study findings showed that the salivary cortisol
daily cortisol secretion was evaluated computing the Area Under
the Curve (AUC (F0) (→)(F14)); the F(14)/F(0) ratio was calculated as
a marker of cortisol rhythm (AUC), is not influenced by age, gender,
metabolic syndrome or use of estrogen-progestin therapy. But, only
late-night salivary cortisol levels were found to increase with age and
in patients with the MetS. Associations indicate that not eating breakfast occurs increased
concentrations of cortisol and much activity on the HPA axis, which if
prolonged may increase the risk of SAH and cardio metabolic disease. The associations revealed that forest therapy decreases systolic and
diastolic blood pressure as well as levels of adrenaline in urine and
serum cortisol. REVIEW OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE AND CORTISOL HORMONE
es Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi. Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as associações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa
Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em: <https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Páginas 05 de 09
não para fins de citação AN INTEGRATIVE REVIEW OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE AND CORTISOL HORMONE
Ernandes Gonçalves Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi. Hoefer et al. Austria,
531
nal of Vascular
ery
Baudrand, et al. Chile,
432
cal Endocrinology
ames USA, 201433
rican Journal of
an Biology
Malan et al. h Africa, 201434
nal of Human
ertension
arrete et al. il, 201435
nal of Clinical &
slation Endocrinology
ennett et al. 201336
ss and Health
Comparison of early sympathetic activity
in carotid endarterectomy surgery among
patients receiving regional anesthesia guided
by ultrasound (US-RA) and patients undergoing
general anesthesia (GA). RESULTS To evaluate whether the diet with high sodium
content is associated with the dysregulation of
cortisol and MetS production. To compare levels of urinary catecholamine (epi-
nephrine and norepinephrine), cortisol excretion
and ambulatory BP values in three distinct daily
microenvironments between women with and
without parental SAH. To assess the association between cortisol levels,
psychological stress and BP responses in South
African men stratified according to testosterone
levels (low and high T). Investigate whether aerobic exercise training
(AET) over twenty-four sessions alters the levels
of cortisol, leptin, and interleukin-1β (IL-1β). To examine the effects of caffeine and
psychological stress on markers of cardiovascular
disease (CVD) in young adults with a family
history of SAH. •Comparative cross-sectional clinical study. •Patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy randomized to receive US-RA (n = 32)
or GA (n = 28). •Cortisol: serum. Radioimmunoassay method. •BP: considered as primary outcome. Measured in 4 times by direct measurement
(arterial catheter). Other measures: anthropometric data, clinical data, meta and normetamefrin,
creatinine, cardiac markers. •Cross-sectional study. •Hispanic adults from low- and middle-income primary health units (n = 370). •Cortisol: salivary, evaluated by immunoassay method. •BP: method of measurement not described. Other measures: anthropometric, metabolic and clinical data, allowing classifying the
MetS, consumption of salt (urinary sodium). •Comparative cross-sectional clinical study. •American adult women, (n = 62) working in clinical, technical or professional positions
in a medical center. •Cortisol: urinary, evaluated by radioimmunoassay method. •BP: monitored ambulatory BP at the beginning of the workday (between 8 and 9 AM). Other measures: anthropometric, demographic data, medical history, daily stress
information, in addition to, epinephrine and norepinephrine. •Comparative cross-sectional clinical study. •African (n = 94) and Caucasian (n = 100) urban teachers from Northwest South Africa,
•Cortisol: serum by immunoassay method. •BP: outpatient BP measurements. Other measures: anthropometric measurements, serum testosterone, mental stress
tests, health perception questionnaire, physical activity practice, electrocardiogram
(silent ischemia). •Longitudinal study of type clinical trial with before and after evaluation. •Postmenopausal hypertensive women (n=18) submitted to physical training protocol. •Cortisol: serum, evaluated by immunoassay method. •BP: the average of three consecutive measurements. Other measures: lipid profile and glycaemia, leptin, interleukin - 1β and cyclic GMP
(cGMP), nitrite - nitrate ratio. •Clinical trial with 2x2 design (sex and caffeine / placebo). •Healthy men (n=26) and women (n=26), young people with a confirmed family history of SAH. •Cortisol: serum, evaluated by immunoassay method. RESULTS •BP: measured in three
times (before, during and after a stress inducing procedure). Other measures: serum
estradiol and progesterone, HR, C-reactive protein (CRP) and plasma fibrinogen. Systolic blood pressure increased in patients with Landmark-guided
regional anesthesia (RA) compared to patients with general anes-
thesia (GA) even prior to surgery and remained elevated throughout
the surgery but returned to baseline values 1 hour after admission of
patients in the postoperative anesthesia unit. They concluded that the
US-RA technique for CEA induces temporary intraoperative SAH and
an increase in levels of stress hormone including cortisol. High sodium intake is associated with increased urinary cortisol
metabolites, insulin resistance, dyslipidemia and lower levels of
adiponectin. The results too suggest that a increase in total urinary
of glucocorticoids may partially explain the metabolic disturbances
observed with a salty diet, in addition to the risk of SAH. The associations suggest that there may be genetically linked
mechanisms that raise levels of epinephrine and nocturnal levels of
cortisol that contribute to elevated circadian BP. The associations of chronic distress (cortisol) and acute stress (total
peripheral resistance cold pressure responses) were associated with
beat-to-beat and ambulatory blood pressure (ABPM) within the
low testosterone (T) in African group. Acute and chronic (cortisol)
stress may contribute to increased BP in low T in African men. Their
cortisol and vascular responses supported a tendency for ischemia,
increasing their risk for coronary artery disease. The beneficial effects of exercise training on blood pressure were related
to an improvement of NO/cGMP pathway without changing in serum
cortisol levels. Were confirmed by the lack of positive correlation between
cortisol and blood pressure after twenty-four sessions of exercise. The
associations show that the endocrine-inflammatory mediators cortisol,
leptin and IL-1b did not contribute to the beneficial effects of the exercise
training on blood pressure in hypertensive postmenopausal women. The result from this study suggests that the combination of stress and
caffeine may be detrimental for females with a family history of SAH. The stress interacted with caffeine and women, at were alter cortisol,
fibrinogen and systolic BP but not CRP levels. These results may on sex -
specific pathways that associate caffeine with on blood markers of CVD. 2 S
th
i
f th
l
d t di
2018
s Gonçalves Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi. DISCUSSION The results of this study demonstrated the variety
of methods of research and associations between SAH
and cortisol. It is known that SAH is a chronic condition
that can lead to the development of heart or kidney di-
sease. Thus, based on the scientific evidence, one study
pointed out that renal function disorders were associated
with the HPA axis with RASS, showing that they are signi-
ficantly associated with SAH. Renal function parameters
such as creatinine and cystatin C (eGFRcr-cys) are related
to the high level of cortisol in subjects with SAH.6,24 However, a study with adults relating MetS to the
measurements of salivary cortisol levels aimed to verify
whether it is affected by the variables age, gender and
hormone therapy, estrogen and progestin; the results
showed that the older age was related to MetS and cor-
tisol excretion.28 Recent studies have shown that deregulation of
the HPA axis together with chronic stress increases the
likelihood of SAH, leading to heart disease such as is-
chemia, a deficit in blood perfusion and stroke-related
diseases.22,23 In addition, high sodium (HS) diet was associated
with increased cortisol in urine and its metabolites, with
SAH, insulin resistance (RI), dyslipidemia, hypoadiponec-
tinemia, higher cortisol, leading to metabolic disorders
related to obesity.32 In another investigation, it was suggested that
healthy individuals with a genetic history of SAH have a
marked increase in catecholamines and cortisol for stres-
sors in relation to elevated plasma levels when compared
to those with no parental history. The study compared
catecholamines by urine (epinephrine and norepinephri-
ne), excretion of cortisol and ambulatory BP in three daily
microenvironments between women, with and without
parental history of SAH. The results of a study in premenopausal women su-
ggest that not eating breakfast is harmful because it can
interrupt the cortisol rhythm and result in altered BP and,
consequently, leading to cardio metabolic diseases.29 In the hospital area, a study on loco-regional
anesthesia was identified, an effective method to evalu-
ate brain function during carotid endarterectomy (CEA). Regional framework-guided anesthesia (RA) is currently
used for CEA and may cause substantial perioperative
SAH. Ultrasound-guided RA (US-RA) is a new method for
performing RA in CEA. The study evaluated early sympa-
thetic activity during CEA in US-RA compared to general
anesthesia (GA). Regional ultrasound-guided anesthesia
for carotid endarterectomy (CEA) induces early changes
in hemodynamic hormone and stress. RESULTS Systolic blood pressure increased in patients with Landmark-guided
regional anesthesia (RA) compared to patients with general anes-
thesia (GA) even prior to surgery and remained elevated throughout
the surgery but returned to baseline values 1 hour after admission of
patients in the postoperative anesthesia unit. They concluded that the
US-RA technique for CEA induces temporary intraoperative SAH and
an increase in levels of stress hormone including cortisol. High sodium intake is associated with increased urinary cortisol
metabolites, insulin resistance, dyslipidemia and lower levels of
adiponectin. The results too suggest that a increase in total urinary
of glucocorticoids may partially explain the metabolic disturbances
observed with a salty diet, in addition to the risk of SAH. Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as associações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa
Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em: <https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as associações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa
Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em: <https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Páginas 06 de 09
não para fins de citação HE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE AND CORTISOL HORMONE
sa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Robazzi. INTEGRATIVE REVIEW OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE AND
andes Gonçalves Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cruz Rob Main types of study, methods of clinical analysis and
factors those were associated robic physical exercises produce a significant reduction of
BP, however, without altering cortisol and leptin levels.35 Another intriguing factor is the effects of caffeine
and stress on biomarkers of cardiovascular disease. A
total of 52 healthy normotensive adults (26 men and 26
women), but with a family history of SAH, participated in
the study to examine the reactivity to stress after caffeine
consumption. Subjects after caffeine received increased
systolic BP and cortisol. The study suggested that the
combination of stress and caffeine may be particularly
harmful for women with a family history of SAH.36 The main methods of study were cross-sectional
and the most frequent clinical analyzes were cortisol
obtained through blood (10 studies), most of which were
evaluated by immunoassay followed by saliva (4), urine
(2) and capillary analysis (1). Among the associated factors between SAH and
cortisol, we observed a population with chronic disease
already established, whose related variables are gender,
age, family history, ethnicity, anthropometric measures,
socio-demographic characteristics, stress questionnaires,
mood, health perception, physical activity, sodium and ca-
ffeine consumption, electrocardiogram, lipid profile, MetS,
insulin, glycemia and others (proteins, hormones, leptin,
interleukin, nitrite, nitrate, adrenaline and serum creatinine). Another study correlated serum cortisol with cor-
tisone (F/E) and BP with severe obesity before and after
weight loss and the alteration of the F/E serum ratio was
associated with BP alteration after weight loss.26 Patients with Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)
are at increased risk for metabolic complications (MetS)
including SAH and excess cortisol. In this sense, a study
was conducted in the Netherlands where they identified
that the risk of MetS was higher in HIV-infected patients
in the lower-level capillary cortisol group compared to
patients with higher levels. These results contradict those
of studies in uninfected individuals, where a high level of
capillary cortisol is being associated with MetS.27 Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360]
Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as as-
sociações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em:
<https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as as
sociações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em
<https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] CONCLUSIONS 8. Kirou KA, Boumpas DT. Chapter 48-Systemic Glucocorticoid
Therapy in SLE 2013;591-600. doi: 10.1016/B978-1-4377-1893-
5.00048-0 The results indicate that the most commonly used
clinical methods for linking SAH to cortisol are associa-
tion tests, performed with renal and / or cardiac function,
metabolic syndrome, stress, chronic diseases together
with the evaluation of laboratory tests and / or markers
and measures anthropometric and physiological. 9. West DWD, Phillips SM. Associations of exercise-induced
hormone profiles and gains in strength and hypertrophy
in a large cohort after weight training. Eur J Appl Physiol
2012;112(7):2693-2702. doi: 10.1007/s00421-011-2246-z Previous studies indicate that BP is altered by HPA
axis dysregulation, where stress is released into the
bloodstream and its effects are possibly malefic. Thus,
to help maintain BP levels within the normal range, it is
recommended to adopt a healthy lifestyle. 10. Herman JP, McKlveen JM, Ghosal S, Kopp B, Wulsin A, Makinson
R et al. Regulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical
stress response. Compr. Physiol 2016;6(2):603-621. doi: 10.1002/
cphy.c150015 Currently, the major challenge for science is to in-
vestigate the pathophysiological processes involved and
in which situations the HPA axis secretes the hormone
cortisol in excess. 11. Neumann A, Direk N, Crawford AA, Mirza S, Adams H, Bolton
J et al. The low single nucleotide polymorphism heritability of
plasma and saliva cortisol levels. Psychoneuroendocrinology
2017;85:88-95. doi: 10.1016/j.psyneuen.2017.08.011 Most of the articles showed a positive association
between cortisol and BP, indicating the correlation be-
tween them, for several variables: increased cortisol was
higher in the elderly (62 years), increased sodium in the
diet, not eating breakfast, excessive caffeine during the
day, Metabolic Syndrome, obesity, excess catecholamine’s,
some types of hormones and biomarkers. 12. Vergouwen MD, Van Geloven N, de Haan RJ, Kruyt ND,
Vermeulen M, Roos YB. Increased Cortisol Levels are Associated
with Delayed Cerebral Ischemia After Aneurysmal Subarachnoid
Hemorrhage. Neurocrit Care 2010;12(3):342-345. doi: 10.1007/
s12028-010-9331-8 13. Errante PR, Menezes-Rodrigues FS, Tavares JGP, Reis
MCM, Icimoto MY, Ferraz RRN et al. Mechanisms of Action
and Resistance to the Use of Glucocorticoids. Rev Pesq
Inov
Farm
2014;6(2):01-11. https://www.researchgate.net/
publication/299562278 Due to the above, there is a need for more clinical
research with other methodological approaches, highlighting
the role of cortisol in the regulation of BP, in order to investi-
gate the possible causes of the secretion of this hormone
in excess and its pathophysiological effects on SAH. 14. Galvão RRS, Soares DA. 8210.86972 Regarding the types of treatments for the control of
SAH, one study presented the physiological effects such
as the reduction of BP in “walking in the forest” therapy,
as a promising treatment strategy. It is known that SAH
requires preventive actions, such as guidelines on life
habits, decreased salt intake, physical activities, and the
correct use of medications and antihypertensive.30,37 4. Eid LP, Nogueira MS, Veiga EV, Cesarino EJ, Alves LMM. Adherence to anti-hypertensive treatment: an analysis using
the Morisky - Green Test. Rev Eletr Enf 2013;15(2): 362-7. doi:
10.5216/ree.v15i2.15599 5. O’Donnell E, Floras JS, Harvey PJ. Estrogen status and the
renin angiotensin aldosterone system. Am J Physiol Regul
Integr Comp Physiol 2014;307(5):498-500. doi: 10.1152/
ajpregu.00182.2014 The findings of this study reinforce the idea of how
cortisol influences SAH, so we can delve into the cause of
HPA axis activation and excess cortisol excretion. 6. Daimon M, Kamba A, Murakami H, Takahashi K, Otaka H,
Makita K. et al. Association Between Pituitary-Adrenal Axis
Dominance Over the Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone System
and Hypertension. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2016;101(3):889-897. doi: 10.1210/jc.2015-3568 6. Daimon M, Kamba A, Murakami H, Takahashi K, Otaka H,
Makita K. et al. Association Between Pituitary-Adrenal Axis
Dominance Over the Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone System
and Hypertension. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2016;101(3):889-897. doi: 10.1210/jc.2015-3568 This study presents as limitations the different rese-
arch methods, such as cortisol collections, demographic
partner factors, ethnicities and different hormones linked
to it, which may influence the association of cortisol with
BP elevation. 7. Bailey
MA. 11β-Hydroxysteroid
Dehydrogenases
and
Hypertension in the Metabolic Syndrome. Curr Hypertens Rep
2017;19:100. doi: 10.1007/s11906-017-0797-z 7. Bailey
MA. 11β-Hydroxysteroid
Dehydrogenases
and
Hypertension in the Metabolic Syndrome. Curr Hypertens Rep
2017;19:100. doi: 10.1007/s11906-017-0797-z CONCLUSIONS Prevalence of Arterial Hypertension and
Associated Factors in Adults: A Review in Brazilian Literature. Rev APS 2016;19(1):139-149. https://aps.ufjf.emnuvens.com.br/
aps/article/view/2273/945 Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as as-
sociações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em:
<https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 REFERENCES 15. Póvoa TIR, Jardim TV, Carneiro CS, Ferreira VR, Mendonça
KL, Morais PRS et al. Home Blood Pressure Monitoring as
an Alternative to Confirm Diagnoses of Hypertension in
Adolescents with Elevated Office Blood Pressure from a
Brazilian State Capital. Arq Bras Cardiol 2017;109(3):241-247. doi:
10.5935/abc.20170114 1. Dinis PG, Cachulo MC, Fernandes A, Paiva L, Gonçalves L. Secondary Arterial Hypertension: Uncertainties in Diagnosis. Acta Med. Port 2017;30(6):493-496. doi: 10.20344/amp.8007 2. Silva EC, Martins MSAS, Guimarães LV, Segri NJ, Lopes MAL,
Espinosa MM. Prevalence of systemic arterial hypertension and
associated factors in men and women living in municipalities
of the Legal Amazon. Rev Bras Epidemiol 2016;19(1):38-51. doi:
10.1590/1980-5497201600010004 2. Silva EC, Martins MSAS, Guimarães LV, Segri NJ, Lopes MAL,
Espinosa MM. Prevalence of systemic arterial hypertension and
associated factors in men and women living in municipalities
of the Legal Amazon. Rev Bras Epidemiol 2016;19(1):38-51. doi:
10.1590/1980-5497201600010004 16. Nascimento LR, Monteiro LN, Pereira TSS, Mill JG, Molina MCB. Arterial hypertension in schoolchildren aged 7 to 10 years: a
study of persistent cases of blood pressure change in Santa
Maria de Jetibá / ES. Rev. Bras. Pesq Saúde Vitória 2015;17(4):76- 3. Gupta V. Mineralocorticoid hypertension. Indian J Endocrinol
Metab
2011;15(Suppl4):S298-S312. doi:
10.4103/2230- 3. Gupta V. Mineralocorticoid hypertension. Indian J Endocrinol
Metab
2011;15(Suppl4):S298-S312. doi:
10.4103/2230- Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] DISCUSSION Thus, systolic BP
increased in patients with RA-AR compared to AR, even
before the surgery was started, remained elevated during
the complete surgery and returned to baseline 1 hour
after admission to the anesthesia care unit postoperative
period, as well as HR and cortisol levels were also higher
in the US-RA group after induction of anesthesia. The
authors concluded that the US-RA technique for CEA
induces temporary intraoperative SAH and an increase in
levels of stress hormone.31 The results suggest that there may be genetically
linked mechanisms that raise levels of adrenaline and
nocturnal levels of cortisol that contribute to elevated
circadian BP. However, elderly people with SAH with low
levels of cortisol on awakening were related to worse
cognitive function.25,33 Another factor was the hormone testosterone (T);
study indicates that low levels of T, high level of cortisol
and chronic stress are associated with SAH. Thus, the
authors concluded that acute and chronic stress may con-
tribute to increase cortisol and BP in subjects with low T,
contributing to an increased risk of coronary heart disease.34
Regarding the women, research examined the inte-
raction between endocrine inflammatory mediators and
aerobic exercise training in postmenopausal individuals
and individuals with SAH. Thus, it was concluded that ae- Another factor was the hormone testosterone (T);
study indicates that low levels of T, high level of cortisol
and chronic stress are associated with SAH. Thus, the
authors concluded that acute and chronic stress may con-
tribute to increase cortisol and BP in subjects with low T,
contributing to an increased risk of coronary heart disease.34 Regarding the women, research examined the inte-
raction between endocrine inflammatory mediators and
aerobic exercise training in postmenopausal individuals
and individuals with SAH. Thus, it was concluded that ae- Páginas 07 de 09
não para fins de citação Páginas 07 de 09
não para fins de citação AN INTEGRATIVE REVIEW OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE
Ernandes Gonçalves Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cru 84. doi: 10.21722/rbps.v17i4.14334 28. Ceccato F, Barbot M, Zilio M, Ferasin S, De Lazzari P, Lizzul L et al. Age and the metabolic syndrome affect salivary cortisol rhythm:
data from a community sample. Hormones 2015;14(3):392-8. doi: 10.14310/horm.2002.1591 17. Mendes KDS, Silveira RCCP, Galvão CM. Integrative literature
review: a research method to incorporate evidence in health
care and nursing. Texto Contexto Enferm 2008;17(4):758-64. doi: 10.1590/S0104-07072008000400018 29. Witbracht M, Keim NL, Forester S, Widaman A, Laugero K. Female breakfast skippers display a disrupted cortisol rhythm
and elevated blood pressure. Physiol Behav 2015;1;140:215-21. doi: 10.1016/j.physbeh.2014.12.044 29. 18. Crossetti MGO. Integrative review of nursing research: scientific
rigor required. Rev. Gaúcha de Enferm 2012;33(2):8-9. doi:
10.1590/S1983-14472012000200001 30. Ochiai H, Ikei H, Song C, Kobayashi M, Takamatsu A, Miura T
et al. Physiological and psychological effects of forest therapy
on middle-aged males with high-normal blood pressure. Int
J Environ Res Public Health 2015;12(3):2532-42. doi: 10.3390/
ijerph120302532 19. Santos CMC, Pimenta CAM, Nobre MRA. The PICO strategy for
the research question construction and evidence search. Rev. Latino-Am. Enferm 2007;15(3):508-511. doi: 10.1590/S0104-
11692007000300023 20. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman, DG. The PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-
analyses: the PRISMA Statement. PLoS Med 2009;6(6). doi:
10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097 31. Hoefer J, Pierer E, Rantner B, Stadlbauer KH, Fraedrich G, Fritz
J et al. Ultrasound-guided regional anesthesia for carotid
endarterectomy induces early hemodynamic and stress
hormone changes. J Vasc Surg 2015;62(1):57-67. doi: 10.1016/j. jvs.2015.02.036 21. Ghazi L, Dudenbostel T, Hachem ME, Siddiqui M, Lin CP,
Oparil S et al. 11-Beta Dehydrogenase Type 2 Activity Is Not
Reduced in Treatment Resistant Hypertension. Am J Hypertens
2017;30(5):518-523. doi: 10.1093/ajh/hpx002 32. Baudrand R, Campino C, Carvajal CA, Olivieri O, Guidi G,
Faccini G et al. High sodium intake is associated with increased
glucocorticoid production, insulin resistance and metabolic
syndrome. Clin Endocrinol 2014;80(5):677-84. doi: 10.1111/
cen.12225 22. Malan L, Schutte CE, Alkerwi A, Stranges S, Malan NT. Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal-axis
dysregulation
and
double product increases potentiate ischemic heart disease
risk in a Black male cohort: the SABPA study. Hypertens Res
2017;40(6):590-597. doi: 10.1038/hr.2017.5 33. James GD, Alfarano AS, Van Berge-Landry HM. Differential
circadian catecholamine and cortisol responses between
healthy women with and without a parental history of
hypertension. Am J Hum Biol 2014;26(6):753-9. doi: 10.1002/
ajhb.22586 33. 23. Al-Abbasi FA, Moselhy SS. Sensitivity of biomarker for early
prediction of cerebral stroke. Biomedical Research 2017; 28(13):
6048-6053. Disponível em: http://www.alliedacademies.org/
articles/sensitivity-of-biomarker-for-early-prediction-of-
cerebral-stroke-7872.html 34. Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as as-
sociações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em:
<https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275
Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan Mar;9(1):87 95. [ISSN 2238 3360] Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] Rev. Epidemiol. Controle Infecç. Santa Cruz do Sul, 2019 Jan-Mar;9(1):87-95. [ISSN 2238-3360] Please cite this article in press as: DIAS, Ernandes Gonçalves et al. Hipertensão Arterial Sistêmica e o Hormônio Cortisol: uma revisão integrativa sobre as as
sociações e os métodos de análises clínicas. Revista de Epidemiologia e Controle de Infecção, Santa Cruz do Sul, v. 9, n. 1, jan. 2019. ISSN 2238-3360. Disponível em
<https://online.unisc.br/seer/index.php/epidemiologia/article/view/12275>. Acesso em: 20 fev. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.17058/reci.v9i1.12275 Páginas 08 de 09
não para fins de citação AN INTEGRATIVE REVIEW OF THE METHODS USED FOR CORTISOL ASSESSMENT IN CLINICAL STUDIES INVESTIGATING THE ASSOCIATION BETWEEN BLOOD PRESSURE
Ernandes Gonçalves Dias, Vanessa Augusto Bardaquim, Silvana Martins Mishima, Eugênia Velludo Veiga, Maria Cecília Bueno Jayme Gallani, Maria Lucia do Carmo Cru 84. doi: 10.21722/rbps.v17i4.14334 Malan NT, Stalder T, Schlaich MP, Lambert GW, Hamer M,
Schutte AE et al. Chronic distress and acute vascular stress
responses associated with ambulatory blood pressure in low-
testosterone African men: the SABPA Study. J Hum Hypertens
2014;28(6):393-8. doi: 10.1038/jhh.2013.124 24. Li X, Xiang X, Hu J, Goswami R, Yang S, Zhang A et al. Association
Between Serum Cortisol and Chronic Kidney Disease in
Patients with Essential Hypertension. Kidney Blood Press Res
2016;41(4):384-91. doi: 10.1159/000443435 35. Jarrete AP, Novais IP, Nunes HA, Puga GM, Delbin MA, Zanesco
A. Influence of aerobic exercise training on cardiovascular
and endocrine-inflammatory biomarkers in hypertensive
postmenopausal women. J Clin Transl Endocrinol 2014;1(3):108-
114. doi: 10.1016/j.jcte.2014.07.004 25. Pulopulos MM, Hidalgo V, Puig-Perez S, Salvador A. Cortisol
awakening response and cognitive performance in hypertensive
and normotensive older people. Horm. Behav 2016;83:75-82. doi: 10.1016/j.yhbeh.2016.05.014 36. Bennett JM, Rodrigues IM, Klein LC. Effects of caffeine and
stress on biomarkers of cardiovascular disease in healthy men
and women with a family history of hypertension. Stress Health
2013;29(5):401-9. doi: 10.1002/smi.2486 26. Byrd JB, Rothberg AE, Chomic R, Burant CF, Brook RD, Auchus
RJ. Serum Cortisol-to-Cortisone Ratio and Blood Pressure in
Severe Obesity before and after Weight Loss. Cardiorenal Med
2015;6(1):1-7. doi: 10.1159/000438462. 37. Mendes GS, Moraes CF, Gomes L. Prevalência de hipertensão
arterial sistêmica em idosos no Brasil entre 2006 e 2010. Rev
Bras Med Fam Comunidade 2014;9(32):273-278. doi: 10.5712/
rbmfc9(32)795 27. LangerakT, Van Den Dries LW, Wester VL, Staufenbiel SM,
Manenschijn L, Van Rossum EF, Van Gorp EC. The relation
between long-term cortisol levels and the metabolic syndrome
in HIV-infected patients. Clin Endocrinol 2015;83(2):167-72. doi:
10.1111/cen.12790 Páginas 09 de 09
não para fins de citação
|
https://openalex.org/W4297979925
|
https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/1/33029912/1/5404611.pdf
|
English
| null |
Genetic effects influencing risk for major depressive disorder in China and Europe
|
Carolina Digital Repository (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill)
| 2,017
|
cc-by
| 9,799
|
Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available
under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http://
nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of-use#LAA Permanent link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:33029912 Citation Bigdeli, T. B., S. Ripke, R. E. Peterson, M. Trzaskowski, S. Bacanu, A. Abdellaoui, T. F. M. Andlauer, et al. 2017. “Genetic effects influencing risk for major depressive disorder in
China and Europe.” Translational Psychiatry 7 (3): e1074. doi:10.1038/tp.2016.292. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1038/tp.2016.292. Bigdeli, T. B., S. Ripke, R. E. Peterson, M. Trzaskowski, S. Bacanu, A. Abdellaoui, T. F. M. Andlauer, et al. 2017. “Genetic effects influencing risk for major depressive disorder in
China and Europe.” Translational Psychiatry 7 (3): e1074. doi:10.1038/tp.2016.292. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1038/tp.2016.292. Published Version
doi:10.1038/tp.2016.292 Share Your Story The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Submit a story . The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Submit a story . Accessibility Genetic effects influencing risk for major
depressive disorder in China and Europe
Citation
Bigdeli, T. B., S. Ripke, R. E. Peterson, M. Trzaskowski, S. Bacanu, A. Abdellaoui, T. F. M.
Andlauer, et al. 2017. “Genetic effects influencing risk for major depressive disorder in
China and Europe.” Translational Psychiatry 7 (3): e1074. doi:10.1038/tp.2016.292. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1038/tp.2016.292. Genetic effects influencing risk for major
depressive disorder in China and Europe
Citation
Bigdeli, T. B., S. Ripke, R. E. Peterson, M. Trzaskowski, S. Bacanu, A. Abdellaoui, T. F. M. Andlauer, et al. 2017. “Genetic effects influencing risk for major depressive disorder in
China and Europe.” Translational Psychiatry 7 (3): e1074. doi:10.1038/tp.2016.292. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1038/tp.2016.292. Accessibility OPEN Citation: Transl Psychiatry (2017) 7, e1074; doi:10.1038/tp.2016.292 www.nature.com/tp 1Department of Psychiatry, Virginia Institute for Psychiatric and Behavioral Genetics, Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine, Richmond, VA, USA; 2Department of
Psychiatry, Charite Universitatsmedizin Berlin Campus Benjamin Franklin, Berlin, Germany; 3Medical and Population Genetics, Broad Institute, Cambridge, MA, USA; 4Analytic and
Translational Genetics Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA; 5Institute for Molecular Bioscience, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia;
6Queensland Brain Institute, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 7Department of Biological Psychology, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands; 8Department of Translational Research in Psychiatry, Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry, Munich, Germany; 9Munich Cluster for Systems Neurology (SyNergy),
Munich, Germany; 10Department of Psychiatry, VU University Medical Center and GGZ inGeest, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; 11Institute of Epidemiology and Social Medicine,
University of Muenster, Münster, Germany; 12Division of Psychiatry, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; 13King's College London, NIHR BRC for Mental Health, London, UK;
14King's College London, MRC Social Genetic and Developmental Psychiatry Centre, London, UK; 15Department of Clinical Medicine, Translational Neuropsychiatry Unit, Aarhus
University, Aarhus, Denmark; 16Department of Biomedicine, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland; 17Division of Medical Genetics, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland;
18Institute of Neuroscience and Medicine (INM-1), Research Center Juelich, Jülich, Germany; 19Institute of Human Genetics, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany; 20Department of
Genetics and Computational Biology, QIMR Berghofer Medical Research Institute, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 21Centre for Advanced Imaging, University of Queensland, Brisbane,
QLD, Australia; 22Department of Psychological Medicine, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK; 23EMGO+ Institute, VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands;
24Department of Genomics, Life and Brain Center, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany; 25Stanley Center for Psychiatric Research, Broad Institute, Cambridge, MA, USA;
26Department of Psychiatry, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA; 27Psychiatric and Neurodevelopmental Genetics Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA,
USA; 28Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, State University of New York Downstate Medical Center, Brooklyn, NY, USA; 29Department of Genetic Epidemiology in
Psychiatry, Central Institute of Mental Health, Medical Faculty Mannheim, Heidelberg University, Heidelberg, Germany; 30Department of Psychiatry, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin,
Ireland; 31Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany; 32Department of Psychiatry, Kaiser-Permanente Northern California,
San Fransisco, CA, USA; 33Institute of Neuroscience, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland; 34Medical Research Council Human Genetics Unit, Institute of Genetics and Molecular
Medicine, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; 35Department of Psychiatry, Washington University in Saint Louis School of Medicine, St Louis, MO, USA; 36Division of Medical
Genetics, Department of Biomedicine, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland; 37Brain and Mind Research Institute, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia; 38Human
Genomics Research Group, Department of Biomedicine, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland; 39Department of Functional Genomics, Interfaculty Institute for Genetics and
Functional Genomics, University Medicine and Ernst Moritz Arndt University Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany; 40Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry, Munich, Germany;
41Department of Psychiatry and The Behavioral Sciences, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA; 42Neuroscience Therapeutic Area, Janssen Research and
Development, LLC, Titusville, NJ, USA; 43Department of Psychiatry, Washington University in Saint Louis School of Medicine, St Louis, MO, USA; 44School of Psychology, University
of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 45Department of Psychiatry, New York State Psychiatric Institute, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY,
USA; 46Centre for Cognitive Ageing and Cognitive Epidemiology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; 47Institute for Molecular Biology, University of Queensland, Brisbane,
QLD, Australia; 48Psychosis Research Unit, Aarhus University Hospital, Risskov, Denmark; 49Department of Molecular and Clinical Pharmacology, University of Liverpool, Liverpool,
UK; 50Institute of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine, University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany; 51Institute of Health and Biomedical Innovation, Queensland
University of Technology, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 52MRC Centre for Neuropsychiatric Genetics and Genomics, Cardiff University School of Medicine, Cardiff, UK; 53Charles E.
Schmidt College of Medicine, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, FL, USA; 54Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA; 55Department of Psychiatry,
Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA; 56Medical Genetics Section, CGEM, IGMM, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; 57Department of Psychiatry, University of
Iowa, Iowa, IA, USA; 58Department of Psychiatry, Washington University in Saint Louis, St Louis, MO, USA; 59Department of Human and Molecular Genetics, Virginia
Commonwealth University School of Medicine, Richmond, VA, USA; 60Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology II, Institute of Neurosciences, Center for Biomedical
Research, University of Granada, Granada, Spain; 61King’s College London, MRC Social Genetic and Developmental Psychiatry Centre, London, UK; 62Department of Psychiatry,
University of Groningen, University of Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands; 63Institute of Psychiatric Phenomics and Genomics, Medical Center of the
University of Munich, Campus Innenstadt, Munich, Germany; 64Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, University Medical Center Göttingen, Göttingen, The Netherlands;
65Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA; 66Human Genetics Branch, NIMH Division of Intramural Research Programs,
Bethesda, MD, USA; 67Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD, USA; 68Division of Psychiatry, Group Health, Seattle, WA, USA;
69Institute for Community Medicine, University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany;
70Department of Psychiatry, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, The
Netherlands; 71Division of Epidemiology, New York State Psychiatric Institute, New York, NY, USA; 72Department of Psychiatry, Columbia University College of Physicians and
Surgeons, New York, NY, USA; 73Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA; 74King's College London, Department of Medical and Molecular
Genetics, London, UK; 75Merton College, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK; 76Wellcome Trust Centre for Human Genetics, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK; 77Medical Epidemiology
and Biostatistics, Karolinska Institutet, Solna, Sweden; 78Department of Genetics, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA and 79Department of Psychiatry,
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA. Correspondence: Dr TB Bigdeli, Department of Psychiatry, Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine,
Virginia Institute for Psychiatric and Behavioral Genetics, 800 E. Leigh Street, Biotech One, Suite 101, Richmond, VA 23219-1534, USA.
E-mail: tim.bigdeli@gmail.com ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Genetic effects influencing risk for major depressive disorder in
Chi
d E TB Bigdeli1, S Ripke2,3,4, RE Peterson1, M Trzaskowski5,6, S-A Bacanu1, A Abdellaoui7, TFM Andlauer8,9, ATF Beekman10, K Berger11,
DHR Blackwood12, DI Boomsma7, G Breen13,14, HN Buttenschøn15, EM Byrne6, S Cichon16,17,18,19, T-K Clarke12, B Couvy-Duchesne6,20,21,
N Craddock22, EJC de Geus7,23, F Degenhardt19,24, EC Dunn25,26,27, AC Edwards1, AH Fanous28, AJ Forstner19,24, J Frank29, M Gill30,
SD Gordon20, HJ Grabe31, SP Hamilton32, O Hardiman33, C Hayward34, AC Heath35, AK Henders6, S Herms19,24,36, IB Hickie37,
P Hoffmann19,24,38, G Homuth39, J-J Hottenga7, M Ising40, R Jansen10, S Kloiber40, JA Knowles41, M Lang29, QS Li42, S Lucae40,
DJ MacIntyre12, PAF Madden43, NG Martin20,44, PJ McGrath45, P McGuffin14, AM McIntosh12,46, SE Medland20, D Mehta6,
CM Middeldorp7, Y Milaneschi10, GW Montgomery47, O Mors48, B Müller-Myhsok8,9,49, M Nauck50, DR Nyholt51, MM Nöthen19,24,
MJ Owen52, BWJH Penninx10, ML Pergadia53, RH Perlis54,55, WJ Peyrot10, DJ Porteous56, JB Potash57, JP Rice58, M Rietschel29, BP Riley1,59,
M Rivera60,61, R Schoevers62, TG Schulze29,63,64,65,66, J Shi67, SI Shyn68, JH Smit10, JW Smoller25,26,27, F Streit29, J Strohmaier29,
A Teumer69, J Treutlein29, S Van der Auwera31, G van Grootheest10, AM van Hemert70, H Völzke69, BT Webb1, MM Weissman71,72,
J Wellmann11, G Willemsen7, SH Witt29, DF Levinson73, CM Lewis14,74, NR Wray5,6, J Flint75,76, PF Sullivan77,78,79 and KS Kendler1,59
on behalf of the CONVERGE consortium and Major Depressive Disorder Working Group of the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium 1Department of Psychiatry, Virginia Institute for Psychiatric and Behavioral Genetics, Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine, Richmond, VA, USA; 2Department of
Psychiatry, Charite Universitatsmedizin Berlin Campus Benjamin Franklin, Berlin, Germany; 3Medical and Population Genetics, Broad Institute, Cambridge, MA, USA; 4Analytic and
Translational Genetics Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA; 5Institute for Molecular Bioscience, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia;
6Queensland Brain Institute, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 7Department of Biological Psychology, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands; 8Department of Translational Research in Psychiatry, Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry, Munich, Germany; 9Munich Cluster for Systems Neurology (SyNergy),
Munich, Germany; 10Department of Psychiatry, VU University Medical Center and GGZ inGeest, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; 11Institute of Epidemiology and Social Medicine,
University of Muenster, Münster, Germany; 12Division of Psychiatry, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; 13King's College London, NIHR BRC for Mental Health, London, UK;
14King's College London, MRC Social Genetic and Developmental Psychiatry Centre, London, UK; 15Department of Clinical Medicine, Translational Neuropsychiatry Unit, Aarhus
University, Aarhus, Denmark; 16Department of Biomedicine, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland; 17Division of Medical Genetics, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland;
18Institute of Neuroscience and Medicine (INM-1), Research Center Juelich, Jülich, Germany; 19Institute of Human Genetics, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany; 20Department of
Genetics and Computational Biology, QIMR Berghofer Medical Research Institute, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 21Centre for Advanced Imaging, University of Queensland, Brisbane,
QLD, Australia; 22Department of Psychological Medicine, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK; 23EMGO+ Institute, VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands;
24Department of Genomics, Life and Brain Center, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany; 25Stanley Center for Psychiatric Research, Broad Institute, Cambridge, MA, USA;
26Department of Psychiatry, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA; 27Psychiatric and Neurodevelopmental Genetics Unit, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA,
USA; 28Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, State University of New York Downstate Medical Center, Brooklyn, NY, USA; 29Department of Genetic Epidemiology in
Psychiatry, Central Institute of Mental Health, Medical Faculty Mannheim, Heidelberg University, Heidelberg, Germany; 30Department of Psychiatry, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin,
Ireland; 31Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany; 32Department of Psychiatry, Kaiser-Permanente Northern California,
San Fransisco, CA, USA; 33Institute of Neuroscience, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland; 34Medical Research Council Human Genetics Unit, Institute of Genetics and Molecular
Medicine, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; 35Department of Psychiatry, Washington University in Saint Louis School of Medicine, St Louis, MO, USA; 36Division of Medical
Genetics, Department of Biomedicine, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland; 37Brain and Mind Research Institute, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia; 38Human
Genomics Research Group, Department of Biomedicine, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland; 39Department of Functional Genomics, Interfaculty Institute for Genetics and
Functional Genomics, University Medicine and Ernst Moritz Arndt University Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany; 40Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry, Munich, Germany;
41Department of Psychiatry and The Behavioral Sciences, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA; 42Neuroscience Therapeutic Area, Janssen Research and
Development, LLC, Titusville, NJ, USA; 43Department of Psychiatry, Washington University in Saint Louis School of Medicine, St Louis, MO, USA; 44School of Psychology, University
of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 45Department of Psychiatry, New York State Psychiatric Institute, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY,
USA; 46Centre for Cognitive Ageing and Cognitive Epidemiology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; 47Institute for Molecular Biology, University of Queensland, Brisbane,
QLD, Australia; 48Psychosis Research Unit, Aarhus University Hospital, Risskov, Denmark; 49Department of Molecular and Clinical Pharmacology, University of Liverpool, Liverpool,
UK; 50Institute of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine, University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany; 51Institute of Health and Biomedical Innovation, Queensland
University of Technology, Brisbane, QLD, Australia; 52MRC Centre for Neuropsychiatric Genetics and Genomics, Cardiff University School of Medicine, Cardiff, UK; 53Charles E. Received 19 November 2016; accepted 27 November 2016 ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Genetic effects influencing risk for major depressive disorder in
Chi
d E Schmidt College of Medicine, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, FL, USA; 54Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA; 55Department of Psychiatry,
Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA; 56Medical Genetics Section, CGEM, IGMM, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; 57Department of Psychiatry, University of
Iowa, Iowa, IA, USA; 58Department of Psychiatry, Washington University in Saint Louis, St Louis, MO, USA; 59Department of Human and Molecular Genetics, Virginia
Commonwealth University School of Medicine, Richmond, VA, USA; 60Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology II, Institute of Neurosciences, Center for Biomedical
Research, University of Granada, Granada, Spain; 61King’s College London, MRC Social Genetic and Developmental Psychiatry Centre, London, UK; 62Department of Psychiatry,
University of Groningen, University of Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands; 63Institute of Psychiatric Phenomics and Genomics, Medical Center of the
University of Munich, Campus Innenstadt, Munich, Germany; 64Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, University Medical Center Göttingen, Göttingen, The Netherlands;
65Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA; 66Human Genetics Branch, NIMH Division of Intramural Research Programs,
Bethesda, MD, USA; 67Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD, USA; 68Division of Psychiatry, Group Health, Seattle, WA, USA;
69Institute for Community Medicine, University Medicine Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany;
70Department of Psychiatry, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, The
Netherlands; 71Division of Epidemiology, New York State Psychiatric Institute, New York, NY, USA; 72Department of Psychiatry, Columbia University College of Physicians and
Surgeons, New York, NY, USA; 73Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA; 74King's College London, Department of Medical and Molecular
Genetics, London, UK; 75Merton College, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK; 76Wellcome Trust Centre for Human Genetics, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK; 77Medical Epidemiology
and Biostatistics, Karolinska Institutet, Solna, Sweden; 78Department of Genetics, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA and 79Department of Psychiatry,
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA. Correspondence: Dr TB Bigdeli, Department of Psychiatry, Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine,
Virginia Institute for Psychiatric and Behavioral Genetics, 800 E. Leigh Street, Biotech One, Suite 101, Richmond, VA 23219-1534, USA. E-mail: tim.bigdeli@gmail.com
R
i
d 19 N
b
2016
t d 27 N
b
2016 Trans-ancestry genomic analysis of depression
TB Bigdeli et al Trans-ancestry genomic analysis of depression
d l
l 2 Major depressive disorder (MDD) is a common, complex psychiatric disorder and a leading cause of disability worldwide. Trans-ancestry genetic correlation The recently developed popcorn software30 allows for estimation of the
trans-ancestry genetic effect correlation (ρg) using GWAS summary
statistics. Cross-ancestry reference scores, representing SNP-wise estimates
of the similarity of LD (with neighboring SNPs) between populations,
were calculated for East Asian (N = 286) and European (N = 379) subjects
from the 1000 Genomes Project (v3).28 For computational efficiency and
consistency with previously reported estimates of genetic correlation,
these calculations were based on ~ 1.2 M common SNPs present in
HapMap3 (ref. 31) following study-wise exclusion of SNPs with INFOo0.9
or minor allele frequencyo0.01%. ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Genetic effects influencing risk for major depressive disorder in
Chi
d E Despite
twin studies indicating its modest heritability (~30–40%), extensive heterogeneity and a complex genetic architecture have
complicated efforts to detect associated genetic risk variants. We combined single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) summary
statistics from the CONVERGE and PGC studies of MDD, representing 10 502 Chinese (5282 cases and 5220 controls) and 18 663
European (9447 cases and 9215 controls) subjects. We determined the fraction of SNPs displaying consistent directions of effect,
assessed the significance of polygenic risk scores and estimated the genetic correlation of MDD across ancestries. Subsequent
trans-ancestry meta-analyses combined SNP-level evidence of association. Sign tests and polygenic score profiling weakly support
an overlap of SNP effects between East Asian and European populations. We estimated the trans-ancestry genetic correlation of
lifetime MDD as 0.33; female-only and recurrent MDD yielded estimates of 0.40 and 0.41, respectively. Common variants
downstream of GPHN achieved genome-wide significance by Bayesian trans-ancestry meta-analysis (rs9323497; log10 Bayes
Factor = 8.08) but failed to replicate in an independent European sample (P = 0.911). Gene-set enrichment analyses indicate
enrichment of genes involved in neuronal development and axonal trafficking. We successfully demonstrate a partially shared
polygenic basis of MDD in East Asian and European populations. Taken together, these findings support a complex etiology for
MDD and possible population differences in predisposing genetic factors, with important implications for future genetic studies. Translational Psychiatry (2017) 7, e1074; doi:10.1038/tp.2016.292; published online 28 March 2017 Polygenic risk score profiling and binomial sign tests Polygenic risk score profiling and binomial sign tests Each data set was filtered on the basis of statistical imputation information
(INFO) greater than 0.8 and minor allele frequency greater than 0.01 in
both CONVERGE and PGC overall; linkage disequilibrium (LD)-based
'clumping' was used to obtain an approximately independent set of SNPs
(r2o0.1) while preferentially retaining the most significant SNP within 500-
kb windows. We computed weighted polygenic scores (that is, log odds
ratio of the associated allele), based on varying P-value thresholds in the
'training set' results (that is, CONVERGE or PGC); P-value thresholds ranged
between 10−5 and 0.5. We evaluated the significance of case–control
differences
using
logistic
regression
and
covarying
ancestry-based
principal components and a study indicator variable. The predictive value
of these scores is reported in terms of Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2 (fmsb
package in R).29 Whether genetic factors predisposing to MDD are shared across
ancestries is not well established, and two replicated genome-
wide significant associations for MDD in China had markedly lower
allele frequencies in Europeans and thus did not replicate.22–24
Allelic heterogeneity and population-specific genetic effects
have been reported for several complex traits;18,25,26 however,
the extent of differences across ancestries remains relatively
unexplored. p
We sought to clarify the extent to which liability to MDD is
shared between European and East Asian populations via
collaboration between the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium
(PGC)22 and CONVERGE6 studies of MDD. We asked whether
observed
directions
of
allelic
effects
are
consistent
across
populations, assessed the significance of cross-ancestry polygenic
scores and estimated the trans-ancestry genetic correlation of
MDD. We attempted to disentangle population differences from
those arising from ascertainment or phenotypic definition through
analyses of recurrent MDD and in female subjects. These meta-
analyses represent the largest trans-ancestry genetic study of
MDD to date. Using the same sets of SNPs and the same P-value thresholds, we
applied a binomial sign test to determine whether the number of SNPs
demonstrating consistent directions of allelic effects between CONVERGE
and PGC was greater than expected by chance (that is, a one-sided test of
whether this fraction is greater than 0.5). INTRODUCTION CONVERGE (China, Oxford and Virginia Commonwealth University
Experimental Research on Genetic Epidemiology): Briefly, all subjects
were Han Chinese women and had two or more episodes of MDD meeting
DSM-IV criteria. After applying quality controls modeled after the PGC
study, 10 502 samples (5282 cases and 5220 controls) and 6 242 619 SNPs
were retained for analysis. Major depressive disorder (MDD) is the most common psychiatric
illness and a leading cause of disability worldwide.1,2 MDD is
modestly heritable (30–40%), may be genetically complex and
likely heterogeneous, complicating efforts to identify replicable
risk loci.3,4 The successful detection and interpretation of genetic
associations require both increased sample sizes5 and empirically
driven efforts to reduce phenotypic heterogeneity.6 PGC MDD: Samples included here comprise Stage 1 of the PGC MDD
study.22 Briefly, all subjects were of European ancestry, all cases were
assessed using validated methods and met DSM-IV criteria for lifetime
MDD, and the majority of controls were screened to exclude lifetime MDD. Available data on number of depressive episodes were used to identify
recurrent cases (two or more episodes). Nine studies from the US,
Europe and Australia were genotyped using SNP arrays. Imputation was
performed with IMPUTE2 (ref. 27) using the 1000 Genomes Project data
(v3; GRCh37/hg19),28 resulting in a total of 13 381 627 autosomal and
X chromosome SNPs. Underpinning the success of genome-wide association studies
(GWAS) of numerous traits has been the emergence of large
research consortia.7 In addition to facilitating larger sample sizes,
many consortia are increasingly ancestrally diverse, enabling
identification of novel associations8–10 and independent replica-
tion of reported findings,11,12 as well as improving fine mapping of
implicated loci.13,14 Consistent associations at replicated loci have
been reported for psychiatric disorders15 and non-psychiatric
traits,8,11,16–18 and shared liabilities are often borne out by
genome-wide polygenic analyses.19–21 MATERIALS AND METHODS Ascertainment and genotyping Sample ascertainment, SNP genotyping and quality-control procedures for
PGC and CONVERGE have been described previously.6,22 Individual sites
and sample sizes are presented in Table 1. Translational Psychiatry (2017), 1 – 7 Trans-ancestry genomic analysis of depression
TB Bigdeli et al 3 Table 1. Sample sizes by participating study site in discovery and replication phases
Phase
Study
Ancestry
No. of controls
No. of cases
No. of recurrent
Discovery
Bonn Mannheim
EUR
1072 (48.3)
588 (64.1)
408 (66.7)
GenRED1
EUR
1097 (42.7)
1020 (70.8)
1020 (70.8)
GSK MPIP
EUR
859 (67.6)
861 (67.4)
831 (67.3)
MPIP MARS 650
EUR
539 (54.5)
373 (55.2)
128 (59.4)
NTR/NESDA
EUR
1727 (62.0)
1685 (69.2)
834 (71.2)
QIMR I317
EUR
960 (55.2)
1017 (61.0)
524 (65.6)
QIMR I610
EUR
748 (61.9)
433 (72.3)
250 (72.4)
RADIANT
EUR
1549 (54.2)
1903 (70.5)
1441 (70.8)
RADIANT—Germany
EUR
217 (53.9)
327 (65.7)
254 (70.5)
STAR*D
EUR
447 (43.8)
1240 (58.6)
912 (59.1)
CONVERGEa
EAS
5220
5282
5282
Replicationb
Edinburgh
EUR
285 (48.8)
372 (59.4)
—
DepGenesNetwork
EUR
470 (62.6)
471 (77.5)
471 (77.5)
GenRED2
EUR
474 (48.9)
830 (82.8)
830 (82.8)
Harvard i2b2
EUR
1067 (50.1)
806 (66.9)
806 (66.9)
Janssen
EUR
1380 (60.5)
466 (68.2)
466 (68.2)
QIMR COEX
EUR
526 (57.6)
565 (71.5)
—
RADIANT—Irish cases
EUR
340 (52.4)
109 (82.6)
109 (82.6)
RADIANT—US cases
EUR
378 (51.9)
223 (78.5)
223 (78.5)
RADIANT—Denmark cases
EUR
516 (40.7)
133 (69.9)
133 (69.9)
SHIP-LEGEND
EUR
1087 (44.0)
366 (67.8)
—
SHIP-TREND-0
EUR
484 (44.6)
163 (71.8)
—
Totals
Discovery
14 435 (71.3)
14 729 (78.4)
11 884 (82.2)
Replication
7007 (51.6)
4504 (72.3)
2572 (75.8)
Abbreviations: EAS, East Asian; EUR, European. Numbers of female subjects are displayed parenthetically. aAll cases and controls were female . bSee note in
Materials and methods section. We
attempted to
address
possible
heterogeneity
by
examining
estimates of genetic correlation within- and across-ancestries, and for
varying phenotypic definitions. Briefly, we divided the PGC and CONVERGE
studies into approximate halves, performing association analysis in each
subsample as described above, and subsequently estimating the genetic
correlations between these nonoverlapping halves. Within the PGC, we
randomly selected 5 of 10 studies (SEUR1), with the remaining five studies
taken as a comparison sample (SEUR2). We selected N = 30 of a possible 126
paired comparisons for which the sample sizes of each subset were
equivalent (~1:1). MATERIALS AND METHODS We followed an analogous procedure in CONVERGE,
selecting 12 of 24 sequencing batches (SASN1), with the remaining
12 batches taken as a comparison sample (SASN2). Within-ancestry
comparisons were between nonoverlapping subsets (for example, SEUR1
versus SEUR2) and utilized reference scores based on a single population,
calculated as described above. Cross-ancestry estimates were based on
comparisons of the full set of CONVERGE results to each of N = 60 subsets
from the within-PGC analysis. We compared cross-ancestry estimates for
lifetime MDD, recurrent MDD and females-only by paired Student’s t-tests. Gene-set enrichment analyses
We applied DEPICT34 to identify significantly enriched gene sets and
pathways in specific tissues and cell types. Briefly, genes in the vicinity of
associated SNPs are tested for enrichment for 'reconstituted' gene sets,
comprising curated sets expanded to include co-regulated loci. Tissue and
cell-type enrichment analysis is conducted by testing whether genes were
highly expressed in any of 209 MeSH annotations based on microarray
data for the Affymetrix U133 Plus 2.0 Array platform (Santa Clara, CA,
USA).35 Because DEPICT adjusts for potential sources of confounding and
multiple testing using precomputed GWAS of randomly distributed
phenotypes, we elected to use as input P-values from inverse variance
weighted (that is, fixed effects) meta-analysis of PGC and CONVERGE. Recalling that MANTRA is effectively a Bayesian implementation of fixed-
effects
meta-analysis
when
allele
frequencies
are
similar
between
populations, we considered this to be an appropriate strategy, if not
somewhat conservative. RESULTS Polygenic risk score profiling and binomial sign tests
We employed polygenic risk score profiling to determine whether
findings
from
CONVERGE
or
the
PGC
are,
in
aggregate,
significantly associated with the MDD status in the other study. Scores based on PGC results were nominally associated with MDD
in CONVERGE (Figure 1; Supplementary Tables S1–S3), accounting
for ~ 0.1% of risk (Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2 = 7.46 × 10−4; P = 0.02). Scores based on results for female-only yielded similar results
(Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2 = 7.60 × 10 −4; P = 0.0141), whereas scores
for
recurrent
MDD
were
most
strongly
associated
overall
(Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2 = 0.00201; P = 6.56 × 10 −5). Scores from
CONVERGE were nominally associated with MDD status in the PGC
data (Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2 = 6.08 × 10−4; P = 6.66 × 10 −3); these
scores yielded similar results when considering female-only
(Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2 = 0.00111; P = 4.15 × 10 −3), and recurrent
MDD (Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2 = 9.13 × 10 −4; P = 2.02 × 10−3). How-
ever, only the results based on PGC-trained polygenic scores for
recurrent MDD remained significant after correction for multiple
testing (Supplementary Table S2). Polygenic risk score profiling and binomial sign tests Trans-ancestry genetic correlation
Table 2 displays the results of the trans-ancestry genetic
correlation between East Asian and European populations. For
lifetime MDD (ρg = 0.332, 95% confidence interval (CI): (0.270,
0.394)),
this
was
both
significantly
greater
than
zero
(Pρg40 = 7.23 × 10−26)
and
significantly
less
than
one
(Pρgo 1 = 1.40 × 10−99), indicating a partially shared polygenic
basis of MDD risk between East Asians and Europeans. These
findings remain significant after correction for multiple tests. g
g
By comparison, recurrent MDD and females-only yielded slightly
higher estimates of genetic correlation (Table 2). We compared g
y
We
evaluated
whether
the
observed
fraction
of
results
displaying the same direction of allelic effects across studies was
significantly greater than expected by chance (that is, 50%) using
binomial sign tests. Supplementary Table S4 gives the number of
LD-independent SNPs considered, fraction of these SNPs display-
ing the same direction of effect in the other study and a one-sided
binomial test P-value. For lifetime MDD, we observed the largest
excess of same-direction effects in PGC for SNPs significant at
Po0.2 in CONVERGE (50.7%; binomial P = 1 × 10−3); this finding
remains
significant
after
multiple-testing
adjustment
(Supplementary Table S4). SNP-based meta-analyses A total of 4504 cases and 7007 controls from 10 independent, European-
ancestry cohorts were available for replication (Table 1). These studies
represent recent additions to the PGC that were not included in the
previously published analysis.22 A brief description of each study site is
given in the Supplementary Material. At the time of writing, neither
comparable East Asian GWAS data sets nor subject-level data on the
number of depressive episodes were readily available. For analyses of
recurrent illness, we included those replication studies that specifically
ascertained recurrent cases. Within each study, we tested for association between SNPs and affection
status by logistic regression with PLINK,32 using allelic dosages and
including ancestry principal components as covariates (plus a site indicator
in PGC analyses). Backward-stepwise regression was used to select
principal components demonstrating association (Po0.159) with each
diagnosis. We excluded SNPs with minor allele frequencyo0.01 or
INFOo0.5 in either CONVERGE or PGC (overall), or missing in greater
than equal to five of nine PGC samples. We analyzed the X chromosome as
previously described.22 For each phenotype definition, we identified independent (pairwise
r2o0.1 within 500-kb windows based on European 1000 Genomes
Project samples), significant autosomal SNPs (log10BF45) from the trans-
ancestry meta-analyses (10, 7 and 7 for MDD, female-only and recurrent
MDD, respectively). We tested these SNPs for association using logistic
regression and including ancestry principal components as covariates. We
performed
inverse-variance
weighted
meta-analyses
of
the
replication samples using METAL. We also performed binomial sign tests
comparing the directions of allelic effects across discovery and replication
stages. We performed Bayesian meta-analyses of PGC and CONVERGE studies
using MANTRA.33 By leveraging population differences in local LD
structure, MANTRA has greater power to detect genetic effects demon-
strating allelic heterogeneity
than traditional approaches assuming
random effects. When effects are consistent across studies, MANTRA is
effectively a Bayesian implementation of fixed-effects meta-analysis. Interstudy genetic distances were calculated from the mean allele
frequency differences. We adopted a threshold of log10 Bayes factor
(log10BF) 47 for declaring genome-wide significance. Translational Psychiatry (2017), 1 – 7 Trans-ancestry genomic analysis of depression
TB Bigdeli et al 4 PGC recurrent MDD analysis (51.1%; binomial P = 3.05 × 10 −5); the
fraction of same-direction effects in the PGC was largest in the
female-only analysis, for SNPs significant at Po0.1 in CONVERGE
(50.9%; binomial P = 1.11 × 10 −3). SNP-based meta-analyses Although statistically significant
after correcting for multiple tests (Supplementary Table S4), the
observed excess of same-direction effects represents only a very
small deviation from expectation under the null hypothesis. SNP-based meta-analyses We observed the strongest overall evidence of association
experiment-wide between SNPs upstream of gephyrin (GPHN) at
14q23.3 (rs9323497; log10BF = 8.08) and lifetime MDD (Supple-
mentary Figures S3 and S4). Associated SNPs show marked
differences in allele frequencies between East Asian and European
populations and opposing directions of allelic effect in CONVERGE
and PGC (Supplementary Figure 4). This locus encodes a neuronal
assembly protein that anchors glycine and GABAA receptors to
the postsynaptic density in inhibitory neurons.36 Intriguingly, the
gephryin region exhibits an unusual ‘yin-yang’ haplotype structure
reflecting strong positive selection related to recent, rapid human
evolution,37 and has previously yielded suggestive evidence
of
association
with
depressive
symptoms
in
the
general
population.38 We initially considered the simple hypothesis that disease-
relevant SNP effects would have similar sizes and directions of
effect across European and Han Chinese studies,39 without explicit
consideration of population differences arising from genetic drift
or divergent genetic architectures. Scores constructed from either
PGC or CONVERGE results were significantly associated with
lifetime MDD in the other study, albeit explaining a diminutive
fraction of risk. However, it is commonly observed that polygenic
prediction is generally poorer when ‘training’ and ‘testing’ data
sets do not originate from a single ancestral population, likely
attributable to differences in allele frequencies and patterns of
LD.20,21 A total of 10 independent associated SNPs (log10BF45) were
prioritized
for
replication
(Supplementary
Table
S5;
Supplementary Figure S4); of these, three were in or near GPHN,
two represent previously reported associations in CONVERGE that
did not replicate in PGC6 and one was the strongest reported
association in the original PGC study.22 No single SNP in either the
females-only or recurrent MDD analyses attained genome-wide
significance (Supplementary Figure S3). From each of these
analyses, seven independent associated SNPs were taken forward
to the replication stage (Supplementary Tables S6 and S7). Next, we applied the recently developed popcorn method30 to
obtain estimates of the genetic effect correlation between these
populations. Briefly, the genetic correlation is the correlation
coefficient of per-allele SNP effect sizes across populations. We
found
that
the
genetic
correlation
of
lifetime
MDD
was
significantly different from both zero and one, suggesting that
there is substantial but incomplete overlap in common SNP effects
predisposing to MDD in Europe and China. RESULTS For the reverse comparison, the largest
excess of same-direction effects was observed for SNPS significant
at Po0.2 in PGC (50.5%; binomial P = 0.016). Table 2. Trans-ancestry genetic correlations between East Asian and
European MDD subtypes
Traita
ρg
b
Pρg40
Pρgo1
Lifetime MDD
0.332 (0.270, 0.394)
7.23 × 10 −26
1.40 × 10−99
Female-only MDD
0.402 (0.326, 0.477)
2.04 × 10 −25
2.59 × 10 −54
Recurrent MDD
0.410 (0.343, 0.477)
5.40 × 10 −33
2.23 × 10 −66
Abbreviation: MDD, major depressive disorder. aEuropean prevalences of
lifetime, females-only and recurrent MDD were assumed to be 0.15, 0.20
and 0.105, respectively; prevalence of recurrent MDD among Chinese
women was assumed to be 0.08. bEstimates of ρg are displayed with
corresponding 95% confidence intervals. Table 2. Trans-ancestry genetic correlations between East Asian and
European MDD subtypes Overall, the greatest excess of same-direction effects in
CONVERGE was observed for SNPs significant at Po0.1 in the P = 4.04 × 10−3
P = 6.66 × 10−3
P = 2.02 × 10−3
P = 1.41 × 10−2
P = 1.92 × 10−2
P = 6.56 × 10−5
CONVERGE−trained polygenic risk score
PGC−trained polygenic risk score
0.0000
0.0002
0.0004
0.0006
0.0008
0.0010
0.0012
0.0014
0.0016
0.0018
0.0020
Lifetime MDD
Females−only MDD
Recurrent MDD
Lifetime MDD
Females−only MDD
Recurrent MDD
Diagnosis
Variance explained (R2)
P−value threshold
0.00001
0.0001
0.001
0.01
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
Figure 1. Trans-ancestry association of polygenic risk scores with major depressive disorder. For scores based on results from PGC or
CONVERGE, the variance in risk explained in the other study is shown on the y axis in terms of Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2; scores based on various
P-value inclusion thresholds are displayed as shaded bars. CONVERGE, China, Oxford and Virginia Commonwealth University Experimental
Research on Genetic Epidemiology; MDD, major depressive disorder; PGC, Psychiatric Genomics Consortium. Figure 1. Trans-ancestry association of polygenic risk scores with major depressive disorder. For scores based on results from PGC or
CONVERGE, the variance in risk explained in the other study is shown on the y axis in terms of Nagelkerke’s pseudo-R2; scores based on various
P-value inclusion thresholds are displayed as shaded bars. CONVERGE, China, Oxford and Virginia Commonwealth University Experimental
Research on Genetic Epidemiology; MDD, major depressive disorder; PGC, Psychiatric Genomics Consortium. Translational Psychiatry (2017), 1 – 7 Trans-ancestry genomic analysis of depression
TB Bigdeli et al 5 Gene-set enrichment analyses these estimates by assuming an approximately normal distribu-
tion for ρg and obtaining a Z-score for the difference in values;
these differences were found to be nominally significant for both
recurrent MDD (Pone-sided = 0.023) and females-only (Pone-sided =
0.044). We followed up these results by calculating genetic effect
correlation estimates based on comparisons of CONVERGE to
N = 60 random subsets of the PGC data (Supplementary Figure S1). Compared with lifetime MDD (ρg = 0.309; 95% CI: (0.290 0.327)),
estimates
of
ρg
were
significantly
higher
for
females-only
(ρg = 0.372,
95%
CI:
(0.344,0.401);
t(59) = 7.41,
Pone-sided =
2.69 × 10 −10) and recurrent MDD (ρg = 0.375, 95% CI: (0.362,
0.389); t(59) = 15.29, Pone-sided = 1.74 × 10-22). We used DEPICT to investigate whether particular pathways or
gene sets were enriched for associations with any of the
phenotypic
definitions
considered. For
SNPs
significant
at
Po10−5 in meta-analyses of lifetime, females-only and recurrent
MDD (29, 24 and 27 independent loci, respectively), no single
pathway or gene set was significantly enriched, or contained more
significant genes than expected by chance, after correction for
multiple testing (q ⩾0.20). When we considered a more inclusive threshold (Po10−4),
there were 167, 161 and 161 independent loci for lifetime,
females-only and recurrent MDD, respectively. Following correc-
tion for multiple testing, only central nervous system neuron
differentiation (GO:0021953) and axon cargo transport pathways
(GO:0008088) were found to be significantly enriched (qo0.05) in
the analysis of lifetime MDD. An additional 11 gene sets were
suggestively enriched (qo0.20) and included several ontology
terms related to neurodevelopmental processes (Supplementary
Table S8). Finally, no tissue or cell types were enriched for
associations with any definition of MDD (q ⩾0.20), irrespective of
the significance threshold applied. To aid our interpretation of the cross-ancestry results, we
derived analogous within-ancestry estimates for East Asians
(ρg = 0.926, 95% CI: (0.967,0.967)) and Europeans (ρg = 0.807, 95%
CI: (0.856,0.856); Supplementary Figure S2). Notably, within-
ancestry analysis of East Asians yielded significantly greater
estimates of ρg (t(56.45) = 3.70, Ptwo-sided = 0.0005). However, as
CONVERGE represents a single study, actual population differ-
ences are confounded here with those arising from ascertainment
or heterogeneity in assessment methods and instruments among
participating PGC studies. DISCUSSION We have conducted a large, trans-ancestry meta-analysis repre-
senting, to our knowledge, the first systematic effort to analyze
European and Han Chinese studies of MDD. As expected, we
identified a shared, common polygenic basis of MDD between
these populations, as exemplified by an excess of same-direction
allelic effects, significant polygenic risk score profiling results and
modest estimates of genetic correlation. SNP-based meta-analyses 01ZZ9603, 01ZZ0103 and 01ZZ0403), the Ministry
of Cultural Affairs as well as the Social Ministry of the Federal State of Mecklenburg-
West Pomerania and the network ‘Greifswald Approach to Individualized Medicine
(GANI_MED)’ funded by the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (grant
03IS2061A). Genome-wide data of SHIP have been supported by the Federal Ministry of
Education and Research (grant no. 03ZIK012) and a joint grant from Siemens
Healthcare, Erlangen, Germany, and the Federal State of Mecklenburg- West Pomerania. The University of Greifswald is a member of the Caché Campus program of the
InterSystems GmbH. SHIP LEGEND was funded by the German Research Foundation
(grant GR1912/5-1). The Harvard i2b2 project was supported by Award # U54LM008748
from the National Library of Medicine (to ISK) and R01MH086026 and R01MH085542
from the National Institute of Mental Health (to RHP and JWS, respectively). CONFLICT OF INTEREST PFS is a scientific advisor to Pfizer. HJG reports receiving funding from the following:
German Research Foundation; Federal Ministry of Education and Research Germany;
speakers honoraria from, Eli Lilly and Servier. BM-M consulted for Affectis
Pharmaceuticals. RP
has
received
consulting
fees
from
Proteus
Biomedical,
Concordant Rater Systems, Genomind and RID Ventures. The remaining author
declare no conflict of interest. Limitations First, the absence of replicable associations with MDD in
ancestrally diverse populations precluded more pointed compar-
isons of specific genetic effects. Our attempts to reduce the heterogeneity of MDD, namely by
focusing on two particular subtypes of illness, should be regarded
as preliminary. Furthermore, questions pertaining to both screen-
ing and ascertainment of controls were not addressed in the
current study, and could have reduced our power to detect
relevant variation. We expect that with larger sample sizes, future
studies will be sufficiently powered to address these issues. Finally, by having conducted multiple separate analyses for
females-only and recurrent MDD, we increased the multiple-
testing burden. As these do not represent completely indepen-
dent analyses, we have not corrected exhaustively for the total
number of tests performed. CONCLUSIONS We have demonstrated a common polygenic basis of MDD that is
partially shared between European and Han Chinese populations. Importantly, our findings appear to reinforce the idea that
subtyping
of
MDD
may
yield
additional
insight
into
its
etiology.40 Striking an advantageous balance between phenoty-
pically more homogeneous definitions of illness and sample size
represents an ongoing and nuanced challenge for genetic studies
of MDD. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The CONVERGE study was funded by the Wellcome Trust (WT090532/Z/09/Z,
WT083573/Z/07/Z, WT089269/Z/09/Z) and by NIH grant MH100549. All authors are
part of the CONVERGE consortium (China, Oxford and VCU Experimental Research on
Genetic Epidemiology) and gratefully acknowledge the support of all partners in
hospitals across China. The PGC is supported by NIH grant U01 MH094421. Statistical
analyses were carried out on the Genetic Cluster Computer (http://www.geneticcluster. org), which is financially supported by the Netherlands Scientific Organization (NWO
480-05-003 PI: Posthuma) along with a supplement from the Dutch Brain Foundation
and the VU University Amsterdam. We thank TH Pers for support for the DEPICT
software. Generation Scotland (GS:SFHS) was supported by a Wellcome Trust Strategic
Award 'Stratifying Resilience and Depression Longitudinally' (STRaDL; Reference
104036/Z/14/Z), and received core support from the Chief Scientist Office (CSO) of
the Scottish Government Health Directorates (grant number CZD/16/6) and the Scottish
Funding Council (HR03006). AMM is supported by a Scottish Funding Council Senior
Clinical Fellowship and by the Dame Theresa and Mortimer Sackler Foundation. The
Bonn/Manheim (BoMa) study was supported by the German Federal Ministry of
Education and Research(BMBF) through the Integrated Genome Research Network (IG)
MooDS (Systematic Investigation of the Molecular Causes of Major Mood Disorders and
Schizophrenia; grant 01GS08144 to Markus M Nöthen and Sven Cichon, grant
01GS08147 to Marcella Rietschel), under the auspices of the National Genome Research
Network plus (NGFNplus), and through the Integrated Network IntegraMent (Integrated
Understanding
of
Causes
and
Mechanisms
in
Mental
Disorders,
grant
BMBF01ZX1314G), under the auspices of the e:Med Programme. The GenRED GWAS
project was supported by NIMH R01 Grants MH061686 (DF Levinson), MH059542 (WH
Coryell), MH075131 (WB Lawson), MH059552 (JB Potash), MH059541 (WA Scheftner)
and MH060912 (MM Weissman). We acknowledge the contributions of Dr George S
Zubenko and Dr Wendy N Zubenko, Department of Psychiatry, University of Pittsburgh
School of Medicine, to the GenRED I project. The NIMH Cell Repository at Rutgers
University and the NIMH Center for Collaborative Genetic Studies on Mental Disorders SNP-based meta-analyses We thank the twins and their families registered at the Australian Twin
Registry for their participation in the many studies that have contributed to this
research. Genotyping of STAR*D was supported by an NIMH Grant MH072802 (SP
Hamilton). STAR*D was funded by the National Institute of Mental Health (contract
N01MH90003) to the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas (AJ
Rush, principal investigator). SHIP is part of the Community Medicine Research net of
the University of Greifswald, Germany, which is funded by the Federal Ministry of
Education and Research (grants no. 01ZZ9603, 01ZZ0103 and 01ZZ0403), the Ministry
of Cultural Affairs as well as the Social Ministry of the Federal State of Mecklenburg-
West Pomerania and the network ‘Greifswald Approach to Individualized Medicine
(GANI_MED)’ funded by the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (grant
03IS2061A). Genome-wide data of SHIP have been supported by the Federal Ministry of
Education and Research (grant no. 03ZIK012) and a joint grant from Siemens
Healthcare, Erlangen, Germany, and the Federal State of Mecklenburg- West Pomerania. The University of Greifswald is a member of the Caché Campus program of the
InterSystems GmbH. SHIP LEGEND was funded by the German Research Foundation
(grant GR1912/5-1). The Harvard i2b2 project was supported by Award # U54LM008748
from the National Library of Medicine (to ISK) and R01MH086026 and R01MH085542
from the National Institute of Mental Health (to RHP and JWS, respectively). made essential contributions to this project. Genotyping was carried out by the Broad
Institute Center for Genotyping and Analysis with support from Grant U54 RR020278
(which partially subsidized the genotyping of the GenRED cases). Collection and
quality-control analyses of the control data set were supported by grants from NIMH
and the National Alliance for Research on Schizophrenia and Depression. We are
grateful to Knowledge Networks (Menlo Park, CA, USA) for assistance in collecting the
control data set. We express our profound appreciation to the families who participated
in this project, and to the many clinicians who facilitated the referral of participants to
the study. The RADIANT studies were funded by the following: a joint grant from the UK
Medical Research Council and GlaxoSmithKline (G0701420); the National Institute for
Health Research (NIHR) Specialist Biomedical Research Centre for Mental Health at the
South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust and King’s College London; and the
UK Medical Research Council (G0000647). SNP-based meta-analyses The GENDEP study was funded by a
European Commission Framework 6 grant, EC Contract Ref.: LSHB-CT-2003-503428. Max
Planck Institute of Psychiatry MARS study was supported by the BMBF Program
Molecular Diagnostics: Validation of Biomarkers for Diagnosis and Outcome in Major
Depression (01ES0811). Genotyping was supported by the Bavarian Ministry of
Commerce, and the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) in the
framework of the National Genome Research Network (NGFN2 and NGFN-Plus, FKZ
01GS0481 and 01GS08145). The Netherlands Study of Depression and Anxiety (NESDA)
and the Netherlands Twin Register (NTR) contributed to GAIN-MDD and to MDD2000. This study was funded by the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (MagW/
ZonMW Grants 904-61-090, 985-10- 002, 904-61-193, 480-04-004, 400-05-717, 912-100-
20; Spinozapremie 56-464-14192; Geestkracht program Grant 10-000-1002); the Center
for Medical Systems Biology (NWO Genomics), Biobanking and Biomolecular Resources
Research Infrastructure, VU University’s EMGO Institute for Health and Care Research
and Neuroscience Campus Amsterdam, NBIC/BioAssist/ RK (2008.024); the European
Science Foundation (EU/QLRT-2001-01254); the European Community’s Seventh
Framework Program (FP7/2007-2013); ENGAGE (HEALTH-F4-2007-201413); and the
European Science Council (ERC, 230374). Genotyping was funded in part by the Genetic
Association Information Network (GAIN) of the Foundation for the US National
Institutes of Health, and analysis was supported by grants from GAIN and the NIMH
(MH081802). Funding for the QIMR samples was provided by the Australian National
Health and Medical Research Council (241944, 339462, 389927, 389875, 389891,
389892, 389938, 442915, 442981, 496675, 496739, 552485, 552498, 613602, 613608,
613674 and 619667), the Australian Research Council (FT0991360 and FT0991022), the
FP-5 GenomEUtwin Project (QLG2-CT- 2002-01254) and the US National Institutes of
Health (AA07535, AA10248, AA13320, AA13321, AA13326, AA14041, MH66206,
DA12854 and DA019951) and the Center for Inherited Disease Research (Baltimore,
MD, USA). We thank the twins and their families registered at the Australian Twin
Registry for their participation in the many studies that have contributed to this
research. Genotyping of STAR*D was supported by an NIMH Grant MH072802 (SP
Hamilton). STAR*D was funded by the National Institute of Mental Health (contract
N01MH90003) to the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas (AJ
Rush, principal investigator). SHIP is part of the Community Medicine Research net of
the University of Greifswald, Germany, which is funded by the Federal Ministry of
Education and Research (grants no. SNP-based meta-analyses Of particular interest,
comparisons based on females-only or recurrent MDD, which
better recapitulated the ascertainment strategy in CONVERGE,
yielded significantly higher estimates of genetic correlation
despite an attendant reduction in sample size. We attempted to replicate these single-SNP associations in a
collection of independent replication samples (4504 MDD cases
and 7007 controls). For lifetime MDD, no single SNP yielded
nominally significant evidence of association (Po0.05) in fixed-
effects meta-analysis of these replication samples (Supplementary
Table S5). Replication analyses also failed to generate replication
support for SNP associations identified for females-only or
recurrent MDD (Supplementary Tables S6 and S7). Regional
association and forest plots for these SNPs are provided in the
Supplementary Figures S4–S6. Given the extensive heterogeneity of MDD, and an expected
and demonstrable loss of power arising from between-study
differences in ancestry and ascertainment, our limited success in
identifying novel, replicable evidence of genome-wide significant
association is perhaps unsurprising. It is well understood that a
trait’s heritability—and by extension, a shared polygenic liability—
is a less important determinant of successful identification of
relevant associations than its underlying genetic architecture. Considering the relatively low genetic correlations reported here,
we might expect an attenuation of statistical power to detect
individual variants, that is, as compared with a similarly sized
studies
of
the
same
ancestry. A
concomitant,
statistically For selected SNPs from the trans-ancestry meta-analyses, we
assessed the significance of the observed fraction of SNPs
showing the same direction of effect across discovery and
replication phases; these fractions were 0.30 (P = 0.9453), 0.286
(P = 0.9375) and 0.571 (P = 0.5) for lifetime, females-only and
recurrent MDD, respectively. Translational Psychiatry (2017), 1 – 7 Translational Psychiatry (2017), 1 – 7 Trans-ancestry genomic analysis of depression
TB Bigdeli et al Trans-ancestry genomic analysis of depression TB Bigdeli et al 6 significant enrichment of biologically relevant gene sets is taken
as an additional support for this interpretation. significant enrichment of biologically relevant gene sets is taken
as an additional support for this interpretation. made essential contributions to this project. Genotyping was carried out by the Broad
Institute Center for Genotyping and Analysis with support from Grant U54 RR020278
(which partially subsidized the genotyping of the GenRED cases). Collection and
quality-control analyses of the control data set were supported by grants from NIMH
and the National Alliance for Research on Schizophrenia and Depression. SNP-based meta-analyses We are
grateful to Knowledge Networks (Menlo Park, CA, USA) for assistance in collecting the
control data set. We express our profound appreciation to the families who participated
in this project, and to the many clinicians who facilitated the referral of participants to
the study. The RADIANT studies were funded by the following: a joint grant from the UK
Medical Research Council and GlaxoSmithKline (G0701420); the National Institute for
Health Research (NIHR) Specialist Biomedical Research Centre for Mental Health at the
South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust and King’s College London; and the
UK Medical Research Council (G0000647). The GENDEP study was funded by a
European Commission Framework 6 grant, EC Contract Ref.: LSHB-CT-2003-503428. Max
Planck Institute of Psychiatry MARS study was supported by the BMBF Program
Molecular Diagnostics: Validation of Biomarkers for Diagnosis and Outcome in Major
Depression (01ES0811). Genotyping was supported by the Bavarian Ministry of
Commerce, and the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) in the
framework of the National Genome Research Network (NGFN2 and NGFN-Plus, FKZ
01GS0481 and 01GS08145). The Netherlands Study of Depression and Anxiety (NESDA)
and the Netherlands Twin Register (NTR) contributed to GAIN-MDD and to MDD2000. This study was funded by the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (MagW/
ZonMW Grants 904-61-090, 985-10- 002, 904-61-193, 480-04-004, 400-05-717, 912-100-
20; Spinozapremie 56-464-14192; Geestkracht program Grant 10-000-1002); the Center
for Medical Systems Biology (NWO Genomics), Biobanking and Biomolecular Resources
Research Infrastructure, VU University’s EMGO Institute for Health and Care Research
and Neuroscience Campus Amsterdam, NBIC/BioAssist/ RK (2008.024); the European
Science Foundation (EU/QLRT-2001-01254); the European Community’s Seventh
Framework Program (FP7/2007-2013); ENGAGE (HEALTH-F4-2007-201413); and the
European Science Council (ERC, 230374). Genotyping was funded in part by the Genetic
Association Information Network (GAIN) of the Foundation for the US National
Institutes of Health, and analysis was supported by grants from GAIN and the NIMH
(MH081802). Funding for the QIMR samples was provided by the Australian National
Health and Medical Research Council (241944, 339462, 389927, 389875, 389891,
389892, 389938, 442915, 442981, 496675, 496739, 552485, 552498, 613602, 613608,
613674 and 619667), the Australian Research Council (FT0991360 and FT0991022), the
FP-5 GenomEUtwin Project (QLG2-CT- 2002-01254) and the US National Institutes of
Health (AA07535, AA10248, AA13320, AA13321, AA13326, AA14041, MH66206,
DA12854 and DA019951) and the Center for Inherited Disease Research (Baltimore,
MD, USA). 6 CONVERGE consortium. Sparse whole-genome sequencing identifies two loci for
major depressive disorder. Nature 2015; 523: 588–591. REFERENCES Biological
interpretation of genome-wide association studies using predicted gene func-
tions. Nat Commun 2015; 6: 5890. 15 Schizophrenia Working Group of the Psychiatric Genomics, Consortium. Biological
insights from 108 schizophrenia-associated genetic loci. Nature 2014; 511:
421–427. 35 Fehrmann RS, Karjalainen JM, Krajewska M, Westra HJ, Maloney D, Simeonov A
et al. Gene expression analysis identifies global gene dosage sensitivity in cancer. Nat Genet 2015; 47: 115–125. 16 McKenzie CA, Abecasis GR, Keavney B, Forrester T, Ratcliffe PJ, Julier C et al. Trans-
ethnic fine mapping of a quantitative trait locus for circulating angiotensin
I-converting enzyme (ACE). Hum Mol Genet 2001; 10: 1077–1084. 36 Tyagarajan SK, Fritschy JM. Gephyrin: a master regulator of neuronal function? Nat
Rev Neurosci 2014; 15: 141–156. 17 Nishida N, Sawai H, Kashiwase K, Minami M, Sugiyama M, Seto WK et al. New
susceptibility and resistance HLA-DP alleles to HBV-related diseases identified by
a trans-ethnic association study in Asia. PLoS One 2014; 9: e86449. 37 Climer S, Templeton AR, Zhang W. Human gephyrin is encompassed within giant
functional noncoding yin-yang sequences. Nat Commun 2015; 6: 6534. 38 Hek K, Demirkan A, Lahti J, Terracciano A, Teumer A, Cornelis MC et al. A genome-
wide association study of depressive symptoms. Biol Psychiatry 2013; 73: 667–678. 39 Ioannidis J, Ntzani EE, Trikalinos TA. ‘Racial’differences in genetic effects for
complex diseases. Nat Genet 2004; 36: 1312–1318. 38 Hek K, Demirkan A, Lahti J, Terracciano A, Teumer A, Cornelis MC et al. A genome-
wide association study of depressive symptoms. Biol Psychiatry 2013; 73: 667–678. 18 Wu Y, Waite LL, Jackson AU, Sheu WH, Buyske S, Absher D et al. Trans-ethnic
fine-mapping of lipid loci identifies population-specific signals and allelic
heterogeneity that increases the trait variance explained. PLoS Genet 2013; 9:
e1003379. 39 Ioannidis J, Ntzani EE, Trikalinos TA. ‘Racial’differences in genetic effects for
complex diseases. Nat Genet 2004; 36: 1312–1318. 40 Power RA, Tansey KE, Buttenschøn HN, Cohen-Woods S, Bigdeli T, Hall LS et al. Genome-wide association for major depression through age at onset stratifica-
tion: major depressive disorder Working Group of the Psychiatric Genomics
Consortium. Biol Psychiatry 2016; S0006-3223: 32386–1. 19 de Candia TR, Lee SH, Yang J, Browning BL, Gejman PV, Levinson DF et al. Additive
genetic variation in schizophrenia risk is shared by populations of African and
European descent. Am J Hum Genet 2013; 93: 463–470. REFERENCES 1 Ustun TB, Ayuso-Mateos JL, Chatterji S, Mathers C, Murray CJ. Global burden of
depressive disorders in the year 2000. Br J Psychiatry 2004; 184: 38q6–392. 1 Ustun TB, Ayuso-Mateos JL, Chatterji S, Mathers C, Murray CJ. Global burden of
depressive disorders in the year 2000. Br J Psychiatry 2004; 184: 38q6–392. 2 Alonso J, Angermeyer MC, Bernert S, Bruffaerts R, Brugha TS, Bryson H et al. Disability and quality of life impact of mental disorders in Europe: results from the
European Study of the Epidemiology of Mental Disorders (ESEMeD) project. Acta
Psychiatr Scand Suppl 2004: 38–46. 3 Sullivan PF, Neale MC, Kendler KS. Genetic epidemiology of major depression:
review and meta-analysis. Am J Psychiatry 2000; 157: 1552–1562. 3 Sullivan PF, Neale MC, Kendler KS. Genetic epidemiology of major depression:
review and meta-analysis. Am J Psychiatry 2000; 157: 1552–1562. 5 Wray NR, Pergadia ML, Blackwood DH, Penninx BW, Gordon SD, Nyholt DR et al. Genome-wide association study of major depressive disorder: new results, meta-
analysis, and lessons learned. Mol Psychiatry 2012; 17: 36–48. 5 Wray NR, Pergadia ML, Blackwood DH, Penninx BW, Gordon SD, Nyholt DR et al. Genome-wide association study of major depressive disorder: new results, meta-
analysis, and lessons learned. Mol Psychiatry 2012; 17: 36–48. 6 CONVERGE consortium. Sparse whole-genome sequencing identifies two loci for
major depressive disorder. Nature 2015; 523: 588–591. Translational Psychiatry (2017), 1 – 7 Trans-ancestry genomic analysis of depression
TB Bigdeli et al 7 24 Hyde CL, Nagle MW, Tian C, Chen X, Paciga SA, Wendland JR et al. Identification of
15 genetic loci associated with risk of major depression in individuals of European
descent. Nat Genet 2016; 48: 1031–1036. 7 Sullivan P. Psychiatric genetics, investigators. Don’t give up on GWAS. Mol Psy-
chiatry 2012; 17: 2–3. 8 Wang H, Burnett T, Kono S, Haiman CA, Iwasaki M, Wilkens LR et al. Trans-ethnic
genome-wide association study of colorectal cancer identifies a new susceptibility
locus in VTI1A. Nat Commun 2014; 5: 4613. 25 Yin X, Low HQ, Wang L, Li Y, Ellinghaus E, Han J et al. Genome-wide meta-analysis
identifies multiple novel associations and ethnic heterogeneity of psoriasis sus-
ceptibility. Nat Commun 2015; 6: 6916. 9 EArly_Genetics_Lifecourse_Epidemiology_(EAGLE)_Eczema_Consortium, Australian
Asthma
Genetics,
Consortium,
Australian
Asthma
Genetics
Consortium,
Aagc. Multi-ancestry genome-wide association study of 21,000 cases and 95,000
controls identifies new risk loci for atopic dermatitis. Nat Genet 2015; 47:
1449–1456. REFERENCES 26 Seyerle AA, Young AM, Jeff JM, Melton PE, Jorgensen NW, Lin Y et al. Evidence of
heterogeneity by race/ethnicity in genetic determinants of QT interval. Epide-
miology 2014; 25: 790–798. 27 Howie BN, Donnelly P, Marchini J. A flexible and accurate genotype imputation
method for the next generation of genome-wide association studies. PLoS Genet
2009; 5: e1000529. 10 Coffee_and_Caffeine_Genetics_Consortium, Cornelis MC, Byrne EM, Esko T, Nalls
MA, Ganna A et al. Genome-wide meta-analysis identifies six novel loci associated
with habitual coffee consumption. Mol Psychiatry 2015; 20: 647–656. 28 Genomes Project, Consortium, Abecasis GR, Auton A, Brooks LD, DePristo MA,
Durbin RM et al. An integrated map of genetic variation from 1,092 human
genomes. Nature 2012; 491: 56–65. 11 Keller MF, Reiner AP, Okada Y, van Rooij FJ, Johnson AD, Chen MH et al. Trans-
ethnic meta-analysis of white blood cell phenotypes. Hum Mol Genet 2014; 23:
6944–6960. 29 Nakazawa M. Practices of Medical and Health Data Analysis using R. Pearson
Education: Japan, 2007. 12 Ng MC, Shriner D, Chen BH, Li J, Chen WM, Guo X et al. Meta-analysis of genome-
wide association studies in African Americans provides insights into the genetic
architecture of type 2 diabetes. PLoS Genet 2014; 10: e1004517. 30 Brown BC, Asian Genetic Epidemiology Network Type 2 Diabetes, Consortium, Ye
CJ, Price AL, Zaitlen N. Transethnic genetic-correlation estimates from summary
statistics. Am J Hum Genet 2016; 99: 76–88. 13 Replication DIG, Meta-analysis, Consortium, Asian Genetic Epidemiology Network
Type 2 Diabetes, Consortium, South Asian Type 2 Diabetes, Consortium, Mexican
American Type 2 Diabetes, Consortium, Type 2 Diabetes Genetic Exploration by
Nex-generation sequencing in muylti-Ethnic Samples, Consortium et al. Genome-
wide trans-ancestry meta-analysis provides insight into the genetic architecture
of type 2 diabetes susceptibility. Nat Genet 2014; 46: 234–244. 31 International HapMap Consortium. A haplotype map of the human genome. Nature 2005; 437: 1299–1320. 32 Purcell S, Neale B, Todd-Brown K, Thomas L, Ferreira MA, Bender D et al. PLINK: a
tool set for whole-genome association and population-based linkage analyses. Am J Hum Genet 2007; 81: 559–575. 33 Morris AP. Transethnic meta-analysis of genomewide association studies. Genet
Epidemiol 2011; 35: 809–822. 14 Liu CT, Buchkovich ML, Winkler TW, Heid IM, African Ancestry Anthropometry
Genetics, Consortium, Consortium, GIANT Consortium. Multi-ethnic fine-mapping
of 14 central adiposity loci. Hum Mol Genet 2014; 23: 4738–4744. 34 Pers TH, Karjalainen JM, Chan Y, Westra HJ, Wood AR, Yang J et al. 21 International Schizophrenia, Consortium, Purcell SM, Wray NR, Stone JL, Visscher
PM, O’Donovan MC et al. Common polygenic variation contributes to risk of
schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Nature 2009; 460: 748–752. 22 Major Depressive Disorder Working Group of the Psychiatric, Gwas Consortium,
Ripke S, Wray NR, Lewis CM, Hamilton SP, Weissman MM et al. A mega-analysis of
genome-wide association studies for major depressive disorder. Mol Psychiatry
2013; 18: 497–511. 23 Consortium, Converge. Sparse whole-genome sequencing identifies two loci for
major depressive disorder. Nature 2015; 523: 588–591. REFERENCES 20 Ikeda M, Aleksic B, Kinoshita Y, Okochi T, Kawashima K, Kushima I et al. Genome-
wide association study of schizophrenia in a Japanese population. Biol Psychiatry
2011; 69: 472–478. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International License. The images or other third party material in this
article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated
otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons
license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the
material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/
by/4.0/ © The Author(s) 2017 Supplementary Information accompanies the paper on the Translational Psychiatry website (http://ww Translational Psychiatry (2017), 1 – 7
|
https://openalex.org/W4296010615
|
https://journal.ipb.ac.id/index.php/jpsl/article/download/40715/24046
|
English
| null |
Wetland Fires in Community Perspectives
|
Jurnal pengelolaan sumberdaya alam dan lingkungan
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 4,381
|
Journal of Natural Resources and Environmental Management
12(3): 466-471. http://dx.doi.org/10.29244/jpsl.12.3.466-471
E-ISSN: 2460-5824
http://journal.ipb.ac.id/index.php/jpsl Journal of Natural Resources and Environmental Management
12(3): 466-471. http://dx.doi.org/10.29244/jpsl.12.3.466-471
E-ISSN: 2460-5824
http://journal.ipb.ac.id/index.php/jpsl Journal of Natural Resources and Environmental Management
12(3): 466-471. http://dx.doi.org/10.29244/jpsl.12.3.466-471
E-ISSN: 2460-5824
http://journal.ipb.ac.id/index.php/jpsl Keywords: Community perspectives,
intention, theory planned of
behavior, wetland fires Corresponding Author:
Mona Lestari
Section of Occupational Health
and Safety, Study Program of
Public Health, Faculty of Public
Health, Sriwijaya University;
Tel. +62-711-580089, 580068
Email:
mona_lestari@unsri.ac.id Corresponding Author:
Mona Lestari
Section of Occupational Health
and Safety, Study Program of
Public Health, Faculty of Public
Health, Sriwijaya University;
Tel. +62-711-580089, 580068
Email:
mona_lestari@unsri.ac.id INTRODUCTION 466
Wetland ecosystems play an important role in human life. Wetlands with their ability to absorb and store
carbon, can be global climate controllers. But as population growth increases, wetland ecosystems have been
threatened in recent years. Wetlands in Indonesia are experiencing deforestation and degradation due to
changes in land function. The impact of heavy land fires can have widespread impacts, such as the destruction
of hydrological institutions, changes in planting patterns, and the impact on the global climate (Rasyid 2014). The problem of wetland fires has become an annual problem faced by Indonesia, especially in South
Sumatra Province. According to South Sumatra Forestry Service, land and forest fires in 2017 amounted to
2.614 ha and in 2018 amounted to 3.925 ha. In 2019, there were land fires with an increasing quantity from
the previous year (South Sumatra Forestry Service 2019). The incident land fires that occurred in South
Sumatra devoured an area of 52.716 ha. Land fires in the South Sumatra region in 2019 began in April. Ogan
Ilir is one of the regencies in South Sumatra with the most land fires every year. Data from Lestari et al. (2021)
show that there were 317 hotspots that occurred in 10 districts in Ogan Ilir in 2019. This number was the
highest compared to the previous year. Wetland ecosystems play an important role in human life. Wetlands with their ability to absorb and store
carbon, can be global climate controllers. But as population growth increases, wetland ecosystems have been
threatened in recent years. Wetlands in Indonesia are experiencing deforestation and degradation due to
changes in land function. The impact of heavy land fires can have widespread impacts, such as the destruction
of hydrological institutions, changes in planting patterns, and the impact on the global climate (Rasyid 2014). The problem of wetland fires has become an annual problem faced by Indonesia, especially in South
Sumatra Province. According to South Sumatra Forestry Service, land and forest fires in 2017 amounted to
2.614 ha and in 2018 amounted to 3.925 ha. In 2019, there were land fires with an increasing quantity from
the previous year (South Sumatra Forestry Service 2019). The incident land fires that occurred in South
Sumatra devoured an area of 52.716 ha. Land fires in the South Sumatra region in 2019 began in April. Mona Lestaria, Fenny Etrawatib, Yustini Ardillahc, Adisyah Fitrah Rahmadinia, Titi Nurhalizaa Mona Lestaria, Fenny Etrawatib, Yustini Ardillahc, Adisyah Fitrah Rahmadinia, Titi Nurhalizaa a Section of Occupational Health and Safety, Study Program of Public Health, Faculty of Public Health, Sriwijaya University,
I d
i a Section of Occupational Health and Safety, Study Program of Public Health, Faculty of Public Health, Sriwijaya University,
Indonesia b Section of Health Promotion, Study Program of Public Health, Faculty of Public Health, Sriwijaya University, Indonesia
c Study Program of Environmental Health, Faculty of Public Health, Sriwijaya University, Indonesia Abstract. Community perception greatly affects the occurrence of fire because
if the community has the intention to burn land, it will produce behavior to
burn land. The intention of carrying out an action, including burning land,
does not appear suddenly but must go through stages. Behavior Planned
Theory states that behavior can be predicted by attitudes toward behavior,
subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control that will change the
intentions and behavior of individuals. The study design is qualitative with a
descriptive approach, which is to review and analyze people's perceptions of
fire events in the Ogan Ilir wetlands of South Sumatra. Study informants
consist of expert informants and key informants. The expert informants in this
study are the Regional Disaster Management Agency, the Subdistrict Head,
and the Village Head. Expert informants are the community in the subdistrict
at the study site. The results showed that attitudes towards behavior,
subjective norms and perceptions of control had a positive effect on people's
perceptions of land fires. Information related to the impact of land fires,
social, and environmental support, and strong regulations related to burning
sanctions can provide a positive perception so that it can prevent people from
burning land. Article Info:
Received: 16 - 04 - 2022
Accepted: 07 - 06 - 2022 Corresponding Author:
Mona Lestari
Section of Occupational Health
and Safety, Study Program of
Public Health, Faculty of Public
Health, Sriwijaya University;
Tel. +62-711-580089, 580068
Email:
mona lestari@unsri.ac.id INTRODUCTION Ogan
Ilir is one of the regencies in South Sumatra with the most land fires every year. Data from Lestari et al. (2021)
show that there were 317 hotspots that occurred in 10 districts in Ogan Ilir in 2019. This number was the
highest compared to the previous year. Jurnal Pengelolaan Sumber Daya Alam dan Lingkungan 12(3): 466-471 Wetland fires in Indonesia are caused by natural conditions and human activities in managing land. In the
tropics, natural factors that cause fires due to the accumulation of foliage or litter, wind, rock friction, and heat
in the dry season trigger fires (Arisanty et al. 2020). The study by Lestari et al. (2021) conducted in the Ogan
Ilir area showed that the most frequently burned areas were peaty soil (53%) and scrub vegetation (43%). Wetland fires, particularly in peat soils are very dangerous and difficult to detect especially if they occur in the
dry season (Nurhayati et al. 2020). According to Indonesian National Board for Disaster Management, economic motives become the basis
of human causes of burning land (Indonesian National Board for Disaster Management 2013). Many wetlands
are converted into farms, plantations, and residential (Murdiyarso and Lebel 2007). Most people prefer to burn
land to clear land because it is considered fast, economical, and easy (Febrie and Wibisono 2017). Siregar et
al. (2021) also stated the same thing in their study. The community's actions in burning land are formed because of the community's perception of the land
fire itself. Perception is a person's way of interpreting the information received. A person's perception does not
arise by itself but through processes and factors that influence that perception. This is what causes everyone to
have a different interpretation, even though the object they see is the same (Qiong 2017). The community's
perception of land fires will affect their behavior in burning land. The perception that grows in the community is one of the determining factors in carrying out the act of
burning, which will impact everyone who lives around the area where the fire occurred (Ariani and Bambang
2018). Perception in the community greatly affects the occurrence of fire because if the community has the
intention to burn land, it will produce behavior to burn land. People have the perception that burning forests is
the best way fast, and save costs. INTRODUCTION According to Hidayah and Haryani (2012), intention is a cognitive
representation of a person's readiness to perform a behavior/action. A person's behavioral intentions are the
determinants of whether or not a person will perform certain behaviors (Suwerda et al. 2019). The intention of
carrying out an action, including burning land, does not appear suddenly but must go through stages. One
theory used in studying the factors that influence human behavior is the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB). According to Ajzen, in theory, a behavior with high engagement requires confidence and evaluation to
foster attitudes, subjective norms, and behavior control, with intention as a mediator that impacts a behavior
(Ajzen 2005). Knowing how the community behaves towards land fires also provides an illustration of how
perceptions related to land fires are formed in individual communities because from the perceptions that people
have, they can determine what behavior will arise. Therefore, this study was conducted to analyze how the
people of Ogan Ilir Regency perceive the occurrence of wetland fires that occur in the area. The results of this
study are expected to be a reference for parties who are concerned about preventing wetland fires in finding
solutions to reduce the causes of fires caused by humans, both in the Ogan Ilir Regency area and throughout
Indonesia. METHOD This qualitative descriptive study was conducted to analyze public perceptions regarding wetland fires in
Ogan Ilir Regency, South Sumatra based on the components of the Planned Behavior theory. This descriptive
research is used to describe, record, analyze and interpret the conditions that currently occur or exist. The
theory of planned behavior is devoted to a person's specific behavior and to all behavior in general. A person's
intention to behave can be predicted by three things, namely attitude toward the behavior, subjective norm,
and perceived behavior control (Wikamorys and Rochmach 2017). The study location was selected based on the highest and lowest number of land fires in Ogan Ilir Regency
based on data from the Regional Disaster Management Agency of Ogan Ilir Regency in 2019. Taken in 2019
because that year, there were fires with the most number of hotspots, and the area burned in the last three years. The selected research locations were the districts with the highest land fires (North Indralaya and Pemulutan
Districts) and the sub-districts with the lowest land fires (Indralaya and South Indralaya District). The 467 Lestari M, Rahmadini AF, Nurhaliza T, Etrawati F, Ardillah Y informants in this study were people from four sub-districts in Ogan Ilir Regency, which consisted of key
informants and expert informants. The selection of expert informants was carried out by purposive sampling
and selected based on the categories of distance from residence to land, land ownership, and community
professions as farmers or non-farmers. The key informants in this study consisted of the Regional Disaster
Management Agency of Ogan Ilir Regency, the Head of the District, and the Head of the Village. This type of study data consists of primary data obtained directly from study subjects using in-depth
interviews and secondary data obtained from the Ogan Ilir Regional Disaster Management Agency. The
validity test in this study used the triangulation method. This is done by comparing observational data with the
results of interviews, comparing a person's circumstances and perspectives with various opinions and views of
others, and comparing the results of interviews with the contents of related documents. Data interpretation is
an activity that gains understanding and meaning from data obtained from informants or participants by
bringing up concepts and theories (Rijali 2018). The data obtained will be analyzed using qualitative methods
and presented in the form of an impressionist narrative. Attitudes Toward Behavior Attitudes towards behavior are based on behavioral beliefs, which are a person's belief in positive or
negative consequences that will be obtained when performing a behavior (salient outcome beliefs). According
to Ajzen (2005), belief in these consequences can strengthen attitudes towards behavior when based on
evaluations conducted by individuals. “We already know that fogs can affect our health, it caused hard to breath, it’s not good for pregnant
woman and the children“ (AM). “We already know that fogs can affect our health, it caused hard to breath, it’s not good for pregnant
woman and the children“ (AM). “Our health is disrupted due to smoke, besides that, the ecosystem is disrupted too” (YIP). “Our health is disrupted due to smoke, besides that, the ecosystem is disrupted too” (YIP). “Smoke causes coughing and because of fog we can’t see clearly” (AR) “Smoke causes coughing and because of fog we can’t see clearly” (AR). “Our land is also burning because of the fire that is spreading, embers sticking in our house, the smoke
makes it difficult for us to breathe” (MZ). Based on the results of the interview, the community knows the impact or consequences that will be
experienced in the event of a land fire. The majority of people say the impact they feel is more on their health. Smoke released at the time of fire makes the view limited and disturbs breathing causing Acute Respiratory
Infection. Based on community information, they cleared the land by using pesticides to poison the grass,
plowing, and manually with tools such as machetes or hoes. “Only sprayed using pesticides, then cleaned with a grass machine”(YA). “Only sprayed using pesticides, then cleaned with a grass machine”(YA). “Oh..to open rice fields, we don’t burn it, the processing is done by clearing the land using machetes and
tractor engines” (MU). Beliefs or behavioral beliefs are related to the subjective assessment of the surrounding world, including
the benefits or disadvantages that individuals will gain if the individual performs or does not perform a
behavior (Ramdhani 2011). Based on the results of the interview, the community has a reason not to burn land
because the impact or consequences on individual health and activities become hampered. In line with study
by Wikamorys and Rochmach, attitude variables towards behavior contribute the most to a patient's behavior
for cataract surgery (Wikamorys and Rochmach 2017). METHOD This study was conducted after obtaining a code of
ethics
and
study
permit
from
the
Faculty
of
Public
Health,
Sriwijaya
University
No.367/UN9.FKM/TU.KKE/2021, on September 24th, 2021. Attitudes Toward Behavior When the individual wants a better and safer life, then
the attitude displayed is a good and safe attitude (Hidayah and Haryani 2012). Therefore, people prefer not to
burn land, considering the impact that will arise can harm themselves. Subjective Norms Subjective Norms 468 Jurnal Pengelolaan Sumber Daya Alam dan Lingkungan 12(3): 466-471 Subjective norms are defined as social pressure for individuals to do something or not. This norm is
determined by a combination of one's beliefs about agreeing and disapproving of a person or group for an
individual to behavior and an individual's motivation to abide by the rules (Wikamorys and Rochmach 2017). In this case, a person's perception of people's habits or the views of the surrounding community about land
burning can affect a person's behavior in burning land. ”Not anymore (burning land habit) since 2018” (BY) “Not anymore, they told us (the authorities) not to burn land” (MKS) “No more burning land anymore, people already know the rules” (ASB) g
y
, p
p
y
(
)
“Not anymore. We are not able to do that, people already know the impact of burning land so they don’t
do that anymore. We usually hijacked and sprayed the land with poisons” (SM) (
)
“Not anymore. We are not able to do that, people already know the impact of burning land so they don’t
do that anymore. We usually hijacked and sprayed the land with poisons” (SM) “Not anymore. We are not able to do that, people already know the impact of burning land so th “Not anymore. We are not able to do that, people already know the impac ot anymore. We are not able to do that, people already know the impact of burning land so they
that anymore. We usually hijacked and sprayed the land with poisons” (SM) y
p
p
y
p
f
g
do that anymore. We usually hijacked and sprayed the land with poisons” (SM) Based on the results of the study, it was found that the majority of the people in Ogan Ilir had not burned
land. This leads to the growth of confidence among fellow communities not to burn land because there is no
community that makes these bad habits. In line with a study conducted by Wijayanti and Putri (2016), those substantive norms have an influence
on intent to commit academic fraud. A person will have the intention to burn land if people around him also
do this. The more subjective norms are accepted by society, the more it increases people's intention to do
something or behave (Suprapto 2017). Subjective Norms Concern is expressed by the community in the event of a land fire. This
shows that the community also pays attention to the surrounding environment to foster motivation from within
the community not to burn land. Subjective norms will greatly affect behavior if people have the belief that
behavior change can benefit them. Perceived Behavioral Control Perception of behavioral control refers to an individual's perception of his or her ability to perform a
particular behavior (Ajzen and Fishbein 2012). Perception of behavioral control is the function of control
beliefs, which is the belief in factors that facilitate or complicate carrying out or realizing a behavior (Suprapto
2017). “I know, the prohibition of burning land if it violates there is a criminal law that has regulate “The regulations already exist from the local government, the village head always appeals” (
h
l
h
d
ll
(b
l
d) b
ff
ll (h
d “There’s some rule, they don’t allow us (burn land) because it can affects all (human and environment)”
(DRJ) “There’s some rule, they don’t allow us (burn land) because it can affects all (human and environment)” CONCLUSION The results of the study show attitudes towards behavior, where people have reasons not to burn land by
burning because of the impact or consequences on individual health and inhibiting activities. Subjective norms,
are where people are aware that their social environment is no longer in the habit of burning land so that people
will follow the habits that grow in their social environment. The perception of behavioral control is where the
community knows the picture that if you burn land can be punished or sanctioned, so it depends on how strong
the regulation is in regulating the community. These three components influence the community's intention to
burn land or not. The intention possessed is directly proportional to the perception of the individual community. Information related to the impact of land fires, social, and environmental support, and strong regulations related
to burning sanctions can provide a positive perception so that it can prevent people from burning land. “First of all, the land is slashed, hijacked, and sprayed with poison” (LN) Based on the results of interviews, people are used to clearing land by not burning land. This proves that
the community already has the intention not to burn but they prefer to do land preparation by using tractors or
poison. Intention has a role in directing a behavior or action, namely by linking the considerations believed
and desired by the individual with a particular action (Pakpahan 2017). In this case, the background to the
community's intention not to burn land is the impact that will be experienced, regulations that have burdensome
sanctions, and communities in social environments that have not burned land. Based on these reasons, there is
an intention from the community to do behavior not to burn land. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The study/publication of this article was funded by DIPA of Public Service Agency of Universitas
Sriwijaya 2021. SP DIPA-023.17.2.677515/2021, On November 23, 2020. In accordance with the Rector’s
Decree Number: 0007/UN9/SK.LP2M.PT/202I, On April 27, 2021. (DRJ) Based on the results of the study, the majority of the public knows about the regulations that have been
made by the government, both central and local. Existing regulations become one of the indicators that affect
in the perception of control of people's behavior. In addition, people often follow the socialization carried out
by the local government related to land fires. “Often (the socialization), sometimes through the Village Head who conveys to the Head of the Hamlet,
sometimes the police or TNI who give appeals to our homes” (FR). “Often (the socialization), sometimes through the Village Head who conveys to the Head of the Hamlet,
sometimes the police or TNI who give appeals to our homes” (FR). “Yes we attend the socialization” (ARJ). The control of behavior is determined by control belief or belief about the ability to control. This
perception describes past experiences, the anticipation of future situations, and attitudes toward norms that
influence society (Achmadi 2010). In this case, the community knows the picture if they do land burning that
is affected by prison sentences and the impact caused by the land fires. In line with a study by Cruz et al. (2015), perception of behavioral control has a positive and significant effect on a person's intentions in
performing a behavior. In addition, the perception of behavioral control is influenced by perceived power or
perception that individuals have about how strongly control can affect eliciting behavior. Government
regulations that regulate sanctions when burning land make the regulation has strong control over individuals
in bringing up behavior not to burn land. 469 Lestari M, Rahmadini AF, Nurhaliza T, Etrawati F, Ardillah Y Ajzen I, Fishbein M. 2012. Belief, Attitude, Intention and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research.
Massachusetts (MA): Addison-Wesley. Ajzen I. 2005. Attitudes, personallity and behavior. Int J Strateg Innov Mark. 3:117–191. Achmadi A. 2010. Psikologi Umum. Jakarta: Rineka Cipta. Ariani T, Bambang H. 2018. Pengetahuan dan Persepsi Masyarakat Desa Rawasari di Sekitar Hutan Lindung
Gambut Londerang Terkait Kebakaran Hutan Kabupaten Tanjung Jabung Timur. Jambi: Pendidik Biol
Univ Jambi. Intention Behavioral intentions indicate an individual's decision to perform a particular behavior (Maskur et al. 2018). The concept of intention states that an individual's motivation for realizing a behavior is defined by the
attitudes that influence that individual's behavior. The basis of an intention in the form of encouragement,
intent, strings, and purpose to perform a behavior (Permatasari 2016). Based on Planned Behavior Theory, the
intention is formed from three components, namely, attitudes toward behavior, subjective norms, and
behavioral control (Ajzen 2005). The intention to realize a behavior is measured using attitude toward the behavior, subjective norm, and
perceived behavioral control (Volva and Djamaludin 2018). If the individual has the intention to perform a
behavior, then the individual will tend to realize the behavior, but if the individual does not intend to perform
the behavior, then he will be less likely to do the behavior. “The land is poisoned first, then cleaned” (AM) “First of all, the land is slashed, hijacked, and sprayed with poison” (LN) REFERENCES Achmadi A. 2010. Psikologi Umum. Jakarta: Rineka Cipta. Achmadi A. 2010. Psikologi Umum. Jakarta: Rineka Cipta. Ajzen I. 2005. Attitudes, personallity and behavior. Int J Strateg Innov Mark. 3:117–191. Ajzen I, Fishbein M. 2012. Belief, Attitude, Intention and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research. Massachusetts (MA): Addison-Wesley. Ariani T, Bambang H. 2018. Pengetahuan dan Persepsi Masyarakat Desa Rawasari di Sekitar Hutan Lindung
Gambut Londerang Terkait Kebakaran Hutan Kabupaten Tanjung Jabung Timur. Jambi: Pendidik Biol
Univ Jambi. 470 Jurnal Pengelolaan Sumber Daya Alam dan Lingkungan 12(3): 466-471 Arisanty D, Anis MZA, Putro HPN, Muhaimin M, Syarifuddin. 2020. Kebakaran Lahan Gambut: Faktor
Penyebab dan Mitigasinya. Pertama. Banjarmasin: Program Studi Pendidikan IPS, Fakultas Keguruan
dan Ilmu Pendidikan, Universitas Lambung Mangkurat. Cruz LD, Suprapti NWS, Yasa NNK. 2015. Aplikasi theory of planned behavior dalam membangkitkan niat
berwirausaha bagi mahasiswa fakultas ekonomi Unpaz, Dili Tomor Leste. E-Jurnal Ekon dan Bisnis
Univ Udayana. 4(12):895–920. Febrie H, Wibisono G. 2017. Karakteristik tanah gambut yang distabilisasi terhadap pebakaran. Jom
FTEKNIK. 4(1):1–8. Haryani. 2012. Implementasi niat (intention) dalam kehidupan kerja. Dharma Ekon. 36:1–8. Indonesian National Board for Disaster Management. 2013. Rencana Kontinjensi Nasional Menghadapi
Ancaman Bencana Kabut Asap Akibat Kebakaran Hutan dan Lahan. Jakarta: Indonesian National Board
for Disaster Management. Lestari M, Andarini D, Camelia A, Novrikasari N, Nandini RF, Fujianti P. 2021. Wetland fires and its
environmental conditions. J Ilmu Lingkung. 19(1):21–28. Maskur A, Saeroji A, Tjahjaningsih E. 2018. Pengaruh norma subjektif dan kontrol prilaku yang dipersepsikan
terhadap niat pinjam kur mikro (Studi pada Nasabah BRI di Pati). UNISBANK. 1(1):978–979. Murdiyarso D, Lebel L. 2007. Local to global perspectives on forest and land fires in Southeast Asia. Mitig
Adapt Strateg Glob Chang. 12(1):3–11. Nurhayati AD, Hero Saharjo B, Sundawati L, Syartinillia, Vetrita Y. 2020. Perilaku dan persepsi masyarakat
terhadap terjadinya kebakaran gambut di Ogan Komeriling Ilir Provinsi Sumatera Selatan. Journal Nat
Resour Environ Manag. 10(4):568–583. Pakpahan DR. 2017. Pengaruh pengetahuan dan sikap terhadap perilaku masyarakat pada bank syariah di
wilayah Kelurahan Sei Sikambing. At-Tawassuth. 2(2):345–367. Permatasari LP. 2016. Pengaruh sikap, norma subjektif, dan kontrol perilaku terhadap intensi berhenti
merokok sebagai dampak peraturan gambar peringatan pada mahasiswa strata satu di Kota Malang. J
Ilm Mhs FEB. 3(2):1–10. g OU. 2017. A brief introduction to perception. Stud Lit Lang. 15(4):18–28. doi:10.3968/10055. Qiong OU. 2017. A brief introduction to perception. Stud Lit Lang. 15(4):18–28. doi:10.3968/10055. Qiong OU. 2017. A brief introduction to perception. Stud Lit Lang. 15(4):18–28. doi:10.3968/10055. Ramdhani N. REFERENCES 2011. Penyusunan alat pengukur berbasis theory of planned behavior. Bul Psikol. 19(2):55–69. 2011. Penyusunan alat pengukur berbasis theory of planned behavior. Bul Psikol. 19(2):55–69. 4 P
l h
d
d
k k b k
h
J Li
k Wid
i
1(4) 47 59 dhani N. 2011. Penyusunan alat pengukur berbasis theory of planned behavior. Bul Psikol. 19(2) Ramdhani N. 2011. Penyusunan alat pengukur berbasis theory of planned behavior. Bul Psikol. 19(2):55 69. Rasyid F. 2014. Permasalahan dan dampak kebakaran hutan. J Lingk Widyaiswara. 1(4):47–59. id F. 2014. Permasalahan dan dampak kebakaran hutan. J Lingk Widyaiswara. 1(4):47–59. 18. Analisis data kualitatif. J Ilmu Dakwah. 17(33):81–95. Rijali A. 2018. Analisis data kualitatif. J Ilmu Dakwah. 17(33):81–95. Siregar AA, Lestari M, Novrikasari, Putri DA, Andarini D, Nandini RF. 2021. Kebakaran lahan basah dan
faktor manusia sebagai penyebabnya. EnviroScienteae. 17(2):30–29. South Sumatra Forestry Service. 2019. Data Kejadian Kebakaran Hutan dan Lahan di Kabupaten Ogan Ilir. Palembang: South Sumatra Forestry Service. Suprapto SW. 2017. Hubungan Sikap, Norma Subjektif, Persepsi Kontrol Perilaku dan Pengetahuan Terhadap
Intensi Pelaporan Kecelakaan Kerja Perawat Rawat Inap Tulip dan Melati di Rumah Sakit X Kota
Bekasi Tahun 2016. Jakarta: Universitas Islam Negeri Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta. Suwerda B, Hardoyo SR, Kurniawan A. 2019. Pengelolaan bank sampah berkelanjutan di wilayah perdesaan
Kabupaten Bantul. J Sains &Teknologi Lingkung. 11(1):74–86. doi:10.20885/jstl.vol11.iss1.art6. Volva L, Djamaludin MD. 2018. Perilaku penggunaan tas belanja pada ibu rumah tangga tidak bekerja dalam
perspektif theory of planned behavior. J Ilmu Kel dan Konsum. 11(1):49–59. Wijayanti AW, Putri GA. 2016. Model theory of planned behavior (TPB) untuk memprediksi niat mahasiswa
melakukan kecurangan akademik. J Manaj dan Kewirausahaan. 14(2):189–197. Wikamorys DA, Rochmach TN. 2017. Aplikasi theory of planned behavior dalam membangkitkan niat pasien
untuk melakukan operasi katarak. J Adm Kesehat Indones. 5(1):32–40. 471
|
https://openalex.org/W4376620544
|
https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas/article/download/1966/pdf
|
Indonesian
| null |
Pelatihan Pembuatan Laporan Keuangan Bagi Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Lestari
|
Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat Royal
| 2,023
|
cc-by-sa
| 2,934
|
Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300 Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300 ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online) DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
I
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas PENDAHULUAN penjualan dengan tunai atau kredit. Padahal
manajemen
keuangan
dan
akuntansi sangat penting untuk menge-
tahui
perkembangan
usaha
dan
melakukan pengembangan usaha atau
ekspansi usaha. Ying, et. al. (2019)
menyatakan bahwa intangible skill dari
para manager sangat berpengaruh pada
kelangsungan hidup UMKM. Hal senada
juga disampaikan oleh Eniola & Ente-
bang (2017) yang menyatakan bahwa
pengambilan keputusan finansial yang
buruk
dipengaruhi
oleh
kurangnya
literasi finansial yang memadai. Purnomo
(2019) juga menyatakan bahwa literasi
keuangan memiliki hubungan positif
dengan kinerja perusahaan. Dusun Kuwangen lor merupakan
salah satu dusun di Kabupaten Gunung-
kidul dengan mayoritas masyarakatnya
berprofesi sebagai petani tadah hujan,
dan hanya sebagian kecil saja yang
memiliki
profesi
lain. Karakteristik
daerah dan masyarakat tersebut memaksa
mereka untuk dapat menambah peng-
hasilan dari sektor selain pertanian. Beberapa pemuda kemudian tergerak dan
mendirikan usaha kelompok pembudi-
daya ikan dengan nama Mina Lestari. Kelompok
Pembudidaya
Ikan
Mina Lestari memfokuskan diri dalam
pembesaran lele untuk konsumsi. Ke-
lompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Lestari
mengambil bibit lele dari beberapa
daerah terutama dari daerah Sleman
karena kualitas bibitnya bagus dan har-
ganya terjangkau. Kelompok Pembudi-
daya Ikan Mina Lestari juga melakukan
kerjasama dengan PT Widodo Makmur
Unggas dalam pengadaan pakan ikan. Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Les-
tari akan membeli telur afkir dari PT
Widodo Makmur Unggas sebagai pakan
lele. Dalam proses pembesaran, lele yang
masih kecil belum mampu untuk me-
makan telur ayam sehingga masih mem-
butuhkan pelet dengan ukuran paling
kecil. Ketidakmampuan anggota Ke-
lompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Lestari
dalam membuat laporan keuangan meng-
hambat mereka dalam mendapatkan pen-
danaan usaha (KUR) karena memang
usaha tersebut tidak
terdokumentasi
dengan baik, baik laporan keuangan
ataupun sekedar arus kas. Hussain,
Samuel dan Amin (2018) menyatakan
bahwa finansial literasi merupakan sum-
ber daya yang menghubungkan UMKM
ke akses pendanaan. Jianmu Ye (2019)
menyatakan bahwa akses ke permodalan
akan memberikan pengaruh positif ter-
hadap keberlangsungan usaha. Hal terse-
but senada dengan Khan et. al. (2019)
yang menyatakan bahwa akses ke per-
modalan merupakan penghambat dalam
kelangsungan usaha. Anggota Kelompok Pembudidaya
Ikan Mina Lestari sebagian besar meru-
pakan petani dan buruh lepas dengan
tingkat pendidikan paling tinggi hanya
SMA dan sebagian besar lainnya SMP
dan SD. Mereka sangat awam dengan
manajemen keuangan apalagi akuntansi
dan pembukuan. PELATIHAN PEMBUATAN LAPORAN KEUANGAN BAGI KELOMPOK
PEMBUDIDAYA IKAN MINA LESTARI Kata kunci: harga pokok produksi; laporan keuangan; laporan laba rugi; pengembangan usaha 295 Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online)
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online)
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300 Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300 ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online) ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online) DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
I
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas PELATIHAN PEMBUATAN LAPORAN KEUANGAN BAGI KELOMPOK
PEMBUDIDAYA IKAN MINA LESTARI Yudas Tadius Andi Candra1, Bianka Andriyani2,
1 Program Studi Akuntansi, Universitas Mercu Buana Yogyakarta
2 Program Studi Manajemen STIE YKPN Yogyakarta
email: yudas@mercubuana-yogya.ac.id Abstract: Business development can be hampered if the owner does not understand financial
report. This happened to members of the Mina Lestari Fish Cultivators Group. Most of the
mebers are unable to make financial reports. This absence of these financial reports will also
hinder access to capital which will ultimately hinder business development. The purpose of this
sevice is to provide training on making reports on cost of production and income statements. These financial reports can be used to access capital and develop their business. This communi-
ty service is carried out using counseling method. The service team begins the service by intro-
ducing financial report and their elements. After that the servant teaches to make a report on the
cost of production and income statements directly on the members’ catfish ponds. The service
team also provides an overview of access to capital and business development to increas profit
margin. The members of Mina Lestari Fish Cultivators Group are directly involved in every
actifity. Through cooperation with various parties, this service can run smoothly so that the pur-
pose of this service can be achieved. Keywords: business development, cost of production, financial report, income statement Abstrak: Perkembangan usaha bisa terhambat jika pemiliknya tidak memahami laporan keu-
angan. Hal tersebut terjadi pada anggota Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Lestari. Sebagian
besar anggota Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Lestari tidak mampu membuat laporan keu-
angan. Tidak adanya laporan keuangan ini juga akan menghambat akses ke permodalan yang
pada akhirnya akan menghambat perkembangan usaha. Tujuan dari pengabdian ini adalah
memberikan pelatihan mengenai pembuatan laporan harga pokok produksi dan laporan laba ru-
gi. Laporan keuangan tersebut bisa digunakan dalam mengakses permodalan dan mengem-
bangkan usaha. Pengabdian ini dilakukan dengan metode penyuluhan. Tim pengabdi memulai
pengabdian dengan mengenalkan laporan keuangan dan elemen-elemennya. Setelah itu
pengabdi memengajarkan membuat laporan harga pokok produksi dan laporan laba rugi secara
langsung pada kolam lele anggota. Tim pengabdi juga memberikan gambaran mengenai akses
ke permodalan dan pengembangan usaha untuk meningkatkan margin laba. Anggota Kelompok
Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Lestari terlibat secara langsung dalam setiap praktik penghitungan laba
rugi usaha. Melalui Kerjasama dengan berbagai pihak, pengabdian ini dapat berjalan dengan
lancar sehingga tujuan pengabdian ini bisa tercapai. PENDAHULUAN Pasaribu dan Asep
(2021) menyatakan bahwa Laporan Ke-
uangan adalah file yang berisi catatan
keuangan, yaitu laporan yang berisi
transaksi yang melibatkan uang, baik
pembelian dengan tunai atau kredit, atau Akses
ke
per-modalan
akan
meningkatkan keberlangsungan usaha
dengan mempermudah akses ke pasar
dan memungkinkan untuk melakukan
inovasi produk (Yang et. al. 2019). Ter-
hambatnya akses pendanaan akan meng-
hambat pula pengembangan usaha. Pa-
dahal peluang sangat terbuka lebar untuk
mengembangkan
usaha,
mulai
dari
menjual langsung ke masyarakat, men- 296 ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online) golah menjadi produk olahan lain seperti
pecel lele, keripik lele, abon lele dan
olahan lain. Permasalahan utama yang
dihadapi Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan
Mina Lestari adalah tiap anggotanya tid-
ak bisa menghitung berapa besarnya
biaya produksi tiap kali panen. Hal terse-
but berdampak pada tidak dibuatnya
laporan keuangan yang memadai, se-
hingga mereka tidak mengetahui secara
pasti berapa keuntungan yang diperoleh
setiap kali panen. Hal tersebut sesuai
dengan hasil penelitian dari Kristanto
(2022) dan juga penelitian dari Yakob, et. al. (2021) yang menyatakan bahwa
literasi finansial berpengaruh positif ter-
hadap pengembangan usaha. pengamatan, peneliti juga meminta agar
mitra membuat laporan keuangan seder-
hana tanpa mengajari bagaimana cara
membuat laporan keuangan yang benar. Metode ini dilakukan untuk mengetahui
sejauh mana anggota Kelompok Pem-
budidaya Ikan Mina Lestari memahami
mengenai laporan keuangan. Pelatihan Dari hasil pengamatan dan dari
hasil laporan keuangan yang sudah
dihasilkan oleh anggota Kelompok Pem-
budidaya Ikan Mina Lestari berjumlah 62
anggota tersebut disusunlah materi yang
mudah dicerna oleh mitra. Setiap anggota
Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Les-
tari akan mendapatkan modul dan buku
serta alat tulis agar bisa langsung
digunakan untuk praktik. Selanjutnya
pengabdi memberikan pelatihan dengan
melakukan praktik langsung kepada ang-
gota Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina
Lestari. Pelatihan
tersebut
terbagi
kedalam ketiga tahapan, yaitu pelatihan
penghitungan HPP bagaimana menghi-
tungnya dan elemen apa saja yang ada
dalam HPP tersebut, mulai dari biaya ba-
han baku, biaya tenaga kerja langsung
dan biaya overhead pabrik. Penghitungan
HPP ini akan dilakukan secara langsung
pada kolam salah satu anggota Kelompok
Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Lestari, Pengabdi
memberikan
solusi
dengan mengajarkan cara menghitung
biaya produksi dan cara membuat laporan
keuangan sederhana. Laporan keuangan
ini pada akhirnya akan bisa dimanfaatkan
untuk mengakses dana bantuan ataupun
pendanaan baik dari koperasi ataupun
perbankan. METODE Pelaksanaan kegiatan pengabdian
kepada masyarakat ini menggunakan
metode penyuluhan yang melalui tiga
tahapan yaitu: Pelatihan pembuatan laporan laba
rugi, Pembuatan laporan laba rugi ini
didasarkan pada laporan HPP yang sebe-
lumnya sudah dibuat, sehingga alurnya
menjadi jelas dan mudah dipahami oleh
anggota Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan
Mina Lestari. Laporan Laba rugi yang
akan diajarkan adalah laporan laba rugi
yang paling sederhana dengan metode
yang mudah dipahami, dan pelatihan ma-
najemen usaha, serta pengembangan
usaha. Saat ini anggota Kelompok Pem-
budidaya Ikan Mina Lestari hanya ber- Pendampingan Pengabdi akan melakukan pen-
dampingan dalam pembuatan laporan
keuangan dan manajemen usaha setelah
selesainnya proses pelatihan. Hal ini dil-
akukan agar anggota Kelompok Pem-
budidaya Ikan Mina Lestari benar-benar
mampu untuk membuat laporan keu-
angan dan melakukan pengembangan
usaha. Pendampingan dilakukan baik
secara
langsung
maupun
melalui
whatsapp. Gambar 1. Dokumentasi Persiapan Gambar 1. Dokumentasi Persiapan Gambar 2. Peserta Pelatihan Pengamatan Sebelum melakukan pelatihan,
pengabdi melakukan pengamatan ter-
hadap mitra yaitu Kelompok Pembudi-
daya Ikan Mina Lestari selama satu bu-
lan. Pengamatan yang dilakukan yaitu
bagaimana Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan
Mitra Lestari beroperasi (mengambil
bibit, membeli pakan dan perawatan
sampai
panen,
bagaimana
sistem
penjualannya dan bagaimana menghitung
keuntungannya). Sambil
melakukan 297 Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online)
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online)
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas dari biaya overhead pabrik (BOP) dalam
penghitungan biaya produksi dan hanya
beberapa saja yang memahami konsep
biaya penyusutan. fokus pada usaha pembesaran lele saja. Usaha tersebut sebenarnya memiliki
peluang lain yang jauh lebih besar yaitu
pembuatan produk konsumsi dari bahan
dasar lele. Pengabdi akan menjelaskan
mengenai prospek-prospek usaha yang
bisa dikembangkan oleh Kelompok Pem-
budidaya Ikan Mina Lestari Gambar 1. Dokumentasi Persiapan
Gambar 2. Peserta Pelatihan
Gambar 3. Penjelasan Materi Gambar 1. Dokumentasi Persiapan PEMBAHASAN Gambar 2. Peserta Pelatihan Pengabdian ini diawali dengan
melakukan pengamatan dan berkomu-
nikasi dengan Kelompok Pembudidaya
Ikan Mina Lestari. Pelatihan pembuatan
laporan ke-uangan ini dimulai pada tang-
gal 13 Juni 2022 yang berlangsung di
Balai Dusun Kuwangen Lor. Selanjutnya
memberikan pema-paran mengenai pent-
ingnya visi misi dan tujuan utama ang-
gota mitra melakukan usaha tersebut yai-
tu untuk menambah penghasilan. Setelah
itu, pengabdi menjelaskan mengenai
pengertian laporan harga pokok produksi,
fungsi dan cara menghitungnya. Gambar 3. Penjelasan Materi Gambar 3. Penjelasan Materi Gambar 3. Penjelasan Materi Pelatihan
pembuatan
laporan
harga pokok produksi ini tidak hanya
selesai dalam satu hari saja karena
pengabdi dan mitra telah sepakat bahwa
pelatihan ini harus dibarengi dengan
praktik penghitungan secara langsung
dilapangan. Praktik penghitungan pem-
buatan laporan harga pokok produksi ini
dilakukan di kolam salah satu anggota Pemaparan materi juga disertai
dengan diskusi langsung sehingga mitra
yang kurang memahami penjelasannya
bisa langsung bertanya dan berdiskusi. Dari hasil diskusi ternyata hampir semua
anggota Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan
Mina Lestari tidak memahami konsep 298 Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online)
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online)
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online) Kelompok
Pembudidaya
Ikan
Mina
Lestari yaitu di kolam Bapak Wasgi. Kelompok
Pembudidaya
Ikan
Mina
Lestari yaitu di kolam Bapak Wasgi. Kelompok
Pembudidaya
Ikan
Mina
Lestari yaitu di kolam Bapak Wasgi. biaya pokok dalam pembesaran ikan lele
yang berupa bibit lele, pakan lele, dan air
sebagai media hidup lele. Biaya tenaga
kerja langsung merupakan biaya tenaga
kerja yang mengurusi lele tersebut, mulai
dari tenaga kerja penyiapan lahan,
penyebaran benih, pemberian pakan, sor-
tir lele dan pemberian vitamin/probiotik. Biaya overhead pabrik merupakan biaya
yang tidak terhubung secara langsung
dengan produk, yaitu berupa vitamin
yang dicampurkan ke dalam pakan lele,
probiotik dan garam yang digunakan un-
tuk
persiapan
kolam. Selanjutnya
pengabdi, Bianka Andriyani membuatkan
format laporan laba rugi yang dihub-
ungkan dengan laporan harga pokok
produksi. Laporan laba rugi ini merupa-
kan laporan yang berisi pendapatan serta
biaya-biaya yang dikeluarkan oleh Bapak
Wasgi. PEMBAHASAN 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online)
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300
ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online)
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. 295 - 300 ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online) ISSN 2614-7912 (Print)
ISSN 2622-3813 (Online) p
DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.33330/jurdimas.v6i2.1966
I
Available online at https://jurnal.stmikroyal.ac.id/index.php/jurdimas UK. J. Small Business Enterprise
Development. mendapatkan margin keuntungan yang
jauh lebih besar dari pada jika lele ter-
sebut langsung dijual mentah. Pengabdi
memberikan gambaran mengenai produk-
produk yang bisa dibuat dari bahan dasar
lele, yaitu abon lele, keripik kulit lele,
stik tulang lele dan nuget lele. Jianmu Ye; Kulathunga. (2019). How
Does Financial Literacy Promote
Sustainability in SMEs? A Devel-
oping Country Perspective. Sus-
tainability. Khan, N.U.; Li, S.; Safdar, M.N.; Khan,
Z.U. (2019). The Role of Entrepre-
neurial Strategy, Network Ties,
Human and Financial Capital in
New Venture Performance. J. Risk
Financ. Manag. SIMPULAN Kegiatan
pengabdian
kepada
masyarakat
ini
memberikan
manfat
kepada Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan
Mina Lestari yaitu peningkatan skill da-
lam pembuatan laporan keuangan. Selain
itu kegiatan pengabdian ini juga membu-
ka peluang pengembangan usaha melalui
pengolahan
produk
pasca
panen. Pengabdian ini juga membuka akses ke
permodalan usaha yang bekerjasama
dengan Bank
BPD
DIY. Kegiatan
pengabdian ini berjalan dengan lancar
karena partisipasi aktif dari semua pihak,
baik dari tim pengabdi, mitra pengabdi
Kelompok Pembudidaya Ikan Mina Les-
tari maupun dari pemerintah daerah
setempat. Kristanto, H. (2022). The Role of Finan-
cial Literacy, Access to Finance,
Financial Risk Attitude on Finan-
cial Performance. Study on SMEs
Jogjakarta. Jurnal Keuangan dan
Perbankan, 805-819. Pasaribu, Marsaulina P.L. & Asep Su-
herman. (2021). Analysis of Fi-
nancial Statements Small and Me-
dium Enterprises Based on SAK –
ETAP. Journal of Industrial Engi-
neering & Management Research. Purnomo, B.R. (2019). Artistic orienta-
tion, financial literacy and entre-
preneurial performance. J. Enterp. Communities People Places Glob. Econ. PEMBAHASAN Penghitungan laba rugi tersebut
seperti tampak pada gambar 4 dibawah
ini. Gambar 5. Kolam Bp. Wasgi Gambar 5. Kolam Bp. Wasgi Praktik penghitungan ini dimulai
dari penebaran bibit lele pertama kali
pada bulan Juni sampai dengan panen
pada akhir Agustus. Perhitungan harga
pokok produksi ini dilakukan pada 1.000
ekor lele dengan ukuran bibit lele 5-7cm
dengan masa panen kurang lebih 3 bulan. Penghitungan harga pokok produksi dan
pembuatan laporan laba rugi dilakukan
secara bersama-sama antara pengabdi
dengan anggota Kelompok Pembudidaya
Ikan Mina Lestari. Praktik penghitungan ini dimulai
dari penebaran bibit lele pertama kali
pada bulan Juni sampai dengan panen
pada akhir Agustus. Perhitungan harga
pokok produksi ini dilakukan pada 1.000
ekor lele dengan ukuran bibit lele 5-7cm
dengan masa panen kurang lebih 3 bulan. Gambar 4. Laporan Laba Rugi
Penjualan
2,340,000
Rp
Harga pokok produksi
1,353,000
Rp
Laba kotor
987,000
Biaya usaha
Biaya listrik
26,283
Rp
Biaya penyusutan kolam
27,500
Rp
Biaya penyusutan peralatan
4,417
Rp
Kerugian pemeliharaan
36,000
Rp
94,200
Rp
892,800
LAPORAN LABA RUGI
LABA BERSIH Gambar 4. Laporan Laba Rugi
Penjualan
2,340,000
Rp
Harga pokok produksi
1,353,000
Rp
Laba kotor
987,000
Biaya usaha
Biaya listrik
26,283
Rp
Biaya penyusutan kolam
27,500
Rp
Biaya penyusutan peralatan
4,417
Rp
Kerugian pemeliharaan
36,000
Rp
94,200
Rp
892,800
LAPORAN LABA RUGI
LABA BERSIH Gambar 4. Laporan Harga Pokok
Produksi
250,000
Rp
125,000
Rp
480,000
Rp
50,000
Rp
Total biaya bahan baku
905,000
Rp
360,000
Rp
Total biaya tenaga kerja langsung
360,000
Rp
55,000
Rp
24,000
Rp
9,000
Rp
88,000
Rp
1,353,000
Rp
Biaya bahan baku
Biaya Tenaga Kerja Langsung
Biaya Overhead Pabrik
Air
Tenaga kerja
Vitamin
Probiotik EM4
Garam krosok
Total biaya overhead pabrik
HARGA POKOK PRODUKSI
LAPORAN HARGA POKOK PRODUKSI
Bibit Lele 1.000 ekor
Pakan Ikan PF 1.000
Pakan Ikan Alternatif Pengabdi
memberikan
pema-
haman bahwa laporan keuangan yang
sudah dibuat terbebut bisa digunakan
untuk mengakses pendanaan dari sector
perbankan. Peningkatan modal diharap-
kan
akan
meningkatkan
kapasitas
produksi yang pada akhirnya mampu
meningkatkan
keuntungan. Pengabdi
selanjutnya
memberikan
pengetahuan
mengenai
pengolahan
pasca
panen. Pengolahan pasca panen merupakan
pengolahan lele setelah dipanen untuk Gambar 4 merupakan gambar
laporan harga pokok produksi dengan
komposisi dasar biaya bahan baku, biaya
tenaga kerja langsung dan biaya overhead
pabrik. Biaya bahan baku merupakan 299 Jurdimas (Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat) Royal
Vol. 6 No. 2, April 2023, hlm. DAFTAR PUSTAKA Yakob, et. al. (2021). Financial Literacy
and
Financial
Performance
of
Small and Medium-sized Enter-
prises. The South East Asian Jour-
nal of Management. Buchari
Alma
(2018). Manajemen
Pemasaran & Pemasaran Jasa. Bandung: Alfabeta. Eniola, A.A.; Entebang, H. (2017). SME
managers and financial literacy. Glob. Bus. Rev.18, 559–576. Yang, Y.; Chen, X.; Gu, J.; Fujita, H. (2019). Alleviating Financing Con-
straints of SMEs through Supply
Chain. Sustainability Gary Vaynerchuk (2020). Crushing It!. Jakarta: PT Gramedia Pustaka
Utama. Ying, Q.; Hassan, H.; Ahmad, H. (2019). The role of a manager’s intangible
capabilities in resource acquisition
and sustainable competitive per-
formance. Sustainability. 11, 527. Hussain, J.; Salia, S.; Karim, A. (2018) Is
knowledge that powerful? Finan-
cial literacy and access to finance:
An analysis of enterprises in the 300
|
https://openalex.org/W4293758605
|
https://www.shs-conferences.org/10.1051/shsconf/202214501028/pdf
|
English
| null |
Research on the improvement of engineering college students’ artistic accomplishment under the new engineering background
|
SHS web of conferences
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 2,524
|
1 The connotation of new engineering New engineering is a higher education reform plan with Chinese characteristics in
response to the global situation, the development situation of domestic engineering
education and the service of national strategy. New engineering mainly includes three
aspects: first, the transformation and upgrading of traditional engineering; The second is the
new engineering specialty that faces the new economy; 3 it is the new major that points to
engineering course and other discipline cross generation. Guided by virtue and cultivating
talents, the company cultivates diversified and innovative outstanding engineering talents in
the future through inheritance and innovation, crossover and integration, coordination and
sharing. Research on the improvement of engineering
college students' artistic accomplishment under
the new engineering background Dongmei Fan*
Shandong Xiehe University, Yaoqiang Town, Licheng District, Jinan City China Shandong Xiehe University, Yaoqiang Town, Licheng District, Jinan City China Abstract. The new engineering is the product of interdisciplinary,
breaking through the institutional bottleneck and administrative barriers in
universities in interdisciplinary, is the new engineering must cross a barrier. Based on the construction of new engineering, this paper promotes the
deep cross and integration of engineering and art disciplines. To explore
the ways to integrate innovative thinking training into professional
education systematically from the aspects of research significance,
research status, development plan and effect evaluation, so as to improve
the artistic accomplishment of engineering college students. SHS Web of Conferences 145, 01028 (2022)
AEME2022 SHS Web of Conferences 145, 01028 (2022)
AEME2022 https://doi.org/10.1051/shsconf/202214501028 * Corresponding author: fandongmei5238@163.com © The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). 3 Significance of research on the improvement of new
engineering college students' artistic accomplishment In the context of new engineering, new requirements are put forward for the quality of new
engineering talents, among which the imagination/innovation of engineering students is
particularly important. Improving the artistic quality of engineering students plays a very
important role in improving these abilities. Based on the current academic
background/artistic foundation of engineering students, the training of creative thinking is
integrated into professional education. To enable students to grow into professionals who
understand both technology and art and have trans-boundary cognition of "science and
technology aesthetics". At the same time, the intervention of creative thinking training also
makes the knowledge structure of engineering students richer, which also happens to
coincide with the current training of new engineering talents. 2 The lack of artistic innovative thinking of new engineering
college students The depth and breadth of art practice are not enough in the training programs of
engineering students in domestic universities. As a result, college students do not know
what is the beauty of art and what can meet the public aesthetic taste, leading to the
disconnection between technology and design. Engineering and art are not opposed to each other, and there will be no gap in
professional integration. Inevitably, engineering students are relatively weak in art
foundation, but when they finish some basic art-related theories and majors, they will ignite * Corresponding author: fandongmei5238@163.com © The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). SHS Web of Conferences 145, 01028 (2022)
AEME2022 https://doi.org/10.1051/shsconf/202214501028 their interest in art, and interest-based learning will have original self-drive. In the process
of training students, it is also necessary to apply science and engineering knowledge and
creative art theory to practice, so as to cultivate the cognition of the intersection of
technology and creativity. their interest in art, and interest-based learning will have original self-drive. In the process
of training students, it is also necessary to apply science and engineering knowledge and
creative art theory to practice, so as to cultivate the cognition of the intersection of
technology and creativity. 4 Research status of the improvement of new engineering
college students' artistic accomplishment Since some foreign art colleges and engineering colleges began to design digital media
education in the mid-1990s, after more than 20 years of changes, especially with the
development of computer, Internet and other technologies and the advent of the digital era,
the current combination of engineering and art education at home and abroad is developing
rapidly. It has the dual characteristics of engineering and art, and integrates different
disciplines such as technology and art, media and culture, digital and design. In February 2017, the Ministry of Education issued a notice on The Development of
New Engineering Research and Practice, aiming at the urgent need of current and future
industrial development to promote the cross-fitting of existing engineering and engineering
with other disciplines. Break the barrier of the discipline, complete curriculum integration,
the key lies in the diversity of courses and knowledge system, take the student as the main
body, let the students receive diversity of knowledge and information, pay attention to the
practice of the art, the transition, the pragmatism of art courses, reduce the cultivation of the
art in the areas of background knowledge, make course subject, strengthen the theoretical
education and design practice, The depth, professionalism and practicality of art courses
will be increased, from cross-boundary general knowledge to cross-boundary knowledge,
and finally cross-boundary practice will be realized. 6 Carry out the plan to improve artistic accomplishment under
the new engineering background 6.1 Take morality as the priority, focus on the top-level design of artistic
accomplishment promotion activities, improve the cultural and art practice
development system, and create a scientific platform for cultural and art
practice development The top-level design of artistic accomplishment promotion is the premise of doing well in
activities, which mainly includes the establishment of artistic accomplishment promotion
system, management system, incentive system, activity content setting and so on. The top-
level design should be based on moral cultivation, according to the actual situation of new
engineering, combined with the teaching curriculum system of quality-oriented education
and the characteristics of students, to form a complete, detailed, scientific and practical
scheme in line with the school, and apply it to practical work. At the same time, the improvement of artistic literacy should focus on the design of the
expansion plan for the improvement of artistic literacy by integrating and summarizing
existing resources, combining with the teaching planning of school quality education and
the deficiency in talent training. Art literacy promotion activities should be carried out
closely around the curriculum construction, which is an extension and expansion of cultural
art practice courses, but also a summary and verification. Therefore, schools should timely
combine talent training programs, sort out the existing art literacy promotion activities, and
set up art practice activities in a scientific way and a systematic way to make them
scientific and advanced. 5 The overall goal of improving artistic accomplishment under
the new engineering background The development of the series of activities to improve artistic literacy, centered on the
cultivation of high-quality talents, based on the characteristics of the school itself, relying
on a sound implementation system, scientific system, deeply attract the attention and
participation of all teachers and students of the school. With the rich content and form of
cultural and artistic practice activities, relying on its positive ideology and innovation, it
promotes the development of quality education and teaching in schools, improves the 2 SHS Web of Conferences 145, 01028 (2022)
AEME2022 https://doi.org/10.1051/shsconf/202214501028 quality of school personnel training, and cultivates comprehensive talents. At the same time,
the establishment of evaluation and feedback system, to establish a systematic and
standardized art literacy promotion activities as the standard, in the same colleges,
nationwide promotion, evaluation, so that it serves the campus culture construction, talent
comprehensive quality training. quality of school personnel training, and cultivates comprehensive talents. At the same time,
the establishment of evaluation and feedback system, to establish a systematic and
standardized art literacy promotion activities as the standard, in the same colleges,
nationwide promotion, evaluation, so that it serves the campus culture construction, talent
comprehensive quality training. 6.3 Innovate the form of activities, enrich the content of activities, improve
the school's artistic accomplishment and enhance the overall level of
activities. Quality art literacy promotion activities can broaden students' horizons, mobilize their
potential interests, and improve their cultural and artistic literacy. The innovation of activity
forms and the enrichment of content should also follow a certain system and mechanism
and develop in a scientific and healthy direction. The improvement of artistic accomplishment is a process for students to practice, learn
and improve themselves in cultural and art activities. Activities should cover traditional
Chinese culture, history, philosophy, art, science and other aspects of multi-disciplinary
content, should not stay in the shallow level of literary activities. Universities such as
Tsinghua university, Fudan university in Shanghai, Zhengzhou sustained over the years,
such as "reading classics" series activities, cultural quality of students in reading and
writing set up the correct moral values, the outlook on life, the feeling of Chinese
traditional culture essence, enrich students' culture, cultivating students' elegant
temperament, build school humanities atmosphere, at the same time promoting quality-
oriented education teaching achievements. Therefore, colleges and universities should often
organize teachers to investigate and study, to share the latest progress and excellent results
of talent training in the way of communication, broaden ideas, improve deficiencies, and
comprehensively improve the level of national culture and art practice and development
activities. 6.4 Develop a complete evaluation system for the promotion of artistic
literacy activities to achieve systematic and standardized management. Nowadays, many colleges and universities, in addition to the youth League committee,
cultural quality education base, student office, various departments, student associations are
holding different lines of color, a variety of student activities. Art literacy promotion
activities, different from other student activities, should have planning, curriculum and
continuity. However, so far, many schools have not developed the relevant activity
evaluation system, responsible for the overall management of cultural and artistic activities,
and there are no unified standards and regulations as a reference. Evaluation system should accumulate through long-term practice, combining study,
research, and to explore, develop directional, representative, directivity, evaluation system
of culture and art activities, covering arts and culture perspective, creativity, artistic level,
participation in scope, influence such as evaluation content, combined with the talent
training schools focus on the direction, set the impact factor, one by one, grade evaluation,
Promote high quality student activities, eliminate backward cultural and artistic practice
activities one by one, so that they are more systematic and standardized, and can better
serve campus cultural construction and education. 6.2 Formulate a scientific management system, increase the benefits of
cultural quality education and teaching, and increase its radiation. Cultural quality education cannot be separated from students. Likewise, artistic quality
improvement activities cannot be separated from the participation of students, especially
teachers. The school should formulate the relevant system scientifically, let more people
participate in the activities through standardized management, broaden the radiation of
cultural quality education and teaching, increase the benefit of cultural quality education
and teaching. The establishment of the management system of cultural practice and art activities in
colleges and universities should have the characteristics of the school, centering on the style
of running the school and the characteristics of students, combining the actual resources of
the school, the direction of talent training and social needs, and formulate scientifically. In
the process of establishing the system, we should pay attention to the responsibilities and
obligations of the school staff, especially the student counselors, and organize and guide
students to participate in the cultural activities of quality education in a systematic,
standardized and planned way with teachers as the starting point. To ensure the smooth
development of cultural and artistic practice activities, effectively enhance the benefit of
cultural quality education and teaching. 3 3 SHS Web of Conferences 145, 01028 (2022)
AEME2022 https://doi.org/10.1051/shsconf/202214501028 6.3 Innovate the form of activities, enrich the content of activities, improve
the school's artistic accomplishment and enhance the overall level of
activities. 6.5 Rely on art quality promotion activities, integrate artistic talents, cultivate
comprehensive talents. For many years, engineering universities have been faced with such problems as
insufficient cultural and artistic resources, lack of artistic talents and lack of campus
cultural and artistic atmosphere. Through the development of art literacy promotion
activities, high-quality cultural and artistic talents of the school can be excavated, so that
they can better play their strengths, and promote the overall cultural and artistic atmosphere
of the school. At the same time, the university of engineering should formulate the 4 4 4 SHS Web of Conferences 145, 01028 (2022)
AEME2022 https://doi.org/10.1051/shsconf/202214501028 cultivation mode and management mode of art talents suitable for the university, and build
the related management system and training scheme for the backbone students of art and art,
so as to make the art talents grow better. cultivation mode and management mode of art talents suitable for the university, and build
the related management system and training scheme for the backbone students of art and art,
so as to make the art talents grow better. 7 Evaluation of the effect of improving artistic accomplishment
under the background of new engineering Art literacy promotion activities are more likely to be accepted by engineering students who
lack art foundation. At the same time, integrating a relatively new teaching method into the
teaching process is conducive to arousing students' interest in learning and expanding the
number of engineering students who are effectively influenced by art. Using the course
design in class and the practice after class, it promotes the improvement of engineering
college students' imagination/innovation ability. To sum up, an innovative talent training path with the construction of new engineering
as the main body, strengthening the crossover and integration of different disciplines and
majors, promoting the combination of art and engineering disciplines, taking "art science
and technology" and "science and technology art" as two wings, and cultivating diversified,
compound and high-quality talents. Project: his paper is "Integration of "engineering and Art" -- Research on the improvement of
engineering college students' artistic accomplishment under the new engineering perspective ",
Shandong Province art Education special project Project number: L2021Y10290366 References 1. Li Meiyan." "Integration of engineering and Art" -- Research on the Improvement of
engineering college students' artistic accomplishment under the new engineering
Background. Journal of Liaoning University of Science and Technology [J]. 2019(21):
5-86. 2. Wang Yongjie. Construction and effect of "Five-in-one" Public art Innovation
education system for engineering. Experimental Technology and Management [J]. 2020(6):225-227. 3. Ai Zhuo, Jiang Kang. Research on the Integration of culture, art and technology [J]. Research on Art Education. 2019(5):54-56. 4. Li Zhengliang, New engineering specialty Construction: Connotation, Path and
training mode [J]. Higher Engineering Education Research, 2018. (4): 87-88.] 5. Xia Jianguo, Zhao Jun. Higher Engineering Education Research, 2017(3): 48-49. (in
Chinese) 6. Wang Haimei, Xuesong, Xu Muxun. Experimental Technology and Management,
2019, 36(5): 28 -- 32, 41. 7. Yang Wenxie. Research on the value significance and construction path of public art
education in the new era in universities' Moral cultivation [J]. Hundred Schools of Art,
2019, 35(2): 78 -- 81, 87. 8. Wang Yue. Experimental Education Research of Art and Design Education in
Engineering University [J]. Fine Arts Education Research, 2020(3):156-157. 5 5
|
https://openalex.org/W2730138546
|
https://researchonline.gcu.ac.uk/files/25096062/Are_HIV_Smartphone_APPS_Online_Int_Fit_for_Purpose.pdf
|
English
| null |
Are HIV Smartphone Apps and Online Interventions Fit for Purpose?
| null | 2,017
|
cc-by
| 11,323
|
re HIV smartphone apps and online interventions fit for purpose? Are HIV smartphone apps and online interventions fit for purpose? Singh, Aneesha; Gibbs, Jo; Estcourt, Claudia; Sonnerberg, Pam; Blandford, An Published in:
Proceedings of the 2017 International Conference on Digital Health Published in:
Proceedings of the 2017 International Conference on Digital Health DOI:
10.1145/3079452.3079469 Document Version
Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Link to publication in ResearchOnline Link to publication in ResearchOnline Citation for published version (Harvard):
Singh, A, Gibbs, J, Estcourt, C, Sonnerberg, P & Blandford, A 2017, Are HIV smartphone apps and online
interventions fit for purpose? in Proceedings of the 2017 International Conference on Digital Health. Association
for Computing Machinery (ACM), pp. 6-15. https://doi.org/10.1145/3079452.3079469 CCS CONCEPTS • CCS → Human-centered computing → Human computer
interaction (HCI) → HCI design and evaluation methods The number of people accessing health related information
online is increasing, as indicated by the increasing number of
health related app downloads [4]. However, there is currently
little evidence on the quality of information on HIV and other
sexually transmitted infections (STIs) available via online
resources [5]. In addition, novel HIV diagnostic tests combined
with advances in digital health provide new opportunities for
people to self-sample, self-test, and receive a diagnosis remote
from traditional health care services [6]. These advances need to
be integrated with services (online or otherwise) to support
people and link them to care. KEYWORDS: m-health; HIV; human immunodeficiency
virus; user needs; qualitative research; mobile applications;
sexual health; sexually transmitted diseases Are HIV Smartphone Apps and Online Interventions
Fit for Purpose? Fit for Purpose? Aneesha Singh1 Jo Gibbs2 Claudia Estcourt3 Pam Sonnenberg2 Ann Blandford1
1 UCL Interaction Centre 2 Research Department of Infection and Population Health 3 School of Health & Life Science
1,2 University College London, UK; 3 Glasgow Caledonian University, UK
{aneesha.singh, jo.gibbs, p.sonnenberg, a.blandford}@ucl.ac.uk; claudia.estcourt@gcu.ac.uk Aneesha Singh1 Jo Gibbs2 Claudia Estcourt3 Pam Sonnenberg2 Ann Blandford1
1 UCL Interaction Centre 2 Research Department of Infection and Population Health 3 School of Health & Life Science
1,2 University College London, UK; 3 Glasgow Caledonian University, UK
{aneesha.singh, jo.gibbs, p.sonnenberg, a.blandford}@ucl.ac.uk; claudia.estcourt@gcu.ac.uk ABSTRACT HIV
weakens
the
ability
of
a
person
to
fight
infections/diseases by targeting the immune system. However,
early diagnosis of HIV coupled with effective antiretroviral
therapy (ART) can mean that people have an almost normal life
expectancy and a very low risk of transmitting the virus to
others. Therefore, early HIV diagnosis is critical for better
outcomes and to prevent onward transmission. Diagnosis of HIV
at a late stage of infection (39% of new diagnoses in 2015 [1,2]), is
associated with a much poorer prognosis, and increases the
potential of inadvertent transmission. A significant proportion
of people at risk of HIV have not tested for HIV in the preceding
12 months [2] and a concerning proportion of people living with
HIV remain undiagnosed. The WHO cites stigma and fear of
discrimination as the main reasons for people’s reluctance to get
tested, disclose their HIV status and take antiretroviral therapy
(ART) [3]. Online HIV interventions offer anonymity and could
break down the barriers to HIV prevention, testing and
management. Existing HIV mobile health (m-health) initiatives
include prevention messages, results notification, and improved
ART adherence/ management [7,11] to overcome barriers and
enable retention in healthcare. We want to understand how
online technology can deliver advances in diagnosis and
prevention, and support users based on needs at different stages
of the pathway. Sexual health is an under-explored area of Human-Computer
Interaction (HCI), particularly sexually transmitted infections
such as HIV. Due to the stigma associated with these infections,
people are often motivated to seek information online. With the
rise of smartphone and web apps, there is enormous potential for
technology to provide easily accessible information and
resources. However, using online information raises important
concerns about the trustworthiness of these resources and
whether they are fit for purpose. We conducted a review of
smartphone and web apps to investigate the landscape of
currently available online apps and whether they meet the
diverse needs of people seeking information on HIV online. Our
functionality
review
revealed
that
existing
technology
interventions have a one-size-fits-all approach and do not
support the breadth and complexity of HIV-related support
needs. We argue that technology-based interventions need to
signpost their offering and provide tailored support for different
stages of HIV, including prevention, testing, diagnosis and
management. Permission to make digital or hard copies of part or all of this work for personal or
classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed
for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full
citation on the first page. Copyrights for third-party components of this work must be
honored. For all other uses, contact the Owner/Author.
DH '17, July 02-05, 2017, London, United Kingdom
© 2017 Copyright is held by the owner/author(s).
ACM ISBN 978-1-4503-5249-9/17/07.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/3079452.3079469 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution International 4.0
License. General rights
C
i ht
d General rights
Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners
and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy
If you believe that this document breaches copyright please view our takedown policy at https://edshare.gcu.ac.uk/id/eprint/5179 for details
of how to contact us. Download date: 24. Oct. 2024 Download date: 24. Oct. 2024 1 INTRODUCTION There are approximately 101,200 people living with Human
Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) in the UK, of whom 13% are
unaware of their infection and at risk of unknowingly
transmitting the virus through unprotected sex [1,2]. In the UK,
95% of new HIV cases are due to sexual transmission [2]. HIV
prevalence is disproportionately higher in men who have sex
with men and Black African men and women than in other
groups [11]. In this paper, we focus on the potential for HCI to improve
the experiences of, and options available to, people accessing
HIV resources online. To this end, we started by conducting an
autoethnography to identify issues in approaching online sources
for HIV related information and support (Study 1). Following
this, we investigated how existing online HIV apps and
interventions address the needs of people and leverage the
opportunities provided by technology (Study 2). This was
achieved through a review of web and smartphone apps available
to support HIV. An evaluation was conducted of features and
functionality offered by the apps. Finally, we investigated user
impressions of the apps using online reviews of the smartphone
apps to identify the gaps and needs from technology (Study 3). This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution International 4.0
License. Permission to make digital or hard copies of part or all of this work for personal or
classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed
for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full
citation on the first page. Copyrights for third-party components of this work must be
honored. For all other uses, contact the Owner/Author. DH '17, July 02-05, 2017, London, United Kingdom
© 2017 Copyright is held by the owner/author(s). ACM ISBN 978-1-4503-5249-9/17/07. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/3079452.3079469 Our paper makes three contributions: first, we disentangle the
different aspects of the HIV pathway and identify the various
aspects of HIV care, and hence target audiences for the different
technologies. Second, through three qualitative studies, we
identify the currently available technology and the strengths as
well as gaps in designing for the HIV pathway, based on features
available and desirable functionalities. Finally, we make
recommendations for developing this area of research in HCI. identified as being at high risk of being infected may benefit from
behavioural interventions and should have regular testing for HIV
and other STIs. 1.3 Using Online Resources Internet access and advances in web and smartphone
capabilities have brought new opportunities and challenges. Social
and sexual networking sites have seen increased access: more than
70% of online adults use one of the social networking sites, and
over half of them use multiple sites [9]. Recently many apps for
dating and sexual hook-ups have become available and some
studies indicate that the incidence of HIV and STIs has increased as
a consequence [10, 11]. However, the uptake of sexual health apps
is still low as they are negatively received by users and have failed
to attract user attention [12]. While reviews of apps and other
technologies designed for STIs have been conducted (e.g. [5,13]),
these either do not specifically target HIV or do not discuss
whether the available technologies meet the needs of the target
users. Furthermore, the landscape of both smartphone ownership
and number and type of apps available has changed dramatically
since these reviews were conducted [4]. For example, the number
of dating apps for people with HIV has gone up from one reported
in 2013 [13], to at least 12 found in the search for this review. 1.1 About HIV HIV weakens a person’s ability to fight infections and diseases as
it targets the immune system. The commonest mode of
transmitting HIV is having sex without a condom [7]. It can also
be transmitted via sharing needles, through transfusion of
infected blood products, and from mother-to-child during
pregnancy. There is no cure for HIV; however, since highly
active antiretroviral therapy was introduced in 1996, the life
expectancy of people diagnosed with HIV has dramatically
improved. To achieve better treatment outcomes and to prevent
onward transmission, early diagnosis of HIV is critical. If a
person with HIV is untreated then they are at risk of serious
infections and cancers, which someone with a healthy immune
system would fight off. Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome
(AIDS) is defined as when a person with HIV has such an
impaired immune system that they develop any of more than 20
opportunistic infections or HIV-related cancers [7]. Table 1: Functionality accessed by people online based on their
HIV status and if they have been diagnosed. People living with
HIV are referred to as HIV+. People not diagnosed with HIV
are referred to as HIV-. Table 1: Functionality accessed by people online based on their
HIV status and if they have been diagnosed. People living with
HIV are referred to as HIV+. People not diagnosed with HIV
are referred to as HIV-. Table 1: Functionality accessed by people online based on their
HIV status and if they have been diagnosed. People living with
HIV are referred to as HIV+. People not diagnosed with HIV
are referred to as HIV-. It is common for people to feel distressed and experience
feelings of anxiety and depression when diagnosed with HIV [8]. It is important that people have timely access to information and
support they need. There continues to be stigma attached to HIV,
which can act as a barrier to effective prevention and treatment
of HIV/AIDS. 1 INTRODUCTION They can also be prescribed daily ART (pre-
exposure prophylaxis (PrEP)) to prevent them being infected with
HIV. People diagnosed as HIV positive, and therefore living with a
chronic infection, may need support with managing their
condition
through
monitoring
appointments,
medication
reminders, information on test results, medication side effects,
notification of their status to partners, testing for other STIs and
psychological support. In assessing HIV apps, it is necessary to
evaluate fitness for purpose for any or all these situations. 1.2 HIV Pathway of Care There are a variety of reasons why people access online HIV
resources. We divided the search for online resources into two
broad categories: pre-test and post-test (see Table 1). At the pre-
test stage, people may be looking for, or be directed by healthcare
professionals towards, information on HIV prevention and safe
sex, and to check their risk of being infected by HIV. People may
also use online resources to access information about testing
following a recent unprotected sexual encounter. They may be
seeking a local sexual health clinic or for kits to test themselves. Two types of remote testing options are available: (1) self-
sampling (blood or saliva), where the person obtains their own
sample and posts it to a laboratory for testing, or (ii) self-testing
(blood), where a person takes their own sample and tests it
themselves with a test kit which takes around 15 minutes to give
results. The laboratory test used with a blood self-sampling kit
gives accurate results at a month post exposure; self-testing kits
and self-sampling kits with a sample of saliva, may not detect
infection acquired within the past 3 months. For both types of
tests, people must have another test in a clinical setting to confirm
a positive result. Widespread access to the Internet and the many web and
smartphone apps available mean there is the potential to reduce
the gaps in HIV prevention, testing and management. Existing m-
Health prevention and management initiatives for HIV include
promotional prevention messages, test result notification, and
improvement to adherence for anti-retroviral therapy (ART) and
management [13, 14]. While phone-based interventions for HIV
have mainly utilised voice or text messaging (SMS) functions,
smartphones are capable of delivering more complex, interactive,
and tailored interventions via mobile web and native apps [13, 14]. In cases of possible exposure to HIV, people can be prescribed
post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP), which must be started within 72
hours of the exposure. People who are HIV negative but who are For people who encounter barriers to care, such apps could enable
entry to and retention in the healthcare system. the development of online results and management pathway for
HIV. A scenario of looking for information on HIV testing and
symptoms following an unprotected sexual encounter was used to
look for information on the web and through apps in the UK Apple
iTunes
Store
(www.apple.com/itunes/)
and
Google
Play
(play.google.com/store/apps). 2 RESEARCH AIMS AND METHODS To understand the landscape of existing technology for HIV, we
conducted a review of current trends and available resources in
online and mobile health technologies for primary, secondary and
tertiary HIV prevention, testing and management. We conducted
the three studies that we report next: Lack of tailoring and transparency f
g
p
y
Often the content and risk assessment questions were not filtered
depending on gender and sexual preference. While the need for
direct language and questions is necessary in asking people what
kind of sexual activity they have performed to inform a future
course of action, the questions could have been more tailored to
the sexual orientation and preferences of the individual. For
example, it is unnecessary to ask explicit questions about sexual
activity between men and women to a man who only has sex with
men to determine HIV risk. Instances where apps and websites did
not make this distinction could be off-putting and erode trust in
the results that the site provided. In some cases of risk analysis
apps, it was not obvious how they calculated the risk of infection
and many of the apps were scaremongering (e.g., Figure 1 - Right,
Middle). Public use. HIV app icons and names were not discreet. Some HIV-related
apps and websites had explicit images or content that came up
without warning, causing embarrassment at times. The presence of
the obvious HIV app icon on the researcher’s screen became a
point of conversation. The researcher also felt uncomfortable using
HIV apps when on public transport where she often uses her
phone otherwise for finding information or to access social media
because they were not discreet. 2.1.1 Findings. The researcher started by searching on Google using phrases such
as “could I have HIV?”, and “testing options for HIV”. Most search
results were known healthcare sites such as NHS choices or clinic-
based testing sites. One striking aspect of the search was the
number of promotional links that appeared when searching for
HIV testing, most of which linked to the sites selling HIV self-
testing or self-sampling kits. When searching for HIV testing on
the app stores, the most relevant apps that appeared were risk
calculators and symptom checkers for HIV. None of the apps
linked to provision of self-sampling or self-testing sites or kits. However, some GPS-based apps allowed the user to locate a local
testing facility. HIV remains a stigmatised chronic condition. HCI research
investigating the design of technologies for chronic conditions
suggests that user needs for technologies supporting chronic
disease differ based on the level of stigma [20]. HIV is under-
researched in HCI [21]; while recent research has emerged on
managing HIV [12, 22], medication adherence, and support for
tracking personal health information [23], barriers affecting
adoption of such technologies such as privacy, security, and trust
have been ignored [20, 24]. As an interdisciplinary field, HCI is in a
good position to develop for, evaluate and create real impact on
sexual health and HIV. 1.2 HIV Pathway of Care As an interdisciplinary field, HCI is in a
good position to develop for, evaluate and create real impact on
sexual health and HIV. In addition to designing technologies that target different parts
of the pathway, consideration is needed towards other needs and
behaviours related with privacy, security, and trust in designing
for sensitive issues such as HIV and other aspects of sexual health
and STIs. However, we found that there is a general dearth of
research addressing these areas [16, 17]. Recent work in HCI has
explored many traditionally sensitive areas including intimate care
of women’s bodies [18] and made contributions on the topic of sex
in divere contexts such as virtual worlds, online pornography, or
human-robot interaction [19] but has largely ignored sexual health. 1.2 HIV Pathway of Care The
study
focused
on
the
impressions that the online material made on the researcher. Advances are also being made in technologies for testing and
diagnosing HIV. Researchers are creating the first smartphone
accessories that will enable people to self-test for HIV just using
their phones [15]. Licensed HIV self-testing kits, available in the
UK since 2014, give a diagnosis in 15 minutes but are not available
via the National Health Service and do not link people with
specialist care and healthcare resources for counselling and
support. Studies report anxiety, depression and social isolation
following a diagnosis [8]. There is therefore a need to understand
how technology can deliver not only advances in diagnosis and
prevention but also emotional support and management. These
needs can differ at different stages of the pathway. Guided by discussions with a sexual health clinical academic
(second author), the researcher carried out this study over a period
of a week. The study was designed based on first encounters with
materials related to HIV on the web and was more exploratory in
nature compared with the functionality reviews of apps that were
conducted later. The researcher carried out a thematic analysis of
diary entries and screenshots. This engagement allowed the
researcher to gain an understanding of online resources for HIV. In addition to designing technologies that target different parts
of the pathway, consideration is needed towards other needs and
behaviours related with privacy, security, and trust in designing
for sensitive issues such as HIV and other aspects of sexual health
and STIs. However, we found that there is a general dearth of
research addressing these areas [16, 17]. Recent work in HCI has
explored many traditionally sensitive areas including intimate care
of women’s bodies [18] and made contributions on the topic of sex
in divere contexts such as virtual worlds, online pornography, or
human-robot interaction [19] but has largely ignored sexual health. HIV remains a stigmatised chronic condition. HCI research
investigating the design of technologies for chronic conditions
suggests that user needs for technologies supporting chronic
disease differ based on the level of stigma [20]. HIV is under-
researched in HCI [21]; while recent research has emerged on
managing HIV [12, 22], medication adherence, and support for
tracking personal health information [23], barriers affecting
adoption of such technologies such as privacy, security, and trust
have been ignored [20, 24]. 2.1 An auto-ethnography style self-observation The first study was conducted using autoethnographic methods,
using self-observation with the first author as participant [25, 26],
to experience the process of accessing HIV related information. This method was adopted for three reasons: (i) to familiarise the
researcher with HIV related resources, (ii) to empathise with
experiences of users in different and difficult to access contexts
when using online HIV resources, and (iii) to simulate how a
search for online resources might be conducted by a naïve user
who did not have experience of looking for this information. p
p
g
This method was adopted for three reasons: (i) to familiarise the
researcher with HIV related resources, (ii) to empathise with
experiences of users in different and difficult to access contexts
when using online HIV resources, and (iii) to simulate how a
search for online resources might be conducted by a naïve user
who did not have experience of looking for this information. The researcher does not have HIV and identifies as a
heterosexual female in a long-term relationship. She had not used
online resources to conduct a focused search for information
related to HIV prior to this. The autoethnographic study was used
as a formative method to inform the design of further studies and When downloading HIV apps on the app store, many permissions
were required for downloads, particularly with the Google Play
store. Apps asked for permission to access identity, contacts, and sending SMS messages automatically and did not state what the
permission and access would be used for. Further, apps did not have
obvious links to healthcare providers. The researcher used a
department phone available to do the study rather than a private one,
as she did not want to expose her data or contacts. This is, however,
a choice that is not available to all users. In many cases, the window period for HIV testing (the time
between someone becoming infected with HIV and being able to
detect it in the saliva or blood) was not explained or in small print as
shown in the example in Figure 3. Consequently, a naïve user may
not get the help they need in making an informed choice about kits
and testing. Figure 1: (Left) Screenshot of app icons on the author’s home
screen. (Middle and Right) App screens showing results
from risk calculator apps. Figure 2: A screenshot from a site offering an HIV self-test
kit. The information that the kit will not detect infection
before 3 months since exposure is under the Further
Information link in blue on the left. Figure 2: A screenshot from a site offering an HIV self-test
kit. The information that the kit will not detect infection
before 3 months since exposure is under the Further
Information link in blue on the left. Stigma, language and general ignorance The researcher also examined the app descriptions before
downloading the apps and some of these showed ignorance about
HIV and stigma. One of the apps for HIV included in the
description, “If you think you have recently been close to someone
with HIV/ AIDS it is best to quarantine yourself faraway from other
people and call a nearby medical center/ doctor” Many prank HIV diagnosis apps (n=18) came up in the initial
search claiming to assess people by taking their fingerprints on the
screen as a method to test if they have HIV as a prank or joke. The
large number of downloads and positive reviews of these apps
working on people suggest that people found the apps credible. The researcher looked for HIV test kits on sites such as Amazon
while being logged into Google and Facebook. She had also looked
for a pair of shoes previously and added the two to a basket on
Amazon. While advertisements of shoes started appearing on her
profile on these sites, no HIV related information was targeted at
her. It appears that targeting based on sexual health is against policy. For example, Google’s personalised privacy policy says, “Because
we understand that sexual experiences and interests are inherently
private, we don’t allow categories related to sexual interests”,
which extends to sexual health. 2.1 An auto-ethnography style self-observation The user interfaces for the apps
show bad colour contrast (e.g., “83%” is barely visible in the
app on the left), and have distracting or provocative
background images. 2.1.2 Conclusions. Figure 1: (Left) Screenshot of app icons on the author’s home
screen. (Middle and Right) App screens showing results
from risk calculator apps. The user interfaces for the apps
show bad colour contrast (e.g., “83%” is barely visible in the
app on the left), and have distracting or provocative
background images. This study was helpful in gaining a first-hand understanding of the
types of online resources available and provided insight into the
issues in using them beyond functionality. Personalisation, privacy,
trust, jargon, stigma, lack of transparency and relevant information
to make informed choices were the main aspects that emerged. The
study gave insight into the challenges some users could face in using
these apps and online resources in different contexts and for
different reasons. In some cases, these resources could be
reinforcing stigma and ignorance of the condition. We are very
aware that the researcher in this study did not have HIV and
perceives herself at low risk of contracting it. However, we were
reflexive and ran the study from the point of view that anyone,
regardless of sex, sexuality, or general risk levels could have the
need to access HIV testing or information. We believe that this
method gave us valuable insights that will be useful in designing
further studies with the general and at-risk populations for accessing
these resources. As suggested by O’Kane et al. [26], who used
autoethnography to study medical device use, we are using this
study method as a first step to understand the online landscape of
HIV related resources from a user standpoint. From this scoping
review, we established inclusion and exclusion criteria for the
systematic review of web and smartphone applications to identify
the features that are offered and what is missing. The main category
of apps excluded at this stage was prank apps as they did not
provide health related information. Stigma, language and general ignorance Stigma, language and general ignorance Figure 3: Features in apps and websites. Blue lines show the percentage of smartphone apps with the feature listed on the y-axis.
Red lines show the websites with the corresponding feature in the y-axis. Figure 3: Features in apps and websites. Blue lines show the percentage of smartphone apps with the feature listed on the y-axis. Red lines show the websites with the corresponding feature in the y-axis. p
g
The search was conducted in August 2016. 683 smartphone apps
(296 for iPhones and 387 for Android phones) were returned. We
excluded apps if they did not have HIV content, targeted only
healthcare, medical, industry or research professionals, did not work
when downloaded, provided only information on conference
schedules and events, were fundraisers, if they were not available in
English or had not been updated in the last three years. “Casual”,
“Games” or “Entertainment” apps were included if they provided
information or resources for HIV per the app description. We
reviewed websites up to the first three pages of search results, as
most users do not go past the first three pages [27]. We conducted
more specific searches by adding the terms “prevention”, “testing”,
“management”, and “diagnosis”. 69 native apps (46 Android apps
and 23 iPhone apps) and 28 web-apps were selected as relevant. Before doing the main analysis, we prepared a list of features based
on the first 10 web apps and smartphone apps found in each store
and grouped the features into categories for easier data collection. We recorded feature categories for all apps (web and smartphone)
during initial data gathering. In addition, for smartphone apps we
recorded details including name of app, its user rating, number of
reviews by users, and age rating. Additional categories were created
when we encountered features that were missing in the original list. The search was conducted in August 2016. 683 smartphone apps
(296 for iPhones and 387 for Android phones) were returned. We
excluded apps if they did not have HIV content, targeted only
healthcare, medical, industry or research professionals, did not work
when downloaded, provided only information on conference
schedules and events, were fundraisers, if they were not available in
English or had not been updated in the last three years. “Casual”,
“Games” or “Entertainment” apps were included if they provided
information or resources for HIV per the app description. We
reviewed websites up to the first three pages of search results, as
most users do not go past the first three pages [27]. We conducted
more specific searches by adding the terms “prevention”, “testing”,
“management”, and “diagnosis”. Figure 3: Features in apps and websites. Blue lines show the percentage of smartphone apps with the feature listed on the y-axis.
Red lines show the websites with the corresponding feature in the y-axis. 69 native apps (46 Android apps
and 23 iPhone apps) and 28 web-apps were selected as relevant. Target audience Target audience
82.6% of the apps on the Google Play Store had a PEGI rating of 3,
considered a rating level where content is suitable for all age groups. 13% of apps were unrated and only two apps were rated 16. This is
surprising as some of the apps dealt with content more suited for
mature audiences. The iTunes Store was more discerning, with 30%
of apps rated 4+, 48% rated 12+ and the rest rated 17+. 37% of the
smartphone apps were classified as Medical apps, 32% as Health
and Fitness apps and 17% as Education. 2.2 Functionality Review of Existing Apps Many apps provide HIV prevention and care services via web and
smartphone applications and there is a wide range of features on
offer. We conducted a review of currently available apps with a
focus on their offered functionalities and features. Jargon and issues of trust
One of the challenges faced by the researcher was navigating
through a new set of acronyms, slang, and terminology. For
example, one of the apps was named Online Elisa test with the
description of the biomedical Elisa test from Wikipedia. However, it
was a risk calculator and made a diagnosis based on sexual
behaviour questions, completely unrelated to the biomedical test. Further, the test used incorrect terminology such as “risk of AIDS”
instead of “risk of HIV”. Such apps can be misleading for users,
particularly those who are vulnerable. 2.2.1 Method. We searched for HIV-related web-apps using Google search. For
smartphone apps, UK Apple iTunes (/www.apple.com/itunes/) and
Google Play (play.google.com/store/apps) stores were searched
using the keywords: HIV, human immunodeficiency virus, acquired
immunodeficiency syndrome, and AIDS. Figure 3: Features in apps and websites. Blue lines show the percentage of smartphone apps with the feature listed on the y-axis. Red lines show the websites with the corresponding feature in the y axis Figure 3: Features in apps and websites. Blue lines show the percentage of smartphone apps with the feature listed on the y-ax Figure 3: Features in apps and websites. Blue lines show the percentage of smartphone apps with the feature listed on the y-axis. Red lines show the websites with the corresponding feature in the y-axis. Functionality y
To evaluate the functionality provided by the apps we divided it into
broad areas: (i) HIV prevention including information/ awareness
and sexual behaviour change applications (risk reduction/ safe sex
promotions/ condom use), (ii) HIV risk calculators and symptom
checkers, (iii) HIV testing and links to care (including window
periods for testing), (iv) HIV management (including pathways for
people living with HIV as well as those who are at high risk of
HIV). Additional functionality that emerged included HIV news,
which was included with the first category of information. We
looked at emerging HIV relationship and hook-up apps, which allow
people with HIV to meet people based on their HIV status. However, only one of these apps was included, as even though they
were meant for people with HIV, they did not include any other HIV
related material. Three apps were identified that specifically targeted
HIV related stigma. Before doing the main analysis, we prepared a list of features based
on the first 10 web apps and smartphone apps found in each store
and grouped the features into categories for easier data collection. We recorded feature categories for all apps (web and smartphone)
during initial data gathering. In addition, for smartphone apps we
recorded details including name of app, its user rating, number of
reviews by users, and age rating. Additional categories were created
when we encountered features that were missing in the original list. App creators In 63% of smartphone apps, the source of information or links to
healthcare professionals (HCPs) or medical evidence was unclear. There was therefore no way of assessing whether the information
provided was reliable. Only 9% of the apps facilitated interaction
with healthcare professionals (HCP). Most of them did not say
which type of HCP they would be communicating with. In contrast,
97% of web-apps were from trusted sources such as known
healthcare providers, charities and high street pharmacies. Functionality
Category
Features
%apps
S* W*
Prevention
Information
Quizzes
PEP/ PrEP/ ART medication
Safe sex promotions (e.g., condoms)
Locators
Testing locatorsab
Pharmacy locatorsab
Condom locators
Reminders
Testing remindersab
Medication remindersab
Tracking sexual activity/ partners
87
40
26
15
19
10
12
5
16
3
93
7
64
86
57
21
32
0
0
0
Calculating risk Checking risk (including risk
calculators and symptom checkers)
12
25
Testing
Testing information
Home testing
Self-sampling
o
Results email/text/call
o
Book repeat test
Self-testing
o
Book repeat test
Partner notification
33
3
3
3
0
0
0
89
21
21
7
11
3
3
Management
(HIV +)
Reminders
Appointment reminders
Locators
Clinic locators
Routine Testing
Treatment (ART)
Drug interactions
Monitoring
Viral load
12
9
11
16
6
10
0
39
0
0
11
0
Management
(HIV- high risk)
Medication management (PEP/PrEP)
19
0
Table 2: Division of app functionality by stage in HIV
pathway. S* = Smartphone apps; W*= Web apps. a= In
Management (HIV+) as well; b= In Management (HIV-) Many apps were poorly designed in terms of basic user interactions:
e.g., the back-button functionality did not work for 22% of
smartphone apps. 12% apps did not allow the user to exit the app. Most apps on the iTunes and Google Play store were free. The only
paid Android app had never been downloaded. On the iTunes store
two apps were paid apps. The revenue model adopted most
commonly was of ads within the app (17%) and in-app purchases. y p
On Google Play, apps require users to give permission upfront for
using certain phone capabilities. However, it was not always clear
how these permissions would be used. For example, over 20% of
apps required access to the user’s identity and contacts but why
the permissions were needed was unclear as the apps mainly
offered information. 2.2.3 Conclusions. The functionality provided by the apps differed widely. However,
the trustworthiness of information was difficult to establish. Many
parts of the HIV pathway were inadequately or not addressed by
the available functionality. In our next study, we investigate if the
apps meet user needs and how useful the users find them. 2.2.2 Findings. Our reviews showed that most of the apps available on the main app
stores were underused, with a median of 100-500 downloads on
Google play for all apps. The iTunes store does not reveal the
number of downloads. The apps were not highly rated or reviewed. The total number of reviews for 47 android apps was 2319, of which
873 were of a single general sexual solutions app, “Sex Solutions”,
with information about safe sex and HIV. Only 11 apps had more
than 5000 installs. Many people uninstall apps after installing them,
especially free apps, but this information was unavailable. While 87% of the smartphone apps provided some HIV related
information, this was not clearly signposted. The naming of apps did
not always reflect the focus of the app. For example, “Health is
vital” does not indicate that the app is focused on HIV information. Although the discreetness of the app may encourage people to
download it, the lack of signposting in the store indicating that this
is an HIV app means that people are unlikely to access it for this
purpose. One app overcame this issue by signposting the app as an
HIV app in the app store and then removing HIV from the name and Figure 4: Percentage of apps using various permissions
A
t having a discreet icon when downloaded. 93% of web-apps
provided information and this was clearly signposted and linked to
resources. The majority of the reviewed web-apps were either linked
to the NHS or non-government organisations. Home-testing options
were available in only one smartphone app but were present in 21%
of web-apps. Interactive content such as reminders, quizzes and risk
calculators were predominantly found in smartphone apps. This
shows that there are clear differences in the functionality offered by
smartphone and web-apps. We present the functionality and features
provided by smartphone apps and web-apps in Table 2 and Figure 3. Risk calculators and symptom checkers were interchangeably
named – while some apps checked for risk based on type of sexual
activity, others classified risk based on symptoms experienced by
the person. We treated both these categories of apps as risk
calculators. The outputs and next steps from risk calculators were
often alarmist (e.g., Figure 1 - Middle). During the review, we
identified app features needed for each stage of the HIV pathway. Table 2 shows the percentage of apps with the identified features. App creators Similarly, only 31% of apps had location-
aware functionality but nearly 45% used location services. The
Apple app store is stricter about permissions and users give
permission at the time of use, so the user knows the context. For
other permissions required by apps, see Figure 4. 2.3 User Reviews Analysis 2.3.1 Method. 2.2.2 Findings. Figure 4: Percentage of apps using various permissions Risk calculators The risk calculator apps gave no indication of how they were
calculating risk. They queried sexual behaviour and symptoms to
give a verdict about what percentage risk of HIV a person had. A
few reviewers commented: “Interesting, but is not scientific. Each
AIDS' sign is a 6% more. I answered with 3 answers positives, and
I got 18%, it's interesting the concept but is not realistic.” Review
#45. Another user commented on unlikely results given by such an
app. “Um I got a 54% chance and I'm a virgin. I'm pretty sure
that is not how HIV/Aids works.” Review #61 In some of the apps, excessive use of ads hindered the actual
usage of the app. “It's the most annoying app I've ever come
across due to the annoyingly nonstop ads pop-ups that has
characterised it”. Review #54 2.3.3 What do users want? Usability and security
Usability of functions was another issue that caused people to be
frustrated with apps. “The user interface leaves a little to be
desired, though, at least on Android. For example, you can
theoretically set reminders to take your drugs throughout the day,
but it isn't clear how to create these reminders.” Review #17 Information on HIV
h
l f
For apps that people relied on for the latest HIV information and
news, the frequency of app content updates was an issue. “I love
this app and reference it often, but the content listed has not
updated for the last two weeks. Please fix.” Review #73. Incorrect
content was also an issue in many comments and raises the
important issue of reliability of apps. “Incorrect info. Links to
where info came from goes to page not found. Nothing in this app
talks about person with hiv on meds how risky? If someone is on
meds the risk is almost zero.” Review #321 Analogous to the autoethnography, there were many comments
concerning security, privacy, offline access to information, data
backups and the combination of different types of functionality in
one place. These issues can be very important for an application
for dealing with HIV or any medical or health condition where
privacy and security of data are important. Hence, trust emerged
as an issue in many reviews as people questioned why apps
needed so many permissions, “This app is very handy, a great
idea, but should an app that's just 'storing' medical info need so
many additional permissions” Review #341. Users also wanted or
appreciated password protection functionality when it was present
because of the personal nature of the information that they needed
to store. “I have told both my doctor and social worker about it
and they have said they are recommending it to some of their
other clients. Oh, *IT HAS PASSWORD PROTECTION*, just go
to the little gear symbol and enable it”. Review #218 2.3.1 Method. We recorded all available reviews for each app. We only included
reviews from Google Play apps, as the iTunes App Store does not
allow copying comments. Besides, most apps on the iTunes store did not have any reviews, instead displaying the message, “Not
enough ratings”. We classified each review by the general
sentiment expressed (neutral, negative or positive) and type of
review (general request for new feature, new or lost functionality,
complaints). The first author assigned codes that described the
review and validated them with the second author. Thematic
analysis was used for data analysis [28]. due to lack of information, emotional support and guidance from
healthcare avenues. “I bought a home AIDS test kit, sent it out in
the mail and waited the 4 days for my results. Called and the lady
on the other end yelled out ‘You're Positive’ Worst news and most
uncaring way to tell it. I haven't been the same since. This site has
definitely helped with the healing process.“ Review #222. Some apps offered interactions with healthcare professionals but
according to the reviews, this was misleading. E.g., “Not a good
app I thought it was good and all but then they disappointed me. They're not online when they are supposed to be online.” Review
#273. Some apps offered interactions with healthcare professionals but
according to the reviews, this was misleading. E.g., “Not a good
app I thought it was good and all but then they disappointed me. They're not online when they are supposed to be online.” Review
#273. 2.3.2 Analysing Reviews. In total, we collected 345 reviews. Since user reviews on the app
store can be quite skewed, we focused on reviews with specific
comments about app functionalities and feature requests. Based on
the overall sentiment expressed in the review and its content, we
divided user comments into two main groups: (i) general review
comments about the users’ attitude towards the apps, and (ii)
complaints or comments related to specific functionality. General
praise about the apps (e.g., “Good app”) were ignored unless they
mentioned specific aspects of the app. 48% of the reviews fell into
the category of functionality comments/ requests. Of these, 51%
comments were complaints of functionality lost due to updates,
non-working features, application crashes and other general
comments (e.g., “awful app”). The remaining were positive
comments about specific aspects of the app or how it had been
helpful to users. “You saved my life. Early diagnosis ftw” Sic. Review #322 People used the management apps to store much of their HIV data
and reliability of the app and security of the data was of concern. People asked for features such as backup options in these cases. “Good app, but lost 4 years of data when lost my phone, data
backup would be a nice feature” Review #12 Many apps did not support an offline mode of working and
needed to be connected to the Internet. “It can only work with data
connection. It suppose to be accessible fully even in offline, then
people can upgrade the data base periodically as new things are
added to it continuously. Try and organise it so that person can
use it even in environment where data connection is poor.”
Review #143 2.3.3 What do users want? We categorised the reviews as they raised separate issues linked
with different functionalities and features. Diagnosis and linkage to care The emotional impact of HIV diagnosis was further highlighted by
comments people left on being diagnosed after being prompted to
test by a risk assessment app based on answers they gave. “Saved
my life. If it were not for this I would have died. I had no idea I
was HIV positive and when I got 81% chance I went straight to
doctors and I am now in treatment for a few months.” Review
#31. Some people turned to the apps for information and guidance Due to stability issues, apps were often regarded unreliable. Users often complained that apps stopped working, and lost data
or alerts after they had been updated. Many people reported that
app updates froze their smartphone. Many apps frequently crashed
and reduced users trust. “Meh It worked ok for a couple of days,
yesterday I tried to go in and log my doses but it kept crashing... same thing today. Just uninstalled it and will try to wait for a
working copy....” Review #115. Users’ trust was also eroded by
smaller issues/ incidents such as alerts that sometimes did not
work, did not work as expected. There were at least four cases of
self-promotion that were obvious in app reviews, which gave the
apps a five-star rating. For example, “If you need help and you
don’t know who to turn to, this is the app for you. [App name] is
online Sun - Thurs 19h00-21h30 for live individual counselling. It
is free of charge. You may stay anonymous. The app has lots of
information about issues young people struggle with. There are
also about 30 self-test quizzes you can do. Please recommend this
to a friend.” These reviews also reduce users’ trust in the app and
the review process. pre- and post-infection. None of the reviewed smartphone apps
provided the full functionality of general information, prevention,
risk calculation, testing, diagnosis and post-test management. While such comprehensiveness is not imperative, it would be
useful to signpost what stage of HIV and aspects of the HIV
pathway the app is targeting to engage users. Lack of signposting
makes it hard to assess the relevance of the apps. While web-apps
provided comprehensive information about prevention and testing,
they lacked support for managing HIV. Smartphone apps provided
more interactive features and personal tools such as reminders and
location finders in comparison to web-apps. 3 DISCUSSION This functionality review of HIV apps was undertaken to
inform the design of technology, specifically for an online
pathway for taking people from seeking information on HIV,
testing, results management and engagement in care and health
promotion. We began with assessing whether HIV apps are fit for
purpose. To evaluate this, we identified aspects of HIV care and
hence different purposes and target audiences for these aspects
(Table 1). We conducted an autoethnography study, an app review
and a further analysis of user reviews. Our studies revealed that
while many web and smartphone apps are available, very few
provide the functionality and information required to support the
needs of people seeking information on HIV. It was difficult to
identify useful apps that supported people at specific stages of the
HIV pathway. However, we also identified privacy, security and
disclosure issues. Our review showed a low level of engagement
with the apps based on the low number of downloads (median
100-500 downloads on Google Play), ratings and reviews. The link between technology, the person diagnosed with HIV,
and the healthcare provider could also be strengthened through
tools such as virtual support, symptom checking, monitoring of
side effects and provision of advice and information in real-time. Prevention messages for reducing HIV transmission, and
notification of partners after a diagnosis were notably absent from
smartphone apps. Of the available apps, only one provided
behaviour modelling or coping information, such as disclosing
HIV status to others and sexual decision making with partners. Finding the right information/ intervention at the right time
The low level of engagement is likely to be compounded by the
difficulty of identifying relevant apps. With smartphone apps, it is
necessary to find and actively download the app. The app store
provides no options to filter apps and apply advanced search
criteria or exclusions. Thus, app designers need to find ways to
make apps more accessible to their audiences. If they are not
adequately signposted or do not meet people’s needs and
expectations, they are either not downloaded or, if downloaded,
are likely to be deleted as smartphone real estate is valuable [12]. Our findings have several implications for the design of apps in
this space. There is a need for much more focus and commitment
from both the technology perspective for designing higher quality,
thoughtful technologies and from the health perspective to ensure
reliable content. 2.3.4 Conclusions. Results show that users want more functions specific to support,
diagnosis and care of HIV and their concerns were specific to the
functionality they needed. There was also concern around
incorrect information, the source of information, and privacy and
security of provided information. Apps often did not declare what
the source of their information was, or whether it was linked to
healthcare providers. Many reported frustrations around non-
updating apps and content, non-working apps, lack of backups or
offline mode and freezing or crashing apps. 3 DISCUSSION Here we discuss five main points that emerged. Bias There were cases of biased reviews based on the target audience. “So how come the users also installed segment had all 3 gay
oriented apps? Am straight so that does that make me think about
this app. Explains why only 5k installed, though.” Review #299 Many aspects of care were not present in the online resources
for HIV. Online interventions for some other health conditions
now provide emotional and psychological support. Considering
that there is a move towards home testing for HIV and self-
management of it as a chronic condition, this is a notable gap, with
few resources providing such support. In contrast, many apps were
alarmist in the way they tell people about their risk of HIV and
few provided any next steps or safe sex advice. They did not
motivate testing, risk reduction or provide targeted information
based on user answers in risk analysis apps. This is a lost
opportunity. Signposting biomedical prevention strategies such as
pre-exposure and post-exposure prophylaxis were also lacking in
smartphone apps. Web resources were better at providing such
information. 3.2 Is the information reliable? Most smartphone apps did not specify their source of
information or links to healthcare providers and making it difficult
to assess their credibility and trustworthiness. Many were
excluded from our review because they have not been updated in Diagnosis and linkage to care Thus, there were
clear differences between features offered by smartphone and web
apps based on their capability and reasons for use. 60% of web-
apps provide links to smartphone apps for more specific
information and localised services. Both types can co-exist but we
need to understand which one is better suited for different
requirements at each stage of the pathway. 3.4 Is it trustworthy, private and secure? 3.4 Is it trustworthy, private and secure? Apps require access to user information to tailor/ personalise
information and services. However, they can inadvertently or
explicitly provide a wealth of information about users and their
medical condition to third parties [36]. Since apps differ in the
functionality they offer, and the information that they collect, the
potential for damage differs from one app to the next. Some apps
collect personal and medical user information where the potential
for damage is high if there were a leak. For example, as recently as
2015, a well-known HIV dating app leaked data related to over 5000
users including personal messages, HIV status, and personal
information [37]. Such leaks could lead to identity theft, extortion
demands and psychological harm. It is important for technology
designers to understand the risks to users and use adequate data
encryption and provide security and protection to users if they
collect such data [38]. Since HIV-related apps collect different types
of user information, there is no one-size-fits-all approach that could
be advocated for all the apps and therefore measures for security
need to be tailored. Smartphone apps are not transparent in how they
deal with users’ data, where it is stored and how it is used [38]. It is
of concern if even the simple task of looking for information,
checking symptoms or calculating the risk of infection can give an
unknown app access to people’s contacts, social media or location. On the other hand, reviewed web apps were obviously related to
trusted healthcare providers and charities. This may be because we
only reviewed the top three pages of search results which are highly
assessed. Many Android apps required upfront permissions for accessing
data and identity related information and control aspects of the
smartphone hardware, such as the camera. It is difficult for the end
user to assess and make an informed choice about how features
would be used. The iTunes app store was better as it asked for
permission in context of using a feature that required it. 3.1 Do apps provide required functionality? As discussed, HIV is a diverse infection affecting different
populations and people have different needs at different stages of the last three years. Although we did not set out to specifically
assess content, some smartphone apps clearly had inaccurate
description and content. The inaccuracies are concerning as users
have no way of identifying trustworthy apps. This raises the need for
a review process agreed by healthcare authorities, app providers and
app stores to assess apps based on agreed guidelines before making
them available to the public, particularly for apps for medical
conditions. However, several authors question the feasibility and
usefulness of accrediting medical health apps as it is a time intensive
process [29]. For example, the US, Happtique Health App
Certification Standards that certified apps based on criteria including
content quality, usability, connectivity, security and privacy were
suspended in 2013 as several previously certified apps were found to
have security issues [29]. Happtique’s was a voluntary process and
time consuming (18 months to certify 16 apps [29]). The US Food
and Drug Administration (FDA) and Medical and Health Regulation
Authority (MHRA) attempt to regulate some medical mobile apps
that they define as medical devices. MHRA classifies apps as ‘low
risk’, ’moderate risk’ or ‘high risk’. Their guidance only applies to
‘moderate’ or ‘high risk’ apps, which leaves out the vast majority
[30]. There are fears that regulation could limit innovation through
introducing unnecessary bureaucracy, increasing cost and delaying
time to market [31]. Some argue that users should be educated on
criteria about how to assess if an app is a trustworthy source of
information [32]. Further, accurate and accessible apps could be
recommended (or prescribed) through trustworthy offline and online
sources [32] such as healthcare professionals. However, app
education may differ based on target users and potential for harm. Even for apps that do not collect personal or medical information,
app providers have a responsibility to ensure correct and current
information as users may base their decisions and actions on the
information provided. Our review highlighted that some apps do not
provide
information
based
on
current
evidence
and
recommendations but since the content of the apps was not the focus
in this paper, we will address this aspect in our future work. information seeking and post-diagnosis support apps to not cause
unintended disclosure and embarrassment due to notifications or
visual design. 3.3 Is it discreet and does it allow control over
disclosure? We are entering an era where major m-Health interventions are
being proposed to increase the proportion of people with HIV who
are diagnosed and engage with care [15, 33, 34]. HIV remains
stigmatized and people living with HIV may be reluctant to disclose
their diagnosis [12, 23], which can result in other issues such as not
accessing health services, or not taking medication regularly. In the end, users must decide what apps to use or information to
share. However, it is important to support users in this decision and
sensitize them to the risks involved in the sharing of sensitive
private or medical information and provide easy ways of assessing
and controlling privacy in m-Health apps [36]. App providers and
stores need processes that ensure some protection before apps are
publicly accessible. Experienced users, researchers, clinicians and
others can contribute to this process by signposting good quality
apps, identifying harmful apps, and disseminating findings. One of the reasons for accessing home testing and online
interventions is privacy and poor design interferes with that goal. Some studies have highlighted how young people do not want to use
HIV related apps for fear of others identifying the app’s purpose
from its icon or finding the app on their phones [14]. Apps and
online interventions can potentially be convenient and discreet. However, our studies found that app designs were typically not
discreet and attracted unwanted attention. Most app icons made it
apparent that the app was HIV-related (see Figure 1 - Left). Recent
studies (e.g., [23]) have recommended that appearance, language
and icons should be non-medical and discreet to avoid unintentional
disclosure of HIV status if someone glances at or uses their phone. Thus, technology designers need to design appropriately for HIV 3.1 Do apps provide required functionality? This could be done through more neutral language
and iconography [23], by providing security features such as
password protection [14] and through discreet user interface design. Dating and hookup apps are increasingly focusing on these issues
[35] and this learning can be extended to HIV-related apps. REFERENCES [28] V. Braun and V. Clarke. 2006. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual. Res. Psychol., vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 77–101. [1] D. Ogaz, M. Furegato, N. Connor, O. Gill, and contributors. 2016. HIV testing in
England: 2016 report. [Online]. Available at:
www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/573596/HIV
_testing_in_England_2016_Report_FinalNB301116.pdf. [Accessed: 28-Apr-2017] [29] S. R. Chan and S. Misra. 2014. Certification of Mobile Apps for Health Care. JAMA, vol. 312, no. 11, p. 1155. p
[30] B. M. Thompson and I. Brodsky. 2013. Should the FDA regulate mobile medical
apps? BMJ, vol. 347. _
g_ _
g
_
_
p
_
p f [
p
]
[2] P. H. England. 2015. HIV in the UK – Situation Report 2015 Incidence, prevalence
and prevention. Prot. Improv. Nations Heal., vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 1–20. and prevention. Prot. Improv. Nations Heal., vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 1–20. [31] E. Charani, E. Castro-Sánchez, L. S. Moore, and A. Holmes. 2014. Do
smartphone applications in healthcare require a governance and legal framework? It depends on the application!. BMC Med., vol. 12, no. 1, p. 29, [3] WHO, UNICEF, & UNAIDS. 2011. Towards universal access, Vasa, pp.1–233. [4] Ofcom. 2015. The Communications Market Report. [4] Ofcom. 2015. The Communications Market Report. It depends on the application!. BMC Med., vol. 12, no. 1, p. 29, [5] J. Gibbs, V. Gkatzidou, L. Tickle, T. Manning, Sarah R Tilakkumar, K. Hone, R. E. Ashcroft, P. Sonnenberg, S. T. Sadiq, and C. S. Estcourt. 2016. Can you
recommend any good STI apps? A review of content, accuracy and
comprehensiveness of current mobile medical applications for sexually transmitted
infections and related genital infections, Sex. Transm. Infect., vol. in press. [32] M. N. Kamel Boulos, A. C. Brewer, C. Karimkhani, D. B. Buller, and R. P. Dellavalle. 2014. Mobile medical and health apps: state of the art, concerns. regulatory control and certification.Online J. Public Health Inform,vol.5, no. 3. [33] Clinicaltrials.gov. Smart Linkage-to-HIV Care Via a Smartphone App. 2016. [Online]. Available: https://clinicaltrials.gov/show/NCT02756949. [Accessed: 23-
Feb-2017]. infections and related genital infections, Sex. Transm. Infect., vol. in p [6] M. Brady, G. Carpenter, and B. Bard. 2016. Self-testing for HIV: initial experience
of the UK’s first kit, 22nd Annu. Conf. Br. HIV. [34] i-Sense, Flagship 4: Low Cost Diagnostics for HIV in Developing Countries | i-
sense. 2016. [Online]. Available: https://www.i-sense.org.uk/research/flagship-4-
low-cost-diagnostics-hiv-developing-countries. [Accessed: 19-Sep-2016]. [7] WHO. 2016. [Online]. Ava
[Accessed: 28-Apr-2017]. f
[7] WHO. 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.who.int/features/qa/71/en/%0D. [Accessed: 28-Apr-2017]. 3.5 Does/ can the user use it? Well-designed apps should allow users to tailor their experience by
selecting useful app features, personalising app messages and
providing options for notifications through the app/ email, or text
messages. The constant availability of app interactive functions can
allow users to engage with the app whenever convenient. However, [13] K. E. Muessig, E. C. Pike, S. LeGrand, and L. B. Hightow-Weidman. 2013. Mobile
Phone Applications for the Care and Prevention of HIV and Other Sexually
Transmitted Diseases: A Review. J. Med. Internet Res., vol. 15, no. 1, p. e1, we found that even where offline features were available they often
did not work. Most apps underused the potential of smartphones by
not providing tailoring or interactivity options. Again, this
represents an opportunity for future developments. A large
proportion of apps were poorly implemented, many lacked basic
functionalities such as back buttons, had distracting user design, had
too many ads, which discourage users and often crashed. [14] V. Gkatzidou, K. Hone, J. Gibbs, L. Sutcliffe, S. T. Sadiq, P. Sonnenberg, and C. Estcourt. 2013. A User-centred Approach to Inform the Design of a Mobile
Application for STI Diagnosis and Management. International BCS Human
Computer Interaction Conference, 2013, p. 27:1-27:6. [15] T. Laksanasopin, T. W. Guo, S. Nayak, A. A. Sridhara, S. Xie, O. O. Olowookere, P. Cadinu, F. Meng, N. H. Chee, J. Kim, C. D. Chin, E. Munyazesa,
P. Mugwaneza, A. J. Rai, V. Mugisha, A. R. Castro, D. Steinmiller, V. Linder, J. E. Justman, S. Nsanzimana, and S. K. Sia. 2015. Supplementary Information: A
smartphone dongle for diagnosis of infectious diseases at the point of care.. Sci. Transl. Med., vol. 7, no. 273, p. 273re1. Our findings highlight many opportunities for improved design
of digital resources for prevention, testing and management of HIV. There is an urgent need for trustworthy resources to support people
accessing information online and to reduce barriers to care. From
the person seeking information following a sexual encounter, to
someone using a self-testing kit at home with no immediate access
to care, to the person living with HIV, apps can provide support. This is a significant opportunity to bring together the strengths of
HCI, with relevant clinical expertise, to address issues common to
apps for other health conditions [14,21] and those specific to sexual
health/ HIV. p
[16] J. Brewer, J. “Jofish” Kaye, A. Williams, and S. Wyche. 2006. 3.5 Does/ can the user use it? Sexual
interactions: why we should talk about sex in HCI. in CHI ’06 extended abstracts
on Human factors in computing systems - CHI EA ’06, 2006, p. 1695. [17] G. Kannabiran, J. Bardzell, and S. Bardzell. 2011. How HCI talks about sexuality. in Proceedings of the 2011 annual conference on Human factors in computing
systems - CHI ’11, 2011, p. 695. [18] T. Almeida, R. Comber, and M. Balaam. 2016. HCI and Intimate Care As an
Agenda for Change in Women’s Health. Proc. 2016 CHI Conf. Hum. Factors
Comput. Syst., pp. 2599–2611. [19] J. Bardzell and S. Bardzell. 2011. Pleasure is your birthright: digitally enabled sex
toys as a case of third-wave HCI. in Proceedings of the 2011 annual conference
on Human factors in computing systems - CHI ’11, 2011, p. 257. [20] A. L. Florom-Smith and J. P. De Santis. 2012. Exploring the Concept of HIV-
Related Stigma. Nurs. Forum, vol. 47, no. 3, pp. 153–165. [20] A. L. Florom-Smith and J. P. De Santis. 2012. Exploring the C COMPETING INTERESTS pp
[26] A. A. O’Kane, Y. Rogers, and A. E. Blandford. 2014. Gaining empathy for non-
routine mobile device use through autoethnography. Proc ACM CHI ’14, pp. 987–990. The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. [27] Chitika, 2013. The Value of Google Result Positioning. 2013. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS [25] S. J. Cunningham and M. Jones. 2005. Autoethnography: A tool for practice and
education. in Proceedings of the 6th ACM SIGCHI New Zealand chapter’s
international conference on Computer-human interaction making CHI natural -
CHINZ ’05, 2005, vol. 94, pp. 1–8. We thank the EPSRC EP/K031953/1 for funding this project. We thank the EPSRC EP/K031953/1 for funding this project. We thank the EPSRC EP/K031953/1 for funding this project. 4 CONCLUSIONS Related Stigma. Nurs. Forum, vol. 47, no. 3, pp. 153–165. [21] F. Nunes, N. Verdezoto, G. Fitzpatrick, M. Kyng, E. Grönvall, and C. Storni. 2015. Self-Care Technologies in HCI: Trends, Tensions, and Opportunities. ACM
Trans. Comput. Interact., vol. 22, no. 6, pp. 1–45, 2015. There is a need to build more acceptable, well-informed and well-
designed online resources for HIV. Appropriately tailored,
interactive applications that address user needs can increase the
acceptance and adoption of new or existing apps and resources. On
the biomedical side, new and improved technologies and
medications are being created to diagnose and prevent HIV. These
fuel the need for innovative technology to improve the uptake of
online/ mobile technologies, and for exploring behavioural
interventions to reduce gaps in HIV prevention, testing and care. [22] A. Bussone, S. Stumpf, and G. Buchanan. 2016. It Feels Like I’m Managing
Myself. in Proceedings of the 9th Nordic Conference on Human-Computer
Interaction - NordiCHI ’16, 2016, pp. 1–10. [23] G. Marcu, N. Dowshen, S. Saha, R. R. Sarreal, and N. Andalibi. 2016. TreatYoSelf: Empathy-driven behavioral intervention for marginalized youth
living with HIV. Pervasive Health, 2016. [24] A. Bussone, S. Stumpf, and J. Bird. 2016. Disclose-It-Yourself: Security and
Privacy for People Living with HIV. CHI EA ’16: Proceedings of the 2016 ACM
annual conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems Extended Abstracts,
2016, pp. 1–4. REFERENCES [8] Y. Qiu, D. Luo, R. Cheng, Y. Xiao, X. Chen, Z. Huang, and S. Xiao. 2014. Emotional problems and related factors in patients with HIV/AIDS]. Zhong Nan Da
Xue Xue Bao. Yi Xue Ban, vol. 39, no. 8, pp. 835–41. [35] M. J. Handel and I. Shklovski. 2012. Disclosure, ambiguity and risk reduction in
real-time dating sites. in Proceedings of the 17th ACM international conference
on Supporting group work - GROUP ’12, 2012, p. 175. [9] Social Media Site Usage 2014 | Pew Research Center. [Online]. Available:
http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/01/09/social-media-update-2014/.[Accessed: 28-
Apr-2017] [36] T. Dehling, D. -Wirt -Inf, F. Gao, S. Schneider, and A. Sunyaev,. 2015. Exploring
the Far Side of Mobile Health: Information Security and Privacy of Mobile Health
Apps on iOS and Android. JMIR mHealth uHealth, vol. 3,no. 1. [10] E. P. H. Choi, J. Y. H. Wong, H. H. M. Lo, W. Wong, J. H. M. Chio, and D. Y. T. Fong. 2016. The association between smartphone dating applications and college
students’ casual sex encounters and condom use. Sex. Reprod. Healthc., vol. 9, pp. 38–41. pp
[37] Databreaches.net. 2015. Two apps with health info found leaking: researcher. Part
2: Hzone. [Online]. Available: www.databreaches.net/two-apps-with-health-info-
found-leaking-researcher-part-2-hzone/[Accessed: 25-Feb-2017]. [38] K. Huckvale, J. T. Prieto, M. Tilney, P.-J. Benghozi, and J. Car. 2013. Unaddressed privacy risks in accredited health and wellness apps: a cross-
sectional systematic assessment. BMC Biol., vol. 11, p. EE. [11] J. Clark. 2015. Mobile dating apps could be driving HIV epidemic among
adolescents in Asia Pacific. BMJ (Clinical research ed.), vol. 351. p. h6493. lescents in Asia Pacific. BMJ (Clinical research ed.), vol. 351. p. h6493. [12] N. Ramanathan, D. Swendeman, W. S. Comulada, D. Estrin, and M. J. Rotheram-
Borus. 2013. Identifying preferences for mobile health applications for self-
monitoring and self-management: Focus group findings from HIV-positive persons
and young mothers Int. J. Med. Inform., vol. 82, no. 4, pp. e38–e46.
|
https://openalex.org/W4361849889
|
https://figshare.com/articles/journal_contribution/Supplementary_Table_S9_from_PDGF_Engages_an_E2F-USP1_Signaling_Pathway_to_Support_ID2-Mediated_Survival_of_Proneural_Glioma_Cells/22408352/1/files/39854228.pdf
|
English
| null |
Supplementary Table S5 from PDGF Engages an E2F-USP1 Signaling Pathway to Support ID2-Mediated Survival of Proneural Glioma Cells
| null | 2,023
|
cc-by
| 99
|
Supplementary Table 9. Primers used for genotyping
Gene/Transgene
Sequence (5'-3')
Id2fl/fl Genotyping F
TAGGCATGAAGGGGCTTGTA
Id2fl/fl Genotyping R
GCCACTGGGCTCATAAAAGT
Id2fl/fl Deletion Specific F
CACCTACACTGAAGGGCACA
Id2fl/fl Deletion Specific R
AGTCAGCCACACTTGGTCCT
GFAP-tTa F
TCGCTTTCCTCTGAACGCTTCTCG
GFAP-tTa R
TCTGAACGCTGTGACTTGGAGTGTCC
Tre-hPDGFβ F
GTGGTTTGTCCAAACTCATC
Tre-hPDGFβ R
GTCCAGGTGAGAAAGATCGAG
GFAP-Cre F
TCCATAAAGGCCCTGACATC
GFAP-Cre R
TGCGAACCTCATCACTCGT Supplementary Table 9. Primers used for genotyping
Gene/Transgene
Sequence (5'-3')
Id2fl/fl Genotyping F
TAGGCATGAAGGGGCTTGTA
Id2fl/fl Genotyping R
GCCACTGGGCTCATAAAAGT
Id2fl/fl Deletion Specific F
CACCTACACTGAAGGGCACA
Id2fl/fl Deletion Specific R
AGTCAGCCACACTTGGTCCT
GFAP-tTa F
TCGCTTTCCTCTGAACGCTTCTCG
GFAP-tTa R
TCTGAACGCTGTGACTTGGAGTGTCC
Tre-hPDGFβ F
GTGGTTTGTCCAAACTCATC
Tre-hPDGFβ R
GTCCAGGTGAGAAAGATCGAG
GFAP-Cre F
TCCATAAAGGCCCTGACATC
GFAP-Cre R
TGCGAACCTCATCACTCGT Supplementary Table 9. Primers used for genotyping
|
https://openalex.org/W3130569119
|
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/medrxiv/early/2021/02/23/2021.02.19.21251232.full.pdf
|
English
| null |
Deep neural network estimated electrocardiographic-age as a mortality predictor
|
medRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 16,264
|
Deep neural network estimated electrocardiographic-age as a mortality predictor Emilly M Lima, MSc1,2 *; Antônio H Ribeiro, PhD3,4 *; Gabriela MM Paixão, MD, MSc1,2,* ; Manoel
Horta Ribeiro5; Marcelo M Pinto Filho, MD, PhD1,2; Paulo R Gomes, MSc1,2; Derick M Oliveira,
MSc3; Ester C Sabino, MD, PhD6; Bruce B Duncan, MD, PhD7; Luana Giatti, MD, PhD2; Sandhi
M Barreto, MD, PhD2; Wagner Meira Jr, PhD3; Thomas B Schön, PhD4 ; Antonio Luiz P Ribeiro,
MD, PhD1,2 1- Telehealth Center, Hospital das Clínicas, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo
Horizonte, Brazil. 1- Telehealth Center, Hospital das Clínicas, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo
Horizonte, Brazil. 2- Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil. 2- Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil. 3- Departamento de Ciência da Computação. Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo
Horizonte, Brazil 3- Departamento de Ciência da Computação. Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Belo
Horizonte, Brazil 4- Department of Information Technology, Uppsala University, Sweden. 4- Department of Information Technology, Uppsala University, Sweden. 5- Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland. 5- Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland. 6- Instituto de Medicina Tropical da Faculdade de Medicina da Universidade de São Paulo, São
Paulo, Brazil. 6- Instituto de Medicina Tropical da Faculdade de Medicina da Universidade de São Paulo, São
Paulo, Brazil. 7- Programa de Pós-Graduação em Epidemiologia and Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre,
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Brazil. 7- Programa de Pós-Graduação em Epidemiologia and Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre,
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Brazil. * Equal contribution. * Equal contribution. * Equal contribution. .
CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021.
;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
pe petu ty Antonio Luiz Pinho Ribeiro Rua Campanha 98/101, Belo Horizonte, 30310-770, MG, Brazil Rua Campanha 98/101, Belo Horizonte, 30310 770,
Tel.: +55 31 3307 9201; Fax: +55 31 987090451. Tel.: +55 31 3307 9201; Fax: +55 31 987090451. Corresponding author: Antonio Luiz Pinho Ribeiro Email: antonio.ribeiro@ebserh.gov.br NOTE: This preprint reports new research that has not been certified by peer review and should not be used to guide clinical practice. . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint CC BY 4 0 I
i
l li
I i
d
il bl
d
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y Keywords: Biological aging, electrocardiogram, mortality prediction, artificial intelligence. Abstract: The electrocardiogram (ECG) is the most commonly used exam for the screening and
evaluation of cardiovascular diseases. Here we propose that the age predicted by artificial
intelligence (AI) from the raw ECG tracing (ECG-age) can be a measure of cardiovascular
health and provide prognostic information. A deep convolutional neural network was trained to
predict a patient's age from the 12-lead ECG using data from patients that underwent an ECG
from 2010 to 2017 - the CODE study cohort (n=1,558,415 patients). On the 15% hold-out CODE
test split, patients with ECG-age more than 8 years greater than chronological age had a higher
mortality rate (hazard ratio (HR) 1.79, p<0.001) in a mean follow-up of 3.67 years, whereas
those with ECG-age more than 8 years less than chronological age had a lower mortality rate
(HR 0.78, p<0.001). Similar results were obtained in the external cohorts ELSA-Brasil
(n=14,236) and SaMi-Trop (n=1,631). The ability to predict mortality from the ECG predicted
age remains even when we adjust the model for cardiovascular risk factors. Moreover, even for
apparent
normal ECGs, having a predicted ECG-age 8 or more years greater than
chronological age remained a statistically significant predictor of risk (HR 1.53, p<0.001 in
CODE 15% test split). These results show that AI-enabled analysis of the ECG can add
prognostic information to the interpretation of the 12-lead ECGs. Keywords: Biological aging, electrocardiogram, mortality prediction, artificial intelligence. 1 1 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y Introduction The electrocardiogram (ECG) is the most commonly used exam for the screening and
evaluation of cardiovascular diseases. Computerized, rule-based, ECG interpretation was
developed to facilitate medical research and clinical practice. However, the limited accuracy of
these methods has limited their application1,2. In this context, deep neural networks (DNNs) are
a promising machine learning approach for the automated analysis of the ECG and have
achieved unprecedented performance in initial studies3,4. DNNs present a paradigm shift from classical ECG automated analysis methods. Classical methods use signal processing techniques to extract the measurements, wavelengths
and detect abnormal beats from the ECG signal and then use the extracted information as input
features to a classifier5. DNN-based ECG analysis, on the other hand, is based on an
"end-to-end" approach, for which the raw signal is used as an input to the classifier, which
learns to extract the features by itself 3,4. Unlike the traditional methods, features learned by end-to-end ECG automated analysis
methods do not necessarily have an interpretation rooted in electrocardiographic knowledge. If
this paradigm introduces new challenges regarding model interpretability6 and out-of-distribution
robustness7, it also introduces new possibilities when it comes to applications. Examples that go
beyond traditional electrocardiography and have been achieved using end-to-end approaches
include: predicting the risk of death from the ECG 8; identifying patients who will develop atrial
fibrillation from a previous ECG taken during sinus rhythm9; and screening for cardiac
contractile dysfunction using only the 12-lead ECG 10. This suggests that end-to-end models
might be able to identify additional markers, that, in their turn, might be a practical and useful
tool in cardiovascular disease prediction. 2 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Introduction ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y Introduction Despite being part of the routine evaluation of many patients in both primary and
specialized care, the role of ECG in cardiovascular disease prediction and, hence, prevention is
not as clear. Its prognostic impact has been explored in previous publications 11,12, nonetheless,
the available methods are not widely adopted as a screening tool for individuals free of
cardiovascular disease13. In this context, we turn to the usage of machine learning algorithms to
infer age from ECG traces14,15. Age is a risk factor for cardiac diseases that affects ECG
measurements and the likelihood of having an ECG with a higher incidence of abnormalities16,17. Moreover, previous research has shown that AI-based age estimates from the 12-lead ECG
(ECG-age) are reasonably accurate, and that overestimation is associated with a higher
incidence of cardiovascular risk factors and comorbidities14,15. In this paper, we demonstrate that AI-predicted ECG-age is a potentially useful tool in the
assessment of the risk of death in the general population. We developed, in the CODE Study
cohort18, a DNN-based age-prediction model and assessed if the difference between predicted
ECG-age and chronological age is a predictor of overall mortality. The model is validated in two
external cohorts, ELSA-Brasil19, of Brazilian public servants, and SaMi-Trop20, of Chagas
disease patients. Furthermore, we tested if the predictive value remains significant after
controlling for the presence of cardiovascular risk factors and for subjects with normal ECGs. We sought to determine whether it can be used as a prognostic marker in the general
population. Finally, we also undertook an exploratory analysis to investigate mechanisms that
are involved in ECG-age prediction, looking at the main components used during the
classification. This is done both by analysing the model sensitivity to changes in the ECG signal
and by the manual review of the ECGs and the corresponding ECG-predicted age by trained
cardiologists. 3 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. Deep neural network age-predictor model We used the CODE Study cohort18 to develop a DNN capable of predicting the patient's
age from the raw ECG tracing. The dataset consists of ECG records from 1,558,415 patients of
811 counties in the state of Minas Gerais (Brazil) collected by the Telehealth Network of Minas
Gerais (TNMG). Patients were divided into 85-15% splits with the 85% split being used to
develop the model (see Methods). The model is evaluated in 3 different cohorts, unseen by the DNN model during its
development, the 15% hold-out split described above, which will be referred to as the
CODE-15% cohort (with 218,169 participants), the ELSA-Brasil (with 14,236 participants), and
the
SaMi-Trop
cohorts
(with
1,631
participants). Table
1
summarizes
the
baseline
characteristics for each of the cohorts including median follow-up and number of events. Compared to the CODE-15% cohort, mean age, the prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors,
and previous myocardial infarction were higher in both ELSA-Brasil and SaMi-Trop cohorts. The
frequency of events was the highest in the SaMi-Trop cohort, composed of Chagas disease
patients, many with chronic cardiomyopathy. We used the DNN architecture known as the residual network21 to perform the task. The
architecture has been successfully used for ECG abnormality detection in previous work3,4. The
DNN mean absolute error (MAE) in the age prediction task is 8.38 (with standard deviation, s.d.,
7.00), 8.44 (s.d. 6.19) and 10.04 (s.d. 7.76) for the CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil, SaMi-Trop,
respectively. Figure 1 shows the relation between predicted and true age for all the patients in
the cohorts. 4 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y In the following sections, we try to establish the prognostic relevance of the ECG-age. We perform regression analyses that use the ECG-age as an input variable. Deep neural network age-predictor model In these analyses
we always use the CODE-15% cohort for deriving the statistics and the ELSA-Brasil and
SaMi-Trop for validating them. Electrocardiographic-age as a mortality predictor CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. more years less than chronological age. In the SaMi-Trop cohort, patients with an ECG-age 8 or
more years greater than the chronological age had a higher mortality risk (HR 2.42, 95%CI
1.53-3.83; p<0.001); for ECG-age 8 or more years less than chronological age, however, the
observed decrease in mortality risk was not statistically significant (HR 0.89, 95%CI 0.52-1.54;
p=0.68)). Additional analysis also show that Cox model adjusted by sex and age presents a
good performance in the prediction of 1-year mortality, with an area under the curve, AUC, of
0.80 (95%CI 0.79-0.81) for the CODE-15% cohort, 0.77 (95%CI 0.66-0.87) for the ELSA-Brasil
and 0.74 (95%CI 0.68-0.80) for the SaMi-Trop. The importance of the ECG-age in predicting mortality remains also when we adjust the
model for cardiovascular risk factors. Hazard ratios for models adjusted by different selections
of variables cardiovascular risk factors are given in Table 2. In this analysis, we additionally
adjusted the model for hypertension, diabetes mellitus, and smoking habits, but this did not yield
significant differences in the results. As in the first case, all associations (except for ECG-age 8
or more years than the chronological age in the Sami-Trop cohort) remained significant with
little change in the adjusted HR. We also did additional adjustments for dyslipidemia
(CODE-15% and ELSA-Brasil cohorts) and obesity (ELSA-Brasil), without changing significantly
the magnitude of the observed association. Electrocardiographic-age as a mortality predictor We try to establish the relevance of ECG-age as a predictor of mortality. We divided the
patients into three groups, based on differences between predicted ECG-age and chronological
age: a) those with ECG-age 8 or more years greater than the chronological age; b) those with
ECG-age within a range of 8 years from their chronological age; and, c) those with ECG-age 8
or more years smaller than the chronological age. The MAE in the CODE dataset is
approximately 8 years, which motivates our choice for the thresholds used. That is, when the
predicted ECG-age deviates from the chronological age by more than the mean deviation found
in the derivation cohort we classify into group (a) if the deviation is positive, and into group (c), if
it is negative. Experiments with alternative choices of threshold yield qualitatively similar results. The risk of death for these three groups, expressed by their hazard ratios (HR), is shown
in Table 2, together with the 95% confidence intervals (CI). We fit a Cox model, adjusted for age
and sex, in the CODE-15% cohort. The adjusted survival curves for this model are presented in
Figure 2. This model indicates that participants with an estimated ECG-age of 8 or more years
greater than the chronological age had higher mortality risk (HR 1.79, 95%CI 1.69-1.90;
p<0.001). On the other hand, those with an estimated ECG-age of 8 or more years less than the
chronological age had a lower mortality risk (HR 0.78, 95%CI 0.74-0.83, p < 0.001). Results in
the ELSA-Brasil cohort, were similar: with a higher mortality risk (HR 1.75, 95%CI 1.35-2.27;
p<0.001) for those with estimated ECG-age of 8 or more years greater than chronological age;
and a lower mortality rate (HR 0.74, 95%CI 0.63-0.88; p<0.001) for those with ECG-age 8 or 5 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . Electrocardiographic-age as a mortality predictor in apparently normal ECGs Table 3 describes conventional ECG measurements for the participants in the three
groups described above - i.e., a) patients with predicted ECG-age 8 or more years greater than
their chronological age; b) 8 or more years less than their chronological age; and, c) within a
range of 8 years from their chronological age. Although in the CODE-15% cohort statistically
significant differences can be seen for all measurements (p<0.001 for all), these numbers do
not yield a clinically significant difference. From a clinical perspective, these measurements can 6 6 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. be considered remarkably similar to each other. In the ELSA-Brasil cohort, measurements were
also numerically similar with a statistically significant difference obtained only for heart rate
(p<0.001) and QTc interval (p<0.001). be considered remarkably similar to each other. In the ELSA-Brasil cohort, measurements were
also numerically similar with a statistically significant difference obtained only for heart rate
(p<0.001) and QTc interval (p<0.001). To further evaluate whether the ECG-age predicted by the DNN was related to traditional
electrocardiographic abnormalities, we performed an additional analysis, now restricted to
normal ECGs from the CODE-15% and ELSA-Brasil cohorts. Which have, respectively, 80679
and
7691 participants with normal ECGs. We did not perform this analysis in the SaMi-Trop
because most patients had ECG abnormalities related to Chagas disease. What was
considered as normal ECG is defined in Methods. An analysis with a Cox model restricted to
the normal ECG was performed and the obtained hazard ratios are displayed in Table 4. The
same parameters of the analysis in Table 2 are used. Electrocardiographic-age as a mortality predictor in apparently normal ECGs In the model adjusted by age and sex,
ECG-age 8 or more years greater than chronological age remained a statistically significant
predictor of death risk in both cohorts (HR 1.53, 95% CI 1.30 – 1.80, p<0.001 in CODE-15%
and HR 1.63, 95% CI 1.00 – 2.66 p=0.050 in ELSA-Brasil). On the other hand, ECG-age 8 or
more years less than chronological age remained associated with reduced risk of mortality in
the CODE-15% (HR 0.66, 95% CI 0.57 - 0.76 p<0.001) but was not statistically significant in the
ELSA-Brasil cohort (HR 0.91, 95% CI 0.68 - 1.21 p=0.502). The results for models additionally adjusted for cardiovascular risk factors is also
displayed in Table 4. After the adjustment, ECG-age 8 or more years than chronological age
was associated with increased risk of mortality in CODE-15% cohort (HR 1.52, 95% CI 1.29 -
1.79, p=0.015), but not in ELSA-Brasil (HR 1.49, 95% CI 0.91-2.43, p=0.114). This was also
true for an ECG-age 8 or more years less than chronological age. Risk was significantly
decreased in CODE-15% cohort (HR 0.66, 95% CI 0.57 – 0.76, p<0.001) but not in ELSA-Brasil
(HR 1.00, 95% CI 0.75 – 1.33, p=0.990). Which might be justified by the lack of statistical power 7 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint CC BY 4 0 I t
ti
l li
It i
d
il bl
d
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y due to the small number of deaths in this group for the ELSA-Brasil cohort (n=19). Electrocardiographic-age as a mortality predictor in apparently normal ECGs Additional
adjustments for dyslipidemia (CODE-15% and ELSA-Brasil cohorts) and obesity (ELSA-Brasil)
do not qualitatively change the results. Electrocardiographic-age and cardiovascular risk factors Figure 3(A) represents which cardiovascular risk factors were most likely associated with
a predicted ECG-age 8 or more years greater than chronological age considering all ECGs from
ELSA-Brasil cohort. After logistic regression adjusted for age and sex, hypertension, diabetes,
smoking and obesity remained significantly associated with an increased odds of having an
ECG-age 8 or more years greater than chronological age. In Figure 3(B) the same model was
applied only to participants with a normal ECG. Hypertension, diabetes and smoking were
significantly associated with a predicted ECG-age 8 or more years greater than chronological
age. Interpretability and time and frequency domain saliency maps To assess whether ECG-age captures signals that can be interpreted by cardiologists,
we conducted an additional experiment. We paired ECG-ages of subjects with the same
chronological age, but where one of them had an ECG-age 8 or more years greater than their
chronological age and the other 8 or more years less than their chronological age. Then, three
medical doctors were asked to independently determine, for each pair, which ECG tracing was
associated with the subject with higher ECG-age. Analyzing doctor's assessments of 134 pairs
of traces, aggregated through majority voting, we found that they were not significantly better
than random (chi square=3.0, p =0.12). We provide detailed results in Sup Table 3. Throughout
the experiment, doctors were given feedback about their predictions (in Stage 2), this did not
increase their accuracy in the subsequent stage. In fact, they performed worse in Stage 3 8 8 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint CC BY 4 0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: Accuracy=45.5%), after the feedback, than in Stage 1 (Accuracy=64.4%), before the feedback,
in Stage 2 (Accuracy=62.2%), during the feedback. . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. (Accuracy=45.5%), after the feedback, than in Stage 1 (Accuracy=64.4%), before the feedback,
or in Stage 2 (Accuracy=62.2%), during the feedback. Additionally, we randomly generated 50 pairs of normal ECG tracings, with saliency
maps22 highlighting the regions in the ECG tracing that have the highest impact in the predicted
ECG-age (see Methods). Sup Fig 1 provides some illustrative examples. We asked the same
set of three medical doctors to qualitatively analyze which sections of the ECG were being
frequently highlighted by the visualization algorithm. Doctors independently suggested that
low-frequency components, as P and T waves, were disproportionately highlighted. We also generate saliency maps in the frequency domain giving the relative importance
of each frequency component for the final prediction (see Methods). Sup Fig 2 shows the
median and interquartile range from this analysis for 100 normal exams in each cohort. The
analysis suggests the frequency component between 8 and 15 Hz of the ECG spectrum are the
ones that most contribute to the model prediction. 9 9 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y b There are missing values in variables from the ELSA-Brasil cohort (Hypertension, 13;
Diabetes, 3; Smoking, 1; Previous myocardial infarction, 7); valid percentages are reported TABLES AND FIGURES Table 1- Baseline characteristics. The table summarizes the characteristics of the three
cohorts analysed in this study. It includes the baseline characteristics, the summary of follow-up
time, and the number of events. Table 1- Baseline characteristics. The table summarizes the characteristics of the three
cohorts analysed in this study. It includes the baseline characteristics, the summary of follow-up
time, and the number of events. CODE-15%
(n = 218169)
ELSA-Brasilb
(n = 14263)
SaMi-Tropc
(n=1631)
Characteristicsa
Sex, male, n (%)
88508 (41)
6494 (46)
550 (34)
Age (years), mean (s.d.)
51 (20)
52 (9)
60 (13)
Hypertension, n (%)
64767 (30)
5108 (36)
593 (36)
Diabetes, n (%)
13720 (6)
2830 (20)
161 (10)
Smoking, n (%)
13645 (6)
1882 (13)
498 (31)
Previous myocardial infarction, n (%) 1553 (0.7)
258 (1.8)
76 (5)
Follow-up(years), median (IQR)
3.4 (2.1-5.0)
9.8 (8.9-10.0)
2.1 (2.0-2.2)
Events, n (%)
8110 (3.7)
617 (4.3)
104 (6.4)
a Data are expressed as number (percentage) unless otherwise indicated b There are missing values in variables from the ELSA-Brasil cohort (Hypertension, 13;
Diabetes, 3; Smoking, 1; Previous myocardial infarction, 7); valid percentages are reporte c There are missing values in a variable from the SaMi-Trop cohort (Smoking, 6); valid
percentages are reported 10 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Figure 1 - Chronological vs ECG-age. The scatter plots display the relation between
ECG-predicted age and chronological age. The black line is the identity line. The lateral
histograms show the distributions of predicted age and chronological age among patients of the
cohorts. A) CODE-15% cohort, B) ELSA-Brasil cohort, C) SaMi-Trop cohort. The mean ECG
predicted-age was 52 (s.d. 19), 47 (s.d. 11), 63 (s.d. 14), for CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil cohort
and SaMi-Trop cohort, respectively. TABLES AND FIGURES The R squared (Pearson correlation) was 0.71 (r = 0.84) in
the CODE-15%, 0.32 (r=0.57) in ELSA-Brasil cohort and 0.35 (r=0.59) in the SaMi-Trop cohort. Figure 1 - Chronological vs ECG-age. The scatter plots display the relation between
ECG-predicted age and chronological age. The black line is the identity line. The lateral
histograms show the distributions of predicted age and chronological age among patients of the
cohorts. A) CODE-15% cohort, B) ELSA-Brasil cohort, C) SaMi-Trop cohort. The mean ECG
predicted-age was 52 (s.d. 19), 47 (s.d. 11), 63 (s.d. 14), for CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil cohort
and SaMi-Trop cohort, respectively. The R squared (Pearson correlation) was 0.71 (r = 0.84) in
the CODE-15%, 0.32 (r=0.57) in ELSA-Brasil cohort and 0.35 (r=0.59) in the SaMi-Trop cohort. 11 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint Table 2: Risk of death. The table displays the hazard ratios (HR) when the difference between
ECG-age and chronological age are larger than 8 years (either positive or negative). The HR
summarizes the Cox regression models obtained for overall mortality. The models were
adjusted by different selection of variables (including age, sex and cardiovascular risk factors). TABLES AND FIGURES CODE-15% (n = 218169)
ELSA-Brasil (n = 14263)
SaMi-Trop (n=1631)
HR (CI 95%)
p
HR (CI 95%)
p
HR (CI 95%)
p
Adjusted by age and sex
ECG-age > age+8y
0.78 (0.74- 0.83)
<0.001
0.74 (0.63- 0.88)
<0.001
0.89 (0.52- 1.54)
0.681
ECG-age < age-8y
1.79 (1.69- 1.90)
<0.001
1.75 (1.35- 2.27)
<0.001
2.42 (1.53- 3.83)
<0.001
Adjusted by age, sex, hypertension, diabetes mellitus and smoking
ECG-age > age+8y
0.78 (0.74- 0.83)
<0.001
0.82 (0.69- 0.98)
0.030
0.90 (0.52- 1.55)
0.702
ECG-age < age-8y
1.79 (1.68- 1.89)
<0.001
1.56 (1.20- 2.03)
<0.001
2.48 (1.56- 3.94)
<0.001
Adjusted by age, sex, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, smoking and dyslipidemy
ECG-age > age+8y
0.78 (0.74- 0.83)
<0.001
0.82 (0.69- 0.98)
0.030
Not available
ECG-age < age-8y
1.78 (1.68- 1.89)
<0.001
1.56 (1.20- 2.03)
<0.001
Adjusted by age, sex, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, smoking, dyslipidemy and obesity
ECG-age > age+8y
Not available
0.82 (0.69- 0.98)
0.030
Not available
ECG-age < age-8y
1.57 (1.21- 2.04)
<0.001
The number of death events was n=8118 for CODE-15%, n=617 for ELSA-Brasil and n=104 for
SaMi-Trop. When the ECG-age is 8 or more years less than the chronological age n=1861, n=239 and
n=19, respectively, for the CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil and SaMi-Trop cohorts. When the ECG-age is 8 or
more years greater than the chronological age n=1675, n=69 and n=41, respectively. . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint Table 2: Risk of death. The table displays the hazard ratios (HR) when the difference between
ECG-age and chronological age are larger than 8 years (either positive or negative). The HR
summarizes the Cox regression models obtained for overall mortality. The models were
adjusted by different selection of variables (including age, sex and cardiovascular risk factors). ,
SaMi-Trop. When the ECG-age is 8 or more years less than the chronological age n=1861, n=239 and
n=19, respectively, for the CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil and SaMi-Trop cohorts. When the ECG-age is 8 or
more years greater than the chronological age n=1675, n=69 and n=41, respectively. 12 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. TABLES AND FIGURES is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Figure 2 - Adjusted survival curves. The plots display the survival curves for the different
cohorts. The curves are computed from the age and sex-adjusted Cox proportional model for
all-cause mortality. Three groups of patients are taken into consideration: those with ECG-age
8 or more years greater than the chronological age (denoted by: ">8 years older") ; those with
ECG-age within a range of 8 years from their chronological age (denoted by: "± 8 years"); and,
those with ECG-age 8 or more years less than the chronological age (denoted by: ">8 years
younger"). 13 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprin
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y Table 3 - ECG measurements. The table displays the median, and (under parentesis) the
interquartile range, for the ECG measurements. It considers three groups of patients: those with
ECG-age 8 or more years greater than the chronological age (denoted by: ">8 years older") ;
those with ECG-age within a range of 8 years from their chronological age (denoted by: "± 8
years"); and, those with ECG-age 8 or more years less than the chronological age (denoted by:
">8 years younger"). perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021.
;
/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232 .
CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y TABLES AND FIGURES CODE-15% (n=80679)
ELSA-Brasil (n=7691)
± 8 years
>8 years
younger
>8 years
older
p
± 8 years
>8 years
younger
>8 years
older
p
Heart rate
(bpm)
70 (63-78)
70 (62-79)
71 (64-79)
<0.001
66 (61-72)
64 (59-71)
69 (63-75)
<0.001
P duration (ms)
106
(100-114)
108
(100-116)
108 (100-116) <0.001
108
(102-116)
110
(102-116)
108
(100-116)
0.558
QRS axis
47 (27-65)
45 (25-62)
43 (24-60)
<0.001
44 (21-60)
43 (20-61)
44 (19-61)
0.737
QRS duration
(ms)
90 (84-96)
90 (84-96)
92 (84-98)
<0.001
86 (80-92)
86 (82-92)
86 (80-90)
0.068
Average RR
interval (ms)
845
(757-942)
845
(750-950)
837 (750-932) <0.001
-
-
-
-
QTc (ms)
411
(400-424)
413
(401-425)
413 (401-425) <0.001
416
(405-427)
414
(403-426)
418
(406-429)
<0.001 14 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Table 4: Hazard Ratios for normal ECGs. The table displays, for patients with a normal ECG,
the hazard ratios (HR) according to the differences between ECG-age and chronological age. The HR summarizes the Cox regression models obtained for overall mortality. The models were
adjusted by different selection of variables (including age, sex and cardiovascular risk factors). TABLES AND FIGURES CODE-15% (n=80679 )
ELSA-Brasil (n=7691)
HR (CI 95%)
p
HR (CI 95%)
p
Adjusted by age and sex
ECG-age > age+8y
0.66 (0.57 – 0.76)
<0.001
0.91 (0.68 – 1.21)
0.502
ECG-age < age-8y
1.53 (1.30 – 1.80)
<0.001
1.63 (1.00 – 2.66)
0.050
Adjusted by age, sex, hypertension, diabetes mellitus and smoking
ECG-age > age+8y
0.66 (0.57 – 0.76)
<0.001
1.00 (0.75 – 1.33)
0.990
ECG-age < age-8y
1.52 (1.29 - 1.79)
<0.001
1.49 (0.91 – 2.43)
0.114
Adjusted by age, sex, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, smoking and dyslipidemy
ECG-age > age+8y
0.66 (0.57 – 0.76)
<0.001
1.00 (0.75 – 1.33)
0.990
ECG-age < age-8y
1.52 (1.29 - 1.79)
<0.001
1.49 (0.91 – 2.43)
0.114
Adjusted by age, sex, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, smoking, dyslipidemy and obesity
ECG-age > age+8y
Not available
1.00 (0.75 – 1.33)
0.992
ECG-age < age-8y
1.42 (0.86 – 2.35)
0.171
The number of events was n = 1074 for CODE-15% and n = 228 for ELSA-Brasil. The number of
events when ECG-age is 8 or more years less than the chronological age there were, n=249 and n=105
for CODE-15% and ELSA-Brasil, respectively. Considering ECG-age is 8 or more years greater than the
chronological age there were n=203 and n=19 events for CODE-15% and ELSA-Brasil, respectively. Table 4: Hazard Ratios for normal ECGs. The table displays, for patients with a normal ECG,
the hazard ratios (HR) according to the differences between ECG-age and chronological age. The HR summarizes the Cox regression models obtained for overall mortality. The models were
adjusted by different selection of variables (including age, sex and cardiovascular risk factors). The number of events was n = 1074 for CODE-15% and n = 228 for ELSA-Brasil. The events when ECG-age is 8 or more years less than the chronological age there were, n=249 and n=105
for CODE-15% and ELSA-Brasil, respectively. Considering ECG-age is 8 or more years greater than the
chronological age there were n=203 and n=19 events for CODE-15% and ELSA-Brasil, respectively. 15 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. TABLES AND FIGURES is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Figure 3 - Adjusted odds ratios (ORs) for the ELSA-Brasil cohort. The figure shows the
adjusted ORs of the ECG-age being 8 or more years greater than chronological age for risk
factors. A) All patients; and, B) only for patients with normal ECG. The dots represent the
adjusted ORs (by age and sex) and the horizontal lines represent the corresponding 95% CIs. 16 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Supp table 1: Baseline characteristics by ECG-age groups. Display baseline characteristics
for three groups of patients: those with ECG-age 8 or more years greater than the chronological
age (denoted by: ">8 years older") ; those with ECG-age within a range of 8 years from their
chronological age (denoted by: "± 8 years"); and, those with ECG-age 8 or more years less than
the chronological age (denoted by: ">8 years younger"). aData are expressed as numbers (percentage) unless otherwise indicated TABLES AND FIGURES Characteristicsa
CODE-15%
ELSA-Brasil
SaMi-Trop
± 8 years
(n=125706)
>8 years
younger
(n=39455)
>8 years
older
(n=53008)
± 8 years
(n=7710)
>8 years
younger
(n=5353)
>8 years
older
(n=1200)
± 8 year
(n=796)
>8 years
younger
(n=307)
>8 years
older
(n=528)
Sex, Male, n (%)
50821 (40) 15508 (39)
22179
(42)
3403
(44)
2536
(47)
555
(46)
259
(33)
102
(33)
189
(36)
Age, years, mean
(s.d.)
50.5 (20)
63.0 (15)
42.2 (17)
49.0 (12)
55.0 (13)
48.5 (12)
62.0 (20)
64.0 (19)
54.0 (16)
Hypertension, n (%)
36418 (29) 15604 (40)
12745
(24)
2695 (35)
1902
(36)
511 (43)
288 (36)
120 (39)
185 (35)
Diabetes, n (%)
7808 (6)
3462 (9)
2450 (5)
1439 (19) 1121 (21)
280 (23)
81 (10)
38 (12)
42 (8)
Smoking, n (%)
7595 (6)
2522 (6)
3528 (7)
1065 (14)
610 (11)
207 (17)
239 (30)
92 (30)
167 (32)
Previous myocardial
infarction, n (%)
885 (0.7)
358 (0.9)
310 (0.6)
132 (1.7)
95 (1.8)
31 (2.6)
40 (5.0)
7 (2.3)
29 (5.5)
aData are expressed as numbers (percentage) unless otherwise indicated aData are expressed as numbers (percentage) unless otherwise indicated 17 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y Sup Table 2: Medical doctors discerning the ECG-age. The table displays the results for the
ECG reading experiment. Medical doctors annotated 134 ECGs in three rounds. Given two
options A and B, they had to decide which one had an ECG-age 8 or more years greater than
their chronological age. TABLES AND FIGURES Doctors were given the chronological age of the two patients (which
were the same), and two traces. In Stage 2, doctors were given the answer after accomplishing
the task (i.e., whether their assessment was correct), this yielded no difference in Stage 3. Overall, these results suggest that ECG-age captures signals that are non-trivial for doctors to
distinguish. Stage 1
n=45
Acc=64.4%
Stage 2
n=45
Acc=62.2%
Stage 3
n=44
Acc=45.5%
Aggregated
n=134
Correct Answer
Given
Answer
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
19
9
12
6
8
10
41
26
B
7
10
11
16
14
12
30
37
chisq=2.1, p=0.15
chisq=1.96 p=0.16
chisq=0.94 p=0.76
chisq=3.0, p=0.08 Stage 1
n=45
Acc=64.4%
Stage 2
n=45
Acc=62.2%
Stage 3
n=44
Acc=45.5%
Aggregated
n=134
Correct Answer
Given
Answer
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
19
9
12
6
8
10
41
26
B
7
10
11
16
14
12
30
37
chisq=2.1, p=0.15
chisq=1.96 p=0.16
chisq=0.94 p=0.76
chisq=3.0, p=0.08 18 CC-BY 4 0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprin
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232 perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y Sup Fig 1: Saliency maps. TABLES AND FIGURES Illustrative example of ECGs with saliency maps. Saliency maps
are displayed overlayed with the ECG signal. The size of the blue dots superimposed with the
ECG trace is proportional to the partial derivative of the ECG-age prediction regarding that point
of the input tracing. A) A)
B) )
B) B) 19 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
pe petu ty Sup Fig 2: Saliency maps in the frequency domain. We analyze the local sensitivity in the
frequency domain and show the relative importance of each frequency component in the DNN
prediction (see Methods for a precise interpretation). The analysis is performed for 100 normal
ECGs randomly sampled from CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil, and Sami-Trop with similar results. The full line is the median and the shaded region gives the interquartile range over the 100
evaluated samples. ECGs randomly sampled from CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil, and
The full line is the median and the shaded region gives the i
evaluated samples. A) CODE-15%
B) ELSA-Brasil
C) Sami-Trop A) CODE-15%
B) ELSA-Brasil
C) Sami-Trop A) CODE-15% A) CODE-15% B) ELSA-Brasil B) ELSA-Brasil B) ELSA Brasil C) Sami-Trop 20 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y Discussion Biological aging refers to the decline in tissue/organismal function, whereas chronological
aging simply indicates the time passed since birth23. In normally aging individuals, chronological
and biological ages are the same. Biological aging, however, is affected by lifestyle,
environmental factors, inheritable and acquired conditions, and diseases. Accelerated biological
aging points to the decline of tissue/organismal function at a faster rate than the average, and
hence associated with the possibility of a premature death23. Most available biomarkers of
biological age measure a specific aspect of aging, like molecular and cellular biomarkers, and
functional and structural vascular parameters23. ECG exams are low-cost and widely available, being part of the routine evaluation of
many patients in both primary and specialized care. And, previous studies have shown that the
age estimated from the ECG tracing (the ECG-age) is related to cardiovascular health14,15: The
ECG-age, calculated using a Bayesian model in 5-minutes ECGs, tended to be close to the
chronological age in healthy non-athletes, whereas most subjects with risk factors or proven
heart diseases had an ECG-age that was higher than their chronological age14; on another
study, patients with a DNN-predicted age that exceeded chronologic age by 7 or more years
presented a higher frequency of low ejection fraction, hypertension, and coronary disease15. More recently, ECG-derived age has also been related to vascular aging, measured by
peripheral endothelial dysfunction24. In this paper, we use a data-driven approach to obtain a model that predicts age from the
raw ECG tracing. We expect such a model to capture, on average, how aging affects the ECG
exam. In this case, having an ECG-age higher than one's actual age is an indication that the
exam is similar to those of older people, who have a higher associated cardiovascular risk and 21 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . Discussion CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. are more likely to die from cardiovascular diseases. Indeed, we have show that classical
cardiovascular risk factors are associated with having a ECG-age 8 or more years greater than
the chronological age, and for some risk factors, such as hypertension, diabetes mellitus, and
smoking, the association remains even when only normal ECGs were considered (cf. Figure 3). Moreover, this study shows, in three different cohorts, that the difference between the ECG-age
and the chronological age can be used as a marker of the risk of death. From a clinical perspective, ECG-age presents itself as a natural summary index of ECG
changes and abnormalities accumulated during the life course of each subject. ECG tracings
are affected by a large number of factors and mechanisms and, while summarizing them in a
single number is a huge oversimplification, it can still be useful. It transmits the idea of
cardiovascular risk in a language that does not require medical expertise and can be
understood by patients and other professionals without medical training. In the literature, an
AI-based model that predicts the probability of 1-year mortality have been recently proposed8
and could also play a similar role. Nonetheless, reporting the ECG-age seems more intuitive
from a patient perspective and, probably, easier to be used in clinical practice. The analyses suggest that ECG-age is capable of capturing more than traditional ECG
abnormalities
or
underlying
conditions. Over-estimation
of
ECG-age
was
significantly
associated with death after controlling for age and sex, cardiovascular risk factors and, even,
when calculated only for subjects with normal ECGs. In the case of normal ECGs, this
association was significant in CODE-15% but not in the ELSA-Brasil cohort. This might be
explained by the small number of deaths in the ELSA-Brasil cohort or by the poorer annotation
of risk factors in the CODE-15% study, in which this information is self-reported and obtained
during the clinical activity. Moreover, ECG measurements were also not meaningfully different in 22 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Discussion is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y the groups with predicted ECG-age 8 or more years greater than, 8 or more years less than,
and within a range of 8 years from their chronological age. the groups with predicted ECG-age 8 or more years greater than, 8 or more years less than,
and within a range of 8 years from their chronological age. Since the maintenance of a normal ECG status over time is associated with a low risk of
cardiovascular diseases in a dose-response relationship25, we hypothesize that the DNN might
be able identify subtle abnormalities that are not being currently identified in traditional analysis. This could help justify the capacity of evaluating the risk even for apparently normal ECGs. The
lack of capability of trained doctors to distinguish between pairs of normal ECGs of the same
age but different ECG-age (see Sup Table 2) also supports this hypothesis. The advance of interpretable machine learning algorithms26 might make it possible to
leverage the features used by these models into clinical practice. Our initial insights on the
mechanisms used for the estimation of ECG-age - and its prognostic value - suggest that
low-frequency components of the ECG, usually associated with P and T waves, might play an
important role although these considerations would deserve a specific and more detailed
investigation. Our work is perhaps best understood in the context of its limitations. The use of
end-to-end DNN models is central to this work and yielded interesting findings (such as the
possibility of predicting mortality even for apparent normal ECGs). Nonetheless, the complexity
of these models makes it hard to fully interpret the results. Our exploratory analysis included
sensitivity analysis both in the time and frequency domain and the analysis and review of more
than one hundred ECGs by trained cardiologists. While it did provide some insight on what is
being detected by the model, it is far from sufficient to completely explain the findings. Furthermore, while our study demonstrates the potential clinical utility of the ECG-age in
individual risk prediction, further studies are desired to evaluate its incorporation in the clinical 23 . Discussion CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. practise, including its use in addition to established risk calculators for primary prevention of
cardiovascular diseases. To conclude, ECG predicted-age may reflect biological age and it is a promising tool for
risk prediction of overall mortality. It summarizes the information from the ECG in a single index
with a clear interpretation for the patient. Data for training these models are also easy to obtain:
while producing large datasets fully annotated with electrocardiographic abnormalities requires
many hours of work by trained physicians, self-reported age is usually easy information to come
by. Finally, the ability to predict mortality even for normal ECGs suggests that there might still be
subtle electrocardiographic markers and abnormalities that are of interest and are not being
captured in traditional analysis and the models presented here might be a useful tool in trying to
find them. 24 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
d by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021.
;
g/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232 .
CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. .
CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity.
is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021.
;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint The CODE cohort Clinical Outcomes in Digital Electrocardiography (CODE) study18 was developed with the
database of digital ECG exams of the TeleHealth Network of Minas Gerais (TNMG)27,28, Brazil,
linked to the public databases of the Mortality and Hospitalization Information Systems. It was
expected that the consolidated database would be useful for multiple purposes, including the
evaluation of the epidemiological and prognostic significance of ECG findings29 and the
development of new methods of automatic classification of ECG abnormalities3, using both
conventional statistical methods and new machine learning techniques. Patients over 16 years old with a valid ECG performed from 2010 to 2017 were included. Clinical data were self-reported. A hierarchical free-text machine learning algorithm recognized
specific ECG diagnoses from cardiologist reports. The Glasgow ECG Analysis Program
provided Minnesota Codes and automatic diagnostic statements. For the CODE database, the
presence of a specific electrocardiographic diagnosis was considered automatically when there
was an agreement between the diagnosis extracted from the cardiologist report and the
automatic report from Glasgow Diagnostic Statements or Minnesota code. In cases where there
were discordances between medical reports and one of the automatic programs, a manual
revision was done by trained cardiologists18. The electronic cohort was obtained linking data from the ECG exams (name, sex, date of
birth, city of residence) and those from the national mortality information system, using standard
probabilistic linkage methods (FRIL: Fine-grained record linkage software, v.2.1.5, Atlanta, GA). After the linkage, the data was anonymized for storage18. 25 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
p
p
y From a dataset of 2,470,424 ECGs, 1,773,689 patients were identified. After excluding
the ECGs with technical problems and patients under 16 years old, a total of 1,558,415 patients
were included for analyses. The mean age was 51.6 [s.d.17.6] years with 40.2% male. The CODE cohort The
overall mortality rate was 3.34% in a mean follow-up of 3.7 years18. The model was also evaluated in two established cohorts, the São Paulo-Minas Gerais
Tropical Medicine Research Center (SaMi-Trop)20 of Chagas disease patients and the
Longitudinal Study of Adult Health (ELSA-Brasil)19, of Brazilian public servants, in which raw
ECG tracings from the baseline and follow-up with total mortality as the end-point are available. These cohorts are described next. The CODE-15% cohort The CODE-15% is a subset of the CODE cohort. The CODE cohort were divided into
85-15% splits, with the 85% split being used for developing the model and 15% hold-out being
the one used in subsequent analyses and referred to as CODE-15%. This hold-out set is
obtained by stratifying the patients in age groups and random sampling from these groups. The
result is an, approximately, uniform age distribution from years 16 to 85 years by randomly
picking, approximately the same number of exams (3300) in equally-spaced one-year intervals. Only the first patient exam is considered in all the analysis with this cohort. The ELSA-Brasil cohort ELSA-Brasil is a cohort study that aims to investigate the development of chronic
diseases, primarily diabetes and cardiovascular diseases, over a long-term follow-up.30,31 All
active or retired employees of the six institutions (and, in a few instances, also of related
educational or health institutions) from six Brazilian capitals, of both sexes, and with ages
between 35 and 74 years, were eligible for the study. Exclusion criteria were severe cognitive or 26 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. communication impairment, intention to quit work at the institution in the near future for reasons
not related to retirement, and, if retired, residence outside the corresponding metropolitan area. Women with current or recent pregnancy were rescheduled so that the first interview could take
place ≥4 months after delivery. A total of 15,105 participants were enrolled, 6887 men and 8218
women, thus giving reasonably large numbers for sex-specific analyses. Baseline assessment
(2008-10) included detailed interviews and measurements to assess social and biological
determinants of health, as well as various clinical and subclinical conditions related to diabetes,
cardiovascular diseases, and mental health. A second and third visit of interviews and
examinations were done (2012-14 and 2017-2019) to enrich the assessment of cohort
exposures and to detect initial incident events. Annual surveillance has been conducted since
2009 for the ascertainment of incident events. Biological samples (sera, plasma, urine, and
DNA) obtained at both visits have been placed in long-term storage. In a mean of 9.36 years of
follow-up, 14,263 (94,5%)
participants were followed, until 01/01/2020, 617 (4.3%) died and
842 (5.6%) were lost to follow-up. The SaMi-Trop cohort SaMi-Trop is an NIH-funded prospective cohort of 1959 patients with chronic Chagas
cardiomyopathy to evaluate whether a clinical prediction rule based on ECG, brain natriuretic
peptide (BNP) levels, and other biomarkers can be useful in clinical practice.20,32 The study is
being conducted in 21 municipalities of the northern part of Minas Gerais State in Brazil with at
least 2 years of follow-up, including one visit at baseline and another at 24 months. Eligible
patients were selected based on the ECG results performed in 2011–2012 by the Telehealth
Network of Minas Gerais, which from now on will be called index ECG. Only patients who
fulfilled all of the following inclusion criteria were selected: (1) self-reported Chagas disease; (2)
an index ECG reported as abnormal and (3) aged 19 years or more. The exclusion criteria 27 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. included pregnancy or breastfeeding, and any life-threatening disease with an ominous
prognosis that suggested a life expectancy of <2 years. The baseline evaluation included a
collection of sociodemographic information, social determinants of health, health-related
behaviors, comorbidities, medicines in use, history of previous treatment for Chagas disease,
functional class, quality of life, blood sample collection, and ECG. Patients were mostly female,
aged 50–74 years, with low family income and educational level, with known Chagas disease
for >10 years; 46% presented with functional class >II. Previous use of benznidazole was
reported by 25.2% and permanent use of pacemaker by 6.2%. Almost half of the patients
presented with high blood cholesterol and hypertension and one-third of them had diabetes
mellitus. N-terminal of the prohormone BNP (NT- ProBNP) level was >300 pg/mL in 30% of the
sample. The SaMi-Trop cohort Clinical and laboratory markers predictive of severe and progressive Chagas disease
were identified as high NT-ProBNP levels, as well as symptoms of advanced heart failure 32. During a mean follow-up of 2.09 years, 1631 patients were being followed until the 2nd visit. 104
(6.4%) died and 328 (16.7%) were lost to follow-up. Electrocardiographic and clinical definitions in CODE and ELSA-Brasil An ECG was considered “normal” in the CODE cohort according to conventional clinical
reporting and by having automatic measurements by the Glasgow software within the normal
range. In the ELSA-Brasil and Sami-Trop cohorts, ECGs were codified by the Minnesota code,
as described elsewhere,19,33 with manual review of a trained cardiologist. Those with no major or
minor abnormalities according to the criteria were considered normal. All clinical risk factors included in the CODE cohort were self-reported in a clinical
standardized questionnaire. Hypertension, diabetes and dyslipidemia were also considered if
informed use of antihypertensives, oral hypoglycemic agents or insulin, statins or fibrates;
respectively. In the Sami-Trop cohort, the risk factors were also self-reported in a baseline 28 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. interview. In the ELSA-Brasil study, hypertension was defined as systolic blood pressure ≥140
mmHg or diastolic blood pressure ≥90 mmHg, or verified treatment with anti-hypertensive
medication during the past 2 weeks; diabetes mellitus as a report of a previous diagnosis of
diabetes, or the use of medication for diabetes, or meeting a diagnostic value for diabetes
according to one of the following tests: fasting or 2-h plasma glucose obtained during a 75-g
oral glucose tolerance test or HbA1C; dyslipidemia as either a total cholesterol ≥ 240mg/dl, LDL
cholesterol ≥ 160 mg/dl, HDL cholesterol < 40 mg/dl or triglycerides ≥ 150 mg/dl; obesity as BMI
≥30 kg/m2 and smoking by participants self-report. The model All the exams from patients in the 85% split of the CODE cohort were used to develop a
convolutional DNN to predict age. Thesplit was further divided into 80-5% splits: being the first
used to learn the neural network weights, and the 5% remaining samples used for comparing
design choices and adjusting optimization parameters. As we did in the CODE-15% cohort, in
the 5% validation split we guarantee an, approximately, uniform age distribution by picking the
same number of patient exams for equally-spaced one-year intervals. The remaining 80%
training dataset is unbalanced and, to correct it, we weight the exam records inversely
proportional to the frequency of patients with the given age during the training procedure. The architecture and the set of hyperparameters are described next and are similar to a
previous study3, for which the DNN was trained to detect 6 types of ECG abnormalities
(considered representative of both rhythmic and morphologic ECG abnormalities) on the same
dataset. The results with this choice of hyperparameters were considered satisfactory and no
further hyperparameter search was performed. 29 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. We used a convolutional neural network similar to the residual network proposed for
image classification21, but adapted to unidimensional signals. This architecture allows deep
neural networks to be efficiently trained by including skip connections. We have adopted the
modification in the residual block proposed by He et. al.34. All ECG recordings, which have between 7 and 10 seconds of duration and are sampled
at frequencies ranging from 300 to 1000Hz, are re-sampled to 400 Hz and zero-padded,
resulting in signals of fixed length (4096 samples), which are fed to the neural network. The
output is the age-predicted for that given exam. The model The network consists of a convolutional layer followed by 5 residual blocks with two
convolutional layers per block. The output of each convolutional layer is rescaled using batch
normalization35 and fed into a rectified linear activation unit ReLU. Dropout36 is applied after the
nonlinearity. The convolutional layers have filter length 17, starting with 4096 samples and 64
filters for the first layer and residual block and increasing the number of filters by 64 and
subsampling by a factor of 4 every residual block. Max Pooling37 and convolutional layers with
filter length 1 are included in the skip connections to make the dimensions match those from the
signals in the main branch. The mean square error is minimized using Adam optimizer38 with default parameters and
a learning rate of 0.001. The learning rate is reduced by a factor of 10 whenever the validation
loss does not present any improvement for 7 consecutive epochs. The neural network weights
were initialized sampling from a normal random variable scaled as in He et. al.39 and the bias
was initialized with zeros. The training runs for 70 epochs with the final model being the one
with the best validation results during the optimization process. Cardiologist assessment of ECG-age from the tracings 30 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. To assess whether ECG-age was capturing ECG changes that are recognizable to
medical doctors, we conducted an additional experiment asking three experienced medical
doctors to identify, in paired ECGs, ECG tracings associated with having higher ECG-age. All
ECGs considered were normal ECGs from the CODE cohort. Within each pair of equal
chronological age and sex, one individual had an ECG-age 8 or more years greater than their
chronological age and the other had an ECG-age 8 or more years less than their chronological
age. We included one pair of male and one pair of female patients for each age between 16 and
85 (whenever possible), totaling 134 pairs. At the edges of our age-range, it was not always
possible to have an ECG tracing with ECG-age 8 or more years smaller than the chronological
age paired 8 years or more years less than the chronological age, and, in these situations, we
use tracings associated with ECG-ages within the 8 years range of the patient’s chronological
age. The experiment was divided into three stages where doctors annotated 44, 45, and 45
pairs of ECGs tracings respectively. In stages 1 and 3, doctors were not given the answer after
accomplishing the task, and in stage 2 they were. The idea behind this distinction is to see
whether doctors would fare any better after a round with explicit feedback on their performance. of the signal at the given point, and might be interpreted as the relative importance of the given
point to the model prediction (at least in terms of the linearized local analysis). of the signal at the given point, and might be interpreted as the relative importance of the given
point to the model prediction (at least in terms of the linearized local analysis). of the signal at the given point, and might be interpreted as the relative importance of the given
point to the model prediction (at least in terms of the linearized local analysis). In Sup Fig 2, we show a similar analysis, but now in the frequency domain. We take discrete
Fourier transform of the gradients computed as described above. We do that for 100 ECG
exams, sampled at random, from the ECG exams classified as normal in each of the three
different cohorts (CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil and SaMi-Trop) and show the median and
interquartile range in the Figure. Saliency maps in the time and frequency domain We performed an analysis to assess the relative importance of different segments of the
ECG trace in the age prediction. The saliency maps intensity at each point is proportional to the
norm of the partial derivatives of the predicted age in relation to the input. These values are
computed through a single back-propagation pass through the DNN22. Similar approaches have
been pursued in the interpretation of other DNN-based ECG predictors8,40. We then generated
ECGs superposed with the saliency maps as in Sup Fig 1. The colored dot sizes are
proportional to the magnitude of the partial derivative of the output with regard to the magnitude 31 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Schoenfeld residuals. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve
(AUC) was
used to evaluate the Cox model performance for 1-year mortality risk prediction. Schoenfeld residuals. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve
(AUC) was
used to evaluate the Cox model performance for 1-year mortality risk prediction. Schoenfeld residuals. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve
(AUC) was
used to evaluate the Cox model performance for 1-year mortality risk prediction. To explore the association of risk factors with the ECG-age being 8 or more years greater
than chronological age we performed a logistic regression analysis for the ELSA-Brasil cohort
including all ECG and only subjects with normal ECG. In this analysis we fitted a model for each
risk factor adjusted by age and sex and reported the ORs and 95% confidence intervals. Acknowledgments This research was partly supported by the Brazilian Agencies CNPq, CAPES, and FAPEMIG,
by projects IATS, INCT-Cyber and Atmosphere, and by the Wallenberg AI, Autonomous
Systems and Software Program (WASP) funded by Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation. The
ELSA-Brasil‐Brasil study was supported by the Brazilian Ministries of Health and of Science
and Technology (grants 01060010.00RS, 01060212.00BA, 01060300.00ES, 01060278.00MG,
01060115.00SP, and 01060071.00RJ). 5U19AI098461-07). The SaMi‐Trop cohort study is
supported by the National Institutes of Health (P50 AI098461‐02 and U19AI098461‐06). AHR,
BBD, PAL, SMB, LG, WMJr, and ALR are recipients of unrestricted research scholarships from
CNPq; EMS and AHR received scholarships from CAPES and CNPq; and DMO, WMJr and
ALPR received a Google Latin America Research Award scholarship. None of the funding
agencies had any role in the design, analysis or interpretation of the study. We also thank
NVIDIA for awarding our project with a Titan V GPU. Statistical analysis To assess the performance of the DNN model in the CODE-15%, ELSA-Brasil and
SaMi-Trop cohorts, we computed the R square metric using linear regression and calculated the
mean absolute error (MAE) using the chronological age. For further analysis, we divided the
samples in three groups, based in differences between predicted ECG-age and chronological
age: those with ECG-age 8 or more years less than the chronological age, those with ECG-age
within a range of 8 years from their chronological age, and those ECG-age 8 or more years
greater than the chronological age. For mortality analysis, we used Cox proportional regression model, reporting hazard
ratios (HR) and 95% confidence intervals (95%CI). The analysis was performed in all ECGs of
the three cohorts, with two levels of adjustments: age and sex; age, sex, and other cardiac risk
factors (hypertension, diabetes mellitus, smoking). Other two models in the second level of
adjustment including dyslipidemia, for CODE-15% and ELSA-Brasil, and obesity, only for
ELSA-Brasil, were fitted. A second mortality analysis with the same parameters, was performed
considering only normal ECGs from CODE-15% (n=80679) and ELSA-Brasil (n=7691) cohorts. The proportional hazard assumption was verified using a log (-log (survival)) plot and 32 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Ethics declarations This study complies with all relevant ethical regulations. CODE Study was approved by the
Research
Ethics
Committee
of
the
Universidade
Federal
de
Minas
Gerais,
protocol
49368496317.7.0000.5149. Since this is a secondary analysis of anonymized data stored in
the TNMG, informed consent was not required by the Research Ethics Committee for the
present study. ELSA-Brasil was approved by the Research Ethics Committees of the
participating institutions and by the National Committee for Research Ethics (CONEP 976/2006)
of the Ministry of Health. Sami-Trop study was approved by the Brazilian National Institutional
Review Board (CONEP), No. 179.685/2012. In both investigations, all human subjects were
adults who gave written informed consent. All researchers who deal with datasets signed terms
of confidentiality and data utilization. None of the authors have financial and non-financial competing interests. None of the authors have financial and non-financial competing interests. Contribution statement E.M.L., G.M.M.P., A.H.R., T.B.S. and A.L.R. were responsible for the study design. A.L.R. conceived the project and acted as the project leader. A.H.R. choose the architecture,
implemented and tuned the deep neural network. E.M.L did the survival analysis and all the
statistical tests. G.M.M.P. and A.L.R. interpreted the results and provided clinical interpretation. A.H.R., D.M.O., P.R.G. were responsible for preprocessing the training data. P.R.G was
responsible for maintaining and extracting the CODE database. M.M.P.F, E.C.S., S.M.B., L.G.,
B.B.D. were responsible for cohort design and management, data acquisition, follow-up and 33 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
pe petu ty ECG exams in ELSA-Brasil and Sami-Trop cohorts. G.M.M.P., A.H.R., E.M.L., W.M.Jr., T.B.S. and A.L.R. contributed to the writing and all authors revised it critically for important intellectual
content. All authors read and approved the submitted manuscript. ECG exams in ELSA-Brasil and Sami-Trop cohorts. G.M.M.P., A.H.R., E.M.L., W.M.Jr., T.B.S. and A.L.R. contributed to the writing and all authors revised it critically for important intellectual
content. All authors read and approved the submitted manuscript. Data Availability: Upon publication,
some of the cohorts used in the model evaluation will be made available. Information about mortality, age, sex, the ECG tracings and the flag indicating whether the ECG
tracing is normal will be made available with no restriction for the Sami-Trop cohort and for the
CODE-15% cohorts. The DNN model parameters that give the results presented in this paper
will also be made available without restrictions. This should allow the reader to partially
reproduce the results presented in the paper. Restrictions apply to additional clinical information
on these two cohorts, to the full CODE cohort and to the ELSA-Brasil cohort, for which requests
will be considered on an individual basis by the Telehealth Network of Minas Gerais and by
ELSA-Brasil Steering Committee. Any data use will be restricted to non-commercial research 34 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. purposes, and the data will only be made available on the execution of appropriate data use
agreements. purposes, and the data will only be made available on the execution of appropriate data use
agreements. Code Availability: The
code
for
the
model
training,
evaluation
and
statistical
analysis
is
available
at
https://github.com/antonior92/ecg-age-prediction. References 1. Topol, E. J. High-performance medicine: the convergence of human and artificial intelligence. Nat. Med. 25,
44–56 (2019). 2. Shah, A. P. & Rubin, S. A. Errors in the computerized electrocardiogram interpretation of cardiac rhythm. J. Electrocardiol. 40, 385–390 (2007). 3. Ribeiro, A. H. et al. Automatic diagnosis of the 12-lead ECG using a deep neural network. Nat. Commun. 11,
1760 (2020). 4. Hannun, A. Y. et al. Cardiologist-level arrhythmia detection and classification in ambulatory
electrocardiograms using a deep neural network. Nat. Med. 25, 65–69 (2019). 4. Hannun, A. Y. et al. Cardiologist-level arrhythmia detection and classification in ambulatory
electrocardiograms using a deep neural network. Nat. Med. 25, 65–69 (2019). 5. Macfarlane, P. W., Devine, B. & Clark, E. The university of glasgow (Uni-G) ECG analysis program. in Computers
in Cardiology 451–454 (2005). 5. Macfarlane, P. W., Devine, B. & Clark, E. The university of glasgow (Uni-G) ECG analysis program. in Computers
in Cardiology 451–454 (2005). 6. Meira, W., Ribeiro, A. L. P., Oliveira, D. M. & Ribeiro, A. H. Contextualized interpretable machine learning for
medical diagnosis. Commun. ACM 63, 56–58 (2020). 7. Han, X. et al. Deep learning models for electrocardiograms are susceptible to adversarial attack. Nat. Med. 26, 360–363 (2020). 7. Han, X. et al. Deep learning models for electrocardiograms are susceptible to adversarial attack. Nat. Med. 26, 360–363 (2020). 8. Raghunath, S. et al. Prediction of mortality from 12-lead electrocardiogram voltage data using a deep neural
network. Nat. Med. (2020) doi:10.1038/s41591-020-0870-z. 8. Raghunath, S. et al. Prediction of mortality from 12-lead electrocardiogram voltage data using a deep neural
network. Nat. Med. (2020) doi:10.1038/s41591-020-0870-z. 9. Attia, Z. I. et al. An artificial intelligence-enabled ECG algorithm for the identification of patients with atrial
fibrillation during sinus rhythm: a retrospective analysis of outcome prediction. Lancet (2019) doi:10/gf7d9h. 10. Attia, Z. I. et al. Screening for cardiac contractile dysfunction using an artificial intelligence–enabled 9. Attia, Z. I. et al. An artificial intelligence-enabled ECG algorithm for the identification of patients with atrial
fibrillation during sinus rhythm: a retrospective analysis of outcome prediction. Lancet (2019) doi:10/gf7d9h. 9. Attia, Z. I. et al. An artificial intelligence-enabled ECG algorithm for the identification of patients with atrial
fibrillation during sinus rhythm: a retrospective analysis of outcome prediction. Lancet (2019) doi:10/gf7d9h. 10. Attia, Z. I. et al. Screening for cardiac contractile dysfunction using an artificial intelligence–enabled
electrocardiogram. Nat. Med. 25, 70–74 (2019). 10. Attia, Z. I. References et al. Screening for cardiac contractile dysfunction using an artificial intelligence–enabled
electrocardiogram. Nat. Med. 25, 70–74 (2019). 35 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. 11. Rezaeian, P. et al. ASSOCIATION OF MAJOR AND MINOR ELECTROCARDIOGRAPHIC ABNORMALITIES WITH
CARDIOVASCULAR MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY IN THE MULTI-ETHNIC STUDY OF ATHEROSCLEROSIS COHORT. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 67, 831 (2016). 12. Pinto-Filho, M. M. et al. Prognostic value of electrocardiographic abnormalities in adults from the Brazilian
longitudinal study of adults’ health. Heart (2020) doi:10.1136/heartjnl-2020-318097. 13. US Preventive Services Task Force et al. Screening for Cardiovascular Disease Risk With Electrocardiography:
US Preventive Services Task Force Recommendation Statement. JAMA 319, 2308–2314 (2018). 14. Ball, R. L., Feiveson, A. H., Schlegel, T. T., Starc, V. & Dabney, A. R. Predicting ‘heart age’ using
electrocardiography. J Pers Med 4, 65–78 (2014). 15. Attia, Z. I. et al. Age and Sex Estimation Using Artificial Intelligence From Standard 12-Lead ECGs. Circ. Arrhythm. Electrophysiol. 12, e007284 (2019). 16. Vicent, L. & Martínez-Sellés, M. Electrocardiogeriatrics: ECG in advanced age. J. Electrocardiol. 50, 698–700
(2017). 17. Palhares, D. M. F. et al. Normal limits of the electrocardiogram derived from a large database of Brazilian
primary care patients. BMC Cardiovasc. Disord. 17, 152 (2017). 18. Ribeiro, A. L. P. et al. Tele-electrocardiography and bigdata: The CODE (Clinical Outcomes in Digital
Electrocardiography) study. J. Electrocardiol. (2019) doi:10.1016/j.jelectrocard.2019.09.008. 19. Pinto-Filho, M. M. et al. Major Electrocardiographic Abnormalities According to the Minnesota Coding System
Among Brazilian Adults (from the ELSA-Brasil Cohort Study). Am. J. Cardiol. 119, 2081–2087 (2017). 20. Di Lorenzo Oliveira, C. et al. Risk Score for Predicting 2-Year Mortality in Patients With Chagas
Cardiomyopathy From Endemic Areas: SaMi-Trop Cohort Study. J. Am. Heart Assoc. 9, e014176 (2020). 21. He, K., Zhang, X., Ren, S. & Sun, J. References Deep Residual Learning for Image Recognition. 2016 IEEE Conference on
Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR) (2016) doi:10.1109/cvpr.2016.90. 22. Simonyan, K., Vedaldi, A. & Zisserman, A. Deep Inside Convolutional Networks: Visualising Image
Classification Models and Saliency Maps. arXiv:1312.6034 [cs] (2013). 23. Hamczyk, M. R., Nevado, R. M., Barettino, A., Fuster, V. & Andrés, V. Biological Versus Chronological Aging:
JACC Focus Seminar. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 75, 919–930 (2020). 23. Hamczyk, M. R., Nevado, R. M., Barettino, A., Fuster, V. & Andrés, V. Biological Versus Chronological Aging:
JACC Focus Seminar. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 75, 919–930 (2020). 36 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for thi
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. 24. Toya, T., Ahmad, A., Attia, Z. & Cohen‐Shelly, M. Vascular Aging Detected by Peripheral Endothelial
Dysfunction Is Associated With ECG‐Derived Physiological Aging. Journal of the (2021). 25. Soliman, E. Z. et al. Usefulness of Maintaining a Normal Electrocardiogram Over Time for Predicting
Cardiovascular Health. Am. J. Cardiol. 119, 249–255 (2017). 26. The Lancet Respiratory Medicine. Opening the black box of machine learning. Lancet Respir Med 6, 801
(2018). 27. Ribeiro, A. L. P. et al. Implementation of a telecardiology system in the state of Minas Gerais: the Minas
Telecardio Project. Arq. Bras. Cardiol. 95, 70–78 (2010). 28. Alkmim, M. B. et al. Improving patient access to specialized health care: the Telehealth Network of Minas
Gerais, Brazil. Bull. World Health Organ. 90, 373–378 (2012). 29. Paixão, G. M. M. et al. References is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for th
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
was not certified by peer review)
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi: . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
pe petu ty References Evaluation of mortality in bundle branch block patients from an electronic cohort:
Clinical Outcomes in Digital Electrocardiography (CODE) study. J. Electrocardiol. (2019)
doi:10.1016/j.jelectrocard.2019.09.004. 30. Aquino, E. M. L. et al. Brazilian Longitudinal Study of Adult Health (ELSA-Brasil): objectives and design. Am. J. Epidemiol. 175, 315–324 (2012). 31. Schmidt, M. I. et al. Cohort Profile: Longitudinal Study of Adult Health (ELSA-Brasil). Int. J. Epidemiol. 44,
68–75 (2015). 32. Cardoso, C. S. et al. Longitudinal study of patients with chronic Chagas cardiomyopathy in Brazil (SaMi-Trop
project): a cohort profile. BMJ Open 6, e011181 (2016). 33. Brito, B. O. de F. et al. Association between typical electrocardiographic abnormalities and NT-proBNP
elevation in a large cohort of patients with Chagas disease from endemic area. J. Electrocardiol. 51,
1039–1043 (2018). 34. He, K., Zhang, X., Ren, S. & Sun, J. Identity Mappings in Deep Residual Networks. in Computer Vision – ECCV
2016 630–645 (Springer International Publishing, 2016). 34. He, K., Zhang, X., Ren, S. & Sun, J. Identity Mappings in Deep Residual Networks. in Computer Vision – ECCV
2016 630–645 (Springer International Publishing, 2016). 35. Ioffe, S. & Szegedy, C. Batch Normalization: Accelerating Deep Network Training by Reducing Internal
Covariate Shift. arXiv [cs.LG] (2015). 35. Ioffe, S. & Szegedy, C. Batch Normalization: Accelerating Deep Network Training by Reducing Internal
Covariate Shift. arXiv [cs.LG] (2015). 36. Srivastava, N., Hinton, G., Krizhevsky, A., Sutskever, I. & Salakhutdinov, R. Dropout: a simple way to prevent 36. Srivastava, N., Hinton, G., Krizhevsky, A., Sutskever, I. & Salakhutdinov, R. Dropout: a simple way to prevent 37 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in
(which was not certified by peer review)
preprint
The copyright holder for this
this version posted February 23, 2021. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.02.19.21251232
doi:
medRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
It is made available under a
perpetuity. neural networks from overfitting. J. Mach. Learn. Res. 15, 1929–1958 (2014). neural networks from overfitting. J. Mach. Learn. Res. 15, 1929–1958 (2014). 37. Scherer, D., Müller, A. & Behnke, S. Evaluation of Pooling Operations in Convolutional Architectures for Object
Recognition. in Artificial Neural Networks – ICANN 2010 92–101 (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2010). 37. Scherer, D., Müller, A. & Behnke, S. Evaluation of Pooling Operations in Convolutional Architectures for Object
Recognition. in Artificial Neural Networks – ICANN 2010 92–101 (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2010). 38. Kingma, D. P. & Ba, J. Adam: A Method for Stochastic Optimization. arXiv [cs.LG] (2014). 38. Kingma, D. P. & Ba, J. Adam: A Method for Stochastic Optimization. arXiv [cs.LG] (2014). 39. He, K., Zhang, X., Ren, S. & Sun, J. Delving deep into rectifiers: Surpassing human-level performance on
imagenet classification. in Proceedings of the IEEE international conference on computer vision 1026–1034
(2015). 40. Strodthoff, N., Wagner, P., Schaeffter, T. & Samek, W. Deep Learning for ECG Analysis: Benchmarks and
Insights from PTB-XL. IEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics 1–1 (2020)
doi:10.1109/jbhi.2020.3022989. 38
|
W4366827193.txt
|
https://www.mdpi.com/2223-7747/12/9/1736/pdf?version=1682212223
|
en
|
Strategies for Engineering Virus Resistance in Potato
|
Plants
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 9,602
|
plants
Review
Strategies for Engineering Virus Resistance in Potato
Jiecai Liu 1,† , Jianying Yue 1,† , Haijuan Wang 1 , Lingtai Xie 1 , Yuanzheng Zhao 2 , Mingmin Zhao 1, *
and Hongyou Zhou 1, *
1
2
*
†
College of Horticulture and Plant Protection, Inner Mongolia Agricultural University, Hohhot 010018, China
Inner Mongolia Academy of Agricultural and Animal Husbandry Sciences, Hohhot 010031, China
Correspondence: mingminzh@163.com (M.Z.); hongyouzhou2002@aliyun.com.cn (H.Z.);
Tel.: +86-471-6385801 (M.Z.); +86-471-6385692 (H.Z.)
These authors contributed equally to this work.
Abstract: Potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) is an important vegetable crop that plays a pivotal role in the
world, especially given its potential to feed the world population and to act as the major staple food
in many developing countries. Every year, significant crop loss is caused by viral diseases due to a
lack of effective agrochemical treatments, since only transmission by insect vectors can be combated
with the use of insecticides, and this has been an important factor hindering potato production. With
the rapid development of molecular biology and plant genetic engineering technology, transgenic
approaches and non-transgenic techniques (RNA interference and CRISPR-cas9) have been effectively
employed to improve potato protection against devastating viruses. Moreover, the availability of
viral sequences, potato genome sequences, and host immune mechanisms has remarkably facilitated
potato genetic engineering. In this study, we summarize the progress of antiviral strategies applied
in potato through engineering either virus-derived or plant-derived genes. These recent molecular
insights into engineering approaches provide the necessary framework to develop viral resistance in
potato in order to provide durable and broad-spectrum protection against important viral diseases of
solanaceous crops.
Keywords: potato; viral resistance; engineering; RNAi
Citation: Liu, J.; Yue, J.; Wang, H.;
Xie, L.; Zhao, Y.; Zhao, M.; Zhou, H.
Strategies for Engineering Virus
Resistance in Potato. Plants 2023, 12,
1736. https://doi.org/10.3390/
plants12091736
Academic Editor: Takeshi Kanto
Received: 1 March 2023
Revised: 12 April 2023
Accepted: 18 April 2023
Published: 22 April 2023
Copyright: © 2023 by the authors.
Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland.
This article is an open access article
distributed under the terms and
conditions of the Creative Commons
Attribution (CC BY) license (https://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/
4.0/).
1. Introduction
Potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) is an important solanaceous food crop. It has the
potential to feed the populating world and especially to act as the major staple food
in many developing countries. Compared with other food crops, potato contains more
nutrition reagents, including proteins, carbohydrates, and minerals [1]. The human need
for food safety drives the high-quality development of potato and has provided many ways
to meet rising food demands, especially in food-deficit countries.
However, an important problem in potato production is the degradation of seed
potatoes caused by viral diseases, which has been an important factor restricting potato
production for a long time. After infection by viral diseases, symptoms on leaves or tubers
such as necrotic mosaic and overall stunted growth appear, which can result in yield
decreases and poor-quality tubers. Commonly, potato production losses caused by viral
infection in potato can reach up to 20~30% with serious production reductions of more
than 80%.
Up to now, around 40 different viruses and 2 viroid species have been known to infect
potato [2]. Among them, potato virus Y (PVY; genus Potyvirus), potato leafroll virus (PLRV;
genus Polerovirus), and potato virus X (PVX; genus Potexvirus) are the most important
viruses that cause significant potato production losses worldwide [3–5]. Once these viruses
invade potato plants or tubers, they exhibit a variety of degradation types, including mosaic,
such as leaf curl and necrosis, bundle top, plant dwarfing, and leaf yellowing. Young leaves
show discoloration and shrinkage. Tubers become small, cracked, and pointed; show
Plants 2023, 12, 1736. https://doi.org/10.3390/plants12091736
https://www.mdpi.com/journal/plants
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
2 of 14
internal network necrosis; and in most cases lose germination ability and cannot be planted.
There is a significant difference between these viruses and other pathogens; that is, after
the virus particles enter the plant body with the help of other factors (such as insects, plant
wounds caused by humans, natural factors, etc.), they use the information, energy, and
enzyme systems of plant cells to complete the replication and proliferation of the virus
itself. This plant virus proliferation mechanism brings great difficulty to the prevention
and control of viral diseases.
At present, although virus-free seed potato used in production can reduce the damage
of virus disease, virus reinfection in the field in the middle and late growth stages can
also lead to a significant reduction in yield. Moreover, although virus-free seed potato
technology has become well established, some viruses (such as PVS) are difficult to remove,
leading to the need to manually remove infected plants in the production of field seed
potato, which is time-consuming and costly.
Potato is a hetero-tetraploid plant, and it is very difficult to develop antiviral varieties
via conventional breeding methods. Cultivating virus-free seed potato through stem tip
detoxification is an effective preventive measure in controlling potato viruses. However,
plants may still be infected by various viruses during the growth seasons, sometimes even
to the extent of epidemic disease.
With the rapid development of molecular biology and plant genetic engineering
technology, generating crops with enhanced viral resistance has become a reality. Virus
resistance in potato has been engineered through different approaches via traditional plant
breeding and genetic engineering [1]. Virus resistance in plants has been obtained through
the transgenic expression of viral proteins and non-viral factors. These strategies will lead to
highly effective and broad-spectrum resistance to virus disease in plants [6]. Notably, RNA
interference (RNAi)-mediated resistance targeting the viral coat protein (CP) of PVY, PVX,
PLRV, and potato virus S (PVS) in potato has been reported [7] to confer resistance [8,9].
At the application level, genetically modified (GM) potatoes, including virus-resistant
potatoes generated through genetic engineering, are currently being incorporated and
commercialized in some countries [10].
2. Engineering Virus-Derived Viral Resistance in Potato
Since virus-resistant transgenic tobacco was obtained by transforming the CP gene
of the tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) [11], the antiviral genetic engineering of plants has
developed rapidly. With respect to potato antiviral gene engineering, researchers have
made some progress in exploring the viral CP gene, viral protein gene, viral replicase gene,
and viral RNA to create genetically engineered antiviral potato germplasm.
Given that CP-mediated resistance to viruses has represented one of the successes of
plant genetic engineering [6], the CP gene of some potato viruses, such as PVY, PVX, and
PLRV, has been cloned and transferred into potato successively to obtain virus-resistant
potato plants [12–14]. In certain cases, resistant plants have been applied in the field for
several years.
Viral CP has a variety of functions, including the ability to wrap the nucleic acid of
a virus and to determine the host range of infection. The application of viral CP genes in
potato antiviral gene engineering is based on viral CP genes inhibiting virus uncoating so
as to block virus infection. Recently, it has been found that CP can bind to the nucleus and
acts as a trans-acting factor to regulate the expression of nuclear genes so that the virus
can successfully complete assembly in the host cytoplasm. In addition, CP-mediated viral
resistance is caused by an important mechanism of cross-protection in potato.
In most cases, this antiviral ability is only against the CP-donor virus or a few strains of
the virus that are very closely related. Moreover, CP-mediated resistance often only delays
infection time and cannot achieve complete antiviral ability to resist. Plants transformed
with the CP gene are only protected from low doses of the virus. Once the viral vaccination
is changed, plants become not at all resistant to viral infection. This places a strict limit on
field application.
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
3 of 14
The application of viral CP genes could also become a problem with respect to virus
transmission where plants are transformed with the CP of a virus spreading via an insect
vector in the field. It is reported that transgenic CP can encapsidate heterologous viral
RNAs by which it may help the virus to gain aphid transmission ability [15,16]. For example, the transgenic expression of the CP of PLRV can encapsulate and promote the aphid
transmission of viroid RNAs. In some cases, the transgene or its RNA product can recombine with an inoculated virus to generate a variant with novel biological properties [17]. To
overcome these problems, efforts have been made to improve coat-protein-mediated virus
resistance by combining different viral CP in the same plant or by conjugating coat protein
genes with satellite RNA into plant cells to obtain a broader antiviral spectrum.
Replicase is an RNA polymerase encoded by viral genes that can specifically synthesize
the positive- and negative-strand RNA of viruses. Functionally, it is similar to RNAdependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). During viral replication, replicase utilizes the plus
strands of viral RNA as a template to synthesize negative-stranded RNA and then uses
negative-stranded RNA as a template for synthesizing plus-stranded RNA. In most viruses,
replicase is a replicase complex formed by the combination of virus-encoded proteins and
host components. In one study, highly PVX-resistant transgenic potatoes were obtained by
introducing partial or full-length replicase genes of PVX [18]. Further, transgenic potatoes
with the full-length sequence of the PVY NIb gene with 381 deletions at the 5’ end and the
antisense RNA of NIb were generated and showed high PVY resistance [19]. To obtain
PLRV-resistant plants, the 30 terminal sequence and 50 terminal sequence of the potato leaf
roll virus (PLRY) replicase gene (ORF2b) were introduced into potato.
Studies have shown that the transcription of a gene with the deletion of replicase
can mediate viral resistance, but resistance is far stronger when the deletion of the RNA
transcription is translated into the deletion of the replicase.
Compared with resistance mediated by CP, resistance mediated by replicase has been
found to be stronger, showing resistance to high concentrations of virion and viral RNA
(500 µg/mL). However, replicase-mediated resistance is more specific; that is, the replicase
gene of a virus transferred into plants is only resistant to the same virus but not to another
strain. Since plant RNA viruses mutate quickly and easily produce different strains, it is
difficult to use replicase-mediated resistance in the field.
Antisense RNAs (asRNAs) are complementary to messenger RNA (mRNA) strands
transcribed within cells [20]. asRNAs occur in nature but normally cannot be detected.
However, synthetic RNAs directed at specific targets have been widely studied for their
inhibition of gene action. The effect of antisense RNA occurs mainly in transcription as well
as in the processing of transcripts. Antisense RNA for acquiring antiviral infection capability
and protecting plants from systemic infection has been successfully established. Antisense
RNA techniques that aim to encode templates can be applied to many viruses, especially
those whose product is spread by aphids or whose infection is limited to specific tissues,
such as PLRV. Transgenic potato plants expressing complementary RNA with the PLRV CP
gene have shown similar resistance to viral infection as transgenic plants expressing the
PLRV CP gene. Lindbo and Dougherty believe that transcription accumulation leads to
further replication in the middle of righteous RNA interference in negative replication [21].
Since antisense transcriptions cannot be transferred to the cytoplasmic replication
region, the antisense RNA of CP is difficult to use against highly effective viruses such as
PVY. Due to the insufficient expression of antisense RNA, antisense RNA-directed resistance
is weak, which leads to the unsatisfactory application of antisense RNA technology to
obtain antiviral infection in practice. Nevertheless, it is worth remaining open to the
possibility of improving the expression amount of antisense RNA.
3. Engineering Virus-Resistant Plants Using Plant Endogenous Genes in Potato
With the exploration of host–virus interaction, more scientists have become focused
on the engineering of virus-resistant plants using plant endogenous genes. At present,
antiviral genes of potato have been found in both wild and cultivated species, which are
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
4 of 14
usually divided into extreme resistance (ER) genes and hypersensitive resistance (HR)
genes. ER genes are resistant to many viruses and can effectively prevent the reproduction
of viruses in the early stages of infection. Evidence has shown that plants expressing
ER typically will remain symptomless and experience extremely low viral accumulation
in inoculated leaves [22,23], whereas HR can be activated to effectively restrict pathogen
growth during host as well as non-host interactions [24]. The HR gene is resistant to various
virus species and is a quick defense response to local cell necrosis after virus infection,
limiting the further expansion of the virus. Host resistance to both ER and HR in potato has
been recognized against PVY [25–27]. In potato cultivars, Ry genes confer ER to all PVY
strains. The Rysto gene (located on chromosome XII) from S. stoloniferum [28,29], the Ryadg
gene (located on chromosome XI) from S. tuberosum ssp. andigena [30], and the Rychc gene
(located on chromosome IX) from S. chacoense [31] were identified to confer ER, and the
Rychc gene was also found to confer extreme resistance to PVY [32]. In addition, the genes
Ryadg, Rysto, and Rychc derived from other potato cultivars such as S. tuberosum subsp.
andigena Hawkes, S. stoloniferum Schlechtd. Et Bché., and S. chacoense Bitt., respectively,
have been used in potato breeding programs [25,31,33–36].
In exploring how PVY CP is recognized by Rysto, it has been demonstrated that Rysto
associates directly with central 149 amino acids of the CP domain in PVY [37]. Each deletion
mutant of the CP core region affects the ability of Rysto to trigger defense. The appropriate
folding of the CP core is crucial to Rysto-mediated recognition [37]. This sheds light on
its potential utility in engineering virus resistance in various crops. The Y-1 gene was
identified in S. tuberosum ssp. andigena and was found to be recognized by PVY, inducing
cell death without preventing the systemic spread of PVY in potato [38]. Moreover, the LRR
or other regions of the Y-1 gene might be developed into a useful resistance gene for potato
breeding. Y-1 is located in potato chromosome XI in an R gene cluster, which includes the
gene Na for HR to PVA and the gene Ryadg for ER to PVY [23,30,39]. More recently, gene
G-Ry, a homolog of Y-1, was isolated and observed to enhance resistance to PVY [40].
In potato, strain-specific Ny genes in several popular potato cultivars have exhibited
HR against PVY [41–44]. Ny-1 from potato cultivar Rywal, a hypersensitivity gene, confers
HR against both common and necrotic strains of PVY. Similar to various resistance genes in
solanaceous genomes, Ny-1 was mapped on the short arm of potato chromosome IX. The
expression of HR was temperature-dependent in potato cultivar Rywal. Strains PVYO
and PVYN and subgroups PVYNW and PVYNTN were effectively restricted in plants at
20 ◦ C. When plants were grown at 28 ◦ C, viruses could systemically spread but without
symptoms [41,43]. In field trials, PVY was restricted to inoculated leaves, and PVY-free
tubers were produced [41,43]. Further, an HR gene Ny-2 conferring resistance to PVY was
mapped on potato chromosome XI in potato cultivar Romula [44].
The Nytbr gene was identified on chromosome IV, although this location was not
consistent with any other resistance genes in potato [45]. Nytbr was identified in a cross
between Solanum tuberosum and Solanum berthaultii segregated for monogenic-dominant
hypersensitivity to PVY. Plants bearing Nytbr displayed necrosis symptoms upon PVY
infection. Benoît Moury et al. demonstrated that the helper component proteinase (HCPro) cistron of PVY induces hypersensitivity and resistance in potato genotypes carrying
dominant resistance genes on chromosome IV [46]. They found that the Nc(tbr) and Ny(tbr)
genes in Solanum tuberosum determine HR against clade C and clade O of PVY, respectively,
via necrotic reactions and the restriction of virus systemic movement, whereas a dominant
gene, Nc(spl), was mapped on potato chromosome IV close or allelic to Ny(tbr) and conferred
a resistance to S. sparsipilum with the same phenotype as Nc(tbr). The HC-Pro cistron of
PVY was shown to affect necrotic reactions and resistance in plants carrying Nc(spl), Nc(tbr),
and Ny(tbr). However, inductions of necrosis and of resistance to systemic virus movement
in plants carrying Nc(spl) were determined by different regions of the HC-Pro cistron [47].
Moreover, genomic determinants outside the HC-Pro cistron are involved in the systemic
movement of PVY after the induction of necroses on inoculated leaves of plants carrying
Ny(tbr). It seems that Ny(tbr) resistance may have been involved in the emergence of PVY
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
5 of 14
isolates through a recombination breakpoint near the junction of HC-Pro and P3 cistrons
in potato crops. Thus, this might serve to explain virus resistance breakdown caused by
recombination other than the accumulation of nucleotide substitutions [43].
Further, it was demonstrated that the gene Ny in potato is responsible for PVY overcoming or triggering hypersensitive resistance to PVY strain group O [48]. For example, the
residues 227 to 327 of HC-Pro are the viral determinants for overcoming Nytbr resistance.
This HC-Pro region with eight residues and a special three-dimensional conformation
model in PVYN differs from PVYO strains, suggesting a structure–function relationship in
recognition of PVYO HC-Pro by Nytbr.
In response to infection by PVX, the Rx1 gene mediates ER, and viral replication is
rapidly terminated, which results in symptoms such as cell death and lesion formation
in plants [49]. Rx10 s ER is conserved in Nicotiana benthamiana (N. benthamiana) by the
evidence of a strong hypersensitive response in Rx1-overexpressed plants [49]. Moreover,
Townsend et al. identified a golden-like transcription factor that interacts with Rx1 and
mediates antiviral immunity, which enables the nonspecific DNA-binding Rx1 to confer ER
to PVX [50].
PLRV is one of the most important virus diseases in potato and is widespread across
the world [51]. A quantitative trait locus (QTL) analysis of resistance to PLRV virus
accumulation revealed one major and two minor QTLs [52]. The major QTL (PLRV.1) was
mapped to potato chromosome XI in a resistance hotspot containing several genes for
qualitative and quantitative resistance to viruses and other potato pathogens with 50% and
60% phenotypic variance. The two minor QTLs were mapped to chromosomes V and VI.
Those genes with sequence similarity to the tobacco N gene for resistance to TMV were
found to be tightly linked to PLRV.1. Based on the cDNA sequence of an N-like gene, the
sequence-characterized amplified region (SCAR) marker Nl271164 was developed to select
potatoes with resistance to PLRV [52].
These identified genes associated with potato viral resistance (Table 1) can be used for
antiviral breeding and to create potato varieties with resistance to a virus or a variety of
viruses. However, scientists should make further efforts to bring about either resistance
gene application or the discovery of new resistance genes in potato.
Table 1. Viral resistance gene and location in potato chromosome.
Name of
Resistance Gene
Virus
Rysto
PVY
Ryadg
PVY
Rychc
PVY
Nytbr
Nctbr
Ncspl
Ny-1
Ny-2
Y-1
G-Ry
Nxphu
Rx(Rxadg )
Rx1
Rx2(Rxacl )
PLRV.1
PLRV.2
PVY
PVY
PVY
PVY
PVY
PVY
PVY
PVX
PVX
PVX
PVX
PLRV
PLRV
Source
Chromosome
Reference
XI
Brigneti (1997) [53]
Song (2005) [29]; Flis (2005) [28]
XI
Hämäläinen (1998) [23]
I-1039
S. stoloniferum
S. andigena,
line 2X(v-2)7
Japanese leading cultivar
‘Konafubuki’
USW2230
S. tuberosum
T. tuberosum
Rywal and Accent
Romula
S. tuberosum ssp. andigena
IX
Masatoshi Sato (2006) [31]
IV
IV
IV
IX
IX
XI
phu Iv35
tbr cv.Cara
S. andigena
S. acaule
DG83-68
DG83-2025
IX
XII
XII
V
XI
VI
Celebi-Toprak (2002) [45]; Benoît Moury (2011) [46]
Benoît Moury (2011) [46]
Benoît Moury (2011) [46]
Szajko (2008) [24]; Szajko (2014) [54]
Szajko K (2014) [54]
Vidal (2002) [38]
Lee (2010) [40]; Vidal (2002) [38]
Tommiska (1998) [55]
Bendahmane (1997) [56]
Ritter (1991) [57]
Ritter (1991) [57]
Marczewski (2001) [52]
Marczewski (2001) [52]
4. RNAi-Mediated Viral Resistance in Potato
RNA silencing is a common gene-regulation mechanism in eukaryotes, functionally
involving various biological processes, including the defense against viruses [58,59]. Small
interfering RNAs (siRNAs) of 21–24 nt in length, initially processed by Dicer-like (DCL) en-
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
6 of 14
donucleases, are the core effectors in this immune system [60,61]. Basically, one strand of the
sRNA duplex is recognized by one of the AGO family proteins, forming an RNA-induced
silencing complex (RISC) [62]. DCL4 and DCL2 generate 21 and 22 siRNAs, respectively,
from the intermediates of double-strand RNAs (dsRNAs) during viral replication, which
mediate defenses against RNA viruses through siRNA-directed and AGO-mediated cleavage and the degradation of viral RNA [63]. By contrast, RNA-dependent RNA polymerase
(RDRs) can convert aberrant single-stranded RNA into dsRNA precursors of secondary
siRNAs to reinforce RNAi [58,64]. As an effect on the immune system, RNAi offers a very
promising approach for genetically engineering resistance against viruses in transgenic
plants. The first layer of the antiviral system of RNA silencing is the DCL-mediated cleavage of the initial trigger viruses. DCL4 plays a major role in antiviral silencing against
plus-strand RNA viruses, while DCL2 has a subordinate role when DCL4 is inhibited.
DCL3 makes a minor contribution to the antiviral process [65].
It has been demonstrated that RNA silencing plays an important role in viroid infection
in plants. The stable structure of viroids serves as the dsRNA substrate for host Dicerlike enzyme cleavage to produce biologically active small RNAs that gain resistance to
RISC-mediated degradation [66]. For example, the replication of the potato spindle tuber
viroid (PSTVd) in infected tomato plants was found to induce resistance to RNA silencing,
although viroid-specific siRNAs were biologically active in guiding the RISC-mediated
cleavage. This suggests that the PSTVd secondary structure might play a crucial role in
resistance to RNAi [66]. Another possibility is that some viroids may build up a structure
to avoid DCL cleavage in order to infect plants; this structure may change to become more
accessible to RISC complexes and AGO targeting.
It has been reported that RNAi plays an unexpected beneficial role in viroid titer. DCL4
may have a positive effect on PSTVd accumulation in N. benthamiana, while DCL2 does
not. However, the reason for this effect remains unknown. It appears that the generation
of sRNAs from viroids is complicated and possibly involves multiple DCL pathways.
RDR6-dependent RNA silencing pathways are linked to viroid-induced pathogenesis. TasiRNA biogenesis and the replication processes of members of the family Pospiviroidae
share several similarities. This indicates that disease symptoms might result from the
incorporation of viroid replication intermediates into the ta-siRNA biogenesis pathway.
The interaction of viroids and RNAi might be useful in designing the targets of engineering
viral resistance.
siRNAs are usually produced from long dsRNAs and miRNAs originated through
the nucleolytic maturation of miRNA genes (MIR) with a self-complementary fold-back
structure [67]. Precise excision from the stem of the fold-back precursor yields a duplex
intermediate (miRNA/miRNA*) that ultimately promotes the miRNA strands to RISC [68].
Vaucheret et al. demonstrated that exchanging the miRNA/miRNA* sequence within a
premiRNA does not affect its biogenesis as long as the secondary structure of the precursor
is kept intact [69], which makes it possible to modify miRNA sequences to create artificial
miRNAs (amiRNAs) that can target specific sequences. Plant miRNA precursors have
therefore been engineered to target one or several interested genes to provide highly specific
and effective post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) in plants [70]. Moreover, SimónMateo proposed that viruses could be targets of miRNA-mediated silencing [71], which has
opened up the possibility of engineering amiRNAs against viral infections. In particular,
using endogenous miRNAs as backbones, artificial microRNAs (amiRNAs) exploit natural
RNA silencing mechanisms to achieve the silencing of viral genes and in turn to generate
resistance against different viruses [72].
The first amiRNA constructed using the miR159a precursor of Arabidopsis thaliana
(A. thaliala) to confer viral resistance was reported by Niu et al. in 2006 [73]. In addition to
the miR159a precursor in Arabidopsis, miRNA precursors including miR171a, miR172a,
and mir528 have been modified to silence endogenous or exogenous targets and have been
observed to be functional in Arabidopsis or tobacco [74–77]. The expression of different
amiRNAs has demonstrated efficacy in different plants against a large variety of plant
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
7 of 14
viruses [78,79]. Using A. thaliana miR167b and miR171a precursors as backbones rather
than miR159a, an amiRNA-targeting sequence that encoded the silencing suppressor HCPro of PVY and p25 of PVX was designed and conferred high specific resistance against
PVY and PVX infection in transgenic Nicotiana tabacum (N. tabacum). This resistance was
also maintained under conditions of increased viral pressure. The transgenic N. tabacum
developed high effective resistance to both PVY and PVX through the expression of a
dimeric amiRNA precursor. This indicates that amiRNA technology could be a promising
tool with which to obtain multiple virus-resistance plants. Because of its exquisite specificity
in avoiding off-target effects compared with long RNA-mediated silencing, amiRNA is
considered a second-generation method and, with respect to viral immunity, also possesses
the advantage of reducing potential biosafety-related risks when applied in agriculture.
To explore RNAi-directed viral resistance, expression cassettes carrying inverted
repeats of PVS (genus Carlavirus) movement or CP sequences were used for generating
viral-resistant plants against PVS, potato virus M (PVM), and PVY [61]. The results showed
that transgenic lines representing seven cultivars remained free of any virus or only became
infected with PVY. When progenies of transgenic lines of the cultivar Zeren were coinfected
with PVS, PVM, and PVY, transgene-derived 21, 22, and 24 nt siRNAs were detected almost
exclusively in the PVS inverted repeats. In some field progenies, 21–22 nt siRNAs from the
entire PVY genome were detected. This indicates that transgenic RNAi is effective for virus
degradation from naturally infected potato cultivars and protects from further infection in
a sequence-specific manner [61].
Some secondary siRNAs are 21 nt phased siRNAs that are processed by successive
DCL enzymes from the dsRNA substrate, which originates from an RDR from an AGOcatalyzed cleaved RNA at a miRNA target site [80,81]. Phased siRNAs are termed transacting siRNAs (tasiRNAs) [82] and are highly abundant in some plant families such as
Solanaceae and Fabaceae but are not well conserved in other plant species [81]. TasiRNAs
regulate plant development [83,84] and coordinate the repression of pentatricopeptide
repeat (PPR) genes [85,86] or the nucleotide-binding site-leucine-rich repeat (NBS–LRR)
family of resistance genes [87–90]. In the A. thaliana genome, families of genes coding for
tasiRNA precursors (TAS) have been identified [82]. The TAS3 family is widely conserved
in moss and higher plants and can generate tasiRNAs via a two-hit mechanism triggered
by miR390 loaded in the specialized argonaute AGO7. The genes of the TAS1/TAS2
families, whose primary transcripts are targeted by a single hit of the 22 nt long version
of miR173, are unique to Arabidopsis and are closely related species [91]. The miR173triggered production of tasiRNAs has been used to engineer single or multiple copies
of synthetic tasiRNAs (syn-tasiRNAs) to silence endogenous genes such as FAD2 [92],
PDS [93], CH42 [94], and FT or TRY/CPC/ETC2 [95]. This syn-tasiRNA technology, named
miRNA-induced gene silencing (MIGS), can reliably knock down single genes or multiple
unrelated genes [96].
In natural infection, to protect themselves from plant RNA silencing systems, many
viruses encode silencing suppressors to counteract host RNAi-based defenses. The first
silencing suppressor, Hc-Pro, was discovered by three different groups independently
in 1998. Since then, a large number of viral silencing suppressors have been identified,
indicating that expressing proteins with RNA silencing activity is a common strategy used
by plant viruses against RNA silencing in plants. Some silencing suppressors, such as
HC-Pro, P38, P19, and P122, may interfere with RNA silencing amplification by binding
small RNAs and by preventing secondary siRNA accumulation, while other silencing
suppressors directly interact with AGO protein and suppress the silencing system. AGO
proteins appear to be targeted by silencing suppressors in different ways.
The second layer of the antiviral component in RNA silencing is AGO proteins. Some
AGO proteins, such as AGO1, AGO2, and AGO7 in Arabidopsis and AGO2 and AGO4
in N. benthamiana, are involved in the antiviral effect. The counter-defense role of P25
is directed by the degradation of AGO proteins through the proteasome pathway [97].
It was demonstrated that the amount of AGO1 in infiltrated leaves carrying P25 was
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
8 of 14
dramatically decreased compared with those infiltrated with HC-Pro, but it could be
restored when treated with the proteasome inhibitor MG132. Plants treated with MG132
were less susceptible to PVX and its relative bamboo mosaic virus [97].
In most cases, viral silencing suppressors are strong enough to counteract RNAi
and result in viral infection in plants. To confer high viral resistance, researchers should
therefore focus on how to improve RNAi activity by increasing the efficiency of AGO
proteins first by modifying siRNA, that is, by facilitating loading into the RISC complex.
Modifying siRNA near the 50 termini could improve RNAi activity and the strand selectivity
of RISC formation. Virus-derived siRNAs are active in targeting viral mRNA. Thus, it is
advantageous to improve the ability of RISC to recruit vsiRNAs and to exert the cleavage
of target viral mRNA. Second, AGOs should be modified in changing the status of AGOs
from inactive to active and from slicer to translation inhibition. Great efforts have been
made to define AGO functions by the selection of specific defective mutant alleles based on
protein structure. This is very helpful in understanding how the AGO family plays a role in
regulatory functions in plant biology. Researchers should also focus on modifying inactive
AGO proteins and changing them into active AGO proteins or changing their function from
slicer to translation inhibition.
In the mammalian system, it has been observed that AGO proteins can be posttranslationally modified such as with modifications in hydroxylation, phosphorylation,
and ubiquitylation, influencing Argonaute stability and function [98–100]. However, AGO
modifications are not yet clear in plants. Future research should work toward unraveling
novel AGO modifications in plants and their corresponding functions. A strategy based on
increasing expression levels of AGOs to meet requirements of AGO-mediated resistance
could also be considered. This may also prove significant because low-expressed AGO
proteins engineered to express at high levels would be useful in facilitating research and in
helping us to find new functions of AGOs.
In addition, another open question is how AGO proteins collaborate with other plant
defense pathways to confer an antiviral effect. The crosstalk between RNA silencing and
plant immune systems remains unexplored. It has been proposed that RDR1 might play
a dual role, firstly contributing to salicylic acid-mediated antiviral defense and secondly
suppressing RDR6-mediated antiviral RNA silencing [81]. This suggests that RNA silencing
may collaborate with other plant defense systems, which is supported by virus resistance
induced by NB–LRR proteins involving AGO4-dependent translational control.
Even though the role of RNA silencing in antiviral plant defense has been well studied,
the positive effect of RNA silencing in viral infection remains unknown. It is possible that
some components of RNA silencing systems could directly or indirectly contribute to viral
infection. It was discovered that DCL4 may have a positive effect on PSTVd accumulation
in N. benthamiana, while DCL2 does not [101]. The mechanism of this protecting effect is
still not clear.
In summary, to establish successful infection, plant viruses suppress or evade RNAi
and other innate immunity systems that crosstalk with RNAi [102,103], which offers us
several possibilities for engineering viral resistance in potato.
5. CRISPR/Cas9-Mediated Viral Resistance in Potato
CRISPR/Cas (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats/CRISPRassociated) is derived from the genomes of bacteria, and its original function was to provide
bacteria with specific immune protection against invading nucleic acids [104]. This system
became a powerful tool for genome engineering, which enables the efficient modification
of endogenous genes in various species and viral disease resistance traits [105–107]. There
are now increasing reports demonstrating that CRISPR/Cas systems can be harnessed
to develop antiviral immunity in plants with high efficiency [108–110]. sgRNA-Cas9
constructs targeting beet severe curly top virus (BSCTV), which inhibits virus accumulation
in N. benthamiana and A. thaliana [84]. Moreover, viral resistance could be obtained through
the CRISPR/Cas9 editing of plant endogenous genes. Mutated eIF4G alleles in rice were
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
9 of 14
generated using the CRISPR/Cas9 system in the RTSV-susceptible variety IR64, widely
grown across tropical Asia, and conferred resistance. The Cas9 sequence did not exist in
the final products with RTSV resistance, and the yield was enhanced under glasshouse
conditions [111].
Several studies have introduced the generation of virus-resistant potato crops using
CRISPR-mediated technology. Zhan and colleagues generated potato-virus-Y-resistant
potatoes with CRISPR/LshCas13a [112]. A correlation between the level of resistance
and the degree of Cas13a/sgRNA expression was observed. It was reported that the Va
gene (Ntab0942120) in tobacco determines the susceptibility of the plant to PVY [113]. The
Va gene product interacts with the PVY genome-linked protein (VPg) to initiate the PVY
genome translation process, which ultimately leads to the systemic infection of tobacco by
the virus [114]. The Va gene in tobacco cultivar LJ911 was knocked out via CRISPR/Cas9
technology. Edited plants showed PVY resistance [113]. These reports demonstrate the
potential of CRISPR/Cas9 in editing susceptibility genes to obtain antiviral immunity for
controlling plant RNA viruses in potato.
6. Future Prospects and Conclusions
Although great progress has been made in molecular virus–host interactions, due
to most potato cultivars lacking broad-spectrum resistance to genetically complex strains
of viruses, further efforts are required to explore viral resistance. In the future, several
strategies might assist in obtaining broad-spectrum resistance:
(i) Disrupting the interaction between the virus and host through potato genome
editing will efficiently protect potato from viral infection. The available potato genome sequences (Potato Genome Sequencing Consortium 2011) will facilitate such studies. Instead
of RNAi, CRISPR-editing-mediated antiviral immunity might be a versatile technology
with which to combat plant virus infections [107].
(ii) Discovering resistance genes that are important to antiviral defense will offer great
opportunities for potato breeding. Identified resistance genes may also be introduced to
potato via genetic transformation.
(iii) Manipulating inducible defense in plants that are naturally resistant to viruses
might be an effective approach for potato breeding. Plant defenses have broad-spectrum
capabilities. Recently, much evidence has supported the identification of viral components
that trigger plant immune mechanisms. This will become a popular research area wherein
the resistance genes that control these defense mechanisms may be identified. It will be
possible to design methods of engineering the broad-spectrum components of natural
defense mechanisms.
(iv) Based on the increasing understanding of the molecular functions of viral proteins, especially those related to replication and virus movement, in the future, we may
manipulate viral proteins used for inoculums to obtain cross-protection from further viral
infection in potato.
(v) The transgenic expression of antiviral proteins of non-plant origin, including
antibodies, may also represent a promising approach with which to obtain resistance to
specific potato viruses.
Author Contributions: Conceptualization, J.L., M.Z. and H.Z.; Formal analysis, J.L., L.X., H.W. and
J.Y.; Writing—original draft preparation, M.Z., J.L. and Y.Z.; Writing—review and editing, M.Z., H.W.,
Y.Z. and J.Y.; Supervision, M.Z. and H.Z. All authors have read and agreed to the published version
of the manuscript.
Funding: This work is supported by grants from a major project of the Natural Science Foundation
of Inner Mongolia of China (2021ZD06 to M.Z.) and potato revealed the most important project of
Inner Mongolia of China (2022JBGS0037 to H.Z.), China Agriculture Research System of MOF and
MARA (CARS-07-C-3 to H.Z.).
Institutional Review Board Statement: Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement: Not applicable.
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
10 of 14
Data Availability Statement: Not applicable.
Acknowledgments: We are grateful for the support of science and technology commissioner of Inner
Mongolia, China.
Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
Hameed, A.; Zaidi, S.S.; Shakir, S.; Mansoor, S. Applications of New Breeding Technologies for Potato Improvement. Front. Plant Sci.
2018, 9, 925. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Salazar, L.F. Potato Viruses and Their Control; International Potato Center: Lima, Peru, 1996.
Fletcher, J.D. A virus survey of New Zealand fresh process and seed potato crops during 2010-11. N. Z. Plant Protec.
2012, 65, 197–203.
Hameed, A.; Iqbal, Z.; Asad, S.; Mansoor, S. Detection of multiple potato viruses in the field suggests synergistic interactions
among potato viruses in Pakistan. Plant Pathol. J. 2014, 30, 407. [CrossRef]
Steinger, T.; Gilliand, H.; Hebeisen, T. Epidemiological analysis of risk factors for the spread of potato viruses in Switzerland.
Ann. Appl. Biol. 2014, 164, 200–207. [CrossRef]
Baulcombe, D. Novel strategies for engineering virus resistance in plants. Curr. Opin. Biotech. 1994, 5, 117–124. [CrossRef]
Missiou, A.; Kalantidis, K.; Boutla, A.; Tzortzakaki, S.; Tabler, M.; Tsagris, M. Generation of transgenic potato plants highly
resistant to potato virus Y (PVY) through RNA silencing. Mol. Breed. 2004, 14, 185–197. [CrossRef]
Chung, B.N.; Yoon, J.Y.; Palukaitis, P. Engineered resistance in potato against potato leafroll virus, potato virus A and potato virus
Y. Virus Genes 2013, 47, 86–92. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Hameed, A.; Tahir, M.N.; Asad, S.; Bilal, R.; Van Eck, J.; Jander, G.; Mansoor, S. RNAi-mediated simultaneous resistance against
three RNA viruses in potato. Mol. Biotech. 2017, 59, 73–83. [CrossRef]
Mathur, V.; Javid, L.; Kulshrestha, S.; Mandal, A.; Reddy, A.A. World cultivation of genetically modified crops: Opportunities and
risks. Sustain. Agric. Rev. 2017, 25, 45–87.
Abel, P.P.; Nelson, R.S.; De, B.; Hoffmann, N.; Rogers, S.G.; Fraley, R.T.; Beachy, R.N. Delay of disease development in transgenic
plants that express the tobacco mosaic virus coat protein gene. Science 1986, 232, 738–743. [CrossRef]
Kaniewski, W.; Lawson, C.; Sammons, B.; Haley, L.; Hart, J.; Delannay, X.; Tumer, N.E. Field resistance of transgenic russeet
burbank potato to effects of infection by potato virus X and potato virus Y. Bio/Technology 1990, 8, 750–754. [CrossRef]
Jongedijk, E.; Huisman, M.J.; Cornelissen, B.J.C. Argonic performance and field resistance of genetically modified, virus-resistant
potato plants. In Seminars in Virology; Academic Press: Cambridge, MA, USA, 1993; Volume 4, pp. 407–416.
Thomas, P.E.; Kaniewski, W.K.; Lawson, E.C. Reduced field spread of potato leafroll virus in potatoes transformed with the
potato leafroll virus coat protein gene. Plant Dis. 1997, 81, 1447–1453. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Lecoq, H.; Ravelonandro, M.; Wipf-Scheibel, C.; Monsion, M.; Raccah, B.; Dunez, J. Aphid transmission of a non-aphidtransmissible strain of zucchini yellow mosaic potyvirus from transgenic plants expressing the capsid protein of plum pox
potyvirus. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 1993, 6, 403–406. [CrossRef]
Farinelli, L.; Malnoë, P.; Collet, G.F. Heterologous encapsidation of potato virus Y strain O (PVYO) with the transgenic coat
protein of PVY strain N (PVYN) in Solanum tuberosum cv. Bintje. Bio/Technology 1992, 10, 1020–1025. [CrossRef]
De Zoeten, G.A. Risk assessment: Do we let history repeat itself? Phytopathology 1991, 81, 585–586.
Braun, C.J.; Hemenway, C.L. Expression of amino-terminal portions or full-length viral replicase genes in transgenic plants
confers resistance to potato virus X infection. Plant Cell 1992, 4, 735–744. [CrossRef]
Xiang, Y.; Yang, L.Y.; Peng, X.X. High virus-resistance of transgenic tobacoo plants mediated by expression of modified NIb gene
of potato virus Y. Chin. J. Biotech. 1996, 12, 258–265.
Rifai, N.; Horvath, A.R.; Wittwer, C.T.; Park, J. Principles and Applications of Molecular Diagnostics; Elsevier: Amsterdam, The
Netherlands, 2018.
Lindbo, J.A.; Dougherty, W.G. Untranslatable transcripts of the tobacco etch virus coat protein gene sequence can interfere with
tobacco etch virus replication in transgenic plants and protoplasts. Virology 1992, 189, 725–733. [CrossRef]
Valkonen, J.P.T.; Jones, R.A.C.; Slack, S.A.; Watanabe, K.N. Resistance specificities to viruses in potato: Standardization of
nomenclature. Plant Breed. 1996, 115, 433–438. [CrossRef]
Hämäläinen, J.H.; Sorri, V.A.; Watanabe, K.N.; Gebhardt, C.; Valkonen, J.P.T. Molecular examination of a chromosome region that
controls resistance to potato Y and A potyviruses in potato. Theor. Appl. Genet. 1998, 96, 1036. [CrossRef]
Szajko, K.; Chrzanowska, M.; Witek, K.; Strzelczyk-Żyta, D.; Zagórska, H.; Gebhardt, C.; Hennig, J.; Marczewski, W. The novel
gene Ny-1 on potato chromosome IX confers hypersensitive resistance to potato virus Y and is an alternative to Ry genes in
potato breeding for PVY resistance. Theor. Appl. Genet. 2008, 116, 297–303. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Cockerham, G. Genetical studies on resistance to potato viruses X and Y. Heredity 1970, 25, 309–348. [CrossRef]
Nie, X.; Liang, Z.; Nie, B.; Murphy, A.; Singh, M. Studies on varietal response to different strains of potato virus Y (PVY)
reveal hypersensitive resistance in Exploits to PVY O and extreme resistance in F87084 to all tested strains. Am. J. Potato Res.
2015, 92, 23–31. [CrossRef]
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
11 of 14
Singh, R.P.; Valkonen, J.P.; Gray, S.M.; Boonham, N.; Jones, R.; Kerlan, C.; Schubert, J. Discussion paper: The naming of potato
virus Y strains infecting potato. Arch. Virol. 2008, 153, 1–13. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Flis, B.; Hennig, J.; Strzelczyk-Żyta, D.; Gebhardt, C.; Marczewski, W. The Ry-f sto gene from Solanum stoloniferum for extreme
resistant to potato virus Y maps to potato chromosome XII and is diagnosed by PCR marker GP122 718 in PVY resistant potato
cultivars. Mol. Breed. 2005, 15, 95–101. [CrossRef]
Song, Y.S.; Hepting, L.; Schweizer, G.; Hartl, L.; Wenzel, G.; Schwarzfischer, A. Mapping of extreme resistance to PVY (Ry sto) on
chromosome XII using anther-culture-derived primary dihaploid potato lines. Theor. Appl. Genet. 2005, 111, 879–887. [CrossRef]
Hämäläinen, J.H.; Watanabe, K.N.; Valkonen, J.P.T.; Arihara, A.; Plaisted, R.L.; Pehu, E.; Miller, L.; Slack, S.A. Mapping and
marker-assisted selection for a gene for extreme resistance to potato virus Y. Theor. Appl. Genet. 1997, 94, 192–197. [CrossRef]
Sato, M.; Nishikawa, K.; Komura, K.; Hosaka, K. Potato virus Y resistance gene, Ry chc, mapped to the distal end of potato
chromosome 9. Euphytica 2006, 149, 367–372. [CrossRef]
Li, G.; Shao, J.; Wang, Y.; Liu, T.; Tong, Y.; Jansky, S.; Xie, C.; Song, B.; Cai, X. Rychc confers extreme resistance to potato virus Y in
potato. Cells 2022, 11, 2577. [CrossRef]
Gebhardt, C.; Bellin, D.; Henselewski, H.; Lehmann, W.; Schwarzfischer, J.; Valkonen, J. Marker-assisted combination of major
genes for pathogen resistance in potato. Theor. Appl. Genet. 2006, 112, 1458–1464. [CrossRef]
Mori, K.; Mukojima, N.; Nakao, T.; Tamiya, S.; Sakamoto, Y.; Sohbaru, N.; Hayashi, K.; Watanuki, H.; Nara, K.; Yamazaki, K.; et al.
Germplasm release: Saikai 35, a male and female fertile breeding line carrying Solanum phureja-derived cytoplasm and potato
cyst nematode resistance (H1) and potato virus Y resistance (Ry chc) genes. Am. J. Potato Res. 2012, 89, 63–72. [CrossRef]
Munoz, F.J.; Plaisted, R.L.; Thurston, H.D. Resistance to potato virus Y in Solanum tuberosum spp. andigena. Am. Potato J.
1975, 52, 107–115. [CrossRef]
Ross, H. Potato Breeding-Problems and Perspectives, J Plant Breed Suppl 13; Paul Parey: Hamburg, Germany, 1986.
Grech-Baran, M.; Witek, K.; Poznański, J.T.; Grupa-Urbańska, A.; Malinowski, T.; Lichocka, M.; Jones, J.D.G.; Hennig, J. The Rysto
immune receptor recognises a broadly conserved feature of potyviral coat proteins. New Phytol. 2022, 235, 1179–1195. [CrossRef]
[PubMed]
Vidal, S.; Cabrera, H.; Andersson, R.A.; Fredriksson, A.; Valkonen, J.P.T. Potato gene Y-1 is an N gene homolog that confers cell
death upon infection with potato virus Y. Mol. Plant. Microbe Interact. 2002, 15, 717–727. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Hämäläinen, J.H.; Kekarainen, T.; Gebhardt, C.; Watanabe, K.N.; Valkonen, J.P.T. Recessive and dominant genes interfere with the
vascular transport of potato virus A in diploid potatoes. Mol. Plant. Microbe Interact. 2000, 13, 402–412. [CrossRef]
Lee, C.; Park, J.; Hwang, I.; Park, Y.; Cheong, H. Expression of G-Ry derived from the potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) increases
PVYO resistance. J. Agric. Food Chem. 2010, 58, 7245–7251. [CrossRef]
Rowley, J.S.; Gray, S.M.; Karasev, A.V. Screening potato cultivars for new sources of resistance to potato virus Y. Am. J. Potato Res.
2015, 92, 38–48. [CrossRef]
Valkonen, J.P. Novel resistances to four potyviruses in tuber-bearing potato species, and temperature-sensitive expression of
hypersensitive resistance to potato virus Y. Ann. Appl. Biol. 1997, 130, 91–104. [CrossRef]
Valkonen, J.P. Elucidation of virus-host interactions to enhance resistance breeding for control of virus diseases in potato. Breed.
Sci. 2015, 65, 69–76. [CrossRef]
Valkonen, J.P.; Gebhardt, C.; Zimnoch-Guzowska, E.; Watanabe, K.N. Resistance to Potato virus Y in potato. In Potato Virus Y:
Biodiversity, Pathogenicity, Epidemiology and Management; Springer: Cham, Switzerland, 2017; pp. 207–241.
Celebi-Toprak, F.; Slack, S.A.; Jahn, M.M. A new gene, Ny tbr, for hypersensitivity to potato virus Y from Solanum tuberosum
maps to chromosome IV. Theor. Appl. Genet. 2002, 104, 669–674. [CrossRef]
Moury, B.; Caromel, B.; Johansen, E.; Simon, V.; Chauvin, L.; Jacquot, E.; Kerlan, C.; Lefebvre, V. The helper component proteinase
cistron of potato virus Y induces hypersensitivity and resistance in potato genotypes carrying dominant resistance genes on
chromosome IV. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 2011, 24, 787–797. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Tian, Y.P.; Valkonen, J.P. Recombination of strain O segments to HCpro-encoding sequence of strain N of potato virus Y modulates
necrosis induced in tobacco and in potatoes carrying resistance genes Ny or Nc. Mol. Plant Pathol. 2015, 16, 735–747. [CrossRef]
[PubMed]
Tian, Y.P.; Valkonen, J.P. Genetic determinants of potato virus Y required to overcome or trigger hypersensitive resistance to PVY
strain group O controlled by the gene Ny in potato. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 2013, 26, 297–305. [CrossRef]
Bendahmane, A.; Kanyuka, K.; Baulcombe, D.C. The Rx gene from potato controls separate virus resistance and cell death
responses. Plant Cell 1999, 11, 781–791. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Townsend, P.D.; Dixon, C.H.; Slootweg, E.J.; Sukarta, O.C.A.; Yang, A.W.H.; Hughes, T.R.; Sharples, G.J.; Pålsson, L.-O.;
Takken, F.L.W.; Goverse, A.; et al. The intracellular immune receptor Rx1 regulates the DNA-binding activity of a Golden2-like
transcription factor. J. Biol. Chem. 2018, 293, 3218–3233. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Syller, J. Potato leafroll virus (PLRV): Its transmission and control. Integr. Pest Manag. Rev. 1996, 1, 217–227. [CrossRef]
Marczewski, W.; Flis, B.; Syller, J.; Schäfer-Pregl, R.; Gebhardt, C. A major quantitative trait locus for resistance to Potato leafroll
virus is located in a resistance hotspot on potato chromosome XI and is tightly linked to N-gene-like markers. Mol. Plant Microbe
Interact. 2001, 14, 1420–1425. [CrossRef]
Brigneti, G.; Garcia-Mas, J.; Baulcombe, D.C. Molecular mapping of the potato virus Y resistance gene Rysto in potato. Theor.
Appl. Genet. 1997, 94, 198–203. [CrossRef]
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
74.
75.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
83.
12 of 14
Szajko, K.; Strzelczyk-Żyta, D.; Marczewski, W. Ny-1 and Ny-2 genes conferring hypersensitive response to potato virus Y (PVY)
in cultivated potatoes: Mapping and marker-assisted selection validation for PVY resistance in potato breeding. Mol Breed.
2014, 34, 267–271. [CrossRef]
Tommiska, T.J.; Hämäläinen, J.H.; Watanabe, K.N.; Valkonen JP, T. Mapping of the gene Nxphu that controls hypersensitive
resistance to potato virus X in Solanum phureja IvP35. Theor. Appl. Genet. 1998, 96, 840. [CrossRef]
Bendahmane, A.; Kanyuka, K.; Baulcombe, D.C. High-resolution genetical and physical mapping of the Rx gene for extreme
resistance to potato virus X in tetraploid potato. Theor. Appl. Genet. 1997, 95, 153–162. [CrossRef]
Ritter, E.; Debener, T.; Barone, A.; Salamini, F.; Gebhardt, C. RFLP mapping on potato chromosomes of two genes controlling
extreme resistance to potato virus X (PVX). Mol. Gen. Genet. 1991, 227, 81–85. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Baulcombe, D. RNA silencing in plants. Nature 2004, 431, 356–363. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Malone, C.D.; Hannon, G.J. Small RNAs as guardians of the genome. Cell 2009, 136, 656–668. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Baulcombe, D. RNA silencing. Trends Biochem. Sci. 2005, 30, 290–293.
Axtell, M.J. Classification and comparison of small RNAs from plants. Annu. Rev. Plant. Biol. 2013, 64, 137–159. [CrossRef]
Fang, X.; Qi, Y. RNAi in plants: An argonaute-centered view. Plant Cell 2016, 28, 272–285. [CrossRef]
Pooggin, M.M. Small RNA-omics for plant virus identification, virome reconstruction, and antiviral defense characterization.
Front. Microbiol. 2018, 9, 2779. [CrossRef]
Mann, K.S.; Johnson, K.N.; Dietzgen, R.G. Cytorhabdovirus phosphoprotein shows RNA silencing suppressor activity in plants,
but not in insect cells. Virology 2015, 476, 413–418. [CrossRef]
Pantaleo, V.; Saldarelli, P.; Miozzi, L.; Giampetruzzi, A.; Gisel, A.; Moxon, S.; Dalmay, T.; Bisztray, G.; Burgyan, J. Deep sequencing
analysis of viral short RNAs from an infected Pinot Noir grapevine. Virology 2010, 408, 49–56. [CrossRef]
Itaya, A.; Zhong, X.; Bundschuh, R.; Qi, Y.; Wang, Y.; Takeda, R.; Harris, A.R.; Molina, C.; Nelson, R.S.; Ding, B. A structured viroid
RNA serves as a substrate for dicer-like cleavage to produce biologically active small RNAs but is resistant to RNA-induced
silencing complex-mediated degradation. J. Virol. 2007, 81, 2980–2994. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Li, X. Next-Generation Sequencing Sheds New Light on Small RNAs in Plant Reproductive Development. Curr Issues Mol Biol.
2018, 27, 143–170. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Schwarz, D.S.; Hutvágner, G.; Du, T.; Xu, Z.; Aronin, N.; Zamore, P.D. Asymmetry in the assembly of the RNAi enzyme complex.
Cell 2003, 115, 199–208. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Vaucheret, H.; Vazquez, F.; Crété, P.; Bartel, D.P. The action of ARGONAUTE1 in the miRNA pathway and its regulation by the
miRNA pathway are crucial for plant development. Genes Dev. 2004, 18, 1187–1197. [CrossRef]
70. Warthmann, N.; Chen, H.; Ossowski, S.; Weigel, D.; Hervé, P. Highly specific gene silencing by artificial miRNAs in rice. PLoS
ONE 2008, 3, e1829. [CrossRef]
Simón-Mateo, C.; García, J.A. Antiviral strategies in plants based on RNA silencing. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 2011, 1809, 722–731.
[CrossRef]
Mesel, F.; Zhao, M.; García, B.; Simón-Mateo, C.; García, J.A. Targeting of genomic and negative-sense strands of viral RNA
contributes to antiviral resistance mediated by artificial miRNAs and promotes the emergence of complex viral populations.
Mol. Plant Pathol. 2022, 23, 1640–1657. [CrossRef]
Niu, Q.W.; Lin, S.S.; Reyes, J.L.; Chen, K.C.; Wu, H.W.; Yeh, S.D.; Chua, N.H. Expression of artificial microRNAs in transgenic
Arabidopsis thaliana confers virus resistance. Nat. Biotechnol. 2006, 24, 1420–1428. [CrossRef]
Schwab, R.; Ossowski, S.; Riester, M.; Warthmann, N.; Weigel, D. Highly specific gene silencing by artificial microRNAs in
Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 2006, 18, 1121–1133. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Parizotto, E.A.; Dunoyer, P.; Rahm, N.; Himber, C.; Voinnet, O. In vivo investigation of the transcription, processing, endonucleolytic activity, and functional relevance of the spatial distribution of a plant miRNA. Genes Dev. 2004, 18, 2237–2242. [CrossRef]
Qu, J.; Ye, J.; Fang, R. Artificial microRNA-mediated virus resistance in plants. J. Virol. 2007, 81, 6690–6699. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Carbonell, A.; Carrington, J.C.; Daròs, J.A. Fast-forward generation of effective artificial small RNAs for enhanced antiviral
defense in plants. RNA Dis. 2016, 3, e1130. [PubMed]
Cisneros, A.E.; Carbonell, A. Artificial Small RNA-Based Silencing Tools for Antiviral Resistance in Plants. Plants 2020, 9, 669.
[CrossRef] [PubMed]
Alexandrova, A.; Karpova, O.; Kryldakov, R.; Golyaev, V.; Nargilova, R.; Iskakov, B.; Pooggin, M.M. Virus Elimination from
Naturally Infected Field Cultivars of Potato (Solanum tuberosum) by Transgenic RNA Interference. Int. J. Mol. Sci. 2022, 23, 8020.
[CrossRef]
Rajeswaran, R.; Aregger, M.; Zvereva, A.S.; Borah, B.K.; Gubaeva, E.G.; Pooggin, M.M. Sequencing of RDR6-dependent doublestranded RNAs reveals novel features of plant siRNA biogenesis. Nucleic Acids Res. 2012, 40, 6241–6254. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Fei, Q.; Xia, R.; Meyers, B.C. Phased, secondary, small interfering RNAs in posttranscriptional regulatory networks. Plant Cell
2013, 25, 2400–2415. [CrossRef]
Chitwood, D.H.; Guo, M.; Nogueira, F.T.; Timmermans, M.C. Establishing leaf polarity: The role of small RNAs and positional
signals in the shoot apex. Development 2007, 134, 813–823. [CrossRef]
Fahlgren, N.; Montgomery, T.A.; Howell, M.D.; Allen, E.; Dvorak, S.K.; Alexander, A.L.; Carrington, J.C. Regulation of AUXIN
RESPONSE FACTOR3 by TAS3 ta-siRNA affects developmental timing and patterning in Arabidopsis. Curr. Biol. 2006, 16, 939–944.
[CrossRef]
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
84.
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
90.
91.
92.
93.
94.
95.
96.
97.
98.
99.
100.
101.
102.
103.
104.
105.
106.
107.
108.
109.
13 of 14
Howell, M.D.; Fahlgren, N.; Chapman, E.J.; Cumbie, J.S.; Sullivan, C.M.; Givan, S.A.; Kasschau, K.D.; Carrington, J.C. Genomewide analysis of the RNA-DEPENDENT RNA POLYMERASE6/DICER-LIKE4 pathway in Arabidopsis reveals dependency on
miRNA- and tasiRNA-directed targeting. Plant Cell 2007, 19, 926–942. [CrossRef]
Chen, H.M.; Li, Y.H.; Wu, S.H. Bioinformatic prediction and experimental validation of a microRNA-directed tandem trans-acting
siRNA cascade in Arabidopsis. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2007, 104, 3318–3323. [CrossRef]
Li, F.; Pignatta, D.; Bendix, C.; Brunkard, J.O.; Cohn, M.M.; Tung, J.; Sun, H.; Kumar, P.; Baker, B. MicroRNA regulation of plant
innate immune receptors. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2012, 109, 1790–1795. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Shivaprasad, P.V.; Chen, H.M.; Patel, K.; Bond, D.M.; Santos, B.A.; Baulcombe, D.C. A microRNA superfamily regulates nucleotide
binding site-leucine-rich repeats and other mRNAs. Plant Cell 2012, 24, 859–874. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Zhai, J.; Jeong, D.H.; De Paoli, E.; Park, S.; Rosen, B.D.; Li, Y.; González, A.J.; Yan, Z.; Kitto, S.L.; Grusak, M.A.; et al. MicroRNAs
as master regulators of the plant NB-LRR defense gene family via the production of phased, trans-acting siRNAs. Genes Dev.
2011, 25, 2540–2553. [CrossRef]
Boccara, M.; Sarazin, A.; Thiébeauld, O.; Jay, F.; Voinnet, O.; Navarro, L.; Colot, V. The Arabidopsis miR472-RDR6 silencing
pathway modulates PAMP- and effector-triggered immunity through the post-transcriptional control of disease resistance genes.
PLoS Pathog. 2014, 10, e1003883. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Axtell, M.J.; Jan, C.; Rajagopalan, R.; Bartel, D.P. A two-hit trigger for siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell 2006, 127, 565–577.
[CrossRef] [PubMed]
Cuperus, J.T.; Fahlgren, N.; Carrington, J.C. Evolution and functional diversification of MIRNA genes. Plant Cell 2011, 23, 431–442.
[CrossRef]
de la Luz Gutiérrez-Nava, M.; Aukerman, M.J.; Sakai, H.; Tingey, S.V.; Williams, R.W. Artificial trans-acting siRNAs confer
consistent and effective gene silencing. Plant Physiol. 2008, 147, 543–551. [CrossRef]
Montgomery, T.A.; Yoo, S.J.; Fahlgren, N.; Gilbert, S.D.; Howell, M.D.; Sullivan, C.M.; Alexander, A.; Nguyen, G.; Allen, E.; Ahn,
J.H.; et al. AGO1-miR173 complex initiates phased siRNA formation in plants. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2008, 105, 20055–20062.
[CrossRef]
Felippes, F.F.; Weigel, D. Triggering the formation of tasiRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana: The role of microRNA miR173. EMBO
Rep. 2009, 10, 264–270. [CrossRef]
Carbonell, A.; Takeda, A.; Fahlgren, N.; Johnson, S.C.; Cuperus, J.T.; Carrington, J.C. New generation of artificial MicroRNA and
synthetic trans-acting small interfering RNA vectors for efficient gene silencing in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol. 2014, 165, 15–29.
[CrossRef]
Zhao, M.; San León, D.; Mesel, F.; García, J.A.; Simón-Mateo, C. Assorted Processing of Synthetic Trans-Acting siRNAs and Its
Activity in Antiviral Resistance. PLoS ONE 2015, 10, e0132281. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Chiu, M.H.; Chen, I.H.; Baulcombe, D.C.; Tsai, C.H. The silencing suppressor P25 of potato virus X interacts with argonaute1 and
mediates its degradation through the proteasome pathway. Mol. Plant Pathol. 2010, 11, 641–649. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Qi, H.H.; Ongusaha, P.P.; Myllyharju, J.; Cheng, D.; Pakkanen, O.; Shi, Y.; Lee, S.W.; Peng, J.; Shi, Y. Prolyl 4-hydroxylation
regulates Argonaute 2 stability. Nature 2008, 455, 421–424. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Rybak, A.; Fuchs, H.; Hadian, K.; Smirnova, L.; Wulczyn, E.A.; Michel, G.; Nitsch, R.; Krappmann, D.; Wulczyn, F.G. The
let-7 target gene mouse lin-41 is a stem cell specific E3 ubiquitin ligase for the miRNA pathway protein Ago2. Nat. Cell Biol.
2009, 11, 1411–1420. [CrossRef]
Zeng, Y.; Sankala, H.; Zhang, X.; Graves, P.R. Phosphorylation of Argonaute 2 at serine-387 facilitates its localization to processing
bodies. Biochem. J. 2008, 413, 429–436. [CrossRef]
Dadami, E.; Boutla, A.; Vrettos, N.; Tzortzakaki, S.; Karakasilioti, I.; Kalantidis, K. DICER-LIKE 4 but not DICER-LIKE 2 may have
a positive effect on potato spindle tuber viroid accumulation in Nicotiana benthamiana. Mol. Plant 2013, 6, 232–234. [CrossRef]
Pooggin, M.M. How can plant DNA viruses evade siRNA-directed DNA methylation and silencing? Int. J. Mol. Sci.
2013, 14, 15233–15259. [CrossRef]
Hryhorowicz, M.; Lipiński, D.; Zeyland, J.; Słomski, R. CRISPR/Cas9 immune system as a tool for genome engineering. Arch.
Immunol. Ther. Exp. 2017, 65, 233–240. [CrossRef]
Pixley, K.V.; Falck-Zpeda, J.B.; Giller, K.E.; Glenna, L.L.; Gould, F.; Mallory-Smith, C.A.; Stelly, D.M.; Stewart, C.N. Genome
editing, gene drives, and synthetic biology: Will they contribute to disease-resistant crops, and who will benefit? Annu. Rev.
Phytopathol. 2019, 57, 165–188. [CrossRef]
Zaidi, S.S.; Maha, A.; Vanderscheuren, H.; Mahfouz, M.M. Engineering crops of the future: CRISPR approaches to develop
climate-resilient and disease-resistant plants. Genome Biol. 2020, 21, 289. [CrossRef]
Ji, X.; Wang, D.; Gao, C. CRISPR editing-mediated antiviral immunity: A versatile source of resistance to combat plant virus
infections. Sci. China Life Sci. 2019, 62, 1246–1249. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Varanda, C.M.; Félix, M.D.R.; Campos, M.D.; Patanita, M.; Materatski, P. Plant Viruses: From Targets to Tools for CRISPR. Viruses
2021, 13, 141. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Zhang, T.; Zheng, Q.; Yi, X.; An, H.; Zhao, Y.; Ma, S.; Zhou, G. Establishing RNA virus resistance in plants by harnessing CRISPR
immune system. Plant Biotechnol. J. 2018, 16, 1415–1423. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Zhang, T.; Zhao, Y.; Ye, J.; Cao, X.; Xu, C.; Chen, B.; An, H.; Jiao, Y.; Zhang, F.; Yang, X.; et al. Establishing CRISPR/Cas13a immune
system conferring RNA virus resistance in both dicot and monocot plants. Plant Biotechnol. J. 2019, 17, 1185–1187. [CrossRef]
Plants 2023, 12, 1736
14 of 14
110. Ji, X.; Zhang, H.; Zhang, Y.; Wang, Y.; Gao, C. Establishing a CRISPR-Cas-like immune system conferring DNA virus resistance in
plants. Nat. Plants 2015, 28, 15144. [CrossRef]
111. Macovei, A.; Sevilla, N.R.; Cantos, C.; Jonson, G.B.; Slamet-Loedin, I.; Čermák, T.; Voytas, D.F.; Choi, I.; Chadha-Mohanty, P.
Novel alleles of rice eIF4G generated by CRISPR/Cas9-targeted mutagenesis confer resistance to Rice tungro spherical virus.
Plant Biotechnol. J. 2018, 16, 1918–1927. [CrossRef]
112. Zhan, X.; Zhang, F.; Zhong, Z.; Chen, R.; Wang, Y.; Chang, L.; Bock, R.; Nie, B.; Zhang, J. Generation of virus-resistant potato
plants by RNA genome targeting. Plant Biotechnol. J. 2019, 17, 1814–1822. [CrossRef]
113. Ruiyi, R.; Qiang, Z.; Futai, N.; Qiu, J.; Xiuqing, W.; Jicheng, W. Breeding for PVY resistance in tobacco LJ911 using CRISPR/Cas9
technology. Crop Breed. Appl. Biotechnol. 2021, 21, 1–6. [CrossRef]
114. Julio, E.; Cotucheau, J.; Decorps, C.; Volpatti, R.; Sentenac, C.; Candresse, T.; Dorlhac de Borne, F. A eukaryotic translation initiation
factor 4E (eIF4E) is responsible for the “va” tobacco recessive resistance to potyviruses. Plant Mol. Bio. Rep. 2015, 3, 609–623. [CrossRef]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual
author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to
people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
|
|
https://openalex.org/W2062866783
|
https://projecteuclid.org/journals/journal-of-applied-mathematics/volume-2014/issue-none/Growth-Theorems-for-a-Subclass-of-Strongly-Spirallike-Functions/10.1155/2014/608641.pdf
|
Latin
| null |
Growth Theorems for a Subclass of Strongly Spirallike Functions
|
Journal of applied mathematics
| 2,014
|
cc-by
| 5,819
|
1. Introduction growth and covering theorems for normalized biholomor-
phic convex functions on the unit disk and also obtained
the growth and covering theorems for normalized biholo-
morphic starlike functions on the unit disk by Alexander’s
theorem. Liu and Ren [6] obtained the growth theorems
for starlike mappings on the general bounded starlike and
circular domains in C𝑛. Liu and Lu [7] obtained the growth
theorems for starlike mappings of order 𝛼on the bounded
starlike and circular domains. Feng and Lu [8] obtained the
growth theorems for almost starlike mappings of order 𝛼
on the bounded starlike and circular domains. Honda [9]
obtained the growth theorems for normalized biholomorphic
𝑘-symmetric convex mappings on the unit ball in complex
Banach spaces. In recent years, there are a lot of new results
about the growth and covering theorems for the subclasses of
biholomorphic mappings in several complex variables [10–
12]. Growth theorems for univalent analytic functions are impor-
tant parts in geometric function theories of one complex
variable. In 1983, Duren [1] obtained the following well-
known growth and deviation theorem. Theorem 1 (see [1]). If 𝑓(𝑧) is a normalized biholomorphic
function on the unit disk 𝐷, then |𝑧|
(1 + |𝑧|)2 ≤𝑓(𝑧)≤
|𝑧|
(1 −|𝑧|)2 ,
1 −|𝑧|
(1 + |𝑧|)3 ≤𝑓(𝑧)≤
1 + |𝑧|
(1 −|𝑧|)3 . (1) (1) Many scholars tried to extend the beautiful results to
the cases in several complex variables. However, Cartan [2]
pointed out that the corresponding growth theorem does
not hold in several complex variables. He suggested that
we may consider the biholomorphic mappings with special
geometrical characteristic, such as convex mappings and
starlike mappings. It can be seen that we can make a great breakthrough
in the growth and covering theorems for the subclasses of
biholomorphic mappings in several complex variables if we
restrict the biholomorphic mappings with the geometrical
characteristic. The mappings discussed focus on starlike
mappings, convex mappings, and their subclasses. In 1991, Barnard et al. [3] obtained the growth theorems
for starlike mappings on the unit ball 𝐵𝑛in C𝑛firstly. After
that, there are a lot of followup studies. Gong et al. [4] ex-
tended the results to the cases on 𝐵𝑛and obtained the growth
theorems for starlike mappings on the bounded convex
Reinhardt domains 𝐵𝑝. Graham and Varolin [5] obtained the In 1974, Suffridge extended starlike mappings and convex
mappings and gave the definition of spirallike mappings. Yan-Yan Cui, Chao-Jun Wang, and Si-Feng Zhu Correspondence should be addressed to Si-Feng Zhu; zhusifeng@163.com Correspondence should be addressed to Si-Feng Zhu; zhusifeng@163.com Received 8 June 2014; Revised 22 July 2014; Accepted 22 July 2014; Published 12 August 2014 Academic Editor: Francisco J. Marcell´an Copyright © 2014 Yan-Yan Cui et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. In this paper we consider a subclass of strongly spirallike functions on the unit disk 𝐷in the complex plane C, namely, strongly
almost spirallike functions of type 𝛽and order 𝛼. We obtain the growth results for strongly almost spirallike functions of type 𝛽and
order 𝛼on the unit disk 𝐷in C by using subordination principles and the geometric properties of analytic mappings. Furthermore
we get the growth theorems for strongly almost starlike functions of order 𝛼and strongly starlike functions on the unit disk 𝐷of
C. These growth results follow the deviation results of these functions. Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Journal of Applied Mathematics
Volume 2014, Article ID 608641, 8 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/608641 Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Journal of Applied Mathematics
Volume 2014, Article ID 608641, 8 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/608641 Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Journal of Applied Mathematics
Volume 2014, Article ID 608641, 8 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/608641 Research Article
Growth Theorems for a Subclass of Strongly Spirallike Functions Yan-Yan Cui, Chao-Jun Wang, and Si-Feng Zhu
College of Mathematics and Statistics, Zhoukou Normal University, Zhoukou, Henan 466001, China
Correspondence should be addressed to Si-Feng Zhu; zhusifeng@163.com
Received 8 June 2014; Revised 22 July 2014; Accepted 22 July 2014; Published 12 August 2014
Academic Editor: Francisco J. Marcell´an 1. Introduction Therefore we get that there
exists an analytic function 𝑤(𝑧) on 𝐷which satisfies 𝑝(𝑧) =
(1 + 𝑐𝑤(𝑧))/(1 −𝑐𝑤(𝑧)), where 𝑤(0) = 0, |𝑤(𝑧)| < 1. Then so we have 𝑝(𝑧) ≺(1+𝑐𝑧)/(1−𝑐𝑧). Therefore we get that there
exists an analytic function 𝑤(𝑧) on 𝐷which satisfies 𝑝(𝑧) =
(1 + 𝑐𝑤(𝑧))/(1 −𝑐𝑤(𝑧)), where 𝑤(0) = 0, |𝑤(𝑧)| < 1. Then Then 𝑓(𝑧) is called a strongly almost spirallike function of
type 𝛽and order 𝛼on 𝐷. −𝛼+ 𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝛼
+ 1 −𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝛼
⋅𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧) = 1 + 𝑐𝑤(𝑧)
1 −𝑐𝑤(𝑧). (9) (9) We can get the definition of strongly spirallike functions
of type 𝛽[18], strongly almost starlike functions of order 𝛼
[19], and strongly starlike functions on 𝐷[19] by setting 𝛼= 0,
𝛽= 0, and 𝛼= 𝛽= 0, respectively, in Definition 2. Immediately, we have 𝑐𝑤(𝑧) i
In order to give the main results, we need the following
lemmas. =
(𝑓(𝑧) /𝑧𝑓(𝑧)) −1
(𝑓(𝑧) /𝑧𝑓(𝑧)) + ((1 −2𝛼+ 𝑖tan 𝛽) / (1 −𝑖tan 𝛽)). (10) Lemma 3 (see [1]). Let 𝑔(𝑧) be an univalent analytic function
on 𝐷. Then 𝑓(𝑧) ≺𝑔(𝑧) if and only if 𝑓(0) = 𝑔(0), 𝑓(𝐷) ⊂
𝑔(𝐷). ))
(10) It follows that
[ 𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧) −1] [ 𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧) −2𝛼−1 −𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝑖tan 𝛽
]
−1
= 𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| . (11) Lemma 4 (see [20]). |(𝑧−𝑧1)/(𝑧−𝑧2)| = 𝑘(0 < 𝑘
̸= 1, 𝑧1
̸=
𝑧2) represents a circle whose center is 𝑧0 and whose radius is 𝜌
in C, where (11) 𝑧0 = 𝑧1 −𝑘2𝑧2
1 −𝑘2 ,
𝜌= 𝑘𝑧1 −𝑧2
1 −𝑘2
. (3) From Lemma 3, we deduce that the image of the unit disk 𝐷
under the mapping 𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧) is the disk whose center is 𝑎
and whose radius is 𝜌, where From Lemma 3, we deduce that the image of the unit disk 𝐷
under the mapping 𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧) is the disk whose center is 𝑎
and whose radius is 𝜌, where (3) Lemma 5 (see [20]). Let 𝑓(𝑧) : 𝐷→𝐷be an analytic
function on 𝐷and 𝑓(0) = 0. Then |𝑓(0)| ≤1 and |𝑓(𝑧)| ≤|𝑧|
for ∀𝑧∈𝐷. Lemma 5 (see [20]). Let 𝑓(𝑧) : 𝐷→𝐷be an analytic
function on 𝐷and 𝑓(0) = 0. Then |𝑓(0)| ≤1 and |𝑓(𝑧)| ≤|𝑧|
for ∀𝑧∈𝐷. 𝑎= [1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 ⋅2𝛼−1 −𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝑖tan 𝛽
]
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
=
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 {1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 [2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽) f
for ∀𝑧∈𝐷. 1. Introduction Gurganus [13] gave the definition of spirallike mappings of
type 𝛽in several complex variables. Hamada and Kohr [14]
obtained the growth theorems for spirallike mappings on 2 Journal of Applied Mathematics 2 where where some domains. Later Feng [15] gave the definition of almost
spirallike mappings of type 𝛽and order 𝛼on the unit ball
𝐵𝑛in C𝑛. Feng et al. [16] obtained the growth theorems for
almost spirallike mappings of type 𝛽and order 𝛼on the unit
ball in complex Banach spaces.i 𝑚1 = 𝑐2 [2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) −1] ,
𝑛= 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽,
𝑚2 = 𝑐2 [1 −4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽] . (5) ]
(5) p
p
However, when we introduce the definition of the new
subclasses of starlike mappings, convex mappings, and spi-
rallike mappings, we always discuss them in C firstly.i Proof. Since 𝑓(𝑧) is a strongly almost spirallike function of
type 𝛽and order 𝛼on 𝐷, we get i
In [17], Cai and Liu gave the definition of strongly almost
spirallike functions of type 𝛽and order 𝛼on the unit disk. They also discussed their coefficient estimates.
−𝛼+ 𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝛼
+ 1 −𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝛼
⋅𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧) −1 + 𝑐2
1 −𝑐2
<
2𝑐
1 −𝑐2 . (6) hfi
In this paper, we mainly discuss the growth theorems for
strongly almost spirallike functions of type 𝛽and order 𝛼on
𝐷, where 𝐷is the unit disk. Moreover we get the growth
theorems for strongly almost starlike functions of order 𝛼
and strongly starlike functions on 𝐷. At last, we obtain the
deviation results of these functions. (6) Let 𝑝(𝑧) = −𝛼+ 𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝛼
+ 1 −𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝛼
⋅𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧). (7) (7) Definition 2 (see [17]). Suppose that 𝑓(𝑧) is an analytic
function on 𝐷, 𝛼∈[0, 1), 𝛽∈(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2), 𝑐∈(0, 1), and Definition 2 (see [17]). Suppose that 𝑓(𝑧) is an analytic
function on 𝐷, 𝛼∈[0, 1), 𝛽∈(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2), 𝑐∈(0, 1), and Then 𝑝(0) = 1,
𝑝(𝑧) −1 + 𝑐2
1 −𝑐2
<
2𝑐
1 −𝑐2 ,
(8)
−𝛼+ 𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝛼
+ 1 −𝑖tan 𝛽
1 −𝛼
⋅𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧) −1 + 𝑐2
1 −𝑐2
<
2𝑐
1 −𝑐2 ,
𝑧∈𝐷\ {0} . (2) (8) (2) so we have 𝑝(𝑧) ≺(1+𝑐𝑧)/(1−𝑐𝑧). 2. Main Results Theorem 6. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost spirallike function of
type 𝛽and order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[1/2, 1), 𝛽∈(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2), 𝑐∈
(0, 1). Then + 𝑖(𝛼−1) sin (2𝛽)]} , 𝜌= 𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
. 1 −𝑐2|𝑧|2
1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
≤
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
,
(4) (4) (12) Journal of Applied Mathematics Journal of Applied Mathematics 3 =
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× {1 + 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× [2 (1 −𝛼) sin 𝛽cos 𝛽
−(1 −2 (1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽)]
+𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽} So we have So we have
𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧) −𝑎
≤𝜌. (13) (13) Then |𝑎| −𝜌≤
𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
≤|𝑎| + 𝜌. (14) (14) =
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× {1 + 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× [2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) −1]
+𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽} . On the one hand, in view of (14), we have
=
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 On the one hand, in view of (14), we have
=
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧 On the one hand, in view of (14), we have
=
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 On the one hand, in view of (14), we have
𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
≤
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× {1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽))
+ 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (1 −𝛼) sin (2𝛽)
+𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽} . (15)
|
( )|
× {1 + 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× [2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) −1]
+𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽} . (18)
Let × {1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽))
+ 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (1 −𝛼) sin (2𝛽)
+𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽} . (15) (18) Observing that bserving that
𝑐2 [2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) −1] = 𝑚1,
(19) Observing that
𝑐2 [2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) −1] = 𝑚1,
(19) (19) −cos (2𝛽) = 2𝛼cos2𝛽−2cos2𝛽+ 1
2𝑐(1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽= 𝑛. 2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽) = 2𝛼cos2𝛽−2cos2𝛽+ 1
= 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽+ 1
= 1 −2 (1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽
(16)
2𝑐(1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽= 𝑛. (19)
Then we have
𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
. (20) 2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽) = 2𝛼cos2𝛽−2cos2𝛽+ 1
= 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽+ 1
(16)
2𝑐
Then we have = 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽+ 1
(16)
Then we have
𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
. 2. Main Results (20) (20) and 1−2(1−𝛼)cos2𝛽< 1 for 𝛼∈[1/2, 1) and 𝛽∈(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2),
we get
This means that and 1−2(1−𝛼)cos2𝛽< 1 for 𝛼∈[1/2, 1) and 𝛽∈(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2),
we get
This means that 1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽)) > 0
(17)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≥
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
. (21) (21) 1
𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| (2𝛼cos 𝛽
cos (2𝛽)) > 0
(17)
for 𝑐∈(0, 1) and |𝑤(𝑧)| < 1. Thus, in view of (15), (16), and
(17), we obtain
𝑓(𝑧)
1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
Let
1
𝑐2𝑥2 for 𝑐∈(0, 1) and |𝑤(𝑧)| < 1. Thus, in view of (15), (16), and
(17), we obtain
Let
2
2 |𝑤(𝑧)| = 𝑥,
1 −𝑐2𝑥2
1 + 𝑚1𝑥2 + 𝑛𝑥= 𝑔(𝑥) . (22) (22)
𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
≤
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
≤
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× {1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽))
+ 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (1 −𝛼) sin (2𝛽)
+𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽}
|𝑤(𝑧)|
𝑥,
1 + 𝑚1𝑥2 + 𝑛𝑥
𝑔(𝑥) . (22)
Obviously, we have
𝑔(𝑥) = −
𝑛𝑐2𝑥2 + 2 (𝑚1 + 𝑐2) 𝑥+ 𝑛
(1 + 𝑚1𝑥2 + 𝑛𝑥)2
. (23)
Observing that Obviously, we have × {1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽))
+ 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (1 −𝛼) sin (2𝛽)
+𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽} 𝑔(𝑥) = −
𝑛𝑐2𝑥2 + 2 (𝑚1 + 𝑐2) 𝑥+ 𝑛
(1 + 𝑚1𝑥2 + 𝑛𝑥)2
. (23) (23) Observing that =
1
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× {1 + 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
× [(1 −𝛼) sin (2𝛽)
−(2𝛼cos2𝛽−cos (2𝛽))]
+𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)| ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽} 𝑚1 + 𝑐2 = 𝑐2 ⋅2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) > 0
(24) (24) and 𝑛> 0, 𝑥= |𝑤(𝑧)| ≥0, we deduce that 𝑔(𝑥) < 0. So 𝑔(𝑥)
is a monotone decreasing function for 𝑥∈[0,1). Also we have
|𝑤(𝑧)| ≤|𝑧| from Lemma 4. Then
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≥
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
≥
1 −𝑐2|𝑧|2
1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
. (25) (25) 4 Journal of Applied Mathematics = ((1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 (|𝑎| + 𝜌))
× ((1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽
⋅𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 −1))
−1
≤
1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽⋅𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
=
1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
1 + [4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽−1] 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 . 2. Main Results (29) = ((1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 (|𝑎| + 𝜌))
× ((1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽
⋅𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 −1))
−1 On the other hand, by direct computations, we have |𝑎|2 =
1
(1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2
× {[1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (1 + 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽)]
2
+ 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4[2 (𝛼−1) cos 𝛽sin 𝛽]2} × {[1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (1 + 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽)]
2
+ 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4[2 (𝛼−1) cos 𝛽sin 𝛽]2} ≤
1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽⋅𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 =
1
(1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2
× {1 −2𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 [1 + 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]
+ 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4 [1 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]} ,
𝜌
2 =
1
(1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 ⋅4𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2(1 −𝛼)2cos2𝛽. ( =
1
(1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2
× {1 −2𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 [1 + 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]
+ 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4 [1 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]} ,
𝜌
2 =
1
(1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 ⋅4𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2(1 −𝛼)2cos2𝛽. (26)
=
1 +
1 + [4𝛼(
Let
𝑐2 [1
Then
𝑧𝑓(𝑧) =
1
(1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2
× {1 −2𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 [1 + 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]
+ 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4 [1 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]} ,
𝜌
2 =
1
(1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 ⋅4𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2(1 −𝛼)2cos2𝛽. (26)
=
1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
1 + [4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽−1] 𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 . (29)
Let
𝑐2 [1 −4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽] = 𝑚2. (30)
Then
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
(31) (26) (29) × {1 −2𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 [1 + 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]
+ 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4 [1 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]} , Let 𝑐2 [1 −4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽] = 𝑚2. (30) (30) Then
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
1 −𝑚2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
. (31) It follows that Let (|𝑎|2 −𝜌2) (1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 (|𝑎|2 −𝜌2) (1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2
= 1 −2𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 [1 + 2 (𝛼−1) cos2𝛽+ 2(1 −𝛼)2cos2𝛽
+ 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4 [1 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]
= 1 −2𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 [1 + 2𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]
+ 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4 [1 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽]
= [1 −2𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4] + 𝑐4|𝑤(𝑧)|4
⋅4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽−2𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 ⋅2𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽
= (1 −𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2)
2 + 4𝛼(𝛼−1) cos2𝛽
⋅𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 (𝑐2|𝑤(𝑧)|2 −1) > 0. ( |𝑤(𝑧)| = 𝑥,
1 + 𝑚1𝑥2 + 𝑛𝑥
1 −𝑚2𝑥2
= ℎ(𝑥) . 2. Main Results (32) (32) Immediately, we have Immediately, we have (𝑥)
=
(2𝑚1𝑥+ 𝑛) (1 −𝑚2𝑥2) + (1 + 𝑚1𝑥2 + 𝑛𝑥) ⋅2𝑚2𝑥
(1 −𝑚2𝑥2)2
= 𝑛𝑚2𝑥2 + 2 (𝑚1 + 𝑚2) 𝑥+ 𝑛
(1 −𝑚2𝑥2)2
=
𝑛𝑚2
(1
𝑚𝑥2)2 ℎ(𝑥) =
(2𝑚1𝑥+ 𝑛) (1 −𝑚2𝑥2) + (1 + 𝑚1𝑥2 + 𝑛𝑥) ⋅2𝑚2𝑥
(1 −𝑚2𝑥2)2
= 𝑛𝑚2𝑥2 + 2 (𝑚1 + 𝑚2) 𝑥+ 𝑛
(1 −𝑚2𝑥2)2 =
(2𝑚1𝑥+ 𝑛) (1 −𝑚2𝑥2) + (1 + 𝑚1𝑥2 + 𝑛𝑥) ⋅2𝑚2𝑥
(1 −𝑚2𝑥2)2 = 𝑛𝑚2𝑥2 + 2 (𝑚1 + 𝑚2) 𝑥+ 𝑛
(1 −𝑚2𝑥2)2 =
𝑛𝑚2
(1 −𝑚2𝑥2)2 × [(𝑥+ 𝑚1 + 𝑚2
𝑛𝑚2
)
2
+ 𝑛2𝑚2 −(𝑚1 + 𝑚2)2
𝑛2𝑚2
2
] . (33) (27) (33) This means that |𝑎| > 𝜌. By (14) we know that
(
)
Also, we can get This means that |𝑎| > 𝜌. By (14) we know that This means that |𝑎| > 𝜌. By (14) we know that Also, we can get 𝑛2𝑚2 −(𝑚1 + 𝑚2)2
= −4𝑐2(1 −𝛼)2cos2𝛽⋅2 (1 −2𝛼) sin 𝛽cos 𝛽≥0
(34)
𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
≥|𝑎| −𝜌. (28) (34) (28) for 𝛼∈[1/2, 1), 𝛽∈(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2). Moreover, it is obvious that
𝑚2 > 0 and 𝑛> 0. So we obtain ℎ(𝑥) > 0. Therefore ℎ(𝑥) is
a monotone increasing function for 𝑥∈[0,1). In addition, we
have |𝑤(𝑧)| ≤|𝑧| from Lemma 4. Hence In view of (15) and (19), we have In view of (15) and (19), we have
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤
1
|𝑎| −𝜌= |𝑎| + 𝜌
|𝑎|2 −𝜌2
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑤(𝑧)|2 + 𝑛|𝑤(𝑧)|
1 −𝑚2|𝑤(𝑧)|2
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
. (35) (35) Journal of Applied Mathematics 5 From the above results, we obtain
Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since From the above results, we obtain
Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since From the above results, we obtain
Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since From the above results, we obtain From the above results, we obtain 1 −𝑐2|𝑧|2
1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
≤
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
. (36)
This completes the proof. Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧) ) = 𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
,
(44)
we get (44) This completes the proof. Theorem 7. Suppose that 𝑓(𝑧) is a strongly almost starlike
unction of order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1), 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
. (45) Theorem 7. Suppose that 𝑓(𝑧) is a strongly almost starlike
function of order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1), 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
. (45) Theorem 7. Suppose that 𝑓(𝑧) is a strongly almost starlike
function of order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1), 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Theorem 7. Suppose that 𝑓(𝑧) is a strongly almost starlike
function of order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1), 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Theorem 7. Suppose that 𝑓(𝑧) is a strongly almost starlike
function of order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1), 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
. (45) (45) 1 −𝑐2|𝑧|2
1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|
≤
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|
1 −𝑐2(1 −2𝛼)2|𝑧|2
. (37) 1 −𝑐2|𝑧|2
1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|
≤
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|
1 −𝑐2(1 −2𝛼)2|𝑧|2
. (37)
Thus
∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
d𝑟≤∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
1 + 𝑚1𝑟2 + 𝑛𝑟
(1 −𝑚2𝑟2) 𝑟d𝑟. (46) (46) Furthermore, Furthermore, Furthermore, Proof. Let 𝛽= 0 and 𝛼∈[0, 1) in Theorem 6. Then (34) holds,
so we can obtain the same result; that is, ∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
1 + 𝑚1𝑟2 + 𝑛𝑟
(1 −𝑚2𝑟2) 𝑟d𝑟
= (𝑚1 + 𝑚2) ∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
𝑟
1 −𝑚2𝑟2 d𝑟
+ 𝑛∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
d𝑟
1 −𝑚2𝑟2 + ∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
d𝑟
𝑟
= 𝑚1 + 𝑚2
−2𝑚2
ln 1 −𝑚2𝑟2
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀
+
𝑛
2√𝑚2
ln
−2𝑚2𝑟−2√𝑚2
−2𝑚2𝑟+ 2√𝑚2
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀
+ ln 𝑟|𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀. (47) 1 −𝑐2|𝑧|2
1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
≤
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
,
(38) (38) (38) where where 𝑚1 = 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) ,
𝑛= 2𝑐(1 −2𝛼) ,
𝑚2 = 𝑐2(1 −2𝛼)2. From the above results, we obtain (50) 6 Journal of Applied Mathematics 6 Observing that 𝑚2 < 1, we have Observing that 𝑚2 < 1, we have Observing that 𝑚2 < 1, we have 𝑓(𝑧)
≤|𝑧| ⋅(1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2)
(𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
⋅(1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|
1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)
𝑛/2√𝑚2
= |𝑧| (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)((𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2)+(𝑛/2√𝑚2)
⋅(1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)((𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2)−(𝑛/2√𝑚2)
= |𝑧| (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2−𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
(51)
𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
≤1 + 𝑐|𝑧|
1 −𝑐|𝑧|. (59)
Thus
∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
d𝑟≤∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
1 + 𝑐𝑟
(1 −𝑐𝑟) 𝑟d𝑟
= ∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
2𝑐
1 −𝑐𝑟d𝑟+ ∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
d𝑟
𝑟. (60)
So we get
𝑟=|𝑧|
ln (1
𝑐𝑟)𝑟=|𝑧| 𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
≤1 + 𝑐|𝑧|
1 −𝑐|𝑧|. (59) 𝑓(𝑧)
≤|𝑧| ⋅(1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2)
(𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
⋅(1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|
1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)
𝑛/2√𝑚2
𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
≤1 + 𝑐|𝑧|
1 −𝑐|𝑧|. (59)
Thus
∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
d𝑟≤∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
1 + 𝑐𝑟
(1 −𝑐𝑟) 𝑟d𝑟
(60) 𝑓(𝑧)
≤|𝑧| ⋅(1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2)
(𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
⋅(1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|
1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)
𝑛/2√𝑚2 (59) ≤|𝑧| ⋅(1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2)
(𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2 ⋅(1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|
1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)
𝑛/2√𝑚2 (60) = |𝑧| (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)((𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2)+(𝑛/2√𝑚2)
⋅(1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)((𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2)−(𝑛/2√𝑚2)
= |𝑧| (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2−𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
⋅(1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2+𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2. (51) (51) = |𝑧| (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)((𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2)+(𝑛/2√𝑚2)
⋅(1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)((𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2)−(𝑛/2√𝑚2)
= |𝑧| (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2−𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
⋅(1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2+𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2. (51)
= ∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
So we get
ln 𝑓(𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃)
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀≤2𝑐ln (1 −
−𝑐 So we get So we get ln 𝑓(𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃)
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀≤2𝑐ln (1 −𝑐𝑟)
−𝑐
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀
+ ln |𝑟||𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀. (61) (61) Letting 𝜀→0, it follows that Letting 𝜀→0, it follows that Letting 𝜀→0, it follows that This completes the proof. ln 𝑓(𝑧)≤−2 ln (1 −𝑐|𝑧|) + ln |𝑧| . (62) (62) Similar to Theorem 9, by Theorem 7, we can get the
following results. Therefore we obtain Theorem 10. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost starlike function of
order 1/2 on 𝐷and 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then 𝑓(𝑧)≤
|𝑧|
(1 −𝑐|𝑧|)2 . (63) (63) 𝑓(𝑧)≤e𝑐|𝑧| . (52) (52) Also, we can get the conclusion by letting 𝛼= 0 in
Theorem 11. This completes the proof. Theorem 11. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost starlike function of
order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1) \ {1/2}, 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Theorem 11. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost starlike function of
order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1) \ {1/2}, 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Theorem 14. From the above results, we obtain (47) (39) 𝑚2 = 𝑐2(1 −2𝛼)2. Therefore we get the conclusion. Therefore we get the conclusion. Therefore we get the conclusion. Let 𝛼= 0 in Theorem 7; we can get the following result
for strongly starlike functions. Corollary 8. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly starlike function on 𝐷and
𝑐∈(0, 1). Then It follows that It follows that ln 𝑓(𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃)
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀 ln 𝑓(𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃)
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀
≤𝑚1 + 𝑚2
−2𝑚2
ln 1 −𝑚2𝑟2
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀
+
𝑛
2√𝑚2
ln
√𝑚2𝑟+ 1
√𝑚2𝑟−1
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀
+ ln 𝑟|𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀. (48) 1 −𝑐|𝑧|
1 + 𝑐|𝑧| ≤
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑐|𝑧|
1 −𝑐|𝑧|. (40) (40) ≤𝑚1 + 𝑚2
−2𝑚2
ln 1 −𝑚2𝑟2
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀
+
𝑛
2√𝑚2
ln
√𝑚2𝑟+ 1
√𝑚2𝑟−1
𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀
+ ln 𝑟|𝑟=|𝑧|
𝑟=𝜀. (48) (48) Theorem 9. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost spirallike function of
type 𝛽and order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈(1/2, 1), 𝛽∈(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2), 𝑐∈
(0, 1). Then 𝑓(𝑧)≤|𝑧| (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2−𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
⋅(1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2+𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2, 𝑓(𝑧)≤|𝑧| (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2−𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
⋅(1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+𝑚2+𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2,
(41)
2√𝑚2
Let 𝜀→0; we have (41)
Let 𝜀→0; we have (41) (41) ln 𝑓(𝑧)≤𝑚1 + 𝑚2
−2𝑚2
ln 1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2 ln 𝑓(𝑧)≤𝑚1 + 𝑚2
−2𝑚2
ln 1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
+
𝑛
2√𝑚2
ln
√𝑚2 |𝑧| + 1
√𝑚2 |𝑧| −1
+ ln |𝑧| . (49) where where (49) 𝑚1 = 𝑐2 [2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) −1] ,
𝑛= 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽,
𝑚2 = 𝑐2 [1 −4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽] . (42)
+
𝑛
2√𝑚2
ln
√𝑚2 |𝑧| + 1
√𝑚2 |𝑧| −1
+ ln |𝑧| . (49)
Consequently, 𝑚1 = 𝑐2 [2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) −1] ,
𝑛= 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽,
𝑚2 = 𝑐2 [1 −4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽] . (42)
Consequent (42) (42) Consequently, Consequently, 𝑚2 = 𝑐2 [1 −4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽] . Consequently, 𝑓(𝑧)≤|𝑧| ⋅1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
(𝑚1+𝑚2)/−2𝑚2 Proof. From Theorem 6, we have Proof. From Theorem 6, we have (50) Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧) ) ≤
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|
1 −𝑚2|𝑧|2
. (43)
⋅
√𝑚2 |𝑧| + 1
√𝑚2 |𝑧| −1
𝑛/2√𝑚2
. From the above results, we obtain Since Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)/𝑓(𝑧)) = 𝑟(𝜕ln |𝑓(𝑧)|)/𝜕𝑟, we
have
× [1 + 𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))+((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|)
⋅[1 −𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))−((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|). Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)/𝑓(𝑧)) = 𝑟(𝜕ln |𝑓(𝑧)|)/𝜕𝑟, we
have
× [1 + 𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))+((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|)
⋅[1 −𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))−((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|). Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)/𝑓(𝑧)) = 𝑟(𝜕ln |𝑓(𝑧)|)/𝜕𝑟, we
have 𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
> (1 −𝑐|𝑧|)3
(1 + 𝑐|𝑧|)3 . (70) 𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
> (1 −𝑐|𝑧|)3
(1 + 𝑐|𝑧|)3 . (70)
[1
𝑐|1
2𝛼| |𝑧|]
Let 𝛼= 0 in Theorem 16; we can get th (77) (70) Let 𝛼= 0 in Theorem 16; we can get the following result. Let 𝛼= 0 in Theorem 16; we can get the following result. Therefore we obtain Therefore we obtain ore we obtain
∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
d𝑟> ∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
(1 −𝑐𝑟)3
(1 + 𝑐𝑟)3 ⋅d𝑟
𝑟. (71)
Corollary 17. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly starlike function on 𝐷and
𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
𝑓( )≤
1 + 𝑐|𝑧|
(78) Corollary 17. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly starlike function on 𝐷and
𝑐∈(0, 1). Then re we obtain
∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
d𝑟> ∫
|𝑧|
𝜀
(1 −𝑐𝑟)3
(1 + 𝑐𝑟)3 ⋅d𝑟
𝑟. (71)
Corollary 17. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly starlike function on 𝐷and
𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
1
| | (1 −𝑐𝑟)3
(1 + 𝑐𝑟)3 ⋅d𝑟
𝑟. (71) (71) 𝑓(𝑧)≤
1 + 𝑐|𝑧|
(1 −𝑐|𝑧|)3 . (78) (78) Then we have ln 𝑓(𝑧) Acknowledgments This work is supported by NSF of China (nos. 11271359 and
U1204618) and Science and Technology Research Projects of This work is supported by NSF of China (nos. 11271359 and
U1204618) and Science and Technology Research Projects of
Henan Provincial Education Department (nos. 14B110015 and
14B110016). So So gy
j
Henan Provincial Education Department (nos. 14B110015 and
14B110016). (73) Conflict of Interests The authors declare that they have no conflict of interests. From the above results, we obtain Suppose that 𝑓(𝑧) is a strongly starlike function
on 𝐷and 𝑐∈(0, 1); then 𝑓(𝑧)≤|𝑧| ⋅[1 + 𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((1−𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))+((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|)
⋅[1 −𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((1−𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))−((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|). (53) 𝑒(4(2𝑐2 |𝑧|2−1))/(1+𝑐|𝑧|)2
⋅
|𝑧|
(1 + 𝑐|𝑧|)2 < 𝑓(𝑧)≤
|𝑧|
(1 −𝑐|𝑧|)2 . (64) (53) )
(64) Remark 12. Let 1/2 < 𝛼< 1 in Theorem 11. Then we have Proof. On the one hand, from Corollary 13, we obtain
|𝑓(𝑧)| ≤(|𝑧|)/(1 −𝑐|𝑧|)2.h Proof. On the one hand, from Corollary 13, we obtain
|𝑓(𝑧)| ≤(|𝑧|)/(1 −𝑐|𝑧|)2.h 𝑓(𝑧)≤|𝑧| ⋅[1 + 𝑐(2𝛼−1) |𝑧|](2(1−𝛼))/(2𝛼−1). (54)
Let 0 < 𝛼< 1/2 in Theorem 10. Then we have 𝑓(𝑧)≤|𝑧| ⋅[1 + 𝑐(2𝛼−1) |𝑧|](2(1−𝛼))/(2𝛼−1). (54) (54) 𝑓
On the other hand, by 𝑎and 𝜌in the proof of Theorem 6,
we can obtain Let 0 < 𝛼< 1/2 in Theorem 10. Then we have (55)
l
Re 𝑎−𝜌
(|𝑎| + 𝜌)
2 = (1 −𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)|)3
(1 + 𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)|)3
(65) Re 𝑎−𝜌
(|𝑎| + 𝜌)
2 = (1 −𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)|)3
(1 + 𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)|)3
(65) 𝑓(𝑧)≤|𝑧| ⋅[1 −𝑐(1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|] (2(1−𝛼))/(2𝛼−1) . (55) (55) (55) (65) Let 𝛼= 0 in Theorem 11; we can get the following result. for 𝛼= 𝛽= 0. Let 𝜆(𝑥) = (1 −𝑐𝑥)3/(1 + 𝑐𝑥)3. Then we have
𝜆(𝑥) = −6𝑐(1 −𝑐𝑥)2
(1 + 𝑐𝑥)4
< 0. (66) Corollary 13. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly starlike function on 𝐷and
𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
for 𝛼
𝛽 Corollary 13. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly starlike function on 𝐷and
𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
𝛽
( )
(
) /(
)h
𝜆(𝑥) = −6𝑐(1 −𝑐𝑥)2
(1
)4
< 0. (66) (66) 𝑓(𝑧)≤
|𝑧|
(1 −𝑐|𝑧|)2 . (56)
The
i (56) (56) Therefore
(1 −𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)|)3/(1 + 𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)|)3
is
a
monotone
increasing function with respect to |𝑤(𝑧)|. Also we can know
that |𝑤(𝑧)| ≤|𝑧| from Lemma 4. Hence Proof. According to Corollary 8, we obtain Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧) ) ≤
𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧)
≤1 + 𝑐|𝑧|
1 −𝑐|𝑧|. (57)
Re 𝑎−𝜌
(|𝑎| + 𝜌)2 = (1 −𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)|)3
(1 + 𝑐|𝑤(𝑧)|)3 > (1 −𝑐|𝑧|)3
(1 + 𝑐|𝑧|)3 . (67) (57) (67) Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since t 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since
By (14) we obtain Since
By (14) we obtain By (14) we obtain By (14) we obtain Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧) ) = 𝑟𝜕ln 𝑓(𝑧)
𝜕𝑟
,
(58)
Re 𝑓(𝑧)
𝑧𝑓(𝑧) ≥Re 𝑎−𝜌. References Therefore we obtain 𝑒(4(2𝑐2|𝑧|2−1))/(1+𝑐|𝑧|)2
⋅
|𝑧|
(1 + 𝑐|𝑧|)2
< 𝑓(𝑧)≤
|𝑧|
(1 −𝑐|𝑧|)2 . [1] P. L. Duren, Univalent Functions, Springer, Berlin, Germany,
1983. [1] P. L. Duren, Univalent Functions, Springer, Berlin, Germany,
1983. (74) [2] H. Cartan, “Sur la possibilite d’entendre aux fonctions de
plusieurs variables complexes la theorie des fonctions univa-
lents,” in Lecons sur les Fonctions Univalents on Mutivalents, P. Montel, Ed., pp. 129–155, Gauthier-Villar, 1933. This completes the proof. [3] R. W. Barnard, C. H. FitzGerald, and S. Gong, “The growth
and 1/4-theorems for starlike mappings in C𝑛,” Pacific Journal
of Mathematics, vol. 150, no. 1, pp. 13–22, 1991. From Theorems 6 and 9, we can get the following result. [4] S. Gong, S. K. Wang, and Q. H. Yu, “The growth and 1/4-
theorem for starlike mappings on 𝐵𝑝,” Chinese Annals of
Mathematics B, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 100–104, 1990. Theorem 15. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost spirallike function
of type 𝛽and order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼
∈
(1/2, 1), 𝛽
∈
(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2), 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Theorem 15. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost spirallike function
of type 𝛽and order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼
∈
(1/2, 1), 𝛽
∈
(−𝜋/2, 𝜋/2), 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then [5] I. Graham and D. Varolin, “Bloch constants in one and several
variables,” Pacific Journal of Mathematics, vol. 174, no. 2, pp. 347–
357, 1996. 𝑓(𝑧) ≤(1 + 𝑚1|𝑧|2 + 𝑛|𝑧|) (1 + √𝑚2 |𝑧|)
(𝑚1+3𝑚2−𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2
⋅(1 −√𝑚2 |𝑧|)(𝑚1+3𝑚2+𝑛√𝑚2)/−2𝑚2,
(75 [6] T. Liu and G. Ren, “The growth theorem for starlike mappings
on bounded starlike circular domains,” Chinese Annals of
Mathematics B, vol. 19, no. 4, pp. 401–408, 1998. (75) [7] H. Liu and K. P. Lu, “Two subclasses of starlike mappings in
several complex variables,” Chinese Annals of Mathematics, vol. 21, no. 5, pp. 533–546, 2000. where [8] S. X. Feng and K. P. Lu, “The growth theorem for almost starlike
mappings of order 𝛼on bounded starlike circular domains,”
Chinese Quarterly Journal of Mathematics. Shuxue Jikan, vol. 15,
no. 2, pp. 50–56, 2000. 𝑚1 = 𝑐2 [2 (1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽(sin 𝛽+ cos 𝛽) −1] ,
𝑚2 = 𝑐2 [1 −4𝛼(1 −𝛼) cos2𝛽] ,
𝑛= 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) cos 𝛽. (76) (76) [9] T. Honda, “The growth theorem for 𝑘-fold symmetric convex
mappings,” The Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society, vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 717–724, 2002. From Theorems 7 and 11, we can get the following result. From the above results, we obtain (68) (58) (68) Journal of Applied Mathematics
7 Journal of Applied Mathematics Journal of Applied Mathematics 7 Furthermore, |𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧)| ≤|𝑎| + 𝜌, so
(𝑓( ) / 𝑓( ))
Theorem 16. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost starlike function of
order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1) \ {1/2}, 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Furthermore, |𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧)| ≤|𝑎| + 𝜌, so
R (𝑓( ) / 𝑓( ))
Theorem 16. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost starlike function of
order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1) \ {1/2}, 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Furthermore, |𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧)| ≤|𝑎| + 𝜌, so
R (𝑓( ) / 𝑓( ))
Theorem 16. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost starlike function of
order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1) \ {1/2}, 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Theorem 16. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost starlike function of
order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1) \ {1/2}, 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then Furthermore, |𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧)| ≤|𝑎| + 𝜌, so
Re 𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧) =
Re (𝑓(𝑧) /𝑧𝑓(𝑧))
𝑓( )/ 𝑓( )2
> Re 𝑎−𝜌
(| |
)
2 . (69)
Theorem 16. Let 𝑓(𝑧) be a strongly almost starlike function of
order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1) \ {1/2}, 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
𝑓(𝑧)≤[1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|] Re 𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧) =
Re (𝑓(𝑧) /𝑧𝑓(𝑧))
𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
2
> Re 𝑎−𝜌
(|𝑎| + 𝜌)
2 . (69)
order 𝛼on
𝑓(𝑧) Re 𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧) =
Re (𝑓(𝑧) /𝑧𝑓(𝑧))
𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
2
> Re 𝑎−𝜌
(|𝑎| + 𝜌)
2 . (69)
𝑖𝜃
( 𝑓( )/𝑓( ))
(𝜕l |𝑓( )|)/𝜕
order 𝛼on 𝐷and 𝛼∈[0, 1) \ {1/2}, 𝑐∈(0, 1). Then
𝑓(𝑧)≤[1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|]
× [1 + 𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))+((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|) Re 𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
𝑓(𝑧) =
Re (𝑓(𝑧) /𝑧𝑓(𝑧))
𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
2
> Re 𝑎−𝜌
(|𝑎| + 𝜌)
2 . (69)
Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)/𝑓(𝑧)) = 𝑟(𝜕ln |𝑓(𝑧)|)/𝜕𝑟, we
haveh
𝑓(𝑧)≤[1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|]
× [1 + 𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))+((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|)
[1
𝑐|1
2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))−((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|) 𝑓(𝑧)≤[1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|]
× [1 + 𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))+((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|)
⋅[1 −𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))−((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|). (77) (69) Re 𝑓(𝑧) =
𝑓(𝑧)/𝑧𝑓(𝑧)
2
>
(|𝑎| + 𝜌)
2 . (69)
Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. Since Re (𝑧𝑓(𝑧)/𝑓(𝑧)) = 𝑟(𝜕ln |𝑓(𝑧)|)/𝜕𝑟, we
have
𝑓(𝑧)≤[1 + 𝑐2 (1 −2𝛼) |𝑧|2 + 2𝑐(1 −𝛼) |𝑧|]
× [1 + 𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))+((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|)
⋅[1 −𝑐|1 −2𝛼| |𝑧|]((2−3𝛼)/(2𝛼−1))−((1−𝛼)/|1−2𝛼|). Let 𝑧= 𝑟𝑒𝑖𝜃. References From Theorems 7 and 11, we can get the following result. From Theorems 7 and 11, we can get the following result. Journal of Applied Mathematics 8 8 [10] N. I. Mahmudov and M. Eini Keleshteri, “𝑞-extensions for the
apostol type polynomials,” Journal of Applied Mathematics, vol. 2014, Article ID 868167, 8 pages, 2014. [11] E. Merkes and M. Salmassi, “Subclasses of uniformly starlike
functions,” International Journal of Mathematics and Mathemat-
ical Sciences, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 449–454, 1992. [12] S. Singh, “A subordination theorem for spirallike functions,”
International Journal of Mathematics and Mathematical Sci-
ences, vol. 24, no. 7, pp. 433–435, 2000. [13] K. R. Gurganus, “𝜙-like holomorphic functions in C𝑛and
Banach spaces,” Transactions of the American Mathematical
Society, vol. 205, pp. 389–406, 1975. [14] H. Hamada and G. Kohr, “Subordination chains and the growth
theorem of spirallike mappings,” Mathematica, vol. 42(65), no. 2, pp. 153–161 (2001), 2000. [15] S. X. Feng, Some classes of holomorphic mappings in several
complex variables [Ph.D. thesis], University of Science and
Technology of China, Hefei, China, 2004. [16] S. X. Feng, T. S. Liu, and G. B. Ren, “The growth and covering
theorems for several mappings on the unit ball in complex
Banach spaces,” Chinese Annals of Mathematics A, vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 215–230, 2007. [17] R. H. Cai and X. S. Liu, “The third and fourth coefficient estima-
tions for the subclasses of strongly spirallike functions,” Journal
of Zhanjiang Normal College, vol. 31, pp. 38–43, 2010. [18] H. Hamada and G. Kohr, “The growth theorem and quasicon-
formal extension of strongly spirallike mappings of type 𝛼,”
Complex Variables, vol. 44, no. 4, pp. 281–297, 2001. [19] M. Chuaqui, “Applications of subordination chains to starlike
mappings in C𝑛,” Pacific Journal of Mathematics, vol. 168, no. 1,
pp. 33–48, 1995. [20] L. V. Ahlfors, Complex Analysis, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY,
USA, 3rd edition, 1978.
|
https://openalex.org/W4240122979
|
https://scholarship.claremont.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1733&context=aliso
|
English
| null |
Back Matter 7 (4)
|
Aliso
| 1,972
|
cc-by
| 21,897
|
eco
e ded C tat o
eco
e ded C tat o
(1972) "Back Matter 7 (4)," Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany: Vol. 7: Iss. 4, Article 9.
Available at: https://scholarship.claremont.edu/aliso/vol7/iss4/9 Back Matter 7 (4)
Back Matter 7 (4) Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.claremont.edu/aliso Recommended Citation
Recommended Citation Recommended Citation
Recommended Citation
(1972) "Back Matter 7 (4)," Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany: Vol. 7: Iss. 4, Article 9. Available at: https://scholarship.claremont.edu/aliso/vol7/iss4/9 Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany
Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany Volume 7
Issue 4 Article 9 Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany
Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany
Volume 7
Issue 4
Article 9
1972
Back Matter 7 (4)
Back Matter 7 (4)
Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.claremont.edu/aliso
Recommended Citation
Recommended Citation
(1972) "Back Matter 7 (4)," Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany: Vol. 7: Iss. 4, Article 9.
Available at: https://scholarship.claremont.edu/aliso/vol7/iss4/9 Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany
Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany RANcHo SANTA ANA BoTANIC GARDEN
1971 It is a pleasure for me to present an account of the activities at the
botanic garden for the year 1971. Except for the effec's of the weather
which are given elsewhere in this report, the year was one of steady and
sound development. The building program of the previous year had been
completed, and early in 1971 landscaping around the annex was finis3ed
and the grounds once again were quiet and serene, suitable for study and
contemplation by the thousands of persons who visit the garden each year. Among events which undoubtedly will mark this year in the garden's
history are two, especially, which should be mentioned. The botanic garden
is a member of the American Association of Museums and durinJ; the year
we applied for accreditation by that organization. In August we were notified
that we had been granted interim approval until an on-site evalu1tion of
the institution could be made by the AAM Accredit1tion Visitin~ Commit-
tee. This visit is expected early in 1972. The second item of interest is that
the botanic garden for the first time applied for a plant patent to cover a
new hybrid which soon will be released to the horticultural trade. We be-
lieve that this hybrid, a Mahonia, is the finest horticultural production so
far achieved at the garden, and preliminary estim -=ttcs m1.de by nurs ~rym en
who have seen the plant would seem to confirm this evaluation. On the debit side would be the continued effecLs of air pollution. These
were detailed at some length in the previous report and will not be repeated
here except to say that there is no evidence that the situation has improved. For those true gardeners who delight in the appearance of healthy p~ants
the sight of damage by air pollution is very depressing. Recommended Citation
Recommended Citation Recommended Citation
Recommended Citation
(1972) "Back Matter 7 (4)," Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany: Vol. 7: Iss. 4, Article 9. Available at: https://scholarship.claremont.edu/aliso/vol7/iss4/9 ALISO VoL. 7, No. 4, pp. 539-556 JULY 20, 1972 ADMINISTRATION: Two staff appointments were made during the year. D1 . .Jean-Pierre
Simon, Experimental Taxonomist at the botanic garden and Assistant Pro-
fessor of botany at the Claremont Graduate School, resigned in order to
accept a position with UNESCO. In .July he and his family left for Paris
for briefings prior to taking up his new duties in Havan-=t, Cuba. Dr. Ronnie
Scogin of Ohio University, Athens, has been appointed Exp ~rim ental Taxon-
omist at the garden and Assistant Professor of botany in the gradu1te
school. Dr. Scogin is a graduate of the University of Texas, Austin, and in
1970-71 was a National Science Foundation Post Doctoral Fellow at the
University of Durham, England. Dr. Scogin will assume his new duties at
the botanic garden in September, 1972. [539] 40
ALIS 540 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 ALISO In April Mrs. Coffeen resigned as Supervisor of the Youth Education
Program and in September Kenneth Zakar was appointed Supervisor of the
Education Department. Mr. Zakar is a native of Illinois and a graduate of
California State College, Los Angeles, with a major in biology. During the year, the Claremont Graduate School created a new endowed
chair of botany and appointed Dr. Carlquist as the first Violetta L. Horton
Professor of Botany. Dr. Carlquist has been a member of the graduate
school faculty since 1956 and is the author of four books, the latest being
Hawaii, a Natural History published in 1970. After nearly 32 years of devoted service to the botanic garden our grounds
foreman, Jesus Manjarrez, retired on July 1. We will all miss Jesus and wish
him much happiness and good health in his retirement. Mr. Geerlof Stein-
huizen was appointed to a newly created position, Maintenance Mechanic,
and will be responsible for all mechanical equipment both in the buildings
and on the grounds. AMOUNTS OF WATER USED DURING THE PAST FIVE YEARS
R i f Year
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
Water used
(cu. feet)
2,816,800
3,148,900
3,910,500
4,524,700
3,691,000
Rainfall for
Calendar Year
(inches)
22.62
10.00
33.50
20.03
13.09 During 1971 we used 18.5% less water than in 1970; however, the cost was
3.5% more than it was for the previous year. DIRECTOR'S REPORT DIRECTOR'S REPORT JuLY 20, 1972] 541 WEATHER: Rainfall recorded during the 1970-71 season was 14.11 inches. This is 1.22
inches over the 1969-70 season and 3.6 inches below the seasonal average. July
August
September
October
November
December
January
February
March
April
May
June
RAINFALL REPORT
1969-70
1970-71
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.16
1.90
4.26
0.29
4.92
1.61
0.79
1.97
1.19
6.85
1.13
0.06
0.53
0.00
1.13
0.21
0.00
Average"
0.05
0.06
0.40
0.20
3.17
2.25
3.60
3.18
2.83
1.62
0.22
0.12 "Average based on rainfall recorded for the past ten years. ge based on rainfall recorded for the past ten years. The temperature high for the year was reached on September 12 when
the hygrothermograph needle went off the chart to an estim:tted 114° F. The temperature reached 100° F or more on 32 days during the summer
season: one day in June, six days in July, 13 in August, eight in September
and four in October. December was the only month that did not have one
or more days with temperatures over 87°. A low of 28° F was recorded on January 3, 4 and 7. The humidity record shows 1971 with 25 days below 10% as compared
with 44 days in 1970. The lowest humidity of the year was reached on
April 1 when it dropped almost to 0% for a period of about four hours. SEEDS AND PLANTS: The University of Washington, Department of Chemistry, requested leaves
of Olneua tesota for chemical research. Pollen of Platanus racemosa was
sent to the National University of Ausb·alia for hybridization studies. Emory
and Hemy College, Virginia, was supplied with seed of Ephedra viridis
and E. nevadensis for research purposes alon~ with information on the
cultural requirements of such plants. The Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburgh,
Scotland, received seed of Penstemon caesius, Cal!Jptridium umbellatum
and Allium burlewii. Hillier & Sons, Nurserymen & Seedsmen, Winchester,
England, received seed of Castanopsis sempervirens and Lyonothamnus
floribundus, and Momovia Nursery, Azusa, California, received seed of
Berberis amplectens and B. pinnata. The botanic garden attempts to help other institutions to build up their
collections and we send such organizations as much material as possible. The Golden View School in Huntington Beach sent the plans for their new
Environmental Learnin~ Facility which covers two and a quarter acres; in
addition to horticultural advice, the garden was able to send 36 lots of seed
suitable for their purpose. A generous amount of seed was given to the
Pasadena Audubon Society for use in creating a Wild Life Sanctuary at the
Cobb Estate -
property purchased throu~h public subscription. This estate
was officially deeded to the U.S. Forest Service in December. A large amount of seed of Lilium humboldtii var. ocellatum was given
to a member of the North American Lily Society. He, in turn, sent a portion
of the seed to the lily society for its Seed Exchange List. The remainder was
divided into 25 lots of 50 seeds each, and these were sent to lily enthusiasts
in Czechoslovakia, Russia, Japan, Chile and Canada and in 13 states in this
country. It was interesting that this was the first time that Lilium humboldtii
var. ocellatum had appeared on the society's Seed Exchange List. The following plants were sent to the Department of Botany, Pomona
College, to supplement their native plant collection: 10 Romneqa coulteri,
two Cneoridium dumosum, one Ceanothus rigidus, three Umbellularia cali-
fornica, three Tetracoccus dioicus, one Ceanothus 'Sierra Blue,' two Lepto-
dactylon glandulosum, three H elianthemum scoparium ssp. aldersonii, two
C omarostaphylis diversifolia var. planifolia, one H eteromeles arbutifolia
var. macrocarpa, three Lyonothamnus floribundus var. asplenifolius. To
Scripps College went four Fremontodendron 'California Glory,' thTee
Ceanothus 'Santa Ana' and two Ceanothus hybrids RSABG selections. SEEDS AND PLANTS: Requests from our 1971 Seed Exchange List resulted in seed being sent
to 28 foreign countries and numerous institutions within the United States. Altogether 436 packets were dispatched from the garden. Many requests were made for seed that did not appear on the Seed Ex-
change List; these requests usually came from institutions and individuals
requiring seed for research purposes. The University of New Zealand re-
quested seed of Garrya elliptica, G. fremontii, Ephedra trifurca and E. viridis for graduate research on carbon fixation and seed germination. Stan-
ford University requested seed of Onagraceae for germination studies, and
seeds representing 11 genera and 14 species were sent. Seed of Coreopsis
gigantea, C. maritima and C. californica was sent to the University of
Arkansas for a biosystematic study of that genus. One packet of Collinsia
heterophylla seed was sent to the University of Hong Kong. Seed of the
following was sent to the National Center of Forest Research, Nancy,
France: Abies amabilis, A. bracteata, Arbutus menziesii, Arctostaphylos
mewukka, A. pringlei var. drupacea, Calocedrus decurrens, Comarostaphylis
diversifolia var. planifolia, Cupressus forbesii, C. sargentii, C. macnabiana,
Fremontodendron californicum, Rhamnus californica, Rhus ovata, Prunus
emarginata, P. virginiana var. melanocarpa, Sequoia sempervirens and
Pinus sabiniana. Seed of 11 species of Lupinus went to the Commonwealth Scientific In-
dustrial Research Organization (Plant Introduction Center) , Canberra,
Australia. To the Landbouwhogesschool, Wageningen, The Netherlands,
went seed of Franseria chamissonis, Franseria chenopodiifolia, Baeria
chrysostoma ssp. gracilis, B. minor, Chaenactis glabriuscula, C. glabriuscula
var. lanosa, Encelia californica, E. virginensis ssp. actonii. This seed was
required for studies in the relationship between plant parasitic nematodes
within different plant genera. Seed of Quercus kelloggii, Q. chrysolepis and
Acer macrophyllum was sent to the Botanic Garden, Hebrew University,
Jerusalem for their North American plant collection, and the Stanford Re-
search Institute received seed of Salvia columbariae, Baeria chrysostoma
ssp. gracilis, Coreopsis bigelovii for use in studies on the fate of carbon
monoxide in the biosphere. Seed of Eriodictyon trichocalyx went to the
Vrije University, Amsterdam, for experimental purposes and to the Univer- 542 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 ALISO sity of Aarhus, Denmark, seed of Trifolium wormskioldii and Lupinus
arboreus for cytotaxonomic studies. The University of California, Irvine,
Department of Population and Environmental Biology, received seed of
Ceanothus griseus, C. incanus, C. rigidus, C. thyrsiflorus, and C. cordulatus. SEEDS AND PLANTS: Plants were also given to the Catalina Island Company for the newly pro-
posed botanic garden; two Fremontodendron 'California Glory,' six Cneo-
ridium dumosum, six Tetracoccus dioicus, five Comarastaphylis diversifolia
var. planifolia, three Populus trichocarpa, 18 Lyonothamnus floribundus
var. asplenifolius, two Populus fremontii var. arizonica and two Rhamnus
crocea. JULY 20, 1972) JULY 20, 1972) DIRECTOR'S REPORT 543 In August the garden supplied specimens of native material to the Cali-
fornia Board of Landscape Architects for their annual Board Examinations. A member of the staff assisted a representative from the Air Pollution
Research Department, Washington State University, Pullman, in making
tests of isoprene emissions from the foliage of species of genera of Cali-
fornia plants. One hundred and twenty-seven seed accessions were made during the
year. GROUNDS: These rodents were discovered in our plantings of
Ceanothus '.Joyce Coulter' and C. horizontalis on the mesa and in Cupressus
forbesii in the plant communities. Over 83 rats were trapped, and it is not
known how many succumbed to bait, none has been observed during the
past several months. the plant is observed. These rodents were discovered in our plantings of
Ceanothus '.Joyce Coulter' and C. horizontalis on the mesa and in Cupressus
forbesii in the plant communities. Over 83 rats were trapped, and it is not
known how many succumbed to bait, none has been observed during the
past several months. The upper pond was cleaned and some minor repairs were made; the
bed of the stream that flows southward from it was cleaned, for mud had
accumulated over the years and had completely covered the decorative
boulders in the stream. Some alterations were made in the rock garden. To carry out this work
it was necessary to rent a five-ton dump truck and a tractor and skip loader
to move fill and soil into the area. The equipment also was used to transport
many tons of compost into the plant communities where, this year, we
concentrated on the redwood forest, mixed evergreen and yellow pine com-
munities. The compost will help improve the soil and conserve the much-
needed moisture in these areas. During the spring and fall we also applied
light dressings of ammonium sulphate to the soil in the same areas. During the year, 6,300 plants representing over 50 genera were added to
the living collections. Species of Arctostaphylos, Ceanothus and Iris were
well represented. Vandalism, like smog, remains to plague us. Redwood signs continue to
be a prime target with over 35 being damaged; ten had to be remade. Last
spring the large flowering stems of Agave utahensis var. nevadensis were
broken. During Easter vacation a favorite pastime of some seems to be to
run through the plant communities kicking wire cages from around young
plants which are then at the mercy of rabbits. During the summer of 1969 the first .Joshua trees, Yucca brevifolia, bloomed
at the age of 18 years. These were planted as seedlings from six-inch pots
during the winter of 1951. At least four more have bloomed during the past
two summers. The largest at the time of flowering was eight feet tall. GROUNDS: From the standpoint of weather, 1971 was a year that left much to be
desired and a repeat performance would be catastrophic. Dry conditions
prevailed throughout the year and were augmented by periods of extreme
heat or cold; many plants sustained damage from frost and foliar scorch
from excessive heat. The year ended with a grand finale of much-needed
moisture with 6.97 inches of rain being received during the Christmas week,
and 1971 slipped into oblivion leaving no fond memories for those who love
the art of gardening. With the weather conditions that prevailed it was necessary to start irri-
gating in January. Seed beds of annuals required moisture and several areas
in the Plant Communities were showing signs of drought. Our display of
annuals was quite colorful, but short-lived; most of the flowering was over
by the end of May. The finest display was on the newly completed coast1l
bluffs and sand dunes where the high but gently undulatin~ contours
exhibited the plants to great advantage. The damage and losses sustained in some of our conifer plantings during
the hot spell, particularly on September 12, were most discouraging. The
heaviest losses occurred in the plantings of Chamaecyparis lawsoniana,
Thuja plicata, Picea sitchensis and Sequoiadendron giganteum, where the
plants looked as if they had been subjected to a flame thrower. Although
specimens of Sequoia sempervirens and Lithocarpus densiflora received
foliar burns they will recover. Our greatest concern at the present time is
for the damage sustained by the sequoiadendrons in the Plant Community
Area and it is difficult to say whether or not the trees will survive. The cypress bark beetle (Phloeosinus cristatus) which has attacked our
cypress plantings with devastating effect over the past two years has been
brought completely under control by the use of Cygan. The recommended
80% wettable Sevin that we had used was not effective. Careful attention
was paid to timing in the spray program; the first application of one pint
Cygon to 100 gallons water was made on March 17, followed by a second
of like concentration on March 30. The wood rat caused much concern this year. These rodents build their
nests in shrubs and trees and feed on the bark. Although we are always on
the look-out for these animals they often go undetected until die-back of [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 544 ALISO the plant is observed. GROUNDS: The
plants that flowered are now branching with the longest branches being
about 12 inches. This species does not branch until after producing a
terminal inflorescence at which time vegetative growth starts from one or
more of the upper leaf axils. These plants, whether they have flowered or
not, are forming dense clumps from the base, and suckering is occurring
many feet from the base of the original plant. This is a growth habit that
does not normally occur in the wild. Four plants of Yucca brevifolia var. herbertii also have flowered. This
took place during their 12th and 13th years. They were planted from one-
gallon cans during the fall of 1957, and at the time of flowering, these plants
ranged in height from four to five and one-half feet. The branching habit
is becoming evident on those plants that have flowered. This variety forms
large clusters in the wild and ours are showing the same tendency. By
contrast, the Yucca brevifolia var. jaegeriana has never flowered although
some are much older than the ones described above. Some of the plants JULY 20, 1972] 545 DIRECTOR'S REPORT were originally planted in 1947 at the garden's old site in Orange County
and moved to their present location in 1951. One of these is nearly 15 feet
tall with no sign of flowering or branching. In its native habitat this variety
normally branches at three to four feet and does not clump or sucker; so
far it has not shown this tendency under cultivation. Natural regeneration of Pinus radiata was noted for the first time in the
plant communities. This is most encouraging as smog continues to take its
toll of these pines each year; four succumbed during 1971, one of which
was a particularly fine specimen. A plant patent for our new introduction, Mahonia 'Golden Abundance,'
has been applied for and many nurserymen are anxious to see this fine plant
in the trade as soon as possible. Several thousand cuttings were taken from
our stock plants this winter by Monrovia Nursery and Pomona Wholesale
Nurseries. In March a representative of the American Horticultural Society Plant
Record Center microfilmed our master record file. Over 7,000 sheets were
photographed and have since been placed on data processing forms. GROUNDS: Readers
may recall that several years ago the botanic garden was one of the original
donors of funds to the American Association of Botanic Gardens and
Arboretums for a feasibility study of establishing a national plant record
file. The October issue of the AABGA Bulletin was devoted to the history
and activities of the Plant Records Center. Two new cesspools were installed during 1971. In the early part of the
year we had evidence that the disposal system was not operating properly
even after the septic tank had been cleaned. Inspection showed that the
leach lines were no longer functioning and soil in the area had reached
saturation. It was in this area that we had earlier lost a fine specimen of
Lithocarpus densiflora and a large area of the ground cover, Arctostaphylos
'Point Reyes.' During the spring the garden entered a small display of native plant
materials at the Flower Show and Garden Exposition held in the Colonial
Savings and Loan Association building in Claremont. Dick Tilforth spoke
to the public on the history of the Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden and
its many functions. The talk and display were enthusiastically received by
visitors to the show. John Dourley gave a short talk to the El Monte Rose
Society in March and then conducted a tour of the garden. . A new one-ton Ford truck with dump body was purchased and is a most
welcome addition, for its predecessor had become nearly useless. Eighty-six
plastic labels were acquired, some to replace those lost or broken and the
remainder for new plantings. FIELD WORK: Partly because of the new graduate course in field taxonomy, 1971 was a
period of considerable field activity in the local San Gabriel Mountains. [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 546 ALISO Approximately 50 forays were made into this range by Dr. Thorne, usually
with Dick Tilforth, John Dourley and various graduate students or by the
graduate students in connection with their canyon surveys for the field
course or with their individual research projects. Nearly -1,750 collections
were made totalling perhaps 3,500 sheets of about 900 species of the 1,150
known from the range. Two strenuous over-night back-packing trips were
made across the mountains. One two-day trip was made with the field
taxonomy class to Santa Catalina Island, and two collecting trips were taken
into the Sierra Nevada. Approximately 50 forays were made into this range by Dr. Thorne, usually
with Dick Tilforth, John Dourley and various graduate students or by the
graduate students in connection with their canyon surveys for the field
course or with their individual research projects. Nearly -1,750 collections
were made totalling perhaps 3,500 sheets of about 900 species of the 1,150
known from the range. Two strenuous over-night back-packing trips were
made across the mountains. One two-day trip was made with the field
taxonomy class to Santa Catalina Island, and two collecting trips were taken
into the Sierra Nevada. Dr. and Mrs. Thorne spent their vacation in Mexico during the month of
October where in the tropical state of Chiapas Dr. Thorne, with Dr. Earl
Lathrop of Lorna Linda University and Dr. Dennis Breedlove of the Cali-
fornia Academy of Sciences, made more than 1,900 collections, mostly in
multiples, of 160 vascular plant families. All the major physiographic
provinces of Chiapas were visited from Oaxaca to Guatemala and from
the Pacific Coastal Plain to the Gulf Slope. In their search for seeds and plants John Dourley and Dick Tilforth col-
lected in a wide range of areas. In San Bernardino County the Clark and
New York Mountains, Eagle Mountain, the eastern San Gabriels and the
Morongo Valley were visited. The southern and eastern portions of San
Diego County and the Mount Palomar area were also covered. The Sierra
Nevada circle was travelled and included Inyo, Mono, Tuolumne, Mariposa
and Madera counties. Another trip into the Sierra Nevada foothills included
Fresno, Madera and Mariposa counties. Eighty-three collections were made
from these trips. Dr. FIELD WORK: Lenz visited a large number of areas on the western
slopes of the Sierra Nevada in his continuing study of members of the
Brodiaea complex. He also collected in San Luis Obispo County. Dr. Benjamin collected only locally in 1971. SCIENTIFIC COLLECTIONS: The integrated herbaria of Pomona College and the garden continue to
receive much use, particularly from southern California botanists, although
there are frequent visitors from other states and from abroad. Nearly 11,300
newly mounted RSA sheets have been filed into the vascular plant collec-
tions, necessitating the addition of hundreds of new genus or species covers. From the combined herbaria or RSA 2,926 sheets were sent on loan to 19
institutions in 25 shipments; 1,996 sheets in 20 loans were returned to us
from 14 institutions; 4,749 sheets were borrowed by us from 16 herbaria in
19 loans; and 661 sheets were returned by us to eight herbaria. Additional
loans were sent out by Pomona College. During 1971 the graduate assistants
mounted 11,298 sheets of vascular plants, bringing the total RSA collections
to more than 225,000 sheets and the integrated herbaria to perhaps 515,000
sheets of vascular plants. More than 19,000 RSA fungi and other crypto-
gamic specimens and nearly 21,000 POM cryptogams swell the total
herbarium collections to 555,000 specimens. Not included in this total are
the large wood block, pollen slide, preserved seedling, seed and fruit and DIRECTOR'S REPORT JULY 20, 1972] 547 cone and spirit collections. Received on an exchange basis were 4,069 sheets
from 25 institutions; whereas, the garden sent out on exchange 769 sheets
to five herbaria. A large distribution of RSA duplicates is intended for early
1972. More than 4,350 specimens of vascular plants were received by RSA
as gifts, some for determination, from 18 individuals or institutions. Of the 11,298 sheets processed, nearly 2,700 were from California and
1,000 from the immediately adjacent Atomic Test Site in Nevada; 1,300
from other parts of the West; 1,500 from the Southeast; nearly 1,950 from
mainland Mexico; more than 1,500 from Australia and other Pacific and
Indian Ocean islands; about 500 from Chile and tropical America; 500 from
Iran; and 325 from Europe. The acquisition of the processed sheets included
nearly 4,700 from exchanges; 5,800 from gifts; and 800 through recent staff
and student collections. About 75 new isolates were added to the fungus culture collection. Most
of these fungi either were isolated by Gerald Benny, graduate student in
mycology, or were solicited by him from other institutions for use in his
studies. Several of the fungi received were cultures representing type col-
lections and specimens of these have been placed in the mycological
herbarium. SCIENTIFIC COLLECTIONS: Some 50 accessions were made to the Laboulbeniales collection,
all prepared by Dr. Benjamin. Among these was an important series of
specimens representing several species of Aporomyces taken from large
collections of Limnichidae (Coleoptera) kindly provided for study by Drs. T. E. Brooks, Southeast Missouri State College, Cape Girardeau, and M. W. Sanderson, Illinois Natural History Survey, Urbana. As in the past, routine
maintenance of the culture collection required in excess of 1,000 transfers
of isolates to fresh media, mostly carried out by Mr. Benny. LIBRARY: We should call 1971 the library's "Project Year." In May, nearly 1,000
periodical and serial titles were sent to Honnold Library as our part of their
computer print-out science holdings of The Claremont Colleges. This cata-
logue should be available for use early in 1972. By June, the graduate students had completed the reconditioning of the
leather-bound volumes. In July and August, with the help of two students
from the Neighborhood Youth Corps, 250 horticultural books were recata-
logued, thus resulting in a shift of two ranges of books. The same two students also started another long-awaited project. The
nursery-seed catalogues were sorted and alphabetized by country and/ or
state. During the fall, the graduate students alphabetized by company with-
in the country and/ or state and arranged these catalogues into 312 enclosed
boxes. The catalogues are now housed in the herbarium. There was a number of short-term projects including properly stamping
the map collection and adding 100 California geographical quadrangle maps
to the holdings. (VoL. 7, No. 4 (VoL. 7, No. 4 548 ALISO Several on-going projects include weeding the reprint collection and
making subject cards for the card catalogue. The latter project has also lead
into uncatalogued periodical/ serial floras being added to the card catalogue. The major 1971 continuing project, an inventory of the book collection,
was started by the graduate students in September. We are finding many
perplexing problems and with the help of Miss Patience Milrod, a junior at
Pitzer College, we are trying to solve them. Serial/periodical statistics show 434 current titles received; 1,700 single
issues checked in including 21 bound volumes; 12 new titles added; 2 titles
deleted; and 296 volumes sent to the bindery. During the year, 250 volumes
were catalogued, 127 volumes accessioned and 176 new books received. Fifty were deposited in the garden library by Honnold Library, 250
volumes reclassified, 500 volumes assigned subject headings, and 49 boxes
of microfiche were catalogued. Numbers 32-35 of Index Nominum Generi-
corum and numbers 260-263 of the Gray Herbarium Card Index were
received. Dr. Thorne continues to serve as chairman of the Advisory Council and
ex officio member of the Steering Committee for tl1e Flora of North America.
In January, he attended joint meetings of the Editorial and Steering Com- RESEARCH AND PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES: He continues to make many determinations of plants
brought or sent in to the garden for identification, and has reviewed various
grant proposals and manuscripts submitted for publication. mittees of the project at the Missouri Botanical Garden. He has continued
to serve locally as Secretary-Treasurer of The Claremont Colleges Sigma
Xi Club and for the City of Claremont as a member of the Parkways and
Street Trees Commission. He is a member of the Visiting Committee for
the Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University and a Research Associate of
the University of Hawaii Botanical Garden. He has served as external
examiner on several doctorate committees for the Universities of Singapore,
Sydney and Adelaide. He continues to make many determinations of plants
brought or sent in to the garden for identification, and has reviewed various
grant proposals and manuscripts submitted for publication. Dr. Simon returned from Chile at the end of January after a three-month
stay during which he collected and studied several disjunct species groups
found in western North and South America. At the end of March Dr. Simon attended the first meeting on mediterranean ecosystems held at Vali-
divia, Chile. This research was sponsored by the National Science Founda-
tion and is part of the International Biology program (IBP). Dr. Simon continued his serological investigations of the Order Nym-
phaeales and a second paper of the series was published in the 1971 issue of
Aliso. He also continued his studies of disjunct species groups of Prosopis
and Lupinus with the assistance of Colin Wainwright. The extensive plant
collections made in Chile were processed during the early months of 1971. Although his research was somewhat curtailed due to ill health, Dr. Munz
was still able to finish several important projects on which he has been
working for some time. All of his many friends will be pleased to learn that
the manuscript of the Flora of Southern California was completed during
the year and is now being prepared for publication by the University of
California Press. Dr. Munz also completed a manuscript on the Onagraceae
of Santa Catarina, Brazil, and has nearly completed one on the Onagraceae
of Ecuador. Much time was devoted to the identification of two large lots
of plants, one a set made by Mary DeDecker of specimens primarily from
Inyo County and another set made by Delzie Demaree, mostly of plants
from New Mexico. Dr. RESEARCH AND PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES: Dr. Thorne has continued his studies of the San Gabriel Mountains toward
the projected flora of that range. Intensive field activity this past year in
the range by him and fellow staff members and graduate students produced
specimens and extensive distributional data for more than 900 of the prob-
able 1,200 species in the range. Work upon the plant communities of Cali-
fornia and his new classification of the Angiospermae was continued. Two
papers were sent off to editors for publication, one on floristic relationships
between tropical America and Africa to be published by the Smithsonian
Press and another on the Sapindales for the Encyclopaedia Britannica. An-
other on the classification of major distributional disjunctions in the vascular
plants is under preparation for Aliso. Further additions to an annotated
check list being prepared in conjunction with Dr. Earl Lathrop of Lorna
Linda University and Dr. Dennis Breedlove of the California Academy of
Sciences on the vascular plants of the Jitotol Ridge of the Northern Hi~h
lands of Chiapas, resulted from more than 1,000 collections made in October
on the Ridge. So far about 1,000 species of 155 families have been deter-
mined and listed. In May, Dr. Thorne presented several lectures in the East at the Smith-
sonian Institution, the University of Maryland, and Kent State University,
Ohio. In November, he lectured to the botanists at the University of Cali-
fornia, Davis, and to the Friends of the Davis Arboretum also at Davis, and
in December to the Claremont Men's Garden Club at the Rancho Santa
Ana Botanic Garden and to the Southern California Horticultural Institute
in Hollywood. Dr. Thorne continues to serve as chairman of the Advisory Council and
ex officio member of the Steering Committee for tl1e Flora of North America. In January, he attended joint meetings of the Editorial and Steering Com- DIRECTOR'S REPORT JULY 20, 1972] 549 mittees of the project at the Missouri Botanical Garden. He has continued
to serve locally as Secretary-Treasurer of The Claremont Colleges Sigma
Xi Club and for the City of Claremont as a member of the Parkways and
Street Trees Commission. He is a member of the Visiting Committee for
the Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University and a Research Associate of
the University of Hawaii Botanical Garden. He has served as external
examiner on several doctorate committees for the Universities of Singapore,
Sydney and Adelaide. RESEARCH AND PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES: Lenz continued his investigations of the members of the Brodiaea
complex and at present is devoting most of his time to the yellow-flowered
species of the section Calliprora of Triteleia. Cytologically the members of
the group are very complex. Artificially produced intra- and interspecific
hybrids are contributing much information toward an understanding of the
evolution of the taxa within the section. Because of the cytological com-
plexity of the group an unusual amount of field work has been required in
his study. At present only two taxa remain to be studied in the field. Dr. Lenz continues to serve as Chairman of the Graduate Program in
Botany of the Claremont Graduate School and as the botany representative
to the Graduate Council. During the fall semester he served as Chairman
of the Academic Procedures Committee and was appoin.ted by President 50
ALISO 550 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 ALISO Keeney to serve on the Medical School Study Committee. He is also a
member of the Life Sciences Field Committee. '
During 1971, Dr. Carlquist prepared and completed the manuscript for
a book to be entitled Island Biology. This book, written in scientific style,
covers top}cs concerning island plants and animals and will be published by
Columbia University Press. Continuing studies of wood anatomy, Dr. Carl-
quist received a two-year grant from the National Science Foundation for
the purpose of preparing a more modem and comprehensive concept of
evolution in woods. David Wheat is working on this project. In April, Dr. Carlquist presented a series of lectures as the George Lamb
Lecturer in Botany at the University of Nebraska. He also presented lectures
at Colorado State University and Utah State University. Dr.' Benson's research during the year emphasized the Cactaceae. Two
extensive trips to Arizona, Utah and Nevada were devoted to field study of
natural populations, collection of specimens and securing black-on-white
and some colored photographs for illustration of The Cacti of the United
States and Canada. The many maps, line drawings, black-on-white photo-
graphs and colored photographs were finished and assembled into 569 plates. This work was completed during 1971; the text was completed earlier. Preparation of the third edition of The Trees and Shrubs of the South-
western Deserts is now ·the major research project. Dr. Benjamin continued his studies of Laboulbeniales and he completed
_a chapter on these fungi to be published in Vol. RESEARCH AND PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES: IV of The Fungi, a treatise
being published by the· Academic Press, New York & London. His Intra-
auction and Supplement to a reprint edition of Thaxter's classic monograph
on the Laboulbeniaceae was published early in the year by J. Cramer,
Lehre, Germany. Current projects involve completion of studies on the
Laboulbeniales infesting semiaquatic Hemiptera, a revision of the genus
-Aporomyces, ahd the description of a new genus from New Guinea. Dr. Benjamin continued as Editor-in-Chief of the journal Mycologia for
the Mycological Society of America. He also served on the Board of Editors
of the society's M ycologia Memoirs and retained his appointment on the
Advisory Committee on Fungi of the American Type Culture Collection. In Nbvember, he lectured on the Laboulbeniales f0r students of the Depart-
ment of Biology at California State College, Fulle1ion. JULY 20, 1972] JULY 20, 1972] Students continuing their studies are Gerald Benny, Christopher Davidson,
Gary Cromwell, Arthur Gibson, Colin Wainwright, and Gary Wallace who
returned to graduate studies after duty in Vietnam. Professor Homer Metcalf
continued work on his Ph.D. thesis but was not in residence during the year. Dr. Simon resigned in July to accept a position with UNESCO and Dr. Ronnie Scogin of Ohio University, Athens, was appointed to replace him. Dr. Scogin's appointment is a joint undertaking of the Claremont Graduate
School and the Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden, the first such arrange-
ment and it represents a strengthening of the ties between the two institu-
tions. During the 1971-72 academic year the botany faculty will be augmented
by having a distinguished visiting professor, Dr. Rajah de Fonseka of the
University of Ceylon, Peradeniya. Dr. Fonseka, who holds a NSF Senior
Foreign Scientist Fellowship, will present lectures and an organized class
in bryophytes and lichens. GRADUATE INSTRUCTION: Two students received the Ph.D. during - the year. They were Dr. Theodore Mortenson, presently assistant professor at . Chapman . College,
Orange, and Dr. Ruth Wilson, assistant professor at the California State
College, San Bernardino. Among the students registering .for the first time
were Larry DeBuhr from Iowa State University, Ames; Loucile Housely, a
graduate of Pomona College; Robin Collins from .Principia College, Alton,
Illinois; and Donald Bissing from the University of Maryland, College Park. DIRECTOR'S REPORT 551 EDUCATION DEPARTMENT: The third annual nature interpretation class· was conducted during
January and February and 15 new volunteers were added to our group. The new nature interpreters are Eloise Baker, Kathy Calagna, Ann Comito,
Barbara Crow, Carol Everett, Gloria Ingels, Judith Kettenhofen, June Lom-
bard, Judith Mercer, Maureen Mcintosh, George Palmer, Mary Sandoe,
Frank Scott, Marion Wilson and Cara Wingert. In early October, letters were sent to 15 neighboring school districts
advising them of our youth education program and enco~raging them to
use the garden as a teaching tool in their science curriculum. 'The response
has been good with many teachers scheduling tours in the Fall of 1971 and
Spring of 1972. The number of students visiting the garden during 1971
was lower than in 1970. This seems to be due to budget limitations in local
school districts which makes it difficult, if not impossible, for many teachers
to arrange transportation. - Early in October, letters were sent to 26 high schools in Los Angeles,
San Bernardino and Riversid~ counties. The purpose of these letters was to
inform these schools of the education department's wjllingness to assist life
science teachers · in using the garden as a part of their biology programs. At this tim£:: only ·one _§chool,~ Claremont High Scliool, has responded. Mr. Jim Troutner, of Claremont High School, is presently using -the plant
communities section of the garden to study plot ecology. Explaining the lack o£ response from 25 of the 26 high schools contacted
is difficult. It is hard to envision 25 high schc;lol s cienc_e depai:tments. so
satisfied with their existing programs that they would not even inquire about
our offer and its possibility of adding to or improving their curriculum. This l)nresponsiverie~s is more puzzling in view of tire good response from
elementary schoo!s conta.cted in the-same areas. 552
ALIS 552 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 ALISO The after-school Audubon junior program resumed its activities in
November. The response to the program by youngsters in the Claremont
area was much greater than anticipated, with many more requests for
membership than existing facilities could accommodate. The program was
staffed by Sally Vogel, Molly Cornell, Mary Sandoe, Harriett Johnson and
Ken Zakar. Assisting these group leaders were: Erika Wodinsky, Beth Platt,
Laurie Coman, Barbara Preston, Wendy Price and Patty Baskin. At the end of this year the education department had 24 active volunteer
nature interpreters. EDUCATION DEPARTMENT: A training session for new interpreters is scheduled to
begin the first week of January, 1972, which will add approximately ten
new members to the volunteer group. SUMMARY OF EDUCATION PROGRAM Number of students and adults participating in organized programs during 1971: Winter
Spring
Fall
Total
Schools: Elementary
748
1,838
446
3,032
Junior and Senior High
131
89
60
280
College and Adult
166
20
0
186
Youth groups:
241
441
75
757
Afternoon Junior Audubon:
3rd grade
0
0
12
12
4th grade
0
0
12
12
5th grade
0
0
12
12
6th grade
0
0
12
12
Junior High
25
25
10
60
Nature Interpreters Service
( hours leading tours ) :
165
297
78
540
PUBLIC SERVICE: ( hours leading tours ) : PUBLIC SERVICE: The garden staff continues to answer many questions of horticultural
nature, either by correspondence, telephone or direct contact. This service
is possibly used more by landscape architects and landscape contractors
than by laymen. This can, no doubt, be attributed to the fact that there is
much more native plant material used today than ever before as the public
becomes more acutely aware of the importance of the environment. More
land has become available for wild life preserves, bird sanctuaries and nature
study centers, or, as in the more affluent communities, for environmental
learning facilities. Within such projects landscape architects encounter
many problems when dealing with native plant material and seek advice
on cultural requirements of various native plants, the advisability of install-
ing irrigation systems and, most often, where these plants can be obtained. We try to be as helpful as possible. The University of California invited Dick Tilforth and John Dourley to
serve on its Advisory Committee on Horticultural Supervision and Man-
agement. The newly formed Claremont Men's Garden Club was granted pennission. to hold monthly meetings in the auditorium of the botanic garden. l DIRECTOR'S REPORT 553 JULY 20, 1972] PUBLISHED WRITINGS OF THE BOTANIC GARDEN STAFF Benjamin, Richard K. 1971. Introduction and supplement to Roland Thaxter's contribu-
tion towards a monograph of the Laboulbeniaceae. J. Cramer, Lehre. 155 p. Carlquist, Sherwin. 1971. Wood anatomy of Macaronesian and other Brassicaceae. Aliso
7: 365-384. LeHz, Lee W. 1971. Experimental evidence for hybrid origin of Dichelostemma venustum
( Liliaceae). Aliso 7: 309-312. -----. 1971. Two new species of Dandya (Liliaceae) from Mexico and a re
tion of Bessera and Behria. Aliso 7: 313-320. -----. 1971. Chromosome numbers in the genus Milla Cav. ( Liliaceae). Aliso 7:
321-324. -----. 1971. The Director's Report. Aliso 7: 385-400. Simon, J. P. 1971. Comparative serology of the Order Nymphaeales II. Relationships of
Nymphaeaceae and Nelumbonaceae. Aliso 7: 325-350. Thorne, R. F. 1971. Summary statement on North Temperate floristics. BioScience 21:
533. PUBLICATIONS: The third number of Volume 7 of Aliso, edited by Dr. Benjamin, was
published on April 22. The issue consisted of 92 pages and included eight
scientific papers and the Director's Report. GIFTS AND GRANTS: American Type Culture Collection, Rockville, Maryland, one fungus culture. Atwood, N. Duane, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah, 11 herbarium specimens,
including nine types. Balazuc, Dr. J., Eaubonne, France, collections of insects bearing Laboulbeniales, mostly
European. Beatley, Dr. Janice C., Curator, Nevada Test Site Herbarium, 330 herbarium specimens. Beauchamp, R. M., San Diego State College, 624 herbarium specimens. Beatley, Dr. Janice C., Curator, Nevada Test Site Herbarium, 330 herbarium specimens. B
h
R
M
S
Di
S
C ll
624 h
b
i
i Beauchamp, R. M., San Diego State College, 624 herbarium specimens. Benjamin, R. K., Claremont, books. Bodger Seed Company, Chino, six lots of seed. Brigham, Dr. Warren, Route 1, Box 84, Sullivan, Illinois, two collections of insects bear-
ing Laboulbeniales. Brooks, Dr. Travis E., Southeast Missouri State College, Cape Girardeau, collection of
insects of the family Limnichidae (Coleoptera) bearing Laboulbeniales. California Department of Agriculture, Sacramento, book (deposit). California State College, Los Angeles Library, books. Carlquist, Dr. Sherwin, Claremont, books, periodicals and herbarium specimens Chien, Dr. Chiu-yuan, National Taiwan Norman University, Taipei, three fungu
tures. Davidson, Christopher and G. L. Benny, Claremont, 12 herbarium specimens. DeDecker, Mrs. Paul, Independence, 137 herbarium specimens. Damaree, Dr. Delzie, Hot Springs, Arkansas, 123 herbarium specimens. Deutsche Akademie der Naturforschen Leopoldina, periodicals. Dourley, John, Claremont, 60 herbarium specimens. Ebert, Babett, Hemet, cash donation. Ellis, Dr. J. J., Northern Regional Research Laboratory, Peoria, Illinois, 12 fungus cul-
tures. [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 554 ALISO Everett, P. C., Claremont, periodicals. Faure!, Dr. L., Pasteur Inst., Paris, two fungus cultures. Ferguson, Mr. and Mrs., periodicals. de Fonseka, Dr. R. N., Claremont, books. Foote, Stanley S., Alhambra, cash donation. Gauger, Dr. Wendell, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, five fungus culture Gibson, Arthur C., Claremont, 187 cacti and other herbarium specimens. Hall, B. Brower, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, cash donation. Hannibal, L. S., Fair Oaks, books and periodicals. Hayes, Byron J ., cash donation. Hesseltine, Dr. C. W., Northern Regional Research Laboratory, Peoria, Illin
fungus culture. Honnold Library, Claremont, books. Kimbrough, Dr. J. W., University of Florida, Gainesville, two fungus cultures. Lathrop, Dr. E. W., Lorna Linda University, Lorna Linda, 369 herbarium sp Lathrop, Dr. E. W., Lorna Linda University, Lorna Linda, 369 herbarium specimens. La Verne College Library, La Verne, periodicals. p,
,
y,
,
p
La Verne College Library, La Verne, periodicals. La Verne College Library, La Verne, periodicals. ALISO 556
ALISO
[VoL. 7, No. 4
RANCHO SANTA ANA BOTANIC GARDEN
FouNDER
Susanna Bixby Bryant
TRUSTEES
Ernest A. Bryant IIL __________ ____ ________ ____ ____ ___ _____ ___ ________ ____________ ____ __ _________ __ Chairman
Stuart O'Melveny --------------------- ------------- ----------- -- ---------------------------------------Secretary
Ernest A. Bryant, Jr. Oscar T. Lawler
James D. Macneil
STAFF
Lee W. Lenz, Ph.D. ____________ ____ ____________ ____________________ __ ______ Cytologist and Director
Beatrice M. Beck, M.S.L.S. ________ ___ __ ____________ __ _________________________________________ Librarian
Donald Bissing, B.A, _________________________________________________ ____ _____ __ ____ Research Assistant
Richard K. Benjamin, Ph.D. _________________________ __ ___________ ____ __ Mycologist and Editor
Gerald Benny, M.S, ________________________ __ _______________________ __ _______________ Research Assistant
Lyman Benson, Ph.D. _______________________ _____ ______________________ ____________ Research Associate
Betty Brunstad ________ ________________________________________ _________________ _______________ ____________ Secretary
Sherwin Carlquist, Ph.D. ________________________________________________________ Research Associate
Gary Cromwell, M.A. _____ _______________________________ __ ___________ _____________ Research Assistant
Larry DeBuhr, B.A .. ____________________________ _______ ______________________________ Research Assistant
John Dourley _______________ _____ ______ ___ ______________ ____ ______ __________ _________ __________ __ Superintendent
Percy C. Everett.. ______ ____ __ ______________________________________________ Superintendent Emeritus
Arthur Gibson, B.A .. _______________________________________________________ ___ _______ Research Assistant
Philip A. Munz, Ph.D., Sc.D. ________________________________ __ ________________ Director Emeritus
Ronnie Scogin, Ph.D. __________________________________________________ Experimental Taxonomist
Jean-Pierre Simon, Ph.D." ______ ______________________ ___________ ___ Experimental Taxonomist
Wan·en Sullivan ______ ______ ____________________________________ ___ ____________________ _____________ Nurseryman
Robert F. Thorne, Ph.D. _______________ _Taxonomist and Curator of the Herbarium
C. W. Tilforth _____________ ______ ______ ______________ ___ ____________ ______________________ _____ ___ Horticulturist
Colin M. Wainwright, B.A .. ___________________________________________________ Research Assistant
Gary Wallace, B.A. _____________________ __ ___________________________________________ Research Assistant
Patricia Wilder, M.A .. _________________________________________ Associate Herbarium Botanist
Kenneth Zakar, B.S. ____________________________________________ Supervisor, Education Program
"Resigned July, 1971 GIFTS AND GRANTS: Leech, Hugh B., California Academy of Sciences, Golden Gate Park, San Francisco,
several collections of insects bearing Laboulbeniales. Lenz, Dr. Lee W., Claremont, books and periodicals. Mehrotra, Dr. B. S., University of Allahabad, India, one fungus culture. Munz, Dr. P. A., Claremont, books and periodicals. Muth, Gilbert, University of California, Davis, 69 herbarium specimens. National Arboretum, Washington, D.C., six Arbutus texana plants. Orr, Dr. G. F., Dugway, Utah, 24 fungus cultures. Rogerson, Dr. C. T., New York Botanical Garden, Bronx, N.Y., eight fungus cultures. Rogerson, Dr. C. T., New York Botanical Garden, Bronx, N.Y., eight fungus cultures. Sanderson, Dr. M. W., Illinois Natural History Survey, Urbana, collection of insects Rogerson, Dr. C. T., New York Botanical Garden, Bronx, N.Y., eight fungus cultures. Sanderson, Dr. M. W., Illinois Natural History Survey, Urbana, collection of insects
bearing Laboulbeniales. Sanderson, Dr. M. W., Illinois Natural History Survey, Urbana, collection of
bearing Laboulbeniales. Simon, Dr. J. P., Claremont, 900 herbarium specimens and vouchers of Chil Solbrig, 0. T., Cambridge, Massachusetts, seed samples of Prosopis species. Stern, Professor W. L., University of Maryland, College Park, 161 herbarium specimens. Stevens, Trow, Claremont, two plants. ,
,
y
y
,
g
,
p
Stevens, Trow, Claremont, two plants. Stevens, Trow, Claremont, two plants. Takhtajan, Professor Armen, Komarov Institute, Leningrad, USSR, six herbarium speci-
mens. -
- Thomas, Dr. John H., Curator, Dudley Herbarium, Stanford University, 575 herbarium
specimens. Thomas, Dr. John H., Curator, Herbarium of the California Academy of Sciences, San
Francisco, 59 herbarium specimens. Thorne, Professor R. F., Claremont, 1,000 herbarium specimens and journals. Tilforth, C. W., Claremont, 75 herbarium specimens and book. Twisselmann, Ernest, Cholame, 300 herbarium specimens. University of California, Los Angeles, Bio-medical Library, book. Union Oil Company, Brea, cash donation. Wallace, Gary, Claremont, four plants. Wilson, Mrs. Howard S., Fullerton, cash donation. LEE w. LENZ LEE w. LENZ LEE w. LENZ [VoL. 7, No. 4 556 ALISO VoL. 7, No. 4, pp. 557-568
JuLY 20, 1972 JuLY 20, 1972 VoL. 7, No. 4, pp. 557-568 TRUSTEES Ernest A. Bryant IIL
Stuart O'Melveny ------ Ernest A. Bryant IIL
Stuart O'Melveny ------ Lee W. Lenz, Ph.D. ____________ ____ ____________ ____________________ __ ______ Cytologist and Director
Beatrice M. Beck, M.S.L.S. ________ ___ __ ____________ __ _________________________________________ Librarian
Donald Bissing, B.A, _________________________________________________ ____ _____ __ ____ Research Assistant
Richard K. Benjamin, Ph.D. _________________________ __ ___________ ____ __ Mycologist and Editor
Gerald Benny, M.S, ________________________ __ _______________________ __ _______________ Research Assistant
Lyman Benson, Ph.D. _______________________ _____ ______________________ ____________ Research Associate
Betty Brunstad ________ ________________________________________ _________________ _______________ ____________ Secretary
Sherwin Carlquist, Ph.D. ________________________________________________________ Research Associate
Gary Cromwell, M.A. _____ _______________________________ __ ___________ _____________ Research Assistant
Larry DeBuhr, B.A .. ____________________________ _______ ______________________________ Research Assistant
John Dourley _______________ _____ ______ ___ ______________ ____ ______ __________ _________ __________ __ Superintendent
Percy C. Everett.. ______ ____ __ ______________________________________________ Superintendent Emeritus
Arthur Gibson, B.A .. _______________________________________________________ ___ _______ Research Assistant
Philip A. Munz, Ph.D., Sc.D. ________________________________ __ ________________ Director Emeritus
Ronnie Scogin, Ph.D. __________________________________________________ Experimental Taxonomist
Jean-Pierre Simon, Ph.D." ______ ______________________ ___________ ___ Experimental Taxonomist
Wan·en Sullivan ______ ______ ____________________________________ ___ ____________________ _____________ Nurseryman
Robert F. Thorne, Ph.D. _______________ _Taxonomist and Curator of the Herbarium
C. W. Tilforth _____________ ______ ______ ______________ ___ ____________ ______________________ _____ ___ Horticulturist
Colin M. Wainwright, B.A .. ___________________________________________________ Research Assistant
Gary Wallace, B.A. _____________________ __ ___________________________________________ Research Assistant
Patricia Wilder, M.A .. _________________________________________ Associate Herbarium Botanist
Kenneth Zakar, B.S. ____________________________________________ Supervisor, Education Program
"Resigned July, 1971 ALISO INDEX TO VOLUME 7, ALISO., Abronia 201, 203, 204, 205, 421--437
alpina 201, 203, 204, 205, 423, 424,
432, 433, 435
bigelovu 431
crux-maltae 422, 423, 425, 429, 430,
433. 4:15
exalata 431
latifolia 421, 423, 425-428, 435
maritima 201, 421--423, 425, 427-429, 435
micrantba 422
nan a 431
ssp. covillei 201, 423, 425, 431--433, 435
ssp. nan a 431, 433
pogonantba 423, 426, 430, 433, 435
salsa 425
turbinata 201, 423, 425, 430--433, 435
umbellata 9, 81, 201, 421--423, 425, 426,
428, 435
villosa 201, 337, 423, 425, 428--430, 435
var. aurita 422
var. villosa 422
Acacia 487, 491, 499, 509, 519, 523
greggii 337
Acaena califomica 337
Acallomyces 168, 179, 180
bomalotae 167
Achillea borealis 5
Aclei<anthes 421
Acnida tamariscina 65
Acompsomyces 179, 180
Acrogynomyces 181
Actinocheita 487
Actinostrobus 26
Adenostoma fasciculatum 9, 153, 337
Adrenopsis velutina 18
Aeonium 43
Agava"Pae 250, 251, 258, 259, 335, 336,
340, 346-348
Agave 250. 252. 347, 348, 496, 509, 521,
527, 529, 531
deserti 251, 255, 340
shawii 251, 252, 257, 340, 343
utah en sis 251, 340
Agrostis longiligula 2, 7
Aizoaceae 4 79
Alisma 258
subcordatum 258, 337
triviale 258, 337
Alismales 244, 250, 335, 337
Alismataceae 251, 258, 259, 340
Allenrolfea 425
occidentalis 2, 6
AIHonia 421
Allium 82, 323
campanulatum 258, 337
davisiae 66
peninsulare 77, 79, 82
p raecox 77, 79, 80
unifo'ium 258, 337
Alopecurus howeJ]ji 88, 151, 154
Alyssum alyssoides 66
minus var. micranthum 66
0 1ncludes authors, titles, and other subject matt
the scientific papers
New taxa and the pages wh Amaranthaceae 65
Amaranthus californicus 337
retroRexus 1
tama r i ~ cinus 65
Amaryllidaceae 258
Amblyopappus p nsillus 81
Ambrosia 509, 531
Ambrosieae, tribe of Asteraceae 369
Ammannia coccinea 90
Amorphomyces floridanus 169
obliqueseptatus 169
Amphidiploid of garden origin 157
Amsinckia hispida 152
menziesii 152
tessallata 233
AnagaiJis minima 88, 92, 151, 152
Anarthria 54
Anatomy
Brassicac<'ae 365
Echium 183
Fouquieriaceae 97
Pilostyles thurberi 263
Andersonia, subgenus of Stylidium 20
Andraenidae 534
Anemopsis califomica 90, 154
Ani1lus coecus 171
Annona cherimola 251, 255, 338, 343
Annonaceae 250, 251, 259, 338, 345
Annonales 245, 254, 345, 346, 349
Annoniflorae, superorder of Dicotyledonea
Antbemideae. 0 1ncludes authors, titles, and other subject matter as well as all plant and animal taxa appearin q; in
the scientific papers. New taxa and the pages where puhlished are in italic typ e. An attempt has been
made to correct scientific names misspelled in the text. INDEX TO VOLUME 7, ALISO., tribe of Asteraceae 369
Anthicidae 166-168, 171, 172, 174
Anthicus floralis 168
Anthocoridae 180
Anthophora 236-238
linsleyi 231, 236, 237, 241
Antirrhinum nuttalliam1m 81
Aphanisn•a blitoides 80
Ap'dae 231, 534
Apis me\Ufera 236, 237, 241
Apodantbeae, tribe of Raffiesiaceae 263
Apodanthes 263
Aquatic ferns 149
Aquilegia pubescens 251, 339
Aradoidea. superfamily of Hemiptera 165
Arceutbobium 275
pusillum 267
Arctostaphylos catalinae 75, 78
subcordata 75
Arctotideae, tribe of Asteraceae 369
Argemone munita 251, 252, 255. 339
Aristolochia elegans 253, 258, 337
grandiflora 258, 337
Artemisia 418
arbuscula ssp. nova 66
caHfomica 7 4
pycnocephala 9
suksdorfii 9 ,
Ambrosieae, tribe of Asteraceae 369 AnagaiJis minima 88, 92, 151, 152 var. villosa 422 q
Pilostyles thurberi 263 Acacia 487, 491, 499, 509, 519, 523 y
Andersonia, subgenus of Stylidium 20 ,
g
Andraenidae 534 Anemopsis califomica 90, 15 Acallomyces 168, 179, 180 p
Ani1lus coecus 171 y
bomalotae 167 Achillea borealis 5 Achillea borealis 5 Aclei<anthes 421 Acnida tamariscina 65 ,
,
,
,
Annoniflorae, superorder of Dicotyledoneae 254 Annoniflorae, superorder of Dicotyledoneae 254 Acompsomyces 179, 180 p
y
Antbemideae. tribe of Asteraceae 369 p
y
,
Acrogynomyces 181 Anthicidae 166-168, Anthicidae 166-168, 171, 172, 174 Actinocheita 487 Anthicus floralis 168 Actinostrobus 26 Adenostoma fasciculatum 9, 153, 337
18 Anthocoridae 180 Anthophora 236-238 Adrenopsis velutina 18
43 p
linsleyi 231, 236, 237, 241 p
Aeonium 43
25 Agava"Pae 250, 251, 258, 259, 335, 336,
340
346 348 Agava"Pae 250, 251, 258, 259, 335, 336,
340, 346-348 y
Antirrhinum nuttalliam1m 81 Aphanisn•a blitoides 80 340, 346 348
Agave 250. 252. 347, 348, 496, 509, 521,
527
529
531 p
Ap'dae 231, 534 p
,
Apis me\Ufera 236, 237, 241 p
,
,
Apodantbeae, tribe of Raffiesiaceae 263 ,
,
shawii 251, 252, 257, 340, 343 q
Aquilegia pubescens 251, 339 q
Aquilegia pubescens 251, 339 g
g
Aizoaceae 4 79 q
g
p
Aradoidea. superfamily of Hemiptera 165 Aradoidea. superfamily of Hemiptera 165
5 Aradoidea. superfamily of H
2 5 Arceutbobium 275 p
Arctostaphylos catalinae 75, 78 Arctotideae, tribe of Asteraceae 369
251
252
255
339 Argemone munita 251, 252, 255. ALISO VoL. 7, No. 4, pp. 557-568 INDEX TO VOLUME 7, ALISO., Reveal A new
species of Lathyrus ( Fabaceae) from the
Death Valley region of California and
Nevada 361
Bdallophyton 263
Beaufortia 40
Bees 18, 231, 534
Behria 313, 314
tenuiRora 318, 319
Belamcanda 401-403, 405-407
chinensis 402, 405
flabellata 405
sinensis 405
Benjamin, Richard K. Laboulbeniales on
semiaquatic Hemiptera. II. Autophagomyces,
Dioicomyces, and Prolixandromyces gen. nov. 165
Berberidaceae 244, 254, 255, 258, 259,
335, 336, 339
Berberidales 245
Berberis amplectens 258, 339
bealei 258, 339
piperiana 258, 339
Bergerocactus 80
emoryi 80
Bergia texana 90
Bcssera 313, 314
elegans 313, 318, 319
ten uiflora 314
Blennosperma chilense 152
nanum 152
ssp. nanum 88, 92
Bloomeria 313
purpusii 313
Boerhaavia 421
Boisduvalia densiflora 9 var. phoxus 75 g
coronaria var. kernensis 94 Aridi, subsection of section Inflati of
Astragalus 161, 162 Aridi, subsection of section Inflati of
Astragalus 161, 162 Baer;a chrysostoma 4, 6, 7, 130
uliginosa 5 Baer;a chrysostoma 4, 6, 7, 130
uliginosa 5 g
Baileya pleniradiata 9 y
p
FaldpiJia ranunculoides 258, 337 p
Barclaya 243, 245 p
Barclaya 243, 245 Bronnia, section of Fouquieria 480 ,
q
Bronnia, subgenus of Fouquieria 449, 454, y
Barclayaceae 243-245 Bronnia, subgenus of Fouqu
478, 479, 480, 482, 535 ,
g
q
478, 479, 480, 482, 535 y
Bameby, Rupert C. A new Astragalus from
Nye County, Nevada 161
-------, and James L. Reveal A new
species of Lathyrus ( Fabaceae) from the
Death Valley region of California and
Nevada 361 ,
,
,
,
Bronnia di~11Ptii 4~4, 497 Bronnia di~11Ptii 4~4, 497
spinosa 478, 480, 491, 516, 525, 528, 535
thiebauti 494 Brugmansia 270, 279 g
Brunella vulgaris 5 g
Buckwheat 217 Bdallophyton 263 Bugs, semiaquatic 165 p y
Beaufortia 40 g ,
q
Bumblebees 239, 506, 518, 527 9,
,
,
Bursera 485, 487, 491, 496, 499, 527, 529 ,
tenuiRora 318, 319 Burseraceae 263
5 Burseraceae 263
Butomaceae 251, 259, 340
Butomus 250
umbellatus 251, 340
Cabomba 245, 246, 344, 345
caroliniana 251, 253
Cabombaceae 243-245, 251, 344
Cnbomboideae, subfamily of Nymphaeacea
243, 245
Cactaceae 137, 479
Caesalpinia 491
Calandrinia ciliata 152, 337
var. menziesii 79, 80, 88
maritima 80
California buckwheats 217
Calliandra 268
Callitriche heterophylla var. bolanderi
92, 93, 154
longipedunculata 81
marginata 74, 75, 79-81, 88
var. longipedunculata 88, 90, 92,
151, 154
var. INDEX TO VOLUME 7, ALISO., longipedunculata 88, 90, 92,
151, 154
var. marginata 92, 151
Callitris 48
Calochortus albus 154
l
d
75 (VoL. 7, No. 4 ALISO 558 Bombus 238-240, 506, 518, 527
crotchii 237, 238, 240
edwardsii 237, 238
vosnesenskii 237, 238
Bora~inaceae 192, 373, 375
Wood anatomy of Echium 183
Roronla 36
Bouteloua 509
Bowlesia incana 81
Boykin.ia elata 337
Brahea 529
Brasenia 245. 344. 345
schreberi 251, 256, 344
Brassica nigra 366
Brassicaceae 66, 183, 365-384
'V nod anntomy of Macaronesian and other
Brassicaceae 365
Brassiceae, tribe of Brassicaceae 366
Brecht, Patrick E., see Capon and Brecht 207
Brevoortia 309
ida-maia 309
venusta 309
Briznla 26
Brodiaea 94, 130, 157, 313, 314
congesta 309
coronaria var. kernensis 94
elp~ans 258, 337
filifolia 79, 90
ida-maia 309
kinkiensis 79, 80
laxa 157
orcuttii 90
peduncularis 157
purpusii 313
terrestris 94
tubergenii 157
Xtubergenii 157
venusta 309
Bromus 79, 80
carinatus 77
. margina tus 77
mollis 90 Aristolochiineae, suborder of An non ales
258, 345 258, 345
Asarum caudatum 258. 337 258, 345
Asarum caudatum 258. 337 Asimina triloba 251, 255, 338 Asimina triloba 251, 255, 338 ,
Aspidotis califomica 74 p
Asteraceae 14, 19, 65, 183, 196, 365, p
Asteraceae 14, 19, 65, 183, 196, 365,
367-370, 373, 375, 382, 413 36
3 0, 3 3, 3 5, 38 ,
3
Astragalus 161, 268
antiselli 75
beatleyae 161, 162
geyeri 161, 162
J;ilmanii 161, 162
leu cops is 7 5
miguelensis 81
nevinii 81
sabulonum 161, 162
serpens 162
trichopodus 75
ssp. antisellii 75
ssp. lettcopsis 75
ssp. trichopodus 75
var. lonchus 75
var. phoxus 75 ,
Brecht, Patrick E., see Capon and B ssp. antisellii 75
ssp. lettcopsis 75
ssp. trichopodus 75
var. lonchus 75
var. phoxus 75
Atriplex 130, 358, 523
hymenelytra 7
watsonii 81
Aridi, subsection of section Inflati of
Astragalus 161, 162
Autophagomyces 165-168, 179, 181
mesoveliae 165, 167, 169
microveliae 166, 167, 181
nigripes 166
peyerimhoffii 166
platensis 166
poissonii 167, 169, 181
sarawakensis 166
Avena 79, 80
Azolla filiculoides 90, 152
Baer;a chrysostoma 4, 6, 7, 130
uliginosa 5
Baileya pleniradiata 9
FaldpiJia ranunculoides 258, 337
Barclaya 243, 245
Barclayaceae 243-245
Bameby, Rupert C. A new Astragalus from
Nye County, Nevada 161
-------, and James L. INDEX TO VOLUME 7, ALISO., 339 Aristolochia elegans 253, 258, 337 Aristolochia elegans 25
grandiflora 258, 337 g
grandiflora 258, 337 Allium 82, 323
campanulatum 258, 337
davisiae 66
peninsulare 77, 79, 82
p raecox 77, 79, 80
unifo'ium 258, 337 Arthrolips 166 ,
Alopecurus howeJ]ji 88, 151, 154
66 Alopecurus howeJ]ji 88, 151
l
l
id
66 p
Arthrorhynch us 179, 180
i
l
bi
244
258 p
j
Alyssum alyssoides 66 Alyssum alyssoides 66
minus var. micranthum 66 Alyssum alyssoides 66
minus var. micranthum 6 Aristolocbiaceae 244, 258, 259, 345 y
y
minus var. micranthum 66 Aristolochiales 258, 337, 345 0 1ncludes authors, titles, and other subject matter as well as all plant and animal taxa appearin q; in
the scientific papers. New taxa and the pages where puhlished are in italic typ e. An attempt has been
made to correct scientific names misspelled in the text. [557] SO
(VoL. 7, No. Bombus 238-240, 506, 518, 527
crotchii 237, 238, 240
edwardsii 237, 238
vosnesenskii 237, 238
Bora~inaceae 192, 373, 375
Wood anatomy of Echium 183
Roronla 36
Bouteloua 509
Bowlesia incana 81
Boykin.ia elata 337
Brahea 529
Brasenia 245. 344. 345
schreberi 251, 256, 344
Brassica nigra 366
Brassicaceae 66, 183, 365-384
'V nod anntomy of Macaronesian and other
Brassicaceae 365
Brassiceae, tribe of Brassicaceae 366
Brecht, Patrick E., see Capon and Brecht 207
Brevoortia 309
ida-maia 309
venusta 309
Briznla 26
Brodiaea 94, 130, 157, 313, 314
congesta 309
coronaria var. kernensis 94
elp~ans 258, 337
filifolia 79, 90
ida-maia 309
kinkiensis 79, 80
laxa 157
orcuttii 90
peduncularis 157
purpusii 313
terrestris 94
tubergenii 157
Xtubergenii 157
venusta 309
Bromus 79, 80
carinatus 77
. margina tus 77
mollis 90
Bronnia, section of Fouquieria 480
Bronnia, subgenus of Fouquieria 449, 454,
478, 479, 480, 482, 535
Bronnia di~11Ptii 4~4, 497
spinosa 478, 480, 491, 516, 525, 528, 535
thiebauti 494
Brugmansia 270, 279
Brunella vulgaris 5
Buckwheat 217
Bugs, semiaquatic 165
Bumblebees 239, 506, 518, 527
Bursera 485, 487, 491, 496, 499, 527, 529
Burseraceae 263
Butomaceae 251, 259, 340
Butomus 250
umbellatus 251, 340
Cabomba 245, 246, 344, 345
caroliniana 251, 253
Cabombaceae 243-245, 251, 344
Cnbomboideae, subfamily of Nymphaeaceae
243, 245
Cactaceae 137, 479
Caesalpinia 491
Calandrinia ciliata 152, 337
var. menziesii 79, 80, 88
maritima 80
California buckwheats 217
Calliandra 268
Callitriche heterophylla var. bolanderi
92, 93, 154
longipedunculata 81
marginata 74, 75, 79-81, 88
var. INDEX TO VOLUME 7, ALISO., marginata 92, 151
Callitris 48
Calochortus albus 154
splendens 7 5
Caltha howellii 339, 343
Calycadenia tenella 90, 153 ,
Belamcanda 401-403, 405-407 Butomaceae 251, 259, 340 ,
chinensis 402, 405 ,
flabellata 405 sinensis 405 Benjamin, Richard K. Laboulbeniales on
semiaquatic Hemiptera. II. Autophagomyces,
Dioicomyces, and Prolixandromyces gen. nov. 165 Berberidaceae 244, 254, 255, 258, 259, ,
335, 336, 339 335, 336, 33
Berberidales 245
b
i
l Berberis amplectens 258, 339 California buckwheats 217 Calliandra 268
C lli i h
h splendens 7 5 p
Caltha howellii 339, 343
Calycadenia tenella 90, 153 p
Caltha howellii 339, 343
l
d
i
ll
90
15 559 JULY 20, 1972] in
southern California 207; see Visco and Capon
231
Capparaceae 365
Capsella bursa-pastoris 79
Carabidae 171
Cardamine califomica 7 4
Carduus pycnocephalus 65
Carex 82
pansa 258, 337
praegracilis 76, 152
tumulicola 76
Carlquist, Sherwin Studies in Stylidiaceae:
new taxa, field observations, evolutionary
tendencies 13
----- Wood anatomy of Eclllum
( Boraginaceae) 183
----- Wood anatomy of Macaronesian and
other Brassicaceae 365
Carpenter bees 488, 493, 506, 514, 515, 518
Carpenteria californica 4, 8, 12, 337
Caryophyllales 337
Cassia 491
Castalia, subgenus of Nymphaea 245, 341
Castilleja foliolosa 153
grisea 81
Casuarina 48, 59, 64
Catapodium rigidum 74
Catha howellii 251, 252, 255, 257
Caulanthus lasiophyllus 79, 81
Ceanothus 233
crassifolius 153
Ceiba 487, 491
Celtis 527
Centaurea 183
Centridium, subgenus of Stylidium 14, 22, 60
Centrolepis 26, 40
Centunculus minimus 92
C:ephalocereus 485, 521, 527, 529
Cerastium glomeratum 81, 90
Ceratophyllaceae 245, 344
Ceratophyllum 245, 344
Cercidiphyllaceae 346
Cercidiphyllum japonicum 346
Cercidium 491, 509, 533
floridum 337
microphyllum 8
Cercis occidentalis 337
Cercocarpus 76, 233
betuloides 337
var. blancheae 76
traskiae 76, 78
Cbaenactis glabriuscula 7
orcuttii 6
11 Calycanthaceae 250, 251, 259, 338 ssp. clementina 81
Campanulaceae 14, 183, 368, 375 p
,
,
Candollea reduplicata 56 p
,
,
Candollea reduplicata 56 Candollea reduplicata 56
Cantua fasciculata 524, 528 p
Cantua fasciculata 524, 528 ,
Capitata, section of Eriogonum 415 ,
Capitata, section of Eriogonum 415 p
g
Capon, Brian, and Patrick E. Brecht Variations
in seed gem1ination and morphology among
populations of Salvia columbariae Benth. in
southern California 207; see Visco and Capon
231 Capon, Brian, and Patrick E. Brecht Variations
in seed gem1ination and morphology among
populations of Salvia columbariae Benth. in
southern California 207; see Visco and Capon
231 venus tum 311
Eriogonum bifurcatum 357, 358
intrafractum 230
Fouquieria 480
burragei 471, 477, 499
columnaris 471, 478, 534
diguetii 471. 477, 497. 499
fasciculata 471, 478, 528, 533
leonilae 471, 477, 486
macdougalii 471, 477, 493
ochoterenae 471, 477, 488
purpusii 471, 478, 530, 533
shrevii 471, 477, 524
splendens
ssp. breviflora 4 71
ssp. campanulata
var. albiflora 471, 519
ssp. splendens 471, 477, 516
MilJa ssp. 322
hiflora 321-323
bryanii 322
magnifica 322, 323
rosea 322
Mitrastemon kawa-sasakii 286
yamamotoi 286
Pilostyles berteri 1'86, 287
thurberi 279, 286. JULY 20, 1972] 287
Raffiesia arnoldii 286
patma 286
Triteleia 323
guadalupensis 145, 146
Jaxa 157
peduncularis 157
tubergenii 158
Cichorieae, tribe of Asteraceae 370, 371, 373
Cirsium drurnmondii 92
foliosum 92
occidentale 6, 11
tioganum 92
Cistaceae 263
Clarkia 75
elegans 4, 5
Claytonia perfoliata 81
Clematis lasiantha 251, 339
Jigusticifolia 251, 339
Cnidosrulus 519, 529
Cneoridium 80
dumosum 80
Coccinellidae 180
Coleoptera 166, 168, 180, 181
Collornia grandiflora 6
Comesperma 44
volubile 54
Comparative serology of the order
Nymphaeales. I 243; II 325
Comptosia cuneata 18
Conostylis 40
Convolvulaceae 183
Convolvulus 183
Cordia 485
Coreopsis 4 79
bigelovii 7
maritima 5
Corethromyces 181
Corylopsis glabescens 258, 337
spicata 258, 337
Cotula coronopifolia 88
Crambe 183, 366, 372, 383
fmticooa 370, 372, 377
strigosa 370, 372 3
Capparaceae 365 Capparaceae 365
Capsella bursa-pastoris 79
Carabidae 171
Cardamine califomica 7 4
Carduus pycnocephalus 65
Carex 82
pansa 258, 337
praegracilis 76, 152
tumulicola 76
Carlquist, Sherwin Studies in Stylidiaceae:
new taxa, field observations, evolutionary
tendencies 13
----- Wood anatomy of Eclllum
( Boraginaceae) 183
----- Wood anatomy of Macaronesian and
other Brassicaceae 365
Carpenter bees 488, 493, 506, 514, 515, 518
Carpenteria californica 4, 8, 12, 337
Caryophyllales 337
Cassia 491
Castalia, subgenus of Nymphaea 245, 341
Castilleja foliolosa 153
grisea 81
Casuarina 48, 59, 64
Catapodium rigidum 74
Catha howellii 251, 252, 255, 257
Caulanthus lasiophyllus 79, 81
Ceanothus 233
crassifolius 153
Ceiba 487, 491
Celtis 527
Centaurea 183
Centridium, subgenus of Stylidium 14, 22, 60
Centrolepis 26, 40
Centunculus minimus 92
C:ephalocereus 485, 521, 527, 529
Cerastium glomeratum 81, 90
Ceratophyllaceae 245, 344
Ceratophyllum 245, 344
Cercidiphyllaceae 346
Cercidiphyllum japonicum 346
Cercidium 491, 509, 533
floridum 337
microphyllum 8
Cercis occidentalis 337
Cercocarpus 76, 233
betuloides 337
var. blancheae 76
traskiae 76, 78
Cbaenactis glabriuscula 7
orcuttii 6, 11
Cbeiranthus 183, 366, 369, 378, 379
arbuscula 368, 370, 379, 381
mutabilis 367, 369, 370, 373, 375, 378
379, 382
scoparius 367, 369, 370, 373, 378, 379,
381-383
tenuifolius 367, 370
Chenopodiaceae 183
Chenopodium 82
berlandieri 7 5
ssp. zschakei 75
var. JULY 20, 1972] INDEX Chorizanthe - Continued
staticoides 7, 75
Chromosome numbers in the genus Milia
( Liliaceae) 321
Chromosome numbers:
Allium 323
Behria tenuiflora 319
Bessera elegans 319
Dandya hannibalii 318, 319
thadhowardii 316, 319
Dichelostemma ida-maia 311
multiflorum 311
venus tum 311
Eriogonum bifurcatum 357, 358
intrafractum 230
Fouquieria 480
burragei 471, 477, 499
columnaris 471, 478, 534
diguetii 471. 477, 497. 499
fasciculata 471, 478, 528, 533
leonilae 471, 477, 486
macdougalii 471, 477, 493
ochoterenae 471, 477, 488
purpusii 471, 478, 530, 533
shrevii 471, 477, 524
splendens
ssp. breviflora 4 71
ssp. campanulata
var. albiflora 471, 519
ssp. splendens 471, 477, 516
MilJa ssp. 322
hiflora 321-323
bryanii 322
magnifica 322, 323
rosea 322
Mitrastemon kawa-sasakii 286
yamamotoi 286
Pilostyles berteri 1'86, 287
thurberi 279, 286. 287
Raffiesia arnoldii 286
patma 286
Triteleia 323
guadalupensis 145, 146
Jaxa 157
peduncularis 157
tubergenii 158
Cichorieae, tribe of Asteraceae 370, 371, 3
Cirsium drurnmondii 92
foliosum 92
occidentale 6, 11
tioganum 92
Cistaceae 263
Clarkia 75
elegans 4, 5
Claytonia perfoliata 81
Clematis lasiantha 251, 339
Jigusticifolia 251
339 Calycanthaceae 250, 251, 259, 338
Calycanthus floridus 338, 343
occidentalis 7, 251, 338
Calystegia macrostegia 81
Camissonia guadalupensis
ssp. clementina 81
Campanulaceae 14, 183, 368, 375
Candollea reduplicata 56
Cantua fasciculata 524, 528
Capitata, section of Eriogonum 415
Capon, Brian, and Patrick E. Brecht Variations
in seed gem1ination and morphology among
populations of Salvia columbariae Benth. JULY 20, 1972] cuspidata 88, 91,
151, 153, 154
Draba 366, 367, 383
Drimys 348
winteri 254, 338, 343
Drosera 15
Dryandra 44
Drymaria 523
Dabautia 377
Dudleya hassei 75, 78
virens 75, 82
Dyssodia thurberi 66
Ebenales 97, 439
Echeveria 527
paniculata 488
spicata 501
Echinocactus 521
viridescens 337
Echinocereus 527
Echinodonts macrophyllus 258, 337
Echium 137, 140, 183-190, 192, 194,
196, 367, 373
aculeatum 184, 187, 188, 190, 194,
195, 198
bourgeauanum 184, 186-188, 190-192,
Hl4, 196, 198
candicans 185, 187-190, 192, 194-196,
198, 367
decaisnei 184, 188, 192, 194, 197
fastuosum 185
giganteum 184, 187, 188, 192, 194, 197
hierrense 187, 188, 192, 194
leucophaeum 184, 188, 192-194
nervosum 184, 185, 188, 192, 194
onosmaefolium 184, 185, 188, 190, 192, 19
pininana 185, 187, 188, 190, 192, 194,
196, 198, 367
strictum 184, 187, 188. 191, 192, 194
virescens 184, 187, 188, 190
var. angustissimum 192
var. virescens 192, 193
webbii 184, 188, 192, 194
Elateridae 180
Elatine 151
brachysperma 90
califomica 88, 92, 93, 151, 154
chil~nsis 88, 92, 93, 151, 152, 154
rubella 90
Eleocharis 86
acicularis 88, 149, 151, 154
macrostachya 74, 77, 79-81, 86, 89,
90. 94, !51
mamillata 77, 79, 94
montevidensis var. parishii 86, 92, 154
palustris 77, 79, 94
Emphoropsis 237, 238
Encelia 496, 499, 509
actoni 1, 4, 7
Epacridaceae 15
Eqnisetum 76
Eremalche parryi 7
E i
74 Crassula aquatica 74, 75, 88, 92, 151
erecta 81, 88, 92, 152 ,
,
Crassulaceae 43 Crossosoma 76
califomicum 2 Crossosoma 76
califomicum 2, 6, 258, 337 p
g
Diptera 180 ,
,
,
Crossosomataceae 258, 259, 337 ,
,
Crossosomataceae 258, p
Distichlis 425 Crucifers 365-367 Crypsis aculeata 90 Doves 488
Downingia cuspitata ssp. JULY 20, 1972] sinuatum 75
califomicum 81
Chilopsis linearis 9
Chlorogalum pomeri<lianum 75
Chorizanthe douglasii 7 pp
Capsella bursa-pastoris 79 p
Carabidae 171 Cardamine califomica 7 4 Carduus pycnocephalus 65 py
p
Carex 82
pansa 258, 337
praegracilis 76, 152
tumulicola 76 py
p
Carex 82
pansa 258, 337
praegracilis 76, 152
tumulicola 76 Carlquist, Sherwin Studies in Stylidiaceae:
new taxa, field observations, evolutionary
tendencies 13
----- Wood anatomy of Eclllum
( Boraginaceae) 183 ssp. splendens 471, 477, 516
MilJa ssp. 322
hiflora 321-323
bryanii 322
magnifica 322, 323
rosea 322 C
9
Castalia, subgenus of Nymphaea 245, 341 Mitrastemon kawa-sasakii 286
yamamotoi 286 y
Pilostyles berteri 1'86, 287
thurberi 279, 286. 287 Raffiesia arnoldii 286
patma 286 Catapod u
g du
7
Catha howellii 251, 252, 255, 257 ,
,
,
Caulanthus lasiophyllus 79, 81 p
Triteleia 323
guadalupensis 145, 146
Jaxa 157
peduncularis 157
tubergenii 158 p
Triteleia 323
guadalupensis 145, 146
Jaxa 157
peduncularis 157
tubergenii 158 Ceanothus 233
crassifolius 153 c ass o us
53
Ceiba 487, 491 Cichorieae, tribe of Asteraceae 370, 37
Cirsium drurnmondii 92
foliosum 92
occidentale 6, 11
tioganum 92
Cistaceae 263
Clarkia 75
elegans 4, 5
Claytonia perfoliata 81
Clematis lasiantha 251, 339
Jigusticifolia 251, 339
Cnidosrulus 519, 529
Cneoridium 80
dumosum 80
Coccinellidae 180
Coleoptera 166, 168, 180, 181
Collornia grandiflora 6
Comesperma 44
volubile 54
Comparative serology of the order
Nymphaeales. I 243; II 325
Comptosia cuneata 18
Conostylis 40
Convolvulaceae 183
Convolvulus 183
Cordia 485
Coreopsis 4 79
bigelovii 7
maritima 5
Corethromyces 181
Corylopsis glabescens 258, 337
spicata 258, 337
Cotula coronopifolia 88
Crambe 183, 366, 372, 383
fmticooa 370, 372, 377
strigosa 370, 372 C:ephalocereus 485, 521, 527, 529 p
,
,
,
Cerastium glomeratum 81, 90 g
,
Ceratophyllaceae 245, 344 p y
,
Ceratophyllum 245, 344 p y
Cercidiphyllaceae 346 p y
Cercidiphyllum japonicum 346 p y
Cercidiphyllum japonicum 346 Coccinellidae 180
Coleoptera 166, 168, 180, 181 p
,
,
Collornia grandiflora 6 381 383
tenuifolius 367, 370 p
Chlorogalum pomeri<lianum 75 g
p
Chorizanthe douglasii 7 [VoL. 7, No. 4 .560 ALISO Dioicomyces - Continued
mesoveliae 171, 172, 174, 181
onchophorus 168
spiniger 168, 173
Diptera 180
Distichlis 425
Donatia 14
Doves 488
Downingia cuspitata ssp. Raffiesiaceae 286 Dactyloctenium aegyptium 69 Dalea 267, 268, 276, 509
emoryi 265, 267, 268, 270, 275
formosa 2e5
frutescens 265
48 ,
,
candicans 185, 187-190, 192, 194-196,
198
367 Da.,dya 137, 313, 314
hannibalii 316, 318, 319
purpusii 313, 314, 316, 319
thadhowardii 314, 318, 319 giganteum 184, 187, 188, 192, 194, 197 g g
hierrense 187, 188, 192, 194 8 ,
88,
9 ,
9
leucophaeum 184, 188, 192-194 Daviesia 268
epiphylla 43 ,
,
Daviesia 268
epiphylla 43
250
251
255
257 ,
,
Daviesia 268
epiphylla 43
250
251 onosmaefolium 184, 185, 188, 190, 192, 194 D egPneria vitiensis 250, 251 , 255, 257,
338, 343 ,
,
strictum 184, 187, 188. 191, 192, 194
184
187
188
190 Degeneriaceae 250, 251, 259, 338, 345
70 ,
,
,
virescens 184, 187, 188, 190
var. angustissimum 192
var. virescens 192, 193
184
188
192
194 Delphinium 70
ki11kien.•·e 69, 70, 80
parryi 251, 339
ssp. parryi 76
variegatum 70, 251, 339
ssp. thornei 70, 7.9, 80
ssp. varif"eatum 71
Dendroseris 368
Deschampsia danthonioides 79, 80, 152
var. gracilis 90, 152, 154
rnonandra 152
Descurainia 183. 366
hourgeauana 367, 370, 379
briquetii 368-370, 377, 379-381, 383
millefolia 370
preauxiana 370, 379, 381
Despe --tae, section of subgenus Stylidium
of Stylidium 22
Dichelostemma 309
capitatum 309
congestum 310, 311
ida-maia 310, 311, 314
rnultiflorum 309-311
parviftorum 310
pulchellum 80, 81, 309
venustum 309-311
Dicotyledoueae 250, 251, 254, 258, 338, 339
Dicrandromyces 171
Dicranocarpus 523
Dilleniaceae 258
Dilleniales 337
Dioicomyces 168, 169, 171-174
anthici 168, 173
endogaeus 171
formicomi 171
indentatus 171 ,
webbii 184, 188, 192, 194 Elateridae 180 Elatine 151
brachysperma 90
califomica 88, 92, 93, 151, 154
chil~nsis 88, 92, 93, 151, 152, 154
rubella 90 Elatine 151
brachysperma 90
califomica 88, 92, 93, 151, 154
chil~nsis 88, 92, 93, 151, 152, 154
rubella 90 p
Dendroseris 368 Deschampsia danthonioides 79, 80, 152
var. gracilis 90, 152, 154
rnonandra 152
i i
183
366 Deschampsia danthonioides 79, 80, 152
90
152
154 p
var. gracilis 90, 152, 154 rubella 90
Eleocharis 86
acicularis 88, 149, 151, 154
macrostachya 74, 77, 79-81, 86, 89,
90. 94, !51
mamillata 77, 79, 94
montevidensis var. JULY 20, 1972] cuspidata 88, 91,
151
153
154 Cryptandromyces peyerimhoffii 166 g
p
151, 153, 154 yp
y
p y
Cryptantha intermedin 79, 80 Cryptantha intermedin 79, 80
traskae 81 151, 153, 154
Draba 366, 367, 383
Drimys 348
winteri 254, 338, 343
Drosera 15
Dryandra 44
Drymaria 523
Dabautia 377
Dudleya hassei 75, 78
virens 75, 82
Dyssodia thurberi 66
Ebenales 97, 439
Echeveria 527
paniculata 488
spicata 501
Echinocactus 521
viridescens 337
Echinocereus 527
Echinodonts macrophyllus 258, 337
Echium 137, 140, 183-190, 192, 194,
196, 367, 373
aculeatum 184, 187, 188, 190, 194,
195, 198
bourgeauanum 184, 186-188, 190-192,
Hl4, 196, 198
candicans 185, 187-190, 192, 194-196,
198, 367
decaisnei 184, 188, 192, 194, 197
fastuosum 185
giganteum 184, 187, 188, 192, 194, 197
hierrense 187, 188, 192, 194
leucophaeum 184, 188, 192-194
nervosum 184, 185, 188, 192, 194
onosmaefolium 184, 185, 188, 190, 192, 194
pininana 185, 187, 188, 190, 192, 194,
196, 198, 367
strictum 184, 187, 188. 191, 192, 194
virescens 184, 187, 188, 190
var. angustissimum 192
var. virescens 192, 193
webbii 184, 188, 192, 194
Elateridae 180
Elatine 151
brachysperma 90
califomica 88, 92, 93, 151, 154
chil~nsis 88, 92, 93, 151, 152, 154
rubella 90
Eleocharis 86
acicularis 88, 149, 151, 154
macrostachya 74, 77, 79-81, 86, 89,
90. 94, !51
mamillata 77, 79, 94
montevidensis var. parishii 86, 92, 154
palustris 77, 79, 94
Emphoropsis 237, 238
Encelia 496, 499, 509
actoni 1, 4, 7
Epacridaceae 15
Eqnisetum 76
Eremalche parryi 7
Erigeron 74
bonariensis 7 4
disco ide us 7 4
foUosus 92
var. foliosus 92
var. stenophyllus 92
Eriodictyon traskiae 7 4
Eriogonum 94, 217, 224, 357, 363, 415, 419
agninum 223
anemophilum 228, 417
angnlosum 229
apachense 226
arborescens 6 ,
,
Draba 366, 367, 383
348 Cryptophagidae 180 Cucujidae 180 Drosera 15
44 Cvanea 368
-leptostegia 190 p
g
C:vanostegia 48 y
Drymaria 523 Drymaria 523 g
Cynareae, tribe of Asteraceae 369 Dabautia 377 y
Cyperaceae 258 Dudleya hassei 75, 78
virens 75, 82 yp
Cyperales 337 yp
Cyperales 337 Cytineae, tribe of Raffiesiaceae 263
263 Dyssodia thurberi 66
9
439 Echeveria 527
paniculata 488
spicata 501 yp
Cytology of:
Hehria tenuillora 318
Bessera elegans 318
Dandya hannibalii 318
thadhowardii 318
Fouquieriaceae 470
Pno<tyles thurberi 263
Raffiesiaceae 286
Triteleia tubergenii 157 p
Echinocactus 521
viridescens 337 Echinodonts macrophyllus 258, 337 Echinodonts macrophyllus 258, 337 Raffiesiaceae 286 parishii 86, 92, 154
palustris 77, 79, 94
Emphoropsis 237, 238
Encelia 496, 499, 509
actoni 1, 4, 7
Epacridaceae 15
Eqnisetum 76
Eremalche parryi 7
Erigeron 74
bonariensis 7 4
disco ide us 7 4
foUosus 92
var. foliosus 92
var. stenophyllus 92
Eriodictyon traskiae 7 4
Eriogonum 94, 217, 224, 357, 363, 415, 419
agninum 223
anemophilum 228, 417
angnlosum 229
apachense 226
arborescens 6 Descurainia 183. 366
hourgeauana 367, 370, 379
briquetii 368-370, 377, 379-381, 383
millefolia 370
preauxiana 370, 379, 381 p
Despe --tae, section of subgenus Stylidium
of Stylidium 22 Despe --tae, section of subgenus Stylidium
f S
lidi
22 Dicrandromyces 171 Dicranocarpus 523
258 p y
Eriodictyon traskiae 7 4
i
94
217
224 y
Eriogonum 94, 217, 224, 357, 363, 415, 419
i
223 Dioicomyces 168, 169, 171-174
hi i 168
173 g
anemophilum 228, 417
l
229 angnlosum 229
h
226 apachense 226 arborescens 6 561 INDEX JuLY 20, 1972] Eriogonum - Continued
beatleyae 415, 416, 417, 419
bifurcatum 357, 358, 359
brach yanthum 225
caninum 223, 224
chrysops 417-419
citharifom1e 222, 225
var. agninum. 223
congdonii 220, 221
cusickii 418, 419
davidsonii 224, 225
deflexum 357, 358
densum 225
diclinum 218, 219, 220
douglasii 337
eastwoodianum 224
eremicola 222
fascicu latum 9
var. foliolosum 230
fusifon11e 222
gigantetml 230
ssp. formosum 81
ssp. giganteum 78
gracile 223, 225
var. cithariforme 222
var. polygonoides 223
grande 76
var. grande 229
var. rubescens 229
var. timorum. 229
heermannH ssp. hnmilius 226
var. heermannii 226
var. hu.milius 226
heracleoides 217
var. angustifolium 217
var. heracleoides 217
hirtellum 218
incanun1 218-220
inerme 224
inflatum 221, 222
var. contigu.um. 221, 222
var. deflatum 222
var. fusiforme 221, 222
var. inHatum 221, 222
insigne 357-359
intrafractum 230
intricatum 222
latifolium ssp. decurrens 228
ssp. grande 76
luteolum 223-225
marifolium 218-220
mohavense 229
nudum var. auriculatum 228, 229
var. decurrens 228, 229
var. indictum 229
var. murinum 228, 229
var. pauciflorum 92, 230
var. saxatile 92
palmerianum 225
panamintense 226-228
pedunculatum 223-225
pilosum 222
polycladon 225
polypodum 218, 220
prociduum 415, 417-419
racemosum 226-228
rixfordii 222
rosense 228, 417, 419
rosemn 225
rupinum 226-228, 230
saxatile 229
scabrellum 357
spregulinum var. pratense 204
ternatum 221
var. congdonH 220
trichopes 221, 222
tripodum 224
umbellatum 218, 221
var. bahiiforme 218 Eriogonum - Continued
ursinum 221
var. congdonii 220
vimineum 223-225
ssp. polygonoides 223
var. agninum 223
var. Raffiesiaceae 286 cithariforme 222
var. luteolum 223
wrightii var. subscaposum 229
Eriophyllum confertill.orum 82
lanatum 8
nevinii 7, 74, 80
Erodium botrys, 79, 80
cicutarium 80, 90
moschatum 80
obtusiplicatum 90
Eryngium aristulatum var. parishii 88, 154
articulatum 9
Erysimum 366
insulare 366
rnoranii 366
sulfrutescens 366
Erythrina 491
Escbscholzia caespitosa 6
var. hypecoides 4, 5, 11
californica 4, 6, 251, 339
glauca 9
lobbii 251, 339
ramosa 79, 80
Eucalyptus 30, 59
Eucantharomyces 181
Eucommia ulmoides 258, 337
Eucommiaceae 258, 259
Eucom1niales 337
Eucrypta chrysanthemifolia var. ch rysanthemifolia 81 vimineum 223-225
ssp. polygonoides 223
var. agninum 223
var. cithariforme 222
var. luteolum 223
wrightii var. subscaposum 229
Eriophyllum confertill.orum 82
lanatum 8
nevinii 7, 74, 80
Erodium botrys, 79, 80
cicutarium 80, 90
moschatum 80
obtusiplicatum 90
Eryngium aristulatum var. parishii 88, 154
articulatum 9
Erysimum 366
insulare 366
rnoranii 366
sulfrutescens 366
Erythrina 491
Escbscholzia caespitosa 6
var. hypecoides 4, 5, 11
californica 4, 6, 251, 339
glauca 9
lobbii 251, 339
ramosa 79, 80
Eucalyptus 30, 59
Eucantharomyces 181
Eucommia ulmoides 258, 337
Eucommiaceae 258, 259
Eucom1niales 337
Eucrypta chrysanthemifolia var. ch rysanthemifolia 81
Euphorbia 185, 196, 382, 479
crenulata 153
oblongata 66
misera 80
peplus 74
serpyllifolia 75
Euphorbiaceae 66
Eupomatia laurina 338, 343
Eupomatiaceae 338, 345
Euptelia pleiospenna 337
Eupteleales 337
Eurotia lanata 9 obtusiplicatum 90
Eryngium aristulatum var. parishii 88, 154
articulatum 9
Erysimum 366
insulare 366
rnoranii 366
sulfrutescens 366
Erythrina 491
Escbscholzia caespitosa 6
var. hypecoides 4, 5, 11
californica 4, 6, 251, 339
glauca 9
lobbii 251, 339
ramosa 79, 80
Eucalyptus 30, 59
Eucantharomyces 181
Eucommia ulmoides 258, 337
Eucommiaceae 258, 259
Eucom1niales 337
Eucrypta chrysanthemifolia var. Raffiesiaceae 286 ch rysanthemifolia 81
Euphorbia 185, 196, 382, 479
crenulata 153
oblongata 66 y
Eucommia ulmoides 258, 337 ,
Eucommiaceae 258, 259 ch rysanthemifolia 81
Euphorbia 185, 196, 382, 479
crenulata 153
oblongata 66
misera 80
peplus 74
serpyllifolia 75
Euphorbiaceae 66
Eupomatia laurina 338, 343
Eupomatiaceae 338, 345
Euptelia pleiospenna 337
Eupteleales 337
Eurotia lanata 9
Euryalaceae 243- 245
Euryalales 243-245, 343, 349
Euryale 243, 245, 325, 327, 329, 331,
333, 335, 337-341, 343, 344
ferox 250, 251, 253, 327, 329-333,
335- 337, 343, 344, 349
Eutriteleia 159
Euzomodendron 366
Evansia 401, 403
dichotoma 403
fimbriata 401
vespertina 401
Evax acaulis 90
Evolutionary tendencies, Stylidiaceae ).3
Exoneura hamulata 18
Fabaceae 66, 263, 346, 347, 361
Fabales 337
Fagaceae 263
Fallugia paradoxa 9
F ern, aquatic 149
Ferocactus 527
F estuca 79
arundinacea 77
bromoides 79
dertonensis 88
megalura 79, 88, 152
myuros 79, 88
pacifica 79
pratensis 77
Filago arizonka 79
californica 79
gallka 88
Flacourtiaceae 263
Flaveria 523 p
Eupomatia laurina 338, 343 562 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 ALISO Flourensia 509, 523
Flora of:
San Clemente Island 73
Santa Catalina Island 73
Santa Rosa Plateau 153
Forstera 13- 16
bellidifolia 13, 14
bidwillli 16
Forsteropsis, subllenus of StyUdium 14, 15, 22
Fouquieria, section of Fouquieria
480, 481, 535
Fouquieria, subgenus of Fouquieria 449,
479-481, 535
Fouquieria 97, 112, 439, 478, 479, 508,
516, 530, 535
sect. Bronnia 480
sect. Fouquieria 480, 481 , 535
sect. Ocotilla 480, 481, 535
subgen. Bronnia 449, 454, 478-480,
482, 535
subgen. Fouqtderia 449, 479-481, 535
subgen. Idria 454, 479, 481, 482, 535
burragei 104, 108, 122, 440, 441, 444,
446, 447, 451-455, 457, 459, 463,
464, 468-471, 473, 475, 477, 478,
481, 496-499, 501, 502, 535
campanulata 102-104. 107. 109. Fouquieria -
Continued 122-124, 441, 443, 444, 451-454,
457-459, 461-464, 468- 471, 477,
482, 501, 511, 522-524, 535
spinosa 508, 524, 528
splendens 97, 98, 102, 104, 107, 110, 112,
117, 121, 122, 124, 439-441, 443,
444, 449, 451, 453-455, 457-460,
463, 464, 467-470, 477, 480, 482,
491, 496, 506, 508, 511-515, 523,
524, 535
beta micrantha 508
ssp. brevifolia 461, 463, 469, 471,
482, 513, 515, 518, 519, 520, 521,
535
ssp. campanula.ta 441, 443, 457, 460-462, Fouquieria
Continued
469, 470, 511-513, 515, 517, 518, 52
535
var. albiflora 465, 471, 482, 518, 535
ssp. splendens 441, 467, 469, 470, 471,
482 .. 508, 509, 511-513, 517, 518,
522, 535
var. campanulata 482, 518
Fouquieriaceae 97, 187, 439
Anatomy of periderm and cortex 97
Cytology 4 70
Ecology 440
Flower structure 457
Growth habits 441
Inflorescence 452
Leaf origin and structure 445
Pollination 469
Root structure 120, 444
Stem structure 98, 444
Frankenia grandifolia 80
Fraxinus velutina var. coriacea 92
Fuchsia, section of Fuchsia 409, 410
Fuchsia 409, 411
apetala 411
austromontana 409
ayaverensis 409
fosberg-i.i 409
lw.rlin gii 409
juntascensis 411
tillettia.na 110
Galbulimima baccata 339
Galium catalinense 75, 80, 81
Galvesia speciosa 76, 82
Ganysma, subgenus of E riogonum 357
Garrya veatchii 153
Geraea canescens 9
Geranium carolinianurn 90
Gerroidea, superfamily of Hemiptera 165
Gilia achilleaefolia 6
chamissonis 5
nevinii 79, 80
starninea 5
tricolor 5
Gilmania luteola 223
Gloeandromyces 179, 180
Gnaphalium 74
califomkun1 7 4
Iuteo-album 64
palustre 79-81, 151
purpureum 7 4
Godetia 4
amoena 5
biloba 3, 5
bottae 5
cylindrica 5
deAexa 5
dudleyana 5
lindleyi 5
quadrivulnera 9
viminalis 5
whitneyi 5
Goodeniaceae 137, 187, 189, 373, 382
Grayia spinosa 7
Grevillea 48
Guadalupe Island 145
Gyrostemon 48
Habroanthus, subgenus and section of
Penstemon 351, 352
Haematoxylon 485, 491
Hakea 38, 4.3, 44, 54
Halictidae 231, 534
Hamamelidaceae 258, 259
Hamamelidales 337, 346
H amamelidiHorae, superorder of ,
Flora of:
San Clemente Island 73
Santa Catalina Island 73
Santa Rosa Plateau 153 Forstera 13- 16
bellidifolia 13, 14
bidwillli 16 Forsteropsis, subllenus of StyUdium 14, 15, 22 ,
,
Fouquieria, subgenus of Fouquieria 449,
479-481, 535 ,
Frankenia grandifolia 80 g
Fraxinus velutina var. Raffiesiaceae 286 112, 121,
122, 124, 437, 508, 517, 528
columnaris 440, 441, 443-447, 449,
451-455, 457, 461, 464, 468-471,
473, 478, 482, 496, 502, 509, 530,
531' 533-535
diguetii 104, 106-109, 111, 122-124,
440, 441, 443, 444, 447, 449,
452-455, 458, 460, 469-471, 473,
477, 481, 491-497, 499, 509, 533, 535
fasciculata 104, 108, 112, 113, 116, 120,
122, 440, 441, 443-446, 448, 449,
452-455, 458, 4.63, 464, 469-471,
473, 478, 480, 482, 485, 493, 516,
524, 527-529, 533, 535
fonnosa 97, 99, 100, 103, 104, 108, 109,
114, 116, 122, 440, 441, 444, 449,
451-455, 458, 468-471, 473, 478,
480, 481, 485, 501, 503-505, 529, 535
gigantea 530
jaboncillo 488, 493
leoniale 101, 104, 108, 116, 122, 124,
440, 441, 444, 448, 449, 451 ,
453-455, 457, 461, 467, 469-471,
473, 477, 481, 483, 485, 488, 535
macdougaUi 104, 107, 108, 113, 114,
121- 124, 440, 441, 444, 449, 451-455,
457, 469-471, 473, 477, 481, 488,
489, 491-493, 496, 509, 535
ochoterenae 101, 104, 106, 108, 111,
113, 114, 116, 117, 122, 124, 440,
441, 443, 444, 449, 451-455, 457,
458, 461, 467, 470, 471, 473, 477,
481, 485-488, 535
peninsularis 470, 494
purpusii 101, 102, 104, 108, 109, 112,
114, 116, 120, 122, 124, 440, 441 ,
443, 445, 446, 448, 449, 452-455,
458, 464, 469-471, 473, 478, 482,
485, 527-530, 533, 535
shrevei 101, 102, 104, 106, 109, 116. 122-124, 441, 443, 444, 451-454,
457-459, 461-464, 468- 471, 477,
482, 501, 511, 522-524, 535
spinosa 508, 524, 528
splendens 97, 98, 102, 104, 107, 110, 112,
117, 121, 122, 124, 439-441, 443,
444, 449, 451, 453-455, 457-460,
463, 464, 467-470, 477, 480, 482,
491, 496, 506, 508, 511-515, 523,
524, 535
beta micrantha 508
ssp. brevifolia 461, 463, 469, 471,
482, 513, 515, 518, 519, 520, 521,
535
ssp
campanula ta 441
443
457
460 462 Fouquieria -
Continued
469, 470, 511-513, 515, 517, 518, 522,
535
var. albiflora 465, 471, 482, 518, 535
ssp. splendens 441, 467, 469, 470, 471,
482 .. 508, 509, 511-513, 517, 518,
522, 535
var. campanulata 482, 518 Fouquieria -
Continued Flourensia 509, 523
Flora of:
San Clemente Island 73
Santa Catalina Island 73
Santa Rosa Plateau 153
Forstera 13- 16
bellidifolia 13, 14
bidwillli 16
Forsteropsis, subllenus of StyUdium 14, 15, 22
Fouquieria, section of Fouquieria
480, 481, 535
Fouquieria, subgenus of Fouquieria 449,
479-481, 535
Fouquieria 97, 112, 439, 478, 479, 508,
516, 530, 535
sect. Bronnia 480
sect. Fouquieria 480, 481 , 535
sect. Ocotilla 480, 481, 535
subgen. Bronnia 449, 454, 478-480,
482, 535
subgen. Fouqtderia 449, 479-481, 535
subgen. Idria 454, 479, 481, 482, 535
burragei 104, 108, 122, 440, 441, 444,
446, 447, 451-455, 457, 459, 463,
464, 468-471, 473, 475, 477, 478,
481, 496-499, 501, 502, 535
campanulata 102-104. 107. 109. 112, 121,
122, 124, 437, 508, 517, 528
columnaris 440, 441, 443-447, 449,
451-455, 457, 461, 464, 468-471,
473, 478, 482, 496, 502, 509, 530,
531' 533-535
diguetii 104, 106-109, 111, 122-124,
440, 441, 443, 444, 447, 449,
452-455, 458, 460, 469-471, 473,
477, 481, 491-497, 499, 509, 533, 535
fasciculata 104, 108, 112, 113, 116, 120,
122, 440, 441, 443-446, 448, 449,
452-455, 458, 4.63, 464, 469-471,
473, 478, 480, 482, 485, 493, 516,
524, 527-529, 533, 535
fonnosa 97, 99, 100, 103, 104, 108, 109,
114, 116, 122, 440, 441, 444, 449,
451-455, 458, 468-471, 473, 478,
480, 481, 485, 501, 503-505, 529, 535
gigantea 530
jaboncillo 488, 493
leoniale 101, 104, 108, 116, 122, 124,
440, 441, 444, 448, 449, 451 ,
453-455, 457, 461, 467, 469-471,
473, 477, 481, 483, 485, 488, 535
macdougaUi 104, 107, 108, 113, 114,
121- 124, 440, 441, 444, 449, 451-455,
457, 469-471, 473, 477, 481, 488,
489, 491-493, 496, 509, 535
ochoterenae 101, 104, 106, 108, 111,
113, 114, 116, 117, 122, 124, 440,
441, 443, 444, 449, 451-455, 457,
458, 461, 467, 470, 471, 473, 477,
481, 485-488, 535
peninsularis 470, 494
purpusii 101, 102, 104, 108, 109, 112,
114, 116, 120, 122, 124, 440, 441 ,
443, 445, 446, 448, 449, 452-455,
458, 464, 469-471, 473, 478, 482,
485, 527-530, 533, 535
shrevei 101, 102, 104, 106, 109, 116. Fouquieria -
Continued see Thome and Lathrop
85, 149
Lathyrns 130, 361, 362
alefeldii 7
graminifolius 361
hitchcockiant<S 361, 362, 363
laetifiorus ssp
barbarae 80 Junceae -
Continued
Stylidium 32 Heliantbeae, tribe of Asteraceae 190
5
6 Heliantbeae, tribe of Asteraceae 190
Helleboms niger 251, 336, 339, 343 Junceae -
Continued
Stylidium 32
Juncus 76, 149
acutus var. sphaerocarpus 77
balticus 77
bufonius 74, 77, 81, 88, 92, 94, 151,
152, 154
mexicanus 77
patens 81
sphaerocarpus 88, 92, 94, 151, 154
textilis 77
Juniperus 418
californica 233
osteosperma 416
Kadsura 345
japonica 258, 337
Karwinskia 491, 496
Keckiella 94
cordifolia 74, 76, 81, 94
Kennedya 36
Labiatae 231
Laboulbenia 165
titschackii 165
Laboulbeniaceae 179, 181
Laboulbeniales 135, 136, 165, 166, 168,
171, 179-181
Lactuca serriola 371
Lamarckia aurea 90
Lambertia 54
Lamiaceae 375
Larrea 496, 509, 519, 523, 531
divaricata 232
Lasthenia chrysostoma 90, 153
glabrata 8
Lathridiidae 180
Lathrop, Earl W. see Thome and Lathrop
85, 149
Lathyrns 130, 361, 362
alefeldii 7
graminifolius 361
hitchcockiant<S 361, 362, 363
laetifiorus ssp. barbarae 80
Janszwertii 361
ssp. aridus 361, 362
pa luster 361
paucifloms 362
ssp. brownii 361, 362
Lauraceae 250, 251, 258, 259, 339
Laurales 337, 345, 349
Laurus nobilis 339, 343
Layia heterotricha 9
platyglossa 7
ssp. campestris 153
Ledum 221
Leguminosae 263, 337
Lemaireocereus 491, 496, 499, 527
Lemna 90
gibba 154
Lenz, L. W. A new species of Triteleia
( Liliaceae) from Guadalupe Island 1
----- An intergeneric hybrid between B
canda chinensis and Pardanthopsis d
oma (=Iris dichotoma) 405
----- Chromosome numbers in the gen
Milia Cav. 321
- ---- Director's Report 1968 137; 1969
1970 385; 1971 539
----- Experimental evidence for hybri
5\Jg of Dichelostemma venustum ( Lili
---4oi The stahlS of Pardanthopsis ( Jrid
- - - -- Triteleia tubergenii, an amphidipl
garden origin 157
----- Two new species of Danclya ( Lili Helobiae 244
Hemiptera 165, 167, 168, 174, 177, 179-181 Hemiptera 165, 167, 168, 174, 177, 179-181 Hemizonia 377
clementina 81
fasciculata 81
411 patens 81
sphaerocarpus 88, 92, 94, 151, 154
textilis 77 Laboulbeniaceae 179, 181 Laboulbeniaceae 179, 181
Laboulbeniales 135, 136, 165, 166, 168, 9,
Laboulbeniales 135, 136, 165, 166, 168,
171
179 181 a
aceae 3 5
Larrea 496, 509, 519, 523, 531
divaricata 232 Lasthenia chrysostoma 90, 153
glabrata 8 g
Lathridiidae 180 Lathrop, Earl W. see Thome and Lathrop
85, 149 Lathrop, Earl W. Fouquieria -
Continued coriacea 92 Fuchsia, section of Fuchsia 409, 410 Fuchsia, section of Fuchsia 409, 410
Fuchsia 409, 411
apetala 411
austromontana 409
ayaverensis 409
fosberg-i.i 409
lw.rlin gii 409
juntascensis 411
tillettia.na 110
Galbulimima baccata 339
Galium catalinense 75, 80, 81
Galvesia speciosa 76, 82
Ganysma, subgenus of E riogonum 357
Garrya veatchii 153
Geraea canescens 9
Geranium carolinianurn 90
Gerroidea, superfamily of Hemiptera 165
Gilia achilleaefolia 6
chamissonis 5
nevinii 79, 80
starninea 5
tricolor 5
Gilmania luteola 223
Gloeandromyces 179, 180
Gnaphalium 74
califomkun1 7 4
Iuteo-album 64
palustre 79-81, 151
purpureum 7 4
Godetia 4
amoena 5
biloba 3, 5
bottae 5
cylindrica 5
deAexa 5
dudleyana 5
lindleyi 5
quadrivulnera 9
viminalis 5
whitneyi 5
Goodeniaceae 137, 187, 189, 373, 382
Grayia spinosa 7
Grevillea 48
Guadalupe Island 145
Gyrostemon 48
Habroanthus, subgenus and section of
Penstemon 351, 352
Haematoxylon 485, 491
Hakea 38, 4.3, 44, 54
Halictidae 231, 534
Hamamelidaceae 258, 259
Hamamelidales 337, 346
H amamelidiHorae, superorder of
Dicotyledoneae 258
Hamamelis virginiana 258, 337
Haplopappus p almeri ssp. pachylepis 7 4
parishii 9
Hebridae 165
Hechtia 485, 487, 509, 521
Heleniae, tribe of Asteraceae 369
Helenium puberulum 74 ,
,
,
,
,
,
fasciculata 104, 108, 112, 113, 116, 120,
122, 440, 441, 443-446, 448, 449,
452-455, 458, 4.63, 464, 469-471,
473, 478, 480, 482, 485, 493, 516,
524, 527-529, 533, 535 ,
,
,
,
,
,
fasciculata 104, 108, 112, 113, 116, 120,
122, 440, 441, 443-446, 448, 449,
452-455, 458, 4.63, 464, 469-471,
473, 478, 480, 482, 485, 493, 516,
524, 527-529, 533, 535 y
,
Gnaphalium 74
califomkun1 7 4
Iuteo-album 64
palustre 79-81, 151
purpureum 7 4 whitneyi 5
Goodeniaceae 137, 187, 189, 373, 382 Guadalupe Island 145 y
Habroanthus, subgenus and section of ,
g
Penstemon 351, 352 ,
Haematoxylon 485, 491 y
,
Hakea 38, 4.3, 44, 54 ssp. brevifolia 461, 463, 469, 471, ssp. b evifolia
6 ,
63,
69,
7 ,
482, 513, 515, 518, 519, 520, 521, Hebridae 165
Hechtia 485, 487, 509, 521 p
f
,
,
,
,
482, 513, 515, 518, 519, 520, 521,
535 ,
,
,
Heleniae, tribe of Asteraceae 369 535
ssp. Fouquieria -
Continued campanula.ta 441, 443, 457, 460-462, ,
Helenium puberulum 74 563 JULY 20, 1972] INDEX ,
]
Heliantbeae, tribe of Asteraceae 190
Helleboms niger 251, 336, 339, 343
Helobiae 244
Hemiptera 165, 167, 168, 174, 177, 179-181
Hemizonia 377
clementina 81
fasciculata 81
Hemsleyella, section of Fuchsia 411
Henrickson, James
Anatomy of periderm and
cortex of Fouquieriaceae 97
----- A taxonomic revision of the
Fouquieriaceae 439
Hesperideae, tribe of Brassicaceae 366
Hesperomyces 179- 181
lasiochili 181
Heteromeles 76
arbutifolia 75, 337
Heuchera micrantha 337
Hibbertia 48
cuneiformis 33 7
scandens 33 7
stellaris 36
Hibiscus 485
Himantandraceae 339, 345
Holmgren, Noel H. A new species of
P enstemon from Nye County, Nevada 351
Holodiscus discolor var. franciscanus 76
Honeybee 236, 239
Hordeum 80
glaucum 90
leporinum 81
Hulsea 413
callicarpha 413
inyoensis 413
parryi 413
vestita 204, 413
ssp. calUcarpha 413
ssp. inyoensis 413
ssp. parryi 413
ssp. pygrnaea 413
ssp. vestita 413
var. caUicarpha 413
var. pygmaea 413
Hummingbird(s) 236, 485, 493, 497, 499,
506, 514, 518, 527
Anna 231
Costa 514
Rufous 514
I-lyclrocharitaceae 251, 259, 340
Hyclrometridae 165
Hymenoptera(n) 236, 237, 239
l-Iypocalymma 36
Ichia, subgenus of Fouquieria 454, 479,
481, 482, 535
leiria 97, 99, 109, 118, 120, 126, 439,
478, 481
columnaris 97, 100-102, 104, 109, 112,
114, 116-122, 124, 444, 478, 481, 535
llliciaceae 345
Illiciales 244, 254, 336, 345
Illiciineae, suborder of Annonales 245, 345
Illicium 254, 345
anisatum 337
Ilyomyces 179
Jnflati, section of Astragalus 161, 162
Ipomoea 4 79, 491
Iriclaceae 258, 401
Iris 401-403, 405, 406
clichotoma 401-403, 405
clouglasiana 258, 337
401 Junceae -
Continued
Stylidium 32
Juncus 76, 149
acutus var. sphaerocarpus 77
balticus 77
bufonius 74, 77, 81, 88, 92, 94, 151,
152, 154
mexicanus 77
patens 81
sphaerocarpus 88, 92, 94, 151, 154
textilis 77
Juniperus 418
californica 233
osteosperma 416
Kadsura 345
japonica 258, 337
Karwinskia 491, 496
Keckiella 94
cordifolia 74, 76, 81, 94
Kennedya 36
Labiatae 231
Laboulbenia 165
titschackii 165
Laboulbeniaceae 179, 181
Laboulbeniales 135, 136, 165, 166, 168,
171, 179-181
Lactuca serriola 371
Lamarckia aurea 90
Lambertia 54
Lamiaceae 375
Larrea 496, 509, 519, 523, 531
divaricata 232
Lasthenia chrysostoma 90, 153
glabrata 8
Lathridiidae 180
Lathrop, Earl W. Fouquieria -
Continued see Thome and Lathrop
85, 149 ,
,
laetifiorus ssp. barbarae 80 p
,
Lauraceae 250, 251, 258, 259, 339 ,
,
,
Laurales 337, 345, 349 ,
,
Laurus nobilis 339, 343 ,
Layia heterotricha 9 Layia heterotricha 9
platyglossa 7
ssp
campestris 153 ssp. campestris 153
Ledum 221 Leguminosae 263, 337 Leguminosae 263, 337 g
63, 33
Lemaireocereus 491, 496, 499, 527 g
,
Lemaireocereus 491, 496, 499, 527 gibba 154
Lenz, L. W. A new species of Triteleia
( Liliaceae) from Guadalupe Island 145
----- An intergeneric hybrid between Belam-
canda chinensis and Pardanthopsis dichot-
oma (=Iris dichotoma) 405
----- Chromosome numbers in the genus
Milia Cav. 321
- ---- Director's Report 1968 137; 1969 289;
1970 385; 1971 539
----- Experimental evidence for hybrid ori-
5\Jg of Dichelostemma venustum ( Liliaceae )
---4oi The stahlS of Pardanthopsis ( Jridaceae)
- - - -- Triteleia tubergenii, an amphidiploid of
garden origin 157
----- Two new species of Danclya ( Liliaceae)
fron1 Mexico and a reexamination of Bessera
and Behria 313 llliciaceae 345
Illiciales 244, 254, 336, 345 ,
,
,
Illiciineae, suborder of Annonales 245, 345
5
5 ,
,
,
Illiciineae, suborder of Annonales 245, 3 ,
,
,
Illiciineae, suborder of Annon Illicium 254, 345
anisatum 337 y
y
Jnflati, section of Astragalus 161, 162 ,
g
,
Ipomoea 4 79, 491 ,
Ipomoea 4 79, 491 ,
Ipomoea 4 79, 491 p
,
Iriclaceae 258, 401 p
,
Iriclaceae 258, 401 Iriclaceae 258, 401
Iris 401-403, 405, 406
clichotoma 401-403, 405
clouglasiana 258, 337
verna 401
wattii 401
yecloensis 401 y
Isoetes 92, 149
howellii 88, 92, 93, 151, 153, 154
orcuttii 88, 92, 93, 151, 153 orcuttii 88, 92, 93,
Isopogon 30, 48, 54 ,
,
,
Isopogon 30, 48, 54 Isopogon 30, 48, 54
Japtropha 479, 491, 496, 499, 519, 529, 531 p g
,
,
Japtropha 479, 491, 496, 499, 519, 529, 531 Lepidieae, tribe of Brassicaceae 366 Lepidieae, tribe of Brassicaceae 366 p
,
Lepidium 366
lasiocarpum var. lasiocarpum 81
latipes 90
nitidum 152 p
,
Lepidium 366 p
p
,
,
,
Jepsonia malvifolia 76, 80 p
,
Lepidium 366
lasiocarpum var. lasiocarpum 81
latipes 90
nitidum 152 Jepsonia malv
Juliania 529
J J uncaginaceae 94 J uncaginaceae 94
Junceae, section of subgenus Stylidium of g
Junceae, section of subgenus Stylidium of [VoL. 7, No. Fouquieria -
Continued 4 ALISO 564 Lepidium - Continued
serra 367, 370, 37 4, 379
Lepidopterans 239
Leschenaultia 43
Leucaena 529
Leucopogon 30, 4:!, 58
Levenhookia 13-16, 18-20, 60, 62
chippendalei 60, 62
dubia 19, 20, 60
leptantha 19, 60, 62
octomaculata 60, 62
pauciflora 19, 60, 62, 63
preissii 19, 60, 62
pulcherrima 60, 62, 63
pusilla 20, 28, 60, 62
sonderi 20, 60
stipitata 60, 62 Macroveliidae 165 ohovata 338
soulangeana 251, 255, 338 p
virginiana 338 g
Magnoliaceae 250, 251, 259 Magnoliaceae 250, 251, 259
Magnoliales 243, 244, 254, 325, 335, 344-346,
349 g
,
,
Magnoliales 243, 244, 254, 325, 335, 344-346,
349 p
,
Lewisia rediviva var. minor 66 349
Magnoliineae, suborder of Annonales 345 349
Magnoliineae, suborder of Annonales 345 Lilaea scilloides 88, 92, 94, 151, 152, 154 Magnoliineae, suborder of A , 9 , 9 ,
,
,
Liliaceae 145, 250, 251, 258, 259, 309, 313, ,
,
,
,
,
Liliaceae 145, 250, 251, 258, 259, 309, 313,
321. 340 g
Malacothrix arachnoidea 7
blairii 371
f li
80 g
Malacothrix arachnoidea 7 Liliales 244, 259, 335, 337 Mammillaria 527, 529 Lilium humboldtii 258, 340
parryi 255, 258, 340 Manihot 487 p
y
,
,
Limonium sinuatum 75 p
y
Limonium sinuatum 75 Marah 76 Limosella acaulis 90 Limosella acaulis 90 p
Marsilea 88, 149 Linanthus hicolor ssp. bicolor 79, 80 p
Marsilea 88, 149
mucronata 88, 92, 149, 151
vestita 92 Linanthus hicolor ssp. bicolor 79, 80
grandiflorus 5
montanus 5
pusillus 152
pygmaeus 152
ssp. continentalis 92
ssp. pygmaeus 79
Li
i
d
i
79
152 Marsilea 88, 149
mucronata 88, 92, 149, 151 Marsileaceae 149 Matthiola 366, 381, 382
maderensis 370, 376, 377, 379, 381 Mattl>ioleae, tribe of Brassicaceae 366, 376, 381 ssp. pygmaeus 79
Linaria canadensis var. texana 79, 152 p
pyg
Linaria canadensis var. texana 79, 152 p
pyg
Linaria canadensis var. Fouquieria -
Continued apus 151, 154
patagonicus 152
Myrica 185
Myrtaceae 54
Myrtillocactus 521
Nama 523
Nasturtium officinale 92
Navarretia prostrata 151, 153, 154
Nelumbo 243-245, 248-254, 256, 258, 259, 325,
327, 329, 331, 333, 335, 337-340, 344,
346, 348, 349
lutea 246-249, 251- 253, 255-257, 259, 327,
329-331, 333, 335, 336, 341, 346
nucifera 1, 246-249, 251, 252, 255, 256, 259,
327, 331, 333, 336, 344
Nelumbonaceae 243-245, 251, 345
Nehm1bonales 244, 245, 344, 345
Nelumbonoideae, subfamily of Nymphaeaceae
243, 245
NemophiJa maculata 6
Neobuxbaumia tetetzo 316
Nerisyrenia 523
N icotiana glauca 69
Nitidulidae 180
Nitrangium, subgenus of Stylidium 14, 15, 58, 5~
Nomia 237, 238
Nupbar 245, 325, 327, 329, 331, 333, 335,
337-341, 343, 349
japonicum 341
luteum 327, 329, 332, 333
ssp. macrophyllum 249, 251, 327, 331, 333
ssp. polysepalum 251, 253, 256, 327, 329-
333, 335, 336, 343, 349
ssp. variegatum 251, 253, 327, 329-331,
333
polysepalum 250
' yctaginaceae 75, 201, 421
Nycteribiidae 180
Nympbaea 245, 325, 327, 329, 331, 333, 335,
337-341, 343, 349
alba 251, 327, 329, 331, 333
capensis 327, 329
ssp. zanzibariensis 251, 331 , 333
gigantea 251, 253, 256, 327, 329, 330-333,
335, 336, 343, 349
lotus 249, 251
nucholi 251
odorata 253, 332
tetragona 251, 327, 329-333
Nymphaeaceae 243-245, 251, 252, 343-345
Nymphaeales 243-246, 248, 249, 251-254, 256,
259, 325, 327, 330-333, 335-341, 343-349
Nymphaeiflorae, superorder of Dicotyledoneae
243, 245
Nymphaeoideae, subfamily of Nymphaeaceae
243, 245
Ocotilla, section of Fouquieria 480, 481, 535
Oenothera brevipes 7
deltoides 4, 8
var. cognata 4, 11
dentata 152
Oligogonum, subgenus of Eriogonum 219
Olneya 491, 509
Onagraceae 75, 138 Munz, Philip A. California miscellany-VII. 65
-----
Three South American species of
Fuchsia 409
Munzothamnus blairii 80, 82, 371
Mycetopbagidae 180
Myoporaceae 68
Myoporum laetum 68
Myosmus minimus 90, 152
var. Fouquieria -
Continued australis 153
laevis 351-355
lemhiensis 352
pahutensis 351-355
pennellianus 352
speciosus 351, 352, 354, 355
spectabilis 6
wardii 352
Perityle emoryi 80
Persea americana 253, 258, 337
indica 258, 337
Petalonyx 523
Phaca leucopsis 75
Phacelia brachyloba 9
ciHata 4, 6
crenulata var. ambigua 232, 233, 240
curvipes 9
distans 81
floribunda 81
grandiAora 9
lyonii 75, 80
parryi 5
tanacetifolia 4, 6
viscida (not viscosa) 5
Phaeoptilum 421
Phalacridae 166
Phalarjs caroliniana 152, 154
Jemmonii 79, 90
minor 154
Pheucticus chrysopeplus 487
Philetaeria 480
horrida 501
Pholistoma aurihnn 80, 81
Phyllachne 13-16, 21 hybridum 69
Papaveraceae 69, 244, 250-252, 254, 259, 336,
339, 345 y
Papaveraceae 69, 244, 250-252, 254, 259, 336,
339, 345 ,
,
,
,
Nelumbonaceae 243-245, 251, 345 ,
Papavprales 244, 255, 325, 335, 349 ,
Papavprales 244, 255, 325, 335, 349 ,
NemophiJa maculata 6 p
Neobuxbaumia tetetzo 316 p
Neobuxbaumia tetetzo 316 Pardanthopsis, section of Iris 401, 403 Nerisyrenia 523 p
,
Parclanthopsis, subgenus of Iris 401, 403, 4 p
Parclanthopsis, subgenus of Iris 401, 403, y
N icotiana glauca 69 p
,
g
,
,
Pardanthopsis, subsection of Iris 401, 403 g
Nitidulidae 180 p
Pardanthopsis 401-403, 405-407 p
,
cUclwtoma 403, 405, 406 ,
Nupbar 245, 325, 327, 329, 331, 333, 335,
337-341, 343, 349
japonicum 341
luteum 327, 329, 332, 333
ssp. macrophyllum 249, 251, 327, 331, 333
ssp. polysepalum 251, 253, 256, 327, 329-
333, 335, 336, 343, 349
ssp. variegatum 251, 253, 327, 329-331,
333 337-341, 343, 349
japonicum 341
luteum 327, 329, 332, 333
ssp. macrophyllum 249, 251, 327, 331, 333
ssp. polysepalum 251, 253, 256, 327, 329-
333, 335, 336, 343, 349 p pp
Pectocarya linearis var. ferocula 79, 152 y
Pedilanthus 496, 531 p
y
p
' yctaginaceae 75, 201, 421 p
,
ssp. zanzibariensis 251, 331 , 333 Perityle emoryi 80 y
Phaca leucopsis 75 ,
,
,
,
,
Nymphaeiflorae, superorder of Dicotyledoneae
243, 245 p
Phacelia brachyloba 9
ciHata 4, 6
crenulata var. Fouquieria -
Continued apus 151, 154
patagonicus 152
Myrica 185
Myrtaceae 54
Myrtillocactus 521
Nama 523
Nasturtium officinale 92
Navarretia prostrata 151, 153, 154
Nelumbo 243-245, 248-254, 256, 258, 259, 325,
327, 329, 331, 333, 335, 337-340, 344,
346, 348, 349
lutea 246-249, 251- 253, 255-257, 259, 327,
329-331, 333, 335, 336, 341, 346
nucifera 1, 246-249, 251, 252, 255, 256, 259,
327, 331, 333, 336, 344
Nelumbonaceae 243-245, 251, 345
Nehm1bonales 244, 245, 344, 345
Nelumbonoideae, subfamily of Nymphaeaceae
243, 245
NemophiJa maculata 6
Neobuxbaumia tetetzo 316
Nerisyrenia 523
N icotiana glauca 69
Nitidulidae 180
Nitrangium, subgenus of Stylidium 14, 15, 58, 5~
Nomia 237, 238
Nupbar 245, 325, 327, 329, 331, 333, 335,
337-341, 343, 349
japonicum 341
luteum 327, 329, 332, 333
ssp. macrophyllum 249, 251, 327, 331, 333
ssp. polysepalum 251, 253, 256, 327, 329-
333, 335, 336, 343, 349
ssp. variegatum 251, 253, 327, 329-331,
333
polysepalum 250
' yctaginaceae 75, 201, 421
Nycteribiidae 180
Nympbaea 245
325
327
329
331
333
335 Mycetopbagidae 180 y
p
g
Myoporaceae 68 y p
Myoporum laetum 68 y
Oxybaphus pumilus 66 y
p
p
Pachycormus 531 y
Pacbypodium 4 79 Pachycereus 491
pectin-aboriginum 496
pringlei 496, 531 y
Myrtillocactus 521 p
g
,
Paeonia califomica 153, 255, 258, 337
33 p
g
Paeonia califomica 153, 255, 258, 337
delavayi 337
lutea 337
officinalis 337 Nasturtium officinale 92 Navarretia prostrata 151, 153, 154 Paeoniaceae 258, 259 Paeonia les 33 7 Papaver apulum var. micranthurn 69
californicum 251, 257, 339
hybridum 69 Papaver apulum var. micranthurn 69
californicum 251, 257, 339
hybridum 69
Papaveraceae 69, 244, 250-252, 254, 259,
339, 345
Papavprales 244, 255, 325, 335, 349
Paracolletes albopilosis 18
Parasitic plants 263
Parasphecodes hirsiventris 18
XPn:rclancancla 1wn·issU 407
Pardanthopsis, section of Iris 401, 403
Parclanthopsis, subgenus of Iris 401, 403, 40
Pardanthopsis, subsection of Iris 401, 403
Pardanthopsis 401-403, 405-407
cUclwtoma 403, 405, 406
Parclanthus 403
clichotomus 401, 403
Parietaria fbridann 81
Parolinia 183, 366, 367, 377, 381, 382
ornata 370, 373, 375-377, 379, 381, 383
Parthenium 509
Pectis papposa 9
Pectocarya linearis var. ferocula 79, 152
Pedilanthus 496, 531
Pelargonium 479
Penstemon 351
cordifolius 76
cyaneus 352
heterophyllus 6
ssp. Fouquieria -
Continued texana 79, 152 Meconella denticulata 15 ,
Liquidambar styraciRua 258, 337 Medicago sativa 337 Liquidambar styraciRua 258, 337 q
y
,
Llriodendron tulipifera 251, 255, 338, 343 g
Megachilidae 231, 238, 534 p
Lithophragma affinis 337 Melaleuca 26, 36, 43
li
i
f
81 p
g
Lobelia 137, 479 Melica imperfecta 81 ,
Lobelioideae, tribe of Campanulaceae p
Mentha citrata 75 X piperita 7 5 ,
,
Lolium temulentum 154 Lolium temulentum 154 p p
Mentzelia laevicaulis 9 Mentzelia laevicaulis 9
lindleyi 6 Mentzelia laevicaulis 9
lindleyi 6
M
b
th
difl
337 Lomatium insulare 81
utriculatum 153 y
Mesembryanthemum nodiflorum 337 y
Mesembryanthemum nodiflorum 337 y
Mesovelia 167, 174
furcata 165
mulsanti 167, 168, 172, 174, 181
vittigera 165 Lonicera hispidula 80- 82
var. vaciUans 74, 75
subspicata var. johnstonii 75, 153 Lonicera hispidula 80- 82
var. vaciUans 74, 75
subspicata var. johnstonii 75, 153 Mesovelia 167, 174
furcata 165
mulsanti 167, 168, 172, 174, 181
vittigera 165 p
j
Lophocereus 491 , 531 p
j
Lophocereus 491 , 531
341 g
Mesoveliidae 165, 167, 168, 172, 174 Lotus, subgenus of Nymphaea 341
L
h ll
i h
80 g
y
p
Lotus argophyllus ssp. ornithopus 80 Lotus argophyllus ssp. ornithopus 80
grandiflorus 75
scoparius 9
strigosus 81
subpinnatus 152 Microseris 79
dougasii ssp. platycarpha 79
h eterocarpa 79-81
linearifolia 79
Mi
t
i
iH
152 p
Ludwigia peploides 90 Mimosa 487
Mi
l
d pallidum var. oligospermum 363 Lycopersicum peruvianum 71 Lycopersicum peruvianum 71
L
id
f
il
f H Lygaeoidea, superfamily of H emiptera 165 Lygaeoidea, superfamily of H emiptera 165 Lygaeoidea, superfamily of H e
L
h
fl
ib
d
337 Lyonothamnus floribundus 337
ssp. floribundus 76, 78 Lythrum byssopifolia 88, J 51, 152 Machaerantbera cane.o;;cens 65
6 Muilla 313
maritima 90
purpusii 313 Machaerocereus 499
M
idi
f li i Macropidia fuliginosa 43 565 JULY 20, 1972] INDEX Munz, Philip A. California miscellany-VII. 65
-----
Three South American species of
Fuchsia 409
Munzothamnus blairii 80, 82, 371
Mycetopbagidae 180
Myoporaceae 68
Myoporum laetum 68
Myosmus minimus 90, 152
var. var. brevissimus 88, 92, tenellus var. tenellus 79-81 Fouquieria -
Continued capillaceus 88, 92
californicus 88, 251, 339
hebecarpus 76 aethopica 285
herteri 270, 275, 285-287 ,
,
hlanchetii 272, 285 p
Rauwenhoffia leichhardtii 338, 343 p
Rauwenhoffia leichhardtii 338, 343 ,
caulotreti 285 Fouquieria -
Continued 343
Polygonaceae 69, 217, 357
Polygonum 69
cuspidatum 69
sachalinense 69
Polypodium californictrnl 82
Polypogon 77
'ien.1iverticillatus 77
Potamogeton 90, 94
foliosus 92, 154
pusillus 88, 94
Prosopis 346, 491, 496, 509, 533, 54fl
chilensis 34 7
juliflora 337, 347
Prolh"anclromyces 174, 179, 181
comiculatus 177, 181
vez.iae 175, 177, 181
Pnmus 76 Rafflesia 270, 279, 286
arnoldii 263, 286
palma 270, 275, 279, 286
rochussenii 283 Phy llachne - Continued
colensoi 13, 16
uliginosa 13 g
Phylloglossum 16 Raffiesiaceae 263, 267, 268, 286 ,
,
,
Raffiesieae, tribe of Raffiesiaceae 263 ,
,
,
Raffiesieae, tribe of Raffiesiaceae 263 Rafinesquia californica 81 Rafinesquia californica 81 americana 337
Picea nigra 267
Pillwort 149, 151, 154
Pilostyles 263, 265, 267-270, 272, 275,
285, 287
aethopica 285
herteri 270, 275, 285-287
hlanchetii 272, 285
caulotreti 285
hamiltonii 268
haussknechtii 268, 285
hoitzii 285
ingae 268-270, 272, 277, 279, 283, 2
thurberi 265, 267-270, 272, 275, 27
283, 285- 287
Pilularia 149, 151- 154
americana 90, 149, 151-154
Pimelea 58
Pinus 418
Pisonia 421
Pisum arvense 337
Pithecellobium 496, 529
Plagiobothrys acanthocarpus 90
canescens 79
californicus var. gracilis 79
nothofulvus 88
undulatus 88, 151, 154
Plantaginaceae 183
Plantago 183
bigelovii 151, 154
ssp. bigelovii 92
ssp. califomica 88, 92, 94
corona pus 7 4
erecta 79, 90, 92
fastigiata 81
insularis 81
Platanus racemosa 6, 92
Plumeria 529
Poa annua 77
Poaceae 69
PodophylJum emodi 258, 339, 343
peltatum 258, 339, 343
Pogiris, section of Iris 401
Pvgogyne abramsii 90
Poleomoniales 439
Pollination mechanisms in Salvia 231
Polvalthia nitidissima 338. 343
Polygonaceae 69, 217, 357
Polygonum 69
cuspidatum 69
sachalinense 69
Polypodium californictrnl 82
Polypogon 77
'ien.1iverticillatus 77
Potamogeton 90, 94
foliosus 92, 154
pusillus 88, 94
Prosopis 346, 491, 496, 509, 533, 54fl
chilensis 34 7
juliflora 337, 347
Prolh"anclromyces 174, 179, 181
comiculatus 177, 181
vez.iae 175, 177, 181
Pnmus 76
virginiana 337
Pselaphidae 166
Pseudosmodingium 485, 487
Psilocarpbus brevissimus 152
var. brevissimus 88, 92, 151, 154
tenellus var. tenellus 79-81
Pterostegia drymarioides 81
Pthiria albocapitis 18
Purshia glandulosa 363
Quercus dumosa 75
engelmannii 86 Ranunculaceae 69, 244, 250-252, 256, 259,
336, 339, 345 ,
,
Rununculales 245, 254, 325, 335,
344-346, 349 ,
,
Rununculales 245, 254, 325, 335, ,
344-346, 349 ,
Ranunculus aquatilis var. Pterostegia drymarioides 81 Pterostegia drymarioides 81 Fouquieria -
Continued ambigua 232, 233, 240
curvipes 9
distans 81
floribunda 81
grandiAora 9
lyonii 75, 80
parryi 5
tanacetifolia 4, 6
viscida (not viscosa) 5 ,
Nymphaeoideae, subfamily of Nymphaeaceae
243, 245 Oligogonum, subgenus of Eriogonum 21 g g
,
g
g
Olneya 491, 509 y
,
Onagraceae 75, 138 (
Phaeoptilum 421 g
,
Ophioglossum californicum 90 p
g
Opuntia 77, 496, 499, 519, 521, 529, 531
acanthocarpa 233
basilaris 337
01icola 81 0
8
Orcuttia califomica 90
var. californica 151, 154 Pheucticus chrysopeplus 487 cuttia califomica 90
var. californica 151, 154 y
Philetaeria 480 ,
Oregonium, subgenus of Eriogonum 222, 224 horrida 501
Pholistoma aurihnn 80, 81 Oregonium, subgenus of Eriogonum 222, 224
Oreostylidium 13-16, 21
su hula tum 16 g
,
g
g
Oreostylidium 13-16, 21
su hula tum 16 o sto
a au
80,
Phyllachne 13-16, 21 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 [VoL. 7, No. 4 ALISO 566 Phy llachne - Continued
colensoi 13, 16
uliginosa 13
Phylloglossum 16
Phyllospadix scouleri 79
torreyi 79
Phytolacca 4 79
americana 337
Picea nigra 267
Pillwort 149, 151, 154
Pilostyles 263, 265, 267-270, 272, 275, 276,
285, 287
aethopica 285
herteri 270, 275, 285-287
hlanchetii 272, 285
caulotreti 285
hamiltonii 268
haussknechtii 268, 285
hoitzii 285
ingae 268-270, 272, 277, 279, 283, 285, 286
thurberi 265, 267-270, 272, 275, 277, 279
283, 285- 287
Pilularia 149, 151- 154
americana 90, 149, 151-154
Pimelea 58
Pinus 418
Pisonia 421
Pisum arvense 337
Pithecellobium 496, 529
Plagiobothrys acanthocarpus 90
canescens 79
californicus var. gracilis 79
nothofulvus 88
undulatus 88, 151, 154
Plantaginaceae 183
Plantago 183
bigelovii 151, 154
ssp. bigelovii 92
ssp. califomica 88, 92, 94
corona pus 7 4
erecta 79, 90, 92
fastigiata 81
insularis 81
Platanus racemosa 6, 92
Plumeria 529
Poa annua 77
Poaceae 69
PodophylJum emodi 258, 339, 343
peltatum 258, 339, 343
Pogiris, section of Iris 401
Pvgogyne abramsii 90
Poleomoniales 439
Pollination mechanisms in Salvia 231
Polvalthia nitidissima 338. g
Regnellidium 149 malacophylla 153 ,
Plantaginaceae 183 p y
Rhync.hangium, section of subgenus Nitrangiu_m
of Stylidium 14, 15 y
g
,
of Stylidium 14, 1 y
Ribes califomicmn 337 Romanschulzia 365-367, 383 ,
Rorippa nasturtium-aquaticun1 77 Platanus racemosa 6, 92 Plumeria 529 Poa annua 77 PodophylJum emodi 258, 339, 34
peltatum 258, 339, 343 PodophylJum emodi 258, 339, 343 PodophylJum emodi 258, 3
peltatum 258, 339, 343 p y
,
peltatum 258, 339, 343 p
,
,
Pogiris, section of Iris g
Pvgogyne abramsii 90 g gy
Poleomoniales 439 Pollination mechanisms in Salvia 231 p
Rutherford, Robert James
Th e a n a tom y and
cytology of Pilostyles thurberi Gray
( Raffiesiaceae) 263 Polvalthia nitidissima 338. 343 Polygonaceae 69, 217, 357 yg
cuspidatum 69 p
sachalinense 69 Polypodium californictrnl 82 yp
Polypogon 77 yp g
'ien.1iverticillatus 77 p
yp y
Saldidae 165 Potamogeton 90, 94
foliosus 92, 154
pusillus 88, 94 Potamogeton 90, 94
foliosus 92, 154
pusillus 88, 94 Salicomia 425 p
,
Prosopis 346, 491, 496, 509, 533, 54fl
chilensis 34 7
juliflora 337, 347 j
,
Prolh"anclromyces 174, 17
comiculatus 177, 181
vez.iae 175, 177, 181 j
,
Prolh"anclromyces 174, 179, 181 ,
ssp. dorrii 231. 233, 235, 237, 240 virginiana 337 g
Regnellidium 149 g
Regnellidium 149 g
Regnellidium 149 g
Repentes, section of subgenus Stylidium of
Stylidium 30 y
Reveal, James L. A n ew a nnu a l Eriogonum
( Polygonaceae) from southern Nevada and
adjacent California 357 ,
Pilularia 149, 151- 154 ,
americana 90, 149, 151-154 j
--- - -
Additional notes on the California buck-
wheats ( Eriogonurn, Polygonaceae) 217 j
--- - -
Additional notes on the California buck-
wheats ( Eriogonurn, Polygonaceae) 217 Pimelea 58 wheats ( Eriogonurn, Polygonaceae) 217
----- Two new species of Eriogonum ( Poly-
gonaceae ) from C a liforni a and adjacent
states 415
--- -- see Barneby and Reveal 361
Rhamnus 76
Rhoedales 243
Rhus 74
integrifolia 7 4, 75
ovata 74
triiobata var. malacophylla 153
Rhync.hangium, section of subgenus Nitrangiu_m
of Stylidium 14, 15
Ribes califomicmn 337
roezlii 337
Ricinus communis 69
Romanschulzia 365-367, 383
Rorippa nasturtium-aquaticun1 77
Rosa gymnocarpa 337
Rosales 337
Rota Ia ramosior 90
Rubus ursinus 74
Ruellia 499
Rumex conglomeratus 76
crispus 92
salicifolius 76
Ruppia cirrhosa 77
maritima 77
spiralis 77
Rutherford, Robert James
Th e a n a tom y and
cytology of Pilostyles thurberi Gray
( Raffiesiaceae) 263
Sagina occidentalis 153
Sagittaria 250
lancifolia 251, 340
latifolia 251, 340, 343
platyphylla 251, 340
Saldidae 165
Salicomia 425
Salvia 74, 231, 233, 236-241
apiana 75, 231
carduacea 9, 231-241
columbariae 6, 81, 207, 211- 21 3, 215, 216,
231, 232, 234-238, 241
dorrii 232-235, 237- 241
ssp. dorrii 231. 233, 235, 237, 240
ssp. gilmanii 363
mellifera 74, 75, 231
patens 239, 240
spathacea 7
parvifloms 90
San Clemente Island 73
Sanicula arguta 74, 80
crassicaulis 152
laciniata 74
Santa Catalina Island 73
Santa Rosa Plateau 153
Saxifraga califomica 94, 337 (
g
,
yg
)
----- Two new species of Eriogonum ( Poly-
gonaceae ) from C a liforni a and adjacent
states 415 (
g
,
yg
)
----- Two new species of Eriogonum ( Poly-
gonaceae ) from C a liforni a and adjacent
states 415 Pisum arvense 337
Pithecellobium 496, 529 --- -- see Barneby and Reveal 361
Rhamnus 76 --- -- see Barneby and Reveal 361 Rhoedales 243 Rhus 74
integrifolia 7 4, 75
ovata 74
triiobata var. malacophylla 153 ovata
triiobata var. g
Pselaphidae 166 g
Pselaphidae 166 p
Pseudosmodingium 485, 487 g
Psilocarpbus brevissimus 152 g
Psilocarpbus brevissimus 152
var
brevissimus 88
92 p
var. brevissimus 88, 92, 151, 15 JULY 20, 1972] diuroides 40
ssp. nanum. 39, 40
diversifolium 34, 43
elongatum 21, 60
emarginahnn 30
ssp. decipiens 30, 31
ssp. emarginahtm 31
ericksonae 22
exoglossurn 20
falcatum 16
fasciculatum var. elongatum 15
galioides 18, 21, 58
glanduliferum 47, 59
glandulosum 15
glaucum 38, 43
ssp. angustifoUum 39, 40
hispidum 46
humphreysi-i 48, 50
imbricatum 14, 15, 18, 22
insensitivtnn 19, · 20, 26, 27, 28
inundatum 18, 20, 22, 24, 26
inversiflorum 18, 32, 40, 42, 43
junceum 32, 34, 40
ssp. b·revius 32, 34
ssp. junceu1n 32, 34
var. brevius 32
laciniatum 32, 34
laricifolium 15
lepidum 41, 42
ssp. glaucifolium 41
leptocalyx 52, 54, 56
limbatun1 48
lineatum 19
longibracteatu1n 37, 49, 50
longituburn 24
luteum 36
ssp. clava.tum 36
ssp. glaucifolitt1n 36, 41
var. glandulosum 38
macranthum 18, 50, 52, 54, 56
macrocarpum 58, 61
maitlandianmn 43, 44
miniatum 46
nungadnense 54, 56
obh1satum 26-28, 30, 31
var. rubricalyx 28
pedunculatum 22
perisceliantbum 27
perpusillum 14, 18, 32, 42
petiolare 16, 20, 28, 30
piliferum 40, 46, 48
ssp. 1ninar 40 Seed germination 207 Seed germination 207 Seed longevity 1 Selinocarpus .523 Serology, comparative 243, 325 Silene laciniata 153, 337 Simon, Jean-Pierre
Comparative serology of the
order Nyn1phaeales. I. Preliminary survey
on the relationships of N elum bo 243
----- Comparative serology of the order Nym-
phaeales. II. Relationships of Nymphaeaceae
and Nelumbonaceae 325 var. proliferum 15
crassifolium 21, 60, 61
l
60 Sinaptidendron 183, 366, 377, 383
angustifolimn 367, 370, 374, 375, 377, 379
frutescens 367, 368, 370
rupestre var. chaetocalyx 370 p
ssp. nanum. 39, 40
diversifolium 34, 43
elongatum 21, 60
emarginahnn 30
d
i i
30
31 p
y
Sisymbdeae, tribe of Brassicaceae 366
Si
b i
ffi i
l
74
90 Sisymbdeae, tribe of Brassicaceae 366 y
,
Sisymbrium officinale 74, 90 Sisymbrium officinale 74, 90 Sisyrinchium bellun1 4, 8, 90
1
183
3 5 Sisyrinchium bellun1 4, 8, 90
Solanaceae 71, 183, 375
Solanum clokeyi 76
wallacei ssp . clokeyi 76
ssp. wallacei 76, 78
xanti 76, 153
Sonchus 137, 183
oleraceus 81
Sonderella, section of subgenus Nitrangium of
Stylidium 58
Sparsifoliae, section
of subgenus Stylidium of
Stvlidium 15
Specios.i, series of Penstemon 351, 352
Spergularia bocconii 79, 153
macrotheca 80
villosa 80
Squamosae. g
y
Pthiria albocapitis 18 g
y
Pthiria albocapitis 18 p
Purshia glandulosa 363 g
Quercus dumosa 75 g
Quercus dumosa 75 Saxifraga califomica 94, 337 567 JULY 20, 1972] JULY 20, 1972] INDEX Saxifragaceae 14
Saxifragales 337
Saxifragoideae, section. of subgenus Stylidimn of
Stylidium 36, 42
Scaevola 36, 185, 196, 382
Scheuchzeriaceae 94
Schisandra 345, 348, 349
chinensis 337
glabra 255, 258, 337
rubiflora 337
Schisandraceae 254, 258, 259, 345
Schisandrales 336
Scolymus hi.spanicus 66
Seed germination 207
Seed longevity 1
Selinocarpus .523
Senecio 137, 479
lvonii 82
Serology, comparative 243, 325
Sida hederacea 92
leprosa var
hederacea 88
92 Stylidium - Continued
arenicola 46, 48
asteroideum 28, 30
barleei 16
beaugleholei 19, 20, 23, 24, 26, 27
bolgartense 28, 30
brachyphyllum 22
hrunonianwn 34, 40, 43
ssp. brunonianum 40
ssp. minor 40
var. minor 40
bulbiferum 15, 18
calcaratum 14, 17, 18, 22, 32, 42
var. calcaratum 22
var. ecome 19, 22
caricifolium 16, 19, 54, 56
ssp. affine 56, 57
ssp. caricifolitnn 56
ssp. nu.nga1"inense 54, 56
carnosum 34, 43
ceonioides 44
choreantbum 18, 32, 42
ciliabnn 21
corymbulosum 42, 54
var. proliferum 15
crassifolium 21, 60, 61
ssp. elongatum 60
despechnn 18, 20, 22, 26
dispermurn 46
diuroides 40, 42, 43
ssp. diuroides 40
ssp. nanum. 39, 40
diversifolium 34, 43
elongatum 21, 60
emarginahnn 30
ssp. decipiens 30, 31
ssp. emarginahtm 31
ericksonae 22
exoglossurn 20
falcatum 16
fasciculatum var. elongatum 15
galioides 18, 21, 58
glanduliferum 47, 59
glandulosum 15
glaucum 38, 43
ssp. angustifoUum 39, 40
hispidum 46
humphreysi-i 48, 50
imbricatum 14, 15, 18, 22
insensitivtnn 19, · 20, 26, 27, 28
inundatum 18, 20, 22, 24, 26
inversiflorum 18, 32, 40, 42, 43
junceum 32, 34, 40
ssp. b·revius 32, 34
ssp. junceu1n 32, 34
var. brevius 32
laciniatum 32, 34
laricifolium 15
lepidum 41, 42
ssp. glaucifolium 41
leptocalyx 52, 54, 56
limbatun1 48
lineatum 19
longibracteatu1n 37, 49, 50
longituburn 24
luteum 36
ssp. clava.tum 36
ssp. glaucifolitt1n 36, 41
var. glandulosum 38
macranthum 18, 50, 52, 54, 56
macrocarpum 58, 61
maitlandianmn 43, 44
miniatum 46
nungadnense 54, 56
obh1satum 26-28, 30, 31 Schisandraceae 254, 258, 259, 345 Schisandraceae 254, 258, 259, 345 Schisandrales 336 Scolymus hi.spanicus 66 Scolymus hi.spanicus 66 var. calcaratum 22
var. ecome 19, 22
caricifolium 16, 19, 54, 56
ssp. affine 56, 57
ssp. caricifolitnn 56
ssp. nu.nga1"inense 54, 56
carnosum 34, 43
ceonioides 44
choreantbum 18, 32, 42
ciliabnn 21
corymbulosum 42, 54
var. proliferum 15
crassifolium 21, 60, 61
ssp. elongatum 60
despechnn 18, 20, 22, 26
dispermurn 46
diuroides 40, 42, 43
ssp. JULY 20, 1972] section of subgenus
Sty1idium
of
Stylidium 50
Stackhousia 48
Stanleya 365, 366, 377, 379, 381
pinnata 365, 366, 368, 370, 373, 375, 377,
379-381, 383
Stanleyeae, tribe of Brassicaceae 365, 366
Staphylinidae 169, 179, 180
Stemmatomyces 179-181
Steninae, subfamily of Staphylinidae 179
Stenus 179
Stephanomeria blairii 371
Stigmatomyces 179, 180
Stigmatomyceteae, tribe of Laboulbeniaceae 179-
181
Stipa 79
pulchra 80
Stirlingia 44
Streblidae 180
Stylidiaceae 13-16, 19, 21, 137
Stylidium, section of subgenus Stylidium of Sty-
lidium 44
Stylidium, subgenus of Stylidium 22, 30, 32, 36,
44, 50
Stylidiuril 13-16, 18-22, 30, 34, 38, 42, 44,
46, 52, 56, 59, 60
aclpressum 15
aeonio-ides 43, 44, 45, 58
affine 56
a.lbomontis 18, 52, 56
nmoenum var. caulescens 15 Solanaceae 71, 183, 375
6 Sonderella, section of subgenus Nitrangium of
Stylidium 58 Sparsifoliae, section
of subgenus Stylidium of
Stvlidium 15
S
i
i
i
f P
351
352 Specios.i, series of Penstemon 351, 352 Squamosae. section of subgenus
Sty1idium
of
Stylidium 50
Stackhousia 48 Stanleyeae, tribe of Brassicaceae 365, 366
S
h li id
169
179
180 Staphylinidae 169, 179, 180 p y
Stemmatomyces 179-181 Steninae, subfamily of Staphylinidae 179 p
pulchra 80
S i li
i
44 var. glandulosum 38
macranthum 18, 50, 52, 54, 56
macrocarpum 58, 61
maitlandianmn 43, 44
miniatum 46
nungadnense 54, 56
obh1satum 26-28, 30, 31
b i
l
28 y
Stylidium, section of subgenus Stylidium of Sty-
lidium 44
S
lidi
b
f S
lidi
22
30
32
36 Stylidium, subgenus of Stylidium 22, 30, 32, 36,
44, 50
13 16
18 22
30
34
38
42
44 var. rubricalyx 28
pedunculatum 22
perisceliantbum 27
perpusillum 14, 18, 32, 42
petiolare 16, 20, 28, 30
piliferum 40, 46, 48
1 i
40 var. rubricalyx 28
pedunculatum 22
perisceliantbum 27
perpusillum 14, 18, 32, 42
petiolare 16, 20, 28, 30
piliferum 40, 46, 48
ssp
1ninar 40 a.lbomontis 18, 52, 56
nmoenum var. caulescens 15 ssp. 1ninar 40 [VoL. 7, No. 4 ALISO 568 Stylidium - Continued
var. minor 40
pilosum 18, 52, 53, 56
preissii 14, 15, 19, 22, 32, 54
pseudocaespitosun1 37
pseudohirsutum 18, 50, 52, 55
f. laevifolium 50
var. laevifolium 50
puhigerum 21 , 58
pulchellum 20, 30
pygmaemn 22, 24
1·eduplicahnn 52, 56
repens 15, 18, 20, 22, 30, 32
var. diplectroglossurn 32
var. sacculatum. JULY 20, 1972] 32
rhipidium 20, 23, 24, 26-28
rhynchocarpum 14, 15
rigidifolium 19
roseoalatum 18, 24, 25
roseona.ntun 24
ru hricalyx 28
sacculatum 19, 22, 30, 32
scandens 18, 22
schoenoides 19
spathulatum 38
ssp. a.cu.m.inatu:m 38
ssp. glanclulosunt 38
ssp. spathulatum 38
var. lehmannianmn 15, 38
spinulosum 18, 32, 42, 44
ssp. montanum. 44, 46
ssp. spinulosun1 45
squamellosum 33, 37, 43, 58
squantosotu.berosr.nn 34, 35
streptocarpum 58
striatum 34, 43
tenue 40
tenu.icarpmn 58, 60
trichopodum 22
uniAorum 18
utricu larioides 24
verticillahuu 18, 22
xanthopis 19, 24
yilgarnense 46, 59
zeicolor 37
Stylomecon heterophylla 251
339 Trichostema lanatum 9
TrifoHum amplectens var. amplectens 79
var. tmncatum 88, 92
gracilentum 79
palmeri 79, 80
tridentatum 80
variegatum 90
Tripterocalyx 422
Triteleia 137, 145, 157, 158, 323
clementina 79, 81, 159
crocea 159
var. modesta 159
grandiflora 159
guadalupensis 145-148
laxa 157-160
1ugens 14.5, 147
peduncularis 157-160
tubergenii 157, 158, 159, 160
Trochodendrales 337
Trochodendron 258
araloides 337
Typha 90
domingensis 77
latifolia 77
Typhales 34 7
Umhellularia 250, 259
caliJornica 250, 339, 343
Utricularia 26
Velia 177, 179, 181
osborniana 165
Veliidae 165-167, 177, 179, 181 Trichostema lanatum 9
TrifoHum amplectens var. amplectens 79
var. tmncatum 88, 92
gracilentum 79
palmeri 79, 80
tridentatum 80
variegatum 90
Tripterocalyx 422
Triteleia 137, 145, 157, 158, 323
clementina 79, 81, 159
crocea 159
var. modesta 159
grandiflora 159
guadalupensis 145-148
laxa 157-160
1ugens 14.5, 147
peduncularis 157-160
tubergenii 157, 158, 159, 160
Trochodendrales 337
Trochodendron 258
araloides 337
Typha 90
domingensis 77
latifolia 77
Typhales 34 7
Umhellularia 250, 259
caliJornica 250, 339, 343
Utricularia 26
Velia 177, 179, 181
osborniana 165
Veliidae 165-167, 177, 179, 181
Vella 366
Velleia 48
Veratrum 250, 259
album 251, 340, 343
nignnn 251, 340
Veronica americana 154
comosa 154
peregrina 152
ssp. xalapensis 151, 154
Verticordia 48
Victoria 245, 325, 327, 329, 331, 333, 337-3
343-345, 349
amazonica 251 , 253, 256, 327, 329-333, 3
336, 343, 349
cruziana 250, 251 , 253, 327, 329, 331, 3
335 Stylidium
Continued
var. minor 40
pilosum 18, 52, 53, 56
preissii 14, 15, 19, 22, 32, 54
pseudocaespitosun1 37
pseudohirsutum 18, 50, 52, 55 p
y
Triteleia 137, 145, 157, 158, 323
clementina 79, 81, 159
crocea 159
var. JULY 20, 1972] modesta 159
grandiflora 159
guadalupensis 145-148
laxa 157-160
1ugens 14.5, 147
peduncularis 157-160
tubergenii 157, 158, 159, 160 pyg
1·eduplicahnn 52, 56 1 eduplicahnn 52, 56
repens 15, 18, 20, 22, 30, 32 p
,
repens 15, 18, 20, 22, 30, 32
var. diplectroglossurn 32 p
,
,
,
,
,
var. diplectroglossurn 32 p
g
var. sacculatum. 32 var. sacculatum. 32
rhipidium 20, 23, 24, 26-28 p
,
,
,
rhynchocarpum 14, 15 g
roseoalatum 18, 24, 25 p
p
38
var. lehmannianmn 15, 38 var. lehmannianmn 15, 38
spinulosum 18, 32, 42, 44 ,
spinulosum 18, 32, 42, 44 p
,
,
,
ssp. montanum. 44, 46 Veratrum 250, 259
album 251, 340, 343
nignnn 251, 340 g
,
Veronica americana 154
comosa 154
peregrina 152
ssp. xalapensis 151, 154 Victoria 245, 325, 327, 329, 331, 333, 337-341,
343-345, 349 3 3 3 5, 3 9
amazonica 251 , 253, 256, 327, 329-333, 335,
336, 343, 349 ,
,
cruziana 250, 251 , 253, 327, 329, 331, 333,
335 Stylomecon heterophylla 251, 339 y
Suaeda 425 Suaeda 425
torreyana 2, 7 Viola pedunculata 80
J p
Visco, Frank J., and Brian Capon
Pollination
mechanisms in three species of Salvia na-
tive to southern California 231 y
,
Synandmmyces 179, 180 y
y
Syntrichopappus 66 Syntrichopappus 66
lemmonii 66 Syntrichopappus
lemmonii 66 y
p pp
lemmonii 66 Went, F. W. A long term test of seed longev-
ity. II. 1 Tamariscaceae 97 Tamaricales 439 y
WHken, Dieter H. A nornenclatural revision of
the Hulsea vestita complex 413 Tanacetum camphoratum 7 p
Tasmannia purpurascens 338, 343 Tasmannia purpurascens 338, 343
xerophila 338 p
Wilson, Ruth C. Ahronia : I. Distribution, ecol-
ogy and habit of nine species of Abronia
fOtmd in California 421
----- The rediscovery of Abronia alpina, a
rare specialized endemic of sandy meadows
in southern Sierra Nevada, California 201
Wi t
254
338 p
Tetracentron 258 Tetrandromyces 171 y
Tetratheca 36 Thalictmm polycarpum 251, 339 Thorne, Robert F. A supplement to the floras of
Santa Catalina and San Clemente Islands,
Los Angeles County, California 73
-----
and Earl W. JULY 20, 1972] Lathrop
A vernal marsh
on 'the Santa Ro s a Plateau of Riverside
County, California 85
-----, an(l ----- Pilularia americana on the
Santa Rosa Plateau, Riverside County, Cali-
fornia 149 ,
Winterineae, suborder of Annonales 345
Xanthorrhoea 38 ,
Winterineae, suborder of Annonales 345 ,
Winterineae, suborder of Annonales 345 ,
Xanthorrhoea 38 Xylococcus hicolor 75 californica arizonensis 237, 238, 514
Xyris 40 y
Yellow grosbeak 487 Thyrsiforn1es, section of subgenus Nitrangium of
Stylidium 59 Yucca 252, 348, 496, 509, 521
breviflora 232, 251 , 340
valida 531
whipplei 251, 255, 257, 340 Yucca 252, 348, 496, 509, 521
breviflora 232, 251 , 340
valida 531
whipplei 251, 255, 257, 340 y
Thysanocarpus laciniatus 76 y
Thysanocarpus laciniatus 76 Tomoderus 166
forticornis 166 pp
,
,
,
Zannichellia palustris 90, 152, 154 Torilis nodosa 7 4, 76 Torilis nodosa 7 4, 76 p
Zauschneria califomica ssp. mexicana 8
i
9 ,
Toxicodendron 76 Zostera marina 77, 79 Toxicodendron 76 radicans ssp. diversilobum 74, 81 radicans ssp. diversilobum 74, 81 Zygadenus fremontii 258, 340, 343 Triandromyces 171 Triandromyces 171 RANCHO SANTA ANA BOTANIC GARDEN Dedication of Garden Foundation to the Board of Trustees for the
Rancho Santa Ana Botanic Garden of the Native Plants of California: "The Nature, Object and Purpose of the Institution hereby Founded
and to be Maintained Hereunder: "Its Nature: A botanic garden of the native plants of California, her-
barium and botanical library, containing living and/or preserved speci-
mens of trees, plants and flowers native to California, and literature
relating thereto. "Its Object: The preservation and improvement of the property now
transferred and such property as may hereafter be transferred to the
Trustees for those who not only wish to enjoy, but to study, assembled
in one accessible locality, native California plants; and for the advance-
ment of science and education with reference to plant life indigenous
to the State of California. "Its Purpose: (a) An institution founded primarily for scientific re-
search in the field of local botany. (b) To preserve the native California flora, try to replenish the depleted
supply of some of the rarest plants which are rapidly being exterminated,
and bring together in a comparatively small area as complete a collec-
tion of the rich store of native California plants as can be grown in this
southern section of the state, thereby promoting the general welfare of
the people of the state by providing the means for encouraging and carry-
ing on the above mentioned activities in said state and by doing such
other things as may be necessary and desirable to carry out the objects
thereof."
|
https://openalex.org/W3181683803
|
https://ojmo.centre-mersenne.org/item/10.5802/ojmo.14.pdf
|
English
| null |
Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method
|
Open journal of mathematical optimization
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 22,948
|
creening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Metho Yifan Sun
Stonybrook University - Department of Computer Science, Stonybrook, New York, USA
yifan.sun@stonybrook.edu Yifan Sun
Stonybrook University - Department of Computer Science, Stonybrook, New York, USA
yifan.sun@stonybrook.edu Francis Bach
INRIA - Département d’Informatique de l’Ecole Normale Supérieure PSL Research University Paris, France
francis.bach@inria.fr Abstract The conditional gradient method (CGM) is widely used in large-scale sparse convex optimization, having a low per
iteration computational cost for structured sparse regularizers and a greedy approach for collecting nonzeros. We explore
the sparsity acquiring properties of a general penalized CGM (P-CGM) for convex regularizers and a reweighted
penalized CGM (RP-CGM) for nonconvex regularizers, replacing the usual convex constraints with gauge-inspired
penalties. This generalization does not increase the per-iteration complexity noticeably. Without assuming bounded
iterates or using line search, we show O(1/t) convergence of the gap of each subproblem, which measures distance to a
stationary point. We couple this with a screening rule which is safe in the convex case, converging to the true support at
a rate O(1/(δ2)) where δ ≥0 measures how close the problem is to degeneracy. In the nonconvex case the screening rule
converges to the true support in a finite number of iterations, but is not necessarily safe in the intermediate iterates. In
our experiments, we verify the consistency of the method and adjust the aggressiveness of the screening rule by tuning
the concavity of the regularizer. Digital Object Identifier 10.5802/ojmo.14 Keywords Dual screening, conditional gradient method, atomic sparsity, reweighted optimization. Acknowledgments This work was funded in part by the French government under management of Agence Nationale de la
Recherche as part of the “Investissements d’avenir” program, reference ANR-19-P3IA-0001 (PRAIRIE 3IA Institute). We
also acknowledge support the European Research Council (grant SEQUOIA 724063). The first is also funded in part by
AXA pour la recherche and Kamet Ventures, as well as a Google focused award. © Yifan Sun & Francis Bach;
licensed under Creative Commons License Attribution 4.0 International Open Journal of
Mathematical
Optimization Yifan Sun & Francis Bach
Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method
Volume 3 (2022), article no. 3 (35 pages) Article submitted on December 6, 2021, revised on May 20, 2022,
accepted on June 10, 2022. This article is licensed under the
CREATIVE COMMONS ATTRIBUTION 4.0 INTERNATIONAL LICENSE. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This article is licensed under the
CREATIVE COMMONS ATTRIBUTION 4.0 INTERNATIONAL LICENSE. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This article is licensed under the
CREATIVE COMMONS ATTRIBUTION 4.0 INTERNATIONAL LICENSE. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ ENTRE
ERSENNE
Open Journal of Mathematical Optimization is a member of the
Centre Mersenne for Open Scientific Publishing
http://www.centre-mersenne.org/ Open Journal of Mathematical Optimization is a member of the
Centre Mersenne for Open Scientific Publishing
http://www.centre-mersenne.org/ 1.1.1
Conditional gradient method When h(s) = ιP(s) the indicator for s in P, the proposed method is the conditional gradient method (CGM)
[24, 29]. Also called the Frank-Wolfe method, it has been studied since the 50s and was revitalized recently [39]
for its success at quickly estimating solutions to sparse optimization problems. Because this foundational method
serves as a baseline, we will refer to it as the “vanilla CGM”. This method is particularly useful when the computation of the supporting hyperplane in the (Min-Maj) step
is cheap (e.g., when P is the unit ball of the ℓ1-norm or a group norm). Much work has come from expanding
its use to general (atomic) norms [20, 38, 39, 62] with many variations such as backward steps [42, 59] and
fully-corrective steps [65]. Many connections between the CGM and existing methods have also been discovered,
such as to mirror descent [2], cutting plane method [72], and greedy coordinate-wise methods [20]. In its simplest
version (with no away-steps, line search, or strongly convex assumptions on f or P) the minimum duality gap in
CGM converges at rate O(1/t) [24]. 1.1.2
Convex gauge function When γ(cp) = cp, we define κP(x) := rP(x), which reduces to the usual convex gauge function for the closed
convex set P [30, 60]. Gauge functions can be seen as generalized versions of the ℓ1-norm, which is a convex
promoter of nonzero vector sparsity, and include penalties like the total variation (TV) norm, nuclear norm,
OWL norm [71], OSCAR norm [6], and general conic constraints. Several works have looked at optimization
over general gauges [30, 32] and in particular for sparse optimization [15, 39]. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method In particular, we solve (1) using the following iteration scheme s(t) = argmin
s∈Rd
∇f(x(t))T s + h(t)(s),
(Min-Maj)
x(t+1) = (1 −θ(t))x(t) + θ(t)s(t),
(Merge) s(t) = argmin
s∈Rd
∇f(x(t))T s + h(t)(s), (Min-Maj) x(t+1) = (1 −θ(t))x(t) + θ(t)s(t), (Merge) where h(t)(s) is a local convexification of φ(rP(s)) at x(t). We call this the reweighted penalized conditional
gradient method (RP-CGM), as it resembles both the conditional gradient method (CGM) in sparse convex
optimization and reweighting schemes in majorization-minorization methods for nonconvex optimization. ▶Example 1. The ℓ1 norm is formed by picking P0 = {±e1, . . . , ±ed} the signed unit bases, and γ(ξ) = ξ. Then
the solution to (2) is always unique and can be expressed in closed form as rP(x) = ∥x∥1. Picking instead a
concave penalty γ(ξ) = 2√ξ leads to the variation rP(x) = 2 P
i
p
|xi| the “half norm”. Similar transformations
also lead to the smoothed capped absolute deviation (SCAD) penalty, minimum concave penalty (MCP), etc. (See Table 1.) By using a generalized convex aggregate penalty φ, we can sweep the space between constrained and
unconstrained problems, via the penalty’s tunable curvature: maximum curvature reduces to the usual constrained
problem, and minimum curvature to the usual LASSO penalty problem. The addition of the nonconvex elementwise
term γ strengthens the sparsifying behavior. However, because of the sometimes erratic way that the conditional
gradient method picks step directions, simple implementations of these features easily lead to divergence. Therefore, a main contribution of this work is to identify carefully the conditions on φ and γ such that these two
modified CGMs perform optimally. The other main contribution of this work concerns safe screening, in which the variable search space is
reduced dynamically by identifying which components will safely not appear in the converged solution. For
example, in nonzero sparsity, we identify early on the indices i in which we are guaranteed that x∗
i = 0, in
hopes of prematurely estimating the solution sparsity pattern. This technique is intended to reduce memory and
computational cost. 1
Introduction Conditional gradient methods (CGMs) are used in constrained optimization to quickly arrive at sparse solutions
of large-scale optimization problems. In this paper, we generalize their applicability to nonconvex penalized
(unconstrained) problems and investigate safe screening methods to obtain sparse supports in finite time. We
describe these problems as minimize
x∈Rd
f(x) + φ(rP(x)), (1) (1) where f : Rd →R is a convex loss function with an L-Lipschitz continuous gradient, φ : R+ →R is a strictly
convex monotonically increasing function, and rP : Rd →R+ a nonconvex variant of a gauge function, defined
as the solution to rP(x) = min
cp≥0
X
p∈P0
γ(cp)p :
X
p∈P0
cpp = x
P(x) = min
cp≥0
X
p∈P0
γ(cp)p :
X
p∈P0
cpp = x
(2) (2) for some concave monotonically increasing function γ : R+ →R+. Here, P0 is a finite collection of vectors in
Rd. In the usual nonzero sparsity case, this penalty reduces to well-studied nonconvex penalties like SCAD,
LSP, or p-“norms” for 0 < p < 1. Problems of this form arise in machine learning, compressed sensing, low-rank
matrix factorization, etc., and are often observed in practice to be more effective sparsifiers than their convex
relaxations [17]. for some concave monotonically increasing function γ : R+ →R+. Here, P0 is a finite collection of vectors in
Rd. In the usual nonzero sparsity case, this penalty reduces to well-studied nonconvex penalties like SCAD,
LSP, or p-“norms” for 0 < p < 1. Problems of this form arise in machine learning, compressed sensing, low-rank
matrix factorization, etc., and are often observed in practice to be more effective sparsifiers than their convex
relaxations [17]. Volume 3 (2022), article no. 3 Volume 3 (2022), article no. 3 2 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 3 bounded assumptions on iterates [2], or with improvement steps to ensure boundedness of sublevel sets [36, 69]. When f is quadratic and for a special form of φ, the P-CGM can be shown to be equivalent to a form of the
iterative shrinkage method, and under proper problem conditioning, has linear convergence [9, 10]. bounded assumptions on iterates [2], or with improvement steps to ensure boundedness of sublevel sets [36, 69]. When f is quadratic and for a special form of φ, the P-CGM can be shown to be equivalent to a form of the
iterative shrinkage method, and under proper problem conditioning, has linear convergence [9, 10]. 1.1.6
Safe screening A screening rule returns an estimate of the support of x∗given a noisy approximation x. The screening rule
is safe if there are no false positives (and called sure if there are no false negatives). Safe screening rules for
LASSO were first proposed by [25], and have since been extended to a number of smooth losses and generalized
penalties [7, 28, 46, 49, 51, 66]. An interesting related work is the “stingy coordinate descent” method [40]
for LASSO, which optimizes the sparse regularized problem in a CGM-like manner, but uses screening to
dynamically skip steps; this kind of method can be extended to P-CGM as well for generalized atoms. In
nonconvex optimization, support recovery is discussed by [12] for handling nonlinear constraints which are
iteratively linearized, and screening rules by [58] are proposed for a reweighted proximal gradient method. 1.1.5
Applications A main use case of CGMs is in finding generalized sparse solutions to convex losses [15, 39], where the ℓ1-norm
penalty, which promotes element-wise sparsity [13, 14, 22, 63], is generalized to gauge functions that promote
sparsity with respect to “atoms”, or low dimensional facets of a convex set. This generalizes sparse optimization to
applications such as low-rank matrix optimization [31, 69] and grouped feature extraction [6, 64, 71]. Additionally,
these atoms may be feasible solutions to combinatorial problems, such as in submodular optimization [1] and
object tracking [16]. CGM has also been applied to a variety of machine learning tasks, such as graphical
models [41], multitask learning [61], SVMs [43], particle filtering [44], and deep learning [5, 57]. 1.1.3
Penalized CGM When h(t)(s) is a convex penalty, we refer to the proposed method as the penalized CGM (P-CGM). Compared to
CGM, P-CGM has been much less studied [36, 50, 69], and has appeared under different names, like regularized
coordinate minimization [23]. An O(1/t) convergence rate has been shown for specific smooth functions [50], with 1.1.4
Reweighted methods for nonconvex minimization Our main algorithmic novelty is to solve a sequence of reweighted penalized CGM (RP-CGM) iterations in
order to accommodate nonlinear γ, which appear in nonconvex penalties like SCAD or MCP penalties in
difference-of-convex or majorization-minimization methods. This results in a nonconvex penalty h(x), which in
practice have been shown to have superior sensing properties [17, 21, 26, 33, 48, 56, 67, 68]. We leverage these
observations to improve the screening properties of RP-CGM; by increasing the concavity of γ, we can create an
aggressive support recovery method based on an easily computable duality-gap-like residual. 2
Reweighted Penalized CGM for simple sparse recovery In this section, we introduce the RP-CGM over problems intending to regularize for nonzero elementwise sparsity. The goal is to present a simple implementation of the full method, to clearly describe the implementation
and screening steps, and give intuition to its analysis. Later, we will expand the analysis for more generalized
problems. We begin by considering the optimization problem We begin by considering the optimization problem minimize
x∈Rd
F(x) := f(x) + φ(r(x))
| {z }
h(x)
,
r(x) =
d
X
i=1
γ(|xi|). (3) (3) This is the simplification of (1) with r := rP and P0 = {±e1, . . . , ±ed} the signed unit basis. The more general
case of the rP gauge-like penalty follows a similar analysis to what is presented in this section, and can be viewed
intuitively as sparsity in a preimage space. This is the simplification of (1) with r := rP and P0 = {±e1, . . . , ±ed} the signed unit basis. The more general
case of the rP gauge-like penalty follows a similar analysis to what is presented in this section, and can be viewed
intuitively as sparsity in a preimage space. 1.2
Contributions and outline We analyze the support recovery and convergence properties of P-CGM and RP-CGM on (1). We assume that
the loss function f is L-smooth, the function φ grows at least asymptotically quadratically, the function γ has
slope bounded away from 0 and +∞, and the set P0 is either finite or a union of a finite set and a nonoverlapping
cone. We give three main contributions. Under mild assumptions the RP-CGM converges to a stationary point. In particular, without boundedness
assumptions on iterates, using the deterministic step size schedule of θ(t) = 2/(1 + t), the function value error
and gap-like residual of RP-CGM converge as O(1/t). Under mild assumptions the RP-CGM converges to a stationary point. In particular, without boundedness
assumptions on iterates, using the deterministic step size schedule of θ(t) = 2/(1 + t), the function value error
and gap-like residual of RP-CGM converge as O(1/t). We offer an online gap-based screening rule, which at each iteration removes some of the non-support atoms
of the true solution x∗. This method is safe for convex penalties and a useful heuristic for nonconvex penalties;
for all penalties it converges in finite time to the true support. Having this information can improve caching
for improving subproblem efficiency, and can be used in two-stage methods if the method is ended early. In general, CGM without line search or away steps does not guarantee finite-time support recovery. We
thus give a finite-time support identification rate of O(1/δ2) on the post-screened atoms, where δ is a
problem-dependent conditioning parameter that measures its distance to degeneracy. We present the RP-CGM in three stages, with increasing complexity. In Section 2 we consider the nonconvex
element-wise penalty, giving the key intuition behind the general method, with simple proofs and analysis. In
Section 3 we consider the generalized convex gauge penalized problem, using P-CGM, and show how to handle
simple recession cones in P. Finally, in Section 4, we introduce reweighting of the gauge penalties, and give fully
general convergence results and screening rules. Experimental results suggest promising method behavior in
Section 5. 4 2.1
Reweighted penalized CGM Inspired by methods in majorization-minimization and difference-of-convex literature, we propose the RP-CGM,
which at each iteration takes a penalized conditional gradient step over the following convex proxy problem min
x∈Rd F(x; x(t)) := f(x) + φ
r(x(t)) −r(x(t); x(t)) + r(x; x(t))
,
(4) min
x∈Rd F(x; x(t)) := f(x) + φ
r(x(t)) −r(x(t); x(t)) + r(x; x(t))
, (4) where r(x; x) := P
i γ′(|xi|)|xi| is the linearized function of r with reference point x. We summarize the linearized
function in terms of a slope and offset where r(x; x) := P
i γ′(|xi|)|xi| is the linearized function of r with reference point x. We summarize the linearized
function in terms of a slope and offset wi = γ′(|x(t)
i |),
r0 = r(x(t)) −r(x(t), x(t)). The RP-CGM on (3) runs by repeatedly iterating The RP-CGM on (3) runs by repeatedly iterating s(t) = argmin
s∈Rd
∇f(x)T s + φ
r0 +
X
i
wi|si|
,
x(t+1) = x(t) + θ(t)(s(t) −x(t)), s(t) = argmin
s∈Rd
∇f(x)T s + φ
r0 +
X
i
wi|si|
, s(t) = argmin
s∈Rd
∇f(x)T s + φ
r0 +
X
i
wi|si|
,
(5)
x(t+1) = x(t) + θ(t)(s(t) −x(t)),
(6) gmin
∈Rd
∇f(x)T s + φ
r0 +
X
i
wi|si|
,
(5) (5) ) + θ(t)(s(t) −x(t)),
(6) x(t+1) = x(t) + θ(t)(s(t) −x(t)), (6) for some predetermined decaying step size sequence θ(t) = O(1/t). We decompose step (5) as follows. First,
assigning the reweighted variables for some predetermined decaying step size sequence θ(t) = O(1/t). We decompose step (5) as follows. First,
assigning the reweighted variables ui = siwi,
vi = −∇f(x)i/wi;
(7)
then (5) is equivalently expressed as
u = argmax
u∈Rd
vT u −φ(r0 + ∥u∥1),
(8) ui = siwi,
vi = −∇f(x)i/wi; (7) then (5) is equivalently expressed as then (5) is equivalently expressed as u = argmax
u∈Rd
vT u −φ(r0 + ∥u∥1), (8) which incidentally is also the conjugate function of g(u) = φ(r0 + ∥u∥1). Now, we further simplify the task by
dividing u into a direction and magnitude which incidentally is also the conjugate function of g(u) = φ(r0 + ∥u∥1). Now, we further simplify the task by
dividing u into a direction and magnitude bu =
1
∥u∥1
u,
ξ = ∥u∥1. 2.1.1
The convex penalty function φ The vanilla CGM is written as an optimization function over a bounded set CGM is written as an optimization function over a bounded set minimize
x∈Rd
{f(x) : x ∈P}, minimize
x∈Rd
{f(x) : x ∈P}, minimize
x∈Rd
{f(x) : x ∈P},
(9) (9) where P is some closed compact set. For example, a common choice of P is a norm ball. By introducing φ, we
allow the problem statement to generalize not just to convex sets, but convex penalties as well. Specifically, let
us first constrain γ(xi) = |xi|. Then if φ(ξ) = ι·<1(ξ) is an indicator function, then (3) is equivalent to (9) where
P is the ℓ1-norm ball. On the other extreme, if we allow φ(ξ) = ξ, (3) resembles the usual LASSO penalized
problem for sparse optimization. This type of problem poses a big problem in the RP-CGM world, since the
conjugate function φ∗(ν) = ι·<1(ν) and the recovered ξ will either be 0 (no step) or +∞(diverge right away). Therefore, it is clear that some curvature must be imposed upon φ for Algorithm 1 to be convergent. ▷Assumption 1 (Lower quadratic bound). We assume φ is lower-bounded by a quadratic function φ(ξ) ≥
µφξ2 −φ0, for some µφ > 0 and φ0. ▷Assumption 1 (Lower quadratic bound). We assume φ is lower-bounded by a quadratic function φ(ξ) ≥
µφξ2 −φ0, for some µφ > 0 and φ0. This minimum curvature assumption is also essential for convergence analysis. Under the usual CGM
framework, each new iterate s ∈P is by design bounded, so as long as θ(t) decays, convergence is guaranteed. In
the P-CGM and RP-CGM case, Assumption 1 is much weaker than boundedness, and leads to the following
growth property. ▶Lemma 2. If Assumption 1 holds, then φ∗is smooth everywhere, and the derivative of φ∗is asymptotically
nonexpansive; e.g., for some finite-valued ξ0, (φ∗)′(ν) ≤
ν
µφ + ξ0. The proof is in Appendix A. Since ξ = (φ∗)′(ν) will be the magnitude of each new step, this Lemma says
that ξ can grow at most linearly with ν, the magnitude of the gradient. We can interpret this as a relaxation of
a boundedness assumption to a controlled growth assumption, which is not fully general, but still much more
relaxed. ▶Example 3 (Monomials). 2.1
Reweighted penalized CGM Compute reweighted negative gradient vi = zi/wi for i = 1, . . . , d. 9:
Compute next atom s = ξ sign(vk)ek in two steps. ▷Min-maj
10:
1. Find the maximizing index k = argmaxi |vi|. 11:
2. Compute the magnitude ξ = (φ∗)′(∥v∥∞) −r0. 12:
Update x(t+1) = (1 −θ(t))x(t) + θ(t)s where θ(t) = 2/(1 + t). ▷Merge
return x(T ) 2.1
Reweighted penalized CGM Then, because bu and ξ can be optimized independently, (8) can be further simplified to two separable problems: Then, because bu and ξ can be optimized independently, (8) can be further simplified to two sepa bu = argmax
u∈Rd
{vT u : ∥u∥1 = ξ},
ξ = argmax
ξ
∥v∥∞ξ −φ(r0 + ξ). bu = argmax
u∈Rd
{vT u : ∥u∥1 = ξ},
ξ = argmax
ξ
∥v∥∞ξ −φ(r0 + ξ). bu = argmax
u∈Rd
{vT u : ∥u∥1 = ξ},
ξ = argmax
ξ
∥v∥∞ξ −φ(r0 + ξ). Solving for bu is exactly the same as the usual LMO for vanilla CGM, and is simply bu = sign(vk)ek where
k = argmaxk |vk|. Solving for ξ is at worse a 1-D convex optimization problem, which can be solved efficiently
via bisection. However, if we pick φ cleverly, then recognizing that the convex conjugate φ∗(ν) = maxξ νξ −φ(ξ),
then the optimal ξ + r0 = (φ∗)′(ν) the derivative of φ∗. (To relate to the vanilla CGM, where φ(ξ) = ι·≤1(ξ), the
convex conjugate φ∗(ν) = ν and is always optimized at ξ = 1.) This leads to the efficient generalization of CGM
in Alg. 1. Solving for bu is exactly the same as the usual LMO for vanilla CGM, and is simply bu = sign(vk)ek where
k = argmaxk |vk|. Solving for ξ is at worse a 1-D convex optimization problem, which can be solved efficiently
via bisection. However, if we pick φ cleverly, then recognizing that the convex conjugate φ∗(ν) = maxξ νξ −φ(ξ),
then the optimal ξ + r0 = (φ∗)′(ν) the derivative of φ∗. (To relate to the vanilla CGM, where φ(ξ) = ι·≤1(ξ), the
convex conjugate φ∗(ν) = ν and is always optimized at ξ = 1.) This leads to the efficient generalization of CGM
in Alg. 1. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 5 Algorithm 1 RP-CGM on simple sparse optimization Algorithm 1 RP-CGM on simple sparse optimization 1: procedure RP-CGM(f, φ, γ, T) 1: procedure RP-CGM(f, φ, γ, T)
2:
Initialize with any x(0) ∈Rd. 3:
for t = 1, . . . , T do
4:
Compute negative gradient z = −∇f(x(t)). 5:
Compute reweighting terms in three steps. ▷Reweight
6:
1. Compute weights wi = γ′(|x(t)
i |) for i = 1, . . . , d. 7:
2. Compute offset r0 = r(x(t)) −r(x(t); x(t)). 8:
3. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 6 Table 1 A list of several popular concave penalties, and their slope behavior at extremities. The last
entry shows the effect of the piecewise construction, which becomes linear with non-zero slope at large
values of ξ. γ(c)
limc→0 γ′(c)
limc→+∞γ′(c)
Fractional fns
q−1cq, 0 < q < 1
+∞
0
LSP
log(1 + |c|/θ) for θ > 0
θ−1
0
SCAD
λ|c|
|c| ≤λ,
−c2+2θλ|c|−λ2
2(θ−1)
λ < |c| ≤θλ,
(θ + 1)λ2/2
|c| ≥θλ,
for θ > 2
λ
0
MCP
(
λ|c| −c2/(2θ)
|c| ≤θλ,
θλ2/2
|c| > θλ,
for θ > 0
λ
0
Locally convex
(12), given γ0 and ξ
limc→0 γ′
0(c)
γ′
0(ξ) γ(c)
limc→0 γ′(c)
limc→+∞γ′(c)
Fractional fns
q−1cq, 0 < q < 1
+∞
0
LSP
log(1 + |c|/θ) for θ > 0
θ−1
0
SCAD
λ|c|
|c| ≤λ,
−c2+2θλ|c|−λ2
2(θ−1)
λ < |c| ≤θλ,
(θ + 1)λ2/2
|c| ≥θλ,
for θ > 2
λ
0
MCP
(
λ|c| −c2/(2θ)
|c| ≤θλ,
θλ2/2
|c| > θλ,
for θ > 0
λ
0
Locally convex
(12), given γ0 and ξ
limc→0 γ′
0(c)
γ′
0(ξ) ▶Example 4 (Barrier functions). Consider ▶Example 4 (Barrier functions). Consider ▶Example 4 (Barrier functions). Consider φ(ξ) = −1
β log(C −ξ) −
ξ
Cβ + log(C)
β
,
(10) φ(ξ) = −1
β log(C −ξ) −
ξ
Cβ + log(C)
β
, (10) which is a log-barrier penalization function for ξ ≤C; as β →+∞, φ(ξ) approaches the indicator function for
this constraint. Its conjugate is which is a log-barrier penalization function for ξ ≤C; as β →+∞, φ(ξ) approaches the indicator function for
this constraint. Its conjugate is Cν −β−1 log(Cβν + 1), φ∗(ν) = Cν −β−1 log(Cβν + 1), achieved at ξ = C2βν/(Cβν + 1). For all C > 0, β > 0, and ν ̸= −(Cβ)−1, both φ∗and ξ∗exist and are finite. Note also the implicit constraint, as φ(κP(x)) is finite only if x ∈CP. achieved at ξ = C2βν/(Cβν + 1). For all C > 0, β > 0, and ν ̸= −(Cβ)−1, both φ∗and ξ∗exist and are finite. Note also the implicit constraint, as φ(κP(x)) is finite only if x ∈CP. 2.1.1
The convex penalty function φ For 1 ≤α, β ≤+∞, the following φ : R+ →R+ and φ∗: R+ →R+ form a conjugate
pair: φ(ξ) = 1
αξα,
φ∗(ν) = 1
β νβ,
1
α + 1
β = 1. In particular, in the case that α = 1, then β →+∞, and the function In particular, in the case that α = 1, then β →+∞, and the function φ∗(ν) =
lim
β→+∞
1
β νβ =
(
0,
ν ≤1
+∞,
ν > 1. In this case, whenever ν > 1 then φ∗(ν) = +∞; we exclude this case as P-CGM will not converge. When α ≥2,
φ is strongly convex and we can show O(1/t) convergence of P-CGM. When 1 < α < 2, φ∗(ν) is finite and the
iterates are well-defined, but the method may converge or diverge. In this case, whenever ν > 1 then φ∗(ν) = +∞; we exclude this case as P-CGM will not converge. When α ≥2,
φ is strongly convex and we can show O(1/t) convergence of P-CGM. When 1 < α < 2, φ∗(ν) is finite and the
iterates are well-defined, but the method may converge or diverge. 2.2
The concave sparsifier γ The function γ is inspired by concave regularization functions like the LSP or fractional p-norms, that have been
shown in practice to more aggressively enforce sparsity. Other popular concave penalties are listed in Table 1; a
more complete table is given by [33, 58]. The linearization (4), given γ concave, is a majorant of (3) The linearization (4), given γ concave, is a majorant of (3) d
X
i=1
γ(|x(t)
i |)
|
{z
}
r(x(t))
+ γ′(|x(t)
i |)(|xi| −|x(t)
i |)
|
{z
}
r0:=r(x;x(t))−r(x(t);x(t))
≥
d
X
i=1
γ(|xi|) = r(x)
(11) (11) and is exactly equal when x(t) reaches a stationary point. However, actually computing the reweighted LMO can
be numerically ill-defined if wi = γ′(|x(t)
i |) is either 0 or +∞, since the reweighted variables (7) will be ill-defined. This leads us to impose Assumption 2 on γ. and is exactly equal when x(t) reaches a stationary point. However, actually computing the reweighted LMO can
be numerically ill-defined if wi = γ′(|x(t)
i |) is either 0 or +∞, since the reweighted variables (7) will be ill-defined. This leads us to impose Assumption 2 on γ. ▷Assumption 2 (γ). Assume that γ : R+ →R+ is concave, monotonically increasing, and differentiable
everywhere on its domain, and the derivative γ′(ξ) is lower and upper bounded by 0 < γmin := lim
ξ→∞γ′(ξ) ≤γ′(ξ) ≤lim
ξ→0+ γ′(ξ) =: γmax < +∞,
∀ξ ≥0. Additionally γ(0)
0 0 < γmin := lim
ξ→∞γ′(ξ) ≤γ′(ξ) ≤lim
ξ→0+ γ′(ξ) =: γmax < +∞,
∀ξ ≥0. Additionally, γ(0) = 0. Additionally, γ(0) = 0. Note that the standard nonconvex sparsifiers (SCAD, MCP, LSP, p-norm for p < 1) do not satisfy these
assumptions, and when used directly in this reweighting scheme will cause numerical instability. Therefore, we
make the following modifications, to ensure stability of RP-CGM. In cases where γ′(ξ) →+∞as ξ →0, we modify to bγ(ξ) = γ(ξ + ξ0) for some hyperparameter ξ0 > 0. 7 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach In cases where γ′(ξ) →0 as ξ →+∞, we use a piecewise linear extension given a “boundary point” ξ: ses where γ′(ξ) →0 as ξ →+∞, we use a piecewise linear extension given a “boundary point” ξ: bγ(ξ) =
(
γ(ξ),
0 ≤ξ ≤ξ,
γ′(ξ)(ξ −ξ) + γ(ξ),
ξ > ξ. (12) See also Figure 1. It is interesting to note that though we do not use the “full effect” of these canonical sparsifiers, we are able to
leverage their aggressive sparsifying effect. When even a very small amount of nonconvex curvature is present,
we notice a significant benefit in the numerical experiments in terms of screening and sparsification of the final
solution. 2.3
Stationary points and support recovery We define the support of x as the indices of the nonzeros as supp(x) = {i : xi ̸= 0}. For a method producing
iterates x(1), x(2), →x∗, we say that this method has recovered the support at iteration t if for all t ≥t,
supp(x(t)) = supp(x∗). For a continuous function h : Rd →R, the point x∗is a Clarke stationary point of (3) if 0 ∈∇f(x∗) + ∂h(x∗)
where ∂h(x) = conv{limx′→x ∇h(x′)} is the Clarke subdifferential of h at x [18, 19]. Given Assumptions 1 and 2,
the Clarke subdifferential for h(x) is 1 (∂h(x))i =
(
{gφ sign(xi) γ′(|xi|) : gφ ∈∂φ(r(x))}
xi ̸= 0,
φ′(0) · [−γmax, γmax],
xi = 0, where we use the · notation here for scaling elements in a set (α · S = {αx : x ∈S}). In other words, in cases
where φ′(r(x)) exists, the optimality conditions can be summarized as follows: x∗is a stationary point of (3) if where we use the · notation here for scaling elements in a set (α · S = {αx : x ∈S}). In other words, in cases
where φ′(r(x)) exists, the optimality conditions can be summarized as follows: x∗is a stationary point of (3) if x∗
i ̸= 0 ⇒−∇f(x∗)i = φ′(r(x)) γ′(|xi|)
x∗
i = 0 ⇒−∇f(x∗)i ∈φ′(r(x)) · [−γmax, γmax]. ▶Example 5. Suppose that γ(xi) = |xi| and φ(ξ) = 1
2ξ2. Since h(x) = φ(r(x)) is convex in this example, the
Clarke subdifferential reduces to the usual convex subdifferential, and can be expressed element-wise ▶Example 5. Suppose that γ(xi) = |xi| and φ(ξ) = 1
2ξ2. Since h(x) = φ(r(x)) is convex in this example, the
Clarke subdifferential reduces to the usual convex subdifferential, and can be expressed element-wise (∂h(x))i = ∥x∥1 ·
[−1, 1],
xi = 0,
{1},
xi > 0,
{−1},
xi < 0. ∂h(x))i = ∥x∥1 ·
[−1, 1],
xi = 0,
{1},
xi > 0,
{−1},
xi < 0. The optimality conditions can also be summarized in terms of “wiggle room”; that is, whenever xi = 0, then
∇f(x)i lies in an interval. But when xi ̸= 0, ∇f(x)i must take a specific value. Duality will then allow the
element-wise gradient to act as a sparsity indicator. (See also [53, 69].) ▶Example 6. 1 In general, φ(x) may not be differentiable for all x. However, since φ is convex and only defined on R+, then φ′(0) :=
limξ→0+ φ(ξ)−φ(0)
ξ
must exist. 2.4
Duality We now give the primal and Fenchel dual formulations of (3) given a reference point x: (P-simple)
min
x∈Rd F(x; x) := f(x) + φ
r0 +
X
i
wi|xi|
|
{z
}
=:h(x;x)
(D-simple)
max
z
F D(z; x) := −f ∗(−z) −φ∗
max
i
|zi|
wi
+ r0
max
i
|zi|
wi
|
{z
}
h∗(z;x)
. {z
h∗(z;x) Here, we define r0 := r(x) −r(x; x) and wi = γ′(|xi|). Given x, both primal and dual objective functions are
convex. In particular, the duality gap of this convexified subproblem, using a primal candidate x and dual
candidate z = −∇f(x), can be expressed as gap(x; x) = f(x) + f ∗(∇f(x))
|
{z
}
=xT ∇f(x)
+h(x; x) + h∗(−∇f(x); x) gap(x; x) = f(x) + f ∗(∇f(x))
|
{z
}
=xT ∇f(x)
+h(x; x) + h∗(−∇f(x); x gap(x; x) = f(x) + f ∗(∇f(x))
|
{z
}
=xT ∇f(x)
+h(x; x) + h∗(−∇f(x); x) and adds little overhead when used to monitor the progress of Alg. 1. Now, we will show that gap(x; x) is an
effective residual measurement, and indeed converges to 0 at the usual O(1/t) rate. and adds little overhead when used to monitor the progress of Alg. 1. Now, we will show that gap(x; x) is an
effective residual measurement, and indeed converges to 0 at the usual O(1/t) rate. 2.3
Stationary points and support recovery Consider the concave regularizer h(x) :=
P
i
p
|xi| + ξ0
2. This construction arises from φ(ξ) = ξ2
and r(ξ) =
p
|ξ| + ξ0. Its Clarke-subdifferential can be expressed element-wise (∂h(x))i =
X
j
q
|xj| + ξ0
·
[−ξ−1/2
0
, ξ−1/2
0
],
xi = 0,
1
√
|xi|+ξ0
,
xi > 0,
−1
√
|xi|+ξ0
,
xi < 0. Again, note that the duality conditions show “wiggle room” in the values of ∇f(x) at stationary x = x∗, for
the indices for which xi = 0. However, in the case of nonconvex functions γ, the gradient at optimality is less
informative, since γ′(|xi|) changes with different input values, and moreover is not necessarily maximal when
|xi| > 0. For this reason, designing screening rules is nontrivial for nonconvex penalty functions, and fully safe
rules may not prove fully efficient. Again, note that the duality conditions show “wiggle room” in the values of ∇f(x) at stationary x = x∗, for
the indices for which xi = 0. However, in the case of nonconvex functions γ, the gradient at optimality is less
informative, since γ′(|xi|) changes with different input values, and moreover is not necessarily maximal when
|xi| > 0. For this reason, designing screening rules is nontrivial for nonconvex penalty functions, and fully safe
rules may not prove fully efficient. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Metho Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 8 Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Met
Figure 1 Transformations φ and γ. Left: Level sets for the penalty h(x) = φ(P
i γ(|xi|)). The
concave penalty γ increases the “spike-ness”; the convex penalty φ increases the effect of the aggregate
value. Right: Three example functions of γ. RP-CGM will behave erratically when γmin = 0 (red and
blue) and γmax is unbounded (red), so we use a penalty that is bounded on both ends (green = concave
+ linear). Figure 1 Transformations φ and γ. Left: Level sets for the penalty h(x) = φ(P
i γ(|xi|)). The
concave penalty γ increases the “spike-ness”; the convex penalty φ increases the effect of the aggregate
value. Right: Three example functions of γ. 2.3
Stationary points and support recovery RP-CGM will behave erratically when γmin = 0 (red and
blue) and γmax is unbounded (red), so we use a penalty that is bounded on both ends (green = concave
+ linear). 2.5
Convergence of RP-CGM e begin with an unusual twist on a usual assumption. We begin with an unusual twist on a usual assumption. ▷Assumption 3 (L-smoothness). We assume that f is convex and L-smooth w.r.t. ∥· ∥1:
f(y) −f(x) ≤∇f(x)T (y −x) + L
2 ∥y −x∥2
1,
∀x, y. (13) We assume that f is convex and L-smooth w.r.t. ∥· ∥1: ▷Assumption 3 (L-smoothness). We assume that f is convex and L-smooth w.r.t. ∥· ∥1: f(y) −f(x) ≤∇f(x)T (y −x) + L
2 ∥y −x∥2
1,
∀x, y. −f(x) ≤∇f(x)T (y −x) + L
2 ∥y −x∥2
1,
∀x, y. (13) (13) An important consequence of (13) is that, while the set of minimizers of (P-simple) may not necessarily be
unique, their gradient ∇f(x∗) will be unique. Specifically, (13) implies that f(x) −f(y) ≥∇f(y)T (x −y) + 1
2L∥∇f(x) −∇f(y)∥2
∞,
∀x, y
(14) f(x) −f(y) ≥∇f(y)T (x −y) + 1
2L∥∇f(x) −∇f(y)∥2
∞,
∀x, y f(x) −f(y) ≥∇f(y)T (x −y) + 1
2L∥∇f(x) −∇f(y)∥2
∞,
∀x, y (14) 9 9 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach and in particular taking y = x∗where −∇f(x∗) ∈∂h(x∗; x), we have
f(x) + h(x; x) −f(x∗) −h(x∗; x) ≥1
2L∥∇f(x) −∇f(x∗)∥2
∞,
∀x and in particular taking y = x∗where −∇f(x∗) ∈∂h(x∗; x), we have
f(x) + h(x; x) −f(x∗) −h(x∗; x) ≥1
2L∥∇f(x) −∇f(x∗)∥2
∞,
∀x and in particular taking y = x∗where −∇f(x∗) ∈∂h(x∗; x), we have f(x) + h(x; x) −f(x∗) −h(x∗; x) ≥1
2L∥∇f(x) −∇f(x∗)∥2
∞,
∀x and thus x is optimal only if ∇f(x) = ∇f(x∗). and thus x is optimal only if ∇f(x) = ∇f(x∗). Under Assumption 3, we first show that the duality gap of the original nonconvex problem (3) is (as expected)
bounded away from 0, and is thus an inadequate measure of suboptimality. ▶Proposition 7 (Duality gap of nonconvex regularizer). For h(x) = φ(r(x)), h(x) −h∗∗(x) ≥φ(r(x)) −φ(γmin∥x∥1). Proof. First, given the conjugate function h∗(z) := sup
x xT z −φ(r(x)) and picking and picking (
xi →sign(zi) · α
for one |zi| = ∥z∥∞,
xi = 0
otherwise, gives h∗(z) ≥α∥z∥∞−φ(γ(α)). h∗(z) ≥α∥z∥∞−φ(γ(α)). Since φ is monotonically increasing and γ is concave, we have the majorant property of the linearizer, and φ(γ(α)) ≤φ(γ′(α0) · (α −α0) + γ(α0)). Therefore Therefore h∗(z) ≥sup
α
α∥z∥∞−φ(γ′(α0) · (α −α0) + γ(α0)) ≥φ∗
∥z∥∞
γ′(α0)
+ (γ′(α0)α0 −γ(α0))
|
{z
}
≥0
∥z∥∞
γ′(α0)
. h∗(z) ≥sup
α
α∥z∥∞−φ(γ′(α0) · (α −α0) + γ(α0)) ≥φ∗
∥z∥∞
γ′(α0)
+ (γ′(α0)α0 −γ(α0))
|
{z
}
≥0
∥z∥∞
γ′(α0)
. In particular, since this holds for any α0, h∗(z) ≥φ∗
∥z∥∞
γmin
. Therefore, h∗∗(x) ≤sup
z
xT z −φ∗
∥z∥∞
γmin
= φ(∥x∥1γmin). h∗∗(x) ≤sup
z
xT z −φ∗
∥z∥∞
γmin
= φ(∥x∥1γmin). ◀ In other words, the duality gap of the original nonconvex problem is somewhat useless for screening, since it
does not converge to 0. Instead, we measure convergence via the gap of the linearized problem at x = x. ▶Proposition 8 (Residual). The duality gap gap(x, z; x) between (P-simple) and (D-simple) at primal variable
x and dual variable z = −∇f(x), with reference point x, satisfies (at x = x) gap(x, z; x) ≥0 ∀x,
gap(x, z; x) = 0 ⇐⇒
x is a stationary point of (3). Proof. Since gap(x, z; x) is a duality gap, it is always nonnegative. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method where ⊙and ⊘represent element-wise multiplication and division, respectively. Tightness of (a) occurs iff
Fenchel–Young is satisfied with equality, e.g. ν ∈∂φ(r(x)). Tightness of (b) occurs iff where ⊙and ⊘represent element-wise multiplication and division, respectively. Tightness of (a) occurs iff
Fenchel–Young is satisfied with equality, e.g. ν ∈∂φ(r(x)). Tightness of (b) occurs iff max
j
|∇f(x)j|
γ′(|xj|) = −∇f(x)i · sign(xi)
γ′(|xi|)
,
∀xi ̸= 0. (15) Combining these two observations, then gap(x, −∇f(x); x) = 0 if and only if −∇f(x)i ∈
{−gφ γ′(|xi|) : gφ ∈∂φ(r(x))},
xi < 0,
{gφ γ′(|xi|) : gφ ∈∂φ(r(x))},
xi > 0,
φ′(0) · [−γ′(0), γ′(0)],
xi = 0, which is the condition for x = x∗a stationary point of (3). ▶Theorem 9 (Convergence of RP-CGM, simple case). Pick any x(0) ∈Rd where h(x(0)) is finite. Define
the sequence x(t), t = 1, . . . by the steps dictated in (Min-Maj) and (Merge), using the step size sequence
θ(t) = 2/(1 + t). Given Assumptions 1, 2, 3, then F(x(t)) −F(x∗) = O(1/t),
min
t′≤t res(x(t′)) = O(1/t). This is a special case of Theorem 33, which is proven in Section 4 and Appendix B. The proof is inductive,
and shows that O(1/t) behavior “kicks in” at a large enough t; explicit constants are given in Section 4. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Explicitly, denote ν = maxi
|∇f(x)i|
γ′(|xi|)
. Then,
since f(x) + f ∗(∇f(x)) = ∇f(x)T x, gap(x, z; x) = xT ∇f(x) + φ(r(x)) + φ∗(ν) + (r(x; x) −r(x)) · ν
(a)
≥xT ∇f(x) + r(x)ν + (r(x; x) −r(x)) · ν
= xT ∇f(x) +
X
i
wi|xi|
|
{z
}
∥w⊙x∥1
· max
j
|∇f(x))j|
wj
|
{z
}
∥∇f(x)⊘w∥∞
(b)
≥xT ∇f(x) −xT ∇f(x) = 0 gap(x, z; x) = xT ∇f(x) + φ(r(x)) + φ∗(ν) + (r(x; x) −r(x)) · ν 10 then x∗
i = 0 for all i ∈I(t)
ϵ , where x∗any minimizer of (3). then x∗
i = 0 for all i ∈I(t)
ϵ , where x∗any minimizer of (3). Note that in the convex case (γ(|xi|) = |xi|) then D(x) = 0 and ϵ = 0 is a safe choice, for all x. In the general
case, since we do not know D(x), we cannot guarantee the safety of an intermediate iterate; however, since
D(x∗) = 0 by definition of stationary point, then x(t) →x∗implies D(x(t)) →0. Picking any decaying sequence
ϵ(t) →0, therefore, forms a heuristic rule that converges to the true support. 2.6
Convex support recovery and screening To understand how gap-based screening works, suppose first that for some x, we magically have a bound on the
gradient error over all indices: ϵ > |(∇f(x))i −(∇f(x∗))i|,
∀i. Then the value of the true maximum gradient at the stationary point is at most ϵ away from the maximum
value of the current gradient, e.g. ∥∇f(x∗)∥∞≥∥∇f(x)∥∞−ϵ. Moreover, if at any index k, ∥∇f(x∗)∥∞≥∥∇f(x)∥∞−ϵ. Moreover, if at any index k, |∇f(x)|k < ∥∇f(x)∥∞−2ϵ ≤∥∇f(x∗)∥∞−ϵ,
this implies that the highest possible value that |∇f(x∗)|k could be is |∇f(x)|k < ∥∇f(x)∥∞−2ϵ ≤∥∇f(x∗)∥∞−ϵ,
this implies that the highest possible value that |∇f(x∗)|k could be is this implies that the highest possible value that |∇f(x∗)|k could be is |∇f(x∗)|k ≤|∇f(x)|k + ϵ < ∥∇f(x∗)∥∞; in other words, index k cannot possibly be maximal. Therefore, it must be that at optimality, x∗
k = 0. The last
missing detail is the observation that the duality gap gives us this ϵ bound explicitly. Now we formalize this notion. From optimality conditions, x∗minimizes (P-simple) if Now we formalize this notion. From optimality conditions, x∗minimi (
{sign(x∗
i )},
x∗
i ̸= 0
[−1, 1],
x∗
i = 0,
(16) −∇f(x∗)i
αwi
∈
(
{sign(x∗
i )},
x∗
i ̸= 0
[−1, 1],
x∗
i = 0, (16) for some α ∈∂ξφ(r0 + ξ) at ξ = P
i wix∗
i . In other words, for this convex reweighting problem, the sparsity
pattern of x∗can be partially ascertained from ∇f(x∗), in that the set of nonzeros of x∗must be contained in
the set of maximal indices of the reweighted ∇f(x∗). Formally, define ) :=
i : |∇f(x)i|
γ′(|xi|) = max
j
|∇f(x)j|
γ′(|xj|)
. (17) dsupp(x; x) :=
i : |∇f(x)i|
γ′(|xi|) = max
j
|∇f(x)j|
γ′(|xj|)
. (17) Then the optimality condition (16) states that supp(x∗) ⊆dsupp(x∗; x), where x∗minimizes (P-simple). We
are in particular interested in x∗= x∗the stationary point of (3). From this observation, we have our first
screening property. Then the optimality condition (16) states that supp(x∗) ⊆dsupp(x∗; x), where x∗minimizes (P-simple). We
are in particular interested in x∗= x∗the stationary point of (3). From this observation, we have our first
screening property. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach I(t)
ϵ
=
n
i : ∥∇f(x)∥∞−|∇f(x)i| ≥ϵ + 2
p
Lgap(x; x) + ϵ
o
. (19) If If ϵ ≥LD(x)
γmin
max
1
2, LD(x)
4γmin
+ ∥∇f(x)∥∞
, then x∗
i = 0 for all i ∈I(t)
ϵ , where x∗any minimizer of (3). Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 11 ▶Proposition 10 (Screening for simple sparsity). If ∥∇f(x) −∇f(x∗)∥∞≤ϵ, then ▶Proposition 10 (Screening for simple sparsity). If ∥∇f(x) −∇f(x∗)∥∞≤ϵ, then ∥∇f(x)∥∞−|∇f(x)i| > 2ϵγmax ⇒x∗
i = 0. (18)
Proof. First, define vi = |∇f(x)i|
wi
and v∗
i = |∇f(x∗)i|
wi
. Then ∥∇f(x)∥∞−|∇f(x)i| > 2ϵγmax ⇒x∗
i = 0. (18) ∥∇f(x)∥∞
|∇f(x)i| > 2ϵγmax ⇒xi = 0. Proof. First, define vi = |∇f(x)i|
wi
and v∗
i = |∇f(x∗)i|
wi
. Then Proof. First, define vi = |∇f(x)i|
wi
and v∗
i = |∇f(x∗)i|
wi
. Then Proof. First, define vi = |∇f(x)i|
wi
and v∗
i = |∇f(x∗)i|
wi
. Then ∥∇f(x∗) −∇f(x)∥∞
γmax
≤∥∇f(x∗) −∇f(x)∥∞
maxi wi
≤∥v −v∗∥∞. By optimality conditions v∗
i < ∥v∗∥∞⇒x∗
i = 0. Thus, (18) implies By optimality conditions v∗
i < ∥v∗∥∞⇒x∗
i = 0. Thus, (18) implies 2ϵ > ∥∇f(x)∥∞−|∇f(x)i|)
γmax
≥∥v∥∞−vi
and therefore ∥v∗∥∞−v∗
i ≤∥v∥∞−vi + 2ϵ < 0. ◀ 2ϵ > ∥∇f(x)∥∞−|∇f(x)i|)
γmax
≥∥v∥∞−vi 2ϵ > ∥∇f(x)∥∞−|∇f(x)i|)
γmax
≥∥v∥∞−vi
and therefore ∥v∗∥∞−v∗
i ≤∥v∥∞−vi + 2ϵ < 0. v∗∥∞−v∗
i ≤∥v∥∞−vi + 2ϵ < 0. ◀ ▶Proposition 11 (Residual bound on gradient error). Define D(x) = Pd
i=1 γ(|xi|) −γ(|x∗
i |) −γ′(|xi|)(|xi −x∗
i |)
the linearization error at x. Denoting x∗a stationary point of (3), then ▶Proposition 11 (Residual bound on gradient error). Define D(x) = Pd
i=1 γ(|xi|) −γ(|x∗
i |) −γ′(|xi|)(|xi −x∗
i |)
the linearization error at x. Denoting x∗a stationary point of (3), then ▶Proposition 11 (Residual bound on gradient error). Define D(x) = Pd
i=1 γ(|xi|) −γ(|x∗
i |) −γ′(|xi|)(|xi −x∗
i |)
the linearization error at x. Denoting x∗a stationary point of (3), then ∥∇f(x∗) −∇f(x)∥∞≤LD(x)
2γmin
+
s
L2D(x)2
4γ2
min
+ Lres(x) + LD(x)∥∇f(x)∥∞
γmin
. Note that if r(x) = ∥x∥1 then D(x) = 0. Since this proposition is a consequence of Proposition 34 in Section 4,
we leave the proof for then. From these two properties, we immediately get a screening rule for (3): From these two properties, we immediately get a screening rule for (3): ▶Theorem 12 (Screening rule). For any x, define ▶Theorem 12 (Screening rule). For any x, define I(t)
ϵ
=
n
i : ∥∇f(x)∥∞−|∇f(x)i| ≥ϵ + 2
p
Lgap(x; x) + ϵ
o
. (19) I(t)
ϵ
=
n
i : ∥∇f(x)∥∞−|∇f(x)i| ≥ϵ + 2
p
Lgap(x; x) + ϵ
o
. 3
P-CGM for general convex sparse optimization Our goal is to now extend the studies of the previous section to solve the generalized sparse optimization
problem (1). The key addition is the introduction of the “gauge-like” function rP(x), but which uses the
sparsifying properties of γ. In this section, we will focus on problem (32) when it is convex; namely, we assume
that γ(c) = c. Just as studying the convex LASSO brings to light many of the sparse recovery properties
illustrated from the nonconvex problem (3), we will first study the convex penalized version of (32) to gain
intuition, and present the full extension in the next section. 2.6.1
Degeneracy and support recovery guarantee Following the terminology introduced in [37], we say that x∗is a degenerate solution if supp(x∗) ̸= dsupp(x∗; x∗);
that is, there exists i where x∗
i = 0
and
|∇f(x∗)i|
γ′(|x∗
i |)
= max
j
|∇f(x∗)j|
γ′(|x∗
j|) . To characterize nearly degenerate solutions, we define To characterize nearly degenerate solutions, we define δi(x) = max
j
|∇f(x)j|
γ′(|xj|) −|∇f(x)i|
γ′(|xi|) ,
δmin(x) = min
i:xi=0 δi(x), and the quantity δmin(x∗) expresses the distance to degeneracy for this solution. This can be interpreted as a
complementary slackness-like condition in duality, where both the primal and dual variables are jointly active. While we may reasonably believe that many real world problems with randomized data do not lead to degenerate
solutions, near-degenerate solutions do pose problems for screening and manifold identification [11, 37, 45]. and the quantity δmin(x∗) expresses the distance to degeneracy for this solution. This can be interpreted as a
complementary slackness-like condition in duality, where both the primal and dual variables are jointly active. While we may reasonably believe that many real world problems with randomized data do not lead to degenerate
solutions, near-degenerate solutions do pose problems for screening and manifold identification [11, 37, 45]. ▶Corollary 13. If δmin > 0, then for a method x(t) →x∗, the screening rule (19) with ϵ = 0 identifies supp(x∗)
after a finite number of iterations t; that is, for all t ≥t, I(t)
0
= supp(x∗). In the convex case (γ(|xi|) = |xi|),
this occurs when ∥∇f(x∗) −∇f(x)∥∞≤δmin/3, which occurs at t = O(1/δ2
min). Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 12 3.1
Gauge penalized problems The penalized CGM (P-CGM) solves problems of the form p
(
)
p
minimize
x∈Rd
f(x) + φ(κP(x)),
(20) (20) minimize
x∈Rd
f(x) + φ(κP(x)), minimize
x∈Rd
f(x) + φ(κP(x)), where κP(x) is the gauge function [15, 30] defined by a set P at point x: where κP(x) is the gauge function [15, 30] defined by a set P at point x: κP(x) := min
cp≥0
X
p∈P0
cp :
X
p∈P0
cpp = x
. κP(x) := min
cp≥0
X
p∈P0
cp :
X
p∈P0
cpp = x
. (21) (21) This function generalizes the 1-norm to more size-measuring functions that include norms, semi-norms, and convex
cone restrictions. It is useful to compare (21) with the definition usually given in convex analysis literature [8, 60],
where the gauge function over a closed convex set P is defined as κP(x) := inf{µ ≥0 : x ∈µP}. (22) κP(x) := inf{µ ≥0 : x ∈µP}. f{µ ≥0 : x ∈µP}. (22) In fact, this is equivalent to (21). In particular, when P is the convex hull of a set of atoms, κP(x) can be used
to promote sparsity with respect to those atoms. The corresponding “dual gauge” is the support function In fact, this is equivalent to (21). In particular, when P is the convex hull of a set of atoms, κP(x) can be used
to promote sparsity with respect to those atoms. The corresponding “dual gauge” is the support function σP(z) = max
s∈P0 sT z which is closely related to the generalized LMO LMOP(z) = argmax
s∈P0
sT z. If κP is a norm, then σP is the usual dual norm [8, 60]. A key feature of the CGM is that this LMO is often
cheap to compute in practice, and despite weaker convergence guarantees compared to higher order methods,
often converges quickly when x∗is sparse with respect to structured P0. (See also Table 2.) ▶Example 14 (ℓ1 norm). We start with the usual sparsity case of the ℓ1 norm. In this case, σP = ∥· ∥∞is
the dual norm of ∥· ∥1. Then, by setting the optimality condition 0 ∈∂g(x∗) and decomposing by index, at
optimality (
(−∇f(x∗))i = ∥x∗∥1 sign(x∗
i )
if x∗
i ̸= 0,
(−∇f(x∗))i ∈∥x∗∥1 · [−1, 1]
if x∗
i = 0. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 13 ▶Example 16 (Latent group norm). For the task of selecting a sparse collection of overlapping subvectors,
such as in gene identification, the latent group norm was proposed in [55]. For x ∈Rd, given a collection of
overlapping groups G = {G1, . . . , GK} where Gk ⊂{1, . . . , d}, this norm a gauge function, κP(x) = ∥x∥G := min
sk∈Rd
( K
X
k=1
∥sk∥2 : x =
K
X
k=1
sk, (sk)i = 0 ∀i ̸∈Gk
)
. (23) (23) n particular, (23) is the solution to (21) when In particular, (23) is the solution to (21) when P0 =
(
1
p
|Gk|
eGk, k = 1, . . . , K
)
,
(eGk)i =
(
1,
i ∈Gk,
0,
else. P0 =
(
1
p
|Gk|
eGk, k = 1, . . . , K
)
,
(eGk)i =
(
1,
i ∈Gk,
0,
else. Then σP(z) = maxk=1,...,K ∥zGk∥2. Now consider (20) for some smooth φ. Then at optimality, decomposing
x∗= P
k s∗
k, for each group k, Then σP(z) = maxk=1,...,K ∥zGk∥2. Now consider (20) for some smooth φ. Then at optimality, decomposing
x∗= P
k s∗
k, for each group k, (
∥z∗
Gk∥2 = φ′(κP(x∗)),
if ∥s∗
k∥2 > 0,
∥z∗
Gk∥2 ≤φ′(κP(x∗)),
if ∥s∗
k∥2 = 0. Screening in this case refers to identifying the subvectors where, at optimality, ∥s∗
k∥2 might be nonzero; however,
just as support identification in the 1-norm case does not imply that the values of x∗
i are known, in a similar
vein here it does not imply that the values of s∗
k are known. Screening in this case refers to identifying the subvectors where, at optimality, ∥s∗
k∥2 might be nonzero; however,
just as support identification in the 1-norm case does not imply that the values of x∗
i are known, in a similar
vein here it does not imply that the values of s∗
k are known. Both P-CGM and RP-CGM can be efficiently implemented for the latent group norm. However, a key numerical
issue is that computing the group norm ∥x∥G when the groups overlap is computationally burdensome (requires
solving complex subproblems) and is needed in the gap computation. Nevertheless, since gap computations are
used only infrequently for monitoring progress and for screening, this overhead can be mitigated. 3.1
Gauge penalized problems (
(−∇f(x∗))i = ∥x∗∥1 sign(x∗
i )
if x∗
i ̸= 0,
(−∇f(x∗))i ∈∥x∗∥1 · [−1, 1]
if x∗
i = 0. In words, the gradient of f along a coordinate for which the optimal variable is nonsmooth with respect to κP is
allowed “wiggle room”; in contrast, if g(x) is smooth in the direction of xi then the gradient is fixed. In terms of
support recovery, maxi |∇f(x∗)i| = ∥x∗∥1 and additionally, if |∇f(x∗)i| < ∥x∗∥1 then it must be that x∗
i = 0. ▶Example 15 (Weighted ℓ1 norm). The convex majorant in Section 2 specifically considered κP(x) = P
i wi|xi|,
for weights wi > 0. Here, P0 = {±w−1
1 e1, . . . , ±w−1
d ed}, with corresponding “dual gauge” σP(z) = maxi
|zi|
|wi|,
and the LMO follows exactly the steps for the bounded maximization computation in (5). Note also that the
optimality conditions of (20) for this choice of κP(x) is
|∇f(x∗)i|
|wi|
= maxj
|∇f(x∗)j|
|wj|
sign(x∗
i )
if x∗
i ̸= 0,
|∇f(x∗)i|
|wi|
∈maxj
|∇f(x∗)j|
|wj|
· [−1, 1]
if x∗
i = 0. It exactly characterizes the optimality conditions for (P-simple). Later, we will generalize this reweighting
technique for general atomic sets P0, to construct the convex majorant of the general nonconvex problem (1). It exactly characterizes the optimality conditions for (P-simple). Later, we will generalize this reweighting
technique for general atomic sets P0, to construct the convex majorant of the general nonconvex problem (1). Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 14 Table 2 Common norms, their atoms, support functions, and their LMOs. In particular, computing
each LMO is computationally cheap, especially compared to computing the proximal operator of the
gauge, or even the gauge itself. Gauge κP(x)
Atoms P0
Support fn σP(z)
LMO(z)
1-norm
{±e1, . . . , ±ed}
∥z∥∞
sign(zk)ek,
∥x∥1
k = argmaxk |zk|
Mapped 1-norm
{±p1, . . . , ±pd}
∥Pz∥∞
sign(pT
k z)pk,
∥P −1x∥1
k = argmaxi |pT
i z|
Group norm
n
1
√
|G1|eG1, . . . ,
1
√
|GK|eGK
o
maxk ∥zGk∥2
1
√
|Gk|eGk,
PK
i=1 ∥xGi∥2,
k = argmaxk ∥zGk∥2
TV norm
{bk}d
k=1 ∪{c1 : c ≥0}
∥D†z∥∞if z ∈range(DT ),
bk,
∥Dx∥1
βk = (1k, 0n−k)
+∞else. k = argmaxi |(D†z)i|
bk = βk −1
nβT
k 1 In particular, for any constant vector x, ∥x∥TV = 0. This adds an unbounded direction for the support function;
specifically or any constant vector x, ∥x∥TV = 0. This adds an unbounded direction for the support function; σP(z) =
(
∥u∥∞
if z = DT u,
+∞
else, σP(z) =
(
∥u∥∞
if z = DT u,
+∞
else, and thus the LMO is not always defined. Note here that if z ∈range(DT ), then u = D(DT D)−1z is uniquely
determined; this inspires an “effective band-aid” to deal with directions of recession. and thus the LMO is not always defined. Note here that if z ∈range(DT ), then u = D(DT D)−1z is uniquely
determined; this inspires an “effective band-aid” to deal with directions of recession. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach (Note that
computing the dual norm, and thus the LMO, is comparatively computationally cheap / trivial.) ▶Example 17 (Nuclear norm). For a matrix X ∈Rm×n, the nuclear norm ∥X∥∗, defined as the sum of singular
values of matrix X, can be expressed as a gauge over the infinite set P0 = {uvT : u ∈Rm, v ∈Rn}. Because P0 is not a finite set, screening in this scenario will most likely not be very efficient, or even useful. However, CGM is indeed frequently applied to this version of P0, in order to promote low-rank matrix solutions,
and applying P-CGM to spectral problems is a central application in [69]. In particular, while computing the
nuclear norm requires a full spectral calculation, computing the dual norm, the spectral norm, is often much
cheaper using fast spectral methods, and can often be compressible [70]. Table 2 summarizes these examples and key properties. Gauges and support functions for convex sets are
fundamental objects in convex analysis, and are discussed more by [8, 30, 32, 60]. ▶Example 18 (Total variation (TV) “norm”). We now investigate a case where P0 contains a direction of
recession, which introduces some ambiguity into our construct. Specifically, we investigate the TV norm, which
is often used in signal processing as a “smoothing regularizer”: ∥x∥TV =
n
X
i=2
|xi −xi−1|. A common way to express this in matrix/vector notation is to introduce a difference matrix A common way to express this in matrix/vector notation is to introduce a difference matrix D =
I
0
−
0
I
∈Rd−1,d, and ∥x∥TV = ∥Dx∥1. This norm can be viewed as a gauge over atoms P0 = {b1, . . . , bd−1} ∪{c1 : c ∈R} where
for 1 the all-ones vector, bk = βk −1
nβT
k 1,
βk = (1, 1, . . . 1
|
{z
}
k
, 0, 0, ..0
| {z }
n−k
) ∈Rn. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 15 ▶Example 20 (Quadratic function). Suppose that f(x) = 1
2∥Ax∥2
2 + bT x. Then ▶Example 20 (Quadratic function). Suppose that f(x) = 1
2∥Ax∥2
2 + bT x. Then L =
L1 := (maxi ∥A:,i∥2)2,
κP = ∥· ∥1,
L2 := ∥A∥2
2,
κP = ∥· ∥2,
L∞:= (P
i ∥A:,i∥2)2,
κP = ∥· ∥∞. L =
L1 := (maxi ∥A:,i∥2)2,
κP = ∥· ∥1,
L2 := ∥A∥2
2,
κP = ∥· ∥2,
L∞:= (P
i ∥A:,i∥2)2,
κP = ∥· ∥∞. While norm bounds would give d2L1 ≥dL2 ≥L∞, the actual values in A might lead to tighter inequalities. While norm bounds would give d2L1 ≥dL2 ≥L∞, the actual values in A might lead to tighter inequalities. The relationship to usual smoothness is as follows. Suppose that f is L2-smooth in the usual sense (with
respect to ∥· ∥2). Then since diam(P)κP(x) ≥∥x∥2, it follows that L ≤diam(P)L2. In this way, we refine the
analysis of CGM by absorbing the usual “set size” term into L, which in certain cases may be smaller than
diam(P)L2. Proposition 21 (Uniqueness of gradient). If (25) holds and 0 ∈int P, then ∇f(x∗) is unique at th The same logical argument as before applies, as “smoothness” in the primal corresponds to “strong convexity”
(w.r.t. ∥· ∥∞) in the dual. 3.1.1
Gauges with directions of recessions The recession cone of P [8, 60] is defined as rec(P) = {r : cr ∈P ∀c ≥0}. Whenever P has a direction of recession, CGM struggles as the LMO can return an infinite atom. We offer to
isolate optimization over this set separately. In particular, suppose P0 = P′
0 ∪K,
P′
0 ∩K = ∅, where P′
0 is a finite set, and thus defining P as the convex hull of P′
0 ensures that P is compact. Then we
rewrite (20) as ize
),y∈K f(x + y) + φ(κP(x))
(2 (24) minimize
x∈cone(P),y∈K f(x + y) + φ(κP(x)) where cone(P) := {αx : α ∈R+, x ∈P} is the conic hull of P. At each iteration, x takes a conditional gradient
step, and y is updated through a full minimization. (In the case of the TV norm, this simply means that the
LMO is applied to a de-meaned bx = x −1
dxT 1.) Since the portion of the solution in K is minimized exactly at
each step, from this point on we only consider the support recovery properties for recovering the atoms in P′
0. where cone(P) := {αx : α ∈R+, x ∈P} is the conic hull of P. At each iteration, x takes a conditional gradient
step, and y is updated through a full minimization. (In the case of the TV norm, this simply means that the
LMO is applied to a de-meaned bx = x −1
dxT 1.) Since the portion of the solution in K is minimized exactly at
each step, from this point on we only consider the support recovery properties for recovering the atoms in P′
0. ▷Assumption 4 (Atomic set conditions). P0 = P′
0 ∪K where P′
0 is a finite set of atoms and K is the
recession cone; moreover, P′
0 ∩K = ∅. We denote P = conv(P′
0). ▷Assumption 4 (Atomic set conditions). P0 = P′
0 ∪K where P′
0 is a finite set of atoms and K is the
recession cone; moreover, P′
0 ∩K = ∅. We denote P = conv(P′
0). Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 3.2
Generalized smoothness To ensure the uniqueness of dsuppP(−∇f(x∗)) and to give a useful gap bound, we again need a notion of
smoothness on f. We again use our unusual twist on the gauge penalty. ▶Definition 19. A function f : Rd →R is L-smooth with respect to P if for all x, y ∈Rd: f(x) −f(y) ≤∇f(y)T (x −y) + L
2 κP(x −y)2. (25) The purpose of this generalized notion is that sometimes, given the data, tighter bounds can be computed [54]. It is similar in spirit to the notion of relative smoothness [3, 47] which facilitates the analysis of generalized
proximal gradient methods, where the 2-norm squared proximity measure is replaced by a Bregman divergence. For CGM, it is more computationally efficient to consider generalized gauges as the penalty generalization,
which we incorporate to the generalized smoothness definition. Additionally, the subadditivity property of gauges
assists with bounding the iterates, a crucial step in the convergence proof. Assumption 5 (Generalized smoothness). The convex function f is L-smooth w.r.t. eP := P ∪(−P Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method This is the gauge equivalent of “nonzero primal gives maximal dual”, and is referred to in [27] as alignment. We now generalize the definition of dual support from (17): dsuppP(x) := {p : −∇f(x)T p = σP(−∇f(x))}, and Property 22 says that for any x, suppP(x) ⊆dsuppP(x). Finally, as in the previous section, we express
this distance as δmin(x∗), where δp(x) = σ(−∇f(x)) + pT ∇f(x),
δmin(x) = min
p∈P{δp(x) : p ̸∈suppP(x)} for any support of x. In particular, δmin(x∗) = 0 means the problem is degenerate. 3.3
Generalized support recovery Given a solution to (21), define the decomposition of x with respect to P0 as tuples cp, p, extracted via the
mapping coeffP(x, p) = cp. The support of x with respect to P0 is suppP(x) = {p : coeffP(x, p) > 0 in (21)}. (26) For general P, neither the decomposition nor the support of x is unique. As before, we say the support recovery
is achieved if one such support suppP(x∗) of the limiting point x(t) →x∗∈X ∗is revealed. The reduction to
the support definition in the previous section occurs when P0 = {±e1, . . . , ±ed} the signed standard basis. Then
suppP(x) is unique, and explicitly suppP(x) = {sign(xi) ei : xi ̸= 0}. ▶Proposition 22 (Support optimality condition). Consider the general convex sparse optimization problem (20)
where φ : R+ →R+ is a monotonically nondecreasing function. Then for any x∗a minimizer of (20), (27) −∇f(x∗)T x∗= κP(x∗)σP(−∇f(x∗)). and and p ∈supp(x∗) ⇒−∇f(x∗)T p = σP(−∇f(x∗)). (28) 16 3.4
Duality and gap For φ monotonically nondecreasing, the convex function h(x) = φ(κP(x)) has conjugate h∗(z) = φ∗(σP(z)). This
gives the primal-dual pair (P-convex)
minx,y,w
f(w) + φ∗(κP(x))
st
w = x + y, y ∈K
(D-convex)
maxz
−f ∗(−z) −φ∗(σP(z))
st
z ∈K◦ (P-convex)
minx,y,w
f(w) + φ∗(κP(x))
st
w = x + y, y ∈K
(D-convex)
maxz
−f ∗(−z) −φ∗(σP(z))
st
z ∈K◦ where K◦is the polar cone of K. The duality gap between (P-convex) and (D-convex) can be w gap(x, y, z) = f(x + y) + h(x) + f ∗(−z) −h∗(z) + ιK◦(z) where ιK◦(z) = +∞if z is not dual-feasible, and 0 otherwise. ▶Lemma 23 (Feasible gradient). Take z := −∇xf(x + y). Then z = −∇yf(x + y). Additionally, if y =
argminy′∈K f(x + y′) then z ∈K◦. roof. The first part is true from chain rule. Then by optimality condition, z is in the normal cone zT (y −y′) ≤0,
∀y′ ∈K. zT (y −y′) ≤0,
∀y′ ∈K. nce 0 ∈K, this implies zT y ≤0, which means z ∈K◦. Since 0 ∈K, this implies zT y ≤0, which means z ∈K◦. From Lemma 23, the LMO step acquires s where for z := −∇xf(x + y), −zT s + h(s) = min
s′
−zT s′ + h(s) = −h∗(z). −zT s + h(s) = min
s′
−zT s′ + h(s) = −h∗(z). Additionally, by Fenchel–Young’s inequality, we know that f(x) + f ∗(∇f(x)) = ∇f(x)T x, and thus we can
simplify the gap to an online-computable quantity Additionally, by Fenchel–Young’s inequality, we know that f(x) + f ∗(∇f(x)) = ∇f(x)T x, and thus we can
simplify the gap to an online-computable quantity gap(x, y, ∇xf(x + y)) = −∇xf(x + y)T (s −x) + h(x) −h(s). ▶Proposition 24 (Gap bounds gradient error). Given a primal feasible x and denote the optimum variable as
x∗= argmin
x′
min
y∈K f(x + y) + h(x). ▶Proposition 24 (Gap bounds gradient error). Given a primal feasible x and denote the optimum variable as
x∗= argmin
x′
min
y∈K f(x + y) + h(x). x∗= argmin
x′
min
y∈K f(x + y) + h(x). x∗= argmin
x′
min
y∈K f(x + y) + h(x). Furthermore, denote y = argminy′∈K f(x + y′) and y∗= argminy′∈K f(x∗+ y′). Then the duality gap bounds
the gradient error Furthermore, denote y = argminy′∈K f(x + y′) and y∗= argminy′∈K f(x∗+ y′). 3.5
Invariance One appealing feature of the CGM is that the iteration scheme and analysis can be done in a way that is
invariant to both linear scaling and translation. However when the gauge function is not used as an indicator,
this translation invariance vanishes; in general, κP(x) ̸= κP+{b}(x + b). Therefore the generalized problem
formulation (32) is only linear (not translation) invariant. ▶Example 26. Consider κP(x) = ∥x∥1 for x ∈R2. Take specifically x = (−1, −1) and b = (1, 1). Then
κP(x) = 2, but κP+{b}(x + b) = κP+{b}(0) = 0 ̸= 2. ▶Proposition 27 (Invariance properties). Define Q = AP, and f(x) = g(Ax). Define w = Ax where A has full
column rank. Then, using (22) and chain rule, the following hold f(x) = g(w) and ∇f(x) = AT ∇g(w), f( )
g( )
f( )
g( ),
κP(x) = κQ(w) and σP(−∇f(x)) = σQ(−∇g(w)), P( )
Q( )
P(
f( ))
Q(
LMOQ(−∇g(w)) = A LMOP(−∇f(x)), f(x) = g(Ax + b) is L-smooth w.r.t. P iffg is L-smooth w.r.t. Q. 4 3.4
Duality and gap Then the duality gap bounds
the gradient error gapP(x, y, −∇f(x + y)) ≥1
2Lσe
P(∇f(x + y) −∇f(x∗+ y∗))2. (29)
Proof. Since the conjugate of h(x) = φ(κP(x)) is h∗(z) = φ∗(σP(z)), then
φ∗(σP(z)) = sup
x xT z −φ(κP(x)) ≥(x∗)T z −φ(κP(x∗)). (30) gapP(x, y, −∇f(x + y)) ≥1
2Lσe
P(∇f(x + y) −∇f(x∗+ y∗))2. (29) roof. Since the conjugate of h(x) = φ(κP(x)) is h∗(z) = φ∗(σP(z)), then (30) Then denoting z = −∇f(x + y), Then denoting z = −∇f(x + y), Then denoting z = −∇f(x + y), gapP(x, y, z) = f(x + y) + f ∗(−z)
|
{z
}
Fenchel Young
+ φ(κP(x)) + φ∗(σP(−∇f(x)))
|
{z
}
(30)
,
≥(x∗−x)T z +
yT ∇f(x)
|
{z
}
y∈K,∇f(x)∈K◦
+ φ(κP(x)) −φ(κP(x∗))
|
{z
}
convexity of h
,
≥(x −x∗)T z + φ(κP(x)) −φ(κP(x∗)) {z
convexity of h Proof. This is a direct consequence to Theorems 33 and 35. Proof. This is a direct consequence to Theorems 33 and 35. Proof. This is a direct consequence to Theorems 33 and 35. Proof. This is a direct consequence to Theorems 33 and 35. Note that Theorem 25 imposes no conditions on the sequence θ(k), or choice of φ, f, etc., except L-smoothness
of f. In other words, for any method where the gap is easily computable and its convergence rate known, then a
corresponding screening rule and support identification rate automatically follow. Additionally, computing L
may be challenging, depending on κP; as shown previously, at the very least it may require a full pass over the
data. However, this is a one-time calculation per dataset, and can be estimated if data are assumed to be drawn
from specific distributions (as in sensing applications). Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 17 since K and K◦are polar cones and thus yT ∇f(x) ≤0. Next, recognizing that h(x) = φ(κP(x)) is convex, we
pick −∇f(x∗+ y∗) ∈∂h(x∗) and use convexity to further reduce to the result: since K and K◦are polar cones and thus yT ∇f(x) ≤0. Next, recognizing that h(x) = φ(κP(x)) is convex, we
pick −∇f(x∗+ y∗) ∈∂h(x∗) and use convexity to further reduce to the result: z) ≥(x −x∗)T (z∗−z) ≥1
2Lσe
P(z∗−z)2. ◀ gapP(x, y, z) ≥(x −x∗)T (z∗−z) ≥1
2Lσe
P(z∗−z)2. ▶Theorem 25 (Support identification of screened P-CGM). Given Assumptions 1, 2, 4, 5, then the screening rule
for convex penalties I(0) = P0,
I(t) = I(t−1) \ {p ∈P0 : p ∈I0(x) for x = x(t)}, is safe and convergent: I(t) ⊇suppP(x∗), ∀t,
and
I(t) = suppP(x∗)(x∗), t ≥t′, I(t) ⊇suppP(x∗), ∀t,
and
I(t) = suppP(x∗)(x∗), t ≥t′,
where t′ is such that I(t) ⊇suppP(x∗), ∀t,
and
I(t) = suppP(x∗)(x∗), t ≥t′,
where t′ is such that where t′ is such that r
L min
i≤t′ gap(x(i), −∇f(x(i)); x(i)) < δmin/3, (31) which happens at a rate t′ = O(1/(δ2
min)). which happens at a rate t′ = O(1/(δ2
min)). which happens at a rate t′ = O(1/(δ2
min)). Proof. This is a direct consequence to Theorems 33 and 35. ◀ Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method ▶Lemma 28 (Smoothness equivalences). Suppose that f is L-smooth with respect to P. Then the following also
holds:
1
E
i holds: 1. Expansiveness (∇f(x) −∇f(y))T (x −y) ≥1
2L(σP(∇f(x) −∇f(y))2 + σP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2),
(33) (∇f(x) −∇f(y))T (x −y) ≥1
2L(σP(∇f(x) −∇f(y))2 + σP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2),
(33) (33) 2. Strongly convex conjugate f(y) −f(x) ≥∇f(x)T (y −x) + 1
2LσP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2. (34) f(y) −f(x) ≥∇f(x)T (y −x) + 1
2LσP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2. (34) The proof is in Appendix A. The proof is in Appendix A. The proof is in Appendix A. ▶Lemma 29 (Uniqueness of gradient). Suppose Assumption 4 holds. If (25) holds, then at the global optimum
x∗, −∇f(x∗) = z∗+ w∗where z∗∈K◦is unique and zT w∗∈K. Proof. Assume that f(x) = f(x∗) for some x ̸= x∗, x feasible. Then by optimality conditions,
∇f(x∗)T (x∗−x) ≤0, and thus f(x) −f(x∗)
|
{z
}
=0
≥∇f(x∗)T (x −x∗)
|
{z
}
≥0
+ 1
2LσP(∇f(x) −∇f(x∗))2, which implies that σP(∇f(x) −∇f(x∗)) = 0. This means that the vector w = ∇f(x) −∇f(x∗) cannot have any
component in cone(K◦), e.g. it is orthogonal to any z ∈K. ◀ which implies that σP(∇f(x) −∇f(x∗)) = 0. This means that the vector w = ∇f(x) −∇f(x∗) cannot have any
component in cone(K◦), e.g. it is orthogonal to any z ∈K. ◀ 4.1
Support recovery As it was for κP, the domain of rP is cone(P). However, the support of κP(x) and rP(x) are often not equivalent. As it was for κP, the domain of rP is cone(P). However, the support of κP(x) and rP(x) are often not equivalent. ▶Example 30 (Different optimal support). Consider κP(x) = ∥x∥1 and rP(x) =
1
√
2
P
i
p
|xi|. The constrained
optimization problem ▶Example 30 (Different optimal support). Consider κP(x) = ∥x∥1 and rP(x) =
1
√
2
P
i
p
|xi|. The constrained
optimization problem minimize
x
f(x) := −4x1 −3x2 −4x3
subject to
κP(x) ≤1
has optimal solution x∗= (1/2, 0, 1/2). We verify this from the normal cone condition, where
∇f(x∗)T (x −x∗) ≥−∥∇f(x∗)∥∞∥x∥1
|
{z
}
≤4
+4 ≥0. minimize
x
f(x) := −4x1 −3x2 −4x3
subject to
κP(x) ≤1
has optimal solution x∗= (1/2, 0, 1/2). We verify this from the normal cone condition, where
∇f(x∗)T (x −x∗) ≥−∥∇f(x∗)∥∞∥x∥1
|
{z
}
≤4
+4 ≥0. Note that rP(x∗) = 1 as well. However, taking x = (0,
√
2, 0) also yields rP(x) = 1, and has a lower objective
value f(x) = −3
√
2 ≈−4.24 < −4 = f(x∗). ▶Example 31 (Different gauge support). The problem can be made even worse, in that the support of x w.r.t. rP may not even intersect with that w.r.t. κP. Suppose that P0 =
1
1
,
0
3
,
3
0
, and consider x = (6, 6). Then, taking γ(c) = √c, we have two options x = (0, 3) + (3, 0),
κP(x) = 2,
rP(x) = 2
√
2 ≈2.8,
x = 6 · (1, 1),
κP(x) = 6,
rP(x) =
√
6 ≈2.4. In other words, the support suppP(x) as defined in (26) may not be the support created by the nonconvex
gauge rP(x), which is often sparser. More generally, rP(x) does not act merely as a concave transformation on
the weights cp in κP, as even the atoms themselves may be selected differently. However, it is worth noting that
this scenario does not happen for the ℓ1 norm or the TV norm, which have unique and consistent supports
across choices of monotonically increasing γ. 4
RP-CGM for general nonconvex sparse optimization Finally, we consider the complete RP-CGM, which expands the method presented in Section 2 to generalized
gauge penalties. The fully generalized optimization problem is rP(x) =
min
cp≥0
X
p∈P0
γ(cp) :
X
p∈P0
cpp = x
. (32) min
x
f(x) + φ(rP(x))
|
{z
}
h(x)
,
rP(x) =
min
cp≥0
X
p∈P0
γ(cp) :
X
p∈P0
cpp = x
. (32) (32) By imposing the concave transformation on cp, we effectively gain the same effect as the nonconvex regularizer
on the ℓ1 norm in Section 2. For the most part, much of the analysis will seem very similar to that in Section 2,
especially in the proofs of key concepts, which we therefore put in the appendix to avoid repetitiveness. We also
use much of the same assumptions (1, 2, 3) and analyses for the scalar functions γ and φ. By imposing the concave transformation on cp, we effectively gain the same effect as the nonconvex regularizer
on the ℓ1 norm in Section 2. For the most part, much of the analysis will seem very similar to that in Section 2,
especially in the proofs of key concepts, which we therefore put in the appendix to avoid repetitiveness. We also
use much of the same assumptions (1, 2, 3) and analyses for the scalar functions γ and φ. 18 4.4
Convergence ▶Proposition 32 (Residual). Denoting gapP(x; x) the gap at x with reference x, then
gapP(x; x) ≥0 ∀x,
gapP(x; x) = 0 ⇐⇒x is a stationary point of (3). The proof follows closely that of Proposition 8; see Appendix A for full details. ▶Proposition 32 (Residual). Denoting gapP(x; x) the gap at x with reference x, then
gapP(x; x) ≥0 ∀x,
gapP(x; x) = 0 ⇐⇒x is a stationary point of (3). The proof follows closely that of Proposition 8; see Appendix A for full details. ▶Proposition 32 (Residual). Denoting gapP(x; x) the gap at x with reference x, then
gapP(x; x) ≥0 ∀x,
gapP(x; x) = 0 ⇐⇒x is a stationary point of (3). The proof follows closely that of Proposition 8; see Appendix A for full details. of follows closely that of Proposition 8; see Appendix A for full details. ▶Theorem 33 (Convergence). Consider G large enough such that for all t < 6B, ∆(t)t ≤G and G > 24A. Given Assumptions 1, 2, 4, 5, with iterates x(t) + y(t) from algorithm 2, using θ(t) = 2/(t + 1), then ▶Theorem 33 (Convergence). Consider G large enough such that for all t < 6B, ∆(t)t ≤G and G > 24A. Given Assumptions 1, 2, 4, 5, with iterates x(t) + y(t) from algorithm 2, using θ(t) = 2/(t + 1), then ▶Theorem 33 (Convergence). Consider G large enough such that for all t < 6B, ∆(t)t ≤G and G > 24A. Given Assumptions 1, 2, 4, 5, with iterates x(t) + y(t) from algorithm 2, using θ(t) = 2/(t + 1), then 1
and
min
i≤t res(x(i)) ≤
3G
2 log(2)(t + 1). ∆(t) ≤
G
t + 1
and
min
i≤t res(x(i)) ≤
3G
2 log(2)(t + 1). ∆(t) ≤
G
t + 1
and
min
i≤t res(x(i)) ≤
3G
2 log(2)(t + 1). The details of the proof closely mirror steps in previous works, and thus we give the explicit details in
Appendix B. Let us compare Theorem 33 with the usual rates for CGM. In [39], the primal convergence rate for vanilla
CGM (with noiseless gradients) is given as ∆(t) ≤2Cf
t+2 where Cf is a curvature constant that depends on the
conditioning of f and the size of P. 4.3
RP-CGM In the case that P0 includes directions of recession, we treat them separately by writing P0 = P′
0 ∪K where
P′
0 contains the important (finite-sized) atoms and K contains directions of recession. We define the reweighted
atomic set for a given reference point x as P0(u) =
1
γ′(coeffP(u, p))p : p ∈P′
0
,
P(u) = conv(P0(u)). P0(u) =
1
γ′(coeffP(u, p))p : p ∈P′
0
,
P(u) = conv(P0(u)). Then rP(s; u) = κP(u)(s), with corresponding reweighted support functio Then rP(s; u) = κP(u)(s), with corresponding reweighted support function = κP(u)(s), with corresponding reweighted support function σP(u)(z) = max
p∈P0
pT z
γ′(coeffP(u, p)). (37)
At
h it
ti
t k
li
d
diti
l
di
t t
t
d
l i
th
i ht d
ti
i
ti σP(u)(z) = max
p∈P0
pT z
γ′(coeffP(u, p)). σP(u)(z) = max
p∈P0
pT z
γ′(coeffP(u, p)). σP(u)(z) = max
p∈P0
pT z
γ′(coeffP(u, p)). (37) (37) max
p∈P0
p z
γ′(coeffP(u, p)). (37) At each iteration, we take a penalized conditional gradient step toward solving the reweighted gauge optimization
problem with dual (P-general)
minimize
x,y∈K
f(x + y) + φ(r0 + κP(x)(x)),
(D-general)
maximize
z∈K◦
−f ∗(−z) −φ∗(σP(x)(z)) + r0 · σP(x)(z). minimize
x,y∈K
f(x + y) + φ(r0 + κP(x)(x)), A description of the most generalized version of the reweighted method is given in Algorithm 2 A description of the most generalized version of the reweighted method is given in Algorithm 2. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 19 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 4.2
Stationary points We can rewrite (32), as the combined optimization problem over cp, p ∈P0: We can rewrite (32), as the combined optimization problem over cp, p ∈P0: f
X
p∈P0
cpp
! + φ
X
p∈P0
γ(cp)
|
{z
}
=:ξ
! . (35) The stationary points of (35) are x satisfying ∀p ∈P0 : 0 ∈∇f(x)T p + φ′(ξ) ∂γ(cp),
at x =
X
p∈P
cpp. (36) x)T p + φ′(ξ) ∂γ(cp),
at x =
X
p∈P
cpp. (36) ∀p ∈P0 : 0 ∈∇f(x)T p + φ′(ξ) ∂γ(cp),
at x =
X
p∈P
cpp. ∀p ∈P0 : 0 ∈∇f(x)T p + φ′(ξ) ∂γ(cp),
at x =
X
p∈P
cpp. (36) Our goal is to find a support of such a stationary point x∗. Given γ smooth everywhere except at 0, note the
close similarity between this and the support optimality conditions for convex gauges: cp > 0
⇒
−pT ∇f(x∗) = α γ′(cp)
(no wiggle room),
cp = 0
⇒
−pT ∇f(x∗) ∈α · [−∞, γmax]
(wiggle room exists). (no wiggle room), Here, the wiggle room condition looks asymmetric, but note that if p and −p is in P0, then cp = c−p = 0
implies −p∇f(x∗) ∈α · [−γmax, γmax], recovering the symmetric condition from Section 2. As before, since γ′ is
a decreasing function, a nonzero coefficient for x∗does not mean a maximal gradient inner product. 4.1
Support recovery Overall, the question of nonunique support of a given vector x over atoms P0 is an interesting one, but not a
focus of this paper, which focuses on cases where the support is always unique. 4.5
Invariance Finally, we investigate the linear invariance properties of RP-CGM. Specifically, we consider Q = AP, f(x) =
g(Ax), w = Ax, w = Ax, where A has full column rank. We will have preserved linear invariance if RP-CGM
applied to min
x {f(x) : x ∈P}
and
min
w {g(w) : w ∈Q} are equivalent. Assume additionally that both x, x ∈cone(P). Then the following hold. Penalty. rP(x) = rQ(w). This follows from noting that x =
X
p∈P
cpp ⇐⇒w =
X
p∈P
cp(Ap) =
X
q∈Q
c′
qq and in fact noting that the coefficients are equal (c′
q = cAp). and in fact noting that the coefficients are equal (c′
q = cAp). q
Stationarity. We construct P with columns containing the atoms in P′
0, and c such that x = Pc, w = Ax =
APc. P T ∂rP(x) = ∂rP(c)
rP(c)=rQ(c)
=
∂rQ(c) = P T AT ∂rQ(w). Additionally, for any stationary point x∗, if ∇f(x∗) ̸∈cone(P) then there exists a descent direction that
is uneffected by the penalty rP(x), and thus it must be that ∇f(x∗) ∈cone(P). By the same token,
AT ∇g(w∗) ∈cone(P). Therefore, the stationary conditions are equivalent: for x∗= Aw∗, 0 ∈∇f(x∗) + P T ∂rP(x∗) ⇐⇒0 ∈AT ∇g(w∗) + AT ∂rQ(w∗). Additionally, it can be shown through the chain rule that AP(x) = Q(w) and resP(x) = resQ(w). Overall, this
shows that the steps and analysis of RP-CGM are all invariant to linear transformations on x. 4.4
Convergence These players appear here in the form of the conditioning of f (quadratic in
L/µ), and implicitly σe
P (which grows proportionally with diam P). The new players ν0, γmin, and γmax account
for the penalty and nonconvex generalizations. 20
Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method
Algorithm 2 RP-CGM on general nonconvex sparse optimization
1: procedure RP-CGM(f, φ, γ, P0 = P′
0 ∪K, max iter T)
2:
Initialize with any x(0) ∈cone(P) where P is the convex hull of P′
0, y(0) ∈K. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 20 Algorithm 2 RP-CGM on general nonconvex sparse optimization 1: procedure RP-CGM(f, φ, γ, P0 = P′
0 ∪K, max iter T) 1: procedure RP-CGM(f, φ, γ, P0 = P′
0 ∪K, max iter T) 2:
Initialize with any x(0) ∈cone(P) where P is the convex hull of P′
0, y(0) ∈K. 3:
4:
for t = 1, . . . , T do
5:
Compute the projected negative gradient z = −∇f(x(t) + y(t)). 6:
Compute the reweighted atomic set P(x). 7:
Compute next atom s = ξp in two steps. ▷Pick next atom
8:
1. Compute direction p = LMOP(x)(z). 9:
2. Compute magnitude ξ = (φ∗)′(σP(z)). 10:
Update x(t+1) = (1 −θ(t))x(t) + θ(t)s where θ(t) = 2/(1 + t). ▷Merge
11:
Update y(t+1) = argminy∈K f(x(t+1) + y). ▷Recession component
return x(T ) + y(T ) 2:
Initialize with any x(0) ∈cone(P) where P is the convex hull of P′
0, y(0) ∈K. ▷Pick next atom ▷Pick next atom ▷Recession component 5.1
Sensing experiment We first compare the various CGM variants on a simple simulated sparse sensing problem (Figures 2 and 3). We
solve a least squares problem minimize
x
1
2m∥Ax −b∥2
2 + φ(rP(x)),
(39) minimize
x
1
2m∥Ax −b∥2
2 + φ(rP(x)), minimize
x
1
2m∥Ax −b∥2
2 + φ(rP(x)), (39) where A ∈Rm×n as Aij ∼N(0, 1/n) i.i.d. for i = 1, . . . , m, j = 1, . . . , n, and for a given x0 with 10% nonzero
sparsity, b = Ax0. Specifically, we pick m = n = 100, where perfect sensing is possible, and either sweep or tune
all the hyperparameters to investigate each case. An important modification needed to improve the stability of P-CGM and RP-CGM is to intensely diminish
the step size; in particular, using θ(t) = 2/(2 + t) is too aggressive, so instead we use θ(t) = 2/(2 + t + t0), where
t0 is another tuned hyperparameter. Note that in performance, this does not slow down the convergence or
sensing abilities of the P-CGM and RP-CGM, suggesting that this is a more appropriate step size sequence in
these regimes (and is still O(1/t)). All hyperparamters (α, ρ, t0) were tuned to present the best results for each
individual method. These two collections of figures are presented to illustrate several points: The gaps (left column) in all cases converges to 0 or machine precision at about a O(1/t) gaps (left column) in all cases converges to 0 or machine precision at about a O(1/t) rate. ( ) The screen error (right column), measured as the support difference between x(t) and x∗the final converged
point, eventually goes to 0, at a speed somewhat correlated with the “aggressiveness” of the method (where
RP-CGM is often more aggressive than P-CGM, but all three variants also depend heavily on choice of
hyperparameter). Note that higher ρ, smaller θ, and smaller α all correspond to more aggressive methods. The screen error (right column), measured as the support difference between x(t) and x∗the final converged
point, eventually goes to 0, at a speed somewhat correlated with the “aggressiveness” of the method (where
RP-CGM is often more aggressive than P-CGM, but all three variants also depend heavily on choice of
hyperparameter). Note that higher ρ, smaller θ, and smaller α all correspond to more aggressive methods. 5.1
Sensing experiment In contrast, the support error, measured as the support difference between x(t) and x0 the ground truth,
seems to have better performance when the method is less aggressive. It is hard to make sweeping conclusions,
but suggests that both metrics are essential to evaluate the success of sparse recovery methods. 5
Experiments In this section, we explore the convergence behavior and screening ability of P-CGM and RP-CGM on compressed
sensing (with ℓ1, group norm, and TV regularization), and on a sparse logistic regression task on a real world
dataset. The code for all the experiments is publicly available. 2 2 Code link: https://github.com/yifan0sun/rpcgm 4.6
Screening We now describe the gradient error measured in terms of this “dual gauge”, where the symmetrization eP := P∪−P
ensures that σe
P(z −z∗) = σe
P(z∗−z), bounding errors in both directions. ▶Proposition 34 (Gap bound on gradient error). Denote D(x) = rP(x) −rP(x∗) + rP(x; x) −rP(x∗; x) the
linearization error at x. Denoting x∗a stationary point of (32) and y(x) = argminy′∈K f(x + y′), then σe
P(∇f(x + y(x)) −∇f(x∗+ y(x∗))) ≤LD(x)
2γmin
+
s
L2D(x)2
4γ2
min
+ Lres(x) + LD(x)
σe
P(∇f(x + y(x)))
γmin
. )
σe
P(∇f(x + y(x)))
γmin
. The linearization error D(x) = 0 when the regularizer is convex. The proof is similar to that for Proposition 11,
and is detailed in Appendix C. then p ̸∈suppP(x∗), where x∗is the optimal variable in (20). In the convex case, D(x) = 0, and thus we pick ϵ = 0 in our screening rule. In this scenario, not only does
this screening rule achieve finite-iteration support identification, but the finite time t depends directly on δmin. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 21 ▶Theorem 35 (Dual screening). For any x and some choice of ϵ > 0, define the screened set as Iϵ(x) = {p ∈P0 : σe
P(∇f(x)) + pT ∇f(x) > ϵ + 2
p
Lres(x) + ϵ}. (38) Then given Assumptions 1, 2, and 5, if Then given Assumptions 1, 2, and 5, if ϵ ≥LD(x)
γmin
max
1
2, LD(x)
4γmin
+ σe
P(∇f(x))
then p ̸∈suppP(x∗), where x∗is the optimal variable in (20). 5.2
Other gauges We now pursue the sensing problem for more creative choices of P0. First, we consider the group norm in cases where when x0 has a “pulse-like” structure, in that the signal has
blocks of nonzero activity, separated by long spans of zero activity. This can be modeled as x0 = P
i si
0 where
si
0 is a pulse signal across the ith overlapping window. Figure 4 shows the trajectory for such an experiment,
where the complementary characteristics between the primal variable and dual norms is visible, as over time, the
nonzero blocks of the primal correspond to the maximal blocks of the dual. Next, we consider the total variation penalization, where κP(x) = P
i |xi −xi−1|, and what is plotted is the
cumulative sum of the demeaned z(t) = −∇f(x(t)). Note that at optimality, the peaks of this dual atom exactly
match the “flip points” of x(t). Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 22 Figure 2 Small sensing experiment, CGM and P-CGM. The first row shows CGM, with
φ(s) = ιs<α. The next three rows show P-CGM where φ(s) =
ρ
psp, for various values of p and
corresponding optimal ρ. For the P-CGM experiments, we also used an iteration offset of t0 = 1000. Offset was not needed for CGM (t0 = 0). Figure 2 Small sensing experiment, CGM and P-CGM. The first row shows CGM, with
φ(s) = ιs<α. The next three rows show P-CGM where φ(s) =
ρ
psp, for various values of p and
corresponding optimal ρ. For the P-CGM experiments, we also used an iteration offset of t0 = 1000. Offset was not needed for CGM (t0 = 0). Figure 2 Small sensing experiment, CGM and P-CGM. The first row shows CGM, with
φ(s) = ιs<α. The next three rows show P-CGM where φ(s) =
ρ
psp, for various values of p and
corresponding optimal ρ. For the P-CGM experiments, we also used an iteration offset of t0 = 1000. Offset was not needed for CGM (t0 = 0). 23 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Figure 3 Small sensing experiment, RP-CGM. We again use φ(s) = ρ
psp, and use a piecewise
LSP function for RP-CGM (γ(w) = log(1 + |w|/θ) if |w| ≤c, and γ(w) = γ′(c)(w −c) for |w| > c). Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 24 20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 3
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 10
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 30
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 100
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 300
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 1000
0
0.5
1
1.5
t = 3
20
40
60
80
0
1
2
3
t = 10
0
50
100
0
0.05
0.1
t = 30
20
40
60
80
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
t = 100
0
50
100
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
t = 300
20
40
60
80
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
t = 1000
20
40
60
80
Figure 4 Trajectory of primal variable and dual group norms. Here we investigate RP-CGM
where θ = 1/2, ρ = 0.01, and p = 2. For stability, t0 = 100. The ground truth x0 contains 3 “pulses”,
e.g. areas where it is nonzero, and the goal is to fit x(t) to x0, using this group structure prior. 50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 3
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 10
20
40
60
80 100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 30
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 100
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
x
t = 300
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
x
t = 1000
-30
-20
-10
0
t = 3
50
100
0
5000
10000
t = 10
0
50
100
0
1
2
109
t = 30
20
40
60
80 100
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
1012 t = 100
0
50
100
-0.5
0
0.5
t = 300
50
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
t = 1000
50
100
Figure 5 Trajectory of primal variable and dual variables for TV penalty. Here we investigate
RP-CGM where θ = 3/4, ρ = 0.25, and p = 2. For stability, t0 = 100. The ground truth x0 contains 3
flips, and is otherwise smooth. As before, the goal is to fit x(t) to x0, using this group structure prior. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method As before, the goal is to fit x(t) to x0, using this group structure prior. 0
500
1000
iterations
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
train F1
0
500
1000
iterations
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
test F1
CGM
PCGM-1
PCGM-2
RPCGM-1
RPCGM-2 100
102
iterations
10-4
10-2
100
102
104
gap
100
102
iterations
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
obj
0
500
1000
iterations
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
train F1
0
500
1000
iterations
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
test F1
CGM
PCGM-1
PCGM-2
RPCGM-1
RPCGM-2
Figure 6 Dorothea classification experiment For CGM, α = 100. PCGM-1 and RPCGM-1 uses
p = 2, and PCGM-2 and RPCGM-2 uses p = 5. Additionally, RPCGM-1 and RPCGM-2 both use
θ = c = 1/2. 100
102
iterations
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
obj 100
102
iterations
10-4
10-2
100
102
104
gap Figure 6 Dorothea classification experiment For CGM, α = 100. PCGM-1 and RPCGM-1 uses
p = 2, and PCGM-2 and RPCGM-2 uses p = 5. Additionally, RPCGM-1 and RPCGM-2 both use
θ = c = 1/2. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 3
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 10
20
40
60
80 100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 30
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 100
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
x
t = 300
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
x
t = 1000
-30
-20
-10
0
t = 3
50
100
0
5000
10000
t = 10
0
50
100
0
1
2
109
t = 30
20
40
60
80 100
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
1012 t = 100
0
50
100
-0.5
0
0.5
t = 300
50
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
t = 1000
50
100
Figure 5 Trajectory of primal variable and dual variables for TV penalty. Here we investigate
RP-CGM where θ = 3/4, ρ = 0.25, and p = 2. For stability, t0 = 100. The ground truth x0 contains 3
flips, and is otherwise smooth. As before, the goal is to fit x(t) to x0, using this group structure prior. 50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 3
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 10
20
40
60
80 100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 30
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 100
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
x
t = 300
50
100
-1
-0.5
0
x
t = 1000
-30
-20
-10
0
t = 3
50
100
0
5000
10000
t = 10
0
50
100
0
1
2
109
t = 30
20
40
60
80 100
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
1012 t = 100
0
50
100
-0.5
0
0.5
t = 300
50
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
t = 1000
50
100
Figure 5 Trajectory of primal variable and dual variables for TV penalty. Here we investigate
RP-CGM where θ = 3/4 ρ = 0 25 and p = 2 For stability t0 = 100 The ground truth x0 contains 3 Figure 5 Trajectory of primal variable and dual variables for TV penalty. Here we investigate
RP-CGM where θ = 3/4, ρ = 0.25, and p = 2. For stability, t0 = 100. The ground truth x0 contains 3
flips, and is otherwise smooth. 3 Our F1 scores are not comparable to SOTA on this task, as we use a weak classifier (better models, like boosted decision trees,
do not have differentiable f) and do not account for label imbalance. It is possible that the score may be improved with more
involved data science techniques, which is not the focus of this work. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 3
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 10
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 30
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 100
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 300
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 1000
0
0.5
1
1.5
t = 3
20
40
60
80
0
1
2
3
t = 10
0
50
100
0
0.05
0.1
t = 30
20
40
60
80
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
t = 100
0
50
100
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
t = 300
20
40
60
80
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
t = 1000
20
40
60
80
Figure 4 Trajectory of primal variable and dual group norms. Here we investigate RP-CGM
where θ = 1/2, ρ = 0.01, and p = 2. For stability, t0 = 100. The ground truth x0 contains 3 “pulses”,
e.g. areas where it is nonzero, and the goal is to fit x(t) to x0, using this group structure prior. 20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 3
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 10
20
40
60
80
100
-0.5
0
0.5
1
x
t = 30 0
0.5
1
1.5
t = 3
20
40
60
80
0
1
2
3
t = 10
0
50
100
0
0.05
0.1
t = 30
20
40
60
80 Figure 4 Trajectory of primal variable and dual group norms. Here we investigate RP-CGM
where θ = 1/2, ρ = 0.01, and p = 2. For stability, t0 = 100. The ground truth x0 contains 3 “pulses”,
e.g. areas where it is nonzero, and the goal is to fit x(t) to x0, using this group structure prior. 5.2
Other gauges In
addition to what is labeled in the figure, we use ρ = 0.5, 0.1, 0.01, 0.001 for p = 1.25, 2, 5, 10 respectively
(all tuned for best performance). Additionally, we have t0 = 1000. Figure 3 Small sensing experiment, RP-CGM. We again use φ(s) = ρ
psp, and use a piecewise
LSP function for RP-CGM (γ(w) = log(1 + |w|/θ) if |w| ≤c, and γ(w) = γ′(c)(w −c) for |w| > c). In
addition to what is labeled in the figure, we use ρ = 0.5, 0.1, 0.01, 0.001 for p = 1.25, 2, 5, 10 respectively
(all tuned for best performance). Additionally, we have t0 = 1000. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Proof of Lemma 2 Proof. Assume that φ0 is as large as possible; e.g., there exists some finite ξ0 where φ(ξ0) = µξ2
0 −φ0. By
convexity, for all ν ∈∂φ(ξ), φ(ξ) −φ(ξ0) ≤ν(ξ −ξ0). Additionally, by the assumption, Additionally, by the assumption, µξ2 −φ0 ≤φ(ξ),
∀ξ. Therefore, Therefore, µ(ξ2 −ξ2
0) ≤φ(ξ) −φ(ξ0) ≤ν(ξ −ξ0), and therefore, for ξ ≥ξ0, ν ≥µ(ξ + ξ0)(ξ −ξ0)
ξ −ξ0
= µξ + µξ0
⇐⇒
ξ ≤µ−1ν −ξ0. ν ≥µ(ξ + ξ0)(ξ −ξ0)
ξ −ξ0
= µξ + µξ0
⇐⇒
ξ ≤µ−1ν −ξ0. Thus, for any ξ, ν ∈∂φ(ξ) must satisfy ξ ≤max{ξ0, µ−1ν −ξ0} ≤µ−1ν + ξ0. By Fenchel Young, this must apply
to all ξ ∈∂φ∗(ν). ◀ Thus, for any ξ, ν ∈∂φ(ξ) must satisfy ξ ≤max{ξ0, µ−1ν −ξ0} ≤µ−1ν + ξ0. By Fenchel Young, this must apply
to all ξ ∈∂φ∗(ν). ◀ 5.3
Dorothea experiment Finally, we consider a “real world” experiment, in which we use these methods to classify the Dorothea
dataset [35]. Sparse optimization is essential in this application, which has only 1950 samples but 100000
attributes. Additionally, the dataset is heavily imbalanced, with very few positive labels. We run sparse logistic
regression over this dataset, and illustrate the performance of the different methods in Figure 6. Note that the
best implementation reaches an F1 score of about 0.3; without regularization, logistic regression achieves a test
F1 score of about 0.16, highlighting the importance of sparse regularization.3 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 25 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 6
Discussion This work considers two variations of the conditional gradient method (CGM): the P-CGM, which accommodates
gauge-based penalties in place of constraints, and the RP-CGM, which allows concave transformations of the
gauges. The gauges may be induced by compact sets, but also accomodate “simple” directions of recession. We give a convergence rate to a stationary point, and propose a gradient screening rule and support recovery
guarantee. Compared with proximal methods, these CGM-based methods often have a much cheaper per-iteration
cost; e.g. in the group norm, computing the LMO (without reweighting) is trivial compared to even computing
the gauge function itself. Additionally, the almost-for-free computation of the gap and residual quantity makes
screening a very small computational addition. The key challenge in showing the convergence of these methods is controlling the size of each s(t). This was
trivial in the CGM case when s(t) was constrained in a compact set; when transformed to a penalty, we require
a minimum amount of curvature of φ at ξ →+∞, and we restrict γ to only having strict concavity over a finite
support. However, as shown in the numerical results, these restrictions do not greatly inhibit the sparsifying
effects of the penalty functions. After determining convergence behavior, we then implement gap-based screening, which allows for knowledge
of the true solution’s sparsity pattern without completing optimization. This is a deliberate tool to reduce
computational cost, and can be used in a number of ways. For nonzero sparsity or group sparsity, we can simply
avoid computation over the “determined zeros”. For problems where the solution is significantly sparse, a 2-stage
solving technique can be used, where after enough zero components have been screened away, the problem can
be solved over the reduced support using a more powerful (e.g. 2nd order) method. And, for problems with a
very large number of atoms that need to be explicitly queried at each iteration (e.g. in submodular optimization)
we can significantly reduce the search space. Therefore we believe these techniques have many practical benefits
in a number of applications. Finally, we do not incorporate away step [34, 42]. In implementation, they are somewhat orthogonal to
the extensions provided in this work; an away-step implementation of P-CGM and RP-CGM can be directly
implemented, and its analysis is a subject for future work. Proof. Assume that φ0 is as large as possible; e.g., there exists some finite ξ0 where φ(ξ0) = µξ2
0 −φ0. By
convexity, for all ν ∈∂φ(ξ), Proof of Lemma 28 Proof. The proof largely follows from [52], mildly adapted. 26 Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method First prove (25) ⇒(33). Construct g(x) = f(x)−xT ∇f(y), which is convex, also L-smooth, and has minimum
at x = y. Then, for any w, First prove (25) ⇒(33). Construct g(x) = f(x)−xT ∇f(y), which is convex, also L-smooth, and has minimum
at x = y. Then, for any w, g(y) ≤g(x + w)
(a)
≤g(x) + ∇g(x)T w + L
2 κP(w)2, where (a) is since g is L smooth and convex. where (a) is since g is L smooth and convex. Now pick w ∈1
LσP(−∇g(x))∂σP(−∇g(x)), which implies which implies L
σP(−∇g(x))w ∈argmax
κP(u)≤1
⟨u, −∇g(x)⟩=
and thus
κP(w) = σP(−∇g(x))
L
,
and
⟨w, −∇g(x)⟩= 1
LσP(−∇g(x))2. Then
L
2 κP(w)2 = 1
2LσP(−∇g(x))2, L
σP(−∇g(x))w ∈argmax
κP(u)≤1
⟨u, −∇g(x)⟩= ∂σP(−∇g(x)), and thus κP(w) = σP(−∇g(x))
L
, ⟨w, −∇g(x)⟩= 1
LσP(−∇g(x))2. Then L
2 κP(w)2 = 1
2LσP(−∇g(x))2, and plugging in the construction for g gives g(y) −g(x) ≤∇g(x)T w + L
2 κP(w)2
|
{z
}
−1
2L σP(−∇g(x))2
⇐⇒f(y) −f(x) ≤(y −x)T ∇f(y) −1
2LσP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2. 2L
⇐⇒f(y) −f(x) ≤(y −x)T ∇f(y) −1
2LσP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2. Applying the last inequality twice gives (y −x)T (∇f(y) −∇f(x)) ≤1
2L((σP(∇f(x) −∇f(y))2 + (σP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2). (y −x)T (∇f(y) −∇f(x)) ≤1
2L((σP(∇f(x) −∇f(y))2 + (σP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2). Now prove (25) ⇒(34). Using the same g as before, consider
min
z
g(x) + ⟨∇g(x), z −x⟩+ L
2 κP(x −z)2 = min
w
⟨∇g(x), w⟩+ L
2 κP(w)2. Using optimality conditions, picking w = z −y, we have
0 ∈∇g(x) + LκP(w)∂κP(w) ⇐⇒−
1
LκP(w)∇g(x) = argmax
( )≤1
⟨u, w⟩, Now prove (25) ⇒(34). Using the same g as before, consider
min
z
g(x) + ⟨∇g(x), z −x⟩+ L
2 κP(x −z)2 = min
w
⟨∇g(x), w⟩+ L
2 κP(w)2. Now prove (25) ⇒(34). Using the same g as before, consider min
z
g(x) + ⟨∇g(x), z −x⟩+ L
2 κP(x −z)2 = min
w
⟨∇g(x), w⟩+ L
2 κP(w)2. Using optimality conditions, picking w = z −y, we have
0 ∈∇g(x) + LκP(w)∂κP(w) ⇐⇒−
1
LκP(w)∇g(x) = argmax
σP(u)≤1
⟨u, w⟩, which implies σP(−∇g(x)) = LκP(w),
−
1
LκP(w)⟨w, ∇g(x)⟩= κP(w). so
⟨w, −∇g(x)⟩= LκP(w)2 = 1
LσP(−∇g(x))2, σP(−∇g(x)) = LκP(w),
−
1
LκP(w)⟨w, ∇g(x)⟩= κP(w). so so ⟨w, −∇g(x)⟩= LκP(w)2 = 1
LσP(−∇g(x))2, ⟨w, −∇g(x)⟩= LκP(w)2 = 1
LσP(−∇g(x))2, and overall g(y) ≥min
z
g(x) + ⟨∇g(x), z −x⟩+ L
2 κP(x −z)2 = g(x) −1
2LσP(−∇g(x))2. Proof of Proposition 22 Proof. Without loss of generality, we assume 0 ∈P, since κP = κP∪{0}. Denote z∗= −∇f(x∗). Then the
optimality condition for (20) is z∗∈∂h(x∗)
(⋆)
= α∂κP(x∗),
h(x) := φ(κP(x)) (40) for some α ∈∂φ(ξ) at ξ = κP(x∗). Here, (⋆) is a result from [4, Corollary 16.72]. Since φ is monotonically nondecreasing over R+, α ≥0. If α = 0, then ∇f(x∗) = 0 and both results are
trivially true. Now consider α > 0. Noting that κP = σP◦where P◦is the polar set of P, α−1z∗= argmax
z∈P◦
(x∗)T z ⇐⇒(z∗)T x∗= κP◦(z∗)σP◦(x∗) = κP(x∗)σP(z∗) which proves (27). Now take the conic decomposition x∗= P
p∈P0 cpp where cp ≥0, and (x∗)T z∗=
X
p∈P0
cppT z∗≤
X
p∈P0
cp
|
{z
}
=κP(x∗)
(pT z∗)
| {z }
≤σP(z∗)
, which is with equality if and only if pT z∗= σP(z∗) whenever cp > 0, proving (28). Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 27 Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Plugging in f gives
f(y) −f(x) ≥(y −x)T ∇f(y) −1
2LσP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2. g(y) ≥min
z
g(x) + ⟨∇g(x), z −x⟩+ L
2 κP(x −z)2 = g(x) −1
2LσP(−∇g(x))2. Plugging in f gives f(y) −f(x) ≥(y −x)T ∇f(y) −1
2LσP(∇f(y) −∇f(x))2. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 28 B B
Convergence results from Section 4 ▶Lemma 36 (Iterate gauge control). Given Assumptions 1, 2,5, suppose additionally θ(t) = 2/(t + 1). Then κP(s(t) −x(t)) ≤γmax
γminµ
2σe
P(∇f(x∗+ y∗)) +
p
2L∆(t) +
2
t(t −1)
t−1
X
u=1
p
2L∆(u)
! + 2ν0γmax + κP(x(0)). Proof. Proof. κP(s(t) −x(t))
subadditive
gauge
≤
κP(s(t)) + κP(x(t))
convexity
≤
κP(s(t)) + θ(t−1)κP(s(t−1)) + (1 −θ(t−1))κP(x(t−1))
recursion
≤
κP(s(t)) + κP(x(0)) +
t−1
X
u=1
θ(u)
t−1
Y
u′=u+1
(1 −θ(u′))
|
{z
}
= (u+1)u
t(t−1)
κP(s(u))
t−1 κP(s(t) −x(t))
s ≤κP(s(t)) + κP(x(0)) +
2
t(t −1)
t−1
X
u=1
uκP(s(u)). In general, for any x, z, x, κP(x) ≤γmaxκP(x)(x),
σP(z) ≥
1
γmin
σP(x)(z). Taking y(u) = argminy∈K f(x(u) + y), z(u) = −∇f(x(u) + y(u)), z∗= −∇f(x∗+ y∗):
κP(x)(s(u)) = (φ∗)′
σP(x)(z(u))
Asspt. 1
≤
µ−1 · σP(x)(z(u)) + ν0
Bound on γ′
≤
1
µrmin
σP(z(u)) + ν0
∆-ineq +
Prop. 34
≤
1
µrmin
σe
P(z∗) +
p
2L∆(u)
+ ν0. Putting it all together gives the desired result. Putting it all together gives the desired result. From Lemmas 37 and 36, we arrive at From Lemmas 37 and 36, we arrive at ∆(t+1) −∆(t) ≤−θ(t)resP(x(t)) + (θ(t))2
B∆(t) + B∆(t−1) + A
for constants for constants A =
6Lγ2
max
µ2γ2
min
σe
P(−∇f(x∗+ y∗) + 6γmaxν0 + 3κP(x(0))
2
,
B = 3L2γ2
max
µ2γ2
min and where ∆(t) is defined as an averaging over square roots, e.g. and where ∆(t) is defined as an averaging over square roots, e.g. p
∆(t) =
2
t(t + 1)
t
X
u=1
u
p
∆(u). ▶Lemma 37 (One step descent). Suppose f is L-smooth w.r.t. P (unweighted). Take
x+ = (1 −θ)x + θs,
s = argmin
˜s
∇f(x + y)T es + h(s; x) ▶Lemma 37 (One step descent). Suppose f is L-smooth w.r.t. P (unweighted). Take
x+ = (1 −θ)x + θs,
s = argmin
˜s
∇f(x + y)T es + h(s; x) ▶Lemma 37 (One step descent). Suppose f is L-smooth w.r.t. P (unweighted). Take
x+ = (1 −θ)x + θs,
s = argmin
˜s
∇f(x + y)T es + h(s; x) x+ = (1 −θ)x + θs,
s = argmin
˜s
∇f(x + y)T es + h(s; x) x+ = (1 −θ)x + θs,
s = argmin
˜s
∇f(x + y)T es + h(s; x) for some θ ∈(0, 1). Proof of Proposition 32 Proof. Denote y = argminy f(x + y), and z = −∇f(x + y), and plug in κP(x)(x) = rP(x; x). Then
resP(x) = f(x + y) + f ∗(−z) + φ(rP(x)) + φ∗(σP(x)(z)) + (κP(x)(x) −rP(x)) · σP(x)(z)
(a)
= xT ∇f(x + y) + φ(rP(x)) + φ∗(σP(x)(z)) + (κP(x)(x) −rP(x)) · σP(x)(z)
(b)
≥xT ∇f(x + y) + yT ∇f(x + y)
|
{z
}
≥0
+rP(x)σP(x)(z) + (κP(x)(x) −rP(x)) · σP(x)(z)
(b) Proof. Denote y = argminy f(x + y), and z = −∇f(x + y), and plug in κP(x)(x) = rP(x; x). Then
resP(x) = f(x + y) + f ∗(−z) + φ(rP(x)) + φ∗(σP(x)(z)) + (κP(x)(x) −rP(x)) · σP(x)(z)
(a)
= xT ∇f(x + y) + φ(rP(x)) + φ∗(σP(x)(z)) + (κP(x)(x) −rP(x)) · σP(x)(z)
(b)
≥xT ∇f(x + y) + yT ∇f(x + y)
|
{z
}
≥0
+rP(x)σP(x)(z) + (κP(x)(x) −rP(x)) · σP(x)(z)
(b)
≥xT ∇f(x + y) + κP(x)(x) · σP(x)(z)
(c)
≥xT ∇f(x + y) −xT ∇f(x + y) = 0 where where (a) uses the Fenchel–Young inequality on f and f ∗, (a) uses the Fenchel–Young inequality on f and f ∗, (a) uses the Fenchel–Young inequality on f and f ∗, (b) uses the Fenchel–Young inequality on φ and φ∗, (c) follows since −∇f(x + y) ∈K◦and y ∈K, and thus yT z ≥0, and (c) follows since −∇f(x + y) ∈K◦and y ∈K, and thus yT z ≥0, and
(d) follows from the definition of σ
( ) (c) follows since −∇f(x + y) ∈K◦and y ∈K, and thus yT z ≥0, and
(d) follows from the definition of σP(x). (d) follows from the definition of σP(x). (d) follows from the definition of σP(x). Tightness of (b) occurs iffFenchel–Young is satisfied with equality, e.g. Tightness of (b) occurs iffFenchel–Young is satisfied with equality, e.g. σP(x)(z) ∈∂φ(rP(x))
(41)
Tightness of (c) occurs iff (41) σP(x)(z) ∈∂φ(rP(x))
(41)
Tightness of (c) occurs iff σP(x)(z) =
−∇f(x)T p
γ′(coeffP(x; p)),
∀p, cp ̸= 0. −∇f(x)T p
γ′(coeffP(x; p)),
∀p, cp ̸= 0. (42) (42) The “element-wise” optimality conditions for (32) are, for all p ∈P0, The “element-wise” optimality conditions for (32) are, for all p ∈P0, −∇f(x)T p
γ′(coeffP(x; p)) ∈γ′(cp) · ∂φ(rP(x))
if cp ̸= 0
−∇f(x)T p
γ′(coeffP(x; p)) ≤γ′(cp)
max
gφ∈∂φ(rP(x)) gφ
if cp = 0 which is true iff(41), (42) hold. which is true iff(41), (42) hold. B
Convergence results from Section 4 Define y = argminy∈K f(x + y), y+ = argminy∈K f(x + y). Then for some θ ∈(0, 1). Define y = argminy∈K f(x + y), y+ = argminy∈K f(x + y). Then
f(x+ + y+) + h(x+) −f(x + y) −h(x) ≤−θres(x) + Lθ2
2 κP(s −x)2. for some θ ∈(0, 1). Define y = argminy∈K f(x + y), y+ = argminy∈K f(x + y). Then
f(x+ + y+) + h(x+) −f(x + y) −h(x) ≤−θres(x) + Lθ2
2 κP(s −x)2. f(x+ + y+) + h(x+) −f(x + y) −h(x) ≤−θres(x) + Lθ2
2 κP(s −x)2. 29 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Proof. From L-smoothness we have f(x+ + y+) −f(x + y) ≤f(x+ + y) −f(x + y)
≤∇f(x + y)T (x+ −x) + L
2 κP(x+ −x)
= θ∇f(x + y)T (s −x) + Lθ2
2 κP(s −x)2
(43)
Denote ν = σe
P(x)(−∇f(x + y)). Since s = ξφ′(ν), then
∇f(x + y)T s + φ(r0 + rP(s; x)) = min
˜s
∇f(x + y)T es
|
{z
}
=−ξ·ν
+φ
r0 + rP(s; x)
|
{z
}
=ξ
= νr0 −φ∗(ν). (44)
Al
b
d fi
f
d
l f(x+ + y+) −f(x + y) ≤f(x+ + y) −f(x + y)
≤∇f(x + y)T (x+ −x) + L
2 κP(x+ −x)
= θ∇f(x + y)T (s −x) + Lθ2
2 κP(s −x)2 (43) ∇f(x + y)T s + φ(r0 + rP(s; x)) = min
˜s
∇f(x + y)T es
|
{z
}
=−ξ·ν
+φ
r0 + rP(s; x)
|
{z
}
=ξ
= νr0 −φ∗(ν). ∇f(x + y)T s + φ(r0 + rP(s; x)) = min
˜s
∇f(x + y)T es
|
{z
}
=−ξ·ν
+φ
r0 + rP(s; x)
|
{z
}
=ξ
= νr0 −φ∗(ν). (44) Also, by definition of residual, resP(x) = f(x + y) + f ∗(∇f(x + y)) + φ(rP(x + y)) + φ∗(ν) −r0 · ν
= ∇f(x + y)T (x + y)
|
{z
}
∇f(x+y)T y≥0
+φ(r(x)) + φ∗(ν) −r0 · ν
≥∇f(x + y)T x + φ(r(x)) + φ∗(ν) −r0 · ν. (45)
Therefore taking F(x + y) = f(x + y) + φ(r(x)) and combining (43), (44), and (45),
F(x+ + y+) −F(x + y) = −θres(x) + θ (φ(rP(x)) −φ(r0 + rP(s; x)))
+ Lθ2
2 κP(s −x)2 + φ(rP(x+)) −φ(rP(x)) (45) Next, by convexity of φ, (1 −θ)φ(rP(x)) + θφ(r0 + rP(s; x)) ≥φ(rP(x) + rP(x+; x) −rP(x; x))
majorant
≥
φ(rP(x+; x)) which leaves the desired result. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method We now pick G large enough such that for all t ≤t, ∆(t) ≤G/t, and G > 24A. Since ∆(t) is always a bounded
quantity (x(t) is always feasible), this is always possible. Then, for all t < t, p
∆(t) ≤
√
G
t(t + 1)
t
X
t′=1
√
t′
(a)
≤
2
√
G
3t(t + 1)t3/2, where (a) is by integral rule, and so where (a) is by integral rule, and so ∆(t) ≤
4Gt
9(t + 1)2 ≤G
2t. ∆(t) ≤
4Gt
9(t + 1)2 ≤G
2t. Now we make an inductive step. Suppose that for some t, ∆(t′) < G/t′ for all t′ ≤t. Then Now we make an inductive step. Suppose that for some t, ∆(t′) < G/t′ for all t′ ≤t. Then ∆(t+1) ≤∆(t) −2
3θ(t)∆(t) + (θ(t))2(A + B∆(t))
≤G
t −2
3
2G
t + 1
1
t +
4
(t + 1)2
A + GB
2t
=
G
t + 1
t + 1
t
−4
3t +
4A
(t + 1)G +
2B
t(t + 1)
≤
G
t + 1
1 −1
3t + 4A
tG + 2B
t2
=
G
t + 1
1 + 1
t
−1
3 + 4A
G
|{z}
<1/6
+ 2B
t
|{z}
<1/6
≤
G
t + 1, which satisfies the inductive step. ◀ which satisfies the inductive step. ◀ which satisfies the inductive step. which satisfies the inductive step. ◀ The following is a generalized and modified version of a proof segment from [39], which will be used for
proving O(1/t) gap convergence. ▶Lemma 39. Pick some 0 < T2 < T1 and pick k = ⌈D(k + D)/(D + T1)⌉−D ⇒
D
D + T1
≤k + D
k + D ≤
D
D + T2
. Then if Then if C1(D + T1)
D
≤C3 · log
D + T2
D
,
C1
D + k +
k
X
i=k
C2
(D + i)2 −
C3
D + i ·
1
D + k
< 0. Proof. Using integral rule, we see that Proof. which leaves the desired result. which leaves the desired result. ▶Proposition 38 (Linearized objective value bound). Given Assumptions 1, 2, 4, 5, then the objective error of
each linearized problem decreases as ∆(t) = O(1/t). Proof
Define ∆(t) = O(1/t). Proof. Define Proof. Define A =
6Lγ2
max
µ2γ2
min
σe
P(−∇f(x∗+ y∗) + 6γmaxν0 + 3κP(x(0))
2
,
B = 3L2γ2
max
µ2γ2
min
. Then putting together lemmas 37, 36 and using the relation (a + b)2 ≤2a2 + 2b2 gives
∆(t+1) −∆(t) ≤−θ(t)resP(x(t)) + (θ(t))2
B∆(t) + B∆(t−1) + A
. A =
6Lγ2
max
µ2γ2
min
σe
P(−∇f(x∗+ y∗) + 6γmaxν0 + 3κP(x(0))
2
,
B = 3L2γ2
max
µ2γ2
min
. Then putting together lemmas 37, 36 and using the relation (a + b)2 ≤2a2 + 2b2 gives
∆(t+1) −∆(t) ≤−θ(t)resP(x(t)) + (θ(t))2
B∆(t) + B∆(t−1) + A
. A =
6Lγ2
max
µ2γ2
min
σe
P(−∇f(x∗+ y∗) + 6γmaxν0 + 3κP(x(0))
2
,
B = 3L2γ2
max
µ2γ2
min
. A =
6Lγ2
max
µ2γ2
min
σe
P(−∇f(x∗+ y∗) + 6γmaxν0 + 3κP(x(0))
2
,
B = 3L2γ2
max
µ2γ2
min
. Then putting together lemmas 37, 36 and using the relation (a + b)2 ≤2a2 + 2b2 gives Then putting together lemmas 37, 36 and using the relation (a + b)2 ≤2a2 + 2b Then putting together lemmas 37, 36 and using the relation (a + b)2 ≤2a2 + 2b2 gives
∆(t+1) −∆(t) ≤−θ(t)resP(x(t)) + (θ(t))2
B∆(t) + B∆(t−1) + A
. ∆(t+1) −∆(t) ≤−θ(t)resP(x(t)) + (θ(t))2
B∆(t) + B∆(t−1) + A
where ∆(t) is defined as an averaging over square roots, e.g. where ∆(t) is defined as an averaging over square roots, e.g. p
∆(t) =
2
t(t + 1)
t
X
u=1
u
p
∆(u). Then picking t > 6B, we get that for all t ≥t, B(θ(t))2 ≤θ(t)/3, and therefore
∆(t+1) −∆(t) ≤−θ(t) resP(x(t))
|
{z
}
≥∆(t)
+(θ(t))2
B∆(t) + B∆(t−1) + A
≤−θ(t)∆(t) + (θ(t))2
B∆(t) + B∆(t−1) + A
≤−2θ(t)∆(t)
3
+ (θ(t))2
B∆(t−1) + A
. 30 Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Using integral rule, we see that k
X
i=k
1
(D + i)2 ≤
Z k−1
z=k−1
1
(D + i)2 =
1
D −1 + k −
1
D −1 + k
k
X
i=k
1
D + i ≥
Z k
z=k
1
D + i = log(D + k) −log(D + k). 31 Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Yifan Sun & Francis Bach This yields c(k) :=
C1
D + k +
k
X
i=k
C2
(D + i)2 −
1
D + i ·
C3
D + k
≤
C1
D + k +
C2
D −1 + k −
C2
D −1 + k +
C3
D + k · (log(D + k) −log(D + k))
≤C1(D + T1)
D(D + k) +
C2
D −1 + k −
C2
D −1 + k
|
{z
}
<0
+
C3
D + k · log
D
D + T2
≤C1(D + T1)
D(D + k) +
C3
D + k · log
D
D + T2
< 0. ▶Lemma 40 (Generalized non-monotonic gap bound). Given ▶Lemma 40 (Generalized non-monotonic gap bound). Given ∆(t) ≤
G1
t+D for some G1, ∆(t) ≤
G1
t+D for some G1, ∆(t) ≤
G1
t+D for some G1, +
θ(t) =
G2
t+D for some G2 and D, and θ(t) =
G2
t+D for some G2 and D, and θ( ) =
2
t+D for some G2 and D, and
∆(t+1) −∆(t)(1 + αθ(t)) ≤−θ(t)res(x(t)) + (θ(t))2G3 for some G3, t+D
∆(t+1) −∆(t)(1 + αθ(t)) ≤−θ(t)res(x(t)) + (θ(t))2G3 for some G3, then for then for G4 ≥G1
G2
(D + 2)
D(log
D+1
D
), we have we have min
i≤t res(x(i)) ≤
G4
t + D. Proof. We have ∆(t+1) −∆(t) ≤αθ(t)∆(t) −θ(t)gap(t) + G3(θ(t))2. Now assume that for all i ≤t, gap(i) >
G4
t+D. Then, telescoping from t to t gives Now assume that for all i ≤t, gap(i) >
G4
t+D. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Then, telescoping from t to t gives ∆(t+1) ≤∆(t) +
t
X
i=t
αθ(i)∆(i) −θ(i)gap(i) + G3(θ(i))2
<
G1
t + D +
t
X
i=t
α G1G2
(i + D)2 −
G2
i + D
G4
t + D +
G3G2
2
(i + D)2
Picking C1 = G1, C2 = αG1G2 + G3G2
2, C3 = G2G4, and invoking Lemma 39, this yields that ∆(t+1) < 0,
which is impossible. Therefore, the assumption must not be true. ◀ Piecing everything in this section together gives Theorem 33 (main convergence theorem.) Proof of Proposition 34 Proof. First, note that φ∗(σP(x)(z)) + r0 · (σP(x)(z)) = sup
y
yT z −φ(r0 + κP(x)(y))
≥zT x∗−φ(r0 + κP(x)(x∗)). (46) φ∗(σP(x)(z)) + r0 · (σP(x)(z)) = sup
y
yT z −φ(r0 + κP(x)(y))
≥zT x∗−φ(r0 + κP(x)(x∗)). (46) (46) Define res(x) = (F(x; x) −F D(−∇f(x); x). Taking (x, −∇f(x)) as a feasible primal-dual pair and reference
point x = x, and denoting ϵ(x) = φ(r0 + κP(x)(x∗)) −φ(x∗), z = −∇f(x + y(x)), and z∗= −∇f(x∗+ y(x∗)), Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 32 res(x) =
f(x) + f ∗(z)
|
{z
}
use Fenchel–Young
+φ(r(x))
+ φ∗(σP(x)(z) −r0 · (σP(x)(z))
|
{z
}
use (46)
≥−zT (x −x∗) + φ(rP(x)) −φ
r0 + κP(x)(x∗)
+ϵ(x)−ϵ(x)
≥
−zT (x −x∗) + φ(rP(x)) −φ(rP(x∗))
|
{z
}
convex in x
−ϵ(x)
g∈∂h(x∗)
≥
−zT (x −x∗) + gT (x −x∗) −ϵ(x). Picking in particular g = −∇f(x∗+ y(x∗)),
res(x) + ϵ(x) ≥(x −x∗)T (z∗−z)
(⋆)
≥1
Lσe
P(z −z∗)2 use (46)
≥−zT (x −x∗) + φ(rP(x)) −φ
r0 + κP(x)(x∗)
+ϵ(x)−ϵ(x)
≥
−zT (x −x∗) + φ(rP(x)) −φ(rP(x∗))
|
{z
}
convex in x
−ϵ(x)
g∈∂h(x∗) where (⋆) follows from Assumption 5. where (⋆) follows from Assumption 5. where (⋆) follows from Assumption 5. Next, note that Next, note that ϵ(x) = φ(rP(x) −rP(x; x) + rP(x∗; x)) −φ(rP(x∗))
convex φ
≤
gφ (rP(x) −rP(x; x) + rP(x∗; x) −rP(x∗))
|
{z
}
=:D(x) for all gφ ∈∂φ(rP(x∗)), where in general, D(x) ≤(γmax −γmin)κe
P(x −x∗) and D(x) = 0 if γ(ξ) = ξ (convex
case). Noting that, at optimality, for all gφ ∈∂φ(rP(x∗)), where in general, D(x) ≤(γmax −γmin)κe
P(x −x∗) and D(x) = 0 if γ(ξ) = ξ (convex
case). Noting that, at optimality, ∂φ(rP(x∗)) ∋σP(x∗)(z∗) ≤
σe
P(z∗)
γmin
, then γminφ′(r(x∗)) ≤σe
P(z∗) ≤σe
P(z) + σe
P(z −z∗)
and overall, γminφ′(r(x∗)) ≤σe
P(z∗) ≤σe
P(z) + σe
P(z −z∗) σe
P(z∗−z)2 ≤Lres(x) + Lϵ(x)
≤Lres(x) + LD(x)
σe
P(z) + σe
P(z∗−z)
γmin
. This inequality is quadratic in σe
P(z∗−z), which leads to the bound σe
P(z∗−z) ≤LD(x)
2γmin
+
s
L2D(x)2
4γ2
min
+ Lres(x) + LD(x)
σe
P(z)
γmin
. 5
Leonard Berrada, Andrew Zisserman, and M. Pawan Kumar. Deep Frank-Wolfe for neural network optimization.
https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.07591, 2018. 4
Heinz H. Bauschke and Patrick L. Combettes. Convex Analysis and Monotone Operator Theory in Hilbert Spaces,
volume 408. Springer, 2 edition, 2011. References 1
Francis Bach. Structured sparsity-inducing norms through submodular functions. In Advances in Neural Information
Processing Systems, pages 118–126, 2010. s Bach. Duality between subgradient and conditional gradient methods. SIAM J. Optim., 25(1):115–12 3
Heinz H. Bauschke, Jérôme Bolte, and Marc Teboulle. A descent lemma beyond Lipschitz gradient continuity:
first-order methods revisited and applications. Math. Oper. Res., 42(2):330–348, 2017. 4
Heinz H. Bauschke and Patrick L. Combettes. Convex Analysis and Monotone Operator Theory in Hilbert Spaces,
volume 408. Springer, 2 edition, 2011. 4
Heinz H. Bauschke and Patrick L. Combettes. Convex Analysis and Monotone Operator Theory in Hilbert Spaces,
volume 408. Springer, 2 edition, 2011. 5
Leonard Berrada, Andrew Zisserman, and M. Pawan Kumar. Deep Frank-Wolfe for neural network optimization. https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.07591, 2018. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Compressed sensing. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, 52(4):1289–1306, 2006. 23
Miroslav Dudik, Zaid Harchaoui, and Jérôme Malick. Lifted coordinate descent for learning with trace-norm
regularization. In Artificial Intelligence and Statistics, pages 327–336, 2012. Dunn and S. Harshbarger. Conditional gradient algorithms with open loop step size rules. J. Math. Anal. 2):432–444, 1978. 24
Joseph C. Dunn and S. Harshbarger. Conditional gradient algorithms with open loop step size rules
Appl., 62(2):432–444, 1978. 25
Laurent El Ghaoui, Vivian Viallon, and Tarek Rabbani. Safe feature elimination for the Lasso and s
learning problems. Pac. J. Optim., 8(4):667–698, 2012. 26
Alina Ene and Adrian Vladu. Improved Convergence for ℓ1 and ℓ∞Regression via Iteratively Reweighted Least
Squares. In International Conference on Machine Learning, pages 1794–1801, 2019. 27
Zhenan Fan, Halyun Jeong, Yifan Sun, Michael Friedlander, et al. Atomic Decomposition via Polar Alignment: The
Geometry of Structured Optimization. Found. Trends Optim., 3(4):280–366, 2020. 28
Olivier Fercoq, Alexandre Gramfort, and Joseph Salmon. Mind the duality gap: safer rules for the lasso. In
International Conference on Machine Learning, pages 333–342. PMLR, 2015. 29
Marguerite Frank and Philip Wolfe. An algorithm for quadratic programming. Nav. Res. Logist. Q., 3(1-2):95–110,
1956. 30
Robert M. Freund. Dual gauge programs, with applications to quadratic programming and the minimum-norm
problem. Math. Program., 38(1):47–67, 1987. 31
Robert M. Freund, Paul Grigas, and Rahul Mazumder. An Extended Frank–Wolfe Method with “In-F
and Its Application to Low-Rank Matrix Completion. SIAM J. Optim., 27(1):319–346, 2017. and Its Application to Low Rank Matrix Completion. SIAM J. Optim., 27(1):319 346, 2017. 32
Michael Friedlander, Ives Macedo, and Ting Kei Pong. Gauge optimization and duality. SIAM J. Optim., 24(4):1999–
2022, 2014. 2
Michael Friedlander, Ives Macedo, and Ting Kei Pong. Gauge optimization and duality. SIAM J. Optim. 2022, 2014. 33
Pinghua Gong, Changshui Zhang, Zhaosong Lu, Jianhua Huang, and Jieping Ye. A general iterative shrinkage and
thresholding algorithm for non-convex regularized optimization problems. In International Conference on Machine
Learning, pages 37–45, 2013. 34
Jacques Guélat and Patrice Marcotte. Some comments on Wolfe’s ‘away step’. Math. Program., 35(1 34
Jacques Guélat and Patrice Marcotte. Some comments on Wolfe’s ‘away step’. Math. Program., 35(1):110–119, 1986. 35
Isabelle Guyon, Steve Gunn, Asa Ben-Hur, and Gideon Dror. Result analysis of the NIPS 2003 feature selection
challenge. Adv. Neural Inf. Process. Syst., 17, 2004. 35
Isabelle Guyon, Steve Gunn, Asa Ben-Hur, and Gideon Dror. Result analysis of the NIPS 2003 feature selection
challenge. Adv. Neural Inf. Process. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 33 6
Howard D. Bondell and Brian J. Reich. Simultaneous regression shrinkage, variable selection, and supervised
clustering of predictors with OSCAR. Biometrics, 64(1):115–123, 2008. 7
Antoine Bonnefoy, Emiya Valentin, Ralaivola Liva, and Remi Gribonval. Dynamic screening: Accelerati
algorithms for the LASSO and group-LASSO. IEEE Trans. Signal Process., 63(19):5121–5132, 2015. 8
Jonathan Borwein and Adrian S. Lewis. Convex Analysis and Nonlinear Optimization: Theory and Examples. Springer, 2010. 9
Kristian Bredies and Dirk A. Lorenz. Iterated hard shrinkage for minimization problems with sparsity constraints. SIAM J. Sci. Comput., 30(2):657–683, 2008. 10
Kristian Bredies, Dirk A. Lorenz, and Peter Maass. A generalized conditional gradient method and its connection
to an iterative shrinkage method. Comput. Optim. Appl., 42(2):173–193, 2009. 11
James V. Burke and Jorge J. Moré. On the identification of active constraints. SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 25(5):1197–
1211, 1988. 12
Jim Burke. On the identification of active constraints II: The nonconvex case. SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 27(4):1081–
1102, 1990. 13
Emmanuel Candès and Justin Romberg. Robust signal recovery from incomplete observations. In 2006 International
Conference on Image Processing, pages 1281–1284. IEEE, 2006. Candès and Terence Tao. Decoding by linear programming. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, 51(12):4203–4215, 14
Emmanuel Candès and Terence Tao. Decoding by linear programming. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, 5
2005. 15
Venkat Chandrasekaran, Benjamin Recht, Pablo A. Parrilo, and Alan S. Willsky. The convex geometry of linear
inverse problems. Found. Comput. Math., 12(6):805–849, 2012. 16
Visesh Chari, Simon Lacoste-Julien, Ivan Laptev, and Josef Sivic. On pairwise costs for network flow multi-object
tracking. In Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, pages 5537–5545,
2015. n Chen and Weijun Zhou. Convergence of reweighted ℓ1 minimization algorithms and unique solution 7
Xiaojun Chen and Weijun Zhou. Convergence of reweighted ℓ1 minimization algorithms and uniqu
truncated ℓp minimization. Department of Applied Mathematics, The Hong Kong Polytechnic Univer ed ℓp minimization. Department of Applied Mathematics, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, 2010. 8
Frank H. Clarke. Generalized gradients and applications. Trans. Am. Math. Soc., 205:247–262, 1975. 19
Frank H. Clarke. Nonsmooth analysis and optimization. In Proceedings of the international congress of mathemati-
cians, volume 5, pages 847–853. Citeseer, 1983. 20
Kenneth L. Clarkson. Coresets, sparse greedy approximation, and the Frank-Wolfe algorithm. ACM Trans. Algo-
rithms, 6(4):63, 2010. 21
Ingrid Daubechies, Ronald DeVore, Massimo Fornasier, and C Sinan Güntürk. Iteratively reweig
minimization for sparse recovery. Commun. Pure Appl. Math., 63(1):1–38, 2010. 22
David L. Donoho. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method 34 36
Zaid Harchaoui, Anatoli Juditsky, and Arkadi Nemirovski. Conditional gradient algorithms for norm-regularized
smooth convex optimization. Math. Program., 152(1-2):75–112, 2015. 37
Warren Hare. Identifying active manifolds in regularization problems. In Fixed-Point Algorithms for I
in Science and Engineering, pages 261–271. Springer, 2011. 38
Elad Hazan. Sparse approximate solutions to semidefinite programs. In Latin American Symposium on Theoretical
Informatics, pages 306–316. Springer, 2008. 39
Martin Jaggi. Revisiting Frank-Wolfe: Projection-free sparse convex optimization. In ICML, pages 427–435, 2013. 40
T l
B J h
d C
l
G
t i
Sti
CD
f l
idi
t f l
d t
i
di
t
d
t I 9
Martin Jaggi. Revisiting Frank-Wolfe: Projectio 39
Martin Jaggi. Revisiting Frank-Wolfe: Projection-free sparse convex optimization. In ICML, pages 427–435, 2013. 40
Tyler B. Johnson and Carlos Guestrin. Stingy CD: safely avoiding wasteful updates in coordinate descent. In 39
Martin Jaggi. Revisiting Frank-Wolfe: Projection-free sparse convex optimization. In ICML, pages 427–435, 2013. 40
Tyler B. Johnson and Carlos Guestrin. Stingy CD: safely avoiding wasteful updates in coordinate descent. In
Proceedings of the 34th International Conference on Machine Learning-Volume 70, pages 1752–1760, 2017. 40
Tyler B. Johnson and Carlos Guestrin. Stingy CD: safely avoiding wasteful updates in coordin
Proceedings of the 34th International Conference on Machine Learning-Volume 70, pages 1752–17 41
Rahul G. Krishnan, Simon Lacoste-Julien, and David Sontag. Barrier Frank-Wolfe for margin
Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, pages 532–540, 2015. 42
Simon Lacoste-Julien and Martin Jaggi. On the global linear convergence of Frank-Wolfe optimization variants. In
Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, pages 496–504. 2015. f
g
y
, p g
43
Simon Lacoste-Julien, Martin Jaggi, Mark Schmidt, and Patrick Pletscher. Block-coordinate Frank-Wolfe optimiza-
tion for structural SVMs. In International Conference on Machine Learning, pages 53–61. PMLR, 2013. 44
Simon Lacoste-Julien, Fredrik Lindsten, and Francis Bach. Sequential kernel herding: Frank-Wolfe optimization for
particle filtering. In Artificial Intelligence and Statistics, pages 544–552. PMLR, 2015. 45
Adrian S. Lewis and Stephen J. Wright. Identifying activity. SIAM J. Optim., 21(2):597–614, 201 46
Jun Liu, Zheng Zhao, Jie Wang, and Jieping Ye. Safe screening with variational inequalities and its application to
lasso. In International Conference on Machine Learning, pages 289–297. PMLR, 2014. 47
Haihao Lu, Robert M. Freund, and Yurii Nesterov. Relatively smooth convex optimization by first-order methods,
and applications. SIAM J. Optim., 28(1):333–354, 2018. 48
Julien Mairal, Francis Bach, and Jean Ponce. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Sparse modeling for image and vision processing. https://arxiv. org/abs/1411.3230, 2014. 49
Abed Malti and Cédric Herzet. Safe screening tests for Lasso based on firmly non-expansiveness. In 2016 IEEE
International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing (ICASSP), pages 4732–4736. IEEE, 2016. 50
Cun Mu, Yuqian Zhang, John Wright, and Donald Goldfarb. Scalable robust matrix recovery: Frank–Wolfe meets
proximal methods. SIAM J. Sci. Comput., 38(5):A3291–A3317, 2016. 51
Eugene Ndiaye, Olivier Fercoq, Alexandre Gramfort, and Joseph Salmon. Gap safe screening rules for sparse
multi-task and multi-class models. In Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, pages 811–819, 2015. 52
Yurii Nesterov. Introductory Lectures on Convex Optimization: A Basic Course. Springer, 2013. 53
Julie Nutini, Mark Schmidt, and Warren Hare. “Active-set complexity” of proximal gradient: How long does it take
to find the sparsity pattern? Optim. Lett., 13(4):645–655, 2019. 54
Julie Nutini, Mark Schmidt, Issam Laradji, Michael Friedlander, and Hoyt Koepke. Coordinate descent converges
faster with the Gauss-Southwell rule than random selection. In International Conference on Machine Learning,
pages 1632–1641, 2015. p g
,
55
Guillaume Obozinski, Laurent Jacob, and Jean-Philippe Vert. Group lasso with overlaps: the latent group lasso
approach. https://arxiv.org/abs/1110.0413, 2011. 56
Peter Ochs, Alexey Dosovitskiy, Thomas Brox, and Thomas Pock. On iteratively reweighted algorithms for
nonsmooth nonconvex optimization in computer vision. SIAM J. Imaging Sci., 8(1):331–372, 2015. 57
Wei Ping, Qiang Liu, and Alexander T. Ihler. Learning infinite RBMs with Frank-Wolfe. In Advances in Neural
Information Processing Systems, pages 3063–3071, 2016. 58
Alain Rakotomamonjy, Gilles Gasso, and Joseph Salmon. Screening rules for lasso with non-convex sp
In International Conference on Machine Learning, pages 5341–5350. PMLR, 2019. 59
Nikhil Rao, Parikshit Shah, and Stephen J. Wright. Forward-backward greedy algorithms for atom
ization. IEEE Trans. Signal Process., 63(21):5798–5811, 2015. 60
R. Tyrrell Rockafellar. Convex Analysis, volume 28. Princeton University Press, 1970. 61
Ozan Sener and Vladlen Koltun. Multi-task learning as multi-objective optimization. In Advances in Neural
Information Processing Systems, pages 527–538, 2018. 2
Ambuj Tewari, Pradeep K. Ravikumar, and Inderjit S. Dhillon. Greedy algorithms for structurally cons
dimensional problems. In Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, pages 882–890, 2011. 3
Robert Tibshirani. Regression shrinkage and selection via the Lasso. J. R. Stat. Soc., Ser. B, Sta
58(1):267–288, 1996. 64
Marina Vinyes and Guillaume Obozinski. Fast column generation for atomic norm regularization. In Proceedings of
International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics, 2017. nference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics, 201 65
Balder Von Hohenbalken. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach Syst., 17, 2004. Screening for a Reweighted Penalized Conditional Gradient Method Simplicial decomposition in nonlinear programming algorithms. Math. Program., 13(1):49–
68, 1977. 66
Jie Wang, Jiayu Zhou, Peter Wonka, and Jieping Ye. LASSO screening rules via dual polytope projection. Adv. Neural Inf. Process. Syst., pages 1070–1078, 2013. 67
R. Wolke and H. Schwetlick. Iteratively reweighted least squares: algorithms, convergence analysis, and numerical
comparisons. SIAM J. Sci. Stat. Comput., 9(5):907–921, 1988. 69
Yaoliang Yu, Xinhua Zhang, and Dale Schuurmans. Generalized conditional gradient for sparse estimation. J. Mach.
Learn. Theory, 18(1):5279–5324, 2017. 68
Stephen J. Wright, Robert D. Nowak, and Mário A. T. Figueiredo. Sparse reconstruction by separabl
IEEE Trans. Signal Process., 57(7):2479–2493, 2009. ( )
70
Alp Yurtsever, Madeleine Udell, Joel Tropp, and Volkan Cevher. Sketchy decisions: Convex low-rank matrix
optimization with optimal storage. In Artificial intelligence and statistics, pages 1188–1196. PMLR, 2017. 71
Xiangrong Zeng and Mário A. T. Figueiredo. The Ordered Weighted ℓ1 Norm: Atomic Formulation, Projections,
and Algorithms. https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.4271, 2014. 72
Song Zhou, Swati Gupta, and Madeleine Udell. Limited memory Kelley’s method converges for composite convex
and submodular objectives. In Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, pages 4414–4424. 2018. Yifan Sun & Francis Bach 35 67
R. Wolke and H. Schwetlick. Iteratively reweighted least squares: algorithms, convergence analysis, and numerical
comparisons. SIAM J. Sci. Stat. Comput., 9(5):907–921, 1988. 69
Yaoliang Yu, Xinhua Zhang, and Dale Schuurmans. Generalized conditional gradient for sparse estimation. J. Mach. Learn. Theory, 18(1):5279–5324, 2017. 70
Alp Yurtsever, Madeleine Udell, Joel Tropp, and Volkan Cevher. Sketchy decisions: Convex low-rank matrix
optimization with optimal storage. In Artificial intelligence and statistics, pages 1188–1196. PMLR, 2017. 71
Xiangrong Zeng and Mário A. T. Figueiredo. The Ordered Weighted ℓ1 Norm: Atomic Formulation, Projections,
and Algorithms. https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.4271, 2014. 72
Song Zhou, Swati Gupta, and Madeleine Udell. Limited memory Kelley’s method converges for composite convex
and submodular objectives. In Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, pages 4414–4424. 2018.
|
https://openalex.org/W2766822528
|
https://www.int-arch-photogramm-remote-sens-spatial-inf-sci.net/XLII-3-W3/81/2017/isprs-archives-XLII-3-W3-81-2017.pdf
|
English
| null |
MEASURING LEAF WATER CONTENT USING MULTISPECTRAL TERRESTRIAL LASER SCANNING
|
The international archives of the photogrammetry, remote sensing and spatial information sciences/International archives of the photogrammetry, remote sensing and spatial information sciences
| 2,017
|
cc-by
| 3,997
|
1.
INTRODUCTION wavelengths which can be used to estimate LWC remotely
(Ceccato et al., 2001). The estimation of LWC in terms of
equivalent water thickness (EWT, the ratio of the weight of
water and leaf area) and drought has been recently studied using
single wavelength terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) and
multispectral terrestrial laser scanning (MS-TLS) (Junttila et al.,
2015; Junttila et al., 2016; Zhu et al., 2015). Single wavelength
TLS has been shown to be able to explain 76% of the variation
in EWT after radiometric correction including incidence angle
correction (Zhu et al., 2015). Zhu et al. (2017) have investigated
the estimation of canopy EWT with a full-waveform single
wavelength TLS resulting in a significant correlation between
canopy EWT and TLS intensity backscatter (R2=0.66). The
estimation of leaf EWT with a dual-wavelength terrestrial laser
scanner has been studied resulting in R2 of 0.8, but the study
used a low number of samples and species (Gaulton et al.,
2013). These studies have used a limited number of samples and
wavelengths to estimate EWT, thus, more investigations are
needed to verify the applicability of laser scanning in EWT
estimation. Measuring tree health is an increasingly important topic as the
world’s climate is warming and growing human population puts
the environment and forests on more stress (Williams et al.,
2013). Forests provide many ecosystem services, such as carbon
storage, recreational activities, timber and non-timber forest
products, which are jeopardized due to declined forest health
and increased forest mortality (Hanewinkel et al., 2013). Managing declining forests efficiently in the face of climate
change requires new information on the condition of forests
(Allen et al., 2010); thus, new methods for mapping and
monitoring of forest health are needed. The healthiness of a tree is a fuzzy concept not easy to define,
but it could be referred as vigour, i.e. a tree that is defined as
healthy is growing at a pace typical to its environmental
conditions. Tree health assessments have been typically based on visual
estimation of crown colour, the amount foliage and bark
condition. The subjective nature of these measures can lead to
bias and require high expertise. The health of a tree is closely
linked to its biochemical properties, i.e. does it have enough
chlorophyll, water, and nutrients to maintain photosynthesis and
growth. MEASURING LEAF WATER CONTENT USING MULTISPECTRAL TERRESTRIAL
LASER SCANNING S. Junttila 1,2,*, M. Vastaranta 1,2, R. Linnakoski 1,3, J. Sugano 1, H. Kaartinen 4, A. Kukko 2,4, M. Holopainen 1,2, H. Hyyppä 2,5, J. Hyyppä 2,4 Department of Forest Sciences, University of Helsinki, 00014 Helsinki, Finland - (samuli.juntttila, mikko.vastaranta, junko.sugano
markus.holopainen)@helsinki.fi p
)
2 Centre of Excellence in Laser Scanning Research, Finnish Geospatial Research Institute FGI, 02431 Masala, Finland. 3 Natural Resources Institute Finland (Luke), Latokartanonkaari 9, 00790 Helsinki, Finland - riikka.linnakoski@luke.fi
4 Department of Remote Sensing and Photogrammetry, Finnish Geospatial Research Institute FGI, 02431 Masala, Finland -
(harri.kaartinen, antero.kukko, juha.hyyppa)@nls.fi j
yypp
5 Department of Built Environment, Aalto University, P.O.Box 15800, 00076 Aalto, Finland - hannu.hyyppa@aalto j
yypp
5 Department of Built Environment, Aalto University, P.O.Box 15800, 00076 Aalto, Finland - hannu ABSTRACT: Climate change is increasing the amount and intensity of disturbance events, i.e. drought, pest insect outbreaks and fungal pathogens,
in forests worldwide. Leaf water content (LWC) is an early indicator of tree stress that can be measured remotely using multispectral
terrestrial laser scanning (MS-TLS). LWC affects leaf reflectance in the shortwave infrared spectrum which can be used to predict
LWC from spatially explicit MS-TLS intensity data. Here, we investigated the relationship between LWC and MS-TLS intensity
features at 690 nm, 905 nm and 1550 nm wavelengths with Norway spruce seedlings in greenhouse conditions. We found that a
simple ratio of 905 nm and 1550 nm wavelengths was able to explain 84% of the variation (R2) in LWC with a respective prediction
accuracy of 0.0041 g/cm2. Our results showed that MS-TLS can be used to estimate LWC with a reasonable accuracy in
environmentally stable conditions. Commission ΙΙI, WG III/4 KEY WORDS: Tree health, drought, multispectral laser scanning, terrestrial laser scanning, forestry, leaf water content,
Endoconidiophora polonica. The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
https://doi.org/10.5194/isprs-archives-XLII-3-W3-81-2017 | © Authors 2017. CC BY 4.0 License. 2.3 Ecophysiological measurements examined in order to find laser intensity-derived features for
estimating EWT. The seedlings were carried to the laboratory after the scanning
and EWT was measured from a sample taken from each
seedling. A sample of approximately 20-40 needles were
randomly collected from the seedlings. The needles were
weighed (with a precision of 0.0001 g) to measure fresh weight,
scanned with a Epson V370 Photo flatbed scanner (Epson
America Inc., CA) at 800 dpi resolution to measure leaf area,
and dried in an oven in 60 °C for 48 hours to measure dry
weight. The images were analysed with the open-source
software EasyLeafArea (Easlon and Bloom, 2014) to segment
the needles and calculate leaf area. The EWT was then
calculated according to Danson et al. (1992) by dividing the
mass of water with leaf area for each sample with the following
equation: 2.1 Experiment design Commercial Norway spruce (Picea abies) seedlings of two
years old (n = 145) were grown for 12 weeks in a greenhouse
during the growing season between May and August 2016. The
seedlings were subjected to different treatments to induce
drought and variation in EWT. The seedlings were divided into
five groups for different treatments. Three of the groups
received 75%, 50%, and 25% of “normal” watering amount
(groups D75, D50 and D25). The watering amount of the
groups was adjusted during the experiment to ensure a decrease
in EWT. The fourth group was grown with a sufficient amount
of water for 10 weeks until irrigation was completely stopped,
and the seedlings were for two weeks without watering (group
D_tot). The fifth group of seedlings were inoculated with
Endoconidiophora polonica, a fungal pathogen that disturbs the
flow of water and nutrients in the phloem and sap wood (group
F). The amount of water given to the seedlings was adjusted
according to the temperature inside the greenhouse during the
experiment. During the 12 weeks 8-14 seedlings were randomly
collected from each treatment for TLS measurements at eight
time intervals. 𝑭𝑾−𝑫𝑾
𝑨
(
𝒈
𝒄𝒎𝟐),
(1) 𝑭𝑾−𝑫𝑾
𝑨
(
𝒈
𝒄𝒎𝟐),
(1) (1) where FW is the fresh weight of the needles (g), DW is the
weight of the dried needles (g), and A is the surface area of the
fresh needles (cm2). A set of statistical features were calculated from the intensity
data from each point cloud representing a seedling at each
wavelength. Intensity features were calculated from the
calibrated intensity data for each seedling at each wavelength. These features were the mean, minimum, maximum, standard
deviation of the intensity values. Based on these features, a set
of spectral indices were calculated for each point cloud based on
ratio and normalization operations. The indices are referred with
the abbreviation, feature name and a subscript describing the
wavelengths used for the calculation (e.g. NDVI690,1550). 1.
INTRODUCTION These properties have been difficult to measure
remotely due to the subtle nature of their response in spectral
properties but recent advances in active remote sensing methods
could provide new tools for tree health measurements. The characteristics of airborne multisensor and single-sensor
multispectral laser scanning data has been compared in a forest
environment, resulting in a conclusion that the single-sensor
data was more stable (Hopkinson et al., 2016). Junttila et al. (2016) studied the use of dual-TLS system with two
wavelengths in detecting leaf EWT. The aim of this study is to
investigate the capability of multisensor MS-TLS in detecting
varying tree health, which is measured in terms of leaf EWT
from Norway spruce seedlings. The dependencies between
EWT and laser intensity at different wavelengths (and
calculated spectral ratios) of segmented point clouds are Leaf water content (LWC) is an early indicator of tree health
that can be measured objectively (Skakun et al., 2003; White et
al., 2007). LWC affects leaf reflectance in the shortwave
infrared spectrum due to the absorbing nature of water at these 81 The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
https://doi org/10 5194/isprs-archives-XLII-3-W3-81-2017 | © Authors 2017 CC BY 4 0 License 2.2 TLS instruments and data processing The seedlings were scanned with three different TLS
instruments consequentially from the same position from a
distance of 5.2 m inside the greenhouse. The TLS instruments
used were: a Leica HDS6100 (Leica Geosystems AG,
Heerbrugg, Switzerland), a FARO S120 (FARO Europe GmbH
& Co. KG, Korntal-Münchingen, Germany), and a FARO
X330, utilizing wavelengths at 690 nm, 905 nm, and 1550 nm,
respectively. Three white spheres were used as common targets
to register the scans with each other facilitating the
segmentation of point clouds in the processing of the data. Measuring vegetation with a TLS that utilizes phase-shifting
measurement technique for range determination tends to
produce a high number of “ghost” points (Balduzzi et al., 2011). The number of ghost points was reduced by filtering the data
with a statistical outlier algorithm in the CloudCompare
software package (Girardeau-Montaut, 2011). Then, cloud-to-
cloud distances were calculated for the point clouds where the
distance of a point is calculated to the nearest point in the
reference cloud (FARO X330). The maximum distance was set
to 2 mm which is the ranging error announced by the
manufacturers of the TLSs. 𝑆𝑅𝜌1,𝜌2 =
𝜌1
𝜌2 ,
(2) (2) 𝑁𝐷𝑉𝐼𝜌1,𝜌2 =
𝜌1−𝜌2
𝜌1+𝜌2 ,
(3) (3) where ρ1 and ρ2 are the mean of calibrated intensity at
wavelengths ρ1 and ρ2. The relationship between ecophysiological parameters and laser
intensity features was investigated using simple linear
regression. We used coefficient of determination (R2) and root
mean square error (RMSE) to assess the goodness of the fit
between the variables with the following equations:
n
y
y
RMSE
n
i
i
i
1
2
ˆ
,
(4)
i
i
i
i
i
y
y
y
y
R
2
2
2
ˆ
1
,
(5) Points from each seedling were detached manually from the
scans for further processing. Since the FARO laser scanners
showed non-linearity in their intensity response, a four-grade
Spectralon panel, with nominal reflectances of 99%, 50%, 25%
and 12%, was used to calibrate the intensity data (I) to relative
reflectance (ρ690, ρ905, and ρ1550) by fitting the intensity of the
detached points from the panel to reflectance measurements
from an ASD spectrophotometer at each wavelength. No
normalization of the intensity data was conducted, thus,
temperature and humidity could have affected the intensity
measurements. https://doi.org/10.5194/isprs-archives-XLII-3-W3-81-2017 | © Authors 2017. CC BY 4.0 License. 3.2 The MS-TLS intensity response to varying EWT The single wavelength laser intensity features explained the
variation in EWT only moderately, the 1550mean being the best
explanatory intensity feature explaining 53% of the variation in
EWT (Table 1). The 1550mean increased with decreasing leaf
EWT as less water was present to absorb the reflectance at this
wavelength. The 1550std feature showed to explain 47% and the
1550max feature 24% of the variation in EWT while other single
wavelength intensity features at 690 nm and 905 nm
wavelengths were able to explain only 2-15% of the variation in
EWT. Intensity feature
R2
RMSE
1550mean
0.53
0.0071
1550std
0.47
0.0075
1550min
0.02
0.010
1550max
0.24
0.0090
905mean
0.12
0.0097
905std
0.15
0.0095
905min
0.15
0.0095
905max
0.14
0.0096
690mean
0.12
0.0097
690std
0.07
0.010
690min
0.13
0.0096
690max
0.02
0.010 Figure 2. Relationship between the best explanatory laser
intensity variable and equivalent water thickness (EWT). 2.2 TLS instruments and data processing (4)
i
i
i
i
i
y
y
y
y
R
2
2
2
ˆ
1
,
(5) (5) where 𝑛 is the number of observations, 𝑦𝑖 is the observed value
for the measurement 𝑖, 𝑦̂𝑖 is the predicted value for the
measurement 𝑖, and 𝑦̅ is the mean of the observed data. All of
the statistical analysis was performed in the open source
software package R ver. 3.2.3 (Team, 2013). This contribution has been peer-reviewed. 82 The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland 3.
RESULTS AND VALIDATION Strong correlations between laser intensity based spectral
indices and EWT were found (Table 2). Spectral indices
calculated from the 690 nm and 1550 nm wavelengths
explained 68-72% of the variation in EWT, NDVI690,1550
showing the best explanatory power with R2 of 0.72. Spectral
indices based on 905 nm and 1550 nm wavelengths were able to
explain 79-84% of the variation in EWT. The SR1550,905 index
showed the highest R2 with a value of 0.84 and a respective
prediction accuracy of 0.0041 g/cm2 (Figure 2). Strong correlations between laser intensity based spectral
indices and EWT were found (Table 2). Spectral indices
calculated from the 690 nm and 1550 nm wavelengths
explained 68-72% of the variation in EWT, NDVI690,1550
showing the best explanatory power with R2 of 0.72. Spectral
indices based on 905 nm and 1550 nm wavelengths were able to
explain 79-84% of the variation in EWT. The SR1550,905 index
showed the highest R2 with a value of 0.84 and a respective
prediction accuracy of 0.0041 g/cm2 (Figure 2). 3.1 The treatments effects on EWT All the treatments affected EWT during the experiment (Figure
1). The inoculated seedlings infected with the pathogen showed
a rapid decrease in EWT during the first 2-4 weeks of the
experiment. The seedlings in the drought treatment groups
showed resistance to drought and a longer time interval was
necessary for a significant decrease in EWT. Spectral index
R2
RMSE
SR690,1550
0.68
0.0058
SR1550,690
0.70
0.0056
SR690,905
0
0.0098
SR 905,1550
0.79
0.0043
SR1550,905
0.84
0.0041
NDVI690,1550
0.72
0.0055
NDVI690,905
0
0.0098
NDVI905,1550
0.82
0.0043
Table 2. Coefficients of determination (R2) and root mean
square error (RMSE) for the linear regression models betwe
spectral indices and EWT. Figure 1. Equivalent water thickness (EWT) in the treatment
groups during the experiment. Table 2. Coefficients of determination (R2) and root mean
square error (RMSE) for the linear regression models between
spectral indices and EWT. Table 2. Coefficients of determination (R2) and root mean
square error (RMSE) for the linear regression models between
spectral indices and EWT. Figure 1. Equivalent water thickness (EWT) in the treatment
groups during the experiment. Figure 2. Relationship between the best explanatory laser
intensity variable and equivalent water thickness (EWT). This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
https://doi.org/10.5194/isprs-archives-XLII-3-W3-81-2017 | © Authors 2017. CC BY 4.0 License. with conference pear trees (Pyrus Communis). Sensors 11, pp.
1657-1681. The use of MS-TLS based spectral indices showed potential for
estimating EWT in tree seedlings. Relatively high prediction
accuracy with R2 of 0.84 was achieved although no
normalization of intensity data for individual scans was
conducted indicating that the intensity measurements were
rather consistent in these environmental conditions. The
combination of 905 nm and 1550 nm wavelengths was able to
explain more of the variation in EWT than the combination of
690 nm and 1550 nm which is in accordance with previous
research (Ceccato et al., 2001). A wavelength in the near-
infrared spectrum is needed for normalizing leaf structural
effects such as specific leaf area rather than one in the visible
spectrum (Ceccato et al., 2001). Thus, the wavelength at 690 nm
used here was found redundant for estimating EWT. Ceccato, P., Flasse, S., Tarantola, S., Jacquemoud, S., Grégoire,
J.-M., 2001. Detecting vegetation leaf water content using
reflectance in the optical domain. Remote Sens. Environ. 77, pp. 22-33. Danson, F., Steven, M., Malthus, T., Clark, J., 1992. High-
spectral resolution data for determining leaf water content. Int. J. Remote Sens. 13, pp. 461-470. Easlon, H.M., Bloom, A.J., 2014. Easy Leaf Area: Automated
digital image analysis for rapid and accurate measurement of
leaf area. Appl. Plant Sci. 2. Gaulton, R., Danson, F., Ramirez, F., Gunawan, O., 2013. The
potential of dual-wavelength laser scanning for estimating
vegetation moisture content. Remote Sens. Environ. 132, pp. 32-
39. Here, the study was conducted in greenhouse conditions where
background illumination was low and other environmental
variables such as humidity and temperature were constant. The
studied method needs to be investigated in a forest environment
to validate the applicability of the method for mature tree
canopies. A forest environment is expected to be challenging for
using several laser scanners due to wind which moves the tree
canopies during data collection, thus, data correction pipelines
that are able to improve poor data quality due to wind are
needed. Girardeau-Montaut, D., 2011. Cloudcompare-open source
project. OpenSource Project. Hanewinkel, M., Cullmann, D.A., Schelhaas, M.-J., Nabuurs,
G.-J., Zimmermann, N.E., 2013. Climate change may cause
severe loss in the economic value of European forest land. Nature Climate Change 3, pp. 203-207. Separating laser returns between woody and foliage parts is also
a challenge that needs investigation to be able to measure EWT
of mature tree canopies. with conference pear trees (Pyrus Communis). Sensors 11, pp.
1657-1681. Scanning trees below the canopy
targets Junttila, S., Kaasalainen, S., Vastaranta, M., Hakala, T.,
Nevalainen, O., Holopainen, M., 2015. Investigating Bi-
Temporal Hyperspectral Lidar Measurements from Declined
Trees—Experiences from Laboratory Test. Remote Sens. 7, pp. 13863-13877. particularly the lower part of the canopy; thus, the response of
the tree canopies to drought and other factors that affect EWT,
and how the alterations in EWT are distributed along the
vertical profile of the canopies is of interest in developing
methods for estimating EWT with MS-TLS. Furthermore, dry
and dying branches below the vigorous part of the canopy may
affect the measurements. Junttila, S., Vastaranta, M., Liang, X., Kaartinen, H., Kukko,
A., Kaasalainen, S., Holopainen, M., Hyyppä, H., Hyyppä, J.,
2016. Measuring Leaf Water Content with Dual-Wavelength
Intensity Data from Terrestrial Laser Scanners. Remote Sens. 9. 5.
CONCLUSIONS Kaasalainen, S., Nevalainen, O., Hakala, T., Anttila, K., 2016. Incidence Angle Dependency of Leaf Vegetation Indices from
Hyperspectral Lidar Measurements. Photogramm. Fernerkun. 2016, pp. 75-84. The utilization of MS-TLS intensity data in estimating EWT in
Norway spruce seedlings showed high potential in this study. In
environmentally stable conditions a strong correlation (R2=0.84)
between EWT and a laser intensity based spectral index
(SR1550,905) was observed with a prediction accuracy of 0.0041
g/cm2. Based on our results, the use of MS-TLS can greatly
improve the estimation of EWT for coniferous species
compared to using single wavelength TLS. Skakun, R.S., Wulder, M.A., Franklin, S.E., 2003. Sensitivity of
the thematic mapper enhanced wetness difference index to
detect mountain pine beetle red-attack damage. Remote Sens. Environ. 86, pp. 433-443. 6.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Team, R.C., 2013. A language and environment for statistical
computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna,
Austria. This research has been co-financed by Center of Excellence in
Laser Scanning Research (CoE-LaSR), Niemi-foundation and
Finnish Cultural Foundation. White, J., Coops, N., Hilker, T., Wulder, M., Carroll, A., 2007. Detecting mountain pine beetle red attack damage with EO‐1
Hyperion moisture indices. Int. J. Remote Sens. 28, pp. 2111-
2121. 4.
DISCUSSION Single wavelength intensity features showed low to moderate
correlations with EWT in this study. The single wavelength
intensity response of TLSs has been shown to be sensitive to
incidence
angle
requiring
complicated
data
correction
procedures for estimating EWT (Zhu et al., 2017). Coniferous
species, such as Norway spruce studied here, have needles
which leaf area and dimensions are very small compared to
deciduous species. Thus, incidence angle is impossible to
calculate from these irregular surfaces when the laser spot
diameter at the target is larger than the width of a single needle. Spectral indices calculated from MS-TLS data have been found
to be insensitive to incidence angle effects when both of the
wavelengths are similarly influenced by the incidence angle
(Kaasalainen et al., 2016). The results from our study support
this since all of the spectral indices were able to explain the
variation in EWT better than single wavelength intensity
features. Table 1. Coefficients of determination (R2) and root mean
square error values (RMSE) for the regression models between
single wavelength laser intensity features and equivalent water
thickness. This contribution has been peer-reviewed. 83 The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland with conference pear trees (Pyrus Communis). Sensors 11, pp. 1657-1681. This contribution has been peer-reviewed.
https://doi.org/10.5194/isprs-archives-XLII-3-W3-81-2017 | © Authors 2017. CC BY 4.0 License. terrestrial laser scanner backscatter intensity with radiometric
correction. ISPRS J. Photogramm. 110, pp. 14-23. terrestrial laser scanner backscatter intensity with radiometric
correction. ISPRS J. Photogramm. 110, pp. 14-23.
Zhu, X., Wang, T., Skidmore, A.K., Darvishzadeh, R.,
Niemann, K.O., Liu, J., 2017. Canopy leaf water content
estimated using terrestrial LiDAR. Agric. For. Meteorol. 232,
pp. 152-162. REFERENCES Allen, C.D., Macalady, A.K., Chenchouni, H., Bachelet, D.,
McDowell, N., Vennetier, M., Kitzberger, T., Rigling, A.,
Breshears, D.D., Hogg, E., 2010. A global overview of drought
and heat-induced tree mortality reveals emerging climate
change risks for forests. For. Ecol. Manage. 259, pp. 660-684. Allen, C.D., Macalady, A.K., Chenchouni, H., Bachelet, D.,
McDowell, N., Vennetier, M., Kitzberger, T., Rigling, A.,
Breshears, D.D., Hogg, E., 2010. A global overview of drought
and heat-induced tree mortality reveals emerging climate
change risks for forests. For. Ecol. Manage. 259, pp. 660-684. Williams, A.P., Allen, C.D., Macalady, A.K., Griffin, D.,
Woodhouse, C.A., Meko, D.M., Swetnam, T.W., Rauscher,
S.A., Seager, R., Grissino-Mayer, H.D., 2013. Temperature as a
potent driver of regional forest drought stress and tree mortality. Nat. Clim. Change 3, pp. 292-297. Balduzzi, M.A., Van der Zande, D., Stuckens, J., Verstraeten,
W.W., Coppin, P., 2011. The properties of terrestrial laser
system intensity for measuring leaf geometries: A case study Zhu, X., Wang, T., Darvishzadeh, R., Skidmore, A.K.,
Niemann, K.O., 2015. 3D leaf water content mapping using This contribution has been peer-reviewed. https://doi.org/10.5194/isprs-archives-XLII-3-W3-81-2017 | © Authors 2017. CC BY 4.0 License. This contribution has been peer-reviewed. https://doi.org/10.5194/isprs-archives-XLII-3-W3-81-2017 | © Authors 2017. CC BY 4.0 License. 84 The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume XLII-3/W3, 2017
Frontiers in Spectral imaging and 3D Technologies for Geospatial Solutions, 25–27 October 2017, Jyväskylä, Finland terrestrial laser scanner backscatter intensity with radiometric
correction. ISPRS J. Photogramm. 110, pp. 14-23. Zhu, X., Wang, T., Skidmore, A.K., Darvishzadeh, R.,
Niemann, K.O., Liu, J., 2017. Canopy leaf water content
estimated using terrestrial LiDAR. Agric. For. Meteorol. 232,
pp. 152-162. 85
|
https://openalex.org/W4297180195
|
https://vbn.aau.dk/ws/files/522175228/1_s2.0_S0956713522005758_main.pdf
|
English
| null |
Effects of grade, smiley, and text on Danish and Finnish consumers’ perceptions of food safety inspection reports
|
Food control
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 9,319
|
Aalborg Universitet Effects of grade, smiley, and text on Danish and Finnish consumers’ perceptions of food
safety inspection reports Effects of grade, smiley, and text on Danish and Finnish consumers’ perceptions of food
safety inspection reports Vainio, Annukka ; Ollila, Sari ; Sørensen, Thomas Alrik; Kaskela, Jenni ; Finell, Eerika;
Leisner , Jørgen J.; Lundén , Janne
Published in:
Food Control Vainio, Annukka ; Ollila, Sari ; Sørensen, Thomas Alrik; Kaskela, Jenni ; Finell, Eerika;
Leisner , Jørgen J.; Lundén , Janne
Published in:
Food Control Vainio, Annukka ; Ollila, Sari ; Sørensen, Thomas Alrik; Kaskela, Jenni ; Finell, Eerika;
Leisner , Jørgen J.; Lundén , Janne
Published in:
Food Control Vainio, Annukka ; Ollila, Sari ; Sørensen, Thomas Alrik; Kaskela, Jenni ; Finell, Eerika;
Leisner , Jørgen J.; Lundén , Janne
Published in:
Food Control DOI (link to publication from Publisher):
10.1016/j.foodcont.2022.109382 Citation for published version (APA):
Vainio, A., Ollila, S., Sørensen, T. A., Kaskela, J., Finell, E., Leisner , J. J., & Lundén , J. (2023). Effects of
grade, smiley, and text on Danish and Finnish consumers’ perceptions of food safety inspection reports. Food
Control, 144, Article 109382. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2022.109382 General rights
Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners
and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Citation for published version (APA):
Vainio, A., Ollila, S., Sørensen, T. A., Kaskela, J., Finell, E., Leisner , J. J., & Lundén , J. (2023). Effects of
grade, smiley, and text on Danish and Finnish consumers’ perceptions of food safety inspection reports. Food
Control, 144, Article 109382. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2022.109382 Aalborg Universitet Annukka Vainio a,b,*, Sari Ollila c, Thomas Alrik Sørensen d, Jenni Kaskela e, Eerika Finell f,
Jørgen J. Leisner g, Janne Lund´en e Annukka Vainio a,b,*, Sari Ollila c, Thomas Alrik Sørensen d, Jenni Kaskela e, Eerika
Jørgen J. Leisner g, Janne Lund´en e a Department of Forest Sciences, Faculty of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Helsinki, Finland
b Helsinki Institute of Sustainability Science (HELSUS), University of Helsinki, Finland
c Department of Food and Nutrition Sciences, Faculty of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Helsinki, Finland
d Department of Communication and Psychology, Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities, Aalborg University, Denmark
e Department of Food Hygiene and Environmental Health, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Helsinki, Finland
f Department of Social Sciences, Faculty of Social Sciences and Business Studies, University of Eastern Finland, Finland
g Department of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, University of Copenhagen, Denmark A R T I C L E I N F O Keywords:
Food safety inspection report
Restaurant
Consumer perceptions
Disclosure
Survey experiment Publicly accessible food safety inspection reports are a standard procedure to inform consumers on restaurants’
food safety levels in many countries. This study examined how different formats of food safety inspection report
are associated with consumer perceptions related to food safety, as well as other perceptions about the restau
rant. The study was conducted in Denmark and Finland with similar inspection grade systems but differences in
the distribution of awarded grades. We conducted a population-based survey experiment with a between-subjects
design on nationally representative samples of the 18–70 years old Danish (n = 978) and Finnish (n = 907)
populations. Respondents received one of six food safety inspection reports with different combinations of in
spection grade with a smiley and/or text. According to the results, both Danish and Finnish consumers’ food
safety perceptions of the same grade were more positive when the report included a smiley, and more negative
when the report included a text. Finnish respondents perceived a good food safety inspection grade more
positively than Danish respondents but there were no country differences when the grade was poor. In addition,
food safety inspection results elicited perceptions that were not related to food safety in both countries. The
results suggest that if the grade is poor, the inclusion of text is effective in eliciting perceptions of increased food
safety risk. If the grade is good, a standalone smiley may be most effective in eliciting positive perceptions of a
high food safety level. Moreover, these results indicate the importance of carefully evaluating how to develop
public accessible inspection grades to ensure they are correctly interpreted by consumers in different countries. Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Available online 24 September 2022
0956-7135/© 2022 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2022.109382
Received 5 July 2022; Received in revised form 29 August 2022; Accepted 12 September 2022 * Corresponding author. Department of Forest Sciences, Faculty of Agriculture and Forestry, University of Helsinki, Finland.
E-mail address: annukka.vainio@helsinki.fi (A. Vainio). General rights
C
i h
d - Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. - You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain - Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. - You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain - Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or re
You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit making activity or commercial gain You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit making activity o
- You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal - y
y p
g
y
- You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal - Take down policy
If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us at vbn@aub.aau.dk providing details, and w
the work immediately and investigate your claim. y
this document breaches copyright please contact us at vbn@aub.aau.dk providing details, and we will remove access to
ely and investigate your claim. Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 Table 1 Distribution of food safety inspection grades in Finnish and Danish retail es
tablishments in 2020 (Finnish Food Authority, 2021; FVFA, 2021). Grade
Smiley
Distribution
%
Description
Finland
A
48.4
Excellent: Operations are in line with the
requirements. B
38.5
Good: There are small issues with the
operations which do not impair food safety
or mislead consumers. C
12.6
To be corrected: There are issues with the
operations which impair food safety or
mislead consumers. These issues must be
rectified within a set time period. D
0.5
Poor: There are issues with the operations
which jeopardise food safety or
considerably mislead consumers, or the
operator has failed to comply with orders
that have been issued. These issues must be
rectified with immediate effect. Denmark
1
81.8
No remarks
2
13.7
Remark
3
0.7
Injunction or prohibitary order
4
3.9
Administrative penalties, reported to the
police, or approval withdrawn. Distribution of food safety inspection grades in Finnish and Danish retail es
tablishments in 2020 (Finnish Food Authority, 2021; FVFA, 2021). Distribution of food safety inspection grades in Finnish and Danish retail es
tablishments in 2020 (Finnish Food Authority, 2021; FVFA, 2021). Grade
Smiley
Distribution
%
Description
Finland
A
48.4
Excellent: Operations are in line with the
requirements. B
38.5
Good: There are small issues with the
operations which do not impair food safety
or mislead consumers. C
12.6
To be corrected: There are issues with the
operations which impair food safety or
mislead consumers. These issues must be
rectified within a set time period. D
0.5
Poor: There are issues with the operations
which jeopardise food safety or
considerably mislead consumers, or the
operator has failed to comply with orders
that have been issued. These issues must be
rectified with immediate effect. Food safety inspection results are displayed to consumers in various
ways in different countries and regions. For example, numeric grading is
used in the UK (Food Standards Agency, 2017), star grading in Australia
(New South Wales Food Authority, 2021), letter grading in New York
City, US (McKelvey et al., 2015) and face symbols in Denmark (DVFA,
2019), Finland (Finnish Food Authority, 2018), Norway (Norwegian
Food Safety Authority, 2017), France (Minist`ere de l’agriculture et de
l’alimentation, 2017) and China (Bai et al., 2019). A core issue is
whether a report preferably should communicate risk in a verbal format,
a numeric grading format or face symbols or combinations thereof. Table 1 The
format of food safety inspection report influences the persuasiveness of
the inspection result as well as consumer response (Choi et al., 2013). Verbal formats may affect consumer behaviour to a larger degree
whereas numeric or letter grade formats may be easier to comprehend
(Dundes & Rajapaksa, 2001; Kim et al., 2017). The smiley format,
defined as visual representation of an idea, feeling, or status, used
alongside or instead of words (Evans, 2015; Luangrath et al., 2017),
seems to be particularly effective in catching consumers’ attention
(Pankaj & Rietveld, 2021). Smiley formats have initially been used in
advertisements and product packaging to convey (in particular) positive
moods (Stark & Crawford, 2015). The heterogeneity of the disclosure
schemes together with the differences in ways grades are awarded create
difficulties when comparing consumer perceptions of disclosed reports
between countries. i
Denmark
1
81.8
No remarks
2
13.7
Remark
3
0.7
Injunction or prohibitary order
4
3.9
Administrative penalties, reported to the
police, or approval withdrawn. The perceptual information available for the consumers can vary
between countries not only depending on whether the grade is readily
available (e.g., displayed on the entrance to an establishment) or not (e. g., hidden behind a QR code), but also in the degree of information the
report provides. Although researchers such as Nisbett (2004) have
argued for general cultural differences in perception and cognitive style,
individual differences are probably more subtle and based in part on
established perceptual categories (Dall et al., 2021; Xie & Zhang, 2017;
Zimmer & Fischer, 2020), and in part how various perceptual categories
are used (Brogaard & Sørensen, in press). Moreover, studies of visual
search behaviour have demonstrated that individuals have difficulties to
detect targets that are very rare (e.g., Wolfe et al., 2013). Similarly, one
may think that targets that are less informative may also capture
attention to a lesser degree. So, an obvious question that is rarely
addressed would be to study whether the frequency of awarding
different grades in a country affects general consumer perception about
food safety. reported to the police, or approval withdrawn” (DVFA, 2019). In addi
tion, the food safety inspection reports also provide verbal information
about the level of compliance with food safety regulations if the result
was below the highest grade. Table 1 Despite relatively similar public food
safety disclosure systems there are also significant differences between
Denmark and Finland in the way inspection grades are awarded to food
establishments in practice. In Denmark most retail establishments are
provided with the highest grade whereas retail inspection reports in
Finland show a much higher level of non-compliances (Table 1). Such
differences may affect consumer expectancy of grades (Pankaj & Riet
veld, 2021), and consequently, the consumer assessment of food safety. How the differences in the distribution of inspection grades affect con
sumer perception have not yet been studied. In this study we focused on two research questions. First, we wanted
to explore how the food safety inspection grade is associated with con
sumers’ perceptions of food safety, as well as other perceptions that are
not related to food safety. Second, we wanted to investigate how the two
different ways to communicate food safety inspection grade: smiley
format and text format are associated with consumers’ perceptions
related and unrelated to food safety. We investigated these two research
questions by analysing a quantitative survey conducted in Finland and
Denmark. There is evidence that consumer perceptions raised by food
safety inspection reports are multifaceted. While many of these per
ceptions are associated with food safety risk, consumers also interpret
food safety inspection reports as indicators of the restaurant and food
quality (R¨ohr et al., 2005; Vainio et al., 2020). However, there are no
studies that simultaneously assess both types of consumer perceptions,
and how they may potentially vary across different types of food safety
report formats cross-culturally. The obtained results can be used to
improve implementation or modification of public accessible inspection Denmark and Finland are examples of two Nordic countries that are
socio-culturally similar and have relatively similar public food safety
disclosure systems. In both countries, a food safety inspection report
targeted at consumers includes a smiley, as well as text. The Danish
Smiley Scheme was introduced in 2001 (DVFA, 2019), and the Finnish
Oiva scheme in 2013 (Finnish Food Authority, 2018). In both schemes,
information about the compliance with food safety regulations is
communicated using four different types of smiley faces (Table 1). The
widest smile indicates full compliance with food safety regulations,
followed by smiling face, straight smiley face, and finally unhappy
smiley face. 1. Introduction grading food safety scheme that was associated with a decline in Sal
monella infections in New York City (Firestone & Hedberg, 2018). Publication of inspector grade reports at food establishments has
become a common means to illustrate the actual food hygiene and safety
level of the establishments to consumers. Such reports may improve food
safety if consumers use them as a cue to shift demand towards restau
rants with higher hygiene standards (Aik et al., 2018; Choi et al., 2013;
Henson et al., 2006; Knight et al., 2007; Vainio et al., 2020), especially if
they are a result of unannounced inspections (Kaskela et al., 2021). In
addition, reports available to the public have been found to improve
compliance and restaurant hygiene (Kaskela et al., 2019; Wong et al.,
2015) and to have a positive effect on food safety, as shown by a letter A successful food safety inspection report can convey information
about the actual level of food safety to the consumer (Dundes & Raja
paksa, 2001) and is based on consumer’s knowledge of risks as well as
their concerns, needs and preferences (Charlebois & Summan, 2015;
Cope et al., 2010; Frewer, 2004). One challenge in effective risk
communication is that consumer behaviour is primarily driven by per
ceptions and not by what scientists regard as facts (Hansen et al., 2003;
Renn, 2006). Moreover, consumers may have illusory opinions on their
own understanding of what is described in inspection reports (Leisner
et al., 2014). Thus, consumers have been found to some degree confuse Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 A. Vainio et al. food safety issues with the topics such as food quality and level of service
at a food establishment (Vainio et al., 2020). For example, in a study
conducted in the US, respondents perceived quick-service restaurants to
be less safe than casual dining or fine dining restaurants (Park &
Almanza, 2015). From the consumer point of view, food safety is often
considered as part of the wider and multidimensional concept of food
quality, and these concepts may be used interchangeably (R¨ohr et al.,
2005). Consumers may also use quality indicators as proxy parameters
of disease risk (Curtis et al., 2004), and therefore the perceived quality of
a restaurant could be used as a cue for indicating the level of food safety
risk. 2.3. Methods We explored the research questions using a population-based survey
experiment approach with a between-subjects design (Mutz, 2011). The
respondents were randomly assigned to one of six groups. In total six
food safety inspection reports were designed with two different grades:
three reports with a good grade and three reports with a poor grade
(Supplementary material A). Each grade was presented with a stand
alone smiley, a standalone text, or both (Table 3). The good grade cor
responded to the grade A (“excellent”) in Finland and the grade 1 (“No
remarks”) in Denmark. The poor grade corresponded to the grade C (“to
be corrected”) in Finland and the grade 3 (“Injunction of prohibitary
order”) in Denmark (Table 1; Finnish Food Authority, 2021; FVFA,
2021). The smileys in the reports were grey. Firstly, the questionnaires were designed in English and then trans
lated into Finnish and Danish by the researchers. Secondly, the ques
tionnaires were pre-tested in Finland and Denmark among a small
sample of respondents, and finally, the questionnaires were pro
grammed into the Compusense Cloud software for a client testing before
actual data collection. The objective was to gather the samples of 900
respondents per each country and 150 respondents of each experimental
group (see Table 3). The total number of completed respondents was 1,141 in Finland and
1,457 in Denmark. Of the responses 20% (n = 234) from Finland and
30% (n = 479) from Denmark were excluded from the dataset due to
poor quality. Poor response quality was determined based on response
time and response patterns. Two questionnaire batteries were analysed
on response behaviour to reveal “straight liners” (standard deviation
between the statements = 0). The final sample included 907 respondents
in Finland and 978 respondents in Denmark (total N = 1,885). Six
different types of food safety inspection reports were distributed to
random sets of respondents (n = 153–169 and 150–152, respectively). The text in a report was designed to communicate the level of food
safety risk to the consumer. In Denmark and Finland, the type of
noncompliance is mentioned in the text description if noncompliance is
detected. Since experimental design requires that all the factors are
controlled, we had to focus on one kind of noncompliance. We chose
cleanliness because it is a major factor in preventing foodborne illness
(e.g., USDA (U.S. Department of Agriculture), 2016). grades to ensure their correct interpretation by consumers. The respondents in both countries were slightly more highly educated
than national populations. According to T-test, there were no statisti
cally significant differences in the level of education and gender distri
bution between the Danish and Finnish respondents. Instead, Danish
respondents (M = 48.4; SD = 15.48) were slightly older than the Finnish
respondents (M = 45.6, SD = 14.43), t(1883) = 4.14, p < 0.001. grades to ensure their correct interpretation by consumers. 2. Materials and methods 2.1. Data collection 2.1. Data collection The data were collected in April–May 2021 using an online ques
tionnaire, directed to the members of several different consumer panels
by a commercial marketing research company (Aistila Oy, Finland). The
samples are representative of 17–70 years old Internet users living in
Finland and Denmark in terms of age, gender, and region. 2.3. Methods Therefore, good
grade was communicated with a text “Food safety risks were not
elevated in the restaurant” and in poor grade was communicated with a
text “Food safety risks were elevated in the restaurant. Noncompliances
were detected in the cleanliness of the restaurant”. The grade was not
reported separately in the reports but through smiley and/or text. The
grade was separated as its own attribute variable in further analyses. In data collection we followed the APA ethical norms and GDPR. The
participation was totally voluntary, and the participants were informed
of the aims of the study. Before the data collection they signed informed
consent. In Denmark and Finland no ethical evaluation was needed in
this kind of data collection (Danish National Committee on Health
Research Ethics, 2018; Finnish National Board on Research Integrity,
2019). The anonymity of each participant was guaranteed. After reading the report, the respondents were requested to indicate
how high or low they perceived seven different food safety related issues
at the restaurant (hygiene level, compliance with food legislation in
restaurant operations, safety of the restaurant’s food to the consumers,
trust in operations of the restaurant, the level of freshness of food in
gredients, risk for the presence of spoiled food ingredients, food
poisoning risk). In addition, they were requested to indicate how high or
low they perceived four different issues that were not related to food
safety (palatability of food served at the restaurant, the level of the
customer service, the level of culinary experience enjoyed by consumers,
nutritional quality of food). These issues were chosen based on previous
findings on consumer perceptions raised by food safety inspection re
ports (Vainio et al., 2020), and presented to the respondents in a random
order. A 7-point response scale where the extremes were “very low” and
“very high” was used. Table 1 In Finland, these categories indicate “excellent”, “good”, “to
be corrected” and “poor” (Finnish Food Authority, 2019) whereas in
Denmark these categories indicate “no remarks”, “enjoining order”,
“injunction or prohibitary order” and “administrative penalties, 2 A. Vainio et al. Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 2.2. Characteristics of respondents The study explored two samples of the 18–70 years old Danish and
Finnish respondents. The samples were rather representative of the
national populations in terms of gender and age distribution (Table 2). Table 2
Characteristics of the respondents. Denmark
Finland
Data
sample
Populationa
c
Data
sample
Populationb
d
Gender
women
49.7
50
50.4
51
men
50.0
50
49.4
49
other/prefer not to
say
0.3
n.a. 0.2
n.a. Age groups
17–29
15.3
25
16.6
23
30–39
15.0
18
20.5
19
40–49
17.9
19
19.6
18
50–59
22.4
20
21.2
19
60–70
29.3
18
22.1
21
Highest level of education
basic
11.0
24
13.5
16
secondary
45.0
40
45.1
59
tertiary
43.5
35
40.6
25
other
0.5
1
0.9
n.a. a Statistics Statistics Denmark (2020a). b Statistics Statistics Finland (2020a). c Statistics Statistics Denmark (2020b). d Statistics Statistics Finland (2020b). Table 3 The experimental design used in the study and the number of respondents in
each experimental group (DK = Denmark; FI = Finland). The experimental design used in the study and the number of respondents in
each experimental group (DK = Denmark; FI = Finland). Report
number
Elements of report
Country
Grade (0 =
poor, 1 =
good)
Smiley (0 = not
included, 1 =
included)
Text description
(0 = not
included,
1 = included)
DK
FI
1
1
1
0
167
151
2
1
1
1
153
152
3
1
0
1
160
152
4
0
1
0
169
150
5
0
1
1
166
152
6
0
0
1
163
150 3 A. Vainio et al. A. Vainio et al. Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 perceptions related to food safety and the perceptions unrelated to food
safety was 0.64 (p < 0.001). 2.4. Analysis 3.1. Perceptions raised by food safety inspection reports Overall, all three reports with a good food safety inspection grade
elicited positive perceptions about food safety and all three reports with
a poor grade elicited negative perceptions about food safety even if the
grades were not explicitly stated but communicated implicitly via smiley
and/or text (Fig. 1A, Supplementary material C). Perceptions related to
food safety raised by the reports were relatively similar in Denmark and
Finland. The comparison of confidence intervals (95%) indicated only
one difference: a good food safety inspection grade was perceived more
positively in Finland than in Denmark when the grade was indicated
with a standalone text. The results of hierarchical multiple linear regression indicated that
all three studied elements of food safety inspection report (grade, smiley
format, and text format were used as binary variables, see Table 2) were
associated with perceptions related to food safety in the first step
(Table 4). More specifically, a good food safety inspection grade was
associated with more positive perceptions related to food safety. The use
of a smiley format independently increased positive perceptions related
to food safety. Instead, the use of a text format in the report was asso
ciated with more negative perceptions related to food safety. The second
step revealed that the Finnish respondents’ perceptions of food safety
raised by the studied reports were more positive than the Danish
respondents. i Instead, there were more differences within countries between
different types of reports. In Denmark, the perceptions of all three re
ports indicating a good grade differed from each other: the report with a
standalone smiley was perceived most positively and the report with a
standalone text was perceived least positively (Fig. 1A, Supplementary
material C). In Finland, a good food safety inspection grade indicated
with a standalone smiley was perceived more positively than the two
other reports that included text (either alone or combined with a
smiley). Three interaction terms were found to be statistically significant (p
< 0.05) in the third step multiple hierarchical regression. The first one
was an interaction between country and food safety inspection grade. A
visual interpretation of this interaction term and the comparison of
confidence intervals (95%) indicated that Finnish respondents perceived
the level of food safety more positively than the Danish respondents
when the food safety inspection grade was good but there were no dif
ferences between the countries when the grade was poor (Fig. 2A). 3.1. Perceptions raised by food safety inspection reports The
second statistically significant interaction was found between the food
safety inspection grade and the text format. Perceptions related to food
safety were more negative when a text format was used, and this effect
was more pronounced when the food safety inspection grade was poor
(Fig. 2B). The third interaction term was found between the re
spondents’ country and smiley format: the use of a smiley format
increased positive perceptions related to food safety in Denmark more
than in Finland (Fig. 2C). In Denmark, a poor food safety inspection grade indicated with a
standalone text was perceived more negatively than the two other re
ports including a smiley (either alone or combined with text) (Fig. 1A,
Supplementary material C). Instead in Finland, a poor grade indicated
with a standalone smiley was perceived less negatively than the other
two reports that included text (either alone or combined with a smiley). Food safety inspection grades also elicited perceptions that were
unrelated to food safety. More specifically, the reports with a good food
safety inspection grade elicited slightly more positive perceptions than
those with a poor grade (Fig. 1B, Supplementary material C). However,
this difference was smaller than in perceptions that were related to food
safety. The comparison of confidence intervals (95%) suggested two
differences between Denmark and Finland. More specifically, a good
food safety inspection grade indicated with a standalone smiley or
standalone text raised more positive perceptions unrelated to food safety In Denmark, a poor food safety inspection grade indicated with a
standalone text was perceived more negatively than the two other re
ports including a smiley (either alone or combined with text) (Fig. 1A,
Supplementary material C). Instead in Finland, a poor grade indicated
with a standalone smiley was perceived less negatively than the other
two reports that included text (either alone or combined with a smiley). Food safety inspection grades also elicited perceptions that were
unrelated to food safety. More specifically, the reports with a good food
safety inspection grade elicited slightly more positive perceptions than
those with a poor grade (Fig. 1B, Supplementary material C). However,
this difference was smaller than in perceptions that were related to food
safety. The comparison of confidence intervals (95%) suggested two
differences between Denmark and Finland. More specifically, a good
food safety inspection grade indicated with a standalone smiley or
standalone text raised more positive perceptions unrelated to food safety 2.4. Analysis An exploratory factor analysis (EFA; Maximum Likelihood, Oblimin
rotation) was used for testing that the eleven perceptions could be
grouped into two variables. As expected, EFA yielded two factors with
Eigenvalue >1: perceptions related to food safety and perceptions unrelated
to food safety (Supplementary material B). They together explained over
75% of variation in the responses. The mean scores of the items loading
over 0.40 to each factor were used in further analyses. For calculating
the mean scores, two items that loaded negatively into the first factor
were reverse coded. Cronbach alphas of the items were high (α = 0.90
and 0.93), indicating high reliability. The bivariate correlation between Respondents’ perceptions raised by six different food safety inspec
tion reports were compared using confidence intervals of the means
(95%). Further, hierarchical multiple linear regression was used for
testing associations between respondents’ country, the three elements of
the food safety inspection report (grade, smiley, text) and the two types
of perceptions: those that were related and those that were unrelated to
food safety. The three elements of the food safety inspection report
(grade, smiley, text) were used as binary variables (Table 2) in the
models. The combined effects were tested using interaction terms in the
regression models. The steps in hierarchical multiple linear regression ated (A) and unrelated (B) to food safety (−3 = very low, 3 = very high) raised by the six different food safety in
Means and confidence intervals (95%). Fig. 1. Perceptions related (A) and unrelated (B) to food safety (−3 = very low, 3 = very high) raised by the six different food safety inspection reports (R1-R6) in
Denmark and Finland. Means and confidence intervals (95%). 4 A. Vainio et al. Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 in Finland than in Denmark. No differences between Denmark and
Finland were identified in the perceptions of the reports with poor
grades. were as follows. The three elements of the food safety inspection report
(grade, smiley, text) were entered in the first step. The country variable
(Denmark vs. Finland) was added in the second step. Interaction terms
were added to the model in the third step. Finally, statistically signifi
cant interaction terms were interpreted using visual representations and
confidence intervals (95%). Because the Danish sample was slightly
older than the Finnish sample, we also tested the regression models
where the effect of age was controlled. 2.4. Analysis Age was not statistically signif
icant, and it did not affect other results. The perceptions unrelated to food safety raised by different types of
reports with a same grade were relatively similar within countries. Confidence intervals revealed only one difference (Fig. 1B, Supple
mentary material C). In Denmark, a poor grade indicated with a
standalone text was perceived more negatively than a poor grade indi
cated with a standalone smiley. In Finland, no differences between the
reports with the same grade were found. 3.3. Multiple hierarchical regression of perceptions unrelated to food
safety Then we analysed associations between respondents’ perceptions
that were unrelated to food safety, socio-demographic characteristics, Table 4 and food safety report elements using hierarchical multiple linear
regression (Table 5). In this analysis, the three elements of the food
safety inspection report (grade, smiley format, and text format) were
used as binary variables (Table 2). All three studied elements of food
safety inspection report were associated with perceptions unrelated to
food safety in the first step. Both a good food safety inspection grade and
the use of a smiley format were independently associated with more
positive perceptions that were unrelated to food safety. In addition, the
use of text format in the report was associated with more negative
perceptions unrelated to food safety. Interestingly, the combination of the positive smiley symbol and the
text format stating that there are no food safety risks in the restaurant
decreased the positive food safety perceptions. It is not clear why text
format decreased positive perceptions or why smiley format increased
them. One hypothesis could be that the consumers are startled by the
text about food safety risks. Another explanation could be that the in
clusion of a smiley increased positive perceptions because traditionally
smileys have been used in advertisements and product packaging for
conveying moods, in particular positive moods (Stark & Crawford,
2015). The mechanisms explaining the reaction should be investigated
further to better understand and control the effects of text and smiley in
communicating the level of food safety to consumers. The second step of hierarchical regression revealed that the Finnish
respondents had more positive perceptions unrelated to food safety than
the Danish respondents. In the third step, two interaction terms were
statistically significant (p < 0.05). The first interaction was found be
tween the country and the grade. Fig. 3A suggests that Finnish re
spondents had more positive perceptions unrelated to food safety than
Danish respondents when the food safety inspection grade was good but
no statistically significant difference between the countries was found
when the grade was poor. The second interaction term was found be
tween the respondents’ country and smiley format. More specifically,
the use of a smiley format in the report increased positive perceptions
unrelated to food safety in Denmark but not in Finland (Fig. 3B). g
y
There were some differences between Danish and Finnish re
spondents’ food safety perceptions. 4. Discussion The results of the study suggest that a combination of smileys and
text is a suitable format of communicating the level of food safety to
Danish and Finnish consumers. More specifically, all tested report for
mats elicited positive perceptions about food safety at the restaurant
when the text and the smiley were positive, and negative perceptions
when the text and the smiley were negative. In other words, the re
spondents interpreted the food safety inspection results in the way as
intended even if the inspection grades were not explicitly stated in the
reports but communicated indirectly via different combinations of
smiley and text. Interestingly, food safety inspection results also elicited perceptions
that were not related to food safety. Similar findings have also been
reported before (Vainio et al., 2020). A positive smiley and/or text eli
cited positive perceptions unrelated to food safety and a negative smiley
and/or text elicited neutral or negative perceptions. These findings
indicate that consumers may use information about food safety as cues
for other qualities of a given enterprise (Park & Almanza, 2015; R¨ohr
et al., 2005). Risk communication is effective when it minimizes misperceptions of
risk (Wall & Chen, 2018). From this perspective, communicating the
level of food safety risk as accurately as possible to the consumer is
important. The results suggest that the way food safety inspection grade
is communicated to consumers matters. More specifically, food safety
perceptions of the same grade were more positive when it was
communicated using a smiley format, and more negative when it was
communicated using a text format. This phenomenon occurred both
with good as well as poor food safety inspection grades and this overall
trend was the same in both countries. If the purpose of a good grade is to
indicate a low food safety risk and poor grade a high food safety risk, it
may be beneficial to combine a negative smiley with text if the purpose
is to elicit most negative food safety risk perceptions. When the purpose It would be of interest to study if consumers interpret information
unrelated to food safety as indicating the level of food safety. It could be
tested for instance by presenting rankings based on parameters unre
lated to food safety to respondents and subsequently ask them on their
perception of such rankings using terms based on food safety. Table 4 Table 4
The effect of food safety report elements and respondent country on perceptions related to food safety. Results of hierarchical multiple linear regression. Perceptions related to food safety
Step 1
Step 2
Step 3
B
S.E. Beta
B
S.E. Beta
B
S.E. Beta
Constant
−0.51***
0.84
−0.82***
0.11
−0.81***
0.27
Report: grade (0 = poor, 1 = good)
2.17***
0.05
0.67
2.17***
0.05
0.67
1.09***
0.22
0.34
Report: smiley format (0 = no, 1 = yes)
0.20**
0.07
0.06
0.20**
0.07
0.06
0.55*
0.21
0.16
Report: text format (0 = no, 1 = yes)
- 0.54***
0.07
−0.16
- 0.55***
0.06
−0.16
−0.37*
0.21
−0.11
Country (0 = DK, 1 = FI)
0.21***
0.05
0.07
0.33
0.17
0.10
Grade * smiley
0.25
0.13
0.07
Grade * text
0.29*
0.13
0.08
Country * grade
0.49***
0.10
0.25
Country * smiley
−0.32*
0.13
−0.16
Country * text
−0.22
0.13
−0.10
Adjusted R2
0.49***
0.50***
0.51***
***p < 0.001; **p < 0.01; *p < 0.05; B = unstandardized regression coefficient; Beta = standardized regression coefficient. nd respondent country on perceptions related to food safety. Results of hierarchical multiple linear regression. t of food safety report elements and respondent country on perceptions related to food safety. Results of hierarchical multipl A. Vainio et al. Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 nt interactions in perceptions related to food safety (−3 = very low, 3 = very high) between food safety i
inclusion of text (p < 0.05) in the whole data sample. Means and confidence intervals (95%). ant interactions in perceptions related to food safety (−3 = very low, 3 = very high) between food safety
inclusion of text (p < 0.05) in the whole data sample. Means and confidence intervals (95%). Fig. 2. Statistically significant interactions in perceptions related to food safety (−3 = very low, 3 = very high) between food safety inspection grade and country,
and between grade and the inclusion of text (p < 0.05) in the whole data sample. Means and confidence intervals (95%). 6 Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 A. Vainio et al. is to elicit positive food safety perceptions instead a standalone smiley
symbol may be most effective. It would be of interest to further study the
effect of the amount and content of text in food safety inspection reports
in different countries as well as over time if food safety inspection
grading systems change within a country. Table 4 In general, Finnish respondents
perceived good food safety inspection grades more positively from the
food safety perspective than Danish respondents but there were no dif
ferences between the two countries when the grade was poor. Regarding
the specific report formats that were explored in this study, Danish re
spondents reacted more negatively to a good food inspection grade
communicated with a standalone text than Finnish respondents. Dif
ferences in report grades for Denmark and Finland as observed by
Lund´en et al. (2021) may add to explain such outcomes. Thus, best food
safety inspection grade is more frequent among Danish inspector records
than is the case for Finnish reports (DVFA, 2020). As negative grades are
often associated with explanatory text, the latter is a more familiar sight
for the Finnish consumers. As a result, they may to a lesser extent
disapprove such records. 4. Discussion The
rankings used could include non-food safety related terms such as those
included in this study (palatability of food, level of customer service,
culinary experience, nutrition value) in addition to others such as price Table 5
The effect of food safety report elements and respondent country on perceptions unrelated to food safety. Results of hierarchical multiple linear regression. Perceptions unrelated to food safety
Step 1
Step 2
Step 3
B
S.E. Beta
B
S.E. Beta
B
S.E. Beta
Constant
−0.24**
0.09
−0.41***
0.12
−0.54
0.28
Report: grade (0 = poor, 1 = good)
0.88***
0.05
0.35
0.88***
0.05
0.35
0.19
0.23
0.08
Report: smiley format (0 = no, 1 = yes)
0.18**
0.07
0.07
0.18*
0.07
0.07
0.51*
0.22
0.19
Report: text format (0 = no, 1 = yes)
- 0.15*
0.07
−0.06
- 0.15*
0.07
−0.06
0.07
0.22
0.03
Country (0 = DK, 1 = FI)
0.12*
0.05
0.05
0.28
0.17
0.11
Grade * smiley
0.16
0.13
0.06
Grade * text
0.17
0.13
0.07
Country * grade
0.32**
0.11
0.21
Country * smiley
- 0.28*
0.13
−0.18
Country * text
−0.21
0.13
−0.13
Adjusted R2
0.13***
0.13***
0.14***
***p > 0.001; **p > 0.01; *p > 0.05; B = unstandardized regression coefficient; Beta = standardized regression coefficient. Table 5 nts and respondent country on perceptions unrelated to food safety. Results of hierarchical multiple linear regression. A. Vainio et al. Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 3. Statistically significant interactions in perceptions unrelated to food safety (−3 = very low, 3 = very high) between food safety inspection grade and country,
between country and the smiley format (p < 0.05) in the whole data sample. Means and confidence intervals (95%). Fig. 3. Statistically significant interactions in perceptions unrelated to food safety (−3 = very low, 3 = very high) between food safety inspection grade and country,
and between country and the smiley format (p < 0.05) in the whole data sample. Means and confidence intervals (95%). Fig. 3. Statistically significant interactions in perceptions unrelated to food safety (−3 = very low, 3 = very high) between
and between country and the smiley format (p < 0.05) in the whole data sample. Means and confidence intervals (95% and authenticity. Moreover, another important line of further study
could be if restaurant quality rankings have a spill-over to perceptions
related to food safety. report and not any other information cues which are present in real-life
situations. Previous research suggests that restaurant customers use a
wide range of cues to assess food safety (Danelon & Salay, 2012; Fatimah
et al., 2011; Gregory & Kim, 2004). Therefore, it is possible that the
perceptions could have been different in a real-life setting where more
information cues would have been present. Moreover, the experiment
was based on a simplified food safety report where many parts included
in actual reports used in Denmark and Finland were missing. Those
other parts might have different impact on consumers’ perceptions than
just those investigated in this study. For example, we focused only on
two grades instead of four. Moreover, we only analysed perceptions and
not behaviour. Therefore, we cannot derive behavioural implications
from our results. For example, the results cannot be used to indicate if
the respondents would visit a restaurant with a certain food inspection
grade or if they generally pay attention to food inspection grades. These
simplifications were necessary because it allowed us to eliminate the
influence of non-controlled variables, which are unavoidable in real-life
contexts. The associations between consumer perceptions and behaviour report and not any other information cues which are present in real-life
situations. Table 5 Previous research suggests that restaurant customers use a
wide range of cues to assess food safety (Danelon & Salay, 2012; Fatimah
et al., 2011; Gregory & Kim, 2004). Therefore, it is possible that the
perceptions could have been different in a real-life setting where more
information cues would have been present. Moreover, the experiment
was based on a simplified food safety report where many parts included
in actual reports used in Denmark and Finland were missing. Those
other parts might have different impact on consumers’ perceptions than
just those investigated in this study. For example, we focused only on
two grades instead of four. Moreover, we only analysed perceptions and
not behaviour. Therefore, we cannot derive behavioural implications
from our results. For example, the results cannot be used to indicate if
the respondents would visit a restaurant with a certain food inspection
grade or if they generally pay attention to food inspection grades. These
simplifications were necessary because it allowed us to eliminate the
influence of non-controlled variables, which are unavoidable in real-life
contexts. The associations between consumer perceptions and behaviour Food inspector records are now accessible to the public in several
countries worldwide. It is evident that the grading systems differ be
tween countries (e.g., Food Standards Agency, 2017; New South Wales
Food Authority, 2021; Norwegian Food Safety Authority, 2017) but it is
less clear what kind of differences there are between countries in the
way good and poor grades are awarded. This study compared two
countries with rather similar grading systems which however are
distributed differently in practice. The obtained results suggest that the
way grades are awarded influences consumer perceptions, but further
studies are required to substantiate this finding. Research in that di
rection will provide important information regarding to what extent
food inspectors’ grades as well as the way of communication of such
grades may affect how consumers perceive food safety at a restaurant. The study involved a hypothetical experiment where the respondents
had to indicate their perceptions based on the simplified food safety 8 A. Vainio et al. Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 Brogaard, B., & Sørensen, T. A. (in press). The role of long-term memory in visual
perception. In French, R. & Brogaard, B. (eds.), The roles of representation in visual
perception. Synthese Library Book Series, Springer. are important issues to be explored in future research. Table 5 In addition, the
data was collected during the COVID-19 pandemic. Therefore, it is
possible that restrictions targeted to the restaurant operations in both
countries may have affected consumers’ perceptions. Charlebois, S., & Summan, A. (2015). A risk communication model for food regulatory
agencies in modern society. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 45, 153–165. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tifs.2015.05.004 In conclusion, despite the limitations, the results can be used for
developing publicly accessible food safety communication to consumers
that is meaningful across different countries and languages. Due to
increased internationalization and travelling, there is increased need for
developing food safety grading systems that are perceived similarly by
people living in different countries. No such system exists now, and one
barrier could be regional and socio-cultural differences in grading
practices and consumer needs. For example, the current system that is
used in Denmark and Finland could potentially be extended to countries
with similar schemes. Currently, due to the decreasing attention spans
there is increasing demand for simplifying food safety inspection re
ports. The findings of the current study suggests that a smiley could be
used for communicating positive results, and a combination of smiley
and text could be used for communicating negative food safety inspec
tion results. However, the results also suggest that one size does not fit
all and therefore the inspection report schemes need to find a balance
between being understandable to a wide range of consumers irrespective
of language barriers and conveying enough information about food
safety. Choi, J., Miao, L., Almanza, B., & Nelson, C. D. (2013). Consumers’ responses to
restaurant inspection reports: The effects of information source and message style. Journal of Foodservice Business Research, 16, 255–275. https://doi.org/10.1080/
15378020.2013.810536 Cope, S., Frewer, L. J., Houghton, J., Rowe, G., Fischer, A. R. H., & de Jonge, S. (2010). Consumer perceptions of best practice in food risk communication and management:
Implications for risk analysis policy. Food Policy, 35, 349–357. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.foodpol.2010.04.002 Curtis, V., Aunger, R., & Rabie, T. (2004). Evidence that disgust evolved to protect from
risk of disease. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, 271, S131–S133. https://
doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2003.0144 Dall, J. O., Wang, Y. M., Cai, X. L., Chan, R. C., & Sørensen, T. A. (2021). Visual short-
term memory and attention: An investigation of familiarity and stroke count in
Chinese characters. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and
Cognition, 47(2), 282–294. https://doi.org/10.1037/xlm0000950 Danelon, M. S., & Salay, E. (2012). 5. Funding y
g
g
p
DVFA. (2020). Smiley-statistik. Danish veterinary and food administration. Ministry of
Environment and Food of Denmark. Available at: https://www.findsmiley.dk/Statist
ik/Smiley-statistik/Sider/default.aspx. Authors gratefully acknowledge funding from the Finnish Founda
tion of Veterinary Research and the Section for Food Safety and Zoo
noses, Department of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, University of
Copenhagen. y
p
Evans, V. (2015). No, the rise of the emoji doesn’t spell the end of language. The
Conversation. May 22th. Available at: https://theconversation.com/no-the-rise-of
-the-emoji-doesnt-spell-the-end-of-language-42208. j
p
g
g
Fatimah, U. S. A. U., Boo, H. C., Sambasivan, M., & Salleh, R. (2011). Foodservice
hygiene factors—the consumer perspective. International Journal of Hospitality
Management, 30, 38–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhm.2010.04.001 Table 5 Perceived physical risk and risk-reducing strategies in
the consumption of raw vegetable salads in restaurants. Food Control, 28, 412–419. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2012.05.026 p
g
j
Danish National Committee on Health Research Ethics. (2018). Rules and guidelines. Available at: https://en.nvk.dk/rules-and-guidelines. Dundes, L., & Rajapaksa, S. (2001). Scores and grades: A sampling of how college
students and food safety professionals interpret restaurant inspection results. Journal
of Environmental Health, 64, 14–19. PMID: 11764676. DVFA. (2019). About the Danish smiley scheme. Danish veterinary and food administration. Ministry of Environment and Food of Denmark. Available at: https://www.findsmile
y.dk/english/Pages/About.aspx. CRediT authorship contribution statement Finnish Food Authority. (2018). Food safety in Finland 2017. Evira publications, 4/2018. (2018). Available at: https://www.ruokavirasto.fi/globalassets/tietoa-meista/julkai
sut/julkaisusarjat/julkaisuja/en/eviran_julkaisuja_4_2018_uk_310818.pdf. Annukka Vainio: Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal anal
ysis, Writing. Sari Ollila: Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal
analysis, Writing. Thomas Alrik Sørensen: Conceptualization, Meth
odology, Writing. Jenni Kaskela: Conceptualization, Methodology. Eerika Finell: Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal analysis,
Writing. Jørgen J. Leisner: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing,
Funding acquisition. Janne Lund´en: Conceptualization, Methodology,
Writing, Funding acquisition. Finnish Food Authority. (2019). Oiva evaluation guidelines for registered food premises. Available at: https://www.oivahymy.fi/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/oiva-arvioi
ntiohjeet-ilmoitetuille-elintarvikehuoneistoille-en-03072017.pdf. Finnish Food Authority. (2021). Food safety in Finland 2020. Finnish Food Authority
publications 3/2021. Available at: https://www.ruokavirasto.fi/globalassets/tietoa
-meista/julkaisut/julkaisusarjat/julkaisuja/julkaisuja_3_2021_elintarviketurvallisuu
s_suomessa_2020.pdf. Finnish National Board on Research Integrity. (2019). The ethical principles of research
with human participants and ethical review in the human sciences in Finland. Finnish National Board on Research Integrity TENK publications. Available at: htt
ps://tenk.fi/sites/default/files/2021-01/Ethical_review_in_human_sciences_2020. pdf. Firestone, M. J., & Hedberg, C. W. (2018). Restaurant inspection letter grades and
Salmonella infections, New York, New York, USA. Emerging Infectious Diseases, 24,
2164. https://doi.org/10.3201/eid2412.180544 Data availability Hansen, J., Holm, L., Frewer, L., Robinson, P., & Sandøe, P. (2003). Beyond the
knowledge deficit: Recent research into lay and expert attitudes to food risks. Appetite, 41(2), 111–121. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0195-6663(03)00079-5 Data will be made available on request. Data will be made available on request. Henson, S., Majowicz, S., Masakure, O., Sockett, P., Jones, A., Hart, R., Carr, D., &
Knowles, L. (2006). Consumer assessment of the safety of restaurants: The role of
inspection notices and other information cues. Journal of Food Safety, 26, 275–301. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-4565.2006.00049.x i Declaration of competing interest Food Standards Agency. (2017). Food hygiene rating scheme (FHRS) biannual public attitude
stracker. UK: Food Standards Agency. Available at: https://www.food.gov.uk/sites/
default/files/media/document/fhrstrackerwave5report_1_0.pdf. The authors declare that they have no known competing financial
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence
the work reported in this paper. i
Frewer, L. (2004). The public and effective risk communication. Toxicology Letters, 149,
391–397. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.toxlet.2003.12.049 Gregory, S., & Kim, J. (2004). Restaurant choice: The role of information. Journal of
Foodservice Business Research, 7, 81–95. https://doi.org/10.1300/J369v07n01_06 Appendix A. Supplementary data Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https://doi. org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2022.109382. g
j
Kaskela, J., Sund, R., & Lund´en, J. (2021). Efficacy of disclosed food safety inspections in
restaurants. Food Control, 123, Article 107775. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. foodcont.2020.107775 Kaskela, J., Vainio, A., Ollila, S., & Lund´en, J. (2019). Food business operators’ opinions
on disclosed food safety inspections and occurrence of disagreements with inspector
grading. Food Control, 105, 248–255. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. foodcont.2019.06.005 Bai, L., Wang, M., Yang, Y., & Gong, S. (2019). Food safety in restaurants: The consumer
perspective. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 77, 139–146. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhm.2018.06.023 Aik, J., Newall, A. T., Ng, L.-C., Kirk, M. D., & Heywood, A. E. (2018). Use of the letter-
based grading information disclosure system and its influence on dining
establishment choice in Singapore: A cross-sectional study. Food Control, 90,
105–112. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2018.02.038 Aik, J., Newall, A. T., Ng, L.-C., Kirk, M. D., & Heywood, A. E. (2018). Use of the letter-
based grading information disclosure system and its influence on dining
establishment choice in Singapore: A cross-sectional study. Food Control, 90,
105–112. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2018.02.038
Bai, L., Wang, M., Yang, Y., & Gong, S. (2019). Food safety in restaurants: The consumer
perspective. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 77, 139–146. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhm.2018.06.023 References Aik, J., Newall, A. T., Ng, L.-C., Kirk, M. D., & Heywood, A. E. (2018). Use of the letter-
based grading information disclosure system and its influence on dining
establishment choice in Singapore: A cross-sectional study. Food Control, 90,
105–112. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2018.02.038 Kim, J., Ma, J., & Almanza, B. (2017). Consumer perception of the food and drug
administration’s newest recommended food facility inspection format: Words
matter. Journal of Environmental Health, 79, 20–25. PMID: 29154529. Knight, A. J., Worosz, M. R., & Todd, E. C. D. (2007). Serving food safety: Consumer
perceptions of food safety at restaurants. International Journal of Contemporary 9 A. Vainio et al. Food Control 144 (2023) 109382 Stark, L., & Crawford, K. (2015). The conservatism of emoji: Work, affect, and
communication. Social Media + Society, 1, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1177/
2056305115604853 i Hospitality Management, 19, 476–484. https://doi.org/10.1108/
09596110710775138 Hospitality Management, 19, 476–484. https://doi.org/10.1108/
09596110710775138 Leisner, J. J., Lund, T. B., Frandsen, E. A., Andersen, N. B. E., Fredslund, L.,
Nguyen, V. P. T., & Kristiansen, T. (2014). What consumers expect from food control
and what they get – a case study of the microbial quality of sushi bars in Denmark. Food Control, 45, 76–80. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2014.04.017 Statistics Denmark. (2020a). FOLK1A: Population at the first day of the quarter by
region, sex, age and marital status (2020Q4). Available at: www.statbank. dk/FOLK1A. Statistics Denmark. (2020b). HFUDD11: Educational attainment by region, ancestry,
highest education completed, age and sex. Available at: https://www.statbank. dk/HFUDD11. i Luangrath, A. W., Peck, J., & Barger, V. A. (2017). Textual paralanguage and its
implications for marketing communications. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 27,
98–107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcps.2016.05.002 Statistics Finland. (2020a). Population structure. Available at: www.stat.fi/en/statisti
cs/vaerak. Lund´en, J., Kosola, M., Kiuru, J., Kaskela, J., & Inkinen, T. (2021). Disclosed restaurant
inspection results on food safety show regional and local differences in Finland. Food
Control, 119, Article 107462. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2020.107462 Statistics Finland. (2020b). Educational structure of population. Available at: https://stat
.fi/tilasto/vkour. McKelvey, W., Wong, M. R., & Matis, B. (2015). Letter grading and transparency promote
restaurant food safety in New York City. Journal of Environmental Health, 78(2),
46–48. PMID: 26502567. i
USDA (U.S. Department of Agriculture). (2016). Cleanliness helps prevent foodborne
illness. Available at: https://www.fsis.usda.gov/food-safety/safe-food-handling-a
nd-preparation/food-safety-basics/cleanliness-helps-prevent. Minist`ere de l’agriculture et de l’alimentation. (2017). Les r´esultats des contrˆoles sanitaires
accessibles `a tous. Available at: https://www.alim-confiance.gouv.fr/. l
b
d Vainio, A., Kaskela, J., Finell, E., Ollila, S., & Lund´en, J. (2020). References Consumer perceptions
raised by the food safety inspection report: Does the smiley communicate a food
safety risk? Food Control, 110, Article 106976. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. foodcont.2019.106976 ,
(
)
p
y
p
y
New South Wales Food Authority. (2021). Scores on doors. Consumer guide. New South
Wales Food Authority. Available at: https://www.foodauthority.nsw.gov.au/retail/s
cores-on-doors/consumer-guide. i b
(2004)
h
h
f h
h
i
d
hi k diff
l Wall, P. G., & Chen, J. (2018). Moving from risk communication to food information
communication and consumer engagement. NPJ. Science of Food, 2, 21. https://doi. org/10.1038/s41538-018-0031-7 Nisbett, R. (2004). The geography of thought: How asians and westerners think differently... And why. Simon and Schuster. g
Wolfe, J. M., Brunelli, D. N., Rubinstein, J., & Horowitz, T. S. (2013). Prevalence effects
in newly trained airport checkpoint screeners: Trained observers miss rare targets,
too. Journal of Vision, 13(3), 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1167/13.3.33, 33. y
Norwegian Food Safety Authority. (2017). Norwegian food safety authority 2017 annual
report. Available at: https://www.mattilsynet.no/om_mattilsynet/annual_report_the y
Norwegian Food Safety Authority. (2017). Norwegian food safety authority 2017 annual
report. Available at: https://www.mattilsynet.no/om_mattilsynet/annual_report_the
_norwegian_food_safety_authority_2017.34799/binary/Annual%20report%20The%
20Norwegian%20Food%20Safety%20Authority%202017. _norwegian_food_safety_authority_2017.34799/binary/Annual%20report%20The%
20Norwegian%20Food%20Safety%20Authority%202017. Wong, M. R., McKelvey, W., Ito, K., Schiff, C., Jacobson, J. B., & Kass, D. (2015). Impact
of a letter-grade program on restaurant sanitary conditions and diner behavior in
New York city. American Journal of Public Health, 105, 81–87. https://doi.org/
10 2105/AJPH 2014 302404 Pankaj, C. P., & Rietveld, C. A. (2021). The impact of the public disclosure of curved
inspection scores using emojis on hygiene violations in food establishments. Cornell
Hospitality Quarterly, 62(4), 455–467. https://doi.org/10.1177/1938965520935398 Xie, W., & Zhang, W. (2017). Familiarity speeds up visual short-term memory
consolidation. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance,
43(6), 1207–1221. https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn_a_01188 Park, H., & Almanza, B. (2015). Consumers’ reactions to sanitation in casual dining,
quick-service, and fine dining restaurants. Hospitality Review, 31(4). Article 10 htt
ps://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/hospitalityreview/vol31/iss4/10. i
Renn, O. (2006). Risk communication – consumers between information and irritation. Journal of Risk Research, 9(8), 833–849. https://doi.org/10.1080/
13669870601010938 Zimmer, H. D., & Fischer, B. (2020). Visual working memory of Chinese characters and
expertise: The expert’s memory advantage is based on long-term knowledge of visual
word forms. Frontiers in Psychology, 11, 516. https://doi.org/10.3389/
fpsyg.2020.00516 R¨ohr, A., Lüddecke, K., Drusch, S., Müller, M. J., & Alvensleben, R. V. (2005). Food
quality and safety––consumer perception and public health concern. Food Control, 16
(8), 649–655. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2004.06.001 10
|
https://openalex.org/W4234362902
|
https://kclpure.kcl.ac.uk/ws/files/3353430/journal.pone.0034188.pdf
|
English
| null |
Culture and End of Life Care: A Scoping Exercise in Seven European Countries
|
Routledge eBooks
| 2,020
|
cc-by
| 20,114
|
Citation for published version (APA):
Gysels, M., Evans, N., Menaca, A., Andrew, E., Toscani, F., Finetti, S., Pasman, H. R., Higginson, I., Harding,
R., Pool, R., & Project PRISMA (2012). Culture and End of Life Care: A Scoping Exercise in Seven European
Countries. PL o S One , 7(4), -. Article e34188. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0034188 Citation for published version (APA):
Gysels, M., Evans, N., Menaca, A., Andrew, E., Toscani, F., Finetti, S., Pasman, H. R., Higginson, I., Harding,
R., Pool, R., & Project PRISMA (2012). Culture and End of Life Care: A Scoping Exercise in Seven European
Countries. PL o S One , 7(4), -. Article e34188. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0034188 Citing this paper
Pl
h C t
g t
s pape
Please note that where the full-text provided on King's Research Portal is the Author Accepted Manuscript or Post-Print version this may
differ from the final Published version. If citing, it is advised that you check and use the publisher's definitive version for pagination,
volume/issue, and date of publication details. And where the final published version is provided on the Research Portal, if citing you are
again advised to check the publisher's website for any subsequent corrections. Citation for published version (APA):
Gysels, M., Evans, N., Menaca, A., Andrew, E., Toscani, F., Finetti, S., Pasman, H. R., Higginson, I., Harding,
R., Pool, R., & Project PRISMA (2012). Culture and End of Life Care: A Scoping Exercise in Seven European
Countries. PL o S One , 7(4), -. Article e34188. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0034188 Abstract doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034188 Editor: Alejandro Lucia, Universidad Europea de Madrid, Spain Received November 17, 2011; Accepted February 28, 2012; Published April 3, 2012 Received November 17, 2011; Accepted February 28, 2012; Published April 3, 2012 Copyright: 2012 Gysels et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Funding: PRISMA is funded by the European Commission’s Seventh Framework Programme (contract number: Health-F2-2008-201655). The funders had no role
in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. Funding: PRISMA is funded by the European Commission’s Seventh Framework Programme (contract number: Health-F2-2008-201655). The funders had no role
in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. * E-mail: mhgysels@gmail.com * E-mail: mhgysels@gmail.com Introduction increasing research activity in clinical practice and service
provision [7,8,9,10]. The history of the hospice movement,
originally developed in the UK, has been well described [11,12]
and the adoption of the hospice model in the rest of the Anglo-
Saxon world is equally well documented [13]. More recently,
initiatives have started to map developments in EoL care in
Europe and the rest of the world with a focus on service-provision
[14,15]. Less is known about the socio-cultural context in which
EoL care is developing. By including a section on culture and EoL
care
the
Economist
Intelligence
Unit’s
comparative
report
recognised its importance for EoL care [1]. However, no attempt
to explore this area more systematically in an international context
has been made so far. This paper addresses evidence on the role of
culture in EoL care in Europe. Given the ageing of European populations, there will be a
growing demand for end of life (EoL) care in the coming years
[1,2]. In a context of globalization, migration and European
integration, culture is becoming increasingly important in relation
to health care. It affects patients’ and professionals’ perceptions of
health conditions and appropriate treatments, and it influences
responses to illness, health care services and death [3,4]. When
patients, their families and health professionals face chronic or
terminal illness, with limitations to cure and difficult decisions,
differences in cultural norms and values become especially salient. Given the ageing of European populations, there will be a
growing demand for end of life (EoL) care in the coming years
[1,2]. In a context of globalization, migration and European
integration, culture is becoming increasingly important in relation
to health care. It affects patients’ and professionals’ perceptions of
health conditions and appropriate treatments, and it influences
responses to illness, health care services and death [3,4]. When
patients, their families and health professionals face chronic or
terminal illness, with limitations to cure and difficult decisions,
differences in cultural norms and values become especially salient. In order to improve care [5,6], and ensure that palliative care
can secure its share from national budgets and allocate these
resources in a just way [7] there is a need for relevant evidence. Culture and End of Life Care: A Scoping Exercise in Seven
European Countries Marjolein Gysels1,2,4*, Natalie Evans1,5, Arantza Men˜ aca1, Erin Andrew1, Franco Toscani3, Sylvia Finetti3,
H. Roeline Pasman5, Irene Higginson2, Richard Harding2, Robert Pool1,4, on behalf of Project PRISMA 1 Barcelona Centre for International Health Research, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain, 2 Department of Palliative Care, Policy and Rehabilitation, King’s College
London, London, United Kingdom, 3 Fondazione ‘‘Lino Maestroni’’, Istituto di Ricerca in Medicina Palliativa, Cremona, Italy, 4 Centre for Social Science and Global Health,
University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 5 Department of Public and Occupational Health, Emgo Institute for Health and Care Research, Expertise Center
for Palliative Care, VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands General rights General rights
Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the Research Portal are retained by the authors and
owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognize and abide by the legal requirements associ ral rights for the publications made accessible in the Research Portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright
condition of accessing publications that users recognize and abide by the legal requirements associated with these right •Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the Research Portal for the purpose of private study or research. •You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain
•You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the Research Portal •Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the Research Portal for the purpose of private study
•You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain y
y p
g
y
•You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the Research Portal Take down policy
If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact librarypure@kcl.ac.uk providing details, and we will remove access to
the work immediately and investigate your claim. p
y
If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact librarypure@kcl.ac.uk providing details, and we w
the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 24. Oct. 2024 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Abstract Aim: Culture is becoming increasingly important in relation to end of life (EoL) care in a context of globalization, migration
and European integration. We explore and compare socio-cultural issues that shape EoL care in seven European countries
and critically appraise the existing research evidence on cultural issues in EoL care generated in the different countries. Methods: We scoped the literature for Germany, Norway, Belgium, the Netherlands, Spain, Italy and Portugal, carrying out
electronic searches in 16 international and country-specific databases and handsearches in 17 journals, bibliographies of
relevant papers and webpages. We analysed the literature which was unearthed, in its entirety and by type (reviews, original
studies, opinion pieces) and conducted quantitative analyses for each country and across countries. Qualitative techniques
generated themes and sub-themes. Results: A total of 868 papers were reviewed. The following themes facilitated cross-country comparison: setting, caregivers,
communication, medical EoL decisions, minority ethnic groups, and knowledge, attitudes and values of death and care. The
frequencies of themes varied considerably between countries. Sub-themes reflected issues characteristic for specific
countries (e.g. culture-specific disclosure in the southern European countries). The work from the seven European countries
concentrates on cultural traditions and identities, and there was almost no evidence on ethnic minorities. Conclusion: This scoping review is the first comparative exploration of the cultural differences in the understanding of EoL
care in these countries. The diverse body of evidence that was identified on socio-cultural issues in EoL care, reflects clearly
distinguishable national cultures of EoL care, with differences in meaning, priorities, and expertise in each country. The
diverse ways that EoL care is understood and practised forms a necessary part of what constitutes best evidence for the
improvement of EoL care in the future. Citation: Gysels M, Evans N, Men˜aca A, Andrew E, Toscani F, et al. (2012) Culture and End of Life Care: A Scoping Exercise in Seven European Countries. PLoS
ONE 7(4): e34188. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034188
Editor: Alejandro Lucia, Universidad Europea de Madrid, Spain
Received November 17, 2011; Accepted February 28, 2012; Published April 3, 2012 s N, Men˜aca A, Andrew E, Toscani F, et al. (2012) Culture and End of Life Care: A Scoping Exercise in Seven European Countries. PLoS
1371/journal.pone.0034188 Citation: Gysels M, Evans N, Men˜aca A, Andrew E, Toscani F, et al. (2012) Culture and End of Life Care: A Scoping Exercise in Seven
ONE 7(4): e34188. AND (palliative OR terminal OR ‘‘end of life’’ OR end-of-life OR
death OR dying OR ‘‘continu* care’’ OR ‘‘advance directive*’’
OR hospice* OR ‘‘supportive care’’) AND (palliative OR terminal OR ‘‘end of life’’ OR end-of-life OR
death OR dying OR ‘‘continu* care’’ OR ‘‘advance directive*’’
OR hospice* OR ‘‘supportive care’’) Approach In addition, a number of country-specific databases were used
when available, (see Table 1). The searches were updated to
February 2012. In addition, a number of country-specific databases were used
when available, (see Table 1). The searches were updated to
February 2012. A scoping exercise with the purpose of aggregating and
interpreting the evidence on culture and EoL care in the seven
targeted European countries. This type of review is suitable to map
evidence in a broad topic area which has not been reviewed
before. The review was exploratory and applied an iterative and
inductive approach. Therefore it did not specify concepts in
advance
of
the
synthesis,
but
let
the
delineation
of
the
phenomenon of culture in relation to EoL care emerge in the
analysis of the literature. We started with an open and broad
review question, which was refined by the search results and the
findings in the studies retrieved. Other searches. Hand searches were carried out in reference
lists of retrieved articles and cited reference searches were
conducted. Archives of key journals were searched, in order to
find relevant articles that had been missed in the initial database
search. Journals were selected for hand searches if they contained
a high frequency of relevant articles, identified in the electronic,
hand and cited references searches (see Table 2). Other searches. Hand searches were carried out in reference
lists of retrieved articles and cited reference searches were
conducted. Archives of key journals were searched, in order to
find relevant articles that had been missed in the initial database
search. Journals were selected for hand searches if they contained
a high frequency of relevant articles, identified in the electronic,
hand and cited references searches (see Table 2). Publications written by authors of the articles deemed relevant
were searched via authors’ web pages (if available) and the Web of
Knowledge ‘author search’ facility. Screening and Data Extraction All documents were considered for relevance based on titles and
abstracts. When the information was not sufficient to decide on
inclusion or exclusion, the full text was evaluated. Because of the
dearth of evidence in this area and the exploratory nature of the
scoping of this literature, the team first became familiar with the
literature from each country and then discussed inclusion and
exclusion criteria in a team meeting. This was then used as a guide
for deciding about their relevance to the review question. We
included reviews and original research studies that informed about Introduction The urgent calls for an evidence-base have already led to In order to improve care [5,6], and ensure that palliative care
can secure its share from national budgets and allocate these
resources in a just way [7] there is a need for relevant evidence. The urgent calls for an evidence-base have already led to April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 1 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care European countries are in different stages of developing
palliative care provisions and services take various organisational
forms within health systems [1]. This is a consequence of different
cultural traditions and attitudes towards the EoL and related care
[16]. The differences in services can lead to further diversification
in the understanding of EoL care across Europe, which presents
challenges
for
research
and
international
collaborations
to
improve EoL care on a wider scale. These initial pilot searches retrieved bodies of literature of
varying sizes from each country and this was compared and
discussed in a team meeting. For Belgium, Spain, Italy and
Portugal, so few articles were retrieved that it was necessary to
make additional, more general searches. The definitive searches
were conducted in the following electronic databases: Web of Knowledge all databases (Web of Science with
conference Proceedings (1899–2012), BIOSIS Previews (1969–
2012), Inspec (1969–2012), MEDLINE (1950–2012), Journal
Citation Reports (2000–2012)); OVID (AMED (1985–2012);
PsycINFO (1806 to 2012); and EMBASE (1980 to 2012));
Cancerlit
(1975–2012);
ASSIA
(1987–2012);
and,
CINAHL
(1982 to 2012). Web of Knowledge all databases (Web of Science with
conference Proceedings (1899–2012), BIOSIS Previews (1969–
2012), Inspec (1969–2012), MEDLINE (1950–2012), Journal
Citation Reports (2000–2012)); OVID (AMED (1985–2012);
PsycINFO (1806 to 2012); and EMBASE (1980 to 2012));
Cancerlit
(1975–2012);
ASSIA
(1987–2012);
and,
CINAHL
(1982 to 2012). This paper reports on a scoping exercise of cultural issues in
EoL care of seven European countries: Germany, Norway,
Belgium, the Netherlands, Spain, Italy and Portugal. These are
seven of the eight participating countries in the PRISMA project,
in the context of which this work was undertaken [17]. The
evidence of the eighth country, the UK, was published separately
[18,19], because it is so different from the other European
countries and therefore not comparable with the same criteria. The focus of this scoping exercise of the European countries was
two-fold. First, we aimed to explore and compare socio-cultural
issues that shape EoL care in each of the countries. Second, we
aimed to critically appraise the research evidence on cultural issues
in EoL care produced in the different countries to throw light on
its adequacy as a basis for the further development of EoL care. Electronic
search
for
Belgium,
Spain,
Italy
and
Portugal. Search Strategy Searches were also conducted in a number of Spanish and
Portuguese web pages dedicated to palliative and cancer care and
these were categorised as ‘hand searches’ as the web pages had no
search facility and the literature available via the web pages was
explored manually. For Spain, the full medical anthropology
bibliography [20], and medical anthropology conferences were
also hand-searched. A team of researchers undertook some pilot searches, separately
for each country, to get an idea of the scope of the literature that
informed about culture and EoL care for each country, and the
suitability of the search terms. The following search terms were
used for the pilot searches: Country name(s): Country name(s): (Germany OR German*) Grey literature –documents that are disseminated outside
standard publication channels such as scientific journals but which
have a definite influence on scientific output (for example policy
reports or conference proceedings)– was obtained from experts
identified from the expert network on culture and EoL care that
was created concurrently to the scoping as part of the PRISMA
project. (Norway OR Norwegian*) (Belgium OR Belg*) (Netherland* OR Dutch OR Holland) (Spain OR Spanish*) (Italy OR Italian*) (Portugal OR Portug*) PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Due to the small size of the body of literature
retrieved by the database search of Belgian, Spanish, Italian, and
Portuguese literature, more general searches unrestricted by the
terms relating to culture, were carried out using the search terms: Electronic
search
for
Belgium,
Spain,
Italy
and
Portugal. Due to the small size of the body of literature
retrieved by the database search of Belgian, Spanish, Italian, and
Portuguese literature, more general searches unrestricted by the
terms relating to culture, were carried out using the search terms: (Belgium OR Belg*) (Spain OR Spanish*)
(Italy OR Italian*) AND Associac¸a˜o Portuguesa de Cuidados Paliativos website; Histo´ria dos Cuidados Paliativos em Portugal website; ONCO.news (As
Enfermagem Oncolo´gica Portuguesa - AEOP). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034188.t001 Second, the country-specific syntheses were exchanged among
the members of the team and read. Each developed a framework
of themes that was capable of integrating all the themes used in the
syntheses of the other countries, retaining the capacity to still
compare findings across countries in a meaningful way. These
frameworks were then discussed in team meetings and a common
framework was agreed upon, consisting of five themes: setting,
caregivers, communication, medical EoL decisions, minority
ethnic groups, and knowledge, attitudes and values of death and
care. The narrative syntheses for each country were then rewritten
according
to
these
cross-cutting
themes. This
assisted
the
comparison of practices, and ideas related to developments in
EoL care across the countries and the identification of similarities
or differences in approaches. socio-cultural issues in EoL care. We excluded studies on clinical
tools, pain and symptom management, pharmaceuticals, donation
and transplants, neonatal EoL issues, legal issues and psychology. However if any of these studies contained relevant elements they
were read fully and included. The electronic searches were
restricted to the English language. Handsearches in the national
languages were conducted for Spain, Portugal, Italy, Germany,
Belgium and the Netherlands. To optimise comparability between
countries we restricted the review to papers that were produced
after the arrival of the ideas of the palliative care movement. socio-cultural issues in EoL care. We excluded studies on clinical
tools, pain and symptom management, pharmaceuticals, donation
and transplants, neonatal EoL issues, legal issues and psychology. However if any of these studies contained relevant elements they
were read fully and included. The electronic searches were
restricted to the English language. Handsearches in the national
languages were conducted for Spain, Portugal, Italy, Germany,
Belgium and the Netherlands. To optimise comparability between
countries we restricted the review to papers that were produced
after the arrival of the ideas of the palliative care movement. Data extraction was conducted for all studies, which inven-
torised
study
details,
participants,
methodology,
and
main
findings. A third step focused on the body of literature itself, as a source
of information on how the evidence approaches and thereby
constructs the issues it addresses. AND Then, by examining the number
and type of studies, insight was gained into the evidence itself, and
how cultural knowledge featured among other types of knowledge
generated in research on EoL care (for example relating to clinical
practice or service development). This showed the areas of
expertise in different countries and revealed gaps in knowledge. Synthesis The initial stage was mainly oriented towards examining the
extent, range and nature of research activity, although this already
implies interpretation and formed a part of the synthesis of the
findings. A mapping of reported practices and concepts was
carried out regarding cultural issues in EoL care for each country
through techniques of identification, listing, tabulating and
counting individual studies. The overviews and opinion pieces
were from this point not systematically analysed, although they
were read as background literature and informed the further stages
of synthesis. Themes across multiple studies were developed
inductively through constant comparison of findings. Each team
member developed a country-specific narrative synthesis. AND (cultur* OR intercultural OR cross-cultural OR transcultural
OR qualitative OR ethnography OR anthropology OR interview*
OR ‘‘focus group*’’) These were chosen with the aim of retrieving articles concerning
EoL care where cultural and social factors were sufficiently
relevant to be referred to in the title, abstract, topic or key words. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 2 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Table 1. Journals hand searched. Country
Journals, conference indices, or websites subjected to hand searches
Germany
Omega Volume 1 Number 1 (1970) to Volume 58 Number 1 (2008); Mortality Volume 1 Issue 1 (1996) to Volume 13 Issue 4 (2008); Medical
Anthropology Volume 21 (2002) to Volume 28 (2009). Norway
Omega Volume 1 Number 1 (1970) to Volume 58 Number 1 (2008); Mortality Volume 1 Issue 1 (1996) to Volume 13 Issue 4 (2008); Scandinavian
Journal of Caring Sciences Volume 15 Issue 1 (2001) to Volume 23 Issue 4 (2009); Medical Anthropology Volume 21 (2002) to Volume 28 (2009). Belgium
Revue Me´dicale de Bruxelles, Ethical Perspectives: Issue 2–3/2002; Tijdschrift voor Geneeskunde; and Acta Hospitalia. Netherlands
Non accessible (due to language limitations). Spain
Spanish medical anthropology bibliography (available in Perdiguero and Comelles (2000)); Spanish National Conferences of Anthropology; The
REDAM conferences; and The Medical Anthropology at Home Conferences; Spanish Society of Palliative Care website (SECPAL); Basque Society
of Palliative Care website (SOVPAL); Spanish Association Against Cancer website (AECC)
Italy
Not included. Portugal
Associac¸a˜o Portuguesa de Cuidados Paliativos website; Histo´ria dos Cuidados Paliativos em Portugal website; ONCO.news (Associac¸a˜o de
Enfermagem Oncolo´gica Portuguesa - AEOP). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034188.t001 Journals, conference indices, or websites subjected to hand searches olume 1 Number 1 (1970) to Volume 58 Number 1 (2008); Mortality Volume 1 Issue 1 (1996) to Volume 13 Issue 4 (2008); Medical
ogy Volume 21 (2002) to Volume 28 (2009). Spain
Spanish medical anthropology bibliography (available in Perdiguero and Comelles (2000)); Spanish National Conferences of Anthropology; The
REDAM conferences; and The Medical Anthropology at Home Conferences; Spanish Society of Palliative Care website (SECPAL); Basque Society
of Palliative Care website (SOVPAL); Spanish Association Against Cancer website (AECC) Portugal
Associac¸a˜o Portuguesa de Cuidados Paliativos website; Histo´ria dos Cuidados Paliativos em Portugal website; ONCO.news (Associac¸a˜o de
Enfermagem Oncolo´gica Portuguesa - AEOP). Nature of the Evidence Nature of the Evidence
A total of 868 papers were reviewed. considers its start with the establishment of hospices in the early
1990s [21], or as a field which already started to develop through
work in nursing homes back in the 1960s [22]. A total of 868 papers were reviewed. A total of 868 papers were reviewed. Literature Flow Literature Flow
See Figure 1 for the flow chart of included countries. Table 2. Additional databases by country. Country
Additional databases
Germany
Non accessible (due to language limitations). Norway
Non accessible (due to language limitations). Belgium
CSA Illumina
Netherlands
CSA Illumina
Spain
IME (medicine); ISOC (social sciences); CUIDEN (nursing) and ENFISPO (nursing); Pubmed and Current Contents. Italy
Non accessible
Portugal
IME (medicine); ISOC (social sciences); CUIDEN (nursing). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034188.t002 Table 2. Additional databases by country. Table 2. Additional databases by country. April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 3 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Figure 1. Flow chart of included countries. Figure 1. Flow chart of included countries. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034188.g001 Synthesis: the Netherlands The literature on the Netherlands provided information about a
variety of settings in which EoL care is provided and the
experience
and
role
of
health
professionals
involved
[23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30]. End of life care used to be part of the
country’s highly developed home care system, with general
practitioners playing an important role, which was further
encouraged by national healthcare policy [25,28]. Some studies Identified papers were well distributed between 1992 and 2012. Articles published before 1992 were in Dutch and beyond the
scope of this review. These were, however, well cited in the papers
appearing in international journals. This already points towards
the contested history of palliative care in the Netherlands: it is
either seen as an underdeveloped area of expertise, when one PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 4 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care into
different
settings
where
people
die
in
Belgium
[65,66,67,68,69],
the
determinants
of
place
of
death
[66,69,70,71,72,73,74,75], and how place of death compared
internationally [70,74,76]. One study focused on transitions
between settings [77]. described how the differences in EoL care settings affected the type
of care provided [27,29]. Despite the key role played by informal
carers in home care, only two studies focused on their experiences
[31,32]. The majority of studies focused on medical EoL decisions
(MELDs),
reflecting
the
country’s
unique
situation,
where
euthanasia was legalised in 2002 (together with Belgium in 2002
and Luxemburg in 2008). Euthanasia and physician assisted
suicide (PAS) were the most common topics of research in this
area. A recent comparative study of the Netherlands and Belgium
on the first five years of euthanasia legislation showed that there
are differences in how the legislation is applied in each country
[33]. Other MELDs such as non-treatment decisions [34] and
palliative sedation [35,36] were also explored. Considerable
attention was devoted to the definitions, differences between,
and incidences of, MELDS [37,38,39,40]. A culture of tolerance
towards euthanasia and PAS was described which had been
embedded in Dutch society for over 100 years [41,42]. One key aspect of the health system in Belgium was that GPs
tended to work alone and often had a long-standing and trustful
relationship with patients. There was an emphasis on individual-
ized care and the ability to choose one’s own doctors. Place of death influenced medical EoL decisions (MELDs) [78]. Synthesis: the Netherlands [60]
Only three studies addressed EoL care relating to ethnic
minority groups in the Netherlands. One study found that
euthanasia was not less common, while symptom alleviation
occurred less among this group [61]. Another study examined
Dutch professional home care and the barriers to the use of this
care for terminally ill Turks and Morrocans and their families
[62]. It was shown that the latter group have conflicting ideas
about ‘good care’ compared to their Dutch care providers and
they found ‘palliative care’ a contradiction in terms due to their
focus on cure. [63] Issues relating to communication revolved mainly around
advance directives (ADs) [41,50,51,52,53], disclosure and infor-
mation giving [26,54,55,56,57,58,59]. The issues relating to ADs
were determined by the euthanasia situation. Public knowledge
about ADs was found to be high. These are documents in which
one can state the wish for euthanasia in certain cicumstances. [60] One paper looked at the approach to EoL care by different
ethnic groups in Belgium and called attention to non-Western
perspectives [137]. Germany Only three studies addressed EoL care relating to ethnic
minority groups in the Netherlands. One study found that
euthanasia was not less common, while symptom alleviation
occurred less among this group [61]. Another study examined
Dutch professional home care and the barriers to the use of this
care for terminally ill Turks and Morrocans and their families
[62]. It was shown that the latter group have conflicting ideas
about ‘good care’ compared to their Dutch care providers and
they found ‘palliative care’ a contradiction in terms due to their
focus on cure. [63] The majority of articles were published within the last decade,
with the remaining studies having been published between 1989
and 1999. Home was identified as most people’s preferred place of death,
even though the majority of deaths actually occurred in hospitals
[138,139,140,141]. The growing importance of nursing homes as
a place of care and death, and the need to incorporate palliative
care into these institutions, was highlighted [142,143]. In cross-country comparisons German physicians were found to
be more likely to exclude patients, patients’ families and non-
medical staff from the decision making process [144,145]. ADs was
a well-covered theme. Studies explored awareness of ADs, use and
compliance [138,144,145,146,147,148,149,150,151,152] and de-
sired level of bindingness [150,153,154,155]. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Synthesis: the Netherlands MELD
h
h d
i i
h B l i
li Place of death influenced medical EoL decisions (MELDs) [78]. MELDs was the most researched topic in the Belgian literature,
mainly focusing on definition of concepts [79,80,81,82], incidence
of MELDs [69,80,83,84], decision making [85,86], including
communication [87], key actors [88,89,90], and the role of health
professionals [91,92,93,94,95,96,97,98,99,100,101]. These studies present evidence for or against the legal
developments in Belgium. The studies that assessed MELDs in
practice showed that the slippery slope effect had not materialized
[65]. Also, with the availability of palliative care, euthanasia
requests were less likely [102,103,104,105,106]. These requests
were however not preventable in all cases. A recent study reported
that 90% of physicians support euthanasia for terminal patients
with extreme uncontrollable symptoms [107]. A study comparing
practices of euthanasia and assisted suicide with the Netherlands,
showed that there were significantly fewer cases in Belgium (1917)
than in the Netherlands (10319), mostly in patients suffering from
diseases of the nervous system, and in hospital [33]. Other articles explored the importance of self-governance for
terminally ill people in a Dutch context [32]. Several aspects were
explored regarding ethanasia, its emotional impact on physicians
[43], patients’ reasons for requesting euthanasia [44], and the
experiences of relatives and friends of patients who received
euthanasia [45]. One study focused on the role of the euthanasia
consultant who evaluates the criteria for careful practice and
advises about palliative care [46]. An ethnography showed that a
request for euthanasia often served a symbolic purpose and
enabled open discussion about taboo subjects of death and
suffering [47]. Similar findings came from subsequent studies
[32,48]. Other topics related to MELDs included application of laws and
other regulations, institutional written ethics policies, and opinions
and
attitudes
[65,83,86,101,105,108,109,110,111,112,113,114,
115,116,117,118,119,120,121,122]. A recent study described the phenomenon of ‘‘self-directed
deaths,’’ individually controlled methods to hasten death, and
showed that frequencies were very close to physician assisted death
in the same year [49]. The
articles
on
communication
examined
disclosure
[123,124,125,126,127,128,129]
communication
with
different
actors [98,127,130], barriers to communication [124,125,131,
132] and ADs [96,115,116,133,134,135,136]. Issues relating to communication revolved mainly around
advance directives (ADs) [41,50,51,52,53], disclosure and infor-
mation giving [26,54,55,56,57,58,59]. The issues relating to ADs
were determined by the euthanasia situation. Public knowledge
about ADs was found to be high. These are documents in which
one can state the wish for euthanasia in certain cicumstances. Norway One of the sub-themes relating to communication was the
uncertainties
experienced
by
doctors
and
nurses
regarding
disclosure [177,178]. A general reluctance to talk about death
was found [172,179], and a 20 year study in one hospital showed
that open discussion of death with patients had not increased over
time [179]. This was ascribed to the Norwegian respect for privacy
[172], although it could also be attributed to a strong death taboo. Another
communication
issue
concerns
the
stakeholders
included in decision-making. Norwegian physicians have the
ultimate responsibility for treatment decisions, and whether or not
the views of other professionals were taken into account depended
upon the individual physician’s views and the culture of the
healthcare setting. Family members were often included in
decision-making, which led to greater agreement concerning
treatment options which was also the case for the understanding of
the patient’s wishes. One of the sub-themes relating to communication was the
uncertainties
experienced
by
doctors
and
nurses
regarding
disclosure [177,178]. A general reluctance to talk about death
was found [172,179], and a 20 year study in one hospital showed
that open discussion of death with patients had not increased over
time [179]. This was ascribed to the Norwegian respect for privacy
[172], although it could also be attributed to a strong death taboo. Another
communication
issue
concerns
the
stakeholders
included in decision-making. Norwegian physicians have the
ultimate responsibility for treatment decisions, and whether or not
the views of other professionals were taken into account depended
upon the individual physician’s views and the culture of the
healthcare setting. Family members were often included in
decision-making, which led to greater agreement concerning
treatment options which was also the case for the understanding of
the patient’s wishes. Disclosure of information regarding diagnosis, prognosis and
treatments was found to be the most frequently discussed in the
literature and this was also the topic of the identified review [220]. International comparisons described southern European countries
as partial and non-disclosure countries [221,222,223] and Spanish
awareness studies suggested that this trend persisted over time
[194,204,218,224,225,226,227]. On the other hand, studies with
healthy populations show that preferences are evolving towards
open disclosure [201,202,203,204,207,228]. Intermediate posi-
tions were also found; the majority of doctors stated that they
would inform the patient only in certain circumstances or if
requested by the patient [206,207,208,209,228,229,230,231,232]. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care than other Scandinavian and western countries in regard to
treatment limitation, euthanasia and PAS [177,180,186]. The low
level of ‘hastening death’ found in Norway was attributed to a
cultural respect for the law, which prevented even physicians who
held liberal ideas concerning euthanasia from carrying out
euthanasia in practice [180]. In Norway palliative sedation and
euthanasia were said to have only recently been differentiated, and
guidelines for practice provided. characteristics of the society [111]. This was ascribed to the use of
the term ‘euthanasia’ by the Nazi regime [111]. Its association
with
Nazi
medicine
has
been
avoided
by
using
different
terminology. The preferred term ‘Sterbehilfe’(literally ‘‘help to
die’’), was found to be the same as that of active and passive
euthanasia in the international literature [158,159] There was confusion among physicians and medical students
regarding the difference between active and passive ‘sterbehilfe’,
and the legality of assisted suicide [146,160]. In contrast to the
high levels of opposition encountered for PAS and euthanasia,
there was a high level of acceptance of palliative/terminal sedation
[157]. Frequent topics in the Norwegian literature were healthcare
spending and accounting. Elderly people were repeatedly said not
to receive a ‘just’ allocation of resources [172,184,189,192]. Also,
ethical dilemmas caused by the use of ‘high technology’ were
frequently highlighted [188,190,192,193]. The German literature on EoL care reflects a lack of social
consensus on all topics and by all stakeholders. Belgium The majority (114) of articles were published between 2000 and
2010. The first publications appeared when the euthanasia debate
had just started, resulting in the enactment of the euthanasia law in
2002. Unlike in the Netherlands, this debate was brief and
palliative care played an important role in it. Although palliative
care had only started five years before, it was very successful. The
two movements developed in parallel. Shared workers were
dedicated to both causes and this resulted in the model of ‘integral
palliative care’ [64]. This model is inclusive of euthanasia, and as
such it responds to the pluralist make up of Belgian society. Medical end of life decisions was also a major theme in the
literature. Active euthanasia is illegal in Germany and the
National Board of Physicians rejects any liberalisation concerning
active euthanasia [156]. PAS is not illegal in Germany. However,
physicians have the responsibility to attempt to apply all medical
measures to prevent death, making PAS unfeasible in practice
[157]. The German Medical Association rejects PAS as against its
ethos [157]. Against this background, research aimed at developing an
understanding of place of care and death. Studies provided insight Cross-country comparisons found that Germans had relatively
low acceptance of euthanasia given the secular and individualistic April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 5 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Norway Only six of the 123 studies for Spain were conducted before
1990 and since then research on EoL care has increased. The
main palliative care resource was home care teams, the second, in-
patient units [14]. There were no general data on place of death:
the identified studies presented a range of percentages of home
deaths: from 22% for elderly people who died in Catalonia in 1998
to 50% for terminal cancer patients in Asturias in 1995
[194,195,196,197,198,199,200]. Percentages of healthy people
who would like to die at home were generally higher than those
who actually die at home [200,201,202,203,204,205] nevertheless
a recent survey showed that half of the population has preferences
for specific care settings or hospitals for terminal patients [202]. There was greater consensus among healthcare professionals than
among the general public that the home is the ideal place of death
[206,207,208,209]. One study was published in the early 1980s, ten were published
in the 1990s and the vast majority (34) were published between
2000–2010. A topic frequently touched upon within the original
studies was the proportion of deaths in institutional settings in
Norway. Norway has the highest percentage of beds in nursing
home facilities per capita in Europe, more than twice that of most
European countries and the highest number of deaths in nursing
homes and hospitals [161,162]. Therefore the importance of
palliative care provision within the nursing home setting was
emphasised [163,164]. In contrast to other international studies,
EoL care in a Norwegian nursing home was perceived as
professional and good by patients’ families [165]. Several studies
also focused on different aspects of home care [162,166,
167,168,169,170,171]. Studies of carers examined their characteristics [172], concerns
[173], activities [174], effects of caring [162,168,171,175,176],
and setting where the care was provided [168,173]. More than 84% of the patients were cared for by family
members, mainly daughters and wives [195,198,210,211,212]. A
majority of the caregivers were found to be overloaded [212,213]
and did not have any economic help or enough information of the
resources available [213,214,215]. Two concepts with negative
connotations relating to the patient’s family were identified: the
‘conspiracy of silence’ [216,217,218], the partial or non-disclosure
which is frequently attributed to family members; and, ‘claudica-
cio´n familiar’ (family surrender), when patients die in hospital and
not at home (the ideal place of death according to health
professionals) [219]. Discussion Socio-Cultural Issues in EoL Care: What the Evidence Says
There is still little agreement about what constitutes EoL care in
Europe. Researchers, practitioners and policy makers have
different understandings of its scope, definitions, goals and
approaches [320,321] and there are limited resources for its
development. Identifying and analysing diversity in understand-
ings and practices in EoL care in the different countries is essential
for reaching consensus on EoL care, and for achieving workable
standards. Also as in Spain, most studies from Italy focused on disclosure of
information, with a review from 2004 on this topic [278]. Awareness studies published between 1994 and 2009 showed that
a trend of partial and non disclosure persisted [279,280,281,
282,283,284,285,286]. The choice of partial or non-disclosure
arises within families, independently of patients’ requests [287]. Other sources however suggest that physicians preferences are
moving towards full disclosure [277,288,289,290]. In this scoping exercise we found a diverse body of evidence on
socio-cultural issues in EoL care with differences in meanings and
priorities in each of the countries (see Table 3 and Table S1). ADs are not legally recognised. Recently the parliament
approved a non-binding law that the patient does not express
his/her ‘will’, but ‘wish’, and this was after there had been intense
debate, influenced by public opinion, concerning a number of
high-profile cases [291,292,293,294]. This reflects a situation where EoL care has developed in
different directions since the unique ideas of the hospice
movement found resonance in Europe. The initial concept of
palliative care has changed through its increasing contact with
mainstream medicine in the different countries [322] and with the
cultural
traditions
relating
to
health, illness,
death,
dying,
bereavement, and ideas about care, the family, and the duties of
medicine and society. Europe-wide surveys of the general public found that Italy was
among the countries with the lowest acceptance of euthanasia
[112], but the differences between Catholic believers and non-
believers were higher than in other European countries. Death was
less likely to be preceeded by a MELD than in other European
countries [295] whereas terminal sedation was more frequent. A
recent paper showed that there is still low and often incorrect
awareness of palliative care among the general public [296]. This scoping exercise revealed practices in EoL care that attest
to cultural differences in ideas of best practices in EoL care. Italy In Italy, there has been a steadily growing number of research
studies since 1979. EoL care is delivered mainly by home care
teams [264] and the number of hospices rose from four in 1996
[265] to 90 in 2005 [14] mainly due to new palliative care policies
since 1999 [266]. From the different factors related to place of
death within Italy [70,267,268], region was found to be the most
determining: in the south of Italy, the percentage of home deaths
was 94% for cancer patients [267]. A recent publication calls for attention to informal caregiving
for older people [318]. Another recent study focuses on palliative
care physicians’ views of ADs, and found them relevant to ethical
decision making [319]. As in Spain, more than 85% of cancer patients’ caregivers were
relatives [269,270,271,272], and caring had an important impact
in their quality of life [270,271,272,273,274]. Nevertheless they
were frequently characterised in a negative way as barriers to full
disclosure and limitation of non-useful treatment [275,276,277]. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Scoping Culture and End of Life Care euthanasia among the general public [239], and the acceptance
had risen since 1995 among the general public. [202,240,241] Many of the studies focused on pain management and showed
low opioid consumption [254] and a significant proportion of
patients not receiving appropriate treatment [297,298,299,300,
301,302]. However knowledge about pain and analgesics was
found to have improved [303,304,305]. In international comparisons, Spain was among the countries
with the lowest prevalence of Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) orders,
and among those where these were discussed less with the patient. There were low rates of treatment withdrawal [212,242,243,
244,245]. In Spain the rates of all three practices were higher than
in Portugal, Italy, Greece, and in the case of withdrawal of dialysis
Spain was above Germany. National studies suggested even higher
use of these MELDS [246,247]. Four articles focused on Italians as minorities in other countries
[306,307,308,309]. Only one original study gave specific infor-
mation on immigrants [310] and one overview presented the
islamic perspective in pediatric biomedical ethics including EoL
[311]. Terminal sedation was considered consistent with the tradition-
al Spanish perception that unconsciousness is the ‘best way out’
[248,249]. However, terminal sedation is still controversial in
Spain. The legal proceedings against the Legane´s Hospital
Emergency Unit have demonstrated that the boundary between
euthanasia and terminal sedation is not totally clear [250]. Part of
the controversy concerns its use to manage existential and family
distress, more common in Spain than in other countries [216]. Portugal More than half of the articles were published in the last five
years (11), with the remaining studies having been published
between 1987 and 2003. The development of services and
research started relatively late in Portugal where the first palliative
care unit only opened at the end of 1994 [312]. There were
country-wide statistical data on place of death: with almost one-
third of all deaths occurring at home [313]. Regarding feelings towards death and dying amongst both
health professionals and the general public in Spain, fears related
to pain were found to be the most important [203,204,251,
252,253]. However morphine consumption per capita was below
the European and global average [254]. Fears about death were
found to be a major barrier to good EoL care [255]. As in Spain and Italy, caregivers needs included information,
time to relax and economical support and care [314]. Following
again the southern Europe trend, disclosure was one of the main
themes explored in original studies. Two studies, both conducted
in Porto, described greater patient awareness (60–69%) and desire
for information than in Spain or Italy [315,316]. Four research studies examined EoL experiences of migrants
from Morocco [256,257], Latinamerica [258] and UK [259] in
Spain, and four overviews were found that covered EoL issues for
migrants [260,261,262,263]. Portugal, like Italy, is among the countries with the lowest
public acceptance of euthanasia [112]. A study from 2009
reported that up to 39% of oncologists favoured the legalisation
of euthanasia [317]. The use of terminal sedation was lower than
in other countries. Delirium was the most common grounds for
initiating sedation while pain was an uncommon reason [315]. Portugal’s opium consumption was found to be above the
European and global average [254]. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Norway The two main obstacles to giving bad news were found to be
acceptance of the wishes of the family, hence tolerating the
‘conspiracy of silence’ imposed by the relatives, and feeling
uncomfortable to give bad news [217]. Only one form of advance directive is available in Norway (the
‘Life Testament’), which has no legal status and is rarely used
[172,180]. Its incidence was studied with two studies on patients
[172,179] and two on health professionals [180,181]. Treatment limitation was the most frequently studied topic
amongst the original studies, including its incidence [179,180,
182,183], criteria for limiting life [172,181,184,185], and ethical
dilemmas surrounding decisions [180,181,182,183,185,186,187]. The role of nurses and physicians was examined and the effect of
EoL decisions [185,188,189,190]. In Spain, the legal and administrative development of ADs is
one of the most advanced in Europe [233]. Most doctors found the
policies relating to their implementation a positive development
[233,234]. However the public’s knowledge and use of ADs was
very limited [202,235,236,237,238]. Euthanasia and PAS are illegal in Norway and the practices are
condemned in the Norwegian Medical Association’s ethical
guidelines [186]. Norway’s Lutheran heritage, and a puritan
‘moral minority’, were said to influence the debate on euthanasia
[191]. Norwegian physicians have more conservative attitudes In an international study Spain was shown to occupy an
intermediate position in Europe regarding the acceptance of April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 6 Discussion Disclosure practices in Mediterranean countries contradict the
obligation to open information about diagnosis and are influenced 7 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Table 3. Numbers and percentage of studies identified per theme across studies. by the continuous presence of the family in EoL care [323]. This
can cause conflicts between the norms prevailing in the medical
process in which palliative care is incorporated into national health
systems Aspects of the hospice movement’s particular philosophy
Country
Type of article
Total
Setting
Caregivers
Communication
Medical EoL
Decisions
Minority
Ethnic
Groups*
Knowledge,
Attitudes and
Values
Germany
Reviews
3
N
0
0
0
2
0
2
%
0
0
0
67
0
67
Original studies
110
N
18
6
43
49
2
36
%
16
6
39
45
2
33
Overviews etc. 37
N
2
3
11
22
2
12
%
5
8
30
59
5
32
Norway
Reviews
1
N
0
0
0
1
0
1
%
0
0
0
100
0
100
Original studies
53
N
22
12
21
30
0
31
%
42
23
40
58
0
60
Overviews etc. 9
N
3
0
2
6
0
2
%
33
0
22
67
0
22
Belgium
Reviews
0
N
0
0
0
0
0
0
%
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Original studies
123
N
25
3
14
61
11
10
%
20
3
11
50
9
9
Overviews etc. 77
N
0
1
6
50
4
13
%
0
1
8
65
5
17
Netherlands
Reviews
1
N
0
0
0
1
0
0
%
0
0
0
100
0
0
Original studies
131
N
16
9
24
70
3
35
%
13
7
18
54
2
27
Overviews etc. 68
N
0
1
4
59
0
24
%
0
1
6
87
0
35
Spain
Reviews
2
N
0
0
1
0
0
1
%
0
0
50
0
0
50
Original studies
124
N
33
18
38
29
3
33
%
27
15
31
24
2
27
Overviews etc. 31
N
0
0
5
5
2
25
%
0
0
16
16
6
81
Italy
Reviews
1
N
0
0
1
0
0
0
%
0
0
100
0
0
0
Original studies
99
N
19
11
38
24
3
25
%
20
11
38
25
3
25
Overviews etc. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Scoping Culture and End of Life Care attend to culture and its uses in a broad sense so that it includes the
majority culture as this will reveal that particular well-established
practices are in fact culturally and historically situated. When these
practices are then compared with those of other countries (as we
did in this scoping exercise) it can show why certain practices
become normalised while others remain unrecognised or become
contested. Insights such as these lead to awareness of cultural
differences and can enhance international collaborations. values have come into contact with alternative conceptions of good
care, which were based on professional experience of care for the
dying developed over long periods of time. Here we think of the
Dutch situation where euthanasia has developed as acceptable as a
last resort and has long since been a topic that can be discussed
openly [324]. The research generated in these seven countries on
cultural issues at the EoL is directed towards the countries
autochthonous cultural traditions and practices. Although this scoping exercise approached the evidence by
country, this does not mean we interpret ‘culture’ exclusively in
terms of ‘national culture’ where cultural differences are aligned
with the territorial borders of the nation state. However, for the
scoping of this field we think this approach was justified. First, the
scoping exercise was exploratory; no previous work has attempted
to map cultural issues in EoL care across different European
countries. Second, because we understand culture as an abstract
notion, rather than a concrete set of values, beliefs, attitudes,
opinions or other ethnic features we did not determine a priori any
factors that could constitute culture. Third, regarding the topic of
EoL care, we could follow national boundaries as there are distinct
approaches between countries which are the result of different
institutional forms of health care and a variety of ways of
organising the professions that are in charge of care provision at
the EoL. The reviews confirm that there are clearly distinguishable
national cultures of EoL care. Contrast with the UK The findings from this review on culture and EoL care from the
seven European countries contrast with the UK research activity
in this area, where EoL care has developed considerable expertise
on ethnic minority groups. Recently a review of original studies
and a review of reviews on this topic was published (also in the
context of this project), which represents a body of research that
was produced in response to the recognition of inequities in access
to healthcare and the quality of services provided related to
patients’ ethnicity [18,19]. Thirteen reviews were identified in this
area of which four reviews were commissioned to directly
influence policy and this already shows the recent interest in these
issues in the UK [18]. The 45 original studies focused for a great
part on the need to develop ‘cultural competence’ in health care
[19]. Limitations The literature from Norway was limited to publications in
English. No electronic searches were carried out with other than
English terms in the main databases. However, publications
identified from Spain, Italy, Portugal, Belgium, the Netherlands
and Germany in their respective national languages from the
vernacular databases searched or those obtained by hand searches
were included in the review. The Nature and Quality of Research in EoL Care and the
Significance of Cultural Knowledge The insights from this scoping exercise contribute to the debate
about the quality and nature of research in palliative care. As a
consequence of the evidence-based medicine movement, biomed-
ical research has been favoured in palliative care. This is reflected
in what is considered high quality research where criteria of
strength are used according to the potential for eliminating bias
[325]. Recently, these classification levels of evidence have been
debated in areas of health research where these criteria are not
representative of quality [326]. People at the end of their lives need
care which is holistic and individual to address the patient and
family’s complex problems, and these can not be grasped by
methodological approaches that exclude contextual factors. The
challenges presented by people at the end of their lives to
enrolment and participation in trials in terms of retainment and
ethical considerations lead to the exclusion of the most vulnerable,
which is the group that is of most relevance to palliative care. Clinical practice guidelines based on the effectiveness results of
RCTs have the danger of increasing existing health inequities
[327]. Socio-cultural knowledge is important in EoL care and we
need research that generates understanding of the ways these
affect illness experiences and caring and that enables the building
of a discipline that is capable to respond to the needs of diverse
and changing communities. This scoping study situated the identified literature in time,
providing insight into a country’s research activity vis-a`-vis its
development of services. This shows (with the exception of the
Netherlands, which already had a research tradition in EoL care)
the first studies appearing not much later than the establishment of
services on the European continent, with a growing production
towards more recent times. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Discussion 30
N
1
1
21
7
2
3
%
3
3
70
23
7
10
Portugal
Reviews
1
N
0
0
1
0
0
0
%
0
0
100
0
0
0
Original studies
29
N
0
6
11
9
0
5
%
0
21
38
33
0
19
Overviews etc. 5
N
0
0
1
2
0
1
%
0
0
20
40
0
20
doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034188.t003 doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034188.t003 process in which palliative care is incorporated into national health
systems. Aspects of the hospice movement’s particular philosophy
can be experienced as foreign, for example the emphasis on
awareness as part of good death contradicts the traditional Spanish
ideas about dying well [248]. In other instances its strong moral by the continuous presence of the family in EoL care [323]. This
can cause conflicts between the norms prevailing in the medical
profession on the one hand and physicians’ and families actual
practices on the other [221,222,223]. Also, the focus on cultural
identity may be due to self-reflection as a consequence of the PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 8 Supporting Information N The lack of research on ethnic minorities’ views, experiences,
and practices is striking and deserves future study. Conclusions This scoping of the literature is a first comparative exploration
of the cultural differences that exist in the understanding of EoL
care in these countries. There was very little work in the evidence
we unearthed specifically looking at cultural issues. With the
exception of some pioneering work on EoL care for ethnic
minority groups in a few countries, no expertise had developed in
this area. European countries wrote about their ‘own’ cultural
traditions and practices. Table S1
Sub-themes of culture and EoL care across
countries. N Dominant cultural ideas equally need to be subjected to
cultural investigation, which will uncover ideological interests
and the way that some taken-for-granted practices are the
product of wider forces. (DOC) Recommendations knowledge is a legitimate and necessary part of what constitutes
best evidence for the improvement of EoL care in the future. Acknowledgments N Robust multi-country studies in this review confirmed the
existence of major cultural differences but sometimes did not
explain the reasons for these differences. It is therefore
advisable to explore these cultural issues more deeply through
in-depth qualitative or mixed-methods studies. PRISMA had the overall aim to co-ordinate high-quality international
research into end-of-life cancer care. This project aimed to provide
evidence and guidance on best practice to ensure that research can
measure and improve outcomes for patients and families. PRISMA
activities aimed to reflect the preferences and cultural diversities of
citizens, the clinical priorities of clinicians, and appropriately measure
multidimensional outcomes across settings where end–of-life care is
delivered. Principal Investigator: Richard Harding. Scientific Director:
Irene J Higginson. In recognition of the collaborative nature of
PRISMA, the authors thank the following PRISMA members: Gwenda
Albers, Barbara
Antunes,
Ana Barros
Pinto,
Claudia Bausewein,
Dorothee Bechinger-English, Hamid Benalia, Lucy Bradley, Lucas
Ceulemans, Barbara A Daveson, Luc Deliens, Noe¨l Derycke, Martine
de Vlieger, Let Dillen, Julia Downing, Michael Echteld, Natalie Evans,
Dagny Faksva˚g Haugen, Lindsay Flood, Nancy Gikaara, Barbara
Gomes, Sue Hall, Stein Kaasa, Jonathan Koffman, Pedro Lopes
Ferreira, Johan Menten, Natalia Monteiro Calanzani, Fliss Murtagh,
Bregje Onwuteaka-Philipsen, Roeline Pasman,
Francesca Pettenati,
Tony Powell, Miel Ribbe, Katrin Sigurdardottir, Steffen Simon, Bart
van den Eynden, Jenny van der Steen, Paul Vanden Berghe, Trudie
van Iersel. We would also like to thank Marie Hoogstraten who assisted
with the update of this scoping to 2012. N Future empirical evidence in this field is needed to serve as a
basis from which to develop a more robust understanding of
theoretical concepts related to culture (for example cultural
competence) and EoL care (for example suffering, the
experience of symptoms, and dignity). Author Contributions This scoping also critically appraised the research evidence on
cultural issues in EoL care produced in the different countries to
throw light on its adequacy as a basis for the further development
of EoL care. The work on culture presented here provides an
understanding of the evolution of the concept of palliative care
across several European countries, shows the different cultural
norms that influence care at the EoL and gives a view of the
existing diversity in what is considered good care. This type of Conceived and designed the experiments: MG NE AM EA FT SF IJH RH
RP. Performed the experiments: MG NE AM EA FT SF IJH RH RP
HRP. Analyzed the data: MG NE AM EA FT SF IJH RH RP. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MG NE AM EA FT SF
IJH RH RP. Wrote the paper: MG NE AM EA FT SF IJH RH RP. Country specific scoping: NE AM EA SF HRP. Supervision: MG. Identification of need for review: MG Comparative analysis: MG. 1.
The quality of death: Ranking end-of-life care across the world. A report from the
Economist Intelligence Unit Commissioned by Lien Foundation: Available: http://
viewswire.eiu.com/report_dl.asp?mode=fi&fi=1267294911.PDF&rf=0. Ac-
cessed on August 4, 2010.. Recommendations On the basis of the findings of this literature scoping on cultural
issues in EoL care in seven European countries we make the
following recommendations for future research: In contrast, very little attention has been paid to cultural issues
of ethnic minorities in EoL care in the European countries
included in this review. In the Netherlands we found that some
pioneering work had started in this area, and in the other countries
there were a few scattered exceptions. N The mapping and investigation of the literature has generated
insight into cultural differences in understanding, priorities and
expertise relating to EoL care across Europe. The analysis of
the number and the type of studies (see Figure 1 and Table 3)
serve as a systematic basis for further more focused analysis. This scoping of the literature informs about the gaps in the
evidence on culture and EoL care and this points to future needs
for research for the further development of the evidence-base. In
the UK, apart from the research on ethnic minority groups, a vast
literature exists on EoL care and this has not yet been reviewed
with attention to socio-cultural issues. This was also not possible in
this project due to time and resource constraints. Such a study
could shed light on the culture-specific pre-occupations with EoL
care in the UK. It could show the dominant concerns towards care
at the end of life and the configurations of positions towards these
concerns in a diversity of contexts and settings. It is important to N The gaps identified in the evidence point to areas that should
be the focus of exploratory studies, and the better-represented
themes (summarized in Table S1) can inform the research
questions of other systematic reviews, or particular topics can
be further interrogated or complemented with new studies. N Given the current expansion of EoL care into new areas, this
field of research should be given due attention beyond the
countries included in this review, and beyond Europe, on a
global level. April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 9 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care N Research on cultural issues in EoL care needs to start from a
well-informed understanding of the notion of culture to avoid
stereotyping, which was a consequence of some previous
research. References 1. The quality of death: Ranking end-of-life care across the world. A report from the
Economist Intelligence Unit Commissioned by Lien Foundation: Available: http://
viewswire.eiu.com/report_dl.asp?mode=fi&fi=1267294911.PDF&rf=0. Ac-
cessed on August 4, 2010.. 13. Saunders CM, Kastenbaum R (1997) Hospice care on the international scene. New York: Springer. 14. Centeno C, Clark D, Lynch T, Rocafort J, Praill D, et al. (2007) Facts and
indecators on palliative care development in 52 countries of the WHO
European region: results of an EAPC task force. Palliative Medicine 21:
463–471. g
2. Higginson IJ, Constantini M (2008) Dying with cancer, living well with
advanced cancer. European Journal of Cancer 44: 1414–1424. 15. Clark D, Ten Have H, Janssen R (2000) Common threads? Palliative care
service developments in seven European countries. Palliative Medicine 14. 3. Kleinman A (1980) Patients and healers in the context of culture. Berkeley, CA:
University of California Press. - p. p
p
16. Gysels M, Evans N, Men˜aca, Andrew E, Bausewein C, et al. (2011) Culture is a
priority for research in end of life care in Europe: a research agenda. In press. 16. Gysels M, Evans N, Men˜aca, Andrew E, Bausewein C, et al. (2011) Culture is a
i
it f
h i
d
f lif
i
E
h
d
I 4. Morris D (1999) Culture and Pain. Berkeley, CA: University of California
Press. 5. Lynn J, Teno JM, Phillips RS, Wu AW, Desbiens N, et al. (1997) Perceptions
by family members of the dying experience of older and seriously ill patients. Annals of Internal Medicine 126: 97–106. 17. Harding R, Higginson I (2010) PRISMA: A pan-European co-ordinating
action to advance the science in end-of-life cancer care. European Journal of
Cancer 46: 1493–1501. 6. Tolley DC, Payne R (2007) Hospice Partnerships with Academic Entities:
Philosophical and Historical Background and Assessment of Future Needs. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 1: 90–98. 18. Evans N, Menaca A, Andrew EVW, Koffman J, Harding R, et al. (2011)
Appraisal of literature reviews on end-of-life care for minority ethnic groups in
the UK and a critical comparison with policy recommendations from the UK
end-of-life strategy. BMC Health Services Research 11: 141. y
p
g
7. Jubb AM (2002) Palliative care research: trading ethics for an evidence base. Journal of Medical Ethics 28: 342–346. end-of-life strategy. BMC Health Services Research 11: 141. 7. Jubb AM (2002) Palliative care research: trading ethics for an evidence base. 12.
Clark D (1999) Cradled to the grave? Terminal care in the United Kingdom,
1948–1967. Mortality 4: 225–247. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Osse B, Vernooij-Dassen M, Schade´ E, Grol R (2005) The problems
experienced by patients with cancer and their needs for palliative care. Supportive Care in Cancer 13: 722–732. 31. Proot IM, Abu-Saad HH, Crebolder H, Goldsteen M, Luker KA, et al. (2003)
Vulnerability of family caregivers in terminal palliative care at home; balancing
between burden and capacity. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences 17:
113–121. 59. Puts MT, Versloot J, Muller MJ, van Dam FS (2004) [The opinion on care of
patients with cancer undergoing palliative treatment in day care]. Ned Tijdschr
Geneeskd 148: 277–280. 32. Proot IM, Abu-Saad HH, Goldsteen M, Spreeuwenberg C, ter Meulen RHJ,
et al. (2004) The needs of terminally ill patients at home: directing one’s life,
health and things related to beloved others. Palliative Medicine 18: 53–61. 60. van Wijmen MP, Rurup ML, Pasman HR, Kaspers PJ, Onwuteaka-
Philipsen BD (2010) Advance directives in the Netherlands: an empirical
contribution to the exploration of a cross-cultural perspective on advance
directives. Bioethics 24 (3): 118–126. 33. Rurup ML, Smets T, Cohen J, Bilsen J, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, et al. (2012)
The first five years of euthanasia legislation in Belgium and the Netherlands:
description and comparison of cases. Palliative medicine 26: 43–49. 61. Buiting H, Rietjens J, Onwuteaka-Philipsen B, van der Maas P, van Delden J,
et al. (2008) A comparison of physicians’ end-of-life decision making for non-
western migrants and Dutch natives in the Netherlands. The European Journal
of Public Health 18: 681–687. 34. Huijer M, van Leeuwen E (2000) Personal values and cancer treatment refusal. Journal of Medical Ethics 26: 358–362. 62. 62. de Graaff FM, Francke AL (2003) Home care for terminally ill Turks and
Moroccans and their families in the Netherlands: carers’ experiences and
factors influencing ease of access and use of services. International Journal of
Nursing Studies 40: 797–805. 35. Rietjens JAC, van Delden JJM, van der Heide A, Vrakking AM, Onwuteaka-
Philipsen BD, et al. (2006) Terminal sedation and euthanasia - A comparison of
clinical practices. Archives of Internal Medicine 166: 749–753. 36. Seymour JE, Janssens R, Broeckaert B (2007) Relieving suffering at the end of
life: Practitioners’ perspectives on palliative sedation from three European
countries. Social Science & Medicine 64: 1679–1691. 63. de Graaff FM, Francke AL, van den Muijsenbergh ME, van der Geest S (2010)
‘Palliative care’: a contradiction in terms? Scoping Culture and End of Life Care 24. Borgsteede SD, Deliens L, Beentjes B, Schellevis F, Stallman WAB, et al. (2007a) Symptoms in patients receiving palliative care: a study on patient-
physician encounters in general practice. Palliative Medicine 21: 417–423. 52. Rurup ML, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, van der Heide A, van der Wal G, van
der Maas PJ (2005) Physicians’ experiences with demented patients with
advance euthanasia directives in the Netherlands. Journal of the American
Geriatrics Society 53: 1138–1144. 25. Borgsteede SD, Graafland-Riedstra C, Deliens L, Francke AL, van Eijk JT, et
al. (2006) Good end-of-life care according to patients and their GPs. British
Journal of General Practice 56: 20–26. y
53. Van Delden J (2004) The unfeasibility of requests for euthanasia in advance
directives. the Journal of Medical Ethics. pp 447–451. 26. de Vogel-Voogt E, van der Heide A, van Leeuwen AF, Visser AP, van der
Rijt CCD, et al. (2007) Patient evaluation of end-of-life care. Palliative
Medicine 21: 243–248. 54. Abma TA, Widdershoven GAA (2005) Sharing stories - Narrative and dialogue
in responsive nursing evaluation. Evaluation & the Health Professions 28:
90–109. 27. Georges JJ, Grypdonck M, Dierckx de Casterle B (2002) Being a palliative care
nurse in an academic hospital: a qualitative study about nurses’ perceptions of
palliative care nursing. Journal of Clinical Nursing 11: 785–793. 55. Francke AL, Willems DJ (2000) Palliatieve zorg vandaag en morgen, feiten,
opvattingen en scenario’s. Elsevier, Maarssen. 56. Goldsteen M, Houtepen R, Proot IM, Abu-Saad HH, Spreeuwenberg C, et al. (2006) What is a good death? Terminally ill patients dealing with normative
expectations around death and dying. Patient Education and Counseling 64:
378–386. 28. Groot MM, Vernooij-Dassen M, Crul BJP, Grol R (2005) General
practitioners (GPs) and palliative care: perceived tasks and barriers in daily
practice. Palliative Medicine 19: 111–118. p
29. Hermsen M, ten Have H (2003) Moral problems in palliative care practice: A
qualitative study. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 6: 263–272. 57. Osse B, Vernooij-Dassen M, Schade E, de Vree B, van den Muijsenbergh M,
et al. (2002) Problems to discuss with cancer patients in palliative care: a
comprehensive approach. Patient Education and Counseling 47: 195. 30. van Staa AL, Visser A, van der Zouwe N (2000) Caring for caregivers:
experiences and evaluation of interventions for a palliative care team. Patient
Education and Counseling 41: 93–105. 58. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care A qualitative study of cancer patients
with a Turkish or Moroccan background, their relatives and care providers. BMC Palliat Care 9: 19. 37. Gordijn B, Janssens R (2004) Euthanasia and palliative care in the Nether-
lands: an analysis of the latest developments. Health Care Analysis 12:
195–207. 64. 64. Bernheim JL, Deschepper R, Distelmans W, Mullie A, Bilsen J, et al. (2008)
Development of Palliative Care and Legalisation of Euthanasia: Antagonism or
Synergy? BMJ 336: 864–867. 38. Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, van der Heide A, Koper D, Keij-Deerenberg I,
Rietjens JAC, et al. (2003) Euthanasia and other end-of-life decisions in the
Netherlands in 1990, 1995, and 2001. Lancet 362: 395–399. 65. Bilsen J, Van der Stichele R, Broeckaert B, Mortier F, Deliens L (2007)
Changes in medical end-of-life practices during the legalization process of
euthanasia in Belgium. Social Science and Medicine 65: 803–808. 39. Rietjens JAC, van der Heide A, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, van der Maas PJ,
van der Wal G (2005) A comparison of attitudes towards end-of-life decisions:
Survey among the Dutch general public and physicians. Social Science &
Medicine 61: 1723–1732. 66. Cohen J, Bilsen J, Hooft P, Deboosere P, van der Wal G, et al. (2006) Dying at
home or in an institution: Using death certificates to explore the factors
associated with place of death. Health Policy 78: 319–329. 40. Sullivan M, Ormel J, Kempen G, Tymstra T (1998) Beliefs concerning death,
dying, and hastening death among older, functionally impaired Dutch adults:
A one-year longitudinal study. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 46:
1251–1257. 67. Cohen J, Houttekier D, Chambaere K, Bilsen J, Deliens L (2011) The use of
palliative care services associated with better dying circumstances. Results from
an epidemiological population-based study in the brussels metropolitan region. Journal of pain and symptom management 42: 839–851. 41. De Haan J (2002) The new Dutch law on euthanasia. Medical Law Review 10:
57–75. 68. Desmedt MS, de la Kethulle YL, Deveugele MI, Keirse EA, Paulus DJ, et al. (2011) Palliative inpatients in general hospitals: a one day observational study
in Belgium. BMC palliative care 10: 2. 42. Fenigsen R (1990) Euthanasia in the Netherlands. Issues in Law & Medicine 6:
229–245. 43. Van Marwijk H, Haverkate I, Van Royen P, The AM (2007) Impact of
euthanasia on primary care physicians in the Netherlands. Palliative Medicine
21: 609–614. 69. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Van Rensbergen G, Nawrot TS, Van Hecke E, Nemery B (2006) Where do the
elderly die? The impact of nursing home utilisation on the place of death. Observations from a mortality cohort study in Flanders. Bmc Public Health 6. 44. Van der Wal G, Van Eijk J, Leenen H, Spreeuwenberg C (1992) Euthanasia
and assisted suicide. II. Do Dutch family doctors act prudently? Family
Practice 9: 135–140. 70. Cohen J, Houttekier D, Onwuteaka-Philipsen B, Miccinesi G, Addington-
Hall J, et al. (2010) Which patients with cancer die at home? A study of six
European countries using death certificate data. J Clin Oncol 28: 2267–2273. 45. Swarte N, van der Lee M, van der Bom J, van den Bout J, Heintz A (2003)
Effects of euthanasia on the bereaved family and friends: a cross sectional
study. British Medical Journal 327: 189. 71. Van den Block L, Bilsen J, Deschepper R, Van der Kelen G, Bernheim JL, et
al. (2006) End-of-life decisions among cancer patients compared with
noncancer patients in Flanders, Belgium. Journal of Clinical Oncology 24:
2842–2848. 46. Buiting HM, Willems DL, Pasman HR, Rurup ML, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD
(2011) Palliative treatment alternatives and euthanasia consultations: a
qualitative interview study. Journal of pain and symptom management 42:
32–43. 72. Van den Block L, Deschepper R, Drieskens K, Bauwens S, Bilsen J, et al. (2007) Hospitalisations at the end of life: using a sentinel surveillance network
to study hospital use and associated patient, disease and healthcare factors. Bmc Health Services Research 7. 47. Norwood F (2007) Nothing More To Do: Euthanasia, General Practice, and
End-of-Life Discourse in the Netherlands. Medical Anthropology 26: 139–174. 73. Van den Eynden B, Hermann I, Schrijvers D, Van Royen P, Maes R, et al. (2000) Factors determining the place of palliative care and death of cancer
patients. Supportive Care in Cancer 8: 59–64. 48. Voorhees J, Drickamer M, Rietjens J, van der Heide A (2009) Discussing
Physician-Assisted Dying: A Qualitative Study of Doctors’ Experiences in the
US & the Netherlands. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 57:
S76–S77. 74. Houttekier D, Cohen J, Bilsen J, Addington-Hall J, Onwuteaka-Philipsen B, et
al. (2010) Place of death in metropolitan regions: Metropolitan versus non-
metropolitan variation in place of death in Belgium, The Netherlands and
England. Health & Place 16: 132–139. 49. Chabot BE, Goedhart A (2009) A survey of self-directed dying attended by
proxies in the Dutch population. References Journal of Medical Ethics 28: 342–346. 19. Evans N, Menaca A, Andrew EVW, Koffman J, Harding R, et al. (2011)
Systematic review of the primary research on minority ethnic groups and end-
of-life care from the UK. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 34:
261–286. Journal of Medical Ethics 28: 342–346 J
8. Kaasa S, Hjermsted MJ, Loge JH (2006) Methodological and structural
challenges in palliative care research: how have we fared in the last decades? Palliative Medicine 20: 727–734. 20. Perdiguero E, Comelles (2000) Medicina y cultura. Estudios entre la
antropologı´a y la medicina. Barcelona. 9. Richards MA, Corner J, Clark D (1998) Developing a research culture for
palliative care. Palliative Medicine 12: 399–403. 9. Richards MA, Corner J, Clark D (1998) Develo 21. Zylicz Z (1993) Hospice in Holland: the story behind the blanc spot. American
Journal of Hospice and Palliative Care 4: 30–34. 10. Riley J, Ross JR (2005) Research into care at the end of life. Lancet 365:
735–737. 22. Janssens R (1999) Report of concepts of palliative care in the Netherlands. Nijmegen: Pallium Project. 11. Clark D (1998) Originating a movement: Cicely Saunders and the
development of St Christopher’s Hospice 1957–1967. Mortality 3: 43–63. 23. Abma T (2001) Evaluating palliative care: Facilitating reflexive dialgoues about
an ambiguous concept. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 4: 261–276. 12. Clark D (1999) Cradled to the grave? Terminal care in the United Kingdom,
1948–1967. Mortality 4: 225–247. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 10 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care (2009) Medical end-of-life practices under the euthanasia law in Belgium. New
England Journal of Medicine 361: 1119. 111. Cohen J, Marcoux I, Bilsen J, Deboosere P, Van der Wal G, et al. (2006)
Trends in Acceptance of Euthanasia among the General Public in 12
European Countries (1981–1999). European Journal of Public Health 16:
663–669. 84. Chambaere K, Bilsen J, Cohen J, Raman E, Deliens L (2010) Differences in
performance of euthanasia and continuous deep sedation by French-and
dutch-speaking physicians in brussels, belgium. Journal of Pain and Symptom
Management 39: e5. 85. Claessens P, Ellen Genbrugge R, Rita Vannuffelen R, Bert Broeckaert P, Paul
Schotsmans P, et al. (2007) Palliative Sedation and Nursing: The Place of
Palliative Sedation Within Palliative Nursing Care. Journal of Hospice and
Palliative Nursing 9. 112. Cohen J, Marcoux I, Bilsen J, Deboosere P, Van der Wal G, et al. (2006)
European public acceptance of euthanasia: socio-demographic and cultural
factors associated with the acceptnce of euthanasia in 33 European countries. Soc Sci Med 63: 743–756. 113. Dierickx K, Schotsmans P, Grubb A, Walsh P, Lambe N (1998) Belgian
doctors’ attitudes on the management of patients in persistent vegetative state
(PVS): Ethical and regulatory aspects. Acta Neurochirurgica 140: 481–489. 86. Seymour J, Payne S, Chapman A, Holloway M (2007) Hospice or home? Expectations of end-of-life care among white and Chinese older people in the
UK. Sociology of Health & Illness 29: 872–890. gy
87. Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, Fisher S, Cartwright C, Deliens L, Miccinesi G, et
al. (2006) End-of-life decision making in Europe and Australia: A physician
survey. Archives of Internal Medicine 166: 921–929. 114. Gastmans C, Lemiengre J, de Casterle BD (2006) Development and
communication of written ethics policies on euthanasia in Catholic hospitals
and nursing homes in Belgium (Flanders). Patient Education and Counseling
63: 188–195. 88. Van Wesemael Y, Cohen J, Bilsen J, Onwuteaka-Philipsen B, Distelmans W, et
al. (2010) Consulting a Trained Physician When Considering a Request for
Euthanasia: An Evaluation of the Process in Flanders and The Netherlands. Evaluation & the Health Professions. 115. Gastmans C, Lemiengre J, van der Wal G, Schotsmans P, de Casterle BD
(2006) Prevalence and content of written ethics policies on euthanasia in
Catholic healthcare institutions in Belgium (Flanders). Health Policy 76:
169–178. 89. Van Wesemael Y, Cohen J, Onwuteaka Philipsen B, Bilsen J, Distelmans W, et
al. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care (2009) Role and Involvement of Life End Information Forum Physicians in
Euthanasia and Other End of Life Care Decisions in Flanders, Belgium. Health Services Research 44: 2180–2192. 116. Lemiengre J, Dierckx de Casterle B, Denier Y, Schotsmans P, Gastmans C
(2008) How do hospitals deal with euthanasia requests in Flanders (Belgium)? A
content analysis of policy documents. Patient Education and Counseling 71:
293–301. 90. Van Wesemael Yanna C, Bregje O, Johan B, Luc D (2009) Establishing
specialized health services for professional consultation in euthanasia:
experiences in the Netherlands and Belgium. Bmc Health Services Research 9. 117. Lemiengre J, Dierckx de Casterle B, Denier Y, Schotsmans P, Gastmans C
(2009) Content analysis of euthanasia policies of nursing homes in Flanders. Med Health Care Philos Epub ahead of print. p
g
91. Bilsen J, Van der Stichele R, Mortier F, Deliens L (2004) Involvement of nurses
in physician-assisted dying. Journal of Advanced Nursing 47: 583–591. 118. Miccinesi G, Fischer S, Paci E, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, Cartwright C, et al. (2005) Physicians’ attitudes towards end-of-life decisions: a comparison
between seven countries. Social Science & Medicine 60: 1961–1974. 92. De Bal N, de Casterle BD, De Beer T, Gastmans C (2006) Involvement of
nurses in caring for patients requesting euthanasia in Flanders (Belgium): A
qualitative study. International Journal of Nursing Studies 43: 589–599. 119. Mortier F, Bilsen J, Stichele R, Bernheim J, Deliens L (2003) Attitudes,
sociodemographic characteristics, and actual end-of-life decisions of physicians
in Flanders, Belgium. Medical Decision Making 23: 502–510. 93. Deliens L, Mortier F (2001) Empirical research on end-of-life decisions in
medical practice in Belgium (Flanders). Clinical and Epidemiological Aspects of
End-of-Life Decision-Making 102: 121–133. 120. Servais O, Legros E, Hiernaux J-P (2001) Changing Attitudes toward
Euthanasia. Between the Disposition of Self and Respect for Others. Recherches Sociologiques 32: 65–78. g
94. Denier Y, de Casterle BD, De Bal N, Gastmans C (2009) Involvement of
Nurses in the Euthanasia Care Process in Flanders (Belgium): An exploration of
two perspectives. Journal of Palliative Care 25: 264–274. 121. Van den Block L, Deschepper R, Bossuyt N, Drieskens K, Bauwens S, et al. (2008) Care for patients in the last months of life - The Belgian Sentinel
Network Monitoring End-of-Life Care study. Archives of Internal Medicine
168: 1747–1754. 95. Denier Y, Dierckx de Casterle B, De Bal N, Gastmans C (2009) ‘‘It’s intense,
you know. ’’ Nurses’ experiences in caring for patients requesting euthanasia. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Med Health Care Philos. 96. Dierckx de Casterle B, Verpoort C, de Bal N, Gastmans C (2006) Nurses’ views
on their involvement in euthanasia: a qualitative study in Flanders (Belgium). Journal of Medical Ethics 32: 187–192. 122. Vincent JL (1990) European attitudes towards ethical problems in intensive
care medicine: Results of an ethical questionnaire. Intensive Care Medicine 16:
256–264. J
97. Gastmans C, Lemiengre J, de Casterle BD (2006) Role of nurses in institutional
ethics policies on euthanasia. Journal of Advanced Nursing 54: 53–61. 123. Cartwright C, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, Williams G, Faisst K, Mortier F, et
al. (2007) Physician discussions with terminally ill patients: A cross-national
comparison. Palliative Medicine 21: 295–303. 98. Inghelbrecht E, Bilsen J, Mortier F, Deliens L (2008) Factors related to the
involvement of nurses in medical end-of-life decisions in Belgium: A death
certificate study. International Journal of Nursing Studies 45: 1022–1031. 124. Deschepper R, Bernheim JL, Van der Stichele R, Van den Block L, Michiels E,
et al. (2008) Truth-telling at the end of life: A pilot study on the perspective of
patients and professional caregivers. Patient Education and Counseling 71:
52–56. 99. Inghelbrecht E, Bilsen J, Mortier F, Deliens L (2009) Nurses’ attitudes towards
end-of-life decisions in medical practice: a nationwide study in Flanders,
Belgium. Palliative Medicine 23: 649. 125. Houtepen R, Hendrikx D (2003) Nurses and the virtues of dealing with
existential questions in terminal palliative care. Nursing Ethics 10: 377–387. 100. Meeussen K, Van den Block L, Bossuyt N, Echteld M, Bilsen J, et al. (2011)
Dealing with requests for euthanasia: interview study among general
practitioners in Belgium. Journal of pain and symptom management 41:
1060–1072. 126. Klastersky J (2004) Humaniser l’annonce d’un cancer (editorial). Rev Med
Brux 25: 69–70. 127. Levorato A, Stiefel F, Mazzocato C, Bruera E (2001) Communication with
terminal cancer patients in palliative care: are there differences between nurses
and physicians? Supportive Care in Cancer 9: 420–427. 101. Verpoort C, Gastmans C, de Casterle BD (2004) Palliative care nurses’ views
on euthanasia. Journal of Advanced Nursing 47: 592–600. p y
pp
128. Nys H, Schotsmans P (2000) Professional autonomy in Belgium. [see
comment]. Theoretical Medicine & Bioethics 21: 425–439. 102. Broeckaert B, Nu´n˜ez-Olarte JM (2002) Sedation in palliative care. Facts and
concepts. In H ten Have, & D Clark (Eds), The ethics of palliative care
European Perspectives (166–180) Buckingham: Open University Press. 129. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care 77. Van den Block L, Deschepper R, Bilsen J, Van Casteren V, Deliens L (2007)
Transitions between care settings at the end of life in Belgium. Jama-Journal of
the American Medical Association 298: 1638–1639. 104. Gastmans C, Van Neste F, Schotsmans P (2004) Facing requests for
euthanasia: a clinical practice guideline. Journal of Medical Ethics 30:
212–217. 105. Lemiengre J, Dierckx de Casterle B, Verbeke G, Guisson C, Schotsmans P, et
al. (2007) Ethics policies on euthanasia in hospitals - A survey in Flanders
(Belgium). Health Policy 84: 170–180. 78. Cohen J, Bilsen J, Fischer S, Lofmark R, Norup M, et al. (2007) End-of-life
decision-making in Belgium, Denmark, Sweden and Switzerland: Does place of
death make a difference? Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 61:
1062–1068. g
y
106. Van Parys T (2003) From Belgium. Palliative Medicine 17: 111–112. 79. Broeckaert B, Claessens P (2003) Physician-assisted death: From euthanasia to
the withholding of life-sustaining treatment. [Dutch]. Acta Hospitalia 43: 9–
20+93. 107. Smets T, Cohen J, Bilsen J, Van Wesemael Y, Rurup ML, et al. (2011)
Attitudes and experiences of Belgian physicians regarding euthanasia practice
and the euthanasia law. Journal of pain and symptom management 41:
580–593. 80. Deliens L, Mortier F, Bilsen J, Cosyns M, Vander Stichele R, et al. (2000) End-
of-life decisions in medical practice in Flanders, Belgium: A nationwide survey. Lancet 356: 1806–1811. 108. Abbadie B, Roland M, Cosyns M, Mainil T, Deveugele M, et al. (2006)
Processus de´cisionnels et soins me´dicaux en fin de vie. Rev Med Brux 27:
S287–291. 81. Herremans J (2008) Euthanasie: la loi, quelques notions essentielles, la question
du suicide assiste´.(Euthanasia: the law, a few notions and the question of
assisted suicide.). Rev Med Brux 29. 109. Bilsen J, Bauwens M, Bernheim J, Vander Stichele R, Deliens L (2005)
Physician-assisted death: attitudes and practices of community pharmacists in
East Flanders, Belgium. Palliative Medicine 19: 151–157. 82. Jans J (2005) The Belgian ‘‘Act on Euthanasia’’: Clarifying context, legislation,
and practice from an ethical point of view. Journal of the Society of Christian
Ethics 25: 163–177. 110. Cohen J, Chambaere K, Bilsen J, Houttekier D, Mortier F, et al. (2010)
Influence of the metropolitan environment on end-of-life decisions: A
population-based study of end-of-life decision-making in the Brussels
metropolitan region and non-metropolitan Flanders. Health & Place 16:
784–793. 83. Bilsen J, Cohen J, Chambaere K, Pousset G, Onwuteaka-Philipsen B, et al. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Social Science and Medicine 68: 1745–1751. 75. Houttekier D, Cohen J, Surkyn J, Deliens L (2011) Study of recent and future
trends in place of death in Belgium using death certificate data: a shift from
hospitals to care homes. BMC public health 11: 228. 50. Klinkenberg M, Willems DL, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, Deeg DJH, van der
Wal G (2004) Preferences in end-of-life care of older persons: after-death
interviews with proxy respondents. Social Science & Medicine 59: 2467–2477. 76. Houttekier D, Cohen J, Bilsen J, Addington-Hall J, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD,
et al. (2010) Place of death of older persons with dementia. A study in five
European countries. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 58: 751–756. 51. Rurup M, Onwuteaka-Philipsen B, van der Heide A, van der Wal G, Deeg D
(2006) Frequency and determinants of advance directives concerning end-of-
life care in The Netherlands. Social Science & Medicine 62: 1552–1563. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 11 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Journal of Pain and Symptom
Management 24: 53–63. 143. Heller A, Dinges S, Heimerl K, Reitinger E, Wegleitner K (2005) Palliative
culture in the stationary care for the elderly. Zeitschrift fur Gerontologie und
Geriatrie 36: 360–365. 171. Sorbye LW (1999) Cancer patients who prefer to die at home -
Characterizations of municipalities with several or few occurrences of home
deaths. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences 13: 102–108. 144. Justinger C, Richter S, Moussavian MR, Serrano Contreras T, Schilling MK
(2009) [Advance health care directives as seen by surgical patients.]. Chirurg
80: 455–461. 172. Schaffer MA (2007) Ethical problems in end-of-life decisions for elderly
Norwegians. Nursing Ethics 14: 242–257. 145. van Oorschot B, Hausmann C, Ko¨hler N, Leppert K, Schweitzer S, et al. (2004) Patientenverfu¨gungen aus Patientensicht. Ethik in Der Medizin 16:
112–122. 173. Ringdal G, Ringdal K, Jordhøy M, Ahlner-Elmqvist M, Jannert M, et al. (2004) Health-related quality of life (HRQOL) in family members of cancer
victims: results from a longitudinal intervention study in Norway and Sweden. Palliative Medicine 18: 108. 146. Borasio G, Weltermann B, Voltz R, Reichmann H, Zierz S (2004) Attitudes
towards patient care at the end of life. A survey of directors of neurological
departments. Der Nervenarzt 75: 1187. 174. Romoren TI (2003) The carer careers of son and daughter primary carers of
their very old parents in Norway. Ageing and Society 23: 471–485. p
147. Burchardi N, Rauprich O, Hecht M, Beck M, Vollmann J (2005) Discussing
living wills. A qualitative study of a German sample of neurologists and ALS
patients. J Neurol Sci 237: 67–74. 175. Norum J, Wist E (1993) When cancer patients die at home: The care provide
experience. Tidsskrift for den Norske Laegeforening 113: 1107–1109. experience. Tidsskrift for den Norske Laegeforening 113: 1107– 148. Kuhnlein P, Kubler A, Raubold S, Worrell M, Kurt A, et al. (2008) Palliative
care and circumstances of dying in German ALS patients using non-invasive
ventilation. Amyotroph Lateral Scler 9: 91–98. 176. Ringdal G, Jordhøy M, Ringdal K, Kaasa S (2001) Factors affecting grief
reactions in close family members to individuals who have died of cancer. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 22: 1016–1026. 149. Sahm S, Will R, Hommel G (2005) Attitudes towards and barriers to writing
advance directives amongst cancer patients, healthy controls, and medical staff. Journal of Medical Ethics 31: 437–440. 177. Hurst SA, Perrier A, Pegoraro R, Reiter-Theil S, Forde R, et al. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care (2007) Ethical
difficulties in clinical practice: experiences of European doctors. Journal of
Medical Ethics 33: 51–57. J
150. Sahm S, Will R, Hommel G (2005) Would they follow what has been laid
down? Cancer patients’ and healthy controls’ views on adherence to advance
directives compared to medical staff. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 8:
297–305. 178. Lorensen M, Davis A, Konishi E, Bunch E (2003) Ethical issues after the
disclosure of a terminal illness: Danish and Norwegian hospice nurses’
reflections. Nursing Ethics 10: 175. 179. Sorbye LW (2000) A longitudinal study on dying in a Norwegian hospital. Int J Palliat Nurs 6: 71–79. 151. Sehgal A, Weisheit C, Miura Y, Butzlaff M, Kielstein R, et al. (1996) Advance
directives and withdrawal of dialysis in the United States, Germany, and Japan. JAMA 276: 1652–1656. 180. Førde R, Aasland OG, Steen PA (2002) Medical end-of-life decisions in
Norway. Resuscitation 55: 235–240. 152. Voltz R, Akabayashi A, Reese C, Ohi G, Sass HM (1998) End-of-life decisions
and advance directives in palliative care: A cross-cultural survey of patients and
health-care professionals. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 16:
153–162. 181. Tallgren M, Klepstad P, Petersson J, Skram U, Hynninen M (2005) Ethical
issues in intensive care a survey among Scandinavian intensivists. Acta
Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica 49: 1092–1100. 182. Hynninen M, Klepstad P, Petersson J, Skram U, Tallgren M (2008) Process of
foregoing life-sustaining treatment: a survey among Scandinavian intensivists. Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica 52: 1081–1085. 153. Jox R, Krebs M, Bickhardt J, Hessdorfer K, Roller S, et al. (2008) How strictly
should advance decisions be followed? The patients’ opinion. Palliative
Medicine 22: 675. 183. Pettila¨ V, Ala-Kokko T, Varpula T, Laurila J, Hovilehto S, et al. (2002) On
what are our end-of-life decisions based? Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica
46: 947–954. 154. Sahm S, Will R, Hommel G (2005) What are cancer patients’ preferences
about treatment at the end of life, and who should start talking about it? A
comparison with healthy people and medical staff. Supportive Care in Cancer
13: 206–214. 184. Pedersen R, Nortvedt P, Nordhaug M, Slettebo A, Grothe KH, et al. (2008) In
quest of justice? Clinical prioritisation in healthcare for the aged. Journal of
Medical Ethics 34: 230–235. 155. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care 130. Timmermann M, Naziri D, Etienne AM (2009) Defence Mechanisms and
Coping Strategies among Caregivers in Palliative Care Units. Journal of
Palliative Care 25: 181–190. 157. Mu¨ller-busch H, Oduncu F, Woskanjan S, Klaschik E (2005) Attitudes on
euthanasia, physician-assisted suicide and terminal sedation–A survey of the
members of the German Association for Palliative Medicine. Medicine, Health
Care and Philosophy 7: 333–339. 131. Aujoulat I, Libion F, Bois H, Martin F, Deccache A (2002) Communication
difficulties of healthcare professionals and family caregivers of HIV infected
patients. Patient Education and Counseling 47: 213–222. 158. Beck S, van de Loo A, Reiter-Theil S (2008) A ‘‘little bit illegal’’? Withholding
and withdrawing of mechanical ventilation in the eyes of German intensive
care physicians. Med Health Care Philos 11: 7–16. 132. Deschepper R, Van der Stichele R, Bernheim JL, De Keyser E, Van der
Kelen G, et al. (2006) Communication on end-of-life decisions with patients
wishing to die at home: the making of a guideline for GPs in Flanders, Belgium. British Journal of General Practice 56: 14–19. 159. Sahm SW (2000) Palliative care versus euthanasia. The German position: the
German General Medical Council’s principles for medical care of the
terminally ill. The Journal of medicine and philosophy 25: 195–219. J
133. Cosyns M, Deveugele M, Abbadie B, Roland M (2008) [Decision-making and
end of life care]. Rev Med Brux 29: 77–88. 160. Schildmann J, Doyal L, Cushing A, Vollmann J (2006) Decisions at the end of
life: an empirical study on the involvement, legal understanding and ethical
views of preregistration house officers. Journal of Medical Ethics 32: 567–570. ]
134. Delfosse M (2008) [Advance directives: what are the ethical choices in
Belgium?]. Bull Soc Sci Med Grand Duche Luxemb 3: 299/ 303. p
g
161. Solem PE (1981) The death taboo in Norway. [Norwegian]. Tidsskrift for
Norsk Psykologforening Suppl 1 7–15. g
]
135. Herremans J (2008) [Advance directives: the legal situation in Belgium]. Bull
Soc Sci Med Grand Duche Luxemb 3: 302–310. Soc Sci Med Grand Duche Luxemb 3: 302–310. 162. Telje J (1990) Care for the Dying in General Practice. Tidsskrift for den Norske
Laegeforening 110: 1954–1956. 136. Meeussen K, Van den Block L, Echteld M, Bossuyt N, Bilsen J, et al. (2011)
Advance care planning in Belgium and The Netherlands: a nationwide
retrospective study via sentinel networks of general practitioners. Journal of
pain and symptom management 42: 565–577. 163. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Hov R, Hedelin B, Athlin E (2007) Being an intensive care nurse related to
questions of withholding or withdrawing curative treatment. Journal of Clinical
Nursing 16: 203–211. 137. Baeke G, Wils JP, Broeckaert B (2011) ‘We are (not) the master of our body’:
elderly Jewish women’s attitudes towards euthanasia and assisted suicide. Ethnicity & health 16: 259–278. 164. Husebø B, Husebø S (2005) Nursing homes as arenas of terminal care–how do
we do in practice? Tidsskrift for den Norske lægeforening: tidsskrift for praktisk
medicin, ny række 125: 1352. y
138. Becker G, Sarhatlic R, Olschewski M, Xander C, Momm F, et al. (2007) End-
of-life care in hospital: Current practice and potentials for improvement. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 33: 711–719. 165. Kaarbo E (2011) End-of-life care in two Norwegian nursing homes: family
perceptions. Journal of clinical nursing 20: 1125–1132. 166. Jordhøy M, Fayers P, Loge J, Ahlner-Elmqvist M, Kaasa S (2001) Quality of
life in palliative cancer care: results from a cluster randomized trial. Journal of
Clinical Oncology 19: 3884. 139. Bickel H (1998) Das letzte Lebensjahr Eine Repra¨sentativstudie an Verstorbe-
nen. I. Wohnsituation, Sterbeort und Nutzung von Versorgungsangeboten. Z Geront Geriat 31: 193–204. 167. Jordhøy M, Fayers P, Loge J, Saltnes T, Ahlner-Elmqvist M, et al. (2001)
Quality of life in advanced cancer patients: the impact of sociodemographic
and medical characteristics. British Journal of Cancer 85: 1478. 140. Nyhsen C, Weber M, Schuz J, Faust G (1999) Dying through the hand of men
or taken by the hand of men? Results of an opinion poll concerning active
euthanasia and the hospice movement. Medizinische Klinik 94: 536–540. 168. Jordhøy M, Fayers P, Saltnes T, Ahlner-Elmqvist M, Jannert M, et al. (2000) A
palliative-care intervention and death at home: a cluster randomised trial. The
Lancet 356: 888–893. 141. Pinzon LC, Weber M, Claus M, Fischbeck S, Unrath M, et al. (2011) Factors
influencing place of death in Germany. Journal of pain and symptom
management 41: 893–903. 169. Norum J (1993) Cancer patients who want to die at home. Tidsskrift for den
Norske Laegeforening 113: 1102–1103. 142. Ewers M, Schaeffer D (2007) Dying in Germany -consequences of societal
changes for palliative care and the health care system. Journal of Public Health
15: 475–465. g
g
170. Ringdal G, Jordhøy M, Kaasa S (2002) Family satisfaction with end-of-life care
for cancer patients in a cluster randomized trial. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Pardon K, Deschepper R, Vander Stichele R, Bernheim J, Mortier F, et al. (2009) Preferences of advanced lung cancer patients for patient-centred
information and decision-making: A prospective multicentre study in 13
hospitals in Belgium. Patient Education and Counseling 77: 421–429. 103. Cannaerts N, Dierckx de Casterle B, Grypdonck M (2004) Palliative care, care
for life: A study of the specificity of residential palliative care. Qualitative
Health Research 14: 816–835. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 12 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Aten Primaria 24: 285–288. 223. Thomsen OO, Wulff HR, Martin A, Singer PA (1993) What do
gastroenterologists in Europe tell cancer patients? Lancet 341: 473–476. 224. Centeno-Cortes C, Nunez-Olarte JM (1994) Questioning diagnosis disclosure
in terminal cancer patients: A prospective study evaluating patients’ responses. Palliative Medicine 8: 39–44. 195. Catalan-Fernandez JG, Pons-Sureda O, Recober-Martinez A, Avella-Mestre A,
Carbonero-Malberti JM, et al. (1991) Dying of cancer. The place of death and
family circumstances. Medical Care 29: 841–852. 225. Fainsinger RL, Nunez-Olarte JM, Demoissac DM (2003) The cultural
differences in perceived value of disclosure and cognition: Spain and Canada. Journal of Palliative Care 19: 43–48. 196. Gomez-Batiste X, Viladiu P, Fontanals Ma D, Borras J, Lafuerza A, et al. (2001) Cancer death in Catalonia: Population study about the last month of life
in cancer patients (1993–94). [Spanish]. Medicina Paliativa 8: 134–137. 226. Formiga F, Chivite D, Ortega C, Casas S, Ramo´n JM, et al. (2004) End-of-life
preferences in elderly patients admitted for heart failure. QJM: Monthly
Journal Of The Association Of Physicians 97: 803. p
(
) [ p
]
197. Jimeno Aranda A, Catala´n R, Garcı´a Ruiz M, Benedi E, Ferna´ndez Pico´ A, et
al. (1993) ¿Do´nde fallece el paciente terminal? Atencio´n Primaria 11: 120. al. (1993) ¿Do´nde fallece el paciente terminal? Atencio´n Primaria 198. Lafuerza A, Alcalde R, Roca J, Lozano A, Borra´s J, et al. (1998) Morir de
ca´ncer en Catalun˜a. Encuesta a cuidadores de pacientes fallecidos por ca´ncer. Estudio multice´ntrico de la utilizacio´n de mo´rficos en pacientes terminales. Oncologı´a (Barcelona) 21: 91–94. 227. Go´mez Pavo´n FJ (2002) Caracterı´sticas del anciano con enfermedad
oncolo´gica en fase terminal en el medio hospitalario sociosanitario. Madrid:
Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Servicio de Publicaciones. 228. Poveda de Agustı´n J (1992) Informacio´n al paciente terminal: un reto
antropolo´gico. Jano 1009: 93–106. 199. Olano Espinosa E, Alonso Perez JL, Crespo Garzon A, Sionis A, Sabugal
Rodelgo G, et al. (1997) [Care for the terminal cancer patient in a primary care
district]. Aten Primaria 19: 483–486. 229. Domı´nguez B, Urraca Martı´nez S (1985) Opiniones de los me´dicos y
enfermeras sobre el dolor y la muerte de pacientes terminales. Jano 654-H:
57–68. ]
200. Ramon I, Alonso J, Subirats E, Yanez A, Santed R, et al. (2006) Place of death
of elderly person in Catalonia. Revista Clinica Espanola 206: 549–555. 230. Garcı´a Caro MP, Rio-Valle JS, Quintana FC, Pen˜a DP, Vinuesa AM, et al. (2008) Terminal illness. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Death... in the words of professionals. A qualitative
study based on in-depth interviews with health professionals [Spanish]. Revista
Rol de Enfermerı´a 31: 54–58. 201. Arana M, Martı´n I, Guille´n MV, Ibero JL, Marzo J, et al. (1993) Actitudes ante
la enfermedad terminal. Ecuesta a usuarios de un centro de salud. Aten
Primaria 12: 523. 202. CIS (2009) Atencio´n a pacientes con enfermedades en fase terminal. Estudio
2803. Madrid: CIS. 231. Lopez de Maturana A, Morago V, San Emeterio E, Gorostiza J, Arrate AO
(1993) Attitudes of general practitioners in Bizkaia, Spain, towards the
terminally ill patient. Palliative Medicine 7: 39. 203. Fernandez Diaz R, Perez Suarez MC, Cossio Rodriguez I, Martinez
Gonzalez P (1996) ACTITUD ANTE UNA ENFERMEDAD INCURABLE. Atencio´n Primaria 17: 389–393. y
p
232. Pacheco R, Osuna E, Go´mez Zapata M, Luna A (1989) Attitudes of medical
personnel (doctors and nurses) toward informing the terminal patient. Medicine And Law 8: 243. 204. Ferna´ndez Sua´rez A, Ferna´ndez Alvarez T, Alonso Arruquero C, Marcilla
Escotet M, Cortina Viesca A, et al. (2002) Actitud de los usuarios de centro de
salud ante el diagno´stico de enfermedad terminal. Atencio´n Primaria 30:
449–454. 233. Simon-Lorda P, Tamayo-Velazquez MI, Barrio-Cantalejo IM (2008) Advance
directives in Spain. Perspectives from a medical bioethicist approach. Bioethics
22: 346–354. 205. Wanden-Berghe C, Guardiola-Wanden-Berghe R, Sanz-Valero J, Red de
Malnutricion en Iberoamerica (2009) [Population wills about the decisions and
cares at the end of life]. Nutricion Hospitalaria 24: 732–737. 234. CIS (2002) Actitudes y opiniones de los me´dicos ante la eutanasia. Estudio
2451. Madrid: CIS. 206. Bajo Garcı´a J, Garcı´a Garcı´a JA, Landa Petralanda V, Marijua´n Arcocha L,
Rodrı´guez Salvador JJ (1990) Cuidado del enfermo terminal visto por el
me´dico de familia. Atencio´n Primaria 7: 538. 235. Angel-Lopez-Rey E, Romero-Cano M, Tebar-Morales JP, Mora-Garcia C,
Fernandez-Rodriguez O (2008) [Knowledge and attitudes of the population
about the living wills]. Enferm Clin 18: 115–119. 207. Osuna E, Perez-Carceles MD, Esteban MA, Luna A (1998) The right to
information for the terminally ill patient. Journal Of Medical Ethics 24:
106–109. 236. Lorente Lo´pez M (2004) Las voluntades anticipadas en el a´mbito de la salud:
opiniones y actitudes de la poblacio´n de la zona de salud urbana Torre
Ramona de Zaragoza. Trab Soc y Salud 49: 83–122. 208. Porta M, Busquet X, Jariod M (1997) Attitudes and views of physicians and
nurses towards cancer patients dying at home. Palliative Medicine 11: 116. 237. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care 187. Solheim K, Kjolseth I, Nordal HL, Molaug M (1990) Euthanasia and
Terminal Care in Hospital Tidsskrift for den Norske Laegeforening
110:
1957–1959. 216. Fainsinger RL, Waller A, Bercovici M, Bengtson K, Landman W, et al. (2000)
A multicentre international study of sedation for uncontrolled symptoms in
terminally ill patients. Palliative Medicine 14: 257–265. 188. Lindseth A, Marhaug V, Norberg A, Uden G (1994) Registered Nurses and
Physicians Reflections on their Narratives about Ethically Difficult Care
Episodes. Journal of Advanced Nursing 20: 245–250. y
p
217. Rio-Valle J, Paz M, Caro G, Juarez R, Pena D, et al. (2009) Bad news for the
patient and the family? The worst part of being a health care professional. J Palliat Care 25: 191–196. 189. Nordam A, Sorlie V, Forde R (2003) Integrity in the care of elderly people, as
narrated by female physicians. Nursing Ethics 10: 388–403. 218. Ruiz-Benı´tez de Lugo MA, Coca MC (2008) El pacto de silencio en los
familiares de los pacientes oncolo´gicos terminales. Psicooncologı´a 5: 53–69. narrated by female physicians. Nursing Ethics 10: 388–403. 190. Ude´n G, Norberg A, Lindseth A, Marhaug V (1992) Ethical reasoning in
nurses’ and physicians’ stories about care episodes. Journal of Advanced
Nursing 17: 1028. 219. Astudillo W, Casado Da Rocha A, Mendinueta C (2005) Alivio de las
situaciones difı´ciles y de sufrimiento en la terminalidad. San Sebastia´n:
Sociedad Vasca de Cuidados Paliativos. g
191. Tranoy KE (1988) Medical ethics in Norway: Modern medicine. Traditional
morality. 220. Centeno Cortes C, Nunez Olarte JM (1998) [Studies about the communication
of the diagnosis of cancer in Spain]. Med Clin (Barc) 110: 744–750. 192. Schou K, Alvsvag H, Blaka G, Gjengedal E (2008) The (dis)appearance of the
dying patient in generalist hospital and care home nurses’ talk about the
patient. Nursing Philosophy 9: 233–247. 221. Holland JC, Geary N, Marchini A, Tross S (1987) An international survey of
physician attitudes and practice in regard to revealing the diagnosis of cancer. Cancer Investigations 5: 151–154. 193. Bunch EH (2002) High technology and nursing: ethical dilemmas nurses and
physicians face on high-technology units in Norway. Nurs Inq 9: 187–195. g
222. Surbone A (1993) Information to the cancer patient: psychosocial and spiritual
implications. Supportive Care in Cancer 1: 89. 194. Belderrain BP, Garcia Busto B, Castanon Quinones EC (1999) [Health care
and communication with the terminal cancer patient and his family in a health
area]. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Miro´ G, Pedrol E, Soler A, Serra Prat M, Ye´benes JC, et al. (2006)
Conocimiento de la enfermedad y de los documentos de voluntades
anticipadas en el paciente sepropositivo por el VIH. Medicina Clı´nica 126:
567–572. 209. Sanz de la Torre JC (2000) Actitudes del enfermero/a ante el paciente
terminal. Enfermerı´a Cientı´fica 0: 17–20. 210. Blanco Toro L, Librada Flores S, Rocafort Gil J, Cabo Domı´nguez R, Galea
Marı´n T, et al. (2007) Perfil del cuidador principal del enfermo en situacio´n
terminal y ana´lisis del riesgo de desarrollar duelo patolo´gico. Medicina
Paliativa 14: 164–168. 238. Solsona JF, Sucarrats A, Maull E, Barbat C, Garcia S, et al. (2003) Taking
decisions at the end of life. A survey of the attitude of critically ill patients
against death. Medicina Clinica 120: 335–336. 239. Cohen J, Marcoux I, Bilsen J, Deboosere P, van der Wal G, et al. (2006)
European public acceptance of euthanasia: Socio-demographic and cultural
factors associated with the acceptance of euthanasia in 33 European countries. Social Science and Medicine 63: 743–756. 211. Molina Linde JM, Romero Cotelo J, Romero Rodrı´guez R, Rodrı´guez
San˜udo RM, Ga´lvez Mateos R (2005) Alteraciones emocionales en el cuidador
del enfermo oncolo´gico terminal. Medicina Paliativa. pp 83–87. 212. Molina Linde JM, Romero Cotelo J, Romero Rodrı´guez Y, Rodrı´guez
San˜udo RM, Ga´lvez Mateos R (2006) Encuesta de satisfaccio´n a cuidadores en
una Unidad de Cuidados Paliativos. Medicina Paliativa 13: 11–17. 240. CIS (1995) Perfiles actitudinales en la sociedad espan˜ola. Estudio 2203. Madrid: CIS. 241. CIS (2008) Religiosidad. Estudio 2752. Madrid: CIS. 213. Gil Garcı´a E, Escudero Carretero M, Prieto Rodrı´guez MA, Frı´as Osuna A
(2005) Vivencias, expectativas y demandas de cuidadoras informales de
pacientes en procesos de enfermedad de larga duracio´n. Enfermerı´a Clı´nica. pp 220–226. 242. Fissell RB, Bragg-Gresham JL, Lopes AA, Cruz JM, Fukuhara S, et al. (2005)
Factors associated with ‘‘do not resuscitate’’ orders and rates of withdrawal
from hemodialysis in the international DOPPS. Kidney International 68:
1282–1288. 214. Palomar Gallardo C, Merino Navarro D, Palanco Gonza´lez I, Perez
Cambriles JM, Reyes Bautista JR (2002) El apoyo socio-sanitario prestado a
los pacientes terminales en domicilio y grado de satisfaccio´n de los mismos. Medicina Paliativa 9: 3–5. 243. Sprung C, Cohen S, Sjokvist P, Baras M, Bulow H, et al. (2003) End-of-Life
Practices in European Intensive Care Units The Ethicus Study. Am Med
Assoc. pp 790–797. 244. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Van Oorschot B, Simon A (2006) Importance of the advance directive and the
beginning of the dying process from the point of view of German doctors and
judges dealing with guardianship matters: results of an empirical survey. Journal of Medical Ethics 32: 623–626. 185. Torjuul K, Nordam A, Sorlie V (2005) Action ethical dilemmas in surgery: an
interview study of practicing surgeons. BMC Med Ethics 6: E7. 186. Førde R, Aasland O, Falkum E (1997) The ethics of euthanasia–attitudes and
practice among Norwegian physicians. Social Science & Medicine 45:
887–892. 156. Kirschner R, Elkeles T (1998) [Physician practice patterns and attitudes to
euthanasia in Germany. A representative survey of physicians]. Gesundheits-
wesen 60: 247–253. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 13 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Supportive Care in
Cancer 2: 242–244. 257. Rodrı´guez R (2005) Inmigracio´n y cuidados paliativos, a propo´sito de..¿ un
caso? Medicina Paliativa 12: 3. 285. Veronesi A, Busato C, Annunziata MA, Magri MD, Foladore S, et al. (1995)
Prospective analysis of the information level of Italian cancer patients. European Journal of Cancer 31A: 425–426. 258. Cata Del Palacio E, Hernandez Nunez-Polo M, Perez Martinez A, Ramirez
Orellana M, Madero Lopez L (2007) End of life in a cross-cultural context -
Immigrant children with end-stage cancer. [Spanish]. Medicina Paliativa 14:
236–242. 6. Welshman A (2003) From Italy. Palliative Medicine 17: 122–123. 287. Locatelli C, Piselli P (2010) Telling bad news to the elderly cancer patients: the
role of family caregivers in the choice of non-disclosure. Journal of Geriatric
Oncology 1: 73–80. 259. Oliver C (2004) Cultural influence in migrants’ negotiation of death: The case
of retired migrants in Spain. Mortality 9: 235–254. 260. Casillas Santana L (2004) Interculturalidad en una unidad de cuidados
intensivos. Educare21 6. 288. Annunziata M, Talamini R, Tumolo S, Rossi C, Monfardini S (1996)
Physicians and death: comments and behaviour of 605 doctors in the north-
east of Italy. Supportive Care in Cancer 4: 334–340. 261. Garcı´a Orella´n R (2003) Antropologı´a de la muerte: entre lo intercultural y lo
universal. In: Astudillo W, Orbegozo A, Latiegi A, Urdaneta E, eds. Cuidados
paliativos en enfermerı´a. Donostia: Sociedad Vasca de Cuidados Paliativos. pp
305–322. 289. Dataanalyis (2003) La comunicazione della diagnosi e prognosi in oncologia. 289. Dataanalyis (2003) La comunicazione della diagnosi e progno 290. Lucchiari C, Masiero M, Pravettoni G, Vago G, Wears RL (2010) End-of-life
decision-making: A descriptive study on the decisional attitudes of Italian
physicians. Life Span and Disability 13: 71–86. 262. Pique´ Prado E, Pozo Flo´rez JA´ (1999) Nursing and the terminal patient:
anthropological perspective [Spanish]. Metas de Enfermerı´a 2: 47–51. 291. Bock M, Ciarrocchi V, Wiedermann CJ (2007) Case involving end-of-life
decision issues in Italy. Intensive Care Medicine 33: 1041–1042. 263. Rodrı´guez Rodrı´guez C (2001) Death and mooring, representation systems
[Spanish]. Cultura de los Cuidados 5: 45–48. 292. Maggiore SM, Antonelli M (2005) Euthanasia, therapeutic obstinacy or
something else? An Italian case. Intensive Care Medicine 31: 997–998. 264. Centeno C, Clark D, Lynch T, Rocafort J, Praill D, et al. (2007) Facts and
indicators on palliative care development in 52 countries of the WHO
European region: results of an EAPC task force. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Surbone A, Ritossa C, Spagnolo AG (2004) Evolution of truth-telling attitudes
and practices in Italy. Critical Reviews in Oncology Hematology 52: 165–172. 251. Barrio Linares Md, Jimeno San Martı´n L, Lo´pez Alfaro P, Ezenarro
Muruamendiaraz A, Margall Coscojuela MA, et al. (2007) Cuidados del
paciente al final de la vida: ayudas y obsta´culos que perciben las enfermeras de
cuidados intensivos. Enfermerı´a Intensiva 18: 3–14. 279. Andruccioli J, Montesi A, Di Leo S, Sarti D, Turci P, et al. (2009) Illness
awareness in hospice: application of a semi-structured interview. American
Journal of Hospice & Palliative Medicine 26: 384–391. 252. Baye´s R, Limonero JT, Buendı´a B, Buro´n E, Enrı´quez N (1999) Evaluacio´n de
la ansiedad ante la muerte. Medicina Paliativa 6: 140–143. 280. Andruccioli J, Montesi A, Raffaeli W, Monterubbianesi MC, Turci P, et al. (2007) Illness awareness of patients in hospice: psychological evaluation and
perception of family members and medical staff. Journal of Palliative Medicine
10: 741–748. 253. Perez-Carceles MD, Esteban MA, Osuna E, Luna A (1999) Medical personnel
and death. Medicine And Law 18: 497. 281. Caruso A, Di Francesco B, Pugliese P, Cinanni V, Corlito A (2000)
Information and awareness of diagnosis and progression of cancer in adult
and elderly cancer patients. Tumori 86: 199–203. 254. Cherny NI, Baselga J, De Conno F, Radbruch L (2010) Formulary availability
and regulatory barriers to accessibility of opioids for cancer pain in Europe: a
report from the ESMO/EAPC Opioid Policy Initiative. Annals of Oncology
21: 615–626. 282. Corli O, Apolone G, Pizzuto M, Cesaris L, Cozzolino A, et al. (2009) Illness
awareness in terminal cancer patients: an Italian study. Palliative Medicine 23:
354–359. 255. Mahtani-Chugani V, Gonzalez-Castro I, de Ormijana-Hernandez AS, Martin-
Fernandez R, de la Vega EF, et al. (2010) How to provide care for patients
suffering from terminal non-oncological diseases: barriers to a palliative care
approach. Palliative Medicine 24: 787–795. 283. Morasso G, Alberisio A, Capelli M, Rossi C, Baracco G, et al. (1997) Illness
awareness in cancer patients: A conceptual framework and a preliminary
classification hypothesis. Psychooncology 6: 212–217. 256. Alonso Babarro A, Varela Cerdeira M, Sa´nchez del Corral Usaola F, Cano JM,
Tordable Ramı´rez A, et al. (2002) La atencio´n a pacientes inmigrantes en
Cuidados Paliativos. Un problema emergente. Medicina Paliativa 9: 161–166. 284. Pronzato P, Bertelli G, Losardo P, Landucci M (1994) What do advanced
cancer patients know of their disease? A report from Italy. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Palliative Medicine 21:
463–471. 293. Servillo G, Striano P (2008) End-of-life: Still an Italian dilemma. Intensive
Care Medicine 34: 1333–1335. 294. Zamperetti N, Proietti R (2006) End of life in the ICU: laws, rules and
practices: the situation in Italy. Intensive Care Medicine 32: 1620–1622. 265. De Conno F, Blumhuber H (1996) Meeting reports. Cross-cultural advances in
pain treatment and palliative care. European Journal of Palliative Care 3:
38–39. 295. van der Heide A, Deliens L, Faisst K, Nilstun T, Norup M, et al. (2003) End-
of-life decision-making in six European countries: descriptive study. Lancet
362: 345–350. 266. Monti M, Cunietti E, Castellani L, Merli M, Cruciatti F (2004) Ten years’
activity of the first Italian public hospice for terminally ill patients. Supportive
Care in Cancer 12: 752–757. 296. Benini F, Fabris M, Pace DS, Verno V, Negro V, et al. (2011) Awareness,
understanding and attitudes of Italians regarding palliative care. Annali
dell’Istituto superiore di sanita 47: 253–259. 267. Beccaro M, Costantini M, Rossi PG, Miccinesi G, Grimaldi M, et al. (2006)
Actual and preferred place of death of cancer patients. Results from the Italian
survey of the dying of cancer (ISDOC). Journal of Epidemiology and
Community Health 60: 412–416. 297. Beccaro M, Caraceni A, Costantini M (2010) End-of-Life Care in Italian
Hospitals: Quality of and Satisfaction With Care From the Caregivers’ Point of
View-Results from the Italian Survey of the Dying of Cancer. Journal of Pain
and Symptom Management 39 (6): 1003–1015. 268. DiMola G, Borsellino P, Brunelli C, Gallucci M, Gamba A, et al. (1996)
Attitudes toward euthanasia of physician members of the Italian Society for
Palliative Care. Annals of Oncology 7: 907–911. 298. Costantini M, Ripamonti C, Beccaro M, Montella M, Borgia P, et al. (2009)
Prevalence, distress, management, and relief of pain during the last 3 months
of cancer patients’ life. Results of an Italian mortality follow-back survey. Annals of Oncology 20: 729–735. 269. Costantini M, Beccaro M, Higginson IJ (2008) Cancer Trajectories at the End
of Life: is there an effect of age and gender? Bmc Cancer 8. 299. Costantini M, Viterbori P, Flego G (2002) Prevalence of pain in Italian
hospitals: results of a regional cross-sectional survey. Journal of Pain &
Symptom Management 23: 221–230. 270. Rodriguez G, De Leo C, Girtler N, Vitali P, Grossi E, et al. (2003)
Psychological and social aspects in management of Alzheimer’s patients: an
inquiry among caregivers. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care 245. Vincent JL (1999) Forgoing life support in western European intensive care
units: The results of an ethical questionnaire. Critical Care Medicine 27:
1626–1633. 272. Rossi PG, Beccaro M, Miccinesi G, Borgia P, Costantini M, et al. (2007) Dying
of cancer in Italy: impact on family and caregiver. The Italian Survey of Dying
of Cancer. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 61: 547–554. 273. Rossi Ferrario S, Zotti AM, Ippoliti M, Zotti P (2003) Caregiving-related needs
analysis: A proposed model reflecting current research and socio-political
developments. Health Soc Care Commun 11: 103–110. 246. Abizanda Campos R, Almendros Corral L, Balerdi Perez B, Socias Crespi L,
Lopez Ferre J, et al. (1994) Limitacion Del Esfuerzo Terapeutico. Encuesta
Sobre El Estado De Opinion De Los Profesionales De La Medicina Intensiva. Medicina Intensiva 18: 100–105. 274. Morasso G, Costantini M, Di Leo S, Roma S, Miccinesi G, et al. (2008) End-
of-life care in Italy: personal experience of family caregivers. A content analysis
of open questions from the Italian Survey of the Dying of Cancer (ISDOC). Psycho-Oncology 17: 1073–1080. 247. Esteban A, Gordo F, Solsona JF, Alı´a I, Caballero J, et al. (2001) Withdrawing
and withholding life support in the intensive care unit: a Spanish prospective
multi-centre observational study. Intensive Care Med 27: 1744–1749. 248. Nunez Olarte JM, Guillen DG (2001) Cultural issues and ethical dilemmas in
palliative and end-of-life care in Spain. Cancer Control 8: 46–54. 275. Dataanalysis La comunicazione della diagnosi e prognosi in oncologia. Available in Saluteeuropa.it website. Available: http://saluteeuropait/
indexphp/salute_europa/News/La_comunicazione_della_diagnosi_e_
prognosi_in_oncologia. Accessed 23 July 2009.. 249. Palomar Gallardo C, Merino Navarro D, Gonza´lez de Grado M, Palanco
Gonza´lez I, Pe´rez Cambriles JM, et al. (2001) ¿Que´ entienden los cuidadores
principales de pacientes oncolo´gicos en domicilio sobre ‘muerte digna’? Primeras Jornadas Nacionales de la Sociedad Cientı´fica Espan˜ola de
Licenciados en Enfermerı´a. Universidad de Alicante: Available: http://www. scele.enfe.ua.es/web_scele/1_jornad.htm. pp 37–41. 276. Giannini A, Pessina A, Tacchi EM (2003) End-of-life decisions in intensive care
units: attitudes of physicians in an Italian urban setting. Intensive Care
Medicine 29: 1902–1910. 277. Grassi F, Giraldi T, Messina EG, Magnani K, Valle E, et al. (2000) Physicians’
attitudes to and problems with truth-telling to cancer patients. Supportive Care
in Cancer 8: 40–45. 250. Del Nogal Saez F (2006) Opiates at the end of life in an emergency department
in Spain: euthanasia or good clinical practice? Intensive Care Med 32:
1086–1087. 278. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Vincent JL (1998) Information in the ICU: are we being honest with our
patients? The results of a European questionnaire. Intensive Care Medicine 24:
1251–1256. 215. Uceda ME, Rodriguez JN, Mora JI (2007) Pilot study of family and social
aspects percibed by caregivers of palliative cancer outpatients. Medicina
Paliativa 14: 69–74. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 14 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care 301. Toscani F, Di Giulio P, Brunelli C, Miccinesi G, Laquintana D (2005) How
people die in hospital general wards: a descriptive study. Journal of Pain and
Symptom Management 30: 33–40. 315. Goncalves JF, Alvarenga M, Silva A (2003) The last forty-eight hours of life in a
Portuguese palliative care unit: does it differ from elsewhere? J Palliat Med 6:
895–900. y
p
g
302. Trentin L, Visentin M, de Marco R, Zanolin E (2001) Prevalence of pain in a
public hospital: correlation between patients and caregivers. Journal of
Headache & Pain 2: 73–78. 316. Pimentel FL, Ferreira JS, Real MV, Mesquita NF, Maia-Goncalves JP (1999)
Quantity and quality of information desired by Portuguese cancer patients. Supportive Care in Cancer 7: 407–412. 303. Mercadante S, Salvaggio L (1996) Cancer pain knowledge in southern Italy:
data from a postgraduate refresher course. J Pain Symptom Manage 11:
108–115. 317. Goncalves JA (2010) Attitudes toward end-of-life situations other than
euthanasia and assisted suicide among Portuguese oncologists. Supportive
care in cancer: official journal of the Multinational Association of Supportive
Care in Cancer 18: 1271–1277. 304. Porzio G, Aielli F, Narducci F, Valenti M, Varrassi G, et al. (2003) Knowledge
and attitudes of Italian medical oncology residents toward the approach and
treatment of pain [2]. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 26:
590–592. 318. Fonseca AM, Goncalves DC, Pereira SM (2010) Working family carers in
Portugal: between the duty and the burden of caring for old vulnerable people. International journal of palliative nursing 16: 476–480. 305. Visentin M, Trentin L, et al. (2001) Knowledge and attitudes of Italian medical
oncology residents toward the approach and treatment of pain. J Pain
Symptom Manage 22: 925–930. 319. Pereira SM, Fradique E, Fialho R, Cerqueira M, Pereira A, et al. (2011)
Advance directives: Portuguese palliative care professionals’ views. Interna-
tional journal of palliative nursing 17: 373–380. 306. Field A, Maher P, Webb D, Field A, Maher P, et al. (2002) Cross cultural
research in palliative care. Social Work in Health Care 35: 523–543. 320. National Institutes of Health (NIH) (2004) National Institutes of Health State-
of-the-Science Conference Statement on Improving End-of-Life Care. USA:
National Institutes of Health. p
307. French J, Schwartz DR (1973) Terminal care at home in two cultures. Am J Nurs 73: 502–505. 321. Bennet M, Davies E, Higginson I (2010) Delivering research in end-of-life
care:problems, pitfalls and future priorities. Palliative Medicine 24: 456–461. 308. Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Neurological Sciences 24: 329–335. 300. Ripamonti C, Zecca E, Brunelli C, Groff L, Boffi R, et al. (2000) Pain
experienced by patients hospitalized at the National Cancer Institute of Milan:
Research project ‘‘Towards a Pain-Free Hospital’’. Tumori 86: 412–418. 271. Rossi Ferrario S, Cardillo V, Vicario F, Balzarini E, Zotti AM (2004)
Advanced care at home: caregiving and bereavement. Palliative Medicine 18:
129–136. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 15 Scoping Culture and End of Life Care Safonte-Strumolo N, Dunn AB (2000) Consideration of cultural and relational
issues in bereavement: The case of an Italian American family. The Family
Journal 8: 334–340. 322. ten Have H, Clark D (2002) The ethics of palliative care: European
perspectives. Buckingham: Open University Press. - p. J
309. Wood WA, McCabe MS, Goldberg RM (2009) Commentary: Disclosure in
oncology – to whom does the truth belong? Oncologist 14: 77–82. 323. Menaca A, Evans M, Andrew EVW, Toscani F, Finetti S, et al. End of life care
across southern Europe: a critical review of cultural similarities and differences
between Italy, Spain and Portugal. Critical Reviews of Oncology and
Haematology. 310. Costantini AS (2000) Geographical variations of place of death among Italian
communities suggest an inappropriate hospital use in the terminal phase of
cancer disease. Public Health 114: 15–20. 324. The AM (2009) Verlossers naast god. Dokters en euthanasie in Nederland. Amsterdam: Uitgeverij Thoeris. 311. Hedayat KM (2002) Pediatric biomedical ethics: Introducing Italian pediatri-
cian to the Islamic perspective. Italian Journal of Pediatrics 28: 112–120. 325. Gysels M, Higginson I (2007) Systematic reviews. In: Addington-Hall J,
Bruera E, Higginson I, Payne S, eds. Research methods in palliative care. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 312. Goncalves JA (2001) A Portuguese palliative care unit. Support Care Cancer 9:
4–7. 313. Instituto Nacional de Estatı´stica de Portugal (2005) Obitos por distribuicao
geographica de residencia (NUTS II) e sexo, segundo a causa de morte. Lisboa:
Instituto Nacional de Estatistica de Portugal. 326. Payne SA, Turner JM (2008) Research methodologies in palliative care: a
bibliometric analysis. Palliative Medicine 22: 336–342. g
314. Pinto C, Santos L (2009) Prestador de cuidados: Quais sao as suas
necessidades? ONCONEWS 3: 16. 327. Aoun S, Kristjanson L (2005) Challenging the framework for evidence in
palliative care research. Palliative Medicine 19: 461–465. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org April 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 4 | e34188 16
|
https://openalex.org/W4309319889
|
https://www.glossa-journal.org/article/id/9367/download/pdf/
|
English
| null |
On the feature (in)deficiency of dedicated impersonal pronouns: the view from Jordanian Arabic
|
Glossa
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 15,594
|
Alhailawani, Mohammad & Othman, Waleed & Abdel-Ghafer, Osama.
2022. On the feature (in)deficiency of dedicated impersonal pronouns:
The view from Jordanian Arabic. Glossa: a journal of general linguistics
7(1). pp. 1–34. DOI: https://doi.org/10.16995/glossa.9367 On the feature (in)deficiency of dedicated
impersonal pronouns: The view from Jordanian
Arabic Mohammad Alhailawani, University of Petra, Amman, JO, mohammad.alhailawani@uop.edu.jo
Waleed Othman, University of Petra, Amman, JO, waleed.othman@uop.edu.jo Mohammad Alhailawani, University of Petra, Amman, JO, mohammad.alhailawani@uop.edu.jo
Waleed Othman, University of Petra, Amman, JO, waleed.othman@uop.edu.jo Osama Abdel-Ghafer, Jordan University of Science & Technology, Irbid, JO, abghafer@just.edu.jo Research on dedicated impersonal pronouns in Germanic and Romance has shown a correlation
between a pronoun’s reading and its case. In particular, impersonal pronouns that are exclusively
generic (e.g. English one) can bear any case, whereas those that can be either generic or existential
(e.g. Dutch men) can only bear nominative case. Moreover, there is a general consensus in the
literature that both types of impersonal pronouns radically lack phi-feature specification, viz. the pronouns are underspecified for person, number, and gender features in the syntax. The
purpose of this paper is twofold: first to discuss the impersonal use of the pronoun waaħad
(one) in Jordanian Arabic (JA) and its implications for the crosslinguistic typology of impersonal
pronouns, and second to argue that a radical feature deficiency approach to these pronouns
is inaccurate. Regarding the first point, we show that waaħad behaves similarly to English-
type pronouns in terms of its interpretation and syntactic distribution. JA waaħad can only
have a generic inclusive reading and can appear in multiple syntactic positions. As for the
second point, we show that waaħad is not completely phi-defective. The JA pronoun patterns
with crosslinguistically recognized impersonal pronouns by being underspecified for person. However, independent empirical evidence from agreement shows that waaħad is always specified
for singular number and also for gender in some contexts. This novel data from JA suggest a
rethinking of the radical feature deficiency approach to impersonal pronouns. Additionally, we
provide evidence for the presence of a DP projection above impersonal waaħad that is overtly
instantiated via the definite article il- (the). Our findings show that impersonal pronouns are
not radically devoid of phi-features. Whereas impersonal pronouns share the core property of
being underspecified for person, some pronouns are specified for number and also for gender
in the syntax. Glossa: a journal of general linguistics is a peer-reviewed open access journal published by the Open Library of
Humanities. © 2022 The Author(s). This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution 4.0 International License (CC-BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original author and source are credited. 1 Introduction Dedicated impersonal pronouns (impersonals henceforth) in Germanic and Romance are divided
into two main groups as far as their interpretation is concerned. On the one hand, pronouns
like English one and Frisian men are always generic (1a), but never existential (1b). On the
other hand, pronouns like Dutch men and Swedish man can be either generic or existential (2)
(Egerland 2003; Hoekstra 2010; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018: among others). )
a. When one is in Italy, one eats pasta. (1)
a. When one is in Italy, one eats pasta. b. *One has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about. (Fenger 2018:296–297) b. *One has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about. (Fenger 2018:296–297) (Fenger 2018:296–297) (2) (2)
a. Dutch
Wanneer men in Italie is, eet men pasta. When
imp in Italy is, eat imp pasta. ‘Intended: ‘When people are in Italy, they have the habit of eating pasta.’
b. Men heeft voor je
gebeld, maar ik weet
niet waar het over
ging
imp has
for
you called but
I
know not what it
about went
Intended: ‘Someone has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about.’
(Fenger 2018:296–297) (2)
a. Dutch
Wanneer men in Italie is, eet men pasta. When
imp in Italy is, eat imp pasta. ‘Intended: ‘When people are in Italy, they have the habit of eating pasta.’ b. Men heeft voor je
gebeld, maar ik weet
niet waar het over
ging
imp has
for
you called but
I
know not what it
about went
Intended: ‘Someone has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about.’
(Fenger 2018:296–297) (Fenger 2018:296–297) Besides the different readings impersonals might take on, the pronouns have been shown to
occupy different syntactic positions that overlap with their readings. In particular, English-
type pronouns can bear any case, whereas Dutch-type pronouns can only bear nominative case
(Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018: among others). Furthermore, many existing accounts
of impersonals treat them as being defective. That is, the pronouns are underspecified for phi-
features in the syntax (Egerland 2003; Hoekstra 2010; Malamud 2012; Ackema & Neeleman
2018; Fenger 2018: among others). Another issue that has been a subject of debate is the status of
impersonals with respect to (in)definiteness. On the feature (in)deficiency of dedicated
impersonal pronouns: The view from Jordanian
Arabic See http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. OPEN ACCESS Glossa: a journal of general linguistics is a peer-reviewed open access journal published by the Open Library of
Humanities. © 2022 The Author(s). This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution 4.0 International License (CC-BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original author and source are credited. See http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS 2 2 1 The Arabic data used throughout this paper are from JA, unless stated otherwise on top of each example. 1 Introduction In the literature, impersonals are classified as either
indefinite (Condoravdi 1989; Moltmann 2006; Malamud 2012), definite (Kratzer 1997; Alonso-
Ovalle 2002; Hoekstra 2010; Hall 2018), or a-definite (Koenig & Mauner 1999; Zobel 2016). This
paper aims to contribute to the body of research on imperosnals by discussing the impersonal
use of the pronoun waaħad (one) in Jordanian Arabic (a Semitic language) and its implications
for the crosslinguistic typology of impersonals. In Jordanian Arabic (JA henceforth), the numeral
waaħad (one) can be used as an impersonal pronoun when preceded by the definite article il-
(the). The pronoun is used to make statements that generalize over people. For instance, the
example in (3) means that all people (including the speaker) must wake up early.1 3 3 (3)
*(il)-waaħad laazim yiSħa
bakkiir
the-one.ms must
wake-up.3ms early
Intended: ‘People must wake up early.’ (3) In this paper, we discuss the morphosyntax of impersonal waaħad (imp-waaħad henceforth)
in JA, focusing on the following issues:2 (i) the possible readings imp-waaħad can take on; (ii)
the internal feature make-up of the pronoun; (iii) the syntactic distribution of imp-waaħad;
and (iv) the status of imp-waaħad with respect to (in)definiteness. First of all, we show that
imp-waaħad can only have a generic inclusive reading. We also discuss verbal agreement with
imp-waaħad to identify the internal feature make-up of the pronoun. JA is a morphologically
rich language in which verbs display full person-number-gender agreement with their
subjects. Our discussion of agreement with imp-waaħad reveals that the pronoun is specified
for some phi-features. More precisely, imp-waaħad aligns with crosslinguistically recognized
impersonals by lacking person specification in the syntax. However, the JA pronoun differs
from other impersonals by virtue of being always specified for singular number and also
for feminine gender, given the right context. The JA facts run counter to the radical feature
deficiency approach to impersonals (Egerland 2003; Hoekstra 2010; Ackema & Neeleman
2018; Fenger 2018: among others). Furthermore, we investigate the syntactic distribution
of imp-waaħad, showing that the pronoun can appear in multiple syntactic positions. The JA
data support Fenger’s (2018) proposal that pronouns that are exclusively generic (e.g. English
one) project a KP, and as such, can bear any case. We also discuss the (in)definite status
of imp-waaħad. We argue that the JA pronoun is best analyzed as a definite (non-specific)
generic DP. 2 In this paper, we restrict our attention to JA dedicated impersonal waaħad. We do not discuss impersonal null sub
jects or impersonal passives. We refer the interested reader to Fassi-Fehri (2009; 2012) for a detailed discussion of
both types in Modern Standard Arabic. 1 Introduction Based on a number of diagnostics of syntactic definiteness, we show that imp-
waaħad projects a DP that is overtly instantiated via the definite article il- (the). Our findings
support existing proposals that treat impersonals as being definite (Hoekstra 2010; Hall 2018:
among others). Regarding the syntax of imp-waaħad, we adopt the structure proposed in
Ackema & Neeleman (2018) for English-type impersonals and its specific implementation in
Fenger (2018). All in all, the findings of this paper suggest a rethinking of the radical feature
deficiency approach to impersonals. In particular, the JA data show that impersonals are
not universally completely devoid of phi-features. Whereas all impersonals share the core
property of being underspecified for person, some impersonals can carry number and even
gender specification in the syntax. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. In the following section, we provide
an overview of the main properties of impersonals and contrast them with the properties
of imp-waaħad in JA. We discuss the possible readings, agreement patterns, and syntactic
distribution of impersonals. We show that the JA pronoun seems to pattern with English-
type impersonals in terms of its interpretation and syntactic distribution. By contrast, we
show that imp-waaħad differs from other impersonals by being specified for number and also
for gender in some contexts. Section 3 introduces Ackema & Neeleman’s (2018) theory of
person. In section 4, we present our analysis of imp-waaħad, which draws on the analysis
presented in the previous section. In section 5, we discuss the (in)definite status of imp-
waaħad, showing that waaħad behaves like a definite (non-specific) generic DP. Section 6 is
a brief conclusion. 2 Crosslinguistic properties of impersonals Etymologically, impersonals across different languages are derived from words that mean ‘man’
or ‘person’ (e.g. Dutch men, German man, French on) or ‘one’ (e.g. English one, Spanish and
Basque uno) (Siewierska 2011). It has been noted in the literature on impersonals that the
pronouns differ in several regards, such as the readings the pronouns might take on and the
possible syntactic positions they might occupy (Cinque 1988; Egerland 2003; Moltmann 2006;
Hoekstra 2010; Siewierska 2011; Malamud 2012; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018; Hall
2018: among others). In each of the following sub-sections, we first review the main properties of
impersonals in Germanic and Romance languages and then contrast them with the properties of
JA imp-waaħad. We focus on the possible readings, agreement patterns, and syntactic distribution
of impersonals. 2.1 Impersonals: The readings Impersonals such as Swedish man and English one can have a generic “quasi-universal” reading
in Cinque’s (1988) sense, a quasi-existential (i.e. arbitrary Egerland 2003) reading in episodic
sentences, and a definite (i.e. specific Egerland 2003) reading that corresponds to first person
singular ‘I’ (e.g. Swedish man Egerland, 2003) or first person plural ‘we’ (e.g. Italian si Cinque
1988). There is language-specific variation regarding the availability of the aforementioned
readings. To illustrate this point, we compare the readings available for impersonals in Swedish
and English. Egerland (2003) notes that Swedish impersonal man can take on the three readings
mentioned above. For instance, the sentence in (4a) has a generic reading where people in
general have to work until the age of 65. Additionally, the same pronoun can have an arbitrary
(i.e. existential) reading. In (4b), man refers to an unspecified group of people who worked for 5 two months to solve the problem. Finally, Egerland (2003) shows that Swedish man can also take
on a specific first person singular reading (4c).3 (4)
a. Swedish
Man mste arbeta till
65. man must work
until 65
‘People have to work until the age of 65.’
b. Man arbetade i
tv
mnader för att
lösa problemet. man worked for two months to
solve the problem
‘Some people / they worked for two months to solve …’
b. I gr
p eftermiddagen blev man avskedad. yesterday afternoon
was man fired
‘Yesterday afternoon I was fired.’ (4)
a. Swedish
Man mste arbeta till
65. man must work
until 65
‘People have to work until the age of 65.’ (4) b. Man arbetade i
tv
mnader för att
lösa problemet. man worked for two months to
solve the problem
‘Some people / they worked for two months to solve …’ b. Man arbetade i
tv
mnader för att
lösa problemet. man worked for two months to
solve the problem
‘Some people / they worked for two months to solve …’ b. I gr
p eftermiddagen blev man avskedad. yesterday afternoon
was man fired
‘Yesterday afternoon I was fired.’ b. I gr
p eftermiddagen blev man avskedad. yesterday afternoon
was man fired
‘Yesterday afternoon I was fired.’ (Egerland 2003:76) (Egerland 2003:76) English impersonal one, on the other hand, can only have a generic reading. The example in (5a)
(adapted from Fenger (2018)) simply means that when people (including the speaker) are in
Italy, they eat pasta. 3 The specific reading in Italian and French gets a plural interpretation ‘we’. The following examples from French
illustrates this point: 2.1 Impersonals: The readings Unlike Swedish man, the existential reading is unavailable for English one,
as seen in (5b). (5)
a. When one is in Italy, one eats pasta. (5)
a. When one is in Italy, one eats pasta. (5) b. *One has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about. b. *One has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about. (Fenger 2018:292,297) Several authors have argued that the generic reading in examples like (4a) and (5a) is derived
via a generic operator [GEN] (Krifka etal. 1995), under the assumption that impersonals act as
variables (Chierchia 1995; D’Alessandro & Alexiadou 2002; Egerland 2003; Moltmann 2006;
Hoekstra 2010; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018: among others). Fenger (2018:296), for
instance, notes that an impersonal like English one in (5a) has a bound variable interpretation,
meaning that all occurrences of the impersonal pronoun in the same sentence refer to the same x
(i.e. ‘‘For any GENx, if x is in Italy, then x eats pasta’’).4 On the other hand, the existential reading 3 The specific reading in Italian and French gets a plural interpretation ‘we’. The following examples from Fren
illustrates this point: (i)
French
Hier
soir
on
a
été
congédié
yesterday evening one has been fired
‘We were fired yesterday evening.’ (Egerland 2003:84)
4 There is a disagreement in the literature on the exact positioning of the [GEN] operator. Some argue that it is located
at the clausal level (Chierchia 1995; D’Alessandro & Alexiadou 2002; Egerland 2003; Fenger 2018), whereas others
argue that [GEN] is merged inside the DP (Ackema & Neeleman 2018). 6 in examples like (4b) is derived via the absence of any feature specification (Egerland 2003),
or via the presence of an existential (i.e. arbitrary) operator on top of the pronoun (Ackema &
Neeleman 2018).5 In addition to the generic vs. existential reading distinction, impersonals are also distinguished
in terms of their inclusiveness/exclusiveness of the speaker. Hoekstra (2010) notes that
impersonals in Germanic might optionally or obligatorily include the speaker. In German, for
instance, impersonal man might optionally include the speaker (6b)–(7b). In Frisian, on the other
hand, men obligatorily includes the speaker, as evidenced from the contrast in grammaticality
between (6a) and (7a). (6)
a. Frisian
Men moat it
izer smeie, at
it hyt is. one shall the iron forge, while it hot is
‘Strike while the iron is hot.’ (6) b. 5 Additionally, D’Alessandro & Alexiadou (2002) note that an impersonal pronoun can receive an existential reading
under locality with an Aspect head in Romance. 2.1 Impersonals: The readings German
Man soll
das Eisen schmieden, solang es heiß ist. one shall the iron
forge,
while it hot is
‘Strike while the iron is hot.’ (Hoekstra 2010:33) (Hoekstra 2010:33) (7) (7)
a. Frisian
*Men seit
dat
smoken
net sûn
is. one says that smoking unhealthy is
‘They say that smoking is unhealthy.’ b. German
Man sagt, dass Rauchen ungesund
sei. one says that smoking unhealthy is
‘They say that smoking is unhealthy.’
(Hoekstra 2010:33) b. German
Man sagt, dass Rauchen ungesund
sei. one says that smoking unhealthy is
‘They say that smoking is unhealthy.’ (Hoekstra 2010:33) (Hoekstra 2010:33) Summarizing, the literature has identified the following readings of impersonals: Summarizing, the literature has identified the following readings of impersonals: (8)
Possible readings of impersonals: (8) a. Obligatorily inclusive generic reading: refers “quasi-universally” to a group that
must include the speaker (and potentially the addressee). b. Optionally inclusive generic reading: refers “quasi-universally” to a group that
need not include the speaker, but can.iii c. Definite personal (i.e. specific) reading : refers to a specific (atomic or plural)
individual, in the way that a personal pronoun normally does. 5 Additionally, D’Alessandro & Alexiadou (2002) note that an impersonal pronoun can receive an existential reading
under locality with an Aspect head in Romance. d. Arbitrary (i.e. existential) reading: refers “quasi-existentially” to some group/
individual (which typically excludes the speaker).i Turning now to JA imp-waaħad, the data in (9) show that the pronoun can take on a generic
inclusive reading in both SVO and VSO orders. Turning now to JA imp-waaħad, the data in (9) show that the pronoun can take on a generic
inclusive reading in both SVO and VSO orders. (9)
a. il-waaħad
laazim yiSħa
bakkiir
the-one.ms must
wake-up.3ms early (9)
a. il-waaħad
laazim yiSħa
bakkiir
the-one.ms must
wake-up.3ms early bakkiir (9) b. laazim yiSħa
il-waaħad
bakkiir
must
wake-up.3ms the-one.ms early c. *waaħad
laazim yiSħa
bakkiir
the-one.ms must
wake-up.3ms early
Intended: ‘People must wake up early.’ In (9), imp-waaħad has a bound variable interpretation (Moltmann 2006). The sentence can only
mean that all people (including the speaker) must wake up early. In its impersonal use, waaħad
must bear the definite article il- (the), as evidenced from the ungrammaticality of (9c). Imp-waaħad is obligatorily inclusive. 8 Ackema & Neeleman (2018) extend their argument to other languages where the specific reading is assumed to be
available for impersonals (e.g. Swedish man (Egerland 2003), Dutch “football je” (Zeijlstra 2015), and West Frisian
men (Hoekstra 2010)). Although see Hall (2018) for an alternative view concerning impersonal man in Multicultural
London English (MLE). 2.1 Impersonals: The readings 8 (11)
a. *imbariħ,
il-waaħad saʔal
ʕann-ak,
bas ma
ħaka
šuu
bidduh
yesterday, the-one.ms asked.3ms about-you, but neg said.3ms what wants-he.3ms
Intended: ‘Someone asked about you yesterday, but they did not say what they want.’
b. *imbariħ,
saʔal
ʕann-ak
il-waaħad,
bas ma
ħaka
šuu
yesterday, asked.3ms about-you the-one.ms, but neg said.3ms what
bidduh
wants-he.3ms
Intended: ‘Someone asked about you yesterday, but they did not say what they
want.’ (11)
a. *imbariħ,
il-waaħad saʔal
ʕann-ak,
bas ma
ħaka
šuu
bidduh
yesterday, the-one.ms asked.3ms about-you, but neg said.3ms what wants-he.3ms
Intended: ‘Someone asked about you yesterday, but they did not say what they want.’ b. *imbariħ,
saʔal
ʕann-ak
il-waaħad,
bas ma
ħaka
šuu
yesterday, asked.3ms about-you the-one.ms, but neg said.3ms what
bidduh
wants-he.3ms
Intended: ‘Someone asked about you yesterday, but they did not say what they
want.’ Furthermore, a specific first person singular reading seems to be available for imp-waaħad in
examples like (12). (12)
il-waaħad
kaan
Taayiš
fi Siɣar-uh
the-one.ms was.ms reckless.ms in youth-his
Intended: ‘I was reckless when I was young.’ On the face of it, the example in (12) seems to be understood as referring to the speaker alone. However, we follow Ackema & Neeleman (2018) by assuming that the specific reading of
impersonals is in fact a generic one. Ackema & Neeleman (2018) question the availability of the
specific reading altogether. For them, the specific reading of impersonals is a particular instance
of the generic reading. More precisely, Ackema & Neeleman (2018) note that the the so-called
specific reading is a generalization over situations, rather than individuals. Ackema & Neeleman,
for instance, show that the “royal” use of English one seen in (13) is not in fact personal (i.e. referential). (Ackema & Neeleman 2018:113) 2.1 Impersonals: The readings Evidence for this view comes from the impossibility of
having waaħad in statements that do not involve the speaker like (10).6 (10) *il-waaħad
biguul
innu il-tadxiin
mish Siħħi
the-one.ms says.3ms that the-smoking neg healthy
Intended: ‘They say that smoking is unhealthy.’ (10) *il-waaħad
biguul
innu il-tadxiin
mish Siħħi
the-one.ms says.3ms that the-smoking neg healthy
Intended: ‘They say that smoking is unhealthy.’ Intended: ‘They say that smoking is unhealthy.’ An arbitrary (existential) reading is unavailable for imp-waaħad in both SVO and VSO orders, as
the ungrammaticality of (11) shows.7 An arbitrary (existential) reading is unavailable for imp-waaħad in both SVO and VSO orders, as
the ungrammaticality of (11) shows.7 6 In JA, the corresponding grammatical example to (10) involves a silent 3rd person plural ‘they’ that is manifested as
3rd person plural inflection on the main verb (i): 6 In JA, the corresponding grammatical example to (10) involves a silent 3rd person plural ‘they’ that is manifested
3rd person plural inflection on the main verb (i): (i)
biguuluu
innu il-tadxiin
mish Siħħi
say.3mpl that the-smoking neg healthy Intended: ‘They say that smoking is unhealthy.’ The reading available in (i) is generic exclusive, since plural number is often seen as conveying exclusiveness
(D’Alessandro & Alexiadou 2002; Fassi-Fehri 2009). As mentioned earlier, in this work we only concern ourselves
with overt dedicated impersonals. See Holmberg (2005; 2010) for a detailed discussion of impersonal constructions
in null subject languages, and Fassi-Fehri (2009; 2012) for a discussion of the same topic in Arabic.i The reading available in (i) is generic exclusive, since plural number is often seen as conveying exclusiveness
(D’Alessandro & Alexiadou 2002; Fassi-Fehri 2009). As mentioned earlier, in this work we only concern ourselves
with overt dedicated impersonals. See Holmberg (2005; 2010) for a detailed discussion of impersonal constructions
in null subject languages, and Fassi-Fehri (2009; 2012) for a discussion of the same topic in Arabic.i 7 The existential use of waaħad is only viable without the definite article (i).i (i)
fii
waaħad/waħdih tawiil/tawiilih
saʔal/saʔlat exp one.ms/one.fs
tall.ms/tall.fs asked.3ms/asked.3fs about-you yesterday Lit: ‘Someone tall asked about you yesterday.’ In (i), the use of waaħad is not impersonal, but rather, waaħad is simply an indefinite noun meaning someone (see
Alhailawani 2018; 2022). As mentioned in section 1, in this paper we restrict our attention to the impersonal use of
waaħad, which only takes place when waaħad is preceded by the definite article il- (the). 9 Generally, most dedicated impersonal pronouns do not allow a second person reading. For instance, English one and
Dutch men cannot have a second person reading, but the second person pronouns you and je can (Ackema & Neele
man 2018). Hall (2018), however, shows that impersonal man in MLE can have a singular or plural second person
interpretations. (13)
One is not amused According to Ackema & Neeleman (2018:114), the use of impersonals in examples like (13)
“gives rise to the implication that the statement that holds of the speaker in the actual world
would be true of other people if they were to find themselves in the same situation”.8i We assume that the same implication holds in JA in examples like (12). More specifically, the
sentence in (12) has a reading where (presumably) most people were reckless when they were
young. The unavailability of imp-waaħad in episodic contexts like (14) bears out the claim that
the pronoun cannot have a specific reading. 9 9 (14) *il-waaħad
rayiħ
ʕa-l-beit
the-one.ms going.3ms to-the-home
Intended: ‘I’m going home.’ (14) *il-waaħad
rayiħ
ʕa-l-beit
the-one.ms going.3ms to-the-home
Intended: ‘I’m going home.’ Finally, a second person reading is unavailable for imp-waaħad at all, as seen in (15). (15) *šuu
(il)-waaħad biddu
youkil? what the-one.ms want.3ms eat.3ms
Intended: ‘What do you want to eat?’ (15) *šuu
(il)-waaħad biddu
youkil? what the-one.ms want.3ms eat.3ms
Intended: ‘What do you want to eat?’ Table 1 summarizes the readings of imp-waaħad explored in this section: Table 1 summarizes the readings of imp-waaħad explored in this section: Table 1 summarizes the readings of imp waaħad explored in this section:
Reading
imp-waaħad
Generic inclusive
Existential (arbitrary)
*
Definite personal (specific)
*
Second Person
*
Table 1: Possible readings of imp-waaħad. Table 1: Possible readings of imp-waaħad. Table 1: Possible readings of imp-waaħad. (17)
a.
We, the students, work hard.
b. *One, the students, work hard. (17)
a. We, the students, work hard. b. *One, the students, work hard. (Fenger 2018:308) Second, several authors have shown that impersonals uniformly trigger 3rd person singular
agreement on verbs irrespective of the reading they might take on (Egerland 2003; Hoekstra
2010; Ackema & Neeleman 2018: among others). Nonetheless, impersonals in a number of
languages (e.g. English, Dutch, and German) can combine with a plural reciprocal (Hoekstra
2010; Malamud 2012; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018; Hall 2018). The following
examples from Dutch and English illustrate both observations:10 (18)
a. Dutch
In dit
land
geef-t men elkaar
cadeautjes met
kerst. In this country give-s imp each.other presents
with Christmas b. In this country, one give-s each other presents at Christmas. (Adapted from Fenger 2018:295) In the literature, the ability of impersonals to combine with a reciprocal has been interpreted
differently. Malamud (2012) takes the ability of German impersonal man to combine with
a reciprocal to be evidence that the pronoun is not specified for number in the syntax. For
Malamud, singular agreement with German impersonal man is default agreement. Moreover,
Hoekstra (2010) and Ackema & Neeleman (2018) assume that this ability provides evidence that
impersonals are “semantically plural”, viz. the pronouns trigger singular agreement in the syntax
because they are underspecified for phi-features, yet they receive a plural interpretation.11 Hall
(2018), on the other hand, notes that such an ability provides evidence for number neutrality
(at least for impersonal man in Multicultural London English (MLE)). All in all, there is a general
consensus in the literature that impersonals lack person and number specification in the syntax
and that 3rd person singular agreement observed with these pronouns involves default agreement
(Hoekstra 2010; Malamud 2012; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018; Hall 2018). In the literature, the ability of impersonals to combine with a reciprocal has been interpreted
differently. Malamud (2012) takes the ability of German impersonal man to combine with
a reciprocal to be evidence that the pronoun is not specified for number in the syntax. For
Malamud, singular agreement with German impersonal man is default agreement. Moreover,
Hoekstra (2010) and Ackema & Neeleman (2018) assume that this ability provides evidence that
impersonals are “semantically plural”, viz. b. *Men, de
studenten, werken hard.
IMP, the students
work
hard (Fenger 2018:308) (Fenger 2018:308) 2.2 Impersonals: agreement and phi-features It is generally accepted that impersonals are deficient, viz. the pronouns are underspecified for
phi-features in the syntax (Egerland 2003; Hoekstra 2010; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger
2018). Egerland (2003:86), for instance, notes that impersonals “radically lack inherent lexical
content with regard to the categories of person and number (and presumably also gender)”. Egerland also notes that the only feature specification assumed for impersonals is [+human],
since the pronouns can only refer to humans (also see Holmberg & Phimsawat (2015)). A number of observations support the feature deficiency view of impersonals. First, unlike
personal pronouns (Cardinaletti & Starke 1999), impersonals cannot be modified. For instance,
Fenger (2018) shows that personal pronouns in Dutch and English can be modified (16a) &
(17a), whereas the impersonals in both languages cannot (16b) & (17b). (16)
a. Dutch
Wij, de
studenten, werken hard. we
the students
work
hard
‘We, the students, work hard.’ (16)
a. Dutch
Wij, de
studenten, werken hard. we
the students
work
hard
‘We, the students, work hard.’ (16)
a. Dutch
Wij, de
studenten, werken hard. we
the students
work
hard
‘We, the students, work hard.’ ‘We, the students, work hard.’ 10 10 10 Malamud (2012) notes that unlike other Germanic impersonals (e.g. German man), English impersonal one cannot
bind a plural reciprocal (i). 11 Borer (2005) notes that, like mass nouns, impersonals are semantically plural but trigger syntactic singular agree
ment. (i)
*?One used to say hello to each other.
(Malamud 2012:1 Given the grammaticality of (18b), it seems that the judgments are not subtle with regard to English impersonal o
and its ability to combine with a reciprocal. (i)
*?One used to say hello to each other. 10 Malamud (2012) notes that unlike other Germanic impersonals (e.g. German man), English impersonal one cannot
bind a plural reciprocal (i).
(i)
*?One used to say hello to each other.
(Malamud 2012:11)
Given the grammaticality of (18b), it seems that the judgments are not subtle with regard to English impersonal one
and its ability to combine with a reciprocal.
11 Borer (2005) notes that, like mass nouns, impersonals are semantically plural but trigger syntactic singular agree bind a plural reciprocal (i).
(i)
*?One used to say hello to each other.
(Malamud 2012:11)
Given the grammaticality of (18b), it seems that the judgments are not subtle with regard to English impersonal one
and its ability to combine with a reciprocal. (i)
*?One used to say hello to each other.
(Malamud 2012:11)
Given the grammaticality of (18b) it seems that the judgments are not subtle with regard to English impersonal one 12 Ritter & Wiltschko (2019) claim that German impersonal man is genderless. As they acknowledge, however, this
claim cannot be empirically motivated since nouns and predicates in German are not marked for gender. Moreover,
the only way to detect gender in German is through determiners and adnominal modifiers which cannot co-occur
with man. 14 The numeral waaħad (one) in Arabic has multiple functions. Alhailawani (2019) shows that waaħad functions as an
indefinite specific marker in prenominal position, similarly to referential this in English (Ionin 2006) and exad (one)
in Hebrew (Borer 2005). Also, Alhailawani (2018; 2022) shows that waaħad functions as a nominal proform that
must be present when DP-internal ellipsis takes place with indefinites, similarly to anaphoric one in English (Günther
2013). 13 Although see Nevins (2007) for an alternative view where 3rd person agreement is not the default. (17)
a.
We, the students, work hard.
b. *One, the students, work hard. the pronouns trigger singular agreement in the syntax
because they are underspecified for phi-features, yet they receive a plural interpretation.11 Hall
(2018), on the other hand, notes that such an ability provides evidence for number neutrality
(at least for impersonal man in Multicultural London English (MLE)). All in all, there is a general
consensus in the literature that impersonals lack person and number specification in the syntax
and that 3rd person singular agreement observed with these pronouns involves default agreement
(Hoekstra 2010; Malamud 2012; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018; Hall 2018). (Malamud 2012:11) 11 Finally, impersonals are often taken to be underspecified for gender. In languages where nouns
are marked for gender (e.g. Italian and French), gender marking on impersonals is unavailable.12
D’Alessandro & Alexiadou (2002), for instance, note that impersonal si in Italian is not specified
for gender, as indicated in the translation of (19). (19)
Italian
Se si è ricchi
si è molto simpatici a
tutti
if
si is rich-pl si is very
nice-pl
to all
‘If one is rich, he/she is very nice for everybody.’ b.
bint
waħdih
girl.fs one.fs
‘One girl.’ (20)
a.
walad
waaħad
boy.ms one.ms
‘One boy.’ 15 Unlike 2nd and 3rd person personal pronouns, both singular and plural 1st person pronouns do not inflect for gender
in JA. (19)
Italian (19)
Italian
Se si è ricchi
si è molto simpatici a
tutti
if
si is rich-pl si is very
nice-pl
to all
‘If one is rich, he/she is very nice for everybody.’ (19)
Italian
Se si è ricchi
si è molto simpatici a
tutti
if
si is rich-pl si is very
nice-pl
to all
‘If one is rich, he/she is very nice for everybody.’ (D’Alessandro & Alexiadou 2002:4) Based on the facts above, several authors adopted the view that 3rd person singular agreement
observed with impersonals reflects the absence of phi-feature specification (Benveniste
1971; Corbett 2006). Thus, 3rd person singular agreement with impersonals involves default
agreement (Hoekstra 2010; Malamud 2012; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018: among
others).13 Based on the facts above, several authors adopted the view that 3rd person singular agreement
observed with impersonals reflects the absence of phi-feature specification (Benveniste
1971; Corbett 2006). Thus, 3rd person singular agreement with impersonals involves default
agreement (Hoekstra 2010; Malamud 2012; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018: among
others).13 In what follows, we zoom in on the the internal feature make-up of imp-waaħad by looking
at the agreement patterns observed with the pronoun. This will enable us to determine whether
imp-waaħad carries any person, number, or gender specification in the syntax. From an etymological perspective, imp-waaħad is derived from the postnominal Arabic
numeral waaħad (one).14 The numeral waaħad inflects for gender: waaħad (one.MSC) is the
masculine form (20a), and waħdih (one.FEM ) is the feminine form (20b). (20)
a. walad
waaħad
boy.ms one.ms
‘One boy.’
b. bint
waħdih
girl.fs one.fs
‘One girl.’ 12 Ritter & Wiltschko (2019) claim that German impersonal man is genderless. As they acknowledge, however, this
claim cannot be empirically motivated since nouns and predicates in German are not marked for gender. Moreover,
the only way to detect gender in German is through determiners and adnominal modifiers which cannot co-occur
with man. 14 The numeral waaħad (one) in Arabic has multiple functions. Alhailawani (2019) shows that waaħad functions as an
indefinite specific marker in prenominal position, similarly to referential this in English (Ionin 2006) and exad (one)
in Hebrew (Borer 2005). Also, Alhailawani (2018; 2022) shows that waaħad functions as a nominal proform that
must be present when DP-internal ellipsis takes place with indefinites, similarly to anaphoric one in English (Günther
2013). (19)
Italian 12 Starting with person, we look at agreement with verbal predicates to see if imp-waaħad carries
any person specification. In JA, verbs agree with personal (referential) subject pronouns in
person, number, and gender, as shown in (21)–(23).15 (21)
a. ana
baħib
il-ijazaat
(1st person)
I.1ms like.1ms the-vacations.fpl
‘I like vacations.’ (1st person) (1st person) (21)
a. ana
baħib
il-ijazaat
(1st person)
I.1ms like.1ms the-vacations.fpl
‘I like vacations.’
b. iħna
binħib
il-ijazaat
we.1pl like.1mpl the-vacations.fpl
‘We like vacations.’ (21)
a. ana
baħib
il-ijazaat
I.1ms like.1ms the-vacations.fpl
‘I like vacations.’ b. iħna
binħib
il-ijazaat
we.1pl like.1mpl the-vacations.fpl
‘We like vacations.’ 2)
a. inta/intii
bitħib/bitħibii
il-ijazaat
(2nd person)
you.2ms/you.2fs like.2ms/like.2fs the-vacations.fpl
‘You (SG) like vacations.’ a. inta/intii
bitħib/bitħibii
il-ijazaat
you.2ms/you.2fs like.2ms/like.2fs the-vacations.fpl
‘You (SG) like vacations.’ (22) (2nd person) b. intuu/intin
bitħibbuu/bitħibbin
il-ijazaat
you.2mpl/you.2fpl
like.2mpl/like.2fpl
the-vacations.fpl
‘You (PL) like vacations.’ bitħibbuu/bitħibbin
il-ijazaat (23)
a. huu/hii
biħib/bitħib
il-ijazaat
(3rd person)
he.3ms/she.3fs
like.3ms/like.3fs the-vacations.fpl
‘He/she likes vacations.’
b. humma/hinnih biħibbuu/biħibbin
il-ijazaat
they.3pl
like.3mpl/like.3fpl the-vacations.fpl
‘They like vacations.’ (23) By contrast, the examples in (24) and (25) show that imp-waaħad uniformly triggers 3rd person
singular masculine agreement on verbal predicates. (24)
il-waaħad
biħib/*biħibbuu
il-ijazaat
the-one.ms like.3ms/like.3mpl the-vacations.fpl
Intended.‘People like vacations.’ (25)
il-waaħad
ʕaana/*ʕaanuu
bisabab
Corona
the-one.ms struggled.3ms/struggled.3mpl
because Corona
Intended.‘People struggled because of Coronavirus.’ Thus far, two observations suggest that imp-waaħad lacks person specification in the syntax. First,
it was shown in section 2.1 that imp-waaħad is unable to pick a specific referent, and as such,
the pronoun can only have a generic reading. Second, the data in (24) and (25) show that imp- 15 Unlike 2nd and 3rd person personal pronouns, both singular and plural 1st person pronouns do not inflect for gender
in JA. 13 waaħad triggers 3rd person singular agreement on verbal predicates. We assume that 3rd person
agreement arises due to the absence of person specification (Benveniste 1971; Corbett 2006). As for number, it is safe to say that imp-waaħad is morphologically singular since it is derived
from the numeral waaħad (one). The question now to consider is whether imp-waaħad is specified
for number in the syntax. To address this question we investigate the possibility of combining
imp-waaħad with a plural reciprocal. As mentioned above, the ability of impersonals to combine
with reciprocals has been taken to be evidence that impersonals are not specified for number
in the syntax (Malamud 2012). Additionally, others assume that such an ability shows that
impersonals are semantically plural (Hoekstra 2010; Ackema & Neeleman 2018), or number
neutral (Hall 2018). Unlike most impersonals, imp-waaħad in JA cannot bind a plural reciprocal,
as seen in (26). (26) *bi-l-ʕeed
il-waaħad
bihanni/bihannuu
baʕd
in-the-Eid the-one.ms congratulate.3ms/congratulate.3mpl each-other
Intended: ‘In Eid (an Islamic holiday), people congratulate each other.’ (26) *bi-l-ʕeed
il-waaħad
bihanni/bihannuu
baʕd
in-the-Eid the-one.ms congratulate.3ms/congratulate.3mpl each-other
Intended: ‘In Eid (an Islamic holiday), people congratulate each other.’ We take this fact to be evidence that imp-waaħad is syntactically specified for singular number. We take this fact to be evidence that imp waaħad is syntactically specified for singular number. We argue that imp-waaħad is endowed with an inherent singular number feature in the syntax. 16 Melisa Rinaldi (pers. comm.) notes that impersonal uno in Spanish cannot bind a plural reciprocal (i), similarly to
imp-waaħad. 17 According to Melisa Rinaldi (pers. comm.), Spanish impersonal uno (one.msc) is the default form used for both male
and female referents. However, the feminine version una (one.fem) is used instead in contexts like (28), as seen in (i). (i)
Spanish
cuando una
esta
embarazada, debe
comer comida saludable
when
one.fs be.3sg pregnant
should eat
food
healthy
Intended: ‘When one (feminine) is pregnant, she must eat healthy food.’ bitħibbuu/bitħibbin
il-ijazaat In (28), for instance, waħdih (one.fem) is specifically used to refer to women in general.17 (28)
il-waħdih
lamma tkuun
ħaamil,
laazim taakul
akil
Siħħi
the-one.fs when
be.3fs pregnant.fs must
eat.3fs food healthy
Intended: ‘When one (feminine) is pregnant, she should eat healthy food.’ (28)
il-waħdih
lamma tkuun
ħaamil,
laazim taakul
akil
Siħħi
the-one.fs when
be.3fs pregnant.fs must
eat.3fs food healthy
Intended: ‘When one (feminine) is pregnant, she should eat healthy food.’ Depending on the speaker, the reading available in the example above could be generic inclusive
or exclusive. Ideally, the reading would be speaker-exclusive when the speaker is a male or a
non-pregnant female. The speaker-exclusive reading available in (28) seems to be problematic
for our claim that imp-waaħad is always speaker-inclusive. However, the availability of such
a reading is unsurprising since it is generally accepted that exceptions are possible in generic
contexts (see Krifka etal., 1995) for detailed discussion of this point). Importantly, the ability of masculine imp-waaħad to refer to both female and male referents
suggests that the pronoun is gender neutral, since masculine is assumed to be the default gender
in Arabic (Alkohlani 2016). However, the example in (28) with waħdih (one.fem) suggests that
a feminine gender feature is present in the syntax. Evidence for this claim comes from gender
agreement on adjectival and verbal predicates. Although imp-waaħad cannot be modified by
adnominal modifiers (e.g. adjectives) (29), the pronoun triggers masculine or feminine gender
agreement on adjectival predicates in copular constructions (30).18 (29)
a. *[il-waaħad il-kaðaab] miš
lazim niθaQ
fii-h
the-one.ms the-liar.ms neg must trust.1mpl in-him.ms
Intended: ‘We should not trust liars.’ b. *[il-waħdih il-kaðaabih] miš
lazim niθaQ
fii-ha
the-one.fs the-liar.fs
neg must trust.1mpl in-her.fs
Intended: ‘We should not trust women who lie.’ 17 According to Melisa Rinaldi (pers. comm.), Spanish impersonal uno (one.msc) is the default form used for both male
and female referents. However, the feminine version una (one.fem) is used instead in contexts like (28), as seen in (i). (i)
S
i h (i)
Spanish
cuando una
esta
embarazada, debe
comer comida saludable
when
one.fs be.3sg pregnant
should eat
food
healthy
Intended: ‘When one (feminine) is pregnant, she must eat healthy food We thank Melisa Rinaldi for providing native speakers’ judgments on Spanish. g
j
g
18 The predicative and attributive uses of adjectives are distinguished in Arabic via definiteness agreement. We thank Melisa Rinaldi for providing native speakers’ judgments on Spanish. We thank Melisa Rinaldi for providing native speakers judgments on Spanish.
18 The predicative and attributive uses of adjectives are distinguished in Arabic via definiteness agreement. Attributive
adjectives agree with the noun in definiteness since they merge DP-internally, whereas predicative adjectives do not. bitħibbuu/bitħibbin
il-ijazaat Our contention here is that singular agreement observed with imp-waaħad does not arise due to
the absence of number specification or due to number neutrality as broadly assumed for other
impersonals, but rather to the presence of a singular number feature in the syntax.16 Nonetheless,
we adopt the mainstream idea that impersonals are semantically plural (Hoekstra 2010; Ackema
& Neeleman 2018). That is, imp-waaħad functions singularly in syntactic agreement (by virtue
of being inherently singular), but is semantically interpreted as referring to people in general,
including the speaker, the addressee, and others. Turning now to gender, imp-waaħad (which is morphologically masculine) refers to both
male and female speakers. The example in (9a) repeated here as (27) is a statement that applies
to people in general, including both males and females. 16 Melisa Rinaldi (pers. comm.) notes that impersonal uno in Spanish cannot bind a plural reciprocal (i), similarly to
imp-waaħad. imp-waaħad. (i)
Spanish
*en España, uno
se
dan
regalos
en Navidad
in Spain,
one.ms each-other give.3pl presents in Christmas
Intended: ‘In Spain, people give each other presents at Christmas.’ (i)
Spanish
*en España, uno
se
dan
regalos
en Navidad
in Spain,
one.ms each-other give.3pl presents in Christmas
Intended: ‘In Spain, people give each other presents at Christmas.’ (i)
Spanish
*en España, uno
se
dan
regalos
en Navidad
in Spain,
one.ms each-other give.3pl presents in Christmas
Intended: ‘In Spain people give each other presents at Christma in Spain,
one.ms each-other give.3pl presents in Christmas Intended: ‘In Spain, people give each other presents at Christmas.’ Given this, one could entertain the idea that impersonals that are derived from the numeral one (e.g. English one and
Spanish uno) are inherently specified as singular in the syntax. If English impersonal one turns out to be unable to
bind a plural reciprocal as noted in Malamud (2012), then such line of reasoning would be sound. We will leave this
for future work. 14 (27)
il-waaħad
laazim yiSħa
bakkiir
the-one.ms must
wake-up.3ms early
‘People must wake up early.’ Moreover, the pronoun can be used by female speakers with a generic inclusive reading despite
being morphologically masculine. In the right context, however, imp-waaħad can inflect for
gender. Table 2 summarizes the JA facts explored in this section: Criterion
imp-waaħad
Person
Ø
Gender
Optional
Morphological Number
SG
Semantic Number
PL
Agreement
3SG
Table 2: Morphosyntax and agreement patterns of imp-waaħad. Table 2: Morphosyntax and agreement patterns of imp-waaħad. The data presented in this section seem to be problematic for the crosslinguistically held
claim that impersonals are not specified for phi-features in the syntax (Egerland 2003; Hoekstra
2010; Malamud 2012; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018: among others). As shown above,
imp-waaħad is underspecified for person, similarly to other impersonals. However, the pronoun
is inherently specified for singular number and also for gender only when feminine. In section 4,
we propose a feature specification that captures the properties of imp-waaħad discussed above. Furthermore, imp-waaħad triggers masculine/feminine agreement on verbs (31). (31)
a. il-waaħad
biħib
il-marʔa
il-SaadiQa
the-one.ms love.3ms the-woman.fs the-honest.fs
Intended: ‘People love honest women.’ b. il-waħdih
bitħib
il-rajul
il-SaadiQ
the-one.fs love.3fs the-man.ms the-honest.ms
Intended: ‘Women love honest men.’ bitħibbuu/bitħibbin
il-ijazaat Attributive
adjectives agree with the noun in definiteness since they merge DP-internally, whereas predicative adjectives do not. The predicative and attributive uses of adjectives are distinguished in Arabic via definiteness agreement. Attributive
adjectives agree with the noun in definiteness since they merge DP-internally, whereas predicative adjectives do not. 15 (30) (30)
a. lamma ykuun
il-waaħad
kaðaab, miš
lazim niθaQ
fii-h
when
be.3ms the-one.ms liar.ms, neg must trust.1mpl in-him.ms
Intended: ‘We should not trust people who lie.’ b. lamma tkuun
il-waħdih
kaðaabih, miš
lazim niθaQ
fii-ha
when
be.3fs the-one.fs liar.fs,
neg must trust.1mpl in-her.fs
Intended: ‘We should not trust women who lie.’ Furthermore, imp-waaħad triggers masculine/feminine agreement on verbs (31). 2.3 Impersonals: Syntactic distribution A number of researchers have noted that impersonals occupy different syntactic positions (Cinque
1988; Egerland 2003; Ackema & Neeleman 2018; Fenger 2018). Fenger (2018), for instance, offers
a case-based division of impersonals in Germanic. Fenger focuses on the syntactic distribution of
dedicated impersonal pronouns in eight Germanic languages, and argues that there are two types 16 of impersonals: (i) imp-ϕ ; and (ii) imp-N. According to Fenger (2018), imp-ϕ can only take on a
generic inclusive reading, and can occur in multiple syntactic position (e.g. English one, Frisian men,
and Icelandic maður). On the other hand, imp-N can have generic and arbitrary readings, but can
only occur with nominative case (e.g. Swedish man, German man, and Dutch men). Fenger (2018)
argues that the difference between the two types boils down to case. More precisely, both types are
structurally defective. However, imp-ϕ pronouns contain an underspecified Person head in their
structure (Ackema & Neeleman 2018), which enables them to project a KP layer. This makes imp-ϕ
eligible to bear any case. On the other hand, imp-N pronouns are simply Ns that lack any phi-feature
specification (Ackema & Neeleman 2018). Consequently, imp-N pronouns are unable to project
a KP layer and can only appear in the nominative form. Fenger (2018) adopts Marantz’s (1991)
dependent case view, and assumes that assignment of nominative case necessitates the absence of
KP (Preminger 2014; Kornfilt & Preminger 2015). The two structures are schematized in (32). (32)
a. imp-ϕ (e.g. English one)
KP
K
ϕP
ϕ
N
b. imp-N (e.g. Dutch men)
N (32)
a. imp-ϕ (e.g. English one)
KP
K
ϕP
ϕ
N
b. imp-N (e.g. Dutch men)
N (Modified from Fenger 2018:309) (Modified from Fenger 2018:309) To elaborate on the division above, we compare the distribution of English one (i.e. an imp-ϕ )
and Dutch men (i.e. an imp-N). Consider the examples in (1) and (2) repeated here as (33) and
(34). (33)
a. When one is in Italy, one eats pasta. (33)
a. When one is in Italy, one eats pasta. b. *One has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about. (Fenger 2018:296–297) b. *One has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about. b. *One has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about. (Fenger 2018:296–297) (34)
a. Dutch
Wanneer men in Italie is, eet men pasta. 19 Fenger (2018) shows that all imp-N pronouns can only occur in the nominative form. However, Fenger notes that
there is a two-way distinction with imp-N pronouns: (i) Swedish man and Dutch men can have a generic or an exist
ential reading in the available positions; (ii) German, Danish and Norwegian man is more restricted than in Dutch and
Swedish. More precisely, an existential reading is unavailable when man is a derived subject. In the interests of space,
we do not provide Fenger’s (2018) examples of imp-ϕ and imp-N as derived subjects in passives and unaccusatives.
Instead, we refer the interested reader to Fenger (2018) for a detailed discussion of this issue. 2.3 Impersonals: Syntactic distribution When
imp in Italy is, eat imp pasta
‘When one is in Italy, one eats pasta.’
b. Man heeft voor je
gebeld, maar ik weet
niet waar het over
ging. imp
has
for
you called
but
I
know not what it
about went
‘Someone has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about.’
(Fenger 2018:296–297)
Fenger (2018) notes that imp-ϕ can only take on a generic inclusive reading, as seen in (33). On the other hand, imp-N can take on both a generic and an existential reading (34). Both (33) (34)
a. Dutch
Wanneer men in Italie is, eet men pasta. When
imp in Italy is, eat imp pasta
‘When one is in Italy, one eats pasta.’
b. Man heeft voor je
gebeld, maar ik weet
niet waar het over
ging. imp
has
for
you called
but
I
know not what it
about went
‘Someone has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about.’
(Fenger 2018:296–297) b. Man heeft voor je
gebeld, maar ik weet
niet waar het over
ging. imp
has
for
you called
but
I
know not what it
about went
‘Someone has called for you, but I don’t know what it was about.’
(F
201 (Fenger 2018:296–297) Fenger (2018) notes that imp-ϕ can only take on a generic inclusive reading, as seen in (33). On the other hand, imp-N can take on both a generic and an existential reading (34). Both (33) 17 and (34) also show that both pronouns can occur as subjects. Additionally, imp-ϕ and imp-N can
occur as derived subjects in passives and unaccusatives, since in both cases the pronouns end up
receiving nominative case.19 and (34) also show that both pronouns can occur as subjects. Additionally, imp-ϕ and imp-N can
occur as derived subjects in passives and unaccusatives, since in both cases the pronouns end up
receiving nominative case.19 Fenger (2018) shows that imp-ϕ can appear in direct object position, whereas imp-N cannot
(also see Cinque 1988; Egerland 2003; Hoekstra 2010 for a similar observation).20 (35)
a. This reminds one of the war. (35)
a. This reminds one of the war. b. Dutch
*Dit
herinnert men aan de
oorlog. This reminds imp of
the war
‘This reminds one of the war.’ b. Dutch (Fenger 2018:298) The restriction on imp-N also holds in other environments where accusative case is assigned. 20 Fenger (2018) notes that all languages with imp-N, except for Dutch, have another pronoun that can occur in obje
position (e.g. einen in German). 21 The existence of true unaccusative verbs in Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) is questionable. Al-Balushi (2011) notes
that crosslinguistically recognized unaccusative verbs (e.g. die, fall, break etc) pattern in Arabic with unaccusative
verbs with respect to some diagnostics (e.g. their unavailability in passives), and with unergative verbs with regard
to other diagnostics (e.g. their availability with cognate objects). Also, the existence of A-movement in MSA is
challenged in Soltan (2007) and Al-Balushi (2011). Whether these verbs are true unaccusative or not, and whether
A-movement exists in MSA or not, the case assigned to the nominal is always nominative. Note that case in MSA is
overtly realized on nouns, whereas in JA and other modern varieties of Arabic case is never realized on nouns. 2.3 Impersonals: Syntactic distribution Fenger (2018) shows that imp-N are unavailable in ECM constructions irrespective of their
reading. In such constructions, the pronoun starts as an external argument in the embedded
clause and ends up receiving accusative case in the main clause. On the other hand, imp-ϕ are
possible in ECM only when generic, since they cannot have an existential reading at all. The
examples in (36) and (37) are generic ECM sentences that involve English one and Dutch men. (36)
Context: He is a station master. Intended: ‘Therefore he always sees people leave for the holidays.’
a. imp-ϕ , generic, ECM. The station master always sees one leave for the holidays.i (36)
Context: He is a station master. Intended: ‘Therefore he always sees people leave for the holidays.’ (36) The station master always sees one leave for the holidays.i (Modified from Fenger 2018:299) (37) (37)
Context: He is a station master. Intended: ‘Therefore he always sees people leave for the holidays.’
a. Dutch
*Daarom
ziet hij men altijd
op vakantie gaan. Therefore sees he imp always on vacation go
(M difi d f
F Therefore sees he imp always on vacation goi Therefore sees he imp always on vacation goi (Modified from Fenger 2018:299) Summing up, the presence vs. absence of KP regulates the syntactic distribution of both imp-ϕ
and imp-N. Thus, it seems clear that besides the different readings impersonals can take on, the
pronouns pattern differently in terms of their syntactic distribution. Summing up, the presence vs. absence of KP regulates the syntactic distribution of both imp-ϕ
and imp-N. Thus, it seems clear that besides the different readings impersonals can take on, the
pronouns pattern differently in terms of their syntactic distribution. 18 18 As concerns the syntactic distribution of imp-waaħad in JA, the data in (38) show that imp-
waaħad can appear in pre- and post verbal subject position. (38)
a. il-waaħad
ʕam
yiʕaani
min
siyaasaat
il-ħukuuma
the-one.ms prog struggle.3ms from policies.fpl the-government.fs
Intended: ‘People are struggling due to the government’s policies.’ b. ʕam
yiʕaani
il-waaħad
min
siyaasaat
il-ħukuuma
prog struggle.3ms the-one.ms from policies.fpl the-government.fs
Intended: ‘People are struggling due to the government’s policies.’ gg
p
g
Intended: ‘People are struggling due to the government’s policies.’ Furthermore, imp-waaħad can appear as a derived subject of passives and unaccusatives, as
shown in (39).21 (39)
a. 22 The JA examples presented in this paper were checked with native speakers of Egyptian, Hijazi, and Iraqi Arabic.
Our informants confirmed that the JA patterns hold in their varieties with some dialectal differences that have no
semantic or syntactic effects (e.g. imp-waaħad is pronounced as waaħid in Egyptian Arabic). 2.3 Impersonals: Syntactic distribution il-waaħad
injabar
yidal
bi-l-beit
ʕašaan
Corona
the-one.ms forced.3ms
stay.3ms in-the-house.ms because Corona
Intended: ‘People were forced to say at home due to Coronavirus.’ bi-l-beit yidal b. bi London,
il-waaħad
biyiwsal
ʕa-l-wagit
ʔiða axad
il-Qitaar
in London, the-one.ms arrives.3ms on-the-time if
take.3ms the-train.ms
Intended: ‘In London, people arrive on time if they take the train.’ As for non-nominative case environments, imp-waaħad can appear as an internal argument (40). As for non-nominative case environments, imp-waaħad can appear as an internal argument (40)
Corona bitzakker
il-waaħad
bi-l-mout
Corona reminds.3fs the-one.ms of-death.ms
Intended: ‘Coronavirus reminds one of death.’ (40)
Corona bitzakker
il-waaħad
bi-l-mout
Corona reminds.3fs the-one.ms of-death.ms
Intended: ‘Coronavirus reminds one of death.’ The same pattern holds for ECM, another construction where the pronoun is assigned accusative
case. The example in (41) shows that imp-waaħad can appear in an ECM construction. (41)
il-ħukuuma
bidha
il-waaħad yidal
bi-l-beit
ʕašaan
Corona
the-government.fs wants.3fs one.ms
stay.3ms
in-the-home.ms because Corona
Intended: ‘The government wants people to stay at home due to Coronavirus.’ Finally, imp-waaħad can be a possessum in a possessive Construct State Construction (CSC), where
the possessum is assigned genitive case (Ritter 1991; Borer 1996; Shlonsky 2004; Alhailawani 2021). Finally, imp-waaħad can be a possessum in a possessive Construct State Construction (CSC), where
the possessum is assigned genitive case (Ritter 1991; Borer 1996; Shlonsky 2004; Alhailawani 2021). (42)
il-šarika
bi-tSalliħ
sayyarit il-waaħad
u
bitrajjiʕha
the-company.fs fixes.3fs car.fs
the-one.ms and return-it.3fs
‘The company fixes one’s car and returns it.’ 19 To sum up, imp-waaħad can appear in positions where nominative, accusative, or genitive case
can be assigned. Table 3 summarizes the JA data discussed in this section.22 Position
imp-waaħad
Subject position
Derived subject
Object position
ECM
Construct State
Table 3: Syntactic distribution of imp-waaħad. Position
imp-waaħad
Subject position
Derived subject
Object position
ECM
Construct State
Table 3: Syntactic distribution of imp-waaħad. Table 3: Syntactic distribution of imp-waaħad. Table 3: Syntactic distribution of imp-waaħad. Table 4: Main properties of imp-waaħad. Table 4: Main properties of imp-waaħad. 23 In the interest of space, we will only review Ackema & Neeleman’s (2018) treatment of singular pronouns. We should
note, however, that for them number is encoded via a Number (NMB) node above PRS. The NMB node contains a fea
ture PL that marks plurality and requires that its input set has a cardinality of more than one. For singular pronouns,
the feature PL is absent from NMB, whereas with plural pronouns PL is present on NMB. See Ackema & Neeleman
(2018) for a detailed discussion of number and its interaction with the person system. 2.4 Summary Table 4 summarizes the properties of JA imp-waaħad: Table 4 summarizes the properties of JA imp-waaħad: arizes the properties of JA imp waaħad:
Reading
imp-waaħad
Generic reading
Existential reading
*
Definite personal (specific)
*
Second Person
*
Agreement and phi-features
Person
Ø
Gender Inflection
Optional
Morphological Number
SG
Semantic Number
PL
Agreement
3SG
Position
Subject position
Derived subject
Object position
ECM
Construct State
20 In the following section, we discuss the theory of person that will lay out the theoretical
foundation for the analysis to be developed to account for imp-waaħad in JA. In the following section, we discuss the theory of person that will lay out the theoretical
foundation for the analysis to be developed to account for imp-waaħad in JA. 3 A theory of person: Ackema & Neeleman (2018) Ackema & Neeleman (2018) propose a person system that involves two main person features:
Proximate (PROX) and Distal (DIST). Following the original insights of Harbour (2016), the
authors take these two feature as being functions that operate over sets. The features are
instantiated in the syntax via a Person node (PRS) that serves as an identity function over sets
provided by the lexical core (dubbed NII) of any pronominal expression. The features take a set as
the input to deliver a subset as the output. The input set, provided by NII, includes all the possible
referents in a given context. To illustrate, the input set in Figure 1 consists of the speaker (i), the
addressee (u), and others (o). The input set Si+u+o also contains a subset consisting of Si+u, which
itself contains another subset Si. Figure 1: The input set of persons (Ackema & Neeleman 2018:23). Figure 1: The input set of persons (Ackema & Neeleman 2018:23). According to Ackema & Neeleman (2018), the feature PROX is a function that operates on
an input set and eliminates its outermost layer. That is, when this feature applies to Si+u+o, the
output is Si+u. On the other hand, when DIST is at play, the feature selects the outermost layer of
its input set. When applied to Si+u+o, the feature yields Si+u+o – Si+u. Ackema & Neeleman (2018)
note that the sets in Figure 1 are ordered in terms of precedence. That is, the subset Si is the
predecessor of the subset Si+u, and at the same time, Si+u is the predecessor of Si+u+o. Ackema & Neeleman (2018) argue that their system can derive the possible persons attested
cross-linguistically.23 For third person singular, the feature DIST derives Si+u+o – Si+u; a set that 21 excludes the speaker and any addressees (43c). As for the second person singular reading, Ackema
& Neeleman note that the reading is generated through the application of both PROX and DIST. First, PROX selects Si+u. This is a set that contains the speaker (and any of their associates) and
individuals that the speaker addresses (and any of their associates). Second, DIST applies to this
set and eliminates Si. The application of DIST leaves only the addressees (and any associates)
as potential referents (43b). Finally, the first person singular reading is generated through the
application of PROX to the output of PROX. 3 A theory of person: Ackema & Neeleman (2018) According to Ackema & Neeleman (2018), applying
PROX to Si+u+o alone will not generate a first person singular reading, because the output would
be Si+u; a set that obligatorily includes the speaker and the addressee. The second application of
PROX eliminates the outermost layer of its input set (i.e. Si+u). As such, the set generated is Si,
which only contains the speaker (43a). (43)
a. 1st person
b. 2nd person
c. 3rd person
PRS
PRS
PROX
PROX
NII
PRS
PRS
PROX
DIST
NII
PRS
PRS
DIST
NII
(Adapted from Ackema & Neeleman 2018:25) (43) (Adapted from Ackema & Neeleman 2018:25) (Adapted from Ackema & Neeleman 2018:25) Ackema & Neeleman (2018) show that their person system can also be extended to account for
impersonals. The authors first distinguish between two types of impersonals: IMP-1 (e.g. English
one, West Frisian men, and Icelandic maður); and IMP-2 (e.g. German man and Dutch men). The
former is exclusively generic, whereas the latter can be generic or existential (see section 2.1
above). For IMP-1, Ackema & Neeleman (2018) propose that such pronouns have the structure in
(44). (44)
a. Generic IMP-1
b. *Arbitrary IMP-1
GNR
PRS
PRS
NII
Gen(x), x ∈Si+u+o
ARB
PRS
PRS
NII
Arb(x), x ∈Si+u+o
(Ackema & Neeleman, 2018:128) b. *Arbitrary IMP-1
ARB
PRS
PRS
NII
Arb(x), x ∈Si+u+o
(Ackema & Neeleman, 2018:128) (44)
a. Generic IMP-1 (45)
a.
Generic IMP-2 (45)
a. Generic IMP-2 NII (Ackema & Neeleman, 2018:122) Under Ackema & Neeleman’s (2018) system, the bare NII delivers the entire input set Si+u+o. Applying GNR to this set derives the generic reading, where a generalization is made over
all relevant people (45a). Ackema & Neeleman (2018) note that applying ARB to the initial
set is also unproblematic since no person specification is encoded in the syntax of IMP-2
(45b). Out of the above discussion, we adopt the idea that impersonals that only give rise to a
generic inclusive reading (e.g. English one) has a structure where an underspecified Person
node projects (44a). imp-waaħad in JA seems to behave similarly to IMP-1 pronouns in terms
of its interpretation and syntactic distribution. Therefore, in the next section we will show that
the structure proposed in Ackema & Neeleman (2018) for IMP-1 can be fruitfully employed in
deriving the main properties of imp-waaħad. (44)
a.
Generic IMP-1 (44)
a. Generic IMP-1 NII (Ackema & Neeleman, 2018:128) (Ackema & Neeleman, 2018:128) Ackema & Neeleman (2018) propose that an IMP-1 has a Person node. However, the person
node, which otherwise contains PROX and/or DIST, is underspecified for any features. According 22 to Ackema & Neeleman (2018), the structure in (44) derives the main properties of IMP-1 (see
section 2). First, the person node, which only introduces an identity function, will deliver the
set Si+u+o. Under Ackema & Neeleman’s (2018) system number marking in NMB is impossible if
the set delivered is Si+u+o (see Ackema & Neeleman (2018) chapters 2 and 3 for more details). The absence of number specification means that such pronouns will trigger default third person
singular agreement. As for interpretation, the generic operator (GNR) can be applied to the
initial set Si+u+o, giving rise to the generic reading. The absence of person features on the PRS
node entails that both the speaker i and the addressee u are included. This also means that such
pronouns cannot have an arbitrary reading that excludes the speaker and addressee. Hence, the
impossibility of (44b). As for IMP-2, Ackema & Neeleman (2018) adopt the original idea of Egerland (2003) that
such pronouns do not carry any person or number specification. This means that IMP-2 pronouns
are bare NII that lack both NMB and PRS, as in (45). (45)
a. Generic IMP-2
b. Arbitrary IMP-2
GNR
NII
Gen(x), x ∈Si+u+o
ARB
NII
Arb(x), x ∈Si+u+o
(Ackema & Neeleman, 2018:122) b. Arbitrary IMP-2 24 In this paper, we do not commit ourselves to any particular ordering of DP-internal phi-features. For simplicity, we
will borrow the label ϕ from Fenger (2018) to collectively represent person, gender (when available with waħdih one.
fem), and number. 4 Deriving imp-waaħad The data discussed in section 2 suggest that Arabic imp-waaħad behaves similarly to English-type
pronouns in terms of its interpretation and syntactic distribution. In this section, we put forward
our analysis of imp-waaħad, building on the analysis of Ackema & Neeleman (2018) introduced
in the previous section. 23 To begin with, we argue that imp-waaħad is an instance of Ackema & Neeleman’s (2018)
IMP-1 (imp-ϕ for Fenger (2018)). Following Ackema & Neeleman, we propose that the pronoun
has a structure where a Person node projects. Moreover, we implement Fenger’s (2018) idea
that IMP-1 pronouns (imp-ϕ) project a KP layer, which enables them to bear any case. Finally,
we argue that imp-waaħad projects a DP layer that is overtly instantiated via the definite article
il- (the). The structure we propose for imp-waaħad is seen in (46).24 (46)
KP
K
DP
D
ϕP
ϕ
N (46)
KP
K
DP
D
ϕP
ϕ
N (46) Additionally, we propose the following feature specification for imp-waaħad: Additionally, we propose the following feature specification for imp-waaħad: 25 See Ritter (1995) for a similar proposal concerning impersonals in Hebrew, where they propose that D encodes def
initeness but not person. (47)
Feature specification of imp-waaħad: (47)
Feature specification of imp-waaħad: (47)
Feature specification of imp-waaħad:
ħ d (
) [
h
l
l
d f] a. waaħad (one.ms): [+human, –plural, +def b. waħdih (one.fem): [+human, –plural, feminine, +def] We take imp-waaħad to be specified as [+human] (Egerland 2003). This feature restricts the
denotation of imp-waaħad to humans. We also propose that imp-waaħad is underspecified for
person in the syntax, similarly to other dedicated impersonals. Our proposal is based on two
observations. First, imp-waaħad can never pick a specific referent. Any example that includes imp-
waaħad is simply a statement that holds generally of all people. Second, imp-waaħad uniformly
triggers 3rd person singular agreement on verbal predicates, which we take to reflect the absence
of person specification (Benveniste 1971; Corbett 2006). Regarding number, we argue that imp-waaħad is inherently specified as singular. The
impossibility of binding a plural reciprocal (see (26) above) further supports our claim that
imp-waaħad is syntactically singular. We assume, following recent literature, that imp-waaħad
is semantically plural since it refers to people in general (Hoekstra 2010; Ackema & Neeleman
2018). As for gender, we assume that masculine imp-waaħad is gender neutral since it is compatible
with both males and females. This amounts to saying that masculine imp-waaħad is not specified
for gender in the syntax. On the other hand, we argue that feminine imp-waaħad is specified
as feminine in the syntax. The presence of a feminine gender feature with waħdih (one.fem) is 24 24 empirically motivated on the basis of agreement on adjectival and verbal predicates (see (30)
and (31) above). Finally, we propose that imp-waaħad is definite, and as such, it projects a DP. We take the
definite article il- (the) to be an overt realization of D. Unlike personal referential pronouns,
however, we take D to encode definiteness and genericity, but not person.25 In section 5, we
provide a number of arguments to show that imp-waaħad behaves as a definite (non-specific)
generic DP. The feature specifications proposed in (47) suggest a rethinking of the radical feature
deficiency approach to impersonals. In particular, we propose that impersonals share the core
property of being underspecified for person. This explains their inability to pick a specific
referent. Nonetheless, the absence of person specification does necessarily entail the absence of
number or gender specification. The agreement patterns observed with JA imp-waaħad strongly
suggest that some impersonals carry number and even gender specification. (47)
Feature specification of imp-waaħad: Now, recall from section 2 that imp-waaħad in JA has the following properties: (48)
Main properties of imp-waaħad in JA
(i)
imp-waaħad has a generic inclusive reading. (ii)
imp-waaħad triggers third person singular agreement. (iii)
imp-waaħad can bear any case (i.e. nominative, accusative, or genitive). (48)
Main properties of imp-waaħad in JA (ii)
imp-waaħad triggers third person singular agreement. (iii)
imp-waaħad can bear any case (i.e. nominative, accusative, or genitive). In what follows, we account for the properties listed in (48). In what follows, we account for the properties listed in (48). Regarding property (i), we adopt Ackema & Neeleman’s (2018) proposal that the [GEN]
operator merges inside the DP. For the time being, we put aside this claim, but come back to discuss
in detail below. Importantly, the application of [GEN] to imp-waaħad yields a generic inclusive
reading, similarly to English one and West Frisian men. The absence of person specification for
imp-waaħad does not conflict with the requirements of [GEN]. Ackema & Neeleman (2018), for
instance, note that a first person singular pronoun can never have a generic reading since it is
specified as [1st person, singular], which contradicts the requirements of [GEN]. For property (ii), the absence of person specification yields default third person agreement
(Benveniste 1971; Corbett 2006). Since imp-waaħad is specified as [-plural], the pronoun triggers
singular agreement. Under Ackema & Neeleman’s (2018) system, this reflects the absence of the
plurality feature in the number projection. In the presence of a feminine gender feature with
waħdih (one.fem), agreement on verbal and adjectival predicates is set to 3rd person feminine. 25 Finally, the presence of a KP projection on top of imp-waaħad accounts for its ability to bear
any case in line with Fenger’s (2018) treatment of English-type pronouns. Thus, property (iii) is
successfully accounted for. Finally, the presence of a KP projection on top of imp-waaħad accounts for its ability to bear
any case in line with Fenger’s (2018) treatment of English-type pronouns. Thus, property (iii) is
successfully accounted for. An important point to underscore here concerns the obligatory presence of the definite article
il- (the) before imp-waaħad, which (as far as we can tell) is not typical of impersonals. We assume
that obligatoriness of the definite article is due to the way the generic reading is negotiated in
Arabic in general.26 The examples in (49) adopted from Fassi-Fehri (2004) show that the generic
reading in Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) is available through the use of the definite article al-,
which is also true of the modern varieties of Arabic. On the other hand, the examples in (50)
show that only an arbitrary (i.e. existential) reading is available in the absence of the definite
article. (48)
Main properties of imp-waaħad in JA Note that both readings are not affected by number marking.27 (49)
a. MSA
al-kalb-u
y-anbaħ-u
the-dog.ms-nom
bark.3ms
‘The dog barks.’
b. al-kilaab-u
t-anbahħ-u
the-dogs.mpl-nom
bark.3fs
‘The dogs bark (Dogs bark).’
(F
i F h i 2004 44) (49)
a. MSA
al-kalb-u
y-anbaħ-u
the-dog.ms-nom
bark.3ms
‘The dog barks.’ (49) b. al-kilaab-u
t-anbahħ-u
the-dogs.mpl-nom
bark.3fs
‘The dogs bark (Dogs bark).’ (Fassi-Fehri 2004:44) (Fassi-Fehri 2004:44) (Fassi-Fehri 2004:44) (50)
a. MSA
kalb-u-n
y-anbaħ-u
dog.ms-nom
bark.3ms
‘A dog is barking.’ (50)
a. MSA
kalb-u-n
y-anbaħ-u
dog.ms-nom
bark.3ms
‘A dog is barking.’ (50) 26 It has long been noted that there is a definiteness restriction on Arabic preverbal subjects. In particular, indefinite
preverbal subjects in Arabic are marginal or even ungrammatical in some varieties, whereas definite preverbal sub
jects are grammatical without any restrictions (see ? and Makkawi (2021)). Therefore, in most varieties of Arabic an
indefinite nominal cannot occur in SVO order unless preceded by expletive fii (there), or if it’s modified by an AP or
a PP (?). Given this, one could entertain the possibility that the obligatory presence of the definite article before imp-
waaħad is due to the definiteness restriction on preverbal subjects. However, it was shown above that imp-waaħad
must bear the definite article when it appears in VSO order as well (see (9b) above). In VSO order, both definite and
indefinite nominals are possible without any restrictions.i 26 It has long been noted that there is a definiteness restriction on Arabic preverbal subjects. In particular, indefinite
preverbal subjects in Arabic are marginal or even ungrammatical in some varieties, whereas definite preverbal sub
jects are grammatical without any restrictions (see ? and Makkawi (2021)). Therefore, in most varieties of Arabic an
indefinite nominal cannot occur in SVO order unless preceded by expletive fii (there), or if it’s modified by an AP or
a PP (?). Given this, one could entertain the possibility that the obligatory presence of the definite article before imp-
waaħad is due to the definiteness restriction on preverbal subjects. However, it was shown above that imp-waaħad
must bear the definite article when it appears in VSO order as well (see (9b) above). In VSO order, both definite and
indefinite nominals are possible without any restrictions.i i
27 Reference to mass generics is another context in which the definite article is obligatory (Fassi-Fehri 2004; 2012). Arabic contrasts with English as far as reference to mass generics is concerned. i
29 As Fassi-Fehri (2009) notes, Arabic is a null subject language that makes use of silent subject pronouns. According to
Fassi-Fehri, this is only possible when the verb bears rich enough inflection to induce the right pronominal interpret
ation. 28 As for exact positioning of [GEN] relative to DP, three options are possible: (i) [GEN] directly merges with the pro
noun (Ackema & Neeleman 2018), (ii) below DP via a GenP as in Fassi-Fehri (2004); or (iii) it could be hypothesized
that a D that is unspecified for person introduces [GEN]. We remain neutral as to which option is viable. (48)
Main properties of imp-waaħad in JA The following example adapted from Fassi-Fehri (2009) illustrates this:29 27 (52)
MSA
fii S-Sahraaʔ-i y-uħibb-uu-na
š-šaay-a
l-muħallaa
in the-sahara
3-like-pl-indf
the-tea-acc the-sugared
‘In the Sahara, they like sweet tea.’ (52) (Fassi-Fehri 2009:8) At closer inspection, however, it seems that aspect affects the reading of an impersonal null
pronoun. For instance, the example in (53a) with imperfective aspect can only be interpreted
generically. So, the example is understood as people in Jordan eat Mansaf (a traditional Jordanian
dish) a lot. On the other hand, the example in (53b) with perfective aspect can only be existential. That is, there is an unspecified group of people who ate Mansaf. (53)
a. bi-l-urdon
kteer
biukluu
Mansaf
in-the-Jordan many eat.3mpl Mansaf
Intended: ‘People in Jordan eat Mansaf a lot.’
b. bi-l-urdon
kteer
ʔakaluu
Mansaf
in-the-Jordan many ate.3mpl Mansaf
Intended: ‘Some group of people ate Mansaf.’ (53)
a. bi-l-urdon
kteer
biukluu
Mansaf
in-the-Jordan many eat.3mpl Mansaf
Intended: ‘People in Jordan eat Mansaf a lot.’ b. bi-l-urdon
kteer
ʔakaluu
Mansaf
in-the-Jordan many ate.3mpl Mansaf
Intended: ‘Some group of people ate Mansaf.’ By contrast, the aspectual specification of the clause does not affect the interpretation of imp-
waaħad. For instance, the example in (54) with perfective aspect can only have a generic inclusive
reading. Likewise, the example in (55) with imperfective aspect has the same reading in (54).30 (54)
il-waaħad
ʕaana
ktiir
bisabab
il-ħajir
the-one.ms struggled.3ms many because the-lockdown.ms
Intended: ‘People struggled a lot due to the lockdown.’ (55)
il-waaħad
ʕam
yiʕaani
ktiir
bisabab
il-ħajir
the-one.ms prog struggle.3ms many because the-lockdown.ms
Intended: ‘People are struggling a lot due to the lockdown.’ Thus, it seems obvious that aspect does not affect the reading of imp-waaħad. This supports our
claim that the generic reading of imp-waaħad is negotiated DP-internally. In the next section, we
provide a number of arguments to show that imp-waaħad behaves syntactically as a definite DP. 30 Following Fassi-Fehri (2012), we assume that perfectivity in Arabic correlates with past tense, whereas imperfectivity
correlates with non-past. (48)
Main properties of imp-waaħad in JA In particular, the definite article has
to be present with mass generics in Arabic (i), but not in English (ii). (i) *(il)-tuffaħ ɣani
bi-l-alyaaf
the-apple rich.ms in-the-fibers.fpl (i) *(il)-tuffaħ ɣani
bi-l-alyaaf (i)
(il)-tuffaħ ɣani
bi-l-alyaaf
the-apple rich.ms in-the-fibers.fpl the-apple rich.ms in-the-fibers.fpl ‘Apples are rich in fiber.’ (ii)
(*The) apples are rich in fiber. 26 b. kilaab-u-n
t-anbaħ-u
dogs.mpl-nom
bark.3fs
‘Dogs are barking.’ (Fassi-Fehri 2004:44) (Fassi-Fehri 2004:44) The above examples clearly show that Arabic generics have to be definite, as such, they must
overtly realize the definite article. Fassi-Fehri (2004) formally captures this by postulating a
Generic Phrase (GenP) below DP that serves to create DP-internal genericity (i.e. D-binding). Putting aside the specifics of Fassi-Fehri’s analysis, the notion of D-binding aligns with Ackema
& Neeleman’s (2018) proposal that generic binding takes place inside the DP.28 The D-binding analysis of imp-waaħad makes the following prediction: if [GEN] binding takes
place DP-internally, as opposed to being introduced at the clause level (i.e. S-binding), then the
generic inclusive reading of imp-waaħad should not be affected by DP-external factors, such
as the aspectual specification of the clause. More precisely, D’Alessandro & Alexiadou (2002)
propose that inclusiveness/exclusiveness of the speaker under the impersonal use of pronouns is
based on aspect specification. Based on the behavior of impersonals in Romance, D’Alessandro &
Alexiadou propose that imperfect aspect triggers a generic reading on impersonals (51a), since
imperfective aspect brings about a generic operator (Chierchia 1995). As such, the speaker might
be optionally included in the impersonal reading. On the other hand, perfective aspect triggers
an obligatory inclusive reading (51b). (51)
a. Italian
In quel ristorante
si mangiava bene
in that restaurant si ate-ipfv
well
‘People used to eat well in that restaurant.’ (GEN)
b. In quel ristorante
si è
mangiato
bene
in that restaurant si is eaten-pfv well
‘We have eaten well in that restaurant.’ (INCL)
(D’Alessandro & Alexiadou 2002:35) (51)
a. Italian
In quel ristorante
si mangiava bene
in that restaurant si ate-ipfv
well
‘People used to eat well in that restaurant.’ (GEN) (D’Alessandro & Alexiadou 2002:35) In Arabic, 3rd person plural null subjects are assumed to be exclusively generic (Fassi-Fehri
2009; 2012). The following example adapted from Fassi-Fehri (2009) illustrates this:29 In Arabic, 3rd person plural null subjects are assumed to be exclusively generic (Fassi-Fehri
2009; 2012). 31 The idea that impersonals project a DP is not new. Hall (2018) argues that MLE man is a true definite and projects
a DP. Hall’s (2018) primary motivation for the projection of D is to account for man’s resistance to binding of any
sort (e.g. generic and anaphoric binding). Additionally, MLE’s man can be interpreted as any person and number
combination (1SG, 1PL, 2SG, 2PL, 3SG, 3PL). Hall (2018) argues that D obligatorily projects and introduces an epsi
lon operator (Egli & von Heusinger 1995; Heusinger 2004) that binds the variable over the set introduced by the
pronoun. The epsilon operator on D blocks any further external binding by operators like [GEN].if 32 Hoekstra (2010) provides examples where definite generic DPs in Frisian can also show QVE effects. Hoekstra (2010:51)
concludes that “the QVE test seems to distinguish, not between definite and indefinite, but rather between specific
and non-specific”. Moreover, Chierchia (1995) notes that even definite DPs can sometimes show QVE effects in some
contexts in English. Due to space limitations, we will not discuss the examples both authors provide here. Instead, we
refer the interested reader to Hoekstra (2010) and Chierchia (1995) for a detailed discussion of these observations. 5 The definiteness of imp-waaħad Typically, dedicated impersonals are classified as either indefinite (Condoravdi 1989; Moltmann
2006; Malamud 2012), definite (Kratzer 1997; Alonso-Ovalle 2002; Hoekstra 2010; Hall 2018),
or a-definite (Koenig & Mauner 1999; Zobel 2016). In this section, we rely on existing and new 28 tests of syntactic definiteness and show that imp-waaħad exhibits the properties of a typical
definite generic DP.31 Hoekstra (2010) argues that impersonals are the pronominal equivalents of generic DPs. Hoekstra shows that impersonals pass the usual syntactic definiteness tests, and concludes that
that pronouns are definite, but non-specific. In what follows, we will use some the diagnostics of
syntactic definiteness introduced in Hoekstra (2010). One diagnostic that is usually used to distinguish between definite and indefinite expressions
is Quantificational Variability Effects (QVE) with adverbs of quantification like often and usually
(Lewis 1975). In their discussion of Frisian impersonal men, Hoekstra (2010) uses QVE to
determiner whether men is a definite or an indefinite-like expression. The Frisian examples in
(56) show that (in)definiteness of the noun studint (student) yields different quantificational
effects for the adverb usually. In particular, the example in (56a) with the indefinite DP in studint
(a student) shows QVE effects, such that the example is understood as ‘most smart students are
proud’. That is, the adverb quantifies over the variable introduced by the indefinite noun. On the
other hand, the example in (56b) with the definite noun de studint (the student) is understood as
‘a certain student’s intelligence and pride mostly fluctuate together’. Hoekstra (2010) shows that
Frisian impersonal men is an indefinite-like expression since it shows QVE effects (57), similarly
to the indefinite expression in (56a).32 (56)
a. Frisian
At in studint
tûk
is, is er ornaris grutsk. If
a student smart is, is he usually proud
‘If a student is smart, he is usually proud.’
(QVE) b. At de
studint
tûk
is, is er ornaris grutsk. If
the student smart is, is he usually proud
‘If the student is smart, he is usually proud.’
(*QVE) (Hoekstra 2010:51) (Hoekstra 2010:51) 31 The idea that impersonals project a DP is not new. Hall (2018) argues that MLE man is a true definite and projects
a DP. Hall’s (2018) primary motivation for the projection of D is to account for man’s resistance to binding of any
sort (e.g. generic and anaphoric binding). 5 The definiteness of imp-waaħad Additionally, MLE’s man can be interpreted as any person and number
combination (1SG, 1PL, 2SG, 2PL, 3SG, 3PL). Hall (2018) argues that D obligatorily projects and introduces an epsi
lon operator (Egli & von Heusinger 1995; Heusinger 2004) that binds the variable over the set introduced by the
pronoun. The epsilon operator on D blocks any further external binding by operators like [GEN].if 29 (57)
Frisian
At men tûk
is, is men ornaris
grutsk. If
one smart is, is one usually proud
‘If one is smart, one is usually proud.’
(QVE reading: ‘Most smart people are proud.’) (Hoekstra 2010:51) (Hoekstra 2010:51) Applying this diagnostic to JA imp-waaħad shows that the pronoun does not show QVE effects. Like the definite description il-Taalib (the student) in (58a), the example in (58b) containing imp-
waaħad can only mean that one’s intelligence and pride fluctuate together. (58)
a. ʔiða kaan
il-Taalib
ðaki,
ʕadatan bikuun
faxuur
if
was.ms the-student.ms smart.ms, usually be.3ms proud.ms
‘If the student is smart, he is usually proud.’
(*QVE) b. ʔiða kaan
il-waaħad
ðaki,
ʕadatan bikuun
faxuur
if
was.ms the-one.ms smart.ms, usually be.3ms proud.ms
‘If one is smart, he is usually proud.’
(*QVE) Another argument that shows the definiteness of imp-waaħad comes from existential-fii
constructions in JA. As in English existential there-constructions (Kayne 2008), the subject of
an existential fii clause must be indefinite (Abdel-Ghafer & Jarbou 2015). The example in (59)
shows that the noun walad (boy) can appear as the subject of an existential fii clause only when
it is indefinite. (59)
fii
(*il)-walad
saʔal
ʕann-ak
EXP (the)-boy.ms asked.3ms about-you
Intended:‘A boy asked about you.’ Imp-waaħad cannot appear in the same environment in (59), as evidenced from the
ungrammaticality of (60). Imp-waaħad cannot appear in the same environment in (59), as evidenced from the
ungrammaticality of (60). (60) *fii
il-waaħad
saʔal
ʕann-ak
EXP the-one.ms asked.3ms about-you
Intended: ‘Someone asked about you.’ (60) *fii
il-waaħad
saʔal
ʕann-ak
EXP the-one.ms asked.3ms about-you
Intended: ‘Someone asked about you.’ ʕann-ak Finally, if imp-waaħad is indeed a definite DP, it is predicted that it can be coordinated with a full
DP. This prediction is borne out in (61). Finally, if imp-waaħad is indeed a definite DP, it is predicted that it can be coordinated with a full
DP. This prediction is borne out in (61). DP. This prediction is borne out in (61). DP. This prediction is borne out in (61). 5 The definiteness of imp-waaħad (61)
il-waaħad
u
mart-uh
laazim yinaaQšuu
mašaakil-hum
the-one.ms and wife-his must
discuss.3mpl problem-their
Intended: ‘A man and his wife must discuss their problems.’ mašaakil-hum 30 Summarizing, the above facts suggest that imp-waaħad syntactically behaves as a definite
DP.33 Following Hoekstra (2010), we assume that both personal and impersonal pronouns are
definite and that the difference between the two types boils down to specificity (Givón 1978). In particular, Hoekstra (2010) proposes that impersonals are definite (like personal pronouns)
in that they generically refer to the whole ensemble of persons that is familiar to everyone. However, the difference between personal and impersonal pronouns is that personal pronouns
can be either specific or non-specific (i.e. the speaker has/does not have a particular person(s) in
mind), whereas impersonals are always non-specific.34 That is, the speaker does not refer to any
particular person(s) when using an impersonal generic pronoun. The same is also true of imp-
waaħad in JA. It seems clear that, by using imp-waaħad, the speaker does not have the intention
to refer to any particular person(s). Thus, we conclude that imp-waaħad is a non-specific definite
DP. 34 See Hoyt (2009) for a discussion of specificity in Arabic. 33 Although we proposed a different feature specification for feminine imp-waaħad (i.e. waħdih ‘one.fem’), all the
examples introduced in this section are possible with the pronoun.i 34 See Hoyt (2009) for a discussion of specificity in Arabic. Acknowledgements We thank two anonymous Glossa reviewers for their helpful comments and suggestions. 6 Conclusion The purpose of this paper was twofold: (i) to investigate the morphosyntax of imp-waaħad
in JA and its implications for the cross-lingusitic typology of impersonals, and (ii) to argue
that a radical feature deficiency approach to impersonals does not hold for JA imp-waaħad. For (i), we showed that imp-waaħad behaves similarly to English-type impersonals in terms of
its interpretation and syntactic distribution. In particular, imp-waaħad can only have generic
inclusive reading and can appear in multiple syntactic positions. To capture this behavior, we
adopted the structure proposed in Ackema & Neeleman (2018) for English-type impersonals and
its specific implementation in Fenger (2018) where it is argued that pronouns that are exclusively
generic project a KP, and as such, can bear any case. Additionally, we argued that imp-waaħad
is best analyzed as a definite (non-specific) generic DP. Our claim was empirically motivated on
the basis of several diagnostics of syntactic definiteness. As for (ii), we investigated agreement patterns with imp-waaħad to determine its internal
feature make-up. We showed that whereas imp-waaħad is underspecified for person, the pronoun
is always specified for singular number and for also feminine gender in some contexts. The JA
data suggest a rethinking of the radical feature deficiency approach to impersonals. In particular,
we proposed that impersonals share the core property of being underspecified for person. Nonetheless, the absence of a person feature does necessarily entail the absence of number or
gender specification. 31 Abbreviations 1 = first person, 2 = second person, 3 = third person, m = masculine, f = feminine, sg =
singular, pl = plural, neg = negation, gen = generic, ext = existential, prog = progressive,
ipfv = imperfective, pfv = perfective, acc = accusative, nom = nominative, indf = indefinite,
incl = inclusive Competing Interests The authors have no competing interests to declare. References Abdel-Ghafer, Osama & Jarbou, Samer. 2015. An existential expletive: fii of Jordanian Arabic. Folia Linguistica 49(1). 159–184. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/flin-2015-0005 Abdel-Ghafer, Osama & Jarbou, Samer. 2015. An existential expletive: fii of Jordanian Arabic. Folia Linguistica 49(1). 159–184. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/flin-2015-0005 Ackema, Peter & Neeleman, Ad. 2018. A grammar of person. Cambridge: MIT Press. DOI: https://
doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/11145.001.0001 Al-Balushi, RashidAli. 2011. Case in Standard Arabic: The untraveled paths. Toronto: University of
Toronto dissertation. Alhailawani, Mohammad. 2018. Nominal structure and ellipsis in Jordanian Arabic. London: Queen
Mary University of London dissertation. Alhailawani, Mohammad. 2019. Indefinite and not-so-indefinite DPs in Jordanian Arabic. SKASE
Journal of Theoretical Linguistics 16(4). 48–64. Alhailawani, Mohammad. 2021. Against a uniform analysis of adnominal possessives in Jordanian
Arabic: Evidence from nominal ellipsis. Poznan Studies in Contemporary Linguistics 57(3). 359–
395. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/psicl-2021-0015 Alhailawani, Mohammad. 2022. Unifying ellipsis and pronominalization in Jordanian Arabic. Studia Linguistica 76(3). 791–836. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/stul.12196 Alkohlani, Fatima. 2016. The problematic issue of grammatical gender in Arabic as a foreign
language. Journal of Language and Cultural Education 4(1). 17–28. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/
jolace-2016-0002 g
g
jolace-2016-0002 Alonso-Ovalle, Luis. 2002. Arbitrary pronouns are not that indefinite. In Beyssade, Claire &
Bok-Bennema, Reineke & Drijkoningen, Frank & Monachesi, Paola (eds.), Romance languages
and linguistic theory: Selected papers from going romance, 1–14. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1075/cilt.232.02alo Benveniste, Émile. 1971. The nature of pronouns. In Gables, Coral (ed.), Problems in general
linguistics, 217–222. Miami: University of Miami Press. 32 32 Borer, Hagit. 1996. The construct in review. In Lecarme, Jacqueline & Lowenstamm, Jean
& Shlonsky, Ur (eds.), Studies in Afroasiatic Grammar, 30–61. The Hague: Holland Academic
Graphics. Borer, Hagit. 1996. The construct in review. In Lecarme, Jacqueline & Lowenstamm, Jean
& Shlonsky, Ur (eds.), Studies in Afroasiatic Grammar, 30–61. The Hague: Holland Academic
Graphics. Borer, Hagit. 2005. In name only: Structuring sense. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI: https://
doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199263905.001.0001 Cardinaletti, Anna & Starke, Michal. 1999. The typology of structural deficiency: A case study
of the three classes of pronouns. In van Riemsdijk, Henk (ed.), Clitics in the languages of europe,
145–234. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110804010.145 Chierchia, Gennaro. 1995. The variability of impersonal subjects. In Bach, Emmon & Jelinek,
Eloise & Kratzer, Angelika & Partee, Barbara (eds.), Quantification in natural languages, 107–143. Dordrecht: Kluwer. Cinque, Guglielmo. 1988. On Si constructions and the theory of Arb. Linguistic inquiry 19(4). 521–581. Condoravdi, Cleo. 1989. Indefinite and generic pronouns. In Fee, E. Jane & Hunt, Katherine
(eds.), Proceedings of the eigth west coast conference on formal linguistics (wccfl). 71–84. Corbett, GrevilleG. 2006. Agreement. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. D’Alessandro, Roberta & Alexiadou, Artemis. 2002. Inclusive and exclusive impersonal pronouns:
A feature-geometrical analysis. Rivista di Grammatica Generativa 27. 31–44. Egerland, Verner. 2003. Impersonal pronouns in Scandinavian and Romance. Working Papers in
Scandinavian Syntax 71. 75–102. Egli, Urs & von Heusinger, Klaus. 1995. The epsilon operator and E-type pronouns. In Egli, Urs
& Pause, Peter & Schwarze, Christoph & von Stechow, Arnim & Wienold, Götz (eds.), Lexical
knowledge in the organisation of language, 121–146. Amsterdam: Benjamins. DOI: https://doi. org/10.1075/cilt.114.07egl Fassi-Fehri, Abdelkader. 2004. Nominal classes, reference, and functional parameters, with
particular reference to Arabic. Linguistic variation yearbook 4(1). 41–108. DOI: https://doi. org/10.1075/livy.4.03feh Fassi-Fehri, Abdelkader. 2009. Arabic silent pronouns, person, and voice. Brill’s Journal
of Afroasiatic Languages and Linguistics 1(1). 3–40. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/1876663
09X12526624903239 Fassi-Fehri, Abdelkader. 2012. Key features and parameters in Arabic grammar. John Benjamins
Publishing Company. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1075/la.182 Fenger, Paula. 2018. How impersonal does one get? The Journal of Comparative Germanic
Linguistics 21(3). 291–325. g
g
jolace-2016-0002 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10828-018-9101-0 Givón, Talmy. 1978. Definiteness and referentiality. In Greenberg, Joseph & Ferguson, Charles
& Moravcsik, Edith (eds.), Universals of human language, 291–330. Stanford: Stanford University
Press. Günther, Christine. 2013. The elliptical noun phrase in English: Structure and use, vol.16. Routledge. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203076194 33 Hall, David. 2018. The impersonal gets personal: A new pronoun in Multicultural London English. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 38. 117–150. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11049-019-
09447-w Harbour, Daniel. 2016. Impossible persons. Cambridge: MIT Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7551/
mitpress/9780262034739.001.0001 Heusinger, Klausvon. 2004. Choice functions and the anaphoric semantics of definite NPs. Research on language and Computation 2(3). 309–329. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11168-004-
0904-6 Hoekstra, Jarich. 2010. On the impersonal pronoun men in Modern West Frisian. The Journal
of Comparative Germanic Linguistics 13(1). 31–59. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10828-010-
9036-6 Holmberg, Anders. 2005. Is there a little pro? Evidence from Finnish. Linguistic inquiry 36(4). 533–564. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1162/002438905774464322 Holmberg, Anders. 2010. The null generic subject pronoun in Finnish: A case of incorporation
in T. In Biberauer, Theresa & Holmberg, Anders & Roberts, Ian & Sheehan, Michelle (eds.),
Parametric variation: Null subjects in minimalist theory, 200–230. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511770784.006 Holmberg, Anders & Phimsawat, On-Usa. 2015. Generic pronouns and Phi-features: Evidence
from Thai. In Newcastle and northumbria working papers in linguistics, vol.21. 55–71. Hoyt, Frederick. 2009. Specificity. In Eid, Mushira & Elgibali, Alaa & Woidich, Manfred & Zaborski,
Andrzej (eds.), Encyclopedia of Arabic Language and Linguistics, 315–320. Leiden: E.J. Brill.iiii Ionin, Tania. 2006. This is definitely specific: Specificity and definiteness in article systems. Natural language semantics 14(2). 175–234. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11050-005-5255-9 Kayne, Richard. 2008. Expletives, datives, and the tension between morphology and syntax. In
Biberauer, Theresa (ed.), The limits of syntactic variation, vol. 132, 175–217. Amsterdam: John
Benjamins. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1075/la.132.07kay Koenig, Jean-Pierre & Mauner, Gail. 1999. A-definites and the discourse status of implicit
arguments. Journal of Semantics 16(3). 207–236. Kornfilt, Jaklin & Preminger, Omer. 2015. Nominative as no case at all: An argument from
raising-to-accusative in Sakha. In Joseph, Andrew & Predolac, Esra (eds.), Proceedings of the 9th
workshop on altaic formal linguistics (wafl 9). 109–120. Cambridge MA: Vol. 76 of MIT working
papers in linguistics. Kratzer, Angelika. 1997. German impersonal pronouns and logophoricity. Berlin: Handout, Sinn
und bedeutung. Krifka, Manfred & Pelletier, Francis & Carlson, Gregory & ter Meulen, Alice & Chierchia, Gennaro
& Link, Godehard. 1995. Genericity: An introduction. In Carlson, Gregory & Pelletier, Francis
(eds.), The generic book, 1–24. g
g
jolace-2016-0002 Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. Lewis, David. 1975. Adverbs of quantification. In Keenan, Edward (ed.), Formal semantics of
natural language, 3–15. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/
CBO9780511897696.003 34 34 Makkawi, Amani. 2021. Preverbal subjects in Makkan Arabic: A feature-inheritance approach. Manitoba: University of Manitoba Winnipeg dissertation. Malamud, Sophia. 2012. Impersonal indexicals: one, you, man, and du. The Journal of Comparative
Germanic Linguistics 15(1). 1–48. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10828-012-9047-6 Marantz, Alec. 1991. Case and licensing. In Westphal, Germán & Ao, Benjamin & Chae, Hee-Rahk
(eds.), Proceedings of escol ’91. 234–253. Ohio State University Department of Linguistics. Moltmann, Friederike. 2006. Generic one, arbitrary PRO, and the first person. Natural language
semantics 14(3). 257–281. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11050-006-9002-7 Nevins, Andrew. 2007. The representation of third person and its consequences for person-case
effects. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 25(2). 273–313. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/
s11049-006-9017-2 Preminger, Omer. 2014. Agreement and its failures. Cambridge: MIT Press. DOI: https://doi. org/10.7551/mitpress/9780262027403.001.0001 Ritter, Elizabeth. 1991. Two functional categories in noun phrases: Evidence from Modern
Hebrew. In Rothstein, Susan (ed.), Syntax and semantics 25: Perspectives on phrase structure, 37–62. New York: Academic Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004373198_004 Ritter, Elizabeth. 1995. On the syntactic category of pronouns and agreement. Natural Language
and Linguistic Theory 13(3). 405–443. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00992737 Ritter, Elizabeth & Wiltschko, Martina. 2019. Nominal speech act structure: Evidence from
the structural deficiency of impersonal pronouns. The Canadian Journal of Linguistics/La revue
canadienne de linguistique 64(4). 709–729. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/cnj.2019.10 Shlonsky, Ur. 2004. The form of Semitic noun phrases. Lingua 114(12). 1465–1526. DOI: https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.lingua.2003.09.019 Siewierska, Anna. 2011. Overlap and complementarity in reference impersonals: Manconstructions
vs. third person plural-impersonals in the languages of europe. In Malchukov, Andrej & Siewierska,
Anna (eds.), Impersonal constructions: A crosslinguistic perspective, 57–90. Amsterdam: Benjamins. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1075/slcs.124.03sie Soltan, Usama. 2007. On formal feature licensing in minimalism: Aspects of Standard Arabic
morphosyntax. Maryland: University of Maryland dissertation. Zeijlstra, Hedde. 2015. Let’s talk about you and me. Journal of Linguistics 51(2). 465–500. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022226714000474 Zobel, Sarah. 2016. On the (in)definiteness of impersonal pronouns. Linguistica 56(1). 363–374. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4312/linguistica.56.1.363-374
|
https://openalex.org/W2621454852
|
https://escholarship.org/content/qt51j2b643/qt51j2b643.pdf?t=owjcot
|
English
| null |
Fluorescent tagged episomals for stoichiometric induced pluripotent stem cell reprogramming
|
Stem cell research & therapy
| 2,017
|
cc-by
| 6,543
|
UCSF
UC San Francisco Previously Published Works
Title
Fluorescent tagged episomals for stoichiometric induced pluripotent stem cell
reprogramming
Permalink
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/51j2b643
Journal
Stem Cell Research & Therapy, 8(1)
ISSN
1757-6512
Authors
Schmitt, Christopher E
Morales, Blanca M
Schmitz, Ellen MH
et al.
Publication Date
2017-12-01
DOI
10.1186/s13287-017-0581-7
Peer reviewed UCSF
UC San Francisco Previously Published Works
Title
Fluorescent tagged episomals for stoichiometric induced pluripotent stem cell
reprogramming
Permalink
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/51j2b643
Journal
Stem Cell Research & Therapy, 8(1)
ISSN
1757-6512
Authors
Schmitt, Christopher E
Morales, Blanca M
Schmitz, Ellen MH
et al. Publication Date
2017-12-01
DOI
10.1186/s13287-017-0581-7
Peer reviewed UCSF
UC San Francisco Previously Published W
Title
Fluorescent tagged episomals for stoichiometric induced p
reprogramming
Permalink
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/51j2b643
Journal
Stem Cell Research & Therapy, 8(1)
ISSN
1757-6512
Authors
Schmitt, Christopher E
Morales, Blanca M
Schmitz, Ellen MH
et al. Publication Date
2017-12-01
DOI
10.1186/s13287-017-0581-7
Peer reviewed * Correspondence: Edward.Hsiao@ucsf.edu; Ann.Zovein@ucsf.edu
2Eli and Edythe Broad Center of Regeneration Medicine and Stem Cell
Research, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA
1Cardiovascular Research Institute, University of California San Francisco, San
Francisco, CA 94158, USA
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © The Author(s). 2017 Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to
the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver
(http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated. METHOD METHOD Abstract Background: Non-integrating episomal vectors have become an important tool for induced pluripotent stem
cell reprogramming. The episomal vectors carrying the “Yamanaka reprogramming factors” (Oct4, Klf, Sox2, and
L-Myc + Lin28) are critical tools for non-integrating reprogramming of cells to a pluripotent state. However, the
reprogramming process remains highly stochastic, and is hampered by an inability to easily identify clones that
carry the episomal vectors. Methods: We modified the original set of vectors to express spectrally separable fluorescent proteins to allow
for enrichment of transfected cells. The vectors were then tested against the standard original vectors for
reprogramming efficiency and for the ability to enrich for stoichiometric ratios of factors. eprogramming efficiency and for the ability to enrich for stoichiometric ratios of factors. Results: The reengineered vectors allow for cell sorting based on reprogramming factor expression. We show
that these vectors can assist in tracking episomal expression in individual cells and can select the reprogramming
factor dosage. Results: The reengineered vectors allow for cell sorting based on reprogramming factor expression. We show
that these vectors can assist in tracking episomal expression in individual cells and can select the reprogramming
factor dosage. Conclusions: Together, these modified vectors are a useful tool for understanding the reprogramming process
and improving induced pluripotent stem cell isolation efficiency. Keywords: Induced pluripotent stem cells, Reprogramming, Pluripotent stem cells, Episomals, Yamanaka factors, OKSM Keywords: Induced pluripotent stem cells, Reprogramming, Pluripotent stem cells, Episomals, Yamana ed pluripotent stem cells, Reprogramming, Pluripotent stem cells, Episomals, Yamanaka factors, OKSM Fluorescent tagged episomals for
stoichiometric induced pluripotent stem
cell reprogramming Christopher E. Schmitt1, Blanca M. Morales2,3, Ellen M. H. Schmitz1, John S. Hawkins1, Carlos
Joan P. Zape1, Edward C. Hsiao2,3* and Ann C. Zovein1,4* Christopher E. Schmitt1, Blanca M. Morales2,3, Ellen M. H. Schmitz1, John S. Hawkins1, Carlos O. Lizama1,
Joan P. Zape1, Edward C. Hsiao2,3* and Ann C. Zovein1,4* Powered by the California Digital Library
University of California eScholarship.org Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132
DOI 10.1186/s13287-017-0581-7 Open Access Background has been shown to be important in reprogramming pro-
cesses [7–9]. It was recently shown that high Oct4/Klf4
and lower Sox2/c-Myc created iPS colonies more effi-
ciently and of a higher quality [10]. The higher quality
iPS colonies are considered more ES-like and have been
shown to perform better in tetraploid complementation
and chimerism assays. One attribute of an ES-like state
is the retention of expression at the Dlk1–Dio3 locus
[11]. This imprinted region is often fully silenced in iPS
cell clones. Genes within this locus have been shown to
be differentially expressed when comparing ES with iPS
cell colonies [11, 12]. It is therefore desirable to directly
recover iPS cell colonies that are ES-like in repro-
gramming efforts. One of the major challenges in the creation of induced
pluripotent stem cells has been the low efficiency of the
reprogramming process. Since the initial findings that
somatic cells can become pluripotent after enforced ex-
pression of Oct4, Sox2, Klf, and c-Myc [1], modifiers
such as Lin28 and Nanog [2], p53 knockdown [3], and
the substitution of L-Myc for c-Myc [4, 5] have been
used to improve reprogramming efficiency from the
initial reports [6]. Direct control and verification of the plasmid dosage
taken up by a cell may be important for different aspects
of reprogramming. The ratio of reprogramming factors Although there are a large number of reprogramming
systems available, the use of fluorescent reporters to
mark individual reprogramming factors has not been
applied widely. In this study, we tailored the Yamanaka Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Page 2 of 9 episomal vectors (Oct3/4, Klf4, Sox2, L-Myc + Lin28. and p53 shRNA) [5] to also express separable fluores-
cent proteins. This strategy allows for direct assessment
of plasmid dosage and for the sorting of successfully
transfected cells for improved programming. In addition,
it provides a tool to track episomal expression in real
time through cell imaging of the surrogate fluorescent
proteins. Generation of Sox2 + CMV:eGFP and Klf4 + CMV:E2Crimson
(Addgenes 27078 and 38770) vectors The pCXLE-hUL + CMV:mTAGBFP2 vector was digested
with EcoRI to remove the Lin28-2A-L-Myc ORF and was
replaced with either Sox2 or Klf4 PCR-generated ORFs. After amplification and sequencing of the vectors, they
were then cut with XhoI and AgeI (New England Biolabs)
to remove the mTAGBFP2 ORF and replaced with
either E2-Crimson or eGFP, generated by PCR with
compatible ends. Generation of pCXLE-hOCT3/4-shp53 + CMV:mCherry-2A-
Puro (Addgene 27080) and pCXLE-hUL + CMV:mTAGBFP2
(Addgene 54572) vectors Generation of pCXLE-hOCT3/4-shp53 + CMV:mCherry-2A-
Puro (Addgene 27080) and pCXLE-hUL + CMV:mTAGBFP2
(Addgene 54572) vectors Generation of pCXLE-hOCT3/4-shp53 + CMV:mCherry-2A-
Puro (Addgene 27080) and pCXLE-hUL + CMV:mTAGBFP2
(Addgene 54572) vectors The expression cassette of CMV:mCherry-2A-Puro was
PCR amplified with addition of FseI and AsiSI (New
England Biolabs) restriction sites. The CMV:mCherry-
2A-puro expression cassette was then directionally
cloned into the Oct4/p53 + FA MCS vector. For the
L-Myc-2A-Lin28 mTagBFP2 vector, FseI and AsiSI
sites
were
also
used
to
directionally
insert
a
CMV:mTAGBFP2-bGHpA expression cassette. Transfection The modified plasmids were purified using the Qiagen
Endotoxin-free Maxi-prep kit. Transfection into human
foreskin fibroblasts (UCSF cell culture facility, catalog num-
ber CCLZR211, log number MB3145, passages 9–20) was
performed using the Neon Transfection system as de-
scribed previously [13]. Lines carrying the transfected fac-
tors were designated with O (Oct3/4 + shp53), K (KLF4), S
(Sox2), or M (L-Myc + Lin28) respectively, using uppercase
or lowercase to designate high or low fluorescence. After
electroporation, cells were plated onto Bovine bovine colla-
gen I (Corning)-coated dishes in recovery medium (DMEM
H21 with 10% FBS without antibiotics). Medium was chan-
ged the next day to DMEM with 10% FBS and 1× penicil-
lin/streptomycin for continued culture into iPS cells. After
4 days, cells were gradually transitioned to mTesR iPS cell
media as described previously [13]. Modification of pCXLE-hOCT3/4-shp53-F (Addgene 27077)
and pCXLE-hUL (Addgene 27080) vectors (L-myc/Lin28)
To generate a new multiple cloning site (MCS), oligonu-
cleotides 5′-agatcgcgatcgcagggccggccatcgatag-3′ and 5′-
ctatcgatggccggccctgcgatcgcatcgatct-3′ were annealed and
then restriction digested with ClaI restriction enzyme
(New England Biolabs). The ClaI-digested MCS insert
was then purified by NaOAc precipitation. Plasmid
vectors were digested with ClaI, treated with alkaline
phosphatase (New England Biolabs), and gel-purified
using the Qiagen Gel extraction kit. The MCS insert
and plasmid backbone was then treated with T4 DNA
ligase (New England Biolabs). The resulting ligation re-
actions were then transformed using Top10 competent
cells (Life Technologies) and selected with ampicillin. The resulting colonies were mini-prepped (Qiagen)
and screened for linearization by FseI and AsiSI en-
zymes (New England Biolabs). The resulting intermedi-
ate plasmids were termed “Oct4/p53 + FA MCS” and
“L-myc/Lin28 + FA MCS”. Cloning of tagged episomal plasmids Cloning of tagged episomal plasmids
Fluorescent protein expression cassettes were generated
using PCR (NEB Phusion) and restriction enzyme-
mediated cloning. From original plasmid vectors, the
single ClaI site in the vector backbone was modified
into a ClaI-FseI-AsiSI-ClaI multiple cloning site. The
Sox2 and Klf4 coding sequences from the original
Sox2-2A-Klf4 sequence were separated by PCR (NEB
Phusion), adding flanking EcoRI sites and a new stop
codon for Sox2. Cell culture
All
S
ll All iPS cell lines showed normal karyotyping or com-
parative genomic array analysis (Cell Line Genetics). iPS
cells were maintained on feeder cells (SNLs) with hESC
medium (Knockout DMEM, 20% Knockout Serum Re-
placement, 1× sodium pyruvate, 1× non-essential amino
acids, 1× Glutamax, 0.5× penicillin/streptomycin solu-
tion, 0.1 mM 2-mercaptoethanol) supplemented with
10 ng/ml bFGF as described previously [13]. On passage
11 the cells started their transition to mTesr1 with in-
creasing ratios of hESC medium:mTesr1: 1:3, then 1:1
on passage 12, 3:1 on passage 13, and finally feeder-free
conditions on passage 14 on Matrigel-coated plates and
mTesr1
media
(StemCell
Technologies, Vancouver,
Canada). Every time the cells were split, the medium
was supplemented with 10 μM Y-27632. Embryoid
bodies for assessment of differentiation capacity were
generated as described previously [13]. All iPS work
was approved by the UCSF Human Gamete, Embryo,
and Stem Cell Research Committee (GESCR) and the
UCSF Committee for Human Research. Fluorescence-facilitated identification of transfected
populations To allow identification of each key Yamanaka reprogram-
ming factor [5], we first separated the Oct4 (+ shp53),
KLF4, Sox2, and L-Myc (+ Lin28) open reading frames
and added a fluorescent protein expression cassette. Vec-
tors are designated by letters: (O) Oct3/4, shp53 and
mCherry, (K) Klf4 and E2Crimson, (S) Sox2 and eGFP,
and (M) L-Myc, Lin28, and BFP (Fig. 1a). The fluorescent
proteins allow identification of cells that take up all four
episomals, as well as cells that contain one, two, or three
episomals, as observed by confocal microscopy (Fig. 1b). The tagged episomal set also allowed for cell sorting
and enrichment of cells successfully transfected with
all four episomal plasmids (OKSM; Fig. 1c; flow Flow cytometry Human foreskin fibroblast lines transfected with the
plasmids were sorted on a BD FACS Aria3 at the lowest
flow rate of “1” with a 130-μM sort nozzle to maintain
viability. Vector Red alkaline phosphatase staining kit (Vector
Labs) or Live AP (Life Technologies) at 1:100 dilution;
Stainalive Tra-1-60 antibody (09-0068; Stemgent) at
1:200; and mouse monoclonal Oct3/4 antibody (sc-5279;
Santa Cruz) 1:100 dilution with Alexa Fluor® 594 Donkey
anti-mouse secondary at 1:300 dilution were used. Anti-
body incubations were performed at 4 °C. Cells were
counter-stained with DAPI in PBS and imaged in PBS. Statistical analysis In order to designate high (OKSM) vs low (oksm)
fluorescent expression in our transfected populations
(Figs. 3, 4), the median fluorescence value (MFV) of
each fluorophore was calculated using BD FACSDiva
software. The positive-gated population for each fluor-
escent protein was used to calculate the respective
MFV. To then determine the high vs low positive popu-
lations, the coefficient of variation (CV%) of the posi-
tively gated population (automatically calculated by BD
FACSDiva software) was calculated. The CV% is the
ratio of the standard deviation to the mean, which mea-
sures population dispersion. High and low fluorescence
designations were then determined by setting gates out-
side a perimeter of 1% CV from the MFV. The bottom-
left corner of the high gate and the top-right corner of
the low gate were placed at (+1,+1) and (–1,–1), re-
spectively, from the MFV. In this instance, the MFV is
the center origin (0,0) and the units of the X and Y axes
are CV% (Fig. 4b). Reprogramming efficiencies were compared using a p value
determined by the Mann–Whitney t test. qPCR of OKSM
and fluorescent proteins was analyzed by both two-tailed
t test and ANOVA (see Additional file 1: Table S2). Fluorescence intensity (MFI) was compared with mRNA
copy number via liner regression (R2). Relative expres-
sion of MEG3 was measured via Student’s t test. p ≤0.05
was considered statistically significant. OKSM sorting strategy The original sorting strategy was to select cells positive
for all four episomals (OSKM) per traditional gating
depicted in Fig. 1c. Cell lines Human foreskin fibroblasts were sourced from the
UCSF cell culture facility (catalog number CCLZR211, Page 3 of 9 Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 log number MB3145, passages 9–20). The BJ2 wildtype
iPS cell line, previously generated from BJ foreskin fi-
broblasts commercially available from ATCC (catalog
number ATCC CRL-2522), were used as a control [13]. Assessment of reprogramming efficiency Reprogramming efficiency was calculated as the number
of iPS colonies at day 22 divided by the number of
cells sorted/plated on day 5.5 (Fig. 2a), and expressed
as a percentage. Gene expression analysis (qRT-PCR) p
y
q
RNA was extracted using the Qiagen RNeasy Micro kit. cDNA was generated using the Superscript VILO Mas-
termix from Thermo Fischer. Primer sequences are pre-
sented in Additional file 1: Table S1. For copy number
quantitation, a 10-fold dilution series of the appropriate
plasmid was used to correlate copy number to cT and
also used to calculate the efficiency of the primers [13]. Each reaction was run in triplicate on a Viia7 Real-Time
PCR System (Life Technologies) and normalized to
GAPDH as an endogenous control. Teratoma formation iPS cells were grown on Matrigel-coated plates with
mTesr1 until reaching 90% confluency. The cells were
injected into the testes of CB-17/SCID mice (Charles
River) as described previously [13]. Tumors were harvested
8–12 weeks after the procedure. Three teratomas for
OKSM and four teratomas for OKSM NE were analyzed. Embryoid bodies Embryoid bodies were generated as described previously
[13]. The EBs were maintained until day 15 and harvested
for RNA extraction in TriReagent (Sigma Aldrich). hiPSC sorting strategy Flow
cytometric percentages of OKSM populations were simi-
lar regardless of the order of fluorescent selection by
FACS (Additional file 1: Figure S2A). Both microscopy
and flow cytometric analyses revealed that a significant
number of cells express fewer than four plasmids after
transfection (Fig. 1c). cytometric controls depicted in Additional file 1: Figure
S1). Expression of the fluorophores was also possible in
live cell cultures (Additional file 1: Figure S1E). Flow
cytometric percentages of OKSM populations were simi-
lar regardless of the order of fluorescent selection by
FACS (Additional file 1: Figure S2A). Both microscopy
and flow cytometric analyses revealed that a significant
number of cells express fewer than four plasmids after
transfection (Fig. 1c). Fibroblasts receiving tagged episomes allow for FACS
enrichment and increased efficiency of reprogramming hiPSC sorting strategy For sorting of mature, passage 9+ iPS cells, Tra-1-60
(Stemgent) antibody was used in conjunction with DAPI
for live/dead discrimination (see Additional file 1: Figure
S4 for gating example). A total of 1000–2000 cells were
sorted per iPS cell clone. Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Page 4 of 9 cytometric controls depicted in Additional file 1 Figure
Fibroblasts receiving tagged episomes allow for FACS
Fig. 1 Fluorescent tagged episomal vectors allow for enrichment of OKSM-positive cells. a Schematic of engineered reprogramming episomal
plasmids. Fluorescent protein expression cassettes were inserted downstream of the reprogramming factor expression cassettes, indicated by color. b Tiled laser-scanning confocal maximum projections capture the heterogeneity of episome-carrying cells. Confluent human foreskin fibroblasts at
2 days post transfection of plasmids are shown. Arrowheads indicate cells with discrepant levels of fluorescent proteins, significantly favoring expression
of one episome over another. Scale bars = 150 μM. c FACS discrimination of the OKSM population. Left: whole population (black) gated for mCherry
(Oct 3/4) (O) and E2-Crimson (Klf4) (K). The double-positive population (OK) is shown in Quadrant 2 (red). Right: whole population (black) and OK (red),
subsequently gated for eGFP (Sox2) (S) and mTAGBFP2 (L-Myc-2A-Lin28) (M). Cyan contours designate the OKSM population (Color figure online). OKSM Oct3/4 + shp53, Klf, Sox2, and L-Myc + Lin28 Fig. 1 Fluorescent tagged episomal vectors allow for enrichment of OKSM-positive cells. a Schematic of engineered reprogramming episomal
plasmids. Fluorescent protein expression cassettes were inserted downstream of the reprogramming factor expression cassettes, indicated by color. b Tiled laser-scanning confocal maximum projections capture the heterogeneity of episome-carrying cells. Confluent human foreskin fibroblasts at
2 days post transfection of plasmids are shown. Arrowheads indicate cells with discrepant levels of fluorescent proteins, significantly favoring expression
of one episome over another. Scale bars = 150 μM. c FACS discrimination of the OKSM population. Left: whole population (black) gated for mCherry
(Oct 3/4) (O) and E2-Crimson (Klf4) (K). The double-positive population (OK) is shown in Quadrant 2 (red). Right: whole population (black) and OK (red),
subsequently gated for eGFP (Sox2) (S) and mTAGBFP2 (L-Myc-2A-Lin28) (M). Cyan contours designate the OKSM population (Color figure online). OKSM Oct3/4 + shp53, Klf, Sox2, and L-Myc + Lin28 cytometric controls depicted in Additional file 1: Figure
S1). Expression of the fluorophores was also possible in
live cell cultures (Additional file 1: Figure S1E). Fibroblasts receiving tagged episomes allow for FACS
enrichment and increased efficiency of reprogramming We compared the reprogramming efficiency of fibro-
blasts transfected with either our four tagged episomals
or with the original untagged Yamanaka episomal set
[14] consisting of three episomal plasmids containing
programming factors and one episomal with an eGFP
tracer. Cells were sorted on day 5.5 for all four fluores-
cent tags, or for the eGFP tracer alone. The isolated Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Page 5 of 9 Fig. 2 Enrichment of OKSM by FACS generates phenotypic iPS colonies. a Schematic for reprogramming with sorting enrichment, with the FACS
enrichment occurring on day 5.5. b Reprogramming efficiency of sorted cells. N > 4 for each condition. Original unmodified Yamanaka episomal
plasmids, NE non-enriched, OKSM cells reprogrammed using our tagged episomal vectors. p value determined by Mann–Whitney t test. Non-significant
(ns) values left to right: p = 0.13, p = 0.37; **p = 0.002. c Immunohistochemistry for pluripotency markers on iPS cell colonies from quadruple-positive
OKSM sorts showing positivity for markers: Oct3/4, alkaline phosphatase (AP), and Tra-1-60. Cells were stained at passage 8 (approximately day 60
post transfection). d Episomal-derived iPS cell embryoid body (EB) formation. iPS cells were transitioned from feeders to Matrigel and finally into
EB differentiation media. Top: iPS cells on SNL feeder cells. Middle: iPS cells transitioned to feeder free conditions. Bottom: EBs at day 8 of differentiation. Scale bar = 200 μm. e Hematoxylin and eosin staining of teratoma sections showing representatives of the three germinal layers (yellow arrows). Scale
bar = 200 μm (Color figure online). iPSC induced pluripotent stem cell, OKSM Oct3/4 + shp53, Klf, Sox2, and L-Myc + Lin28 Fig. 2 Enrichment of OKSM by FACS generates phenotypic iPS colonies. a Schematic for reprogramming with sorting enrichment, with the FACS
enrichment occurring on day 5.5. b Reprogramming efficiency of sorted cells. N > 4 for each condition. Original unmodified Yamanaka episomal
plasmids, NE non-enriched, OKSM cells reprogrammed using our tagged episomal vectors. p value determined by Mann–Whitney t test. Non-significant
(ns) values left to right: p = 0.13, p = 0.37; **p = 0.002. c Immunohistochemistry for pluripotency markers on iPS cell colonies from quadruple-positive
OKSM sorts showing positivity for markers: Oct3/4, alkaline phosphatase (AP), and Tra-1-60. Cells were stained at passage 8 (approximately day 60
post transfection). d Episomal-derived iPS cell embryoid body (EB) formation. Fibroblasts receiving tagged episomes allow for FACS
enrichment and increased efficiency of reprogramming iPS cells were transitioned from feeders to Matrigel and finally into
EB differentiation media. Top: iPS cells on SNL feeder cells. Middle: iPS cells transitioned to feeder free conditions. Bottom: EBs at day 8 of differentiation. Scale bar = 200 μm. e Hematoxylin and eosin staining of teratoma sections showing representatives of the three germinal layers (yellow arrows). Scale
bar = 200 μm (Color figure online). iPSC induced pluripotent stem cell, OKSM Oct3/4 + shp53, Klf, Sox2, and L-Myc + Lin28 cells were then evaluated for ability to generate iPS
cell-like colonies per previous protocols [14] (Fig. 2a). Unsorted cells run through a sorter but not selected/
enriched for fluorescence (not enriched (NE)) were used
as a control. when enriching for tagged cells containing all four
OKSM factors). The use of tagged episomals resulted in
a reprogramming efficiency of approximately 0.03%
(Fig. 2b, Additional file 1: Table S1). A subset of colonies generated by fluorescent selection
of OKSM was evaluated at passage 8 (approximately
60 days post transfection) for pluripotency markers. These cells expressed Tra-1-60, AP, and endogenous
Oct3/4 (Fig. 2c). In addition, colonies generated from
sorted OKSM formed all three germ layers in embryoid
body formation (Fig. 2d) and in vivo teratoma assays
(Fig. 2e). The generated iPS cells and EBs were evaluated
via qPCR, which validated iPS pluripotent gene expres-
sion and germ layer gene expression after differentiation
(Additional file 1: Figure S3). Quantitation of alkaline phosphatase (AP)-positive col-
onies (Additional file 1: Figure S2B) showed that the
overall reprogramming efficiency of the MB132 foreskin
fibroblasts, without FACS enrichment, were equivalent
between the original Yamanaka plasmids and our tagged
episomal plasmids, but lower than reported previously
for other cell types. The introduction of FACS enrich-
ment increased the efficiency of alkaline phosphate-
positive colonies (trend when using GFP to enrich the
original plasmids, vs statistically significant improvement Page 6 of 9 Page 6 of 9 Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Fluorescent tagged episomals allow for sorting on
factor dosage levels of all four fluorescent proteins (designated OKSM);
and one population with low but positive fluorescence as
compared with controls (designated oksm; Fig. 3a). We found a striking range of fluorescent intensities
present in the positive population (OKSM), suggesting
that individual cells take up a wide range of episome
dosages. To understand the effect of dosage on repro-
gramming, we selected for cells exhibiting high or low
levels of fluorescence and correlated the intensity of fluor-
escence to reprogramming factor expression. Populations
were sorted into two subsets: one population with high Microscopy demonstrated that OKSM cells exhibited
brighter fluorescence in all channels as compared with the
dimmer oksm cells; unexpectedly, levels of each fluores-
cent protein varied per OKSM cell (Fig. 3b). Transcripts
for each exogenous reprogramming factor were quantified
in addition to fluorescent protein transcripts, and there
was a significant difference in expression levels between Fig. 3 Fluorescence intensity correlates with reprogramming factor transcription levels, and allows for discrimination between high and low
levels of O, K, S, and M. a Gating strategy for discriminating high vs low fluorescence. Single cells out of 10,000 events are shown. Gates are
drawn according to the process described in Methods. The top two FACS plots show single events. The bottom two plots are the ok and OK
populations (low vs high OK expression), respectively (blue vs green plots). Gates delineating the sm and SM populations are shown. Percentages
shown are relative to the parental gates. b Laser-scanning confocal images of transfected HFFs after sorting for negative, low fluorescence (oksm),
and high fluorescence (OKSM) on day 6 confirm the output of FACS. c Quantification of exogenous mRNA by qRT-PCR. HFFs sorted for negative,
low, and high fluorescence were assayed by qPCR directly after sorting. Each target was significantly different between groups, p < 0.005. Error
bars represent SEM. R2 > 0.987 for all mRNA copy numbers vs mean fluorescence intensity values. d Mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) of individual
sorts measured during flow vs mRNA copy number per cell measured by qRT-PR of corresponding Yamanaka/Fluorescent reporter sets. Each
point represents one biological replicate (Color figure online). OKSM Oct3/4 + shp53, Klf, Sox2, and L-Myc + Lin28 Fig. 3 Fluorescence intensity correlates with reprogramming factor transcription levels, and allows for discrimination between high and low
levels of O, K, S, and M. a Gating strategy for discriminating high vs low fluorescence. Fluorescent tagged episomals allow for sorting on
factor dosage Single cells out of 10,000 events are shown. Gates are
drawn according to the process described in Methods. The top two FACS plots show single events. The bottom two plots are the ok and OK
populations (low vs high OK expression), respectively (blue vs green plots). Gates delineating the sm and SM populations are shown. Percentages
shown are relative to the parental gates. b Laser-scanning confocal images of transfected HFFs after sorting for negative, low fluorescence (oksm),
and high fluorescence (OKSM) on day 6 confirm the output of FACS. c Quantification of exogenous mRNA by qRT-PCR. HFFs sorted for negative,
low, and high fluorescence were assayed by qPCR directly after sorting. Each target was significantly different between groups, p < 0.005. Error
bars represent SEM. R2 > 0.987 for all mRNA copy numbers vs mean fluorescence intensity values. d Mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) of individual
sorts measured during flow vs mRNA copy number per cell measured by qRT-PR of corresponding Yamanaka/Fluorescent reporter sets. Each
point represents one biological replicate (Color figure online). OKSM Oct3/4 + shp53, Klf, Sox2, and L-Myc + Lin28 Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Page 7 of 9 Fig. 4 (See legend on next page.) Fig. 4 (See legend on next page.) Fig. 4 (See legend on next page.) Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Page 8 of 9 (See figure on previous page.)
Fig. 4 Reprogramming factor dosage selected via flow cytometry impacts iPS cell phenotype. a Schematic detailing procedure for isolating
colonies reprogrammed with various plasmid dosages. As previously, cells are reprogrammed using our tagged episomal set. Plasmids were also
titrated to favor the isolation of OKsm cells (see Methods). Prior to qRT-PCR, clones were passaged eight times to promote stable colonies. Sorting
for the pluripotency marker Tra-1-60 and subsequent qRT-PCR for hMEG3 are subsequently performed. b Representative sort and gating strategy
for isolating OKsm cells. Here, the ‘sm’ (low blue and green) population was 2.83% of the ‘OK’ (high red and far red) population or 0.11% of the
total single events. c Reprogramming efficiency of OKSM vs OKsm sorted cells. N > 3, not significantly different p value. Error bars represent SEM. p = 0.15. d. Expression by qRT-PCR of the imprinted gene hMEG3 at passage 9 post reprogramming within the Tra-1-60+ population of cells (rela-
tive expression to GAPDH). Fluorescent tagged episomals allow for sorting on
factor dosage Cells reprogrammed with OKsm (red bars) and OKSM (purple) are shown, each different clone designated by a letter or
number. Dashed lines represent mean of each group. Clone names reflect the reprogramming method. N = 10 clones, p = 0.041. Error bars repre-
sent SEM (Color figure online). OKSM Oct3/4 + shp53, Klf, Sox2, and L-Myc + Lin28 OKSM, oksm, and negative populations (Fig. 3c). To-
gether there was a high correlation of transcript expres-
sion to fluorescence. Gene expression was compared with
the corresponding fluorescent protein mean fluorescence
intensity (MFI; Fig. 3d), and showed less correlation
among the three biological replicates per group. These
populations showed a proportionate mRNA copy number
per cell as estimated by qPCR (Fig. 3c, d). of transfected cells, evaluation of transfection efficiency
and heterogeneity, and the ability to enrich for popula-
tions with specific stoichiometry via cell sorting. Also, the
fluorescent tagged episomals can allow for monitoring the
status of all four episomes, and therefore present a viable
method of screening out undesirable clones. While other
groups have generated similar tools using lentiviral vectors
[8, 16], our system provides traceable non-integrating epi-
somal vectors. Although constitutive lentiviral vectors are
silenced in hiPSC clones [8], they are known to leave a
genomic “footprint” and demonstrate lower rates of aneu-
ploidy as compared with episomals [17, 18]. Our study
demonstrates an application of the individually marked epi-
somal plasmids to select OKsm iPS colonies, and showed
that these colonies maintained higher expression of MEG3,
the human homolog of Gtl2, a gene within an imprinted
locus that corresponds to ES cell-like iPS colonies with im-
proved performance in pluripotency assays [10–12]. These
results indicate that improved efficiency of iPS cell gener-
ation from human foreskin fibroblasts may be improved by
a higher ratio of the OK to SM factors. In addition, the use
of FACS purification may improve the yield of iPS cells by
decreasing the number of cells that pick up one, two, or
three of the plasmids, rather than all four. A high Oct3/4/Klf4 to Sox2/Myc ratio preserves
expression of the Dlk1–Dio3 locus in human cells Colonies after multiple passages were sorted for Tra-1-60
(Additional file 1: Figure S4) and then evaluated for
MEG3 (murine Gtl2) expression (Additional file 1: Tables
S2–S4). OKsm colonies exhibited higher expression of
MEG3 than OKSM colonies (Fig. 4d), indicating that the
elevated OK to SM ratio has benefit for imprinting at the
hallmark Dio3 locus in human cells. Discussion Additional file 1: presents supplementary figures and tables. (DOCX 3644 kb) Here we described a toolkit for the generation of
integration-free human iPS cells. The original Yamanaka
episomal factors [14] were revised to separate them, and
fluorescent protein reporters were added. We found that
these fluorescent proteins do not interfere with the repro-
gramming process, and allowed for real-time visualization Additional file 1: presents supplementary figures and tables. (DOCX 3644 kb) Conclusion The fluorescent tagged episomal vectors allow for non-
integrative iPS reprogramming while allowing for con-
trolled Yamanaka factor stoichiometry. The system also
gives the ability to monitor episomal expression in live
cells by surrogate fluorescent detection. These new
fluorescent-tagged episomal plasmids will useful to the
stem cell community for improved selection and moni-
toring during iPS programming. A high Oct3/4/Klf4 to Sox2/Myc ratio preserves
expression of the Dlk1–Dio3 locus in human cells expression of the Dlk1 Dio3 locus in human cells
The tagged episomal plasmids allow cells with negative,
low, and high fluorescence to be purified. Because the
fluorescence intensity correlates with reprogramming
factor mRNA expression, we used our system to test
whether cell populations with a high dosage of “OK” and
low dosage of “SM” (designated OKsm; Fig. 4a, b) could
still preserve expression of the Dlk1–Dio3 locus, because
an ES-like state is correlated with Dlk1–Dio3 levels [11]. OKsm cells were less prevalent in the transfected popu-
lation. We titrated the respective plasmids for collection
of sufficient numbers of these cells. A hallmark of OKsm
cells in the mouse is the retention of expression at the
Dlk1–Dio3 locus [10] where the expression of gene Gtl2
within the locus can act as a surrogate for locus imprint-
ing [11, 12, 15]. We evaluated expression of the human
homolog of murine Gtl2, MEG3. Sorted OKsm cells were
able to reprogram at similar efficiency to OKSM (Fig. 4c). Colonies after multiple passages were sorted for Tra-1-60
(Additional file 1: Figure S4) and then evaluated for
MEG3 (murine Gtl2) expression (Additional file 1: Tables
S2–S4). OKsm colonies exhibited higher expression of
MEG3 than OKSM colonies (Fig. 4d), indicating that the
elevated OK to SM ratio has benefit for imprinting at the
hallmark Dio3 locus in human cells. The tagged episomal plasmids allow cells with negative,
low, and high fluorescence to be purified. Because the
fluorescence intensity correlates with reprogramming
factor mRNA expression, we used our system to test
whether cell populations with a high dosage of “OK” and
low dosage of “SM” (designated OKsm; Fig. 4a, b) could
still preserve expression of the Dlk1–Dio3 locus, because
an ES-like state is correlated with Dlk1–Dio3 levels [11]. OKsm cells were less prevalent in the transfected popu-
lation. We titrated the respective plasmids for collection
of sufficient numbers of these cells. A hallmark of OKsm
cells in the mouse is the retention of expression at the
Dlk1–Dio3 locus [10] where the expression of gene Gtl2
within the locus can act as a surrogate for locus imprint-
ing [11, 12, 15]. We evaluated expression of the human
homolog of murine Gtl2, MEG3. Sorted OKsm cells were
able to reprogram at similar efficiency to OKSM (Fig. 4c). Ethics approval and consent to participate 14. Okita K, Nakagawa M, Hyenjong H, Ichisaka T, Yamanaka S. Generation
of mouse induced pluripotent stem cells without viral vectors. Science. 2008;322:949–53. iPS cells were derived from commercially available human foreskin fibroblast
lines as detailed in the Methods section. All iPS work was approved by the
UCSF Human Gamete, Embryo, and Stem Cell Research Committee (GESCR)
and the UCSF Committee for Human Research (IRB number 13-11789). All
mouse studies were approved by the UCSF Institutional Animal Care and
Use Committee (IACUC) (protocol number AN107468-03). 15. Sommer CA, Stadtfeld M, Murphy GJ, Hochedlinger K, Kotton DN,
Mostoslavsky G. Induced pluripotent stem cell generation using a
single lentiviral stem cell cassette. Stem Cells. 2009;27:543–9. 16. Tiemann U, Sgodda M, Warlich E, Ballmaier M, Schöler HR, Schambach A, et
al. Optimal reprogramming factor stoichiometry increases colony
numbers and affects molecular characteristics of murine induced
pluripotent stem cells. Cytometry A. 2011;79:426–35. Abbreviations CV: Coefficient of variation; EB: Embryoid body; hESC: Human embryonic
stem cell; hiPSC: Human induced pluripotent stem cell; iPS: Induced
pluripotent stem; OKSM: Oct3/4 + shp53, Klf4, Sox2, and L-Myc + Lin28 Page 9 of 9 Page 9 of 9 Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Schmitt et al. Stem Cell Research & Therapy (2017) 8:132 Availability of data and materials Episomal plasmids are submitted to the Addgene repository (#74944, #74945,
#74946, #74947) and will be made available upon publication. 9. Yamaguchi S, Hirano K, Nagata S, Tada T. Sox2 expression effects on direct
reprogramming efficiency as determined by alternative somatic cell fate. Stem Cell Res. 2011;6:177–86. Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. 17. Rao MS, Malik N. Assessing iPSC reprogramming methods for their suitability
in translational medicine. J Cell Biochem. 2012;113:3061–8. 18. Schlaeger TM, Daheron L, Brickler TR, Entwisle S, Chan K, Cianci A, et al. A
comparison of non-integrating reprogramming methods. Nat Biotechnol. 2015;33:58–63. Funding 7. Miyashita K, Miyatsuka T, Matsuoka T-A, Sasaki S, Takebe S, Yasuda T, et al. Sequential introduction and dosage balance of defined transcription factors
affect reprogramming efficiency from pancreatic duct cells into insulin-
producing cells. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2014;444:514–9. This work was supported by the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine
(RN3-06479, to ACZ), the FOP Developmental Grants Program at the Center for
Research in FOP and Related Disorders (to ECH), and the UCSF Core Laboratory
for Cell Analysis supported by the National Cancer Institute Cancer Center
Support Grant (5P30CA082103). 8. Papapetrou EP, Tomishima MJ, Chambers SM, Mica Y, Reed E, Menon J, et
al. Stoichiometric and temporal requirements of Oct4, Sox2, Klf4, and
c-Myc expression for efficient human iPSC induction and differentiation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009;106:12759–64. Acknowledgements
h
h
ld l k 6. Tanabe K, Nakamura M, Narita M, Takahashi K, Yamanaka S. Maturation, not
initiation, is the major roadblock during reprogramming toward pluripotency
from human fibroblasts. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2013;110:12172–9. Available
from: http://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pubmed&
amp;id=23812749&retmode=ref&cmd=prlinks. g
The authors would like to acknowledge the UCSF Core Laboratory for Cell
Analysis, and Ajay Chawla MD, PhD for use of his laboratory flow cytometer. The authors would like to acknowledge the UCSF Core Laboratory for Cell
Analysis, and Ajay Chawla MD, PhD for use of his laboratory flow cytometer. Author’s information
Not applicable. Author’s information
Not applicable. 12. Sindhu C, Samavarchi-Tehrani P, Meissner A. Transcription Factor-mediated
Epigenetic Reprogramming. The Journal of Biological Chemistry. 2012;
287(37):30922-31. doi:10.1074/jbc.R111.319046. Author details
1 1Cardiovascular Research Institute, University of California San Francisco, San
Francisco, CA 94158, USA. 2Eli and Edythe Broad Center of Regeneration
Medicine and Stem Cell Research, University of California San Francisco, San
Francisco, CA, USA. 3Division of Endocrinology and Metabolism, Institute for
Human Genetics, Department of Medicine, University of California San
Francisco, San Francisco, CA 94143, USA. 4Division of Neonatology,
Department of Pediatrics, University of California San Francisco School of Department of Pediatrics, University of California San Francisco School of
Medicine, San Francisco, CA 94143, USA. Received: 24 March 2017 Revised: 28 April 2017
Accepted: 8 May 2017 Received: 24 March 2017 Revised: 28 April 2017
Accepted: 8 May 2017 Received: 24 March 2017 Revised: 28 April 2017
Accepted: 8 May 2017 Competing interests Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. 13. Matsumoto Y, Hayashi Y, Schlieve CR, Ikeya M, Kim H, Nguyen TD, et al. Induced pluripotent stem cells from patients with human fibrodysplasia
ossificans progressiva show increased mineralization and cartilage formation. Orphanet J Rare Dis. 2013;8:190. Authors’ contributions
CES
d ACZ d
i
d 10. Carey BW, Markoulaki S, Hanna JH, Faddah DA, Buganim Y, Kim J, et al. Reprogramming factor stoichiometry influences the epigenetic state and
biological properties of induced pluripotent stem cells. Cell Stem Cell. 2011;9:588–98. CES and ACZ designed and planned experiments, with advisement from
ECH. CES, BMM, and EMHS performed the experiments, with assistance from
JSH, JPZ, and COL. CES and ACZ wrote the manuscript, with significant
editing by ECH. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. 11. Stadtfeld M, Apostolou E, Akutsu H, Fukuda A, Follett P, Natesan S, et al. Aberrant silencing of imprinted genes on chromosome 12qF1 in mouse
induced pluripotent stem cells. Nature. 2010;465:175–81. References 1. Takahashi K, Yamanaka S. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from
mouse embryonic and adult fibroblast cultures by defined factors. Cell. 2006;126:663–76. 1. Takahashi K, Yamanaka S. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from
mouse embryonic and adult fibroblast cultures by defined factors. Cell. 2006;126:663–76. 1. Takahashi K, Yamanaka S. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from
mouse embryonic and adult fibroblast cultures by defined factors. Cell. 2006;126:663–76. Submit your next manuscript to BioMed Central
and we will help you at every step: • We accept pre-submission inquiries
• Our selector tool helps you to find the most relevant journal
• We provide round the clock customer support
• Convenient online submission
• Thorough peer review
• Inclusion in PubMed and all major indexing services
• Maximum visibility for your research
Submit your manuscript at
www.biomedcentral.com/submit
and we will help you at every step: 2. Yu J, Hu K, Smuga-Otto K, Tian S, Stewart R, Slukvin II, et al. Human induced
pluripotent stem cells free of vector and transgene sequences. Science. 2009;324:797–801. 2. Yu J, Hu K, Smuga-Otto K, Tian S, Stewart R, Slukvin II, et al. Human induced
pluripotent stem cells free of vector and transgene sequences. Science. 2009;324:797–801. • We accept pre-submission inquiries 3. Hong H, Takahashi K, Ichisaka T, Aoi T, Kanagawa O, Nakagawa M, et al. Suppression of induced pluripotent stem cell generation by the p53-p21
pathway. Nature. 2009;460:1132–5. 4. Nakagawa M, Takizawa N, Narita M, Ichisaka T, Yamanaka S. Promotion of
direct reprogramming by transformation-deficient Myc. Proc Natl Acad Sci
U S A. 2010;107:14152–7. 5. Okita K, Matsumura Y, Sato Y, Okada A, Morizane A, Okamoto S, et al. A more efficient method to generate integration-free human iPS cells. Nat Meth Nat Res. 2011;8:409–12.
|
https://openalex.org/W4214923002
|
https://www.scielo.br/j/edur/a/MRBhfLcyM9ZVBhMvMMvNhTN/?lang=pt&format=pdf
|
Portuguese
| null |
PARQUE TEMÁTICO, POPULARIZAÇÃO E PESQUISA AMAZÔNICA: A PROPOSTA DO BOSQUE DA CIÊNCIA/INPA
|
Educação em Revista
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 14,579
|
SAULO CÉZAR SEIFFERT SANTOS1
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7890-1886 MÁRCIA BORIN DA CUNHA2
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3953-5198 RESUMO: Os parques temáticos são espaços de entretenimento e de aprendizagem científico-cultural
por meio das atividades educativas. Nos estados que compõem a Amazônia brasileira, há poucos museus
de ciências do tipo clássico; em contrapartida, há ambientes abertos com a presença do verde e do vivo. Assim, o objetivo aqui foi realizar uma caracterização de um Espaço de Ciência e Tecnologia na Região
Norte, com suas características amazônicas, que realiza investigação científica e que promove a
popularização desta pesquisa junto às audiências em espaço de visitação física. Foi escolhida uma
instituição de Ciência e Tecnologia que promove popularização científica das suas pesquisas – no caso,
em Manaus (AM), o Instituto Nacional de Pesquisa da Amazônia (INPA) no seu espaço de extensão, o
Bosque da Ciência. No início de 2018, foram recebidos documentos relacionados aos planejamentos,
relatórios, solicitações de visitas e publicidade, com os quais se realizou uma análise de conteúdo do tipo
temático. Os dados indicaram que a equipe de monitores realiza estágio curricular, com duração média
de seis meses, ligado ao turismo e ao manejo florestal. Os visitantes são, na sua maioria, do público escolar
da educação infantil e do ensino fundamental, e suas motivações de visita estão ligadas ao cultivo do
enriquecimento cultural oriundo do espaço amazônico. Considera-se que o modelo de monitoria pode
ser melhorado com ações de maior interiorização dos monitores na instituição, bem como com a adoção
de uma visão do parque temático enquanto museu para uso de equipe multidisciplinar educativa para
além do edutenimento, mas com uma visão de patrimônio amazônico. Palavras-chave: educação não formal, museu de Ciências, Espaço de Ciência e Tecnologia, INPA. EDUR • Educação em Revista. 2022; 38:e29448
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/0102-469829448 EDUR • Educação em Revista. 2022; 38:e29448
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/0102-469829448 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
1 Universidade Federal do Amazonas (UFAM). Manaus, AM, Brasil. <sauloseiffert@ufam.edu.br>
2 Universidade Estadual do Oeste do Paraná (UNIOESTE). Cascavel, PR, Brasil. <borin.unioeste@gmail.com> ARTIGO
PARQUE TEMÁTICO, POPULARIZAÇÃO E PESQUISA AMAZÔNICA: A PROPOSTA DO
BOSQUE DA CIÊNCIA/INPA SAULO CÉZAR SEIFFERT SANTOS1
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7890-1886 THEME PARK, POPULARIZATION AND AMAZONIC RESEARCH: THE PROPOSAL OF THE SCIENCE
GROVE PARK/INPA ABSTRACT: Theme parks are spaces for entertainment and scientific-cultural learning through cultural
activities. In the states that make up the Brazilian Amazon there are few classic science museums,
however, there are open environments with the presence of green and living. Thus, the objective was to
characterize a Science and Technology Setting in the North Region, with its Amazonian characteristics, 2 which carries out scientific research and promotes the popularization of this research among audiences
in physical visitation spaces. We chose a Science and Technology institution that promotes the scientific
popularization of its research, in this case, in Manaus/AM, the National Institute for Research in the
Amazon (INPA), in its extension space, the Science Grove Park. Between February and March 2018, we
received documents related to planning, reports, requests for visits and advertising, in which we carried
out a thematic content analysis. The data indicated that the team of monitors carries out a curricular
internship, with an average duration of six months, linked to tourism and forest management, the visitors
are mostly from the early childhood school audience and their visit motivations are linked to the
cultivation of enrichment. cultural origin from the Amazonian space. We believe that the monitoring
model can be improved with actions of greater internalization of monitors in the institution, adopting a
vision of the theme park as a museum for the adoption of a multidisciplinary educational team in addition
to education/entertainment, but a vision of Amazonian heritage. which carries out scientific research and promotes the popularization of this research among audiences
in physical visitation spaces. We chose a Science and Technology institution that promotes the scientific
popularization of its research, in this case, in Manaus/AM, the National Institute for Research in the
Amazon (INPA), in its extension space, the Science Grove Park. Between February and March 2018, we
received documents related to planning, reports, requests for visits and advertising, in which we carried
out a thematic content analysis. The data indicated that the team of monitors carries out a curricular
internship, with an average duration of six months, linked to tourism and forest management, the visitors
are mostly from the early childhood school audience and their visit motivations are linked to the
cultivation of enrichment. cultural origin from the Amazonian space. THEME PARK, POPULARIZATION AND AMAZONIC RESEARCH: THE PROPOSAL OF THE SCIENCE
GROVE PARK/INPA We believe that the monitoring
model can be improved with actions of greater internalization of monitors in the institution, adopting a
vision of the theme park as a museum for the adoption of a multidisciplinary educational team in addition
to education/entertainment, but a vision of Amazonian heritage. Keywords: informal education, sciences museum, science and technology setting, INPA. Keywords: informal education, sciences museum, science and technology setting, INPA. Palabras clave: educación no formal; Museo de Ciencia; espacio de ciencia y tecnología; INPA. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 INTRODUÇÃO O Brasil é o país da América Latina que mais realiza divulgação científica e tecnológica
(MAIA; BERGAMINI; CASTRO, 2018). Sendo um país de dimensões continentais, o desafio de realizar
a divulgação científica está na mesma altura e complexidade em diferentes regiões, etnias, produções
culturais e atividades econômicas. Todavia, esse grande feito da nação popularizadora da Ciência e Tecnologia (CT) não é
homogêneo entre as regiões brasileiras, tendo em vista que há grandes desigualdades econômicas, sociais
e de produção de CT, país afora. Assim, destaca-se aqui a Região Norte do Brasil, que reflete essa
desigualdade e busca avançar para superar anos de atraso e exploração econômica e social, pois que esta
foi a última região brasileira a ser integrada ao Brasil por via terrestre, como também data de poucas
décadas que o Norte recebe atenção e atendimento consistente de políticas públicas em educação,
economia e desenvolvimento social (ARAGON, 2013). As instituições científicas da Região Norte são de número muito pequeno em comparação
com as outras regiões e possuem, historicamente, pouco tempo no processo de construção de uma
tradição de pesquisa. Atualmente, são menos de cinco instituições de pesquisa com mais de 50 anos na
Região Norte (SEIFFERT-SANTOS; CUNHA, 2020). Isso impacta diretamente a divulgação dessa
produção científica e tecnológica pelo número rarefeito de instituições e, por conseguinte, o volume de
grupos de pesquisas engajados numa região que ocupa quase 50% do território brasileiro. Essa região é conhecida como parte da Amazônia, um signo bastante ventilado com vários
sentidos e com significado polifônico. Para isso, podem-se elencar algumas marcas próprias, que,
segundo Fonseca (2011) e Loureiro (2015), são: maior floresta tropical do mundo, maior biodiversidade
terrestre do planeta, uma das maiores bacias de água doce do mundo; apresenta um mosaico de
diversidade cultural entre povos indígenas, ribeirinhos e regiões rurais e urbanas, distribuídas de forma
distinta no território – há povos vivendo em isolamento na floresta e outros em complexos urbanos de
conurbação. Logo, a sua investigação científica reflete e refrata essas marcas e condições. Assim, a Divulgação Científica e Tecnológica (doravante designada por DC) processa-se por
meios diversos. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 PARQUE TEMÁTICO, POPULARIZACIÓN E INVESTIGACIÓN AMAZÓNICA: LA PROPUESTA DEL
BOSQUE DE LA CIENCIA/INIA RESUMEN: Los parques temáticos son espacios de entretenimiento y aprendizaje científico-cultural a
través de actividades culturales. En los estados que componen la Amazonía brasileña hay pocos museos
de ciencia clásicos, sin embargo, hay ambientes abiertos con presencia de verde y vivo. Así, el objetivo
fue caracterizar un Espacio de Ciencia y Tecnología en la Región Norte, con sus características
amazónicas, que realiza investigación científica y promueve la divulgación de esta investigación entre las
audiencias en espacios de visitación física. Elegimos una institución de Ciencia y Tecnología que
promueve la popularización científica de su investigación, en este caso, en Manaus/AM, el Instituto
Nacional de Investigaciones en la Amazonía (INPA), en su espacio de extensión, el Bosque de la Ciencia. Entre febrero y marzo de 2018 recibimos documentos relacionados con la planificación, informes,
solicitudes de visitas y publicidad, en los que realizamos un análisis de contenido temático. Los datos
indicaron que el equipo de monitores realiza una pasantía curricular, con una duración promedio de seis
meses, vinculada al turismo y al manejo forestal. Los visitantes son, en su mayoría, del público escolar de
la primera infancia y sus motivaciones de visita están vinculadas al cultivo del enriquecimiento cultural
originado del espacio amazónico. Creemos que el modelo de seguimiento se puede mejorar con acciones
de mayor internalización de los monitores en la institución, adoptando una visión del parque temático
como museo para la adopción de un equipo educativo multidisciplinario además de “edutenimiento”,
pero una visión del patrimonio amazónico. Palabras clave: educación no formal; Museo de Ciencia; espacio de ciencia y tecnología; INPA. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 INTRODUÇÃO As autoras o denominaram como “jardim
temático”, mas há outro termo usado – o Parque Temático. do ano que são percebidas); a audição, com os cantos dos pássaros e outros elementos naturais; e o aroma
das frutas, flores e árvores. A essa caracterização, as autoras incorporaram a linguagem expográfica da
museografia, em artefatos verbais e iconográficos, para complementar o ambiente em um sistema de
integração, e não de destaque aos outros elementos do jardim. As autoras o denominaram como “jardim
temático”, mas há outro termo usado – o Parque Temático. q
O termo Parque Temático não é frequente nas pesquisas em educação em Ciências e espaços
de educação não formal. Entretanto, é um termo utilizado no livro organizado por Silvério Crestana e
colaboradores (2001), diretor da Estação Ciência nessa época – uma divisão de divulgação científica e
tecnológica da Universidade de São Paulo (USP) –, intitulada “Educação para a Ciência: Curso para
treinamento em Centros e Museus de Ciência”. Na seção de Parques Temáticos do livro, aberta por Alain
Baldacci (representante da Associação Mundial de Parques), embora não se defina o que seja um parque
temático, o termo é relacionado ao ambiente, à atividade e à visita com interatividade e entretenimento
para proporcionar uma experiência leve e suave aos visitantes, além de introduzir o neologismo
“edutenimento”, no caso da temática de Ciência. Essa seção apresenta, como parques temáticos, o
Parque de Ciência, na temática Saúde da Fiocruz, no Rio de Janeiro; o Parque da Água Branca, em São
Paulo; a Casa da Ciência/Bosque da Ciência do INPA, em Manaus; o Parque de Ciências, em Belém; e
o Parque de Ciências da Terra e do Universo, em São Paulo. Todavia, Bonatto (2001), em seu texto sobre o Parque de Ciência da Fiocruz, define que o
Parque Temático está associado aos parques de diversão. Assim, o que esses parques têm em comum é
a oferta de atividades de entretenimento com aspecto educativo, o edutenimento. Considerando-se esse
critério, os parques temáticos como o Bosque da Ciência são um local de lazer para os visitantes,
preservando uma área de fragmento florestal e, ao mesmo tempo, promovendo a educação ambiental
(BUENO, 2001). (
)
Dessa forma, o objetivo deste trabalho é fazer uma caracterização de um ECT na Região
Norte, o qual realiza pesquisa científica e promove o seu espaço para popularizar parte dessa pesquisa
junto às audiências visadas pela instituição. INTRODUÇÃO Essa caracterização parte das informações sobre as exposições
e os documentos de solicitação de visita e de organização funcional do parque. No caso, o parque
temático selecionado para esta análise foi o Bosque da Ciência do Instituto Nacional de Pesquisa da
Amazônia (INPA). Com isso, tem-se a intenção de reconhecer traços favoráveis à constituição da educação não
formal em Ciência e Tecnologia em um ECT de contexto amazônico. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
3 ICOM. Disponível em: https://icom.museum/en/activities/standards-guidelines/museum-
definition/?fbclid=IwAR2OIpsWyJLfce1Bej1H1otK9a06e5i358gTaX36rjmRyty 3lPbIeclapZc. Acesso em: 6 ago. 2019. INTRODUÇÃO Seiffert-Santos (2020b), com base em Bueno (2002) e Nascimento (2010), informa que: [...] [a DC] é vista como responsável pela disponibilização da informação científica e tecnológica
ao público amplo, escolar e não escolar, no formato do jornalismo científico e no formato de
popularização da Ciência para a formação cidadã e crítica (SEIFFERT-SANTOS, 2020b, p. 419). Das formas de DC, o Museu de Ciências e seus análogos/similares (jardins botânicos,
parques, zoológicos e outros) são instituições ou Espaços de Ciência e Tecnologia (ECT) com emprego
de popularização dessas produções da cultura científica como modalidade própria e características
distintas (CGEE, 2019). São concomitantemente instituições de recepção de visitas que normalmente
apresentam o seu projeto de educação não formal (museal) próprio (MARANDINO, 2001; PALHARES,
2009; CGEE, 2019). Como mencionado anteriormente, a Região Norte do Brasil apresenta o menor número de
instituições; isso se reflete nos ECT, com somente 11 Museus e Centros de Ciências, entre os 268
cadastrados no guia Museus e Centros de Ciências presentes no “Catálogo Centros e Museus de Ciências
do Brasil 2015” (ABCMC, 2015). Situados especificamente nos estados do Amapá, Amazonas e Pará,
alguns desses ECTs são: Centro de Pesquisa Museológica – Museu Sacaca (Macapá/AP); Bosque da
Ciência/INPA (Manaus/AM); e Museu Zoobotânico Emílio Goeldi (Belém/PA). Trata-se de
instituições com ênfase nas ricas exposições sobre a biodiversidade e os elementos antropológicos
amazônicos (mais detalhes serão apresentados na próxima seção). Assim, observa-se, nesses exemplos,
que a marca regional amazônica de DC em ECT são locais abertos, associados à floresta e a seus
elementos, em especial ao vivo. A título de exemplo de pesquisa com ambientes abertos que recebem visitantes, Suescun et
al. (2012), que analisaram o Jardim Botânico do Rio de Janeiro, descreveram a experiência como uma
totalidade não percebida imediatamente; contudo, entendem que há uma mediação pela noção espacial
proporcionada pelo informativo (mapa do jardim). A experiência vivida nesse espaço compreende ainda
a luz do ambiente, que ativa a dimensão visual (cores e características em função dos horários e estações Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 4 do ano que são percebidas); a audição, com os cantos dos pássaros e outros elementos naturais; e o aroma
das frutas, flores e árvores. A essa caracterização, as autoras incorporaram a linguagem expográfica da
museografia, em artefatos verbais e iconográficos, para complementar o ambiente em um sistema de
integração, e não de destaque aos outros elementos do jardim. 4 […] para estimular según el máximo de las siguientes tres clases de interactividad con el visitante: 1) Interactividad manual o de emoción
provocadora (Hands-On) 2) Interactividad mental o de emoción inteligible (Minds-On) 3) Interactividad cultural o de emoción cultural (Heart-On)
La tercera es muy recomendable, la primera es muy conveniente, y la segunda, sencillamente imprescindible. Interactividad significa conversación.
Experimentar es conversar con la naturaleza. Reflexionar es conversar con uno mismo. Un buen rincón de museo dispara también la conversación
entre los visitantes. REFERENCIAL TEÓRICO 5 Em termos legais, a definição de museu, fundamentada no artigo 2º, incisos IX e X, do
Decreto Federal nº 8.124/2013, é objeto da Portaria nº 422/2017, do Ministério da Cultura, por meio
do Instituto Brasileiro de Museus, que dispõe sobre a Política Nacional de Educação Museal,
apresentando as definições de museu e de processo museológico: [...] – museu – instituição sem fins lucrativos, de natureza cultural, que conserva, investiga,
comunica, interpreta e expõe, para fins de preservação, estudo, pesquisa, educação,
contemplação e turismo, conjuntos e coleções de valor histórico, artístico, científico, técnico ou
d
b
b
d
d d
d
d [...] – museu – instituição sem fins lucrativos, de natureza cultural, que conserva, investiga,
comunica, interpreta e expõe, para fins de preservação, estudo, pesquisa, educação,
contemplação e turismo, conjuntos e coleções de valor histórico, artístico, científico, técnico ou
de outra natureza cultural, abertos ao público, a serviço da sociedade e de seu desenvolvimento;
– processo museológico – programa, projeto e ação em desenvolvimento ou desenvolvido com
fundamentos teórico e prático da museologia, que considere o território, o patrimônio cultural e
a memória social de comunidades específicas, para produzir conhecimento e desenvolvimento
cultural e socioeconômico. (BRASIL, 2017, n.p). de outra natureza cultural, abertos ao público, a serviço da sociedade e de seu desenvolvimento;
– processo museológico – programa, projeto e ação em desenvolvimento ou desenvolvido com
fundamentos teórico e prático da museologia, que considere o território, o patrimônio cultural e
a memória social de comunidades específicas, para produzir conhecimento e desenvolvimento
cultural e socioeconômico. (BRASIL, 2017, n.p). Segundo a definição do ICOM e da Portaria nº 422/2017, o museu e o processo museológico
têm a função de conservar e educar para o patrimônio cultural e devem ser acessíveis aos cidadãos. A
mesma portaria também informa a necessidade de uma equipe multidisciplinar para o projeto de
educação museal (educação não formal), com abordagem de comunicação e interação com os públicos-
alvo da instituição. Segundo Wagensberg, a interação com o visitante pode ser: […] para estimular de acordo com o máximo de três tipos de interatividade com o visitante: 1)
manual ou provocador de emoção – Interatividade Hands-On – em mãos; 2) emoção mental ou
inteligível – Interatividade Minds-On – na mente; 3) emoção cultural ou cultural – Interatividade
Heart-On – no coração. O terceiro é altamente recomendado, o primeiro é muito conveniente e
o segundo, simplesmente essencial. Interatividade significa conversa. REFERENCIAL TEÓRICO Foi feita uma associação dos Espaços de Ciência e Tecnologia (ECT) com os espaços de
educação não formal científico e tecnológico, caracterizando-os como formas inclusas ou análogas na
categoria de Museus de Ciências (ABCMC, 2015). Dessa forma, os estudos de educação não formal
empregados nos Museus de Ciências podem ser comparados com os projetos educativos de ambientes
abertos institucionais. Considera-se que os museus de Ciências possuem “modalidades” de educação não formal
(CHAGAS, 1993). Em sua recente atualização da definição de museu, o Conselho Internacional de
Museus (International Council of Museums – ICOM) estabeleceu que: Os museus são espaços democratizantes, inclusivos e polifônicos para um diálogo crítico sobre
o passado e o futuro. Reconhecendo e abordando os conflitos e desafios do presente, eles
mantêm artefatos e espécimes em confiança para a sociedade, salvaguardam diversas memórias
para as gerações futuras e garantem direitos iguais e acesso igual ao patrimônio para todas as
pessoas. Os museus não são lucrativos. Eles são participativos e transparentes, e trabalham em
parceria ativa com e para diversas comunidades para coletar, preservar, pesquisar, interpretar,
exibir e melhorar a compreensão do mundo, visando contribuir para a dignidade humana e a
justiça social, a igualdade global e o bem-estar planetário (ICOM, 2019, online, tradução livre)3. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 REFERENCIAL TEÓRICO diferenças entre essas gerações não se restringem somente ao enfoque, uma vez que são influenciadas
por uma complexa relação de condições materiais, históricas e econômicas. Para um estudo detalhado
das condições históricas de desenvolvimentos dos enfoques, sugere-se a leitura de McManus (1992). q
g
(
)
Há uma ideia de terceira geração tardia, ou quarta geração, que, segundo Padilla (2001), são
instituições que se caracterizam por levar em consideração as condições contemporâneas de globalização
(pelo alto grau de trabalho competente e integrado; pela passagem dos artefatos de alto volume para
outros de alto valor; pela informatização; pela integração entre tecnologia, conhecimento e habilidades;
por inovações em práticas educativas; pelo uso de esquemas laborais; pela personalização da experiência
de visita; e pela interação entre temas globais e locais). Essas demandas tanto podem ser relacionadas aos parques temáticos, segundo Londoño,
Solbes e Guisasola (2009), a exemplo dos parques da Disney (privados e lucrativos)5, como também aos
parques de conservação e lazer, com quadros temáticos que não possuem um único foco, ou um
predominante, mas oferecem várias formas de entretenimento com informação. Atualmente, com o aparecimento dos parques temáticos com alta tecnologia e de expressivos
empreendimentos de grupos privados, ou até com a participação de governos, há constituições
enunciativas polifônicas e pluriestilísticas que ocorrem desde a presença de jardins zoobotânicos até a de
exposições com interação com inteligência artificial (SABIESCU; CHARATZOPOULOU, 2018). Entende-se que o espírito do tempo atual contempla uma grande diversidade nos aspectos culturais,
econômicos e ideológicos, que se manifesta pelas formas de expressão dos grupos de pensamentos
científicos próprios e com tratamento e apresentação específicos do contexto local. Assim, entende-se
como parques temáticos não só os empreendimentos lucrativos e de alta tecnologia, mas também os
ambientes com múltiplos focos, que contribuem para o lazer e o conhecimento dos visitantes. Assim, as ações de divulgação em CT na Região Norte, por meio de instituições de espaços
de educação não formal (ECTs), são novas, mas contam com uma história nada recente, pelo fato de
existir na Amazônia o mais antigo zoológico do Brasil. Contudo, há poucas outras instituições não
formais, em especial fora do estado do Pará. Não obstante, esse número começou a mudar recentemente. De início, enfocam-se os dados da última pesquisa de percepção pública da Ciência realizada
pela CGEE (2019) sobre o acesso aos espaços de CT. REFERENCIAL TEÓRICO Experimentar é conversar
com a natureza. Refletir é estar falando consigo mesmo. Um bom canto do museu também
desencadeia conversas entre os visitantes. (WAGENSBERG, 2001, p. 23, tradução livre)4. Para Wagensberg (2001), a interação realiza-se das seguintes formas: pela conversa; consigo
mesmo; pela manipulação de botões (o que acontecerá se aperto isto?) – hands-on; pelas questões e
atividades do cotidiano em pensar e se emocionar com as respostas e reflexões por meio da
inteligibilidade mental – minds-on; e pelas atividades para a distinção das identificações culturais, daquilo
que é fora da cultura própria de cada um, e da promoção da emoção cultural – heart-on. Ressalta-se, conforme Pavão e Leitão (2007), que há uma extrapolação, em especial com os
Centros de Ciências, na interação hands-on, por vezes confundida com a própria interatividade,
inviabilizando outras interações, em especial as com o monitor/mediador, e a experiência social do outro
(visitante de audiência). Por outro lado, na tradicional contemplação, apesar de não envolver interação
física, há interação do discurso externo com o discurso interno do sujeito do conhecimento
(VOLÓCHINOV; BAKHTIN, 2017 [1927]); o sujeito não manipula fisicamente, mas observa. Aqui, há
de convir que se possa convergir para um grau monológico; mas, na perspectiva cultural, a interpretação
não pode ser generalizada, pois, a partir da filosofia hermenêutica, ela é uma construção pessoal, podendo
ocorrer várias negociações de significados entre o discurso interno do sujeito e os discursos da exposição. g
g
j
p
No tocante a essa estratégia comunicativa, percebe-se que os museus de Ciências são
marcados historicamente. McManus (1992), Padilla (2001) e Friedman (2010) chamam de ‘gerações de
museus de Ciências’ determinadas formas e estratégias comunicativas de expressar um dialogismo de
divulgação científica, pois são grupos relativamente homogêneos no teor comunicativo. Cada um deles
possui um enfoque reconhecido nos momentos históricos dos museus de CT. Esses enfoques são
delimitados usualmente por três gerações: 1ª Geração – Museus de História Natural (coleções de acervo
natural conservado); 2ª Geração – Museus da Indústria e Tecnologias (acervo histórico de artefatos
tecnológicos); 3ª Geração – Centros de Ciências (acervo de experimentos de Ciências). Entretanto, as 6 6 diferenças entre essas gerações não se restringem somente ao enfoque, uma vez que são influenciadas
por uma complexa relação de condições materiais, históricas e econômicas. Para um estudo detalhado
das condições históricas de desenvolvimentos dos enfoques, sugere-se a leitura de McManus (1992). Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 5 Em 2019, a definição de museu foi reelaborada, caracterizando-o como ‘não lucrativo’ e, nesse caso, não contemplando os
Parques Temáticos da Disney e de outras empresas, mesmo que possuam atividades ligadas ao patrimônio cultural e à
conservação. REFERENCIAL TEÓRICO 103), em sua pesquisa sobre percepção pública da CT em documentos oficiais de alguns países da
América Latina, informa que a maior parte das populações opta por visitar parques ambientais6, jardins
b
â i
ló i
d
d
ã
d f
ô
l
i
d B
il tânicos e zoológicos, demonstrando não se tratar de fenômeno exclusivo do Brasil: g
● Argentina – pesquisa em 2012 – Visitas a um zoológico, jardim botânico ou aquári
(26,3%); e visitas a um parque nacional ou reserva natural (24,7%); (
)
p q
(
)
● Colômbia – pesquisa em 2012 – Visitas a um parque natural (48,4%); e visitas a um
zoológico ou aquário (40,1%); g
q
(
,
);
● México – pesquisa em 2011 – Visitas a um zoológico ou aquário (43,4%); ● Uruguai – pesquisa em 2011 – Visitas a um zoológico, jardim botânico, aquário, reserva
ou planetário (30%). Apesar dessa preferência brasileira e latino-americana, a Região Norte do Brasil conta com
o menor número de instituições. De um total de 3.118 museus registados no Instituto Brasileiro de
Museus (2011), somente 152 (4,8%) estão na Região Norte, e somente 19 dessas instituições são
categorizadas em Ciências Naturais e História Natural. A mudança do quadro de ausência de ECTs pode acontecer a partir do aumento dos
programas de pós-graduação em educação e ensino de Ciências na Região Norte, com foco nos estudos
pedagógicos escolares em locais fora da sala de aula, com elevação especial no número de pesquisas a
partir de 2008 (SEIFFERT-SANTOS; FACHÍN-TERÁN, 2013). Isso se deve ao fato de não haver
museus de história natural e centros de ciências na maioria dos estados da Região Norte, com exceção
do Pará e do Amapá. Logo, essas pesquisas buscaram espaços institucionais onde ocorre o processo de
DC e instituições congêneres ao museu que possibilitam temas ligados ao ensino de Ciências e ao
contexto local (elementos culturais, antropológicos e florestais amazônicos etc.). Merecem destaque os
grupos de pesquisa nas linhas de investigação relacionadas ao espaço não formal dos estados do Pará,
Amazonas e de Roraima. As atividades de pesquisa em museologia no estado do Pará são as mais antigas e
consolidadas no País, resultado da criação do primeiro jardim zoológico e segundo centro de pesquisa
brasileiro, em 1885, o Museu Paraense Emílio Goeldi (MPEG), tendo o Parque Zoobotânico sido
registrado em 1887 (SANJAD et al., 2012). g
Segundo Sanjad et al. REFERENCIAL TEÓRICO A pesquisa mostra que os zoológicos, os jardins
botânicos e os parques ainda são os mais visitados pela população, correspondendo a 25% das respostas,
como pode ser visto na Figura 1. Figura 1 – Percentual dos entrevistados segundo a declaração de visitação a espaços de difusão científico-
cultural e participação em eventos de Ciência e Tecnologia, em 2006, 2010, 2015 e 2019. Fonte: CGEE (2019, p. 15). Figura 1 – Percentual dos entrevistados segundo a declaração de visitação a espaços de difusão científico-
cultural e participação em eventos de Ciência e Tecnologia, em 2006, 2010, 2015 e 2019. Figura 1 – Percentual dos entrevistados segundo a declaração de visitação a espaços de difusão científico-
cultural e participação em eventos de Ciência e Tecnologia, em 2006, 2010, 2015 e 2019. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
Figura 1 – Percentual dos entrevistados segundo a declaração de visitação a espaços de difusão científico-
cultural e participação em eventos de Ciência e Tecnologia, em 2006, 2010, 2015 e 2019. Fonte: CGEE (2019, p. 15). 5 Em 2019, a definição de museu foi reelaborada, caracterizando-o como ‘não lucrativo’ e, nesse caso, não contemplando os
Parques Temáticos da Disney e de outras empresas, mesmo que possuam atividades ligadas ao patrimônio cultural e à
conservação. 5 Em 2019, a definição de museu foi reelaborada, caracterizando-o como ‘não lucrativo’ e, nesse caso, não contemplando os
Parques Temáticos da Disney e de outras empresas, mesmo que possuam atividades ligadas ao patrimônio cultural e à
conservação. 7 A preferência por esses espaços abertos com objetos biológicos ou com elementos
ambientais regionais vem-se mantendo nas quatro últimas consultas de âmbito nacional. Polino (2015,
p. REFERENCIAL TEÓRICO (2012) e Florez, Sanjad e Okada (2018), as coleções vivas e a
distribuição no espaço aberto desenvolvem uma musealização e um tipo de atividade museal com as
seguintes proposições: a) o arranjo segundo o qual as coleções vivas são expostas colaboram para a
compreensão da relação entre o homem e a natureza em diferentes períodos históricos; b) o processo de
musealização ocorre de forma diferente nos jardins botânicos em relação aos museus de história natural,
em decorrência da imobilidade do acervo (plantado); c) o potencial de comunicação dos museus de
natureza é relacionado à fixidez ou imobilidade da coleção, e ao dinamismo das transformações naturais
verificadas no decorrer do tempo (o ciclo natural dos organismos e as estações do ano). Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
7 O INPA instalou-se em Manaus sob a direção do Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa (CNPq), em 27 de junho de 1954; em
1987, foi transformado em órgão de administração direta, com autonomia administrativa e financeira, vinculado à Secretaria
de Ciência e Tecnologia. Atualmente, o INPA está vinculado ao Ministério de Ciência, Tecnologia, Inovação e Comunicação,
disposto no Decreto nº 8.877/2016, sendo uma Instituição de Ciência e Tecnologia (ICT) nos termos da Lei nº 10.973/2004,
regulamentada pelo Decreto nº 5.563/2005, e tendo por finalidade/missão “gerar e disseminar conhecimentos e tecnologias,
bem como capacitar recursos humanos para o desenvolvimento da Amazônia”. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
6 O uso do termo parque não coincide com o conceito de parque temático, pois o parque temático tem um foco lúdico. Os
parques ambientais, nacionais ou naturais são termos jurídicos ligados à legislação ambiental para a pesquisa, a conservação
e/ou o desenvolvimento sustentável. Todavia, há uma aparente aproximação: todos eles são ambientes abertos e com acesso
à biodiversidade e às diversas dinâmicas humanas.
7 O INPA instalou-se em Manaus sob a direção do Conselho Nacional de Pesquisa (CNPq), em 27 de junho de 1954; em
1987, foi transformado em órgão de administração direta, com autonomia administrativa e financeira, vinculado à Secretaria
de Ciência e Tecnologia. Atualmente, o INPA está vinculado ao Ministério de Ciência, Tecnologia, Inovação e Comunicação,
disposto no Decreto nº 8.877/2016, sendo uma Instituição de Ciência e Tecnologia (ICT) nos termos da Lei nº 10.973/2004,
regulamentada pelo Decreto nº 5.563/2005, e tendo por finalidade/missão “gerar e disseminar conhecimentos e tecnologias,
bem como capacitar recursos humanos para o desenvolvimento da Amazônia”. 6 O uso do termo parque não coincide com o conceito de parque temático, pois o parque temático tem um foco lúdico. Os
parques ambientais, nacionais ou naturais são termos jurídicos ligados à legislação ambiental para a pesquisa, a conservação
e/ou o desenvolvimento sustentável. Todavia, há uma aparente aproximação: todos eles são ambientes abertos e com acesso
à biodiversidade e às diversas dinâmicas humanas. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
p O Bosque da Ciência/INPA a partir das pesquisas Seiffert-Santos e Cunha (2018) realizaram um levantamento das investigações acerca do
Bosque da Ciência/INPA, local desta pesquisa. Os trabalhos destacaram a fundação do INPA, em 19547,
e a criação do Bosque da Ciência, em 1995, com um ambiente físico de 13 hectares, localizado na Zona 6 O uso do termo parque não coincide com o conceito de parque temático, pois o parque temático tem um foco lúdico. Os
parques ambientais, nacionais ou naturais são termos jurídicos ligados à legislação ambiental para a pesquisa, a conservação
e/ou o desenvolvimento sustentável. Todavia, há uma aparente aproximação: todos eles são ambientes abertos e com acesso
à biodiversidade e às diversas dinâmicas humanas. 8 8 Centro-Sul de Manaus (AM), definindo-o como espaço socioeducativo para promoção da divulgação
científica e da educação ambiental para visitantes da comunidade e das escolas. Centro-Sul de Manaus (AM), definindo-o como espaço socioeducativo para promoção da divulgação
científica e da educação ambiental para visitantes da comunidade e das escolas. Em seu site8, a instituição destaca que os seus objetivos são: desenvolver e promover o
programa do INPA para difusão tecnológica, científica e de inovação; e oferecer à população local uma
opção de lazer que possa contribuir para sua educação cultural e ambiental. pç
q
p
p
ç
Os trabalhos ressaltam a implementação do Programa Circuito da Ciência, em 1999, ligado
às atividades de extensão, baseadas na aprendizagem pela exibição e ludicidade. Tais atividades são
destinadas a estudantes da educação infantil e fundamental, com tarefas variadas, envolvendo o uso dos
recursos hídricos, pirogravuras recicladas, saúde bucal, nutrição e rotulagem de alimentos, invertebrados
terrestres, mamíferos aquáticos, vida do gavião real, malária e dengue, tecnologias sociais das abelhas e
sapos, dentre outros (NORONHA; SANTOS; CARVALHO, 2013; BATISTA; VASCONCELLOS;
FACHÍN-TERÁN, 2015; MARTINS et al., 2015; MOTA; FACHÍN-TERÁN; GONZAGA, 2015;
SILVA et al., 2015). As três estações mais citadas nas pesquisas são o tanque do peixe-boi – Trichechus inunguis –
(Figura 2); o recanto das ariranhas – Pteronura brasiliensis –; e o recanto das inajás (palmeira, Attalea maripa),
embora também mereçam destaque as trilhas, ricamente ocupadas por vegetação, com placas
informativas, em que os animais, como os poraquês (peixe-elétrico, Electrophorus electricus), e as plantas
aquáticas diversas são os protagonistas (SEIFFERT-SANTOS; CUNHA, 2018). Figura 2 – Vivências sensoriais, no tanque do Peixe-boi, conduzidas por pesquisadores e professores junto a
crianças da educação infantil. p
p
q
p g
q
p p
j
9 Não foram localizadas no site institucional informações relativas aos projetos coordenados pela COEXT e CAAV, somente
a sua menção. Também não foi possível ter acesso ao projeto escrito. Assim, a fonte de informação foram os folhetos
publicitários do INPA. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 8 Disponível em: http://bosque.inpa.gov.br/bosque/index.php/obj. O Bosque da Ciência/INPA a partir das pesquisas À esquerda, a criança, por meio dos fones de ouvido, ouve as vocalizações do animal; à direita,
as crianças podem tocar no couro de um filhote. as c a ças pode
oca
o co
o de
o e. Fonte: Alencar, Fachín-Terán e Barbosa (2016). Fonte: Alencar, Fachín-Terán e Barbosa (2016). Segundo Seiffert-Santos e Cunha (2020), houve três projetos de divulgação científica cultural
promovidos junto ao Bosque: a) Projeto Pequenos Guias – que funcionou entre 1995 e 2010, com
atividades de crianças locais para uma formação ambiental e que contribuíam como guias no parque para
os turistas e visitantes; b) INPA de Portas abertas – projeto no qual os laboratórios do INPA fazem
atividade de divulgação sobre suas pesquisas para o público em geral (hoje, foi em parte substituído pela
Semana de Ciência e Tecnologia); c) Projeto Circuito da Ciência – escolas são cadastradas e visitam o
parque com a presença de vários grupos de pesquisa do INPA e de parceiros que apresentam resultados
e produtos das investigações feitas por esses grupos aos escolares. Este último projeto no campo da divulgação científica e da educação ambiental (o Circuito
da Ciência), dirigido pela COEXT (Coordenação de Extensão), está ativo até o presente. Segundo
Moreno (2009), estima-se que esse projeto tenha contribuído com atividades de disseminação científica
e ambiental para mais de 25 mil estudantes, entre 1999 e 2010. Em folhetos publicados pela COEXT
(2012), é possível observar que as atividades se baseiam em três eixos9: 9 ● Saúde – doenças tropicais: malária, dengue, leishmaniose; plantas medicinais d
Amazônia; e saúde bucal; ● Saúde – doenças tropicais: malária, dengue, leishmaniose; plantas medicinais da
Amazônia; e saúde bucal; ● Práticas ambientais – perguntas (Quiz) aos estudantes sobre redução de emissões de
Gases de Efeito Estufa (GEE); produção de mudas; como evitar queimadas urbanas; e
os escoteiros do Amazonas; ● Práticas ambientais – perguntas (Quiz) aos estudantes sobre redução de emissões de
Gases de Efeito Estufa (GEE); produção de mudas; como evitar queimadas urbanas; e
os escoteiros do Amazonas; ● Biodiversidade – quelônios da Amazônia; invertebrados terrestres vivos; insetos
aquáticos; e mamíferos aquáticos (peixe-boi). As atividades ocorreram até o ano de 2012 no Bosque da Ciência e Jardim Botânico Adolpho
Ducke10, envolvendo 45 mil pessoas, entre crianças, jovens e adultos, e com a participação de 182
comunidades urbanas e mais de 520 escolas. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
10 Em decorrência das invasões e desmatamentos na área da Reserva Adolpho Ducke, foi criado o Jardim Botânico Adolpho
Ducke, em 2000, administrado pela Prefeitura Municipal de Manaus até 2009, quando foi transferida a administração para a
empresa privada Musa (BARROSO; MESQUITA, 2014). O Bosque da Ciência/INPA a partir das pesquisas O projeto, que envolve aproximadamente 300 estudantes a cada edição, tem um formato
que lembra uma Feira Científica, ou Workshop, com apresentações diversas, tendas, banners, modelos,
material biológico conservado etc., dependendo do tipo de exposição que os colaboradores da COEXT
entendem adequada para apresentar às escolas visitantes. O Circuito da Ciência tem dez edições anuais,
sempre na última sexta-feira do mês (ver Figuras 3 e 4). O Circuito conta com diversas barracas de
exposições (que variam entre 15 e 30), também chamadas de estações de visitas, organizadas pelos
colaboradores do Circuito da Ciência: grupos de pesquisa do INPA, universidades, entre outras
instituições. Figura 4 – Edição do Circuito da Ciência de
Novembro/2018. Consumo da água. Fonte: Seiffert-Santos (2020a). Figura 3 – Circuito da Ciência, com participação dos
pesquisadores de insetos aquáticos. Figura 4 – Edição do Circuito da Ciência de
Novembro/2018. Consumo da água. Fonte: Barcellar (2011). Fonte: Seiffert-Santos (2020a). Figura 4 – Edição do Circuito da Ciência de
Novembro/2018. Consumo da água. Figura 3 – Circuito da Ciência, com participação dos
pesquisadores de insetos aquáticos. Fonte: Barcellar (2011). Figura 3 – Circuito da Ciência, com participação dos
pesquisadores de insetos aquáticos. Fonte: Barcellar (2011). Fonte: Barcellar (2011). Fonte: Seiffert-Santos (2020a). Fonte: Seiffert-Santos (2020a). Os colaboradores alternam-se a cada edição, o que permite variações ou mesmo diferenças
a cada exposição. Além disso, essa estratégia de DC colabora com a participação/diálogo dos professores
escolares nas atividades do Circuito da Ciência (MARTINS et al., 2015). Essa diversidade pode ser
reportada pelo relato de pesquisas sobre duas edições do Circuito da Ciência, realizadas em 2014, a
exemplo de Silva et al. (2015) e de Mota, Fachín-Terán e Gonzaga (2015). A partir desses dados e considerando-se o arcabouço teórico deste artigo, espera-se ter
deixado compreensíveis as possíveis relações entre o ECT, na função de DC, e parte dos processos de
comunicação do Bosque da Ciência. q
Na Figura 5, é possível observar um esquema de distribuição das estações de visita com os
seus atrativos e seus nomes atuais escritos em português e inglês. Figura 5 – Esquema dos locais de visitação pública do Bosque da Ciência constantes do folheto destinado ao
visitante. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
Q
,
) PROCEDIMENTOS METODOLÓGICOS A pesquisa é de vertente qualitativa com a função de compreensão dos fenômenos humanos
e sociais (MALHEIROS, 2011). Segundo Richardson (2012), a investigação qualitativa é a mais adequada
para os fenômenos sociais no que se refere aos aspectos metodológicos, às formas de coleta e à análise
de dados. Assim, esta é uma pesquisa qualitativa, descritiva e exploratória. Nesta investigação, construiu-se um corpus de documentos a partir da solicitação feita aos
servidores administrativos lotados no Bosque da Ciência, em Manaus (AM), subordinado à Coordenação
de Apoio às Áreas de Visitação (CAAV) da Coordenação de Extensão (COEXT) do Instituto Nacional
de Pesquisa da Amazônia (INPA). O critério de escolha do ECT deu-se por meio da seleção de instituições de pesquisa que
realizam DC com apresentação de ECT na cidade onde o pesquisador reside – a saber, Manaus (AM). No caso, havia apenas o Museu da Amazônia (ONG Musa), o Museu Amazônico (administrado pela
Universidade Federal do Amazonas) e o Bosque da Ciência/INPA. Foi selecionado este último devido
à sua presença no catálogo da ABCMC (2015). Nesta investigação, foi adotada uma análise categorial simples para os termos inicialmente
formulados por Bardin (2009) e por Richardson (2012). A pesquisa deu-se a partir dos documentos
recolhidos: planos de trabalhos dos servidores; planos de trabalho dos monitores; planilha eletrônica das
solicitações de agendamento de visitas via internet do período de junho de 2016 a dezembro de 2018;
relatório de gestão; site do Bosque; panfletos de divulgação do Bosque; registro fotográfico das estações
de visita pelo pesquisador. Os dados de agendamento de visita presentes na planilha, após serem
reorganizados, foram tabulados. A partir da tabulação, utilizou-se de um tratamento de análise descritiva
de conteúdo categorial (BARDIN, 2009), construindo-se um gráfico de frequência de visitação a partir
das variáveis já explicitadas no próprio documento. Segundo Bardin, a análise de conteúdo pode ser definida como Um conjunto de técnicas de análise das comunicações visando obter, por procedimentos
sistemáticos e objetivos de descrição do conteúdo das mensagens, indicadores (quantitativos ou
não) que permitam a inferência de conhecimentos relativos às condições de produção/recepção
(variáveis inferidas) destas mensagens. (BARDIN, 2009, p. 44). Foram realizadas algumas visitas ao parque, bem como conversas com servidores e
monitores sobre o funcionamento das atividades e registro no diário de campo. O Bosque da Ciência/INPA a partir das pesquisas Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
10 Em decorrência das invasões e desmatamentos na área da Reserva Adolpho Ducke, foi criado o Jardim Botânico Adolpho
Ducke, em 2000, administrado pela Prefeitura Municipal de Manaus até 2009, quando foi transferida a administração para a
empresa privada Musa (BARROSO; MESQUITA, 2014). 10
Fonte: COEXT (2018). 10 Fonte: COEXT (2018). Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 Equipe de Trabalho O Bosque da Ciência é administrado pela Coordenação de Apoio às Áreas de Visitação
(CAAV), que conta com seis técnicos administrativos, cujas funções estão em consonância com os
objetivos e as metas do plano individual de trabalho, no qual estão discriminados o planejamento, o
treinamento e a execução do Projeto Circuito da Ciência e Estágio Curricular por monitoria, bilheteria,
apoio e supervisão das visitações. Entre os técnicos da equipe de trabalho, há pessoas com formação em
Pedagogia, Assistência Social, Agronomia e Engenharia Florestal. A coordenação do CAAV tem a função de supervisionar e apoiar os trabalhos de recepção
de visitantes, zelar pela manutenção do parque e realizar o planejamento e a execução da sua
coordenação. Não há necessariamente atividade de produção intelectual, pois todos são técnicos, tendo
como função apoiar os pesquisadores e as atividades dos laboratórios. Os objetivos do CAAV são: organização, realização e apoio a eventos científicos,
educacionais e culturais na área da visitação; recepção, supervisão e apoio a grupos de visitantes na área
de visitação; capacitação de novos profissionais para as atividades voltadas à área do turismo ambiental,
gestão administrativa e manejo ambiental com ênfase no bioma amazônico; e promoção e difusão
científica e educação ambiental no INPA (INPA, 2018a, Plano de Trabalho dos Servidores – Metas
Individuais). Integrantes do grupo de trabalho e treinamento, os monitores de recepção turística são os
que fazem os percursos nas estações de visita. Identificaram-se 13 monitores durante o período de busca
de dados, dos quais 4 estagiavam no período vespertino, e 9 aos sábados e domingos. Esses monitores
eram estudantes do curso de Turismo nas seguintes instituições: Centro Universitário Fametro,
Universidade do Estado do Amazonas e Universidade Nilton Lins. Os estagiários de recepção têm os seguintes objetivos: mediar ações de recepção junto ao
público que visita o Bosque da Ciência e contribuir para o desenvolvimento de ações educativas no
contexto do Bosque da Ciência. Destacam-se como objetivos específicos: acompanhar os visitantes e as
escolas pelas trilhas e fornecer informações simples sobre os centros de visitações e sobre a flora e a fauna, tentando
despertar no visitante o interesse maior pela paisagem natural do local; participar dos projetos desenvolvidos no
Bosque da Ciência, como o Circuito da Ciência e as atividades organizadas em datas comemorativas
(Semana do Meio Ambiente, por exemplo). PROCEDIMENTOS METODOLÓGICOS Dentre as variáveis constantes na planilha eletrônica de agendamento de visitas que foi
disponibilizada, destacam-se as seguintes: nome da instituição solicitante; natureza jurídica, pública ou
privada; nível de escolaridade do grupo de visitação; característica do grupo escolar; informações
adicionais; presença de portador de necessidades especiais; ano escolar; turno da visita; data; quantidade
de alunos pretendidos; quantidade de alunos presentes; quantidade de outros/acompanhantes
pretendidos; quantidade de outros/acompanhantes presentes; primeira visita; como foi informado sobre
o Bosque da Ciência; pontos de visitação pretendidos; decisão do moderador; e idade do grupo. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 11 De forma a propiciar uma análise qualitativa categorial, procedeu-se a uma reorganização
das variáveis da planilha. As variáveis das solicitações que estavam com campos vazios acima de 70%
dos registros (ano escolar, quantidade de alunos presentes, quantidade de outros/acompanhantes
presentes e idade do grupo), por exemplo, deixaram de ser incluídas na análise categorial. Os dados estão apresentados em: as atividades das equipes de colaboradores, servidores e
monitores do Bosque da Ciência, e os dados das solicitações de visita. A investigação orienta-se através das seguintes questões: a) Quais são as funções e as
atividades da equipe de trabalho do Bosque da Ciência com relação à atividade de popularização da
Ciência e Tecnologia?; b) Quais são os perfis dos visitantes que encaminham a solicitação de visita e os
seus interesses pelo ECT?; e c) Como essa dinâmica dos servidores e das solicitações de visita apresentam
o perfil e os interesses dos visitantes de origem escolar (educação formal)? Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 Equipe de Trabalho Os estagiários elaboram um plano individual de estágio
contemplando a formação preparatória, a leitura bibliográfica, o auxílio em oficinas, o acompanhamento em
visitação, o atendimento na Casa da Ciência e a entrega do relatório final pessoal (INPA, 2018b, Plano de
Trabalho dos Estagiários – Metas Individuais, grifo nosso). g
g
Os monitores de manejo florestal e paisagismo também eram 13, dentre os quais 8
estagiavam no turno da manhã e 5 no turno vespertino, nos dias úteis. Os estagiários eram estudantes
dos seguintes cursos: técnico em Meio Ambiente pelo Centro de Educação Tecnológica do Amazonas
(CETAM) e Centro de Ensino Técnico (CENTEC); graduação em Biologia pela Universidade Estácio
de Sá; graduação em Engenharia Ambiental pela Universidade Nilton Lins; e graduação em Gestão
Ambiental pelo Instituto de Ensino Superior – UNIASSELVI. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 12 12 Os objetivos dos estagiários de manejo florestal e paisagismo são: capacitar novos
profissionais para atividades voltadas para a área ambiental, com ênfase no bioma amazônico, com o
intuito de torná-los mais preparados tecnicamente, de modo a responderem às solicitações do cotidiano
do Bosque da Ciência, tanto em relação aos assuntos socioambientais quanto às questões pedagógicas e
de linguagem científica. Os seus objetivos específicos são: acompanhar a demonstração de atividades
rotineiras na produção de mudas de espécies florestais e agronômicas no Viveiro do Bosque da Ciência;
acompanhar e realizar práticas silviculturais adotadas na área florestal; orientar visitantes do Bosque da Ciência
quanto aos assuntos da área técnica, da educacional e do receptivo (INPA, 2018b, grifo nosso). q
p
(
g
)
No cronograma de trabalho, estão as atividades de coleta de sementes, apoio às oficinas,
participação em atividades ambientais, cuidado com o paisagismo do parque, plantio de mudas, produção
de mudas, realização de visitas guiadas e entrega do relatório final (INPA, 2018b, grifo nosso). z ç
g
g
f
(
g
)
Observou-se que todos os estagiários eram responsáveis por visitas guiadas e participavam
das atividades pedagógicas ambientais. Contudo, um grupo tinha como foco o manejo florestal e o
paisagismo, e o outro, a recepção de visitantes e o estudo programado. p
g
p
p
g
Sobre a formação dos monitores, não foi entregue documento escrito. Equipe de Trabalho Todavia, em trabalho
publicado pelo INPA (HIGUCHI; FARIA, 2002) e, depois, em conversa registrada no diário de campo
com os monitores e servidores do Bosque da Ciência, tomou-se conhecimento de que, após o processo
seletivo semestral, na primeira semana de estágio, eles participam de um evento de capacitação com
palestras, atividades de reconhecimento das estações de visitas e dos laboratórios e integração com os
servidores e outros monitores. Destacam-se, dentre as informações, as das palestras de cada laboratório
com espaço no Parque, a exemplo do Laboratório de Mamíferos Aquáticos (LMA), do Grupo de
Pesquisa com Abelhas (GPA), do Centro de Pesquisa de Quelônios da Amazônia (CEQUA), do
Laboratório de Psicologia e Educação Ambiental (LAPSEA), do Herbário e do grupo de pesquisa que
estuda o poraquê. Na atividade de reconhecimento das espécies de plantas amazônicas, houve a
participação de agrônomo e/ou engenheiro florestal; e, na de reconhecimento das estações de visita, o
próprio coordenador da CAAV esteve presente. Foi mencionado o recebimento de material de leitura
abordando as atividades de recepção e também o atendimento ao público visitante. Nesta pesquisa, é possível elencar um programa de formação de monitores e professores
usuários do Bosque11 para o desenvolvimento de experiências positivas de educação. Todavia, para mais
fatores a serem pensados como programa de formação de monitores, pode-se consultar Hooper-
Greenhill (1999), Falk e Storksdieck (2005), Rodari e Merzagora (2007), Marandino (2008), National
Research Council (2009), Queiroz et al. (2011), Bizerra e Marandino (2014), e Carvalho e Pacca (2015),
entre outros. Entende-se que há repetição de alguns problemas já encontrados em outras pesquisas sobre
o projeto de monitoria em espaços não formais, aqui, em parque temático, quais sejam: reduzido quadro
de monitores em vista da numerosa visitação (veja-se na próxima seção); estágio voluntário sem repasse
de valores de transporte, alimentação e custeio de material de leitura; formação e maturação da
experiência de monitoria curta (seis meses); grande rotatividade de monitores; desligamento sem
incentivo de permanência e integração com outros setores da instituição, ao término do estágio
monitorial. 11 Azevedo, Higuchi e Barcelos (2009) informam que o LAPSEA/INPA possui um projeto de formação continuada de
professores da rede básica sobre o conhecimento científico e cotidiano e a floresta Amazônica numa perspectiva
socioambiental. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
12 A Prefeitura Municipal de Manaus, no ano de 2019, realizou um convênio com a COEXT/INPA para manter com bolsas
municipais os monitores depois do aviso de fechamento de visitas monitoradas e da redução do quadro de servidores lotados
neste setor. É dessa forma que se tem mantido o funcionamento do Bosque da Ciência até o presente. Equipe de Trabalho Essas circunstâncias podem ser balanceadas com medidas possíveis, como, por exemplo: • Realização de convênio com instituições de ensino superior e órgãos ligados à
profissionalização de esfera municipal ou estadual; efetivação de programa de formação
de visita guiada a professores da educação básica e em temáticas específicas (KATZ et al.,
2011); e elaboração de sequências didáticas (PASCUAL; ARANZABAL, 2014) – com
isso, fazer o banco de voluntários docentes do Bosque; 13 • Estabelecimento de convênios com órgãos de profissionalização da esfera estadual,
municipal e federal, com disponibilidade para bolsas, ou a constituição de fundação para
captação de recursos12; p
• Desenvolvimento de programas de formação de monitores em que haja integração com
os laboratórios para possibilitar outros estágios na área da pesquisa e para os quais se
mantenham alguns dias do mês contribuindo para a formação de novos monitores
(LUEHMANN, 2009); • Planificação de atividades de registro da memória do Bosque, reuniões de formação e
decisões e redações/dissertações temáticas sobre a realidade do Bosque para o banco de
experiências e boas práticas (BASSOLI, 2013); p
p
(
)
• Realização anual de um encontro dos monitores do Bosque da Ciência para compartilhar
experiências, projetos e construção de network junto à administração do Bosque
(HIGUCHI; FARIAS, 2002). Figura 6 – Distribuição do número de visitantes no Bosque da Ciência a partir das solicitações formais de visita
(2016 a 2018). Solicitação de Visita Em relação às solicitações, foram identificados 1.958 pedidos de agendamento de visita
(n=1.958), entre junho de 2016 e dezembro de 2018, sendo que 914 foram de escolas públicas (n=914
grupos de escolas; 46,6%); 611 de escolas privadas (n=611 grupos de escolas; 31,2%); e 433 de outras
instituições (n=433 grupos; 22,1%). Destas últimas, destacam-se igrejas (n=53 grupos), escoteiros (n=46
grupos) e centros de atenção social ou filantrópicos (n=20 grupos), entre outros. g
p
)
ç
p
(
g
p
)
Nesse período, foram registrados em média 63,1 grupos/mês, 3.700 visitantes/mês e 58,1
visitantes/grupo/mês, o que equivale a uma média de 142 pessoas por dia (considerando a semana de
visitação de seis dias). )
Pode-se destacar que os níveis de escolaridade dos grupos de estudantes em visita foram:
infantil (n=272 grupos; 13,9%); fundamental (n=440 grupos; 22,5%); médio (n=121 grupos; 6,2%); e
superior (n=125 grupos; 6,4%). As outras instituições apresentaram grupos mistos com visitantes nos
níveis de escolarização infantil, fundamental, médio e superior (n=458 grupos; 23,4%). O grupo
majoritário de visitas agendadas foi o dos escolares dos níveis infantil e fundamental, somando 36,4%
das solicitações. As visitas pelo turno matutino foram mais solicitadas (n=1.298; 66,3%) do que as do
vespertino (n=658; 33,6%). Podem-se associar as visitas matutinas às de escolas do nível infantil e anos
iniciais do ensino fundamental, considerando ser esse o horário em que normalmente funcionam tais
escolas. Em termos anuais, essas solicitações de visitas foram assim distribuídas: 2016 (n=481 grupos;
24,6%); 2017 (n=775 grupos; 39,6%); e 2018 (n=697 grupos; 35,6%). Dessas solicitações, somente 8,58%
(n=168) declararam a presença de pessoas portadoras de necessidades especiais. Nesses interstícios, os meses mais visitados foram: junho, em decorrência da Semana do
Meio Ambiente; e outubro, por conta da Semana de Ciência e Tecnologia, do período comemorativo das
crianças e do aniversário do INPA (Figura 6). As datas comemorativas escolares têm uma forte influência
nas visitas ao Bosque. Os meses de dezembro, janeiro e julho são menos visitados, em associação ao
recesso escolar; nos meses de fevereiro e março, as visitas se iniciam com o retorno escolar. 14
Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. 14
Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. 14 14 Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Nesse período de três anos, o Bosque recebeu 95.356 visitantes (n=95.356), uma média de
48,7 visitantes por solicitação. Solicitação de Visita Contudo, deve-se salientar que as solicitações formais são uma parte da
demanda que o Parque recebe, não contemplando as entradas gratuitas para visitantes com idade inferior
a 10 anos ou maiores de 60 anos, os pagantes de visita espontânea (individuais, grupos e famílias) e
também os grupos não agendados (esses dados possuem registro físico). Também não são contemplados
os visitantes dos dias em que a entrada é franca, sem contagem na bilheteria, a exemplo da semana do
aniversário do Bosque da Ciência (primeira semana de abril), a semana de aniversário do INPA, a Semana
do Meio Ambiente e a Semana de Ciência e Tecnologia. A frequência dos visitantes, ilustrada na figura anterior, é proporcional à frequência dos
acompanhantes responsáveis pelos grupos de visitantes (Figura 7). Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
Figura 7 – Distribuição do número de acompanhantes aos grupos de visitas no Bosque da Ciência a partir das
solicitações formais de visita (2016 a 2018). Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 15 As visitas são realizadas em grupos, limitadas a cem pessoas por grupo e 300 pessoas por
turno. Assim, realizou-se a contagem das solicitações em grupos de múltiplos de 50, ou seja, 50 visitantes
(Quadro 1). As visitas são realizadas em grupos, limitadas a cem pessoas por grupo e 300 pessoas por
turno. Assim, realizou-se a contagem das solicitações em grupos de múltiplos de 50, ou seja, 50 visitantes
(Quadro 1). Quadro 1 – Distribuição em grupos múltiplos de 50 visitantes (2016 a 2018). Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Quadro 1 – Distribuição em grupos múltiplos de 50 visitantes (2016 a 2018). Mais de 70% das solicitações envolveram grupos de até 50 pessoas, no período informado. Percentual semelhante foi observado em relação ao número de acompanhantes e responsáveis; os grupos
com até cinco pessoas adultas representaram 47,75% (n=935). Veja-se o Quadro 2. Quadro 2 – Distribuição de acompanhantes/responsáveis por grupos de visitantes (2016 a 2018). Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Ressalta-se que, no período de análise, a maioria dos visitantes assinalou que estava visitando
o Bosque da Ciência pela primeira vez (n=1.196; 61%), e, portanto, somente 37,8% (n=740) já o tinham
visitado. Embora o normal seja que as solicitações sejam autorizadas, há registro de pedidos negados
pelo moderador (n=281; 14,3%) em decorrência de remarcação de visitas e outras causas. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
13 Esse quadro apresenta totais diferentes dos elencados no Quadro 6, tendo em vista que foram desconsideradas as
solicitações que não preencheram essa informação e também as relativas aos grupos mistos, que são heterogêneos, não
escolares, cujas visitas não têm, necessariamente, intenção educativa científica ou ambiental. Quadro 3 – Motivações para as visitas (2016 a 2018). Solicitação de Visita Uma informação interessante refere-se à fonte que sugeriu a atividade no Bosque da Ciência,
ou seja, como o visitante ficou sabendo sobre a possibilidade de realizar visitas em grupos. O comum é
que o “boca a boca” seja a principal forma de divulgação (COSTA; IMHOFF; BORGES, 2015); mas,
em relação ao Parque, as fontes foram sites da Internet com 33,25% (n=651), as redes sociais (10,9%,
n=213), os jornais (6,8%, n=133) e outros (0,4%, n=9). A maioria informou ter tido conhecimento das
visitas ao Parque por várias fontes, o que chamamos de fonte mista, com 39,6% (n=775), opção que
abrange as indicações de familiares, amigos e colegas de trabalho. g
g
g
Os objetivos e/ou motivações para as visitas de público proveniente dos níveis fundamental,
médio e superior estão circunscritos a quatro grupos: a) conhecimentos escolares, ou seja, atividades que
geram relatórios técnicos, ou algum tipo de atividade análoga à avaliação escolar; b) experiência de
enriquecimento sobre o Bosque da Ciência, relacionada à biodiversidade e ao meio ambiente; c) atividade
de evento, premiação escolar ou projetos; d) outros, como remarcação de atividade, ou reconhecimento
do INPA. Isso pode ser visto no Quadro 313 (22,1% das solicitações; n=433). 16 16 Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Observa-se, no Quadro 3, que as principais motivações dos níveis fundamental e médio são
semelhantes. Há uma ênfase na experiência de enriquecimento na maior parte das solicitações, superando
os 50%. Todavia, as atividades de eventos ocorrem em percentual significativo no nível fundamental, em
especial em decorrência de premiação e de alguns projetos em nível escolar, ou em comemoração de
datas especiais. Por sua vez, a ênfase no nível médio refere-se às atividades de conhecimento escolar, em
especial em visitas técnicas de cursos técnicos e aulas ligadas à Biologia e à Educação Ambiental. Já no
nível superior, a ênfase das visitas dá-se no conhecimento escolar, ou seja, atividades de aulas práticas de
disciplinas e outras atividades semelhantes, para experiência de enriquecimento, além de atividades de
eventos programados. Solicitação de Visita Podem-se relacionar esses resultados com os obtidos por Seiffert-Santos e Cunha
(2019) em estudo envolvendo pesquisas sobre educação científica em espaços não formais, nos trabalhos
apresentados no Encontro Nacional de Pesquisa em Educação em Ciências (ENPEC), entre 2011 e 2017,
relativas às três categorias desta pesquisa, a saber: de enriquecimento cultural (similar à experiência de
enriquecimento), de complementação escolar (similar a conhecimento escolar) e de alternativas não
formais. No trabalho citado, a maior frequência de trabalhos foi encontrada na categoria de
enriquecimento cultural, semelhante a este estudo. q
Os objetivos e as motivações das atividades no nível infantil são mais homogêneos. As visitas
são para a aula passeio, socialização, premiação por visita ao bosque, experiência com a fauna e a flora,
comemoração do Dia da Criança e do Meio Ambiente. Observa-se, a partir dos dados apresentados anteriormente, que a maioria das visitas ao Bosque da Ciência
se dá pela manhã, por escolas públicas, por estudantes do nível infantil e fundamental, com grupos de até 50 pessoas, e com
o acompanhamento de grupos de cinco pessoas responsáveis com objetivos/motivações de experienciar os ambientes, a
biodiversidade e a socialização, especialmente na Semana do Meio Ambiente e na Semana da Ciência e Tecnologia. A única pesquisa localizada que apresenta dados relativos à visitação do Bosque da Ciência
é a de Maciel e Fachín-Terán (2014), abrangendo o período de 2010 a 2012, com números considerados
elevados se comparados aos obtidos pela presente pesquisa: mais de 100 mil visitantes por ano, e com
média superior a 600 escolas por ano. Contudo, reforça-se a observação de que, nos dados aqui presentes,
não foram incluídos os registros físicos não digitalizados. g
g
Retomando as motivações de visitas escolares, nota-se o uso frequente de palavras como
experiências, sensibilizar e conhecimento, entre outras com o sentido semelhante, na categoria de
experiência de enriquecimento, na qual se percebe uma crença de que a experiência gera o conhecimento
acerca do meio ambiente, da fauna e da flora, sem que haja o peso das obrigações escolares. Por outro
lado, identifica-se que a categoria conhecimentos escolares tem como sentido o de aula prática, a
elaboração de relatórios e o estabelecimento de relações entre a teoria e o mundo prático na natureza:
um entendimento de que os conceitos vistos em aula, na escola, podem ser observados no espaço não
formal, como se ocorresse uma confirmação. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 Dados de solicitações de visitas às estações Levando-se em conta que são 20 as estações e estimando-se a permanência mínima de dez
minutos em cada uma delas, a visitação duraria pelo menos três horas, sem se levar em consideração o
tempo de caminhada nas trilhas entre uma estação e outra. Dessa forma, é fundamental planejar bem o
roteiro de visitação, selecionando as estações e focando em temáticas e possíveis observações, de forma
a não deixar os visitantes exaustos pela caminhada nas trilhas florestais, possibilitando que desfrutem das
experiências ricas que uma estação tem a oferecer e viabilizando diálogos e interações com professores e
monitores. No formulário eletrônico de agendamento do Bosque da Ciência, são disponibilizadas as
seguintes opções de escolha: Caminhada pelas Trilhas; Centro de Quelônios da Amazônia (CEQUA);
Sessão do Planetário; Circuito da Ciência; “Nenhum” [destes]; e “Todos” [estes]. [
]
[
]
Logo abaixo desse item, é solicitado que se informe o objetivo da visita, para que se dê a
seleção prévia das estações, a fim de haver um planejamento da recepção dos grupos ao parque e também
o controle do número de monitores e as possíveis combinações de estações, para que não haja
congestionamento dos espaços. Ao assinalar a opção “Caminhada pelas Trilhas”, é possível fazer combinações envolvendo
as seguintes estações: Portaria, Viveiros da Ariranha e dos Peixes-boi, Ilha da Tanimbuca, Trilha
Suspensa, Paiol da Cultura (passagem sem entrada), Lago Amazônico (as visitas ao CEQUA e aos
viveiros dos jacarés são opcionais) e retorno pela estação desativada das Ilhas das Inajás (devido às
rampas de acessos com acessibilidade a cadeirantes), trilha de acesso direto ao ambiente externo da Casa
da Ciência, ou trilha que passa pela Casa de Vidro e Lanchonete (chegando ao ambiente externo da Casa
da Ciência, cuja visitação se dá quando não esgotado o tempo planejado). Nesse percurso, é possível
visitar de 7 a 11 estações. O CEQUA apresenta duas possibilidades de acesso. Uma delas é realizar a tradicional
Caminhada pelas Trilhas, com foco na visita ao CEQUA e aos Viveiros dos jacarés (parte do CEQUA);
a outra é pela trilha de acesso ao Recanto das Inajás (grafado por Poraquê nos esquemas de visitações
atuais), que dispõe de acessibilidade a cadeirantes, cujo retorno se dá pelo mesmo caminho. Solicitação de Visita Nesse sentido, é possível inferir que alguns conceitos
envolvendo relações ecológicas, algumas estruturas morfológicas e a análise de alguma situação
ambiental, especialmente associada à destruição de origem antrópica ao meio ambiente, possam ser
apreendidos sem muitas dificuldades no ECT, na condição de fragmento florestal. Contudo, é necessário
planejar, fazer acertos prévios junto ao grupo e preparar o local de forma a apreender o conceito na
observação. É importante ressaltar que se trata de uma situação construída, uma observação dirigida e
não uma observação natural pura ou espontânea. É fundamental haver a reflexão epistemológica para
não se permear um empirismo ingênuo, bem como visualizar o fragmento florestal, nesse caso de mata
secundária, como ambiente puro, não obstante seja uma área que propicie atividade com o meio florestal 17 amazônico, mas modificado, e com muitos vegetais plantados em regime de manejo florestal e
paisagismo. Figura 8 – Frequência relativa de solicitações de visitas a partir da escolha das estações de visita do Bosque da
Ciência (2016 a 2018). 14 A Instrução Normativa IBAMA nº 7/2015, de 30 de abril de 2015, informa no seu Artigo 32: “Os criadouros científicos
para fins de conservação e mantenedouros somente poderão ser objeto de visitas monitoradas de caráter técnico, didático ou
para atender programas de educação ambiental da rede de ensino formal, e desde que não mantenham espécimes dos grupos
elencados no artigo anterior. Parágrafo único. As visitas monitoradas deverão ser objeto de aprovação junto ao órgão
ambiental competente mediante apresentação de projeto de visitação, sendo vedada a cobrança de qualquer taxa aos
visitantes”. Dados de solicitações de visitas às estações Isso leva a um efeito especial pela vivência dos
ritmos naturais, algo que somente o experenciar com todos os sentidos conduz a um saber de contato e
que não é reduzido a apenas um saber cognitivo pelo design da exposição. 18
Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. 18
Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Entretanto, a diferença entre a opção mais assinalada e a menos assinalada é de
aproximadamente 21,4% (n=396), confirmando que todas as opções são bem solicitadas. O NRC (2009)
sugere percursos de visita, que sejam como narrativas para que cada estação contribua para a construção
de sentido ao visitante – ele individualmente ou em grupo, todavia, em ambientes fechados normalmente. Isso é relativamente mais controlável em ambientes planejados e fechados. Porém, conforme já foi dito,
os ambientes abertos possuem as limitações de o acervo ser plantado, as edificações serem fixas e sujeitas
ao intemperismo, às estações do ano e ao horário do dia. Isso leva a um efeito especial pela vivência dos
ritmos naturais, algo que somente o experenciar com todos os sentidos conduz a um saber de contato e
que não é reduzido a apenas um saber cognitivo pelo design da exposição. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 Dados de solicitações de visitas às estações A Sessão do Planetário, que ocorre em uma das salas da Casa da Ciência, não é executada
pela equipe do Parque, mas por graduandos ou egressos dos cursos de Ciências Naturais e de Física da
Universidade Federal do Amazonas, muitos deles ligados a projetos de extensão da universidade ou de
iniciação à docência. Por envolver uso de espaço do INPA por terceiros, o agendamento das visitas
ocorre de acordo com a disponibilidade das programações do Parque. No Projeto Circuito da Ciência, as escolas são convidadas a se cadastrarem para serem
agendadas em uma das dez exibições anuais. A totalidade das opções é apresentada na opção “Todos”, tornando possível o agendamento
de acordo com as possibilidades das atividades, conforme os objetivos da visita. E a opção “Nenhum”
está associada a eventos e atividades próprias de aulas práticas ou visitas técnicas, nas quais não há
necessidade de monitor, uma vez que se trata de atividade dirigida por instrutor ou professor vinculado
ao grupo de visitantes. A Figura 8 apresenta a frequência relativa das opções selecionadas. A opção “Nenhum” foi
pouco computada (n=66), e a opção “Todos”, a mais selecionada (n=1.451). Todavia, ao se fazer a
decomposição das opções, foi percebido que a opção mais selecionada foi “Caminhada pelas Trilhas”, o
que, de certa forma, confirma a motivação das visitas. Os dados na Figura 8 mostram as motivações
relacionadas à experiência de enriquecimento e ao conhecimento escolar (Quadro 3). Figura 8 – Frequência relativa de solicitações de visitas a partir da escolha das estações de visita do Bosque da
Ciência (2016 a 2018). Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 18
Fonte: Dados reconstruídos pelo pesquisador. Entretanto, a diferença entre a opção mais assinalada e a menos assinalada é de
aproximadamente 21,4% (n=396), confirmando que todas as opções são bem solicitadas. O NRC (2009)
sugere percursos de visita, que sejam como narrativas para que cada estação contribua para a construção
de sentido ao visitante – ele individualmente ou em grupo, todavia, em ambientes fechados normalmente. Isso é relativamente mais controlável em ambientes planejados e fechados. Porém, conforme já foi dito,
os ambientes abertos possuem as limitações de o acervo ser plantado, as edificações serem fixas e sujeitas
ao intemperismo, às estações do ano e ao horário do dia. CONSIDERAÇÕES FINAIS escolarizar o passeio, mas permitir que ele seja plural para grupos diversos. Isso fica evidente devido à
missão do parque e suas atividades diversificadas, operacionalizadas pelos monitores de recepção e de
paisagismo; e à agenda do Bosque da Ciência com atividades variadas, como foi mostrado, a Semana do
Meio Ambiente e a Semana de Ciência e Tecnologia, as quais recebem diversas audiências, sendo a visita
estimulada nessas datas, com catraca aberta. Um ponto importante na comunicação desenvolvida no ECT Bosque da Ciência é
reconhecer o objeto de observação, que é a razão da experiência e da atividade, e reconhecê-lo como um
patrimônio em CT. Entende-se que o conceito adaptado de patrimônio não deve se limitar à espécie a
ser preservada, mas ser estendido à noção de identidade e pertencimento ao universo amazônico,
considerando que patrimônio é algo que traz o sentimento de posse, de vínculo a algo a que se pertence:
é amazônico, é brasileiro, e é da humanidade, de acordo com a Portaria nº 422/2017 MC/IBM, o ICOM
e a Constituição Federal do Brasil (BRASIL, 1988). A partir desse conceito, considera-se que o Bosque
da Ciência realiza o processo de musealização como patrimônio das riquezas amazônicas, vivas e
presentes, numa forma inovadora e distinta em relação aos museus cobertos. p
ç
A identidade institucional de parque temático para museu vivo formalmente eleva, a um
novo degrau, o conceito organizacional e o diálogo com integração entre os laboratórios. Os princípios
de educação museal da Portaria nº 422/2017, Artigo 4º, nivelam o museu a uma instituição de educação
não formal e esclarecem a necessidade de um processo educativo organizado, de orientação teórico-
prático plural, em diálogo com a sociedade, levando-se em conta uma equipe pedagógica multidisciplinar,
a construção de plano educativo e cultural, na busca de assegurar o conceito de Patrimônio Integral e
assim colaborar para a promoção da cidadania e do desenvolvimento regional. A sensibilidade de uma identidade institucional voltada ao patrimônio amazônico exige uma
organização de projetos que envolve uma equipe de profissionais, com captação de recursos de longo
prazo para uma adequação de um museu, e não só de um laboratório, espaço este que, muitas vezes,
executa suas propostas com poucos recursos. CONSIDERAÇÕES FINAIS As considerações aqui apresentadas ocorrem em função do objetivo da pesquisa em uma
síntese dos resultados principais da caracterização de um ECT amazônico e no reforço da associação
deste espaço não formal ao conceito de Patrimônio Integral e ao ensino de Ciências. O Bosque da Ciência
é uma instituição única por suas características – inicialmente, por ter seu enquadramento como Parque
Temático e, por conseguinte, pelo fato de ser análogo ao museu de Ciência por essa razão. Ademais, por
um lado, o Bosque da Ciência conduz a um lazer científico e ambiental, o que lhe dá uma identidade
própria de Parque Temático para a ludicidade; e, por outro lado, aproxima-se menos da ideia de Centro
de Ciências que prima pelo experimento e pela aplicação de conceitos científicos. A equipe de trabalho ligada à Coordenação de Extensão gerencia o espaço em conjunto com
os laboratórios de pesquisa do INPA e realiza a DC com papéis distintos: (i) a CAAV gerencia com os
monitores as visitas de recepção e a execução do Projeto Circuito da Ciência; (ii) os laboratórios presentes
no parque expõem material informativo, como banner e placas interpretativas de sua área de pesquisa
que julgam importante popularizar. q
j g
p
p p
A DC é desenvolvida na temática científica e ambiental. É científica devido à presença de
criadouros científicos 14 com presença de mídias interpretativas com informações ligadas a esses
criadouros, como o caso do peixe-boi e dos quelônios do CEQUA. É ambiental devido ao fato de o
ambiente aberto ter o apelo natural da imersão florestal e, dessa forma, associar-se à conservação dos
espécimes amazônicos. A própria documentação do Bosque assume essa temática e se confirma pela
solicitação de visita com motivação de experiência de enriquecimento e pelas escolhas ao realizarem as
trilhas. O público visitante predominante é o escolar, em especial a educação infantil e o ensino
fundamental. Mas há a presença de diversos grupos. Dessa forma, o parque assume um papel de não 19 escolarizar o passeio, mas permitir que ele seja plural para grupos diversos. Isso fica evidente devido à
missão do parque e suas atividades diversificadas, operacionalizadas pelos monitores de recepção e de
paisagismo; e à agenda do Bosque da Ciência com atividades variadas, como foi mostrado, a Semana do
Meio Ambiente e a Semana de Ciência e Tecnologia, as quais recebem diversas audiências, sendo a visita
estimulada nessas datas, com catraca aberta. CONSIDERAÇÕES FINAIS Sobre a contribuição para a educação, pode-se explicitar, sobre a interação com o ECT
Bosque da Ciência, que: a) é um ambiente para experiência de enriquecimento e potencial de
interdisciplinaridade devido à caracterização das exposições; b) o uso escolar do espaço é menos
frequente na educação básica do que no ensino superior, devido à necessidade de preparação da visita e
possíveis recortes para o trabalho analítico, ou seja, visita a poucas exposições e mais interação dialogal
e analítica sobre o objeto de aprendizagem e os conteúdos escolares; c) o papel lúdico do espaço enfatiza
o aspecto estético da percepção do ambiente natural, a visualização dos animais e plantas e o impacto da
imersão florestal junto às consciências dos visitantes, fazendo o que os monitores entendem como “[...]
tentando despertar no visitante o interesse maior pela paisagem natural do local”. Esse entendimento do plano educativo e cultural por meio de uma equipe multidisciplinar
sobre a ação educativa não é contraditório ao caráter lúdico e estético. Acredita-se que um dialogismo
entre ambos é possível para a construção de um plano educativo cultural baseado no edutenimento, uma
vez que devem ser observadas as características locais que tanto atraem as pessoas. Há a necessidade de
tornar inteligível uma mensagem científica e ambiental, num trabalho de mútua contribuição entre
laboratórios e a CAAV, neste esforço para uma versão da Amazônia a ser divulgada, uma versão que
prime pela ciência e tecnologia com respeito ao ambiente. Por fim, o Bosque da Ciência, como um exemplo de ECT de DC, permite compreender
como o local está associado ao regional em presença de temas e objetos de pesquisa e de DC em nível
institucional. No caso, o INPA apresenta, por meio do parque, elementos e recortes do bioma
amazônico, que podem favorecer o conhecimento e o autoconhecimento que os amazônidas possuem
de interagir no contexto urbano e em diálogo com informações científicas e ambientais. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 REFERÊNCIAS ABCMC – ASSOCIAÇÃO BRASILEIRA DE CENTROS E MUSEUS DE CIÊNCIA. Centros e
museus de Ciência do Brasil 2015. Rio de Janeiro: ABCMC: UFRJ. FCC. CC; Fiocruz. Museu da Vida,
2015. ALENCAR, Raimundo N. B.; FACHÍN-TERÁN, Augusto; BARBOSA, Ierecê. S. O processo de
aprendizagem das crianças da pré-escola usando o “peixe-boi-da-amazônia” (Trichechus inunguis). In:
FACHÍN-TERÁN, Augusto; SEIFFERT-SANTOS, Saulo C. Novas perspectivas de ensino de ciências em
espaços não formais amazônicos. Manaus: UEA Edições, 2016. ARAGÓN, Luis E. Amazônia, conhecer para desenvolver e conservar: cinco temas para um debate. São Paulo:
Hucitec, 2013. AZEVEDO, Genoveva C.; HIGUCHI, Maria Inês G.; BARCELOS, Valdo. Contribuição do INPA na
formação continuada de professores em educação ambiental: desafios, práticas e reflexões. Ambiente &
Educação –Revista de Educação Ambiental, s.l., v. 14, n. 1, p. 89-109, 2009. BARCELLAR, Clarissa. A sobrevivência das espécies e o comprometimento do manejo florestal. Revista de Divulgação Científica do INPA, Manaus, v. 3, n. 7, p. 6-9, 2011. BARDIN, Laurence. Análise de conteúdo. 4. ed. Lisboa: Edições 70, 2009. BARROSO, Antônia L. F.; MESQUITA, Rita de Cássia G. Subsídios para a gestão de jardins
botânicos no Brasil – O caso do Jardim Botânico Adolpho Ducke de Manaus. Rodriguesia, s.l., v. 65, n. 3, p. 791-805, 2014. BASSOLI, Fernanda. O processo de apropriação da bioexposição a célula ao alcance da mão em um
centro de Ciências: desafios da mediação. Ensaio Pesquisa em Educação em Ciências, Belo Horizonte, v. 15,
n. 1, p. 155-174, abr. 2013. BATISTA, Daniel; VASCONCELLOS, Regina; FACHÍN-TERÁN, Augusto. A presença do lúdico no
evento Circuito da Ciência, Manaus, Amazonas, Brasil. Areté Revista Amazônica de Ensino de Ciências,
Manaus, v. 8, n. 15, p. 165-174, 4 maio 2015. BIZERRA, Alessandra; MARANDINO, Martha. Mediação em museus de Ciências: contribuições da
teoria histórico-cultural. Museologia & Interdisciplinaridade, s.l., n. 5, p. 113-130, 2014. BONATTO, Maria Paula. Parque da ciência Fiocruz: onde a saúde é o tema. In: CRESTANA, Silvério
et al. (Orgs.). Educação para a ciência: curso de treinamento em centros e museus de ciências. São Paulo:
Editora Livraria da Física, 2001. p. 337-344. BRASIL. Constituição Federal da República do Brasil de 1988. Promulgada em 5 de outubro de 1988. Disponível em: http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/constituicao/constituição.htm. Acesso em: 1
maio 2020. BRASIL. Instituto Brasileiro de Museus. Portaria n° 422, de 30 de novembro de 2017 – Dispõe sobre a
Política Nacional de Educação Museal – PNEM e dá outras providências. Diário Oficial da União,
Brasília, p. Agradecimento Este trabalho foi realizado com o apoio da Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de
Nível Superior – Brasil (CAPES) –, Código de Financiamento 001. A licença de estudo em pós-graduação
da Universidade Federal do Amazonas. S.D.g. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 20 20 Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 REFERÊNCIAS 12-14, 2017. BUENO, Carlos. R. Instituto Nacional de Pesquisa da Amazônia: Bosque da Ciência/Casa da Ciência. In: CRESTANA, Silvério et al. Educação para a ciência: curso de treinamento em centro e museus de
ciências. São Paulo: Editora Livraria da Física, 2001. p. 357-360. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 21 21 BUENO, Wilson C. José Reis: a divulgação científica como compromisso. Comunicação & Sociedade, s.l.,
v. 24, n. 38, p. 227-235, 2002. BUENO, Wilson C. José Reis: a divulgação científica como compromisso. Comunicação &
v. 24, n. 38, p. 227-235, 2002. CARVALHO, Tassiana F. G.; PACCA, Jesuína L. A. A aprendizagem num museu de ciência e o papel
do monitor. Investigações em Ensino de Ciências, Porto Alegre, v. 20, n. 1, p. 167-180, 2015. CGEE – CENTRO DE GESTÃO E ESTUDOS ESTRATÉGICOS. Percepção Pública da C&T no Brasil
– 2019. Resumo executivo. [s.l.: s.n.], 2019. CHAGAS, Isabel. Aprendizagem não formal/formal das Ciências. Relações entre os Museus de
Ciência e as escolas. Revista de Educação, s.l., v. 3, n. 1993, p. 51-59, 1993. COEXT. INPA Instituto Nacional de Pesquisa da Amazônia. COEXT/INPA: Manaus, 2018. COEXT. Projeto Circuito da Ciência: a ciência mais perto de você. INPA: Manaus, 2012. COSTA, Graziela G.; IMHOFF, Ana Lúcia; BORGES, Regina M. R. O centro de ciências de São
Paulo – CECISP. In: BORGES, Regina M. R.; IMHOFF, Ana Lúcia; BARCELLOS, Guy B. Educação e
cultura científica e tecnológica: centros e museus de ciências no Brasil. Porto Alegre: EDIPUCRS, 2015. p. 157-168. CRESTANA, Silvério; HAMBURGER, Ernest W.; SILVA, Dilma N.; MASCARENHAS, Sérgio
(Orgs.). Educação para a ciência: curso para treinamento em centros e museus de ciências. São Paulo:
Editora Livraria da Física, 2001. FALK, John H.; STORKSDIECK, Martin. Using the contextual model of learning to understand
visitor learning from a science center exhibition. Science education, s.l., v. 89, n. 5, p. 744-778, 2005. FLOREZ, Lilian S.; SANJAD, Nelson; OKADA, Wanda. Construção do espaço museal: Ciência,
educação e sociabilidade na gênese do Parque Zoobotânico do Museu Goeldi (1895–1914). Anais do
Museu Paulista: História e Cultura Material, São Paulo, v. 26, 8 out. 2018. e15. Disponível em:
https://doi.org/10.1590/1982-02672018v26e15. Acesso em: 21 jul. 2021. Epub 08 Out 2018. ISSN
1982-0267. FONSECA, Ozório M. Pensando a Amazônia. Manaus: Editora Valer, 2011. FRIEDMAN, Alan J. The evolution of the science museum. Physics Today, s.l., v. 63, n. 10, p. 45-51,
out. 2010. HIGUCHI, Maria Inês G.; FARIAS, Maria Solange M. REFERÊNCIAS Pequenos guias do Bosque da Ciência: trajetória de
experiência de educação ambiental com crianças na Amazônia. Manaus: INPA, 2002. HOOPER-GREENHILL, Eilean. Learning in art museums: strategies of interpretation. In: The
educational role of the museum. [s.l.: s.n.], 1999. p. 44-52. INPA. Plano de Trabalho: Metas individuais (servidores técnicos). Manaus: CAAV, 2018a. INPA. Plano de Trabalho – Recepção. Manaus: CAAV, 2018b. INPA. Plano de Trabalho – Recepção. Manaus: CAAV, 2018b. INSTITUTO BRASILEIRO DE MUSEUS. Guia dos Museus Brasileiros/Instituto Brasileiro de Museus. Brasília: Instituto Brasileiro de Museus, 2011. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 22 22 KATZ, Phyllis et al. Professional Identity Development of Teacher Candidates Participating in an
Informal Science Education Internship: A focus on drawings as evidence. International Journal of Science
Education, s.l., v. 33, n. 9, p. 1169-1197, 2011. Disponível em:
https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2010.489928. Acesso em: 1 maio 2019. KATZ, Phyllis et al. Professional Identity Development of Teacher Candidates Participating in an
Informal Science Education Internship: A focus on drawings as evidence. International Journal of Science
Education, s.l., v. 33, n. 9, p. 1169-1197, 2011. Disponível em:
https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2010.489928. Acesso em: 1 maio 2019. LONDOÑO, Germán; SOLBES, Jordi; GUISASOLA, Jenaro. Aprovechamiento conceptual y
actitudinal de las visitas a un parque temático. Didáctica de las ciencias experimentales y sociales, s.l., n. 23, p. 71-92, 2009. LOUREIRO, João J. P. Cultura Amazônica: uma poética do imaginário. 5. ed. Manaus: Editora Valer,
2015. LUEHMANN, April. Students’ Perspectives of a Science Enrichment Programme: Out-of-school
inquiry as access. International Journal of Science Education, s.l., v. 31, n. 13, p. 1831-1855, 2009. Disponível
em: https://doi.org/10.1080/09500690802354195. Acesso em: 1 maio 2019. MACIEL, Hiléia M.; FACHÍN-TERÁN, Augusto. O potencial pedagógico dos espaços não formais da cidade de
Manaus. Curitiba: Editora CRV, 2014. MAIA, Beatriz; BERGAMINI, Cristiane; CASTRO, Paula D. Divulgação científica na América Latina
enfrenta desafios de alcançar públicos heterogêneos. ComCiência, n. 197, p. online, 2018. Disponível em:
http://www.comciencia.br/divulgacao-cientifica-na-america-latina-enfrenta-desafio-de-alcancar-
publicos-heterogeneos/. Acesso em: 13 fev. 2021. MALHEIROS, Bruno T. Metodologia da pesquisa em educação. Rio de Janeiro: LTC, 2011. MARANDINO, Martha. Educação em museus: a mediação em foco. São Paulo: GEENF/FEUSP, 2008. MARANDINO, Martha. O conhecimento biológico nas exposições de museus de ciências: análise do processo de
construção do discurso expositivo. 2001. 450f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação) – Faculdade de
Educação, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 2001. MARTINS, Paula C. S. et al. O circuito da Ciência: uma estratégia desafiadora para o ensino de Ciências
na região Amazônica. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 REFERÊNCIAS In: SIMPÓSIO DE EDUCAÇÃO EM CIÊNCIAS NA AMAZÔNIA, Manaus. Anais... Manaus: UEA, 2015. MCMANUS, Paulette M. Topics in museums and science education. Studies in Science Education, s.l., v. 20, n. 1, p. 157-182, 1992. MORENO, Tabajara. De portas abertas para a comunidade. Revista de Divulgação Científica do INPA,
Manaus, v. 1, n. 2, p. 58-61, 2009. MOTA, Elizângela; FACHÍN-TERÁN, Augusto; GONZAGA, Amarildo. O projeto circuito da
ciência: análise do comportamento dos estudantes em relação à questão ambiental. Areté Revista
Amazônica de Ensino de Ciências, Manaus, v. 8, n. 15, p. 175-181, 4 maio 2015. NASCIMENTO, Silvana S. A relação museu e escola na prática docente: tensões de uma atividade
educativa. In: DALBEN, Angela; DINIZ, Júlio; LEAL, Leiva; SANTOS, Lucíola (Orgs.). Convergências e
tensões no campo da formação e do trabalho docente. Belo Horizonte: Autêntica, 2010. p. 357-369. NORONHA, Evelyn; SANTOS, Gilmara; CARVALHO, Márcia. O Projeto Circuito da Ciência do
Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas da Amazônia (INPA): contribuições para a alfabetização científica. Areté Revista Amazônica de Ensino de Ciências, Manaus, v. 6, n. 11, p. 179-194, 2013. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 23 23 NRC – NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL. Learning Science in Informal Environments: People, Places,
and Pursuits. In: BELL, Philip et al. (Eds.) Washington-DC: The Nacional Academies Press, 2009. PADILLA, Jorge. Museos y Centros de Ciencia en México. In: CRESTANA, Silvério et al. (Orgs.). Educação para a ciência: curso de treinamento em centros e museus de ciências. São Paulo: Editora
Livraria da Física, 2001. p. 41-58. PALHARES, José A. Reflexões sobre o não-escolar na escola e para além dela. Revista Portuguesa de
Educação, s.l., v. 22, p. 53-84, 2009. PASCUAL, Morentin M.; ARANZABAL, Jenaro G. La visita a un museo de ciencias en la formación
inicial del profesorado de Educación Primaria. Revista Eureka sobre Enseñanza y Divulgación de las Ciencias,
s.l., v. 11, n. 3, p. 364-380, 2014. PAVÃO, Antonio C.; LEITÃO, Ângela. Hands-on? Minds-on? Hearts-on? Social-on? Explainers-on! In: MASSARANI, Luisa (Org.). Diálogos & ciência: mediação em museus e centros de ciência. Rio de
Janeiro: Casa de Oswaldo Cruz: Fiocruz, 2007. p. 40-47. POLINO, Carmelo. Las encuestas de percepción pública de la ciencia en América Latina: estructura,
evolución y comparabilidad. In: MASSARANI, Luisa (Ed.). RedPOP: 25 años de popularización de la
ciencia en América Latina. Rio de Janeiro: Fiocruz: RedPOP; Montevidéu: Unesco, 2015. p. 95-108. QUEIRÓZ, Glória et al. REFERÊNCIAS O Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas da Amazônia
(INPA) e o seu papel na popularização da Ciência em Manaus. História da Ciência e Ensino: construindo
interfaces, v. 22, p. 67-85, 2020. Disponível em:
https://revistas.pucsp.br/index.php/hcensino/article/view/49326. Acesso em: 27 dez. 2020. SEIFFERT-SANTOS, Saulo C.; FACHÍN-TERÁN, Augusto. O uso da expressão espaços não
formais no ensino de Ciências. Areté Revista Amazônica de Ensino de Ciências, Manaus, v. 6, n. 11, p. 01-15,
2013. SILVA, Glauciane S.; SHIMADA, Marly S.; ALENCAR, Mary S. D.; FACHÍN-TERÁN, Augusto. Participação dos estudantes do ensino fundamental no circuito da ciência e aprendizagem dos
conteúdos sobre o ensino de ciências. Areté Revista Amazônica de Ensino de Ciências, Manaus, v. 8, n. 15,
p. 140-153, 2015. SUESCUN FLÓREZ, Lílian; MORAIS, Silvilene; SCHEINER, Tereza C.; REIS, Maria Amélia. Qual o
discurso privilegiado nos jardins botânicos? tensões e aproximações entre linguagem científica e
linguagem leiga. Revista Eletrônica do Programa de Pós-Graduação em Museologia e Patrimônio, s.l., v. 5, n. 1, p. 3-28, 2012. VOLÓCHINOV, Valentin N.; BAKHTIN, Mikhail M. [1927]. O freudismo. 2. ed. São Paulo:
Perspectiva, 2017. WAGENSBERG, Jorge. Principios fundamentales de la museología científica moderna. B.MM
Cuaderno Central, s.l., n. 55, 2001. Disponível em:
http://www.bcn.cat/publicacions/bmm/quadern_central/bmm55/5.Wagensberg.pdf. Acesso em: 18
jun. 2019. REFERÊNCIAS Construindo saberes da mediação na educação em museus de ciências: o caso
dos mediadores do museu de astronomia e ciências afins/ Brasil. Revista Brasileira de Pesquisa em Educação
em Ciências, s.l., v. 2, n. 2, p. 77-88, 28 nov. 2011. RICHARDSON, Roberto J. Pesquisa social e técnicas. 3. ed. 14. reimp. São Paulo: Atlas, 2012. RODARI, Paola; MERZAGORA, Matteo. Mediadores em museus e centros de ciência: Status, papéis
e treinamento. Uma visão geral europeia. In: Diálogos & Ciência: mediação em museus e centros de
Ciência. Rio de Janeiro: Museu da Vida: Casa de Oswaldo Cruz: Fiocruz, 2007. p. 7-20. SABIESCU, Amalia; CHARATZOPOULOU, Katerina. The Museum as Ecosystem and Museums in
Learning Ecosystems. In: SPRINGER (Ed.). Museum Experience Design. [s.l.] Springer, Cham, 2018, p. 325-345. SANJAD, Nelson; OREN, David C.; SILVA JUNIOR, José S.; HOOGMOED, Marinus S.;
HIGUCHI, Horácio. Documentos para a história do mais antigo jardim zoológico do Brasil: o Parque
Zoobotânico do Museu Goeldi. Bol. Mus. Para. Emílio Goeldi. Cienc. Hum, Belém, v. 7, n. 1, p. 197-258,
2012. SEIFFERT-SANTOS, Saulo C. O discurso expositivo de um espaço amazônico de educação não formal em Ciência
e Tecnologia: o caso do Bosque da Ciência. 2020. 338f. Tese (Doutorado em Educação em Ciências) –
Programa de Pós-Graduação em Educação em Ciências e Educação Matemática, Unioeste, Cascavel,
2020a. SEIFFERT-SANTOS, Saulo C. Uma visão sobre os museus de ciências como espaços não formais: o
Bosque da Ciência um exemplo amazônico. REAMEC – Rede Amazônica de Educação em Ciências e
Matemática, Manaus, v. 8, n. 3, p. 415-434, 1 out. 2020b. SEIFFERT-SANTOS, Saulo C. Uma visão sobre os museus de ciências como espaços não formais: o
Bosque da Ciência um exemplo amazônico. REAMEC – Rede Amazônica de Educação em Ciências e
Matemática, Manaus, v. 8, n. 3, p. 415-434, 1 out. 2020b. Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022 24 24 SEIFFERT-SANTOS, Saulo C.; CUNHA, Márcia B. A pesquisa em espaços de educação não formal
em Ciências na Região Norte: o caso do Bosque da Ciência. Amazônia RECM, Belém, v. 14, n. 32, p. 160-173, 2018. SEIFFERT-SANTOS, Saulo C.; CUNHA, Márcia B. A tradição de pesquisa segundo Laudan em
educação em espaços não formais num evento de ensino de Ciências. Góndola, Enseñanza y Aprendizaje
de las Ciencias, s.l., v. 14, n. 1, p. 88-107, 2019. SEIFFERT-SANTOS, Saulo C.; CUNHA, Márcia B. CONTRIBUIÇÃO DOS AUTORES Autor 1 – Coordenador do projeto, coleta de dados, análise dos dados e escrita do texto. Autora 2 – Orientadora do projeto, participação ativa na análise dos dados e revisão da escrita final. Autor 1 – Coordenador do projeto, coleta de dados, análise dos dados e escrita do texto. Autora 2 – Orientadora do projeto, participação ativa na análise dos dados e revisão da escrita fi Submetido: 13/02/2021
Aprovado: 08/09/2021 DECLARAÇÃO DE CONFLITO DE INTERESSE Os autores declaram que não há conflito de interesse com o presente artigo. Submetido: 13/02/2021
Aprovado: 08/09/2021 Submetido: 13/02/2021
Aprovado: 08/09/2021 Educação em Revista|Belo Horizonte|v.38|e29448|2022
|
https://openalex.org/W3203998766
|
https://aclanthology.org/2021.inlg-1.20.pdf
|
English
| null |
Single Example Can Improve Zero-Shot Data Generation
| null | 2,021
|
cc-by
| 7,653
|
1
Introduction Training dialogue systems used by virtual assis-
tants in task-oriented applications requires large
annotated datasets. The core machine learning task
to every dialogue system is intent detection, which
aims to detect what the intention of the user is. New
intents emerge when new applications, supported
by the dialogue systems, are launched. However,
an extension to new intents may require annotating
additional data, which may be time-consuming and
costly. What is more, when developing a new dia-
logue system, one may face the cold start problem
if little training data is available. Open sources
provide general domain annotated datasets, primar-
ily collected via crowd-sourcing or released from
commercial systems, such as Snips NLU bench-
mark (Coucke et al., 2018). However, it is usually
problematic to gather more specific data from any
source, including user logs, protected by the pri- 4. We apply reinforcement learning for the one-
shot generation to eliminate the semantic shift
problem. The one-shot approach retains se-
mantic accuracy without sacrificing fluency
and diversity. Abstract Sub-tasks of intent classification, such as ro-
bustness to distribution shift, adaptation to spe-
cific user groups and personalization, out-of-
domain detection, require extensive and flex-
ible datasets for experiments and evaluation. As collecting such datasets is time- and labor-
consuming, we propose to use text generation
methods to gather datasets. The generator
should be trained to generate utterances that
belong to the given intent. We explore two
approaches to generating task-oriented utter-
ances. In the zero-shot approach, the model
is trained to generate utterances from seen in-
tents and is further used to generate utterances
for intents unseen during training. In the one-
shot approach, the model is presented with a
single utterance from a test intent. We perform
a thorough automatic, and human evaluation
of the dataset generated utilizing two proposed
approaches. Our results reveal that the at-
tributes of the generated data are close to orig-
inal test sets, collected via crowd-sourcing. For all these reasons, we suggest a learnable ap-
proach to create training data for intent detection. We simulate a real-life situation in which no anno-
tated data but rather only a short description of a
new intent is available. To this end, we propose to
use methods for zero-shot conditional text gener-
ation to generate plausible utterances from intent
descriptions. The generated utterances should be
in line with the intent’s meaning. Our contributions are: 1. We propose a zero-shot generation method
to generate a task-oriented utterance from an
intent description; 2. We evaluate the generated utterances and
compare them to the original crowd-sourced
datasets. The proposed zero-shot method
achieves high scores in fluency and diversity
as per our human evaluation; 3. We provide experimental evidence of a seman-
tic shift when generating utterances for unseen
classes using the zero-shot approach; A Single Example Can Improve Zero-Shot Data Generation A Single Example Can Improve Zero-Shot Data Generation
Pavel Burnyshev1, Valentin Malykh1,2, Andrey Bout1, Ekaterina Artemova1,3, and Irina Piontkovskaya1
1Huawei Noah’s Ark Lab, Moscow, Russia
2Kazan Federal University, Kazan, Russia
3HSE University, Moscow, Russia
{burnyshev.pavel, malykh.valentin, bout.andrey, artemova.ekaterina, piontkovskaya.irina}@huawei.com vacy policy in real-life settings. Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Natural Language Generation (INLG), pages 201–211,
Aberdeen, Scotland, UK, 20-24 September 2021. ©2021 Association for Computational Linguistics 2
Related work Conditional language modelling
generalizes
the task of language modelling. Given some con-
ditioning context z, it assigns probabilities to a
sequence of tokens (Mikolov and Zweig, 2012). Machine translation (Sutskever et al., 2014; Cho
et al., 2014) and image captioning (You et al., 2016)
are seen as typical conditional language modelling
tasks. More sophisticated tasks include text ab-
stractive summarization (Nallapati et al., 2017;
Narayan et al., 2019) and simplification (Zhang 201 and Lapata, 2017), generating textual comments to
source code (Richardson et al., 2017) and dialogue
modelling (Lowe et al., 2017). Structured data
may act as a conditioning context as well. Knowl-
edge base (KB) entries (Vougiouklis et al., 2018)
or DBPedia triples (Colin et al., 2016) serve as
condition to generated plausible factual sentences. Neural models for conditional language modelling
rely on encoder-decoder architectures and can be
learned both jointly from scratch (Vaswani et al.,
2017) or by fine-tuning pre-trained encoder and
decoder models (Budzianowski and Vuli´c, 2019;
Lewis et al., 2020). latent distributions (Xia et al., 2021), simple heuris-
tics, such as synonym replacement (Wei and Zou,
2019) and oversampling (Chawla et al., 2002). Few-
shot text generation has been applied to natural lan-
guage generation from structured data, such as ta-
bles (Chen et al., 2020) and to intent detection data
augmentation (Xia et al., 2021). However, these
methods are incompatible with ZSL, requiring at
least a few labeled examples for the class being aug-
mented. An alternative approach suggests to use a
model to generate data for the target class based on
task-specific world knowledge (Chen et al., 2017)
and linguistic features (Iyyer et al., 2018). Deep reinforcement learning (RL)
methods
prove to be effective in a variety of NLP tasks. Early works approach the tasks of machine trans-
lation (Grissom II et al., 2014), image captioning
(Rennie et al., 2017) and abstractive summariza-
tion (Paulus et al., 2017), assessed with not differen-
tiable metrics. (Wu et al., 2021) tries to improve the
quality of transformer-derived pre-trained models
for generation by leveraging proximal policy opti-
mization. Other applications of deep RL include
dialogue modeling (Li et al., 2016b) and open-
domain question answering (Wang et al., 2018). Zero-shot learning (ZSL)
has formed as a rec-
ognized training paradigm with neural models be-
coming more potent in the majority of downstream
tasks. 3
Methods Our main goal is to generate plausible and coherent
utterances, which relate to unseen intents, lever-
aging the description of the intent only. These
utterances should clearly express the desired intent. For example, if conditioned on the intent “delivery
from the grocery store” the model should generate
an utterance close to “Hi! Please bring me milk
and eggs from the nearest convenience store” or
similar. Zero-shot conditional text generation
implies
that the model is trained in such a way that it can
generalize to an unseen condition, for which only a
description is provided. A few recent works in this
direction show-case dialog generation from unseen
domains (Zhao and Eskenazi, 2018) and question
generation from KB’s from unseen predicates and
entity types (Elsahar et al., 2018). CTRL (Keskar
et al., 2019), pre-trained on so-called control codes,
which can be combined to govern style, content,
and surface form, provides for zero-shot generation
for unseen codes combinations. PPLM (Dathathri
et al., 2019) uses signals, representing the class,
e.g., bag-of-words, during inference, and can gener-
ate examples with given semantic attributes without
pre-training. Two scenarios can be used to achieve this goal. In
the zero-shot scenario, we train the model on a
set of seen intents S to generate utterances. If the
generation model generalizes well, the utterances
generated for unseen intents U are diverse and flu-
ent and retain intents’ semantics. In the one-shot
scenario, we utilize one utterance per unseen in-
tent U to train the generation model and learn the
semantics of this particular intent. Training data generation
can be treated as form
of data augmentation, a research direction being in-
creasingly in demand. It enlarges datasets for train-
ing neural models and help avoid labor-intensive
and costly manual annotation. Common tech-
niques for textual data augmentation include back-
translation (Sennrich et al., 2016), sampling from 2
Related work In the NLP domain, the ZSL scenario aims
at assigning a label to a piece of text based on the
label description. The learned classifier becomes
able to assign class labels, which were unseen dur-
ing the training time. The classification task is then
reformulated in the form of question answering
(Levy et al., 2017) or textual entailment (Yin et al.,
2019). Other techniques for ZSL leverage metric
learning and make use of capsule networks (Du
et al., 2019) and prototyping networks (Yu et al.,
2019). 3.1
Zero-shot generation Our model as depicted in Figure 1) aims to generate
plausible utterances conditioned on the intent de-
scription. We fine-tune the GPT-2 medium model 202 (Radford et al., 2019) on task-oriented utterances,
collected from several NLU benchmarks (see Sec-
tion 5.1 for more details on the dataset). is ambiguous or contains ambiguous words. Pro-
duced utterances may distort the initial meaning
of the intent or be meaningless at all. The model
may generate an utterance “Count the number of
people in the United States” for the intent “cal-
culator”, or “Add a book by Shakespeare to the
calendar” for a “book reading” service. Although
such examples can be treated not as outliers but
rather as real-life whimsical utterances, this is not
the desired behavior for the generation model. We
address this phenomenon as Semantic Shift and
provide experimental evidence of it in Section 5.4. Input
Utterance
Intent
description
Language Model
Output
I
want
to
book
a
table
MASK
MASK
MASK
MASK
I
want
to
book
a
table
[
reserve
restaurant
]
Figure 1: Training setup. The input an intent descrip-
tion and an utterance concatenated, the output is the
utterance. Figure 1: Training setup. The input an intent descrip-
tion and an utterance concatenated, the output is the
utterance. Based on these observations, we hypothesize that
the problem could be solved if we provide a single
training example to improve models’ generaliza-
tion abilities. A single example can give the model
a clue about what the virtual assistant can do with
books and which entities our calculator is designed
to calculate by gaining better world knowledge. For this purpose, we are moving from the zero-shot
to the one-shot setting. We propose a method for
improving zero-shot generation by leveraging just
one example. Our approach to fine-tuning the GPT-2 model fol-
lows (Budzianowski and Vuli´c, 2019). Two pieces
of information, the intent description and the utter-
ance are concatenated to form the input. More pre-
cisely, the input has the following format: [intent
description] utterance. During the training phase,
the model is presented with the output obtained
from the input by masking the intent description. The output has the following format: <MASK>, . . .,
<MASK> utterance. The full list of intents is pro-
vided in Table 4 in Appendix. Our approach is inspired by the recent TextGAIL
(Wu et al., 2021) approach. 3.1
Zero-shot generation It addresses the prob-
lem of exposure bias in pre-trained language mod-
els and proposes a GAN-like style scheme for fine-
tuning GPT-2 to produce appropriate story end-
ings using a reinforcement algorithm. As a reward,
TextGAIL uses a discriminator output trained to
distinguish real samples from generated samples. As we are limited in using learnable discriminators
because of the lack of training data, we propose an
objective function based on a similarity score. Our
objective function produces utterances, which are
close to the reference example. At the same time,
it forces the model to generate more diverse and
plausible utterances. Table 5 in Appendix provides
reference examples used for the one-shot genera-
tion method. Such input allows the model to pay attention to
intent tokens while generating. The standard lan-
guage modeling objective, negative log-likelihood
loss, is used to train the model: L (θ) = −
X
i
|x(i)|
X
t=1
log pθ
x(i)
t |intent, x(i)
<t
. We fine-tuned the model for one epoch to avoid
over-fitting. Otherwise, the model tends to repeat
redundant semantic constructions of the input utter-
ances. At the same time, a bias towards the words
from the training set gets formed. The parameters
of the training used were set to the following val-
ues: batch size equals to 32, learning rate equals to
5e-5, the optimizer chosen is Adam (Kingma and
Ba, 2015) with default parameters. Method. After zero-shot fine-tuning, we perform
a one-shot model update for each intent separately. We perform several steps of the Proximal Policy
Optimization algorithm (Schulman et al., 2017)
with the objective function described further. 3.3
Decoding strategies Recent studies show that a properly chosen decod-
ing strategy significantly improves consistency and
diversity metrics and human scores of generated
samples for multiple generation tasks, such as story
generation (Holtzman et al., 2019), open-domain
dialogues, and image captioning (Ippolito et al.,
2019). However, to the best of our knowledge, no
method proved to be a one-size-fits-all one. We
perform experiments with several decoding strate-
gies, which improve diversity while preserving the
desired meaning. We perform an experimental eval-
uation of different decoding parameters. It is not enough to reward the model only for the
similarity of the generated utterance to the refer-
ence one. If so, the model tends to repeat the ref-
erence example and receives the maximal reword. We add the negative sum of frequencies of all n-
grams in the utterance to the reward function, forc-
ing the model to generate less frequent sequences. Beam Search, a standard decoding mechanism,
keeps the top b partial hypotheses at every time
step and eventually chooses the hypothesis that has
the overall highest probability. Given an intent I and a reference example xI
ref,
the reward for the sentence x is calculated by the
formula: Random Sampling (top-k) (Fan et al., 2018)
greedily samples at each time step one of the top-k
most likely tokens in the distribution. RI(x) = Rsim(xI
ref, x) + Rdiv(x)
Rsim(xI
ref, x) = BERTScore(xI
ref, x)
Rdiv(x) =
X
s∈n-grams(x)
(−νs)
where νs is the n-gram frequency, calculated from
all the generated utterances inside one batch RI(x) = Rsim(xI
ref, x) + Rdiv(x)
Rsim(xI
ref, x) = BERTScore(xI
ref, x)
Rdiv(x) =
X
s∈n-grams(x)
(−νs) Nucleus Sampling (top-p) (Holtzman et al., 2019)
samples from the most likely tokens whose cumu-
lative probability does not exceed p. where νs is the n-gram frequency, calculated from
all the generated utterances inside one batch. where νs is the n-gram frequency, calculated from
all the generated utterances inside one batch. where νs is the n-gram frequency, calculated from
all the generated utterances inside one batch. Post Decoding Clustering (Ippolito et al., 2019)
(i) clusters generated samples using BERT-based
similarity and (ii) selects samples with the highest
probability from each cluster. It can be combined
with any decoding strategy. Objective function. First, we plug this reward into
standard PPO objective function, getting intent-
specific term Lpolicy
I
(θ). 3.2
One-shot Generation Reward. Our reward function is based on
BERTScore (Zhang et al., 2019), which serves
as the measure of contextual similarity between
generated sentences and the reference example. Motivation. The zero-shot approach to conditional
generation may degrade or even fail if (i) the in-
tent description is too short to properly reflect the
semantics of the intent, (ii) the intent description 203 BERTScore correlates better with human judg-
ments than other existing metrics, used to control
semantics of generated texts and detect paraphrases. Given a reference and a candidate sentence, we em-
bed them using RoBERTa model (Liu et al., 2019). The BERTScore F1 calculated on top of these em-
beddings is used as a part of the final reward. BERTScore correlates better with human judg-
ments than other existing metrics, used to control
semantics of generated texts and detect paraphrases. Given a reference and a candidate sentence, we em-
bed them using RoBERTa model (Liu et al., 2019). The BERTScore F1 calculated on top of these em-
beddings is used as a part of the final reward. 3.3
Decoding strategies Following the TextGAIL
approach, we add KL divergence with the model
without zero-shot fine-tuning to prevent forgetting
the information from the pre-trained model. We
add an entropy regularizer, making the distribution
smoother, which leads to more diverse and fluent
sentences. According to our experiments, this term
helps avoid similar prefixes for all generated sen-
tences as n-gram reward only does not cope with
this issue. The final generator objective for maxi-
mization in the one-shot scenario for the intent I
can be written as follows: 4
Performance evaluation High accclsf val-
ues mean that the intents are well distinguishable,
and the utterances that belong to the same intent
are semantically consistent. SGD dataset consists of multi-turn task-oriented
dialogues between user and system; each user utter-
ance is labeled by service and intent. We adopted
only those utterances from each dialog in which
a new intent arose, which means the user clearly
announced a new intention. This is a common tech-
nique to remove sentences that do not express any
intents. As a result, we got three utterances per
dialog on average. Human evaluation We perform two crowd-
sourcing studies to evaluate the quality of generated
utterances, which aim at the evaluation of semantic
correctness and fluency. As NLU-Bench consists of user utterances, each
marked up with a scenario and intent label, we
used it without filtering. Summary statistics of the
dataset used is provided in Table 1. First, we asked crowd workers to evaluate semantic
correctness. We gave crowd workers an utterance
and asked them to assign one of the four provided
intent descriptions; a correct option was among
them (i.e., the one used to generate this very ut-
terance). For the sake of completeness, we added
a fifth option, “none of above”. We assess the re-
sults of this study by two metrics, accuracy and
recall@4. Accuracy acccrowd measures the num-
ber of correct answers, while recall@4 measures
the number of answers which are different from the
last “none of above” option. SGD
NLU-
bench
Total
No. of utterances
49986
25607
75593
No. of services
32
18
50
No. of intents
67
68
135
Total tokens
∼550k
∼170k
∼720k
Unique tokens
∼10.8k
∼8.3k
∼17.4k
Table 1: The total number of utterances, intents, ser-
vices and words across datasets and final statistics of
our fine-tuning data. Table 1: The total number of utterances, intents, ser-
vices and words across datasets and final statistics of
our fine-tuning data. Second, we asked crowd workers to evaluate the
fluency of generated utterances. Crowd workers
were provided with an utterance and were asked to
score it on a Likert-type scale from 1 to 5, where (5)
means that the utterance sounds natural, (3) means
that the utterance contains some errors, (1) means
that it is hard or even impossible to understand the
utterance. We assess the results of this study by
computing the average score. Intent set for generation. 4
Performance evaluation We use several quality metrics to assess the gener-
ated data: (i) we use multiple fluency and diversity
metrics, (ii) we account for the performance of the
classifiers trained on the generated data. Fluency. We consider fluency dependent upon the
number of spelling and grammar mistakes: the
utterance is treated as a fluent one if there are no
misspellings and no grammar mistakes. We utilize
LanguageTool (Miłkowski, 2010), a free and open-
source grammar checker, to check spelling and
correct grammar mistakes. L(I; θ) =Lpolicy
I
(θ) + ˆEt[βH(pθ;I(·|st))
−αKL[pθ;I(·|st), q(·|st)]], L(I; θ) =Lpolicy
I
(θ) + ˆEt[βH(pθ;I(·|st)) where st is intent description, pθ;I is the con-
ditional distribution pθ(·|I)(distribution, derived
from model with updates from PPO policy), q is an
unconditional LM distribution, calculated by GPT-
2 language model without fine-tuning. The entropy
and KL are calculated per each token, while the
Lpolicy term is calculated for the whole sentence. where st is intent description, pθ;I is the con-
ditional distribution pθ(·|I)(distribution, derived
from model with updates from PPO policy), q is an
unconditional LM distribution, calculated by GPT-
2 language model without fine-tuning. The entropy
and KL are calculated per each token, while the
Lpolicy term is calculated for the whole sentence. Diversity. Following (Ippolito et al., 2019), we
consider two types of diversity metrics: Dist-k (Li et al., 2016a) is the total number of
distinct k-grams divided by the total number of
produced tokens in all of the utterances for an in-
tent; 204 Ent-k (Zhang et al., 2018) is an entropy of k-
grams distribution. This metric takes into consid-
eration that infrequent k-grams contribute more to
diversity than frequent ones. structure: they are organized according to services
(in SGD) or scenarios (in NLU-Bench). Each ser-
vice/scenario contains several intents, typically 2-5
intents per high-level class. For example, the ser-
vice Buses 1 is divided into two intents FindBus
and BuyBusTickets. Accuracy. After we obtain a large amount of gen-
erated data, we train a RoBERTa-based classifier
(Liu et al., 2019) to distinguish between different in-
tents, based on the generated utterances. As usual,
we split the generated data into two parts so that the
first part is used for training, and the second part
serves as the held-out validation set to compute the
classification accuracy accclsf. 1The full list of services and intents in both sets presented
in the Appendix 4
Performance evaluation For the evaluation of
our generation methods, we created a set of 38
services and 105 intents1 covering the most com-
mon requirements of a typical user of a modern
dialogue system. The set includes services dedi-
cated to browsing the Internet, adjusting mobile
device settings, searching for vehicles, and others. To adopt a zero-shot setup, we split the data into
train and test sets in the following way. Some of
the services are unseen (s ∈U), i.e., are present
in the test set only. There are no seen services in
the train set related to unseen services. The rest
of the services are seen, i.e., present in both train
and test set (s ∈S), but different intents put in
train and test sets. For example, Flight services
are present in the train data and Plane service is 5.1
Data preparation Data for fine-tuning. We combined two NLU
datasets, namely The Schema-Guided Dialogue
Dataset (SGD) (Rastogi et al., 2020) and Natu-
ral Language Understanding Benchmark (NLU-
bench) (Coucke et al., 2018) for the fine-tuning
stage. Both datasets have a two-level hierarchical 205 Zero-shot generation
Decoding strategy
Automated metrics
Human evaluation
accclsf
Dist-4
Ent-4
acccrowd
recall@4
Fluency score
Random Sampling (b = 4)
0.82
0.50
6.20
0.63
0.87
4.77
Nucleus Sampling (p = 0.6) + PDC
0.82
0.40
5.77
0.68
0.85
4.95
Beam Search (b = 3) + PDC
0.85
0.22
4.92
0.67
0.85
4.88
Beam Search (b = 3)
0.88
0.15
4.76
0.60
0.80
4.76
Nucleus Sampling (p = 0.4)
0.89
0.25
4.95
0.72
0.90
4.81
One-shot generation
Nucleus Sampling (p = 0.4)
0.94
0.39
5.88
0.78
0.91
4.86
Table 2: Decoding strategies for zero-shot and one-shot generation. PDC stands for Post Decoding Clustering. g strategies for zero-shot and one-shot generation. PDC stands for Post Decoding Clustering. uation of the test dataset, created by merging and re-splitting two datasets under consideration. used in the test set; from Music services, intents
Lookup song and Play song were used for training,
and Create playlist and Turn on music for a testing. To form the intent description for fine-tuning and
generation, we join service and intent labels. too. Punctuation issues include missing quotes,
question marks, periods, or repeated punctuation
marks. Common mistakes are omitting of a hy-
phen in the word “Wi-Fi” and “e-mail” and con-
fusing definite and indefinite articles, as well as
confusing “a”/“an”. These issues are more or less
natural to humans and thus do not prevent further
use of generated utterances. The only unnatural
issues found by LanguageTool are phrase repeti-
tion in small numbers (4 errors of this type per
10000 utterances). For examples of fluency issues
in generated data, see Table 1 in Appendix. 5.2
Evaluation We generated 100 examples per intent using differ-
ent decoding strategies and their parameters. For
the more detailed evaluation, we picked up the gen-
eration methods of different decoding strategies
that achieved good scores (accclsf > 80% and
Ent-4 > 4). For these utterances, we performed
a human evaluation of semantic correctness and
diversity; Table 2 compares the decoding strategies
according to various quality metrics. For a more de-
tailed evaluation of decoding strategies, see Table
2 in Appendix. Diversity. Table 4 shows examples of the phrases
generated by means of different decoding strategies,
conditioning on the intent Show message, along
with diversity metrics, Dist and Ent. Higher Ent
and Dist scores indeed correspond to a more di-
verse decoding strategy. At the same time, ex-
tremely high diversity may generate utterances un-
related to the intent, expressing non-clear meaning
and lack of common sense. To compare the diversity of human-generated ut-
terances to our generated utterances, we evaluate
the fine-tuning dataset with Ent-4 and Dist-4 met-
rics. The semantics of generated data is assessed
by acccrowd and recall@4. We present metrics for
this dataset in Table 3. Diversity / Accuracy trade-off. Figure 2 shows
the trade-off between the diversity (Ent-4) and the
accuracy (accclsf) of the generated data. 5.3
Analysis and model comparison Every point corresponds to sentences generated
using different zero-shot strategies. The human
level stands for the diversity and accuracy metrics
computed for the test set as is. The beam search
scores are mainly in the top-left corner of the plane,
leading to high accuracy and low diversity values. Fluency. Spell checking results reveal the follow-
ing issues of the generated utterances. The major
issues are related to casing: an utterance may start
in lower case, the first-person singular personal
pronoun “I” is frequently generated in lower case, 206 Beam Search (3)
Ent-4 = 4.26 show me a message from jean lee
for my favorite apple company
how can you tell me mike with the
message i want to see my messages in
the phone book i need to know what’s going on
with my phone
i want to see my messages in
the phone book show me my most recent mes-
sages from my phone number
show me the messages from the
device i was using
h
h
f could you check to see if my friends
are in a group that is gossiping
list all messages in my bbq menu
from ausy just turn on the smart mute this mon-
day night model generates examples which are consistent in-
side each class, and classes are well-separated, but
the generated examples do not correspond well to
the intent descriptions. 4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
Ent-4
0.60
0.65
0.70
0.75
0.80
0.85
0.90
Accuracy
b
b_k3
b_p0.3
b
b_k3
b_p0.3
k3
k4
k5
k8
p0.3
p0.4
p0.5
p0.6
p0.7
p0.8
p0.9
p0.98
p0.6
p0.7
p0.8
p0.9
p0.98
p1.0
Human level
BeamSearch(b)
RandomSampling(top-k)
Nucleus Sampling(p)
w/o PDC
w/ PDC
Figure 2: The trade-off between diversity (Ent-4) and
accuracy. 5.4
Semantic shift problem The semantic consistency is crucial: how well do
the generated utterances correspond to the intent
description? In most cases, zero-shot generation
is quite reliable: acccrowd > 0.8 for 57% of in-
tents, recall@4 > 0.9 for 72% of intents. How-
ever, generated utterances are distinguishable from
other classes for some intents, but they do not com-
pletely correspond to the intent description. Several
generated utterances below illustrate this issue. Intent: Buy train tickets
Utterance: I want to buy a bus ticket. I want to
leave on the 12th of this month. Intent: Put default wallpapers
Utterance: Put the default wallpaper for the bed-
room. I want to see it on the wall. Intent: Calculator Find sum
Utterance: I need to find a calculator. I need to
know the value of one dollar. Intent: Buy train tickets
Utterance: I want to buy a bus ticket. I want to
leave on the 12th of this month. Intent: Put default wallpapers
Utterance: Put the default wallpaper for the bed-
room. I want to see it on the wall. Intent: Calculator Find sum
Utterance: I need to find a calculator. I need to
know the value of one dollar. Intent: Buy train tickets Figure 2: The trade-off between diversity (Ent-4) and
accuracy. Intent: Buy train tickets
Utterance: I want to buy a bus ticket. I want to
leave on the 12th of this month. Utterance: I want to buy a bus ticket. I want to
leave on the 12th of this month. Top-k Random Sampling strategy does not achieve
the highest levels of accuracy. Nucleus Sampling
can generate datasets with a large range of diver-
sity and accuracy scores, depending on the cho-
sen parameter. Post-decoding clustering increases
diversity for low-diverse decoding strategies and
decreases it for high-diverse ones, moving the gen-
erator closer to the human level. For example, The bias in the fine-tuning data
causes this issue. For example, travel-related in-
tents mainly correspond to bus travel. So the model
confuses buses and trains. In other cases, the model
gets wrong the intent description due to the lack of
world knowledge. E. g. the generated phrases for
Wallpaper may be related to wallpapers in a house;
utterances for Calculator may be related to finding
some numbers like the average price of houses in
the area. Two ways to assess accuracy. Table 2 shows
that there is no clear correspondence between
automated accuracy accclsf and human accuracy
acccrowd. Therefore accclsf cannot serve as the
final measure for the semantic consistency of the
generator. The Semantic shift problem cannot be
captured by the automated accuracy accclsf: the 207 Intent description and reference examples
Undesirable meaning
Zero-
shot
One-
shot
Intent description Train Buy train ticket
Reference Make a purchase of the train ticket, not
bus. Buy a train ticket for a specific date to some
location
Meaning Get bus ticket
Example I need a bus to go there. I need to leave on the 3rd of this
month. 97
23
Intent description Wallpapers Put default wallpaper
Reference Change the background picture of the de-
vice display to the default one. Replace current back-
ground on the device with the default one
Meaning Put new wall cover in
a house
Example I want to put the wall-
paper for my bedroom on the
wall. 74
1
Intent description Calculator Find sum
Reference Compute, calculate the sum of the given
numbers. Open the calculator and compute the sum
of the following numbers
Meaning Find some amount of
money
Example I need to find the aver-
age price of a house. Intent: Buy train tickets 57
0
Table 5: Evaluation of semantic shift reduction by one-shot generation. The first column contains intent description
and reference utterances used for one-shot generation. The second column shows examples of typical undesirable
meaning. The last two columns show the percentage of examples with given incorrect meaning among 100 gener-
ated utterances by zero-shot and one-shot generation. Nucleus sampling (p = 0.4) is used for both methods. Intent description and reference examples Intent description Calculator Find sum
Reference Compute, calculate the sum of the given
numbers. Open the calculator and compute the sum
of the following numbers Table 5: Evaluation of semantic shift reduction by one-shot generation. The first column contains intent description
and reference utterances used for one-shot generation. The second column shows examples of typical undesirable
meaning. The last two columns show the percentage of examples with given incorrect meaning among 100 gener-
ated utterances by zero-shot and one-shot generation. Nucleus sampling (p = 0.4) is used for both methods. Table 5: Evaluation of semantic shift reduction by one-shot generation. The first column contains intent description
and reference utterances used for one-shot generation. The second column shows examples of typical undesirable
meaning. The last two columns show the percentage of examples with given incorrect meaning among 100 gener-
ated utterances by zero-shot and one-shot generation. Nucleus sampling (p = 0.4) is used for both methods. 6
One-shot generation experiments generated dataset by a range of different measures
for diversity, fluency, and semantic correctness, in-
cluding a crowd-sourcing study. We show that the
one-shot generation outperforms the zero-shot one
based on all metrics considered. Using only a sin-
gle utterance for an unseen intent to fine-tune the
model increases diversity and fluency. Moreover,
fine-tuning on a single utterance diminishes the
semantic shift problem and helps the model gain
better world knowledge. Based on human evaluation of zero-shot generated
data, we select Nucleus Sampling (p = 0.4) as the
best decoding strategy and apply it further in the
one-shot scenario. Indeed, Table 2 confirms that
the one-shot generation improves all evaluation
metrics, both human and automated. The resulting
one-shot utterances are more fluent than zero-shot
utterances. The classifier trained on one-shot utter-
ances has higher accuracy values when compared
to the one trained on zero-shot utterances. Virtual assistants in real-life setup should be highly
adaptive. In some tasks, we need much more data
than is currently available: exploring model robust-
ness to distribution change, finding the best archi-
tecture, dealing with a fast-growing set of intents
(the number of intents could be thousands). If the
intents to support come from different providers,
they pose diverse semantics, style, and noises. Adaptation to different user groups and individ-
ual users, having different intent usage distribution,
is another crucial problem. We need large-scale
and flexible datasets to approach these tasks, which
can hardly be collected via crowd-sourcing from
external sources. At the same time, one-shot generation restricts the
semantics of the generated utterances and reduces
the semantic shift. To illustrate, how the problem of
semantic shift diminishes, we study several cases
where the zero-shot model tends to generate utter-
ances with undesirable meaning (see Section 5.4):
bus instead of train; wallpaper as a wall cover
instead of background picture; sum as amount of
money instead of number. Table 5 shows that after
one-shot fine-tuning, the number of utterances with
undesirable meaning becomes drastically lower;
for more examples, see Table 3 in Appendix. 7
Conclusion Zero- or one-shot generation is an appealing tech-
nique. The model obtains the background knowl-
edge about the world and the domain during pre-
training. Next, only small amounts of data are In this paper, we have introduced zero-shot and one-
shot methods for generating utterances from intent
descriptions. We ensure the high quality of the 208 In Proceedings of the 9th International Natural Lan-
guage Generation conference, pages 163–167. In Proceedings of the 9th International Natural Lan-
guage Generation conference, pages 163–167. needed to fine-tune the model. State-of-the-art
pre-trained language models, fine-tuned in a zero-
or one-shot fashion, generate fluent and diverse
phrases close to real-life utterances. The meaning
of the intent and essential details, such as book ti-
tles, movie genres, expression of speech acts, or
emoticons, are preserved. What is more, manip-
ulating a decoding strategy makes it possible to
balance the generated utterances’ diversity, seman-
tic consistency, and correctness. needed to fine-tune the model. State-of-the-art
pre-trained language models, fine-tuned in a zero-
or one-shot fashion, generate fluent and diverse
phrases close to real-life utterances. The meaning
of the intent and essential details, such as book ti-
tles, movie genres, expression of speech acts, or
emoticons, are preserved. What is more, manip-
ulating a decoding strategy makes it possible to
balance the generated utterances’ diversity, seman-
tic consistency, and correctness. Alice Coucke, Alaa Saade, Adrien Ball, Th´eodore
Bluche, Alexandre Caulier, David Leroy, Cl´ement
Doumouro, Thibault Gisselbrecht, Francesco Calta-
girone, Thibaut Lavril, et al. 2018. SNIPS Voice Plat-
form: an Embedded Spoken Language Understanding
System for Private-by-Design Voice Interfaces. arXiv
preprint arXiv:1805.10190. Alice Coucke, Alaa Saade, Adrien Ball, Th´eodore
Bluche, Alexandre Caulier, David Leroy, Cl´ement
Doumouro, Thibault Gisselbrecht, Francesco Calta-
girone, Thibaut Lavril, et al. 2018. SNIPS Voice Plat-
form: an Embedded Spoken Language Understanding
System for Private-by-Design Voice Interfaces. arXiv
preprint arXiv:1805.10190. Sumanth Dathathri, Andrea Madotto, Janice Lan, Jane
Hung, Eric Frank, Piero Molino, Jason Yosinski, and
Rosanne Liu. 2019. Plug and Play Language Mod-
els: A Simple Approach to Controlled Text Generation. In International Conference on Learning Representa-
tions. Sumanth Dathathri, Andrea Madotto, Janice Lan, Jane
Hung, Eric Frank, Piero Molino, Jason Yosinski, and
Rosanne Liu. 2019. Plug and Play Language Mod-
els: A Simple Approach to Controlled Text Generation. In International Conference on Learning Representa-
tions. References Paweł Budzianowski and Ivan Vuli´c. 2019. Hello, it’s
gpt-2-how can i help you? towards the use of pretrained
language models for task-oriented dialogue systems. In
Proceedings of the 3rd Workshop on Neural Generation
and Translation, pages 15–22. Angela Fan, Mike Lewis, and Yann Dauphin. 2018. Hi-
erarchical Neural Story Generation. Proceedings of the
56th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computa-
tional Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers). Angela Fan, Mike Lewis, and Yann Dauphin. 2018. Hi-
erarchical Neural Story Generation. Proceedings of the
56th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computa-
tional Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers). Nitesh V Chawla, Kevin W Bowyer, Lawrence O Hall,
and W Philip Kegelmeyer. 2002. SMOTE: synthetic
minority over-sampling technique. Journal of artificial
intelligence research, 16:321–357. Nitesh V Chawla, Kevin W Bowyer, Lawrence O Hall,
and W Philip Kegelmeyer. 2002. SMOTE: synthetic
minority over-sampling technique. Journal of artificial
intelligence research, 16:321–357. Alvin Grissom II, He He, Jordan Boyd-Graber, John
Morgan, and Hal Daum´e III. 2014. Don’t Until the Fi-
nal Verb Wait: Reinforcement learning for Simultane-
ous Machine Translation. In Proceedings of the 2014
Conference on empirical methods in natural language
processing (EMNLP), pages 1342–1352. Yubo Chen, Shulin Liu, Xiang Zhang, Kang Liu, and
Jun Zhao. 2017. Automatically Labeled Data Genera-
tion for Large Scale Event Extraction. In Proceedings
of the 55th Annual Meeting of the Association for Com-
putational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages
409–419. Yubo Chen, Shulin Liu, Xiang Zhang, Kang Liu, and
Jun Zhao. 2017. Automatically Labeled Data Genera-
tion for Large Scale Event Extraction. In Proceedings
of the 55th Annual Meeting of the Association for Com-
putational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages
409–419. Ari Holtzman, Jan Buys, Li Du, Maxwell Forbes, and
Yejin Choi. 2019. The Curious Case of Neural Text
Degeneration. In International Conference on Learn-
ing Representations. Zhiyu Chen, Harini Eavani, Wenhu Chen, Yinyin Liu,
and William Yang Wang. 2020. Few-shot nlg with pre-
trained language model. In Proceedings of the 58th
Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational
Linguistics, pages 183–190. Daphne Ippolito, Reno Kriz, Maria Kustikova, Jo˜ao
Sedoc, and Chris Callison-Burch. 2019. Comparison
of Diverse Decoding Methods from Conditional Lan-
guage Models. In Proceedings of the 57th Annual
Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguis-
tics, pages 3752–3762. Kyunghyun Cho, Bart van Merri¨enboer, Caglar Gul-
cehre, Dzmitry Bahdanau, Fethi Bougares, Holger
Schwenk, and Yoshua Bengio. 2014. 7
Conclusion Our future work directions include assessing the
downstream performance of proposed generation
methods for an end-user application and evaluating
slot-filling performance. The proposed approach
can be tested to generate utterances specific to in-
terest groups. Chunning Du, Haifeng Sun, Jingyu Wang, Qi Qi,
Jianxin Liao, Chun Wang, and Bing Ma. 2019. In-
vestigating Capsule Network and Semantic Feature on
Hyperplanes for Text Classification. In Proceedings of
the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural
Language Processing and the 9th International Joint
Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-
IJCNLP), pages 456–465. Chunning Du, Haifeng Sun, Jingyu Wang, Qi Qi,
Jianxin Liao, Chun Wang, and Bing Ma. 2019. In-
vestigating Capsule Network and Semantic Feature on
Hyperplanes for Text Classification. In Proceedings of
the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural
Language Processing and the 9th International Joint
Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-
IJCNLP), pages 456–465. Acknowledgements Ekaterina Artemova is partially supported by the
framework of the HSE University Basic Research
Program. Hady Elsahar, Christophe Gravier, and Frederique
Laforest. 2018. Zero-shot question generation from
knowledge graphs for unseen predicates and entity
types. In Proceedings of the 2018 Conference of the
North American Chapter of the Association for Com-
putational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies,
Volume 1 (Long Papers), pages 218–228. Nitish Shirish Keskar, Bryan McCann, Lav R Varsh-
ney, Caiming Xiong, and Richard Socher. 2019. CTRL: References Learning Phrase
Representations using RNN Encoder–Decoder for Sta-
tistical Machine Translation. In Proceedings of the
2014 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural
Language Processing (EMNLP), pages 1724–1734. Mohit Iyyer, John Wieting, Kevin Gimpel, and Luke
Zettlemoyer. 2018. Adversarial Example Generation
with Syntactically Controlled Paraphrase Networks. In
Proceedings of NAACL-HLT, pages 1875–1885. Emilie Colin, Claire Gardent, Yassine M’rabet, Shashi
Narayan, and Laura Perez-Beltrachini. 2016. The
webnlg challenge: Generating text from dbpedia data. Nitish Shirish Keskar, Bryan McCann, Lav R Varsh-
ney, Caiming Xiong, and Richard Socher. 2019. CTRL: 209 A conditional transformer language model for control-
lable generation. arXiv preprint arXiv:1909.05858. Romain Paulus, Caiming Xiong, and Richard Socher. 2017. A Deep Reinforced Model for Abstractive Sum-
marization. arXiv preprint arXiv:1705.04304. Diederik P Kingma and Jimmy Ba. 2015. Adam: A
method for stochastic optimization. In ICLR (Poster). Alec Radford, Jeffrey Wu, Rewon Child, David Luan,
Dario Amodei, and Ilya Sutskever. 2019. Language
models are unsupervised multitask learners. OpenAI
Blog, 1(8):9. Omer Levy, Minjoon Seo, Eunsol Choi, and Luke
Zettlemoyer. 2017. Zero-shot relation extraction
via reading comprehension. In Proceedings of the
21st Conference on Computational Natural Language
Learning (CoNLL 2017), pages 333–342. Abhinav Rastogi, Xiaoxue Zang, Srinivas Sunkara,
Raghav Gupta, and Pranav Khaitan. 2020. Towards
scalable multi-domain conversational agents:
The
schema-guided dialogue dataset. In Proceedings of the
AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence, volume 34,
pages 8689–8696. Mike Lewis, Yinhan Liu, Naman Goyal, Marjan
Ghazvininejad, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Omer Levy,
Veselin Stoyanov, and Luke Zettlemoyer. 2020. BART:
Denoising Sequence-to-Sequence Pre-training for Nat-
ural Language Generation, Translation, and Compre-
hension. In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of
the Association for Computational Linguistics, pages
7871–7880. Steven J Rennie, Etienne Marcheret, Youssef Mroueh,
Jerret Ross, and Vaibhava Goel. 2017. Self-critical Se-
quence Training for Image Captioning. In Proceedings
of the IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pat-
tern Recognition, pages 7008–7024. Jiwei Li, Michel Galley, Chris Brockett, Jianfeng Gao,
and Bill Dolan. 2016a. A Diversity-Promoting Objec-
tive Function for Neural Conversation Models. Pro-
ceedings of the 2016 Conference of the North American
Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguis-
tics: Human Language Technologies. Kyle Richardson, Sina Zarrieß, and Jonas Kuhn. 2017. The code2text challenge: Text generation in source li-
braries. In Proceedings of the 10th International Con-
ference on Natural Language Generation, pages 115–
119. John Schulman, Filip Wolski, Prafulla Dhariwal, Alec
Radford, and Oleg Klimov. 2017. Proximal policy op-
timization algorithms. References Jiwei Li, Will Monroe, Alan Ritter, Dan Jurafsky,
Michel Galley, and Jianfeng Gao. 2016b. Deep Rein-
forcement Learning for Dialogue Generation. In Pro-
ceedings of the 2016 Conference on Empirical Methods
in Natural Language Processing, pages 1192–1202. Rico Sennrich, Barry Haddow, and Alexandra Birch. 2016. Improving Neural Machine Translation Models
with Monolingual Data. In Proceedings of the 54th An-
nual Meeting of the Association for Computational Lin-
guistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), pages 86–96. Yinhan Liu, Myle Ott, Naman Goyal, Jingfei Du, Man-
dar Joshi, Danqi Chen, Omer Levy, Mike Lewis, Luke
Zettlemoyer, and Veselin Stoyanov. 2019. Roberta: A
robustly optimized bert pretraining approach. arXiv
preprint arXiv:1907.11692. Ilya Sutskever, Oriol Vinyals, and Quoc V Le. 2014. Sequence to sequence learning with neural networks. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems,
27:3104–3112. Ryan Thomas Lowe, Nissan Pow, Iulian Vlad Ser-
ban, Laurent Charlin, Chia-Wei Liu, and Joelle Pineau. 2017. Training end-to-end dialogue systems with
the ubuntu dialogue corpus. Dialogue & Discourse,
8(1):31–65. Ashish Vaswani, Noam Shazeer, Niki Parmar, Jakob
Uszkoreit, Llion Jones, Aidan N Gomez, Łukasz
Kaiser, and Illia Polosukhin. 2017. Attention is all you
need. In Advances in neural information processing
systems, pages 5998–6008. Tomas Mikolov and Geoffrey Zweig. 2012. Con-
text Dependent Recurrent Neural Network Language
Model. In 2012 IEEE Spoken Language Technology
Workshop (SLT), pages 234–239. IEEE. Pavlos Vougiouklis, Hady Elsahar, Lucie-Aim´ee Kaf-
fee, Christophe Gravier, Fr´ed´erique Laforest, Jonathon
Hare, and Elena Simperl. 2018. Neural wikipedian:
Generating textual summaries from knowledge base
triples. Journal of Web Semantics, 52:1–15. Marcin Miłkowski. 2010. Developing an Open-source,
Rule-based Proofreading Tool. Software: Practice and
Experience, 40(7):543–566. Shuohang Wang, Mo Yu, Xiaoxiao Guo, Zhiguo Wang,
Tim Klinger, Wei Zhang, Shiyu Chang, Gerry Tesauro,
Bowen Zhou, and Jing Jiang. 2018. R3: Reinforced
Ranker-Reader for Open-domain Question Answering. In Thirty-Second AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelli-
gence. Ramesh Nallapati, Feifei Zhai, and Bowen Zhou. 2017. Summarunner: A recurrent neural network based se-
quence model for extractive summarization of docu-
ments. In Thirty-First AAAI Conference on Artificial
Intelligence. Shashi Narayan, Shay B Cohen, and Mirella Lapata. 2019. What is this article about? extreme summariza-
tion with topic-aware convolutional neural networks. Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research, 66:243–
278. Jason Wei and Kai Zou. 2019. EDA: Easy Data
Augmentation Techniques for Boosting Performance
on Text Classification Tasks. References In Proceedings of the
2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural
Language Processing and the 9th International Joint 210 Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-
IJCNLP), pages 6383–6389. Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-
IJCNLP), pages 6383–6389. Qingyang Wu, Lei Li, and Zhou Yu. 2021. Textgail:
Generative adversarial imitation learning for text gen-
eration. In Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Ar-
tificial Intelligence, volume 35, pages 14067–14075. C Xia, C Xiong, and PS Yu. 2021. Pseudo siamese
network for few-shot intent generation. In ACM SIGIR. Wenpeng Yin, Jamaal Hay, and Dan Roth. 2019. Benchmarking zero-shot text classification: Datasets,
evaluation and entailment approach. In Proceedings of
the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural
Language Processing and the 9th International Joint
Conference on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-
IJCNLP), pages 3905–3914. Quanzeng You, Hailin Jin, Zhaowen Wang, Chen Fang,
and Jiebo Luo. 2016. Image captioning with semantic
attention. In Proceedings of the IEEE conference on
computer vision and pattern recognition, pages 4651–
4659. Yunlong Yu, Zhong Ji, Zhongfei Zhang, and Jungong
Han. 2019. Episode-based prototype generating net-
work for zero-shot learning. Tianyi Zhang, Varsha Kishore, Felix Wu, Kilian Q
Weinberger, and Yoav Artzi. 2019. BERTScore: Eval-
uating Text Generation with BERT. In International
Conference on Learning Representations. Xingxing Zhang and Mirella Lapata. 2017. Sentence
simplification with deep reinforcement learning. In
Proceedings of the 2017 Conference on Empirical
Methods in Natural Language Processing, pages 584–
594. Yizhe Zhang, Michel Galley, Jianfeng Gao, Zhe Gan,
Xiujun Li, Chris Brockett, and Bill Dolan. 2018. Gen-
erating Informative and Diverse Conversational Re-
sponses via Adversarial Information Maximization. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems. Tiancheng Zhao and Maxine Eskenazi. 2018. Zero-
shot dialog generation with cross-domain latent actions. In Proceedings of the 19th Annual SIGdial Meeting on
Discourse and Dialogue, pages 1–10. 211
|
https://openalex.org/W2013537480
|
https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:e4b3b3a3-66dc-4534-aad8-68f0f4baaed6/download_file?safe_filename=journal.pone.0032555.pdf&file_format=application%2Fpdf&type_of_work=Journal+article
|
English
| null |
Structural Stability of Human Protein Tyrosine Phosphatase ρ Catalytic Domain: Effect of Point Mutations
|
PloS one
| 2,012
|
cc-by
| 10,103
|
Abstract Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. * E-mail: roberta.chiaraluce@uniroma1.it * E-mail: roberta.chiaraluce@uniroma1.it . These authors contributed equally to this work. Structural Stability of Human Protein Tyrosine
Phosphatase r Catalytic Domain: Effect of Point
Mutations Alessandra Pasquo1., Valerio Consalvi2., Stefan Knapp3, Ivan Alfano3, Matteo Ardini2, Simonetta
Stefanini2, Roberta Chiaraluce2* 1 UT-BIORAD-FARM CR Casaccia ENEA, Rome, Italy, 2 Department of Biochemical Sciences ‘‘A. Rossi Fanelli’’, Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy, 3 Structura
Genomics Consortium, Oxford University, Oxford, England, United Kingdom PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Introduction encoding PTPr (PDB accession code 2OOQ) was found to be
most frequently mutated and it was also mutated in about 20% of
lung and gastric cancer [10]. The classical protein tyrosine phosphatase (PTP) superfamily
includes 38 proteins which specifically dephosphorylate phospho-
tyrosine residues and, in concert with protein tyrosine kinases,
control a large number of diverse biological processes, such as cell
proliferation, adhesion, apoptosis and migration [1–6]. Reversible
tyrosine phosphorylation controls numerous signaling pathways
which require a right balance between kinase and phosphatase
activity. The involvement of PTP in controlling cellular signaling
has been largely recognized [2,5,7], though the role of PTP in
human diseases has not been explored so extensively as that of
protein kinases. However in diverse diseases, such as cancer,
diabetes and immune deficiencies, dysregulation of Tyr phosphor-
ylation has been observed [4,7,8]. g
g
[
]
PTPr belongs to the classical receptor type IIB family of PTP. The 107 PTPs encoded by the human genome are classified into
four classes, on the basis of the amino acid sequence of their
catalytic domain. Class I includes 61 dual-specificity phosphatases
and 38 classical phosphotyrosine-specific phosphatase which are
further divided into receptor and non-transmembrane groups
[5,7]. The full-length PTPr contains an extracellular domain,
formed by a meprin-A5 antigen-PTP (MAM) domain and Ig-like
and fibronectin type III-like repeats, a single transmembrane
segment and one or two cytoplasmic catalytic domains. The
catalytically active proximal D1 domain is adjacent to the
membrane and is connected to the inactive membrane-distal D2
domain [3,5]. The PTP membrane-proximal catalytic domain
consists of about 280 residues that fold into a highly conserved a/b
structure [4,11]. Conserved functional elements of the catalytic
PTP domain are the PTP signature motif, the mobile ‘‘WPD’’
loop, a highly conserved aspartate residue required for catalysis
and the phosphotyrosine recognition loop. On the basis of their counteracting activity on the oncogenic
protein tyrosine kinase, PTPs have been initially considered as
potential tumor suppressors, however it is clear that several
phosphatases have oncogenic properties [2–6,9]. Over the last
decade a limited number of phophatases have been studied
systematically to evaluate their role in tumorigenesis. Abstract Protein tyrosine phosphatase r (PTPr) belongs to the classical receptor type IIB family of protein tyrosine phosphatase, the
most frequently mutated tyrosine phosphatase in human cancer. There are evidences to suggest that PTPr may act as a
tumor suppressor gene and dysregulation of Tyr phosphorylation can be observed in diverse diseases, such as diabetes,
immune deficiencies and cancer. PTPr variants in the catalytic domain have been identified in cancer tissues. These natural
variants are nonsynonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms, variations of a single nucleotide occurring in the coding
region and leading to amino acid substitutions. In this study we investigated the effect of amino acid substitution on the
structural stability and on the activity of the membrane-proximal catalytic domain of PTPr. We expressed and purified as
soluble recombinant proteins some of the mutants of the membrane-proximal catalytic domain of PTPr identified in
colorectal cancer and in the single nucleotide polymorphisms database. The mutants show a decreased thermal and
thermodynamic stability and decreased activation energy relative to phosphatase activity, when compared to wild- type. All
the variants show three-state equilibrium unfolding transitions similar to that of the wild- type, with the accumulation of a
folding intermediate populated at ,4.0 M urea. Citation: Pasquo A, Consalvi V, Knapp S, Alfano I, Ardini M, et al. (2012) Structural Stability of Human Protein Tyrosine Phosphatase r Catalytic Domain: Effect of
Point Mutations. PLoS ONE 7(2): e32555. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555 itor: Annalisa Pastore, National Institute for Medical Research - Medical Research Council, United Kingdom Editor: Annalisa Pastore, National Institute for Medical Research - Medical Research Council, United Kingdom Received October 19, 2011; Accepted February 1, 2012; Published February 28, 2012 Copyright: 2012 Pasquo et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. f Biochemical Sciences; Uniroma1, www.uniroma1.it. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to
f the manuscript. Funding: Department of Biochemical Sciences; Uniroma1, www.uniroma1.it. The funders had no role in study design, data col
publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Funding: Department of Biochemical Sciences; Uniroma1, www.uniroma1.it. The funders had no role in study design, data collectio
publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Funding: Department of Biochemical Sciences; Uniroma1, www.uniroma1.it. The funders
publish, or preparation of the manuscript. February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 Introduction In particular,
six mutated phosphatases have been directly linked to colorectal
cancers [1,10]; among the six mutated genes, the PTPRT gene In cancer tissues several PTPr variants in the catalytic domain
have been identified and there is evidence to suggest that PTPr 1 February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 PTP r Mutants Stability PTP r Mutants Stability PTP r Mutants Stability stability and on the activity of the membrane-proximal catalytic
domain of PTPr [1,24]. The analysis revealed that, in comparison
to the wild-type, the thermal and thermodynamic stability of all
the mutants are decreased as well as the activation energy relative
to the phosphatase activity, indicating an increase in protein
flexibility of all the PTPr mutants. All the variants show three-
state equilibrium unfolding transitions similar to that of the wild-
type, with the accumulation of a folding intermediate at ,4.0 M
urea. may act as a tumor suppressor gene [10]. These natural variants
are nonsynonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms (nsSNPs),
single nucleotide variations occurring in the coding region and
leading to a polypeptide sequence with amino acid substitutions. A large number of amino acid substitutions originate from
nsSNPs and an increasingly large number of diseases and defects
reported in Human Gene Mutation Database [12] and Online
Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM) [13] are referred to
nsSNPs [14]. Although most nsSNPs are considered not to affect
protein function, computational analysis predicts that around 30%
of protein variants resulting from nsSNPs are less stable than the
most common variant [15]. The effect of disease-causing nsSNPs
on protein structure and function has been widely investigated by
computational analysis, and change in protein stability has been
suggested as the most common mechanism involved in monogenic
disease [16–18]. However, nsSNPs may also affect and modulate
the protein function by altering protein dynamics without affecting
protein stability [19]. Notably, since genetic variations related to
nsSNPs may influence individual susceptibility to complex diseases
such as cancer [20] or response to drugs, a more extended study
about the effect of nsSNPs on protein structure may help in
understanding their role in inducing protein functional changes
[21]. To
date
there
are
few
experimental
data
available
concerning the consequences of nsSNPs on protein function and
stability. To our knowledge, this study represents the first spectroscopic
and thermodynamic characterization of human PTPr catalytic
domain and some of its mutants found in cancer. Introduction In addition, the
effects of none of the mutations reported in this manuscript on
protein thermodynamic stability has been previously investigated. Results Four mutations of the PTPr membrane-proximal catalytic
domain in public databases have been identified: D927G, Q987K,
N1128I and A1118P. Introduction of these mutations resulted in
soluble recombinant protein only for D927G, Q987K and N1128I
whereas the A1118P mutant could not be expressed in the soluble
fraction even when different growth and induction conditions were
used. Mapping of the mutations onto the structure of the PTPr
catalytic domain revealed that A1118P is located in the middle of a
central helix (Fig. 1). It is likely that the introduction of a proline
residue at this position in substitution of alanine will break the
helical secondary structure resulting in misfolding of the catalytic In this study we investigate the effect of amino acid substitutions
identified in colorectal cancer [10] and in the single nucleotide
polymorphisms
database
[18,22,23]
on
the
thermodynamic Figure 1. Location of PTPr mutations. (A) Structure of PTPr (PDB code 2OOQ) shown as a ribbon diagram. Mutated residues are highlighted in
ball and stick and transparent cpk representation and are labelled in red. The active site cystein residue (C1106) is also shown and the catalytically
important WPD loop is coloured in yellow. (B) Local environment of N1128. (C) Local environment of D927. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g001 Figure 1. Location of PTPr mutations. (A) Structure of PTPr (PDB code 2OOQ) shown as a ribbon diagram. Mutated residues are highlighted in
ball and stick and transparent cpk representation and are labelled in red. The active site cystein residue (C1106) is also shown and the catalytically
important WPD loop is coloured in yellow. (B) Local environment of N1128. (C) Local environment of D927. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g001 Figure 1. Location of PTPr mutations. (A) Structure of PTPr (PDB code 2OOQ) shown as a ribbon diagram. Mutated residues are highlighted in
ball and stick and transparent cpk representation and are labelled in red. The active site cystein residue (C1106) is also shown and the catalytically
important WPD loop is coloured in yellow. (B) Local environment of N1128. (C) Local environment of D927. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g001 February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 2 PTP r Mutants Stability i di
d b
h
d
h
d
f h
Figure 2. Spectroscopic properties of PTPr wild
mutants. (A) Near-UV CD spectra were recorded in a 1
cuvette at 1.0 mg/ml protein concentration in 20 mM Tris/
containing 0.2 M NaCl and 2 mM DTT. Results (B) Intrinsic f
emission spectra were recorded at 0.04 mg/ml protein co
(295 nm excitation wavelength) in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5
0.2 M NaCl and 200 mM DTT. (C) Far-UV CD spectra were re
0.1-cm quartz cuvette at 0.2 mg/ml in 20 mM Tris/H
containing 0.2 M NaCl and 0.4 mM DTT. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g002 domain. N1128 is located at the C-terminal end of the same helix
(Fig. 1B). This residue is located in a very polar environment with
flanking acidic (E1124, E1127, E1129) and a histidine residue
(H974) located in a neighbouring loop region. D927G and Q987K
are located in solvent exposed loops with little interaction with
other amino acid side chains (Fig. 1C). The solvent accessibility of
the mutated residues Asp-927 and Gln-987 is more than 70% and
Asn-1128 is 49% solvent exposed. The mutation D927G involves
a residue (Asp-927) placed in a 4 residues turn between two coils. In the wild-type Asp-927 connects different protein secondary
structure regions through hydrogen bonds with three residues. One hydrogen bond is between the N of the peptide bond and the
OD2 of Asp-947 and the other two hydrogen bonds are between
the carbonyl of the peptide bond and the amidic nitrogens of Lys-
930 and Glu-931. The carboxylic moiety of Asp-927 is completely
solvent exposed and does not apparently make any contact with
other residues. Spectroscopic characterization of PTPr wild-type and its
mutants The near-UV CD spectrum of wild-type PTPr shows the
contribution of all aromatic residues and is characterized by two
negative components centred at 280 nm and at around 298 nm
accompanied by fine structure features at 275–280 nm (Fig. 2A). Q987K variant displays a near-UV CD spectrum almost identical
to that of the wild-type as well as D927G and N1128I, which
nevertheless show a slight decrease of the dichroic activity at 275–
280 nm. In line with the near-UV CD results, which suggest a
similar tertiary arrangement for the wild-type and all the variants,
the fluorescence emission spectra of mutants are similar to that of
wild-type protein, being all centred at the same maximum
emission wavelength around 338 nm but characterized by a
decreased emission fluorescence intensity (Fig. 2B). Far-UV CD
spectra of all the PTPr mutants superimpose well with that of the
wild-type and are typical of an alpha and beta protein, showing a
local minimum at around 208 nm, a 200 nm zero intercept and a
1.13 ratio of the 208/222 bands (Fig. 2C). These results indicate
that the SNP mutations had no effect on the secondary structure of
the protein and suggest that, in the native state, the effect of the
mutations are directed and localized to the mutated residue with
minor modification of tertiary arrangements. Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding transitions PTPr wild-type and variants reversibly unfold in urea at 10uC
in 20 mM TrisHCl, pH 7.5, containing 200 mM DTT and 0.2 M
NaCl. The effect of increasing urea concentrations (0–8 M) on the
structure of PTPr mutants was analyzed by far-UV CD and
intrinsic fluorescence emission spectroscopy and compared to the
wild-type. Incubation of PTPr wild-type and variants at increasing urea
concentrations at 10uC for 30 min, a time sufficient to reach the
equilibrium, resulted in a progressive change of the intrinsic
fluorescence emission intensity and a red-shift of the maximal
emission wavelength. At the end of the transition, above 7 M urea,
the intrinsic fluorescence emission intensity is increased about 1.5
fold and the maximal fluorescence emission wavelength shifts to
around 358 nm either for the wild-type and all the variants (Fig. 5). Determination of the red-shift of the intrinsic fluorescence
emission was obtained by calculating the intensity averaged
emission wavelength l at increasing urea concentration (Fig. 6A). This parameter is an integral measurement, negligibly influenced
by the noise, and reflects changes in both the shape and the
position of the emission spectrum. The same samples used to monitor the fluorescence emission
changes during the unfolding transition were used to monitor far-
UV CD ellipticity (Fig. 6A). The unfolding process is fully
reversible upon dilution of the denaturant, either for the wild-type
as well as for all the mutants (Fig. 6A). The urea-induced changes
in intensity averaged emission wavelength l and in 222 nm
ellipticity of all the mutants are similar to that of the wild-type and
show a sigmoidal dependence on urea concentration, following an
apparent two-state transition. However, the transitions monitored
by ellipticity changes and l changes do not coincide (Fig. 6A)
suggesting the possible presence of an intermediate in the
transition region at approximately 4 M urea for the wild-type
and for all the variants. The plot of the relative fluorescence
intensity changes versus urea concentration shows a complex
dependence upon increasing denaturant concentration for the
wild-type and all the mutants (Fig. 6B). The data in Fig. 6B clearly
indicate a non two-state unfolding process and the population of a
denaturation intermediate at about the same urea concentration of
the apparent denaturation midpoints observed by ellipticity and l
averaged changes (Fig. 6 A and B). Thermal unfolding g
The thermal stability of D927G, Q987K and N1128I was
investigated by continuously monitoring the ellipticity changes at
209 nm between 10 and 72uC in comparison with that of wild-type
(Fig. 3). The parameter chosen to compare the transition curves of
PTPr wild-type and mutants is the melting temperature (Tm)
defined as the mid point of the denaturation process calculated by
plotting the first derivative of the molar ellipticity values as a
function of temperature (Fig. 3, inset). The temperature-induced
ellipticity changes at 209 nm, where the main amplitude was
observed, occur in an apparent cooperative transition for PTPr
wild-type, Q987K, N1128I and D927G, and with apparent Tm
values of 43.0, 42.0, 41.0 and 40.0uC, respectively. The tempera-
ture-induced ellipticity changes for wild type and mutants are all
coincident with the heat-induced increase of the photomultiplier
tube voltage (PMTV) above 370 V (Fig. 3B), suggesting that the
temperature-induced unfolding is accompanied by protein aggre-
gation [25]. Aggregation occurred also when thermal scans were
performed at a lower heating rate with a low-temperature shifts of
the apparent Tm; the differences between the apparent Tm of wild
type and variants were the same as those measured at higher heating
rate (data not shown). The observed transitions are irreversible as Figure 2. Spectroscopic properties of PTPr wild-type and
mutants. (A) Near-UV CD spectra were recorded in a 1-cm quartz
cuvette at 1.0 mg/ml protein concentration in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5
containing 0.2 M NaCl and 2 mM DTT. (B) Intrinsic fluorescence
emission spectra were recorded at 0.04 mg/ml protein concentration
(295 nm excitation wavelength) in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5 containing
0.2 M NaCl and 200 mM DTT. (C) Far-UV CD spectra were recorded in a
0.1-cm quartz cuvette at 0.2 mg/ml in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5
containing 0.2 M NaCl and 0.4 mM DTT. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g002 indicated by the spectra measured at the end of the cooling phase
that differ from those of the native proteins measured at the
beginning of the thermal transitions (data not shown). Furthermore,
inspection of the cuvette at the end of the cooling phase revealed the
presence of a large amount of precipitate in all the samples. Thermal unfolding PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org PLoS February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 3 PTP r Mutants Stability Figure 3. Thermal transition of PTPr wild-type and mutant
PTPr wild-type, N1128I, Q987K and D927G were heated from 10
72uC in a 0.1-cm quartz cuvette at 0.2 mg/ml in 20 mM Tris/HCl, p
containing 0.2 M NaCl and 0.4 mM DTT. The dichroic activity at 20
was monitored continuously every 0.5uC. The inset shows the
derivative of the same data. (B) PMTV data recorded in the
experiments shown in (A). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g003 wild-type, particularly evident for N1128I and D927G whose
phosphatase activity is significantly decreased at 42uC. The
comparison of temperature dependence of phosphatase activity
with the structural thermal unfolding monitored at 209 nm clearly
indicates that the D927G and N1128I variants are significantly
more flexible and less thermal resistant than the wild-type. Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding transitions The folding intermediate
detected by relative fluorescence intensity is populated at around
4.45 M urea for wild-type and Q987K and at around 3.95 M urea
for D927G and N1128I. The intrinsic fluorescence emission
spectra of the folding intermediate are similar for all the proteins:
the fluorescence intensity is increased of about 1.5 fold and the
maximum emission wavelength is shifted from 338 to 345 nm,
with respect to the native state (Fig. 5). The hyperfluorescent
intermediate of wild-type and variants retains about 35% of the
222 nm ellipticity of the native state (Fig. 6A). Figure 3. Thermal transition of PTPr wild-type and mutants. (A)
PTPr wild-type, N1128I, Q987K and D927G were heated from 10uC to
72uC in a 0.1-cm quartz cuvette at 0.2 mg/ml in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5
containing 0.2 M NaCl and 0.4 mM DTT. The dichroic activity at 209 nm
was monitored continuously every 0.5uC. The inset shows the first
derivative of the same data. (B) PMTV data recorded in the same
experiments shown in (A). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g003 Temperature dependence of phosphatase activity For the second transition, that represents the unfolding of
the intermediate to the denatured state, the m values of all the
proteins are lower than those of the first transition, indicating that
a larger increase in solvent-exposed surface area occur in the
unfolding from the native to the intermediate state (Table 1). Notably, DG values relative to the second unfolding transition for
N1128I and Q987K are larger than those relative to the first
transition, suggesting a higher stability of the intermediate states,
compared to that of the wild-type. spectra of the intermediate state of both proteins. Furthermore, the
280–260 nm region, dominated by contribution of Phe and Tyr
residues, in D927G is less defined than the wild-type (Fig. 7A). The
data clearly indicate that both the spectral components of the wild-
type and D927G contribute to the urea induced transitions with
the accumulation of a denaturation intermediate at the same urea
concentration range observed by monitoring intrinsic fluorescence
intensity (Fig. 5 and Fig. 6B). The urea-induced unfolding transitions monitored by far-UV CD
ellipticity changes are non-coincident with those monitored by
fluorescence (Fig. 6) and near-UV CD (Fig. 7). To identify the
number of spectral components contributing to the urea-induced
ellipticity changes, far-UV CD spectra were analysed after removal
of the high-frequency noise and the low-frequency random error by
SVD. The global changes in the spectral region 213–250 nm,
analyzed by SVD, indicate that only two spectral components
contribute to the far-UV CD spectra of wild-type and all the
variants. The most significant singular values are very similar for
wild-type and all the variants and range between 1.766105 and
1.676105. The second singular values are 19.8% of the first singular
value for the wild-type, 16.6% for the D927G variant, 11.2% for
Q987K and 8.0% for N1128I. All the other singular values are
below 7.0% of the largest singular value and progressively decrease
approaching to zero. The plots of the first column of the V matrix
(V1), which reflect the global change in the 213–250 nm region, as a
function of urea concentration (data not shown) show sigmoidal
transition profiles comparable to the transitions monitored at
222 nm for the wild-type and the variants (data not shown). Non
cooperative changes of V2 at increasing denaturant are observed. Temperature dependence of phosphatase activity The temperature dependence of phosphatase activity of PTPr
wild-type and variants was examined over the temperature range
of 10–42uC (Fig. 4A). The optimal temperatures were estimated to
be at 37uC for wild type and Q987K, at around 33uC for N1128I
and at 30uC for D927G (Fig. 4A). Notably, at 37uC, the
phosphatase activity of all PTPr variants is significantly reduced
and corresponds to 72, 54 and 20% of that of the wild-type protein
for Q987K, N1128I and D927G, respectively. The activation
energy, Ea
{, determined by the Arrhenius equation (1) in the
temperature range between 10uC and the optimal temperature of
each protein, corresponds to 13.8860.40 kcal/mol for the wild-
type and to 12.7760.51, 10.7360.54 and 11.3860.46 kcal/mol
for N1128I, D927G and Q987K (Fig. 4B), respectively. This result
suggests an increased flexibility of all the variants compared to the The transitions monitored by relative fluorescence intensity
changes (Fig. 6B) were fitted to a three-state unfolding process
which yielded the thermodynamic parameters for wild-type and
the variants of PTPr (Table 1). For the first transition, m values are
all closely similar to that of the wild-type, suggesting a similar
unfolding mechanism for all the variants; DG values lower than
that of the wild-type are observed for N1128I and D927G, PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 4 PTP r Mutants Stability Figure 4. Effect of temperature on phosphatase activity of PTPr wild-type and mutants. (A) Temperature dependence of phosphatase
activity of PTPr wild-type and mutants. (B) Non-linear fit of the temperature dependence of phosphatase activity to the Arrhenius equation (Eqn. 1);
the inset shows the linear Arrhenius plot for the same data. Assays were performed under the conditions described in Materials and Methods, using
1 nM enzyme. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g004 Figure 4. Effect of temperature on phosphatase activity of PTPr wild-type and mutants. (A) Temperature dependence of phosphatase
activity of PTPr wild-type and mutants. (B) Non-linear fit of the temperature dependence of phosphatase activity to the Arrhenius equation (Eqn. 1);
the inset shows the linear Arrhenius plot for the same data. Assays were performed under the conditions described in Materials and Methods, using
1 nM enzyme. doi:10 1371/journal pone 0032555 g004 doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g004 suggesting a destabilization of the native state for these two
variants, that also show a decreased thermal stability (see Fig. 3
and 4). February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 Temperature dependence of phosphatase activity Furthermore, the reconstituted spectra of the first spectral
component superimposed well with those of the sum of the first
and the second spectral component (data not shown), indicating that The near-UV CD changes of D927G, the most temperature
sensitive variant, upon increasing urea concentrations were
monitored in comparison with wild-type (Fig. 7) to better
characterize the nature of the intermediate state. The resulting
data were analyzed after removal of the high-frequency noise and
the low-frequency random error by a singular value decomposition
algorithm (SVD) which resolved two main spectra components
either for wild-type or for the mutant D927G. The most significant
singular values were 2.056103 for wild-type and 1.966103 for
D927G, the second singular values were 38.2% and 40.1% of the
first singular value for wild-type and D927G, respectively. The
plots of the first (V1) and of the second column (V2) of the V matrix
which reflect the global change in the 250–320 nm region as a
function of urea concentration show non-two state transition
profiles comparable to the transitions monitored by intrinsic
fluorescence emission intensity and confirm the accumulation of
an intermediate at around 4.2 M urea (Fig. 7 B, and C). At this
denaturant concentration, the near-UV CD spectra of wild-type
and D927G significantly differ from those of the native state and
are completely opposite in sign (Fig. 7A). The 298 nm negative
band is lost and a positive contribution at 289 nm is present in the PLoS O February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 5 PTP r Mutants Stability Figure 5. Intrinsic fluorescence emission spectra of PTPr wild-type and mutants. Fluorescence spectra of PTPr wild-type and mutants in
0 M (continuous lines), 8.30 M (dotted lines), 3.95 M (D927G and N1128I, dashed lines) and 4.45 M urea (wild-type and Q987K, dashed lines) were
recorded at 0.04 mg/ml protein concentration (295 nm excitation wavelength) at 10uC in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5 containing 0.2 M NaCl and 200 mM
DTT. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g005 Figure 5. Intrinsic fluorescence emission spectra of PTPr wild-type and mutants. Temperature dependence of phosphatase activity Fluorescence spectra of PTPr wild-type and mutants in
0 M (continuous lines), 8.30 M (dotted lines), 3.95 M (D927G and N1128I, dashed lines) and 4.45 M urea (wild-type and Q987K, dashed lines) were
recorded at 0.04 mg/ml protein concentration (295 nm excitation wavelength) at 10uC in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5 containing 0.2 M NaCl and 200 mM
DTT. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g005 doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g005 3.6560.10 and 3.8260.07 kcal/mol for wild-type, N1128I, D927G
and Q987 K, respectively, for a shared m value of 1.0660.05 kcal/
mol/M. Equilibrium unfolding of PTPr wild-type and variants
occurs via a hyperfluorescent intermediate state that cannot be
detected by far-UV CD. Hence, the thermodynamic folding
intermediate may represent a conformational change which occurs
in the proximity of any of the tryptophans most likely due to an
increase of native state flexibility [26]. only the first spectral component contributed to the urea induced
transitions monitored by ellipticity at 222 nm. These results indicate
an apparent two-state process for far-UV CD unfolding transitions
of wild-type and variants. Thus the data have been globally fitted to
a two-state model according to equation 4 with the m parameter
shared between all the data sets. The free energy of unfolding,
DGH
2
O, of wild-type and mutants obtained from the global fit-
ting are very similar and correspond to 3.5660.09, 3.6360.10, February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 6 PTP r Mutants Stability Figure 6. Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding of PTPr wild-
type and mutants. (A) Normalized intensity-averaged emission
wavelength (l, left axis, filled circles) and molar ellipticity at 222 nm
reported after removal of the high-frequency noise and the low-
frequency random error by SVD ([H]222, right axis, empty squares); the
continuous lines represent the nonlinear global fitting of the molar
ellipticities at 222 nm data to Eqn. 4 for PTPr calculated as described in
Materials and Methods. (B) Normalized relative fluorescence intensities
at 338 nm; the continuous lines represent the nonlinear regression fit of
the relative fluorescence intensities at 338 nm to Eqn. 6 calculated as
described in Materials and Methods. The reversibility points (empty
circles) are shown, for clarity, only for the relative fluorescence
intensities of the wild-type and were not included in the nonlinear
regression analysis. All spectra were recorded at 10uC as described in
Materials and Methods. doi:10 1371/journal pone 0032555 g006 Table 1. Temperature dependence of phosphatase activity Thermodynamic parameters for urea-induced
unfolding equilibrium of PTPrwild-type and mutants. Wild-type
N1128I
D927G
Q987K
mI-N (kcal/mol/M)
2.9460.32
2.4360.28
2.6960.45
2.9860.27
D50I-N (M)
3.5160.02
3.3460.03
3.4660.03
3.5860.02
DGH
2
O
I-N (kcal/mol)
10.32
8.12
9.31
10.67
mU-I (kcal/mol/M)
1.6160.13
1.9160.18
1.8160.26
2.5160.25
D50U-I(M)
5.4960.03
5.4060.03
5.3160.05
5.0660.02
DGH
2
O
U-I (kcal/mol)
8.84
10.31
9.61
12.70
Urea-induced unfolding equilibrium data were obtained at 10uC in 20 mM Tris/
HCl, pH 7.5, containing 0.2 M NaCl and 200 mM DTT by measuring the relative
fluorescence intensity at 338 nm. The free energy of unfolding from the native
state to the intermediate (DGH
2
O
I-N) and from the intermediate to the unfolded
state (DGH
2
O
U-I) were calculated from Eqn. 5. D50I-N and mI-N which are the
midpoint and m value for the transition between native and intermediate state,
respectively, and D50U-I and mU-I are the midpoint and m value for the
transition between the intermediate and the unfolded state, respectively, were
calculated from Eqn.6. Data are reported 6 SE of the fit. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.t001 Table 1. Thermodynamic parameters for urea-induced
unfolding equilibrium of PTPrwild-type and mutants. Urea-induced unfolding equilibrium data were obtained at 10uC in 20 mM Tris/
HCl, pH 7.5, containing 0.2 M NaCl and 200 mM DTT by measuring the relative
fluorescence intensity at 338 nm. The free energy of unfolding from the native
state to the intermediate (DGH
2
O
I-N) and from the intermediate to the unfolded
state (DGH
2
O
U-I) were calculated from Eqn. 5. D50I-N and mI-N which are the
midpoint and m value for the transition between native and intermediate state,
respectively, and D50U-I and mU-I are the midpoint and m value for the
transition between the intermediate and the unfolded state, respectively, were
calculated from Eqn.6. Data are reported 6 SE of the fit. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.t001 different growth and induction conditions. The spectroscopic
properties of the wild-type compared with those of all the variants
indicate that the mutations D927G, Q987K and N1128I had no
effect on protein secondary structure with minor modifications of
tertiary arrangements. All the mutants show a decrease in the thermal stability and in
the activation energy for phosphatase activity with respect to the
wild-type indicating an increase in protein flexibility of all the
mutants. Hence, at 37uC the phosphatase activity of all the
variants was significantly reduced, similarly to what reported by
Wang et al. Temperature dependence of phosphatase activity for Q987K and N1128I [10]. The most destabilizing
mutation,
D927G,
yielded
a
protein
that
at
physiological
temperature was almost completely inactive. Figure 6. Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding of PTPr wild-
type and mutants. (A) Normalized intensity-averaged emission
wavelength (l, left axis, filled circles) and molar ellipticity at 222 nm
reported after removal of the high-frequency noise and the low-
frequency random error by SVD ([H]222, right axis, empty squares); the
continuous lines represent the nonlinear global fitting of the molar
ellipticities at 222 nm data to Eqn. 4 for PTPr calculated as described in
Materials and Methods. (B) Normalized relative fluorescence intensities
at 338 nm; the continuous lines represent the nonlinear regression fit of
the relative fluorescence intensities at 338 nm to Eqn. 6 calculated as
described in Materials and Methods. The reversibility points (empty
circles) are shown, for clarity, only for the relative fluorescence
intensities of the wild-type and were not included in the nonlinear
regression analysis. All spectra were recorded at 10uC as described in
Materials and Methods. Figure 6. Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding of PTPr wild-
type and mutants. (A) Normalized intensity-averaged emission
wavelength (l, left axis, filled circles) and molar ellipticity at 222 nm
reported after removal of the high-frequency noise and the low-
frequency random error by SVD ([H]222, right axis, empty squares); the
continuous lines represent the nonlinear global fitting of the molar
ellipticities at 222 nm data to Eqn. 4 for PTPr calculated as described in
Materials and Methods. (B) Normalized relative fluorescence intensities
at 338 nm; the continuous lines represent the nonlinear regression fit of
the relative fluorescence intensities at 338 nm to Eqn. 6 calculated as
described in Materials and Methods. The reversibility points (empty
circles) are shown, for clarity, only for the relative fluorescence
intensities of the wild-type and were not included in the nonlinear
regression analysis. All spectra were recorded at 10uC as described in
Materials and Methods. Figure 6. Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding of PTPr wild-
type and mutants. (A) Normalized intensity-averaged emission
wavelength (l, left axis, filled circles) and molar ellipticity at 222 nm
reported after removal of the high-frequency noise and the low-
frequency random error by SVD ([H]222, right axis, empty squares); the
continuous lines represent the nonlinear global fitting of the molar
ellipticities at 222 nm data to Eqn. 4 for PTPr calculated as described in
Materials and Methods. Temperature dependence of phosphatase activity (B) Normalized relative fluorescence intensities
at 338 nm; the continuous lines represent the nonlinear regression fit of
the relative fluorescence intensities at 338 nm to Eqn. 6 calculated as
described in Materials and Methods. The reversibility points (empty
circles) are shown, for clarity, only for the relative fluorescence
intensities of the wild-type and were not included in the nonlinear
regression analysis. All spectra were recorded at 10uC as described in
Materials and Methods. All the mutations studied here are located at very diverse
positions in the structure, distant from the catalytic site and, except
A1118P, in solvent-exposed loop regions. Presumably, the change
in main chain flexibility caused by the most destabilizing D927G
mutation may lead to local disorder and may affect the stabilizing
hydrogen bonds of residues in close proximity (Asp-947, Lys-930
and Glu-931). This hypothesis is in agreement with the changes in
local
environment
of
aromatic
residues
suggested
by
the
comparison of the near-UV CD spectrum of D927G with that
of the wild-type. The N1128I mutation is less destabilizing than
D927G. In the wild-type structure N1128, about 50% solvent
accessible, is located in a very polar environment at the C-
terminus of helix 8 and is involved, through its peptidic nitrogen,
in a hydrogen bond with the peptide carbonyl of Asp-1124. The
susbtitution of a polar residue, Asn-1128, to a nonpolar residue,
Ile, may also contribute to destabilize the N1128I mutant. Q987K
is the least destabilizing mutation with regard to thermal stability
and temperature dependence of phosphatase activity, probably
due to the fact that Gln-987 in the wild-type structure is not
involved in any interaction with other protein residues. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g006 Discussion (A) Near-UV CD spectra of wild-type and D927G in 0 M,
4.28 M and 7.31 M urea were recorded in a 1-cm quartz cuvette at 2.4 mg/ml protein concentration at 10uC in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5 containing
0.2 M NaCl and 2 mM DTT. (B) and (C) Near-UV CD changes of wild-type and D927G at increasing urea concentrations reported as the first (V1, B) and
the second (V2, C) column of the V matrix. V1 and V2 were obtained by SVD of the near-UV CD spectral data as described in the text. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g007 The reversibility of the urea-induced unfolding equilibrium at
low temperature allows a quantitative determination of the effect
of mutations on the thermodynamic parameters of PTPr catalytic
domain. The destabilizing effect of mutations caused by nsSNPs
on PTPr thermodynamic stability (Table 1) may be referred i) to a
destabilization of the native state for N1128I and D927G, as
indicated by the values of DGH
2
O
I-N lower than that of the wild-
type, and ii) to a stabilization of the intermediate for all the
variants, as suggested by the higher free energy of unfolding from
the intermediate to the unfolded state (DGH
2
O
U-I), with respect to
that of the wild-type (Table 1). The destabilizing effect of D927G
and N1128I substitutions is also evident from the decrease in
melting temperature monitored by secondary structure changes
and from the significant reduction of phosphatase activity at 37uC
that suggests a higher flexibility of the two variants with respect to
the wild-type. by fluorescence intensity. As a matter of fact, fluorescence intensity is
extremely sensitive to the microenvironment of a fluorophore and is
considered as the most straightforward signal that can be related to
thermodynamics of unfolding transitions [31]. The discrepancy
between the thermodynamic parameters obtained by far-UV CD
and fluorescence intensity and the lack of a detectable intermediate
by far-UV CD may indicate that the hyperfluorescent intermediate
state represents conformational changes which occur in the
proximity of any of the tryptophans, with an alternative tertiary
arrangement. In the native state, the maximum emission wavelength
(lmax = 338 nm) indicate that tryptophan residues are shielded
from the solvent, whereas a partial exposure of tryptophan residues
to the solvent is observed for the intermediate (lmax = 345 nm). Discussion PTPr, which belongs to the classical receptor type IIB family of
PTP, is one of the most frequently mutated PTP in human cancers
[1,24]. In this study we investigated the effect of amino acid
substitution on the thermal and thermodynamic stability and on the
activity, of the membrane-proximal catalytic D1 domain of PTPr. Catalytically active fragments of several PTPs of type IIB family are
proteolytically cleaved and released within the cytoplasm of tumour
cells [27–29], hence the biophysical characterization of this catalytic
domain may be relevant. The D1 domain is a monomeric,
structurally independent and stable folding unit characterized by
a high thermodynamic stability. In this study, we selected PTPr
mutations of D1 domain found in colorectal cancers [10] and
reported in nsSNP database [14], D927G, Q987K, A1118P and
N1128I. All the mutants are expressed as soluble recombinant
proteins, except A1118P which remains insoluble also upon All the variants, as revealed by intrinsic fluorescence emission
intensity, show three-state equilibrium unfolding transitions similar
to that of the wild-type, with the accumulation of a hyperfluorescent
intermediate at ,4.0 M urea that retains 35% of the native
secondary structure ellipticity. The hyperfluorescent intermediate of
wild-type and of D927G, the most temperature sensitive variant,
contains tertiary contacts, although the packing of aromatic side-
chains appears different from that of the native state. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 7 PTP r Mutants Stability Figure 7. Effect of urea on near-UV CD spectra of PTPr wild-type and D927G. (A) Near-UV CD spectra of wild-type and D927G in 0 M,
4.28 M and 7.31 M urea were recorded in a 1-cm quartz cuvette at 2.4 mg/ml protein concentration at 10uC in 20 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5 containing
0.2 M NaCl and 2 mM DTT. (B) and (C) Near-UV CD changes of wild-type and D927G at increasing urea concentrations reported as the first (V1, B) and
the second (V2, C) column of the V matrix. V1 and V2 were obtained by SVD of the near-UV CD spectral data as described in the text. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.g007 Figure 7. Effect of urea on near-UV CD spectra of PTPr wild-type and D927G. February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 Protein Expression and Purification PTPr wild-type and mutants were expressed in E. coli strain
BL21(DE3). 10 ml of overnight culture was grown at 37uC in 1 L
LB
media
containing
kanamycin
as
antibiotic
at
a
final
concentration of 50 mg/ml until optical density OD600 reached
0.6. The culture was cooled on ice for 20 min, then the protein
expression was induced overnight by adding 0.5 mM isopropyl-b-
D-thiogalactoside (Sigma-Aldrich) and grown overnight at 15uC
with energic shaking. The culture was harvested by centrifugation
and resuspended in 50 ml of Binding buffer (50 mM Hepes,
500 mM NaCl, 5 mM Imidazole, 5% Glycerol, pH 7.5) contain-
ing 0.5 mM tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine, and stored at 220uC
until use. The cells were thawed on ice supplemented with
protease inhibitors (Complete, Roche) and disrupted by sonica-
tion. The lysate was cleared by centrifugation and the supernatant
was loaded on a DE52 column (GE Healthcare), previously
equilibrated with Binding buffer and 0.5 mM tris(2-carboxyethyl)-
phosphine, to remove nucleic acids. The flow-through was loaded
on
a
Ni-NTA
(Ni2+-
nitriltriacetate)
affinity
column
(GE
Healthcare) pre-equilibrated with Binding buffer. The column
was
washed
with
Binding
buffer
to
elute
weakly
bound
contaminants. The recombinant protein was eluted by passing
over the column binding buffer solutions containing increasing
imidazole
concentrations
(50 mM,
100 mM,
150 mM
and
250 mM, respectively). The collected eluates were supplemented
with a final concentration of 10 mM dithiothreitol (DTT) and
tested for purity on SDS gel using precasted gel system
(Invitrogen). The pure fractions were incubated overnight with
tobacco etch virus protease (Pro-TEV), to remove the hexahisti-
dine tag. After digestion, the protein was concentrated to 2 ml
using Millipore concentrators and loaded onto a Superdex 200
300/10 gel filtration column previously equilibrated with 50 mM
Tris/HCl, 0.25 M NaCl, 10 mM DTT, pH 7.5 at a flow rate of k~Ae{Ea=RT
ð1Þ ð1Þ where k (s21) is the rate constant at temperature T (K), A is a
reaction
specific
quantity,
R
the
gas
constant
(1.987 cal6
mol216K21) and Ea the activation energy of the reaction. Hence,
a plot of ln k versus 1/T gives a straight line with the slope being
2Ea/R. Temperature dependence of phosphatase activity PTPr wild-type enzyme plasmid was obtained by SGC (Oxford)
[8]. Quick Change Site-Directed Mutagenesis Kit (Stratagene) was
used to introduce the single mutations on wild-type PTPr plasmid
used as template. The mutagenic oligonucleotides used are listed
in Table 2. The activity assay mixture containing 20 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.5,
200 mM NaCl, 5 mM CaCl2, 250 mM DTT, and 100 mM of 6,8-
difluoro-4-
methylumbelliferyl
phosphate
(Molecular
Probes
D6567) in a 0.5 ml final volume was incubated at increasing
temperature in a thermostated cuvette. Reaction was started by
adding 2–4 ml of purified enzyme at 10uC to 0.5 ml assay mixture
equilibrated at the desired temperature. The final enzyme
concentration was 1 nM. The solution was thoroughly mixed by
pipetting and the fluorescence at 460 nm (360 nm excitation
wavelength)
was
continuously
monitored
for
360 s
in
the
thermostated cuvette. The fluorescence changes between 150
and 300 s were extrapolated to a standard curve of 6,8-difluoro-7-
hydroxy-4-methylcoumarin (Molecular Probes) monitored under
the same conditions. The 6,8-difluoro-4- methylumbelliferyl
phosphate concentration was well below the Km of the wild-type
(753 mM) [10] and substrate consumption did not exceed 0.4%,
hence the first order rate constant for phosphatase activity, k = s21,
is
obtained
from
[6,8-difluoro-7-
hydroxy-4-methylcoumar-
in]6s21/[enzyme]. The temperature dependence was fitted
nonlinearly to the Arrhenius equation using GraphPad Prism
4.0 to obtain the activation energies (Ea
{) for the catalytic reaction Spectroscopic measurements Intrinsic fluorescence emission measurements were carried out
at 10uC with a LS50B spectrofluorimeter (Perkin-Elmer), at
40.0 mg/ml protein concentration, using a 1.0 cm path length
quartz cuvette. Fluorescence emission spectra were recorded from
300–450 nm
(1 nm
sampling
interval),
with
the
excitation
wavelength set at 295 nm. Far-UV (190–250 nm) CD spectra
were recorded either at a protein concentration of 0.20 mg/ml in
a 0.1 cm cuvette or at 40.0 mg/ml in a 0.5 cm cuvette; near-UV
(250–320 nm) CD spectra were recorded at protein concentration
ranging from 1.0 to 2.4 mg/ml in a 1.0 cm cuvette. Far- and near-
UV CD spectra were measured using 0.1, 0.5 and 1.0 cm path
length quartz cuvettes and the results obtained were expressed as
the mean residue ellipticity [H], assuming a mean residue
molecular mass of 110 per amino acid residue. All spectroscopic
measurements were carried out at 10uC in 20 mM Tris/HCl,
pH 7.5 containing 0.2 M NaCl and 200 mM or 2 mM DTT. Table 2. Primers sequences for mutagenesis of PTPr. Mutant
Primer sequences (59 to 39)
Q987K
Forward: GCGACTCAAGGTCCGATGAAGGAGACTGTAAAGGAC
Reverse: GTCCTTTACAGTCTCCTTCATCGGACCTTGAGTCGC
A1118P Forward:CGGACTGGCTGCTTCATTCCCATTGACACCATGCTTGACATGGC
Reverse:GCCATGTCAAGCATGGTGTCAATGGGAATGAAGCAGCCAGTCCG
N1128I
Forward: GCTTGACATGGCCGAGATTGAAGGGGTGGTGG
Reverse: CCACCACCCCTTCAATCTCGGCCATGTCAAGC
D927G
Forward: GCAGACAGCTTCGTGGGGCACAGCCAAGGAGG
Reverse: CCTCCTTGGCTGTGCCCCACGAAGCTGTCTGC
Mutations were introduced using a Quick Change Site-Directed Mutagenesis Kit
(Stratagene) with the listed primers. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.t002 Table 2. Primers sequences for mutagenesis of PTPr. Mutant
Primer sequences (59 to 39)
Q987K
Forward: GCGACTCAAGGTCCGATGAAGGAGACTGTAAAGGAC
Reverse: GTCCTTTACAGTCTCCTTCATCGGACCTTGAGTCGC
A1118P Forward:CGGACTGGCTGCTTCATTCCCATTGACACCATGCTTGACATGGC
Reverse:GCCATGTCAAGCATGGTGTCAATGGGAATGAAGCAGCCAGTCCG
N1128I
Forward: GCTTGACATGGCCGAGATTGAAGGGGTGGTGG
Reverse: CCACCACCCCTTCAATCTCGGCCATGTCAAGC
D927G
Forward: GCAGACAGCTTCGTGGGGCACAGCCAAGGAGG
Reverse: CCTCCTTGGCTGTGCCCCACGAAGCTGTCTGC
Mutations were introduced using a Quick Change Site-Directed Mutagenesis Kit
(Stratagene) with the listed primers. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.t002 Table 2. Primers sequences for mutagenesis of PTPr. Mutant
Primer sequences (59 to 39)
Q987K
Forward: GCGACTCAAGGTCCGATGAAGGAGACTGTAAAGGAC
Reverse: GTCCTTTACAGTCTCCTTCATCGGACCTTGAGTCGC
A1118P Forward:CGGACTGGCTGCTTCATTCCCATTGACACCATGCTTGACATGGC
Reverse:GCCATGTCAAGCATGGTGTCAATGGGAATGAAGCAGCCAGTCCG
N1128I
Forward: GCTTGACATGGCCGAGATTGAAGGGGTGGTGG
Reverse: CCACCACCCCTTCAATCTCGGCCATGTCAAGC
D927G
Forward: GCAGACAGCTTCGTGGGGCACAGCCAAGGAGG
Reverse: CCTCCTTGGCTGTGCCCCACGAAGCTGTCTGC
Mutations were introduced using a Quick Change Site-Directed Mutagenesis Kit
(Stratagene) with the listed primers. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032555.t002 Table 2. Primers sequences for mutagenesis of PTPr. Discussion Protein
concentration
was
determined spectrophotometrically using a molar absorptivity of
49850 M21 cm21 at 280 nm based on a molecular mass of
35.190 kDa. Discussion These results are in agreement with the structural data which
indicate that in PTPr two out of the five tryptophans, Trp-994 and
Trp-998, are located in the same helical region (helix 6) and Trp-
926, Trp-1023 and Trp-1072 are placed in coil regions. All the five
tryptophans are almost completely buried. In the native state the
solvent accessibility of the five chromophores is 15% for Trp-998,
14% for Trp-926 and 4% for Trp-1023, whereas all the other
tryptophan residues are completely buried. Hence, at approximately
4.0 M urea, it is impossible to assign to any of the five chromophores
a particular role in the fluorescence properties of the intermediate
state. The reversible equilibrium unfolding transitions monitored by
far-UV CD are not coincident with those monitored by near-UV
CD and intrinsic fluorescence emission intensity and do not reveal
any denaturation intermediate. The thermodynamic parameters
relative to the apparent two-state equilibrium unfolding measured
by far-UV CD do not indicate any significant difference between
the variants and the wild-type and are lower than those
determined
by
intrinsic
fluorescence
emission
intensity. In
particular, the shared m value of 1.06 kcal/mol/M calculated
from global fitting of the far-UV CD equilibrium unfolding data is
significantly lower than the predicted m value for a monomeric
protein of 280 amino acid residues unfolded in urea which is
3.7160.3 kcal/mol/M [30], a value closely similar to that measured In conclusion our results revealed a destabilizing and inactivat-
ing role of the mutations of PTPr D1 domain found in colorectal
cancers [10]. All the amino acid mutations studied here are on the
surface of PTPr and could potentially participate in protein-
protein interactions. The stabilization of a folding intermediate, PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 8 PTP r Mutants Stability 1.0 ml/min. 2 ml fractions were collected and the pure protein
was
identified
by
SDS
PAGE. Protein
concentration
was
determined spectrophotometrically using a molar absorptivity of
49850 M21 cm21 at 280 nm based on a molecular mass of
35.190 kDa. coincident with an alternative tertiary arrangement, may play a
role in recognition and interaction with other substrate proteins as
well as in sensitivity of this phosphatase to degradation. 1.0 ml/min. 2 ml fractions were collected and the pure protein
was
identified
by
SDS
PAGE. Data analysis FN~aNzbN urea
½
ð7Þ
FU~aUzbU urea
½
ð8Þ ð7Þ The changes in intrinsic fluorescence emission spectra at
increasing urea concentrations were quantified as the decrease of
relative fluorescence intensity at 345 nm or as the intensity-
averaged emission wavelength, l, [32] calculated according to FU~aUzbU urea
½
ð8Þ ð8Þ where aN and aU are the baseline intercepts for N and U, bN and
bU are the baseline slopes for N and U, respectively. All unfolding
transition data were fitted by using Graphpad Prism 4.0. l~
X
Iili
ð
Þ
.X
Ii
ð Þ
ð2Þ ð2Þ y
g
p p
Far-UV CD spectra recorded as a function of urea concentra-
tion were analyzed by SVD using the software MATLAB (Math-
Works, South Natick, MA) to remove the high frequency noise
and the low frequency random errors and to determine the
number of independent components in any given set of spectra. CD spectra in the 213–250 nm or in the 250–320 nm region were
placed in a rectangular matrix A of n colu mns, one column for
each spectrum collected at each time. The A matrix is decomposed
by SVD into the product of three matrices: A = U*S*VT, where U
and V are orthogonal matrices and S is a diagonal matrix. The U
matrix columns contain the basis spectra and the V matrix
columns contain the urea dependence of each basis spectrum. Both U and V columns are arranged in terms of decreasing order
of the relative weight of information, as indicated by the
magnitude of the singular values in S. The diagonal S matrix
contains the singular values that quantify the relative importance
of each vector in U and V. The signal-to-noise ratio is very high in
the earliest columns of U and V while the random noise is mainly
accumulated in the latest U and V columns. The wavelength
averaged spectral changes induced by increasing denaturant
concentrations are represented by the columns of matrix V;
hence, the plot of the columns of V versus the denaturant
concentrations provides information about the observed transition. where li and Ii are the emission wavelength and its corresponding
fluorescence intensity at that wavelength, respectively. This
quantity is an integral measurement, negligibly influenced by the
noise, which reflects changes in the shape and position of the
emission spectrum. Data analysis Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding transi-
tions monitored by far-UV CD ellipticities changes was analysed
by fitting baseline and transition region data to a two-state linear
extrapolation model [33] according to DGunfolding~DGH2Ozm urea
½
{RT ln Kunfolding
ð3Þ ð3Þ Where DGunfolding is the free energy change for unfolding for a
given denaturant concentration, DGH
2
O the free energy change for
unfolding in the absence of denaturant and m a slope term which
quantifies the change in DGunfolding per unit concentration of
denaturant, R the gas constant, T the temperature and Kunfolding
the equilibrium constant for unfolding. The model expresses the
signal as a function of denaturant concentration: yi~ yNzsN½Xiz yUzsU½Xi
exp
{DGH2O{m½Xi
=RT
1zexp
{DGH2O{m½Xi
RT
ð4Þ Acknowledgments where yi is the observed signal, yU and yN are the baseline
intercepts for unfolded and native protein, sU and sN are the
baseline slopes for the unfolded and native protein, [X]i the
denaturant concentration after the ith addition, DGH
2
O the
extrapolated free energy of unfolding in the absence of denaturant, where yi is the observed signal, yU and yN are the baseline
intercepts for unfolded and native protein, sU and sN are the
baseline slopes for the unfolded and native protein, [X]i the
denaturant concentration after the ith addition, DGH
2
O the
extrapolated free energy of unfolding in the absence of denaturant,
m the slope of a DGunfolding versus [X] plot. Data were globally
fitted with the m values shared between the data sets; all other
parameters were not constrained. The denaturant concentration
at the midpoint of the transition, [urea]0.5, according to equation
3, is calculated as: where yi is the observed signal, yU and yN are the baseline
intercepts for unfolded and native protein, sU and sN are the
baseline slopes for the unfolded and native protein, [X]i the
denaturant concentration after the ith addition, DGH
2
O the
extrapolated free energy of unfolding in the absence of denaturant, We would like to thank Dr Eugenio Benvenuto, head of Biorad-Farm Lab,
for helpful discussion. Thermal denaturation experiments PTPr variants and wild-type (0.20 mg/ml) were heated from
10uC to 72uC in a 0.1 cm quartz cuvette with a heating rate of 1.0
and 0.5 degree6min21 controlled by a Jasco programmable
Peltier element. The dichroic activity at 209 nm and the PMTV
were continuously monitored in parallel every 0.5uC [25]. All the
thermal scans were corrected for the solvent contribution at the
different temperatures. Melting temperature (Tm) values were
calculated by taking the first derivative of the ellipticity at 209 nm
with respect to temperature. All denaturation experiments were
performed in triplicate. where F is the observed fluorescence intensity, m is a constant that
is proportional to the increase in solvent-accessible surface area
between the two states involved in the transition, D50I-N and mI-N
are the midpoint and m value for the transition between N and I,
respectively, and D50U-I and mU-I are the midpoint and m value for
the transition between I and U, respectively [34]. The fluorescence
intensity of the intermediate state (I), FI, is constant whereas that of
the folded state (N) and of the unfolded state (U), FN and FU,
respectively, has a linear dependence on denaturant concentration Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding For equilibrium transition studies, PTPr wild-type and variants
(final concentration 40.0 mg/ml) were incubated at 10uC at
increasing concentrations of urea (0–8 M) in 20 mM Tris/HCl,
pH 7.5, in the presence of 0.2 M NaCl and 200 mM DTT. After
10 min, equilibrium was reached and intrinsic fluorescence
emission and far-UV CD spectra (0.5-cm cuvette) were recorded
in parallel at 10uC. To test the reversibility of the unfolding, PTPr February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 9 PTP r Mutants Stability PTP r Mutants Stability urea
½
0:5~DGH2O
m
ð5Þ wild-type and variants were unfolded at 10uC in 7.0 M urea at
0.4 mg/ml protein concentration in 25 mM Tris/HCl, pH 7.5, in
the presence of 2 mM DTT and 0.2 M NaCl. After 10 min,
refolding was started by 10-fold dilution of the unfolding mixture
at 10uC into solutions of the same buffer used for unfolding
containing decreasing urea concentrations. The final enzyme
concentration was 40 mg/ml. After 24 h, intrinsic fluorescence
emission and far-UV CD spectra were recorded at 10uC. ð5Þ The denaturation curves obtained by plotting the relative
fluorescence intensities changes induced by increasing urea
concentrations were fitted to the following equation assuming a
three-state model: F~
FNzexp mI-N
½urea{D50I-N
RT
. FIzFUexp mU-I
½urea{D50U-I
RT
1zexp mI-N
½urea{D50I-N
RT
. 1zexp mU-I
½urea{D50U-I
RT
ð6Þ ð6Þ PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org References 18. Yue P, Moult J (2006) Identification and analysis of deleterious human SNPs. J Mol Biol 356: 1263–1274. 1. Zhao Y, Zhang X, Guda K, Lawrence E, Sun Q, et al. (2010) Identification and
functional characterization of paxillin as a target of protein tyrosine phosphatase
receptor T. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 107: 2592–2597. 19. Teng S, Michonova-Alexova E, Alexov E (2008) Approaches and resources for
prediction of the effects of non-synonymous single nucleotide polymorphism on
protein function and interactions. Curr Pharm Biotechnol 9: 123–133. p
2. Julien SG, Dube´ N, Hardy S, Tremblay ML (2011) Inside the human cancer
tyrosine Phosphatome. Nat Rev Cancer 11: 35–49. 20. Pleasance ED, Cheetham RK, Stephens PJ, McBride DJ, Humphray SJ, et al. (2010) A comprehensive catalogue of somatic mutations from a human cancer
genome. Nature 463: 191–196. 3. Tonks NK (2006) Protein tyrosine phosphatases: from genes, to function, to
disease. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 7: 833–846. 4. Zhang ZY (2002) Protein tyrosine phosphatases: structure and function,
substrate specificity, and inhibitor development. Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol
42: 209–234. 21. Cheng TM, Lu YE, Vendruscolo M, Lio’ P, Blundell TL (2008) Prediction by
graph theoretic measures of structural effects in proteins arising from non-
synonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms. PLoS Comput Biol 4: e1000135. 5. Andersen JN, Mortensen OH, Peters GH, Drake PG, Iversen LF, et al. (2001)
Structural and evolutionary relationships among protein tyrosine phosphatase
domains. Mol Cell Biol 21: 7117–7136. 22. Yuan HY, Chiou JJ, Tseng WH, Liu CH, Liu CK, et al. (2006) FASTSNP: an
always up-to-date and extendable service for SNP function analysis and
prioritization. Nucleic Acids Res 34: W635–41. 6. O¨ stman A, Hellberg C, Bo¨hmer FD (2006) Protein-tyrosine phosphatases and
cancer. Nat Rev Cancer 6: 307–320. 23. Forbes SA, Bindal N, Bamford S, Cole C, Kok CY, et al. (2011) COSMIC:
mining complete cancer genomes in the Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in
Cancer. Nucleic Acids Res 39: D945–50. 7. Alonso A, Sasin J, Bottini N, Friedberg I, Friedberg I, et al. (2004) Protein
tyrosine phosphatases in the human genome. Cell 117: 699–711. 24. Zhang X, Guo A, Yu J, Possemato A, Chen Y, et al. (2007) Identification of
STAT3 as a substrate of receptor protein tyrosine phosphatase T. Proc Natl
Acad Sci U S A 104: 4060–4064. 8. Barr AJ, Ugochukwu E, Lee WH, King ON, Filippakopoulos P, et al. References (2009)
Large-scale structural analysis of the classical human protein tyrosine
phosphatome. Cell 136: 352–363. 25. Benjwal S, Verma S, Ro¨hm KH, Gursky O (2006) Monitoring protein
aggregation during thermal unfolding in circular dichroism experiments. Protein
Sci 15: 635–639. p
p
9. Zheng XM, Wang Y, Pallen CJ (1992) Cell transformation and activation of
pp60c-src by overexpression of a protein tyrosine phosphatase. Nature 359:
336–339. 26. Ervin J, Larios E, Osva´th S, Schulten K, Gruebele M (2002) What causes
hyperfluorescence: folding intermediates or conformationally flexible native
states? Biophys J 83: 473–483. 10. Wang Z, Shen D, Parsons DW, Bardelli A, Sager J, et al. (2004) Mutational
analysis of the tyrosine phosphatome in colorectal cancers. Science 304:
1164–1166. p y J
27. Scott A, Wang Z (2011) Tumour suppressor function of protein tyrosine
phosphatase receptor-T. Biosci Rep 31: 303–307. 11. Barford D, Flint AJ, Tonks NK (1994) Crystal structure of human protein
tyrosine phosphatase 1B. Science 263: 1397–1404. 28. Craig SE, Brady-Kalnay SM (2011) Cancer cells cut homophilic cell adhesion
molecules and run. Cancer Res 71: 303–309. 12. Stenson PD, Ball E, Howells K, Phillips A, Mort M, et al. (2008) Human Gene
Mutation Database: towards a comprehensive central mutation database. J Med
Genet 45: 124–126. 29. Burgoyne AM, Phillips-Mason PJ, Burden-Gulley SM, Robinson S, Sloan AE, et
al. (2009) Proteolytic cleavage of protein tyrosine phosphatase mu regulates
glioblastoma cell migration. Cancer Res 69: 6960–6968. 13. Hamosh A, Scott AF, Amberger JS, Bocchini CA, McKusick VA (2005) Online
Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM), a knowledgebase of human genes and
genetic disorders. Nucleic Acids Res 33: D514–517. g
g
30. Geierhaas CD, Nickson AA, Lindorff-Larsen K, Clarke J, Vendruscolo M (2007)
BPPred: A computational tool to predict biophysical quantities of proteins. Protein Sci 16: 125–134. 14. Bromberg Y, Rost B (2009) Correlating protein function and stability through
the analysis of single amino acid substitutions. BMC Bioinformatics 10, Suppl 8:
S8. 31. Eftink MR (1994) The use of fluorescence methods to monitor unfolding
transitions in proteins Biophys J 66: 482–501. 15. Allali-Hassani A, Wasney GA, Chau I, Hong BS, Senisterra G, et al. (2009) A
survey of proteins encoded by non-synonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms
reveals a significant fraction with altered stability and activity. Biochem J 424:
15–26. 32. Royer CA, Mann CJ, Matthews CR (1993) Resolution of the fluorescence
equilibrium unfolding profile of trp aporepressor using single tryptophan
mutants. Protein Sci 2: 1844–1852. 33. Author Contributions m the slope of a DGunfolding versus [X] plot. Data were globally
fitted with the m values shared between the data sets; all other
parameters were not constrained. The denaturant concentration
at the midpoint of the transition, [urea]0.5, according to equation
3, is calculated as: Conceived and designed the experiments: AP VC SK IA MA SS RC. Performed the experiments: AP VC IA MA RC. Analyzed the data: AP
VC SK IA MA SS RC. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: VC
SK SS RC. Wrote the paper: AP VC SK SS RC. Purified most of the
proteins: IA. 3, is calculated as: PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 10 PTP r Mutants Stability References Santoro MM, Bolen DW (1988) Unfolding free energy changes determined by
the linear extrapolation method. 1. Unfolding of phenylmethanesulfonyl alpha-
chymotrypsin using different denaturants. Biochemistry 27: 8063–8068. 16. Wang Z, Moult J (2001) SNPs, protein structure, and disease. Hum Mutat 17:
263–270. 34. Rowling PJ, Cook R, Itzhaki LS (2010) Toward classification of BRCA1
missense variants using a biophysical approach. J Biol Chem 285: 20080–20087. 17. Yue P, Li Z, Moult J (2005) Loss of protein structure stability as a major
causative factor in monogenic disease. J Mol Biol 353: 459–473. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org February 2012 | Volume 7 | Issue 2 | e32555 11
|
https://openalex.org/W2866185521
|
http://dspace.vutbr.cz/bitstream/11012/137171/4/Venclovsky__2018_IOP_Conf._Ser.__Mater._Sci._Eng._383_012033.pdf
|
English
| null |
Stochastic optimization of reinforced concrete elements’ design
|
IOP conference series. Materials science and engineering
| 2,018
|
cc-by
| 4,276
|
Stochastic optimization of reinforced concrete
elements’ design To cite this article: J Venclovský* et al 2018 IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng. 383 012033 View the article online for updates and enhancements. This content was downloaded from IP address 147.229.6.155 on 06/12/2018 at 12:02 IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering PAPER • OPEN ACCESS
Stochastic optimization of reinforced concrete
elements’ design
To cite this article: J Venclovský* et al 2018 IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng. 383 012033
View the article online for updates and enhancements. Related content
Stochastic optimization of the scheduling
of a radiotherapy center
Antoine Legrain, Marie-Andrée Fortin,
Nadia Lahrichi et al. -
Stochastic optimization of GeantV code by
use of genetic algorithms
G. Amadio, J. Apostolakis, M. Bandieramonte et al. -
Stochastic Optimization in The Power
Management of Bottled Water Production
Planning
Budi Antoro, Esther Nababan and Herman
Mawengkang
- Related content
Stochastic optimization of the scheduling
of a radiotherapy center
Antoine Legrain, Marie-Andrée Fortin,
Nadia Lahrichi et al. -
Stochastic optimization of GeantV code by
use of genetic algorithms
G. Amadio, J. Apostolakis, M. Bandieramonte et al. -
Stochastic Optimization in The Power
Management of Bottled Water Production
Planning
Budi Antoro, Esther Nababan and Herman
Mawengkang
- PAPER • OPEN ACCESS PAPER • OPEN ACCESS This content was downloaded from IP address 147.229.6.155 on 06/12/2018 at 12:02 1234567890‘’“”
CMSME 2018
IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 1234567890‘’“”
onf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/01203 1
Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution
of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd Stochastic optimization of reinforced concrete elements’
design J Venclovský*, P Štěpánek and I Laníková
Institute of Concrete and Masonry Structures, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Brno
University of Technology, Veveří 331/95, 602 00 Brno, Czech Republic J Venclovský*, P Štěpánek and I Laníková
Institute of Concrete and Masonry Structures, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Brno
University of Technology, Veveří 331/95, 602 00 Brno, Czech Republic J Venclovský*, P Štěpánek and I Laníková
Institute of Concrete and Masonry Structures, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Brno
University of Technology, Veveří 331/95, 602 00 Brno, Czech Republic *E-mail: venclovsky.j@fce.vutbr.cz Abstract. Main goal of the paper is to present an algorithm for stochastic optimization of
design of steel-reinforced concrete element’s cross section. Firstly, the deterministic problem is
introduced and described, followed by the description of uncertainties involved in the process
and stochastic reformulation of the problem. Afterwards, the algorithm itself is introduced. This algorithm is based on internal cycle of deterministic optimization using reduced gradient
method and external cycle of stochastic optimization using regression analysis. The probability
is assessed on orthogonal grid via modified bisection method. The paper concludes with
presentation of the performed calculations and their results. 1. Introduction It is possible to see various applications of mathematical optimization in civil engineering (structural
design, reconstruction of transportation networks etc.) Initially, deterministic approaches have been
introduced to solve these issues (see [1]). But despite their complexity, these approaches are
insufficient to comprehend the probabilistic nature of mentioned problems and thus provide only
suboptimal solutions. Hence the effort prevails to reconsider these deterministic approaches and deal
with uncertainties involved in said issues in less straightforward way (see [2, 3]). Paper focuses on optimization of the structural design. There are various approaches to the
optimization. The difference between deterministic and stochastic optimization was already mentioned. This paper is aimed on stochastic optimization. Further differences derive from the subject of
optimization. In this case, it is the shape of the cross section. It is also possible to distinguish various optimization algorithms. There are analytic algorithms
(e.g. [4]) and simulation algorithms (e.g. [5]). Analytic algorithms are based on probabilistic analysis
of the problem and it is known, that they cannot be used to achieve a high precision. Simulation
algorithms are based on discretization of probability into particular scenarios followed by simulation
using these scenarios (every particular scenario is actually deterministic). Since the precision that
needs to be achieved can be very high (even 10-6) it seems that the only possibility to achieve such
precision is to use simulation and heuristic algorithm simultaneously. This paper aims to introduce an optimization algorithm, which works in two cycles. The internal
cycle is deterministic and based on reduced gradient method. The external cycle deals with probability
and as mentioned before it is heuristic, based on simulation and regression analysis. It works in the
space of stochastic variables rather than the space of the design variables. The algorithm is aimed to
reach 99.99 % probability that the structural element satisfies ultimate and serviceability limit states. 1 1234567890‘’“”
CMSME 2018
IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 1234567890‘’“”
CMSME 2018
IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 1234567890‘’“”
g
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 1234567890‘’“”
onf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/01203 2.1. Vector of design variables x. This paper restricts itself to one-dimensional construction elements – beams. The length of the beam is
obviously set and cannot change. Vector x in task (1-4) therefore contains variables, which describe
shape of the beam’s cross section, including the area of reinforcing steel (see figure 1 as an example). C
x
. (4) All conditions and variables are described in more detail in the following text. It is necessary to
mention, that besides the vector of design variables x, there are another inputs into the task (1-4),
namely prescribed loads and material characteristics. 2.4. Serviceability limit state 2. Deterministic approach pp
It is necessary to begin by introducing the problem in its deterministic form. In deterministic approach,
all probability inputs are replaced with their design values. Furthermore, the principle of safety
coefficients is applied. Simplified definition of the optimization task therefore is: )
(
in
x
f
, subject to:
(1)
)
(
)
(
x
x
R
L
,
(2)
max
)
(
w
w
x
,
(3)
C
x
. (4) )
(
min
x
x
f
, subject to:
(1)
)
(
)
(
x
x
R
L
,
(2)
max
)
(
w
w
x
,
(3)
C
x
. (4) )
(
min
x
f
, subject to: 2.2. Objective function The objective function f(x) in (1) can represent anything from simple cost of materials to multi-criteria
function describing environmental aspects through construction, maintenance and disposal of the
structure. To maintain simplicity, the objective function, which calculates the cost of materials, is used
in this paper: sw
s
cv
c
C
W
C
V
f
)
(
)
(
)
(
x
x
x
,
(5) (5) where Vc is volume of used concrete, Ccv is cost of concrete per unit of volume, Ws is weight of used
steel and Csw is cost of steel per unit of weight. where Vc is volume of used concrete, Ccv is cost of concrete per unit of volume, Ws is weight of used
steel and Csw is cost of steel per unit of weight. 2.3. Ultimate limit state The condition (2) represents ULS in task (1-4) – L(x) is the effect of load and R(x) is the structural
resistance. This description of ULS is of course very simplified. In fact, ULS consists of many
equations and a condition limiting the values of strain of concrete and steel. In order to evaluate ULS it is necessary to calculate the vector of deformations first. This is
achieved using matrix calculations, which are in principle based on solving the following differential
equation via the finite element method: q
EIw
)
4
(
,
(6) q
EIw
)
4
(
, (6) where E is the Young modulus of elasticity, I is the moment if inertia, w is the deflection and q is the
prescribed uniformly distributed load over unit of length. Solving this equation via matrix calculations
based on FEM gives: F
KU
,
(7) (7) F
KU
, where K is the stiffness matrix, U is the vector of deformations and F is the vector of load. U i
hi
i
h i
l f
l
l
d F
h
h
ll d
i where K is the stiffness matrix, U is the vector of deformations and F is the vector of load. Using this equation, the internal forces are calculated. From them, the so-called strain parameters
(see [5]) and subsequently the strains of concrete and steel in decisive points are computed and they
are compared to their limiting values. 2 CMSME 2018 CMSME 2018 1234567890‘’“”
CMSME 2018
IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 1234567890‘’“”
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 As it is obvious from condition (3), the SLS in this paper is restricted to limiting deflection. The
condition (3) is again very simplified and actually represents large number of equations. The
evaluation of SLS is similar to evaluation of ULS with the difference, that the possible formation of
cracks must be taken into account. These cracks then affect the bending stiffness Bi: i
i
EI
B
,
(8) (8) i
i
EI
B
, which affects the moment of inertia Ii – one of the inputs into the differential equation and therefore
the matrix calculation. Whether the cracks form is determined from the vector of internal forces. 2.5. Design variables’ boundaries Condition (4) define boundaries of the design variables’ values. It also represents conditions following
mutual relations among these variables – e.g. maximal and minimal area of steel reinforcement in
relation to area of the concrete cross section. 2.6. Optimization algorithm Optimization itself uses the reduced gradient method, specifically the solver CONOPT from the
optimization software GAMS. This sets some rules for the performed calculations. All relations
(equations) and their first derivatives must be continuous. In some cases (stress-strain diagrams,
mentioned stiffness in SLS), this is achieved using Hermit interpolation (see [5] again). C
x
, (12) where M is mean, ξ represents uncertainty, α is a desired probability that the ULS condition holds and
β is a desired probability that the SLS condition holds. where M is mean, ξ represents uncertainty, α is a desired probability that the ULS condition holds and
β is a desired probability that the SLS condition holds. 2.3. Ultimate limit state It is
therefore necessary to find the state of equilibrium (of variables’ values in the mentioned equations,
see [5]). 3. Stochastic approach pp
p
p
p
mbodying uncertainties, the original task (1-4) is reformulated to its stochastic form: By embodying uncertainties, the original task (1-4) is reformulated to its stochastic form ))
,
(
(
min
x
x
f
M
, subject to:
(9)
))
,
(
)
,
(
(
x
x
R
L
P
,
(10)
)
)
,
(
(
max
w
w
P
x
,
(11)
C
x
,
(12) ))
,
(
(
min
x
x
f
M
, subject to:
(9)
))
,
(
)
,
(
(
x
x
R
L
P
,
(10)
)
)
,
(
(
max
w
w
P
x
,
(11)
C
x
,
(12) ))
,
(
(
min
x
x
f
M
, subject to:
(9)
))
,
(
)
,
(
(
x
x
R
L
P
,
(10)
)
)
,
(
(
max
w
w
P
x
,
(11)
C
x
,
(12)
where M is mean, ξ represents uncertainty, α is a desired probability that the ULS condition holds and
β is a desired probability that the SLS condition holds. ))
,
(
(
min
x
x
f
M
, subject to:
(9)
))
,
(
)
,
(
(
x
x
R
L
P
,
(10)
)
)
,
(
(
max
w
w
P
x
,
(11)
C
x
,
(12) (9) (10)
(11)
(12) (11)
(12) (11) C
x
,
(12) 3. Stochastic approach pp
The designing process involves a lot of uncertainties. Among these are: The designing process involves a lot of uncertainties. Among these are: The designing process involves a lot of uncertainties. Among these are:
randomness of physical quantities used in the design (as its natural characteristic)
statistical uncertainties during the description of a quantity caused by a lack of data,
model uncertainties caused by inaccuracies in the calculation model in comparison with real
structural behavior,
uncertainties caused by inaccuracies of the limit states definitions,
human element deficiencies within the design procedure and execution and usage of the
randomness of physical quantities used in the design (as its natural characteristic)
statistical uncertainties during the description of a quantity caused by a lack of data, model uncertainties caused by inaccuracies in the calculation model in comparison with re
structural behavior, ,
uncertainties caused by inaccuracies of the limit states definitions,
human element deficiencies within the design procedure and execution and usage of the
structure. In the deterministic approach all these uncertainties are included in the calculation by using design
values and/or via using various safety coefficients. It is obvious, that for desired probability of
structure failure, the stochastic approach provides more precise and improved solution. 4. Example p
osed solution is presented directly on a simple example. p
Proposed solution is presented directly on a simple example. The task is to design 5 m long cantilever beam loaded with uniformly distributed load q and normal
force N as shown on figure 1. The task is to design 5 m long cantilever beam loaded with uniformly distributed load q and normal
force N as shown on figure 1. Cross section of the beam is described by 8 variables b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3, As1, As3 – 6 of them
describe the shape of cross section, while 2 describe the area of reinforcing steel (see figure 1). Cross section of the beam is described by 8 variables b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3, As1, As3 – 6 of them
describe the shape of cross section, while 2 describe the area of reinforcing steel (see figure 1). 3 IOP Publishing 1234567890‘’“”
CMSME 2018
IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 1234567890‘’“”
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 Figure 1. Scheme of the cantilever, x = (b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3, As1, As3). h
h1
h2
h3
b2
b2
b1
b3
As1
As3
N
5 m
q Figure 1. Scheme of the cantilever, x = (b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3, As1, As3). Figure 1. Scheme of the cantilever, x = (b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3, As1, As3). Figure 1. Scheme of the cantilever, x = (b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3, As1, As3). In the FEM calculation, the cantilever is divided into 10 elements e1, …, e10, each 0.5 m in length. Th
di t ib t d l
d
[kN/ ]
d
l f
N [kN]
d
i bl
ith In the FEM calculation, the cantilever is divided into 10 elements e1, …, e10, each 0.5 m in length. The distributed load q [kN/m] and normal force N [kN] are random variables with gamma
distribution. Probability distributions of q and N are: g
The distributed load q [kN/m] and normal force N [kN] are random variables with gamma
distribution. Probability distributions of q and N are: )
015
.0
;
1500
(
~
q
,
)
05
.0
;
148
(
~
N
. 5. Solution algorithm The algorithm uses regression analysis to iterate towards the suitable solution of the task. In this
chapter, the algorithm is described, including the method of probability assessment. 4. Example (13) (13) In order to better understand the distributions, the 0.05 quantile of distribution of q is 21.6 kN/m,
0.5 quantile is 22.5 kN/m and 0.95 quantile is 23.5 kN/m. Analogically, 0.05 quantile of distribution of
N is 6.4 kN, 0.5 quantile is 7.4 kN and 0.95 quantile is 8.4 kN. All these values are approximate. ,
q
q
pp
To maintain simplicity, the probabilities α and β from conditions (10) and (11) are replaced with
only one probability γ. The mentioned conditions are thus replaced with following condition: (14)
)
)
,
(
)
,
(
)
,
(
(
max
w
w
R
L
P
x
x
x
. (14)
)
)
,
(
)
,
(
)
,
(
(
max
w
w
R
L
P
x
x
x
. (14 The value γ is set to 99.99 %. γ
There are some other restrictions regarding design variables. The overall height of cross section is
limited to 350 mm. Each of the heights h1, h2, h3 has to be minimally 100 mm. The width b2 is at least
100 mm, b1 and b3 at least 200 mm but no more than 900 mm. For widths b1, b3 the following
condition needs to be fulfilled: )
20
50
(
)
4
/
20
/(
50
2
2
sk
k
A
b
. (15) (15) This relation represents, that the given width has to accommodate required area of reinforcing steel;
reinforcing steel is composed of bars 20 mm in diameter, minimum distance between the surface of
any steel bar and the concrete surface and between any two steel bars is 50 mm. y
y
The considered costs are 2500 CZK per 1 m3 of concrete and 30 CZK per 1 kg of steel. 5.1. Probability assessment The probability is assessed on an orthogonal mesh via method, that can be described as modified
bisection method. The principle of this method is to find the boundary between scenarios, which
satisfies deterministic conditions of the task, and scenarios, which do not. Orthogonal mesh in its maximum size (bisection divides maximum mesh into smaller ones)
consists of 514×514 points. The mesh layout is thicker toward the expected location of the mentioned
boundary. 4 CMSME 2018 1234567890‘’“”
CMSME 2018
IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 1234567890‘’“”
g
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/012033 1234567890‘’“”
onf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/01203 5.2. Calculation initialization The calculation is initialized by selecting given number of scenarios of random variables. For each
scenario the deterministic optimization is performed and probability, that thus acquired solution holds
ULS and SLS conditions, is assessed (assessment of the left hand side of condition (14)). In this paper,
the example defined in chapter 4 is initialized by 16 scenarios, which are made of combinations of
values of q and N as follows:
75
. 24
;
25
. 23
;
75
. 21
;
25
. 20
q
,
(16)
75
.9
;
25
.8
;
75
.6
;
25
.5
N
. (17) (16)
(17) (17) 5.5. Heuristic algorithm Proposed algorithm actually does not solve minimization task (9) but the task:
)
(
i
i
f
(18) (18) Therefore, the algorithm is heuristic and provides only suboptimal solution. Therefore, the algorithm is heuristic and provides only suboptimal solution. 5.3. Regression analysis g
y
Acquired points are fitted with a polynomial function via least squares method – for probability it is
the 3rd degree polynomial, for objective function it is the 1st degree polynomial. Degrees of
polynomials were chosen appropriately in regard to values of probability and objective function
observed on a greater sample than just the mentioned 16 scenarios. Regression analysis is weighted. The error in each point i is multiplied by 1/|pi-γ|, where pi is the
assessed left hand side of condition (14) for point i. This way, the regression resembles interpolation
while near the solution. 5.4. Iteration After initialization, the iterative process follows. According to regression analysis, the point that
satisfies condition (14) and at the same time has the minimal value of objective function is selected as
a possible solution. For this scenario the deterministic optimization is performed and probability that
thus acquired solution satisfies deterministic conditions is assessed. If the resulting probability is greater and also sufficiently close to value γ, the algorithm ends and
the current deterministic solution is the solution of the whole task. In the opposite case, this newly assessed point is added as another point to the regression analysis. Regression, new point selection, deterministic optimization and probability assessment are all
performed again. This iterative procedure continues, until the assessed probability is higher and also
sufficiently close to value γ. 6. Calculation results u
o
esu s
contains the values of design variables, which were found as a solution to the example from
4. Table 1 contains the values of design variables, which were found as a solution to the example from
chapter 4. ble 1. Values of design variables b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3 [mm] and As1, As2 [mm2] in finite elements
e1, …, e10 as a solution to example defined in chapter 4. Table 1. Values of design variables b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3 [mm] and As1, As2 [mm2] in fin
e1
e10 as a solution to example defined in chapter 4 Table 1. Values of design variables b1, b2, b3, h1, h2, h3 [mm] and As1, As2 [mm2] in finite elements
e1, …, e10 as a solution to example defined in chapter 4. e1
e2
e3
e4
e5
e6
e7
e8
e9
e10
b1
900.0
781.9
655.5
546.1
445.1
353.0
900.0
470.1
200.0
200.0
b2
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
b3
900.0
900.0
899.6
712.5
542.3
392.1
402.0
200.0
200.0
200.0
h1
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
h2
150.0
150.0
150.0
150.0
150.0
150.0
150.0
150.0
100.0
100.0
h3
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
As1
3590.4
3060.2
2493.0
2002.2
1548.9
1135.6
360.7
196.4
92.8
60.0
As2
210.0
195.8
180.6
152.5
126.8
103.7
170.2
102.4
60.0
60.0 5 1234567890‘’“”
onf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 383 (2018) 012033 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/383/1/01203 The probability, that solution satisfies ULS and SLS was assessed as 99.99017 %. This probability
was subsequently tested by the Monte Carlo simulation. From 105 scenarios, 9 failed the deterministic
conditions which is in accordance with previous probability assessment. p
p
y
The solution was found for the scenario q = 24.6767 kN/m, N = 4.7635 kN. Its objective function
value is 3575.08 CZK. Evidently, the values from table 1 are not suitable for an actual design purposes. They serve rather
as a guide to arrange the cantilever’s cross section over its length. Table 1 contains one peculiar value (b1 in e7). This is caused by the deterministic optimization
algorithm – the GRG method. Since the only function of width b1 is to accommodate reinforcement
area As1, this value can obviously be lowered. Acknowledgment g
This contribution was prepared within a scientific-research work of the project FAST/FSI-J-17-4753
“Advanced methods of design optimization of structural elements”, supported by the Brno University
of Technology, Faculty of Civil Engineering and Faculty of Mechanical Engineering. 6. Calculation results Nevertheless, the optimization algorithm kept the
current value, because the minimum (defined as a reduced gradient sufficiently close to zero) was
already reached. 7. Conclusions The algorithm to stochastically optimize design of reinforced concrete structural elements was
developed. This algorithm was successfully tested on a simple example. Probability assessment of
proposed algorithm was successfully tested by Monte Carlo method. The future work should focus on
reaching higher precision of probability of failure as well as on using the algorithm in issues with
more random variables. [1]
Chakrabarty B K 1992 A model for optimal design of reinforced concrete beam Journal of
Structural Engineering 108 3238–42 References
[1]
Chakrabarty B K 1992 A model for optimal design of reinforced concrete beam Journal of
Structural Engineering 108 3238–42
[2]
Frangopol D M, Kongh J S and Ghareibeh E S 2001 Reliability-based life-cycle management of
highway bridges Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering 15 27–34
[3]
Ziemba W T and Wallace S W 2004 Applications of Stochastic Programming SIAM conference
[4]
Žampachová E 2009 Approximations in stochastic optimization and their applications
(Ph.D. thesis, Brno University of Technology)
[5]
Plšek J 2011 Design optimisation of concrete structures (Ph.D. thesis, Brno University of
Technology) References [1]
Chakrabarty B K 1992 A model for optimal design of reinforced concrete beam Journal of
Structural Engineering 108 3238–42 g
g
rangopol D M, Kongh J S and Ghareibeh E S 2001 Reliability-based life-cycle management of
highway bridges Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering 15 27–34 g
y
g
f
p
g
g
g
[3]
Ziemba W T and Wallace S W 2004 Applications of Stochastic Programming SIAM conference g
y
g
f
p
g
g
g
Ziemba W T and Wallace S W 2004 Applications of Stochastic Programming SIAM conferenc
Ž [4]
Žampachová E 2009 Approximations in stochastic optimization and their applications
(Ph.D. thesis, Brno University of Technology) (
y
gy)
[5]
Plšek J 2011 Design optimisation of concrete structures (Ph.D. thesis, Brno University of
Technology) 6 6
|
https://openalex.org/W3150541371
|
https://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/track/pdf/10.1186/s12864-021-07562-w
|
English
| null |
Evolutionary research on the expansin protein family during the plant transition to land provides new insights into the development of Tartary buckwheat fruit
|
BMC genomics
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 12,502
|
Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12864-021-07562-w Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12864-021-07562-w Open Access © The Author(s). 2021 Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License,
which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give
appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if
changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons
licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons
licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain
permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the
data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Evolutionary research on the expansin
protein family during the plant transition to
land provides new insights into the
development of Tartary buckwheat fruit Wenjun Sun1†, Haomiao Yu1†, Moyang Liu1,2†, Zhaotang Ma3 and Hui Chen1* Wenjun Sun1†, Haomiao Yu1†, Moyang Liu1,2†, Zhaotang Ma3 and Hui Chen1* * Correspondence: chenhui@sicau.edu.cn p
@
†Wenjun Sun, Haomiao Yu and Moyang Liu contributed equally to this work. 1College of Life Science, Sichuan Agricultural University, Ya’an 625014, China
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article Abstract Background: Plant transitions to land require robust cell walls for regulatory adaptations and to resist changing
environments. Cell walls provide essential plasticity for plant cell division and defense, which are often conferred by
the expansin superfamily with cell wall-loosening functions. However, the evolutionary mechanisms of expansin
during plant terrestrialization are unclear. Results: Here, we identified 323 expansin proteins in 12 genomes from algae to angiosperms. Phylogenetic
evolutionary, structural, motif gain and loss and Ka/Ks analyses indicated that highly conserved expansin proteins
were already present in algae and expanded and purified after plant terrestrialization. We found that the expansion
of the FtEXPA subfamily was caused by duplication events and that the functions of certain duplicated genes may
have differentiated. More importantly, we generated space-time expression profiles and finally identified five
differentially expressed FtEXPs in both large and small fruit Tartary buckwheat that may regulate fruit size by
responding to indoleacetic acid. Conclusions: A total of 323 expansin proteins from 12 representative plants were identified in our study during
terrestrialization, and the expansin family that originated from algae expanded rapidly after the plants landed. The
EXPA subfamily has more members and conservative evolution in angiosperms. FtEXPA1, FtEXPA11, FtEXPA12,
FtEXPA19 and FtEXPA24 can respond to indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) signals and regulate fruit development. Our study
provides a blueprint for improving the agronomic traits of Tartary buckwheat and a reference for defining the
evolutionary history of the expansin family during plant transitions to land. Keywords: Expansin, Terrestrialization, Phylogenetic, Evolutionary research, Tartary buckwheat * Correspondence: chenhui@sicau.edu.cn Background Land plant radiation and colonization are important key-
stones in the evolutionary history of living organisms,
which have created the ecological diversity on Earth that
we see today. This transition was accompanied by com-
plex and long biological evolution, which included mor-
phological, physiological, and genetic changes, to cope
with the terrestrial environment and its challenging con-
ditions [1, 2]. The cell wall plays a key role in plant
growth and development, material transport, pathogen
resistance, cell division and differentiation, organ senes-
cence and shedding. It also provides the necessary mech-
anical support for plant cells and the plasticity that is
necessary for protection against external intrusion [3, 4]. The number and volume of plant cells always change dy-
namically, and both are regulated by cell wall plasticity
during plant growth [5]. Studies have shown that the
role of expansin proteins in the cell wall is critical to
achieve this necessary plasticity [5]. Expansin is an import-
ant plant growth-regulating divisor that can realize the
continuous assembly, remodeling and decomposition of
cell walls [6]. It has significant functionality in many stages
of plant growth and development [7], such as stem growth
and internode elongation [8], fruit ripening [9], seed ger-
mination [10], control of flowering time and flower size
[11], root growth [12] and leaf development [13]. g
p
Expansin proteins contain 250-275 amino acid resi-
dues [14] and consist of two conserved domains. The N-
terminal conserved domain I (DPBB), which contains
approximately 120-135 amino acids, is homologous to
glycoside hydrolase family-45 (GH45). Previous studies
have shown that there is no β-glucan sugar hydrolysis at
the N-terminus of expansin proteins [15]. Another do-
main (domain II in the C-terminus) contains approxi-
mately 90-120 amino acids and has higher similarity
with Group-II pollen allergen proteins (G2A family) and
presumably is a polysaccharide binding domain (PLN)
based on the polar residues on the surfaces of proteins
and conserved aromatics [16]. To date, no other proteins
containing domain II congeners have been found except
for the G2A families [17]. A recent study established a
3D model of the FaEXPA2 protein that was involved in
strawberry fruit softening and determined that FaEXPA2
formed a more stable complex with cellulose than other
ligands via the different residues present in the open
groove surface of its two domains [18]. © The Author(s). 2021 Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License,
which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give
appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if
changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons
licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons
licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain
permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the
data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 2 of 17 Page 2 of 17 EXLA and EXLB also possess two typical expansin pro-
tein domains, there is no experimental evidence that
they also have the function of loosening cell walls [21]. Generally, EXPA is widely found in dicotyledonous and
monocotyledonous plants, except non-Poaceae, while
EXPB is mainly found in monocotyledonous plants [15]. Expansin proteins have been studied in many important
species, including Arabidopsis thaliana (A. thaliana)
[22], tea [23], Solanum lycopersicum [24], Z. mays [25],
Glycine max [26], cotton [27] and wheat [28]. The EXPA
subfamily was the first subfamily to be identified that
contains cell wall-loosening proteins, which can quickly
induce relaxation of the cell wall without lytic activity
[29]. AtEXPA7, which is an EXPA family gene that is
specifically expressed in root hair cells, was isolated from
A. thaliana, and its biological function was detected by
using
RNA
interference. The
results
showed
that
AtEXPA7 played an indispensable role in root hair tip
growth [30]. Overexpression of AtEXPA2 promotes seed
germination, while inhibition of its expression leads to a
delay in seed germination [31]. Meanwhile, studies have
shown that AtEXPA2 may regulate seed germination
through the GA signaling pathway [31]. The EXPB sub-
family consists of two subgroups. Group-1 proteins are
highly expressed in grass pollen [32] and can relax cell
walls without destroying them [32]. Research on EXPA
and EXPB is relatively deeper [33]. Recent reports have
also confirmed the role of expansin proteins in fruit
enlargement [34, 35], which provides new insights for
improving crop agronomic traits. Global identification and evolution of Expansin proteins
from algae to land plants Considering the important role of expansin proteins in
plant development and adaptation to complex terrestrial
environments, we identified 323 expansin proteins in 12
genomes from algae to angiosperms. We studied these
proteins by performing phylogenetic analysis, gene struc-
ture and motif composition analysis, cis-acting element
identification of promoter regions, and gene duplication. We also analyzed the origin and evolution of expansin
proteins in representative plants during plant terrestriali-
zation. More importantly, we identified five candidate
genes from the EXPA subfamily that may improve the
important agronomic traits of Tartary buckwheat, which
was accomplished by combining the expression of 37
genes in different tissues and organs, especially in the
important stages of fruit development. In summary, our
study identified the FtEXP gene family for the first time. The conservation and evolution of this species in the
process of plant landing are discussed, and its potential
regulatory roles in fruit development and hormone re-
sponse are determined, which provides new insights for
Tartary buckwheat breeding. To further understand the evolutionary history of expan-
sin during plant transitions to land, we identified 323
expansin genes by using BLAST and profile HMM
searches of two algae (Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and
Volvox carteri); three bryophytes (Marchantia polymor-
pha, Physcomitrella patens and Sphagnum palustre);
early angiosperms (Amborella trichopoda); two mono-
cotyledons (Oryza sativa and Zea mays) and four
dicotyledons (F. tataricum, Arabidopsis, Vitis vinifera
and Coffea arabica) (Fig. 1, Table S1). We divided the
expansin family into four subfamilies (EXPA, EXPB,
EXLA and EXLB) according to the distribution and
structural
characteristics
of
the
Arabidopsis
EXP
(AtEXP) members [20] (Fig. 1, Table S2). Furthermore, the numbers of expansins in each sub-
group of these species were investigated (Fig. 1, Table S1). There were fewer members of the algae EXPA subfamily
and more members of the EXLB subfamily, which was in
sharp contrast to higher plants (Fig. 1). Interestingly, up to
32 members of the EXPA subfamily were found in M. polymorpha, while other subfamily members were not Fig. 1 Phylogeny and diversity of expansin proteins in 12 species. A species tree was constructed using the online software TIMETREE (http://
www.timetree.org/). The number of members in different subfamilies is expressed by a color scale. The blue, green, gray, light green and orange
colors represent algae, Bryophyta, early angiosperms, monocotyledons and dicotyledons, respectively Fig. 1 Phylogeny and diversity of expansin proteins in 12 species. Background Similarly, mo-
lecular dynamics showed that the FaEXPA5 protein is
involved in strawberry fruit softening and can interact
with ligands through the residues present in the open
groove along the two domains [19]. Expansin proteins
are cocoded by multiple gene families and are divided
into
the
α-expansin
(EXPA),
β-expansin
(EXPB),
expansin-like A (EXLA), and expansin-like B (EXLB)
subfamilies according to their phylogeny [20]. While Current agricultural studies are centered on the main
staple crops, including rice, wheat and maize. However,
this narrow research scope is not promising for provid-
ing systematic solutions to the challenges of food secur-
ity and poverty [36]. Adding nutrient-rich pseudocereals
to major cereals is a potential strategy to improve dietary
diversity and provide alternative food stocks. Tartary
buckwheat (Fagopyrum tataricum) is a versatile pseudo-
cereal that is known as the golden crop [36]. It is also a
traditional Chinese grain crop that is widely cultivated in
China. Because of its strong environmental adaptability,
it has become the main food source for people living in
severe environments such as the southwest plateau of
China [37]. Tartary buckwheat fruits are rich in starch,
proteins, dietary fiber, vitamins and other nutrients [38]. In addition, the flavonoid contents in Tartary buckwheat
are significantly higher than those of other foods, and
proper intake can help organisms due to their antioxi-
dant and anti-aging properties, as well as their ability to
lower blood pressure and reduce the risk of arterioscler-
osis [39]. Because of its important value in food and
medicine, Tartary buckwheat has received more atten-
tion from breeding and genetic researchers in recent
years. Some challenges in the breeding of Tartary Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 3 of 17 Page 3 of 17 buckwheat, such as increasing the dehulling efficiency of
fruit, improving fruit quality, and increasing fruit size,
remain to be solved [40]. Results Global identification and evolution of Expansin proteins
from algae to land plants Global identification and evolution of Expansin proteins
from algae to land plants Analysis of phylogeny and evolution suggests that the
FtEXPA subfamily has rich members and special
structures We identified 37 expansin proteins in the Tartary buck-
wheat genome and assembled the basic information for
these genes, such as Mw, PI, subcellular localization,
CDS and protein sequence (Table S3-4). Based on the
multiple sequence alignment of 37 FtEXP proteins and
34 A. thaliana expansin proteins, we reconstructed a
maximum likelihood phylogenetic tree to explore the
evolutionary relationships of expansin proteins in Tar-
tary buckwheat (Fig. 2). The number of genes in differ-
ent subfamilies varies. The EXLB subfamily has the
lowest number of members (only one gene), and the
EXPA subfamily has the largest number of genes (Fig. 2). The number of expansin proteins in each subfamily
of Tartary buckwheat is very close to that in A. thaliana. Furthermore, we mapped all FtEXPs to 8 chromo-
somes, based on physical location information from the
Tartary buckwheat genome generic feature format (Gff)
data (Fig. 3). The 37 FtEXPs are unevenly distributed on
8 chromosomes. Most genes are on chromosome 3
(eleven genes), and the fewest are on chromosome 6
(only one gene). The genes on chromosome 7 and
chromosome
8 are also
less distributed, but each
chromosome has a tandem duplicate region. Multiple
FtEXPs are distributed on chromosomes 1, 3 and 4, but
only one pair of tandemly duplicated genes was detected
on chromosome 3 (Fig. 3). Two pairs of EXPA subfamily
genes (FtPinG0001244700.01-FtPinG0001244900.01 and
FtPinG0009206900.01-
FtPinG0009207100.01)
from
chromosomes 3 and 8 are tandem duplications, which
may have contributed to the expansion of the EXPA
subfamily to some extent. In addition, 37 FtEXPs were
renamed according to their subfamilies and chromo-
somal distributions (Table S3). Environmental stress can profoundly affect the growth
and development of plants [41]. We analyzed the cis-
acting elements of 37 FtEXP promoter regions by using
PlantCARE software to investigate their responses to the
environment. Three
environmentally
responsive
ele-
ments were detected, including light-, low temperature-
and defense stress resistance-responsive elements, and
they were widespread in 37 FtEXPs (Fig. S3). Most
hormone-responsive elements (MeJA, auxin, abscisic
acid and gibberellin) were also widely distributed in all
FtEXPs, except the salicylic acid-responsive elements
(Fig. S3). Salicylic acid-responsive elements exist only in
the EXPA subfamily, and such responsive elements that
are related to plant disease resistance [42] and drought
tolerance [43] have attracted our attention. Global identification and evolution of Expansin proteins
from algae to land plants A species tree was constructed using the online software TIMETREE (http://
www.timetree.org/). The number of members in different subfamilies is expressed by a color scale. The blue, green, gray, light green and orange
colors represent algae, Bryophyta, early angiosperms, monocotyledons and dicotyledons, respectively Page 4 of 17 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 4 of 17 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 five
introns,
while
its
exon
length
is
significantly
different from those of the other genes (Fig. 4a). Analysis
of the motifs was performed through the online MEME
software to further study the characteristic regions of
the FtEXP proteins (Fig. 4b). Most members of the
EXPA subfamily contain motifs 1 to 8, while most
members of the other subfamilies contain motifs 3, 4, 7, 9
and 10 (Fig. 4b). Notably, some genes contain very few mo-
tifs; for example, FtEXPA26 (FtPinG0007038600.01) con-
tains only motif 5, while FtEXPA9 (FtPinG0000802100.01)
contains only motifs 3 and 4. Overall, most genes
from the same subfamily have similar motif composi-
tions, and the expansin proteins of the other 11
plants also have conserved domains and general char-
acteristics (Fig. S1-S2, Table S5). found, which shows that the EXPA subfamily began to ex-
pand as the plant made the transition to land. In mono-
cotyledon species, EXPB was the larger subfamily, while
EXPA was the larger subfamily in dicotyledons. EXLB was
present only in early angiosperms and dicotyledons but
not in other plants except for V. carteri, and EXPA arose
early in the evolution of bryophytes and was conserved
across land plants (Fig. 1). found, which shows that the EXPA subfamily began to ex-
pand as the plant made the transition to land. In mono-
cotyledon species, EXPB was the larger subfamily, while
EXPA was the larger subfamily in dicotyledons. EXLB was
present only in early angiosperms and dicotyledons but
not in other plants except for V. carteri, and EXPA arose
early in the evolution of bryophytes and was conserved
across land plants (Fig. 1). Gene duplication and evolutionary analysis of Expansin
gene families in representative species Gene duplication that arises from tandem duplication or
during polyploidization and segmental duplication asso-
ciated with replication is a major factor causing family
expansion. For a deeper understanding of the evolution
of expansin homologous copy genes, we conducted a
syntenic analysis of the expansin proteins from four di-
cotyledons (F. tataricum, Arabidopsis, C. arabica and V. vinifera) and two monocotyledonous plants (O. sativa
and Z. mays). We detected 14 pairs of segmental
duplications on different chromosomes of Tartary buck-
wheat (Fig. 5a). Most segmental duplication genes also
came from the EXPA subfamily (FtPinG0000209500.01,
FtPinG0002998000.01, FtPinG0000802100.01, FtPinG0
006622100.01 and FtPinG0004679600.01), which could
be another important reason why the EXPA subfamily
expanded within species. The results also showed that
different pairs of segmental duplication EXP gene pairs
were found in the genomes of Arabidopsis (22 pairs), V. vinifera (6 pairs), and O. sativa (6 pairs) (Fig. 5b-d). To
explore the different selective constraints of the dupli-
cated FtEXP pairs, we calculated the Ks values and Ka/ We also investigated the exon-intron organizations of
all identified FtEXPs for a deeper understanding of the
evolution of this family in Tartary buckwheat (Fig. 4a). Among 37 FtEXPs, the number of introns ranged from 0
to 3, and most members of the EXPA subfamily con-
tained 2 introns. Notably, the structure of several mem-
bers of the EXPA subfamily is special; for example, only
FtEXPA6 (FtPinG0002998000.01) contains a PLN do-
main, and FtEXPA26 (FtPinG0007038600.01) contains Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 5 of 17 Fig. 2 Phylogenetic tree that represents the relationships among 37 expansin genes of Tartary buckwheat and 34 expansin genes of A. thaliana. The phylogenetic tree of the expansin protein sequences of Tartary buckwheat and A. thaliana was constructed with Mega 7.0 by the maximum
likelihood method and was visualized by the online tool Interactive Tree Of Life (iTOL) (http://itol2.embl.de/). The genes in Tartary buckwheat are
marked in red diamond, while those in A. thaliana are marked in green circle Fig. 2 Phylogenetic tree that represents the relationships among 37 expansin genes of Tartary buckwheat and 34 expansin genes of A. thaliana. The phylogenetic tree of the expansin protein sequences of Tartary buckwheat and A. thaliana was constructed with Mega 7.0 by the maximum
likelihood method and was visualized by the online tool Interactive Tree Of Life (iTOL) (http://itol2.embl.de/). Gene duplication and evolutionary analysis of Expansin
gene families in representative species The genes in Tartary buckwheat are
marked in red diamond, while those in A. thaliana are marked in green circle Fig. 2 Phylogenetic tree that represents the relationships among 37 expansin genes of Tartary buckwheat and 34 expansin genes of A. thaliana. The phylogenetic tree of the expansin protein sequences of Tartary buckwheat and A. thaliana was constructed with Mega 7.0 by the maximum
likelihood method and was visualized by the online tool Interactive Tree Of Life (iTOL) (http://itol2.embl.de/). The genes in Tartary buckwheat are
marked in red diamond, while those in A. thaliana are marked in green circle Ks ratios of each homologous gene pair between Tartary
buckwheat and other terrestrial plants (Table S6). The
Ka/Ks values of the majority of expansin homologous
gene pairs were less than 1, especially for the EXPA sub-
family, which indicated that expansin genes are highly
conserved in evolution and can be important for plant
growth and development (Fig. 5e, Table S6). species are often another channel for the rapid evolu-
tion of gene families and are prone to copy genes
with similar functions [44]. Therefore, we further in-
vestigated syntenic genes that are homologous to Tar-
tary
buckwheat
expansins
in
representative
plants. Syntenic expansin gene pairs are widely found among
Tartary buckwheat and Arabidopsis (32 homologous
gene pairs), C. arabica (32 homologous gene pairs),
V. vinifera (15 homologous gene pairs), O. sativa (5 Previous reports have shown that synteny occurs
not
only
within
species;
synteny
genes
between Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 6 of 17 Fig. 3 Schematic representations of the chromosomal distributions of the Tartary buckwheat expansin genes. Gff files and sequencing files were
used to obtain chromosome localization information of FtEXPs and visualized by TBtools v1.082. The chromosome number is indicated to the left
of each chromosome. The red lines behind the genes indicate that they are pairs of tandem duplication genes Fig. 3 Schematic representations of the chromosomal distributions of the Tartary buckwheat expansin genes. Gff files and sequencing files were
used to obtain chromosome localization information of FtEXPs and visualized by TBtools v1.082. The chromosome number is indicated to the left
of each chromosome. The red lines behind the genes indicate that they are pairs of tandem duplication genes homologous gene pairs), and Z. mays (only 1 homolo-
gous gene pair) (Fig. 6, Table S7). Gene duplication and evolutionary analysis of Expansin
gene families in representative species FtPinG0001244900.01
were
specific
genes
that
were
expressed only in flowers (Fig. 7a). Among the 36 genes, 12
genes had the highest expression levels in roots, and 5 genes
had the highest expression levels in stems. Interestingly, we
found six FtEXPs with special expression in fruit, including
five genes (FtPinG0002998000.01, FtPinG0007038600.01,
FtPinG0005157100.01,
FtPinG0006353400.01
and
FtPinG0006225500.01) with significantly higher expression
than in other tissues, and one gene (FtPinG0000802100.01)
that was expressed only in fruit. The six special genes were
all
from
the
EXLA
subfamily,
although
the
FtPinG0000802100.01 expression was relatively low. Mem-
bers of the EXPA subfamily are generally involved in the
regulation of plant fruit development, which has been fully
confirmed in previous studies [50]. FtPinG0001244900.01
were
specific
genes
that
were
expressed only in flowers (Fig. 7a). Among the 36 genes, 12
genes had the highest expression levels in roots, and 5 genes
had the highest expression levels in stems. Interestingly, we
found six FtEXPs with special expression in fruit, including
five genes (FtPinG0002998000.01, FtPinG0007038600.01,
FtPinG0005157100.01,
FtPinG0006353400.01
and
FtPinG0006225500.01) with significantly higher expression
than in other tissues, and one gene (FtPinG0000802100.01)
that was expressed only in fruit. The six special genes were
all
from
the
EXLA
subfamily,
although
the
FtPinG0000802100.01 expression was relatively low. Mem-
bers of the EXPA subfamily are generally involved in the
regulation of plant fruit development, which has been fully
confirmed in previous studies [50]. different tissues of Tartary buckwheat Orange represents the EXPA subfamily gene, green
represents the EXPB subfamily gene, blue represents the EXLA subfamily gene, and purple represents the EXLB subfamily gene. Prediction of the
exon-intron structures of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes was performed using the online Gene Structure Display Service 2.0 (http://gsds.gao-
lab.org/) and was visualized by TBtools v1.082. Gray boxes indicate untranslated 5′- and 3′-regions, and black lines indicate introns. The number
indicates the phases of the corresponding introns. b The motif compositions of the Tartary buckwheat expansin proteins. The conserved motifs
of expansin proteins were determined by the MEME online program (http://meme-suite.org/tools/meme) and were visualized by TBtools v1.082. The motifs, numbered 1-10, are displayed in different colored boxes. The sequence information for each motif is provided in Table S5. Protein
lengths can be estimated using the scale at the bottom Fig. 4 Phylogenetic relationships, gene structures, and architectures of the conserved protein motifs of the expansin genes from Tartary
buckwheat. a The phylogenetic tree was constructed based on the full-length sequences of Tartary buckwheat expansin proteins using MEGA 7.0
and was visualized by the online tool Interactive Tree Of Life (iTOL) (http://itol2.embl.de/). Orange represents the EXPA subfamily gene, green
represents the EXPB subfamily gene, blue represents the EXLA subfamily gene, and purple represents the EXLB subfamily gene. Prediction of the
exon-intron structures of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes was performed using the online Gene Structure Display Service 2.0 (http://gsds.gao-
lab.org/) and was visualized by TBtools v1.082. Gray boxes indicate untranslated 5′- and 3′-regions, and black lines indicate introns. The number
indicates the phases of the corresponding introns. b The motif compositions of the Tartary buckwheat expansin proteins. The conserved motifs
of expansin proteins were determined by the MEME online program (http://meme-suite.org/tools/meme) and were visualized by TBtools v1.082. The motifs, numbered 1-10, are displayed in different colored boxes. The sequence information for each motif is provided in Table S5. Protein
lengths can be estimated using the scale at the bottom most important fruit development stages (13 DAP, 19
DAP and 25 DAP) by qRT-PCR. The results showed that
the expression of 4 genes increased gradually at 13 DAP,
19 DAP and 25 DAP, including three genes from the
EXPA
subfamily
(FtPinG0002998000.01,
FtPinG0007
038600.01 and FtPinG0005157100.01) and one gene
from EXPB (FtPinG0008584700.01), which was not
expressed at 25 DAP. different tissues of Tartary buckwheat In addition, among the genes that
were expressed in all three periods, six genes experi-
enced both upregulation and downregulation. Three
EXPA subfamily genes that were specifically expressed
in fruit (FtPinG0006353400.01, FtPinG0006255000.01
and FtPinG0000802100.01) were also within the range
(Fig. 8a). correlation analysis of the 36 genes expressed in differ-
ent tissues that there were positive correlations among
the expression profiles of most genes, especially the six
fruit-specific genes mentioned earlier, all of which were
significantly positively correlated (Fig. 7b). different tissues of Tartary buckwheat Many reports have shown that expansin proteins are closely
related to plant growth and development, especially the
fruit development of angiosperms; examples include A. thaliana [45], wheat [46], rice [47], tomatoes [48], and to-
bacco [49]. Therefore, we detected the expression of 37
FtEXPs in different tissues of Tartary buckwheat by quanti-
tative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR). The histograms show that all FtEXPs were expressed ex-
cept FtPinG0001244700.01. Twenty genes exhibited expres-
sion in each tissue. There were some tissue-specific genes, of
which FtPinG0000772400.01 was a specific gene that was
expressed only in roots, and FtPinG0008584900.01 and Moreover, we also provided the correlations among
the expression levels of each gene. We can see from the Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 7 of 17 Fig. 4 Phylogenetic relationships, gene structures, and architectures of the conserved protein motifs of the expansin genes from Tartary
buckwheat. a The phylogenetic tree was constructed based on the full-length sequences of Tartary buckwheat expansin proteins using MEGA 7.0
and was visualized by the online tool Interactive Tree Of Life (iTOL) (http://itol2.embl.de/). Orange represents the EXPA subfamily gene, green
represents the EXPB subfamily gene, blue represents the EXLA subfamily gene, and purple represents the EXLB subfamily gene. Prediction of the
exon-intron structures of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes was performed using the online Gene Structure Display Service 2.0 (http://gsds.gao-
lab.org/) and was visualized by TBtools v1.082. Gray boxes indicate untranslated 5′- and 3′-regions, and black lines indicate introns. The number
indicates the phases of the corresponding introns. b The motif compositions of the Tartary buckwheat expansin proteins. The conserved motifs
of expansin proteins were determined by the MEME online program (http://meme-suite.org/tools/meme) and were visualized by TBtools v1.082. The motifs, numbered 1-10, are displayed in different colored boxes. The sequence information for each motif is provided in Table S5. Protein
lengths can be estimated using the scale at the bottom Fi
4 Ph l
i
l i
hi
d
hi
f h
d
i
if
f h
i
f
T Fig. 4 Phylogenetic relationships, gene structures, and architectures of the conserved protein motifs of the expansin genes from Tartary
buckwheat. a The phylogenetic tree was constructed based on the full-length sequences of Tartary buckwheat expansin proteins using MEGA 7.0
and was visualized by the online tool Interactive Tree Of Life (iTOL) (http://itol2.embl.de/). Fig. 5 Schematic representations of the interchromosomal relationships of the expansin genes from different plants. a Analysis of the
interchromosomal relationships of the expansin genes from Tartary buckwheat was conducted by using multiple collinear scanning toolkits
(MCScanX) and was visualized by TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background indicate collinear blocks within the Tartary buckwheat genome,
while red lines highlight syntenic expansin gene pairs. b Analysis of the interchromosomal relationships of the expansin genes from A. thaliana
was conducted by using multiple collinear scanning toolkits (MCScanX), and was visualized by TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background
indicate collinear blocks within the A. thaliana genome, while red lines highlight syntenic expansin gene pairs. c Analysis of the interchromosomal
relationships of the expansin genes from Vitis vinifera was conducted by using multiple collinear scanning toolkits (MCScanX), and was visualized
by TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background indicate collinear blocks within the Vitis vinifera genome, while red lines highlight syntenic
expansin gene pairs. d Analysis of the interchromosomal relationships of the expansin genes from Oryza sativa was conducted by using multiple
collinear scanning toolkits (MCScanX), and was visualized by TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background indicate collinear blocks within the
Oryza sativa genome, while red lines highlight syntenic expansin gene pairs. e KaKs_Calculator 2.0 was used to calculate the synonymous (Ks) and
nonsynonymous (Ka) substitutions of each homologous expansin gene pair and their ratios (Ka/Ks). The results were visualized using
TBtools v1.082 correlations
with
nearly
all
genes,
such
as
FtPinG0002998000.01, FtPinG0008510400.01, FtPinG00
07038600.01,
FtPinG0006255000.01
and
FtPinG0
005157100.01 (Fig. 8b). High gene expression levels in a
certain tissue or development phase indicate that the
gene may perform certain actions during the growth and
development of this tissue, while some negatively related
genes may have developed differences in function. In
general, there were close correlations among those genes
of the EXPA family that were highly expressed in fruit
(Fig. 8b). At all stages of fruit development, the variation
trends of EXPA subfamily expression were not exactly the same, and negative correlations of some genes were
obvious (Fig. 8). Expression patterns of EXPA subfamily members were
different in the three important periods of fruit
development In the preliminary study, we divided Tartary buckwheat
into five stages from anthesis to maturation according to
embryonic development morphology, among which the
green fruit stage (13 DAP), discoloration stage (19 DAP)
and initial maturity stage (25 DAP) were the three most
important developmental stages [51]. To screen the po-
tential FtEXPs regulating fruit development, we deter-
mined the expression of 31 FtEXPs during the three From the correlation study of 31 FtEXP expression
levels in fruits at different developmental stages, it can
be seen that some genes showed significant negative Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 8 of 17 Fig. 5 Schematic representations of the interchromosomal relationships of the expansin genes from different plants. a Analysis of the
interchromosomal relationships of the expansin genes from Tartary buckwheat was conducted by using multiple collinear scanning toolkits
(MCScanX) and was visualized by TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background indicate collinear blocks within the Tartary buckwheat genome,
while red lines highlight syntenic expansin gene pairs. b Analysis of the interchromosomal relationships of the expansin genes from A. thaliana
was conducted by using multiple collinear scanning toolkits (MCScanX), and was visualized by TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background
indicate collinear blocks within the A thaliana genome while red lines highlight syntenic expansin gene pairs c Analysis of the interchromosomal Five genes from the EXPA subfamily were identified to
regulate fruit development by responding to Indole-3-
acetic acid (IAA) signals Studies have shown that overexpression of AtEXPA10 in
tobacco affects the size of reproductive organs, while
overexpression of NtEXPA5 in tobacco increases the size
of tobacco leaf and stem cells [49]. To further screen
expansin proteins that potentially regulate fruit size, six
genes with the highest homology to the previously Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 9 of 17 Fig. 6 Synteny analyses between the expansin genes of Tartary buckwheat and five angiosperms. The syntenic relationships among the expansin
genes of Tartary buckwheat and five angiosperms were visualized by using Dual Synteny Plotter software. The results were visualized using
TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background indicate collinear blocks within the Tartary buckwheat genome and other plant genomes, while red
lines highlight syntenic expansin gene pairs Fig. 6 Synteny analyses between the expansin genes of Tartary buckwheat and five angiosperms. The syntenic relationships among the expansin
genes of Tartary buckwheat and five angiosperms were visualized by using Dual Synteny Plotter software. The results were visualized using
TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background indicate collinear blocks within the Tartary buckwheat genome and other plant genomes, while red
lines highlight syntenic expansin gene pairs Fig. 6 Synteny analyses between the expansin genes of Tartary buckwheat and five angiosperms. The syntenic relationships among the expansin
genes of Tartary buckwheat and five angiosperms were visualized by using Dual Synteny Plotter software. The results were visualized using
TBtools v1.082. Gray lines in the background indicate collinear blocks within the Tartary buckwheat genome and other plant genomes, while red
lines highlight syntenic expansin gene pairs reported AtEXP10 (AT1G26770.2) were selected in the
phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1). The expression of these six
FtEXPA genes in BTB fruit and STB fruit was deter-
mined (Fig. 9a). The results showed that there were sig-
nificant differences in the expression of the other five
genes except FtPinG0006622100.01 in STB and BTB
fruits. Among them, the expression of three genes
(FtPinG0009591900.01,
FtPinG0000209500.01
and
FtPinG0004679600.01) in STB fruits was higher than
that in BTB fruits, and the expression of the other two
genes (FtPinG0006353400.01 and FtPinG0005157100.01)
in BTB fruits was higher than that in STB fruits. Auxin
plays an indispensable role in the expansion of plant or-
gans [52]. The Tartary buckwheat fruit size reached a
maximum at 19 DAP, and the auxin content in Tartary buckwheat fruits increased gradually from 13 DAP to 19
DAP
[51]. Five genes from the EXPA subfamily were identified to
regulate fruit development by responding to Indole-3-
acetic acid (IAA) signals FtPinG0006353400.01
and
FtPinG000
5157100.01 were both highly expressed in BTB fruits,
and their expression levels in the fruit development stage
were consistent with the changes in the auxin content in
fruits. Through the above results, we found genes that
were differentially expressed in the STB and BTB fruits,
which further narrowed the candidate range of fruit
size-regulating genes. The studies above showed that several EXPA subfam-
ily genes (FtPinG0009591900.01, FtPinG0000209500.01,
FtPinG0006353400.01,
FtPinG0004679600.01
and
FtPinG0005157100.01) were highly expressed in both
the STB and BTB fruits, and there were significant dif-
ferences in the expression of these genes between the Page 10 of 17 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Fig. 7 Tissue-specific gene expression of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes and the correlation between the gene expression patterns of FtEXPs. a The expression patterns of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes in flower (FL), leaf (L), root (R), stem (S) and fruit (FR) were examined by qRT-PCR. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates were performed for each biological replicate. Error bars were obtained
from nine measurements. Lowercase letter(s) above the bars indicate significant differences (α = 0.05, LSD) among different tissues. The results
were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04. b The correlation of expression patterns of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes in different tissues was
visualized by TBTools v1.082. Positive number: positively correlated; negative number: negatively correlated. The red numbers indicate a
significant correlation at the 0.05 level Fig. 7 Tissue-specific gene expression of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes and the correlation between the gene expression patterns of FtEXPs. a The expression patterns of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes in flower (FL), leaf (L), root (R), stem (S) and fruit (FR) were examined by qRT-PCR. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates were performed for each biological replicate. Error bars were obtained
from nine measurements. Lowercase letter(s) above the bars indicate significant differences (α = 0.05, LSD) among different tissues. The results
were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04. b The correlation of expression patterns of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes in different tissues was
visualized by TBTools v1.082. Positive number: positively correlated; negative number: negatively correlated. The red numbers indicate a
significant correlation at the 0.05 level Page 11 of 17 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Fig. Five genes from the EXPA subfamily were identified to
regulate fruit development by responding to Indole-3-
acetic acid (IAA) signals 8 Gene expression of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes during fruit development and the correlation between the gene expression patterns
of FtEXPs during fruit development. a The expression patterns of Tartary buckwheat FtEXPs in the fruit developmental stages were examined
using a qRT-PCR assay. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates were performed for each biological replicate. Error bars were obtained from nine measurements. Lowercase letter(s) above the bars indicate significant differences (α = 0.05, LSD) among fruits
at different developmental stages. The results were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04. b The correlation of expression patterns of Tartary
buckwheat expansin genes in different fruit developmental stages was visualized by TBTools v1.082. Positive number: positively correlated;
negative number: negatively correlated. Red numbers indicate a significant correlation at the 0.05 level Fig. 8 Gene expression of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes during fruit development and the correlation between the gene expression patterns
of FtEXPs during fruit development. a The expression patterns of Tartary buckwheat FtEXPs in the fruit developmental stages were examined
using a qRT-PCR assay. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates were performed for each biological replicate. Error bars were obtained from nine measurements. Lowercase letter(s) above the bars indicate significant differences (α = 0.05, LSD) among fruits
at different developmental stages. The results were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04. b The correlation of expression patterns of Tartary
buckwheat expansin genes in different fruit developmental stages was visualized by TBTools v1.082. Positive number: positively correlated;
negative number: negatively correlated Red numbers indicate a significant correlation at the 0 05 level Fig. 8 Gene expression of Tartary buckwheat expansin genes during fruit development and the correlation between the gene expression patterns
of FtEXPs during fruit development. a The expression patterns of Tartary buckwheat FtEXPs in the fruit developmental stages were examined
using a qRT-PCR assay. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates were performed for each biological replicate. Error bars were obtained from nine measurements. Lowercase letter(s) above the bars indicate significant differences (α = 0.05, LSD) among fruits
at different developmental stages. The results were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04. b The correlation of expression patterns of Tartary
buckwheat expansin genes in different fruit developmental stages was visualized by TBTools v1.082. Positive number: positively correlated;
negative number: negatively correlated. Red numbers indicate a significant correlation at the 0.05 level Sun et al. Discussion Expansin proteins can regulate many plant growth and
development processes by participating in the synthetic
modification of cell walls. As a result, the expansin gene
family is valuable for plant growth and development [5]. In addition, expansin proteins are not found in animal
and fungal species, while they are widespread in plants
ranging from algae to higher plants, which also makes
them of fascinating significance for studying the terres-
trial evolution of plants. Based on our phylogenetic re-
search, expansin proteins have at least one DPBB
conserved domain in both algae and higher plants (Fig. S1). The EXPA subfamily has the largest number of
members and was already present in algae. The EXPB
subfamily originated later and had a smaller number of
members. The surprising number of EXPA subfamily
members in the basal terrestrial moss (M. polymorpha)
may suggest that the family’s genes expanded as plants
transitioned to land (Fig. 1). Abundant gene duplication
events drove the expansion of expansin families in an-
giosperms, and the Ka/Ks values of most homologous
EXP gene pairs in both monocotyledonous and dicotyle-
donous plants were all obviously less than 1, which indi-
cates that the expansin family received purification
options after plant terrestrialization (Fig. 5). Another important finding is that duplication and loss
of expansin proteins are common in representative an-
giosperms, and the conservative traits that were acquired
from ancestors are favored by natural selection. This
study found that two subfamilies (EXPA and EXPB) are
conserved in representative angiosperms, which implies
that they may already have existed in the common an-
cestor of angiosperms and were preserved after species
differentiation. Studies have shown that certain plants
that adapted to the land environment have lost some
expansin proteins during evolution [57], which can pro-
vide a possible explanation for the larger number of
EXLA subfamilies in algae, while few other species exist
(Fig. 1). It has been reported that the expansion and
contraction of gene families is a manifestation of the
rapid adaptation of organisms to the environment [58]. However, new genes that formed with family expansion
often faced harsh natural selection [59]. The Ka/Ks
values of FtEXPs were also all obviously less than 1
(Table S6), which indicated that the FtEXPs were puri-
fied during evolution. Specifically, although new genes
were generated through evolutionary processes, the
primitive functional genes that originated from ancestors
were more conducive to adaptation to the environment
[60]. Five genes from the EXPA subfamily were identified to
regulate fruit development by responding to Indole-3-
acetic acid (IAA) signals BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 12 of 17 Fig. 9 Gene expression of six FtEXPA genes in the BTB and STB at 13 DAP and 19 DAP and the expression patterns of five FtEXPA genes from 13
DAP and 19 DAP of the STB with IAA treatment. a The expression patterns of six FtEXPA genes in BTB and STB at 13 DAP and 19 DAP were
examined using a qRT-PCR assay. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates were performed for each biological
replicate. Error bars were obtained from nine measurements. Asterisk above the bars indicate significant differences (*P < 0.05; **P < 0.01) between
the BTB and STB fruits. The results were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04. b The expression patterns of five FtEXPA genes in STB at 13 DAP
and 19 DAP with IAA treatment were examined using a qRT-PCR assay. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates
were performed for each biological repeat. Error bars were obtained from nine measurements. Asterisk above the bars indicate significant
differences (*P < 0.05; **P < 0.01) between mock and IAA. The results were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04 Fig. 9 Gene expression of six FtEXPA genes in the BTB and STB at 13 DAP and 19 DAP and the expression patterns of five FtEXPA genes from 13
DAP and 19 DAP of the STB with IAA treatment. a The expression patterns of six FtEXPA genes in BTB and STB at 13 DAP and 19 DAP were
examined using a qRT-PCR assay. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates were performed for each biological
replicate. Error bars were obtained from nine measurements. Asterisk above the bars indicate significant differences (*P < 0.05; **P < 0.01) between
the BTB and STB fruits. The results were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04. b The expression patterns of five FtEXPA genes in STB at 13 DAP
and 19 DAP with IAA treatment were examined using a qRT-PCR assay. Three biological replicates were performed, and three technical replicates
were performed for each biological repeat. Error bars were obtained from nine measurements. Asterisk above the bars indicate significant
differences (*P < 0.05; **P < 0.01) between mock and IAA. The results were visualized using GraphPad Prism 7.04 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 13 of 17 Sun et al. Five genes from the EXPA subfamily were identified to
regulate fruit development by responding to Indole-3-
acetic acid (IAA) signals BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 FtPinG0001244900.01-FtPinG0001244700.01 and FtPin
G0009206900.01-FtPinG0009207100.01 are two pairs of
tandem duplicated genes located on chromosomes 3 and
8 (Fig. 3), all of which are from the EXPA subfamily. Among them, the expression of FtPinG0009206900.01
and FtPinG0009207100.01 was obviously different (Fig. 8a), which indicates that they may have evolved into two
genes with different functions. Furthermore, it was
found that the motif compositions of these two genes
were consistent, and it was suggested that the difference
in function may originate from the difference in cis-
acting elements in the promoter region (Fig. 4, Fig. S3). In contrast, FtPinG0001244900.01 is only expressed in
flowers, and FtPinG0001244700.01 had no expression
(Fig. 8a), which indicated that FtPinG0001244700.01
may have become a pseudogene after duplication events. Whether pseudogenes are functional is an unresolved
issue, and some argue that pseudogenes provide binding
sites for transcription factors [56]. At least it is certain
that these two pairs of tandem duplication genes from
the same subfamily evolved in different directions after
duplication occurred. two types of fruits. A previous study showed that the
fruit weights of STB increased with exogenous auxin
treatment [51]. Therefore, we measured the expression
of these five genes in STB fruits under IAA treatment to
further screen potential genes for regulating fruit size. The results showed that the expression of three genes
(FtPinG0009591900.01,
FtPinG0006353400.01
and
FtPinG0005157100.01) increased and that the expression
of
two
genes
(FtPinG0004679600.01
and
FtPinG00
00209500.01) decreased with IAA treatment (Fig. 9b). Plant genome sequence acquisition and identification of
the Expansin gene family Plant genome sequence acquisition and identification of
the Expansin gene family Plant genome sequence acquisition and identification of
the Expansin gene family Plant genome sequence acquisition and identification of
the Expansin gene family The Arabidopsis genome sequence was acquired from
the TAIR database (https://www.arabidopsis.org/). The
Tartary buckwheat genome was obtained from the Tar-
tary buckwheat Genome Project (http://www.mbkbase. org/Pinku1) [40]. Other plant genome sequences (M. polymorpha, V. carteri, C. reinhardtii, P. patens, S. palustre, O. sativa, Z. mays, V. vinifera, C. arabica and
A. trichopoda) were downloaded from the Phytozome
database (http://www.phytozome.net/). The hidden Mar-
kov model (HMM) profiles of two domains (PF03330
and PF01357) were obtained from the Pfam protein fam-
ily database (http://pfam.sanger.ac.uk/). HMMER3.0 was
used to identify EXPs from the genomes. SMART [63],
Pfam [64] and InterPro [65] were used to verify whether
the identified genes had conserved domains and to re-
move the genes without conserved domains. Then, the
expansin
proteins
identified
above
were
BLASTp
searched in NCBI to analyze whether they were part of
the expansin family. We identified all expansin proteins
from the genomes of 12 plants by using the above
methods. Information on the isoelectric point (PI) and
molecular weight (Mw) was acquired from the ExPASy
website (https://web.expasy.org/protparam/). The sub-
cellular localizations of the FtEXP proteins were pre-
dicted with CELLO (http://cello.life.nctu.edu.tw/). g
g
Unfortunately, studies have shown that expansin pro-
teins inevitably have negative effects on immune func-
tion while increasing fruit yield. Cell wall loosening is
the direct cause of fruit organ enlargement [5], but ex-
pansion of the cell wall also leads to an increase in the
gaps between cells, which may make plants vulnerable to
external pathogens. Overexpression of indole-3-acetic
acid–amido synthetase GH3-8 in rice induces IAA accu-
mulation and then inhibits expansin protein expression
[62]. Previous experimental evidence has confirmed that
the disease resistance of rice was significantly enhanced,
but its development was delayed [62]. This appears to
indicate that we must make a choice between fruit en-
largement and pathogen defense or other means to com-
pensate for the lack of immune capacity that is caused
by high expansin protein expression. Of the two FtEXPA
subfamily genes (FtPinG0004679600.01 and FtPinG00
00209500.01) that were significantly downregulated after
exogenous IAA treatment in our study (Fig. Plant genome sequence acquisition and identification of
the Expansin gene family 9b), we sug-
gest that the response of these two genes under IAA
treatment may be similar to those mentioned in reports
on rice [62]. For future studies, we should integrate
other developmental, evolutionary, and ecological as-
pects to improve plant disease resistance to compensate
for deficiencies in immune function after expansin pro-
tein expression. Phylogenetic analyses, chromosomal location, intron-
exon structure, motif composition and Cis-acting element
analysis Phylogenetic analyses, chromosomal location, intron-
exon structure, motif composition and Cis-acting element
analysis Discussion Furthermore, EXPA subfamily genes may also have
experienced motif loss and functional alternatives during
evolution. Within the subfamily, motifs 5 and 10 do not
usually coexist. One possible explanation is that the
functions of motif 5 and motif 10 are redundant, and
only one of them was preserved after a long period of
evolution. Studies have also shown that the extra lost
motif 1 (DPBB domain) is predicted to contain a signal g
Evolutionary analysis of expansin families provides
valuable insight into the regulation of important agro-
nomic traits in Tartary buckwheat genetics and breed-
ing. Our first key finding is that the Tartary buckwheat
EXPA subfamily expanded after gene duplication, and
the evolution direction of the members varied. Com-
pared with the other three subfamilies, the EXPA sub-
family has the most members, as has been reported for
other plants [46]. It has been reported that segmental
duplication events contribute to gene expansion [53]. This conclusion is further supported by the finding that
most
members
of
the
Tartary
buckwheat
EXPA
subfamily undergo tandem and segmental duplication
(Fig. 3, Fig. 5a). Studies have shown that gene duplica-
tion events can trigger family expansion [54], and the
genes that undergo duplication have three evolutionary
outcomes: maintaining the original conserved function,
generating new functions or forming pseudogenes [55]. Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 14 of 17 Page 14 of 17 Page 14 of 17 Methods peptide sequence (Fig. 4, Table S5) and can bind to cel-
lulose [61], which may be a key factor for EXLA and
EXLB not having cell wall-loosening functions. Conclusions Collectively,
our
research
not
only
identified
all
expansin family members in the 12 representative
plants during terrestrial processes, but also from the
perspective of evolution, a blueprint was drawn for
the selection and cultivation of the important agro-
nomic traits of Tartary buckwheat fruit develop-
ment. The expansin family originated from early
algae that expanded rapidly after plant terrestrializa-
tion. EXPA subfamily members that are dependent
on gene duplication expansion provide insights into
Tartary buckwheat genetics and breeding. Notably,
we identified five key candidate genes from the
EXPA subfamily that could potentially regulate fruit
size. Identification of target genes through evolu-
tionary analyses at the whole-genome level can pro-
vide new insights for crop breeding. Our results will
also contribute to improving the important agro-
nomic properties of Tartary buckwheat. In addition,
the research highlighted a new challenge regarding
balancing the tradeoff between high yield and dis-
ease resistance of fruit, which provides an idea for
future breeding. TBtools v1.082 was used to extract CDSs from all plant
genomes and translate them into protein sequences [66]. The expansin protein sequences from different plants
were aligned by using the Clustalx1.81 program [67]. The Clustalx1.81 parameters were defined as follows: in
pairwise alignment, the gap opening penalty was 10, and
the gap extension penalty was 0.1; in multiple align-
ments, the gap opening penalty was also 10, but the gap
extension penalty was 0.2. The phylogenetic tree of the
expansin protein sequences in different plants was con-
structed with Mega 7.0 by the maximum likelihood
method and 1000 bootstrap replications. The phylogen-
etic tree of Tartary buckwheat and A. thaliana was
established to define the grouping of FtEXPs and was
constructed by the above method. After that, the Clus-
talx1.81 program was used to align the expansin protein
sequences of Tartary buckwheat and A. thaliana. Predic-
tions of intron structures with expansin DNA sequences
were performed by using the online Gene Structure Dis-
play Service 2.0 (http://gsds.gao-lab.org/). The conserved
motifs of expansin proteins were determined by the
MEME online program (http://meme-suite.org/tools/ Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Page 15 of 17 Page 15 of 17 Page 15 of 17 blast/). The Tartary buckwheat histone H3 gene was
used as an internal reference gene, and SYBR Premix Ex
Taq II (TaKaRa) was used in qRT-PCR [71]. The cor-
relative expression data were calculated using the 2-△△CT
method [72]. Plant growth The
big
fruit
Tartary
buckwheat
accessions
(BTB,
XIQIAO) and small fruit Tartary buckwheat accessions
(STB, MIQIAO) were cultivated at the experimental
farm of the College of Life Sciences, Sichuan Agricul-
tural University, China. We collected samples from three
replicate plants. After 90 days of Tartary buckwheat ger-
mination, we collected flowers, stems, roots and leaves. We picked the fruits at 13, 19 and 25 days after pollin-
ation (DAP). All picked materials were rapidly placed in
liquid nitrogen and were then kept at −80 °C. Auxin treatment of STB In previous studies of the regulation of fruit size by
FtARF2, STB was sprayed at the budding stage with 40,
70, 100, 130, or 160 mg L−1 IAA. It was found that 100
mg L−1 IAA was the best concentration for increasing
fruit weight [68]. Therefore, STB plants were treated
with 100 mg L−1 IAA in this study. After treatment,
fruits at 13 DAP and 19 DAP were collected and placed
at −80 °C. Additional file 2: Figure S2. Protein motif model of the expansin
protein family in representative species. (A) Motif model of the algal
expansin protein family. The conserved motifs of the algal expansin
proteins were determined by the MEME online program (http://meme-
suite.org/tools/meme) and were visualized by TBtools v1.082. (B) Motif
model of the bryophyta expansin protein family. The conserved motifs of
the bryophyta expansin proteins were determined by the MEME online
program (http://meme-suite.org/tools/meme), and were visualized by
TBtools v1.082. (C) Motif model of the monocotyledon expansin protein
family. The conserved motifs of the monocotyledon expansin proteins
were determined by the MEME online program (http://meme-suite.org/
tools/meme), and were visualized by TBtools v1.082. (D) Motif model of
the dicotyledonous expansin protein family. The conserved motifs of
dicotyledonous expansin proteins were determined by the MEME online
program (http://meme-suite.org/tools/meme), and were visualized by
TBtools v1.082. Abbreviations A. thaliana: Arabidopsis thaliana; BTB: Big fruit Tartary buckwheat; DAP: Days
after pollination; EXP: Expansin; EXPA: α-expansin; EXPB: β-expansin;
EXLA: Expansin-like A; EXLB: Expansin-like B; FtEXP: Fagopyrum tataricum
expansin; FtEXPA: FtEXP in EXPA family; Gff: Generic feature format;
GH45: Glycoside hydro-lase family-45; HMM: Hidden Markov Model;
IAA: Indole-3-acetic acid; Mw: Molecular weight; PI: Isoelectric points; qRT-
PCR: Quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction; STB: Small fruit Tartary
buckwheat; TBGP: Tartary buckwheat genome project Data availability statement Data availability statement
The datasets supporting the conclusions of this article
are included in the article and its additional files. Supplementary Information
h
l
l The online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi. org/10.1186/s12864-021-07562-w. The online version contains supplem
org/10.1186/s12864-021-07562-w. Additional file 1: Figure S1. Phylogenetic relationships and motif
compositions of the expansin proteins from five different plant species. Outer layer: Phylogenetic trees were constructed using MEGA 7.0 with
the maximum likelihood method. These phylogenetic trees were
visualized by using the online tool Interactive Tree Of Life (iTOL) (http://
itol2.embl.de/). Inner layer: Distribution of the conserved motifs in
expansin proteins. The conserved motifs of the expansin proteins were
determined by the MEME online program (http://meme-suite.org/tools/
meme) and were visualized by TBtools v1.082. The differently colored
boxes represent different motifs and their positions in each expansin
protein sequence. Conclusions meme), and the parameters were defined based on those
used by Liu et al. [68]. The cis-acting elements that were
2000 bp upstream of all FtEXPs were predicted through
the PlantCare online software (http://bioinformatics.psb. ugent.be/webtools/plantcare/html/). Chromosome distribution, duplication events, Syntenic
analysis and Ka/Ks ratio calculations of EXPs to
homologous gene pairs in all angiosperms Statistical analysis The obtained experimental data were processed and an-
alyzed by GraphPad Prism 7.04, and the least significant
difference test was used to compare the data. Gff files and sequencing files were used to obtain the
chromosome localization information of FtEXPs. Ana-
lysis of FtEXP duplication events was performed through
multiple collinear scanning toolkits (MCScanX) [69] and
to visualize data through TBtools v1.082. The syntenic
relationships between the expansin genes of Tartary
buckwheat and five angiosperms were visualized by
using Dual Synteny Plotter software and were visualized
using TBtools v1.082. KaKs_Calculator 2.0 was used to
calculate the synonymous (Ks) and nonsynonymous (Ka)
substitutions of each homologous expansin gene pair
and their ratios (Ka/Ks) [70]. Expression analysis of the FtEXPs The FtEXP expression in the stem, root, leaf, flower and
fruit during different developmental stages (green fruit
stage, 13 DAP; discoloration stage, 19 DAP; and initial
maturity stage, 25 DAP) were measured by qRT-PCR. At
the same time, the expression of FtEXPA genes in the
BTB and STB fruits and in the STB fruits treated with
IAA was also measured. The primers used in qRT-PCR
(Table S8) were designed through the online software
primer 3 (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/tools/primer- Additional file 3: Figure S3. Cis- Additional file 3: Figure S3. Cis-acting element analysis of the expan-
sin protein promoters from Tartary buckwheat. The cis-acting elements
that were 2000 bp upstream of all FtEXPs were predicted through the
PlantCare online software (http://bioinformatics.psb.ugent.be/webtools/
plantcare/html/) and were visualized by TBtools v1.082. Blocks of different
colors represent light responsiveness elements, low temperature respon-
siveness elements, salicylic acid responsiveness elements, abscisic acid re-
sponsiveness elements, MeJA responsiveness elements, auxin Page 16 of 17 Page 16 of 17 Page 16 of 17 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Sun et al. BMC Genomics Received: 22 September 2020 Accepted: 26 March 2021 Funding This research was supported by function study of FtbHLH transcription factor
regulating Tartary buckwheat fruit dehiscence (2021YFH0086) of Sichuan
province science and technology support program. Funds were used for the
design of the study and collection, analysis, and interpretation of data and in
writing the manuscript, as well as in the open access payment. 12. He X, Zeng J, Cao F, Ahmed I, Zhang GP, Vincze E, et al. HvEXPB7 , a
novel β-expansin gene revealed by the root hair transcriptome of
Tibetan wild barley, improves root hair growth under drought stress. J
Exp Bot. 2015;66:erv436. 13. Muthusamy M, Kim J-A, Jeong M-J, Lee S. Blue and red light upregulate α-
expansin 1 (EXPA1) in transgenic Brassica rapa and its overexpression
promotes leaf and root growth in Arabidopsis. Plant Growth Regul. 2020;91:
75–87. Declarations 17. Sampedro J, Cosgrove D. The expansin superfamily. Genome Biol. 2005;
6:242. Availability of data and materials The genome sequences of Tartary buckwheat used for identifying the FtEXPs
in this study were located in the Tartary Buckwheat Genome Project (TBGP;
http://www.mbkbase.org/Pinku1/). The Tartary buckwheat accessions (XIQIAO
and MIQIAO) materials used in the experiment were supplied by Professor
Wang Anhu of Xichang University. The datasets supporting the conclusions
of this article are included with in the article and its Additional files. Li Y, Jones L, McQueen-Mason S. Expansins and cell growth, vol. 6; 15. Cosgrove D. Enzymes and other agents that enhance cell wall extensibility. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol. 1999;50:391–417. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol. 1999;50:391–417. 16. Nikolaos G, Yennawar NH, Cosgrove DJ. Structural basis for entropy-driven
cellulose binding by a type-a cellulose-binding module (CBM) and bacterial
expansin. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012;109(37):14830–5. Received: 22 September 2020 Accepted: 26 March 2021 responsiveness elements, gibberellin responsiveness elements and
defense and stress responsiveness elements. Additional file 4: Table S1. Number of expansion family members in
multiple species. Table S2 Gene ID of expansion in multiple species. Table S3 List of the 37 FtEXP genes identified in this study. Table S4
List of the Tartary buckwheat 37 FtEXP genes identified in this study. Table S5 Analysis and distribution of conserved motifs in Tartary
buckwheat expansin proteins. Table S6 Ka, Ks and Ka/Ks value of
synteny expansin gene pairs in angiosperms genome. Table S7 Synteny
expansin gene pairs between Tartary buckwheat and other angiosperms. Table S8 Primer sequences for qRT-PCR. Additional file 4: Table S1. Number of expansion family members in
multiple species. Table S2 Gene ID of expansion in multiple species. Table S3 List of the 37 FtEXP genes identified in this study. Table S4
List of the Tartary buckwheat 37 FtEXP genes identified in this study. Table S5 Analysis and distribution of conserved motifs in Tartary
buckwheat expansin proteins. Table S6 Ka, Ks and Ka/Ks value of
synteny expansin gene pairs in angiosperms genome. Table S7 Synteny
expansin gene pairs between Tartary buckwheat and other angiosperms. Table S8 Primer sequences for qRT-PCR. Acknowledgements 5. Marowa P, Ding A, Kong Y. Expansins: roles in plant growth and potential
applications in crop improvement. Plant Cell Rep. 2016;35:949–65. 5. Marowa P, Ding A, Kong Y. Expansins: roles in plant growth and potential
applications in crop improvement. Plant Cell Rep. 2016;35:949–65. We thank all the colleagues in our laboratory for providing useful discussions
and technical assistance. We are very grateful to the editor and reviewers for
critically evaluating the manuscript and providing constructive comments for
its improvement. 6. AbuQamar S. Expansins: Cell Wall remodeling proteins with a potential
function in plant defense; 2018. 6. AbuQamar S. Expansins: Cell Wall remodeling proteins with a potential
function in plant defense; 2018. 7. Wang DJ, Hu BZ. The role of expansin in plant growth and development. Plant Physiol. 2013;49:19–23. 7. Wang DJ, Hu BZ. The role of expansin in plant growth and development. Plant Physiol. 2013;49:19–23. References 1. Kenrick P, Crane P. The origin and early evolution of plants on land. Nature. 1997;389:33–9. 2. Wang S, Li L, Li H, Sahu SK, Wang H, Xu Y, et al. Genomes of early-diverging
streptophyte algae shed light on plant terrestrialization. Nat Plants. 2020;6:
95–106. 3. Lamport D, Tan L, Held M, Kieliszewski M. The role of the primary Cell Wall
in plant morphogenesis. Int J Mol Sci. 2018;19:2674. 3. Lamport D, Tan L, Held M, Kieliszewski M. The role of the primary Cell Wall
in plant morphogenesis. Int J Mol Sci. 2018;19:2674. 4. Zhang B, Gao Y, Zhang L, Zhou Y. The plant Cell Wall: biosynthesis,
construction, and functions. J Integr Plant Biol. 2020;63:251–72. 4. Zhang B, Gao Y, Zhang L, Zhou Y. The plant Cell Wall: biosynthesis,
construction, and functions. J Integr Plant Biol. 2020;63:251–72. Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. 22. Yi L, Choi D, Kende H. Expansins: ever-expanding numbers and functions. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2001;4(6):527–32. The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Authors’ contributions 8. Wang G, Gao Y, Wang J, Yang L, Song R, Li X, et al. Overexpression of two
cambium-abundant Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata) α-expansin
genes ClEXPA1 and ClEXPA2 affect growth and development in transgenic
tobacco and increase the amount of cellulose in stem cell walls. Plant
Biotechnol J. 2011;9(4):486–502. M.-Y.L. planned and designed the research, and analyzed data. W.-J.S. and H.-
M.Y. wrote the original manuscript. W.-J.S. and M.-Y.L. determined the
expression of genes by qRT-PCR. Z.-T.M. and H.C. identified FtEXPs and visual-
ized their structures. H.-M.Y. and W.-J.S. performed the evolutionary analysis
of FtEXPs and several different species. W.-J.S. and H.C. performed FtEXPs
chromosome distribution, gene duplication and synteny analysis. H.C. reviewed and edited the manuscript. H.C. supervised the research. W.-J.S., H.-
M.Y. and M.-Y.L. contributed equally. All authors read and approved the final
manuscript. M.-Y.L. planned and designed the research, and analyzed data. W.-J.S. and H.-
M.Y. wrote the original manuscript. W.-J.S. and M.-Y.L. determined the
expression of genes by qRT-PCR. Z.-T.M. and H.C. identified FtEXPs and visual-
ized their structures. H.-M.Y. and W.-J.S. performed the evolutionary analysis
of FtEXPs and several different species. W.-J.S. and H.C. performed FtEXPs
chromosome distribution, gene duplication and synteny analysis. H.C. 9. Civello PM, Powell AL, Sabehat A, Bennett AB. An expansin gene expressed
in ripening strawberry fruit. Plant Physiol. 1999;121(4):1273–80. reviewed and edited the manuscript. H.C. supervised the research. W.-J.S., H.-
M.Y. and M.-Y.L. contributed equally. All authors read and approved the final
manuscript. 10. Muthusamy M, Kim JY, Yoon E, Kim J-A, Lee S. BrEXLB1, a Brassica rapa
Expansin-like B1 gene is associated with root development, drought stress
response, and seed germination. Genes. 2020;11:404. 11. Kuluev BR, Lebedev YP, Chemeris AV. Morphological and physiological
characteristics of transgenic tobacco plants expressing expansin genes:
AtEXP10 from Arabidopsis and PnEXPA1 from poplar. Russ J Plant Physiol. 2012;59(1):97–104. Consent for publication Consent for publication
Not applicable. p
Not applicable. Not applicable. 21. Cosgrove D, Bedinger P, Durachko DM. Group I allergens of grass pollen as
Cell Wall-loosening agents. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1997;94:6559–64. Ethics approval and consent to participate 18. Valenzuela-Riffo F, Morales-Quintana L. Study of the structure and binding
site features of FaEXPA2, an α-expansin protein involved in strawberry fruit
softening. Comput Biol Chem. 2020;87:107279. These plant materials (XIQIAO and MIQIAO) are widely used all over the
world and no permits are required for the collection of plant samples. The
plant materials are maintained in accordance with the institutional
guidelines of the College of Life Sciences, Sichuan Agricultural University,
China. This article did not contain any studies with human participants or
animals and did not involve any endangered or protected species. 19. Valenzuela-Riffo F, Palma C, Ramos P, Morales-Quintana L. Molecular and
structural insights into FaEXPA5, an alpha-expansin protein related with cell
wall disassembly during ripening of strawberry fruit. Plant Physiol Biochem. 2020;154:581–9. 20. Kende H, Bradford K, Brummell D, Cho H-T, Cosgrove D, Fleming A, et al. Nomenclature for members of the expansin superfamily of genes and
proteins. Plant Mol Biol. 2004;55:311–4. Author details
1 23. Sarma Bordoloi K, Dihingia P, B Krishnatreya D, Agarwala N. Genome-wide
identification, characterization and expression analysis of the expansin gene
family under drought stress in tea (Camellia sinensis L.). Plant Sci Today. 2021:8:32–44. Author details
1College of Life Science, Sichuan Agricultural University, Ya’an 625014, China. 2Joint Center for Single Cell Biology, School of Agriculture and Biology,
Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China. 3State Key
Laboratory of Crop Gene Exploration and Utilization in Southwest China, Key
Laboratory of Major Crop Diseases and Rice Research Institute, Sichuan
Agricultural University, Chengdu 611130, China. 24. Lu Y, Liu L, Wang X, Han Z, Ouyang B, Zhang J, et al. Genome-wide
identification and expression analysis of the expansin gene family in
tomato. Mol Genet Genom Mgg. 2016;291(2):597. Page 17 of 17 Page 17 of 17 Page 17 of 17 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 Sun et al. BMC Genomics (2021) 22:252 25. Zhang W, Yan H, Chen W, Liu J, Jiang C, Jiang H, et al. Genome-wide
identification and characterization of maize expansin genes expressed in
endosperm, vol. 289; 2014. 50. Heng W, Yang J, Hou Z, Li F, Jia B, Liu P, et al. Characterization and
expression analysis of PbEXP genes in the epidermis of pear (Pyrus
bretschneideri Rehd.). Plant Growth Regul. 2017;84:1–9. 51. Liu M, Ma Z, Zheng T, Sun W, Zhang Y, Jin W, et al. Insights into the
correlation between physiological changes in and seed development of
tartary buckwheat (Fagopyrum tataricum Gaertn.). BMC Genomics. 2018;
19(1):648. 26. Zhu Y, Wu N, Song W, Yin G, Qin Y, Yan Y, et al. Soybean (Glycine max)
expansin gene superfamily origins: segmental and tandem duplication
events followed by divergent selection among subfamilies. BMC Plant Biol. 2014;14(1):93. 52. Perrot-Rechenmann C. Cellular responses to Auxin: division versus
expansion. Cold Spring Harb Perspect Biol. 2010;2(5):a001446. 27. Lv L-M, Zuo D-Y, Wang X-F, Cheng H-L, Zhang Y-P, Wang Q-L, et al. Genome-wide identification of the expansin gene family reveals that
expansin genes are involved in fibre cell growth in cotton. BMC Plant Biol. 2020;20:223–36. 53. Dossa K, Diouf D, Cisse N. Genome-wide investigation of Hsf genes in
sesame reveals their segmental duplication expansion and their active role
in drought stress response. Front Plant Sci. 2016;7:1522. 28. Chen S, Ren H, Luo Y, Feng C, Li H. Genome-wide identification of wheat
(Triticum aestivum L.) expansin genes and functional characterization of
TaEXPB1A. Environ Exp Bot. 2021;182:104307. Author details
1 54. Qiao X, Li Q, Yin H, Qi K, Li L, Wang R, et al. Gene duplication and evolution
in recurring polyploidization–diploidization cycles in plants. Genome Biol. 2019;20(1):38–61. 29. Cosgrove DJ. Loosening of plant cell walls by expansins. Nature. 2000;
407(6802):321–6. 55. Nan Q, Qian D, Niu Y, He Y, Tong S, Niu Z, et al. Plant actin-depolymerizing
factors possess opposing biochemical properties arising from key amino
acid changes throughout evolution. Plant Cell. 2017;29(2):395–408. 30. Lin C, Choi HS, Cho HT. Root hair-specific EXPANSIN A7 is required for root
hair elongation in Arabidopsis. Mol Cell. 2011;31(4):393. 56. Jianbo X, Ying L, Xiaomin L, Yiyang Z, Bailian P. Evolutionary origins of
Pseudogenes and their association with regulatory sequences in plants. Plant Cell. 2019;31:563–78. 31. An Y, Minjie W, Limei Y, Rui H, Imran A, Yinbo G. AtEXP2 is involved in seed
germination and abiotic stress response in Arabidopsis. PLoS One. 2014;9(1):
e85208. 57. Hepler NK, Bowman A, Carey RE, Cosgrove DJ. Expansin gene loss is a common
occurrence during adaptation to an aquatic environment. Plant J. 2019;101:666–
80. 32. Javier S, Mara G, Lian-Chao L, Cosgrove DJ. Evolutionary divergence of β-
expansin structure and function in grasses parallels emergence of
distinctive primary cell wall traits. Plant J. 2015;81(1):108–20. 58. Schilling S, Kennedy A, Pan S, Jermiin L, Melzer R. Genome-wide analysis of
MIKC -type MADS -box genes in wheat: pervasive duplications, functional
conservation and putative neofunctionalization. New Phytol. 2019;225:511–
29. 33. Cosgrove DJ. Plant expansins: diversity and interactions with plant cell walls. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2015;25:162–72. 34. Quinet M, Angosto T, Yuste-Lisbona F, Blanchard-Gros R, Bigot S,
Martínez J, et al. Tomato fruit development and metabolism. Front
Plant Sci. 2019;10:1554. 59. Theißen G, Rümpler F, Gramzow L. Array of MADS-box genes: facilitator for
rapid adaptation? Trends Plant Sci. 2018;23:563–76. 35. Shinozaki Y, Nicolas P, Fernandez Pozo N, Ma Q, Evanich D, Shi Y, et al. High-resolution spatiotemporal transcriptome mapping of tomato fruit
development and ripening. Nat Commun. 2018;9:364. 60. Hurst LD. The Ka/Ks ratio: diagnosing the form of sequence evolution. Trends Genet. 2002;18(9):486. 61. Gray-Mitsumune M, Mellerowicz E, Schrader J, Winzéll A, Sterky F, Blomqvist
K, et al. Expansins abundant in secondary xylem belong to subgroup a of
the -Expansin gene family. Plant Physiol. 2004;135:1552–64. 36. Joshi DC, Chaudhari GV, Sood S, Kant L, Pattanayak A, Zhang K, et al. Author details
1 Revisiting the versatile buckwheat: reinvigorating genetic gains through
integrated breeding and genomics approach. Planta. 2019;250:783–801. 62. Ding X, Cao Y, Huang L, Zhao J, Xu C, Li X, et al. Activation of the Indole-3-
acetic acid-Amido Synthetase GH3-8 suppresses Expansin expression and
promotes salicylate- and Jasmonate-independent basal immunity in Rice. Plant Cell. 2008;20(1):228–40. 37. Zhu F. Chemical composition and health effects of Tartary buckwheat. Food
Chem. 2016;203:231–45. 38. Yiming Z, Hong W, Linlin C, Xiaoli Z, Wen T, Xinli S. Evolution of nutrient
ingredients in tartary buckwheat seeds during germination. Food Chem. 2015;186:244–8. 63. Ivica L, Tobias D, Peer B. SMART 7: recent updates to the protein domain
annotation resource. Nucleic Acids Res. 2011;D1:D1. 39. Wójcicki J, Wiszniewska B, Samochowiec L, Rózewicka L. Extractum
Fagopyri reduces atherosclerosis in high-fat diet fed rabbits. Die
Pharmazie. 1995;50:560–2. 64. Finn RD, Bateman A, Clements J, Coggill P, Eberhardt RY, Eddy SR, et al. Pfam: the protein families database. Nucleic Acids Res. 2013;42(D1):D222–30. 65. Zdobnov EM, Rolf A. InterProScan – an integration platform for the
signature-recognition methods in InterPro. Bioinformatics. 2001;9:9. 40. Zhang L, Li X, Ma B, Gao Q, Du H, Han Y, et al. The Tartary buckwheat
genome provides insights into Rutin biosynthesis and abiotic stress
tolerance. Mol Plant. 2017;10(9):1224–37. 66. Chen C, Chen H, Zhang Y, Thomas H, Frank M, He Y, et al. TBtools: An
integrative toolkit developed for interactive analyses of big biological data. Mol Plant. 2020;13:1194–202. 41. Araújo S, Beebe S, Crespi M, Bruno D, González E, Gruber V, et al. Abiotic
stress responses in legumes: strategies used to cope with environmental
challenges. Crit Rev Plant Sci. 2015;34:237–80. 67. Thompson JD, Gibson TJ, Plewniak F, Jeanmougin F, Higgins DG. The
ClustalX windows interface: flexible strategies for multiple sequence
alignment aided by quality analysis tools. Nucleic Acids Res. 1997;25(25):
4876–82. 42. War AR, Sharma HC. Effect of jasmonic acid and salicylic acid induced resistance
in groundnut on Helicoverpa armigera. Physiol Entomol. 2014;39:136–42. 43. Sharma M, Gupta S, Majumder B, Maurya V, Deeba F, Alam A, et al. Salicylic
acid mediated growth, physiological and proteomic responses in two
wheat varieties under drought stress. J Proteome. 2017;163:28–51. 68. Liu M, Ma Z, Wang A, Zheng T, Huang L, Sun W, et al. Genome-wide
investigation of the Auxin response factor gene family in Tartary buckwheat
(Fagopyrum tataricum). Int J Mol Sci. 2018;19(11):3526–44. 44. Xu J-H, Messing J. Author details
1 Diverged copies of the seed regulatory Opaque-2 gene
by a segmental duplication in the progenitor genome of Rice, sorghum,
and maize. Mol Plant. 2008;1:760–9. 69. Wang Y, Tang H, Debarry J, Tan X, Li J, Wang X, et al. MCScanX: a toolkit for
detection and evolutionary analysis of gene synteny and collinearity. Nucleic Acids Res. 2012;40:e49. 45. Kuluev B, Knyazev A, Lebedev Y, Chemeris A. Morphological and
physiological characteristics of transgenic tobacco plants expressing
expansin genes: AtEXP10 from Arabidopsis and PnEXPA1 from poplar. Russ
J Plant Physiol. 2011;59:97–104. 70. Wang D, Zhang Y, Zhang Z, Zhu J, Yu J. KaKs_Calculator 2.0:a toolkit
incorporating gamma-series methods and sliding window strategies. Genom Proteomics Bioinform. 2010;8(1):77–80. 71. Liu M, Huang L, Ma Z, Sun W, Wu Q, Tang Z, et al. Genome-wide identification,
expression analysis and functional study of the GRAS gene family in Tartary
buckwheat (Fagopyrum tataricum). BMC Plant Biol. 2019;19(1):342–59. 46. Han Z, Yanlin L, Deng X, Liu D, Liu Y, Hu Y, et al. Genome-wide
identification and expression analysis of expansin gene family in common
wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). BMC Genomics. 2019;20:101–20. 72. Livak KJ, Schmittgen TD. Analysis of relative gene expression data using
real-time quantitative PCR and the 2(−Delta Delta C(T)) method. Methods. 2012;25(4):402–8. 72. Livak KJ, Schmittgen TD. Analysis of relative gene expression data using
real-time quantitative PCR and the 2(−Delta Delta C(T)) method. Methods. 2012;25(4):402–8. 47. Shin J-H, Jeong D-H, Park M, An G. Characterization and transcriptional
expression of the alpha-expansin gene family in rice. Mol Cell. 2005;20:210–8. 48. Rose J, Lee H, Bennett A. Expression of a divergent Expansin gene is fruit-
specific and ripening-regulated. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1997;94:5955–60. 48. Rose J, Lee H, Bennett A. Expression of a divergent Expansin gene is fruit-
specific and ripening-regulated. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1997;94:5955–60. Publisher’s Note 49. Kuluev B, Safiullina M, Knyazev A, Chemeris A. Effect of ectopic expression
of NtEXPA5 gene on cell size and growth of organs of transgenic tobacco
plants. Russ J Dev Biol. 2013;44:34–41. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations.
|
https://openalex.org/W3200041105
|
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.645266/pdf
|
English
| null |
Explaining Variation in Parents' and Their Children's Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns
|
Frontiers in psychology
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 14,593
|
Explaining Variation in Parents’ and
Their Children’s Stress During
COVID-19 Lockdowns Theo Toppe 1*†, Roman Stengelin 1,2†, Louisa S. Schmidt 3, Naiera Amini 3 and
Nils Schuhmacher 4 1 Department of Comparative Cultural Psychology, Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, Leipzig, Germany,
2 Leipzig Research Center for Early Child Development, Department of Education, Leipzig University, Leipzig, Germany,
3 Department of Education, Leipzig University, Leipzig, Germany, 4 Department of Psychology, University of Münster,
Münster, Germany The coronavirus pandemic poses a substantial threat to people across the globe. In
the first half of 2020, governments limited the spread of virus by imposing diverse
regulations. These regulations had a particular impact on families as parents had to
manage their occupational situation and childcare in parallel. Here, we examine a
variation in parents’ and children’s stress during the lockdowns in the first half of
2020 and detect the correlates of families’ stress. Between April and June 2020, we
conducted an explorative online survey among n = 422 parents of 3- to 10-year-old
children residing in 17 countries. Most participants came from Germany (n = 274),
Iran (n = 70), UK (n = 23), and USA (n = 23). Parents estimated their own stress,
the stress of their own children, and various information on potential correlates (e.g.,
accommodation, family constellation, education, community size, playtime for children,
contact with peers, media consumption, and physical activity). Parents also stated
personal values regarding openness to change, self-transcendence, self-enhancement,
and conservation. The results indicate a substantial variation in the stress levels of
families and their diverse reactions to regulations. Media consumption by children
commonly increased in comparison to the time before the pandemic. Parents raising
both pre-school- and school-aged children were at a particular risk of experiencing
stress in response to regulations. Estimated stress and reactions varied with the age
of children and the personal values of parents, suggesting that such variables need to be
considered when implementing and evaluating regulations and supporting young families
in the current and future pandemic. Keywords: COVID-19, lockdown, stress, family, parents, children, cultural values †These authors share first authorship Specialty section:
This article was submitted to
Developmental Psychology,
a section of the journal
Frontiers in Psychology Received: 22 December 2020
Accepted: 30 July 2021
Published: 09 September 2021 Received: 22 December 2020
Accepted: 30 July 2021
Published: 09 September 2021
Citation:
Toppe T, Stengelin R, Schmidt LS,
Amini N and Schuhmacher N (2021)
Explaining Variation in Parents’ and
Their Children’s Stress During
COVID-19 Lockdowns. Front. Psychol. 12:645266. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.645266 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
published: 09 September 2021
doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.645266 Edited by:
Tobias Krettenauer,
Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada
Reviewed by:
Sha Xie,
Shenzhen University, China
Ashley Michelle Fraser,
Arizona State University, United States Edited by:
Tobias Krettenauer,
Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada
Reviewed by:
Sha Xie,
Shenzhen University, China
Ashley Michelle Fraser,
Arizona State University, United States
*Correspondence:
Theo Toppe
theotoppe@gmail.com
†These authors share first authorship Edited by:
Tobias Krettenauer,
Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada Reviewed by:
Sha Xie,
Shenzhen University, China
Ashley Michelle Fraser,
Arizona State University, United States *Correspondence:
Theo Toppe
theotoppe@gmail.com *Correspondence:
Theo Toppe
theotoppe@gmail.com Citation: So far, empirical data are
scarce, and researchers mostly speculate about the reactions of
families to such measures (Katz et al., 2020). Consequently, the
studies exploring the determinants of stress in families during
regulations are much needed to inform governments and non-
governmental agencies on combating this challenge. Doing so
may help identify constellations that are of a particular risk
and recognize the factors that may help buffer and counteract
parental and children’s stress. Further, we assessed parents’ personal values to better
understand the variation in families’ stress levels within and
across countries (Bavel et al., 2020). In the current study, we
assessed the values on a household level to gain a detailed
understanding of the effect of personal values during the
pandemic. To this end, we utilized Schwartz’s personal values. Schwartz assumes 10 basic values to be universally relevant
to humans across the globe (see Supplementary Table 1;
Schwartz
and
Bilsky,
1990;
Schwartz,
1992),
which
are
aligned on four superordinate scales: openness to change,
conservation, self-enhancement, and self-transcendence. The
prioritization of these values, however, varies across individuals
and cultural contexts. In general, Schwartz’s personal values
represent different motivations helping individuals cope with
their eco-social environment (Schwartz, 2012) and might
thus have shaped how individuals and families dealt with
Covid-19 regulations. The current study aims to contribute to this agenda by
exploring the reactions of families to COVID-19 regulations in
2020 and identifying the correlates of parents’ and children’s
stress. To this end, we conducted an online survey among
parents of 3- to 10-year-old children between April 2020 and
June 2020. In particular, we targeted participants from Germany,
India, Iran, the UK, and the USA. We approached participants
residing in these countries as we aimed at a more representative
understanding of the variety with which families respond to
regulations. However, because we shared an English version
of the survey via social media, parents from other countries
participated in this study as well. Citation: Toppe T, Stengelin R, Schmidt LS,
Amini N and Schuhmacher N (2021)
Explaining Variation in Parents’ and
Their Children’s Stress During
COVID-19 Lockdowns. Front. Psychol. 12:645266. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.645266 In the first half of the year 2020, governments across the globe counteracted the spread of
the novel coronavirus by enacting regulations, including lockdowns, proclamations for social
distancing, home confinements, restrictions on private and public gatherings, and the closures of
educational facilities. Although these regulations reduced the spread of the virus (Dehning et al.,
2020), they also challenged people’s psychosocial well-being (Aghili and Arbabi, 2020; Zhang et al.,
2020). People faced drastic effects related to occupation, social relations, and welfare support, September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. increasing their psychosocial stress (Huang and Zhao, 2020;
Marazziti et al., 2020; Pierce et al., 2020). hand, a higher number of children in a household may have
exacerbated parental stress due to an increased demand for
care and attention. This may have been particularly relevant
in constellations in which parents had to supervise children of
different ages in parallel. While preschool-aged children and
toddlers need constant supervision and primary care, school-
aged children demand assistance in homeschooling activities and
managing their (digital) peer contact. Likely, the combination
of differential demands in both age groups (pre-school- vs. school-aged children) elicited a particular stress to parents
due to the dual burden of supervising children with largely
differential demands. Families comprising young children had to cope with
additional burdens: in quarantine, parents had to manage their
occupation in times of major economic impediments and had
to invest in housekeeping, childcare, and homeschooling in
parallel. It is thus no wonder that these circumstances resulted
in a particular exposure to psychosocial distress among families
(Campbell, 2020; Chung et al., 2020; Janssen et al., 2020; Jiao et al.,
2020; Miller et al., 2020; Zhou et al., 2020; Moscardino et al., 2021;
Ravens-Sieberer et al., 2021; Volk et al., 2021). However, despite these strains posed by Covid-19 regulations,
the disruption of families’ lives varied considerably, leading to
variation in parental stress levels (Brown et al., 2020; Janssen
et al., 2020; Jentsch and Schnock, 2020). Identifying the sources
of such a variation may help to bundle support to families at
a particular risk during regulations. Citation: Thus, parents residing in 17
countries participated in the survey: Algeria (n = 1), American
Samoa (n = 1), Austria (n = 2), Belgium (n = 2), Canada (n = 3),
Colombia (n = 1), Denmark (n = 1), Finland (n = 1), France (n
= 2), Germany (n = 274), India (n = 4), Iran (n = 70), Iraq (n =
2), Spain (n = 3), Sweden (n = 1), the UK (n = 23), and the USA
(n = 23). We assessed how parents estimated their own as well as
the psychosocial stress of their children during the regulations. For example, variation in how parents approached novel
situations (i.e., openness to change) may have been associated
with their stress during the lockdown: parents valuing openness
might have been more flexible to adjust to the novel situation and
consequentially may have experienced less stress. Potential links
between personal values emphasizing conservation (i.e., order,
self-restriction, preservation of the past, and conformity) and
families’ stress during regulations are less conclusive. The degree
to which people valued conservation may have aligned with
higher stress levels as routines were challenged and spontaneity
was needed to navigate novel situations. On the other hand,
parents emphasizing conservation may have also been more
willing to adhere to regulations and may have felt less intimidated
by social restrictions. We further assumed higher stress levels
among parents scoring high on self-enhancement as they should
have been more likely to perceive the lockdown as an impediment
of their autonomy (Bavel et al., 2020). In line with this
assumption, recent work found a variation in individualism, both
within and across societies, being associated with the adherence
to pandemic prevention measures (Maaravi et al., 2021). Societies
emphasizing individualism over collectivism were more likely to
oppose such measures, which may account for increased case
rates and more stress experience during a pandemic (see also
Kim et al., 2016, on the role of individualism in the response
of people to the Ebola epidemic). Parents scoring high on self-
transcendence may have accepted and implemented regulations
with relative ease by outweighing individual needs in favor of the
common good. On the other hand, these individuals may have To assess which factors may have contributed to stress levels
in parents and children, we assessed diverse predictors such
as household characteristics and socioeconomic variables. Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Citation: This
included the information on socioeconomic variables, formal
education of parents, and aspects of accommodation of families
(i.e., number of rooms and access to garden) as these have
been linked to the stress in people during the current pandemic
(Agberotimi et al., 2020; Ali et al., 2020; Atchison et al., 2020; Jay
et al., 2020; Rehman et al., 2021; Volk et al., 2021). The number of children in a household may have also
affected the stress response of parents and children to regulations. For example, siblings may have offered social support that
only children would have lacked otherwise. On the other September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 2 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. faced particular psychosocial stress as they are prone to being
concerned about the well-being of others. 14.02, range = 13–91) substantially varied across the countries
of residence of participants’. We advertised a German, English, and Farsi version of the
survey via mailing lists and postings on social media platforms. Further, we asked professionals working in daycare centers,
schools, and welfare organizations to share the link to the survey. We utilized formr (Arslan et al., 2018) to create each online
survey version. Surveys were translated from English by native
speakers and double-checked by fluent speakers. Conceptual
disagreements between translations occurred rarely and were
solved through discussion until we achieved mutual agreement. Furthermore, parents reported the quantity of time they had
spent with their children in direct interaction and play activities,
their demands for homeschooling their children, children’s media
consumption, digital contact with peers and relatives, physical
activity, and the maintenance of the daily routines of children. In
addition, parents reported their age, gender, whether they worked
from home at the moment of participation and gave information
on community sizes and their country of residence. We also considered specific regulations (e.g., closure of
educational facilities) and their duration as these factors have
been found to impact families’ stress substantially (Brooks
et al., 2020; Golberstein et al., 2020; Roccella, 2020; Röhr
et al., 2020). To complement such subjective ratings on the
regulations, we added data of the Oxford Covid-19 Government
Response Tracker to our analyses (Hale et al., 2020). This
tracker systematically indicates policy responses to the COVID-
19 pandemic on a stringency score ranging from 0 to 100 (with
higher values indicating stronger regulations). Citation: Participants provided informed consent by confirming
that they participated voluntarily, understood the objectives
of this study, and knew that they could withdraw from
participation at any time. Participants did not receive any
incentives besides their scientific contribution. We did not
obtain any information, which could be traced back to
individual participants. The study was approved by the Max
Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology Child Subjects
Committee following legal requirements in Germany. Table 1 offers a description of the sample characteristics. While we approached both fathers and mothers of young
children,
most
participants
were
female
(89.00%). Most
participants were married, were from Germany, and held
University degrees at bachelor’s or master’s levels. Participants
were aged between 23 and 65 years (M = 38.23, SD = 5.50) and
mostly lived together with one or two children in their household
(M = 1.83, SD = 0.77). The majority of participants lived in
urban communities with more than 1,000,000 inhabitants. Around half of the parents (53.83%) reported raising pre-school-
aged children, whereas 64.83% reported raising school-aged
children. Thus, 18.66% of the parents raised both pre-school-
and school-aged children in parallel. About half of the parents
worked from their homes at the time in which the survey
was conducted. Finally, we added Hofstede’s individualism score of national
culture from Hofstede’s national culture survey (Hofstede, 2021)
as a proxy for eventual differences in the stress levels of
families across countries. We did so to better account for cross-
country differences in meaningful psychological properties and
the following previous work relating individualism to the spread
of COVID-19 and other pandemic situations (Maaravi et al.,
2021). We
added
both
the
stringency
score
of
the
Oxford
COVID-19 Government Response Tracker and Hofstede’s
individualism score to our analyses following suggestions by
anonymous reviewers. Materials and Procedures A total of n = 422 parents from 17 countries participated
in this study. Concerning our sample size, we refrained from
conducting an a priori power calculation as no previous studies
were available based on which we could estimate expectable effect
sizes. However, we aimed at collecting full data sets from at least
n = 200 participants because—as a rule of thumb—there should
be at least 10 cases per predictor in regression models comprising
several predictors (e.g., Wilson Van Voorhis and Morgan, 2007). Our study consisted of an online survey containing different
scales as outlined in the following parameters. Parents needed
∼30 min for participation. After giving informed consent,
parents
reported
their
age,
gender,
relationship
status,
sociodemographic information, community size, country of
residence, and current regulations related to the COVID-19
pandemic. Further, they indicated the descriptions of their
accommodation, the number of children in their household,
and whether children would typically attend a school or
daycare institution. g
g
We collected the data between April 29, 2020 and June 7,
2020, across different targeted countries (i.e., USA, UK, India,
Iran, and Germany). We focused on these countries as they
were all affected by the pandemic but vary in their cultural
orientations (e.g., Hofstede, 2011), allowing us to gain more
generalizable data than surveys focusing on single countries
only. Further, many (middle-class) families in these countries
could participate in the survey given unrestricted internet access. Notably, there were also participants residing in other countries
than the five targeted ones (7.58%), who were included in the
analyses. Further, the stringency of the policy responses to the
COVID-19 pandemic (M = 62.92, SD = 7.93, range = 38.34–
86.55) and Hofstede’s individualism score (M = 64.44, SD = Participants described their current daily life in the following
sections, focusing on their school- and pre-school-aged children
(assessed separately). Parents provided this information on all
children in the respective age group (pre-school- vs. school-
aged children). Parents who reported to have two or more
children attending school were asked to merge their impressions
considering both these children to describe their current daily
life. The same applied to pre-school-aged children. The descriptions of everyday lives of families comprised the
information on direct interactions of children with their parents, September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 3 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. TABLE 1 | Sample description. Materials and Procedures Variable
Value
Variable
Value
Variable
Value
Basic information
Community
Accommodation
Age in years M (SD)
38.23 (5.5)
Country of residence%a
Access to private garden%
76.79
Gender%
Germany
65.55
Balcony%
55.22
Female
89.00
Iran
16.75
Access to a park or forest%
89.23
Male
10.77
United Kingdom
5.50
Pets%
34.21
Other
0.24
United States
5.50
Single parents%
9.81
Community size (No. of citizens)%
Regulations%
Relationship status%
< 500
2.87
Restrictions on leaving the accommodation
39.95
Married
76.56
< 1500
3.59
Closure of educational facilities
96.65
In a relationship
14.83
< 5,000
7.18
Restrictions on public transport
48.56
Single
4.55
< 20,000
8.85
Extent of regulations
Divorced
3.83
< 100,000
7.66
Not leaving the house at all
1.44
Widowed
0.24
< 500,000
6.46
Leaving the house for essential activities
44.26
< 1,000,000
7.18
Leaving the house less than normally
52.63
Educational degree%
> 1,000,000
56.22
Leaving the house as usual
1.67
Secondary degree
13.98
Quarantine duration
A level
1.42
Household constellation M (SD)
No restrictions
0.72
Bachelor degree
26.78
No. of adults in the household
2.11 (0.75)
Less than one week
0.00
Master degree
51.12
No. of children in the household
1.82 (0.75)
One week
0.24
PhD
6.64
Two weeks
0.24
Accommodation M (SD)
Three weeks
17.70
Home office%
58.13
No. of bedrooms
6.36 (2.47)
More than three weeks
81.10
Housing condition%
Owner-occupied house
35.17
Stringency score
62.94 (7.93)
Owner-occupied apartment
17.46
Rented house
10.29
Individualism score
64.44 (14.02)
Rented apartment
37.08
aHere, we listed the residences that included >5% of the sample only. Here, we listed the residences that included >5% of the sample only. conservation (C), self-enhancement (SE), and self-transcendence
(ST). The PVQ has proven to be a high-quality instrument with
adequate sociometric properties (see Schwartz, 2003). Internal
consistencies were acceptable (αO = 0.70; αC = 0.70; αSE = 0.70;
αST = 0.63). siblings, peers, and relatives living outside the household and the
information on digital communication, daily routines, physical
activity, media consumption, and homeschooling of children. Also, participants reported on how harmful and beneficial they
perceived current regulations affecting them. We gathered this
information using Likert scales. We investigated whether the scales measured the same latent
constructs across the three translations. Specifically, we sought to
establish a weak measurement invariance as we were interested
in the relations between our independent variables and the stress
level of parents and children across various countries. Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org Materials and Procedures To this end,
we compared a model in which loadings were constrained to be
equal across translations with a model in which the loadings of a
dimension were estimated freely across translations. In the next section, parents indicated their stress levels on the
Parental Stress Scale (Zelman and Ferro, 2018), an established
scale in clinical psychology. Here, we used the subscales on
parental rewards and stressors. Parents indicated their agreement
with statements on different aspects of their stress level during the
last 2 weeks on a five-point Likert scale (e.g., “Having children
leaves little time and flexibility in my life” and “I am happy in my
role as a parent”). Internal consistencies were acceptable (αReward
= 0.68; αStress = 0.75). Further, parents reported the stress level of
their children by indicating their agreement with the statement,
“Compared to before the pandemic, my child(ren)’s current stress
level is much higher now” on a five-point Likert scale. The invariant model was supported for the reward dimension
for the Parental Stress Scale (1χ2(4) = 3.77, p = 0.44). The
model with free loadings significantly outperformed the model
with invariant loadings for the stress dimension (1χ2(4) = 10.26,
p = 0.04). For the PVQ, the metric model was supported for
the conservation (1χ2(10) = 16.81, p = 0.08), self-enhancement
(1χ2(6) = 8.94, p = 0.18), and self-transcendence dimension
(1χ2(8) = 10.61, p = 0.23). The model with free loadings
significantly outperformed the model with invariant loadings for Finally, parents filled out a brief version of the Portrait Values
Questionnaire (PVQ; Schwartz, 2003). The PVQ covers 21 items
assessing the 10 values assumed by Schwartz’s theory of basic
values subsumed into 4 main scales: openness to change (O), September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 4 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. the openness dimension (1χ2(10) = 18.72, p = 0.04). Thus, by
large, a variation in the latent constructs assessed by our scales
likely reflects the same individual differences across the English,
German, and Farsi version of the questionnaire. their school-aged children (Figure 2). In contrast, parents spent
about twice as much time homeschooling their school-aged
children (3 hours) than their preschool-aged children (1.5 hours;
Figure 3). Data Analysis First,
we
provide
the
descriptive
metrics
regarding
the
experiences and daily lives of parents during the pandemic
as such data are sparse. We also report explorative t-tests for
items related to the change since the COVID-19 outbreak, in
which we explored the mean against the “no change” values of
the respective scale. Afterwards, we report the results of an explorative inferential
analysis. We ran generalized linear mixed models using the
lme4 package (Bates et al., 2017) in R (R Core Team, 2018). These exploratory models aimed to identify the predictors of
parents’ and children’s stress (for a list of all predictors and
scaling, see Supplementary Table 2). Notably, the stringency
score and Hofstede’s individualism score were added as Level 2
predictors (i.e., country-level) to explain variability in intercepts
across countries; all other variables were Level 1 predictors (i.e.,
household level). All metric predictors were standardized. To
eliminate the inflation of type I errors, we compared the fit
of a model comprising all predictors of interest (hereafter: full
model) with a model lacking these predictors and consisting
of the intercept only (hereafter: null model; see Forstmeier
and Schielzeth, 2011). In case of significant full-null model
comparisons, we proceeded with the detailed analyses of each
predictor. We ran likelihood ratio tests for the detailed analyses
comparing full models with reduced models not comprising
each predictor. Thus, statistically significant full-null model
comparisons were a necessary condition for detailed analyses and
served as a gatekeeper reducing the total number of tests. Descriptively, school-aged children reported more support
from their parents on digital communication than did pre-
school-aged
children
(Figure 6). However,
support
and
permission for digital communication by parents increased
for both school children, t(270) = 12.958, p < 0.001, d = 0.79,
and pre-school children, t(224) = 8.009, p < 0.001, d = 0.53. In
general, parents facilitated daily routines and physical activity for
their children (Figures 7, 8). This support significantly increased
since the implementation of regulations for both school children,
troutines(270) = 6.854, p < 0.001, d = 0.42; tactivity(270) = 6.985, p
< 0.001, d = 0.42; and pre-school children troutines(224) = 6.664,
p < 0.001, d = 0.44, tactivity(224) = 6.467, p < 0.001, d = 0.43. Both school- and pre-school-aged children spent about 2.5 h
per day with media consumption (Figure 9). RESULTS We were interested in determining the effects of various
predictors on parents’ and children’s stress during the lockdown. To this end, we ran separate analyses for the data of parents
of daycare children (age 3–5 years) and parents of school-aged
children (age 5–9 years) to account for the differential demands
(i.e., supervision needed, mobility, and child autonomy). It is
noted that 18.5% of the parents reported living together with
both pre-school- and school-aged children. We included this
subsample in both analyses. Data Analysis Parents reported a
substantial increase in media consumption by children since the
lockdown, for school-aged children, t(270) = 16.809, p < 0.001,
d = 1.02, and for pre-school-aged children, t(224) = 16.233, p <
0.001, d = 1.08. To
rule
out
multicollinearity
between
predictors,
we
calculated variance inflation factors (VIFs; Field, 2005), using the
function vif of the car package (Fox and Weisberg, 2011). When
including both the stringency and individualism score, VIFs
suggested high multicollinearity between these predictors (note
that both variables were coded on a country level). Therefore, we
investigated the effect of the individualism score in a separate
analysis. That is, we ran a model including the stringency score
and interpreted the effects of all predictors. After that, we ran
a model comprising the individualism score instead of the
stringency score and focused on a statistically significant effect
of the individualism scale. None of the VIFs indicated the issues
regarding multicollinearity (all VIFs < 5.14). Mostly, parents perceived the lockdown as harmful and non-
beneficial for the development of their children (Figure 10). The
stress of parents and their judgment regarding the stress of their
children varied considerably across parents (Figure 11); however,
on average, parents indicated medium to high stress levels. Materials and Procedures Face-to-face interactions with peers decreased considerably in
response to regulations for both pre-school-, t(224) = 28.454, p <
0.001, d = 1.90, and school-aged children, t(270) = 27.212, p <
0.001, d = 1.65 (Figure 4). On average, children communicated
with peers via digital means once a week. For school-aged
children, digital communication with peers increased markedly
since the lockdown, t(270) = 6.944, p < 0.001, d = 0.42. This trend
was less pronounced but still significant for pre-school-aged
children, t(224) = 2.757, p = 0.006, d = 0.18. A similar pattern was
observed for digital contact with family members living outside
the household (Figure 5). Here, there was a decrease in face-to-
face contact since the lockdown for pre-school-, t(224) = 16.339,
p < 0.001, d = 1.09, and school-aged children, t(270) = 16.114,
p < 0.001, d = 0.98. For most households, the frequency of
digital communication with family relatives remained unaffected
by the lockdown. However, we still find a significant increase for
preschoolers’, t(224) = 6.366, p < 0.001, d = 0.42, and schoolers’,
t(270) = 4.362, p < 0.001, d = 0.26, digital contact to family
members living outside their household. Descriptive Results The time parents directly interacted with their children varied
considerably for both school and preschool children (Figure 1). Overall, this adult–child time increased substantially since the
beginning of the COVID-19 outbreak for pre-school-, t(224) =
19.732, p < 0.001, d = 1.32, and school-aged children, t(270)
= 21.335, p < 0.001, d = 1.30. On average, parents played
about 4.0 h with their pre-school-aged children and 2.5 h with September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 5 Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns FIGURE 1 | Upper plots indicate the number of hours parents spent with their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the change of this time since
the COVID-19 pandemic. FIGURE 1 | Upper plots indicate the number of hours parents spent with their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the change of this time since
the COVID-19 pandemic. In each of the two models, we explored parents’ or children’s
stress using a set of predictors (see Table 2, first column). To
account for a systematic variation in the predictors and outcomes
across countries, models comprised the country of residence of
participants as a random intercept. To underline the robustness
of the current findings, we accounted for a large proportion of
participants living in Germany by running identical analyses with
German participants only. parents holding a PhD reported particularly high stress levels
compared to other parents and that the stress level of parents
of all other educational levels did not vary substantially (see
Supplementary Table 3). For the personal values of parents, the
model revealed a positive association between parents’ stress
and their values on self-transcendence, χ2
ST (1) = 4.189, p =
0.041. Parents from households with access to a garden reported
less stress than parents living in households without garden
access, χ2
garden (1) = 4.214, p = 0.040. Parents raising both
pre-school- and school-aged children (M = 3.25, SD = 0.92)
reported higher stress levels than those raising pre-school-aged
children only (M = 2.78, SD = 1.10), χ2
constellation of children (1) =
6.288, p = 0.012. Children’s digital peer contact was positively
associated with the stress level of parents, χ2
digital peer contact
(1) = 5.399, p = 0.020. Descriptive Results Finally, we found a negative link
between the support parents provided for the physical activity
of their pre-school-aged children and their own level of stress,
χ2
physical activity (1) = 7.951, p = 0.005. That is, parents who Parents’ Stress A full-null model comparison indicated that the combined
set of predictors had a statistically significant effect on stress
levels among parents of daycare children, χ2
full−null (38) =
69.902, p < 0.001 (Table 2). Likelihood ratio tests revealed a
statistically significant effect of parental education, χ2
education
(4) = 14.390, p = 0.006. To explore this effect further, we
ran multiple Tukey post hoc comparisons using the package
multicomp (Hothorn et al., 2008). These tests suggested that September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 6 Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns FIGURE 2 | Upper plots indicate the number of hours parents played with their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the time siblings spent for
playing. FIGURE 2 | Upper plots indicate the number of hours parents played with their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the time siblings spent for
playing. FIGURE 3 | Plots indicate the number of hours parents currently spent for homeschooling with their school- and preschool-aged children. Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org
7
September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 FIGURE 2 | Upper plots indicate the number of hours parents played with their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the time siblings spent for
playing FIGURE 2 | Upper plots indicate the number of hours parents played with their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the time siblings spent for FIGURE 3 | Plots indicate the number of hours parents currently spent for homeschooling with their school- and preschool-aged children. FIGURE 3 | Plots indicate the number of hours parents currently spent for homeschooling with their school- and preschool-aged children. RE 3 | Plots indicate the number of hours parents currently spent for homeschooling with their school- and preschool-aged children September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 7 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns RE 4 | Upper plots indicate the number of days per week on which school- and preschool-aged children had contact with peers living outside their household. n the middle indicate the change of children’s digital peer contact since the COVID-19 pandemic. Lower plots indicate the change of children’s face-to-face peer
t since the COVID-19 pandemic. d more support for the physical activity of their pre-
-aged children reported feeling less stressed. Parents’ Stress A separate
l d
h
f
d ’
d
d
l
d
d
We found an overall effect of the variables for parents of
school-aged children, χ2
full−null (38) = 79.382, p < 0.001. Pairwise
d l
d
b FIGURE 4 | Upper plots indicate the number of days per week on which school- and preschool-aged children had contact with peers living outside their household. Plots in the middle indicate the change of children’s digital peer contact since the COVID-19 pandemic. Lower plots indicate the change of children’s face-to-face peer
contact since the COVID-19 pandemic. We found an overall effect of the variables for parents of
school-aged children, χ2
full−null (38) = 79.382, p < 0.001. Pairwise
model comparisons suggested negative associations between
parents’ stress and their values on openness to change, χ2
O (1)
= 5.155, p = 0.023, and conservation, χ2
C (1) = 7.296, p = 0.007, offered more support for the physical activity of their pre-
school-aged children reported feeling less stressed. A separate
model revealed that Hofstede’s individualism score predicted
higher stress levels among parents, χ2
individualsm (1) = 4.047, p
= 0.044. offered more support for the physical activity of their pre-
school-aged children reported feeling less stressed. A separate
model revealed that Hofstede’s individualism score predicted
higher stress levels among parents, χ2
individualsm (1) = 4.047, p
= 0.044. September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns RE 5 | Upper plots indicate the number of days per week on which school- and preschool-aged children had a contact with family members living outside their
hold. Plots in the middle indicate the change of children’s digital contact with family members living outside their household since the COVID-19 pandemic. plots indicate the change of children’s face-to-face contact with family members living outside their household since the COVID-19 pandemic. positive association between stress and self-enhancement,
) = 4.601, p = 0.032. Again, the constellation of children
nked to the stress level of parents, χ2
constellation of children
12 462
p < 0 001
such that parents of both pre-
parents and their children was positively linked to parents’
stress, χ2
change in parent−child time (1) = 9.856, p = 0.002. Parents’ Stress Besides, the more parents supported
the routines of their children, the less stress was reported, χ2
routines
(1) = 5.666, p = 0.017. The change in parents’ support for
children’s physical activity since Covid-19 was linked to children’s
stress, χ2
change in physical activity (1) = 7.896, p
= 0.005. Here,
increased support was associated with more stress. Finally, the
change in media consumption by children was related to their
stress level, χ2
change in media consumption (1) = 6.439, p = 0.011, with
increasing media consumption going along with higher stress
levels of children. Parents’ Stress The more
parents spent time in a direct interaction with their school-
aged children the more stress parents reported Finally the FIGURE 5 | Upper plots indicate the number of days per week on which school- and preschool-aged children had a contact with family members living outside their
household. Plots in the middle indicate the change of children’s digital contact with family members living outside their household since the COVID-19 pandemic. Lower plots indicate the change of children’s face-to-face contact with family members living outside their household since the COVID-19 pandemic. parents and their children was positively linked to parents’
stress, χ2
change in parent−child time (1) = 9.856, p = 0.002. The more
parents spent time in a direct interaction with their school-
aged children, the more stress parents reported. Finally, the
more school-aged children contacted their peers digitally, the less
stress was reported by parents, χ2
digital peer contact (1) = 5.543, p
= 0.019. and a positive association between stress and self-enhancement,
χ2
SE (1) = 4.601, p = 0.032. Again, the constellation of children
was linked to the stress level of parents, χ2
constellation of children
(1) = 12.462, p < 0.001, such that parents of both pre-
school- and school-aged children had a higher stress level (M
= 3.25, SD = 0.92) than parents of school-aged children only
(M = 2.90, SD = 0.97). The change in time spent between and a positive association between stress and self-enhancement,
χ2
SE (1) = 4.601, p = 0.032. Again, the constellation of children
was linked to the stress level of parents, χ2
t ll ti
f hild September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 9 Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns FIGURE 6 | Upper plots indicate the support of parents for digital communication to school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the change of this
support since the COVID-19 pandemic. FIGURE 6 | Upper plots indicate the support of parents for digital communication to school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the change of this
support since the COVID-19 pandemic. COVID-19 was linked to children’s stress, χ2
change in time spent
(1) = 6.411, p = 0.011. The more time parents spent with
their children had increased in response to the pandemic
and accompanying regulations, the less stressed were children
described by their parents. Children’s Stress For parents of pre-schoolers, we found a statistically significant
effect of the combined set of predictors, χ2
full−null (39) =
87.163, p < 0.001. Likelihood ratio tests revealed a statistically
significant effect of parental education, χ2
education (4) = 11.170,
p = 0.025. Again, we ran multiple Tukey post hoc comparisons
using the package multicomp (Hothorn et al., 2008) to
explore this effect. These tests did not suggest a clear pattern
(see Supplementary Table 4). However, an inspection of the
estimates suggests that parents holding a lower educational
degree report more stress of their children. Parents’ stress was
positively associated with children’s stress, χ2
parents′ stress (1) =
7.936, p < 0.005. Parental values on self-transcendence were
negatively linked to children’s stress, χ2
self−transcendence (1) =
11.687, p < 0.001, such that children whose parents strongly
valued self-transcendence were described as being less stressed. Children living in households with more rooms were described as
less stressed, χ2
number of rooms (1) = 4.850, p = 0.028. The change
in time parents spent with their pre-school-aged children since For parents of school-aged children, we found an overall
effect of the combined set of predictors, χ2
full−null (39) =
62.026, p = 0.011. Similar to pre-school-aged children, parents’
stress was positively associated with school-aged children’s stress,
χ2
parents′ stress (1) = 13.973, p < 0.001. Children’s stress was also September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 10 Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns FIGURE 7 | Upper plots indicate the support of parents for the routines of school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the change of this support since
the COVID-19 pandemic. | FIGURE 7 | Upper plots indicate the support of parents for the routines of school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the change of this support since
the COVID-19 pandemic. positively linked to media consumption, χ2
media consumption (1)
= 6.884, p = 0.009. Again, the change in parents’ support for
children’s physical activity since the lockdown was positively
associated with children’s stress, χ2
change in physical activity (1) =
9.812, p = 0.002. Finally, the stringency of countries was
negatively linked to children’s stress χ2
stringency (1) = 5.609, p
= 0.018. situation as harmful rather than beneficial, with a considerable
variation in this evaluation across families. Children’s Stress Unsurprisingly,
parents spent more time with their children as compared
to the time before the pandemic and engaged in more
homeschooling. Children
engaged
in
fewer
face-to-face
interactions with peers and family members living outside
their households, which was substituted with an increased
emphasis
on
digital
communication. Further,
parents
reported that their children’s media consumption increased
substantially compared to the time before the pandemic. This
finding on increased media consumption in young children
during COVID-19 regulations resonates with recent studies
(Feierabend et al., 2020; Hartshorne et al., 2021; Poulain et al.,
2021). positively linked to media consumption, χ2
media consumption (1)
= 6.884, p = 0.009. Again, the change in parents’ support for
children’s physical activity since the lockdown was positively
associated with children’s stress, χ2
change in physical activity (1) =
9.812, p = 0.002. Finally, the stringency of countries was
negatively linked to children’s stress χ2
stringency (1) = 5.609, p
= 0.018. When analyzing the German subsample only, we find a
pattern of results that is similar to the results based on the full
sample (see Supplementary Table 5). Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org DISCUSSION To explore variation in parents’ and children’s stress, we
estimated the effect of various variables. Overall, we find (a)
mostly different predictors for parents’ stress as compared to
children’s stress and (b) different associations among pre-school-
and school-aged children. The coronavirus pandemic had and has drastic effects on the life
of young families around the globe. The current study explored
the potential correlates of psychosocial stress among parents and
their children in response to COVID-19 regulations exhibited in
the first half of 2020. Notably, the cross-sectional design of our study does not
allow for causal conclusions regarding these associations. The Our study indicates moderate to high levels of stress
among parents and their children. Parents perceived the September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 11 Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns FIGURE 8 | Upper plots indicate the support of parents for the physical activity in school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the change of this
support since the COVID-19 pandemic. FIGURE 8 | Upper plots indicate the support of parents for the physical activity in school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate the change of this
support since the COVID-19 pandemic. from one of the two age groups only. It appears that the
confrontation with a dual load of childcare was particularly
stressful for parents. During COVID-19 regulations, parents
needed to provide primary care and close supervision for pre-
schoolers, whereas school-aged children needed support for
homeschooling and (digital) peer interactions. The presence of
both types of demands may have enhanced psychosocial stress
of parents. detected associations between families’ stress and some variables
should not be conceived of as monocausal. This particularly
applies to variables subject to situational changes (e.g., changes
in media consumption and homeschooling activities). It is
most likely that these variables affected parents’ and children’s
stress and, at the same time, were affected by these stress
levels. Given the cross-sectional research design, we can only
speculate on the directionality of links between personal values
and stress. Personal values have likely changed in response
to the pandemic and governmental regulations, rendering
monocausal interpretations of such associations premature. Discussions regarding the directions of the detected effects
remain speculative and require confirmation by longitudinal and
experimental studies. We focus below on the most prominent
and congruent associations in the current data and reasonable
interpretations thereof. DISCUSSION It is important to note that this effect was evident regardless
of the absolute number of children in a given household,
indicating that the differential demands posed by pre-school- and
school-aged children drove the association. Siblings of roughly
similar ages may eventually buffer parents’ stress as children
support each other during homeschooling or play activities. Moreover, parents may supervise children of similar ages in
parallel, increasing the efficiency of parenting interventions
during regulations. Parents’ Stress Governments and social support systems may particularly
consider parents raising both pre-school- and school-aged
children when deciding on how to allocate support for
families. For example, parents raising both school-aged and Constellation of Children Constellation of Children We found that parents raising both pre-school- and school-
aged children were more stressed than those raising children September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 12 Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns FIGURE 9 | Upper plots indicate the daily number of hours school- and preschool-aged children spent for media consumption. Lower plots indicate the change in the
media consumption by children since the COVID-19 pandemic. FIGURE 9 | Upper plots indicate the daily number of hours school- and preschool-aged children spent for media consumption. Lower plots indicate the change in the
media consumption by children since the COVID-19 pandemic. preschool-aged children may be given priority to make use
of limited (i.e., emergency) childcare programs or access to
other support. these parents may have aimed to work from home while taking
care of their children—leading to exceptionally high levels of
psychosocial stress. As such, these parents may have been affected
most severely by the closing of daycare institutions, leaving
them unprepared to manage caregiving and their occupation
in parallel. Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org Education Parents of pre-school-aged children holding a PhD degree
reported higher stress levels during regulations as compared
to other parents. Given that lower socioeconomic status is
typically associated with heightened stress levels and health
issues (Chen and Miller, 2013; Brown et al., 2020), this finding
appears surprising at first glance as it contradicts previous work,
suggesting more stress among families from lower socioeconomic
backgrounds during the Covid-19 lockdown (Agberotimi et al.,
2020; Ali et al., 2020; Atchison et al., 2020; Jay et al., 2020;
Huebener et al., 2021; Rehman et al., 2021; Volk et al., 2021). One may speculate that some of the parents holding a
PhD may have been enrolled in jobs linked to medical care. Accordingly, the association of education and parents’ stress
is in line with the previous work highlighting the necessity
for psychosocial support of medical staffat the frontline in
combating the pandemic (Galbraith et al., 2020; Zaka et al., 2020). Notably, caregiving duties have been identified as a stressor for
medical staffpreviously (Mo et al., 2020). Besides, one may assume that parents in the PhD subgroup
may commonly be early career scholars in academia who find
themselves in vulnerable situations due to short-time contracts
and pressure to generate scientific output (e.g., publications and
grant funding). The dual load of compensating closed daycare
institutions while being in an insecure career phase may have
resulted in high levels of psychosocial stress. Notably, scientists
have emphasized the need to support early career researchers Interestingly, this link was only evident among parents of pre-
school-aged, but not older children. We suppose this link may
indicate that parents with high levels of education and raising
younger children may rely on institutionalized childcare more
frequently—most urgently if both parents have a full-time or
leading position (Petitclerc et al., 2017; Alt et al., 2018). In times of
COVID-19 regulations and a lack of institutionalized childcare, Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 13 Toppe et al. Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns FIGURE 10 | Upper plots indicate how harmful parents perceive the lockdown for their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate how beneficial
parents perceive the lockdown for their school- and preschool-aged children. FIGURE 10 | Upper plots indicate how harmful parents perceive the lockdown for their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate how beneficial
parents perceive the lockdown for their school- and preschool-aged children. Education FIGURE 11 | Plots indicate the stress levels of parents and children when taking the survey. Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org
14
September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 FIGURE 10 | Upper plots indicate how harmful parents perceive the lockdown for their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate how beneficial
parents perceive the lockdown for their school- and preschool-aged children. FIGURE 10 | Upper plots indicate how harmful parents perceive the lockdown for their school- and preschool-aged children. Lower plots indicate how beneficial
parents perceive the lockdown for their school- and preschool-aged children. FIGURE 11 | Plots indicate the stress levels of parents and children when taking the survey. September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 14 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. TABLE 2 | Outcomes for inferential models. Parents’ stress
Children’s stress
Preschool-aged children
School-aged children
Preschool-aged children
School-aged children
Full-null model comparison
χ2(38) = 69.902, p = 0.001
χ2(38) = 79.382, p < 0.001
χ2(39) = 87.163, p < 0.001
χ2(39) = 62.026, p = 0.011
estimate
S.E. estimate
S.E. Estimate
S.E. estimate
S.E. Education Age
0.003
0.075
−0.105
0.073
0.072
0.100
0.116
0.094
Gender (ref: Male)
Female
0.058
0.219
0.249
0.230
−0.382
0.293
−0.554
0.297
Other
1.124
0.980
−0.036
0.984
0.064
1.317
0.666
1.270
Home office
0.020
0.145
−0.031
0.136
0.201
0.195
0.233
0.174
Education (ref: Secondary)
A level
0.097*
0.442
0.080
0.980
0.584*
0.592
−0.962
1.265
Bachelor
0.059*
0.261
−0.173
0.218
−0.268*
0.350
0.149
0.276
Master
0.291*
0.224
−0.014
0.192
−0.497*
0.301
−0.098
0.246
PhD
0.972*
0.319
0.533
0.308
−0.970*
0.438
−0.366
0.395
Single parent
0.170
0.305
0.239
0.206
0.456
0.409
0.016
0.264
Parents’ stress
–
–
–
–
0.254*
0.097
0.316*
0.091
Openness
−0.011
0.076
–0.154*
0.071
−0.014
0.102
−0.102
0.091
Self-enhancement
0.045
0.078
0.153*
0.076
−0.017
0.105
0.058
0.098
Self-transcendence
0.148*
0.077
0.033
0.076
−0.330*
0.103
−0.068
0.097
Conservation
−0.055
0.079
–0.182*
0.073
0.058
0.105
−0.027
0.095
Community size (ref: < 500)
< 1500
0.279
0.743
0.215
0.428
−0.595
0.995
−0.087
0.544
< 5000
0.018
0.591
0.140
0.391
−0.567
0.792
−0.024
0.494
< 20.000
−0.112
0.588
−0.254
0.379
−0.089
0.788
0.399
0.479
< 100.000
0.494
0.591
−0.397
0405
−0.379
0.792
0.190
0.511
< 500.000
0504
0.600
0.528
0.434
−0.836
0.805
−0.700
0.554
< 1.000.000
0.315
0.601
0.211
0.415
−0.852
0.804
−0.344
0.524
1.000.000+
0.054
0.561
0.167
0.344
−0.424
0.751
−0.170
0.435
Number of rooms
0.045
0.081
−0.009
0.082
−0.208*
0.109
−0.180
0.103
Garden
−0.318*
0.167
−0.044
0.175
0.052
0.226
0.045
0.223
Restrictions
−0.058
0.144
−0.138
0.137
−0.204
0.193
0.264
0.174
Stringency score (Level 2)
0.179
0.121
0.037
0.184
0.099
0.159
−0.354*
0.157
Individualism score (Level 2)a
0.197*
0.111
0.221
0.140
0.142
0.149
0.095
0.165
Constellation of children
0.405*
0.185
0.494*
0.149
−0.084
0.250
−0.232
0.196
Number of children
0.019
0.084
0.098
0.071
0.132
0.112
0.113
0.091
Parent-child time
0.090
0.079
−0.075
0.080
0.178
0.106
0.073
0.103
Change in parent-child time
0.109
0.074
0.215*
0.074
−0.235*
0.100
−0.068
0.095
Homeschooling
−0.124
0.070
0.012
0.066
−0.039
0.095
0.066
0.084
Digital peer contact
0.146*
0.071
–0.146*
0.066
0.035
0.097
0.046
0.086
Support for digital contact
−0.024
0.081
−0.126
0.078
0.062
0.109
0.020
0.099
Change in support for digital contact
−0.032
0.082
0.019
0.075
0.045
0.109
0.008
0.096
Support for physical activity
−0.241*
0.096
−0.074
0.080
−0.003
0.130
−0.061
0.102
Change in support for physical activity
0.103
0.084
0.042
0.076
0.283*
0.112
0.270*
0.097
Support for routines
0.115
0.085
−0.004
0.079
−0.225*
0.114
−0.088
0.100
Change in support of routines
−0.009
0.086
−0.015
0.078
0.215
0.115
−0.107
0.100
Media consumption
−0.101
0.092
−0.007
0.085
0.151
0.123
0.009
0.107
Change in media consumption
0.143
0.080
0.064
0.074
0.224*
0.107
0.220*
0.094
Model determination (Marginal)
0.248
0.178
0.285
0.193
SE; boldly printed estimates and SEs marked with an asterisk indicate a significant pairwise comparison with p < 0.05. boldly printed estimates and SEs marked with an asterisk indicate a significant pairwise comparison with p < 0.05. Model determination indicat aFor the individualism score, estimates and SEs of the separate model are reported here. marked with an asterisk indicate a significant pairwise comparison with p < 0.05. Model determination indicates marginal effects of all fixed effe s and SEs of the separate model are reported here. dualism score, estimates and SEs of the separate model are reported here. Education Model determination indicates marginal effects of all fixed effects
aFor the individualism score estimates and SEs of the separate model are reported here TABLE 2 | Outcomes for inferential models. September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 15 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. during the pandemic (Cheng and Song, 2020; Gibson et al., 2020;
Termini and Traver, 2020). Furthermore, some of these parents
may have been employed in responsible positions in which the
dual load of homeschooling and job occupations may have had
more severe effects on their stress. disruptions of personal values. As such, causal interpretations of
the links between parents’ stress and personal values should be
made with caution. For parents of school-aged children, the pattern seems to
be straightforward. Higher emphasis on self-enhancement went
along with higher stress levels. It is likely that the increased
demand for childcare disrupted parents’ goal achievement (e.g.,
job success) and that this was particularly stressful for parents
valuing such goals. Alternatively, this link may indicate that
parents suffering from higher stress were more sensitive to the
disruptive potential of the pandemic situation on their autonomy. Parents being open to change and valuing conservation reported
being stressed to lower degrees. Parents emphasizing openness
to novel situations might cope better with everyday life changes
during the lockdown and may have been more optimistic. For
parents valuing conservation, it might have been easier to accept
and adapt to measures counteracting the pandemic. Accordingly,
these parents may have been eager to take such steps out of a sense
of responsibility for the public (see also Bavel et al., 2020; Gelfand
et al., 2021). Again, a reverse effect may have been of relevance:
parents experiencing lower levels of stress may have had fewer
concerns regarding the pandemic situations, and such optimism
may have accentuated their personal values regarding openness
to change. Another explanation holds that these parents may have had
more severe concerns regarding the negative consequences of
regulations on the development of their children. If so, these
parents may have been susceptible to the disruptive nature of
social restrictions, leading them to experience high stress levels by
themselves. This account may also explain why these parents did
not ascribe higher stress levels to their children—as the adverse
consequences of regulations may have been unknown to these
children at the time. Accommodation We find that access to a private garden was associated with lower
parental stress. Having a garden may be particularly beneficial
when families are restricted in mobility (i.e., public parks, sport
facilities, and playing grounds). Having a safe environment
outside may reduce the urge for close supervision among parents
and, thus, provide parents (and children) much needed degrees of
freedom during lockdowns. Furthermore, spending time outside
might have also reduced the stress levels of parents more directly
due to enjoying nature and engaging in recreational gardening
activities (Hilbert, 2020). This link also resonates with our finding
on children’s stress and the number of rooms available in their
households (see below). In general, our findings align with those from transcultural
psychiatry, showing significant links between personal value
orientations and vulnerability to psychological strain (Heim et al.,
2019). Personal values reveal important information to predict
the stress reactions of parents to the pandemic. Future research is
needed to gain a more comprehensive overview of such relations
while considering the causality of such links via longitudinal
study designs. Particularly studies investigating participants from
diverse cultural contexts seem a promising avenue in this arena
(Bavel et al., 2020; Katz et al., 2020). Of course, possessing a private garden may also be indicative
of a higher level of wealth, which may buffer against stress during
the pandemic (see also Agberotimi et al., 2020; Ali et al., 2020;
Atchison et al., 2020; Jay et al., 2020; Rehman et al., 2021; Volk
et al., 2021). Education As we did not assess detailed information
on the employment of participants, we can only emphasize that
more work is needed to examine these associations by focusing
on parents employed in these and other high-risk domains. Surprisingly, the link between education and stress level did
not recur among parents of school-aged children. One may
assume that parents with higher degrees in the formal education
may be better offto master schooling their children at home. However, it has to be noted that the current study did not
investigate homeschooling in detail. While it is plausible that
parents with higher degrees in formalized education may have
advantages to compensate formal schooling, this does not imply
that they conceive this situation as less stressful than parents
reporting lower degrees in formalized education. We did not find this pattern for parents of pre-school-aged
children. Here, parents emphasizing self-transcendence reported
being more stressed. One may assume that directedness to
others may have led parents to be particularly concerned with
the disruptive effects of the pandemics. Further, our results
suggest that cultural individualism—as indicated by Hofstede’s
score—was positively associated with stress for parents of pre-
school-aged children. Cultural contexts characterized by loosely
knit social networks might promote parents’ stress as parents
had to cope with the situation more independent of social
or family support. Previous findings also suggest that cultural
individualism is associated with more severe consequences of the
pandemic (Gelfand et al., 2021). Children’s Stress pre-schoolers may have been an efficient means to promote the
mood of children toward being more balanced, which may have
had downstream effects on parents’ stress. Partial support for this
interpretation stems from the studies finding the physical activity
of children negatively related to their stress levels (Martikainen
et al., 2013; Rodriguez-Ayllon et al., 2019). Given that regulations
disrupted the physical activity of children outside their homes
(e.g., limited access to club sport), pre-school children (and
their parents) may have suffered from these disruptions most
heavily. This interpretation also resonates with the finding that
pre-school-aged children were less stressed when living in more
spacious accommodations allowing for physical activity without
relying on public playgrounds (see below). However, it also
seems plausible that less stressed parents were better equipped to
promote the physical activity of their pre-school-aged children. We found a positive association between parents’ own stress
and their pre-school- and school-aged children’s stress. Parents
reporting higher stress tended to report higher stress of their
children. Because the reports on both parents’ and children’s
stress were obtained from parents, it stands to reason that those
parents suffering from more severe stress may have also ascribed
this stress to their children. To counteract this effect, we suggest
assessing children’s stress directly through self-report in future
studies (see Limitations). This methodological concern notwithstanding, a genuine link
between parents’ and children’s stress levels is also plausible. That
is, stressed parents might not have had the capacity to adequately
support their children, thereby increasing their children’s stress,
and stressed children might have been a strain for their parents. This association suggests that children’s and parents’ stress should
not be seen as a separated phenomenon. Families had to cope
with the novel situation as units. School-aged children’s contact with peers via digital means
was linked with parents’ stress, such that the facilitation of
digital peer contact was associated with lower stress levels. We
propose two interpretations for this finding: firstly, parents with
lower stress levels may be better equipped to support their
children’s digital peer contact, which requires high levels of adult
supervision and technical know-how. Alternatively, substituting
children’s in-person contact with their peers through digital
means may present an efficient coping mechanism allowing
parents to reduce psychosocial stress. 1Notably, such programs have been implemented successfully in some instances
by local sport teams and federations (e.g., https://www.albaberlin.de/news/details/
reaktion-auf-coronavirus-albas-taegliche-digitale-sportstunde-fuer-kinder-und-
jugendliche/;
https://www.sport.wales/beactivewales-campaign/beactivewales-
keeping-young-people-active/). Behavioral Adaptations Our investigation revealed different links between the personal
values of parents, Hofstede’s individualism score, and stress
levels. As outlined above, it is important to bear in mind that the
current study design does not allow us to identify the causality
of this association. While Schwartz’ personal values target
participants’ trait-like (rather than state-like) values (Roccas
et al., 2002; Parks-Leduc et al., 2015), significant events such
as the COVID-19 pandemic have likely altered the personal
values of parents. Stressful experiences might result in substantial p
Across the age groups of both children, we found diverse
associations between parents’ stress and changes since the
COVID-19 regulations. Importantly, all these associations do
not allow for causal interpretations but may reflect bidirectional
links instead. The more parents of pre-school-aged children facilitated the
physical activity of children, the less stress they reported. One way
of interpreting this finding is that fostering the physical activity of September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 16 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org Children’s Stress Given the increasing
importance of peer contact for the psychosocial well-being of
children throughout school-age (Rubin et al., 2005, 2007), we
argue that encouraging children’s digital peer contact offers an
important means to substitute social disruptions and stabilize
psychosocial well-being. We also found associations between adaptive strategies and
children’s stress. Firstly, the more children consumed media since
the lockdown, the more stress parents ascribed to their children. Secondly, the more parents supported the physical activity of
children since the lockdown, the more stress parents ascribed to
their children. Again, these associations cannot be interpreted
in terms of causal directions, and different interpretations are
applicable. For example, parents might have allowed more media
consumption and might have encouraged more physical activities
as a reaction towards their children’s increased stress levels. Regardless of the causal inferences drawn from this data, the
current findings highlight the role of these two domains for the
stress levels of children. Providing parents with resources such as
media services (see above) and sports instructions for the physical
exercise of children at home seems advisable in this regard.1 Interestingly, this association was reversed for parents of
pre-school-aged children. Parents facilitating more digital peer
contact among pre-schoolers reported higher stress levels. On one hand, stressed parents might have aimed to reduce
their strain by promoting digital peer contact. On the other
hand, the development of self-regulation and autonomy of
children might have driven this effect. That is, school-aged
children may have benefitted from their increasing competency
to navigate digital media to communicate with peers. Here,
media use by children may have buffered parental stress
efficiently. Younger children lacking such competence and
autonomy may have required more supervision by their parents
to engage in digital peer communication, promoting their
stress levels. Pre-School-Aged Children As such,
the detected effects of cultural individualism and the stringency
of the COVID-19 regulation need to be interpreted with caution. Further, we found a link between pre-school-aged children’s
stress and parents’ support for daily routines. This finding
resonates with research documenting the promotive effects of
daily routines on the well-being of children (Fiese et al., 2002;
Kitsaras et al., 2018). Our data confirm the importance of daily
routines for reducing the stress level of pre-schoolers’ in response
to COVID-19 regulations. of the COVID 19 regulation need to be interpreted with caution. A final limitation concerns the generalizability of our findings
based on sample characteristics. Participants were mostly female
and came from wealthy urban areas in Global North countries
(i.e., Germany and UK). Also, we did not assess ethnic variability
within countries. In consequence, the current findings cannot be
easily generalized outside such societies. Firstly, it is important to
note that most parents partaking in the current study identified
themselves as females even though we aimed to assess both
fathers and mothers. Numerous studies have emphasized that
many of the burdens posed by the pandemic situations have fallen
on mothers (Power, 2020; Forbes et al., 2021; Staniscuaski et al.,
2021). This particularly applies to variables subject to situational
changes (e.g., changes in media consumption, homeschooling
activities) (Staniscuaski et al., 2021). More data on the role of
fathers in the pandemic is much needed. Following our cross-
cultural approach, inter-individual and societal variation in the
involvement of fathers in childcare presents a promising variable
in this regard. Secondly, the participants of the current study
reported high degrees in formal education and socioeconomic
status. We also targeted participants from diverse, non-Western
societies to gain a more representative perspective (Henrich
et al., 2010). Still, the response rate from parents in Global
North countries was much higher. A fundamental challenge
of such cross-cultural survey research is that it is difficult to
isolate the drivers of country-level variation in study findings. Human societies vary alongside multiple factors, including
the importance ascribed to formalized education, monetary
wealth, ethnicity, household compositions, and cultural values. Parents’ occupation of parents in more industrialized and
digitalized contexts may have been easier to adjust to home office
settings. Furthermore, the COVID-19 pandemic caused more
fundamental problems to people residing in the Global South
(e.g., related to nutrition, see Amadasun, 2021). Pre-School-Aged Children e Sc oo
ged C
d e
Pre-school-aged children’s stress was associated with the number
of rooms in accommodations of families, such that more spacious
accommodations went along with less stress. In line with the
associations found between parents’ stress and the physical
activity of children and parents’ stress and access of families
to a garden (see above), one may assume that pre-school-aged
children may require sufficient space for their playing activities. Opportunities to children for playing outside were disrupted
drastically during COVID-19 regulations in many countries,
suggesting that the home environment presented children’s
playground during this time. Our data point to the vulnerability
of families lacking access to supportive accommodations (e.g.,
spacious housing or access to a garden), such as those living
in urban contexts or families from lower socioeconomic
backgrounds. As such, our findings hint toward the importance
of public playgrounds, parks, and sports facilities for families’ the
well-being of families well-being in times of regulations. As such, Irrespective of all these interpretations, our data imply that
children’s digital peer contact is associated with the stress levels
of parents. One potential implication of this is that media
competencies of parents could be actively promoted to use
school-aged children’s digital peer contact as an effective coping
mechanism. Furthermore, parents could be equipped with
hands-on services allowing for children’s digital communication. Providing families with intuitive and secure services to ensure a
digital communication between peers might present an effective
means to ensure social exchange between children and reduce
parents’ stress. Eventually, such services might also be helpful
for parents of pre-school-aged children as these have more
difficulties with the handling of digital communication tools. September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 17 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. we encourage scholars to explore this data and test directed
hypotheses using this source. our findings hint toward the importance of public playgrounds,
parks, and sports facilities for families’ well-being in times of
regulations. Instead, granting temporary controlled access for
families with young children may be an efficient tool to reduce the
stress levels of children with otherwise limited access to playing
grounds and space. Further, our data were not optimal for the investigation of
differences between countries. That is, we only obtained sufficient
participants (n > 20) from four countries (i.e., Germany, Iran,
UK, and USA; Centre for Multilevel Modelling, 2021). Limitations As noted above, the cross-sectional design of the current study
hinders firm conclusions about the direction of the detected
associations. Longitudinal or experimental studies are needed to
understand which coping strategies families used during social
distancing regulations, which of them were proven useful, and
which of them were maladaptive. It has to be noted that we did not assess reports of children’s
stress directly but relied on the evaluation of parents, which
were assessed with one item only. We chose this approach
as it was more convenient and allowed us to assess a larger
sample as parents could complete the survey individually. However, ratings of parents on the psychosocial well-being of
children’s might not be accurate, particularly so if parents are
themselves exposed to increased psychosocial stress in response
to regulations—rendering a close monitoring of the well-being
of their children challenging. The link between parents’ and
children’s stress emphasizes this methodological limitation. The
inclusion of the perspectives of children presents an important
avenue for upcoming research and can reveal more detailed
effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on their psychological
well-being. While the identification of intra-cultural and inter-cultural
variation in parents’ and children’s stress is important to gain
a better grasp of the psychological correlates of governmental
regulations during the pandemic, more targeted research is
needed to include more diverse and globally representative
participants. Comparing societies converging in some aspects
(i.e., individualism) but not others (i.e., severity of regulations)
may be helpful to tease apart the drivers of variation on a country
level (Norenzayan and Heine, 2005). One limitation regarding the statistical approach of the
current study in combination with its explorative nature is
the inclusion of diverse predictors into the models but their
interactions were not explored. While such an assessment was
beyond the scope of the current investigation, a focus on
selective interactions in the current data set may offer fruitful
insights to learn more about familiar risk constellations in times
of regulations. Also, the analysis of subgroups might reveal
interesting insights (e.g., families with children from both age
groups). Our data can be retrieved online (osf.io/r84ca/), and School-Aged Children In addition to the abovementioned effect, our data suggest a
negative link between the stringency of the COVID-19 regulation
and school-aged children’s stress. That is, higher stringency went
along with less stress. This finding contradicts our predictions
and points to the need for more detailed assessments of both
children’s stress and regulations. Event-based sampling strategies
might be useful to assess the impact of specific regulations on
children’s stress. Pre-School-Aged Children As such, one
can assume different effects on families’ stress in such regions
and should be careful generalizing from our findings without
further data. Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org REFERENCES the COVID-19 pandemic: a cross-sectional survey of UK Adults. medRxiv
[preprint]. 1–21. doi: 10.1101/2020.04.01.20050039 the COVID-19 pandemic: a cross-sectional survey of UK Adults. medRxiv
[preprint]. 1–21. doi: 10.1101/2020.04.01.20050039 Agberotimi, S. F., Akinsola, O. S., Oguntayo, R., and Olaseni, A. O. (2020). Interactions between socioeconomic status and mental health outcomes in
the nigerian context amid COVID-19 pandemic: a comparative study. Front. Psychol. 11:559819. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.559819 Bates, D., Maechler, M., and Bolker, B. (2017). lme4: Linear Mixed-Effects Models
Using “Eigen” and S4 Classes. R Package Version 1.1.15. Bavel, J. J. V., Baicker, K., Boggio, P. S., Capraro, V., Cichocka, A., Cikara, M., et al. (2020). Using social and behavioural science to support COVID-19 pandemic
response. Nat. Hum. Behav. 4, 1–12. doi: 10.1038/s41562-020-0884-z Aghili, S. M., and Arbabi, M. (2020). The COVID-19 pandemic and the health care
providers; what does it mean psychologically? Adv. J. Emerg. Med. 4, e63–e63. doi: 10.22114/ajem.v4i2s.419 Brooks, S. K., Webster, R. K., Smith, L. E., Woodland, L., Wessely, S.,
Greenberg, N., et al. (2020). The psychological impact of quarantine and
how to reduce it: rapid review of the evidence. Lancet 395, 912–920. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30460-8 Ali, S., Asaria, M., and Stranges, S. (2020). COVID-19 and inequality:
are
we
all
in
this
together? Can. J. Public
Health
111,
415–416. doi: 10.17269/s41997-020-00351-0 Brown, S. M., Doom, J. R., Lechuga-Peña, S., Watamura,
S. E., and
Koppels, T. (2020). Stress and parenting during the global COVID-19
pandemic. Child Abuse Negl. 110(Pt 2):104699. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2020.1
04699 Alt, C., Gedon, B., Hubert, S., Hüsken, K., and Lippert, K. (2018). DJI-
Kinderbetreuungsreport (2018): Inanspruchnahme und Bedarfe bei Kindern
bis
14
Jahre
aus
Elternperspektive–ein
Bundesländervergleich. Munich:
Deutsches
Jugendinstitut
(DJI). Available
online
at:
https://www.dji. de/veroeffentlichungen/literatursuche/detailansicht/literatur/27356-dji-
kinderbetreuungsreport-2018.html Campbell, A. M. (2020). An increasing risk of family violence during the Covid-19
pandemic: strengthening community collaborations to save lives. Forensic Sci. Int. Rep. 2:100089. doi: 10.1016/j.fsir.2020.100089 Centre for Multilevel Modelling (2021). Sample Sizes for Multilevel Models. Available
online
at:
http://www.bristol.ac.uk/cmm/learning/multilevel-
models/samples.html (accessed August 14, 2021). Amadasun, S. (2021). From coronavirus to ‘hunger virus’: mapping the urgency of
social work response amid COVID-19 pandemic in Africa. Int. Soc. Work 64,
444–448. doi: 10.1177/0020872820959366 Arslan, R. C., Tata, C. S., and Walther, M. P. (2018). formr: A Study Framework
Allowing for Automated Feedback Generation and Complex Longitudinal
Experience Sampling Studies Using R. (version v0.18.3). Available online at:
https://zenodo.org/record/3229668 (accessed May 27, 2019). Chen,
E.,
and
Miller,
G. E. (2013). ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank all families who participated in the study. Special
thanks to Shahrzad Sheibani, Saeed Mirzaee, and Hasan Ali
Beigloo for sharing the questionnaire in Iran and Paul Buder and
Sebastian Vogel for supporting data acquisition in Germany. We
further want to thank Katharina Haberl for her valuable feedback
in the piloting phase. ETHICS STATEMENT the first lockdown phase of the coronavirus pandemic in
2020. We documented that families’ stress varied substantially
during COVID-19 regulations, pointing to the importance
of individual factors and the eco-social contexts surrounding
these families. Ethical review and approval was not required for the study on
human participants in accordance with the local legislation and
institutional requirements. The patients/participants provided
their written informed consent to participate in this study. Ethical review and approval was not required for the study on
human participants in accordance with the local legislation and
institutional requirements. The patients/participants provided
their written informed consent to participate in this study. Regulations were not stressful for all, but most families, and
personal values concerning openness, self-enhancement, self-
transcendence, and conservation were linked to the reported
stress levels. We found parents raising both pre-school- and
school-aged children to be at particular risk of suffering from
psychosocial stress during limited access to and closures of
institutionalized daycare or elementary schools. For children,
media consumption and physical activity seem to be important
to regulate families’ stress. For school-aged children, peer
contact via digital means may offer a valuable resource to
buffer stress. SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL The Supplementary Material for this article can be found
online
at:
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg. 2021.645266/full#supplementary-material The datasets presented in this study can be found in online
repositories. The names of the repository/repositories and
accession number(s) can be found below: https://osf.io/r84ca/. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS TT, RS, LS, and NS conceptualized the study and planned
data acquisition. NA supported study conceptualization and
data acquisition in Iran. TT, RS, and NS conducted the formal
analysis and wrote the first draft of the manuscript. LS and
NA commented on the manuscript. LS and TT curated the
data. All authors contributed to the article and approved the
submitted version. Across the globe, countries are bracing themselves against
new
waves
of
the
COVID-19
pandemic,
with
potential
impediments for young families throughout the year 2021
and
beyond. We
hope
that
the
current
study
informs
scholars and policymakers on the manifold correlations of
psychological well-being of parents and children during COVID-
19 regulations and that it helps to provide targeted support
to families. Conclusion Our investigation provides explorative insights into the correlates
of parents’ and children’s psychosocial stress throughout September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 18 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. REFERENCES Examining the impact
of COVID-19 on parental stress: a study of foster parents. Child Adolesc. Soc. Work J. 1–10. doi: 10.1007/s10560-020-00725-w. [Epub ahead of print]. Golberstein, E., Wen, H., and Miller, B. F. (2020). Coronavirus disease 2019
(COVID-19) and mental health for children and adolescents. JAMA Pediatr. 174, 819–820. doi: 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2020.1456 Mo, Y., Deng, L., Zhang, L., Lang, Q., Liao, C., Wang, N., et al. (2020). Work
stress among Chinese nurses to support Wuhan in fighting against COVID-19
epidemic. J. Nurs. Manage. 28, 1002–1009. doi: 10.1111/jonm.13014 Hale, T., Webster, S., Petherick, A., Phillips, T., and Kira, B. (2020). Oxford COVID-
19 Government Response Tracker, Blavatnik School of Government. Available
online at: https://covidtracker.bsg.ox.ac.uk/ (accessed April 28, 2020). Moscardino, U., Dicataldo, R., Roch, M., Carbone, M., and Mammarella, I. C. (2021). Parental stress during COVID-19: a brief report on the role of
distance education and family resources in an Italian sample. Curr. Psychol. 1–4. doi: 10.1007/s12144-021-01454-8. [Epub ahead of print]. Hartshorne, J. K., Huang, Y. T., Lucio Paredes, P. M., Oppenheimer, K., Robbins, P. T., and Velasco, M. D. (2021). Screen time as an index of family distress. Curr. Res. Behav. Sci. 2:100023. doi: 10.1016/j.crbeha.2021.100023 Heim,
E.,
Maercker,
A.,
and
Boer,
D. (2019). Value
orientations
and
mental health: a theoretical review. Transcult. Psychiatry 56, 449–470. doi: 10.1177/1363461519832472 Norenzayan,
A.,
and
Heine,
S. J. (2005). Psychological
universals:
what are they and how can we know? Psychol. Bull. 131, 763–784. doi: 10.1037/0033-2909.131.5.763 Henrich, J., Heine, S. J., and Norenzayan, A. (2010). The weirdest people in the
world? Behav. Brain Sci. 33, 61–83. doi: 10.1017/S0140525X0999152X Parks-Leduc, L., Feldman, G., and Bardi, A. (2015). Personality traits and
personal values: a meta-analysis. Personal. Soc. Psychol. Rev. 19, 3–29. doi: 10.1177/1088868314538548 Hilbert, M. (2020). Into the Wild! Greening and Pleasure as Predictors of
Psychological Well-Being After a Recreational Walk. in (Cyprus). Available
online
at: http://www.eaohp.org/uploads/1/1/0/2/11022736/2018_book_of_
proceedings.pdf (accessed August 14, 2021). Petitclerc, A., Côté, S., Doyle, O., Burchinal, M., Herba, C., Zachrisson, H. D.,
et al. (2017). Who uses early childhood education and care services? Comparing
socioeconomic selection across five western policy contexts. Int. J. Child Care
Educ. Policy 11:3. doi: 10.1186/s40723-017-0028-8 Hofstede, G. (2011). Dimensionalizing cultures: the hofstede model in context. Online Read. Psychol. Cult. 2, 2–26. doi: 10.9707/2307-0919.1014 Pierce, M., Hope, H., Ford, T., Hatch, S., Hotopf, M., John, A., et al. (2020). REFERENCES socioeconomic
status
and
health:
mediating and moderating factors. Annu. Rev. Clin. Psychol. 9, 723–749. doi: 10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-050212-185634 Cheng,
C.,
and
Song,
S. (2020). How
early-career
researchers
are
navigating
the
COVID-19
Pandemic. Mol. Plant
13,
1229–1230. doi: 10.1016/j.molp.2020.07.018 Atchison, C. J., Bowman, L., Vrinten, C., Redd, R., Pristera, P., Eaton, J. W., et al. (2020). Perceptions and behavioural responses of the general public during September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 19 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. Chung, S. K. G., Lanier, P., and Wong, P. (2020). Mediating effects of
parental stress on harsh parenting and parent-child relationship during
coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic in Singapore. J. Fam. Viol. 1–12. doi: 10.1007/s10896-020-00200-1. [Epub ahead of print]. Janssen, L. H. C., Kullberg, M.-L. J., Verkuil, B., Zwieten, N. van, Wever, M. C. M., Houtum, L. A. E. M. van, et al. (2020). Does the COVID-19 pandemic
impact parents’ and adolescents’ well-being? An EMA-study on daily affect and
parenting. PLoS ONE 15:e0240962. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0240962 Dehning, J., Zierenberg, J., Spitzner, F. P., Wibral, M., Neto, J. P., Wilczek,
M., et al. (2020). Inferring change points in the spread of COVID-
19
reveals
the
effectiveness
of
interventions. Science
369:eabb9789. doi: 10.1126/science.abb9789 Jay, J., Bor, J., Nsoesie, E. O., Lipson, S. K., Jones, D. K., Galea, S., et al. (2020). Neighbourhood income and physical distancing during the COVID-
19 pandemic in the United States. Nat. Hum. Behav. 4, 1294–1302. doi: 10.1038/s41562-020-00998-2 Jentsch, B., and Schnock, B. (2020). Child welfare in the midst of the coronavirus
pandemic—emerging evidence from Germany. Child. Abuse Negl. 110(Pt
2):104716. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2020.104716 Feierabend, S., Rathgeb, T., Kheredmand, H., and Glöckler, S. (2020). JIM-Studie
2020 - Jugend, Information, Medien. Medienpädagogischer Forschungsverbund
Südwest. Available online
at: https://www.mpfs.de/studien/jim-studie/2020/
(accessed August 14, 2021). Jiao, W. Y., Wang, L. N., Liu, J., Fang, S. F., Jiao, F. Y., Pettoello-Mantovani,
M., et al. (2020). Behavioral and emotional disorders in children during the
covid-19 epidemic. J. Pediatr. 221, 264–266.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.jpeds.2020.03.013 (
g
)
Field, A. (2005). Discovering Statistics using SPSS. London: SAGE Publications. 2005). Discovering Statistics using SPSS. London: SAGE Publicatio Fiese, B. H., Tomcho, T. J., Douglas, M., Josephs, K., Poltrock, S., and Baker,
T. (2002). A review of 50 years of research on naturally occurring family
routines and rituals: cause for celebration? J. Fam. Psychol. 16, 381–390. doi: 10.1037/0893-3200.16.4.381 Katz, C., Priolo Filho, S. REFERENCES R., Korbin, J., Bérubé, A., Fouché, A., Haffejee, S., et al. (2020). Child maltreatment in the time of the COVID-19 pandemic: a proposed
global framework on research, policy and practice Child. Abuse Negl. 116(Pt
2):104824. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2020.104824 Forbes,
L. K.,
Lamar,
M. R.,
Speciale,
M.,
and
Donovan,
C. (2021). Mothers’ and fathers’ parenting attitudes during COVID-19. Curr. Psychol. doi: 10.1007/s12144-021-01605-x. [Epub ahead of print]. Kim, H. S., Sherman, D. K., and Updegraff, J. A. (2016). Fear of ebola: the influence
of collectivism on xenophobic threat responses. Psychol. Sci. 27, 935–944. doi: 10.1177/0956797616642596 Forstmeier, W., and Schielzeth, H. (2011). Cryptic multiple hypotheses testing in
linear models: overestimated effect sizes and the winner’s curse. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 65, 47–55. doi: 10.1007/s00265-010-1038-5 Kitsaras, G., Goodwin, M., Allan, J., Kelly, M. P., and Pretty, I. A. (2018). Bedtime routines child wellbeing & development. BMC Public Health 18:386. doi: 10.1186/s12889-018-5290-3 Fox, J., and Weisberg, S. (2011). An R Companion to Applied Regression. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage. Available online at: http://socserv.socsci.mcmaster.ca/jfox/
Books/Companion (accessed May 17, 2020). Maaravi, Y., Levy, A., Gur, T., Confino, D., and Segal, S. (2021). “The
tragedy of the commons”: how individualism and collectivism affected
the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic. Front. Public Health 9:627559. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2021.627559 Galbraith, N., Boyda, D., McFeeters, D., and Hassan, T. (2020). The mental
health of doctors during the COVID-19 pandemic. BJPsych. Bull. 45, 1–4. doi: 10.1192/bjb.2020.44 Marazziti, D., Pozza, A., Di Giuseppe, M., and Conversano, C. (2020). The
psychosocial impact of COVID-19 pandemic in Italy: a lesson for mental health
prevention in the first severely hit European country. Psychol. Trauma Theory
Res. Pract. Policy 12, 531–533. doi: 10.1037/tra0000687 j
Gelfand, M. J., Jackson, J. C., Pan, X., Nau, D., Pieper, D., Denison, E., et al. (2021). The relationship between cultural tightness–looseness and COVID-
19 cases and deaths: a global analysis. Lancet Planet. Health 5, E135–E144. doi: 10.1016/S2542-5196(20)30301-6 Martikainen, S., Pesonen, A.-K., Lahti, J., Heinonen, K., Feldt, K., Pyhälä, R.,
et al. (2013). Higher levels of physical activity are associated with lower
hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical axis reactivity to psychosocial stress in
children. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab. 98, E619–E627. doi: 10.1210/jc.2012-3745 Gibson, E. M., Bennett, F. C., Gillespie, S. M., Güler, A. D., Gutmann, D. H., Halpern, C. H., et al. (2020). How support of early career researchers
can reset science in the post-COVID19 World. Cell 181, 1445–1449. doi: 10.1016/j.cell.2020.05.045 Miller, J. J., Cooley, M. E., and Mihalec-Adkins, B. P. (2020). REFERENCES Mental health before and during the COVID-19 pandemic: a longitudinal
probability sample survey of the UK population. Lancet Psychiatry 7, 883–892. doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366(20)30308-4 Hofstede, G. (2021). Hofstede Insights. Available online at: https://www.hofstede-
insights.com/product/compare-countries/ (accessed June 25, 2021). Hothorn, T., Bretz, F., and Westfall, P. (2008). Simultaneous inference in general
parametric models. Biom. J. 50, 346–363. doi: 10.1002/bimj.200810425 Poulain, T., Meigen, C., Sobek, C., Ober, P., Igel, U., Körner, A., et al. (2021). Loss of childcare and classroom teaching during the Covid-19-
related lockdown in spring 2020: a longitudinal study on consequences
on leisure behavior and schoolwork at home. PLoS ONE 16:e0247949. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0247949 Huang, Y., and Zhao, N. (2020). Generalized anxiety disorder, depressive
symptoms
and
sleep
quality
during
COVID-19
outbreak
in
China:
a
web-based
cross-sectional
survey. Psychiatry
Res. 288:112954. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2020.112954 Huebener, M., Waights, S., Spiess, C. K., Siegel, N. A., and Wagner, G. G. (2021). Parental well-being in times of Covid-19 in Germany. Rev. Econ. Househ. 19,
91–122. doi: 10.1007/s11150-020-09529-4 Power,
K. (2020). The
COVID-19
pandemic
has
increased
the
care
burden of women and families. Sustain. Sci. Pract. Policy 16, 67–73. doi: 10.1080/15487733.2020.1776561 September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 20 Families’ Stress During COVID-19 Lockdowns Toppe et al. R Core Team (2018). R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing. Available online
at: https://www.R-project.org/ (accessed August 14, 2021). Staniscuaski, F., Kmetzsch, L., Soletti, R. C., Reichert, F., Zandonà, E., Ludwig, Z. M. C., et al. (2021). Gender, race and parenthood impact academic productivity
during the COVID-19 pandemic: from survey to action. Front. Psychol. 12:663252. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.663252 Ravens-Sieberer, U., Kaman, A., Erhart, M., Devine, J., Schlack, R., and Otto, C. (2021). Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on quality of life and mental health
in children and adolescents in Germany. Eur. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry 1–11. doi: 10.1007/s00787-021-01726-5 Termini, C. M., and Traver, D. (2020). Impact of COVID-19 on early
career scientists: an optimistic guide for the future. BMC Biol. 18:95. doi: 10.1186/s12915-020-00821-4 Volk, A. A., Brazil, K. J., Franklin-Luther, P., Dane, A. V., and Vaillancourt,
T. (2021). The influence of demographics and personality on COVID-
19
coping
in
young
adults. Personal. Individ. Differ. 168:110398. doi: 10.1016/j.paid.2020.110398 Rehman, U., Shahnawaz, M. G., Khan, N. H., Kharshiing, K. D., Khursheed,
M., Gupta, K., et al. (2021). Depression, anxiety and stress among indians
in times of Covid-19 lockdown. Community Ment. REFERENCES Health J. 57, 42–48. doi: 10.1007/s10597-020-00664-x Roccas, S., Sagiv, L., Schwartz, S. H., and Knafo, A. (2002). The big five
personality factors and personal values. Pers. Soc. Psychol. Bull. 28, 789–801. doi: 10.1177/0146167202289008 Wilson Van Voorhis, C. R., and Morgan, B. L. (2007). understanding power and
rules of thumb for determining sample sizes. Tutor. Quant. Methods Psychol. 3,
43–50. doi: 10.20982/tqmp.03.2.p043 Roccella, M. (2020). Children and Coronavirus Infection (Covid-19): what to tell
children to avoid Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Open Pediatr. Med. J. 10, 1–2. doi: 10.2174/1874309902010010001 Zaka, A., Shamloo, S. E., Fiorente, P., and Tafuri, A. (2020). COVID-19
pandemic as a watershed moment: a call for systematic psychological
health care for frontline medical staff. J. Health Psychol. 25, 883-887. doi: 10.1177/1359105320925148 Rodriguez-Ayllon, M., Cadenas-Sánchez, C., Estévez-López, F., Muñoz, N. E.,
Mora-Gonzalez, J., Migueles, J. H., et al. (2019). Role of physical activity
and sedentary behavior in the mental health of preschoolers, children and
adolescents: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Med. 49, 1383–1410. doi: 10.1007/s40279-019-01099-5 Zelman, J. J., and Ferro, M. A. (2018). The parental stress scale: psychometric
properties in families of children with chronic health conditions. Fam. Relat. 67, 240–252. doi: 10.1111/fare.12306 Zhang, S. X., Wang, Y., Rauch, A., and Wei, F. (2020). Unprecedented disruptions
of lives and work: health, distress and life satisfaction of working adults in
China one month into the COVID-19 outbreak. Psychiatry Res. 288:112958. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2020.112958 Röhr, S., Müller, F., Jung, F., Apfelbacher, C., Seidler, A., and Riedel-
Heller, S. G. (2020). Psychosoziale Folgen von Quarantänemaßnahmen bei
schwerwiegenden Coronavirus-Ausbrüchen: ein Rapid Review. Psychiatr. Prax. 47, 179–189. doi: 10.1055/a-1159-5562 Zhou, S.-J., Zhang, L.-G., Wang, L.-L., Guo, Z.-C., Wang, J.-Q., Chen, J.-C., et al. (2020). Prevalence and socio-demographic correlates of psychological health
problems in Chinese adolescents during the outbreak of COVID-19. Eur. Child
Adolesc. Psychiatry 29, 749–758. doi: 10.1007/s00787-020-01541-4 Rubin, K. H., Bukowski, W. M., and Parker, J. G. (2007). “Peer interactions,
relationships, and groups,” in Handbook of Child Psychology, eds W. Damon, and R. M. Lerner (Alanta, GA: American Cancer Society). doi: 10.1002/9780470147658.chpsy0310 Rubin, K. H., Coplan, R. J., Chen, X., Buskirk, A. A., and Wojslawowicz, J. C. (2005). “Peer Relationships in Childhood,” in Developmental Science: An
Advanced Textbook, eds. M. H. Bornstein and M. E. Lamb (New Jersey, US:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers), 469–512. Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 REFERENCES Conflict of Interest: The authors declare that the research was conducted in the
absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a
potential conflict of interest. Schwartz, S. H. (1992). “Universals in the content and structure of values:
Theoretical advances and empirical tests in 20 countries,” in Advances in
Experimental Social Psychology, ed M. P. Zanna (San Diego: Academic Press). doi: 10.1016/S0065-2601(08)60281-6 Publisher’s Note: All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors
and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of
the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in
this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or
endorsed by the publisher. Schwartz, S. H. (2003). “A proposal for measuring value orientations across
nations,” in Questionnaire Development Package of the European Social
Survey, 259–319. Available online at: http://www.europeansocialsurvey.org/
docs/methodology/core_ess_questionnaire/ESS_core_questionnaire_human_
values.pdf (accessed August 14, 2021). Copyright © 2021 Toppe, Stengelin, Schmidt, Amini and Schuhmacher. This is an
open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted,
provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the
original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic
practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply
with these terms. p
g
Schwartz, S. H. (2012). An overview of the Schwartz theory of basic values. Online
Read. Psychol. Cult. 2, 2–20. doi: 10.9707/2307-0919.1116 Schwartz, S. H. (2012). An overview of the Schwartz theory of basic values. Online
Read. Psychol. Cult. 2, 2–20. doi: 10.9707/2307-0919.1116 Schwartz, S. H., and Bilsky, W. (1990). Toward a theory of the universal content
and structure of values: extensions and cross-cultural replications. J. Pers. Soc. Psychol. 58, 878–891. doi: 10.1037/0022-3514.58.5.878 Schwartz, S. H., and Bilsky, W. (1990). Toward a theory of the universal content
and structure of values: extensions and cross-cultural replications. J. Pers. Soc. Psychol. 58, 878–891. doi: 10.1037/0022-3514.58.5.878 September 2021 | Volume 12 | Article 645266 Frontiers in Psychology | www.frontiersin.org 21
|
https://openalex.org/W3200762904
|
https://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/1721.1/141441/2/s41467-021-25705-1.pdf
|
English
| null |
Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn
|
Nature communications
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 12,993
|
MIT Open Access Articles
Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the
surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn
The MIT Faculty has made this article openly available. Please share
how this access benefits you. Your story matters.
tation: Han, Minyong, Inoue, Hisashi, Fang, Shiang, John, Caolan, Ye, Linda et al. 2021.
Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal
eSn." Nature Communications, 12 (1).
s Published: 10.1038/S41467-021-25705-1
ublisher: Springer Science and Business Media LLC
ersistent URL: https://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/141441
ersion: Final published version: final published article, as it appeared in a journal, conferenc
roceedings, or other formally published context
erms of use: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license MIT Open Access Articles
Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the
surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn
The MIT Faculty has made this article openly available. Please share
how this access benefits you. Your story matters. Citation: Han, Minyong, Inoue, Hisashi, Fang, Shiang, John, Caolan, Ye, Linda et al. 2021. "Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal
FeSn." Nature Communications, 12 (1). As Published: 10.1038/S41467-021-25705-1
Publisher: Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Persistent URL: https://hdl.handle.net/1721.1/141441
Version: Final published version: final published article, as it appeared in a journal, conferen
proceedings, or other formally published context
Terms of use: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license MIT Open Access Articles The MIT Faculty has made this article openly available. Please share
how this access benefits you. Your story matters. Version: Final published version: final published article, as it appeared in a journal, conference
proceedings, or other formally published context Version: Final published version: final published article, as it appeared in a journal, conference
proceedings, or other formally published context Terms of use: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license Terms of use: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license 1 Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA. 2 Frontier Research Institute for Interdisciplinary Sciences and
Institute for Materials Research, Tohoku University, Miyagi, Japan. 3 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Center for Materials Theory, Rutgers University,
Piscataway, NJ, USA. 4 National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, LANL, Los Alamos, NM, USA. 5 National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, Tallahassee, FL,
USA. 6 Central Department of Physics, Tribhuvan University, Kirtipur, Kathmandu, Nepal. 7 Leibniz Institute for Solid State and Materials Research, IFW
Dresden, Dresden, Germany. 8 Samsung Advanced Institute of Technology (SAIT), Suwon-si, Gyeonggi-do, Korea. 9 Department of Physics, Harvard
University, Cambridge, MA, USA. 10Present address: National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology, Tsukuba, Japan. 11Present address:
Department of Applied Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA. 12Present address: Department of Physics, Toho University, Chiba, Japan. 13These
authors contributed equally: Minyong Han, Hisashi Inoue. ✉email: checkelsky@mit.edu ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications Results Planar tunneling spectroscopy measurements. Epitaxial thin
films of FeSn were deposited on Nb:STO with varying Nb con-
centrations (x = 0.05, 0.2, 0.5, 0.7 wt.%) by MBE37 (see Methods). X-ray diffraction measurements confirmed the formation of (001)
oriented FeSn films with in-plane crystallographic orientation
epitaxially locked to that of Nb:STO (see Supplementary Note 3,
20). Cross-sectional transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and
electron energy loss spectroscopy measurements corroborate that
the films are highly crystalline down to the interface, which itself
is comprised of the Fe kagome layer and Ti-rich termination layer
of Nb:STO (see Supplementary Note 21). The Neel temperature
of the films was found to be consistent with that of bulk single-
crystal FeSn, which exhibits a type-II antiferromagnetic spin
structure35–37. When the two materials come in contact, a
depletion layer is formed at the Schottky interface, creating an
insulating barrier useful for tunneling measurements38–40. Fig-
ure 1c shows a schematic of the measurement setup in the three-
terminal configuration, consisting of the tunnel (middle), current
(right), and reference (left) electrodes. Upon applying a voltage
on the tunnel electrode, a tunnel current flows between the tunnel x (wt. %) Fig. 1 Tunneling measurements across FeSn/Nb:STO heterointerfaces. a Fig. 1 Tunneling measurements across FeSn/Nb:STO heterointerfaces. a
Top view of the Fe kagome layer (Fe3Sn). Dashed lines delineate the
crystallographic unit cell. b Crystal structure of FeSn, consisting of kagome
layers (K) and Sn honeycomb (stanene) layers (S) stacked along the c-
direction. c Schematic of the three-terminal planar Schottky tunneling
measurement setup. AC (VAC) and DC (VDC) voltages are applied onto the
tunneling electrode and the junction voltage (VJ) and the tunnel current (I)
are measured. d Current-voltage (I–V) characteristics of FeSn/Nb:STO
junctions with different Nb concentrations, all measured at temperature
T = 2 K. e Nb concentration-dependent zero bias differential tunneling
conductance (dI/dV(VJ = 0 V)) at T = 2 K. Top view of the Fe kagome layer (Fe3Sn). Dashed lines delineate the
crystallographic unit cell. b Crystal structure of FeSn, consisting of kagome
layers (K) and Sn honeycomb (stanene) layers (S) stacked along the c-
direction. c Schematic of the three-terminal planar Schottky tunneling
measurement setup. AC (VAC) and DC (VDC) voltages are applied onto the
tunneling electrode and the junction voltage (VJ) and the tunnel current (I)
are measured. d Current-voltage (I–V) characteristics of FeSn/Nb:STO
junctions with different Nb concentrations, all measured at temperature
T = 2 K. Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the
surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn One way to design a system with interaction
energy larger than the kinetic energy of individual constituents is
to confine electrons into a flat, dispersionless band in momentum
space. Historically, flat bands have been realized when inherently
localized atomic orbitals constitute a periodic lattice (i.e., f-elec-
tron bands)1,2 or when magnetic field traps electrons to quantized
cyclotron orbits (i.e., Landau levels in quantum Hall phases)3,4. More recently, there has been a growing interest in constructing a
generalized lattice model that can universally produce flat bands
through destructive phase interference of electronic hopping,
even in the absence of compact atomic orbitals or high magnetic
field5–12. Though real crystals inevitably harbor non-zero inter-layer
couplings (i.e., orbital hybridization, charge transfer, magnetic
interaction), it has been pointed out from a number of three-
dimensional systems that their surfaces offer a unique venue that
connects to the character of their parent two-dimensional unit
cells. For instance, from the surface of bismuth single crystals, a
two-dimensional electron gas and quantum Hall wavefunction
imprinting the crystallographic symmetry of a single bismuthene
layer have been observed27–31. In addition, the Chern insulating
phase has been predicted at the kagome-terminated surface of
Cs2LiMn3F12, a ferromagnetic insulator containing completely
filled kagome-derived bands. In the absence of charge-donating
adlayers, the local chemical potential of the bare kagome network
at the surface was expected to cross the Dirac mass gap. The
Chern insulating phase has also been realized but through a
different mechanism at the surface of an antiferromagnetic
topological insulator32–34. There, the local magnetic field distinct
from the global mean field stabilized a distinguished phase at the
surface. The kagome lattice, a two-dimensional hexagonal network of
corner-sharing triangles (Fig. 1a), is one example of a lattice
model that accommodates a flat band. In addition, the D6 point
group symmetry in the kagome lattice, similar to graphene,
engenders a linearly dispersing Dirac band, which with the
inclusion of spin-orbit coupling and non-zero magnetization
hosts a topologically nontrivial Chern gap13–20. Following dec-
ades of theoretical predictions, recent angle-resolved photoemis-
sion spectroscopy measurements on transition metal kagome
compounds have shown that certain features in the two-
dimensional electronic structure of a single kagome layer man-
ifest largely unperturbed in their three-dimensional electronic
structures13,21,22. Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the
surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn The kagome lattice has long been regarded as a theoretical framework that connects lattice
geometry to unusual singularities in electronic structure. Transition metal kagome com-
pounds have been recently identified as a promising material platform to investigate the long-
sought electronic flat band. Here we report the signature of a two-dimensional flat band at
the surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn by means of planar tunneling spectro-
scopy. Employing a Schottky heterointerface of FeSn and an n-type semiconductor Nb-doped
SrTiO3, we observe an anomalous enhancement in tunneling conductance within a finite
energy range of FeSn. Our first-principles calculations show this is consistent with a spin-
polarized flat band localized at the ferromagnetic kagome layer at the Schottky interface. The
spectroscopic capability to characterize the electronic structure of a kagome compound at a
thin film heterointerface will provide a unique opportunity to probe flat band induced phe-
nomena in an energy-resolved fashion with simultaneous electrical tuning of its properties. Furthermore, the exotic surface state discussed herein is expected to manifest as peculiar
spin-orbit torque signals in heterostructure-based spintronic devices. 1 Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA. 2 Frontier Research Institute for Interdisciplinary Sciences and
Institute for Materials Research, Tohoku University, Miyagi, Japan. 3 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Center for Materials Theory, Rutgers University,
Piscataway, NJ, USA. 4 National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, LANL, Los Alamos, NM, USA. 5 National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, Tallahassee, FL,
USA. 6 Central Department of Physics, Tribhuvan University, Kirtipur, Kathmandu, Nepal. 7 Leibniz Institute for Solid State and Materials Research, IFW
Dresden, Dresden, Germany. 8 Samsung Advanced Institute of Technology (SAIT), Suwon-si, Gyeonggi-do, Korea. 9 Department of Physics, Harvard
University, Cambridge, MA, USA. 10Present address: National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology, Tsukuba, Japan. 11Present address:
Department of Applied Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA. 12Present address: Department of Physics, Toho University, Chiba, Japan. 13These
authors contributed equally: Minyong Han, Hisashi Inoue. ✉email: checkelsky@mit.edu 1 TURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 W kagome
compounds
with
sufficiently
large
inter-layer
hybridization23–26, suggestive of the importance of strong elec-
tronic two-dimensionality in connecting to the original lattice
model. W
hen the electron–electron interaction becomes the
dominant energy scale in a condensed matter system,
a variety of interaction-driven quantum phases are
expected to arise. Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the
surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn However, it was also observed that the physics
of a single kagome layer can be significantly altered in other In this study, we investigate a flat band at the surface of
antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn using planar tunneling
spectroscopy. FeSn consists of an alternating stack of two-
dimensional Fe kagome layers and two-dimensional Sn honey-
comb (stanene) layers (Fig. 1a, b). It is known to develop a type-II
antiferromagnetic order below TN = 365 K, in which the Fe spin
moments align ferromagnetically within a single kagome plane
but antiferromagnetically from those in the neighboring kagome
planes35,36. Along with the magnetic degrees of freedom inter-
weaved therein, its characteristic layered crystal structure makes
FeSn an ideal platform to explore the interplay of the kagome
lattice with the honeycomb lattice at the surface with different
types of atomic terminations. For surface-sensitive spectroscopy,
we used molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) to synthesize epitaxial
films of FeSn on lattice-matched n-type degenerate semi-
conductor Nb-doped SrTiO3 (Nb:STO). Combining tunneling
spectroscopy and first-principles calculations, we find that the
observed signals constitute signatures consistent with a two-
dimensional flat band originating from the spin-polarized surface
kagome-stanene bilayer unit cell. a
-0.2
-0.1
0.0
0.1
0.2
1.5
-1.5
I (mA)
x = 0.7 wt. %
0.5
0.2
0.05
T = 2 K
10
-8
10
-7
10
-6
10
-5
10
-4
dI/dV( VJ = 0 V ) (S)
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
x (wt. %)
T = 2 K
VJ (V)
Fe
Sn
FeSn
(001)
Ti/Au
Nb:SrTiO3 (111)
( x wt. % )
e-
VJ
I
Fe
Sn
a
b
c
K
K
S
5.3 Å
0
Schottky
b
d
c
e
VAC
VDC
VAC+VDC
Fig. 1 Tunneling measurements across FeSn/Nb:STO heterointerfaces. a
Top view of the Fe kagome layer (Fe3Sn). Dashed lines delineate the
crystallographic unit cell. b Crystal structure of FeSn, consisting of kagome
layers (K) and Sn honeycomb (stanene) layers (S) stacked along the c-
direction. c Schematic of the three-terminal planar Schottky tunneling
measurement setup. AC (VAC) and DC (VDC) voltages are applied onto the
tunneling electrode and the junction voltage (VJ) and the tunnel current (I)
are measured. d Current-voltage (I–V) characteristics of FeSn/Nb:STO
junctions with different Nb concentrations, all measured at temperature
T = 2 K. e Nb concentration-dependent zero bias differential tunneling
conductance (dI/dV(VJ = 0 V)) at T = 2 K. Evidence of two-dimensional flat band at the
surface of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn a
Fe
Sn
a
b
c
5.3 Å FeSn
(001)
Ti/Au
Nb:SrTiO3 (111)
( x wt. % )
e-
VJ
I
Schottky
c
VAC
VDC
VAC+VDC a c VJ Fe
Sn
K
K
S
b b -0.2
-0.1
0.0
0.1
0.2
1.5
-1.5
I (mA)
x = 0.7 wt. %
0.5
0.2
0.05
T = 2 K
VJ (V)
0
d d 10
-8
10
-7
10
-6
10
-5
10
-4
dI/dV( VJ = 0 V ) (S)
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
x (wt. %)
T = 2 K
e e ARTICLE ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 and current electrodes across the Schottky barrier. Simulta-
neously, the reference potential with respect to the reference
electrode was measured in order to precisely estimate the junction
voltage VJ. As the tunnel current is determined by the total
number of electronic states which electrons can tunnel into, the
differential tunneling conductance dI/dV encodes the energy-
resolved density of states (DOS) of FeSn overlaid onto a mono-
tonic background signal arising from, e.g., energy-dependent
DOS of the tunnel electrode40–46. We note that in the regime
where the tunnel electrode has a small Fermi energy (i.e.,
EF,electrode < < ∣VJ∣) when VJ < 0 the observed dI/dV is a direct
measure of the intrinsic DOS spectrum (the case we will inves-
tigate primarily here); this is contrary to the case of VJ > 0 where
the absence of electronic states below the electrode’s conduction
band edge can make such a direct analysis more difficult (see
Supplementary Note 23). Scanning tunneling spectroscopy (STS)
studies on bulk single crystals have proven their extreme sensi-
tivity to the local electronic states at the cleaved surface, enabling
atomic termination dependent DOS characterizations47,48. In the
case of Schottky tunneling, the tunneling conductance is expected
to be most sensitive to the bottom-most layer of FeSn at the
Schottky interface with Nb:STO, FeSn, and the Schottky barrier
each serving the role of the tip, sample, and vacuum in STS,
respectively. When TE and TFE are sufficiently suppressed at low T, the dI/
dV spectra reveal an anomalous behavior beyond that expected
for conventional Schottky barriers. Figure 2c, d show the
temperature-dependent dI/dV for negative and positive VJ,
respectively. Although dI/dV over the entire range of VJ decreases
exponentially as T decreases, within the finite range −400 mV <
VJ < −100 mV, the exponential suppression of dI/dV at T > 100
K gives way to an upturn in dI/dV at T < 100 K. This feature is
also manifested as a broad peak in the dI/dV spectra at T = 2 K
(VJ,peak = −250 mV) that eventually broadens and diminishes at
higher T. Qualitatively, this feature can be understood as a
combination of an anomalous enhancement of dI/dV in the
negative bias range with the conventional rectifying behavior of
Schottky diodes in the positive bias range. ARTICLE The prominent peak in dI/dV is resolved ~VJ,peak = −180 mV at
T = 2 K for x = 0.7 wt.%, whilst for x = 0.2 wt.%, the feature is
absent. We hypothesize that the 20-fold enhancement of the
overall tunneling conductance from x = 0.2 wt.% to x = 0.7 wt.%
originates from the difference in the depletion layer widths. The
peak in dI/dV at T = 2 K for the x = 0.7 wt.% junction occurs at a
similar energy range as the broad peak in dI/dV for the x = 0.5
wt.% junction (VJ,peak = −250 mV, Fig. 2c), indicating a common
origin of the two conductance anomalies. If originating from a
peak in the DOS of FeSn, it would be expected that the associated
peak feature in dI/dV would become less prominent for junctions
with lower Nb concentrations, as electron tunneling across the
thicker depletion layer involves more inelastic scattering events. This is in fact what is observed as the Nb concentration is
changed from x = 0.7 wt.% to x = 0.2 wt.%. Therefore, we con-
clude that the enhancement in dI/dV at VJ,peak = −180 mV ori-
ginates from a large, narrowly peaked DOS at this energy in FeSn. We point out additionally that Ti-3d t2g-derived conduction
bands of Nb:STO harbor a relatively featureless DOS spectrum in
the energy range of interest here and therefore are not expected to
generate any prominent spectral feature. Although oxygen
vacancies with a few % concentration (below the detectable limit)
may be present in Nb:STO, oxygen-vacancy-induced states typi-
cally occur below the conduction band edge of Nb:STO56–59. The
effects of these states are to broaden the dI/dV features by
inelastic tunneling and potentially give rise to additional dI/dV
peaks in the VJ > 0 range. However, given the current experi-
mental configuration, these defect states inside the bandgap of
Nb:STO are not expected to generate any feature to dI/dV in the
VJ < 0 range (see Supplementary Note 1, 23). Temperature-dependent tunneling in FeSn/Nb:STO (x = 0.5
wt.%). Figure 2a, b show I–V curves and dI/dV spectra, respec-
tively, at different temperatures for the FeSn/Nb:STO (x = 0.5
wt.%) junction (the device micrograph is shown in Fig. 2a inset). ARTICLE The enhancement in
dI/dV at lower T suggests a dominant field emission (FE)
contribution to the tunneling conductance for T < 100 K (Fig. 2f). FE is a resonant process (Einitial = Efinal) that becomes more
pronounced in lower T when thermal band broadening in FeSn
and inelastic scattering events within the tunnel barrier both
diminish. The upturn in dI/dV around VJ,peak = −250 mV for
T < 100 K suggests high DOS concentrated at this energy in FeSn,
manifested more clearly as the FE dominates the tunneling
process. p
y
Figure 1d shows the current-voltage (I–V) characteristics of
FeSn/Nb:STO junctions with different Nb concentrations, all
acquired at temperature T = 2 K. All of the I–V traces show non-
linear behavior, reflecting the tunneling transport process across
these junctions. Typical tunneling resistance of the FeSn/Nb:STO
(x = 0.5 wt.%) junction at T = 2 K and VJ = 0 V was >1 MΩ with
minor variance between different devices. This is much larger
than the 7 Ω resistance observed across the Ti/Nb:STO ohmic
junctions on the same sample (see Supplementary Note 2). These
suggest the presence of a depletion layer at the FeSn/Nb:STO
interface. Figure 1e shows the exponential growth of the zero bias
differential tunneling conductance at T = 2 K for Nb concentra-
tion from x = 0.05 wt.% to x = 0.7 wt.%. We ascribe this to the
cooperative
action
of
increased
carrier
density
(Nd)
and
suppressed dielectric permittivity (ϵ) in highly doped Nb:STO
dramatically shortening the depletion layer width Wd =
ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
2ϵΔΨWF
qNd
q
at the Schottky interface, where q is elementary charge and ΔΨWF
is work function difference between FeSn and Nb:STO49–51. Fermi level pinning and its subsequent screening from Nb-doping
may also be present but represent a negligible contribution
compared with that observed (see Supplementary Note 22). Consistent with our observation, recent studies have shown that
Wd ~ 5 nm in Pt/Nb:STO (x = 0.7 wt.%) Schottky junctions52, in
contrast with Wd > 100 nm in metal/Nb:STO Schottky junctions
with lower Nb concentrations38,44,53,54. Nb concentration-dependent tunneling and surface electronic
structure. To elucidate the origin of the anomaly in dI/dV seen in
Fig. 2, we investigate the tunneling characteristics of two junc-
tions with different Nb concentrations: dI/dV spectra for x = 0.2
wt.% and x = 0.7 wt.% are shown in Fig. 3a and b, respectively. Results e Nb concentration-dependent zero bias differential tunneling
conductance (dI/dV(VJ = 0 V)) at T = 2 K. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 2 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 %
300
200
100
0
T (K)
E > EF
=
0 mV
+ 50
+ 100
+ 150
+ 200
+ 250
+ 300
+ 400
+ 500
+ 600
+ 700
+ 800
+ 450
+ 350
VJ
x = 0.5 wt. %
c
d
e
f FeSn
Nb:STO
High temperature
FE
TE
e-
TFE
VJ,peak
e FeSn
Low temperature
FE
TE
e-
Nb:STO
VJ,peak
TFE
f f Fig. 2 Temperature-dependent tunneling in a x = 0.5 wt.% junction. a I–V characteristics and b dI/dV spectra at different temperatures for the FeSn/
Nb:STO junction with x = 0.5 wt. %. The measurements were taken at T = 2, 25, 50, 75, 100, 125, 150, 200 K. The inset in a is an optical micrograph of the
measuring device. The red arrow in b marks VJ,peak, the position of the broad peak in dI/dV at low temperature. c, d Temperature-dependent dI/dV for
negative and positive VJ for the x = 0.5 wt.% junction. The green-shaded area denotes the region in which dI/dV increases as temperature decreases. e, f
Schematic of the tunneling mechanisms across the Schottky barrier. Non-resonant thermionic emission (TE) and thermionic field emission (TFE) processes
dominate in the high-temperature regime, whereas resonant field emission (FE) process through the barrier dominates in the low-temperature regime. 80
60
40
20
0
-1.5
1.5
4
3
2
1
0
VJ,peak
dI/dV (10 -3
x = 0.2 wt. %
x = 0.7 wt. %
200
150
Longer
Barrier
Shorter
Barrier
S)
VJ (V)
dI/dV (10 -3 S)
-1.0
-0.5
0
0.5
300
200
100
0
T (K)
E
k
a
e
p
)
V
e
(
♦
♦
♦
♦
♦
♦
♦
♦
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
( L = 8 )
( L = 7 )
( L = 6 )
( L = 5 )
Eight-layer slab of AFM FeSn
T = 2 K
x =
0.7 wt. %
E ( = eVJ ) (eV)
0.0
-1.0
1.0
FeSn film
Tunneling
Slab Calculation
Kagome-term. ( L = 1 )
Slab Calculation
Bulk ( L = 4 & 5 )
♦
♦
*
*
x = 0.7 wt. ARTICLE The overall tunneling conductance, as revealed from both I and
dI/dV, gradually increases as T increases, owing to the expo-
nential growth of thermionic emission (TE) and thermionic field
emission (TFE) contributions (Fig. 2e)50,53. This resembles the
behavior of a conventional Schottky junction in which enhanced
thermal activation probability of electrons at high-temperature
boosts the junction current55. We note that TE and TFE are non-
resonant processes (Einitial ≠Efinal, where Einitial and Efinal are the
energy of electrons before and after the tunneling, respectively)
and therefore the resulting broadened dI/dV spectra at high
temperatures obscure fine DOS features of FeSn. In order to directly correlate the features in the tunneling
spectra to those in the DOS of FeSn, we performed first-principles
electronic structure calculations of a slab containing eight
crystallographic unit cells of FeSn (1 ≤L ≤8), where L denotes
the layer index (Fig. 3c, see Methods). Here, we recall that dI/dV
reflects DOS of FeSn for VJ < 0 except for a monotonic TURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 3 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 %
Sn2
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
( L = 4 )
( L = 3 )
( L = 2 )
( L = 1 )
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
0
-1.5
1.5
VJ (V)
0
T =
2 K
T =
2 K
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
dI/dV (10 -3 S)
DOS
(states/unit cell/eV)
4
8
12
16
10
20
0
Slab Calculation
Sn-term. ( L = 8 )
DOS
(states/unit cell/eV)
4
8
12
16
DOS
(states/unit cell/eV)
4
8
12
16
Fig. 3 Tunneling in x = 0.2, 0.7 wt.% junctions. dI/dV spectra at different temperatures for FeSn/Nb:STO junctions with a x = 0.2 wt.% and b x = 0.7
wt.%. The measurements were taken at T = 2, 25, 50, 75, 100, 125, 150, 200 K. Each curve is offset vertically by an equal amount with respect to the T = 2
K trace for clarity. For the x = 0.7 wt.% junction in b, the positions of the peak in dI/dV are marked with diamonds. c Schematic of the eight-layer slab of
antiferromagnetic FeSn. d dI/dV spectrum for the x = 0.7 wt.% junction at T = 2 K. Energy-dependent DOS spectra at e the kagome-terminated surface, f
the Sn-terminated surface, and g the bulk of the eight-layer FeSn slab with the antiferromagnetic spin configuration. The green-shaded box across d–g
denotes the energy window in which the peak feature in dI/dV was observed. Diamonds and asterisks mark the positions of noticeable features that
correlate between d and e. h Temperature-dependent dI/dV peak positions (Epeak) (circles) and corresponding full widths at half maximum (FWHM)
(vertical bar), extracted from b. 80
60
40
20
0
-1.5
1.5
VJ,peak
x = 0.7 wt. %
200
Shorter
Barrier
VJ (V)
dI/dV (10 -3 S)
♦
♦
♦
♦
♦
♦
♦
♦
0
T =
2 K
b 4
3
2
1
0
dI/dV (10 -3
x = 0.2 wt. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 10
-7
10
-6
10
-5
10
-4
10
-3
300
200
100
0
T (K)
=
0 mV
- 50
- 100
- 150
- 200
- 250
- 300
- 400
- 500
- 600
- 700
- 800
- 450
- 350
dI/dV (S)
E < EF
5
4
3
2
1
0
dI/dV (10 -3 S)
-1.5
1.5
200
T =
2 K
VJ,peak
-0.5
0.5
IDC (mA)
-1.5
1.5
VJ (V)
x = 0.5 wt. %
R(0 V, 2 K)
= 4.8 MΩ
200
T = 2 K
FeSn
Nb:STO
High temperature
FE
TE
FeSn
Low temperature
FE
TE
e-
e-
Nb:STO
2 mm
VJ,peak
TFE
TFE
VJ,peak
VJ
x = 0.5 wt. %
VJ (V)
300
200
100
0
T (K)
E > EF
=
0 mV
+ 50
+ 100
+ 150
+ 200
+ 250
+ 300
+ 400
+ 500
+ 600
+ 700
+ 800
+ 450
+ 350
VJ
x = 0.5 wt. %
0
0
a
b
c
d
e
f
Fig. 2 Temperature-dependent tunneling in a x = 0.5 wt.% junction. a I–V characteristics and b dI/dV spectra at different temperatures for the FeSn/
Nb:STO junction with x = 0.5 wt. %. The measurements were taken at T = 2, 25, 50, 75, 100, 125, 150, 200 K. The inset in a is an optical micrograph of the
measuring device. The red arrow in b marks VJ,peak, the position of the broad peak in dI/dV at low temperature. c, d Temperature-dependent dI/dV for
negative and positive VJ for the x = 0.5 wt.% junction. The green-shaded area denotes the region in which dI/dV increases as temperature decreases. e, f
Schematic of the tunneling mechanisms across the Schottky barrier. Non-resonant thermionic emission (TE) and thermionic field emission (TFE) processes
dominate in the high-temperature regime, whereas resonant field emission (FE) process through the barrier dominates in the low-temperature regime. 10
-7
10
-6
10
-5
10
-4
10
-3
300
200
100
0
T (K)
=
0 mV
- 50
- 100
- 150
- 200
- 250
- 300
- 400
- 500
- 600
- 700
- 800
- 450
- 350
dI/dV (S)
E < EF
VJ
x = 0.5 wt. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 %
150
Longer
Barrier
S)
dI/dV (10 -3 S)
-1.5
1.5
VJ (V)
0
T =
2 K
a
b dI/dV (10 -3 Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
( L = 8 )
( L = 7 )
( L = 6 )
( L = 5 )
Eight-layer slab of AFM FeSn
Sn2
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
Fe3Sn
( L = 4 )
( L = 3 )
( L = 2 )
( L = 1 )
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
Sn2
c c Eight-layer slab of AFM FeSn Eight-layer slab of AFM FeSn Fig. 3 Tunneling in x = 0.2, 0.7 wt.% junctions. dI/dV spectra at different temperatures for FeSn/Nb:STO junctions with a x = 0.2 wt.% and b x = 0.7
wt.%. The measurements were taken at T = 2, 25, 50, 75, 100, 125, 150, 200 K. Each curve is offset vertically by an equal amount with respect to the T = 2
K trace for clarity. For the x = 0.7 wt.% junction in b, the positions of the peak in dI/dV are marked with diamonds. c Schematic of the eight-layer slab of
antiferromagnetic FeSn. d dI/dV spectrum for the x = 0.7 wt.% junction at T = 2 K. Energy-dependent DOS spectra at e the kagome-terminated surface, f
the Sn-terminated surface, and g the bulk of the eight-layer FeSn slab with the antiferromagnetic spin configuration. The green-shaded box across d–g
denotes the energy window in which the peak feature in dI/dV was observed. Diamonds and asterisks mark the positions of noticeable features that
correlate between d and e. h Temperature-dependent dI/dV peak positions (Epeak) (circles) and corresponding full widths at half maximum (FWHM)
(vertical bar), extracted from b. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 4 4 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 To gain further insight into the surface flat band, we calculated
the two-dimensional band structure of a ferromagnetic kagome-
stanene bilayer, which constitutes half of the magnetic unit cell of
FeSn (Fig. 4e). The band structure of the ferromagnetic kagome-
stanene
bilayer
reasonably
matches
that
of
the
kagome-
terminated surface (Fig. 4b). It also exhibits a spin-polarized
non-dispersive band (enclosed with the dashed line in Fig. 4e)
that nearly coincides in shape and energy with the surface flat
band in Fig. 4b. The resemblance between the two reflects the
layered crystal structure of FeSn (Fig. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 In addition to peak broadening, the peak position gradually
shifts from VJ,peak = −180 mV at T = 2 K to VJ,peak = −560 mV at
T = 200 K. Though the triangular shape of the tunnel barrier and
non-linear dielectric properties of SrTiO3 (STO) in metal/Nb:STO
Schottky junction is known to displace the energy axis of the
tunneling spectra from the actual DOS spectra by ~10 mV at high
temperature, this is insufficient to explain the large shift of
∣ΔVJ,peak∣= 380 mV (see the model calculation for the tunneling
spectra in Supplementary Note 7, 8, 24). Instead, we hypothesize that
this shift originates from the modulation of the surface band
structure. We examine this more thoroughly in the following sections
by considering spin polarization-dependent band reconstruction. g
g
y
)
Further analyses reveal that the complex interaction of the
kagome
layer
and
the
stanene
layer
under
an
inversion
asymmetric environment has an important influence on the flat
band in the kagome-stanene bilayer. By considering continuous
evolution of band structure in fictitious bilayers with variable
inter-layer spacing zK−S, we find that the bands originally
expected
in
the
kagome
monolayer
limit
(zK−S ≫2.24 Å)
gradually deform into the ones in the kagome-stanene bilayer
(zK−S = 2.24 Å) as zK−S shrinks. In particular, the Fermi velocity
vF of one of the Dirac bands in the monolayer limit decreases by
more than fivefold in the bilayer limit, as a result generating the
dz2 orbital derived bilayer flat band with a Dirac-like crossing
squeezed within the highly flattened dispersion (see Supplemen-
tary Note 13). In case the magnetization vector is along z, spin-
orbit coupling further flattens this band by opening a sizeable gap
ESO ~30 meV at the crossing point, across which significant Berry
curvature is concentrated (see Supplementary Note 14). It is
noteworthy that while vF has diminished dramatically, ESO is still
comparable to that of highly dispersive Dirac bands in the
ferromagnetic kagome metal Fe3Sn2 (~30 meV)13. The regime of
high spin-orbit coupling and strong electronic correlation has
been pointed out as a potential parameter space to blend
nontrivial band topology and interaction-driven quantum phases
into a single material63. The kagome-stanene interaction under an
inversion
asymmetric
environment
proposes an
alternative
pathway to drive highly spin-orbit coupled materials towards
the strong correlation regime. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 With the key ingredients naturally
built-in, surface (or heterointerface) of FeSn, as well as isolated
kagome-stanene bilayer, offers a unique physical platform to
realize novel types of edge modes and correlated flat bands. Surface accommodation of the spin-polarized two-dimensional
flat band. To understand the origin of the DOS peak at the
surface, it is instructive to compare the bulk and surface elec-
tronic structures. Figure 4a shows the band structure of bulk FeSn
in the antiferromagnetic phase. Some of the essential features of
the two-dimensional kagome network appear intact in the three-
dimensional band structure of bulk FeSn, including the Dirac
point at the K-point near E ~ −460 meV and the flat band cen-
tered around E ~ 600 meV (only the bottom band edge visible in
Fig. 4a). The latter was identified from previous studies to have
dxz/dyz and dxy/dx2−y2 orbital character21,22,60,61 and is respon-
sible for the prominent peak in DOS around E ~ 600 meV in
Fig. 3g. Turning to the kagome-terminated surface band structure
(Fig. 4b), near the energy at which the DOS peak is expected, a
highly non-dispersive band is observed (enclosed with the dashed
line in Fig. 4b). The layer-resolved DOS color map (Fig. 4c) also
corroborates the existence of the surface-localized (L = 1) flat
band with high DOS concentrated at that energy and the orbital
projection analysis (Fig. 4d) reveals that the major contribution to
the surface flat band comes from dz2 orbital, distinct from the
orbital character of the bulk flat band. Considering the vertically
elongated shape of dz2 orbital and its hybridization with Sn p
orbitals in neighboring stanene layers, it is expected to gain a
sizeable dispersion along z when placed inside the bulk, resulting
in a dilution of the spectral weight in energy. However, at the
surface, the translational invariance is broken and kz-dispersion is
quenched, thereby allowing a surface state non-dispersive within
the ab-plane as well as along the c axis. This demonstrates an
approach to engineering a high degree of band flattening along all
three directions for d-orbital based flat bands that may prove
useful for a wide variety of systems. In addition to the peculiar chemical environment created by Sn
and Nb:STO, the characteristic spin arrangement of FeSn (Fig. 3c)
generates a spin-split band structure at the surface. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 1b) in which hybridization
between the consecutive kagome layers is suppressed by the
stanene layers. This as a result allows FeSn band structure to be
well described by the minimal constituent of the kagome-stanene
bilayer. We also find that the intrinsically inversion asymmetric
kagome-stanene bilayer is most precisely represented by the
kagome layer at the surface (or Schottky interface) that neighbors
a stanene on one side and vacuum (or Nb:STO) on the other side. However, kagome layers in the bulk, being sandwiched by two
stanene layers, are situated in an inversion symmetric environ-
ment and therefore give rise to the band structure deviated from
that of the kagome-stanene bilayer (see Supplementary Note 15). We note that while the stanene layers play an important
structural role as well as control the local symmetry environment,
the presence of Sn in both the stanene and kagome layers
introduces three-dimensional hopping pathways that preclude the
observation of two-dimensional stanene bands (which itself might
be mitigating with isolation of the stanene layers)62. background signal (see Supplementary Note 23). The slab has Fe
kagome layers (Fe3Sn) at each layer index site with stanene layers
(Sn2) inserted between (Fig. 3c). This structure terminates with
the Fe kagome layer on one surface (L = 1) and the stanene layer
on the other surface (L = 8). The dI/dV spectrum for the x = 0.7
wt.% junction at T = 2 K (Fig. 3d) is compared with the calculated
DOS spectra at the kagome-terminated surface (Fig. 3e), the Sn-
terminated surface (Fig. 3f), and the bulk part of the slab (Fig. 3g). Within the energy range of the dI/dV peak (green-shaded box
across Fig. 3d–g), the kagome-terminated surface hosts a clear
peak in DOS at E = −125 meV (diamonds in Fig. 3d, e) whereas
the other two do not manifest any pronounced feature. In
addition, a shoulder-like feature in dI/dV is observed at
VJ = −560 mV nearby the satellite peak in DOS at the kagome-
terminated surface at E = −525 meV (asterisks in Fig. 3d, e). These suggest that the major features in the tunneling spectra
including the peak at VJ,peak = −180 mV originate from the
electronic states at the kagome-terminated surface of FeSn. Figure 3h shows the temperature dependence of dI/dV peak
positions and full widths at half maximum of the x = 0.7 wt.%
junction. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 Model junction simulations taking into account thermal and
dielectric effects give consistent positions of the flat band at each
temperature (the observed VJ,peak is within the simulated ranges
of the flat band across the entire temperature range, see
Supplementary Note 7, 8, 24). By estimating MFe at each
temperature from VJ,peak, we find that the magnetic transition at
the surface kagome layer effectively occurs ~316 K, reduced from
the Neel temperature of FeSn extracted from bulk-sensitive
measurements on single crystals (TN,bulk ~ 365 K)35,36,60,64 and
thin films (TN,film ~ 358 K)37,65. The modulation of the flat band
position as a function of the size of the spin moment suggests a
possibility of engineering the chemical potential of an arbitrary
magnetic kagome compound to the position of the flat band with
a fine balance of thermal fluctuation, disorder, and magnetic field. It is of significant interest to study this further with, e.g., depth-
resolved magnetic scattering probes or spin-resolved electron
microscopes with sub-nanometer spatial resolution. Furthermore,
stabilization of ultrathin FeSn, where the interface dominates the meV to E = −480 meV as average Fe spin moment (MFe) reduces
from Msat to 0.5 Msat, where Msat denotes Fe’s saturation
moment. We attribute
this as a potential origin of the
temperature-dependent shift in the dI/dV peak position observed
in the tunneling experiment (Fig. 3h). Gradual depolarization of
MFe at the interface upon thermal fluctuation and the consequent
reduction of the local exchange field may explain the shift from
VJ,peak = −180 mV at T = 2 K to VJ,peak = −560 mV at T = 200 K. Model junction simulations taking into account thermal and
dielectric effects give consistent positions of the flat band at each
temperature (the observed VJ,peak is within the simulated ranges
of the flat band across the entire temperature range, see
Supplementary Note 7, 8, 24). By estimating MFe at each
temperature from VJ,peak, we find that the magnetic transition at
the surface kagome layer effectively occurs ~316 K, reduced from
the Neel temperature of FeSn extracted from bulk-sensitive
measurements on single crystals (TN,bulk ~ 365 K)35,36,60,64 and
thin films (TN,film ~ 358 K)37,65. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 Such a
magnetic environment at the surface gives an opportunity to
investigate how the two-dimensional band structure of the
kagome-stanene bilayer changes as a function of the average
sublattice magnetization. We show in Fig. 4f that the position of
the DOS peak associated with the flat band in the kagome-
stanene bilayer shifts to higher binding energy from E = −110 5 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 Fig. 4 Spin-polarized surface flat band in FeSn. First-principles band structure calculations and DOS spectra of a bulk FeSn in the antiferromagnetic phase
and b kagome-terminated surface of the eight-layer FeSn slab with the antiferromagnetic spin configuration. The intensity denotes Fe d-orbital projection
weights in arbitrary units (arb. units). Insets in a, b show schematics of corresponding Brillouin zones. Spin down/up bands are color-coded with red/blue
in a. The DOS peak and the flat band in b are marked with the green-shaded box and the dashed line, respectively. c Layer-resolved DOS color map in the
eight-layer slab. d Orbital projected band structure of b. e Band structure and DOS spectrum of a ferromagnetic kagome-stanene bilayer. f Average Fe spin
moment (MFe)-dependent DOS spectra of the ferromagnetic kagome-stanene bilayer. The DOS peak associated with the flat band shifts to higher binding
energy as MFe depolarizes. Fig. 4 Spin-polarized surface flat band in FeSn. First-principles band structure calculations and DOS spectra of a bulk FeSn in the antiferromagnetic phase
and b kagome-terminated surface of the eight-layer FeSn slab with the antiferromagnetic spin configuration. The intensity denotes Fe d-orbital projection
weights in arbitrary units (arb. units). Insets in a, b show schematics of corresponding Brillouin zones. Spin down/up bands are color-coded with red/blue
in a. The DOS peak and the flat band in b are marked with the green-shaded box and the dashed line, respectively. c Layer-resolved DOS color map in the
eight-layer slab. d Orbital projected band structure of b. e Band structure and DOS spectrum of a ferromagnetic kagome-stanene bilayer. f Average Fe spin
moment (MFe)-dependent DOS spectra of the ferromagnetic kagome-stanene bilayer. The DOS peak associated with the flat band shifts to higher binding
energy as MFe depolarizes. entirety of the signal, would most clearly elucidate the properties
of the proposed interfacial state. meV to E = −480 meV as average Fe spin moment (MFe) reduces
from Msat to 0.5 Msat, where Msat denotes Fe’s saturation
moment. We attribute
this as a potential origin of the
temperature-dependent shift in the dI/dV peak position observed
in the tunneling experiment (Fig. 3h). Gradual depolarization of
MFe at the interface upon thermal fluctuation and the consequent
reduction of the local exchange field may explain the shift from
VJ,peak = −180 mV at T = 2 K to VJ,peak = −560 mV at T = 200 K. Methods The oscillation frequency and the effective mass of the Fermi
pocket are in good agreement with those of the δ pocket observed
in FeSn bulk single crystals22, indicating comparable electronic
structure and Fermi level position. p
To investigate the geometry of the Fermi pocket, we performed
field angle-dependent SdH measurements at T = 0.35 K. As the
magnetic field is tilted away from the c axis, the oscillation
frequency gradually increases, while its amplitude diminishes (see
Supplementary Note 19). Figure 5d shows a scatter plot of the
field angle-dependent oscillation frequencies extracted with
various fitting methods from two independent measurements in
65 T pulsed field and 45 T DC field. The overlaid dashed lines
denote expected Fermi surface cross-sections assuming different
ellipticities of the Fermi pocket. The observed trend suggests a
Fermi pocket highly elongated along the c axis with b ≳3a, where
a and b are minor and major axes of the ellipse, respectively. The
elliptical geometry of the Fermi pocket reflects the electronic
hopping anisotropy in bulk FeSn, originating from its layered
crystal structure (Fig. 1b). These altogether validate that subsur-
face layers of the FeSn film in fact retain the band structure of the
bulk single-crystal FeSn with a comparable Fermi level. Three-terminal tunneling measurements. Tunneling measurements were carried
out on five Schottky junctions consisting of Nb-doped SrTiO3 substrates with four
different doping concentrations: 0.05 wt.%, 0.2 wt.%, 0.5 wt.%, and 0.7 wt.%
(Junction #1 and #2), three of them presented in the main text. The measurements
were performed with the three-terminal geometry in a Helium-4 cryostat (Quan-
tum Design PPMS Dynacool). The tunneling contacts were made by evaporating
Au/Ti electrodes onto as-grown FeSn films, using shadow masks. The current and
voltage reference electrodes were made directly onto the Nb:STO substrate by
removing the FeSn layer and evaporating Au/Ti. Electrical connections were made
with Ag paint and gold wires. An excitation signal was generated by mixing outputs
from a sinusoidal oscillator (Stanford Research model SR860) and a DC voltage
source (Yokogawa model 7651). Upon applying the excitation signal to the tun-
neling electrode, the resulting tunnel current was measured using a lock-in
amplifier (Stanford Research model SR860) and a voltmeter (Keithley model
2182a) via a current amplifier (DL Instruments model 1211). Discussion b In this work, we probed the local DOS of antiferromagnetic
kagome metal FeSn at the Schottky heterointerface with an n-type
degenerate semiconductor Nb:STO, using planar tunneling
spectroscopy. An anomalous enhancement of the tunneling
conductance ~180 meV below the Fermi level of FeSn, in con-
junction with surface band structure calculations, revealed evi-
dence for a flat band residing at the bottom-most kagome layer of
FeSn at the interface. Our numerical calculations suggest that the
observed surface flat band corresponds to a dz2 orbital derived
spin-polarized flat band expected in a ferromagnetic kagome-
stanene bilayer. Although our findings constitute consistent sig-
natures of the proposed surface flat band, a critical future
direction would be to directly probe the spin texture and elec-
tronic structure of the interfacial layer via space-, spin-, and layer-
resolved high-resolution spectroscopy techniques. Furthermore, it
is of significant interest to stabilize an isolated kagome-stanene
bilayer, which would most readily facilitate the direct investiga-
tion of the surface flat band discussed herein. In connection with
the degree of band flattening, the two-dimensional surface loca-
lization of a vertically elongated orbital suggests a new design
principle towards flat bands with nearly zero dispersion along all
directions. Viewed more broadly, these observations suggest that
the surface of the magnetic flat band material, being situated in an
electromagnetic environment distinct from that of the bulk, has
the potential to host a flat band with unique orbital and spin
characters. In addition, given the surface-localized nature of this
flat band, it is expected to have a pronounced effect when
embedded into heterostructure-based devices for spintronic
applications. 0
Frequency (T)
(º)
PF,Index
DC,Dingle
PF,FFT
DC,FFT
Cylinder
(b>>a)
Ellipse
(b=3a)
Ellipse
(b=1.5a)
Sphere
(b=a)
300
200
100
180
0
T = 0.35 K
90
FeSn
STO
[001]
H
d 0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
FFT Int. (arb. units)
1000
500
Frequency (T)
0.1
0.0
SdH Int. (arb. units)
40
0
T ( K )
m* = 0.38
LK-fit
c d Frequency (T) (º) Fig. 5 Electrical transport at high magnetic field. a High-field magnetoresistance of FeSn/STO at different temperatures. b Shubnikov-de
Haas (SdH) oscillations at different temperatures, extracted from a. c Fast
Fourier Transform (FFT) of the SdH oscillations in b. The inset shows the
temperature-dependent SdH oscillation amplitudes (marker) and their fit to
Lifshitz-Kosevich (LK) formula (dashed line), from which the effective mass
of m⋆= 0.38 m0 was extracted. Methods Film synthesis and characterization. FeSn thin films were synthesized on single-
crystal Nb-doped SrTiO3 (111) substrates (Shinkosha, Co. and MTI, Co.) for the
tunneling measurements and on single-crystal SrTiO3 (111) substrates (Shinkosha,
Co.) for the high-field electrical transport measurements. Prior to film synthesis,
substrates were annealed at 1050 ∘C in air for 1 h in order to prepare atomically flat
and nominally oxygen-vacancy-free surfaces. This treatment is consistent with
what has been conducted in ref. 70. Then the substrates were loaded into MBE
chamber and annealed at 600 ∘C in UHV for 1 h to remove any residual moisture
and adsorbates from the surface. FeSn films were deposited by evaporating Fe and
Sn from solid source effusion cells. For the tunneling measurements, we deposited
FeSn at high-temperature Tg = 500 ∘C to improve the FeSn/Nb:STO interface
quality. The ratio of beam-equivalent pressures (BEPs) was PFe:PSn ¼ 1:2:7, where
PFe and PSn are BEPs for Fe and Sn, respectively. For the high-field transport
measurements, the substrate temperature during deposition was Tg = 180 ∘C and
the ratio of BEPs was PFe:PSn ¼ 1:2:2. The low-temperature-synthesized FeSn films
had improved in-plane morphology compared with the high-temperature-
synthesized samples. FeSn films for the transport measurements were additionally
capped with amorphous BaF2 at Tg = 200 ∘C and post-annealed at Tg = 500 ∘C for
12 h to improve crystalline quality, all in situ in the MBE chamber. The films were
characterized with an X-ray diffractometer to ensure crystalline quality and the
absence of impurity phases. high-field magnetoresistance
Δρxx
ρxx H¼0
ð
Þ
ρxx H
ð Þρxx H¼0
ð
Þ
ρxx H¼0
ð
Þ
of an FeSn
film with the thickness tFeSn = 25.5 nm. The overall response is
quadratic in a magnetic field with a growing magnitude from
T = 40 K to T = 0.58 K, originating from enhanced electronic
mobility at lower temperatures. SdH oscillations are also observed
with an onset field of μ0H ~ 30 T. Figure 5b shows the SdH
oscillations at different temperatures, from which the effective
mass of m⋆= 0.38 m0 was extracted using Lifshitz-Kosevich (LK)
formula (Fig. 5c, inset). The oscillation frequency, extracted by
the Fast Fourier Transformation (FFT), was f = 145 T (Fig. 5c). ARTICLE 0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
FFT Int. (arb. units)
1000
500
Frequency (T)
0.1
0.0
SdH Int. (arb. units)
40
0
T ( K )
m* = 0.38
50
40
30
20
10
0
xx /
xx ( H = 0 ) (%)
60
40
20
0
µ0H (T)
T = 0.58 K
40
LK-fit
H // c
Pulsed Field
T = 0.58 K
1.3
2.4
5
10
15
20
25
30
40
-0.2
-0.1
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.04
0.02
Rxx ( )
1/µ0H (T )
-1
40
T = 0.58 K
Frequency (T)
(º)
PF,Index
DC,Dingle
PF,FFT
DC,FFT
Cylinder
(b>>a)
Ellipse
(b=3a)
Ellipse
(b=1.5a)
Sphere
(b=a)
300
200
100
180
0
T = 0.35 K
H // c
Pulsed Field
90
FeSn
STO
[001]
H
c
d
a
b
Fig. 5 Electrical transport at high magnetic field. a High-field 50
40
30
20
10
0
xx /
xx ( H = 0 ) (%)
60
40
20
0
µ0H (T)
T = 0.58 K
40
H // c
Pulsed Field
a T = 0.58 K
1.3
2.4
5
10
15
20
25
30
40
-0.2
-0.1
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.04
0.02
Rxx ( )
1/µ0H (T )
-1
40
T = 0.58 K
H // c
Pulsed Field
b NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 The oscillation frequen
the Fast Fourier Transformation (FFT), was f =
The oscillation frequency and the effective ma
pocket are in good agreement with those of the δ
in FeSn bulk single crystals22, indicating compa
structure and Fermi level position. To investigate the geometry of the Fermi pocke
field angle-dependent SdH measurements at T =
magnetic field is tilted away from the c axis
frequency gradually increases, while its amplitude
Supplementary Note 19). Figure 5d shows a sc
field angle-dependent oscillation frequencies
various fitting methods from two independent m
65 T pulsed field and 45 T DC field. The overl
denote expected Fermi surface cross-sections ass
ellipticities of the Fermi pocket. The observed
Fermi pocket highly elongated along the c axis wi
a and b are minor and major axes of the ellipse, r
elliptical geometry of the Fermi pocket reflect
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
FFT Int. (arb. units)
1000
500
Frequency (T)
0.1
0.0
SdH Int. (arb. units)
40
0
T ( K )
m* = 0.38
50
40
30
20
10
0
xx /
xx ( H = 0 ) (%)
60
40
20
0
µ0H (T)
T = 0.58 K
40
LK-fit
H // c
Pulsed Field
-0.2
-0.1
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.02
Rxx ( )
1/µ0H (T )
-1
40
T = 0.58 K
Frequency (T)
(º)
PF,Index
DC,Dingle
P
DC
300
200
100
18
0
T = 0. H
Pulsed F
90
FeSn
STO
[001]
H
c
d
a
b
Fig. 5 Electrical transport at high magnetic field. a Hig
magnetoresistance of FeSn/STO at different temperatur
Haas (SdH) oscillations at different temperatures, extra
Fourier Transform (FFT) of the SdH oscillations in b. Th
temperature-dependent SdH oscillation amplitudes (mar
Lifshitz-Kosevich (LK) formula (dashed line), from which
of m⋆= 0.38 m0 was extracted. d Field angle-dependen
frequencies. Different fitting methods were applied to d
experiments in two different magnet systems (see Suppl
The overlaid dashed lines denote expected Fermi surfac
assuming different Fermi pocket ellipticity. a and b, resp
minor and major axes of the ellipse, also corresponding
wavevectors along the ab-plane and the c axis of FeSn. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.103 Discussion d Field angle-dependent SdH oscillation
frequencies. Different fitting methods were applied to data sets from
experiments in two different magnet systems (see Supplementary Note 19). The overlaid dashed lines denote expected Fermi surface cross-sections
assuming different Fermi pocket ellipticity. a and b, respectively, are the
minor and major axes of the ellipse, also corresponding to the Fermi
wavevectors along the ab-plane and the c axis of FeSn. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 The modulation of the flat band
position as a function of the size of the spin moment suggests a
possibility of engineering the chemical potential of an arbitrary
magnetic kagome compound to the position of the flat band with
a fine balance of thermal fluctuation, disorder, and magnetic field. It is of significant interest to study this further with, e.g., depth-
resolved magnetic scattering probes or spin-resolved electron
microscopes with sub-nanometer spatial resolution. Furthermore,
stabilization of ultrathin FeSn, where the interface dominates the Focusing on its implication for device application, the knowl-
edge of the surface flat band presented herein will be useful in
designing heterostructure-based electronic or spintronic devices
where interfacial phenomena govern the overall performance. A
recent discovery of strong spin-orbit torque in f-electron-based
flat band materials suggests that the exotic surface flat band in
FeSn is also expected to generate peculiar spin-orbit torque
signals66. When FeSn is interfaced with a conventional ferro-
magnet for spintronic device operations, strong Berry curvature
contribution from FeSn’s surface flat band may transfer a
significant
spin-orbit
torque
to
the
latter,
manifesting
as
significant anomalous Hall or Nernst signal in the second
Harmonic domain67. In addition, if magnetic anisotropy and
exchange biasing interaction of FeSn and the ferromagnet can be
further engineered with appropriate chemical doping or mechan-
ical strain, we expect that FeSn’s surface flat band will drive
efficient magnetization switching in the latter68,69. Shubnikov-de Haas oscillations in FeSn/STO. Finally, in order
to confirm that subsurface layers of the FeSn thin films retain the
band structure consistent with bulk single crystals, we performed
bulk-sensitive Shubnikov-de Haas (SdH) oscillation measure-
ments, as a complementary probe to the interface-sensitive tun-
neling spectroscopy. For SdH measurements, FeSn films were
deposited on undoped (insulating) STO. Figure 5a shows the NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 6 high-field magnetoresistance
Δρxx
ρxx H¼0
ð
Þ
ρxx H
ð Þρxx
ρxx H¼
ð
film with the thickness tFeSn = 25.5 nm. The ov
quadratic in a magnetic field with a growing m
T = 40 K to T = 0.58 K, originating from enha
mobility at lower temperatures. SdH oscillations a
with an onset field of μ0H ~ 30 T. Figure 5b
oscillations at different temperatures, from wh
mass of m⋆= 0.38 m0 was extracted using Lifshit
formula (Fig. 5c, inset). References The DFT calculations were performed
using the standard generalized-gradient approximation in the Perdew, Burke, and
Ernzerhof (PBE)74 parametrization. A k space integration was carried out with the
linear tetrahedron method using 8 × 8 × 1 subdivisions in the full Brillouin zone. Fe
valence orbitals of 3s, 3p, 4s, 5s, 3d, 4d, and 4p and Sn valence orbitals of 4s, 4p, 4d,
5s, 6s, 5d, 5p, and 6p were used as basis states. The self-consistent electronic states
were considered with ferromagnetic moments within the kagome plane with spin
moments along the [100] direction (a axis) and antiferromagnetic ordering along
the [001] direction (c axis). A vacuum size of 1.7924 nm was created to separate the
periodic slabs. The calculations converged with a self-consistent spin density better
4 15. Xu, G., Lian, B. & Zhang, S.-C. Intrinsic quantum anomalous Hall effect in the
kagome lattice Cs2LiMn3F12. Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 186802 (2015). 16. Guo, H.-M. & Franz, M. Topological insulator on the kagome lattice. Phys. Rev. B 80, 113102 (2009). 17. Kane, C. L. & Mele, E. J. Quantum spin Hall effect in graphene. Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 226801 (2005). 18. Haldane, F. D. M. Model for a quantum Hall effect without Landau levels:
condensed-matter realization of the “parity anomaly.”. Phys. Rev. Lett. 61,
2015 (1988). 19. Thouless, D. J., Kohmoto, M., Nightingale, M. P. & den Nijs, M. Quantized
Hall conductance in a two-dimensional periodic potential. Phys. Rev. Lett. 49,
405 (1982). 20. Hasan, M. Z. & Kane, C. L. Colloquium: topological insulators. Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 3045 (2010). 21. Kang, M. et al. Topological flat bands in frustrated kagome lattice CoSn. Nat. Commun. 11, 4004 (2020). 22. Kang, M. et al. Dirac fermions and flat bands in the ideal kagome metal FeSn. Nat. Mater. 19, 163 (2020). 23. Kuroda, K. et al. Evidence for magnetic Weyl fermions in a correlated metal. Nat. Mater. 16, 1090 (2017). pp
g
To complement the FeSn slab simulation above, we also computed the band
structure of a single Fe kagome layer, with and without a neighboring stanene layer. The DFT calculations were carried out using the Vienna ab initio simulation
package76,77, based on the pseudopotential formalism and the Projector
Augmented-Wave method78. Data availability 29. Randeria, M. T. et al. Interacting multi-channel topological boundary modes
in a quantum Hall valley system. Nature 566, 363 (2019). The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding
author on reasonable request. 30. Koroteev, Y. M. et al. Strong spin-orbit splitting on Bi Surfaces. Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 046403 (2004). References 1. Stewart, G. R. Non-Fermi-liquid behavior in d- and f-electron metals. Rev. Mod. Phys. 73, 797 (2001). 2. Si, Q. & Steglich, F. Heavy fermions and quantum phase transitions. Science
329, 1161 (2010). ,
(
)
3. Laughlin, R. B. Anomalous quantum Hall effect: an Incompressible quantum 3. Laughlin, R. B. Anomalous quantum Hall effect: an Incompressible quantum
fluid with fractionally charged excitations. Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 1395
(1983). 4. Tsui, D. C., Stormer, H. L. & Gossard, A. C. Two-dimensional 4. Tsui, D. C., Stormer, H. L. & Gossard, A. C. Two-dimensional
magnetotransport in the extreme quantum limit. Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1559
(1982). magnetotransport in the extreme quantum limit. Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1559
(1982). 5. Sutherland, B. Localization of electronic wave functions due to local topology. Phys. Rev. B 34, 5208 (1986). 6. Lieb, E. H. Two theorems on the Hubbard model. Phys. Rev. Lett. 62, 1201
(1989). 7. Tang, E., Mei, J.-W. & Wen, X.-G. High-temperature fractional quantum Hall
states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 236802 (2011). 8. Sun, K., Gu, Z., Katsura, H. & Das Sarma, S. Nearly flatbands with nontrivial
topology. Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 236803 (2011). p
gy
y
9. Wang, F. & Ran, Y. Nearly flat band with Chern number C = 2 on the dice
lattice. Phys. Rev. B 84, 241103(R) (2011). A T; H
ð
Þ ¼ A1
2π2m?kBT
e_μ0H
exp 2π2m?kBTD
e_μ0H
sinh
2π2m?kBT
e_μ0H
1
sin
2πf
μ0H þ γ
, where
A1 is a temperature and field-independent prefactor, TD is the Dingle temperature,
γ is a phase of the oscillations (Dingle). 10. Leykam, D., Andreanov, A. & Flach, S. Artificial flat band systems: from lattice
models to experiments. Adv. Phys.: X 3, 1473052 (2018). 11. Cao, Y. et al. Unconventional superconductivity in magic-angle graphene
superlattices. Nature 556, 43 (2018). First-principles calculations. The FeSn slab consisted of eight crystallographic
unit cells stacked along the c-direction and was terminated with a kagome layer on
one side (L = 1) and a stanene layer on the other side (L = 8), preserving the
stoichiometric bulk structure. The electronic structure of the slab was simulated
with the four-component fully relativistic full-potential local-orbital (FPLO) den-
sity functional theory (DFT) code, version 18.0071–73. This procedure is consistent First-principles calculations. References The ferromagnetic and nonmagnetic calculations
were converged with exchange-correlation energy functional parametrized by
PBE74, a Γ-centered 15 × 15 × 1 Monkhorst-Pack k-mesh grid, an energy cutoff
300 eV, with or without relativistic spin-orbit coupling terms. Similarly, effective
models were projected from the converged electronic state using Wannier
transformations75 implemented in Wannier90 code79,80. The Wannier basis states
were the Fe d orbitals and Sn p orbitals and the projected Hamiltonians give further
insights into the slab electronic structure when magnetic layers were stacked. 24. Nayak, A. K. et al. Large anomalous Hall effect driven by a nonvanishing
Berry curvature in the noncolinear antiferromagnet Mn3Ge. Sci. Adv. 2,
e1501870 (2016). 25. Wang, Q. et al. Large intrinsic anomalous Hall effect in half-metallic
ferromagnet Co3Sn2S2 with magnetic Weyl fermions. Nat. Commun. 9, 3681
(2018). 26. Burkov, A. A. & Balents, L. Weyl semimetal in a topological insulator
multilayer. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 127205 (2011). 27. Feldman, B. E. et al. Observation of a nematic quantum Hall liquid on the
surface of bismuth. Science 354, 316 (2016). 28. Randeria, M. T. et al. Ferroelectric quantum Hall phase revealed by visualizing
Landau level wavefunction interference. Nat. Phys. 14, 796 (2018). NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 Electrical transport measurements at high magnetic field. Electrical transport
measurements were performed on two different samples at the National High Methods The actual voltage
across the Schottky junction was monitored by measuring the potential difference
between the tunnel and the reference electrodes, using a lock-in amplifier (Stanford
Research model SR860) and a voltmeter (Keithley model 2182a) via voltage pre-
amplifier (DL Instruments model 1201). 7 References The FeSn slab consisted of eight crystallographic
unit cells stacked along the c-direction and was terminated with a kagome layer on
one side (L = 1) and a stanene layer on the other side (L = 8), preserving the
stoichiometric bulk structure. The electronic structure of the slab was simulated
with the four-component fully relativistic full-potential local-orbital (FPLO) den-
sity functional theory (DFT) code, version 18.0071–73. This procedure is consistent
with what has been conducted in ref. 22. The DFT calculations were performed
using the standard generalized-gradient approximation in the Perdew, Burke, and
Ernzerhof (PBE)74 parametrization. A k space integration was carried out with the
linear tetrahedron method using 8 × 8 × 1 subdivisions in the full Brillouin zone. Fe
valence orbitals of 3s, 3p, 4s, 5s, 3d, 4d, and 4p and Sn valence orbitals of 4s, 4p, 4d,
5s, 6s, 5d, 5p, and 6p were used as basis states. The self-consistent electronic states
were considered with ferromagnetic moments within the kagome plane with spin
moments along the [100] direction (a axis) and antiferromagnetic ordering along
the [001] direction (c axis). A vacuum size of 1.7924 nm was created to separate the
periodic slabs. The calculations converged with a self-consistent spin density better
than 10−4. The Fe atoms at L = 1 and L = 8 converged to 2.40 μB and 2.03 μB,
respectively, whereas those at inner layers converged to intermediate values
between the two. Based on the converged electronic state, PYFPLO module
interface of the FPLO package71,72 was used to derive a tight-binding Wannier
Hamiltonian75. The basis states include atomic-orbital-like Wannier functions
associated with Fe 3d and 4s states, and Sn 5s and 5p states. This Wannier model
construction not only enables efficient electronic structure simulations for a thin
slab but also allows the analysis of microscopic atomic on-site potentials and
hopping terms. 12. Cao, Y. et al. Correlated insulator behaviour at half-fill 12. Cao, Y. et al. Correlated insulator behaviour at half-filling in magic-angle
graphene superlattices. Nature 556, 80 (2018). graphene superlattices. Nature 556, 80 (2018) 13. Ye, L. et al. Massive Dirac fermions in a ferromagnetic kagome metal. Nature
555, 638 (2018). 14. Ye, L. et al. De Haas-van Alphen effect of correlated Dirac states in kagome
metal Fe3Sn2. Nat. Commun. 10, 4870 (2019). y
y
p
with what has been conducted in ref. 22. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 Received: 23 December 2020; Accepted: 24 August 2021; Received: 23 December 2020; Accepted: 24 August 2021; Received: 23 December 2020; Accepted: 24 August 2021; Electrical transport measurements at high magnetic field. Electrical transport
measurements were performed on two different samples at the National High
Magnetic Field Laboratory. Sample #1 has a rectangular shape of ~1 mm × 2 mm
and electrical contacts were made by attaching gold wires to the film top surface
with Ag paint. Measurements were conducted in the 65 T pulsed magnet system in
Helium-3 environment at National High Magnetic Field Laboratory (LANL). Magnetoresistance was measured in the two-terminal geometry by driving the
sample with 297 μA 297 kHz AC current and recording the voltage across the
sample by an oscilloscope (National Instruments model 5105) through a voltage
preamplifier with the gain 100. Simultaneously, the time evolution of the magnetic
field pulse was monitored with a pickup coil and another oscilloscope (National
Instruments model 6133). The phase-sensitive response of the sample was analyzed
offline after the measurements. Sample #2 has a rectangular shape of ~2 mm × 5
mm and electrical contacts were made the same way as Sample #1. Measurements
were conducted in the 45 T DC magnet system in Helium-3 environment with the
standard lock-in technique at National High Magnetic Field Laboratory (Talla-
hassee). The non-oscillatory component of the magnetoresistance was obtained by
a polynomial fit and was subtracted to get the oscillatory component. The effective
mass m⋆was obtained from the temperature dependence of the oscillation
amplitude according to the LK formula A T
ð Þ ¼ A0
2π2m?kBT
e_μ0H
sinh1
2π2m?kBT
e_μ0H
,
where A0 is a temperature-independent prefactor, kB is the Boltzmann constant,
and ℏis the reduced Planck constant. The frequency of the oscillations was
obtained by three different methods: from the slope of the extremum positions of
the oscillations as a function of inverse magnetic field (index), by fast fourier
transform of the oscillations as a function of inverse magnetic field (FFT), and by
fitting the oscillations to the Dingle formula
A T; H
ð
Þ ¼ A1
2π2m?kBT
e_μ0H
exp 2π2m?kBTD
e_μ0H
sinh
2π2m?kBT
e_μ0H
1
sin
2πf
μ0H þ γ
, where
A1 is a temperature and field-independent prefactor, TD is the Dingle temperature,
γ is a phase of the oscillations (Dingle). ARTICLE ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 63. Witczak-Krempa, W., Chen, G., Kim, Y. B. & Balents, L. Correlated quantum
phenomena in the strong spin-orbit regime. Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. 5, 57 (2014). 33. Deng, Y. et al. Quantum anomalous Hall effect in intrinsic magnetic
topological insulator MnBi2Te4. Science 367, 895 (2020). topological insulator MnBi2Te4. Science 367, 895 (2020). 34. Liu, C. et al. Robust axion insulator and Chern insulator phases in a two
dimensional antiferromagnetic topological insulator. Nat. Mater. 19, 522
(2020). 64. Kakihana, M. et al. Electronic states of antiferromagnet FeSn and Pauli
paramagnet CoSn. J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 88, 014705 (2019). 35. Hartmann, O. & Wäppling, R. Muon spin precession in the hexagonal
antiferromagnet FeSn. Phys. Scr. 35, 499 (1987). 65. Hong, D. et al. Molecular beam epitaxy of the magnetic kagome metal FeSn on
LaAlO3 (111). AIP Adv. 10, 105017 (2020). 36. Häggström, L., Ericsson, T., Wäppling, R. & Chandra, K. Studies of the
magnetic structure of FeSn using the Mössbauer Effect. Phys. Scr. 11, 47
(1975). 66. Reynolds, N. D. et al. Strong, temperature-dependent spin-orbit torques in
heavy fermion YbAl3. Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.03678
(2020). 37. Inoue, H., Han, M., Ye, L., Suzuki, T. & Checkelsky, J. G. Molecular beam
epitaxy growth of antiferromagnetic kagome metal FeSn. Appl. Phys. Lett. 115
072403 (2019). 67. Roschewsky, N. et al. Spin-orbit torque and Nernst effect in Bi-Sb/Co
heterostructures. Phys. Rev. B 99, 195103 (2019). y
68. Sales, B. C., Saparov, B., McGuire, M. A., Singh, D. J. & Parker, D. S. Ferromagnetism of Fe3Sn and alloys. Sci. Rep. 4, 7024 (2014). y
68. Sales, B. C., Saparov, B., McGuire, M. A., Singh, D. J. & Parker, D. S. F
i
f F S
d ll
S i R
4 7024 (2014) 38. Kozuka, Y., Susaki, T. & Hwang, H. Y. Rectifying NdNiO3/Nb:SrTiO3
junctions as a probe of the surface electronic structure of NdNiO3. Appl. Phys. Lett. 88, 142111 (2006). Ferromagnetism of Fe3Sn and alloys. Sci. Rep. 4, 7024 (2014) 69. Han, J. et al. Room-temperature spin-orbit torque switching Induced by a
topological insulator. Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 077702 (2017). 39. Yoshimi, R. et al. Dirac electron states formed at the heterointerface between a
topological insulator and a conventional semiconductor. Nat. Mater. 13, 253
(2014). 70. Connell, J. G., Isaac, B. J., Ekanayake, G. B., Strachen, D. R. & Seo, S. S. A. Acknowledgements (
)
51. Weaver, H. E. Dielectric properties of single crystals of SrTiO3 at low
temperatures. J. Phys. Chem. Solids 11, 274 (1959). We are grateful to R. Comin, M. Kang, and M. Richter for fruitful discussions. This work
was funded, in part, by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation EPiQS Initiative, grant
no. GBMF9070 to J.G.C. (synthesis instrumentation), ARO grant no. W911NF-16-1-
0034 (characterization instrumentation), and is/was supported by the Global Research
Outreach program of the Samsung Advanced Institute of Technology (SAIT) (material
development). C.J. and E.K. acknowledge support from the STC Center for Integrated
Quantum Materials, NSF grant DMR-1231319. H.I. acknowledges support by the Japan
Society for the Promotion of Science, KAKENHI grant no. JP19K23415, JP20K14398,
and JP20H05148, and Grant for Basic Science Research Projects from The Sumitomo
Foundation. S.F. is supported by a Rutgers Center for Material Theory Distinguished
Postdoctoral Fellowship. A part of the work presented here was performed at the
National High Magnetic Field Laboratory (NHMFL), supported by the National Science
Foundation Cooperative Agreement no. DMR-1644779, the State of Florida and the
DOE. Pulsed magnetic field experiments were supported by the DOE BES ‘Science at
100T’ grant. The computations presented here were run on the FASRC Cannon cluster
supported by the FAS Division of Science Research Computing Group at Harvard
University and on the computer clusters at IFW Dresden, Germany. Technical assistance
by U. Nitzsche in using the latter is gratefully acknowledged. 52. Mikheev, E., Hoskins, B. D., Strukov, D. B. & Stemmer, S. Resistive switching
and its suppression in Pt/Nb:SrTiO3 junctions. Nat. Commun. 5, 3990
(2014). 53. Shimizu, T. & Okushi, H. Intrinsic electrical properties of Au/SrTiO3 Schottky
junctions. J. Appl. Phys. 85, 7244 (1999). 54. Swartz, A. G. et al. Polaronic behavior in a weak-coupling superconductor. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 115, 1475 (2018). 55. Sze, S. M & Ng, K. K. Physics of Semiconductor Devices. 2nd edn. (Wiley: New
York, 1981). 56. Muller, D. A., Nakagawa, N., Ohtomo, A., Grazul, J. L. & Hwang, H. Y. Atomic-scale imaging of nanoengineered oxygen vacancy profiles in SrTiO3. Nature 430, 657 (2004). 57. Tanaka, T., Matsunaga, K., Ikuhara, Y. & Yamamoto, T. First-principles study
on structures and energetics of intrinsic vacancies in SrTiO3. Phys. Rev. B 68,
205213 (2003). 58. Mitra, C., Robertson, J. & Demkov, A. A. Electronic structure of oxygen
vacancies in SrTiO3 and LaAlO3. Phys. Rev. B 86, 155105 (2012). 59. ARTICLE Preparation of atomically flat SrTiO3 surfaces using a deionized-water
leaching and thermal annealing procedure. Appl. Phys. Lett. 101, 251607
(2012). 40. Hikita, Y. et al. Negative differential resistance induced by Mn substitution at
SrRuO3/Nb:SrTiO3 Schottky interfaces. Phys. Rev. B 77, 205330
(2008). 71. Koepernik, K. & Eschrig, H. Full-potential nonorthogonal local-orbital
minimum-basis band-structure scheme. Phys. Rev. B 59, 1743
(1999). 41. Hansma, P. K. Tunneling Spectroscopy: Capabilities, Applications and New
Techniques. (Plenum Press, New York, 1982). 72. Koepernik, K. FPLO code (IFW Dresden), https://www.fplo.de. q
42. Binnig, G. & Hoenig, H. E. Energy gap of the superconducting semiconductor
SrTiO3−x determined by tunneling. Solid State Commun. 14, 597
(1974). 73. Richter, M., Koepernik, K. & Eschrig, H. Full-potential local-orbital approach
to the electronic structure of solids and molecules. In Condensed Matter
Physics In The Prime Of The 21st Century: Phenomena, Materials, Ideas,
Methods, 271 (World Scientific, 2008). 43. Conley, J. W. & Mahan, G. D. Tunneling spectroscopy in GaAs. Phys. Rev. 161, 681 (1967). 74. Perdew, J. P., Burke, K. & Ernzerhof, M. Generalized gradient approximation
made simple. Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865 (1996). 44. Fujii, T. et al. Electrical properties and colossal electroresistance of
heteroepitaxial SrRuO3/SrTi1−xNbxO3 (0.0002 ≤x ≤0.02) Schottky junctions. Phys. Rev. B 75, 165101 (2007). 75. Marzari, N., Mostofi, A. A., Yates, J. R., Souza, I. & Vanderbilt, D. Maximally
localized Wannier functions: theory and applications. Rev. Mod. Phys. 84,
1419 (2012). y
45. Richter, C. et al. Interface superconductor with gap behaviour like a high-
temperature superconductor. Nature 502, 528 (2013). 76. Kresse, G. & Furthmüller, J. Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-
energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set. Phys. Rev. B 54, 11169 (1996). 46. Inoue, H. et al. Origin of the magnetoresistance in oxide tunnel junctions
determined through electric polarization control of the interface. Phys. Rev. X
5, 041023 (2015). 77. Kresse, G. & Furthmüller, J. Efficiency of ab-initio total energy calculations for
metals and semiconductors using a plane-wave basis set. Comp. Mat. Sci. 6, 15
(1996). 47. Morali, N. et al. Fermi-arc diversity on surface terminations of the magnetic
Weyl semimetal Co3Sn2S2. Science 365, 1286 (2019). 78. Blöchl, P. E. Projector augmented-wave method. Phys. Rev. B 50, 17953
(1994). y
48. Su, C.-C. et al. Surface termination dependent quasiparticle scattering y
48. Su, C.-C. et al. Surface termination dependent quasiparticle scattering
interference and magneto-transport study on ZrSiS. New J. Phys. ARTICLE 20, 103025
(2018). 79. Mostofi, A. A. et al. Wannier90: a tool for obtaining maximally-localised
Wannier functions. Comp. Phys. Commun. 178, 685 (2008). interference and magneto-transport study on ZrSiS. New J. Phys. 20, 103025
(2018). 49. Yamamoto, T. et al. Effect of the field dependent permittivity and interfacial
layer on Ba1−xKxBiO3/Nb-Doped SrTiO3 Schottky junctions. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 36, L390 (1997). 80. Mostofi, A. A. et al. An updated version of Wannier90: a tool for obtaining
maximally-localised Wannier functions. Comp. Phys. Commun. 185, 2309
(2014). y
50. Susaki, T., Kozuka, Y., Tateyama, Y. & Hwang, H. Y. Temperature-dependent
polarity reversal in Au/Nb:SrTiO3 Schottky junctions. Phys. Rev. B 76, 155110
(2007). Acknowledgements Henrich, V. E., Dresselhaus, G. & Zeiger, H. J. Surface defects and the
electronic structure of SrTiO3 surfaces. Phys. Rev. B 17, 4978
(1978). Author contributions M.H., H.I., and J.G.C. conceived the project. M.H, H.I., and C.J. synthesized thin film
samples. M.H. performed the tunneling measurements and analyzed the data with H.I. M.H. and H.I. performed and analyzed the electrical transport measurements with
assistance from M.K.C., D.G., L.Y., T.S. S.F. performed the theoretical calculations with
input from M.H., M.P.G., W.J.C., and E.K. M.H., H.I., and J.G.C. wrote the manuscript
with contributions from all authors. J.G.C. supervised the project. 60. Sales, B. C. et al. Electronic, magnetic, and thermodynamic properties of the
kagome layer compound FeSn. Phys. Rev. Mater. 3, 114203 (2019). 61. Meier, W. R. et al. Flat bands in the CoSn-type compounds. Phys. Rev. B 102,
075148 (2020). 62. Xu, Y. et al. Large-gap quantum spin Hall insulators in tin films. Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 136804 (2013). Code availability
h
d
d 31. Ast, C. R. & Höchst, H. Fermi surface of Bi(111) measured by photoemission
spectroscopy. Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 177602 (2001). The codes used to support the findings in this study are available from the corresponding
author on reasonable request. spectroscopy. Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 177602 (2001). 32. Mong, R. S. K., Essin, A. M. & Moore, J. E. Antiferromagnetic topological
insulators. Phys. Rev. B 81, 245209 (2010). 8 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 Additional information
Supplementary information The online version contains supplementary material
available at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to Joseph G. Checkelsky. Peer review information Nature Communications thanks the anonymous reviewers for
their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available. Reprints and permission information is available at http://www.nature.com/reprints
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. Open Acces
Attribution
adaptation, distribution and r
appropriate credit to the origi
Commons license, and indica
material in this article are in
indicated otherwise in a cred
article’s Creative Commons li
regulation or exceeds the perm
the copyright holder. To view
licenses/by/4.0/. © The Author(s) 2021 Competing interests
Th
h
d
l Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests. Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests 9 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications MMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications © The Author(s) 2021 Additional information Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing,
adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give
appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative
Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party
material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless
indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the
article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory
regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from
the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/
licenses/by/4.0/. Supplementary information The online version contains supplementary material
available at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to Joseph G. Checkelsky. Peer review information Nature Communications thanks the anonymous reviewers for
their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available. Reprints and permission information is available at http://www.nature.com/reprints Reprints and permission information is available at http://www.nature.com/reprints Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. © The Author(s) 2021 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 10 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021) 12:5345 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25705-1 | www.nature.com/naturecommunicatio
|
https://openalex.org/W3007246627
|
https://rgu-repository.worktribe.com/preview/2014795/RABAH%202020%20Heterogeneous%20parallelization%20%28VOR%29.pdf
|
English
| null |
Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs
|
IEEE access
| 2,020
|
cc-by
| 8,240
|
Received February 7, 2020, accepted February 19, 2020, date of publication February 28, 2020, date of current version March 11, 2020. Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2977120 INDEX TERMS CNN, object detection, object tracking, Gain-Scheduled PID, quadcopter. INDEX TERMS CNN, object detection, object tracking, Gain-Scheduled PID, quadcopter. INDEX TERMS CNN, object detection, object tracking, Gain-Scheduled PID, quadcopter. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. For more information, see http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 MOHAMMED RABAH
1,2, ALI ROHAN
1, MOHAMMAD-HASHEM HAGHBAYAN
3
JUHA PLOSILA
3, AND SUNG-HO KIM
4
1School of Electronics and Information Engineering, Kunsan National University, Gunsan 54150, South Korea
2Department of Electronics and Telecommunication Engineering, Al-Safwa High Institute of Engineering, Cairo 11837, Egypt
3Department of Future Technologies, University of Turku (UTU), 20500 Turku, Finland
4Department of Control and Robotics Engineering, Kunsan National University, Gunsan 54150, South Korea
C
di
th
M h
d R b h (
h
d
t f
1991@
il
) 1School of Electronics and Information Engineering, Kunsan National University, Gunsan 54150, South Korea
2Department of Electronics and Telecommunication Engineering, Al-Safwa High Institute of Engineering, Cairo 1
3Department of Future Technologies, University of Turku (UTU), 20500 Turku, Finland
4Department of Control and Robotics Engineering, Kunsan National University, Gunsan 54150, South Korea 1School of Electronics and Information Engineering, Kunsan National University, Gunsan 54150, South Korea
2Department of Electronics and Telecommunication Engineering, Al-Safwa High Institute of Engineering, Cairo 11837, Egypt
3Department of Future Technologies, University of Turku (UTU), 20500 Turku, Finland
4Department of Control and Robotics Engineering, Kunsan National University, Gunsan 54150, South Korea Corresponding author: Mohammed Rabah (mohamedmostafamousa1991@gmail.com) Corresponding author: Mohammed Rabah (mohamedmostafamousa1991@gmail.com) Corresponding author: Mohammed Rabah (mohamedmostafamousa1991@gmail.com) ABSTRACT Recent technical advancements in both fields of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) control and
artificial intelligence (AI) have made a certain realm of applications possible. However, one of the main
problems in integration of these two areas is the bottle-neck of computing AI applications on UAV’s resource
limited platform. One of the main solution for this problem is that AI and control software from one side and
computing hardware mounted on UAV from the other side be adopted together based on the main constraints
of the resource limited computing platform on UAV. Basically, the target constraints of such adaptation are
performance, energy efficiency, and accuracy. In this paper, we propose a strategy to integrate and adopt
the commonly used object detection and tracking algorithm and UAV control software to be executed on
a heterogeneous resource limited computing units on a UAV. For object detection, a convolutional neural
network (CNN) algorithm is used. For object tracking, a novel algorithm is proposed that can execute
along with object tracking via sequential stream data. For UAV control, a Gain-Scheduled PID controller
is designed that steers the UAV by continuously manipulation of the actuators based on the stream data from
the tracking unit and dynamics of the UAV. All the algorithms are adopted to be executed on a heterogeneous
platform including NVIDIA Jetson TX2 embedded computer and an ARM Cortex M4. The observation from
real-time operation of the platform shows that using the proposed platform reduces the power consumption
by 53.69% in contrast with other existing methods while having marginal penalty for object detection and
tracking parts. RABAH, M., ROHAN, A., HAGHBAYAN, M.-H., PLOSILA, J. and KIM, S.-H. 2020. Heterogeneous parallelization for
object detection and tracking in UAVs. IEEE access [online], 8, pages 42784-42793. Available from:
https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2977120
Heterogeneous parallelization for object
detection and tracking in UAVs.
RABAH, M., ROHAN, A., HAGHBAYAN, M.-H., PLOSILA, J. and KIM, S.-H.
2020 RABAH, M., ROHAN, A., HAGHBAYAN, M.-H., PLOSILA, J. and KIM, S.-H. 2020. Heterogeneous parallelization for
object detection and tracking in UAVs. IEEE access [online], 8, pages 42784-42793. Available from:
https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2977120 RABAH, M., ROHAN, A., HAGHBAYAN, M.-H., PLOSILA, J. and KIM, S.-H. 2020. Heterogeneous parallelization for
object detection and tracking in UAVs. IEEE access [online], 8, pages 42784-42793. Available from:
https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2977120 2020 This document was downloaded from
https://openair.rgu.ac.uk I. INTRODUCTION The main ideas of the proposed system; 1) achieve high
framerate for real-time detection on an embedded platform, The main ideas of the proposed system; 1) achieve high
framerate for real-time detection on an embedded platform,
2) overcome the resources limitation of the embedded plat-
form by consuming less power, which will extend the flight
time of the quadcopter, and finally, 3) achieve higher accuracy
in detecting the target, thus the quadcopter can keep tracking
the object without losing it. For this, two heterogeneous on-
board processing units are used, i.e., big and little for object
detection and following, and the tasks are managed on them
based on the requirements and constraints of the system. The
heavy parts of the object tracking application are mapped on
big processing unit while the light weight part of the applica-
tion are mapped on the little processing units. Since the object
detection is a stream application [6], the big processing unit
activity is adjusted by the requirement of the processing for
each iteration that determined by [7]. The required heart-beat
is adjusted via the ability of the little part and accuracy of
the tracking. The task scheduling part is designed in a way
that the workload is evenly distributed in this heterogeneous
platform. Adaptive multi-layered CNN is used for object
detection that is running on big processing unit. While the lit-
tle processing unit is responsible for tracking process. Using
this heterogeneous platform and appropriate scheduling of
tasks, we adjust the performance and accuracy of the tracking
part according to the requirements of the feed-back based
system. In this paper, an adopted version of CNN is used to be exe-
cuted on big core according to the requirement of the object
tracking and the energy limitation of the mobile platform. There has been several object detection algorithms based on
CNN e.g., Single-Shot Detector (SSD) [11], YOLO [12],
and Faster R-CNN [13]. A CNN algorithm for detecting and
labelling disease in a radish field using a UAV is proposed
in [14]. In [15], authors proposed an object detection algo-
rithm based on CNN to detect drones. In [16], the authors
present a convolutional neural network algorithm to analyze
images captured from a drone to identify objects captured in
the images. Authors in [17], [18] applied convolutional neural
network based object detection schemes on fault diagnosis
and fault tolerant control. I. INTRODUCTION algorithms w.r.t. the performance, energy, and accuracy [4]. Using cloud servers for object detection is not possible solu-
tion since the communication cost between the drone and
cloud enormously prolongs response time in real-time stream
data processing of object tracking. Furthermore, detecting
objects in run-time basically faces noisy and low resolution
images accompanied by the background motion that neg-
atively affects the accuracy of the detection outcome [5]. Beside all of these, other real-time or non-real time tasks, e.g.,
navigation and control tasks, should be executed on-board
consuming resources and energy. Therefore, application exe-
cution on this platform demands appropriate system architec-
ture and adopted algorithms to improve the system constraints
as much as possible while meeting the strict requirements. Object recognition and tracking is one of the most
challenging tasks in autonomous aerial vehicles since the
detection and tracking the objects should be accurate and
agile in run-time and with rational energy consumption. There has been several methods focusing on object tracking
and based on making use of different sensors [1], thereof
using vision-based object detection is one of the most cheap-
est and convenient one beside which the obtained information
from vision sensors, e.g., RGB camera, can be used in other
tasks simultaneously, e.g., odometry and navigation [2], [3]. The main drawback of vision-based object tracking
methods is the high computation cost of executing their The associate editor coordinating the review of this manuscript and
approving it for publication was Shihong Ding
. In this paper, a heterogeneous platform for stream data pro-
cessing in real-time object detection and tracking is proposed. 42784 42784 VOLUME 8, 2020 VOLUME 8, 2020 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs parallelization in fog-edge layers. In [8] the authors propose a
neural network based approach to the acceleration of approx-
imate programs for on-chip system. In [9] a hierarchical
management framework for on-chip asymmetric multi-core
architectures is demonstrated. The target multi-core system
is ARM big.LITTLE mobile platforms. In this architecture,
cores have different size that can be used to execute different
types of applications. In [10] the authors have done a similar
attempt to exploit energy efficiency in symmetric multi-core
processors, which is demonstrated on the AMD Opteron
6168 processor. I. INTRODUCTION In this work, authors used CNN
to detect the working condition of an induction motor and
classify it as a faulty or healthy. In this work, an SSD architecture is implemented on
an embedded Artificial Intelligence (AI) computing device
NVIDIA Jetson TX2 (big processing unit). The CNN is
trained to detect two classes. The first class contains images
with an object, which can be thought as positive images,
while the other class contains images with no object which
can be thought as negative class. Furthermore, the object
detection algorithm is combined with an object tracking algo-
rithm based on Gain-Scheduled PID controller to follow the
detected object under variable speed. The reason for choos-
ing the Gain-Scheduled PID controller is to overcome the
instability and non-linearity of the quadcopter system, thus
enables it to follow a target under various speeds. The output
of the object tracking algorithm is sent to the flight controller
(little processing unit) to start the tracking process by sending
the required pulse width modulation (PWM) values to the
motors. Many control systems for tracking and following object
have been developed. A controller system for quadcopter
to follow different trajectories is presented in [19]. Authors
in [20] developed a non-linear control algorithm for object
tracking. An approach for target detection and wireless charg-
ing using a Hill-climbing method in presented in [21]. In [1],
the authors propose a method for tracking a moving target
under different paths using an IR camera. A vision based
object detection and safe landing using a fuzzy logic con-
troller is presented in [5], [22]. The previous studies show respectable outputs and per-
formance in detecting objects. However, some of the earlier
studies are based on cloud computing which is not suitable for
real-time applications, because the cloud computing systems
are internet-biased, and service outages are always possible
and can occur for various reason. Furthermore, other stud-
ies are based on wireless communication which is also not
suitable for real-time applications due to its limited coverage
area, and high latency which leads to a significant degrade in
performance. The remaining part of this paper is divided as follows:
Section II review the related work about workload balancing,
task scheduling, and mapping. Moreover the state-of-the-art
for object detection and designing controllers for quadcopters
will be discussed in this chapter. System architecture is illus-
trated in Section III. I. INTRODUCTION Section IV explains the real-time object
detection and tracking system. Section V demonstrates the
simulation studies and the experimental results, followed by
the conclusion in section VI. FIGURE 1. Block diagram of the overall system. FIGURE 1. Block diagram of the overall system. IV. OBJECT DETECTION AND TRACKING ALGORITHM IV. OBJECT DETECTION AND TRACKING ALGORITHM In this work, a real-time feed-back-based object detection
and tracking algorithm is proposed that can be adapted to be
executed on the proposed heterogeneous system architecture. Figure 2 shows the feed-back-based algorithm for object
detection and tracking. The visionary data from the camera
is fed into the object detection algorithm to detect the target
object for tracking. If the object detection part finds the target
object in the scene, the location of the object will be passed
to the object tracking algorithm that’s responsibility is to
extract the final location of the object based on the history
and the probability of possible error. After finalizing the
location of the target object, this location is passed to the
controller that adjusts the location of the quadcopter. This
process happens by comparing the observed location, i.e., the
location from the Object Tracking Unit, with a reference
that shows the expectation. In our case the reference is the
center of the image. The Controller Unit operates based on
the calculated difference of the observed location from the
reference, and thereby, the actuation parameters to each motor
will be adjusted. X = x −width
2
(1)
Y = y −height
2
(2) (1) (2) where X and Y are the new position in pixels, width and
height are the resolution of the input image. II. RELATED WORK Recent studies includes vast investigation on improve-
ment of system performance using heterogeneous distributed FIGURE 1. Block diagram of the overall system. VOLUME 8, 2020 VOLUME 8, 2020 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs FIGURE 2. Block diagram of the proposed system. FIGURE 2. Block diagram of the proposed system. FIGURE 3. Proposed object detection and tracking parts. III. SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE III. SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE Figure 1 shows the block diagram of the proposed system
architecture where the little processing unit is the flight con-
troller, and the big processing unit is Jetson TX2. The little
processing unit is an ARM Cortex M4 and is responsible to
adjust the attitude and stability of the quadcopter by receiving
data coming from the sensors and sending commands to
the motors via electronic speed controller modules (ESC). The processor receives information of roll, pitch, yaw and
altitude from the 10-DoF IMU device mounted on the board. The peripheral devices around the little core facilitate the IO
interface for the little core and are the ESC modules, brushless
DC motor (BLDC), RF transmitter, and RC receiver. (
)
The big processing unit in this paper is a NVIDIA Jetson
TX2 processing unit that is a powerful processing unit for AI
applications in terms of speed and power efficiency. Jetson
TX2 consists of 256 GPU units that makes it suitable to com-
pute the parallel tasks in neural network based applications. It also supports NVIDIA Jetpack—a complete SDK that
includes the BSP, libraries for deep learning, computer vision,
GPU computing, and multimedia processing. The peripherals
around the big core are HD Webcam, Bluetooth, and a camera
gimbal that provides the IO interface of big processing unit
to the environment. The interface between the big and little
processing units is a serial UART port that facilitate sending
the data from big part to the little part. FIGURE 3. Proposed object detection and tracking parts. In Figure 2, the camera keeps on capturing continues
images and send it to the Jetson TX2. The image is given as
an input to the pre-trained CNN, features are extracted from
the input image and weights are calculated. Based on the esti-
mated weights, the CNN gives an output image by drawing a
boundary box around the object with the expected probability
in percentage. Then the X and Y position of the detected
object is given out. The position (pos) of the detected object
is represented in pixel coordinates (X, Y). These coordinates
is changed so that the center co-ordinates are converted from
( width
2 , height
2
) to (0, 0) by using Equation 1 and Equation 2. These values are used to calculate the required Roll and Pitch
angle responsible for following the object. A. OBJECT DETECTION ALGORITHM As it is shown in Figure 3, after receiving an image of an
object, a CNN algorithm is applied. In this paper, a pre-
trained single-shot multibox detector (SSD) model is used 42786 42786 VOLUME 8, 2020 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs FIGURE 4. General architecture of the CNN method for object detection. FIGURE 4. General architecture of the CNN method for object detection. in each mode. The details of the implementation in each mode
are explained in the following. to detect the objects. Figure 4 illustrates the architecture of
the SSD. The SSD approach is based on a feed-forward
convolutional network that produces a fixed size collection
of bounding boxes and scores for the presence of object
class instances in those boxes, followed by a non-maximum
suppression step to produce the final detection [11]. It can be
seen in Figure 4, SSD’s architecture builds on the venerable
VGG-16 architecture, but discards the fully connected layers. The reason VGG-16 was used as the base network is because
of its strong performance in high quality image classification
tasks and its popularity for problems where transfer learning
helps in improving results. Instead of the original VGG fully
connected layers, a set of auxiliary convolutional layers (from
conv6 onwards) were added, thus enabling to extract features
at multiple scales and progressively decrease the size of the
input to each subsequent layer. Mode-Out: In this mode, the current position of the quad-
copter and its change of position are continuously checked
to determine the required roll/pitch angles responsible for
following the detected object. In this mode a Gain-Scheduled
PID controller is utilized. Gain scheduling is one of the most
popular approaches to nonlinear control design, as it has a
better performance and stability than robust ones [23]. The
Gain-Scheduled PID controller has three inputs, pos, △pos,
and Max△pos, and one output, roll/pitch angle. The extracted
position (pos) is assumed to be the error e(t) between the
position of the detected object and the centroid of the image
since the centroid is always zero. Then, by calculating the
difference between the current position and the previous
position, change of position △pos is obtained. The maximum
change of position Max△pos is a fixed value that is obtained
by storing the maximum change of position of the moving
object. A. OBJECT DETECTION ALGORITHM Equation 3 indicates how to calculate the required roll
and pitch angle for following, while Equation 4 shows how
to obtain the △pos. After applying the SSD model, a boundary box will be
drawn around the detected object. The location data of the
detected target is extracted and used as an input to the object
tracking algorithm to start the tracking process. y(t) = (1 + |
△pos
Max△pos|)Kpe(t) + Ki
tZ
0
e(τ) dτ + Kd
de(t)
dt
(3)
△pos = poscur −posprev
(4) B. OBJECT TRACKING ALGORITHM The location of the detected object is passed to the object
tracking unit. The tracking unit works based on the history
of the target’s objects location and current location of the
detected object. After pre-processing the data and filtering,
the location of the object in the image will be subtracted
from the expected reference and based on the results, i.e., the
error, the object tracking unit tries to specify and stabilize the
appropriate location of the quadcopter. To do that, two possi-
ble situations might happen upon which we define different
working modes. One situation is that the error is high enough
to activate the thrust of the quadcopter to change the velocity
and follow the object that is called mode-out in this paper. The
other situation is that the error is not that much high and the
quadcopter should keep its current velocity to stabilize over
the object. In mode-in the stabilization of the quadcopter is
essential, while in mode-out acceleration is. Therefore, two
different types of PID controller with different gains are used (3)
(4) ( )
(4) △pos = poscur −posprev
(4) where the error e(t) = pos, y(t) is the output of the controller
where in this work it represents roll/pitch angles, Kp,Ki and
Kd are the proportional, Integral, and derivative gains, △pos
is the change of position, poscur is the current position of the
quadcopter, and posprev is the previous position. As it is seen in the previous Equations, a higher △pos
value indicates that the quadcopter moved in a higher speed
since it covers a bigger distance in a fixed time (36 msec),
and vice versa. This will results in increasing/decreasing
the proportional gain of the PID controller which is
changed according to the ratio between △pos and Max△pos. VOLUME 8, 2020 42787 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs FIGURE 5. Flow chart of Object-tracking and data packet processing. Following are examples of the operation of the quadcopter in
Mode Out: • If △pos is a small value, Kp will be increased by a
small value too resulting in a slight increase in the
quadcopter angle and speed, causing the quadcopter to
move towards the center of the detected object where it
will trigger Mode In. B. OBJECT TRACKING ALGORITHM • If △pos is a big value, Kp will quickly increase up to
double, this will increase the angle and speed of the
quadcopter so it can quickly react and keep up with the
moving object. Mode-In: In this mode, a typical PID controller is used
for stabilizing the quadcopter over the detected object. Also,
this mode works as a brake for the quadcopter when it comes
from the Mode Out region by using a big proportional gain. Following are examples of the operation of the quadcopter in
Mode Out: • If △pos of the quadcopter approaching the Mode In
region is big, the quadcopter angle and speed will
increase. This will cause the quadcopter to quickly
decrease its angle and speed to be able to stabilize above
the center of the detected object. • If the quadcopter is in the Mode In, the PID controller
will be able to stabilize the quadcopter above the center
of the detected object which is either fixed or moving at
low speed. FIGURE 5. Flow chart of Object-tracking and data packet processing. FIGURE 6. Quadcopter experimental setup. V. SIMULATION AND EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES V. SIMULATION AND EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES To run the CNN on the big part, an SSD object detector is
used in this work. The SSD is able to achieve real-time and
high accuracy detection by using low resolution images as an
input. The SSD algorithm is implemented on an embedded
Artificial Intelligence (AI) computing device of NVIDIA
Jetson TX2. The CNN is trained to detect two classes, the first
class contains images with an object, which can be thought as
positive images, while the other class contains images with
no object which can be thought as negative class. The SSD
architecture is selected because it combines the performance
of YOLO with the accuracy of region-based detectors so it
can detect objects in real-time. The problem with SSD is that
the computational time is higher than other object detection
algorithms such as YOLO. Therefore, SSD is implemented
with an optimization method where the computational load is
divided onto CPU and GPU, resulting in a low computational time on the Jetson TX2, 36 ms, compared to the normal
time, 111 ms. Furthermore, the object detection algorithm is
combined with an object tracking algorithm based on Gain-
Scheduled PID controller to follow the detected object under
variable speed. The reason for choosing the Gain-Scheduled
PID controller is to overcome the instability and non-linearity
of the quadcopter system and thus enables it to follow a target
under various speeds. C. DATA PACKET PROCESSING PART After calculating the suitable angle required for following
the object, a packet consists of pitch, roll, and a flag is sent
to the flight controller every 36 msec. Once the flight con-
troller receives the data, it will look up for the value of flag. If the value is equal to ‘1’, it will start the tracking process. Additionally, a safety switch is provided to support the safe
operation of the quadcopter. Figure 5 shows the flowchart of
the object following algorithm inside the Jetson TX2, and the
data packet processing inside the flight controller. FIGURE 6. Quadcopter experimental setup. A. QUADCOPTER SETUP The experimental system is shown in Figure 6. It consists
of a quadcopter frame with flight controller, which is based
on an ARM Cortex M4 processor. It’s equipped with eight
PWM outputs which can support up to eight BLDC motors. The flight controller is build on ArduPilot, which is an open 42788 VOLUME 8, 2020 VOLUME 8, 2020 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs FIGURE 7. Quadcopter simulation system. FIGURE 8. Simulation results of the two controllers in a rectangular trajectory. FIGURE 7. Quadcopter simulation system. FIGURE 8. Simulation results of the two controllers in a rectangular trajectory. FIGURE 7. Quadcopter simulation system. FIGURE 8. Simulation results of the two controllers in a rectangular trajectory. is the time. The three inputs are stored as an array in the
Path Command block. In this work a rectangular path is
defined and stored in the Path Command block. The Position
Controller block outputs the required angle for controlling
the quadcopter over the defined path. Figure 7(b) shows the
position control block, where X/Y error block is responsible
for calculating the position error between the current position
in the desired path and the current position of the quadcopter,
and gives out X error and Y error. The Control blocks in
the Position Controller block takes the X error and Y error
and use it to calculate the desired Roll/Pitch angles required
for tracking based on the outputs of the two controllers. The
Control block has been modified so that the Gain-Scheduled
PID controller is added beside the typical PID controller
to compare between them as it is shown in Figure 7(c). In the Control blocks, the manual switch block is used to
switch between the two controllers, and the saturation block
is used to limit the output angle between −15◦and 15◦. Figure 7(d) shows the implementation of the Gain-Scheduled
PID controller based on Equation 3. Figure 8(a) shows the
simulation results of the two controllers in a rectangular
path. In Figure 8(a) and Figure 8(b), Gain-Scheduled PID
controller shows better response and faster settling time in x source code program written in C++. The big processing unit
(Jetxon TX2) is installed on a 3rd party carrier board and
is connected to the little processing unit (Flight controller)
through UART. A Logitech BRIO camera attached to a
2D-gimbal is connected to the TX2 through USB. A. QUADCOPTER SETUP This cam-
era is able to automatically adjust the image quality to com-
pensate for too much or too little light with High Dynamic
Range (HDR) capabilities. Finally, A Bluetooth linked to the
Jetson TX2 is used to send the current position of the detected
object to a ground station in meters. source code program written in C++. The big processing unit
(Jetxon TX2) is installed on a 3rd party carrier board and
is connected to the little processing unit (Flight controller)
through UART. A Logitech BRIO camera attached to a
2D-gimbal is connected to the TX2 through USB. This cam-
era is able to automatically adjust the image quality to com-
pensate for too much or too little light with High Dynamic
Range (HDR) capabilities. Finally, A Bluetooth linked to the
Jetson TX2 is used to send the current position of the detected
object to a ground station in meters. VOLUME 8, 2020 1) OBJECT DETECTION RESULTS The implementation of SSD is done via TensorRT and
Python, due to the availability of the most common machine
learning libraries. The SSD model used in this work is an
SSD MobileNet V1 which is optimized to run on embedded
platforms in real-time [24]. The proposed algorithm is imple-
mented on a Jetson TX2 and programmed using python 3.5. To test the performance of the the object detector, a custom
image dataset that contains 2000 images of RC car, rectan-
gle and a circle (positive images) on different backgrounds
and 3000 backgrounds (negative images) without objects has
been used for training. All images have been captured by the
camera installed on the quadcopter on 1280 × 720 pixels
and has been manually labeled. The images is divided into
two parts, training and testing dataset. 20% of the images is
used to test the network, while the 80% is used to train the
dataset. A dropout ratio of 0.8, kernel size 3×3 and a box-
code size set to 4 is used in this network. The root mean square
propagation (RMSprop) optimization algorithm is used for
optimizing the loss functions trained for 100,000 steps using
the following parameters; a learning rate of 0.004, decay
factor 0.95, and decays at an interval of 80,0720 steps. The
training was carried out on a desktop with an AMD Ryzen 7
2700X 3.70 GHz, 16 GB RAM, and NVIDIA GTX 1080Ti. Figure 9 shows the detection results of the object detection
algorithm, the position of each object and the calculated
fps. Once the object is detected, a boundary box will be
drawn around the object, and the center of the detected
objects will be extracted to be used for the object following
algorithm. FIGURE 9. Object detection algorithm output. As shown in Table 2, the YOLO V3 has the highest accu-
racy, it consumes a lot of power and the processing speed
(4.1 fps) was not up for practical use. Therefore, a Tiny-
YOLO V3 has been used instead of the YOLO V3 as it
can achieve higher fps (17 fps). However, the Tiny-YOLO
V3 is not good for practical use because of its high power
consumption and low accuracy. Moreover, Faster R-CNN was
able to get higher accuracy compared to the Tiny-YOLO v3. TABLE 2. Object detection models comparison. TABLE 2. Object detection models comparison. and y-direction while PID controller has overshot. Figure 8(c)
shows the output of the two controllers in the XY plane. The Gain-Scheduled PID controller has better performance
compared to the PID controller which has overshot and longer
settling time. and y-direction while PID controller has overshot. Figure 8(c)
shows the output of the two controllers in the XY plane. The Gain-Scheduled PID controller has better performance
compared to the PID controller which has overshot and longer
settling time. C. EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES FIGURE 9. Object detection algorithm output. In this section, the performance of the real-time object detec-
tion based on CNN and object following based on Gain-
Scheduled PID controller is described. B. SIMULATION STUDIES MATLAB/SIMULINK based quadcopter simulation system
is used to perform a comparative study between the typical
PID controller and the Gain-scheduled PID controller. This
simulation system is available on MATLAB file exchange
and it’s free to use. The basic purpose of this system is to
study the behavior of a quadcopter system and how different
parameters affect the quadcopter flight. Figure 7(a) shows the full quadcopter simulation system. In this system, the Position Controller block takes three
inputs from the user (x,y,t), where ’x’ and ’y’ represent the
coordinate’s points in a Cartesian coordinate system and ’t’ 42789 42789 VOLUME 8, 2020 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs TABLE 1. Initialization parameters of the object detectors. TABLE 1. Initialization parameters of the object detectors. TABLE 2. Object detection models comparison. 2) OBJECT TRACKING RESULTS As can been seen in Table 3, the PID controller is slightly less
than Gain-Scheduled PID controller (1.5 ms difference). TABLE 3. Timing comparison (Average time). This section covers the following; 1) a vision-based algo-
rithm is used to calculate the absolute position of the quad-
copter in real-time, 2) the proposed algorithm is compared
to a developed PID controller that is used for Human-follow
[25], and how much each algorithm takes to be executed,
3) the proposed algorithm is compared to the previous men-
tioned one to track the RC car in a rectangular path under
variable speed (2 m/s and 4 m/s), and the results of their
performance are carried out. TABLE 3. Timing comparison (Average time). Figure 10 compares between the Gain-Scheduled PID con-
troller and the PID controller under 2m/s of the target speed. Figure 10(a) shows that Gain-Scheduled PID controller has
a slightly better response in X-position than PID controller,
while in Figure 10(b), PID controller shows feeble response
and stability in the Y-position. Figure 10(c) depicts the per-
formance of the quadcopter in the XY plane under 2m/s of
the target speed. As seen in the Figure, the PID controller has
poor performance, poor stability and it fails to reach the center
of the detected target. For calculating the absolute position of the quadcopter in
meters, a vision-based algorithm is used to obtain the absolute
position between the detected target and the quadcopter. The
algorithm uses the pinhole camera model and the captured
images to build a metric map. The coordinate of a point in 3D
(X, Y, Z) can be computed from its projection pixel in the
2D (x,y) image and the projection matrix. Firstly, a reference
object is used to measure the pixels per metric ratio. In the
algorithm, an RC car with a 39cm width and 22cm height
is used as a reference object. An image of the reference
object is captured from a defined height of 2 meters using the
camera attached to the quadcopter. Then, the reference object
is detected in the image, based on a color detection algorithm,
where a contour technique and a threshold is used to define
the boundaries of the detected object. Thus, the width and
height of the reference object in pixels are obtained. 2) OBJECT TRACKING RESULTS 2) OBJECT TRACKING RESULTS To verify the feasibility of the proposed algorithm, several
experiments were performed under variable speed of the
detected target to obtain the optimal values for the param-
eters gains that is used for object-tracking algorithm. The
experimental setup shown in Figure 6 is composed of quad-
copter frame with a flight controller connected to a Jetson
TX2 through UART communication. The proposed object
detection and tracking algorithm is implemented on the Jet-
son TX2 and executed every 36 msec. Initially the quadcopter
is flying at an altitude of 2 meters, once the RC car is detected,
the real-time object detection is triggered and a boundary
box is drawn around the moving RC car based on our pro-
posed object detector. Afterwards, the location of the RC car
and its change of position are extracted and are passed to
the object-tracking algorithm based on our developed Gain-
scheduled PID control. The object-tracking algorithm works
differently based on the location of the detected object as been
discussed in section IV.B. Finally, the object-tracking algo-
rithm outputs the required values of roll and pitch angles that
are responsible for tracking and stabilizing the quadcopter
over the moving RC car. These values is sent to the flight
controller every 36 msec, where the flight controller uses
these values for the tracking process. ˆx =
A1 × x + B1
(C(x −100)2 + D(y −160)2 −1)
(6)
ˆy =
A2 × y + B2
(C(x −100)2 + D(y −160)2 −1)
(7) (6) (7) where ˆx and ˆy are the distance in meter, x and y are the
distance in pixels. As shown in the previous Equations, each
Equation has four unknowns, therefore four known points
are used to generate four Equations for each axis to identify
these unknowns. The identified parameters are obtained by
using regular simultaneous equation solving methods, such
as substitution and elimination. The experimental target is moving in a rectangular path
under two different speed, 2 m/s and 4 m/s. Figure 10 and
Figure 11 show the results of the performed trials using our
object following algorithm and the PID controller that was
developed in [25] to follow a human based on CNN detection. Table 3 shows the average time for capturing the image,
perform object detection, process the info using our object
following algorithm and the PID controller developed in [25]. 1) OBJECT DETECTION RESULTS However, It has a higher power consumption compared to the
previous two object detectors, and a much lower fps (1.9),
which make it unsuitable for real-time detection applications. Therefore, an SSD MobileNet V1 is used instead of the other
two models, as it consumes less power and achieves higher
fps. The time it takes for the object detector to process a frame
and give output on the detected object is 36 msec which is
7 times faster than the YOLO V3, 14 times higher than Faster
R-CNN, and 1.7 time faster than the Tiny-YOLO V3. The
reduction in the computational time besides the low power
consumption of this model, which is 63.15% less than YOLO
V3, 67.92% lower than Faster R-CNN, and 44.23% less than
Tiny-YOLO V3, made it feasible to implement it on a system
like a quadcopter where response time is very critical parame-
ter to consider. Furthermore, the SSD MobileNet V1 accuracy
which is slightly less than the YOLO V3 made it the best
option besides the computational time to to be used for real-
time object detection. In this 36 msec, the frames received
though camera are processed and the CNN gives the output
in form of an image with the position of the detected object
in pixels as shown in Figure 9. To evaluate the performance of the proposed object detec-
tor on the Jetson TX2, another three models have been trained
using the same dataset and same desktop. Table 1 shows the
default initialization parameters of the four models used for
training the dataset, while Table 2 shows their comparison
results. 42790 VOLUME 8, 2020 VOLUME 8, 2020 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs computed as shown in Equation 6 and Equation 7: VOLUME 8, 2020 VI. CONCLUSION In this work, an approach for implementation of a real-
time object detection and tracking system for a quadcopter
based on CNN have been proposed. The proposed system is
implemented on an embedded computer. The object detection
algorithm is based on CNN. An SSD model is used to detect
the moving object, draw a boundary box around it then extract
the center positions of the detected object. Object tracking
algorithm based on Gain-Scheduled PID controller is estab-
lished to follow the detected object under variable speed. The presented algorithm can be used in many applications
such as search-and-rescue, tracking a specific object, and
providing aerial footage of sports events. Several trials are
performed. The experimental results shows that the object
detection algorithm is able to detect and classify objects with
high accuracy, less power consumption, and high fps, and
the object tracking algorithm is able to follow and track
the detected object under variable speed. In addition, using
this technique to track multiple/specific object might prove
an important area for future research. Moreover, develop-
ing the proposed work to estimate the distance between the [4] S. Mittal and J. S. Vetter, ‘‘A survey of CPU-GPU heterogeneous comput-
ing techniques,’’ ACM Comput. Surv., vol. 47, no. 4, pp. 1–35, Jul. 2015. [5] M. Rabah, A. Rohan, M. Talha, K.-H. Nam, and S. H. Kim, ‘‘Autonomous
vision-based target detection and safe landing for UAV,’’ Int. J. Control,
Autom. Syst., vol. 16, no. 6, pp. 3013–3025, Dec. 2018. [6] F. Patrona, I. Mademlis, A. Tefas, and I. Pitas, ‘‘Computational UAV cine-
matography for intelligent shooting based on semantic visual analysis,’’ in
Proc. IEEE Int. Conf. Image Process. (ICIP), Sep. 2019, pp. 4155–4159. [7] H. Hoffmann,
J. Eastep,
M. D. Santambrogio,
J. E. Miller,
and
A. Agarwal, ‘‘Application heartbeats: A generic interface for specifying
program performance and goals in autonomous computing environments,’’
in Proc. 7th Int. Conf. Autonomic Comput. (ICAC). New York, NY, USA:
ACM, 2010, pp. 79–88, doi: 10.1145/1809049.1809065. [8] H. Esmaeilzadeh, A. Sampson, L. Ceze, and D. Burger, ‘‘Neural acceler-
ation for general-purpose approximate programs,’’ in Proc. 45th Annu. IEEE/ACM Int. Symp. Microarchitecture, Dec. 2012, pp. 449–460. [9] T. S. Muthukaruppan, M. Pricopi, V. Venkataramani, T. Mitra, and
S. Vishin, ‘‘Hierarchical power management for asymmetric multi-core in
dark silicon era,’’ in Proc. 50th Annu. Des. Autom. Conf. (DAC), 2013,
p. 174. [10] K. Ma and X. 2) OBJECT TRACKING RESULTS The
pixels per metric can be calculated as follow: Figure 11 evaluates the performance of the Gain-
Scheduled PID controller and the PID controller under 4m/s
of the target speed in a rectangular trajectory. Figure 11(a)
shows that PID controller has very bad response and stability
in X-position compared to the Gain-Scheduled PID con-
troller, while in Figure 11(b), PID controller has bad response
and overshoot. Figure 11(c) demonstrates that under 4m/s of
the target speed, Gain-Scheduled PID controller shows good
performance and stability compared to the PID controller. p = h
w
(5) (5) According to the previous evaluation of the experimental
results, the Gain-Scheduled PID controller has proven that it
has better response, and shorter settling time compared to the
typical PID controller. Although PID controller can track the
detected target under 2m/s, it shows very poor performance where p denotes the pixels per metric ratio, h and w are the
reference object width in pixels and metric, respectively. The
distance between the quadcopter and the detected target is 42791 42791 VOLUME 8, 2020 VOLUME 8, 2020 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs FIGURE 10. Controller result in a rectangular trajectory under 2m/s. FIGURE 11. Controller result in a rectangular trajectory under 4m/s. FIGURE 10. Controller result in a rectangular trajectory under 2m/s. FIGURE 10. Controller result in a rectangular trajectory under 2m/s. FIGURE 11. Controller result in a rectangular trajectory under 4m/s. FIGURE 11. Controller result in a rectangular trajectory under 4m/s. quadcopter and the detected target based on vision-based
techniques, and landing safely on a moving/fixed object with-
out the use of an optical ranging sensor is also an important
application for future work. under 4m/s because of its fixed gains. In order to get the
best performance from a PID controller, gains need to be
changed continuously according to the speed of the target. Therefore, a Gain-Scheduled PID controller is used to over-
come the problems of the typical PID controller. Moreover,
for further improving the performance of the Gain-Scheduled
PID controller, a typical PID controller has been used to brake
the quadcopter while it’s approaching the middle region as
discussed in section IV.B, this will lead to increase in the
response and performance of the quadcopter especially in
the sharp turns or sudden change of target speed as shown
in Figure 10 and Figure 11. REFERENCES [1] M. Rabah, A. Rohan, S. A. S. Mohamed, and S.-H. Kim, ‘‘Autonomous
moving target-tracking for a UAV quadcopter based on fuzzy-PI,’’ IEEE
Access, vol. 7, pp. 38407–38419, 2019. [2] S. A. S. Mohamed, M.-H. Haghbayan, T. Westerlund, J. Heikkonen,
H. Tenhunen, and J. Plosila, ‘‘A survey on odometry for autonomous nav-
igation systems,’’ IEEE Access, vol. 7, pp. 97466–97486, 2019. [3] S. A. Mohamed, M.-H Haghbayan, M. Rabah, J. Heikkonen, H. Tenhunen,
and J. Plosila, ‘‘Towards dynamic monocular visual odometry based on
an event camera and IMU sensor,’’ in Intelligent Transport Systems. From
Research and Development to the Market Uptake. INTSYS (Lecture Notes
of the Institute for Computer Sciences, Social Informatics and Telecom-
munications Engineering) vol. 310, A. Martins, J. Ferreira, and A. Kocian,
Eds. Cham, Switzerland: Springer, 2020, doi: 10.1007/978-3-030-38822-
5_17. VI. CONCLUSION Wang, ‘‘Pgcapping: Exploiting power gating for power
capping and core lifetime balancing in cmps,’’ in Proc. 21st Int. Conf. Parallel Archit. Compilation Techn., 2012, pp. 13–22. 42792 VOLUME 8, 2020 M. Rabah et al.: Heterogeneous Parallelization for Object Detection and Tracking in UAVs [11] W. Liu, D. Anguelov, D. Erhan, C. Szegedy, S. Reed, C.-Y. Fu, and
A. C. Berg, ‘‘SSD: Single shot multibox detector,’’ in Proc. Eur. Conf. Comput. Vis. Cham, Switzerland: Springer, 2016, pp. 21–37, doi:
10.1007/978-3-319-46448-0_2. ALI ROHAN received his B.S. degree in Electrical
Engineering from The University of Faisalabad,
Pakistan in 2012. From 2012 to 2013, worked
as a Development Engineer at Niagara group of
Industries, Pakistan. From 2013 to 2015, worked
as a Project Engineer for Circle Club, Pakistan. From 2015 to 2016, worked as a Project Manager
for Steam Masters, Pakistan and also as a Lecturer
at the department of Electrical and Telecommuni-
cation Engineering, Government College Univer-
sity Faisalabad, Pakistan. In 2018, completed his M.S. degree in Electrical,
Electronics and Control Engineering from Kunsan National University,
South Korea. In February 2020, he completed his Ph.D. degree in Electri-
cal, Electronics and Control Engineering from Kunsan National University,
South Korea. His Research Interests includes Machine learning, AI, UAV’s,
Power Electronics, Fuzzy Logic, EV system, Flywheel Energy Storage
System. [12] J. Redmon, S. Divvala, R. Girshick, and A. Farhadi, ‘‘You only look once:
Unified, real-time object detection,’’ in Proc. IEEE Conf. Comput. Vis. Pattern Recognit. (CVPR), Jun. 2016, pp. 779–788. [13] S. Ren, K. He, R. Girshick, and J. Sun, ‘‘Faster R-CNN: Towards real-time
object detection with region proposal networks,’’ in Proc. Adv. Neural Inf. Process. Syst., 2015, pp. 91–99. y
pp
[14] L. M. Dang, S. I. Hassan, I. Suhyeon, A. K. Sangaiah, I. Mehmood,
S. Rho, S. Seo, and H. Moon, ‘‘UAV based wilt detection system via con-
volutional neural networks,’’ Sustain. Comput., Informat. Syst., May 2018. [15] M. Saqib, S. D. Khan, N. Sharma, and M. Blumenstein, ‘‘A study on
detecting drones using deep convolutional neural networks,’’ in Proc. 14th
IEEE Int. Conf. Adv. Video Signal Based Surveill. (AVSS), Aug. 2017,
pp. 1–5. [16] A. Rivas, P. Chamoso, A. González-Briones, and J. Corchado, ‘‘Detection
of cattle using drones and convolutional neural networks,’’ Sensors, vol. 18,
no. 7, p. 2048, Jun. 2018. [17] Y. Wu, B. Jiang, and N. VI. CONCLUSION Lu, ‘‘A descriptor system approach for estimation
of incipient faults with application to high-speed railway traction devices,’’
IEEE Trans. Syst., Man, Cybern., Syst., vol. 49, no. 10, pp. 2108–2118,
Oct. 2019. MOHAMMAD-HASHEM HAGHBAYAN recei-
ved the B.A. degree in computer engineering from
the Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, the M.S. degree in computer architecture from the Uni-
versity of Tehran, Iran, and the Ph.D. degree
(Hons.) from the University of Turku (UTU),
Finland. Since 2018, he has been a Postdoc-
toral Researcher with the Department of Future
Technologies, UTU. He has published 42 peer-
reviewed publications in international conferences
and journals. His research interests include machine learning, autonomous
systems, high-performance energy-efficient architectures, and on-chip/fog
resource management. [18] Y. Wu, B. Jiang, and Y. Wang, ‘‘Incipient winding fault detection and
diagnosis for squirrel-cage induction motors equipped on CRH trains,’’ ISA
Trans., to be published. [19] M. Rabah, A. Rohan, Y.-J. Han, and S.-H. Kim, ‘‘Design of fuzzy-pid
controller for quadcopter trajectory-tracking,’’ Int. J. Fuzzy Log. Intell. Syst., vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 204–213, 2018. [20] A. Joukhadar, M. AlChehabi, C. Stöger, and A. Müller, ‘‘Trajectory track-
ing control of a quadcopter uav using nonlinear control,’’ in Mecha-
nism, Machine, Robotics and Mechatronics Science. Cham, Switzerland:
Springer, 2019, pp. 271–285, doi: doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-89911-
4_20. [21] A. Rohan, M. Rabah, F. Asghar, M. Talha, and S.-H. Kim, ‘‘Advanced
drone battery charging system,’’ J. Electr. Eng. Technol., vol. 14, no. 3,
pp. 1395–1405, Feb. 2019. JUHA PLOSILA received the Ph.D. degree in
electronics and communication technology from
the University of Turku (UTU), Finland, in 1999. He is currently a Professor in autonomous systems
and robotics with the Department of Future Tech-
nologies, UTU. He is also the Head of the EIT
Digital Master Programme in Embedded Systems,
EIT Digital Master School (European Institute
of Innovation and Technology). He represents
UTU in the Node Strategy Committee of the EIT
Digital Helsinki/Finland node. He has a strong research background in
adaptive multiprocessing systems and platforms, and their design. This
includes, e.g., specification, development, and verification of self-aware
multiagent monitoring and control architectures for massively parallel
systems, machine learning, and evolutionary computing-based approaches,
as well as application of heterogeneous energy-efficient architectures
to new computational challenges in the cyber-physical systems and the
Internet-of-Things domains, with a recent focus on fog/edge computing
(edge intelligence) and autonomous multidrone systems. [22] M. Talha, F. Asghar, A. Rohan, M. Rabah, and S. H. VI. CONCLUSION Kim, ‘‘Fuzzy logic-
based robust and autonomous safe landing for UAV quadcopter,’’ Arabian
J. Sci. Eng., vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 2627–2639, Jun. 2018. [23] V. Veselý and A. Ilka, ‘‘Gain-scheduled PID controller design,’’ J. Process
Control, vol. 23, no. 8, pp. 1141–1148, Sep. 2013. [24] A. G. Howard, M. Zhu, B. Chen, D. Kalenichenko, W. Wang, T. Weyand,
M. Andreetto, and H. Adam, ‘‘MobileNets: Efficient convolutional neu-
ral networks for mobile vision applications,’’ 2017, arXiv:1704.04861. [Online]. Available: http://arxiv.org/abs/1704.04861 [Online]. Available: http://arxiv.org/abs/1704.04861 [25] A. Rohan, M. Rabah, and S.-H. Kim, ‘‘Convolutional neural network-
based real-time object detection and tracking for parrot AR drone 2,’’ IEEE
Access, vol. 7, pp. 69575–69584, 2019. MOHAMMED RABAH received his B.S. degree
in Electronics and Telecommunication Engineer-
ing from the AL-SAFWA High Institute of Engi-
neering, Egypt in 2015. He completed his MSc
in Electronics and Information Engineering from
Kunsan National University, South Korea in
December 2017. Currently, he is a PhD candi-
date and works as a Research Assistant at Fac-
tory Automation & Intelligent Control Laboratory,
Department of Electronics and Information Engi-
neering, Kunsan National University, South Korea. His research Interests
includes UAV’s applications, autonomous systems, intelligent control sys-
tems, and deep learning. SUNG-HO KIM SUNG-HO KIM received the B.S., M.S., and
Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering from Korea
University, in 1984, 1986, and 1991, respectively,
and the Ph.D. degree from Hiroshima University,
Japan, in 1996. He is currently a Professor with
Kunsan National University. His research inter-
ests include fuzzy logic, sensor networks, neural
networks, intelligent control systems, renewable
energy systems, and fault diagnosis systems. 42793 VOLUME 8, 2020
|
https://openalex.org/W2797659889
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc5922351?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
BET inhibition is an effective approach against KRAS-driven PDAC and NSCLC
|
Oncotarget
| 2,018
|
cc-by
| 8,226
|
BET inhibition is an effective approach against KRAS-driven
PDAC and NSCLC
p Toni Jauset1,2,3, Daniel Massó-Vallés1,2, Sandra Martínez-Martín1,2, Marie-Eve
Beaulieu1,3, Laia Foradada1,3, Francesco Paolo Fiorentino4,5, Jun Yokota6, Bernard
Haendler7, Stephan Siegel7, Jonathan R. Whitfield1 and Laura Soucek1,2,3,8
1Vall d’Hebron Institute of Oncology (VHIO), Edifici Cellex, Hospital Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain
2Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Bellaterra, Barcelona, Spain
3Peptomyc S.L., Edifici Cellex, Hospital Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain
4Kitos Biotech srls, Porto Conte Ricerche, Alghero, Italy Toni Jauset1,2,3, Daniel Massó-Vallés1,2, Sandra Martínez-Martín1,2, Marie-Eve
Beaulieu1,3, Laia Foradada1,3, Francesco Paolo Fiorentino4,5, Jun Yokota6, Bernard
Haendler7, Stephan Siegel7, Jonathan R. Whitfield1 and Laura Soucek1,2,3,8
1Vall d’Hebron Institute of Oncology (VHIO), Edifici Cellex, Hospital Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain
2Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Bellaterra, Barcelona, Spain
3Peptomyc S.L., Edifici Cellex, Hospital Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain
4Kitos Biotech srls, Porto Conte Ricerche, Alghero, Italy 5Department of Biomedical Sciences, University of Sassari, Sassari, Italy 6Genomics and Epigenomics of Cancer Prediction Program, Institut d’Investigació Germans Trias I Pujol (IGTP), Campus Can
Ruti, Barcelona, Spain 6Genomics and Epigenomics of Cancer Prediction Program, Institut d’Investigació Germans Trias I Pujol (IGTP), Campus Can
Ruti, Barcelona, Spain 7Drug Discovery, Bayer AG, Berlin, Germany 8Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats (ICREA), Barcelona, Spain Correspondence to: Laura Soucek, email: lsoucek@vhio.net Correspondence to: Laura Soucek, email: lsoucek@vhio.net Keywords: BET inhibition; MYC; PDAC; NSCLC Published: April 10, 2018 Received: January 04, 2018 Accepted: February 25, 2018 Copyright: Jauset et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License
3.0 (CC BY 3.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and
source are credited. Copyright: Jauset et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License
3.0 (CC BY 3.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and
source are credited. ABSTRACT Effectively treating KRAS-driven tumors remains an unsolved challenge. The
inhibition of downstream signaling effectors is a way of overcoming the issue of direct
targeting of mutant KRAS, which has shown limited efficacy so far. Bromodomain
and Extra-Terminal (BET) protein inhibition has displayed anti-tumor activity in a
wide range of cancers, including KRAS-driven malignancies. Here, we preclinically
evaluate the effect of BET inhibition making use of a new BET inhibitor, BAY 1238097,
against Pancreatic Ductal Adenocarcinoma (PDAC) and Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer
(NSCLC) models harboring RAS mutations both in vivo and in vitro. Our results
demonstrate that BET inhibition displays significant therapeutic impact in genetic
mouse models of KRAS-driven PDAC and NSCLC, reducing both tumor area and tumor
grade. The same approach also causes a significant reduction in cell number of a panel
of RAS-mutated human cancer cell lines (8 PDAC and 6 NSCLC). In this context, we
demonstrate that while BET inhibition by BAY 1238097 decreases MYC expression in
some cell lines, at least in PDAC cells its anti-tumorigenic effect is independent of MYC
regulation. Together, these studies reinforce the use of BET inhibition and prompt
the optimization of more efficient and less toxic BET inhibitors for the treatment of
KRAS-driven malignancies, which are in urgent therapeutic need. BET inhibition is an effective approach against KRAS-driven
PDAC and NSCLC
Toni Jauset1,2,3, Daniel Massó-Vallés1,2, Sandra Martínez-Martín1,2, Marie-Eve
Beaulieu1,3, Laia Foradada1,3, Francesco Paolo Fiorentino4,5, Jun Yokota6, Bernard
Haendler7, Stephan Siegel7, Jonathan R. Whitfield1 and Laura Soucek1,2,3,8
1Vall d’Hebron Institute of Oncology (VHIO), Edifici Cellex, Hospital Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain
2Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Bellaterra, Barcelona, Spain
3Peptomyc S.L., Edifici Cellex, Hospital Vall d’Hebron, Barcelona, Spain
4Kitos Biotech srls, Porto Conte Ricerche, Alghero, Italy
5Department of Biomedical Sciences, University of Sassari, Sassari, Italy
6Genomics and Epigenomics of Cancer Prediction Program, Institut d’Investigació Germans Trias I Pujol (IGTP), Campus Can
Ruti, Barcelona, Spain
7Drug Discovery, Bayer AG, Berlin, Germany
8Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats (ICREA), Barcelona, Spain
Correspondence to: Laura Soucek, email: lsoucek@vhio.net
Keywords: BET inhibition; MYC; PDAC; NSCLC
Received: January 04, 2018 Accepted: February 25, 2018 Published: April 10, 2018
Copyright: Jauset et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License
3.0 (CC BY 3.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and
source are credited.
www.oncotarget.com
Oncotarget, 2018, Vol. 9, (No. 27), pp: 18734-18746
Research Paper www.oncotarget.com www.oncotarget.com INTRODUCTION In this context,
some groups have recently demonstrated the therapeutic
potential of Bromodomain and Extra-terminal (BET) protein
inhibition in NSCLC and PDAC preclinical models [7–12]. Bromodomains recognize the N-terminal acetylated lysines
on histones and recruit chromatin-regulating factors on
promoters and enhancers to control gene expression. The
key role of BET bromodomains in cancer initiation and
maintenance has been highlighted by the development of
small molecule BET bromodomain inhibitors [13]. Such
inhibitors prevent the interaction between bromodomains and
acetylated lysines, displaying significant anti-tumorigenic
activity by regulating key engines of tumorigenesis like MYC
[14, 15]. While the efficacy of BET inhibitors expands to a
wide range of cancers, evidences of de novo and acquired
resistance to some compounds have already been observed
[16–18]. Moreover, there is an increasing concern about the
potential toxicity that BET inhibitors might display in normal
tissues versus cancer cells [19]. [
,
]
To investigate the therapeutic impact of BET
inhibition by BAY 1238097 in PDAC, we treated tumor-
bearing 8 week-old LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER
mice. The animals were treated for 4 weeks with 35 mg/
kg of BAY 1238097 (maximum tolerated dose in mice) or
with vehicle via oral gavage (Figure 1A), pancreata were
collected and tumor burden evaluated by hematoxylin
and eosin (H&E) staining (Supplementary Figure 1A). Histology analysis revealed a dramatic reduction of
the tumor area relative to whole tissue in the treated
samples compared to the control counterparts (28±21%
vs 64±31%) (Figure 1B). In addition, while the tumors
of the control group were mainly graded as PDACs, in
the treated cohort tumors of lower grades (PanIN2 and
PanIN3) were prevalent over PDAC regions (Table 1A). During the course of the treatment, weight was recorded
twice a week as a general read-out of animal health. All
mice showed a progressive increase of weight for both
treated and control groups, although control mice gained
more weight compared to the treated ones (10.12±4.04%
vs 5.45±4.39%, at the endpoint) (Supplementary Figure
2A), indicative of mild drug toxicity. BAY 1238097 is a new BET bromodomain inhibitor
with potent anti-tumor activity in B cell lymphoma and
melanoma models, both in vitro and in vivo [20, 21], which
has recently been evaluated in a phase I dose-escalation trial
in patients with advanced malignancies [22]. In the present
study, we have determined the anti-tumorigenic impact of
BET inhibition against two different immunocompetent
KRAS-driven mouse models. INTRODUCTION Ductal Adenocarcinoma (PDAC), which presents the
lowest survival rates among all cancers, 90% of the tumors
harbor KRAS mutations [2]. Because of its high prevalence
and relevance, KRAS has been extensively studied with
the ultimate objective of finding a safe and effective
therapeutic strategy for patients presenting KRAS-driven
tumors. Despite the knowledge acquired over the past Mutation in the KRAS oncogene is one of the most
frequent events in human cancers. In Non-Small Cell
Lung Cancer (NSCLC), the main lung cancer subtype that
accounts for the highest number of cancer-related deaths,
KRAS is mutated in 30% of the cases [1]. In Pancreatic www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18734 years and the new therapeutic technologies, treating
KRAS-mutated cancers still remains a major health issue. immunocompetent context, we made use of two well-
characterized KRAS-driven genetically engineered mouse
models of PDAC (LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER)
and NSCLC (LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/ER) [23, 24]. In both
models, the constitutively-active KrasG12D mutant allele
is expressed from the endogenous Kras locus after CRE-
mediated recombination. Briefly, constitutive KrasG12D
transcription is prevented by a loxP-STOP-loxP (LSL)
cassette. Expression of CRE recombinase excises the
LSL cassette, activating the expression of KrasG12D and
consequently triggering tumorigenesis in a tissue-specific
manner. In the PDAC model, Cre recombinase is placed
under the control of the Pdx1 promoter, which is activated
in progenitor cells of mouse pancreas [23], while in the
NSCLC model, adenocarcinomas are generated focally
in the lung epithelium by delivering CRE recombinase
through intranasal instillation of adenoviruses (Ad-Cre)
[24]. Additionally, in both mouse models, the p53 wild
type alleles were substituted by an inactive form of P53
(p53ER/ER), which accelerates tumor progression to better
recapitulate the aggressiveness and heterogeneity of
human tumors [25, 26]. j
Indeed, targeting KRAS has proven challenging at
multiple levels and different strategies have been explored:
inhibiting KRAS translation by interfering with its messenger
RNA, impairing KRAS processing using farnesyltransferase
inhibitors, directly targeting the KRAS protein by peptide
inhibitors or instructing the immune system against
mutant KRAS [3]. However, no clinical trial based on
these approaches has so far demonstrated convincing anti-
tumorigenic activity [4, 5]. Others have adopted a different
approach by targeting downstream RAS effectors such as
mTOR, PI3K, Akt or MEK. Although trials are ongoing,
these drugs have not proven to be effective against RAS-
driven cancers in patients thus far [6]. INTRODUCTION We have then expanded the
study to human PDAC and NSCLC cell lines, to investigate
whether the anti-tumorigenic activity of the compound is
dependent on MYC downregulation in a human setting. Our
results indicate that BET bromodomain inhibition might
be an effective therapeutic option for patients harboring
KRAS-mutated PDAC and NSCLC, even independently of
MYC regulation, as seems to be the case in PDAC. In parallel, to assess the efficacy of BAY 1238097
in NSCLC, lung tumors were induced in 8- to 10-week
old LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/ER mice by Ad-Cre administration. Tumors were allowed to develop for 10 weeks and then
animals were treated with BAY 1238097 or vehicle for
4 weeks (Figure 1C). At treatment endpoint, lung tissues
were harvested and H&E-stained (Supplementary Figure
1B). Quantification of tumor area showed an even
more striking effect than in PDAC: both tumor burden
relative to whole lung epithelium and tumor number
were dramatically reduced by BET inhibitor treatment
(7.72±4.17% vs 0.45±0.60% and an average of 10±3 BET inhibition is effective against KRAS-driven
NSCLC and PDAC mouse models In order to preclinically assess the in vivo
efficacy of BET inhibition by BAY 1238097 in an www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18735 vs 2±1 tumors per animal, in untreated versus treated
animals respectively) (Figure 1D). Strikingly, the lungs
of 3 out of 8 treated animals were completely tumor-
free and the remaining 5 presented atypical adenomatous
hyperplasia, while all the untreated mice showed presence
of multiple adenocarcinomas (Table 1B). However, while
the weight of control mice remained stable during the
treatment window, the treated counterparts displayed a
clear decrease (gain of 2.90±3.05 vs loss of 5.97±3.45 at
the endpoint) (Supplementary Figure 2B). In this case and
in accordance with the protocol approved by our ethical
committee, 3 out of 8 treated animals that experienced
more than 10% weight-loss skipped the treatment until
weight recovery. Notably, all mice recovered rapidly - in
only one or two days - indicating that the mild toxicity
of the compound is quickly reversible. However, in this
context, it is worth noting that 2 of the 5 treated animals
still harboring tumors at the end of the experiments had been subject to a “drug holiday” due to weight loss,
indicating that continuous treatment with the compound
might be potentially more effective. Nevertheless, mice
given suboptimal (interrupted) treatment still presented
a clear reduction in tumor burden when compared to
untreated animals (0.77±0.91% vs 7.72±4.17%). Although these results suggest that NSCLC
responds more effectively than PDAC to the treatment
with the BET inhibitor, this therapeutic strategy seems to
be a good therapeutic option against both KRAS-mutated
diseases. BET inhibition downregulates MYC in the
KRAS-driven PDAC and NSCLC mouse cells BET bromodomain inhibition has been reported to
be a potential strategy to inhibit MYC [14], a central node
of tumorigenesis. The BET inhibitor JQ1 has shown an Figure 1: Treatment with BAY 1238097 reduces tumor burden in genetic mouse models of KRAS-driven PDAC and NSCLC. Timeline of the therapeutic intervention with BAY 1238097 in (A) PDAC and (C) NSCLC are represented. In the pancreas model, tumors were
allowed to evolve for 8 weeks to reach the PDAC stage, while in the lung model tumors developed for 10 weeks to adenocarcinomas. Treatment
was then administered for 4 weeks. Therapeutic impact of BAY 1238097 after 4 weeks of treatment in (B) PDAC and (D) NSCLC is shown. Representative images of H&E-stained sections from lungs and pancreas of each model in vehicle (upper panels) and BAY 1238097 treated
samples (lower panels) are shown. Black arrows indicate tumorigenic tissue and green arrows indicate normal tissue. Graphs show quantification
of tumor burden as the percentage of tumor area relative to the whole tissue (tumor+normal tissue). Means and standard deviations are represented. For statistical analysis of the data, two-tailed unpaired t-tests between groups were performed; p<0.0001 (****) and p=0.0002 (***). Figure 1: Treatment with BAY 1238097 reduces tumor burden in genetic mouse models of KRAS-driven PDAC and NSCLC. Timeline of the therapeutic intervention with BAY 1238097 in (A) PDAC and (C) NSCLC are represented. In the pancreas model, tumors were
allowed to evolve for 8 weeks to reach the PDAC stage, while in the lung model tumors developed for 10 weeks to adenocarcinomas. Treatment
was then administered for 4 weeks. Therapeutic impact of BAY 1238097 after 4 weeks of treatment in (B) PDAC and (D) NSCLC is shown. Representative images of H&E-stained sections from lungs and pancreas of each model in vehicle (upper panels) and BAY 1238097 treated
samples (lower panels) are shown. Black arrows indicate tumorigenic tissue and green arrows indicate normal tissue. Graphs show quantification
of tumor burden as the percentage of tumor area relative to the whole tissue (tumor+normal tissue). Means and standard deviations are represented. For statistical analysis of the data, two-tailed unpaired t-tests between groups were performed; p<0.0001 (****) and p=0.0002 (***). BET inhibition downregulates MYC in the
KRAS-driven PDAC and NSCLC mouse cells (B) In the NSCLC model (Supplementary Figure 1B), presence of atypical
adenomatous hyperplasias (AAH), large adenomas and adenocarcinomas were evaluated. “-“ represents tumor-free sections. them mutations in p53 as well (Supplementary Table 1). Importantly, simultaneous LKB1 and KRAS mutations in lung
adenocarcinoma cell lines were previously shown to prevent
MYC downregulation and sensitivity in response to BET
inhibition [9]. Thus, we included 3 LKB1-mutated cell lines
in our NSCLC panel (A549, H23 and H460) (Supplementary
Table 1 A). With this comprehensive experimental system,
we investigated the sensitivity of each cell line to the BET
inhibitor, treating cells with different concentrations of the
compound (0.63, 1.25, 2.5, 5, 10, 20 μM) for 3 days. Even
though all human cell lines responded to 10 μM of BAY
1238097 displaying a reduction of at least 50% of cell density,
various degrees of sensitivity were observed (Figure 3A–3B). Overall, NSCLC cell lines presented higher sensitivity than
PDAC cell lines, as previously observed in the mouse models
both in vivo and in vitro. Among PDAC and NSCLC cell
lines, MIA PaCa-2 and H1299 showed the highest response
respectively. anti-tumorigenic effect by suppressing MYC expression in
both PDAC [12] and NSCLC [9]. In contrast, others have
shown that BET inhibition is able to abolish tumorigenesis
independently of MYC regulation [7, 8]. p
y
g
[
]
To determine the potential regulation of MYC in
murine PDAC and NSCLC tumors treated with BAY
1238097, we generated two cell lines from each tumor
type (PDAC: mPDAC 1.1 and mPDAC 1.2; NSCLC:
MLT#1 and MLT#6) (Supplementary Figure 3) and
treated them in vitro for 3 days with the compound. In
these conditions, BAY 1238097 caused a reduction in cell
number at the nanomolar range in both PDAC and NSCLC
cell lines (Figure 2A–2B). Interestingly, similarly to their
in vivo counterparts, the 2 NSCLC-derived cell lines
showed a higher sensitivity to BAY 1238097 compared to
the PDAC-derived cell lines (IC50 of 0.072 and 0.075 μM
vs 0.236 and 0.150 μM respectively). To check for MYC levels, protein extracts were
obtained after 24 hours of treatment at 2 different
concentrations of the compound (one corresponding
to the average of all 4 IC50s, and the other one 10-fold
higher). Western Blot analysis showed a dose-dependent
decrease of MYC protein levels in all 4 cell lines (Figure
2C), implying that BAY 1238097 is able to regulate MYC
expression in these experimental models. BET inhibition downregulates MYC in the
KRAS-driven PDAC and NSCLC mouse cells In order to establish whether there was any
correlation between efficacy of the BET inhibitor and
regulation of MYC protein levels, all cell lines were
treated with 0.63 μM of the compound (the lowest
concentration tested, which was effective against the most
sensitive cell lines) and protein lysates were collected
24 hours later for Western Blot analysis. Half of the
analyzed cell lines (7 out of the 14: CFPAC-1, AsPC-1,
PaCa3, HPAF-II, Capan-1, HOP-62, and H441) displayed
a reduction of MYC to less than 50% compared to the
untreated cell lines (Figure 3C–3D and Supplementary
Figure 4). BET inhibition downregulates MYC in the
KRAS-driven PDAC and NSCLC mouse cells www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18736 Table 1: Mice treated with BAY 1238097 presented lower tumor grades compared to untreated animals
A
PDAC model
Sample ID
Group
Grades Observed
PC-1
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-2
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-3
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-4
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-5
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-6
Vehicle
PanIN3, PDAC
PC-7
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-8
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-9
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-10
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-11
Vehicle
PDAC
PT-1
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-2
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-3
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-4
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-5
Treated
PanIN3, PDAC
PT-6
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-7
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-8
Treated
PanIN3, PDAC
PT-9
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-10
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
B A
PDAC model
Sample ID
Group
Grades Observed
PC-1
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-2
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-3
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-4
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-5
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-6
Vehicle
PanIN3, PDAC
PC-7
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-8
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-9
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-10
Vehicle
PDAC
PC-11
Vehicle
PDAC
PT-1
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-2
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-3
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-4
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-5
Treated
PanIN3, PDAC
PT-6
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-7
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-8
Treated
PanIN3, PDAC
PT-9
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
PT-10
Treated
PanIN2, PanIN3, PDAC
B
NSCLC model
Sample ID
Group
Grades Observed
LC-1
Vehicle
Adenocarcinoma
LC-2
Vehicle
Adenocarcinoma
LC-3
Vehicle
Adenocarcinoma
LC-4
Vehicle
Adenocarcinoma
LC-5
Vehicle
Adenocarcinoma
LC-6
Vehicle
Adenocarcinoma
LC-7
Vehicle
Adenocarcinoma
LC-8
Vehicle
Adenocarcinoma
LT-1
Treated
-
LT-2
Treated
AAH
(Continued ) www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18737 B B
NSCLC model
Sample ID
Group
Grades Observed
LT-3
Treated
-
LT-4
Treated
AAH
LT-5
Treated
AAH
LT-6
Treated
-
LT-7
Treated
AAH
LT-8
Treated
AAH
(A) Presence of pancreatic intraepithelial lesions (PanIN) of grade 2 and 3 and PDACs were evaluated in the pancreata sections
of the PDAC model (Supplementary Figure 1A). (B) In the NSCLC model (Supplementary Figure 1B), presence of atypical
adenomatous hyperplasias (AAH), large adenomas and adenocarcinomas were evaluated. “-“ represents tumor-free sections. (A) Presence of pancreatic intraepithelial lesions (PanIN) of grade 2 and 3 and PDACs were evaluated in the pancreata sections
of the PDAC model (Supplementary Figure 1A). (B) In the NSCLC model (Supplementary Figure 1B), presence of atypical
adenomatous hyperplasias (AAH), large adenomas and adenocarcinomas were evaluated. “-“ represents tumor-free sections. (A) Presence of pancreatic intraepithelial lesions (PanIN) of grade 2 and 3 and PDACs were evaluated in the pancreata sections
of the PDAC model (Supplementary Figure 1A). MYC downregulation correlates with increased
sensitivity to BET inhibition in NSCLC but not
in PDAC human cell lines Consistently with previously published data [9],
while the cell lines harboring wild type LKB1 in the
NSCLC panel (HOP-62, H1299 and H441) showed a clear
reduction in MYC levels, the cell lines with the mutated
tumor suppressor (A549, H460 and H23) did not show a
comparable regulation. To determine whether the therapeutic effect of BAY
1238097 extends also to human tumors, a panel of NSCLC
(H23, A549, H1299, H460, HOP-62 and H441) and PDAC
(NP18, PANC-1, PaCa3, MIA PaCa-2, HPAF-II, AsPC-
1, Capan-1 and CFPAC-1) human cell lines were treated
with the compound. Of note, all these cell lines harbor
different activating mutations in the KRAS oncogene, with
the exception of H1299 that is NRAS mutated, and most of Six cell lines of our PDAC panel (CFPAC-1, AsPC-
1, PANC-1, MIA PaCa-2, HPAF-II and Capan-1) are www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18738 AC and NSCLC derived cell lines from the LSL KrasG12D;Pdx1 Cre;p53ER/ER and LSL Kra Figure 2: PDAC- and NSCLC-derived cell lines from the LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER and LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/
ER genetic mouse models showed IC50s within the nanomolar range and a dose-dependent MYC decrease in response
to BAY 1238097. 2 cell lines derived from each model were treated with varying concentrations of BAY 1238097 for 3 days. Cell were
then fixed, stained with crystal violet and absorbance was quantified. IC50s were determined for cells derived from the PDAC (A) and
NSCLC (B) models. Means and standard deviations are indicated. (C) A representative Western Blot is shown of all 4 cell lines treated with
0.13 and 1.3 μM of BAY 1238097 for 24 hours. Tubulin and Ponceau S are provided as loading controls. C- and NSCLC-derived cell lines from the LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER and LSL-Kra
use models showed IC50s within the nanomolar range and a dose-dependent MYC decre
7. 2 cell lines derived from each model were treated with varying concentrations of BAY 1238097 for
d with crystal violet and absorbance was quantified. IC50s were determined for cells derived from th
ls. Means and standard deviations are indicated. (C) A representative Western Blot is shown of all 4 cell
of BAY 1238097 for 24 hours. Tubulin and Ponceau S are provided as loading controls. Figure 2: PDAC- and NSCLC-derived cell lines from the LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER and LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/
ER genetic mouse models showed IC50s within the nanomolar range and a dose-dependent MYC decrease in response
to BAY 1238097. MYC downregulation correlates with increased
sensitivity to BET inhibition in NSCLC but not
in PDAC human cell lines 2 cell lines derived from each model were treated with varying concentrations of BAY 1238097 for 3 days. Cell were
then fixed, stained with crystal violet and absorbance was quantified. IC50s were determined for cells derived from the PDAC (A) and
NSCLC (B) models. Means and standard deviations are indicated. (C) A representative Western Blot is shown of all 4 cell lines treated with
0.13 and 1.3 μM of BAY 1238097 for 24 hours. Tubulin and Ponceau S are provided as loading controls. Figure 2: PDAC- and NSCLC-derived cell lines from the LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER and LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/ Figure 2: PDAC- and NSCLC-derived cell lines from the LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER and LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/
ER genetic mouse models showed IC50s within the nanomolar range and a dose-dependent MYC decrease in response
to BAY 1238097. 2 cell lines derived from each model were treated with varying concentrations of BAY 1238097 for 3 days. Cell were
then fixed, stained with crystal violet and absorbance was quantified. IC50s were determined for cells derived from the PDAC (A) and
NSCLC (B) models. Means and standard deviations are indicated. (C) A representative Western Blot is shown of all 4 cell lines treated with
0.13 and 1.3 μM of BAY 1238097 for 24 hours. Tubulin and Ponceau S are provided as loading controls. www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18739 igure 3: Human PDAC and NSCLC cell lines respond to BAY 1238097 and show variable MYC downregulatio
pon BET inhibition. Cell density (relative to untreated controls) of (A) NSCLC and (B) PDAC cell lines after 3 days of treatment
63, 1.25, 2.5, 5, 10 and 20 μM was calculated using crystal violet staining and quantification of absorbance. A two-tailed unpaired t-te
as performed for statistical analysis of each concentration vs. the corresponding untreated control; all comparisons show statistical
gnificant differences (p<0.0001). Western Blots of (C) NSCLC and (D) PDAC cell lines untreated (-) or treated (+) with 0.63 μM of BA
238097 were probed to detect MYC (n=2). Ponceau S staining was used as protein loading control. The dotted line indicates separate blot
uantification of MYC downregulation is represented in Supplementary Figure 4. Figure 3: Human PDAC and NSCLC cell lines respond to BAY 1238097 and show variable MYC downregulation
upon BET inhibition. MYC downregulation correlates with increased
sensitivity to BET inhibition in NSCLC but not
in PDAC human cell lines In those cells, we observed
reduction of MYC protein levels, with the notable
exception of MIA PaCa-2 that, despite harboring wild type
LKB1, did not show any significant MYC downregulation
(Figure 3D and Supplementary Figure 4). The other 2
PDAC cell lines, whose LKB1 status is not present in
COSMIC, responded to the inhibitor with a moderate
(NP18) or strong (PaCa3) reduction in MYC levels too. Interestingly, within the NSCLC cell lines, LKB1-
wild type cells that show a clear decrease of MYC protein
upon BAY 1238097 treatment also display a significantly
higher sensitivity to the inhibitor than the cell lines in
which MYC levels remain unchanged or slightly decreased
(Figure 4A). However, a similar analysis shows that this
correlation is not true in PDAC cells, where the sensitivity
to the inhibitor does not mirror MYC downregulation
(Figure 4B). In summary, in our study, BET inhibition by BAY
1238097 showed remarkable efficacy against NSCLC
and PDAC in vivo, significantly reducing tumor burden
in genetic mouse models of KRAS-driven tumors. The
BET inhibitor also showed efficacy in vitro in RAS-
mutated NSCLC and PDAC human cell lines. The degree
of response partially correlated with a downregulation of
MYC in NSCLC, but not in PDAC, implying the existence
of other molecular effectors that will need to be further
investigated. Taken together, these results demonstrate
that BET bromodomain inhibition may be an effective
anti-cancer approach against RAS-mutated PDAC and
NSCLC, which are in urgent need of new therapeutic
options. Despite these slight differences, the overall efficacy
of BET inhibition in these two models indicates that this
can represent an effective therapeutic approach against
both KRAS-mutated cancers. The effectivity of BET bromodomain inhibitors,
especially JQ1, has been linked to the downregulation of
MYC [14, 15]. However, in some cases, BET inhibition
may exert its anti-tumorigenic effect independently
of MYC inhibition [30]. To investigate this aspect in
a RAS-mutated context, we made use of both mouse-
derived and human cancer cell lines. BET inhibition
does indeed downregulate MYC in most cells. However,
MYC remained largely unchanged upon BAY 1238097
treatment in a subset of 3 NSCLC cell lines. Notably,
these are the only 3 cell lines presenting mutations in
LKB1, which has been previously described to confer
resistance to BET-mediated MYC inhibition [9]. MYC downregulation correlates with increased
sensitivity to BET inhibition in NSCLC but not
in PDAC human cell lines Cell density (relative to untreated controls) of (A) NSCLC and (B) PDAC cell lines after 3 days of treatment at
0.63, 1.25, 2.5, 5, 10 and 20 μM was calculated using crystal violet staining and quantification of absorbance. A two-tailed unpaired t-test
was performed for statistical analysis of each concentration vs. the corresponding untreated control; all comparisons show statistically
significant differences (p<0.0001). Western Blots of (C) NSCLC and (D) PDAC cell lines untreated (-) or treated (+) with 0.63 μM of BAY
1238097 were probed to detect MYC (n=2). Ponceau S staining was used as protein loading control. The dotted line indicates separate blots. Quantification of MYC downregulation is represented in Supplementary Figure 4. www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18740 single alteration in KRAS and evolve, through acquisition
of additional mutations, until the development of
macroscopic adenocarcinomas, in a process that resembles
the natural development of cancer in humans. Importantly,
these experimental animals possess a fully operative
immune system, a key element to evaluate the response to
therapies, both in terms of efficacy and off-target toxicity. In addition, in order to enhance the tumor heterogeneity
and genetic complexity, which constitute notable features
of human cancers, we adopted models in which both
endogenous copies of the p53 tumor suppressor have
been substituted by an impaired p53 (p53ER/ER), allowing
for accelerated mutational rate and the development of
more aggressive and heterogeneous tumors [25, 26]. In
both NSCLC and PDAC genetic mouse models, BAY
1238097 caused a remarkable reduction of the tumor
burden, not only decreasing the tumor area, but also
reducing the tumor grade. Interestingly, the therapeutic
impact was more dramatic in the NSCLC model than in
PDAC, an observation that has been consistent across
the subsequent in vitro studies both in mice and human
cells. This suggests that an intrinsic feature of NSCLC
cells might further sensitize them compared to PDAC
cells. In addition, in vivo, the lower sensitivity of PDAC
could also be related to the stromal fibro-inflammatory
reaction characteristic of these tumors, which may result
in lower drug penetration and, therefore, reduced efficacy,
as previously reported for other drugs [28, 29]. present in the Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer
(COSMIC) and appear to harbor wild type LKB1 alleles
(Supplementary Table 1 B). MYC downregulation correlates with increased
sensitivity to BET inhibition in NSCLC but not
in PDAC human cell lines Hence,
even if LKB1 mutation does not confer resistance to BAY
1238097, our results reinforce the correlation of wild type
LKB1 and the susceptibility to MYC downregulation
upon BET inhibition, which appears to predispose cells
to a higher anti-tumorigenic effect compared to impaired
MYC downregulation due to LKB1 mutations, at least in
NSCLC. In PDAC, all the cell lines whose LKB1 status
is known (6/8) harbor the wild type tumor suppressor and,
consistently with the results in NSCLC, upon treatment
with the BET inhibitor, downregulation of MYC is
preponderant. However, the sensitivity of PDAC cell lines DISCUSSION In cancer generally, and particularly in PDAC and
NSCLC, KRAS is one of the most frequently mutated
oncogenes. Despite the increasing number of studies
and the technological advance in the generation of more
effective therapies, direct KRAS inhibition has proven to
be extremely challenging and, when tested in the clinic,
provided an insufficient therapeutic index in patients [5,
27]. Hence, many groups have instead put their efforts
into targeting Ras indirectly, through the inhibition
of its multiple effector pathways. Among those, BET
bromodomains might constitute a well characterized and
tractable target. BAY 1238097 is a new BET inhibitor
that has been tested against lymphoma [20] and, more
recently, melanoma [21], but its use against KRAS-
mutated tumors has not been yet investigated. Here, we
used genetic mouse models of KRAS-driven NSCLC and
PDAC to underpin the efficacy of BET inhibitors against
KRAS-driven malignancies and preclinically validate
their use in tumors presenting mutations in KRAS. These
models develop tissue-specific lesions that arise from a www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18741 sponse of NSCLC cell lines to BET inhibition correlates with MYC
C-independent sensitivity to the compound. Cell lines were grouped accord
nt (refer to Supplementary Figure 4). In (A), A549, H460 and H23 display no
OP-62, H441 and H1299 show clear MYC downregulation (red line). In (B), PAN
es (blue line), while CFPAC-1, AsPC-1, PaCa3, HPAF-II and Capan-1 display a cl
up of cell lines and standard errors of the mean (SEM) of these values are represe
he curve and SEM were calculated with GraphPad Prism 7 and two-tailed unpaire
nd p=0.2173 (non-significant; n.s.). Figure 4: The higher response of NSCLC cell lines to BET inhibition correlates with MYC downregulation, while
PDAC cells display MYC-independent sensitivity to the compound. Cell lines were grouped according to MYC downregulation
upon BAY 1238097 treatment (refer to Supplementary Figure 4). In (A), A549, H460 and H23 display no change or a moderate MYC
decrease (blue line), while HOP-62, H441 and H1299 show clear MYC downregulation (red line). In (B), PANC1, MIA PaCa-2 and NP18
show minimum MYC changes (blue line), while CFPAC-1, AsPC-1, PaCa3, HPAF-II and Capan-1 display a clear reduction in MYC levels
(red line). Means of the group of cell lines and standard errors of the mean (SEM) of these values are represented. www.oncotarget.com Animal studies is lower than that of NSCLC cell lines, which implies that
other molecular mechanisms besides MYC regulation
might play a key role in mediating the anti-tumorigenic
effect of BET inhibition. Indeed, in contrast to NSCLC,
the degree of MYC regulation in our PDAC cell lines
does not correlate with the response to the inhibitor. This
phenomenon is best exemplified in MIA PaCa-2 and
PaCa3: while MIAPaCa-2 cells barely display changes in
MYC upon treatment, they show the strongest response to
the compound; in contrast, PaCa3 cells, which display the
most dramatic reduction in MYC levels upon treatment,
are one of the least sensitive PDAC cell lines. All the animal studies were performed in accordance
with the ARRIVE guidelines and the 3 Rs rule of
Replacement, Reduction and Refinement principles. Mice were maintained and treated following the protocols
approved by the CEEA (Ethical Committee for the Use
of Experimental Animals) at the Vall d’Hebron Institute
of Oncology, Barcelona, Spain. To generate tumors in the
NSCLC model, 8- to 10-week old LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/ER
mice were anesthetized with isoflurane (5%) and 30μL
of EMEM + 12mM CaCl2 containing 5x107 pfu of Ad-
Cre were administered intranasally. Tumors in the
PDAC model (LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER) were
spontaneously generated by tissue-specific expression of
CRE recombinase. Mice of both models had a C56BL6/
FVBN mixed background. 8-week old and 10 weeks
post-AdCRE infection, for PDAC and NSCLC models
respectively, mice initiated the 4-week treatment. The
animals were treated twice a week (first and fourth day)
by oral gavage with BAY 1238097 (35mg/kg) or an
equivalent volume of NaCl 0.9% (vehicle) for 4 weeks. Weights were measured before every treatment and,
in case of 10% cumulative weight loss relative to the
treatment onset, the regimen was interrupted until weight
was recovered. After the 4-week treatment, the animals
were euthanized with CO2. Either lungs or pancreata
were collected, fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde (PFA) and
paraffin-embedded for histological analysis. Therefore, our study suggests that the MYC-
mediated sensitivity of KRAS-mutated cancer cells to
BET inhibition is highly context dependent and that such
effectivity relies on more than one molecular mechanism. More investigation will need to be undertaken to identify
the key molecular players, other than MYC, that contribute
to the increased sensitivity to BET inhibitors. Histology and sample analysis Tissue sections were H&E-stained to quantify
tumor burden (see Supplementary Figure 1). Accurate
quantifications of tumor and normal tissue areas in the
PDAC model were performed using 4 representative
microscopy images of each section. In the NSCLC model,
tumor and normal epithelium areas were quantified using
the whole section. All areas were quantified using ImageJ. Percentage of tumor tissue was obtained by dividing the
tumor area by the total area (tumor area + normal tissue
area). Tumor grades of both models were blindly rated
by a pathologist. Grades were evaluated considering
previously published characterizations of both models
[23, 24]. Representative images of each tumor grade are
provided as Supplementary Figure 5. DISCUSSION For statistical analysis
of the data, the area under the curve and SEM were calculated with GraphPad Prism 7 and two-tailed unpaired t-test between groups was
performed; p = 0.0080 (**) and p=0.2173 (non-significant; n.s.). Figure 4: The higher response of NSCLC cell lines to BET inhibition correlates with MYC downregulation, while
PDAC cells display MYC-independent sensitivity to the compound. Cell lines were grouped according to MYC downregulation
upon BAY 1238097 treatment (refer to Supplementary Figure 4). In (A), A549, H460 and H23 display no change or a moderate MYC
decrease (blue line), while HOP-62, H441 and H1299 show clear MYC downregulation (red line). In (B), PANC1, MIA PaCa-2 and NP18
show minimum MYC changes (blue line), while CFPAC-1, AsPC-1, PaCa3, HPAF-II and Capan-1 display a clear reduction in MYC levels
(red line). Means of the group of cell lines and standard errors of the mean (SEM) of these values are represented. For statistical analysis
of the data, the area under the curve and SEM were calculated with GraphPad Prism 7 and two-tailed unpaired t-test between groups was
performed; p = 0.0080 (**) and p=0.2173 (non-significant; n.s.). www.oncotarget.com www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18742 BAY 1238097 preparation Chemical structure and synthesis of BAY 1238097
have been described [21]. Lyophilized BAY 1238097
was stored at room temperature in a dry environment
protected from light. Fresh working solutions (3.5g/L)
were prepared weekly by stirring and resuspending the
powder in 0.9% NaCl at 50ºC for 1 hour. HCl was added
dropwise until a clear solution was obtained and pH was
finally adjusted at 3.6. The resulting solution was filtered
through a 0.22μm filter and stored at room temperature
protected from light for a maximum of 7 days for animal
studies or frozen at -20ºC for a maximum of 1 month for
in vitro studies. Animal studies Finally, it should be noted that, unfortunately, a
recent Phase I clinical trial study based on BAY 1238097
was discontinued due to dose-limiting toxicity in patients
[22], indicating that more investigation is needed to
explore and identify BET inhibitors with limited side
effects that retain anti-tumor efficacy within an acceptable
therapeutic window. Other BET bromodomain inhibitors with different
chemical scaffolds are currently being tested in the
clinic for various haematological and solid tumor types,
including pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma and NSCLC. The most advanced ones include CPI-0610, GS-5829,
GSK525762, INCB054329, INCB057643 and BMS-
986158, which are currently being evaluated in Phase I/
II or Phase II studies. It remains to be determined whether
monotherapy with BET bromodomain inhibitors will
show significant efficacy within an acceptable therapeutic
window or whether combinations with other anti-cancer
drugs will be required to increase the therapeutic impact
of BET inhibitors [31, 32]. Western blot For mouse cells, 5×105 cells were plated in 15cm
dishes and treated after 24 hours with BAY 1238097 at
0.13 and 1.3 μM. 24 hours later, cells were scraped and
harvested using cold PBS. Cells were lysed by resuspending
the pellets in RIPA buffer containing HaltTM Protease
Inhibitor Cocktail (Thermo) followed by a 30-minute
incubation at 4ºC and non-solubilized material was pelleted
by centrifugation and discarded. Supernatants containing
protein extracts were quantified by DCTM Protein Assay
(Biorad) and equivalent protein concentrations dissolved
in Laemmli buffer (containing 15% of β-mercaptoethanol). Samples were loaded in 15-well 10% Bis-Tris NuPAGE
Novex Gels. The gel was run in MOPS buffer for 2 hours
at 150V. Protein was transferred to a PVDF membrane
using the standard procedure of the iBlot2 Dry Blotting
System (Life Technologies). Membrane was stained using
Ponceau to visualize total amount of protein as a loading
control. Membrane was then blocked in 5% milk in PBS-
0.1%Tween. MYC was detected using the anti-MYC Y69
antibody (Abcam) and tubulin using the anti-tubulin DM1A
antibody (Sigma). Anti-rabbit and anti-mouse IgG-HRP (GE
Healthcare) were used as secondary antibodies at 1:5,000. Membrane was incubated with Supersignal West Pico
Chemiluminescent Substrate (Thermo) for 5 minutes before ACKNOWLEDGMENTS AND FUNDING We are grateful to Dr. Aniello Cerrato and Dr. Silvestre Vicent Cambra for providing some of the cell
lines used in this study. Also, we would like to thank
the other members of the Soucek laboratory for critical
review of the present manuscript. This research was
supported by grants from European Research Council
(CoG Grant #617473), Fondo de Investigación en Salud
– Instituto de Salud Carlos III (FIS Grant #PI13/01705),
Agency for Management of University and Research
Grants (AGAUR Grant # 2014 SGR 1171) and the
FERO Foundation. TJ was supported by a fellowship
of Instituto de Salud Carlos III. DMV and SMM were
supported by AGAUR. MEB was supported by Fonds de
Recherche Québecois en Santé. FPF was supported by
Fondazione Umberto Veronesi. CONFLICTS OF INTEREST TJ, DMV, SMM, MEB, LF, FPF, JY, JW and LS
declare no conflict of interest. BH and SS are employees at
Bayer AG. This work was supported in part by Bayer AG. Cell lines H1299, H441 and A549 were purchased from ATCC. HOP-62 was purchased from NCI. H460 and H23 were
kindly donated by Dr. Aniello Cerrato and all PDAC cells
were a gift from Dr. Silvestre Vicent Cambra. Cell lines
(with the exception of HPAF-II, NP18 and MIA PaCa-
2) were maintained in RPMI supplemented with 10%
of FBS and 1% of glutamine. HPAF-II and NP18 were
maintained in DMEM supplemented with 10% FBS and www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18743 1% of glutamine and MIA PaCa-2 with additional 2.5%
horse serum. Murine cell lines were derived from the
genetic mouse models of NSCLC (LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/
ER) and PDAC (LSL-KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER) when
adenocarcinomas were fully developed and the presence of
the KRAS(G12D) mutation was confirmed (Supplementary
Figure 3). Murine cells were maintained in DMEM/F12
containing 10% of FBS and 1% of glutamine. revealing. For human cell lines, each one was seeded at
1×106 cells in 15cm dishes and, after 24 hours, either treated
with 0.63 μM of BAY1238097 or left untreated. After 24
hours of treatment, cells were harvested as previously
described. The following procedure is equivalent to the
one applied to the mouse cells. ImageJ quantification of the
MYC bands normalized by total protein content (Ponceau
staining) was calculated to quantify MYC downregulation
(see Supplementary Figure 4). Statistical analysis PDAC- and NSCLC-derived cell lines from the LSL-
KrasG12D;Pdx1-Cre;p53ER/ER and LSL-KrasG12D;p53ER/ER
genetic mouse were seeded in 96-well plates at 500 cells/
well. After 24 hours, cells were treated with increasing
concentrations of BAY 1238097: 0.008, 0.016, 0.031,
0.063, 0.125, 0.250, 0.5, 1, 2 and 4 μM. 3 days after
treatment, cells were fixed with PFA 4% for 20 minutes
and stained with 0.5% crystal violet. Wells were washed
twice using tap water and let dry for 24 hours. Staining
was dissolved in 10% acetic acid and absorbance
measured at 560nm to determine cell density. IC50s were
determined using the XY Dose-response stimulation
equation/log(dose) vs. response option of Graphpad Prism
7. Human cancer cell lines were seeded in 96-well plate
at 1.000 cells/well. Cell density (relative to untreated
controls) after 3 days of treatment at 0.63, 1.25, 2.5, 5,
10 and 20 μM was calculated using crystal violet staining
and quantification of absorbance as previously described. All data were analyzed using GraphPad Prism 7.0
software. Statistical analysis was performed by two-tailed
unpaired Student’s t-test and results were considered
significant when p<0.05. Results are shown as mean ±SD. When mean was calculated using means of different cell
lines (see Figure 4), mean ±SEM was represented. REFERENCES BET bromodomain inhibitors
block growth of pancreatic cancer cells in three-dimensional
collagen. Mol Cancer Ther. 2014; 13: 1907-17. https://doi. org/10.1158/1535-7163.MCT-13-0925. 18. Shi X, Mihaylova VT, Kuruvilla L, Chen F, Viviano S,
Baldassarre M, Sperandio D, Martinez R, Yue P, Bates JG,
Breckenridge DG, Schlessinger J, Turk BE, et al. Loss of
TRIM33 causes resistance to BET bromodomain inhibitors
through MYC- and TGF-beta-dependent mechanisms. Proc
Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2016; 113: E4558-66. https://doi. org/10.1073/pnas.1608319113. 9. Shimamura T, Chen Z, Soucheray M, Carretero J, Kikuchi
E, Tchaicha JH, Gao Y, Cheng KA, Cohoon TJ, Qi J, Akbay
E, Kimmelman AC, Kung AL, et al. Efficacy of BET
bromodomain inhibition in Kras-mutant non-small cell
lung cancer. Clin Cancer Res. 2013; 19: 6183-92. https://
doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-12-3904. 19. Andrieu G, Belkina AC, Denis GV. Clinical trials for
BET inhibitors run ahead of the science. Drug Discov
Today Technol. 2016; 19: 45-50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. ddtec.2016.06.004. 10. Yamamoto K, Tateishi K, Kudo Y, Hoshikawa M, Tanaka
M, Nakatsuka T, Fujiwara H, Miyabayashi K, Takahashi
R, Tanaka Y, Ijichi H, Nakai Y, Isayama H, et al. Stromal
remodeling by the BET bromodomain inhibitor JQ1 suppresses
the progression of human pancreatic cancer. Oncotarget. 2016;
7: 61469-84. https://doi.org/10.18632/oncotarget.11129. 20. Bernasconi E, Gaudio E, Lejeune P, Tarantelli C, Cascione
L, Kwee I, Spriano F, Rinaldi A, Mensah AA, Chung E,
Stathis A, Siegel S, Schmees N, et al. Preclinical evaluation
of the BET bromodomain inhibitor BAY 1238097 for the
treatment of lymphoma. Br J Haematol. 2017; 178: 936-48. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjh.14803. 11. Klingbeil O, Lesche R, Gelato KA, Haendler B, Lejeune
P. Inhibition of BET bromodomain-dependent XIAP and
FLIP expression sensitizes KRAS-mutated NSCLC to pro-
apoptotic agents. Cell Death Dis. 2016; 7: e2365. https://
doi.org/10.1038/cddis.2016.271. 21. Gelato KA, Schockel L, Klingbeil O, Ruckert T, Lesche R,
Toedling J, Kalfon E, Heroult M, Lejeune P, Monning U,
Fernandez-Montalvan AE, Baurle S, Siegel S, et al. Super-
enhancers define a proliferative PGC-1alpha-expressing
melanoma subgroup sensitive to BET inhibition. Oncogene. 2018; 37: 512-21. https://doi.org/10.1038/onc.2017.325. 12. Mazur PK, Herner A, Mello SS, Wirth M, Hausmann S,
Sanchez-Rivera FJ, Lofgren SM, Kuschma T, Hahn SA,
Vangala D, Trajkovic-Arsic M, Gupta A, Heid I, et al. Combined inhibition of BET family proteins and histone
deacetylases as a potential epigenetics-based therapy for
pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma. Nat Med. 2015; 21:
1163-71. https://doi.org/10.1038/nm.3952. 22. REFERENCES 1. Ding L, Getz G, Wheeler DA, Mardis ER, McLellan MD,
Cibulskis K, Sougnez C, Greulich H, Muzny DM, Morgan
MB, Fulton L, Fulton RS, Zhang Q, et al. Somatic mutations
affect key pathways in lung adenocarcinoma. Nature. 2008;
455: 1069-75. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature07423. 2. Biankin AV, Waddell N, Kassahn KS, Gingras MC,
Muthuswamy LB, Johns AL, Miller DK, Wilson PJ, Patch
AM, Wu J, Chang DK, Cowley MJ, Gardiner BB, et al. Pancreatic cancer genomes reveal aberrations in axon
guidance pathway genes. Nature. 2012; 491: 399-405. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11547. www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18744 18744 J, Chesi M, Schinzel AC, McKeown MR, et al. BET
bromodomain inhibition as a therapeutic strategy to target
c-Myc. Cell. 2011; 146: 904-17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. cell.2011.08.017. 3. Cox AD, Fesik SW, Kimmelman AC, Luo J, Der CJ. Drugging the undruggable RAS: Mission possible? Nat Rev
Drug Discov. 2014; 13: 828-51. https://doi.org/10.1038/n
rd4389. 4. McCormick F. K-Ras protein as a drug target. J Mol
Med (Berl). 2016; 94: 253-8. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s00109-016-1382-7. 15. Mertz JA, Conery AR, Bryant BM, Sandy P,
Balasubramanian S, Mele DA, Bergeron L, Sims RJ 3rd. Targeting MYC dependence in cancer by inhibiting BET
bromodomains. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011; 108:
16669-74. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1108190108. 5. Kempf E, Rousseau B, Besse B, Paz-Ares L. KRAS
oncogene in lung cancer: focus on molecularly driven
clinical trials. Eur Respir Rev. 2016; 25: 71-6. https://doi. org/10.1183/16000617.0071-2015. 16. Fong CY, Gilan O, Lam EY, Rubin AF, Ftouni S, Tyler D,
Stanley K, Sinha D, Yeh P, Morison J, Giotopoulos G, Lugo
D, Jeffrey P, et al. BET inhibitor resistance emerges from
leukaemia stem cells. Nature. 2015; 525: 538-42. https://
doi.org/10.1038/nature14888. 6. Vasan N, Boyer JL, Herbst RS. A RAS renaissance:
emerging targeted therapies for KRAS-mutated non-small
cell lung cancer. Clin Cancer Res. 2014; 20: 3921-30. https://doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-13-1762. 17. Kurimchak AM, Shelton C, Duncan KE, Johnson
KJ, Brown J, O'Brien S, Gabbasov R, Fink LS, Li Y,
Lounsbury N, Abou-Gharbia M, Childers WE, Connolly
DC, et al. Resistance to BET Bromodomain Inhibitors Is
Mediated by Kinome Reprogramming in Ovarian Cancer. Cell Rep. 2016; 16: 1273-86. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. celrep.2016.06.091. 7. Lockwood WW, Zejnullahu K, Bradner JE, Varmus H. Sensitivity of human lung adenocarcinoma cell lines to
targeted inhibition of BET epigenetic signaling proteins. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012; 109: 19408-13. https://
doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1216363109. 8. Sahai V, Kumar K, Knab LM, Chow CR, Raza SS, Bentrem
DJ, Ebine K, Munshi HG. REFERENCES Postel-Vinay S, Herbschleb K, Massard C, Woodcock V,
Ocker M, Wilkinson G, Walter A, Ewerton F, Poelman
M, Middleton M, Soria JC. First-in-human phase I dose
escalation study of the Bromodomain and Extra-Terminal
motif (BET) inhibitor BAY 1238097 in subjects with
advanced malignancies. Eur J Cancer. 2016; 69: S7-S8. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0959-8049(16)32620-X. 13. Shi J, Vakoc CR. The mechanisms behind the therapeutic
activity of BET bromodomain inhibition. Mol Cell. 2014;
54: 728-36. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2014.05.016. 23. Hingorani SR, Petricoin EF, Maitra A, Rajapakse V, King C,
Jacobetz MA, Ross S, Conrads TP, Veenstra TD, Hitt BA,
Kawaguchi Y, Johann D, Liotta LA, et al. Preinvasive and 14. Delmore JE, Issa GC, Lemieux ME, Rahl PB, Shi J,
Jacobs HM, Kastritis E, Gilpatrick T, Paranal RM, Qi www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18745 invasive ductal pancreatic cancer and its early detection in
the mouse. Cancer Cell. 2003; 4: 437-50. 28. Erkan M, Hausmann S, Michalski CW, Fingerle AA,
Dobritz M, Kleeff J, Friess H. The role of stroma in
pancreatic cancer: diagnostic and therapeutic implications. Nat Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2012; 9: 454-67. https://doi. org/10.1038/nrgastro.2012.115. 24. Jackson EL, Willis N, Mercer K, Bronson RT, Crowley D,
Montoya R, Jacks T, Tuveson DA. Analysis of lung tumor
initiation and progression using conditional expression of
oncogenic K-ras. Genes Dev. 2001; 15: 3243-8. https://doi. org/10.1101/gad.943001. 29. Provenzano PP, Cuevas C, Chang AE, Goel VK, Von Hoff
DD, Hingorani SR. Enzymatic targeting of the stroma
ablates physical barriers to treatment of pancreatic ductal
adenocarcinoma. Cancer Cell. 2012; 21: 418-29. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.ccr.2012.01.007. 25. Soucek L, Whitfield JR, Sodir NM, Masso-Valles D,
Serrano E, Karnezis AN, Swigart LB, Evan GI. Inhibition of
Myc family proteins eradicates KRas-driven lung cancer in
mice. Genes Dev. 2013; 27: 504-13. https://doi.org/10.1101/
gad.205542.112. 30. Wirth M, Mahboobi S, Kramer OH, Schneider G. Concepts to
Target MYC in Pancreatic Ca ncer. Mol Cancer Ther. 2016;
15: 1792-8. https://doi.org/10.1158/1535-7163.MCT-16-0050. 26. Masso-Valles D, Jauset T, Serrano E, Sodir NM, Pedersen
K, Affara NI, Whitfield JR, Beaulieu ME, Evan GI, Elias
L, Arribas J, Soucek L. Ibrutinib exerts potent antifibrotic
and antitumor activities in mouse models of pancreatic
adenocarcinoma. Cancer Res. 2015; 75: 1675-81. https://
doi.org/10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-14-2852. 31. Baumgart SJ, Haendler B. Exploiting Epigenetic Alterations
in Prostate Cancer. Int J Mol Sci. 2017; 18. https://doi. org/10.3390/ijms18051017. 32. Doroshow DB, Eder JP, LoRusso PM. BET inhibitors: a
novel epigenetic approach. Ann Oncol. 2017; 28: 1776-87. https://doi.org/10.1093/annonc/mdx157. 27. Dang CV, Reddy EP, Shokat KM, Soucek L. REFERENCES Drugging the
'undruggable' cancer targets. Nat Rev Cancer. 2017; 17:
502-8. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrc.2017.36. www.oncotarget.com Oncotarget 18746
|
https://openalex.org/W1975025884
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc4061208?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
High dosage of agmatine alleviates pentylenetetrazole-induced chronic seizures in rats possibly by exerting an anticonvulsive effect
|
Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine
| 2,014
|
cc-by
| 4,434
|
Introduction Agmatine is an endogenous amine synthesized via the decar
boxylation of L‑arginine mediated by arginine decarboxylase. Agmatine is expressed in a variety of animal organs, particu
larly the brain, where it acts as a novel neurotransmitter or
neuromodulator (1).i Although the specific physiological actions of agmatine
have yet to be elucidated, numerous studies have confirmed that
agmatine significantly inhibits seizures induced by maximal
electroshock and pentylenetetrazole in rat models (2‑6). The
selective reduction of N‑methyl‑D‑aspartic acid (NMDA)
receptor‑mediated activity (3,4) and the inhibition of nitric
oxide synthase activity (2,6) have been proposed to contribute
to this inhibitory effect on seizures. However, the majority
of previous studies have investigated the effect of agmatine
on acute seizures, and only a few studies have used chronic
epilepsy animal models, which are similar to the pathological
physiology of clinical epileptic patients. It was hypothesized
that agmatine may also have an anticonvulsive effect in
chronic epilepsy. Therefore, in the present study, pentylenetet
razole‑induced chronic epilepsy rat models were employed in
order to examine the anticonvulsive effects of agmatine. DOI: 10.3892/etm.2014.1711 Abstract. The aim of the present study was to investigate the
mechanism underlying the effects of different doses of agma
tine in rats with chronic epilepsy. To generate chronic epilepsy
models, rats pretreated with different doses of agmatine (20,
40 and 80 mg/kg) were intraperitoneally injected with pentyl
enetetrazole (35 mg/kg) for 28 consecutive days. Epileptic
behavior was observed using behavioral measurements of
convulsion for 1 h after each treatment with pentylenetetra
zole. Morphological alterations of the hippocampal neurons
were also observed using hematoxylin and eosin staining. In
addition, the expression levels of glial fibrillary acidic protein
and inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) in the hippocampus
were detected by immunohistochemistry. Furthermore, reverse
transcription polymerase chain reaction was performed to
detect the mRNA expression of two subunits (NR1 and NR2B)
of the N‑methyl‑D‑aspartic acid (NMDA) receptor in the rat
hippocampus. The results demonstrated that administration of
agmatine (80 mg/kg) significantly decreased the daily average
grade of epileptic seizures and also reduced neuronal loss and
astrocyte hyperplasia in the hippocampal area. Furthermore,
agmatine (80 mg/kg) affected the mRNA expression levels of
the NR1 subunit of the NMDA receptor, however, agmatine
had no effect on the expression of iNOS in the hippocampus. Higher doses of agmatine inhibited the effect of pentylene
tetrazole in rats, reduced astrocytic hyperplasia and neuronal
damage in the hippocampus caused by seizures and selectively
reduced the expression of the NR1 subunit of NMDA. Our results suggest that agmatine has an anticonvulsive effect in
chronic epilepsy. EXPERIMENTAL AND THERAPEUTIC MEDICINE 8: 73-78, 2014 EXPERIMENTAL AND THERAPEUTIC MEDICINE 8: 73-78, 2014 Received December 4, 2013; Accepted March 27, 2014 Received December 4, 2013; Accepted March 27, 2014 Received December 4, 2013; Accepted March 27, 2014 Correspondence to: Dr Huiqin Xu, Department of Neurology, The
First Affiliated Hospital and Research Institute of Experimental
Neurobiology, Wenzhou Medical College, 2 Fuxue Lane, Wenzhou,
Zhejiang 325000, P.R. China
E‑mail: 13732479011@163.com HUIQIN XU1, FUYONG OU2, PEI WANG1, MANGDULA NAREN1, DONGPEI TU1 and RONGYUAN ZHENG1 HUIQIN XU1, FUYONG OU2, PEI WANG1, MANGDULA NAREN1, DONGPEI TU1 and RO 1Department of Neurology, The First Affiliated Hospital and Research Institute of Experimental Neurobiology,
Wenzhou Medical College, Wenzhou, Zhejiang 325000; 2Department of Neurology,
Chenzhou No. 1 People's Hospital, Chenzhou, Hunan 423000, P.R. China XU et al: AGMATINE ALLEVIATES SEIZURES IN RATS 74 The rats were randomly divided into the following five
groups, with 10 rats in each group: i) the saline‑saline group
(normal control group), saline was injected as the nega
tive control; ii) the pentylenetetrazole‑saline group (model
control group), the rats were treated with saline 30 min prior
to intraperitoneal injections of pentylenetetrazole; iii) the
pentylenetetrazole low‑dose agmatine group (pentylenetetra
zole + 20 mg/kg agmatine; Sigma); iv) the pentylenetetrazole
medium‑dose agmatine group (pentylenetetrazole + 40 mg/kg
agmatine); and v) the pentylenetetrazole high‑dose agmatine
group (pentylenetetrazole + 80 mg/kg agmatine). Agmatine
pretreatment was administered 30 min prior to the pentylene
tetrazole injections. was performed in a similar manner, however, the primary
antibodies were substituted with rabbit anti‑mouse iNOS anti
body (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Inc.). A Leica microscope
equipped with a digital camera was used for the examination
and imaging of the sections (Leica, Solms, Germany). Image analysis. To quantify the GFAP expression, the average
number of positive cells in each section were counted in a
blinded manner in five randomly selected high power fields
in the hippocampal CA1 and CA3 areas (magnification, x20),
and plotted using Prism 3.0 software (GraphPad Software,
Inc., San Diego, CA, USA). To quantify the iNOS expression,
Image‑Pro Plus 6.0 (Media Cybernetics, Inc., Rockville, MD,
USA) was used to analyze the iNOS immunohistochemical
images and to calculate the average light density values
(IOD/area) of each section of five randomly selected high
power fields in the hippocampal CA1 and CA3 areas (magni
fication, x40). All the sections were analyzed under the same
light intensity and magnification. Behavioral observations of convulsion. The behavior of each
rat was observed for 1 h after pentylenetetrazole injection. The seizure activity was scored according to the following
five‑point scale as previously described by Fathollahi et al (8):
stage 0, no response; stage 1, ear and facial twitching; stage 2,
convulsive wave throughout the body; stage 3, myoclonic
jerks; stage 4, turn onto their side; stage 5, turn over onto
their back, generalized tonic‑clonic seizures. The convulsion
grade of each rat was recorded daily. If the rat maintained the
epileptic behavior (i.e. at stage 2) for five consecutive days, it
was regarded as kindling and the kindling rate was calculated. RT‑PCR. RT‑PCR was performed using the Quant One
Step RT‑PCR kit (Tiangen Biotech, Co., Ltd., Beijing,
China) according to the manufacturer's instructions. XU et al: AGMATINE ALLEVIATES SEIZURES IN RATS The
thermal cycler parameters were: 4 min at 94˚C followed by
30 cycles of 30 sec at 94˚C, 30 sec at 58˚C, 40 sec at 72˚C
and then 10 min at 72˚C. The following specific primers
were used: NR1, forward 5'‑GCTGCACGCCTTTATCTG‑3'
and reverse 5'‑TCCTACGGGCATCCTTGT‑3'; NR2b,
forward 5'‑CACGGTGCCTTCAGAGTT‑3' and reverse
5'‑CCTCCTCCAAGGTGACAA‑3'. The PCR products
were separated using electrophoresis on a 2.0% agarose gel. The intensity of the bands was analyzed using BioSense
SC-810 Gel Documentation System (Shanghai Bio-Tech Co.,
Ltd., Shanghai, China) and Gel-Pro 3.1 software (Media
Cybernetics, Inc., Bethesda, MD, USA). Sample preparation. After the rats were decapitated, the entire
brain was rapidly removed and dissected on ice. One half of the
hippocampus was immediately flash frozen in liquid nitrogen
and stored at ‑80˚C for subsequent reverse transcription poly
merase chain reaction (RT‑PCR) experiments. The other half
was immersed in 4% paraformaldehyde (Shanghai Generay
Biotech Co., Ltd., Shanghai, China) for 24 h at 4˚C and then
paraffin embedded. The paraffin‑embedded brain was then
cut into 5‑µm thick coronal sections using a microtome. For
each rat, several brain sections were collected for subsequent
experiments. Statistical analysis. Statistical analysis was performed using
SPSS 180 statistical software (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). The values are expressed as the mean ± standard error of the
mean. Comparisons among multiple groups were performed
using a one‑way analysis of variance and a least significant
difference post hoc test. P<0.05 was considered to indicate a
statistically significant difference. Hematoxylin and eosin staining. Two paraffin slices were
selected and stained using hematoxylin and eosin as previ
ously described (9). In the slices, hippocampal CA3, CA1 and
DG regions were examined using a light microscope (BX51M;
Olympus, Tokyo, Japan; magnification, x10) to observe
morphological alterations of the hippocampal neurons. Materials and methods Animals. A total of 50 healthy, male adult Sprague‑Dawley rats
(weighing between 170 and 200 g; The Experimental Animal
Center of Wenzhou Medical College, Wenzhou, China) were
used in the present study. Convulsion was induced in the rats
using pentylenetetrazole (Sigma, St. Louis, MO, USA) as
previously described (7). Pentylenetetrazole (35 mg/kg) was
administered to rats in the agmatine pretreatment and model
control groups each morning via intraperitoneal injection
for 28 consecutive days. The present study was approved by
the ethics committee at the Medical University of Wenzhou
(Wenzhou, Zhejiang, China) and was in accordance with the
Chinese laws for animal protection. Correspondence to: Dr Huiqin Xu, Department of Neurology, The
First Affiliated Hospital and Research Institute of Experimental
Neurobiology, Wenzhou Medical College, 2 Fuxue Lane, Wenzhou,
Zhejiang 325000, P.R. China
E‑mail: 13732479011@163.com Correspondence to: Dr Huiqin Xu, Department of Neurology, The
First Affiliated Hospital and Research Institute of Experimental
Neurobiology, Wenzhou Medical College, 2 Fuxue Lane, Wenzhou,
Zhejiang 325000, P.R. China
E‑mail: 13732479011@163.com Key words: agmatine, chronic seizures, pentylenetetrazole,
N‑methyl‑D‑aspartic acid receptor Results Immunohistochemistry. Immunostaining was performed
on the brain slices using the Polink‑2 Plus® HRP Polymer
Detection System (PV‑9001; GBI Labs, Mukilteo, WA, USA)
as previously described (9). Then, the sections were briefly
dehydrated through a graded series of ethanol and incubated
with rabbit anti‑mouse glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP)
antibody (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Inc., Santa Cruz, CA,
USA). The sections were washed with phosphate‑buffered
saline (Shanghai Generay Biotech Co., Ltd.) and then incu
bated with poly horseradish peroxidase anti‑rabbit secondary
antibody (PV‑9001). The avidin‑biotin complex and diamino
benzidine were used to obtain a visible reaction product. As
a negative control, the specimens in the control experiments
were processed without primary or secondary antibodies. The
immunostaining of inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) Agmatine treatment reduces the severity of pentylenetetra
zole‑induced chronic seizures. To evaluate the effect of agmatine
on chronic seizures induced by pentylenetetrazole, convulsions
were measured using a five‑point scale, as previously described
by Fathollahi et al (8). Following 20 days of treatment, the
majority of the rats reached a completely kindled condition. The
daily average seizure grades in the 40 and 80 mg/kg agmatine
groups were significantly lower compared with those of the
model control group (P<0.001; Fig. 1A). However, no significant
difference in the kindling rate was observed among the agma
tine and model control groups (Table I). Agmatine has no effect on the expression of iNOS. To investigate
the effect of agmatine on the expression of iNOS, the average EXPERIMENTAL AND THERAPEUTIC MEDICINE 8: 73-78, 2014 75 Table I. Severity and the kindling rate of rats in each treatment group. Seizure grade
‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑
Group
Sample (n)
Survival rate
Moderate (≤Ⅲ)
Severe (≥Ⅲ)
Kindling rate
Normal control (A)
10
‑
‑
‑
‑
Model control (B)
10
10/10
5/10
5/10
10/10
Agmatine 20 mg/kg (C1)
10
10/10
6/10
4/10
10/10
Agmatine 40 mg/kg (C2)
10
10/10
6/10
4/10
10/10
Agmatine 80 mg/kg (C3)
10
10/10
7/10
3/10
8/10
The rate of severe grade seizures in agmatine groups was markedly decreased compared with the model control group, whilst no significant
difference was observed between the kindling rates among the groups. Table I. Severity and the kindling rate of rats in each treatment group. The rate of severe grade seizures in agmatine groups was markedly decreased compared with the model control group, whilst no significant
difference was observed between the kindling rates among the groups. Figure 1. Results Decreased neuronal injury in the hippocampal region of agmatine‑treated rats. The hippocampus region of rats was sectioned and stained using
hematoxylin and eosin to compare the severity of neuron loss between the (A) normal control, (B) model control and (C) the agmatine groups (magnification, x4). B A C C A B Figure 2. Decreased neuronal injury in the hippocampal region of agmatine‑treated rats. The hippocampus region of rats was sectioned and stained using
hematoxylin and eosin to compare the severity of neuron loss between the (A) normal control, (B) model control and (C) the agmatine groups (magnification, x4). By contrast, in the model control group, GFAP‑positive cells
were significantly increased in number and exhibited more
intense staining, as well as thicker and extended neurites. In
the agmatine groups, GFAP expression was increased to a
certain extent, however, the number of GFAP‑positive cells
was reduced and the staining was less intense compared with
the model control group. The cells were decreased in size and
the neurites were relatively thinner and shorter. The differ
ences between the agmatine groups and the model control
group were significant (P<0.05), in particular for the 40 and
80 mg/kg agmatine groups (P<0.01), as shown in Fig. 3B. These results demonstrated that agmatine suppressed astro
cytic hyperplasia. of agmatine had marked anticonvulsive effects (3‑5). In the
present study, only rats treated with a high dose of agmatine
(40 and 80 mg/kg/d) demonstrated clear inhibitory effects. This may be due to the rapid metabolism of agmatine in the
peripheral tissues. In addition, the blood‑brain barrier may
also restrict the penetration of agmatine into the brain (6). Therefore, an adequate peripheral dose is required to produce
apparent protective effects. However, this is controversial as
certain studies have found that agmatine administered alone
at doses of ≤100 mg/kg had no affect on the threshold and
provided no protection against seizures (7). In fact, in the
present study repeated administration of agmatine did not
decrease the kindling rate. This suggests that agmatine is
unable to alter the threshold and this may be associated with
under‑dosing, which requires investigation in future studies. Agmatine treatment decreases the expression of the NMDA
receptor. In order to analyze the alterations in the expression
of the NMDA receptor induced by agmatine, RT‑PCR was
performed to detect NR1 and NR2b mRNA expression in the
rat hippocampus (Fig. 4A). Results (A) Daily behavior scores for each group. The daily average scores of the 40 and 80 mg/kg agmatine groups were significantly decreased compared
with the model control group (P=0.025 and 0.02, respectively). (B) Average light density (IOD/Area) values of inducible nitric oxide synthase expression in
the CA1 and CA3 regions of the hippocampus (CA1, P<0.05; CA3, P<0.01; compared with the normal control group). *P<0.05, **P<0.01. AGM, agmatine; PTZ,
pentylenetetrazole. A
B A B Figure 1. (A) Daily behavior scores for each group. The daily average scores of the 40 and 80 mg/kg agmatine groups were significantly decreased compared
with the model control group (P=0.025 and 0.02, respectively). (B) Average light density (IOD/Area) values of inducible nitric oxide synthase expression in
the CA1 and CA3 regions of the hippocampus (CA1, P<0.05; CA3, P<0.01; compared with the normal control group). *P<0.05, **P<0.01. AGM, agmatine; PTZ,
pentylenetetrazole. light density (IOD/Area) values of iNOS‑positive regional
expression in the CA1 and CA3 areas of the hippocampus
were obtained. The data revealed that the pentylenetetrazole
group had significantly higher values compared with the
normal group (P<0.05). A decreasing trend was observed in
the agmatine‑treated rats compared with the rats in the model
control group, however, no significant difference was observed. This suggested that iNOS activity may be increased in chronic
epileptic seizures, however, the long‑term usage of agmatine
does not significantly inhibit iNOS expression (Fig. 1B). hippocampal pyramidal cells exhibited regular morphological
integrity, whereas, in the model control group, cell loss was
observed and the cells were irregularly distributed and
exhibited abnormal structures, as well as wider interspaces. By contrast, the agmatine group also exhibited neuronal loss,
however, with reduced severity, particularly in the hippo
campal area (Fig. 2). This observation indicated that agmatine
treatment partially decreased cell injury in the hippocampal
area. Treatment with agmatine suppresses astrocytic hyperplasia. To investigate how agmatine treatment affects astrocytic
hyperplasia, hematoxylin and eosin staining and image
analysis were performed (Fig. 3A). In the CA1 and CA3
hippocampal regions of normal rats, GFAP‑positive cells were
scattered, light brown‑yellow in color and reduced in number. Agmatine treatment decreases cell injury in the hippocampal
area of pentylenetetrazole‑treated rats. To determine whether
agmatine alleviated cell injury in the hippocampal area of
pentylenetetrazole‑treated rats, hippocampal pyramidal cells
were observed under a microscope. In the normal group, XU et al: AGMATINE ALLEVIATES SEIZURES IN RATS 76 A
B
C
Figure 2. Results Compared with the model control
group, the quantity of NR1 mRNA in the agmatine groups
(40 and 80 mg/kg) was significantly decreased (P<0.01),
suggesting that pretreatment with agmatine may suppress
the actions of the hippocampal NR1 (Fig. 4B). However, the
low‑dose agmatine group (20 mg/kg) showed no significant
difference compared with the model control group (Fig. 4B). In
addition, no significant difference in NR2b mRNA expression
was observed among all the groups (data not shown). These
results indicated that treatment with higher concentrations of
agmatine decreased the expression of the NMDA receptor. Astrocytes are important glial cells in the brain. Following
epilepsy, the number of astrocytes increases and alterations in
morphology and function are observed. Astrocytes have been
demonstrated to be important in the mechanisms underlying
epilepsy (10). For example, it has been demonstrated that they
are involved in the maintenance of the inflammatory state
during epilepsy by releasing inflammatory cytokines. These
cytokines directly alter the excitability of the neurons and
promote mossy fiber budding of the dentate gyrus to form
an excitability loop, which may induce seizures (11). In the
present study, GFAP immunohistochemistry demonstrated
that agmatine was able to significantly reduce hippocampal
astrocytic cell proliferation in a dose‑dependent manner
following pentylenetetrazole‑induced seizures. This may
contribute to the inhibitory effect of agmatine on seizures. The activation of NMDA receptors is responsible for the
development of seizures and their binding sites are upregu
lated in different types of convulsant animal models. NMDA
receptor antagonists have previously been demonstrated to
inhibit convulsion (12). In addition, agmatine has been shown
to selectively modulate NMDA subunits in rat hippocampal
neurons (12) and mediate anticonvulsive actions (3,4). In
accordance with previous studies, RT‑PCR results from
the present study demonstrated that the mRNA expression
of NR1 was significantly inhibited in the agmatine groups
(40 and 80 mg/kg). However, this was only observed in animals
repeatedly treated with large doses of agmatine. The reason
for this may be that only 1% of the injected agmatine reaches
the brain (4). However, the same result was not observed for
NMDA R2b mRNA expression. Discussion In the present study, it was demonstrated that consecutive
administration of agmatine provided protection against pentyl
enetetrazole‑induced chronic seizures in rats. These results are
consistent with previous studies that demonstrated the inhibi
tory effect of agmatine in acute seizure animal models (2,3). Furthermore, in the present study, rats treated with agmatine
exhibited significantly reduced astrocytic hyperplasia and
neurological defects in the hippocampal area compared with
rats in the model control group. Furthermore, the expres
sion of the NMDA1 receptor was selectively suppressed in
agmatine‑treated rats. The results from the present study are in accordance
with several previous studies demonstrating that high doses EXPERIMENTAL AND THERAPEUTIC MEDICINE 8: 73-78, 2014 77 Figure 3. (A) Hyperplasia of astrocytes in the hippocampus of agmatine‑treated rats was reduced. Immunostaining of GFAP was performed on the sections to
detect increased astrocyte expression. The expression of astrocytes in the (1a and 1a') normal control group and the (1c and 1c') agmatine group was decreased
compared with the (1b and 1b') model control group (magnification, x4; boxed area, magnification, x20). (B) The number of GFAP positive cells was counted
from five randomly selected microscopic fields (magnification, x20) and plotted. Data are presented as the mean ± the standard deviation. *P<0.05, **P<0.01,
compared with the normal control group. ΔP<0.05, ΔΔP<0.01, for comparisons between the agmatine group and the model control group. AGM, agmatine; PTZ,
pentylenetetrazole; GFAP, glial fibrillary acidic protein. A
B A A Figure 3. (A) Hyperplasia of astrocytes in the hippocampus of agmatine‑treated rats was reduced. Immunostaining of GFAP was performed on the sections to
detect increased astrocyte expression. The expression of astrocytes in the (1a and 1a') normal control group and the (1c and 1c') agmatine group was decreased
compared with the (1b and 1b') model control group (magnification, x4; boxed area, magnification, x20). (B) The number of GFAP positive cells was counted
from five randomly selected microscopic fields (magnification, x20) and plotted. Data are presented as the mean ± the standard deviation. *P<0.05, **P<0.01,
compared with the normal control group. ΔP<0.05, ΔΔP<0.01, for comparisons between the agmatine group and the model control group. AGM, agmatine; PTZ,
pentylenetetrazole; GFAP, glial fibrillary acidic protein. B B B B Figure 3. (A) Hyperplasia of astrocytes in the hippocampus of agmatine‑treated rats was reduced. Immunostaining of GFAP was performed on the sections to
detect increased astrocyte expression. XU et al: AGMATINE ALLEVIATES SEIZURES IN RATS 78 4. Feng Y, LeBlanc MH and Regunathan S: Agmatine reduces extra
cellular glutamate during pentylenetetrazole‑induced seizures in
rat brain: a potential mechanism for the anticonvulsive effects. Neurosci Lett 390: 129‑133, 2005. results of hippocampal morphology suggest that agmatine may
decrease cell loss in the rat hippocampus. Agmatine exhibits
seizure‑suppressive and neuroprotective capabilities and may
therefore protect against convulsions on seizure-suppressive
and neuroprotective capabilities. 5. Luszczki JJ, Czernecki R, Wojtal K, Borowicz KK and
Czuczwar SJ: Agmatine enhances the anticonvulsant action of
Phenobarbital and valproate in the mouse maximal electroshock
seizure model. J Neural Transm 115: 1485‑1494, 2008. Several studies have also suggested that the inhibitory
effect of agmatine may be important in its anticonvulsive
properties (2,6). In the present study, the expression of iNOS
was found to increase in the hippocampus following pentyl
enetetrazole administration. However, agmatine was not found
to significantly inhibit iNOS expression. p
seizure model. J Neural Transm 115: 1485‑1494, 2008 6. Bahremand A, Ziai P, Khodadad TK, Payandemehr B, et al:
Agmatine enhances the anticonvulsant effect of lithium chloride
on pentylenetetrazole‑induced seizures in mice: Involvement of
L‑arginine/nitricoxide pathway. Epilepsy Behav 18: 186‑192,
2010. 7. Obay BD, Taşdemir E, Tümer C, Bilgin H and Atmaca M: Dose
dependent effects of ghrelin on pentylenetetrazole‑induced
oxidative stress in a rat seizure model. Peptides 29: 448‑455,
2008. In conclusion, the present study demonstrated that agma
tine has a protective effect against pentylenetetrazole‑induced
chronic seizures and that its effective dose is relatively large
(80 mg/kg). Agmatine treatment results in decreased astrocytic
hyperplasia, neuronal cell loss and selective suppression of the
NMDA1 receptor in the hippocampus. The majority of clinical
epilepsy cases are diagnosed as long‑term repeated chronic
epilepsy. Thus, further investigation regarding the function of
agmatine in chronic epilepsy is particularly important. 8. Fathollahi Y, Motamedi F, Semnanian S and Zardoshti M:
Examination of persistent effects of repeated administration
of pentylenetetrazol on rat hippocampal CA1: evidence from
in vitro study on hippocampal slices. Brain Res 758: 92‑98, 1997. y
pp
p
9. Wang XS, Chen YY, Shang XF, et al: Idazoxan attenuates spinal
cord injury by enhanced astrocytic activation and reduced
microglial activation in rat experimental autoimmune encepha
lomyelitis. Brain Res 1253: 198‑209, 2009. y
,
10. Stringer JL: Repeated seizures increase GFAP and vimentin in
the hippocampus. Brain Res 717: 147‑153, 1996. pp
p
11. XU et al: AGMATINE ALLEVIATES SEIZURES IN RATS Ravizza T, Gagliardi B, Noé F, Boer K, Aronica E and Vezzani A:
Innate and adaptive immunity during epileptogenesis and
spontaneous seizures: evidence from experimental models and
human temporal lobe epilepsy. Neurobiol Dis 29: 142‑160, 2008. Acknowledgements This study was supported by grants from the Building Funding
of Wenzhou Science & Technology Bureau Fund (grant
no. Y20070031). p
p
p y
12. Ekonomou A and Angelatou F: Upregulation of NMDA receptors
in hippocampus and cortex in the pentylenetetrazol‑induced
‘kindling’ model of epilepsy. Neurochem Res 24: 1515‑1522,
1999. 13. Bengzon J, Kokaia Z, Elmér E, Nanobashvili A, Kokaia M and
Lindvall O: Apoptosis and proliferation of dentate gyrus neurons
after single and intermittent limbic seizures. Proc Natl Acad Sci
USA 94: 10432‑10437, 1997. 1. Raasch W, Schäfer U, Chun J and Dominiak P: Biological
significance of agmatine, an endogenous ligand at imidazoline
binding sites. Br J Pharmacol 133: 755‑780, 2001. 3. Su RB, Wei XL, Zheng JQ, Liu Y, Lu XQ and Li J: Anticonvulsive
effect of agmatine in mice. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 77:
345‑349, 2004. Discussion The expression of astrocytes in the (1a and 1a') normal control group and the (1c and 1c') agmatine group was decreased
compared with the (1b and 1b') model control group (magnification, x4; boxed area, magnification, x20). (B) The number of GFAP positive cells was counted
from five randomly selected microscopic fields (magnification, x20) and plotted. Data are presented as the mean ± the standard deviation. *P<0.05, **P<0.01,
compared with the normal control group. ΔP<0.05, ΔΔP<0.01, for comparisons between the agmatine group and the model control group. AGM, agmatine; PTZ,
pentylenetetrazole; GFAP, glial fibrillary acidic protein. A A
B
Figure 4. (A) Detection of NMDAR1 mRNA expression in the rat hippocampus using reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction. A, normal control
group; B, model control group; C1, C2 and C3, agmatine groups (20, 40 and 80 mg/kg, respectively). (B) Quantification of NMDAR1 mRNA expression of the
five groups. The Y axis indicates the ratio of optical density (OD) of the samples to the corresponding internal standard (β‑actin). Data are expressed as the
mean ± standard error of the mean (n=10). *P<0.05, **P<0.01, compared with the normal control group. ΔP<0.01, for comparisons between the agmatine group
and the model control group. NMDAR1, N‑methyl‑D‑aspartic acid receptor; AGM, agmatine; PTZ, pentylenetetrazole. A B Figure 4. (A) Detection of NMDAR1 mRNA expression in the rat hippocampus using reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction. A, normal control
group; B, model control group; C1, C2 and C3, agmatine groups (20, 40 and 80 mg/kg, respectively). (B) Quantification of NMDAR1 mRNA expression of the
five groups. The Y axis indicates the ratio of optical density (OD) of the samples to the corresponding internal standard (β‑actin). Data are expressed as the
mean ± standard error of the mean (n=10). *P<0.05, **P<0.01, compared with the normal control group. ΔP<0.01, for comparisons between the agmatine group
and the model control group. NMDAR1, N‑methyl‑D‑aspartic acid receptor; AGM, agmatine; PTZ, pentylenetetrazole. Seizures are known to cause neuronal death and cell loss
may in turn increase the potential for further seizure activity. This feedback cycle may explain the progressive and chronic course of epilepsy (13). Previous studies have revealed a
decrease in the number of hippocampal neurons in seizures
induced by pentylenetetrazole (14). In the present study, the XU et al: AGMATINE ALLEVIATES SEIZURES IN RATS g
2. Demehri S, Homayoun H, Honar H, et al: Agmatine exerts anti
convulsant effect in mice: modulation by α2‑adrenoceptors and
nitric oxide. Neuropharmacology 45: 534‑542, 2003. 1. Raasch W, Schäfer U, Chun J and Dominiak P: Biological
significance of agmatine, an endogenous ligand at imidazoline
binding sites. Br J Pharmacol 133: 755‑780, 2001.
2. Demehri S, Homayoun H, Honar H, et al: Agmatine exerts anti
convulsant effect in mice: modulation by α2‑adrenoceptors and
nitric oxide. Neuropharmacology 45: 534‑542, 2003.
3. Su RB, Wei XL, Zheng JQ, Liu Y, Lu XQ and Li J: Anticonvulsive
effect of agmatine in mice. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 77:
345‑349, 2004. References 14. Oses JP, Leke R, Portela LV, et al: Biochemical brain markers
and purinergic parameters in rat CSF after seizure induced by
pentylenetetrazol. Brain Res Bull 64: 237‑242, 2004.
|
https://openalex.org/W4385366363
|
https://djm.uodiyala.edu.iq/index.php/djm/article/download/993/798
|
Arabic
| null |
Risk Factors for Colonization with S.aureus and Methicillin Resistant Staphylococcus aureus Among Health Care Workers in Al-Batool teaching hospital for maternity and children in Diyala, Iraq
|
Maǧallaẗ Diyālá al-ṭibbiyyaẗ/Maǧallaẗ diyālá al-ṭibbiyyaẗ
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 11,342
|
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Risk Factors for Colonization with
S.aureus
and
Methicillin
Resistant Staphylococcus aureus
Among Health Care Workers in
Al-Batool teaching hospital for
maternity and children in Diyala,
Iraq Mohamed Mahjoob Aljboori (MSc)1, Rideh Abbas Abdul Jabbar
(PhD)2 , Ali Ibrahim Ali Al-Ezzy (PhD)3
1,2 Department of Biology, College of Science , University of Tikrit , Iraq
3 Department of Pathology, College of Veterinary medicine, University of
Diyala , Diyala ,Iraq Mohamed Mahjoob Aljboori (MSc)1, Rideh Abbas Abdul Jabbar
(PhD)2 , Ali Ibrahim Ali Al-Ezzy (PhD)3
1,2 Department of Biology, College of Science , University of Tikrit , Iraq
3 Department of Pathology, College of Veterinary medicine, University of
Diyala , Diyala ,Iraq Abstract Background: Staphylococcus aureus coloniza-tion for the human nose
representing a challenge that requires a cope with host defense and
competing resident microor-ganisms. Keywords: Health care workers , S.aureus, MRSA ,Risk factors OPEN ACCESS Correspondence Address: Ali Ibrahim Ali
Al-Ezzy
Department
of
Pathology,
College
of
Veterinary medicine, University of Diyala,
Diyala, Iraq
Email: alizziibrahim@gmail.com
Copyright: ©Authors, 2023, College of
Medicine, University of Diyala. This is an
open access article under the CC BY 4.0
license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
Website:
https://djm.uodiyala.edu.iq/index.php/djm
Received: 16 August 2022
Accepted: 11 September 2022
Published: 30 June 2023 Objective: To evaluate the risk factors for in-fection with S. au-reus and
MRSA among health care workers (HCWs) in Al-Batool teaching hospital
for maternity and children in Diyala, Iraq. Correspondence Address: Ali Ibrahim Ali
Al-Ezzy Correspondence Address: Ali Ibrahim Ali
Al-Ezzy Department
of
Pathology,
College
of
Veterinary medicine, University of Diyala,
Diyala, Iraq Patients and Methods: A total of 27 swabs were taken from HCWs in Al-
Batool teaching hospital for ma-ternity and chil-dren in Diyala, Iraq
(ATHMC) Standard microbi-ological proce-dures were used for diagnosis
of S. aureus and Methicillin Re-sistant Staphylo-coccus aureus (MRSA). Email: alizziibrahim@gmail.com
Copyright: ©Authors, 2023, College of
Medicine, University of Diyala. This is an
open access article under the CC BY 4.0
license Results: Significant corre-lation was report-ed between age and
colonization with S. aureus & MRSA. Inverse correlation was reported
between education level and colonization with S. aureus and MRSA. Signifi-cant correlation was reported be-tween acne and colonization with S. aureus. Signifi-cant correlation was reported be-tween sinusitis, years of
experi-ence, contact with farm animals and colonization with S. aureus and
MRSA. Significant correlation was reported between ward of duty and
colonization with MRSA. (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
Website: https://djm.uodiyala.edu.iq/index.php/djm Received: 16 August 2022
Accepted: 11 September 2022
P bli h d 30 J
2023 Conclusion: Colonization with S. aureus and MRSA inversely correlated
with younger age group, education level of HCWs. Colonization with S. aureus and MRSA correlated with sinusitis, years of experience (5 -6);
contact with farm animals. Colonization with S. aureus correlated with
acne. Colonization with MRSA correlated with ward of duty at children
care floor. Keywords: Health care workers , S.aureus, MRSA ,Risk factors 1 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Study Participants Current study was conducted, from March
to November 2020 . The study included
health care workers working in intensive
care unit, children's care floor, Preterm care
floor at ATHMC, Diyala. Iraq . Clinical and
epidemiological data including: age, sex,
smoking, using of hand disinfectants ,
education level , sinusitis , acne, years of
experi-ence , ward of duty ,Contact with
MRSA carriers, working with ambulant
sector outside the work, contact with farm
animals. S.aureus do not form spores or flagella, has
possessed a capsule and produce gold-en-
yellow pigment, with decomposed mannitol
[5] . Furthermore, it has also been found that
plasma test coagulase, lactose fermentation,
additionally the deoxyribonuclease ac-tivity
is positive in S.aureus[6].Most of S.aureus
possess alpha-hemolytic activity , forming a
perfect transparent hemolytic ring around
bacterial colonies, seen on a blood agar[7]. To evaluate the risk factors for infection
with S.aureus and MRSA among health care
workers(HCWs)
in
Al-Batool
teaching
hospital for maternity and children in
Diyala, Iraq, (ATHMC). To evaluate the risk factors for infection
with S.aureus and MRSA among health care
workers(HCWs)
in
Al-Batool
teaching
hospital for maternity and children in
Diyala, Iraq, (ATHMC). The
Staphylococcus
aureus
has
a
colonization of the human nose represents a
challeng-ing impact that requires not only
adherence to nasal epithelial cells but also
competence to cope with host defense and
competing resident microorganisms[1] . The
continuous
and
heavy
challenge
of
community- and hospital-acquired S. aureus
infections poses a major threat for public
health, mostly in children, pregnant women,
and postpartum women [2]. Patients and Methods The study was conducted at Al-Batool
teaching Hospital for Maternity and Children
(ATHMC), Diyala. The study was performed
consistent with local regulations. Informed
consent and consistent with the (Declaration
of Helsinki) was obtained of the take samples
from HCWs . The Clinical Research Ethics
Committee approved the study at (ATHMC,
Diyala, Iraq. Bloodstream infections with methicillin-
susceptible(MSSA) and -resistant S.aureus
(MRSA) raise of high-risk in hospitals death
because the treatment requires fre-quent and
prolonged hospitalization[3].At the same
time, the hospital intensive care units
represents the main site for MRSA, which is
likely to cause and affect an outbreak[4]. Introduction To evaluate the risk factors for infection
with S.aureus and MRSA among health care
workers(HCWs)
in
Al-Batool
teaching
hospital for maternity and children in
Diyala, Iraq, (ATHMC). Study Samples For the species identification, slide and
tube coagulase test, and PCR-based tests are
uti-lized and molecular methods for the
detection of mecA are employed for MRSA
[8]. S. aureus invades and adheres to host
epithelial cells using a diversity of molecules
that are collectively called microbial surface
the components recognizing adhesive matrix
mole-cules [9]. Nasal, mouth, and skin swabs from health
care workers, were collected following a
standardized protocol, inserting the swab tip
from the places to be sampled and rotating
and moving it for (five seconds) in each
place.Transport
swabs
(AFCO,
Origen
Jordan) were used. The samples were
submitted to microbiology laboratory of
ATHMC,
Diyala,
Iraq
.Isolation
and
diagnosis of S. aureus were based on 2 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine standard microbiological proce-dures, and
methods and other interpretations were in
accordance with the EUCAST guidelines
[10]. ported between age group(22-24) year of
HCWs and colonization with S.aureus. Significant difference (p value= 0.033) and
correlation (P value= 0.033)was reported
between age group(28-30) year of HCWs
and colonization with S.aureus.The main
group at risk for getting S.aureus colonization
was (22-24) with(2.159) time compared with
, (0.341) time for (25-27) year. Statistical Analysis Health care workers demography and cross
tabulation were calculated by SPSS for win-
dows version 17 ( SPSS, Armonk, NY: IBM
Corp). Pearson's chi-square and Pearson's
correlation coefficient were utilized for the
correlation between parameters[11] . P value
of ≤ 0.05 and ≤ 0.01(2-tailed) were
statistically significant [12, 13]. MRSA was isolated from HCWs at the age
group (22-24),(25-27) ,(28-30) years 1/27,
(3.70%). Significant difference (p value=
0.050) and Inverse correlation (P value=
0.052)was reported between age group(22-
24) year of HCWs in ATHMC and coloniza-
tion with MRSA. Sex As shown in Table (2), S.aureus was
detected mainly from females HCWs in
ATHMC ,3/27, (11.11%) ,followed by males,
2/27, (7.40%). Neither significant difference
(p value = 0.629) nor correlation(P Value=
0.885) were reported between sex of HCWs
in ATHMC and colonization with S.aureus. The risk of getting S.aureus colonization
among females (1.061) compared with
(0.909) for males . Table (2): Sex as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in
ATHMC
Sex
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
S.aureus
Negative
Positive
Male
8(29.62%)
2(7.40%)
0.023
0.629
0.029
0.885
0.909
0.272- 3.041
Female
14(51.85%)
3(11.11%)
0.023
0.879
0.029
0.885
1.061
0.485- 2.319
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
“27(100%)”
Sex
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
MRSA
Negative
Positive
Male
9(33.33%)
1(3.70%)
0.020
0.697
-0.027
0.893
1.125
0.066-
10.553
Female
15(55.56%)
2(7.40%)
0.020
0.697
0.027
0.893
0.938
0.397- 2.211
Total
24(88.89%)
3(11.11%)
27(100%) among smokers was (0.341) time compared
with (1.439) for nonsmokers. Results As shown in Table (1), S.aureus was
isolated equally from HCWs at the age
group (22-24 )year , (25-27) year ,2/27,
(7.40%) ,followed by 1/27, (3.70%) for (28-
30 )year. As shown in Table (1), S.aureus was
isolated equally from HCWs at the age
group (22-24 )year , (25-27) year ,2/27,
(7.40%) ,followed by 1/27, (3.70%) for (28-
30 )year. Significant difference (p value = 0.004) and
correlation (P value= 0.003) was reported
between age group(28-30) year of HCWs in
ATHMC and colonization with MRSA. The
main group at risk for getting MRSA
colonization was (22-24), with(2.5)time com-
pared with (0.500) time for (25-27) year. Significant difference p value= 0.024) and
Inverse correlation (P value= 0.024)was re- p
(
)
(
) y
Table (1): Age as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in ATHMC”
“Age
group”
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC
χ2
P value
R
P
value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
S.aureus
Negative
Positive
“22-24”
19(70.37%)
2(7.40%)
5.067
0.024* -0.433 0.024
2.159
0.729- 6.398
“25-27”
3(11.11%)
2(7.40%)
1.877
0.171
0.264
0.184
0.341
0.076- 1.532
“28-30”
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
4.569
0.033
0.411
0.033
ND
ND
“Total
“22(81.48%)” “5(18.51%)”
“27(100%)”
Age group
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
MRSA
“Negative”
“Positive”
“22-24”
20(74.07%)
1(3.70%)
3.857
0.050
-0.378
0.052
2.500
0.500-12.510
“25-27”
4(14.81%)
1(3.70%)
0.491
0.484
0.135
0.502
0.500
0.080- 3.127
“28-30”
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
8.308
0.004
0.555
0.003*
ND
ND
Total
24(88.89%) 3(11.11%)
27(100%)
*Significant *Significant 3 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Diyala Journal of Medicine MRSA was detected primarily in females
HCWs in ATHMC,2/27, (7.40%) compared
with 1/27, (3.70%) for males HCWs in
ATHMC. Neither significant difference (p
value= 0.697 ) nor correlation(P Value=
0.893) were reported between sex of HCWs
in ATHMC and colonization with MRSA. The risk of getting MRSA colonization
among males (1.125) compared with (0.938)
for females. Sex Smoking As shown in Table (3), S. aureus was
detected among 3/27, (11.11%) nonsmoker
HCWs in ATHMC compared with 2/27,
(7.40%)
smokers. Neither
significant
difference ( p value =0.221) nor correlation
(p value = 0.184) were reported between
smoking habit of HCWs ATHMC and
colonization with S.aureus. The odd ratio for
colonization of nonsmokers versus smokers
was (4.222).The risk of getting S.aureus MRSA was detected among 1/27, (3.70%)
from smoker and 2/27,(7.40%) nonsmoker
HCWs in ATHMC. Neither significant
difference ( p value =0.484) nor correlation
(p value = 0.502) were reported between
smoking habit of HCWs ATHMC and
coloniza-tion with MRSA”. “The risk of
getting MRSA among smokers was (0.500)
time com-pared with (1.250) for nonsmokers. 4 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (3): Smoking as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in
ATHMC
Type of isolates from HCWs in ATHMC
Smoking
S.aureus
MRSA
Negative
Positive
Negative
Positive
Total
No
19(70.37%)
3(11.11%) 20(74.07%)
2(7.40%)
22(81.48%)
Yes
3(11.11%)
2(7.40%)
4(14.81%)
1(3.70%)
5(18.51%)
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
24(88.89%)
3(11.11%)
27(100%)
χ2
1.877
0.491
P value
0.221
0.484
R
0.264
0.135
P value
0.184
0.502
Odds ratio for Smoking
( no /yes )
Value
95% CI
Value
95% CI
4.222
0.485-
36.767
5.250
.269- 102.424
Risk estimate Smoking
=yes
0.341
0.076- 1.532
0.500
0.080-3.127
Risk estimate for Smoking
=No
1.439
0.690- 3.001
1.250
0.551- 2.838 Table (3): Smoking as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in
ATHMC ): Smoking as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in
ATHMC disinfectant was lower, (0.909) compared
with (1.364) for those irregularly use hand
disinfectant. MRSA was detected among
2/27, (7.40%) of HCWs in ATHMC which
claimed to regu-larly use hand disinfectant. Neither significant difference ( p value
=0.277) nor correlation (p value = 0.295)
were reported between the use of hand
disinfectant among HCWs in ATHMC and
coloniza-tion with MRSA. The risk of getting
MRSA among HCWs in ATHMC that
regularly use disinfectant was (0.708) time Using of Hand disinfectants
“As shown in Table (4), S.aureus was
detected among 4/27, (14.81%) of HCWs in
ATHMC
which
regularly
use
hand
disinfectant versus 1/27, (3.70%) who use
hand disin-fectants irregularly . Smoking Neither
significant difference ( p value =0.612) nor
correlation (p value = 0.749) were reported
between the use of hand disinfectant among
HCWs in ATHMC and colonization with
S.aureus. The risk of getting S.aureus among
HCWs
ATHMC
that
regularly
use Using of Hand disinfectants Using of Hand disinfectants Using of Hand disinfectants
“As shown in Table (4), S.aureus was
detected among 4/27, (14.81%) of HCWs in
ATHMC
which
regularly
use
hand
disinfectant versus 1/27, (3.70%) who use
hand disin-fectants irregularly . Neither
significant difference ( p value =0.612) nor
correlation (p value = 0.749) were reported
between the use of hand disinfectant among
HCWs in ATHMC and colonization with
S.aureus. The risk of getting S.aureus among
HCWs
ATHMC
that
regularly
use 5 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (4): Using of Hand disinfectants as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA
among HCWs in ATHMC
Type of isolates from HCWs in ATHMC
Using of Hand
disinfectants
S.aureus
MRSA
Negative
Positive
Negative
Positive
Total
Regularly
16(59.25%)
4(14.81%)
18(66.66%) 3(11.11%)
20(74.07%)
Irregularly
6(22.22%)
1(3.70%)
7(25.92%)
0(0%)
7(25.92%)
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
24(88.89%) 3(11.11%)
27(100%)
χ2
0.112
1.181
P value
0.612
0.277
R
-0.064
-0.209
P value
0.749
0.295
Risk estimate Using of
Hand disinfectants
=regularly
0.909
.547- 1.510
0.708
0.548- 0.916
Risk estimate for Using of
Hand disinfectants
=irregularly
1.364
.208-8.947
ND
ND Table (4): Using of Hand disinfectants as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA
among HCWs in ATHMC Table (4): Using of Hand disinfectants as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA
among HCWs in ATHMC colonization with S.aureus among those
having Diploma of health care was (1.250). colonization with S.aureus among those
having Diploma of health care was (1.250). MRSA was isolated from 2/27,(7.40%)
,HCWs in ATHMC . Significant differ-ence (
p value =0.004) and inverse correlation (p
value = 0.003 ) were reported be-tween
education level among HCWs in ATHMC
and colonization with MRSA. The risk for
colonization with MRSA among those
having Diploma of health care (1.500 )time. Education level Education level
As shown in Table, (5),S.aureus was isolated
primarily from HCWs have Diploma of
health care in ATHMC, 4/27, (14.81%)
compared with 1/27,(3.70%) have Bachelor
of nursing. Significant difference ( p value
=0.033) and inverse correlation (p value =
0.033) were reported between education
level among HCWs in ATHMC and
coloniza-tion with S.aureus . The risk for MRSA was isolated from 2/27,(7.40%)
,HCWs in ATHMC . Significant differ-ence (
p value =0.004) and inverse correlation (p
value = 0.003 ) were reported be-tween
education level among HCWs in ATHMC
and colonization with MRSA. The risk for
colonization with MRSA among those
having Diploma of health care (1.500 )time. MRSA was isolated from 2/27,(7.40%)
,HCWs in ATHMC . Significant differ-ence (
p value =0.004) and inverse correlation (p
value = 0.003 ) were reported be-tween
education level among HCWs in ATHMC
and colonization with MRSA. The risk for
colonization with MRSA among those
having Diploma of health care (1.500 )time. 6 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (5): Education level as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCW
in ATHMC
*Significant
Type of isolates from HCWs in ATHMC
Education level
S.aureus
MRSA
Total
Negative
Positive
Negative
Positive
Bachelor of nursing
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
1(3.70%)
Diploma of health care
22(81.48%)
4(14.81%) 24(88.89%) 2(7.40%)
26(96.29%)
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%) 24(88.89%) 3(11.11%)
27(100%)
χ2
4.569
8.308
P value
0.033*
0.004*
R
-0.411
-0.555
P value
0.033*
0.003*
Risk estimate for Education
level = Bachelor of nursing
ND
ND
ND
ND
Risk estimate for Education
level =Diploma of health care
1.250
0.806- 1.938
1.500
0.674- 3.339 Table (5): Education level as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs
in ATHMC in ATHMC without sinusitis was (1.250)
time. MRSA was isolated from 1/27, (3.70%)
of HCWs in in ATHMC have no sinusitis . Significant difference ( p value =0.004) and
correlation (p value = 0.003) were reported
between sinusitis among HCWs in
ATHMC and colonization with MRSA . The risk of getting MRSA colonization
among HCWs in ATHMC without sinusitis
was (1.500) time. in ATHMC without sinusitis was (1.250)
time. MRSA was isolated from 1/27, (3.70%)
of HCWs in in ATHMC have no sinusitis . Education level Significant difference ( p value =0.004) and
correlation (p value = 0.003) were reported
between sinusitis among HCWs in
ATHMC and colonization with MRSA . The risk of getting MRSA colonization
among HCWs in ATHMC without sinusitis
was (1.500) time. Sinusitis As shown in Table (6),S.aureus was isolated
from 4/27, (14.81%) of HCWs in ATHMC
have no sinusitis compared with 1/27,
(3.70%) suffering from sinusitis. Significant
dif-ference ( p value =0.033) and correlation
(p value = 0.033 ) were reported between si-
nusitis among HCWs in ATHMC and
colonization with S.aureus. The risk of
getting S.aureus colonization among HCWs 7 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (6): Sinusitis as a risk factor for colonization with S. aureus and MRSA among HCWs in
ATHMC
Type of isolates from HCWs in ATHMC
Sinusitis
S.aureus
MRSA
Total
Negative
Positive Negative Positive
NO
22(81.48%) 4(14.81%) 24(88.89%) 2(7.40%) 26(96.29%)
Yes
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
1(3.70%)
Total
22(81.48%) 5(18.51%) 24(88.89%) 3(11.11%) 27(100%)
χ2
4.569
8.308
P value
0.033
0.004
R
0.411
0.555
P value
0.033*
0.003*
Risk estimate for sinusitis=yes
ND
ND
ND
ND
Risk estimate for sinusitis=No
1.250
0.806-
1.938
1.500
0.674- 3.339
*Significant MRSA was isolated from 2/27, (7.40%) of
HCWs in in ATHMC have and do not suf-
fering from acne versus 1/27,(3.70%)have
acne.No significant difference ( p value
=0.069) nor correlation (p value = 0.074)
were reported between acne among HCWs
in ATHMC and colonization with MRSA. The risk of getting MRSA colonization
among HCWs in ATHMC with acne was
(0.080 ) time compared with those do not
suffering
from
acne
(1.438). Acne As shown in Table (7), S. aureus was isolated
from 3/27, (11.11%) of HCWs in ATHMC
have no acne compared with 2/27, (7.40%)
suffering from acne. Significant difference (
p value =0.002) and correlation ( p value =
0.001) were reported between acne among
HCWs in ATHMC and colonization with
S.aureus .The risk of getting S.aureus colo-
nization among HCWs in ATHMC without
acne was (1.667) time. 8 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (7): Acne as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in ATHMC
Type of isolates from HCWs in ATHMC
Suffering from acne
S.aureus
MRSA
Negative
Positive
Negative
Positive
Total
No
22(81.48%)
3(11.11%) 23(85.18%) 2(7.40%) 25(92.59%)
Yes
0(0%)
2(7.40%)
1(3.70%)
1(3.70%)
2(7.40%)
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%) 24(88.89%) 3(11.11%
)
27(100%)
χ2
9.504
3.308
P value
0.002
0.069
R
0.593
0.350
P value
0.001*
0.074*
Risk estimate for Acne=yes
ND
ND
0.080
0.010-1.520
Risk estimate for Acne=No
1.667
0.815-
3.409
1.438
0.643-3.214
*significant Years of experience MRSA was isolated equally from 1/27,
(3.70%) of HCWs in ATHMC have (1-2),(3-
4),(5-6) years of experience . Neither
Significant difference ( p value =0.496,
0.885)nor correlation (p value = 0.515, 0. 681) were reported between year of
experience (1-2),(3-4) among HCWs in
ATHMC and colonization with MRSA. Significant difference ( p value =0.004) and
correlation (p value = 0.003) was reported
between year of ex-perience (5-6) among
HCWs in ATHMC and colonization with
MRSA . The risk of get-ting MRSA
colonization was(1.625)among those with (1-
2) years of experience compared with (1.375)
for those with (3-4) years of experience. As shown in table (8),S.aureus was isolated
from 3/27, (11.11%) of HCWs in ATHMC
have(1-2) years of experience compared with
1/27, (3.70%) for those with(3-4),(5-6) years
of experience . No significant difference ( p
value =0.686 , 0.223) nor correlation ( p
value = 0.700, 0.239) respectively were
reported between year of experience (1-2, 3-
4) among HCWs in ATHMC and
colonization with S.aureus . Significant
difference (p value =0.003,) and correlation
(p value = 0.003) respectively were reported
between year of experience (5-6) among
HCWs in ATHMC and colonization with
S.aureus . The risk of getting s. aureus
colonization was higher among those with (3-
4) years of experience (2.5) compared with
those of (1-2) years ,( 0.833 ). Acne 9 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (8): Years of experience as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among
HCWs in ATHMC
Years of
experience
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
S.aureus
Negative
positive
1-2
11(40.74%)
3(11.11%)
0.163
0.686
0.078
0.700
0.833
0.364- 1.909
3-4
11(40.74%)
1(3.70%)
1.485
0.223
-0.235
0.239
2.500
0.412- 15.157
5-6
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
4.569
0.003
0.411
0.003
ND
ND
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
27(100%)
Years of
experience
Type of isolates from HCWs
in ATHMC
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
MRSA
Negative
Positive
1-2
13(48.14%)
1(3.70%)
0.464
0.496
-0.131
0.515
1.625
0.315- 8.395
3-4
11(40.74%)
1(3.70%)
0.245
0.885
-0.083
0. 681
1.375
0.262- 7.220
5-6
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
8.308
0.004
0.555
0.003*
ND
ND
Total
24(88.89%)
3(11.11%)
27(100%)
*Significant Ward of Duty 10 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (9): Ward of Duty as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in
ATHMC
Ward of Duty
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
S.aureus
Negative
Positive
Intensive care
unit
7(25.92%)
2(7.40%)
0.123
0.726
0.067
0.738
0.795
0.231-2.737
Children care
floor
8(29.62%)
3(11.11%)
0.943
0.332
0.187
0.351
0.606
0.24- 1.497
Preterm care
floor
7(25.92%)
0(0%)
2.148
0.143
-0.282
0.154
ND
ND
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
27(100%)
Ward of Duty
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC”
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
MRSA
Negative
Positive
Intensive care
unit
9(33.33%)
0(0%)
1.688
0.194
-0.250
0.209
ND
ND
Children care
floor
8(33.33%)
3(11.11%)
4.909
0.027
0.426
0.027
0.333
0.189- 0.587
Preterm care
floor
7(25.92%)
0(0%)
1.181
0.277
-0.209
0.277
ND
ND
Total
24(88.89%)
3(11.11%)
27(100%)
Contact with MRSA
Carriers As show in in Table (10) S.aureus
was isolated from 5 /27, (18.51%) HCWs
who as-sumed that they do not have contact
with MRSA carriers in hospital with neither
signifi-cant difference( p value=0.057) nor
significant correlation (p value=0.061).The
risk of getting S.aureus colonization among
HCWs who assumed that they do not have
contact with MRSA carriers in hospital was
(0 545)
MRSA
i
l
d f
2 /27
(7.40%) HCWs who assumed that they do not
have con-tact with MRSA carriers in
hospital. Neither significant difference ( p
value=0.828) nor significant correlation (p
value=0.887). The risk of getting MRSA
colonization among HCWs who assumed that
they do not have contact with MRSA carriers
in hospital was (1.063) versus (0.438) for
those not sure if they have contact with
MRSA carrier or not. Ward of Duty Table (9): Ward of Duty as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in
ATHMC
Ward of Duty
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
S.aureus
Negative
Positive
Intensive care
unit
7(25.92%)
2(7.40%)
0.123
0.726
0.067
0.738
0.795
0.231-2.737
Children care
floor
8(29.62%)
3(11.11%)
0.943
0.332
0.187
0.351
0.606
0.24- 1.497
Preterm care
floor
7(25.92%)
0(0%)
2.148
0.143
-0.282
0.154
ND
ND
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
27(100%)
Ward of Duty
Type of isolates from
HCWs in ATHMC”
χ2
P value
R
P value
Risk
estimate
C I 95%
MRSA
Negative
Positive
Intensive care
unit
9(33.33%)
0(0%)
1.688
0.194
-0.250
0.209
ND
ND
Children care
floor
8(33.33%)
3(11.11%)
4.909
0.027
0.426
0.027
0.333
0.189- 0.587
Preterm care
floor
7(25.92%)
0(0%)
1.181
0.277
-0.209
0.277
ND
ND
Total
24(88.89%)
3(11.11%)
27(100%) (7.40%) HCWs who assumed that they do not
have con-tact with MRSA carriers in
hospital. Neither significant difference ( p
value=0.828) nor significant correlation (p
value=0.887). The risk of getting MRSA
colonization among HCWs who assumed that
they do not have contact with MRSA carriers
in hospital was (1.063) versus (0.438) for
those not sure if they have contact with
MRSA carrier or not. (7.40%) HCWs who assumed that they do not
have con-tact with MRSA carriers in
hospital. Neither significant difference ( p
value=0.828) nor significant correlation (p
value=0.887). The risk of getting MRSA
colonization among HCWs who assumed that
they do not have contact with MRSA carriers
in hospital was (1.063) versus (0.438) for
those not sure if they have contact with
MRSA carrier or not. Ward of Duty (11.11%) , workers at Intensive care unit and
Preterm care floor were clear.Significant
difference( p value =0.027) and correlation
(p value =0.027) were reported between ward
of duty at Children care floor for HCWs in
ATHMC and colonization with MRSA. Neither significant difference (p value
=0.194 ) nor correlation ( p value =0.209,
0.277) respectively were reported between
working at intensive care unit, Preterm care
floor for HCWs in ATHMC and colonization
with MRSA. The risk of getting S.aureus
colo-nization among HCWs at Children care
floor in ATHMC was (0.333). (11.11%) , workers at Intensive care unit and
Preterm care floor were clear.Significant
difference( p value =0.027) and correlation
(p value =0.027) were reported between ward
of duty at Children care floor for HCWs in
ATHMC and colonization with MRSA. As shown in Table (9),S.aureus was isolated
from HCWs in ATHMC at Children care
floor, 3/27, (11.11%) ,followed by HCWs at
Intensive care unit 2/27, (7.40%). Preterm
care floor was clear. Neither significant
difference( p value =0.726) nor correlation (;
p value = 0.738 ) respectively were reported
between ward of duty for HCWs in ATHMC
and colonization with S.aureus. The risk of
getting S.aureus colonization among HCWs
at Intensive care unit in ATHMC was(0.795)
versus (0.606) for those working in Children
care floor . MRSA was isolated from HCWs
in ATHMC at Children care floor, 3/27, Neither significant difference (p value
=0.194 ) nor correlation ( p value =0.209,
0.277) respectively were reported between
working at intensive care unit, Preterm care
floor for HCWs in ATHMC and colonization
with MRSA. The risk of getting S.aureus
colo-nization among HCWs at Children care
floor in ATHMC was (0.333). Contact with MRSA Carriers As show in in Table (10) S.aureus
was isolated from 5 /27, (18.51%) HCWs
who as-sumed that they do not have contact
with MRSA carriers in hospital with neither
signifi-cant difference( p value=0.057) nor
significant correlation (p value=0.061).The
risk of getting S.aureus colonization among
HCWs who assumed that they do not have
contact with MRSA carriers in hospital was
(0.545). MRSA was isolated from 2 /27, 11 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (10): Contact with MRSA carriers as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA
among HCWs in ATHMC
Type of isolates from HCWs in ATHMC
Contact with MRSA
carriers
S.aureus
MRSA
Total
Negative
Positive
Negative
Positive
No
12(44.44%)
5(18.51%)
15(55.55%) 2(7.40%) 17(62.96%)
I am not sure
10(37.03%)
0(0%)
9(33.33%)
1(3.70%) 10(37.03%)
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
24(88.89%) 3(11.11%) 27(100%)
2χ
3.610
0.022
P value
0.057
0.828
R
-0.366
0.029
P value
0.061
0.887
Risk estimate =I am not sure
ND
ND
0.438
0.159-1.206
Risk estimate for =No
0.545
0.372- 0.799
1.063
0.459- 2.462 : Contact with MRSA carriers as a risk factor for colonization with S.aureus and MRSA
among HCWs in ATHMC (0.455) for those working in ambulant sector
outside the work. MRSA was isolated
equally from 1 /27, (3.70%) HCWs in
ATHMC who do /do not work in ambulant
sector outside the work with no significant
difference(p val-ue=0.069) nor correlation (p
value=0.074). Working with ambulant sector outside the
work As show in Table (11) S.aureus was isolated
from 4 /27, (14.81%) HCWs in in ATHMC
who do not work in ambulant sector versus
1/27, (3.70 %) Working with ambu-lant
sector outside the work with neither
significant difference (p value=0.484) nor
signif-icant correlation (p value=0.502). The
risk of getting S.aureus colonization among
HCWs who do not working in ambulant
sector outside the work (1.136) time versus The risk of getting MRSA colonization
among HCWs who do not working in
ambulant sector outside the work (1.840)
versus (0.160) for those working in ambulant
sector out-side the work. 12 12 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (11): “Working with ambulant sector outside the work as a risk factor for colonization with
S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs in ATHMC”
Type of isolates from HCWs in ATHMC
Working with ambulant sector
outside the work
S.aureus
MRSA
Total
Negative
Positive
Negative Positive
No
20(74.07%)
4(14.81%)
22(81.48%) 2(7.40%) 24(88.88%)
Yes
2(7.40%)
1(3.70%)
2(7.40%)
1(3.70%)
3(11.11%)
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
24(88.89%) 3(11.11%)
27(100%)
2χ
0.491
1.688
P value
0.484
0.194
R
0.135
0.250
P value
0.502
0.209
Risk estimate for working
0.455
0.051- 4.083
0.160
0.023- 1.092
Risk estimate for not working
1.136
0.719- 1.796
1.840
0.458- 7.393 isolated equally from 2 /27, (7.40%) HCWs
in ATHMC who do not have Contact with
farm animals versus 1/27, (3.70%) have
contact with farm animals with significant
difference( p value=0.004) and correlation (p
value=0.003). The risk of getting MRSA
infection among HCWs who do not have
contact with farm animals (1.500) time
versus (0.250) for those contacted with farm
animals. Contact with farm animals Contact with farm animals Contact with farm animals As show in Table (12) S.aureus was isolated
from 4 /27, (13.33%) HCWs in ATHMC who
do not have Contact with farm animals
versus 1/27, (10%) they have contact with
farm animals with significant difference( p
value=0.033) and significant correlation (p
value=0.033). The risk of getting S.aureus infection
among HCWs who have do not contact with
farm animals (1.250) time. MRSA was 13 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 Diyala Journal of Medicine ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Table (12): “Contact with farm animals as a risk factor for infection with S.aureus and MRSA among
HCWs in ATHMC”
Type of isolates from HCWs in in ATHMC
Contact with farm animals
S.aureus
MRSA
“Total”
Negative
Positive
Negative
Positive
No
22(81.48%)
4(14.81%)
24(92.59%)
2(7.40%)
26(96.29%)
Yes
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
0(0%)
1(3.70%)
1(3.70%)
Total
22(81.48%)
5(18.51%)
24(88.89%)
3(11.11%)
27(100%)
2χ
4.569
8.308
P value
0.033*
0.004*
R
0.411
0.555
P value
0.033*
0.003*
Risk estimate for Contacting
with farm animals =yes
ND
ND
0.250
0.031- 1.999
Risk estimate for Contacting
=No
1.250
0.806-
1.938
1.500
0.674- 3.339
*Significant Table (12): “Contact with farm animals as a risk factor for infection with S.aureus and MRSA among
HCWs in ATHMC” Table (12): “Contact with farm animals as a risk factor for infection with S.aureus and MRSA among
HCWs in ATHMC” In Brazil, [20],stated that the HCWs of
younger age group (20-28)years were more
colonized with S.aureus at (33.9%) which is
at higher risk at 3.5 time greater than older
age groups, (12.7%). Discussion In the present study, significant differences
and inverse correlations were reported be-
tween age group (22-24) years of health care
workers and colonization with S. aureus and
MRSA. The main group at risk for getting S. aureus colonization was (22-24) with (2.159)
time compared with the same group of age
MRSA colonization was (22-24), with (2.5)
time in ATHMC. In current study, no correlation was
reported between the sex as a risk factor for
HCWs and colonization with S. aureus and
MRSA for ATHMC which come in line
with[21]in Iran, [22] in Nepal and [15] in
Ethiopia , [18] in Spain
[ و17
] in Egypt and
[23] in Oman. Current results come in accordance with a
study achieved among HCWs at Evliya
Celebi hospital in Turkey by [14] , and[15,
16] in Ethiopia and [17] in Egypt, and [18]
in Spain and [19] in Iran , they stated that
the age of HCWs play no role in infection
with S.aureus or MRSA . Although there
are differences in the main group at risk for
getting S. aureus and MRSA infection they
weren't significant nor had a correlation
between the age of HCWs and infection with
S. aureus and MRSA . In current study ,S. aureus was
detected mainly among females HCWs,
(11.11%), and males, (7.40%) while MRSA
was detected among females HCWs, (7.40%)
compared with (3.70%) for males. These
results come in accordance with that reported
in Brazil by, [20], who reported that S.aureus
was isolated from (26.5%) of females HCWs
ver-sus(22.2%) for males HCWs without
significant correlation between the sex of 14 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine infection control measures in different
countries . On the other hand [15, 16, 22]
stated that ,sex play no role as risk factor for
carriage rate of MRSA. HCWs and MRSA . Similar conclusion was
recorded by [19] from Iran. Current results
come in contrary with several studies around
the world such as [22] who stated that
colonization of MRSA was high among
males (8.7%) than in females (4.3%) (p
>0.05). Accordingly [24], reported higher
MRSA colonization in males (7.2%) in
comparison to females (5.8%) in Argentina ,
while [25] from Nepal ,reported that
colonization was higher in fe-males (8.3%) in
comparison to males (5.1%). Discussion In the present study, S.aureus was detected
among (11.11%) of nonsmoker health care
workers compared with (7.40%) of smokers,
while MRSA was detected among (3.70%) of
smokers
and
(7.40%)
of
non-smoker
healthcare workers. No correlation was
reported between the smoking habit of
HCWs and colonization with S. aureus and
MRSA in ATHMC which come in line with
that reported by [26, 28]. The result of
current study come in line with that reported
by a study achieved in the college of
dentistry at Karbala University, Iraq, who
stated that non-smokers are more likely to
have S.aureus infec-tions[29]. In contrary to
the present result [22],stated that significant
correlation was re-ported between smoking
and S.aureus isolation from HCWs in Nepal
and similar conclu-sion was reported in
Taiwan [30]. The risk of getting S. aureus colonization
among females HCWs in ATHMC was
(1.061) versus (0.909) for males HCWs
which come in agreement with [26] who
stated that the risk of colonization of S.aureus
was more frequent among males HCWs
working
at
chil-dren
hospitals
in
Bangladesh”. “The risk of getting MRSA
colonization
among
males
HCWs
in
ATHMC (1.125) compared with (0.938) for
females HCWs. A study achieved by [14],in Turkey come
agreement with current result. In Azadi
teaching hospital in Kirkuk city\Iraq, [27]
stated that the prevalence of S.aureus was
higher in males (52.4%), versus (47.6%) for
females on the other hand the prevalence of
MRSA infection was (1.6%) for males versus
for (1.2%) females including HCWs. While
in current study MRSA was detected among
females HCWs, (7.40%) versus (3.70%) for
males . Here the variation may have
attributed to the differences in the samples
size and demographic distribution beside the
quality of collected samples and differences
in the quality of hospital environment as well
as in the microbiological procedures that
used for diagnosis and differences in the In ATHMC, S. aureus was detected among
(14.81%) of HCWs, who regularly use hand
disinfectants versus (3.70%) who use hand
disinfectants irregularly. MRSA was de-
tected among (7.40%) of HCWs who
claimed to regularly use hand disinfectant. No correlation was reported between the use
of hand disinfectant among HCWs colonized
with S. aureus or MRSA. A study achieved by [31] in among Indian
HCWs confirmed that, (51.61%) of HCWs
were positive for MRSA and after the use of
an alcohol-based hand sterilization a total of
(9.68%), HCWs were remained positive for
MRSA. Discussion This corresponds with cur-rent study,
and the possibility for persistence of MRSA 15 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine “The risk for colonization with S.aureus
among those having a diploma in health care
was (1.250), while the risk for colonization
with MRSA among those having a diploma
in health care was(1.500 )time in ATHMC
.These results come in agreement with
[38],who stated that nurses was at 2.58 times
higher than other HCWs for getting MRSA. may attributed insufficient time for hand
rubbing and superficial cleaning of hand
dirt’s as well as direct contact with
contaminated surfaces such as walls, tools,
patients skin and clothes beside the role of
the length of the nails of HCWs (especially
females) which is a reason for not fully
sanitizing the hand despite using sterilization. Current study come in contrary with [15,
16],who stated that hand washing practice
among HCWs have no role in minimizing of
infection with S.aureus and MRSA. On the
other hand the contentious exposure of
gloves
and
gown
of
HCWS
for
contamination with S.aureus and other
pathogens especially during health care
activities and exposure to the contaminated
secretions[32],which facilitate the second line
of problem as the HCWs will be the source
for contamination for patients and hospital
environment [33, 34] .Another source for
contamination was the mobile phone which
was used even at duty that permit the
possibility of cross contamination and failure
of safety precautions[35]”. On the other hand [39],reported that the
risk for nursing staff of being colonized with
MRSA was almost two-fold higher than for
medical staff and three-fold higher than for
other healthcare staff . Results of current
study come in partial agreement with [14],in
turkey and [40] in Gaza Strip-Palestine and
[41] in Saudi Arabia , stated that the educa-
tion level play no role in infection with
S.aureus and MRSA among HCWs. The
possible explanation for high isolation rate of
S. aureus and MRSA from those with
diploma in health care may attributed to their
adhesion with patients and entry for different
hospital wards during their shift, change of
patients dressing and continuous exposure for
several possible sources for infection . In current study, S.aureus was in (14.81%)
of HCWs have no sinusitis versus (3.70%)
suffering from sinusitis, while MRSA was in
(3.70%) of HCWs who have no sinusitis . Discussion In current study, S.aureus was recovered
from (14.81%) of HCWs who have a
diploma in health care, compared with
(3.70%) among those who have a Bachelor of
nursing . Significant
correlations
was
reported
between
sinusitis
among
HCWs
and
colonization with S. aureus, and marginal
correlation was reported between sinusitis
among HCWs and colonization with S. aureus and MRSA, in ATHMC. These results
come in accord-ance with [39] and in
contrary with that reported by [36] who
stated
that
there
was
no
significant
correlation between S. aureus and MRSA
colonization and sinusitis among HCWs. In ATHMC, MRSA was isolated from
(7.40%), of HCWs in had a diploma in health
care, and (3.70%) with a bachelor of nursing. “ No significant correlation was reported
between education level among HCWs ,
which come in line with that reported by [36,
37] while inverse correlation was reported
be-tween education level among HCWs and
colonization with S. aureus and MRSA in
ATHMC”. 16 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine cases furthermore the limited awareness
about personal protection during the routine
work which is usually noticed with those of
limited years of experience . In the present study, S.aureus was isolated
from (11.11%) of HCWs , who have no
acne versus (7.40%) suffering from acne,
while MRSA was isolated from (7.40%) of
HCWs who do not suffer from acne. Significant
correlations
were
reported
between acne among HCWs colonization
with S. aureus, in ATHMC which come in
line with that re-ported by [38],who stated
that acne represent a important risk factor for
MRSA coloniza-tion among HCWs. In current study, In ATHMC S.aureus was
isolated from HCWs on the Children's care
floor, (11.11%), followed by HCWs in the
Intensive care unit (7.40%), while MRSA
was from HCWs on the children's care floor,
(11.11%). These results come in approximate
of that recorded in Sultan Qaboos University
hospital in Oman, where the prevalence of
MRSA reach up to 9.1% in neonate intensive
care unit however they reported a high
prevalence in surgery unit 21.4%[23]. In the present study, in ATHMC. S. aureus
was from (11.11%) of HCWS have (1-2)
years of experience compared with (3.70%)
for those with(3-4),(5-6) years of experience,
while MRSA was isolated equally from
(3.70%) of HCWs have (1-2),(3-4),(5-6)
years of experience. Discussion Significant correlation
respectively were reported between years of
experience (one, two) among HCWs and
colonization with S.aureus which come in
agreement with In ATHMC, No correlation
respectively was reported between years of
experience (1-2, 3-4) among HCWs and
colonization with S.aureus and MRSA, while
significant correla-tion was reported between
years of experience (5-6) among HCWs
colonized with S.aureus and MRSA which
come in line with [16, 36, 41] . No correlation was reported between ward
of duty and colonization with S. aureus and
MRSA
in
ATHMC. Which
come in
accordance with that reported in Iran by [21]
and in Oman by [23]. Significant correlations were reported
between wards of duty on the children's care
floor for HCWs colonization with MRSA in
ATHMC. One of the reasons that lead to
high rates on the children’s floor is the basic
design of the building that is not designated
as a hospital and the large number of children
admitted at a ward that exceeds the basic
capacity of the rooms, which certainly leads
to cases of contamination and cross-
contamination . Contradictory result reported by [42],who
stated that HCWs with few years of experi-
ence were more susceptible for colonization
with S.aureus and MRSA. The possible ex-
planation for the correlation between the
years of experience and the coloniza-
tion/infection rate of S.aureus may have
attributed to the continuous exposure for
microbs due to the heavy duty especially at
the first years of occupation as a medical
staff that required adhesion with clinical This lead to subsequent spread of the
pathogens from one place to another,
whether in the hospital environment or to the
skin of the coming patient. This happened
due to the lack of awareness of the necessity
to perform hand disinfection with alcoholic
solutions to reduce the number of germs and
thus the possibility of transmission of the
pathogens to the medical staff and to the 17 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine colonization among HCWs who have
contact with farm animals (3.500) times. These
results
come
in
agreement
with[44],who stated ,that the German HCWs
how have direct or indirect contact with
calves and /or pigs have 10 fold possibility of
getting S.aureus. Current results come in
agreement with [38, 43]. Discussion In the other hand
,the possibil-ity of cross-transmission from
farm or even pets animals to human leads to
form a status of transient to stable
colonization especially if they have sinusitis
or dermatitis among HCWs who have
contact with these animals [39] ,and
subsequently they act as a vector for
transmission of S.aureus /MRSA to the
following patients during their ward
duty[43]. largest possible number if we take into
account the fre-quent use of tools such as
tables and desks on which the mobile phone
or papers are placed of the patient, which is
very likely to contain pathogenic germs. In a
study achieved by [16], they stated that there
was no significant relationship between
specialties and S. aureus or MRSA infection . In the present study, in ATHMC. S. aureus
was isolated from (18.51%) of HCWs who
assumed that they do not have contact with
MRSA carriers, while MRSA was iso-lated
from (7.40%) of HCWs who assumed that
they do not have contact with MRSA
carriers, with no significant correlation for S. aureus and MRSA in ATHMC. These result
come in line with that reported by [38],stated
that contact with MRSA carrier with or
without protective clothes have no effect on
the possibility of colonization among HCWs. Current results indicate the limited awareness
about the presence of s. aureus and MRSA
around in hospital and their critical role in
serious consequences for patient and medical
staff equally. In current study, S. aureus was isolated
from (14.81%) of HCWs who do not work in
th
b l
t
t
(3 70 %)
f th largest possible number if we take into
account the fre-quent use of tools such as
tables and desks on which the mobile phone
or papers are placed of the patient, which is
very likely to contain pathogenic germs. In a
study achieved by [16], they stated that there
was no significant relationship between
specialties and S. aureus or MRSA infection . In the present study, in ATHMC. S. aureus
was isolated from (18.51%) of HCWs who
assumed that they do not have contact with
MRSA carriers, while MRSA was iso-lated
from (7.40%) of HCWs who assumed that
they do not have contact with MRSA
carriers, with no significant correlation for S. aureus and MRSA in ATHMC. Discussion These result
come in line with that reported by [38],stated
that contact with MRSA carrier with or
without protective clothes have no effect on
the possibility of colonization among HCWs. Current results indicate the limited awareness
about the presence of s. aureus and MRSA
around in hospital and their critical role in
serious consequences for patient and medical
staff equally. Conclusions Inverse correlation was reported between
younger age group , education level of
HCWs and colonization with S.aureus and
MRSA .Significant correlation was reported
between age group(28-30) year of HCWs in
ATHMC and colonization with MRSA. Significant correlation was reported
between sinusitis , years of experience (5-
6)years ,contact with farm animals and
colonization with S.aureus and MRSA
.Significant correlation was reported between
acne and colonization with S.aureus
.Significant correlation was reported between
ward of duty at children care floor and
colonization with MRSA. In current study, S. aureus was isolated
from (14.81%) of HCWs who do not work in
the ambulant sector versus (3.70 %) of those
working in the ambulant sector outside the
work. These results come in agreement with [38,
43] ,they stated that working in ambulant sec-
tor outside the work represent a considerable
risk for getting S.aureus /MRSA and then
transmitted to the patient and /or hospital
environment. Recommendations Take care for the role of health care
workers in the transmission of S.aureus and
MRSA
for
the
patients
and
hospital
environment. In ATHMC, S. aureus (13.33%) of HCWs
hospitals that do not have contact with farm
animals versus (10%) that have contact with
farm animals, the risk of getting S.aureus 18 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine tubing. Antimicrobial Resistance & Infection
Control. 2017;6(1):1-7. [7]Piccirilli A, Pompilio A, Rossi L, Segatore
B, Amicosante G, Rosatelli G, et al. Identification of CTX-M-15 and CTX-M-27
in antibiotic-resistant Gram-negative bacteria
isolated from three rivers running in central
Italy. Microbial
Drug
Resistance. 2019;25(7):1041-9. [8] Gill AA, Singh S, Thapliyal N,
Karpoormath R. Nanomaterial-based optical
and electrochemical techniques for detection
of
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus:
a
review. Microchimica
Acta. 2019;186:1-19. tubing. Antimicrobial Resistance & Infection
Control. 2017;6(1):1-7. Source of funding: The current study was
funded by our charges with no any other
funding sources elsewhere. Source of funding: The current study was
funded by our charges with no any other
funding sources elsewhere. [7]Piccirilli A, Pompilio A, Rossi L, Segatore
B, Amicosante G, Rosatelli G, et al. Identification of CTX-M-15 and CTX-M-27
in antibiotic-resistant Gram-negative bacteria
isolated from three rivers running in central
Italy. Microbial
Drug
Resistance. 2019;25(7):1041-9. Ethical clearance:Ethical approval was
obtained from the College of Medicine /
University of Diyala ethical committee for
this study. Ethical clearance:Ethical approval was
obtained from the College of Medicine /
University of Diyala ethical committee for
this study. References [8] Gill AA, Singh S, Thapliyal N,
Karpoormath R. Nanomaterial-based optical
and electrochemical techniques for detection
of
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus:
a
review. Microchimica
Acta. 2019;186:1-19. [1] van Dalen R, Peschel A, van Sorge NM. Wall teichoic acid in Staphylococcus aureus
host interaction. Trends in microbiology. 2020;28(12):985-98. (
)
[2] Matuszkiewicz-Rowińska J, Małyszko J,
Wieliczko M. Urinary tract infections in
pregnancy:
old
and
new
unresolved
diagnostic
and
therapeutic
problems. Archives
of
medical
science:
AMS. 2015;11(1):67. [3] Pulido-Cejudo A, Guzmán-Gutierrez M,
Jalife-Montaño A, Ortiz-Covarrubias A,
Martínez-Ordaz JL, Noyola-Villalobos HF, et
al. Management of acute bacterial skin and
skin structure infections with a focus on
patients at high risk of treatment failure. Therapeutic advances in infectious disease. 2017;4(5):143-61. [2] Matuszkiewicz-Rowińska J, Małyszko J,
Wieliczko M. Urinary tract infections in
pregnancy:
old
and
new
unresolved
diagnostic
and
therapeutic
problems. Archives
of
medical
science:
AMS. 2015;11(1):67. [2] Matuszkiewicz-Rowińska J, Małyszko J,
Wieliczko M. Urinary tract infections in
pregnancy:
old
and
new
unresolved
diagnostic
and
therapeutic
problems. Archives
of
medical
science:
AMS. 2015;11(1):67. [2] Matuszkiewicz-Rowińska J, Małyszko J,
Wieliczko M. Urinary tract infections in
pregnancy:
old
and
new
unresolved
diagnostic
and
therapeutic
problems. Archives
of
medical
science:
AMS. 2015;11(1):67. [9] Fajer ZB, Al-Ezzy AIA, Al-Zuhairi AH. Evaluation Of Risk Factors For Dermal
Infections with Staphylococcus au-reus and
Methicillin Resistant Staphylococcus aureus
Among Sheep In Diyala Governorate, Iraq. Diyala Journal for Veterinary Sciences-Print
ISSN: 2410-8863. 2023;1(1):98-125. [3] Pulido-Cejudo A, Guzmán-Gutierrez M,
Jalife-Montaño A, Ortiz-Covarrubias A,
Martínez-Ordaz JL, Noyola-Villalobos HF, et
al. Management of acute bacterial skin and
skin structure infections with a focus on
patients at high risk of treatment failure. Therapeutic advances in infectious disease. 2017;4(5):143-61. [10] Fajer ZB, AL-Ezzy AIA, AL-Zuhairi
AH. Molecular detection of MecA, Blaz
Genes and phenotypic detection of Antibiotic
Sensitivity Pattern For S. aureus And MRSA
Isolated From Dermal lesions of Sheep In
Diyala Governorate-Iraq. Diyala Journal for
Veterinary Sciences 2023;2(1):50-65. [4 Lindsay JA. Hospital-associated MRSA
and antibiotic resistance—What have we
learned from genomics? International Journal
of
Medical
Microbiology. 2013;303(6-
7):318-23. [11] Fajer ZB, Al-Ezzy AIA, AL-Zuhairi
AH. Sociodemographic Risk Factors for
Dermal Infections with Methi-cillin Sensitive
and Methicillin Resistant Staphylococcus
aureus among Sheep Breeders in Diyala
Governorate,
Iraq. Diyala
Journal
of
Medicine. 2023;24(1):66-84. [11] Fajer ZB, Al-Ezzy AIA, AL-Zuhairi
AH. Sociodemographic Risk Factors for
Dermal Infections with Methi-cillin Sensitive
and Methicillin Resistant Staphylococcus
aureus among Sheep Breeders in Diyala
Governorate,
Iraq. Diyala
Journal
of
Medicine. 2023;24(1):66-84. [12] Liu GY. References Molecular pathogenesis of
Staphylococcus aureus infection. Pediatric
research. 2009;65(7):71-7. [5] Moshe T-FETO. A. Goldschmidt-Tran O. Sawaya MR Coquelle N. Coquelle JP Landau
M. Science. 2017;355:831-3. [6] Chino T, Nukui Y, Morishita Y, Moriya
K. Morphological bactericidal fast-acting
effects of peracetic acid, a high-level
disinfectant, against Staphylococcus aureus
and Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms in [12] Liu GY. Molecular pathogenesis of
Staphylococcus aureus infection. Pediatric
research. 2009;65(7):71-7. 19 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Staphylococcus
aureus
among
Dessie
Referral Hospital health care workers;
Dessie, Northeast Ethiopia. Antimicrobial
resistance and infection control. 2013;2:1-5. [20] Allam AAE, Fakhr AE, Mahmoud ME,
El-Korashi LA. Staphylococcus aureus nasal
colonization among health care workers at an
Egyptian tertiary care hospital. Microbes and
Infectious Diseases. 2021;2(1):108-18. [13] Novelli-Rousseau A, Espagnon I,
Filiputti D, Gal O, Douet A, Mallard F, et al. Culture-free
antibiotic-susceptibility
determination from single-bacterium Raman
spectra. Scientific reports. 2018;8(1):1-12. [14] Al-Ezzy AIA, Khadim AT. Evaluation
For
sociodemographic
Risk
Factors
associated with Cryptosporidium Parvum
Infection In Children under Five years. Diyala Journal For Veterinary Sciences. 2021;1(2):100-14. [13] Novelli-Rousseau A, Espagnon I,
Filiputti D, Gal O, Douet A, Mallard F, et al. Culture-free
antibiotic-susceptibility
determination from single-bacterium Raman
spectra. Scientific reports. 2018;8(1):1-12. [14] Al-Ezzy AIA, Khadim AT. Evaluation
For
sociodemographic
Risk
Factors
associated with Cryptosporidium Parvum
Infection In Children under Five years. Diyala Journal For Veterinary Sciences. 2021;1(2):100-14. [21] de Benito S, Alou L, Becerro-de-
Bengoa-Vallejo
R,
Losa-Iglesias
ME,
Gómez-Lus ML, Collado L, et al. Prevalence
of Staphylococcus spp. nasal colonization
among doctors of podiatric medicine and
associated
risk
factors
in
Spain. Antimicrobial
Resistance
&
Infection
Control. 2018;7(1):1-7. [15] AL-Ezzy AIA. In Situ Nick End
Labeling as a Molecular Immunopathological
Indicator
for
the
Severity
of
DNA
Fragmentationand
Gastroduodenal
Tissue
Damage among H. Pylori Cag APositive
Patients. Indian Journal of Science and
Technology. 2016;9(2). [22] Khalili Mohammad B, Moshref M,
Sharifi M, Sadeh M, Sazmand A. Prevalence
Of
Staphylococcus
Aureus
(SA)
And
Methicillin Resistant Staphylococcus Aureus
(MRSA) In Personnel Of Operation Room Of
Shahid Sadoughi Hospital, Yazd, Iran. Payavard Salamat. 2013;6(5). [16] Al-Ezzy AIA, Al-Khalidi AAH, Hameed
MS. Evaluation of C-Reactive Protein in
Iraqi
Children
Presented
with
Acute
Enteropathogenic
Escherichia
Coli
Associated Diarrhea with Special Emphasis
to Age and Gender. Gazi Medical Journal. 2020;31:143-8. [16] Al-Ezzy AIA, Al-Khalidi AAH, Hameed
MS. References Evaluation of C-Reactive Protein in
Iraqi
Children
Presented
with
Acute
Enteropathogenic
Escherichia
Coli
Associated Diarrhea with Special Emphasis
to Age and Gender. Gazi Medical Journal. 2020;31:143-8. [23] Silva ECBFd, Antas MdGC, B Neto
AM, Rabelo MA, Melo FLd, Maciel MAV. Prevalence
and
risk
factors
for
Staphylococcus aureus in health care workers
at a university hospital of Recife-PE. Brazilian Journal of Infectious Diseases. 2008;12:504-8. [17] Genc O, Arikan I. The relationship
between hand hygiene practices and nasal
Staphylococcus aureus carriage in healthcare
workers. La
Medicina
del
Lavoro. 2020;111(1):54. [18] Legese H, Kahsay AG, Kahsay A, Araya
T, Adhanom G, Muthupandian S, et al. Nasal
carriage, risk factors and antimicrobial
susceptibility pattern of methicillin resistant
Staphylococcus aureus among healthcare
workers in Adigrat and Wukro hospitals,
Tigray, Northern Ethiopia. BMC research
notes. 2018;11(1):1-6. [19] Shibabaw A, Abebe T, Mihret A. Nasal
carriage
rate
of
methicillin
resistant [24]
Pourramezan
N,
Moghadam
SO,
Pourmand
MR. Methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus
tracking
spread
among health-care workers and hospitalized
patients in critical wards at a university
hospital, Tehran, Iran. New microbes and
new infections. 2019;27:29-35. [25] Giri N, Maharjan S, Thapa TB, Pokhrel
S, Joshi G, Shrestha O, et al. Nasal carriage 20 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine Gingivitis Caused by Staphylococcus aureus. Inter J Pharmaceutical Quality Assurance. 2019;10:02. of
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus among healthcare workers in a tertiary
care
hospital,
Kathmandu,
Nepal. International
Journal
of
Microbiology. 2021;2021. [32] Wu T-H, Lee C-Y, Yang H-J, Fang Y-P,
Chang Y-F, Tzeng S-L, et al. Prevalence and
molecular characteristics
of methicillin-
resistant Staphylococcus aureus among nasal
carriage strains isolated from emergency
department patients and healthcare workers
in central Taiwan. Journal of Microbiology,
Immunology and Infection. 2019;52(2):248-
54. [26] Al Wahaibi L, Al Sudairi R, Balkhair A,
Al-Awaisi H, Mabruk M. Methicillin-
resistant Staphylococcus aureus colonization
among healthcare workers in Oman. The
Journal of Infection in Developing Countries. 2021;15(10):1426-35. [27] Khatri S, Pant ND, Bhandari R, Shrestha
KL, Shrestha CD, Adhikari N, et al. Nasal
carriage
rate
of
methicillin
resistant
Staphylococcus aureus among health care
workers at a tertiary care hospital in
Kathmandu, Nepal. Journal of Nepal Health
Research Council. 2017;15(1):26-30. [33] Sharma A, Kalita JM, Nag VL. Screening
for
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus carriage on the hands
of healthcare workers: an assessment for
hand hygiene practices. References Effect of ablution on Methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus
(MRSA)
nasal
colonisation in healthcare workers. J Pak
Med Assoc. 2021;71:1472-5. [45] Wulf M, Tiemersma E, Kluytmans J,
Bogaers D, Leenders A, Jansen M, et al. MRSA carriage in healthcare personnel in
contact with farm animals. Journal of
Hospital Infection. 2008;70(2):186-90. [46]Schubert M, Kämpf D, Wahl M,
Hofmann S, Girbig M, Jatzwauk L, et al. MRSA point prevalence among health care
workers in German rehabilitation centers: a
multi-center, cross-sectional study in a non-
outbreak setting. International Journal of
Environmental Research and Public Health. 2019;16(9):1660. [38] Shahsavarinia K, Samadi Kafil H. Prevalence
of
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus colonization in the
emergency department health care workers. Journal of Research in Clinical Medicine. 2020;8(1):30-. [38] Shahsavarinia K, Samadi Kafil H. Prevalence
of
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus colonization in the
emergency department health care workers. Journal of Research in Clinical Medicine. 2020;8(1):30-. [44] Shoaib NF, Ain QU, Iqbal K, Asif M. Effect of ablution on Methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus
(MRSA)
nasal
colonisation in healthcare workers. J Pak
Med Assoc. 2021;71:1472-5. [39] Salman MK, Ashraf MS, Iftikhar S,
Baig MAR. Frequency of nasal carriage of
Staphylococcus Aureus among health care
workers at a Tertiary Care Hospital. Pakistan
journal
of
medical
sciences. 2018;34(5):1181. ;
[45] Wulf M, Tiemersma E, Kluytmans J,
Bogaers D, Leenders A, Jansen M, et al. MRSA carriage in healthcare personnel in
contact with farm animals. Journal of
Hospital Infection. 2008;70(2):186-90. [46]Schubert M, Kämpf D, Wahl M,
Hofmann S, Girbig M, Jatzwauk L, et al. MRSA point prevalence among health care
workers in German rehabilitation centers: a
multi-center, cross-sectional study in a non-
outbreak setting. International Journal of
Environmental Research and Public Health. 2019;16(9):1660. [45] Wulf M, Tiemersma E, Kluytmans J,
Bogaers D, Leenders A, Jansen M, et al. MRSA carriage in healthcare personnel in
contact with farm animals. Journal of
Hospital Infection. 2008;70(2):186-90. [40] Sassmannshausen R, Deurenberg RH,
Köck R, Hendrix R, Jurke A, Rossen JW, et
al. MRSA prevalence and associated risk
factors among health-care workers in non-
outbreak situations in the Dutch-German
EUREGIO. Frontiers
in
microbiology. 2016;7:1273. [46]Schubert M, Kämpf D, Wahl M,
Hofmann S, Girbig M, Jatzwauk L, et al. MRSA point prevalence among health care
workers in German rehabilitation centers: a
multi-center, cross-sectional study in a non-
outbreak setting. International Journal of
Environmental Research and Public Health. 2019;16(9):1660. [41] Dulon M, Peters C, Schablon A,
Nienhaus
A. References Indian Journal of
Critical
Care
Medicine:
Peer-reviewed,
Official Publication of Indian Society of
Critical Care Medicine. 2019;23(12):590. [34] Snyder GM, Thorn KA, Furuno JP,
Perencevich EN, Roghmann M-C, Strauss
SM, et al. Detection of methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus and vancomycin-
resistant enterococci on the gowns and gloves
of healthcare workers. Infection Control &
Hospital Epidemiology. 2008;29(7):583-9. [35] Morgan DJ, Rogawski E, Thom KA,
Johnson JK, Perencevich EN, Shardell M, et
al. Transfer of multidrug-resistant bacteria to
healthcare workers’ gloves and gowns after
patient contact increases with environmental
contamination. Critical
care
medicine. 2012;40(4):1045. [28] Moni SC, Sihan MN, Saha D, Akter S,
Mannan M, Shahidullah M. Nasal Carriage
Rate of Staphylococcus Aureus and Risk
Factors among Healthcare Workers and
Attendants of Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
in a Tertiary Care Centre in Bangladesh. Journal of Pediatrics, Perinatology and Child
Health. 2022;6(1):188-99. [29]
Hasan
SA,
Saleh
I,
Ali
H. Bacteriological and Molecular Detection of
Staphylococcus Aureus and its Resistance to
Methicillin among Specimens from Kirkuk
Community. Annals of the Romanian Society
for Cell Biology. 2021;25(7):461-73. [30] Rashid Z, Farzana K, Sattar A, Murtaza
G. Prevalence of nasal Staphylococcus
aureus
and
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus in hospital personnel
and associated risk factors. Acta Poloniae
Pharmaceutica. 2012;69(5):985-91. [31] Zghair MH Hussain MS
Sahib AA [29]
Hasan
SA,
Saleh
I,
Ali
H. Bacteriological and Molecular Detection of
Staphylococcus Aureus and its Resistance to
Methicillin among Specimens from Kirkuk
Community. Annals of the Romanian Society
for Cell Biology. 2021;25(7):461-73. [30] Rashid Z, Farzana K, Sattar A, Murtaza
G. Prevalence of nasal Staphylococcus
aureus
and
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus in hospital personnel
and associated risk factors. Acta Poloniae
Pharmaceutica. 2012;69(5):985-91. [36] Mitchell A, Spencer M, Edmiston Jr C. Role of healthcare apparel and other
healthcare textiles in the transmission of
pathogens: a review of the literature. Journal
of Hospital Infection. 2015;90(4):285-92. [36] Mitchell A, Spencer M, Edmiston Jr C. Role of healthcare apparel and other
healthcare textiles in the transmission of
pathogens: a review of the literature. Journal
of Hospital Infection. 2015;90(4):285-92. [31] Zghair MH, Hussain MS, Sahib AA. Studying
Some
Factors
Affecting
in 21 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine [42] El Aila NA, Al Laham NA, Ayesh BM. Nasal
carriage
of
methicillin
resistant
Staphylococcus aureus among health care
workers at Al Shifa hospital in Gaza Strip. BMC infectious diseases. 2017;17(1):1-7. References [43] Al-Humaidan OS, El-Kersh TA, Al-
Akeel RA. Risk factors of nasal carriage of
Staphylococcus
aureus
and
methicillin-
resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus
among
health care staff in a teaching hospital in
central Saudi Arabia. Saudi Medical Journal. 2015;36(9):1084. [42] El Aila NA, Al Laham NA, Ayesh BM. Nasal
carriage
of
methicillin
resistant
Staphylococcus aureus among health care
workers at Al Shifa hospital in Gaza Strip. BMC infectious diseases. 2017;17(1):1-7. [43] Al-Humaidan OS, El-Kersh TA, Al-
Akeel RA. Risk factors of nasal carriage of
Staphylococcus
aureus
and
methicillin-
resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus
among
health care staff in a teaching hospital in
central Saudi Arabia. Saudi Medical Journal. 2015;36(9):1084. [37] Halwani M, Hussein E, Al-Hawarri H,
Alghamdi H, Alghamdi H, Alghamdi A, et
al. Bacterial Contamination of Healthcare
Providers’ Mobile Phones: Potential Risk of
Transmission. American
Journal
of
Epidemiology. 2021;9(1):4-10. [38] Shahsavarinia K, Samadi Kafil H. Prevalence
of
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus colonization in the
emergency department health care workers. Journal of Research in Clinical Medicine. 2020;8(1):30-. [37] Halwani M, Hussein E, Al-Hawarri H,
Alghamdi H, Alghamdi H, Alghamdi A, et
al. Bacterial Contamination of Healthcare
Providers’ Mobile Phones: Potential Risk of
Transmission. American
Journal
of
Epidemiology. 2021;9(1):4-10. [38] Shahsavarinia K, Samadi Kafil H. Prevalence
of
methicillin-resistant
Staphylococcus aureus colonization in the
emergency department health care workers. Journal of Research in Clinical Medicine. 2020;8(1):30-. [39] Salman MK, Ashraf MS, Iftikhar S,
Baig MAR. Frequency of nasal carriage of
Staphylococcus Aureus among health care
workers at a Tertiary Care Hospital. Pakistan
journal
of
medical
sciences. 2018;34(5):1181. [40] Sassmannshausen R, Deurenberg RH,
Köck R, Hendrix R, Jurke A, Rossen JW, et
al. MRSA prevalence and associated risk
factors among health-care workers in non-
outbreak situations in the Dutch-German
EUREGIO. Frontiers
in
microbiology. 2016;7:1273. [41] Dulon M, Peters C, Schablon A,
Nienhaus
A. MRSA
carriage
among
healthcare workers in non-outbreak settings
in Europe and the United States: a systematic
review. BMC infectious diseases. 2014;14:1- [42] El Aila NA, Al Laham NA, Ayesh BM. Nasal
carriage
of
methicillin
resistant
Staphylococcus aureus among health care
workers at Al Shifa hospital in Gaza Strip. BMC infectious diseases. 2017;17(1):1-7. [43] Al-Humaidan OS, El-Kersh TA, Al-
Akeel RA. Risk factors of nasal carriage of
Staphylococcus
aureus
and
methicillin-
resistant
Staphylococcus
aureus
among
health care staff in a teaching hospital in
central Saudi Arabia. Saudi Medical Journal. 2015;36(9):1084. [44] Shoaib NF, Ain QU, Iqbal K, Asif M. References االستعمار ببكتريا المكورات
.العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين مرتبط بجناح الواجب في طابق رعاية األطفال
الكلمات
المفتاحية:
العاملون في الرعاية الصحية , بكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية , بكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية
المقاومه ل
لميثيسيلين, عوامل الخطر
البريد االلكتروني:
alizziibrahim@gmail.com
تاريخ :استالم البحث16
آب
2022
تاريخ قبول البحث :
11
ايلول
2022 ع
عإ
ي
.والكائنات الحية الدقيقة المقيمة المنافسة
اهداف الدراسة: عوامل الخطر لالستعمار بالمكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية ال
ذهبية المقاومة
للميثيسيلين بين
العاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية في مستشفى البتول التعليمي للوالدة واألطفال في ديالى , العراق. :المرضى والطرائق
تم أخذ ما مجموعه27
مسحة من العاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية في مستشفى البتول التعليمي للوالدة
, واألطفال في ديالى
العراق , واستخدمت اإلجراءات الميكروبيولوجية القياسية لتشخيص بكتريا العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات
ل
ة لل ث
ة ال قا
ة الذ
ال ق اهداف الدراسة: عوامل الخطر لالستعمار بالمكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية ال
ذهبية المقاومة
للميثيسيلين بين
العاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية في مستشفى البتول التعليمي للوالدة واألطفال في ديالى , العراق. يأا
ي
ي
ي
:المرضى والطرائق
تم أخذ ما مجموعه27
مسحة من العاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية في مستشفى البتول التعليمي للوالدة
, واألطفال في ديالى
العراق , واستخدمت اإلجراءات الميكروبيولوجية القياسية لتشخيص بكتريا العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات
.العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين :النتائج
وجد عالقة ارتباط إحصائي بين العمر واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية
الم قاومة للميثيسيلين. وجد ارتباط عكسي بين مستوى التعليم واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات
.العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين. وجد ارتباط كبير بين حب الشباب واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية
وجد ارتباط كبير بين التهاب الجيوب األنفية , وسنوات الخبرة , والتواصل مع حيوانات المزرعة واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات
العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين. وجد ارتباط كبير بين ردهه الواجب في طابق رعايه
االطفال و واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهب
ية المقاومة للميثيسيلين اا
االستنتاجات:
االستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين مرتبطان عكسيا
بالفئة العمرية األصغر , والمستوى التعليمي للعاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية . االستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقود ية
( الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين مرتبطان بالتهاب الجيوب األنفية , عدد سنوات الخبره5-6
, )
مالمسة حيوانات المزرعة. االستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية
مرتبط بحب الشباب. References MRSA
carriage
among
healthcare workers in non-outbreak settings
in Europe and the United States: a systematic
review. BMC infectious diseases. 2014;14:1- 14. 22 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2 ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Published: 30 June 2023
Doi: 10.26505/DJM.24026850816 Diyala Journal of Medicine عوامل الخطر لالستعمار بالمكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية
المقاومة
للميثيسيلين بين العاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية في مستشفى البتول
التعليمي للوالدة واألطفال في ديالى ، العراق
3,علي ابراهيم علي العزي2عبد الجبار رياض عباس ,1محمد محجوب الجبوري
الملخص عوامل الخطر لالستعمار بالمكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية
المقاومة
للميثيسيلين بين العاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية في مستشفى البتول
التعليمي للوالدة واألطفال في ديالى ، العراق
3,علي ابراهيم علي العزي2عبد الجبار رياض عباس ,1محمد محجوب الجبوري
الملخص :خلفية الدراسة
يمثل استعمار المكورات العنقودية الذهبية في أنف اإلنسان تأثيرًا صعبًا يتطلب التعامل مع دفاع المضيف
.والكائنات الحية الدقيقة المقيمة المنافسة :خلفية الدراسة
يمثل استعمار المكورات العنقودية الذهبية في أنف اإلنسان تأثيرًا صعبًا يتطلب التعامل مع دفاع المضيف
.والكائنات الحية الدقيقة المقيمة المنافسة :خلفية الدراسة
يمثل استعمار المكورات العنقودية الذهبية في أنف اإلنسان تأثيرًا صعبًا يتطلب التعامل مع دفاع المضيف
.والكائنات الحية الدقيقة المقيمة المنافسة
اهداف الدراسة: عوامل الخطر لالستعمار بالمكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية ال
ذهبية المقاومة
للميثيسيلين بين
العاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية في مستشفى البتول التعليمي للوالدة واألطفال في ديالى , العراق. :المرضى والطرائق
تم أخذ ما مجموعه27
مسحة من العاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية في مستشفى البتول التعليمي للوالدة
, واألطفال في ديالى
العراق , واستخدمت اإلجراءات الميكروبيولوجية القياسية لتشخيص بكتريا العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات
.العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين
:النتائج
وجد عالقة ارتباط إحصائي بين العمر واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية
الم قاومة للميثيسيلين. وجد ارتباط عكسي بين مستوى التعليم واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات
.العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين. وجد ارتباط كبير بين حب الشباب واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية
وجد ارتباط كبير بين التهاب الجيوب األنفية , وسنوات الخبرة , والتواصل مع حيوانات المزرعة واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات
العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين. وجد ارتباط كبير بين ردهه الواجب في طابق رعايه
االطفال و واالستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهب
ية المقاومة للميثيسيلين
االستنتاجات:
االستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين مرتبطان عكسيا
بالفئة العمرية األصغر , والمستوى التعليمي للعاملين في مجال الرعاية الصحية . االستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقود ية
( الذهبية والمكورات العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين مرتبطان بالتهاب الجيوب األنفية , عدد سنوات الخبره5-6
, )
مالمسة حيوانات المزرعة. االستعمار ببكتريا المكورات العنقودية الذهبية
مرتبط بحب الشباب. References االستعمار ببكتريا المكورات
.العنقودية الذهبية المقاومة للميثيسيلين مرتبط بجناح الواجب في طابق رعاية األطفال البريد االلكتروني:
alizziibrahim@gmail.com
تاريخ :استالم البحث16
آب
2022
تاريخ قبول البحث :
11
ايلول
2022 البريد االلكتروني:
alizziibrahim@gmail.com
تاريخ :استالم البحث16
آب
2022
تاريخ قبول البحث :
11
ايلول
2022 2,1
كلية العلوم-
جامعة تكريت-
صالح الدين– العر
اق
3 كلية الطب
البيطري–
جامعة ديالى–
ديالى- العراق 23 June 2023 ,Volume 24, Issue 2
|
https://openalex.org/W4306173537
|
https://jnanobiotechnology.biomedcentral.com/counter/pdf/10.1186/s12951-022-01641-0
|
English
| null |
Cancer-derived small extracellular vesicles: emerging biomarkers and therapies for pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma diagnosis/prognosis and treatment
|
Journal of nanobiotechnology
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 19,048
|
© The Author(s) 2022. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use,
sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and
the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this
article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included
in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will
need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The
Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available
in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Journal of Nanobiotechnology Journal of Nanobiotechnology Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12951-022-01641-0 REVIEW Open Access Abstract Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) is one of the most fatal cancers worldwide with high mortality, which
is mainly due to the lack of reliable biomarkers for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis in the early stages and effective
therapeutic strategies for the treatment. Cancer-derived small extracellular vesicles (sEVs), which carry various
messages and signal biomolecules (e.g. RNAs, DNAs, proteins, lipids, and glycans) to constitute the key features
(e.g. genetic and phenotypic status) of cancer cells, are regarded as highly competitive non-invasive biomarkers
for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. Additionally, new insights on the biogenesis and molecular functions of cancer-
derived sEVs pave the way for novel therapeutic strategies based on cancer-derived sEVs for PDAC treatment
such as inhibition of the formation or secretion of cancer-derived sEVs, using cancer-derived sEVs as drug carriers
and for immunotherapy. This review provides a comprehensive overview of the most recent scientific and clinical
research on the discovery and involvement of key molecules in cancer-derived sEVs for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis
and strategies using cancer-derived sEVs for PDAC treatment. The current limitations and emerging trends toward
clinical application of cancer-derived sEVs in PDAC diagnosis/prognosis and treatment have also been discussed. Keywords Pancreatic cancer, Extracellular vesicles, Cancer diagnosis/prognosis, Cancer treatment Wei Zhang1, Douglas H. Campbell2, Bradley J. Walsh2, Nicolle H. Packer1, Dingbin Liu3* and Yuling Wang1* Zhang1, Douglas H. Campbell2, Bradley J. Walsh2, Nicolle H. Packer1, Dingbin Liu3* and Yuling Wang Wei Zhang1, Douglas H. Campbell2, Bradley J. Walsh2, Nicolle H. Packer1, Dingbin Liu3* and Yuling Wang1* Introduction Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC), account
ing for more than 90% of pancreatic cancers, is one of
the most aggressive malignancies with a 5-year survival
rate of 8-9%.[1–6] It has been reported that only 15–20%
of PDAC patients can be surgically resected; the other
80–85% of patients present with unresectable metastatic
or locally progressed diseases.[7, 8] Most PDAC patients
still suffer local recurrence or systematic metastasis in 12
months after surgery, with an overall 5-year survival rate
between 20% and 30%.[9] There were over 55,989 new
cases (29,673 men and 26,316 women) of PDAC diag
nosed in the United States in 2022 according to cancer
statistics of American Cancer Society.[10] And PDAC *Correspondence:
Dingbin Liu
liudb@nankai.edu.cn
Yuling Wang
yuling.wang@mq.edu.au
1School of Natural Sciences, Faculty of Science and Engineering, ARC
Centre of Excellence for Nanoscale BioPhotonics (CNBP), Macquarie
University, 2109 Sydney, NSW, Australia
2Minomic International Ltd, Macquarie Park, 2113 Sydney, NSW, Australia
3State Key Laboratory of Medicinal Chemical Biology, Research Center for
Analytical Sciences, and Tianjin Key Laboratory of Molecular Recognition
and Biosensing, College of Chemistry, Nankai University, 300071 Tianjin,
China *Correspondence:
Dingbin Liu
liudb@nankai.edu.cn
Yuling Wang
yuling.wang@mq.edu.au
1School of Natural Sciences, Faculty of Science and Engineering, ARC
Centre of Excellence for Nanoscale BioPhotonics (CNBP), Macquarie
University, 2109 Sydney, NSW, Australia
2Minomic International Ltd, Macquarie Park, 2113 Sydney, NSW, Australia
3State Key Laboratory of Medicinal Chemical Biology, Research Center for
Analytical Sciences, and Tianjin Key Laboratory of Molecular Recognition
and Biosensing, College of Chemistry, Nankai University, 300071 Tianjin,
China © The Author(s) 2022. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use,
sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and
the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this
article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included
in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will
need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The
Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available
in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 2 of 20 Page 2 of 20 (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology Fig. 1 Biogenesis and identification of small extracellular vesicles (sEVs). sEVs originate from the endosomal pathway by the formation of endosomes
and MVBs. When MVBs fuse with cell membrane, sEVs are released into extracellular milieu. sEVs are composed of a lipid bilayer vesicle containing nucleic
acids, proteins, lipids, glycans, and other small molecules Fig. 1 Biogenesis and identification of small extracellular vesicles (sEVs). sEVs originate from the endosomal pathway by the formation of endosomes
and MVBs. When MVBs fuse with cell membrane, sEVs are released into extracellular milieu. sEVs are composed of a lipid bilayer vesicle containing nucleic
acids, proteins, lipids, glycans, and other small molecules has been estimated to surpass colon cancer as the sec
ond leading cause of cancer-related death in the United
States by 2030.[11] The majority of patients failed to
be diagnosed in the early stage of PDAC, which caused
approximately 48,220 deaths.[12] Despite various fac
tors that influence cancer patient outcomes, there remain
two essential problems, namely reliable PDAC diagno
sis/prognosis and effective treatment regimes. The poor
diagnosis/prognosis of PDAC is attributed to multiple
reasons, including non-specific symptoms or even no
symptoms in the early stage of PDAC, lack of sensitive
and specific PDAC biomarkers, and difficulties in imag
ing early-stage tumors.[5] While the treatment failure
of PDAC is typically caused by its insidious onset, high
invasiveness and metastasis[13], detecting PDAC at an
early stage is crucial to improve the therapeutic effect
and thereby significantly increase the overall survival of
PDAC patients. lesions or to differentiate benign from malignant lesions. [20] On the other hand, tissue biopsies are invasive, show
low sensitivity and require specialized surgical skills and
facilities for sampling.[21, 22] Therefore, PDAC patients
can only gain very limited benefit from the advanced sur
gical techniques, perioperative management and onco
logical treatments due to the weaknesses of the current
diagnostic methods for early PDAC diagnosis. There is an
urgent need for reliable, specific and sensitive PDAC bio
markers and diagnosis methods to improve the diagnos
tic accuracy of PDAC at early stages. lesions or to differentiate benign from malignant lesions. [20] On the other hand, tissue biopsies are invasive, show
low sensitivity and require specialized surgical skills and
facilities for sampling.[21, 22] Therefore, PDAC patients
can only gain very limited benefit from the advanced sur
gical techniques, perioperative management and onco
logical treatments due to the weaknesses of the current
diagnostic methods for early PDAC diagnosis. There is an
urgent need for reliable, specific and sensitive PDAC bio
markers and diagnosis methods to improve the diagnos
tic accuracy of PDAC at early stages. Earlier diagnosis of cancer would give patients more
time for treatment, but patient outcomes will not be sig
nificantly improved without efficient treatment plans. The currently available therapeutic options for PDAC
involve the combination of chemotherapy, surgery, radia
tion and immunotherapy, most of which are palliative
treatments aiming to relieve the symptoms and prolong
the patient survival rate.[23] However, PDAC can survive
under these harsh conditions and increase proliferative
ability because of its genetic and metabolic remodeling. [24, 25] Furthermore, a dense and diffuse stroma form
ing around the tumor can increase its resistance to treat
ments and affect the tumor progression.[25] PDAC may
also develop chemoresistance during treatment due to
tumor heterogeneity and plasticity.[26, 27] These char
acteristics make PDAC resistant to traditional treatment
approaches and lead to poor clinical outcomes, thus
innovative therapies are required to improve the pros
pects of PDAC patients. Fortunately, researchers have
discovered emerging biomarkers and treatment candi
dates for both PDAC diagnosis and therapy after inten
sive studies of extracellular vesicles (EVs) in recent years.i Currently, there are no validated and specific tests to
reliably diagnose PDAC in clinic, particularly during
early stages. PDAC is usually diagnosed by biochemi
cal examination, imaging examination and tissue biopsy. [14] The most extensively evaluated biomarker for bio
chemical examination of PDAC is carbohydrate antigen
19−9 (CA19-9). However, CA19-9 has insufficient sen
sitivity and specificity to distinguish the PDAC patients
from healthy people or patients with other pancreatic
disease (chronic pancreatitis, acute pancreatitis, etc.).[15,
16] Studies have shown that multiple biomarkers pro
vide more accurate results than individual biomarkers. [17, 18] For example, Shreya et al. identified a diagnostic
panel of 4 serum biomarkers (S100A2, A100A4, CA-125
and CA19-9) which had higher diagnostic potential
(AUC 0.913) than CA19-9 alone (AUC 0.869) in a small
study of 120 PDAC patients and 80 healthy controls. [19] However, larger clinical trials are still essential to
validate its accuracy and investigate the potential for
early PDAC detection. Imaging examination, such as
contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT), mag
netic resonance imaging (MRI), and endoscopic ultra
sound are quite expensive and inefficient to detect early EVs released from a variety of cell types are classified
into three broad groups according to their size, pathway
of origin, and biomolecules: small EVs (sEVs) (namely
exosomes, 40–200nm) (Fig.1), microvesicles (micropar
ticles or ectosomes, 50-2000nm) and apoptotic bodies
(500–4000nm).[28, 29] In the past decade, sEVs have
attracted worldwide attention among researchers from
various fields of life sciences because of their special and Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 3 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology cancer-derived sEVs to be promising candidates for pro
viding novel therapeutic strategies for cancer treatment. Cancer-derived sEVs have been reported to play dif
ferent roles in PDAC, including cancer initiation, pro
gression, metastasis, drug resistance, cancer diagnosis/
prognosis and treatment. [32, 35, 48] In this review, we
will mainly focus on the most recent progress in the
use of key molecules of cancer-derived sEVs as emerg
ing biomarkers for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis and can
cer-derived sEVs based therapeutic strategies for PDAC
treatment, as well as discussing the current hurdles and
perspectives for further clinical applications, with the
aim of gaining new insights for researchers working on
sEVs in cancer diagnosis/prognosis and treatment. important roles in various biological functions (angio
genesis, cell apoptosis, inflammation and immune regu
lation, etc.) at normal physiological condition as well as
pathological condition, determining by which cells they
originate as well as the status of these cells at time of sEV
generation.[30] sEVs derived from cancer cells played a
crucial role in PDAC biology, including tumorigenesis,
cancer progression, cancer metastasis, immune regula
tion and therapeutic resistance, etc., showing great value
in cancer studies.[31, 32] Cancer-derived sEVs are small,
lipid bilayer membrane vesicles generated inside the cell
in multivesicular bodies (MVBs), which release cancer-
derived sEVs into the extracellular microenvironment
by fusion with the cell membrane (Fig.1).[1, 33] These
cancer-derived small vesicles contain numerous bio
molecules including DNAs, RNAs, proteins, glycans
and lipids, which can be transported from donor cells
to other recipient cells (adjacent or distant cells) mainly
by receptor-ligand binding, endocytosis and direct
fusion, to establish a desired small-scale environment
for modifying the functions (gene expression, signaling,
and overall functions) in states of cancers.[34] Although
the mechanism of cancer-derived sEV for tumorigenesis
is complex, it is generally accepted that the interactions
of cancer associated proteins and oncogenes between
cancer cells and healthy cells promote the process. [35]
These cancer associated biomolecules in cancer derived
sEVs can activate the signal transduction pathways and
induce cellular change within recipient cells to regulate
cancer growth and metastasis.[36] Body fluids such as
blood in cancer patients contain diverse mixture of EV
subsets, among which cancer-derived sEVs (~ 23–66%
of total sEVs in plasma) are substantial and important
EV subset, acting as an indicator of tumor and holding
a significant potential to serve as a liquid biopsy tool for
cancer diagnosis/prognosis.[37–40] These sEVs secreted
by cancer cells can be collected and provide the dynamic
information from the tumors at the time of blood draw
ing. Thus, cancer-derived sEVs are promising cancer bio
markers for non-invasive cancer diagnosis/prognosis. [41–44] In addition, cancer-derived sEVs have also been
explored for their use in cancer therapeutics. Using sEVs
in therapeutics has been studied for preventing the for
mation and release of cancer-derived sEVs; using cancer-
derived sEVs as drug delivery vesicles; as well as using
cancer-derived sEVs in immunotherapy. Compared with
synthetic nanoparticles, cancer-derived sEVs encompass
several desirable attributes: intrinsic ability to carry bio
molecules such as RNAs, DNAs, and proteins ; immune
tolerance when using autologous-derived sEVs; desir
able stability in body fluids; natural targeting property of
cancer cells; ease of surface modification and ability to
cross biological barriers, such as the blood-brain barrier
(BBB).[45–47] Overall, these advantageous features allow PDAC diagnosis/prognosis Given the absence of non-invasive and robust biomarkers
for PDAC diagnosis, there has recently been significant
interest in the use of PDAC-derived sEVs as biomarkers
due to their diverse molecular contents. The biogenesis
of sEVs enables the packing of these complex extracellu
lar and intracellular molecular contents into sEVs (or on
the surface of sEVs) in a cell specific manner.[49] These
molecular contents can reflect the key features of cells
from which they originate.[50] As the contents of PDAC-
derived sEVs are cell-type specific, PDAC-derived sEVs
may provide a unique ‘signature’ of genetic and pheno
typic status of the tumor.[51] This molecular signature
is able to discriminate cancer-derived sEVs from differ
ent types of cancer cells, as well as distinguish cancer-
derived sEVs from healthy sEVs. Cancer-derived sEVs
also carry specific oncogenes and oncoproteins (mutant
KRAS, etc.), which can be used to detect cancer-derived
sEVs from other sources of sEVs as well.[52] Moreover,
sEVs secreted by PDAC cells can be easily collected from
body fluids, such as blood. Under the protection of the
endogenous membrane of the sEVs, these biomolecules
carried by sEVs can remain stable inside the blood cir
culation, which makes the PDAC diagnosis/progno
sis more reliable. PDAC-derived sEVs in blood can be
enriched using different isolation approaches (e.g. ultra
centrifugation, immunoaffinity isolation, polymeric pre
cipitation isolation and size exclusion chromatography)
and their molecular components (e.g. RNAs, DNAs,
proteins, lipids and glycans) can be analyzed by corre
sponding techniques (e.g. polymerase chain reaction, gel
electrophoresis, flow cytometry and mass spectroscopy)
for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis (Fig.2). There are plenty
of excellent review articles [30, 31, 49, 53] on sEVs’ ori
gin, isolation, characterization and analysis techniques,
which are not the focus of this review article. Here we
will initially focus on the key molecules that are carried
by PDAC-derived sEVs and discuss their potential as bio
markers in PDAC diagnosis/prognosis . Page 4 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology Fig. 2 Molecular analysis of components in/on sEVs for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. PDAC-derived sEVs circulating in blood can be enriched by tech
niques such as ultracentrifugation. Molecular components including RNAs, DNAs, proteins, lipids and glycans can be analyzed to generate the unique
molecular signature for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis Fig. 2 Molecular analysis of components in/on sEVs for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. PDAC diagnosis/prognosis PDAC-derived sEVs circulating in blood can be enriched by tech
niques such as ultracentrifugation. Molecular components including RNAs, DNAs, proteins, lipids and glycans can be analyzed to generate the unique
molecular signature for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis Fig. 3 Schematic of the formation and release of sEVs. MVB biogenesis is associated with ESCRT-dependent and ESCRT-independent pathways, agents
such as ROCK, RAB, SNARE, Ca2+ affect the release of sEVs from cells Fig. 3 Schematic of the formation and release of sEVs. MVB biogenesis is associated with ESCRT-dependent and ESCRT-independent pathways, agents
such as ROCK, RAB, SNARE, Ca2+ affect the release of sEVs from cells RNAs Journal of Nanobiotechnology Table 1 sEV RNA biomarkers for PDAC diagn
RNA
types
Biomarkers
Sources
Patient
numbers
miRNA
miR-196a
Plasma
Stage I-IIA
n = 15
miR-10b
Plasma
N = 3
miR-451a
Plasma
Stage
I n = 7,
stage II
n = 43
miR-125b-3p,
miR-122-5p, and
miR-205-5p
Plasma
N = 65
miR-10b, miR-
21, miR-30c,
miR-181a and
miR-let7a
Plasma
N = 29
miR-1226-3p
Serum
N = 17
miR-17-5p and
miR-21
Serum
N = 22
miR-451 and
miR-720
Serum
N = 52
miR-191, miR-21
and miR-451a
Serum
N = 32
miR-1246, miR-
4644, miR-3976
and miR-4306
Serum
N = 131
miR-1246 and
miR-4644
Saliva
N = 12
miR-21 and
miR-155
Pancre
atic juice
N = 27
mRNA
GPC-1 mRNA
Serum
Stage
I- II n = 86,
stage III-IV
n = 32
CK18 and CD63
RNA
Plasma
N = 57
Apbb1ip, Aspn,
BCO31781, Daf2,
Foxp1, Gng2,and
Incenp
Saliva
N = 22
(mouse)
lncRNA
Sox2ot
Plasma
N = 61
HULC
Serum
N = 20
Malat-1
and CRNDE
Serum
N = 2
FGA, KRT19,
HIST1H2BK,
TIH2,MARCH2,
CLDN1, MAL2
and TIMP1
Plasma
N = 284
circRNAs
Circ-IARS
Plasma
N = 40
Circ-PDE8A
Plasma
N = 60 Table 1 sEV RNA biomarkers for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis
RNA
types
Biomarkers
Sources
Patient
numbers
Discoveries and diagnostic performance
Ref. miRNA
miR-196a
Plasma
Stage I-IIA
n = 15
Higher miR-196a expression in sEVs from PDAC patients with AUC of 0.81
[58]
miR-10b
Plasma
N = 3
The expression of miR-10b was significantly higher in sEVs from PDAC patients when
compared with patients with chronic pancreatitis (CP) or normal controls
[59]
miR-451a
Plasma
Stage
I n = 7,
stage II
n = 43
The level of miR-451a showed a significant association with cancer diagnosis and cancer
stage discrimination (stage I vs. healthy volunteers P= 0.019, stage II vs. healthy volunteers
P< 0.001, stage II vs. RNAs stage I P= 0.041)
[60]
miR-125b-3p,
miR-122-5p, and
miR-205-5p
Plasma
N = 65
MiR-125b-3p, miR-122-5p, and miR-205-5p were overexpressed in PDAC patients than
healthy people with AUC values of 0.782, 0.814, and 0.857, respectively
[61]
miR-10b, miR-
21, miR-30c,
miR-181a and
miR-let7a
Plasma
N = 29
High levels of miR-10b, miR-21, miR-30c, and miR-181a and a low level of miR-let7a in sEVs
could differentiate PDAC from normal control and CP samples with AUC of 1.00
[13]
miR-1226-3p
Serum
N = 17
The expression of miR-1226-3p was downregulated in PDAC patients compared to benign
pancreatic lesions with AUC of 0.74
[62]
miR-17-5p and
miR-21
Serum
N = 22
High expression of miR-17-5p and miR-21 in sEVs from PDAC patients with AUC of 0.887
and 0.897, respectively
[63]
miR-451 and
miR-720
Serum
N = 52
PDAC patients had significantly higher levels of miR-451 and lower levels of miR-720 in
sEVs than healthy controls with AUC of 0.93 and 1.00, respectively
[64]
miR-191, miR-21
and miR-451a
Serum
N = 32
The expression of miR-191, miR-21 and miR-451a in sEVs was significantly up-regulated in
patients with pancreatic cancer and IPMN compared to controls with AUC of 0.788, 0.826
and 0.759, respectively
[65]
miR-1246, miR-
4644, miR-3976
and miR-4306
Serum
N = 131
The level of miR-1246, miR-4644, miR-3976 and miR-4306 were significantly upregulated
in 83% of the cancer patient group, but rarely in control groups, these marker panels re
markably improved the sensitivity (1.00, CI: 0.95-1) with a specificity of 0.80 (CI: 0.67–0.90)
[66]
miR-1246 and
miR-4644
Saliva
N = 12
The relative expression ratios of miR1246 and miR4644 were significantly higher in
the cancer group than these ratios in the control group with AUC of 0.814 and 0.763,
respectively. RNAs [67]
miR-21 and
miR-155
Pancre
atic juice
N = 27
Relative levels of both ex-miR-21 and ex-miR-155 in EVs were significantly higher in PDAC
patients compared with chronic CP patients
[68]
mRNA
GPC-1 mRNA
Serum
Stage
I- II n = 86,
stage III-IV
n = 32
GPC1 mRNA was enriched in pancreatic cancer patients and could be used to classify
patients with healthy donors with AUC of 1.00 and sensitivity and specificity of 100%
[69]
CK18 and CD63
RNA
Plasma
N = 57
Biomarker panel consisted of miRNA, mRNA, CA19-9, and cell free DNA for PDAC diagnosis
achieved an accuracy of92% (95% CI, 86-96%), with sensitivity of 88% (95% CI, 76-95%)
and specificity of 95% (95% CI, 88-99%)
[70]
Apbb1ip, Aspn,
BCO31781, Daf2,
Foxp1, Gng2,and
Incenp
Saliva
N = 22
(mouse)
The 7 biomarkers were significantly elevated in in pancreatic cancer-bearing mouse saliva
when compared with control saliva (P < 0.05)
[71]
lncRNA
Sox2ot
Plasma
N = 61
Sox2ot in sEVs was significantly associated with cancer stages (P = 0.014) and was also
related to lymphatic or vascular invasion, showing potential as prognosis marker
[72]
HULC
Serum
N = 20
The expression of HULC in sEVs was significantly higher in PDAC patients than in healthy
individuals or IPMN patients with AUC of 0.92
[73]
Malat-1
and CRNDE
Serum
N = 2
Significantly Higher expression levels of Malat-1 and CRNDE in PDAC-derived sEVs than in
healthy donors with P of 0.018 and 0.028
[74]
FGA, KRT19,
HIST1H2BK,
TIH2,MARCH2,
CLDN1, MAL2
and TIMP1
Plasma
N = 284
The signature of a combination of 8 RNAs in sEVs showed high accuracy in PDAC detec
tion with AUC of 0.960, 0.950 and 0.936 in the training, internal validation and external
validation cohort, respectively. RNAs miRNAs are small, noncoding RNAs of ~ 19–24 nucle
otide length and regulate about 70% of mRNA transcripts
in humans, playing vital roles in a variety of cellular pro
cesses such as cancer development. [78, 79] Oncogenic
and cancer-suppressor miRNAs in sEVs may be of high
diagnostic/prognostic value in PDAC because of their
differential expression between cancer cells and normal
cells. For instance, Takahasi et al. profiled the expression
of miRNAs of sEVs from plasma of 50 PDAC patients
and 20 healthy volunteers using real-time quantitative
reverse transcription (qRT-PCR) and found that miR-
451a showed higher upregulation in the patients and was
associated with PDAC stages.60 In another study, Xu et
al. analyzed miRNA expression in sEVs from plasma of PDAC-derived sEVs contain different forms of RNAs,
including micro RNAs (miRNAs), messenger RNAs
(mRNAs), long non-coding RNAs (lncRNAs) and circu
lar RNAs (circRNAs).[54, 55] RNAs in sEVs have been
extensively studied, due to their critical roles in regu
lating almost all aspects of cancer-related metabolism
and function.[56] Among these RNAs, miRNAs are the
most studied target for cancer diagnosis/prognosis,
whereas other RNAs may also act as potential biomark
ers for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. [57] Table1 provides
the reported RNA biomarkers for PDAC diagnosis/
prognosis. Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 5 of 20 Zhang et al. RNAs [75] Table 1 sEV RNA biomarkers for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis Biomarker panel consisted of miRNA, mRNA, CA19-9, and cell free DNA for PDAC diagnosis
achieved an accuracy of92% (95% CI, 86-96%), with sensitivity of 88% (95% CI, 76-95%)
and specificity of 95% (95% CI, 88-99%)
[70]
The 7 biomarkers were significantly elevated in in pancreatic cancer-bearing mouse saliva
when compared with control saliva (P < 0.05)
[71] Sox2ot in sEVs was significantly associated with cancer stages (P = 0.014) and was also
related to lymphatic or vascular invasion, showing potential as prognosis marker
[72]
The expression of HULC in sEVs was significantly higher in PDAC patients than in healthy
individuals or IPMN patients with AUC of 0.92
[73]
Significantly Higher expression levels of Malat-1 and CRNDE in PDAC-derived sEVs than in
healthy donors with P of 0.018 and 0.028
[74]
The signature of a combination of 8 RNAs in sEVs showed high accuracy in PDAC detec
tion with AUC of 0.960, 0.950 and 0.936 in the training, internal validation and external
validation cohort, respectively. [75] Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 6 of 20 15 PDAC patients and 15 healthy people using qRT PCR
the miRNA levels in the sEVs from healthy people and
Table 2 sEV protein biomarkers for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis
Biomarkers
Sources
Patient
numbers
Discoveries and diagnostic performance
Ref. GPC-1
Plasma
N = 27
High GPC-1 in sEVs may be able to determine PDAC tumor size and disease burden. AUC of 0.59
was achieved for PDAC detection. [99]
MIF
Plasma
N = 40
MIF was highly expressed in sEVs from PDAC patients (PDAC patients without liver metastasis vs. RNAs healthy controls P < 0.01)
[83]
EpCAM
Plasma
N = 19
PDAC patients had a high level of EpCAM in sEVs, and the level changed during palliative chemo
therapy treatment
[100]
EphA2
Plasma
N = 49
EphA2 in sEVs could distinguish pancreatic cancer patients from pancreatitis patients and healthy
subjects with AUC of 0.93–0.96
[101]
KRASmut,
P53mut
Plasma
Stage I
n = 16
Mutant proteins KRASmut and/or P53mut were detected in 15 of the 16 early stage PDAC patients
[102]
EGFR, CA19-9 Plasma
N = 5
More abundant of EGFR (5 fold) and CA19-9 (15 fold) enriched sEVs in PDAC patients than healthy
donors
[103]
EGFR,
EpCAM,
MUC1, GPC1,
WNT2
Plasma
N = 22
The five-marker signature yielded a more accurate diagnosis of PDAC than CA19-9 and a single sEV
biomarker with sensitivity of 86% (CI, 65 to 97%) and a specificity of 81% (CI, 58 to 95%) in prospec
tive cohort
[95]
GPC-1, CD63
Plasma,
serum
N = 20
Twenty PDAC patient samples could be distinguished from 11 healthy subjects with 99% sensitivity
and 82% specificity
[104]
GPC-1,
EpCAM,
CD44V6
Plasma
N = 9
The PDAC EV signature of the three protein biomarkers could be used for PDAC diagnosis with AUC
of 1.000 (95% CI: 84.6–100%) and showed strong correlation with cancer stages
[105]
GPC-1
Serum
N = 190
GPC-1 in sEVs showed higher level in PDAC patients than healthy donors with P < 0.0001
[96,
106,
107]
c-Met
Serum
N = 55
Diagnostic test based on c-Met in sEVs resulted in a sensitivity of 70%, a specificity of 85%
[108]
CKAP4
Serum
N = 47
The CKAP4 levels in sEVs were higher in patients with PDAC than healthy control individuals
[109]
ANXA6
Serum
N = 108
ANXA6 level in sEVs could be used to diagnose PDAC patients with AUC of 0.979 and improved
sensitivity and specificity
[110]
ZIP4
Serum
N = 24
The level of ZIP4 in sEVs showed promising diagnostic efficacy between PDAC and control group
with AUC of 0.893
[97]
ADAM8
Serum
N = 5
ADAM8 in EVs from PDAC patients or precursor lesions had significantly higher expression when
compared to healthy individuals with P < 0.0001or P = 0.0139, respectively
[64]
CD41, CD61,
CD63
Serum
N = 39
The levels of CD41, CD61 and CD63 in sEVs increased in PDAC patients then healthy donors with
AUC of 0.678, 0.652 and 0.846, respectively
[111]
CD44v6,
C1QBP
Serum
N = 142
Highly expressed CD44v6 and C1QBP in sEVs were promising biomarkers for predicting prognosis
and liver metastasis in patients with PDAC
[112]
LRG-1, GPC-1
Serum
N = 15
Combination of LRG-1 and GPC-1 positive sEVs could improve the diagnostic accuracy of PDAC
with AUC of 0.95, even for the early stage PDAC. RNAs [113]
Integrin α6
Blood
N/A
The expression of Integrin α6 in sEVs from blood of PDAC patients significantly decreased after
surgery and increased several months before clinical recurrence
[114]
Mucin-4,
Mucin-5AC,
Mucin-6,
Mucin-16,
etc. Pancreatic
duct fluid
N = 4
Unique proteins were detected exclusively in sEVs from Pancreatic duct fluid by mass spectroscopy
(MS)
[115]
Combina
tion of 35
proteins
Pancreatic
duct fluid
N = 13
Pancreatic duct fluid proteins were potential biomarkers of patients with different pancreatic
diagnoses
[116] Table 2 sEV protein biomarkers for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis
Biomarkers
Sources
Patient
numbers
Discoveries and diagnostic performance [116] the miRNA levels in the sEVs from healthy people and
PDAC patients. They discovered that PDAC patients
expressed higher levels of some miRNAs such as miR-
21, miR-10b, miR-30c, and miR-181a and lower levels of
some miRNAs such as miR-let7a and miR-122 in sEVs
from serum, which could be used to differentiate healthy
controls and PDAC patients.[13] According to ROC 15 PDAC patients and 15 healthy people using qRT-PCR
and discovered that both miR-196a and miR-1246 were
increased in the serum-derived sEVs of PDAC patients,
as compared to the controls.[58] Interestingly, few stud
ies indicated that some miRNAs might decrease in
patients, which can also be used as biomarkers for PDAC
diagnosis/prognosis. For example, Lai et al. compared Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 7 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology Table 3 Cancer-derived sEV based strategies for PDAC treatment
Strategies
sEVs involved
Drugs
Therapeutic performance
Ref. RNAs [148]
Panc-1-derived sEVs
siRNA (siPAK4)
The siPAK4 loaded sEVs induced significant apoptosis of tissue and prolonged
survival of PDAC bearing mice
[149]
TAS-derived sEVs
miR-145
The miR-145 in TAS-derived suppressed the PDAC development
[150]
Using cancer-
derived sEVs in
immunotherapy
Panc-1-derived sEVs
Immune
activating
proteins in
sEVs
PDAC-derived sEV lysates increased the tumor-killing capacity of DCs/CIKs
towards PDAC cells
[151]
Human pancreas
carcinoma cell-
derived sEVs
HSP70
HSP70 in sEVs stimulated NK cell migration and caused cytotoxicity against
cancer cells
[152]
Rat PDAC-derived
sEVs
N/A
PDAC-derived sEVs supported leukocyte effector functions by strengthening NK
and cytotoxic T cell activity
[153]
PDAC-derived sEVs
SEB
PDAC-derived sEVs loaded with T cell immune stimulator SEB could significantly
induce cancer cell apoptosis
[154]
Immunogenically
dying tumor cell-
derived sEVs
CCL22 siRNA
CCL22 siRNA loaded in MART-1 peptide modified sEVs could enhance antitumor
immune response
[155]
PDAC-derived sEVs
(Panc02)
GTPase Rab11
Inhibition of saliva sEVs could lose their ability to inhibit NK cells
[156] Table 3 Cancer-derived sEV based strategies for PDAC treatment curves, miR-10b, -21, -30c, -181a, and -let7a in sEVs all
have 100% sensitivity and specificity in detecting PDAC
from normal controls, while miR-106b and − 483 failed
to distinguish these two groups. Furthermore, another 3
serum-derived sEV RNAs (ANLN, ITGA6, and KRT18)
were recently reported lower expression in PDAC than
benign pancreatic diseases or healthy controls, while sEV
RNA MMP9 showed relatively higher level in advanced
PDAC patients than in early stage patients.[80]To further
improve the detection accuracy and promote the clinical
application of sEVs for PDAC diagnosis, the combination
of miRNAs and other molecules such as proteins have
been applied for PDAC diagnosis. For instance, a study
indicated a combination of proteins (CD44v6, Tspan8,
EpCAM, MET, and CD104) and miRNAs (miR-1246,
miR-4644, miR-3976, and miR-4306) in serum-derived
sEVs could improve the diagnostic accuracy of PDAC curves, miR-10b, -21, -30c, -181a, and -let7a in sEVs all
have 100% sensitivity and specificity in detecting PDAC
from normal controls, while miR-106b and − 483 failed
to distinguish these two groups. RNAs Inhibition of cancer-
derived sEV forma
tion or secretion
CAF-derived sEVs
GW4869
GW4869 treated CAF decreased the release of sEVs and reduced the survival of
epithelial cells
[140]
CAF tumor organ
oid-derived sEVs
Climbazole,
imipramine
Climbazole and imipramine prevented the release of PDAC-derived sEVs and
inhibited the growth of organoids and chemoresistance
[141]
PDAC-derived sEVs
(Panc-1, MiaPaCa-2,
PSN-1)
RAB27B
siRNA
Downregulated miR-155 inhibited the release of cancer-derived sEVs and
reduced the GEM resistance
[142]
CAF-derived sEVs
GW4869
Suppression of CAF-derived sEV secretion could
reduce these PTEN targeting miRNAs and restore the PTEN expression
[143]
Pan02-derived sEVs
Short hairpin
RNAs
Knocking down of overexpressed genes ITGβ4 or ITGβ5 remarkably reduced the
metastatic ability of cancer cells
[144]
PDAC-derived sEVs
(Panc-1, MiaPaCa-2,
etc.)
GW4869, MEK
inhibitor
Blocking of VEFG-C could inhibit PDAC
early dissemination and cancer malignancy
[145]
Cancer-derived
sEVs as drug carrier
vesicles
Panc-1-derived sEVs
GEM
Tumor growth was suppressed treated with GEM loaded sEVs in mice model
[146]
Melanoma cell-
derived sEVs
Survivin T34A
Survivin T34A loaded sEVs restored GEM sensitivity to PDAC cell lines and in
duced a significant increase in apoptotic cancer cell deaths
[147]
Panc-1-derived sEVs
PTX
RGD modified sEVs showed good affinity for αvβ3 on pancreatic cancer cells and
improved the tumor cell targeting ability. RNAs The overexpression of the circRNAs in sEVs was
speculated to contribute to tumor invasion and metasta
sis.[76, 77]. (IPMN) patents and 21 heathy individuals, showing sig
nificantly higher HULC level in PDAC patients than oth
ers.[73] Apart from above RNAs, circRNAs, which was
recognized as a novel class of highly stable noncoding
RNA species, may also act as a biomarker for PDAC diag
nosis. [83] Specifically, Li et al. found an elevated expres
sion level of circRNAs such as circPDE8A and circIARS,
in tumor tissues and sEVs from the plasma of PDAC
patients. The overexpression of the circRNAs in sEVs was
speculated to contribute to tumor invasion and metasta
sis.[76, 77]. Multiple DNA mutations in cancer-derived sEVs were
also explored for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. F.A. San
et al. identified multiple DNA mutations from plasma-
derived sEVs of 2 PDAC patients and found NOTCH1
and BRCA2 in the samples. [90] In another study with
bigger cohort, Yang et al. investigated the potential clini
cal utility of sEV DNA from the serum of 114 healthy
subjects, 7 IPMN patients, 9 CP patients, 48 PDAC
patients and 12 other patients (diseases such as autoim
mune pancreatitis, common bile duct cancer) for iden
tification of both KRASG12D and TP53R273H mutations. [91] They found that sEV DNA harbors KRASG12D muta
tion in 39.6% of cases, and TP53R273H mutation in 4.2%
of cases of PDAC patients, while 2.6% of healthy sub
jects presented with KRASG12D mutation and none with
TP53R273H mutation in the sEVs, indicating the strong
potential of circulating sEV DNA for cancer diagnosis/
prognosis. All in all, RNAs in PDAC-derived sEVs showed prom
ising performance in PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. How
ever, there is still some disputes. John et al. found most
individual sEVs isolated by ultracentrifugation contained
biologically insufficient quantities of miRNAs, accompa
nied by a small proportion of free miRNAs from plasma,
making them unlikely to serve as miRNA-based commu
nication vehicles.[84] Currently, there are no RNA-based
detection method for PDAC in clinic due to various rea
sons, such as heterogeneous nature of sEVs, difficulty
in pure RNA extraction from sEVs and lack of validated
RNA biomarkers. To realize their potential value as bio
markers for clinical application, more efforts are needed
to discover new RNA biomarkers, develop highly sensi
tive and specific detection techniques and evaluate their
significance in PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. DNAs Owing to their ability to carry information regarding can
cer-associated mutations, DNAs in cancer-derived sEVs
are of great value as a diagnostic/prognosis tool.[85, 86]
Thus, detection of DNA mutations in sEVs from PDAC
patients can be potentially used for PDAC diagnosis/
prognosis. RNAs Furthermore, another 3
serum-derived sEV RNAs (ANLN, ITGA6, and KRT18)
were recently reported lower expression in PDAC than
benign pancreatic diseases or healthy controls, while sEV
RNA MMP9 showed relatively higher level in advanced
PDAC patients than in early stage patients.[80]To further
improve the detection accuracy and promote the clinical
application of sEVs for PDAC diagnosis, the combination
of miRNAs and other molecules such as proteins have
been applied for PDAC diagnosis. For instance, a study
indicated a combination of proteins (CD44v6, Tspan8,
EpCAM, MET, and CD104) and miRNAs (miR-1246,
miR-4644, miR-3976, and miR-4306) in serum-derived
sEVs could improve the diagnostic accuracy of PDAC with a sensitivity of 1.00 (CI: 0.95–1) and specificity of
0.80 (CI: 0.67–0.90).[66] Results of these studies demon
strated that these miRNAs could serve as diagnostic and
prognostic indicators for PDAC. p
g
mRNAs in sEVs have also been reported to be PDAC
biomarkers.[81] In a study by Hu et al., glypican-1
(GPC-1) mRNA in sEVs from serum with an AUC of 1.0
or 100% specificity and 100% sensitivity in each stage
of PDAC were identified by a biochip, distinguishing
patients with early- and late-stage PDAC from healthy
donors and patients with benign pancreatic disease.[69]
IncRNAs are nonprotein-coding RNAs with more than
200 nucleotides, playing an important role in regulation
of gene expression and pathogenesis in cancers.[82] Kenji
et al. analyzed lncRNA “highly upregulated in liver can
cer (HULC)” expression from serum sEVs of 20 PDAC
patients, 22 intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 8 of 20 Page 8 of 20 Page 8 of 20 DNA in sEVs was detected in 43.6% (17/39) of early-stage
PDAC patients and 20% (17/82) of healthy controls. [88]
Furthermore, Vincent et al. also reported that KRAS
mutant allele fraction (MAF) from sEV DNA provides
both predictive and prognostic information for PDAC
based on data from 123 serial blood samples. [89] (IPMN) patents and 21 heathy individuals, showing sig
nificantly higher HULC level in PDAC patients than oth
ers.[73] Apart from above RNAs, circRNAs, which was
recognized as a novel class of highly stable noncoding
RNA species, may also act as a biomarker for PDAC diag
nosis. [83] Specifically, Li et al. found an elevated expres
sion level of circRNAs such as circPDE8A and circIARS,
in tumor tissues and sEVs from the plasma of PDAC
patients. RNAs Excitedly, two
clinical trials (NCT03821909 and NCT04636788) were
started to investigate the diagnostic and prognostic val
ues of small RNA biomarkers in sEVs for PDAC diagnosis
in August of 2018 in affiliated Nanjing drum tower hospi
tal of Nanjing University medical school and in Novem
ber of 2020 in Tongji hospital (Tongji medical college),
respectively. All these studies demonstrate the value of DNA muta
tions in sEVs as potential biomarkers for PDAC diag
nosis/prognosis. Considering that some healthy people
also had these DNA mutations in sEVs, this approach
may also be used to predict the development of PDAC. However, it should be noted that a DNA mutation does
not indicate the presence or prognosis of cancer. In addi
tion, DNA methylation has also been found to play an
important role in the initiation and progression of many
tumors, such as gastric cancer.[92] The role of DNA
methylation in PDAC diagnosis/prognosis will need fur
ther investigations. Lipids Compared to the great attention being paid to nucleic
acids and proteins in sEVs, lipids represent other less-
explored bioactive molecules abundantly present in sEVs. According to a report of 2019, research into sEV lipido
mics accounted for less than 4.3% of the sEV genomics
studies, and approximately 5.5% of the sEV proteomics
work, indicating low scientific interest in sEV lipid
research.[120] However, lipid is one of the most impor
tant components in sEVs, playing indispensable roles
on the structural and regulatory functions of sEV bio
genesis, release, targeting and cellular uptake.[120, 121]
Therefore, lipidomic studies of sEVs may be an innovative
direction for the discovery of new biomarkers for cancer
diagnosis/prognosis. Different proteins played different roles in biologic
functions, thus simultaneous detection of multiple pro
teins on/in sEVs may provide much richer information
than each one alone, which may more accurately reflect
a molecular signature of the cell from which they origi
nate, comparing to the presence of only one biomarker. [50] For example, Yang et al. used a multiplexed plas
monic assay to analyze circulating cancer-derived sEV
biomarkers in the training cohort involving 22 PDAC
patients and 10 healthy donors. [95] They found that the
five surface membrane proteins (EGFR, EPCAM, MUC1,
GPC1, and WNT2) showed relatively different individual
expression levels in each subject. The authors also found
that GPC-1 had a sensitivity of 55% and a specificity of
60%, whereas the PDAC sEV signature of the five surface
proteins showed a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of
100%. In a more recent study, Juan et al. used bead-based
multiplex immunoassay kits to test the isolated sEVs
from plasma of stage I-II PDAC patients and healthy
donors and found the six protein biomarkers could iden
tify the PDAC with AUC of 0.997 in the training cohort
(controls, n = 146; PDAC cases, n = 33) and AUC of 0.978
in the validation cohort (controls, n = 139; PDAC cases,
n = 35).[118] The PDAC EV protein signature of sEVs
offered higher sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy than
the single sEV protein biomarker. g
g
Currently, lipids of sEVs have been reported to be
biomarkers for cancer diagnosis/prognosis in diverse
cancers, including prostate cancer,[122] non-small cell
lung cancer,[123] and colorectal cancer.[124] So far,
very limited studies on lipids in sEVs for PDAC diagno
sis/prognosis have been published. Raghava et al. Proteins sEVs contain a great number of cytosolic proteins
(enzymes, cytokines, apoptotic proteins, oncoproteins,
etc.) and surface proteins (adhesion molecules, integrins,
tetraspanins, etc.). According to the current version of
sEV content database, 9769 proteins have been identi
fied associated with sEVs and 745 of them are relevant to
pancreatic cancer.[93] Analysis of these sEV proteins is a
powerful tool for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis, due to their
unique characteristics compared with traditional sero
logical markers. For example, sEV proteins show higher
stability, as they are protected by the lipid bilayer from
degradation by extracellular proteases and enzymes. [94] Notably, abundant cancer-associated proteins have
been identified in PDAC-derived sEVs, and their types
and expression levels are strongly correlated with the
presence and progression of PDAC.[95] The aberrantly Wan et al. developed a device utilizing sEV size-
matched silica nanostructures and a surface-conjugated
lipid nanoprobe to enrich sEVs from the plasma of 3
PDAC patients and 2 healthy controls. They confirmed
that the concentration of DNA with the KRAS mutation
was higher in patients than controls. [87] In a study with
higher number of PDAC patient cohorts by Allenson
et al., sEV KRAS mutations were detected in 66.7%
(22/33), 80% (12/15), and 85% (17/20) of localized, locally
advanced, and metastatic PDAC, respectively, and in
7.4% (4/54) of healthy controls in the discovery cohort. In the validation cohort of 121 individuals, mutant KRAS Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 9 of 20 Page 9 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (n = 8) and benign pancreatic diseases (n = 5) using mass
spectroscopy, and validated the expression by immuno
histochemistry. Among all the proteins, the top 35 pro
teins were significantly associated with PDAC, showing
strong potential to be PDAC diagnosis biomarkers.[116]
Hiroyuki et al. detected the proteins of sEVs from endo
scopic ultrasound-fine needle aspiration (EUS-FNA)
biopsy PDAC patients (n = 40) and autoimmune pan
creatitis (AIP) patients (n = 6) using nano liquid chro
matography tandem-mass spectrometry.[119] 1071 sEV
proteins were identified only in PDAC and 153 of them
were significantly different between PDAC and AIP, indi
cating the specific sEV protein barcode of PDAC was
promising biomarkers for diagnosis. Mass spectrom
etry has the potential to greatly promote the proteomics
research on cancer-derived sEVs, facilitating the discov
ery of specific and sensitive protein biomarkers for PDAC
diagnosis/prognosis. Proteins expressed proteins in PDAC-derived sEVs distinguish
them from sEVs of healthy donors or patients with
other diseases, and make them a novel means to identify
PDAC.[96–98] Table2 summarizes the sEV protein bio
markers for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. g
g
In 2015, Melo et al. reported that the level of GPC-1 on
circulating blood sEVs was significantly higher in PDAC
patients compared to healthy people, with the sensitiv
ity and specificity of GPC-1 detection both at 100% for
PDAC diagnosis.[96] In another study, Buscail et al. modified magnetic beads with CD63 antibody to col
lect PDAC-derived sEVs from the blood and detected
GPC-1 positive sEVs by flow cytometry with sensitivity
of 64% and specificity of 90%.[117] Furthermore, Liang et
al. found that ephrin type-A receptor 2 (EphA2), which
expressed on the surface of sEVs from plasma, could
be used to distinguish PDAC patients and healthy sub
jects.[101] Mutant proteins can also be biomarkers for
PDAC diagnosis. In a recent study, Scott et al. found the
mutant proteins KRASmut and/or P53mut were positive in
plasma-derived sEVs from 15 to 16 stage I PDAC patients
using single-sEV analysis technique, showing potential
of mutant sEV proteins for early stage cancer diagnosis. [102]. Glycans Glycans consist of oligosaccharides linked glycosidically
to proteins, lipids and proteoglycans which are displayed
on the exterior surfaces of cells and sEVs. They can be
classified into different types of glycans. Specifically, they
can be divided into N-linked glycans (attached to the Asn
of glycoproteins in a particular Asp-X-Ser/Thr sequon),
O-linked glycans (attached to the Ser or Thr of glycopro
teins and predominate on mucins), glycosaminoglycans
(attached to Ser residues of proteoglycans), and glyco
lipids (attached variously to lipids).[129] Different types
of glycans and their receptor binding lead to different
physical properties and cellular functions which attribute
to the development and progression of cancer and other
diseases.[130, 131] Moreover, glycans play significant
roles in intracellular interactions that depend on cellu
lar conditions and the onset of diseases such as PDAC. [132] Therefore, glycans on PDAC-derived sEVs may also
have the potential to be a useful biomarker for PDAC
diagnosis/prognosis. Biomolecules such as nucleic acids, proteins, lip
ids and glycans in PDAC-derived sEVs have all shown
the potential to act as biomarkers for PDAC diagnosis/
prognosis. RNAs and proteins serve as highly specific
biomarker candidates for PDAC detection and repre
sent the most important biomolecules associated with
PDAC-derived sEV studies. RNAs affect the cancer asso
ciated metabolism and functions. They could be easily
extracted and analyzed using the well-developed RNA
profiling techniques such as polymerase chain reaction
and next-generation sequencing. There are three ongo
ing clinical trials using RNAs for PDAC detection as
mentioned above. sEV proteins include membrane pro
teins and inner proteins, analysis of which could help us
to understand the mechanisms of sEV biogenesis and
functions. Membrane proteins are more studied than
inner proteins for PDAC detection due to easier sample
preparation and rapid and sensitive analysis approaches
(e.g. flow cytometry and enzyme-linked immunosorbent
assay), which are based on high specific of antibodies. DNA mutations exist in sEVs from both healthy donors
and PDAC patients, their role for clinic use need more
investigation. sEV glycans and lipids have been explored
for cancer diagnosis/prognosis due to the fast devel
opment of glycomics and lipidomics in recent years, To study the roles of glycan changes in pancreatic dis
eases, Engle et al. inducibly expressed human fucosyl
transferase 3 and β-1,3-galactosyltransferase 5 in mice
to reconstitute the glycan sialyl-Lewisa (also known as
CA19-9) which was a carbohydrate antigen attached to
O-glycans on the surface of pancreatic cells. Lipids found
phosphatidylserine positive sEVs in blood increased
significantly in PDAC bearing mouse, suggesting the
potential of phosphatidylserine positive sEVs for PDAC
detection.[125] Furthermore, Samuel et al. extracted
lipid from different PDAC cell-derived sEVs and ana
lyzed them by mass spectroscopy.[126] They found that
sEVs derived from AsPC-1, Panc-1, BxPC-3 and HDPE
cells all had significantly different lipid expression pro
files, including phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine,
phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidic acid and phos
phatidylinositol, which showed potential use for PDAC
diagnosis. Charles et al. analyzed 1021 lipid species from
sEVs of different pancreatic cancer cell lines (Panc-1,
Capan-1, SW-1990, Mia PaCa-2, PPCL-68 and PPCL-46) Apart from the membrane proteins on sEVs, proteins
inside the sEVs can also serve as biomarkers. Zheng et
al. identified the protein complement of sEVs from pan
creatic duct fluid of patients with PDAC (n = 13), IPMN Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 10 of 20 Page 10 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology and normal cell lines (hTERT-HPNE, HPDE-H6c7) dys
regulated lipids were observed between cancer-dervied
sEVs and normal sEVs, especially these lipid species con
taining palmitic acid (16:0) and sphingomyelin.[127] In
another study by Tao et al., liquid chromatography-data
dependent acquisition-mass spectroscopy (LC-DDA-
MS) based lipidomic analysis was used to analyze the
lipid expression profile in sEVs derived from peripheral
blood of 22 PDAC patients and 17 healthy people.[128]
The authors found that about 270 lipids were signifi
cantly dysregulated between the sEVs of PDAC patients
and healthy controls, and 61 significantly dysregulated
lipids were further analyzed by LC-MRM-MS to verify
the results of lipidomic analysis in sEVs from 24 PDAC
patients and 40 healthy donors. They discovered that
LysoPC 22:0, PC (P-14:0/22:2) and PE (16:0/18:1) were all
associated with tumor stage, CA19-9, CA242 and tumor
diameter. These findings revealed that dysregulated lipids
in sEVs from PDAC patients show potential as biomark
ers for diagnosis/prognosis. The research into the role of
lipids in sEVs offers a un-explored avenue for PDAC bio
marker discovery. cohorts including 117 PDAC patients and 98 normal con
trols) using lectin microarrays.[134] The glyco-candidates
of PDAC-specific sEVs were quantified using a highly-
sensitive sEV-counting system, ExoCounter. Quantitative
analysis using ExoCounter revealed that the O-glycan-
binding lectins, Agaricus bisporus agglutinin (ABA) and
Amaranthus caudatus agglutinin (ACA), positive sEVs
were significantly increased in the culture of PDAC cell
lines and in the serum of PDAC patients. Lipids These specific
sEVs with O-glycans recognized by ABA/ACA were ele
vated in PDAC sera and could act as potential biomarkers
in a liquid biopsy for PDAC patient screening. Choi et al. attached lectins with a high and specific affinity for sialic
acid or fucose to bifunctional Janus nanoparticles (JNPs)
for glycan detection on sEVs by a microfluidic device. [135] sEVs derived from PDAC cell lines and plasma
samples of PDAC patients were successfully captured on
the lectin-conjugated JNPs. The relatively higher glycan
recognition of sEVs from patient plasma by Sambucus
nigra agglutinin (SNA) and Aleuria aurantia lectin (AAL)
modified JNPs could thus potentially be used for cancer
diagnosis. The abnormal expression of specific glycans
on sEVs, their presence in patient serum and plasma, and
their possible ability to facilitate metastases, suggests that
glycans could contribute to cancer diagnosis/prognosis. To fully exploit glycans for further clinical use, it will be
vital to fully profile the glycans of PDAC-derived sEVs
and determine how this varies between different cancer
stages and healthy people. Glycans 133They
found that CA19-9 expression in mice resulted in rapid
and severe pancreatitis with hyperactivation of epider
mal growth factor receptor (EGFR) signaling to promote
PDAC. Yokose and his colleagues analyzed the differen
tial glycomic profiling of sEVs derived from serum (two Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology Page 11 of 20 Fig. 4 Strategies of using cancer-derived sEVs for drug delivery. Chemo
therapy drugs, nucleic acids and/or proteins can be loaded into sEVs by
direct or indirect methods screening and validation of clinical biomarkers for PDAC
diagnosis/prognosis require more efforts. There is no
sEV based clinical assays for PDAC detection now. To
realize clinical use of these biomolecules, more inten
sive studies are still required to determine their clinical
sensitivity, specificity and accuracy. Moreover, the lack
of clinically applicable, reliable detection techniques for
these biomolecules makes them difficult to be utilized. These potential problems may be solved by gaining more
knowledge about how these biomolecules transport into
sEVs, optimizing the extraction procedures and improv
ing the detection techniques of these active molecules,
which could eventually lead to the development of a het
erogeneous panel of biomarkers for clinical application
in PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. Although cancer-derived
sEVs as biomarkers for cancer diagnosis/prognosis in
patients have been reported in a flurry of papers, very few
clinical diagnostic/prognostic assays are implemented. To date, two sEV-based clinical assays have reached the
stage of clinical validation and one assay called ExoDx
Prostate (IntelliScore) has been launched onto the mar
ket in United States since 2016.[136, 137] Briefly, the
ClarityDx™ System (NCT03957252) is used for prostate
cancer diagnosis by detecting GHSR (ghrelin receptor),
PSMA (prostate-specific membrane antigen) and polysi
alic acid in blood-derived sEVs by micro flow cytometry. Sentinel™ PCC4 test (NCT04100811, NCT04661176)
is used for prostate cancer by detecting 442 small non-
coding RNAs (sncRNAs) in urinary sEVs. Another test
Sentinel™ (NCT04155359) detecting 280 sncRNAs is
used for bladder cancer diagnosis. The commercial avail
able assay ExoDx Prostate (IntelliScore) (NCT03235687,
NCT03031418, NCT04720599, NCT02702856) is based
on the detection of three RNAs (PCA3, SPDEF, ERG) in
urinary sEVs from prostate cancer patients by quantita
tive reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction
(RT-PCR). Fig. 4 Strategies of using cancer-derived sEVs for drug delivery. Glycans Chemo
therapy drugs, nucleic acids and/or proteins can be loaded into sEVs by
direct or indirect methods will mainly review the advances in therapeutic strategies
using cancer-derived sEVs for PDAC treatment (Table3). Inhibition of cancer-derived sEV formation and secretion
Cancer-derived sEVs play key roles in PDAC progression
and in the onset of cancer drug resistance.[35] It has also
been reported that cancer-derived sEVs can transport
epidermal growth factors to macrophages, thus inter
fering with the innate immune system’s function.[157]
These cancer-derived sEVs not only promoted the cancer
development, but also affected the immune system and
drug resistance in order to protect the cancer cells. Thus,
inhibiting the formation and release of cancer-derived
sEVs may delay cancer progression and improve cancer
treatment. A growing number of studies have indicated
that disrupting the signaling pathway of cancer-derived
sEVs was able to block the formation and secretion of
cancer-derived sEVs, thus inhibiting tumor growth and
metastasis in cancers.[158–161] As aforementioned, the
biogenesis of sEVs occurs inside MVBs, and is driven
mainly by two mechanisms: endosomal sorting com
plexes required for transport (ESCRT)-dependent and
ESCRT-independent pathways (Fig.3). Manumycin A
is an antibiotic that can inhibit RAS (small GTPases)
activation, thus disrupting the biogenesis of sEVs by the
ESCRT-dependent pathway. GW4869 is able to sup
press neutral sphingomyelinase (nSMase), which is an
important enzyme for MVB biogenesis, resulting in the
inhibition of sEV formation by the ESCRT-independent
pathway.[162] Furthermore, the transportation of MVBs,
the fusion between MVBs and cell membrane, and
the release of sEVs from MVBs, are regulated by many
agents, such as the RAB family (a member of the RAS
superfamily of small G proteins) for recruiting cytosolic
tethers to MVB membranes, soluble N-ethylmaleimide-
sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE)
for MVB and cell membrane fusion, Ca2+ for calpain Cancer therapyh The exploration of cancer-derived sEVs for therapeutic
purposes is still in its infancy due to the risk of endog
enous cargo molecules which may activate pathological
pathways.[138] Over the past few years, several cancer-
derived sEV based therapeutic approaches have been
developed, including inhibition of cancer-derived sEV
formation or secretion, using cancer-derived sEVs as a
potential drug carrier for target therapy and for immu
notherapy. As compared to other therapeutic strategies,
cancer-derived sEV based therapies are likely to have
targetable ability, high stability, cross biological barrier
ability and low toxic side effects.[139] All of these char
acteristics support the potential application of cancer-
derived sEVs in cancer treatment. In this section, we Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 (2022) 20:446 Page 12 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology activation, and Rho-associated protein kinases (ROCK)
for cytoskeleton re‐organization (Fig.3).[162–164].i by Capello et al. indicated that PDAC-derived sEVs dis
played a wide variety of tumor-associated antigens which
could bind circulating autoantibodies.[167] PDAC-
derived sEVs exerted a decoy function and possibly
attenuated complement-dependent cytotoxicity against
PDAC cells, which suggested that it may be possible to
inhibit PDAC sEV secretion or selectively eliminate the
circulating PDAC-derived sEVs through affinity capture
as one way to treat PDAC. One interesting finding is that
the inhibition of a specific molecule on cancer-derived
sEVs could also improve cancer treatment. Chun-an et al. found vascular endothelial growth factor-C (VEGF-C) on
PDAC-derived sEVs promoted lymphangiogenesis and
thus blocking of the production of VEFG-C could inhibit
PDAC early dissemination and cancer malignancy.[145]. Cancer-associated fibroblasts (CAFs) are the domi
nant components of PDAC tumor bulk. Richard et al. found that CAFs played a critical role in promoting the
proliferation of PDAC cells through sEV signaling.[140]
While CAFs were intrinsically resistant to gemcitabine
(GEM), GEM-treated CAFs significantly increased the
release of sEVs, which resulted in elevation of a chemo
resistance-inducing factor in recipient epithelial cells and
promoted proliferation and drug resistance. The treated
GEM exposed CAFs were then treated with sEV release
inhibitor GW4869 and the survival of epithelial cells
was significantly reduced, indicating an important role
of cancer-derived sEVs in chemotherapeutic drug resis
tance. Weikun et al. Cancer therapyh built a bio-mimetic 3D co-culture
model to integrate the complex tumor organoids and
used sEV release inhibitor climbazole and imipramine to
treat the PDAC organoids, finding that climbazole and
imipramine inhibited the growth of organoids and che
moresistance by preventing the release of CAF tumor
organoid-derived sEVs. [141] In another study, Mikamori
et al. found GEM resistance in PDAC cells might be rel
evant to miR-155, which controlled genes required for
sEV synthesis.[142] The authors used RAB27B siRNA
(siRAB27B) to transfect PDAC cells and downregulated
RAB27B effectively. The resultant RAB27B knockdown
resulted in the remarkable reduction of the amounts of
sEVs and GEM resistance in PDAC cells with or with
out transfection with pre miR-155. These results indi
cated that targeted miR-155 therapy and inhibition of
cancer-derived sEV secretion may be an effective way to
reduce or eliminate GEM resistance and to help improve
the therapy of PDAC. PDAC patients normally have
altered tumor suppressor phosphatase and tensin homo
log (PTEN) and low expression of PTEN may promote
PDAC progression.[165, 166] Katherine et al. discovered
GEM treated CAFs could release PTEN targeting miR
NAs (miR-21, miR-181a, miR-221, miR-222, and miR-
92a) and the suppression of CAF-derived sEV secretion
with inhibitor GW4869 could reduce these PTEN tar
geting miRNAs and restore the PTEN expression.[143]
However, these strategies involve the inhibition of sEVs
being secreted from both healthy cells and cancer cells. Therefore, their use in cancer treatment should be care
fully considered and investigated, as sEVs also play an
essential role in regulating normal biological functions as
well. It would be safer to only inhibit or remove the cancer
cells derived sEVs For example Hoshino et al found that PDAC-derived sEVs have been reported to promote
immune suppression, cancer metastasis and chemoresis
tance in PDAC. The suppression of PDAC sEV secretion
or disruption of the signaling pathways is thus an achiev
able strategy to treat PDAC. To bring these therapeutic
approaches to clinical application, it is essential to com
prehensively understand the biogenesis of PDAC-derived
sEVs as well as their signaling pathways and elucidation
of the mechanisms as to how PDAC-derived sEVs con
tribute to cancer metastasis and chemoresistance. Cancer-derived sEVs as drug carrier vesicles Several
clinical trials have been conducted using cancer-derived
sEVs and no serious safety issues were reported in these
studies [181–183]. For example, Guo et al. used autolo
gous tumor cell-derived nanoparticles loaded with a
chemotherapeutic drug (methotrexate) to treat lung
cancer patients with pleural effusions (4 females and 8
males).[182] Six mild adverse events (grades 1 to 2) were
observed through the treatments and no acute autoim
mune reactions were recorded. In another clinic trial
(NCT01854866), Huang et al. investigated the safety and
effectiveness of cancer-derived sEVs loaded with chemo
therapeutic drugs for malignant ascites and pleural effu
sion treatment and reported no typical side effects.[184]
Furthermore, the development of new techniques that
remove the harmful contents in cancer-derived sEVs or
preparation of sEV mimetics might helpful to improve
the safety. The drug loading capacity of cancer-derived
sEVs is also one of the obstacles. Thus a few studies
reported the fused sEVs with other nanoparticles such as
liposomes or synthesis of sEV mimetics to enhance the
loading capacity.[45] Moreover, the improvement of the
drug loading method such as electroporation, saponin-
assisted loading and extrusion could further increase the
loading capacity of sEVs.[185] Another major problem
for drug loading using cancer-derived sEVs is their low
yield. The effective sEV dose is 10–500µg sEV proteins to g
g
y
Li et al. loaded GEM into autologous Panc-1 cell-
derived sEVs for targeted chemotherapy of PDAC.[146]
GEM-loaded sEVs facilitated the cellular drug uptake and
significantly suppressed tumor growth in tumor bearing
mice; even tumors in several mice disappeared without
recurrence after treatment. PDAC treatment response
however may be affected by cancer associated macro
phages. Cristina et al. demonstrated these cancer asso
ciated macrophage-derived sEVs decreased the PDAC
cell sensitivity to GEM, which was caused by chitinase
3-like-1 (CHI3L1) and fibronectin (FN1).[178] In order
to overcome GEM resistance in PDAC, Aspe JR et al. delivered survivin T34A by melanoma cell-derived sEVs
to restore GEM sensitivity to PDAC cell lines, inducing a
significant increase in apoptotic cancer cell deaths, com
pared with using GEM alone.[147] More recently, Hasan
et al. engineered the surface of PDAC (Panc-1)-derived
sEVs by conjugating with functional ligand RGD (pep
tide composed of several repetitions of Arg-Gly-Asp) and
magnetic nanoparticles, then loaded PTX into the modi
fied sEVs to treat xenograft mice bearing Panc-1 tumor. Cancer-derived sEVs as drug carrier vesicles This therapeu
tic formulation based on the passive and active targeting
ability of cancer-derived sEVs could efficiently deliver
the drug to the cancer cells and significantly reduced the
tumor size when comparing with the control groups. In
addition to chemical drugs, RNA drugs have also been
shown to be highly effective for PDAC treatment. Xu
et al. encapsulated siRNA (siPAK4) into PDAC-derived
sEVs by electroporation for PDAC treatment in a mouse
model. The siPAK4 induced significant apoptosis of tis
sue and prolonged survival of PDAC bearing mice with
minimal toxicity.[149] Another study by Song et al. found
selective packaging of miRNAs into EVs could lead to
enrichment of stromal specific miR-145 in sEVs from
tumor-associated stroma (TAS). The TAS-derived miR-
145 was able to be delivered into PDAC cells by the sEVs
and suppressed the cancer development.[150] sEVs have
also been engineered to enhance the loading ability of
therapeutic cargo or to improve the targeting ability for
treatment of other cancers [179], [180]. Cancer-derived sEVs accumulate preferentially in the
tumor tissue via the so-called passive targeting ability,
which may be ascribed to the presence of several classes
of proteins (e.g. integrins, tetraspanins and cancer-spe
cific antigens) on their surface.[47, 176] For example, Xu
et al. investigated the uptake properties of sEVs derived
from Panc-1 and other cell lines (B16-F10, HEK-293) and
Panc-1-derived sEVs showed significant higher uptake
in Panc-1 cells than other types of sEVs in vitro and in
vivo (Panc-1 tumor bearing mouse model), demon
strating the passive homing ability of Panc-1 sEVs.[177]
Additionally, modification the surface of cancer-derived
sEVs with targeting molecules such as ligands, aptamers
and antibodies can improve the targeting ability (active
targeting ability).[176] Furthermore, some researchers
proposed that fusing sEVs with conventional synthetic
nanoparticles such as liposomes to form hybrid parti
cles (combination of two unique entities) could achieve
the beneficial properties associated with both sEVs and
synthetic nanoparticles. Fig.4 illustrates the strategies of
using cancer-derived sEVs for drug delivery. Collectively, these results indicated an interesting
potential utility of cancer-derived sEVs as candidates for
different therapeutic agent delivery that could be used
to develop innovative treatment strategies for PDAC. However, it should be noted that the endogenous car
gos such as oncogenes in cancer-derived sEVs may be
associated with cancer progression and migration,[174]
thus their potential safety concerns still remain. Cancer-derived sEVs as drug carrier vesicles Cancer derived sEVs as drug carrier vesicles
In recent years, researchers have made great progress in
the development of sEVs as drug carriers. Compared with
liposomes and other nanoparticles, sEVs possess better
biocompatibility and are considered as a natural way for
drug delivery. Injected sEVs shed from endogenous cells
of the body are tolerated with minimal immune reaction
and toxicity.[139, 168] The therapeutic cargos can be effi
ciently delivered into the tumor microenvironment using
sEVs since these vesicles display efficient target-homing
capabilities and easily penetrate through natural biologi
cal barriers due to their small particle size.[139, 168] In
addition, sEVs express the integrin-associated transmem
brane protein CD47 that protects sEVs from phagocyto
sis by monocytes and macrophages, thus increasing the
sEVs’ half-life.[169] Because of these unique advantages,
sEVs have emerged as ideal candidates for the delivery of
therapeutic cargos, such as chemotherapy drugs, nucleic
acids, and proteins.[170, 171] Therapeutic agents can be
loaded into sEVs by direct methods such as incubation,
sonication and electroporation, or by indirect meth
ods using a drug to treat parent cells and collecting the
released sEVs containing the drugs.[172] A series of clini
cal trials in phase I and II have demonstrated that sEVs
hold strong potential for drug delivery.[173] sEVs from
different sources such as mesenchymal stem cells, mac
rophages, dendritic cells, embryonic kidney cells, cancer
cells have been used for drug delivery.[174] For example, It would be safer to only inhibit or remove the cancer
cells-derived sEVs. For example, Hoshino et al. found that
ITGβ4 or ITGβ5 genes were overexpressed in pancreatic
cancer cell-derived sEVs; knocking down or inactivating
these genes dramatically reduced the metastatic abil
ity of pancreatic cancer cells.[144] A more recent study Page 13 of 20 Page 13 of 20 Page 13 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Kamerkar et al. loaded short interfering RNA or short
hairpin RNA in sEVs from fibroblast-like mesenchymal
cells to target oncogenic KRASG12D in Panc-1 tumor
bearing mouse models and moved forward to a Phase-I
clinical trial by the M.D. Anderson Cancer Center in Jan
uary of 2021 (NCT03608631) [169, 175]. Panc-1 sEVs to their parent cancer cells. Using cancer-derived sEVs in immunotherapy Que et al. investigated the proteins of PDAC-derived
sEVs and their effect on immune cells DCs/ cytokine-
induced killer cells (CIKs) for anti-tumor activity.[151]
They isolated sEVs from Panc-1 cell supernatants, then
ruptured and ultrafiltered the sEV lysate. 128 proteins,
including several immune-activating proteins (attractin,
complement C3, C4 and C5, integrin and lactotransfer
rin), remained in the lysate, while the miRNAs from sEVs
were removed. The authors found that these PDAC-
derived sEV lysates increased the tumor-killing capac
ity of DCs/CIKs towards PDAC cells, suggesting that
miRNA-depleted cancer-derived sEVs might represent
valuable immunotherapeutic tools in PDAC treatment. In line with this study, Gastpar et al. found one protein,
HSP70, enriched from PDAC-derived sEVs, stimulated
NK cell migration and caused cytotoxicity against cancer
cells.[152] Another study discovered that PDAC-derived
sEVs, from rats, supported leukocyte effector functions
by strengthening NK and cytotoxic T cell activity and
showed a minor effect on leukocyte activation. Thus,
these cancer-derived sEVs might be used as adjuvant in
immunotherapy.[153]. Antitumor immunity is triggered when immune effec
tor cells such as natural killer (NK) cells are activated. sEVs derived from immune cells, such as NK cells, den
dritic cells (DCs) and bone marrow mesenchymal stem
cells (BM-MSC), can inhibit PDAC progression.[189,
190]. Similarly, sEVs derived from cancer cells carrying
immunosuppressive molecules such as Fas ligand (FasL),
TNF-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL), pro
grammed death-ligand 1 (PD-L1), and enzymes engaged
in the adenosine pathway (CD39 and D73) were found
to mediate the functions of immune cells, such as acti
vation of regulatory T-cells (T regs), DCs, macrophages
and immature myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs)
(Fig.5), thus playing important roles in the establishment
of an immunosuppressive microenvironment.[191–193]. For example, these cancer-derived sEVs caused the
apoptosis of CD8 + T cells, which is critical for immune
defense against cancer, by activating death receptor path
ways.[194] Although cancer-derived sEVs have thus been
shown to have an immunosuppressive effect on various
immune cells, some studies also indicate these sEVs may
contain immunostimulatory factors (hear shock protein
70/90 (HSP70/90), major histocompatibility complex
class I/II (MHC I/II), tumor-associated antigens (TAAs),
etc.) and serve as anti-tumor agonists or vaccines to
increase cancer antigen recognition and promote tumor
clearance.[152, 195196197] Therefore, cancer-derived Cancer-derived sEVs can also be used as vectors of
immune drugs for cancer immunotherapy. Mahmoodza
deh et al. Cancer-derived sEVs as drug carrier vesicles [148] RGD showed good affinity for αvβ3 that was highly
expressed in pancreatic cancer cells, thus RGD modi
fication on sEVs could improve the tumor cell targeting
ability. The authors also found one important molecule
integrin β3, which was expressed in Panc-1 cells and
Panc-1 sEVs, involved in the home-driving properties of Page 14 of 20 (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology Fig. 5 Effects of cancer-derived sEVs on immune cells and therapeutic strategies for cancer treatment by immunotherapy. Cancer-derived sEVs contain
immunosuppressive and immunostimulatory molecules, which can be used to activate immune cells. Loading immune drugs into sEVs or inhibition of
cancer-derived sEV secretion are two other strategies for immunotherapy Fig. 5 Effects of cancer-derived sEVs on immune cells and therapeutic strategies for cancer treatment by immunotherapy. Cancer-derived sEVs contain
immunosuppressive and immunostimulatory molecules, which can be used to activate immune cells. Loading immune drugs into sEVs or inhibition of
cancer-derived sEV secretion are two other strategies for immunotherapy each mouse or 0.5–1.4 × 1011 sEVs to each patient in one
clinic trial.[186–188] Thus, the strategies to obtain large-
scale clinical-grade sEVs are required for in vitro basic
research, in vivo preclinical animal models, and clinical
trials. sEVs are considered to be valuable agents for the treat
ment of cancer. Although current progress of using
cancer-derived sEVs for PDAC immunotherapy is very
limited, it is an emerging field for study. Fig. 5 illustrates
the effect of cancer-derived sEVs on immune cells and
possible therapeutic strategies for cancer treatment by
immunotherapy. Using cancer-derived sEVs in immunotherapy used PDAC-derived sEVs as carriers to load
staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB), which was used as
a potent immune stimulator for T cell activation.[154] Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Page 15 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology They demonstrated that SEB-loaded sEVs could sig
nificantly induce cancer cell apoptosis and no cytotoxic
effect was observed in both human kidney embryonic
cells and peripheral human white blood cells, indicat
ing that such a strategy might be used to stimulate an
immune response against PDAC cells. The authors also
investigated the expression of anti-apoptotic genes
including Bax, Bak and Fas in cells and found the induc
tion of these genes after treatment with SEB-loaded
sEVs. In a more recent study, Wenxi et al. modified sEVs
derived from immunogenically dying tumor cells with
MART-1 peptide (sequence: ELAGIGILTV), which dis
played immunogenic properties and was able to expand
CD8 + T cells for adoptive T cell transfer.[155] The modi
fied sEVs could enhance antitumor immune response. The authors also loaded CCL22 siRNA into the modi
fied sEVs to suppress Treg expansion, the results dem
onstrated them as an effective prophylactic vaccine in
delaying tumor growth and good adjuvant for chemo
therapeutic drugs in PDAC treatment. As cancer-derived
sEVs can suppress the functions of some immune cells,
the inhibition of these cancer-derived sEV secretion may
also improve cancer treatment by immunotherapy. Lau et
al. reported that PDAC-derived sEVs from tumor-bear
ing mice affected the expression of genes in the salivary
glands and subsequently induced changed contents of
salivary sEVs in vivo.[156] The salivary sEVs from PDAC
tumor-bearing mice regulated the phenotype of NK cells,
resulting in inhibition of the antitumor cytotoxicity of
NK cells. When these saliva sEVs were inhibited, they lost
the ability to inhibit NK cells. diagnosis/prognosis and treatment. The biomolecules
in/on sEVs including RNAs, mutated DNAs, proteins,
lipids and glycans provide the feasibility for develop
ing non-invasive liquid biopsy for low-risk and routine
screening for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis. However, it
seems unrealistic to detect a single biomarker for accu
rate PDAC diagnosis/prognosis as a highly sensitive and
specific test. Multiplex biomarker detection of sEVs with
simple, sensitive and specific assay is a promising area
for further development. Using cancer-derived sEVs in immunotherapy Researchers should continue to
investigate the use of cancer-derived sEVs as biomarkers
to detect PDAC. In addition, these cancer-derived sEVs
play vital roles in cancer environment, including cancer
progression and metastasis, drug resistance, immune
regulation, etc., and hold unique properties for cancer
treatment such as intrinsic homing ability to tumor tis
sues, which make them an advantageous mechanism for
cancer therapy. Thus new therapeutic approaches based
on the understanding of biological functions of these
cancer-derived sEVs may facilitate the development of
new PDAC treatments. The targeting ability, safety and
drug loading efficiency of cancer-derived sEVs should be
further explored to enable effective cancer treatment. f
To further implement the clinical application of cancer-
derived sEVs for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis, there are
several issues to be considered: (1) lack of reliable tech
niques for sEV separation in high-purity homogeneous
form; (2) isolation of cancer-derived sEVs from bodily flu
ids containing healthy sEVs; (3) screening of multiple and
reliable biomarkers; (4) development of highly sensitive,
specific sEV detection methods. Given that the lipopro
teins and other type of EVs have similar particle size with
sEVs, it is impossible to enrich high-purity homogeneous
sEVs using single traditional isolation method (e.g. ultra
centrifugation and size exclusion chromatography). The
combination of multiple isolation methods for specific
sEV subtype enrichment might be one of the solutions. f
To further implement the clinical application of cancer-
derived sEVs for PDAC diagnosis/prognosis, there are
several issues to be considered: (1) lack of reliable tech
niques for sEV separation in high-purity homogeneous
form; (2) isolation of cancer-derived sEVs from bodily flu
ids containing healthy sEVs; (3) screening of multiple and
reliable biomarkers; (4) development of highly sensitive,
specific sEV detection methods. Given that the lipopro
teins and other type of EVs have similar particle size with
sEVs, it is impossible to enrich high-purity homogeneous
sEVs using single traditional isolation method (e.g. ultra
centrifugation and size exclusion chromatography). The
combination of multiple isolation methods for specific
sEV subtype enrichment might be one of the solutions. For example, particles with similar size of sEVs can be
enriched using size exclusion chromatography then puri
fied by immunocapture of the specific subtype of sEVs
using antibodies. However, the lack of high discriminat
ing cancer biomarker slow down the progress. With the
development of multi-omics tools, multiple and reliable
biomarker can be screened and used for cancer detection
in the near future. Using cancer-derived sEVs in immunotherapy In addition, new techniques are still
under exploration to improve the sensitivity and specific
ity for the detection of sEVs for cancer diagnosis/prog
nosis. The development of new analysis methods such
as machine learning are expected to advance the cancer
diagnosis/prognosis as well. To progress the development
of cancer-derived sEVs in cancer treatment towards clinic
application, there are several tasks researchers should
pay more attention: (1) large-scale production and iso
lation approaches for sEVs; (2) technical difficulties in Overall, studies using cancer-derived sEVs as poten
tial immunity enhancers against PDAC have so far pro
vided some preliminary but promising results, which
encourages further investigations in this field. There has
however been some controversy regarding the biological
roles of cancer-derived sEVs in immunotherapy, as these
sEVs mediate both immunosuppressive or immunostim
ulatory responses and it is challenging to reconcile these
two aspects. The safety concerns of cancer-derived sEVs
is another problem and substantial research is required
to evaluate this issue. For example, particles with similar size of sEVs can be
enriched using size exclusion chromatography then puri
fied by immunocapture of the specific subtype of sEVs
using antibodies. However, the lack of high discriminat
ing cancer biomarker slow down the progress. With the
development of multi-omics tools, multiple and reliable
biomarker can be screened and used for cancer detection
in the near future. In addition, new techniques are still
under exploration to improve the sensitivity and specific
ity for the detection of sEVs for cancer diagnosis/prog
nosis. The development of new analysis methods such
as machine learning are expected to advance the cancer
diagnosis/prognosis as well. To progress the development
of cancer-derived sEVs in cancer treatment towards clinic
application, there are several tasks researchers should
pay more attention: (1) large-scale production and iso
lation approaches for sEVs; (2) technical difficulties in Conclusion and perspectives p
p
In summary, PDAC is a highly aggressive and lethal
malignancy mostly due to its late-stage presentation
and lack of curative therapies. This malignancy is diffi
cult to diagnose/prognose, monitor and treat. Hence, the
development of novel diagnostic/prognostic biomarkers
and better therapeutic strategies are urgently needed. Cancer-derived sEVs are abundant in both the tumor
environment and circulation system. They act as a non-
invasive biomarker and provide diverse biological func
tional information and medical applications in PDAC Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology Page 16 of 20 Page 16 of 20 2. Neoptolemos JP, Kleeff J, Michl P, Costello E, Greenhalf W, Palmer DH. Thera
peutic developments in pancreatic cancer: current and future perspectives. Nat reviews Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2018;15:333–48. production of clinical-grade sEVs and establishment of
corresponding quality control standards; (3) drug loading
capacity; (4) cancer cell targeting efficiency; and (5) safety
in human trials. Cancer-derived sEVs based therapeutic
strategies are still in the primary research stage, there
still a long way to go before they can be applied in clinic. For application of cancer-derived sEVs in therapy, it is
essential to develop strict good manufacturing practice
(GMP) procedures that include all the parameters such as
the type of parent cells, the sample volume and isolation
conditions (temperature, speed, time, etc.). Correspond
ing quality control standards should also be developed to
release the qualified sEV products and maintain repro
ducible manufacturing process, including the accept
able range of particle size, concentration and biomarker
profiles. Hybrid particles (e.g. sEV and liposome hybrid)
or sEV mimetics which carry various payloads may be
an interesting area to explore to improve the drug load
ing capacity. The development of different drug loading
techniques such as electroporation could also increase
the loading efficiency. As for the cancer cell targeting effi
ciency and safety of cancer-derived sEVs in human trials,
there are quite limited studies being reported. Further
collaborative efforts in multiple disciplines are needed to
transform cancer-derived sEVs based therapeutic strate
gies into practical applications for the benefit of cancer
patients. 3. Buscail L. Commentary. Pancreatic cancer: is the worst to come? Int J Epide
miol. 2017;46:1774–5. 4. Siegel RL, Miller KD, Jemal A. Cancer statistics. 2020. CA: a cancer journal for
clinicians. 2020; 70: 7–30. 5. Kleeff J, Korc M, Apte M, La Vecchia C, Johnson CD, Biankin AV, et al. Pancre
atic cancer. Conclusion and perspectives Nat Reviews Disease Primers. 2016;2:16022. 6. Sung H, Ferlay J, Siegel RL, Laversanne M, Soerjomataram I, Jemal A, et al. Global cancer statistics 2020: GLOBOCAN estimates of incidence and mortal
ity worldwide for 36 cancers in 185 countries. Cancer J Clin. 2021;71:209–49. 7. Humphris JL, Chang DK, Johns AL, Scarlett CJ, Pajic M, Jones MD, et al. The
prognostic and predictive value of serum CA19.9 in pancreatic cancer. Ann
Oncol. 2012;23:1713–22. 8. Zhou B, Xu J-W, Cheng Y-G, Gao J-Y, Hu S-Y, Wang L, et al. Early detection of
pancreatic cancer: Where are we now and where are we going? J Cancer. 2017;141:231–41. 9. Garrido-Laguna I, Hidalgo M. Pancreatic cancer: from state-of-the-art treat
ments to promising novel therapies. Nat reviews Clin Oncol. 2015;12:319–34. 10. Cancer statistics of American Cancer Society. https://www.cancer.org/cancer/
pancreatic-cancer/about/key-statistics.html. Accessed 20 August 2022. 11. Rahib L, Smith BD, Aizenberg R, Rosenzweig AB, Fleshman JM, Matrisian LM. Projecting cancer incidence and deaths to 2030: the unexpected burden
of thyroid, liver, and pancreas cancers in the United States. Cancer Res. 2014;74:2913–21. 12. Siegel RL, Miller KD, Fuchs HE, Jemal A. Cancer Statistics. 2021. CA: a cancer
journal for clinicians. 2021; 71: 7–33. 13. Lai X, Wang M, McElyea SD, Sherman S, House M, Korc M. A microRNA sig
nature in circulating exosomes is superior to exosomal glypican-1 levels for
diagnosing pancreatic cancer. Cancer Lett. 2017;393:86–93. 14. Zhu Y, Zhang H, Chen N, Hao J, Ma XJM. Diagnostic value of various liquid
biopsy methods for pancreatic cancer: A systematic review and meta-analy
sis. Med (Baltim). 2020;99:e18581. 15. Poruk KE, Gay DZ, Brown K, Mulvihill JD, Boucher KM, Scaife CL, et al. The
clinical utility of CA 19 – 9 in pancreatic adenocarcinoma: diagnostic and
prognostic updates. Curr Mol Med. 2013;13:340–51. p g
p
16. Ballehaninna UK, Chamberlain RS. The clinical utility of serum CA 19 – 9 in the
diagnosis, prognosis and management of pancreatic adenocarcinoma: An
evidence based appraisal. J Gastrointest Oncol. 2012;3:105–19. Data availability
Not applicable. 20. Capurso G, Signoretti M, Valente R, Arnelo U, Lohr M, Poley JW, et al. Methods
and outcomes of screening for pancreatic adenocarcinoma in high-risk
individuals. World J Gastrointest endoscopy. 2015;7:833–42. Acknowledgements WZ acknowledges the support from Macquarie University Research Excellence
Scholarship (MQRES). 17. Mellby LD, Nyberg AP, Johansen JS, Wingren C, Nordestgaard BG, Bojesen SE,
et al. Serum Biomarker Signature-Based Liquid Biopsy for Diagnosis of Early-
Stage Pancreatic Cancer. J Clin Oncol. 2018;36:2887–94. Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable. 22. Kitano M, Yoshida T, Itonaga M, Tamura T, Hatamaru K, Yamashita Y. Impact of
endoscopic ultrasonography on diagnosis of pancreatic cancer. J Gastroen
terol. 2019;54:19–32. Consent for publication All authors have approved the final draft of this manuscript for submission and
have given consent for the publication of identifiable details. 23. Adamska A, Domenichini A, Falasca M. Pancreatic Ductal Adenocarcinoma:
Current and Evolving Therapies. Int J Mol Sci. 2017;18:1338. Declarations 21. Baek HW, Park MJ, Rhee YY, Lee KB, Kim MA, Park IA. Diagnostic accuracy of
endoscopic ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration cytology of pancreatic
lesions. J Pathol translational Med. 2015;49:52–60. Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable. Competing interests 24. Neesse A, Krug S, Gress TM, Tuveson DA, Michl P. Emerging concepts in
pancreatic cancer medicine: targeting the tumor stroma. Onco Targets Ther. 2014;7:33–43. p
g
The authors declare no competing financial interest. Received: 18 July 2022 / Accepted: 11 September 2022 25. Xu Z, Pothula SP, Wilson JS, Apte MV. Pancreatic cancer and its stroma: a
conspiracy theory. World J gastroenterology: WJG. 2014;20:11216. 26. Gu Z, Du Y, Zhao X, Wang C. Tumor microenvironment and metabolic remod
eling in gemcitabine-based chemoresistance of pancreatic cancer. Cancer
Lett. 2021;521:98–108. 27. Zeng S, Pöttler M, Lan B, Grützmann R, Pilarsky C, Yang H. Chemoresistance in
Pancreatic Cancer. Int J Mol Sci. 2019;20:4504. Author contributions WZ conceived and wrote the manuscript. DHC, BJW and NHP reviewed and
edited the manuscript. DL and YW contributed to the conceptualization,
revised the original draft and provided the supervision. All authors read and
approved the final manuscript. 18. Mayerle J, Kalthoff H, Reszka R, Kamlage B, Peter E, Schniewind B, et al. Meta
bolic biomarker signature to differentiate pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma
from chronic pancreatitis. Gut. 2018;67:128–37. 19. Mehta S, Bhimani N, Gill AJ, Samra JS, Sahni S, Mittal A. Serum Biomarker
Panel for Diagnosis and Prognosis of Pancreatic Ductal Adenocarcinomas. Front Oncol. 2021;11:708963. 1.
Court CM, Ankeny JS, Hou S, Tseng HR, Tomlinson JS. Improving pancreatic
cancer diagnosis using circulating tumor cells: prospects for staging and
single-cell analysis. Expert Rev Mol Diagn. 2015;15:1491–504. References Bioinspired exosome-like therapeutics and delivery nanoplat
forms. Biomaterials. 2020;242:119925. 70. Yang Z, LaRiviere MJ, Ko J, Till JE, Christensen T, Yee SS, et al. A Multianalyte
Panel Consisting of Extracellular Vesicle miRNAs and mRNAs, cfDNA, and
CA19-9 Shows Utility for Diagnosis and Staging of Pancreatic Ductal Adeno
carcinoma. 2020; 26: 3248–58. 46. Jiang L, Gu Y, Du Y, Liu J. Exosomes: diagnostic biomarkers and therapeutic
delivery vehicles for cancer. Mol Pharm. 2019;16:3333–49. 71. Lau C, Kim Y, Chia D, Spielmann N, Eibl G, Elashoff D, et al. Role of Pancreatic
Cancer-derived Exosomes in Salivary Biomarker Development. J Biol Chem. 2013;288:26888–97. 47. Qiao L, Hu S, Huang K, Su T, Li Z, Vandergriff A, et al. Tumor cell-derived
exosomes home to their cells of origin and can be used as Trojan horses to
deliver cancer drugs. Theranostics. 2020;10:3474. g
48. Massoumi RL, Hines OJ, Eibl G, King JC. Emerging Evidence for the Clinical
Relevance of Pancreatic Cancer Exosomes. Pancreas. 2019;48:1–8. 72. Li Z, Jiang P, Li J, Peng M, Zhao X, Zhang X, et al. Tumor-derived exosomal
lnc-Sox2ot promotes EMT and stemness by acting as a ceRNA in pancreatic
ductal adenocarcinoma. Oncogene. 2018;37:3822–38. Relevance of Pancreatic Cancer Exosomes. Pancreas. 2019;48:1–8 49. Kalluri R, LeBleu VS. The biology, function, and biomedical applications of
exosomes. Science. 2020;367:eaau6977. 73. Takahashi K, Ota Y, Kogure T, Suzuki Y, Iwamoto H, Yamakita K, et al. Circulating
extracellular vesicle-encapsulated HULC is a potential biomarker for human
pancreatic cancer. Cancer Sci. 2020;111:98–111. exosomes. Science. 2020;367:eaau6977. 50. Li W, Li C, Zhou T, Liu X, Liu X, Li X, et al. Role of exosomal proteins in cancer
diagnosis. Mol Cancer. 2017;16:145. g
51. Erb U, Zöller M. Progress and potential of exosome analysis for early pancre
atic cancer detection. Expert Rev Mol Diagn. 2016;16:757–67. 74. Kumar SR, Kimchi ET, Manjunath Y, Gajagowni S, Stuckel AJ, Kaifi JT. RNA car
gos in extracellular vesicles derived from blood serum in pancreas associated
conditions. Sci Rep. 2020;10:2800. 52. Tai YL, Chu PY, Lee BH, Chen KC, Yang CY, Kuo WH, et al. Basics and applica
tions of tumor-derived extracellular vesicles. J Biomed Sci. 2019;26:35. 75. Yu S, Li Y, Liao Z, Wang Z, Wang Z, Li Y, et al. Plasma extracellular vesicle long
RNA profiling identifies a diagnostic signature for the detection of pancreatic
ductal adenocarcinoma. 2020; 69: 540–50. 53. Zhang Y, Bi J, Huang J, Tang Y, Du S, Li P. References 37. Pisitkun T, Shen R-F, Knepper MA. Identification and proteomic profiling of
exosomes in human urine. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2004;101:13368. 64. Verel-Yilmaz Y, Fernández JP, Schäfer A, Nevermann S, Cook L, Gercke N, et al. Extracellular Vesicle-Based Detection of Pancreatic Cancer. Frontiers in Cell
and Developmental Biology. 2021; 9. 38. Bonnerot C, Vincendeau-Scherrer C, Lankar D, Raposo G, Caby M-P. Exosomal-like vesicles are present in human blood plasma. Int Immunol. 2005;17:879–87. 65. Goto T, Fujiya M, Konishi H, Sasajima J, Fujibayashi S, Hayashi A, et al. An
elevated expression of serum exosomal microRNA-191, – 21, – 451a of
pancreatic neoplasm is considered to be efficient diagnostic marker. BMC
Cancer. 2018;18:116. 39. Ogawa Y, Miura Y, Harazono A, Kanai-Azuma M, Akimoto Y, Kawakami H, et
al. Proteomic Analysis of Two Types of Exosomes in Human Whole Saliva. Biol
Pharm Bull. 2011;34:13–23. 66. Madhavan B, Yue S, Galli U, Rana S, Gross W, Müller M, et al. Combined
evaluation of a panel of protein and miRNA serum-exosome biomarkers for
pancreatic cancer diagnosis increases sensitivity and specificity. Int J Cancer. 2015;136:2616–27. 40. Sharma P, Diergaarde B, Ferrone S, Kirkwood JM, Whiteside TL. Melanoma
cell-derived exosomes in plasma of melanoma patients suppress functions of
immune effector cells. Sci Rep. 2020;10:1–11. f
p
41. Simpson RJ, Lim JWE, Moritz RL, Mathivanan S. Exosomes: proteomic insights
and diagnostic potential. Expert Rev Proteomics. 2009;6:267–83. 67. Machida T, Tomofuji T, Maruyama T, Yoneda T, Ekuni D, Azuma T, et al. miR–1246 and miR–4644 in salivary exosome as potential biomarkers for
pancreatobiliary tract cancer. Oncol Rep. 2016;36:2375–81. 42. Choi D-S, Lee J, Go G, Kim Y-K, Gho YS. Circulating Extracellular Vesicles in
Cancer Diagnosis and Monitoring. Mol Diagn Ther. 2013;17:265–71. Cancer Diagnosis and Monitoring. Mol Diagn Ther. 2013;17:265–71. 68. Nakamura S, Sadakari Y, Ohtsuka T, Okayama T, Nakashima Y, Gotoh Y, et al. Pancreatic Juice Exosomal MicroRNAs as Biomarkers for Detection of Pancre
atic Ductal Adenocarcinoma. Ann Surg Oncol. 2019;26:2104–11.i 43. Alderton GK. Fishing for exosomes. Nat Rev Cancer. 2015;15:453. 44. Zhang W, Jiang L, Diefenbach RJ, Campbell DH, Walsh BJ, Packer NH, et al. Enabling Sensitive Phenotypic Profiling of Cancer-Derived Small Extracellular
Vesicles Using Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy Nanotags. ACS Sens. 2020;5:764–71. 69. Hu J, Sheng Y, Kwak KJ, Shi J, Yu B, Lee LJ. A signal-amplifiable biochip quanti
fies extracellular vesicle-associated RNAs for early cancer detection. Nat
Commun. 2017;8:1683. 45. Lu M, Huang Y. References 28. Théry C, Ostrowski M, Segura E. Membrane vesicles as conveyors of immune
responses. Nat Rev Immunol. 2009;9:581–93. Page 17 of 20 Page 17 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 (2022) 20:446 29. Kalra H, Drummen GPC, Mathivanan S. Focus on Extracellular Vesicles: Intro
ducing the Next Small Big Thing. Int J Mol Sci. 2016;17:170. 59. Joshi GK, Deitz-McElyea S, Liyanage T, Lawrence K, Mali S, Sardar R, et
al. Label-Free Nanoplasmonic-Based Short Noncoding RNA Sensing at
Attomolar Concentrations Allows for Quantitative and Highly Specific Assay
of MicroRNA-10b in Biological Fluids and Circulating Exosomes. ACS Nano. 2015;9:11075–89. 30. Gurunathan S, Kang M-H, Jeyaraj M, Qasim M, Kim J-H. Review of the isola
tion, characterization, biological function, and multifarious therapeutic
approaches of exosomes. Cells. 2019;8:307. 31. Shao H, Im H, Castro CM, Breakefield X, Weissleder R, Lee H. New Technolo
gies for Analysis of Extracellular Vesicles. Chem Rev. 2018;118:1917–50. 60. Takahasi K, Iinuma H, Wada K, Minezaki S, Kawamura S, Kainuma M, et al. Usefulness of exosome-encapsulated microRNA-451a as a minimally invasive
biomarker for prediction of recurrence and prognosis in pancreatic ductal
adenocarcinoma. 2018; 25: 155–61. 32. Chang C-H, Pauklin S. Extracellular vesicles in pancreatic cancer progression
and therapies. Cell Death Dis. 2021;12:1–12. and therapies. Cell Death Dis. 2021;12:1–12. 61. Marin AM, Mattar SB, Amatuzzi RF, Chammas R, Uno M, Zanette DL, et al. Plasma Exosome-Derived microRNAs as Potential Diagnostic and Prognostic
Biomarkers in Brazilian Pancreatic Cancer Patients. Biomolecules. 2022;12:769. 33. Tkach M, Théry C. Communication by Extracellular Vesicles: Where We Are
and Where We Need to Go. Cell. 2016;164:1226–32. 34. Kourembanas S. Exosomes. Vehicles of Intercellular Signaling, Biomarkers, and
Vectors of Cell Therapy. Annu Rev Physiol. 2015;77:13–27. 62. Wang C, Wang J, Cui W, Liu Y, Zhou H, Wang Y, et al. Serum Exosomal miRNA-
1226 as Potential Biomarker of Pancreatic Ductal Adenocarcinoma. Onco
Targets Ther. 2021;14:1441–51. 35. Armstrong EA, Beal EW, Chakedis J, Paredes AZ, Moris D, Pawlik TM, et al. Exo
somes in Pancreatic Cancer: from Early Detection to Treatment. J Gastrointest
surgery: official J Soc Surg Aliment Tract. 2018;22:737–50. 63. Que R, Ding G, Chen J, Cao L. Analysis of serum exosomal microRNAs and
clinicopathologic features of patients with pancreatic adenocarcinoma. World J Surg Oncol. 2013;11:219. fi
36. De Lellis L, Florio R, Di Bella MC, Brocco D, Guidotti F, Tinari N, et al. Exosomes
as pleiotropic players in pancreatic cancer. Biomedicines. 2021;9:275. References Detection and proteomic characterization of extracellular vesicles in human
pancreatic juice. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2018;499:37–43. p
;
93. ExoCarta. http://wwwexocartaorg/. Accessed 20 August 2022. 93. ExoCarta. http://wwwexocartaorg/. Accessed 20 August 2022 116. Zheng J, Hernandez JM, Doussot A, Bojmar L, Zambirinis CP, Costa-Silva B, et
al. Extracellular matrix proteins and carcinoembryonic antigen-related cell
adhesion molecules characterize pancreatic duct fluid exosomes in patients
with pancreatic cancer. HPB. 2018;20:597–604. 94. Wu H, Chen X, Ji J, Zhou R, Liu J, Ni W, et al. Progress of Exosomes in the
Diagnosis and Treatment of Pancreatic Cancer. Genetic Test Mol biomarkers. 2019;23:215–22. 95. Yang KS, Im H, Hong S, Pergolini I, Del Castillo AF, Wang R, et al. Multipara
metric plasma EV profiling facilitates diagnosis of pancreatic malignancy. Sci
Transl Med. 2017;9:eaal3226. 117. Buscail E, Chauvet A, Quincy P, Degrandi O, Buscail C, Lamrissi I, et al. CD63-
GPC1-Positive Exosomes Coupled with CA19-9 Offer Good Diagnostic
Potential for Resectable Pancreatic Ductal Adenocarcinoma. Translational
Oncol. 2019;12:1395–403. 96. Melo SA, Luecke LB, Kahlert C, Fernandez AF, Gammon ST, Kaye J, et al. Glypi
can-1 identifies cancer exosomes and detects early pancreatic cancer. Nature. 2015;523:177–82. 118. Hinestrosa JP, Lewis JM, Balcer HI, Kurzrock R, Lippman S, Krishnan R. Abstract
5960: Blood-based extracellular vesicle biomarker test for detection of early-
stage pancreatic cancer. Cancer Res. 2022;82:5960. 97. Jin H, Liu P, Wu Y, Meng X, Wu M, Han J, et al. Exosomal zinc transporter ZIP4
promotes cancer growth and is a novel diagnostic biomarker for pancreatic
cancer. Cancer Sci. 2018;109:2946–56. 119. Inoue H, Eguchi A, Kobayashi Y, Usugi E, Yamada R, Tsuboi J, et al. Extracellular
vesicles from pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma endoscopic ultrasound-fine
needle aspiration samples contain a protein barcode. J Hepato-Biliary-Pan
creat Sci. 2022;29:394–403. 98. Liu C, Zhao J, Tian F, Cai L, Zhang W, Feng Q, et al. Low-cost thermophoretic
profiling of extracellular-vesicle surface proteins for the early detection and
classification of cancers. Nat Biomedical Eng. 2019;3:183–93. i
99. Frampton AE, Prado MM, López-Jiménez E, Fajardo-Puerta AB, Jawad ZAR,
Lawton P, et al. Glypican-1 is enriched in circulating-exosomes in pancreatic
cancer and correlates with tumor burden. Oncotarget. 2018;9:19006–13. 120. Donoso-Quezada J, Ayala-Mar S, González-Valdez J. The role of lipids in
exosome biology and intercellular communication: Function, analytics and
applications. 2021; 22: 204 – 20. 100. Giampieri R, Piva F, Occhipinti G, Bittoni A, Righetti A, Pagliaretta S, et al. References Wan Y, Maurer M, He H-Z, Xia Y-Q, Hao S-J, Zhang W-L, et al. Enrichment of
extracellular vesicles with lipid nanoprobe functionalized nanostructured
silica. Lab Chip. 2019;19:2346–55. 110. Leca J, Martinez S, Lac S, Nigri J, Secq V, Rubis M, et al. Cancer-associated
fibroblast-derived annexin A6 + extracellular vesicles support pancreatic
cancer aggressiveness. J Clin Investig. 2016;126:4140–56. 88. Allenson K, Castillo J, San Lucas FA, Scelo G, Kim DU, Bernard V, et al. High
prevalence of mutantKRAS in circulating exosome-derived DNA from early-
stage pancreatic cancer patients. Ann Oncol. 2017;28:741–7. 111. Odaka H, Hiemori K, Shimoda A, Akiyoshi K, Tateno H. CD63-positive extra
cellular vesicles are potential diagnostic biomarkers of pancreatic ductal
adenocarcinoma. BMC Gastroenterol. 2022;22:153. stage pancreatic cancer patients. Ann Oncol. 2017;28:741–7. 89. Bernard V, Kim DU, San Lucas FA, Castillo J, Allenson K, Mulu FC, et al. Circulat
ing Nucleic Acids Are Associated With Outcomes of Patients With Pancreatic
Cancer. Gastroenterology. 2019; 156: 108 – 18.e4. 112. Xie Z, Gao Y, Ho C, Li L, Jin C, Wang X, et al. Exosome-delivered CD44v6/
C1QBP complex drives pancreatic cancer liver metastasis by promoting
fibrotic liver microenvironment. Gut. 2022;71:568–79. 90. San Lucas FA, Allenson K, Bernard V, Castillo J, Kim DU, Ellis K, et al. Minimally
invasive genomic and transcriptomic profiling of visceral cancers by next-
generation sequencing of circulating exosomes. Ann Oncol. 2016;27:635–41. 113. Li J, Li Y, Chen S, Duan W, Kong X, Wang Y, et al. Highly Sensitive Exosome
Detection for Early Diagnosis of Pancreatic Cancer Using Immunoassay
Based on Hierarchical Surface-Enhanced Raman Scattering Substrate. Small
Methods. 2022;6:2200154. 91. Yang S, Che SPY, Kurywchak P, Tavormina JL, Gansmo LB, Correa de Sampaio
P, et al. Detection of mutant KRAS and TP53 DNA in circulating exosomes
from healthy individuals and patients with pancreatic cancer. Cancer Biol
Ther. 2017;18:158–65. 114. Asada T, Nakahata S, Fauzi YR, Ichikawa T, Inoue K, Shibata N, et al. Integrin
α6A (ITGA6A)-type Splice Variant in Extracellular Vesicles Has a Potential as a
Novel Marker of the Early Recurrence of Pancreatic Cancer. Anticancer Res. 2022;42:1763. 92. Yamamoto H, Watanabe Y, Oikawa R, Morita R, Yoshida Y, Maehata T, et al. BARHL2Methylation Using Gastric Wash DNA or Gastric Juice Exosomal DNA
is a Useful Marker For Early Detection of Gastric Cancer in anH. pylori-Inde
pendent Manner. Clin Translational Gastroenterol. 2016;7:e184. 115. Osteikoetxea X, Benke M, Rodriguez M, Pálóczi K, Sódar BW, Szvicsek Z, et al. References Liu B, Yang H, Taher L, Denz A, Grützmann R, Pilarsky C, et al. Identification of
Prognostic Biomarkers by Combined mRNA and miRNA Expression Microar
ray Analysis in Pancreatic Cancer. Translational Oncol. 2018;11:700–14. Prognostic Biomarkers by Combined mRNA and miRNA Expression Microar
ray Analysis in Pancreatic Cancer. Translational Oncol. 2018;11:700–14. 82. Gupta RA, Shah N, Wang KC, Kim J, Horlings HM, Wong DJ, et al. Long
non-coding RNA HOTAIR reprograms chromatin state to promote cancer
metastasis. Nature. 2010;464:1071–6. 105. Zhang W, Wang L, Li D, Campbel DH, Walsh BJ, Packer NH, et al. Phenotypic
profiling of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma plasma-derived small extra
cellular vesicles for cancer diagnosis and cancer stage prediction: a proof-of-
concept study. Anal Methods. 2022;14:2255–65. 83. Costa-Silva B, Aiello NM, Ocean AJ, Singh S, Zhang H, Thakur Basant K, et al. Pancreatic cancer exosomes initiate pre-metastatic niche formation in the
liver. Nat Cell Biol. 2015;17:816–26. 106. Dong C, Huang L, Melo SA, Kurywchak P, Peng Q, Kahlert C, et al. Multiple
antibodies identify glypican-1 associated with exosomes from pancreatic
cancer cells and serum from patients with pancreatic cancer. bioRxiv; 2018:
145706. 84. Chevillet JR, Kang Q, Ruf IK, Briggs HA, Vojtech LN, Hughes SM, et al. Quan
titative and stoichiometric analysis of the microRNA content of exosomes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2014; 111: 14888-93. 107. Moutinho-Ribeiro P, Adem B, Batista I, Silva M, Silva S, Ruivo CF, et al. Exosoma
glypican-1 discriminates pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma from chronic
pancreatitis. Dig Liver Disease. 2022;54:871–7. 85. Kahlert C, Melo SA, Protopopov A, Tang J, Seth S, Koch M, et al. Identification
of double-stranded genomic DNA spanning all chromosomes with mutated
KRAS and p53 DNA in the serum exosomes of patients with pancreatic
cancer. J Biol Chem. 2014;289:3869–75. p
g
108. Lux A, Kahlert C, Grützmann R, Pilarsky C. c-Met and PD-L1 on Circulating
Exosomes as Diagnostic and Prognostic Markers for Pancreatic Cancer. Int J
Mol Sci. 2019;20:3305. 86. Thakur BK, Zhang H, Becker A, Matei I, Huang Y, Costa-Silva B, et al. Double-
stranded DNA in exosomes: a novel biomarker in cancer detection. Cell Res. 2014;24:766–9. 109. Kimura H, Yamamoto H, Harada T, Fumoto K, Osugi Y, Sada R, et al. CKAP4, a
DKK1 Receptor, Is a Biomarker in Exosomes Derived from Pancreatic Cancer
and a Molecular Target for Therapy. Clin Cancer Res. 2019;25:1936–47. 87. References Exosome. A Review of Its Classifica
tion, Isolation Techniques, Storage, Diagnostic and Targeted Therapy Applica
tions. Int J Nanomedicine. 2020;15:6917–34. 76. Li J, Li Z, Jiang P, Peng M, Zhang X, Chen K, et al. Circular RNA IARS (circ-IARS)
secreted by pancreatic cancer cells and located within exosomes regulates
endothelial monolayer permeability to promote tumor metastasis. J Experi
mental Clin Cancer Res. 2018;37:177. 54. Qian L, Yu S, Chen Z, Meng Z, Huang S, Wang P. Functions and clinical
implications of exosomes in pancreatic cancer. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta
(BBA) - Reviews on Cancer. 2019; 1871: 75–84. 77. Li Z, Yanfang W, Li J, Jiang P, Peng T, Chen K, et al. Tumor-released exosomal
circular RNA PDE8A promotes invasive growth via the miR-338/MACC1/MET
pathway in pancreatic cancer. Cancer Lett. 2018;432:237–50. 55. Zhao G, Zhou A, Li X, Zhu S, Wang Y, Zhang S, et al. The Significance of Exo
somal RNAs in the Development, Diagnosis, and Treatment of Gastric Cancer. Genes. 2021;12:73. 78. Bartel DP. MicroRNAs: target recognition and regulatory functions. Cell. 2009;136:215–33. 56. Zhao Z, Zhao G, Yang S, Zhu S, Zhang S, Li P. The significance of exosomal
RNAs in the development, diagnosis, and treatment of pancreatic cancer. Cancer Cell Int. 2021;21:1–16. 79. Chiang HR, Schoenfeld LW, Ruby JG, Auyeung VC, Spies N, Baek D, et al. Mammalian microRNAs: experimental evaluation of novel and previously
annotated genes. Genes Dev. 2010;24:992–1009. 57. Yee NS, Zhang S, He H-Z, Zheng S-Y. Extracellular Vesicles as Potential Bio
markers for Early Detection and Diagnosis of Pancreatic Cancer. 2020; 8: 581. 80. Zhang X, Xia D, Wang R-X, Zhang Y-T, Zhang S-Y, Yang C, et al. Identification
of potential biomarkers for digestive system cancers from serum-derived
extracellular vesicle RNA. Clin Chim Acta. 2022;531:36–47. 58. Xu Y-F, Hannafon BN, Zhao YD, Postier RG, Ding W-Q. Plasma exosome miR-
196a and miR-1246 are potential indicators of localized pancreatic cancer. 2017; 8: 77028–40. Page 18 of 20 Page 18 of 20 Page 18 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 81. Liu B, Yang H, Taher L, Denz A, Grützmann R, Pilarsky C, et al. Identification of 104. Lewis JM, Vyas AD, Qiu Y, Messer KS, Heller MJJAN. Integrated Analysis of Exo
somal Protein Biomarkers on Alternating Current Electrokinetic Chips Enables
Rapid Detection of Pancreatic Cancer in Patient Blood. 2018; 12: 3311–20. 81. References Clinical impact of different exosomes’ protein expression in pancreatic ductal
carcinoma patients treated with standard first line palliative chemotherapy. PLoS ONE. 2019;14:e0215990. 121. Record M, Carayon K, Poirot M, Silvente-Poirot S. Exosomes as new vesicular
lipid transporters involved in cell-cell communication and various patho
physiologies. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2014;1841:108–20. 122. Skotland T, Ekroos K, Kauhanen D, Simolin H, Seierstad T, Berge V, et al. Molecular lipid species in urinary exosomes as potential prostate cancer
biomarkers. European journal of cancer (Oxford, England: 1990). 2017; 70: 122
– 32. 101. Liang K, Liu F, Fan J, Sun D, Liu C, Lyon CJ, et al. Nanoplasmonic Quantification
of Tumor-derived Extracellular Vesicles in Plasma Microsamples for Diagnosis
and Treatment Monitoring. Nat Biomed Eng. 2017;1:0021. 123. Fan TWM, Zhang X, Wang C, Yang Y, Kang W-Y, Arnold S, et al. Exosomal lipids
for classifying early and late stage non-small cell lung cancer. Anal Chim Acta. 2018;1037:256–64. 102. Ferguson S, Yang KS, Zelga P, Liss AS, Carlson JC, Del Castillo CF, et al. Single-
EV analysis (sEVA) of mutated proteins allows detection of stage 1 pancreatic
cancer. Sci Adv. 2022;8:eabm3453. 103. Lennon KM, Wakefield DL, Maddox AL, Brehove MS, Willner AN, Garcia-
Mansfield K, et al. Single molecule characterization of individual extracellular
vesicles from pancreatic cancer. J Extracell Vesicles. 2019;8:1685634. 124. Eylem CC, Yilmaz M, Derkus B, Nemutlu E, Camci CB, Yilmaz E, et al. Untar
geted multi-omic analysis of colorectal cancer-specific exosomes reveals
joint pathways of colorectal cancer in both clinical samples and cell culture. Cancer Lett. 2020;469:186–94. Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology Page 19 of 20 Page 19 of 20 (2022) 20:446 125. Sharma R, Huang X, Brekken RA, Schroit AJ. Detection of phosphatidylserine-
positive exosomes for the diagnosis of early-stage malignancies. Br J Cancer. 2017;117:545–52. 149. Xu L, Faruqu FN, Lim YM, Lim KY, Liam-Or R, Walters AA, et al. Exosome-medi
ated RNAi of PAK4 prolongs survival of pancreatic cancer mouse model after
loco-regional treatment. Biomaterials. 2021;264:120369. 126. Linton SS, Abraham T, Liao J, Clawson GA, Butler PJ, Fox T, et al. Tumor-
promoting effects of pancreatic cancer cell exosomes on THP-1-derived
macrophages. PLoS ONE. 2018;13:e0206759. 150. Han S, Gonzalo DH, Feely M, Rinaldi C, Belsare S, Zhai H, et al. Stroma-derived
extracellular vesicles deliver tumor-suppressive miRNAs to pancreatic cancer
cells. Oncotarget. 2018;9:5764. 127. References Hinzman CP, Singh B, Bansal S, Li Y, Iliuk A, Girgis M, et al. A multi-omics
approach identifies pancreatic cancer cell extracellular vesicles as mediators
of the unfolded protein response in normal pancreatic epithelial cells. J
Extracell Vesicles. 2022;11:e12232. 151. Que R-s, Lin C, Ding G-p, Wu Z-r. Cao L-p. Increasing the immune activity of
exosomes: the effect of miRNA-depleted exosome proteins on activating
dendritic cell/cytokine-induced killer cells against pancreatic cancer. J Zheji
ang University-SCIENCE B. 2016;17:352–60. 152. Gastpar R, Gehrmann M, Bausero MA, Asea A, Gross C, Schroeder JA, et al. Heat shock protein 70 surface-positive tumor exosomes stimulate migratory
and cytolytic activity of natural killer cells. Cancer Res. 2005;65:5238–47. 128. Tao L, Zhou J, Yuan C, Zhang L, Li D, Si D, et al. Metabolomics identifies serum
and exosomes metabolite markers of pancreatic cancer. Metabolomics. 2019;15:86. 153. Zech D, Rana S, Büchler MW, Zöller M. Tumor-exosomes and leukocyte activa
tion: an ambivalent crosstalk. Cell Communication and Signaling. 2012;10:37. 129. Chen Y, Ding L, Ju H. In Situ Cellular Glycan Analysis. Acc Chem Res. 2018;51:890–9. 130. Scott E, Munkley J. Glycans as Biomarkers in Prostate Cancer. Int J Mol Sci. 2019;20:1389. 154. Mahmoodzadeh Hosseini H, Ali Imani Fooladi A, Soleimanirad J, Reza Nourani
M, Mahdavi M. Exosome/staphylococcal enterotoxin B, an anti tumor com
pound against pancreatic cancer. J BUON. 2014;19:440–8. 131. Díaz-Fernández A, Miranda-Castro R, de-los-Santos-Álvarez N, Lobo-Castañón
MJ, Estrela P. Impedimetric aptamer-based glycan PSA score for discrimina
tion of prostate cancer from other prostate diseases. Biosens Bioelectron. 2021;175:112872. 155. Zhou W, Chen X, Zhou Y, Shi S, Liang C, Yu X, et al. Exosomes derived from
immunogenically dying tumor cells as a versatile tool for vaccination against
pancreatic cancer. Biomaterials. 2022;280:121306. 132. Munkley J. The glycosylation landscape of pancreatic cancer (Review). Oncol
Lett. 2019;17:2569–75. 156. Lau C, Kim Y, Chia D, Spielmann N, Eibl G, Elashoff D, et al. Role of pancreatic
cancer-derived exosomes in salivary biomarker development. J Biol Chem. 2013;288:26888–97. 133. Engle DD, Tiriac H, Rivera KD, Pommier A, Whalen S, Oni TE, et al. The glycan
CA19-9 promotes pancreatitis and pancreatic cancer in mice. Science. 2019;364:1156–62. 157. Wang M, Su Z, Amoah Barnie P. Crosstalk among colon cancer-derived exo
somes, fibroblast-derived exosomes, and macrophage phenotypes in colon
cancer metastasis. Int Immunopharmacol. 2020;81:106298. 134. Yokose T, Kabe Y, Matsuda A, Kitago M, Matsuda S, Hirai M, et al. References O-Glycan-
Altered Extracellular Vesicles: A Specific Serum Marker Elevated in Pancreatic
Cancer. Cancers. 2020;12:2469. 158. Binenbaum Y, Fridman E, Yaari Z, Milman N, Schroeder A, Ben David G, et al. Transfer of miRNA in Macrophage-Derived Exosomes Induces Drug Resis
tance in Pancreatic Adenocarcinoma. Cancer Res. 2018;78:5287. 135. Choi Y, Park U, Koo H-J, Park J-s, Lee DH, Kim K, et al. Exosome-mediated
diagnosis of pancreatic cancer using lectin-conjugated nanoparticles bound
to selective glycans. Biosens Bioelectron. 2021;177:112980. 159. Ostenfeld MS, Jeppesen DK, Laurberg JR, Boysen AT, Bramsen JB, Primdal-
Bengtson B, et al. Cellular Disposal of miR23b by RAB27-Dependent Exo
some Release Is Linked to Acquisition of Metastatic Properties. Cancer Res. 2014;74:5758. 136. Tutrone R, Donovan MJ, Torkler P, Tadigotla V, McLain T, Noerholm M, et al. Clinical utility of the exosome based ExoDx Prostate(IntelliScore) EPI test in
men presenting for initial Biopsy with a PSA 2–10 ng/mL. Prostate Cancer
Prostatic Dis. 2020;23:607–14. 160. Fares J, Kashyap R, Zimmermann P. Syntenin. Key player in cancer exosome
biogenesis and uptake? Cell Adhes Migr. 2017;11:124–6. 137. Enderle D, Noerholm M. Are extracellular vesicles ready for the clinical labora
tory? LaboratoriumsMedizin. 2022. 161. Christianson HC, Svensson KJ, van Kuppevelt TH, Li J-P, Belting M. Cancer cell
exosomes depend on cell-surface heparan sulfate proteoglycans for their
internalization and functional activity. Proceedings of the National Academy
of Sciences. 2013; 110: 17380. 138. Becker A, Thakur BK, Weiss JM, Kim HS, Peinado H, Lyden D. Extracel
lular Vesicles in Cancer: Cell-to-Cell Mediators of Metastasis. Cancer Cell. 2016;30:836–48. 162. Hao Y, Song H, Zhou Z, Chen X, Li H, Zhang Y, et al. Promotion or inhibition of
extracellular vesicle release: Emerging therapeutic opportunities. J Controlled
Release. 2021;340:136–48. 139. Pullan JE, Confeld MI, Osborn JK, Kim J, Sarkar K, Mallik S. Exosomes as Drug
Carriers for Cancer Therapy. Mol Pharm. 2019;16:1789–98. 163. Rezaie J, Akbari A, Rahbarghazi R. Inhibition of extracellular vesicle biogenesis
in tumor cells: A possible way to reduce tumorigenesis. Cell Biochem Funct. 2022;40:248–62. 140. Richards KE, Zeleniak AE, Fishel ML, Wu J, Littlepage LE, Hill R. Cancer-asso
ciated fibroblast exosomes regulate survival and proliferation of pancreatic
cancer cells. Oncogene. 2017;36:1770–8. 164. Catalano M, O’Driscoll L. Inhibiting extracellular vesicles formation and
release: a review of EV inhibitors. J Extracell vesicles. 2020;9:1703244. 141. Xiao W, Pahlavanneshan M, Eun C-Y, Zhang X, DeKalb C, Mahgoub B, et al. References Matrix stiffness mediates pancreatic cancer chemoresistance through induc
tion of exosome hypersecretion in a cancer associated fibroblasts-tumor
organoid biomimetic model. Matrix Biology Plus. 2022;14:100111. 165. Rosenfeldt MT, O’Prey J, Flossbach L, Nixon C, Morton JP, Sansom OJ, et al. PTEN deficiency permits the formation of pancreatic cancer in the absence of
autophagy. Cell Death & Differentiation. 2017;24:1303–4. 142. Mikamori M, Yamada D, Eguchi H, Hasegawa S, Kishimoto T, Tomimaru Y, et
al. MicroRNA-155 Controls Exosome Synthesis and Promotes Gemcitabine
Resistance in Pancreatic Ductal Adenocarcinoma. Sci Rep. 2017;7:42339. 166. Si W, Liu X, Wei R, Zhang Y, Zhao Y, Cui L, et al. MTA2-mediated inhibition of
PTEN leads to pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma carcinogenicity. Cell Death
Dis. 2019;10:206. 143. Richards KE, Xiao W, Hill R, Team obotUPR. Cancer-Associated Fibroblasts
Confer Gemcitabine Resistance to Pancreatic Cancer Cells through PTEN-
Targeting miRNAs in Exosomes. Cancers. 2022;14:2812. 167. Capello M, Vykoukal JV, Katayama H, Bantis LE, Wang H, Kundnani DL, et al. Exosomes harbor B cell targets in pancreatic adenocarcinoma and exert
decoy function against complement-mediated cytotoxicity. Nat Commun. 2019;10:254. 144. Hoshino A, Costa-Silva B, Shen T-L, Rodrigues G, Hashimoto A, Tesic Mark M,
et al. Tumour exosome integrins determine organotropic metastasis. Nature. 2015;527:329–35. 168. Vader P, Mol EA, Pasterkamp G, Schiffelers RM. Extracellular vesicles for drug
delivery. Adv Drug Deliv Rev. 2016;106:148–56. 145. Wang C-A, Chang I-H, Hou P-C, Tai Y-J, Li W-N, Hsu P-L, et al. DUSP2 regulates
extracellular vesicle-VEGF-C secretion and pancreatic cancer early dissemina
tion. J Extracell vesicles. 2020;9:1746529. 169. Kamerkar S, LeBleu VS, Sugimoto H, Yang S, Ruivo CF, Melo SA, et al. Exosomes
facilitate therapeutic targeting of oncogenic KRAS in pancreatic cancer. Nature. 2017;546:498–503. 146. Li Y-J, Wu J-Y, Wang J-M, Hu X-B, Cai J-X, Xiang D-X. Gemcitabine loaded
autologous exosomes for effective and safe chemotherapy of pancreatic
cancer. Acta Biomater. 2020;101:519–30. 170. Kim MS, Haney MJ, Zhao Y, Mahajan V, Deygen I, Klyachko NL, et al. Develop
ment of exosome-encapsulated paclitaxel to overcome MDR in cancer cells. Nanomed Nanotechnol Biol Med. 2016;12:655–64. 147. Aspe JR, Diaz Osterman CJ, Jutzy JMS, Deshields S, Whang S, Wall NR. Enhancement of Gemcitabine sensitivity in pancreatic adenocarcinoma by
novel exosome-mediated delivery of the Survivin-T34A mutant. J Extracell
Vesicles. 2014;3:23244. 171. Lamichhane TN, Jeyaram A, Patel DB, Parajuli B, Livingston NK, Arumugas
aamy N, et al. Oncogene Knockdown via Active Loading of Small RNAs into
Extracellular Vesicles by Sonication. Cell Mol Bioeng. 2016;9:315–24. References 172. Rahbarghazi R, Jabbari N, Sani NA, Asghari R, Salimi L, Kalashani SA, et al. Tumor-derived extracellular vesicles: reliable tools for Cancer diagnosis and
clinical applications. Cell Communication and Signaling. 2019;17:1–17. 148. Al Faruque H, Choi E-S, Kim J-H, Kim E. Enhanced effect of autologous
EVs delivering paclitaxel in pancreatic cancer. J Controlled Release. 2022;347:330–46. Page 20 of 20 Page 20 of 20 Zhang et al. Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2022) 20:446 173. Fais S, O’Driscoll L, Borras FE, Buzas E, Camussi G, Cappello F, et al. Evidence- 173. Fais S, O’Driscoll L, Borras FE, Buzas E, Camussi G, Cappello F, et al. Evidence-
Based Clinical Use of Nanoscale Extracellular Vesicles in Nanomedicine. ACS
Nano. 2016;10:3886–99. 187. de Almeida Fuzeta M, Bernardes N, Oliveira FD, Costa AC, Fernandes-
Platzgummer A, Farinha JP, et al. Scalable production of human mesen
chymal stromal cell-derived extracellular vesicles under serum-/xeno-free
conditions in a microcarrier-based bioreactor culture system. Front cell Dev
biology. 2020;8:553444. Based Clinical Use of Nanoscale Extracellular Vesicles in Nanomedicine. ACS
Nano. 2016;10:3886–99. 174. Walker S, Busatto S, Pham A, Tian M, Suh A, Carson K, et al. Extracellular
vesicle-based drug delivery systems for cancer treatment. Theranostics. 2019;9:8001. 188. Yi YW, Lee JH, Kim S-Y, Pack C-G, Ha DH, Park SR, et al. Advances in analysis of
biodistribution of exosomes by molecular imaging. Int J Mol Sci. 2020;21:665. 175. Surana R, LeBleu VS, Lee JJ, Smaglo BG, Zhao D, Lee MS, et al. Phase I study of
mesenchymal stem cell (MSC)-derived exosomes with KRASG12D siRNA in
patients with metastatic pancreatic cancer harboring a KRASG12D mutation. J Clin Oncol. 2022;40:TPS633-TPS. 189. Sun H, Shi K, Qi K, Kong H, Zhang J, Dai S, et al. Natural Killer Cell-Derived
Exosomal miR-3607-3p Inhibits Pancreatic Cancer Progression by Targeting
IL-26. Front Immunol. 2019;10:2819. 190. Shang S, Wang J, Chen S, Tian R, Zeng H, Wang L, et al. Exosomal miRNA-1231
derived from bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells inhibits the activity of
pancreatic cancer. Cancer Med. 2019;8:7728–40. 176. Ou Y-H, Liang J, Czarny B, Wacker MG, Yu V, Wang J-W, et al. Extracellular
Vesicle (EV) biohybrid systems for cancer therapy: Recent advances and
future perspectives. Seminars in Cancer Biology: Elsevier; 2021. p.45–61. 177. Xu L, Faruqu FN, Liam-Or R, Abu Abed O, Li D, Venner K, et al. References Exosomes
derived from tumor cells genetically modified to express Mycobacterium
tuberculosis antigen: a novel vaccine for cancer therapy. Biotechnology let
ters. 2016; 38: 1857–66. 183. Ma J, Zhang Y, Tang K, Zhang H, Yin X, Li Y, et al. Reversing drug resistance
of soft tumor-repopulating cells by tumor cell-derived chemotherapeutic
microparticles. Cell Res. 2016;26:713–27. 184. Tang K, Zhang Y, Zhang H, Xu P, Liu J, Ma J, et al. Delivery of chemotherapeu
tic drugs in tumour cell-derived microparticles. Nat Commun. 2012;3:1282. References Design of
experiment (DoE)-driven in vitro and in vivo uptake studies of exosomes for
pancreatic cancer delivery enabled by copper-free click chemistry-based
labelling. J Extracell vesicles. 2020;9:1779458. 191. Huber M, Brehm CU, Gress TM, Buchholz M, Alashkar Alhamwe B, von Strand
mann EP, et al. The Immune Microenvironment in Pancreatic Cancer. Int J Mol
Sci. 2020;21:7307. 192. Hofmann L, Ludwig S, Vahl JM, Brunner C, Hoffmann TK, Theodoraki M-N. The
Emerging Role of Exosomes in Diagnosis, Prognosis, and Therapy in Head and
Neck Cancer. Int J Mol Sci. 2020;21:4072. 178. Xavier CP, Castro I, Caires HR, Ferreira D, Cavadas B, Pereira L, et al. Chitinase
3-like-1 and fibronectin in the cargo of extracellular vesicles shed by human
macrophages influence pancreatic cancer cellular response to gemcitabine. Cancer Lett. 2021;501:210–23. 193. Whiteside TL. Exosomes and tumor-mediated immune suppression. J Clin
Investig. 2016;126:1216–23. 193. Whiteside TL. Exosomes and tumor-mediated immune suppression. J Clin
Investig. 2016;126:1216–23. 179. Gilligan KE, Dwyer RM. Engineering exosomes for cancer therapy. Int J Mol
Sci. 2017;18:1122. 194. Sun W, Luo J-d, Jiang H, Duan DD. Tumor exosomes: a double-edged sword
in cancer therapy. Acta Pharmacol Sin. 2018;39:534–41. 194. Sun W, Luo J-d, Jiang H, Duan DD. Tumor exosomes: a double-edged sword
in cancer therapy. Acta Pharmacol Sin. 2018;39:534–41. 180. Liang Y, Duan L, Lu J, Xia J. Engineering exosomes for targeted drug delivery. Theranostics. 2021;11:3183–95. 195. Gehrmann U, Näslund TI, Hiltbrunner S, Larssen P, Gabrielsson S. Harnessing
the exosome-induced immune response for cancer immunotherapy. Sem
Cancer Biol. 2014;28:58–67. 181. Dai S, Wei D, Wu Z, Zhou X, Wei X, Huang H, et al. Phase I clinical trial of
autologous ascites-derived exosomes combined with GM-CSF for colorectal
cancer. Mol Ther. 2008;16:782–90. 196. Gu X, Erb U, Büchler MW, Zöller M. Improved vaccine efficacy of tumor exo
some compared to tumor lysate loaded dendritic cells in mice. Int J Cancer. 2015;136:E74–84. 182. Guo M, Wu F, Hu G, Chen L, Xu J, Xu P, et al. Autologous tumor cell–derived
microparticle-based targeted chemotherapy in lung cancer patients with
malignant pleural effusion. Sci Transl Med. 2019;11:eaat5690. 197. Koyama Y, Ito T, Hasegawa A, Eriguchi M, Inaba T, Ushigusa T, et al. Exosomes
derived from tumor cells genetically modified to express Mycobacterium
tuberculosis antigen: a novel vaccine for cancer therapy. Biotechnology let
ters. 2016; 38: 1857–66. 197. Koyama Y, Ito T, Hasegawa A, Eriguchi M, Inaba T, Ushigusa T, et al. Publisher’s Note 185. Meng W, He C, Hao Y, Wang L, Li L, Zhu G. Prospects and challenges of extra
cellular vesicle-based drug delivery system: Considering cell source. Drug
Delivery. 2020;27:585–98. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. 186. Yamashita T, Takahashi Y, Takakura Y. Possibility of exosome-based thera
peutics and challenges in production of exosomes eligible for therapeutic
application. Biol Pharm Bull. 2018;41:835–42.
|
https://openalex.org/W4297944867
|
https://zenodo.org/records/7124172/files/ZDPP2307.pdf
|
Quechua
| null |
MUSTAQIL SÓZ TURKUMLARINING ÓZIGA XOS XUSUSIYATLARI
|
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 497
|
ARI ARI O`qituvchi, Termiz davlat universiteti qoshidagi akadem
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7124172 O`qituvchi, Termiz davlat universiteti qoshidagi akademik litsey
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7124172 So‘zlarning lug‘aviy va grammatik ma’no jihatdan o‘xshashligiga ko‘ra ayrim
leksik - grammatik guruhlariga ajratilish so‘z turkumlari deyiladi. So‘zlarni
turkumlarga ajratishda ularning grammatik ma’no-lari bilan bir qatorda, lug‘aviy
ma’nosi ham asosiy belgilardan hisob-lanadi. Ham grammatik, ham leksik
ma’nolarga ega bo‘lib, gapda mustaqil sintaktik bo‘lak sifatida ishtirok etadigan
so‘zlar mustaqil so‘zlar deyiladi. Mustaqil so‘zlarga: ot, sifat, son, olmosh, fe’l,
ravish kiradi. Shuni ham ta’kidlash joizki, tilimizdagi ba’zi mustaqil so‘zlar ham nutq
jarayonida o‘zining mustaqil lug‘aviy ma’nosini yo‘qotib, gram-matik ma’no
ifodalashga xoslangan holda, yordamchi so‘z vazifasiga o‘tishi mumkin. Bu
hodisa tilshunoslikda grammatikalizatsiya deb yuritiladi. Masalan: ko‘rib
qolmoq, bilib olmoq, xafta ichi kabi birikmalardagi qol, ol, ich so‘zlari o‘zining
mustaqil lug‘aviy ma’nosni yo‘qotgan holda yordamchi so‘z sifatida qo‘llangan. Shuni ham ta’kidlash joizki, tilimizdagi ba’zi mustaqil so‘zlar ham nutq
jarayonida o‘zining mustaqil lug‘aviy ma’nosini yo‘qotib, gram-matik ma’no
ifodalashga xoslangan holda, yordamchi so‘z vazifasiga o‘tishi mumkin. Bu
hodisa tilshunoslikda grammatikalizatsiya deb yuritiladi. Masalan: ko‘rib
qolmoq, bilib olmoq, xafta ichi kabi birikmalardagi qol, ol, ich so‘zlari o‘zining
mustaqil lug‘aviy ma’nosni yo‘qotgan holda yordamchi so‘z sifatida qo‘llangan. Mustaqil leksik ma’noga ega bo‘lmaydigan, gap bo‘lagi vazifasini bajara
olmaydigan, biroq so‘z va gaplarni o‘zaro bog‘lash yoki ularga qo‘shimcha ma’no
nozikligi kiritish (yuklash) uchun xizmat qiladigan so‘zlar yordamchi so‘zlar
deyiladi. Yordamchi so‘zlar umumiy vazifalarga ko‘ra uch turli bo‘ladi:1)
ko‘makchi; 2) bog‘lovchi; 3) yuklama. Mustaqil leksik ma’noga ega bo‘lmaydigan, gap bo‘lagi vazifasini bajara
olmaydigan, biroq so‘z va gaplarni o‘zaro bog‘lash yoki ularga qo‘shimcha ma’no
nozikligi kiritish (yuklash) uchun xizmat qiladigan so‘zlar yordamchi so‘zlar
deyiladi. Yordamchi so‘zlar umumiy vazifalarga ko‘ra uch turli bo‘ladi:1)
ko‘makchi; 2) bog‘lovchi; 3) yuklama. Undov, taqlid va modal so‘zlar esa, yordamchi so‘zlarning alohida guruhini
tashkil etadi. Chunki undov va taqlid so‘zlar gap bo‘lagi sifatida ham, mustaqil
so‘z-gap sifatida ham qo‘llanadi. Ayni paytda mustaqil so‘zlarning yasalishida
ham ishtirok eta oladi. Biroq bu so‘zlar harakat va hodisaning atamasi bo‘la
olmasligi, ya’ni lug‘aviy ma’no ifoda eta olmasligi bilan yordamchi so‘zlarga
o‘xshashdir. Shuning uchun ham undov, taqlid, modal so‘zlarning har biri o‘ziga
xos xususiyatlari bilan alohida - alohida turkumni tashkil etadi. Ko‘rinadiki, so‘zlarni turkumlarga ajratishda, birinchidan, lug‘aviy ma’no,
ikkinchidan, morfologik shakl, uchinchidan, biror sintaktik vazifa bajarish
xususiyati, to‘rtinchidan, qo‘llanish qurshovi (distributsiyasi) e’tiboridan kelib
chiqiladi. Shunga ko‘ra so‘zlarning hozirgi o‘zbek tilidagi turkumlari: 1) ot, sifat,
son, olmosh, fe’l, ravish kabi mustaqil so‘zlar; 2) ko‘makchi, bog‘lovchi, yuklama
kabi yordamchi so‘zlar; 3) modal so‘zlar, taqlid so‘zlar, undov so‘zlar kabi
alohida yordamchi so‘zlar guruhidan iborat. O`qituvchi, Termiz davlat universiteti qoshidagi akadem
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7124172 Foydalanilgan adabiyotlar ro'yxati: 27 Дониёров Zamonaviy dunyoda pedagogika va psixologiya»
omli ilmiy, masofaviy, onlayn konferensiya 1. Ш. Шоабдураќмонов, М.Асљарова, А.Ќожиев, И.Расулов, , Х.Дониёров
Ќозирги њзбек адабий тили. 1-љисм .Т., «Њљитувчи» 1980. 1. Ш. Шоабдураќмонов, М.Асљарова, А.Ќожиев, И.Расулов, , Х.Дониёров
Ќозирги њзбек адабий тили. 1-љисм .Т., «Њљитувчи» 1980. 2. У. Турсунов, Ж. Мухторов, Ш. Раќматуллаев Ќозирги њзбек адабий
тили. Т., «Њљитувчи» 1992. 3. Њзбек тили грамматикаси. 1-том. Т., «Фан» 1975. 4. N.Mahmudov, A.Nurmonov,A.Sobirov, D.Nabiyeva, A.Mirzaahme-dov Ona
tili. Umumta’lim maktablarining 7-sinfi uchun darslik. T., «Ma’naviyat» 2005 28
|
https://openalex.org/W2097430149
|
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0007616&type=printable
|
English
| null |
Quantitative Assessment of Stereotyped and Challenged Locomotion after Lesion of the Striatum: A 3D Kinematic Study in Rats
|
PloS one
| 2,009
|
cc-by
| 10,557
|
Quantitative Assessment of Stereotyped and Challenged
Locomotion after Lesion of the Striatum: A 3D Kinematic
Study in Rats Olivier Perrot, Davy Laroche, Thierry Pozzo, Christine Marie* Olivier Perrot, Davy Laroche, Thierry Pozzo, Christine Marie*
INSERM U887 Motricite´-Plasticite´, Universite´ de Bourgogne, Dijon, France INSERM U887 Motricite´-Plasticite´, Universite´ de Bourgogne, Dijon, France Abstract Cookson, National Institutes of Health, United States of America Received July 24, 2009; Accepted October 5, 2009; Published October 27, 2009 Received July 24, 2009; Accepted October 5, 2009; Published October 27, 2009 Copyright: 2009 Perrot et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Copyright: 2009 Perrot et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attr
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Funding: This study was supported by grants from the Conseil Rgional de Bourgogne. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis,
decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. * E-mail: chmarie@u-bourgogne.fr * E-mail: chmarie@u-bourgogne.fr PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Abstract Background: Although the striatum is in position to regulate motor function, the role of the structure in locomotor
behaviour is poorly understood. Therefore, a detailed analysis of locomotion- and obstacle avoidance-related parameters
was performed after unilateral lesion of the striatum in rats. Methods and Results: Using the three dimensional motion capture technology, kinematics of walking and clearing
obstacles, head and body orientation were analyzed before and up to 60 days after the lesion. Recordings were performed
in treadmill running rats with or without obstacles attached to the treadmill belt. The lesion, which was induced by the
direct injection of the mitochondrial toxin malonate into the left caudoputamen resulted in the complete destruction of the
dorsal striatum. During the first three days following the lesion, rats were unable to run on the treadmill. Thereafter, rats
showed normal looking locomotion, yet the contralesional limbs exhibited changes in length and timing parameters, and
were overflexed. Moreover, the head of lesioned rats was orientated towards the side of the lesion, and their postural
vertical shifted towards the contralesional side. During obstructed running, the contralesional limbs when they were leading
the crossing manoeuvre stepped on the obstacle rather than to overcome obstacle without touching it, yet more frequently
with the forelimb than the hindlimb. Unsuccessful crossings appeared to be due to a paw placement farther away from the
front of the obstacles, and not to an inappropriate limb elevation. Importantly, deficit in locomotor behaviour did not
regress over the time. Conclusion: Our results argue that the striatum of one hemisphere controls kinematics of contralateral limbs during
stereotyped locomotion and plays a prominent role in the selection of the right motor program so that these limbs
successfully cross over obstacle. Citation: Perrot O, Laroche D, Pozzo T, Marie C (2009) Quantitative Assessment of Stereotyped and Challenged Locomotion after Lesion of the Striatum: A 3D
Kinematic Study in Rats. PLoS ONE 4(10): e7616. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616 Citation: Perrot O, Laroche D, Pozzo T, Marie C (2009) Quantitative Assessment of Stereotyped and Challenged Locomotion after Lesion of the Striatum: A 3D
Kinematic Study in Rats. PLoS ONE 4(10): e7616. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616
Editor: Mark R Cookson National Institutes of Health United States of America Editor: Mark R. Cookson, National Institutes of Health, United States of America Editor: Mark R. Striatum and Locomotion Striatum and Locomotion and lack of swing arm, but normal performance in obstacle
avoidance tasks [12]. Assuming that PD is caused by striatal
dopamine depletion consecutive to degeneration of dopaminergic
neurons originating from the substantia nigra (SN) pars compacta,
locomotor deficit in PD only reveals how important is the striatal
dopaminergic input in the control of the basic locomotor pattern. Additionally, the functional deficit observed in PD patients is the
net result of two opposite phenomena, i.e. the severity of the
striatal dopamine depletion and the intensity of the different
compensatory mechanisms, which are sequentially activated in
parallel with the progressive striatal dopamine depletion [13]. A
detailed and quantitative analysis of stereotyped and challenged
locomotion after acute lesion of the striatum in rat may help to
increase our understanding on the role of the striatum in
locomotor behaviour. It could also help to interpret the locomotor
deficit and recovery observed in stroke patients in which the
striatum alone or in combination with cortical areas is a common
site of acute neuronal death. 18.965.4 mm3 and tissue loss in the lesioned hemisphere reached
16.664.0% (relative to the unlesioned hemisphere). These data
are in accordance with previous data of our laboratory [14]. Fig. 1
shows a representative slice of brain collected at the striatum level. Note the dilation of the ventricle on the lesion side as well as the
multiple cavities within the lesioned striatum. Results In a first experiment (10 rats with body weight about 450 g), 8
rats were selected at the end of the selection period, 1 rat died
during anaesthesia, and the remaining rats were treated with
malonate. In lesioned rats, pre-lesion kinematic recordings were
performed 19, 12, 5 and 1 days before malonate administration. During this period, the body weight (g) increased from 467616 to
478618. Pre-lesion kinematic parameters were not different. Therefore, the values were pooled and compared to values
collected 4, 7, 14, 21, 28, 35, 42, 49, or 60 days after malonate
administration (n = 7 at all time points except at day 4 lesion where
n = 6). During the post-lesion period, the body weight (g) increased
from 431614 to 499615. The weight loss was not due to some
difficulties to reach food. In a second experiment (6 rats with a body weight of 370 g), 4
rats were selected at the end of the selection period and treated
with saline instead of malonate (sham rats). Among these rats, one
rat was excluded from the kinematic analysis because of frequent
removals of the forelimb distal markers with teeth. Kinematic
recordings were performed 3, 2 and 1 days before saline
administration. As values were not different, they were pooled
and compared to values collected 1, 2 and 4 days after saline
administration. In sham rats, the body weight remained close to
370 g. Figure 1. Representative photographs of a brain slice passing
through the lesioned striatum. Note the preservation of the corpus
callosum (a), the dilation of the lateral ventricle (b) and the cavities
within the striatum (c) of the lesioned side (A) as compared to the
unlesioned site (B) Staining: cresyl violet; scale bars for the top and the
bottom photographs are 350 and 500 mm, respectively. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g001 3) Effect of the striatal lesion on stereotyped locomotion Whereas the sham procedure affected none of the measured
parameters (data not shown), malonate administration impaired Figure 1. Representative photographs of a brain slice passing
through the lesioned striatum. Note the preservation of the corpus
callosum (a), the dilation of the lateral ventricle (b) and the cavities
within the striatum (c) of the lesioned side (A) as compared to the
unlesioned site (B) Staining: cresyl violet; scale bars for the top and the
bottom photographs are 350 and 500 mm, respectively. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g001 Introduction limbic zones, which receives afferents from the sensori-motor,
associative, and the limbic cortical areas, respectively [3]. The
commonest consequence of lesion of the striatum is dystonia and
the syndrome of abulia (apathy with loss of initiative and of
spontaneous thought and emotional response) in human depend-
ing on the site of the lesion within the striatum [4]. However,
electrophysiogical studies in primates and imaging studies in
humans are in keeping with the idea that the striatum supports
hand/fingers movement selection, preparation and execution
[5–9]. In contrast, the role of the striatum in the regulation of
locomotion and the voluntary adaptation of locomotion to
environment, which requires a precise and fine supraspinal control
of the basic locomotor pattern, is not well understood. Activation
of the striatum during treadmill locomotion in rats [10] and during
the imagination of locomotor tasks in human [11] has been
reported. However, most of what is known of the role of the
striatum in the control of locomotion has been deduced from the
disturbances of gait accompanying Parkinson’s disease (PD)
including slow gait speed, little steps, narrowing of base support The study of quadrupeds has furnished most of our under-
standing of mammalian locomotion [1,2]. Thus, locomotion is
controlled by the interaction of three components: (1) central
pattern generators (CPGs), networks of spinal interneurons which
provide the basic locomotor pattern, (2) proprioceptive and
exteroceptive feedbacks, and (3) descending supraspinal control
from the brain cortex including the corticospinal pathway and
from the brain stem including the rubro-, vestibulo- and tecto-
spinal
pathways. The
cortico-
and
rubro-spinal
tracts
are
responsive
for
fine
control
and
voluntary
modification
of
locomotion and the other tracts serve to activate CPGs, which
are silent at rest, and to adjust the posture. However, how these
components are implemented and how they interplay to generate/
regenerate locomotion in normal/pathological conditions is not
well understood. The striatum is the main input layer of the basal ganglia. It is
organized in three zones; the sensorimotor, the associative and the October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 1 2) Overview Rats were all unable to run on the treadmill during the first
three days following malonate administration. At day 4 post-lesion,
running was possible in 6 rats, the remaining rat being capable of
running from day 7 post-lesion. The running incapacity was
apparently due to the inability of rats to adapt limb motion to the
treadmill belt movement. Once capable of running, lesioned rats
badly performed the obstacle clearance task with their contrale-
sional
limbs
when
these
limbs
were
leading
the
obstacle
manoeuvre. In contrast, sham rats were capable of treadmill
running as soon as the first day following saline treatment, and
saline did not impair obstacle crossing. Accordingly, changes in
locomotor behaviour observed in malonate-treated rats were not
due to the surgical procedure. Moreover, deficit after malonate
cannot involve changes in body weight. First, kinematic changes
were restricted to limbs contralateral to the lesion. If the
impairments had been due to changes in body weight, kinematics
would have been impaired bilaterally. In addition, changes in
kinematics did not parallel with changes in body weight in lesioned
rats. The aim of the present study was to better understand the role
of the striatum in the two components of the locomotion; the basic
locomotor pattern which is provided by CPGs, and the possibility
to deal with environmental constraints by the voluntary modifi-
cation of the basic locomotor pattern, which requires supraspinal
control. For this purpose, locomotion was studied before and up to
two months after unilateral lesion of the striatum during treadmill
running with or without obstacles attached to the treadmill belt in
the rat. The brain lesion was induced by the direct injection of the
mitochondrial toxin malonate into the dorsal striatum (caudoputa-
men) which includes the sensorimotor and the associative zones of
the striatum in rat. Locomotion was quantitatively and objectively
assessed from the 3-D motion capture technology. Recordings
were also performed in sham rats in order to assess the impact of
the surgical procedure on kinematics. 3) Effect of the striatal lesion on stereotyped locomotion
Whereas the sham procedure affected none of the measured
parameters (data not shown), malonate administration impaired 1) Histological study After malonate administration, all rats exhibited a complete
lesion of the dorsal striatum which was associated with a severe
atrophy of the lesioned hemisphere. The mean lesion volume was PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 2 Striatum and Locomotion lesion vs 1.6660.89 before lesion, P,0.025), whereas TSR
between
the
hindlimbs
was
not
modified
(1.0160.31
and
1.0260.22 at day 7 and 60 post-lesion vs 1.0960.10 before
lesion, NS). Length parameters were also significantly affected by
the lesion (Fig. 2B). After lesion, stride length of the contralesional
hindlimb (CHL) progressively increased over the time (P,0.025 at
day 60 post-lesion). Nevertheless, the stride length remained in
proportion with the stance phase duration after lesion (Fig. 2C). Finally, the homologous, homolateral and diagonal coupling many locomotion-related parameters either transiently or persis-
tently as described in the following paragraphs. a) Timing and length parameters. After lesion, timing
parameters were affected only for the contralesional forelimb
(CFL) (Fig. 2A). That limb exhibited an early and persistent
increase in the stance phase duration. However, the stride
duration remained close to pre-lesion values. The lesion also led
to a persistent decrease in temporal symmetry ratio (TSR) between
the forelimbs (1.0960.81 and 0.9360.37 at day 7 and 60 post- Figure 2. Effect of the lesion on timing and length parameters. A) duration of the stride, the stance and swing phases, B) stride length, C)
relationship between the stride length and the stance phase duration after lesion. The parameters were measured before lesion (BL) and up to 60
days after lesion from the ipsilesional and contralesional forelimbs (IFL and CFL) and hindlimbs (IHL and CHL). The stride length was plotted against
the corresponding stance phase duration. Values are means6SD, * different from BL values (P,0.025). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g002 Figure 2. Effect of the lesion on timing and length parameters. A) duration of the stride, the stance and swing phases, B) stride length, C)
relationship between the stride length and the stance phase duration after lesion. The parameters were measured before lesion (BL) and up to 60
days after lesion from the ipsilesional and contralesional forelimbs (IFL and CFL) and hindlimbs (IHL and CHL). The stride length was plotted against
the corresponding stance phase duration. Values are means6SD, * different from BL values (P,0.025). 1) Histological study doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g002 October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 3 Striatum and Locomotion between limbs before lesion were ,50%, 30% and 80%,
respectively, and were not affected by the lesion, regardless of
the post-lesion time (data not shown). knee angle values did well inform on the impact of the lesion on
joint kinematics. The impact of the lesion on joint angle values is shown in Fig. 3
and 4. Unlike ipsilesional limbs whose joint angle values were not
affected by the lesion, the contralesional limbs exhibited significant
changes in joint angle values (Fig. 3). After lesion, the knee and
shoulder angles were decreased early and persistently during the
stance phase, i.e. the joints were over-flexed. In contrast, a
transient over-flexion followed by a delayed over-extension of the b) Joint angle values. The mean distance between the hip
and the knee markers as well as between the knee and the ankle
markers was not significantly different between the two hindlimbs
and not affected by the lesion. In addition, the distance was not
different among rats whatever the time point of the measurement. Therefore, comparisons between pre- and post-lesion values of Therefore, comparisons between pre- and post-lesion values of
transient over-flexion followed by a delayed over-exte
Figure 3. Effect of the lesion on joint angle values of the contralesional limbs. The solid and dashed lines correspond to the
minimal values, respectively. The parameters were measured during the stance and swing phases before lesion (BL) and up to 60 day
Values are means6SD, * different from BL values (P,0.025). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g003 Figure 3. Effect of the lesion on joint angle values of the contralesional limbs. The solid and dashed lines correspond to the maximal and
minimal values, respectively. The parameters were measured during the stance and swing phases before lesion (BL) and up to 60 days after lesion. Values are means6SD, * different from BL values (P,0.025). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g003 October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 4 Striatum and Locomotion Figure 4. Effect of the lesion on mean values of the joint angle positions. A and C) angular excursion, the solid and dashed lines correspond
to values measured before and at day 60 after lesion, respectively. 1) Histological study The phases of the locomotor cycle were normalized (the stance phase in grey),
* difference between pre- and post-lesion values (P,0.025), B and D) corresponding stick figures of one complete step cycle (stance ad swing). Horizontal arrows indicate the direction of the movement, downward arrows foot contact and upward arrows foot lift. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g004 Figure 4. Effect of the lesion on mean values of the joint angle positions. A and C) angular excursion, the solid and dashed lines correspond
to values measured before and at day 60 after lesion, respectively. The phases of the locomotor cycle were normalized (the stance phase in grey),
* difference between pre- and post-lesion values (P,0.025), B and D) corresponding stick figures of one complete step cycle (stance ad swing). Horizontal arrows indicate the direction of the movement, downward arrows foot contact and upward arrows foot lift. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g004 lesion values (2.962.1u). Such a shift of the body is consistent with
the increased flexion of the contralesional limbs (Fig. 3). elbow was observed during the swing phase. The mean pre- and
post-lesion (at day 60) angular excursion (over 2 consecutive cycles)
as well as sticks diagrams of a representative rat is shown in Fig. 4. Clearly,
the
pre-lesion
and
post-lesion
angular
traces
are
superimposed for the ipsilesional but not the contralesional limbs. For these limbs, the post-lesion trace is below the pre-lesion trace
for the knee and the shoulder and above the pre-lesion trace for
the elbow. 4) Effect of the striatal lesion on obstacle avoidance Before lesion, no preference was shown for leading either with
the right or with the left forelimb (data not shown) and rats crossed
over the obstacle without touching it. When rats stepped over
obstacles, they used a strategy in which the first hindlimb to step
over the obstacle was always ipsilateral to the leading forelimb as
illustrated in Fig. 6A. In the example, the right forelimb (limb 1)
was the first limb to step over the obstacle (leading forelimb),
followed by the left forelimb (trailed forelimb = limb 2). Then, the
rat stepped over the obstacle with the right hindlimb (leading
hindlimb = limb 3) and finally with the left hindlimb (trailed
hindlimb = limb 4). The pre-obstacle distances (cm) were 5.461.2
and 2.460.8 for the leading and trailed forelimbs, respectively. The corresponding values for the hindlimbs were 9.761.4 and
3.760.8. The maximal height (mm) of the more distal marker
during the crossing swing was 36.961.4 for limb 1, 30.661.7 for
limb 2, 45.762.8 for limb 3 and 50.462.7 for limb 4. For both
forelimbs, maximal elevation was reached when the tip of limbs
was just above the obstacle. On the contrary, maximal elevation of
limbs 3 and 4 was reached before and after the tip of the paw had
crossed over the obstacle, respectively. Time to avoid obstacle was
,250 ms for all limbs. Fig. 6D illustrates limbs trajectory before
lesion in a representative rat. c) Paw placement in the frontal plane. The results are
summarized in Fig. 5A and 5B. The lesion resulted in a more
internal placement of the contralesional hindlimb. Thus, the
distance (mm) between the hip and MTP markers in the frontal
plane at toe off was 210.563 before lesion and decreased to
26.463.5 and 27.463.2 at days 4 and 7 post-lesion, respectively. The distance progressively recovered pre-lesion values over the
time. The paw placement of other limbs was not affected by the
lesion. These data are consistent with a reversible decrease in the
hindlimb base of support in the lesioned rats. d) Head and body orientation. The results are summarized
in Fig. 5C and 5D. Before lesion, the mean horizontal head-on-
trunk position was close to the mid-sagittal body axis as evidenced
by the value of the roll angle (0.562.2u). A substantial and long-
lasting deviation toward the ipsilesional side was observed in
lesioned rats. Thus, as shown in Fig. October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 4) Effect of the striatal lesion on obstacle avoidance Empty bars represent pre-lesion values and black bars post-lesion values (from day 4 to 60 post-lesion). Values are means6SD, * different
from pre-lesion values (P,0.025). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g005 was leading the crossing manoeuvre, obstacle avoidance was
impaired. In contrast, all the limbs crossed over obstacle normally
when the ispilesional forelimb was the first to encounter the
obstacle. The situation in which the contralesional forelimb was
the leading limb (limb 1) is illustrated in Fig. 6B and 6C. In this
situation, limb 1 either stepped on the obstacle and remained for
varying durations on the obstacle (unsuccessful crossings, Fig 6B)
or crossed over the obstacle normally (successful crossing, Fig 6C). When limb 1 badly performed obstacle crossing, limb 2 (forelimb
ipsilateral to the lesion) and limb 4 (hindlimb ipsilateral to the
lesion) successfully crossed over the obstacle. On the contrary, limb
3 (the leading contralesional hindlimb) either stepped on the
obstacle, successfully crossed over the obstacle, or took an extra
step before passing over the obstacle without touching it (see
bottom panel of Fig. 6B). In steps in which the leading
contralesional forelimb normally performed obstacle crossing,
the other limbs also crossed over obstacle normally (Fig.6C). Deficit in obstacle avoidance did not regress over the time. Indeed,
the
percentage
of
unsuccessful
crossings
with
the
leading
contralesional forelimb was 63.6612.2% at day 7 post-lesion
and 67.3613.2% at day 60 post-lesion. The corresponding values
for the leading contralesional hindlimb were 28.8611.1% and
24.769.5%. forelimb was not different from pre-lesion values (not shown). In
contrast, pre-obstacle distance of this limb was 10.460.6 cm when it
stepped on the obstacle (limb 1 in Fig 6B, above panel) whereas
distance (5.760.9 cm) was not different from pre-lesion value when
the limb overcame obstacle normally (limb 1 in Fig. 6C, above
panel). The bad placement of limb 1 was accompanied with a bad
placement of other limbs which were also placed farther away from
the front of the obstacle. However, the increase in pre-obstacle
distance was more important for limb 1 (, +200% vs , +30% for
other limbs) as shown in Fig. 6E and 6F. Finally, in steps in which
the contralesional forelimb was leading the crossing manoeuvre
with success (Fig. 6C) as in steps in which the ipsilesional forelimb
was leading (not shown), the trailed forelimb was placed farther
behind the obstacle as compared to limb position before lesion, at
least within the acute post-lesion period. 4) Effect of the striatal lesion on obstacle avoidance 5C, the roll angle was
23.2.063.5u and 22.663.0u at days 7 and 60 post-lesion,
respectively. In addition, the lesion produced a persistent shift of
the body towards the side opposite to the lesion (Fig. 5D) as
evidenced by the increased lateral shift angle from day 7
(6.462.1u) to day 60 post-lesion (5.268u) as compared to pre- d) Head and body orientation. The results are summarized
in Fig. 5C and 5D. Before lesion, the mean horizontal head-on-
trunk position was close to the mid-sagittal body axis as evidenced
by the value of the roll angle (0.562.2u). A substantial and long-
lasting deviation toward the ipsilesional side was observed in
lesioned rats. Thus, as shown in Fig. 5C, the roll angle was
23.2.063.5u and 22.663.0u at days 7 and 60 post-lesion,
respectively. In addition, the lesion produced a persistent shift of
the body towards the side opposite to the lesion (Fig. 5D) as
evidenced by the increased lateral shift angle from day 7
(6.462.1u) to day 60 post-lesion (5.268u) as compared to pre- After lesion, no preference for leading was observed either with
the contralesional or ipsilesional forelimb (data not shown). However, in the situation in which the contralesional forelimb PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 5 Striatum and Locomotion Figure 5. Effect of the lesion on paw placement in the frontal plane and head and body orientation. A) paw placement of forelimbs, B)
paw placement of the hindlimbs, C) horizontal head-on-trunk position, D) the lateral shift of the body. Positive values indicate deviation towards the
contralesional side and negative values towards the ipsilesional side. IFL, IHL = ipsilesional forelimb, hindlimb; CFL, CHL = contralesional forelimb,
hindlimb. Empty bars represent pre-lesion values and black bars post-lesion values (from day 4 to 60 post-lesion). Values are means6SD, * different
from pre-lesion values (P,0.025). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g005 Figure 5. Effect of the lesion on paw placement in the frontal plane and head and body orientation. A) paw placement of forelimbs, B)
paw placement of the hindlimbs, C) horizontal head-on-trunk position, D) the lateral shift of the body. Positive values indicate deviation towards the
contralesional side and negative values towards the ipsilesional side. IFL, IHL = ipsilesional forelimb, hindlimb; CFL, CHL = contralesional forelimb,
hindlimb. 4) Effect of the striatal lesion on obstacle avoidance Thus, post-obstacle
distance of limb 2 when it was the ipsilesional forelimb was
12.561 cm at day 7 (P,0.025) and 12.661 cm at day 60 (NS,
P = 0.027) vs 10.561.5 cm before lesion. On the contrary, maximal
elevation of limbs 3 and 4 was reached before and after the tip of the
paw had crossed over the obstacle, respectively. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Discussion The 3-D motion capture technology primarily dedicated to
human is a little-used method in rodents. Available studies
focussed on kinematics in normal conditions, after spinal lesion
or hindlimb [15–18]. Using this high-performing technology, our Unsuccessful crossings with the contralesional forelimb were
associated with a placement of the limb farther away from the front
of the obstacle and not with an inappropriate limb elevation. Indeed, maximal paw elevation of the leading contralesional October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 6 Striatum and Locomotion Figure 6. Obstacle avoidance-related parameters. A) before lesion, rats never touch the obstacle and used a strategy in which the first
(leading) hindlimb (limb 3) to step over obstacle is always ipsilateral to the leading forelimb (limb 1), B) when the contralesional leading forelimb
(limb 1) is placed farther away from the front of the obstacle, it steps on the obstacle (unsuccessfull crossing). The ipsilesional trailed forelimb (limb 2)
crosses over obstacle normaly whereas the contralesional leading hindlimb (limb 3) either steps on the obstacle or, crosses over obstacle normally
with or without an extrastep before crossing (bottom panel), C) when pre-obstacle distance of the contralesional leading forelimb is not different
from pre-lesion values, this limb performs obstacle crossing normally (successful crossing). In this situation, the trailed forelimb (limb 2) is placed
further behind the obstacle. D) Pre-lesion limb trajectory for a representative rat, E and F) pre-obstacle distances of the forelimbs (E) and the
hindlimbs (F) in situation in which the contralesional forelimb badly performs obstacle crossing. * different from BL (before lesion) values (P,0.025). Values of pre- and post-obstacle distances (cm) are mean6SD, in B and C, values correspond to those measured at day 60 post-lesion. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g006 Figure 6. Obstacle avoidance-related parameters. A) before lesion, rats never touch the obstacle and used a strategy in which the first
(leading) hindlimb (limb 3) to step over obstacle is always ipsilateral to the leading forelimb (limb 1), B) when the contralesional leading forelimb
(limb 1) is placed farther away from the front of the obstacle, it steps on the obstacle (unsuccessfull crossing). Discussion This suggests that the striatal lesion
has compromised the interaction of the three components involved
in the neural control of locomotion including CPGs, sensory
feedback, and descending supraspinal control. Despite the lack of
direct link between CPGs and the striatum, CPGs activity may be
indirectly dependent on striatal output. The striatum contains
GABAergic neurons that inhibit the SN pars reticulata [19], a brain
stem area recently demonstrated to exert tonic inhibition of the
mesencephalic locomotor region (MLR) [20], which contains the
reticulospinal neurons projecting on CPGs. Therefore, the striatal
lesion may produce an abnormal MLR inhibition, thus resulting in
a delayed production of locomotion [21] as well as troubles of the
rhythmic alternations of limbs [20]. Besides, regarding the sensory
processing ability of striatal neurons [22], changes in the sensory
control of locomotion may contribute to the observed deficit. Consistent with this mechanism, the motor responses to tactile and
proprioceptive stimuli on the contralateral limbs are transiently lost
after a striatal lesion [14,23]. study reveals persistent changes in the basic locomotor pattern and
obstacle avoidance performance after lesion of the striatum in rat. Within the first week following malonate administration, lesioned
rats did initiate treadmill locomotion but were unable to adapt limbs
motion with the speed of the treadmill belt, thus resulting in
treadmill running incapacity. This suggests that the striatal lesion
has compromised the interaction of the three components involved
in the neural control of locomotion including CPGs, sensory
feedback, and descending supraspinal control. Despite the lack of
direct link between CPGs and the striatum, CPGs activity may be
indirectly dependent on striatal output. The striatum contains
GABAergic neurons that inhibit the SN pars reticulata [19], a brain
stem area recently demonstrated to exert tonic inhibition of the
mesencephalic locomotor region (MLR) [20], which contains the
reticulospinal neurons projecting on CPGs. Therefore, the striatal
lesion may produce an abnormal MLR inhibition, thus resulting in
a delayed production of locomotion [21] as well as troubles of the
rhythmic alternations of limbs [20]. Besides, regarding the sensory
processing ability of striatal neurons [22], changes in the sensory
control of locomotion may contribute to the observed deficit. Consistent with this mechanism, the motor responses to tactile and
proprioceptive stimuli on the contralateral limbs are transiently lost
after a striatal lesion [14,23]. Discussion The ipsilesional trailed forelimb (limb 2)
crosses over obstacle normaly whereas the contralesional leading hindlimb (limb 3) either steps on the obstacle or, crosses over obstacle normally
with or without an extrastep before crossing (bottom panel), C) when pre-obstacle distance of the contralesional leading forelimb is not different
from pre-lesion values, this limb performs obstacle crossing normally (successful crossing). In this situation, the trailed forelimb (limb 2) is placed
further behind the obstacle. D) Pre-lesion limb trajectory for a representative rat, E and F) pre-obstacle distances of the forelimbs (E) and the
hindlimbs (F) in situation in which the contralesional forelimb badly performs obstacle crossing. * different from BL (before lesion) values (P,0.025). Values of pre- and post-obstacle distances (cm) are mean6SD, in B and C, values correspond to those measured at day 60 post-lesion. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g006 Whatever the mechanisms involved in the treadmill running
incapacity after a striatal lesion, all rats regained their ability to
regularly run on the treadmill from day 7 post-lesion, suggesting
that the intact neuronal circuitry can rapidly compensate for the
lesioned striatum when the striatum is engaged in the production
of the basic locomotor pattern. However, the neuroplasticity of
locomotor control mechanisms did not allow a full recovery of the
initial locomotor pattern as evidenced by the persistent increase in
the stance phase duration and in the stride length of the
contralesional forelimb and hindlimb, respectively. These data
argue that the integrity of the striatum is required for the structure
and the timing of the basic locomotor pattern as suggested by a
recent study that specifically examined the relationship between
lesion location and gait asymmetry in ambulatory chronic stroke
patients [24]. The authors report that lesion to putamen is evident
60% to 80% more frequently in the asymmetrical patients
compared to the symmetrical patients. Further studies are needed
to elucidate how the striatum contributes to the basic locomotor
pattern knowing that hypermetry of the contralesional hindlimb is
also observed after unilateral pyramidal tract section [25] but not
after lesion of the somatosensory cortex [26] in the rat. study reveals persistent changes in the basic locomotor pattern and
obstacle avoidance performance after lesion of the striatum in rat. Within the first week following malonate administration, lesioned
rats did initiate treadmill locomotion but were unable to adapt limbs
motion with the speed of the treadmill belt, thus resulting in
treadmill running incapacity. October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 Discussion Nevertheless,
since the corticospinal fibres course through the striatum in rats, it
is relevant to ask whether some aspects of the observed deficits are
attributable to impaired structural or functional integrity of these
fibres. Against the existence of structural damage is the normal
appearance of the fibres after lesion induced by malonate or the
other neurotoxin quinolinic acid [48,49]. However, this does not
mean that functionality of the fibres is not impaired. Functionality
of the corticospinal tract has never been investigated after
malonate lesions but is spared after quinolinic lesions [50]. Regarding the similarities between malonate and quinolinic lesions
with respect to histological characterization [51], it is tempting to
speculate that functionality of the corticospinal pathway is normal
after malonate lesions, and that deficit after malonate lesions is not
due to changes in corticospinal outflow. In accordance with this
hypothesis, walking performance is not associated with the extent
of lesion overlap with the corticospinal tract in stroke patients [52],
and differences exist between deficit induced by lesion of the
corticospinal tract and that induced by lesion of the striatum. Stereotyped locomotion is possible as soon as the first day
following lesion to the corticospinal tract and most impairments in
kinematics and ground reaction forces recover rapidly within the
first week after operation [25,53]. In contrast, treadmill running is
impossible during the first three days after malonate, and
locomotor behaviour is impaired persistently after malonate. In
addition, the contralesional forelimb which badly performs
obstacle crossing after striatal lesion (our results) was reported to
cross
over
obstacle
normally
after
pyramidal
lesions
[45]. Nevertheless, further studies are needed to prove that deficit after
malonate is not due in part to damage of the corticospinal fibres. Obstacle avoidance tasks provide an adequate paradigm to
explore the possibility to deal with environmental constraints by
the voluntary modification of the basic locomotor pattern. To
date, information on obstacle avoidance in human and animals
(cats only) with a central lesion are scarce. In addition, available
studies focussed on the role of the cerebral cortex and the
cerebellum. It was demonstrated that the cerebellum and the
motor cortex both contribute to adequate paw placement and limb
trajectory [33,34] and that the posterior parietal cortex is rather
involved in planning gait modification [35]. Discussion During stereotyped locomotion, lesioned rats showed abnormal
posture as evidenced by the persistent lateral tilting of their body October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 7 Striatum and Locomotion towards the side opposite to the lesion as well as the overflexion of
their contralesional limbs. These data are in agreement with the
emergent theory that the output nuclei of the basal ganglia (the SN
pars reticulata, the globus pallidus, the ventral pallidum) keep
the brainstem areas that control posture under tonic inhibition
[27–29]. However, pathological asymmetry of postural muscle
tone regulation is not necessarily the cause of the shift of the body. The shift may be alternatively an attempt to align the body with a
vertical reference which should be erroneously perceived to be
tilted from true earth vertical in lesioned rats. Evidence that the
striatum filters information that originates within the parietal
cortex, a structure that has a critical role in the perception of the
verticality [30] supports this hypothesis. Interestingly, the shift of
the body is towards the contralesional side in stroke patients with a
striatal lesion [31], but towards the ipsilesional side in hemi-
parkinsonian rats [32]. Accordingly, lesions of the striatum and
striatal dopamine depletion both produce abnormal posture, yet
through different mechanisms. locomotion. The striatum is thought to select which motor
programs should be called into action through multiple cortico-
striato-pallido-thalamo-cortical loops. However, the hypothesis that
striatal lesion-associated impaired obstacle avoidance solely reflects
disconnection between the striatum and the cortical areas is
unlikely. Indeed, in cats with lesions of the motor or the parietal
cortex, the contralesional limbs badly performed obstacle crossing
when they are the leading or the trailed limbs [44–46], and
hemiplegic stroke patients with unilateral cortical lesion exhibit
impaired ability to avoid obstacle regardless of whether the
avoidance manoeuvre is led by the affected or unaffected leg [47]. Moreover, as patients with PD perform as well as aged matched
controls [12] in obstacle avoidance tasks, the disconnection between
the striatum and the SN pars compacta cannot either be involved in
unsuccessful obstacle crossing observed after lesion of the striatum. g
Malonate is considered as a selective neurotoxin. Discussion They also suggest that the intact neuronal circuitry cannot
spontaneously compensate for the lesioned striatum, at least when
the (dorsal) striatum is fully lesioned. Techniques and data described
here are likely to be useful for a better comprehension of the neural
pathways involved in the regulation of stereotyped and challenged
locomotion, and for the guidance of new therapeutic interventions
in pathologies associated with impaired gait. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Discussion The new finding of
the present study is that the integrity of the striatum is required to
successful obstacle avoidance (as a second subtask added to
locomotion), and that intact neuronal circuitry cannot spontane-
ously compensate for the lesioned striatum when the structure is
engaged in challenged locomotion. Our results show that limbs
contralateral to the striatal lesion badly perform obstacle crossing
from day 4 to 60 post-lesion in the situation in which the
contralesional limb is the first to encounter obstacle. The limbs
step on the obstacle and remain for varying durations on the
obstacle rather than to overcome obstacle without touching it. An
asymmetrical deficit in limbs force production appears to be not
involved in deficit because contralesional limbs normally crossed
over obstacle when they were the second to encounter the
obstacle. Alternatively, impaired performance may be related to
persistent hemispatial neglect. Actually, the head of lesioned rats
was orientated towards the side of the lesion (see also [36] similarly
to that observed in hemiparkinsonian animals [37–39] and stroke
patients (‘‘Pre´vost’s’’ sign). This abnormal head orientation leads
to the neglect of information on the contralesional side [40,41]. Because visual input is critical to successful obstacle avoidance
with the leading limbs [42], the hemispatial neglect of the right
side may therefore explain why only the right limbs stepped on the
obstacle after lesion of the left striatum. However, the hindlimb
that is moved in the absence of direct visual input also badly
performs obstacle crossing, suggesting that mechanisms other than
hemispatial neglect also contribute to the impaired performance. Of note, impaired performance in obstacle avoidance is observed
even in stroke patients without hemispatial neglect [43]. With an
effort to identify the causes of unsuccessful crossings, we have
measured the position of the leading forelimb with respect to the
obstacle as well as its trajectory as measured by the maximal
elevation of limbs during the crossing swing. The results clearly
show that unsuccessful crossing is associated with increased pre-
obstacle distance and not with inappropriate limb trajectory. Th
d t
t
i
t
t
l
f th
t i t
i
th In conclusion, our results argue that the striatum of one
hemisphere controls kinematics of contralateral limbs during
stereotyped locomotion and plays a prominent role in the selection
of the right motor program so that these limbs successfully cross over
obstacle. Kinematics recordings The 3D kinematics data were collected using the VICON MX-
13 optical motion capture system (Vicon, Oxford, Great Britain)
consisting of 6 high-speed digital cameras placed at approximately
0.7 m from the treadmill. Three cameras were placed facing the
rat’s left side and three other cameras facing the rat’s right side,
perpendicular to the direction of the movement, thus allowing the
simultaneous recording of the two hemi-bodies. Data were
collected at a sampling rate of 200 Hz. The image dimension
was 128061024 pixels. The magnification of the cameras was
calibrated to cover the 45 cm length of the treadmill apparatus. Figure 7. Position of the reflective markers and kinematics
parameters in rats. A and B) five markers were placed on each
hindlimb, four markers on each forelimb and four markers (1 to 4) on
the back, C) the paw placement of the ipsilesional and contralesional
hindlimb (IHL, CHL) in the frontal plane was assessed from the position
at toe off of the MCP marker (marker i) on the Z-axis (mediolateral) with
respect to the Y-axis (vertical) that passed through the hip marker
(marker f), D) the horizontal head-on-trunk position was assessed from
the roll angle, i.e. the angle between the straight line passing through
the dorsal markers 1 and 2 and that passing through the dorsal markers
3 and 4, E) the lateral tilt of the body was assessed from the angle
between the plane (in grey) passing through the two hip markers (f)
and the two shoulder markers (a) and the horizontal plane of the
laboratory (not indicated). d i 10 1371/j
l
0007616 007 After anaesthesia (chloral hydrate, 400 mg/kg, i.p.) the limbs
and the back were shaved and tattooed in order to locate the bony
processes as previously described in details [15]. The area around
the tattoo marks was regularly shaved and re-touched with
permanent ink as soon as tattoo fading was observed. For this step,
anaesthesia of animals that were now confident with the
experimenter was not required. Animals Experiments were carried out on Wistar adult male rats (Depre´,
Saint-Doulchard, France) with age of 13 weeks. All procedures
were approved by the ethical committee of the Universite´ de
Bourgogne and were conducted according to guidelines of the These data suggest an important role of the striatum in the
planning rather than execution of the voluntary modification of October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 8 Striatum and Locomotion Figure 7. Position of the reflective markers and kinematics
parameters in rats. A and B) five markers were placed on each
hindlimb, four markers on each forelimb and four markers (1 to 4) on
the back, C) the paw placement of the ipsilesional and contralesional
hindlimb (IHL, CHL) in the frontal plane was assessed from the position
at toe off of the MCP marker (marker i) on the Z-axis (mediolateral) with
respect to the Y-axis (vertical) that passed through the hip marker
(marker f), D) the horizontal head-on-trunk position was assessed from
the roll angle, i.e. the angle between the straight line passing through
the dorsal markers 1 and 2 and that passing through the dorsal markers
3 and 4, E) the lateral tilt of the body was assessed from the angle
between the plane (in grey) passing through the two hip markers (f)
and the two shoulder markers (a) and the horizontal plane of the
laboratory (not indicated). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g007 French department of agriculture (licence nu 21CAE101). Animals
kept in ventilated, humidity and temperature-controlled rooms
with a 12/12-h light/dark cycle received food and water ad libitum. To reduce the animal’s stress level, the same operator performed
all steps of the experiments. Selection of animals Rats were selected according to their capacity of running
regularly on a horizontal treadmill (Bioseb, Vitrolles, France) with
the speed of the treadmill belt fixed at 25 cm/s. A 3 min-long
running session (first without obstacles and then with obstacles
attached to the belt) was given twice a day for seven days. On the
first day, mild intensities of foot shocks were used as negative
reinforcement to improve performance. Rats that failed to run in a
regular way on the treadmill (contact of the forelimbs with the
front wall of the treadmill, frequent immobility or gallop) at the
end of the selection period were excluded. It is noteworthy that
obstacle clearance was not a difficulty for any of the rats. Induction of the lesion A lesion confined to the caudoputamen was induced by the
direct injection of the mitochondrial toxin malonate (disodium salt,
Sigma, Saint Quentin Fallavier, France) into the left striatum. Briefly, rats were anaesthetized with chloral hydrate (400 mg/kg,
i.p.) and positioned in a stereotaxic frame. Injection of malonate
(pH 7.4) was performed into the left striatum via a cannula
inserted at the following coordinates relative to bregma: AP:
0.5 mm, Lat: 3.5 mm, V: 6 mm from the skull (Paxinos &
Watsons’ atlas). Injection of malonate (3 mmol) was carried out
over 3 min at a rate of 1 mL/min. According to this dosage, the
lesion measured at day 1 after malonate poisoning affects the
whole caudoputamen [14,54]. It can be noticed here that the
malonate lesion is a pannecrotic lesion and has revealed striking
similarities to the lesion induced by ischemic stroke with respect to
histological characterization [51]. Histological study The lesion volume and the amount of histologically intact
residual brain tissue were measured at the end of the experiment. After anaesthesia (chloral hydrate, 400 mg/kg, i.p.), rats were
subjected to a transcardial perfusion with saline followed by a
perfusion with paraformaldehyde (4% in phosphate buffer). Then,
the brains were removed, postfixed for 30 min in paraformalde-
hyde, submerged for 36 h in 20% sucrose at 4uC, and frozen in
isopentane (240uC). Coronal sections (20 mm, 200 mm apart, and
starting +2.2 mm to bregma and extending back to 23.6 mm to
bregma) were collected on SuperFrost slides and stained with
Cresyl violet (0.4%). Histological measurements were performed
on sections using an image analyzing system (Scion Image, NIH,
Bethesda, MD, USA). The areas of the lesion, the cavitations
within parenchyma, the ventricles and the entire hemispheres
were measured by contour tracing these regions on the computer
screen. Corresponding volumes were calculated as the product of
the sum of the areas and the distance between sections. Tissue loss
induced by malonate poisoning corresponded to the difference in
the amount of histologically intact residual tissue between the
lesioned and the unlesioned hemispheres. –
stance and swing phases duration, and stride duration (time in
milliseconds between two successive foot contacts of the same
limb), –
stance and swing phases duration, and stride duration (time in
milliseconds between two successive foot contacts of the same
limb), –
temporal symmetry ratio (TSR) of gait, a salient index of gait
dysfunction in human stroke [57] was calculated for each of the
locomotor cycles using the following equation: Acknowledgments –
lateral tilt of the body. This parameter was assessed from the
measurement of the lateral tilted angle, i.e. the angle between the
horizontal plane of the laboratory and the plane passing through
the two hip markers and the two shoulder markers (see Fig.7E). A positive angular value indicates a tilt toward the right side. We thank doctor Philippe d’Athis for his help in statistical analysis of data. Numerical analysis –
the maximal height of the more distal marker during the
crossing swing. –
the maximal height of the more distal marker during the
crossing swing. The step cycle was split into two parts, the stance and the swing
phase. The stance phase was defined as the part of the cycle that
begins as soon as the foot contacts the treadmill belt and
terminates when the foot starts its forward movement (i.e. when
the velocity of the MTP markers was higher than a threshold fixed
at 5% of its maximal velocity). The swing phase was considered to
begin at the onset of forward movement and to end when the foot
strikes the treadmill belt. Using a MATLAB program (Math-
Works, Natick, USA), we measured the following locomotor-
related parameters: The parameters of stereotyped locomotion were calculated for
15 step cycles with at least four regular and consecutive step cycles
during each trial in order to eliminate deviant curves [58]. The
parameters used for assessing obstacle avoidance were calculated
for 25 obstacle crossings with at least four consecutive crossings. Striatum and Locomotion –
pre-obstacle distance: the distance between the obstacle and
the tip of the paw just before the crossing swing, –
pre-obstacle distance: the distance between the obstacle and
the tip of the paw just before the crossing swing, hip marker and the knee marker or between the knee marker and
the ankle marker were measured before and after lesion to the
striatum. In the present study, locomotion without obstacle
attached to the treadmill belt is referred to as stereotyped
locomotion whereas locomotion with obstacles attached to the
belt to as challenged locomotion. –
post-obstacle distance: the distance between the obstacle and
the tip of the paw just at crossing swing ending, –
time to avoid obstacle, i.e. the duration of successful crossing
swings (from the toe-off before obstacle to the paw contact after
obstacle), TSR ~ contralateral
swing duration=stance duration
ipsilateral
swing duration=stance duration –
stride length was computed as the Euclidian distance (mm) of
the more distal markers (MTP for the hindlimbs, MTC for the
forelimbs) between the beginning of the swing phase and the
next contact with the treadmill belt. The reference frame was
fixed to the hip marker, –
interlimb coordination. We calculated the homologous,
homolateral and diagonal coupling from the time of the paw
contact of a given limb with respect to the step cycle of the limb
of the same girdle, of the same side, and of the diagonal limb,
respectively, Statistical analysis Data are expressed as mean6SD. Statistics were performed
using the 9.0 version of SYSTAT (Systat Software, Inc, Chicago,
USA). Friedman’s non parametric test was used to detect a global
difference between kinematic recordings. If the P value was below
0.5, we compared data collected at days 7 and 60 post-lesion with
those collected before lesion using Wilcoxon’s test two times with
Bonferroni’s procedure. Such a small set of planned comparisons
should increase only slightly the type I error risk as compared to
more numerous planned comparisons. If these comparisons were
both significant (P,0.025), it was concluded that lesions produced
persistent impairment in kinematics. If only the comparison at day
7 post-lesion was significant (P,0.025), the impairment was
suggested to regress over time. If only the comparison at day 60
post-lesion
was
significant
(P,0.025),
a
delayed
kinematic
impairment was suggested. –
maximal (Max) and minimal (Min) values of joint angles during
the stance and the swing phases, –
paw placement of the more distal marker of limbs at toe off in the
frontal plan. For the hindlimb (see Fig.7C), this parameter
corresponds to the position of the MCP marker (marker i) on the
Z-axis (mediolateral) with respect to the Y-axis (vertical) that
passes through the hip marker (marker f). For the forelimbs, it
corresponds to the position of the MTP marker on the Z-axis
with respect to the Y-axis that passes through the shoulder, –
horizontal head-on-trunk position. This parameter was assess-
ed from the measurement of the roll angle, i.e. the angle
between the straight line passing through the dorsal markers 1
and 2 and that passing through the dorsal markers 3 and 4 (see
Fig.7D). A positive angle indicates a deviation of the head
towards the right side, Kinematics recordings Twenty two infrared-reflective
hemispherical markers (BTS Bioengineering, Cod FMK0005,
Milano, Italy) with a diameter of 6 mm were placed over the
following anatomical landmarks (see Fig.7A, B): the scapula
(marker a), the upper (shoulder marker b) and lower (elbow marker
c) humerus epiphysis, the metacarpophalangeal (MTC) joint
(marker d), the iliac crest (marker e), the great trochanter (hip
marker f), the knee (marker g), the internal malleolus (ankle marker
h) and the fifth metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint (marker i). Four
markers (markers 1, 2, 3 and 4) were also placed on the back from
the neck to the tail at regular distances. Finally, two markers were doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0007616.g007 placed on the base of each of the two obstacles. Markers were fixed
on rat and obstacles with a double face adhesive tape. The kinematic data were collected with the speed of the
treadmill belt fixed at 25 cm/s, a speed that is within the range of
speed of rat’s overground locomotion [55]. Stereotyped locomo-
tion was first assessed in a 1-min long session (3620 sec). Then,
two obstacles (3 cm high, 1.2 cm wide) separated by 45 cm were
attached to the treadmill belt and data were again recorded in a 3-
min long session (361 min). Soft tissue movement around the knee
(skin slippage) is a source of error when estimating joint kinematics
of hindlimbs in rats from markers placed on the surface of the
body overlying joints [56]. Therefore, mean distance between the PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 9 Striatum and Locomotion PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org References Arch Phys Med Rehabil 80: 1054–9. 15. Thota AK, Watson SC, Knapp E, Thompson B, Jung R (2005) Neuromecha-
nical control of locomotion in the rat. J Neurotrauma 22: 442–65. 44. Drew T, Jiang W, Kably B, Lavoie S (1996) Role of the motor cortex in the
control of visually triggered gait modifications. Can J Physiol Pharmacol 74:
426–42. 16. Garnier C, Falempin M, Canu MH (2008) A 3D analysis of fore- and hindlimb
motion during locomotion: comparison of overground and ladder walking in
rats. Behav Brain Res 186: 57–65. 45. Drew T, Jiang W, Widajewicz W (2002) Contributions of the motor cortex to the
control of the hindlimbs during locomotion in the cat. Brain Res Brain Res Rev
40: 178–91. 17. Courtine G, Song B, Roy RR, Zhong H, Herrmann JE, et al. (2008) Recovery of
supraspinal control of stepping via indirect propriospinal relay connections after
spinal cord injury. Nat Med 14: 69–74. 46. Lajoie K, Drew T (2007) Lesions of area 5 of the posterior parietal cortex in the
cat produce errors in the accuracy of paw placement during visually guided
locomotion. J Neurophysiol 97: 2339–2354. 18. Couto PA, Filipe VM, Magalhaes LG, Pereira JE, Costa LM, et al. (2008) A
comparison of two-dimensional and three-dimensional techniques for the
determination of hindlimb kinematics during treadmill locomotion in rats
following spinal cord injury. J Neurosci Methods 173: 193–200. 47. Den Otter AR, Geurts AC, de Haart M, Mulder T, Duysens J (2005) Step
characteristics during obstacle avoidance in hemiplegic stroke. Exp Brain Res
161: 180–92. 19. Deniau JM, Menetrey A, Charpier S (1996) The lamellar organization of the rat
substantia nigra pars reticulata: segregated patterns of striatal afferents and
relationship to the topography of corticostriatal projections. Neuroscience 73:
761–81. 48. Schwarcz R, Whetsell WO, Jr., Mangano RM (1983) Quinolinic acid: an
endogenous metabolite that produces axon-sparing lesions in rat brain. Science
219: 316–318. 49. Greene JG, Porter RH, Eller RV, Greenamyre JT (1993) Inhibition of succinate
dehydrogenase by malonic acid produces an ‘‘excitotoxic’’ lesion in rat striatum. J Neurochem 61: 1151–1154. 20. Takakusaki K, Habaguchi T, Ohtinata-Sugimoto J, Saitoh K, Sakamoto T
(2003) Basal ganglia efferents to the brainstem centers controlling postural
muscle tone and locomotion: a new concept for understanding motor disorders
in basal ganglia dysfunction. Neuroscience 119: 293–308. 50. References Karl JM, Sacrey LA, McDonald RJ, Whishaw IQ (2008) Intact intracortical
microstimulation (ICMS) representations of rostral and caudal forelimb areas in
rats with quinolinic acid lesions of the medial or lateral caudate-putamen in an
animal model of Huntington’s disease. Brain Res Bull 77: 42–48. g
g
y
21. Garcia-Rill E (1986) The basal ganglia and the locomotor regions. Brain Res
396: 47–63. 22. Brown LL (1992) Somatotopic organization in rat striatum: evidence for a
combinational map. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 89: 7403–7. 51. Greene JG, Greenamyre JT (1996) Manipulation of membrane potential
modulates malonate-induced striatal excitotoxicity in vivo. J Neurochem 66:
637–43. p
23. Marshall JF, Berrios N, Sawyer S (1980) Neostriatal dopamine and sensory
inattention. J Comp Physiol Psychol 94: 833–846. 52. Dawes H, Enzinger C, Johansen-Berg H, Bogdanovic M, Guy C, et al. (2008)
Walking performance and its recovery in chronic stroke in relation to extent of
lesion overlap with the descending motor tract. Exp Brain Res 186: 325–333. 24. Alexander LD, Black SE, Patterson KK, Gao F, Danells CJ, et al. (2009)
Association between gait asymmetry and brain lesion location in stroke patients. Stroke 40: 537–44. 25. Metz GA, Dietz V, Schwab ME, van de Meent H (1998) The effects of unilateral
pyramidal tract section on hindlimb motor performance in the rat. Behav Brain
Res 96: 37–46. 53. Muir GD, Whishaw IQ (1999) Complete locomotor recovery following
corticospinal tract lesions: measurement of ground reaction forces during
overground locomotion in rats. Behav Brain Res 103: 45–53. 26. Wang Y, Bontempi B, Hong SM, Mehta K, Weinstein PR, et al. (2008) A
comprehensive analysis of gait impairment after experimental stroke and the
therapeutic effect of environmental enrichment in rats. J Cereb Blood Flow
Metab 28: 1936–50. 54. Demougeot C, Garnier P, Mossiat C, Bertrand N, Giroud M, et al. (2001) N-
Acetylaspartate, a marker of both cellular dysfunction and neuronal loss: its
relevance to studies of acute brain injury. J Neurochem 77: 408–15. 55. Clarke KA, Parker AJ (1986) A quantitative study of normal locomotion in the
rat. Physiol Behav 38: 345–51. 27. Grillner S, Hellgren J, Menard A, Saitoh K, Wikstrom MA (2005) Mechanisms
for selection of basic motor programs–roles for the striatum and pallidum. Trends Neurosci 28: 364–70. 56. Filipe VM, Pereira JE, Costa LM, Mauricio AC, Couto PA, et al. References 31. Lafosse C, Kerckhofs E, Troch M, Santens P, Vandenbussche E (2004)
Graviceptive misperception of the postural vertical after right hemisphere
damage. Neuroreport 15: 887–891. 1. Rossignol S, Dubuc R, Gossard JP (2006) Dynamic sensorimotor interactions in
locomotion. Physiol Rev 86: 89–154. y
2. Takakusaki K (2008) Forebrain control of locomotor behaviors. Brain Res Rev
57: 192–198. 32. Miklyaeva EI, Martens DJ, Whishaw IQ (1995) Impairments and compensatory
adjustments in spontaneous movement after unilateral dopamine depletion in
rats. Brain Res 681: 23–40. 3. Alexander GE, Crutcher MD, DeLong MR (1990) Basal ganglia-thalamocor-
tical circuits: parallel substrates for motor, oculomotor, ‘‘prefrontal’’ and
‘‘limbic’’ functions. Prog Brain Res 85: 119–146. 33. Armstrong DM, Marple-Horvat DE (1996) Role of the cerebellum and motor
cortex in the regulation of visually controlled locomotion. Can J Physiol
Pharmacol 74: 443–455. g
4. Bhatia KP, Marsden CD (1994) The behavioural and motor consequences of
focal lesions of the basal ganglia in man. Brain 117 (Pt 4): 859–876. 4. Bhatia KP, Marsden CD (1994) The behavioural and motor consequences of
focal lesions of the basal ganglia in man. Brain 117 (Pt 4): 859–876. focal lesions of the basal ganglia in man. Brain 117 (Pt 4): 859–876 5. Benecke R, Rothwell JC, Dick JP, Day BL, Marsden CD (1987) Disturbance of
sequential movements in patients with Parkinson’s disease. Brain 110 (Pt 2):
361–379. 34. Drew T, Andujar JE, Lajoie K, Yakovenko S (2008) Cortical mechanisms
involved in visuomotor coordination during precision walking. Brain Res Rev
57: 199–211. sequential movements in patients with Parkinson’s disease. Brain 110 (Pt 2):
361–379. 6. DeLong MR (1990) Primate models of movement disorders of basal ganglia
origin. Trends Neurosci 13: 281–285. 35. Lajoie K, Drew T (2007) Lesions of area 5 of the posterior parietal cortex in the
cat produce errors in the accuracy of paw placement during visually guided
locomotion. J Neurophysiol 97: 2339–54. 7. Brown LL, Schneider JS, Lidsky TI (1997) Sensory and cognitive functions of
the basal ganglia. Curr Opin Neurobiol 7: 157–163. the basal ganglia. Curr Opin Neurobiol 7: 157–163 36. Hebb MO, Robertson HA (1999) Synergistic influences of the striatum and the
globus pallidus on postural and locomotor control. Neuroscience 90: 413–421. 8. Seitz RJ, Roland PE (1992) Learning of Sequential Finger Movements in Man:
A Combined Kinematic and Positron Emission Tomography (PET) Study. Eur J Neurosci 4: 154–65. 37. Striatum and Locomotion Striatum and Locomotion Striatum and Locomotion References Schallert T, Upchurch M, Wilcox RE, Vaughn DM (1983) Posture-independent
sensorimotor analysis of inter-hemispheric receptor asymmetries in neostriatum. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 18: 753–759. J
9. Middleton FA, Strick PL (2000) Basal ganglia and cerebellar loops: motor and
cognitive circuits. Brain Res Brain Res Rev 31: 236–250. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 18: 753–759. 38. Henderson JM, Stanic D, Tomas D, Patch J, Horne MK, et al. (2005) Postural
changes after lesions of the substantia nigra pars reticulata in hemiparkinsonian
monkeys. Behav Brain Res 160: 267–276. g
10. Shi LH, Luo F, Woodward DJ, Chang JY (2004) Neural responses in multiple
basal ganglia regions during spontaneous and treadmill locomotion tasks in rats. Exp Brain Res 157: 303–314. 39. Da Cunha C, Wietzikoski EC, Ferro MM, Martinez GR, Vital MA, et al. (2008)
Hemiparkinsonian rats rotate toward the side with the weaker dopaminergic
neurotransmission. Behav Brain Res 189: 364–372. p
11. Wagner J, Stephan T, Kalla R, Bruckmann H, Strupp M, et al. (2008) Mind the
bend: cerebral activations associated with mental imagery of walking along a
curved path. Exp Brain Res 191: 247–55. 40. Miyashita N, Hikosaka O, Kato M (1995) Visual hemineglect induced by
unilateral striatal dopamine deficiency in monkeys. Neuroreport 6: 1257–60. p
p
12. Dietz V, Michel J (2008) Locomotion in Parkinson’s disease: neuronal coupling
of upper and lower limbs. Brain 131: 3421–31. 41. Fruhmann Berger M, Pross RD, Ilg UJ, Karnath HO (2006) Deviation of eyes
and head in acute cerebral stroke. BMC Neurol 6: 23. 13. Bezard E, Gross CE, Brotchie JM (2003) Presymptomatic compensation in
Parkinson’s disease is not dopamine-mediated. Trends Neurosci 26: 215–221. and head in acute cerebral stroke. BMC Neurol 6: 23. 42. Sparrow WA, Shinkfield Alison J, Chow S, Begg RK (1996) Characteristics of 42. Sparrow WA, Shinkfield Alison J, Chow S, Begg RK (1996) Characteristics o
gait in stepping over obstacles. Human Movement Science 15: 605–622. 14. Millerot-Serrurot E, Chausset A, Mossiat C, Prigent-Tessier A, Bertrand N,
et al. (2007) Effect of early decrease in the lesion size on late brain tissue loss,
synaptophysin expression and functionality after a focal brain lesion in rats. Neurochem Int 50: 328–35. 42. Sparrow WA, Shinkfield Alison J, Chow S, Begg RK (1996) Characteristics of
gait in stepping over obstacles. Human Movement Science 15: 605–622. g
pp g
43. Said CM, Goldie PA, Patla AE, Sparrow WA, Martin KE (1999) Obstacle
crossing in subjects with stroke. Author Contributions Conceived and designed the experiments: TP CM. Performed the
experiments: OP DL. Analyzed the data: OP DL TP CM. Contributed
reagents/materials/analysis tools: TP CM. Wrote the paper: CM. We also measured the following obstacle avoidance-related
parameters: October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 10 References (2006) Effect of
skin movement on the analysis of hindlimb kinematics during treadmill
locomotion in rats. J Neurosci Methods 153: 55–61. 28. Hikosaka O (2007) GABAergic output of the basal ganglia. Prog Brain Res 160:
209–226. 57. Patterson KK, Parafianowicz I, Danells CJ, Closson V, Verrier MC, et al. (2008)
Gait asymmetry in community-ambulating stroke survivors. Arch Phys Med
Rehabil 89: 304–10. 29. Takakusaki K (2009) [Motor control by the basal ganglia]. Rinsho Shinkeigaku
49: 325–334. 30. Perennou DA, Mazibrada G, Chauvineau V, Greenwood R, Rothwell J, et al. (2008) Lateropulsion, pushing and verticality perception in hemisphere stroke: a
causal relationship? Brain 131: 2401–13. 58. Duhamel A, Bourriez JL, Devos P, Krystkowiak P, Destee A, et al. (2004)
Statistical tools for clinical gait analysis. Gait Posture 20: 204–12. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org October 2009 | Volume 4 | Issue 10 | e7616 11
|
https://openalex.org/W2565257577
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc5192336?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
Role of Uric Acid Metabolism-Related Inflammation in the Pathogenesis of Metabolic Syndrome Components Such as Atherosclerosis and Nonalcoholic Steatohepatitis
|
Mediators of inflammation
| 2,016
|
cc-by
| 13,338
|
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Mediators of Inflammation
Volume 2016, Article ID 8603164, 15 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2016/8603164 Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Mediators of Inflammation
Volume 2016, Article ID 8603164, 15 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2016/8603164 Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Mediators of Inflammation
Volume 2016, Article ID 8603164, 15 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2016/8603164 1Division of Diabetes and Metabolism, Institute for Adult Disease, Asahi Life Foundation, 1-6-1 Marunouchi,
Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo, Japan y
y
p
2Department of Medical Science, Graduate School of Medicine, Hiroshima University, 1-2-3 Kasumi,
Minami-ku, Hiroshima City, Hiroshima, Japan 3Division of Neurology, Respirology, Endocrinology and Metabolism, Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine,
University of Miyazaki, Miyazaki 889-1692, Japan 3Division of Neurology, Respirology, Endocrinology and Metabolism, Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of Medicine,
University of Miyazaki, Miyazaki 889-1692, Japan 4Department of Internal Medicine, Graduate School of Medicine, University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan
5Department of Endocrinology and Diabetes, School of Medicine, Saitama Medical University, Moroyama, Saitama 350-0495, Japan 4Department of Internal Medicine, Graduate School of Medicine, University of Tokyo, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan
5Department of Endocrinology and Diabetes, School of Medicine, Saitama Medical University, Moroyama, Saitama 350-0495, Japan Correspondence should be addressed to Akifumi Kushiyama; kusiyaa-tky@umin.ac. Correspondence should be addressed to Akifumi Kushiyama; kusiyaa-tky@umin.ac.jp Correspondence should be addressed to Akifumi Kushiyama; kusiyaa-tky@umin.ac.jp Received 18 September 2016; Revised 3 November 2016; Accepted 15 November 2016 Academic Editor: Jie Yin Academic Editor: Jie Yin Copyright © 2016 Akifumi Kushiyama et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly
cited. Uric acid (UA) is the end product of purine metabolism and can reportedly act as an antioxidant. However, recently, numerous
clinical and basic research approaches have revealed close associations of hyperuricemia with several disorders, particularly those
comprising the metabolic syndrome. In this review, we first outline the two molecular mechanisms underlying inflammation occur-
rence in relation to UA metabolism; one is inflammasome activation by UA crystallization and the other involves superoxide free
radicals generated by xanthine oxidase (XO). Importantly, recent studies have demonstrated the therapeutic or preventive effects of
XO inhibitors against atherosclerosis and nonalcoholic steatohepatitis, which were not previously considered to be related, at least
not directly, to hyperuricemia. Such beneficial effects of XO inhibitors have been reported for other organs including the kidneys
and the heart. Thus, a major portion of this review focuses on the relationships between UA metabolism and the development
of atherosclerosis, nonalcoholic steatohepatitis, and related disorders. Although further studies are necessary, XO inhibitors are a
potentially novel strategy for reducing the risk of many forms of organ failure characteristic of the metabolic syndrome. Akifumi Kushiyama,1 Yusuke Nakatsu,2 Yasuka Matsunaga,2
Takeshi Yamamotoya,2 Keiichi Mori,2 Koji Ueda,2 Yuki Inoue,2 Hideyuki Sakoda,3
Midori Fujishiro,4 Hiraku Ono,5 and Tomoichiro Asano2 Akifumi Kushiyama,1 Yusuke Nakatsu,2 Yasuka Matsunaga,2
Takeshi Yamamotoya,2 Keiichi Mori,2 Koji Ueda,2 Yuki Inoue,2 Hideyuki Sakoda,3
Midori Fujishiro,4 Hiraku Ono,5 and Tomoichiro Asano2 1. Introduction hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HGPRT)
plays an important role in generating IMP, thereby inhibiting
UA generation. Uric acid (UA) is the end product of the metabolic path-
way for purines, the main constituents of nucleotides. The
pathway of UA generation is shown in Figure 1. Briefly,
inosine monophosphate (IMP) is derived from de novo
purine synthesis and from purine salvage. Hypoxanthine
from IMP is catalyzed to xanthine and then to uric acid by
xanthine oxidase (XO). De novo nucleotide synthesis gener-
ates IMP via ribose-5-phosphate, catalyzed to 5-phosphor-
ibosyl-1-pyrophosphate (PRPP). In the salvage pathway, Since humans are unable to catabolize UA to the more
soluble compound allantoin due to lack of urate oxidase or
uricase [1], the serum UA concentration is higher in humans
than almost all other mammals. However, this high UA level
in humans has been regarded as being beneficial in the
presence of elevated oxidative stress [2]. UA is oxidized to
allantoin and other metabolites via nonenzymatic oxidation 2 2 Mediators of Inflammation UA metabolic route
Purine intake
Purine
degradation
De novo pathway
ATP
Alcohol intake
Insulin
Glucose
Glycogen
−ATP
−ATP
Glucose 6-phosphate
Ribose 5-phosphate
Fructose intake
Fructose
Fructose
−ATP
6-phosphate
−ATP
PRPP synthetase
Phosphoribosyl diphosphate (PRPP)
ATPase
ADP
GMP
Glyceraldehyde
3-phosphate
GDP
GTP
Adenine
Adenosine
Inosine
Guanosine
Hypoxanthine
Guanine
Xanthine oxidase
Xanthine
Uric acid
Allantoin
Allantoic acid
Salvage pathway
Glyoxylic acid + urea
TG accumulation
AMP
IMP
Figure 1: Metabolic pathways involving UA. UA metabolic route UA metabolic route Insulin Glucose −ATP Fructose
−
6-phosphate Ribose 5-phosphate Ribose 5-phosphate TG accumulation Adenine Adenosine Guanosine Inosine Guanine Xanthine Uric acid Uric acid Salvage pathway Allantoin Allantoin Allantoic acid Figure 1: Metabolic pathways involving UA. [3] and, thus, UA can function to neutralize prooxidant
molecules, such as hydroxyl radicals, hydrogen peroxide,
and peroxynitrite. UA shows the highest scavenging rate
constant against O2
−∙, with constants being low against
CH3∙and t-BuOO∙[4]. UA directly (nonenzymatically)
and preferentially deletes nitric oxide (NO) and forms 6-
aminouracil in physiological environments or in association
with antioxidants [5]. In vitro, UA has both an antioxidant
effect on native LDL and a prooxidant effect on mildly
oxidized LDL [6]. Allantoin does not have these effects. The
mechanisms of these reactions vary among combinations of
prooxidant molecules and solution polarities [7].f crystallization and the other involves superoxide free radicals
generated by XO. 1. Introduction While the UA crystallization mechanism
would be dependent on a high serum UA concentration, the
latter may not necessarily reflect the serum UA concentration
though XO activity does lead to the production of reactive
oxygen species (ROS). yg
p
Subsequently, lines of research showing relationships
between UA metabolism and the development of various
disorders are introduced and discussed. Importantly, recent
studies have demonstrated beneficial effects of XO inhibitors
against the occurrence and/or progression of several dis-
orders, particularly atherosclerosis and nonalcoholic steato-
hepatitis (NASH), both of which are associated with insulin
resistance, hyperlipidemia, and/or obesity. In this review,
atherosclerosis and NASH are discussed extensively, while
studies of gout and chronic kidney diseases (CKD) are
mentioned briefly. In conclusion, we propose that such XO
inhibitors may be more useful for preventing a variety of
disorders, such as atherosclerosis and NASH, than previously
believed, probably via an anti-inflammatory effect. It has been suggested that this antioxidant effect of the
high UA concentrations in humans contributes to neuropro-
tection in several neurodegenerative and neuroinflammatory
diseases [8–14].f However, despite the potential antioxidant effect of UA
itself, numerous studies have revealed close associations of
serum UA concentrations and various disorders, most of
which are included in the metabolic syndrome category. Thus,
UA metabolism may be a so-called double-edged sword as
regards the inflammatory and/or oxidative responses in many
organs, though on the whole, its harmful effects appear to
outweigh the benefits of UA in most cases.i 2. Inflammation Occurrence Related to
UA Metabolism Excessive metabolites, such as ATP or monosodium urate
crystals (MUC), were also confirmed to be involved in the
activation of inflammasomes, and inflammatory responses
occurring via inflammasomes have been demonstrated to
be linked to the onset and progression of human diseases,
including gout, atherosclerosis and NASH, as described
below in detail [18–24].l ROS from XO might play physiological roles, especially in
development. Treatment during pregnancy with allopurinol
alters maternal vascular function involving 𝛽1-adrenergic
stimulation and impairs the fetal 𝛼1-adrenergic vasoreflex
response involving NO [36]. Fetal XO is activated in vivo
during hypoxia and XO-derived ROS contributes to fetal
peripheral vasoconstriction, leading to fetal defense against
hypoxia [37]. XO depletion induces renal interstitial fibrosis,
and renal epithelial cells from XOR (−/−) mice are more
readily transformed into myofibroblasts [38]. Indeed, how
ROS from XO directly and physiologically acts in vivo is
unknown.h Inflammasomes are known to be divided into dis-
cernible patterns, depending on component proteins [16]. Among them, the NLRP3 inflammasome, comprised of three
major components, Nod-like receptor 3 (NLRP3), apoptosis-
associated speck-like protein containing a CARD (ASC) and
caspase-1, has been well investigated. Maturations of both IL-1
and IL-18 by inflammasomes require a two-step mechanism. First, the Toll-like receptor ligands, such as lipopolysaccha-
ride (LPS), activate the NF-𝜅B pathway and upregulate the
expression levels of interleukins, including pro-IL-1𝛽and
pro-IL-18. Subsequently, the inflammasome complex acti-
vated by pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs)
or damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) cleaves
pro-IL-1𝛽or pro-IL-18, resulting in the production of mature
interleukins [15–17]. The tissue and cellular distributions of XO in mammals
are highest in the liver and intestines due to XO-rich
parenchymal cells [39]. Xanthine oxidoreductase (XOR) is
present in hepatocytes, while XO is present in bile duct
epithelial cells, concentrated toward the luminal surface. Moreover, in human liver disease, proliferating bile ducts are
also strongly positive for XO [40]. Molybdenum supplemen-
tation significantly increased XO activities in the liver and
small intestinal mucosa [41]. XO activity is low in human
serum, the brain, heart, and skeletal muscle, while being rich
in microvascular endothelial cells [42] and is also present in
macrophages [43]. Circulating XO can adhere to endothelial
cells by associating with endothelial glycosaminoglycans
[44]. The study using electron spin resonance measure-
ments revealed the contribution of increased XO activity
to endothelial dysfunction in patients with coronary artery
diseases [45]. 2. Inflammation Occurrence Related to
UA Metabolism Among the disorders related to hyperuricemia, gout is the
most representative and well known. Features of gout include
painful arthritis affecting the limbs, caused by reduced UA i
In this review, we first explain the two putative molecular
mechanisms underlying inflammation occurrence in relation
to UA metabolism; one is inflammasome activation via UA 3 Mediators of Inflammation (TXNIP) from thioredoxin and enables TXNIP to associate
with NLRP3, leading to NLRP3 inflammasome activation
[29, 30]. Thus, MUC accumulation promotes inflammatory
responses through inflammasomes (Figure 2) and thereby
promotes the onset of diseases, such as gout. crystals in the joints. While symptoms of a gout attack are
typical of an acute inflammatory response, as indicated by
the presence of swelling, heat, rubescence, and pain, there
are many disorders with mild but chronic inflammation
which are very likely to be related to UA metabolism. In the
latter case, superoxide free radicals generated by XO are key
players leading to chronic inflammatory processes eventually
resulting in impaired organ functions. Thus, we introduce
two independent mechanisms underlying UA metabolism-
induced inflammation. 2.2. Superoxide Free Radicals Generated by XO. When mam-
malian xanthine dehydrogenase (XDH) is converted to XO
under stressed conditions such as tissue damage and ischemia
[31], superoxide anion and hydrogen peroxide are produced
during molybdenum hydroxylase-catalyzed reactions in a
molar ratio of about 1 : 3 [32]. The proteolytic activation
from XDH to XO is required for superoxide generation [33]. In essence, XO oxidizes a variety of purines and pterins,
classified as molybdenum iron-sulfur flavin hydroxylases. When XO reacts with xanthine, electrons are transferred
from Mo, Fe-S, and FAD. XO produces FADH2, while XDH
produces FADH. Only FADH2 reacts with O2 [34]. In the
UA metabolic pathway, XO oxidizes hypoxanthine from
nucleic acid metabolites into xanthine and xanthine into
UA (Figure 1). XO, as well as nicotinamide adenine dinu-
cleotide phosphate (NADPH) oxidase and the mitochondrial
electron-transport chain, generates ROS [35]. 2.1. Inflammasome Activation by Crystallized UA Particles. In
2002, the inflammasome concept was proposed to involve
multiple proteins and to control the cleavage of prointer-
leukin 1 (IL-1) [15]. Initially, inflammasomes were considered
to play a role in immune responses and serve as defense sys-
tems against pathogens [16, 17]. However, a line of subsequent
studies has elucidated that inflammasomes are key players in
the onsets of a wide range of diseases as well as host defense. 2. Inflammation Occurrence Related to
UA Metabolism depletion, such as that characteristic of glycogen storage
disease type 1 [69], hypoglycemia [70], exercise [71], and
starvation [72], also increases UA production. Conditions
associated with DNA turnover, such as tumor progression
[73] and tumor lysis [74], are also mediated by XO. significantly higher in the aortic walls and skeletal muscles
of old rats than in those of their young counterparts. The
correlation between plasma XO activity and age is observed
in both humans and rats [55]. It appears that hyperglycemia
itself has no impact on liver XO activity, though cardiac,
renal, and brain XO activities were shown to be increased
in rats with advanced diabetes [56, 57]. XO activity rises
remarkably in ischemic congestive heart failure and XO
localizes within CD68 positive macrophages [43]. The asso-
ciation between XO and ischemic reperfusion injury has
been well investigated. XO is one of the major superoxide
sources in ischemia/reperfusion injuries of the heart [58],
forebrain [59], skin [60], liver [61, 62], and gastric mucosa
[63], as well as multiple system organ failure after hind limb
reperfusion [64]. XO activity, along with lipid peroxidation,
myeloperoxidase activity and NO levels, is increased in the
liver in response to renal ischemia/reperfusion in diabetic rats
[65]. Ischemia/reperfusion injury is attributable to elevated
XO activity and ATP depletion related to increasing hypox-
anthine and xanthine levels during ischemia, and reperfusion
provides O2 for oxidation of these compounds [1]. Superoxide produced by XO is an important messenger
inducing inflammation and signal transduction, leading to
tissue damage. We found inflammatory cytokines to be
induced via XO when foam cells form with lipid accu-
mulation [75]. XO regulates cyclooxygenase-2 [76] in the
inflammatory system, and XO appears to be critical for
innate immune function [77]. XO increased Egr-1 mRNA
and protein, as well as the phosphorylation of ERK1/2, while
pretreatment with an ERK1/2 inhibitor prevented induction
of Egr-1 by XO [78]. In addition, XO reportedly reduced
SUMOylation of PPAR𝛾in inflammatory cells [79]. ROS
from XO augment TRB3 expression in podocytes [80]. g
y
As noted above, superoxide from XO has been suggested
to play roles in various forms of inflammatory or ischemic
pathophysiology (Figure 3), not necessarily involving hyper-
uricemia. Superoxide production by XO may also be enhanced
by increasing the amount of its substrate, purine bodies. 2. Inflammation Occurrence Related to
UA Metabolism Excess fructose metabolism results in ATP depletion which
is associated with degradation of AMP to hypoxanthine,
followed by conversion to UA by XO [66]. Indeed, the
serum UA level is upregulated in response to a fructose
burden [67]. Inversely, UA stimulates fructokinase and fruc-
tose metabolism during fatty liver development [68]. ATP 2. Inflammation Occurrence Related to
UA Metabolism MUC also reportedly serve as a danger signal and trigger
the activation of inflammasomes [18]. Although the mech-
anism of inflammasome activation by MUC has not been
fully elucidated, the following mechanism was proposed. MUC stimulate the Toll-like receptor 2/4-Myd88 pathway
and raise transcriptional levels of pro-IL-1𝛽through the
NF-𝜅B pathway [25]. It is theorized that MUC-induced
inflammasome activation is driven by two key factors. One
is a decrease in the intracellular potassium concentration. Indeed, the addition of high potassium abrogated IL-1𝛽
release by MUC. The other is the generation of ROS, because
an antioxidant, N-acetyl-cysteine, abolished IL-1𝛽secretion
by MUC [26]. Other studies have indicated the application
of MUC to raise intracellular ROS levels. However, the
relationship between intracellular K+ level changes and ROS
generation remains unknown, and future studies are expected
to resolve this issue [27, 28]. Elevation of intracellular ROS
mediates the detachment of thioredoxin-interacting protein XO activation is induced by LPS, angiotensin II, NADPH
oxidase, hypoxia, hypoxia-inducible factor 1, and inflamma-
tory cytokines such as IL-1𝛽[46–49]. The release of XO is
increased in hypercholesterolemia, chronic hyperammone-
mia, thermal trauma, beta-thalassemia, brain ischemia, and
pulmonary artery hypertension [50–54]. Aging is another
factor associated with elevated XO activity. Indeed, XO was 4 Mediators of Inflammation 4
Mediators of Inflammation
MUC
MUC
ROS
TXNIP
TRX
NLRP3
ASC
Caspase-1
MUC
TLR
p65
p50
Pro-IL-1𝛽
TXNIP
IL-1𝛽
NADPH oxidase
? K+
K+
Figure 2: MUC induces inflammasome activation. MUC activates the NF-𝜅B pathway through TLR2/4, thereby increasing the expressions
of pro-IL-1𝛽or pro-IL-18. At the same time, MUC induces ROS release from mitochondria. The generated ROS detaches TXNIP from
thioredoxin and enables TXNIP to interact with the NLRP3 complex. The binding of TXNIP to NLRP3 activates inflammasomes, leading to
the production of mature IL-1𝛽or IL-18. MUC: monosodium urate crystals, TLR: Toll-like receptor, TXNIP: thioredoxin-interacting protein,
TXR: thioredoxin, and ROS: reactive oxygen species. Figure 2: MUC induces inflammasome activation. MUC activates the NF-𝜅B pathway through TLR2/4, thereby increasing the expressions
of pro-IL-1𝛽or pro-IL-18. At the same time, MUC induces ROS release from mitochondria. The generated ROS detaches TXNIP from
thioredoxin and enables TXNIP to interact with the NLRP3 complex. The binding of TXNIP to NLRP3 activates inflammasomes, leading to
the production of mature IL-1𝛽or IL-18. MUC: monosodium urate crystals, TLR: Toll-like receptor, TXNIP: thioredoxin-interacting protein,
TXR: thioredoxin, and ROS: reactive oxygen species. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH While gout is a disorder well known to be caused by the pre-
cipitation of UA crystals, the involvement of hyperuricemia
in CKD is also widely recognized. The major causes of CKD
have been regarded as diabetes mellitus and hypertension, 5 Mediators of Inflammation ROS
NADPH
LPS
TLR
? XO
Tissue damage/
ischemic condition
Angiotensin II
Inflammatory cytokines
IL-1𝛽 etc.)
Lipid
Mo
? ? Lipid accumulation
Inflammation
Cox-2
Egr-1
Uric acid
Purine metabolism
ERK1/2 P
ERK1/2
JNK
JNK P
Lipid
transporter
Cytokines
receptor
XDH
XDH
receptor
Cidea
C/EBP
Oxidative stress
XDH
Insulin resistance
PPAR SUMO
Hypoxia
XDH
HIF-1
PPAR
ER stress
[O2] ↓
AT2
𝛾
𝛾
and so on
Figure 3: Involvement of XO in molecular pathologies related to inflammation; “causes and results.” Lipid Insulin resistance Hypoxia Lipid
transporter Figure 3: Involvement of XO in molecular pathologies related to inflammation; “causes and results.” and thus, hyperuricemia was long viewed as a consequence of
CKD. In fact, loss of kidney function reduces the excretion of
UA into urine, resulting in hyperuricemia. In contrast, recent
studies demonstrated a significant association between serum
UA and the development of CKD. While each metabolic
syndrome component, including hyperglycemia, hyperlipi-
demia, and hypertension, was associated with an increased
CKD risk, hyperuricemia was apparently an independent risk
factor not influenced by the others. Therefore, hyperuricemia
is both a cause and a consequence of CKD and is frequently
associated with other metabolic syndrome features. and superoxide free radical generation both play roles
in the molecular mechanisms underlying hyperuricemia-
related CKD development, but further research is required
to elucidate the complex mechanistic interactions between
serum UA and CKD. As mentioned in Section 2, both UA and superoxide free
radicals are simultaneously produced by XO and might be
the pathophysiological cause of these diseases. As shown in
Figure 3, chronic inflammation is also involved in pathophys-
iological processes, generally exhibiting a close relationship
with oxidative stress. ROS from XO induces LPS-induced
JNK activation via inactivation of MAPK phosphatase-
(MKP-) 1 [84] and XO regulates cyclooxygenase-2, one of
the master regulators of inflammation [76]. Therefore, dam-
age from UA, ROS, and UA-induced and/or ROS-induced
inflammation might together contribute to the progression
of certain diseases, and distinguishing which mechanism acts
first is often difficult in lifestyle-related diseases. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH Furthermore, allopurinol suppressed the expres-
sions of inflammatory cytokines such as IL-1𝛽, IL-6, IL-
12, and TNF𝛼, and the expressions of VCAM1, MCP-1, and
MMP2, which were upregulated in J774.1 cells transformed
into foam cells by atherosclerogenic serum. Subsequently,
febuxostat, another XO inhibitor, was also demonstrated
to attenuate the development of atherosclerotic lesions in
ApoE−/−mice [114]. That study showed XO expression
to be increased in macrophages infiltrating atherosclerotic
plaques and that febuxostat diminished the ROS level in the
aortic walls of ApoE−/−mice. The authors demonstrated that
cholesterol crystals (CCs) increased endogenous XO activity
and ROS production in macrophages and that CCs enhanced
not only IL-1𝛽release via NLRP3 inflammasome activation
but also secretions of other inflammatory cytokines such as
IL-1𝛼, IL-6, and MCP-1 from macrophages, processes which
in turn were suppressed by febuxostat or ROS inhibitors. The significance of NLRP3 inflammasome activation in
macrophages by CCs was verified by the observation that
atherosclerosis in high-cholesterol diet fed LDL receptor-
(LDLR-) deficient mice was alleviated by transplanting bone
marrow from NLRP3-deficient, ASC-deficient, or IL-1𝛼/𝛽-
deficient mice [117]. Taking these observations together, we
can reasonably speculate that XO in macrophages enhances
foam cell formation, ROS production, and NLRP3 inflamma-
some activation, all three of which exacerbate inflammation
and plaque formation, thereby contributing to the develop-
ment of atherosclerotic diseases [75, 114–116]. p
yp
Despite the association between hyperuricemia and
hypertension having been recognized since the 19th cen-
tury [85], it was not until recently that hyperuricemia was
demonstrated to be an independent risk factor for hyper-
tension development [87–93]. A recently published meta-
analysis showed that the adjusted relative risk of developing
hypertension was 1.48 for hyperuricemic patients [94], and
this association was apparently much stronger in younger,
early-onset hypertensive patients [86, 95]. Several clinical
trials have demonstrated the beneficial effects of UA low-
ering therapy for hypertension [96–99]. In a trial targeting
prehypertensive obese adolescents, administration of either
allopurinol (XO inhibitor) or probenecid (uricosuric agent)
lowered blood pressure [98]. Consistently, both allopurinol
and benziodarone (uricosuric agent) reduced blood pressure
in rats with hypertension induced by hyperuricemia [100,
101], suggesting that not only XO activity but also UA itself
plays an important role in the pathogenesis of hypertension. Besides the association with hypertension, hyperuricemia
or gout has been confirmed to be related to the morbidity
and the mortality of CVD [102–106]. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH In terms of CKD pathogenesis, serum UA is likely to
activate the renin-angiotensin system resulting in vascular
smooth muscle cell proliferation [81] and to induce an
epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition of renal tubular cells
[82]. XO inhibitor treatment reportedly reduced intercel-
lular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) expression in tubular
epithelial cells [83] of mice. We speculate that UA itself Mediators of Inflammation 6 3.1. Atherosclerosis, Vascular Dysfunction, and Heart Failure. Although the relationships between serum UA levels and
atherosclerotic diseases, including hypertension [85, 86],
have been documented, whether or not serum UA itself is an
independent cardiovascular risk factor remains controversial
as most hyperuricemic patients with cardiovascular diseases
(CVD) have other complications such as hypertension, dys-
lipidemia, diabetes, and CKD as well, which are generally
regarded as more established risk factors for CVD than hype-
ruricemia. Recently, however, a growing body of evidence
from both clinical and basic research supports the hypothesis
that hyperuricemia, partly via elevated XO activity, is an
independent risk factor for hypertension and CVD. beneath the endothelium and transform into macrophages,
which then turn into foam cells by incorporating modi-
fied low density lipoproteins (LDL) (such as oxidized LDL
and acetyl LDL) or very low density lipoproteins (VLDL). Foam cells contribute to the formation of unstable plaques
by secreting inflammatory mediators and matrix-degrading
proteases (such as matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs)) and
by generating a prothrombotic necrotic core by eventually
undergoing necrotic or apoptotic death [116]. We demon-
strated that allopurinol treatment ameliorated aortic lipid
accumulation and calcification of the vessels of ApoE-KO
mice and that allopurinol markedly suppressed the transfor-
mation of J774.1 murine macrophages or primary cultured
human macrophages into foam cells in response to stimula-
tion with acetyl LDL or VLDL. The expressions of scavenger
receptors (SR-A1, SR-B1, and SR-B2) and VLDL receptors
in J774.1 cells were upregulated by XOR overexpression and
downregulated by siRNA-mediated XOR suppression, raising
the possibility that XO activity in macrophages positively
regulates foam cell formation by increasing the uptake of
modified LDL or VLDL. Conversely, expressions of ABCA1
and ABCG1, which regulate cellular cholesterol efflux, were
decreased by XOR overexpression and increased by XOR
knockdown. Furthermore, allopurinol suppressed the expres-
sions of inflammatory cytokines such as IL-1𝛽, IL-6, IL-
12, and TNF𝛼, and the expressions of VCAM1, MCP-1, and
MMP2, which were upregulated in J774.1 cells transformed
into foam cells by atherosclerogenic serum. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH Subsequently,
febuxostat, another XO inhibitor, was also demonstrated
to attenuate the development of atherosclerotic lesions in
ApoE−/−mice [114]. That study showed XO expression
to be increased in macrophages infiltrating atherosclerotic
plaques and that febuxostat diminished the ROS level in the
aortic walls of ApoE−/−mice. The authors demonstrated that
cholesterol crystals (CCs) increased endogenous XO activity
and ROS production in macrophages and that CCs enhanced
not only IL-1𝛽release via NLRP3 inflammasome activation
but also secretions of other inflammatory cytokines such as
IL-1𝛼, IL-6, and MCP-1 from macrophages, processes which
in turn were suppressed by febuxostat or ROS inhibitors. The significance of NLRP3 inflammasome activation in
macrophages by CCs was verified by the observation that
atherosclerosis in high-cholesterol diet fed LDL receptor-
(LDLR-) deficient mice was alleviated by transplanting bone
marrow from NLRP3-deficient, ASC-deficient, or IL-1𝛼/𝛽-
deficient mice [117]. Taking these observations together, we
can reasonably speculate that XO in macrophages enhances
foam cell formation, ROS production, and NLRP3 inflamma-
some activation, all three of which exacerbate inflammation
and plaque formation, thereby contributing to the develop-
ment of atherosclerotic diseases [75, 114–116]. Independently of XO, UA itself is widely recognized to beneath the endothelium and transform into macrophages,
which then turn into foam cells by incorporating modi-
fied low density lipoproteins (LDL) (such as oxidized LDL
and acetyl LDL) or very low density lipoproteins (VLDL). Foam cells contribute to the formation of unstable plaques
by secreting inflammatory mediators and matrix-degrading
proteases (such as matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs)) and
by generating a prothrombotic necrotic core by eventually
undergoing necrotic or apoptotic death [116]. We demon-
strated that allopurinol treatment ameliorated aortic lipid
accumulation and calcification of the vessels of ApoE-KO
mice and that allopurinol markedly suppressed the transfor-
mation of J774.1 murine macrophages or primary cultured
human macrophages into foam cells in response to stimula-
tion with acetyl LDL or VLDL. The expressions of scavenger
receptors (SR-A1, SR-B1, and SR-B2) and VLDL receptors
in J774.1 cells were upregulated by XOR overexpression and
downregulated by siRNA-mediated XOR suppression, raising
the possibility that XO activity in macrophages positively
regulates foam cell formation by increasing the uptake of
modified LDL or VLDL. Conversely, expressions of ABCA1
and ABCG1, which regulate cellular cholesterol efflux, were
decreased by XOR overexpression and increased by XOR
knockdown. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH The number of nonalco-
holic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) patients including those
with NASH has been increasing worldwide and a portion
of NASH patients will progress to hepatocarcinoma onset
[121–123]. Therefore, numerous investigations have been
performed in efforts to elucidate the causes of NASH.l ROS generation by UA is considered to depend on
NADPH oxidase activation [136, 138, 139]. For example, UA
reportedly promotes translocation of the NADPH oxidase
subunit NOX4 into mitochondria [136]. It was also reported
that UA treatment raises NADPH oxidase activity and alters
its localization, leading to lipid oxidation [139]. In addition,
XO may also function as a source of ROS generation because
XO activity is upregulated in the livers of murine NASH
models. f
NASH is characterized by fat deposition, inflammation
and fibrosis in the liver, and a two-hit mechanism of onset has
been proposed [124–126]. This hypothesis is that fatty liver
formation and subsequent injuries, including inflammation
and oxidative stress, cause NASH pathology [127]. Interest-
ingly, recent studies have raised the possibility that UA is
among the risk factors for NASH pathology. We discuss the
relationship between UA and NASH below. Collectively, these observations indicate that UA enhances
fatty acid synthesis by regulating lipogenesis and induces
ROS generation by regulating NADPH oxidase activity and
upregulating fatty acid synthesis, thereby contributing to
NASH development. 3.2.1. Serum UA Is a Predictor of NAFLD/NASH Onset and
Progression. Many clinical studies have been carried out to
investigate the relationship between serum UA levels and
NAFLD/NASH progression. For example, a cohort study
in Korea found the serum UA level to be a useful marker
for predicting NAFLD development because the serum UA
concentration correlated positively with the 5-year incidence
rate of NAFLD [128]. Their conclusion is supported by
another study showing that serum UA levels of NAFLD
patients are higher than those of control groups [129]. In
addition, there are also studies demonstrating that serum UA
is a risk factor for the development and/or progression of
NAFLD including NASH [130–132]. 3.2.3. Inflammasome Participation in NASH Progression. As described elsewhere, UA is involved in inflammasome
activation. Recent investigations have provided convincing
evidence that inflammasomes are key players in NASH devel-
opment. An initial study revealed that inflammasome impair-
ment exacerbated the NASH progression induced by feeding
a methionine-choline deficient diet for 4 weeks to ASC or
IL-1 KO mice [140]. Subsequent studies, however, found that
inflammasomes themselves exacerbate NASH symptoms. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH According to a recently
published meta-analysis [107], the relative risks of morbidity
and mortality for coronary heart diseases were 1.13 and
1.27, respectively, in hyperuricemic patients as compared to
controls. Several clinical studies have indicated the benefits
of XO inhibitors for reducing the incidence of myocardial
infarction [108], improving exercise tolerance in patients
with stable angina [109], and enhancing endothelial function
[110, 111]. However, interestingly, unlike the case of treating
hypertension, uricosuric agents have failed to show any
benefits in patients with hyperuricemia or gout [110, 112]. i
What are the mechanisms underlying the aforementioned
association between hyperuricemia and atherosclerotic dis-
eases? First, the role of XO in the pathogenesis of atheroscle-
rosis merits attention. As described above, XO produces ROS
when converting hypoxanthine into xanthine and then UA. XO is also expressed in endothelial cells [113] and was shown
to be increased in the aortic endothelial cells of ApoE−/−mice
[114], an established model of atherosclerosis. Since oxidative
stress inactivates NO and leads to endothelial dysfunction
[115], endothelial XO, especially given its enhanced expres-
sion during the development of atherosclerosis, contributes
to vascular damage via ROS production. Independently of XO, UA itself is widely recognized to
exert direct effects on vascular functions. Vascular endothe-
lial cells express several UA transporters [118] and incorpo-
rated UA impairs NO production and leads to endothelial
dysfunction [118, 119]. In vascular smooth muscle cells, UA
stimulates proliferation and ROS production and inhibits NO
production via increased angiotensin II expression [81, 120]. As noted above, not only XO inhibitors but also uricosuric Recently, we established that XO activity in macrophages
also plays a key role in the development of atherosclerosis
[75]. During atherosclerosis development, monocytes migrate 7 Mediators of Inflammation agents markedly lowered blood pressure, especially in studies
targeting early-stage hypertensive patients [98] and those
using animal models [100, 101]. The results obtained suggest
that UA presumably contributes to early-stage hypertension
by promoting renal vasoconstriction via reduced NO produc-
tion and activation of the renin-angiotensin system [86, 98]. lyase activity via enhanced phosphorylation at S455, resulting
in the induction of lipogenesis. These observations are sup-
ported by those of another study in which pretreatment with
antioxidants inhibited the elevation of triglyceride contents
by UA [137]. The authors asserted that ROS generation by UA
evoked endoplasmic reticulum stress, leading to upregulation
of lipogenic genes, such as acetyl CoA carboxylase1 and FASN
[137]. 3.2. Nonalcoholic Steatohepatitis. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH For
example, it was reported that NLRP3 deficiency prevents liver
fibrosis in response to a choline diet deficient in amino acids
[141]. In addition, caspase-1 deficient mice were also resistant
to developing steatosis or fibrosis while being fed a high-fat
diet [142]. Moreover, other groups have demonstrated that
diets which lead to NASH also increase the expressions of
inflammasome components [143–145]. g
Consistent with these observations, hepatic XO activities
and serum UA levels are reportedly increased in murine
NAFLD/NASH models [133, 134]. Moreover, a fraction of
NAFLD/NASH patients also have obesity, and hypertrophic
adipocytes were also reported to secrete UA [135]. Taken
together, these results indicate serum UA to be a good param-
eter for predicting the development of NAFLD/NASH, and
that XO inhibitors or uricosuric agents might have potential
as treatments for ameliorating the features of NAFLD. l
Taking these lines of evidence together, in the initial stage
of NASH, inflammasomes appear to exert a protective effect,
but continuous inflammasome activation appears to cause
excessive productions of inflammatory cytokines, ultimately
resulting in liver injury. Although, to date, numerous factors
playing important roles in NASH progression have been
identified, UA also appears to be a key participant in the onset
of NAFLD/NASH. 3.2.2. The Mechanism of UA-Induced NAFLD/NASH Pro-
gression. As described above, increasing serum UA or XO
activity apparently plays important roles in NAFLD/NASH
onset and progression. Interestingly, UA was reported to
induce fat depositions by enhancing lipogenesis in hepato-
cytes. Fructose treatment of HepG2 cells reportedly increased
both the intracellular UA concentration and triglyceride (TG)
accumulation, while allopurinol, an XO inhibitor, suppressed
this fructose-mediated TG deposition. Moreover, the applica-
tion of UA alone was demonstrated to increase intracellular
TG contents as well as ROS generation in mitochondria
[136]. As a mechanism of UA-induced TG accumulation, the
authors asserted that the elevation of intracellular ROS by
UA raised both the citrate concentration and ATP citrate 3.3. Insulin Resistance, Diabetes, and Hyperlipidemia. Hype-
ruricemia was reportedly found to be related to insulin
resistance in several clinical analyses [146–152]. In addition,
several meta-analyses have suggested the UA level to be
positively associated with the development of type 2 diabetes
mellitus (DM) [153–156], although Mendelian randomization
studies did not support circulating UA as being among the
causes of DM development [157, 158]. In metabolic syndrome
patients, an oxidative stress marker, the myeloperoxidase
level, was decreased by allopurinol and endothelial function
improved [159]. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH On the other hand, rapid UA reduction 8 Mediators of Inflammation Infection
Ischemia
Excess energy intake
Fructose intake
Exercise
Starvation
Low oxygenation
Tumor lysis
Immune response
Lipid accumulation
Purine intake
ATP depletion
Purine generation
ADP
ATP
Uric acid
Purine
Ribose-5-phosphate and so on
Purine
XO activity ↑
XO substrate ↑
Alcohol intake
Figure 4: Increased catalyst activity of XO, originating from pathological and physiological events. Involvement of XO in pathophysiological
processes suggests applications of XO inhibitors to the treatment of various disorders. Figure 4: Increased catalyst activity of XO, originating from pathological and physiological events. Involvement of XO in pathophysiological
processes suggests applications of XO inhibitors to the treatment of various disorders. achieved by rasburicase, a urate oxidase, in obese subjects
with high UA resulted in increasing the markers of systemic
and skeletal muscle oxidative stress while having no effect on
insulin sensitivity [160]. stimulation of ATP citrate lyase and fatty acid synthase, ulti-
mately leading to de novo lipogenesis [136]. In hepatocytes
treated with high UA, oxidative stress is increased, which
activates serine (rat Ser307 and human Ser312) phosphory-
lation of IRS-1. This activity impairs Akt phosphorylation,
thereby resulting in acute hepatic insulin resistance after
exposure to high UA levels [165]. Therefore, UA-induced lipid
accumulation and oxidative stress are responsible for the
development of insulin resistance and diabetes. Furthermore, excess fructose intake is one of the major
causes of the development of obesity with hyperuricemia,
fatty liver, and metabolic syndrome. Fructose is metabo-
lized by fructokinase to fructose-1-phosphate and results
in a drop in both intracellular phosphate and ATP levels
[161]. The intracellular phosphate decrease stimulates AMP
deaminase (AMPD), the enzyme catalyzing the degradation
of AMP to inosine monophosphate and eventually UA. Activated AMPD increases the expressions of gluconeo-
genesis genes, that is, PEPCK and G6Pase, via inhibition
of AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) [162]. AMPD
also increases lipogenesis through AMPK inhibition. AMPK
phosphorylation was decreased in HepG2 cells treated with
UA. The UA increased fructose-induced TG accumulation
and decreased 𝛽-hydroxybutyrate levels, dose-dependently,
while allopurinol, a XO inhibitor, blocked it. Because UA
is the downstream product of AMPD and allopurinol abol-
ished fructose-induced lipid accumulation, AMPD effects
on AMPK appeared to depend on UA [163]. UA activates
the transcription factor ChREBP, which triggers a vicious
cycle of fructokinase transcription and accelerated fructose
metabolism [68]. 3. UA Metabolism and Chronic Renal Disease,
Atherosclerosis, Heart Failure, and NASH Via these mechanisms, activated AMPD
and increased UA production tend to promote fat accumu-
lation and glucose production. 4. Beneficial Effects of XO Inhibitors Involvement of increased XO catalyst activity in patho-
physiological processes (Figure 4) suggests applications of
XO inhibitors to the treatment of various disorders. At
present, XO inhibitors, including allopurinol, oxypurinol,
febuxostat, and topiroxostat, are widely used for treating gout
and hyperuricemia. Furthermore, XO inhibitors have been
experimentally or clinically shown to exert beneficial effects
by lowering serum UA and oxidative stress. Febuxostat preserved renal function in 5/6 nephrec-
tomized rats with and without coexisting hyperuricemia
and prevented diabetic renal injury in streptozotocin-treated
rats [166, 167]. Febuxostat also ameliorated tubular dam-
age, diminished macrophage interstitial infiltration, and
suppressed both proinflammatory cytokine activities and
oxidative stress [168]. Febuxostat also reduced the induction
of endoplasmic reticulum stress, as assessed by GRP-78
(glucose-regulated protein-78), ATF4 (activating transcrip-
tion factor-4), and CHOP (C/EBP homologous protein-10)
[169]. The clinical significance of measuring the serum UA
level and XO inhibition for renal protection has largely been
established by the results of recent studies [170–173].if UA is considered to be an antioxidant in human blood,
though UA induces oxidative stress in cells [164]. UA raised
NADPH oxidase activity and ROS production in mature
adipocytes. The stimulation of NADPH oxidase-dependent
ROS by UA resulted in the activation of MAP kinase p38
and ERK1/2, a decrease in NO bioavailability, and increases
in both protein nitrosylation and lipid oxidation [138]. Increased UA production, in turn, generates mitochondrial
oxidants. Mitochondrial oxidative stress inhibits aconitase in
the Krebs cycle, resulting in citrate accumulation and the On the other hand, beneficial effects of XO inhibitors
on atherosclerosis and NASH constitute an evolving concept
that has yet to be proven. In rats with fructose-induced
metabolic syndrome, febuxostat treatment reversed hyper-
uricemia, hypertension, dyslipidemia, and insulin resistance
[174]. The beneficial effects of XO inhibitors on NASH are 9 Mediators of Inflammation rarely reported, except by our research group [134], because
animal models of NASH with obesity, inflammation, and
fibrosis have been difficult to establish. NASH in response
to the MCD diet, as used in our studies, caused primarily
inflammation and also made the mice lean, such that no
benefit of XO inhibition was obtained [134]. Thus, we next
used a high-fat diet containing trans-fatty acids and a high-
fructose diet to induce NASH development in our animal
models. Another report showed that inhibition of XO activity
also significantly prevents hepatic steatosis induced by a high-
fat diet in mice. Abbreviations l
Atherosclerosis has been far more extensively investi-
gated than NASH, both clinically and experimentally. Tung-
sten, acting as an XO inhibitor, has an inhibitory effect on
both atherosclerosis and oxidative stress [176]. We reported
for the first time that more specific XO inhibition, using
allopurinol rather than tungsten on macrophages, resulted in
the inhibition of foam cell formation and reduced atheroscle-
rotic lesions in ApoE-KO mice, independently of the serum
lipid profile [75]. We also identified phenotypic changes of
macrophages in response to allopurinol, such as alterations of
gene expressions involved in lipid accumulation. Moreover,
both XO overexpression and knockdown of XO expression
revealed VLDL receptors to be dramatically upregulated
by XO. Febuxostat was also proven to have similar effects
in terms of reducing the atherosclerotic lesions in ApoE-
KO mice, and oxidative stress was reduced in macrophages
from atherosclerotic lesions [113]. Febuxostat also suppressed
LPS-induced MCP-1 production via MAPK phosphatase-1-
mediated inactivation of JNK [84]. As a strategy for suppress-
ing atherosclerosis, XO inhibition is expected to act on either
macrophages or inflammatory cells. UA:
Uric acid
MUC:
Monosodium urate crystal
NASH:
Nonalcoholic steatohepatitis
XO:
Xanthine oxidase
LPS:
Lipopolysaccharide
TIMP:
Tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases
MCP-1:
Monocyte chemoattractant protein 1
NADPH: Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate
CKD:
Chronic kidney disease
ICAM-1: Intercellular adhesion molecule-1. ICAM-1: Intercellular adhesion molecule-1. Competing Interests The authors have no competing interests regarding the
publication of this report to declare. References [1] C. E. Berry and J. M. Hare, “Xanthine oxidoreductase and
cardiovascular disease: molecular mechanisms and pathophys-
iological implications,” Journal of Physiology, vol. 555, no. 3, pp. 589–606, 2004. p
gl
y
XO inhibitors also improve endothelial function and pre-
vent vascular remodeling. Oxypurinol reduces O2
−radical
dot production and improves endothelial function in blood
vessels from hyperlipidemic experimental animals [69]. XO inhibition can also provide protection from radiation-
induced endothelial dysfunction and cardiovascular com-
plications [177]. Allopurinol treatment prevents hypoxia-
induced vascular remodeling in the lung [178]. However,
controversy persists as to whether the effect of XO on
endothelial function is clinically relevant as an interventional
target [49]. Pretreatment with XO inhibitors has beneficial
effects on ischemia/reperfusion injuries of the intestine [179],
in the impaired liver [61, 62], the edematous brain [180],
kidneys with contrast induced nephropathy [181], and coro-
nary ischemia [182]. XO inhibitors prevent postischemic O2
−
generation [183]. [2] B. N. Ames, R. Cathcart, E. Schwiers, and P. Hochstein,
“Uric acid provides an antioxidant defense in humans against
oxidant- and radical-caused aging and cancer: a hypothesis,”
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United
States of America, vol. 78, no. 11, pp. 6858–6862, 1981. [3] C. X. C. Santos, E. I. Anjos, and O. Augusto, “Uric acid oxidation
by peroxynitrite: multiple reactions, free radical formation, and
amplification of lipid oxidation,” Archives of Biochemistry and
Biophysics, vol. 372, no. 2, pp. 285–294, 1999. [4] E. Kamogawa and Y. Sueishi, “A multiple free-radical scaveng-
ing (MULTIS) study on the antioxidant capacity of a neuropro-
tective drug, edaravone as compared with uric acid, glutathione,
and trolox,” Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry Letters, vol. 24,
no. 5, pp. 1376–1379, 2014. [5] C. Gersch, S. P. Palii, K. M. Kim, A. Angerhofer, R. J. Johnson,
and G. N. Henderson, “Inactivation of nitric oxide by uric acid,”
Nucleosides, Nucleotides and Nucleic Acids, vol. 27, no. 8, pp. 967–978, 2008. 4. Beneficial Effects of XO Inhibitors XO has also been indicated to regulate
activation of the NLRP3 inflammasome [175]. and NASH are diseases for which relationships with UA
metabolism were not immediately recognized, but rodent
model studies revealed the importance of UA metabolism
maintenance for managing these disorders. We believe the
impact of UA metabolism on many diseases accompanying
chronic inflammation to have been underestimated. Future
studies are anticipated to reveal the pathological contribution
of serum UA and/or XO activity to the specific processes
underlying various disorders. Further study of the detailed
molecular mechanisms is clearly warranted. 5. Conclusion Inflammation related to UA metabolism is induced via
either inflammasome activation by UA crystal precipitation
or free radical production in response to XO activity. In
addition to gout, many disorders are known to be related
to UA metabolism and XO inhibitor treatments have been
shown to be effective for preventing the onset and/or the
progression of such disorders. In particular, atherosclerosis [6] R. A. Patterson, E. T. M. Horsley, and D. S. Leake, “Prooxi-
dant and antioxidant properties of human serum ultrafiltrates
toward LDL: important role of uric acid,” Journal of Lipid
Research, vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 512–521, 2003. [7] J. R. Le´on-Carmona and A. Galano, “Uric and 1-methyluric
acids: metabolic wastes or antiradical protectors?” Journal of
Physical Chemistry B, vol. 115, no. 51, pp. 15430–15438, 2011. Mediators of Inflammation 10 by low intracellular potassium concentration,” Cell Death and
Differentiation, vol. 14, no. 9, pp. 1583–1589, 2007. [8] J. W. Davis, A. Grandinetti, C. I. Waslien, G. W. Ross, L. R. White, and D. M. Morens, “Observations on serum uric acid
levels and the risk of idiopathic Parkinson’s disease,” American
Journal of Epidemiology, vol. 144, no. 5, pp. 480–484, 1996. [27] J.-J. Jhang, Y.-T. Cheng, C.-Y. Ho, and G.-C. Yen, “Monosodium
urate crystals trigger Nrf2- and heme oxygenase-1-dependent
inflammation in THP-1 cells,” Cellular & Molecular Immunol-
ogy, vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 424–434, 2015. [9] J. Drulovi´c, I. Dujmovi´c, N. Stojsavljevi´c et al., “Uric acid
levels in sera from patients with multiple sclerosis,” Journal of
Neurology, vol. 248, no. 2, pp. 121–126, 2001. [28] J. Nomura, A. So, M. Tamura, and N. Busso, “Intracellular
ATP decrease mediates NLRP3 inflammasome activation upon
nigericin and crystal stimulation,” The Journal of Immunology,
vol. 195, no. 12, pp. 5718–5724, 2015. [10] G. Toncev, B. Milicic, S. Toncev, and G. Samardzic, “Serum uric
acid levels in multiple sclerosis patients correlate with activity of
disease and blood-brain barrier dysfunction,” European Journal
of Neurology, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 221–226, 2002. [29] R. Zhou, A. Tardivel, B. Thorens, I. Choi, and J. Tschopp,
“Thioredoxin-interacting protein links oxidative stress to
inflammasome activation,” Nature Immunology, vol. 11, no. 2,
pp. 136–140, 2010. [11] B. Liu, Y. Shen, K. Xiao, Y. Tang, L. Cen, and J. Wei, “Serum uric
acid levels in patients with multiple sclerosis: a meta-analysis,”
Neurological Research, vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 163–171, 2012. [12] F. Ashtari, M. Bahar, M. Aghaei, and A. 5. Conclusion Zahed, “Serum uric acid
level in patients with relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis,”
Journal of Clinical Neuroscience, vol. 20, no. 5, pp. 676–678, 2013. [30] K. Schroder, R. Zhou, and J. Tschopp, “The NLRP3 inflamma-
some: a sensor for metabolic danger?” Science, vol. 327, no. 5963,
pp. 296–300, 2010. [13] D. Keizman, M. Ish-Shalom, S. Berliner et al., “Low uric acid
levels in serum of patients with ALS: further evidence for
oxidative stress?” Journal of the Neurological Sciences, vol. 285,
no. 1-2, pp. 95–99, 2009. [31] A. Mittal, A. R. J. Phillips, B. Loveday, and J. A. Windsor, “The
potential role for xanthine oxidase inhibition in major intra-
abdominal surgery,” World Journal of Surgery, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 288–295, 2008. [14] S. Paganoni, M. Zhang, A. Q. Z´arate et al., “Uric acid levels
predict survival in men with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis,”
Journal of Neurology, vol. 259, no. 9, pp. 1923–1928, 2012. [32] R. Asai, T. Nishino, T. Matsumura et al., “Two mutations convert
mammalian xanthine oxidoreductase to highly superoxide-
productive xanthine oxidase,” Journal of Biochemistry, vol. 141,
no. 4, pp. 525–534, 2007. [15] F. Martinon, K. Burns, and J. Tschopp, “The Inflammasome:
a molecular platform triggering activation of inflammatory
caspases and processing of proIL-𝛽,” Molecular Cell, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 417–426, 2002. [33] A. Papi, M. Contoli, P. Gasparini et al., “Role of xanthine oxidase
activation and reduced glutathione depletion in rhinovirus
induction of inflammation in respiratory epithelial cells,” Jour-
nal of Biological Chemistry, vol. 283, no. 42, pp. 28595–28606,
2008. [16] K. Schroder and J. Tschopp, “The inflammasomes,” Cell, vol. 140,
no. 6, pp. 821–832, 2010. [17] R. Medzhitov, “Origin and physiological roles of inflammation,”
Nature, vol. 454, no. 7203, pp. 428–435, 2008. [34] M. J. Barber, R. C. Bray, R. Cammack, and M. P. Cough-
lan, “Oxidation—reduction potentials of turkey liver xanthine
dehydrogenase and the origins of oxidase and dehydrogenase
behaviour in molybdenum-containing hydroxylases,” Biochem-
ical Journal, vol. 163, no. 2, pp. 279–289, 1977. [18] F. Martinon, V. P´etrilli, A. Mayor, A. Tardivel, and J. Tschopp,
“Gout-associated uric acid crystals activate the NALP3 inflam-
masome,” Nature, vol. 440, no. 7081, pp. 237–241, 2006. [19] K. L. Rock, H. Kataoka, and J.-J. Lai, “Uric acid as a danger signal
in gout and its comorbidities,” Nature Reviews Rheumatology,
vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 13–23, 2013. [35] H. Li, S. Horke, and U. 5. Conclusion F¨orstermann, “Oxidative stress in
vascular disease and its pharmacological prevention,” Trends in
Pharmacological Sciences, vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 313–319, 2013. [20] K. H. G. Mills, L. S. Dungan, S. A. Jones, and J. Harris, “The
role of inflammasome-derived IL-1 in driving IL-17 responses,”
Journal of Leukocyte Biology, vol. 93, no. 4, pp. 489–497, 2013.l [36] E. A. Herrera, A. D. Kane, J. A. Hansell et al., “A role for xanthine
oxidase in the control of fetal cardiovascular function in late
gestation sheep,” Journal of Physiology, vol. 590, no. 8, pp. 1825–
1837, 2012. [21] P. P. Duewell, H. Kono, K. J. Rayner et al., “NLRP3 inflamma-
somes are required for atherogenesis and activated by choles-
terol crystals,” Nature, vol. 464, no. 7293, pp. 1357–1361, 2010. [37] A. D. Kane, J. A. Hansell, E. A. Herrera et al., “Xanthine oxidase
and the fetal cardiovascular defence to hypoxia in late gestation
ovine pregnancy,” Journal of Physiology, vol. 592, no. 3, pp. 475–
489, 2014. [22] B. Razani, C. Feng, T. Coleman et al., “Autophagy links inflam-
masomes to atherosclerotic progression,” Cell Metabolism, vol. 15, no. 4, pp. 534–544, 2012. [38] T. Ohtsubo, K. Matsumura, K. Sakagami et al., “Xanthine oxi-
doreductase depletion induces renal interstitial fibrosis through
aberrant lipid and purine accumulation in renal tubules,”
Hypertension, vol. 54, no. 4, pp. 868–876, 2009. [23] T. Csak, M. Ganz, J. Pespisa, K. Kodys, A. Dolganiuc, and
G. Szabo, “Fatty acid and endotoxin activate inflammasomes
in mouse hepatocytes that release danger signals to stimulate
immune cells,” Hepatology, vol. 54, no. 1, pp. 133–144, 2011. [39] C. A. Pritsos, “Cellular distribution, metabolism and regulation
of the xanthine oxidoreductase enzyme system,” Chemico-
Biological Interactions, vol. 129, no. 1-2, pp. 195–208, 2000. [24] G. C. Farrell, D. Van Rooyen, L. Gan, and S. Chitturi, “NASH
is an inflammatory disorder: pathogenic, prognostic and ther-
apeutic implications,” Gut and Liver, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 149–171,
2012. [40] H. M. Martin, K. P. Moore, E. Bosmans et al., “Xanthine
oxidoreductase is present in bile ducts of normal and cirrhotic
liver,” Free Radical Biology and Medicine, vol. 37, no. 8, pp. 1214–
1223, 2004. [25] P. Gasse, N. Riteau, S. Charron et al., “Uric acid is a danger signal
activating NALP3 inflammasome in lung injury inflammation
and fibrosis,” American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care
Medicine, vol. 179, no. 10, pp. 903–913, 2009. [41] X. Wang, D. Oberleas, M. 5. Conclusion T. Yang, and S. P. Yang, “Molybdenum
requirement of female rats,” Journal of Nutrition, vol. 122, no. 4,
pp. 1036–1041, 1992. [26] V. P´etrilli, S. Papin, C. Dostert, A. Mayor, F. Martinon, and J. Tschopp, “Activation of the NALP3 inflammasome is triggered Mediators of Inflammation 11 [42] Y. Moriwaki, T. Yamamoto, M. Suda et al., “Purification and
immunohistochemical tissue localization of human xanthine
oxidase,” Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA)—Protein Struc-
ture and Molecular Enzymology, vol. 1164, no. 3, pp. 327–330,
1993. [56] Y. Aliciguzel, I. Ozen, M. Aslan, and U. Karayalcin, “Activities of
xanthine oxidoreductose and antioxidant enzymes in different
tissues of diabetic rats,” The Journal of Laboratory and Clinical
Medicine, vol. 142, no. 3, pp. 172–177, 2003. [57] L. Malard´e, A. Rebillard, S. Le Douairon-Lahaye et al., “Super-
oxide production pathways in aortas of diabetic rats: beneficial
effects of insulin therapy and endurance training,” Molecular
and Cellular Biochemistry, vol. 389, no. 1-2, pp. 113–118, 2014. [43] J. W. De Jong, R. G. Schoemaker, R. De Jonge et al., “Enhanced
expression and activity of xanthine oxidoreductase in the failing
heart,” Journal of Molecular and Cellular Cardiology, vol. 32, no. 11, pp. 2083–2089, 2000. [58] D. A. Peterson, R. W. Asinger, K. J. Elsperger, D. C. Homans,
and J. W. Eaton, “Reactive oxygen species may cause myocar-
dial reperfusion injury,” Biochemical and Biophysical Research
Communications, vol. 127, no. 1, pp. 87–93, 1985. [44] Y. Ohara, T. E. Peterson, and D. G. Harrison, “Hypercholes-
terolemia increases endothelial superoxide anion production,”
Journal of Clinical Investigation, vol. 91, no. 6, pp. 2546–2551,
1993. [59] T. Ono, R. Tsuruta, M. Fujita et al., “Xanthine oxidase is one of
the major sources of superoxide anion radicals in blood after
reperfusion in rats with forebrain ischemia/reperfusion,” Brain
Research, vol. 1305, pp. 158–167, 2009. [45] S. Spiekermann, U. Landmesser, S. Dikalov et al., “Electron spin
resonance characterization of vascular xanthine and NAD(P)H
oxidase activity in patients with coronary artery disease: rela-
tion to endothelium-dependent vasodilation,” Circulation, vol. 107, no. 10, pp. 1383–1389, 2003. [60] M. Portugal-Cohen and R. Kohen, “Exposure of human ker-
atinocytes to ischemia, hyperglycemia and their combination
induces oxidative stress via the enzymes inducible nitric oxide
synthase and xanthine oxidase,” Journal of Dermatological
Science, vol. 55, no. 2, pp. 82–90, 2009. [46] C.-C. Yang, M.-C. Ma, C.-T. Chien, M.-S. Wu, W.-K. Sun, and C.-F. 5. Conclusion Chen, “Hypoxic preconditioning attenuates
lipopolysaccharide-induced oxidative stress in rat kidneys,”
The Journal of Physiology, vol. 582, no. 1, pp. 407–419, 2007. [61] M. O. Taha, M. J. Sim˜oes, E. C. Noguerol et al., “Effects
of allopurinol on ischemia and reperfusion in rabbit livers,”
Transplantation Proceedings, vol. 41, no. 3, pp. 820–823, 2009. [47] U. Landmesser, S. Spiekermann, C. Preuss et al., “Angiotensin
II induces endothelial xanthine oxidase activation: role for
endothelial dysfunction in patients with coronary disease,”
Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology, vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 943–948, 2007. [62] S. Peglow, A. H. Toledo, R. Anaya-Prado, F. Lopez-Neblina,
and L. H. Toledo-Pereyra, “Allopurinol and xanthine oxidase
inhibition in liver ischemia reperfusion,” Journal of Hepato-
Biliary-Pancreatic Sciences, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 137–146, 2011. [48] S. A. Nicholas, V. V. Bubnov, I. M. Yasinska, and V. V. Sumbayev,
“Involvement of xanthine oxidase and hypoxia-inducible factor
1 in Toll-like receptor 7/8-mediated activation of caspase 1 and
interleukin-1𝛽,” Cellular and Molecular Life Sciences, vol. 68, no. 1, pp. 151–158, 2011. [63] T. Yoshikawa, S. Ueda, Y. Naito et al., “Role of oxygen-derived
free radicals in gastric mucosal injury induced by ischemia or
ischemia-reperfusion in rats,” Free Radical Research Communi-
cations, vol. 7, no. 3–7, pp. 285–291, 1989. [49] U. F¨orstermann, “Nitric oxide and oxidative stress in vascular
disease,” Pflugers Archiv—European Journal of Physiology, vol. 459, no. 6, pp. 923–939, 2010. [64] V. L. Vega, L. Mardones, M. Maldonado et al., “Xanthine
oxidase released from reperfused hind limbs mediate K¨upffer
cell activation, neutrophil sequestration, and hepatic oxidative
stress in rats subjected to tourniquet shock,” Shock, vol. 14, no. 5, pp. 565–571, 2000. [50] C. R. White, V. Darley-Usmar, W. R. Berrington et al., “Cir-
culating plasma xanthine oxidase contributes to vascular dys-
function in hypercholesterolemic rabbits,” Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,
vol. 93, no. 16, pp. 8745–8749, 1996. [65] J. D. Vaghasiya, N. R. Sheth, Y. S. Bhalodia, and N. P. Jivani,
“Exaggerated liver injury induced by renal ischemia reperfusion
in diabetes: effect of exenatide,” Saudi Journal of Gastroenterol-
ogy, vol. 16, no. 3, pp. 174–180, 2010. [51] O. Elmas, O. Elmas, and S. Caliskan, “Investigation of the
oxidative effect of chronic hyperammonemia on the kidney and
the possible protective effect of allopurinol,” Renal Failure, vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 61–65, 2011. [66] J. Hallfrisch, “Metabolic effects of dietary fructose,” The FASEB
Journal, vol. 5. Conclusion [94] J. Wang, T. Qin, J. Chen et al., “Hyperuricemia and risk of
incident hypertension: a systematic review and meta-analysis
of observational studies,” PLoS ONE, vol. 9, no. 12, Article ID
e114259, 2014. [79] S. Gibbings, N. D. Elkins, H. Fitzgerald et al., “Xanthine
oxidoreductase promotes the inflammatory state of mononu-
clear phagocytes through effects on chemokine expression,
peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-𝛾sumoylation, and
HIF-1𝛼,” Journal of Biological Chemistry, vol. 286, no. 2, pp. 961–
975, 2011. [95] M. Volterrani, F. Iellamo, B. Sposato, and F. Romeo, “Uric
acid lowering therapy in cardiovascular diseases,” International
Journal of Cardiology, vol. 213, pp. 20–22, 2016. [96] S. E. Perez-Pozo, J. Schold, T. Nakagawa, L. G. S´anchez-Lozada,
R. J. Johnson, and J. L. Lillo, “Excessive fructose intake induces
the features of metabolic syndrome in healthy adult men: role
of uric acid in the hypertensive response,” International Journal
of Obesity, vol. 34, no. 3, pp. 454–461, 2010. [80] E. Morse, J. Schroth, Y.-H. You et al., “TRB3 is stimulated in
diabetic kidneys, regulated by the ER stress marker CHOP,
and is a suppressor of podocyte MCP-1,” American Journal of
Physiology—Renal Physiology, vol. 299, no. 5, pp. F965–F972,
2010. [97] D. I. Feig, B. Soletsky, and R. J. Johnson, “Effect of allopurinol
on blood pressure of adolescents with newly diagnosed essential
hypertension: a randomized trial,” The Journal of the American
Medical Association, vol. 300, no. 8, pp. 924–932, 2008. [81] D. B. Corry, P. Eslami, K. Yamamoto, M. D. Nyby, H. Makino,
and M. L. Tuck, “Uric acid stimulates vascular smooth muscle
cell proliferation and oxidative stress via the vascular renin-
angiotensin system,” Journal of Hypertension, vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 269–275, 2008. [98] B. Soletsky and D. I. Feig, “Uric acid reduction rectifies
prehypertension in obese adolescents,” Hypertension, vol. 60,
no. 5, pp. 1148–1156, 2012. [82] T. Kosugi, T. Nakayama, M. Heinig et al., “Effect of lowering
uric acid on renal disease in the type 2 diabetic db/db mice,”
American Journal of Physiology—Renal Physiology, vol. 297, no. 2, pp. F481–F488, 2009. [99] V. Agarwal, N. Hans, and F. H. Messerli, “Effect of allopurinol on
blood pressure: a systematic review and meta-analysis,” Journal
of Clinical Hypertension, vol. 15, no. 6, pp. 435–442, 2013. [83] E.-S. Ryu, M. J. Kim, H.-S. Shin et al., “Uric acid-induced phe-
notypic transition of renal tubular cells as a novel mechanism of
chronic kidney disease,” American Journal of Physiology—Renal
Physiology, vol. 5. Conclusion ¨Ozt¨urk, M. Kac¸maz, K. Karaca, H. Tokuc¸oˇglu,
and I. Durak, “Activities of DNA turnover and free radical
metabolizing enzymes in cancerous human prostate tissue,”
Cancer Investigation, vol. 17, no. 5, pp. 314–319, 1999. [88] S. C. Hunt, S. H. Stephenson, P. N. Hopkins, and R. R. Williams,
“Predictors of an increased risk of future hypertension in Utah. A screening analysis,” Hypertension, vol. 17, no. 6, pp. 969–976,
1991. [74] K. Kishimoto, R. Kobayashi, M. Ichikawa et al., “Risk factors
for tumor lysis syndrome in childhood acute myeloid leukemia
treated with a uniform protocol without rasburicase prophy-
laxis,” Leukemia & Lymphoma, vol. 56, no. 7, pp. 2193–2195, 2015. [89] D. I. Feig and R. J. Johnson, “Hyperuricemia in childhood
primary hypertension,” Hypertension, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 247–252,
2003. [75] A. Kushiyama, H. Okubo, H. Sakoda et al., “Xanthine oxidore-
ductase is involved in macrophage foam cell formation and
atherosclerosis development,” Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and
Vascular Biology, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 291–298, 2012. [90] J. Sundstr¨om, L. Sullivan, R. B. D’Agostino, D. Levy, W. B. Kannel, and R. S. Vasan, “Relations of serum uric acid to lon-
gitudinal blood pressure tracking and hypertension incidence,”
Hypertension, vol. 45, no. 1, pp. 28–33, 2005. [76] T. Ohtsubo, I. I. Rovira, M. F. Starost, C. Liu, and T. Finkel, “Xanthine oxidoreductase is an endogenous regulator of
cyclooxygenase-2,” Circulation Research, vol. 95, no. 11, pp. 1118–
1124, 2004. [91] T. S. Perlstein, O. Gumieniak, G. H. Williams et al., “Uric acid
and the development of hypertension: The Normative Aging
Study,” Hypertension, vol. 48, no. 6, pp. 1031–1036, 2006. [92] E. Krishnan, C. K. Kwoh, H. R. Schumacher, and L. Kuller,
“Hyperuricemia and incidence of hypertension among men
without metabolic syndrome,” Hypertension, vol. 49, no. 2, pp. 298–303, 2007. [77] C. Vorbach, R. Harrison, and M. R. Capecchi, “Xanthine
oxidoreductase is central to the evolution and function of the
innate immune system,” Trends in Immunology, vol. 24, no. 9,
pp. 512–517, 2003. [93] J. P. Forman, H. Choi, and G. C. Curhan, “Uric acid and
insulin sensitivity and risk of incident hypertension,” Archives
of Internal Medicine, vol. 169, no. 2, pp. 155–162, 2009. [78] T. Hartney, R. Birari, S. Venkataraman et al., “Xanthine oxidase-
derived ROS upregulate Egr-1 via ERK1/2 in PA smooth muscle
cells; model to test impact of extracellular ROS in chronic
hypoxia,” PLoS ONE, vol. 6, no. 11, Article ID e27531, 2011. 5. Conclusion 4, no. 9, pp. 2652–2660, 1990. [67] F. Stirpe, E. Della Corte, E. Bonetti, A. Abbondanza, A. Abbati,
and F. De Stefano, “Fructose-induced hyperuricaemia,” The
Lancet, vol. 296, no. 7686, pp. 1310–1311, 1970. [52] M. Faruk Hossain, M. Ismail, A. R. Tanu, and H. Uddin Shekhar,
“Respiratory burst enzymes, pro-oxidants and antioxidants
status in bangladeshi population with 𝛽-thalassemia major,”
North American Journal of Medical Sciences, vol. 7, no. 6, pp. 253–258, 2015. [68] M. A. Lanaspa, L. G. Sanchez-Lozada, C. Cicerchi et al.,
“Uric acid stimulates fructokinase and accelerates fructose
metabolism in the development of fatty liver,” PLOS ONE, vol. 7, no. 10, Article ID e47948, 2012. [53] G. Chen, J. Yang, G. Lu, J. Guo, and Y. Dou, “Limb remote
ischemic post-conditioning reduces brain reperfusion injury by
reversing eNOS uncoupling,” Indian Journal of Experimental
Biology, vol. 52, no. 6, pp. 597–605, 2014. [69] T. F. Roe and M. D. Kogut, “The pathogenesis of hyperuricemia
in glycogen storage disease, type I,” Pediatric Research, vol. 11,
no. 5, pp. 664–669, 1977. [54] L. A. Gabrielli, P. F. Castro, I. Godoy et al., “Systemic oxida-
tive stress and endothelial dysfunction is associated with an
attenuated acute vascular response to inhaled prostanoid in
pulmonary artery hypertension patients,” Journal of Cardiac
Failure, vol. 17, no. 12, pp. 1012–1017, 2011. [70] N. B. Medvedeva, P. L. Telushkin, and A. Y. Stel’makh, “Parame-
ters of nitrogen metabolism during insulin hypoglycemia in rats
with alloxan-induced diabetes,” Bulletin of Experimental Biology
and Medicine, vol. 146, no. 2, pp. 203–205, 2008. [55] R. Aranda, E. Dom´enech, A. D. Rus et al., “Age-related increase
in xanthine oxidase activity in human plasma and rat tissues,”
Free Radical Research, vol. 41, no. 11, pp. 1195–1200, 2007. [71] S. Sachdev and K. J. A. Davies, “Production, detection, and
adaptive responses to free radicals in exercise,” Free Radical
Biology and Medicine, vol. 44, no. 2, pp. 215–223, 2008. 12 Mediators of Inflammation [87] J. V. Selby, G. D. Friedman, and C. P. Quesenberry Jr, “Precursors
of essential hypertension: pulmonary function, heart rate,
uric acid, serum cholesterol, and other serum chemistries,”
American Journal of Epidemiology, vol. 131, no. 6, pp. 1017–1027,
1990. [72] M. F. Vincent, G. Van den Berghe, and H. G. Hers, “The pathway
of adenine nucleotide catabolism and its control in isolated rat
hepatocytes subjected to anoxia,” Biochemical Journal, vol. 202,
no. 1, pp. 117–123, 1982. [73] H. Biri, H. S. 5. Conclusion Larter, “Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease:
from steatosis to cirrhosis,” Hepatology, vol. 43, no. 2, pp. S99–
S112, 2006. [106] A. G. Stack, A. Hanley, L. F. Casserly et al., “Independent and
conjoint associations of gout and hyperuricaemia with total
and cardiovascular mortality,” QJM, vol. 106, no. 7, pp. 647–658,
2013. [124] D. E. Kleiner, E. M. Brunt, M. Van Natta et al., “Design and
validation of a histological scoring system for nonalcoholic fatty
liver disease. Nonalcoholic Steatohepatitis Clinical Research
Network,” Hepatology, vol. 41, no. 6, pp. 1313–1321, 2005. [107] M. Li, X. Hu, Y. Fan et al., “Hyperuricemia and the risk for
coronary heart disease morbidity and mortality a systematic
review and dose-response meta-analysis,” Scientific Reports, vol. 6, article 19520, 2016. [125] C. A. Matteoni, Z. M. Younossi, T. Gramlich, N. Boparai,
Yao Chang Liu, and A. J. McCullough, “Nonalcoholic fatty
liver disease: a spectrum of clinical and pathological severity,”
Gastroenterology, vol. 116, no. 6, pp. 1413–1419, 1999. [108] L. Grimaldi-Bensouda, A. Alp´erovitch, E. Aubrun et al.,
“Impact of allopurinol on risk of myocardial infarction,” Annals
of the Rheumatic Diseases, vol. 74, no. 5, pp. 836–842, 2015. [126] J. D. Browning and J. D. Horton, “Molecular mediators of hep-
atic steatosis and liver injury,” Journal of Clinical Investigation,
vol. 114, no. 2, pp. 147–152, 2004. [109] A. Noman, D. S. Ang, S. Ogston, C. C. Lang, and A. D. Struthers, “Effect of high-dose allopurinol on exercise in
patients with chronic stable angina: a randomised, placebo
controlled crossover trial,” The Lancet, vol. 375, no. 9732, pp. 2161–2167, 2010. [127] J. S. Lim, M. Mietus-Snyder, A. Valente, J.-M. Schwarz, and R. H. Lustig, “The role of fructose in the pathogenesis of NAFLD
and the metabolic syndrome,” Nature Reviews Gastroenterology
and Hepatology, vol. 7, no. 5, pp. 251–264, 2010. [110] J. George, E. Carr, J. Davies, J. J. F. Belch, and A. Struthers,
“High-dose allopurinol improves endothelial function by pro-
foundly reducing vascular oxidative stress and not by lowering
uric acid,” Circulation, vol. 114, no. 23, pp. 2508–2516, 2006. [128] J. W. Lee, Y. K. Cho, M. C. Ryan et al., “Serum uric acid as a
predictor for the development of nonalcoholic fatty liver disease
in apparently healthy subjects: A 5-Year Retrospective Cohort
Study,” Gut and Liver, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 378–383, 2010. [111] N. S. Rajendra, S. Ireland, J. George, J. J. F. Belch, C. C. Lang,
and A. D. 5. Conclusion Struthers, “Mechanistic insights into the therapeutic
use of high-dose allopurinol in angina pectoris,” Journal of the
American College of Cardiology, vol. 58, no. 8, pp. 820–828, 2011. [129] Y. Li, C. Xu, C. Yu, L. Xu, and M. Miao, “Association of serum
uric acid level with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease: a cross-
sectional study,” Journal of Hepatology, vol. 50, no. 5, pp. 1029–
1034, 2009. [112] K. Ogino, M. Kato, Y. Furuse et al., “Uric acid-lowering
treatment with benzbromarone in patients with heart failure: a
double-blind placebo-controlled crossover preliminary study,”
Circulation: Heart Failure, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 73–81, 2010. [130] S. Petta, C. Camm`a, D. Cabibi, V. Di Marco, and A. Crax`ı,
“Hyperuricemia is associated with histological liver damage
in patients with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease,” Alimentary
Pharmacology & Therapeutics, vol. 34, no. 7, pp. 757–766, 2011. [113] Y. Moriwaki, T. Yamamoto, M. Suda et al., “Purification and
immunohistochemical tissue localization of human xanthine
oxidase,” Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, vol. 1164, no. 3, pp. 327–
330, 1993. [131] E. Sertoglu, C. N. Ercin, G. Celebi et al., “The relationship of
serum uric acid with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease,” Clinical
Biochemistry, vol. 47, no. 6, pp. 383–388, 2014. [114] J. Nomura, N. Busso, A. Ives et al., “Xanthine oxidase inhibition
by febuxostat attenuates experimental atherosclerosis in mice,”
Scientific Reports, vol. 4, article no. 4554, 2014. [132] S. M. Lerret, L. Garcia-Rodriguez, J. Skelton, V. Biank, D. Kil-
way, and G. Telega, “Predictors of nonalcoholic steatohepatitis
in obese children,” Gastroenterology Nursing, vol. 34, no. 6, pp. 434–437, 2011. i
[115] H. Cai and D. G. Harrison, “Endothelial dysfunction in car-
diovascular diseases: the role of oxidant stress,” Circulation
Research, vol. 87, no. 10, pp. 840–844, 2000. [133] C. Xu, X. Wan, L. Xu et al., “Xanthine oxidase in non-alcoholic
fatty liver disease and hyperuricemia: one stone hits two birds,”
Journal of Hepatology, vol. 62, no. 6, article 5522, pp. 1412–1419,
2015. [116] K. J. Moore, F. J. Sheedy, and E. A. Fisher, “Macrophages in
atherosclerosis: a dynamic balance,” Nature Reviews Immunol-
ogy, vol. 13, no. 10, pp. 709–721, 2013.l [134] Y. Nakatsu, Y. Seno, A. Kushiyama et al., “The xanthine
oxidase inhibitor febuxostat suppresses development of nonal-
coholic steatohepatitis in a rodent model,” American Journal of
Physiology—Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology, vol. 309, no. 1, pp. G42–G51, 2015. [117] P. Duewell, H. Kono, K. J. 5. Conclusion 304, no. 5, pp. F471–F480, 2013. [100] M. Mazzali, J. Hughes, Y.-G. Kim et al., “Elevated uric
acid increases blood pressure in the rat by a novel crystal-
independent mechanism,” Hypertension, vol. 38, no. 5, pp. 1101–
1106, 2001. [84] J. Nomura, N. Busso, A. Ives et al., “Febuxostat, an inhibitor
of xanthine oxidase, suppresses lipopolysaccharide-induced
MCP-1 production via MAPK phosphatase-1-mediated inacti-
vation of JNK,” PLOS ONE, vol. 8, no. 9, Article ID e75527, 2013. [101] M. Mazzali, J. Kanellis, L. Han et al., “Hyperuricemia induces
a primary renal arteriolopathy in rats by a blood pressure-
independent mechanism,” American Journal of Physiology—
Renal Physiology, vol. 282, no. 6, pp. F991–F997, 2002. [85] N. Davis, “The cardiovascular and renal relations and manifes-
tations of gout,” JAMA, vol. 29, pp. 261–262, 1897. [102] M. H. Alderman, H. Cohen, S. Madhavan, and S. Kivlighn,
“Serum uric acid and cardiovascular events in successfully
treated hypertensive patients,” Hypertension, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 144–150, 1999. [86] D. I. Feig, D.-H. Kang, and R. J. Johnson, “Uric acid and
cardiovascular risk,” The New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 359, no. 17, pp. 1811–1821, 2008. Mediators of Inflammation 13 [103] P. Verdecchia, G. Schillaci, G. Reboldi, F. Santeusanio, C. Porcellati, and P. Brunetti, “Relation between serum uric acid
and risk of cardiovascular disease in essential hypertension: The
PIUMA study,” Hypertension, vol. 36, no. 6, pp. 1072–1078, 2000. [120] G. N. Rao, M. A. Corson, and B. C. Berk, “Uric acid stimulates
vascular smooth muscle cell proliferation by increasing platelet-
derived growth factor A-chain expression,” The Journal of
Biological Chemistry, vol. 266, no. 13, pp. 8604–8608, 1991. [104] M. J. Bos, P. J. Koudstaal, A. Hofman, J. C. M. Witteman, and
M. M. B. Breteler, “Uric acid is a risk factor for myocardial
infarction and stroke: the Rotterdam Study,” Stroke, vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 1503–1507, 2006. [121] R. Loomba and A. J. Sanyal, “The global NAFLD epidemic,”
Nature Reviews Gastroenterology and Hepatology, vol. 10, no. 11,
pp. 686–690, 2013. [122] S. Mittal and H. B. El-Serag, “Epidemiology of hepatocellular
carcinoma: consider the population,” Journal of Clinical Gas-
troenterology, vol. 47, no. 1, pp. S2–S6, 2013. [105] H. K. Choi and G. Curhan, “Independent impact of gout on
mortality and risk for coronary heart disease,” Circulation, vol. 116, no. 8, pp. 894–900, 2007. [123] G. C. Farrell and C. Z. 5. Conclusion [154] S. Kodama, K. Saito, Y. Yachi et al., “Association between serum
uric acid and development of type 2 diabetes,” Diabetes Care,
vol. 32, no. 9, pp. 1737–1742, 2009. [140] J. Henao-Mejia, E. Elinav, C. Jin et al., “Inflammasome-
mediated dysbiosis regulates progression of NAFLD and obe-
sity,” Nature, vol. 482, no. 7384, pp. 179–185, 2012. [155] Z. Jia, X. Zhang, S. Kang, and Y. Wu, “Serum uric acid levels
and incidence of impaired fasting glucose and type 2 diabetes
mellitus: a meta-analysis of cohort studies,” Diabetes Research
and Clinical Practice, vol. 101, no. 1, pp. 88–96, 2013. [141] A. Wree, M. D. McGeough, C. A. Pe˜na et al., “NLRP3 inflamma-
some activation is required for fibrosis development in NAFLD,”
Journal of Molecular Medicine, vol. 92, no. 10, pp. 1069–1082,
2014. [156] Q. Lv, X.-F. Meng, F.-F. He et al., “High serum uric acid and
increased risk of type 2 diabetes: a systemic review and meta-
analysis of prospective cohort studies,” PLoS ONE, vol. 8, no. 2,
Article ID e56864, 2013. [142] L. J. Dixon, C. A. Flask, B. G. Papouchado, A. E. Feldstein, and
L. E. Nagy, “Caspase-1 as a central regulator of high fat diet-
induced non-alcoholic steatohepatitis,” PLoS ONE, vol. 8, no. 2,
Article ID e56100, 2013. [157] R. Pfister, D. Barnes, R. Luben et al., “No evidence for a
causal link between uric acid and type 2 diabetes: a mendelian
randomisation approach,” Diabetologia, vol. 54, no. 10, pp. 2561–
2569, 2011. [143] T. Matsuzaka, A. Atsumi, R. Matsumori et al., “Elovl6 promotes
nonalcoholic steatohepatitis,” Hepatology, vol. 56, no. 6, pp. 2199–2208, 2012. [158] I. Sluijs, M. V. Holmes, Y. T. van der Schouw et al., “A
mendelian randomization study of circulating uric acid and
type 2 diabetes,” Diabetes, vol. 64, no. 8, pp. 3028–3036, 2015. [144] K. Miura, L. Yang, N. van Rooijen, D. A. Brenner, H. Ohnishi,
and E. Seki, “Toll-like receptor 2 and palmitic acid cooperatively
contribute to the development of nonalcoholic steatohepatitis
through inflammasome activation in mice,” Hepatology, vol. 57,
no. 2, pp. 577–589, 2013. [159] O. Yiginer, F. Ozcelik, T. Inanc et al., “Allopurinol improves
endothelial
function
and
reduces
oxidant-inflammatory
enzyme of myeloperoxidase in metabolic syndrome,” Clinical
Research in Cardiology, vol. 97, no. 5, pp. 334–340, 2008. [145] A. Bashiri, D. Nesan, G. 5. Conclusion Tavallaee et al., “Cellular cholesterol
accumulation modulates high fat high sucrose (HFHS) diet-
induced ER stress and hepatic inflammasome activation in the
development of non-alcoholic steatohepatitis,” Biochimica et
Biophysica Acta—Molecular and Cell Biology of Lipids, vol. 1861,
no. 7, pp. 594–605, 2016. [160] E. Fabbrini, M. Serafini, I. C. Baric, S. L. Hazen, and S. Klein,
“Effect of plasma uric acid on antioxidant capacity, oxidative
stress, and insulin sensitivity in obese subjects,” Diabetes, vol. 63, no. 3, pp. 976–981, 2014. [161] G. van den Berghe, M. Bronfman, R. Vanneste, and H. G. Hers,
“The mechanism of adenosine triphosphate depletion in the
liver after a load of fructose. A kinetic study of liver adenylate
deaminase,” Biochemical Journal, vol. 162, no. 3, pp. 601–609,
1977. [146] W. Rathmann, E. Funkhouser, A. R. Dyer, and J. M. Roseman,
“Relations of hyperuricemia with the various components of the
insulin resistance syndrome in young black and white adults:
the CARDIA study,” Annals of Epidemiology, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 250–261, 1998. [162] C. Cicerchi, N. Li, J. Kratzer et al., “Uric acid-dependent
inhibition of AMP kinase induces hepatic glucose production in
diabetes and starvation: evolutionary implications of the uricase
loss in hominids,” FASEB Journal, vol. 28, no. 8, pp. 3339–3350,
2014. [147] F. Facchini, Y.-D. I. Chen, C. B. Hollenbeck, and G. M. Reaven,
“Relationship between resistance to insulin-mediated glucose
uptake, urinary uric acid clearance, and plasma uric acid
concentration,” Journal of the American Medical Association,
vol. 266, no. 21, pp. 3008–3011, 1991. [163] M. A. Lanaspa, C. Cicerchi, G. Garcia et al., “Counteracting
roles of AMP deaminase and AMP kinase in the development
of fatty liver,” PLoS ONE, vol. 7, no. 11, Article ID e48801, 2012. [148] W. Y. Tae, C. S. Ki, S. S. Hun et al., “Relationship between serum
uric acid concentration and insulin resistance and metabolic
syndrome,” Circulation Journal, vol. 69, no. 8, pp. 928–933, 2005. [164] Y.-J. Choi, Y. Yoon, K.-Y. Lee et al., “Uric acid induces endothe-
lial dysfunction by vascular insulin resistance associated with
the impairment of nitric oxide synthesis,” FASEB Journal, vol. 28, no. 7, pp. 3197–3204, 2014. [149] E. S. Ford, C. Li, S. Cook, and H. K. Choi, “Serum concen-
trations of uric acid and the metabolic syndrome among US
children and adolescents,” Circulation, vol. 115, no. 19, pp. 2526–
2532, 2007. [165] Y. Zhu, Y. Hu, T. 5. Conclusion Rayner et al., “NLRP3 inflammasomes
are required for atherogenesis and activated by cholesterol
crystals,” Nature, vol. 464, no. 7293, pp. 1357–1361, 2010. [118] M. Mishima, T. Hamada, N. Maharani et al., “Effects of Uric
Acid on the NO Production of HUVECs and its Restoration by
Urate Lowering Agents,” Drug Research, vol. 66, no. 05, pp. 270–
274, 2016. [135] Y. Tsushima, H. Nishizawa, Y. Tochino et al., “Uric acid
secretion from adipose tissue and its increase in obesity,” Journal
of Biological Chemistry, vol. 288, no. 38, pp. 27138–27149, 2013. [119] U. M. Khosla, S. Zharikov, J. L. Finch et al., “Hyperuricemia
induces endothelial dysfunction,” Kidney International, vol. 67,
no. 5, pp. 1739–1742, 2005. [136] M. A. Lanaspa, L. G. Sanchez-Lozada, Y.-J. Choi et al., “Uric
acid induces hepatic steatosis by generation of mitochondrial 14 Mediators of Inflammation oxidative stress: potential role in fructose-dependent and -
independent fatty liver,” Journal of Biological Chemistry, vol. 287,
no. 48, pp. 40732–40744, 2012. hepatic steatosis,” American Journal of Cardiology, vol. 110, no. 12, pp. 1787–1792, 2012. [151] B. E. K. Klein, R. Klein, and K. E. Lee, “Components of the
metabolic syndrome and risk of cardiovascular disease and
diabetes in Beaver Dam,” Diabetes Care, vol. 25, no. 10, pp. 1790–
1794, 2002. [137] [137] Y.-J. Choi, H.-S. Shin, H. S. Choi et al., “Uric acid induces
fat accumulation via generation of endoplasmic reticulum
stress and SREBP-1c activation in hepatocytes,” Laboratory
Investigation, vol. 94, no. 10, pp. 1114–1125, 2014. [152] H. Yuan, C. Yu, X. Li et al., “Serum uric acid levels and
risk of metabolic syndrome: a dose-response meta-analysis
of prospective studies,” Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and
Metabolism, vol. 100, no. 11, pp. 4198–4207, 2015. [138] Y. Y. Sautin, T. Nakagawa, S. Zharikov, and R. J. John-
son, “Adverse effects of the classic antioxidant uric acid in
adipocytes: NADPH oxidase-mediated oxidative/nitrosative
stress,” American Journal of Physiology—Cell Physiology, vol. 293, no. 2, pp. C584–C596, 2007. [153] V. Bhole, J. W. J. Choi, S. Woo Kim, M. De Vera, and H. Choi, “Serum uric acid levels and the risk of type 2 diabetes: A
Prospective Study,” American Journal of Medicine, vol. 123, no. 10, pp. 957–961, 2010. [139] W. Baldwin, S. McRae, G. Marek et al., “Hyperuricemia as a
mediator of the proinflammatory endocrine imbalance in the
adipose tissue in a murine model of the metabolic syndrome,”
Diabetes, vol. 60, no. 4, pp. 1258–1269, 2011. 5. Conclusion Huang et al., “High uric acid directly inhibits
insulin signalling and induces insulin resistance,” Biochemical
and Biophysical Research Communications, vol. 447, no. 4, pp. 707–714, 2014. [150] T. Keenan, M. J. Blaha, K. Nasir et al., “Relation of uric
acid to serum levels of high-sensitivity c-reactive protein,
triglycerides, and high-density lipoprotein cholesterol and to Mediators of Inflammation 15 [166] H.-J. Lee, K. H. Jeong, Y. G. Kim et al., “Febuxostat ameliorates
diabetic renal injury in a streptozotocin-induced diabetic rat
model,” American Journal of Nephrology, vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 56–
63, 2014. reperfusion-induced edema in gerbil brains,” The Journal of
Clinical Investigation, vol. 81, no. 5, pp. 1556–1562, 1988. [181] A. Kumar, G. Bhawani, N. Kumari, K. S. N. Murthy, V. Lalwani, and C. N. Raju, “Comparative study of renal protective
effects of allopurinol and n-acetyl-cysteine on contrast induced
nephropathy in patients undergoing cardiac catheterization,”
Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research, vol. 8, no. 12, pp. HC03–HC07, 2014. [167] L. G. S´anchez-Lozada, E. Tapia, V. Soto et al., “Effect of febux-
ostat on the progression of renal disease in 5/6 nephrectomy
rats with and without hyperuricemia,” Nephron—Physiology,
vol. 108, no. 4, pp. 69–78, 2008. [182] S. Wang, Y. Li, X. Song et al., “Febuxostat pretreatment attenu-
ates myocardial ischemia/reperfusion injury via mitochondrial
apoptosis,” Journal of Translational Medicine, vol. 13, no. 1,
article 209, 2015. [168] H. Omori, N. Kawada, K. Inoue et al., “Use of xanthine oxidase
inhibitor febuxostat inhibits renal interstitial inflammation and
fibrosis in unilateral ureteral obstructive nephropathy,” Clinical
and Experimental Nephrology, vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 549–556, 2012. [183] M. Duda, A. Konior, E. Klemenska, and A. Beresewicz, “Pre-
conditioning protects endothelium by preventing ET-1-induced
activation of NADPH oxidase and xanthine oxidase in post-
ischemic heart,” Journal of Molecular and Cellular Cardiology,
vol. 42, no. 2, pp. 400–410, 2007. [169] H. Tsuda, N. Kawada, J.-Y. Kaimori et al., “Febuxostat sup-
pressed renal ischemia-reperfusion injury via reduced oxidative
stress,” Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications,
vol. 427, no. 2, pp. 266–272, 2012. [170] K. Tanaka, S. Hara, A. Kushiyama et al., “Risk of macrovascular
disease stratified by stage of chronic kidney disease in type
2 diabetic patients: critical level of the estimated glomerular
filtration rate and the significance of hyperuricemia,” Clinical
and Experimental Nephrology, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. 391–397, 2011. [171] K. Tanaka, S. Hara, M. 5. Conclusion Hattori et al., “Role of elevated serum
uric acid levels at the onset of overt nephropathy in the risk for
renal function decline in patients with type 2 diabetes,” Journal
of Diabetes Investigation, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 98–104, 2015. [172] K. Tanaka, M. Nakayama, M. Kanno et al., “Renoprotective
effects of febuxostat in hyperuricemic patients with chronic
kidney disease: a parallel-group, randomized, controlled trial,”
Clinical and Experimental Nephrology, vol. 19, no. 6, pp. 1044–
1053, 2015. [173] S. Kato, M. Ando, T. Mizukoshi et al., “Randomized control trial
for the assessment of the anti-albuminuric effects of topiroxo-
stat in hyperuricemic patients with diabetic nephropathy (the
ETUDE study),” Nagoya Journal of Medical Science, vol. 78, no. 2, pp. 135–142, 2016. [174] L. G. S´anchez-Lozada, E. Tapia, P. Bautista-Garc´ıa et al., “Effects
of febuxostat on metabolic and renal alterations in rats with
fructose-induced metabolic syndrome,” American Journal of
Physiology—Renal Physiology, vol. 294, no. 4, pp. F710–F718,
2008. [175] C. Xu, X. Wan, L. Xu et al., “Xanthine oxidase in non-alcoholic
fatty liver disease and hyperuricemia: one stone hits two birds,”
Journal of Hepatology, vol. 62, no. 6, pp. 1412–1419, 2015. [176] K. Schr¨oder, C. Vecchione, O. Jung et al., “Xanthine oxidase
inhibitor tungsten prevents the development of atherosclerosis
in ApoE knockout mice fed a Western-type diet,” Free Radical
Biology and Medicine, vol. 41, no. 9, pp. 1353–1360, 2006. [177] K. G. Soucy, H. K. Lim, D. O. Attarzadeh et al., “Dietary
inhibition of xanthine oxidase attenuates radiation-induced
endothelial dysfunction in rat aorta,” Journal of Applied Phys-
iology, vol. 108, no. 5, pp. 1250–1258, 2010. [178] R. P. Jankov, C. Kantores, J. Pan, and J. Belik, “Contribution
of xanthine oxidase-derived superoxide to chronic hypoxic
pulmonary hypertension in neonatal rats,” American Journal of
Physiology—Lung Cellular and Molecular Physiology, vol. 294,
no. 2, pp. L233–L245, 2008. [179] A. N. Shafik, “Febuxostat improves the local and remote organ
changes induced by intestinal ischemia/reperfusion in rats,”
Digestive Diseases and Sciences, vol. 58, no. 3, pp. 650–659, 2013. [180] A. Patt, A. H. harken, L. K. Burton et al., “Xanthine
oxidase-derived hydrogen peroxide contributes to ischemia
|
https://openalex.org/W2214279053
|
https://www.nature.com/articles/srep18037.pdf
|
English
| null |
CellMethy: Identification of a focal concordantly methylated pattern of CpGs revealed wide differences between normal and cancer tissues
|
Scientific reports
| 2,015
|
cc-by
| 8,962
|
CellMethy: Identification of a focal
concordantly methylated pattern
of CpGs revealed wide differences
between normal and cancer tissues
Fang Wang1,*, Shaojun Zhang1,*, Hongbo Liu1, Yanjun Wei1, Yihan Wang1, Xiaole Han1,
Jianzhong Su1, Dongwei Zhang2, Baodong Xie3 & Yan Zhang1
ved: 23 June 2015
0 November 2015
0 December 2015
OPEN received: 23 June 2015
accepted: 10 November 2015
Published: 10 December 2015 received: 23 June 2015
accepted: 10 November 2015
Published: 10 December 2015 DNA methylation patterns may serve as a key in determining cell phenotypes and functions. Adjacent
CpG patterns may provide insight into methylation functional mechanisms. Some regions display
different DNA methylation patterns between normal and cancer tissues, but the same average
methylation level. Here, we developed a method (CellMethy) to infer a region in which all CpGs exhibit
concordant methylation (CM) and to quantify the extent of CM in the region. Using simulation data,
CellMethy showed high performance in discovering the concordant methylation patterns (AUC = 0.89). CellMethy was then applied to RRBS data including 11 normal tissues and 12 tumors. We found that the
extent of CM exhibited wider differentials among tissues than did the average methylation levels from
the CM regions, with 45% of CM regions occurring specifically in one tissue and mainly in tumors. Then,
we identified CM regions through genome wide bisulfite sequencing (GWBS) data on breast cancer. Approximately 82% of CM regions revealed a significantly different extent of CM between cancer and
normal tissues. CellMethy can accurately describe concordantly methylated regions, and the results
suggest that CM might also serve as a stable marker of cell sub-populations. Genomes of multiple species are tagged by epigenetic markers, including the methylation of cytosine within DNA. DNA methylation is one of the most important epigenetic modifications and plays important roles in germline
development1,2, embryogenesis3, and somatic differentiation4–6. Methylation modifications throughout the genome
are referred to as the ‘methylome’7. DNA methylation has been shown to occur in both regional and preserved local
activity states, such as during gene transcription8. DNA methylation patterns may serve as a key in determining
cell phenotypes and functions. Recently, a large number of studies have identified numerous differential regions
based on average methylation levels across tissues9–11. In addition, many cancer-related hyper-methylated and
hypo-methylated regions have been found10,12–14, and several onco- and tumor-suppressor genes frequently alter
epigenetic states in tumors15. However, DNA methylation patterns are highly divergent among various cell types,
especially comparing tumor and normal cells16–18. Unlike the genomic DNA sequence, the epigenome is variable
among tissues/cells even from the same individual19. There are at least as many methylomes as cell types, and
fluctuations occur within a single cell according to cellular and environmental conditions20. www.nature.com/scientificreports www.nature.com/scientificreports www.nature.com/scientificreports Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 CellMethy: Identification of a focal
concordantly methylated pattern
of CpGs revealed wide differences
between normal and cancer tissues
Fang Wang1,*, Shaojun Zhang1,*, Hongbo Liu1, Yanjun Wei1, Yihan Wang1, Xiaole Han1,
Jianzhong Su1, Dongwei Zhang2, Baodong Xie3 & Yan Zhang1
ved: 23 June 2015
0 November 2015
0 December 2015
OPEN DNA methylation
patterns within a cell population from somatic tissue are highly heterogeneous and polymorphic21. Currently,
more high-throughput sequencing data are available, which make possible to observe each methylation pattern
in cell populations.f p p
Although average DNA methylation levels have proven their powers, the mechanism of underlying different
methylation patterns remains poorly understood. Some studies have observed that adjacent CpGs within a region
exhibit co-methylation states, especially within CpG islands (CGI)22,23. The methylation patterns of adjacent CpGs
may provide insight into methylation functional mechanisms. Different methylation patterns within a cell popu-
lation may result in an identical average methylation level of the region but represent the outcomes of markedly 1College of Bioinformatics Science and Technology, Harbin Medical University, 150081, Harbin. 2The 2nd Affiliated
Hospital, Harbin Medical University, Harbin, 150081, China. 3The Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, The Second
Affiliated Hospital, Harbin Medical University, Harbin, 150081, China. *These authors contributed equally to this work. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to Y.Z. (email: tyozhang@ems.hrbmu.edu.cn) or B.X. (email: baodongxie_doctor@aliyun.com) Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 1 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 1. Outline of CellMethy. (A) Diagram of concordant methylation in cell. Balls indicated by blue
shading represent individual cells from the tissue. Filled and empty circles represent methylated and
unmethylated CpGs, respectively. Rows represent methylation patterns of each sequencing read. The regions in
different somatic tissues showed similar average methylation levels (55%) but different methylation patterns. CM fractions represent the extent of concordant methylation of adjacent CpGs in the region. (B) Flowchart of
identification and quantification of CMR. Empty circles represent CpGs in the human genome. Blue empty bars
represent sequencing reads, in which red and gray represent methylated and unmethylated states corresponding
to the genome CpG. Scatter points in the fitting curve represent the CM fraction of sliding windows, the
horizontal axis represents the physical position of the genomem, and dx and dy represent the physical distance
of two adjacent siliding windows. Figure 1. Outline of CellMethy. (A) Diagram of concordant methylation in cell. Balls indicated by blue
shading represent individual cells from the tissue. Filled and empty circles represent methylated and
unmethylated CpGs, respectively. Rows represent methylation patterns of each sequencing read. The regions in
different somatic tissues showed similar average methylation levels (55%) but different methylation patterns. CM fractions represent the extent of concordant methylation of adjacent CpGs in the region. CellMethy: Identification of a focal
concordantly methylated pattern
of CpGs revealed wide differences
between normal and cancer tissues
Fang Wang1,*, Shaojun Zhang1,*, Hongbo Liu1, Yanjun Wei1, Yihan Wang1, Xiaole Han1,
Jianzhong Su1, Dongwei Zhang2, Baodong Xie3 & Yan Zhang1
ved: 23 June 2015
0 November 2015
0 December 2015
OPEN (B) Flowchart of
identification and quantification of CMR. Empty circles represent CpGs in the human genome. Blue empty bars
represent sequencing reads, in which red and gray represent methylated and unmethylated states corresponding
to the genome CpG. Scatter points in the fitting curve represent the CM fraction of sliding windows, the
horizontal axis represents the physical position of the genomem, and dx and dy represent the physical distance
of two adjacent siliding windows. different epigenetic mechanisms. We have termed the adjacent concordantly methylated CpG patterns in a region
focal concordantly methylated patterns. Here, we aimed to identify concordantly methylated patterns of adjacent CpGs using high-throughput,
single-base-resolution DNA methylation data. Adjacent CpGs within a region tend toward co-methylation, and
the aberrance of concordant methylation between adjacent CpGs in specific regions is often invoked as a direct
driver of the carcinogenic process. Therefore, we focused on the focal concordant methylation of adjacent CpGs. A
computational approach (CellMethy) was developed to identify regions containing concordantly methylated DNA
(CM region, CMR) and to quantify the extent of genomic regions that share a common concordant methylation
status. Tthe methylation status in each sequence read, called an epiallele21, can be regarded as a representation of
the “haplo-methy-type” in each cell. The ratio of concordant methylation “haplo-methy-type” can be estimated as
a novel biomarker representing the cell sub-population. CellMethy can be used to analyze methylation patterns
in mixed cell populations, including tumor cells; may be beneficial in exploring cell subpopulations with unique
DNA methylation patterns and can be regarded as a biomarker representing a cell subpopulation. Results
O er ie Black lines represent the ROC curve of average methylation levels with
the AUC value of 0.50 (Meth). (B) The correlation between predicted and theoretical values of CM fractions. R-square was calculated by linear regression model. window and the coverage depth. The state of each CpG site in each simulation dataset was generated randomly
(random methylated data) or identically to the state of the adjacent CpG (concordantly methylated data) (see
Methods). With the size of sliding windows ranging from 2 to 10 CpGs, CMRs were identified in both random
and concordantly methylated simulation data. We found that the characteristics of CMRs, including the number of
regions (Supplementary Figure 1), number of CpGs (Supplementary Figure 2), and CM fraction (Supplementary
Figure 3), did not vary with coverage depth. However, the characteristics did vary with sliding window size. CM
was significantly different between the random and concordantly methylated data when the sliding window length
was greater than 4. Moreover, the probability distribution of the CM fraction was similar to the theoretical uniform
distribution in random methylated data but similar to the bimodal distribution in concordantly methylated data. Thus, the sliding window length and the least coverage depth were defined as 5 and 10× in the following analysis,
respectively.h The power of CellMethy in identifying concordant methylation patterns compared to average methylation levels
was measured through simulation data. A methylation value randomly selected from 0.1 to 0.9 was considered the
theoretical value of each region. CM (positive) and random methylation (negative) were simulated based on the
theoretical value, and replication was randomized 1000 times. Both the CM fraction and the average methylation
levels were estimated in each region. The theoretical value of each region in the positive set was regarded as the true
CM fraction. As shown in Fig. 2A, the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) of CellMethy
was 0.89, which can accurately distinguish between concordant and random methylation patterns. When average
methylation levels were used as the distinguishing indicator, the AUC value was 0.50, corresponding to the power
of random prediction. Moreover, the predicted values of the CM fraction were highly correlated with the true value
(R2 = 0.88, Fig. 2B). Above all, CellMethy not only showed high performance in distinguishing the concordant
methylation pattern, but also accurately estimated the extent of CM in a cell population. Concordantly methylated patterns are characteristic across cells/tissues. Results
O er ie Overview of CellMethy. CellMethy was developed to identify CMR and quantify its extent in a cell popu-
lation based on single-base-resolution DNA methylation data. The region shown in Fig. 1A, displayed different
DNA methylation patterns but the same average methylation level (0.55), upon comparing the cell populations. However, the quantization of the CMR is great enough to reflect the differential methylation patterns between cell
populations (CM fraction = 0 vs. 0.49). Therefore, it is very important to accurately assess DNA methylation in a
cell population, as different DNA methylation patterns may result in differential epigenetic regulation mechanisms,
driving multiple cell phenotypes. g
p
p
yp
A brief overview of CellMethy is outlined in Fig. 1B. First, the reference genome was divided into small win-
dows based on the number of CpGs after sequencing reads were mapped to the reference genome. Starting from
the sliding window, the CellMethy algorithm claimed that all CpGs in the window were commonly covered by at
least 10 sequencing reads. The fraction of reads in which all CpGs were concordantly methylated was calculated
(CM fraction). Second, the hot spot was selected as the location in which the CM fraction was the highest in the
neighborhood. We extended the hot spot to both sides of the window until the CM fraction equaled zero or the
distance between two adjacent windows was greater than 100 bp. Lastly, CMRs were determined and quantified
based on the definite integral strategy (see Methods). dentification and assessment of CMR in simulation data. Simulation datasets with four different
overage depths (10× , 20× , 50× , and 100× ) were used to estimate parameters, including the length of the sliding Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 2 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 2. Performance evaluation on identification and quantification of CMRs based on simulation data. (A) Receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC) of CMR. Red lines represent the ROC curve of CellMethy
with the AUC value of 0.89 (CM). Black lines represent the ROC curve of average methylation levels with
the AUC value of 0.50 (Meth). (B) The correlation between predicted and theoretical values of CM fractions. R-square was calculated by linear regression model. Figure 2. Performance evaluation on identification and quantification of CMRs based on simulation data. (A) Receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC) of CMR. Red lines represent the ROC curve of CellMethy
with the AUC value of 0.89 (CM). Results
O er ie We applied CellMethy
to RRBS data downloaded from the Encode Project including 11 normal cells/tissues and 12 tumors. The lengths
of CMRs identified in normal cells/tissues were similar, especially H1 ESC, which showed the highest CM extent
among normal cells/tissues (Table 1). We found that the H1 ESC and testis showed an increased CM fraction
compared to other normal tissues, corresponding to different average methylation levels, especially in the testis,
which was almost linearly correlated with average methylation levels (Fig. 3A). It has been suggested that meth-
ylation patterns within germline and pluripotent cell populations maintain a stable state but undergo stochastic
variation processes during subsequent somatic development. Therefore, decreased CM fraction at similar average
methylation levels were observed in other somatic cells/tissues. This result was consistent with the conclusion of
epipolymorphism, which was lower H1 ESC and testis21. y
Compared to normal cells, tumor cells contained longer CMRs, involved more CpGs, and showed a higher
CM extent (Fig. 3B). Moreover, the promoter, 5′ -UTR, exon, intron, 3′ -UTR, DNase I hypersensitive sites (DHS),
CGI, and CpG island shore (CGS) all revealed higher occupancy rates of CMRs in cancer than in normal cells/
tissues. The greatest difference between cancerous and normal cells/tissues was observed in CGI (Fig. 3C). Some
CMRs were located in DHS and had the lowest CM fraction (Fig. 3D). Due to the inhibition of transcription from
DNA methylation, regions marking active chromatin and controlling active transcription, such as the promoter
and DHS, showed an inverse correlation with CM. However, smaller occupancy rates but a higher extent of CMRs
were located in the CGS compared to the CGI. The CGI shore was associated with the differentiation of tissues
but had lower CpG density than the CGI. It is implied that a high CM extent located in the CGI shore may be due
to differences among tissues. Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 3 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Sample
NO. Length ± SD
NO. Results
O er ie CG ± SD
CM ± SD
M ± SD
Normal
H1 ESC
2903
39.6 ± 41.03
6 ± 3
0.65 ± 0.31
0.93 ± 0.29
SF
3533
37.47 ± 38.56
6 ± 2
0.43 ± 0.34
0.78 ± 0.34
HMEC
3316
35.56 ± 33.35
6 ± 2
0.49 ± 0.36
0.70 ± 0.33
SMC
10144
38.09 ± 37.96
6 ± 2
0.19 ± 0.30
0.30 ± 0.36
BL 1
3141
35.74 ± 33.25
6 ± 2
0.52 ± 0.34
0.89 ± 0.27
BL 2
2431
34.85 ± 30.59
6 ± 2
0.43 ± 0.32
0.71 ± 0.28
Pancreas
2790
33.39 ± 30.19
6 ± 2
0.34 ± 0.34
0.51 ± 0.36
Skeleton
3646
36.36 ± 33.75
6 ± 2
0.39 ± 0.35
0.65 ± 0.35
Skin
4702
37.23 ± 37.42
6 ± 3
0.37 ± 0.35
0.52 ± 0.37
Testis
3908
36.99 ± 35.79
6 ± 3
0.34 ± 0.33
0.43 ± 0.36
Uterus
4351
35.88 ± 34.44
6 ± 2
0.37 ± 0.35
0.56 ± 0.37
Normal Mean
4078
36.47
6
0.41
0.63
Cancer
Lung
5347
45.74 ± 52.10
7 ± 3
0.65 ± 0.33
0.76 ± 0.27
Colon
7137
49.85 ± 59.29
7 ± 4
0.64 ± 0.35
0.75 ± 0.36
Endometrium
5019
43.64 ± 49.29
7 ± 3
0.57 ± 0.33
0.77 ± 0.26
Neuroblastoma
5598
45.31 ± 54.19
7 ± 4
0.51 ± 0.35
0.69 ± 0.32
AML
6637
50.35 ± 58.80
7 ± 4
0.62 ± 0.34
0.77 ± 0.30
Cervial
7544
58.87 ± 71.41
8 ± 5
0.69 ± 0.29
0.83 ± 0.24
Liver
6345
50.27 ± 61.54
7 ± 4
0.52 ± 0.33
0.73 ± 0.27
PML
5674
38.12 ± 39.70
6 ± 3
0.41 ± 0.37
0.61 ± 0.35
ACL
4886
39.79 ± 41.56
7 ± 3
0.51 ± 0.35
0.71 ± 0.31
CLL
5156
51.66 ± 62.36
7 ± 4
0.46 ± 0.31
0.70 ± 0.26
Prostate
6541
48.21 ± 57.90
7 ± 4
0.48 ± 0.33
0.70 ± 0.29
Breast
11183
64.08 ± 68.72
8 ± 5
0.63 ± 0.31
0.79 ± 0.28
Cancer Mean
6422
48.82
7
0.56
0.73
Table 1. Identification of CMRs based on RRBS data from Encode. NO.: The number of CMRs whose CM
fraction were more than 0, identified from the sample. Length: average length of CMRs corresponding to the
sample. SD: standard deviation. NO.CG: average number of CGs in CMRs. Results
O er ie CM: average CM fraction of all
CMRs corresponding to the sample. M: average methylation level of each sample. Table 1. Identification of CMRs based on RRBS data from Encode. NO.: The number of CMRs whose CM
fraction were more than 0, identified from the sample. Length: average length of CMRs corresponding to the
sample. SD: standard deviation. NO.CG: average number of CGs in CMRs. CM: average CM fraction of all
CMRs corresponding to the sample. M: average methylation level of each sample. Combined with average methylation levels, we found that the extent of CM was significantly different between
normal and cancerous cells, especially in moderately methylated regions (0.2 ~ 0.8) (Fig. 3E, Supplementary Figure 4). It is suggested that, compared to normal tissue, adjacent CpGs in moderately methylated regions are more prone
to co-methylation in cancerous tissue. However, lower correlations of CM fractions were observed among cancers
than in normal cells/tissues. Moreover, the correlations of CM fractions among cells were lower than the corre-
lations of average methylation levels (Fig. 3F). Interestingly, breast cell lines (MCF) showed global differences in
CMRs compared to both normal and cancer tissues. This result hinted thatthe focal concordant methylation may
diverge more among tissues than their average methylation levels, and may be regarded as biomarkers of different
tissues, especially in cancers.h p
y
Thus, the average quantity of CM in normal tissue and the standard deviation within each tissue were calculated. As expected, CM showed greater variation than the average methylation levels both in normal and cancerous
tissues, with the greatest variation observed in cancer (Fig. 4A). Moreover, the average differential degrees of the
CM fraction between cancerous and normal tissue within the promoter, 5′ -UTR, exon, intron, 3′ -UTR, CGI,
and CGS were greater than the average methylation levels (Fig. 4B). Distribution of the number of samples that
shared the same CM or methylation regions revealed that although the vast majority (approximately ~45%) of
CMRs were methylated in all 23 tissues, more than 45% of CMRs revealed a concordantly methylated pattern only
in one tissue and were enriched primarily in cancer cells (Fig. 4C), suggesting concordant methylarion is highly
specific. It is noteworthy that these cancer-specific CMRs were primarily enriched in breast cancer (Fig. 4D). These
results indicate that the extent of concordant methylation exhibits greater differences among cells/tissues and has
specificity in cancerous cells. Results
O er ie Together, the extent of concordant methylation was
larger in tumors than in normal tissue and seems to reflect a dynamic mechanism of methylation that drive the
formation of tumor cells. identified 1407 DCMRs in HCC, most of which revealed a greater CM fraction in the cancerous cells. On the
other hand, 506 DMRs were identified with an absolute difference in average methylation levels of more than 0.2. Most DMRs revealed hypo-methylation in cancer, which is distinct from differential CMRs (DCMRs). As shown
in Fig. 5A, approximately 27% of the differential CMRs overlapped with 75% of the DMRs. A large number of
differential CMRs did not overlap with DMRs, but they showed a significant difference between HCC and HMEC
(Fig. 5B). These results illustrate that the extent of focal concordant methylation is more distinct between breast
cancer and normal cells than their average methylation levels. In addition, we found some regions with decreased
average methylation levels in cancer but increased CM fractions. The number of these regions was higher than in
cancerous cells whose average methylation levels increased, but whose CM fractions decreased (38 vs. 9, Fig. 5C). It is suggested that adjacent CpGs prefer concordant methylation in tumors. Functional enrichment analysis of
DCMRs revealed that multiple Gene Ontology (GO) functional terms were significantly enriched. Those regions
exhibiting an increased CM fraction in cancer are associated with more functions, such as molecular function
regulation, cell death regulation, phosphate metabolic processes, and intracellular signaling cascades. In addition,
regions with an increased CM fraction in cancer were significantly associated with the MAPK signaling pathway
and were up-regulated in normal epithelial cells (Fig. 5D). Together, the extent of concordant methylation was
larger in tumors than in normal tissue and seems to reflect a dynamic mechanism of methylation that drive the
formation of tumor cells. Further analysis of genes associated with breast cancer, including ABCB1, BRCA1, GSTP1, IGF2, and TERT,
showed a high CM fraction in cancer but non-CM in normal cell lines (Fig. 5E). ABCB1, BRCA1, GSTP1, and IGF2
displayed both an increased CM fraction and hyper-methylation in cancer. It is interesting that TERT exhibited
higher CM in cancer than normal tissue (0.27 vs. 0) but a lower average methylation level (0.53 vs. 0.65). Results
O er ie This result suggests that concordant methylation is more likely to be a characteristic
of the cancer methylome. Widespread differences in focal concordant methylation between breast cancer and normal
tissue. CellMethy was also successfully applied to a GWBS dataset including one HCC1954 breast cancer cell
line (HCC) and one normal primary human mammary epithelial cell line (HMEC) and identified 1723 CMRs in
total. There were 1093 and 835 CMRs identified in HCC and HMEC, respectively (Supplementary Table 1). The
number of CMRs in HMEC accounted for less than half of the total CMRs, and the overlaps between cancer and
normal tissue were less. The median value of the CM fraction was 0.38 in HCC and 0 in HMEC from all 1723
CMRs, displaying a more significant difference than their average methylation levels (Supplementary Figure 5). Differential methylation region (DMR) and differential CM region (DCMR) were identified respectively
through the same criterion which were at least 0.2 differences in average methylation level or CM level. We further Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 4 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 3. Characteristics of CM. (A) The relationship of CM fractions and average methylation levels in
normal tissues is shown in Table 1. The maximum CM and CM of random methylation trends were computed
using simulated data of concordant and random methylation pattern (methylation levels from 0.1 to 0.9),
respectively. (B) Probability density distribution of average CM fraction from cancer and normal tissues,
respectively. (C) Occupancy rates of CMRs in promoter, 5′ -UTR, exon, intron, 3′ -UTR, DHS, CGI and CGS. Box figure represents the degree of difference in occupancy rate between cancer and normal cells in each region. Notably, the occupancy rate of CGI in cancer was more than 1 because the length of some CMRs in CGI was
longer than the CGI. (D) Average values of CM fraction of cancer and normal cells in promoter, 5′ -UTR, exon,
intron, 3′ -UTR, DHS, CGI and CGS. (E) The relationship between CM fractions and average methylation levels
in normal and cancer cells, respectively. (F) Heat map of correlation of CM fraction or average methylation
levels among tissues. Figure 3. Characteristics of CM. (A) The relationship of CM fractions and average methylation levels in
normal tissues is shown in Table 1. Results
O er ie The maximum CM and CM of random methylation trends were computed
using simulated data of concordant and random methylation pattern (methylation levels from 0.1 to 0.9),
respectively. (B) Probability density distribution of average CM fraction from cancer and normal tissues,
respectively. (C) Occupancy rates of CMRs in promoter, 5′ -UTR, exon, intron, 3′ -UTR, DHS, CGI and CGS. Box figure represents the degree of difference in occupancy rate between cancer and normal cells in each region. Notably, the occupancy rate of CGI in cancer was more than 1 because the length of some CMRs in CGI was
longer than the CGI. (D) Average values of CM fraction of cancer and normal cells in promoter, 5′ -UTR, exon,
intron, 3′ -UTR, DHS, CGI and CGS. (E) The relationship between CM fractions and average methylation levels
in normal and cancer cells, respectively. (F) Heat map of correlation of CM fraction or average methylation
levels among tissues. identified 1407 DCMRs in HCC, most of which revealed a greater CM fraction in the cancerous cells. On the
other hand, 506 DMRs were identified with an absolute difference in average methylation levels of more than 0.2. Most DMRs revealed hypo-methylation in cancer, which is distinct from differential CMRs (DCMRs). As shown
in Fig. 5A, approximately 27% of the differential CMRs overlapped with 75% of the DMRs. A large number of
differential CMRs did not overlap with DMRs, but they showed a significant difference between HCC and HMEC
(Fig. 5B). These results illustrate that the extent of focal concordant methylation is more distinct between breast
cancer and normal cells than their average methylation levels. In addition, we found some regions with decreased
average methylation levels in cancer but increased CM fractions. The number of these regions was higher than in
cancerous cells whose average methylation levels increased, but whose CM fractions decreased (38 vs. 9, Fig. 5C). It is suggested that adjacent CpGs prefer concordant methylation in tumors. Functional enrichment analysis of
DCMRs revealed that multiple Gene Ontology (GO) functional terms were significantly enriched. Those regions
exhibiting an increased CM fraction in cancer are associated with more functions, such as molecular function
regulation, cell death regulation, phosphate metabolic processes, and intracellular signaling cascades. In addition,
regions with an increased CM fraction in cancer were significantly associated with the MAPK signaling pathway
and were up-regulated in normal epithelial cells (Fig. 5D). Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 Results
O er ie TERT,
normally repressed in postnatal somatic cells, plays a role in cellular senescence by the progressive shortening
of telomeres, and its decreased expression in somatic cells may play a role in oncogenesis. Consistent with this
result, the expression of TERT is suppressed in breast cancer, as assessed by quantitative polymerase chain reac-
tion (q-PCR)24, but no studies have shown variations of TERT DNA methylation in breast cancer. In our study,
we found that a CGI within TERT showed a significantly differential CM fraction between cancerous and normal
cells (absolute difference = 0.27), significantly higher than the difference of average methylation levels (absolute Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 5 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 4. Divergence and specificity of CM. (A) Standard deviations of each tissue from average value of all
normal tissues/cells. Blue represents the standard deviations of methylation levels. Red represents the standard
deviations of CM fractions. (B) Differential degree between normal and cancer cells in promoter, 5′ -UTR, exon,
intron, 3′ -UTR, DHS, CGI and CGS regions. Dark red represents the differential degree of CM fractions, while
light red represents the differential degree of methylation levels. (C) Distribution of the number of samples that
shared the same CM or methylation regions. Blue represents CMRs with methylation levels greater than 0, and
red represents a CM fraction greater than 0. (D) Distribution of CMRs (%) among somatic tissues. Normal
represents all normal tissues/cells; others represent each cancer. Figure 4. Divergence and specificity of CM. (A) Standard deviations of each tissue from average value of all
normal tissues/cells. Blue represents the standard deviations of methylation levels. Red represents the standard
deviations of CM fractions. (B) Differential degree between normal and cancer cells in promoter, 5′ -UTR, exon,
intron, 3′ -UTR, DHS, CGI and CGS regions. Dark red represents the differential degree of CM fractions, while
light red represents the differential degree of methylation levels. (C) Distribution of the number of samples that
shared the same CM or methylation regions. Blue represents CMRs with methylation levels greater than 0, and
red represents a CM fraction greater than 0. (D) Distribution of CMRs (%) among somatic tissues. Normal
represents all normal tissues/cells; others represent each cancer. difference = 0.12) that was not identified as a DMR based on the absolute difference cutoff (0.2). Results
O er ie Although TERT
showed a higher average methylation level in normal, adjacent CpGs of the CGI within TERT preferentially showed
concordant methylation in cancer cells but a random methylated pattern in normal cells. Variation in the concord-
ant methylation pattern rather than average methylation levels of TERT may lead to deregulation of expression. Thus, we propose that focal DNA concordant methylation can more accurately reflect phenotype regulation than
average methylation levels, which may drive the variation in cell phenotypes. Discussion
h
d b In this study, bisulfite sequencing data (BS-Seq) have been reanalyzed at the read level instead of by average meth-
ylation. We developed a method (CellMethy) to systematically identify the region in which adjacent CpGs are
concordantly methylated and to quantify the extent of concordant methylation. Through CellMethy, we have ana-
lyzed different methylation datasets and found distinct methylation patterns across cancers. The cancer methylome
generally exhibits a larger extent of concordantly methylated pattern than the normal methylome. Moreover, the
CM extent showed greater variability than the average methylation levels among tissues/cells. In particular, approx-
imately half of CMRs were specific to a single tissue/cell, especially cancerous ones. Of course, this finding is only a
preliminary insight from our observation that needs to be studied in more cancerous and normal methylomes. In
addition, we identified DMRs and DCMRs based on the same criterion in the GWBS data of breast cells. We found
that 27% of DCMRs overlapped with DMRs and accounted for 75% of DMR, in which 88% regions had the same
change directions in average methylation and CM levels. For the regions with opposite change directions between
DMRs and DCMRs, the overlaps of hypo-DMRs and H-DCMRs were greater than the overlaps of hyper-DMRs
and L-DCMRs (38 vs. 9). The remaining 25% of DMRs were not DCMRs, and two-thirds showed a reduction of
average methylation levels in cancer. Although the difference of CM fraction in the remaining 25% of DMRs was
not more than 0.2, two-thirds of regions showed a slightly higher CM fraction. The phenomenon that hypo-DMRs
exhibited a higher CM fraction suggested that adjacent CpGs might prefer concordant methylation in tumors.f Although CellMethy infers CMRs based on BS-seq data, it is different from some DMR detection tools such as
BSmooth25. DMR detection tools usually identify DMRs between two types of samples, e.g., normal and cancer,
through a comparison of average methylation level. A majority of DMRs may bury the differential methylation
pattern. However, the opposite is not always true. There are a large number of regions with different methylation
patterns showing similar average methylation levels among different samples that reflect different epigenetic regu-
latory mechanisms. We focus on the region that shows a concordant methylation pattern of all CpGs and quantify Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 6 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 5. DCMRs of breast cancer from GWBS data. (A) DCMRs and DMRs. Methods
d Data and processing. Three datasets of DNA methylation were downloaded from the Encode (http://genome. ucsc.edu/ENCODE/) and SRA databases (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra/). The Encode datasets included DNA
methylation data on 11 normal and 12 cancer samples through the RRBS technique, including samples of embry-
onic stem cells (H1 ESC), skin fibroblasts (BJ), mammary epithelial cells (HMEC), skeletal muscle cells (Hsmm),
B-lymphocytes (Gm12891, Gm12892), pancreas, skeleton, skin, testis, uterus, lung cancer (A549), colon cancer
(Hct), endometrial carcinoma (Ecc1), neuroblastoma (Be2c), acute megakaryocytic leukemia cells (Cmk), cervi-
cal carcinoma (Helas), hepatocellular carcinoma (Hepg2), promyelocytic leukemia cells (Hl60), T cell leukemia
(Jurkat), leukemia (K562), prostate cancer (Lncap), and breast cancer (Mcf). GWBS data were downloaded from
the SRA database (accession no. SRP006728), including HCC and HMEC as a control. A human reference genome
was downloaded from Ensemble (HG19). All short sequence fragments from the three datasets were aligned to the
human reference genome through bismark respectively. If there were multiple replicates in one tissue, all sequence
fragments were merged, and the DNA methylation status of CpGs from each read was determined. CellMethy algorithm. To identify and quantify concordant methylation regions using single-base resolution
DNA methylation data, every read resulting from the DNA methylation data was regarded as representative of a
methylation state or epiallele. All reads mapping to a CpG represented a mixture of methylation patterns in a cell
population. The method began with sliding windows: the window size was defined from 2 to 10 CpGs, and the
sliding step was one CpG. Common reads that covered all CpGs in a window were first identified, suggesting that
the distance of adjacent CpGs in the window was no more than the length of bisulfite sequence fragment. That
is to say, the distance of adjacent CpGs in the window was no more than 100 bp because the length of reads from
RRBS data was usually ~100 bp. If the number of common reads was more than 10, we calculated the fraction of
reads (f) that showed methylation for all CpGs in a window from common reads. Scanning the genome from 5′
to 3′ , the f value of each window was obtained from each sample in the three datasets. The window containing the
highest f value in the neighborhood was considered the hot point. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ www.nature.com/scientificreports/ the extent of concordant methylation in a single sample. MethylPurify is a statistical algorithm that uses sequencing
reads showing discordant methylation levels to infer tumor purity from tumor samples26. This algorithm focuses
on the heterogeneity between tumorous and normal cells and infers tumor purity from tumor samples based on
the assumption that tumor tissues often contain normal cells. Sequencing data from a tissue are frequently het-
erogeneous due to being composed of various cells. We focused on the heterogeneity of methylation patterns in
both tumor and normal cells, further identifying the regions or markers that can reflect the proportion of tumor
cells showing a specific methylation pattern. g
pi
y
p
Each cell population, especially in a tumor, may contain multiple cell subpopulations, which could have tre-
mendous therapeutic implications. There are existing clinical therapies that may target the most prevalent cells
but do not complement all cellular sub-types contained within the population, so the tumors always come back. To optimize therapy, differential drugs and operation methods should be adopted according to the composition
of tumor cells. Human cancers harbor epigenetic alterations, such as DNA methylation, that can be dynamically
altered. Moreover, some regions of the promoter have shown methylation heterogeneity within individual met-
astatic tumors27. The heterogeneity of DNA methylation may contribute to the heterogeneity of cells from the
same cell type. Landan et al. found that regional DNA methylation patterns within a cell population from the
same cell type were highly polymorphic, both in normal and tumorous cells21. They observed reduced levels of
epipolymorphism in testicular and H1 ESC populations, which were dominated by completely methylated or
unmethylated patterns compared with other somatic cells. We obtained similar results in testicular and H1 ESC
populations, which revealed increased levels of CM compared with other somatic cells. In addition, Landan et al. found that the epipolymorphism of cancer was lower than normal control samples in hypermethylated regions but
similar in hypomethylated regions. Although the distribution of methylation patterns was not further explored
in hypomethylated regions, the frequency of concordantly methylated pattern is increased in hypermethylated
regions with an average methylation level of 60–70%. The results were partial agreement with our observation that
higher differences were observed between cancer and normal cells in the moderately methylated regions (0.2 ~ 0.8). www.nature.com/scientificreports/ gf
y
y
g
There are many DNA methylation patterns within a cell population, and we did not infer the fractions of all
methylation patterns in a cell population. A concordantly methylated pattern of adjacent CpGs was selected because
local hyper-methylation is one of the primary features of the cancer epigenome. Although we only focused on
the concordantly methylated pattern, CellMethy can be applied to other methylation patterns to further explore
the constituents of cells. This method may further understanding of the dynamic changes in DNA methylation
patterns during the development and differentiation of cells, and potentially target a specific cell subpopulation
to support personalized cancer therapy. Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 Discussion
h
d b (B) Differential degree of
CM fractions and average methylation levels in CMRs. The dotted line represents the cutoff of variance. (C) Overlap between differential CM and methylation regions. H(L)-DCMR represents higher (lower) CM
fractions in cancer than normal cells, and Hyper(Hypo)-DMR represents higher (lower) average methylation level
in cancer than normal cells. (D) Enrichment analysis of DCMRs that did not show differential methylation levels. Red represents functions enriched in H-DCMRs, green represents functions enriched in L-DCMRs, and purple
represents functions enriched in both H-DCMRs and L-DCMRs. (E) An example of CM patterns from TERT,
ABCB1, GSTP1, IGF2 and BRCA1 that were associated with breast cancer in previous studies. The gray rectangle
corresponding to each gene represents the genomic position. Vertical lines represents the locations of CMRs, and
arrows represents the transcriptional direction of each gene. Purple histograms represents the average methylation
l
l f
h
f
d
h
h l
f
h Figure 5. DCMRs of breast cancer from GWBS data. (A) DCMRs and DMRs. (B) Differential degree of
CM fractions and average methylation levels in CMRs. The dotted line represents the cutoff of variance. (C) Overlap between differential CM and methylation regions. H(L)-DCMR represents higher (lower) CM
fractions in cancer than normal cells, and Hyper(Hypo)-DMR represents higher (lower) average methylation levels
in cancer than normal cells. (D) Enrichment analysis of DCMRs that did not show differential methylation levels. Red represents functions enriched in H-DCMRs, green represents functions enriched in L-DCMRs, and purple
represents functions enriched in both H-DCMRs and L-DCMRs. (E) An example of CM patterns from TERT,
ABCB1, GSTP1, IGF2 and BRCA1 that were associated with breast cancer in previous studies. The gray rectangle
corresponding to each gene represents the genomic position. Vertical lines represents the locations of CMRs, and
arrows represents the transcriptional direction of each gene. Purple histograms represents the average methylation
level of each CpG in CMR from sequencing reads. Heat map shows methylation state of each CpG in sequencing
reads in HCC1954 (left, cancer) and HMEC (right, normal). Red is methylated and gray is unmethylated. Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 7 Methods
d We extended the hot spot to both sides of the
window and computed the integration of the f value (I) as follows, until either dx or dy was greater than 100 bp or
the f value equaled 0: ∫
∫
=
+
( )
I
fdx
fdy
1
x
y ( )
1 If the region after extension is from a to b (Fig. 1), then I satisfies the following equation: ∫
∫
∫
=
+
=
( )
( )
I
fdx
fdy
f p dp
2
x
y
a
b ( )
2 Assuming the maximum value of f is M, and the minimum value is m in the interval [a, b], then Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 8 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ (
−
) <
<
(
−
)
( )
m b
a
I
M b
a
and
3 ( )
3 <
(
−
)
<
( )
m
I
b
a
M
4 ( )
4 With the assumption that f(p) is a continuous function on [a, b], the value between m and M can be reached, i.e.,
ξ exists that satisfies ∫
ζ
=
( )
=
( )(
−
)
( )
I
f p dp
f
b
a
5
a
b ( )
5 The mean area covered by f on the interval [a, b] is equal to the area of a rectangle with edge lengths of (b − a)
and
ξ
( )
f
. Thus,
ξ
( )
f
is considered the average size of a cell subpopulation showing full methylation, and is defined
as the CM fraction ∫
∫
ξ
( ) =
(
−
)
=
+
( )
f
I
b
a
fdx
fdy
length
6
x
y ( )
6 Simulation data. To determine the appropriate window size, we simulated two datasets that included both a
random methylation pattern and a concordant methylation pattern based on genome position and the DNA meth-
ylation levels of all CpGs from RRBS data (Bj). A flowchart of the simulation is shown in Supplementary Figure 6. Four different coverage depths (10-, 20-, 50- and 100-fold) were simulated, and the read length was 100 bp. The
genome was scanned from 5′ to 3′ , and the initial CpG (CpG0) and its methylation level were determined. Methods
d If the
distance between CpGi (i = 0, 1, 2, ……) and CpGi+1 was greater than 100 bp, CpGi+1 was considered a new initial
CpG. All reads covering each CpG were allocated to two sets, RS and RC. RS includes the reads that do not cover
the next CpG, and RC includes the reads that are shared with the next CpG. The methylation state was determined
as 0 or 1, representing unmethylated or methylated, respectively. Beginning from the initial CpG0 site, the relative position of each read was randomly generated and ranged from
1 to 100. The methylation state of CpG0 was simulated according to the methylation level. Meanwhile, RC and RS
were determined by the relative position of CpG0 and the distance between CpG0 and CpG1. Then, the methylation
state of CpG1 on each read from RC was simulated. For random methylation simulation data, the methylation state
of each read in RC was randomly generated based on the methylation level of CpG1. For concordant methylation
simulation data, the methylation state of each read in RC was the same as for CpG0. Reads in RC and RS were
updated according to the distance between CpG1 and CpG2. In a similar manner, all CpGs in the genome were sim-
ulated. If the number of total reads of RC and RS in CpGi was less than the defined coverage depth, new reads were
generated and allocated to RC or RS according to the relative position of CpGi and the distance between CpGi and
CpGi+1. When the relative position of CpGi in the new read minus the distance between CpGi and CpGj (j = i − 1,
i − 2, …, 0) was greater than or equal to zero, the methylation state of CpGj was simulated through the previous rule. Accuracy evaluation of CellMethy. To evaluate the performance of CellMethy, we simulated 1000 random
and concordant methylation regions as negative and positive sets, respectively, with 50-fold coverage depth. The
number of CpGs in each region was randomly selected (> 5). To control the purity of the negative and positive
sets, the methylation level of each region was randomly selected from 0.1 to 0.9. For each region, we simulated
negative data through a random methylation pattern and positive data through a concordant methylation pattern
(the same as above). 1. Wu, S. C. & Zhang, Y. Active DNA demethylation: many roads lead to Rome. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 11, 607–620 (2010).
2. Smallwood, S. A. et al. Dynamic CpG island methylation landscape in oocytes and preimplantation embryos. Nat Genet. 43, 811–814
(2011).
3. Feng, S., Jacobsen, S. E. & Reik, W. Epigenetic reprogramming in plant and animal development. Science 330, 622–627 (2010). Acknowledgements g
We are gratful for the support of the National Natural Science Foundation of China [grant number 61402139 to FW,
31401075 to SZ, and 81573021 to YZ, 61403112 to HL and 61203262 to JS] , and the Natural Scientific Research
Fund of Heilongjiang Provincial [grant number QC2011C061 to SZ]. We are gratful for the support of the National Natural Science Foundation of China [grant number 61402139 to FW,
31401075 to SZ, and 81573021 to YZ, 61403112 to HL and 61203262 to JS] , and the Natural Scientific Research
Fund of Heilongjiang Provincial [grant number QC2011C061 to SZ]. We are gratful for the support of the National Natural Science Foundation of China [grant number 61402139 to FW,
31401075 to SZ, and 81573021 to YZ, 61403112 to HL and 61203262 to JS] , and the Natural Scientific Research
Fund of Heilongjiang Provincial [grant number QC2011C061 to SZ]. Methods
d Disclosing the crosstalk among DNA methylation, transcription factors, and histone
marks in human pluripotent cells through discovery of DNA methylation motifs. Genome Res. 23, 2013–2029 (2013). 0 S
ki M M & Bi d A DNA
th l ti
l
d
ti
i
i ht f
i
i
N t R
G
t 9 465 476 (2008) 20. Suzuki, M. M. & Bird, A. DNA methylation landscapes: provocative insights from epigenomics. Nat Rev Genet. 9, 465–476 (2008). d
l
l
h
d h
h
f
f d ff
ll
h l
d
l
d 20. Suzuki, M. M. & Bird, A. DNA methylation landscapes: provocative insights from epigenomics. Nat Rev Genet. 9, 465 476 (
21. Landan, G. et al. Epigenetic polymorphism and the stochastic formation of differentially methylated regions in normal and can
tissues. Nat Genet. 44, 1207–1214 (2012).i 21. Landan, G. et al. Epigenetic polymorphism and the stochastic formation of differentially methylated regions in normal an
tissues. Nat Genet. 44, 1207–1214 (2012). 22 Eckhardt F et al DNA methylation profiling of human chromosomes 6 20 and 22 Nat Genet 38 1378 1385 (2006) ,
p g
p y
pf
y
y
g
tissues. Nat Genet. 44, 1207–1214 (2012). 2 Eckhardt, F et al DNA methylation profiling of human chromosomes 6, 20 and 22 Nat Genet 38, 1378–1385 (2006) (
)
22. Eckhardt, F. et al. DNA methylation profiling of human chromosomes 6, 20 and 22. Nat Genet. 38, 1378–1385 (2006). 22. Eckhardt, F. et al. DNA methylation profiling of human chromo i
23. Ladd-Acosta, C., Aryee, M. J., Ordway, J. M. & Feinberg, A. P. Comprehensive high-throughput arrays for relative m
(CHARM). Curr Protoc Hum Genet. Chapter 20, Unit 20 21 21–19 (2010).f 24. Ghasemali, S. et al. Inhibitory effects of beta-cyclodextrin-helenalin complexes on H-TERT gene expression in the T47D breast
cancer cell line - results of real time quantitative PCR. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev. 14, 6949–6953 (2013).if . Ghasemali, S. et al. Inhibitory effects of beta-cyclodextrin-helen 25. Hansen, K. D., Langmead, B. & Irizarry, R. A. BSmooth: from whole genome bisulfite sequencing reads to differentially methylated
regions. Genome Biol. 13, R83 (2012).f 5. Hansen, K. D., Langmead, B. & Irizarry, R. A. BSmooth: from whole genome bisulfite sequencing reads to differentially methylated
regions. Genome Biol. 13, R83 (2012).f g
6. Zheng, X. et al. Author Contributions Y.Z. and S.Z. conceived the hypothesis. F.W. and S.Z. designed the algorithm and performed the simulation
experiments and subsequent analysis. H.L., Y.W. and Y.H.W. paticipated in helpful discussions. Y.Z. and F.W. wrote the manuscript with help from H.L., J.S. and D.Z. B.X. and X.H. revised the manuscript. Y.Z. and S.Z. conceived the hypothesis. F.W. and S.Z. designed the algorithm and performed the simulation
experiments and subsequent analysis. H.L., Y.W. and Y.H.W. paticipated in helpful discussions. Y.Z. and F.W. wrote the manuscript with help from H.L., J.S. and D.Z. B.X. and X.H. revised the manuscript. Methods
d & Greenberg, M. E. Genetics. The maturing brain methylome. Science 341, 626–627 (2013). p
y
p
g
p
p
g
7. Gabel, H. W. & Greenberg, M. E. Genetics. The maturing brain methylome. Science 341, 626–627 (2 gh
g
y
(
)
8 Lande-Diner, L et al Role of DNA methylation in stable gene repression J Biol Chem 282, 12194–12200 (2007) h
8. Lande-Diner, L. et al. Role of DNA methylation in stable gene repression. J Biol Chem. 282, 12194–12200 (2007).i . Rakyan, V. K. et al. An integrated resource for genome-wide id 9. Rakyan, V. K. et al. An integrated resource for genome-wide identification and analysis of human tissue-specific differen
methylated regions (tDMRs). Genome research 18, 1518–1529 (2008).hi y
g
10. Irizarry, R. A. et al. The human colon cancer methylome shows similar hypo- and hypermethylation at conserved tissue-specific CpG
island shores. Nat Genet. 41, 178–186 (2009).f yh
island shores. Nat Genet. 41, 178–186 (2009). 1. Meissner, A. et al. Genome-scale DNA methylation maps of pluripotent and differentiated cells. Nature 454, 766–770 (2008).ii y
p
p
pf
12. Noushmehr, H. et al. Identification of a CpG island methylator phenotype that defines a distinct subgroup of glioma. Cancer Cell. 17, 510–522 (2010). 13. Hansen, K. D. et al. Increased methylation variation in epigenetic domains across cancer types. Nat Genet. 43, 768–775 (2011) 14. Berman, B. P. et al. Regions of focal DNA hypermethylation and long-range hypomethylation in colorectal cancer coincide
nuclear lamina-associated domains. Nat Genet. 44, 40–46 (2012). 14. Berman, B. P. et al. Regions of focal DNA hypermethylation and long-ra
nuclear lamina-associated domains. Nat Genet. 44, 40–46 (2012). 15. Timp, W. & Feinberg, A. P. Cancer as a dysregulated epigenome allowing cellular growth advantage at the expense of the host
Rev Cancer. 13, 497–510 (2013). 6. Broske, A. M. et al. DNA methylation protects hematopoietic stem cell multipotency from myeloerythroid restriction. Nat Genet
41, 1207–1215 (2009). (
)
17. Trowbridge, J. J., Snow, J. W., Kim, J. & Orkin, S. H. DNA methyltransferase 1 is essential for and uniquely regulates hematopoietic
stem and progenitor cells. Cell Stem Cell. 5, 442–449 (2009). g
18. Baylin, S. B. & Jones, P. A. A decade of exploring the cancer epigenome - biological and translational implications. Nat Rev Cancer. 11, 726–734 (2011). 9. Luu, P. L., Scholer, H. R. & Arauzo-Bravo, M. J. Methods
d In the positive set, the predefined methylation level of each region was considered the true
level of CM. In addition, the average methylation levels of CMRs were estimated. AUC values were used to measure
the performance of the algorithm. Genome region distribution. The position of genes and CpG islands from the human reference genome
were downloaded from UCSC (HG19). The promoter was defined as 2 kb upstream from the transcription start
site of each gene. Regions with 2 kb distance from the CGI boundary were considered the CGS. The exon, intron,
5′ -UTR, 3′ -UTR, promoter, and CGS were extracted using Python. For each genomic region, the occupancy
rate was calculated from the total length of all CMRs located within the region divided by the total length of the
corresponding genomic region. Identification of differential region. The criteria for differential regions including DMRs and DCMRs
referenced the standard of Landan et al. which required differences of at least 0.221. Therefore, if the region in the
cancer sample showed an increase or decrease in average methylation of at least 0.2 relative to the matched normal
sample, the region was regarded as hyper- or hyper-DMR. Similarly, a H-DCMR or L-DCMR was defined as a
region with at least a 0.2 increase or decrease in CM level relative to the matched normal sample. Availability. CellMethy is open source and available at https://pypi.python.org/pypi/CellMethy/1.1.27. References
1. Wu, S. C. & Zhang, Y. Active DNA demethylation: many roads lead to Rome. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 11, 607–620 (2010). 2. Smallwood, S. A. et al. Dynamic CpG island methylation landscape in oocytes and preimplantation embryos. Nat Genet. 43, 811–814
(2011). 3 Feng S Jacobsen S E & Reik W Epigenetic reprogramming in plant and animal development Science 330 622–627 (2010) ( 0
). 3. Feng, S., Jacobsen, S. E. & Reik, W. Epigenetic reprogramming in plant and animal development. Science 330, 622–627 (2010) Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 9 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ . Bird, A. DNA methylation patterns and epigenetic memory. Gene y
g
y
5. Hodges, E. et al. Directional DNA methylation changes and complex intermediate states accompany lineage specificity in the adul
hematopoietic compartment. Mol Cell. 44, 17–28 (2011). p
p
(
)
et al. Comprehensive methylome map of lineage commitment from 6. Ji, H. et al. Comprehensive methylome map of lineage commitment from haematopoietic progenitors. Nature 467, 338 3
7. Gabel, H. W. Methods
d MethylPurify: tumor purity deconvolution and differential methylation detection from single tumor DNA methylomes
Genome Biol. 15, 419 (2014). ,
(
)
7. Aryee, M. J. et al. DNA methylation alterations exhibit intraindividual stability and interindividual heterogeneity in prostate cance
S i T
l M d 5 169
110 (2013) 27. Aryee, M. J. et al. DNA methylation alterations exhibit intraindividual stability and interindividual heterogeneity in prostate cancer
metastases. Sci Transl Med. 5, 169ra110 (2013). 27. Aryee, M. J. et al. DNA methylation alterations exhibit intraindividual stability and interindividual heterogeneity in prostate cancer
metastases. Sci Transl Med. 5, 169ra110 (2013). Additional Information upplementary information accompanies this paper at http://www.nature.com/srep Supplementary information accompanies this paper at http://www.nature.com/srep Supplementary information accompanies this paper at http://www.nature.com/srep Competing financial interests: The authors declare no competing financial interests. Competing financial interests: The authors declare no competing financial interests. How to cite this article: Wang, F. et al. CellMethy: Identification of a focal concordantly methylated pattern of
CpGs revealed wide differences between normal and cancer tissues. Sci. Rep. 5, 18037; doi: 10.1038/srep18037
(2015). How to cite this article: Wang, F. et al. CellMethy: Identification of a focal concordantly methylated pattern of
CpGs revealed wide differences between normal and cancer tissues. Sci. Rep. 5, 18037; doi: 10.1038/srep18037
(2015). How to cite this article: Wang, F. et al. CellMethy: Identification of a focal concordantly methylated pattern of
CpGs revealed wide differences between normal and cancer tissues. Sci. Rep. 5, 18037; doi: 10.1038/srep18037
(2015). This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images
or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license,
unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license,
users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this
license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Scientific Reports | 5:18037 | DOI: 10.1038/srep18037 10
|
https://openalex.org/W2016680591
|
https://www.scielo.br/j/pusf/a/VcjpqtBmfsK9hMwhK55xjYQ/?lang=pt&format=pdf
|
Portuguese
| null |
Fantasias freudianas: aspectos centrais e possível aproximação com o conceito de esquemas de Aaron Beck
|
Psico-USF
| 2,013
|
cc-by
| 5,983
|
Resumen Este artículo discute los puntos sobre el concepto de fantasía, de Sigmund Freud, y se propone a un diálogo entre ellos y
el concepto de esquemas propuesto por la teoría de la terapia cognitiva de Aaron Beck. Esa sugerencia no significa
eclecticismo teórico o práctico y aborda estos conceptos teniendo en cuenta las diferencias en sus suposiciones. Según la
teoría freudiana, las fantasías representan una forma de lectura subjetiva, organizada a partir de los deseos y de los
mecanismos de defensa, de la realidad de los hechos. Se trata de lo que Freud llamó de la realidad psíquica, la cual tiene
sus bases en la infancia y en las fantasías filogenéticas. La teoría de Beck no hace referencia a la noción de fantasía, sin
embargo, considera el papel de las impresiones y de las interpretaciones subjetivas de los acontecimientos, especialmente
aquellos vividos en la infancia. Así se desarrolla la tesis de que los esquemas organizan procesos cognitivos, afectivos y
comportamentales. El diálogo entre esas teorías ha sido apoyado por estudios de las ciencias cognitivas. Palabras clave: Fantasía, Psicoanálisis, Esquemas, Ciencia Cognitiva. Este artigo aborda pontos fundamentais sobre o
conceito de fantasia, na obra de Sigmund Freud, e
propõe um diálogo entre eles e o conceito de
esquemas, apresentado pela teoria da terapia cognitiva,
elaborada por Aaron Beck. Cumpre notar que essa
proposta não indica ecletismo teórico ou prático, e
apresenta tais conceitos considerando sempre as
diferenças dos pressupostos que os fundamentam. Tal
objetivo tem interesse didático, bem como pode
colaborar para novos debates e desdobramentos
teóricos. Vale considerar, contudo, que não é pretensão
deste artigo apresentar todas as especificidades do
conceito de esquema, que engendra as propostas das
terapias cognitivas, bem como do conceito de fantasia
presente nas diferentes formulações da psicanálise. As elaborações sobre as fantasias não somente
estão na gênese da teoria de Freud, mas também
sustentam seu desenvolvimento e, pode-se dizer,
constituem-se como núcleo instransponível até seu
final. Da mesma forma, o conceito de esquemas
encontra-se nos fundamentos, bem como nos
desdobramentos das terapias cognitivas. Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 321 Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 321 Disponível em www.scielo.br Fantasías freudianas: aspectos centrales y posible aproximación con el concepto de esquemas de Aaron Beck Fantasías freudianas: aspectos centrales y posible aproximación con el concepto de esquemas de Aaron Beck Resumo Resumo
Este artigo aborda pontos sobre o conceito de fantasia, de Sigmund Freud, e propõe um diálogo entre eles e o conceito
de esquemas, proposto pela teoria da terapia cognitiva de Aaron Beck. Essa sugestão não indica ecletismo teórico ou
prático, abordando esses conceitos considerando as diferenças dos seus pressupostos. De acordo com a teoria freudiana,
as fantasias representam uma forma de leitura subjetiva, organizada a partir dos desejos e dos mecanismos de defesa, da
realidade dos fatos. Trata-se do que Freud denomina realidade psíquica, a qual tem suas bases na infância e nas fantasias
filogenéticas. A teoria de Beck não faz referências à noção de fantasia, contudo considera o papel das impressões e das
interpretações subjetivas dos eventos, especialmente aqueles vividos na infância. Assim desenvolve a tese de que os
esquemas organizam processos cognitivos, afetivos e comportamentais. O diálogo entre tais teorias tem sido corroborado
por estudos das ciências cognitivas. Palavras-chave: Fantasia, Psicanálise, Esquemas, Cognitiva. Palavras-chave: Fantasia, Psicanálise, Esquemas, Cognitiva. Fantasias freudianas: aspectos centrais e possível aproximação com o conceito de esquemas de
Aaron Beck Lara Cristina D’Avila Lourenço – Universidade Federal de São Paulo – Campus Baixada Santista, São Paulo, Brasil
Ricardo da Costa Padovani – Universidade Federal de São Paulo – Campus Baixada Santista, São Paulo, Brasil Abstract
Th
l This article discusses points about the concept of fantasy of Sigmund Freud, and suggests a dialogue between them and
the concept of schemes proposed by Aaron Beck’s cognitive therapy theory. This suggestion does not indicate any form
of eclecticism, theoretical or practical, and discusses these concepts considering the differences in their assumptions. According to Freudian theory, the fantasy represents a form of subjective reading, organized from the wishes and defense
mechanisms, of facts’ reality. This is what Freud called psychic reality, w hich has its basis in childhood and the
phylogenetic fantasies. Beck’s theory does not make references to the notion of fantasy, however, and considers the role
of subjective impressions and interpretations of events, especially those experienced in childhood. Thus, he develops the
thesis that the schemes organize cognitive, affective and behavioral processes. The dialogue between these theories has
been supported by studies in cognitive science. Keywords: Fantasy, Psychoanalysis, Schemes, Cognitive. The Freudian fantasies: central aspects and possible approaches with concepts of Aaron Beck’s schemes The Freudian fantasies: central aspects and possible approaches with concepts of Aaron Beck’s schemes Resumen Entre tais fatores merecem destaque: a
chamada revolução cognitiva nas décadas de 50 e 60;
os escritos sobre os construtos cognitivos, de George
Kelly, Albert Ellis e Jean Piaget; as reações da
comunidade clínica e científica ao modelo estritamente
comportamental; e o questionamento, feito pelo autor,
do modelo clínico psicodinâmico (Beck, 2005a, 2005b;
Knapp & Beck, 2008). É também importante advertir que as noções de
afeto e de cognição têm distinções fundamentais,
conforme apresentadas por Freud e por Beck. Para
aquele, o afeto está baseado no conceito de pulsão
(especificamente pulsão sexual), e a cognição inclui
processos inconscientes (notando que o inconsciente,
nesse caso, é definido enquanto instância psíquica, com
formas próprias de funcionamento e cujo núcleo é
inacessível à consciência). Para Beck, o afeto é produto
de esquemas cognitivos, porém um mecanismo circular
pode ser visto entre ambos: os esquemas cognitivos
determinam os afetos, e estes reforçam as atividades de
tais esquemas. Embora afirme que alguns processos
cognitivos podem não ser conscientes (especialmente
aqueles que se apresentam conforme os chamados
pensamentos automáticos), Beck não se refere ao
inconsciente enquanto instância psíquica. Ou seja, os
processos inconscientes, para esse autor, não têm uma
forma
de funcionamento própria e não são
necessariamente inacessíveis à consciência. Portanto,
nesse caso, seria melhor falar em pré-consciente
(Alford & Beck, 1997). Segundo Beck (Beck e cols., 2005b; 1997) a
ativação de estruturas cognitivas idiossincráticas,
denominadas esquemas, exerce papel central na
determinação de sintomas cognitivos, emocionais e
comportamentais. Sem dúvida, essa teoria não
desconsidera os aspectos afetivos, mas privilegia a
análise e a modificação de padrões cognitivos
disfuncionais,
subjacentes
aos
quadros
psicopatológicos. Beck (1963, 1964, 2005a) entende
que a aquisição de padrões cognitivos realistas
determina a emergência de novas respostas emocionais
e comportamentais. Em síntese, de acordo com a teoria freudiana, as
fantasias representam uma leitura subjetiva da realidade
dos fatos, organizada a partir dos desejos e dos
mecanismos de defesa do indivíduo. E a origem dessas
fantasias, o autor encontra no que denomina pré-
história do indivíduo e da espécie (ou seja, nas
vivências da infância e nos primórdios da humanidade,
respectivamente). Segundo a teoria da terapia cognitiva
(Alford & Beck, 1997; Beck, 2005ª, 1964; Knapp &
Beck, 2008), os esquemas são formados desde a
infância, a partir do modo como o indivíduo conhece e
interpreta os eventos fundamentais de sua experiência. Além do conteúdo representacional, os esquemas
apresentam
valência
afetiva,
permeabilidade,
flexibilidade, amplitude. Resumen p
g
Com efeito, as declarações freudianas sobre as
fantasias confundem-se com a própria afirmação da
realidade psíquica, que marca o início das teses
psicanalíticas; também é possível afirmar que a temática
da fantasia não está ausente nos textos (especialmente
aqueles datados do período de 1891 a 1900) em que
Freud tenta definir e localizar a dinâmica entre as
representações
psíquicas
e
as
percepções, 322 Lourenço, L. C. D. & Padovani, R. C. Fantasias e esquemas: possível aproximação particularmente por meio das hipóteses sobre a
memória, os sonhos e as alucinações. E quando a teoria
psicanalítica
estava
fortemente
consolidada,
especialmente quando a repressão é entendida como
mecanismo de defesa primordial (Freud, 1915, 1980a),
a fantasia pode ser vista como retorno do reprimido,
cujo conteúdo deve ser decifrado pelo tratamento
clínico. A universalidade e tipicidade das fantasias, bem
como suas resistências às intervenções clínicas (Freud,
1937/1980b), são explicadas por meio da complexa
noção de fantasias filogenéticas, que ocupam o
pensamento desse autor até seus últimos escritos. da cognição, não está excluído o fato de que tanto as
fantasias quanto os esquemas constituem espécies de
roteiros, por meio dos quais o indivíduo realiza suas
experiências. E assim, conhecê-los e reorganizá-los são
tarefas fundamentais das clínicas orientadas por tais
teorias. Vale considerar que afeto e cognição não são
conteúdos absolutamente separados, para ambos os
autores. Afinal, Freud (1950/1980c) primordialmente
designa por afeto o processo que compreende a
descarga das excitações e seus resultados psíquicos. Isto é, os caminhos dos afetos estão nas bases dos
processos mnêmicos. Beck (1964) salienta que
esquemas
cognitivos
são
organizadores
dos
comportamentos do indivíduo, na medida em que são
carregados de afeto. Mas o afeto, por sua vez, pode ser
entendido como uma espécie de resposta, elaborada a
partir de conteúdos cognitivos específicos: “A resposta
afetiva é determinada pela forma como um indivíduo
estrutura sua experiência” (Beck, 1964, p. 567). Dessa
maneira, quando uma resposta afetiva inapropriada se
apresenta em determinada situação, a incongruência
pode ser atribuída a um esquema particular que foi
evocado. Na teoria da terapia cognitiva, proposta por Beck
(1963, 1964), não há referências explícitas à noção de
fantasia. Contudo, além da formação psicanalítica do
autor, vários fatores o levam a considerar o papel das
interpretações subjetivas dos eventos, cujos arranjos
compõem as estruturas cognitivas denominadas
esquemas. Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 As fantasias de sedução e o complexo de Édipo, na obra de
Freud O comportamento humano obedece a certos
roteiros, versões psíquicas da realidade dos fatos, as
quais têm um núcleo inconsciente: essa tese encontra-
se nos fundamentos da psicanálise propriamente dita. Os precursores dessa tese são os relatos das pacientes
histéricas, que ocupam Freud desde o início de sua
prática clínica. A partir de tais relatos, os autores
(Breuer & Freud, 1895/1980) concluem que na gênese
dos sintomas histéricos estariam cenas traumáticas de
cunho sexual, das quais essas pacientes teriam sido
vítimas na infância. Tais cenas, por não terem recebido
significação e reação adequadas nos momentos de suas
ocorrências, teriam permanecido como pontos de
fixação, excluídos da consciência. Inconscientes, essas
cenas seriam repetidas simbólica e compulsivamente
mediante sintomas histéricos (Freud, 1950/1980c). A formação e vivência das fantasias edípicas
aconteceriam numa cronologia específica, entre três e
seis
anos
de
idade, aproximadamente (Freud,
1905/1980e). Nesse momento, seria formado o que o
autor
(Freud,
1912/1980f)
denomina
“clichê
estereotípico”, espécie de protótipo das relações
afetivas. Ou seja, em tais fantasias o sujeito
representaria sua posição diante do objeto de amor, a
qual seria inconscientemente repetida nas relações
amorosas futuras. Essa repetição seria tanto mais
rígida, conforme a existência da psicopatologia. Entretanto, em 1897, em uma carta a Fliess,
Freud (1950/1980d) confessa não mais acreditar na
veracidade de tais relatos; ou melhor, ele não mais os
entende como realidade dos fatos, mas como realidade
psíquica. Tem-se início o conceito de fantasia
inconsciente: a realidade dos fatos vista e interpretada
conforme os recursos psíquicos e desejos do indivíduo. Longe de mentir, as histéricas mostram que, ao se
colocarem como vítimas, estão se defendendo da
própria excitação sexual, a qual seria alvo de suas
censuras. Ou seja, além do aspecto de defesa, tais
fantasias
de
sedução
também
seriam
formas
representativas do desejo inconsciente. No tratamento, tratar-se-ia então de desvendar
tais protótipos das relações amorosas, para que o
indivíduo tenha consciência da repetição e possa
reorganizar os roteiros de suas fantasias. Tal
desvendamento e reorganização aconteceriam por meio
da “transferência” (Freud, 1912/1980f): na relação com
o analista, o paciente atuaria esse protótipo de relação
afetiva. Tal repetição, no setting específico do
tratamento analítico, daria ao analista as indicações do
curso psíquico do paciente e a oportunidade de
manejar adequadamente a transferência. Isso permitiria
ao paciente a consciência e certa modificação dessas
formas estereotipadas de relacionamento. Resumen E se Freud privilegia o papel
dos afetos e da sexualidade nesse processo, e Beck, o É justamente em torno da questão sobre o
privilégio dos afetos ou dos processos cognitivos que
Beck afasta-se de sua formação psicanalítica. Ao
analisar o mecanismo da depressão, ele enfatiza o
processo cognitivo desse quadro clínico. Segundo ele, a
psicanálise não considera em sua totalidade os aspectos
cognitivos
da
depressão,
entendendo-a
primordialmente como transtorno afetivo. Beck (1963) Lourenço, L. C. D. & Padovani, R. C. Fantasias e esquemas: possível aproximação 323 323 amorosas primordiais, ou seja, dos que cumprem as
funções parentais). Com efeito, é a afirmação das
fantasias inconscientes que leva Freud às teses sobre o
“complexo de Édipo”. Isso acontece na medida em
que esse autor conclui que as fantasias de sedução,
relatadas pelos pacientes apresentam um roteiro
específico subjacente, o qual sempre diz respeito às
relações de afeto entre a criança e o casal parental. entende a depressão como transtorno do pensamento e
amplia a discussão afirmando que transtornos do
pensamento são subjacentes a todas as psicopatologias. Sem a pretensão de se debruçar sobre esse tema, este
artigo apenas nota que as conclusões de Beck sobre a
depressão deixam evidente a supremacia da cognição
em seu modelo teórico (Alford & Beck, 1997; Beck,
1963, 1964). p
O complexo de Édipo pode ser visto como um
conjunto de fantasias inconscientes, ou ainda, como
teorias tecidas pelas crianças em suas interpretações de
temas como: a distinção e a excitação sexual; o
funcionamento do próprio corpo; a origem dos bebês e
a própria origem, portanto (D’Avila Lourenço, 2000). É por meio dessas teorias que a criança inicia suas
relações amorosas em uma posição masculina ou
feminina. E o que daria nuances individuais a esse
processo seria o que o autor entende por “fatores
complementares”, ou seja, a inter-relação entre fatores
inatos e acidentais na constituição psíquica (o peso e a
maneira como tais fatores se complementam é um
enigma não respondido pela psicanálise, admite Freud). Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 As fantasias de sedução e o complexo de Édipo, na obra de
Freud Dessa maneira, está afirmada a presença da
sexualidade infantil (isto é, ela não é despertada em
razão do ato perverso de algum adulto, mas inerente à
infância). Contudo, Freud não exclui totalmente a
presença da sedução. Como nota Monzani (1989), ao
se referir ao movimento do pensamento freudiano, o
que acontece é que a sedução deixa de ser vista como
um ato perverso e pontual, para tornar-se difusa e
inerente às relações de afeto e cuidados que os adultos
dispensam à criança. Em 1937, portanto ao final de sua obra, Freud
(1937/1980b) admite que os tratamentos psicanalíticos,
no que tange ao objetivo de elaborar e superar as
fantasias edípicas, têm limite. As explicações dessa
limitação tocam em pontos complexos da obra do
autor, especialmente naquele que se refere às “fantasias
filogenéticas”, as quais Freud fundamenta a partir de
sua leitura de Darwin e da chamada teoria da herança Para a psicanálise, as fantasias de um indivíduo
são sempre constituídas a partir da leitura e introjeção
da rede de fantasias daqueles que o cercam
(especificamente, daqueles que compõem suas relações 324 Lourenço, L. C. D. & Padovani, R. C. Fantasias e esquemas: possível aproximação dos caracteres adquiridos (Ritvo, 1992). De acordo
com essa formulação teórica, as experiências pelas
quais diversas gerações sucessivas passam tornam-se
herança da espécie. As fantasias em torno do complexo
de Édipo se ligariam às experiências vividas pela
humanidade
em seus primórdios. Esse fundo
filogenético seria instransponível pela psicanálise, o que
sem dúvida relativiza os alcances da clínica psicanalítica
(D’Avila Lourenço, 2005a). observados na clínica. De qualquer forma, a ideia de
repressão primeva nunca é muito clara para Freud. E
em 1926, ele levanta a hipótese de que as repressões
são realizadas para evitar a angústia, a qual é
consequente a traumas ou à iminência deles. A primeira
situação traumática seria vivida na ocasião do
nascimento; nesse caso, tratar-se-ia de um trauma
unicamente
fisiológico,
que
produziria
angústia
somática (Freud, 1926/1980h). De acordo com essa hipótese, a primeira
repressão traria a marca do desamparo biológico,
diante do excesso de estímulos no nascimento. Tal
desamparo, porque só aliviado mediante a presença de
um ser humano cuidador, desdobrar-se-ia em
desamparo psíquico. Freud (1926/1980h) esclarece
que, desde muito cedo, o ser humano entende que,
para amenizar o desamparo, não basta a presença de
outro ser humano protetor, mas é também necessário
que esse outro esteja voltado para ele, que o ame. As fantasias freudianas e a dinâmica da repressão As fantasias nem sempre são conscientes e, se o
são, o indivíduo na maior parte das vezes não sabe
decifrar seus conteúdos. Isso é explicado por meio do
mecanismo da repressão: nas bases do inconsciente há
desejos reprimidos, expressos inclusive por meio de
fantasias,
as
quais
permanecem
excluídas
da
consciência ou, se a atingem, é com a condição de não
estarem decifradas. Quando
os
representantes
pulsionais,
sob
repressão, são investidos com alta carga de afeto, cria-
se seu acesso à consciência. Contudo, esse acesso deve
obedecer a certa condição, qual seja, um grau de
distorção nos referidos representantes, suficiente para
que a consciência não perceba a manifestação do
conteúdo reprimido (Freud, 1915/1980a). Se essa
distorção não é suficiente, a repressão falha em seu
propósito, que é o de evitar a angústia. Dessa forma, a
angústia é justamente o sinal para que a repressão seja
reforçada. Vale notar que a repressão ocorre quando a
satisfação da pulsão, prazerosa em si, causaria
desprazer maior em virtude de interesses contrários e
concomitantes na mente. Ou seja, a repressão
pressupõe uma divisão na mente, especificamente, a
divisão entre consciente e inconsciente, uma vez que a
essência da repressão consiste em inibir (ou suprimir) a
pulsão, afastando sua representação da consciência. Nesse ponto, interessa esclarecer o que Freud entende
por pulsão e seus representantes: em termos breves, a
pulsão é definida como o representante dos estímulos
endógenos (Freud, 1915/1980a). O que representa a
pulsão é um conjunto ideativo que, por ser expressão
direta das tensões somáticas e organizado de acordo
com a história do sujeito, é acompanhado de uma carga
afetiva (D’Avila Lourenço, 2005b). Assim o caráter enigmático das fantasias está
de acordo com a função da repressão. Isso, em grande
parte, explica as resistências do paciente ao tratamento
que deve, portanto, trabalhar no sentido de diminui-las,
desvendando os conteúdos reprimidos (salientando
que, conforme as definições da repressão primeva,
sempre há limite nesse desvendamento). Os desejos edípicos são particularmente alvos da
repressão. São eles que, cumpre enfatizar, Freud
encontra subjacentes às fantasias de seus pacientes. Nesse ponto, vale citar o comentário do autor, a
respeito de uma das fantasias obsessivas de seu
paciente, conhecido como Homem dos Ratos (Freud,
1909/1980i): Por exemplo, uma das mais antigas e
preferidas obsessões do paciente [...] tinha o seguinte
contexto: “Se eu casar com a dama, a meu pai ocorrerá algum
infortúnio
(no
outro
mundo)”
[itálico
do
autor]. As fantasias de sedução e o complexo de Édipo, na obra de
Freud Assim, o risco da perda do amor do outro torna-se
fonte principal de angústia. Em outras palavras, a
angústia diante do risco da perda do amor do outro é
motor das repressões. Dessa maneira, os representantes
pulsionais reprimidos são, em especial, aqueles que
representam desejos que colocariam em risco o amor
do outro ser humano. Aliás, é possível pensar que, para Freud
(1923/1980g), o núcleo do inconsciente é algo
hipotético
e inatingível psiquicamente. Primeiro,
porque ele toca em bases biológicas, exatamente no
ponto em que biológico e psíquico se perpassam; o
que, para Monzani (1989), leva Freud a formalizar o
conceito de id. Segundo, porque o aparelho psíquico é
definido na dualidade entre inconsciente e consciente
(com efeito, qualquer hipótese sobre a consciência
absoluta é ausente da teoria freudiana). Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 Esquema, no modelo teórico proposto por Aaron Beck q
p p
p
O próprio Beck (Beck e cols., 1997, 2005a)
identifica a influência da filosofia estoica na formulação
da sua teoria, especificamente no que concerne à tese
de que o que perturba o homem não são os fatos, mas
a interpretação feita deles. Neste cenário da supremacia
da cognição, as respostas emocionais, motivacionais e
comportamentais são determinadas a partir de
estruturas cognitivas com conteúdos que se apresentam
relativamente estáveis, denominadas esquemas. Os
esquemas são compostos de representações (crenças) e
proveem estabilidade aos sistemas cognitivo, afetivo e
comportamental. Nessa perspectiva, enfatiza-se a
investigação e validação de ideias e de crenças
idiossincráticas a respeito de si, de suas experiências e
do futuro, o que compõe o que foi definido como
tríade cognitiva (Alford & Beck, 1997; Beck e cols,
1997). q
(
y
)
Os processos psicoterápicos, fundamentados a
partir da investigação cuidadosa dos dados clínicos e do
emprego de técnicas cognitivas e comportamentais
específicas, permitiriam que os pacientes pudessem se
antecipar às suas distorções cognitivas, assim como
modificá-las. Apesar dessa proposta clínica, Beck
(1963) observa que uma parcela significativa dos
pacientes, embora consiga identificar os pensamentos
depressivos,
não
consegue evitar que eles se
manifestem antes que uma avaliação mais realista e
coerente da realidade seja feita. Outra parcela nem
mesmo consegue reconhecer que esses pensamentos
são distorcidos. Essa constatação clínica, realizada
ainda no início da teoria da terapia cognitiva de Beck,
mostra que quando as estruturas cognitivas estão
fortemente consolidadas, os tratamentos clínicos
envolvem maiores dificuldades e tempo. Beck (1963) nota que a importância dos processos
cognitivos, especialmente vistos como interpretação
dos
fatos,
também
é
encontrada
nas
ideias
psicanalíticas. Nesse sentido, o autor (Beck, 1963)
considera principalmente as noções freudianas de
processos primários e processos secundários de
funcionamento psíquico, as quais se referem a certo
desenvolvimento nas formas de cognição, ou seja, à
ideia de que os pensamentos racionais e elaborados
estão fundados em um psiquismo arcaico e irracional
(sobre isso ver Freud, 1911/1980j). j
É como psiquiatra e psicanalista que, no final da
década
de
1950,
Beck
(1963) busca analisar
empiricamente os critérios envolvidos nos quadros de
depressão. Segundo o autor, a teoria de Freud
entenderia a depressão como consequência da
agressividade do indivíduo dirigida contra si, uma
forma de autopunição, portanto. As fantasias freudianas e a dinâmica da repressão E o autor (Freud, 1915/1980a) supõe a existência
de uma repressão primeva, sempre inacessível à
consciência (justamente na medida em que marca a
divisão entre as instâncias consciente e inconsciente) e
que estabeleceria um ponto de fixação para futuras
repressões. Esse ponto seria o primeiro representante
reprimido da pulsão. Os derivados desse representante
se tornariam alvo da repressão propriamente dita, ou
melhor, da repressão cujos efeitos podem ser Lourenço, L. C. D. & Padovani, R. C. Fantasias e esquemas: possível aproximação 32 325 Introduzindo os elementos intermediários, que foram
omitidos mas que conhecemos da análise, obtemos a
seguinte corrente de pensamento: pessimismo e negativismo. Tais pensamentos se
apresentam como distorções da realidade (distorções
cognitivas) e expressam interpretações negativas que o
indivíduo tem de si, de suas experiências e de seu
futuro (tríade cognitiva). Tais observações levam Beck
(1963) à conclusão de que os transtornos de humor
são, em essência, transtornos de pensamentos. Se meu pai estivesse vivo, ele estaria tão furioso com
minha intenção de casar-me com a dama como esteve na
cena de minha infância; de modo que eu teria outra
explosão de raiva contra ele, desejando-lhe todo mal
possível; e graças à onipotência de meus desejos esses
males acabariam inevitavelmente por incidir sobre ele. (Freud, 1909/1980i, p. 228) Além disso, Beck (Beck & cols., 1997) observa
que os pensamentos depressivos são experimentados
pelos
pacientes
como
respostas
automáticas,
involuntárias. Alford e Beck (1997), influenciados pelo
conceito de processamento automático de informação
(conceito proveniente da ciência e da psicologia
cognitivas), afirmam que processos cognitivos podem
ser explicados em termos de automatismo. E, nesse
sentido,
seria
possível
falar
em
pensamentos
inconscientes. Entretanto, como dito na introdução
deste artigo, a teoria de Beck não considera o
inconsciente como instância psíquica. Os pensamentos
automáticos são ditos inconscientes somente medida
em que não são previstos ou controlados pelo
indivíduo; porém, nada impede que tais conteúdos
tornem-se conscientes. Nesse caminho, Beck afirma a
necessidade de questionar as crenças do paciente, na
qual o terapeuta teria êxito por meio do chamado
empirismo colaborativo e por meio da técnica que
denominou questionamento socrático (Padesky, 2010). Essa citação evidencia o funcionamento dos
pensamentos inconscientes, os quais são fundados em
processos pulsionais. Esquema, no modelo teórico proposto por Aaron Beck Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 Esquema, no modelo teórico proposto por Aaron Beck Nesse sentido, Beck
(Beck & cols., 1997, 1963/1964) observa os conteúdos
oníricos de seus pacientes e conclui que eles são
similares aos conteúdos de seus pensamentos em
vigília, os quais seriam então marcados pela autocrítica, Sempre mantendo o papel central do conceito de
esquemas, as terapias cognitivas realizaram avanços em
suas formulações teóricas e técnicas, a saber: o conceito
de modos proposto por Beck (2005b); a terapia focada
no esquema, apresentando uma proposta integrativa de
diferentes teorias psicológicas, entre as quais se
destacam a gestalt e psicanálise (Young, Klosko &
Weishaar, 2008); a noção do processamento cognitivo
inconsciente, formulada a partir da aproximação com
as neurociências (Callegaro, 2005, 2011). Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 326 Lourenço, L. C. D. & Padovani, R. C. Fantasias e esquemas: possível aproximação 326 Lourenço, L. C. D. & Padovani, R. C. Fantasias e esquemas: possível aproximação Em relação aos tratamentos clínicos, a terapia
cognitiva (Alford & Beck, 1997; Beck, 1963; Beck &
cols., 1997; Knapp & Beck, 2008) entende que paciente
e terapeuta têm papéis colaborativos na elaboração do
chamado plano terapêutico. Isso em nada lembra as
direções da clínica freudiana, baseadas na associação
livre (por parte do paciente) e na atenção flutuante (por
parte do analista). Contudo, é interessante notar que
Beck não desconsidera as manifestações e importância
da transferência, em sua clínica: pelo menos epistemologicamente, nenhum tratamento
é capaz de ultrapassar as barreiras da chamada
repressão primeva e da organização filogenética
(D’Avila Lourenço, 2005a). De acordo com Beck
(Alford & Beck, 1997), os esquemas podem se tornar
conscientes e, de certa forma, controláveis e
modificáveis. Isso seria alcançado por meio de uma
abordagem colaborativa e psicoeducativa (Knapp &
Beck, 2008). A esse respeito é possível pensar em uma
das distinções importantes entre a clínica de Beck e a
de Freud: se para aquele autor os esquemas são
passíveis de uma abordagem psicoeducativa, Freud
(1911/1980j) é enfático ao afirmar que as pulsões
sexuais não se educam, justamente porque podem
funcionar por meio das fantasias. Embora a transferência, conforme o conceito
psicanalítico, não seja incentivada, sua manifestação
pode ser uma ferramenta valiosa para demonstrar as
distorções interpessoais do paciente. Da mesma forma,
qualquer manifestação de resistência ao tratamento é
lidada e tratada como crenças subjacentes disfuncionais
(Knapp & Beck, 2008, p. S59). Esquema, no modelo teórico proposto por Aaron Beck p
É interessante indicar que as neurociências
cognitivas têm se mostrado importante elo entre as
teses psicanalíticas e os modelos de terapias cognitivas. Segundo Westen (2006), as terapias cognitivas têm
considerado
amplamente
as
declarações
das
neurociências cognitivas, segundo as quais a maioria
dos processos mentais não alcançam a consciência. Tais declarações não deixam de ser referidas aos
escritos freudianos, especificamente a aquele em que
Freud (1950/1980c) busca descrever o aparelho mental
a partir de um modelo de excitação neural. Da mesma
forma, as neurociências cognitivas têm proposto o que
Westen (2006) designa por certos refinamentos da
técnica psicanalítica, justamente segundo afirmações
dos modelos de terapias cognitivas. Notando
que
os
padrões cognitivos são
organizadores
dos
processos
afetivos
e
comportamentais, Beck (1963, 1964) os entende como
verdadeiros esquemas. Os esquemas funcionam como
filtros, que orientam a seleção, a codificação, o
armazenamento (memória) e a recuperação de
informações do aparato cognitivo. Por meio dos
esquemas, o organismo confere significados aos
eventos e provê estabilidade aos sistemas cognitivos,
afetivos e comportamentais. Alguns esquemas podem estar latentes e ser
ativados por eventos análogos às experiências nas quais
eles foram formados. Quando ativados, e se
disfuncionais, interferem na capacidade de avaliação
objetiva dos eventos. Distorções cognitivas sistemáticas
se apresentam à medida que esquemas disfuncionais
são ativados (Alford & Beck, 1997, Knapp & Beck,
2008). Assim, o tratamento clínico exige que o
terapeuta identifique e modifique os esquemas
disfuncionais, que proveem a base para a interpretação
das experiências da realidade objetiva. Tais considerações mostram a fecundidade dos
diálogos entre as teorias aqui referidas, revelando-se
meio para o desenvolvimento de novas reflexões sobre
a integralidade humana. Sem a pretensão de esgotar
esse tema, este artigo indica pontos relevantes para tais
diálogos, e que são corroborados por autores como
Timary, Heenen-Wolff e Philippot (2011), que
discutem a importância das representações para ambas
as teorias. Cumpre ainda observar que a escolha de
dois autores, Freud e Beck, não desconsidera a
importância dos teóricos que avançaram ou deram
novas interpretações aos conceitos de esquemas e de
fantasias. Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 Considerações finais Em P. M. Salkovskis (Ed.). Fronteiras da terapia cognitiva (pp. 21-40). São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo. Freud, S. (1980g). O ego e o id. Em J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard brasileira de obras completas de Sigmund
Freud (Vol. XIX, pp. 23-78). Rio de Janeiro:
Imago. (Original publicado em 1923). Breuer, J. & Freud, S. (1980). Estudos sobre a histeria
(V. Ribeiro, Trad.). Em J. Salomão (Org.). Edição
standard brasileira de obras completas de Sigmund Freud
(Vol.II). Rio
de Janeiro: Imago. (Original
publicado em 1895). Freud, S. (1980h). Inibições, sintomas e ansiedade. Em
J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard brasileira de obras
completas de Sigmund Freud (Vol. XX, pp. 95-203). Rio de Janeiro: Imago. (Original publicado em
1926). Callegaro, M. M. (2005). A neurobiologia da terapia do
esquema e o processamento inconsciente. Revista
Brasileira de Terapias Cognitivas, 1(1), 9-20. Freud, S. (1980i). História de uma neurose infantil. Em
J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard brasileira de obras
completas de Sigmund Freud (Vol. XVII, pp. 19-152). Rio de Janeiro: Imago. (Original publicado em
1918). p
Callegaro, M. (2011). O novo inconsciente. Porto Alegre:
Artmed. D’ Avila Lourenço, L. C. (2000). O complexo de Édipo, na
teoria de Jacques Lacan. (Dissertação de Mestrado). São Carlos: Universidade Federal de São Carlos –
Pós-Graduação em Filosofia e Metodologia das
Ciências. Freud, S. (1980j). Formulações sobre os dois princípios
do funcionamento mental. Em J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard brasileira de obras completas de Sigmund
Freud (Vol. XII, pp. 277-289). Rio de Janeiro:
Imago. (Original publicado em 1911). D’Avila Lourenço, L. C. (2005a). Transferência e
complexo de Édipo, na obra de Freud: notas sobre
os destinos da transferência. Psicologia: Reflexão e
Crítica, 18(1), 143-149. Knapp, P. & Beck, A. T. (2008). Fundamentos,
modelos conceituais, aplicações e pesquisa da
terapia cognitiva. Revista Brasileira de Psiquiatria,
30(Supl. II), S54-64. D’Avila Lourenço, L. C. (2005b). A angústia, segundo
Freud e Heidegger. Tese de Doutorado. Ribeirão
Preto: Universidade de São Paulo – Programa de
Pós-Graduação em Ciências. (
p
)
Monzani, L. R. (1989). Freud: o movimento de um
pensamento. Campinas: Editora da Unicamp. Padesky, C. A. (2010). Aaron T. Beck: a mente, o
homem e o mentor. Em R. L. Leahy (Org.). Terapia cognitiva contemporânea: teoria, pesquisa e prática
(pp. 19-36). Porto Alegre: Artmed. Freud, S. (1980a). Repressão. Em J. Salomão (Org.),
Edição standard brasileira de obras completas de Sigmund
Freud (Vol. XIV, pp. 169-189). Rio de Janeiro:
Imago. Considerações finais As fantasias e os esquemas cognitivos são
construtos fundamentais, nas teorias e técnicas de
Freud e de Beck, respectivamente. Para ambos os
autores, os sintomas são organizados em torno desses
conceitos, ou seja, a posição subjetiva é assumida e
atuada com base nesses roteiros e interpretações
primordiais. Considerando as diferenças e as aproximações
(tanto teóricas quanto práticas) entre as teses de Freud
sobre as fantasias e as teses Beck sobre os esquemas,
fica salientada a importância da escuta da palavra do
sujeito. E por que não dizer que, para ambos os
autores, a realidade dos fatos é sempre vivida como
realidade psíquica. Visto a importância dos esquemas e das fantasias,
eles são focos dos tratamentos clínicos orientados por
essas teorias. Mas a identificação e mudanças desses
processos são pensadas de maneiras distintas por elas. As fantasias, segundo Freud, podem se tornar
conscientes ou ter seus conteúdos decifrados. Contudo, Lourenço, L. C. D. & Padovani, R. C. Fantasias e esquemas: possível aproximação 327 327 Referências científica. Em J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard
brasileira de obras completas de Sigmund Freud (Vol. I,
pp. 303-421). Rio de Janeiro: Imago. (Original
publicado em 1950). Alford, B. A. & Beck, A. T. (1997). The integrative power
of cognitive therapy. Nova Iorque: The Guilford
Press. Freud, S. (1980d). Carta 69. Em J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard brasileira de obras completas de Sigmund
Freud (Vol. I, pp. 279-281). Rio de Janeiro: Imago. (Original publicado em 1950). Beck, A. T. (1963). Thinking and depression. I. Idiosyncratic content and cognitive distortions. Archives of General Psychiatry, 9, 324-333. Beck, A. T. (1964). Thinking and depression. II. Theory and therapy. Archives of General Psychiatry,
10, 561-571. Freud, S. (1980e). Três ensaios sobre a teoria da
sexualidade. Em J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard
brasileira de obras completas de Sigmund Freud (Vol. VII, pp. 129-249). Rio de Janeiro: Imago. (Original
publicado em 1905). Beck, A. T., Rush, A. J., Shaw, B. F. & Emery, G. (1997). Terapia cognitiva da depressão (S. Costa, trad). Porto Alegre: Artmed. p
)
Freud, S. (1980f). A dinâmica da transferência. Em J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard brasileira de obras
completas de Sigmund Freud (Vol. XII, pp. 131-143). Rio de Janeiro: Imago. (Original publicado em
1912). Beck, A. T. (2005a). The current state of cognitive
therapy: a 40-year retrospective. Archives of General
Psychiatry, 62, 953-959. Beck, A. T. (2005b). Além da crença: uma teoria de
modos, personalidade e psicopatologia. Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 Considerações finais (Original publicado em 1915). Ritvo, L. (1992). A influência de Darwin sobre Freud. Rio de Janeiro: Imago. Freud, S. (1980b). Análise terminável e interminável. Em J. Salomão (Org.). Edição standard brasileira de
obras completas de Sigmund Freud (Vol. XXIII, pp. 239-287). Rio de Janeiro: Imago. (Original
publicado em 1937). Timary, P., Heenen-Wolff, S. & Philippot, P. (2011). The
question
of
“representation”
in
the
psychoanalytical
and
cognitive-behavioral
approaches. Some theoretical aspects and therapy
considerations. Frontiers in Psychology, 2(71), 1-8. p
)
Freud, S. (1980c). Projeto para uma psicologia 328 Lourenço, L. C. D. & Padovani, R. C. Fantasias e esquemas: possível aproximação Westen, D. (2006). Implications of research in
cognitive
neuroscience
for
psychodynamic
psychotherapy. Focus, 4(2), 215-222. Recebido em 09/08/2012
Reformulado em 05/02/2013
Aprovado em 25/03/2013 Young, J. E., Klosko, J. S., Weishaar, M. E. (2008). Terapia do esquema: guia de técnicas cognitivo-
comportamenais inovadoras. Porto Alegre: Artmed. Departamento de Saúde, Educação e Sociedade. Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Campus Baixada Santista
Rua Silva Jardim, 136 – Vl. Mathias – CEP 11015-020 – Santos-SP, Brasil.
E
il i
d
d
i@
h
b Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013 Recebido em 09/08/2012
Reformulado em 05/02/2013
Aprovado em 25/03/2013 Sobre os autores: Sobre os autores: Lara Cristina D’Avila Lourenço é psicóloga, doutora em Psicologia pela Universidade de São Paulo, mestre em
Filosofia e Metodologia das Ciências, pela Universidade Federal de São Carlos, professora adjunta II do curso de
Psicologia da Universidade Federal de São Paulo – Campus Baixada Santista. Ricardo da Costa Padovani é psicólogo, doutor em Educação Especial pela Universidade Federal de São Carlos,
especialista em Terapia Comportamental Cognitiva em Saúde Mental pelo Instituto de Psiquiatria
HCFMUSP/Programa de Ansiedade, e professor adjunto II do curso de Psicologia da Universidade Federal de São
Paulo – Campus Baixada Santista. Contato com os autores: Departamento de Saúde, Educação e Sociedade. Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Campus Baixada Santista
Rua Silva Jardim, 136 – Vl. Mathias – CEP 11015-020 – Santos-SP, Brasil. E
il i
d
d
i@
h
b J
E-mail: ricardopadovani@yahoo.com.br Psico-USF, Bragança Paulista, v. 18, n. 2, p. 321-328, maio/agosto 2013
|
https://openalex.org/W1545260418
|
https://hal.inria.fr/hal-01590384/document
|
English
| null |
Discovery and Integration of Web 2.0 Content into Geospatial Information Infrastructures: A Use Case in Wild Fire Monitoring
|
Lecture notes in computer science
| 2,011
|
cc-by
| 7,571
|
To cite this version: Manuela Núñez-Redó, Laura Díaz, José Gil, David González, Joaquín Huerta. Discovery and Inte-
gration of Web 2.0 Content into Geospatial Information Infrastructures: A Use Case in Wild Fire
Monitoring. 1st Availability, Reliability and Security (CD-ARES), Aug 2011, Vienna, Austria. pp.50-
68, 10.1007/978-3-642-23300-5_5. hal-01590384 Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License Abstract— Abstract— Efficient environment monitoring has become a major
concern
for
society
to
guarantee
sustainable
development. For instance, forest fire detection and
analysis is important to provide early warning systems
and identify impact. In this environmental context,
availability of up-to-date information is very important
for
reducing
damages
caused. Environmental
applications are deployed on top of Geospatial
Information
Infrastructures
(GIIs)
to
manage
information pertaining to our environment. Such
infrastructures
are
traditionally
top-down
infrastructures that do not consider user participation. This provokes a bottleneck in content publication and
therefore a lack of content availability. On the contrary
mainstream IT systems and in particular the emerging
Web 2.0 Services allow active user participation that is
becoming a massive source of dynamic geospatial
resources. In this paper, we present a web service, that
implements a standard interface, offers a unique entry
point for spatial data discovery, both in GII services and
web 2.0 services. We introduce a prototype as proof of
concept in a forest fire scenario, where we illustrate how
to leverage scientific data and web 2.0 content. providing a framework for multidisciplinary analysis [3]. In this domain, we find multiple geospatial standards for
data encodings and service interfaces. The combination of
these
standards
allows
for
establishing
Geospatial
Information Infrastructures (GIIs), also known as Spatial
Data Infrastructures (SDIs) [4]. These multi-participatory
infrastructures allow administration and other official
providers to publish environmental information. However,
GIIs are dynamic and require continuous maintenance. Still,
GII complex deployment mechanisms limit the possible
contributions of expert users suffering from a low-rate of
user motivation regarding participation and content
management [6][7]. Recent natural disasters such as the
Indian and Chilean tsunamis, forest fires in Greece and
California or the earthquake in Haití have demonstrated that
difficulties still exist inefficiently exploiting geospatial
resources in GII. The difficulties stem from the absence of
sufficient available resources and a lack of collaboration and
interrelation between different geospatial infrastructures and
components. In contrast, we are witnessing the consolidation of a new
generation of the World Wide Web, in which the main
feature is user participation. Tim O’Reilly (2005)
popularized the evolving nature of the web by introducing
the term ‘Web 2.0.’ The Web is now a collaborative
environment where the increasing number of web-based
social networks has turned users into active providers [11]
[31], motivated to provide a massive amount of information
[30]. HAL Id: hal-01590384
https://inria.hal.science/hal-01590384v1
Submitted on 19 Sep 2017 L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers. Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License Abstract— This user-generated content [16] is mostly geo-
georeferenced to the user location, leading to huge amounts
of geo-referenced information available in practically any
domain [32]. For example, the photos uploaded by the
public on Flickr during the California wildfires in 2007. These photos provided a quicker overview of the situation
than information coming from official channels, such as
mapping agencies. Keywords—VGI,
SDI,
Geospatial
Information
Infrastructures, Web 2.0, Open Search Discovery and integration of Web 2.0 content into
Geospatial Information Infrastructures: A use case in
wild fire monitoring Manuela Núñez-Redó, Laura Díaz, José Gil, David González, Joaquín Huerta
Institute of New Imaging Technologies, University Jaume I, Castellón, Spain
{nunezm, laura.diaz, jose.gil, gonzaled, huerta}@uji.es geospatial
content
for
environmental
sciences,
and
providing a framework for multidisciplinary analysis [3]. A.
Geospatial Information Infrastructures A. Geospatial Information Infrastructures A trend involves deploying geospatial and environmental
applications on service-oriented architectures (SOA) [9]. One of the goals of SOA is to enable interoperability among
existing
technologies
and
provide
an
interoperable
environment based on reusability and standardized
components. GIIs enable end-users to share geospatial content in a
distributed manner following an SOA approach. They play a
key role in supporting users and providers in decision-
making where they can discover, visualize, and evaluate
geospatial data at regional, national and global levels [4]. However, the integration of these sources of information
in GII poses new research challenges. Environmental
applications need to retrieve this valuable information. This
means to deal with the different search interfaces of each
web 2.0 service and its heterogeneous capacities. International Initiatives describe the overall architecture
and best practices to design and implement GIIs. Content is
managed by means of regulated and standardized service
types. Adopted as a European directive in February 2007,
INSPIRE sets out a legal framework for the European GII,
regarding policies and activities with environmental impact
[5]. It defines a network based on discovery, view,
download, transformation and invocation services. The
technical level provides a range of interoperability standards
available for the integration of information systems [12]. To address these issues, we propose a more scalable
solution, which aims at improving the interoperability of the
heterogeneous nature of the multiple Web 2.0 services
available. Our proposal materializes in a middleware component
that provides a homogeneous search interface to improve
the discover ability over social networks and crowd
sourcing platforms. This middleware is a discovery service
that implements the OpenSearch Geo-Time standard
interface specification. Although some of the Web 2.0
services already expose an OpenSearch interface to increase
interoperability, they do not offer the spatio-temporal query
capacity, which is crucial for most of the environmental
scenarios. The realization of our proposal, called Web 2.0
Broker (W2.0B), offers a common entry point to retrieve
and aggregate web 2.0 content according to spatial and
temporal criteria. g
y
In this context many authors address questions concerning
the
increasing
number
of
people
participating
in
crowdsourcing platforms while GIIs traditionally face
problems to attract users. GII researchers have called for a
user-driven model [60] [61] [62], which relates to the hybrid
GII that incorporates user generated content. Combining
scientific knowledge and public information is not new,
according to [58] . B.
Web 2.0 Services and volunteered geospatial
information With the emergence of Web 2.0, ordinary citizens have
begun to produce and share Geographic Information (GI) on
the Internet. These Web 2.0-based activities show that users
are willing to engage more actively in the production and
provision of contents. This gives rise to a new phenomenon,
which has been referred to as “neogeography” [15] [18],
“cybercartography”
[30],
or
“voluntary
geographic
information” (VGI) [17] [21]. A.
Geospatial Information Infrastructures [59] develope the “citizen panels” in the
1970’s involving experts and citizens to allow everybody to
participate. In the context of municipal activities, [57] also
proposed to capture and utilize the “city knowledge” from
those close to a particular phenomenon with the richest
geospatial knowledge. Another example is the management
of natural resources in the Amazon where there is a need for
user participation to integrate their local knowledge [63]. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows:
Section II defines the overall context of geospatial
information
infrastructures,
volunteered
geographic
information and geospatial discovery. Section III defines the
Open Search specification. We present the architecture in
Section IV, the prototype (Section V), and conclude the
paper with a discussion and an outlook towards future work
(Section VI). I. INTRODUCTION Analyzing
the
Earth’s
behavior
requires
a
multidisciplinary approach and the assessment of a broad
range of thematic areas [1] [2]. Geospatial information is
essential for addressing related challenges. The amount of
scientific
geospatial
data
collected
has
increased
significantly due to advances in data-capturing technologies. Geospatial Information Systems (GIS) have become
indispensable tools for organizing and exploiting this 1 This information provides a complementary view to the
scientific data and shows the social impact of environmental
events like forest fires. Furthermore, due to advanced
devices that allow users to capture and share data from the
field, there is a massive source of geo-information available
at near real time. This humans-as-sensors paradigm [17]
provides a new means of providing data in its context,
which is fundamental to the vision of a spatially enabled
society [14]. To leverage this new source of information,
has to be integrated, in the context of the GIIs, to enrich
scientific information with social and local knowledge. II. BACKGROUND AND RELATED WORK Geoscience research is a multidisciplinary field that
demands heterogeneous data and a multitude of expert
profiles such as technologists and remote sensing specialists
[1] [2] [8]. These experts collect and manage data to run
scientific models and produce information. On the other
hand web 2.0 Services and crowdsourcing platforms have
demonstrated how ordinary citizens, encouraged by
technological advances, are also able to generate and
publish high scale spatial information at near real time
offering
a
complementary
vision
to
monitor
our
environment. In this section, we briefly reflect on standard
based approaches to share geospatial content and
approaches to leverage both sources of information to enrich
environmental monitoring. VGI provides a massive source of information that cannot
be ignored. This information can complete gaps in official
data including cheap and big scale up to date information. Research has related these collaborative services, paying
special attention to the trust and credibility [23] [25],
quality, and reliability as compared to official data, [22]
[26] constraints and user motivation [14] [24]. In our scope we consider VGI as a complement to official
data. Scientists will be provided with discovery mechanisms 2 to retrieve appropriate VGI that will complement the social
aspect with their scientific information. need to pay attention to discovery interfaces widely spread
in other information communities different from the
established catalogues services in the geospatial domain
[36]. Several Web 2.0 services, like Flickr, expose basic
discovery capacities through the Open Search specification
allowing for a common technique to run term-based queries. In this sense, our approach extends this to the design a
mechanism that allows users to search using the
OpenSearch (OS) specification [38] by also adding spatial-
temporal criteria to retrieve content over different social
networks and services. The use of a hybrid approach that integrates bottom-up
and
top-down
methodologies
has
already
been
demonstrated [27], with the purpose of integrating user
generated
information,
scientific
tools
and
official
information in the same geospatial infrastructure. In this
context merging the top-down SDI model with VGI
infrastructures has already been described [13] [17] [28]
[29].0 [7] [20] describe a publication service to hide
complex standards and assist users in publishing content
directly into standard geospatial data services. This direct
user publication raises issues about data consistency and
quality in GII. A Second approach is the retrieval of data
directly from crowdsourcing services. III. THE OPEN SEARCH SPECIFICATION Web 2.0 services expose their own API to be accessed,
using specific encodings formats and schemas. This
constitutes a technical barrier for discovering content in a
homogeneous way. To overcome this problem our proposal is materialized in
a discovery web service, the so-called Web 2.0 Broker. The
W2.0B implements the OpenSearch specification with the
Geo and Time extension [51], adopted by the Open
Geospatial Consortium and the geospatial community as a
standard de facto. We have performed a survey of the multiple Web 2.0
Services available, with the aim of selecting those where
spatial and temporal queries were reliable. The service
selection is the following: Twitter a social networking and
micro-blogging service. Its users can send and read text-
based posts of up to 140 characters, so-called “tweets”,
which are publicly visible by default. Flickr is an online
application that allows uploading, storing and organizing
photographs. It enables the creation and retrieval of the
pictures. YouTube allows sharing videos that can be geo-
referenced. OpenStreetMap and Geonames are both explicit
VGI platforms. Meteoclimatic is a weather resource and
Wikipedia is an open free web enclyclopedia. OS specification offers an interface based on minimal
input, which can be extended, among others, with spatial or
temporal criteria. OS has rapidly become a successful
search specification over web repositories, which are
increasingly adapting it to demonstrate their search
interfaces in a standard and simple way. In this section we
describe the OpenSearch Geo-Time specification and how
we have adopted it as the interface for our discovery service
to allow users to perform spatio-temporal queries over
social networks. II. BACKGROUND AND RELATED WORK In this context we
propose a Discovery Service that deploys on an INSPIRE-
based infrastructure that offers a standard and unique entry
point to retrieve Web 2.0 resources according to spatial and
temporal criteria that can be integrated with official
environmental information to produce a richer and more up
to date system [14]. C.
Geospatial content discovery OS defines a service interface for minimal search and
retrieval capabilities. The simplicity of OS for search fits
into the basic search interfaces that identified many Web 2.0
services. An OpenSearch-enabled service exposes an
interface for client applications to send simple HTTP GET
requests providing specific query parameters. As a result,
responses are often encoded in lightweight data formats
such as GeoRSS [39], Atom [40] or KML [41]. Within GIIs, metadata and catalogue services are key to
discover content properly [54] [55]. In this context most of
the issues arise because metadata creation and publication is
a complex and arduous task that has to be done manually
[53]. On the contrary, the ease of content production and
publication in Web 2.0 Services makes vast amounts of VGI
available. As a result, social networks are immense online
repositories with geo-referenced content. However, attempts
at providing spatial and temporal-based search engines over
VGI are relatively scarce [33]. Despite the popularity of
Web 2.0 services, there has not been many integrated and
interoperable approaches that allow users to search for
content regardless of the nature of the underlying services
[37]. One of the reasons may be found in the diversity and
heterogeneity of these types of services and their interfaces. The OpenSearch specification has only one mandatory
query parameter called “searchTerms” allowing client
applications to retrieve information related to one or more
keywords. Other query parameters like those supporting
results pagination (“count”, “startIndex”, “startPage”) are
optional. The W2.0B implements this interface to broadcast
keywords-based search over a selected pool of Web 2.0
services. Each service must be described by its Description
Document, a file whose aim is, to describe the search engine
of the target service. This description could vary from one
to another, but there are several mandatory parameters like
the root node called OpenSearchDescription, shortName
that contain a brief human-readable title to identify this
search engine, Description which is a text explanation of the The process of searching over multiple services becomes
a tedious task because they provide different data
encodings, geo-referencing and proprietary application
programming interface (API). In order to overcome this heterogeneity the use of a
common interface, following a standard specification,
would increase interoperability. Walsh [35] points out the 3 search engine and the URL with the location to execute a
search request. A. Application Layer Whereas traditional applications offer access to the
content via the Geospatial Networking Service layer (Figure
1), this architecture offers an additional entry point to the
W2.0B. This functionality is part of the Service Connector
module, since it is the component in charge of connecting to
the available middleware. Table 1: Search Parameters implemented in the W2.0B
applicable to Web 2.0 services. Table 1: Search Parameters implemented in the W2.0B
applicable to Web 2.0 services. In this layer users are presented with a friendly interface
to perform queries according to keyword and spatial-
temporal criteria. Both standard catalogues and the W2.0B
can be used to retrieve results. In the case of the W2.0B, this
query will be transmitted and the results transformed to a
well-known common data encoder to be presented in this
layer using geospatial Web Mapping technology. applicable to Web 2.0 services. B.
Spatial and Temporal-based discovery More advanced search criteria are necessary in our
environment-monitoring scenario. Specific search profiles
are described by extending the OpenSearch specification. The OGC OpenSearch Geo Temporal specification [51],
defines a list of query parameters to enable spatial and
temporal filtering. This extension is built upon the basic
OpenSearch specification, so all mandatory and optional
query parameters previously mentioned are also available. The spatial and temporal extensions define spatial and time
specific, optional query parameters. The “geo:box”
parameter filters are the result of a rectangular area. The
“geo:lat”, “geo:lon” and “geo:radius” parameter filters
results from a circular area around a point. The
“geo:geometry” parameter defines a geographic filter by
means of an arbitrary geometry. The “geo:name” parameter
allows filtering by place name. The “time:start” and
“time:end” allow the definition of a temporal range for valid
results. Figure 1 shows a simplified overview of the INSPIRE
technical architecture which basically extends a classical
three-layered SOA. This architecture is composed (top-
down) of the application layer, service layer and content
layer. The next subsections will describe each of these
layers and the components that describe our contribution. Figure 1: Classical three-tier GII architecture (extracted
from [10]) extended with a new channel connecting to
VGI sources. The W2.0B implements the OS Geo-Time specification. Therefore, we increase the interoperability of the selected
crowdsourcing platforms because now client applications
can run spatio-temporal queries in these services by using
OS-Geo-Time as unique interfaces. Table 1 shows the
current status of the W2.0B prototype. The colored cells
show the service currently offered where the rows show the
web 2.0 services where the query is propagated and the
columns shows the operations, available in the OS Geo-
Time specification, implemented to query the Web 2.0
services. Regarding the response formats, Atom, the format
recommended by [51], KML and MIMETEXT KML[43]
are supported. Figure 1: Classical three-tier GII architecture (extracted
from [10]) extended with a new channel connecting to
VGI sources. B. Geospatial Networking Service Layer A classical GII provides discovery, access and processing
services that, implement the OGC standards, such as
Catalogue Services (CS-W), Web Mapping Service (WMS),
Web Feature Service (WFS), and Web Processing Service
(WPS), providing access to the geospatial content. In our
research we propose to extend this layer with a new
discovery service that, by implementing the OpenSearch
Geo-Time interface, acts as a search engine to access Web
2.0 content. C.
Geospatial content discovery The W2.0B offers the functionality to perform a spatio-
temporal search of VGI in multiple Web 2.0 services for its
integration
with
official
environmental
information
available in the infrastructure. In this way the vast amount
of VGI becomes another data source in GIIs to complement
scientific data. The integration is performed at the client
side since the W2.0B provides common data encoding. B. Spatial and Temporal-based discovery V. WEB 2.0 BROKER: OPEN SEARCH SERVICE W2.0B implements the function to search different social
networks and Web 2.0 Services. A collection of social
media services, with geo-referencing capabilities, has been
analyzed (Table I), and only those that support, to some
degree, geospatial and temporal filtering functions through
their public API have been selected as target repositories
[44]. The OS Descriptor Manager dynamically generates the
service description document [38] specifying how the
different services must be queried. This document,
mandatory by the specification, is generated by each service
adapter. Its function is to advertise the set of accepted query
parameters and supported response formats. This allows
both calls from outside and within a client application to
understand the discovery interfaces supported by services
and how to build valid OpenSearch-styled queries. Although some Web 2.0 services implement the
OpenSearch specification (Flickr, Wikipedia, Youtube
OpenStreetMap), some of them do not offer the
OpenSearch-Geo-Time
search
interface. The
W20B
overcomes this limitation by offering spatial and temporal
criteria queries to these services. The Geo-reference Manager component deals with the
management of geospatial content. In terms of spatial search
accuracy and performance, the W20B relies on the spatial
search capabilities provided by the services queried and the
content available, for instance, only a few tweets are
actually geo-referenced. In this case, the Geo-reference
Manager follows a methodology to extract the location from
the user profile by using the Geonames service to extract the
location of a place name found in the content. Java API which facilitates the development of client
applications implemented in JAVA or accessing the OS
standard interface. Java API which facilitates the development of client
applications implemented in JAVA or accessing the OS
standard interface. C. Content Layer We focus on the integration of both official and non
official sources. Specifically, we focus on the retrieval of
the content provided by Web 2.0 Services. These non-
official resources are especially relevant due to the fact that
users provide real time information, local knowledge and
social impact to enrich the official environmental
information. Figure 2: W2.0B components diagram. At the top of Figure 2 we can see how the W2.0B
implements the OS Geo-Time specification to provide
discovery capabilities over heterogeneous VGI resources. Table 1 shows the set of crowdsourcing platforms being
queried by the W2.0B. The content provided by these
platforms differs in nature, for instance, geo-tagged
photographs are shared through Flickr [45], short text
messages shared via Twitter [48], or videos uploaded to
Youtube [50], encyclopedic descriptions in Wikipedia [49],
place names using Geonames [46], tagged vector geometries
in OpenStreetMap [47] or information about weather
stations provided by Meteoclimatic [56]. Due to the
substantial availability of resources in crowdsourcing
platforms a big part of the retrieved results are not related to
the target scenario and they represent somehow “noise” that
has to be eliminated for an appropriated assessment. Although it is out of the scope of this current investigation
to assess data quality, section VII overviews a preliminary
discussion and outlines open questions that remain for
future research. The OS Core component deals with the interpretation of
the query in the standard OS format. It retrieves the query
and forwards it to the Search Engine component. Only the
SearchTerms input parameter from the specification is
mandatory, but other criteria can be specified. The accuracy
of results is improved either by adding spatial filtering with
the bbox, location or lon, lat and radius parameters, or
adding time criteria by setting up the start and end
parameters as we will see in the discussion section. The Search Engine component contains the logic to map
the query and the specified search criteria to then perform
the concrete operations offered by the different web 2.0
services. It will broadcast the query to the different search
engines and adapters that the client has selected. The
supported query can add spatial constraints to the queries
sent to the Web 2.0 services that natively support
geographic search capabilities through their own API. For
instance, users can search for resources that are restricted to
a given area of interest represented as a polygonal geometry. IV. SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE IV. SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE In this section we elaborate on the architecture of the
proposed approach. Our main goal is to extend traditional
GII architecture with a middleware component that offers a
standard interface to retrieve and integrate web 2.0 content. W2.0B allows searching for VGI data through its standard
OS Geo-Time interface and through a specific API. Client
that have two ways to connect on the one hand, through its 4 Figure 2: W2.0B components diagram. B.
Web 2.0 Broker implementation p
p
Table 1 shows the specific capabilities of each adapter in
terms of the OpenSearch Geo-Time features. Capabilities
supported by W2.0B were shaded in the corresponding
cell(s). These capabilities are limited by the functionality
offered natively by each specific API. For example, some
services allow filtering by bounding box and others by
centre and radius. In all cases, KML and Atom extended
with GeoRSS are provided as standard geographic formats
in the response. In addition, the nature of each service leads
to different constraints and requirements in terms of
discovery. For instance, Flickr’s resources can be queried
over time while Twitter’s resources are only discoverable
during a narrow time frame. Indeed, these open issues pose
new challenges in the field of social mining. The W2.0B has been designed as a middleware
component with a standard interface to be re-used in
different scenarios. OpenSearch Geo-Time is the standard
of choice to implement the W2.0B in order to increase
interoperability when accessing multiple Web 2.0 services. In this section we illustrate how the W2.0B works when it is
invoked. Figure 4 shows a sequence diagram illustrating the
workflow of how the different components are invoked
when running a query. The W2.0B receives a OS GeoTime
styled query such as the following: http://elcano.dlsi.uji.es:8082/broker.jsp?service=service
&q={searchTerms}&per_page={count?}&page={startPag
e}&format={responseFormat}&name={geo:name}&lon={
geo:lon?}&lat={geo:lat?}&radius={geo:radius?}&bbox={
geo:box?}&start={time:start}&end{time:end}&format=dat
format However, not all the web 2.0 services have an API from
which the data is accessed. For instance wheather
information extracted from Meteoclimatic or environmental
news from European media sites are analyzed and
interpreted to add them information sources. For the time
being, the RSS information that is retrieved is related to Fire
News and MODIS Hotspots of the last seven days, and it is
gathered from European Forest Fire Information System
(EFFIS)[52] sources through the European Commission's
Joint Research Centre (JRC). This adapter injects the query parameters into the specific
Flickr API discovery methods and carries out the query. Optional query parameters may be encoded in the URL
itself for results pagination, language selection, and
character encoding. This component also allows the integration of the custom
search engine with the most popular web browsers such as
Internet Explorer, Firefox and Opera. This custom search
engine refers to the Multiquery adaptor which offers a
multiple search of each service provided by the W2.0B
(Table 1). A.
Web 2.0 Broker –Design Figure 2 shows the component diagram of the W20B. It
illustrates its modular design and how the components are
linked to each other. Below, we will elaborate more on each
component and its functionality. The Adapter Manager component is the manager of a set
of specific adapters for each service. It plays a mediating
role between service-specific APIs and the OpenSearch
query. The W2.0B clients control the search procedure by
selectively activating one or more services. The Adapter 5 Manager delegates on the selected adapters which adapt the
query to the specific APIs. The manager will aggregate the
results. Furthermore, since these social networks and media
services offer specific discovery interfaces, they also
provide different response formats. discovery interface from the client perspective. In doing so,
clients and adapters are independent, loosely coupled
components where each one evolves separately, enhancing
the system scalability as a whole [34]. VI. PROTOTYPE: USE CASE IN FOREST FIRE MONITORING Figure 5: Screenshot of the EFFIS layer with hotspots of
the last seven days. Forest fire disasters are increasingly frequent events
around the globe. The growing severity of fire disasters is a
consequence of increased vulnerability of the natural
environment. Forest fires are not only an environmental
problem; as a social concern a forest fire is reflected in the
social networks. People use social networks in Internet to
reveal their perception and feeling. Therefore, it is possible
to find pictures, videos, real-time information, NGO reports,
and scientific papers in Internet that describe fires, the post-
fire consequences and even events regarding vegetation
recovery. Our purpose is to include this web 2.0 content to
complement data coming from the “official sources” at
global, national or regional level. For the first prototype, W2.0B encompasses the adapters
for a selection of services: Twitter, Flickr, YouTube,
OpenStreetMap, Wikipedia and Geonames. Different levels
of expertise and quality can be found in crowd sourcing
platforms. In our scenario different queries demonstrated
that the most relevant information was retrieved from
Youtube, Twitter and Flickr services. The web client offers a simple and an advanced user
interface to the user to specify the search criteria and build
the query. Users can add spatial temporal criteria by setting
the area of interest by selecting a rectangle in the map or by
point and radius information; users can also set the time
period by what the results are valid. To demonstrate the added value of our solution to the
scientific workflow we will describe a scenario and how the
solution is integrated into it. We focus on assisting scientific
users in the data collection step so that the user can compare
the official information with Web 2.0 content to refine the
output and help in the decision making. The central
functioning of the W2.0B as middleware can be best
illustrated with a practical example. Figure 6: Screenshot of the area selected by the user. For demonstration purposes we have designed and
developed a web client application to access the W2.0B. This
client,
developed
with
Google
Web
Toolkit
technology, offers a user-friendly interface to facilitate
users’ access to the functionality of the W2.0B in a simple
and visual way. B.
Web 2.0 Broker implementation To do so, we add auto-discovery by adding to the
search client a HTML tag which points to the corresponding
OpenSearch description document. This tag activates the
“search engine manager” of the browsers to offer the
possibility of adding Web 2.0 broker as a new Search
Engine as we can see in Figure 3. First of all, as shown in Figure 4, search clients retrieve
the required descriptors via OS Descriptor Manager
component. Figure 4: Web 2.0 Broker sequence diagram. Figure 3: Web 2.0 Broker search engine added in a
common browser. Figure 4: Web 2.0 Broker sequence diagram. Once the descriptor is loaded, the client is able to build
and send the OS query. When the query is received, the OS
Core interprets it and the Search Engine propagates the
query to the Adapter Manager. Afterwards, the adapter Figure 3: Web 2.0 Broker search engine added in a
common browser. This broker architecture configuration is flexible as new
adapters may be added without altering the broker’s 6 Figure 5: Screenshot of the EFFIS layer with hotspots of
the last seven days. manager connects and queries each service by means of the
specific adapter. At this point, the Geo-Reference component becomes
important as it is in charge of several geospatial features
such as extracting coordinates from a placenames, as well
as the inverse functionality, or getting the center coordinates
and radius from a bounding box based on the Haversine
formula, implemented in this module. The Adapter Manager aggregates the retrieved results and
the Search Engine component generates the response to be
derived to the client. A. Forest Fire monitoring scenario Forest fire monitoring is a complex scenario that involves
many phases and procedures. To illustrate our prototype we
focus on the post fire monitoring phase, i.e., once the fire
has taken place, how it will be monitored to evaluate its
environmental and social impact. In our scenario the chosen
geographical area is the region of Ibiza, one of the Balearic
Islands in Spain. In order to monitor the status of the
detected fire, the user accesses the web client that provides a
map viewer. This map viewer is able to visualize data
coming from SDI services. In this context we add some
layers to the map coming from the Data Services of EFFIS
to overview some official information in the fire warning
index or HotSpots as is shown in Figure 5. Figure 6: Screenshot of the area selected by the user. In our scenario the user restricts the area of interest to the
island of Ibiza, Spain and fills out the time constraint in
order to retrieve information about fires during a one week
time period beginning on May 21st. According to the parameters available in the OS Geo and
Time specification, the OS query set to the W20B is as
follows: http://elcano.dlsi.uji.es:8082/broker.jsp?service=fck,twi,y
tb&q=incendio&format=kml&bbox=2.637,34.917,6.724,1. 450&lon=1.450&lat=38.993&radius=120&start=2011-05-
21&end=2011-05-28 http://elcano.dlsi.uji.es:8082/broker.jsp?service=fck,twi,y
tb&q=incendio&format=kml&bbox=2.637,34.917,6.724,1. 450&lon=1.450&lat=38.993&radius=120&start=2011-05-
21&end=2011-05-28 7 of Web 2.0 Services and improve data accessibility. Based
on this previous research we propose a web service, the
Web 2.0 Broker. The functionality of this service is to
access the Web 2.0 Services functions (search interface,
geographic content data type) through a unique entry point
implementing
a
common
simple
query
interface:
OpenSearch Geo and Time extension. When the W2.0B receives the query sent by the search
client, it is broadcasted to the web 2.0 services that were
specified in the query. Users are able to select different web
2.0 services at once to be queried. This increases the amount
of retrieved information. In our case we specify
“service=fck,twi,ytb” which means that the W2.0B queries
the services Flickr, Twitter and Youtube. Figure 7 shows
some of the retrieved results, which in this case are returned
in KML format to be visualized in the map. OpenSearch (OS) defines a minimal interface to query a
search engine that is extensible by adding extra parameters
to define other filtering criteria. Table 2: Findings of the W2.0B comparative study of
Open Search Extension in three services. Table 2: Findings of the W2.0B comparative study of
Open Search Extension in three services. Table 2: Findings of the W2.0B comparative study of
Open Search Extension in three services. Figure 8: VGI Data extracted from Flickr through
W2.0B. A. Forest Fire monitoring scenario Such extensions include the
time and geo-extension [42] [51] allowing the use of spatial
and temporal filters: bounding box, circle, polygon, place
name and valid period of time. Figure 7: Screenshot of W20B results. OS and its geo and time extensions are proposed as the
query interface to access spatial content, both for Web 2.0
Services and SDI services. The Web 2.0 Broker is able to
receive OS queries, propagate them to a set of Web 2.0
Services and return the results encoded in standard data
formats such as GeoRSS, GeoJSON, KML or ATOM. As a first assessment of the results retrieved in the
previous section, using spatial and time criteria, we have
performed a preliminary study that may be used as a starting
point for future work. Table 2 shows some statistics of the
results retrieved in three of the services. Three queries have
been built and sent; the first one (identified as OS row)
contains only the term criteria (fire) with the basic Opens
Search parameters, the second one (OS GEO) using spatial
criteria and the third one (OS GEO TEM) also adds time
criteria. Regarding the location information, the retrieved
results are handled by the Geocoding Manager of the
W2.0B to extract the coordinates when missing, especially
in the case of Twitter. Figure 7: Screenshot of W20B results. Figure 8 shows an example of a photograph of the fire in
Ibiza. Some other retrieved results are videos about the fire
from YouTube, and user comments expressing current
concerns or describing other events at near real time from
Twitter. Figure 8: VGI Data extracted from Flickr through
W2.0B. Relevance and accuracy in the content is achieved thanks
to the addition of spatial and time criteria to the query. This
is also reflected in Table 2. REFERENCES [1] M. Craglia, M.F. Goodchild, A. Annoni, G. Câmara, M. Gould, W. Kuhn, D.M. Mark, I. Masser, D.J. Maguire,
S. Liang, E. Parsons. “Next generation Digital Earth”. A position paper from the Vespucci Initiative for the
Advancement of Geographic Information Science. International Journal of Spatial Data Infrastructure
Research, vol. 3, 2008, pp. 146–167. [18] M.F Goodchild. NeoGeography and the nature of
geographic expertise. Journal of Location Based
Services, Vol. 3, No. 2, p. 82-96. 2009 [19] M. Bishr and W. Kuhn. Geospatial information bottom-
up: A matter of trust and semantics. In S. Fabrikant &
M. Wachowicz (Eds.), The European information
society: Leading the way with geo-information (pp. 365–387). Berlin: Springer. 2007. [2] M.F. Goodchild. “Geographic information science: the
grand
challenges”. In
J.P. Wilson
and
A.S. Fotheringham, editors, The Handbook of Geographic
Information Science. Malden, MA: Blackwell, 2008,
pp. 596–608 [20] L. Díaz and S. Schade. GEOSS Service Factory:
Assisted Publication of Geospatial Content. Accepted
to the 14th AGILE International Conference on
Geographic Information Science (AGILE 2011). Utrecht, The Netherlands, April 2011 [3] M.K. Ramamurthy,
"A
new
generation
of
cyberinfrastructure and data services for earth science
education and research”. Advances in Geosciences, pp. 69-78, June 6, 2006. [21] Tulloch, D.L. (2007). Many many maps: Empowerment
and online participatory mapping. First Monday. [22] Coote, A. and Rackham, L. (2008), "Neogeographic
Data Quality – Is it an issue?" Paper presented at the
2008 Annual Conference of the Association for
Geographic Information (AGI). [4] I. Masser. GIS Worlds: Creating Spatial Data
Infrastructures. Redlands: ESRI Press. 2005. [5] INSPIRE EU Directive. 2007. Directive 2007/2/EC of
the European Parliament and of the Council of 14
March 2007 establishing an Infrastructure for Spatial
Information in the European Community (INSPIRE). Official Journal of the European Union, L 108/1,
Volume 50, 25 April 2007. [23] Harvey, F. (2003), "Developing geographic information
infrastructures for local government: the role of trust". The Canadian Geographer. Vol. 47, No. 1, pp. 28-36 [24] Elwood,
S. (2008),
"Volunteered
geographic
information: future research directions motivated by
critical, participatory, and feminist GIS". GeoJournal,
vol. 72, no. 3-4, pp. 173-183. [6] D.J. Coleman, P.Y. Georgiadou, and J. Labonte. “Volunteered geographic information: the nature and
motivation of produsers”. In: International journal of
spatial data infrastructures research : IJSDIR, vol. 4,
2009, pp. 332-358. [25] Flanagin, A.J. & Metzger, M.J. (2008), "The credibility
of volunteered geographic information", GeoJournal,
vol. 72, no. 3-4, pp. 137-148. VII. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS The implemented prototype illustrates the current work on
the W2.0B. Practically speaking, we have developed a
mechanism to collect and aggregate VGI from multiple
platforms. The Web 2.0 Broker aggregates Web 2.0 adapters that
translate an original OS query to the concrete syntax of each
Web 2.0 Service API. This approach implies the
development of OS adapters for each Web 2.0 Service
instead of using the proprietary search tools of each Web
2.0 resources. Its advantage is that potential calibration p
To
increase
interoperability
and
scalability
this
mechanism offers a standard entry point to query multiple
web 2.0 services to be integrated [44] and implements a
mechanism to use a simple query interface to integrate a set 8 [8] S. Schade, and M. Craglia. “A Future Sensor Web for
the Environment in Europe”. EnviroInfo Conference,
Berlin, Germany, 2010. mechanisms
can
be
encapsulated
in
well-defined
components, which directly connect and use the specific
Web 2.0 service APIs. However, the search criteria based on
the OS needs to be mapped into the specific Web 2.0 service
API and this means that we could lose accuracy in certain
parts of a query. This may have an impact on the numbers
of VGI items retrieved and therefore further research has to
be performed. [9] M. Papazoglou, W-J. Van den Heuvel. “Service
oriented architectures: approaches, technologies and
research issues”. The VLDB Journal, vol. 16, issue 3,
pp. 389- 415, 2007. [10] W.M.P. Aalst, M. van der Beisiegel, K.M. van der Hee,
D. Konig, C. Stahl. “An SOA-based architecture
framework”. International Journal of Business Process
Integration and Management, vol. 2, issue 2, pp. 91-
101, 2007. The wild fire examples illustrate the complexity of VGI
data integration where VGI publication patterns differ
depending on the considered types of phenomena and the
associated geospatial, temporal and event criteria. [11] N. Alameh. “Chaining Geographic Information Web
Services”. IEEE Internet Computing, vol. 7, issue 5, pp. 22-29, 2003. The potential of the massive VGI availability monitoring,
which is the state of the environment to validate global
models with local knowledge, has yet to be fully exploited. [12] J. Mykkänen, and M. Tuomainen. “An evaluation and
selection framework for interoperability standards”. Information and Software Technology, vol 50, issue 3,
pp. 176-197, 2008. Our work indicates that VGI can be complementary and
can provide high-scale value-added information at low cost. VII. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS Furthermore, this approach could be used to enrich crisis
management models inputs or to refine their output results. Further developments of the Web 2.0 Broker are ongoing to
improve the means to harness VGI to integrate it into GII
and to leverage its full potential. [13] N.R. Budhathoki, B. Bertram, Z. Nedovic-Budic. “Reconceptualizing the role of the user of spatial data
infrastructure”. GeoJournal, vol, 72, pp. 149-160, 2008. [14] D.J., Coleman. Volunteered Geographic Information in
Spatial Data Infrastructure: An Early Look At
Opportnities And Constraints. GSDI 12 World
Conference. Singapore. October 2010 [15] A. Turner. Introduction to Neogeography (O’Reilly
Short Cuts series). O’Reilly Media. 2006 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS [16] T. O'Reilly. What Is Web 2.0: Design Patterns and
Business Models for the Next Generation of Software. 2005 This work has been partially supported by the European
FP7 Project nr. 226487 called EuroGEOSS. [17] M.F Goodchild, M.F. Citizens as voluntary sensors:
spatial data infrastructure in the world of Web 2.0. International Journal of Spatial Data Infrastructures
Research 2: 24–32. (437). 2007 [56] Meteoclimatic: http://www.meteoclimatic.com/ [56] Meteoclimatic: http://www.meteoclimatic.com [57] Carrera, F. Ferreira, J. (2007) The Future of Spatial
Data
Infrastructures:
Capacitybuilding
for
the
Emergence of Municipal SDI. International Journal of
Spatial Data Infrastructures Research, vol. 2,49-68 [33] Tsai FS (2011) Web-based geographic search engine
for location-aware search in Singapore. Expert Systems
with Applications 38:1011-1016 [34] Nuñez M, Díaz L, Granell C, Huerta J (2011) Web 2.0
Broker: a tool for massive collection of user
information. Accepted to European Geosciences Union
(EGU) General Assembly 2011 (EGU 2011). Vienna,
Austria, Apr 2011 [58] Jankowski, P. (2009) Towards participatory geographic
information
systems
for
community-based
environmental
decision
making. Journal
of
environmental management, vol 90, 1966-1971 [59] Dienel, P. (1989) Contributing to social decision
methodology: citizen reports on technological projects. Social Decision Methodology for Technological
Projects (Theory and Decision Library, Series A),
Kluwer Academic Publishers. [35] Walsh J (2007) On Spatial Data Search. Terradue
White
Paper. http://www.terradue.com/images/T2-
Research-07-003-OnSearch.pdf
Á [36] Nogueras-Iso J, Zarazaga-Soria FJ, Béjar R, Álvarez
PJ, Muro-Medrano PR (2005) OGC Catalog Services: a
key element for the development of Spatial Data
Infrastructures. Computers & Geosciences, 31(2): 199-
209 [60] Williamson,
I.(2003)
SDIs—setting
the
scene. Developing spatial data infrastructures: From concept
to reality.CRC Press. (pp. 3–16). [61] Masser, I. (2005). GIS worlds: Creating spatial data
infrastructures (First ed.). ESRI Press. [37] Naaman M (in press) Social multimedia: highlighting
opportunities for search and mining of multimedia data
in social media applications. Multimed Tools Appl. DOI 10.1007s/11042-010-0538-7 [62] Budhathoki, N.R. Nedovic-Budic, Z.(2007). Expanding
the SDI knowledge base. In H. Onsrud (Ed.), Research
and theory in advancing spatial data infrastructure (pp. 7–32). [38] Clinton,
D. (2010)
OpenSearch
1.1
Draft
4
specification. http://www.opensearch.org [63] Fonseca, C.R., Ganade, G., Baldissera, R., Becker,
C.G., Boelter, C.R., Brescovit, A.D., Campos, L.M.,
Fleck, T., Fonseca, V.S., Hartz, S.M., Joner, F., Käffer,
M.I., Leal-Zanchet, A.M., Marcelli, M.P., Mesquita,
A.S., Mondin, C.A., Paz, C.P., Petry, M.V., Piovezan,
F.N., Putzke, J., Stranz, A., Vergara, M., Vieira, E.M.,
(2009). Towards an ecologically sustainable forestry in
the Atlantic Forest. Biological Conservation vol 142,
1144–1154. [39] GeoRSS (2011) http://www.georss.org/Main_Page [40] Nottingham M, Syare R (2005) The Atom Syndication
Format. RFC 4287, http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287 [41] OGC KML (2008) OpenGIS Keyhole Markup
Language
(KML)
Implementation
Specification,
Version 2.2.0. Open Geospatial Consortium Inc (Open
GIS
Consortium
Inc). REFERENCES [7] L., Díaz, C., Granell, M., Gould, J., Huerta. Managing
user
generated
information
in
geospatial
cyberinfrastructures. Future
Generation
Computer
Systems, vol. 27, no.3, pp. 304-314, 2011. [26] S. Shade, G. Luraschi, B. De Longueville, S. Cox,
Laura Díaz. Citizens as sensors for forest fires: Sensor
Web
Enablement
for
Volunteered
Geographic
Information. M.A. Brovelli, S. Dragicevic, S. Li, B. Veenendaal (Eds): ISPRS Workshop on Pervasive Web 9 Mapping, Geoprocessing and Services XXXVIII-
4/W13 (WebMGS 2010). Como, Italy, August 2010,
ISSN 1682-1777 [48] Twitter (2011) http://twitter.com [49] Wikipedia (2011) http://www.wikipedia.org [50] YouTube (2011) http://youtube.com [27] Jankowski, P. 2009. Towards participatory geographic
information
systems
for
community-based
environmental
decision
making. Journal
of
Environmental Management 90. 1966–1971 [51] Gonçalves (2010) OpenSearch Geo –Time extension. OpenGIS. [52] http://effis.jrc.ec.europa.eu/data [28] Craglia,
M. (2007). Volunteered
Geographic
Information and Spatial Data Infrastructures: when
docparallel lines converge? Specialist Meeting on
Volunteered Geographic Information. 13-14 December
2007. Santa Barbara [53] Díaz L, Martín C, Gould M, Granell C, Manso
M.A,(2007) Semi-automatic Metadata Extraction from
Imagery
and
Cartographic
data,
International
Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium (IGARSS
2007). Barcelona,. IEEE CS Press, pp. 3051-3052. [54] Craglia, M. Kanellopoulos, I. Smits, P. (2007)
Metadata: where we are now, and where we should be
going. Proceedings of 10th AGILE International
Conference on Geographic Information Science 2007. Aalborg University, Denmark [29] Gould, M. (2007). Vertically interoperable geo-
infrastructures and scalability. Specialist Meeting on
Volunteered Geographic Information. 13-14 December
2007. Santa Barbara [30] Belimpasakis P, Saaranen A (2010) Sharing with
people: a system for user-centric content sharing. Multimed Syst 16:399-4216[ [55] Nogueras-Iso, J. Zarazaga-Soria, F.J. Béjar, R. Álvarez, P.J. . Muro-Medrano, P.R. . (2005) OGC
Catalog Services: a Key element for the development of
Spatial
Data
Infrastructures,
Computers
and
Geosciences, vol. 31/2, 199-209. [31] Boll S (2007) MultiTube–Where Multimedia and Web
2.0 Could Meet. IEEE Multimed 14(1): 9-13 [32] Nature Editorial (2008) A place for everything. Nature
453(2):2 [56] Meteoclimatic: http://www.meteoclimatic.com/ http://www.opengeospatial.org/standards/kml [42] Turner, A (2010) The OpenSearch Geo extension (draft
2) [43] Abargues C, Beltrán A, Granell C (2010) MIMEXT: a
KML extension for georeferencing and easy share
MIME type resources. In: Geospatial Thinking. Springer, pp. 315-334. [44] Fonts
O.,
Huerta,
J. Díaz,
L,
Granell
C. (2009).OpenSearch-geo: The simple standard for
geographic search engines. Proceedings IV Jornadas
SIG Libre [45] Flickr.com (2011) http://www.flickr.com [46] Geonames (2011) http://www.geonames.org (2011) [47] Open
Street
Maps
(2011)
http://www.openstreetmaps.org 10
|
https://openalex.org/W4389146176
|
https://www.ijfmr.com/papers/2023/6/9300.pdf
|
Latin
| null |
Leisure and Rural Elders: China’s Leisure Education Programmes Under the Rural Revitalization Strategy
|
International Journal For Multidisciplinary Research
| 2,023
|
cc-by-sa
| 4,798
|
Abstract: The World Leisure Organisation’s Charter for Leisure outlines the right to adequate time for rest and for
the pursuit of leisure activity. The right to leisure time and to participate in the cultural life of the
community are significant for the wellbeing of a person. Leisure time refers to the remaining disposable
time after completing various social responsibilities such as labour and professional activities, mainly used
for entertainment, rest, and to meet spiritual and cultural needs. For older adults, mastering their leisure
time is an important component of their lifestyle. However, the current situation is that doing household
chores and helping the next generation take care of their children occupy a large part of their leisure time. Older adults’ decline in leisure activity participation is related to occurrence of diseases such as
Alzheimer’s disease. Therefore, with the acceleration of the aging population in the world, monitoring the
participation level of older adults in leisure activities and timely intervention has become an urgent task. China has an aging population, with the rural elderly population growing faster than the urban one. Data
from the seventh national census in 2021 show that the proportion of people aged 60 and 65 and above in
rural areas has reached 23.81 percent and 17.72 percent respectively, which are 7.99 and 6.61 percentage
higher than the corresponding figure in urban areas. With the migration of young people to urban areas,
rural older adults are left alone causing serious social concerns. Through the Healthy China initiative,
many proactive policy initiatives are formulated for the older adults. Initiation of policies to improve the
mental and physical well-being of older adults especially in the rural areas show the significance China
attaches to solve the challenges faced by rural elders. Since leisure directly determines the happiness of
the people, the Chinese government is increasingly attaching importance to leisure education for the
people, and paying attention to adult leisure education in rural areas has become an important part of the
rural revitalization strategy. Promoting rural adults’ leisure is significant for creating an environment for
them to live happily in their later years. This complements the rural revitalization strategy to construct a
beautiful countryside. In this backdrop, this paper discusses the various aspects of aging and leisure of
rural elders and how it is integrated into the rural revitalization strategy of China. International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR)
E-ISSN: 2582-2160 ● Website: www.ijfmr.com ● Email: editor@ijfmr.com International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR)
E-ISSN: 2582-2160 ● Website: www.ijfmr.com ● Email: editor@ijfmr.com Leisure and Rural Elders: China’s Leisure
Education Programmes Under the Rural
Revitalization Strategy Anna Thomas Assistant Professor, Anhui Normal University Keywords: rural elders, leisure, health, rural revitalization strategy, China. Introduction The rise of rural revitalization as a national strategy is essentially an affirmation of rural values
and a return to the spirit of rural China. The Rural Revitalization Strategy (2018-2022) proposed by the
19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China is of great significance in the development of
China’s three problems: agriculture, rural areas and farmers. On February 4, 2018, the Opinions of the
Central Committee of the Communist Party of China and the State Council on Implementing the Rural
Revitalization Strategy was officially released, proposing the overall requirements of rural revitalization
strategy to be industrial prosperity, ecological liveability, civilized rural culture, effective governance, and
a prosperous life. To solve the current imbalance in rural social development and alleviate the main
contradictions in rural development, the revitalization strategy emphasised on building a scientific
institutional mechanism and policy system to promote urban-rural integration and accelerate the process
of agricultural and rural modernization. In February 2021, general secretary Xi Jinping pointed out that
the revitalization of the countryside is a major task for the great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation.1 In
the wake of the comprehensive victory of China’s strategy of tackling poverty alleviation, the revitalization
of the countryside focussing on agriculture, rural areas, and farmers has become a major task ahead for
China. Rural revitalization cannot be successful without addressing the basic issue of rural people. Elderly
in rural areas are an important component of rural revitalization. According to the seventh national
population census, the population aged 60 and above accounts for 18.70% of the total population in China,
an increase of 5.44 percentage compared to 2010. Among them, the proportion of elderly people aged 60,
65 and above in rural areas is 23.81% and 17.72% respectively which are 7.99 and 6.61 percentage higher
than those in urban areas.2 The most severe aging problem in China is in rural areas because of large influx
of many young people from rural areas to cities, resulting in an increasingly high degree of aging in these
areas. While China can be proud of the achievement in making its people’s life longer, it must tackle the
challenge of how to make the leisure life of aging population as an important part of their later year’s life
for both urban and rural people. 1 Yang Xuyan, Gong Na. Study on the Sustainability of Rural Tourism under the Background of Rural Revitalization. E3S Web
of Conferences 251, 02075 (2021) TEES 2021.
2 尹东昊、 宋佳雨#、陈明燕 、黄诗琴 、贾 溢. 乡村振兴视角下休闲方式对农村老年人幸福感的影响研究 ——
基于CGSS 数据的实证分析. 安徽农学通报, 2022，28（10）：13. Introduction With a rising aging population, China is experimenting many ways to
improve the quality of life of elderly people in rural areas. Various policies related to leisure and education
are significant for a healthy rural China and hence it has become a major part of the rural revitalization
strategy of the country. Previous studies on leisure education programmes have focussed less on rural
elderly people, and there have been very few studies based on the background of rural revitalization. In
this backdrop, this paper will investigate aspects of aging and leisure of rural elders and discusses how it
is integrated into the rural revitalization strategy of China. Abstract: Even though China has
rightly identified the problem of rural elder adults’ need for leisure activities, the paper argues that
integrating rural elderly leisure with rural revitalization strategy has opened a new path of development
for rural China. Keywords: rural elders, leisure, health, rural revitalization strategy, China. Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 IJFMR23069300 1 rnational Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR) argue that leisure can significantly improve the subjective well-being of rural elderly people,
and at the same time, an increase in the categories and duration of leisure activities can be helpful in
improving the happiness of rural elderly people.3 Wang Xin (2013) writes that as affluent farmers' income increase, their needs gradually shift from
academic and vocational education to leisure education aimed at improving quality of life and to meet
their spiritual needs.4 Sun Linye (2010) believes that improving the leisure taste of rural residents is an
important guarantee for improving the quality of leisure life and satisfaction.5 Previous research has
identified aging as a problem associated with the decline and loss of physical and psychological health in
later life. The development of the concept of “successful aging” has inspired considerable interest in
“healthy aging”, “active aging” and “productive aging” as strategies to overcome these problems.6 Several
studies have noted that tourism positively affects elders’ subjective well- being and level of social
engagement by enhancing their self- esteem and confidence. In China, an important symbol of the arrival of the leisure era is the increasing number of leisure
policies issued by the country, and leisure education policies are the core of leisure policies. The
Guidelines for National Leisure Education issued in 2014 pointed out that an institutionalized leisure
education exchange mechanism should be established connecting the government, communities, families,
social groups, volunteer groups, educational institutions, and the media.7 In her study on leisure and power
in urban China, Unn Målfrid H. Rolandsen (2011) argues that leisure is a social field where power is
exercised. She finds that the official discourse on leisure has little or no impact on the way people lead
their everyday lives. The case of rural China is no different. The number of policies officially launched
support the fact that state is interested in the leisure of rural people. State intervention in leisure of aging
population in rural areas throws light at the seriousness of concerns like loneliness, mental health, reducing
expenditure on medical costs etc. of aging population. The challenge in the case of rural elders for the
state is how to educate them on the importance of leisure in their later lives. Since majority of rural
population are older adults, the entire society should provide elder adults with diverse forms of healthy
leisure opportunities and implement flexible and diverse leisure education programmes. rnational Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR) E-ISSN: 2582-2160 ● Website: www.ijfmr.com ● Email: editor@ijfmr.com people often feel lonely and lack many social contacts. The outcome of the research pointed to the need
for leisure in increasing or maintaining social integration in the later life. Many public policy debates are
concerned with the physical issues of aging, while social issues such as isolation tend to be ignored. Therefore, efforts are needed to reduce the social isolation which can help in improving the quality of life
of older people thereby reducing the public expenditure on medical costs. A specific strategy to increase
social integration for older people could be facilitating their connections with others via leisure activities. Leisure activities, as a primary aspect of the participation element of active aging, can help in preventing
disease and functional decline, extend longevity and enhance the quality of life in older people. Nie
Jianliang et al. argue that leisure can significantly improve the subjective well-being of rural elderly people,
and at the same time, an increase in the categories and duration of leisure activities can be helpful in
improving the happiness of rural elderly people.3 people often feel lonely and lack many social contacts. The outcome of the research pointed to the need
for leisure in increasing or maintaining social integration in the later life. Many public policy debates are
concerned with the physical issues of aging, while social issues such as isolation tend to be ignored. Therefore, efforts are needed to reduce the social isolation which can help in improving the quality of life
of older people thereby reducing the public expenditure on medical costs. A specific strategy to increase
social integration for older people could be facilitating their connections with others via leisure activities. Leisure activities, as a primary aspect of the participation element of active aging, can help in preventing
disease and functional decline, extend longevity and enhance the quality of life in older people. Nie
Jianliang et al. 3 聂建亮，吴玉锋.劳动幸福还是休闲幸福？——“无休”状态对 农村老人主观幸福感影响的实证分析［J］.江汉
学术，2021，40 （05）：60-71
4 王 昕.农民对继续教育和学习需求的分析与思考〔J〕.中国 职工教育，2013，（10）：64.
5 孙林叶.我国农村居民休闲的现状与对策〔J〕.北京理工大学 学报（社会科学版），2010，（2）：134-137.
6 Sara Marsillas (2017). Does Active Ageing Contribute to Life Satisfaction for Older People? Testing a New Model of Active
Ageing, Eur J. Ageing, 14: 295.
7
《
国
民
休
闲
教
育
导
引
2014》
https://std.samr.gov.cn/gb/search/gbDetailed?id=71F772D7F428D3A7E05397BE0A0AB82A Leisure and Ageing What is leisure? Leisure is the time available to the individual when the disciplines of work, sleep
and other basic needs been met (Rapport& Rapport:1974). Vera Toepoel (2013) studied the relation
between leisure activities and social status of elderly of Dutch population. The study indicated that older 2 Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 IJFMR23069300 2 4 王 昕.农民对继续教育和学习需求的分析与思考〔J〕.中国 职工教育，2013，（10）：64.
5 孙林叶.我国农村居民休闲的现状与对策〔J〕.北京理工大学 学报（社会科学版），2010，（2）：134-137.
6 Sara Marsillas (2017). Does Active Ageing Contribute to Life Satisfaction for Older People? Testing a New Model of Active
Ageing, Eur J. Ageing, 14: 295.
7
《
国
民
休
闲
教
育
导
引
2014》
https://std.samr.gov.cn/gb/search/gbDetailed?id=71F772D7F428D3A7E05397BE0A0AB82A Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 6 Sara Marsillas (2017). Does Active Ageing Contribute to Life Satisfaction for Older People? Testing a New Model of Active
Ageing, Eur J. Ageing, 14: 295.
7
《
国
民
休
闲
教
育
导
引
2014》
https://std.samr.gov.cn/gb/search/gbDetailed?id=71F772D7F428D3A7E05397BE0A0AB82A g
g,
g
g,
7
《
国
民
休
闲
教
育
导
引
2014》
https://std.samr.gov.cn/gb/search/gbDetailed?id=71F772D7F428D3A7E05397BE0A0AB82A 8 中华人民共和国文化和旅游部. “《中国休闲发展年度报告（2021）》认为 我国居民休闲时间较疫情前有所增
加”, https://www.mct.gov.cn/whzx/zsdw/zglyyjy/202110/t20211011_928211.html
9 崔高峰,曹 垚,周妩娜,李际麟. 乡村振兴战略下农村老年人体育锻炼现状研究. 渭南师范学院学报. 2022 年 5 月
第 37 卷 第 5 期: 75.
10 国家体育总局《关于进一步加强新形势下老年人体育工作的意见》2015，
https://www.sport.gov.cn/n315/n20001395/c20049504/content.html
11 中共中央 国务院印发《“ 健康中国2030” 规划纲要》2016， https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2016-
10/25/content_5124174.htm
12 国务院办公厅印发《体育强国建设纲要》2019，https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2019-09/02/content_5426540.htm
13 崔高峰,曹 垚,周妩娜,李际麟. 乡村振兴战略下农村老年人体育锻炼现状研究. 渭南师范学院学报. 2022 年 5
月 第 37 卷 第 5 期: 75. Rural Elders and Sports According to data from the National Bureau of Statistics based on 2012 China Health Statistics
Yearbook, the chronic disease rate among elderly people aged 60 and above in China has reached 43.8%.9
The current status of health and disease prevention for the elderly are urgent issues that China needs to
address. Sports can not only prevent diseases and promote health, but also can be an effective means to
alleviate the psychological pressure of the elderly in an aging society. In 2015, the General Administration
of Sport of the People's Republic of China issued the Opinions on Further Strengthening the Sports Work
for the Elderly in the New Situation which emphasised the positive role of sports in responding to the
aging process and outlined the promotion of comprehensive development of national fitness.10 In 2016,
the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China and the State Council issued the Healthy China
2030 Plan which aimed at national health while paying special attention to addressing health issues of key
populations such as women, children and the elderly.11 In September 2019, the General Office of the State
Council issued the Outline for Building a Strong Sports Country, which again mentioned promoting the
development of sports activities for key groups.12 The outline called for to develop and implement physical
health intervention plans for young people, the elderly, farmers, occupational groups, and people with
disabilities. All these documents affirm the role of sports in the aging population. A study by Cui Gaofeng, Cao Yao et.al (2022) analyses the current situation and obstacles of
elderly people in rural areas of the Wanjiang urban belt participating in physical exercise. From 7 cities,
including Hefei and Wuhu, researchers randomly selected the rural elderly with registered residence who
are over 60 years old from 14 towns and villages for investigation. Research analysis found that 78.33%
of the total survey population participated in physical exercise among elderly people in rural areas were
mainly aged between 60-75.13 The participation rate of women is slightly higher than that of men. The
main way of participation is to engage in physical exercise alone or with family and friends. The main
goals cited were to achieve physical fitness, prevent disease, leisure, and entertainment. The favourite
exercise programs for rural elderly people are brisk walking, jogging, and square dancing. rnational Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR) holidays has increased by varying degrees since 2021, with the largest increase being on weekends
followed by holidays, with leisure time increase of 0.91 hours and 0.64 hours respectively. The average
daily leisure time of rural residents has increased from 3.14 hours to 4.36 hours, an increase of 38.85%.8 Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 rnational Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR) On October 9，
2021, the China Tourism Research Institute released the Annual Report on China's Leisure Development. 2021, the China Tourism Research Institute released the Annual Report on China's Leisure Development. The report says that compared with 2019, urban residents' leisure time on weekdays, weekends, and Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 IJFMR23069300 3 Rural Elderly Care Industry Rural elderly care is a new type of elderly care model that has emerged in China in recent years. Although there are differences in the definitions of rural elderly care among scholars in China, they all
believe that rural elderly care relies on the superior natural environment in rural areas to establish nursing
homes with rural style. In addition to providing basic elderly care services, elderly people can also engage
in simple agricultural activities to get close to nature to meet their spiritual needs. It is an elderly care
model that integrates elderly care, leisure agriculture, medical care, and tourism. The continuous rise in aging population has led to an increase in the demand for elderly care,
making rural elderly care a new form of elderly care method. Rural areas have advantages such as abundant
land resources, beautiful ecological environment, and low living costs, making them suitable for elderly
care industry. Under rural revitalization, it is possible to gradually expand the scope of social security
coordination and to improve rural medical facilities. It can also attract urban elderly people to rural elderly
care, thereby reducing population pressure in big cities which can drive rural economic development and
take the path of urban-rural integration development. Developing the rural elderly care industry in rural
areas has become one of the effective means to achieve rural revitalization in the context of a new elderly
care culture. With the improvement of living standards, people's needs for a better life are increasingly. While
looking forward to basic elderly care services such as having a sense of security for the elderly and having
access to medical care for the elderly being met, leisure, health preservation, and enjoying life after
retirement have become people's expectations and pursuits. Rural elderly care is a supplement to
traditional elderly care methods such as home care and community elderly care. Whether it is long-term
relocation elderly care or a short-term tourism elderly care, it can fully meet the needs of elderly people
for tourism, leisure, and health thereby improving elders’ quality of life, and enrich their retirement life. Developing the leisure and elderly service industries in rural areas is of great significance for
promoting rural development and building a beautiful countryside. Guangxi is a major agricultural
province in China. 14 Ibid
15 曾子峰，刘丹丹. 乡村振兴与大健康产业背景下 广西田园式养老研究. 农村经济与科技 2022 年第 33 卷第 19
期（总第 543 期）:182. International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR)
E-ISSN: 2582-2160 ● Website: www.ijfmr.com ● Email: editor@ijfmr.com
of scientific guidance and venue facilities are the main factors hindering the participation of rural elderly
people in physical exercise. International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR)
E-ISSN: 2582-2160 ● Website: www.ijfmr.com ● Email: editor@ijfmr.com
of scientific guidance and venue facilities are the main factors hindering the participation of rural elderly
people in physical exercise. of scientific guidance and venue facilities are the main factors hindering the participation of rural elderly
people in physical exercise. With the continuous progress of agricultural economic development under the rural revitalization
strategy, the living condition of elderly people in rural areas of the Wanjiang urban belt is constantly
improving, and their awareness of participating in exercise also shows an increase. However, the data also
shows that 21.67% of elderly people do not participate in sports activities, especially those who are lonely
in rural areas who have little awareness and time to participate in physical exercise.14 Elderly people in
rural areas have limited access to online information. They believe that work is just physical exercise. The
common reason for elders to not participate in any sports activities is that they need to take care of their
grandchildren and are busy doing household chores. Rural Elders and Sports The frequency
of exercise is mainly 3-5 times a week, and the exercise time is mostly between 31 and 120 minutes. The
study indicates that the overall level of sports participation among the elderly in Anhui province is
relatively low, with physical exercise being the focus. It further adds that weak awareness of exercise, lack Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 4 IJFMR23069300 International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR)
E-ISSN: 2582-2160 ● Website: www.ijfmr.com ● Email: editor@ijfmr.com
of scientific guidance and venue facilities are the main factors hindering the participation of rural elderly
people in physical exercise. rnational Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR) E-ISSN: 2582-2160 ● Website: www.ijfmr.com ● Email: editor@ijfmr.com urban community day care centres for the elderly, and nearly 10000 community mutual assistance elderly
care facilities such as rural happiness homes.16 From the comparison between the number of elderly
population and the number of elderly care beds, the current supply of elderly care services is still difficult
to meet the large elderly population. With the passage of time, the proportion of the population aged 65
and above is about to reach its peak, and the self-care ability, physical and psychological health, and other
issues of the elderly may become increasingly serious. urban community day care centres for the elderly, and nearly 10000 community mutual assistance elderly
care facilities such as rural happiness homes.16 From the comparison between the number of elderly
population and the number of elderly care beds, the current supply of elderly care services is still difficult
to meet the large elderly population. With the passage of time, the proportion of the population aged 65
and above is about to reach its peak, and the self-care ability, physical and psychological health, and other
issues of the elderly may become increasingly serious. The traditional elderly care service industry pay more attention to the physical health issues of the
elderly population, often neglecting the psychological and spiritual needs of the elderly. Therefore, it is
particularly important to develop an elderly care model that can not only ensure the physiological health
needs of the elderly, but also meet their spiritual needs. Relying on the unique ecological environment
advantages and rich health care resources in Guangxi, an effective integration of tourism and health care
industry is possible to push the efforts of rural revitalization. Guangxi is a province with many ethnic
minorities in China, and different ethnic cultures have blended into a unique culture. It not only has a
series of cultural arts such as folk songs, Guiju, but also many unique ethnic and folk festivals. For example,
Binyang Paolong Festival, Yao King Pan Festival, etc.17 This series of folk culture can bring a special
elderly care experience to the elderly, which not only enriches their elderly care life but also makes it no
longer monotonous. It can satisfy the spiritual pursuits of the elderly, allowing them to feel the unique
cultural charm of the place they live in. rnational Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR) Due to the unique nature of the elderly population, safety is also a necessary element to be
considered for the development of elderly care in rural areas. A sound medical security system, convenient
and accessible medical system, professional medical team, healthy and nutritious food, and sufficient and
reassuring sleep during the travel process are all factors that affect the choices of the elderly population. Efforts should be made to avoid risks due to fire, unhygienic surroundings, and public security risks in
rural elderly accommodations. The beautiful rural countryside, comprehensive elderly care services, and
a warm and caring sense of community belonging provide the elderly with not only the structure and
environment, but also a new way of life. Rural Elderly Care Industry According to the data of the seventh population census of Guangxi, the population of
Guangxi aged 60 and above is 8.36 million, with an aging rate of 16.69%.15 It is expected that by 2030,
the population aged 60 and above in the entire region will reach 9.5 million. At present, there are 1179
elderly care institutions in the entire Guangxi region, with 92000 beds for elderly care. There are over 700 Ibid
15 曾子峰，刘丹丹. 乡村振兴与大健康产业背景下 广西田园式养老研究. 农村经济与科技 2022 年第 33 卷第 19
期（总第 543 期）:182. Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 IJFMR23069300 5 International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR) difficult for any research to make a generalization possible. The idea of a rural community with a shared
future and healthy living is something what China is striving for. References 1. C.Y. Jim & Wendy Y. Chen. Leisure Participation Pattern of Residents in a New Chinese City. Annals
of the Association of American Geographers, October 2009, Vol. 99, No. 4: 657- 673. 1. C.Y. Jim & Wendy Y. Chen. Leisure Participation Pattern of Residents in a New Chinese City. Annals
of the Association of American Geographers, October 2009, Vol. 99, No. 4: 657- 673. f
f
g
p
2. Rhona Rapoport & Robert N. Rapoport. Four Themes in the Sociology of Leisure. The British Journal
of Sociology, June 1974, Vol. 25, No. 2: 215-229. 2. Rhona Rapoport & Robert N. Rapoport. Four Themes in the Sociology of Leisure. The British Journal
of Sociology, June 1974, Vol. 25, No. 2: 215-229. 3. Stebbins A. Robert. The Sociology of Leisure: An Estranged Child of Mainstream Sociology. Int. J
Sociol Leis. 2018, 1: 43-53. 3. Stebbins A. Robert. The Sociology of Leisure: An Estranged Child of Mainstream Sociology. Int. J
Sociol Leis. 2018, 1: 43-53. 4. Toepoel, Vera. Ageing, Leisure and Social Connectedness: How Could Leisure Help Reduce Social
Isolation of Older People? Social Indicators Research, August 2013, Vol. 113, No. 1: 355-372. 4. Toepoel, Vera. Ageing, Leisure and Social Connectedness: How Could Leisure Help Reduce Social
Isolation of Older People? Social Indicators Research, August 2013, Vol. 113, No. 1: 355-372. 5. Su, Baoren. Leisure Life of Elderly Residents in China: A Case Study of Difference between Rural
and Urban Area. Asian Social Science. 2008, Vol. 4, No. 11: 100-106. 5. Su, Baoren. Leisure Life of Elderly Residents in China: A Case Study of Difference between Rural
and Urban Area. Asian Social Science. 2008, Vol. 4, No. 11: 100-106. 6. Qi Liu, Decai Gong, Yuxuan Gong. Index System of Rural Human Settlement in Rural Revitalization
under the Perspective of China. Scientific Reports, 2022, 12: 10586. 6. Qi Liu, Decai Gong, Yuxuan Gong. Index System of Rural Human Settlement in Rural Revitalization
under the Perspective of China. Scientific Reports, 2022, 12: 10586. 7. Jiangling Cao, Dongfu Qian, Fan Yang. Socioeconomic Disparities in Leisure Activities over the Life
Course of the Oldest- Old in China. Australasian Journal on Ageing, 2020, 39: Issue 3: e416- e424. 8. Ningning Chen, Jingfu Chen, Pei- Chunko. Active Aging in the Countryside: Space, Place and the
Performance of Leisure- Work Lifestyles in Contemporary Rural China. Population Space and Place,
2021, 27: e2429. 9. Robert A. Conclusion As China enters an aging society, exploring various leisure models for the elderly population has
become an important matter of concern facing China at present. An analysis of the policy documents
shows that China is attaching great importance to the issue of aging population. For a large population of
rural elders, sports and elderly care model not only meets their leisure and health requirements, but also
conforms to the national strategy of rural revitalization. The integration of rural revitalization and elderly
care through culture and tourism is the new way ahead for the economic development of the countryside. It can revive the traditional villages and bring in more economic advantages to the overall development
of the region. Rural areas with its cultural characteristics for leisure activities can provide a good quality
of life for the elders. It can also open a new space for cultural and social interactions for rural elderly. A
detailed case study of rural elders and their leisure education in a particular village might throw some light
on the challenges faced by the rural elders. However, China with its immense regional variations make it Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 IJFMR23069300 6 References Stebbins: The Sociology of Leisure: an Estranged Child of Mainstream Sociology, Int J
Sociol Leis (2018) 1:43–53. 10. Dumazedier, J. (1967). Towards a sociology of leisure. Trans by S. McClure. New York: Free Press. 11. Dumazedier, J. (1974). Sociology of leisure. Trans by M. A. McKenzie. London: Elsevier Science. 12. Kaplan, M. (1975). Leisure: theory and policy. New York: John Wiley. 13. Kelly, J. R. (1987). Freedom to be: a new sociology of leisure. New York: Macmillan 14. Roberts,
K. (2013). Sociology
of
leisure. Sociopedia. isa,
pp. 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1177/205684601371. 15. Veal, A. J. (2011). The leisure society I: myths and misconceptions. World Leisure Journal, 53, 206–
227. 16. Veal, A. J. (2012). The leisure society II: the era of critique, 1980–2011. World Leisure Journal, 54,
99–140. 17. 曾姣. 基于事系统的乡村老人休闲活动空间设计研究 ——以骆驼湾村为例. 西南科技大学学报：
哲学社会科学版, 2019 年6 月 第36 卷第3 期:98-102. 18. 王 蕾 伍眉函. 乡村休闲养老模式下近郊型乡村规划策略 研究 ——以西安市草店村为例. 乡村
规划编制与实践,2022:33-35. 19. 戴天舒 贾纯琳. 乡村振兴背景下农村旅游养老实践探索 ——以陕西商南石垭子村为例. 环渤
海经济瞭望, 2022: 53-55. 20. 雷 承 琪. 乡村振兴战略下农村异地养老产业发展的思考. 经济研究导刊. 2022 年第 22 期 总第
516 期: 77-79. 20. 雷 承 琪. 乡村振兴战略下农村异地养老产业发展的思考. 经济研究导刊. 2022 年第 22 期 总第
516 期: 77-79. Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 IJFMR23069300 7 International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR)
E-ISSN: 2582-2160 ● Website: www.ijfmr.com ● Email: editor@ijfmr.com
21. 崔高峰,曹 垚,周妩娜,李际麟. 乡村振兴战略下农村老年人体育锻炼现状研究. 渭南师范学院学
报. 2022 年 5 月 第 37 卷 第 5 期: 75-81. 22. 梁 赉，周高华. 乡村振兴与旅居养老融合路径研究. 丽 水 学 院 学 报. 2021 年 5 月第 43 卷第 3
期:33-38. 23. 尹东昊、 宋佳雨#、陈明燕 、黄诗琴 、贾 溢. 乡村振兴视角下休闲方式对农村老年人幸福感
的影响研究 ——基于CGSS 数据的实证分析. 安徽农学通报, 2022，28（10）：13-16. 24. 甘艺冰. 乡村振兴背景下农村休闲养老产业开发研究. 经济·管理·综述. 2023 年 5 月:102-104. 25. 曾子峰，刘丹丹. 乡村振兴与大健康产业背景下 广西田园式养老研究. 农村经济与科技 2022 年
第 33 卷第 19 期（总第 543 期）:181-185. International Journal for Multidisciplinary Research (IJFMR) 25. 曾子峰，刘丹丹. 乡村振兴与大健康产业背景下 广西田园式养老研究. 农村经济与科技 2022 年
第 33 卷第 19 期（总第 543 期）:181-185. Volume 5, Issue 6, November-December 2023 IJFMR23069300 8
|
https://openalex.org/W2136189576
|
https://research.vumc.nl/ws/files/878054/283071.pdf
|
English
| null |
The dimensional structure of the functional abilities in cases of long-term sickness absence
|
BMC public health
| 2,011
|
cc-by
| 10,249
|
Abstract Background: The health problems that working people suffer can affect their functional abilities and,
consequently, can cause a mismatch between those abilities and the demands of the work, leading to sickness
absence. A lasting decrease in functional abilities can lead to long-term sickness absence and work disability, with
negative consequences for both the worker and the larger society. The objective of this study was to identify
common disability characteristics among large groups of long-term sick-listed and disabled employees. Methods: As part of the disability benefit entitlement procedure in the Netherlands, an insurance physician
assesses the functional abilities of the claimant in a standardised form, known as the List of Functional Abilities
(LFA), which consists of six sections containing a total of 106 items. For the purposes of this study, we compiled
data from 50,931 assessments. These data were used in an exploratory factor analyses, and the results were then
used to construct scales. The stability of dimensional structure of the LFA and of the internal consistency of the
scales was studied using data from 80,968 assessments carried out earlier, under a slightly different legislation. Results: Three separate factor analyses carried out on the functional abilities of five sections of the LFA resulted in
14 scale variables, and one extra scale variable was based on the items from the sixth section. The resulting scale
variables showed Cronbach’s Alphas ranging from 0.59 to 0.97, with the exception of one of 0.54. The dimensional
structure of the LFA in the verification population differed in some aspects. The Cronbach’s Alphas of the
verification population ranged from 0.58 to 0.97, again with the exception of the same scale: Alpha = 0.49. Conclusion: The differences between the dimensional structures of the primary data and the earlier data we found
in this study restrict the possibilities to generalise the results. The scales we constructed can be utilised to produce
a compact description of the functional abilities of groups of claimants in the Netherlands. Moreover, the matching
work demands can be used to identify jobs low on those demands as being the most accessible for the specific
type of disabled employees, particularly severely disabled individuals. number of countries, the inflow into disability benefits
even declined [1]. Nevertheless, public expenditures on
disability benefits in 20 OECD member states amounted
to a mean of 2.25% of the Gross Domestic Product
(GDP) in 1999. © 2011 Broersen et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Abstract Surveys conducted by Eurostat also
looked at chronic illness and disability in the European
Union: the 1996 estimate for the prevalence rate for
chronic disease and disability (moderate and severe) in
the working-age population was 14.5% [2,3]. In the
Netherlands, the number of disability benefit recipients
decreased in recent years [4], but more than 850,000
individuals out of a labour force of nearly ten million
received a disability benefit in 2007 [5]. The dimensional structure of the functional
abilities in cases of long-term sickness absence Jake PJ Broersen1,2, Henny PG Mulders1,3, Antonius JM Schellart1,2, Allard J van der Beek1,2* Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Open Access Open Access * Correspondence: a.vanderbeek@vumc.nl
1Research Centre for Insurance Medicine, collaboration between AMC-
UMCG-UWV-VUmc, Amsterdam, the Netherlands
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article Background Long-term sickness absence and work disability stem
from a mismatch of the job demands on the one hand
and the capacities of the employee on the other. The
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Develop-
ment (OECD) studied the extent of the problem of
long-term sickness and work disability in a number of
OECD member states. This problem increased in a
majority of those countries over the period from 1990
through 1999, although the increase in work disability
slowed during the second half of the 1990s, and in a * Correspondence: a.vanderbeek@vumc.nl
1Research Centre for Insurance Medicine, collaboration between AMC-
UMCG-UWV-VUmc, Amsterdam, the Netherlands
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article In the Netherlands, the remaining work capacity of a
long-term sick-listed employee is assessed by matching Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Page 2 of 14 the work demands of various jobs with the functional
abilities of the sick-listed employee. An insurance physi-
cian (IP) assesses those functional abilities, which are
then registered in a standardised format known as the
List of Functional Abilities (LFA), which was partly
based on the International Classification of Functioning,
Disability and Health (ICF [6]). Subsequently, each func-
tional ability is compared separately to the correspond-
ing work demand in various jobs by a labour expert
(LE). However, many of the functional abilities of
employees are not statistically independent, nor are
many of the demands within jobs. To simplify the
description of those various employee and job character-
istics, attempts can be made to summarise these charac-
teristics in a restricted number of dimensions. On the
job side, reducing the demands to a limited number of
dimensions facilitates the clustering of jobs into job
types [7-11]. The number of dimensions identified in
these studies varied from two to nine, leading to four to
15 occupational categories. Schellart et al. [11], for
example, distinguished two main dimensions: mental
demands and physical demands. The study identified
three job types mainly involving varying degrees of phy-
sical demands; two types involving mainly mental
demands; and one type involving mixed types of
demands. various other jobs. Insight into these problems could
enable us to identify obstacles and opportunities for
return to work, and to select potentially suitable job
alternatives for these groups of claimants. Methods In the Netherlands, the assessment of work disability is
facilitated by using a (computer) system, called the
Claim Assessment and Monitoring System, or CAMS
[16]. Part of the system is the List of Functional Abilities
(LFA), which is used to register the assessment of func-
tional abilities by insurance physicians (IPs), to be
matched to the work demands in various jobs by a
labour expert (LE). The LFA consists of 106 items, more
than two thirds of which are dichotomous indicating the
presence or absence of a specific ability. Nearly one-
third of the items are polytomous, with three through
five ordinal scoring categories for the severity of the dis-
ability. The items of the LFA are categorised into six
sections: I personal functioning (30 items), II social
functioning (17 items), III adjusting to the physical
environment (13 items), IV dynamic movements (31
items), V static posture (11 items), and VI working
hours (4 items). The monitoring part of the CAMS
enabled us to study the LFA data of claimants for a dis-
ability benefit in secondary data analyses. In the interest
of protecting claimants’ privacy, the data used in our
study are not openly available for others. In 2004, the European Union of Medicine in Assurance
and Social Security (EUMASS) created a working group
on ICF. This working group proposed a ICF core set for
functional assessment in disability claims in European
social security systems, based on consensus among 20
members of the working group from 11 countries [14]. The ICF core set was intended to represent the common
denominator, to be applied in all assessments and to be
supplemented by other categories according to national
standards and legislation. The proposed ICF core set con-
sists of 20 functional (dis-)abilities. Identification of dimensions within the various func-
tional abilities (or disabilities) of disability benefit clai-
mants could potentially produce valuable insight into the
common disability characteristics of large groups within
the population of claimants, who are all long-term sick-
listed employees. These common disability characteristics
of a group of claimants could be a common cause for the
problems in matching their functional abilities with the
work demands in their former jobs, and most likely in The data used in the primary analysis of this study
originated from LFA records of assessments made from
October 2005 through September 2007. Background These large
groups of claimants with common disability characteris-
tics vary in the extent of their disability. The claimants
with the most severe disabilities face the most significant
hurdles in their return to work [15], and for them it is
most important to identify low-demand jobs. The purpose of the current study was to identify com-
mon disability characteristics of groups of sick-listed
and disabled employees. By determining dimensions
within the LFA, we will facilitate the development of a
concise disability profile, which can be used to monitor
trends in disability claims; to assess the determinants of
dependency on a disability benefit; and to identify pro-
blems in matching the functional abilities of groups of
sick-listed and disabled employees with the work
demands in various jobs. As a result of this last applica-
tion, jobs that are particularly low in specific demands
can be identified, which are most likely to be very acces-
sible jobs for those groups of employees with the corre-
sponding disability (assuming the absence of other
major impediments in those jobs). To achieve this, we
aimed to determine the dimensions within the LFA,
their reliability and the stability of these findings. In Norway, information on the functional abilities of
sick-listed employees was registered using the Norwe-
gian Function Assessment Scale (NFAS) [12,13]. The 39
items of the NFAS were summarized in seven scales,
which reduce the amount of information to four physi-
cal dimensions of functional abilities and three mental
dimensions. These seven scales may aid professionals in
assessing the work capacity of employees. Methods No LFA data
were available for two specific types of claimants: the Page 3 of 14 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 of the above-mentioned choices, 77 items were used in
three factor analyses. The selected items for each analy-
sis are described briefly in the figures 1 (section I and
II), 2 (section III), and 3 (section IV and V). first type of claimant was able to return to work in their
former job, according to the judgement of the IP; the
second type was too seriously disabled, for example bed-
ridden, and a search for suitable jobs was considered
useless. For the exploratory factor analyses, we used the
LFA data of 50,931 claimants. The interrelations between items within sections of the
LFA were analyzed using factor analysis of the SPSS
package, opting for principal components analysis and
oblimin rotation. In choosing the most suitable number
of factors in the analyses on the WIA data, a minimum
value of 1 of the so-called eigenvalues was used as a first
criterion. Further decisions on the number of factors
were based mainly on the plausibility of the resulting fac-
tors. As the items within a factor had more clear com-
mon characteristics, a factor was subjectively regarded as
more plausible and nameable. The results of the factor
analysis were used to construct scales. The items were
assigned to the scales according to the highest coefficient
in the pattern matrix, except under the following condi-
tions: 1) the content shows a closer resemblance to the
items of the alternative scale; 2) the addition of the item
to the alternative scale should not weaken the statistical
quality of this alternative scale, and preferably even
strengthen it. The internal consistency of the scales was
assessed by reliability analysis of the SPSS package. In
many studies, Cronbach’s Alphas of 0.70 or more are
considered to be adequate. Instead of this usual value, we
consider a value of the Cronbach’s Alpha of 0.60 to be
acceptable, because the items of the LFA were originally
not selected to measure a common dimension. Methods If the
items of a list are not meant to measure a limited number
of common dimensions, then the expected correlations
between the items of scales within the list is lower, and
consequently the Cronbach’s Alphas will more rarely
reach a level that is usual for scale construction. For the
factor analyses on the WAO data we chose to use the
same type of analysis as the initial analyses on the WIA
data, with an equal number of factors as in the corre-
sponding analysis on the WIA data. The predecessor to the current social insurance law
WIA was called the WAO. Under the WAO, the func-
tional abilities of claimants were assessed in a compar-
able way, and also registered in LFA data files. LFA data
from assessments were available from July 2003 through
March 2005. No LFA data were available for the same
two types of claimants as described in the previous para-
graph. In this study, the WAO data were used to study
the stability of the dimensional structure of the LFA and
the internal consistency of the scales in an earlier time
period and under slightly different legislation, and in a
different population. The main difference between the
two populations is the time interval from the start of
the sick leave until the assessment by the IP: approxi-
mately one year under WAO and two years under WIA. Under WIA, a prolonged time interval until the assess-
ment may lead to the recovery of some of the relatively
healthy sick-listed employees in the second year. There-
fore, after a two-year sickness absence period, a rela-
tively unhealthy group remains. A difference in the
composition of the population may lead to other inter-
relations between variables, and thus to differences in
dimensional structure and scale characteristics. For the
analysis on the data from the WAO legislation period
we used the data of 80,968 claimants. Claimants with
incomplete data were excluded from both the WIA and
the WAO analyses. To avoid that the differences between sections would
dominate the results, we analysed the sections sepa-
rately, except two combinations of related sections: I +
II and IV + V. Not all items on the LFA were eligible for the study of
the structure within the LFA. In the analyses, 26 items
were precluded, leaving 80 items. Methods Most of the excluded
items of the LFA were excluded for their heterogeneous
meaning, i.e. these items did not refer to a specific
(restriction in) capacity. An example of just such an
excluded item was the final item of section VI regarding
the working time: “There are other restrictions to the
working hours, i.e. . . . “. The IP indicated the presence
or absence of other restrictions (yes/no), and, if so, the
IP had to describe the nature of the restriction (in free
format). Results Table 1 lists a number of characteristics of both the
WIA and the WAO population. The largest differences
between the two populations were observed in the age
groups, with higher percentages in the oldest age groups
of the WIA population. The differences between popula-
tions in gender, education and outcome of the assess-
ment were much smaller. A factor analysis on the items of sections I and II of
the LFA items produced eight factors with eigenvalues
exceeding 1. However, the homogeneity of the content
of the resulting factors was considered unsatisfactory,
and a seven-factor solution produced results with
greater homogeneity of content (figure 1). The reliabil-
ities of the seven scales based on these factors are The preclusion of one item with a heterogeneous
meaning of section VI reduced the number of items of
section VI to three items, and we decided not to use
factor analysis but only reliability analysis to study the
relations between the three remaining items. As a result Broersen et al. Results BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Page 4 of 14 Pattern Matrix reported in the second column of table 2 Short descrip-
whether someone can perform independently in a work
Pattern Matrix
Component
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Work without frequent deadlines
,858
Work without managerial tasks
,704
Work without high action tempo
,676
Predictable working situation
,673
Cope with conflicts
,594
,402
Possibilities to fall back on direct colleagues and superiors
,566
Work without constant interruptions
,545
Work without increased personal risk
,374
Fixed and familiar methods of working
,318
-,303
Does not choose an alternative approach
,796
Does not realize a wrong approach
,766
Does not appeal to colleagues for help
,609
Does not decide about approach
,568
Does not think of alternatives
,509
Does not persist until the goal is reached
,410
No insight into one’s own capacities and disabilities
,317
Reading
,744
Writing
,708
Seeing
,615
Transportation
,449
Speaking
,411
Hearing
Lacking initiative
-,830
Does not set targets
-,789
Does not start in time
-,708
No direct contact with colleagues required
,773
No direct contacts with clients
,646
Teamwork
,623
No direct contacts with patients/people needing help
,605
Expressing personal feelings
,583
Dealing with the emotional problems of other people
,479
Dividing attention
-,744
Focusing attention / concentration
-,742
Memory
-,681
Action tempo
-,475
Pre-structured tasks
-,452
No distractions by others
,318
-,397
Working under intensive coaching
-,334
Does not act in a logical sequence
,591
Does not stop when the goal is achieved
,591
Does not check the proceedings of actions
,563
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method: Oblimin with Kaiser Normalization. KMO: 0.932; MSA > 0.687
Cumulative percentage of variance explained (seven factors): 48.7%
Figure 1 Pattern matrix of the factor analysis on sections I and II of the LFA, using WIA data. Section I includes 26 items related to
personal functioning and section II includes 15 items on social functioning. whether someone can perform independently in a work
situation. ‘Communication’ is the title of the third scale,
but the Cronbach’s Alpha was only 0.54: clearly below
the threshold and not acceptable. The common subject
of the three items of the fourth scale was taking initiative: reported in the second column of table 2. Short descrip-
tions of the items within each scale are listed in figure 1. Results The items of the first scale can be denoted as causes of
work stress, for example, work demands, and stress-
modifying characteristics. The second scale measures Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Page 5 of 14 Table 1 Characteristics of the population of claimants having a List of Functional Abilities in the CAMS computer
system under two successive disability pension legislations
Characteristics of the claimant
Disability pension legislation WIA/time
period 2005-2007 (N = 50,931)
Disability pension legislation WAO/time
period 2003-2005 (N = 80,968)
Sex:
Male
47%
45%
Female
53%
55%
Age group:
< 25 years
2%
5%
25 - 35 years
16%
21%
35 - 45 years
26%
28%
45 - 55 years
32%
31%
>= 55 years
24%
14%
Educational level:
primary education
30%
27%
lower secondary education
33%
31%
medium secondary education
27%
30%
higher or university education
10%
12%
The ultimate result of the assessment, i.e. the
percentage reduction in earning capacity:
< 35% reduction
52%
52%
35% - 80% reduction
19%
19%
> 80% reduction
29%
29% Table 1 Characteristics of the population of claimants having a List of Fu
system under two successive disability pension legislations being able to start and execute a task without guidance. The common subject of the items of scale five was the
interaction with other people as a requirement of the job. Cognitive functioning was the main subject of the sixth
scale. The seventh scale related to an individual’s goal-
orientation. The Cronbach’s Alpha of this scale, 0.59,
nearly equalled the threshold value. Due to the common being able to start and execute a task without guidance. The common subject of the items of scale five was the
interaction with other people as a requirement of the job. Cognitive functioning was the main subject of the sixth
scale. The seventh scale related to an individual’s goal-
orientation. The Cronbach’s Alpha of this scale, 0.59,
nearly equalled the threshold value. Due to the common characteristics of the items within this last scale (the con-
tent), we nevertheless considered the results of this scale
as just acceptable. The Cronbach’s Alphas of the five
scales above the threshold of the first two sections ranged
from 0.73 to 0.86. The analysis on the items of section III produced five
factors (figure 2). Results We therefore decided
not to use the scales of this section, and we did not
repeat this analysis on the WAO data. (which is measured by the second scale of this section). The sixth scale contained two items relating to the use
of the neck, and the last scale was about the movements
of the trunk (in a forced posture). The seven scales
within these two sections had Cronbach’s Alphas ran-
ging from 0.61 to 0.94 (see table 2). Considering the small number of items (three) of sec-
tion VI, we did not use factor analysis for these items. The item ‘maximum number of hours per day’ corre-
lated highly (r = 0.95) with the item ‘maximum number
of hours per week’, but the correlation of each of these
two items with the third item, i.e. ‘day work or (type of)
shift work’, was considerably lower: just over 0.50. Moreover, addition of the third item decreased the
Cronbach’s Alpha of the two-item scale considerable:
from 0.97 to 0.86. Therefore, a two-item solution was
chosen. Within sections IV and V of the LFA, a factor analysis
on the WIA data identified seven factors (figure 3). The
common denominator of the first scale was the use of
the legs. The item ‘frequent bending’ had the highest
coefficient on this scale. However, if one interprets ‘fre-
quent bending’ as using the arms to manipulate some-
thing manually in a low position, for example to pick
something up, then the item fits better in the scale ‘Use
of the arms’. Moreover, the coefficient of this item on
the scale ‘Use of the arms’ was the second highest, and
only slightly less than the highest one. We therefore
decided to assign the item ‘frequent bending’ to the
scale ‘Use of the arms’ (but not in the comparison with
the dimensional structure within the WAO data, see
below and table 3). The items of the second scale of this
factor analysis assessed the ability to get a grip of
objects of various shapes. The subject of the third scale
was the use of the arms. The common denominator of
the fourth scale was the sustained posture of the trunk. Results The fifth factor would consist of only Table 2 The scales of the List of Functional Abilities under two successive disability pension legislations: reliability
(Cronbach’s Alpha) and 95% confidence interval
Scale (number of items)
Disability pension legislation WIA/time period 2005-
2007 (N = 50,931)
Disability pension legislation WAO/time period 2003-
2005 (N = 80,968)
Work stress (9)
0.856 (0.854-0.858)
0.827 (0.826-0.829)
No independence in
performance (7)
0.727 (0.723-0.731)
0.724 (0.721-0.727)
Communication (6)
0.537 (0.530-0.543)
0.491 (0.485-0.496)
Taking initiative (3)
0.749 (0.745-0.753)
0.718 (0.715-0.721)
Social task demands (6)
0.800 (0.797-0.802)
0.766 (0.763-0.768)
Cognitive functioning (7)
0.791 (0.788-0.793)
0.757 (0.754-0.760
Acting efficiently (3)
0.592 (0.586-0.598)
0.635 (0.631-0.640)
Use of the legs (8)
0.924 (0.923-0.925)
0.914 (0.913-0.915)
Grip of the hand (5)
0.937 (0.936-0.937)
0.903 (0.902-0.904)
Use of the arms (7)
0.865 (0.864-0.867)
0.843 (0.842-0.845)
Posture of the trunk/back
(3)
0.720 (0.716-0.725)
0.730 (0.727-0.733)
Use of the hand and
fingers (7)
0.762 (0.759-0.766)
0.683 (0.680-0.687)
Use of the neck (2)
0.691 (0.686-0.697)
0.675 (0.670-0.679)
Movement of the trunk/
back (4)
0.612 (0.606-0.617)
0.583 (0.578-0.588)
Working hours (2)
0.973 (0.972-0.973)
0.968 (0.968-0.969) List of Functional Abilities under two successive disability pension legislations: reliability 2 The scales of the List of Functional Abilities under two successive disability pension legislations Table 2 The scales of the List of Functional Abilities under two successive disability Table 2 The scales of the List of Functional Abilities under two successiv
(Cronbach’s Alpha) and 95% confidence interval (Cronbach’s Alpha) and 95% confidence interval Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Page 6 of 14 Pattern Matrix
Component
1
2
3
4
5
Heat
,679
Draught
,634
Cold
,546
-,469
Increased susceptibility for infections
,530
Weakened skin barrier
,798
Skin contact
,751
Vibrations
-,840
Protective measures
-,625
Allergy
,895
Dust, smoke, gases and fumes
,457
,582
‘Noise nuisance’
,990
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method: Oblimin with Kaiser Normalization. KMO: 0.675; MSA > 0.558
Cumulative percentage of variance explained (five factors): 61.6%
Figure 2 Pattern matrix of the factor analysis on section III of the LFA, using WIA data. Section III includes 11 items related to adjusting
to the physical environment. Pattern Matrix Pattern Matrix one item, ‘noise’, and therefore no scale could be based
on this last factor. The Cronbach’s Alphas of the other
four scales ranged from 0.39 to 0.51, considerably lower
than the threshold value of 0.60. Results The fifth scale related to the use of the hands and the
fingers, with the exception of the grip on various objects The stability of the results of the factor analyses on the
combined sections I and II and the combined sections IV
and V was studied by repeating the analyses for the
WAO population. The pattern matrices of the factor ana-
lyses are presented in the figures 4 and 5, and the results
of the reliability analyses in third column of table 2, in
which the scale ‘Working hours’, based on section VI of
the LFA, was added. The results of the factor analysis on
the sections I and II for the WAO data are presented in
figure 4. Differences between the dimensional structure of Page 7 of 14 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Pattern Matrix Pattern Matrix th
WIA d t
d th
WAO d t
l
t if th
d
b
i
t bl 4
hi h l
l d t diff
Pattern Matrix
Component
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Duration of continuous walking
,882
Total duration of walking
,870
Climbing of stairs
,870
Total duration of standing
,797
Duration of continuous standing
,780
Climbing
,719
Prolonged activities in a kneeling or squatting posture
,685
Kneeling or squatting
,593
-,322
Frequent bending
,370
,331
Handling objects like keys
,914
Handling objects like pens
,905
Handling cylindrical shapes
,888
Handling objects like tweezers
,883
Handling objects like balls
,876
Frequent stretching of the arm
,645
Lifting and carrying
,410
,582
Frequent handling of light objects
,569
Frequent handling of heavy loads
,341
,530
Prolonged activities above the shoulder height
,518
Pushing and pulling
,405
,506
Total duration of sitting
,747
Duration of continuous sitting
,744
Changing posture
,653
Repetitive movements of hands and fingers
,813
Precision movements of hands and fingers
,715
Squeezing and gripping strength
,692
Total duration of working with keyboard and mouse
,334
,575
Twisting movements with hand and arm
,387
,522
Touch
,465
Operate a keyboard and handle a mouse
,459
Head movements
,887
Keeping one’s head in a fixed position for some time
,883
Turning
,644
Bending
,576
Stretching of the arm
,513
Prolonged activities in a bended or turned posture
,450
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method: Oblimin with Kaiser Normalization. Results Movement of the trunk/back (4)
2
2
(a) Section IV of the LFA: 27 items on dynamic movements. (b) Section V of the LFA: 9 items on static postures. (c) Scale WAO: serial number and title:
1. Use of the legs. 2. Grip of the hand. 3. Use of the arms. 4. Bending or fixed posture of the trunk/back. 5. Use of the neck. 6. Use of the hand and fingers. 7. Turning/reaching. (d) The numbers in the table denote the number of items that are allocated to a specific combination of a WIA scale and a WAO scale, for example 8 out of 9
items of the WIA scale ‘Use of the legs’ were placed in scale with the same name on the basis of the WAO analysis. g
g
(d) The numbers in the table denote the number of items that are allocated to a specific combination of a WIA scale and a WAO scale, for example 8 out of 9
items of the WIA scale ‘Use of the legs’ were placed in scale with the same name on the basis of the WAO analysis. the scale ‘Work stress’ from the WIA analysis in the first
row, eight items were placed in the first column/scale from
the WAO analysis (also called ‘Work stress’), and one in
the sixth scale, called ‘No interference during work’. from 69 (including the three items from section VI, and
not counting the 11 items from section III) to 15. The
clustering of the items into scale variables produced no
clear surprises, partly due to the separate factor analyses
within (combined) sections. However, not all of the
results on the WIA data could be replicated on
the WAO data. The results of the factor analyses on the
WAO data showed a different dimensional structure,
and this result limits the possibilities for generalization
of the dimensional structure of the LFA in the WIA
data. Nevertheless, the reliability analyses on the WAO
data, using the 14 WIA scales with an acceptable Cron-
bach’s Alpha, showed that these scales kept acceptable
or nearly acceptable Cronbach’s Alphas. The pattern matrix of the factor analysis on the combined
items of the sections IV and V of the LFA for the WAO
data are presented in figure 5. In table 3, the item alloca-
tions based on the WIA data (rows) and on the WAO data
(columns) are compared. Results KMO: 0.930; MSA > 0.769
Cumulative percentage of variance explained (seven factors): 64.6%
Figure 3 Pattern matrix of the factor analysis on sections IV and V of the LFA, using WIA data. Section IV includes 27 items on dynamic
movements and section V includes 9 items on static postures. occurred, as can be seen in table 4, which also led to differ-
ences in the naming of the scales. The items of one WIA
scale were split up into two WAO scales, and the items of
two WIA scales were joined into one, and one item was
assigned to another scale. For example, of the nine items of the WIA data and the WAO data are relevant if those
would have led to an alternative distribution of the items
over the scales. In table 4, the item allocation based on the
WIA data (rows) was compared to that based on the WAO
data (columns). Three differences in item allocations Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Page 8 of 14 Table 3 The relation between the dimensional structures of the items of the sections IV(a) and V(b) of the LFA within
the population of clients during the WIA legislation (rows) and the WAO legislation (columns)
Scale WAO: serial number of the scale(c) (number of items)
Scale WIA (number of items)
1(8)
2(5)
3(7)
4(6)
5(2)
6(6)
7(2)
1. Use of the legs (9)
8(d)
1
2. Grip of the hand (5)
5
3. Use of the arms (6)
6
4. Posture of the trunk/back (3)
3
5. Use of the hand and fingers (7)
1
6
6. Use of the neck (2)
2
7. Movement of the trunk/back (4)
2
2 Table 3 The relation between the dimensional structures of the items of the sections IV(a) and V(b) of the LFA within
the population of clients during the WIA legislation (rows) and the WAO legislation (columns)
Scale WAO: serial number of the scale(c) (number of items)
Scale WIA (number of items)
1(8)
2(5)
3(7)
4(6)
5(2)
6(6)
7(2)
1. Use of the legs (9)
8(d)
1
2. Grip of the hand (5)
5
3. Use of the arms (6)
6
4. Posture of the trunk/back (3)
3
5. Use of the hand and fingers (7)
1
6
6. Use of the neck (2)
2
7. Results Table 3 shows that four items
switched from one WIA scale to another WAO scale. The third column of table 2 shows the results of relia-
bility analyses on the WAO data, using the scale compo-
sitions based on the WIA data. The Cronbach’s Alpha
of the scale ‘Communication’ was in both populations
clearly below the threshold value of 0.60. The Cron-
bach’s Alpha of the scale ‘Acting efficiently’ rose above
the threshold value in the WAO population, whereas
that of the scale ‘Movement of the trunk/back’ fell just
below the threshold. Because of the small difference,
this last Cronbach’s Alpha was considerd acceptable. Although the results of the factor analyses on the WAO
data showed many similarities to those on the WIA data,
the differences that were found were systematic, given the
sizes of the two data sets. The most plausible cause for
these differences is the one year vs. two year interval
between the start of the sickness spell and the disability
assessment. If these relatively minor difference produced a
number of differences in scale composition, then even
more and greater deviations may be expected if these ana-
lyses were repeated on data sets showing fewer similarities,
for example originating from another country; recorded for
another purpose or in another context; and so on. How-
ever, the scales that were developed on the WIA data can
be used to describe subgroups of WIA claimants in the
Netherlands. A provisional set of scales was used to pro-
duce profiles of subgroups according to diagnosis type [4]. To include a broad variety of relevant disabilities, the Discussion The factor analyses on the WIA data within two groups
of items, each group from two of the six sections of the
LFA, produced 14 factors. Scale scores were based on
these factors, and one extra scale was added, based on
the items from section VI. Subsequent reliability ana-
lyses showed acceptable Cronbach’s Alphas for 14 out
of 15 scales, although the Alpha of one scale was just
below the threshold we defined. The scales represented
nameable concepts, and reduced the number of variables Page 9 of 14 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Pattern Matrix (WAO, 2003-2005) Pattern Matrix (WAO, 2003-2005)
Component
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Work without frequent deadlines
,794
Work without managerial tasks
,634
Work without high action tempo
,615
Predictable working situation
,541
Cope with conflicts
,509
,427
Possibilities to fall back on direct colleagues and superiors
,492
-,370
Work without constant interruptions
,473
Work without increased personal risk
,377
Does not realize a wrong approach
,799
Does not choose an alternative approach
,772
Does not decide about approach
,703
Does not think of alternatives
,609
Does not appeal to colleagues for help
,555
Does not check the proceedings of actions
,530
Does not stop when the goal is achieved
,523
Does not act in a logical sequence
,515
Does not persist until the goal is reached
,397
-,323
No insight into one’s own capacities and disabilities
Reading
,724
Writing
,692
Seeing
,572
Speaking
,434
Transportation
,424
Hearing
Focusing attention / concentration
-,765
Dividing attention
-,732
Memory
-,713
Action tempo
-,322
Lacking initiative
-,782
Does not set targets
-,707
Does not start in time
-,698
Pre-structured tasks
-,636
Working under intensive coaching
-,615
Fixed and familiar methods of working
-,586
No distractions by others
-,384
No direct contact with colleagues required
,712
No direct contacts with clients
,680
No direct contacts with patients/people needing help
,650
Teamwork
,633
Expressing personal feelings
,571
Dealing with the emotional problems of other people
,304
,460
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method: Oblimin with Kaiser Normalization. KMO: 0.928; MSA > 0.643
Cumulative percentage of variance explained (seven factors): 46.7%
Figure 4 Pattern matrix of the factor analysis on sections I and II of the LFA, using WAO data. Figure 4 Pattern matrix of the factor analysis on sections I and II of the LFA, using WAO data. Discussion The LFA is intended to be a compact inventory of the
functional abilities/disabilities of the claimant, as
assessed by the IP. Although the items are classified into
six sections, all separate items should be based on the
assessment of a distinct ability. In other words, the dimensions we found can be used as a starting point for a
work disability assessment instrument, by selecting the
relevant dimensions for the population concerned, and
then selecting items within each of these dimension (not
necessarily items of the LFA). Page 10 of 14 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Pattern Matrix (WAO 2003-2005) bsence or presence of a disability and for about one-
are necessarily mutually partly interdependent mostly
Pattern Matrix (WAO 2003-2005)
Component
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Climbing of stairs
,853
Duration of continuous walking
,849
Total duration of walking
,814
Climbing
,718
Total duration of standing
,718
Duration of continuous standing
,710
Kneeling or squatting
,697
,343
Prolonged activities in a kneeling or squatting posture
,693
Handling objects like keys
,872
Handling objects like pens
,868
Handling objects like tweezers
,840
Handling objects like balls
,837
Handling cylindrical shapes
,829
Frequent stretching of the arm
,756
Frequent handling of light objects
,659
Lifting and carrying
,336
,603
Prolonged activities above the shoulder height
,589
Pushing and pulling
,356
,541
Frequent handling of heavy loads
,541
Twisting movements with hand and arm
,500
,377
Duration of continuous sitting
,813
Total duration of sitting
,797
Changing posture
,605
Bending
,537
,423
Frequent bending
,322
,496
Prolonged activities in a bended or turned posture
,486
Head movements
,864
Keeping one’s head in a fixed position for some time
,857
Repetitive movements of hands and fingers
,795
Precision movements of hands and fingers
,710
Squeezing and gripping strength
,614
Total duration of working with keyboard and mouse
,438
,468
Operate a keyboard and handle a mouse
,399
Touch
,378
Turning
,467
,526
Stretching of the arm
,394
,469
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method: Oblimin with Kaiser Normalization. KMO: 0.916; MSA > 0.759
Cumulative percentage of variance explained (seven factors): 61.1%
Figure 5 Pattern matrix of the factor analysis on sections IV and V of the LFA, using WAO data. Figure 5 Pattern matrix of the factor analysis on sections IV and V of the LFA, using WAO data. Discussion (d) The numbers in the table denote the number of items that are allocated to a specific combination of a WIA scale and a WAO scale, for example 8 out of 9
items of the WIA scale ‘Work stress’ were placed in scale with the same name on the basis of the WAO analysis. (d) The numbers in the table denote the number of items that are allocated to a specific combination of a WIA scale and a WAO scale, for example 8 out of 9
items of the WIA scale ‘Work stress’ were placed in scale with the same name on the basis of the WAO analysis. ‘Grip of the hand’ and ‘Use of hands and fingers’. The
last two physical scales we identified, i.e. ‘Use of the
neck’ and ‘Movement of the trunk/back’, were not
found in the Norwegian study. relations between items will be based on characteristics
of the population of claimants, such as: the prevalence
of a disease with a typical pattern of disabilities; the co-
morbidity of certain diseases; more than one disorder
leading to the same pattern of disabilities; and so on. Because the items of the LFA were not selected to mea-
sure a common dimension, we regarded a Cronbach’s
Alpha of 0.60 as acceptable, which is lower than in
many other studies. From this perspective, the reliabil-
ities of some of the scales we identified in the results
section may be only moderate in comparison with reli-
abilities found in other studies, but can be regarded as
substantial in the present context, with the exception of
the scale ‘communication’. The above-mentioned Norwegian study identified
three mental factors/scales. The last scale, ‘Senses’, was
composed of the items ‘watching television’ and ‘listen-
ing to the radio’. These items show the most resem-
blance to those in the scale ‘Communication’ of the
LFA. The reliability of the scale ‘Senses’ was relatively
low compared to the other scales within the Norwegian
study [12], but considerably higher (0.76) than that of
our scale ‘Communication’. The remaining two scales
do not bear a clear resemblance to any of the scales we
found in the present study. The differences in the num-
ber and the nature of the dimensions can presumably
ascribed in part to the main differences between the stu-
dies in the input of the analysis: professional assessment
registrations vs. self-evaluation questionnaires; 80 vs. Discussion are, necessarily, mutually partly interdependent, mostly
because they place a limit to two aspects of the same
activity, of which the two highly correlated items of the
scale ‘working hours’ form the most extreme example. Apart from these kind of (logical) interdependencies, absence or presence of a disability, and for about one-
third of the items with an indication of the severity of
the disability. The assessment of each disability aspect
should be more or less independent of the assessments
of other disabilities. However, some items of the LFA Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Page 11 of 14 Table 4 The relation between the dimensional structures of the items of the sections I(a) and II(b) of the LFA within the
population of clients during the WIA legislation (rows) and the WAO legislation (columns)
Scale WAO: serial number of the scale(c) (number of items)
Scale WIA (number of items)
1(8)
2(10)
3(6)
4(4)
5(3)
6(4)
7(6)
1. Work stress (9)
8(d)
1
2. No independence in performance (7)
7
3. Communication (6)
6
4. Taking initiative (3)
3
5. Social task demands (6)
6
6. Cognitive functioning (7)
4
3
7. Acting efficiently (3)
3 Table 4 The relation between the dimensional structures of the items of the sections I(a) and II(b) of the LFA within the
population of clients during the WIA legislation (rows) and the WAO legislation (columns)
Scale WAO: serial number of the scale(c) (number of items)
Scale WIA (number of items)
1(8)
2(10)
3(6)
4(4)
5(3)
6(4)
7(6)
1. Work stress (9)
8(d)
1
2. No independence in performance (7)
7
3. Communication (6)
6
4. Taking initiative (3)
3
5. Social task demands (6)
6
6. Cognitive functioning (7)
4
3
7. Acting efficiently (3)
3
(a) Section I of the LFA: 26 items on personal functioning. (b) Section II of the LFA: 15 items on social functioning. (c) Scale WAO: serial number and title:
1. Work stress. 2. No independent execution of tasks. 3. Communication. 4. Cognitive functioning. 5. Taking initiative. 6. No interference during work. 7. Social task demands. Discussion The low-
demand jobs selected for specific groups of disabled
within one country, can be used to identify low-demand
jobs for similar disabled people in other countries. make clear that trying to generalise the dimensional
structure within the functional abilities of work disabled
over countries is not a realistic target at the moment
with the present differences, for example, in legislation,
in measuring instruments, and so on. The identification
of large groups of workers with similar disabilities in dif-
ferent countries seems to be more feasible. Similar dis-
abilities may require similar low-demand jobs to employ
these individuals. Identifying the similarities in the dis-
abilities and, subsequently, in the corresponding low-
demand jobs would make the results of these types of
studies applicable in more than one country. The low-
demand jobs selected for specific groups of disabled
within one country, can be used to identify low-demand
jobs for similar disabled people in other countries. Another disadvantage of the use of existing LFA data
was that we did not monitor the quality of the assess-
ments (and the registration of the assessments). How-
ever, various estimates on the reliability of the LFA and
related data were produced in four other studies we will
discuss below. Spanjer et al. [17] reported the inter-rater reliability of
the items on physical abilities of the LFA in a study of a
new method for the assessment of work disability. In
this study, 62 work disability claimants were interviewed
and examined by two IPs independently. The authors
reported a reasonable to good inter-rater reliability of
the items, for both the newly introduced method and
the usual method of assessment. The latter was also
applied in our study. In an earlier study, Spanjer et al. [18] reported a comparable inter-rater agreement of IPs
on the items on physical abilities of the LFA in simu-
lated assessments of claimants with low back pain or a
lower extremity disorder, based on written interview
reports of assessments in practice. Before that, similar
results were found in a study of Spanjer [19] into the
predecessor of the LFA, the work capacity profile of the
Function Information System (FIS). The items of this
predecessor of the LFA resemble the items of the pre-
sent LFA, and these results are therefore relevant. Discussion The
assessments of the IPs in this last study [19] were based
on video recordings of interviews of other IPs with
claimants. The EUMASS working group for the ICF proposed an
ICF core set for functional assessment in disability
claims of 20 categories [14]. Compared to our set of 15
scales, some categories of the ICF core set are more
general than our dimensions, while other categories are
more detailed, on the level of items of the LFA. For
example, the category ‘Handling stress and other psy-
chological demands’ is more general than the dimen-
sions we found within the sections I and II of the LFA,
and other categories equal almost all items of the scale
‘Communication’ of the LFA. The category ‘Sensation of
pain’ of the ICF core set has no equivalent item in the
LFA, and the subjects in section III of the LFA about
the physical environment are not addressed in the ICF
core set. The differences between the two sets can prob-
ably be ascribed in large part to the differences in goals
of the two studies/development projects. Brouwer et al. [20] studied the applicability of the
items on physical abilities of the LFA in the work-
related functional status assessment of chronic low back
pain patients in a rehabilitation centre. The reliabilities
of the items on physical abilities of the LFA were judged
as generally insufficient for that purpose, as were those
of the aforementioned predecessor, the work capacity
profile of the FIS. Brouwer et al. [20] restricted their
negative conclusions about the LFA to the application
in the rehabilitation domain. Possibly, some patients
present their health problems differently to the physi-
cian, as compared to disability benefit claimants [21,22]. Therefore, their study is less relevant for the quality of
the LFA in disability assessments than the studies of
Spanjer and colleagues. j
The data of our study were collected in regular dis-
ability assessments of IPs as part of the public work dis-
ability
insurance
system
of
employees
in
the
Netherlands. The data for all claimants were registered
in LFA files, with the exception of two types of clai-
mants, the first of which was regarded as hardly dis-
abled, and the other as too severely disabled (see the
method section). The data for all other claimants in the
two intervals of data collection were included. Discussion 39
items; four separate analyses on subgroups of items vs. one analysis on all the items; a sick leave duration of
two years vs. six weeks; and differences in the context/
content of the items. These last differences in context/
content may be related to the observed lack of resem-
blance, particularly in the mental dimensions, although
both lists are partly based on the ICF. In the Norwegian
questionnaire, the emphasis is on limitations in everyday
actions and activities, whereas many of the items of the
LFA relate disability to work situations. This may influ-
ence the subject matter of the items, and the thresholds
for dysfunction/disability. The observed differences The Cronbach’s Alphas of 14 scales (the scale ‘Com-
munication’ excluded) were acceptable (or nearly accep-
table) in the WIA population, and this remained so in
the WAO population. These 14 scales can be applied
for a compact description of the nature of the disabil-
ities of claimants in the WIA population. The number of scales we identified, 15 scales (includ-
ing the scale ‘Communication’), was more than twice
the number of scales Brage and colleagues [12] dis-
cerned in their study of the Norwegian Function Assess-
ment Scale, which totalled 7 scales. The Norwegian
study identified four factors/scales within the physical
domain, three of which show resemblance to scales we
identified: ‘Walking/standing’ (’Use of the legs’); ‘Lifting/
carrying’ (’Use of the arms’); and ‘Sitting’ (’Posture of
the trunk/back’). The Norwegian scale ‘Holding/picking
up things’ seems to combine elements from our scales Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Page 12 of 14 make clear that trying to generalise the dimensional
structure within the functional abilities of work disabled
over countries is not a realistic target at the moment
with the present differences, for example, in legislation,
in measuring instruments, and so on. The identification
of large groups of workers with similar disabilities in dif-
ferent countries seems to be more feasible. Similar dis-
abilities may require similar low-demand jobs to employ
these individuals. Identifying the similarities in the dis-
abilities and, subsequently, in the corresponding low-
demand jobs would make the results of these types of
studies applicable in more than one country. Discussion There-
fore, the population of our study was highly diverse and
substantial in size, and those characteristics were major
strengths of this study. In addition, the earlier-described
context for the data collection was beneficial to the rele-
vance and the quality of the items of the LFA as indica-
tors of the work capacity of the claimants. However, the
LFA was developed and the data were registered for the
purpose of the assessment of work disability, and
although it was based in part on the ICF, the compar-
ability of the LFA items with items of other well-known
instruments was only of minor importance in the devel-
opment of the LFA. This limits the possibilities to gen-
eralise the results to other countries. The characterisation of subgroups of disabled employ-
ees by the scale variables can be used to identify rela-
tively accessible jobs for that group. In other words, jobs
that are low in the corresponding work demands, and
with hardly any other high-level demands and job
requirements that might form an impediment for many
employees to work in those jobs. Subsequently, these
jobs can be used in work rehabilitation and work coun-
selling for disabled employees with a specific type of dis-
ability. In addition, in occupational health and in social
security, professionals can utilise these jobs to illustrate Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Page 13 of 14 Page 13 of 14 Page 13 of 14 Received: 27 April 2010 Accepted: 14 February 2011
Published: 14 February 2011 Received: 27 April 2010 Accepted: 14 February 2011
Published: 14 February 2011 the existence of the residual work capacity of sick-listed
employees in existing regular jobs. Without further
research, our scale variables as such can only be applied
in research in the context of the Dutch social security
system, for example: to study the broad effects of a
rehabilitation programme for disabled employees; to
monitor the functional abilities in the population of clai-
mants; to give a concise description of subgroups of dis-
abled employees; and so on. References 1. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development: Transforming
disability into ability: policies to promote work and income security for
disabled people Transforming disability into ability: policies to promote work
and income security for disabled people Paris: OECD; 2003. 1. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development: Transforming
disability into ability: policies to promote work and income security for
disabled people Transforming disability into ability: policies to promote work
and income security for disabled people Paris: OECD; 2003. 2. Eurostat: Disability and social participation in Europe Luxemburg: Office for
the Official Publications of the European Communities; 2001. 2. Eurostat: Disability and social participation in Europe Luxemburg: Office for
the Official Publications of the European Communities; 2001. 3. Grammenos S: Illness, disability and social inclusion. Dublin, European
Foundation for the Improvement of Working Conditions; 2003, Ref Type:
Report. 3. Grammenos S: Illness, disability and social inclusion. Dublin, European
Foundation for the Improvement of Working Conditions; 2003, Ref Type:
Report. Author details
1 19. Spanjer J: De inter-en intra-beoordelaarsbetrouwbaarheid van WAO-
beoordelingen [The inter- and intra-rater reliability of of work disability
assessments]. TIJDSCHRIFT VOOR BEDRIJFS-EN VERZEKERINGSGENEESKUNDE
2001, 9:234-241. 1Research Centre for Insurance Medicine, collaboration between AMC-
UMCG-UWV-VUmc, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. 2Department of Public and
Occupational Health, EMGO Institute for Health and Care Research, VU
University Medical Centre, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. 3Knowledge Centre
of the Employee Insurance Authority, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. 20. Brouwer S, Dijkstra PU, Gerrits EHJ, Schellekens JMH, Groothoff JW,
Geertzen JHB, et al: Intra-en inter-beoordelaarsbetrouwbaarheid ‘FIS-
Belastbaarheidspatroon’ en ‘Functionele mogelijkhedenlijst’ [Intra- and
inter-rater reliability of the work capacity profile of the FIS and the List
of Functional Abilities]. TIJDSCHRIFT VOOR BEDRIJFS-EN
VERZEKERINGSGENEESKUNDE 2003, 11:360-367. Conclusions Disability & Rehabilitation 2008, 30:1392-1396. 14. Brage S, Donceel P, Falez F: Development of ICF core set for disability
evaluation in social security. Disability & Rehabilitation 2008, 30:1392-1396. 15. Krause N, Dadinger LK, Neuhauser F: Modified Work and Return to Work:
A Review of the Literature. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation 1998,
8:113-139. 16. Landelijk Instituut Sociale Verzekeringen (LISV): Handleiding Claim
Beoordelings-en Borgingssysteem (CBBS) [Manual of the Claim
Assessment and Monitoring System (CAMS)]. Amsterdam, Landelijk
Instituut voor Sociale Verzekeringen; 2001, Ref Type: Report. Conclusions Chi CF, Lin YT: Ratings of 830 jobs on 45 characteristics: factor and
cluster analyses into age-enhanced, age-neutral and age-counteracted,
and age-impaired categories. Percept Mot Skills 1998, 87:803-816. 8. Chi CF: A study on job placement for handicapped workers using job
analysis data. Int J Ind Ergon 1999, 24:337-351. 8. Chi CF: A study on job placement for handicapped workers using job
analysis data. Int J Ind Ergon 1999, 24:337-351. y
g
9. Chi CF, Pan JS, Liu TH, Jang Y: The development of a hierarchical coding
scheme and database of job accommodation for disabled workers. Int J
Ind Ergon 2004, 33:429-447. 9. Chi CF, Pan JS, Liu TH, Jang Y: The development of a hierarchical coding
scheme and database of job accommodation for disabled workers. Int J
Ind Ergon 2004, 33:429-447. 10. de Zwart BC, Broersen JP, van der Beek AJ, Frings-Dresen MH, van Dijk FJ:
Occupational classification according to work demands: an evaluation
study. Int J Occup Med Environ Health 1997, 10:283-295. 10. de Zwart BC, Broersen JP, van der Beek AJ, Frings-Dresen MH, van Dijk FJ:
Occupational classification according to work demands: an evaluation
study. Int J Occup Med Environ Health 1997, 10:283-295. 11. Schellart AJM, van Deynen R, van Koten JW: Beroep en ziekte in de WAO
(II) [Occupation and disease in the WAO]. Tijdschrift voor
Verzekeringsgeneeskunde 1990, 28:6-11. 11. Schellart AJM, van Deynen R, van Koten JW: Beroep en ziekte in de WAO
(II) [Occupation and disease in the WAO]. Tijdschrift voor
Verzekeringsgeneeskunde 1990, 28:6-11. 12. Brage S, Fleten N, Knudsrod OG, Reiso H, Ryen A: Norwegian Functional
Scale–a new instrument in sickness certification and disability
assessments. Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen 2004, 124:2472-2474. 12. Brage S, Fleten N, Knudsrod OG, Reiso H, Ryen A: Norwegian Functional
Scale–a new instrument in sickness certification and disability
assessments. Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen 2004, 124:2472-2474. 13. Osteras N, Brage S, Garratt A, Benth JS, Natvig B, Gulbrandsen P: Functional
ability in a population: normative survey data and reliability for the ICF
based Norwegian Function Assessment Scale. BMC public health 2007, 7:278 13. Osteras N, Brage S, Garratt A, Benth JS, Natvig B, Gulbrandsen P: Functional
ability in a population: normative survey data and reliability for the ICF
based Norwegian Function Assessment Scale. BMC public health 2007, 7:278. g
p
14. Brage S, Donceel P, Falez F: Development of ICF core set for disability
evaluation in social security. CAMS: Claim Assessment and Monitoring System; C.I.: confidence interval;
EUMASS: European Union of Medicine in Assurance and Social Security; FIS:
Function Information System; ICF: International Classification of Functioning,
Disability and Health; IP: insurance physician; LE: labour expert; LFA: List of
Functional Abilities; NFAS: Norwegian Function Assessment Scale; OECD:
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development; WAO: the
former Dutch law on work disability, the predecessor of the WIA; WIA: the
present Dutch law on work disability Authors’ contributions JPJB wrote this manuscript. HPGM, AJMS and AJvdB advised on the
methods used, and commented on the manuscript. All authors have read
and approved the final version of this manuscript. 21. Hadler NM: If you have to prove you are ill, you can’t get better. The
object lesson of fibromalgia. Spine 1996, 21:2397-2400. Abbreviations
CAMS Cl i
A CAMS: Claim Assessment and Monitoring System; C.I.: confidence interval;
EUMASS: European Union of Medicine in Assurance and Social Security; FIS:
Function Information System; ICF: International Classification of Functioning,
Disability and Health; IP: insurance physician; LE: labour expert; LFA: List of
Functional Abilities; NFAS: Norwegian Function Assessment Scale; OECD:
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development; WAO: the
former Dutch law on work disability, the predecessor of the WIA; WIA: the
present Dutch law on work disability 17. Spanjer J, Krol B, Brouwer S, Popping R, Groothoff JW, van der Klink JJL:
Reliability and validity of the Disability Assessment Structured Interview
(DASI): a tool for assessing functional limitations in claimants. J Occup
Rehabil 2010, 20:33-40. 18. Spanjer J, Krol B, Popping R, Groothoff JW, Brouwer S: Disability
assessment interview: the role of detailed information on functioning in
addition to medical history-taking. J Rehabil Med 2009, 41:267-272. Conclusions 4. Kenniscentrum UWV: UWV Kwartaal Verkenning 2007-IV [Fourth Quarterly
Exploratory Report 2007]. Amsterdam, UWV. UKV Kwartaalverkenning;
2008, Ref Type: Generic. 4. Kenniscentrum UWV: UWV Kwartaal Verkenning 2007-IV [Fourth Quarterly
Exploratory Report 2007]. Amsterdam, UWV. UKV Kwartaalverkenning;
2008, Ref Type: Generic. The interrelations between the items of the LFA were
dependent of details of the legislation and/or the com-
position of the population. Thus, the results of this
study cannot be fully generalised to other situations, due
to the differences in legislation, assessment regulations,
instruments, population, and so on. However, the scales
we constructed may be applied to construct a concise
description of the functional abilities of groups of clai-
mants in the Netherlands, for example, classified accord-
ing to age class or diagnosis type. The results of this
study may further be useful for the assessment of the
relevant functional abilities and disabilities of large
groups of long-term sick-listed employees to identify the
impediments to their work resumption in their former
job, as well as in various other jobs. In addition, the cor-
responding work demands can be identified, and jobs
low on those demands can be selected as being most
accessible for the specific type of disabled employees,
particularly severely disabled employees. These low-
demand jobs could be utilised in rehabilitation efforts in
the Netherlands, and, under the assumption of compar-
able subgroups of disabled employees, also in other
countries. 5. CBS [Statistics Netherlands CBS]: Statistics of the year 2007. Voorburg/
Heerlen, CBS [Statistics Netherlands CBS]; 2009, Ref Type: Report. 6. World Health Organization: ICF: international classification of functioning,
disability and health Geneva: World Health Organization; 2001. 5. CBS [Statistics Netherlands CBS]: Statistics of the year 2007. Voorburg/
Heerlen, CBS [Statistics Netherlands CBS]; 2009, Ref Type: Report. 6. World Health Organization: ICF: international classification of functioning,
disability and health Geneva: World Health Organization; 2001. 7. Chi CF, Lin YT: Ratings of 830 jobs on 45 characteristics: factor and
cluster analyses into age-enhanced, age-neutral and age-counteracted,
and age-impaired categories. Percept Mot Skills 1998, 87:803-816. 7. Chi CF, Lin YT: Ratings of 830 jobs on 45 characteristics: factor and
cluster analyses into age-enhanced, age-neutral and age-counteracted,
and age-impaired categories. Percept Mot Skills 1998, 87:803-816. 8. Chi CF: A study on job placement for handicapped workers using job
analysis data. Int J Ind Ergon 1999, 24:337-351. 7. Competing interests
Th
h
d
l
h 22. Sullivan MD, Loeser JD: The diagnosis of disability. Treating and rating
disability in a pain clinic. Arch Intern Med 1992, 152:1829-1835. The authors declare that they have no competing interests. The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Page 14 of 14 Broersen et al. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:99
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99 Pre-publication history
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99/prepub
doi:10.1186/1471-2458-11-99
Cite this article as: Broersen et al.: The dimensional structure of the
functional abilities in cases of long-term sickness absence. BMC Public
Health 2011 11:99. Pre-publication history The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/99/prepub doi:10.1186/1471-2458-11-99
Cite this article as: Broersen et al.: The dimensional structure of the
functional abilities in cases of long-term sickness absence. BMC Public
Health 2011 11:99. Submit your next manuscript to BioMed Central
and take full advantage of:
• Convenient online submission
• Thorough peer review
• No space constraints or color figure charges
• Immediate publication on acceptance
• Inclusion in PubMed, CAS, Scopus and Google Scholar
• Research which is freely available for redistribution
Submit your manuscript at
www.biomedcentral.com/submit
|
https://openalex.org/W2023852236
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc2928747?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
Are Unfamiliar Neighbours Considered to Be Dear-Enemies?
|
PloS one
| 2,010
|
cc-by
| 6,617
|
Abstract This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attributi
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Funding: This study was supported by the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (http://www.cnrs.fr/index.php) - Universite´ Paris Sud (http://www.u-psud. fr/en/index.html). Elodie Briefer was funded by a French Minister of Research and Technology (http://www.enseignementsup-recherche.gouv.fr/) fellowship
during the data collection. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. ¤ Current address: School of Biological and Chemical Sciences, Queen Mary University of London, London, United Kingdom compared to strangers, which could potentially be floaters looking
for a territory. Thus, birds may benefit from recognizing both
categories of neighbours and from showing reduced territorial
aggression towards them. As the probability of hearing songs
produced by a given individual decreases with the emitter-receiver
distance, birds are likely to be unfamiliar with their distant
neighbours’ songs, or a lot less familiar than with their adjacent
neighbours’ songs. An unexplored question is whether territory
owners perceive distant neighbours as strangers because of the
unfamiliarity with their songs, or as neighbours because of their
group membership, signalled by particular shared song compo-
nents. Recognition of familiar song components within unfamiliar
songs has been studied in laboratory conditions (e.g. [5,6]), but has
rarely been explored in the field (but see [7,8]). Here, we
investigated vocal distant neighbour recognition in a songbird with
a large repertoire (average repertoire size per male = 340 syllables
[8]) and a complex song, the skylark Alauda arvensis, in its natural
environment. To study this process, we considered for the first
time the three following related problems: 1) how territory owners
respond to songs of their adjacent neighbours, of their distant Are Unfamiliar Neighbours Considered to Be
Dear-Enemies? Elodie Briefer¤*, Fanny Rybak, Thierry Aubin
CNPS, CNRS-UMR 8195, Universite´ Paris Sud, Orsay, France Elodie Briefer¤*, Fanny Rybak, Thierry Aubin
CNPS, CNRS-UMR 8195, Universite´ Paris Sud, Orsay, France CNPS, CNRS-UMR 8195, Universite´ Paris Sud, Orsay, France PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Abstract Background: Discriminating threatening individuals from non-threatening ones allow territory owners to modulate their
territorial responses according to the threat posed by each intruder. This ability reduces costs associated with territorial
defence. Reduced aggression towards familiar adjacent neighbours, termed the dear-enemy effect, has been shown in
numerous species. An important question that has never been investigated is whether territory owners perceive distant
neighbours established in the same group as strangers because of their unfamiliarity, or as dear-enemies because of their
group membership. Methodology/Principal Findings: To investigate this question, we played back to male skylarks (Alauda arvensis) songs of
adjacent neighbours, distant neighbours established a few territories away in the same microdialect area and strangers. Additionally, we carried out a propagation experiment to investigate how far skylark songs are propagated in their natural
habitat and we estimated repertoire similarity between adjacent neighbours, distant neighbours and strangers. We show
that skylarks, in the field, respond less aggressively to songs of their distant and likely unfamiliar neighbours, as shown by
the propagation experiment, compared to stranger songs. The song analysis revealed that individuals share a high amount
of syllables and sequences with both their adjacent and distant neighbours, but only few syllables and no sequences with
strangers. Conclusions: The observed reduction of aggression between distant neighbours thus probably results from their familiarity
with the vocal group signature shared by all members of the neighbourhood. Therefore, in skylarks, dear-enemy-like
relationships can be established between unfamiliar individuals who share a common acoustic code. Citation: Briefer E, Rybak F, Aubin T (2010) Are Unfamiliar Neighbours Considered to Be Dear-Enemies? PLoS ONE 5(8): e12428. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428 Citation: Briefer E, Rybak F, Aubin T (2010) Are Unfamiliar Neighbours Considered to Be Dear-Enemies? PLoS ONE 5(8): e12428. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428
Editor: Frederick R. Adler, University of Utah, United States of America
Received April 22, 2010; Accepted July 31, 2010; Published August 26, 2010 Citation: Briefer E, Rybak F, Aubin T (2010) Are Unfamiliar Neighbours Considered to Be Dear-Enemies? PLoS ONE 5(8): e12428. doi:10. Editor: Frederick R. Adler, University of Utah, United States of America Received April 22, 2010; Accepted July 31, 2010; Published August 26, 2010 efer et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
tion, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Copyright: 2010 Briefer et al. August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 Study area, subjects and song recordings y
j
g
g
We carried out our study during the 2008 breeding season, from
March to May, in the fields surrounding the University of Paris
South, France. Subjects were 17 males established in 2 groups of
respectively 16 and 19 neighbours, separated by 5.8 km. Within a
group, individuals were established in adjoining and stable
territories of circa 1 ha. We estimated territory boundaries after
careful observations of the birds’ movements at different times of
day and recorded GPS coordinates at the centre of each territory. Distances between two GPS coordinates where then calculated in
metres with a calculator using a spherical earth assumption. We
recorded several songs per individual between 0900 and 1200 hours
Eastern Daylight Time using a Marantz PMD 690 numeric
recorder (sampling rate: 48 kHz) connected to a Sennheiser ME 64
K6 omnidirectional microphone (frequency response: 30 Hz to
20 kHz 61 dB) mounted on a Telinga Universal parabola
(diameter: 50 cm). We then transferred song files to a computer
and high-pass filtered (cut-off frequency: 1600 Hz) to remove
background noise. We used Avisoft SASLab pro v.4.31 software
[12], Goldwave v.5.11 [13] and Seewave [14] for the preparation of
songs played back and for subsequent analyses. We tested two alternative hypotheses by playing back songs of
adjacent
neighbours,
distant
neighbours
established
a
few
territories away in the same microdialect area and strangers: (1) A male’s response to a given song depends on its familiarity
with the singer. In this case, responses to a song will increase
with the distance to the bird singing this song. We thus predict
lowest responses to adjacent neighbour songs, intermediate
responses to distant neighbour songs and high responses to
stranger songs. (2) A male’s response to a given song depends on the presence in
this song of familiar song components shared by members of
the neighbourhood. In this case, responses to a neighbour
song will not be related to the distance to the bird singing this
song. We expect similar responses to adjacent and distant
neighbour songs, regardless of the distance to these neigh-
bours, and higher responses to stranger songs. Figure 1. Sequence shared by members of the neighbourhood (microdialect). Distant Neighbour Recognition neighbours and of strangers; 2) how far skylark songs are
propagated in their natural habitat and 3) what is the degree of
repertoire sharing between individuals. Additionally, we carried out a propagation experiment to
investigate how far skylark songs are propagated in an open
landscape corresponding to skylark habitat. This allowed us to
characterize the vocal active space of each individual in a group. We also analysed repertoire similarity between adjacent neigh-
bours, distant neighbours and strangers to characterize the
spreading of vocal sharing within a neighbourhood. During the breeding season, skylark pairs settle in territories
gathered in distinct groups of neighbours spaced by few kilometres
because of habitat heterogeneity. Within a neighbourhood, males
defend stable and adjacent territories with conspicuous territorial
behaviour [9]. Their long and continuous song is an obvious
element of this behaviour. In this song, particular sequences of
syllables are shared by all males of a group (microdialect [8,10],
Fig. 1). When boundaries between territories are stable, adjacent
neighbours establish dear-enemy relationships, reacting weakly to
each other’s songs played from the shared territory boundary and
aggressively to songs of strangers from other groups [8,11]. Introduction The ability to discriminate potential territory and/or mate
usurpers
from
non-threatening
individuals
enables
territory
owners to modulate their territorial responses according to the
threat posed by each intruder. In songbirds, males commonly hold
adjacent territories forming neighbourhoods, within which they
share whole songs or song components (microdialects, reviewed in
[1]). A weak territorial reaction towards adjacent familiar
individuals compared to unfamiliar individuals (‘‘strangers’’,
‘‘dear-enemy’’ effect [2]), has been observed in numerous
songbirds (review [3]). Social relationships between males are
likely to go beyond neighbours with whom territory boundaries
are shared [4], but territorial reactions towards less familiar
neighbours
established
some
territories
away
in
the
same
neighbourhood (hereafter ‘‘distant neighbours’’) have never been
investigated. Theoretically, within a neighbourhood, distant and adjacent
neighbours, which are already in possession of a suitable territory,
present a similarly low level of threat for territory owners PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 1 Distant Neighbour Recognition Playback Experiment y
(a) Signals tested. We tested each subject with three song
treatments: an adjacent Neighbour (aN) song, i.e. a song produced
by one of its adjacent neighbours (distance between the centre of
the territory of a subject and its adjacent neighbour: mean 6 SE
= 129.56613.14 m, n = 17); a distant Neighbour (dN) song, i.e. a
song produced by a neighbour established 2 to 3 territories, i. e. 230 to 570 m away, on the same side as the adjacent neighbour’s
territory (distance between the centre of the territory of a subject
and its distant neighbour: mean 6 SE
= 353.53626.56 m,
n = 17); and a Stranger (S) song, i.e. a song produced by a
territory owner established in a distant group (mean 6 SE distance
between the group tested and the group of the stranger:
7.2360.49 km, n = 7, Fig. 2). To avoid pseudo-replication [15],
we prepared a different aN and dN song for each subject, and five
different S songs for each group (10 S songs in total, recorded in 7
different groups), so that each S song was played back to a mean 6
SE of 1.5060.17 individuals. We adjusted all song stimuli to the
same duration by taking the first 90 s of continuous song. We
rescaled each song to match the root mean square (RMS)
amplitude of the other stimuli. (c) Responses measured and statistical analyses. For
each trial, we scored the response of the bird during 180 s,
corresponding to the broadcast of 90 s of continuous song and 90 s
of post-playback observation. We recorded 4 measures of response
to assess the effect of the different song treatments (Table 1). Composite response measures were derived from a principal
components analysis (PCA, correlation matrix) of the 4 original
response measures, which are likely to be correlated [15]. We
retained the first two principal components of the PCA (PC1 and
PC2), which had eigenvalues greater than 1 (Kaiser’s criterion),
and tested and confirmed their scores for normality (Kolmogorov-
Smirnov test). We compared PC1 scores corresponding to the
different song treatments (aN, dN and S songs) using a factorial
ANOVA with group membership, song treatment, treatment
order (1–3) and the interaction between song treatment and
treatment order as fixed factors, and individual identity as a
random factor to control for repeated measurements. Playback Experiment We used
two-tailed Tukey honest significant difference (HDS) tests for two-
by-two comparisons. The same comparisons were made with PC2
scores. Then, to investigate the effect of the distance between the
territories of tested subjects and the territories of neighbours whose
songs were used as a stimulus on PC1 scores, we used a Linear
Mixed Model (LMM) fitted with Restricted Estimate Maximum
Likelihood (RELM, lme function in R v.2.9.0 [16]). In this model,
song treatment (aN and dN) was fitted as a random term to control
for treatment effects. Residuals were inspected to ensure normality
of error. (b) Playback procedure. We played back songs with a
Marantz-PMD 690 digital recorder connected via a 20 m cable to
a 10 W Megavox-6000 loudspeaker (frequency response: 400 Hz
to 10 kHz 63 dB), at the intensity estimated to be normal for the
birds (mean 6 SE: 90.860.8 dBSPL measured at 1 m from the
loudspeaker with a Bru¨el & Kjaer 2235 sound level meter, linear
setting). We positioned the loudspeaker on the ground at
approximately 5 m from the boundary within the subject’s
territory, on the side shared with the adjacent neighbour whose
song was used as a stimulus. The experimenter stood at 20 m from
the loudspeaker. The 3 song treatments (aN, dN and S songs) were
broadcast randomly on the same day to each subject, separated by
at least 5 min delay. This time interval allowed the birds to return Study area, subjects and song recordings Spectrograms (FFT length, 256; frame, 100%; Hanning
window) of song parts produced by an individual (ind a), his adjacent neighbour (ind b) and his distant neighbour (ind c) whose songs had been
broadcast during the playback experiment, all including the same shared sequence (*). Syllables composing the shared sequence are labelled with
numbers 1 to 7, and the other syllables with numbers 8 to 18. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.g001 Figure 1. Sequence shared by members of the neighbourhood (microdialect). Spectrograms (FFT length, 256; frame, 100%; Hanning
window) of song parts produced by an individual (ind a), his adjacent neighbour (ind b) and his distant neighbour (ind c) whose songs had been
broadcast during the playback experiment, all including the same shared sequence (*). Syllables composing the shared sequence are labelled with
numbers 1 to 7, and the other syllables with numbers 8 to 18. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.g001 August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 2 Distant Neighbour Recognition to a normal activity. We initiated the playback when the subject
was standing on the ground inside its territory at more than 10 m
from the loudspeaker. to a normal activity. We initiated the playback when the subject
was standing on the ground inside its territory at more than 10 m
from the loudspeaker. Song analysis We selected seven individuals tested during the playback
experiments and whose songs had been recorded for the song
analysis. The repertoires of syllables and sequences of 3 to 10
syllables of each individual and the repertoires of the adjacent
neighbours, distant neighbours and strangers whose songs had
been broadcast during the playback experiment were analyzed as
described in Briefer et al. [10], by selecting 100 s of a continuous
good signal to noise ratio song, labelling syllables on a spectrogram
(FFT-Length: 1024; Frame: 100%; Bandwidth: 61 Hz; Resolution:
46 Hz,
Hamming
window)
and
examining
the
sequential
organization of syllables using a custom Matlab program (The
MathWorks, Natick, MA, USA; see [19]). Sharing of syllables and
of sequences of each individual with its corresponding adjacent
neighbour, distant neighbour and stranger were then estimated by
calculating coefficients of repertoire similarity (RS) as follows:
RS = Z/((X+Y) 2Z), with X and Y being the total number of
syllables or sequences produced by males x and y, and Z being the
number of syllables or sequences shared by males x and y [20]. RS
values range from 0 to 1, with 1 being maximum sharing. Conventional parametric and non-parametric tests are not suitable
for analyses in which each individual is included several times in
the different pair-wise comparisons [21,22]. Thus, we compared ,
The second principal component (PC2) explained 27.7% of the
variance in the responses measured. The latency to move was
more strongly correlated with PC2 than other measures (Table 1). We found no significant effect of song treatment on PC2 scores
(Factorial ANOVA: F2,29 = 1.00, p = 0.38). Playback experiment y
The first principal component (PC1) explained 56.3% of the
variance in the responses measured. The duration of movements
around the loudspeaker, the time spent around the loudspeaker
and the total duration of movements were strongly correlated with
PC1 (Table 1). Higher positive PC1 scores corresponded to
stronger responses, i.e. subjects spent more time in movement in
the immediate vicinity of the loudspeaker and responded faster. A
comparison between PC1 scores showed that responses were
significantly different depending on the song treatment (Factorial
ANOVA: F2,29 = 8.57, p = 0.001). There was no significant effect
of treatment order and of group membership (Factorial ANOVA:
order, F1,29 = 0.51, p = 0.48; group, F1,13 = 0.001, p = 0.98) and no
significant interaction effect between treatment order and song
treatment
on
PC1
scores
(Factorial
ANOVA:
F2,29 = 0.09,
p = 0.91). Subjects responded significantly more to S songs than
to both aN and dN songs (Tukey HSD test: S and aN, n = 17,
p = 0.0009; S and dN, n = 17, p = 0.031; Fig. 3). On the other side,
responses to aN and dN songs were not significantly different
(Tukey HSD test: n = 17, p = 0.36; Fig. 3). The LMM showed that
these responses were not affected by the distance between
territories of tested subjects and of their neighbours whose songs
were used as a stimulus (LMM: F1,31 = 0.54, p = 0.47; Fig. 3). Propagation experiment doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.t001 Statistics and response measures Eigenvalues, variances explained and contributions of the response measures to the first (PC1) and second (PC2) principal components for playbacks of S, aN and dN
songs. The total variance explained by PC1 and PC2 was 84.0%. Measures that contributed most to the particular compound variables are in bold. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.t001 duration using a 10 W Megavox Pro mega-6000 loudspeaker
placed on a tripod at a height of 2 m from the ground and
connected to a Marantz PMD 690 digital recorder, at the intensity
estimated to be normal for the birds (same intensity as for
playbacks). The song was re-recorded at 0.1 m high and 2 m high
using a Marantz PMD 690 numeric recorder connected to a
Beyerdynamic M69 microphone (frequency response: 50 Hz a`
16 kHz 61 dB) over seven distances (control signal: 1.56 m;
propagated signals: 12.5, 25, 50, 100 m (extreme diameter of a
territory), 200 m and 400 m). We analyzed the re-recorded sounds
by comparing the propagated signals with the control. Re-
recorded signals were digitally filtered (pass-band: 1.6 Hz–7 Hz). We measured signal envelopes to assess modifications of main
amplitude fluctuations, signal spectrums to assess modifications of
frequency composition, and signal spectrograms to assess modi-
fications of frequency modulation. Each of these measures were
averaged (n = 5 exemplars) for each propagation distances. Mean
envelopes and mean spectrums of control signals were correlated
(r-values) with those of propagated signals using Bravais-Pearson
product-moment. Mean spectrograms were compared using the
digital spectrographic cross-correlation method [17] with Avisoft-
Correlator v.2.0 [18]. At distances greater than 200 m, we were
unable to carry out correlations, the songs being indistinguishable
from background noise. RS values calculated between males tested during the playback
experiment and their adjacent neighbours, distant neighbours
and strangers with two-tailed exact paired permutation tests using
the Monte Carlo method. Additionally, we used a permuted
correlation test (1000 permutations) for vectors of numeric values
containing distances or similarities to test the correlation between
RS values calculated between pairs of neighbours (adjacent and
distant) and geographical distances between their territories
(equivalent of a Mantel test [23]; see also [21]). Statistical analyses were carried out using R v.2.9.0 [16]. Results
attained significance when p,0.05. All means are given with SEs. Propagation experiment We broadcast, in an open landscape corresponding to skylarks’
habitat, five exemplars of a selected song sequence of 19.7 s Figure 2. Playback experiment design. Schematic overview of the territories of a tested subject (*) and the adjacent Neighbour (aN, square), the
distant Neighbour (dN, circle) and the Stranger (triangle) whose songs were played at the subject’s territory boundary (X). Distances between the
subject’s territory and the territories of the adjacent and distant Neighbours, and between the subject’s neighbourhood and the Stranger’s
neighbourhood are indicated (mean 6 SE). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.g002 Figure 2. Playback experiment design. Schematic overview of the territories of a tested subject (*) and the adjacent Neighbour (aN, square), the
distant Neighbour (dN, circle) and the Stranger (triangle) whose songs were played at the subject’s territory boundary (X). Distances between the
subject’s territory and the territories of the adjacent and distant Neighbours, and between the subject’s neighbourhood and the Stranger’s
neighbourhood are indicated (mean 6 SE). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.g002 August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 3 Distant Neighbour Recognition Table 1. Factor loadings of the response measures on the first two principal components. Statistics and response measures
PC1
PC2
Eigenvalue
1.50
1.05
Percent of variance
56.3
27.7
Duration of movements at less than 10 m from the loudspeaker
0.966
20.184
Time spent at less than 10 m from the loudspeaker
0.793
0.346
Total duration of movements
0.771
20.469
Latency to move
20.308
20.857
Eigenvalues, variances explained and contributions of the response measures to the first (PC1) and second (PC2) principal components for playbacks of S, aN and dN
songs. The total variance explained by PC1 and PC2 was 84.0%. Measures that contributed most to the particular compound variables are in bold. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.t001 Statistics and response measures
PC1
PC2
Eigenvalue
1.50
1.05
Percent of variance
56.3
27.7
Duration of movements at less than 10 m from the loudspeaker
0.966
20.184
Time spent at less than 10 m from the loudspeaker
0.793
0.346
Total duration of movements
0.771
20.469
Latency to move
20.308
20.857
Eigenvalues, variances explained and contributions of the response measures to the first (PC1) and second (PC2) principal components for playbacks of S, aN and dN
songs. The total variance explained by PC1 and PC2 was 84.0%. Measures that contributed most to the particular compound variables are in bold. August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 Song analysis RS values calculated between males tested during the playback
experiments and their adjacent and distant neighbours were
similar (Exact paired permutation test using Monte Carlo method,
n = 7 RS values between adjacent neighbours and 7 RS values
between
distant
neighbours:
Syllables,
p = 1.00;
Sequences,
p = 0.64, Fig. 4). Furthermore, RS values calculated between
neighbours (adjacent or distant) were not significantly correlated
with the distance between their territories (Permuted Pearson
correlation test, n = 14 RS values between neighbours: Syllables,
r = 20.25, p = 0.19; Sequences, r = 20.31, p = 0.12). RS values
calculated between tested males and both their adjacent and Propagation experiment The propagation experiment showed that the correlation
between the propagated song sequence (envelope, spectrum and
spectrogram) and the control one decreased with the propagation
distance (Table 2), with weak correlations from 100 m, especially PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 4 Distant Neighbour Recognition Figure 3. Playback responses. Individual PC1 scores (n = 17) for playbacks of adjacent Neighbour songs (aN, squares), distant Neighbour songs
(dN, circles) and Stranger songs (S, triangles) plotted against the distance between the subject’s territory and the territory of the individual whose
song was used as a stimulus. Lines show repeated measures of the same individual between song treatments. Higher positive PC1 scores correspond
to stronger responses. Responses to S songs are significantly stronger than responses to both aN and dN songs (Tukey HSD test, * p,0.05, ***
p,0.001). Responses to aN and to dN songs are not significantly different and are not affected by the distance between territories. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.g003 Figure 3. Playback responses. Individual PC1 scores (n = 17) for playbacks of adjacent Neighbour songs (aN, squares), distant Neighbour songs
(dN, circles) and Stranger songs (S, triangles) plotted against the distance between the subject’s territory and the territory of the individual whose
song was used as a stimulus. Lines show repeated measures of the same individual between song treatments. Higher positive PC1 scores correspond
to stronger responses. Responses to S songs are significantly stronger than responses to both aN and dN songs (Tukey HSD test, * p,0.05, ***
p,0.001). Responses to aN and to dN songs are not significantly different and are not affected by the distance between territories. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.g003 for the envelope (amplitude modulations) and the spectrogram
(frequency modulations). distant neighbours were significantly higher than RS values
calculated between tested males and strangers (Exact paired
permutation test using Monte Carlo method, n = 7 RS values
between adjacent neighbours, 7 RS values between distant
neighbours and 7 RS values between strangers: p,0.001 for each
comparison (syllables and sequences, adjacent neighbours versus
strangers and distant neighbours versus strangers), Fig. 4). Therefore, adjacent and distant neighbours share a similar amount
of syllables and sequences in their songs. In contrast, individuals
share only few syllables and no sequences with strangers. Discussion Indeed, in such large repertoire species, (1) or (2) would
probably require considerable time and neuronal resources to
sample and remember the entire repertoire of neighbours (e.g. 6 h
to sample most of the syllable repertoire of a given male in tropical
mockingbirds [34]). In a previous study on individual recognition
[35], we did not find any evidence for voice characteristics in
skylarks, i.e. the within-individual variation of song frequency and
temporal parameters measured was greater than the between-
individual variation. However, we found individually distinctive
syllables and sequences of syllables that males could potentially use
to individually identify their close neighbours. Skylarks seem thus
to rely on the composition of the syllable and sequence repertoires
rather than on other acoustic cues to differentiate group members
from strangers and to individually recognize their adjacent
neighbours. Figure 4. Syllable and sequence sharing. Mean 6 SE (n = 7 pairs
for each category) syllable repertoire sharing (A graph) and sequence of
3 to 10 syllables repertoire sharing (B graph) between adjacent
neighbours (squares), distant neighbours (circles) and strangers
(triangles). Adjacent and distant neighbours share a similar amount of
syllables and sequences in their songs and more syllables and
sequences than strangers (Exact paired permutation test using the
Monte Carlo method, *** p,0.001). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.g004 We cannot rule out that males may perform excursions outside
their territories to occasionally approach their distant neighbours
so that they would be sufficiently close to experience their songs. However, this is unlikely because, during the breeding season,
males remain within their territory to breed and forage at short
distances from their nest [24]. We thus believe that a male’s
response to a given song most probably depends on his familiarity
with particular song components in this song that are shared by all
group members. Indeed, in the present study, we showed that
male skylarks share a similar amount of song components (syllables
and sequences of syllables) with their adjacent neighbours and with
distant ones. Furthermore, within a group, repertoire sharing is
not correlated with the distance between territories (see also [10]). In a previous study, we showed that sequences of syllable shared
by males of a given group constitute a group signature used by
birds for neighbour-stranger discrimination [8]. Discussion We investigated responses of territory owners to songs of their
neighbours settled a few territories away in the skylark, a species
showing dear-enemy relationships between adjacent neighbours. Our first hypothesis was that a male’s response to a given song
depends on his familiarity with the singer, in which case his
response to a song would increase with the distance to the bird
singing this song. The alternative hypothesis was that a male’s
response to a given song depends on the presence in this song of
familiar song components shared by members of the neighbour-
hood. In this case, we predicted that his response to a neighbour
song would not be related to the distance to the territory of the
bird singing this song, inducing a similar response to adjacent and
distant neighbour songs. Our results show that males respond less
aggressively to adjacent and distant neighbours than to strangers. Responses to adjacent and distant neighbour songs were not
significantly different and not related to the distance to the
territory of the neighbour, thus lending support to our second
hypothesis. This indicates that skylark males are tolerant towards
every group member, even distant ones whose songs are unlikely
to be decoded or even detected as revealed by our propagation
results. Because of these dear-enemy-like relationships, members
of a group benefit from a reduction in energy and in time spent
deterring non-threatening individuals [2]. Table 2. Propagation results. Distance (m)
Microphone
Height (m)
12.5
25
50
100
200
Envelope
0.1
0.82
0.61
0.56
0.58
0.48
2.0
0.61
0.67
0.58
0.41
0.40
Spectrum
0.1
0.88
0.89
0.76
0.69
0.67
2.0
0.90
0.89
0.86
0.75
0.64
Spectrogram
0.1
0.89
0.92
0.79
0.49
0.29
2.0
0.89
0.80
0.86
0.60
0.57
Correlations (r-values, Bravais-Pearson product-moment) between control and
propagated envelopes, spectra and spectrograms (digital spectrographic cross-
correlation method). Re-recording height and propagation distances are
indicated. All the correlations are significant at p,0.001. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.t002 Table 2. Propagation results. Table 2. Propagation results. August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org 5 Distant Neighbour Recognition Figure 4. Syllable and sequence sharing. Mean 6 SE (n = 7 pairs
for each category) syllable repertoire sharing (A graph) and sequence of
3 to 10 syllables repertoire sharing (B graph) between adjacent
neighbours (squares), distant neighbours (circles) and strangers
(triangles). Discussion Adjacent and distant neighbours share a similar amount of
syllables and sequences in their songs and more syllables and
sequences than strangers (Exact paired permutation test using the
Monte Carlo method, *** p,0.001). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012428.g004 familiar with a common code display dear-enemy-like relation-
ships. These relationships are not established through experience
with the singer as common dear-enemy relationships between
adjacent neighbours [2], but through experience with the local
microdialect. Relying on sequence sharing to extend dear-enemies-like
relationships to non-adjacent territory owners has not been
observed in other bird species, where males usually react strongly
to non-adjacent neighbours sharing the same dialect (e.g. song
sparrow Melospiza melodia [7], ortolan bunting Emberiza hortulana
[25]). This process could arise in our studied species because,
contrary to a vast majority of songbirds living in more continuous
habitats, skylark populations have a particularly fragmented
distribution, mainly due to human activities, leading to distinct
small patches of acoustic variability [10]. A different relationship
between distant neighbours may be found in populations of
skylarks living in continuous habitats not subjected to high
anthropization, where both syllable and sequence sharing are
lower between neighbours and decrease with the distance between
birds without distinct microdialects [10]. Further studies would be
needed in other bird species showing similar group signatures as
skylarks (e.g. [26–29]) to investigate if the group recognition
process identified in our study is widespread in other songbird
populations living in fragmented habitats. To distinguish among neighbours and strangers or among
different neighbours, several cues have been suggested to be used
by songbirds [3]: (1) repertoire composition (phonology); (2) order
of production of repertoire components (syllable types or song
types, i.e. syntax); (3) distinctive ‘voice’ characteristics and/or
subtle differences in the song types versions of each individual
[30,31]. (1) and (2) are probably more important in species with
moderate or large repertoires that produce their repertoire
components with immediate variety (no repetitions of repertoire
components), like skylarks [10] (e.g. European robin Erithacus
rubecula [32]), because the entire repertoire is produced within a
short time interval. On the other side, (3) may be more widespread
in species with small repertoires and/or high song sharing (e.g. song sparrow [7]), or in species with very large repertoire and no
or eventual variety of repertoire component production (repeti-
tions of repertoire components, e.g. tropical mockingbirds Mimus
gilvus [33]). August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org Acknowledgments To conclude, we showed that, in skylarks, even distant
neighbours can be identified as group members and considered
to be dear-enemies. They are probably discriminated from
strangers using the group signature in their song. Such signature
may thus act as a key that strengthens group cohesion through a
reduction in territorial aggression between group members. Similar studies in other cluster living territorial songbirds could We are grateful to Carlos Botero, Taffeta Elliott, Alan McElligott, and an
anonymous reviewer for helpful comments on the manuscript. Discussion Responses of
subjects to distant neighbour songs can be compared to responses
to chimeric songs (stranger songs in which the group signature was
artificially inserted) tested in this previous study. Such chimeric
songs elicited significantly less aggressive responses than stranger
songs and similar responses as adjacent neighbour songs. These
findings indicate that group signatures (microdialects) act as
‘passwords’ allowing territory owners to identify distant neigh-
bours as group members and to show reduced territorial responses
towards them. Thus, male skylarks unfamiliar with each other but Our playback procedure of distant neighbour song mimicked a
group member leaving its territory and attempting to come up
closer to the tested male. In this situation, we observed a trend
towards a stronger response to the distant neighbour song than to
the adjacent neighbour song that a larger sample size might be
able to detect (Fig. 3). This trend could be the result of an
adjacent-distant neighbour discrimination. We showed previously
that males spatially categorized adjacent neighbour songs ([35], see
also [36], and [32,37] for other songbird species with similar PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 6 Distant Neighbour Recognition add to our understanding of interactions occurring between and
within communication networks. add to our understanding of interactions occurring between and
within communication networks. repertoire size as the skylark). Here, the birds could have been
confused not to hear the ‘‘correct’’ individual neighbour song at
the ‘‘correct’’ distance, inducing a slightly stronger response to this
displaced group member song. References Wilson PL, Vehrencamp SL (2001) A test of the deceptive mimicry hypothesis in
song-sharing song sparrows. Anim Behav 62: 1197–1205. 8. Briefer E, Aubin T, Lehongre K, Rybak F (2008) How to identify dear-enemies:
the group signature in the complex song of the skylark Alauda arvensis. J Exp Biol
211: 317–326. 28. Baker MC (2004) The Chorus Song of Cooperatively Breeding Laughing
Kookaburras (Coraciiformes, Halcyonidae: Dacelo novaeguineae): Characterization
and Comparison Among Groups. Ethology 110: 21–35. 9. Aubin T, Bre´mond JC (1983) The process of species-specific song recognition in
the skylark Alauda arvensis. An experimental study by means of synthesis. Z Tierpsychol 61: 141–152. 29. Radford AN (2005) Group-specific vocal signatures and neighbour-stranger
discrimination in the cooperatively breeding green woodhoopoe. Anim Behav
70: 1227–1234. 10. Briefer E, Osiejuk T, Rybak F, Aubin T (2010) Are bird song complexity and
song sharing shaped by habitat structure? An information theory and statistical
approach. J Theor Biol 262: 151–164. 30. Lambrechts MM, Dhondt AA (1995) Individual voice discrimination in birds. Curr Ornithol 12: 115–139. 31. Weary DM, Krebs JR (1992) Great tits classify songs by individual voice
characteristics. Anim Behav 43: 283–287. 11. Briefer E, Rybak F, Aubin T (2008) When to be a dear-enemy: flexible acoustic
relationships of neighbouring skylarks Alauda arvensis. Anim Behav 76:
1319–1325. 32. Brindley EL (1991) Response of European robins to playback of song: neighbor
recognition and overlapping. Anim Behav 41: 503–512. 12. Specht R (2004) Avisoft-SASLab pro v.4.31 Avisoft, Berlin. 33. Botero CA, Riveros JM, Vehrencamp SL (2007) Relative threat and recognition
ability in the responses of tropical mockingbirds to song playback. Anim Behav
73: 661–669. p
(
)
p
,
13. Craig C (2000) Goldwave v.5.11 Goldwave. St John’s, Canada. 13. Craig C (2000) Goldwave v.5.11 Goldwave. St John’s, Canada 14. Sueur J, Aubin T, Simonis C (2008) Seewave: a free modular tool for sound
analysis and synthesis. Bioacoustics 18: 213–226. 34. Botero CA, Mudge AE, Koltz AM, Hochachka WM, Vehrencamp SL (2008)
How reliable are the methods for estimating repertoire size? Ethology 114:
1227–1238. y
y
15. McGregor PK (1992) In: McGregor PK, ed (1992) Playback and studies of
Animal Communication. New York: Plenum Press. pp 1–9; 79–96. pp
16. R Development Core Team (2009) R Foundation for Statistical Computing,
Vienna, Austria. ISBN 3-900051-07-0, URL http://www.R-project.org. 35. Briefer E, Aubin T, Rybak F (2009) Response to displaced neighbours in a
territorial songbird with a large repertoire. Author Contributions Conceived and designed the experiments: EB FR TA. Performed the
experiments: EB. Analyzed the data: EB. Wrote the paper: EB FR TA. Conceived and designed the experiments: EB FR TA. Performed the
experiments: EB. Analyzed the data: EB. Wrote the paper: EB FR TA. References 1. Mundinger PC (1982) Microgeographic and macrogeographic variation in the
acquired vocalizations of birds. In: Kroodsma DE, Miller, EH, eds. Acoustic
communication in birds. New York: Academic Press. pp 147–208. 20. Hultsch H, Todt D (1981) Repertoire sharing and song post distance in
nightingales. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 8: 182–188. 21. Sokal RR, Rohlf FJ In: Freeman WH, ed (1995) Biometry the principles and
practice of statistics in biological research. 3rd ed. New York. pp
2. Temeles EJ (1994) The role of neighbours in territorial systems: when are they
‘dear enemies’? Anim Behav 47: 339–350. pp
2. Temeles EJ (1994) The role of neighbours in territorial systems: when are they
‘dear enemies’? Anim Behav 47: 339–350. 22. Mundry R (1999) Testing related samples with missing values: a permutation
approach. Anim Behav 58: 1143–1153. 3. Stoddard PK (1996) Vocal recognition of neighbors by territorial Passerines. In:
Kroodsma DE, Miller, EH, eds. Ecology and Evolution of Acoustic
Communication in Birds. IthacaNew York: Cornell University Press. pp
356–374. pp
23. Mantel N (1967) The detection of disease clustering and a generalized regression
approach. Cancer Res 27: 209–220. 24. Donald PF (2004) In: The Skylark., Song and song flight. London: T and A. D. Poyser. pp 72–88. 4. Naguib M (2005) Singing interactions in songbirds: implications for social
relations and territorial settlement. In: McGregor PK, ed. Animal Communi-
cation Networks. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp 300–319. 25. Skierczynski M, Osiejuk T (2010) Sharing songs within a local dialect does not
hinder neighbour-stranger discrimination in ortolan bunting (Emberiza hortulana)
males. Behaviour 147: 333–351. g
g
y
pp
5. Gentner TQ, Hulse SH (2000) Perceptual classification based on the component
of song in European starlings. J Acoust Soc Am 107: 3369–3381. . Gentner TQ, Hulse SH (2000) Perceptual classification based on the 26. Mammen DL, Nowicki S (1981) Individual differences and within-flock
convergence in chickadee calls. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 19: 179–186. 6. Gentner TQ, Hulse SH, Bentley GE, Ball GF (2000) Individual vocal
recognition effect of partial lesions to HVc on discrimination, learning, and
categorization conspecific song in adult songbirds. J Neurobiol 42: 117–133. 27. Hausberger M (1997) Social influences on song acquisition and sharing in the
European starling (Sturnus vulgaris). In: Snowdon CT, Hausberger M, eds. Social
Influences on Vocal Development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp
128–156. g
p
g
g
J
7. References Naturwissenschaften 96: 1067–1077. ,
,
p
p
j
g
17. Khanna H, Gaunt LL, McCallum DA (1997) Digital spectrographic cross-
correlation: tests of sensitivity. Bioacoustics 7: 209–234. 36. Stoddard PK, Beecher MD, Horning CL, Campbell SE (1991) Recognition of
individual neighbors by song in the song sparrow, a species with song repertoires. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 29: 211–215. correlation: tests of sensitivity. Bioacoustics 7: 209–234. 18. Specht R (2001) Avisoft-Correlator v.2.0 Avisoft, Berlin. 19. Lehongre K, Aubin T, Robin S, Del Negro C (2008) Individual signature in
canary songs: contribution of multiple levels of song structure. Ethology 114:
425–435. 37. Naguib M, Todt D (1998) Recognition of neighbors song in a species with large
and complex song repertoires-the thrush nightingale. J Avian Biol 2: 155–160. PLoS ONE | www.plosone.org August 2010 | Volume 5 | Issue 8 | e12428 7
|
https://openalex.org/W2787701362
|
https://kar.kent.ac.uk/65821/15/Milner-Gulland_et_al-2018-Fish_and_Fisheries.pdf
|
English
| null |
Translating the terrestrial mitigation hierarchy to marine megafauna by-catch
|
Fish and fisheries
| 2,018
|
cc-by
| 14,956
|
Licence for this version
CC BY (Attribution) Additional information Versions of research works Versions of Record
If this version is the version of record, it is the same as the published version available on the publisher's web site. Cite as the published version. Author Accepted Manuscripts If this document is identified as the Author Accepted Manuscript it is the version after peer review but before type
setting, copy editing or publisher branding. Cite as Surname, Initial. (Year) 'Title of article'. To be published in Title
of Journal , Volume and issue numbers [peer-reviewed accepted version]. Available at: DOI or URL (Accessed: date). Kent Academic Repository Kent Academic Repository Milner-Gulland, E.J., Garcia, Serge, Arlidge, William, Bull, Joseph, Charles,
Anthony, Dagorn, Laurent, Fordham, Sonya, Graff Zivin, Joshua, Hall, Martin,
Shrader, Jeffrey and others (2018) Translating the terrestrial mitigation
hierarchy to marine megafauna bycatch. Fish and Fisheries . ISSN 1467-2960. Downloaded from Downloaded from
https://kar.kent.ac.uk/65821/ The University of Kent's Academic Repository KAR wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/faf | 1 Enquiries If you have questions about this document contact ResearchSupport@kent.ac.uk. Please include the URL of the record
in KAR. If you believe that your, or a third party's rights have been compromised through this document please see
our Take Down policy (available from https://www.kent.ac.uk/guides/kar-the-kent-academic-repository#policies). Received: 29 June 2017 | Accepted: 18 January 2018
DOI: 10.1111/faf.12273 Accepted: 18 January 2018 DOI: 10.1111/faf.12273 E J Milner-Gulland1
| Serge Garcia2 | William Arlidge1 | Joseph Bull3,4 |
Anthony Charles5 | Laurent Dagorn6 | Sonya Fordham7 | Joshua Graff Zivin8 |
Martin Hall9 | Jeffrey Shrader10 | Niels Vestergaard11 | Chris Wilcox12 | Dale Squires13 E J Milner-Gulland1
| Serge Garcia2 | William Arlidge1 | Joseph Bull3,4 |
Anthony Charles5 | Laurent Dagorn6 | Sonya Fordham7 | Joshua Graff Zivin8 |
Martin Hall9 | Jeffrey Shrader10 | Niels Vestergaard11 | Chris Wilcox12 | Dale Squires13 Fish and Fisheries. 2018;1–15. 1Department of Zoology, University of
Oxford, Oxford, UK
2IUCN Commission on Ecosystem Management
Fisheries Expert Group, Gland, Switzerland
3Department of Food and Resource
Economics, Center for Macroecology,
Evolution and Climate, University of
Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark
4Durrell Institute of Conservation and Ecology,
University of Kent, Canterbury, UK
5School of Environment and School of
Business, Saint Mary’s University, Halifax,
NS, Canada
6French National Research Institute for
Sustainable Development (IRD), UMR
MARBEC (IRD, Ifremer, Univ. Montpellier,
CNRS), Sète, France
7Shark Advocates International, Washington,
DC, USA
8School of Global Policy and Strategy,
University of California San Diego, San
Diego, CA, USA
9Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission,
San Diego, CA, USA
10School of International and Public Affairs,
Columbia University, New York, NY, USA
11Department of Sociology, Environmental
and Business Economics, University of
Southern Denmark, Esbjerg, Denmark
12CSIRO Marine and Atmospheric Research,
Hobart, Tas., Australia
13Southwest Fisheries Science Centre,
National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration, San Diego, CA, USA
Correspondence
E J Milner-Gulland, Department of Zoology,
University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. Email: ej.milner-gulland@zoo.ox.ac.uk
Funding information
Pew Charitable Trusts
This is an open access article under the terms o
provided the original work is properly cited. © 2018 The Authors. Fish and Fisheries Publish Fish and Fisheries. 2018;1–15. 1Department of Zoology, University of
Oxford, Oxford, UK
2IUCN Commission on Ecosystem Management
Fisheries Expert Group, Gland, Switzerland
3Department of Food and Resource
Economics, Center for Macroecology,
Evolution and Climate, University of
Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark
4Durrell Institute of Conservation and Ecology,
University of Kent, Canterbury, UK
5School of Environment and School of
Business, Saint Mary’s University, Halifax,
NS, Canada
6French National Research Institute for
Sustainable Development (IRD), UMR
MARBEC (IRD, Ifremer, Univ. E J Milner-Gulland1
| Serge Garcia2 | William Arlidge1 | Joseph Bull3,4 |
Anthony Charles5 | Laurent Dagorn6 | Sonya Fordham7 | Joshua Graff Zivin8 |
Martin Hall9 | Jeffrey Shrader10 | Niels Vestergaard11 | Chris Wilcox12 | Dale Squires13 Montpellier,
CNRS), Sète, France
7Shark Advocates International, Washington,
DC, USA
8School of Global Policy and Strategy,
University of California San Diego, San
Diego, CA, USA
9Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission,
San Diego, CA, USA
10School of International and Public Affairs,
Columbia University, New York, NY, USA
11Department of Sociology, Environmental
and Business Economics, University of
Southern Denmark, Esbjerg, Denmark
12CSIRO Marine and Atmospheric Research,
Hobart, Tas., Australia
13Southwest Fisheries Science Centre,
National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration, San Diego, CA, USA
Correspondence
E J Milner-Gulland, Department of Zoology,
University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. Email: ej.milner-gulland@zoo.ox.ac.uk
Funding information
Pew Charitable Trusts
This is an open access article under the terms of
provided the original work is properly cited. © 2018 The Authors. Fish and Fisheries Publishe Abstract Abstract
In terrestrial and coastal systems, the mitigation hierarchy is widely and increasingly
used to guide actions to ensure that no net loss of biodiversity ensues from develop-
ment. We develop a conceptual model which applies this approach to the mitigation
of marine megafauna by-catch in fisheries, going from defining an overarching goal
with an associated quantitative target, through avoidance, minimization, remediation
to offsetting. We demonstrate the framework’s utility as a tool for structuring think-
ing and exposing uncertainties. We draw comparisons between debates ongoing in
terrestrial situations and in by-catch mitigation, to show how insights from each
could inform the other; these are the hierarchical nature of mitigation, out-of-kind
offsets, research as an offset, incentivizing implementation of mitigation measures,
societal limits and uncertainty. We explore how economic incentives could be used
throughout the hierarchy to improve the achievement of by-catch goals. We con-
clude by highlighting the importance of clear agreed goals, of thinking beyond single
species and individual jurisdictions to account for complex interactions and policy
leakage, of taking uncertainty explicitly into account and of thinking creatively about
approaches to by-catch mitigation in order to improve outcomes for conservation
and fishers. We suggest that the framework set out here could be helpful in support-
ing efforts to improve by-catch mitigation efforts and highlight the need for a full
empirical application to substantiate this. 3Department of Food and Resource
Economics, Center for Macroecology,
Evolution and Climate, University of
Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark 4Durrell Institute of Conservation and Ecology,
University of Kent, Canterbury, UK 5School of Environment and School of
Business, Saint Mary’s University, Halifax,
NS, Canada 6French National Research Institute for
Sustainable Development (IRD), UMR
MARBEC (IRD, Ifremer, Univ. Montpellier,
CNRS), Sète, France 7Shark Advocates International, Washington,
DC, USA 2 |
1 | INTRODUCTION We take “marine megafauna” to encompass long-lived species
with low reproductive rates which are therefore potentially sensitive
to by-catch, for example marine mammals, turtles, seabirds and large
fish, while we define by-catch as catch which is not directly targeted
(bearing in mind the complexities in definition highlighted by FAO
2011). We limit our discussion to marine megafauna by-catch for
manageability of scope, and because this issue is of particular con-
cern within both the conservation and fisheries realms. However,
many of the points we raise are applicable to by-catch more broadly. It is also the issue for which discussion of the applicability of NNL
and the mitigation hierarchy to marine systems has been particularly
active (e.g. following the paper by Wilcox & Donlan, 2007). First, we outline a conceptual framework for by-catch mitiga-
tion, based on the application of a sequential mitigation hierarchy
to achieve NNL. We then discuss some key issues that arise in the
application of a mitigation hierarchy to marine megafauna by-catch,
and relate them to the equivalent debate in the terrestrial setting. We move on to consider how incentives to mitigate the amount or
impact of by-catch can be used to support the application of the
framework. Finally, we sum up the potential of our framework for
improving by-catch mitigation outcomes. Despite its growing use in terrestrial and coastal environments,
the mitigation hierarchy has not been so widely applied in near-
shore and high seas marine settings, and many questions about its
application in the ocean remain (Squires & Garcia, in press, UNEP-
WCMC 2016). Marine experience to date has mostly concerned
coastal development, for example relating to windfarms, urban de-
velopment, aquaculture and ports, rather than in the capture fish-
eries arena (e.g. Kyriazi, Lejano, Maes, & Degraer, 2015; Vaissière,
Levrel, Pioch, & Carlier, 2014). The four steps of the mitigation
hierarchy are discussed in fisheries, however, and as in the terres-
trial literature, the option of offsetting is particularly controversial
(e.g. the debate around Wilcox & Donlan, 2007 analysis of the po-
tential for offsetting seabird by-catch by invasive species eradica-
tion on nesting islands; Finkelstein et al., 2008; Wilcox & Donlan,
2009; Žydelis, Wallace, Gilman, & Werner, 2009). 2 |
1 | INTRODUCTION MILNER-GULLAND et al. innovation in gear technology (FAO 2011). Many questions remain
as to whether it is possible to apply the mitigation hierarchy to
marine by-catch, and what measures could be used to incentivize
action at each stage in the hierarchy. In particular, there is a need
for a conceptual framework that integrates the range of by-catch
mitigation measures, and the approaches used to incentivize them,
in an holistic way. The goal of no net loss (NNL) of biodiversity from economic de-
velopment is becoming widely adopted by national governments
and international lenders, potentially offering a method to limit
the impacts of environmental damage in terrestrial and coastal
systems (BBOP 2012, IFC 2012). Several large multinational com-
panies have signed up to NNL, or even to producing a net gain of
biodiversity as a result of their activities (Bull & Brownlie, 2017;
Rainey et al., 2015). Generally, NNL is assured by the use of a mit-
igation hierarchy, often applied as part of an Environmental and
Social Impact Assessment (ESIA). The mitigation hierarchy requires
that project proponents first avoid doing harm to biodiversity, for
example by sitting the development away from particularly sen-
sitive areas. Subsequently, while carrying out their development,
they should minimize the harm done, for example by limiting the
footprint of heavy machinery to specific areas and not polluting
watercourses. They then remediate the biodiversity loss within the
development footprint, for example by replanting cleared areas
post-development. The final step is to offset any residual additional
damage caused by their development through improvement of
biodiversity elsewhere (Gardner et al., 2013), using a range of ap-
proaches, for example digging new ponds or clearing invasive veg-
etation in an adjacent site (Bull, Hardy, Moilanen, & Gordon, 2015). Offsetting is a particularly controversial element of the hierarchy
because it requires acceptance of a development that harms biodi-
versity in a given location and assumes that it is possible to com-
pensate for this harm by biodiversity enhancement elsewhere (e.g. Maron et al., 2016). More generally, there is much debate about
whether NNL is attainable, and how it should be implemented in
practice (most recently explored by Bull, Lloyd, & Strange, 2017). This article explores application of the mitigation hierarchy to
address a specific fishery concern, that of marine megafauna by-
catch. 2 |
1 | INTRODUCTION The use of eco-
nomic incentives to reduce the amount or impact of by-catch has
received attention but has also not yet been fully explored (Dutton
& Squires, 2008; Gjertsen, Squires, Dutton, & Eguchi, 2014; Innes,
Pascoe, Wilcox, Jennings, & Paredes, 2015). The current FAO
International Guidelines on Bycatch Management and Reduction
of Discards mention economic incentives only briefly (as the only
economic instrument) and refer only to incentives to promote K E Y W O R D S albatrosses, biodiversity offsetting, economic incentives, no net loss, sharks and rays, turtles wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/faf | 1 If the baseline is dynamic, the counterfactual is the same
as the baseline; otherwise, both are required to fully define the scenario
against which NNL is evaluated The desired change in biodiversity, for example no net loss (NNL) of
biodiversity as a result of the combined effect of the damaging action (e.g. by-catch) and associated mitigation measures The next step is to define a quantitative target and associated
metric by which the goal will be measured. In the case of by-catch
of marine megafauna, one relatively intuitive approach is to de-
fine the target as zero net change in population growth rate of
the focal species caused as a result of by-catch and associated
mitigation measures, in the context of all the other factors influ-
encing that population (as was done, e.g., in the studies reviewed
by Lewison, Crowder, Read, & Freeman, 2004). The downside of
this metric is its requirement for monitoring data that can pro-
vide trends in population size over time, decomposed into vital
rates (survival, fecundity) so that the contribution of by-catch and
mitigation measures to change in population growth rate can be
discerned. This may be challenging for many marine megafauna
(Caswell, Brault, Read, & Smith, 1998). Other more readily mon-
itored targets could be based on numbers of animals, for exam-
ple not exceeding a Potential Biological Removal (PBR) threshold
(Richard & Abraham, 2013). The downside of numbers-based met-
rics is their more indirect relationship with the conservation status
of the species concerned. is compared (i.e. what would have happened in the absence of the
by-catch mitigation measures). Next, the different approaches which can be used to attain
NNL (or whatever goal is set) are assessed in terms of their effect
on the chosen metric; for example, the reduction in seabird mortal-
ity from fitting tori lines in a fishery can be assessed in terms of its
effect on the growth rate of a wandering albatross (Diomedea exu-
lans, Diomedeidae) population. The four categories of the terrestrial
mitigation hierarchy are avoidance, minimization, remediation (also
known as restoration or rebuilding) and offsetting. In the case of
marine megafauna by-catch, we take “avoidance” to represent mea-
sures taken in order to reduce the probability of encounter between
potentially harmful gear and a potentially by-caught individual,
by separating fishing activity from individuals or stocks of poten-
tial megafauna by-catch species (see Table 2 for example actions). | | Term
Explanation
Goal
The desired change in biodiversity, for example no net loss (NNL) of
biodiversity as a result of the combined effect of the damaging action (e.g. by-catch) and associated mitigation measures
Target
In our framework, we distinguish between the overall goal at the policy level
(e.g. NNL), and the quantitative target which operationalizes the goal, for
which a metric can be defined
Metric
The units used to measure gains and losses in biodiversity, in order to
evaluate whether the goal has been achieved. In our case, this is net change
in population growth rate of the focal species as a result of by-catch +
mitigation measures
Baseline
The reference point against which NNL is assessed. This could be static (e.g. current population growth rate), dynamic (projected population growth rate
in the absence of by-catch, but continuation of other processes affecting
vital rates), or aspirational (desired change in population growth rate)
Counterfactual
The projected change in population growth rate in the presence of by-catch
but absence of mitigation measures, against which NNL is assessed (e.g. business as usual). If the baseline is dynamic, the counterfactual is the same
as the baseline; otherwise, both are required to fully define the scenario
against which NNL is evaluated TA B LE 1 Explanation of terms used in
the mitigation hierarchy Term
Explanation
Goal
The desired change in biodiversity, for example no net loss (NNL) of
biodiversity as a result of the combined effect of the damaging action (e.g. by-catch) and associated mitigation measures
Target
In our framework, we distinguish between the overall goal at the policy level
(e.g. NNL), and the quantitative target which operationalizes the goal, for
which a metric can be defined
Metric
The units used to measure gains and losses in biodiversity, in order to
evaluate whether the goal has been achieved. In our case, this is net change
in population growth rate of the focal species as a result of by-catch +
mitigation measures
Baseline
The reference point against which NNL is assessed. This could be static (e.g. current population growth rate), dynamic (projected population growth rate
in the absence of by-catch, but continuation of other processes affecting
vital rates), or aspirational (desired change in population growth rate)
Counterfactual
The projected change in population growth rate in the presence of by-catch
but absence of mitigation measures, against which NNL is assessed (e.g. business as usual). 2 | CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR
BY-CATCH REDUCTION To clarify how achieving NNL through a mitigation hierarchy would
work for marine megafauna by-catch, we present a conceptual
framework relating to the target level of by-catch impact in a fishery. The approach can operate at a range of levels from the global to the
stock to the individual animal. The most usual, and most intuitive,
scale at which NNL could apply to by-catch is at the scale of a fish-
ery, targeting a given stock or set of stocks, so this is the scale we
use in this exploration. Table 1 explains the terms we use to describe
the conceptual framework. The approach starts by defining the goal in terms of a desired
change in biodiversity; this is commonly taken to be NNL of biodiver-
sity but that is not necessarily the only goal. For example, in the ter-
restrial realm, net gain is a widely used goal (Rainey et al., 2015), while
in the marine realm, by-catch minimization is often the policy goal
(except for totally protected species), which may imply a net loss or
gain in biodiversity, depending on the current by-catch level. Another
potential goal could be population recovery (cf the US Endangered
Species Act; Wolf, Hartl, Carroll, Neel, & Greenwald, 2015). MILNER-GULLAND et al. 3 4 | BPUE is a function of catchability of the by-caught spe-
cies as well as EB; for example, Ward, Lawrence, Darbyshire, and
Hindmarsh (2008) carried out a multispecies analysis of the effects
of nylon leaders on catch rates and showed that catch reduced
with nylon for sharks, blue marlin (Makaira nigricans, Istiophoridae)
and snake mackerel (Gempylus serpens, Gempylidae), and in-
creased for bigeye tuna (Thunnus obesus, Scombridae) and black
marlin (Istiompax indica, Istiophoridae). The relationships between
E, EB and BPUE are likely to be complex and confounded. There
have been limited explorations of these relationships in by-catch
datasets, which typically suffer from low sample sizes and zero-
inflation requiring specialized modelling techniques (e.g. the spa-
tially explicit Bayesian hierarchical models of Sims, Cox, & Lewison,
2008). By-catch mitigation may use a suite of interacting measures
from several levels of the mitigation hierarchy (Table 2), which
change over time, adding further to the complexity of separating E,
EB and BPUE (as discussed for target fishery data by Bishop, 2006). We do not here attempt further to clarify these relationships, but a
key research need is to disentangle these variables in an empirical
setting. Our division of mitigation approaches into these categories can
be represented in the following conceptual model, relating to a par-
ticular by-catch species, in which the unit is rate of change in popu-
lation size as a result of by-catch and its mitigation: (1)
ΔλT =f (EB ×BPUE)−OT (1) Here, ΔλT is the target level of overall net damage inflicted by
by-catch on the species concerned, measured in terms of change in
population growth rate with respect to the agreed baseline. A zero
ΔλT implies that the reduction in population growth rate caused by
by-catch, after avoidance and mitigation measures have been im-
plemented, is balanced by the gain engendered by offset measures. There is also the possibility for ΔλT to be negative (there is still addi-
tional population decline as a result of by-catch, even after measures
to reduce it) or positive (equivalent to net gain, meaning that species
population growth is higher than it would otherwise have been, as
a result of the combination of measures taken under the mitigation
hierarchy). 4 | 4 | MILNER-GULLAND et al. 4 Step of the
hierarchy
Example measures
Avoidance
Excluding fishing from the areas (no-fishing zones), seasons (closed seasons) or
times of day where these species are most vulnerable
Minimization
Using on-vessel technologies which aim to reduce the number of encountered
individuals that are captured during fishing operations, such as tori lines for
scaring seabirds away from longlines or sonic devices to signal nets to marine
mammals
Remediation
Devices which enable individuals to release themselves from the gear
(selectivity grids, turtle excluder devices) or to be released (e.g. Medina
panels operated in tuna purse-seine fisheries to let dolphins escape before
getting on the deck), or releasing them on deck and providing for a safe
return to the sea (e.g. a large mesh soft webbing cargo net can be used to
“sieve” a ray from the catch and lift it over the side of the vessel; Francis,
2014)
Offsetting
Eradicating invasive predators on islands where seabirds nest, restoring
habitat, restocking with hatchery-raised individuals, improving by-catch
performance of other gear types in the area TA B LE 2 Examples of measures which
can be taken under each step of the
mitigation hierarchy the stock more indirectly or act at the broader species level (such as
restoration in other locations or measures to improve compliance
and reduce uncertainty). However, we feel that the clarity of the
probabilistic approach in our framework, which extends the classi-
fication by Hall (1996), is particularly helpful. prevalent). A reduction in BPUE is the result of the at-sea measures
encompassed in the “minimize” and “remediate” steps of the miti-
gation hierarchy. By-catch-relevant effort EB is a subset of the overall fishing ef-
fort that occurs in the area in which there is risk of by-catch (E). Given the complexities of estimating EB, in many cases it will be
necessary to approximate it by E (e.g. Tuck, Polacheck, & Bulman,
2003). This may be problematic; for example, Báez et al. (2007)
show that loggerhead turtle (Caretta caretta, Cheloniidae) by-
catch in the Mediterranean was not correlated with fishing effort
(measured as number of hooks); by-catch was instead strongly re-
lated to distance from the coast. They suggest that this was not
because turtle abundance is a function of distance (which would
have implied a gradient in EB), but because fisher behaviour var-
ied, although they left investigation of the mechanisms for further
research. We take “minimization” as measures which reduce the probability
of capture by the gear given that the encounter cannot be realisti-
cally “avoided”. These measures occur once there is spatio-temporal
overlap between a fishing vessel and a marine megafauna individ-
ual. “Remediation” also occurs at sea, but post-capture, and aims to
reduce the probability of mortality given capture. “Offsetting” re-
fers to measures to compensate for by-catch mortality that operate
separately from the focal fishing activity, but which target the same
stock of the by-caught species. Using the metric of net change in population growth rate, the
baseline from which gains and losses from different measures taken
to mitigate by-catch are assessed could be: a zero population growth
rate such that the population remains stable at the current level (a
static baseline); the projected population growth rate of the spe-
cies in the absence of by-catch, which could be positive or negative
depending on the relative importance of by-catch in the context of
other threats (a dynamic baseline); or an aspirational baseline, such
as population growth at X% per year to the point at which it reaches
some desired steady-state abundance (which would need to be dy-
namic given that populations have density-dependent growth). Such
a baseline is therefore a type of counterfactual, against which any
improvement or deterioration in the population of the by-caught
species as a result of the implementation of the mitigation hierarchy In reality, there are grey areas between each of these stages, and
a range of ways in which by-catch mitigation measures can be cat-
egorized. For example, here we include restoration and rebuilding
activities at the stock level in “offsetting”, because our framework
is structured around individual-level capture probability. However,
another approach might be to combine remediation at the individ-
ual level in a category with restoration/rebuilding measures that im-
prove population viability at the stock level, such as restocking and
habitat improvement, leaving offsetting as measures which benefit 3 | OPERATIONALIZING THE FRAMEWORK In Table 3, we illustrate the application of the by-catch mitigation
framework using four examples from different fisheries and by-
catch taxa. Specific solutions to Equation 1 could come from taking
into account the regulatory, cultural and economic conditions in a
particular fishery. For instance, once the focal by-catch population
has been defined, then it is possible to solve the equation by assign-
ing factors affecting decision-making, including cost. If a least-cost
approach to by-catch goals is appropriate, EB, BPUE and OT could be
expressed as functions of cost to solve the equation for a given ΔλT. Another approach would be to maximize ΔλT subject to a budget
constraint. In Table 3, we illustrate the application of the by-catch mitigation
framework using four examples from different fisheries and by-
catch taxa. Specific solutions to Equation 1 could come from taking
into account the regulatory, cultural and economic conditions in a
particular fishery. For instance, once the focal by-catch population
has been defined, then it is possible to solve the equation by assign-
ing factors affecting decision-making, including cost. If a least-cost
approach to by-catch goals is appropriate, EB, BPUE and OT could be
expressed as functions of cost to solve the equation for a given ΔλT. Another approach would be to maximize ΔλT subject to a budget
constraint. It is important to note that this equation is not a true bioeco-
nomic equation to be solved. Rather, it is a conceptual framework in
which we make the components of the mitigation hierarchy explicit,
in order to guide thinking towards a more holistic approach to ad-
dressing by-catch. It also does not represent a hierarchy such as is
required in terrestrial systems. To make this equation into a hierar-
chy, rather than a model for least-cost mitigation of by-catch, it could
be set up as a goal programming function, with sequential solutions
to each element, summed to produce the final mitigation outcome. In
operational terms, this translates into a presumption that investment
and effort should be focussed differentially on sequential elements
of the model, starting with EB, then BPUE, then OT, so that offsetting
relates only to the unavoidable residual harm once all other steps
have been taken. 4 | f(EB × BPUE) is the effect on population growth rate of the by-
catch-relevant component of fishing effort, broken down into the
by-catch-relevant effort itself, EB, and the by-catch taken per unit
of that effort, BPUE, where f() is the effect of this effort on the
by-caught species’ population dynamics. This would generally be
calculated as the output of a population model. A reduction in EB
is equivalent to a fishery avoiding by-catch, partially or completely. It could include restricting the fishery to particular areas or sea-
sons, modification of fishing practices and operations (e.g. set-
ting the gear deeper to avoid depths where by-caught species are | 5
the vessel, and individuals dying after live release, we can rewrite
BPUE as a series of factors: | 5
the vessel, and individuals dying after live release, we can rewrite
BPUE as a series of factors:
( )
(
) MILNER-GULLAND et al. | 5
the vessel, and individuals dying after live release, we can rewrite
BPUE as a series of factors: OT is the net effect on population growth rate of policies
aiming to improve the overall viability of the by-caught species’
population, representing “offsetting” of the damage caused. It
represents the expected effects of measures to improve con-
ditions for individuals which would not have been at risk of
by-catch at that particular stage in their lives or location. For
example, supplementation in nesting areas (for turtles); resto-
ration of nesting habitat (for seabirds); or implementation of pro-
tected areas aimed at demographic groups not directly impacted
by fishing (calving areas for cetaceans; juvenile concentrations
for fish). the vessel, and individuals dying after live release, we can rewrite
BPUE as a series of factors: the vessel, and individuals dying after live release, we can rewrite
BPUE as a series of factors: (2) (2) BPUE=BDOA +PDV ×BOB +(1−PDV
)×BOB ×PDR where BDOA is the by-catch per unit effort that arrives to the boat
dead, BOB is the by-catch per unit effort that arrives to the vessel
alive, PDV is the proportion dying on the vessel, and PDR is the pro-
portion dying after release. 3 | OPERATIONALIZING THE FRAMEWORK This may be reflected in the emphasis placed on
the incentives given to fishers to change behaviour pertaining to se-
quential elements of the hierarchy, in the timing of the offset, or in
the disposition of the funding for research and conservation action
allocated by government. Table 3 highlights that there is not always potential for effec-
tive action at each level of the hierarchy; for some species (e.g. oceanic whitetips/longlines), there may be limited potential at all
levels. The framework is a way of organizing and structuring think-
ing about by-catch mitigation, and enabling mitigation effective-
ness to be assessed against a concretely defined and measurable
target. Its function is not to propose new ways of doing by-catch
mitigation for cases like these. If, on using the framework to anal-
yse the effectiveness of the measures available for a given by-
caught stock, it is found that it is not possible to reach the chosen
target (e.g. NNL), then difficult decisions must be made. For exam-
ple, the target may need to change, which could imply an accep-
tance of continuing decline of the by-caught stock. Or the fishery
must be restructured in a way that reduces by-catch effectively
(maybe even closed down). Or investment must be made into tech-
nological innovation to develop new ways to reduce by-catch. If
it is found that the data are inadequate for the analysis required,
then the decision must be made either to invest in improving the
evidence base or to recognize that it is not possible to evaluate
whether by-catch mitigation has been effective in reaching the
agreed goal. The framework’s main utility, therefore, is to make
these choices explicit. Research is currently ongoing to operationalize Equation 1 to re-
duce turtle by-catch of a small-scale gillnet fishery operating out of
San Jose port, Peru (Alfaro-Shigueto et al., 2010). Currently, a small-
scale certification scheme is under trial by the NGO ProDelphinus,
which aims to give premium prices for fish caught by skippers
abiding by best-practice by-catch reduction guidelines (J. Alfaro-
Shigueto and J. Mangel, personal communication). The research
entails collecting detailed economic data from all gillnet vessels to
understand the economic costs involved in fishing operations, to
calculate the potential additional costs of measures at each stage in Equation 1 could be extended to handle multiple species, vary-
ing gear types, or heterogeneous by-catch reduction methods. 4 | For instance, a higher proportion of
by-catch of sea turtles and other species arrives to the boat dead
when using longlines that are set deep, such as those used for big-
eye tuna that can be set more than 300 m deep, when compared
to a shallow set longline such as those used in many nearshore
artisanal fisheries (Andraka et al., 2013; Hall, Swimmer, & Parga,
2012; Swimmer et al., 2006). This difference would appear in the
BDOA term. Such a decomposition illustrates the flexibility of this
framework in handling fishery- and species-specific features and
also serves to highlight areas where different mitigation methods
would have the greatest influence (e.g. Shiode, Hu, Shiga, Yokota,
& Tokai, 2005). Another extension to the basic framework would
be to consider explicitly the uncertainty surrounding different el-
ements of the conceptual model, and the impact of this uncer-
tainty on which element of by-catch mitigation should be a focus
(Table 3). 3 | OPERATIONALIZING THE FRAMEWORK For
instance, BPUE can be decomposed into several components repre-
senting the different stages of the process. If BPUE represents the
sum of individuals dead on arrival, individuals captured and dying on 6 MILNER-GULLAND et al. 6 TA B LE 3 Summary of options for by-catch mitigation, structured according to the mitigation hierarchy, for four case-studies
Framework step
Case-study
Albatrosses/longlines
Turtles/longlines
Rays/purse seines
Oceanic whitetips/longlines
Defining the problem
Fishery and spatial
extent
Brazilian domestic industrial coastal longline
fleet
Eastern Pacific (coastal and pelagic)
small-scale commercial longline fishery
Tuna purse-seine fishery of
the eastern Pacific
Asian and EU longline tuna fisheries in the
Indian ocean
Target species
Various species of shark and swordfish
Mahi-mahi (Coryphaena hippurus
Coryphaenidae; seasonal), tuna, sharks
(mostly silky; Carcharhinus falciformis,
Carcharinidae), billfish
Various species of tuna
Various species of tuna
By-catch species of
concern
Albatross & petrel species; particular concern
for critically endangered Tristan albatross
(Diomedea dabennena, Diomedeidae)
Olive ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea,
Cheloniidae), green/black (Chelonia
mydas, Cheloniidae), hawksbill
(Eretmochelys imbricata, Cheloniidae),
loggerhead (Peru and Mexico) and
leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea,
Cheloniidae)
Seven mobulid species,
including CITES-listed Manta
birostris (Mobulidae) and
M. alfredi (Mobulidae),
caught mostly alive in
dolphin-associated or
free-school sets
Oceanic whitetip shark; Vulnerable on IUCN
red list, retention banned by tuna RFMOs,
listed on CITES Appendix II
By-catch target
(ΔλT)
Brazilian government: Minimize by-catch. Rules focus on targets for use of minimizing
measures, rather than on by-catch numbers
Not well defined. RFMOs suggest
minimizing by-catch. Could consider PBR
for olive ridleys, zero catch for leather-
backs (reflecting their respective
population status)
IATTC (2015): zero retention,
storing or selling and live
release of by-caught rays
when possible. Implies
by-catch minimization
Target by-catch level not defined due to
uncertainty; RFMOs ban retention, landing
and trans-shipment
Mitigation hierarchy element
Avoid
✓✓
[time/area closures, night-time setting]
✓
[time/area closures, deeper lines]
✓
[time/area closures]
✓✓
[deep setting]
Minimize
✓✓✓
[tori lines, line weights]
✓✓✓
[monofilament line, circle hooks (not
leatherbacks)]
–
[hard to avoid catching]
✓
[monofilament line, circle hooks, ban on
steel leaders]
Remediate
–
[hard to release alive]
✓✓
[improved handling]
✓✓✓
[improved handling]
✓
[short sets]
Offset
✓✓
[invasive eradication]
✓✓
[beach protection]
✓
[illegal trade]
✓
[information gathering, illegal trade]
Factors affecting operationalization
Scope for
incentives
Participatory research on barriers to uptake of
minimization measures. The information for the case-studies is based on the expert knowledge
of the authors through their involvement in management of the by-catch issue in these fisheries. RFMO, regional fisheries management organization; PBR, potential biological removal. Ticks indicate the potential for action at different steps of the hierarchy, based on feasibility, current knowledge and impact on mortality (✓✓✓ = high potential; ✓✓ = some potential; ✓ = limited potential;
– = no potential). Text in brackets gives suggested measures at each level of the hierarchy; these are illustrative rather than definitive. The information for the case-studies is based on the expert knowledge
of the authors through their involvement in management of the by-catch issue in these fisheries. RFMO, regional fisheries management organization; PBR, potential biological removal. the mitigation hierarchy. In the absence of high quality population
data with which to parameterize a model, a PBR-based approach is
being used to set a target by-catch level in terms of number of in-
dividuals of each of the turtle species caught in the fishery. Expert
opinion from fishers and Prodelphinus staff, supplemented by data
from a long-running by-catch observer programme operating out of
the port (Alfaro-Shigueto et al., 2011), gives the potential reduction
in turtle by-catch numbers as a result of a given mitigation approach. Interviews and focus groups with fishers provide understanding
of their preferences for different by-catch mitigation approaches,
barriers and constraints to implementation, and potential partici-
pation in different incentive schemes; this can be supplemented by
Discrete Choice Experiments providing empirical estimates for pref-
erences for combinations of by-catch reduction measures (cf Rogers,
2013). This field research produces a short-list of feasible mitigation
measures at each stage in the mitigation hierarchy, for costing and
testing (e.g. specific areas or times for fishery closure under avoid-
ance, combinations of hook types and net modification under mini-
mization, training in turtle handling and release for remediation, and
improving by-catch performance of other gear types in the area for
offsetting). This enables the analysis of the effectiveness and cost
of various combinations of by-catch reduction strategies, framed
within the four steps of the mitigation hierarchy (avoid, minimize, re-
mediate, offset), with a clear target by-catch reduction goal in mind. the mitigation hierarchy. In the absence of high quality population
data with which to parameterize a model, a PBR-based approach is
being used to set a target by-catch level in terms of number of in-
dividuals of each of the turtle species caught in the fishery. (2012); Andraka et al. (2013)
Jones & Francis (2012); Hall &
Roman (2013); Croll et al. (2016); Fowler (2016)
Tolotti et al. (2015)
icks indicate the potential for action at different steps of the hierarchy, based on feasibility, current knowledge and impact on mortality (✓✓✓ = high potential; ✓✓ = some potential; ✓ = limited potential;
= no potential). Text in brackets gives suggested measures at each level of the hierarchy; these are illustrative rather than definitive. The information for the case-studies is based on the expert knowledge
f the authors through their involvement in management of the by-catch issue in these fisheries. RFMO, regional fisheries management organization; PBR, potential biological removal. Framework step
y
Albatrosses/longlines
Turtles/longlines
Rays/purse seines
Oceanic whitetips/longlines
Major
uncertainties
Lack of species-level identification of
by-catch, lack of understanding of
compliance
Lack of ecological knowledge of turtle
population trends & distribution. Potential for significant additional
by-catch from coastal gillnet fishery
Impact of catch on mobulid
survival. Predictors of
mobulid distributions
Lack of observers or reporting so very limited
understanding of by-catch levels, spatio-
temporal encounter hotspots, post-release
survival, compliance
Key obstacle
Compliance with existing rules must be
improved
Funding for alternatives to fishing at a
large enough scale. Long time lag and
uncertainty in offset effectiveness
Limited knowledge of mobulid
distributions makes
avoidance difficult
Lack of monitoring limits options
Overall assessment
Existing measures for improving implementa-
tion of minimization step already exist but
need incentivizing; offsetting could provide
short-term gains to complement these
Targeted funding could facilitate improve-
ments throughout the hierarchy. Best
approach may differ by species (particu-
larly leatherbacks vs others)
Focus on remediation step is
currently the main option
available
Some potential for minimization through
deep setting, but challenging to change
behaviour in this fishery; electronic
monitoring systems would help
Key references
Bugoni, Mancini, Monteiro, Nascimento, &
Neves (2008); Wanless et al. (2009)
Alfaro-Shigueto, Dutton, & Mangel (2007);
Hall et al. (2012); Andraka et al. (2013)
Jones & Francis (2012); Hall &
Roman (2013); Croll et al. (2016); Fowler (2016)
Tolotti et al. (2015)
Ticks indicate the potential for action at different steps of the hierarchy, based on feasibility, current knowledge and impact on mortality (✓✓✓ = high potential; ✓✓ = some potential; ✓ = limited potential;
– = no potential). Text in brackets gives suggested measures at each level of the hierarchy; these are illustrative rather than definitive. Expert
opinion from fishers and Prodelphinus staff, supplemented by data
from a long-running by-catch observer programme operating out of
the port (Alfaro-Shigueto et al., 2011), gives the potential reduction
in turtle by-catch numbers as a result of a given mitigation approach. Interviews and focus groups with fishers provide understanding
of their preferences for different by-catch mitigation approaches,
barriers and constraints to implementation, and potential partici-
pation in different incentive schemes; this can be supplemented by
Discrete Choice Experiments providing empirical estimates for pref-
erences for combinations of by-catch reduction measures (cf Rogers,
2013). This field research produces a short-list of feasible mitigation
measures at each stage in the mitigation hierarchy, for costing and
testing (e.g. specific areas or times for fishery closure under avoid-
ance, combinations of hook types and net modification under mini-
mization, training in turtle handling and release for remediation, and
improving by-catch performance of other gear types in the area for
offsetting). This enables the analysis of the effectiveness and cost
of various combinations of by-catch reduction strategies, framed
within the four steps of the mitigation hierarchy (avoid, minimize, re-
mediate, offset), with a clear target by-catch reduction goal in mind. Framework step
Albatrosses/longlines
Turtles/longlines
Rays/purse seines
Oceanic whitetips/longlines
Major
uncertainties
Lack of species-level identification of
by-catch, lack of understanding of
compliance
Lack of ecological knowledge of turtle
population trends & distribution. Potential for significant additional
by-catch from coastal gillnet fishery
Impact of catch on mobulid
survival. Predictors of
mobulid distributions
Lack of observers or reporting so very limited
understanding of by-catch levels, spatio-
temporal encounter hotspots, post-release
survival, compliance
Key obstacle
Compliance with existing rules must be
improved
Funding for alternatives to fishing at a
large enough scale. Long time lag and
uncertainty in offset effectiveness
Limited knowledge of mobulid
distributions makes
avoidance difficult
Lack of monitoring limits options
Overall assessment
Existing measures for improving implementa-
tion of minimization step already exist but
need incentivizing; offsetting could provide
short-term gains to complement these
Targeted funding could facilitate improve-
ments throughout the hierarchy. Best
approach may differ by species (particu-
larly leatherbacks vs others)
Focus on remediation step is
currently the main option
available
Some potential for minimization through
deep setting, but challenging to change
behaviour in this fishery; electronic
monitoring systems would help
Key references
Bugoni, Mancini, Monteiro, Nascimento, &
Neves (2008); Wanless et al. (2009)
Alfaro-Shigueto, Dutton, & Mangel (2007);
Hall et al. 3 | OPERATIONALIZING THE FRAMEWORK Positive incentives
for those using new measures, paid for by,
for example, fisheries-wide levy
Certification/sustainability standards in
export markets
Transitional payments to
promote better handling on
deck, hence improving
survival
If information gathering seen as a valid offset
due to high uncertainty, funding a tagging
scheme could incentivize fishers to collect
data on shark catch rate, survival of
released sharks, by-catch hotspots, to
support improvements across the whole (Continues) | 7 MILNER-GULLAND et al. | 7 4.2 | Out-of-kind offsets Out-of-kind offsets are those which do not act to increase the
impact-affected biodiversity. In terms of our conceptual framework,
they are offsets which do not act to increase the population growth
rate of the by-catch-affected focal population (Equation 1). For ex-
ample, one suggested benefit of raising funds for offsetting from
a by-catch tax on fishers is that the proceeds from such a tax can
finance offsets elsewhere within the range of the by-catch-affected
population (Dutton & Squires, 2008): Although not a true offset
under a mitigation hierarchy, funds from the California drift gillnet
industry in 2002 financed sea turtle nesting site conservation in
Baja California for compensatory mitigation of sea turtle by-catch
(Jannise, Squires, Seminoff, & Dutton, 2010). In terrestrial (and
marine) systems, it can be more challenging to define the impact-
affected biodiversity, because impact is rarely as clearly linked
to a given species and stock as it is for by-catch. Because of this,
the location and biodiversity target of conservation actions falling
under the “offset” heading has sometimes been loosely related to
the actual impact. Best-practice standards state that offsets must
be implemented as close to the damaging activities as possible and
focus on biodiversity as similar as possible to that which has been
impacted (BBOP 2012). However, there have also been calls for
“out-of-kind” offsets that give more conservation bang-for-buck by
focussing on threatened species or rare habitats, or areas in need
of conservation, rather than the impacted areas or species which
may be considered less “valuable” for conservation (Bull, Hardy
et al., 2015). This has led to substantial debate as to the appropri-
ate limits on the geographic scale and biodiversity focus for offset-
ting (e.g. Apostolopoulou & Adams, 2017). It also draws attention to
the subjective and user-defined nature of the word “biodiversity”
(Morar, Toadvine, & Bohannan, 2015). As it is impossible fully to
operationalize the concept, implementers of the mitigation hierar-
chy have latitude to interpret biodiversity according to, for example,
ease of measurement, perceived societal value or mitigation cost
(Maron et al., 2016). In our case, we take a narrow focus on the
by-caught species itself; this is in line with much of the literature
on by-catch, but not with the broader discourses on ecosystem-
based approaches to marine management and ecosystem services
(Rosenberg & McLeod, 2005). 4.3 A related area of active controversy for marine by-catch is whether
research or information gathering should be seen as a valid offset
mechanism. The rationale is that this research could be used to
reduce uncertainty, promote innovation and thereby improve out-
comes for by-caught species, albeit indirectly. An offset could be
used to incentivize better data collection, for instance, using a by-
catch levy to pay for tagging or to put by-catch observers or elec-
tronic monitoring systems on boats. This might be a prelude to later
mitigation or avoidance activities once more is known about the
biological setting. Whether research activities could appropriately
be considered as part of an “offset” is controversial—in some cases,
an indirect benefit to the by-caught stock might be clearly appar-
ent (e.g. the oceanic whitetip (Carcharinus longimanus, Carcharinidae)
case-study in Table 3), while in other cases using investment in re-
search as an offset could be seen as a case of moral hazard, poten-
tially compromising scientists’ independence and having at best a
highly indirect relationship to NNL of the by-caught species. Another
view is that reducing uncertainty is a core responsibility of operating
a fishery, which therefore should be borne by the management au-
thority or fishing businesses. In terrestrial systems, these dilemmas
also exist, but the sentiment is much more clearly expressed that re-
search activities are not appropriate offsets (Bull, Gordon, Watson,
& Maron, 2016). 4.2 | Out-of-kind offsets These discourses suggest the need
for a more functional, ecosystem-based approach to no net loss of
biodiversity; this has yet to transpire either in the marine or in the
terrestrial literature, possibly because substantial challenges in de-
fining impact-affected biodiversity then inevitably ensue. As marine megafauna stocks are often transboundary and mi- 8 | 8 a challenge because the most effective location for an offset may
or may not be within the area of influence of a given fishery. Clearly
and precisely defining the spatial unit within which the mitigation
hierarchy will be implemented, during the process of defining the
overall goal (such as NNL), is vital. This unit should reflect the scale
over which an action will affect λT; offsets which are within the dis-
tribution of the focal stock of the by-caught species (as defined for
Equation 1) are not out-of-kind. However, challenges emerge when
the appropriate spatial unit for offsetting activities is different to
the appropriate spatial unit for other elements of the mitigation hi-
erarchy, which are likely to be defined instead by jurisdictional area
or target fish stock distribution. In many fisheries, the species af-
fected by by-catch may not be well enough known, and offsets may
accordingly need to be broadly targeted to benefit any potentially
affected species. True out-of-kind offsets would include funding the
conservation of unaffected species or stocks, of habitats not used
by the focal stock, or contributions to a conservation fund without a
clear commitment that the funds are to be spent on increasing λT for
the focal by-caught stock. These are unlikely to form part of best-
practice guidance for by-catch offsets. 2009). By contrast, in fisheries settings there have been suggestions
that, depending on the legal environment, it may be more appropriate
for offsets to be used as part of a least-cost conservation approach
alongside more traditional mitigation methods, rather than as the last
step in a mitigation hierarchy (Dutton, Joseph, Squires, & Williams,
2011; Dutton & Squires, 2008; Wilcox & Donlan, 2007). 4.1 | The hierarchical nature of mitigation Terrestrial situations are usually viewed as requiring a strict hierar-
chy with avoidance, minimization and remediation taking precedence
over offsets. Part of the reason for this hierarchy may be societal val-
ues and expectations, but also it is a reflection of reversibility and
uncertainty. The terrestrial mitigation hierarchy was set up to address
habitat destruction caused by development, which is effectively ir-
reversible, hence avoidance is strictly preferred from a conservation
perspective. In practice, avoidance has been a neglected step, and
much of the disquiet about biodiversity offsetting has been because
of the tendency to pay lip service to avoidance and focus instead on
offsets, which then may be implemented on paper only (Hough &
Robertson, 2009; Phalan et al., 2017). Even with perfect enforcement
and compliance with measures further down the mitigation hierarchy,
the strict avoidance of habitat loss is more certain to limit impact than
reducing losses in the course of a potentially damaging action, which
is more certain than restoring damage after the fact or compensating
for it with actions elsewhere. Often in terrestrial systems multipliers
are used at the offset stage to reflect this uncertainty, requiring that
an additional amount of equivalent land is protected in an offset over
and above the amount that is lost during the development (with the
ratio of land offset to land destroyed in the 10 s to 100 s depending
on the circumstances; Moilanen, Van Teeffelen, Ben-Haim, & Ferrier, MILNER-GULLAND et al. 4.4 | Incentivizing implementation of mitigation
measures The factors that drive decision-making about megafauna by-catch
reduction (by skippers, companies, fishery managers, policymak-
ers and other stakeholders) include legal obligations to minimize As marine megafauna stocks are often transboundary and mi-
gratory, defining the appropriate spatial unit for offsetting may be MILNER-GULLAND et al. 9 | 9 by-catch at the national or international levels (e.g. FAO, 2011;
Rice, 2014), the availability and quality of technical fixes, associ-
ated costs to fishers, limits on access to seafood markets, as well
as societal pressures. However, much research on by-catch reduc-
tion focuses on identifying and implementing technical measures
to reduce BPUE, rather than on the social and economic barriers
to implementation (Campbell & Cornwell, 2008). Technological
innovation to improve BPUE needs to be appropriately incentiv-
ized, with efforts made to ensure that such measures are as cost-
effective as possible for fishers (Gjertsen, Hall, & Squires, 2010;
Lent & Squires, 2017). However, it often happens that even ap-
parently suitable by-catch measures are not widely implemented
(e.g. Damalas & Vassilopoulou, 2013; Orphanides & Palka, 2013;
Radzio, Smolinsky, & Roosenburg, 2013). In these cases, the degree
of non-implementation, and the reasons behind it, needs to be un-
derstood so it can be addressed (Cox et al., 2007). These types of
consideration are also not well researched in the terrestrial offset-
ting literature, because compliance is poorly monitored (Bull, Suttle,
Gordon, Singh, & Milner-Gulland, 2013), and there is little support
for research on the barriers to implementation of a mitigation hi-
erarchy, and how to support developers to address these barriers
(Bull, Bryant, Baker, & Milner-Gulland, 2015). The social impacts of
implementing a biodiversity mitigation hierarchy on resource users
are mentioned in guidance (e.g. BBOP 2012) but how to measure
and account for them is very poorly understood. The few studies in-
vestigating delivery of promised offset measures in terrestrial sys-
tems suggest a very poor record (Quétier, Regnery, & Levrel, 2014). Therefore, the social side of implementing the mitigation hierar-
chy and incentivizing compliance is an area that needs more, and
more active, research within both the terrestrial and marine realms
(Fulton, Smith, Smith, & van Putten, 2011). This is particularly true
when the burden of implementing mitigation approaches is borne
by relatively small-scale producers rather than governments or mul-
tinationals (e.g. the pelagic longline fisheries in Table 3). 4.4 | Incentivizing implementation of mitigation
measures hierarchy is seen as most appropriate for application in more com-
mon and degraded habitats such as farmland. Similarly, in fisheries,
there may be some situations in which the stocks subject to by-catch
are so precious or threatened that no level of threat from fishing
can be contemplated, and others where fishing subject to NNL and
the mitigation hierarchy is a socially acceptable approach. In situa-
tions in which trade-offs between conservation and development
are seen as necessary or acceptable by wider society, a social licence
to operate may be gained through adopting offsets in the absence of
regulation. For example, in sub-Saharan Africa, several large devel-
opment projects are attempting to offset their impacts on great apes
and their habitats (Kormos et al., 2014). A by-catch equivalent might
be fishing companies voluntarily donating funds for turtle nesting
beach restoration in their area of operation, in addition to comply-
ing with regulatory by-catch mitigation measures. These measures
may improve the image of the company with the general public, but
to avoid accusations of “greenwashing”, their effectiveness needs to
be properly scrutinized (Bull et al., 2016). Transparently embedding
these types of actions within a mitigation hierarchy such as we are
proposing and critically evaluating their contribution to increasing
the population growth rate (as per Equation 1), would be one way to
prompt such scrutiny. 4.6 | Uncertainty The nature of the uncertainties surrounding biology and enforce-
ment in the marine setting raises questions about the ordering of
steps in the mitigation hierarchy, in a way that is dissimilar to ter-
restrial systems where the hierarchy of uncertainties may be clearer
and uncertainty is generally lower. For example, it may be that the
impact on overall population growth rate of an offset measure like
eradicating invasive species from a seabird nesting habitat is both
less uncertain and more cost-effective than avoidance measures
such as closing areas which may or may not be frequented by adult
seabirds in a given time-period. Generally, though, it might be as-
sumed that measures which target life stages subject to high levels
of natural mortality, or within which individual contribution to over-
all population growth rate is low (e.g. headstarting juvenile turtles)
may be less effective in achieving NNL than measures which target
reproductively mature adult females (such as live releases; Heppell,
Crowder, & Crouse, 1996). However, before implementing an offset
that aims to improve the survival of one lifestage in order to com-
pensate for the by-catch mortality of another, a robust assessment
of the consequences (with associated uncertainties) should be car-
ried out through detailed population modelling, based on strong
empirical studies (c.f. Wallace, Heppell, Lewison, Kelez, & Crowder,
2008). In terrestrial systems, the requirement sequentially to apply
the mitigation hierarchy is broadly unchallenged, but actually similar
arguments apply. For example, habitat restoration sits above off-
setting in the hierarchy, and yet it is a long-term, uncertain process,
which may in some circumstances be much less preferable to an off-
set using a well-established approach which is highly likely to lead to
conservation gains. 4.7 | Temporal considerations The timing of offsets in relation to other elements of the mitigation
hierarchy has been the subject of debate within the terrestrial litera-
ture. The main suggestion for addressing the temporary loss of bio-
diversity while offsets come to fruition has been adopting mitigation
banking, whereby offsets are implemented in advance of potentially
damaging activities, providing biodiversity credits which can be used
to compensate for later losses. This both removes an element of un-
certainty from the offset implementation and reduces the time lag
between loss and gain (Mann, 2015). With respect to marine mega-
fauna by-catch, flexibility in timing provides additional scope for cost
reduction and benefit enhancement which may not be present in
traditional habitat-based terrestrial offsets. For example, temporary
measures such as a short-term by-catch tax to fund an offset may be
used if mitigation or avoidance methods take time to come online,
or if a temporary nudge is enough to cause behavioural change. This
might be the case if a policy was needed to induce fishers to take up
new gear to avoid the cost of an offset, or if concerns about safety or
yield reductions during the transition to new gear could be allayed by
a temporary subsidy for early adopters or a paid participatory moni-
toring programme to inform wider implementation (e.g. the mobu-
lid and shark case-studies in Table 3). Just as for habitat restoration
(Zedler & Callaway, 1999), by-catch offset strategies which target
juvenile stages of long-lived species (e.g. turtle headstarting or in-
vasive removal from seabird nesting islands) may take many years
for their effects to become apparent in an increase in population
growth rates. Additional uncertainty is introduced by the difficulty
in monitoring populations of many by-catch species (e.g. seabirds;
Hatch, 2003), leading to uncertain estimates of the impact of offset
activities on population growth (see case-studies in Table 3). These
problems are not insuperable, however; positive trends have been
reported in turtle populations over decades as a result of nest pro-
tection (e.g. Dutton, Dutton, Chaloupka, & Boulon, 2005). If by-catch is seen as an unpriced externality, it might be socially
optimal to tax fishers for their by-catch so that this externality is in-
ternalized. This places an explicit price upon by-catch (Boyce, 1996;
Pascoe et al., 2010; Squires & Garcia, 2014). 4.7 | Temporal considerations The by-catch price is
likely to be incorporated into the price of the target species, and
thereby becomes part of the target species cost. This price could be
set differently for different demographic classes of the by-caught
species, depending on the impact the loss of an individual would
have on the population. All else being equal, putting a price on by-
catch means that the seafood product that is the target catch be-
comes more expensive and consumers have to pay more for their
seafood, reducing demand. Then, in principle, every firm in the sup-
ply chain, every vessel and every consumer have an incentive to re-
duce by-catch until each economic actor’s marginal cost of by-catch
reduction equals the common price of by-catch that they all face. Offsets are one way to price and internalize the by-catch externality
cost. If an offsetting action is costly to implement and must be paid
for with each unit of by-catch, it implicitly prices the residual by-
catch. In this circumstance, the effect from a financial standpoint
is the same as a by-catch tax, with the level set based on the cost
of the offset. Various institutional structures to support this charge
per unit of by-catch are possible, with different implications in terms
of the distribution of costs and benefits. For example, an insurance
scheme could be paid into by fishers that pays out in the event of a
by-catch event, thereby spreading the cost of unavoidable, rare, by-
catch events. Or a tradable permit scheme could operate, such that
fishers who experience a by-catch event can buy a permit, with the
cost varying depending on demand for permits (hence providing a
vessel-level incentive to innovate to reduce by-catch). equipment, or the loss of access to a fishery. Costs may also arise
from the deployment of by-catch observers or training in the use of
new gear. These costs can be paid by fishing companies or individ-
uals, or by governments, NGOs or seafood consumers. Whether or
not compensation for costs incurred by fishers is seen as appropri-
ate depends on whether by-catch reduction is seen as a social good
that fishers are providing (in which case they should be compensated
for it), or as putting right the harm that they are doing to biodiver-
sity while generating their own private gain (in economic language,
whether by-catch is viewed as an unpriced externality, in which case
they should pay). It also depends on whether economic hardship will
ensue; a case for compensation of by-catch reduction costs incurred
by people dependent on fishing for their livelihoods may be more
sympathetically received by other actors than a case made by a large
multinational fishing company. 4.5 | Societal limits For a species at high risk of extinction, complete avoidance of by-
catch might be the most desirable policy from both a management
agency and societal perspective. In addition, with emblematic or
highly threatened marine megafauna it may be viewed by members
of the public as morally wrong to kill any individuals even if miti-
gation is in place (e.g. Maui’s dolphin; Hamner et al., 2014), leading
to pressure on governments to reflect this ethical concern in regu-
lations. These dilemmas echo the issue of thresholds in terrestrial
offsets, which recognizes that there are some critical areas in which
development is not societally appropriate, regardless of the poten-
tial for mitigation, and other areas in which the mitigation hierarchy
can be appropriately applied (Bull et al., 2013). Examples of loca-
tions where a threshold approach is seen as appropriate in terres-
trial systems include the habitat of highly endangered species, or
ecosystems which are limited in extent and irreplaceable (such as
old growth forest). In terrestrial systems, therefore, the mitigation MILNER-GULLAND et al. 10 6 | CONCLUSIONS In fact, incentive-based by-
catch reduction policy instruments could even be counterproduc-
tive by reducing the effectiveness of intrinsic motivation, depending
upon the situation (although the empirical evidence on this topic
is weak; Rode, Gómez-Baggethun, & Krause, 2015). If the change
required for by-catch reduction to work meets cultural resistance,
then participatory research might be especially effective in break-
ing down barriers between those who want by-catch reduction to
take place and those who actually have to implement it (the fishers). For example, in Australia, the government-funded body Oceanwatch
facilitates engagement between communities, the fishing industry,
seafood suppliers and government to improve knowledge sharing
(www.oceanwatch.org.au). Innovation is crucial in fisheries, and fish-
ers are accustomed to adopting new technology or processes, po-
tentially making an incentivized participatory research programme
especially fruitful. Once the by-catch goal is known, options for implementing
avoidance, minimization, remediation and offsets can be clarified (as
in Table 2). However, outside of the interconnected biology of the
ecosystem, by-catch is embedded within social and economic sys-
tems. Different units of analysis may be needed at different levels
of the hierarchy, to cope with the challenges of incomplete overlap
between jurisdictional units, fisheries, target stocks and by-catch
stocks. Jurisdictional issues are important and complex, potentially
impeding implementation. Fleets interact, raising the risk of policy
leakage, for example if people shift to other fisheries, gear or liveli-
hoods. Therefore, the scale at which each element of the mitigation
hierarchy is implemented is likely to vary, with incentives to mitigate
often being best applied at the vessel level, focussed on reducing
individual mortality, while offsetting is implemented at the scale of
the by-catch species’ stock. With transboundary species, unilateral
conservation in one jurisdiction creates the potential for production,
trade and conservation leakages. For example, a conserving State
could implement the avoidance step and shut down or dramatically
curtail its own production of swordfish to reduce sea turtle by-catch,
but the knock-on effect may be more importation of swordfish from
fleets with higher sea turtle by-catch (Rausser, Hamilton, Kovach, &
Stifter, 2009). Sometimes the most efficient way to solve problems is a so-
cial instrument or an institutional change in place of, or as well as,
an economic instrument. For example, supporting development
of fisher organizations rather than instituting a vessel-level tax or
subsidy might provide the impetus needed to change behaviour. 6 | CONCLUSIONS The framework we present here is novel. It draws upon and ex-
tends the frameworks for conceptualizing by-catch developed by
Hall (1996) and Hall, Alverson, and Metuzals (2000). It amalgam-
ates Hall’s framework with the mitigation hierarchy as used in the
Environmental Impact Assessment literature (BBOP 2012). The
suggestions about goals, metric and mitigation actions are drawn
from the empirical by-catch literature, and the issues we discuss in-
tegrate the concerns of the extensive terrestrial and nascent marine
offsetting literature with the by-catch literature. The framework
makes clear that an early, crucial, step is to clarify the goal of any
by-catch reduction policy. Overarching goals, like those issued by
the Convention on Biological Diversity (e.g. Aichi Target 11 that 10%
of marine habitat should be under protection by 2020), need to be
translated into operational terms within each fishery. Currently, leg-
islated or agreed by-catch reduction goals tend to be less specific
than they could be, and this leads to problems in interpreting these
goals in order to plan a by-catch mitigation strategy (see the case-
studies in Table 3 for examples). This ambiguity is to be expected
within negotiated targets, but it is a challenge nonetheless (Maxwell
et al., 2015). Using a common unit of by-catch impact, such as the
ΔλT which we use here, would be helpful both in clarifying expecta-
tions, and evaluating the effectiveness of elements of the mitigation
hierarchy. Other changes which may need to be incentivized for successful
implementation of by-catch reduction policies may be less amenable
to financial measures, at least partly because it is less clear how to
assign financial value to the actions, or to the benefits and losses
which they produce. For example, perceived reductions in safety for
fishing crews (from weighted longlines, for instance) are costs that
may be hard to value financially. Other prerequisites for long-term
sustainable behaviour change, such as changes in social norms so
that fishing communities see by-catch reduction as appropriate be-
haviour, or technical skill acquisition so that they can use new meth-
ods, may be incentivized by carefully designed interventions working
with fishers (Hall et al., 2007). Conservation policies based on eco-
nomic incentives (extrinsic motivation) are not always superior to
those based upon intrinsic motivation. 5 | USING INCENTIVES TO REDUCE BY-
CATCH Many of the examples and principles discussed above either implic-
itly or explicitly relate to the economic, social, institutional or moral
incentives operating on different actors inside and outside the fish-
ery, which can be positive or negative. We now turn to a discussion
of how incentives can be used to reduce by-catch within our frame-
work. Incentives can be put in place to change fisher behaviour with
respect to any of the elements of the framework (avoid, minimize,
remediate and offset; Table 3). Although discussed in the literature,
most of these incentive approaches are yet to be implemented in
the real world, particularly for by-catch. Therefore, until empirical
evidence of their effectiveness is available, these suggestions come
with a caveat. If there is demand for conservation in an international market,
then price premiums and market access (through eco-labelling,
supply chain certification, other food sustainability campaigns;
Ward & Phillips, 2010), or boycotts acting as strategic threats from
consumers (Kotchen, 2013; Segerson, 2010), could act as positive
or negative economic levers on the fishery, providing an incentive
for fishers to reduce their by-catch voluntarily (as has been sug-
gested for the Brazilian mahi-mahi fishery; Table 3). For example,
the Marine Stewardship Council now includes by-catch mitigation Financial costs of by-catch mitigation actions can arise, for in-
stance, from lost catch, capital investments in new gear or mitigation MILNER-GULLAND et al. 11 in their certification process (MSC 2014). Demand-led levers may be
more or less applicable at different levels in the hierarchy; for exam-
ple, avoidance may be relatively hard to evidence, while offsetting
may be less easy to sell to a consumer than minimization or reme-
diation. Concerns about the unintended consequences of positive
incentives (particularly for direct subsidies, rather than conditional
incentives) may determine whether they are an appropriate instru-
ment in a given case. For example, they may be inappropriate if there
is a risk that the additional money is reinvested in increased fishing
capacity, or if there may be consumption, production or conserva-
tion leakages (transfer of the problem somewhere else), whether at
the vessel, fishery or trans-national level. High transactions costs
may also limit the benefits of incentives schemes. more effective in the longer run than direct economic incentives
(Clements et al., 2010). REFERENCES Alfaro-Shigueto, J., Dutton, P. H., & Mangel, J. (2007). Interactions
between leatherback turtles and Peruvian artisanal fisher-
ies. Chelonian Conservation and Biology, 6, 129–134. https://doi. org/10.2744/1071-8443(2007)6[129:ibltap]2.0.co;2 By-catch reduction measures have had significant successes
over the last decades, as a result of substantial investment of time
and funding by researchers, management authorities, conserva-
tion organizations and fishers (Cox et al., 2007). However, this suc-
cess is not universal. Just as for any fisheries management issue,
a poor regulatory regime, limited compliance and lack of informa-
tion hamper efforts to reduce by-catch. In some places, high levels
of by-catch, limited options for mitigation and weak governance
(leading to poor enforcement) can combine to make the by-catch
problem intractable. Our framework will not solve these problems. However, it brings together the full range of approaches for by-
catch mitigation in a structured and systematic way, which requires
a target to be expressed against which outcomes can be evaluated. By exposing areas of uncertainty and data deficiency, it could chal-
lenge scientists and managers to obtain the data required properly
to evaluate the effectiveness of mitigation measures. This could
then support and encourage clearer decision-making and prioriti-
zation of actions. Our framework demonstrates that the principle
of implementing the goal of no net loss through a mitigation hi-
erarchy is as applicable to marine megafauna by-catch as to ter-
restrial systems, where it is already widely used in challenging,
data-poor, circumstances. Alfaro-Shigueto, J., Mangel, J. C., Bernedo, F., Dutton, P. H., Seminoff,
J. A., & Godley, B. J. (2011). Small-scale fisheries of Peru: A major
sink for marine turtles in the Pacific. Journal of Applied Ecology, 48,
1432–1440. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2664.2011.02040.x Alfaro-Shigueto, J., Mangel, J. C., Pajuelo, M., Dutton, P. H., Seminoff,
J. A., & Godley, B. J. (2010). Where small can have a large im-
pact: Structure and characterization of small-scale fisheries in
Peru. Fisheries Research, 106, 8–17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. fishres.2010.06.004 Andraka, S., Mug, M., Hall, M., Pons, M., Pacheco, L., Parrales, M., …
Ortega, D. (2013). Circle hooks: Developing better fishing prac-
tices in the artisanal longline fisheries of the Eastern Pacific Ocean. Biological Conservation, 160, 214–224. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. biocon.2013.01.019 Apostolopoulou, E., & Adams, W. M. (2017). Biodiversity offsetting and
conservation: Reframing nature to save it. Oryx, 51, 23–31. https://
doi.org/10.1017/S0030605315000782 Báez, J. C., Real, R., García-Soto, C., José, M., Macías, D., & Camiñas, J. A. (2007). E J Milner-Gulland
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0324-2710 E J Milner-Gulland
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0324-2710 or new approaches such as offsets. However, in this context of dy-
namic uncertainty, the dividends of thinking more creatively about
by-catch mitigation could be high. by-catch mitigation approaches targeted at different species (Serafy
et al., 2012). Actions to mitigate by-catch for one group of spe-
cies can increase or decrease it for others, and so a system-wide
approach is needed. For example, changing from J-hooks to circle
hooks to reduce mortality of turtles may decrease or increase shark
mortality (Andraka et al., 2013; Godin, Carlson, & Burgener, 2012). In terrestrial systems, similar interactions arise, and value judge-
ments are made (whether explicitly or implicitly) as to what loss and
gain of “biodiversity” translates to in operational terms, and what
elements of biodiversity matter most to implementers. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS EJMG acknowledges the Pew Charitable Foundation for its sup-
port of this work. This article originated at a 2013 workshop co-
organized by NOAA-Fisheries and IUCN-CEEM-FEG, entitled
“Multidisciplinary Workshop to Address Ecosystem-Level Impacts of
Fisheries Bycatch on Marine Megafauna: Biodiversity Conservation
through Mitigation, Policy, Economic Instruments, and Technical
Change.” We thank the reviewers for their insightful comments
which much improved the manuscript. Uncertainty is high in ocean ecosystems, creating both chal-
lenges and opportunities in applying the concept of NNL through a
mitigation hierarchy that includes offsetting. In particular, for marine
megafauna, there is high uncertainty in the processes linking any el-
ement of the mitigation hierarchy through to changes in population
growth rate. Furthermore, impacts can be long-term, hard to mea-
sure and spatially diffuse, and uncertainty is not predictably spread
through the hierarchy. This creates a different set of challenges to
those faced in terrestrial systems, where at least for some types of
environmental impact, the links between action and impact are rel-
atively direct and measurable, and uncertainty generally increases
through the mitigation hierarchy (from avoid through minimize/re-
mediate to offset). ORCID E J Milner-Gulland
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0324-2710 6 | CONCLUSIONS Instituting catch shares (individual transferable quotas) may provide
an enabling environment for by-catch reduction, for example by pro-
moting more effective monitoring (Grimm et al., 2012). Experience
in terrestrial system produces similar insights; incentive-based
schemes which also build community cohesion and support the de-
velopment or strengthening of local management institutions, are Translating the framework from a species to an ecosystem level
will require consideration of the potential interactions between 12 MILNER-GULLAND et al. Conservation Biology, 28, 140–149. https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.12239 Caswell, H., Brault, S., Read, A. J., & Smith, T. D. (1998). Harbor
porpoise and fisheries: An uncertainty analysis of inciden-
tal mortality. Ecological Applications, 8, 1226–1238. https://doi. org/10.1890/1051-0761(1998)008[1226:hpafau]2.0.co;2 Godin, A. C., Carlson, J. K., & Burgener, V. (2012). The effect of circle
hooks on shark catchability and at-vessel mortality rates in long-
lines fisheries. Bulletin of Marine Science, 88, 469–483. https://doi. org/10.5343/bms.2011.1054 Clements, T., John, A., Nielsen, K., An, D., Tan, S., & Milner-Gulland, E. J. (2010). Payments for biodiversity conservation in the context of
weak institutions: Comparison of three programs from Cambodia. Ecological Economics, 69, 1283–1291. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. ecolecon.2009.11.010 Grimm, D., Barkhorn, I., Festa, D., Bonzon, K., Boomhower, J., Hovland,
V., & Blau, J. (2012). Assessing catch shares’ effects evidence
from Federal United States and associated British Columbian
fisheries. Marine Policy, 36, 644–657. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. marpol.2011.10.014 Cox, T., Lewison, R., Žydelis, R., Crowder, L., Safina, C., & Read, A. (2007). Comparing effectiveness of experimental and implemented bycatch
reduction measures: The ideal and the real. Conservation Biology, 21,
1155–1164. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.2007.00772.x Hall, M. A. (1996). On bycatches. Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries, 6,
319–352. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00122585 Croll, D. A., Dewar, H., Dulvy, N. K., Fernando, D., Francis, M. P., Galván-
Magaña, F., … Newton, K. M. (2016). Vulnerabilities and fisher-
ies impacts: The uncertain future of manta and devil rays. Aquatic
Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 26, 562–575. https://doi.org/10.1002/aqc.2591 Hall, M. A., Alverson, D. L., & Metuzals, K. I. (2000). By-catch: Problems
and solutions. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 41, 204–219. https://doi. org/10.1016/S0025-326X(00)00111-9 Hall, M. A., Nakano, H., Clarke, S., Thomas, S., Molloy, J., Peckham, S. H., … Hall, S. J. (2007). Working with fishers to reduce by-catches. In S. J. Kenelly (Ed.), By-catch reduction in the world’s fisheries (pp. 235–288). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. https://doi. org/10.1007/978-1-4020-6078-6_8 Damalas, D., & Vassilopoulou, V. (2013). Slack regulation com-
pliance in the Mediterranean fisheries: A paradigm from the
Greek Aegean Sea demersal trawl fishery, modelling discard
ogives. Fisheries Management and Ecology, 20, 21–33. https://doi. org/10.1111/j.1365-2400.2012.00860.x Hall, M., & Roman, M. (2013). Bycatch and non-tuna catch in the tropi-
cal tuna purse seine fisheries of the world. Fisheries and Aquaculture
Technical Paper, 568. Rome, Italy: FAO. Dutton, D. L., Dutton, P. H., Chaloupka, M., & Boulon, R. H. (2005). Increase
of a Caribbean leatherback turtle Dermochelys coriacea nesting pop-
ulation linked to long-term nest protection. Biological Conservation,
126, 186–194. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2005.05.013 Hall, M. Bull, J. W., & Brownlie, S. (2017). The transition from no net loss to a net
gain of biodiversity is far from trivial. Oryx, 51, 53–59. https://doi. org/10.1017/S0030605315000861 marine bycatch. PLoS ONE, 3, e2480. https://doi.org/10.1371/jour-
nal.pone.0002480 Fowler, S. J. (2016, January 5). Draft best practice mitigation guidelines for
sharks and rays taken in purse- seine and long-line fisheries. Convention
on Migratory Species. [pdf document] Retrieved from http://www.cms. int/sites/default/files/document/CMS_Sharks_CWG1_Doc_3_2.pdf Bull, J. W., Bryant, C., Baker, J., & Milner-Gulland, E. J. (2015, December
28). Developing, measuring and communicating the outcomes of cor-
porate biodiversity strategies. [pdf document] Retrieved from http://
www.wildbusiness.org/Bull_etal_2015_WBL.pdf es/default/files/document/CMS_Sharks_CWG1_Doc_3_2. Francis, M. P. (2014). Survival and depth distribution of spinetail devilrays
(Mobula japanica) released from purse-seine catches. NIWA Client
Report No: WLG2014-2. Wellington, New Zealand: Department of
Conservation. Bull, J. W., Gordon, A., Watson, J. E., & Maron, M. (2016). Seeking con-
vergence on the key concepts in ‘no net loss’ policy. Journal of Applied
Ecology, 53, 1686–1693. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.12726 Fulton, E. A., Smith, A. D., Smith, D. C., & van Putten, I. E. (2011). Human behaviour: The key source of uncertainty in fish-
eries management. Fish and Fisheries, 12, 2–17. https://doi. org/10.1111/j.1467-2979.2010.00371.x Bull, J. W., Hardy, M. J., Moilanen, A., & Gordon, A. (2015). Categories
of flexibility in biodiversity offsetting, and their implications for
conservation. Biological Conservation, 192, 522–532. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.biocon.2015.08.003 Bull, J. W., Lloyd, S. P., & Strange, N. (2017). Implementation gap be-
tween the theory and practice of biodiversity offset multipliers. Conservation Letters, https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.12335 Gardner, T. A., Hase, A., Brownlie, S., Ekstrom, J. M., Pilgrim, J. D., Savy,
C. E., … Ten Kate, K. (2013). Biodiversity offsets and the challenge of
achieving no net loss. Conservation Biology, 27, 1254–1264. https://
doi.org/10.1111/cobi.12118 Bull, J. W., Suttle, K. B., Gordon, A., Singh, N. J., & Milner-Gulland, E. J. (2013). Biodiversity offsets in theory and practice. Oryx, 47, 369–
380. https://doi.org/10.1017/S003060531200172X Gjertsen, H., Hall, M., & Squires, D. (2010). Incentives to address bycatch. In R. Allen, J. Joseph, & D. Squires (Eds.), Conservation and manage-
ment of transnational tuna fisheries (pp. 225–250). Ames, IA: Wiley-
Blackwell. https://doi.org/10.1002/9780813820262.ch14 Campbell, L. M., & Cornwell, M. L. (2008). Human dimensions of bycatch
reduction technology: Current assumptions and directions for fu-
ture research. Endangered Species Research, 5, 325–334. https://doi. org/10.3354/esr00172 Gjertsen, H., Squires, D., Dutton, P., & Eguchi, T. (2014). Cost-
effectiveness of alternative conservation strategies with application
to the Pacific Leatherback Turtle. REFERENCES Loggerhead turtle by-catch depends on distance to the coast,
independent of fishing effort: Implications for conservation and fish-
eries management. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 338, 249–256. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605315000782 BBOP (2012). Standard on biodiversity offsets. Business and biodiversity
offsets programme. Washington, DC: Forest Trends. Bishop, J. (2006). Standardizing fishery-dependent catch and ef-
fort data in complex fisheries with technology change. Reviews
in Fish Biology and Fisheries, 16, 21–38. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s11160-006-0004-9 There is untapped potential for cost-effective by-catch mitiga-
tion, which could be realized with the adoption of this framework,
and with consideration of new approaches to incentivizing by-catch
mitigation within the steps of the hierarchy. Applying it to a few case-
studies in practice will demonstrate empirically where and how the
potential for improved effectiveness could best be realized. Existing
legal frameworks often preclude approaches which implicitly or ex-
plicitly permit by-catch, including the use of economic incentives Boyce, J. (1996). An economic analysis of the fisheries bycatch problem. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 31, 314–336. https://doi.org/10.1006/jeem.1996.0047 Bugoni, L., Mancini, P. L., Monteiro, D. S., Nascimento, L., & Neves, T. S. (2008). Seabird bycatch in the Brazilian pelagic longline fishery and a
review of capture rates in the southwestern Atlantic Ocean. Endangered
Species Research, 5, 137–147. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00115 MILNER-GULLAND et al. 13 A review of corporate goals
of no net loss and net positive impact on biodiversity. Oryx, 49, 232–
238. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605313001476 Kormos, R., Kormos, C. F., Humle, T., Lanjouw, A., Rainer, H., Victurine,
R., … Williamson, E. A. (2014). Great apes and biodiversity offset
projects in Africa: The case for national offset strategies. PLoS ONE,
9(11), e111671. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0111671 Rausser, G. C., Hamilton, S. F., Kovach, M., & Stifter, R. (2009). Unintended consequences: The spillover effects of common prop-
erty regulations. Marine Policy, 33, 24–39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. marpol.2008.03.020 Kotchen, M. J. (2013). Voluntary and information-based approaches to
environmental management: A public economics perspective. Review
of Environmental Economics and Policy, 7(2), 276–295. https://doi. org/10.1093/reep/ret012 Rice, J. (2014). Evolution of international commitments for fisheries
sustainability. ICES Journal of Marine Science: Journal du Conseil, 71,
157–165. https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fst078 Kyriazi, Z., Lejano, R., Maes, F., & Degraer, S. (2015). Bargaining a net
gain compensation agreement between a marine renewable energy
developer and a marine protected area manager. Marine Policy, 60,
40–48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2015.06.005 Richard, Y., & Abraham, E. R. (2013). Application of Potential Biological
Removal methods to seabird populations. New Zealand Aquatic
Environment and Biodiversity Report, 108. Lent, R., & Squires, D. (2017). Reducing marine mammal bycatch in global
fisheries: An economics approach. Deep Sea Research Part II: Topical
Studies in Oceanography, 140, 268–277. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. dsr2.2017.03.005 Rode, J., Gómez-Baggethun, E., & Krause, T. (2015). Motivation crowd-
ing by economic incentives in conservation policy: A review of the
empirical evidence. Ecological Economics, 117, 270–282. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2014.11.019 Lewison, R. L., Crowder, L. B., Read, A. J., & Freeman, S. A. (2004). Understanding impacts of fisheries bycatch on marine megafauna. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 19, 598–604. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. tree.2004.09.004 Rogers, A. A. (2013). Social welfare and marine reserves: Is willingness to
pay for conservation dependent on management process? A discrete
choice experiment of the Ningaloo Marine Park in Australia. Canadian
Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue Canadienne D’agroeconomie,
61, 217–238. https://doi.org/10.1111/cjag.12008 Mann, C. (2015). Strategies for sustainable policy design: Constructive
assessment of biodiversity offsets and banking. Ecosystem Services,
16, 266–274. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoser.2015.07.001 Rosenberg, A. A., & McLeod, K. L. (2005). Implementing ecosystem-
based approaches to management for the conservation of ecosystem
services. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 300, 270–274. https://doi. org/10.3354/meps300270 Marine Stewardship Council (2014, June 21). MSC fisheries certifica-
tion requirements v2.0. [pdf doc] https://www.msc.org/documents/
scheme-documents/fisheries-certification-scheme-documents/
fisheries-certification-requirements-version-2.0 Segerson, K. (2010). Can voluntary programs reduce sea turtle by-
catch? Insights from the literature in environmental economics. Ecology and Management, 17, 15–33. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s11273-008-9093-7 Ecology and Management, 17, 15–33. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s11273-008-9093-7 Orphanides, C. D., & Palka, D. L. (2013). Analysis of harbor porpoise gill-
net bycatch, compliance, and enforcement trends in the US north-
western Atlantic, January 1999 to May 2010. Endangered Species
Research, 20, 251–269. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00499 IATTC (2015). Resolution on the conservation of mobulid rays caught in as-
sociation with fisheries in the IATTC convention area. Inter-American
Tropical Tuna Commission 89th Annual Meeting, Resolution C-15-
04. La Jolla, CA: Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission. Pascoe, S., Innes, J., Holland, D., Finas, M., Thébaud, O., Townsend,
R., … Hutton, T. (2010). Use of incentive-based management
systems to limit bycatch and discarding. International Review of
Environmental and Resource Economics, 4, 123–161. https://doi. org/10.1561/101.00000032 04. La Jolla, CA: Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission IFC (2012). Performance standard 6. Biodiversity conservation and sustain-
able management of natural resources. January 1, 2012. Washington,
DC: International Finance Corporation. Innes, J., Pascoe, S., Wilcox, C., Jennings, S., & Paredes, S. (2015). Mitigating undesirable impacts in the marine environment: A review
of market-based management measures. Frontiers in Marine Science,
2, 76. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2015.00076 Phalan, B., Hayes, G., Brooks, S., Marsh, D., Howard, P., Costelloe, B.,
… Whitaker, S. (2017). Avoiding impacts on biodiversity through
strengthening the first stage of the mitigation hierarchy. Oryx,
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605316001034 Jannise, C., Squires, D., Seminoff, J., & Dutton, P. (2010). Conservation
investments and mitigation: The California drift gillnet fishery and
pacific sea turtles. In R. Q. Grafton, R. Hilborn, D. Squires, M. Tait,
& M. J. Williams (Eds.), Handbook of marine fisheries conservation and
management (pp. 231–240). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Quétier, F., Regnery, B., & Levrel, H. (2014). No net loss of biodiver-
sity or paper offsets? A critical review of the French no net loss
policy. Environmental Science & Policy, 38, 120–131. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.envsci.2013.11.009 Radzio, T. A., Smolinsky, J. A., & Roosenburg, W. M. (2013). Low use of re-
quired terrapin bycatch reduction devices in a recreational crab pot
fishery. Herpetological Conservation and Biology, 8, 222–227. Jones, E., & Francis, M. (2012). Protected rays – Occurrence and devel-
opment of mitigation methods in the New Zealand tuna purse seine
fishery. Auckland, New Zealand: National Institute of Water and
Atmospheric Research. Rainey, H. J., Pollard, E. H. B., Dutson, G., Ekstrom, J. M., Livingstone, S. R., Temple, H. J., & Pilgrim, J. D. (2015). 14 | 14 MILNER-GULLAND et al. 14 | 14 A., Swimmer, Y., & Parga, M. (2012). No “silver bullets”, but plenty
of options: Working with the eastern pacific artisanal fishers to re-
duce sea turtle mortality in fisheries. In J. A. Seminoff, & B. Wallace
(Eds.), Sea turtles of the eastern pacific: Advances in research and con-
servation (pp. 136–153). Tucson, AZ: University of Arizona Press. Dutton, P., Joseph, J., Squires, D., & Williams, M. (2011). Bellagio blue-
print for action on sea turtles. Chapter 2. In P. Dutton, D. Squires,
& M. Ahmed (Eds.), Conservation of pacific sea turtles (pp. 15–36). Honolulu, HI: University of Hawaii Press. Hamner, R. M., Wade, P., Oremus, M., Stanley, M., Brown, P., Constantine,
R., & Baker, C. S. (2014). Critically low abundance and limits to
human-related mortality for the Maui’s dolphin. Endangered Species
Research, 26, 87–92. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00621 Dutton, P., & Squires, D. (2008). A holistic strategy for Pacific sea tur-
tle recovery. Ocean Development and International Law, 39, 200–222. https://doi.org/10.1080/00908320802013685 Hatch, S. A. (2003). Statistical power for detecting trends with applica-
tions to seabird monitoring. Biological Conservation, 111, 317–329. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3207(02)00301-4 FAO (2011, January 5). International guidelines on bycatch manage-
ment and reduction of discards. Rome, Italy: Food and Agriculture
Organisation. [pdf document] Retrieved from http://www.fao.org/
docrep…t/ba0022t00.pdf Heppell, S. S., Crowder, L. B., & Crouse, D. T. (1996). Models to evaluate
headstarting as a management tool for long-lived turtles. Ecological
Applications, 6, 556–565. https://doi.org/10.2307/2269391 Finkelstein, M., Bakker, V., Doak, D. F., Sullivan, B., Lewison, R.,
Satterthwaite, W. H., … Henry, R. W. (2008). Evaluating the po-
tential effectiveness of compensatory mitigation strategies for Hough, P., & Robertson, M. (2009). Mitigation under Section 404 of the
Clean Water Act: Where it comes from, what it means. Wetlands In
R. Q. Grafton, R. Hilborn, D. Squires, M. Tait, & M. J. Williams (Eds.),
Handbook of marine fisheries conservation and management (pp. 618–
629). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Maron, M., Ives, C. D., Kujala, H., Bull, J. W., Maseyk, F. J., Bekessy, S.,
… Possingham, H. P. (2016). Taming a wicked problem: Resolving
controversies in biodiversity offsetting. BioScience, 66(6), 489–498. https://doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biw038 Serafy, J. E., Cooke, S. J., Diaz, G. A., Graves, J. E., Hall, M., Shivji, M.,
& Swimmer, Y. (2012). Circle hooks in commercial, recreational, and
artisanal fisheries: Research status and needs for improved conser-
vation and management. Bulletin of Marine Science, 88, 371–391. https://doi.org/10.5343/bms.2012.1038 Maxwell, S. L., Milner-Gulland, E. J., Jones, J. P., Knight, A. T., Bunnefeld,
N., Nuno, A., … Rhodes, J. R. (2015). Being smart about SMART envi-
ronmental targets. Science, 347, 1075–1076. https://doi.org/10.1126/
science.aaa1451 Moilanen, A., Van Teeffelen, A. J., Ben-Haim, Y., & Ferrier, S. (2009). How much compensation is enough? A framework for incorporat-
ing uncertainty and time discounting when calculating offset ratios
for impacted habitat. Restoration Ecology, 17, 470–478. https://doi. org/10.1111/j.1526-100X.2008.00382.x Shiode, D., Hu, F., Shiga, M., Yokota, K., & Tokai, T. (2005). Midwater
float system for standardizing hook depths on tuna longlines to re-
duce sea turtle by-catch. Fisheries Science, 71, 1182–1184. https://
doi.org/10.1111/j.1444-2906.2005.01080.x Sims, M., Cox, T., & Lewison, R. (2008). Modeling spatial patterns
in fisheries bycatch: Improving bycatch maps to aid fisheries
management. Ecological Applications, 18, 649–661. https://doi. org/10.1890/07-0685.1 Morar, N., Toadvine, T., & Bohannan, B. J. (2015). Biodiversity at twenty-
five years: Revolution or red herring? Ethics, Policy & Environment, 18,
16–29. https://doi.org/10.1080/21550085.2015.1018380 MILNER-GULLAND et al. 15 Squires, D., & Garcia, S. M. (2014). Ecosystem-level impacts of fisheries
bycatch on marine megafauna: Biodiversity conservation through miti-
gation, policy, economic instruments, and technical change. Report of
the IUCN-CEM-FEG Scientific workshop, Gland, Switzerland, 7–10
October 2013. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN. the critically endangered Tristan albatrosses on Gough Island. Biological Conservation, 142, 1710–1718. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. biocon.2009.03.008 Ward, P., Lawrence, E., Darbyshire, R., & Hindmarsh, S. (2008). Large-
scale experiment shows that nylon leaders reduce shark bycatch
and benefit pelagic longline fishers. Fisheries Research, 90, 100–108. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2007.09.034 Squires, D., & Garcia, S. M. (in press). Fisheries bycatch in marine ecosys-
tems: Policy, economic instruments and technical change. Chichester,
UK: J. Wiley & Sons. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2007.09.034 Ward, T., & Phillips, B. (2010). Seafood ecolabeling. In R. Q. Grafton, R. Hilborn, D. Squires, M. Tait, & M. J. Williams (Eds.), Handbook of ma-
rine fisheries conservation and management (pp. 608–617). Oxford,
UK: Oxford University Press. Swimmer, Y., Arauz, R., McCracken, M., McNaughton, L., Ballestero, J.,
Musyl, M., … Brill, R. (2006). Diving behavior and delayed mortality of
olive ridley sea turtles Lepidochelys olivacea after their release from
longline fishing gear. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 323, 253–261. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps323253 Wilcox, C., & Donlan, C. J. (2007). Compensatory mitigation as a solu-
tion to fisheries bycatch-biodiversity conservation conflicts. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 5, 325–331. https://doi. org/10.1890/1540-9295(2007)5[325:cmaast]2.0.co;2 Tolotti, M. T., Filmalter, J. D., Bach, P., Travassos, P., Seret, B., & Dagorn,
L. (2015). Banning is not enough: The complexities of oceanic shark
management by tuna regional fisheries management organizations. Global Ecology and Conservation, 4, 1–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. gecco.2015.05.003 Wilcox, C., & Donlan, C. J. (2009). Need for a clear and fair evaluation
of biodiversity offsets for fisheries bycatch. Conservation Biology, 23,
770–772. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.2009.01173.x Tuck, G. N., Polacheck, T., & Bulman, C. M. (2003). Spatio-temporal
trends of longline fishing effort in the Southern Ocean and implica-
tions for seabird bycatch. Biological Conservation, 114, 1–27. https://
doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3207(02)00378-6 Wolf, S., Hartl, B., Carroll, C., Neel, M. C., & Greenwald, D. N. (2015). Beyond PVA: Why recovery under the Endangered Species Act is
more than population viability. BioScience, 65, 200–207. https://doi. org/10.1093/biosci/biu218 doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3207(02)00378-6 UNEP-WCMC (2016). Marine no net loss: A feasibility assessment of imple-
menting no net loss of biodiversity in the sea. Cambridge, UK: United
Nations Environment Programme. Zedler, J. B., & Callaway, J. C. (1999). Tracking wetland restoration: Do
mitigation sites follow desired trajectories? Restoration Ecology, 7,
69–73. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1526-100X.1999.07108.x Vaissière, A.-C., Levrel, H., Pioch, S., & Carlier, A. (2014). Biodiversity
offsets for offshore wind farm projects: The current situation in
Europe. Marine Policy, 48, 172–183. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. marpol.2014.03.023 Žydelis, R., Wallace, B. P., Gilman, E. L., & Werner, T. B. (2009). Conservation of marine megafauna through minimization of fish-
eries bycatch. Conservation Biology, 23, 608–616. https://doi. org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.2009.01172.x Wallace, B. P., Heppell, S. S., Lewison, R. L., Kelez, S., & Crowder,
L. B. (2008). Impacts of fisheries bycatch on loggerhead tur-
tles
worldwide
inferred
from
reproductive
value
analy-
ses. Journal of Applied Ecology, 45, 1076–1085. https://doi. org/10.1111/j.1365-2664.2008.01507.x How to cite this article: Milner-Gulland EJ, Garcia S, Arlidge W,
et al. Translating the terrestrial mitigation hierarchy to marine
megafauna by-catch. Fish Fish. 2018;00:1–15. https://doi.org/10.1111/faf.12273 Wanless, R. M., Ryan, P. G., Altwegg, R., Angel, A., Cooper, J.,
Cuthbert, R., & Hilton, G. M. (2009). From both sides: Dire de-
mographic consequences of carnivorous mice and longlining for
|
https://openalex.org/W4287728638
|
https://zenodo.org/records/6242441/files/Digital%20Identity%20Management-%20A%20key%20factor%20on%20the%20pursuit%20of%20privacy%20and%20the%20fight%20against%20cybercrime.pdf
|
English
| null |
Digital Identity Management: a key factor on the pursuit of privacy and the fight against cybercrime (Draft version)
|
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
| 2,020
|
cc-by
| 8,675
|
DIGITAL IDENTITY MANAGEMENT: A KEY FACTOR ON THE
PURSUIT OF PRIVACY AND THE FIGHT AGAINST
CYBERCRIME Mª Cristina Timón López, Julián Valero Torrijos, Ignacio Alamillo Domingo
(More information to complete after the review process) ABSTRACT: The increasing number of actions that take place in the cyberspace, replacing traditional
processes based on physical presence, has led to the transformation of identity management systems
accordingly to the challenges raised by digitalisation. In this context, the emergence of a digital identity
has arisen new specifications for identification processes that have been mostly covered by identity
providers, who play a key role for individuals’ identification in Information Society. These providers have
become a focus of cyberattacks aimed to steal the personal data stored by thereof, or to directly
impersonate their users. Notwithstanding the fact that identity related crime is wide spreading through
different techniques in a global scale, the services provided, as well as the providers offering them, lack
of a comprehensive regulation. In addition, traditional delegated identity management systems suffer
from excessive data collection and centralization of information, as well as deficient security measures
for ensuring data privacy. The University of Murcia has already participated in a previous research project concerning these
issues, H2020 ARIES,1 and has continued the study through the coordination of H2020 OLYMPUS
project.2 These projects aim to hinder identity theft by increasing security through stronger mechanisms
for verifying user’s identity before providing authentication (e.g. biometrics) or adding a higher level of
security for users’ credentials by implementing a novel architecture based on identity provider
virtualisation and password disaggregation. This paper aims to develop the legal grounds for the
technologies proposed by the abovementioned EU projects, with particular attention to existing
regulations, such as the GDPR or eIDAS, which may constitute the basis for developing a specific
regulation for these new privacy-enhanced identification systems. Reusing the eIDAS Regulation
security and interoperability rules would allow the recognition of these enhanced identity management
services in the whole European Union, contributing to the Digital Single Market objective. EYWORDS: Digital Identity, Identity Management, Identity Theft, Data Protection, eIDAS Regula 1 https://www.aries-project.eu/ (Grant Agreement 700085)
2 https://olympus-project.eu/(Grant Agreement 786725) 3 For example, the bank BBVA has its own identification system, offering different authentication methods
(credentials, biometrics, double factor…), depending on the online banking service the client is trying to access.
Particularly, banks have focused on the challenge of verifying user’s real identity at the moment of opening a new
account through different mechanisms (videocall, ID document scanning…). All these processes are managed by
the bank IdM services, instead of relying on an external legal entity. See, inter alia, the following site:
https://www.bbva.es/en/finanzas-vistazo/tu-guia-bbva/cuentas/metodos-identificacion.html#video-call Introduction Widespreading digitalization of society has arisen the need to identify individuals through
networks as a building block for guaranteeing those movements or transactions which take
place online. For that purpose, different models or systems for identity management (hereafter
IdM) have emerged, often harming individuals’ right to privacy and arising new legal issues. Data protection regulations, and particularly the General Data Protection Regulation (hereafter
GDPR), have not been oblivious to the problems triggered by technological advances in the
Information Society, forecasting legal tools designed to assess and, if necessary, conduct or
limit innovations. On the other hand, information and communication technologies have brought new
possibilities to carry out conducts with criminal implications. In this sense, criminals have
modernized their activities and have made use of the possibilities offered by the cyberspace
in which each individual becomes at the same time sender and receiver "almost
instantaneously" in diffuse territorial boundaries [24]. 1 1 More specifically, a large majority of digital crimes are related to identity theft [29] and the
methods for their commission have been refined [23]. Nevertheless, unlike traditional identity
theft, committed by physical means, the theft of the digital identity is integrated in the innovative
discipline of the cyber criminology [28]. Hence, the fight against digital identity related crime
require a multidisciplinary approach, involving the collaboration of technical, legal and social
experts in order to assess the problem, propose solutions and in a last stage, validate them. The aim of this paper is not only to offer some background regarding the relation between the
design of IdM systems and the prevention of identity theft, but also to introduce a practical
example of how two specific H2020 European research projects in the area (ARIES and
OLYMPUS) propose different solutions in order to tackle the problem. In addition, besides
giving a comprehensible explanation of the solutions proposed, we will focus on their legal
implications, particularly how they prevent identity theft, but also which other legal concerns
may arise (i.e. the impact on Data Protection and eIDAS regulations). 1. Identity Management: a new building block in the Information Society The concept of digital identity refers to a set of attributes (or personal data), which allow to
clearly identify a person through an authentication process in those movements that take place
online [9]. In so far as our identity is composed by a collection of attributes that might be
combined and disaggregated in different environments in support of authentication processes,
the role developed by the certification entities becomes essential [39]. Considering the entity
providing the service, two main models might be concluded: [10] a) In-house digital identities refer to those which allow us to interact with the person or
organization that has provided us with them. In this scenario there is not a sole legal entity, but
the identification services work as an “in house service.” This is common in the case of financial
entities, which normally rely on their own identification systems.3 Figure 1.1. IdM in-house service model
(Source: Authors, 2020)
IdM services
e.g. maintenance services
User/Customer
e.g. procurement services User/Customer Figure 1.1. IdM in-house service model
(Source: Authors, 2020) b) Delegated or outsourced identities refers to those identities which allow us to interact
with organizations or entities different to the ones that have provided us with them. In
this scenario, we find separated legal entities whose relations might have a statutory
or a contractual basis. In the first case we refer to the identity federation regulated by
eIDAS, in which each Member State acts as an IdP (hereafter the IdP), but also admits
and recognizes other Member States as IdPs. Regarding the second case, we would 2 be in the scenario of private legal entities, that establish their relations through a single,
or multiple contracts. Hence, a legal entity, the IdP, provides with IdM services to a
different legal entity, the Service Provider (hereafter the SP). This is the most common
authentication method as it facilitates authentication in different places by using the
same credentials, through a standardized delegated authentication process (i.e. Single
Sign-On Solutions). Figure 1.2 Delegated IdM model
(Source: Authors, 2020)
SP
IdP
1. Requires for user’s
authentication
4. Issues the required
attributes
6. Provides the service
2.Requirement of authentication before the SP
3.The IdP provides proof of requested attributes
5. Identity provider confirms
proof of attributes (not in all
cases
but
the
most
common) 2.Requirement of authentication before the SP
3.The IdP provides proof of requested attributes 1. Requires for user’s
authentication
4. 4 That’s however a different problem we are not going to discuss in this paper. Indeed, privileged position of the
IdPs to control users’ movements online might arise essential concerns regarding individuals right to privacy and
data protection. There is a lot of bibliography discussing this issue as it might be Mitsilegas V. “Surveillance and
Digital privacy in the Transatlantic War on Terror: The Case for a Global Privacy Regime” in Columbia Human
Rights Law Review no.47 or Neil M. Richards, “The Dangers of Surveillance.” Harvard Law Review, vol.126, no.7.
5 Search engine consists on the use of the power of search engines to collect information (personal data, emails,
credit cards...) in order to, among other possibilities, impersonate the user at a later stage. See, inter alia, the
following site: https://techterms.com/definition/searchengine, 1. Identity Management: a new building block in the Information Society Issues the required
attributes
6. Provides the service 5. Identity provider confirms
proof of attributes (not in all
cases
but
the
most
common) Figure 1.2 Delegated IdM model
(Source: Authors, 2020) Furthermore, regarding this second scenario we can distinguish between centralized and
federated IdM systems. In the first one there is a sole IdP, while in federated IdM user can
access different services by using a single credential, among multiple credential providers (e.g. Facebook, Google, Amazon…). The first model main drawback is that there is a sole
intermediary for all user’s movements online.4 Nevertheless, “centralization” is a common
problem for both IdM models (i.e. centralized or federated), as user’s data always appear
regrouped in a single IdP, affecting data security [34] and exposed, among other forms of
cybercrime, to identity theft. 6 Web scraping consist in the practice of looking for personal information in plain text, unduly forgotten between
the programming language. See, inter alia, the following site: tps://techterms.com/definition/scraping
7 A spoofing attack takes place when a malicious party impersonates another device or user on a network in order
to launch attacks against network hosts, steal data, spread malware or bypass access controls. ... Some of the p
g
,
craping consist in the practice of looking for personal information in plain text, unduly forgotten between
amming language. See, inter alia, the following site: tps://techterms.com/definition/scraping p
g
g
g
g
,
,
g
p
p g
7 A spoofing attack takes place when a malicious party impersonates another device or user on a network in order
to launch attacks against network hosts, steal data, spread malware or bypass access controls. ... Some of the g
p
g
6 Web scraping consist in the practice of looking for personal information in plain text, unduly forgotten between
the programming language. See, inter alia, the following site: tps://techterms.com/definition/scraping
7 A spoofing attack takes place when a malicious party impersonates another device or user on a network in order
to launch attacks against network hosts steal data spread malware or bypass access controls
Some of the 2. Improving IdM in the fight against cybercrime Criminals have taken advantage of possibilities offered by the online identification systems to
gain access to individuals’ personal data and probably impersonate them at a later stage. One
of the most common methods to commit identity theft was stealing the computer or other
storage device, something that today lacks efficiency considering complex data encryption
processes. Indeed, nowadays common techniques used in order to steal users’ identities
consist in hacking practices [32], or cracker attacks that look for an abusive access into a
system. Another widely used techniques are search engine,5 web scraping,6 spoofing,7 or 3 spywares.8 In addition, social engineering, such as phishing, smishing, vishing 9 or pharming
10 also represent a considerable percentage of attacks aimed to steal personal data [15]. On the other hand, attacks to digital identity do not limit to a specific conduct, but they can
materialize in different forms distinguishing between identity theft, identity abuse and identity
fraud.11 In addition, authentication processes usually involve the issuance of “proofs” which
normally materialize in form of tokens.12 These tokens are presented at the time of a
transaction, hence the person making use of it assumes the right to exclusive use thereof [44]. Consequently, attacks focused on the token’s issuance processes must also be taken into
account when considering IdM systems vulnerabilities before identity related crime. Furthermore, it should be noted that identity theft includes or requires different actions. First, it
implies an abusive access to computer systems, the data interception and finally the use of
these data. The actions of access and use have commonly been punished in most of the
States’ criminal rulings, existing a “grey area” regarding the data possession. However, latest
privacy concerns have also covered the unlawful possession and transfer of data as a
punishable conduct [38]. This is consistent with social developments in privacy issues, so theft
is not limited to economic data (e.g. bank’s information), but it includes all those referring to an
individual which affect his privacy [11]. IdM tend to evolve in the light of an improved prevention from such attacks, at the time a higher
degree of compliance with Data Protection Regulations is achieved, considering both, the legal
and technical concepts of privacy [43]. Different techniques of encryption are used in order to
assure privacy in case of loss or theft of physic equipment, fulfilling what established in article
32.1.a) of the GDPR among other legal provisions. most common methods include IP address spoofing attacks (or web spoofing), ARP spoofing attacks and DNS
server spoofing attacks. See, inter alia, the following site: https://techterms.com/definition/spoofing
8 The spyware consists on a software that spies a computer so it might capture information such as usernames
and passwords. See, inter alia, the following site: https://techterms.com/definition/spyware
9 Phishing consists on the fraudulent practice of sending emails or another kind of messages (e.g. it might
consist in just displaying fraudulent information on your computer screen) pretending being from reputable
companies or acquaintances in order to induce individuals to reveal personal information, such as passwords
and credit card numbers. The term smishing is used in those cases that this practice is carried out through text
messages, and vishing in case of phone calls or voice messaged. See, inter alia, the following sites:
https://techterms.com/definition/phishing https://techterms.com/definition/smishing
10 Pharming consists on the practice of installing a malicious code on a personal computer or server to misdirect
users to fraudulent websites without their knowledge or consent. It is considered as a form of phishing. See, inter
alia, the following site: https://techterms.com/definition/pharming
11 Following definitions given by institutions such as the UK Home Office Identity Fraud Steering, Cifas or the
Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice of the United Nations, we can conclude that “identity theft”
refers to an unauthorized appropriation of identification information, while “identity abuse” consists on the
unauthorized use of other’s identity, and “identity fraud” adds to this unauthorized access the aim to obtain goods
or contract services.
12 An access token can be defined in the context of an authentication processes a set of information that constitutes
an
individual’s
identity
for
transactional
purposes
See,
inter
alia,
the
following
site:
https://developers.facebook.com/docs/facebook-login/access-tokens/?locale=es_LA most common methods include IP address spoofing attacks (or web spoofing), ARP spoofing attacks and DNS
server spoofing attacks. See, inter alia, the following site: https://techterms.com/definition/spoofing
8 The spyware consists on a software that spies a computer so it might capture information such as usernames
and passwords. See, inter alia, the following site: https://techterms.com/definition/spyware
9 Phishing consists on the fraudulent practice of sending emails or another kind of messages (e.g. it might
consist in just displaying fraudulent information on your computer screen) pretending being from reputable
companies or acquaintances in order to induce individuals to reveal personal information, such as passwords
and credit card numbers. The term smishing is used in those cases that this practice is carried out through text
messages, and vishing in case of phone calls or voice messaged. See, inter alia, the following sites:
https://techterms com/definition/phishing https://techterms com/definition/smishing 2. Improving IdM in the fight against cybercrime In this sense, controllers are obliged to determine in cases of theft or data leakage
(articles2(2), 4(7), 4(12), 33, 34 and 83(4) 4.7 of the GDPR), which data have been
compromised, and communicate such information to the subjects of the processing in a clear
and precise manner, indicating the nature of the conduct, the time and content of the
compromised data. Important latest research in the area have focused on the development of highly resilient
architectures against direct attacks or in a radical change in the way IdM has been understood
until the moment (e.g. self-sovereign identity proposals) [48]. This paper focus on the first
aspect, the development of a strongly resistant architecture before attacks aimed to
impersonate the user by the design of new architecture systems, which also imply a
comprehensive study in legal terms in order to conduct or limit such inventions, in the light of
the compliance with the European principles and regulations. Important latest research in the area have focused on the development of highly resilient
architectures against direct attacks or in a radical change in the way IdM has been understood
until the moment (e.g. self-sovereign identity proposals) [48]. This paper focus on the first
aspect, the development of a strongly resistant architecture before attacks aimed to
impersonate the user by the design of new architecture systems, which also imply a
comprehensive study in legal terms in order to conduct or limit such inventions, in the light of
the compliance with the European principles and regulations. 2. Improving IdM in the fight against cybercrime Similarly, double storages or replicated
information is avoided, at the time term of storage is limited in order to enhance data
minimization principle (articles 5.1. section c) and 25.1 of the GDPR among others). In addition,
Data Protection Authorities as well as private intermediaries in the area develop an important
task for individuals concern in choosing strong passwords [31] or systems with two-factor
authentication mechanisms, as well as avoiding data collectors on the internet. Likewise, considering that one of the major problems of identity theft is its belated detection by
the user, some mechanisms such as Firefox Monitor or Google leaked-password checker are
gaining importance, enhancing internet users’ capacity of managing and safeguarding their
online privacy, which in turn, minimize the possible harm of online risks [30]. On the other side,
data controllers play an essential role in preventing or at least limiting the effects of identity 11 Following definitions given by institutions such as the UK Home Office Identity Fraud Steering, Cifas or the
Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice of the United Nations, we can conclude that “identity theft”
refers to an unauthorized appropriation of identification information, while “identity abuse” consists on the
unauthorized use of other’s identity, and “identity fraud” adds to this unauthorized access the aim to obtain goods
or contract services. 11 Following definitions given by institutions such as the UK Home Office Identity Fraud Steering, Cifas or the
Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice of the United Nations, we can conclude that “identity theft”
refers to an unauthorized appropriation of identification information, while “identity abuse” consists on the
unauthorized use of other’s identity, and “identity fraud” adds to this unauthorized access the aim to obtain goods
or contract services. 12 An access token can be defined in the context of an authentication processes a set of information that constitutes
an
individual’s
identity
for
transactional
purposes
See,
inter
alia,
the
following
site:
https://developers.facebook.com/docs/facebook-login/access-tokens/?locale=es_LA 12 An access token can be defined in the context of an authentication processes a set of information that constitutes
an
individual’s
identity
for
transactional
purposes
See,
inter
alia,
the
following
site:
https://developers.facebook.com/docs/facebook-login/access-tokens/?locale=es_LA 12 An access token can be defined in the context of an authentication processes a set of information that constitutes
an
individual’s
identity
for
transactional
purposes
See,
inter
alia,
the
following
site:
https://developers.facebook.com/docs/facebook-login/access-tokens/?locale=es_LA 4 theft [33]. 3. Main drawbacks of traditional IdPs 5 Following the methodology given for conducting a risk analysis (Risk = likelihood x impact) [42]
in a Data Protection Impact Assessment (hereafter DPIA) [26], we would obtain important risks
regarding traditional IdPs architecture design: Following the methodology given for conducting a risk analysis (Risk = likelihood x impact) [42]
in a Data Protection Impact Assessment (hereafter DPIA) [26], we would obtain important risks
regarding traditional IdPs architecture design: Risk of identity theft: likelihood of identity theft (relevant) x impact of identity theft (maximum)
Data theft: likelihood of data theft (relevant) x impact of data theft (variable)
Depending on security
measures implemented,
but in any case, it just
requires compromising
an IdP Risk of identity theft: likelihood of identity theft (relevant) x impact of identity the Depending on security
measures implemented,
but in any case, it just
requires compromising
an IdP Data theft: likelihood of data theft (relevant) x impact of data theft (variable) Depending on security
measures implemented,
but also of the risk of
data theft
Depending on the
affected data (type of
access and nature of
the data leaked) Depending on security
measures implemented,
but also of the risk of
data theft From this perspective there is a clear link between identity theft and data theft, or in other
words, criminal and privacy issues. Data theft becomes in many cases a consequence of
identity theft, hence by limiting this first attack possibilities of data theft would also be reduced. Equally, possibilities of identity theft can be reduced by ensuring privacy rules compliance,
particularly but not limited to data minimization and proportionality principles. According to the
first one, the data stored by the IdP would be pertinent and limited to the strictly necessary
purposes for which they were collected [40], that is to say, a forthcoming authentication
process. In addition, proportionality principle envisages that the measures implemented should
not exceed what it is necessary to achieve the purposes or objectives of the processing [20],
hence not only the amount of the data stored, but also the adopted actions affecting this data
(e.g. the use of encryption techniques, duplicated databases…) must be considered. Finally, regarding the service, in this architecture design user will require at every moment the
availability of the IdP in order to proceed in his authentication, so there is also a high chance
of system failure. 3. Main drawbacks of traditional IdPs Traditional delegated authentication IdM systems (centralized or federated) share a common
vulnerability: they appear as a single point of failure or attack [49]. Consequently,
cybercriminals focus their actions on a sole objective, the IdP, which once compromised, will
allow the attacker to gain access to the personal data stored in its databases or even
impersonate the user in all the services connected [50]. This task becomes easier since all
these legal entities act as guarantor of users’ credentials for authentication processes [16],
usually lacking appropriate (or at least enough) safeguards to protect passwords from
cybercriminal attacks. More specifically, in this scenario identity theft might be committed by two main different
conducts: More specifically, in this scenario identity theft might be committed by two main different
conducts: a) By attacking the IdP databases in order to steal users’ password and then sign on
in the service pretending to be the authorized user. a) By attacking the IdP databases in order to steal users’ password and then sign on
in the service pretending to be the authorized user. g
b) By compromising the IdP through some form of malicious attack and issuing tokens
for the cybercriminal authentication. b) By compromising the IdP through some form of malicious attack and issuing tokens
for the cybercriminal authentication. Figure 3.1. Traditional IdP in Single Sign-On scenario before identity theft
(Source: Authors, 2020)
IdP
Token
SP
SP
SP Figure 3.1. Traditional IdP in Single Sign-On scenario before identity theft
(Source: Authors, 2020) Note that both conducts also apply in a scenario of data theft: a) The attacker can directly steal users’ personal data by compromising those
databases where they are stored. a) The attacker can directly steal users’ personal data by compromising those
databases where they are stored. b) The attacker can also access all user’s personal data by impersonating them,
hence once he has authenticated, he would gain access to the user’s account and
therefore to all his personal information. 4.1. ARIES approach The project ARIES (conducted between the years 2016-2018) presented an innovative
authentication mechanism at that moment: the use of biometrics. For that purpose, the user
has to perform in a first stage a biometric enrolment (i.e. facial or voice enrollment) for in a
later moment, perform a live acquisition of his biometric feature to compare it with the
information previously stored [2]. Furthermore, ARIES had foreseen two different use cases. The first one was an e-commerce
scenario in which the user attempts to buy products in a website performing authentication and
if necessary, a live biometric authentication on his mobile device. The second one refers to an
airport passport control scenario, where the possibility for passengers to use this
authentication method at the boarding gate by performing a live biometric test at the camera
and screen of the boarding terminal system had been envisaged. Then, the user will share the
biometric token stored in the smartphone obtained during enrolment leaked to his real identity 6 (e.g. to his national identity document) to the biometric verifier service deployed in the boarding
terminal for their comparison. This technique could also be deployed in order to confirm the
user has a valid boarding pass for shopping at the terminal or even to check his age without
disclosing any additional personal data [3]. Biometric authentication systems allow recognition of an individual by considering his
biological or behavioral features. The main advantage of biometrics is that they are unique and
personal, enabling strong authentication [13]. However, it must be noted that these
characteristics are permanent and cannot be renewed, therefore the process itself needs to
be properly handled to avoid biometric data leakage, representing a potential security threat. Nevertheless, risks of theft are significantly less than other authentication methods (e.g. passwords), as it normally requires a personal knowledge of the person aiming to impersonate,
as well as an appropriate method to replicate this physical feature [22]. Biometric data are however included by article 9.1 of the GDPR among the special category
of personal data. Therefore, its processing shall not be permitted unless one of the
circumstances envisaged in section two of the article applies. 4.1. ARIES approach Moreover, considering the high
risks inherently attached to the processing of biometric data, the conduction of a DPIA will be
mandatory in many cases to justify the proportionality of using this data instead of a different
mechanism which might imply a lower risk [36]. In the case of the project ARIES, to minimize these privacy concerns, biometric information
required during enrollment process was stored at the user’s mobile device. Equally, during
authentication process, data are discarded afterwards, just storing an audit log in order to fulfill
the Law Enforcement Authorities requirements [4]. 4.2. OLYMPUS approach The project OLYMPUS (envisaged between the years 2018-2021) has introduced a new
architecture design for delegated IdM: the IdP virtualization or the virtual IdP (hereafter vIdP). More specifically, this architecture consists on the distribution of the task of a single IdP, the
vIdP, among several IdPs which still appear as one for the user. Figure 4.2.1. OLYMPUS architecture design
(Source: Authors, 2020)
OLYMPUS vIdP
IdP 1
IdP 2
IdP N
SP
SP Figure 4.2.1. OLYMPUS architecture design
(Source: Authors, 2020) OLYMPUS distributed architecture proposal constitutes an improvement from the point of view
of software security, hampering the success of those cyberattacks aiming to steal individuals’
identity and normally making a fraudulent use thereof. For that purpose, user’s password
appears disaggregated among the several IdPs, enabling the distributed authentication, or in
other words, the necessary collaboration of all the IdPs for the token issuance [14]. Regarding identity theft, this would mean that the attacker will need to have the control over
all the structure as user’s password (necessary for the token issuance) appears disaggregated 7 through thereof. Moreover, OLYMPUS includes a proactive security mechanism called “Key-
Resharing” which allows password redistribution, posing different scenarios before the
attacker, thus in the event he successfully compromise one of the IdPs, the “segment” of
password obtained will just remain valid for a short period of time as these “segments of
password” will redistribute again, 13 assuring the IdPs honesty [5]. Figure 4.2.2. OLYMPUS proactive security mechanisms
(Source: Authors, 2020)
Password redistribution
(Key- Resharing)
Password segment
Password segment
Password segment Password redistribution
(Key- Resharing) Figure 4.2.2. OLYMPUS proactive security mechanisms
(Source: Authors, 2020) Furthermore, OLYMPUS combines this innovative architecture with the objective of an
“oblivious IdM”, so user’s privacy is enhanced by limiting the possibilities of the IdP to control
his movements online. Until the moment, this has been successfully achieved in one of the
use cases, the Mobile Driver’s License offline modality, through the generation of credentials
which are stored in user’s mobile device to be presented in a further authentication process in
order to proof the attributes contained in that document (the use case is envisaged for the
event of age proof) [35]. OLYMPUS final purpose is to develop that “highly resistant” architecture before cyberattacks,
maintaining the use of passwords, but adding security to this traditional authentication method
by the introduction of a new architecture design and complex cryptographic protocols [12]. 13 This mechanism has essential importance for the prevention of brute-force attacks as it is described in the article
“The OLYMPUS Architecture—Oblivious Identity Management for Private User-Friendly Services” accessible at the
following address: https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/20/3/945/htm 4.2. OLYMPUS approach This
is consistent with the imperative of privacy by design or the introduction of guarantees for the
protection of individuals’ rights and freedoms in the processing of their personal data since the
first stage of systems and products development. At the same time those events which might
affect privacy must be foreseen prior their materialization, or what is the same, the introduction
of proactive safeguards or mechanisms which anticipate to threats, identifying weakness to
neutralize or minimize risks [41]. 5.Widely recognized IdM systems and their privacy concerns The final purpose of all IdM systems is to provide users’ identification before the maximum
extent possible of services or relying parties. However, this requires considering those
regulations in charge of determining what types or means for identification are valid or
recognized. In that sense, not only National Law, but also EU Law must be considered, as it is
the case of the eIDAS regulation, which has an essential importance in the context of the
Digital Single Market [27]. The aim of the eIDAS regulation is to enhance trust in electronic transactions in the internal
market by providing a common basis for secure electronic interactions between citizens,
businesses and public authorities. For that purpose, the eIDAS regulation establishes a set of
common high-level rules or principles, and technical standards, completed by technical 8 specifications that allow different eID systems to interoperate. This results in a set of technical
requirements, set of levels of assurance, and particularly, a set of minimum identification data
[17] in support of a European-wide public identity federation specifications that allow different eID systems to interoperate. This results in a set of technical
requirements, set of levels of assurance, and particularly, a set of minimum identification data
[17] in support of a European-wide public identity federation More specifically, the implementation of the Interoperability Framework relies on the eIDAS
nodes. Indeed, in the context of a cross-border identification process, the eIDAS nodes
facilitate the “translation” of the tokens to make them compatible with the eID schemes, or in
other words, eIDAS nodes “translate” incoming SAML requests from the SP into authentication
requests compliant with the eID scheme of end user’s country of origin [19]. Figure 5.1. Cross-border authentication process through eIDAS nodes
(Source: Authors, 2020)
eIDAS node
in Spain
eIDAS node
in France
IdP
Spain
SP
France
1.Sends a SAML request
2.translates SAML
request to Spanish
eIDAS node
3.Forwards a compatible
request to the Spanish
eIDAS node
End-user in Spain
5. “Translates” the token
4.Authentication token 5. “Translates” the token eIDAS node
in France eIDAS node
in Spain 2.translates SAML
request to Spanish
eIDAS node 3.Forwards a compatible
request to the Spanish
eIDAS node 1.Sends a SAML request 4.Authentication token Figure 5.1. Cross-border authentication process through eIDAS nodes
(Source: Authors, 2020) On the other hand, the eIDAS regulation includes two main different contents. 14Article 3 (16) eIDAS regulation defines trust services as: “an electronic service normally provided for
remuneration which consists of: (a) the creation, verification, and validation of electronic signatures, electronic seals
or electronic time stamps, electronic registered delivery services and certificates related to those services, or (b)
the creation, verification and validation of certificates for website authentication; or (c) the preservation of electronic
signatures, seals or certificates related to those services. 5.Widely recognized IdM systems and their privacy concerns First, it stipulates
a framework for accessing public services in the European Union by using an identification
service of their own Member State, and second, it creates an internal market for trust services
defining their conditions as well as their possible classification [18]. Regarding this second
objective, the eIDAS regulation offers a list of those services considered as trust services.14
However, among these services the eIDAS regulation does not expressly include the electronic
identification as a trust service, by the fact that it constitutes a prerogative of the State [25]. Consequently, different legal regimes can coexist in a single State, and an electronic
identification service might be considered as a public service, a trust service or even a private
service regarding specific permissions established by the State [6]. Nevertheless, certain trust services allow identification, as it is the case of certificates for
electronic signature, which in the end provide an electronic attestation that binds the
identification data with the name of that person, in support of his/her electronic signature [7]. It must be noted, however, that these electronic certificates have to be admitted by National
Law for authentication purposes and then notified as a form of electronic identification means. Otherwise, they would be excluded of the eIDAS regulation [8]. Regarding authentication processes, both, federated and non-federated methods can be
employed under eIDAS regulation, and despite the fact that federated authentication
mechanisms are generally easier to use, the downside however is that all information 9 regarding authentication will pass through that federation, causing major privacy and security
concerns [37]. According to the European Data Protection Supervisor, policies promoting privacy enhancing
technologies and strategies should be within the priorities of the EU agenda [21], hence new
developments have to find a balance between a wide usability and privacy. The project ARIES
introduced an innovative approach in that sense as it is the creation of partial derived
identities,15 which can be presented before the different SPs maintaining user’s privacy, while
keeping their validity for those transactions which require a strong identification. The
substitution of the respective document by these derived ARIES identities maintaining legal
certainty, will require the definition of these services as a new trust service. 15 Derived identities consist in the creation of different identities from a former identity, normally a valid identity,
that might proof separated attributes of the individual. 5.Widely recognized IdM systems and their privacy concerns In the case of OLYMPUS, different possibilities are currently being discussed, from the use of
pseudonyms before the different SPs, possibility that will be directly implementable in the
current EU framework prior authorization in each Member State, to the possibility of reusing
derived identities [1]. Furthermore, one of the main contributions from the OLYMPUS project
to the eIDAS Regulation consists in enhancing the security measures set forth in its article 8,
which have been developed by Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/1502 of 8
September 2015 on setting out minimum technical specifications and procedures for
assurance levels for electronic identification means pursuant to article 8(3) of Regulation (EU)
Nº 910/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council on electronic identification and
trust services for electronic transactions in the internal market. Concretely, the OLYMPUS
protocols could contribute to implement levels of assurance substantial or high with a higher
level of privacy for the users. However, achieving compatibility between the GDPR and the eIDAS regulation presents some
difficulties. In this sense, the Interoperability Framework requires a minimum data set. This
also excludes the possibility of implementing selective disclosure for services that require less
attributes than those in the minimum dataset [45]. Equally, regarding pseudonymization, the
minimum data set required by eIDAS alongside with the pseudonym, will never satisfy the
GDPR definition of pseudonymized data [46]. Consequently, even if eIDAS is expected to comply with Data Protection Goals and facilitate
privacy by design, as it states in its article 12 c), the reality is that it is arguable if the
Interoperability Framework lowers the level of data protection guaranteed by some national
eID schemes [47]. Conclusions and further discussion The improvement of IdM affects from the data protection, to the prevention of cybercrime and
the realization of a Single Digital Market in the framework of the European Union. The
achievement of these objectives relies on the result of progressing together, the professionals
of different areas in the task of finding appropriate and balanced solutions to the problematics
emerged. Regulations cannot be adopted in a radical attempt to solve the problem, ignoring social and
economic realities as well as latest technological developments. This paper offers two clear
examples of the existing feedback between technology and Law, or more specifically: how the
Law conducts technological developments, and at the same time how these pose new
scenarios which may promote new regulations or, at least, adapt the existing ones. 10 Likewise, it is essential to achieve balanced solutions, assessing risks in order to determine
the most appropriate proposal. The current panorama is the result of an uncontrolled evolution,
which is however encountering nowadays more limits for the protection of valuables goods,
rights and freedoms. The GDPR constitutes a crucial representation of those limits, returning
individuals the power over their own data, at the time it institutes a meaningful, and adapted to
the current time, right to privacy. However, regulations cannot remain unchangeable, but they must be adapted to the current
state at each moment of their object. This is particularly evident when it comes to those laws
whose object is referred to technological related content, as these tools evolve certainly so
quickly that force Law to adapt its requirements and safeguards at a higher speed than legal
experts are used to. Regarding IdM evolution, we consider that each model or solution pose a decisive question. Indeed, perfect solutions are still far to exist, hence we have to decide if for example, a greater
usability might justify a wider data processing or the processing of personal data that involves
a higher risk (as it is the case of biometrics). It is clear that the solution must be obtained case
per case, but maybe by studying and combining thereof, we can set the bases for future
increasingly better and widely recognized IdM systems. Allmer, T. (2019). Critical Internet privacy studies. Fast Capitalism. Vol.10.no.1, pp.71-8 References [Date of access: 16th
March 2020] Available at the following address: https://olympus-project.eu/wp-
content/uploads/2019/07/Olympus_pu_d3_1_v1.0.pdf [14] Bernal, J., Skarmeta, A., Torres, R., Torroglosa, E. et al. (2019). D3.1- “Requirements
and Design Templates for OLYMPUS [Online deliverable]. Horizon 2020 Project OLYMPUS
(Oblivious identitY Management for Private and User-friendly Services). [Date of access: 16th
March 2020] Available at the following address: https://olympus-project.eu/wp-
content/uploads/2019/07/Olympus_pu_d3_1_v1.0.pdf [15] Atkins, B., Huang, W. (2013) A Study of Social Engineering in Online Frauds. Open
Journal of Social Sciences, Vol.1, No.3, pp. 23-32. Available at the following address:
https://www.scirp.org/html/36435.html [15] Atkins, B., Huang, W. (2013) A Study of Social Engineering in Online Frauds. Open
Journal of Social Sciences, Vol.1, No.3, pp. 23-32. Available at the following address:
https://www.scirp.org/html/36435.html [16] Celesti, A., Tusa, F., Villari, M., & Puliafito, A. (2011). Federation establishment between
CLEVER clouds through a SAML SSO authentication profile. Int. J. on Adv. in Internet
Tech, Vol.4, no.1. [16] Celesti, A., Tusa, F., Villari, M., & Puliafito, A. (2011). Federation establishment between
CLEVER clouds through a SAML SSO authentication profile. Int. J. on Adv. in Internet
Tech, Vol.4, no.1. pp.14-88. Available at the following address:
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.225.8297&rep=rep1&type=pdf#pag
e=21 [16] Celesti, A., Tusa, F., Villari, M., & Puliafito, A. (2011). Federation establishment between
CLEVER clouds through a SAML SSO authentication profile. Int. J. on Adv. in Internet
Tech, Vol.4, no.1. pp 14 88 Available at the following address: pp.14-88. Available at the following address:
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.225.8297&rep=rep1&type=pdf#pag
e=21 [17] Cuijpers, C. M. K. C., & Schroers, J. (2014). eIDAS as guideline for the development of a
pan European eID framework in FutureID [Online article]. repository.ubn.ru.nl. [Date of
access: 24th March]. Available at the following address:
https://repository.ubn.ru.nl/bitstream/handle/2066/135087/135087.pdf [17] Cuijpers, C. M. K. C., & Schroers, J. (2014). eIDAS as guideline for the development of a
pan European eID framework in FutureID [Online article]. repository.ubn.ru.nl. [Date of
access: 24th March]. Available at the following address:
https://repository.ubn.ru.nl/bitstream/handle/2066/135087/135087.pdf [17] Cuijpers, C. M. K. C., & Schroers, J. (2014). eIDAS as guideline for the development of a
pan European eID framework in FutureID [Online article]. repository.ubn.ru.nl. [Date of
access: 24th March]. Available at the following address:
https://repository.ubn.ru.nl/bitstream/handle/2066/135087/135087.pdf [18] Regulation (EU) no 910/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 July
2014 on electronic identification and trust services for electronic transactions in the internal
market and repealing Directive 1999/93/EC. Official Journal of the European Union (28th
August 2014), L 257/73-257/114. References [1] Alamillo, I., Fortune, D., Lodge, J., Valero, J. (2017). D2.3 – “Legal requirements and
analysis of ID legislation and law enforcement aspects” [Online deliverable]. Horizon 2020
Project ARIES (reliAble euRopean Identity EcoSystem). [Date of access: 16th March 2020]. Available at the following address: https://www.aries-
project.eu/sites/default/files/aries/public/content-
files/deliverables/D2.3%20Legal%20requirements%20and%20analysis%20of%20ID%20legi
slation%20and%20law%20enforcement%20aspects.pdf [2,3,4] Alamillo, I., Fortune, D., Lodge, J., Valero, J. (2018). D2.4–Privacy and data protection
compliance report ARIES "reliAble euRopean Identity EcoSystem" [Online deliverable]. Horizon 2020 Project ARIES (reliAble euRopean Identity EcoSystem). [Date of access: 16th
March 2020]. Available at the following address: https://www.aries-
project.eu/sites/default/files/aries/public/content-files/deliverables/D2.4-
Privacy%20and%20data%20protection%20compliance%20report.pdf [5] Alamillo, I., Timón, C., Valero, J., et al. (2020). D3.2- “Security and Privacy-aware
OLYMPUS Framework Impact Assessment” [Online deliverable]. Horizon 2020 Project
OLYMPUS (Oblivious identitY Management for Private and User-friendly Services. [Date of
access: 16th March 2020] Available at the following address: https://olympus-project.eu/wp-
content/uploads/2020/02/Olympus_pu_d3_2_v1_0.pdf [6,7,8] Alamillo Domingo, I. (2018). Identificación electrónica y confianza en las
transacciones electrónicas la regulación jurídico-administrativa de las instituciones de
acreditación de la actuación electrónica. [Online doctoral thesis] Universidad de Murcia,
pp.41-56. [Date of access: 18th March 2020] Available at the following
address:https://digitum.um.es/digitum/bitstream/10201/61019/6/Ignacio Alamillo Domingo
Tesis Doctoral.pdf [9,10] Alamillo Domingo I. (2010) Identidad electrónica, robo de identidad y protección de
datos personales en la red. At Robo de Identidad y Protección de Datos en la red. Thomson
Reuters (Legal) Limited /Spanish Data Protection Agency, pp.17-19 [11] Allmer, T. (2019). Critical Internet privacy studies. Fast Capitalism. Vol.10.no.1, pp.71-80. 11 [12] Carsten B., Frederiksen T., Hesse J., Lehmann A., Yanai A. (2020). PESTO: Proactively
Secure Distributed Single Sign-On, or How to Trust a Hacked Server [Online article] Cryptology
ePrint Archive. [Date of access: 17th March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/1470.pdf [13] Bernal, J., David, M., Torres Moreno, R., Cordero, J. P., Bahloul, S., & Skarmeta, A. (2020)
Aries: Evaluation of a reliable and privacy-preserving European identity management
framework. Future Generation Computer Systems, Vol.102, pp.409-425. Available at the
following
address: [13] Bernal, J., David, M., Torres Moreno, R., Cordero, J. P., Bahloul, S., & Skarmeta, A. (2020)
Aries: Evaluation of a reliable and privacy-preserving European identity management
framework. Future Generation Computer Systems, Vol.102, pp.409-425. Available at the
following
address: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jorge_Bernal_Bernabe/publication/335499099_ARIES_
Evaluation_of_a_reliable_and_privacy- preserving_European_identity_management_framework/links/5e20aa0f458515ba208ddd48/
ARIES-Evaluation-of-a-reliable-and-privacy-preserving-European-identity-management-
framework.pdf preserving_European_identity_management_framework/links/5e20aa0f458515ba208ddd48/
ARIES-Evaluation-of-a-reliable-and-privacy-preserving-European-identity-management-
framework.pdf [14] Bernal, J., Skarmeta, A., Torres, R., Torroglosa, E. et al. (2019). D3.1- “Requirements
and Design Templates for OLYMPUS [Online deliverable]. Horizon 2020 Project OLYMPUS
(Oblivious identitY Management for Private and User-friendly Services). References Available at the following address: https://eur-
lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32014R0910&from=ES [19] Engelbertz, N., Erinola, N., Herring, D., Somorovsky, J., Mladenov, V., & Schwenk, J. (2018). Security analysis of eIDAS–the cross-country authentication scheme in Europe
[Online article] 12th {USENIX} Workshop on Offensive Technologies ({WOOT} 18) [Date of
access: 24th March 2020]. Available at the following address: ]
g
tps://www.usenix.org/system/files/conference/woot18/woot18-paper-engelbertz.pdf [20] European Data Supervisor. (2019). Guidelines on assessing the proportionality of
measures that limit the fundamental rights to privacy and to the protection of personal data
[Online guideline] edps.europa.eu. [Date of access: 12th March 2020]. Available at the
following address: https://edps.europa.eu/sites/edp/files/publication/19-12-
19_edps_proportionality_guidelines2_en.pdf 12 [21] European Data Protection Supervisor. Opinion 5/2018 Preliminary Opinion on Privacy by
design [Online opinion]. edps.europa.eu. [Date of access: 12th March 2020]. Available at the
following address: https://edps.europa.eu/sites/edp/files/publication/18-05-
31_preliminary_opinion_on_privacy_by_design_en_0.pdf [22] Ezennaya-Gomez, S., Vielhauer, C., & Dittmann, J. (2018) Towards a Protection Profile
for User-Centric and Self-Determined Privacy Management in Biometrics [Online article]. [22] Ezennaya-Gomez, S., Vielhauer, C., & Dittmann, J. (2018) Towards a Protection Profile
for User-Centric and Self-Determined Privacy Management in Biometrics [Online article]. [23] Federal Trade Commission. (2019). Consumer sentinel network data book for 2018
[Online report]. US Federal Trade Commission United States of America. [Date of access 4th
March 2020]. Available at the following address: g
https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/consumer-sentinel-network-data-book-
2018/consumer_sentinel_network_data_book_2018_0.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/consumer-sentinel-network-data-book-
2018/consumer_sentinel_network_data_book_2018_0.pdf [24] García Luna, J.C., Peña Labrín, D.E. (2017). Cibercriminalidad y postmodernidad: La
cibercriminología en respuesta al escenario contemporáneo. Revista Pensamiento Penal. Available at the following address: [24] García Luna, J.C., Peña Labrín, D.E. (2017). Cibercriminalidad y postmodernidad: La
cibercriminología en respuesta al escenario contemporáneo. Revista Pensamiento Penal. Available at the following address: g
http://www.pensamientopenal.com.ar/system/files/2017/02/doctrina44898.pdf [25] GOBERT, D. (2015). Le règlement européen du 23 juillet 2014 sur l’identification
électronique et les services de confiance (eIDAS): analyse approfondie [Online article]. caprioli-avocats.com. [Date of access: 24th March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://www.caprioli-avocats.com/migration/pdf/ReglementeIDAS.pdf [25] GOBERT, D. (2015). Le règlement européen du 23 juillet 2014 sur l’identification
électronique et les services de confiance (eIDAS): analyse approfondie [Online article]. caprioli-avocats.com. [Date of access: 24th March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://www.caprioli-avocats.com/migration/pdf/ReglementeIDAS.pdf [26] Grütter, B., & Schneider, B. (2019). Data Protection Impact Assessment Guidelines In The
Context Of The General Data Protection Regulation. Thriving on Future Education, Industry,
Business and Society; Proceedings of the MakeLearn and TIIM International Conference 2019,
pp. 261-270. Available at the following address: http://www.toknowpress.net/ISBN/978-961-
6914-25-3/papers/ML19-056.pdf [27] Hučková, R., Sokol, P., & Rózenfeldová, L. (2018). References Int J Eng Innov Res IJEIR, Vol.1, no.2,
pp.104-108. Available at the following address: pp
g
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jatinderkumar_Saini/publication/281965204_An_Investi
gation_of_Challenges_to_Online_Federated_Identity_Management_Systems/links/55ffde6b0
8aeba1d9f8412b5.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jatinderkumar_Saini/publication/281965204_An_Investi
gation_of_Challenges_to_Online_Federated_Identity_Management_Systems/links/55ffde6b0
8aeba1d9f8412b5.pdf [35], Papaxanthis, K,. Paschou, M., Sakkopoulos, V., Stausholm, M. Viennas, M., et al. (2020)
D5.1-“Benchmarking and Testing Environment for OLYMPUS” [Online deliverable]. Horizon
2020 Project OLYMPUS (Oblivious identitY Management for Private and User-friendly
Services) [Date of access: 16th March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://olympus-project.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Olympus_pu_d5_1_v1_0.pdf [35], Papaxanthis, K,. Paschou, M., Sakkopoulos, V., Stausholm, M. Viennas, M., et al. (2020)
D5.1-“Benchmarking and Testing Environment for OLYMPUS” [Online deliverable]. Horizon
2020 Project OLYMPUS (Oblivious identitY Management for Private and User-friendly
Services) [Date of access: 16th March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://olympus-project.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Olympus_pu_d5_1_v1_0.pdf [36] Prabhakar, S., Pankanti, S., & Jain, A. K. (2003). Biometric recognition: Security and
privacy concerns. IEEE security & privacy, Vol.1, no.2, pp.33-42. Available at the following
address: [36] Prabhakar, S., Pankanti, S., & Jain, A. K. (2003). Biometric recognition: Security and
privacy concerns. IEEE security & privacy, Vol.1, no.2, pp.33-42. Available at the following
address: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/S_Pankanti/publication/3437477_Biometric_Recognition
_Security_and_Privacy_Concerns/links/0912f50ecd7b5b5e29000000/Biometric-Recognition-
Security-and-Privacy-Concerns.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/S_Pankanti/publication/3437477_Biometric_Recognition
_Security_and_Privacy_Concerns/links/0912f50ecd7b5b5e29000000/Biometric-Recognition-
Security-and-Privacy-Concerns.pdf [37] Roelofs, F., Verheul, E., & Jacobs, B. (2019). Analysis and comparison of identification
and authentication systems under the eIDAS regulation [Online master thesis]. Radboud
University. [Date of access: 17th March 2020]. [37] Roelofs, F., Verheul, E., & Jacobs, B. (2019). Analysis and comparison of identification
and authentication systems under the eIDAS regulation [Online master thesis]. Radboud
University. [Date of access: 17th March 2020]. [38] Salvadori I: (2010). La lucha contra el hurto de identidad: las diferentes perspectivas
legislativas. At Robo de Identidad y Protección de Datos en la red. Thomson Reuters (Legal)
Limited /Spanish Data Protection Agency, pp.231-233. [39] Segovia A.I. (2018). Digital Identity: Who are we on the net? [Online article] Expansion
Diary, BBVA Research. [Date of access: 2nd March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://www.bbvaresearch.com/en/publicaciones/digital-identity-who-are-we-on-the-net/ [40] Spanish Data Protection Agency. (2018). Guía para el ciudadano [Online guideline]. Guías
Agencia Española de Protección de Datos. [Date of access: 15th March 2020]. Available at the
following address: https://www.aepd.es/sites/default/files/2019-10/guia-ciudadano.pdf [40] Spanish Data Protection Agency. (2018). Guía para el ciudadano [Online guideline]. Guías
Agencia Española de Protección de Datos. [Date of access: 15th March 2020]. Available at the
following address: https://www.aepd.es/sites/default/files/2019-10/guia-ciudadano.pdf [41] Spanish Data Protection Agency. (2019). Guía para la privacidad desde el diseño [Online
guideline]. Guías Agencia Española de Protección de Datos. [Date of access: 15th March
2020]. References 4th Industrial revolution and challenges
for European law (with special attention to the concept of digital single market). EU and
comparative law issues and challenges series (ECLIC), 2, pp. 201-215. Available at the
following address: https://hrcak.srce.hr/ojs/index.php/eclic/article/view/7107 [28] Jaishankar, K. (2007). Cyber criminology: Evolving a novel discipline with a new
journal. International Journal of Cyber Criminology, vol.1, no.1, pp. 1-6. Available at the
following address: http://www.cybercrimejournal.com/editorialijcc.pdf [29] Jorna, P., Smith, R. G., & Norman, K. (2020). Identity crime and misuse in Australia:
results of the 2018 online survey [Online statistical report]. Australian Institute of Criminology. [Date of access: 4th March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://aic.gov.au/publications/sr/sr19 [29] Jorna, P., Smith, R. G., & Norman, K. (2020). Identity crime and misuse in Australia:
results of the 2018 online survey [Online statistical report]. Australian Institute of Criminology. [Date of access: 4th March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://aic.gov.au/publications/sr/sr19 [30] Lee, W. Y., Tan, C. S., & Siah, P. C. (2017). The Role of Online Privacy Concern as a
Mediator between Internet Self-Efficacy and Online Technical Protection Privacy
Behavior. Sains Humanika, Vol.9, no.3-2, pp.37-43. Available at the following address:
https://sainshumanika.utm.my/index.php/sainshumanika/article/viewFile/1271/724 [31] Premier Ministre. (2012). Note technique Recommandations de sécurité relatives aux
mots de passe [Online technical note]. ANSSI. [Date of access: 9th March 2020]. Available at
the following address: https://www.ssi.gouv.fr/uploads/IMG/pdf/NP_MDP_NoteTech.pdf 13 [32] Chawki, M., & Abdel Wahab, M. (2006). Identity theft in cyberspace: Issues and
solutions. Lex Electronica, vo.11 no.1. Available at the following address: [32] Chawki, M., & Abdel Wahab, M. (2006). Identity theft in cyberspace: Issues and
solutions. Lex Electronica, vo.11 no.1. Available at the following address:
https://papyrus.bib.umontreal.ca/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1866/9563/articles_54.pdf?sequence
1 g
https://papyrus.bib.umontreal.ca/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1866/9563/articles_54.pdf?se
1 g
https://papyrus.bib.umontreal.ca/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1866/9563/articles_54.pdf?sequence
=1 [33] Nieuwesteeg, B., and Faure.M. (2018) An analysis of the effectiveness of the EU data
breach notification obligation. Computer Law & Security Review, Vol. 34, no.6, pp. 1232-1246. Available at the following address: [33] Nieuwesteeg, B., and Faure.M. (2018) An analysis of the effectiveness of the EU data
breach notification obligation. Computer Law & Security Review, Vol. 34, no.6, pp. 1232-1246. Available at the following address: g
http://www.infosecon.net/workshop/downloads/2018/pdf/An_analysis_of_the_effectiveness_o
f_the_EU_data_breach_notification_obligation.pdf http://www.infosecon.net/workshop/downloads/2018/pdf/An_analysis_of_the_effectiveness_o
f_the_EU_data_breach_notification_obligation.pdf [34] Pandey, Aparajita, and Jatinderkumar R. Saini. (2012). An Investigation of challenges to
online federated identity management systems. Int J Eng Innov Res IJEIR, Vol.1, no.2,
pp.104-108. Available at the following address: [34] Pandey, Aparajita, and Jatinderkumar R. Saini. (2012). An Investigation of challenges to
online federated identity management systems. [49,50] Torres Moreno, R., Bernabe, J. B., Skarmeta, A., Stausholm, M., Frederiksen, T. K.,
Martínez, N., et al. (2019). OLYMPUS: Towards oblivious identity management for private
and user-friendly services [Online article]. 2019 Global IoT Summit (GIoTS) [Date of access:
18th March]. References Available at the following address: https://www.aepd.es/sites/default/files/2019-11/guia-
privacidad-desde-diseno.pdf [42] Spanish Data Protection Agency (2018). Guía práctica para las evaluaciones de impacto
en la protección de los datos sujetas al RGPD [Online guideline]. Guías Agencia Española de 14 Protección de Datos. [Date of access: 15th March 2020]. Available at the following a
https://www.aepd.es/sites/default/files/2019-09/guia-evaluaciones-de-impacto-rgpd.pd Protección de Datos. [Date of access: 15th March 2020]. Available at the following address:
https://www.aepd.es/sites/default/files/2019-09/guia-evaluaciones-de-impacto-rgpd.pdf 3] Sokolovska, A., & Kocarev, L. (2018). Integrating technical and legal concepts of
ivacy. Ieee Access, Vol.6, pp.26543-26557. Available at the following address:
tps://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=8358762 [43] Sokolovska, A., & Kocarev, L. (2018). Integrating technical and legal concepts of
privacy. Ieee Access, Vol.6, pp.26543-26557. Available at the following address:
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=8358762 [44] Sullivan, C. (2009) Is Identity Theft Really Theft. International Review of Law, Computers
Technology, Vol.23, no.1-2, pp.77-87. [44] Sullivan, C. (2009) Is Identity Theft Really Theft. International Review of Law, Computers
Technology, Vol.23, no.1-2, pp.77-87. [45] Tsakalakis, N., and Stalla-Bourdillon, S., (2018) D2.8-Documentation of the legal
foundations of trust and trustworthiness [Online deliverable].FutureTrust. [Date of access: 24th
March 2020]. [46,47] Tsakalakis, N., Stalla-Bourdillon, S., & O'hara, K. (2016). What's in a name: the
conflicting views of pseudonymisation under eIDAS and the General Data Protection
Regulation [Online article] eprints.soton.ac.uk Date of access: 24th March]. Available at the
following address: https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/400477/1/OID_23_11.pdf [48] Tobin, A., & Reed, D. (2016). The inevitable rise of self-sovereign identity. The Sovrin
Foundation, Vol.29. Available at the following address: https://sovrin.org/wp-
content/uploads/2017/06/The-Inevitable-Rise-of-Self-Sovereign-Identity.pdf [49,50] Torres Moreno, R., Bernabe, J. B., Skarmeta, A., Stausholm, M., Frederiksen, T. K.,
Martínez, N., et al. (2019). OLYMPUS: Towards oblivious identity management for private
and user-friendly services [Online article]. 2019 Global IoT Summit (GIoTS) [Date of access:
18th March]. 15
|
https://openalex.org/W4366333650
|
https://comparativemigrationstudies.springeropen.com/counter/pdf/10.1186/s40878-023-00334-3
|
English
| null |
Instead of ‘writing against’ and discarding ‘immigrants’ integration, why not reconceptualize integration as a wicked concept?
|
Comparative migration studies
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 9,804
|
© The Author(s) 2023. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits
use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original
author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third
party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the mate-
rial. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or
exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Abstract Over the years, some scholars have not only written against the concept of immi-
grant integration but have called for its rejection and abandonment. Critics argue that
the concept is normative, objectifies others, mirrors outmoded imaginary of society,
orients towards methodological nationalism, and a narrow emphasis on immigrants
in the forces defining integration progression. Nonetheless, the concept continues to
receive academic and policy attention. Against the backdrop of this polarized view,
this paper raises an important question relating to the benefit or otherwise of writing
against the concept of integration in the field of integration studies. Specifically, the
paper asks: Is it appropriate to write against and reject the concept of integration? The
paper responds to this question from a provocative conceptual perspective. Here, the
paper argues that when the concept is purged of its inherent criticisms and rather
reconceptualize as a wicked concept, it still offers a unique analytical spectrum with
which scholars can approach several substantive critical questions regarding immi-
grants’ integration. 1 Department of Geography
and Environment, University
of Western Ontario, London, ON
N6A 5C2, Canada Keywords: Immigrant, Integration, Methodological nationalism, Transnationalism,
Wicked concept Instead of ‘writing against’
and discarding ‘immigrants’ integration, why
not reconceptualize integration as a wicked
concept? Senanu Kwasi Kutor1* , Godwin Arku1 and Elmond Bandauko1 Senanu Kwasi Kutor1* , Godwin Arku1 and Elmond Bandauko1 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-023-00334-3 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-023-00334-3 Comparative Migration Studies Open Access Introduction This paper focuses on ‘immigrant integration’ as used in scientific and academic cir-
cles rather than as a political statement. Immigrant integration—the scientific study
of the practices and processes of newcomers’ settlement in receiving countries has a
long history (Penninx & Garcés-Mascareñas, 2016). Integration has received a great
deal of scholarly and public attention as both a policy goal and a conceptual frame-
work. However, its prominence in academia and policy circles is without contesta-
tion (Fawadleh, 2021; Penninx & Garcés-Mascareñas, 2016). The highly contested
nature of integration among scholars borders on the concept’s normative nature and
othering of ‘others’; thus, focusing on what ought to be or the desired end goals and
highlighting a sense of difference between immigrants and the host populations, Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 2 of 16 respectively (see Spencer & Charsley, 2021; Penninx & Garcés-Mascareñas, 2016). “The major point of criticism is the fact that it continues to assume—as did the old
conception of assimilation—that immigrants must conform to the norms and values
of the dominant majority in order to be accepted,” write Penninx and Garcés-Mas-
careñas (2016: 12). As a result, there is a resemblance between integration and the
tenets embedded in assimilation. There is a rich body of scholarship on the empirical and conceptual dimensions
of immigrants’ integration across different geographic scales and contexts. Empiri-
cally, Penninx and Garcés-Mascareñas (2016) posit three main literature strands. The
first literature strand focuses primarily on the newcomers and modifications in their
behaviours and ideas, while other scholars emphasize on host societies’ reactions to
immigrants (see Costello & Hodson, 2011; Van Oudenhoven et al., 2006). The second
literature strand examines the aspects of immigrants’ settlement process; with some
scholars focusing on the cultural-religious dimensions (see Gońda et al., 2021; Fokkema
& de Haas, 2015; Ersanilli & Koopmans, 2010); socio-economic component (see Carlson
& Bell, 2021; Bakker et al., 2014; Godin, 2008; Offer, 2004) and other researchers study-
ing the political and legal components of becoming an integral part of receiving coun-
tries (see Dollmann, 2021; Chaudhary, 2018; Tillie, 2004). The third literature strand
goes beyond the individual immigrants, collective groups of immigrants, and civil soci-
ety analysis to the institutional level. Introduction With a focus on Denmark, Rytter (2019: 692) also suggests and encourages scholars to
write against integration on the basis that: Integration is solely the vocabulary of power, a prerogative of the nation-state and
the indigenous majority population that, intentionally or not, tends to objectify,
stigmatise and exclude Muslim immigrants. Integration is not the solution, it is a
significant aspect of the problem, and therefore more talking, thinking, and ‘writing
against integration’ is needed. In fact, Rytter (2019: 680) suggests three strategies of “writing against integration”:
namely: first, the need to ask critical questions whenever the notion of integration is
deployed in political and public discourse, and more importantly in academic scholar-
ship; second, the need to commence analyzing the social imaginaries and assumptions
regarding the connection between the mainstream population, the nation, and the state
that the majority populations marshal in their discourse and call for integration; and
third, the need to advance a novel or new language for a comprehensive analysis (Rytter,
2019). Although the concept may be riddled with flaws, this paper is opposed to the idea of
outright rejection and writing against; indeed, such suggestion is rather short sighted
and premature. This paper sees outright abandoning and writing against the concept as
akin to throwing out the baby with the bath water. Hadj Abdou (2019: 1) inspires the
current paper, arguing that “rather than abandoning immigrant integration as a field
of research, we have to continue to strengthen critical approaches.” One such critical
approach is our call for a reconceptualization of the concept of integration as wicked. The paper argues that when the concept of integration is purged of with its apparent cri-
tiques and rethink integration as a wicked concept, especially in the scientific discourses
where the term is used, it still provides a unique analytical framework through which
scholars can approach several substantive critical questions. Thus, the goal of this paper is twofold. First, we seek to contribute to integration schol-
arship from a novel conceptual standpoint. Instead of rejecting and writing against inte-
gration, we urge scholars to reconsider it as a wicked concept. Second, we hope that our
call to rethink integration as a wicked concept would spark intellectual discourse among
integration scholars and attract more discussions about this novel approach to integra-
tion scholarship. This paper is organized into five main thematic sections. Introduction Critical questions are raised here, such as “whether
immigrant collectives have established their own institutions in the new society and,
conversely, to what extent and how have institutions of the receiving society reacted to
newcomers” (Penninx & Garcés-Mascareñas, 2016: 12). Notable scholarly works include
the establishment of immigrant settlement organizations (see Veronis, 2019; Moya,
2005; Schrover & Vermeulen, 2005). Various conceptual frameworks have been developed as heuristic models for analyzing
immigrants’ integration. Some of these integration models include Heckmann’s (2006)
framework on social integration, Ager and Strang’s (2008) conceptual framework, Pen-
ninx and Garcés-Mascareñas’ (2016) framework on integration processes, Skrobanek
and Jobst’s (2019) approach of ‘liquid integration’, and Spencer and Charsley’s (2021)
revised framework on integration processes and effectors. These models primarily
seek to elucidate what constitutes integration and its inherent processes in one way or
another by building upon fundamental limitations of each other’s works to comprehend
integration’s complexities. Notwithstanding the contributions to the field, both conceptually and empirically,
there is still a lack of consensus on the concept’s theoretical and methodological under-
standing–resulting in some scholars calling for its total rejection. While this paper
acknowledges the various efforts by scholars to reach a common consensus on the
definition and model of integration (see Spencer & Charlsey, 2021 for the most recent
attempt), sociologist, Willem Schinkel (2018) and anthropologist, Mikkel Rytter (2019),
suggest that social scientists should write entirely against the concept of integration. For instance, commenting on the sociology of immigrant integration in the text,
‘Against ‘immigrant integration’: for an end to neocolonial knowledge production’,
Schinkel (2018: 10) expresses reservations about the concept of integration by stating: Page 3 of 16 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies I would say that the sociology of immigrant integration stands a good chance of
one day being judged as a theoretical hiccup of a still young discipline, as one
of those paths, like social Darwinism, into which researchers once strayed and
made careers in meaningless imitations of normal science, a historical oddity
that did nothing to further either the complexity with which the discipline grasps
the social world or the public knowledge which helps publics and collectives gain
insight into themselves. Embedded in the above quotation is the idea that integration is an inadequate analyti-
cal framework that brings little relevance to the discourse of immigrant integration. A brief overview of immigrants’ integration It is neither the intention nor within the scope of this paper to provide a comprehensive
definition, models, and empirical scholarship on integration; that exercise is beyond the
scope of this paper. Rather, the purpose of this section is to outline some key arguments
concerning the concept of integration. How to conceptualize the ways in which immigrants become embedded or otherwise
integrated into host societies has long been a source of contention (Korteweg, 2017),
prompting some to label it as conceptually illusory (Sözeri et al., 2022). This debate has
resulted in the recognition that the concept of integration is subjective in nature. Schol-
ars generally agree that integration as a concept is subjective, highly contested, com-
plex, and problematic (Ager & Strang, 2008; Penninx & Garcés-Mascareñas, 2016). On
the one hand, the concept is hotly debated because its meanings and connotations vary
across geographic scales and are thus contingent on the values, perspectives, and inter-
ests of scholars and researchers debating it (Ager & Strang, 2008). On the other hand,
its complexity stems from the fact that there is no universal agreement on its definition
or how it should be measured (Harder et al., 2018). Regardless of definitional ambigui-
ties, scholars argue that one thing remains unchallenged: immigrants’ integration in the
receiving countries remains a challenge to policy makers and researchers (Kyeremeh
et al., 2021; Penninx & Garcés-Mascareñas, 2016). Initially, scholarship on immigrants’ integration was approached from a one-way per-
spective. Immigrants are assumed to be responsible for their integration in host societies
(Wong & Tézli, 2013), implying a linear process (Penninx & Garcés-Mascareñas, 2016). This linear or one-way conceptualization of integration denotes that once immigrants
arrive in the host society, they are supposed to relinquish their cultural identity. Thus,
“the process was measured by how similar migrants had become to ‘natives’ in terms
of their attitudes and behaviour, extending for some authors to labour market perfor-
mance” (Spencer & Charsley, 2021: 7). This perspective is dominant in the United States,
where the prevalent used terminology is assimilation, as opposed to the widely used ter-
minology of integration in Canada and Europe. The linear conceptualization of integration has been vigorously rethought by schol-
ars. Introduction First, ‘A brief overview of
immigrants’ integration’ introduces some key fundamental arguments about integra-
tion from different contexts. ‘Critiques of the concept of integration’, the second section, Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2 Page 4 of 16 centers on the various ways in which the concept has been critiqued—which in the
views of some scholars warrant its complete rejection and others calling to write against
the concept. ‘Unwriting against and rethinking integration as a wicked concept’, the third
section, makes a case for rethinking integration as a wicked concept using the five prop-
ositions outlined by Kutor et al. (2021). The final section, ‘What are the benefits to be
gained from rethinking integration as a wicked concept?’ answers the ‘so what question’
of why integration ought to be reconceptualized as a wicked concept. Here, the paper
demonstrates that for a rich intellectual cross-fertilization of ideas on integration, the
time is ripe to commence thinking of the concept of integration as wicked. A brief overview of immigrants’ integration Currently, the concept is now understood as a two-way process that requires efforts
on the part of both individual immigrants and the host country to provide the requisite
societal and institutional support for immigrants (Klarenbeek, 2021; Andrew et al., 2012;
Frideres, 2008). In this vein, several scholars have endorsed this position, arguing that
the realization of integration is contingent not only on the efforts by immigrants, but Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 5 of 16 also on the receiving society’s openness and structures (see Klarenbeek, 2021; Korteweg,
2017; Waters & Pineau, 2015; Andrew et al., 2012). Worth noting is Klarenbeek’s (2021)
argument that the two-way integration thinking involves processes in which both insid-
ers and outsiders participate, despite their different roles. also on the receiving society’s openness and structures (see Klarenbeek, 2021; Korteweg,
2017; Waters & Pineau, 2015; Andrew et al., 2012). Worth noting is Klarenbeek’s (2021)
argument that the two-way integration thinking involves processes in which both insid-
ers and outsiders participate, despite their different roles. f
Integration has also been viewed as a multidimensional process. According to Guo
and Guo (2016), the multidimensionality of immigrant integration suggests that a single
criterion indicator of integration is insufficient to fully comprehend immigrants’ lived
experiences, implying the need for scholars and researchers to adopt a more compre-
hensive approach. The multidimensional aspect of integration revolves around social,
political, cultural, economic, and identity elements. Owing to these forces in determin-
ing the multidimensionality of integration, some scholars, including Phalet (2003) argue
that researchers must be circumspect when examining and discussing immigrants’ inte-
gration because some immigrants are more or less likely to be integrated into certain
components than others. Relatedly, receiving countries are likely to overly concentrate
on one dimension of integration over others. Guo and Guo (2016), for instance, dem-
onstrate that contemporary immigration policies in Canada have primarily focused on
economic integration, with an emphasis on the state’s economic interests. However, this
policy focus raises an important question: are immigrants truly capable of achieving suc-
cessful integration? The literature has addressed successful immigrant integration on both a conceptual
and empirical level. Harder et al. (2018) propose the Immigration Policy Lab (IPL) Inte-
gration Index at the conceptual level, recognizing that there is no common measure of
successful integration. A brief overview of immigrants’ integration Fundamentally, the IPL Integration Index has two components—
the 12-item short form (IPL-12) and the 24-item long form (IPL-24), which encompasses
six components of integration: social, political, economic, linguistic, navigational, and
psychological. The IPL Integration Index addresses scientific advancement in the immi-
grant integration which hitherto was hindered by the lack of a common measure of inte-
gration that allows for comparison across studies, geographic scales, and time. Kyeremeh
et al. (2021) comment on Harder et al.’s index, noting that, despite the significant insights
gleaned from their index, it is based on a review of policies which is less likely to incor-
porate the voices and lived experiences of immigrants. Other scholars have examined what constitutes successful integration empirically,
focussing on the normative component of integration as in a policy domain. For pol-
icy makers at all geographic scales, ensuring successful integration of immigrants in the
receiving country in all facets of life has been a critical issue. Indeed, successful integra-
tion is frequently viewed as being dependent on the immigrants and the host society’s
characteristics (Saharso, 2019). In examining the perceptions of Muslim immigrants
concerning what constitutes successful integration in Germany and the Netherlands,
Kortmann (2015) demonstrates that while the Muslim immigrants in the Netherlands
have a positive view of multicultural integration policy–hence the right to protect their
original identities, their counterparts in Germany consider moderate forms of accul-
turation such as the formation of ‘hybrid’ identities in Germany. However, Kortmann’s
(2015) study fails to account for the voices of different classes of immigrants within these
two research contexts. In the context of Hong Kong, Hung and Fung (2016) examine the
relationship between socio-economic status, social capital, and successful integration of Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 6 of 16 Chinese migrant women in comparison with the local population. The findings dem-
onstrate that migrant women have less social capital than the mainstream population
and that possessing social capital does not guarantee successful integration. Within the
Canadian context, Kyeremeh et al. (2021) interrogate successful integration by draw-
ing on in-depth interviews with African immigrants in London, Ontario, noting that
the creation of conducive avenues for personal growth and development in the context
where opportunities and options are available to immigrants for their progress is a true
indication of successful integration. A brief overview of immigrants’ integration The preceding illustration shows how the concept of integration has evolved over time. Therefore, it is critical to continue to reflect upon the concept rather than succumbing
to calls in the academic domain to ‘write against’ it or discard it completely. In the next
section, we elucidate on the predominant critiques of integration. Critiques of the concept of integration Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 7 of 16 that an integrated society is utopian, except in some peoples’ imagination, particularly
political players. In keeping with the objectification of the other, Schinkel (2018) demon-
strates that dispensation of integration denotes that white citizens are not investigated
regarding integration—culminating into what Meissner and Heil (2021) refer to as the
reproduction of power asymmetries. This presupposes that a holistic analysis of immi-
grants’ integration must be seen as a process that encompasses both immigrants and
citizens of the host society. Third, another prominent criticism of the concept of integration is the outdated social
imaginary. This imagination, in the words of Schinkel (2018: 7) commences with a “theo-
retical imagination, or lack of it, that conceives of ‘society’ as an entity with an identity,
and as an order with a border, in effect positioning social science into the role of border
control”. Buttressing this position further within the Dutch context is Schinkel’s (2010)
assertion that the idea of society is problematic because it denotes the configurations
of a society as a unified social environment and roughly homogenous into which only
immigrants are supposed to integrate. Thus, the outdated imaginary society’s criticism
is based on the notion that society is not a static, imaginary, and homogenous entity,
but rather embedded in dynamism where society is characterized by fluidity, diversity,
segmentation, and heterogenous boundaries (Spencer & Charlsey, 2021). Thus, its het-
erogeneity is influenced by immigrants and their engagements which transcend the
boundaries of the receiving society to encapsulate ‘there’ and ‘elsewhere’. Such engage-
ments involve exchange of ideas and practices which alter the host country’s configura-
tion as well as the sending countries’ contexts. The fourth criticism levelled against the application of the concept of integration is
its methodological nationalism orientation. Historically, Wimmer and Schiller (2003)
coined the term–methodological nationalism to imply that the discussion and analysis
of social processes, including migration, is limited to the nation states, and thus encour-
aged scholars to move beyond such types of analysis. The concern here is that the cur-
rent conceptualization and deployment of integration in research is limited to the host
society, with immigrants’ integration viewed in relation to the mainstream populations
rather than forces beyond the nation-state. Critiques of the concept of integration Several shortcomings of the concept-as used in the scientific domain and as a politi-
cal action-have been highlighted in the existing literature on integration. Spencer and
Charlsey (2021: 5–6), for instance, identify five core critiques of the concept: “normativ-
ity; objectification of the ‘other’; outdated imaginary of society; methodological nation-
alism; a narrow focus on immigrants as a force in shaping integration processes.” These
criticisms are discussed in the subsequent section. First, the normative disposition of the concept of integration has been criticized. This
criticism is primarily associated with the use of integration in the domain of political
actions. According to Spencer and Charlsey (2021), scholars have to address the norma-
tivity that has permeated the field of immigrants’ integration. They particularly empha-
size the need to shift away from prescribing what ought to happen (the ultimate and
desired end goal) toward the actual process of integration—what is actually happening
(Spencer & Charlsey, 2021). Other scholars have expressed similar sentiment, includ-
ing Schinkel (2018) who critiques integration by arguing that it neglects the relational
components of migration and only focuses on immigrants’ position and problems in the
host society. Similarly, Li (2003) emphasizes that the normative expectation of immi-
grants into the host society invariably “projects immigrants’ deviations from the major-
ity standard–whether pertaining to economic performances, normative values, or other
behavioural benchmarks–as signs of incomplete or poor integration” (316). Second, the concept has been critiqued for emphasizing objectification of the other. Spencer and Charlsey (2021), contend that the concept highlights a sense of difference,
where migrants are assumed to be on one end of the integration process and the main-
stream populations on the other. In fact, they posit that “it must contextualise individuals
within not beyond society; reorienting the focus of study away from migrant popula-
tions towards the population as a whole (whether that be of a neighbourhood or on a
larger scale), within which the significance of migration and/or ethnicity can be explored
for the issue in question” (Spencer & Charlsey, 2021: 6). Similarly, Meissner and Heil
(2021) argue that if a segment of the population is considered unintegrated, it implies
that the entire population group, as identified through pointers of difference (their status
as poor/non-white), is regarded as lagging on the integration yardstick. This viewpoint
echoes the argument that Joppke and Morawska (2003) advanced some decades ago Kutor et al. Critiques of the concept of integration In the words of Spencer and Charlsey (2021:
6), there is the: need to incorporate the global and the transnational into our concept of the pro-
cesses in which migrants and other residents are engaged. We need to conceptualise
integration processes outside of a national paradigm, recognise the ephemerality of
the borders of the nation state, and contemporary migration patterns of temporary
and circular migration, as well as the transnational connections they maintain:
individuals belong to and have a sense of belonging in more than one locality within
and across international borders. Thus, immigrants’ integration processes extend beyond the nation-state, or put differ-
ently, the host society. In this vein, Firang, (2021) contends that transnational scholars
have intellectually liberated the scholarly comprehension of the integration process from
the monopoly of methodological nationalism, emphasizing the critical role of transna-
tional engagements. Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 8 of 16 The fifth criticism directed against the concept of integration is its narrow focus on
immigrants in forces defining integration progression. Spencer and Charlsey (2021), for
instance, argue that boundary conditions or (in their words—‘effectors’) to immigrants’
integration are not only limited to individual immigrants’ factors, such as skills and edu-
cational level, but rather, multiple and systemic forces also work against immigrants’
integration. They also highlight that when scholars recognize that multiple and systemic
factors serve as boundary conditions for immigrants’ integration, it exposes the fallacy
of attributing blame or responsibility (for successful integration or lack of it) to any one
party. Fundamentally, there is a need to reconsider forces beyond individual immigrants’
control in terms of their ability to successfully integrate into the host society. Commenting on the criticisms levelled against integration, Meissner and Heil (2021)
argue that the issue that needs to be addressed is not how immigrant integration is done,
measured, or discussed, but rather the notion itself and its application in the European
context. Critiques of the concept of integration Contributing to the debate about why immigrant integration logics cannot be
solved through reappropriations and redefinitions of integration, Meissner and Heil
(2021: 753) use convivial disintegration as “an attempt to deromanticise, and always con-
sider the superdiverse re/configurations of asymmetrical difference, the instability this
entails and the relational modes which prevent total fragmentation.” Thus, convivial dis-
integration underscores the point that urban, and contexts characterized by profound
migration-driven diversifications encompass interaction together with reconfigurations
of differentiation (Meissner & Heil, 2021). Unwriting against and rethinking integration as a wicked concept
In their seminal paper, ‘Theorizing “Wicked Concept” and Reconceptualizing Wisdom
as Wicked’, Kutor et al. (2021) present a well-timed conceptualization of concepts that
are characterized by ambiguities—under the overarching umbrella of a wicked concept. However, Kutor et al’s. (2021) paper is distinctive in that it proposes a wicked concept by
drawing insights from wicked problem thinking. They then apply their proposed wicked
concept to wisdom as a construct and argue convincingly why the concept of wisdom
should be rethought as wicked. Specifically, Kutor et al., (2021: 632) note that: This article proposes a “wicked concept” by expanding on insights from wicked prob-
lem thinking. Using the concept of wisdom as a reference point, we argue that aca-
demic knowledge production, most notably as it relates to wisdom, would benefit
significantly from being reconceptualized as a wicked concept. We also suggest that
reframing, acknowledging, and rethinking the notion of wisdom as wicked would
shape the direction of wisdom research across academic disciplines. Problematizing wisdom as a wicked concept is relevant to critical approaches to
inquiry, particularly how being wise is related to being critical. Reflecting on this nexus,
Simandan (2011) suggests three alternative ways of thinking about this connection: (1)
both stances as mutually exclusive; (2) both stances are complementary; and (3) the crit-
ical stance seems nested within a more all-embracing wise stance. Relatedly, rethinking
certain concepts as wicked resonates with the scholarship on the geography of personal
and social change (see Simandan, 2020 for a detailed discussion). Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 9 of 16 According to Kutor et al. Critiques of the concept of integration (2021: 633), a wicked concept is “one that lacks a precise defi-
nition, conceptualization, and replicable model of assessment; it is constantly evolving
and must be ever refined to achieve a universal applicability” and they suggest five unex-
haustive propositions characterizing wicked concepts. These are: (a) wicked concepts
are difficult to define and have no universally agreed meaning; (b) the unending quest
for a universal definition of wicked concepts; (c) definitions and conceptualizations of
wicked concepts are neither true nor false; (e) all wicked concepts’ components are fun-
damentally unique; and (f) wicked concepts are multidimensional. Notwithstanding the five dominant criticisms levelled against integration (as dis-
cussed in the previous section), this paper suggests that scholars and researchers fol-
low the lead of Kutor et al.’s (2021) conceptualization of a wicked concept and begin
to reconsider integration as wicked. In this regard, the paper makes five suggestions
based on Kutor et al.’ (2021) coinage of a wicked concept–suggesting integration to be
reconceptualized as such. Immigrants’ integration is difficult to define and has no universally agreed
meaningifi One of the defining characteristics of a wicked concept is the difficulty to provide
a concise definition and the lack of a universally accepted definition. According to
Kutor et al. (2021), wicked concepts are inherently embedded with diverse compo-
nents—so scholars tend to gravitate towards components that serve their research
interests. This proposition applies to the concept of integration. In migration and
integration literature, for example, there are several definitions of integration. As a
result, there is no universally accepted definition of integration. Table 1 summarizes
some of the definitions of integration. i
Due to the definitional complexities surrounding integration, we contend that
immigrants’ integration fits into Kutor et al.’s (2021) conceptualization of a wicked Table 1 Definitions of immigrants’ integration
Definition of Integration
Author(s)
“Processes of interaction, personal and social change among
individuals and institutions across structural, social, cultural and civic
spheres and in relation to identity; processes which are multi-direc-
tional and have spatial, transnational and temporal dimensions”
Spencer and Charsley (2021: 16)
“Integration refers to the process of settlement of newcomers in a
given society, to the interaction of these newcomers with the host
society, and to the social change that follows immigration”
Penninx (2019: 5)
“The processes that take place after an immigrant has moved to a
new country… a two-way process, requiring accommodation by
both the native and the immigrant populations”
Givens (2007: 72)
“The process of becoming an accepted part of society”
Penninx and Garcés-Mascareñas (2016: 14)
“A generations lasting process of inclusion and acceptance of
migrants in the core institutions, relations and statuses of the receiv-
ing society”
Heckmann (2006: 18)
“The inclusion of new populations into existing social structures of
the immigration country”
Heckmann and Schnapper’s (2003: 10) Table 1 Definitions of immigrants’ integration The unending quest for a universal definition of immigrants’ integration The unending quest for a universal definition of immigrants’ integration
As argued somewhere (see Kutor et al., 2021: 634), “for a study phenomenon to be con-
sidered a wicked concept, there should be a persistent and evolving attempt to find com-
mon meaning.” Thus, the critical question is, are there endless attempts for a common
denominator, conceptualization, definition, or model of integration? The answer is yes. First, the various definitions and models associated with integration support this asser-
tion (Table 1). Essentially, each subsequent definitions and models seek for a stand-
ardization. Kutor et al. (2021) emphasize that standardization is an elusive mission to
accomplish. Second, Spencer and Charsley (2021) have recently attempted to continue
this mission of never-ending quest for a universal definition and model for integration
research. They specifically state that their heuristic model of integration processes has
the greatest potential to confer rigour to integration research and analysis (Spencer &
Charsley, 2021). Implicit in this assertion is the fact that their heuristic model and defini-
tion have superior explanatory prowess to alternative models and definitions—hence the
need for their model and definition to become the denominator for integration research. In this direction, the authors defined integration as “processes of interaction, personal
and social change among individuals and institutions across structural, social, cultural
and civic spheres and in relation to identity; processes which are multi-directional and
have spatial, transnational and temporal dimensions” (Spencer & Charsley, 2021: 16). From the foregoing, scholars will always strive to refine, retune, rethink, and reconcep-
tualize integration for clarity and rigour purposes. This rethinking effort is the hallmark
of the current paper. Definition of Integration Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 10 of 16 Page 10 of 16 concept. Thus, a definition adopted by researchers is intended to serve the research-
er’s epistemological orientation. Overall, it is these multiple definitions that enrich
the scholarship on integration. Definitions and conceptualizations of immigrants’ integration are neither true
nor false According to Kutor et al. (2021), conceptualization and operationalization of a wicked
concept are neither true nor false. Fundamentally, this preposition suggests that there
are no true or false answers to how researchers conceptualize and assess components of
a concept deemed as wicked. When compared to integration research, it is evident that
there are various models and definitions of immigrants’ integration. Even if each model
and definition have some limitations, this does not render them true or false. To men-
tion a few of the integration models: Heckmann’s (2006) framework on social integra-
tion, Ager and Strang’s (2008) conceptual framework, Penninx and Garcés-Mascareñas’
(2016) framework on integration processes, Skrobanek and Jobst’s (2019) approach of
‘liquid integration’, and Spencer and Charsley’s (2021) revised framework on integra-
tion processes and effectors. These various integration assessment models reaffirms the
assertion that, nonetheless the fact that many actors and parties are interested in judg-
ing a conceptualization, none has the authority to set formal decision rubrics to assess
correctness (Rittel & Webber, 1973). Thus, emphasizing the point that definitions and
conceptualizations of integration models are neither true nor false, because whatever Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 11 of 16 Page 11 of 16 definition and model that researchers choose to apply in their study is invariably contin-
gent on their philosophical and paradigm dispositions. Indeed, whatever limitations are
associated with integration models and definitions deployed in scholarly works do not
render them false either. All immigrants’ integration components are fundamentally unique g
g
p
y
q
Another feature of a wicked concept as propounded by Kutor et al. (2021) is its unique-
ness. Uniqueness is used for heuristic utility, where “for any two approaches or con-
ceptualizations of the same concept, at least one (if not more) peculiar property can be
established, hence making each of them unique in their terms” (Kutor et al., 2021: 635). Juxtaposing this to integration implies that all definitions and models of immigrants’
integration are somewhat unique in their own terms. For example, on the one hand,
Spencer and Charsley (2021: 16) define integration as the “processes of interaction, per-
sonal and social change among individuals and institutions across structural, social, cul-
tural and civic spheres and in relation to identity; processes which are multi-directional
and have spatial, transnational and temporal dimensions.” On the other hand, Givens
(2007: 72) defines integration as “the processes that take place after an immigrant has
moved to a new country… a two-way process, requiring accommodation by both the
native and the immigrant populations.” A critical analysis of these two definitions reveals
a degree of similarity as well as a peculiar uniqueness associated with them. For instance,
while Spencer and Charsley’s definition suggests that the focus is absolutely on process–
transcending a two-way process to incorporate the transnational perspective, Givens’
definition emphasizes immigrants and the host society, thus, emphasizing a two-way
process. It is these distinct differences that are specific to integration components that
qualify it as a wicked concept. Indeed, Rittel and Webber (1973: 164) referred to this dif-
ferentiating factor as having “overriding importance” in distinguishing one component
of integration from another. Immigrants’ integration is multidimensional One of the characteristics of a wicked concept is its multidimensionality. According to
Kutor et al. (2021), a wicked concept’s multidimensionality is predicated on the assump-
tion that it has multiple dimensions and aspects. A wicked concepts’ multifaceted nature
includes their complexity, metaphorical meanings and application nuances (Kutor et al.,
2021). Integration fits this description because a thorough examination of the concept
reveals multiple dimensions. Penninx and Garcés-Mascareñas (2016), for instance, note
that the fundamental definition of integration encapsulates three analytically separate
components in which people are likely or unlikely to become an accepted members of
a society: the cultural religious, the legal-political, and the socio-economic. Similarly,
Heckmann and Schnapper’s (2003) distinction between structural integration, cultural
integration, identificational integration, and interactive integration is another multidi-
mensionality of integration that fits the analytical framework of a wicked concept. As a
result of this classification, integration’s diminuendos and tempos (Penninx and Garcés-
Mascareas, 2016) are distinct, emphasising the concept’s multidimensionality. Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 12 of 16 Another important aspect of integration’s multidimensionality is that the term-inte-
gration is a vocabulary of political call for action and of social sciences (Wieviorka,
2014). This resonates with Kutor et al.’s (2021) claim that concepts deemed as wicked
have metaphor connotation–where they are used in two domains: (a) scientific sense;
and (b) social sense. The social sciences’ use of integration coincided with the scientific
sense, while its political discourse corresponded with its usage in the social sense. In a
political sense or common usage, it denotes political actions on the part of policy makers
to create a conducive environment that allows immigrants to fully integrate into the host
society. As a concept in social science–hence its scientific operationalization, integration
is used as an analytical framework in interrogating the processes of immigrants’ incor-
poration into the host society. What are the benefits to be gained from rethinking integration as a wicked
concept? Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 13 of 16 Lastly, reconsidering integration as a wicked concept would allow researchers to pur-
sue a range of theoretical assumptions and framing around integration research. For
emphasis, the predominant academic fields researching immigrant integration, such as
sociology, human geography, and gender studies are oriented towards diverse episte-
mologies, thereby bringing different perspectives, methodological approaches, and theo-
retical lenses to knowledge production regarding integration. Indeed, pursuing a broad
range of epistemological assumptions about integration is required, because as Fajth and
Lessard-Phillips (2023) argue, a lack of consensus leads to inconsistency in the concep-
tualization and measurement of integration. In fact, we believe that developing a more
coherent, provocative, and conceptual framework for the study of immigrant integration
is one way to overcome this inconsistency—resulting from the concepts’ normativity;
objectification of the ‘other’; outdated imaginary of society; methodological nationalism;
narrow focus on migrants as a force in shaping integration progression. The proposed coherent, provocative, and conceptual framework through wicked con-
cept provides the conducive approach to incorporate other rich scholarships in areas,
such as postcolonial studies, critical race studies, Black studies, political economy
approach, and urban studies perspective to integration scholarship. Specifically, Hadj
Abdou (2019: 4) notes that “immigrant integration research can benefit here from the
extremely rich tradition of critical scholarship in urban studies dating back to the works
of scholars such as Lefebvre.” Similarly, when the lens of intersectionality is brought to
the discourse through gender and sexuality, identity markers, such as sex, race, class,
gender, and nationality, it is likely to enrich the discourse on immigrants’ integration. Moreso, Hadj Abdou (2019) demonstrates how immigration integration in cities reflects
a critical approach to immigrant integration scholarship to overcome methodological
nationalism and in the process incorporate race and class into the discussion, rather
than overlooking them by focusing on the migrant as the principal analytical category. What are the benefits to be gained from rethinking integration as a wicked
concept? The ‘so what question’ is critical. What are the benefits of rethinking integration as a
wicked concept–owing to the criticisms identified in the earlier section? Essentially, this
rethinking endeavour would assist researchers and scholars to move beyond the calls
from some sections of scholars to write against the concept of integration or come up
with a single working definition of integration. Here, the paper highlights two potential
gains when integration is reconceptualized as a wicked concept. First, rethinking integration as a wicked concept would open the door to cross-ferti-
lization of ideas, culminating in dialogue among different disciplines. “Interdisciplinary
efforts are critical not only for scientific discovery but also for knowledge production” as
critical geographer Kutor et al. (2021: 637) so elegantly remind us in their work ‘Theoriz-
ing “Wicked Concept” and Reconceptualizing Wisdom as Wicked’. Studies on immigrants’
integration, for example, have been a focus for sociologists (see Favell, 2022; Schinkel,
2018; Hondagneu-Sotelo, 2017; Menjívar, 2010), and human geographers (see Kyeremeh
et al., 2021; McDaniel et al., 2019; Walker, 2015). However, the extent to which these dis-
ciplinary backgrounds dialogue with one another is limited. Phrased differently, the level
of multi-relational approach adopted by these academic disciplines are limited. There-
fore, crucial to this opening of the terrain by reconceptualizing integration as a wicked
concept is that academic disciplines are more likely to draw on each other’s unique per-
spectives to enrich immigrants’ integration scholarship. Indeed, this provocative piece to
reconceptualize integration as a wicked concept is a way to advance the frontiers of inte-
gration research from a conceptual point of view. When scholars recognize the multiple
characteristics associated with integration, which makes it fits the label, wicked concept,
such a realization is a new strategy for knowledge construction. In essence, the increas-
ing interdisciplinarity benefit of integration as wicked is that it provides the context to
“transcend the narrow scope of disciplinarity worldviews through an overarching syn-
thesis … a new mode of knowledge production that fosters a synthetic configuration and
re-contextualization of available knowledge” (Klein, 2003: 4). One such all-encompass-
ing synthesis is our rallying call for integration scholars to rethink immigrant integra-
tion as a wicked concept. Overall, this endeavour, the paper posits, create the conducive
avenue for cross-fertilization of ideas, resulting in dialogue among different academic
disciplines vis-à-vis immigrants’ integration scholarship. Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Funding Funding
The authors did not receive support from any organization for the submitted work. Availability of data and materials
Data sharing not applicable—no new data generated, or the article describes entirely conceptual research. Availability of data and materials Availability of data and materials
Data sharing not applicable—no new data generated, or the article describes entirely conceptual research. Concluding remarks Author contributions
Conceptualization: SKK, Writing—original draft preparation: SKK and EB; Writing—review and editing: SKK, EB, & GA;
Supervision: GA. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Funding
The authors did not receive support from any organization for the submitted work. Availability of data and materials
Data sharing not applicable—no new data generated, or the article describes entirely conceptual research. Author contributions
Conceptualization: SKK, Writing—original draft preparation: SKK and EB; Writing—review and editing: SKK, EB, & GA;
Supervision: GA. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Author contributions Funding
The authors did not receive support from any organization for the submitted work. Competing interests Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Received: 17 October 2022 Accepted: 11 April 2023 Concluding remarks Academic and policy attention has been focused on immigrant integration in a variety
of geographic contexts and disciplines. Despite this allure, the concept of integration
is without controversy. Notable criticisms of immigrants’ integration coalesce around
issues of normativity; objectification of the ‘other’; outdated imaginary of society; meth-
odological nationalism; and narrow focus on immigrants as a force in shaping integra-
tion progression. Some scholars argued that it was necessary to write against the concept
as a result of these criticisms, while others sought a common definitional denominator
of integration. However, this paper posits that the concept of immigrant integration, particularly its
scientific application, remains relevant—especially when the criticisms discussed above
are purged of and reconceived integration as a wicked concept, it still offers a unique
framework through which scholars can approach several substantive critical questions
regarding immigrants’ integration. The paper achieves this by drawing insights from
Kutor et al.’s (2021) wicked concept. Following the tenets or propositions of Kutor et al.’s
(2021) wicked concept, the paper argues that immigrants’ integration fits the terminol-
ogy of a wicked concept because: (a) immigrants’ integration is difficult to define and
has no universally agreed meaning; (b) the unending quest for a universal definition of Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Page 14 of 16 immigrants’ integration; (c) definitions and conceptualizations of ‘immigrants’ integra-
tion are neither true nor false; (d) all immigrants’ integration components are funda-
mentally unique; and (e) immigrants’ integration is multidimensional. With this in mind, the fundamental question is–so what if integration is reconcep-
tualized as wicked? The paper contends that by reconsidering immigrants’ integration
as a wicked concept, it allows for: (a) a cross-fertilization of ideas–culminating in dia-
logue among different disciplines, and (b) researchers to pursue a variety of theoretical
assumptions or framings around integration research. Abbreviation
IPL
Immigration Policy Lab
Acknowledgements
Not applicable. Author contributions
Conceptualization: SKK, Writing—original draft preparation: SKK and EB; Writing—review and editing: SKK, EB, & GA;
Supervision: GA. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Funding
The authors did not receive support from any organization for the submitted work. Availability of data and materials
Data sharing not applicable—no new data generated, or the article describes entirely conceptual research. Abbreviation
IPL
Immigration Policy Lab
Acknowledgements
Not applicable. References Ager, A., & Strang, A. (2008). Understanding integration: A conceptual framework. Journal of Refugee Studies, 21(2),
166–191. Andrew, C., Biles, J., Burstein, M., Esses, V. M., & Tolley, E. (Eds.). (2012). Immigration, integration, and inclusion in Ontario
cities. McGill-Queen’s University Press. Andrew, C., Biles, J., Burstein, M., Esses, V. M., & Tolley, E. (Eds.). (2012). Immigration, integration, and inclusion in Ontario
cities. McGill-Queen’s University Press. Andrew, C., Biles, J., Burstein, M., Esses, V. M., & Tolley, E. (Eds.). (2012). Immigration, integration, and inclusion in Ontario
cities. McGill-Queen’s University Press. Bakker, L., Dagevos, J., & Engbersen, G. (2014). The importance of resources and security in the socio-economic integra-
tion of refugees. A study on the impact of length of stay in Asylum Accommodation and residence status on socio-
economic integration for the four largest refugee groups in the Netherlands. Journal of International Migration and
Integration, 15(3), 431–448. Bakker, L., Dagevos, J., & Engbersen, G. (2014). The importance of resources and security in the socio-economic integra-
tion of refugees. A study on the impact of length of stay in Asylum Accommodation and residence status on socio-
economic integration for the four largest refugee groups in the Netherlands. Journal of International Migration and
Integration, 15(3), 431–448. g
Carlson, D., & Bell, E. (2021). Socioeconomic status, race, and public support for school integration. AERA Open, 7, Carlson, D., & Bell, E. (2021). Socioeconomic status, race, and public support for school integration. AERA Open, 7,
2332858420986864. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858420986864 Carlson, D., & Bell, E. (2021). Socioeconomic status, race, and public support for scho
2332858420986864. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858420986864 2332858420986864. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858420986864 Chaudhary, A. R. (2018). Voting here and there: Political integration and transnational political engagement among immi-
grants in Europe. Global Networks, 18(3), 437–460. Costello, K., & Hodson, G. (2011). Social dominance-based threat reactions to immigrants in need of assistance. European
Journal of Social Psychology, 41(2), 220–231. y
gy
Dollmann, J. (2021). The political integration of immigrants: How pre- and postmigration contexts matter. Journal of
I
i
l Mi
i
d I
i
h
//d i
/10 1007/ 12134 021 00867 5 y
gy
Dollmann, J. (2021). The political integration of immigrants: How pre- and postmigration contexts matter. Journal of
International Migration and Integration. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-021-00867-5 Dollmann, J. (2021). The political integration of immigrants: How pre- and postmigration co
International Migration and Integration. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-021-00867-5 Dollmann, J. (2021). The political integration of immigrants: How pre- and postmigration c
International Migration and Integration. References Retrieved from http://www. Harder, N., Figueroa, L., Gillum, R. M., Hangartner, D., Laitin, D. D., & Hainmueller, J. (2018). Multidimensional measure of
immigrant integration. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 115(45), 11483–11488. g
g
g
y
Heckmann, F. (2006). Integration and integration policies: IMISCOE network feasibility study. Retrieved from http://www.
efms.uni-bamberg.de/pdf/INTPOL%20Final%20Paper.pdf [28:01:2022]. Heckmann, F. (2006). Integration and integration policies: IMISCOE network feasibility study. Retrieved from http://www.
efms.uni-bamberg.de/pdf/INTPOL%20Final%20Paper.pdf [28:01:2022]. Heckmann, F. (2006). Integration and integration policies: IMISCOE network feasibility study. Retrieved from http://www.
efms.uni-bamberg.de/pdf/INTPOL%20Final%20Paper.pdf [28:01:2022]. g
p
p
p
Heckmann, F., & Schnapper, D. (2003). The Integration of Immigrants in European Societies: National Differences and
Trends of Convergence. In The Integration of Immigrants in European Societies (Vol. 7). De Gruyter Oldenbourg. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110507324 p
g
Hondagneu-Sotelo, P. (2017). Place, nature and masculinity in immigrant integration: Latino immigrant men in inner-city
parks and community gardens. NORMA, 12(2), 112–126. p
y g
Hung, S. L., & Fung, K. K. (2016). Understanding social capital in migrant women from mainland China to Hong Kong. Journal of Social Service Research, 42(1), 1–14. Joppke, C., & Morawska, E. (2003). Toward assimilation and citizenship: Immigrants in liberal nation-states. Palgrave
Macmillan. Klein, J. T. (2003). Thinking about interdisciplinarity—A primer for practice. Colorado School of Mines Quarterly, 103(1),
101–114. Korteweg, A. C. (2017). The failures of ‘immigrant integration’: The gendered racialized production of non-belonging. Migration Studies, 5(3), 428–444. Kortmann, M. (2015). Asking those concerned: How Muslim migrant organisations define integration. A German–Dutch
comparison. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 16(4), 1057–1080. Kortmann, M. (2015). Asking those concerned: How Muslim migrant organisations define integration. A German Dutch
comparison. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 16(4), 1057–1080. Kutor, S. K., Amoak, D., Owusu, B., & Kyeremeh, E. (2021). Theorizing “wicked concept” and reconceptualizing wisdom as
wicked. The Professional Geographer, 73(4), 632–640. comparison. Journal of International Migration and Integration, 16(4), 1057 1080. Kutor, S. K., Amoak, D., Owusu, B., & Kyeremeh, E. (2021). Theorizing “wicked concept” and reconceptualizing wisdom as
wicked. The Professional Geographer, 73(4), 632–640. g p
Kyeremeh, E., Arku, G., Mkandawire, P., Cleave, E., & Yusuf, I. (2021). What is success? Examining the concept of successful
integration among African immigrants in Canada. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 47(3), 649–667. Li, P. (2003). Deconstructing Canada’s discourse of immigrant integration. Journal of International Migration and Integra-
tion, 4(3), 315–333. McDaniel, P. N., Rodriguez, D. X., & Wang, Q. (2019). References Creating an inclusive society: Promoting social integration in Canada. In J. Biles, M. Burstein, & J. Frideres
(Eds.), Immigration, integration and citizenship in 21st century Canada (pp. 77–102). School of Policy Studies, Queen’s
University. Givens, T. E. (2007). Immigrant integration in Europe: Empirical research. Annual Review of Political Science, 10(1), 67–83. Godin, J.-F. (2008). Immigrant economic integration: A prospective analysis over ten years of settlement. International
Migration, 46(2), 135–165. Givens, T. E. (2007). Immigrant integration in Europe: Empirical research. Annual Review of Political Science, 10(1), 67–83. Godin, J.-F. (2008). Immigrant economic integration: A prospective analysis over ten years of settlement. International
Migration, 46(2), 135–165. Gońda, M., Pachocka, M., & Podgórska, K. (2021). Measuring the cultural dimension of migrant integration and integration
policy in the European context: Dilemmas and discussions. International Migration, 59(1), 241–262. Gońda, M., Pachocka, M., & Podgórska, K. (2021). Measuring the cultural dimension of migrant integration and integration
policy in the European context: Dilemmas and discussions. International Migration, 59(1), 241–262. Guo, S., & Guo, Y. (2016). Immigration, integration and welcoming communities: Neighbourhood-based initiative to
facilitate the integration of newcomers in Calgary. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 48(3), 45–67. Hadj Abdou, L. (2019). Immigrant integration: The governance of ethno-cultural differences. Comparative Migration Stud-
ies, 7(1), 15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-019-0124-8 y
Guo, S., & Guo, Y. (2016). Immigration, integration and welcoming communities: Neighbourhood-based initiative to
f
l
h
f
l
d
h
d Guo, S., & Guo, Y. (2016). Immigration, integration and welcoming communities: Neighbourhood-based initiative to
facilitate the integration of newcomers in Calgary. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 48(3), 45–67. d
bd
(
)
h
f
h
l
l d ff
C
S d Guo, S., & Guo, Y. (2016). Immigration, integration and welcoming communities: Neighbourhood-based initiative to
facilitate the integration of newcomers in Calgary. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 48(3), 45–67. Hadj Abdou, L (2019) Immigrant integration: The governance of ethno-cultural differences Comparative Migration St ,
,
,
(
)
g
,
g
g
g
facilitate the integration of newcomers in Calgary. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 48(3), 45–67.f g
g y
Hadj Abdou, L. (2019). Immigrant integration: The governance of ethno-cultural differences. Comparative Migration Stud-
ies, 7(1), 15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-019-0124-8 Harder, N., Figueroa, L., Gillum, R. M., Hangartner, D., Laitin, D. D., & Hainmueller, J. (2018). Multidimensional measure of
immigrant integration. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 115(45), 11483–11488. Heckmann, F. (2006). Integration and integration policies: IMISCOE network feasibility study. References https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-021-00867-5 ,
(
)
p
g
g
p
p
g
International Migration and Integration. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-021-00867-5 ration and Integration. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-021-00867-5 mans, R. (2010). Rewarding integration? Citizenship regulations and the socio-cultural integration of
the Netherlands, France and Germany. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 36(5), 773–791. Ersanilli, E., & Koopmans, R. (2010). Rewarding integration? Citizenship regulations and the socio cultural integration of
immigrants in the Netherlands, France and Germany. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 36(5), 773–791. Fajth, V., & Lessard-Phillips, L. (2023). Multidimensionality in the integration of first-and second-generation migrants in
Europe: A conceptual and empirical investigation International Migration Review 57(1) 187–216 Fajth, V., & Lessard-Phillips, L. (2023). Multidimensionality in the integration of first-and second-generation migrants in
Europe: A conceptual and empirical investigation. International Migration Review, 57(1), 187–216. Favell, A. (2022). Immigration, integration and citizenship: Elements of a new political demography. Journal of Ethnic and
Migration Studies, 48(1), 3–32. j
,
,
p ,
(
)
y
gi
g
g
Europe: A conceptual and empirical investigation. International Migration Review, 57(1), 187–216. Favell, A. (2022). Immigration, integration and citizenship: Elements of a new political demography. Journal of Ethnic and
Migration Studies, 48(1), 3–32. Favell, A. (2022). Immigration, integration and citizenship: Elements of a new political demography. Journal of Ethnic and
Migration Studies, 48(1), 3–32. Favell, A. (2022). Immigration, integration and citizenship: Elements of a new political demography. Journal of Ethnic and
Migration Studies, 48(1), 3–32. Fawadleh, H. (2021). Palestinians in France: Integration versus community integration. Journal of International Migration
and Integration. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-021-00895-1 Fawadleh, H. (2021). Palestinians in France: Integration versus community integration. Journal of International Migration
and Integration. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-021-00895-1 Firang, D. (2021). We don’t only live here, but we also live there”: Exploring transnational ties among ghanaian immigrants
in Toronto. Journal of International Migration and Integration. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12134-021-00911-4 Fokkema, T., & de Haas, H. (2015). Pre- and post-migration determinants of socio-cultural integration of African immi-
grants in Italy and Spain. International Migration, 53(6), 3–26. Fokkema, T., & de Haas, H. (2015). Pre- and post-migration determin
grants in Italy and Spain. International Migration, 53(6), 3–26. Page 15 of 16 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Frideres, J. (2008). Creating an inclusive society: Promoting social integration in Canada. In J. Biles, M. Burstein, & J. Frideres
(Eds.), Immigration, integration and citizenship in 21st century Canada (pp. 77–102). School of Policy Studies, Queen’s
University. Frideres, J. (2008). References Immigrant integration and receptivity policy formation in welcoming
cities. Journal of Urban Affairs, 41(8), 1142–1166. f
Meissner, F., & Heil, T. (2021). Deromanticising integration: On the importance of convivial disintegration. Migration Stud-
ies, 9(3), 740–758. Menjívar, C. (2010). Immigrants, immigration, and sociology: Reflecting on the state of the discipline. Sociological Inquiry,
80(1), 3–27. Moya, J. C. (2005). Immigrants and associations: A global and historical perspective. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Stud-
ies, 31(5), 833–864. Offer, S. (2004). The socio-economic integration of the Ethiopian Community in Israel. International Migration, 42(3),
29–55. Penninx, R. (2019). Problems of and solutions for the study of immigrant integration. Comparative Migration Studies, 7(1),
13. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-019-0122-x Penninx, R. (2019). Problems of and solutions for the study of immigrant integration. Comparative Migration Studies, 7 Penninx, R. (2019). Problems of and solutions for the study of immigrant integration. Comparative Migration Studies, 7
13. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-019-0122-x 13. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-019-0122-x p
g
Penninx, R., & Garcés-Mascareñas, B. (2016). The concept of integration as an analytical tool and as a policy concep Penninx, R., & Garcés Mascareñas, B. (2016). The concept of integration as an analytical tool and as a policy concept. In Integration processes and policies in Europe (pp. 11–29). Springer, Cham. y
In Integration processes and policies in Europe (pp. 11–29). Springer, Cham. Phalet, K. (2003). Measuring immigrant integration: The case of Belgium. 773–803. Rittel, H. W. J., & Webber, M. M. (1973). Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 15 Rytter, M. (2019). Writing against integration: Danish imaginaries of culture, race and belonging. Ethnos, 84(4), 678–697. Saharso, S. (2019). Who needs integration? Debating a central, yet increasingly contested concept in migration studies. Comparative Migration Studies, 7(1), 1–3. p
g
, ( ),
Schinkel, W. (2010). The virtualization of citizenship. Critical Sociology, 36(2), 265–283. Schinkel, W. (2018). Against ‘immigrant integration’: For an end to neocolonial knowledge production. Comparative Migra
tion Studies, 6(1), 31. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-018-0095-1 Schinkel, W. (2018). Against ‘immigrant integration’: For an end to neocolonial knowle
tion Studies, 6(1), 31. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-018-0095-1 chrover, M., & Vermeulen, F. (2005). Immigrant organisations. Journal Schrover, M., & Vermeulen, F. (2005). Immigrant organisations. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 31(5), 823–832. Simandan, D. (2020). Being surprised and surprising ourselves: A geography of personal and social change. Progress in
Human Geography, 44(1), 99–118. Simandan, D. (2011). The wise stance in human geography. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 36(2),
188–192. 188–192. References Sözeri, S., Altinyelken, H. K., & Volman, M. L. L. (2022). The role of mosque education in the integration of Turkish–Dutch
youth: Perspectives of Muslim parents, imams, mosque teachers and key stakeholders. Ethnic and Racial Studies, Sözeri, S., Altinyelken, H. K., & Volman, M. L. L. (2022). The role of mosque education in the integration of Turkish–Dutch
youth: Perspectives of Muslim parents, imams, mosque teachers and key stakeholders. Ethnic and Racial Studies,
45(16), 122–143. Skrobanek, J., & Jobst, S. (2019). Liquid integration? Thinking beyond conventional understanding. In S. V. Ryazantsev, M. N. Khramova, & A. S. Maximova (Eds.), Migration as a resource for socio-economic and demographic development (pp. 307–321). Econ-Inform. Page 16 of 16 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies (2023) 11:9 Kutor et al. Comparative Migration Studies Spencer, S., & Charsley, K. (2021). Reframing ‘integration’: Acknowledging and addressing five core critiques. Comparative
Migration Studies, 9(1), 18. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40878-021-00226-4 g
p
g
Tillie, J. (2004). Social capital of organisations and their members: Explaining the political integration of immigrants in
Amsterdam. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 30(3), 529–541. Amsterdam. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 30(3), 529–5 g
,
( ),
Van Oudenhoven, J. P., Ward, C., & Masgoret, A.-M. (2006). Patterns of relations between immigrants and host societies. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 30(6), 637–651. Veronis, L. (2019). Building intersectoral partnerships as place-based strategy for immigrant and refugee (re)settlement:
The Ottawa local immigration partnership. The Canadian Geographer/le Géographe Canadien, 63(3), 391–404. Walker, K. E. (2015). The spatiality of local immigration policies in the United States. Tijdschrift Voor Economische En Sociale
Geografie, 106(4), 486–498. i
Waters, M. C., & Pineau, M. G. (2015). The integration of immigrants into American Society. National Academies Press. Wieviorka, M. (2014). A critique of integration. Identities, 21(6), 633–641. q
g
Wimmer, A., & Schiller, N. G. (2003). Methodological nationalism, the social sciences, and the study of migration: An essay
in historical epistemology 1. International Migration Review, 37(3), 576–610. gy
g
Wong, L. L., & Tézli, A. (2013). Measuring social, cultural, and civic integration in Canada: The creation of an index and
some applications. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 45(3), 9–37. Publisher’s Note Publisher s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
|
https://openalex.org/W2203942355
|
https://threatenedtaxa.org/index.php/JoTT/article/download/1757/3479
|
Latin
| null |
Cave-dwelling bats (Mammalia: Chiroptera) and conservation concerns in South central Mindanao, Philippines
|
Journal of threatened taxa
| 2,015
|
cc-by
| 7,286
|
òͲ󽽮ĦãÝ;DÃý®͗«®ÙÊÖãÙͿÄÊÄÝÙòã®ÊÄ
ÊÄÙÄÝ®Ä^Êçã«ÄãÙ½D®ÄÄÊ͕W«®½®ÖÖ®ÄÝ <ƌŝnjůĞƌ͘dĂŶĂůŐŽϭΘ:ŽŚŶƌŝĞƐ'͘dĂďŽƌĂϮ <ƌŝnjůĞƌ͘dĂŶĂůŐŽϭΘ:ŽŚŶƌŝĞƐ'͘dĂďŽƌĂϮ 1,2 Department of Biological Sciences, College of Arts and Sciences, University of Southern Mindanao, Kabacan,
Cotabato, 9407, Philippines
K WƌĞƐĞŶƚĚĚƌĞƐƐ͗ĞŶƚĞƌĨŽƌ/ŶƚĞŐƌĂƟǀĞŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶ͕yŝƐŚƵĂŶŐďĂŶŶĂdƌŽƉŝĐĂůŽƚĂŶŝĐĂů'ĂƌĚĞŶ͕ŚŝŶĞƐĞĐĂĚĞŵLJŽĨ
^ĐŝĞŶĐĞƐ͕DĞŶŐůƵŶdŽǁŶ͕DĞŶŐůĂ͕zƵŶŶĂŶϲϲϲϯϬϯ͕ŚŝŶĂ͘ 1 ƚŬƌŝnjůĞƌΛŐŵĂŝů͘ĐŽŵ;ĐŽƌƌĞƐƉŽŶĚŝŶŐĂƵƚŚŽƌͿ͕2 ũƚĂďŽƌĂΛƵƐŵ͘ĞĚƵ͘ƉŚ ďƐƚƌĂĐƚ͗dŚĞƐƚĂďůĞŵŝĐƌŽĐůŝŵĂƚĞŝŶĐĂǀĞƐƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƐĂƌĞůĂƟǀĞůLJĐŽŶƐƚĂŶƚŚĂďŝƚĂƚĨŽƌŵĂŶLJďĂƚƐƉĞĐŝĞƐŝŶƚŚĞWŚŝůŝƉƉŝŶĞƐ͕ďƵƚŚƵŵĂŶ
ĞŶĐƌŽĂĐŚŵĞŶƚĐŽŶƟŶƵĞƐƚŽĚŝƐƌƵƉƚƚŚŝƐŚĂďŝƚĂƚĂŶĚŝŵƉĞƌŝůŵĂŶLJŽĨƚŚĞƐƉĞĐŝĞƐƌŽŽƐƟŶŐŝŶƚŚĞĐĂǀĞƐ͘/Ŷ^ŽƵƚŚĐĞŶƚƌĂůDŝŶĚĂŶĂŽ͕ƚŚĞ
ĚŝǀĞƌƐŝƚLJĂŶĚĐŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶƐƚĂƚƵƐŽĨĐĂǀĞďĂƚƐƌĞŵĂŝŶƵŶĚŽĐƵŵĞŶƚĞĚĂŶĚƵŶĞdžƉůŽƌĞĚ͘tĞĞŵƉůŽLJĞĚŵŝƐƚͲŶĞƫŶŐƚŽĐĂƉƚƵƌĞďĂƚƐĨƌŽŵ
ĮǀĞĚŝīĞƌĞŶƚĐĂǀĞƐǁŝƚŚŝŶƚŚĞƚŽǁŶŽĨ<ĂďĂĐĂŶ͕ŶŽƌƚŚĞƌŶŽƚĂďĂƚŽ͕WŚŝůŝƉƉŝŶĞƐ͘ƚŽƚĂůŽĨϭϰďĂƚƐƉĞĐŝĞƐǁĞƌĞŝĚĞŶƟĮĞĚŝŶĐůƵĚŝŶŐƚŚĞ
Philippine endemics Hipposideros pygmaeus and Ptenochirus jagori and the threatened Megaerops wetmorei. ,ŽǁĞǀĞƌ͕ĚĞƐƉŝƚĞƚŚĞ
ĚĞĐůŝŶŝŶŐĐŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶƐƚĂƚƵƐŽĨƚŚĞďĂƚƐ͕ůŽĐĂůĚŝƐƚƵƌďĂŶĐĞƐƵĐŚĂƐďĂƚŚƵŶƟŶŐĨŽƌďƵƐŚŵĞĂƚĂŶĚƵŶƌĞŐƵůĂƚĞĚƚŽƵƌŝƐŵĂƌĞĐƵƌƌĞŶƚůLJƚĂŬŝŶŐ
ƉůĂĐĞŝŶƚŚĞĐĂǀĞƐ͘>ĂƌŐĞƐƉĞĐŝĞƐƐƵĐŚĂƐEonycteris spelaea and ZŽƵƐĞƩƵƐĂŵƉůĞdžŝĐĂƵĚĂƚƵƐĂƌĞŬŝůůĞĚĂůŵŽƐƚĞǀĞƌLJĚĂLJĨŽƌĨŽŽĚĂŶĚƚƌĂĚĞ͘
dŚĞƌĞĨŽƌĞ͕ƚŚĞŚŝŐŚƐƉĞĐŝĞƐƌŝĐŚŶĞƐƐ͕ĂŶĚƚŚĞƉƌĞƐĞŶĐĞŽĨĞŶĚĞŵŝĐĂŶĚƚŚƌĞĂƚĞŶĞĚƐƉĞĐŝĞƐĐŽƵƉůĞĚǁŝƚŚƚŚĞŽĐĐƵƌƌĞŶĐĞŽĨĂŶƚŚƌŽƉŽŐĞŶŝĐ
ĚŝƐƚƵƌďĂŶĐĞƐŝŶĐĂǀĞƐƐƵŐŐĞƐƚƐƚŚĞŶĞĞĚĨŽƌĂŶƵƌŐĞŶƚĂŶĚĞīĞĐƟǀĞĐŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶŝŶƚĞƌǀĞŶƟŽŶŝŶǀŽůǀŝŶŐƚŚĞůŽĐĂůŐŽǀĞƌŶŵĞŶƚĂŶĚƉƵďůŝĐ
ĐŽŵŵƵŶŝƚLJ͘ <ĞLJǁŽƌĚƐ͗ĂƚĐŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶ͕ĐĂǀĞͲĚǁĞůůŝŶŐďĂƚƐ͕ĐĂǀĞƐ͕ĚŝƐƚƵƌďĂŶĐĞ͕ŚƵŶƟŶŐ͘ K/͗ ŚƩƉ͗ͬͬĚdž͘ĚŽŝ͘ŽƌŐͬϭϬ͘ϭϭϲϬϵͬũŽƩ͘ϭϳϱϳ͘ϳ͘ϭϱ͘ϴϭϴϱͲϴϭϵϰͮŽŽĂŶŬ͗ƵƌŶ͗ůƐŝĚ͗njŽŽďĂŶŬ͘ŽƌŐ͗ƉƵď͗ϳϮϬϮ&ϵͲ&ϱ&ͲϰϵϵͲϳϴϳͲϴ ϴϲϭϬϭ
<ĞLJǁŽƌĚƐ͗ĂƚĐŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶ͕ĐĂǀĞͲĚǁĞůůŝŶŐďĂƚƐ͕ĐĂǀĞƐ͕ĚŝƐƚƵƌďĂŶĐĞ͕ŚƵŶƟŶŐ͘
DATA
DEFICIENT
DD
NOT
EVALUATED
NE
NEAR
THREATENED
NT
VULNERABLE
VU
ENDANGERED
EN
EXTINCT
IN THE WILD
EW
EXTINCT
EX
CRITICALLY
ENDANGERED
CR
LEAST
CONCERN
LC
ZŽƵƐĞƩƵƐĂŵƉůĞdžŝĐĂƵĚĂƚƵƐ
'ĞŽīƌŽLJ͛ƐZŽƵƐĞƩĞ ZŽƵƐĞƩƵƐĂŵƉůĞdžŝĐĂƵĚĂƚƵƐ
'ĞŽīƌŽLJ͛ƐZŽƵƐĞƩĞ /͗ ŚƩƉ͗ͬͬĚdž͘ĚŽŝ͘ŽƌŐͬϭϬ͘ϭϭϲϬϵͬũŽƩ͘ϭϳϱϳ͘ϳ͘ϭϱ͘ϴϭϴϱͲϴϭϵϰͮŽŽĂŶŬ͗ƵƌŶ͗ůƐŝĚ͗njŽŽďĂŶŬ͘ŽƌŐ͗ƉƵď͗ϳϮϬϮ&ϵͲ&ϱ&ͲϰϵϵͲϳϴϳͲϴ ϴϲϭϬϭ ĚŝƚŽƌ͗WĂƵůZĂĐĞLJ͕hŶŝǀĞƌƐŝƚLJŽĨ džĞƚĞƌ͕ŽƌŶǁĂůůĐĂŵƉƵƐ͕h<͘ ĚŝƚŽƌ͗WĂƵůZĂĐĞLJ͕hŶŝǀĞƌƐŝƚLJŽĨ džĞƚĞƌ͕ŽƌŶǁĂůůĐĂŵƉƵƐ͕h<͘
Ăƚ /^^EϬϵϳϰͲϳϵϬϳ;KŶůŝŶĞͿ
/^^EϬϵϳϰͲϳϴϵϯ;WƌŝŶƚͿ /^^EϬϵϳϰͲϳϵϬϳ;KŶůŝŶĞͿ
/^^EϬϵϳϰͲϳϴϵϯ;WƌŝŶƚͿ ĂƚĞŽĨƉƵďůŝĐĂƟŽŶ͗ϮϲĞĐĞŵďĞƌϮϬϭϱ;ŽŶůŝŶĞΘƉƌŝŶƚͿ ĂƚĞŽĨƉƵďůŝĐĂƟŽŶ͗ϮϲĞĐĞŵďĞƌϮϬϭϱ;ŽŶůŝŶĞΘƉƌŝŶƚͿ DĂŶƵƐĐƌŝƉƚĚĞƚĂŝůƐ͗DƐηŽϰϮϴϴͮZĞĐĞŝǀĞĚϭϬ:ĂŶƵĂƌLJϮϬϭϱͮ&ŝŶĂůƌĞĐĞŝǀĞĚϬϯKĐƚŽďĞƌϮϬϭϱͮ&ŝŶĂůůLJĂĐĐĞƉƚĞĚϭϱĞĐĞŵďĞƌϮϬϭϱ ŝƚĂƟŽŶ͗dĂŶĂůŐŽ͕<͘͘Θ:͘͘'͘dĂďŽƌĂ ;ϮϬϭϱͿ͘ĂǀĞͲĚǁĞůůŝŶŐďĂƚƐ;DĂŵŵĂůŝĂ͗ŚŝƌŽƉƚĞƌĂͿĂŶĚĐŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶĐŽŶĐĞƌŶƐŝŶ^ŽƵƚŚĐĞŶƚƌĂůDŝŶĚĂŶĂŽ͕WŚŝůŝƉƉ
of Threatened Taxaϳ;ϭϱͿ͗ϴϭϴϱʹϴϭϵϰ͖ŚƩƉ͗ͬͬĚdž͘ĚŽŝ͘ŽƌŐͬϭϬ͘ϭϭϲϬϵͬũŽƩ͘ϭϳϱϳ͘ϳ͘ϭϱ͘ϴϭϴϱͲϴϭϵϰ ŽƉLJƌŝŐŚƚ͗ © dĂŶĂůŐŽΘdĂďŽƌĂ ϮϬϭϱ͘ƌĞĂƟǀĞŽŵŵŽŶƐƩƌŝďƵƟŽŶϰ͘Ϭ/ŶƚĞƌŶĂƟŽŶĂů>ŝĐĞŶƐĞ͘:ŽddĂůůŽǁƐƵŶƌĞƐƚƌŝĐƚĞĚƵƐĞŽĨƚŚŝƐĂƌƟĐůĞŝŶĂŶLJŵĞĚŝƵ
ƟŽŶĂŶĚĚŝƐƚƌŝďƵƟŽŶďLJƉƌŽǀŝĚŝŶŐĂĚĞƋƵĂƚĞĐƌĞĚŝƚƚŽƚŚĞĂƵƚŚŽƌƐĂŶĚƚŚĞƐŽƵƌĐĞŽĨƉƵďůŝĐĂƟŽŶ͘ &ƵŶĚŝŶŐ͗^ŽƵƚŚĞĂƐƚƐŝĂŶĂƚŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶĂŶĚZĞƐĞĂƌĐŚhŶŝƚ;^ ZhͿ͘ &ƵŶĚŝŶŐ͗^ŽƵƚŚĞĂƐƚƐŝĂŶĂƚŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶĂŶĚZĞƐĞĂƌĐŚhŶŝƚ;^ ZhͿ͘ ŽŶŇŝĐƚŽĨ/ŶƚĞƌĞƐƚ͗dŚĞĂƵƚŚŽƌƐĚĞĐůĂƌĞŶŽĐŽŵƉĞƟŶŐŝŶƚĞƌĞƐƚƐ͘ ŽŶŇŝĐƚŽĨ/ŶƚĞƌĞƐƚ͗dŚĞĂƵƚŚŽƌƐĚĞĐůĂƌĞŶŽĐŽŵƉĞƟŶŐŝŶƚĞƌĞƐƚƐ͘ ƵƚŚŽƌĞƚĂŝůƐ, ƵƚŚŽƌŽŶƚƌŝďƵƟŽŶΘ&ŝůŝƉŝŶŽĂďƐƚƌĂĐƚƐĞĞĞŶĚŽĨƚŚŝƐĂƌƟĐůĞ͘ The Study Site The village of Pisan is located in the southeast of
the municipality of Kabacan in the province of North
Cotabato, South central Mindanao region (Fig.1). It is
the only mountainous part of the municipality, covered
with secondary disturbed forest and agro-forest with a
maximum elevation of 300–400 m. The area is known
as one of the main sources of food for the municipality
including rice, corn, banana, and sweet potato. Pisan
is known throughout the province for its caves and
underground habitats which are visited by many for
tourism and caving activities. It is also the location of the
Kulaman watershed, the only one in the municipality. Their habitats include forests, urban sites and caves. Caves are vital for the maintenance and survival of
many bat species (Furey & Racey 2016). They roost in
thousands, and sometimes millions in caves because of
the size, permanency and stable microclimate of these
habitats (Kingston 2010). The roost structure, external
habitat, and the presence of anthropogenic activities in
caves can affect the physiological condition and the roost
selection of cave-dwelling bats (Nagy & Postawa 2010;
Sedlock et al. 2014). Moreover, reproductive condition
and predation may also influence roost selection of bats
in caves (Ho & Lee 2003). Consequently, caves and other
underground habitats are considered to be among the
most important and critically imperiled habitats for bats
in Southeast Asia (Kingston 2010). Locals recounted that there were numerous caves
in the area. However, only five caves are open to
the public due to unstable security conditions and
further exploration of other cave sites is prohibited
(MENRO 2013). Accessible caves were surveyed in
the village of Pisan (located between 7.199585190N &
124.890602850E). The caves are karstic with a diverse
structure, some with narrow or wide mouth openings,
numerous openings and obstacles; others have alluvial
floors composed of guano and soil. The caves are
situated in an agro-forest ecosystem. Throughout the
year the area experiences a wet season (November–
February) and a dry season (March–October). In the Philippines, there are about 1500 surveyed
caves in the country (PAWB-DENR 2008) and about
10% of the archipelago is covered with karst landscape
characterized by an abundance of caves (Restificar et al. 2006). According to the recent report of the Philippine
Cave Committee (2012), about 308 caves house bats
but only a few are under government protection. INTRODUCTION the best of our knowledge none was ever published on
cave bats. This may explain the lack of bat conservation
initiatives in the region. The primary goal of this study
is to document species of cave bats species present in
caves of Pisan, Kabacan, northern Cotabato, in South
central Mindanao, Philippines so that this information
can be utilized in future conservation management. Bats are important in providing essential ecosystem
services that are important for maintaining species
and ecosystem interactions (Jones et al. 2009; Kunz et
al. 2011). They are responsible for the pollination and
seed dispersal of many economically important plant
species thus enhancing the regeneration of degraded
habitats (Nassar et al. 1997; Corlett 1998; Momose et
al. 1998; Hodgkison et al. 2003; Bumrungsri et al. 2013). Insectivorous bats consume some of the insect pests
that devastate crops (Cleveland et al. 2006; William-
Guillen et al. 2008) and bats thus play critical roles in
maintaining ecosystem health (Medellin 2000). Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Tanalgo & Tabora ƵƚŚŽƌĞƚĂŝůƐ, ƵƚŚŽƌŽŶƚƌŝďƵƟŽŶΘ&ŝůŝƉŝŶŽĂďƐƚƌĂĐƚƐĞĞĞŶĚŽĨƚŚŝƐĂƌƟĐůĞ͘ ĐŬŶŽǁůĞĚŐĞŵĞŶƚ͗dŚĞĂƵƚŚŽƌƐǁŽƵůĚůŝŬĞƚŽƚŚĂŶŬƚŚĞ^ŽƵƚŚĞĂƐƚƐŝĂŶĂƚŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶZĞƐĞĂƌĐŚhŶŝƚ;^ ZhͿĂŶĚdĞdžĂƐdĞĐŚhŶŝǀĞƌƐŝƚLJ͕ĞƐƉĞĐŝĂůůLJƌ͘dŝŐŐĂ
<ŝŶŐƐƚŽŶ͕ĨŽƌŐĞŶĞƌŽƵƐůLJƐƵƉƉŽƌƟŶŐƉŽƌƟŽŶƐŽĨƚŚĞƉƌŽũĞĐƚƚŚƌŽƵŐŚƚŚĞ^ŽƵƚŚĞĂƐƚƐŝĂŶĂƚŽŶƐĞƌǀĂƟŽŶZĞƐĞĂƌĐŚhŶŝƚ;^ ZhͿ^ŵĂůů'ƌĂŶƚĨŽƌ^ŽƵƚŚĞĂƐƚ
ƐŝĂŶ^ƚƵĚĞŶƚƐ͘dŚĞƐĂŵĞĂƉƉƌĞĐŝĂƟŽŶŝƐŐŝǀĞŶƚŽƚŚĞĞƉĂƌƚŵĞŶƚŽĨŝŽůŽŐŝĐĂů^ĐŝĞŶĐĞƐŽĨƚŚĞŽůůĞŐĞŽĨƌƚƐĂŶĚ^ĐŝĞŶĐĞƐ͕hŶŝǀĞƌƐŝƚLJŽĨ^ŽƵƚŚĞƌŶDŝŶĚĂŶĂŽĨŽƌ
ŚŽƐƟŶŐĂŶĚƉƌŽǀŝĚŝŶŐĨĂĐŝůŝƟĞƐĨŽƌƚŚĞƉƌŽũĞĐƚ͕ƚŽƚŚĞZĞŐŝŽŶy//WƌŽƚĞĐƚĞĚƌĞĂƐĂŶĚtŝůĚůŝĨĞƵƌĞĂƵĂŶĚĞƉĂƌƚŵĞŶƚŽĨ ŶǀŝƌŽŶŵĞŶƚĂůĂŶĚEĂƚƵƌĂůZĞƐŽƵƌĐĞƐ͕
<ŝĚĂƉĂǁĂŶŝƚLJ ŶǀŝƌŽŶŵĞŶƚĂůKĸĐĞĂŶĚ<ĂďĂĐĂŶDƵŶŝĐŝƉĂů ŶǀŝƌŽŶŵĞŶƚĂůKĸĐĞĨŽƌŐƌĂŶƟŶŐƚŚĞƌĞƐĞĂƌĐŚĞƌƐƚŚĞŐƌĂƟƐƉĞƌŵŝƚƚŽĐŽŶĚƵĐƚĂďĂƚĐĂǀĞƐƵƌǀĞLJŝŶ
WŝƐĂŶĐĂǀĞƐ͘ƐĂŵĞĂƉƉƌĞĐŝĂƟŽŶŝƐŐŝǀĞŶƚŽƚŚĞƐƚƵĚĞŶƚƚƌĂŝŶĞĞƐ͕ůŽĐĂůƉĞŽƉůĞĂŶĚŐŽǀĞƌŶŵĞŶƚƵŶŝƚŽĨƚŚĞĂƌĂŶŐĂLJWŝƐĂŶĨŽƌƚŚĞŝƌƉĂƌƟĐŝƉĂƟŽŶĂŶĚĐŽŽƌĚŝŶĂƟŽŶ
ĚƵƌŝŶŐƚŚĞŝŵƉůĞŵĞŶƚĂƟŽŶŽĨƚŚĞƐƚƵĚLJ͘&ŝŶĂůůLJ͕ŐƌĂƚĞĨƵůƚŚĂŶŬƐĂƌĞĚƵĞƚŽƚŚĞƚŚƌĞĞĂŶŽŶLJŵŽƵƐƌĞǀŝĞǁĞƌƐĂŶĚƚŚĞƐƵďũĞĐƚĞĚŝƚŽƌĨŽƌƚŚĞŝƌŐĞŶĞƌŽƵƐĂŶĚ
ĐŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟǀĞŝŶƉƵƚƐƚŽƚŚĞŝŵƉƌŽǀĞŵĞŶƚŽĨƚŚŝƐƉĂƉĞƌ͘ ϴϭϴϱ The Study Site Furthermore, over 30 bat species in the country are
known to be cave dwellers and dependent on these
roost sites for their survival and life history (Heaney et
al. 2010; Ingle et al. 2011). However, many species are
threatened by local extinction because many caves still
lack effective management and protection as evidenced
by intensive meat harvest for food and trade, guano
collection and unregulated tourism (Ingle et al. 2011). Of the species thought to be present in the caves,
Megaerops wetmorei is threatened (Rosell-Ambal et al. 2008) and although Emballonura alecto is not listed as
threatened, its population is thought to be decreasing
(Csorba et al. 2008). Caves that were surveyed for cave bats include Lope,
Cathedral, Shortcut, Avenue, and Usok caves. Lope
(7.201374220N, 124.87201950E) cave is located around
500 m from the nearest local settlement. The atrium of
the cave is about 30m wide and 15m high with a wide
opening. The cave floor is covered by river water that
flows through the cave, which is about 1m deep. Bat
roosting marks can be found on the cave ceiling. The
cave is long and it may take several days for a surveyor
to reach its end. Cathedral Cave (7.200206120N & 124.87201950E) is
about 45 mins trek from Lope cave. It is located under
a hill and is the widest (around 40–50 m in diameter)
and the highest cave (around 30m) cave surveyed. In South central Mindanao, although some
information is available on the bats of the region, to 8186 Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Tanalgo & Tabora Figure 1. Location of the Pisan caves, in South central Mindanao, Philippines (Quantum GIS 2.2.0 version). All caves are found in different
area but in a single locality. Figure 1. Location of the Pisan caves, in South central Mindanao, Philippines (Quantum GIS 2.2.0 version). All caves are found in different
area but in a single locality. The interior is dome-shaped with two fenestrae in the
ceiling. Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 Survey Method and Data Analysisi one as the lowest possible figure. The higher the value
the greater the diversity of the species in the area. The relative abundance of bat species (%) was
calculated using the equation N/n (where: N is the total
number of captured individuals of a species and n is
the total number of all species). Relative abundance
of species and relative abundance of all species was
calculated for each cave. The species diversity of the
bats at each cave site was compared using the reciprocal
form of Simpson’s index (1/D), 1/D = Spi2 (where 1/D
=reciprocal of Simpson’s D, Spi2= abundance of common
genera) and calculated using Biodiversity Pro 2.0
software (McAleece et al. 1997). Survey Method and Data Analysisi The study received a gratis permit from the
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
allowing the collection of bats from Pisan caves (GP #
RXII 2013-04). The survey was conducted from July to
August 2013. Bats were captured using mono-filament
mist nets of various dimensions (12x6 m, 10x6 m, 5x12
m) depending on the geophysical characteristic of the
sampling site. Nets were set on suitable flight paths such
as cave openings, cliffs, and crevices. Nets were checked
at least every 2–3 hours from 18:00–24:00 hr. Captured
bats were carefully removed from the nets and placed
in a clean moisture-free cloth bag and immediately
processed at the camp site. Shortcut Cave (7.1997222220N & 124.89177780E)
is located 300m from Cathedral Cave. It is only around
50m long with a narrow opening passable by a single
person, although it widens a little in the central part. Avenue Cave (7.199178580N & 124.89021610E) is
located on the side of a 350 slope. It is surrounded by
the endemic natural plants of Pisan in contrast to the
introduced Gmelina arboria trees around some other
caves. The cave starts with a very low entrance of about
1–2 m wide. The ceiling rises to 20m. The Avenue Cave
is wide in its main chamber and can accommodate 15
people walking side-by-side. Captured bats were identified using the keys of
Ingle & Heaney (1992), Kingston et al. (2006) and the
photographic guide for the cave bats of the Philippines by
Sedlock & Ingle (2010) by examining basic morphological
structures including the lengths of the total body, snout-
vent, forearm, tail, ear and hind foot, measured using
plastic vernier calipers and a ruler. Notable features Usok Cave (7.1997222220N & 124.89177780E)
derives its name from the Ilocano (a local language)
word which means ‘pass-through’. In this cave, a river
passes through the cave and there are no solid surfaces
on which to step. A person exploring the site has to swim
to get to the other side of the cave and the ceiling is
about 60m high. Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 8187 Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Tanalgo & Tabora one as the lowest possible figure. The higher the value
the greater the diversity of the species in the area. including the presence of a tail, markings, tragus/
antitragus, noseleaves and interfemoral membrane
were recorded. Legend: # - Vulnerable; * - Endemic to the Philippines DISCUSSION This study is the first to provide details of cave bat
biodiversity in the South central Mindanao region. The
exploration of five accessible caves in Pisan, Kabacan,
North Cotabato, in South central Mindanao identified
a total of 14 bat species with three endemics: H. pygmaeus, P. jagori and M. wetmorei, which are listed as
threatened with a decreasing population (Rosell-Ambal
et al 2008; Heaney et al. 2010). Image 1. Rousettus amplexicaudatus cave openings especially in Avenue and Lope near fruiting
tree such as Ficus spp. Rousettus amplexicaudatus and
Eonycteris spelaea were observed roosting in caves with
large openings. Other fruit bat species recorded were
the endemic Megaerops wetmorei and Ptenochirus
jagori. Among all fruit bats, R. amplexicaudatus was
the most dominant in all cave sites and has highest
population count in Cathedral Cave. Visual observations
estimated the population size to range from hundreds
to thousands of individuals roosting in walls and ceilings
inside the cave. ;
y
)
Among these 14 species, five were fruit bats,
comprising 36% of all bat species recorded from Pisan
caves during the current survey. They were observed
roosting in caves near fruiting trees and in caves with large
openings. Species such as C. brachyotis were netted in
caves near areas where fruit trees grows, while other fruit
bats such as E. spelaea and R. amplexicaudatus roosted
in caves such as Usok and Cathedral with large openings
and near water. According to Funakoshi & Zubaid (1997),
fruit bats such as Cynopterus sp. are common plant-
visiting bats that feed on fruits, flowers, and foliage. They
commonly roost in areas with high vegetation because
they are attracted to fruiting and flowering plants as it
complements their dietary requirements (Mohd-Azlan
et al. 2010). In Thailand, Bumrungsri et al. (2013) found
that E. spelaea, which commonly roosts in caves, is a
vital pollinator of many economically important plant
species. In Panay Island, large maternity colonies of fruit
bats, particularly R. amplexicaudatus, roosted in caves,
which were therefore important for the conservation of
their local populations (Mould 2012). In addition to fruit bats (Pteropodidae), 64% (n=5)
of the species are represented by insectivorous bat
species from families Emballonuridae, Hipposideridae,
Rhinolopidae
and
Vespertilionidae. Hipposideros
diadema was the most abundant comprising 18.7% of
the total number of captures and occupying all cave
sites. Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 RESULTS A second species
with a decreasing population, Emballonura alecto, was
recorded in Avenue, Usok and shortcut cave. (1/D=4.0, Lope cave (1/D=3.8) and Cathedral cave
(1/D=2.8). Remarkably, a threatened species with a
decreasing population, M. wetmorei was recorded
at two sites - Lope and Usok caves. A second species
with a decreasing population, Emballonura alecto, was
recorded in Avenue, Usok and shortcut cave. Image 1. Rousettus amplexicaudatus
© Krizler C. Tanalgo RESULTS A total of 14 species representing five chiropteran
families Pteropodidae, Emballonuridae, Hipposideridae,
Rhinolophidae, and Vespertilionidae were recorded
(Table 1). Cynopterus brachyotis accounted for the
highest relative abundance among all species in cave
sites with 26.3% of total captures, although it was
absent from Shortcut cave. It was followed by Rousettus
amplexicaudatus (Image 1) and Hipposideros diadema
with 22.4% and 18.7% relative abundance respectively. Moreover, H. diadema and two other species Myotis
horsfieldii and Rhinolophus arcuatus were common at
all cave sites.i This reciprocal form of Simpson’s index (1/D = Spi2),
which is considered to be the most accurate measure of
diversity (Rex et al. 2008) was used to compute the data
sets from the study. The computation was based only on
captured individuals. The value of this index starts with The frugivorous C. brachyotis was observed around Species
Lope
Avenue
Usok
Cathedral
Shortcut
Total
Species Relative
Abundance (%)
Pteropodidae
Cynopterus brachyotis
41
80
26
2
0
149
26.28
Eonycteris spelaea
0
12
17
1
0
30
5.29
Megaerops wetmorei # *
1
0
2
0
0
3
0.52
Ptenochirus jagori *
4
0
10
0
0
14
2.47
Rousettus amplexicaudatus
17
32
44
34
0
127
22.40
Hipposideridae
Hipposideros ater
2
0
0
0
0
2
0.35
Hipposideros diadema
41
12
15
29
9
106
18.69
Hipposideros pygmaeus *
0
4
2
0
2
8
1.41
Rhinolophidae
Rhinolophus arcuatus
7
6
5
6
12
36
6.35
Emballunuridae
Emballonura alecto
0
17
16
0
7
40
7.05
Vespertilionidae
Miniopterus australis
0
7
7
0
1
15
2.65
Miniopterus tristis
0
0
7
1
3
11
1.94
Myotis horsfieldii
5
4
6
1
4
20
3.53
Pipistrellus javanicus
0
6
0
0
0
6
1.06
Total # of individuals
118
180
157
74
38
567
100
Relative abundance of cave
bats per cave
20.8112875
31.746
27.6896
13.051146
6.70194
100
Species richness
8
10
12
7
7
Simpson's Reciprocal Index
3.805
4.041
7.014
2.748
5.286
Eveness
0.475625
0.4041
0.5845
0.3435
0.755143
Table 1. Taxonomic list of cave-dwelling bat species identified from Pisan caves, Kabacan, northern Cotabato, in South central Mindanao. L
d
# V l
bl
* E d
i t th Phili
i 8188 Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Tanalgo & Tabora (1/D=4.0, Lope cave (1/D=3.8) and Cathedral cave
(1/D=2.8). Remarkably, a threatened species with a
decreasing population, M. wetmorei was recorded
at two sites - Lope and Usok caves. DISCUSSION Both Hipposideros ater and Pipistrellus javanicus
were the least common species among cave sites with
0.35% and 1.05% relative abundance, respectively. Hipposideros ater was netted only from Lope cave and P. javanicus was present only in Avenue Cave. The role of caves as roosts for bats has recently
been reviewed by Furey & Racey (2016). Fruit bats are
important for seed dispersal, leading to the regeneration
of forests. They also play a vital role as pollinators in
lowland Malaysian rainforest (Hodgkinson et al. 2003). According to Tuttle (2011), approximately 70% of fruits
from trees or shrubs sold in tropical food markets depend
on bats for pollination. Furthermore, the presence of
fruit bats in disturbed areas such as those around Pisan
caves may promote forest regeneration and pollination
of many crops in the area (Fujita & Tuttle 1991). Among cave sites, 31.8% of all individual bats were
captured in Avenue cave followed by Usok and Lope
with 27.7% and 20.8% respectively. The lowest number
of individuals captured was at Shortcut caves (6.7%). The
highest species richness was recorded in Usok (n=12),
followed by the adjacent site, Avenue cave (n=10), then
Lope cave (n=8) and finally Cathedral and Shortcut caves
with seven species each. The
highest
computed
Simpson’s
Reciprocal
Index was recorded from Usok cave with 1/D=7 value
suggesting high species diversity at this cave site. This
was followed by shortcut cave (1/D=5.3), Avenue cave Two-thirds of the bat community in Pisan is Two-thirds of the bat community in Pisan is Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 8189 Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Tanalgo & Tabora comprised of insectivorous species. Hipposideros
diadema was the most abundant and common bat in all
cave sites in Pisan. It was also one of most abundant
insectivorous bat species recorded in other caves in
Mindanao in Iligan, Bukidnon, and Valencia in northern
Mindanao region, Davao Oriental in northeastern region
(Nuneza et al. 2010; Galorio & Nuneza 2014) and Samal
Island (Quibod et al. 2013). According to Heaney et al. (1991), H. diadema is widespread and common in the
Philippines particularly in primary forest and disturbed
lowland forest from sea level to 900m and is also known
to roost in low trees. In the present study H. ater and P. javanicus were the least recorded species occurring only
in a single cave, in Lope and Avenue cave respectively. DISCUSSION Hipposideros ater is found in many habitats. It is
known to roost in caves, primary and secondary forest
and agricultural areas (Heaney et al. 1998) and a few
individuals were also recorded from mining areas in
Mindanao Island (Tanalgo et al. in-review). In the
Philippines, this species may have declined as a result
of destruction of lowland forest and disturbance of
caves (Heaney et al. 1998; Heaney et al. 2010). While
P. javanicus is common in urban and agricultural areas,
and in secondary and primary lowland and montane
forest, it is uncommon in mossy forest, from sea level
to 1750m (Heaney et al. 1998). The presence of many
insectivorous bats in Pisan caves suggest they may play
a vital role in the area as major predators of nocturnal
insects and have the potential to act as biological pest
control agents in farmlands, where they can consume comprised of insectivorous species. Hipposideros
diadema was the most abundant and common bat in all
cave sites in Pisan. It was also one of most abundant
insectivorous bat species recorded in other caves in
Mindanao in Iligan, Bukidnon, and Valencia in northern
Mindanao region, Davao Oriental in northeastern region
(Nuneza et al. 2010; Galorio & Nuneza 2014) and Samal
Island (Quibod et al. 2013). According to Heaney et al. (1991), H. diadema is widespread and common in the
Philippines particularly in primary forest and disturbed
lowland forest from sea level to 900m and is also known
to roost in low trees. In the present study H. ater and P. javanicus were the least recorded species occurring only
in a single cave, in Lope and Avenue cave respectively. Hipposideros ater is found in many habitats. It is
known to roost in caves, primary and secondary forest
and agricultural areas (Heaney et al. 1998) and a few
individuals were also recorded from mining areas in
Mindanao Island (Tanalgo et al. in-review). In the
Philippines, this species may have declined as a result
of destruction of lowland forest and disturbance of
caves (Heaney et al. 1998; Heaney et al. 2010). While
P. javanicus is common in urban and agricultural areas,
and in secondary and primary lowland and montane
forest, it is uncommon in mossy forest, from sea level
to 1750m (Heaney et al. 1998). DISCUSSION The presence of many
insectivorous bats in Pisan caves suggest they may play
a vital role in the area as major predators of nocturnal
insects and have the potential to act as biological pest
control agents in farmlands, where they can consume insects up to 30‒100 % of their body weight each night
(Leelapaibul et al. 2005). The consumption of pest insects
by bats contributes to the reduction of insecticides used
in farm crops (Cleveland et al. 2006). Furthermore, the
guano from the bats is also good source of nutrient for
improving plant crops when used as a fertilizer (Furey &
Racey 2016).i We examined existing and recent reports of cave
bat diversity in the region with which to compare our
findings. In Visayas Island, Sedlock et al. (2014) surveyed
Bohol Island and a total of 29 species were identified,
19 of which are known to be cave dwellers. In Siquijor
Island, Sedlock et al. (2012) assessed a total of 20 large
caves and captured a total of 19 species, including 13
cave dwellers with only four caves containing relatively
large colonies and only five containing fruit bats. Mould
(2012) recorded large colonies of R. amplexicaudatus in
Panay Island. In Luzon - the largest Island in the Philippines, Galvan
(2012) surveyed cave bats in Polilio Island and recorded
10 cave bat species. Macasaet et al. (2011) reported bat
species in 14 cave sites in Marinduque Island with 13
species recorded including a single frugivorous species
R. amplexicaudatus. Moreover, Vinarao & Cabauatan
(2011) surveyed selected caves in the northern Sierra
Madre Natural Park, Luzon, Philippines and recorded 24
species. From previous and recent findings on cave bats,
we found that caves in Pisan in south Central Mindanao
has a relatively higher bat diversity and species richness
then other sites in the Archipelago. Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194
8190
Figure 2. Relative species richness in selected cave sites on Mindanao Island, Philippines, calculated by dividing the total number of species
recorded (r) by the total number of caves assessed (Nuňeza et al. 2010; Quibod et al. 2013; Requiroso et al. 2013; Warguez et al. 2013; Maca-
alang et al. 2014; Nuňeza et al. 2014). Journal
f Threatened Taxa | www threatenedtaxa org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15) 8185 8194
8190
Figure 2. Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Tanalgo & Tabora However, current cave destruction occurring in many
areas imperils this rich bat biodiversity in South central
Mindanao. There are an estimated 38 to 41 caves in Pisan
but from information provided by the local government
unit (LGU), it appears that cave sites claimed by locals
are part of some villages including Barangay Banawag,
Pentag, New Abra and Bangilan. Some caves are located
near the boundaries of the municipalities of Kabacan,
Carmen and Matalam. Hunting for food and trade were commonly
observed and identified by locals as threat for cave
bats. Local authorities reported that hunters came from
different sites and neighboring villages and towns. They
usually enter caves with larger mouth openings such as
Cathedral and Lope. To harvest bats roosting inside the
caves, a loud noise is made using pistols and disturbed
bats are captured using fishing nets placed in front of
cave openings. Hunters prefers large species such as
R. amplexicaudatus, Eonycteris spp. and H. diadema
for these species are abundant and common to all sites
especially caves with large openings and multiple entry
points. Local reports revealed that hunted cave bats
were beheaded and skinned alive, brought down to local
markets or sold in houses at 2.00 to 3.00 (US $ .06) pesos
per piece, a very cheap price compared to reported price
in some area which is 100 pesos (US $ 2.00) for three
pieces (Bat Conservation International 2010), some
locals consume bats as part of an exotic menu such as
‘Adobo’, a kind of casserole. This report is supported by
observations at cave sites. We found remains of dead
bats in cave openings and the darkening of the walls and
ceiling in Cathedral Cave, indicating that bats formerly
inhabited the cave but may have been removed or the
bats may have moved to another cave site. According
to Cardiff et al. (2009) hunting of pteropodids in
Madagascar occurs in highly accessible caves. In Panay
Island, Mould (2012) mentioned harvesting for food,
cultural use and treasure hunting in caves, and land
developments as threats to bats. We narrowed down our examination by comparing
our results to recent cave bat studies in other regions in
Mindanao. Relative species richness over the number of
caves assessed was used as a reference for comparison
(Fig. 2). Nuṅeza et al. (2010) conducted a Mindanao
Island-wide survey of cave vertebrates. Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines A total of 28
caves were surveyed which resulted in the record of 13
bat species. Nuṅeza & Galoria (2014) surveyed 10 caves
with eight species in northeastern region in Siargao
Island. Quibod et al. (2013) surveyed cave bats from
Samal Island, Davao Oriental and identified 15 species,
several of which were recorded in the current study. Requiroso et al. (2013) studied a total of six caves in
Mindanao with four species, from Zamboanga, Bacolod,
Lanao, and Misamis Oriental. In northeastern Mindanao,
Warguez et al. (2013) assessed the roosting preference
of three species of insectivorous bats and two species of
fruit bats, noting that E. spelaea and R. amplexicaudatus
prefer to cling on walls on areas with partial illumination. Maca-alang et al. (2014) identified six species from
caves in Lanao del Sur - E. spelaea, R. amplexicaudatus,
Miniopterus schreibersii, M. australis, H. diadema and
Rhinolophus arcuatus. Based on a comparison of the
number of caves assessed over the number of species
identified from throughout the Island of Mindanao,
Pisan caves in South central Mindanao contains a
relatively higher bat diversity. Such a comparison must
be viewed with caution because each survey may have
employed different methods for detection and different
sampling efforts. Furthermore, noteworthy in the present survey is
the presence of the endemic species H. pygmaeus, M. wetmorei and P. jagori in three caves in Pisan (Lope,
Avenue and Usok). Hipposideros pygmaeus is a poorly
known species known from caves and secondary forests
and thought to be widespread. However this species
is negatively impacted by degradation of cave habitats
(Heaney et al. 1998). In contrast, although M. wetmorei
is not endemic to the Philippines it is known to occur
only in the Mindanao faunal region, and only from
primary and lightly disturbed lowland forest from 800–
1200 m and is probably absent from montane forest
beyond 1500m (Heaney et al. 2006). Ptenochirus jagori
is widespread in various habitats in the Philippines with
a large and stable population, and tolerant of heavily
disturbed habitats (Heaney et al. 1998). The presence
of endemic and threatened species could pave the way
for implementing conservation and protection measures
at cave sites that are also tourism hotspots in Pisan, as it
shows that Pisan caves are suitable roosting habitats for
many bat species. Unregulated tourism is also among the threats
recorded in the area. DISCUSSION Relative species richness in selected cave sites on Mindanao Island, Philippines, calculated by dividing the total number of species
recorded (r) by the total number of caves assessed (Nuňeza et al. 2010; Quibod et al. 2013; Requiroso et al. 2013; Warguez et al. 2013; Maca-
alang et al. 2014; Nuňeza et al. 2014). Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194
8190
Figure 2. Relative species richness in selected cave sites on Mindanao Island, Philippines, calculated by dividing the total number of species
recorded (r) by the total number of caves assessed (Nuňeza et al. 2010; Quibod et al. 2013; Requiroso et al. 2013; Warguez et al. 2013; Maca-
alang et al. 2014; Nuňeza et al. 2014). 8190 Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 REFERENCES Conservation concerns noted from Pisan caves were
also noted in other regions. In recent years, reductions
in the numbers of cave bat populations have increasingly
concerned conservation biologists (Furey & Racey 2016). One of the major problems that places bat populations
at risk is their low reproductive rates which means
they are unable to recover quickly from population
declines (Mickleburgh et al. 2002). Human disturbance
at caves is a persistent problem internationally and
has been documented as a major cause of decline of
cave-dependent bats (Barbour & Davis 1969). Threats
to cave species occur both on the outside and inside
of the caves (Stone & Howarth 2007). Tourism and
absence of regulations are major threats to cave and
karst sites (Pulido-Bosch et al. 1997). Mickelburgh et al. (2002) added that many of the threats to bats can be
directly related to increasing human population causing
extra demands for land, food and other resources that
ultimately results in the degradation or destruction of
habitat for bats and other organisms. This pressure
is especially acute in tropical countries where a large
proportion of the population may live in rural areas and
have relatively low income. The willingness of the local
government and communities to cooperate remains an
important element in the conservation of caves and bats
in South central Mindanao. Barbour, R.W. & W.H. Davis (1969). Bats of America. University Press
of Kentucky, Lexington, 312pp. Bumrungsri, S., D. Lang, C. Harrower, E. Sripaoraya, K. Kitpipit & P.A. Racey (2013). The dawn bat, Eonycteris spelaea Dobson (Chiroptera:
Pteropodidae) feeds mainly on pollen of economically important
food plants in Thailand. Acta Chiropterologica 15(1): 95–104; http://
dx.doi.org/10.3161/150811013x667894 Cardiff, S.G., F.H. Ratrimomanarivo, G. Rembert & S.M. Goodman
(2009). Hunting, disturbance and roost persistence of bats in caves
at Ankarana, northern Madagascar. African Journal of Ecology 47(4):
640–649; http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2028.2008.01015.x 640–649; http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2028.2008.01015.x Cleveland, C.J., M. Betke, P. Federico, J.D. Frank, T.G. Hallam, J. Horn
& T.H. Kunz (2006). Economic value of the pest control service
provided by Brazilian free-tailed bats in south-central Texas. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 4(5): 238–243.t Corlett, R.T. (1998). Frugivory and seed dispersal by vertebrates in the
Oriental (Indomalayan) Region. Biological Reviews 73: 413–448;
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-185x.1998.tb00178.x Csorba, G., S. Bumrungsri, C. Francis, P. Bates, K. Helgen, M. Gumal, L. Heaney, D. Balete, A. Suyanto & I. Maryanto (2008). Emballonura
alecto. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2008; http://dx.doi. org/10.2305/IUCN.UK.2008.RLTS.T7670A12842113.en Fujita, M.S. & M.D. Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines There are inadequate protocols for
cave tourism in Pisan caves as exhibited by the absence
of local regulation of the number of visitors allowed
to enter the cave sites, uncontrolled deposits of waste
during visits, unregulated local guidance and entrance
fees. Heavy vandalism, use of bright lights, and coconut
torches inside the caves is further evidence that tourism
at the sites is unregulated. Quibod et al. (2013) noted
that guano collection and cave visitation were among
current threats in Samal Island. Furey et al. (2011) noted
harvesting for consumption and tourism developments Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 8191 Tanalgo & Tabora Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines in Vietnam were among the threats to the high bat
diversity in the country. and unregulated entry to caves sites were the most
persistent threats to bats, (4) Large species (Rousettus
amplexicaudatus, Eonycteris spelaea and Hipposideros
diadema) are preferred game species because of their
size and abundance. Additionally, locals perceived bats as pests causing
damage to their fruiting crops such as Durian Durio,
Rambutan Nephelium lappaceum and Lanzones Lansium
domesticum. Some locals believe in the ‘Aswang’ (a local
mythical creature) and that bats are associated with evil
and witchcraft though there is no major extermination
of bat colonies for these beliefs. Other local threats
that were noted outside the caves include the removal
of vegetation, deforestation and charcoal production,
which is also one of the major source of community
livelihood and income in Pisan. The results of the present survey and the presence
of unexplored cave sites in South central Mindanao
suggests further sampling and comprehensive cave
exploration is necessary to fully understand the
biodiversity of cave-dwelling bats in the region and to
establish their effective conservation. REFERENCES Tuttle (1991). Flying foxes (Chiroptera:
Pteropodidae): threatened animals of key ecological and economic
importance. Conservation Biology 5(4): 455–463; http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/0006-3207(93)90766-t i Funakoshi, K. & A. Zubaid (1997). Behavioural and reproductive
ecology of the Dog-faced Fruit Bats, Cynopterus brachyotis and C. horsfieldi, in a Malaysian rainforest. Mammal Study 22(1/2): 95–
108; http://dx.doi.org/10.3106/mammalstudy.22.95 i Furey, N.M., I.J. Mackie & P.A. Racey (2011). Reproductive phenology
of bat assemblages in Vietnamese karst and its conservation
implications. Acta Chiropterologica 13(2): 341–354; http://dx.doi. org/10.3161/150811011x624811 i Furey, N. & P.A. Racey (2016). Conservation Ecology of Cave Bats, pp. 463–500. In: Voigt, C. & T. Kingston (eds.). Bats in the Anthropocene
- Conservation of Bats in A Changing World. Springer, New York;
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-25220-9_15 Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Endangered
Species Research 8(1–2): 93–115; http://dx.doi.org/10.3354/
esr00182 gi
f
y
Climate Change, PICC, Manila, Philippines, February 1–3, 2010.t Philippine Cave Bat Committee (2011). The Philippine Caves and Bats. http://phcaves.crowdmap.com/reports <accessed on 19 October
2011> Kingston, T. (2010). Research priorities for bat conservation in
Southeast Asia: a consensus approach. Biodiversity and Conservation
19(2): 471–484; http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-0168-7_12 Protected Areas and Wildlife Bureau, Department of Environment
and Natural Resources, Philippines (PAWB-DENR). (2008). A
Handbook on Cave Classification for the Philippines. i Kingston, T., B.L. Lim & A. Zubaid (2006). Bats of Krau Wildlife Reserve. University Kebangsaan Malaysia, Penerbit UKM, Bangi, 115pp. ii
Pulido-Bosch, A., W. Martin-Rosales, M. López-Chicano, C.M. Rodriguez-Navarro & A. Vallejos (1997). Human impact in a tourist
karstic cave (Aracena, Spain). Environmental Geology 31(3-4): 142–
149; http://dx doi org/10 1007/s002540050173 Kunz, T.H., E.B. de Torrez, D. Bauer, T. Lobova & T.H. Fleming (2011). Ecosystem services provided by bats. Annals of the New York
Academy of Sciences 1223(1): 1–38; http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/
j.1749-6632.2011.06004.x t i
149; http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s002540050173 t
Quibod, N.M., P.A. Alviola, A.P. de Guia, I.L. Lit & V.C. Cuevas (2013). Diversity of cave-dwelling bats in Samal Island, Davao del Norte. Proceedings of the 22nd Philippine Biodiversity Symposium of the
Wildlife Conservation Society of the Philippines, Central Mindanao
University, Musuan, Bukidnon, April 21–23, 2013. Leelapaibul, W., S. Bumrungsri & A. Pattanawiboon (2005). Diet of
Wrinkle-lipped Free-tailed Bat (Tadarida plicata Buchannan, 1800)
in central Thailand: insectivorous bats potentially act as biological
pest control agents. Acta Chiropterologica 7(1): 111–119; http://
dx.doi.org/10.3161/1733-5329(2005)7[111:DOWFBT]2.0.CO;2 Restificar, S.D.F., D.J. Day & P.B. Urich (2006). Protection of karst in
the Philippines. Acta Carsologica 35(1): http://dx.doi.org/10.3986/
ac.v35i1.248 Maca-alang, J.M., B.V. dela Calzada, D.A. Warguez & D.L. Polestico
(2014). Diversity and diurnal roosting preferences of cave-
dwelling bats in Barangay Plaza and Lower Itil, Balabagan, Lanoa
del Sur, Philippines. Proceedings of the 23rd Philippine Biodiversity
Symposium of the Wildlife Conservation Society of the Philippines,
San Carlos University, Cebu City, April 1–7, 2014. Requiroso, M.L., F.C. Redoble, F.A. Serapio, K.D. Carmen, M.M. Geografo, K.A. Sanchez, F.A. Arumpac, M.M. Tangalin & D.A. Warguez (2013). Roosting Preferences of Bats in Selected Caves
of Mindanao. Proceedings of the 22nd Philippine Biodiversity
Symposium of the Wildlife Conservation Society of the Philippines,
Central Mindanao University, Musuan, Bukidnon, April 21–23, 2013. Macasaet, J.P., P.A. Alviola & A.V. Lacaste (2011). Diversity and habitats
of cave bats in Marinduque Island, Philippines. Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Tanalgo & Tabora community in a lowland dipterocarp forest. American Journal of
Botany 85(10): 1477–1501; http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2446404 Rickart, B.R. Tabaranza Jr. & R.C.B. Utzurrum (1998). A synopsis of
the mammalian fauna of the Philippine Islands. Fieldiana Zoology
88: 1–61; http://dx.doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.3419 community in a lowland dipterocarp forest. American Journal of
Botany 85(10): 1477–1501; http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2446404 Mould, A. (2012). Cave bats of the central west coast and southern
section of the Northwest Panay Peninsula, Panay Island, the
Philippines. Journal of Threatened Taxa 4(11): 2993–3028; http://
dx.doi.org/10.11609/jott.o3104.2993-3028 tt 88: 1–61; http://dx.doi.org/10.5962/bhl.title.3419 Heaney, L.R., M.L. Dolar, D.S. Balete, J.A. Esselstyn, E.A. Rickart & J.L. Sedlock (2010). Synopsis of Philippine Mammals. The Field Museum
of Natural History in co-operation with the Philippine Department of
Environment and Natural Resources - Protected Areas and Wildlife
Bureau. http://archive.fieldmuseum.org/philippine_mammals dx.doi.org/10.11609/jott.o3104.2993-3028 tt Myers, N., R.A. Mittermeier, C.G. Mittermeier, G.A. da Fonseca
& J. Kent (2000). Biodiversity hotspots for conservation
priorities. Nature 403(6772): 853–858.i ti
Ho, Y.Y. & L.L. Lee (2003). Roost selection by Formosan leaf-nosed bats
(Hipposideros armiger terasensis). Zoological Science 20(8): 1017–
1024; http://dx.doi.org/10.2108/zsj.20.1017 Nagy, Z.L. & T. Postawa (2011). Seasonal and geographical distribution
of cave‐dwelling bats in Romania: Implications for conservation. Animal Conservation 14(1): 74–86; http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/
j.1469-1795.2010.00392.x ii t
Hodgkison, R., S.T. Balding, A. Zubaid & T.H. Kunz (2003). Fruit Bats
(Chiroptera: Pteropodidae) as seed dispersers and pollinators in a
lowland Malaysian rain Forest. Biotropica 35(4): 491–502; http://
dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-7429.2003.tb00606.x Nassar, J., N. Ramirez & O. Linares (1997). Comparative pollination
biology of Venezuelan columnar cacti and the role of nectar-feeding
bats in their sexual reproduction. American Journal of Botany 84(7):
918–918; http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2446282 dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-7429.2003.tb00606.x Ingle, N.R. & L.R. Heaney (1992). A key to the bats of the Philippine
Islands. Fieldiana Zoology (NS) 69:1–44; http://dx.doi.org/10.5962/
bhl.title.3504 918–918; http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2446282 Nuñeza, O.M. & A.H.N. Galorio (2014). Cave bat fauna of Siargao
Island Protected landscape and seascape, Philippines. AES Bioflux
6(3): 243–255. Ingle, N.R., R.K. Gomez, M. Mendoza, L. Paguntalan, E. Sambale, J. Sedlock & D. Waldein (2011). Status of The Philippine Cave Bats. Proceedings of the Second International Southeast Asian Bat
Conference, Bogor, West Java, Indonesia, June 6–9, 2011. Nuňeza, O.M., R.C. Enguito, Y.I. Labajo & A.G. Ponce (2010). Vertebrate fauna in selected caves in Mindanao, the Philippines. Proceedings of the International Conference on Biodiversity and
Climate Change, PICC, Manila, Philippines, February 1–3, 2010.t Jones, G., D.S. Jacobs, T.H. Kunz, M.R. Willig & P.A. Racey (2009). Carpe noctem: the importance of bats as bioindicators. Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 CONCLUSION Galvan, R.J. (2012). Ecological Aspect of Arthropods on Cave dwelling
Bats of Polillo Island, Quezon: A progress report. Proceedings of the
20th Philippine Biodiversity Symposium of the Wildlife Conservation
Society of the Philippines, Silliman University, Dumaguete,
Philippines, April 19–20, 2011. This study has provided the first survey of bats in
selected caves sites in South central Mindanao. A total of
14 bat species with three endemics and two vulnerable
populations were identified. Field surveys revealed
the following: (1) accessible caves in Pisan contains
bat populations belonging to several different species,
(2) caves were exploited mainly for tourism and other
recreational purposes, (3) hunting for meat and trade, Heaney, L.R., P.C. Gonzales, R.C.B. Utzurrum & E.A. Rickart (1991). The
mammals of Catanduanes Island: implications for the biogeography
pf small land-bridge Islands in the Philippines. Proceedings of the
Biological Society of Washington 104(2): 399–415. Heaney, L.R., D.S. Balete, M.L. Dolar, A.C. Alcala, A.T.L. Dans, P.C. Gonzales, N.R. Ingle, M.V. Lepiten, W.L.R. Oliver, P.S. Ong, E.A. Heaney, L.R., D.S. Balete, M.L. Dolar, A.C. Alcala, A.T.L. Dans, P.C. Gonzales, N.R. Ingle, M.V. Lepiten, W.L.R. Oliver, P.S. Ong, E.A. Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 8192 Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Tanalgo & Tabora Filipino abstract: Ang pirmihang mikroklima sa mga kweba ay
nagbibigay ng isang katamtaman and maayos na tahanan para sa
maraming uri ng paniki sa Pilipinas, ngunit patuloy na sinisira ng mga
tao ang maraming kweba at maraming uri ng paniking kweba ang
nanganganib mawala. Sa gitnang-timog ng Mindanao, ang pag-aaral
sa ibat-ibang uri at ang estadong konserbasyon ng mga paniking kweba
ay hindi pa nadokumento at nasaliksik. Sa pamamagitan ng Mist-nets,
ang mga paniki ay hinuli mula sa limang kweba sa bayan ng Kabacan,
Hilagang Cotabato, Pilipinas. Sa isang kabuuan, 14 na uri ng paniki ang
nakilala, kabilang na dito ang Hipposideros pygmaeus at Ptenochirus
jagori na sa Pilipinas lamang matatagpuan, at ang nanganganib ng
maubos na Megaerops wetmorei. Gayunpaman, ang patuloy na
pagbaba ng estadong konserbasyon ng mga paniki, kasama ang mga
banta at aktibidad na maaring magpababa sa populasyon ng mga
paniki tulad pangangaso para sa karne at hindi makontrol na turismo
ay kasalukuyang nangyayari sa mga kweba. Ang mga malalaking uri
tulad ng Eonycteris spelaea at Rousettus amplexicaudatus ay araw-
araw na kinakatay para gawing pagkain at sa kalakalan. Samakatuwid,
ang mataas na bilang ng uri ng paniki sa mga kweba, at ang presensya
ng endemic at mga nanganganib na uri ay isang pagpapahiwatig
ng pangangailangan ng isang kagyat at epektibong interbensyong
konserbasyon kasama ang mga lokal na pamahalaan at mga
komunidad. Philippines with observations on ‘blasting-noise’ and bat activity. t Tuttle, M.D. (2011). Bats as Invaluable Allies. Accessed 13 August
2013. http://bankofnaturalcapital.com/2011/01/20/bats/ Tuttle, M.D. (2011). Bats as Invaluable Allies. Accessed 13 Au 2013. http://bankofnaturalcapital.com/2011/01/20/bats/ Vinarao, G.B. & J.G. Cabauatan (2011). Morphometrics and Ecology
of Order Chiroptera in Selected Caves of the Northern Sierra Madre
Natural Park, Luzon, Philippines. ISU-Cabagan Journal of Research
20(1): 1–10. Warguez, D., P.M. Tagarda & C.G. Demayo (2013). Diurnal roosting
preferences of cave-dwelling bats in Northeastern Agusan Del Norte,
Mindanao, Philippines. Extreme Life, Biospeology & Astrobiology
5(2): 103–116. Williams-Guillén, K., I. Perfecto & J. Vandermeer (2008). Bats limit
insects in a Neotropical agroforestry system. Science 320(5872):
70–70; http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.1152944 t
Wilson, D.E. & D.M. Reeder (Editors) (2005). Mammal Species of
the World: A Taxonomic and Geographic Reference (Vol. 12). John Hopkins University Press; http://dx.doi.org/10.5860/
choice.44-1281 Threatened Taxa Author Detail: Krizler C. Tanalgo is a former member of the Department of
Biological Sciences, University of Southern Mindanao where he worked as a
faculty and researcher. Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines Proceedings of the
21st Philippine Biodiversity Symposium of the Wildlife Conservation
Society of the Philippines, De la Salle University, Philippines, April
20–24, 2011. Rex, K., D.H. Kelm, K. Wiesner, T.H. Kunz & C.C. Voigt (2008). Species richness and structure of three Neotropical bat
assemblages. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 94(3): 617–
629; http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1095-8312.2008.01014.x McAleece, N., J.D.G. Gage, P.J.D. Lambshead & G.L.J. Paterson
(1997). Biodiversity Professional Statistics Analysis Software. Jointly
developed by the Scottish Association for Marine Science and the
Natural History Museum London. Rosell-Ambal, G., B. Tabaranza & S. Ramayla (2008). Megaerops
wetmorei. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2008. Accessed
September 1, 2013; http://dx.doi.org/10.2305/IUCN.UK.2008.RLTS. T12948A3401295.en Medellín, R.A., M. Equihua & M.A. Amin (2000). Bat diversity and
abundance as indicators of disturbance in Neotropical rainforests. Conservation Biology 14(6): 1666–1675; http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/
j.1523-1739.2000.99068.x Sedlock, J.L., R.P. Jose, J.M. Vogt, L.M.J. Paguntalan & A.B. Cariño
(2014). A survey of bats in a karst landscape in the central
Philippines. Acta Chiropterologica 16(1): 197–211; http://dx.doi. org/10.3161/150811014x683390 Mickleburgh, S.P., A.M. Hutson & P.A. Racey (2002). A review of
the global conservation status of bats. Oryx 36(01): 18–34; http://
dx.doi.org/10.1017/s0030605302000054 Sedlock, J.L. & N.R. Ingle (2010). Cave Bats of the Philippines: A
Photographic Guide with Species Accounts Extracted from the
Synopsis of Philippine Mammals. Mock Version. Mohd-Azlan, J., A.A. Tuen & A.R.M. Ridwan (2010). Preliminary
assessment of activity pattern and diet of the Lesser Dog-faced Fruit
Bat Cynopterus brachyotis in a Dipterocarp Forest, Sarawak, Borneo. Tropical Ecology 51(2): 297–302. Stone, F.D. & F.G. Howarth (2007). Hawaiian cave biology: status of
conservation and management, pp. 21–26. In: 2005 National Cave
and Karst Management Symposium. National Speleological Society,
Huntsville. Momose, K., T. Yumoto, T. Nagamitsu, M. Kato, H. Nagamasu, S. Sakai & T. Inoue (1998). Pollination biology in a lowland dipterocarp
forest in Sarawak, Malaysia. I. Characteristics of the plant-pollinator Tanalgo, K.C., L.F. Casim & J.A.G. Tabora (in review). Chiropteran
Species in a Small-scale Mining Site in South central Mindanao, Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 8193 Journal of Threatened Taxa | www.threatenedtaxa.org | 26 December 2015 | 7(15): 8185–8194 Cave-dwelling bats in South central Mindanao, Philippines His interest focused on bats, birds, and human-wildlife
interaction. Currently he is a Master student in Ecology and Conservation at
Xishuangbanna Tropical Botanical Garden, Chinese Academy of Sciences, China. John Aries G. Tabora is a professor at the Department of Biological Sciences,
University of Southern Mindanao. His research is focused on wildlife and habitat
conservation and currently leading the functional genomic project at the
university. Author Contribution: All authors of the paper contributed equally in data
gathering and writing of the final manuscript. All authors read and approved
the final manuscript. 8194
|
https://openalex.org/W4393221749
|
http://catalog.liha-pres.eu/index.php/liha-pres/catalog/download/258/7524/16959-1
|
Ukrainian
| null |
УПРАВЛІННЯ ЕФЕКТИВНІСТЮ ВИРОБНИЦТВА НА АГРАРНОМУ ПІДПРИЄМСТВІ
| null | 2,024
|
cc-by
| 717
|
p
g
УПРАВЛІННЯ ЕФЕКТИВНІСТЮ ВИРОБНИЦТВА
НА АГРАРНОМУ ПІДПРИЄМСТВІ
Бардась Артем Володимирович
доктор економічних наук,
професор кафедри менеджменту,
Національний технічний університет «Дніпровська політехніка»
Клименко Аркадій Тимофійович
аспірант кафедри менеджменту,
Національний технічний університет «Дніпровська політехніка» УПРАВЛІННЯ ЕФЕКТИВНІСТЮ ВИРОБНИЦТВА
НА АГРАРНОМУ ПІДПРИЄМСТВІ
Бардась Артем Володимирович
доктор економічних наук,
професор кафедри менеджменту,
Національний технічний університет «Дніпровська політехніка»
Клименко Аркадій Тимофійович
аспірант кафедри менеджменту,
Національний технічний університет «Дніпровська політехніка» НАПРЯМ 5. МЕНЕДЖМЕНТ
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36059/978-966-397-363-0-49
УПРАВЛІННЯ ЕФЕКТИВНІСТЮ ВИРОБНИЦТВА
НА АГРАРНОМУ ПІДПРИЄМСТВІ
Бардась Артем Володимирович
доктор економічних наук,
професор кафедри менеджменту,
Національний технічний університет «Дніпровська політехніка»
Клименко Аркадій Тимофійович
аспірант кафедри менеджменту,
Національний технічний університет «Дніпровська політехніка» НАПРЯМ 5. МЕНЕДЖМЕНТ НАПРЯМ 5. МЕНЕДЖМЕНТ DOI: https://doi.org/10.36059/978-966-397-363-0-49 УПРАВЛІННЯ ЕФЕКТИВНІСТЮ ВИРОБНИЦТВА
НА АГРАРНОМУ ПІДПРИЄМСТВІ Національний технічний університет «Дніпровська політехніка»
Клименко Аркадій Тимофійович
аспірант кафедри менеджменту, Управління ефективністю виробництва стає предметом розгляду
менеджменту з моменту зародження останнього, хоча фокус уваги
дослідників постійно змінювався. Сьогодні, якщо мова йде про
менеджмент аграрних підприємств та їх структурних підрозділів, то тут
домінуючою стала ресурсна концепція, відповідно до якої ефективність
господарської
діяльності
підприємства
визначається
здатністю
менеджерів забезпечувати максимально повне використання його
ресурсного потенціалу, а сам ресурсний потенціал при цьому
трактується
як
сукупність
властивостей,
що
є
незмінними
у
короткостроковій перспективі його діяльності та визначають можливості
підприємства на ринку [1, c. 26–27]. Саме з цих міркувань керівництву
підприємства необхідно визначати ключові показники ефективності
для трудових, фінансових, матеріальних, технічних ресурсів аграрного
підприємства,
а
також
розроблення
та
реалізації
комплексу
управлінських заходів з урахуванням динаміки ринкового середовища. Таким чином, керівництво (менеджмент) аграрного підприємства
повинно визнавати той факт, що ефективність є відносною категорією,
що в будь-який визначений момент часу визначається поєднанням умов
зовнішнього та внутрішнього по відношенню до цієї організації
середовища. Приклади впливу внутрішнього середовища можна
побачити на прикладах того, як воєнні дії російсько-української війни
обмежили доступ виробників аграрної продукції до морських портів, як
протести фермерів в країнах Європи обмежують можливості експорту до
країн Європейського Союзу, так само як і транзит української продукції
через територію країн-членів. Так само вартість палива та матеріально-
технічних засобів, доступність позикових коштів та передбачуваність 183 валютно-фінансової
політики
Національного
банку
визначає
ефективність діяльності підприємства саме з позиції впливу зовнішнього
середовища. У статтях [2, c. 7, 3] серед показників, які дозволяють оцінити
ефективність управління аграрним підприємством, визначаються як
традиційні абсолютні (валовий прибуток чи збиток), так і відносні
(частка прибутку на одного адміністративного працівника, питому вагу
адміністративного персоналу у загальній чисельності працівників,
питома вага витрат на оплату праці у повній собівартості продукції), а
також питомих витрат на утримання парку сільськогосподарської
техніки (машинно-тракторного парку). Довгаль О.В. відзначає, що
причинами низької ефективності аграрних підприємств є низька
забезпеченість трудовими ресурсами та матеріальними оборотними
активами [4, с. 21], рекомендуючи концентрувати увагу керівників на
підвищенні рівня інтенсивності використання виробничих ресурсів. р
р
р
р
ур
Варто відзначити, що проблема низького рівня залученості трудових
ресурсів є абсолютно закономірним наслідком промислової революції
та
процесів
урбанізації,
коли
зростання
міського
населення
супроводжується зменшенням сільського. УПРАВЛІННЯ ЕФЕКТИВНІСТЮ ВИРОБНИЦТВА
НА АГРАРНОМУ ПІДПРИЄМСТВІ Утім, на відміну від минулих
років описана проблема не є критичною, оскільки зростання рівня
механізації
та
автоматизації
аграрного
виробництва
дозволяє
забезпечувати
приріст
обсягів
продукції
за
умови
зменшення
чисельності працюючих: очевидною умовою такого стану речей є
оновлення парку сільськогосподарської техніки та доступ до фінансових
ресурсів, які можуть бути як від власників-інвесторів, так і від установ
банківського сектору. Правильна організація використання земельних ресурсів також є
однією з умов досягнення ефективності – це охоплює і питання вибору
видів сільськогосподарських культур, і дотримання термінів та норм
внесення добрив, часу початку посівної і жнив, а також зберігання
родючості земель і уникнення їхнього виснаження внаслідок виробничої
діяльності. Список використаних джерел: 1. Воловик Д.В. Розвиток системи управління ресурсним потенціалом
аграрних підприємств : дис. … канд. екон. наук : 08.00.04. Дніпро, 2016. 179 с. 1. Воловик Д.В. Розвиток системи управління ресурсним потенціалом
аграрних підприємств : дис. … канд. екон. наук : 08.00.04. Дніпро, 2016. 179 с. 2. Лесюк В.С. Управління ефективністю використання машинно-тракторного
парку аграрних підприємств. Агросвіт. 2020. № 15. С. 74–80. DOI: https://doi.org/
10.32702/2306-6792.2020.15.74 2. Лесюк В.С. Управління ефективністю використання машинно-тракторного
парку аграрних підприємств. Агросвіт. 2020. № 15. С. 74–80. DOI: https://doi.org/
10.32702/2306-6792.2020.15.74 3. Колесник В.М., Гросу А.Д. Оцінка стану управління та його ефективності в
аграрних підприємствах. Інноваційна економіка. 2018. № 6 (25). С. 98–104. р р
р
(
)
4. Довгаль О.В. Механізм ефективного управління ресурсним потенціалом
аграрних підприємств. Агросвіт. 2016. № 5. С. 20–22. 4. Довгаль О.В. Механізм ефективного управління ресурсним потенціалом
аграрних підприємств. Агросвіт. 2016. № 5. С. 20–22. 184
|
https://openalex.org/W2887165702
|
https://www.matec-conferences.org/10.1051/matecconf/201818304005/pdf
|
English
| null |
Sustainable Development in Accordance With the Concept of Industry 4.0 on the Example of the Furniture Industry
|
MATEC web of conferences
| 2,018
|
cc-by
| 2,874
|
© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Sustainable Development in Accordance With
the Concept of Industry 4.0 on the Example of
the Furniture Industry Anna Wiśniewska-Sałek1,*
1Czestochowa University of Technology, Faculty of Management, Poland Abstract. Sustainable development, as an integral part of building an
economically rational market, is a challenge which is faced by many
branches of the economy. The paper is an attempt to assess the
opportunities provided by Industry 4.0 in the process of sustainable
development of the furniture industry in Poland, making use of the
experiences resulting from the participation of the Author in the project co-
funded by the Erasmus+ Program of the European Union “Curriculum
Development of Master’s Degree Program in Industrial Engineering for
Thailand Sustainable Smart Industry - MSIE4.0”. * Corresponding author: anna.wisniewska-salek@wz.pcz.pl MATEC Web of Conferences 183, 04005 (2018)
QPI 2018 MATEC Web of Conferences 183, 04005 (2018)
QPI 2018 https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201818304005 MATEC Web of Conferences 183, 04005 (2018)
QPI 2018 https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201818304005 The origin of the term “Industry 4.0” comes from the government of the Federal
Republic of Germany when in 2011 it was used by the initiative group “Industrie 4.0”
(representatives of the world of business, politics and science) who identified the name with
the concept of increasing the competitiveness of the German economy. Meanwhile, the
government, while providing the support, acknowledged that the name of “Industry 4.0”
would be an integral part of the program of the development of the country. The key
objective of the program is leadership in the field of innovative technologies on a global
scale [2]. The essence of “Industry 4.0” is brought to creating intelligent value chains, based on
sociotechnical systems which are dynamic, self-organizing and optimizing, perceived as
smart factories [3]. They are created by spontaneously emerging virtual networks: Internet
of Services [4], Internet of Things [5], cloud computing [6], which include both employees,
machinery and equipment: augmented reality [7], artificial intelligence [8] Human Machine
Interface [9], and supporting IT systems: robotics [10], intelligent production [11], digital
transformation [12], cyber-physical systems [13]. These value chains are to a certain extent
a dynamic network which is centered around a unified object of cooperation. The network
is subjected to constant reconfiguration, which depends on the current objectives and
conditions, ensuring high flexibility and production efficiency.[1] The solutions changing
the modern industry into the one operating in accordance with “Industry 4.0” make the
Internet a driving force in the organization of operational work [14]. 1 Introduction Global economic development brought about that the industry should respond relatively
quickly to the market requirements while complying with high quality standards. Economic
criteria clearly depict the pattern which technology, employees and resources ought to
adjust to. Production processes adapted to the dynamics of changes imposed by the
economic leader (regardless of who they are) should be possibly the most innovative and
automated. The human being, wishing to be a part of this process of changes must “be
a lifelong learner” simultaneously having an interdisciplinary experience”. The
environment ought to “produce” infinite amounts of resources and help (taking into
account, e.g. clean air) the human existence. The idea of sustainable development allows
for maintaining a relative balance between the listed criteria. The economy and more specifically its development largely depends on production
capacities. The processes of automation and digitization lead to the transformation of the
currently existing factories into the so called Smart Factories, which allow for creating
intelligent value chains. The industry operating in this way is described with the term of
“Industry 4.0“, which refers to “the fourth industrial revolution” taking place at the
moment. The revolution is the reference to the previous stages in the socio-economic
development of humankind which may include [1]: revolution 1.0: mechanization of
production using water and steam driven machines; revolution 2.0: mass production based
on the division of labor and electrification of machinery and equipment; revolution 3.0: use
of electronics and information technology to automate production. MATEC Web of Conferences 183, 04005 (2018)
QPI 2018 2 Sustainable development In accordance with the Polish Environmental Protection Act, sustainable development is
understood as “[…] socio-economic development in which there takes place the process of
integrating political, economic and social activities maintaining the natural balance and
durability of basic natural processes in order to guarantee the possibility of satisfying basic
needs of individual communities or citizens of both modern generation and future ones
[15].” The definition of sustainable development is associated with the UN since the report
of this organization recorded it for the first time in 1987 in Our Common Future as a result
of the work of the World Commission on Environment and Development [16]. Satisfying
the needs of each of the key factors of sustainable development, being in the mutual
correlation, is a very difficult process. “The fourth industrial revolution”, being an integral
part of economic development and processes taking place in a globalized world, is also
a challenge in the field of its significance in balancing the needs of all participants of
economic processes. From the point of view of the organization, it is very important to
maintain a balance between innovation which is the measure of the efficiency of the
organization and practices of sustainable development which is aimed at achieving
efficiency in the field of sustainable development due to a gradual improvement in its
individual processes. [17] The economic situation of each country is generated by the emphasis on continuous
economic growth, which is very often associated with an increasingly high consumption of
already limited natural resources. This is related to the lack of synthesis between the
exhaustibility and renewability of raw materials, which recently has been the source of
many environmental and social problems. Sustainable development, as an idea practiced for
many years, encounters numerous economic, political and cultural barriers, which i.e. lead
to crossing the limits of tolerance of the nature. [18] The industry depending on renewable
natural resources is the furniture production. In accordance with the report by PDF (Polish
Development Fund), the furniture industry (taking into account manufacturing industries),
in terms of net export value, occupies the second position and at the same time constitutes
a significant part of the Polish economy. 2.1 The industry - automation The development of the furniture industry brought about that it began to face some
constraints resulting at least from the globalization of distribution or problems with human
capital resources. Striving for production automation and robotics will allow for gaining
a competitive advantage using economies of scale. This is associated with an increase in
investments in the use of the latest generation solutions in the field of the automated
interoperational transport; additionally, the implementation of the methodology of the
operation of Lean principles (e.g. Lean Production), the use of autonomous and
collaborative robots as well as or above all the use of all available IT resources in the
correlation of subsequent stages of production. [19] “Industry 4.0”, in its concept, includes the areas closely related to IT. Its main elements
include: 1. Industrial Internet of Things – IIoT, originating from Internet of Things – IoT:
formulated by Kevin Ashton in 1999. It consists in the use of data transmission via the
Internet network using the radio identification of RFID to manage the value chain [20]. 2. Smart Factory: constitutes the key characteristic of Industrie 4.0. It is assumed that
factories are managed comprehensively thus being less susceptible to disturbances. In this
way, they are able to produce more efficiently and humans, machinery and resources
communicate with each other following the principles of social network [21]. 3. Cyber-
Physical Systems (CPS): consists in combining the computational layer and physical
processes, where the system of the review of the manufacturing process functions in the
feedback loop. Physical processes are identified as the data source used for calculating the
control signal of the selected executive objects [22]. 2 Sustainable development In 2016, exports of goods in the CN 94 group (the 2 MATEC Web of Conferences 183, 04005 (2018)
QPI 2018 https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201818304005 descriptive version of the Combined Nomenclature 2016 - Chapter 94: furniture; bedding,
mattresses, mattress supports, cushions and similar stuffed furnishings; lamps and lighting
fittings, not elsewhere specified or included; illuminated advertising, illuminated signs and
the like; prefabricated buildings) exceeded PLN 48 billion. The share of sales of this
industry (according to PKD – Polish Classification of Activities 2007, Chapter 31) in GDP
for furniture producers (over 49 employees) remains at the level of about 2% and more than
130 thousand people are employed in this industry. [19] 2.2 The society - education Rapid economic growth, among others in Poland, brought about an increase in the need for
employees. Increased production caused by a high share of sales in GDP, also in the
furniture industry, brought about the same effect. The statistics by Central Statistical Office
show that, in Poland, in 2017 there were registered 1081746 unemployed people with the
following educational background: higher education - 149491; post-secondary, upper
secondary vocational education - 234599; general secondary education - 117266;
vocational education - 281679; lower secondary education and below - 298711. The
number of the unemployed steadily indicates a downward trend. [23] In turn, the analysis of
the higher education market conducted by Wiśniewska-Sałek or Ulewicz [26], indicated
that the number of engineering graduates, which are of particular significance in industrial
sectors, varied [24]. The detailed listing is presented in Figure 1. A drop in the interest in
engineering studies in the context of other types of studies showed the smallest declines and
in the academic year of 14/15-13/14 – even large increases. Obviously, the situation of a
declining population among young people is the interpretation of such a downturn. Managerial skills, which freely allow for keeping up intellectually with communication
technologies, may also become significant. Such people, while excluding practical 3 MATEC Web of Conferences 183, 04005 (2018)
QPI 2018 https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201818304005 knowledge, have the ability to use “computer technologies” at the same time constituting
the so called senior manager [25]. Fig. 1. The dynamics of changes in the number of graduates in the Poland from the academic year of
2012/2013 to 2015/2016. knowledge, have the ability to use “computer technologies” at the same time constituting
the so called senior manager [25]. knowledge, have the ability to use “computer technologies” at the same time constituting
the so called senior manager [25]. Fig. 1. The dynamics of changes in the number of graduates in the Poland from the academic year of
2012/2013 to 2015/2016. Social Product Development (SPD) is one of the elements of “Industry 4.0” from the
social point of view. This idea has no unambiguous definition. It is identified with the
involvement of the team (which includes the qualified group of people from the inside
or/and the outside of the company) in the development of the product using: technologies,
social tools and media. 2.2 The society - education Users have impact on the product life cycle (subsequent stages of
design), due to which a new product, introduced into the market, has a shorter time of
development and is burdened with lower investments. [22] From the point of view of the
furniture industry, the fact that, with such a large share of this industry in the national
economy, only 3 universities provide education in the field of tree farming and 4
universities – in the field of forestry, seems to be disturbing. 2.3 The environment - natural resources (wood) The wood industry, as relating to the renewable natural raw material, is one of the key and
most difficult to implement parts of sustainable development. The situation depends on the
time which is needed by forest stands to “recover” its resources and its general usability in
purifying the air and, on the other, the rapid development of the industry indicates an
increased demand for this raw material. According to the statistical data published by
Central Statistical Office, the area of forest land in Poland in recent 6 years (2010-2016)
increased on average by 0.19% with an increase of 0.2% in woodiness, at the same time
occupying less than 30% of the area of the country. In accordance with the Regulation by
the Minister of Environment, the minimum felling age for individual species ranges from
30 years, e.g. for poplar and up to 120 years for oak and ash, it is connected with the
problem of sustainability. On the basis of the data by Central Statistical Office, it can be
observed that in years 2010-2016 the dynamics of changes (chain index) of restoration and
a forestation in Poland was the following: 8.7%; 2.1%; -3.8%; 2.2%; 3.4%; -1.0%. At the
same time, in the research period, there was received the following dynamics of
changeability of the acquired large timber: 3.90%; 0.29%; 2.34%; 5,21%; 1.77%; 2.09%
due to which there was acquired 33568291 m3 of wood in 2010 and as much as
39129329m3 in 2016. The restoration of forest land may take place naturally or artificially. With a significant increase in the acquisition of large timber in 2016 compared to 2015
there was artificially restored only 1.4% more of forest land with no natural restoration (-
13.4%). The assumptions of “Industry 4.0” do not directly translate into the environment
but indirectly, through more efficient use of raw materials for production, it is possible to 4 https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201818304005 MATEC Web of Conferences 183, 04005 (2018)
QPI 2018 reduce production waste or utilizing a more appropriate technology use it more
significantly. reduce production waste or utilizing a more appropriate technology use it more
significantly. Acknowledgements g
This publication is a partial outcome of project „Curriculum Development of Master’s Degree
Program in Industrial Engineering for Thailand Sustainable Smart Industry (MSIE4.0)” that has been
funded with support from the European Commission (Project Number: 586137-EPP-1-2017-1-TH-
EPPKA2-CBHE-JP). 3 Conclusions Industry 4.0 very clearly and legibly outlines the bridge between the economy and social
expectations. On the one hand, it creates the grounds for the development of technological
innovation but, on the other, shows how important the human being is in this whole
process. On the one hand, it fosters economic development and, on the other, satisfies staff
shortages with automation. On the one hand, it streamlines and optimizes production time
and, on the other, allows the transfer of dangerous and burdensome tasks from the human
being to the machinery. It allows for using the mental potential of the human being instead
of crushing it. All these activities bring about that there may occur the co-integration
correlation between sustainable development and “the fourth industrial revolution”. An
example of the implementation of the assumptions of “Industry 4.0” in accordance with the
social dimension of sustainable development is the project MSIE4.0. Project assumes an
increase in opportunities and capacity of universities in Thailand (based on the experience
of European countries, including Polish) to provide a high-quality syllabus – based on
competencies for Masters courses in the field of industrial engineering, which supports
sustainable smart industry (Industry 4.0) and is compliant with European Qualifications
Framework. Disclaimer
Thi
bli This publication reflects the views only of the authors, and the Commission cannot be held
responsible for any use which may be made of the information contained therein. References 1. J. Bendkowski, Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Śląskiej, 112 (2017) 2. H. Kagermann, W. Lukas, W. Wahlster, VDI nachrichten, 13 (2011) 3. P.N. Koustoumpardis, J.S. Fourkiotis, N.A. Aspragathos, International Journal of
ClothingScience and Technology, 19, 2 (2007) 4. J. Cardoso, K. Voigt, M. Winkler, ICEIS 2008, LNBIP, 19 (2009) 5. T. Qu, S.P. Lei, Z.Z. Wang, D.X. Nie, X. Chen, G.Q. Huang, Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol., 84, 1-4 (2015) 6. F. Scavo, B. Newton, M. Longwell, Computer Economics Report, 34, 8 (2012) 7. V. Paelke, IEEE Emerging Technology and Factory Automation (ETFA), (2014) 8. S.P.L. Kumar, Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, 65 (2017) 9. D. Gorecky, M. Schmitt, M. Loskyll, IEEE International Conference on Industrial
Informatics (INDIN), (2014) 10. B. Kehoe, S. Patil, P. Abbeel, K. Goldberg K, IEEE Transactions on Automation
Science and Engineering, 12, 2 (2015) 5 MATEC Web of Conferences 183, 04005 (2018)
QPI 2018 https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201818304005 11. R.Y. Zhong, X. Xu, E. Klotz, S.T. Newman S.T, Engineering, 3, 5 (2017) 12. A. Ustundag, E. Cevikcan, Industry 4.0: Managing The Digital Transformation
(Springer, Berlin, 2017) 13. N. Jazdi, IEEE Conference on Automation, Quality and Testing, Robotics (AQTR),
(2014) 14. W. Torbacki, data odczytu 27.04.2018:
http://www.ptzp.org.pl/files/konferencje/kzz/artyk_pdf_2018/T2/2018_t2_716.pdf 15. Prawo ochrony środowiska z dnia 27 kwietnia 2001 r., art.3, pkt.50. 16. A. Pawłowski, Środkowo-Pomorskie Towarzystwo Naukowe Ochrony Środowiska, 11
(2009) 17. F. Susanto, W. Arafah, Z. Husin, Polish Journal of Management Studies, 16, 2 (2017 18. A. Pabian, Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Częstochowskiej Zarządzanie, 28, 1 (2017 19. Polskie Meble. Raport specjalny. Inwestycje dla Polski, Data odczytu 27.04.2018:
https://www.paih.gov.pl/files/?id_plik=30887 20. K. Ashton, Data odczytu 29.04.2018: http://www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?4986 21. H. Kagermann, W. Wahlster, J. Helbig J., Data odczytu 27.04.2018 :
http://www.acatech.de/fileadmin/user_upload/Baumstruktur_nach_Website/Acatech/ro
ot/de/Material_fuer_Sonderseiten/Industrie_4.0/Final_report__Industrie_4.0_accessibl
e.pdf 22. P. Wittbrodt, I. Łapuńka, Data odczytu 29.04.2018:
http://www.ptzp.org.pl/files/konferencje/kzz/artyk_pdf_2017/T2/t2_793.pdf 23. Bank Danych Lokalnych: https://bdl.stat.gov.pl/BDL/start 24. A. Wiśniewska-Sałek, Knowledge For Market Use 2017: People In Economics –
Decisions, Behavior And Normative Models. International Scientific Conference
Proceedings, Pavla Slavíčková (Ed.), Palacký University, Olomouc (2017) 25. L. Kiełtyka, Przegląd Organizacji, 8 (2016) 26. R. Ulewicz, Polish Journal of Management Studies, 8 (2013) 6
|
https://openalex.org/W1981713576
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc4348603?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
Real-Time Scintigraphic Assessment of Intravenous Radium-223 Administration for Quality Control
|
BioMed research international
| 2,015
|
cc-by
| 3,415
|
Academic Editor: Shekhar Kumta Copyright © 2015 Chadwick L. Wright et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly
cited. Radium-223 (223Ra) dichloride is an approved intravenous radiotherapy for patients with osseous metastases from castration-
resistant prostate cancer (CRPC). In addition to the therapeutic alpha radiation, there is additional 223Ra radiation generated
which produces photons that can be imaged with conventional gamma cameras. No studies have evaluated real-time and quality
imaging during intravenous 223Ra administration to verify systemic circulation and exclude 223Ra extravasation at the injection
site. A retrospective review was performed for fifteen 223Ra administrations for CRPC patients which were imaged using a large
field of view portable gamma camera (LFOVPGC) for the purposes of quality control and patient safety. Dynamic imaging of
the chest was performed before, during, and after the 223Ra administration to verify systemic circulation, per institutional clinical
protocol. Before and after 223Ra administration, a static image was obtained of the intravenous access site. Dynamic imaging of the
chest confirmed systemic administration early during the 1-minute injection period for all patients. There were no cases of focal
223Ra extravasation at the site of intravenous access. These results verify that systemic 223Ra administrations can be quantified with
real-time imaging using an LFOVPGC. This simple approach can confirm and quantify systemic circulation of 223Ra early during
injection and exclude focal extravasation for the purposes of quality control. Hindawi Publishing Corporation
BioMed Research International
Volume 2015, Article ID 324708, 6 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/324708 Hindawi Publishing Corporation
BioMed Research International
Volume 2015, Article ID 324708, 6 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/324708 Hindawi Publishing Corporation
BioMed Research International
Volume 2015, Article ID 324708, 6 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/324708 Research Article
Real-Time Scintigraphic Assessment of Intravenous
Radium-223 Administration for Quality Control Chadwick L. Wright,1 J. Paul Monk III,2 Douglas A. Murrey Jr.,1 and Nathan C. Hall1
1Department of Radiology, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, 410 West Tenth Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210, USA
2Division of Medical Oncology, Department of Internal Medicine, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center,
410 West Tenth Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210, USA Correspondence should be addressed to Nathan C. Hall; nathan.hall@uphs.upenn.edu Correspondence should be addressed to Nathan C. Hall; nathan.hall@uphs.upenn.edu Received 13 October 2014; Accepted 24 January 2015 Academic Editor: Shekhar Kumta 1. Introduction All patients referred for 223Ra radiotherapy must initially be
evaluated for verification of osseous metastases using intra-
venous Technetium-99m (99mTc) MDP bone scintigraphy or
intravenous sodium fluoride-18 (Na18F) PET/CT to insure
eligibility for therapy [3, 4]. A complete course of 223Ra
dichloride radiotherapy involves intravenous administration
of 223Ra every 4 weeks for 6 cycles. Most of the radioactivity
produced by 223Ra results from the production of therapeutic
alpha particles which travel only a very short distance in bone
but are sufficiently energetic for therapeutic benefit. There
is additional radiation generated by 223Ra which produces
photons (i.e., 81 and 84 keV) that have potential to be imaged
using routine clinical nuclear medicine imaging [1, 3, 5]. To
date, no studies have evaluated real-time and quality imaging
during intravenous 223Ra administration to verify systemic All patients referred for 223Ra radiotherapy must initially be
evaluated for verification of osseous metastases using intra-
venous Technetium-99m (99mTc) MDP bone scintigraphy or
intravenous sodium fluoride-18 (Na18F) PET/CT to insure
eligibility for therapy [3, 4]. A complete course of 223Ra
dichloride radiotherapy involves intravenous administration
of 223Ra every 4 weeks for 6 cycles. Most of the radioactivity
produced by 223Ra results from the production of therapeutic
alpha particles which travel only a very short distance in bone
but are sufficiently energetic for therapeutic benefit. There
is additional radiation generated by 223Ra which produces
photons (i.e., 81 and 84 keV) that have potential to be imaged
using routine clinical nuclear medicine imaging [1, 3, 5]. To
date, no studies have evaluated real-time and quality imaging
during intravenous 223Ra administration to verify systemic Targeted radiotherapy is a technique for treating primary
malignancies and metastatic disease with intravascular
administration of therapeutic radioisotopes, peptides, anti-
bodies, and microspheres. 223Ra dichloride is approved for
intravenous radiotherapy for patients with osseous metas-
tases from castration-resistant prostate cancer (CRPC). 223Ra
is an alpha-particle emitting radioisotope that mimics cal-
cium and forms complexes with hydroxyapatite at areas
of increased bone turnover, such as osseous metastases. 223Ra has a half-life of 11.4 days. Osseous metastases from
CRPC are amenable to targeted radiotherapy using 223Ra
and have the advantage of maximizing local alpha radiation
effects to osseous metastases while minimizing radiation
toxicity to adjacent normal bone and soft tissues [1, 2]. circulation and exclude 223Ra extravasation at the injection
site. circulation and exclude 223Ra extravasation at the injection
site. 2. Materials and Methods The purpose was to confirm
the presence of detectable 223Ra activity in syringe prior to
injection and obtain background activity level assessments
of the injection room and the patient’s anterior chest before
administration. The total preinjection LFOVPGC imaging
time was 3 minutes (1 minute per image). 2.5. Statistics. Unless otherwise indicated, all values are
expressed as mean ± standard deviation. Linear regression
analysis of LFOVPGC counts and syringe 223Ra activity was
performed using JMP Pro 10.0.2 (SAS Institute, Inc.). 2. Materials and Methods This retrospective study was approved by the Institutional
Review Board at the Ohio State University Wexner Medical
Center (OSUWMC). Between October 2013 and January
2014, 15 radiotherapy administrations of 223Ra dichloride
for 8 CRPC patients were performed and imaged using
an institutional PGC imaging protocol for the purposes of
quality control and patient safety. All 8 patients had received
at least one prior administration of 223Ra. (a) (b) Figure 3: Postinjection LFOVPGC imaging of the capped empty
syringe (left, 1 minute) and IV injection site (right, 1 minute). dynamic LFOVPGC imaging time was 5 minutes for the
dynamic imaging of the therapeutic IV administration. 2.1. Imaging Protocol. The imaging protocol utilized an
LFOVPGC (DIGIRAD Ergo, DIGIRAD Corporation, Poway,
CA, USA) operating under the Xenon-133 setting (photopeak
of 81 keV with a 10% window) with a 128 × 128 matrix for
preinjection and postinjection 223Ra planar and dynamic
imaging. Low energy all purpose (LEAP) collimation was
used. All images were subsequently processed using a Philips
EBW workstation. 2.4. Postinjection Imaging. Following slow IV injection of
223Ra and removal of the dedicated IV access, 1-minute static
images, each of the patient’s IV injection site and the capped
empty syringe, were obtained (Figure 3). The purpose of these
images was to confirm the presence or absence of any residual
223Ra activity in syringe or syringe cap after injection and
to assess any gross extravasation of 223Ra at the IV injection
site. The total postinjection LFOVPGC imaging time was 2
minutes (one minute per image). 2.2. Preinjection Imaging. Prior to injection, a 1-minute static
image of the background activity in the injection room was
obtained as well as 1-minute static images of the patient’s
capped syringe containing the treatment dose and the
patient’s anterior chest (Figure 1). The purpose was to confirm
the presence of detectable 223Ra activity in syringe prior to
injection and obtain background activity level assessments
of the injection room and the patient’s anterior chest before
administration. The total preinjection LFOVPGC imaging
time was 3 minutes (1 minute per image). 2.2. Preinjection Imaging. Prior to injection, a 1-minute static
image of the background activity in the injection room was
obtained as well as 1-minute static images of the patient’s
capped syringe containing the treatment dose and the
patient’s anterior chest (Figure 1). 1. Introduction BioMed Research International 2 and 3 saline flushes
LFOV
PGC
223Ra dichloride
IV over 1min
Figure 2: Dynamic LFOVPGC imaging of the anterior chest during
intravenous administration of 223Ra and subsequent saline flushes
(5-minute continuous imaging 6 sec/frame). Background
no
syringe
LFOV
PGC
(a)
Capped syringe
LFOV
PGC
with 223Ra dose
(b)
IV site
Background
anterior chest
LFOV
PGC
(c)
Figure 1: Preinjection LFOVPGC imaging (one minute per image)
of the injection room background (left), capped syringe containing
the 223Ra dose (middle), and anterior chest background (right). The
LFOVPGC detector head is represented by either a gray trapezoid
or gray square just overlying the imaging target. and 3 saline flushes
LFOV
PGC
223Ra dichloride
IV over 1min Capped syringe
LFOV
PGC
with 223Ra dose
(b) IV site
Background
anterior chest
LFOV
PGC
(c) Background
no
syringe
LFOV
PGC
(a) and 3 saline flushes
223Ra dichloride
IV over 1min (b) (c) Figure 1: Preinjection LFOVPGC imaging (one minute per image)
of the injection room background (left), capped syringe containing
the 223Ra dose (middle), and anterior chest background (right). The
LFOVPGC detector head is represented by either a gray trapezoid
or gray square just overlying the imaging target. Figure 2: Dynamic LFOVPGC imaging of the anterior chest during
intravenous administration of 223Ra and subsequent saline flushes
(5-minute continuous imaging 6 sec/frame). Capped empty
syringe
LFOV
PGC
(a)
IV site
Intravenous
access site
LFOV
PGC
(b)
Figure 3: Postinjection LFOVPGC imaging of the capped empty
syringe (left, 1 minute) and IV injection site (right, 1 minute). IV site
Intravenous
access site
LFOV
PGC
(b) Capped empty
syringe
LFOV
PGC
(a) IV site 3. Results and Discussion The average ± standard deviation for the 223Ra dichloride
doses administered intravenously was 4662 ± 666 kBq (𝑛=
15, range 3848–5994 kBq). During preinjection LFOVPGC
imaging (Figure 4), the average injection room background
activity was 1032 ± 61 counts (𝑛
=
15, range 916–1183
counts). The average background-corrected preinjection
syringe activity was 291345 ± 49406 counts (𝑛
=
15,
range 209633–389084 counts). There were two radiotherapy
administrations (out of 15) in which the delivered 223Ra 2.3. Dynamic Imaging during Injection. At the start of intra-
venous administration of 223Ra, dynamic imaging of the
anterior chest was obtained at 6 seconds/frame for 5 minutes
in order to image the angiographic phase during the entire
injection and subsequent 3 saline flushes (Figure 2). The
camera was allowed to acquire data for approximately 15–
30 seconds before the IV administration began. The total 3 3 BioMed Research International Total cts: 1183
Total cts: 230156
Total cts: 1667
Background
no
syringe
LFOV
PGC
Capped syringe
LFOV
PGC
with 3885 kBq 223Ra
IV site
Background
anterior chest
LFOV
PGC
Figure 4: Preinjection LFOVPGC imaging of the injection room background (top left), capped syringe containing the 223Ra dose (top
middle), and anterior chest background (top right). Total LFOVPGC counts for the entire field of view are provided for these 1-minute
acquisitions (top row). Total cts: 1667 Total cts: 230156 Background
no
syringe
LFOV
PGC Capped syringe
LFOV
PGC
with 3885 kBq 223Ra IV site
Background
anterior chest
LFOV
PGC Background
no
syringe Figure 4: Preinjection LFOVPGC imaging of the injection room background (top left), capped syringe containing the 223Ra dose (top
middle), and anterior chest background (top right). Total LFOVPGC counts for the entire field of view are provided for these 1-minute
acquisitions (top row). dichloride doses were provided in two syringes instead of
one syringe (not shown and excluded from subsequent
quantitative dynamic imaging analyses of the anterior chest). The average anterior chest background activity was 1722 ±
516 counts (𝑛= 15, range 1016–2903 counts). The increased
background counts for the anterior chest relative to the
background counts for the injection room are consistent with
the fact that all patients had received at least one prior 223Ra
radiotherapy administration. 3. Results and Discussion This implies that 223Ra from the
last radiotherapy administration had been incorporated into
the osseous structures within the anterior chest field of view
(presumably within osseous metastases) and some residual
incorporated 223Ra was still detectable on the preinjection
chest imaging. The average absolute difference in anterior
chest and background activities was 691 ± 525 (𝑛= 15, range
9–1878 counts). activity was 37 kBq in all syringes and incidentally all residual
activity localized to the syringe cap on imaging. Background-
corrected preinjection and postinjection syringe activity pos-
itively correlated with the corresponding preinjection and
postinjection syringe dose activity measurements (𝑟2 = 0.99,
𝑛= 30) (see the following equation): Background-corrected syringe activity (counts)
( (1) = 87.66 + [62.21 × Syringe dose (kBq)] . There were no instances of focal 223Ra extravasation at the
site of intravenous access (Figure 8). Given that 37 kBq of
residual 223Ra activity within a syringe cap produced a
discrete focus of activity on LFOVPGC imaging and that the
vast majority of IV sites are superficially located (i.e., minimal
soft tissue attenuation), it is likely that any focal extravasation
of ≥37 kBq would be detectable at the IV site. Dynamic LFOVPGC images of the anterior chest were
compressed into 30-second frames (Figure 5). In all cases,
dynamic imaging of the chest confirmed systemic adminis-
tration early during the 1-minute injection period. Quantita-
tive region-of-interest (ROI) analysis of the dynamic anterior
chest imaging confirmed that the time-to-peak 223Ra activity
was at least 1 minute for all radiotherapy administrations. ROIs were drawn around the heart and entire anterior chest
field of view (including the heart) and total activity counts for
each 30-second frame were measured. Dynamic ROI analysis
confirmed that the time-to-peak 223Ra activity was at least 1
minute in all 13 single-syringe radiotherapy administrations
(Figure 6). 4. Conclusions The demand for 223Ra dichloride is anticipated to increase
significantly in the foreseeable future with potential expan-
sion into women with osseous metastatic disease from breast
cancer. Our results demonstrate that (1) systemic 223Ra
administrations in CRPC patients can be dynamically imaged
using a clinical LFOVPGC imaging system and (2) systemic
223Ra administrations can be further quantified with this
real-time LFOVPGC imaging approach. Total time for this
LFOVPGC imaging protocol is 10 minutes and the total
patient imaging time is 7 minutes. This simple imaging
approach can be used to quickly confirm and quantify
systemic circulation of 223Ra during injection as well as During postinjection LFOVPGC imaging (Figure 7), the
average ± standard deviation for the background-corrected
postinjection syringe activity was 3312 ± 564 counts (𝑛=
15, range 2656–4644 counts). The measured residual 223Ra 4 4 BioMed Research International Figure 5: Dynamic images of the anterior chest during injection of 3848 kBq 223Ra via a right antecubital fossa IV site. Dynamic images were
compressed into 30-second frames. First 30-second frame is in the upper left and progresses from left to right and top to bottom. Figure 5: Dynamic images of the anterior chest during injection of 3848 kBq 223Ra via a right antecubital fossa IV site. Dynamic images were
compressed into 30-second frames. First 30-second frame is in the upper left and progresses from left to right and top to bottom. evaluate focal soft tissue extravasation at the IV site for the
purposes of patient safety and quality control.t for real-time quality assessment of other radionuclide ther-
apy administrations such as gamma-emitting intravenous
radiotherapies (e.g., Samarium-153, Iodine-131 metaiodoben-
zylguanidine), bremsstrahlung-emitting intravenous radio-
therapies (e.g., Strontium-90, Yttrium-90-labeled antibod-
ies/peptides), and bremsstrahlung-emitting intra-arterial
radioembolization therapies (e.g., Yttrium-90 containing
resin or glass microspheres). Although no cases of focal soft tissue extravasation were
identified in this study, our results indicate that injection
site imaging could rapidly quantify focally extravasated 223Ra
activity for subsequent monitoring and dosimetry. Serial
imaging of the injection site (e.g., right antecubital fossa) and
the contralateral noninjected limb (i.e., left antecubital fossa)
would allow for quantitative assessment of 223Ra resorption
and confirm when complete resorption was achieved (i.e.,
223Ra activity in the injected limb approximates the activity
in contralateral noninjected limb). 4. Conclusions It remains to be determined in a prospective clinical
trial throughout the course of 223Ra radiotherapy if there is
any prognostic significance to serial quantitative assessment
of the difference in measured residual activity between
preinjection anterior chest and the background activity of
the injection room (e.g., patients with significantly higher
preinjection residual activity demonstrate improved clinical
outcomes when compared with those patients with little or
no preinjection residual activity). This real-time LFOVPGC assessment of the patient, dose,
and injection site is a simple adjunct to routine survey
meter evaluation by radiation safety or medical physics. There is sparse literature on the role of gamma camera
imaging for quality assessment of intravenous radiotherapy
administration. One study demonstrated the feasibility of
gamma camera imaging to qualitatively assess Yttrium-
90 bremsstrahlung activity using a phantom simulation of
intravenous Yttrium-90-labeled antibody extravasation [6]. Thus, real-time LFOVPGC imaging can be easily adapted Acknowledgments The authors would like to thank Nichole Storey, MSHS, Angie
Dado, Alicia Gould, and Michelle Bowen for their assistance. The authors would like to thank Nichole Storey, MSHS, Angie
Dado, Alicia Gould, and Michelle Bowen for their assistance. Conflict of Interests The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests
regarding the publication of this paper. BioMed Research International 5 IV site
Total cts: 5908
LFOV
PGC 0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
0
30
60
90
120
150
180
210
240
270
Heart only
Anterior chest
Average total activity (cts)
Time (s)
Figure 6: Average total activity counts for the heart and anterior
chest ROIs for all 13 radiotherapy administrations using only single-
syringe doses (𝑛
=
13). Quantitative ROI analysis confirmed
systemic administration early during the 1-minute injection period
and the time-to-peak 223Ra activity was at least 1 minute. IV site
Total cts: 5908
LFOV
PGC 0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
0
30
60
90
120
150
180
210
240
270
Average total activity (cts)
Time (s) Average total activity (cts) Figure 6: Average total activity counts for the heart and anterior
chest ROIs for all 13 radiotherapy administrations using only single-
syringe doses (𝑛
=
13). Quantitative ROI analysis confirmed
systemic administration early during the 1-minute injection period
and the time-to-peak 223Ra activity was at least 1 minute. Total cts: 5908 Total cts: 5908 Total cts: 5908 Figure 8: Postinjection LFOVPGC imaging of the patient’s IV
injection site (bottom, one-minute acquisition). A white outline of
the patient’s body contour has been manually superimposed on the
bottom LFOVPGC image which demonstrates no evidence of focal
223Ra extravasation in the right antecubital fossa injection site but
rather systemic 223Ra activity within the partially imaged chest and
abdomen. Total LFOVPGC counts for the entire field of view are
provided for this 1-minute acquisition (bottom). Total cts: 230156
Total cts: 2656
LFOV
PGC
Capped syringe
with 3885 kBq 223Ra
LFOV
PGC
Capped syringe
37 kBq 223Ra residual
Figure 7: Preinjection LFOVPGC imaging of a capped syringe
containing the 223Ra dose (top left) and subsequent postinjection
imaging of the capped empty syringe (top right). There is a single
discrete focus of activity in the capped empty syringe corresponding
to 37 kBq of residual 223Ra activity within the syringe cap. Total
LFOVPGC counts for the entire field of view are provided for these
1-minute acquisitions (top row). References LFOV
PGC
Capped syringe
with 3885 kBq 223Ra LFOV
PGC
Capped syringe
37 kBq 223Ra residual [1] O. Sartor, P. Hoskin, and Ø. S. Bruland, “Targeted radio-nuclide
therapy of skeletal metastases,” Cancer Treatment Reviews, vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 18–26, 2013. [2] C. Parker and O. Sartor, “Radium-223 in prostate cancer,” The
New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 369, no. 17, pp. 1659–1660,
2013. [3] S. Nilsson, R. H. Larsen, S. D. Fossa et al., “First clinical
experience with 𝛼-emitting radium-223 in the treatment of
skeletal metastases,” Clinical Cancer Research, vol. 11, no. 12, pp. 4451–4459, 2005. Capped syringe
37 kBq 223Ra residual [4] E. Even-Sapir, U. Metser, E. Mishani, G. Lievshitz, H. Ler-
man, and I. Leibovitch, “The detection of bone metastases in
patients with high-risk prostate cancer: 99mTc-MDP planar
bone scintigraphy, single- and multi-field-of-view SPECT, 18F-
fluoride PET, and 18F-fluoride PET/CT,” Journal of Nuclear
Medicine, vol. 47, no. 2, pp. 287–297, 2006. Figure 7: Preinjection LFOVPGC imaging of a capped syringe
containing the 223Ra dose (top left) and subsequent postinjection
imaging of the capped empty syringe (top right). There is a single
discrete focus of activity in the capped empty syringe corresponding
to 37 kBq of residual 223Ra activity within the syringe cap. Total
LFOVPGC counts for the entire field of view are provided for these
1-minute acquisitions (top row). [5] C. Hindorf, S. Chittenden, A.-K. Aksnes, C. Parker, and G. D. Flux, “Quantitative imaging of 223Ra-chloride (Alpharadin) for BioMed Research International 6 targeted alpha-emitting radionuclide therapy of bone metas-
tases,” Nuclear Medicine Communications, vol. 33, no. 7, pp. 726–
732, 2012. [6] S. M. Rhymer, J. A. Parker, and M. R. Palmer, “Detection
of 90Y extravasation by bremsstrahlung imaging for patients
undergoing 90Y-ibritumomab tiuxetan therapy,” Journal of
Nuclear Medicine Technology, vol. 38, no. 4, pp. 195–198, 2010.
|
https://openalex.org/W3203547160
|
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fcell.2022.844342/pdf
|
English
| null |
Extracellular matrix stiffness and TGFβ2 regulate YAP/TAZ activity in human trabecular meshwork cells
|
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 16,100
|
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
published: 01 March 2022
doi: 10.3389/fcell.2022.844342 Extracellular Matrix Stiffness and
TGFβ2 Regulate YAP/TAZ Activity in
Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells
Haiyan Li 1,2,3, VijayKrishna Raghunathan 4, W. Daniel Stamer 5,6, Preethi S. Ganapathy 1,3,7 and
Samuel Herberg 1,2,3,8,9* 1Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, United States,
2Department of Cell and Developmental Biology, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, United States, 3BioInspired
Institute, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY, United States, 4Department of Basic Sciences, The Ocular Surface Institute,
University of Houston, Houston, TX, United States, 5Department of Ophthalmology, Duke Eye Center, Duke University, Durham,
NC, United States, 6Department of Biomedical Engineering, Duke University, Durham, NC, United States, 7Department of
Neuroscience and Physiology, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, United States, 8Department of Biochemistry and
Molecular Biology, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, United States, 9Department of Biomedical and Chemical
Engineering, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY, United States Keywords: mechanotransduction, hydrogel, HTM cell contractility, HTM stiffness, POAG Edited by:
Donna Peters,
University of Wisconsin-Madison,
United States Primary open-angle glaucoma progression is associated with increased human
trabecular meshwork (HTM) stiffness and elevated transforming growth factor beta
2 (TGFβ2) levels in the aqueous humor. Increased transcriptional activity of Yes-
associated protein (YAP) and transcriptional coactivator with PDZ-binding motif
(TAZ), central players in mechanotransduction, are implicated in glaucomatous
HTM
cell
dysfunction. Yet,
the
detailed
mechanisms
underlying
YAP/TAZ
modulation in HTM cells in response to alterations in extracellular matrix (ECM)
stiffness and TGFβ2 levels are not well understood. Using biomimetic ECM
hydrogels with tunable stiffness, here we show that increased ECM stiffness
elevates
YAP/TAZ
nuclear
localization
potentially
through
modulating
focal
adhesions and cytoskeletal rearrangement. Furthermore, TGFβ2 increased nuclear
YAP/TAZ in both normal and glaucomatous HTM cells, which was prevented by
inhibiting extracellular-signal-regulated kinase and Rho-associated kinase signaling
pathways. Filamentous (F)-actin depolymerization reversed TGFβ2-induced YAP/TAZ
nuclear localization. YAP/TAZ depletion using siRNA or verteporfin decreased focal
adhesions, ECM remodeling and cell contractile properties. Similarly, YAP/TAZ
inactivation with verteporfin partially blocked TGFβ2-induced hydrogel contraction
and stiffening. Collectively, our data provide evidence for a pathologic role of aberrant
YAP/TAZ signaling in glaucomatous HTM cell dysfunction, and may help inform
strategies for the development of novel multifactorial approaches to prevent
progressive ocular hypertension in glaucoma. Reviewed by:
Padmanabhan Pattabiraman,
Indiana University, Purdue University
Indianapolis, United States
Evan B. Stubbs,
Loyola University Chicago,
United States Reviewed by:
Padmanabhan Pattabiraman,
Indiana University, Purdue University
Indianapolis, United States
Evan B. Stubbs,
Loyola University Chicago,
United States *Correspondence:
Samuel Herberg
herbergs@upstate.edu Specialty section:
This article was submitted to
Cell Adhesion and Migration,
a section of the journal
Frontiers in Cell and Developmental
Biology Specialty section:
This article was submitted to
Cell Adhesion and Migration,
a section of the journal
Frontiers in Cell and Developmental
Biology INTRODUCTION cell-derived matrices (Thomasy et al., 2013; Yemanyi et al., 2020). Whilst it appears that these findings may be contradictory, it is
important to note that functional outcomes of YAP and TAZ are
governed by their subcellular localization which is substrate and
context dependent. Together, these highlight the importance of
studying YAP/TAZ signaling in a microenvironment mimicking
the native tissue to further our understanding of HTM cell
mechanobiology with an emphasis on cell-ECM interactions. This is especially important considering a recent multi-ethnic
genome wide meta-analysis report that identified YAP1 as a
potential genetic risk factor for POAG across European, Asian,
and African ancestries implicating a causal relationship for
outflow dysfunction (Gharahkhani et al., 2021). Primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) is a leading cause of
irreversible vision loss worldwide, and elevated intraocular
pressure (IOP) is the primary modifiable risk factor (Quigley,
1993; Quigley and Broman, 2006; Kwon et al., 2009; Tham et al.,
2014; Tamm et al., 2015). Elevated IOP results from increased
resistance to aqueous humor outflow in the juxtacanalicular
region
of
the
conventional
outflow
pathway
where
the
trabecular meshwork (TM) and Schlemm’s canal inner wall
cells interact (Brubaker, 1991). Human trabecular meshwork
(HTM) cells within the juxtacanalicular tissue are surrounded
by a complex extracellular matrix (ECM), which is primarily
composed of non-fibrillar and fibrillar collagens, elastic fibrils,
proteoglycans and the glycosaminoglycan hyaluronic acid (Acott
and Kelley, 2008; Tamm, 2009; Hann and Fautsch, 2011; Keller
and Acott, 2013; Abu-Hassan et al., 2014). In addition to
providing structural support, the ECM imparts biochemical
signals
(e.g.,
hormones,
growth
factors
and
diffusible
morphogens) and mechanical cues (e.g., matrix stiffness;
tensile, compressive and shear forces; topographical strain) to
regulate cell behaviors (Frantz et al., 2010). These external
biophysical
cues
are
translated
into
internal
biochemical
signaling
cascades
through
a
process
known
as
mechanotransduction,
and
cells
play
an
active
role
in
remodeling their matrix to promote mechanical homeostasis
and maintain tissue-level functionality (Lampi and Reinhart-
King, 2018). Biomaterials for cell culture applications are designed to mimic
aspects of the ECM and provide researchers with methods to better
understand cell behaviors. Protein-based hydrogels (i.e., water-
swollen networks of polymers) are attractive biomaterials owing
to
their
similarity
to
in
vivo
cellular
microenvironments,
biocompatibility,
biodegradability
and
tunable
mechanical
properties (Drury and Mooney, 2003; Panahi and Baghban-
Salehi, 2019). INTRODUCTION Recently, we developed a bioengineered hydrogel
composed of HTM cells and ECM biopolymers found in the
native
HTM
tissue,
and
demonstrated
its
viability
for
investigating cell-ECM interactions under normal and simulated
glaucomatous conditions in both 2D and 3D conformations (Li et al.,
2021a; Li et al., 2021b). Here, we hypothesized that altered YAP/TAZ activity drives
HTM cell dysfunction under simulated glaucomatous conditions. The TM from POAG eyes is stiffer than that from healthy eyes
(Last et al., 2011; Wang et al., 2017a; Vahabikashi et al., 2019);
transforming growth factor beta 2 (TGFβ2), the predominant
TGFβ isoform in the eye and aqueous humor, has been identified
as a major contributor to the pathologic changes occurring in
ocular hypertension and POAG (Granstein et al., 1990; Quigley,
1993; Inatani et al., 2001; Fuchshofer and Tamm, 2009; Agarwal
et al., 2015; Kasetti et al., 2018). Using TGFβ2 as a glaucomatous
stimulus and tuning the stiffness of our hydrogels, here, we
investigated the effects of ECM stiffening and TGFβ2 on
regulating YAP/TAZ in HTM cells in 2D and 3D cultures. In
this tissue-mimetic environment, we then investigated whether
YAP/TAZ inhibition would alleviate ECM stiffness- or TGFβ2-
induced HTM cell pathobiology. HTM cells are exposed to a variety of biophysical cues through
cell-cell and cell-ECM interactions, and fluctuations in IOP. In
POAG, impaired HTM cell function (i.e., remodeling of cell
cytoskeleton, increased cell stiffness) and increased ECM
deposition contribute to HTM stiffening (Schlunck et al., 2008;
Han et al., 2011; McKee et al., 2011; Wang et al., 2017b; Li et al.,
2021a). Tissue stiffening affects HTM cell function and IOP in a
feed-forward cycle characterized by dynamic reciprocity. HTM
stiffening in POAG indicates that a biophysical component likely
contributes
to
IOP
regulation. Therefore,
targeting
mechanotransduction pathways in the HTM to interrupt this
feed-forward cycle between HTM stiffening and cellular response
to the stiffened ECM is emerging as a promising strategy for
managing ocular hypertension. Yes-associated protein (YAP) and transcriptional coactivator
with PDZ-binding motif (TAZ, encoded by WWTR1) are central
players in mechanotransduction. YAP/TAZ can be activated by
increased ECM stiffness, mechanical stress and growth factors
(Dupont et al., 2011; Boopathy and Hong, 2019). INTRODUCTION It has been
demonstrated that certain glaucoma related molecules that
influence
outflow
function,
such
as
dexamethasone,
lysophosphatidic
acid
and
interleukin-6,
mediate
the
expression of YAP and TAZ in HTM cells (Ho et al., 2018;
Honjo et al., 2018; Peng et al., 2018; Yemanyi and Raghunathan,
2020). YAP was found to be reduced in HTM cells incubated on
stiff two-dimensional (2D) polyacrylamide hydrogels, while TAZ
levels were increased (Raghunathan et al., 2013). Other research
showed that both YAP and TAZ were significantly higher in
HTM cells on stiffer polyacrylamide substrates or stiffened HTM Citation: Li H, Raghunathan V, Stamer WD,
Ganapathy PS and Herberg S (2022)
Extracellular Matrix Stiffness and
TGFβ2 Regulate YAP/TAZ Activity in
Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Front. Cell Dev. Biol. 10:844342. doi: 10.3389/fcell.2022.844342 March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 1 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. Li et al. MATERIALS AND METHODS HTM Cell Isolation and Culture HTM Cell Isolation and Culture Ce
so a o
a d Cu u e
Experiments using human donor eye tissue were approved by the
SUNY Upstate Medical University Institutional Review Board
(protocol #1211036), and were performed in accordance with the
tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki for the use of human tissue. Primary HTM cells were isolated from healthy donor corneal
rims discarded after transplant surgery as recently described (Li
et al., 2021a; Li et al., 2021b), and cultured according to
established protocols (Stamer et al., 1995; Keller et al., 2018). Five HTM cell strains (HTM05, HTM12, HTM14, HTM17,
HTM19)
were
used
for
the
experiments
in
this
study March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 2 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. with 10% FBS and 1% PSG for 1 or 2 days. Then, HTM cells were
cultured in serum-free DMEM with 1% PSG and subjected to the
different treatments for 3 days: TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml; R&D Systems,
Minneapolis, MN, United States), the ERK inhibitor U0126
(10 μM; Promega, Madison, WI, United States), the Rho-
associated kinase (ROCK) inhibitor Y27632 (10 μM; Sigma-
Aldrich),
the actin de-polymerizer latrunculin B (10 μM;
Tocris Bioscience; Thermo Fisher Scientific), or the YAP
inhibitor verteporfin (0.5 μM; Sigma). The monolayer HTM
cells
were
processed
for
immunoblot,
qRT-PCR
and
immunocytochemistry analyses. (Supplementary Table S1). All HTM cell strains were validated
with dexamethasone (DEX; Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA,
United States; 100 nM) induced myocilin expression in more
than 50% of cells by immunocytochemistry and immunoblot
analyses [Supplementary Figures S1A,B and (Li et al., 2021a; Li
et al., 2021b)]. Different combinations of two to three HTM cell
strains were used per experiment with three to four replicates
each, depending on cell availability, and all studies were
conducted between cell passage 3–7. HTM cells were cultured
in low-glucose Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s Medium (DMEM;
Gibco; Thermo Fisher Scientific) containing 10% fetal bovine
serum
(FBS;
Atlanta
Biologicals,
Flowery
Branch,
GA,
United States) and 1% penicillin/streptomycin/glutamine (PSG;
Gibco), and maintained at 37°C in a humidified atmosphere with
5% CO2. Fresh media was supplied every 2–3 days. Immunoblot Analysis Protein was extracted from cells using lysis buffer (CelLyticTM M,
Sigma-Aldrich) supplemented with Halt™protease/phosphatase
inhibitor cocktail (Thermo Fisher Scientific). Equal protein
amounts (10 µg), determined by standard bicinchoninic acid
assay (Pierce; Thermo Fisher Scientific), in 4× loading buffer
(Invitrogen;
Thermo
Fisher
Scientific)
with
5%
beta-
mercaptoethanol (Fisher Scientific) were boiled for 5 min and
subjected to SDS-PAGE using NuPAGE™4–12% Bis-Tris Gels
(Invitrogen; Thermo Fisher Scientific) at 120 V for 80 min and
transferred to 0.45 µm PVDF membranes (Sigma; Thermo Fisher
Scientific). Membranes were blocked with 5% bovine serum
albumin (Thermo Fisher Scientific) in tris-buffered saline with
0.2% Tween®20 (Thermo Fisher Scientific), and probed with
various primary antibodies followed by incubation with HRP-
conjugated
secondary
antibodies
or
fluorescent
secondary
antibodies (LI-COR,
Lincoln,
NE, United
States). Bound
antibodies
were
visualized
with
the
enhanced
chemiluminescent
detection
system
(Pierce)
on
autoradiography film (Thermo Fisher Scientific) or Odyssey®
CLx imager (LI-COR). Densitometry was performed using the
open-source National Institutes of Health software platform, FIJI
(Schindelin et al., 2012) or Image StudioTM Lite (LI-COR); data
were normalized to GAPDH. A list of all of antibodies used in this
study, including their working dilutions, can be found in
Supplementary Table S2. Glaucomatous Donor History y
Glaucomatous HTM cells (GTM211 and GTM1445) were used in
this study. GTM211 was isolated from a 75-year-old, white female
that was taking Xalatan (0.005%) in both eyes nightly for
treatment of ocular hypertension. The patient was diagnosed
with glaucoma, and had bilateral cataract surgery, and retina
surgery. Upon receipt of donor eyes by W.D.S., outflow facility
measurements during constant pressure perfusion conditions
were 0.24 and 0.17 μL/min/mmHg from OD and OS eyes,
respectively. GTM211 were isolated from the OS eye of the
donor and characterized as previously described (Li et al.,
2021a). GTM1445 has been characterized in our previous
study (Li et al., 2021a). GTM cell strain information can be
found in Supplementary Table S1. Preparation of Hydrogels p
y
g
Hydrogel precursors methacrylate-conjugated bovine collagen
type
I
[MA-COL,
Advanced
BioMatrix,
Carlsbad,
CA,
United States; 3.6 mg/ml (all final concentrations)], thiol-
conjugated hyaluronic acid (SH-HA, Glycosil®, Advanced
BioMatrix; 0.5 mg/ml, 0.025% (w/v) photoinitiator Irgacure®
2959; Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, United States) and in-
house expressed elastin-like polypeptide (ELP, thiol via KCTS
flanks (Li et al., 2021a); 2.5 mg/ml) were thoroughly mixed. Thirty microliters of the hydrogel solution were pipetted onto
a Surfasil (Fisher Scientific) coated 12-mm round glass coverslip
followed by placing a regular 12-mm round glass coverslip onto
the hydrogels. Constructs were crosslinked by exposure to UV
light (OmniCure S1500 UV Spot Curing System; Excelitas
Technologies, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada) at 320–500 nm,
2.2 W/cm2 for 5 s, as previously described (Li et al., 2021a). The hydrogel-adhered coverslips were removed with fine-
tipped tweezers and placed in 24-well culture plates (Corning;
Thermo Fisher Scientific). Hydrogel stiffening was achieved by
soaking the hydrogels in 0.1% (w/v) riboflavin (RF; Sigma) for
5 min, followed by low-intensity secondary UV crosslinking
(bandpass filter: 405–500 nm, 5.4 mW/cm2) for 5 min. Immunocytochemistry Analysis y
y
y
HTM cells in presence of the different treatments were fixed
with 4% paraformaldehyde (Thermo Fisher Scientific) at
room temperature for 20 min, permeabilized with 0.5%
Triton™X-100 (Thermo Fisher Scientific), blocked with
blocking buffer (BioGeneX), and incubated with primary
antibodies,
followed
by
incubation
with
fluorescent
secondary
antibodies;
nuclei
were
counterstained
with
4′,6′-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI; Abcam). Similarly,
cells
were
stained
with
Phalloidin-iFluor
488
or
594
(Abcam)/DAPI
according
to
the
manufacturer’s
instructions. Coverslips were mounted with ProLong™
Gold Antifade (Invitrogen) on Superfrost™microscope
slides
(Fisher
Scientific),
and
fluorescent
images
were
acquired
with
an
Eclipse
Ni
microscope
(Nikon
Instruments, Melville, NY, United States) or a Zeiss LSM
780 confocal microscope (Zeiss, Germany). Fluorescent
signal intensity was measured using FIJI software. A list of HTM Hydrogel Contraction Analysis y
Total RNA was extracted from HTM cells using PureLink RNA
Mini Kit (Invitrogen). RNA concentration was determined with a
NanoDrop spectrophotometer (Thermo Fisher Scientific). RNA
was reverse transcribed using iScript™cDNA Synthesis Kit
(BioRad,
Hercules,
CA,
United
States). One
hundred
nanograms of cDNA were amplified in duplicates in each 40-
cycle reaction using a CFX 384 Real Time PCR System (BioRad)
with annealing temperature set at 60°C, Power SYBR™Green
PCR Master Mix (Thermo Fisher Scientific), and custom-
designed qRT-PCR primers. Transcript levels were normalized
to GAPDH, and mRNA fold-changes calculated relative to mean
values of normal HTM cell controls using the comparative CT
method (Schmittgen and Livak, 2008). A list of all of primers used
in this study can be found in Supplementary Table S3. HTM Hydrogel Contraction Analysis
HTM cell-laden hydrogels were prepared by mixing HTM cells (1.0 ×
106 cells/ml) with MA-COL (3.6 mg/ml [all final concentrations]),
SH-HA (0.5 mg/ml, 0.025% (w/v) photoinitiator) and ELP (2.5 mg/
ml) on ice, followed by pipetting 10 μL droplets of the HTM cell-laden
hydrogel precursor solution onto polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS;
Sylgard
184;
Dow
Corning)
coated
24-well
culture
plates. Constructs were crosslinked as described above (320–500 nm,
2.2 W/cm2, 5 s). HTM cell-laden hydrogels were cultured in
DMEM with 10% FBS and 1% PSG in presence of the different
treatments. Longitudinal brightfield images were acquired at 0 and
5 days with an Eclipse Ti microscope (Nikon). Construct area from
n = 8–11 hydrogels per group from 2 HTM/GTM cell strains with
three to four replicates per HTM/GTM cell strain was measured using
FIJI software and normalized to 0 days followed by normalization to
controls. siRNA Transfection HTM cells were depleted of YAP and TAZ using siRNA-loaded
lipofectamine
RNAimax
(Invitrogen)
according
to
the
manufacturer’s instructions. In brief, HTM cells were seeded
at 2 × 104 cells/cm2 on RF double-crosslinked hydrogels in
DMEM with 10% FBS and 1% PSG. The following day, the
cell culture medium was changed to antibiotic-free and serum-
free DMEM and the samples were kept in culture for 24 h
followed by transfection. Transfection was performed using a
final concentration 3% (v/v) lipofectamine RNAimax with
150 nM
RNAi
duplexes
(custom
oligonucleotides;
Dharmacon). Transfected HTM cells were used 48 h after
transfection. ON-TARGET plus nontargeting siRNA were
obtained from Dharmacon. Custom siRNA were based on
validated sequences previously described (Dupont et al., 2011):
YAP, sense, 5′-GACAUCUUCUGGUCAGAGA-3′, and YAP,
anti-sense, 5′-UCUCUGACCAGAAGAUGUC-3’; TAZ, sense,
5′-ACGUUGACUUAGGAACUUU-3′, and TAZ, anti-sense,
5′-AAAGUUCCUAAGUCAACGU-3’. HTM Cell Treatments HTM/GTM cells were seeded at 2 × 104 cells/cm2 on premade
hydrogels/coverslips/tissue culture plates, and cultured in DMEM March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 3 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. Substrate Solution. After 20 min, the reaction was stopped by
adding Stop Solution. Absorbance was measured at 450 nm using
a spectrophotometer plate reader (BioTEK, Winooski, VT,
United States), with background correction at 540 nm. Active
levels of TGFβ2 were calculated using standard curves. all of antibodies used in this study, including their working
dilutions, can be found in Supplementary Table S2. Image Analysis All image analysis was performed using FIJI software. Briefly, the
cytoplasmic YAP intensity was measured by subtracting the
overlapping nuclear (DAPI) intensity from the total YAP
intensity. The nuclear YAP intensity was recorded as the
proportion of total YAP intensity that overlapped with the
nucleus (DAPI). YAP/TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic (N/C) ratio
was calculated as follows: N/C ratio = (nuclear YAP signal/
area
of
nucleus)/(cytoplasmic
signal/area
of
cytoplasm). Fluorescence intensity of F-actin, αSMA, FN, and p-MLC were
measured in at least 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three
replicates
per
HTM
cell
strain
with
image
background
subtraction using FIJI software. For number of vinculin puncta
quantification, the 3D Object Counter plugin in FIJI software was
used to threshold images and quantify puncta/0.05 mm2 (above
2 μm in size). Nuclear area was also measured using FIJI software. At least 100 nuclei were analyzed from 2 HTM cell strains with
three replicates per HTM cell strain. TGFβ2 and YAP/TAZ Activity is Upregulated
in GTM Cells It has been shown that levels of TGFβ2 are elevated in eyes of
glaucomatous patients compared to age-matched normal eyes
(Inatani et al., 2001; Picht et al., 2001; Ochiai and Ochiai, 2002;
Agarwal et al., 2015). We confirmed that GTM cells isolated from
donor eyes with POAG history secreted significantly more active
TGFβ2 protein by ~2.44-fold (Figure 1A) compared to normal
HTM cells, which was consistent with increased mRNA levels
(Supplementary Figure S2A). To investigate YAP and TAZ transcriptional activity under
normal and glaucomatous conditions, the expression of YAP/
TAZ and relevant select downstream targets at mRNA and
protein levels were evaluated in normal HTM and GTM cells,
which were plated with similar cell density. The functions of
YAP/TAZ depend on their spatial localization within the cellular
nucleus or cytoplasm. When localized to the nucleus, YAP/TAZ
interact with TEAD transcription factors to drive the expression
of certain proteins, such as transglutaminase-2 (TGM2) and
connective
tissue
growth
factor
(CTGF),
cysteine-rich
angiogenic inducer 61 (CYR61) and ankyrin repeat domain 1
(ANKRD1) (Low et al., 2014). When localized in the cytoplasm,
YAP can be phosphorylated at five serine/threonine residues,
TAZ at four, by the large tumor suppressor (LATS) kinases 1 and
2. Of these sites, the most relevant residues that keep YAP and
TAZ inhibited are S127 (S89 in TAZ) and S381 (S311 in TAZ)
(Zhao et al., 2010). Phosphorylation of YAP/TAZ either primes to
binding with 14-3-3σ leading to their cytoplasmic sequestration
or ubiquitin-mediated protein degradation (Zhao et al., 2007; Lei
et al., 2008; Dupont et al., 2011). We demonstrated that mRNA
levels of YAP and TAZ were both significantly upregulated in
GTM cells compared to normal HTM cells (Figure 1B). TGM2
and CTGF have been shown to play a role in HTM cell
pathobiology in glaucoma (Tovar-Vidales et al., 2008; Junglas
et al., 2012); here we showed that mRNA of TGM2, CTGF and
ANKRD1 were also significantly upregulated in GTM cells vs. normal HTM cells, whereas no significant difference was
observed for CYR61 (Figure 1B; Supplementary Figures
S2B,C). GTM cells showed significantly lower p-YAP (S127)
and p-TAZ (S89) vs. normal HTM cells, while total YAP and TAZ
expression were equivalent to HTM cells; this resulted in
significantly decreased p-YAP/YAP and p-TAZ/TAZ ratios (=
less inactive YAP/TAZ in GTM cells). HTM Hydrogel Atomic Force Microscopy
Analysis Analysis
Thirty microliters of HTM cell-laden hydrogel solution were
pipetted onto a Surfasil (Fisher Scientific) coated 12-mm
round glass coverslip followed by placing a regular 12-mm
round glass coverslip onto the hydrogels. Constructs were
crosslinked by exposure to UV light at 320–500 nm, 2.2 W/
cm2 for 5 s, and cultured in DMEM with 10% FBS and 1%
PSG for 7 days. Samples were shipped overnight to UHCO where
they were locally masked. Elastic modulus of HTM cell-laden
hydrogels were obtained by atomic force microscopy (AFM) in
fluid in contact mode as described previously (Raghunathan et al.,
2018). Briefly, force vs. indentation curves were obtained on a
Bruker BioScope Resolve (Bruker nanoSurfaces, Santa Barbara,
CA) AFM employing a PNP-TR cantilever (NanoAndMore,
Watsonville, CA) whose pyramidal tip was modified with a
borosilicate bead (nominal diameter 5 µm), nominal spring
constant of 0.32 N/m assuming sample Poisson’s ratio of 0.5. The diameter of each sphere attached to the cantilever was
qualified
prior
to
usage. Prior
to
experimental
samples,
cantilever was calibrated on a silicon wafer in fluid. Force-
distance curves were randomly obtained from 7–10 locations
with three force curves obtained per location per sample. Force
curves were analyzed using the Hertz model for spherical
indenters using a custom MATLAB code (Chang et al., 2014). Curve fits were performed for at least 1 µm of indentation depth
for the samples. TGFβ2 and YAP/TAZ Activity is Upregulated
in GTM Cells Consistent with the lower
ratio of phosphorylated-to-total proteins, 14-3-3σ expression in
GTM cells was significantly decreased compared to normal HTM
cells (Figures 1C,D). Besides, GTM cells exhibited significantly
increased YAP/TAZ nuclear-to-cytoplasmic (N/C) ratio and
TGM2 expression compared to normal HTM cells (= more
active
YAP/TAZ
in
GTM
cells)
(Figures
1E–H;
Supplementary Figure S3). Together, these data demonstrate
that levels of active TGFβ2 as well as YAP and TAZ nuclear HTM Hydrogel Rheology Analysis HTM Hydrogel Rheology Analysis
Fifty microliters of acellular hydrogel precursor solutions were
pipetted into custom 8x1-mm PDMS molds. Similarly, 250 µL of
HTM cell-laden hydrogel precursor solutions were pipetted into
16x1-mm PDMS molds. All samples were UV crosslinked and
equilibrated as described above. Acellular hydrogels were
measured at 0 days. HTM hydrogels, cultured in DMEM with
10% FBS and 1% PSG in presence of the different treatments,
were measured at 5 days; samples were cut to size using an 8-mm
diameter
tissue
punch. A
Kinexus
rheometer
(Malvern
Panalytical, Westborough, MA, United States) fitted with an 8-
mm diameter parallel plate was used to measure hydrogel
viscoelasticity. To
ensure
standard
conditions
across
all
experiments (n = 3 per group), the geometry was lowered into
the hydrogels until a calibration normal force of 0.02 N was
achieved. Subsequently, an oscillatory shear-strain sweep test
(0.1–60%, 1.0 Hz, 25°C) was applied to determine storage
modulus (G′) and loss modulus (G″) in the linear region. Elastic modulus was calculated with E = 2 * (1 + v) * G′,
where a Poisson’s ratio (v) of 0.5 for the ECM hydrogels was
assumed (Timothy and Lodge, 2020). HTM Hydrogel Cell Proliferation Analysis HTM Hydrogel Cell Proliferation Analysis
Cell proliferation was measured with the CellTiter 96® Aqueous
Non-Radioactive Cell Proliferation Assay (Promega) following
the manufacturer’s protocol. HTM hydrogels cultured in DMEM
with 10% FBS and 1% PSG in presence of the different treatments
for 5 days were incubated with the staining solution (38 μL MTS,
2 μL PMS solution, 200 μL DMEM) at 37°C for 1.5 h. Absorbance
at 490 nm was recorded using a spectrophotometer plate reader
(BioTEK, Winooski, VT, United States). Blank-subtracted
absorbance values served as a direct measure of HTM cell
proliferation from n = 6–8 hydrogels per group from 2 HTM/
GTM cell strains with three to four replicates per HTM/GTM cell
strain. y
TGFβ2 levels were quantified using the Quantikine ELISA kit
(R&D Systems). HTM and GTM cells were seeded at 2 × 104 cells/
cm2 on tissue culture plates, and cultured in DMEM with 10%
FBS and 1% PSG for 1 or 2 days to grow to 80–90% confluence. Then, HTM and GTM cells were cultured in 1 ml serum-free
DMEM with 1% PSG for 3 days. After 3 days, the cell culture
supernatants were collected and centrifuged at 1,000 g for 10 min. The supernatants were used immediately without processing/
activation
for
ELISA
according
to
the
manufacturer’s
instructions. In brief, after a 2 h incubation of standards and
samples in the adhesive strip, wells were washed and incubated
for 2 h with TGFβ2 Conjugate followed by incubation with March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 4 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. Li et al. Prism
software
v9.2
(GraphPad
Software,
La
Jolla,
CA,
United States) was used for all analyses. Prism
software
v9.2
(GraphPad
Software,
La
Jolla,
CA,
United States) was used for all analyses. HTM Hydrogel Rheology Analysis Statistical Analysis Individual sample sizes are specified in each figure caption. Comparisons between groups were assessed by unpaired t-test,
one-way or two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Tukey’s
multiple comparisons post hoc tests, as appropriate. The
significance level was set at p < 0.05 or lower. GraphPad March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 5 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. FIGURE 1 | Upregulated active TGFβ2 and YAP/TAZ nuclear localization in GTM cells compared to normal HTM cells. (A) Active TGFβ2 levels were quantified by
ELISA (n = 16 replicates from three HTM cell strains, n = 13 replicates from 2 GTM cell strains). (B) mRNA fold-change of YAP, TAZ, TGM2 and CTGF normalized to
GAPDH by qRT-PCR (n = 6 replicates from 2 HTM/GTM cell strains). (C) Immunoblot of 14-3-3σ, p-YAP, p-TAZ, total YAP and total TAZ. (D) Immunoblot analysis of 14-
3-3σ, p-YAP/YAP and p-TAZ/TAZ normalized to GAPDH (n = 6 replicates from 2 HTM/GTM cell strains). (E,G) Representative fluorescence micrographs of YAP/
TAZ in HTM and GTM cells (YAP/TAZ = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm; arrows indicate YAP/TAZ nuclear localization. (F,H) Analysis of YAP/TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n =
20 images from 2 HTM/GTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). Open and closed symbols represent different cell strains. In (A,B,D), the bars or lines and
error bars indicate Mean ± SD; In (F,H) the box and whisker plots represent median values (horizontal bars), 25th to 75th percentiles (box edges) and minimum to
maximum values (whiskers), with all points plotted. Significance was determined by unpaired t-test (A,F,H) and two-way ANOVA using multiple comparisons tests (B,D)
(*p < 0.05; **p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001; ****p < 0.0001). FIGURE 1 | Upregulated active TGFβ2 and YAP/TAZ nuclear localization in GTM cells compared to normal HTM cells. (A) Active TGFβ2 levels were quantified by
ELISA (n = 16 replicates from three HTM cell strains, n = 13 replicates from 2 GTM cell strains). (B) mRNA fold-change of YAP, TAZ, TGM2 and CTGF normalized to
GAPDH by qRT-PCR (n = 6 replicates from 2 HTM/GTM cell strains). (C) Immunoblot of 14-3-3σ, p-YAP, p-TAZ, total YAP and total TAZ. (D) Immunoblot analysis of 14-
3-3σ, p-YAP/YAP and p-TAZ/TAZ normalized to GAPDH (n = 6 replicates from 2 HTM/GTM cell strains). Statistical Analysis (E,G) Representative fluorescence micrographs of YAP/
TAZ in HTM and GTM cells (YAP/TAZ = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm; arrows indicate YAP/TAZ nuclear localization. (F,H) Analysis of YAP/TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n =
20 images from 2 HTM/GTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). Open and closed symbols represent different cell strains. In (A,B,D), the bars or lines and
error bars indicate Mean ± SD; In (F,H) the box and whisker plots represent median values (horizontal bars), 25th to 75th percentiles (box edges) and minimum to
maximum values (whiskers), with all points plotted. Significance was determined by unpaired t-test (A,F,H) and two-way ANOVA using multiple comparisons tests (B,D)
(*p < 0.05; **p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001; ****p < 0.0001). localization and transcriptional activity are elevated in GTM cells
isolated from patients with glaucoma compared to normal
HTM cells. cells on stiff glass exhibited strong vinculin FA staining
(Supplementary Figure S5A), while cells on soft hydrogels
showed qualitatively fewer vinculin puncta compared to cells
on
glass
(Figure
2C). The
stiffened
ECM
hydrogels
significantly increased number and size of vinculin puncta
in HTM cells compared to HTM cells on the soft hydrogel
substrates (Figures 2C,D; Supplementary Figure S5B). Consistent with our observation on vinculin FA, HTM
cells on stiff hydrogels exhibited ~1.26-fold larger nuclei
compared to cells on the soft hydrogels, which was still
less compared to the nuclei in HTM cells on conventional
glass (Figures 2E,F). We also found that the stiffened ECM
hydrogels
significantly
increased
filamentous
(F)-actin,
phospho-myosin
light
chain
(p-MLC)
and
α-smooth
muscle actin (αSMA) levels in HTM cells compared to
cells on the soft matrix (Figures 2G–J, Supplementary
Figures S5C,D). Importantly, we observed that nuclear
localization
of
YAP/TAZ,
TGM2
expression,
and
fibronectin
(FN)
remodeling
in
HTM
cells
were
upregulated by the stiffened ECM hydrogels compared to
cells on the soft hydrogels (Figure 2K–N; Supplementary
Figures S5E–H). Rearrangement Atomic force microscopy (AFM) analyses showed that the TM
from POAG eyes is ~1.5-5-fold stiffer compared to that from
healthy eyes (Wang et al., 2017a; Wang et al., 2017b; Vahabikashi
et al., 2019). To that end, we recently showed that DEX treated
HTM cell-laden hydrogels are ~2-fold stiffer compared to
controls (Li et al., 2021a). Here, we demonstrated that TGFβ2-
treated HTM cell encapsulated hydrogels were also ~2-fold stiffer
compared to controls using AFM and rheology (Figure 2A,
Supplementary Figure S4). To mimic the stiffness difference
between glaucomatous and healthy HTM tissue, we utilized
riboflavin
(RF)-mediated
secondary
UV
crosslinking
of
collagen fibrils, which stiffened the hydrogels by ~2-fold
(Figure 2B). Together, these results suggest that the stiffened ECM
hydrogels induce a bigger nuclear size in HTM cells on stiff
matrix compared to cells on soft matrix. The stiffened hydrogels
induce
FA
and
actomyosin
cytoskeletal
rearrangement, Adherent cells are connected to the ECM through
transmembrane receptor integrins and focal adhesion (FA)
proteins such as vinculin (Mohammed et al., 2019). HTM March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 6 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. FIGURE 2 | Stiffened ECM hydrogels elevate YAP/TAZ activity in HTM cells via modulating FA and cytoskeletal rearrangement. (A) Elastic modulus of HTM cell-
encapsulated hydrogels subjected to control and TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml) measured by AFM (n = 6 replicates/group). (B) Schematic of riboflavin (RF)-mediated double photo-
crosslinking to stiffen ECM hydrogels, and elastic modulus of the hydrogels (n = 3 replicates/group). (C) Representative fluorescence micrographs and FIJI mask images
of vinculin in HTM cells on soft and stiff hydrogels (dashed box shows region of interest in higher magnification image; vinculin = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm (left) and
5 μm (right). (D) Analysis of number of vinculin puncta (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (E,F) Representative fluorescence
micrographs and size analysis of HTM cell nuclei on soft and stiff hydrogels (n = 30 images from 2 HTM cell strains with 3–6 replicates per cell strain; more than 100 nuclei
were analyzed per cell strain; dotted line shows mean nuclear area of HTM cells on glass for reference). (G,I) Representative fluorescence micrographs of F-actin and
p-MLC in HTM cells on soft and stiff hydrogels (dashed box shows region of interest in higher magnification image. Rearrangement Open and closed symbols, or symbols with different colors represent different cell strains. The lines and error
bars indicate Mean ± SD; Significance was determined by unpaired t-test (**p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001; ****p < 0.0001). correlating with elevated YAP/TAZ nuclear localization in
HTM cells. to upregulate ERK via activating RhoA/ROCK to induce a fibrotic-
like, contractile cell phenotype using conventional stiff culture
substrates (Pattabiraman and Rao, 2010). By contrast, we recently
demonstrated that in the context of cell contractility, ROCK activity
was negatively regulated by ERK with TGFβ2 induction in HTM cells
cultured on soft tissue-like ECM hydrogels; this resulted in
differentially regulated F-actin, αSMA, FN, and p-MLC (Li et al.,
2021b). Here, we investigated whether YAP signaling in HTM cells in
response to TGFβ2 induction requires ERK or ROCK. HTM or GTM
cells were seeded on top of soft hydrogels treated with TGFβ2 ±
U0126 (ERK inhibitor) or Y27632 (ROCK inhibitor). Consistent with
our observation for cells seeded on glass (Figure 1), we found Rearrangement F-actin = green; p-MLC = red). Scale bar, 20 μm. (H,J)
Analysis of F-actin and p-MLC intensity (n = 20 images per group from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per HTM cell strain). (K,M) Representative fluorescence
micrographs of YAP/TAZ in HTM cells on soft and stiff hydrogels (YAP/TAZ = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm. (L,N) Analysis of YAP/TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 30 images
from 2 HTM cell strains with 3–6 replicates per cell strain). Open and closed symbols, or symbols with different colors represent different cell strains. The lines and error
bars indicate Mean ± SD; Significance was determined by unpaired t-test (**p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001; ****p < 0.0001). FIGURE 2 | Stiffened ECM hydrogels elevate YAP/TAZ activity in HTM cells via modulating FA and cytoskeletal rearrangement. (A) Elastic modulus of HTM cell-
encapsulated hydrogels subjected to control and TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml) measured by AFM (n = 6 replicates/group). (B) Schematic of riboflavin (RF)-mediated double photo-
crosslinking to stiffen ECM hydrogels, and elastic modulus of the hydrogels (n = 3 replicates/group). (C) Representative fluorescence micrographs and FIJI mask images
of vinculin in HTM cells on soft and stiff hydrogels (dashed box shows region of interest in higher magnification image; vinculin = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm (left) and
5 μm (right). (D) Analysis of number of vinculin puncta (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (E,F) Representative fluorescence
micrographs and size analysis of HTM cell nuclei on soft and stiff hydrogels (n = 30 images from 2 HTM cell strains with 3–6 replicates per cell strain; more than 100 nuclei
were analyzed per cell strain; dotted line shows mean nuclear area of HTM cells on glass for reference). (G,I) Representative fluorescence micrographs of F-actin and
p-MLC in HTM cells on soft and stiff hydrogels (dashed box shows region of interest in higher magnification image. F-actin = green; p-MLC = red). Scale bar, 20 μm. (H,J)
Analysis of F-actin and p-MLC intensity (n = 20 images per group from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per HTM cell strain). (K,M) Representative fluorescence
micrographs of YAP/TAZ in HTM cells on soft and stiff hydrogels (YAP/TAZ = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm. (L,N) Analysis of YAP/TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 30 images
from 2 HTM cell strains with 3–6 replicates per cell strain). TGFβ2 Regulates YAP/TAZ Activity via ERK
and ROCK Signaling Pathways TGFβ2 Regulates YAP/TAZ Activity via ERK
and ROCK Signaling Pathways TGFβ2 has been shown to activate canonical Smad (Smad2/3) and
diverse non-Smad signaling pathways including extracellular-signal-
regulated kinase (ERK), c-Jun N-terminal kinases, P38 kinases and
Rho-associated kinase (ROCK) in various cell types with context-
dependent crosstalk (Zhang, 2009; Prendes et al., 2013; Montecchi-
Palmer et al., 2017; Ma et al., 2020). In HTM cells, TGFβ2 was shown March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 7 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. FIGURE 3 | Effects of TGFβ2 in absence or presence of ERK or ROCK inhibition on nuclear YAP/TAZ localization in HTM and GTM cells. (A,C,E,G) Representative
fluorescence micrographs of YAP or TAZ in HTM or GTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected to control, TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml), TGFβ2 + U0126 (10 µM), TGFβ2 + Y27632
(10 µM) at 3 days (YAP = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm. (B,D,F,H) Analysis of YAP or TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates
per cell strain; n = 10 images from one GTM cell strain with three replicates). Symbols with different colors represent different cell strains; dotted line shows HTM cell
control mean value for reference. The lines and error bars indicate Mean ± SD. Significance was determined by one-way ANOVA using multiple comparisons tests
[shared significance indicator letters represent non-significant difference (p > 0.05), distinct letters represent significant difference (p < 0.05)]. FIGURE 3 | Effects of TGFβ2 in absence or presence of ERK or ROCK inhibition on nuclear YAP/TAZ localization in HTM and GTM cells. (A,C,E,G) Representative
fluorescence micrographs of YAP or TAZ in HTM or GTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected to control, TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml), TGFβ2 + U0126 (10 µM), TGFβ2 + Y27632
(10 µM) at 3 days (YAP = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm. (B,D,F,H) Analysis of YAP or TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates
per cell strain; n = 10 images from one GTM cell strain with three replicates). Symbols with different colors represent different cell strains; dotted line shows HTM cell
control mean value for reference. The lines and error bars indicate Mean ± SD. TGFβ2 Regulates YAP/TAZ Activity via ERK
and ROCK Signaling Pathways Significance was determined by one-way ANOVA using multiple comparisons tests
[shared significance indicator letters represent non-significant difference (p > 0.05), distinct letters represent significant difference (p < 0.05)]. Y27632 with TGFβ2 rescued TAZ nuclear localization to
control levels (Figures 3E,F). Similarly, TGFβ2 increased
TAZ N/C ratio in GTM cells, while ERK or ROCK
inhibition decreased TGFβ2-induced nuclear TAZ to HTM
control levels (Figures 3G,H). Consistent with YAP/TAZ
nuclear localization, TGM2 expression was upregulated by
TGFβ2, which was significantly decreased by co-treatment of
U0126 or Y27632 (Supplementary Figure S6). significantly higher levels of nuclear YAP/TAZ and TGM2
expression in GTM cells compared to normal HTM cells on the
soft ECM hydrogels (Figure 3; Supplementary Figure S6). TGFβ2
increased nuclear YAP in both HTM and GTM cells, which were
blocked by co-treatment of U0126 or Y27632. Importantly, we found
that YAP N/C ratio in GTM cells with ERK or ROCK inhibition were
at similar levels as HTM controls (Figures 3A–D). YAP and TAZ are generally thought to function similarly
in response to mechanical and biochemical signals (Totaro
et al., 2018). However, it has been shown that YAP and TAZ
are
distinct
effectors
of
TGFβ1-induced
myofibroblast
transformation (Muppala et al., 2019). In this study, we
observed that TGFβ2 significantly induced nuclear TAZ
localization in HTM cells, and co-treatment of U0126 or These data show that TGFβ2 increases nuclear YAP/TAZ
and TGM2 expression in both HTM and GTM cells, which
was attenuated by either U0126 or Y27632 co-treatment. Collectively,
this
suggests
that
external
biophysical
(stiffened
ECM)
and
biochemical
signals
(increased
TGFβ2) drive altered YAP and TAZ mechanotransduction March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 8 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. FIGURE 4 | Lat B reduces YAP/TAZ activity in HTM cells. (A) Schematic showing time course of Lat B experiments with HTM cells. (B) Representative fluorescence
micrographs of F-actin in HTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected to control, TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml), TGFβ2 + Lat B (2 µM) at 3 days (F-actin = green; DAPI = blue). Scale bar,
20 μm. (C) Quantification of F-actin intensity (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). TGFβ2 Regulates YAP/TAZ Activity via ERK
and ROCK Signaling Pathways (D) Representative fluorescence micrographs of
vinculin in HTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (dashed box shows region of interest in higher magnification image; vinculin = grey;
DAPI = blue). Scale bar, 20 and 10 μm. (E) Analysis of number of vinculin puncta (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (F,H)
Representative fluorescence micrographs of YAP/TAZ in HTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (YAP/TAZ = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm. (G,I)
Analysis of YAP/TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (J) Representative fluorescence micrographs of
TGM2 in HTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected the different treatments (TGM2 = green; DAPI = blue). Scale bar, 20 μm. (K) Analysis of TGM2 intensity (n = 20 images
per group from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per HTM cell strain). (L,M) Immunoblot of p-YAP, total YAP, p-TAZ and total TAZ, and immunoblot analysis of
p-YAP/YAP and pTAZ/TAZ (n = 3 replicates). Symbols with different colors represent different cell strains. The lines or bars and error bars indicate Mean ± SD. Significance was determined by one-way (C,E,H,J,L) and two-way ANOVA (F) using multiple comparisons tests (*p < 0.05; **p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001; ****p < 0.0001). FIGURE 4 | Lat B reduces YAP/TAZ activity in HTM cells. (A) Schematic showing time course of Lat B experiments with HTM cells. (B) Representative fluorescence
micrographs of F-actin in HTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected to control, TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml), TGFβ2 + Lat B (2 µM) at 3 days (F-actin = green; DAPI = blue). Scale bar,
20 μm. (C) Quantification of F-actin intensity (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (D) Representative fluorescence micrographs of
vinculin in HTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (dashed box shows region of interest in higher magnification image; vinculin = grey;
DAPI = blue). Scale bar, 20 and 10 μm. (E) Analysis of number of vinculin puncta (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (F,H)
Representative fluorescence micrographs of YAP/TAZ in HTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (YAP/TAZ = grey). Scale bar, 20 μm. TGFβ2 Regulates YAP/TAZ Activity via ERK
and ROCK Signaling Pathways (G,I)
Analysis of YAP/TAZ nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (J) Representative fluorescence micrographs of
TGM2 in HTM cells on soft hydrogels subjected the different treatments (TGM2 = green; DAPI = blue). Scale bar, 20 μm. (K) Analysis of TGM2 intensity (n = 20 images
per group from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per HTM cell strain). (L,M) Immunoblot of p-YAP, total YAP, p-TAZ and total TAZ, and immunoblot analysis of
p-YAP/YAP and pTAZ/TAZ (n = 3 replicates). Symbols with different colors represent different cell strains. The lines or bars and error bars indicate Mean ± SD. Significance was determined by one-way (C,E,H,J,L) and two-way ANOVA (F) using multiple comparisons tests (*p < 0.05; **p < 0.01; ***p < 0.001; ****p < 0.0001). in HTM cells that contributes to glaucomatous cellular
dysfunction. significantly increased F-actin fibers, and co-treatment of Lat B
with TGFβ2 potently depolymerized F-actin and decreased
F-actin fiber formation (Figures 4B,C) without negatively
influencing cell viability (all three groups exhibited ~8 cells/
0.05 mm2). We observed significantly more vinculin puncta
and increased puncta size induced by TGFβ2, which was
abolished by Lat B treatment (Figures 4D,E; Supplementary
Figure S7). Similar to before (Figure 3), TGFβ2 significantly
increased YAP/TAZ nuclear localization and TGM2 expression,
which were restored to control levels by 30 min of Lat B co-
treatment (Figures 4F–K). Immunoblot analyses corroborated
the immunostaining results and showed that co-treatment of
TGFβ2 and Lat B increased the ratio of p-YAP to YAP and p-TAZ
to TAZ (Figures 4L,M), representing overall decreased nuclear
YAP and TAZ consistent with previous studies (Piccolo et al.,
2014; Das et al., 2016; Panciera et al., 2017). Interestingly,
according to the immunoblot result, Lat B may regulate YAP F-Actin Polymerization Modulates YAP/TAZ
Activity It has been shown that latrunculin B (Lat B), a compound that
inhibits polymerization of the actin cytoskeleton, increases
outflow facility and decreases IOP in human and non-human
primate eyes (Peterson et al., 1999; Tian et al., 2000; Ethier et al.,
2006). Likewise, Lat B has been reported to depolymerize HTM
cell actin and decrease cellular stiffness via cytoskeletal relaxation
(McKee et al., 2011). To investigate the effects of F-actin
cytoskeletal disruption on YAP/TAZ activity, HTM cells were
seeded on top of soft hydrogels, and treated with TGFβ2 for
3 days, followed by Lat B treatment for 30 min (Figure 4A). Consistent with our previous study (Li et al., 2021b), TGFβ2 March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 9 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. FIGURE 5 | YAP/TAZ are regulators of FA formation, ECM remodeling and cell contractile properties in HTM cells. (A) Schematic showing time course of YAP/TAZ
depletion using siRNA experiments with HTM cells. (B,D,F,H,J and L) Representative fluorescence micrographs of TGM2, FN, αSMA, F-actin, p-MLC and vinculin in
HTM cells on stiff hydrogels subjected to siControl or siYAP/TAZ (dashed box shows region of interest in higher magnification image; TGM2/F-actin = green; FN/p-MLC/
αSMA = red; vinculin = grey; DAPI = blue). Scale bar, 20 μm in (B,F,H,J); 20 and 5 μm in L; 100 μm in D. (C,E,G,I,K,M) Analysis of TGM2, FN, αSMA, F-actin,
p-MLC and number of vinculin puncta (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (N) Representative fluorescence micrographs and size
analysis of HTM cell nuclei on stiff hydrogels subjected to siControl or siYAP/TAZ (n = 40 images from 2 HTM cell strains with six replicates per cell strain; more than 100
nuclei were analyzed per cell strain). (O) mRNA fold-change of FN, TGM2, CTGF, αSMA in HTM cells on stiff hydrogels subjected to siControl or siYAP/TAZ by qRT-PCR. The mRNA levels were normalized to the levels of GAPDH mRNA 48 h post transfection (n = 6 replicates from 2 HTM cell strain). Open and closed symbols represent
different cell strains. The lines and error bars indicate Mean ± SD; Significance was determined by unpaired t-test (C,E,G,I,K,M,N) and two-way ANOVA (O) using
multiple comparisons tests (**p < 0.01; ****p < 0.0001). F-Actin Polymerization Modulates YAP/TAZ
Activity FIGURE 5 | YAP/TAZ are regulators of FA formation, ECM remodeling and cell contractile properties in HTM cells. (A) Schematic showing time course of YAP/TAZ
depletion using siRNA experiments with HTM cells. (B,D,F,H,J and L) Representative fluorescence micrographs of TGM2, FN, αSMA, F-actin, p-MLC and vinculin in
HTM cells on stiff hydrogels subjected to siControl or siYAP/TAZ (dashed box shows region of interest in higher magnification image; TGM2/F-actin = green; FN/p-MLC/
αSMA = red; vinculin = grey; DAPI = blue). Scale bar, 20 μm in (B,F,H,J); 20 and 5 μm in L; 100 μm in D. (C,E,G,I,K,M) Analysis of TGM2, FN, αSMA, F-actin,
p-MLC and number of vinculin puncta (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (N) Representative fluorescence micrographs and size
analysis of HTM cell nuclei on stiff hydrogels subjected to siControl or siYAP/TAZ (n = 40 images from 2 HTM cell strains with six replicates per cell strain; more than 100
nuclei were analyzed per cell strain). (O) mRNA fold-change of FN, TGM2, CTGF, αSMA in HTM cells on stiff hydrogels subjected to siControl or siYAP/TAZ by qRT-PCR. The mRNA levels were normalized to the levels of GAPDH mRNA 48 h post transfection (n = 6 replicates from 2 HTM cell strain). Open and closed symbols represent
different cell strains. The lines and error bars indicate Mean ± SD; Significance was determined by unpaired t-test (C,E,G,I,K,M,N) and two-way ANOVA (O) using
multiple comparisons tests (**p < 0.01; ****p < 0.0001). we seeded HTM cells on stiff hydrogels to increase the baseline
levels of YAP/TAZ in controls, and depleted YAP and TAZ using
combined siRNA knockdown (Figure 5A). Treatment reduced
mRNA expression levels to 34.52 and 35.25% of siRNA controls,
respectively (Supplementary Figure S8A). On a protein level, we
observed 64.80% YAP knockdown with combined siYAP/TAZ
treatment or 49.10% YAP knockdown with single siYAP
treatment. TAZ protein levels were reduced by 89.90% with
siYAP/TAZ
and
by
80.90%
with
siTAZ
treatments,
respectively (Supplementary Figures S8B–D). Curiously, we
noted a drop in TAZ protein levels in siYAP-treated HTM
cells, whereas no such effects were noted in YAP protein
expression
with
siTAZ
treatment,
requiring
further activity by increasing p-YAP while maintaining similar levels of
total YAP, whereas Lat B may decrease total levels of TAZ while
maintaining similar levels of p-TAZ (Figures 4L,M). F-Actin Polymerization Modulates YAP/TAZ
Activity In sum, these findings demonstrate that F-actin depolymerization
decreases TGFβ2-induced vinculin FA, nuclear YAP/TAZ and their
downstream target TGM2. YAP/TAZ Regulate FA Formation, ECM YAP/TAZ Regulate FA Formation, ECM
Remodeling and Cell Contractile Properties
Our results so far suggest that POAG-related stimuli (i.e., TGFβ2
and stiffened ECM) increase YAP/TAZ activity in HTM cells. To
further investigate the roles of YAP/TAZ in HTM cell function, March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 10 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. FIGURE 6 | Inhibition of YAP/TAZ-TEAD interaction with VP decreases nuclear YAP and F-actin levels. (A) Representative fluorescence micrographs of YAP in HTM
cells cultured on top of soft hydrogels subjected to control, TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml), VP (0.5 µM), TGFβ2 + VP at 3 days (YAP = grey; DAPI = blue). Scale bar, 20 μm. (B)
Analysis of YAP nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (C) Representative fluorescence micrographs of
YAP in HTM cells encapsulated in soft hydrogels subjected to the different treatments at 3 days (YAP = grey; DAPI = blue). Arrows indicate higher YAP in nuclei,
arrowheads indicate higher YAP in cytoplasm. Scale bar, 20 μm. (D) Analysis of YAP nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 6 images from one HTM cell strain with three
replicates). (E) Representative fluorescence micrographs of F-actin in HTM cells on or inside of soft hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (F-actin = red). Scale
bar, 50 μm. (F) Analysis of F-actin intensity in HTM cells on soft hydrogels (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (G) Analysis of
F-actin intensity in HTM cells inside of soft hydrogels (n = 6 images from one HTM cell strain with three replicates). Open and closed symbols represent different cell
strains. The lines and error bars indicate Mean ± SD; Significance was determined by one-way ANOVA using multiple comparisons tests [shared significance indicator
letters represent non-significant difference (p > 0.05), distinct letters represent significant difference (p < 0.05)]. FIGURE 6 | Inhibition of YAP/TAZ-TEAD interaction with VP decreases nuclear YAP and F-actin levels. (A) Representative fluorescence micrographs of YAP in HTM
cells cultured on top of soft hydrogels subjected to control, TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml), VP (0.5 µM), TGFβ2 + VP at 3 days (YAP = grey; DAPI = blue). Scale bar, 20 μm. (B)
Analysis of YAP nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). YAP/TAZ Regulate FA Formation, ECM (C) Representative fluorescence micrographs of
YAP in HTM cells encapsulated in soft hydrogels subjected to the different treatments at 3 days (YAP = grey; DAPI = blue). Arrows indicate higher YAP in nuclei,
arrowheads indicate higher YAP in cytoplasm. Scale bar, 20 μm. (D) Analysis of YAP nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio (n = 6 images from one HTM cell strain with three
replicates). (E) Representative fluorescence micrographs of F-actin in HTM cells on or inside of soft hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (F-actin = red). Scale
bar, 50 μm. (F) Analysis of F-actin intensity in HTM cells on soft hydrogels (n = 20 images from 2 HTM cell strains with three replicates per cell strain). (G) Analysis of
F-actin intensity in HTM cells inside of soft hydrogels (n = 6 images from one HTM cell strain with three replicates). Open and closed symbols represent different cell
strains. The lines and error bars indicate Mean ± SD; Significance was determined by one-way ANOVA using multiple comparisons tests [shared significance indicator
letters represent non-significant difference (p > 0.05), distinct letters represent significant difference (p < 0.05)]. formation, cytoskeletal/nuclear and ECM remodeling, and cell
contractile properties. investigation. Immunostaining showed that YAP/TAZ nuclear
localization in HTM cells transfected with siYAP/TAZ were
significantly
decreased
vs. controls
despite
culture
in
a
stiffened ECM environment (Supplementary Figures S8E–H). Importantly, we observed that YAP/TAZ depletion significantly
reduced expression of TGM2, FN and CTGF, which may decrease
HTM ECM stiffness (Figures 5B–E,O). YAP/TAZ-TEAD Interaction is Required for
YAP/TAZ Downstream Effects Canonically, YAP/TAZ bind to TEAD family members to induce
the transcription of YAP/TAZ target genes (Low et al., 2014). To
test the effects of YAP/TAZ-TEAD interaction on HTM cell
behavior under simulated glaucomatous conditions, we tested the
effects of verteporfin (VP), a selective inhibitor of the YAP/TAZ-
TEAD transcriptional complex (Liu-Chittenden et al., 2012). HTM cells were seeded on top of or encapsulated in soft
hydrogels, and treated with TGFβ2 ± VP. Interestingly, we
observed that HTM cells inside hydrogels showed qualitatively
decreased YAP nuclear-to-cytoplasmic ratio compared to cells
atop of the hydrogels in absence of any treatments (Figures
6A–D). In both cell culture environments, TGFβ2 increased
nuclear YAP/TAZ localization, and treating HTM cells with
VP significantly decreased TGFβ2-induced nuclear YAP/TAZ
as well as downstream TGM2 compared to controls, consistent
with the effects of siRNA-mediated YAP/TAZ depletion (Figures
6A–D; Supplementary Figures S9A–D). We observed that the
inhibition of YAP/TAZ-TEAD interaction not only decreased
nuclear YAP/TAZ, but also reduced cytoplasmic and total protein F-actin filaments, αSMA and p-MLC are all involved in cell
contractility regulation, and we have previously demonstrated
that their expression was upregulated in HTM cells under
simulated glaucomatous conditions (Li et al., 2021a; Li et al.,
2021b). Here, YAP/TAZ depletion significantly decreased
F-actin filaments and expression of αSMA and p-MLC,
suggestive
of
reduced
HTM
cell
contractility
(Figures
5F–I,O). We also found that the expression of canonical
Hippo pathway kinases LATS1, LATS2 and 14-3-3σ was not
affected by siYAP/TAZ knockdown (Supplementary Figure
S8I). Tension generated within the actomyosin cytoskeleton is
transmitted across FA to induce integrin-mediated remodeling
of the ECM (Jansen et al., 2017). As such, we observed that
YAP/TAZ depletion significantly decreased the number and
size of vinculin puncta and nuclear size (Figures 5L−N;
Supplementary Figure S8J). Collectively, these data demonstrate that YAP/TAZ depletion
using siRNA leads to impaired YAP/TAZ signaling, FA March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 11 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. FIGURE 7 | Inhibition of YAP/TAZ activity decreases HTM hydrogel contractility and stiffness. (A) Representative brightfield images of HTM hydrogels subjected to
control, TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml), TGFβ2 + VP (0.5 µM) at 5 days (dashed lines outline original size of constructs at 0 days). Scale bar, 1 mm. (B) Construct size quantification
of HTM hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (n = 11 replicates per group from three HTM cell strains). YAP/TAZ-TEAD Interaction is Required for
YAP/TAZ Downstream Effects (C) Normalized elastic modulus (to controls) of HTM
hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (n = 6 replicates per group from three HTM cell strains). (D) Representative brightfield images of GTM hydrogels
subjected to the different treatments at 5 days (dashed lines outline original size of constructs at 0 days). Scale bar, 1 mm. (E) Construct size quantification of GTM
hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (n = 8 replicates per group from 2 GTM cell strains). Open and closed symbols, or symbols with different colors represent
different cell strains; dotted line shows HTM cell control mean value for reference. The lines and error bars indicate Mean ± SD; Significance was determined by one-way
ANOVA using multiple comparisons tests [shared significance indicator letters represent non-significant difference (p > 0.05), distinct letters represent significant
difference (p < 0.05)]. FIGURE 7 | Inhibition of YAP/TAZ activity decreases HTM hydrogel contractility and stiffness. (A) Representative brightfield images of HTM hydrogels subjected to
control, TGFβ2 (2.5 ng/ml), TGFβ2 + VP (0.5 µM) at 5 days (dashed lines outline original size of constructs at 0 days). Scale bar, 1 mm. (B) Construct size quantification
of HTM hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (n = 11 replicates per group from three HTM cell strains). (C) Normalized elastic modulus (to controls) of HTM
hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (n = 6 replicates per group from three HTM cell strains). (D) Representative brightfield images of GTM hydrogels
subjected to the different treatments at 5 days (dashed lines outline original size of constructs at 0 days). Scale bar, 1 mm. (E) Construct size quantification of GTM
hydrogels subjected to the different treatments (n = 8 replicates per group from 2 GTM cell strains). Open and closed symbols, or symbols with different colors represent
different cell strains; dotted line shows HTM cell control mean value for reference. The lines and error bars indicate Mean ± SD; Significance was determined by one-way
ANOVA using multiple comparisons tests [shared significance indicator letters represent non-significant difference (p > 0.05), distinct letters represent significant
difference (p < 0.05)]. prevented by co-treatment with VP (1.16-fold of controls)
(Figure 7B). levels (Supplementary Figure S9E). VP treatment significantly
decreased TGFβ2-induced F-actin filaments, expression of αSMA
and p-MLC, and FN deposition (Figures 6E–G; Supplementary
Figures S9F–K). YAP/TAZ-TEAD Interaction is Required for
YAP/TAZ Downstream Effects To assess whether YAP/TAZ inhibition had comparable
effects on GTM cells, we evaluated GTM cell-laden hydrogel
contraction in response to the same treatments. Consistent with
our previous study (Li et al., 2021a), we demonstrated that GTM
hydrogels in absence of additional TGFβ2 induction exhibited
significantly greater contraction relative to normal HTM
hydrogels (86.08% of HTM hydrogels controls); TGFβ2 further
increased GTM hydrogel contraction, and VP partially blocked
this during the short 5 days exposure (Figure 7C). Collectively,
these
results
show
that
pharmacological
inhibition of YAP/TAZ-TEAD interaction leads to impaired
ECM remodeling and cell contractile properties, which is
independent
of
cell
culture
environments
(atop
or
encapsulated in ECM hydrogels). Collectively,
these
results
show
that
pharmacological
inhibition of YAP/TAZ-TEAD interaction leads to impaired
ECM remodeling and cell contractile properties, which is
independent
of
cell
culture
environments
(atop
or
encapsulated in ECM hydrogels). YAP/TAZ Mediate HTM Cell Contractility
and HTM Hydrogel Stiffness g
y
p
g
To determine if hydrogel contractility was influenced by the
cell number, we assessed HTM/GTM cell proliferation in
constructs subjected to the different treatments. We observed
a fewer number of cells in the TGFβ2 + VP group compared to
TGFβ2-treated samples (10.10% decreased) (Supplementary
Figure S10A), while co-treatment of TGFβ2 + VP reduced
hydrogel contraction and stiffening by 21.63 and 59.45%
compared to the TGFβ2-treated group, respectively (Figures
7A,B); demonstrating that VP induced decreasing hydrogel
contraction was not only caused by the smaller cell number,
but also reduced cell contractility. No significant differences
between the different groups were observed for GTM cell-
laden hydrogels (Supplementary Figure S10B). y
g
Lastly, to investigate the effects of YAP/TAZ on HTM cell
contractility and ECM stiffening, we encapsulated HTM cells
in ECM hydrogels and treated with TGFβ2, either alone or in
combination with VP, and assessed hydrogel contractility and
stiffness. TGFβ2-treated HTM hydrogels exhibited significantly
greater contraction vs. controls by 5 days (74.30% of controls),
consistent with our previous report (Li et al., 2021a). Co-
treatment of TGFβ2 + VP potently decreased HTM hydrogel
contraction (90.37% of controls) compared to TGFβ2-treated
samples (Figure 7A). We observed that TGFβ2 significantly
increased hydrogel stiffness (1.86-fold of controls), which was March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 12 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. FIGURE 8 | Schematic illustration of the effects elicited by ECM stiffness and TGFβ2 that modulate YAP/TAZ activity in HTM cells. Stiffened ECM hydrogels elevate
YAP/TAZ activity potentially through regulating focal adhesion formation and actin cytoskeleton rearrangement. TGFβ2 activates ERK and ROCK signaling pathways,
with potential context-dependent crosstalk, to regulate YAP/TAZ activity in normal HTM and GTM cells. YAP/TAZ activation induces HTM cell contractility and ECM
remodeling, which together may increase HTM stiffness in POAG. Created with BioRender.com. FIGURE 8 | Schematic illustration of the effects elicited by ECM stiffness and TGFβ2 that modulate YAP/TAZ activity in HTM cells. Stiffened ECM hydrogels elevate
YAP/TAZ activity potentially through regulating focal adhesion formation and actin cytoskeleton rearrangement. TGFβ2 activates ERK and ROCK signaling pathways,
with potential context-dependent crosstalk, to regulate YAP/TAZ activity in normal HTM and GTM cells. YAP/TAZ activation induces HTM cell contractility and ECM
remodeling, which together may increase HTM stiffness in POAG. Created with BioRender.com. YAP/TAZ Mediate HTM Cell Contractility
and HTM Hydrogel Stiffness Together, these data demonstrate that TGFβ2 robustly induces
HTM hydrogel contractility and stiffening in a soft ECM
environment,
which
are
potently
reduced
by
YAP/TAZ
inhibition. Likewise, inhibition of YAP/TAZ had similar effects
on GTM cells inside the 3D hydrogel network. we found that YAP/TAZ nuclear localization, the principal
mechanism to regulate their function, is significantly higher in
TM cells from patients with glaucoma compared to cells isolated
from healthy tissue, exhibiting normal variability between cells
from different donors (i.e., one GTM cell strain showed higher
baseline YAP/TAZ nuclear localization and transcriptional
activity compared to the other) (Figure 1; Supplementary
Figures S2, S3). However, the detailed mechanisms for YAP/
TAZ modulation in HTM cells under glaucomatous conditions
(i.e., stiffened ECM and increased growth factors in AH) remain
to be elucidated. To model this, we used biomimetic ECM
hydrogels with tunable stiffness to study the roles of YAP and
TAZ in HTM cells in response to stiffened matrix and TGFβ2. As
summarized in Figure 8, our data support that YAP/TAZ are
critical regulators in mediating HTM cellular responses to the
stiffened ECM and elevated TGFβ2 in POAG involving both ERK
and ROCK signaling with likely crosstalk; we propose that
increased YAP/TAZ nuclear retention may drive further HTM
tissue stiffening to exacerbate disease pathology conditions. This
conclusion is supported by the findings that (i) stiffened ECM
hydrogels elevate YAP/TAZ nuclear localization, potentially
through
regulating
FA
formation
and
cytoskeleton
rearrangement;
(ii)
TGFβ2
induces
nuclear
YAP/TAZ
localization and target gene activation through ERK and
ROCK signaling pathways; (iii) depolymerization of F-actin
decreases nuclear YAP/TAZ; (iv) YAP/TAZ depletion using
siRNA or pharmacological inhibition of YAP/TAZ-TEAD DISCUSSION In this study,
we demonstrated that TGFβ2 treatment resulted in a comparable
~2-fold increase in ECM stiffness surrounding the HTM cells as
they
reside
embedded
in
our
bioengineered
hydrogels
(Figure 2A). In both scenarios, the stiffness changes were cell-
driven in response to biochemical cues implicated in glaucoma. Corneal UV crosslinking with riboflavin (RF) is a clinical
treatment to stabilize the collagen-rich stroma in corneal ectasias
(Zhang et al., 2011; Rahman et al., 2020), with promising
potential for enhancing mechanical properties of collagen-
based hydrogels (Ahearne and Coyle, 2016; Heo et al., 2016). Crosslinking occurs via covalent bond formation between amino
acids of collagen fibrils induced by singlet O2 from UV-excited RF
(Tirella et al., 2012). To simulate glaucomatous ECM stiffening
for investigations of the cellular response, we used riboflavin to
double-crosslink collagen in the hydrogels, which increased their
stiffness ~2-fold over baseline (Figure 2B). HTM cells on the
stiffened hydrogels exhibited bigger nuclei, increased number of
vinculin FA, cytoskeleton rearrangement, ECM deposition and
YAP/TAZ nuclear localization compared to cells on soft
hydrogels (Figures 2C–N; Supplementary Figure S3). Taken
together, our findings indicate that YAP/TAZ subcellular Increased tissue stiffness has been observed in multiple
pathologies, including cancer, cardiovascular and fibrosis-
related
diseases
(Lampi
and
Reinhart-King,
2018). ECM
stiffening can precede disease development and consequently
increased mechanical cues can drive their progression via altered
mechanotransduction (Frantz et al., 2010; Kaess et al., 2012;
Pickup et al., 2014). Therefore, therapeutically targeting ECM
stiffening by disrupting the cellular response to the stiffened ECM
environment, or in other words targeting mechanotransduction,
is an emerging field with clear implications for glaucoma
treatment. It is widely accepted that the ECM is stiffer in the
glaucomatous HTM (Wang et al., 2017b). Previous studies have
also shown that ECM deposited by HTM cells treated with DEX
was ~2-4-fold stiffer relative to controls (Raghunathan et al.,
2015; Raghunathan et al., 2018). Our recent data using DEX-
induced HTM cell-encapsulated 3D ECM hydrogels were in good
agreement with these observations (Li et al., 2021a). In this study,
we demonstrated that TGFβ2 treatment resulted in a comparable
~2-fold increase in ECM stiffness surrounding the HTM cells as
they
reside
embedded
in
our
bioengineered
hydrogels
(Figure 2A). In both scenarios, the stiffness changes were cell-
driven in response to biochemical cues implicated in glaucoma. DISCUSSION The mechanosensitive transcriptional coactivators YAP and TAZ
play important roles in mechanotransduction, a process through
which cells translate external biophysical cues into internal
biochemical
signals. YAP/TAZ
modulate
target
gene
expression profiles with broad functional consequences across
many cell and tissue types (Dupont et al., 2011; Boopathy and
Hong, 2019). Through this mechanism, YAP/TAZ signaling
regulates
critical
cellular
functions
and
normal
tissue
homeostasis; imbalance or failure of this process is at the core
of various diseases (Panciera et al., 2017). Indeed, elevated YAP/
TAZ transcriptional activity is associated with glaucomatous
HTM cell dysfunction (Thomasy et al., 2013; Chen et al.,
2015; Ho et al., 2018; Peng et al., 2018; Dhamodaran et al.,
2020; Yemanyi et al., 2020; Yemanyi and Raghunathan, 2020). Importantly, a recent genome-wide meta-analysis identified YAP
among 44 previously unknown POAG risk loci (Gharahkhani
et al., 2021); this observation provides strong new evidence that
YAP may play a prominent role in glaucoma pathogenesis. Here, March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 13 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. Li et al. interaction decreases FA formation, cytoskeletal/nuclear/ECM
remodeling and cell contractile properties; (v) YAP/TAZ
inhibitor
VP
decreases
HTM/GTM
cell-laden
hydrogel
contraction and HTM hydrogel stiffening. localization in HTM cells is distinctive on different substrates,
suggesting that hydrogels with tunable physiochemical properties
may be more suitable to investigate subtleties in HTM cell
behaviors that would otherwise go unnoticed when relying
exclusively on traditional stiff 2D culture substrates. Most in vitro studies of HTM cell (patho-)physiology have
relied on conventional cell monolayer cultures on plastic or glass
of supraphysiologic stiffness. However, biophysical cues such as
substrate composition and stiffness are known to be potent
modulators of cell behaviors (Raghunathan et al., 2013). In
our previous studies, we reported that HTM cells on glass
exhibited bigger nuclei and different organization of F-actin
fibers compared to HTM cells on ECM hydrogels (Li et al.,
2021b). Here, we demonstrated that HTM cells on hydrogels
showed a smaller number of vinculin FA vs. HTM cells on glass
(Figures 2C,D; Supplementary Figure S5A), confirming that
HTM cells display distinct physiological characteristics on soft
tissue-mimetic biomaterials and traditional tissue culture plastic
or glass substrates of supraphysiological stiffness (Caliari and
Burdick, 2016). DISCUSSION ERK or ROCK inhibition decreased nuclear YAP/TAZ and
TGM2 in both HTM and GTM cells, and co-treatment of ERK or
ROCK inhibitor with TGFβ2 restored YAP/TAZ cellular
localization and TGM2 to HTM control levels (Figure 3;
Supplementary Figure S6). TGFβ2 is known to signal via
both canonical Smad and non-canonical signaling pathways,
such as ERK, JNK, P38 kinases and ROCK in various cell
types (Zhang, 2009). In HTM cells, TGFβ2 induces cross-
linked actin network formation and this process is similarly
blocked
by
inhibition
of
Smad
or
non-Smad
signaling
pathways (Montecchi-Palmer et al., 2017). Among the non-
canonical TGFβ2 signaling pathways, ERK and ROCK have
emerged as potent regulators of F-actin, αSMA and FN
expression - all of which are implicated in glaucomatous cell
pathobiology (Pattabiraman and Rao, 2010; Montecchi-Palmer
et al., 2017; Faralli et al., 2019). Other reports showed that ROCK
promotes smooth muscle cell migration and serotonin-mediated
cell proliferation via increasing ERK activity (Liu et al., 2004;
Zhao et al., 2012). In neurons and microglia, ERK activity has
been found to be negatively regulated by ROCK (Hensel et al.,
2015). Together, this suggests the presence of complex ERK and
ROCK signaling crosstalk to regulate cellular behaviors in a
context-dependent manner; yet, the molecular mechanisms of
their crosstalk in HTM cells is far from clear. TGFβ2 was shown
to upregulate ERK via activating RhoA/ROCK in HTM cells
cultured on conventional stiff substrates, such as glass or plastic,
to induce a fibrotic-like, contractile cell phenotype (Pattabiraman Corneal UV crosslinking with riboflavin (RF) is a clinical
treatment to stabilize the collagen-rich stroma in corneal ectasias
(Zhang et al., 2011; Rahman et al., 2020), with promising
potential for enhancing mechanical properties of collagen-
based hydrogels (Ahearne and Coyle, 2016; Heo et al., 2016). Crosslinking occurs via covalent bond formation between amino
acids of collagen fibrils induced by singlet O2 from UV-excited RF
(Tirella et al., 2012). To simulate glaucomatous ECM stiffening
for investigations of the cellular response, we used riboflavin to
double-crosslink collagen in the hydrogels, which increased their
stiffness ~2-fold over baseline (Figure 2B). HTM cells on the
stiffened hydrogels exhibited bigger nuclei, increased number of
vinculin FA, cytoskeleton rearrangement, ECM deposition and
YAP/TAZ nuclear localization compared to cells on soft
hydrogels (Figures 2C–N; Supplementary Figure S3). DISCUSSION y
TGFβ2 levels are elevated in the aqueous humor of glaucoma
patients compared to age-matched normal eyes (Inatani et al.,
2001; Picht et al., 2001; Ochiai and Ochiai, 2002; Agarwal et al.,
2015). Here, we showed that GTM cells isolated from POAG
donor eyes secreted significantly more active TGFβ2 compared to
normal HTM cells (Figure 1A; Supplementary Figure S2). We
observed that TGFβ2 upregulated YAP/TAZ nuclear localization
and TGM2 expression, a downstream effector of active YAP/TAZ
signaling, in both normal HTM and GTM cells, confirming that
YAP/TAZ
activity
are
upregulated
under
glaucomatous
conditions. Consistent
with
these
observations,
our
immunoblot data showed significantly decreased p-YAP/YAP
and p-TAZ/TAZ ratios (Figures 1C,D), indicative of “less
inactive YAP/TAZ” in GTM cells compared to normal HTM
cells. Given that S127 in YAP (and S89 in TAZ) is among the most
relevant residues that keeps YAP inhibited, it appears likely that
LATS1/2 kinases play a central role in HTM/GTM cell
modulation. However, it is conceivable that kinases other than
LATS1/2 target S127, as it was originally identified as AKT target
(Basu et al., 2003). S127 phosphorylation has been observed to
occur in a LATS1/2-independent manner; in the context of cell
contractility and ECM stiffening, YAP mechanotransduction was
also
shown
to
occur
independently
of
LATS-mediated
phosphorylation, rather involving ROCK and myosin activities
(Piccolo et al., 2014; Sorrentino et al., 2014). Burdick, 2016). Increased tissue stiffness has been observed in multiple
pathologies, including cancer, cardiovascular and fibrosis-
related
diseases
(Lampi
and
Reinhart-King,
2018). ECM
stiffening can precede disease development and consequently
increased mechanical cues can drive their progression via altered
mechanotransduction (Frantz et al., 2010; Kaess et al., 2012;
Pickup et al., 2014). Therefore, therapeutically targeting ECM
stiffening by disrupting the cellular response to the stiffened ECM
environment, or in other words targeting mechanotransduction,
is an emerging field with clear implications for glaucoma
treatment. It is widely accepted that the ECM is stiffer in the
glaucomatous HTM (Wang et al., 2017b). Previous studies have
also shown that ECM deposited by HTM cells treated with DEX
was ~2-4-fold stiffer relative to controls (Raghunathan et al.,
2015; Raghunathan et al., 2018). Our recent data using DEX-
induced HTM cell-encapsulated 3D ECM hydrogels were in good
agreement with these observations (Li et al., 2021a). DISCUSSION Taken
together, our findings indicate that YAP/TAZ subcellular March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 14 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. Li et al. activity, cell contractile properties and ECM remodeling
(Figure 6; Supplementary Figure S9). and Rao, 2010). Consistent with other cell systems, findings from
this study suggested that the two non-canonical signaling
pathways act in sequence. In our recent study, however, we
demonstrated that ERK may inhibit ROCK activity and
p-MLC to increase contractility of HTM cells cultured in a
soft tissue-like ECM environment; no such effect was observed
in cells on stiff glass (Li et al., 2021b). Further research will be
necessary to investigate in greater detail whether/how canonical
Smad signaling cross talks with non-canonical ERK and ROCK
signaling pathways to regulate YAP and TAZ activity in
HTM cells. Notably, YAP/TAZ inhibition using VP blunted HTM/GTM
cell-laden hydrogel contraction and stiffening (Figure 7). Thus,
we conclude that YAP/TAZ act as central players in regulating
HTM cell mechanical homeostasis in response to changes of the
surrounding microenvironment (e.g., levels of growth factors,
ECM stiffness) to maintain tissue-level structural integrity and
functionality. It has been demonstrated that the relative roles of
YAP/TAZ are cell type- and context-dependent; they can cause
homeostatic regulation of tissue properties (negative feedback
loop) or promote fibrotic conditions (positive feedback loop). Some reports implicated YAP/TAZ in a feed-forward promotion
of cytoskeletal tension and ECM protein deposition (Lin et al.,
2017; Nardone et al., 2017; Yemanyi and Raghunathan, 2020),
while some research showed YAP/TAZ had a negative feedback
regulation that acted to suppress actin polymerization and
cytoskeletal tension (Qiao et al., 2017; Mason et al., 2019). Our data were consistent with the former; i.e., YAP/TAZ
drives HTM cell contraction and ECM stiffening. Actomyosin cell contractility forces are increased in response
to elevated ECM stiffness and TGFβ2 induction (Lampi and
Reinhart-King, 2018; Li et al., 2021b). Additionally, we have
demonstrated
that the stiffened
ECM
induces
YAP/TAZ
nuclear localization, and increases F-actin filaments, p-MLC
and αSMA - all involved in actomyosin cell contractility force
generation. We hypothesized that increased actomyosin cell
contractility may drive YAP/TAZ nuclear localization in HTM
cells. Here, we used Lat B to depolymerize F-actin stress fibers and
increase cytoskeletal relaxation. We found that a short exposure
time to Lat B eliminated vinculin FA formation and YAP/TAZ
nuclear localization, and decreased TGM2 expression. DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT All data needed to evaluate the conclusions in the paper are
present in the paper and/or the Supplementary Materials. Additional data related to this paper may be requested from
the authors. DISCUSSION ROCK
inhibition has also been shown to decrease HTM cell F-actin
fibers and contractility (Li et al., 2021a). These observations on
effects of Lat B were consistent with our findings that ROCK
inhibitor
reduced
YAP/TAZ
activity
(Figures
3,
4F–M–M4F–M). It would be worthwhile to further investigate
effects of other cell contractility related molecules, such as myosin
light chain kinase, myosin II, cofilin and gelsolin, on YAP/TAZ
activity in both HTM and GTM cells. In conclusion, using our bioengineered tissue-mimetic ECM
hydrogel system, we demonstrated that nuclear YAP/TAZ is
upregulated in response to simulated glaucomatous conditions
(i.e., TGFβ2 induction and stiffened ECM), and that YAP/TAZ
activation induces HTM cell contractility and ECM remodeling,
which together may increase HTM stiffness in POAG. Our
findings provide strong evidence for a pathologic role of
aberrant
YAP/TAZ
signaling
in
glaucomatous
HTM
cell
dysfunction,
and
may
help
inform
strategies
for
the
development of novel multifactorial approaches to prevent
progressive ocular hypertension in glaucoma. y
We have observed that simulated glaucomatous conditions
(i.e., elevated TGFβ2 and stiffened ECM) upregulated nuclear
YAP/TAZ,
and
treatments
that
can
reduce
IOP
in
experimental models (i.e., ROCK inhibitor and Lat B)
downregulated YAP/TAZ nuclear localization, in agreement
with previous reports (Piccolo et al., 2014; Das et al., 2016;
Panciera et al., 2017). These observations led us to explore the
role of YAP/TAZ on glaucoma pathology development. We
found that YAP/TAZ depletion using siRNA consistently
decreased
FA
formation
(i.e.,
vinculin),
and
reduced
expression of cell contractile proteins (i.e., F-actin, p-MLC
and αSMA) and ECM proteins (i.e., FN) (Figure 5). Also, YAP/
TAZ deactivation reduced expression of TGM2, a protein that
promotes cell-matrix interactions and FN crosslinking to
stiffen the ECM (Akimov et al., 2000), and CTGF, known
to increase ECM production and cell contractility in HTM
cells, and elevate IOP in mouse eyes (Junglas et al., 2012). Thus, YAP/TAZ inhibition may decrease subsequent ECM
stiffness potentially through regulation of ECM, TGM2 and
CTGF
production. Furthermore,
we
demonstrated
that
inhibition
of
YAP/TAZ-TEAD
interaction
using
VP
significantly decreased TGFβ2-induced YAP/TAZ nuclear
localization in HTM cells independent of their spatial
arrangement
atop
or
inside
of
the
ECM
hydrogels. Consistent with the effects of siRNA-mediated YAP/TAZ
depletion, VP treatment rescued TGFβ2-induced YAP/TAZ AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS HL, VR, WDS, PSG, and SH designed all experiments, collected,
analyzed, and interpreted the data. WDS provided the GTM cells. VR performed the AFM experiments. HL and SH wrote the
manuscript. All authors commented on and approved the final
manuscript. PSG and SH conceived and supervised the research. REFERENCES The Elastin Fiber System between and
Adjacent to Collector Channels in the Human Juxtacanalicular Tissue. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 52, 45–50. doi:10.1167/iovs.10-5620 Boopathy, G. T. K., and Hong, W. (2019). Role of Hippo Pathway-YAP/TAZ
Signaling in Angiogenesis. Front. Cel. Dev. Biol. 7, 49. doi:10.3389/fcell.2019. 00049 Hensel, N., Rademacher, S., and Claus, P. (2015). Chatting with the Neighbors:
Crosstalk between Rho-Kinase (ROCK) and Other Signaling Pathways for
Treatment of Neurological Disorders. Front. Neurosci. 9, 198. doi:10.3389/fnins. 2015.00198 Brubaker, R. F. (1991). Flow of Aqueous Humor in Humans [The Friedenwald
Lecture]. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 32, 3145–3166. Caliari, S. R., and Burdick, J. A. (2016). A Practical Guide to Hydrogels for Cell
Culture. Nat. Methods 13, 405–414. doi:10.1038/nmeth.3839 Heo, J., Koh, R. H., Shim, W., Kim, H. D., Yim, H.-G., and Hwang, N. S. (2016). Riboflavin-induced
Photo-Crosslinking
of
Collagen
Hydrogel
and
its
Application in Meniscus Tissue Engineering. Drug Deliv. Transl. Res. 6,
148–158. doi:10.1007/s13346-015-0224-4 Chang, Y.-R., Raghunathan, V. K., Garland, S. P., Morgan, J. T., Russell, P., and
Murphy, C. J. (2014). Automated AFM Force Curve Analysis for Determining
Elastic Modulus of Biomaterials and Biological Samples. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 37, 209–218. doi:10.1016/j.jmbbm.2014.05.027 Ho, L. T. Y., Skiba, N., Ullmer, C., and Rao, P. V. (2018). Lysophosphatidic Acid
Induces ECM Production via Activation of the Mechanosensitive YAP/TAZ
Transcriptional Pathway in Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 59, 1969–1984. doi:10.1167/iovs.17-23702 Chen, W.-S., Cao, Z., Krishnan, C., and Panjwani, N. (2015). Verteporfin without
Light Stimulation Inhibits YAP Activation in Trabecular Meshwork Cells:
Implications for Glaucoma Treatment. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 466, 221–225. doi:10.1016/j.bbrc.2015.09.012 Honjo, M., Igarashi, N., Nishida, J., Kurano, M., Yatomi, Y., Igarashi, K., et al. (2018). Role of the Autotaxin-LPA Pathway in Dexamethasone-Induced
Fibrotic
Responses
and
Extracellular
Matrix
Production
in
Human
Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 59, 21–30. doi:10. 1167/iovs.17-22807 Das, A., Fischer, R. S., Pan, D., and Waterman, C. M. (2016). YAP Nuclear
Localization in the Absence of Cell-Cell Contact Is Mediated by a Filamentous
Actin-dependent, Myosin II- and Phospho-YAP-independent Pathway during
Extracellular Matrix Mechanosensing. J. Biol. Chem. 291, 6096–6110. doi:10. 1074/jbc.m115.708313 Inatani, M., Tanihara, H., Katsuta, H., Honjo, M., Kido, N., and Honda, Y. (2001). Transforming Growth Factor-β2 Levels in Aqueous Humor of Glaucomatous
Eyes. Graefe’s Arch. Clin. Exp. Ophthalmol. 239, 109–113. doi:10.1007/
s004170000241 Dhamodaran, K., Baidouri, H., Sandoval, L., and Raghunathan, V. (2020). Wnt
Activation after Inhibition Restores Trabecular Meshwork Cells toward a
Normal Phenotype. REFERENCES Ethier, C. R., Read, A. T., and Chan, D. W.-H. (2006). Effects of Latrunculin-B on
Outflow Facility and Trabecular Meshwork Structure in Human Eyes. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 47, 1991–1998. doi:10.1167/iovs.05-0327 Abu-Hassan, D. W., Acott, T. S., and Kelley, M. J. (2014). The Trabecular
Meshwork: A Basic Review of Form and Function. J. Ocul. Biol. 2, 9. doi:10. 13188/2334-2838.1000017 p
Faralli, J. A., Filla, M. S., and Peters, D. M. (2019). Role of Fibronectin in Primary Faralli, J. A., Filla, M. S., and Peters, D. M. (2019). Role of Fibronectin in Primary
Open Angle Glaucoma Cells 8 1518 doi:10 3390/cells8121518 Open Angle Glaucoma. Cells 8, 1518. doi:10.3390/cells812151 Frantz, C., Stewart, K. M., and Weaver, V. M. (2010). The Extracellular Matrix at a
Glance. J. Cel. Sci. 123, 4195–4200. doi:10.1242/jcs.023820 Acott, T. S., and Kelley, M. J. (2008). Extracellular Matrix in the Trabecular
Meshwork. Exp. Eye Res. 86, 543–561. doi:10.1016/j.exer.2008.01.013 Fuchshofer, R., and Tamm, E. R. (2009). Modulation of Extracellular Matrix
Turnover in the Trabecular Meshwork. Exp. Eye Res. 88, 683–688. doi:10.1016/
j.exer.2009.01.005 Agarwal, P., Daher, A. M., and Agarwal, R. (2015). Aqueous Humor TGF-β2 Levels
in Patients with Open-Angle Glaucoma: A Meta-Analysis. Mol. Vis. 21,
612–620. Gharahkhani, P., Jorgenson, E., Jorgenson, E., Hysi, P., Khawaja, A. P.,
Pendergrass,
S.,
et
al. (2021). Genome-wide
Meta-Analysis
Identifies
127 Open-Angle Glaucoma Loci with Consistent Effect across Ancestries. Nat. Commun. 12, 1258. doi:10.1038/s41467-020-20851-4 Ahearne, M., and Coyle, A. (2016). Application of UVA-Riboflavin
Crosslinking to Enhance the Mechanical Properties of Extracellular
Matrix
Derived
Hydrogels. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 54,
259–267. doi:10.1016/j.jmbbm.2015.09.035 Granstein, R. D., Staszewski, R., Knisely, T. L., Zeira, E., Nazareno, R., Latina, M.,
et al. (1990). Aqueous Humor Contains Transforming Growth Factor-Beta and
a Small (Less Than 3500 Daltons) Inhibitor of Thymocyte Proliferation. J. Immunol. 144, 3021–3027. Akimov, S. S., Krylov, D., Fleischman, L. F., and Belkin, A. M. (2000). Tissue
Transglutaminase Is an Integrin-Binding Adhesion Coreceptor for Fibronectin. J. Cel. Biol. 148, 825–838. doi:10.1083/jcb.148.4.825 Basu, S., Totty, N. F., Irwin, M. S., Sudol, M., and Downward, J. (2003). Akt
Phosphorylates the Yes-Associated Protein, YAP, to Induce Interaction with
14-3-3 and Attenuation of P73-Mediated Apoptosis. Mol. Cel. 11, 11–23. doi:10. 1016/s1097-2765(02)00776-1 Han, H., Wecker, T., Grehn, F., and Schlunck, G. (2011). Elasticity-Dependent
Modulation of TGF-β Responses in Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 52, 2889–2896. doi:10.1167/iovs.10-6640 Hann, C. R., and Fautsch, M. P. (2011). FUNDING This project was supported in part by National Institutes of
Health grants R01EY026048, R01EY031710, K08EY031755 (to
VR, WDS, and PSG), an American Glaucoma Society Young
Clinician Scientist Award (to PSG), a Syracuse University
BioInspired Seed Grant (to SH), unrestricted grants to SUNY March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 15 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. ELP, Dr. Alison Patteson at Syracuse University for rheometer
access, Drs. Audrey M. Bernstein and Mariano S. Viapiano, and
Neuroscience Microscopy Core at Upstate Medical University for
imaging support. Upstate Medical University Department of Ophthalmology and
Visual Sciences from Research to Prevent Blindness (RPB) and
from Lions Region 20-Y1, and RPB Career Development Awards
(to PSG and SH). The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at:
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fcell.2022.844342/
full#supplementary-material The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at:
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fcell.2022.844342/
full#supplementary-material SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL We thank Dr. Robert W. Weisenthal and the team at Specialty
Surgery Center of Central New York for assistance with corneal
rim specimens. We also thank Dr. Nasim Annabi at the
University of California–Los Angeles for providing the KCTS- REFERENCES Transforming Growth Factor β2 Levels in the Aqueous Humor in Different
Types of Glaucoma and the Relation to Filtering Bleb Development. Graefe’s
Arch. Clin. Exp. Ophthalmol. 239, 199–207. doi:10.1007/s004170000252 Lin, C., Yao, E., Zhang, K., Jiang, X., Croll, S., Thompson-Peer, K., et al. (2017). YAP Is Essential for Mechanical Force Production and Epithelial Cell
Proliferation during Lung Branching Morphogenesis. Elife 6, e21130. doi:10. 7554/eLife.21130 Pickup, M. W., Mouw, J. K., and Weaver, V. M. (2014). The Extracellular Matrix
Modulates the Hallmarks of Cancer. EMBO Rep. 15, 1243–1253. doi:10.15252/
embr.201439246 Liu, Y., Suzuki, Y. J., Day, R. M., and Fanburg, B. L. (2004). Rho Kinase-Induced
Nuclear Translocation of ERK1/ERK2 in Smooth Muscle Cell Mitogenesis
Caused by Serotonin. Circ. Res. 95, 579–586. doi:10.1161/01.res.0000141428. 53262.a4 Prendes, M. A., Harris, A., Wirostko, B. M., Gerber, A. L., and Siesky, B. (2013). The Role of Transforming Growth Factor β in Glaucoma and the Therapeutic
Implications. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 97, 680–686. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2011-
301132 Liu-Chittenden, Y., Huang, B., Shim, J. S., Chen, Q., Lee, S.-J., Anders, R. A., et al. (2012). Genetic and Pharmacological Disruption of the TEAD-YAP Complex
Suppresses the Oncogenic Activity of YAP. Genes Dev. 26, 1300–1305. doi:10. 1101/gad.192856.112 Qiao, Y., Chen, J., Lim, Y. B., Finch-Edmondson, M. L., Seshachalam, V. P., Qin, L.,
et al. (2017). YAP Regulates Actin Dynamics through ARHGAP29 and
Promotes Metastasis. Cel Rep. 19, 1495–1502. doi:10.1016/j.celrep.2017.04.075 Low, B. C., Pan, C. Q., Shivashankar, G. V., Bershadsky, A., Sudol, M., and Sheetz,
M. (2014). YAP/TAZ as Mechanosensors and Mechanotransducers in
Regulating Organ Size and Tumor Growth. FEBS Lett. 588, 2663–2670. doi:10.1016/j.febslet.2014.04.012 Quigley, H. A., and Broman, A. T. (2006). The Number of People with Glaucoma
Worldwide in 2010 and 2020. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 90, 262–267. doi:10.1136/bjo. 2005.081224 Quigley, H. A. (1993). Open-Angle Glaucoma. N. Engl. J. Med. 328, 1097–1106. doi:10.1056/nejm199304153281507 Ma, J., Sanchez-Duffhues, G., Goumans, M.-J., and Ten Dijke, P. (2020). TGF-β-
Induced Endothelial to Mesenchymal Transition in Disease and Tissue
Engineering. Front. Cel Dev. Biol. 8, 260. doi:10.3389/fcell.2020.00260 Raghunathan, V. K., Morgan, J. T., Dreier, B., Reilly, C. M., Thomasy, S. M., Wood,
J. A., et al. (2013). Role of Substratum Stiffness in Modulating Genes Associated
with Extracellular Matrix and Mechanotransducers YAP and TAZ. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 54, 378–386. doi:10.1167/iovs.12-11007 Mason, D. E., Collins, J. M., Dawahare, J. H., Nguyen, T. D., Lin, Y., Voytik-Harbin,
S. L., et al. (2019). REFERENCES Higher Concentration of Transforming Growth
Factor-β in Aqueous Humor of Glaucomatous Eyes and Diabetic Eyes. Jpn. J. Ophthalmol. 46, 249–253. doi:10.1016/s0021-5155(01)00523-8 Kwon, Y. H., Fingert, J. H., Kuehn, M. H., and Alward, W. L. M. (2009). Primary
Open-Angle Glaucoma. N. Engl. J. Med. 360, 1113–1124. doi:10.1056/
nejmra0804630 Panahi, R., and Baghban-Salehi, M. (2019). “Protein-Based Hydrogels,” in
Cellulose-Based Superabsorbent Hydrogels. Editor M.I.H. Mondal (Cham:
Springer
International
Publishing),
1561–1600. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-
77830-3_52 Lampi, M. C., and Reinhart-King, C. A. (2018). Targeting Extracellular Matrix
Stiffness to Attenuate Disease: From Molecular Mechanisms to Clinical Trials. Sci. Transl Med. 10, eaao0475. doi:10.1126/scitranslmed.aao0475 Panciera, T., Azzolin, L., Cordenonsi, M., and Piccolo, S. (2017). Mechanobiology
of YAP and TAZ in Physiology and Disease. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cel. Biol. 18,
758–770. doi:10.1038/nrm.2017.87 Last, J. A., Pan, T., Ding, Y., Reilly, C. M., Keller, K., Acott, T. S., et al. (2011). Elastic
Modulus Determination of Normal and Glaucomatous Human Trabecular
Meshwork. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 52, 2147–2152. doi:10.1167/iovs.10-
6342 Pattabiraman, P. P., and Rao, P. V. (2010). Mechanistic Basis of Rho GTPase-
Induced Extracellular Matrix Synthesis in Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Am. J. Physiol.-Cell Physiol. 298, C749–C763. doi:10.1152/ajpcell.00317.2009 Lei, Q.-Y., Zhang, H., Zhao, B., Zha, Z.-Y., Bai, F., Pei, X.-H., et al. (2008). TAZ
Promotes Cell Proliferation and Epithelial-Mesenchymal Transition and Is
Inhibited by the Hippo Pathway. Mol. Cel. Biol. 28, 2426–2436. doi:10.1128/
mcb.01874-07 Peng, J., Wang, H., Wang, X., Sun, M., Deng, S., and Wang, Y. (2018). YAP and
TAZ Mediate Steroid-Induced Alterations in the Trabecular Meshwork
Cytoskeleton in Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Int. J. Mol. Med. 41,
164–172. doi:10.3892/ijmm.2017.3207 Li, H., Bagué, T., Kirschner, A., Strat, A. N., Roberts, H., Weisenthal, R. W., et al. (2021a). A Tissue-Engineered Human Trabecular Meshwork Hydrogel for
Advanced Glaucoma Disease Modeling. Exp. Eye Res. 205, 108472. doi:10. 1016/j.exer.2021.108472 Peterson, J. A., Tian, B., Bershadsky, A. D., Volberg, T., Gangnon, R. E., Spector, I.,
et al. (1999). Latrunculin-A Increases Outflow Facility in the Monkey. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 40, 931–941. Piccolo, S., Dupont, S., and Cordenonsi, M. (2014). The Biology of YAP/TAZ:
Hippo Signaling and beyond. Physiol. Rev. 94, 1287–1312. doi:10.1152/physrev. 00005.2014 Li, H., Henty-Ridilla, J. L., Ganapathy, P. S., and Herberg, S. (2021b). TGFβ2
Regulates Human Trabecular Meshwork Cell Contractility via ERK and ROCK
Pathways with Distinct Signaling Crosstalk Dependent on the Culture
Substrate. bioRxiv [Epub ahead of print]. doi:10.1101/2021.07.01.450718 Picht, G., Welge-Luessen, U., Grehn, F., and Lütjen-Drecoll, E. (2001). REFERENCES Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 61, 30. doi:10.1167/iovs.61. 6.30 Jansen, K. A., Atherton, P., and Ballestrem, C. (2017). Mechanotransduction at the
Cell-Matrix Interface. Semin. Cel. Dev. Biol. 71, 75–83. doi:10.1016/j.semcdb. 2017.07.027 Drury, J. L., and Mooney, D. J. (2003). Hydrogels for Tissue Engineering: Scaffold
Design Variables and Applications. Biomaterials 24, 4337–4351. doi:10.1016/
s0142-9612(03)00340-5 Junglas, B., Kuespert, S., Seleem, A. A., Struller, T., Ullmann, S., Bösl, M., et al. (2012). Connective Tissue Growth Factor Causes Glaucoma by Modifying the
Actin Cytoskeleton of the Trabecular Meshwork. Am. J. Pathol. 180,
2386–2403. doi:10.1016/j.ajpath.2012.02.030 Dupont, S., Morsut, L., Aragona, M., Enzo, E., Giulitti, S., Cordenonsi, M., et al. (2011). Role of YAP/TAZ in Mechanotransduction. Nature 474, 179–183. doi:10.1038/nature10137 March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 16 YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Li et al. Kaess, B. M., Rong, J., Larson, M. G., Hamburg, N. M., Vita, J. A., Levy, D., et al. (2012). Aortic
Stiffness,
Blood
Pressure
Progression,
and
Incident
Hypertension. JAMA 308, 875–881. doi:10.1001/2012.jama.10503 Montecchi-Palmer, M., Bermudez, J. Y., Webber, H. C., Patel, G. C., Clark, A. F.,
and Mao, W. (2017). TGFβ2 Induces the Formation of Cross-Linked Actin
Networks (CLANs) in Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells through the Smad
and Non-smad Dependent Pathways. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 58,
1288–1295. doi:10.1167/iovs.16-19672 Kasetti, R. B., Maddineni, P., Patel, P. D., Searby, C., Sheffield, V. C., and Zode, G. S. (2018). Transforming Growth Factor β2 (TGFβ2) Signaling Plays a Key Role in
Glucocorticoid-Induced Ocular Hypertension. J. Biol. Chem. 293, 9854–9868. doi:10.1074/jbc.ra118.002540 Muppala, S., Raghunathan, V. K., Jalilian, I., Thomasy, S., and Murphy, C. J. (2019). YAP and TAZ Are Distinct Effectors of Corneal Myofibroblast Transformation. Exp. Eye Res. 180, 102–109. doi:10.1016/j.exer.2018.12.009 Keller, K. E., and Acott, T. S. (2013). The Juxtacanalicular Region of Ocular
Trabecular Meshwork: A Tissue with a Unique Extracellular Matrix and
Specialized Function. J. Ocul. Biol. 1, 3. doi:10.13188/2334-2838.1000003 Nardone, G., Oliver-De La Cruz, J., Vrbsky, J., Martini, C., Pribyl, J., Skládal, P.,
et al. (2017). YAP Regulates Cell Mechanics by Controlling Focal Adhesion
Assembly. Nat. Commun. 8, 15321. doi:10.1038/ncomms15321 Keller, K. E., Bhattacharya, S. K., Borrás, T., Brunner, T. M., Chansangpetch, S.,
Clark, A. F., et al. (2018). Consensus Recommendations for Trabecular
Meshwork Cell Isolation, Characterization and Culture. Exp. Eye Res. 171,
164–173. doi:10.1016/j.exer.2018.03.001 Ochiai, Y., and Ochiai, H. (2002). REFERENCES YAP and TAZ Limit Cytoskeletal and Focal Adhesion
Maturation to Enable Persistent Cell Motility. J. Cel. Biol. 218, 1369–1389. doi:10.1083/jcb.201806065 Raghunathan, V. K., Morgan, J. T., Park, S. A., Weber, D., Phinney, B. S., Murphy,
C. J., et al. (2015). Dexamethasone Stiffens Trabecular Meshwork, Trabecular
Meshwork Cells, and Matrix. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 56, 4447–4459. doi:10.1167/iovs.15-16739 McKee, C. T., Wood, J. A., Shah, N. M., Fischer, M. E., Reilly, C. M., Murphy, C. J.,
et al. (2011). The Effect of Biophysical Attributes of the Ocular Trabecular
Meshwork Associated with Glaucoma on the Cell Response to Therapeutic
Agents. Biomaterials 32, 2417–2423. doi:10.1016/j.biomaterials.2010.11.071 Raghunathan, V. K., Benoit, J., Kasetti, R., Zode, G., Salemi, M., Phinney, B. S., et al. (2018). Glaucomatous Cell Derived Matrices Differentially Modulate Non-
Glaucomatous Trabecular Meshwork Cellular Behavior. Acta Biomater. 71,
444–459. doi:10.1016/j.actbio.2018.02.037 Mohammed, D., Versaevel, M., Bruyère, C., Alaimo, L., Luciano, M., Vercruysse,
E., et al. (2019). Innovative Tools for Mechanobiology: Unraveling Outside-In
and Inside-Out Mechanotransduction. Front. Bioeng. Biotechnol. 7, 162. doi:10. 3389/fbioe.2019.00162 Rahman, N., O’neill, E., Irnaten, M., Wallace, D., and O’brien, C. (2020). Corneal
Stiffness and Collagen Cross-Linking Proteins in Glaucoma: Potential for Novel March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 17 Li et al. YAP/TAZ Activity in HTM Cells Therapeutic Strategy. J. Ocul. Pharmacol. Ther. 36, 582–594. doi:10.1089/jop. 2019.0118 Canal in Glaucomatous Human Eyes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 116,
26555–26563. doi:10.1073/pnas.1911837116 Wang, K., Johnstone, M. A., Xin, C., Song, S., Padilla, S., Vranka, J. A., et al. (2017a). Estimating Human Trabecular Meshwork Stiffness by Numerical Modeling and
Advanced OCT Imaging. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 58, 4809–4817. doi:10. 1167/iovs.17-22175 Schindelin, J., Arganda-Carreras, I., Frise, E., Kaynig, V., Longair, M., Pietzsch, T.,
et al. (2012). Fiji: an Open-Source Platform for Biological-Image Analysis. Nat. Methods 9, 676–682. doi:10.1038/nmeth.2019 Schlunck, G. n., Han, H., Wecker, T., Kampik, D., Meyer-Ter-Vehn, T., and Grehn, Schlunck, G. n., Han, H., Wecker, T., Kampik, D., Meyer-Ter-Vehn, T., and Grehn,
F. (2008). Substrate Rigidity Modulates Cell-Matrix Interactions and Protein
Expression in Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 49, 262–269. doi:10.1167/iovs.07-0956 Wang, K., Read, A. T., Sulchek, T., and Ethier, C. R. (2017b). Trabecular Meshwork
Stiffness in Glaucoma. Exp. Eye Res. 158, 3–12. doi:10.1016/j.exer.2016.07.011 Yemanyi, F., and Raghunathan, V. (2020). Lysophosphatidic Acid and IL-6 Trans-
signaling Interact via YAP/TAZ and STAT3 Signaling Pathways in Human
Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. REFERENCES 61, 29. doi:10.1167/
iovs.61.13.29 Schmittgen, T. D., and Livak, K. J. (2008). Analyzing Real-Time PCR Data by the
Comparative CT Method. Nat. Protoc. 3, 1101–1108. doi:10.1038/nprot.2008.73 Sorrentino, G., Ruggeri, N., Specchia, V., Cordenonsi, M., Mano, M., Dupont, S.,
et al. (2014). Metabolic Control of YAP and TAZ by the Mevalonate Pathway. Nat. Cel. Biol. 16, 357–366. doi:10.1038/ncb2936 Yemanyi, F., Vranka, J., and Raghunathan, V. K. (2020). Crosslinked Extracellular
Matrix Stiffens Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells via Dysregulating β-
Catenin and YAP/TAZ Signaling Pathways. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 61,
41. doi:10.1167/iovs.61.10.41 Stamer, W. D., Seftor, R. E. B., Williams, S. K., Samaha, H. A. M., and Snyder, R. W. (1995). Isolation and Culture of Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells by
Extracellular Matrix Digestion. Curr. Eye Res. 14, 611–617. doi:10.3109/
02713689508998409 Zhang, Y., Conrad, A. H., and Conrad, G. W. (2011). Effects of Ultraviolet-A and
Riboflavin on the Interaction of Collagen and Proteoglycans during Corneal
Cross-Linking. J. Biol. Chem. 286, 13011–13022. doi:10.1074/jbc.m110.169813 Tamm, E. R., Braunger, B. M., and Fuchshofer, R. (2015). Intraocular Pressure and
the Mechanisms Involved in Resistance of the Aqueous Humor Flow in the
Trabecular Meshwork Outflow Pathways. Prog. Mol. Biol. Transl Sci. 134,
301–314. doi:10.1016/bs.pmbts.2015.06.007 Zhang, Y. E. (2009). Non-Smad Pathways in TGF-β Signaling. Cell Res. 19,
128–139. doi:10.1038/cr.2008.328 Zhao, B., Wei, X., Li, W., Udan, R. S., Yang, Q., Kim, J., et al. (2007). Inactivation of
YAP Oncoprotein by the Hippo Pathway Is Involved in Cell Contact Inhibition
and Tissue Growth Control. Genes Dev. 21, 2747–2761. doi:10.1101/gad. 1602907 Tamm, E. R. (2009). The Trabecular Meshwork Outflow Pathways: Structural and
Functional Aspects. Exp. Eye Res. 88, 648–655. doi:10.1016/j.exer.2009.02.007 Tham, Y.-C., Li, X., Wong, T. Y., Quigley, H. A., Aung, T., and Cheng, C.-Y. (2014). Global Prevalence of Glaucoma and Projections of Glaucoma Burden through
2040: a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Ophthalmology 121, 2081–2090. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2014.05.013 Zhao, B., Li, L., Lei, Q., and Guan, K.-L. (2010). The Hippo-YAP Pathway in Organ
Size Control and Tumorigenesis: an Updated Version. Genes Dev. 24, 862–874. doi:10.1101/gad.1909210 Thomasy, S. M., Morgan, J. T., Wood, J. A., Murphy, C. J., and Russell, P. (2013). Substratum Stiffness and Latrunculin B Modulate the Gene Expression of the
Mechanotransducers YAP and TAZ in Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells. Exp. Eye Res. 113, 66–73. doi:10.1016/j.exer.2013.05.014 Zhao, Y., Lv, M., Lin, H., Hong, Y., Yang, F., Sun, Y., et al. (2012). Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org REFERENCES ROCK1 Induces
ERK Nuclear Translocation in PDGF-BB-Stimulated Migration of Rat Vascular
Smooth Muscle Cells. IUBMB Life 64, 194–202. doi:10.1002/iub.598 Conflict of Interest: The authors declare that the research was conducted in the
absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a
potential conflict of interest. Tian, B., Geiger, B., Epstein, D. L., and Kaufman, P. L. (2000). Cytoskeletal
Involvement
in
the
Regulation
of
Aqueous
Humor
Outflow. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 41, 619–623. Timothy, P., and Lodge, P. C. H. (2020). Polymer Chemistry. Boca Raton, FL,
United States: CRC Press. Publisher’s Note: All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors
and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of
the publisher, the editors, and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in
this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or
endorsed by the publisher. Tirella, A., Liberto, T., and Ahluwalia, A. (2012). Riboflavin and Collagen: New
Crosslinking Methods to Tailor the Stiffness of Hydrogels. Mater. Lett. 74,
58–61. doi:10.1016/j.matlet.2012.01.036 Totaro, A., Panciera, T., and Piccolo, S. (2018). YAP/TAZ Upstream Signals and
Downstream Responses. Nat. Cel. Biol. 20, 888–899. doi:10.1038/s41556-018-
0142-z Copyright © 2022 Li, Raghunathan, Stamer, Ganapathy and Herberg. This is an
open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted,
provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the
original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic
practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply
with these terms. Tovar-Vidales, T., Roque, R., Clark, A. F., and Wordinger, R. J. (2008). Tissue
Transglutaminase Expression and Activity in normal and Glaucomatous
Human Trabecular Meshwork Cells and Tissues. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 49, 622–628. doi:10.1167/iovs.07-0835 Vahabikashi, A., Gelman, A., Dong, B., Gong, L., Cha, E. D. K., Schimmel, M., et al. (2019). Increased Stiffness and Flow Resistance of the Inner wall of Schlemm’s March 2022 | Volume 10 | Article 844342 Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology | www.frontiersin.org 18
|
https://openalex.org/W2044711830
|
https://bmcmedgenet.biomedcentral.com/counter/pdf/10.1186/1471-2350-11-87
|
English
| null |
1Novel MEFV transcripts in Familial Mediterranean fever patients and controls
|
BMC medical genetics
| 2,010
|
cc-by
| 3,459
|
RESEARCH ARTICLE Open Access © 2010 Medlej-Hashim et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Com-
mons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduc-
tion in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Abstract Background: Familial Mediterranean fever is a recessive autoinflammatory disease frequently encountered in
Armenians, Jews, Arabs and Turks. The MEFV gene is responsible for the disease. It encodes a protein called pyrin/
marenostrin involved in the innate immune system. A large number of clinically diagnosed FMF patients carry only one
MEFV mutation. This study aims at studying the MEFV gene splicing pattern in heterozygous FMF patients and healthy
individuals, in an attempt to understand the mechanism underlying the disease in these patients. Methods: RNA was extracted from peripheral blood leucocytes of 41 FMF patients and 34 healthy individuals. RT-PCR
was then performed, and the amplified products were migrated on a polyacrylamide electrophoresis gel, characterized
by gel extraction of the corresponding bands followed by sequencing. Results: Five novel splicing events were observed in both patients and controls deleting either exons 3, 4 (del34), or
exons 2, 3, 4 (del234), or exons 2, 3, 4, 5 (del2345) or exon7 (del7) or exons 7 and 8 (del78). Conclusions: The observation of such qualitative variability in the expression of the MEFV gene suggests a complex
transcriptional regulation. However, the expression of these novel transcripts in both patients and controls is not in
favour of a severe pathogenic effect. * Correspondence: megarbane@usj.edu.lb
1 Unité de Génétique Médicale. Faculté de Médecine, Université Saint Joseph,
Beirut, Lebanon
† Contributed equally
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article Research article
1Novel MEFV transcripts in Familial Mediterranean
fever patients and controls yrna Medlej-Hashim†1,2, Nancy Nehme†1, Eliane Chouery1, Nadine Jalkh1 and André Megarbane*1 Myrna Medlej-Hashim†1,2, Nancy Nehme†1, Eliane Chouery1, Nadine Jalkh1 and André Megarbane*1 Medlej-Hashim et al. BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87 Medlej-Hashim et al. BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87 Background pyrin domain (or PyD), a bZIP basic domain, a B-box zinc
finger domain, a coiled coil domain, 2 nuclear localization
signals domains and a Ret Finger protein (RFP or B30.2)
domain, also known as SPRY domain [7,8]. g
Familial Mediterranean fever (FMF) is an autoinflamma-
tory autosomal recessive disease particularly frequent
around the Mediterranean basin. It is characterized by
recurrent bouts of fever and serosal inflammation, the
most severe manifestation of the disease being renal amy-
loidosis [1]. The MEFV gene on chromosome 16p13.3,
responsible for this disease [2,3], is composed of 10
exons. Over 80 MEFV mutations were detected in FMF
patients and registered in the autoinflammatory mutation
database Infevers http://fmf.igh.cnrs.fr/infevers/[4]. Five
of these mutations (M694V, M694I, V726A, M680I and
E148Q) were mostly encountered in the mainly affected
populations, namely Jews, Armenians, Arabs and Turks
[5]. MEFV encodes a 781 amino acids' protein named
pyrin or marenostrin (P/M) that is involved in the inflam-
matory pathways of the innate immune system [6]. Sequence alignment of the protein revealed 6 domains: a MEFV is expressed in neutrophils, eosinophils, mono-
cytes [9,10] and to a lesser extent in skin and peritoneal
fibroblasts [11]. Several alternatively spliced MEFV tran-
scripts have been previously described. The first one
(MEFV-d2) was identified in peripheral blood leukocytes
(PBLs) and lacks exon 2 [12]. Diaz et al. characterized 3
other transcripts in synovial fibroblasts from osteoarthri-
tis affected patients, one substituting exon 2a for exon 2
(2a), one with an extra exon corresponding to a sequence
in intron 4 (4a), and one with an extension of exon 8
(8ext) [13]. Moreover, MEFV-d2 and 2a combined with
4a or 8ext to form four other transcripts: Δ2/4a, 2a/4a,
Δ2/8ext and 2a/8ext. The various combinations of 4a and
8ext result in a frameshift leading to putative truncated
proteins [13]. Clinical diagnosis is often confirmed by genetic testing
of the MEFV gene. However, in an important number of
clinically diagnosed FMF patients, only one MEFV muta-
tion was detected by screening of the genomic MEFV Medlej-Hashim et al. BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87 Page 2 of 5 Page 2 of 5 from the 5' PCR products which lacked either exons 2 to
4 (del234), exons 2 to 5 (del2345) or exons 3 and 4 (del34)
(Figure 1, left panel). Discussion The detection of only one MEFV mutation in clinically
diagnosed FMF patients and the highly variable pheno-
type among FMF patients (even those having the same
MEFV genotype) have always been a subject of concern. Modifying genes could be a possible explanation for such
observations, as well as the fact that only one MEFV
mutation may cause the disease that could be dominant
with a variable expressivity. Diseases which pattern of
inheritance could be recessive in some families, and dom-
inant in others have already been described [16]. This
work aimed at investigating the expression pattern of the
MEFV gene and trying to relate it to the clinical picture of
the patients. Human material from FMF patients and controls This study included 2 series consisting of 41 unrelated
Lebanese FMF patients who fulfilled international diag-
nostic FMF criteria [15] and 34 Lebanese healthy individ-
uals. 36 of the FMF patients had only one identifiable
exonic mutation and 5 patients had 2 mutations (Table 1). Written consent was obtained from all individuals, and
the work was approved by the Saint Joseph University
ethical committee. Blood was collected into tubes con-
taining heparin, and whole PBLs were purified by lysis of
the red cells with blood lysis buffer according to standard
protocols. RT-PCR analysis Total RNAs were extracted from PBLs using the phenol
chloroform method, then retro-transcribed (RT) into
complementary DNA (cDNA) using random primers. Two sets of Polymerization Chain Reaction (PCR) were
run on the MEFV cDNAs. The 5' amplicon was obtained
with primers 5' AGCCAGATCCAGAGAGCCA 3' in
exon 1 and 5' CCTGTGCAAGATGTCTCCAA 3' in exon
6 and the 3' amplicon with primers 5' TGCAGAG-
GAAGCTGGAGCA 3' in exon 5 and 5' ACCTCCAC-
CTCCCAGTAACGG 3' in exon 10. The amplified
products were migrated on a polyacrylamide gel and
characterized by extraction of the corresponding bands
from the gel then sequencing on an ABI Prism 3130
genetic analyzer. The study of MEFV transcripts in clinically diagnosed
FMF patients having one or two MEFV mutations and in
healthy controls revealed 5 novel exon skipping events
(del234, del2345, del34, del7 and del78) (Figures 1 and 2),
and one previously reported one (MEFV-d2) [12]. Skip-
ping of exons 2 to 4, 7 and 7-8 were the most frequently
observed events (Table 1). Molecular events that could cause these alternative
spliced transcripts are still unclear. Sequencing of introns
6 and 7 did not show any relevant sequence variation in
the tested individuals. Furthermore, the absence of corre-
lation between the MEFV point mutations harboured by
the patients and controls, and the observed transcripts
does not support impairment of splicing regulatory ele-
ments that would result in exon skipping [17]. The selec-
tive presence of these transcripts among individuals,
suggests they might be due to modifying genes or to some
external factor such as a reaction to an allergen. Background Two other alternative splicing
events were identified in the 3' fragment, one lacking
exon 7 (del7), and one lacking exons 7 and 8 (del78) (Fig-
ure 1, right panel). The deletion boundaries were charac-
terized by sequencing (Figure 2). This revealed that the
splicing events derived from the MEFV canonical splice-
sites. coding sequence [5,14]. In the present study, we exam-
ined the splicing pattern of MEFV in normal and FMF
PBLs, in an attempt to understand the mechanism under-
lying FMF in the clinically diagnosed patients carrying
only one MEFV mutation. A qualitative analysis of MEFV
transcripts was conducted in 41 FMF patients and 34
healthy individuals. Results were compared, and plotted
to the patient genotype data. Our study did not show evi-
dence for any correlation between genotypes and splic-
ing, but revealed 5 novel transcripts which increases the
number of transcripts identified in human leukocytes. The distribution of the 5 new splicing events (Table 1)
showed that del7 and del78 were always found together in
a given individual. del234, del7 and del78 were found in
the majority of the individuals. No correlation was
observed between the new alternative splicing events and
the MEFV exonic mutations, and no significant differ-
ence was elicited between the genetically confirmed FMF
patients, the apparently heterozygous patients and the
healthy individuals. Methods Human material from FMF patients and controls Results The studied series were screened for the presence of
splicing events by RT-PCR. Two overlapping fragments
of MEFV cDNA, one from exon 1 to 6, and one from exon
5 to 10, were amplified. Normal transcripts were
detected, in addition to the already described transcript,
MEFV-d2, that was variously expressed (Figure 1). Five novel alternative splicing events were identified in
both patients and controls. Three of them were observed Medlej-Hashim et al. BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87 Page 3 of 5 Page 3 of 5 Table 1: MEFV genotypes and splicing events in FMF patients and healthy controls. Genotype
Number of patients
5' Splicing eventsa
3' Splicing eventsa
del34
del234
del2345
del7
del78
Genetically confirmed patients
p.[M694V]+[=]
1
+
+
+
1
p.[M694I]+[=]
1
+
+
p.[M680I]+[=]
1
+
+
+
+
p.[V726A] +[=]
1
+
+
Heterozygous patients
p.[M694V]+[?]
4
+
+
+
4
1
+
1
+
+
1
p.[M694I]+[?]
1
+
+
+
1
+
p.[V726A] +[?]
2
+
1
p.[E148Q] +[?]
3
3
+
+
2
+
+
+
+
1
+
+
+
+
1
+
p.[M680I]+[?]
1
1
+
+
+
p.[P369S/R408Q]+[?]
2
+
+
+
+
1
+
+
+
p.[A744S]+[?]
2
p.[K695R]+[?]
2
+
+
+
p.[R761H]+[?]
1
+
Healthy controls
11
+
9
+
+
+
9
1
+
+
1
+
+
1
+
+
+
1
+
+
+
+
1
+
+
+
+
+ Table 1: MEFV genotypes and splicing events in FMF patients and healthy controls. a The + sign indicates the presence of the corresponding splicing event. a The + sign indicates the presence of the corresponding splicing event. Page 4 of 5 Medlej-Hashim et al. BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87 Figure 1 Two representative RT-PCR electrophoresis gels show-
ing the novel isoforms observed from the 5' amplified segment
(left) and the 3' amplified segment (right) of the MEFV transcripts
in heterozygous patients and healthy controls. The 2 amplicons
span respectively the region between exons 1 and 6 and the region
between exons 5 and 10. L = 100 basepair DNA ladder (Fermentas). Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Figure 2 Sequencing chromatograms showing the deletion junc-
tions of the 5 novel splicing events. Results Figure 1 Two representative RT-PCR electrophoresis gels show-
ing the novel isoforms observed from the 5' amplified segment
(left) and the 3' amplified segment (right) of the MEFV transcripts
in heterozygous patients and healthy controls. The 2 amplicons
span respectively the region between exons 1 and 6 and the region
between exons 5 and 10. L = 100 basepair DNA ladder (Fermentas). The presence of these novel alternative splicing events
in both controls and FMF patients' PBLs seems not in
favour of a causal effect of these transcripts in the disease
pathogenesis. Previous quantitative studies aiming at cor-
relating disease and MEFV mRNA expression showed
inconsistent results. MEFV transcript levels decreased
significantly in FMF patients as compared to controls in
the initial reports [18,19], but no significant difference
was evidenced in a more recent series [20]. The present
study opens a new trail to be addressed regarding the
FMF pathophysiology in that the patient's phenotype
could be modulated by variations of the different tran-
scripts' ratio. Such a molecular mechanism has been
recently described in cystic fibrosis patients who dis-
played altered regulation of Toll-like Receptor-4 splice
variants [21]. A larger series is warranted to replicate our
findings. Further analyses of the relative amounts of each
transcript are also necessary to confirm or rule out their
role in the pathogenic mechanisms underlying inflamma-
tion in FMF patients. Figure 2 Sequencing chromatograms showing the deletion junc-
tions of the 5 novel splicing events. Figure 2 Sequencing chromatograms showing the deletion junc-
tions of the 5 novel splicing events. Conclusions In conclusion, we identified 5 novel MEFV splicing
events observed in both clinically diagnosed FMF
patients and controls. The observation of such qualitative
variability in the expression of the MEFV gene suggests
that this gene is subjected to a complex transcriptional
and post-transcriptional regulation. The relative produc-
tion of the different transcripts is a possibility that could
modulate the physiopathological aspect of the disease. Figure 2 Sequencing chromatograms showing the deletion junc-
tions of the 5 novel splicing events. Figure 2 Sequencing chromatograms showing the deletion junc-
tions of the 5 novel splicing events. Acknowledgements This work was supported by Scientific Research grants from the Saint Joseph
University, Beirut, and by the Lebanese National Council for Scientific Research. We are also grateful to all the FMF patients who accepted to contribute to this
study. 17. Cartegni L, Wang J, Zhu Z, Zhang MQ, Krainer AR: ESEfinder: a web
resource to identify exonic splicing enhancers. Nucleic Acids Res 2003,
31(13):3568-3571. 18. Notarnicola C, Didelot MN, Kone-Paut I, Seguret F, Demaille J, Touitou I:
Reduced MEFV messenger RNA expression in patients with familial
Mediterranean fever. Arthritis Rheum 2002, 46(10):2785-2793. References 21. Jaresova I, Rozkova D, Spísek R, Janda A, Brazova J, Sediva A: Kinetics of
Toll-like receptor-4 splice variants expression in lipopolysaccharide-
stimulated antigen presenting cells of healthy donors and patients
with cystic fibrosis. Microbes Infect 2007, 9(11):1359-1367. 1. Sohar E, Gafni J, Pras M, Heller H: Familial Mediterranean Fever. A survey
of 470 cases and review of the literature. Am J Med 1967, 43:227-253. 1. Sohar E, Gafni J, Pras M, Heller H: Familial Mediterranean Fever. A survey
of 470 cases and review of the literature. Am J Med 1967, 43:227-253. 1. Sohar E, Gafni J, Pras M, Heller H: Familial Mediterranean Fever. A survey
of 470 cases and review of the literature. Am J Med 1967, 43:227-253. 2. The French FMF Consortium: A candidate gene for familial
Mediterranean fever. Nat Genet 1997, 17:25-31. 2. The French FMF Consortium: A candidate gene for familial
Mediterranean fever. Nat Genet 1997, 17:25-31. 3. The International FMF Consortium: Ancient missense mutations in a
new member of the RoRet gene family are likely to cause familial
Mediterranean fever. Cell 1997, 90:797-807. 3. The International FMF Consortium: Ancient missense mutations in a
new member of the RoRet gene family are likely to cause familial
Mediterranean fever. Cell 1997, 90:797-807. Medlej-Hashim et al. BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87 Medlej-Hashim et al. BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87 gel electrophoresis and sequencing. EC helped in the results analysis, NJ
assisted and participated in the experimental work, and AM directed and
supervised the study. 15. Livneh A, Langevitz P, Zemer D, Zaks N, Kees S, Lidar T, Migdal A, Padeh S,
Pras M: Criteria for the diagnosis of familial Mediterranean fever. Arthritis Rheum 1997, 40(10):1879-1885. 16. Hennekam RC: Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome: review of the
phenotype. Am J Med Genet A 2006, 140(23):2603-2624. Pre-publication history The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87/prepub The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87/prepub 4. Milhavet F, Cuisset L, Hoffman HM, Slim R, El-Shanti H, Aksentijevich I,
Lesage S, Waterham H, Wise C, Sarrauste de Menthiere C, Touitou I: The
infevers autoinflammatory mutation online registry: update with new
genes and functions. Hum Mutat 2008, 29(6):803-808. 4. Milhavet F, Cuisset L, Hoffman HM, Slim R, El-Shanti H, Aksentijevich I,
Lesage S, Waterham H, Wise C, Sarrauste de Menthiere C, Touitou I: The
infevers autoinflammatory mutation online registry: update with new
genes and functions. Hum Mutat 2008, 29(6):803-808. doi: 10.1186/1471-2350-11-87
Cite this article as: Medlej-Hashim et al., 1Novel MEFV transcripts in Familial
Mediterranean fever patients and controls BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87 doi: 10.1186/1471-2350-11-87
Cite this article as: Medlej-Hashim et al., 1Novel MEFV transcripts in Familial
Mediterranean fever patients and controls BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87 5. Touitou I: The spectrum of familial Mediterranean fever (FMF)
mutations. Eur J Hum Genet 2001, 9:473-483. 5. Touitou I: The spectrum of familial Mediterranean fever (FMF)
mutations. Eur J Hum Genet 2001, 9:473-483. 6. Gumucio DL, Diaz A, Schaner P, Richards N, Babcock C, Schaller M, Cesena
T: Fire and ice: The role of pyrin domain-containing proteins in
inflammation and apoptosis. Clin Exp Rheumatol 2002, 20(4 Suppl
26):S45-S53. 7. Centola M, Aksentijevich I, Kastner DL: The hereditary periodic fever
syndromes: molecular analysis of a new family of inflammatory
diseases. Hum Mol Genet 1998, 7(10):1581-1588. 7. Centola M, Aksentijevich I, Kastner DL: The hereditary periodic fever
syndromes: molecular analysis of a new family of inflammatory
diseases. Hum Mol Genet 1998, 7(10):1581-1588. 8. Martinon F, Hoffman K, Tschopp J: The pyrin domain: a possible member
of the death domain-fold family implicated in apoptosis and
inflammation. Curr Biol 2001, 10:R118-R120. 8. Martinon F, Hoffman K, Tschopp J: The pyrin domain: a possible member
of the death domain-fold family implicated in apoptosis and
inflammation. Curr Biol 2001, 10:R118-R120. 9. Centola M, Wood G, Frucht DM, Galon J, Aringer M, Farrell C, Kingma DW,
Horwitz ME, Mansfield E, Holland SM, O'Shea JJ, Rosenberg HF, Malech HL,
Kastner DL: The gene for familial Mediterranean fever, MEFV, is
expressed in early leukocyte development and is regulated in
response to inflammatory mediators. Blood 2000, 95(10):3223-3231. 9. Author Details 19. Ustek D, Ekmekci CG, Selçukbiricik F, Cakiris A, Oku B, Vural B, Yanar H,
Taviloglu K, Ozbek U, Gül A: Association between reduced levels of
MEFV messenger RNA in peripheral blood leukocytes and acute
inflammation. Arthritis Rheum 2007, 56(1):345-350. 1Unité de Génétique Médicale. Faculté de Médecine, Université Saint Joseph,
Beirut, Lebanon and 2Department of Life and Earth Sciences, Faculty of
Sciences, Branch II, Lebanese University, Beirut, Lebanon 20. Booty MG, Chae JJ, Masters SL, Remmers EF, Barham B, Le JM, Barron KS,
Holland SM, Kastner DL, Aksentijevich I: Familial Mediterranean fever
with a single MEFV mutation: Where is the second hit? Arthritis Rheum
2009, 60(6):1851-1861. 20. Booty MG, Chae JJ, Masters SL, Remmers EF, Barham B, Le JM, Barron KS,
Holland SM, Kastner DL, Aksentijevich I: Familial Mediterranean fever
with a single MEFV mutation: Where is the second hit? Arthritis Rheum
2009, 60(6):1851-1861. Authors' contributions MMH designed the project and wrote the article. NN looked for the patients
and performed the RNA extraction and the RT-PCR followed by polyacrylamide Page 5 of 5 Medlej-Hashim et al. BMC Medical Genetics 2010, 11:87
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2350/11/87 14.
Medlej-Hashim M, Serre JL, Corbani S, Saab O, Jalkh N, Delague V, Chouery
E, Salem N, Loiselet J, Lefranc G, Mégarbané A: Familial Mediterranean
fever (FMF) in Lebanon and Jordan: a population genetics study and
report of three novel mutations. Eur J Med Genet 2005, 48:412-420. Pre-publication history Centola M, Wood G, Frucht DM, Galon J, Aringer M, Farrell C, Kingma DW,
Horwitz ME, Mansfield E, Holland SM, O'Shea JJ, Rosenberg HF, Malech HL,
Kastner DL: The gene for familial Mediterranean fever, MEFV, is
expressed in early leukocyte development and is regulated in
response to inflammatory mediators. Blood 2000, 95(10):3223-3231. 10. Tidow N, Chen X, Müller C, Kawano S, Gombart AF, Fischel-Ghodsian N,
Koeffler HP: Hematopoietic-specific expression of MEFV, the gene
mutated in familial Mediterranean fever, and subcellular localization of
its corresponding protein, pyrin. Blood 2000, 95(4):1451-1455. 11. Matzner Y, Abedat S, Shapiro E, Eisenberg S, Bar-Gil-Shitrit A, Stepensky P,
Calco S, Azar Y, Urieli-Shoval S: Expression of the familial Mediterranean
fever gene and activity of the C5a inhibitor in human primary
fibroblast cultures. Blood 2000, 96(2):727-731. 11. Matzner Y, Abedat S, Shapiro E, Eisenberg S, Bar-Gil-Shitrit A, Stepensky P,
Calco S, Azar Y, Urieli-Shoval S: Expression of the familial Mediterranean
fever gene and activity of the C5a inhibitor in human primary
fibroblast cultures. Blood 2000, 96(2):727-731. 12. Papin S, Duquesnoy P, Cazeneuve C, Pantel J, Coppey-Moisan M,
Dargemont C, Amselem S: Alternative splicing at the MEFV locus
involved in familial Mediterranean fever regulates translocation of the
marenostrin/pyrin protein to the nucleus. Hum Mol Genet 2000,
9(20):3001-3009. 13. Diaz A, Hu C, Kastner DL, Schaner P, Reginato AM, Richards N, Gumucio
DL: Lipopolysaccharide-induced expression of multiple alternatively
spliced MEFV transcripts in human synovial fibroblasts: a prominent
splice isoform lacks the C-terminal domain that is highly mutated in
familial Mediterranean fever. Arthritis Rheum 2004, 50(11):3679-3689. 14. Medlej-Hashim M, Serre JL, Corbani S, Saab O, Jalkh N, Delague V, Chouery
E, Salem N, Loiselet J, Lefranc G, Mégarbané A: Familial Mediterranean
fever (FMF) in Lebanon and Jordan: a population genetics study and
report of three novel mutations. Eur J Med Genet 2005, 48:412-420.
|
https://openalex.org/W2598234126
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc5405794?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
Cardiovascular involvement and manifestations of systemic Chikungunya virus infection: A systematic review
|
F1000Research
| 2,017
|
cc-by
| 14,807
|
29 Mar 2017, :390 (doi:
)
First published:
6
10.12688/f1000research.11078.1
02 May 2017, :390 (doi:
)
Latest published:
6
10.12688/f1000research.11078.2
v2 29 Mar 2017, :390 (doi:
)
First published:
6
10.12688/f1000research.11078.1
02 May 2017, :390 (doi:
)
Latest published:
6
10.12688/f1000research.11078.2
v2 SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
Cardiovascular involvement and manifestations of
systemic Chikungunya virus infection: A systematic review
[version 2; referees: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]
María Fernanda Alvarez ,
Adrián Bolívar-Mejía , Alfonso J. Rodriguez-Morales
,
Eduardo Ramirez-Vallejo3,4
1
2
3,4
3,4 Faculty of Health, Universidad Industrial de Santander, Santander, Colombia
Department of Internal Medicine, Universidad Industrial de Santander, Santander, Colombia
Public Health and Infection Research Group, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira, Pereira, Risaralda, Colombia
Colombian Collaborative Network on Zika and other Arboviruses (RECOLZIKA), Pereira, Risaralda, Colombia
1
2
3
4 Faculty of Health, Universidad Industrial de Santander, Santander, Colombia
Department of Internal Medicine, Universidad Industrial de Santander, Santander, Colombia
Public Health and Infection Research Group, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira,
Colombian Collaborative Network on Zika and other Arboviruses (RECOLZIKA), Pereira, Risaralda, Colombia
2
3
4 Open Peer Review
Discuss this article
(0)
Comments
Referee Status:
Invited Referees
version 2
published
02 May 2017
version 1
published
29 Mar 2017
1
2
3
report
report
report
, Instituto
José Antonio Suárez
Conmemorativo Gorgas de Estudios de la
Salud Panama
1
, Universidad
Stalin Vilcarromero
Nacional de la Amazonía Peruana Peru,
Naval Medical Research Unit № 6 Peru
2
, Pontificia Universidad
Cecilia Perret
Católica de Chile Chile
3 Open Peer Review
Referee Status:
Invited Referees
version 2
published
02 May 2017
version 1
published
29 Mar 2017
1
2
3
report
report
report F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
Cardiovascular involvement and manifestations of
systemic Chikungunya virus infection: A systematic review
[version 2; referees: 1 approved, 2 approved with reservations]
María Fernanda Alvarez ,
Adrián Bolívar-Mejía , Alfonso J. Rodriguez-Morales
,
Eduardo Ramirez-Vallejo3,4
1
2
3,4
3,4 Abstract Background: In the last three years, chikungunya virus disease has been
spreading, affecting particularly the Americas, producing more than two million
cases. In this setting, not only new disease-related epidemiological patterns
have been found, but also new clinical findings have been reported by different
research groups. These include findings on the cardiovascular system,
including clinical, electrocardiographic and echocardiographic alterations. No
previous systemic reviews have been found in major databases about it. Methods: We performed a systematic review looking for reports about
cardiovascular compromise during chikungunya disease. Cardiac compromise
is not so common in isolated episodes; but countries where chikungunya virus
is an epidemic should be well informed about this condition. We used 6
bibliographical databases as resources: Medline/Pubmed, Embase,
ScienceDirect, ClinicalKey, Ovid and SciELO. Dengue reports on
cardiovascular compromise were included as well, to compare both arbovirus’
organic compromises. Articles that delved mainly into the rheumatic articular
and cutaneous complications were not considered, as they were not in line with
the purpose of this study. The type of articles included were reviews,
meta-analyses, case-controls, cohort studies, case reports and case series. This systematic review does not reach or performed a meta-analysis. Results: Originally based on 737 articles, our reviewed selected 40 articles with
54.2% at least mentioning CHIKV cardiovascular compromise within the
systemic compromise. Cardiovascular manifestations can be considered
common and have been reported in France, India, Sri Lanka, Malaysia,
Colombia, Venezuela and USA, including mainly, but no limited to:
hypotension, shock and circulatory collapse, Raynaud phenomenon,
arrhythmias, murmurs, myocarditis, dilated cardiomyopathy, congestive
insufficiency, heart failure and altered function profile (Troponins, CPK). Conclusions: Physicians should be encouraged to keep divulgating reports on
the cardiovascular involvement of chikungunya virus disease, to raise
awareness and ultimately encourage suitable diagnosis and intervention
worldwide. More research about cardiovascular involvement and
manifestations of systemic Chikungunya virus infection is urgently needed. , Instituto
José Antonio Suárez
Conmemorativo Gorgas de Estudios de la
Salud Panama
1 (0)
Comments Page 1 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 Introduction
R
i
l Not every patient develops the full three stages, and at least a 20%
of the infected population will not develop any symptoms at all,
despite serological confirmation3,9. On the other hand, isolated
cases have reported severe acute manifestations, far from the classic
expected evolution of the disease, especially in areas with renowned
late outbreaks such as India (2006)1,10, La Réunion and Mayotte
(France, 2006)9,11, Malaysia (2008), Thailand (2008)12,13 and South
America (Colombia, Venezuela and later Brazil, from 2014 until
now)14,15. As a result, some authors have started to classify the clini-
cal progression of CHIKV into either classical, severe or neuro-
logical (neuro-chikungunya)10,13. The severe subtype of the disease
contemplates an atypical systemic compromise, in which the liver,
lungs, and even the eye are affected by the extra-articular intense
inflammatory response10,16,17. Similarly, the involvement of the heart
has often been fatal and worth highlighting in some reports18–22, but
it has not been very largely discussed. Chikungunya virus (CHIKV) is an RNA-type arbovirus species
that according to the International Committee on Taxonomy of
Viruses (ICTV) belongs to the Togaviridae family and Alphavirus
genus, along with more than 30 other pathogens for vertebrates
and humans, causing a very broad spectrum of disease1,2. The word
“Chikungunya” means “which contorts or bends up” in Makonde
language from Tanzania and Mozambique, referring accurately
to the difficulty in deambulation or walking of those affected1,2. Despite CHIKV first being documented in 1954 in Tanzania, Africa
and subsequently Asia1,3,4, it was not until 2006 that CHIKV first
alarmed the world for being a major public health concern. After an
explosive epidemic outbreak in French island La Réunion, where
35% of the total population was infected over six months, CHIKV
arrived to central France and extended to Germany, Italy, Norway,
and Switzerland1. Later on, the virus hit North, Central and South
America and brought with it the concept of a “self-limited febrile
illness”, a more benign type of infection with predominantly articu-
lar symptomatology1,3–5. Characterizing potential systemic compromise due to CHIKV
infection, especially cardiovascular, and characterizing manifesta-
tions and complications as a result, is essential in clinical practice. Here, identifying the febrile syndrome is particularly common on
a daily basis and, coexists in a great proportion of patients with
other morbidities and chronic conditions, that could easily trigger
a more severe presentation and clinical picture of the disease9,11,23. This article is included in the Zika & Arbovirus
channel.
Outbreaks Alfonso J. Rodriguez-Morales (
)
Corresponding author:
ajrodriguezm_md@hotmail.com g
(
)
p
g
j
g
_
@
Alvarez MF, Bolívar-Mejía A, Rodriguez-Morales AJ and Ramirez-Vallejo E. How to cite this article:
Cardiovascular involvement and
manifestations of systemic Chikungunya virus infection: A systematic review [version 2; referees: 1 approved, 2 approved with
2017, :390 (doi:
)
reservations] F1000Research
6
10.12688/f1000research.11078.2
© 2017 Alvarez MF
. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the
,
Copyright:
et al
Creative Commons Attribution Licence
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. The author(s) is/are
employees of the US Government and therefore domestic copyright protection in USA does not apply to this work. The work may be protected
under the copyright laws of other jurisdictions when used in those jurisdictions. Data associated with the article are available under the terms of the
(CC0 1.0 Public domain dedication). Creative Commons Zero "No rights reserved" data waiver
The author(s) declared that no grants were involved in supporting this work. Grant information:
Competing interests: No competing interests were disclosed. 29 Mar 2017, :390 (doi:
)
First published:
6
10.12688/f1000research.11078.1 Page 2 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 of a healthy host takes place6,7. After the infectious bite, the incuba-
tion period of CHIKV ranges from 1–12 days before clinical onset
of symptoms1,6. The appearance of clinical manifestations of the
febrile syndrome coincides with viremia settling in during a period
of 5–7 days, when viral load can be as high as 109 viral genome
copies per milliliter3. Most recently, cases of vertical transmission
have been reported, but it is indeed rare, and transmission through
nursing has not been proven1,6,8. Amendments from Version 1
REVISED This new version considered interesting comments of one of the
reviewers regarding multiple aspects related to the comparison
with dengue cardiovascular compromise, myocarditis and rhythm
alterations in chikungunya, as well to correct some missed points
during the first version, attending most of the comments raised
by one the reviewers. This version 2 also includes updated
PRISMA guidelines, as displayed in Supplementary file 1 and
Supplementary file 2. Furthermore the grant information has been
amended to declare that no grants were involved in supporting
this work. Three stages of disease after the incubation period have been
recognized9: See referee reports • Acute (<3 weeks post-infection) • Post-acute or subacute (3 to 12 weeks post-infection) • Chronic (>12 weeks post-infection) Introduction
R
i
l No previous systematic reviews have been found in major databases
about cardiovascular involvement and cardiovascular manifesta-
tions of chikungunya virus infection, which is the main focus of
this article. Alphaviruses can be separated into two phylogenetic categories:
“Old World” viruses and “New World” viruses. “Old World” viruses
such as CHIKV are known for their articular tropism and exan-
thematous febrile syndrome; and the “New World” viruses such as
the western equine encephalitis and Venezuelan equine encepha-
litis viruses1–3 have preference for nervous system stromal cells. CHIKV infection pathway in humans is shared with Dengue
fever, and is caused by the biting of borne-arthropods from the
Aedes mosquito family, Aedes aegypti and most recently Aedes
albopictus1, the last one being essential to the wide geographic col-
onization process ever since a new mutation (A226V) in CHIKV
has conferred the virus a better ability to replicate in this species. Ae. albopictus is more common in Asia, and has become wor-
thy of mentioning in the Southeast of the United States and the
Caribbean region6. CHIKV currently circulating in America
seems to no longer be related to the African lineage, but to strains
documented in Asia and the Phillipines2,4. Objectives To systematically review published literature on the cardiovascular
manifestations and involvement of systemic CHIKV infection; • To explore which are the main clinical cardiovascular
features of chikungunya infection • To identify which are the main electrocardiographic
findings of chikungunya infection The transmission cycle, although originally merely sylvatic between
primates and forest mosquitoes, has developed an alternate urban
cycle involving humans1,6. Aedes as vectors are capable of spread-
ing the virus after biting a viremic human, after which CHIKV rep-
licates in salivary glands of the female mosquito and then a new bite Methods
Protocol and registration Methods
Protocol and registration Methods
Protocol and registration Methods
Protocol and regis Methods
Protocol and registration Protocol and registration This protocol has followed PRISMA guidelines (Supplementary
File 1 and Supplementary File 2) Page 3 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 Study selection The type of articles included were reviews, meta-analyses, case-
controls, cohort studies, case reports and case series. Data items During individual article assessment the variables for which data
were sought included any cardiovascular manifestation associ-
ated with CHIKV infection, as well as any electrocardiographic,
echocardiographic and related laboratory findings in patients dur-
ing acute and/or chronic phases of Chikungunya disease. Eligibility criteria of the classic and severe/atypical disease. It provides a clear focus
on the extra-articular and mainly cardiovascular manifestations
of the CHIKV infection, diagnosis of CHIKV-induced cardiomy-
opathy, management, prognosis, and differences from what can be
observed with Dengue virus (DENV) infection. Any original studies that report cases with cardiovascular manifes-
tations (acute and/or chronic) related to Chikungunya. We included
studies published in English and Spanish. Eligible study designs
were case-control, cohort studies, case reports and series of cases. Data collection Data extraction from reports was done independently by two inves-
tigators. They checked for duplicates and were responsible for an
initial quality screening of the studies. Clinical course. The acute stage extends from the first symp-
tomatic day to the 21st day and is characterized by an end-of-
incubation
sudden
high
fever
(often
above
39°C),
headaches, myalgia and the insidious onset of typical symmetric,
bilateral polyarthalgia (most frequently of small distal joints –
phalanges, wrists, ankles), along with a typical maculopapular
evanescent rash1,3,9. The location of the arthralgias tends to vary
between individuals. There are rare descriptions in the literature
of pain in the costochondral, hip and temporomandibular
articulations24, so it may not be advisable to dismiss a CHIKV
diagnosis if these pains are present. Palmo-plantar pruritus, pho-
tophobia, edema in the face and extremities and adenopathies have
been also described, and benign and self-limited hemorrhagic man-
ifestations are relatively common in children. Subsequently, by the
end of the acute stage, asthenia and adynamia tends to appear1,9. Study selection The systematic review was conducted using six bibliographical
databases (Medline/Pubmed, Embase, Elsevier, ClinicalKey, Ovid
and SciELO) as resources. The research initially rendered a total of 737 articles: dupli-
cates across the databases and articles about other viruses were
eliminated, unless they focused solely on cardiac compromise
(Supplementary File 2). Finally, 40 articles were selected based on
their relevance and pertinence of the title or abstract to the systemic
compromise that was being evaluated, with 54.2% at least men-
tioning CHIKV cardiovascular compromise within the systemic
compromise (Supplementary File 2). Search strategy. To explore the extent by which this topic is
currently represented in medical literature, searches were initiated
with “Chikungunya AND Systemic AND Manifestations”,
“Chikungunya AND Heart” and “Chikungunya AND Cardiac”. Given the lack of studies, we explored other options (such as
“Chikungunya AND cardiac involvement” “Chikungunya AND
cardiac complication” or “Chikungunya AND cardiovascular
involvement” “Chikungunya AND cardiovascular complications”
and Chikungunya AND Atypical manifestation/complications“,
among others), but to be more sensitive and to include all the
possibly relevant studies related to our SR, we only included
studies that had been found in our initial searches. Article language
was limited to English and Spanish, and there was no limit set for
time of publication, but searches concluded on November 1, 2016. Dengue reports on cardiovascular compromise were included as
well, to compare between both arbovirus’ organic compromise. Articles that delved mainly into the rheumatic articular and
cutaneous complications were not considered, as they were not in
line with the purpose of this study. Study characteristics
Th f
hi h The frequency at which the rest of the organs systems are affected
is shown in Table 1. The information on the role of the cardiovas-
cular system during CHIKV infection is very scarce indeed; only
21.4% of the resulting articles focused solely and exclusively
on the cardiovascular findings; the first publication on the topic
was by Obeyeskere et al. and dates to 1972. In relation to extra-
articular compromise of other organ systems besides cardiovascu-
lar, the most published were the nervous system –both central and
peripheral- and secondary skin complications. According to the system that is compromised (e.g. osteoarticular,
cardiovascular, neurological, etc) in the literature, the frequency of
compromise of organs/systems was separated into six categories:
extremely common (100-80%), very common (79-60%), common
(59-40%), unusual (39-20%), rare (19-10%) and extremely rare if
below 10%. Data were registered in Table 1, showing the coun-
tries of origin of reports describing such types of manifestations of
CHIKV infection. Risk of bias in individual studies Chikungunya is an emerging disease in the Americas and reemerg-
ing in the world, so there are a small number of studies addressing
the cardiovascular manifestations (acute and/or chronic) related to
Chikungunya. The risk of bias is discussed throughout the article. To assess the quality of eligible studies critical appraisals specific to
study design were completed by two independent reviewers. In the post-acute stage, from the first to the third month, all symp-
toms described above tend to vanish, except for some residual
arthralgia, and some residual fever and adynamia. Extra-articular
rheumatisms such as tenosynovitis, bursitis, tendinitis, worsening
of osteoarthritis and even tunnel syndrome and Raynaud We have compiled and submitted a complete review of CHIKV that
includes the main facts about characterization, origin and transmis-
sion of the virus, epidemiology, pathogenesis, and clinical features Page 4 of 22 Page 4 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 Table 1. Frequency at which different organ systems are affected during CHIKV infection. Affected organs
Reporting
articles
Frequency of
compromise
Countries of origin
Osteoarticular
97.1% (34)
Extremely common
• France, Italy
• India, Sri Lanka, Malaysia,
Singapore, Thailand
• Colombia, Venezuela, Peru
• USA
Cardiovascular
54.2% (19)
Common
• France
• India, Sri Lanka, Malaysia
• Colombia, Venezuela
• USA
Neurological
37.1% (13)
Unusual
• France
• India, Singapore, Thailand
• Colombia, Peru
Skin and mucous membranes
complications
25.7% (9)
Unusual
• France
• India, Sri Lanka
• Colombia, Peru, Venezuela
Renal
22.8% (8)
Unusual
• France
• India, Sri Lanka, Malaysia
• Venezuela
Gastrointestinal tract
20% (7)
Unusual
• France
• Singapore
• Colombia, Peru
Hepatic
20% (7)
Unusual
• France
• India, Malaysia, Singapore
Hematological
20% (7)
Unusual
• France
• India, Malaysia
• Colombia, Peru
Ocular
14.3% (5)
Rare
• France
• India, Sri Lanka
• Colombia, Peru
Respiratory
14.3% (5)
Rare
• France
• India, Sri Lanka
• Colombia
Endocrine
5.7% (2)
Extremely rare
• France
• India
Reporting articles n () and % corresponded to the number of articles (out of the eligible n=40), that described the type of
compromise (e.g. osteoarticular, cardiovascular, etc). The frequency of different organ-type of manifestations was classified
as follows: extremely common (100-80%), very common (79-60%), common (59-40%), unusual (39-20%), rare (19-10%)
and extremely rare if below 10%. Table 1. Frequency at which different organ systems are affected during CHIKV infection. Table 1. Risk of bias in individual studies Frequency at which different organ systems are affected during CHIKV infection. Reporting articles n () and % corresponded to the number of articles (out of the eligible n=40), that described the type of
compromise (e.g. osteoarticular, cardiovascular, etc). The frequency of different organ-type of manifestations was classified
as follows: extremely common (100-80%), very common (79-60%), common (59-40%), unusual (39-20%), rare (19-10%)
and extremely rare if below 10%. Reporting articles n () and % corresponded to the number of articles (out of the eligible n=40), that described the type of
ompromise (e.g. osteoarticular, cardiovascular, etc). The frequency of different organ-type of manifestations was classified
s follows: extremely common (100-80%), very common (79-60%), common (59-40%), unusual (39-20%), rare (19-10%)
nd extremely rare if below 10%. to moderate; leaving to a mean of 50% the most incapacitating and
aggressive compromise9. phenomenon have been reported9. Not every patient develops this
phase, and degrees of severity and functional limitation will depend
on patients’ previous comorbidities, mainly musculoskeletal. Alternatively, other risk factors for being still symptomatic after
the first month have been linked, for instance, to having poor rest
during the acute phase, and females above the age of 40 are at major
risk1,9,11. Atypical presentations. Atypical presentations of CHIKV infection
can involve almost every organ system, as seen in Table 2. Even
though the most common extra-articular manifestations reported in
the literature involve the nervous system25–27 and the eye17; altera-
tions in the gastrointestinal tract, liver16, kidney, muscles, mucous
membranes and skin and hematologic cells have been evidenced,
as well as in hemostasis and coagulation processes. Cardiovas-
cular compromise is worthy of mentioning because of its usually
fatal outcomes10,28. Infection can lead to cardiovascular manifesta-
tions, but in addition, patients with existing cardiovascular disease
can deteriorate quickly, worsening the short-term prognosis; as it
has been described with diabetes, lupus; or neurological, renal,
pulmonary and cardiovascular insufficiency9,11,23. Chronic CHIKV infection would be defined as a symptomatic
period longer than three months and manifestations (continuous or
episodic) that last for months, years or even a decade. Manifesta-
tions are the same as previously described in the post-acute phase,
presenting as oscillating arthralgias over time with or without
inflammatory signs until, according to natural history of the dis-
ease, the patient returns to the health state that they had before the
infection. Synthesis of results y
Cardiovascular involvement. La Réunion reported an overall out-
break mortality of 10%; heart failure was the attributed cause in 15%
of the cases, myocarditis and pericarditis in 5% and acute myocar-
dial infarction in 2%; leaving a remarkable total of 22% mortality
due to cardiovascular compromise11,15. Several similar past records
raise concerns about a possible cardiac tropism of CHIKV, with
clear evidence. The first description of clinical myocardial involve-
ment of CHIKV infection was reported in 1972, when Obeyeskere
et al presented a cohort of 10 patients who had a history of
arbovirus-like syndrome, serological evidence of Dengue IgM
antibodies or CHIKV haemagglutination inhibition (HI) antibod-
ies test, and complement-fixation antibodies tst in high titres, and
now had clinical and electrocardiographic evidence of myocarditis. Apart from the classic acute febrile symptoms, patients manifested
palpitations, chest pain, fatigue, dyspnea and vagal-stimulation
symptoms; which by themselves could already indicate coronary
syndrome20. First is “pre-congestive or prodromal”; when isolated, not very
specific electrocardiographic findings are detected (especially
T wave abnormalities). Cardiomegaly can be detected with a sim-
ple thorax radiography or echocardiogram and gallop rhythm may
be auscultated, but there are no visible cardiovascular symptoms. By this time (after 7 days), the initial viremia peak is over, but we
are in front of an incipient heart failure19. The most documented electrocardiographic changes were T wave
inversion in DII, III, aVF and V5–V6, and ST elevation18,23,28,29. These are relatively nonspecific findings, which are encouraged
to be interpreted within the whole clinical context so that other
compatible differential diagnoses such as acute coronary syn-
drome, electrolyte disorder, or even digitalis intoxication, can be
dismissed20. In addition, echocardiograms mostly reveal biven-
tricular hypertrophy and dyskinesia of wall movements; and these
results are compatible with myocarditis. Ejection fraction may
be mildly diminished and pericardial effusion is rare. Creatine
Phospho-Kinase (CPK) levels may be increased after the first
phase28. Further studies have histopathologically identified and verified
the presence of the virus in cardiac tissue of postmortem biop-
sies. Lemant et al reported the case of an elderly woman with
serologically confirmed CHIKV who developed a fulminant myo-
carditis, with no significant medical background29. Myocardial
biopsy revealed extensive necrosis and cytoplasmic viral inclusions
in the cells29. Nowadays, evidence shows that, besides the heart,
CHIKV may also have tropism for the nervous system and the
liver28. The second phase is known as the “arrhythmic phase”. Risk of bias in individual studies The degree of functional limitation may vary from little Page 5 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 Alanine-aminotranspherase, ASAT: Aspartate-aminotranspherate, CPK: Creatine-phosphokinase,
SCr: serum creatinine, BUN: Blood Urea Nitrogen. Affected system
Clinical manifestations
Neurological
• Fulminant meningoencephalitis*
• Myelopathy
• Encephalopathy
• Polyneuropathy, optic neuritis and tunnel syndrome
• Dysautonomy
• Flaccid paralysis
• Stroke
• Cerebral edema*
• Confusion and other sensory alterations
• Seizures and psychomotor sequelae*
• Guillain-Barre Syndrome
• Cerebellar syndrome
• Sensorineural hearing loss
Skin and mucous membranes
• Bullous dermatosis*
• Skin dyschromia
• Hemorrhagic lesions (gingivorrhagia, epistaxis, cutaneous)*
• Oral and genital ulceration
• Conjunctivitis
Gastrointestinal tract
• Pharyngitis
• Severe abdominal pain*
• Diarrhea*
• Vomit*
• Internal bleeding (hematemesis and melena)*
Liver
• Fulminant hepatitis
• Hepatomegaly*
• Ascites*
• Altered function profile (ALAT, ASAT, bilirubin)
Hematological
• Thromboembolism
• Intravascular coagulation
• Thrombocytopenia*
• Lymphopenia*
Cardiovascular
• Hypotension*
• Shock and circulatory collapse
• Raynaud phenomenon
• Arrhythmias
• Murmurs*
• Myocarditis*
• Dilated cardiomyopathy*
• Congestive insufficiency*
• Heart failure
• Altered function profile (Troponins, CPK)
Respiratory
• Dyspnea
• Pulmonary edema
• Pneumonia
• Pleural effusion
Renal
• Albuminuria
• Hematuria
• Nephritis
• Acute renal failure*
• Altered function profile (SCr, BUN)
Ocular
• Uveitis
• Retinitis
• Iridocyclitis
• Epiescleritis
Psychiatric
• Delirium
• Depression
• Anxiety
• Loss of memory
*: Seen also in children. Page 6 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 A common denominator of the 0.5% of patients who develop
these systemic atypical patterns of disease is having some kind of
predisposing condition, disease, or advanced age9,16,24. In retro-
spective records of severe cases reported by Economopolou A.,
et al. from La Réunion, 89% had previous medical conditions, 78%
took medication before the disease (14% NSAIDS) and 14% were
alcoholic11,23. Nevertheless, it is notable that risk of severe infec-
tion and compromise seems to increase in large outbreaks, as
documented in India (2006), where only 25% of cases developed
classical CHIKV; and 75% were severe cases where 60% of these
had some degree of neurological compromise10. recurrent damage from other microorganisms20 and favor transition
from myocarditis to dilated cardiomyopathy30. As has been men-
tioned, Obeyeskere et al in 1972 was the first group to make such
reports and observed the CHIKV physiopathology at cardiovascu-
lar level. Clinical cardiovascular progression pattern. Risk of bias in individual studies A progression pattern
has been identified and proposed, with three phases. Patients may
follow the three phases strictly, or present a torpid evolution right
to the last phase and skip the second one. Also, time of progression
varies between individuals, depending on the severity of the initial
cardiovascular injuries and previous comorbidities. Synthesis of results It starts
when the recent myocardial injury can no longer permit an adequate
functioning of the cardiac conduction system. Again, according to
the severity, findings may range from premature auricular and ven-
tricular extrasystoles to atrial fibrillation with high risk of throm-
boembolism; and in the worst-case scenario, ventricular fibrillation
and sudden death19. This wide spectrum directly correlates with the
symptoms and hemodynamic state of the patient31. Physiopathology of CHIKV-induced cardiac compromise. Few
authors have tried to determine the physiopathology behind the car-
diac damage that CHIKV can potentially cause19,20. Studying other
viruses that share tropism for the heart is essential. A postmortem
study, based on endomyocardial biopsies with PCR, in patients
diagnosed with idiopathic dilated cardiomyopathy, evidenced a
viral infiltration of myocytes in 66% of the cases. In that study the
three most isolated viral agents were: parvovirus 19, herpes virus
and showing that direct viral organ invasion is feasible, lethal and
more frequent than expected for such viruses. The patients after the acute and subacute phase that are most
affected will invariably develop heart failure, displaying some a
right side insufficiency with pulmonary and peripheral edema and
hepatomegaly; but more frequently a left side insufficiency with
low perfusion and shock clinic19. Reduced peripheral blood flow
can be responsible for many pathological events too, blurring the
line between expected consequences of shock and the real direct
organ damage of CHIKV. Kidneys are an example, as in Economo-
polou et al’s retrospective study, 20% of the patients with heart fail-
ure also presented with pre-renal failure23, which suggests it is more
of a consequence of shock in this instance. In contrast, lesions such
as nephritis are more likely to be caused by the virus. Additionally,
in this third stage, a constrictive syndrome has also been described,
with extensive compromise and pericarditis, but it is indeed less
common24. CHIKV penetrates the myocytes and generates direct damage to
the muscle fibers, meanwhile inflammatory response and infiltrate
grows, leading to secondary damage by a hypersensitivity reaction
and necrosis, but usually with no typical signs of infarction20,22,30. Synthesis of results Furthermore, it has been proposed that these alterations are long-
standing, and tend to make the cardiac tissue more vulnerable to Page 7 of 22 Page 7 of 22 Page 7 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 A summary of most the common clinical manifestations during
CHIKV infection that suggest cardiac viral compromise is given
in Table 3. Isolated signs and symptoms reported in single case
reports that seemed to relate more to the pre-morbidities of the
patient were excluded. Regarding blood pressure, there are sig-
nificant variations in the reports, but recently hypotension was
reported during acute CHIKV infection in patients with high blood
pressure undergoing antihypertensive treatment. A pattern through
the revised articles could not be identified, so having hypo or
hypertension may be a poor predictor of cardiac compromise dur-
ing CHIKV infection and seems more a product of the severity of
the case and the numbers previously managed by the patient20. Diagnosis and management of CHIKV infection with cardiac
compromise. Diagnosis of a CHIKV infection with cardiac com-
promise must be more epidemiological and clinical based rather
than anything else. Specific CHIKV infection during acute phase
could be diagnosed by molecular techniques such as PCR, but
the phases that follow must be diagnosed by immunological/
serological tests, particularly the detection of IgG anti-CHIKV. Once CHIKV infection is suspected, echocardiographic imaging,
MRI and other paraclinical exams will only help in assessing the
severity of the damage. There is an evident lack of studies on the
topic and therefore, lack of data determining sensibility and spe-
cificity of the findings that are mentioned in Table 3. However, Table 3. Key clinical findings during CHIKV infection that suggest cardiac viral
compromise12,19–22 . AV: Atrioventricular. NTproBNP: N-terminal pro-Brain Natriuretic
Peptide. MRI: Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Synthesis of results • Asymptomatic with no imaging sequelae; • Asymptomatic with partial reversion of EKG and echocar-
diogram changes; • Asymptomatic with partial reversion of EKG and echocar-
diogram changes; • Death • Death Changes seen on cardiac magnetic resonance imaging that persist
for more than one year from disease onset will be permanent and
affect the patients to some degree later in life18. Simon et al thus
proposes that in upcoming years, countries that suffered outbreaks
of CHIKV since 2005, will see a long-term increase in dilated car-
diomyopathy, reporting this as the most frequent sequelae, even in
asymptomatic patients who had an apparently classic clinical pic-
ture involving arthralgia predominantly18. This raises public health
concerns and the risk of a noticeable limitation in quality of life for
these patients in the future. Nevertheless, what is noticed is that diagnoses are rarely made,
interventions tend to be delayed and insufficient, and outcome is
often an imminent refractory heart failure. Management has mostly
been ineffective in containing the damage, and death by cardiac
arrest becomes inevitable. Cases as severe as a 63-year-old woman
with a T wave inversion in V5–V6 and global progressive hypo-
kinesia have been reported. She experienced cardiac arrest and
died 4 hours after admission25, where action time was so limited
and management was not even mentioned29. It is not possible to
state the standard management process for cardiac compromise
from CHIKV infection due to the low frequency of reports of this
type of CHIKV disease, so the only possibility available is to ana-
lyse management given to past reported cases in the literature and
compare outcomes. Similar reports and findings on Dengue fever: Arbovirus-induced
cardiopathy. The cardiac tropism of CHIKV seems to be shared
with DENV, with multiple cases in the literature displaying simi-
lar cardiovascular complications and often mimicking acute myo-
cardial infarction as well33,34. Myocarditis is reported similarly. However, arrhythmias and compromise of the electric conduction
system of the heart have a higher incidence with DENV, including
supraventricular arrhythmias such as atrial fibrillation, atrioven-
tricular (AV) blockage28 and cases reporting refractory ventricular
fibrillation as the ultimate cause of death34. Acute pericardial and
pulmonary edema are also described, but the outcome is rarely fatal. As a common denominator in the published literature, most reports
of cardiac involvement are seen in patients with hemorrhagic fever
manifestations of CHIKV infection. Synthesis of results Scenario
Cardiovascular clinical findings
Data of symptoms in
medical record
• Chest pain, more specifically substernal
• Fatigue
• Dyspnea
• Palpitations
• Intolerance to exercise
• Vagal symptoms: diaphoresis, paleness, cough,
nausea, lypotimia/syncope, dizziness
• Maleolar edema
Physical examination
• Tachycardia
• Atrial and ventricular premature ectopic
beats
• Crepitation or rhonchi in pulmonary basis
• Murmurs/third heart sound
• Gallop rhythm
• Irregular pulse
• Jugular ingurgitation and raised jugular pressure
(positive hepatojugular reflex)
• Tachypnea
Electrocardiography
• Tachycardia
• T wave inversion in II, III, aVF and V5-V5 leads
• Prolonged ST segment
• Deep S in V2
• Prominent R in V5
• Extrasystoles
• AV blocks
• Atrial fibrillation
Laboratory
Besides serologic IgM confirmation of CHIKV:
• Increased troponins
• High NTproNBP
Radiography
• Augmented cardio-thoracic ratio
• Pleural effusion
Echocardiogram
• Diffuse hypokinesia, asynergia of wall movements
• Ventricular hypertrophy (mostly left)
• Dilated chambers
• Ventricular ejection fraction may be preserved
Contrast-enhanced
MRI
• Intramyocardial and subepicardial foci with
increased signal intensities suggestive of necrosis
(not corresponding to coronary vascular expected
distribution) Table 3. Key clinical findings during CHIKV infection that suggest cardiac viral
compromise12,19–22 . AV: Atrioventricular. NTproBNP: N-terminal pro-Brain Natriuretic
Peptide. MRI: Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Table 3. Key clinical findings during CHIKV infection that suggest cardiac viral
compromise12,19–22 . AV: Atrioventricular. NTproBNP: N-terminal pro-Brain Natriuretic
Peptide. MRI: Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Page 8 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 imaging18,21. By now, it is evident that there are three clear, different
outcomes to CHIKV infection: imaging18,21. By now, it is evident that there are three clear, different
outcomes to CHIKV infection: Simon et al. mentioned and delimited specific and very valid diag-
nostic criteria for what is called CHIKV-induced myopericarditis
in their case report. They demonstrated clinical, biological and
morphological evidence of myocarditis, with serologically docu-
mented CHIKV infection and no serological evidence of another
recent infection, then linked the cardiovascular compromise to
CHIKV18,28. Results like these are very useful but it is always advis-
able to always look at these criteria in the context of the patients and
their previous comorbidities. Synthesis of results On the other hand, the treatment given to a successful case in India
who remained fully asymptomatic after follow ups consisted of
inotropic support (dopamine and dobutamine) and levocarnitine
used to relieve mitochondrial dysfunction. Additionally, a 19-year-
old male who was previously healthy developed myocarditis but
was discharged after 3 days with Acebutolol and Ramipril, and at
follow-up, premature beats had disappeared22. There is another
case of a 21-year old woman who returned from La Reunion and
responded clinically to with high doses of aspirin, and her EKG
changes reverted18. Such good prognosis as seen in the aforemen-
tioned cases may not be representative of the true clinical progres-
sion, and may be biased due to the early age of the patients28. Physiopathology Even though the etiological agent is very similar, DENV-induced
cardiomyopathy has a variant: the plasma leak syndrome and char-
acteristically endothelial dysfunction of DENV that may result
helpful to the extravasation process and chemotaxis of inflam-
matory cells to myocardial tissue, creating a highly cytokine rich
environment35, besides the already known tropism of DENV for
the heart. This could explain why cardiovascular manifestations
are much more common with DENV than with CHIKV35,36. Host
susceptibility and the virulence of the strain also play a role in the
severity of the clinical picture37. In summary, management of CHIKV disease is not established
everywhere, remains very variable, and consists mainly in cor-
recting the clinical features of the cardiac failure, but does not tak-
ing into consideration the root cause. Beta-adrenergic blockers,
ACE-inhibitors and inotropic support during the crisis are com-
monly reported in order to maintain hemodynamic stability. Only
one case reported the use of prednisolone21, but without any other
cardiac support drugs, and the outcome was equally poor. Studies
on the impact of anti-inflammatory corticosteroids along with
cardiovascular support drugs should be carried out, it seems to be a
promising option considering the underlying severe systemic
inflammatory response in these cases. A very similar substrate is
seen in the eosinophilic myocarditis that can cause Toxocara canis,
where early prednisolone in doses of 1mg/kg/day for the acute phase
and 5–10mg/kg/day for maintenance has been recommended32. Management Management of DENV is poorly reported and not established eve-
rywhere, as is the case with CHIKV. Early use of IV hydrocortisone
resulted in full recovery in two cases of myocarditis in 12 year old
patients42, and authors support that fatality is significantly reduced
under opportune intervention during the first hours42. A more con-
servative attitude was adopted for the analyzed cohort from the
Sri Lanka outbreak; with indications of strict bed rest, liquid main-
tenance, oxygen, close monitorization of vital signs and inotropic
support when needed, and a clear avoidance of steroids and other
empirical drugs37. Although arboviral cardiovascular manifestations have been
described for over 40 years20, few studies8,18,40 have documented
in detail the specific cardiovascular and specific EKG patterns
during acute disease40, especially in recent epidemics in Latin
America. Initial reports of three fatal cases of chikungunya in
Barranquilla, Colombia15, in which patients presented hypotension
and tachycardia, raised red flags among physicians in the region. More recently in Sucre, Colombia, in 2016, a case series of 42
patients with chikungunya followed in detail found arrhythmias in
EKG findings, such as repolarization disturbances, in more than
71% of those cases. Repolarization disturbances were the most
frequent (21%)40. Preliminary unpublished data41 from a study in
Caracas, Venezuela, reported in 2016, they provided similar find-
ings in patients, although at a lower frequency. Indeed, evidence of
patent or silent myocarditis was observed in a high percentage of
patients prospectively evaluated in Venezuela. An unexpected
finding was persistent symptomatic arterial hypotension observed
in one third of these patients with prior stable hypertension on treat-
ment, requiring the anti-hypertensive medication to be discontinued
or reduced due to severe clinical manifestations41. The importance of a rapid intervention (first hours) is exemplified
by the case of a 25 year old Indian male, that presented with non-
specific abdominal epigastric pain and vomiting. Exams revealed
myocarditis. The patient died in a few hours when he developed
pharmacological and electrical refractory ventricular tachycardia
while evaluating a much more invasive treatment option: the pos-
sibility of implanting a left ventricular assistance device. Positive
DENV serology results were known later34. It is clear at this point,
that therapy needs to be standardized for arbovirus-induced cardio-
myopathy, comparing efficacy of treatments that have already been
proposed, as well as new treatment options. Management A study from Tolima, Colombia, carried out in 2016 provided con-
sistent findings and information with regards to the spectrum of
EKG alterations. Rhythm disturbances occurred in 10 patients out
of 14 (71%)35. They included sinusal tachycardia (3/14 patients),
hemiblocks (2/14), left ventricular hypertrophy (2/14) and ST seg-
ment depression (2/14), among others35. Electrocardiography and echocardiography Manifestations remain comparable, but electrocardiography distur-
bances are observed frequently in a wide range of 34–75%35,36 of
the dengue cases. In the 2005 outbreak, Sri Lanka reported 62.5%
of patients affected37. Abnormalities basically consist of sinus
bradycardia, T inversion, depression of ST segment in precordial
leads and avF, AV blocks, (Mobitz type I second degree has
been mentioned) bundle branch blocks and rarely, atrial fibrilla-
tion33,34,37,38. All were reported as supposedly transient39. Two cases
of remaining atrial fibrillation after the resolution of disease have
been reported, with reversion only achieved after antiarrhythmic
treatment (Amiodarone)39. Prognosis and functional sequelae. The Indian child cited above
showed general improvement within three days, with no relapses. A follow up echocardiogram reported only a mild mitral regurgita-
tion, with intact left ventricle function28. The 19 and 21 year old
patients remained asymptomatic, but dilation persisted on Page 9 of 22 Page 9 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 the the spectrum of symptoms such as rhythm and conduction
disturbances20,40. Imaging is similar to what is reported in CHIKV echocardiography:
global hypokinesia and important decrease in left ventricle ejection
fraction (LVEF). A study reported a mean of 47.08% of LVEF in
all DENV infected patients, and of 39.6% if shock syndrome was
present. At follow up after three weeks, LVEF was superior to 50%
in all cases and ECG changes had reverted35. From these findings,
JP Wali et al proposed three diagnostic criteria for suspected car-
diac compromise: ST-T changes in ECG, global hypokinesia and a
decreased LVEF in imaging. Imaging is similar to what is reported in CHIKV echocardiography:
global hypokinesia and important decrease in left ventricle ejection
fraction (LVEF). A study reported a mean of 47.08% of LVEF in
all DENV infected patients, and of 39.6% if shock syndrome was
present. At follow up after three weeks, LVEF was superior to 50%
in all cases and ECG changes had reverted35. From these findings,
JP Wali et al proposed three diagnostic criteria for suspected car-
diac compromise: ST-T changes in ECG, global hypokinesia and a
decreased LVEF in imaging. Ongoing studies should focus on determining the potential chronic
cardiovascular outcomes that could develop in patients infected
with chikungunya, in order to provide an appropriate early clinical
intervention strategy to avoid potential disabilities. Discussion The key for a successful outcome of CHIKV-induced cardiomy-
opathy is recognizing signs and symptoms early on. It is certainly a
condition that can be life-threatening, which is why patients should
be referred for cardiac assessment as early as possible, after display-
ing any of the previously mentioned symptoms. Identifying comor-
bidities is recommended as well to distinguish CHIKV-induced
cardiomyopathy from an exacerbation of previous heart disease. Patients with chikungunya may present cardiovascular compli-
cations including myocarditis and pericarditis18,40,41. Thus, an
accurate physical examination, including a detailed cardiovascular
system assessment should be performed. This should include
cardiac auscultation looking for sound alterations, which could
be indicating premature ventricular contractions18,20,40,41. Besides
that, all CHIKV infected patients with should have an EKG
performed on them, given that it is an easy, cheap and quick assess-
ment tool that could prevent potential deleterious cardiovascular
outcomes40. For dengue virus infection, it is now known that the cardiovascu-
lar involvement is mostly characterized by rhythm abnormalities
(bradycardia), with no symptoms or complications. However, in
moderate or severe cases where there was a cardiovascular affec-
tation or complication, myocarditis has been an important issue. Myocarditis due to DENV infection may present several patterns
such as “refractory shock”, “heart failure”, “arrhythmia”, etc and
It would be important to consider this diagnosis. In the case of
CHIKV infection and cardiac involvement, myocarditis should be
also considered. In light of any clinical or electrocardiographic abnormality, car-
diac enzymes should also be measured (e.g. troponin)20. As
suggested for over 40 years20 cardiac tropism and direct cytolytic
effects of the virus remains a latent possibility40, yet to date has not
been demonstrated at a tissue level. Further studies using novel
molecular approaches for virus detection in endomyocardial
biopsies of symptomatic CHIKV infected patients could confirm
this possible role and establish the underlying physiopathologi-
cal mechanisms of CHIKV myocarditis which then translate into Cardiac compromise is not so common in isolated episodes; but
countries where chikungunya virus is an epidemic should be
alarmed and well informed about this condition. Physicians should
be encouraged to keep divulgating reports on the cardiovascu-
lar involvement of chikungunya virus disease, to raise awareness
and ultimately encourage suitable diagnosis and intervention Page 10 of 22 Page 10 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 worldwide. Discussion Questions are still raised about the real incidence, as
every outbreak seems to follow a different pattern, but what is
needed the most is further investigation on therapy for this specific
condition and in different age groups. complications came from France in relation to the outbreak on
La Reunion Island, and many of these were published in French. Nevertheless, from these publications we did not identify,
initially by the title or the abstract, any relating to cardiovascular
complications. A significant issue arises with the diagnosis of myocarditis by arbo-
viruses such as DENV and CHIKV, because a myocardial biopsy
or cardiac magnetic resonance imaging needs to be considered and
performed. However, performing these, in tropical areas where
these arboviruses are prevalent, is very hard and there are many
restrictions. The management of myocarditis, regardless its etiol-
ogy, should be focused in the therapeutics oriented to the agent
(virus, bacteria, etc); the cardiovascular events support (controllling
heart failure, cardiogenic shock, arrhythmia, etc) and the treatment
of the inflammatory process. The last one is under discussion and
needs more research, although in some severe cases due to DENV,
the corticosteroids administration changed the evolution given their
positive benefits. Competing interests g
No competing interests were disclosed. No competing interests were disclosed. Author contributions
d
f
l AJRM and ERV formulated the research questions, designed the
study, developed the preliminary search strategy, and drafted the
manuscript. ABM and MFA refined the search strategy by conduct-
ing iterative database queries and incorporating novel search terms. MFA and ABM searched and collected the articles. All authors
critically reviewed the manuscript for important intellectual con-
tent. All authors have read and approved the final version of the
manuscript. Conclusions Finally, these observations on DENV and CHIKV associated car-
diovascular manifestations could be useful for management of Zika
virus infections, which are currently causing epidemics in Latin
America44–46. Cardiovascular compromise has already been described
and reported in fatal cases47,48. In addition, cardiovascular complica-
tions might be underdiagnosed in clinical practice49. Future research
needs to focus on the potential cardiovascular complications of
Zika virus infection, with prompt cardiovascular screening in sus-
pected cases45,49,50. Other emerging arboviruses such as Mayaro50–55,
Oropouche52,53, Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis54,55 may be also
causing cardiovascular compromise, or even be co-infecting. We are still learning about the multiple clinical implications56,57
of co-infection, including those affecting the cardiovascular
system. CHIKV would induce not just cardiovascular compromise and
cardiovascular manifestations during the acute phase, but also at
subacute and chronic stages 43–56. Today it is known that com-
promise during chronic disease is not just limited to the rheuma-
tological manifestations. Nevertheless, in CHIKV, the definition of
systemic manifestation or extra-articular compromise has not well
defined. But in the case of atypical conditions, this was defined by
PAHO/WHO during the expert consultation meeting in Managua,
Nicaragua, 2016, and later published by WHO43. Limitations Limitations will always be the sporadic nature of these cases,
something we need to be prepared for in future outbreaks. Method-
ologically, it should also be considered that the inclusion of reviews
may cause a bias, but in some cases, some would serve to locate
some additional key articles useful for a novel topic such as the
one of this systematic review. Additionally, many studies did not
report detailed information about laboratory diagnoses (Troponin,
BNP, CK-MB, etc), imaging studies (echocardiography, magnetic
resonance), final diagnoses (myocarditis, etc), as well management
(inotropics, corticosteroids, etc) and outcomes (survival, death). Additionally, articles published in French have been excluded. This could be a limitation as the largest series of cases and their 1.
Simon F, Parola P, Grandadam M, et al.: Chikungunya infection: an emerging
rheumatism among travelers returned from Indian Ocean islands. Report of 47
cases. Medicine (Baltimore). 2007; 86(3): 123–37.
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text ;
( )
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 9. Simon F, Javelle E, Cabie A, et al.: French guidelines for the management of
chikungunya (acute and persistent presentations). November 2014. Med Mal
Infect. 2015; 45(7): 243–63. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 32. Bolívar-Mejía A, Rodríguez-Morales AJ, Paniz-Mondolfi AE, et al.: Manifestaciones
cardiovasculares de la toxocariasis humana. Arch Cardiol Mex. 2013; 83(2):
120–129. Publisher Full Text 10. Tandale BV, Sathe PS, Arankalle VA, et al.: Systemic involvements and fatalities
during Chikungunya epidemic in India, 2006. J Clin Virol. 2009; 46(2): 145–9. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 33. Lee CH, Teo C, Low AF: Fulminant dengue myocarditis masquerading as acute
myocardial infarction. Int J Cardiol. 2009; 136(3): e69–71. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 11. Economopoulou A, Dominguez M, Helynck B, et al.: Atypical Chikungunya
virus infections: clinical manifestations, mortality and risk factors for severe
disease during the 2005–2006 outbreak on Réunion. Epidemiol Infect. 2009;
137(4): 534–41. 34. Mahmod M, Darul ND, Mokhtar I, et al.: Atrial fibrillation as a complication of
dengue hemorrhagic fever: non-self-limiting manifestation. Int J Infect Dis. 2009; 13(5): e316–18. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text ;
(
)
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 6. Madariaga M, Ticona E, Resurrecion C: Chikungunya: bending over the
Americas and the rest of the world. Braz J Infect Dis. 2016; 20(1): 91–8. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 29. Lemant J, Boisson V, Winer A, et al.: Serious acute chikungunya virus infection
requiring intensive care during the Reunion Island outbreak in 2005–2006. Crit
Care Med. 2008; 36(9): 2536–41. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 7. Vega-Rúa A, Schmitt C, Bonne I, et al.: Chikungunya Virus Replication in
Salivary Glands of the Mosquito Aedes albopictus. Viruses. 2015; 7(11): 5902–7. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 30. Kühl U, Pauschinger M, Noutsias M, et al.: High Prevalence of Viral Genomes
and Multiple Viral Infections in the Myocardium of Adults With “Idiopathic” Left
Ventricular Dysfunction. Circulation. 2005; 111(7): 887–93. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 8. Villamil-Gómez W, Alba-Silvera L, Menco-Ramos A, et al.: Congenital
Chikungunya Virus Infection in Sincelejo, Colombia: A Case Series. J Trop
Pediatr. 2015; 61(5): 386–92. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 31. Mendoza I, Morr I, Mendoza I, et al.: Chikungunya myocarditis: an emerging
threat to America. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2015; 65(10): A946. Publisher Full Text Grant information The author(s) declared that no grants were involved in supporting
this work. Supplementary material
Supplementary file 1: PRISMA checklist. Click here to access the data. Supplementary file 2: PRISMA flowchart showing the number of records identified, included and excluded. Click here to access the data. Supplementary material pp
y
Supplementary file 1: PRISMA checklist. lementary file 2: PRISMA flowchart showing the number of records identified, included and excluded. Click here to access the data. Page 11 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 ( )
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 12. Sam IC, Kamarulzaman A, Ong GS, et al.: Chikungunya virus-associated death
in Malaysia. Trop Biomed. 2010; 27(2): 343–7. PubMed Abstract 35. Hidalgo-Zambrano DM, Jiménez-Canizales CE, Alzate-Piedrahita JA, et al.:
Electrocardiographic changes in patients with chikungunya fever. Rev Panam
Infectol. 2016; 18(1): 13–5. Reference Source 13. Chusri S, Siripaitoon P, Hirunpat S, et al.: Case reports of neuro-Chikungunya in
southern Thailand. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2011; 85(2): 386–9. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 36. Wali JP, Biswas A, Chandra S, et al.: Cardiac involvement in Dengue
Haemorrhagic Fever. Int J Cardiol. 1998; 64(1): 31–6. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 14. Torres JR, Leopoldo Códova G, Castro JS, et al.: Chikungunya fever: Atypical
and lethal cases in the Western hemisphere: A Venezuelan experience. IDCases. 2014; 2(1): 6–10. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 37. Kularatne SA, Pathirage MM, Kumarasiri PV, et al.: Cardiac complications of a
dengue fever outbreak in Sri Lanka, 2005. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2007;
101(8): 804–8. ( )
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 15. Hoz JM, Bayona B, Viloria S, et al.: Fatal cases of Chikungunya virus infection in
Colombia: Diagnostic and treatment challenges. J Clin Virol. 2015; 69: 27–9. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 38. Patil DR, Hundekar SL, Arankalle VA: Expression profile of immune response
genes during acute myopathy induced by chikungunya virus in a mouse
model. Microbes Infect. 2012; 14(5): 457–69. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 16. Chua HH, Abdul Rashid K, Law WC, et al.: A fatal case of chikungunya virus
infection with liver involvement. Med J Malaysia. 2010; 65(1): 83–4. PubMed Abstract 39. Lee IK, Lee WH, Liu JW, et al.: Acute myocarditis in dengue hemorrhagic fever:
a case report and review of cardiac complications in dengue-affected patients. Int J Infect Dis. 2010; 14(10): e919–22. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 17. Mahendradas P, Avadhani K, Shetty R: Chikungunya and the eye: a review. J Ophthalmic Inflamm Infect. 2013; 3(1): 35. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 40. Villamil-Gómez WE, Ramirez-Vallejo E, Cardona-Ospina JA, et al.:
Electrocardiographic alterations in patients with chikungunya fever from
Sucre, Colombia: A 42-case series. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2016; 14(5): 510–2. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 18. Simon F, Paule P, Oliver M: Chikungunya virus-induced myopericarditis: toward
an increase of dilated cardiomyopathy in countries with epidemics? Am J Trop
Med Hyg. 2008; 78(2): 212–3. PubMed Abstract 41. Torres JR: Severe and fatal chikungunya fever in the Americas. Hotel RIU Plaza,
Panama City. April 20 to 23, 2016. 5th Pan-American Dengue Research Network
Meeting; Panama. 2016; 66, Access date: May 1, 2016. Reference Source 19. Obeyesekere I, Hermon Y: Arbovirus heart disease: myocarditis and
cardiomyopathy following dengue and chikungunya fever--a follow-up study. Am Heart J. 1973; 85(2): 186–94. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text References virus acute infection in the Island of La Réunion during the 2005–2006
outbreak. PLoS One. 2009; 4(10): e7603. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text virus acute infection in the Island of La Réunion during the 2005–2006
outbreak. PLoS One. 2009; 4(10): e7603. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 25. Maity P, Roy P, Basu A, et al.: A case of ADEM following Chikungunya fever. J Assoc Physicians India. 2014; 62(5): 441–2. PubMed Abstract 2. Zuluaga M, Isaza D: El virus Chikungunya en Colombia: aspectos clínicos y
epidemiológicos y revisión de la literatura. Iatreia. 2016; 29(1): 65–74. Publisher Full Text 26. Chandak NH, Kashyap RS, Kabra D, et al.: Neurological complications of
Chikungunya virus infection. Neurol India. 2009; 57(2): 177–80. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 3. Couderc T, Lecuit M: Chikungunya virus pathogenesis: From bedside to bench. Antiviral Res. 2015; 121: 120–31. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 27. Gérardin P, Couderc T, Bintner M, et al.: Chikungunya virus–associated
encephalitis: A cohort study on La Réunion Island, 2005–2009. Neurology. 2016; 86(1): 94–102. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 4. Simon F, Javelle E, Oliver M, et al.: Chikungunya virus infection. Curr Infect Dis
Rep. 2011; 13(3): 218–28. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 5. Moro ML, Grilli E, Corvetta A, et al.: Long-term chikungunya infection clinical
manifestations after an outbreak in Italy: a prognostic cohort study. J Infect. 2012; 65(2): 165–72. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 28. Menon PR, Krishnan C, Sankar J, et al.: A child with serious Chikungunya virus
(CHIKV) infection requiring intensive care, after an outbreak. Indian J Pediatr. 2010; 77(11): 1326–8. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 177 179.
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 53. Culquichicón C, Cardona-Ospina JA, Patiño-Barbosa AM, et al.: Bibliometric
analysis of Oropouche research: impact on the surveillance of emerging
arboviruses in Latin America [version 1; referees: 2 approved]. F1000Res. 2017; 6: 194. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text
47. Arzuza-Ortega L, Polo A, Pérez-Tatis G, et al.: Fatal Sickle Cell Disease and Zika
Virus Infection in Girl from Colombia. Emerg Infect Dis. 2016; 22(5):
925–927. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text
48. Sarmiento-Ospina A, Vásquez-Serna H, Jimenez-Canizales CE, et al.: Zika virus
associated deaths in Colombia. Lancet Infect Dis. 2016; 16(5): 523–524. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text
49. Krittanawong C, Zhang H, Sun T: Cardiovascular complications after Zika virus
infection. Int J Cardiol. 2016; 221: 859. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text
50. Patiño-Barbosa AM, Bedoya-Arias JE, Cardona-Ospina JA, et al.: Bibliometric
assessment of the scientific production of literature regarding Mayaro. J Infect
Public Health. 2016; 9(4): 532–534. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text
51. Paniz-Mondolfi AE, Rodriguez-Morales AJ, Blohm G, et al.: ChikDenMaZika
Syndrome: the challenge of diagnosing arboviral infections in the midst of
concurrent epidemics. Ann Clin Microbiol Antimicrob. 2016; 15(1): 42. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 47. Arzuza-Ortega L, Polo A, Pérez-Tatis G, et al.: Fatal Sickle Cell Disease and Zika
Virus Infection in Girl from Colombia. Emerg Infect Dis. 2016; 22(5):
925–927. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text ( )
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text
56. Rodriguez-Morales AJ: Aspectos agudos y crónicos de la infección por virus
chikungunya: aun aprendiendo. Actualizaciones en SIDA e Infectología. 2016;
24(93): 98–104. Reference Source
57. Torres JR, Murillo J, Bofill L: The ever changing landscape of Zika virus
infection. Learning on the fly. Int J Infect Dis. 2016; 51: 123–126. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 46. Rodríguez-Morales AJ, Villamil-Gómez WE, Franco-Paredes C: The arboviral
burden of disease caused by co-circulation and co-infection of dengue,
chikungunya and Zika in the Americas. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2016; 14(3):
177–179. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 52. Rodríguez-Morales AJ, Paniz-Mondolfi AE, Villamil-Gómez WE, et al.: Mayaro,
Oropouche and Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis viruses: following in the
footsteps of Zika? Travel Med Infect Dis. 2017; 15: 72–73. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text ;
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 54. Ortiz-Martinez Y, Villamil-Gómez WE, Rodríguez-Morales AJ: Bibliometric
assessment of global research on Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis: a latent
threat for the Americas. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2017; 15: 78–79. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 48. Sarmiento-Ospina A, Vásquez-Serna H, Jimenez-Canizales CE, et al.: Zika virus
associated deaths in Colombia. Lancet Infect Dis. 2016; 16(5): 523–524. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 49. Krittanawong C, Zhang H, Sun T: Cardiovascular complications after Zika virus
infection. Int J Cardiol. 2016; 221: 859. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 55. Paniz-Mondolfi AE, Blohm G, Piñero R, et al.: Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis:
how likely are we to see the next epidemic? Travel Med Infect Dis. 2017;
pii: S1477-8939(17)30030-3. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 50. Patiño-Barbosa AM, Bedoya-Arias JE, Cardona-Ospina JA, et al.: Bibliometric
assessment of the scientific production of literature regarding Mayaro. J Infect
Public Health. 2016; 9(4): 532–534. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text p
(
)
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 56. Rodriguez-Morales AJ: Aspectos agudos y crónicos de la infección por virus
chikungunya: aun aprendiendo. Actualizaciones en SIDA e Infectología. 2016;
24(93): 98–104. Reference Source 51. Paniz-Mondolfi AE, Rodriguez-Morales AJ, Blohm G, et al.: ChikDenMaZika
Syndrome: the challenge of diagnosing arboviral infections in the midst of
concurrent epidemics. Ann Clin Microbiol Antimicrob. 2016; 15(1): 42. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 ( )
PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 42. Wiwanitkit V: Dengue myocarditis, rare but not fatal manifestation. Int J Cardiol. 2006; 112(1): 122. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 20. Obeyesekere I, Hermon Y: Myocarditis and cardiomyopathy after arbovirus
infections (dengue and chikungunya fever). Br Heart J. 1972; 34(8): 821–7. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 43. WHO: Chikungunya: case definitions for acute, atypical and chronic cases. Conclusions of an expert consultation, Managua, Nicaragua, 20–21 May 2015. Wkly Epidemiol Rec. 2015; 90(33): 410–4. PubMed Abstract 21. Nagaratnam N, Siripala K, de Silva N: Arbovirus (dengue type) as a cause of
acute myocarditis and pericarditis. Br Heart J. 1973; 35(2): 204–6. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text 22. Mirabel M, Vignaux O, Lebon P, et al.: Acute myocarditis due to Chikungunya
virus assessed by contrast-enhanced MRI. Int J Cardiol. 2007; 121(1): e7–8. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 44. Rodríguez-Morales AJ: Zika: the new arbovirus threat for Latin America. J Infect
Dev Ctries. 2015; 9(6): 684–685. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 23. Rajapakse S, Rodrigo C, Rajapakse A: Atypical manifestations of chikungunya
infection. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2010; 104(2): 89–96. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 45. Martinez-Pulgarin DF, Acevedo-Mendoza WF, Cardona-Ospina JA, et al.: A
bibliometric analysis of global Zika research. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2016; 14(1):
55–57. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text 24. Staikowsky F, Talarmin F, Grivard P, et al.: Prospective study of Chikungunya Page 12 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 52. Rodríguez-Morales AJ, Paniz-Mondolfi AE, Villamil-Gómez WE, et al.: Mayaro,
Oropouche and Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis viruses: following in the
footsteps of Zika? Travel Med Infect Dis. 2017; 15: 72–73. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text
53. Culquichicón C, Cardona-Ospina JA, Patiño-Barbosa AM, et al.: Bibliometric
analysis of Oropouche research: impact on the surveillance of emerging
arboviruses in Latin America [version 1; referees: 2 approved]. F1000Res. 2017; 6: 194. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text | Free Full Text
54. Ortiz-Martinez Y, Villamil-Gómez WE, Rodríguez-Morales AJ: Bibliometric
assessment of global research on Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis: a latent
threat for the Americas. Travel Med Infect Dis. 2017; 15: 78–79. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text
55. Paniz-Mondolfi AE, Blohm G, Piñero R, et al.: Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis:
how likely are we to see the next epidemic? Travel Med Infect Dis. 2017;
pii: S1477-8939(17)30030-3. Open Peer Review Current Referee Status: Current Referee Status: (
)
Reference Source 57. Torres JR, Murillo J, Bofill L: The ever changing landscape of Zika virus
infection. Learning on the fly. Int J Infect Dis. 2016; 51: 123–126. PubMed Abstract | Publisher Full Text Page 13 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 doi:10.5256/f1000research.11949.r21386 doi:10.5256/f1000research.11949.r21386 Version 1 25 April 2017
Referee Report Cecilia Perret Cec
a
e e
División de Pediatría, Departamento de Enfermedades Infecciosas e Inmunología Pediátricas, Escuela de
Medicina, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile General comment This is a very interesting article that compiles information relevant to an emerging and widely
disseminated infection in the American continent whose complications are still under study and its impact
still to be known. This is a very interesting article that compiles information relevant to an emerging and widely
disseminated infection in the American continent whose complications are still under study and its impact
still to be known. Specifically, there are some aspects of the review that need to be considered:
Objectives: Specifically, there are some aspects of the review that need to be considered:
Objectives: j
- Clearly specified focusing on the cardiovascular involvement of Chikungunya virus infection, frequency
of presentation, clinical manifestations and laboratory elements such as the electrocardiogram j
- Clearly specified focusing on the cardiovascular involvement of Chikungunya virus infection, frequency
of presentation, clinical manifestations and laboratory elements such as the electrocardiogram - Clearly specified focusing on the cardiovascular involvement of Chikungunya virus infecti
of presentation, clinical manifestations and laboratory elements such as the electrocardiog Methodology Methodology - Articles published in French have been left out, which could be a limitation considering that the largest
series of cases and their complications came from France in relation to the big outbreak on La Reunion
island, and many of them published in French. - The search criteria are wide: Chikungunya AND systemic manifestations, heart, cardiac. However, with
these criteria, you could lose some reports of severe disease that do not appear under these search
criteria. Chikungunya AND mortality or Death could be included. Also, more specific criteria could be used
in order to answer the question the authors propose to find cardiovascular involvement in Chikungunya
infection - The inclusion of dengue in the search and in the results escapes the objectives of this sys There is no reference to the use of PRISMA checklist in this review, if it was used, make it more explicit in
each of the items. There is no reference to the use of PRISMA checklist in this review, if it was used, make it more explicit in
each of the items. Results It is confusing and difficult to follow what results are obtained from the systematic
i l
)
d
h
l
f
i l
i
l d d i
h
i It is confusing and difficult to follow what results are obtained from the systematic review (40
articles) and what results are from articles not included in the review. articles) and what results are from articles not included in the review. Table 1, which shows the frequency of the involvement of different organs in chikungunya can be
absolutely biased since the inclusion criteria are articles with systemic involvement. According to
the search criteria, the classical form of the disease has not been included overestimating the
frequency of systemic involvement. q
y
y
It is not clear what criteria you used to classify an organ involvement as very common or extremely
rare. According to the authors, an unusual manifestation occurs between 39-20%. This could be
debatable. Th
li i
l d
i ti
f th di
i t
f
t
t
t
d h
i
h
i i
l
t It is not clear what criteria you used to classify an organ involvement as very common or extremely
rare. According to the authors, an unusual manifestation occurs between 39-20%. This could be
debatable. Methodology Page 14 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 debatab e
The clinical description of the disease in terms of acute, post-acute and chronic phase is irrelevant
for the purposes of this review. Just mention the clinical aspects that are important for the
objectives. In this sense, clarify the terms used as atypical manifestations, extra-articular
manifestations, systemic disease, severe disease. They are used sometimes as synonyms and
sometimes with a different meaning. It is confusing. It is difficult to understand why in table 1,
cardiovascular manifestations are as frequent as 54% but does not appear to be so in the text of
atypical presentations. The entire section of cardiovascular manifestations in dengue goes beyond the purpose of the
study and should not be mentioned in the results. Comparisons with the cardiovascular
compromise in chikungunya, which is appreciated, can be presented in the discussion. At the end of results and before management, the paragraph of studies determining the
cardiovascular outcome in patients with chikungunya should be included in conclusions. Discussion
It is not clear the meaning of the phrase cardiac compromise is not so common in isolated episodes. The authors do not clearly indicate the home take messages for this study and its main contribution. Limitations: authors do not mention the limitations of their study. Conclusions: Do not correspond to purpose of the study or objectives. Limitations: authors do not mention the limitations of their study. Conclusions: Do not correspond to purpose of the study or objectives. References
In the references, it is not clear what are the articles included in the systematic review and what are
included for discussion. References
In the references, it is not clear what are the articles included in the systematic review and what are
included for discussion. In the references, it is not clear what are the articles included in the systematic review and what are
included for discussion. Are the rationale for, and objectives of, the Systematic Review clearly stated? Yes
Are sufficient details of the methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? Partly
Is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? Not applicable
Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results presented in the review? No
No competing interests were disclosed. Competing Interests:
Referee Expertise: Tropical and Travel Medicine. Viral emerging diseases
I have read this submission. Methodology I believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm th
it is of an acceptable scientific standard, however I have significant reservations, as outlined
above. Author Response 26 Apr 2017
, Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira, Colombia
Alfonso Rodriguez-Morales
Dear Dr. Perret
Thanks for your valuable comments. Certainly the topic of this systematic review (without Are the rationale for, and objectives of, the Systematic Review clearly stated?
Yes Page 15 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 Thanks for your valuable comments. Certainly the topic of this systematic review (without
meta-analysis), is on ongoing findings that in the near future will be better defined. Regard your
assessment, unfortunately this arrived when two others reviews ago had been submitted; based on
them, we have recently proceeded to develop the new revised version. Your comments are
consistent with those from Dr. Vilcarromero in a significant magnitude. Then, most of your
comments are addressed in the revised version of the paper, including clarification on the
objectives as well on the Methodology (explaining more the search criteria as well the clarification
regard the use of PRISMA checklist and flow diagram). Regard the language of articles included,
we agree that this would be a limitation. Limitations are now better described in the new version of
the article. As we explained, dengue cardiovascular compromise and manifestations was a
necessary comparison for understanding of readers. In the new version, Discussion and
Conclusions were improved. None.
Competing Interests: 18 April 2017
Referee Report 18 April 2017
Referee Report doi:10.5256/f1000research.11949.r21382 doi:10.5256/f1000research.11949.r21382 Stalin Vilcarromero1,2 Instead of that, why do not
they also use specific “key words” such as: “Chikungunya AND cardiac involvement”
“Chikungunya AND cardiac complication” or “Chikungunya AND cardiovascular involvement”
“Chikungunya AND cardiovascular complications” or Chikungunya AND Atypical
manifestation/complications“. The idea is to be more specific and less general. 4. According to the authors, the protocol was registered in PROSPERO; however it was not possible
to view the registered protocol in the web 4. According to the authors, the protocol was registered in PROSPERO; however it was not possible
to view the registered protocol in the web
(https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/searchadvanced.php). (https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/searchadvanced.php). 5. I wonder if the inclusion of reviews may cause a bias. Please clarify and if it is true, consider in the
“limitations section”. 5. I wonder if the inclusion of reviews may cause a bias. Please clarify and if it is true, consider in the
“limitations section”. 1. Authors use “cardiac affectation” and also “cardiovascular compromise”. I recommend to
standardize the term in order to avoid creating confusion for the reader. 2. Authors describe with detail the clinical features during the acute, post-acute and chronic
stage of CHIKV infection. I recommend shortening and focusing on the topic. 3. In “Atypical presentation” section, authors shows systemic manifestation considering the
affectation in different organs such as neurological, cardiovascular, etc. Why did not the
authors use also the key word “atypical” rather than “systemic manifestation” or
“extra-articular” in the searching strategy and also in the analyses? It is confusing. 4. In Table 2, the word “Systemic extra-articular involvement of atypical CHIKV” shows clinical
manifestation, however, we do not know more information about “who (co-morbidities? Older? Young?)”, “how many”(number/percentage), type of paper(case report, case control,
etc), etc. Are these clinical manifestations in outpatients or inpatients? Are these early
clinical features or complications? So there are many questions around this information that
would be useful in order to form a correct interpretation. 5. In Table 3, it is important to consider more information about the selected papers. I
recommend a big table showing the different cardiovascular involvement/complication, for
example: 1. the clinical diagnoses (heart failure, acute coronary syndrome, refractory shock,
and rhythm abnormalities), relevant signs and symptoms, especially early signs/symptoms
(chest pain, dyspnea, bradycardia, etc), laboratory diagnose (Troponin, BNP, CK-MB, etc),
Imaging studies (echocardiography, Magnetic resonance), final diagnose (Myocarditis?),
Management (inotropics, corticosteroid, etc) and outcome (survive, died). Stalin Vilcarromero1,2 Stalin Vilcarromero
Sociedad Científica de Estudiantes de Medicina de la Amazonía Peruana (SOCIEMAP), Facultad de
Medicina, Universidad Nacional de la Amazonía Peruana, Iquitos, Peru
Naval Medical Research Unit № 6, Lima & Iquitos, Peru
1
2 Sociedad Científica de Estudiantes de Medicina de la Amazonía Peruana (SOC
1 Medicina, Universidad Nacional de la Amazonía Peruana, Iquitos, Peru Naval Medical Research Unit № 6, Lima & Iquitos, Peru
2 In the manuscript entitled “Cardiovascular involvement and manifestations of systemic Chikungunya virus
infection: A systematic review” authors have made a hard and interesting description of the
cardiovascular effect by chikungunya virus infection. This analysis would be important to share with the
scientific community; however it is necessary major changes in order to be ready for publication. Mainly, focus in the specific topic and put in order and properly the information in the paper. General comments: 1. Objective:
It s not clear, author start assessing that the objective focus among cardiovascular involvement and
manifestation, however, other systemic manifestation or atypical manifestation also become relevant in
the results section. 1. Methodology 1. The main objective of systematic reviews is to respond to a specific question. Initially authors seem
to do that pointing on cardiovascular involvement, but then, when they write the introduction and
results section, this main point seem to disappear or is not clear for the reader. However, in the
discussion section, authors re-take the objectives again. Certainly, the big amount of information
given in the introduction section and talking about the virus, history, classification, vector and
cycles is very interesting, but it is not the purpose of this study. I suggest them shortening it and
focussing on the cardiovascular involvement and complications. I also recommend displaying a
flow (figure) of how papers were excluded and included. 2. ( g
)
p p
What guideline do the authors follow up in order to assess the risk of bias (PRISMA or Cochrane? It is possible you follow PRISMA approach (For example:
). Please give this information
http://prisma-statement.org/PRISMAStatement/Checklist.aspx
explaining the steps. Page 16 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 3. In the Methods section, the next key word “Chikungunya AND Systemic AND Manifestation” used
by authors has probably given them no specific references or papers. 8. F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 cardiogénico shock, arrhythmia, etc) and the management of the inflammatory process. The
last, is under discussion and needs more research, although in some severe cases by
DENV, the corticosteroids administration changed the evolution. cardiogénico shock, arrhythmia, etc) and the management of the inflammatory process. The
last, is under discussion and needs more research, although in some severe cases by
DENV, the corticosteroids administration changed the evolution. 2. Discussion
Authors say, “The key for a successful outcome of CHIKV-induced cardiomyopathy is recognizing signs
and symptoms”. Here I recommend repeating the most important ones. 2. Discussion
Authors say, “The key for a successful outcome of CHIKV-induced cardiomyopathy is recognizing signs
and symptoms”. Here I recommend repeating the most important ones. 1. Limitations
This section would consider some of the bias common to this kind of study where there is no clinical trials
included and where “case reports” were including. Bias such as “selection” or
“publication” bias, etc. 1. Limitations
This section would consider some of the bias common to this kind of study where there is no clinical trials
included and where “case reports” were including. Bias such as “selection” or
“publication” bias, etc. Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results presented in the review?
Partly No competing interests were disclosed. Competing Interests: Stalin Vilcarromero1,2 I consider, this
data would be important to understand the impact of cardiovascular involvement due to
CHIKV. 6. In dengue, now it is known that more about the cardiovascular involvement is mostly
characterized by rhythm abnormalities (bradycardia) with no symptoms or complications. However, in moderate or severe cases where there was a cardiovascular affectation or
complication, myocarditis has been an important cause. Myocarditis due to DENV infection
may present several patterns such as “refractory shock”, “heart failure”, “arrhythmia”, etc
and It would be important to consider this diagnose. In the comparison with CHIKV infection
and cardiac involvement, myocarditis, should be discussed. It is not clear what do authors
try to assess when they say: “The cardiac tropism of CHIKV seem to be shared with DENV”,
it is important to clarify. 7. Diagnose myocarditis by those arbovirus, need to consider a myocardial biopsy or a cardiac
magnetic resonance, however performing these in tropical areas where these arbovirus are
prevalent, is very hard. 8. The management of myocarditis, whatever is the etiology, focus in the management of the
agent (virus, bacteria, etc); management of the cardiovascular event (heart failure, 8. The management of myocarditis, whatever is the etiology, focus in the management of the
agent (virus, bacteria, etc); management of the cardiovascular event (heart failure, Page 17 of 22 8. No competing interests were disclosed.
Competing Interests: Referee Expertise: epidemiology and clinic of Arbovirus infection I have read this submission. I believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that
it is of an acceptable scientific standard, however I have significant reservations, as outlined
above. Author Response 19 Apr 2017 , Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira, Colombia
Alfonso Rodriguez-Morales The main objective of systematic reviews is to respond to a specific question. The main objective of systematic reviews is to respond to a specific question. In our case, to three specific questions, with the proper context to make it readable and
understandable given the novelty of the topic, as mentioned, also with ongoing research in multiple
aspects. Initially authors seem to do that pointing on cardiovascular involvement, but then, when
they write the introduction and results section, this main point seem to disappear or is not
clear for the reader. From the title it's clear that this SR is not only about the cardiovascular involvement, but also about
cardiovascular manifestations of chikungunya. Nevertheless, we will make more clarifications on
our Introduction regarding this. manifestation also become relevant in the results section. manifestation also become relevant in the results section. Our SR has as objectives, not just one: -To systematically review published literature on the cardiovascular manifestations and
involvement of systemic CHIKV infection; -To systematically review published literature on the cardiovascular manifestations and
involvement of systemic CHIKV infection; -To explore which are the main clinical cardiovascular features of chikungunya infection? -To identify which are the main electrocardiographical findings of chikungunya infection? All of them, are clearly developed in the section Synthesis of Results, which is the main part of the
SR. -To identify which are the main electrocardiographical findings of chikungunya infection? All of them, are clearly developed in the section Synthesis of Results, which is the main part of the
SR. Before that section, a brief introduction on other systemic manifestation or atypical manifestation of
chikungunya infection is at Clinical Course, short section of just 3 paragraphs and atypical
presentations, a section of just 2 paragraphs, which include, by the way, the transition to the
cardiovascular aspects, developed in the section Synthesis of Results and later sections of the SR. Dear Dr. Vilcarromero Dear Dr. Vilcarromero First, thanks for your initial comments on our systematic review (SR) (without meta-analysis). In
second place we want to clarify that making for the first time a SR about cardiovascular
involvement and manifestations of systemic Chikungunya virus infection implies comparisons with
dengue, unavoidably, as well, to introduce readers about the systemic manifestations of
chikungunya, to better understand the cardiovascular involvement and manifestations in this
arboviral disease. By the way, still on this specific topic, many aspects will become more detailed
along with research in the near future. In which our group is specifically also contributing with
studies, already published on the cardiovascular electrocardiographical alterations, as well
ongoing on the ecochardiographical and cardiovascular biochemical ones. j
It s not clear, author start assessing that the objective focus among cardiovascular
involvement and manifestation, however, other systemic manifestation or atypical
if
i
i
i Page 18 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 manifestation also become relevant in the results section. However, in the discussion section, authors re-take the objectives again.
Ok. Thanks. Certainly, the big amount of information given in the introduction section and talking
about the virus, history, classification, vector and cycles is very interesting, but it is not
the purpose of this study. This is not properly a study, it is a SR, without meta-analysis. Then, we consider, given the still
novelty of the topic, such aspects are necessary for the readers. According to the authors, the protocol was registered in PROSPERO; however it was not
possible to view the registered protocol in the web
(https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/searchadvanced.php). We agree with you. This protocol was not prospectively registered in PROSPERO. But this is not a
mandatory aspect for publication at F1000 Research, then this was modified later, but when
published appeared with that incorrect comment. This will be deleted in the revised version. I wonder if the inclusion of reviews may cause a bias. Please clarify and if it is true
consider in the “limitations section”. We will extend more on our Limitations. I suggest them shortening it and focussing on the cardiovascular involvement and
complications. We have done that at Synthesis of Results and later sections of the SR. I also recommend displaying a flow (figure) of how papers were excluded and included. With our submission we provided the PRISMA Flow Chart and Checklist. However, this was not
published by the journal with our article. Considering its importance and agreeing with you about it,
we will incorporate as a Figure 1 and including properly in the manuscript, and not as
supplementary file of our submission. What guideline do the authors follow up in order to assess the risk of bias (PRISMA or
Cochrane? It is possible you follow PRISMA approach (For example:
http://prisma-statement.org/PRISMAStatement/Checklist.aspx). Please give this
information explaining the steps. Page 19 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 We followed the PRISMA statement, as recommended by F1000 Research. We will clarify more on
this in our revised manuscript. In the Methods section, the next key word “Chikungunya AND Systemic AND
Manifestation” used by authors has probably given them no specific references or papers. Instead of that, why do not they also use specific “key words” such as: “Chikungunya
AND cardiac involvement” “Chikungunya AND cardiac complication” or “Chikungunya
AND cardiovascular involvement” “Chikungunya AND cardiovascular complications” or
Chikungunya AND Atypical manifestation/complications“. The idea is to be more specific
and less general. Given the lack of studies, we explore both options, finally trying to be more sensitive in order to
include all the possibly relevant studies related to our SR. According to the authors, the protocol was registered in PROSPERO; however it was not
possible to view the registered protocol in the web
(h
//
d
k
k/
/
h d
d
h ) Results Authors use “cardiac affectation” and also “cardiovascular compromise”. I recommend to
standardize the term in order to avoid creating confusion for the reader. Agree, we will use only "compromise" and not "affectation". Authors describe with detail the clinical features during the acute, post-acute and chronic
stage of CHIKV infection. I recommend shortening and focusing on the topic. We will consider this in the revised version. In “Atypical presentation” section, authors shows systemic manifestation considering the
affectation in different organs such as neurological, cardiovascular, etc. Why did not the
authors use also the key word “atypical” rather than “systemic manifestation” or
“extra-articular” in the searching strategy and also in the analyses? It is confusing. In chikungunya, the definition of systemic manifestation or extra-articular has not well typified. Conversely, atypical case was defined by PAHO/WHO during the expert consultation meeting in
Managua, Nicaragua, 2016, and later published at the Weekly Epidemiological Record of the WHO
14 august 2015, 90, 33, 409-420. We will clarify this in our revised version. In Table 2, the word “Systemic extra-articular involvement of atypical CHIKV” shows
clinical manifestation, however, we do not know more information about “who
(co-morbidities? Older? Young?)”, “how many”(number/percentage), type of paper(case
report, case control, etc), etc. Are these clinical manifestations in outpatients or
inpatients? Are these early clinical features or complications? So there are many
questions around this information that would be useful in order to form a correct
interpretation. In Table 2, the word “Systemic extra-articular involvement of atypical CHIKV” shows
clinical manifestation, however, we do not know more information about “who
(co-morbidities? Older? Young?)”, “how many”(number/percentage), type of paper(case
report, case control, etc), etc. Are these clinical manifestations in outpatients or
inpatients? Are these early clinical features or complications? So there are many
questions around this information that would be useful in order to form a correct
interpretation. Page 20 of 22 F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 We will consider the improvement of this Table. In Table 3, it is important to consider more information about the selected papers. I
recommend a big table showing the different cardiovascular involvement/complication,
for example: 1. Results the clinical diagnoses (heart failure, acute coronary syndrome, refractory
shock, and rhythm abnormalities), relevant signs and symptoms, especially early
signs/symptoms (chest pain, dyspnea, bradycardia, etc), laboratory diagnose (Troponin,
BNP, CK-MB, etc), Imaging studies (echocardiography, Magnetic resonance), final
diagnose (Myocarditis?), Management (inotropics, corticosteroid, etc) and outcome
(survive, died). I consider, this data would be important to understand the impact of
cardiovascular involvement due to CHIKV. Unfortunately the number of papers as well the data available is limited to fully performed that,
although was discussed by the group of authors of this SR. Nevertheless, we will consider your
comment to improve this Table. In dengue, now it is known that more about the cardiovascular involvement is mostly
characterized by rhythm abnormalities (bradycardia) with no symptoms or complications. However, in moderate or severe cases where there was a cardiovascular affectation or
complication, myocarditis has been an important cause. Myocarditis due to DENV
infection may present several patterns such as “refractory shock”, “heart failure”,
“arrhythmia”, etc and It would be important to consider this diagnose. In the comparison
with CHIKV infection and cardiac involvement, myocarditis, should be discussed. It is not
clear what do authors try to assess when they say: “The cardiac tropism of CHIKV seem to
be shared with DENV”, it is important to clarify. Thanks for this comment. We will use it in the revised version. Diagnose myocarditis by those arbovirus, need to consider a myocardial biopsy or a
cardiac magnetic resonance, however performing these in tropical areas where these
arbovirus are prevalent, is very hard. p
,
y
We fully agree with this. The management of myocarditis, whatever is the etiology, focus in the management of the
agent (virus, bacteria, etc); management of the cardiovascular event (heart failure,
cardiogénico shock, arrhythmia, etc) and the management of the inflammatory process. The last, is under discussion and needs more research, although in some severe cases by
DENV, the corticosteroids administration changed the evolution. We fully agree with this. Discussion
Authors say, “The key for a successful outcome of CHIKV-induced cardiomyopathy is
recognizing signs and symptoms”. Here I recommend repeating the most important ones. Ok. Agree. F1000Research 2017, 6:390 Last updated: 02 MAY 2017 doi:10.5256/f1000research.11949.r21381 doi:10.5256/f1000research.11949.r21381 None.
Competing Interests: 18 April 2017
Referee Report 18 April 2017
Referee Report José Antonio Suárez Unidad Clínica de Enfermedades Tropicales, Instituto Conmemorativo Gorgas de Estudios de la Salud,
Panama, Panama Unidad Clínica de Enfermedades Tropicales, Instituto Conmemorativo Gorgas de Estudios de la Salud,
Panama, Panama Cardiovascular involvement in CHIKV disease has been described in several publication highlighting a
possible cardiac tropism of CHIKV. This findings have shown that arboviruses like CHIKV and Dengue
can share with parvovirus 19, herpes virus and enterovirus30 and other viruses, the list of the viral causes
of heart damage. This study helps the understanding of cardiovascular manifestations and complications in all 3 stages of
CHICK disease and it gives the physician the awareness of thinking in arbovirus-related diseases to make
the accurate diagnosis and avoid fatalities. Once the physician thinks in CHIKV, the patient should have a
cardiac assessment as early as possible, especially in countries where CHIKV is epidemic. From study design, methods and analysis points of view, the authors complied with all PRISMA and
PROSPERO criteria for a Systematic Review showing a robust data and good conclusions. In Latin America where other arboviruses are co-circulating with CHIKV and Dengue, cardiovascular
symptoms can be the first signal of a viral infection. The content of this Systematic Review can help tropical medicine and travel medicine physicians to have
a better approach in the assessment of patients with some arbovirus diseases. The content of this Systematic Review can help tropical medicine and travel medicine physicians to have
a better approach in the assessment of patients with some arbovirus diseases. No competing interests were disclosed. Competing Interests: Limitations This section would consider some of the bias common to this kind of study where there is
no clinical trials included and where “case reports” were including. Bias such as
“selection” or “publication” bias, etc. We will comment more on that. Page 21 of 22 None.
Competing Interests: No competing interests were disclosed
Competing Interests: No competing interests were disclosed. nterests: I have read this submission. I believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that
it is of an acceptable scientific standard. Author Response 19 Apr 2017 , Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira, Colombia
Alfonso Rodriguez-Morales , Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira, Colombia
Alfonso Rodriguez-Morales , Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira, Colombia
Alfonso Rodriguez-Morales
Dear Dr. Suárez Dear Dr. Suárez Thanks for your assessment as well your positive comments on our review, which as can be
appreciated after reviewing major bibliographical databases, such as Scopus, PubMed and/or
Web of Science, is probably the first to address specifically the cardiovascular involvement and
manifestations of systemic Chikungunya virus infection. None. Competing Interests: Page 22 of 22
|
https://openalex.org/W2914294763
|
http://ij-aquaticbiology.com/index.php/ijab/article/download/483/459
|
English
| null |
The alwathba wetland reserve lake in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates and its ostracod (seed shrimp) fauna
|
DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals)
| 2,018
|
cc-by
| 6,089
|
g
The Al Wathba Wetland Reserve Lake in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates and its
ostracod (seed shrimp) fauna Anitha Saji *1, Steffen Mischke2, Pritpal S. Soorae1, Shakeel Ahmed1, Shaikha Al Dh 1Environment Agency Abu Dhabi (EAD), United Arab Emirates. 2Faculty of Earth Sciences, University of Iceland, Sturlugata 7, Askja, 101 Reykjavík, Iceland. Article history:
Received 26 July 2018
Accepted 4 January 2019
Available online 5 January 2019 s
Abstract: Al Wathba Wetland Reserve (AWWR) lake, in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), is an
artificially created water body in a natural wetland region that experienced seasonal flooding before
the establishment of the lake. The lake is mostly fed by treated waste water, and became a protected
wetland reserve after the Greater Flamingo started to successfully breed in the area in 1998. Detailed
monitoring of several hydrochemical parameters and water depth at nine stations and two inlets of
treated water in the lake was conducted over a period of seven years starting in January 2010. As a
result, the seed-shrimps (Ostracoda: Podocopida) Heterocypris salina, previously reported from a
late Miocene location in the UAE, and Cyprinotus cingalensis were recorded for the modern fauna
of the UAE for the first time. The presence of the ostracods only at the station with the lowest salinity
in the AWWR Lake shows that their distribution is predominantly controlled by the salinity of the
water which covered an extremely large range of more than two orders of magnitude (1.45-457‰)
at the different sampling sites and inlets during the monitoring period. Thus, the lake represents an
interesting and important ecological research laboratory under semi-natural conditions. Keywords:
Heterocypris salina
Cyprinotus cingalensis
Salinity
Ramsar wetland site Keywords:
Heterocypris salina
Cyprinotus cingalensis
Salinity
Ramsar wetland site An important component of aquatic ecosystems
such as Al Wathba is the micro-crustacean fauna. Among micro-crustaceans, the ostracods form a
widely distributed and diverse group which occupies
all types of aquatic or even semi-aquatic environments
(the ocean, marginal marine settings such as lagoons
and estuaries, saline and freshwater lakes, rivers,
wetlands, springs, wet leaf litter, etc.). The ostracods
have two calcitic valves that enclose the soft body and
form a carapace typically 0.5-2.0 mm long. More than
65,000 living and fossil ostracod taxa at or below the
species level have been described (Kempf, 1997). We
here present a study of a man-made lake in the UAE
with a focus on its spatial and temporal water-
chemistry characteristics and a first record of its
ostracod (micro-crustacean) fauna. Int. J. Aquat. Biol. (2018) 6(5): 265-273
ISSN: 2322-5270; P-ISSN: 2383-0956
Journal homepage: www.ij-aquaticbiology.com
© 2018 Iranian Society of Ichthyology Int. J. Aquat. Biol. (2018) 6(5): 265-273
ISSN: 2322-5270; P-ISSN: 2383-0956
Journal homepage: www.ij-aquaticbiology.com
© 2018 Iranian Society of Ichthyology *Correspondence: Anitha Saji
E-mail: asaji@ead.ae Introduction Terrestrial surface waters are rare in arid regions and
they represent important biodiversity hotspots of the
aquatic and terrestrial flora and fauna, including
migratory birds, amphibians and mammals in lake,
wetland and gallery forest regions. Dryland lakes
often support local fisheries and provide recreational
services. Natural surface waters in western and central
Asia are often endangered due to man-made
hydrological changes such as water withdrawal for
irrigation farming and due to increasingly frequent
extreme weather conditions as a result of global
climate change (Lelieveld et al., 2012). The
desiccation of the Aral Sea, the rapidly falling level of
the Dead Sea and the disappearing Lake Urmia are the
most prominent and serious examples (Micklin, 1988;
Tourian et al., 2015; Willner et al., 2015). Knowledge
of the state of local surface waters in arid regions is
urgently required to understand their ecological and
societal significance, and to assess their vulnerability
to human impacts and global climate change. Materials and Methods Materials and Methods
The Al Wathba Wetland Reserve (AWWR) Lake is
located on the coastal sabkha plain ca. 40 km
southeast of Abu Dhabi Island (Fig. 1). The partly DOI: https://doi.org/10.22034/ijab.v6i5.483 Saji et al./ Al Wathba Wetland in Abu Dhabi and its ostracod fauna 266 Figure 2. Sampling stations ST 1 to 10 and the inlet water valves I
and II of the wastewater treatment plant (WWTP). Ostracods were
exclusively recorded at station 8. Figure 1. Al Wathba Lake in the Al Wathba Wetland Reserve in the
UAE (green dot) and the location of a late Miocene record of the
ostracod Heterocypris salina (triangle). Figure 2. Sampling stations ST 1 to 10 and the inlet water valves I
and II of the wastewater treatment plant (WWTP). Ostracods were
exclusively recorded at station 8. covers ca. 1.6 km² (Al Dhaheri, 2004). The maximum
water depth of the lake is 2.3 m. Figure 1. Al Wathba Lake in the Al Wathba Wetland Reserve in the
UAE (green dot) and the location of a late Miocene record of the
ostracod Heterocypris salina (triangle). The AWWR is managed by the Environment
Agency Abu Dhabi (EAD) and mainly used for
research, education and eco-tourism including bird-
watching today. The salinity of AWWR Lake is
variable due to the fresh water input and the
underlying sabkha substrate. However, most of the
lake is hyperhaline with a mean salinity of ca. 200‰
between 2010 and 2014 (Saji et al., 2016). During the
same period, mean monthly values of water
temperature, pH and dissolved oxygen concentration
ranged from 22.8-35.9°C, 7.0-8.6, and 3.7-7.9 mg L-1,
respectively (Saji et al., 2016). dune-covered sabkha in the lake area lies 15-18 m
above sea level. The region represented a seasonally
flooded wetland with temporarily rising water levels
probably resulting from increasing sub-surface water
flow and hydrostatic pressure from stronger winds and
higher tides in winter (Al Dhaheri, 2004). The
construction of the Mussafah - Al Ain Truck Road
between 1980 and 1984 dammed the southward flow
of surface waters and increased the area and annual
duration of emerging surface waters, and the
abundance of waterfowl. The ecological potential of
the wetland for local birdlife was recognised and
AWWR Lake established as a perennial water body
mostly fed by treated waste water from the Mafraq
Wastewater Treatment Plant, which is the main
sewage treatment plant of the city of Abu Dhabi (Fig. 2). Materials and Methods Water samples were collected within the frame of
an Artemia research programme from nine stations Int. J. Aquat. Biol. (2018) 6(5): 265-273 267 Figure 4. Water depth data for the sampling stations (ST) during the
years 2010 to 2016. Grey vertical bars indicate months during which
water samples were unsuccessfully examined for the presence of
ostracods and orange bars represent months during which ostracods
were present at ST 08. The two horizontal lines at the left show the
water depth range at ST 08 during the monitoring period and the
vertical line in between these lines indicates the water depth range
for the ostracod records at ST 08. ST 08 was dry in March 2014 and
ostracods were not recorded. Figure 3. Typical scenery of the Al Wathba Lake. Figure 3. Typical scenery of the Al Wathba Lake. (ST 01 to ST 10, ST 09 excluded due to mostly dry
conditions) in the lake and two inlets (Inlets I and II)
on a quarterly basis between 2012 and 2015 and on an
almost complete monthly basis in 2010, 2011 and
2016. This programme was established by the
Terrestrial Environment Research Center of the
Environment Agency - Abu Dhabi in 2001 to monitor
Artemia as most important food source for birdlife and
especially the Greater Flamingo in the AWWR. The
sampling sites for Artemia were chosen based on a
100 m grid overlaid on AWWR Lake. The samples
were collected with a Van Dorn water sampler (2.2 L)
from the water column below the water surface. The
two inlets were not examined for the presence of
Artemia or ostracods. The water was passed through a
20 µm plankton net and the retained organisms
examined using a Zeiss Stemi 2000 low-power
binocular microscope. The presence of ostracods was
checked on a regular basis and the identification of
taxa is based on two samples of 23 March (sample 1)
and 22 June 2016 (sample 2) which were stored in
70% ethanol. Identification was aided by the use of a
Zeiss Supra 40VP scanning electron microscope at the
Institute of Geological Sciences of the Free University
of Berlin (Germany) and is based on descriptions of
(Malz, 1976; Meisch, 2000). Voucher specimens in
ethanol are deposited in the wet collection of the
Invertebrate collection of the Environment Agency -
Abu Dhabi (ICEAD). Figure 4. Materials and Methods Water depth data for the sampling stations (ST) during the
years 2010 to 2016. Grey vertical bars indicate months during which
water samples were unsuccessfully examined for the presence of
ostracods and orange bars represent months during which ostracods
were present at ST 08. The two horizontal lines at the left show the
water depth range at ST 08 during the monitoring period and the
vertical line in between these lines indicates the water depth range
for the ostracod records at ST 08. ST 08 was dry in March 2014 and
ostracods were not recorded. a measuring metre scale. A hand-held WTW 350i was
used to measure pH and temperature. Salinity was
mostly measured in the lab using sub-samples of water
samples diluted with distilled water. Lab analyses of
water samples focused on nitrogen (as nitrate, nitrite
and ammonia), phosphate (as PO4), total organic
carbon (TOC) and heavy metals Copper (Cu),
Cadmium (Cd) and Iron (Fe), and followed standard
procedures (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,
1983; Saji et al., 2016). All the data were presented in
graphs drawn using CoralDraw V.12 and Grapher
(Golden Software V.3). Figure 7 was prepared using
Corel Photo-Paint and CorelDraw and the map of
Figure 9 was created in amCharts software. Materials and Methods The permanent water body attracts a diverse
birdlife and became protected as Al Wathba Wetland
Reserve since 1998 due to the first successful breeding
of the Greater Flamingo (Phoenicopterus roseus) on
the Arabian Peninsula since a last record in 1922 from
Kuwait (Ticehurst, 1926). Its high biodiversity
including 260 bird species (Soorae et al., 2014) led to
the declaration as an internationally recognised and
protected Ramsar wetland site in 2013. The protected
wetland has an area of ca. 5 km² and the lake surface dune-covered sabkha in the lake area lies 15-18 m
above sea level. The region represented a seasonally
flooded wetland with temporarily rising water levels
probably resulting from increasing sub-surface water
flow and hydrostatic pressure from stronger winds and
higher tides in winter (Al Dhaheri, 2004). The
construction of the Mussafah - Al Ain Truck Road
between 1980 and 1984 dammed the southward flow
of surface waters and increased the area and annual
duration of emerging surface waters, and the
abundance of waterfowl. The ecological potential of
the wetland for local birdlife was recognised and
AWWR Lake established as a perennial water body
mostly fed by treated waste water from the Mafraq
Wastewater Treatment Plant, which is the main
sewage treatment plant of the city of Abu Dhabi (Fig. 2). The permanent water body attracts a diverse
birdlife and became protected as Al Wathba Wetland
Reserve since 1998 due to the first successful breeding
of the Greater Flamingo (Phoenicopterus roseus) on
the Arabian Peninsula since a last record in 1922 from
Kuwait (Ticehurst, 1926). Its high biodiversity
including 260 bird species (Soorae et al., 2014) led to
the declaration as an internationally recognised and
protected Ramsar wetland site in 2013. The protected
wetland has an area of ca. 5 km² and the lake surface Mixed
plant
communities
of
Zygophyllum
qatarense, Haloxylon salicornicum, Dipterygium
glaucum,
Anabasis
setifera
and
Tamarix
cf. ramossisiima
dominate
the
vegetation,
with
Phragmites australis reed beds along the less brackish
margins of the lake (Al Dhaheri, 2004) (Fig. 3). The
mean January and July temperatures are 19.8 and
35.8°C, respectively, and mean annual temperature is
28.1°C (NCMS, 2017). Mean annual precipitation in
the region is ca. 100 mm, mostly occurring between
December
and
February,
and
mean
annual
evaporation in the order of 2000 mm (Abdelfattah and
Meharibi, 2005; SCAD, 2015). Results All images apart from 4 show
internal views of valves. Specimens housed at Institute for
Geological Sciences of the Free University of Berlin, Germany. Figure 7. The ostracods Heterocypris salina (1-6) and Cyprinotus
cingalensis (7-10) from AWWR Lake. Heterocypris salina: (1) right
valve (RV) with anterior soft parts, 2 left valve (LV) with anterior
soft parts, 3 RV, 4 carapace with RV fully visible, 5 juvenile RV, 6
LV; Cyprinotus cingalensis: 7 RV, 8 LV, 9 RV with more
pronounced “hump”, 10 juvenile RV. All images apart from 4 show
internal views of valves. Specimens housed at Institute for
Geological Sciences of the Free University of Berlin, Germany. Figure 5. Salinity data and ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016
shown in a similar way as for water depth in Figure. 4. (Refer to Fig. Figure 5. Salinity data and ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016
shown in a similar way as for water depth in Figure. 4. (Refer to Fig. 4 for symbols of the sampling stations). Figure 5. Salinity data and ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016
shown in a similar way as for water depth in Figure. 4. (Refer to Fig. 4 for symbols of the sampling stations). Figure 6 pH data and ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016 Figure 7. The ostracods Heterocypris salina (1-6) and Cyprinotus
cingalensis (7-10) from AWWR Lake. Heterocypris salina: (1) right
valve (RV) with anterior soft parts, 2 left valve (LV) with anterior
soft parts, 3 RV, 4 carapace with RV fully visible, 5 juvenile RV, 6
LV; Cyprinotus cingalensis: 7 RV, 8 LV, 9 RV with more
pronounced “hump”, 10 juvenile RV. All images apart from 4 show
internal views of valves. Specimens housed at Institute for
Geological Sciences of the Free University of Berlin, Germany. and 10 and as high as 18.7 mg L-1 at ST 03 (Fig. 8c). Phosphate concentrations were in a range from
<0.2 mg L-1 at STs 01 to 07 and ST 10, to 20.88 mg L-
1 at inlet II (Fig. 8d). TOC concentrations were
between 2.4 mg L-1 at inlet I and 257.3 mg L-1 at ST
10 (Fig. 8e). Concentrations of Cd were often below
detection limit (<0.0005 mg L-1) and reached a
maximum of 1.62 mg L-1 at inlet I (Fig. 8f). Results The water depth at the sampling stations changed over
the observation period by a minimum of 0.56 m at ST
10 to a maximum of 2.10 m at ST 04 (Fig. 4). The
salinity ranged from 1.45‰ at inlet I to 457‰ at ST The water depth was recorded at each station with Saji et al./ Al Wathba Wetland in Abu Dhabi and its ostracod fauna 268 07 (Fig. 5). The pH value was lowest with 6.55 at inlet
I and highest with 9.67 at ST 10 (Fig. 6). Nitrate
concentrations were lowest at ST 08 with <0.03 mg
L-1 and highest at ST 10 with 771.66 mg L-1 (Fig. 8a). Nitrite concentrations ranged from <0.03 mg L-1 at ST
to
9 07 mg L-1
at
inlet
I
(Fig
8b)
Ammonia
and 10 and as high as 18.7 mg L-1 at ST 03 (Fig. 8c). Phosphate concentrations were in a range from
<0.2 mg L-1 at STs 01 to 07 and ST 10, to 20.88 mg L-
1 at inlet II (Fig. 8d). TOC concentrations were
between 2.4 mg L-1 at inlet I and 257.3 mg L-1 at ST
10 (Fig. 8e). Concentrations of Cd were often below
detection limit (<0.0005 mg L-1) and reached a
maximum of 1.62 mg L-1 at inlet I (Fig. 8f). The Cu
concentrations were also often below detection limit
(<0.005 mg L-1) and a maximum of 26.94 mg L-1 was
determined for inlet I (Fig. 8g). Concentrations of Fe
remained also often below detection limit (0.05 mg L-
1). A highest value of 259.2 mg L-1 was recorded at
inlet II (Fig. 8h). Ostracods were exclusively recorded at ST 08
Figure 5. Salinity data and ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016
shown in a similar way as for water depth in Figure. 4. (Refer to Fig. 4 for symbols of the sampling stations). Figure 6. pH data and ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016. (Refer to Fig. 4 for symbols of the sampling stations). Figure 7. The ostracods Heterocypris salina (1-6) and Cyprinotus
cingalensis (7-10) from AWWR Lake. Heterocypris salina: (1) right
valve (RV) with anterior soft parts, 2 left valve (LV) with anterior
soft parts, 3 RV, 4 carapace with RV fully visible, 5 juvenile RV, 6
LV; Cyprinotus cingalensis: 7 RV, 8 LV, 9 RV with more
pronounced “hump”, 10 juvenile RV. Results (a) Nitrate, (b) Nitrite, (c)
Ammonia, (d) Phosphate, (e) TOC, (f) Cd,
(g) Fe and (h) Cu concentrations and
ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016. Figure 8. (a) Nitrate, (b) Nitrite, (c)
Ammonia, (d) Phosphate, (e) TOC, (f) Cd,
(g) Fe and (h) Cu concentrations and
ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016. Figure 8. (a) Nitrate, (b) Nitrite, (c)
Ammonia, (d) Phosphate, (e) TOC, (f) Cd,
(g) Fe and (h) Cu concentrations and
ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016. years 2010-2016. Ostracods were present during two
thirds (27) of the 41 surveys at ST 08 (Fig. 4). Sample
1 collected on the 23 March 2016 contained juvenile
and adult specimens of Heterocypris salina (Brady,
1886) (Fig. 7). Sample 2 from the 22 June 2016
included juvenile and adult specimens of H. salina and
of Cyprinotus cingalensis (Sohn and Morris, 1963)
(Fig. 7). The specimens of H. salina are more abundant
than those of C. cingalensis in sample 2. Results The Cu
concentrations were also often below detection limit
(<0.005 mg L-1) and a maximum of 26.94 mg L-1 was
determined for inlet I (Fig. 8g). Concentrations of Fe
remained also often below detection limit (0.05 mg L-
1). A highest value of 259.2 mg L-1 was recorded at
inlet II (Fig. 8h). Figure 6. pH data and ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016. (Refer to Fig. 4 for symbols of the sampling stations). 07 (Fig. 5). The pH value was lowest with 6.55 at inlet
I and highest with 9.67 at ST 10 (Fig. 6). Nitrate
concentrations were lowest at ST 08 with <0.03 mg
L-1 and highest at ST 10 with 771.66 mg L-1 (Fig. 8a). Nitrite concentrations ranged from <0.03 mg L-1 at ST
to 9.07 mg L-1 at inlet I (Fig. 8b). Ammonia
concentrations were as low as <0.02 mg L-1 at STs 07 Ostracods were exclusively recorded at ST 08
during the course of the observations between the 269
Int. J. Aquat. Biol. (2018) 6(5): 265-273
Figure 8. (a) Nitrate, (b) Nitrite, (c)
Ammonia, (d) Phosphate, (e) TOC, (f) Cd,
(g) Fe and (h) Cu concentrations and
ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016. Int. J. Aquat. Biol. (2018) 6(5): 265-273 269 years 2010-2016. Ostracods were present during two
thirds (27) of the 41 surveys at ST 08 (Fig. 4). Sample
1 collected on the 23 March 2016 contained juvenile
and adult specimens of Heterocypris salina (Brady,
1886) (Fig. 7). Sample 2 from the 22 June 2016
included juvenile and adult specimens of H. salina and
of Cyprinotus cingalensis (Sohn and Morris, 1963)
(Fig. 7). The specimens of H. salina are more abundant
than those of C. cingalensis in sample 2. Discussion
The occurrence of C. cingalensis in the AWWR Lake
represents the first record of the species from the
UAE. Valves or living specimens of C. cingalensis
were recorded so far from Saudi Arabia, Yemen
including Socotra Island, Sudan, Palestine, Sri Lanka,
India, Indonesia, the Philippines, Japan, Australia and
Hawaii given that some records as C. scholiosus and
Cheikella scholiosa represent junior synonyms of the
Figure 8. (a) Nitrate, (b) Nitrite, (c)
Ammonia, (d) Phosphate, (e) TOC, (f) Cd,
(g) Fe and (h) Cu concentrations and
ostracod records in the years 2010 to 2016. Figure 8. Discussion The occurrence of C. cingalensis in the AWWR Lake
represents the first record of the species from the
UAE. Valves or living specimens of C. cingalensis
were recorded so far from Saudi Arabia, Yemen
including Socotra Island, Sudan, Palestine, Sri Lanka,
India, Indonesia, the Philippines, Japan, Australia and
Hawaii given that some records as C. scholiosus and
Cheikella scholiosa represent junior synonyms of the Saji et al./ Al Wathba Wetland in Abu Dhabi and its ostracod fauna 270 270
Saji et al./ Al Wathba Wetland in Abu Dhabi and its ostracod fauna
Figure 9. Distribution of the records of fossil and living Cyprinotus cingalensis (blue) and the record of living specimens from the UAE (red). (Map
produced with AMCHARTS.COM). Figure 9. Distribution of the records of fossil and living Cyprinotus cingalensis (blue) and the record of living specimens from the UAE (red). (Map
produced with AMCHARTS.COM). Table 1. Preliminary checklist of the non-marine ostracods from the UAE. Table 1. Preliminary checklist of the non-marine ostracods from the UAE. Taxon
Age
Reference
Cyprideis torosa (Jones, 1850)
Late Miocene (7 Ma) - Holocene
Mazzini et al., 2013; Gebel et al., 1989; Preston et al., 2015
Cyprideis sp. Holocene
Gebel et al., 1989 ; Stewart et al., 2011
Candona (Lineocypris?) sp. Holocene
Gebel et al., 1989
Candona sp. Late Miocene (7 Ma)
Mazzini et al., 2013
Heterocypris salina (Brady, 1868)
Late Miocene (7 Ma), living
Mazzini et al., 2013; this study
Vestalenula cylindrica (Straub, 1952)
Late Miocene (7 Ma)
Mazzini et al., 2013
Prolimnocythere sp. Late Miocene (7 Ma)
Mazzini et al., 2013
Cyprinotus cingalensis Brady, 1886
living
this study southern origin (Saudi Arabia or Yemen) or from
other regions with known or even unknown
C. cingalensis populations. species (Brady, 1886; Sars, 1889; Vavra, 1906; Klie, species (Brady, 1886; Sars, 1889; Vavra, 1906; Klie,
1933; Sohn and Morris, 1963; Hartmann, 1964; Bhatia
and Khosla, 1967, 1975; Malz, 1976; Neale, 1979;
Bhatia, 1983; Kempf, 1986; Bhatia and Singh, 1988;
Reeves, 2004; Karanovic, 2008, 2012; Mischke et al.,
2012; Mohammed et al., 2014) (Fig. 9). Cyprinotus
cingalensis is apparently distributed in the African and
Australasian subtropical and tropical region. Living
specimens of C. cingalensis or eggs were probably
introduced to the AWWR Lake by migrating birds. Specimens or eggs may have travelled attached to the
feathers or may have survived passage through the
digestive tract (Meisch, 2000; Karanovic, 2012). Discussion Iron concentrations in the water
samples from AWWR Lake are mostly in the range of
naturally occurring waters with the exception of water
collected in May 2010. typically
<0.05 mg L-1. However,
mean
concentrations between 2.7 mg L-1 at sampling station
ST 07 and 8.8 mg L-1 at inlet II are not critically high. TOC values are low for the inlets (inlet I: 6.1 mg L-1
on average, Inlet II: 7.0 mg L-1 on average) and at ST
08 (13.0 mg L-1 on average), and between 25.9-
54.4 mg L-1 on average at the other sampling stations. respect to water depth, salinity, pH and the other
recorded parameters over the monitoring period. The
large fluctuations probably result from the discharge
of treated waste water at relatively irregular time
intervals and the rise of the groundwater level as a
results of stronger winds and higher tides in winter
which is sometimes accompanied by precipitation. Although generally a very shallow lake, water depth
was changing by a maximum of 2.1 m at ST 04. The
smallest water depth variations were recorded at ST
10 where depth varied between 0.17 and 0.73 m. The
salinity gradient in the lake is extremely large, with a
lowest value of 1.45‰ measured at inlet I and a
maximum of 457‰ at ST 07. This recorded maximum
salinity is significantly higher than those of the Dead
Sea brine (~340‰) and even higher than those of the
most saline lakes in the Dry Valleys of Antarctica
(Marion, 1997). Fluctuations were also most extreme
at ST 07 where the salinity changed over a full order
of magnitude (from 43‰ in October 2010 to 459‰ in
June 2016). In contrast, lowest salinity variations
occurred at ST 08 (2.18-68.78‰). However, mostly
low salinities of <5‰ were measured at the inlets I and
II, and between 5-10‰ at ST 08. The pH values varied
from neutral to highly alkaline conditions. Lowest pH
values were recorded at the Inlets (mean pH 7.5)
whilst predominantly high values occurred at ST 08
(mean pH 8.2). Cadmium concentrations are mostly below
detection limit (<0.0005 mg L-1) and thus, below the
recommended threshold for drinking water of
0.003 mg L-1 (WHO, 2011). However, concentrations
as high as an order of magnitude above this level were
occasionally recorded during the first two years of the
monitoring period. Discussion However, it remains speculative whether the
C. cingalensis population in the AWWR Lake
possibly originates from specimens or eggs of species (Brady, 1886; Sars, 1889; Vavra, 1906; Klie,
1933; Sohn and Morris, 1963; Hartmann, 1964; Bhatia
and Khosla, 1967, 1975; Malz, 1976; Neale, 1979;
Bhatia, 1983; Kempf, 1986; Bhatia and Singh, 1988;
Reeves, 2004; Karanovic, 2008, 2012; Mischke et al.,
2012; Mohammed et al., 2014) (Fig. 9). Cyprinotus
cingalensis is apparently distributed in the African and
Australasian subtropical and tropical region. Living
specimens of C. cingalensis or eggs were probably
introduced to the AWWR Lake by migrating birds. Specimens or eggs may have travelled attached to the
feathers or may have survived passage through the
digestive tract (Meisch, 2000; Karanovic, 2012). However, it remains speculative whether the
C. cingalensis population in the AWWR Lake
possibly originates from specimens or eggs of The record of H. salina from the AWWR Lake is
the first record of living ostracods from the UAE. Fossil valves of late Miocene age (7 million years)
were reported from the Al Gharbia region in the UAE
(Mazzini et al., 2013) (Table 1). The species is widely
distributed in the Holarctic region and occurs also in
the southern hemisphere where it was probably
introduced relatively recently (Meisch, 2000). Heterocypris salina is common in the region with
records from Iran, Jordan, Palestine, Saudi Arabia and
Sudan (Schöning, 1996; Griffiths et al., 2001;
Rosenberg et al., 2011; Mischke et al., 2012). AWWR Lake experienced large fluctuations with Int. J. Aquat. Biol. (2018) 6(5): 265-273 271 typically
<0.05 mg L-1. However,
mean
concentrations between 2.7 mg L-1 at sampling station
ST 07 and 8.8 mg L-1 at inlet II are not critically high. TOC values are low for the inlets (inlet I: 6.1 mg L-1
on average, Inlet II: 7.0 mg L-1 on average) and at ST
08 (13.0 mg L-1 on average), and between 25.9-
54.4 mg L-1 on average at the other sampling stations. Cadmium concentrations are mostly below
detection limit (<0.0005 mg L-1) and thus, below the
recommended threshold for drinking water of
0.003 mg L-1 (WHO, 2011). However, concentrations
as high as an order of magnitude above this level were
occasionally recorded during the first two years of the
monitoring period. Copper concentrations are mostly
well below the recommended value of 2 mg L-1
(WHO 2011). 2029-2039. recorded in a range of relatively low salinities between
2.18-13.74‰. Abdelfattah M.A., Al Meharibi M.A. (2005). The soils of
Al Wathba Wetland Reserve. Unpublished Internal
Report, ERWDA. 55 p. Future monitoring of the lake would benefit from
additional analysis of the bottom-water oxygenation at
the stations, from analysis of the ion chemistry of the
lake water and of groundwater in the region, and from
observations of the temporal occurrence of the
individual ostracod species in the lake. Bhatia S.B., Khosla S.C. (1967). Sub-recent ostracodes
from southern Punjab. Research Bulletin of the Panjab
University NS, 18: 502-509. Bhatia S.B., Khosla S.C. (1975). Sub-recent ostracodes
from Tehsil Charkhi Dardi, District Mahendragarn,
southern Haryana. Journal of the Palaeontological
Society of India, 20: 333-338. Discussion Copper concentrations are mostly
well below the recommended value of 2 mg L-1
(WHO 2011). Iron concentrations in the water
samples from AWWR Lake are mostly in the range of
naturally occurring waters with the exception of water
collected in May 2010. The results of our study demonstrate that salinity
level at sampling station ST08 was significantly lower
as compared to other sampling stations at different
locations in AWWR. Therefore, the occurrence of
ostracods
in
AWWR
Lake
is
apparently
predominantly controlled by salinity level. On the
other hand, the evaluation of other parameters at all
sampling stations such as pH, TOC and cadmium
concentrations did not reveal significant relationships
with the distribution of the recorded ostracods. The
presence of the recorded ostracods is mainly
controlled by the relatively low salinity at station
ST08 in AWWR. The concentration of Nitrate in the water of the
AWWR Lake is mostly between 5 and 50 mg L-1. These values are typical for treated waters or generally
for waters affected by industrial or agricultural
activities. However, the nitrate concentrations are
mostly not critical with respect to drinking water
standards (WHO, 2011; Saji et al., 2016). Similarly to
nitrate concentrations, nitrite levels are mostly under
the recommended concentration of 3 mg L-1 in
drinking water (WHO, 2011). Mean ammonia
concentrations are between 1.5 mg L-1 at inlet I and
2.8 mg L-1 at ST 04. These values are relatively high
and typical for anaerobic ground waters (WHO,
2011). The Phosphate concentrations in AWWR lake
waters are almost exclusively above those of natural
waters with geogenic phosphate concentrations of Based on our limnological analyses carried out in
the years 2010 to 2016, the ostracod species
C. cingalensis was recorded for the first time in UAE. A second species H. salina was also recorded, which
was reported from the late Miocene of the UAE
before. Cyprinotus cingalensis was not recorded for
the country before. The ostracods were only recorded
at one of nine regularly monitored sampling stations
in the lake which is characterised by the lowest salinity
of all stations. Thus, salinity is probably the
predominant parameter which controls the distribution
of ostracods in AWWR Lake. Ostracods were only Saji et al./ Al Wathba Wetland in Abu Dhabi and its ostracod fauna 272 Acknowledgements We thank Sirthaj Khan for help with sampling and
data accumulation and C. Steuber from Emirate
Natural History Group (ENHG) for continuous
support of the project. We thank Dr. Richard Perry
(Research committee, EAD) for comments and
editorial help that greatly improved the manuscript. The study was supported by Environment Agency -
Abu Dhabi (EAD). Brady G.S. (1886). Notes on Entomostraca collected by
Mr. A. Haly in Ceylon. Journal of The Linnean Society
of London, 19: 293-317. Gebel H.G., Hannss C., Liebau A., Raehle W. (1989). The
late Quaternary environments of `Ain al-Faidha/Al-Ain,
Abu Dhabi Emirate. Archaeology in the United Arab
Emirates, 5: 9-48. Griffiths H.I., Schwalb A., Stevens L.R (2001). Environmental change in southwestern Iran. The
Holocene ostracod fauna of Lake Mirabad. The
Holocene, 11: 757-764. East. Climatic Change, 114: 667-687. East. Climatic Change, 114: 667-687. Malz H. (1976). Heterocypris vel. Cyprinotus? Ist die
Morphologie des Gehäuses entscheidend für die
Bestimmung
rezenter
Ostracoden-Gattungen? Senckenbergiana Lethaea, 57: 185-199. Schöning C. (1996). Subrecent Ostracoda (Crustacea) from
the Sudan, with a description of the juvenile stages of
Oncocypris muelleri (Daday, 1910). Mitteilungen aus
dem Zoologischen Staatsinstitut und Zoologischen
Museum in Hamburg, 93: 39-56. Marion G.M. (1997). A theoretical evaluation of mineral
stability in Don Juan Pond, Wright Valley, Victoria
Land. Antarctic Science, 9: 92-99 Sohn I.G., Morris R.W. (1963). Cheikella, a new fresh-
water ostracode genus and Telekia, a new name for a
homonym. Micropaleontology, 9: 327-331. Mazzini I., Schuster B.F., Beech M., Hill A. (2013). The
“elephants” and the ostracods: a 7 MY old tale from the
United Arab Emirates. Naturalista Siciliano, 37(1): 209-
211. Stewart J.R., Aspinall S., Beech M., Fenberg P., Hellyer P.,
Larkin N., Lokier S., Marx F., Meyer M., Miller R. (2011). Biotically constrained palaeoenvironmental
conditions of a mid-Holocene intertidal lagoon on the
southern shore of the Arabian Gulf: evidence associated
with a whale skeleton at Musaffah, Abu Dhabi, UAE. Quaternary Science Reviews, 30: 3675-3690. Meisch C. (2000). Freshwater Ostracoda of Western and
Central Europe. Spektrum, Heidelberg. 522 p. Micklin P.P. (1988). Dessication of the Aral Sea. A water
management disaster in the Soviet Union. Science, 241:
1170-1176. Ticehurst C.B. (1926). Additional notes on the avifauna of
Iraq. Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society,
31: 110. Mischke S., Ginat H., Al-Saqarat B., Almogi-Labin A. (2012). Ostracods from water bodies in hyperarid Israel
and Jordan as habitat and water chemistry indicators. Ecological Indicators, 14: 87-99. Tourian M.J., Elmi O., Chen Q., Devaraju B., Roohi S.H.,
Sneeuw N. (2015). A spaceborne multisensor approach
to monitor the desiccation of Lake Urmia in Iran. Remote Sensing of Environment, 156: 349-360. Mohammed M.A., Keyser D., Al-Wosabi M.A., Al-
Khirbash B., Al-Qadassi W.M. (2014). Taxonomy and
distribution of fresh water Ostracoda from Socotra
Island, Yemen. Revue de Micropaléontologie, 57: 23-
33. Vávra W. (1906). Ostracoden von Sumatra, Java, Siam, den
Sandwich-Inseln und Japan. Zoologisches Jahrbuch, 23:
413-438. NCMS. (2017). National center of meteorology and
seismology, United Arab Emirates. Willner S.E., Lipchin C., Aloni Z. (2015). Salt storms,
sinkholes and major economic losses: Can the
deteriorating Dead Sea be saved from the looming eco
crisis? Negev, Dead Sea and Arava Studies, 7: 27-37. Neale J. (1979). On the genus Cyprinotus and its
interpretation. References Bhatia S.B. (1983). Quaternary Ostracoda of the Indo-
Gangetic
Plain
and
their
paleozoogeographic
implications. In: R.F. Maddocks (ed.). Applications of
Ostracoda, University of Houston. pp: 442-458. Hartmann G. (1964). Asiatische Ostracoden. Internationale
Revue der gesamten Hydrobiologie, Systematische
Beihefte, 3: 1-155. Karanovic I. (2008). Three interesting Cyprididae
(Ostracoda) from Western Australia. Records of the
Western Australian Museum, 24: 267-287. Soorae P.S., Al Zaabi R., Saji A., Sakkir S., Ahmed S.,
Khan S. (2014). Al Wathba wetland reserve field guide. Environment Agency – Abu Dhabi, UAE. 84 p. Karanovic I. (2012). Recent Freshwater Ostracods of the
World. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. 608 p. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Water
Regulations and Standards Office of Wetlands
Protection (1990). Water quality standards for wetlands,
National Guidance. 2nd ed. Kempf E.K. (1986). Late Quaternary environmental
changes in the eastern Sahara (Libyan Desert)
documented by an ostracode diagram. Centre National
de la Recherche Scientifique, 197: 235-238. Bhatia S.B., Singh N. (1988). Middle Holocene
palaeoclimatic and palaeoenvironmental events in
southern Haryana. Proceedings of the Indian National
Science Academy, 54: 574-584. Kempf E.K. (1997). Index and bibliography of nonmarine
Ostracoda. Parts 6 and 7. Sonderveröffentlichungen des
Geologischen Instituts der Universität zu Köln, 109
(Part 6: Index a supplement 1): 1-142; 110 (Part 7: Index
B Supplement 1): 1-134; 111 (Part 8: Index C
Supplement 1): 1-152; 112 (Part 9: Bibliography C): 1-
144. Al Dhaheri S.S. (2004). Assessment of brine shrimp
(Artemia sp.) Productivity at Al Wathba wetland
reserve, Abu Dhabi (UAE). BSc, United Arab Emirates
University, Abu Dhabi, UAE. Reeves J.M. (2004). The use of Ostracoda in the
palaeoenvironmental reconstruction of the Gulf of
Carpentaria, Australia, from the last interglacial to
present. PhD, University of Wollongong, Australia. Klie W. (1933). Die Ostracoden der Deutschen
Limnologischen
Sunda-Expedition. Archiv
für
Hydrobiologie, 11: 447-502. Lelieveld J., Hadjinicolaou P., Kostopoulou E., Chenoweth
J., El Maayar M., Giannakopoulos C., Hannides C.,
Lange MA., Tanarhte M.T. (2012). Climate change and
impacts in the eastern Mediterranean and the Middle Al-Hamad S.S., Albadran B.N., Pournelle J.R. (2017). Geological history of Shatt Al-Arab River, south of
Iraq. International Journal of Science and Research, 6: Int. J. Aquat. Biol. (2018) 6(5): 265-273 Int. J. Aquat. Biol. (2018) 6(5): 265-273 273 Dhabi through Statistics. East. Climatic Change, 114: 667-687. East. Climatic Change, 114: 667-687. East. Climatic Change, 114: 667-687. In: Taxonomy, Biostratigraphy and
Distribution
of
Ostracodes. VII
International
Symposium on Ostracoda, Belgrad. pp: 77-86. World Health Organization (2011). Guidelines for
drinking-water quality. Gutenberg, Malta. 564 p. Wouters K. (2017). On the modern distribution of the
euryhaline species Cyprideis torosa (Jones, 1850)
(Crustacea, Ostracoda). Journal of Micropalaeontology,
36: 21-30. Preston G.W. Thomas W., David S.G., Goudie A.S.,
Atkinson O.A.C., Leng M.J., Hodson, M.J., Walkington
H., Charpentier V., Méry S., Borgi F., Parker A.G. (2015). A multi-proxy analysis of the Holocene humid
phase from the United Arab Emirates and its
implications
for
southeast
Arabia's
Neolithic
populations. Quaternary International, 382: 277-292. Saji A., Al Dhaheri S., Shah J.N., Soorae P.S. (2016). Influence of chemical parameters on Artemia sp. (Crustacea: Anostraca) population in AWWR lake in
the Abu Dhabi Emirate, UAE. International Journal of
Aquatic Biology, 4: 87-95. Sars G.O. (1889). On some fresh water Ostracoda and
Copepoda, raised from
dried
Australian mud. Forhandlungen Christiania Vidensk-Selsk, 8: 1-78. SCAD Statistics Centre – Abu Dhabi (2015). Explore Abu
|
https://openalex.org/W4386837078
|
https://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ/article/download/28313/12881
|
English
| null |
Development of Flip book-Based Interactive Learning Media to Improving Understanding of Statistical Material Concepts
|
MEJ (Mathematics Education Journal)
| 2,023
|
cc-by-sa
| 1,390
|
Abstract Corresponding author:
Abstract
Junior High School
. Keywords:
i
;
f
; s
m
Masrifah, S., Taufik, M.,
Kusumawardana, A., S.. 3
Development of Flip book-
Based Interactive Learning Media to Improving Understanding of Statistical Material
Concepts. 7 2
239 247 DOI : 10.22219/mej.v7i1.28313 Abstract
Junior High School
. Keywords:
i
;
f
; s
m Masrifah, S., Taufik, M.,
Kusumawardana, A., S.. 3
Development of Flip book-
Based Interactive Learning Media to Improving Understanding of Statistical Material
Concepts. 7 2
239 247 DOI : 10.22219/mej.v7i1.28313 Development of Flip book-Based Interactive Learning Media to
Improving Understanding of Statistical Material Concepts
1
2
a3
Study Program of mathematics Education, Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang
Indonesia Study Program of mathematics Education, Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang
Indonesia ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 INTRODUCTION The urgency of interactive learning is increasingly needed today, this is
because interactive learning has several advantages, as conveyed by Afifah et al. (2022) that interactive learning is a learning approach that provides two-way
communication, so that students will be directly involved in the learning material
and can strengthen their critical thinking and problem-solving skills using a much
more holistic learning approach. In addition, interactive learning will involve
students more directly in lessons that can help students improve communication
skills with fellow students and teachers. Referring to the explanation of the previous paragraph, it is known that
interactive learning can be used as a way to make it easier for students to understand
learning material, so learning media that can present interactive learning is needed. Currently there are several interactive learning media, Putri et al. (2020) stating that
one of the learning media that can be used in interactive learning is flipbooks, this
is because flipbooks are able to provide space for students to understand directly
the learning material through the visual aspects presented in flipbooks. Furthermore
according to Febriani & Maritasari (2015) Interactive learning can also be
developed from animation media because animation media can provide the effect 239 ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 of visualizing movement and object characteristics so that students can be more
easily understood by students. of visualizing movement and object characteristics so that students can be more
easily understood by students. Flipbook and animation media have their own advantages, but the accuracy
of using learning media depends on the grade level and learning material to be
delivered to students. Animation media is more for lower-level students with
material related to understanding motion, while flipbooks are more effective for
upper-level students because they require an understanding of digital operations,
then the advantage of other flipbooks is that they can combine aspects of animation
and audio in it. This is also in line with delivery Putri et al. (2020) that one of the
learning media that can be developed to create interactive learning is through the
development of digital-based learning media in the form of flipbooks, this is
because through flipbooks it can regulate interaction between students regularly, for
example by adding simulations that involve students in activities or problems,
which require them to cooperate with teammates in solving problems. INTRODUCTION The use of flipbooks as an interactive learning medium can also be applied in
mathematics subjects, this is because in mathematics it takes activeness from
students in the process of identifying and solving problems. Aspects of
identification and problem solving, for example in statistical material with various
problems that must be solved through understanding problems and problem solving
patterns. However, the understanding of statistical concepts is poorly understood by
students who consider that statistical problems and concepts have no relation to the
process of solving problems in real life. This is in accordance with the delivery of
Setyorini et al. (2017) which states that students often find it difficult to understand
statistical concepts that are abstract in explaining the characteristics of problem
solving. Student difficulties as conveyed in empirical studies by Setyorini et al. (2017)
also occurs in learning mathematics statistical material in grade VIII students at
SMP PGRI 01 Ngajum, it is known from the results of interviews delivered by
mathematics teachers at SMP PGRI 01 Ngajum that students often have difficulty
in understanding statistical concepts which often emphasize aspects of abstraction
and require a deductive approach, which is an approach that tries to describe the
core of the problem in sequence. Referring to the results of the interview, it is known
that the research gap in this study is a problem at the research location, namely at
Junior High School PGRI 01 Ngajum in the form of student weaknesses in
understanding problems in statistical problems and difficulties in solving problems
in questions. The research gap is then tried to be resolved through the use of interactive
statistical learning media, the concept refers to the results of empirical studies
conducted by Fitri et al. (2021) With the results of the study, it is known that
interactive learning media is able to improve the quality of student learning with a
significant increase in learning outcomes compared to before the use of interactive
learning media. Through reference to the empirical study, this study focused on
developing interactive media for students at SMP PGRI 01 Ngajum so that students
can easily understand statistical concepts and can describe solving statistical
problems systematically. 240 ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 RESEARCH METHOD 1) Validity analysis 1) Validity analysis Vp = Tse
Tsh x 100% Vp = Tse
Tsh x 100% Vp = Tse
Tsh x 100% Vp = Tse
Tsh x 100% Table 1. Validity Criteria 2) Effectiveness analysis 2) Effectiveness analysis 2) Effectiveness analysis )
y 241 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ b
d Skor maximal P = ∑Sn
K x 100% Information : Information : Table 2. Effectiveness Criteria Table 2. Effectiveness Criteria ) Practicality analysis 3) Practicality analysis y
y P =
TS
Smax x 100% P =
TS
Smax x 100% Table 3. Practicality Criteria Table 3. Practicality Criteria 242 ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Table 4. Due Diligence Results
Aspect
Score
93%
91%
96%
93%
93% Table 5. Practicality Aspect
Very practical 243 ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Very practical
Very practical Table 6. Effectiveness Aspect
79% Table 7. T Test Results Table 7. T Test Results 244 ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 In addition to referring to the results of the t test between the pre-test and the post-
test, the results of the analysis of understanding statistical concepts using flipbook
learning media for grade VIII students at SMP PGRI 01 Ngajum are also
strengthened by the way students answer the questions, the largest percentage
results in the aspect of planning and writing answers correctly and correctly shows
that students in addition to understanding statistical concepts, students are also able
to apply this understanding to solve problems, this is in accordance with the
statement Irawan et al. (2020) which states that the growth of students' cognitive
levels can be a reference in the development of educational modules including the
development of innovative learning media, student cognitive improvement can be
supported by educational media that match the age growth of junior high school
students. 245 ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 REFERENCES 246 ISSN : 2579-5724
ISSN : 2579-5260 (Online)
http://ejournal.umm.ac.id/index.php/MEJ Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 Mathematics Education Journals
Vol. 7 No. 2 August 2023 247 247
|
https://openalex.org/W2800177368
|
http://old.scielo.br/pdf/rod/v58n2/2175-7860-rod-58-02-0283.pdf
|
Portuguese
| null |
Revisão taxonômica de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. (Leguminosae, Papilionoideae, Dalbergieae)
|
Rodriguésia
| 2,007
|
cc-by
| 17,210
|
Artigo recebido em 07/2006. Aceito para publicação em 03/2007.
1Parte da tese de doutorado do primeiro autor realizada junto ao Programa de Pós-graduação em Biologia Vegetal, Unicamp.
2Universidade Federal dos Vales do Jequitinhonha e Mucuri. Rua da Glória, 187, Centro, 39100-000, Diamantina, MG,
Brasil. cvictor@jknet.com.br
3Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Depto. Botânica, Instituto de Biologia, Cx.Postal 6109, 13083-970, Campinas, SP, Brasil. ABSTRACT (Taxonomic survey of Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. (Leguminosae, Papilionoideae, Dalbergieae))
Twelve species were recognized in the present revision: M. floridum, M. goudoti, M. gracile, M. hatschbachii,
M. myrianthum, M. nyctitans, M. obovatum, M. ovalifolium, M. ruddianum, M. saraense, M. scleroxylon and
M. tortipes. M. nyctitans had its circumscription modified and infraspecific taxa were not recognized for this
species. A new name, M. ruddianum, was proposed to replace M. floridum var. parviflorum. New synonyms
were recognized for M. myrianthum and M. nyctitans and an epitype was designated for this last species. The
species of this section show disjunct distribution, with some species occuring mainly in Southeastern Brazil
and others in countries from the Amazon basin and Central America. K
d
T
L
i
P
ili
id
D lb
i
M
h
i Key words: Taxonomy, Leguminosae, Papilionoideae, Dalbergieae, Machaerium. REVISÃO TAXONÔMICA DE MACHAERIUM SECT. OBLONGA (BENTH.)
TAUB. (LEGUMINOSAE, PAPILIONOIDEAE, DALBERGIEAE)1 Carlos Victor Mendonça Filho2, Ana Maria Goulart de Azevedo Tozzi3
& Eliana R. Forni Martins3 Carlos Victor Mendonça Filho2, Ana Maria Goulart de Azevedo Tozzi3
& Eliana R. Forni Martins3 RESUMO (Revisão taxonômica de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. (Leguminosae, Papilionoideae, Dalbergieae))
Na presente revisão taxonômica foram reconhecidas 12 espécies: M. floridum, M. goudoti, M. gracile, M. hatschbachii, M. myrianthum, M. nyctitans, M. obovatum, M. ovalifolium, M. ruddianum, M. saraense, M. scleroxylon e M. tortipes. Não foram reconhecidos táxons infra-específicos para M. nyctitans que teve sua
circunscrição modificada. Foi proposto um nome novo, M. ruddianum, para M. floridum var. parviflorum. Foram
também reconhecidos novos sinônimos para M. myrianthum e M. nyctitans e designado um epitipo para esta
última espécie. As espécies da seção apresentam uma distribuição disjunta, com algumas espécies ocorrendo
principalmente na Região Sudeste do Brasil e outras em países da região Amazônica e da América Central. Palavras-chave: Taxonomia, Leguminosae, Papilionoideae, Dalbergieae, Machaerium. MATERIAL E MÉTODOS Foram analisadas cerca de 1500
exsicatas de 26 herbários nacionais e 16
herbários do exterior, cujas siglas designativas
estão de acordo com Holmgren et al. (1990). Foram realizadas coletas adicionais e
observações de campo, especialmente
daquelas espécies que necessitaram de
maiores estudos, nos estados da Bahia,
Espírito Santo, Minas Gerais, Paraná, São
Paulo e Rio de Janeiro. O material coletado
foi depositado no herbário UEC e duplicatas
foram enviadas aos herbários BHCB, CVRD,
MBML e VIC. Das seções do gênero, Machaerium
sect. Oblonga é particularmente complexa,
devido à grande variação morfológica
observada especial-mente em M. nyctitans,
que tem resultado na dificuldade de
delimitação da espécie e levantado discussões
sobre o reconhecimento de táxons infra-
específicos (Rudd 1973; Lima et al. 1994;
Lima 1995; Sartori & Tozzi 1998). Por outro
lado, a observação de espécies correlatas a
esse táxon, caracteriza a existência de um
“complexo taxonômico” que necessita ser
mais bem investi-gado. A atualização das
descrições das espécies permitirá uma melhor
delimitação dos táxons, bem como a
verificação de caracteres unificadores para
a caracterização desta seção, principalmente
reprodutivos, como soldadura dos estames e
características do embrião e da plântula, uma
vez que os caracteres vegetativos muitas
vezes não tem sido suficientes para separar
seções afins. A citação dos tipos foi realizada de acordo
com o apresentado na obra princeps. A
terminologia utilizada na caracterização
morfológica foi baseada em Radford et. al. (1974) e Stearn (1983). As medidas das flores
foram tomadas a partir da base do cálice. Os
ápices dos lacínios do cálice foram descritos
como lobados (obtusos, com ângulo maior que
90º), triangulares ou estreitamente triangulares
(com ângulo menor que 90º). As medidas do
vexilo, asas e das pétalas da carena incluíram
a unha. A medida do comprimento do fruto
incluiu o estipe. As partes florais e detalhes
de outras estruturas foram ilustradas com o
auxílio de estereomicroscópio Zeiss, com
câmara clara acoplada. Amostras de flores
foram fixadas em solução de formol, ácido
acético e álcool (FAA 50%) para ilustração
de detalhes florais. Bentham (1860) tratou nove espécies
em Machaerium sect. Oblonga: M. gardneri, M. goudoti, M. gracile, M. moritzianum, M. myrianthum, M. nyctitans,
M. scleroxylon, M. polyphyllum (Poir.) e M. sordidum Benth. A composição da seção foi
ampliada com a inclusão de M. multifoliolatum Ducke por Bastos (1987) e
de M. cobanense Donn. Sm. e M. cirrhiferum Pittier, por Rudd (1977). INTRODUÇÃO dos inventários florísticos, nos mais variados
habitats e apresenta ampla distribuição
geográfica (Ducke 1922, 1949; Barroso 1965;
Bastos 1987; Lewis 1987; Lima et al. 1994;
Mendonça 1996; Sartori & Tozzi 1998). A
despeito desta importância, é necessário
ampliar-se o estudo sobre o gênero, devido
à dificuldade de delimitação de muitas
espécies. O gênero Machaerium Pers. está
subordinado à tribo Dalbergieae (Leguminosae,
Papilionoideae). Constitui-se por cerca de 130
espécies com distribuição tipicamente
neotropical, estendendo-se do sul do México à
América do Sul, com apenas uma espécie
ocorrendo na costa oeste da África (Rudd
1977). A maior diversidade ocorre no Brasil,
onde são encontradas cerca de 120 espécies,
variando desde árvores a até plantas
escandentes (Hoehne 1941). As formas
escandentes predominam na hiléia amazônica,
enquanto as arbóreas, no centro-sul do Brasil
(Ducke 1949). As 56 espécies de Machaerium então
conhecidas foram agrupadas em cinco séries
por Bentham (1860), utilizando caracteres
vegetativos, principalmente forma e venação
dos folíolos e presença de estípulas
espinescentes. Estas foram elevadas à
categoria de seções por Taubert (1891):
Machaerium sect. Penninervea, M. sect. Machaerium é um gênero que apresenta
uma grande riqueza específica na maioria Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 284 Lineata, M. sect. Oblonga, M. sect. Reticulata e M. sect. Acutifolia. Rudd
(1987) indicou o autônimo Machaerium sect. Machaerium para substituir a secão
Penninervea, na qual estava inserida a
espécie tipo do gênero: M. ferrugineum
(Willd.) Pers., atualmente sinônimo de M. quinata (Aubl.) Sandwith. A autora
reconheceu quatro seções para o gênero,
sugerindo a inclusão das espécies da seção
Acutifolia em Machaerium sect. Reticulata,
sem tratá-las formalmente como sinônimos. Lineata, M. sect. Oblonga, M. sect. Reticulata e M. sect. Acutifolia. Rudd
(1987) indicou o autônimo Machaerium sect. Machaerium para substituir a secão
Penninervea, na qual estava inserida a
espécie tipo do gênero: M. ferrugineum
(Willd.) Pers., atualmente sinônimo de M. quinata (Aubl.) Sandwith. A autora
reconheceu quatro seções para o gênero,
sugerindo a inclusão das espécies da seção
Acutifolia em Machaerium sect. Reticulata,
sem tratá-las formalmente como sinônimos. taxonômicas recentes (a última foi de Hoehne
1941), o presente trabalho teve como objetivos
atualizar a nomenclatura, tipificação e
circunscrição dos táxons de Machaerium
sect. Oblonga; realizar descrições e
ilustrações,
apresentar
chave
para
identificação das espécies e informações
sobre sua distribuição geográfica, hábitat e
épocas de floração e frutificação. MATERIAL E MÉTODOS M. multifoliolatum foi aqui
considerada sinônimo de M. myrianthum. RESULTADOS E DISCUSSÃO Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. In:
Engler & Prantl., Naturl. Pflanzenfam. 3:337. 1891. (Lectótipo, aqui designado: Machaerium
nyctitans (Vell.) Benth.). Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. In:
Engler & Prantl., Naturl. Pflanzenfam. 3:337. 1891. (Lectótipo, aqui designado: Machaerium
nyctitans (Vell.) Benth.). Machaerium ser. Oblonga Benth., J. Linn. Soc. Bot., 4 Suppl.: 53. 1860. Lianas, arbustos-escandentes, arvoretas
a árvores, até 30 m alt. Estípulas
espinescentes, retas ou recurvadas, 4−45 mm
compr., às vezes decíduas. Folhas 7−65(−
150)-folioladas, folíolos oblongos, 0,5−5,6 ×
0,2−2 cm, o terminal geralmente obovado,
obtuso a retuso, base cuneada, venação
broquidódroma. Racemos a panículas 2,5−
40(−80) × 0,7−20 cm, axilares ou terminais,
laxos ou congestos nos ápices, pauci a
multifloros. Brácteas e bractéolas orbiculares,
ovadas, obovadas, lanceoladas a triangulares,
às vezes cimbiformes. Flores até 12 mm
compr., sésseis a pediceladas; estames
monadelfos a diadelfos (estame vexilar livre),
às vezes na mesma espécie; ovário
uniovulado; disco nectarífero cupulado. Sâmaras até 8 cm compr., cultriformes; asas
concolores ou discolores na base, de
coloração distinta do núcleo seminífero. Plúmula
pluripartida,
germinação
faneroepígea, eófilos plurifoliolados. 2n= 20,
40 Américas Central e do Sul. Neste trabalho foram reconhecidas 12
espécies pertencentes a Machaerium sect. Oblonga dentre elas um nome novo: M. ruddianum C. V. Mendonça F. & A. M. G. Azevedo. Das nove espécies tratadas por Bentham
(1860) foram mantidas na seção Oblonga
cinco espécies: M. goudoti, M. gracile, M. myrianthum, M. nyctitans e M. scleroxylon. MATERIAL E MÉTODOS A classificação do hábitat das espécies
está de acordo com Andrade-Lima (1966) para
as espécies brasileiras e com Cabrera & Willink
(1973) para as espécies extra-brasileiras. Com o intuito de ampliar o atual
conhecimento taxonômico de Machaerium,
considerando a escassez de revisões Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 285 M. sordidum Benth. trata-se de um sinônimo
de Dalbergia villosa Benth. (Carvalho 1997)
e M. gardneri foi considerado uma variedade
de M. nyctitans (Rudd 1973). A análise de
material de diferentes herbários indicou que
M. moritzianum Benth. e M. polyphyllum
Benth. apresentam características de folhas e
flores afins às das espécies de Machaerium
sect. Lineata e devem ser transferidas para
esta seção. Bentham (1860) reconheceu uma
maior proximidade da primeira espécie com
M. angustifolium (atualmente M. hirtum),
subordinada à seção Lineata. Quanto a M. polyphyllum, o autor baseou-se na descrição
de De Candolle (1825) para Nissolia
polyphylla e não teve oportunidade de
examinar as flores desta espécie e compará-
la com as demais descritas por ele para
Machaerium sect. Oblonga. Ducke (1922)
observou uma semelhança de M. polyphyllum
com M. angustifolium corroborando a sua
transferência. Outras duas espécies, M. cobanense e M. cirrhiferum, também tiveram
material de herbário examinado e por
apresentarem
características
florais
semelhantes às das espécies de Machaerium
sect. Lineata também devem ser tratadas
nesta seção. M. multifoliolatum foi aqui
considerada sinônimo de M. myrianthum. M. sordidum Benth. trata-se de um sinônimo
de Dalbergia villosa Benth. (Carvalho 1997)
e M. gardneri foi considerado uma variedade
de M. nyctitans (Rudd 1973). A análise de
material de diferentes herbários indicou que
M. moritzianum Benth. e M. polyphyllum
Benth. apresentam características de folhas e
flores afins às das espécies de Machaerium
sect. Lineata e devem ser transferidas para
esta seção. Bentham (1860) reconheceu uma
maior proximidade da primeira espécie com
M. angustifolium (atualmente M. hirtum),
subordinada à seção Lineata. Quanto a M. polyphyllum, o autor baseou-se na descrição
de De Candolle (1825) para Nissolia
polyphylla e não teve oportunidade de
examinar as flores desta espécie e compará-
la com as demais descritas por ele para
Machaerium sect. Oblonga. Ducke (1922)
observou uma semelhança de M. polyphyllum
com M. angustifolium corroborando a sua
transferência. Outras duas espécies, M. cobanense e M. cirrhiferum, também tiveram
material de herbário examinado e por
apresentarem
características
florais
semelhantes às das espécies de Machaerium
sect. Lineata também devem ser tratadas
nesta seção. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga 1. Folíolo terminal maior que 0,7 cm larg. 2. Raque da folha 15−19 cm compr..............................................................12. M. tortipes
2. Raque da folha menor que 12 cm compr. 3. Raque foliar e superfície abaxial dos folíolos glabras; pecíolo 0,5 mm diâm. 4. Ramos inermes; folíolos membranáceos; peciólulo 1−2 mm compr.; frutos 5,8−
6 cm compr.; núcleo seminífero glabro. Sara, Bolívia .............. 10. M. saraense
4. Ramos aculeados; folíolos cartáceos; peciólulo 1 mm compr.; frutos até 5 cm compr.;
núcleo seminífero fulvo-seríceo. Cabo Frio-RJ, Brasil ............ 7. M. obovatum
3. Raque foliar e superfície abaxial dos folíolos pilosas; pecíolo 1 mm diâm. 1. Folíolo terminal maior que 0,7 cm larg. 2. Raque da folha 15−19 cm compr... 2. Raque da folha menor que 12 cm compr. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 286 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 5. Inflorescência laxa; flores com bractéolas menores do que o cálice. 6. Cálice e bractéolas estriados externamente; lacínios do cálice obtusos; vexilo
atenuado na base; núcleo seminífero enegrecido, asa discolor na base ............... .................................................................................................... 11. M. scleroxylon
6. Cálice e bractéolas lisos; lacínios do cálice triangulares; vexilo auriculado na base;
núcleo seminífero castanho, asa concolor ..................................... 9. M. ruddianum
5. Inflorescência congesta no ápice; flores com bractéolas do tamanho do cálice. 7. Tricomas de base dilatada presentes nas margens dos lacínios e bractéolas; estipe
maior que 1,5 mm compr., estilete até 2,5 mm compr. ......................6. M. nyctitans
7. Tricomas de base dilatada ausentes; estipe 1 mm compr., estilete maior que 3 mm
compr............................................................................................. 8. M. ovalifolium
1. Folíolo terminal até 0,7 cm larg. 8. Peciólulo até 0,5 mm compr. (folíolos subsésseis). 9. Superfície adaxial dos folíolos nítida, brilhante, nervuras secundárias imersas no
mesofilo ........................................................................................ 5. M. myrianthum
9. Superfície adaxial dos folíolos opaca, nervuras secundárias salientes. 10. Lianas; pedicelos 1,5−2 mm compr.; bractéolas orbiculares; ovário fulvo-viloso;
frutos falcados; Sudeste do Brasil................................................. 2. M. gracile
10. Subarbustos a árvores; pedicelos 1 mm compr.; bractéolas lanceoladas; ovário
ferrugíneo-seríceo; frutos ovados; Panamá ................................ 3. M. goudoti
8. Peciólulo maiores que 0,5 mm compr. 11. Bractéolas do tamanho do cálice; bainha de estames glabra; estigma conspícuo ..... ................................................................................................... 4. M. hatschbachii
11. Bractéolas menores que o cálice; bainha de estames puberulenta nas margens; estigma
inconspícuo ........................................................................................ 1. M. floridum 1. Machaerium floridum (Mart. ex Benth.)
Ducke, Arch. Jard. Bot. Rio de Janeiro 5: 135. 1930. Fig. 1 1. Machaerium floridum (Mart. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga ex Benth.)
Ducke, Arch. Jard. Bot. Rio de Janeiro 5: 135. 1930. Fig. 1 8 × 1−3 cm, 17−25(−37)-folioladas; pecíolo
0,4−1 cm compr., 0,5−1 mm diâm., cilíndrico,
hialino-puberulento a ferrugíneo-viloso, às
vezes glabrescente; raque 2−7,5 cm compr.,
0,5−1 mm diâm., cilíndrico, indumento como
no pecíolo; peciólulo 0,5−1 mm compr. Folíolos alternos a subopostos, 0,4−2 × 0,3−
0,7 cm, ápice obtuso, levemente retuso,
mucronulado, base arredondada, obtusa,
cuneada a oblíqua, cartáceos, discolores,
margens inteiras, espessadas, revolutas,
superfície adaxial esparsamente hialino-
serícea a glabrescente, superfície abaxial
flava a hialino-serícea a vilosa na base,
glabrescente, venação broquidódroma. Panículas 2,5−12,5 × (1−)1,5−7,5 cm, até 3
vezes o comprimento das folhas, terminais,
às vezes axilares, laxas, multifloras; pedúnculo
0−1,7 cm compr., 0,5−1,5 mm diâm.; raque Drepanocarpus floridus Mart. ex
Benth., Comm. Legum. Gen.: 32. 1837; Ann. Mus. Vind. 2: 96. 1838. Typus: BRASIL. BAHIA: In sylvis provinciae Bahia, legit et
communic. Pr. Vidensis, 1829, Herbarium
Martii (Lectótipo, aqui designado BR!;
Isolectótipo BR!). Árvore 4-8 m alt. Tronco 12−15 cm
diâm., acúleos lineares com 8−10 × 2 mm na
base, casca lisa, levemente fissurada,
castanho-clara a acinzentada, lenticelada;
cerne creme, exsudato resinoso. Ramos 2−
5 mm diâm., sulcados longitudinalmente,
esbranquiçados, acinzentados a enegrecidos,
lenticelados, glabros. Estípulas 5−7 × 1−2 mm,
triangulares, retas, espinescentes. Folhas 3− Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 287 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. Figura 1 - Machaerium floridum (Mart. ex Benth.) Ducke - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor
em antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a Mori 10060; b Braz 76; c-l Santos 3205)
b
e
j
i
d
a
h
g
f
c
2 mm
2 mm
1 mm
2 cm
2 mm
2 cm b
2 cm 1 mm b 2 mm c 2 cm e a f h g Figura 1 - Machaerium floridum (Mart. ex Benth.) Ducke - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor
em antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a Mori 10060; b Braz 76; c-l Santos 3205) 3−3,5 vezes o compr. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga do cálice, pétalas
brancas, com nervuras avermelhadas,
dicotômicas, às vezes inconspícuas, como
também as superfícies internas das bractéolas
e do cálice; vexilo 6−7 × 4 mm, ovado,
superfície externa hialino-serícea a
ferrugíneo-tomentosa, superfície interna
flavo-tomentosa na margem a glabra, carnoso,
ápice obtuso, mucronulado, base atenuada,
unha 1,5 mm compr.; asas 6−6,5 × 1,5−2 mm,
elípticas, esparsamente fulvo-seríceas a
puberulentas no dorso, membranáceas, ápice
obtuso, base levemente auriculada, unha 1,4−11,5 cm compr., canescente-serícea a
ferrugíneo-tomentosa; eixos laterais 0,5−3,6 cm
compr., indumento como na raque. Brácteas
1−3 × 0,5−2 mm, triangulares a ovadas, côncavas,
canescente-tomentosas a ferrugíneo-seríceas,
membranáceas. Flores sésseis a subsésseis,
5−9 mm compr.; bractéolas 1,5−2,5 × 0,5−
1 mm, triangulares, cimbiformes, carnosas,
lisas, hialino-lanosas a ferrugíneo-tomentosas;
cálice 2,5−3 × 1−2,5 mm, 1,6−2 mm diâm.,
superfície lisa, hialina-serícea a ferrugíneo-
tomentosa, lacínios triangulares, os carenais
0,5 × 0,5 mm, os vexilares 0,5 × 0,8 mm; corola Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 288 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 1,5−2,5 mm compr.; pétalas da carena 6−7 × 2
mm, elípticas, glabras, membranáceas, ápice
agudo a obtuso, base auriculada, oblíqua, unha
2−2,5 mm compr.; estames 10, monadelfos, às
vezes diadelfos, soldados até 3−4 mm compr.;
filetes 4−6 mm compr., hialino-vilosos a
ferrugíneo-tomentosos nas laterais da bainha,
a hialino-vilosos nos estames vexilares, ao longo
do filete; anteras 0,5 × 0,5 mm, oblongas; disco
nectarífero 0,5 × 0,5 mm, cupulado; ovário
estipitado, 2−2,5 × 0,5−0,8 mm, hialino a
ferrugíneo-seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 1−1,5
mm, hialino a ferrugíneo-puberulento a seríceo;
estilete 2,5−3 mm compr., glabro. Fruto 3−4,6
cm compr.; estipe 0,2−0,4 cm compr.,
canescente, flavo a ferrugíneo-tomentoso;
núcleo seminífero 1−1,2 × 0,6−0,7 cm, 2−2,5
mm diâm., verde quando imaturo, castanho
escuro quando maturo, ferrugíneo-puberulento
a seríceo, superfície reticulada, fibroso; asa
2,4−3 × 0,8−1,3 cm, lanceolada, apresentando
ângulo menor que 90º em relação ao núcleo
seminífero, vinosa quando imatura, quando
matura concolor, castanho-clara, esparsamente
flavo-serícea a hialino-puberulenta, lisa,
reticulada, cartácea, ápice agudo a obtuso,
mucronulado, às vezes apiculado, margem
plana a levemente encurvada. Semente 8 × 4
mm; testa castanho-escura, ruminada da rafe
a 1/4 da margem, o restante corrugada; embrião
com primórdios foliares pluripinulados. Neste trabalho está sendo feita a correção
sobre o tipo da espécie. Em diversas exsicatas,
assinaladas com a informação “Campo Geral,
Brasil, Martius” que estão listadas no material
examinado, constavam etiquetas assinaladas
pela Dra. Velva E. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga Rudd, indicando tratar-se
aparentemente de um isótipo de Drepanocarpus
floridus Mart. ex Benth. var. floridus. Numa
dessas exsicatas (K-Hb. Hook.) há uma
interrogação feita por Martius sobre a
possibilidade de tratar-se de uma Dalbergia. Essas informações não correspondem ao que foi
apresentado no protólogo da espécie. Entretanto,
há duas exsicatas no herbário de Bruxelas nas
quais constam etiquetas com as mesmas
informações do protólogo e, portanto,
certamente correspondem à coleção sintípica. p
ç
p
A espécie apresenta afinidade com M. nyctitans e M. scleroxylon como indicado por
Benthan (1862) e Hoehne (1941) e também
com M. ruddianum. Distingue-se de M. nyctitans pelo menor tamanho dos folíolos,
pelas estípulas menores, pelas inflorescências
mais curtas, menos ramificadas, pelas brácteas
e bractéolas e pelas flores e frutos menores,
pela asa do fruto mais estreita. Diferencia-se
de M. scleroxylon pelo menor porte e tronco
liso, pelas inflorescências mais longas,
bractéolas maiores, lanceoladas, pelo cálice liso
e estipe normalmente mais curto e pela
coloração homogênea da asa do fruto. Diferencia-se de M. ruddianum pelo estilete
mais longo, vexilo ovado e androceu
pubescente na margem da bainha e pelo disco
nectarífero inconspícuo e assemelha-se pelas
características do tronco e das folhas. Material examinado: BRASIL. BAHIA?: Campo
Geral, 1829, C. P. von Martius s.n. (BM, K-Hb. Hook.;
Foto BM: UEC!); BAHIA: Caetité, rod. p/ Bom Jesus
da Lapa, 17.VI.1986, fr., G. Hatschbach & F. J. Zelma
50458 (CEPEC, K, MBM, MO, UC, US); Igaporã,
13.V.1978, fl., J. S. Silva 500 (F, SP, NY); Maracás,
13 a 22 km ao sul, antiga rod. Jequié, 27.IV.1978, fl.,
S. A. Mori et al. 10060 (CEPEC, K); MINAS
GERAIS: Aguas Vermelhas, próximo à comunidade
Maristela, 9.XI.2000, est., C. V. Mendonça & R. Belinello 628 (BHCB, UEC); Itaobim, 28.IV.1983,
fl., C. T. Rizzini & A.-Mattos-Filho 1567 (K, RB). Fenologia: floração de março a maio e
frutificação maio a agosto. 2. Machaerium gracile Benth., Comm. Legum. Gen. 34. 1837; ann. Mus. Vind. 2: 98
(1838). In: Martius & Eichler (eds.). Fl. bras. 15(1): 240. 1862. Typus: BRASIL: Schott s.n. (Holótipo K-Hb. Benth.!; Foto K: AMES!,
NY!, S!, UEC!). Fig. 2
Liana. Tronco com seção cilíndrica,
acúleos 4,5−10 × 1−3 mm, lineares a triangulares,
casca lisa, acinzentada, sulcada, lenticelas
circulares, cerne creme, exsudato avermelhado. Ramos 4 mm diâm., rugosos, acinzentados a 2. Machaerium gracile Benth., Comm. Legum. Gen. 34. 1837; ann. Mus. Vind. 2: 98
(1838). In: Martius & Eichler (eds.). Fl. bras. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga Flores
pediceladas, 5−6 mm compr.; pedicelo 1,5−2 mm
compr., ferrugíneo-puberulento, glabrescente;
bractéolas 1,2 × 1 mm, orbiculares, côncavas,
carnosas, estriadas, ferrugíneo-puberulentas;
cálice 2−3,5 × 3 mm, 2 mm diâm., estriado
longitudinalmente, ferrugíneo-puberulento,
lacínios obtusos, os carenais 1−1,2 × 1 mm, os
vexilares 1 × 1−2 mm; corola 2,5 vezes o
compr. do cálice, pétalas alvo esverdeadas
com nervuras violáceas, dicotômicas, como
também as superfícies internas de bractéolas
e cálice; vexilo 5−6 × 4−5 mm, oblado, superfície
externa ferrugíneo-serícea, superfície interna
glabra, carnoso, ápice plano, base auriculada,
unha 1 mm compr.; asas 4,5−5,5 × 1,5 mm,
oblongas, glabras no dorso, membranáceas,
ápice obtuso, base levemente auriculada,
unha 1,5 mm compr.; pétalas da carena 4,5−
5,5 × 2 mm, elípticas, glabras no dorso,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base auriculada,
unha 2 mm compr.; estames 10, monadelfos,
soldados de 2 a 3,5 mm compr.; filetes 3,5−5 mm
compr., glabros; anteras 0,5 × 0,5 mm, oblongas;
disco nectarífero 0,2 × 0,2 mm, cupulado,
inconspícuo; ovário estipitado, 1,5 × 0,5 mm,
ferrugíneo-seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 1,5 mm
compr., ferrugíneo-seríceo; estilete 1,5 mm compr.,
glabro; estigma levemente capitado. Frutos 3−
7,2 cm compr.; estipe 0,8−1,2 cm compr.,
esparsamente ferrugíneo-seríceo, glabrescente;
núcleo seminífero 1,5−1,7 × 0,8−1 cm, 3 mm diâm.,
castanho-escuro, glabro, superfície verrucosa,
reticulada, fibroso; asa 2,5−4,5 × 1,2−1,5 cm,
falcada, apresentando ângulo igual ou maior
que 90º em relação ao núcleo seminífero,
homogênea, glabra, lisa, reticulada, cartácea,
ápice obtuso a agudo, apiculado, margem
plana. Semente reniforme, plano-comprimida. Material examinado: BRASIL. ESPÍRITO SANTO:
Santa Teresa, Escola Agrotécnica Federal,
11.XII.1985, fl., W. Boone 971 (CEPEC), idem.,
18.IX.2000, est., C. V. Mendonça & L. Kollmann
574 (MBML, UEC); MINAS GERAIS: Carangola,
Pedra do elefante, 13.XII.1988, fl., L. S. Leoni 582
(CEPEC, K); Coronel Pacheco, 10.II.1942, fl., E. P. Heringer 925 (US, VIC); RIO DE JANEIRO: Nova
Friburgo, Macaé de Cima, Sítio São João, 6.VI.1989,
fr., H. C. Lima et al. 3582 (BHCB, CEPEC, RB, SP). Fenologia: floração de setembro a fevereiro
e frutificação de março a agosto. ç
ç
g
Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, floresta costeira, 680-1200 m.s.m. Brasil: Espírito Santo, Minas Gerais e Rio
de Janeiro. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, floresta costeira, 680-1200 m.s.m. Brasil: Espírito Santo, Minas Gerais e Rio
de Janeiro. Foi observada foto do herbário F de uma
exsicata de M. gracile com coleta de Schott
4302, proveniente do herbário de Viena. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga 15(1): 240. 1862. Typus: BRASIL: Schott s.n. (Holótipo K-Hb. Benth.!; Foto K: AMES!,
NY!, S!, UEC!). Fig. 2 Liana. Tronco com seção cilíndrica,
acúleos 4,5−10 × 1−3 mm, lineares a triangulares,
casca lisa, acinzentada, sulcada, lenticelas
circulares, cerne creme, exsudato avermelhado. Ramos 4 mm diâm., rugosos, acinzentados a Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 289 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 289
Figura 2 - Machaerium gracile Benth.- a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em antese;
f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a Pereira 7251; b Lima 3747; c-l Sucre 6313)
2 mm
2 cm
2 mm
2 cm
2 mm
c
b
d
j
i
h
g
a
f
e
2 mm
1 mm 2 mm
c 2 mm c 1 mm 2 mm 2 mm 2 mm
g
f 2 mm h Figura 2 - Machaerium gracile Benth.- a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em antes
f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a Pereira 7251; b Lima 3747; c-l Sucre 6313) enegrecidos, lenticelados, espinescentes,
quando novos castanho-claros, glabros. Estípulas 2−3,7 × 1 mm, triangulares, retas,
espinescentes, estriadas, persistentes, às vezes
decíduas. Folhas 4,5−15 × 1−2,5 cm, 15−50-
folioladas; pecíolo 0,4−0,8 cm compr., 0,6 mm
diâm., ferrugíneo-seríceo; raque 4,7−6 cm compr.,
0,4 mm diâm., indumento como no pecíolo;
peciólulo 0,5 mm diâm. Folíolos alternos a
subopostos, 1−2,2 × 0,3−0,7 cm, ápice obtuso,
mucronulado, base obtusa, cuneada a oblíqua,
cartáceos, levemente discolores, margens planas, espessadas, superfície adaxial glabra,
superfície abaxial esparsamente ferrugíneo-
serícea, principalmente na nervura central,
glabrescente, venação broquidódroma. Inflorescência racemosa a paniculada, 2,5−7 ×
0,8−3 cm, do tamanho das folhas, axilar ou terminal,
pêndula, laxa; pedúnculo (0−)1,3−2,3 cm compr.,
0,5 mm diâm.; raque (0−)1−3,6 cm compr.,
ferrugíneo-puberulenta; eixos laterais 2,5−
5,3 cm compr., indumento como na raque. Brácteas 1,3−3,3 × 0,1−0,6 mm, triangulares a
filiformes, estriadas, ferrugíneo-seríceas, Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 290 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. Fenologia: floração de setembro a fevereiro
e frutificação de março a agosto. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, floresta costeira, 680-1200 m.s.m. Brasil: Espírito Santo, Minas Gerais e Rio
de Janeiro. membranáceas, às vezes decíduas. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga Abaixo da foto está grafada a indicação de
holótipo da espécie, possivelmente pela Dra. V.E. Rudd. Entretanto, no herbário de K (Hb. Benth.), foi observada uma exsicata de
material coletado por Schott, sem numeração,
assim como referido no protólogo da espécie,
e com manuscrito de Bentham na etiqueta,
sendo reconhecido como o holótipo da espécie. O porte de M. gracile lembra o de M. uncinatum (pertencente à seção Lineata) da
qual diferencia-se pelos folíolos com venação
broquidódroma (craspedódroma nesta última). As informações sobre as sementes foram
compiladas de Lima et al. (1994). Estes autores
citaram que M. gracile é uma espécie rara,
exclusiva da porção sudeste da floresta pluvial
atlântica que ocorre no Rio de Janeiro e Minas
Gerais, sendo esta, portanto, a primeira citação
para o Espírito Santo. 3. Machaerium goudoti Benth., J. Linn. Soc.,
Bot. 4 Suppl.: 59. 1860. Typus: Nova Granada:
em Ratata ou Oratata (nome não legível),
(Colômbia, Magdalena Valley), 1844, fl. e fr.,
M.J. Goudot s.n. (Síntipos G-DC-2, BM!, K!,
UEC-foto K!). Fig. 3 3. Machaerium goudoti Benth., J. Linn. Soc.,
Bot. 4 Suppl.: 59. 1860. Typus: Nova Granada:
em Ratata ou Oratata (nome não legível),
(Colômbia, Magdalena Valley), 1844, fl. e fr.,
M.J. Goudot s.n. (Síntipos G-DC-2, BM!, K!,
UEC-foto K!). Fig. 3 M. whitfordii J.F Macbr., Contrib. Gray
Herb., n.s. 56: 53. 1918. Typus: COLÔMBIA,
IUAGUAQUI: Boyacá, 180 m alt.,
14.VI.1917, fr.; H.N. Whitford & J. Pinzon
12 (Holótipo GH; Isótipos A, K!, UEC foto-
FI!; US foto!). M. whitfordii J.F Macbr., Contrib. Gray
Herb., n.s. 56: 53. 1918. Typus: COLÔMBIA,
IUAGUAQUI: Boyacá, 180 m alt.,
14.VI.1917, fr.; H.N. Whitford & J. Pinzon
12 (Holótipo GH; Isótipos A, K!, UEC foto-
FI!; US foto!). Subarbustos a árvores até 20 m alt. Tronco
10−20 cm diâm., inerme, casca escamosa,
fissurada, acinzentada; cerne enegrecido,
exsudato avermelhado. Ramos 3−5 mm diâm.,
lisos, sulcados, acinzentados, glabros, lenticelados,
espinescentes, quando novos esparsamente
fulvo-estrigosos. Estípulas 0,6−0,8(−1) × 0,1− Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 291 Figura 3 - Machaerium goudoti Benth.- a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. ovário. (a-c Goudot s.n.)
2 mm
a
c
b
2 cm b Figura 3 - Machaerium goudoti Benth.- a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. ovário. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (a-c Goudot s.n.) lanceoladas, estriadas, carnosas, glabras; cálice
2,5−4 × 2 mm, 2 mm diâm., superfície lisa, fulvo-
serícea, carnoso, lacínios carenais triangulares,
1−1,3 × 0,5 mm, lacínios vexilares lobados, 1 ×
1 mm; corola 2−2,5 vezes o compr. do cálice;
pétalas da carena 8 mm compr., conatas no
dorso; estames 10, diadelfos; ovário 2,5 × 2 mm,
fulvo-viloso; estipe e estilete 2 mm compr.;
estilete glabro, encurvado; estigma capitado. Fruto 5−7 cm compr.; estipe 5−6 mm compr.,
fulvo-viloso; núcleo seminífero 1,5−6 × 1 cm,
castanho-escuro, fulvo-tomentoso, superfície
lisa, nervuras longitudinais prolongadas em
direção ao ápice, fibroso; asa 3,5−4 × 1,7−2 cm,
ovada, ângulo menor que 90º em relação ao
núcleo seminífero, homogênea, pardacenta,
glabra, reticulada, cartácea, ápice obtuso,
margem plana. Sementes não observadas. 0,2 cm, triangulares, lisas a estriadas, retas,
espinescentes, às vezes decíduas. Folhas 11−
14,5 × 3−4 cm, 21−39-folioladas; pecíolo 0,75−
8,7 cm compr., 1 mm diâm., fulvo-hirsuto; raque
8−10 cm compr., 1 mm diâm., indumento como
no pecíolo; peciólulo 0,5 mm compr. Folíolos
alternos, 1,2−2,4 × 0,4−0,7 cm, ápice retuso, base
cuneada a oblíqua, cartáceos, discolores,
margens levemente revolutas, espessadas,
superfície adaxial glabrescente, superfície
abaxial hialino-serícea, nervura principal
avermelhada, venação broquidódroma. Racemos,
3,8−7,5 × 1−1,5 cm, 1/2 do compr. das folhas,
axilar; pedúnculo 0,7−1 cm compr., 0,7 mm
diâm., fulvo-tomentoso; raque 3,2−4 cm compr.,
indumento como no pedúnculo. Flores
pediceladas, 8 mm compr., pedicelo 1 mm compr.,
fulvo-tomentoso; bractéolas 1,2−2 × 0,5 mm, 0,2 cm, triangulares, lisas a estriadas, retas,
espinescentes, às vezes decíduas. Folhas 11−
14,5 × 3−4 cm, 21−39-folioladas; pecíolo 0,75−
8,7 cm compr., 1 mm diâm., fulvo-hirsuto; raque
8−10 cm compr., 1 mm diâm., indumento como
no pecíolo; peciólulo 0,5 mm compr. Folíolos
alternos, 1,2−2,4 × 0,4−0,7 cm, ápice retuso, base
cuneada a oblíqua, cartáceos, discolores,
margens levemente revolutas, espessadas,
superfície adaxial glabrescente, superfície
abaxial hialino-serícea, nervura principal
avermelhada, venação broquidódroma. Racemos,
3,8−7,5 × 1−1,5 cm, 1/2 do compr. das folhas,
axilar; pedúnculo 0,7−1 cm compr., 0,7 mm
diâm., fulvo-tomentoso; raque 3,2−4 cm compr.,
indumento como no pedúnculo. Flores
pediceladas, 8 mm compr., pedicelo 1 mm compr.,
fulvo-tomentoso; bractéolas 1,2−2 × 0,5 mm, Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 292 compr., 0,5−0,7 mm diâm., cilíndrica, indumento
como no pecíolo; peciólulo 0,5−1 mm compr. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga Folíolos alternos a subopostos, (0,8−)1,5−2,5 ×
0,3−0,7 cm, ápice obtuso, retuso, mucronulado,
base obtusa, cuneada a oblíqua, membranáceos
a cartáceos, levemente discolores, margens
inteiras, espessadas, revolutas, às vezes ciliadas,
superfície adaxial esparsamente hialino a
ferrugíneo-serícea, a glabra, superfície abaxial
esparso a densamente hialino a flavo-serícea,
venação broquidódroma. Racemos a panículas
(1−)2−4 × 0,7−1,5(−4) cm, até 0,5 do compr. das folhas, axilares, laxas, palcifloras, às vezes
com folhas entremeadas; pedúnculo (0−)0,3−
0,7 cm compr., 0,5−1 mm diâm.; raque 0,5−2 cm
compr.; ferrugíneo-serícea a tomentosa; eixos
laterais 1,5−2 cm compr., indumento como na
raque. Brácteas 2−7 × 1−4 mm, triangulares a
ovadas, ferrugíneo-tomentosas, glabrescentes,
endurecidas. Flores sésseis a subsésseis, 5−7 mm
compr., pedicelo 0,2−0,5 mm, ferrugíneo-seríceo
a tomentoso; bractéolas 2−3,5 × (0,5−)1−1,5 mm,
lanceoladas, cimbiformes, lisas, densamente
ferrugíneo-seríceas a tomentosas; cálice 3−3,5
× 2,5-3 mm, 2,4−3 mm diâm., superfície lisa,
ferrugíneo-serícea a tomentosa, lacínios carenais
(0,5−)1−1,5 × 0,5 mm, estreitamente triangulares,
lacínios vexilares triangulares (0,5−)1−1,5 × 1,6−
2 mm; corola 2−2,5 vezes o compr. do cálice,
pétalas vinosas, com nervuras avermelhadas,
dicotômicas, como também as superfícies
internas das bractéolas e do cálice; vexilo 5−6
× 5−6 mm, oblado, superfície externa ferrugíneo-
serícea, superfície interna ferrugíneo-tomentosa
na margem, ápice retuso, base levemente
auriculada, unha 1−2 mm compr.; asas 5−5,5 ×
1,5−2 mm, elípticas, glabras a esparsamente
hialino a ferrugíneo-seríceas no dorso,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base auriculada,
unha 1,5−2 mm compr.; pétalas da carena 4−5
× 2 mm, falcado-elípticas, glabras a esparsamente
hialino-seríceas no dorso, membranáceas, ápice
obtuso, base auriculada, unha 1,5−2 mm compr.;
estames 10, monadelfos, soldados até 2−3 mm
compr.; filetes 3−4,5 mm compr., glabros; anteras
0,25−0,5 × 0,25 mm, oblongas; disco nectarífero
0,5−1 × 0,5−1 mm, cupulado; ovário estipitado, compr., 0,5−0,7 mm diâm., cilíndrica, indumento
como no pecíolo; peciólulo 0,5−1 mm compr. Folíolos alternos a subopostos, (0,8−)1,5−2,5 ×
0,3−0,7 cm, ápice obtuso, retuso, mucronulado,
base obtusa, cuneada a oblíqua, membranáceos
a cartáceos, levemente discolores, margens
inteiras, espessadas, revolutas, às vezes ciliadas,
superfície adaxial esparsamente hialino a
ferrugíneo-serícea, a glabra, superfície abaxial
esparso a densamente hialino a flavo-serícea,
venação broquidódroma. Racemos a panículas
(1−)2−4 × 0,7−1,5(−4) cm, até 0,5 do compr. das folhas, axilares, laxas, palcifloras, às vezes
com folhas entremeadas; pedúnculo (0−)0,3−
0,7 cm compr., 0,5−1 mm diâm.; raque 0,5−2 cm
compr.; ferrugíneo-serícea a tomentosa; eixos
laterais 1,5−2 cm compr., indumento como na
raque. Brácteas 2−7 × 1−4 mm, triangulares a
ovadas, ferrugíneo-tomentosas, glabrescentes,
endurecidas. Chave para a identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga Flores sésseis a subsésseis, 5−7 mm
compr., pedicelo 0,2−0,5 mm, ferrugíneo-seríceo
a tomentoso; bractéolas 2−3,5 × (0,5−)1−1,5 mm,
lanceoladas, cimbiformes, lisas, densamente
ferrugíneo-seríceas a tomentosas; cálice 3−3,5
× 2,5-3 mm, 2,4−3 mm diâm., superfície lisa,
ferrugíneo-serícea a tomentosa, lacínios carenais
(0,5−)1−1,5 × 0,5 mm, estreitamente triangulares,
lacínios vexilares triangulares (0,5−)1−1,5 × 1,6−
2 mm; corola 2−2,5 vezes o compr. do cálice,
pétalas vinosas, com nervuras avermelhadas,
dicotômicas, como também as superfícies
internas das bractéolas e do cálice; vexilo 5−6
× 5−6 mm, oblado, superfície externa ferrugíneo-
serícea, superfície interna ferrugíneo-tomentosa
na margem, ápice retuso, base levemente
auriculada, unha 1−2 mm compr.; asas 5−5,5 ×
1,5−2 mm, elípticas, glabras a esparsamente
hialino a ferrugíneo-seríceas no dorso,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base auriculada,
unha 1,5−2 mm compr.; pétalas da carena 4−5
× 2 mm, falcado-elípticas, glabras a esparsamente
hialino-seríceas no dorso, membranáceas, ápice
obtuso, base auriculada, unha 1,5−2 mm compr.;
estames 10, monadelfos, soldados até 2−3 mm
compr.; filetes 3−4,5 mm compr., glabros; anteras
0,25−0,5 × 0,25 mm, oblongas; disco nectarífero
0,5−1 × 0,5−1 mm, cupulado; ovário estipitado, Material examinado: COLÔMBIA. Rio
Tucurinca, 16.VIII.1936, est., A. Dugand 1015 (F);
CUNDINAMARCA: 4.V.1944, fr., E. P. Killip et al.
38136 (F); PANAMA. CHIRIQUI: IV.1858, est., M.
Wagner 319 (M). Material examinado: COLÔMBIA. Rio
Tucurinca, 16.VIII.1936, est., A. Dugand 1015 (F);
CUNDINAMARCA: 4.V.1944, fr., E. P. Killip et al. 38136 (F); PANAMA. CHIRIQUI: IV.1858, est., M. Wagner 319 (M). Fenologia: floração não conhecida e
frutificação de maio a junho. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: em áreas
montanhosas. Colômbia e Panamá. Nome popular: “negrillo” No protólogo da espécie Bentham (1860)
citou que foram examinadas duas exsicatas do
herbário G-DC, que não foram aqui analisadas. Como os materiais analisados por Bentham não
estavam, segundo o autor, em boas condições,
nem tão pouco os demais materiais observados
no MBM e K, não foi designado um lectótipo. No protólogo da espécie Bentham (1860)
citou que foram examinadas duas exsicatas do
herbário G-DC, que não foram aqui analisadas. Como os materiais analisados por Bentham não
estavam, segundo o autor, em boas condições,
nem tão pouco os demais materiais observados
no MBM e K, não foi designado um lectótipo. Essa espécie tem sido pouco coletada e
por isto foi descrita através da análise da
coleção típica, do auxílio da diagnose e de outras
coleções. Bentham (1860) indicou que as
características do ovário distinguem essa
espécie das demais do gênero. 4. Machaerium hatschbachii Rudd,
Phytologia 26(2): 100. 1973. Typus: BRASIL. PARANÁ: Campina Grande do Sul, Sítio do
Belizário, 23.XI.1966, fl., G. Hatschbach
15254 (Holótipo US!; Isótipos C!, L!, MBM!,
P, SI, UC!, UPCB!). Fig. 4 Árvore 7−20 m alt. Tronco reto, 25−40 cm
diâm., aculeados nos rebrotos, acúleos 8−12(−18)
× 1−2 mm na base, triangulares, casca escamosa,
acinzentada, com lenticelas horizontais, cerne
creme, entrecasca avermelhada, exsudato
ausente. Ramos 2−4 mm diâm., sulcados
longitudinalmente, acinzentados a enegrecidos,
glabros, lenticelados, espinescentes, às vezes
inermes, quando novos glabros a esparsamente
hialino a ferrugíneo-puberulentos, gemas axilares
ovadas a lanceoladas. Estípulas (2−)6−8(−12)
× 1−2 mm, lineares a triangulares, retas,
espinescentes, às vezes decíduas. Folhas (3−)
5,5−9(−13) × 1,5−2,5 cm, 15−25(−31)-folioladas;
pecíolo 0,4−0,6(−1) cm compr., 0,4−0,5 mm diâm.,
cilíndrico, flavo-seríceo a ferrugíneo-estrigoso
a tomentoso; raque (2,5−)4,5−8(−10,5) cm Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 293 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. Figura 4 - Machaerium hatschbachii Rudd - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em antese;
f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a Maschio 220; b Ziller 814; c-l Hatschbach 20347)
2 mm
2 mm
2 mm
c
j
g
f
e
d
i
a
b
1 mm
2 cm
2 cm
2 mm
2 mm
h
2 mm
2 mm 2 mm c 2 cm 2 mm 2 mm g Figura 4 - Machaerium hatschbachii Rudd - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em antes
f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. Nome popular: “negrillo” (a Maschio 220; b Ziller 814; c-l Hatschbach 20347) 16280 (L!, MBM!, NY!, SI, US!, PARÁTIPOS); Cerro
Azul, Morro Grande, G. Hatschbach 6390 (C!, LP!,
MBM!, UPCB!, US!, WAG!, PARÁTIPOS); Dr. Ulysses, na divisa com Cerro Azul, 6.X.1999, fr., C.V. Mendonça & G. Hatschbach 521 (BHCB, UEC);
Guaraqueçaba, Rio do Cedro, G. Hatschbach 18117
(CEPEC!, F!, K!, MBM!, NY!, US, PARÁTIPOS);
Guaraqueçaba, Serrinha, 1.VI.1967, fr., G. Hatschbach
16506 (L!, MBM!, SI, PARÁTIPOS); Guaratuba, Rio
Itararé, G. Hatschbach 15118 (C!, F!, L!, P, SI, MBM!,
NY!, UC!, US!, WAG, PARÁTIPOS); Piraquara,
Campininha, G. Hatschbach 2652 (LP!, MBM!, SI,
PARÁTIPOS); SÃO PAULO: Cananéia, Ilha do
Cardoso, 5.XII.1990, fl., F. Barros & J. E. L. S. Ribeiro
2025 (SP); São Vicente, Morro do Japu, 3.III.1991,
fl., F. S. Santos 24205 (UEC). 2 × 1 mm, densamente ferrugíneo-seríceo a
tomentoso; estipe 1−1,5 mm, ferrugíneo-seríceo
a tomentoso; estilete 1 mm compr., glabro. Fruto
3−7 cm compr.; estipe 0,4−0,8 mm compr.,
esparsamente ferrugíneo-seríceo, glabrescente;
núcleo seminífero 1−2,2 × 0,7−1,7(−2,4) cm, 2 mm
diâm., esparsamente ferrugíneo-puberulento a
glabro, superfície reticulada, 4 nervuras
longitudinais, prolongadas em direção a asa,
fibroso; asa 3−4,5 × (0,8−)1−1,3 cm, falcada,
formando com o núcleo seminífero ângulo maior
que 90º, castanho clara a escura, concolor,
esparsamente ferrugíneo-puberulenta a
glabra, lisa, reticulada, cartácea, ápice obtuso
a apiculado, margem plana a encurvada. M t i l
i
d
BRASIL PARANÁ A t
i Fenologia: floração de novembro a março e
frutificação de dezembro a junho. Fenologia: floração de novembro a março e
frutificação de dezembro a junho. Fenologia: floração de novembro a março e
frutificação de dezembro a junho. Material examinado: BRASIL. PARANÁ: Antonina,
Cacatu, 20.XI.1968, fl., G. Hatschbach 20347 (C, M,
MBM, MO, NY, UC, UEC, US, WAG); Campina
Grande do Sul, Sítio do Belizário, G. Hatschbach Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
costeira, floresta de araucária. BRASIL: São Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
costeira, floresta de araucária. BRASIL: São Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 294 puberulentos, ramos apreensores laterais com
acúleos uncinados. Estípulas decíduas não
observadas. Folhas 5−14 cm × 3−4 cm, 29−51
(−149)-folioladas; pecíolo 0,1−0,5 cm compr.,
1 mm diâm., cilíndrico, fusco-puberulento a hípido-
tomentoso; raque 4,8−13 cm compr., 0,8 mm
diâm., indumento como no pecíolo; peciólulo
0−0,4 mm compr. Nome popular: “negrillo” Brácteas 1−1,5 × 0,5 mm, triangulares
a orbiculares, fulvo a ferrugíneo-puberulentas,
cartáceas, às vezes decíduas. Flores sésseis a
subsésseis, 5−7,3 mm compr., bractéolas 1,2−
1,4 × 0,5−1,4 mm, oblongas a orbiculares, lisas,
fulvo a ferrugíneo-seríceas, carnosas; cálice 2,5−
3,3 × 2,5−2,8 mm, 2,4 mm diâm., superfície lisa,
fulvo a ferrugíneo-serícea, carnoso, lacínios
carenais triangulares, 0,8 × 1 mm, lacínios
vexilares 0,5−1 × 1−1,2 mm, lobados; corola 2
vezes o compr. do cálice, pétalas esbranquiçadas
a amareladas, com nervuras dicotômicas
inconspícuas; vexilo 3,5−5,5 × 3−3,3 mm,
cordiforme, superfície externa glabrescente,
superfície interna glabra, carnoso, ápice fissurado,
base auriculada, unha 1−1,5 mm compr.; asas
3,5−6,6 × 1,4−2 mm, oblongas, glabras,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base auriculada,
unha 1,4−2,7 mm compr.; pétalas da carena 4−
6 × 2 mm, elípticas, conatas no dorso, glabras,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base auriculada,
unha 1,7−2,9 mm compr.; estames 10, semelhantes
em compr. e tamanho, monadelfos; filetes 4,2−
5,2 mm compr., glabros; anteras 0,2 × 0,2 mm,
oblongas; disco nectarífero 0,3−0,5 × 0,3−0,8 mm,
cupulado; ovário estipitado, 1−2 × 0,6−1 mm,
fulvo-seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 2−3 mm compr.,
glabro; estilete 1,4 mm compr., glabro; estigma
levemente capitado. Fruto 5,5−7 cm compr.; A espécie distingue-se de M. floridum,
M. nyctitans, M. scleroxylon e M. ruddianum
pelo tronco com casca escamosa, acinzentada,
pelo estigma amplamente captado e pelos frutos
geniculados. De M. nyctitans distingue-se pelo
menor tamanho das flores e dos folíolos e pelas
inflorescências menores, paucifloras, laxas, e
assemelha-se no formato e revestimento de
brácteas e bractéolas, estas geralmente do mesmo
comprimento do cálice. Das outras espécies
distingue-se pelas brácteas florais maiores e
corola até 2,5 vezes o compr. do cálice. Diferencia-se de M. scleroxylon também pelas
bractéolas lanceoladas, pelas flores menores,
cálice liso, vexilo quase orbicular e pelos folíolos
numerosos, mais revestidos, como também
observado por Rudd (1973) e Sartori & Tozzi
(1998). De M. floridum e M. ruddianum
distingue-se pelo porte maior, inflorescências
mais curtas e pelas pétalas da carena com base
fortemente auriculada. Os materiais citados
para São Paulo representam a primeira
referência da espécie para este estado. 5. Machaerium myrianthum Spruce ex
Benth., J. Linn. Soc., Bot. 4 Suppl.: 59. 1860. In: Martius & Eichler (eds.) Fl. bras. 15(1): 241. 1862. Typus: VENEZUELA: near Panuré, on
the Rio Vaupés, I.1853, fl. e fr., R. Spruce 2758
(Holótipo K-Hb. Nome popular: “negrillo” Folíolos alternos, (0,3−)0,6−2,8
× (0,1−)0,3−0,7 cm, linear-oblongos, ápice obtuso,
levemente retuso, base cuneada a oblíqua,
cartáceos, discolores, margens revolutas,
espessadas, superfície adaxial glabra, superfície
abaxial ferrugíneo-serícea a vilosa na nervura
principal, glabrescente, venação broquidódroma. Panículas, 5−30 × 4−15 cm, terminais, laxas;
pedúnculo 0−0,8 cm compr., 0,7 mm diâm.; raque
5−7,7 cm compr., fulvo a ferrugíneo-puberulenta;
eixos laterais 2−5,6 cm compr., indumento como
na raque. Brácteas 1−1,5 × 0,5 mm, triangulares
a orbiculares, fulvo a ferrugíneo-puberulentas,
cartáceas, às vezes decíduas. Flores sésseis a
subsésseis, 5−7,3 mm compr., bractéolas 1,2−
1,4 × 0,5−1,4 mm, oblongas a orbiculares, lisas,
fulvo a ferrugíneo-seríceas, carnosas; cálice 2,5−
3,3 × 2,5−2,8 mm, 2,4 mm diâm., superfície lisa,
fulvo a ferrugíneo-serícea, carnoso, lacínios
carenais triangulares, 0,8 × 1 mm, lacínios
vexilares 0,5−1 × 1−1,2 mm, lobados; corola 2
vezes o compr. do cálice, pétalas esbranquiçadas
a amareladas, com nervuras dicotômicas
inconspícuas; vexilo 3,5−5,5 × 3−3,3 mm,
cordiforme, superfície externa glabrescente,
superfície interna glabra, carnoso, ápice fissurado,
base auriculada, unha 1−1,5 mm compr.; asas
3,5−6,6 × 1,4−2 mm, oblongas, glabras,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base auriculada,
unha 1,4−2,7 mm compr.; pétalas da carena 4−
6 × 2 mm, elípticas, conatas no dorso, glabras,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base auriculada,
unha 1,7−2,9 mm compr.; estames 10, semelhantes
em compr. e tamanho, monadelfos; filetes 4,2−
5,2 mm compr., glabros; anteras 0,2 × 0,2 mm,
oblongas; disco nectarífero 0,3−0,5 × 0,3−0,8 mm,
cupulado; ovário estipitado, 1−2 × 0,6−1 mm,
fulvo-seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 2−3 mm compr.,
glabro; estilete 1,4 mm compr., glabro; estigma
levemente capitado Fruto 5 5−7 cm compr ; Paulo e Paraná. As citações para o estado de
São Paulo são inéditas para a espécie, que era
conhecida apenas para o estado do Paraná. Nome popular: “jacarandá-de-espinho”. puberulentos, ramos apreensores laterais com
acúleos uncinados. Estípulas decíduas não
observadas. Folhas 5−14 cm × 3−4 cm, 29−51
(−149)-folioladas; pecíolo 0,1−0,5 cm compr.,
1 mm diâm., cilíndrico, fusco-puberulento a hípido-
tomentoso; raque 4,8−13 cm compr., 0,8 mm
diâm., indumento como no pecíolo; peciólulo
0−0,4 mm compr. Folíolos alternos, (0,3−)0,6−2,8
× (0,1−)0,3−0,7 cm, linear-oblongos, ápice obtuso,
levemente retuso, base cuneada a oblíqua,
cartáceos, discolores, margens revolutas,
espessadas, superfície adaxial glabra, superfície
abaxial ferrugíneo-serícea a vilosa na nervura
principal, glabrescente, venação broquidódroma. Panículas, 5−30 × 4−15 cm, terminais, laxas;
pedúnculo 0−0,8 cm compr., 0,7 mm diâm.; raque
5−7,7 cm compr., fulvo a ferrugíneo-puberulenta;
eixos laterais 2−5,6 cm compr., indumento como
na raque. Nome popular: “negrillo” Benth.!; Foto K: AMES!, C!,
F!, NY!, S!, UEC!; Isótipos BM!, BR!, C!, F!,
K!; Foto C: AMES!, MO!, Foto K: AMES!,
F!, NY!, S!, UEC!). Fig. 5 M. multifoliolatum Ducke, Bull. Mus. Hist. Nat. Paris, 2(5): 734-735. 1932; Arq. Jard. Bot. Rio de Janeiro 6: 34. 1933. Typus: BRASIL. AMAZONAS: Manaus, margem do igapó da
cabeceira do iguarapé do Crespo, 17.XII.1929,
fl., A. Ducke s.n. (Lectótipo RB!), syn. nov. Liana; inerme, exsudato avermelhado. Ramos 2−3 mm diâm., superfície escamosa,
glabros, às vezes lenticelados, com acúleos
uncinados 4 × 1 5 mm quando novos fusco- Liana; inerme, exsudato avermelhado. Ramos 2−3 mm diâm., superfície escamosa,
glabros, às vezes lenticelados, com acúleos
uncinados, 4 × 1,5 mm, quando novos fusco- Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 295 Figura 5 - Machaerium myrianthum Spruce ex Benth. - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em
antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; j. asa; l. pétalas da carena. (a Liesner 7324; b Zarucchi 2430, c-l Lasser 1940)
c
2 cm
f
j
i
h
g
e
d
a
b
2 mm
2 mm
2 mm
1 mm
2 cm
2 mm d
1 mm e
2 mm 1 mm 2 mm d 2 mm b g 2 mm h Figura 5 - Machaerium myrianthum Spruce ex Benth. - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor e
antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; j. asa; l. pétalas da carena. (a Liesner 7324; b Zarucchi 2430, c-l Lasser 1940 estipe 6−7 mm compr., fulvo-seríceo; núcleo
seminífero 1,2−1,6 × 0,6−0,7 cm, castanho-
escuro, fulvo-seríceo, superfície lisa, reticulada,
fibroso; asa 3,4−4,5 × 1,3−1,5 cm, oblanceolada,
com ângulo maior que 90º em relação ao núcleo
seminífero, homogênea, fulvo-puberulenta,
lisa, reticulada, cartácea, ápice obtuso,
mucronulado, margem plana. DEMERARA: entre os rios Demerara e Berbice,
15.VII.1922. fl., J. S. La Cruz 1612 (AMES, F, MO,
NY, UC); GUIANA FRANCESA. Cayenne, 15.II.1985,
est., M. Sauvain 248 (U); SURINAME. BROKOPONDO:
28.I.1966, est., J. van Donselaar 3082 (U); NICKERIE:
20.XI.1976, est., N. M. Heyde & J. C. Lindeman 220
(U); VENEZUELA. BOLIVAR: IV.1956, fl., Vareschi
& Foldats 4529b (NY); idem, entre Puerta Lema e
a base da serra, 24.IX.1961, fr., J. A. Steyermark
89460 (NY); BRASIL. AMAZONAS: Cerro
Neblina, Rio Mawarinuma, 20.IV.1984, est., A. Gentry
& B. Nome popular: “negrillo” Stein 46784 (MO, NY); MATO GROSSO:
Tabajara, divisa com Rondônia, rio Machado, Material examinado: COLOMBIA. VAUPÉS: 3 km
de Mitú, 4.VII.1979, fr., J. L. Zarucchi 2430 (AMES,
U); GUIANA. Dadanawa, rio Rupununi, 14.VI.1922,
fl., J. S. La Cruz 1500 (AMES, F, MO, NY, US); Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 296 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. (Lectótipo, aqui designado SPF; Isolectótipo RB;
Síntipo: Viçosa, 24.X.1935, est., J. G. Kuhlmann
s.n. RB, SPF, VIC). Syn. nov. (Lectótipo, aqui designado SPF; Isolectótipo RB;
Síntipo: Viçosa, 24.X.1935, est., J. G. Kuhlmann
s.n. RB, SPF, VIC). Syn. nov. (Lectótipo, aqui designado SPF; Isolectótipo RB;
Síntipo: Viçosa, 24.X.1935, est., J. G. Kuhlmann
s.n. RB, SPF, VIC). Syn. nov. 29.XI.1931, fl., B. A. Krukoff 1516 (AMES, BM, F,
K, MO, S, NY, UC); PARÁ: alto Tapajós, rio Cururu,
12.II.1974, fr., W. R. Anderson 10816 (IAN, NY);
RORAIMA, estrada de Surucucu a Uaicá, Serra dos
Surucucus, 6.II.1971, fl., G. T. Prance et al. 13518
(F, K, NY, S, U, WAG). Árvore 5−25 m alt.; tronco reto, 6−57
(−100) cm diâm., aculeado, acúleos 8-10 × 2 mm
na base, casca escamosa, acinzentada, cerne
creme, exsudato avermelhado, resinoso. Ramos
3−6 mm diâm., levemente sulcados, castanho-
escuros, glabrescentes, lenticelados,
espinescentes, acúleos piramidais, quando
novos ferrugíneo-seríceos, glabrescentes, às
vezes inermes. Estípulas 5−28 × 1−8 mm,
lineares a triangulares, retas, espinescentes, às
vezes decíduas. Folhas 8−18 × 3−6 cm, 13−29-
folioladas; pecíolo 0,8−2 cm compr., 1−6 mm
diâm., hialino a fulvo-seríceo a ferrugíneo-
estrigoso a tomentoso, glabrescente; raque
4,8−8,2 cm compr., 1 mm diâm., indumento
como no pecíolo; peciólulo 0,7−2 mm compr. Folíolos alternos, 1,5−4 × 0,6−2 cm, ápice obtuso
a retuso, mucronulado, base arredondada,
obtusa, cuneada, cartáceos, levemente
discolores a concolores, margens planas a
levemente revolutas, espessadas, superfície
adaxial esparçamente hialino-vilosa, hialino-
puberulenta na nervura principal, glabrescente,
superfície abaxial fulvo a canescente-serícea
a vilosa, venação broquidódroma. Racemos ou
panículas 5−29 × 3−25 cm, do tamanho a até 5
vezes o comprimento das folhas, terminais, raro
axilares, pêndulas, congestas, multifloras, às
vezes com folhas entremeadas; pedúnculo (0−)
0,6−2 cm compr., 1−6 mm diâm.; raque (0−)
1,5−12 cm compr., canaliculada, flavo a ferrugíneo-
puberulenta, tomentosa, estrigosa a vilosa; eixos
laterais 04−3,5 cm compr., ferrugíneo-seríceos,
às vezes com tricomas esparsos, de base larga. Machaerium nyctitans var. gardneri
(Benth.) Rudd, Phytologia 26(2): 100 (1973). M. sericiflorum Gardn. nom. ileg. In: Hook,
Lond. Journ. Bot. 2: 341. 1843. non Vogel, 1837. Nome popular: “negrillo” Brácteas 2−4,7 × 1−2 mm triangulares, deltadas
a ovadas, espinescentes, a lanceoladas,
cimbiformes, carnosas, esparsamente flavo a
ferrugíneo-seríceas a tomentosas, às vezes
canescentes, a glabras. Flores sésseis a subsésseis,
7,8−12 mm compr.; pedicelo 0−1 mm compr.,
fulvo a a ferrugíneo-seríceo; bractéolas 3−5 ×
0,5−1,5 cm, falcadas a lanceoladas, cimbiformes,
lisas, carnosas, canescente a ferrugíneo-
seríceas, às vezes com tricomas de base Fenologia: floração de outubro a julho e
frutificação de dezembro a julho. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, igapó. Colômbia, Guiana, Guiana
Francesa, Suriname, Venezuela. Brasil:
Amazonas, Mato Grosso, Pará, Roraima. Nome popular: “kabu-jasi-tatay (Suriname). A observação da coleção típica de
M. multifoliolatum não deixou dúvidas sobre
sua inclusão na sinonímia de M. myrianthum,
principalmente quanto às características da
inflorescência, demais detalhes florais e dos
frutos. O menor tamanho e maior número dos
folíolos descritos para M. multifoliolatum
foram considerados uma variação populacional,
não justificando seu reconhecimento como
táxon distinto. 6. Machaerium nyctitans (Vell.) Benth.,
Comm. Legum. Gen.: 34. 1837; Ann. Mus. Vind. 2: 98. 1838, “nictitans”. Fig. 6
Nissolia nyctitans Vell., Fl. fl. 295. 1829
í1825ý; (Lectótipo: Fl. fl., Icon. 7: tab. 75. 1831 í1827ý; Epitipo, aqui designado: BRASIL. RIO DE JANEIRO: São Cristovão, 4.X.1878,
fl., A. Glaziou 8404 (BR!; Isótipos C!, S!, NY!). M. gardneri Benth., J. Linn. Soc., Bot.,
4 Suppl.: 60. 1860. In: Martius & Eichler (eds.). Flora bras. 15(1): 242. 1862. Typus: BRASIL. RIO DE JANEIRO: Rio de Janeiro, Serra dos
Orgãos, IV.1837, fl., G. Gardner 357
(Holótipo K-Hb. Hook.!; Foto K: AMES!, F!,
NY!, S!, UEC!; Isótipos K-Hb. Benth.!, BM!;
Foto K: AMES!, F!, UEC!). Machaerium nyctitans var. gardneri
(Benth.) Rudd, Phytologia 26(2): 100 (1973). M. sericiflorum Gardn. nom. ileg. In: Hook,
Lond. Journ. Bot. 2: 341. 1843. non Vogel, 1837. M. kuhlmannii Hoehne, Arq. Bot. Est. S. Paulo 1(1): 33. 1938. Typus: BRASIL. MINAS
GERAIS: estrada que vai de Caratinga a Entre-
Folhas, 26.VII.1928, fr., J.G. Kuhlmann 50 M. kuhlmannii Hoehne, Arq. Bot. Est. S. Paulo 1(1): 33. 1938. Typus: BRASIL. MINAS
GERAIS: estrada que vai de Caratinga a Entre-
Folhas, 26.VII.1928, fr., J.G. Kuhlmann 50 Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 297 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. Figura 6 - Machaerium nyctitans (Vell.) Benth. - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; c´. lacínio; d. bractéola; e. flor
em antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. Nome popular: “negrillo” Fruto 5,3−
8,2 cm compr.; estipe 0,5−0,9 cm compr., fulvo
a ferrugíneo-seríceo a tomentoso; núcleo
seminífero 1,4−1,7 × 0,7−1 cm, 4,6−6 mm
diâm., castanho-escuro, esparsamente fulvo a
ferrugíneo-seríceo a tomentoso, glabrescente,
superfície verrucosa, estriada, 3 a 6 nervuras
principais prolongadas em direção a asa,
fibroso; asa 4−4,7 × 1,3−2 cm, falcada a
oblanceolada, apresentando ângulo menor que
90º com o núcleo seminífero, homogênea,
esparsamente hialino a ferrugíneo-puberulenta
a serícea, às vezes glabra, lisa, reticulada,
cartácea, ápice obtuso, mucronulado, margem
plana a levemente encurvada, semente 1,4−1,6
× 0,7−1 cm, 3 mm diâm., reniforme; embrião
com promórdios foliares pluripinulados. Fenologia: floração de janeiro a outubro e
frutificação de fevereiro a novembro. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
costeira, floresta de araucária, Província
Paranaense, em solo arenoso. Argentina: San
Pedro, San Tomé. Brasil: Bahia, Minas Gerais
Paraná, Rio de Janeiro e São Paulo. Nomes populares: “bico-de-pato”; “jacarandá-
bico-de-pato”, “bico-de-pato-grande” “chimbé”;
“tapa-tripa” (Brasil). “cuentrillo” (Argentina). p
p
(
)
(
g
)
A ampla variação observada em M. nyctitans foi o que possivelmente levou
Bentham (1860) a descrever M. gardneri,
incluída na sinonímia de M. nyctitans por
Hoehne (1941). Rudd (1973) não concordou
com o último autor e estabeleceu uma
combinação nova M. nyctitans var. gardneri
(Benth.) Rudd, sendo portanto a primeira a
reconhecer um táxon infra-específico. Entretanto, Rudd (com. pes., 1992) reconheceu
a dificuldade de algumas vezes diferenciar as
duas variedades. Outros autores têm indicado
que o atual nível de conhecimento sobre a
espécie sugere o uso de um conceito amplo,
sem separação de táxons infra-específicos
(Lima et al. 1994; Lima 1995; Sartori & Tozzi
1998), conceito aqui adotado. Material examinado: ARGENTINA. MISSIONES:
San Pedro, 26.IX.1945, fr., Bertoni 2135 (BM, F,
K); CORRIENTES: San Tomé, 8.IV.1992, fl., S. G. Tressens et al. 4018 (AMES, C, CTES, F, MBM,
MO, NY, UB); idem, 27.VIII.1992, fr., M. Pompert
43 (AMES, C, CTES, F, MBM, MO, NY, UB). BRASIL. BAHIA: Almadina, 2.III.1971, fl., R. S. Pinheiro 1110 (CEPEC, US); Ilhéus, distrito de
Rio do Engenho, Faz. Theobroma, 1.VII.1995, fr.,
L. A. Mattos Silva 3151 (ALCB, CEPEC, NY);
ESPÍRITO SANTO: Linhares, CVRD, 14.VIII.2001,
fr., D. A. Folli 4001 (CVRD, UEC); MINAS
GERAIS: Caratinga, estrada para Entre-Folhas, 1,5
km do trevo, 10.XI.1993, fr., C. V. Mendonça & F. Garcia 304 (BHCB); Três Pontas, Faz. Jacarandá,
12.IV.1998, fl., C. V. Mendonça 428 (BHCB, SPF);
PARANÁ: Antonina, Sapitanduva, 28.II.1969, fl.,
G. Nome popular: “negrillo” (a Mexia 4741; b Mendonça 428; c-l Mexia 4724)
i
h
2 mm
2 mm
e
c
j
2 mm
2 cm
b
a
d
2 cm
1 mm
f
g
c’
2 mm
1 mm 2 mm c 1 mm b 2 mm e 2 mm h g f Figura 6 - Machaerium nyctitans (Vell.) Benth. - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; c´. lacínio; d. bractéola; e. fl
em antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a Mexia 4741; b Mendonça 428; c-l Mexia 472 dilatada nas margens; cálice 3,7−6 × 2,2−3 mm,
2−3,7 mm diâm., campanulado a cilíndrico,
superfície lisa, canescente, fulvo a ferrugíneo-
serícea, carnoso, lacínios com esparsos tricomas
de base larga, os carenais 1−3 × 0,5−1 mm,
triangulares a estreitamente triangulares, o
central às vezes mais longo, os vexilares 0,8−
2,6 × 0,5−1,6 mm, triangulares a estreitamente
triangulares; corola 2−2,5 vezes o comprimento
do cálice, pétalas vinosas, apresentando nervuras
avermelhadas, dicotômicas, como as superfícies
internas das bractéolas e do cálice; vexilo
6,4−10 × 5−8 mm, orbicular, internamente lilás, dilatada nas margens; cálice 3,7−6 × 2,2−3 mm,
2−3,7 mm diâm., campanulado a cilíndrico,
superfície lisa, canescente, fulvo a ferrugíneo-
serícea, carnoso, lacínios com esparsos tricomas
de base larga, os carenais 1−3 × 0,5−1 mm,
triangulares a estreitamente triangulares, o
central às vezes mais longo, os vexilares 0,8−
2,6 × 0,5−1,6 mm, triangulares a estreitamente
triangulares; corola 2−2,5 vezes o comprimento
do cálice, pétalas vinosas, apresentando nervuras
avermelhadas, dicotômicas, como as superfícies
internas das bractéolas e do cálice; vexilo
6,4−10 × 5−8 mm, orbicular, internamente lilás, superfície externa fulvo-serícea, superfície
interna fulvo a ferrugíneo-puberulenta a
tomentosa na margem, carnoso, ápice retuso,
às vezes mucronulado, base atenuada a
auriculada, unha 1,3−2 mm compr.; asas 6,5−9
× 2−3 mm, oblongas, glabras no dorso,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, fulvo a ferrugíneo-
puberulento a tomentoso, glabrescente, base
levemente auriculada a truncada, unha 2,2−
3,5 mm compr.; pétalas da carena 6,6−9 × 2−
3 mm, elípticas a oblongas, conatas, glabras a
esparsamente ferrugíneo-seríceas no dorso,
membranáceas, ápice agudo a obtuso, base Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 298 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Nome popular: “negrillo” auriculada a truncada, unha 2−4 mm compr.;
estames 10, monadelfos, soldados 3−6 mm
compr., às vezes diadelfos; filetes 4−8 mm compr.,
glabros a ferrugíneo-puberulentos a seríceos
na margem da bainha; anteras 0,5−0,9 × 0,2−
0,5 mm, oblongas; disco nectarífero 0,5-1 ×
0,5−1,4 mm, cupulado; ovário estipitado, 2−4 ×
0,8−2 mm, flavo, fulvo a ferrugíneo-tomentoso
a seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 1,5−4 mm compr.,
reto a encurvado na base, flavo a fulvo-
tomentoso a seríceo; estilete 1,2−2,5 mm
compr., glabro; estigma capitado. Fruto 5,3−
8,2 cm compr.; estipe 0,5−0,9 cm compr., fulvo
a ferrugíneo-seríceo a tomentoso; núcleo
seminífero 1,4−1,7 × 0,7−1 cm, 4,6−6 mm
diâm., castanho-escuro, esparsamente fulvo a
ferrugíneo-seríceo a tomentoso, glabrescente,
superfície verrucosa, estriada, 3 a 6 nervuras
principais prolongadas em direção a asa,
fibroso; asa 4−4,7 × 1,3−2 cm, falcada a
oblanceolada, apresentando ângulo menor que
90º com o núcleo seminífero, homogênea,
esparsamente hialino a ferrugíneo-puberulenta
a serícea, às vezes glabra, lisa, reticulada,
cartácea, ápice obtuso, mucronulado, margem
plana a levemente encurvada, semente 1,4−1,6
× 0,7−1 cm, 3 mm diâm., reniforme; embrião
com promórdios foliares pluripinulados. 48085 (MBM); RIO DE JANEIRO: Itatiaia,
7.IV.1941, fl., W. D. Barros 256 (F, MO); Nova
Friburgo, 6.III.1986, est., A. M. Carvalho & H. C. Lima 2333 (CEPEC, HRB, IBGE, K, MBM, RB,
UFBA); Rio de Janeiro, Jacarepaguá, 2.IV.1965, fl.,
J. P. L. Sobrinho 797 (IAC, L, NY, US); SÃO PAULO:
Águas da Prata, 21.III.1994, fl., A. B. Martins et al. 31473 (UEC); Agudos, Faz. Sta. Rita, 24.III.1998,
fl., P. F. A. Camargo & P. F. A. Junior 528 (BAUR,
UEC); Atibaia, 22.III.1988, fl., M. T. Grombone et al. 21451 (UEC). auriculada a truncada, unha 2−4 mm compr.;
estames 10, monadelfos, soldados 3−6 mm
compr., às vezes diadelfos; filetes 4−8 mm compr.,
glabros a ferrugíneo-puberulentos a seríceos
na margem da bainha; anteras 0,5−0,9 × 0,2−
0,5 mm, oblongas; disco nectarífero 0,5-1 ×
0,5−1,4 mm, cupulado; ovário estipitado, 2−4 ×
0,8−2 mm, flavo, fulvo a ferrugíneo-tomentoso
a seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 1,5−4 mm compr.,
reto a encurvado na base, flavo a fulvo-
tomentoso a seríceo; estilete 1,2−2,5 mm
compr., glabro; estigma capitado. Nome popular: “negrillo” Hatschbach 21202 (M, MBM, NY, SPF, UB,
UC, UPCB, WAG); Campina Grande do Sul,
Jaguariaiva, 16.IV.1911, fl., P. Dusén 11658 (F, MO,
NY, S); Cerro Azul, 17.VII.1984, fr., G. Hatschbach A designação do epitipo A. Glaziou 8404,
proveniente do Rio de Janeiro, em associação
à estampa apresentada por Vellozo na Flora
Fluminensis (lectótipo da espécie) está em
conformidade com o protólogo da espécie. A inclusão de M. kuhlmannii na sinonímia
desse táxon foi realizada após um cauteloso
exame dos tipos e de coletas nas localidades
típicas. Hoehne (1941) indicou que a ilustração
das flores dessa espécie foi baseada em Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 299 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. Ramos 4−5 mm, sulcados, acinzentados,
glabros, lenticelados, espinescentes, quando
novos glabros. Estípulas 2,5−6(−23) × 0,6−1,4
(−5) mm, triangulares, retas, membranáceas,
estriadas, a espinescentes, persistentes. Folhas
4,5−7,7 × 2,3−3,6 cm, 9−11-folioladas; pecíolo
1−1,3 cm compr., 0,6 mm diâm., cilíndrico,
esparsamente fulvo-seríceo a glabro; raque
1,5−3,5 cm compr., 0,7 mm diâm., sulcada,
glabra; peciólulo 1 mm compr., glabro. Folíolos
alternos 1,2−3,7 × 0,6−1,7 cm, ápice retuso,
base cuneada, oblíqua a cordata, cartáceos,
concolores, oliváceos, margens inteiras,
espessadas, superfícies adaxial e abaxial
glabras, venação broquidódroma. Racemos ou
panículas, 2−5,5 × 1,5−3 cm, do tamanho das
folhas ou menores, axilares ou terminais,
pêndulas, laxas; pedúnculo 0−0,8 cm compr.,
1 mm diâm.; raque 1−4,2 cm compr., fusco-
tomentosa; eixos laterais 1,3−3,5 cm compr.,
indumento como na raque. Brácteas 5 × 1 mm,
triangulares, glabras, espinescentes, às vezes
decíduas. Flores pediceladas, 8 mm compr.,
pedicelo 2 mm compr., ferrugíneo-híspido;
bractéolas 4,7 × 1 mm, cimbiformes, ferrugíneo-
estrigosas, carnosas; cálice 5 × 2 mm, 2 mm
diâm., cilíndrico, superfície lisa, fusco-tomentosa
a ferrugíneo-serícea, carnoso, lacínios carenais
1,4−1,6 × 0,7−1 mm, estreitamente triangulares,
lacínios vexilares 1,6−2 × 1,2−1,4 mm,
triangulares; corola 2 vezes o compr. do cálice,
lilás, pétalas com nervuras dicotômicas, como
também as superfícies internas das bractéolas
e cálice; vexilo 8,6 × 7 mm, orbicular, superfície
externa fusco-serícea, superfície interna fusco-
puberulenta na margem, carnoso, ápice
levemente retuso, base auriculada, unha 2−
6 mm compr.; asas 7,3 × 2,5 mm, oblongas,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base levemente
auriculada, unha 3 mm compr.; pétalas da
carena 7 × 2,5 mm, elípticas, conatas, glabras,
membranáceas, ápice agudo, base auriculada,
unha 3 mm compr.; estames diadelfos,
semelhantes em compr. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Nome popular: “negrillo” e tamanho, os centrais
um pouco maiores que os laterais, soldados a
2,5−4 mm compr.; filetes 5−6,5 mm compr.,
glabros; anteras 0,5 × 0,5 mm, oblongas; disco fragmentos dos frutos em desenvolvimento. A ilustração de uma bractéola orbicular,
distinta daquela de M. nyctitans, possívelmente
foi um equívoco na reconstituição da flor. A forma estreitamente triangular dos lacínios
assemelhou-se àquela desse último táxon,
corroborando a sinonimização de M. kuhlmannii. M. nyctitans difere-se de M. floridum e
M. scleroxylon pelo maior tamanho das folhas
e da inflorescência, pelas flores lilases, pelo
tamanho e forma das bractéolas e pelos frutos
maiores. De M. hatschbachii distingue-se
pelo tronco amarronzado, maior tamanho das
folhas, folíolos, da inflorescência e das flores
e também pelas estrias longitudinais no núcleo
seminífero. Diferencia-se de M. ruddianum
pelo revestimento hialino-viloso da superfície
abaxial dos folíolos e ferrugíneo-tomentoso
das inflorescências, bractéolas e cálice, pelas
inflorescências ramificadas, bractéolas e flores
maiores, pela presença de tricomas de base
dilatada no cálice e nas bractéolas, pelo estipe mais
longo, além de frutos, quando imaturos, com
asa avermelhada, distinta do núcleo seminífero
que é verde. Diferencia-se de M. ovalifolium
pelo tronco escamoso, sem despregar placas,
presença de tricomas de base larga nos lacínios
do cálice, gineceu com estipe mais longo e
estilete mais curto. Desta três últimas espécies
difere também pelo núcleo seminífero com
nervuras longitudinais que se prolongam na asa. Estudos cromossômicos com M. nyctitans
(Mendonça Filho et al. 2002), indicaram que
esta espécie é tetraplóide, apresentando
número cromossômico 2n= 40. Segundo
Guerra (1988) espécies poliplóides normalmente
apresentam uma ampla distribuição, o que está
de acordo com o observado nessa espécie. 7. Machaerium obovatum Kuhlm. & Hoehne,
Arq. Bot. Estado São Paulo 1(1): 34. 1938. Typus: BRASIL. RIO DE JANEIRO: Cabo
Frio, X. 1899, fl., E. Ule s.n. (Holótipo R). Fig. 7 7. Machaerium obovatum Kuhlm. & Hoehne,
Arq. Bot. Estado São Paulo 1(1): 34. 1938. Typus: BRASIL. RIO DE JANEIRO: Cabo
Frio, X. 1899, fl., E. Ule s.n. (Holótipo R). Fig. 7 Arbusto a árvores até 6,5 m alt. Tronco
aculeado, acúleos 1−3 × 0,5−1 cm na base,
piramidais, casca lisa, acinzentada, lenticelada. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 300
Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. Figura 7 - Machaerium obovatum Kuhlm. & Hoehne - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor
em antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. Nome popular: “negrillo” asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a, c-l Mendonça 471, b. Lima 2695)
1 mm
2 mm
2 mm
2 mm
j
i
h
g
f
d
e
c
b
a
2 cm
2 mm
2 cm
2 mm Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 300 2 mm 2 cm 1 mm c b 2 mm 2 mm e 2 mm h a g Figura 7 - Machaerium obovatum Kuhlm. & Hoehne - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor
em antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a, c-l Mendonça 471, b. Lima 2695) nectarífero 0,5 × 0,5 mm, cupulado; ovário
estipitado, 2 × 1 mm, fulvo-seríceo a ferrugíneo-
hirsuto, uniovulado; estipe 1,5 mm compr.,
ferrugíneo-seríceo; estilete 1 mm compr.,
glabro; estigma capitado. Fruto 3,5−5 cm
compr.; estipe 0,4−0,6 cm compr., fulvo-
seríceo; núcleo seminífero 1−1,3 × 0,7−0,8 cm,
2,5−3 mm diâm., castanho-escuro, fulvo-
seríceo a ferrugíneo-puberulento, às vezes com
tricomas de base dilatada esbranquiçados,
superfície lisa, reticulada, fibroso; asa 2,5−3,3
× 1−1,3 cm, oblonga, formando ângulo menor
que 90º em relação ao núcleo seminífero,
homogênea, esparsamente fulvo a ferrugíneo-
serícea, glabrescente, lisa, reticulada, cartácea,
ápice obtuso a agudo, apiculado, margens planas;
semente 1,2 × 0,6 cm; testa avermelhada,
ruminada, embrião com promórdios foliares
pluripinulados. nectarífero 0,5 × 0,5 mm, cupulado; ovário
estipitado, 2 × 1 mm, fulvo-seríceo a ferrugíneo-
hirsuto, uniovulado; estipe 1,5 mm compr.,
ferrugíneo-seríceo; estilete 1 mm compr.,
glabro; estigma capitado. Fruto 3,5−5 cm
compr.; estipe 0,4−0,6 cm compr., fulvo-
seríceo; núcleo seminífero 1−1,3 × 0,7−0,8 cm,
2,5−3 mm diâm., castanho-escuro, fulvo-
seríceo a ferrugíneo-puberulento, às vezes com
tricomas de base dilatada esbranquiçados,
superfície lisa, reticulada, fibroso; asa 2,5−3,3
× 1−1,3 cm, oblonga, formando ângulo menor
que 90º em relação ao núcleo seminífero,
homogênea, esparsamente fulvo a ferrugíneo-
serícea, glabrescente, lisa, reticulada, cartácea,
ápice obtuso a agudo, apiculado, margens planas;
semente 1,2 × 0,6 cm; testa avermelhada,
ruminada, embrião com promórdios foliares
pluripinulados. RB); idem, estrada para a praia das conchas,
5.IX.1999, fl., C. V. Mendonça 467 (BHCB, UEC);
idem, morro do canal, 7.IX.1999, fl. e fr., C. V. Mendonça 471 (BHCB, UEC); idem, lagoa de
Araruama, 3.XI.1993, fr., B. B. Klitgaard & H. C. Lima 3 (NY, RB, U). Fenologia: floração de agosto a setembro e
frutificação de agosto a novembro. Nome popular: “negrillo” do cálice, pétalas lilases a
avermelhadas, apresentando nervuras
avermelhadas, dicotômicas, como também
as superfícies internas das bractéolas e do
cálice; vexilo 5,5−8 × 7−7,5 mm, orbicular,
superfície externa fulvo-serícea, superfície
interna glabra, carnoso, ápice mucronulado,
base auriculada, unha 1−2,5 cm compr.; asas
7−9 × 2−2,5 cm, elípticas a oblongas,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso a agudo, fulvo-
tomentoso, base auriculada, unha 2−2,5 mm
compr.; pétalas da carena 7−8,5 × 2−3 mm,
falcado-elípticas, conatas no dorso, glabras,
membranáceas, ápice agudo, base auriculada,
unha 2−2,5 mm compr.; estames 10,
monadelfos, às vezes diadelfos; filetes 5−
7 mm compr., glabros; anteras 0,5 × 0,5 mm,
oblongas; disco nectarífero 0,5−1 × 0,6−1 mm,
cupulado; ovário estipitado, 2,5−3 × 1 mm,
fulvo-seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 1 mm compr.,
hialino a fulvo-seríceo; estilete 3−3,5 mm
compr., glabro; estigma levemente capitado. Fruto 4−7,2 cm compr.; estipe 0,5−0,7 cm
compr., fulvo-seríceo; núcleo seminífero 1−
1,5 × 0,8−1 cm, 4-6 mm diâm., castanho-
escuro, esparsamente fulvo-puberulento a
seríceo, reticulado, verrucoso, fibroso; asa
2,5−5,5 × 1,3−1,8 cm, oblanceolada a falcada,
apresentando ângulo de 90º em relação ao
núcleo seminífero, homogênea, glabra, lisa,
reticulada, cartácea, ápice obtuso, margem
plana; semente 1−1,4 × 0,7−0,8 cm, reniforme;
testa castanho-clara, ruminada. 8. Machaerium ovalifolium Glaz. ex Rudd,
Phytologia 24(2): 124. 1972. Typus: BRASIL. y
g
MINAS GERAIS: Carandahy, 4.VI.1882, fl.,
A.F.M. Glaziou 13710 (Holótipo P; Isótipos
C!, G!, K!). Fig. 8 M. ovalifolium Glaz., Bull. Soc. Bot. France, Mem 3: 147. 1906, nom. nud. France, Mem 3: 147. 1906, nom. nud. M. ovalifolium Glaz. ex Hoehne, Fl. brasilica 25(3): 37. 1941, nom. nud. ( )
,
Árvore, 5−18 m alt. Tronco reto, 15−
30 cm diâm., acúleos 2−2,5 × 0,3−1,5 cm,
triangulares, cerne creme, exsudato
avermelhado, casca lisa, acinzentada na
planta jovem e nos rebrotos, lenticelas
horizontais, na planta adulta escamosa,
despregando placas longitudinais, amarronzada. Ramos 3,5−5 mm diâm., sulcados
longitudinalmente, acinzentados, glabros,
lenticelados, espinescentes, quando novos
ferrugíneo a fulvo-seríceos a glabros. Estípulas 10−30 × 3−4 mm, triangulares, retas,
espinescentes, persistentes. Folhas (7−)11−
15-folioladas, 8−14 × 3,5−7,5 cm; pecíolo
0,8−2 cm, 1 mm diâm., cilíndrico, sulcado,
ferrugíneo a fulvo-seríceo; raque 4,5−8 cm
compr., 1 mm diâm., cilíndrica, indumento
como no pecíolo; peciólulo 1 mm compr. Folíolos alternos, 2,5−4,5 × 1−2 cm, ápice
obtuso, mucronulado, base obtusa, cordada a
cuneada, cartáceos, discolores, margens
revolutas, espessadas, superfície adaxial glabra,
superfície abaxial hialino a fulvo-serícea na
nervura principal a glabra, venação
broquidódroma. Nome popular: “negrillo” Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: mata
seca sobre colinas litorâneas, em solo arenoso,
pedregoso. Restrita ao Rio de Janeiro. Essa espécie assemelha-se bastante a
M. ovalifolium, principalmente quanto ao
tronco acinzentado, com acúleos piramidais
também
observado
nessa
espécie,
principalmente em populações que ocorrem
em solos arenosos, rochosos nas áreas de
caatinga do norte de Minas Gerais e na Bahia. Diferencia-se desta pelo porte menor, pelas
folhas e folíolos menores, glabros, pelo estilete
mais curto e frutos menores. Material examinado: RIO DE JANEIRO: Cabo Frio,
29.VIII.1986, fr., H. C. Lima et al. 2695 (MBM, NY, Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 301 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. triangulares, lacínios vexilares 0,8−1 × 2 mm,
lobados a triangulares; corola 2−3 vezes o
compr. do cálice, pétalas lilases a
avermelhadas, apresentando nervuras
avermelhadas, dicotômicas, como também
as superfícies internas das bractéolas e do
cálice; vexilo 5,5−8 × 7−7,5 mm, orbicular,
superfície externa fulvo-serícea, superfície
interna glabra, carnoso, ápice mucronulado,
base auriculada, unha 1−2,5 cm compr.; asas
7−9 × 2−2,5 cm, elípticas a oblongas,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso a agudo, fulvo-
tomentoso, base auriculada, unha 2−2,5 mm
compr.; pétalas da carena 7−8,5 × 2−3 mm,
falcado-elípticas, conatas no dorso, glabras,
membranáceas, ápice agudo, base auriculada,
unha 2−2,5 mm compr.; estames 10,
monadelfos, às vezes diadelfos; filetes 5−
7 mm compr., glabros; anteras 0,5 × 0,5 mm,
oblongas; disco nectarífero 0,5−1 × 0,6−1 mm,
cupulado; ovário estipitado, 2,5−3 × 1 mm,
fulvo-seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 1 mm compr.,
hialino a fulvo-seríceo; estilete 3−3,5 mm
compr., glabro; estigma levemente capitado. Fruto 4−7,2 cm compr.; estipe 0,5−0,7 cm
compr., fulvo-seríceo; núcleo seminífero 1−
1,5 × 0,8−1 cm, 4-6 mm diâm., castanho-
escuro, esparsamente fulvo-puberulento a
seríceo, reticulado, verrucoso, fibroso; asa
2,5−5,5 × 1,3−1,8 cm, oblanceolada a falcada,
apresentando ângulo de 90º em relação ao
núcleo seminífero, homogênea, glabra, lisa,
reticulada, cartácea, ápice obtuso, margem
plana; semente 1−1,4 × 0,7−0,8 cm, reniforme;
testa castanho-clara, ruminada. triangulares, lacínios vexilares 0,8−1 × 2 mm,
lobados a triangulares; corola 2−3 vezes o
compr. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Nome popular: “negrillo” Hábitat e distribuição: floresta costeira,
hiléia bahiana, caatinga arbustiva densa, em
solo arenoso, pedregoso. BRASIL: Bahia,
Espírito Santo e Minas Gerais. Drepanocarpus floridus var. parviflorus
Benth. In: Martius & Eichler (eds.). Fl. bras. Drepanocarpus floridus var. parviflorus
Benth. In: Martius & Eichler (eds.). Fl. bras. (
)
15(1): 257. 1862. Typus: BRASIL. RIO DE
JANEIRO: in silvis montis Corcovado et alibi
prope Rio de Janeiro, C.P. von Martius 158
(Lectótipo, aqui designado BR!; Isolectótipos F!,
K-Hb. Benth.!, K-Hb. Hook.!, L!, M; Foto K:
AMES!, F!, FI, NY!, S!, UEC!; Síntipo: Brasil,
Rio de Janeiro, 1839, fl., J.B.A. Guillemin s.n. K-Hb. Benth.!; Foto K: UEC!). 15(1): 257. 1862. Typus: BRASIL. RIO DE
JANEIRO: in silvis montis Corcovado et alibi
prope Rio de Janeiro, C.P. von Martius 158
(Lectótipo, aqui designado BR!; Isolectótipos F!, Nome popular: “bico-de-jurití” (MG), “bico-
de-pato”, “jacarandá-cipó” (ES). O tamanho dos indivíduos, indumento,
consistência e número de folíolos e coloração
dos frutos são caracteres bem variáveis em
M. ovalifolium e estão possivelmente
relacionadas com as condições edáficas e
climáticas. Em regiões mais úmidas, como em
Carandaí-MG (localidade típica) e em
Linhares-ES, os indivíduos são mais altos, as
folhas apresentam maior número de folíolos,
que são mais estreitos e bastante revestidos
na face abaxial e os frutos apresentam asa
estreita e coloração castanha. Na caatinga ou
em matas secas ao norte de Minas Gerais e
na Bahia as árvores são menores, as folhas
apresentam menor número de folíolos, que são
mais largos, glabros e os frutos possuem asa
mais larga, amarelada. Os caracteres florais
observados, entretanto, são suficientes para
reconhecer estas populações como parte de
uma única espécie. K-Hb. Benth.!, K-Hb. Hook.!, L!, M; Foto K:
AMES!, F!, FI, NY!, S!, UEC!; Síntipo: Brasil,
Rio de Janeiro, 1839, fl., J.B.A. Guillemin s.n. K-Hb. Benth.!; Foto K: UEC!). Drepanocarpus floridus Mart. nom. ileg., Flora 20(2): 118. nov. 1837., non Mart. ex
Benth., jun. 1837. Machaerium floridum var. parviflorum
(Benth.) Hoehne, Fl. brasilica 128: 69. 1941. Árvore 5−15 m alt. Tronco reto, 6−10 cm
diâm., acúleos 8−10 × 2 mm, lineares, casca
lisa, acinzentada, lenticelada, cerne creme,
exsudato ausente. Ramos 2−5 mm diâm.,
sulcados, esbranquiçados, acinzentados a
enegrecidos, glabros, lenticelados, espinescentes,
quando novos esparçamente fulvo-puberulentos. Estípulas 3,4−12 × 1−3 mm, lineares a triangulares,
retas, espinescentes, às vezes decíduas. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Nome popular: “negrillo” Racemos ou panículas, 3,5−
9,5 × 3−4 cm, axilares ou terminais, flores
congestas; pedúnculo 0−1,8 cm compr., 1,5 mm
diâm.; raque 2,5−9 cm compr., fulvo-serícea a
tomentosa, lenticelada, eixos laterais 1,5−7 cm
compr., indumento como na raque. Brácteas
(1−)4−8 × 2−6 mm, lanceoladas a orbiculares,
fulvo-seríceas a glabras, membranáceas a
espinescentes. Flores sésseis a subsésseis, 7−
10 mm compr.; bractéolas 3−4 × 1−2 mm,
oblanceoladas, côncavas, lisas, ferrugíneo-
seríceas, carnosas; cálice 3,5−5 × 2−3,5 cm,
2−3 mm diâm., campanulado, liso, fulvo-
seríceo, carnoso, lacínios carenais 1−2 × 1 mm, Material examinado: BRASIL. BAHIA: Abaíra,
31.VII.1992, fr., W. Ganeo 799 (SPF); Almadina,
rodovia para Ibitupã, 12.III.1971, fr., R. S. Pinheiro
1142 (CEPEC); Itajú da Colônia, 23.I.1969, fl., T. S. Santos 344 (CEPEC, NY, US); ESPÍRITO SANTO:
Linhares, CVRD, 26.III.1973, fl., J. Spada 226 (US);
idem, 21.IX.2000, fr., C. V. Mendonça & D. A. Folli
601 (CVRD, UEC); MINAS GERAIS: Almenara,
18.VII.1988, fr., G. Hatschbach et al. 52204 (C, CEPEC,
K, MBM, MO, US); Coronel Murta, beira do Rio
Jequetinhonha, V.1997, fr., E. T. Neto 2511 (BHCB);
Itaobim, Vale do Jequetinhonha, 14.VI.1986, fr., G. Hatschbach & J. M. Silva 50395 (C, K, MBM, UC). Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 302 Figura 8 - Machaerium ovalifolium Glaz. ex Rudd - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em
antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a Glaziou 13710; b Mendonça 601; c-l Spada 226)
2 mm
2 mm
2 mm
2 cm
d
c
j
i
b
f
g
a
1 mm
h
e c 2 mm 1 mm b d d f e h Figura 8 - Machaerium ovalifolium Glaz. ex Rudd - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em
antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a Glaziou 13710; b Mendonça 601; c-l Spada 226) Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 303 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 9. Machaerium ruddianum C.V. Mend. F. & A.M.G. Azevedo, stat. & nom. nov. Fig. 9 Fenologia: floração de dezembro a maio e
frutificação de janeiro a setembro. Hábitat e distribuição: floresta costeira,
hiléia bahiana, caatinga arbustiva densa, em
solo arenoso, pedregoso. BRASIL: Bahia,
Espírito Santo e Minas Gerais. Nome popular: “bico-de-jurití” (MG), “bico-
de-pato”, “jacarandá-cipó” (ES). Nome popular: “negrillo” Folhas
3,5−14(−20) × 3,8−5 cm, 11−27-folioladas; pecíolo
0,5−2 cm compr., 1 mm diâm., fusco-puberulento,
estrigoso a tomentoso, às vezes hialino-estrigoso;
raque 4−12 cm, 1 mm diâm., indumento como
no pecíolo; peciólulo 1−2 mm compr. Folíolos
alternos, 1−3,5 × 0,3−1,5 cm, ápice obtuso, retuso,
às vezes mucronulado, base arredondada, obtusa,
cuneada a oblíqua, cartáceos, levemente
discolores, margens inteiras, planas, espessadas,
superfície adaxial esparsamente hialino-
serícea, glabrescente, superfície abaxial hialino-
serícea, ferrugíneo-puberulenta na nervura
principal, venação broquidódroma. Panículas
2,8−15 × 1,5−6 cm, 0,5 a 3 vezes o comprimento
das folhas, axilares ou terminais, laxas,
multifloras; pedúnculo (0−) 0,5−2,3 cm compr.,
0,5−1 mm diâm.; raque 2,5−17,5 cm compr., A espécie apresenta grande afinidade
com M. nyctitans da qual diferencia-se
pelo tronco esfoliante, desprendendo placas
longitudinais, ausência de tricomas de base
larga nos lacínios do cálice, gineceu com
estipe mais curto e estilete mais longo e pelo
núcleo seminífero sem estrias longitudinais. Diferencia-se de M. obovatum pelo porte
maior e folíolos mais largos e também pelas
características do tronco, que nesta espécie
apresenta acúleos piramidais. Diferencia-
se de M. tortipes pelas asas, pétalas da
carena e ovário menores, androceu
monadelfo e núcleo seminífero mais estreito
e também pelo gineceu com estipe mais
curto e estilete mais longo. Diferencia-se de M. obovatum pelo porte
maior e folíolos mais largos e também pelas
características do tronco, que nesta espécie
apresenta acúleos piramidais. Diferencia-
se de M. tortipes pelas asas, pétalas da
carena e ovário menores, androceu
monadelfo e núcleo seminífero mais estreito
e também pelo gineceu com estipe mais
curto e estilete mais longo. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 304 Figura 9 - Machaerium ruddianum C.V. Mend. F. & A.M.G. Azevedo - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice;
d. bractéola; e. flor em antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. (a, c-l Duarte 4780; b Lima 3041)
1 mm
f
g
j
i
c
b
2 mm
2 cm
a
2 mm
2 mm
2 mm
h
2 cm
2 mm
d
e 1 mm 2 mm c e 2 cm a h g Figura 9 - Machaerium ruddianum C.V. Mend. F. & A.M.G. Azevedo - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálic
d. bractéola; e. flor em antese; f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; i. asa; j. pétalas da carena. Nome popular: “negrillo” (a, c-l Duarte 4780; b Lima 304 × 0,5−1 mm, triangulares, lacínios vexilares 1 ×
1 mm, triangulares; corola 2−3 vezes o
comprimento do cálice, pedicelo 0−0,5 mm
compr., ferrugíneo-puberulento, pétalas com
nervuras avermelhadas, dicotômicas, inconspícuas,
como também as superfícies internas das
bractéolas e do cálice; vexilo 4,5−5,5 × 4−5 mm,
orbicular a oblado, superfície externa ferrugíneo-
serícea, superfície interna ferrugíneo-tomentosa
na margem, ápice mucronulado, base levemente
auriculada, unha 1−1,5 mm compr.; asas 5−6
× 1,5−2 mm, oblongas, membranáceas, ápice fulvo a ferrugíneo-serícea a tomentosa; eixos
laterais 0,8−5 cm compr., indumento como na
raque. Brácteas 1−2,5 × 0,5−2,7 mm,
triangulares, ovadas a orbiculares, às vezes
côncavas; hialino a fulvo-puberulentas a seríceas,
a ferrugíneo-tomentosas, papiráceas, rígidas a
carnosas, decíduas. Flores subsésseis, 5−6,5 mm
compr.; bractéolas 1−2,5 × 0,4−1 mm, ovadas,
triangulares, cimbiformes, carnosas, lisas,
ferrugíneo-seríceas a tomentosas; cálice 2−3,5
× 1,5−2,5 mm, 1,5−2 mm diâm., superfície lisa,
ferrugíneo-tomentosa, lacínios carenais 0,5−1 Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 305 parviflorum já havia sido descrito por Bentham
e desta forma não estava disponível, foi
necessário designar um “nomem novum”. obtuso, esparsamente ferrugíneo-seríceo, base
levemente auriculada, unha 2 mm compr.;
pétalas da carena 5−5,5 × 1−2 mm, elípticas,
conatas no dorso, glabras, membranáceas,
ápice agudo, base auriculada, unha 1,5−2 mm
compr.; estames 10, monadelfos, às vezes
diadelfos, soldados até 2−3 mm compr.; filetes
3−5 mm compr., glabros; anteras 0,5 × 0,3 mm,
oblongas; disco nectarífero 0,4−1 × 0,5 mm,
cupulado; ovário estipitado, 1,5−2 × 0,6−1 mm,
ferrugíneo-seríceo, uniovulado; estipe 0,6−
1 mm, ferrugíneo-seríceo; estilete 1−2 mm
compr., glabro. Fruto 3−6 cm compr.; estipe
0,2−0,5 cm, ferrugíneo-seríceo; núcleo
seminífero 1−1,5 × 0,7−0,8(−1) cm, 2 mm diâm.,
castanho-escuro, esparsamente ferrugíneo-
seríceo, superfície reticulada, fibroso; asa 1,6−
4 × 0,8−1,2 cm, oblonga, apresentando ângulo
menor que 90º em relação ao núcleo
seminífero, concolor, esparsamente ferrugíneo-
puberulenta, lisa, reticulada, cartácea, ápice
obtuso, margens planas a encurvadas. Drepanocarpus
floridus
Mart.,
publicado em novembro de 1837 e baseado em
Martius 158, é um nome ilegítimo por ser
homônimo de D. floridus Mart. ex Benth.,
espécie descrita com base em outra coleta de
Martius procedente da Bahia e que tem
prioridade por ter sido publicada anteriormente,
em junho de 1837. O nome é uma homenagem
à Dra. Velva E. Rudd pela sua importante
contribuição à taxonomia de Machaerium. Machaerium ruddianum difere-se de M. Nome popular: “negrillo” floridum pelo estilete mais curto, vexilo
orbicular, pela bainha de estames e/ou pelo
estame vexilar (quando presente) glabros, pelo
disco nectarífero proeminente e estilete mais
curto e assemelha-se pelo tronco acinzentado,
lenticelado e pelas características das folhas. Diferencia-se de M. nyctitans pela ausência
de tricomas de base glandular nos lacínios do
cálice, pelas inflorescências mais ramificadas
e esguias, estilete mais curto, bractéolas e
frutos menores. As citações de M. ruddianum
para o Espírito Santo, Minas Gerais e Paraná
são inéditas. Material examinado: BRASIL. ESPÍRITO SANTO:
Ibatiba, 21.III.1991, fr., D. A. Folli 1319 (CVRD, UEC);
Santa Teresa, estr. São Lourenço até a Mata Fria,
18.IX.2000, est., C. V. Mendonça & L. Kollmann 573
(MBML, UEC); MINAS GERAIS: Araguari, Parque
John Kennedy, 9.V.1992, fr., G. M. Araújo et al. 896
(HUFU); Caratinga, Faz. Montes Claros, 23.III.1991,
fr., C. V. Mendonça et al. 153 (BHCB); idem, frente
ao laboratório de campo, 31.I.1998, fl. e fr., C. V. Mendonça 389 (BHCB, UEC); Mariana, beira do Rio
Gualaxo, 5.IV.1998, fl., E. T. Neto 2708 (BHCB, UEC);
PARANÁ: Teixeira Soares, IV.1908, fl., A. J. Sampaio
731 (R); RIO DE JANEIRO: Rio de Janeiro, 19.V.1959,
fl., A. P. Duarte & E. Pereira 4780 (LP, RB); idem,
Santa Teresa, Monte Corcovado, V.1839, fl., J. B. A. Guillemin 830 (F, K, NY, RB). 10. Machaerium saraense Rudd, Phytologia,
24(2): 125. 1972. Typus: BOLÍVIA. SANTA
CRUZ:
Sará,
“campos-region,
Rio
Palometillas” 400 m. elev., 21.XII.1924. fr., J. Steinbach 6788 (Holótipo F!; Isótipos BA!,
BM!, G, K!, MO!, NY, S!, U, UC!, UEC- foto
K!, W). Fig. 10 Arbusto a árvore até 8 m alt. Tronco
inerme. Ramos 3 mm diâm., superfície
escamosa, esbranquiçada, lenticelados, glabros. Estípulas decíduas, não observadas. Folhas
4,5−7 × 3,5−4,5 cm, 9−13-folioladas; pecíolo
0,8−1,3 cm compr., 0,5 mm diâm., castanho-
claro, glabro; raque 3−5 cm compr., 0,5−1 mm
diâm., sulcada, glabra; peciólulo 1−2 mm
compr., glabro. Folíolos alternos, 1−2 × 0,5−
1,2 cm, ápice obtuso, retuso, base arredondada
a cuneada, membranáceos, discolores, margens
revolutas, espessadas, superfícies adaxial e Fenologia: floração e frutificação de janeiro
a julho. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, floresta costeira. Brasil: Espítio Santo, Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, floresta costeira. Brasil: Espítio Santo, Minas Gerais, Paraná e Rio de Janeiro. Nome popular: “bico-de ganso” (ES); “rabo-
de bugio” (MG). Nome popular: “bico-de ganso” (ES); “rabo-
de bugio” (MG). Nome popular: “bico-de ganso” (ES); “rabo-
de bugio” (MG). Ao considerar que Machaerium floridum
var. parviflorum constitui uma espécie e não
táxon infra-específico e que o nome Machaerium Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 306 306 Rudd (1972) observou uma afinidade
dessa espécie com M. nyctitans e M. scleroxylon. De fato, a espécie assemelha-se
principalmente a M. scleroxylon da qual
distingue-se pelos folíolos membranáceos, em
menor número e pelos frutos com núcleo
seminífero liso, da cor da asa. As
características da inflorescência e das flores
foram baseadas na descrição original da
espécie apresentada pela autora e não foi
completada devido ao pouco material fértil
desta espécie. Figura 10 - Machaerium saraense Rudd - a. ramo; b. fruto. (a-b Guillén 1088)
b
a
2 cm
2 cm 2 cm b 11. Machaerium scleroxylon Tul., Arch. Mus. Hist. Nat. 4: 93. 1844., “scleroxylum”. Typus: BRASIL. MINAS GERAIS: 1838, fr.,
P. Claussen 98, Cat. herb. Bras. Mus. Par. n. 884. (Holótipo P; Isótipo S!). Fig. 11
Machaerium nyctitans var. scleroxylon
(Tul.) Hassler, In: Fedde, Rep. Sp. 12:371. 1913. Á a Figura 10 - Machaerium saraense Rudd - a. ramo; b. fruto. (a-b Guillén 1088) Árvore 6 a 30 m alt. Tronco reto, 24−70 cm
diâm., acúleos até 3 cm compr. nos rebrotos,
lineares a triangulares, casca variegada na
planta jovem, esfoliante na adulta, despregando
placas longitudinais. Ramos 2−8 mm diâm.,
sulcados, acinzentados, castanhos a enegrecidos,
glabrescentes, lenticelados, espinescentes ou
não, quando novos 1−3 mm diâm. Estípulas (1−)
2−7(−18) mm compr., lineares a triangulares,
retas, espinescentes, persistentes, às vezes
decíduas. Folhas 4−8,5(−11,5) × 2−7 cm, 9−
19-folioladas; pecíolo 0,5−1,5 cm compr., 0,5−
1 mm diâm., cilíndrico, hialino a ferrugíneo-
puberulento a tomentoso; raque 3−7 cm compr.,
0,5−1 mm diâm., cilíndrica a canaliculada,
indumento como no pecíolo; peciólulo 1−2 mm
compr. Folíolos alternos, 1−2,7(−4,6) × 0,5−1,2
(−1,5) cm, ápice obtuso, retuso, base arredondada,
obtusa, cuneada a oblíqua, cartáceos,
levemente discolores, margens inteiras,
espessadas, ligeiramente revolutas, superfície
adaxial esparsamente hialino-puberulenta a
serícea, principalmente na nervura central,
glabrescente, superfície abaxial hialino a
ferrugíneo-puberulenta a serícea, às vezes
vilosa na base, venação broquidódroma. Racemos ou panículas, 1,5−5,5 × 1−4,5 cm, abaxial glabras, venação broquidódroma. Inflorescência terminal ou axilar, pedúnculo e
raque glabros. Brácteas e bractéolas não
observadas. Flores 8 mm compr.; cálice 4−5 mm
compr., glabro; corola não observada. Fruto
5,8−7 cm compr., cálice persistente; estipe
0,7−1,5 cm compr.; núcleo seminífero 1,4−2 ×
1 cm, 3 mm diâm., castanho-claro a escuro,
glabro, superfície lisa, fibroso; asa 3−4 × 1−
1,2 cm, falcada, apresentando ângulo menor
que 90º em em relação ao núcleo seminífero,
homogênea, glabra, lisa, reticulada, cartácea,
ápice obtuso, mucronulado, margem
encurvadada. 306 Material examinado: BOLÍVIA. CHUQUISACA:
1.XII.1910, est., T. Herzog 1169 (L); SANTA CRUZ,
Velasco: 21.III.1994, fr., R. Guillén et al. 1088 (NY). BRASIL. AMAZONAS: Rio Guaporé, 8.VI.1952, fr.,
G. A. Black & E. Cordeiro 52-14758 (IAN). Fenologia: floração não conhecida e
frutificação de março a junho. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica:
Províncias Yungas e Chaquenã, 350 a 900
m.s.m., em região pedregosa, solo argiloso
arenoso. BOLÍVIA e BRASIL: AMAZONAS. Material examinado: BOLÍVIA. CHUQUISACA:
1.XII.1910, est., T. Herzog 1169 (L); SANTA CRUZ,
Velasco: 21.III.1994, fr., R. Guillén et al. 1088 (NY). BRASIL. AMAZONAS: Rio Guaporé, 8.VI.1952, fr.,
G. A. Black & E. Cordeiro 52-14758 (IAN). Fenologia: floração não conhecida e
frutificação de março a junho. Fenologia: floração não conhecida e
frutificação de março a junho. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica:
Províncias Yungas e Chaquenã, 350 a 900
m.s.m., em região pedregosa, solo argiloso
arenoso. BOLÍVIA e BRASIL: AMAZONAS. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica:
Províncias Yungas e Chaquenã, 350 a 900
m.s.m., em região pedregosa, solo argiloso
arenoso. BOLÍVIA e BRASIL: AMAZONAS. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 307 Figura 11 - Machaerium scleroxylon Tul. - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em antese;
f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; j. asa; l. pétalas da carena. (a Alvarenga 2518; b Heringer 3693; c-l Hatschbach 61460)
b
c
a
2 mm
2 cm
e
d
2 mm
1 mm
2 mm
f
j
g
h
i
2 cm b 2 cm 2 mm d e g h Figura 11 - Machaerium scleroxylon Tul. - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em antese;
f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; j. asa; l. pétalas da carena. (a Alvarenga 2518; b Heringer 3693; c-l Hatschbach 61460) até 0,5 do comprimento das folhas, axilares,
às vezes terminais, laxas ou congestas no ápice;
pedúnculo (0−)0,5−1 cm compr., 1 mm diâm.;
raque (0−)0,3−5 cm compr., hialino a ferrugíneo-
tomentosa; eixos laterais 0,5−1,5(−3) cm
compr., indumento como na raque. Brácteas
(0,8−)1−3 × 0,5−1,5 mm, triangulares a
orbiculares, hialino a ferrugíneo-tomentosas a
seríceas. 306 Flores sésseis, 5−10 mm compr.,
bractéolas 1 × 1 mm, orbiculares, lisas,
ferrugíneo-puberulentas a tomentosas; cálice 1,2−4 × 1,2−3 mm, 1,7−2 mm diâm., superfície
estriada longitudinalmente, ferrugíneo-
puberulenta a serícea, lacínios lobados, obtusos,
os carenais 0,4−0,5 × 0,5 mm, os vexilares
0,4−0,5 × 0,8 mm; corola 2,5−3,5 vezes o
comprimento do cálice, pétalas creme,
amareladas a róseo-esbranquiçadas, com
nervuras avermelhadas, dicotômicas, às vezes
inconspícuas, como também as superfícies
internas das bractéolas e do cálice; vexilo 5,5−
8,4 × 4−7,7 mm, largo-obovado, superfície 1,2−4 × 1,2−3 mm, 1,7−2 mm diâm., superfície
estriada longitudinalmente, ferrugíneo-
puberulenta a serícea, lacínios lobados, obtusos,
os carenais 0,4−0,5 × 0,5 mm, os vexilares
0,4−0,5 × 0,8 mm; corola 2,5−3,5 vezes o
comprimento do cálice, pétalas creme,
amareladas a róseo-esbranquiçadas, com
nervuras avermelhadas, dicotômicas, às vezes
inconspícuas, como também as superfícies
internas das bractéolas e do cálice; vexilo 5,5−
8,4 × 4−7,7 mm, largo-obovado, superfície Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 308 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. Gameleira, 19.V.1984, fr., M. M. Santos 80 (HRB);
GOIÁS: Amarelina, Rio Formiga, 22.VIII.1996, fr.,
S. S. Silva et al. 21 (NY); Cabeceiras, km 29 rod. que parte de Unaí, 22.XI.1996, fl., B. A. S. Pereira
& D. Alvarenga 3260 (IBGE); MINAS GERAIS:
Corumbataí, estrada para Rio Claro-SP, 30.VII.1992,
fr., H. Lorenzi 28788 (UEC); Januária, estrada de
terra para Riacho da Cruz, 18.IX.1994, fr., G. F. Árbocz 663 (UEC); Virgem da Lapa, I.1998, fl., E. Tameirão 2531 (BHCB); PARANÁ: Cerro Azul,
5.VIII.1966, fr., J. C. Lindeman & J. H. Hass 2027
(U); Dr. Ulysses, Cabeceiras do Ribeirão do Tigre,
7.XI.1994, fl., G. Hatschbach & J. M. Silva 6140
(BHCB, C, CEPEC, MBM, NY, SPF, UB); SÃO
PAULO: Agudos, Faz. Sta. Rita, 25.XI.1997, fl., P. F. A. Camargo & S.R. Christianini 506 (BAUR,
UEC); Amparo, Monte Alegre, 5.IV.1943, fr., M. Kuhlmann 572 (SP). Gameleira, 19.V.1984, fr., M. M. Santos 80 (HRB);
GOIÁS: Amarelina, Rio Formiga, 22.VIII.1996, fr.,
S. S. Silva et al. 21 (NY); Cabeceiras, km 29 rod. que parte de Unaí, 22.XI.1996, fl., B. A. S. Pereira
& D. Alvarenga 3260 (IBGE); MINAS GERAIS:
Corumbataí, estrada para Rio Claro-SP, 30.VII.1992,
fr., H. Lorenzi 28788 (UEC); Januária, estrada de
terra para Riacho da Cruz, 18.IX.1994, fr., G. F. Árbocz 663 (UEC); Virgem da Lapa, I.1998, fl., E. Tameirão 2531 (BHCB); PARANÁ: Cerro Azul,
5.VIII.1966, fr., J. C. Lindeman & J. H. 306 Hass 2027
(U); Dr. Ulysses, Cabeceiras do Ribeirão do Tigre,
7.XI.1994, fl., G. Hatschbach & J. M. Silva 6140
(BHCB, C, CEPEC, MBM, NY, SPF, UB); SÃO
PAULO: Agudos, Faz. Sta. Rita, 25.XI.1997, fl., P. F. A. Camargo & S.R. Christianini 506 (BAUR,
UEC); Amparo, Monte Alegre, 5.IV.1943, fr., M. Kuhlmann 572 (SP). externa ferrugíneo-serícea, superfície interna
ferrugíneo-tomentosa na margem, ápice retuso,
base atenuada, unha 1−2 mm compr.; asas 4,3−
8 × 2−3 mm, elípticas, ferrugíneo-seríceas no
dorso, às vezes esparsamente ferrugíneo-
seríceas no ápice, membranáceas, ápice obtuso,
base oblíqua, auriculadas ventralmente, às
vezes com dobras, unha 1,5−2,8 mm compr.;
pétalas da carena 3,2−8 × 2 mm, elípticas,
ferrugíneo-seríceas a glabras no dorso,
membranáceas, ápice agudo, base oblíqua,
auriculada ventralmente, unha 1,5−3 mm
compr.; estames 10, monadelfos, soldados até
2,5−3,5 mm compr.; filetes 2,5−6 mm compr.,
esparsamente ferrugíneo-seríceos no dorso a
glabros; anteras 0,5−0,8 × 0,3−0,5 mm, oblongas;
disco nectarífero 0,6−1,5 × 0,5−1 mm, cupulado;
ovário estipitado, 2-3 × 1 mm, ferrugíneo-
tomentoso a seríceo; estipe 1−2,5 mm compr.,
ferrugíneo-seríceo; estilete 1−1,5 mm compr.,
glabro, às vezes esparsamente ferrugíneo-
seríceo. Fruto 3−6,5 cm compr.; estipe 0,5−
0,8 cm compr., ferrugíneo-seríceo; núcleo
seminífero 1−2 × 0,6−1 cm, 2−4 mm diâm.,
castanho-escuro a enegrecido, hialino a
ferrugíneo-puberulento a seríceo, superfície
estriada, 2−4 nervuras longitudinais prolongadas
em direção a asa, fibroso; asa 2,3−3,6 × 1−
1,6 cm, oblanceolada, às vezes falcada,
formando com o núcleo seminífero ângulo
maior que 90º, pardacenta, discolor, castanho-
clara na base, esparsamente hialino-
puberulenta, glabrescente, reticulada, cartácea,
ápice agudo a obtuso, margem plana ou
levemente encurvada; semente 1−1,2 × 0,6 cm,
reniforme; testa 1 mm de espessura, castanho-
clara, ruminada desde a rafe até a metade da
semente, o restante corrugada, membranácea;
embrião com promórdios foliares pluripinulados. Material examinado: BOLÍVIA. Florida: 6 km al N de
Bermejo, tramo de 2-3 km al NW de la escuela en la
comunidad, 4.IX.1996, fr., I. G. Vargas 5095 (NY);
SANTA CRUZ: Velasco, San Juancito, 27 km al N de
San Ignácio, 1.V.1986, fr., R. Seidel & S. G. Beck 357
(NY); PARAGUAI. Cerro Margarita, 1901.1902, fr.,
E. Hassler 11053 (AMES, BM, NY, S, UC); BRASIL. BAHIA: Itambé, 1.III..1993, fr., M. C. Guedes et al. 2875 (ALCB); Santana, próximo ao Riacho da Fenologia: floração de setembro a abril e
frutificação de outubro a agosto. Fenologia: floração de setembro a abril e
frutificação de outubro a agosto. 306 Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, floresta costeira, mata seca, cerradão,
em regiões calcáreas, em áreas periodicamente
inundáveis, com solo argiloso ou arenoso. Bolívia e Paraguai. Brasil: Bahia, Goiás, Minas
Gerais, Paraná e São Paulo. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, floresta costeira, mata seca, cerradão,
em regiões calcáreas, em áreas periodicamente
inundáveis, com solo argiloso ou arenoso. Bolívia e Paraguai. Brasil: Bahia, Goiás, Minas
Gerais, Paraná e São Paulo. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila, floresta costeira, mata seca, cerradão,
em regiões calcáreas, em áreas periodicamente
inundáveis, com solo argiloso ou arenoso. Bolívia e Paraguai. Brasil: Bahia, Goiás, Minas
Gerais, Paraná e São Paulo. Nome popular: “candeia-do-sertão”, “candeia”,
“caviúna”, “caviúna-rajada”, “caviúna-vermelha”,
“gaviúna”, “jacarandá-caviúna”, jacarandá-
violeta”, “pau-ferro”, “penanguba”, “uruvaeiro”,
“violeta” (Brasil); “canela-do-brejo”, “espuela-de-
gallo”, “guayacán-morotí”, “sapy’y” (Paraguai). Nome popular: “candeia-do-sertão”, “candeia”,
“caviúna”, “caviúna-rajada”, “caviúna-vermelha”,
“gaviúna”, “jacarandá-caviúna”, jacarandá-
violeta”, “pau-ferro”, “penanguba”, “uruvaeiro”,
“violeta” (Brasil); “canela-do-brejo”, “espuela-de-
gallo”, “guayacán-morotí”, “sapy’y” (Paraguai). As principais características que
diferenciam essa espécie de outras afins, como
M. floridum, M. hatschbachii, M. ruddianum
e M. nyctitans, são as flores odoríferas, o tronco
variegado quando jovem, com casca esfoliante,
desprendendo placas longitudinais quando
adulto, as bractéolas orbiculares, o cálice estriado
longitudinalmente, com lacínios obtusos no ápice,
os frutos com núcleo seminífero enegrecido e
asa discolor na base. Diferencia-se de M. nyctitans pelos acúleos menores, menor número
de folíolos, revestimento menos denso,
inflorescência pauciflora, laxa, características
também observadas por Sartori e Tozzi (1998),
e frutos com asa pardacenta, discolor na base. M. scleroxylon apresenta ainda folíolos maiores
e menos numerosos que os de M. hatschbachii. Nome popular: “candeia-do-sertão”, “candeia”,
“caviúna”, “caviúna-rajada”, “caviúna-vermelha”,
“gaviúna”, “jacarandá-caviúna”, jacarandá-
violeta”, “pau-ferro”, “penanguba”, “uruvaeiro”,
“violeta” (Brasil); “canela-do-brejo”, “espuela-de-
gallo”, “guayacán-morotí”, “sapy’y” (Paraguai). As principais características que
diferenciam essa espécie de outras afins, como
M. floridum, M. hatschbachii, M. ruddianum
e M. nyctitans, são as flores odoríferas, o tronco
variegado quando jovem, com casca esfoliante,
desprendendo placas longitudinais quando
adulto, as bractéolas orbiculares, o cálice estriado
longitudinalmente, com lacínios obtusos no ápice,
os frutos com núcleo seminífero enegrecido e
asa discolor na base. Diferencia-se de M. nyctitans pelos acúleos menores, menor número
de folíolos, revestimento menos denso,
inflorescência pauciflora, laxa, características
também observadas por Sartori e Tozzi (1998),
e frutos com asa pardacenta, discolor na base. M. scleroxylon apresenta ainda folíolos maiores
e menos numerosos que os de M. hatschbachii. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 306 309 superfície lisa, fulvo-serícea, carnoso, lacínios
triangulares, os carenais 1 × 0,5 mm, os
vexilares 1 × 1,3 mm; corola 2,5 vezes o tamanho
do cálice, alvo-rosada, estrias lilases; vexilo
10 × 5,5 mm, orbicular, superfície externa
fulvo-serícea, superfície interna glabra,
carnoso, ápice mucronulado, base atenuada,
unha 2,6 mm compr.; asas 12 × 2,2 mm,
oblongas, fulvo-puberulenta no ápice,
membranáceas, ápice obtuso, base auriculada,
unha 3,5 mm compr.; pétalas da carena 11
× 2,5 mm, elípticas, conatas, glabras,
membranáceas, ápice agudo, base auriculada,
unha 3 mm compr.; estames 10, diadelfos;
filetes 4,2−6 mm compr., esparsamente
fulvo-puberulentos na margem da bainha;
anteras 0,2 × 0,2 mm, oblongas; disco
nectarífero, inconspícuo, cupulado; ovário
estipitado, 3,2 × 1,4 mm, fulvo-seríceo,
uniovulado; estipe 3,7 mm, fulvo-seríceo;
estilete 1,5 mm compr., glabro; estigma
capitado. Fruto 7−7,5 cm compr.; estipe
0,5 cm compr., fulvo-seríceo; núcleo
seminífero 1,3−1,6 × 1−1,2 cm, 2−3 mm
diâm., castanho-claro, fulvo-puberulento,
superfície lisa, reticulada, fibroso; asa 4,5−5,3
× 1,3−1,5 cm, oblonga, apresentando ângulo
menor que 90º em relação ao núcleo
seminífero, homogênea, glabra, lisa,
reticulada, cartácea, ápice obtuso, às vezes
mucronulado, margem plana. Hoehne (1941) comentou que houve um
equívoco de Tulasne ao descrever M. scleroxylon
como inerme e ressaltou a utilização da
madeira desta espécie para construções. Um
estudo do potencial de utilização da madeira
foi apontado por Bernadi (1984), por ela ser pesada,
dura e de cor forte. A madeira entretanto é
apontada como causadora de alergia ao contato
(Pickel 1962). 12. Machaerium tortipes Hoehne, Arq. Bot. Estado São Paulo 1(2): 49. 1939. Typus: BRASIL. ACRE: Rio Branco, em capoeirão de terra firme,
2.IV.1933. fl. e fr., A. Ducke s.n. (Holótipo RB!;
Isótipos K!, S!, SP, SPF!). Fig. 12 Arbusto a árvore 6−10(−30) m alt. Tronco
25−60 cm diâm., inerme, casca escamosa,
estriada, esfoliante. Ramos 3−5,5 mm diâm.,
lisos, fulvo-tomentosos a glabros, lenticelados,
inermes, quando novos fulvo-seríceos, com
esparsos tricomas de base dilatada. Estípulas
4,5−5 × 1,2−1,5 mm, triangulares, retas,
espinescentes, decíduas. Folhas (13−)18−26,5
× 3,5−6,5 cm, 21−25-folioladas; pecíolo 2−2,5 cm
compr., 1,5−1,7 mm diâm., hialino-puberulento
a fulvo-tomentoso, a glabro; raque 15−19 cm
compr., 1,2−1,4 mm diâm., indumento como no
pecíolo; peciólulo 1−3 mm compr. Folíolos
alternos, 3−5,6 × (0,8−)1,5−1,8 cm, ápice obtuso,
mucronulado, base arredondada a cuneada,
cartáceos, discolores, margens revolutas,
espessadas, superfície adaxial esparsamente
hialino-serícea a glabra, superfície abaxial
fulvo-serícea, venação broquidódroma. 306 Racemos ou panículas, 3,6−7,2(−17) × 1,2−4,8
(−15) cm, 2 a 5 vezes o comprimento das folhas,
axilar ou terminal, flores congestas; pedúnculo
0,5−1,7 cm compr., 1,5 mm diâm.; raque 0−7 cm
compr., fulvo-tomentosa, com esparsos
tricomas de base dilatada; eixos laterais 1,3−
3 cm compr., indumento como na raque. Brácteas
1−3 × 0,5−2 mm, triangulares a ovadas, fulvo-
seríceas a glabras, papiráceas a cartáceas,
estriadas, decíduas. Flores sésseis, 10 mm
compr.; bractéolas 4,2−4,4 × 0,5 mm, linear-
lanceoladas, lisas, fulvo-seríceas, carnosas;
cálice 5 × 2 mm, 2 mm diâm., campanulado, Material examinado: BOLÍVIA. LA PAZ: Yungas,
Rio Bopi, VII.1939, fr., B. A. Krukoff 10274 (K,
AMES, MO, LP, UC, S, NY); PERU. HUÁNUCO:
Puerto Inca, 16.I.1991, fl., Tello 1139 (NY); JUNIN:
próximo a San Ramon, VI.1988, fr., E. Meneses & R. Pisculich 28 (K); BRASIL. ACRE: Cruzeiro do Sul,
11.III.1992, fl. e fr., C. A. C. Ferreira et al. 10761
(NY); idem, Guiomar Santos, 27.II.1980, fl., H. C. Lima 1212 (RB); idem, Seringal Boa Água,
25.VII.1972, est., N. T. Silva 22-215 (US). Material examinado: BOLÍVIA. LA PAZ: Yungas,
Rio Bopi, VII.1939, fr., B. A. Krukoff 10274 (K,
AMES, MO, LP, UC, S, NY); PERU. HUÁNUCO:
Puerto Inca, 16.I.1991, fl., Tello 1139 (NY); JUNIN:
próximo a San Ramon, VI.1988, fr., E. Meneses & R. Pisculich 28 (K); BRASIL. ACRE: Cruzeiro do Sul,
11.III.1992, fl. e fr., C. A. C. Ferreira et al. 10761
(NY); idem, Guiomar Santos, 27.II.1980, fl., H. C. Lima 1212 (RB); idem, Seringal Boa Água,
25.VII.1972, est., N. T. Silva 22-215 (US). Fenologia: floração janeiro a março e
frutificação março a julho. Hábitat e distribuição geográfica: floresta
mesófila e cerrado, em áreas montanhosas. Bolívia (220 a 900 m) e Peru. Brasil: Acre. Essa espécie difere de M. nyctitans
pelo maior tamanho das folhas e do folíolo Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. 310 Figura 12 - Machaerium tortipes Hoehne - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em antese;
f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; j. asa; l. pétalas da carena. (a Ducke s.n. 306 (RB 24198); b-l Lima 1212)
b
a
2 cm
2 cm
2 mm
2 mm
i
h
c
2 mm
2 mm
e
2 mm
d
1 mm
2 mm
j
f
g 1 mm 2 mm d e 2 mm h b 2 mm 2 mm f Figura 12 - Machaerium tortipes Hoehne - a. ramo e inflorescência; b. fruto; c. cálice; d. bractéola; e. flor em antes
f. androceu; g. gineceu; h. vexilo; j. asa; l. pétalas da carena. (a Ducke s.n. (RB 24198); b-l Lima 1212) terminal, pela inflorescência menos ramificada
e pelo vexilo com unha mais longa. Difere-se
dessa espécie e também de M. ovalifolium
pelas asas, pétalas da carena e ovário maiores,
androceu diadelfo e núcleo seminífero mais
largo. Dessa última difere-se também pelo
estipe mais longo e estilete mais curto. florais e dos frutos; as formas das bractéolas,
dos lacínios do cálice e do vexilo e
particularmente, no gineceu, o tamanho do disco
nectarífero, estipe e do estilete. A ocorrência
de um androceu monadelfo, raras vezes diadelfo
(o vexilar livre), é um caráter unificador da
seção, além da presença de folíolos oblongos,
destacada nos primeiros estudos com a seção e
possivelmente, a ocorrência de uma plúmula
pluripartida no embrião. Os caracteres diagnósticos para a
identificação das espécies de Machaerium sect. Oblonga, foram o tamanho dos folíolos, partes Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 Revisão de Machaerium sect. Oblonga (Benth.) Taub. 311 As espécies apresentaram um padrão
de distribuição principalmente restrito à
Região Sudeste do Brasil e a estados vizinhos,
mas foram também observadas espécies
com distribuição muito restrita, como no caso
de M. obovatum e com distribuição ampla
como M. nyctitans, M. scleroxylon e
M. myrianthum. Essa última espécie bem como
M. tortipes, M. goudoti e M. saraense
representaram uma disjunção da seção,
ocorrendo na região amazônica. REFERÊNCIAS BIBLIOGRÁFICAS Andrade-Lima, D. 1996. Atlas Geográfico do
Brasil. IBGE, Rio de Janeiro. Barroso, G. M. 1965. Leguminosas da
Guanabara. Archivos do Jardim Botânico
do Rio de Janeiro 18: 109-177. Bastos, M. N. C. 1987. Contribuição ao estudo
de algumas espécies do gênero
Machaerium Persoon (Leguminosae-
Papilionoideae), ocorrentes na Amazônia
brasileira. Boletim do Museu Paraense de
História Natural 3(2): 183-278. CONCLUSÕES Bentham, G. 1860. Synopsis of Dalbergieae a
tribe of Leguminosae. Journal of the
Linnean Society, Botany 4: 1-128. Machaerium sect. Oblonga com 12
espécies, é a terceira maior seção de
Machaerium ficando atrás de M. sect. Reticulata e M. sect. Lineata, com cerca de 31
e 29 táxons, respectivamente. O estudo permitiu
estabelecer os limites taxonômicos entre
espécies de difícil delimitação como M. nyctitans,
M. ovalifolium, M. scleroxylon, M. floridum
e M. ruddianum. A determinação de novos
sinônimos como M. kuhlmannii, sinônimo de
M. nyctitans, auxiliou no entendimento deste
complexo taxonômico. Foi possível também
atualizar as informações taxonômicas das
demais espécies da seção, bem como as
informações sobre distribuição geográfica,
hábitat e fenologia, ampliando o atual
conhecimento sobre as espécies de Machaerium. Para completar o estudo com o gênero é
necessário ampliar o número de coletas,
principalmente nas Regiões Norte e Nordeste,
bem como realizar revisões taxonômicas das
demais seções de Machaerium. ______. 1862. Machaerium. In: Martius, C. F. P. von & Eichler, A. W. (eds.). Flora
brasiliensis. Munchen, Wien, Leipzig 15
(1): 232-259. Bernadi, L. Contribuição a la dendrologia
Paraguaya. 1. 1984. Boissiera 35: 307-320. Cabrera, A. L. & Willink, A. 1973. Biogeografia de America Latina. Secretaria Geral da Organização dos
Estados Americanos, Washington, DC,
126p. Carvalho, A. M. V. 1997. A synopsis of the
genus Dalbergia (Fabaceae: Dalbergieae)
in Brazil. Brittonia 49(1): 87-109. De Candolle, A. P. 1825. Podromus Systematis
Naturalis Regni Vegetabilis 2: 258. Ducke, A. 1922. Plantes nouvelles ou peu
connues de la region amazonienne II. Arquivo do Jardim Botânico do Rio de
Janeiro 3: 146-152. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 AGRADECIMENTOS ______. 1949. As leguminosas da Amazônia
brasileira. Boletim Técnico do Instituto
Agronômico do Norte 18: 4-248. Agradecemos à Fundação de Amparo à
Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP)
pela concessão da bolsa de doutorado (98/
02889-3) e da reserva técnica (98/6378-3) para
o primeiro autor, sem os quais não seria possível
a execução deste trabalho; aos curadores dos
herbários nacionais e internacionais pelo
empréstimo do material examinado, à
Esmeralda Zanchetta Borghi pelas ilustrações
e aos revisores pelas críticas e sugestões. Guerra, M. S. 1988. Introdução a citogenética
geral. Guanabara, Rio de Janeiro, 142p. Hoehne, F. C. 1941. Leguminosas Papilionadas
(Machaerium e Paramachaerium). Flora brasilica 25(3): 1-99. Holmgren, P. K., Holmgren, N. H. & Barnett,
L. C. 1990. Index herbariorum. Part I: The Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 312 Mendonça Filho, C. V.; Tozzi, A. M. G. A. & Martins, E. R. F. herbaria of the world. 8th ed. New York
Botanical Garden, New York, 693 pp. Radford, A. E.; Dickison, W. C.; Massey, J. R. &
Bell, C. R. 1974. Vascular Plant Systematics. Harper & Row, New York, 891p. Lewis, G. P. 1987. Legumes of Bahia. Royal
Botanic Gardens, Kew, 369p. Rudd, V. E. 1972. New taxa and combinations
in Machaerium (Leguminosae) II. Phytologia 24(2): 121-125. Lima, H. C.; Correia, C. M. B. & Farias, D. S. 1994. Leguminosae In: Lima, M. P. M. & Guedes-Bruni, R. R. (orgs.). Reserva Ecológica de Macaé de Cima,
Nova Friburgo-RJ: Aspectos florísticos
das espécies vasculares 1: 167-228. ______. 1973. New taxa and combinations in
Machaerium
(Leguminosae)
IV. Phytologia 26(2): 398-403. ______. 1977. The genus Machaerium
(Leguminosae) in Mexico. Boletin de
la Sociedad Botanica de México 37:
119-146. Lima, H. C. 1995. Leguminosas da Flora
Fluminensis-J.M. da C. Vellozo- Lista
atualizada das espécies arbóreas. Acta
Botanica Brasilica 9(1): 123-146. ______. 1987. Studies in Machaerium
(Leguminosae). V. History and Fossil
Names. Phytologia 62(4): 277-302. Mendonça-Filho, C. V. 1996. Braúna, Angico,
Jacarandá e outras Leguminosas de Mata
Atlântica: Estação Biológica de Caratinga,
Minas Gerais. Fundação Botânica
Margaret Mee, Belo Horizonte, 100p. ______; Forni-Martins, E. R. & Tozzi, A. M. G. A. 2002. New chromosome counts
in Neotropical Machaerium Pers. species
(Fabaceae) and their taxonomic
significance. Caryologia 55(2): 111-114. Sartori, A. L. B. & Tozzi, A. M. G. A. 1998. As espécies de Machaerium Pers. (Leguminosae Papilionoideae) ocorrentes
no estado de São Paulo. Revista Brasileira
de Botânica 21(3): 211-246. Stearn, W. T. 1983. Botanical Latin. Rodriguésia 58 (2): 283-312. 2007 AGRADECIMENTOS 3rd ed. David & Charles Publ., Inglaterra, 566p. Taubert, P. 1891. Machaerium. In: Engler,
H. G. A & Plant., K. A. E. (eds.). Die
Naturlichen Pflanzenfamilien. 2. Aufl. Leipzig (Wilhem Engelmann). 3: 337. Pickel, B. J. A. 1962. Caviúna legítima do
Brasil. Arquivos de Botânica do Estado
de São Paulo. 3: 237-239.
|
https://openalex.org/W2566759407
|
https://pure.mpg.de/pubman/item/item_2378397_5/component/file_2378401/2378397.pdf
|
English
| null |
Two pathways regulate cortical granule translocation to prevent polyspermy in mouse oocytes
|
Nature communications
| 2,016
|
cc-by
| 16,712
|
ARTICLE Received 12 Jun 2016 | Accepted 27 Oct 2016 | Published 19 Dec 2016 Received 12 Jun 2016 | Accepted 27 Oct 2016 | Published 19 Dec 2016 1 Medical Research Council Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Francis Crick Avenue, Cambridge Biomedical Campus, Cambridge CB2 0QH, UK. 2 Max Planck
Institute for Biophysical Chemistry, Am Fassberg 11, Go¨ttingen 37077, Germany. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to
M.S. (email: melina.schuh@mpibpc.mpg.de). ARTICLE We investigated the dynamics of cortical
granules during meiotic maturation, during which they are
synthesized and translocated to the plasma membrane. To this
end, we recorded 4D videos of oocytes expressing GFP-Rab27a
and counted the number of cortical granules in the centre of the
cell and measured the intensity of Rab27a at the cell cortex
(Fig. 1d). Granules in the centre of the cell produced a clear
pattern over time: (1) an initial increase in number until around
nuclear envelope breakdown (NEBD); (2) a decrease in number
in the centre of the cell by 37% starting around 10 min following
NEBD and lasting for around 4.5 h; (3) a second increase in
granule numbers in the cytosol, likely due to the generation of
new cortical granules in the centre of the cell (Fig. 1e). We
observed that the decrease in granule number in the centre of the
cell coincided with an increase in Rab27a intensity at the cortex,
consistent with the notion of cortical granule translocation to the
cell periphery during this time (Fig. 1f). We therefore divided the
time of meiotic maturation into three distinct phases based on
these observations: phase (1) during which newly synthesized
cortical granules accumulated in the cell centre; phase (2) which
displays the fastest rate of translocation to the cortex; phase (3)
during which cortical granules continue to be recruited to the
cortex, but synthesis exceeds translocation. These phases are
colour-coded from Fig. 1e onwards. The parameters of cortical
granule dynamics are presented in Table 1. Rab27a is essential for cortical granule translocation. We were
able to use Rab27a as a marker for cortical granules in live
t
h
it
i
d t
b d t
i
d
h th
R b27 established marker for cortical granules21 (Fig. 1a). We found
that the vast majority of Rab27a puncta colocalized with LCA
(Fig. 1b), suggesting that cortical granules are positive for Rab27a. To verify this, we expressed GFP-Rab27a in live oocytes and
imaged them through meiotic maturation. The behaviour of
Rab27a spots was strikingly similar to that of cortical granules,
including a strong recruitment to the cortex during meiotic
maturation (Fig. 1c,f), a reduction of the number of puncta in the
centre of the cells (Fig. 1c,e), and the formation of a Rab27a-free
zone at the cortex adjacent to the meiotic spindle, similar
to
the
previously
observed
cortical
granule-free
zone21,22
(Supplementary Fig. ARTICLE 1; Supplementary Movie 1). Interestingly,
although 25% of Rab27a puncta did not stain positive for LCA,
we did not observe a subpopulation that remained in the oocyte
centre, suggesting that the LCA-negative granules also displayed
the hallmarks of cortical granule behaviour. It is possible that the
variability in staining may reflect different stages of granule
maturation. We therefore concluded that cortical granules are
positive for Rab27a, and that Rab27a is a suitable marker for these
granules in live oocytes, consistent with a recent study in fixed
cells16. A
viable human embryo can only develop from an egg that
is fertilized by a single sperm1,2. However, human eggs are
frequently fertilized by multiple sperm: around 10% of
spontaneous abortions are due to triploidy3, the presence of an
extra set of chromosomes in a fetus, and the majority of triploidy
is caused by polyspermy4,5. Consistent with these statistics, the
rate of polyspermy in in vitro fertilized human eggs is around
10% (ref. 1) and therefore remarkably high. Understanding the
mechanisms that protect mammalian eggs from polyspermy is
thus not only of interest for fundamental research but also of
direct medical relevance. Two primary safeguards protect eggs against polyspermy:
firstly, polyspermy is prevented at the plasma membrane level,
where fusion of the first sperm causes depolarization of the
membrane and shedding of the egg’s sperm receptor Folr4 (folate
receptor 4; also known as Juno), thereby preventing fusion
of further sperm6,7. Secondly, fertilization triggers the exocytosis
of cortical granules, a process termed ‘cortical reaction’. Cortical
granules contain enzymes that modify and thereby harden the
zona pellucida, a proteinaceous matrix surrounding the oocyte8. This lowers the binding affinity of sperm by cleavage of the zona
pellucida protein ZP2 (ref. 9) and makes the zona impermeable to
additional sperm. 10 Previous studies only analysed the behaviour of cortical
granules in fixed oocytes, and therefore could not reveal the
dynamics of their behaviour. They also focussed on granules
docked at the plasma membrane, with no quantitative informa-
tion on their number in the oocyte centre. The discovery of a
marker for cortical granules in live oocytes now allowed us to
address these points. We investigated the dynamics of cortical
granules during meiotic maturation, during which they are
synthesized and translocated to the plasma membrane. ARTICLE To this
end, we recorded 4D videos of oocytes expressing GFP-Rab27a
and counted the number of cortical granules in the centre of the
cell and measured the intensity of Rab27a at the cell cortex
(Fig. 1d). Granules in the centre of the cell produced a clear
pattern over time: (1) an initial increase in number until around
nuclear envelope breakdown (NEBD); (2) a decrease in number
in the centre of the cell by 37% starting around 10 min following
NEBD and lasting for around 4.5 h; (3) a second increase in
granule numbers in the cytosol, likely due to the generation of
new cortical granules in the centre of the cell (Fig. 1e). We
observed that the decrease in granule number in the centre of the
cell coincided with an increase in Rab27a intensity at the cortex,
consistent with the notion of cortical granule translocation to the
cell periphery during this time (Fig. 1f). We therefore divided the
time of meiotic maturation into three distinct phases based on
these observations: phase (1) during which newly synthesized
cortical granules accumulated in the cell centre; phase (2) which
displays the fastest rate of translocation to the cortex; phase (3)
during which cortical granules continue to be recruited to the
cortex, but synthesis exceeds translocation. These phases are
colour-coded from Fig. 1e onwards. The parameters of cortical
granule dynamics are presented in Table 1. Cortical granules are synthesized in the centre of the oocyte10
and translocate to the plasma membrane during meiosis in
preparation for fertilization. Although the cortical reaction has
been observed for many years11, the mechanisms that underlie
the synthesis, transport and release of cortical granules in
mammals are still mostly unclear. Research in various species
has
identified
molecular
players
involved
in
either
the
transport12,13,
docking
at
the
plasma
membrane13
or
exocytosis14–18 of the granules, but the majority of players in
mammalian oocytes are yet to be discovered. It has previously been shown that the transport of cortical
granules to the plasma membrane is
an actin-dependent
process12,13. Previously, we have demonstrated the existence
of a cytoplasmic actin network in mouse oocytes which is able to
mediate the long-range transport of Rab11a vesicles19 and is
required for the correct positioning of the meiotic spindle, a
process essential for asymmetric division20. ARTICLE The actin-based
nature of this network, along with its suitability for long-range
transport, made it an ideal candidate for the translocation of
cortical granules and warranted further investigation. Here, we show that cortical granules translocate along the
cytoplasmic actin network in a process that is regulated by
Rab27a. The translocation occurs via two distinct pathways: in
the first pathway, myosin Va transports cortical granules along
actin. In the second unexpected pathway, cortical granules
‘hitchhike’
on
Rab11a
vesicles
that
move
to
the
plasma
membrane, which ultimately delivers the granules to the cortex. We show that the disruption of granule translocation and
subsequent association with the plasma membrane in Rab27a
mutant oocytes causes a dramatic increase in the number
of sperm that can penetrate the zona. These results provide the
molecular mechanisms underlying cortical granule translocation,
and suggest that translocation defects could contribute to the
large number of miscarriages caused by polyspermy. Rab27a is essential for cortical granule translocation. We were
able to use Rab27a as a marker for cortical granules in live
oocytes; however, it remained to be determined whether Rab27a
was required for their transport. To investigate this, we fixed and
stained oocytes from the Ashen transgenic mouse strain, which
lacks a functional Rab27a gene23, with LCA either before NEBD
or after being released into meiosis for 5 h, during which time
most of the translocation is achieved (Fig. 2a). Remarkably, there
was a complete absence of recruitment of cortical granules to the
cortex in Rab27aAsh/Ashoocytes (Fig. 2a,c). Furthermore, the
Rab27aAsh/Ashoocytes had significantly more cortical granules in
the cell centre before NEBD compared to controls, and this NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications Two pathways regulate cortical granule
translocation to prevent polyspermy
in mouse oocytes Liam P. Cheeseman1, Je´roˆme Boulanger1, Lisa M. Bond1 & Melina Schuh1,2 An egg must be fertilized by a single sperm only. To prevent polyspermy, the zona pellucida, a
structure that surrounds mammalian eggs, becomes impermeable upon fertilization,
preventing the entry of further sperm. The structural changes in the zona upon fertilization
are driven by the exocytosis of cortical granules. These translocate from the oocyte’s centre
to the plasma membrane during meiosis. However, very little is known about the mechanism
of cortical granule translocation. Here we investigate cortical granule transport and dynamics
in live mammalian oocytes by using Rab27a as a marker. We show that two separate
mechanisms drive their transport: myosin Va-dependent movement along actin filaments,
and an unexpected vesicle hitchhiking mechanism by which cortical granules bind to Rab11a
vesicles powered by myosin Vb. Inhibiting cortical granule translocation severely impaired the
block to sperm entry, suggesting that translocation defects could contribute to miscarriages
that are caused by polyspermy. 1 Medical Research Council Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Francis Crick Avenue, Cambridge Biomedical Campus, Cambridge CB2 0QH, UK. 2 Max Planck
Institute for Biophysical Chemistry, Am Fassberg 11, Go¨ttingen 37077, Germany. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to
M.S. (email: melina.schuh@mpibpc.mpg.de). 1 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications ARTICLE ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 A A
viable human embryo can only develop from an egg that
is fertilized by a single sperm1,2. However, human eggs are
frequently fertilized by multiple sperm: around 10% of
spontaneous abortions are due to triploidy3, the presence of an
extra set of chromosomes in a fetus, and the majority of triploidy
is caused by polyspermy4,5. Consistent with these statistics, the
rate of polyspermy in in vitro fertilized human eggs is around
10% (ref. 1) and therefore remarkably high. Understanding the
mechanisms that protect mammalian eggs from polyspermy is
thus not only of interest for fundamental research but also of
direct medical relevance. Two primary safeguards protect eggs against polyspermy:
firstly, polyspermy is prevented at the plasma membrane level,
where fusion of the first sperm causes depolarization of the
membrane and shedding of the egg’s sperm receptor Folr4 (folate
receptor 4; also known as Juno), thereby preventing fusion
of further sperm6,7. Secondly, fertilization triggers the exocytosis
of cortical granules, a process termed ‘cortical reaction’. Cortical
granules contain enzymes that modify and thereby harden the
zona pellucida, a proteinaceous matrix surrounding the oocyte8. This lowers the binding affinity of sperm by cleavage of the zona
pellucida protein ZP2 (ref. 9) and makes the zona impermeable to
additional sperm. Cortical granules are synthesized in the centre of the oocyte10
and translocate to the plasma membrane during meiosis in
preparation for fertilization. Although the cortical reaction has
been observed for many years11, the mechanisms that underlie
the synthesis, transport and release of cortical granules in
mammals are still mostly unclear. Research in various species
has
identified
molecular
players
involved
in
either
the
transport12,13,
docking
at
the
plasma
membrane13
or
exocytosis14–18 of the granules, but the majority of players in
mammalian oocytes are yet to be discovered. It has previously been shown that the transport of cortical
granules to the plasma membrane is
an actin-dependent
process12,13. Previously, we have demonstrated the existence
of a cytoplasmic actin network in mouse oocytes which is able to
mediate the long-range transport of Rab11a vesicles19 and is
required for the correct positioning of the meiotic spindle, a
process essential for asymmetric division20. The actin-based
nature of this network, along with its suitability for long-range
transport, made it an ideal candidate for the translocation of
cortical granules and warranted further investigation. ARTICLE Here, we show that cortical granules translocate along the
cytoplasmic actin network in a process that is regulated by
Rab27a. The translocation occurs via two distinct pathways: in
the first pathway, myosin Va transports cortical granules along
actin. In the second unexpected pathway, cortical granules
‘hitchhike’
on
Rab11a
vesicles
that
move
to
the
plasma
membrane, which ultimately delivers the granules to the cortex. We show that the disruption of granule translocation and
subsequent association with the plasma membrane in Rab27a
mutant oocytes causes a dramatic increase in the number
of sperm that can penetrate the zona. These results provide the
molecular mechanisms underlying cortical granule translocation,
and suggest that translocation defects could contribute to the
l
b
f
i
i
d b
l
established marker for cortical granules21 (Fig. 1a). We found
that the vast majority of Rab27a puncta colocalized with LCA
(Fig. 1b), suggesting that cortical granules are positive for Rab27a. To verify this, we expressed GFP-Rab27a in live oocytes and
imaged them through meiotic maturation. The behaviour of
Rab27a spots was strikingly similar to that of cortical granules,
including a strong recruitment to the cortex during meiotic
maturation (Fig. 1c,f), a reduction of the number of puncta in the
centre of the cells (Fig. 1c,e), and the formation of a Rab27a-free
zone at the cortex adjacent to the meiotic spindle, similar
to
the
previously
observed
cortical
granule-free
zone21,22
(Supplementary Fig. 1; Supplementary Movie 1). Interestingly,
although 25% of Rab27a puncta did not stain positive for LCA,
we did not observe a subpopulation that remained in the oocyte
centre, suggesting that the LCA-negative granules also displayed
the hallmarks of cortical granule behaviour. It is possible that the
variability in staining may reflect different stages of granule
maturation. We therefore concluded that cortical granules are
positive for Rab27a, and that Rab27a is a suitable marker for these
granules in live oocytes, consistent with a recent study in fixed
cells16. Previous studies only analysed the behaviour of cortical
granules in fixed oocytes, and therefore could not reveal the
dynamics of their behaviour. They also focussed on granules
docked at the plasma membrane, with no quantitative informa-
tion on their number in the oocyte centre. The discovery of a
marker for cortical granules in live oocytes now allowed us to
address these points. Results
b Crop cell centre
Cell cortex
2. Detect spots
2. Detect surfaces
Cortical granules in cell centre
Cortical granules at the cortex
1. Crop cell cortex
Time (h)
Cortical granules /μm3
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
3. Plot values
3. Plot values
e
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Cytoplasmic cortical granules μm–3
n = 30
Average plot
Smoothed curve
f
50
100
150
200
250
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to NEBD (%)
n = 30
Fitted curve (single exponential)
Fitted curve (linear)
Average plot
3
2
1
3
2
1
3
2
1
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
Figure 1 | Rab27a is a marker for cortical granules. (a) Oocyte expressing GFP-Rab27a, fixed and stained with lens culinaris agglutinin, a cortical granule
marker. Scale bar, 20mm. (b) Quantification of the colocalization of Rab27a puncta with lens culinaris agglutinin puncta (mean±s.d. from three experiments). Total
number of Rab27a puncta quantified are indicated. (c) Cortical granules visualized with GFP-Rab27a translocate from the centre of oocytes to the cortex, where
they become enriched. Scale bars, 20mm (overview) and 5mm (enlarged). (d) Schematic diagram of the quantification methods for cortical granule translocation
and enrichment at the cortex. Scale bars, 20mm. (e) Cortical granule dynamics in the oocyte centre during meiotic maturation. Three separate phases can be
identified in the cell centre, which are colour-coded in all subsequent graphs. The start and end of each phase was determined by calculating the derivative of the
data. (f) Cortical granule enrichment at the oocyte cortex during meiotic maturation. The three separate phases identified in the cell centre are colour-coded. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications
3 d d
Movie
1. Crop cell centre
Cell cortex
2. Detect spots
2. Detect surfaces
Cortical granules in cell centre
Cortical granules at the cortex
1. Crop cell cortex
Time (h)
Cortical granules /μm3
Total cortex intensity
3. Plot values
3. Results
b Rab27a is a marker for cortical granules in live oocytes. The
expression of GFP-Rab27a in mouse oocytes generated a pattern
that was reminiscent of cortical granules. We therefore sought to
confirm whether Rab27a colocalized with cortical granules by
staining fixed oocytes expressing GFP- or mCherry-Rab27a with
rhodamine- or FITC-labelled lens culinaris agglutinin (LCA), an NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 2 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Lens culinaris
agglutinin
Rab27a
Merge DNA
d
Movie
1. Crop cell centre
Cell cortex
a
b
c
2. Detect spots
2. Detect surfaces
Rab27a puncta positive for
lens culinaris agglutinin (%)
Cortical granules in cell centre
Cortical granules at the cortex
1. Crop cell cortex
NEBD
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
Time (h)
Cortical granules /μm3
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
3. Plot values
3. Plot values
01 h 00 min
e
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Cytoplasmic cortical granules μm–3
n = 30
Average plot
Smoothed curve
f
50
100
150
200
250
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to NEBD (%)
n = 30
Fitted curve (single exponential)
Fitted curve (linear)
Average plot
–01 h 40 min
Before NEBD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
3
2
1
3
2
1
3
2
1
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
n = 6292
is a marker for cortical granules. (a) Oocyte expressing GFP-Rab27a, fixed and stained with lens culinaris agglutinin, a cortical granule
0mm. (b) Quantification of the colocalization of Rab27a puncta with lens culinaris agglutinin puncta (mean±s.d. from three experiments). Total
puncta quantified are indicated. (c) Cortical granules visualized with GFP-Rab27a translocate from the centre of oocytes to the cortex, where
hed Scale bars 20mm (overview) and 5mm (enlarged) (d) Schematic diagram of the quantification methods for cortical granule translocation Lens culinaris
agglutinin
Rab27a
Merge DNA
a
b
Rab27a puncta positive for
lens culinaris agglutinin (%)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
n = 6292 b a c c
NEBD
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
01 h 00 min
–01 h 40 min
Before NEBD d
Movie
1. Results
b Plot values e
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Cytoplasmic cortical granules μm–3
n = 30
Average plot
Smoothed curve
3
2
1
3
2
1
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3 Time (h)
f
50
100
150
200
250
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to NEBD (%)
n = 30
Fitted curve (single exponential)
Fitted curve (linear)
Average plot
3
2
1 f Phase 1 Phase 1 Figure 1 | Rab27a is a marker for cortical granules. (a) Oocyte expressing GFP-Rab27a, fixed and stained with lens culinaris agglutinin, a cortical granule
marker. Scale bar, 20mm. (b) Quantification of the colocalization of Rab27a puncta with lens culinaris agglutinin puncta (mean±s.d. from three experiments). Total
number of Rab27a puncta quantified are indicated. (c) Cortical granules visualized with GFP-Rab27a translocate from the centre of oocytes to the cortex, where
they become enriched. Scale bars, 20mm (overview) and 5mm (enlarged). (d) Schematic diagram of the quantification methods for cortical granule translocation
and enrichment at the cortex. Scale bars, 20mm. (e) Cortical granule dynamics in the oocyte centre during meiotic maturation. Three separate phases can be
identified in the cell centre, which are colour-coded in all subsequent graphs. The start and end of each phase was determined by calculating the derivative of the
data. (f) Cortical granule enrichment at the oocyte cortex during meiotic maturation. The three separate phases identified in the cell centre are colour-coded. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 3 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Table 1 | Parameters of cortical granule translocation in mouse oocytes. Parameters in cell centre (n ¼ 20 cells)
Value
s.d. Results
b Unit
Onset of phase 2
28
33
min
End of phase 2
246
63
min
Duration of phase 2
218
61
min
Average CG at start of phase 2 per mm3
0.066
0.028
CGs mm 3
Average CG at start of phase 2 per oocyte*
14,573
6,176
CGs
Average CG at end of phase 2 per mm3
0.041
0.021
CGs mm 3
Average CG at end of phase 2 per oocyte*
9,092
4,648
CGs
Percentage decrease
37.6
%
Rate of phase 1 increase per mm3
0.00016
0.00014
CGs mm 3 min 1
Rate of phase 1 increase per oocyte*
35.6
30.9
CGs min 1
Rate of phase 2 decline per mm3
0.00012
0.00012
CGs mm 3 min 1
Rate of phase 2 decline per oocyte*
26.7
27.1
CGs min 1
Fastest rate of decline per mm3 (over 60 min period)
0.00015
0.00011
CGs mm 3 min 1
Fastest rate of decline per oocyte*
32.1
24.8
CGs min 1
Rate of phase 3 increase per mm3
0.000056
0.000095
CGs mm 3 min 1
Rate of phase 3 increase per oocyte*
12.4
21.0
CGs min 1
Parameters at the cell cortex (n ¼ 21 cells)
Onset of increase
42
27
min
Average intensity at start of increase
99.0
16.8
%
Average intensity at end of phase 2 (n ¼ 14)
187.9
81.9
%
Percentage increase
89.8
%
Average rate of increase of phase 1
0.14
0.21
% min 1
Average rate of increase of phase 2
0.37
0.32
% min 1
Average rate of increase of phase 3
0.16
0.19
% min 1
Rate of change during first 60 min of increase
0.37
0.29
% min 1
Rate of change for 30 min before phase 3 (n ¼ 14)
0.06
0.20
% min 1
Fitting equation
y ¼ A * exp( x/t1) þ y0
A (Amplitude)
123.91
1.90
t1 (constant decay)
199.81
8.97
min
Upper limit asymptote (y0)
220.17
2.28
%
Adjusted R2
0.9897
Half-life of exponential increase
138.50
min
CG, cortical granule. *Based on oocyte diameter of 75 mm. Table 1 | Parameters of cortical granule translocation in mouse oocytes. Results
b a
b
c
Before NEBD
5 h after release
Rab27a Ash/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27a Ash/Ash
mCherry-Rab27a
(rescue)
Cytoplasmic cortical granules μm–3
5 h
after release
Before NEBD
Rab27a Ash/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27a Ash/Ash rescue
Rab27a Ash/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27a Ash/Ash rescue
Rab27a Ash/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27a Ash/Ash rescue
Rab27a Ash/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27a Ash/Ash rescue
5 h
after release
Before NEBD
0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
Total cortex intensity ×106 (AU)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
25
24
28
26
23
35
25
23
28
26
23
n= 35
n=
*
n.s. n.s. ***
*** n.s. ***
*** n.s. ***
***
***
Lens culinaris agglutinin
Figure 2 | Rab27a is required for cortical granule translocation. (a) Maximum intensity projections of confocal micrographs of Rab27a þ /Ash (control) or
Rab27aAsh/Ash (mutant) oocytes at NEBD or released for 5 h, then fixed and stained with lens culinaris agglutinin. Scale bar, 20 mm. (b) Quantification
of cortical granules in the cell centre for the conditions in a. (c) Quantification of cortical granules at the cell cortex for the conditions in a. Tukey box plots
in b,c show the median (line), mean (small square), interquartile range, and the 5th and 95th (whiskers). Significance levels: ns non-significant,
*Po0.05, ***Po0.001, analysed using Kruskal–Wallis’ ANOVA test from three experiments. 4
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS |
13 26 | DOI 10 1038/
13 26 |
/
i
i b
Cytoplasmic cortical granules μm–3
5 h
after release
Before NEBD
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
25
24
28
26
23
n= 35
*
n.s. n.s. ***
*** n.s. a
Before NEBD
5 h after release
Rab27a Ash/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27a Ash/Ash
mCherry-Rab27a
(rescue)
Lens culinaris agglutinin c
5 h
after release
Before NEBD
Total cortex intensity ×106 (AU)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
35
25
23
28
26
23
n=
***
*** n.s. ***
***
*** b a a c Total cortex intensity ×106 (AU) Rab27a+/Ash Lens culinaris agglutinin Figure 2 | Rab27a is required for cortical granule translocation. (a) Maximum intensity projections of confocal micrographs of Rab27a þ /Ash (control) or
Rab27aAsh/Ash (mutant) oocytes at NEBD or released for 5 h, then fixed and stained with lens culinaris agglutinin. Scale bar, 20 mm. (b) Quantification
of cortical granules in the cell centre for the conditions in a. (c) Quantification of cortical granules at the cell cortex for the conditions in a. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications ARTICLE We therefore analysed the movements
of
Rab27a
vesicles
associated
with
or
dissociated
from
Rab11a vesicles. Both the speed and the displacement speed of
cortical granules were significantly increased when associated
with Rab11a, and were of intermediate value between those of
Rab27a alone and of Rab11a vesicles themselves (Fig. 4e,f). We
also found that ‘hitchhiking’ Rab27a vesicles travelled further
than the ‘non-hitchhiking’ ones during the same time period
(Fig. 4g). Taken together, these data suggest a surprising function
for Rab11a vesicles: they transiently bind cortical granules and
increase their translocation speed by pulling them towards the
cortex. Cortical granule transport via the cytoplasmic actin network. Previous studies in fixed oocytes indicated that the transport of
cortical granules to the plasma membrane is actin-dependent12,13. However, detailed studies of the dynamics of cortical granules in
the presence and absence of actin in live oocytes were missing. To
investigate which stages of the translocation of cortical granules
are
actin
dependent,
we
treated
oocytes
with
the
actin-
depolymerizing drug cytochalasin D. In the absence of actin,
cortical granule recruitment to the cortex was abolished in all
phases of cortical translocation and the number of granules in the
cell centre accumulated over time (Fig. 3c,d; Supplementary
Fig. 2b; Supplementary Movie 3). By contrast, none of the phases
were
affected
by
the
microtubule-depolymerizing
drug
nocodazole, indicating that microtubules are not involved in
cortical granule transport (Fig. 3a,b; Supplementary Fig. 2a;
Supplementary Movie 2). This suggested that cortical granules are
translocated during all phases via an actin-based mechanism with
no contribution by microtubules. If Rab11a hitchhiking has a significant impact on cortical
granule translocation, one would expect that blocking Rab11a
function would decrease the efficiency of translocation. To test
this, we expressed the dominant-negative variant Rab11aS25N. Cells expressing mutant Rab11a did not display the typical phase
2 decrease in granule number, but interestingly did not
accumulate them in the cell centre either: rather the number
reached a plateau around NEBD (Fig. 4h,i; Supplementary
Fig. 2d; Supplementary Movie 5). Conversely, some cortical
enrichment of Rab27a was observed, but this was significantly
lower than in wild-type cells. Together, these results suggest that
cortical granules are able to accelerate their transport to the
cortex by hitchhiking on Rab11a vesicles. y
Next, we investigated which actin structures and motor
proteins mediate the translocation of cortical granules. ARTICLE ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Cortical granules hitchhike on Rab11a vesicles. We have pre-
viously observed that Rab11a vesicles frequently form the nodes
of the cytoplasmic actin network19 and drive the network
dynamics19,20. As cortical granules sometimes colocalized with
the actin nodes (Fig. 3h), we investigated the interactions between
Rab11a and Rab27a. Unexpectedly, we frequently noticed a close
association between a subset of cortical granules and Rab11a
vesicles (Fig. 4a). Upon investigation using high spatial and
temporal imaging, we found that a subset of cortical granules
seemed to ‘latch onto’ Rab11a vesicles which passed in proximity
to them, then maintained this bond during the rapid Rab11a
vesicle movement, and detached several microns from their point
of origin (Fig. 4b). These interactions were transient, but could
last for more than 10 s (Fig. 4c; Supplementary Movie 7). Additionally, a single Rab11a vesicle was able to bind multiple
cortical granules at a time (Fig. 4c). We observed around 7% of
cortical granules were bound to Rab11a vesicles at any one time,
and there were on average two ‘on’ and two ‘off’ events per
Rab11a vesicle per minute (Fig. 4d). number increased dramatically after a 5-h release, in contrast to
control cells (Fig. 2b). Together, these data suggest that Rab27a is
involved in the translocation and association of granules with
the
cortex. We
then
sought
to
rescue
these
defects
by
expressing functional Rab27a mRNA in the Ash/Ash oocytes. This significantly rescued the translocation of cortical granules to
the cortex and reduced the number of granules in the cell centre,
although these did not reach control levels (Fig. 2a–c). Consistent
with our observation that there is little translocation of cortical
granules before NEBD, expression of functional Rab27a had no
significant effect on oocytes before NEBD. We also observed
that in Ash/Ash oocytes, cortical granules aggregated in the
perinuclear region (see Fig. 2a), which we did not observe in
control cells. This indicated a complete lack of transport from
their point of synthesis, suggesting that Rab27a was involved in
the transport of cortical granules rather than only their
maintenance at the cortex. Together, our data indicate that
Rab27a is essential for the translocation of cortical granules to the
plasma membrane. We reasoned that this co-transport mechanism could potenti-
ate the translocation of cortical granules since Rab11a vesicles
move towards the cortex19. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications Results
b Tukey box plots
in b,c show the median (line), mean (small square), interquartile range, and the 5th and 95th (whiskers). Significance levels: ns non-significant,
*Po0.05, ***Po0.001, analysed using Kruskal–Wallis’ ANOVA test from three experiments. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 4 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Quantification of cortical granule translocation in the oocyte
centre or cortex (mean±s.e.m.) in cells treated with nocodazole or DMSO (a), cytochalasin D or DMSO (c), in Fmn2 / (which lack an important actin
nucleator) or Fmn2 þ / oocytes (e). Representative still images (all maximum intensity projections of confocal Z sections) for each condition are presented
in b,d and f. Control images are included in Supplementary Fig. 2. Scale bars, 20 mm (overview) and 5 mm (enlarged). (g-h) Still confocal images of a cortica
granule being transported along actin (g), or interacting with an actin node (h). Scale bars, 2 mm. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 the anomalous diffusion of granules is a complex motion com-
posed of the superimposition of Brownian motion and actin-
blocked the network dynamics by expressing dominant-negative
myosin Vb19
Myosin Vb is essential for the actin network
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
0
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
0
Cortical granules μm–3
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Cortical granules in the cell centre
Cortical granules at the cell cortex
DMSO cytochalasin D
DMSO nocodazole
n = 19; 25
n = 13; 13
n = 16; 18
Before NEBD
NEBD
5 h after NEBD
Cytochalasin D
Nocodazole
Fmn2–/–
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
–00 h 10 min
3
2
1
3
2
1
0 s
6.6 s
8.8 s
13.2 s
18.7 s
Actin
Rab27a
Merge
0 s
4.4 s
7.7 s
24.2 s
34.3 s
Actin
Rab27a
Merge
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
Cortical granules μm–3
Fmn2+/– Fmn2–/–
Cortical granules μm–3
0.14
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
200
150
100
50
250
200
150
100
50
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
Figure 3 | Cortical granule translocation is dependent on the cytoplasmic actin network. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 ARTICLE
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 0
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Cortical granules μm–3
Cortical granules in the cell centre
DMSO nocodazole
n = 13; 13
3
2
1
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
a Before NEBD
NEBD
5 h after NEBD
Nocodazole
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
b b b –1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Cortical granules at the cell cortex
3
2
1 a Nocodazole d –1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
DMSO cytochalasin D
n = 19; 25
Cortical granules μm–3
c Cytochalasin D
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
d c –1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
0
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
200
150
100
50 Cytochalasin D f 0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
n = 16; 18
Fmn2+/– Fmn2–/–
Cortical granules μm–3
0.14
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
e Fmn2–/–
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
–00 h 10 min
f e 0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
250
200
150
100
50 h 0 s
6.6 s
8.8 s
13.2 s
18.7 s
Actin
Rab27a
Merge
g g 0 s
4.4 s
7.7 s
24.2 s
34.3 s
Actin
Rab27a
Merge
h Figure 3 | Cortical granule translocation is dependent on the cytoplasmic actin network. Quantification of cortical granule translocation in the oocyte
centre or cortex (mean±s.e.m.) in cells treated with nocodazole or DMSO (a), cytochalasin D or DMSO (c), in Fmn2 / (which lack an important actin
nucleator) or Fmn2 þ / oocytes (e). ARTICLE We and
others have previously demonstrated the existence of a cytoplas-
mic actin network in mouse oocytes that is nucleated by the actin
nucleation factors Formin-2 (Fmn2) and Spire1/2 and required
for asymmetric spindle positioning in oocytes24–26. This network
also mediates the transport of Rab11a-positive vesicles over long
distances19. The movements of these vesicles and the dynamics of
the actin network are driven by myosin Vb19,20. The actin-based
nature of this network, along with its suitability for long-range
transport, made it an ideal candidate for the translocation of
cortical granules and warranted further investigation. We tested if
the translocation of cortical granules relies on the cytoplasmic
actin network by imaging cortical granules in oocytes from
Fmn2 /
mice, which lack the actin nucleator Formin-2
(ref. 26). Indeed, the rate of translocation of cortical granules to
the cortex and their reduction in the centre were significantly
inhibited (Fig. 3e,f; Supplementary Fig. 2c; Supplementary Movie
4), suggesting that Fmn2 /
oocytes are less efficient at
translocating cortical granules. We then verified these results by
imaging actin and cortical granules together in oocytes expressing
GFP-UtrCH
and
mCherry-Rab27a. Cortical
granules
were
frequently observed moving along actin structures (Fig. 3g) or
associated with actin nodes (Fig. 3h). Together, these results show
that the cytoplasmic actin network forms the tracks via which
cortical granules are transported to the cortex. Anomalous diffusion of cortical granules by actin dynamics. When Rab27a particles were not hitchhiking on Rab11a vesicles,
we often observed them undergoing local movement in random
directions similar to diffusion; however, their speed was high and
inconsistent with Brownian motion. We wondered if the
increased velocity of this anomalous super-diffusion could be due
to the association of Rab27a vesicles with the actin network. To
test this possibility, we treated oocytes with cytochalasin D to
disassemble the actin cytoskeleton and compared the movements
of the granules to diffusion-only granule trajectories in control
oocytes. The mean speed and displacement speed of cortical
granules in oocytes treated with cytochalasin D were significantly
lower than those of the diffusive motions observed in controls
(Supplementary Fig. 3a–d; Po0.0001 in both cases, Student’s t
test). Local mean squared displacement (MSD) analysis showed
that the median diffusion parameter in control oocytes was four
times that of cytochalasin
D-treated oocytes (Supplementary
Fig. 3e,f; 0.0129 versus 0.0031, respectively). This indicated that NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 5 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Significance levels: *Po0.05,
***Po0 001 analysed using Kruskal Wallis’ ANOVA test from two experiments (g) Representative example trajectories of the particle categories
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726
ARTICLE Example 3
0
1
2
3
4
Rab27a / Rab11a
Time (s)
Example 1
0
1
2
3
4
Rab27a / Rab11a
Time (s)
0
2.2
4.4
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
4.4
c Example 3
0
1
2
3
4
Rab27a / Rab11a
Time (s)
Example 1
0
1
2
3
4
Rab27a / Rab11a
Time (s)
Example 4
Time (s)
Example 2
Time (s)
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
0
2.2
4.4
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
4.4
4.4
4.4
c Merge
Rab11a
Rab27a
a c a Example 3
0
1
2
3
4
Rab27a / Rab11a
Time (s)
0
1
Rab27a
Time (s)
0
2.2
4.4
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
4.4 Example 3
0
1
2
3
4
Rab27a / Rab11a
Time (s)
Time (s)
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
4
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
4.4 Example 4
Time (s)
Time (s)
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
4
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
4.4 b Rab27a
Rab11a
Merge
Cortex
0 s
6.54 s
28.34 s
17.44 s
32.7s
Cortex
2 μm
10 s
b Time (s)
***
***
n.s. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Example 3
0
1
2
3
4
Rab27a / Rab11a
Time (s)
Example 1
0
1
2
3
4
Rab27a / Rab11a
Time (s)
Example 4
Time (s)
Example 2
Time (s)
Merge
Rab11a
Rab27a
Example tracks (2D projections):
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Rab11a
***
Rab27a
Rab11a
Merge
Cortex
0 s
6.54 s
28.34 s
17.44 s
32.7s
Cortex
2 μm
10 s
***
***
n.s. *** *
0.45
0.50
0.55
0.60
n = 350 3032
531
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
6
0
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
0
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Rab11aWT Rab11aS25N
n = 19; 15
Rab11aS25N
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
Cortical granules in the cell centre
Cortical granules at the cell cortex
Before NEBD
NEBD
5 h after NEBD
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
μm
μm
μm
0
2.2
4.4
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
0
2.2
6.6
8.8
11.0
13.2
15.4
17.6
19.8
22.0
24.2
26.4
28.6
30.8
33.0
35.2
37.4
39.6
41.8
4.4
Events per Rab11a
vesicle (min–1)
7.00
6.00
5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
–1.00
Vesicle speed (μm s–1)
0.00
0.40
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
0.40
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Vesicle displacement speed
(μm s–1)
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
–6
–4
–2
2
4
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
Cortical granules μm–3
0.1
0.09
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
300
250
200
150
100
50
4.4
4.4
a
c
b
d
e
f
g
h
i
Figure 4 | Cortical granules are translocated to the cortex by hitchhiking on Rab11a vesicles. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Rab11a
6
μm
0.00
0.00
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
–6
–4
–2
2
4
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0 0.00
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a Example tracks (2D projections):
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Rab11a
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
μm
μm
μm
Rab11
Rab27a alon
Rab27a + Rab11
Rab11
Rab27a alon
Rab27a + Rab11
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
–6
–4
–2
2
4
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
g g Example tracks (2D projections):
Rab27a alone
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
μm Rab27a + Rab11a
μm
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0 Rab27a + Rab11a
6 Rab11aS25N
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
Before NEBD
NEBD
5 h after NEBD
i i i h 0
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Cortical granules at the cell cortex
300
250
200
150
100
50 0
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Rab11aWT Rab11aS25N
n = 19; 15
Cortical granules in the cell centre
Cortical granules μm–3
0.1
0.09
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
h 5 h after NEBD Rab11aS25N Time (h) Time (h) Figure 4 | Cortical granules are translocated to the cortex by hitchhiking on Rab11a vesicles. (a) Maximum intensity projections of confocal micrographs
of an oocyte expressing GFP-Rab27a and mCherry-Rab11a. Note the close association between both types of vesicles (insets). Scale bar, 20 mm. (b) Example still images of a cortical granule (Rab27a, green; indicated by arrows) hitchhiking on a Rab11a vesicle (magenta) to reach the cortex (dotted
line), with corresponding kymograph. Scale bar, 2 mm. (c) Quantification of the number of cortical granules associated to four example Rab11a vesicles. (d) Number of cortical granule hitchhiking ‘on’ and ‘off’ events per Rab11a vesicle per minute (n ¼ 23 trajectories from three oocytes). NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Representative still images (all maximum intensity projections of confocal Z sections) for each condition are presented
in b,d and f. Control images are included in Supplementary Fig. 2. Scale bars, 20 mm (overview) and 5 mm (enlarged). (g-h) Still confocal images of a cortical
granule being transported along actin (g), or interacting with an actin node (h). Scale bars, 2 mm. the anomalous diffusion of granules is a complex motion com-
posed of the superimposition of Brownian motion and actin-
generated movement. blocked the network dynamics by expressing dominant-negative
myosin Vb19. Myosin Vb is essential for the actin network
dynamics, and its inhibition produces a static cytoskeleton19,20. The diffusion parameter of non-directed motion was significantly
reduced in cells expressing dominant-negative myosin Vb and g
To investigate further if the high dynamics of cortical granules
could be due to association with the dynamic actin network, we 6 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 (a) Maximum intensity projections of confocal micrographs
of an oocyte expressing GFP-Rab27a and mCherry-Rab11a. Note the close association between both types of vesicles (insets). Scale bar, 20 mm. (b) Example still images of a cortical granule (Rab27a, green; indicated by arrows) hitchhiking on a Rab11a vesicle (magenta) to reach the cortex (dotted
line), with corresponding kymograph. Scale bar, 2 mm. (c) Quantification of the number of cortical granules associated to four example Rab11a vesicles. (d) Number of cortical granule hitchhiking ‘on’ and ‘off’ events per Rab11a vesicle per minute (n ¼ 23 trajectories from three oocytes). Vesicle speed (e) and
vesicle displacement speed (f) were quantified for cortical granules while associated to Rab11a vesicles (Rab27a þ Rab11a), cortical granules while not
associated to Rab11a vesicles (Rab27a alone), and for Rab11a vesicles. Number of tracks used for quantification are indicated in e, from six oocytes. Tukey
box plots in d,e and f show the median (line), mean (small square), interquartile range, and the 5th and 95th (whiskers). NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 (a) Maximum intensity projections of confocal micrographs
of an oocyte expressing GFP-Rab27a and mCherry-Rab11a. Note the close association between both types of vesicles (insets). Scale bar, 20 mm. (b) Example still images of a cortical granule (Rab27a, green; indicated by arrows) hitchhiking on a Rab11a vesicle (magenta) to reach the cortex (dotted
line), with corresponding kymograph. Scale bar, 2 mm. (c) Quantification of the number of cortical granules associated to four example Rab11a vesicles. (d) Number of cortical granule hitchhiking ‘on’ and ‘off’ events per Rab11a vesicle per minute (n ¼ 23 trajectories from three oocytes). Vesicle speed (e) and
vesicle displacement speed (f) were quantified for cortical granules while associated to Rab11a vesicles (Rab27a þ Rab11a), cortical granules while not
associated to Rab11a vesicles (Rab27a alone), and for Rab11a vesicles. Number of tracks used for quantification are indicated in e, from six oocytes. Tukey
box plots in d,e and f show the median (line), mean (small square), interquartile range, and the 5th and 95th (whiskers). Significance levels: *Po0.05,
***Po0.001, analysed using Kruskal–Wallis’ ANOVA test from two experiments. (g) Representative example trajectories of the particle categories
indicated in e and f (six trajectories per condition), projected in two dimensions. Duration of each trajectory is 52 s. (h) Quantification of cortical granule
translocation in the oocyte centre or cortex (mean±s.e.m.) in oocytes expressing Rab11aS25N or wild-type Rab11a. (i) Representative still images
(maximum intensity projections of confocal Z sections) of oocytes expressing Rab11aS25N. Control images are included in Supplementary Fig. 2. Scale bars,
20 mm (overview) and 5 mm (enlarged). NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 0.00
0.40
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
1a
ne
1a
Vesicle displacement speed
(μm s–1)
f ( )
***
*** *
0.45
0.50
0.55
0.60
n = 350 3032
531
Vesicle speed (μm s–1)
0.00
0.40
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
a
e
a
e Events per Rab11a
vesicle (min–1)
7.00
6.00
5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
–1.00
d f d e Vesicle displacement speed
(μm s–1)
f Example tracks (2D projections):
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Rab11a
Merge
2 μm
10 s
0.45
n = 350 3032
531
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
μm
μm
μm
Events per Rab11a
vesicle (min–1)
5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
–1.00
Vesicle speed (μm s
0.00
0.40
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Vesicle displacement s
(μm s–1)
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
–6
–4
–2
2
4
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
g Merge Example tracks (2D projections):
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Rab11a
n = 350 3032
531
6
0
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
0
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Rab11aWT Rab11aS25N
n = 19; 15
Rab11aS25N
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
Cortical granules in the cell centre
Cortical granules at the cell cortex
Before NEBD
NEBD
5 h after NEBD
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
μm
μm
μm
–1.00
0.00
0.00
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
Rab11a
Rab27a alone
Rab27a + Rab11a
V
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
–6
–4
–2
2
4
–6
–4
–2
2
4
6
0
Cortical granules μm–3
0.1
0.09
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
300
250
200
150
100
50
g
h
i
Figure 4 | Cortical granules are translocated to the cortex by hitchhiking on Rab11a vesicles. ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 anomalous
diffusion
was
largely
inhibited
(Supplementary
Fig. 3g,h), demonstrating that this motion was driven by actin
dynamics. of the high anomalous diffusion of Rab27a granules in oocytes
(Supplementary Fig. 3). We therefore used MSD to analyse the
velocity parameter separately from the diffusion parameter. Particle trajectories, separated based on whether they displayed
Rab11a-dependent or Rab11a-independent active motions, were
analysed by local MSD (Fig. 5d; Supplementary Movie 10). As
periods of directed motion were extremely transient (o10 s), the
time lag was set to 6 timepoints (12.6 s) to detect local variations
in movement and to dissect the different motions of a trajectory
temporally. Velocity and diffusion parameter thresholds were
used to separate trajectory steps into types of motions so that
we could focus our analysis on periods of directed motion
alone (Supplementary Fig. 5; see Methods for details). Consistently, cortical granules could associate with actin
filaments (Supplementary Fig. 3i) or actin nodes (Fig. 3h) without
directed motion, instead displaying diffusive motion. This
movement was visibly different to active transport along an actin
filament (Fig. 3g). These results suggest that cortical granules are
predominantly bound to the actin cytoskeleton between periods
of directed transport, consistent with a previous study that
showed that the granules link to actin at the onset of meiotic
maturation12. pp
y
g
When MyoVaLT was expressed, the proportion of active
steps in Rab11a-independent trajectories was reduced by over
40% (Fig. 5e,f; Po0.0001, Fischer’s exact test). Additionally, the
median velocity parameter of Rab11a-independent transport was
significantly reduced, suggesting a function of myosin Va in
Rab11a-independent
transport
(Fig. 5h;
Po0.001,
Mann-
Whitney’s U-test). By contrast, MyoVaLT did not affect the
proportion of active steps or velocity parameter of Rab11a-
dependent trajectories (Fig. 5e,g; P ¼ 0.803, Fischer’s exact test;
Fig. 5i; P ¼ 0.376, Mann-Whitney’s U-test). As a control, we
inhibited myosin Vb which is known to power the movement of
Rab11a vesicles19. Expression of MyoVbLT strongly affected all
types of motion, reducing the number of active steps and both
MSD parameters (Fig. 5e–i; Supplementary Fig. 5), consistent
with its role in driving the dynamics of the actin network19,20. Importantly, it was the only condition to significantly affect
Rab11a-dependent transport (Fig. 5g,i), indicating that Rab11a
hitchhiking is powered by myosin Vb but not myosin Va,
consistent with previous findings19,20. Myosin Va transports cortical granules. ARTICLE Rab27a is known to
regulate the transport of secretory cargoes in various cell types in
complex with the motor protein myosin Va27–29. We investigated
whether myosin Va might similarly be involved in the transport
of cortical granules by expressing the dominant-negative tail
construct MyoVaLT, which did not affect Rab11a motility in a
previous study20. We note that the MyoVaLT construct used here
is reported to bind dynein light chain 8 (refs 30,31). However,
given that our results demonstrated clearly that the translocation
of cortical granules is independent of microtubules (Fig. 3a,b),
this potential secondary effect of MyoVaLT is unlikely to have an
influence
on
cortical
granule
behaviour. Cells
expressing
MyoVaLT
displayed
a
dramatic
accumulation
of
cortical
granules in the cell centre compared to control cells and cells
expressing the wild-type myosin (Fig. 5a,b; Supplementary
Fig. 2e; Supplementary Movie 6). Intriguingly, MyoVaLT first
caused a clustering of cortical granules at the plasma membrane. Shortly after NEBD, the granules were released from the cortex
and displayed retrograde movement towards the cell centre
(Supplementary Fig. 4). Consistently, the intensity of Rab27a at
the cortex declined over time (Fig. 5a,b). Together, these results
suggested that myosin Va is involved in the association of cortical
granules with the plasma membrane, and potentially in their
transport. An alternative interpretation is that the hitchhiking is merely a
by-product of random encounters between Rab11a and Rab27a. However, the inhibition of Rab11a or myosin Vb both prevented
efficient granule translocation (Fig. 4h,i; Supplementary Fig. 6),
indicating that Rab11a hitchhiking actively contributes to the
transport of cortical granules and is a bona fide pathway. We further noticed that in high temporal resolution movies of
oocytes expressing GFP-Rab27a and mCherry-Rab11a, cortical
granules were able to undergo fast and brief bursts of directed
motion towards the cortex in the absence of Rab11a association
(Fig. 5c; Supplementary Movie 8). These fast motions still took
place when myosin Vb was inhibited, suggesting that a different
motor powered their movement separately from myosin Vb and
Rab11a (Supplementary Movie 9). We therefore queried whether
this myosin Vb- and Rab11a-independent pathway might be
powered by myosin Va. Collectively, these results establish the existence of two separate
pathways to translocate cortical granules to the oocyte cortex. The
first is a myosin Va-dependent transport mechanism along actin
filaments, and the second is an unexpected vesicle hitchhiking
mechanism by which cortical granules bind to Rab11a vesicles
powered by myosin Vb. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Vesicle speed (e) and
vesicle displacement speed (f) were quantified for cortical granules while associated to Rab11a vesicles (Rab27a þ Rab11a), cortical granules while not
associated to Rab11a vesicles (Rab27a alone), and for Rab11a vesicles. Number of tracks used for quantification are indicated in e, from six oocytes. Tukey
box plots in d,e and f show the median (line), mean (small square), interquartile range, and the 5th and 95th (whiskers). Significance levels: *Po0.05,
***Po0.001, analysed using Kruskal–Wallis’ ANOVA test from two experiments. (g) Representative example trajectories of the particle categories
indicated in e and f (six trajectories per condition), projected in two dimensions. Duration of each trajectory is 52 s. (h) Quantification of cortical granule
translocation in the oocyte centre or cortex (mean±s.e.m.) in oocytes expressing Rab11aS25N or wild-type Rab11a. (i) Representative still images
(maximum intensity projections of confocal Z sections) of oocytes expressing Rab11aS25N. Control images are included in Supplementary Fig. 2. Scale bars,
20 mm (overview) and 5 mm (enlarged). 7 7 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 ARTICLE –1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
Time (h)
(NEBD) 0
–1.0
–0.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
Time (h)
Cortical granules μm–3
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Control MyoVaWT MyoVaLT
n = 16; 11;16
a
Cortical granules in the cell centre
Cortical granules at the cell cortex
0
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
50
200
150
100 (NEBD) 0
–1.0
–0.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
Time (h)
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Cortical granules at the cell cortex
0
50
200
150
100 b MyoVaLT
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
b
Before NEBD
NEBD
5 h after NEBD a Rab27a
Rab11a
Cortex
0 s
4.36 s
8.72 s
13.08 s
17.44 s
–1.0
–0.5
(NEBD) 0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
Time (h)
(NEBD) 0
–1.0
–0.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
Time (h)
Cortical granules μm–3
Total cortex intensity
normalized to control NEBD (%)
Control MyoVaWT MyoVaLT
n = 16; 11;16
MyoVaLT
–01 h 00 min
00 h 00 min
05 h 00 min
Cortical granules in the cell centre
Cortical granules at the cell cortex
Before NEBD
NEBD
5 h after NEBD
10 s
2 μm
c
d
–2
–1
0
1
2
3
–2
–1
0
1
2
3
Time (s)
Raw single trajectory
State-separated steps
Mean squared
displacement analysis
–2 –1
0
1
2
3
–2 –1
0
1
2
3
Diffusive
Active
f
g
h
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
0
***
***
MSD velocity parameter
of active steps (μ m2 s–2)
Rab11a-independent
transport
Rab11a-dependent
transport
e
0
10
20
30
Tracks containing
Rab11a hitchhiking
Tracks containing
Rab11a-independent
transport
All Rab27a trajectories
10
20
30
40
50
***
***
n.s.***
1998
2452
1547 2570
Rab11a-independent
transport
Rab11a-dependent
transport
336
116
134
122
n=282
n=200
Control
MyoVaLT
MyoVbLT
Tracks with directed
motion only
i
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
10
20
30
40
50
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
35
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
35
30
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
60
79 trajectories
89% 11%
78 trajectories
93.6% 6.4%
58 trajectories
95.1% 4.9%
39 trajectories
79.7% 20.3%
70 trajectories
79.2% 20.8%
66 trajectories
95.6% 4.4%
0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
0.12
0.14
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Rab11a-independent
transport
Rab11a-dependent
transport
n.s.***
n=2474
n=946
Diffusive state
Active state
Active steps (% of total)
Experimental strategy
Active steps (% of total)
MSD velocity parameter
of active steps (μ m2 s–2)
0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
0.12
0.14
0.16
X (μm)
Y (μm)
MyoVbLT
MyoVaLT
Control
MyoVbLT
MyoVaLT
Control
MyoVbLT
MyoVaLT
Control
MyoVbLT
MyoVaLT
Control
X (μm)
Y (μm)
X (μm)
Y (μm)
Y (μm)
Y (μm)
X (μm)
X (μm)
X (μm)
0
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
50
200
150
100
ure 5 | A myosin Va-dependent pathway powers cortical granule translocation. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 d
0
10
20
30
All Rab27a trajectories
10
20
30
40
50
Experimental strategy
X (μm)
Y (μm) d
–2
–1
0
1
2
3
Raw single trajectory
Mean squared
–2 –1
0
1
2
3
0
10
20
30
Tracks containing
Rab11a hitchhiking
Tracks containing
Rab11a-independent
transport
All Rab27a trajectories
10
20
30
40
50
Tracks with directed
motion only
Experimental strategy
X (μm)
Y (μm)
X (μm)
Y (μm) Rab27a
Rab11a
Cortex
0 s
4.36 s
8.72 s
13.08 s
17.44 s
10 s
2 μm
c d d c –2
–1
0
1
2
3
Raw single trajectory
–2 –1
0
1
2
3
Tracks containing
Rab11a hitchhiking
Tracks containing
Rab11a-independent
transport
Tracks with directed
motion only
X (μm)
Y (μm) –2
–1
0
1
2
3
Raw single trajectory
State-separated steps
Mean squared
displacement analysis
–2 –1
0
1
2
3
e
Tracks containing
Rab11a hitchhiking
Tracks containing
Rab11a-independent
transport
Rab11a-independent
transport
Rab11a-dependent
transport
Control
MyoVaLT
MyoVbLT
Tracks with directed
motion only
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
10
20
30
40
50
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
35
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
35
30
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
60
79 trajectories
89% 11%
78 trajectories
93.6% 6.4%
58 trajectories
95.1% 4.9%
39 trajectories
79.7% 20.3%
70 trajectories
79.2% 20.8%
66 trajectories
95.6% 4.4%
Diffusive state
Active state
X (μm)
Y (μm)
Y (μm)
Y (μm)
X (μm)
X (μm)
X (μm) e
Rab11a-independent
transport
Rab11a-dependent
transport
Control
MyoVaLT
MyoVbLT
10
20
30
40
10
20
30
40
10
20
30
40
50
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
35
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
35
30
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
60
79 trajectories
89% 11%
78 trajectories
93.6% 6.4%
58 tra
95.1% 4.9%
39 trajectories
79.7% 20.3%
70 trajectories
79.2% 20.8%
66 tra
95.6% 4.4%
Diffusive state
Active state
Y (μm)
Y (μm)
X (μm)
X (μm)
X (μm) e
Rab11a-independent
transport
Rab11a-dependent
transport
Control
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
60
79 trajectories
89% 11%
39 trajectories
79.7% 20.3%
Diffusive state
Active state
Y (μm)
Y (μm)
X (μm) e e MyoVaLT
10
20
30
40
50
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
10
20
30
40
50
60
78 trajectories
93.6% 6.4%
70 trajectories
79.2% 20.8%
X (μm) MyoVbLT
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
20
30
40
50
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
35
30
–5
0
5
10
15
20
25
35
30
58 trajectories
95.1% 4.9%
66 trajectories
95.6% 4.4%
X (μm) Mean squared
displacement analysis –2
–1
0
1
2
3
Time (s)
State-separated steps
–2 –1
0
1
2
3
Diffusive
Active
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
0
X (μm)
Y (μm) f
***
***
1998
2452
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Rab11a-independent
transport
n=2474
Active steps (% of total)
MyoVbLT
MyoVaLT
Control h
***
***
Rab11a-independent
transport
134
122
n=282
0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
0.12
0.14
MSD velocity parameter
of active steps (μ m2 s–2)
MyoVbLT
MyoVaLT
Control f f h i g
n.s.***
1547 2570
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Rab11a-dependent
transport
n=946
Active steps (% of total)
MyoVbLT
MyoVaLT
Control MSD velocity parameter
of active steps (μ m2 s–2)
Rab11a-dependent
transport
336
116
n=200
i
n.s.***
0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
0.12
0.14
0.16
MyoVbLT
MyoVaLT
Control g Rab11a-dependent
transport ab11a-independ
transport Time (s) Figure 5 | A myosin Va-dependent pathway powers cortical granule translocation. ARTICLE Disrupting granule transport inhibits the zona pellucida block. With these results at hand, we were able to investigate the con-
sequences of perturbing the translocation of cortical granules on
fertilization. For this, we performed in vitro fertilization assays
using oocytes from the Ashen transgenic mouse line which lacks a
functional Rab27a allele, and cannot translocate cortical granules
or maintain them at the cortex (Fig. 2). We noticed that fertilized
Rab27aAsh/Ash oocytes had extra sperm heads that had success-
fully crossed the zona pellucida (Fig. 6a). This indicated that these
cells had an inefficient zona block following fertilization. Upon
quantification, almost 90% of all fertilized mutant oocytes had
extra sperm cells inside the zona pellucida, compared to less than
20% of heterozygote controls (Fig. 6b; Po0.0001, Student’s
t-test). Moreover, the majority of fertilized Rab27aAsh/Ash eggs
had five or more extra sperm heads in the perivitelline space,
indicating that the defect was severe (Fig. 6c). Subsequent staining
with LCA also revealed that the mutant oocytes had a two-fold
increase in the number of cortical granules remaining in the cell
centre, indicating that the cortical reaction must have been
incomplete (Fig. 6d). These results indicate that Rab27a, without y
y
To test if both myosin Va and myosin Vb were involved in
cortical granule translocation, we depleted each protein using
siRNA in oocytes cultured from follicle cells. The cells were then
fixed either at GV stage, or after being released from prophase
arrest for 5 h, and then stained with LCA (Supplementary
Fig. 6a). We found that depletion of either myosin caused the
number of remaining cortical granules in the cell centre to
increase significantly compared to controls (Supplementary
Fig. 6b). Also, the intensity at the cortex was also lower than in
controls when either myosin was depleted (Supplementary
Fig. 6c), although significance was not attained due to high
staining variability between cells. These results suggested both
myosin Va and myosin Vb are involved in the translocation of
cortical granules. Myosin Va-dependent motions have been described as very
short bursts of fast movement, and are thus very difficult to
discern in living cells32. We were unable to identify these motions
and to measure their instantaneous speed reliably in the presence NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 8 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Quantification of cortical granule translocation in the oocyte centre or c
ean±s.e.m) in cells expressing either wild-type myosin Va (MyoVaWT), a dominant-negative mutant (MyoVaLT), or control (a), with representative examp
ges (maximum intensity projections of confocal Z sections) in b. Still images from MyoVaWT-expressing cells are included in Supplementary Fig. 2. Scale
mm (overview) and 5mm (enlarged). (c) Example still images of a cortical granule (Rab27a) translocating to the cortex in a Rab11a-independent manner (indi
arrows), with corresponding kymograph. Scale bar, 2mm. (d) Schematic diagram of the local mean squared displacement analysis of Rab27a trajectories
tained Rab11a-dependent transport (hitchhiking) or Rab11a-independent transport, and excluding purely diffusive trajectories. Each track was analysed by
h a short lag time to distinguish between active (magenta) and diffusive (blue) states on a step-by-step basis. (e) Combined Rab27a trajectories that cont
11a-dependent transport (hitchhiking) or Rab11a-independent transport in oocytes expressing MyoVaLT, MyoVbLT, or control, after local MSD analysis. Ac
es are coloured in magenta, while diffusive states are in blue. Proportion of each state is indicated (%). (f–g) Total number of active steps from Rab27a trajec
determined by MSD analysis; % of total steps) containing either Rab11a-independent transport (f), or Rab11a-dependent transport (hitchhiking; g) in ooc
ressing MyoVaLT, MyoVbLT, or control. Total number of steps in each category is indicated. Compared using Fischer’s exact test. (h–i) Mean squared displace
ocity parameters of the active steps from Rab27a trajectories containing Rab11a-independent (h) or Rab11a-dependent transport (i) in oocytes expressing Myo
oVbLT, or control. Number of active steps in each category is indicated. Tukey box plots in h and i show the median (line), mean (small square), interquartile r
the 5th and 95th (whiskers), compared using Mann-Whitney’s U test. Significance levels: ns, non-significant, ***Po0.001, from three experiments. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 (b) Quantification of the number of fertilized oocytes which had extra sperm heads in the perivitelline space in Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash oocytes
(mean±s.d.; Student’s t test) (c) Quantification of the number of extra sperm inside the perivitelline space of fertilized Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash
oocytes. (d) Quantification of remaining cortical granules in the centre of Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash oocytes after fertilization (mean±s.d.; Student’s
t test). (e) Mechanistic model of the two cortical granule translocation mechanisms in mammalian oocytes. See text for details. Significance levels:
***Po0.001, from three experiments. transport cargo27,28,42,47–53. This study reinforces a general
role of the cooperation between these proteins in organelle
trafficking and regulated exocytosis. Since Rab27a and myosin Va
are not thought to bind directly27,43,49,50, it is likely that an
adaptor links the two proteins, similarly to the tripartite
complexes
reported
in
melanocytes
and
cytotoxic
T
lymphocytes27,45,48–50,52,54. The identification of the adaptor
protein will be of importance in future studies, and raises the
interesting possibility that a mouse mutant for this adaptor would
display severe defects in the efficiency of the zona block to sperm
entry. which translocation and maintenance of cortical granules at the
cortex are impaired (Fig. 2), has a strong impact on the efficiency
of the zona block following fertilization. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 DNA
DNA DIC
≥5
4
3
2
1
0
PB
Number of extra sperm inside
the perivitelline space
c
***
***
0
0.005
0.010
0.015
0.020
0.025
0.030
0.035
0.040
Cytoplasmic cortical granules
after fertilization μm–3
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Fertilised eggs (%)
Fertilised eggs with inefficient
zona pellucida block (%)
Rab27aAsh/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27aAsh/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27aAsh/Ash ; n = 34
Rab27a+/Ash ; n = 33
27a+/Ash
7aAsh/Ash
b
d DNA
DNA DIC
PB
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27aAsh/Ash
a ***
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Fertilised eggs with inefficient
zona pellucida block (%)
Rab27aAsh/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
b b d d c c a Legend
Myosin Vb-powered movement
Myosin Va-powered movement
Docked granule (myosin Va-dependent)
F-actin
Rab11a vesicle
Cortical granule (Rab27a)
Spindle
Ra
Ra
e e Figure 6 | Disruption of cortical granule translocation severely impairs the zona pellucida block to polyspermy. (a) Maximum intensity Z projections of
in vitro fertilized oocytes from Rab27a þ /Ash (control) or Rab27aAsh/Ash (mutant) oocytes, fixed and stained with Hoechst. Male and female pronuclei
and polar body (PB) are indicated. Note the extra sperm heads present inside the zona pellucida in mutant oocytes (arrows). Scale bar, 20 mm. (b) Quantification of the number of fertilized oocytes which had extra sperm heads in the perivitelline space in Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash oocytes
(mean±s.d.; Student’s t test) (c) Quantification of the number of extra sperm inside the perivitelline space of fertilized Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash
oocytes. (d) Quantification of remaining cortical granules in the centre of Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash oocytes after fertilization (mean±s.d.; Student’s
t test). (e) Mechanistic model of the two cortical granule translocation mechanisms in mammalian oocytes. See text for details. Significance levels:
***Po0.001, from three experiments. Figure 6 | Disruption of cortical granule translocation severely impairs the zona pellucida block to polyspermy. (a) Maximum intensity Z projections of
in vitro fertilized oocytes from Rab27a þ /Ash (control) or Rab27aAsh/Ash (mutant) oocytes, fixed and stained with Hoechst. Male and female pronuclei
and polar body (PB) are indicated. Note the extra sperm heads present inside the zona pellucida in mutant oocytes (arrows). Scale bar, 20 mm. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Quantification of cortical granule translocation in the oocyte centre or cortex
(mean±s.e.m) in cells expressing either wild-type myosin Va (MyoVaWT), a dominant-negative mutant (MyoVaLT), or control (a), with representative example still
images (maximum intensity projections of confocal Z sections) in b. Still images from MyoVaWT-expressing cells are included in Supplementary Fig. 2. Scale bars,
20mm (overview) and 5mm (enlarged). (c) Example still images of a cortical granule (Rab27a) translocating to the cortex in a Rab11a-independent manner (indicated
by arrows), with corresponding kymograph. Scale bar, 2mm. (d) Schematic diagram of the local mean squared displacement analysis of Rab27a trajectories that
contained Rab11a-dependent transport (hitchhiking) or Rab11a-independent transport, and excluding purely diffusive trajectories. Each track was analysed by MSD
with a short lag time to distinguish between active (magenta) and diffusive (blue) states on a step-by-step basis. (e) Combined Rab27a trajectories that contained
Rab11a-dependent transport (hitchhiking) or Rab11a-independent transport in oocytes expressing MyoVaLT, MyoVbLT, or control, after local MSD analysis. Active
states are coloured in magenta, while diffusive states are in blue. Proportion of each state is indicated (%). (f–g) Total number of active steps from Rab27a trajectories
(as determined by MSD analysis; % of total steps) containing either Rab11a-independent transport (f), or Rab11a-dependent transport (hitchhiking; g) in oocytes
expressing MyoVaLT, MyoVbLT, or control. Total number of steps in each category is indicated. Compared using Fischer’s exact test. (h–i) Mean squared displacement
velocity parameters of the active steps from Rab27a trajectories containing Rab11a-independent (h) or Rab11a-dependent transport (i) in oocytes expressing MyoVaLT,
MyoVbLT, or control. Number of active steps in each category is indicated. Tukey box plots in h and i show the median (line), mean (small square), interquartile range,
and the 5th and 95th (whiskers), compared using Mann-Whitney’s U test. Significance levels: ns, non-significant, ***Po0.001, from three experiments. 9 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 Legend
Myosin Vb-powered movement
Myosin Va-powered movement
Docked granule (myosin Va-dependent)
F-actin
Rab11a vesicle
Cortical granule (Rab27a)
Spindle
DNA
DNA DIC
≥5
4
3
2
1
0
PB
Number of extra sperm inside
the perivitelline space
c
***
***
0
0.005
0.010
0.015
0.020
0.025
0.030
0.035
0.040
Cytoplasmic cortical granules
after fertilization μm–3
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Fertilised eggs (%)
Fertilised eggs with inefficient
zona pellucida block (%)
Rab27aAsh/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27aAsh/Ash
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27aAsh/Ash ; n = 34
Rab27a+/Ash ; n = 33
Rab27a+/Ash
Rab27aAsh/Ash
a
b
d
e
Figure 6 | Disruption of cortical granule translocation severely impairs the zona pellucida block to polyspermy. (a) Maximum intensity Z projections of
in vitro fertilized oocytes from Rab27a þ /Ash (control) or Rab27aAsh/Ash (mutant) oocytes, fixed and stained with Hoechst. Male and female pronuclei
and polar body (PB) are indicated. Note the extra sperm heads present inside the zona pellucida in mutant oocytes (arrows). Scale bar, 20 mm. (b) Quantification of the number of fertilized oocytes which had extra sperm heads in the perivitelline space in Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash oocytes
(mean±s.d.; Student’s t test) (c) Quantification of the number of extra sperm inside the perivitelline space of fertilized Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash
oocytes. (d) Quantification of remaining cortical granules in the centre of Rab27a þ /Ash or Rab27aAsh/Ash oocytes after fertilization (mean±s.d.; Student’s
t test). (e) Mechanistic model of the two cortical granule translocation mechanisms in mammalian oocytes. See text for details. Significance levels:
***Po0.001, from three experiments. Methods
P
ti We finally used these two
thresholds to classify active (all steps with ‘high speed’) versus non-directed motion
(all steps with ‘low speed’) and high diffusion versus low diffusion in the parameter
space in the MSD scatter plots (Supplementary Figs 3e-h and 5b,c). Follicle culture and siRNA knock down. To deplete myosin Va or myosin
Vb, siRNA knockdown was performed in cultured follicle cells as described
previously59. Briefly, mixes of three siRNA oligos per target (Qiagen) were
microinjected into follicles from 10- to 12-day-old (C57BL CBA) F1 female mice,
and cultured for 8-10 days. siRNA sequences used were (1) ATGATAAATACT
GTTATTAAA, (2) CACGATTGTTATTCAGTCTTA and (3) CAGCCTTGTAT
CAATCTTATA for myosin Va, and (1) CCGGAAGGTGGATTTGTTAAA, (2)
TCAAACTGAGATAATATTAAA and (3) AACCTGGAGTTTCTCAATGAA for
myosin Vb. Resulting mature oocytes were then stripped, injected with reporter
mRNA and left to express for 3-4 h before release from prophase arrest. To test the reliability of our analysis, we repeated the MSD analysis but defined
the two thresholds as the 99.9 percentile of the velocity and diffusion parameters of
all Rab27a trajectories from control oocytes (active þ non-active) using a robust
estimation of the mean and variance (using the median and median of absolute
deviation, respectively) assuming a Gaussian distribution (not shown). This
produced a less stringent definition of active motions, but did not change the
results of the experiment. Statistics and curve fitting. Statistical testing was performed with InStat or Excel. Student’s unpaired t-test was used to compare two normally distributed data sets,
and Mann-Whitney’s U-test for two non-parametric data sets. Kruskal–Wallis’
ANOVA test was used to compare more than two data sets. Fischer’s exact test was
used to compare proportions of active steps. Tukey box plots show the median
(line), mean (small square), interquartile range, and the 5th and 95th (whiskers). Origin Pro 8.0 was used for curve fitting. To fit central cortical granule curves, a
Fast Fourier Transform filter was applied. To determine the start and end of the
cortical granule decline period in the centre of the cell, the derivative of the
smoothed curve was calculated. To fit the curves of cortical recruitment, Rab27a
intensity increase at the cortex was fitted with a single exponential curve. Prior to
the increase, at NEBD±30 min, the data were best fitted with a linear curve. MatLab and Octave were used to write the MSD analysis software. Significance
levels: ns non-significant, *Po0.05, **Po0.01, ***Po0.001. Confocal microscopy. Methods
P
ti Preparation and culture of oocytes. All mice were maintained in a specific
pathogen-free environment according to UK Home Office regulations. The use of
animals was approved by the MRC Cambridge Ethical Review Committee, and was
performed under the UK Home Office project license 70/8087. Oocytes were
isolated from ovaries of 8- to 12-week-old FVB/n, Fmn2 / or Rab27aAsh/Ash
mice, cultured and microinjected as described in detail previously26. Briefly,
oocytes were collected from the ovaries of 7-14-week-old females by puncturing
using a hypodermic needle, and kept in M2 medium containing dibutyryl cAMP
(Sigma-Aldrich) at 37 C. Oocytes were released into meiosis by rinsing into
dibutyryl cAMP-free medium. In some experiments, oocytes were treated with
1 mM nocodazole or 5 mg ml 1 cytochalasin D (Calbiochem). For in vitro
fertilization experiments, we followed a previously described protocol58. Briefly,
mature oocytes from super-ovulated female mice were stripped of cumulus cells by
5-min incubation in M2 medium containing hyaluronidase (0.3 mg ml 1). The
eggs were then incubated in human tubal fluid medium (Gibco) for 5 h at 37 C
with fresh sperm (1 106 motile sperm per ml) which had been capacitated
for 30 min at 37 C. Dr2 t; t
ð
Þ ¼ ft0 2 ½t Dt; t þ Dt; jjr t0 þ t
ð
Þ r t0
ð Þjj2g
ð1Þ ð1Þ As many of the switches between active and diffusive motion states along tracks
were extremely transient (o10 s), the square displacements were computed using
an analysis window of 2Dt þ 1 ¼ 9 time points with maximum lag t of 6 time
points (illustrated in Supplementary Movie 10). The following second-order
polynomial model with no constant term a tð Þt2 þ b tð Þt was then robustly fitted
using an iterative reweighted least square procedure to Dr2(t,t) at each time point t. We use the two parameters to discriminate between the types of motion each
particle undergoes in its lifetime. To simplify, we refer to a(t) as the ‘velocity
parameter’ in mm2 s 2 and b(t) as the ‘diffusion parameter’ in mm2 s 1. To distinguish between active and diffusive motions, and between low and
high diffusive motion (also termed ‘anomalous diffusion’), a threshold on each
parameter was set by calculating the 99.9 percentile of the distribution of control
trajectories which did not display any active transport. ARTICLE ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 they must undergo meiotic maturation, such a slow but
overarching mechanism to boost delivery speed would be
highly advantageous. HindIII-XhoI. Full-length pGEMHE–mCherry–myosin-Va, pGEMHE–mCherry–
myosin-VaLT, pGEMHE–mCherry–myosin-VbLT, pGEMHE–mCherry–Rab11a,
pGEMHE–mCherry–Rab11aS25N and pCS2-EGFP-UtrCH have been previously
described19,20. A previous study reported a 20-50% reduction in litter size
in Ashen female mice compared to their background strain55. Our results now offer an explanation for this observation. It is
tempting to speculate that separate redundant polyspermy
avoidance mechanisms, such as the block at the plasma
membrane6, are responsible for the remaining fertility of the
Ashen mice and without which polyspermy would be far more
prevalent. The Ashen genotype possesses a human equivalent in
the form of the autosomal Griscelli syndrome type 2 (refs 56,57). Type 2 Griscelli syndrome patients exhibit partial albinism and
immunodeficiency; however, there have been no systematic
studies of fertility in these patients. These constructs were linearized with AscI (NsiI for Utrophin). Capped mRNA
was synthesized using T7 polymerase (mMessage mMachine kit, Ambion), and
dissolved in 6-11 ml water. mRNA concentrations were determined using a
NanoDrop spectrophotometer system (Thermo Scientific). Image analysis. Zen software (Zeiss) was used to crop the centre of oocytes and
Fiji/ImageJ was used to crop the cortex of the oocytes; Imaris software (Bitplane)
was then used to analyse all images. The Spots detection function was used to
detect and count central cortical granules in three dimensions by setting the
detection parameters to 500 or 700 nm diameter. For total intensity measurements
at the cell cortex, the Surfaces function was used to create a matrix covering the
fluorescence at the plasma membrane, and the sum intensity was measured. For
high spatial and temporal imaging, Rab27a vesicles were detected as 600-700 nm
diameter spots and Rab11a vesicles were detected as 900 nm diameter spots and
tracked. To determine hitchhiking Rab27a spots, an Imaris ‘Spots Colocalize’
MatLab XTension was used, and 1.5 mm was determined as the most accurate
distance threshold for colocalization. The minimum track length for further
analysis was set as five frames. Our results now provide a conceptual framework for how
cortical granules become arranged before fertilization and provide
a basis for studying the mechanisms that prevent polyspermy in
humans. Local mean squared displacement analysis. We defined a set of squared
displacements at each time point t and lag t for a given temporal analysis window
of length 2Dt þ 1 as: Methods
P
ti Images were acquired with a Zeiss LSM710 confocal
microscope equipped with a Zeiss environmental incubator box or a Zeiss LSM780
confocal microscope equipped with a Tokai Hit Stage Top Incubator, with a 40
C-Apochromat 1.2 NA water-immersion objective lens. Typically, whole cells were
imaged by taking a Z-stack of three 0.65 mm-thick sections every 5 or 10 min for
12 h. For high spatial and temporal imaging, Z-stacks composed of three or six
0.65 mm-thick sections were acquired every B2–2.5 s for 5 min. Images of actin and
Rab27a were imaged every 1.1 s in single planes. All images of oocytes shown in
this study are maximum intensity projections of the acquired Z sections. Oocytes
expressing SNAP-Rab11a were incubated in 647-SiR dye (New England Biolabs)
according to the manufacturer’s instructions prior to imaging. Immunofluorescence microscopy. Oocytes were fixed for 30–60 min at 37 C in
100 mM HEPES (pH 7; titrated with KOH), 50 mM EGTA (pH 7; titrated with
KOH), 10 mM MgSO4, 2% formaldehyde and 0.2% Triton X-100, based on
previously published methods. Oocytes were left in PBS with 0.1% Triton X-100
overnight at 4 C. LCA staining was carried out in PBS with 0.1% Triton X-100 and
3% BSA. DNA was stained with 5 mg ml 1 Hoechst33342 (MolecularProbes). Data availability. The data that support the findings of this study are available
within the article and its supplementary information files or from the
corresponding author on reasonable request. Data availability. The data that support the findings of this study are available
within the article and its supplementary information files or from the
corresponding author on reasonable request. NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications Discussion In summary, this study provides the first dynamic data on cortical
granule translocation in mouse oocytes, and answers the long-
standing question of its underlying mechanisms in the form of
two pathways (Fig. 6e). p
y
g
Unexpectedly, we found that cortical granules hitchhike on
Rab11a vesicles powered by myosin Vb to reach the cortex. Recent studies reported that large ribonucleoprotein complexes
(mRNPs), peroxisomes, lipid droplets and the endoplasmic
reticulum are similarly able to hitchhike on early endosomes in
some fungal species33–35 in order to achieve long-range transport. This study provides the first observation of vesicle hitchhiking in
mammalian cells, indicating that such transport systems are
evolutionarily conserved, and more widely involved in important
biological processes than previously anticipated. y
The short periods of active transport were interrupted by long
periods in which the cortical granules underwent anomalous
diffusion. Our results suggest that these unusual dynamics are
driven by the highly dynamic actin network that the cortical
granules are associated with. This activity likely reflects a highly
dynamic actin network. The dynamics of the actin network could
potentiate granule translocation by increasing the likelihood of
interaction with Rab11a vesicles and of capture by the actin
cytoskeleton via a search-and-capture mechanism. Previously, we
have suggested a model whereby filaments of the actin network
move outward towards the cortex over time, pulled by Rab11a
vesicles19. If correct, the association of cortical granules to actin
would produce a gradual translocation to the periphery. Given
the large size of oocytes and the short time window during which g
p
p
y
p
In the second mechanism, cortical granules undergo short
bursts of movements that are myosin Va-dependent. Both myosin
Va (refs 36–41) and Rab27a (refs 42–46) have been implicated in
secretory granule trafficking and exocytosis in a number of cells
types. In several cases, both proteins form a complex together to NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 10 ARTICLE Spindle positioning in mouse oocytes relies on a dynamic
meshwork of actin filaments. Curr. Biol. 18, 1514–1519 (2008). 55. Tolmachova, T. et al. A general role for Rab27a in secretory cells. Mol. Biol. Cell
15, 332–344 (2004). 24. Azoury, J. et al. Spindle positioning in mouse oocytes relies on a dynamic
meshwork of actin filaments. Curr. Biol. 18, 1514–1519 (2008). 56. Griscelli, C. et al. A syndrome associating partial albinism and
immunodeficiency. Am. J. Med. 65, 691–702 (1978). immunodeficiency. Am. J. Med. 65, 691–702 (1978) 25. Schuh, M. & Ellenberg, J. A new model for asymmetric spindle positioning in
mouse oocytes. Curr. Biol. 18, 1986–1992 (2008). 57. Me´nasche´, G. et al. Mutations in RAB27A cause Griscelli syndrome associated
with haemophagocytic syndrome. Nat. Genet. 25, 173–176 (2000). 26. Pfender, S., Kuznetsov, V., Pleiser, S., Kerkhoff, E. & Schuh, M. Spire-type
actin nucleators cooperate with Formin-2 to drive asymmetric oocyte division. Curr. Biol. 21, 955–960 (2011). 58. Nagy, A., Vintersten, K. & Behringer, R. Manipulating the Mouse Embryo: A
Laboratory Manual 3rd edn (CSH Laboratory press, 2003). 59. Pfender, S. et al. Live imaging RNAi screen reveals genes essential for meiosis in
mammalian oocytes. Nature 524, 239–242 (2015). 27. Strom, M., Hume, A. N., Tarafder, A. K., Barkagianni, E. & Seabra, M. C. A
family of Rab27-binding proteins: Melanophilin links Rab27a and myosin Va
function in melanosome transport. J. Biol. Chem. 277, 25423–25430 (2002). Acknowledgements 28. Wu, X., Wang, F., Rao, K., Sellers, J. R. & Hammer, J. A. Rab27a is an essential
component of melanosome receptor for myosin Va. Mol. Biol. Cell 13,
1735–1749 (2002). We thank John Hammer III and Miguel Seabra for reagents, and the LMB light
microscopy team and animal facilities for assistance. With thanks to members of the
Schuh lab for helpful discussions. This study received financial support from the
European Community’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) under grant
agreement no 241548 and from the Medical Research Council under grant
MC_U105192711. 29. Hume, A. N., Ushakov, D. S., Tarafder, A. K., Ferenczi, M. a. & Seabra,
M. C. Rab27a and MyoVa are the primary Mlph interactors regulating
melanosome transport in melanocytes. J. Cell Sci. 120, 3111–3122 (2007). 30. Izidoro-Toledo, T. C. et al. A myosin-Va tail fragment sequesters dynein
light chains leading to apoptosis in melanoma cells. Cell Death Dis. 4, e547
(2013). ARTICLE Myosin Va transports dense core secretory
vesicles in pancreatic MIN6 beta-cells. Mol. Biol. Cell 16, 2670–2680 (2005). 11. Just, E. E. The fertilization reaction in Echinarachnius Parma. I. Cortical
response of the egg to insemination. Biol. Bull. 36, 1–10 (1919). 41. Wagner, W., Brenowitz, S. D. & Hammer, J. A. Myosin-Va transports the
endoplasmic reticulum into the dendritic spines of Purkinje neurons. Nat. Cell Biol. 13, 40–48 (2011). 12. Wessel, G. M., Conner, S. D. & Berg, L. Cortical granule translocation is
microfilament mediated and linked to meiotic maturation in the sea urchin
oocyte. Development 129, 4315–4325 (2002). 42. Wu, X. et al. Rab27a enables myosin Va-dependent melanosome capture by
recruiting the myosin to the organelle. J. Cell Sci. 114, 1091–1100 (2001). 13. Connors, S. a., Kanatsu-Shinohara, M., Schultz, R. M. & Kopf, G. S. Involvement of the cytoskeleton in the movement of cortical granules during
oocyte maturation, and cortical granule anchoring in mouse eggs. Dev. Biol. 200, 103–115 (1998). 43. Hume, A. N. et al. Rab27a regulates the peripheral distribution of melanosomes
in melanocytes. J. Cell Biol. 152, 795–808 (2001). 44. Stinchcombe, J. C. et al. Rab27a is required for regulated secretion in cytotoxic
T lymphocytes. J. Cell Biol. 152, 825–834 (2001). 14. Conner, S. & Wessel, G. M. Rab3 mediates cortical granule exocytosis in the sea
urchin egg. Dev. Biol. 203, 334–344 (1998). 45. Yi, Z. et al. The Rab27a/granuphilin complex regulates the exocytosis of
insulin-containing dense-core granules. Mol. Cell Biol. 22, 1858–1867 (2002). 15. Masumoto, N. et al. Involvement of Rabphilin-3a in cortical granule exocytosis
in mouse eggs. J. Cell Biol. 135, 1741–1747 (1996). 46. Bustos, M. a., Lucchesi, O., Ruete, M. C., Mayorga, L. S. & Tomes, C. N. PNAS
Plus: Rab27 and Rab3 sequentially regulate human sperm dense-core
granule exocytosis. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 109, E2057–E2066 (2012). 16. Wang, H. H. et al. Rab3A, Rab27A, and Rab35 regulate different events during
mouse oocyte meiotic maturation and activation. Histochem. Cell Biol. 145,
647–657 (2016). g
y
47. Wu, X. S. et al. Identification of an organelle receptor for myosin-Va. Nat. Cell Biol. 4, 271–278 (2002). 17. de Paola, M., Bello, O. D. & Michaut, M. A. Cortical granule exocytosis is
mediated by alpha-SNAP and N-ethilmaleimide sensitive factor in mouse
oocytes. PLoS ONE 10, e0135679 (2015). 48. Nagashima, K. et al. Melanophilin directly links Rab27a and myosin Va
through its distinct coiled-coil regions. FEBS Lett. ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 3. Hassold, T. et al. A cytogenetic study of 1000 spontaneous abortions. Ann. Hum. Genet. 44, 151–178 (1980). 33. Baumann, S., Pohlmann, T., Jungbluth, M., Brachmann, A. & Feldbru¨gge, M. Kinesin-3 and dynein mediate microtubule-dependent co-transport of mRNPs
and endosomes. J. Cell Sci. 125, 2740–2752 (2012). 4. McFadden, D. E., Jiang, R., Langlois, S. & Robinson, W. P. Dispermy—origin of
diandric triploidy: brief communication. Hum. Reprod. 17, 3037–3038 (2002). 34. Guimaraes, S. C. et al. Peroxisomes, lipid droplets, and endoplasmic reticulum
‘hitchhike’ on motile early endosomes. J. Cell Biol. 211, 945–954 (2015). 5. Zaragoza, M. V. et al. Parental origin and phenotype of triploidy in
spontaneous abortions: predominance of diandry and association with the
partial hydatidiform mole. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 66, 1807–1820 (2000). 35. Salogiannis, J., Egan, M. J. & Reck-Peterson, S. L. Peroxisomes move by
hitchhiking on early endosomes using the novel linker protein PxdA. J. Cell Biol. 212, 289–296 (2016). p
y
6. Gardner, A. J. & Evans, J. P. Mammalian membrane block to polyspermy: new
insights into how mammalian eggs prevent fertilisation by multiple sperm. Reprod. Fertil. Dev. 18, 53–61 (2006). 36. Pastural, E. et al. Griscelli disease maps to chromosome 15q21 and is associated
with mutations in the myosin-Va gene. Nat. Genet. 16, 289–292 (1997). p
7. Bianchi, E., Doe, B., Goulding, D. & Wright, G. J. Juno is the egg Izumo receptor
and is essential for mammalian fertilization. Nature 508, 483–487 (2014). 37. Bridgman, P. C. Myosin Va movements in normal and dilute-lethal axons
provide support for a dual filament motor complex. J. Cell Biol. 146, 1045–1060
(1999). 8. Wassarman, P. et al. Structure and function of the mammalian egg zona
pellucida. J. Exp. Zool. 285, 251–258 (1999). 38. Rose´, S. D. et al. Myosins II and V in chromaffin cells: myosin V is a chromaffin
vesicle molecular motor involved in secretion. J. Neurochem. 85, 287–298
(2003). 9. Avella, M. A., Baibakov, B. & Dean, J. A single domain of the ZP2 zona
pellucida protein mediates gamete recognition in mice and humans. J. Cell Biol. 205, 801–809 (2014). 39. Rudolf, R. et al. Myosin Va facilitates the distribution of secretory granules
in the F-actin rich cortex of PC12 cells. J. Cell Sci. 116, 1339–1348 (2003). 10. Gulyas, B. J. Cortical granules of mammalian eggs. Int. Rev. Cytol. 63, 357–392
(1980). 40. Varadi, A., Tsuboi, T. & Rutter, G. A. ARTICLE 517, 233–238 (2002). 49. Fukuda, M., Kuroda, T. S. & Mikoshiba, K. Slac2-a/melanophilin, the missing
link between Rab27 and myosin Va: Implications of a tripartite protein
complex for melanosome transport. J. Biol. Chem. 277, 12432–12436 (2002). 18. Kimura, K. & Kimura, A. Rab6 is required for the exocytosis of cortical granules
and the recruitment of separase to the granules during the oocyte-to-embryo
transition in Caenorhabditis elegans. J. Cell Sci. 125, 5897–5905 (2012). link between Rab27 and myosin Va: Implications of a tripartite protein
complex for melanosome transport. J. Biol. Chem. 277, 12432–12436 (2002). 50. Hume, A. N. et al. The leaden gene product is required with Rab27a to
recruit myosin Va to melanosomes in melanocytes. Traffic 3, 193–202 (2002). 19. Schuh, M. An actin-dependent mechanism for long-range vesicle transport. Nat. Cell Biol. 13, 1431–1436 (2011). 51. Rojo Pulido, I. et al. Myosin Va acts in concert with Rab27a and MyRIP to
regulate acute von-Willebrand factor release from endothelial cells. Traffic 12,
1371–1382 (2011). 20. Holubcova´, Z., Howard, G. & Schuh, M. Vesicles modulate an actin network
for asymmetric spindle positioning. Nat. Cell Biol. 15, 937–947 (2013). 21. Ducibella, T., Anderson, E., Albertini, D. F., Aalberg, J. & Rangarajan, S. Quantitative studies of changes in cortical granule number and distribution in
the mouse oocyte during meiotic maturation. Dev. Biol. 130, 184–197 (1988). 52. Brozzi, F. et al. Molecular mechanism of myosin Va recruitment to dense core
secretory granules. Traffic 13, 54–69 (2012). 53. Singh, R. K. et al. Distinct and opposing roles for Rab27a/Mlph/MyoVa and
Rab27b/Munc13-4 in mast cell secretion. FEBS J. 280, 892–903 (2013). 22. Ducibella, T., Duffy, P., Reindollar, R. & Su, B. Changes in the distribution of
mouse oocyte cortical granules and ability to undergo the cortical reaction
during gonadotropin-stimulated meiotic maturation and aging in vivo. Biol. Reprod. 43, 870–876 (1990). 54. Matesic, L. E. et al. Mutations in Mlph, encoding a member of the Rab effector
family, cause the melanosome transport defects observed in leaden mice. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 98, 10238–10243 (2001). 23. Wilson, S. M. et al. A mutation in Rab27a causes the vesicle transport defects
observed in ashen mice. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 97, 7933–7938 (2000). 23. Wilson, S. M. et al. A mutation in Rab27a causes the vesicle transport defects
observed in ashen mice. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 97, 7933–7938 (2000). 24. Azoury, J. et al. References References
1. van der Ven, H. H. et al. Polyspermy in in vitro fertilization of human oocytes:
frequency and possible causes. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 442, 88–95 (1985). 2. Wentz, A. C., Repp, J. E., Maxson, W. S., Pittaway, D. E. & Torbit, C. A. The problem of polyspermy in in vitro fertilization. Fertil. Steril. 40, 748–754
(1983). 1. van der Ven, H. H. et al. Polyspermy in in vitro fertilization of human oocytes:
frequency and possible causes. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 442, 88–95 (1985). b Expression constructs and mRNA synthesis. pEGFP–Rab27a was a gift
from M. Seabra and described in Hume et al.43 Rab27a was inserted into a
pGEMHE–EGFP or pGEMHE–mCherry vector via XhoI and BamHI. pGEMHE–SNAP–Rab11aS25N was obtained from pGEMHE–EGFP–Rab11aS25N
by switching EGFP with SNAP from pSNAPf (New England Biolabs) via Expression constructs and mRNA synthesis. pEGFP–Rab27a was a gift
from M. Seabra and described in Hume et al.43 Rab27a was inserted into a
pGEMHE–EGFP or pGEMHE–mCherry vector via XhoI and BamHI. pGEMHE–SNAP–Rab11aS25N was obtained from pGEMHE–EGFP–Rab11aS25N
by switching EGFP with SNAP from pSNAPf (New England Biolabs) via 2. Wentz, A. C., Repp, J. E., Maxson, W. S., Pittaway, D. E. & Torbit, C. A. The problem of polyspermy in in vitro fertilization. Fertil. Steril. 40, 748–754
(1983). 11 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications ARTICLE ARTICLE r The Author(s) 2016 Author contributions 31. Bodor, A. et al. DYNLL2 dynein light chain binds to an extended linear
motif of myosin 5a tail that has structural plasticity. Biochemistry 53,
7107–7122 (2014). L.P.C. performed all experiments and analysed the data. J.B. performed the MSD tra-
jectory analysis with input from L.P.C. L.M.B. provided initial findings and a method for
analysing movies. L.P.C. and M.S. designed the experiments and wrote the manuscript
with input from all authors. M.S. supervised the study and acquired the images of actin
with Rab27a. 32. Hammer, J. a. & Sellers, J. R. Walking to work: roles for class V myosins as
cargo transporters. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 13, 13–26 (2011). 12 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications Additional information Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. Supplementary Information accompanies this paper at http://www.nature.com/
naturecommunications This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International License. The images or other third party material in this
article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise
in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license,
users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Competing financial interests: The authors declare no competing financial interests. Reprints and permission information is available online at http://npg.nature.com/
reprintsandpermissions/ How to cite this article: Cheeseman, L. P. et al. Two pathways regulate cortical granule
translocation to prevent polyspermy in mouse oocytes. Nat. Commun. 7, 13726
doi: 10.1038/ncomms13726 (2016). r The Author(s) 2016 13 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:13726 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms13726 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications
|
https://openalex.org/W1982701618
|
https://www.scielo.br/j/jvb/a/bLnWWbFdyWGm4JRcX7vt7LJ/?lang=pt&format=pdf
|
Portuguese
| null |
Mobilização precoce na fase aguda da trombose venosa profunda de membros inferiores
|
Jornal Vascular Brasileiro
| 2,009
|
cc-by
| 6,637
|
1 . Acadêmica de Fisioterapia, Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina (UDESC), Florianópolis, SC.
2 . Mestranda, UDESC, Florianópolis, SC.
3 . Doutor. Médico especialista, Cardiologia e Medicina do Esporte. Coordenador, professor, Núcleo de Cardiologia e Medicina do Exercício, Centro de Ciências da
Saúde e do Esporte (CEFID), UDESC, Florianópolis, SC.
4 . Especialista, Cirurgia Vascular, Hospital Regional de São José Dr. Homero de Miranda Gomes, São José, SC.
Não foram declarados conflitos de interesse associados à publicação deste artigo.
Artigo submetido em 02.08.08, aceito em 07.11.08.
J Vasc Bras. 2009;8(1):77-85.
Copyright © 2009 by Sociedade Brasileira de Angiologia e de Cirurgia Vascular Geane de Souza Penha1, Ana Paula Damiano2, Tales de Carvalho3, Vinícius Lain4, João Daniel Serafim4 Geane de Souza Penha1, Ana Paula Damiano2, Tales de Carvalho3, Vinícius Lai Abstract O tratamento convencional da trombose venosa profunda na fase
aguda consiste em restrição ao leito. Porém, estudos recentes contestam
essa abordagem terapêutica, enfatizando que a mobilização precoce
propicia resultados clínicos favoráveis. O objetivo deste estudo foi
pesquisar em literatura científica, principalmente ensaios clínicos
controlados, sobre a mobilização precoce de pacientes portadores de
trombose venosa profunda de membros inferiores na fase aguda. Utilizou-se como estratégia de pesquisa o site PubMed para a busca
de estudos relacionados à mobilização precoce, deambulação e
trombose venosa profunda na fase aguda. Os artigos consultados
abrangeram o período de 1992 a 2007. Em todos os estudos, a
mobilização precoce esteve associada à heparina de baixo peso
molecular e a terapia de compressão. Estudos avaliados nesta revisão
têm demonstrado os benefícios na redução da dor e edema, com
melhora da qualidade de vida, pela estratégia terapêutica de
mobilização precoce em combinação com anticoagulação e
compressão da perna na trombose venosa profunda, sem que ocorra
maior risco de desfechos relevantes, como embolia pulmonar e morte. Conventional treatment of deep venous thrombosis in the acute
phase is bed confinement. However, recent studies have challenged
such therapeutic approach, emphasizing that early mobilization
provides favorable clinical outcomes. This study aimed at finding
qualified scientific studies, especially controlled clinical trials, on early
mobilization of patients with acute deep venous thrombosis of the
lower limbs. PubMed was used to search for articles related to early
mobilization, ambulation and acute deep venous thrombosis. Articles
covered the period from 1992 to 2007. In all studies, early mobilization
was associated with low molecular weight heparin and compression
therapy. Studies evaluated in this review showed benefits in reducing
pain and edema, with improvement in quality of life, using the
therapeutic strategy of early mobilization in combination with
anticoagulation and compression of the leg in patients with deep
venous thrombosis, without increased risk of relevant outcomes, such
as pulmonary embolism and death. Keywords: Venous thrombosis, ambulation, compression, lower
extremity. Palavras-chave: Trombose venosa, deambulação, compressão,
extremidade inferior. por flebografia ou duplex scan. Em trabalho de revisão
sistemática (metanálise), Fowkes et al.6, em 2003, esti-
maram incidência mundial de TVP de 0,5 casos por
1.000 habitantes/ano. Bastante comum em hospitais, a
TVP acomete 84 pessoas por 100.000 habitantes/ano7,
sendo a causa mais comum de morbidade e mortali-
dade em pacientes cirúrgicos. É responsável por 300.000 ARTIGO DE REVISÃO ARTIGO DE REVISÃO Introdução A trombose venosa profunda (TVP) é uma doença
que se caracteriza pela formação aguda de trombos que
acometem as veias profundas dos membros, acarre-
tando obstrução parcial ou total1-3. Segundo Labas et al.4, a TVP é uma doença vascular
comum e potencialmente ameaçadora à vida. No Bra-
sil, Maffei5 relata incidência de 0,6 casos por 1.000
habitantes/ano, a partir dos casos de TVP confirmados 77 Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. 78
J Vasc Bras 2009, Vol. 8, Nº 1 78 a 600.000 hospitalizações a cada ano8. A TVP está pre-
sente em 20 a 35% dos óbitos intra-hospitalares e é asso-
ciada à embolia pulmonar (EP) em 10 a 20% dos casos,
em estudos baseados em necropsias9-11. consequente redução da velocidade do fluxo sanguí-
neo1,2. Existe maior incidência no sexo feminino, que é
frequentemente relacionada ao uso de medicação anti-
concepcional, tendo em vista que os estrógenos aumen-
tam os níveis sanguíneos de fatores de coagulação20. A
obesidade é um fator de risco independente para o desen-
volvimento da TVP, uma vez que inibe a atividade fibli-
nolítica e dificulta a deambulação1,5. As complicações provenientes da TVP repercutem
negativamente em termos socioeconômicos e na quali-
dade de vida, sendo causa de morte precoce do indiví-
duo acometido. A EP é uma das manifestações mais
temidas, sendo a terceira causa de morte por doenças
cardiovasculares1,2. Outra complicação não-mortal
dessa afecção, porém de grande repercussão para a rea-
lização de atividades da vida diária, é a insuficiência
venosa crônica, nesse caso, denominada síndrome pós-
trombótica, decorrente de dano progressivo e perma-
nente do sistema valvular venoso durante o lento
processo de lise dos coágulos. Tal síndrome causa seque-
las graves, como varizes e úlcera venosa, o que deixa
evidente a importância de uma intervenção terapêutica
precoce e adequada que reduza a possibilidade de com-
plicações graves e óbito1. A mobilização precoce tem
sido considerada procedimento contraindicado durante
a fase aguda de TVP, pela crença de que a contração
muscular provocaria desprendimento do trombo da
parede vascular, ocasionando EP1-3. Na cirurgia de prótese total do quadril, a aborda-
gem ântero-lateral proporciona incidência maior de
TVP21, devido à torção da veia femoral profunda,
durante as manobras de adução e rotação externa
forçadas22. Etiopatogenia A etiopatogenia da TVP é explicada pela clássica trí-
ade de Virchow: estase venosa, lesão endotelial e
hipercoagulabilidade1-3,5. A estase venosa é vista como
o principal fator predisponente da TVP. A diminuição
do fluxo sanguíneo leva ao aumento da quantidade de
sangue nas veias, dilatando-as passivamente, com con-
sequente redução da velocidade do fluxo sanguíneo. Desse modo, tais alterações decorrem de: 1) queda no
débito cardíaco, relaxamento muscular durante o
repouso, anestesia e paralisias; 2) déficit da bomba
venosa periférica. Portanto, a diminuição da velocidade
do fluxo sanguíneo nas veias ocasiona a perturbação do
fluxo laminar, causando acúmulo local de hemácias, pla-
quetas e leucócitos. Esse depósito celular é estabilizado
pela constituição de uma rede de fibrina que prende tais
elementos, culminando com a formação do trombo2,5. Em contrapartida, estudos recentes têm sugerido que
a mobilização precoce não aumentaria o risco de EP,
mas propiciaria benefícios na fase aguda da TVP12-18. Diante da controvérsia exposta, o objetivo deste estudo
foi pesquisar estudos científicos qualificados, principal-
mente ensaios clínicos controlados, sobre a mobiliza-
ção precoce de pacientes portadores de TVP de membros
inferiores na fase aguda. O endotélio normal é uma superfície não-
trombogênica sobre a qual não aderem plaquetas, nem
ocorre ativação de proteínas coagulantes. Quando,
porém, existe lesão endotelial, ocorre uma exposição do
subendotélio, favorecendo a agregação de plaquetas e
glóbulos brancos, o que desencadeia a ativação dos
mecanismos de coagulação, com formação do trombo23. Métodos Utilizou-se como estratégia a pesquisa em indexado-
res, como PubMed, LILACS e SciELO, para a busca de
artigos relacionados à mobilização precoce, deambula-
ção e TVP na fase aguda. Foram selecionadas 15 refe-
rências, todas publicadas na língua inglesa. Os artigos
consultados abrangeram o período entre 1992 e 2007. Métodos diagnósticos A ultrassonografia tem sido o método de escolha
para diagnóstico de TVP proximal, por não ser invasivo
e apresentar boa sensibilidade e especificidade5,24. Na
avaliação pela ultrassonografia, o Doppler incorpo-
rado ao exame permite a detecção da menor influência
dos movimentos ventilatórios pulmonares na modula-
ção da velocidade do fluxo sanguíneo, o que contribui
para o diagnóstico da TVP. A avaliação pela ultrasso-
nografia oferece maior sensibilidade e especificidade
quando se trata do segmento fêmoro-poplíteo ou
ilíaco-femoral5. Fatores de risco A TVP é considerada uma doença multifatorial1. A
imobilidade no leito e as varizes são fatores de risco dos
mais importantes, da estase venosa19. Os fatores trom-
bogênicos podem estar presentes em neoplasias, haja
vista que tumores podem aumentar a ação dos fatores
pró-coagulantes3. A idade avançada também é conside-
rada fator de risco para a TVP, porque no envelheci-
mento ocorre diminuição da atividade fibrinolítica,
elevação da resistência vascular e dilatação venosa, com A hipercoagulabilidade está presente quando há
aumento de fatores de coagulação e redução dos fatores
inibidores da coagulação, o que pode ocorrer em deter-
minados estados fisiológicos, patológicos e terapêuti-
cos, como na gravidez, câncer, trombofilia e uso de
medicamentos esteroides e quimioterápicos24. Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. J Vasc Bras 2009, Vol. 8, Nº 1 79 Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. molecular, utilizando a via subcutânea, de modo que
pode ser utilizada no tratamento ambulatorial das trom-
boses venosas não-complicadas, por apresentar menor
potencial hemorrágico em comparação com a heparina
não-fracionada. A heparina de baixo peso molecular
difere da heparina não-fracionada por apresentar maior
atividade antiXa, maior biodisponibilidade com dosa-
gens menores, maior meia vida e maior preditibilidade
na resposta anticoagulante quando administrada em
dosagens fixas, não exigindo rigoroso controle labora-
torial, como as demais25. Após a fase aguda, o paciente
deve ser mantido anticoagulado por meio de terapia
oral4,25. Resultados No passado, o repouso prolongado no leito era con-
siderado essencial para o tratamento da TVP com intuito
de controlar a propagação trombótica e reduzir o risco
de EP14. Por outro lado, o descanso no leito por um perí-
odo de 7 a 10 dias é ainda parte do tratamento da TVP Compressão venosa A terapia de compressão é o tratamento sintomático
da TVP, com aplicação de uma pressão exercida e trans-
mitida aos tecidos, com a finalidade de aumentar a pres-
são intravenosa, orientar o fluxo venoso de retorno e
potencializar a fração de ejeção da panturrilha, de modo
que ocorra a resolução do edema17,26. As ataduras são
tiras de tecido elástico ou inelástico. Quanto menor o
grau de elasticidade de uma atadura, mais profunda-
mente ela atuará. A bota de Unna é uma compressão
inelástica composta de ataduras de crepe embebida em
pasta com gelatina incolor, glicerina, óxido de zinco e
água, normalmente usada no tratamento para úlcera
venosa. As meias de compressão elástica são adiciona-
das no tratamento da TVP para prevenir a síndrome pós-
trombótica26. A compressão máxima é exercida no
tornozelo e vai decrescendo em direção à coxa27. Entretanto, a flebografia, um procedimento inva-
sivo, é considerado como o padrão-ouro para o diag-
nóstico da TVP. Permite uma visualização global do
sistema venoso, por meio da aplicação de contraste
iodado em veias do pé. Pela falha no enchimento venoso
em determinado segmento se constata a presença do
trombo3,5. A flebografia radioisotópica é um método de
valor histórico empregado em alguns estudos científi-
cos, consistindo da injeção de microesferas de albumina
marcadas com tecnécio-99m, cujos trajetos nas veias são
visualizados pela cintilografia. O diagnóstico do trombo
é feito pela ausência de visualização do vaso e, mais tar-
diamente, pela presença de concentração de substância
radiativa no local de um trombo. É possível empregá-la
em pacientes com suspeita de EP, uma vez que pode ser
realizada simultaneamente a cintilografia pulmonar24. Diagnóstico clínico A grande maioria das TVP tem início insidioso, com
poucas manifestações clínicas ou apresenta-se em cará-
ter assintomático. São sintomas e sinais clínicos clássi-
cos da TVP: dor a palpação muscular, dor espontânea,
empastamento da panturrilha, edema subcutâneo e mus-
cular, distensão venosa superficial e aumento da tempe-
ratura do membro afetado. As alterações da coloração
da pele são mais comuns nas TVP proximais severas,
com coloração cianótica pela obstrução do segmento
(phlegmasia cerulea) ou palidez pela presença do vaso-
espasmo (phlegmasia alba)1-3. Tratamento medicamentoso Nos grupos A e B, o grau de dor sofreu um decréscimo
estaticamente significativo (p < 0,05) no segundo dia e,
no grupo de repouso, apenas depois de 10 dias. No
último dia de estudo, a redução do edema (avaliado com
fita métrica) e a melhoria na pontuação clínica (ava-
liada por meio de escore clínico contendo sete itens: dor
durante a caminhada; dor na planta do pé na posição
ortostática; palpação dolorosa na panturrilha; edema
subfascial e prefascial; hiperemia; cianose; e aumento
da temperatura) foi significativamente mais pronun-
ciada (p < 0,01) nos grupos da compressão em relação
ao grupo de repouso. Não houve diferença significativa
quanto à ocorrência de novos eventos de EP e progres- estudo, com cintilografia e eco-Doppler, respectiva-
mente. Ademais, nenhuma complicação proveniente das
terapias empregadas foi detectada. É interessante salien-
tar que a comparação entre os grupos de compressão
revelou que a estratégia aplicada aos pacientes do grupo
A produziu efeitos superiores em reduzir os sinais e sin-
tomas clínicos agudos. O estudo de Partsch & Blättler16
sugeriu que pacientes com TVP proximal deveriam ser
incentivados a caminhar com bandagens ou meias de
compressão, visando a uma diminuição importante de
sinais e sintomas clínicos agudos, sem aumentar o risco
de EP. Blättler & Partsch27 realizaram um estudo prospec-
tivo randomizado com a finalidade de verificar se a uti-
lização de heparina, associada a compressão e a
caminhada, proporcionaria melhor evolução clínica do
que o repouso no leito. A amostra consistiu de 53 pacien-
tes com TVP proximal sintomática, todos hepariniza-
dos, divididos em três grupos submetidos a distintas
terapias. Nos pacientes do grupo A (n = 18) foi aplicada
bandagem de compressão inelástica, e nos pacientes do
grupo B (n =18), meias de compressão elástica. Os
pacientes de ambos os grupos foram encaminhados ime-
diatamente para a deambulação. Os pacientes do grupo
C (n = 17) permaneceram em repouso absoluto, sem que
fossem submetidos a terapêutica compressiva. A varre-
dura pulmonar e eco-Doppler da perna foram realiza-
das nos dias 0 e 9. Nos grupos em que foi utilizada a
terapêutica compressiva, a distância caminhada diaria-
mente, determinada por meio de podômetro, aumentou
no decorrer do tempo, atingindo 4 km/dia em média. Tratamento medicamentoso No
último dia de estudo, a redução do edema (avaliado com
fita métrica) e a melhoria na pontuação clínica (ava-
liada por meio de escore clínico contendo sete itens: dor
durante a caminhada; dor na planta do pé na posição
ortostática; palpação dolorosa na panturrilha; edema
subfascial e prefascial; hiperemia; cianose; e aumento
da temperatura) foi significativamente mais pronun-
ciada (p < 0,01) nos grupos da compressão em relação
ao grupo de repouso. Não houve diferença significativa
quanto à ocorrência de novos eventos de EP e progres-
são do trombo avaliados no primeiro e segundo dias de em muitos centros hospitalares12. No entanto, os resul-
tados de algumas experiências controladas sugerem que
a mobilização precoce é uma modalidade terapêutica
segura e eficaz para tratar aspectos clínicos da
TVP12-15,17,18. Partsch & Blättler16 relataram estudo
experimental controlado com a finalidade de avaliar os
benefícios da compressão e exercícios de caminhada em
comparação com repouso no leito na fase aguda da TVP
proximal, diagnosticada por eco-Doppler ou flebogra-
fia. A amostra foi composta por 45 pacientes heparini-
zados, divididos em três grupos de 15 pacientes, seguindo
distintas modalidades terapêuticas durante 10 dias. Os
indivíduos do grupo A receberam bandagem de com-
pressão inelástica (botas de Unna) sobre a perna e ban-
dagem adesiva sobre a coxa, enquanto os do grupo B
utilizaram meias elásticas compressivas classe II (com-
pressão no tornozelo de 23 a 32 mmHg)26 até a exten-
são da coxa. Os pacientes dos dois primeiros grupos
foram submetidos a programa de caminhadas. Já os indi-
víduos do grupo C foram mantidos ao repouso e não
foram submetidos ao tratamento de compressão. Pelo
podômetro, foi constatado que a distância caminhada
nos grupos A e B variou entre 600 e 1.200 m, enquanto
no grupo de C a distância média de caminhadas diárias
foi somente de 66 m. O nível da dor foi estimado diaria-
mente por meio da escala analógica visual (VAS – Visual
Analogue Scale), que é a aferição subjetiva da intensi-
dade da dor por meio de variação numérica de 0 a 1017,
e do teste de Lowenberg, através do qual aplica-se pres-
são sobre a musculatura com o uso do manguito e
registra-se o nível de pressão que o paciente refere dor17. Tratamento medicamentoso O tratamento hospitalar da TVP pode ser realizado
com heparina não-fracionada por via intravenosa e sub-
cutânea. Atualmente, porém, vem sendo dada preferên-
cia, no tratamento da TVP, à heparina de baixo peso Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. 80
J Vasc Bras 2009, Vol. 8, Nº 1 80 em muitos centros hospitalares12. No entanto, os resul-
tados de algumas experiências controladas sugerem que
a mobilização precoce é uma modalidade terapêutica
segura e eficaz para tratar aspectos clínicos da
TVP12-15,17,18. Partsch & Blättler16 relataram estudo
experimental controlado com a finalidade de avaliar os
benefícios da compressão e exercícios de caminhada em
comparação com repouso no leito na fase aguda da TVP
proximal, diagnosticada por eco-Doppler ou flebogra-
fia. A amostra foi composta por 45 pacientes heparini-
zados, divididos em três grupos de 15 pacientes, seguindo
distintas modalidades terapêuticas durante 10 dias. Os
indivíduos do grupo A receberam bandagem de com-
pressão inelástica (botas de Unna) sobre a perna e ban-
dagem adesiva sobre a coxa, enquanto os do grupo B
utilizaram meias elásticas compressivas classe II (com-
pressão no tornozelo de 23 a 32 mmHg)26 até a exten-
são da coxa. Os pacientes dos dois primeiros grupos
foram submetidos a programa de caminhadas. Já os indi-
víduos do grupo C foram mantidos ao repouso e não
foram submetidos ao tratamento de compressão. Pelo
podômetro, foi constatado que a distância caminhada
nos grupos A e B variou entre 600 e 1.200 m, enquanto
no grupo de C a distância média de caminhadas diárias
foi somente de 66 m. O nível da dor foi estimado diaria-
mente por meio da escala analógica visual (VAS – Visual
Analogue Scale), que é a aferição subjetiva da intensi-
dade da dor por meio de variação numérica de 0 a 1017,
e do teste de Lowenberg, através do qual aplica-se pres-
são sobre a musculatura com o uso do manguito e
registra-se o nível de pressão que o paciente refere dor17. Nos grupos A e B, o grau de dor sofreu um decréscimo
estaticamente significativo (p < 0,05) no segundo dia e,
no grupo de repouso, apenas depois de 10 dias. Tratamento medicamentoso A
melhoria do bem-estar geral (foi avaliada com uso da
VAS) e a qualidade de vida (questionário de qualidade
de vida específico para doença venosa contendo 10 itens)
foram significativamente superiores nos grupos de com-
pressão (p < 0,05 para meia e p < 0,001 para bandagem)
em comparação com o grupo de repouso. O repouso
significou pouca influência sobre o edema nas pernas,
ao passo que a terapia de compressão associada a mobi-
lização precoce conduziu a uma rápida e drástica redu-
ção da circunferência da perna (p < 0,001). Na
pontuação clínica, os grupos de compressão obtiveram
resultados significativamente melhores do que o grupo
de repouso (p < 0,001). A dor avaliada diariamente atra-
vés da VAS indicou que houve uma diminuição grada-
tiva de dor em todos os grupos (p < 0,001); porém, J Vasc Bras 2009, Vol. 8, Nº 1 81 Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. parâmetros foram mensurados em três diferentes ocasi-
ões: à admissão ao estudo, durante o estudo e após 6
meses. Os resultados revelaram que não houve dife-
rença entres os grupos. Para a avaliação da extensão e
severidade da TVP na perna, foi utilizado o sistema de
classificação de Bjorgell, que varia de 0 a 3 (0 = sem
TVP, 1 = menos de um terço, 2 = um terço ou mais, 3 =
dois terços ou mais da perna, referente ao segmento
venoso comprometido), empregado durante a avalia-
ção diagnóstica e depois de 6 meses, quando o proto-
colo do estudo foi finalizado. Os resultados indicaram
que o grau de recanalização dos segmentos venosos afe-
tados foi alto e não diferiu entre os grupos. Não houve
TVP recorrente ou EP ou outras complicações do tra-
tamento em nenhum indivíduo durante os 6 meses do
período acompanhado, concluindo-se que a terapia pro-
posta neste estudo não exacerbou agudamente o risco
de complicações em pacientes com TVP. Nenhum bene-
ficio da mobilização foi visto em relação ao grau de reca-
nalização da trombose ou resolução rápida de dor ou
edema e melhora na força muscular de quadríceps e equi-
líbrio. Todavia, este estudo demonstrou que o exercício
precoce foi seguro em combinação com anticoagulação
e meias de compressão, quando aplicados em pacientes
com TVP. ocorreu melhora mais rápida durante os primeiros 4 dias
nos grupos de compressão (p < 0,01). Tratamento medicamentoso O melhor efeito
foi alcançado no grupo de bandagem, sendo observada
quase ausência de dor no final do período de observa-
ção (p < 0,01). A dor induzida pelo teste de Lowenberg
revelou que no grupo de repouso a dor reduziu conside-
ravelmente em 3 dias, mas houve recorrência, com a dor
sendo constante e acentuada ao longo dos 6 dias subse-
quentes. Porém, nos grupos de deambulação precoce
ocorreu diminuição da dor de forma progressiva desde
o início da terapia, sem recorrência. A progressão do
trombo, verificada no primeiro e segundo dias de estudo
com eco-Doppler, foi menos frequente e menos pronun-
ciada nos grupos A e B em relação ao grupo C (p <
0,01). Não houve diferença de novos eventos de EP no
segundo exame de varredura pulmonar entre os grupos. O estudo de Blättler & Partsch27 sugeriu ser a compres-
são na perna combinada com a caminhada a melhor
estratégia terapêutica para o tratamento de pacientes sin-
tomáticos com TVP proximal, sendo superior à estraté-
gia de repouso absoluto no leito. Isma et al.14 realizaram estudo randomizado no Hos-
pital Universitário de Malmo, Suécia, com o propósito
de avaliar se o exercício precoce supervisionado melho-
raria a recanalização e reduz os sintomas clínicos da TVP
diagnosticada por meio de flebografia. Os 72 pacientes
incluídos no estudo foram seguidos durante 6 meses,
após serem divididos em: grupo experimental (n = 36),
com anticoagulação, meias de compressão classe II e
exercício supervisionado; e grupo controle (n = 36) rece-
bendo a mesma terapia, exceto em relação ao exercício. Os pacientes foram incentivados a caminhar já na fase
hospitalar. Entre 5 e 7 dias após o diagnóstico de TVP,
todos os indivíduos no grupo experimental foram incen-
tivados a se exercitar diariamente em casa por 15 minu-
tos, durante 6 meses. Durante o primeiro mês,
frequentavam sessão semanal de 45 minutos, supervisio-
nada por fisioterapeuta. Nos meses subsequentes, fre-
quentaram apenas 1 sessão mensal supervisionada. O
programa de exercícios consistiu basicamente de cami-
nhadas e exercícios resistidos, com ênfase nos membros
inferiores. Foram avaliados: qualidade de vida (ava-
liada por meio de VAS); força muscular do quádriceps;
equilíbrio; e circunferência da coxa e da panturrilha. Tais No estudo randomizado de Aschwanden et al.13, o
objetivo foi demonstrar que a mobilização precoce não
aumentaria a frequência de EP em 129 pacientes com
TVP proximal, diagnosticada por meio de eco-Dopller. Tratamento medicamentoso Todos receberam terapia de heparina e foram submeti-
dos à estrita imobilização (grupo A: n = 60) durante 4
dias ou a deambulação (grupo B: n = 69) por 4 h/dia
sob supervisão. Os indivíduos de ambos os grupos usa-
ram meias de compressão classe II. Os pacientes foram
investigados por meio de cintilografia ventilação
/perfusão pulmonar quanto à presença de EP no início
do estudo e no quarto dia. As alterações das circunfe-
rências das pernas e dor em repouso e durante o exercí-
cio foram avaliadas por meio de fita métrica e VAS,
respectivamente. Os resultados encontrados demonstra-
ram não haver diferença estatisticamente significativa
entre os grupos, no que se refere à diminuição da circun-
ferência e da dor em repouso nas pernas. No entanto,
no grupo experimental foi observado decréscimo signi-
ficativo na dor durante a prática de exercício. Todos os Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. 82
J Vasc Bras 2009, Vol. 8, Nº 1 82 pacientes foram contatados em 3 meses e entrevistados
a respeito de recorrência de TVP, sinais clínicos de EP,
novas doenças concomitantes e ocorrência de maiores
complicações. A incidência de EP no início do estudo
foi 53 e 44,9%, respectivamente nos indivíduos imóveis
e móveis. Durante os 4 dias de observação ocorreram
novos episódios de EP, com incidências de 10 e de 14,4%,
respectivamente, em pacientes do grupo A e B. Dos 16
casos de EP detectados no quarto dia, 12 ocorreram em
indivíduos com EP prévia, correspondendo ao risco rela-
tivo 3,65, considerando-se a incidência de eventos trom-
boembólicos nos que já a haviam apresentado
comparados com os que a apresentaram pela primeira
vez. Não houve óbito durante os 4 dias de observação. No decorrer de 3 meses, a taxa de mortalidade foi 3,9%
(2 mortes no grupo A e 3 mortes no grupo B). As mor-
tes foram ocasionadas por doenças malignas e houve
três recorrências de TVP (1 do grupo A e 2 do grupo B). Os resultados deste estudo sugeriram ser a mobilização
precoce recurso terapêutico efetivo e seguro para ser uti-
lizada como rotina em pacientes com TVP, levando-se
em consideração a comparação com a imobilização. Discussão Durante muito tempo, preconizou-se repouso abso-
luto no leito como tratamento da TVP aguda. O proto-
colo comumente utilizado na prática hospitalar consiste
em repouso, elevação de membros inferiores e anticoa-
gulantes até que se obtenha a estabilidade do trom-
bo1,15. Entretanto, muitos estudos sugerem ser a
deambulação precoce recomendada para a maioria dos
pacientes com TVP, devendo haver maior precaução com
indivíduos com histórico de EP prévia13,15,17,18,29,30,32. Pesquisas têm demonstrado que a prescrição de repouso
no leito para pacientes com TVP não reduziu a incidên-
cia de EP a ponto de influenciar significativamente a
evolução clínica13,15,17,18,30,32. Do ponto de vista fisio-
patológico, a imobilização produz consequências decor-
rentes da estase venosa, revelando-se como um dos mais
importantes fatores discriminados por Virchow como
sendo responsáveis pela trombogênese. A inatividade do
mecanismo de bombeamento do sistema venoso propor-
cionado pelos músculos dos membros inferiores
(“bomba muscular”) e a atividade fibrinolítica depri-
mida são outros fatores que contribuem para a forma-
ção
e
propagação
do
trombo,
com
sequelas
pós-trombóticas graves4,33. Durante muito tempo, preconizou-se repouso abso-
luto no leito como tratamento da TVP aguda. O proto-
colo comumente utilizado na prática hospitalar consiste
em repouso, elevação de membros inferiores e anticoa-
gulantes até que se obtenha a estabilidade do trom-
bo1,15. Entretanto, muitos estudos sugerem ser a
deambulação precoce recomendada para a maioria dos
pacientes com TVP, devendo haver maior precaução com
indivíduos com histórico de EP prévia13,15,17,18,29,30,32. Partsch et al.15 desenvolveu estudo prospectivo no
intuito de determinar a incidência de EP em 139 pacien-
tes hospitalizados que apresentavam TVP proximal diag-
nosticada por flebografia radioisotópica, submetidos à
terapia de anticoagulação, programa de caminhadas e
compressão venosa. No início do estudo, 80 pacientes
foram diagnosticados com EP, mas apenas 11 eram sin-
tomáticos. No último dia de internação (11 dias em
média), a cintilografia pulmonar realizada detectou
novos casos de EP em quatro dos 59 sem histórico pré-
vio e em sete com EP no primeiro exame. Porém, 33
pacientes (23,7%) apresentaram regressão dos defeitos
de perfusão na cintilografia. Um paciente de 80 anos de
idade com carcinoma da próstata sofreu EP fatal. O
estudo corroborou a informação de que existe uma rela-
ção direta entre TVP e EP, independente da mobiliza-
ção precoce. Tratamento medicamentoso durante o período de permanência hospitalar: presença
de EP à admissão (V/Q scan) e incidência de EP após 10
dias (segunda V/Q scan), eventos fatais (necropsia), pre-
sença de doença maligna, complicações hemorrágicas e
trombocitopenia induzida por heparina. A incidência
de EP à admissão hospitalar foi: 53,4% no segmento
ilíaco-femoral; 52,6% na veia femoral; e 35,1% nas veias
da perna. Em dois terços dessas EP, os pacientes esta-
vam assintomáticos. Nesse estudo, a baixa incidência de
recidiva e EP fatal depõem a favor da deambulação pre-
coce com compressão em membros inferiores em pacien-
tes com sintomas de TVP. Além dos já comentados neste presente artigo, exis-
tem muitos outros estudos que comprovaram a eficácia
e a segurança de se considerar a mobilização precoce no
contexto terapêutico da TVP4,12,18,28-32. Discussão Partsch et al.16, em 1.289 pacientes com TVP sinto-
mática, tratados com heparina de baixo peso molecu-
lar, compressão e exercícios de caminhada, determinou
a incidência em curto prazo de EP, hemorragia, trom-
bocitopenia induzida por heparina e morte. Os indiví-
duos foram avaliados por meio de cinco parâmetros Quando se compara a evolução de pacientes deixa-
dos em repouso no leito com os mobilizados precoce-
mente, tem-se observado ausência de diferença J Vasc Bras 2009, Vol. 8, Nº 1 83 Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. 83 significativa no aparecimento de EP13-17,28, embora se
afirme que a mobilização precoce contribuiria para a
redução da progressão do trombo16,28. Partsch et al.16
argumentou que a deambulação precoce poderia ser um
aspecto protetor, uma vez que reduz a estase venosa, um
dos fatores de risco para TVP recorrente ou progres-
siva. Os dados reportados por Partsch & Blättler16 suge-
riram que a deambulação em combinação com
anticoagulação e compressão da perna em pacientes com
TVP na fase aguda conduziria a uma regressão mais
rápida de sintomas e sinais clínicos, como dor, edema,
hiperemia e aumento de temperatura. Isma et al.14 cor-
roborou, indicando que a mobilização precoce é o tra-
tamento adequado para sintomatologia clínica dos
pacientes, acrescentando ter sido observada melhora na
qualidade de vida desses indivíduos. propagação do trombo foi relacionada ao nível de anti-
coagulação, tendo sido provavelmente influenciada pelo
grau de estase37. Por isso, no paciente com TVP, tem
sido proposta a mobilização aliada a heparina de baixo
peso
molecular
imediatamente
após
o
diagnóstico28,29,31,32,34. No estudo realizado por Isma et al.14, não foi obser-
vado nenhum benefício substancial do exercício na reca-
nalização venosa, haja vista que o acompanhamento foi
tardio, efetuado 6 meses depois do fim do protocolo de
estudo, inviabilizando a análise do efeito da mobiliza-
ção na fase aguda. A pontuação de severidade relativa-
mente baixa em ambos os grupos dificultou a avaliação
dos eventuais efeitos do exercício. Os sintomas provenientes da TVP resultam, parcial-
mente, de um aumento na pressão intracapilar e de pos-
terior transudação de fluido dos capilares para o espaço
intersticial38, ocasionados pelo obstáculo ao fluxo san-
guíneo venoso e pela insuficiência valvar39. Tais fenô-
menos prejudicam a perfusão muscular da perna,
promovendo a fadiga muscular38. Referências 18. Schaub RG, Simmons CA, Koets MH, Romano PJ 2nd,
Stewart GJ. Early events in the formation of a venous thrombus
following local trauma and stasis. Lab Invest. 1984;51:218-24. 1. Maffei FHA, Lastoria S, Yoshida WB, Rollo HA. Doenças
vasculares periféricas. 3ª ed. Rio de Janeiro: Medsi; 2002. vol. 2. 19. Albuquerque HPC, Vidal PC. Trombose venosa profunda:
revisão dos conceitos atuais. Rev Bras Ortop. 1996;31:851-6. 2. Mello NA. Síndromes vasculares: clínica, diagnóstico,
tratamento. São Paulo: Fundo Editorial BYK; 1999. p. 383. 20. Sikorski JM, Hampson WG, Stadsdon GE. The natural history
and a etiology of deep vein thrombosis after total hip
replacement. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1981;63-B:171-7. 3. Verstraete M, Vermylen J. Trombose. São Paulo: Sarvier; 1989. p. 356. 4. Labas P, Ohrádka B, Vladimír J, Cambal M. The home
treatment of deep vein thrombosis with low molecular weigth
heparin, forced mobilisation and compression. Int Angiol. 2000;19:303-7. 21. Thomas DP, Meston RE, Wood RD, Hockley DJ. The
relationship between vessel wall injury and venous thrombosis:
an experimental study. Br J Haematol. 1985;59:449-57. 22. Brenner BM, Troy JL, Ballerman BJ. Endothelium-dependent
vascular responses. J Clin Invest. 1989;84:1373-8. 5. Maffei, FHA. Trombose venosa profunda dos membros
inferiores: incidência, patologia, fisiopatologia e diagnóstico. In: Maffei FHA, Lastoria S, Yoshida WB, Rollo HA. Doenças
vasculares periféricas. 3ª ed. São Paulo: Medsi; 2002. p. 1363-86. 23. Hirsh J, Hull R. Venous thromboembolism: natural history,
diagnosis and management. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 1987. p. 17-21. 6. Fowkes FJ, Price JF, Fowkes FG. Incidence of diagnosed deep
vein thrombosis in the general population: systematic review. Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2003;25:1-5. 24. Green D, Hirsh J, Heit J, Prins M, Davidson B, Lensing AW. Low molecular weight eparin:a critical analysis of clinical
trials. Pharmacol Rev. 1994;46:89-10. 7. Anderson FA, Wheeler HB, Goldberg RJ, et al. A population
based perspective of the hospital incidence and case-fatality
rates of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism: the
Worchester DVT Study. Arch Intern Med. 1991;151:933-8. 25. Merlo I, Parente JB, Komlós PP. Varizes e telangiectasias:
diagnóstico e tratamento. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter; 2006. 26. Figueiredo MAM., Filho AD, Cabral ALS. Avaliação do efeito
da meia elástica na hemodinâmica venosa dos membros
inferiores de pacientes com insuficiência venosa crônica. J Vasc
Bras. 2004;3:231-7. 8. National Institutes of Health Consensus Conference. Prevention of venous thrombosis and pulmonary embolism. JAMA. 1986;256:744-9. 27. Blättler W, Partsch H. Discussão Killewich et al.34 mencionam que regressão da TVP
aguda ocorre devido ao aumento da atividade fibrinolí-
tica endógena e do ativador de plasminogênio tecidual. O exercício físico acentua a atividade fibrinolítica endó-
gena manifestada como uma diminuição no inibidor do
ativador do plasminogênio34. Fischer35, em 1910, recomendava ataduras com
emplastro de zinco para tratar pacientes com trombose,
especulando que a firme compressão externa fixaria os
coágulos na parede das veias. O efeito físico da compres-
são externa verificada no estudo realizado por Partsch
et al.36, demonstrado por meio da flebografia, eviden-
ciou ação contra a formação do edema decorrente do
estreitamento das veias superficiais e profundas. Os mes-
mos autores concluíram que os materiais inelásticos,
como o emplastro de zinco, são mais eficazes que o mate-
rial elástico na redução da estase venosa local. Por-
tanto, os resultados encontrados nos estudos realizados
por Partsch & Blättler16 e Blättler & Partsch27 demons-
traram que o grupo de compressão inelástica apresen-
tou efeitos superiores em reduzir os sinais e sintomas
clínicos. Em todos esses estudos mencionados, houve uti-
lização de meias de compressão, o que impossibilitou
avaliar o efeito isolado da mobilização precoce. Os efeitos potencialmente benéficos da mobilização
precoce relacionam-se à teoria da bomba muscular da
panturrilha e ao treino muscular17. Durante a contra-
ção muscular, ocorre aumento na habilidade de ejeção,
facilitando o retorno venoso, o que, por sua vez, reduz o
gradiente de pressão hidrostática, responsável pela for-
mação do edema40-42, bem como melhora a perfusão
muscular potencializando sua ação38. O estudo de
Partsch et al.16 corroborou ao relatar que compressão
externa da perna, aliada ao programa de caminhadas,
proporcionaria redução na pressão hidrostática sanguí-
nea e, consequentemente, diminuiria os sintomas e sinais
venosos. A qualidade dos artigos, ensaios clínicos controla-
dos e estudos epidemiológicos pesquisados neste estudo
permitiu que os resultados, a discussão e, consequente-
mente, as conclusões, fossem fundamentadas em um
bom grau de evidência científica. Os principais estudos
pesquisados e citados são internacionais, oriundos de
países desenvolvidos. Existe uma lacuna de pesquisas
realizadas no Brasil e América Latina sobre o tema, A propagação do trombo foi observada em cerca de
20% dos pacientes, apesar de tratamento adequado com
heparina e mobilização tardia. Porém, esse valor cai para
1% se a mobilização for instituída precocemente37. A 84
J Vasc Bras 2009, Vol. 8, Nº 1 Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. 12. Discussão Aldrich D, Hunt DP. When can the patient with deep venous
thrombosis begin to ambulate? Phys Ther. 2004;84:268-73. diante da qual fica a sugestão para a realização de estu-
dos experimentais no Brasil, o que poderia fornecer sub-
sídios em prol da proposta de mobilização precoce no
âmbito hospitalar em nosso meio. 13. Aschwanden M, Labs KH, Engel H, et al. Acute deep vein
thrombosis: early mobilization does not increase the frequency
of pulmonary embolism. Thromb Haemost. 2001;85:42-6. 14. Isma N, Johanssson E, Björk A, et al. Does supervised exercise
after deep venous thrombosis improve recanalization of
occluded vein segments? A randomized study. J Thromb
Thrombolysis. 2007;23:25-30. Conclusão Opondo-se à estratégia de restrição ao leito, estudos
recentes, avaliados nesta revisão, demonstraram os bene-
fícios na redução da dor e edema, com melhora da qua-
lidade de vida, pela estratégia terapêutica de
deambulação precoce em combinação com anticoagu-
lação e compressão da perna em pacientes com TVP,
sem que fosse verificada maior incidência de desfechos
relevantes, como EP e morte. 15. Partsch H, Oburger K, Mostbeck A, König B, Köhn H. Frequency of pulmonary embolism in ambulant patients with
pelvic vein thrombosis: a prospective study. J Vasc Surg. 1992;16:715-22. 16. Partsch H, Blättler W. Compression and walking versus bed
rest in the treatment of proximal deep venous thrombosis with
low molecular weight heparin. J Vasc Surg. 2000;32:861-9. 17. Schellong
SM,
Schwarz
T,
Kropp
J,
Prescher
Y,
Beuthien-Baumann B, Daniel WG. Bed rest in deep venous
thrombosis and the incidence of scintigraphic pulmonary
embolism. Thromb Haemost. 1999;82(suppl 1):127-9. Referências Leg compression and ambulation is
better than bed rest for the treatment of acute deep venous
thrombosis. Int Angiol. 2003;22:393-400. 9. Diebold J, Löhrs U. Venous thrombosis and pulmonary
embolism. A study of
5039 autopsies. Pathol Res
Pract.1991;187:260-6. 28. Partsch H. Therapy of deep vein thrombosis with low
molecular weight heparin, leg compression and immediate
ambulation. Vasa. 2001;30:195-204. 10. Saeger W, Genzkow M. Venous thrombosis and pulmonary
embolisms in post-mortem series: probable causes by
correlations of clinical data and basic diseases. Pathol Res
Pract. 1994;190:394-9. 29. Kiser TS, Stefans VA. Pulmonary embolism in rehabilitation
patients: relation to time before return to physical therapy after
diagnosis of deep vein thrombosis. Arch Phys Me Rehabil. 1997;78:942-5. 11. Lindblad B, Sternby NH, Berqqvist D. Incidence of venous
thromboembolism verified by necropsy over 30 years. BMJ. 1991;302:709-11. J Vasc Bras 2009, Vol. 8, Nº 1 85 Mobilização precoce de trombose venosa profunda – Penha GS et al. 30. Partsch H, Kaulich M, Mayer W. Immediate mobilisation in
acute vein thrombosis reduces post-thrombotic syndrome. Int
Angiol. 2004;23:206-12. 38. Qvarfordt P, Christenson JT, Eköf B, Ohlin P, Saltin B. Intramuscular pressure, muscle blood flow, and skeletal muscle
metabolism in chronic anterior tibial compartment syndrome. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1983;179:284-90. 31. Partsch, H. Ambulation and compression after deep vein
thrombosis:
dispelling
myths. Semin
Vasc
Surg. 2005;18:148-52. 39. Susan RK, Jeffrey SG. Relationship between deep venous
thrombosis and the postthrombotic syndrome. Arch Intern
Med. 2004;164:17-26. http://archinte.ama-assn.org/cgi/
content/full/164/1/17?. Acessado: 26/10/2008. 32. Jünger M, Diehm C, Störiko H, et al. Mobilization versus
immobilization in the treatment of acute proximal deep venous
thrombosis: a prospective, randomized, open, multicentre trial. Curr Med Res Opin. 2006;22:593-602. 40. Stick C, Grau H, Witzleb E. On the edema: preventing effect
of the calf muscle pump. Eur J Appl Physiol. 1989;59:39-47. 41. Padberg FT Jr, Johnson MV, Sisto SA. Structured exercise
improves calf muscle pump function in choronic venous
insufficiency: a randomized trial. J Vasc Surg. 2004; 39:79-87. 33. Samama MM, Simonneau G, Wainstein J-P, De Vathaire F,
Huet Y, Landauer D. SIRIUS Study: Epidemiology of risk
factors of deep venous thrombosis of the lower limbs in
community practice. Thromb Haemost. 1993;69:797A. 42. Journal of Vascular Surgery [site na Internet]. Elsevier, Inc. http://www.journals.elsevierhealth.com/periodicals/ymva/
article/PIIS0741521403014125/fulltext. Acessado: 12/01/2008. 34. Killewich LA, Macko RF, Cox K, et al. Regression of proximal
deep venous thrombosis is associated with fibrinolytic
enhancement. J Vasc Surg.1997;26:861-8. 43. Shrier I, Kahn S R. Referências Effect of physical activity after recent deep
venous thrombosis: a cohort study. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2005;37:630-4. 35. Fischer H. Eine neue Therapie der Phlebitis. Med Klin. 1910;30:1172-80. Correspondência:
Geane de Souza Penha
Rua Coronel Américo, 131, Barreiros
CEP 88117-310 – São José, SC
Tel.: (48) 3240.0040, (48) 9926.1728
E-mail: geanepenha@yahoo.com.br Correspondência:
Geane de Souza Penha
Rua Coronel Américo, 131, Barreiros
CEP 88117-310 – São José, SC
Tel.: (48) 3240.0040, (48) 9926.1728
E-mail: geanepenha@yahoo.com.br 36. Partsch H, Menzinger G, Mostbeck A. Inelastic leg
compression is more effective to reduce deep venous refluxes
than elastic bandages. Dermatol Surg. 1999;25:695-700. 37. Schulman S. Studies on the medical treatment of deep vein
thrombosis. Acta Med Scand Suppl. 1985;704:1-68.
|
https://openalex.org/W1976479029
|
https://redc.revistas.csic.es/index.php/redc/article/download/674/749/1163, https://digital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/77746/1/2010-33-4%20Analisis%20de%20genero.pdf
|
es
|
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias de Ciencias de la Salud en la Comunidad Valenciana (2003-2007)
|
Revista española de documentación científica
| 2,010
|
cc-by
| 7,461
|
Revista Española de Documentación Científica,
33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010
ISSN: 0210-0614. doi: 10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
Análisis de género, productividad científica
y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias
de Ciencias de la Salud en la Comunidad
Valenciana (2003-2007)
Adolfo Alonso-Arroyo*, Máxima Bolaños-Pizarro**, Gregorio GonzálezAlcaide**, Miguel Villamón***, Rafael Aleixandre-Benavent**
Resumen: Se presenta la producción científica de las profesoras universitarias en el área
de las Ciencias de la Salud de la Comunitat Valenciana durante el quinquenio 20032007 aplicando técnicas bibliométricas y realizando un análisis de género con el fin
de conocer cuántas llegan a ser grandes productoras de artículos científicos frente a
las que no alcanzan estos niveles de productividad e impacto. Se han recuperado 3.739
artículos durante el período estudiado, identificando el género de todos los autores
con más de 2 artículos. De estos autores, 2.774 (60,41 %) son hombres y 1.818 (39,59 %)
son mujeres, pero si se analizan solamente a los grandes productores, las autoras con
más de 10 trabajos únicamente llegan a ser el 26,72 %. Respecto a la colaboración
científica hay que resaltar que las mujeres están presentes en todas las redes de al
menos 10 autores y en algunos casos su presencia se equipara a la de los hombres.
Pese a que la participación de la mujer en todas las áreas del conocimiento es inferior
a los hombres, en las Ciencias de la Salud la proporción es menor que en otras áreas
técnicas. La aportación de las mujeres al ámbito científico es cada vez mayor pudiendo alcanzar la paridad con el paso de los años.
Palabras clave: Análisis de género, bibliometría, producción científica, colaboración científica, Comunitat Valenciana, Ciencias de la Salud.
Gender analysis, scholarly productivity and collaboration of female
university professors of Health Science in the Autonomous Region
of Valencia (2003-2007)
Abstract: The article presents an analysis of the scholarly output of female professors in the
field of Health Science in the Autonomous Region of Valencia from 2003 to 2007,
through bibliometric techniques and the application of a gender variable. The work
attempted to identify how many women became large producers of scholarly articles
compared to those who did not reach the same levels of productivity and impact. A total
* Departamento de Historia de la Ciencia y Documentación. Facultad de Medicina y Odontología. Universitat de València. Correo-e: adolfo.alonso@uv.es.
** Instituto de Historia de la Medicina y de la Ciencia López Piñero. (UISYS), (CSIC).
*** Facultad de Ciencias de la Actividad Física y el Deporte. Universitat de València.
Recibido: 13-12-2009; 2.ª versión: 27-2-2010; aceptado: 3-3-2010.
624
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 624
25/11/10 13:44
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
of 3,739 articles were retrieved during this period and the gender of all authors with
more than 2 articles was identified. Of these authors 2,774 (60.41 %) were male and
1,818 (39.59 %) were female. Focusing solely on large producers, the percentage of
women publishing more than 10 papers was reduced to 26.72 %. As regards to scientific
collaboration, it is significant to note that women are included in all clusters of at least
10 authors and in some cases their presence is comparable with that of men. Although
women’s participation is lower than men’s in all areas of knowledge, it is noteworthy
that in Health Sciences the difference is not as great as in other technical areas. Women’s
contribution to the scientific field is increasing, suggesting the possibility of a significant
improvement in gender parity in the coming years.
Keywords: Gender analysis, Bibliometrics, scholarly output, scholarly collaboration,
Valencian Community, Health science.
1.
Introducción
Impulsadas por el movimiento feminista y buscando esclarecer la construcción
histórica, social y cultural de las relaciones entre los sexos, profesoras de diversas universidades de Estados Unidos e Inglaterra comenzaron, a finales de los
años sesenta y principios de los setenta del pasado siglo, a incorporar el pensamiento feminista a sus estudios e investigaciones. Este tipo de estudios pretende
aplicar la perspectiva de género en todos los objetos de conocimiento, propiciando la construcción de una ciencia no androcéntrica y recibiendo diversos
nombres tales como Estudios de las Mujeres (Women’s Studies), Estudios Feministas o Estudios de Género (Torres, 2009).
Desde la perspectiva de género y a lo largo de todo el siglo XX, el camino de las mujeres en la Educación se ha concebido como una estrategia para
superar la discriminación y la incorporación de la mujer en la Universidad.
En España, hasta 1910 no se obtuvo un respaldo legal para que este hecho
pudiera convertirse en realidad (Guil, 2005). En torno a los años cincuenta,
aparece la primera generación de mujeres en la Universidad española y será en
los años setenta cuando constituyen un grupo significativo (García de León,
1995). La transición democrática española favoreció la participación de la mujer
en la vida política y social. Esto propició el reconocimiento oficial de los Estudios de la Mujer en el seno de la Universidad y, por consiguiente, su institucionalización.
La docencia y la investigación en la Universidad en general, y en las Ciencias
de la Salud en particular, han estado ligadas históricamente a los varones y desde su perspectiva se ha creado el conjunto de conocimientos que constituyen el
saber médico (Martínez y otros, 2003). Hoy en día todavía la condición femenina
es un obstáculo para la promoción en el ámbito académico, investigador y de
gestión y el influjo de las mujeres en la medicina académica está en desacuerdo
con la evolución registrada en la medicina asistencial. La relación entre el número de mujeres que ejerce la medicina y las que ocupan puestos de responsabilidad no guarda proporción (Arrizabalaga y Valls, 2005).
Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 625
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 625
25/11/10 13:44
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
A raíz de muchos de estos datos, la Dirección General de Investigación de
la Unión Europea creó un grupo de trabajo sobre Mujeres y Ciencia en 1998,
que elaboró el llamado informe ETAN, donde se analizaba la situación de las
mujeres en este ámbito y se realizaba toda una serie de recomendaciones para
promover la igualdad de género (ETAN, 2000). Una de las conclusiones de este
informe fue que la «infra-representación de las mujeres amenaza los objetivos científicos de alcanzar la excelencia, además de ser un derroche y una injusticia».
La igualdad entre hombres y mujeres en Europa ha tenido un amplio reflejo
normativo en los textos básicos presentados en el 50º aniversario en política europea de igualdad en 2007. Sin embargo, y pese a todos los esfuerzos realizados,
en los sucesivos informes que la Comisión de las Comunidades Europeas viene
elaborando anualmente desde 2004, se observa que los avances en la calidad del
empleo femenino son escasos o nulos. Se ha producido un estancamiento en la
presencia de mujeres en los puestos de responsabilidad empresarial (33 %) y un
lento progreso en la política (23 % de diputadas nacionales; 33 % de diputadas
europeas) (Comisión de las Comunidades Europeas, 2008).
En la actualidad, el tema «mujeres y ciencia» se encuentra en el centro de las
políticas europeas sobre la construcción del Espacio Europeo de Investigación
(ERA). Para la Unión, la infra-representación de las mujeres investigadoras impide la completa realización del ERA y, además, significa: «un inaceptable despilfarro de recursos humanos que no podemos costear» (CSIC, 2007).
La preocupación por favorecer la igualdad de género a nivel gubernamental
tiene como uno de los hitos más destacados en España la creación en 2005 de
un organismo específico adscrito al Ministerio de Educación a través de la Secretaría General de Política Científica y Tecnológica, la Unidad de Mujeres y Ciencia
(UMYC), cuya misión es favorecer la incorporación de las mujeres en condiciones
de igualdad al sistema científico y tecnológico español (BOE, 2005). También, a
lo largo de los últimos años numerosas universidades e instituciones científicas
han creado organismos y han promovido acciones para favorecer la promoción
de la igualdad entre hombres y mujeres.
Este estudio pretende analizar, mediante indicadores bibliométricos, la actividad y la aportación científica de las profesoras universitarias en Ciencias de la
Salud de la Comunitat Valenciana (productividad, colaboración, visibilidad e impacto y calidad de los trabajos publicados) desagregados por género. Las universidades públicas valencianas lideran las actividades de investigación en la Comunitat Valenciana, siendo el primer agente del sistema de I+D por volumen de
recursos financieros y humanos destinados a estas actividades imprescindibles
para el desarrollo de la sociedad del conocimiento (Pérez y Pastor, 2009), y por
tanto, los datos obtenidos constituyen uno de los pilares básicos para profundizar
sobre la situación de la mujer en la ciencia y proporcionan una información objetiva imprescindible para establecer las bases de una política científica de promoción de la mujer investigadora.
626 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 626
25/11/10 13:44
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
2.
Material y método
Para la realización de esta investigación se han utilizado las bases de datos:
Web of Science consultada en el portal del Web of Knowledge (http://www.accesowok.fecyt.es/wos/) e IME consultada en la Intranet de la base de datos del
Instituto de Historia de la Ciencia y Documentación López Piñero (http://ime.
uv.es/info/index.htm). La limitación cronológica se estableció en el quinquenio
2003-2007 y en cuanto a la tipología documental, el estudio se restringió a artículos originales, revisiones, cartas y editoriales, excluyendo las críticas de libros,
resúmenes de comunicaciones a congresos, reprints, noticias y artículos bilbiográficos, entre otros, ya que su aparición era esporádica. La metodología utilizada puede agruparse en 4 fases:
a) La estrategia de búsqueda en la base de datos SCI-Expanded incluyó todas las revistas fuente de las 63 áreas de las Ciencias de la Salud (Medicina Clínica y Ciencias de la Vida) que se han indizado a lo largo del
período estudiado según la clasificación (Subject categories) del Journal
Citation Reports (JCR) (anexo I), una vez excluidas las revistas españolas
indizadas en la base de datos IME. En el caso de la base de datos IME
se descargó toda la producción científica correspondiente al período estudiado, eliminando mediante una revisión manual los trabajos no firmados por universidades valencianas.
b) Tratamiento de los datos y normalización de autores e instituciones. Se
efectuó una meticulosa depuración manual unificando las diferentes variantes de los nombres de un mismo autor o institución, bien porque los
autores no firman siempre sus trabajos de la misma forma o debido a
errores en el momento del procesado de la información en las bases de
datos analizadas. En el caso de los autores, el criterio que se siguió ante
dos o más variantes de un mismo nombre y/o apellidos consistió en comprobar la coincidencia en los lugares de trabajo de las diferentes variantes.
Respecto a las instituciones, se procedió a la normalización de las
diferentes variantes en su denominación. Igualmente, en ocasiones existían registros bibliográficos que incluían dos o más instituciones dentro
de una única adscripción institucional. En estos casos se consignaba para
cada registro bibliográfico tantas firmas como instituciones se pudieran
individualizar.
Para la identificación del género se consultaron los directorios de
personal de las universidades y en ocasiones se contactó «in situ» con los
servicios de recursos humanos de las universidades objeto de estudio. A
su vez, también se consultaron las Web del Ministerio de Sanidad y Consumo, Colegios Médicos, directorios específicos de las diferentes disciplinas del área de Ciencias de la Salud, o de las propias instituciones de
adscripción de los autores, bases de datos o directorios específicos de
personas (Who is who?) o bien se accedió al texto completo de los traRev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 627
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 627
25/11/10 13:44
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
bajos o a los índices de las revistas fuente donde fueron publicados,
donde es habitual que se desarrolle el nombre completo de los autores.
c) Los indicadores se calcularon sobre la totalidad de la comunidad investigadora con el objeto de determinar la existencia de diferencias según
el sexo. Se analizó la productividad según el número de trabajos y evolución durante el quinquenio, distribución según su tipología documental,
posición relativa de la mujer en el orden de las firmas, revistas de publicación de los trabajos y redes de colaboración institucional y redes de
coautoría de investigadores como base para la identificación de grupos
de investigación. Se consideró la existencia de un grupo cuando estuviera formado al menos por tres o más autores vinculados entre sí, de forma
directa o través de intermediarios, con cinco o más relaciones de coautoría.
d) Software para el análisis de los datos. Se utilizó el software de desarrollo
propio Bibliométricos, permitiendo confeccionar bases de datos relacionales en Microsoft Access a partir de la información bibliográfica de los
registros recuperados.
Para el cálculo de los indicadores y la construcción de las representación
gráficas de la redes se utilizaron los programas de análisis y visualización de redes Pajek.
3.
Resultados
Se han recuperado 3.739 registros publicados durante el período comprendido entre 2003-2007, realizados por 9.096 autores diferentes que al menos han
publicado un trabajo.
Se ha identificado el género de 4.592 autores (50,48 %), la mitad del total de
autores, pero hay que matizar que dicho porcentaje incluye la totalidad de autores que han publicado al menos 3 trabajos en el período estudiado (2003-2007).
Además se ha identificado el género de un 39,03 % de autores transeúntes con
1 ó 2 trabajos (2.111 autores (35,23 %) con 1 trabajo y 762 autores (55,66 %) con 2
trabajos). No se ha podido realizar la identificación del género de aquellos autores que tenían apellidos comunes (generalmente un solo apellido), y de los
autores que no tenían nexos de colaboración con autores más productivos.
De estos autores, 2.774 (60,41 %) son hombres y 1.818 (39,59 %) son mujeres.
En la distribución cronológica que se presenta en la tabla I, se observa un aumento constante en número y porcentaje de mujeres, pasando del 30,61 % en
2003 al 39,52 % en 2007, alcanzando este último año su mayor cota. Estos datos
reflejan cómo la mujer universitaria se va incorporando progresivamente a la investigación. En relación con las firmas, estos autores son responsables de 15.134
firmas, con incremento en el período estudiado más leve, pasando del 34,04 %
en el año 2003 al 36,60 % en 2007.
628 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 628
25/11/10 13:44
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
TABLA I
Distribución de hombres y mujeres en relación con los años de publicación
de los trabajos (número de autores y número de firmas)
Número de autores
Número de firmas
Años
H
%H
M
%M
Total
H
%H
M
%M
Total
2003
786
62,83
465
30,61
1.251
1.519
65,96
784
34,04
2.303
2004
896
62,53
537
31,59
1.433
1.700
66,93
840
33,07
2.540
2005
886
61,06
565
33,63
1.451
1.680
65,55
883
34,45
2.563
2006
1.310
61,73
812
35,00
2.122
2.320
65,35
1.230
34,65
3.550
2007
1.586
60,24
1.047
39,52
2.633
2.649
63,40
1.529
36,60
4.178
Total
2.774
60,41
1.818
39,59
4.592*
9.868
65,20
5.266
34,80
15.134
* El valor de los autores totales no coincide con los valores totales desglosados por años por el hecho de
que existen autores que han publicado en diferentes años, mientras que en el total se computan los autores
distintos en todo el período. H: hombres; M: mujeres.
En lo que se refiere a la distribución según su tipología documental, puede
observarse en la tabla II que las mujeres publican en mayor medida artículos
originales (40,03 %), mientras que lo hacen menos en la sección de editoriales
(26,74 %). Si se analiza el número de firmas, los datos oscilan entre un 22,90 %
de firmas de mujeres en la sección de editoriales y un 35,22 % de artículos originales.
TABLA II
Distribución de hombres y mujeres en relación con la tipología documental
de los trabajos (número de trabajos, número de autores y número de firmas)
Tipología
Nº de
documental trabajos
Número de autores
H
%H
M
%M
Número de firmas
Total
H
%H
M
%M
Total
Artículo original
3.195
Revisión
295
356 65,44
188 34,56
544
559 67,59
268 32,41
827
Carta
155
262 63,44
151 36,56
413
370 66,43
187 33,57
557
137 73,26
50 26,74
187
202 77,10
60 22,90
262
Editorial
94
Total
3.739
2.628 59,97 1.754 40,03 4.382 8.737 64,78 4.751 35,22 13.488
3.383 61,22 2.143 38,78 5.526 9.868 65,20 5.266 34,80 15.134
La distribución de hombres y mujeres en relación con los niveles de productividad (figura 1) muestra valores constantes en el número de autores que han
publicado entre 3 y 5 trabajos (60-62 % de hombres y 38-39 % de mujeres), obteniéndose el valor máximo en autoras con 6 trabajos, donde se equipara prácRev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 629
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 629
25/11/10 13:44
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
ticamente con los hombres. A medida que aumenta el número de trabajos, la
participación de la mujer va siendo más reducida, llegando únicamente a ser el
27,8 % las autoras con más de 10 trabajos.
FIGURA 1
Productividad de autores (porcentaje del número de autores
por hombres y mujeres)
100
Hombres
90
Mujeres
80
70,4%
70
61,1%
60,8%
Porcentaje
59,8%
▲
▲
▲
60
72,2%
▲
62,1%
▲
52,4%
▲
50
▲
59,4%
▲
60,9%
▲
47,6%
40
39,2%
38,9%
30
40,6%
40,2%
37,9%
39,1%
29,6%
27,8%
20
10
jos
ba
10
es
tor
Au
Au
tor
es
co
co
n>
n1
0
tra
ba
tra
tra
co
es
tor
Au
jos
jos
ba
jos
n9
tra
ba
jos
Au
tor
es
co
n8
tra
ba
jos
n7
co
es
tor
Au
Au
tor
es
co
n6
tra
ba
jos
ba
tra
n5
co
Au
tor
es
sc
re
to
Au
Au
tor
es
co
on
4
n3
tra
tra
ba
ba
jos
jo s
0
El análisis desagregado por sexos del orden o posición de las firmas, que se
recoge en la figura 2, pone de manifiesto que el mayor porcentaje de mujeres
firma en segundo lugar (40,42 %). No se observa un descenso de las mujeres
como firmantes en primer lugar (39,80 %), respecto al porcentaje de mujeres que
firman en segundo y tercer lugar; sin embargo, el porcentaje de mujeres sí se
reduce en relación con las últimas posiciones (24,29 % de mujeres que firman en
séptimo lugar y 29,30 % de mujeres como firmantes en octavo lugar). Si el análisis se centra en las posiciones más privilegiadas, primeros y últimos firmantes,
se aprecia en la tabla III, cómo las mujeres firman tan solo en un 20 % o aproximadamente en último lugar, verificando que las mujeres aún no están presentes
en la dirección de las obras, ya que estos puestos de directores o investigadores
principales de los grupos suelen estar copados por hombres.
630 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 630
25/11/10 13:44
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
FIGURA 2
Distribución porcentual de hombres y mujeres en relación con el orden
de autores (porcentaje del número de autores. por hombres y mujeres)
80
73,7%
69,3%
70
60,2%
59,6%
39,8%
40,4%
70,7%
75,7%
64,7%
61,9%
Porcentaje
60
50
40
38,1%
35,3%
30
24,3%
30,7%
20
Hombres
10
Mujeres
29,3%
26,3%
ar
7.º
l
8.
ºl
ug
ug
ar
ar
F ir
F ir
m
m
a
a
en
en
6.
ºl
en
a
m
F ir
F ir
F ir
m
m
a
a
en
en
5.
ºl
4.
ºl
ug
ug
ug
ar
ar
ar
3 . er
lug
en
a
m
F ir
F ir
F ir
m
m
a
a
en
en
2.
ºl
ug
1. er
lug
ar
ar
0
TABLA III
Distribución de hombres y mujeres primeros y últimos firmantes
(tipología documental)
Primeros firmantes
Tipología
documental
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
H
H
H
H
H
Art. original
232 155 272 174 260 168 298 227 353 270 1.415
M
M
M
M
Total
M
H
M
%H
%M
994 58,74 41,26
Carta
12
4
19
7
20
7
22
13
14
12
87
43 66,92 33,08
Editorial
10
2
8
3
14
2
16
6
11
8
59
21 73,75 26,25
Revisión
36
14
23
13
23
17
38
16
33
15
153
75 67,11 32,89
Total
290 175 322 197 317 194 374 262 411 305 1.714 1.133 60,20 39,80
Últimos firmantes
Art. original
342
99 358 105 341 103 428 131 500 156 1.969
594 76,82 23,18
Carta
12
1
18
7
20
4
31
7
23
3
104
22 82,54 17,46
Editori
12
1
9
3
15
1
13
6
14
6
63
17 78,75 21,25
Revisión
39
8
22
7
27
9
52
10
35
16
175
50 77,78 22,22
Total
405 109 407 122 403 117 524 154 572 181 2.311
683 77,19 22,81
Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 631
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 631
25/11/10 13:44
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
En la figura 3 se muestra la evolución diacrónica de los trabajos publicados
agrupados por tipología documental. Destaca de manera sobresaliente el incremento a lo largo de los años en la producción de artículos originales pasando
de 583 en 2003 a 739 en 2007.
FIGURA 3
Evolución anual del número de trabajos
800
739
700
663
611
600
599
583
Artículo original
Carta
500
Editorial
Revisión
100
63
0
72
51
52
24
31
31
16
13
19
24
2003
2004
2005
2006
40
57
29
22
2007
Los trabajos han sido publicados en un total de 1.049 revistas distintas. En la
tabla IV se presentan las revistas que publicaron al menos 20 trabajos durante el
período estudiado. Del total de revistas (1.049), 148 son españolas (14,10 %), y
sólo 18 de ellas tienen factor de impacto, pero es destacable que de las 24 revistas más productivas, 10 son españolas (41,66 %) y 3 de ellas tienen factor de
impacto (Medicina Clínica, Revista Española de Cardiología y Revista de Neurología). Si se analiza la participación respecto al número de mujeres, existen 5
revistas que tienen una proporción superior al 50 %, destacando Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health con un 58,21 %; Gaceta Sanitaria (56 %) y
Food Chemistry con un 54,55 % entre otras. Por su parte, respecto a la participación de mujeres atendiendo al número de firmas dicha proporción aumenta,
llegando en Food Chemistry hasta un 63,24 %.
También se ha analizado la colaboración científica de los autores, identificando todas las combinaciones de pares de autores existentes en cada uno de los
632 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 632
25/11/10 13:44
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
TABLA IV
Revistas de publicación de los trabajos
(con un mínimo de 20 documentos)
Autores
Firmas
FI
2007
H
M
%M
H
M
%M
Total
docu.
Gaceta Sanitaria
—
44
56
56,00
87
109
55,61
62
Medicina Clínica
1,337
84
60
41,67
133
80
37,56
62
Journal of Refractive Surgery
1,696
44
13
22,81
123
20
13,99
36
Journal of Cataract and Refractive
Surgery
2,497
34
17
33,33
104
24
18,75
35
Applied and Environmental Microbiology
4,004
45
48
51,61
65
68
51,13
33
Anales de Pediatría
—
28
24
46,15
44
32
42,11
32
Fertility and Sterility
3,168
32
31
49,21
101
43
29,86
32
European Journal of Neuroscience
3,673
56
35
38,46
77
41
34,75
30
Revista Española de Cardiología
2,207
76
17
18,28
198
25
11,21
30
Food Chemistry
3,052
20
24
54,55
25
43
63,24
26
International Journal of Food Microbiology
2,581
26
24
48,00
53
40
43,01
26
Human Reproduction
3,543
32
30
48,39
95
39
29,10
24
Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health
2,956
28
39
58,21
37
54
59,34
24
Medicina Oral, Patología Oral y Cirugía Bucal
—
19
12
38,71
37
16
30,19
24
Archivos de Bronconeumología
—
26
20
43,48
55
32
36,78
22
Neuroscience
3.352
36
19
34,55
54
22
28,95
22
FEBS Letters
3,263
39
25
39,06
48
27
36,00
21
Revista Española de Salud Pública
—
34
27
44,26
39
30
43,48
21
Atención Primaria
—
22
15
40,54
46
24
34,29
20
International Journal of Systematic
and Evolutionary Microbiology
2,384
25
24
48,98
45
51
53,13
20
Journal of Neuroscience
7,490
43
23
34,85
59
29
32,95
20
Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis
2,761
12
13
52,00
24
21
46,67
20
Revista de Neurología
0,736
28
12
30,00
37
19
33,93
20
Revista Rol de Enfermería
—
10
5
33,33
20
6
23,08
20
Nombre revista
Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 633
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 633
25/11/10 13:44
Redes de autores (>20 colaboradores)
FIGURA 4
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
634 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 634
25/11/10 13:44
Redes de autores (>30 colaboradores)
FIGURA 5
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 635
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 635
25/11/10 13:44
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
trabajos (coautorías) y obteniendo las agrupaciones de autores que firman habitualmente sus trabajos en colaboración (>10 autores vinculados entre sí). En la
figura 4 se representan 4 redes que agrupan entre 20 y 30 autores. Por otro lado,
existen 2 redes que agrupan a más de 30 autores (figura 5). Hay que resaltar que
las mujeres están presentes en todas las agrupaciones con al menos 6 autores y
en algunos casos su presencia llega a estar equiparada con la de los hombres.
En las redes inferiores con una colaboración de al menos 5 autores, existen casos
en los que el predominio de la mujer es completo.
4.
Discusión
Las universidades del Sistema Universitario Público Valenciano (SUPV) producen el 12,4 % del total de los artículos publicados en revistas científicas de las
universidades españolas y el 98 % de los publicados por las universidades de la
Comunitat Valenciana. La producción científica de las profesoras ha adquirido en
España a lo largo de las últimas décadas un peso aceptable, como se contempla
en los informes y estudios realizados sobre las mujeres en el seno de la Universidad (Ballarín y otros, 1995; Ortiz y otros, 1998; Ortiz y otros, 2000; Consejo de
Coordinación Universitaria, 2006-2007; CSIC, 2001, 2003, 2005, 2006, 2009), llegando a alcanzar en el conjunto de las universidades españolas, un 36,1 % de
participación de la mujer en las plantillas del profesorado, y tan sólo una tercera
parte (33,2 %) de la plantilla en las universidades públicas valencianas. Si se analizan las universidades valencianas individualmente, destaca la Universitat Jaume
I con un 38,4 % de mujeres y la Universitat de València con un 37,2 %, mientras
que en el lado contrario, aparece la Universidad Politécnica de Valencia con un
26,7 %. Si dicho análisis se centra en las profesoras universitarias en Ciencias de
la Salud es destacable el incremento que ha sufrido la Universitat de València a
lo largo de los años, pasando del 32 % en 2003 al 37 % en 2007 (Universitat de
Valéncia, 2007). Pero, esta presencia de la mujer en los ámbitos académico y
científico, es reducida en determinadas categorías profesionales, como es el caso
de las mujeres docentes que son catedráticas. A raíz de los datos anteriores, es
destacable que la Universidad Politécnica de Valencia, con el porcentaje más bajo
en cuanto a profesoras universitarias, destaca con un 10,2 % de catedráticas, frente al 8 % de la Universidad de Alicante, 7,2 % de la Universitat de València, o el
5,4 y 2,8 de las Universidades Miguel Hernández y Jaume I, respectivamente. De
hecho, la Universitat Politécnica de Valencia se sitúa en segundo lugar entre las
universidades españolas en cuanto a número de catedráticas, por detrás de la
Universidad de León (11,4 %) (Elizondo y otros, 2008). Para completar este apartado dedicado a las mujeres catedráticas hay que decir que no hay universidad
española, pública ni privada, que cumpla en alguna rama de la enseñanza con
el mínimo óptimo de presencia de mujeres establecido en un 25 % (Cobos, 2008).
Se observa como las categorías profesionales superiores, así como los cargos de alta
jerarquía y responsabilidad, normalmente son ocupadas por profesorado de ma-
636 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 636
25/11/10 13:44
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
yor edad y donde el colectivo femenino se encuentra realmente infrarrepresentado, mientras que conforme disminuye la edad va aumentando la representación
de la mujer, lo que lleva a pensar que con el paso del tiempo se pueda equiparar en el total del profesorado (Pérez y Pastor, 2009).
Como muestra, sirvan los datos de un estudio llevado a cabo en el CSIC para
analizar la actividad científica de su personal investigador durante el período
1996-2000, a través de indicadores bibliométricos y desde una perspectiva de
género (Bordons y otros, 2005). Los resultados permitieron observar signos de
segregación vertical, pues el porcentaje de mujeres descendía a medida que se
ascendía en la categoría profesional, desde el 38 % de mujeres en la categoría de
Científico/a Titular, al 29 % de los Investigadores/as Científicos/as y al 14 % de
los Profesores/as de Investigación. La proporción de mujeres entre el personal
investigador del CSIC era de un 32 % en el año 2002, cifra ligeramente inferior a
la descrita para el sector de la educación superior en España (36 %) y en la UE15 (34 %) y muy por encima de la descrita para el sector empresarial (19 % en
España y 15 % en la UE) en el año 2000. Este porcentaje de mujeres en el CSIC
variaba de forma importante según las disciplinas, alcanzando en Biología/Biomedicina el 30 %, es decir, una cifra muy próxima a la media, alejada del 20 %
del Área de Ciencia y Tecnologías Físicas (la que contaba con menor participación de mujeres) y del 44 % que tenía el área de Ciencia y Tecnología de Alimentos, en la que trabajaba un mayor número de investigadoras. Así mismo,
existían indicios de una promoción más lenta para las mujeres que para los hombres, de tal modo que con más de 30 años en la institución el 29 % de las mujeres son Profesoras de Investigación, frente a un 50 % de los hombres, siendo
similares los datos correspondientes a la categoría de Científico/a Titular.
Sin embargo, la evaluación de la situación de la mujer se encuentra con la
dificultad que supone la ausencia de datos fiables, accesibles, armonizados y
desglosados por género y niveles profesionales. Una forma de conocer la participación de la mujer en las actividades científicas es mediante la realización de
estudios bibliométricos desagregados por género (Bordons y otros, 2003, Mauleón
y Bordons, 2006a).
Algunos de los estudios realizados en áreas de conocimiento determinadas
han demostrado que no existe una igualdad entre hombres y mujeres en cuanto
a número de investigadores y trabajos publicados, diferencias que se acentúan
en relación con la mayor productividad de los autores (Aleixandre y otros, 2007a;
Aleixandre y otros, 2007b; Alonso y otros, 2008; González y otros, 2009); la disparidad de género también se aprecia en el orden de las firmas, donde las mujeres quedan relegadas a firmar en segunda, tercera y posiciones posteriores; otro
aspecto que se ha apreciado muestra la inexistencia, a nivel institucional, de una
paridad de género o el predominio de las mujeres en algunas instituciones. En
un estudio previo (González y otros, 2007), la Universidad Complutense de Madrid mostraba una igualdad entre el número de hombres y de mujeres, lo que
pone de manifiesto que en algunas instituciones existe paridad, mientras que lo
habitual es que predomine la desigualdad. La baja presencia de la mujer en las
Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 637
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 637
25/11/10 13:44
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
categorías profesionales más altas se puede deber a su posterior incorporación
en la ciencia. Sin embargo, para un mismo número de años en la institución, se
ha comprobado en la mayor parte de las áreas que la promoción de las mujeres
es más lenta que la de los hombres (Mauleón y Bordons, 2006a).
Al analizar la producción respecto a la tipología documental es comprensible que
la participación de la mujer en editoriales sea más baja, debido al predominio de
los hombres en la composición de los comités editoriales de las revistas científicas.
Aunque existen diferentes opiniones o teorías acerca del orden en el que los
autores aparecen firmando los trabajos o artículos de investigación, la más aceptada es aquella que da más responsabilidad a la primera y a la última firma,
siendo el primer firmante el autor principal del trabajo y el último el director o
investigador responsable del grupo (Guerrero-Bote y otros, 2009). Otra teoría
responde a que cuanto más baja es la categoría profesional, mayor tendencia a
firmar como primer autor, mientras que la tendencia a firmar como último aumenta con la categoría jerárquica, tanto en hombres como en mujeres (Mauleón
y Bordons, 2006b). Si se aplica a nuestros resultados se verifica en ambos supuestos que los puestos de dirección son ocupados predominantemente por hombres.
Respecto a los niveles de productividad de las mujeres, es importante destacar que el estudio analiza la productividad científica de todo el ámbito de las
Ciencias de la Salud y eso hace posible que este porcentaje sea muy superior al
de otros estudios que se centran en una disciplina concreta y donde el porcentaje de grandes productoras tiende a ser inferior a un 10 %.
Los datos muestran cómo con el paso del tiempo la mujer va adoptando posiciones más relevantes en cuanto a los cargos docentes y aunque está equiparada aún con el hombre en cuanto a productividad científica, sí va adquiriendo
un incremento paulatino que se refleja año a año y que, en algunas áreas temáticas como las Ciencias de la Salud, llega a ser significativo. Las diferencias entre
hombres y mujeres en la carrera investigadora discurren por varias vertientes. Por
un lado, se achacan a factores personales y socioculturales y a la incorporación
más tardía al mundo del trabajo, adquiriendo un papel crítico la influencia del
entorno familiar y dejando en un segundo plano su actividad investigadora (Ministerio de Sanidad y Consumo, 2009); y por otro lado, autoras como Wennerás
y Wold indican que las investigadoras estadounidenses, finlandesas y noruegas
con hijos son más productivas que las colegas que no los tienen (Wennerás y
Wold, 1997, 2000).
La presencia de las mujeres en la Universidad española es actualmente una
realidad aceptada y asumida por la sociedad como algo natural y positivo (Alberdi, 1996).
5.
Conclusiones
Se ha identificado un crecimiento de la producción científica de las universidades valencianas en Ciencias de la Salud en los 5 años de estudio, pasando de
686 en 2003 a 847 documentos en 2007, lo que supone un incremento en la
638 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 638
25/11/10 13:44
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
producción de un 19 %. La participación de las profesoras universitarias en estos
años ya se sitúa en torno al 40 %, presentando igualmente un aumento a lo largo
de los años, pues ha pasado de un 30,61 % en 2003 al 39,52 % en 2007. Este hecho ha supuesto una mayor participación de la mujer entre los niveles de productividad superiores respecto a años anteriores. Respecto a la colaboración
científica de los autores, es destacable cómo las redes compuestas por más de
20 autores en su mayoría son hombres, pero cuando estas redes van reduciéndose llegan a equipararse entre hombres y mujeres o incluso a tener un predominio de mujeres entre sus miembros. Entre las limitaciones hay que mencionar
que no se han tratado los resultados de producción científica desglosados de
cada una de las universidades de la Comunidad Valenciana por tratarse de un
estudio sobre un área temática tan amplia como las Ciencias de la Salud, y porque las universidades participantes no imparten las mismas carreras universitarias,
por lo que la aportación es muy variada, pudiendo obtener datos erróneos o
engañosos si se analizan individualmente.
Todos los aspectos recogidos en este estudio pueden ser aplicables a la práctica totalidad de áreas del conocimiento, y consideramos que, como se aprecia
en los resultados obtenidos, puede existir una preocupación por la presencia de
la mujer en el contexto científico y el rol que tiene que adquirir en la docencia
y en la investigación sin ningún tipo de discriminación y con el fin de alcanzar
una paridad entre hombres y mujeres desde los estamentos más bajos hasta las
categorías profesionales superiores.
6.
Bibliografía
Alberdi, I. (1996). El poder de las mujeres en las instituciones públicas. En Radl Philipp,
R. M., (editora), Mujeres e institución universitaria en Occidente: conocimiento, investigación y roles de género. Servicio de Publicaciones de la Universidad de Santiago de
Compostela.
Aleixandre Benavent, R.; Alonso Arroyo, A.; González Alcaide, G.; Gónzalez de Dios, J.;
Pérez Sempere, A., y Valderrama Zurián, J. C. (2007a). Análisis de género de los artículos publicados en «Revista de Neurología» durante el quinquenio 2002-2006. Revista de Neurología, vol. 45 (3), 137-143.
Aleixandre Benavent, R.; González Alcalde, G.; Alonso Arroyo, A.; Castellano Gómez, M.,
y Valderrama Zurián, J. C. (2007b).Valoración de la paridad en la autoría de los artículos publicados en la Revista Enfermedades Infecciosas y Microbiología Clínica
durante el quinquenio 2001-2005. Enfermedades Infecciosas y Microbiología Clínica,
vol. 25 (10), 619-626.
Alonso Arroyo, A.; González Alcaide, G.; Bolaños Pizarro, M.; Castelló Cogollos, L.; Valderrama Zurián, J. C., y Aleixandre Benavent, R. (2008). Análisis de género de los
trabajos publicados en la revista Actas Españolas de Psiquiatría (1999-2006). Actas
Españolas de Psiquiatría, vol. 36 (6), 314-322.
Arrizabalaga, P., y Valls Llobet, C. (2005). Mujeres médicas: de la incorporación a la discriminación. Medicina Clínica (Barcelona), vol. 125, 103-107.
Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 639
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 639
25/11/10 13:44
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
Ballarín, P.; Gallego, M. T., y Martínez, I. (1995). Los estudios de las mujeres en las universidades españolas. 1975-1991. Libro blanco. Madrid: Instituto de la Mujer.
Boletín Oficial del Estado (BOE) (2005) ORDEN de 7 de marzo, por la que se da publicidad
al Acuerdo de Consejo de Ministros por el que se adoptan medidas para favorecer la
igualdad entre mujeres y hombres. BOE nº 57, de 8 de marzo de 2005, 8111-8114.
Bordons, M.; Morillo, F.; Fernández, M. T., y Gómez, I. (2005). Incorporación de la dimensión de género a los estudios bibliométricos. Proyecto de Investigación financiado
por el Instituto de la Mujer. Estudios e investigaciones. Madrid; CSIC [consultado el 11
de noviembre de 2009]: Disponible en http://www.igualdad.us.es/pdf/incorporación %20de %20la %20dimension.pdf.
Bordons, M.; Morillo, F.; Fernández, M. T., y Gómez, I. (2003). One step further in the
production of bibliometric indicators at the micro level: Differences by gender and
professional category of scientists. Scientometrics, vol. 57, 159-173.
Cobos, M. (2008). La desigualdad de género persiste en las universidades españolas.
AmecoPress [consultado el 6-11-12]. Disponible en http://www.amecopress.net/spip.
php?article932.
Comisión de las Comunidades Europeas. (2008). La igualdad entre hombres y mujeres
2008. Informe de la Comisión al Consejo, al Parlamento Europeo, al Comité Económico y Social Europeo y al Comité de las Regiones [consultado el 3 de octubre de
2009]. Disponible en http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=COM:200
8:0010:FIN:ES:PDF.
Comisión de Mujeres y Ciencia del CSIC. (2007). Plan de igualdad de género en la carrera
científica de la agencia estatal CSIC (2007-2009). Madrid [consultado el 17 de septiembre de 2009]: Disponible en http://www.csic.es/documentos/mujerCiencia/Plan_
Igualdad_JG.pdf.
Consejo de Coordinación Universitaria. Informes y Estudios 2006-2007. Informe sobre el
profesorado funcionario de las Universidades públicas españolas [consultado el 17 de
septiembre de 2009]. Disponible en http://aplicaciones.mec.es/educa/jsp/plantilla.
jsp?area=ccuniv&id=267.
Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas. (2001, 2003, 2005, 2006, 2009). Mujeres
investigadoras del CSIC [consultado el 21 de septiembre de 2009]. Disponible en http://
www.csic.es/mujerCienciaInformes.do.
Elizondo, A.; Novo, A., y Silvestre, M. (2008). Indicadores de igualdad entre mujeres y
hombres en las Universidades Españolas [consultado el 12 de noviembre de 2009].
Disponible en http://www.unizar.es/economiafeminista/comunicaciones/area_5_ciencia_tecnologia/Elizondo_NOVO_SILVESTRE_comunicacion.pdf.
ETAN Expert Working Group of Women and Science (2000). Science policies in the European Union: Promoting excellence trough mainstreaming gender equality. European
Commission.
Fundación Española para la Ciencia y la Tecnología (FECYT) (2005). Mujer y Ciencia: la
situación de las mujeres investigadoras en el sistema español de ciencia y tecnología.
Madrid; Fundación Española para la Ciencia y la Tecnología [consultado el 25 de septiembre de 2009]. Disponible en http://www.fecyt.es/fecyt/docs/tmp/1649797961.pdf.
García de León, M. A. (1995). Élites discriminadas: sobre el poder de las mujeres. Barcelona: Antrophos, 81.
640 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 640
25/11/10 13:44
Análisis de género, productividad científica y colaboración de las profesoras universitarias...
González Alcaide, G.; Valderrama Zurián, J. C.; Aleixandre Benavent, R.; Alonso Arroyo,
A., y Miguel Dasit, A. (2007). Análisis de género de la producción científica española
sobre drogodependencias en biomedicina (1999-2004). Adicciones, vol. 19 (1), 45-50.
González Alcaide, G.; Alonso Arroyo, A.; Valderrama Zurián, J. C., y Aleixandre Benavent,
R. (2009). Mujeres en la investigación cardiológica española. Revista Española de Cardiología, 62 (8) 945-946.
Guerrero-Bote, V. P.; Gómez-Crisóstomo, R.; Romo Fernández, L., y Moya-Anegón, F.
(2009). Visibility and responsibility of women in research papers through the order
of signatures: the case of the University of Extremadura, 1990-2005. Scientometrics,
81 (1), 225-238.
Guil Bozal, A. (2005). Mujeres, Universidad y cambio social: tejiendo redes. I Jornadas de
Sociología. Centro de Estudios Andaluces. El cambio social en España. Visiones y retos
de futuro. Sevilla.
Martínez, I.; Pindado, R., y Vicente, J. (2003). Las mujeres y los estudios técnicos. XI Congreso Universitario de Innovación Educativa en las Enseñanzas Técnicas. R0254. Vilanova i la Geltrú [consultado el 20 de noviembre de 2009]. Disponible en http://
www.epsevg.upc.es/xic/cd/ponencias/R0254.pdf.
Mauleón, E., y Bordons, M. (2006a). Productivity, impact and publication habits by gender
in the area of Materials Science. Scientometrics, vol. 66, 199-218.
Mauleón, E., y Bordons, M. (2006b). Productividad e impacto de los investigadores del
CSIC desde una perspectiva de género. VI Congreso Iberoamericano de Ciencia, Tecnología y Género. 131-132. Zaragoza, España: Universidad de Zaragoza.
Ministerio de Sanidad y Consumo. Informes, Estudios e Investigación (2009). Informe,
Salud y Género 2007-2008: mujeres y hombres en las profesiones sanitarias [consultado el 29 de enero de 2010]. Disponible en http://www.msps.es/ciudadanos/proteccionSalud/mujeres/docs/informeSaludGenero2007_2008.pdf.
Ortíz Gómez, T.; Birriel Salcedo, J., y Marín Parra, V. (1998). Universidad y Feminismo en
España (I). Bibliografía de Estudios de las Mujeres (1992-1996). Granada; Universidad
de Granada.
Ortíz Gómez, T.; Birriel Salcedo, J., y Marín Parra, V. (2000). Universidad y feminismo en
España (II). Situación de los Estudios de las Mujeres en los años 90. Granada; Universidad de Granada.
Pérez, F., y Pastor, J. M. (2009). La contribución socioeconómica de las universidades públicas valencianas. Valencia; Instituto Valenciano de Investigaciones Económicas
(IVIE).
Torres Ramírez, I. Los recursos informativo-documentales para los Estudios de las Mujeres.
Panorámica breve desde Europa [consultado el 10 de octubre de 2009]. Disponible
en http://www.nodo50.org/mujeresred/isabel_de_torres.html#1.
Universitat de València (2007). La Universitat de València desde la perspectiva de género
2003-2007. Valencia; Servei d’Anàlisi i Planificació [SAP].
Wennerás, C., y Wold, A. (1997). Nepotism and sexism in peer-review. Nature, vol. 387,
341-343.
Wennerás, C., y Wold, A. (2000). A chair of one’s own. Nature, vol. 408, 647.
Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764 641
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 641
25/11/10 13:44
A. ALONSO -ARROYO, M. BOLAÑOS-PIZARRO, G. GONZÁLEZ-ALCAIDE, M. VILLAMÓN, R. ALEIXANDRE-BENAVENT
ANEXO
Ciencias de la Salud. Subject categories del JCR
ALLERGY
MICROSCOPY
ANATOMY & MORPHOLOGY
NEUROIMAGING
ANDROLOGY
NEUROSCIENCES
ANESTHESIOLOGY
NURSING
BIOTECHNOLOGY & APPLIED MICROBIOLOGY
NUTRITION & DIETETICS
CARDIAC & CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEMS
CELL BIOLOGY
CHEMISTRY, MEDICINAL
CLINICAL NEUROLOGY
CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE
DENTISTRY, ORAL SURGERY & MEDICINE
DERMATOLOGY
DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY
ENDOCRINOLOGY & METABOLISM
ENGINEERING, BIOMEDICAL
GASTROENTEROLOGY & HEPATOLOGY
GENETICS & HEREDITY
GERIATRICS & GERONTOLOGY
GERONTOLOGY
OBSTETRICS & GYNECOLOGY
ONCOLOGY
OPHTHALMOLOGY
ORTHOPEDICS
OTORHINOLARYNGOLOGY
PARASITOLOGY
PATHOLOGY
PEDIATRICS
PERIPHERAL VASCULAR DISEASE
PHARMACOLOGY & PHARMACY
PHYSIOLOGY
PSYCHIATRY
PUBLIC, ENVIRONMENTAL & OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH
HEALTH CARE SCIENCES & SERVICES
RADIOLOGY, NUCLEAR MEDICINE & MEDICAL IMAGING
HEALTH POLICY & SERVICES
REHABILITATION
HEMATOLOGY
REPRODUCTIVE BIOLOGY
IMMUNOLOGY
RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
INFECTIOUS DISEASES
RHEUMATOLOGY
INTEGRATIVE & COMPLEMENTARY MEDICINE
SOCIAL SCIENCES, BIOMEDICAL
MEDICAL ETHICS
SUBSTANCE ABUSE
MEDICAL INFORMATICS
SURGERY
MEDICAL LABORATORY TECHNOLOGY
TOXICOLOGY
MEDICINE, GENERAL & INTERNAL
TRANSPLANTATION
MEDICINE, LEGAL
TROPICAL MEDICINE
MEDICINE, RESEARCH & EXPERIMENTAL
UROLOGY & NEPHROLOGY
MICROBIOLOGY
VIROLOGY
642 Rev. Esp. Doc. Cient., 33, 4, octubre-diciembre, 624-642, 2010. ISSN: 0210-0614. doi:10.3989/redc.2010.4.764
05_Rev_33_4_764.indd 642
25/11/10 13:44
|
|
https://openalex.org/W4311574565
|
https://bmcwomenshealth.biomedcentral.com/counter/pdf/10.1186/s12905-022-02089-y
|
English
| null |
Value of endometrial thickness for the detection of endometrial cancer and atypical hyperplasia in asymptomatic postmenopausal women
|
BMC women's health
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 5,486
|
Abstract Conclusion: An ET cut-off of ≥ 8 mm shows a reasonable performance to detect AH and EC in asymptomatic post-
menopausal women, thereby avoiding more invasive endometrial biopsy. Keywords: Asymptomatic, Endometrial carcinoma, Postmenopausal, Ultrasonography © The Author(s) 2022. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which
permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the
original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or
other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line
to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory
regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this
licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativeco
mmons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Abstract Background: The role of transvaginal sonography (TVS) in screening endometrial cancer and hyperplasia is signifi-
cant in postmenopausal women. The objective of this study is to determine the endometrium thickness (ET) cut-off
to distinguish premalignancy and malignancy in asymptomatic postmenopausal women. Methods: We retrospectively evaluated data of 968 eligible patients among 2537 asymptomatic postmenopausal
women with ET ≥ 5 mm examined by TVS who were subjected to hysteroscopy and endometrial biopsy between
January 1, 2017, and June 30, 2020 in an urban tertiary specialized hospital in China. The patients were divided into
two groups according to the pathology outcomes: benign, and atypical hyperplasia (AH) and endometrial carcinoma
(EC). The risk factors and the optimal cut-off of ET for detecting AH and EC were determined by logistic regression
analysis and receiver operating characteristic curve. Results: 2537 patients were offered hysteroscopy during a 42-month period. Finally, 968 patients were included for
further analysis. Of these, 8 (0.8%) women were diagnosed with EC and 5 (0.5%) women with AH. The mean ET of AH
and EC group was substantially higher than that in benign group (10.4 mm vs. 7.7 mm, P < 0.05). ET was significantly
correlated with AH and EC shown by logistic regression analysis with an odds ratio (OR) of 1.252 (95% confidence
interval [CI] 1.107–1.416, P < 0.001). The optimal cut-off value for AH and EC was found to be 8 mm with the maximum
AUC of 0.715 (95% CI 0.686–0.743, P < 0.001), with a sensitivity of 0.846, a specificity of 0.609, positive likelihood ratio
(LR+) of 2.164 and negative likelihood ratio (LR−) of 0.253. Results: 2537 patients were offered hysteroscopy during a 42-month period. Finally, 968 patients were included for
further analysis. Of these, 8 (0.8%) women were diagnosed with EC and 5 (0.5%) women with AH. The mean ET of AH
and EC group was substantially higher than that in benign group (10.4 mm vs. 7.7 mm, P < 0.05). ET was significantly
correlated with AH and EC shown by logistic regression analysis with an odds ratio (OR) of 1.252 (95% confidence
interval [CI] 1.107–1.416, P < 0.001). The optimal cut-off value for AH and EC was found to be 8 mm with the maximum
AUC of 0.715 (95% CI 0.686–0.743, P < 0.001), with a sensitivity of 0.846, a specificity of 0.609, positive likelihood ratio
(LR+) of 2.164 and negative likelihood ratio (LR−) of 0.253. Value of endometrial thickness
for the detection of endometrial cancer
and atypical hyperplasia in asymptomatic
postmenopausal women Linna Zhang1,2,3†, Ying Guo1,2,3†, Guxia Qian4, Tao Su1,2,3* and Hong Xu1,2,3* Introduction Endometrial carcinoma (EC) is the most common
gynecologic cancer in the developed countries with
steadily increasing incidence [1, 2]. Although 90% cases
with EC present with postmenopausal bleeding [3], 15%
cases of EC occur in women without vaginal bleeding [4]. The EC or atypical hyperplasia (AH) rate was reported to
be 0.62% to 0.59% among asymptomatic postmenopausal †Linna Zhang and Ying Guo contributed equally to this work
*Correspondence: sutaodoctor@126.com; xuhong1558@sjtu.edu.c 1 The International Peace Maternity and Child Health Hospital, School
of Medicine, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200030, China
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-022-02089-y Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-022-02089-y © The Author(s) 2022. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which
permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the
original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or
other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line
to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory
regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this
licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativeco
mmons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data. Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517 Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517 Page 2 of 6 Exclusion criteria was as follows: (1) breast cancer
patients with unknown information of tamoxifen treat-
ment by reviewing the medical records were excluded;
(2) patients with uterine malformation and those who
were diagnosed with more than one malignancy were
not included. women [5]. Given the fact that the five-year survival for
patients with localized EC is 90%, detection of EC is quite
pivotal for patients at early stage. American College of
Obsetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) guidelines sup-
port the transvaginal sonography (TVS) endometrial
threshold of more than 4 mm to screen EC in women
with postmenopausal bleeding [6]. Among the 2537 patients to whom the hysteros-
copy was offered during the period, 1464 patients hav-
ing symptoms were excluded. 101 patients with breast
cancer were excluded for the absence of information
of tamoxifen therapy in the medical records. Patients
diagnosed with uterus duplex (n = 2) and ovarian can-
cer (n = 2) were not included. Finally, 968 patients were
available for further analysis (Fig. 1).h TVS is performed in postmenopausal women due to
a variety of indications such as pelvic pain, pelvic mass,
and physical examination [7, 8]. Patients and study design A total of 2537 patients were provided with inpatient
hysteroscopy between January 1, 2017, and June 30, 2020
in International Peace Maternity and Child Health Hos-
pital (IPMCH), an urban tertiary specialized hospital in
Shanghai, China. All medical records of these patients
were reviewed. Patients who were eligible for both the
inclusion criteria and exclusion criteria were included for
the study. However, it remains
controversial that how to manage an incidental finding
of thickened endometrium in asymptomatic postmeno-
pausal women [3, 4, 9–11], consequently leading to a
large number of invasive biopsies. Using an endometrial
thickness (ET) cut-off value ≥ 4 mm, a prospective study
indicated that only 3% of hysteroscopies were useful in
the diagnosis of endometrial pre-malignant or malignant
lesions [11]. In addition, the hysteroscopy and endome-
trial sampling could result in surgical risks including
uterine perforation and bowel injury, patient anxiety as
well as significant healthcare costs [3, 8, 12–14]. A previ-
ous study revealed 80% of the women undergoing hyster-
oscopy had a moderate to severe anxiety state [13]. The
average cost of hysteroscopy and dilatation and curet-
tage (D&C) turned out to be $2614 in Australia [14]. Therefore, the ET cut-off for identifying AH and EC in
asymptomatic postmenopausal women warrants to be
standardized. The endometrium of all these women was investigated
by TVS in our hospital by two certified radiologists
for routine physical examination using a transvagi-
nal probe (GE Voluson scanner, E8, GE-Healthcare,
Waukesha, WI, USA). The double wall ET was meas-
ured in the longitudinal plane at its thickest point. Hys-
teroscopies were conducted under total intravenous
anesthesia. All the hysteroscopist were experienced
with appropriate skill set. Endometrial biopsies were
immediately immersed in 10% formaldehyde and sent
to a pathology laboratory. The histopathological results
were estimated by two pathologists. Data were collected for all the eligible patients including
age, body mass index (BMI), gravidity, parity, hypertension,
diabetes, the image findings, histopathology results and out-
come of all patients. All the 13 patients with premalignancy
and malignancy were followed up until July 2022. All the
procedures performed in studies involving human partici-
pants were in accordance with the ethical standards of Ethics
Committee of IPMCH in Shanghai and with the 1964 Hel-
sinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable
ethical standards. The publication of this study has the per-
mission of the patients. In the current study, we sought to review our present
practice and determine the ET threshold as well as the
risk of EC and AH in asymptomatic postmenopausal
women with ET ≥ 5 mm. Statistical analysis The
Table 1 Pathologic outcomes in 968 menopausal asymptomatic
postmenopausal women with a thickened endometrium ≥ 5 mm
Pathologic outcomes
n (%)
Benign endometrium
955 (98.7)
Endometrial polyps
696 (71.9)
Hyperplasia
26 (2.7)
Leiomyoma
32 (3.3)
Atrophic endometrium
123 (12.7)
Endometritis
27 (2.8)
Normal endometrium
51 (5.3)
Atypical hyperplasia
5 (0.5)
Endometrial carcinoma
8 (0.8)
Table 2 Demographic and clinical characteristics of patients
with different pathologic outcomes
Group A
(n = 955)
Group B
(n = 13)
P
Age, yr, mean ± SD
61 ± 6.5
63 ± 6.4
0.237
BMI, kg/m2, mean ± SD
24.1 ± 3.37
24.2 ± 3.34
0.928
Gravity, mean ± SD
2 ± 1.2
3 ± 1.2
0.175
Parity, mean ± SD
1 ± 0.6
1 ± 0.6
0.805
Duration of menopause, yr, mean ± SD
9 ± 6.4
12 ± 9.0
0.222
Hypertension, n (%)
373 (39%)
4 (31%)
0.543
Diabetes, n (%)
76 (8%)
2 (15%)
0.643
History of cancer, n (%)
23 (2%)
1 (8%)
0.326
Family history of cancer, n (%)
17 (2%)
0 (0%)
1.000
Endometrial thickness, mm, mean ± SD
7.7 ± 2.50
10.4 ± 4.50
0.047 Table 1 Pathologic outcomes in 968 menopausal asymptomatic
postmenopausal women with a thickened endometrium ≥ 5 mm Table 2 Demographic and clinical characteristics of patients
with different pathologic outcomes Table 2 Demographic and clinical characteristics of patients
with different pathologic outcomes Table 2 Demographic and clinical characteristics of patients
with different pathologic outcomes Table 2 Demographic and clinical characteristics of patients
with different pathologic outcomes
Group A
(n = 955)
Group B
(n = 13)
P
Age, yr, mean ± SD
61 ± 6.5
63 ± 6.4
0.237
BMI, kg/m2, mean ± SD
24.1 ± 3.37
24.2 ± 3.34
0.928
Gravity, mean ± SD
2 ± 1.2
3 ± 1.2
0.175
Parity, mean ± SD
1 ± 0.6
1 ± 0.6
0.805
Duration of menopause, yr, mean ± SD
9 ± 6.4
12 ± 9.0
0.222
Hypertension, n (%)
373 (39%)
4 (31%)
0.543
Diabetes, n (%)
76 (8%)
2 (15%)
0.643
History of cancer, n (%)
23 (2%)
1 (8%)
0.326
Family history of cancer, n (%)
17 (2%)
0 (0%)
1.000
Endometrial thickness, mm, mean ± SD
7.7 ± 2.50
10.4 ± 4.50
0.047 postmenopausal women with a thickened endometrium ≥ 5 mm
Pathologic outcomes
n (%)
Benign endometrium
955 (98.7)
Endometrial polyps
696 (71.9)
Hyperplasia
26 (2.7)
Leiomyoma
32 (3.3)
Atrophic endometrium
123 (12.7)
Endometritis
27 (2.8)
Normal endometrium
51 (5.3)
Atypical hyperplasia
5 (0.5)
Endometrial carcinoma
8 (0.8) Statistical analysis 1 Flow diagram of the study
Table 1 Pathologic outcomes in 968 menopausal asymptomatic
postmenopausal women with a thickened endometrium ≥ 5 mm
Pathologic outcomes
n (%)
Benign endometrium
955 (98.7)
Endometrial polyps
696 (71.9)
Hyperplasia
26 (2.7)
Leiomyoma
32 (3.3)
Atrophic endometrium
123 (12.7)
Endometritis
27 (2.8)
Normal endometrium
51 (5.3)
Atypical hyperplasia
5 (0.5)
Endometrial carcinoma
8 (0.8)
Table 2 Demographic and clinical characteristics of patients
with different pathologic outcomes
Group A
(n = 955)
Group B
(n = 13)
P
Age, yr, mean ± SD
61 ± 6.5
63 ± 6.4
0.237
BMI, kg/m2, mean ± SD
24.1 ± 3.37
24.2 ± 3.34
0.928
Gravity, mean ± SD
2 ± 1.2
3 ± 1.2
0.175
Parity, mean ± SD
1 ± 0.6
1 ± 0.6
0.805
Duration of menopause, yr, mean ± SD
9 ± 6.4
12 ± 9.0
0.222
Hypertension, n (%)
373 (39%)
4 (31%)
0.543
Diabetes, n (%)
76 (8%)
2 (15%)
0.643
History of cancer, n (%)
23 (2%)
1 (8%)
0.326
Family history of cancer, n (%)
17 (2%)
0 (0%)
1.000
Endometrial thickness, mm, mean ± SD
7.7 ± 2.50
10.4 ± 4.50
0.047 Fig. 1 Flow diagram of the study Fig. 1 Flow diagram of the study Fig. 1 Flow diagram of the study Results
TVS showed an ET ≥ 5 mm for all the included patients
(n = 968). Pathologic outcomes of biopsy of the endo-
metrium were listed in Table 1. Among the 955 patients
with benign results, 696 (71.9%) were reported as endo-
metrial polyps, 26 (2.7%) as hyperplasia, 32 (3.3%) as leio-
myoma, 123 (12.7%) as atrophic endometrium, 27 (2.8%)
as endometritis and 51 (5.3%) as normal endometrium. 5
(0.5%) cases had AH, and 8 (0.8%) were found to be EC. Table 2 shows the demographic and clinical char-
acteristics of patients. Patients were divided into 2
groups according to the pathologic outcomes (Group
A, benign endometrium; Group B, AH and EC). Statistical analysis Continuous and nonparametric variables were analyzed
using t-test and chi-squared test respectively. Logistic
regression analysis was performed to determine risk
factors for AH and EC. The optimal cut-off value of ET
for AH and EC was determined by receiver operating
characteristic (ROC) curve analysis by area under curve
(AUC). Statistical analysis were performed with SPSS
version 23.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). A P value
of < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. We enrolled patients with the following inclusion cri-
teria: (1) amenorrhoea for at least 12 months; (2) the
indication of hysteroscopy was ET ≥ 5 mm which was
incidentally found by TVS; (3) the ET must be evaluated
by TVS in the same hospital, namely IPMCH; (4) patients
had no obvious adnexal mass to eliminate the impact of
hormone-secreting tumors on the endometrium; and (5)
patients had no vaginal bleeding, no vaginal discharge,
and no pelvic pain. Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517 Page 3 of 6 Results
TVS showed an ET ≥ 5 mm for all the included patients
(n = 968). Pathologic outcomes of biopsy of the endo-
metrium were listed in Table 1. Among the 955 patients
with benign results, 696 (71.9%) were reported as endo-
metrial polyps, 26 (2.7%) as hyperplasia, 32 (3.3%) as leio-
myoma, 123 (12.7%) as atrophic endometrium, 27 (2.8%)
as endometritis and 51 (5.3%) as normal endometrium. 5
(0.5%) cases had AH, and 8 (0.8%) were found to be EC. Table 2 shows the demographic and clinical char-
acteristics of patients. Patients were divided into 2
groups according to the pathologic outcomes (Group
A, benign endometrium; Group B, AH and EC). The
Fig. Results as endometritis and 51 (5.3%) as normal endometrium. 5
(0.5%) cases had AH, and 8 (0.8%) were found to be EC. Table 2 shows the demographic and clinical char-
acteristics of patients. Patients were divided into 2
groups according to the pathologic outcomes (Group
A, benign endometrium; Group B, AH and EC). The as endometritis and 51 (5.3%) as normal endometrium. 5
(0.5%) cases had AH, and 8 (0.8%) were found to be EC. as endometritis and 51 (5.3%) as normal endometrium. 5
(0.5%) cases had AH, and 8 (0.8%) were found to be EC. as endometritis and 51 (5.3%) as normal endometrium. 5
(0.5%) cases had AH, and 8 (0.8%) were found to be EC. TVS showed an ET ≥ 5 mm for all the included patients
(n = 968). Pathologic outcomes of biopsy of the endo-
metrium were listed in Table 1. Among the 955 patients
with benign results, 696 (71.9%) were reported as endo-
metrial polyps, 26 (2.7%) as hyperplasia, 32 (3.3%) as leio-
myoma, 123 (12.7%) as atrophic endometrium, 27 (2.8%) Table 2 shows the demographic and clinical char-
acteristics of patients. Patients were divided into 2
groups according to the pathologic outcomes (Group
A, benign endometrium; Group B, AH and EC). The Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517 Page 4 of 6 Table 3 Comparison of diagnostic value of endometrial
thickness with different cut-off value in endometrial lesions Table 3 Comparison of diagnostic value of endometrial
thickness with different cut-off value in endometrial lesions age of the patients varied from 46 to 87 years. The mean
age in Group A was 61 years and in Group B it was 63
(P = 0.237). There was no significant difference between
the BMI of the two groups (24.1 ± 3.37 vs. 24.2 ± 3.34,
P = 0.928). Compared to Group A, it was comparable as
with the other risk factors including gravity, parity, dura-
tion of menopause, hypertension, diabetes, history of
cancer and family history of cancer in Group B. How-
ever, a significant difference was observed in the ET
between Group A and Group B (7.7 ± 2.50 vs. 10.4 ± 4.50,
P = 0.047). No complication was reported for all the
included patients. Results Cut-off
(mm)
Sensitivity
(% (95% CI))
Specificity
(% (95% CI))
LR +
(% (95% CI))
LR-
(% (95% CI))
≧ 7.0
84.6
(57.8–95.7)
43.5
(40.3–46.6)
1.50
(0.97–1.79)
0.35 (0.09–0.44)
≧ 8.0
84.6
(57.8–95.7)
60.9
(57.8–64.0)
2.16
(1.37–2.66)
0.25 (0.07–0.44)
≧ 9.0
53.8
(29.1–76.8)
74.8
(71.9–77.4)
2.13
(1.05–3.40)
0.62 (0.30–0.92)
≧ 10.0
46.2
(23.2–70.9)
82.0
(79.4–84.3)
2.57
(1.13–4.52)
0.66 (0.35–1.08)
≧ 11.0
38.5
(17.7–64.5)
88.1
(85.9–90.0)
3.24
(1.26–6.45)
0.70 (0.39–1.28)
≧ 12.0
38.5
(17.7–64.5)
91.6
(89.7–93.2)
4.58
(1.72–9.49)
0.67 (0.38–1.28) Logistic regression analysis showed that the ET was the
risk factor for the AH and EC in asymptomatic postmen-
opausal women. The odds ratio (OR) for ET was 1.252
(95% confidence interval [CI] 1.107–1.416, P < 0.001). The diagnostic performance of ET was further analyzed
by ROC curve analysis (Fig. 2). The optimal cut-off value
for AH and EC was found to be 8 mm with the maxi-
mum AUC (0.715, 95% CI 0.686–0.743), with a sensitiv-
ity of 0.846, a specificity of 0.609, positive likelihood ratio
(LR +) of 2.164 and negative likelihood ratio (LR−) of
0.253. The diagnostic value of ET with different cut-off
value in endometrial lesions was compared in Table 3. available for all the 13 patients with AH and EC. With a
follow-up period of between 2 and 5 years, one case of
EC aging 70 years at stage IA (G2) exhibited recurrence
and died 2 years after the staging surgery. The other 12
patients were alive without recurrence until July 2022. Discussionh It remains
unknown what effects the threshold would pose on the
outcomes of these patients. findings cannot be extrapolated to the whole popula-
tion of asymptomatic postmenopausal women. Although
it was revealed that there was no significant associa-
tion between endometrial cancer and postmenopausal
hormone usage [11, 15], the use of hormone therapy is
necessary to be considered. Third, all the patients with
benign conditions were not followed up. It remains
unknown what effects the threshold would pose on the
outcomes of these patients. cases were at stage I in postmenopausal women with
no symptoms [3, 21, 26]. It was reported that there was
no significant difference in rates of high-grade histology
between asymptomatic women and women with abnor-
mal uterine bleeding [26]. However, whether the survival
rate benefits from the detection of EC in asymptomatic
postmenopausal women compared to that in sympto-
matic postmenopausal women remains to be investi-
gated. A further study including all the EC patients will
provide more detailed information for pathological out-
comes and survival rates.h p
EC ranks fourth in female cancers, the management
of which is of great concern. The surgical complications
were reported especially in patients treated with lapa-
rotomy [15–17]. Given the fact that patients with late
stage were more frequently subject to laparotomy, early
identification of EC is quite important. The current study
indicates that an incidentally-found ET of more than
8 mm in asymptomatic postmenopausal women might be
recommended for further endometrial biopsy. Although
different ET cut-off values had been investigated by vari-
ous groups, there is no consensus as with the recom-
mended ET to distinguish abnormal endometrium in
postmenopausal woman without vaginal bleeding. The
identified thresholds ranged 8–15 mm to distinguish EC
or AH in asymptomatic women [3, 11, 18, 19]. Hysteros-
copy was recommended to perform at a measurement of
ET ≥ 8 mm in asymptomatic postmenopausal women in
a study in Italy [11], while the threshold of 10 mm was
suggested by several studies [3, 9, 18, 20]. The ET of
11 mm was identified as the optimal diagnostic thresh-
old for atypical endometrium and malignancies [3, 4, 21,
22].Of note, the reported cut-offs were mostly based on
AUC ROC method, which could be different from the
ideal threshold when all the risk factors and patient out-
comes are prospectively considered. Availability of data and materials The data analyzed during the study is available from the corresponding author
upon reasonable request. Funding This work was supported by the National Key Research and Development
Program of China (NO. 2020YFC2002804), the National Natural Science
Foundation of China (NO. 82071622, 81771551 and 82001622), and Shanghai
Sailing Program (20YF1453700). Discussionh Thus, prospective
study with more samples will provide a more favorable
threshold and diagnostic model for asymptomatic post-
menopausal women in the future. This study has practice implications for clinicians to
help provide with a threshold for management of asymp-
tomatic postmenopausal women with endometrial thick-
ening. However, the findings require confirmation in
future clinical trials. The prospective study underlying
the potential cut-off for endometrial premalignancy and
malignancy desiderates to be further investigated and
will shed light on the management of asymptomatic post-
menopausal women with thickened endometrium. Conclusionh The mean ET of women with AH and EC is higher than
that of patients with benign endometrium. An ET cut-
off of ≥ 8 mm shows a reasonable performance to detect
AH and EC in asymptomatic postmenopausal women,
thereby avoiding more invasive endometrial biopsy. Author contributions LNZ: data collection, data analysis, YG: data analysis, manuscript writing, GXQ:
data collection, TS and HX: supervision, manuscript editing. All authors read
and approved the final manuscript. The present study also provides evidence for the fact
that the incidence of malignancies or premalignancy is
minimal in asymptomatic postmenopausal women. The
prevalence of AH and/or EC was reported to be 0.62–
9.9% [3, 5, 7, 10, 22–24]. As the endometrial condition is
not routinely screened among asymptomatic women, the
prevalence of EC and AH is difficult to estimate in this
population. Thus, whether screening EC and AH is nec-
essary warrants further investigation among postmeno-
pausal women without symptoms. Many studies reported
a significant association between EC and obesity [17, 25]. However, the benign and EC and AH groups showed no
difference as with the BMI in our study, which may result
from the small sample size in EC and AH group. Our
study and previous studies consistently found that most Discussionh Amongst women with the diagnosis of AH, 4 under-
went hysterectomy, with one for observation. All 8
women with EC underwent staging surgery, with 3 at
stage IA (grade 1, G1), 2 at stage IA (G2), 1 at stage IA
(G3), 1 at stage IB and 1 at stage II (Fig. 3). 75% cases
were found to be at stage IA. Follow-up information was The current retrospective study included 968 eligible
cases and revealed that ET was the risk factor for the
endometrial premalignancy and malignancy in asympto-
matic postmenopausal women. The 8-mm ET was iden-
tified as the optimal threshold to detect AH and EC in
asymptomatic postmenopausal women. The strength of this study is that a large number of
patients were included. But there are several limitations
to our study. First, the analysis was limited due to the
low prevalence of endometrial AH and EC as well as the
retrospective property, which could result in bias. Sec-
ond, it is a drawback that our analysis has not included
the risk factors such as the use of hormone therapy and
tamoxifen due to incomplete medical records, so the h
patients were included. But there are several limitations
to our study. First, the analysis was limited due to the
low prevalence of endometrial AH and EC as well as the
retrospective property, which could result in bias. Sec-
ond, it is a drawback that our analysis has not included
the risk factors such as the use of hormone therapy and
tamoxifen due to incomplete medical records, so the
Fig. 2 Effects of endometrial thickness detected using TVS in
predicting the results of endometrial sampling
Fig. 3 Distribution of pathologic outcomes among EC patients Fig. 3 Distribution of pathologic outcomes among EC patients Fig. 3 Distribution of pathologic outcomes among EC patients Fig. 2 Effects of endometrial thickness detected using TVS in
predicting the results of endometrial sampling Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517 Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517 Page 5 of 6 findings cannot be extrapolated to the whole popula-
tion of asymptomatic postmenopausal women. Although
it was revealed that there was no significant associa-
tion between endometrial cancer and postmenopausal
hormone usage [11, 15], the use of hormone therapy is
necessary to be considered. Third, all the patients with
benign conditions were not followed up. Abbreviations EC: Endometrial carcinoma; AH: Atypical hyperplasia; ET: Endometrial thick-
ness; TVS: Transvaginal sonography; AUC: Area under the curve; ROC: Receiver
operating characteristic; OR: Odds ratio; CI: Confidence interval; LR+: Positive
likelihood ratio; LR−: Negative likelihood ratio; BMI: Body mass index. Received: 30 August 2022 Accepted: 21 November 2022 20. Ai F, Wang Y, Wang Y, Wang J, Zhou L, Wang S. Clinicopathological features
of endometrial lesions in asymptomatic postmenopausal women with
thickened endometrium. Menopause. 2022;29(8):952–6. Competing interests 17. Di Donato V, D’Oria O, Giannini A, Bogani G, Fischetti M, Santangelo G,
et al. Age-adjusted charlson comorbidity index predicts survival in endo-
metrial cancer patients. Gynecol Obstet Invest. 2022;87(3–4):191–9. References 21. Li Z, Li L. Risk of malignancies among asymptomatic postmenopausal
women with thickened endometrium: a cohort study. Medicine (Balti-
more). 2019;98(6):e14464. 1. Siegal R, Miller KD, Jemal A. Cancer statistics, 2014. CA Cancer J Clin. 2014;64(1):9–29. 22. Alcázar JL, Bonilla L, Marucco J, Padilla AI, Chacón E, et al. Risk of endo-
metrial cancer and endometrial hyperplasia with atypia in asymptomatic
postmenopausal women with endometrial thickness≥ 11 mm: a system-
atic review and meta-analysis. J Clin Ultrasound. 2018;46(9):565–70. 2. Arnold M, Jiang L, Stefanick ML, Johnson KC, Lane DS, LeBlanc ES, et al. Duration of adulthood overweight, obesity, and cancer risk in the
women’s health initiative: a longitudinal study from the United States. PLoS Med. 2016;13(8):e1002081. 23. Lee SC, Kaunitz AM, Sanchez-Ramos L, Rhatigan RM. The oncogenic
potential of endometrial polyps: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Obstet Gynecol. 2010;116(5):1197–205. 3. Li JX, Chan F, Johansson C. Can a higher endometrial thickness threshold
exclude endometrial cancer and atypical hyperplasia in asymptomatic
postmenopausal women? A systematic review. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynae-
col. 2022;62(2):190–7. 24. Archer DF, McIntyre-Seltman K, Wilborn WW, Dowling EA, Cone F, Creasy
GW, et al. Endometrial morphology in asymptomatic postmenopausal
women. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1991;165(2):317–20. 4. Smith-Bindman R, Weiss E, Feldstein V. How thick is too thick? When
endometrial thickness should prompt biopsy in postmenopausal women
without vaginal bleeding. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2004;24(5):558–65. 4. Smith-Bindman R, Weiss E, Feldstein V. How thick is too thick? When
endometrial thickness should prompt biopsy in postmenopausal women
without vaginal bleeding. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2004;24(5):558–65. 25. Liu F, Cheung ECW, Lao TT. Obesity increases endometrial cancer
risk in Chinese women with postmenopausal bleeding. Menopause. 2021;28(10):1093–8. 5. Breijer M, Peeters J, Opmeer B, Clark TJ, Verheijen R, Mol B, et al. Capacity
of endometrial thickness measurement to diagnose endometrial carci-
noma in asymptomatic postmenopausal women: a systematic review
and meta-analysis. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2012;40(6):621–9. 5. Breijer M, Peeters J, Opmeer B, Clark TJ, Verheijen R, Mol B, et al. Capacity
of endometrial thickness measurement to diagnose endometrial carci-
noma in asymptomatic postmenopausal women: a systematic review
and meta-analysis. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2012;40(6):621–9. 26. Segev Y, Dain-Sagi L, Lavie O, Sagi S, Gemer O. Is there a survival advan-
tage in diagnosing endometrial cancer in asymptomatic patients? A sys-
temic review and meta-analysis. J Obstet Gynaecol Can. 2020;42(4):481–7 6. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists Committee on
Gynecologic Practice. Consent for publication
Not applicable. treatment for endometrial cancer: the role of the fragility index. Int J
Gynaecol Obstet. 2020;148(2):174–80. treatment for endometrial cancer: the role of the fragility index. Int J
Gynaecol Obstet. 2020;148(2):174–80. y
16. Buzzaccarini G, Torok P, Vitagliano A, Petousis S, Noventa M, et al. Predic-
tors of pain development after laparoscopic adnexectomy: a still open
challenge. J Invest Surg. 2022;35(6):1392–3. References ACOG committee opinion. No. 336: tamoxifen and
uterine cancer. Obstet Gynecol. 2006;107(6):1475–8. Author details 1 The International Peace Maternity and Child Health Hospital, School of Medi-
cine, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200030, China. 2 Shanghai Key
Laboratory of Embryo Original Diseases, Shanghai 200030, China. 3 Shanghai
Municipal Key Clinical Speciality, Shanghai 200030, China. 4 Putuo District
Maternity and Child Care Center, Shanghai 200062, China. 18. Aggarwal A, Hatti A, Tirumuru SS, Nair SS. Management of asymptomatic
postmenopausal women referred to outpatient hysteroscopy service
with incidental finding of thickened endometrium–a UK district general
hospital experience. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2021;28(10):1725–9. 19. Louie M, Canavan TP, Mansuria S. Threshold for endometrial sampling
among postmenopausal patients without vaginal bleeding. Int J Gynae-
col Obstet. 2016;132(3):314–7. Received: 30 August 2022 Accepted: 21 November 2022 Received: 30 August 2022 Accepted: 21 November 2022 Ethical approval and consent to participate This study was performed in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and
approved by Ethic Committee of the International Peace Maternity and Child
Health Hospital in Shanghai. All the patients signed the informed consent. Page 6 of 6 Zhang et al. BMC Women’s Health (2022) 22:517 Publisher’s Note
S y
7. Famuyide AO, Breitkopf DM, Hopkins MR, Laughlin-Tommaso SK. Asymptomatic thickened endometrium in postmenopausal women:
malignancy risk. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2014;21(5):782–6. y
7. Famuyide AO, Breitkopf DM, Hopkins MR, Laughlin-Tommaso SK. Asymptomatic thickened endometrium in postmenopausal women:
malignancy risk. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2014;21(5):782–6. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in pub-
lished maps and institutional affiliations. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in pub-
lished maps and institutional affiliations. 8. Laiyemo R, Dudill W, Jones SE, Browne H. Do postmenopausal women
with thickened endometrium on trans-vaginal ultrasound in the absence
of vaginal bleeding need hysteroscopic assessment? A Pilot Study J
Obstet Gynaecol. 2016;36(2):223–6. 9. Ghoubara A, Emovon E, Sundar S, Ewies A. Thickened endometrium in
asymptomatic postmenopausal women - determining an optimum
threshold for prediction of atypical hyperplasia and cancer. J Obstet
Gynaecol. 2018;38(8):1146–9. 10. Bracco Suarez MB, Benetti-Pinto CL, Gibran L, Yela DA. Asymptomatic
postmenopausal women: What are the risk factors for endome-
trial malignancies? A Multicent Retrosp Study Gynecol Endocrinol. 2021;37(9):853–6. 11. Giannella L, Mfuta K, Setti T, Boselli F, Bergamini E, Cerami LB. Diagnostic
accuracy of endometrial thickness for the detection of intra-uterine
pathologies and appropriateness of performed hysteroscopies among
asymptomatic postmenopausal women. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod
Biol. 2014;177:29–33. •
fast, convenient online submission
•
thorough peer review by experienced researchers in your field
•
rapid publication on acceptance
•
support for research data, including large and complex data types
•
gold Open Access which fosters wider collaboration and increased citations
maximum visibility for your research: over 100M website views per year
•
At BMC, research is always in progress. Learn more biomedcentral.com/submissions
Ready to submit your research
Ready to submit your research ? Choose BMC and benefit from:
? Choose BMC and benefit from: 12. Gambadauro P, Navaratnarajah R, Carli V. Anxiety at outpatient hysteros-
copy. Gynecol Surg. 2015;12(3):189–96. 13. Carta G, Palermo P, Marinangeli F, Piroli A, Necozione S, De Lellis V, et al. Waiting time and pain during office hysteroscopy. J Minim Invasive
Gynecol. 2012;19(3):360–4. 14. Aston B, Weaver E. Risks and benefits of hysteroscopy and endometrial
sampling as a standard procedure for assessing serendipitous findings of
endometrial thickening in postmenopausal women. Aust N Z J Obstet
Gynaecol. 2014;54(6):597–9. 15. Giannini A, Di Donato V, Schiavi MC, May J, Panici PB, Congiu MA. Predic-
tors of postoperative overall and severe complications after surgical
|
https://openalex.org/W4376224274
|
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0285662&type=printable
|
English
| null |
Experiences, barriers, and facilitators of health data use among performance monitoring teams (PMT) of health facilities in Eastern Ethiopia: A qualitative study
|
PloS one
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 8,889
|
PLOS ONE PLOS ONE RESEARCH ARTICLE Experiences, barriers, and facilitators of
health data use among performance
monitoring teams (PMT) of health facilities in
Eastern Ethiopia: A qualitative study Admas AberaID1*, Abebe ToleraID1, Biruk Shalmeno Tusa1, Adisu Birhanu Weldesenbet1,
Assefa Tola1, Tilahun ShiferawID2, Alemayehu Girma3, Rania Mohammed4, Yadeta Dessie1 1 School of Public Health, College of Health and Medical Sciences, Haramaya University, Harar, Ethiopia,
2 Department of Information Sciences, College of Computing and Informatics, Haramaya University,
Haramaya, Ethiopia, 3 Policy and Plan Directorate, Dire Dawa Administration Health Bureau, Dire Dawa,
Ethiopia, 4 Policy and Plan Directorate, Harari Regional Health Bureau, Harar, Ethiopia 1 School of Public Health, College of Health and Medical Sciences, Haramaya University, Harar, Ethiopia,
2 Department of Information Sciences, College of Computing and Informatics, Haramaya University,
Haramaya, Ethiopia, 3 Policy and Plan Directorate, Dire Dawa Administration Health Bureau, Dire Dawa,
Ethiopia, 4 Policy and Plan Directorate, Harari Regional Health Bureau, Harar, Ethiopia a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111 a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111 * admasabera10@gmail.com Editor: Dawit Wolde Daka, Jimma University,
ETHIOPIA Editor: Dawit Wolde Daka, Jimma University,
ETHIOPIA OPEN ACCESS OPEN ACCESS
Citation: Abera A, Tolera A, Tusa BS, Weldesenbet
AB, Tola A, Shiferaw T, et al. (2023) Experiences,
barriers, and facilitators of health data use among
performance monitoring teams (PMT) of health
facilities in Eastern Ethiopia: A qualitative study. PLoS ONE 18(5): e0285662. https://doi.org/
10.1371/journal.pone.0285662 Routine health data is crucial in decision-making and improved health outcomes. Despite
the significant investments in improving Ethiopia’s Performance Monitoring Team (PMT),
there is limited evidence on the involvement, implementation strategies, and facilitators and
barriers to data utilization by these teams responding to present and emerging health chal-
lenges. Therefore, this study aimed to explore the PMT experiences, facilitators, and barri-
ers to information use in healthcare facilities in Eastern Ethiopia. Method Received: April 11, 2022
Accepted: April 27, 2023
Published: May 11, 2023 This study employed a phenomenological study design using the Consolidated Framework
for Implementation Research (CFIR) to identify the most relevant constructs, aiming to
describe the data use approaches at six facilities in Dire Dawa and Harari regions in July
2021. Key informant interviews were conducted among 18 purposively selected experts
using a semi-structured interview guide. Thematic coding analysis was applied using a par-
tially deductive approach informed by previous studies and an inductive technique with the
creation of new emerging themes. Data were analyzed thematically using ATLAS.ti. Peer Review History: PLOS recognizes the
benefits of transparency in the peer review
process; therefore, we enable the publication of
all of the content of peer review and author
responses alongside final, published articles. The
editorial history of this article is available here:
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662 * admasabera10@gmail.com Conclusion Performance monitoring teams in the health facilities were established and functioning
according to the national standard. However, barriers to operative data use included PMT
engagement with multiple committees, poor data quality, lack of accountability, and poor
documentation practices. Addressing the potential barriers by leveraging the PMT and exist-
ing structures have the potential to improve data use and health service performance. Results Study participants felt the primary function of PMT was improving health service delivery. This study also revealed that data quality, performance, service quality, and improvement
strategies were among the major focus areas of the PMT. Data use by the PMT was
affected by poor data quality, absence of accountability, and lack of recognition for outstand-
ing performance. In addition, the engagement of PMT members on multiple committees
negatively impacted data use leading to inadequate follow-up of PMT activities, weariness,
and insufficient time to complete responsibilities. Copyright: © 2023 Abera et al. This is an open
access article distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original
author and source are credited. Data Availability Statement: All relevant data are
within the paper. 1 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams Funding: This work would not be possible without
the financial support of the Doris Duke Charitable
Foundation (DDCF) under grant number 2017187. The mission of the Doris Duke Charitable
Foundation is to improve the quality of people’s
lives through grants supporting the performing
arts, environmental conservation, medical
research, and child well-being, and through the
preservation of the cultural and environmental
legacy of Doris Duke’s properties. The funders had
no role in study design, data collection and
analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the
manuscript. The funder website can be found here:
https://www.ddcf.org/. Introduction Health systems are complex and continually changing to adapt to political, economic, social,
technological, and epidemiological realities within constrained resources, particularly in low-
and middle-income countries (LMICs) [1–3]. Health facilities must cope with these changing
realities through organized management and leadership, which require reliable data for devel-
oping a comprehensive policy package for health sector reforms [2, 4]. Competing interests: The authors have declared
that no competing interests exist. There has been an increased need for health service performance strengthening to manage
population needs through effective leadership [5–7], and an improved health facility data use
culture [8–10]. The increasing demand and capacity to use data appear more critical than the
expanding supply of evidence [3, 11] for improved access and quality of care [4, 12]. Collec-
tion, processing, transforming, communicating, and using service delivery reports and admin-
istrative records are crucial in decision-making for improved health outcomes [13, 14]. Data use is the process through which decision-makers and stakeholders explicitly evaluate
information in one or more steps of policymaking, program planning, management, or service
provision [6]. In the Ethiopian context, the PMT is a multidisciplinary health workforce team
primarily responsible for data use [15, 16]. By effectively using the data, targeted health service
delivery improvements meets the population’s needs [17]. However, in many developing countries, the quality of the evidence needed to generate
valid information to make decisions about health programs could be better or more [18–20],
mainly due to an ineffective data use culture [20]. The major bottlenecks for information use
include inadequate infrastructure, leadership turnover, dysfunctional external relations [21],
deficient data collection, and limited resources [13]. In addition, a shortage of skilled work-
force, an imbalance in skills, geographic misdistribution, difficulty in inter-professional collab-
oration, inefficient use of resources, and burnout were found to affect the health service
quality [22]. To date, most efforts to strengthen the health information systems have primarily focused
on digitization, improving data quality and analysis, and identifying problems; however, the
ultimate goal is utilizing information to problem solve, which requires time to build an infor-
mation use culture [8]. Therefore, engagement (including involvement, commitment, effort or
observable behaviour, a positive effect, or some combination of these) of healthcare leaders
and managers is pivotal if we are to improve the Health Information System (HIS) and hence,
the health service delivery [4, 11]. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 Study setting The study was conducted in selected Dire Dawa and Harari public health facilities. Dire Dawa
is located 515 kilometers from Addis Ababa and has an estimated population of 341,834, with
68.23% living in urban areas [23]. Data from the public health facilities indicate 15 health cen-
ters (8 urban and seven rural), two hospitals, and 32 health posts under the city administration. Harar is the capital of Harari, one of the regional states of Ethiopia, located 517 Km east of
Addis Ababa and 48 km south of Dire Dawa. According to the 2007 census, the region has a
total population of 183,415 people [23], and more than half (54.18%) reside in urban areas
[24]. The region has three government hospitals, one university teaching hospital, two private
hospitals, nine health centers, and 24 health posts. Study design and participants This study used a phenomenological study design. The Consolidated Framework for Imple-
mentation Research (CFIR) was used to identify the most relevant constructs to describe data
use approaches. The CFIR framework is an evidence-based framework from multiple disci-
plines providing a comprehensive arrangement of paradigms that influence complex imple-
mentations [25]. The framework was adapted through a qualitative theme reduction process
and has five significant domains (inner setting, outer setting, intervention characteristics, indi-
viduals involved, and implementation process) with associated components. From these
domains, we chose to focus specifically on the domains of inner settings, outer settings and
individuals involved based upon their relevance to our research question, which is to identify
the different factors influencing the data use practice of the PMT. The three domains used in
this study were: 1) Inner setting of data use practice (HIS input & infrastructure, communica-
tion between PMT and other health workers, PMTs competing priorities, engagement of
PMT, staff turnover, and PMT structure at health facilities); 2) Outer settings (policy and
guidelines, accountability mechanism, supervision and mentorship, and recognition); and 3)
Individuals involved (value for data, workload, readiness and perception). The framework was
applied in the design and during data collection phase of this study. Two hospitals and four health centers were randomly selected from a list of facilities in the
two regions. A purposive sampling technique was employed to select the key informants. Eigh-
teen interviews were conducted until data saturation was achieved. The key informants were
PMT members from the health facilities, including hospital medical directors, heads of health
centers, heads of departments (outpatient, inpatient, emergency, maternal and child health,
pharmacy, laboratory, nursing, human resource, and finance team leads), and the Health Man-
agement Information System (HMIS) officers. pharmacy, laboratory, nursing, human resource, and finance team leads), and the Health Man-
agement Information System (HMIS) officers. Introduction The engagement level and capacities of health managers and performance monitoring
teams to respond to current and emerging issues still need to be better understood [22]. With-
out radical structural and systemic changes, the existing governance structures and manage-
ment systems will continue to fail to address the gaps in health service delivery [2]. Furthermore, despite significant investments in performance monitoring teams in Ethiopia, a
joint performance renewal effort must be improved. There is also paucity of studies addressing out radical structural and systemic changes, the existing governance structures and manage-
ment systems will continue to fail to address the gaps in health service delivery [2]. Furthermore, despite significant investments in performance monitoring teams in Ethiopia, a
joint performance renewal effort must be improved. There is also paucity of studies addressing Furthermore, despite significant investments in performance monitoring teams in Ethiopia, a
joint performance renewal effort must be improved. There is also paucity of studies addressing 2 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams the facilitators, and challenges influencing health data use to improve primary health care
delivery in LMICs. Therefore, this study aimed to identify the PMT experiences, facilitators
and barriers to information use in the healthcare facilities in the Harari region and Dire Dawa
city administration in Eastern Ethiopia. Data processing and analysis The interviews were transcribed verbatim, and notes were taken in the field. The interviews
were translated into English and translated back to the original languages to confirm the accu-
racy. A codebook was developed based on the initial review of the transcripts, and transcripts
were systematically coded using ATLAS.ti software. Double coding was initially used, with dis-
agreements resolved by discussion; updates to the code definitions were made when needed. Double coding continued until no new disagreements were identified. Subsequently, summa-
ries for each transcript were written under each code using a matrix. Thematic data analysis
described and compared general statements as relationships, themes, and sub-themes emerged
in the data. Accordingly, findings were categorized into five themes. Under each theme, sub-
themes were defined with verbatim quotes representing opinions to substantiate the results. Researchers read all interview transcripts, counterchecked the transcripts, coded the data, and
agreed on the emerging themes and sub-themes. Additionally, research rigor was enhanced
through regular discussions between researchers. Key themes and sub-themes In this study, three major themes, five key sub-themes and 16 sub-themes emerged. The main
themes and sub-themes are presented in Table 1. Data collection We conducted key informant interviews using a semi-structured interview guide. The guide
was comprised of questions related to the respondents’ socio-demographic characteristics, the
process of the PMT establishment and implementation strategy process, data use processes 3 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams and practices, barriers to data use, motivating factors for data use, and recommended mecha-
nisms to improve the data use practice. Data quality control Data were collected between July 05, 2021, and July 24, 2021, by interviewers fluent in local
languages (Amharic and Afan Oromo) and English, with graduate-level education and experi-
ence in qualitative data collection. All data collection team members underwent a one-day
training workshop to understand the interview guide and study objectives. The data collection
activities were supervised daily by the study investigators. All interviews were conducted pri-
vately and lasted 20–60 minutes. Ethical considerations Ethical clearance was obtained from Haramaya University, College of Health and Medical Sci-
ences, Institutional Health Research Ethics Review Committee (IHRERC) (reference number
IHRERC/196/2020). Permission was sought from Dire Dawa Administration and the Harari
Regional Health Bureaus, and the studied health facilities. In addition, informed written con-
sent was obtained from the study participants before data collection. Furthermore, participants
were assured of the confidentiality of the information and their right to withdraw from the
study at any time during the study. This article omitted personal identifiers to maintain confi-
dentiality, while neutral identifiers and participants’ age were mentioned in direct quotes. PLOS ONE Table 1. Categories of key themes and sub-themes emerged. Major Themes
Sub-Themes
Experiences of PMT
Membership and roles of PMT members at the health facilities
• Roles and responsibilities of PMT members
• The current PMT status and experiences
Relevance of PMT strategies and its implementation
• Perceived benefits of PMT
• The modality of PMT meetings
• Adequacy and convenience of time of PMT meeting
• The focuses of PMT meetings
Barriers to data use
Barriers to data use in the facility
• Organizational barriers
• Healthcare workers’ work ethic and behavioral barriers
• Demotivating factors COVID-19 effect on data use
Facilitators of data
use
Motivation mechanisms to enhancing data use practices in place for PMT
members
• Capacity building practices for PMT members
• Recognition and non-monetary incentives
Recommended mechanisms to improve the data use practices
• Performance-based recognition
• Continuous supply of resources, and improving HIS
infrastructures
• Strengthening the overall HIS
• Enhancing the quality of routine data https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662.t002 Socio-demographic characteristics Of the total eighteen in-depth interviews conducted, eight were females, and three were health
facility heads with a median age (IQR) of 31 (7) years (Table 2). 4 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams Another key informant pointed out; Another key informant pointed out; “. . .any health care provider in a case team can be a member of the PMT. That means there
will be one representative from each case team in PMT irrespective of his/her status.” (KI15,
42 years old) Roles and responsibilities of PMT members include use of health data to improve the
health service performance. The specific roles include preparing action plans, preparing direc-
tions to improve service delivery, comparing performance overtime, monitoring monthly per-
formance, providing feedback to various units, building the capacity of health workers, and
preparing reports. The present study also found that the PMT members were aware of their
responsibilities. One of the participants stated that “. . .each member of the PMT is expected to prepare and
submit their case team or department reports to the head of the health facility on time. All
PMT members will discuss on the submitted report during the monthly PMT meeting in
which the reports are crosschecked for its consistency and quality. When the achievements are
lower than expected, the reasons for underachievement are sorted out and future directions
are put to improve the performance.” (KI4, 38 years old) The participants’ opinions on aligning the PMT’s roles and responsibilities at the facility
with their activities were mixed. While the majority of respondents stated that PMT tasks and
responsibilities are aligned with their actual activities, some stated they do not match with
their actual activities. There is some overlapping of duties and roles, according to these
participants. “As a case team leader, my responsibility is identifying the challenges in my activities but
sometimes the roles and activities rendered to us are not related to service performance and
members get frustrated due to that” (KI16, 35 years old) Relevance of PMT strategy and its implementation. The perceived benefits of PMT for
the facility include improving the service delivery and customer satisfaction. Additionally, this
team is essential for sharing experiences and skills among the departments and case teams. “. . .the members of PMT are from different departments; there is knowledge sharing on differ-
ent topics including preparation of reports and how to improve performance.” (KI11, 32 years
old) “. . 1. Experiences of PMT Membership and roles of PMT at the health facilities. Participants reported that health
facilities use specific criteria to select the members of the PMT, including the head of the qual-
ity department, HMIS unit team leader, department head, management team, and staff with
good performance. A respondent stated, “. . .since the performance of every department is reviewed in the meet-
ing, the main criteria for PMT membership is being a department head. The heads of manage-
ment unit, HMIS unit, and quality department are also included. I became a member because
I have served as a vice matron for the last one and half years.” (KI9, 29 years old) Table 2. Socio-demographic characteristics of key informants at the health facilities, Eastern Ethiopia 2021. Participant ID
Sex
Age in years
Educational status
Work experience in years
Facility type
KI1
Female
34
BSc
11
Health center
KI2
Female
25
Diploma
2
Health center
KI3
Male
27
BSc
9
Health center
KI4
Female
38
BSc
20
Health center
KI5
Male
26
BSc
7
Health center
KI6
Male
34
BSc
13
Health center
KI7
Male
28
Master’s
3
Health center
KI8
Female
25
BSc
1
Health center
KI9
Female
29
BSc
6
Referral Hospital
KI10
Male
28
BSc
32
Referral Hospital
KI11
Male
32
BSc
13
Health center
KI12
Male
30
BSc
7
Health center
KI13
Female
34
BSc
8
Health center
KI14
Female
39
BSc
12
Health center
KI15
Male
42
BSc
19
General Hospital
KI16
Male
35
BSc
3
General Hospital
KI17
Female
35
BSc
12
General Hospital
KI18
Female
30
BSc
10
General Hospital
htt
//d i
/10 1371/j
l
0285662 t002 Table 2. Socio-demographic characteristics of key informants at the health facilities, Eastern Ethiopia 2021. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 5 / 16 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 that the monthly meetings were conducted immediately after each unit submitted their
monthly report. that the monthly meetings were conducted immediately after each unit submitted their
monthly report. “Our PMT meeting is conducted on monthly basis. Immediately after the submission of the
monthly report (usually at 21st day of the month), we hold our PMT meeting at 23rd or 24th
day of the month. Substitution date will be posted on our telegram page if a meeting is
rescheduled.” (KI12, 30 years old) Adequacy and convenience of timing of PMT meeting. On the other hand, it was found
that the time allocated for PMT meetings was inadequate and inconvenient. All participants
unanimously agreed that there should be enough time assigned and a convenient time allo-
cated for the PMT meetings. “The meeting time is not enough because every participant usually come to the meeting by
interrupting their work. Usually, the meeting date and time is decided by the head.” (KI16, 35
years old) “The meeting time is not enough because every participant usually come to the meeting by
interrupting their work. Usually, the meeting date and time is decided by the head.” (KI16, 35
years old) Participants discussed how holding the meeting on weekends could reduce absenteeism
and unnecessary interruptions. “. . .previously, we used to hold the PMT meeting during working hours and hence the dura-
tion of the meetings was not adequate. This was due to high workload of the PMT members. However, currently we are conducting our PMT meeting on Saturdays. Since it is not a work-
ing day, PMT members are paid some pocket money for attending the meeting on over the
weekend.” (KI8, 25 years old) “. . .previously, we used to hold the PMT meeting during working hours and hence the dura-
tion of the meetings was not adequate. This was due to high workload of the PMT members. However, currently we are conducting our PMT meeting on Saturdays. Since it is not a work-
ing day, PMT members are paid some pocket money for attending the meeting on over the
weekend.” (KI8, 25 years old) The focus of PMT meetings reportedly included data quality, performance activities
(monthly, quarterly, or annual performance), service quality, and service improvement strate-
gies. According to participants, the first agenda of the PMT meeting was evaluating the previ-
ous report, and then comparing it with the current performance. Next, the team develops an
action plan based on the identified gaps. Another key informant pointed out; .the members of PMT are from different departments; there is knowledge sharing on differ-
ent topics including preparation of reports and how to improve performance.” (KI11, 32 years
old) Planning, identifying gaps through root cause analysis, and intervening on the identified
problems, and monitoring and evaluating specific activities. The key informants further pointed out, “. . .we select poorly performed activities and the
responsible departments will design an action plan for the identified problems by conducting a
root cause analysis. Then, the department will be directed to monitor the implementation of
the action plan and they are expected to bring the progress in the subsequent meetings.”
(KI17, 35 years old) The modality of PMT meetings. Health facilities have a monthly meeting plan in their
health facilities, which is prepared in advance in the annual plan. Respondents pointed out PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 6 / 16 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 that the monthly meetings were conducted immediately after each unit submitted their
monthly report. However, in some health facilities, the previous per-
formance is not conducted at all. “In our monthly PMT meeting, the first thing is presenting the monthly performance report
for each unit. Based on the report, gaps and challenges are identified, before action plans are
drafted on the identified gaps”. (KI9, 29 years old) The PMTs mainly utilize routine data for evaluation and monitoring of service delivery
programs. Therefore, there needed to be a culture of using health related data from other
sources, such as surveys, assessments, or research findings. “In our health center, the main target of PMT is the routine data. The data accuracy and com-
pleteness are checked. Service improvement strategies are also discussed.” (KI5, 26 years old) The respondent further stated “data collected in our health facility is used for making deci-
sions. I have not seen other data sources from researches or surveys being utilized so far.”
(KI5, 26 years old) The respondent further stated “data collected in our health facility is used for making deci-
sions. I have not seen other data sources from researches or surveys being utilized so far.”
(KI5, 26 years old) 7 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams 2. Barriers to data use The organizational barriers to data use at the facility level were poor data quality, being a
member of multiple committees and high patient flow, human resource related issues, input
related issues, inadequate budget allocation, and lack of performance-based incentives. “. . .PMT members have their own duties in addition to the PMT activities which makes it dif-
ficult to collect quality data due to competing priorities. If someone is engaged with overlap-
ping duties, the desired outcome may not be achieved”. (KI3, 27 years old) “. . .PMT members have their own duties in addition to the PMT activities which makes it dif-
ficult to collect quality data due to competing priorities. If someone is engaged with overlap-
ping duties, the desired outcome may not be achieved”. (KI3, 27 years old) Participants reported that they were in at least two other committees in their health facility. This resulted in poor follow-up of the designated PMT activities and time constraint with
committee meetings and assignments. According to the participants, multiple committees
negatively affected the effectiveness of the PMT activities. “. . .being the member of several committees affects the PMT activities. The aim of including a
person in a given team or committee is to perform the task effectively and efficiently in order
to bring the intended changes. However, the focus of the individual is usually divided to differ-
ent committees. In most cases the meeting times is overlapping between different committees”
(KI2, 25 years old) “. . .being the member of several committees affects the PMT activities. The aim of including a
person in a given team or committee is to perform the task effectively and efficiently in order
to bring the intended changes. However, the focus of the individual is usually divided to differ-
ent committees. In most cases the meeting times is overlapping between different committees”
(KI2, 25 years old) It was further pointed out: “Participation in multiple committees decreases the effectiveness of the PMT. Not only for the
PMT, but even the other committees are also adversely affected. I suggest to not assign case
team leaders on more than one committee.” (KI14, 39 years old) The routine data quality collected at the health facilities was reported as a barrier for effec-
tive data use. “There is a gap in data quality including gaps with data consistency and completeness. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 2. Barriers to data use Healthcare providers perform their daily activities but they do not document it on the register
regularly. The data from HMIS may contradict from your observation every day. Hence it is
difficult to use our data for decision making due to its poor quality.” (KI2, 25 years old) Another participant further pointed out “A timely, reliable and high-quality data should be
generated in order to use the data for decision making. Monitoring and supporting the staffs is
also critical to obtain high quality data.” (KI17, 35 years old) HIS input related factors, including a shortage of patient registrations was cited as another
barrier for data use. “We have an old register called daily register for documentation of our data. This register was
supplied by a Non-Governmental Organization. However, this supply of registers has stopped
and currently, we have shortage of the daily registers which affected our documentation.”
(KI13, 34 years old) An additional barrier for effective data use at the health facilities was budget constraints,
which was felt to influence documentation in the facilities. 8 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams “We use the budget given for the health center, but there is no budget allocated specifically for
HMIS.” (KI6, 34 years old) “We use the budget given for the health center, but there is no budget allocated specifically for
HMIS.” (KI6, 34 years old) Healthcare providers’ work ethic and behavioural barriers were another sub-theme that Healthcare providers’ work ethic and behavioural barriers were another sub-theme that
emerged in this study. Poor commitment and lack of accountability from healthcare providers
and PMT members were the most reported challenges. One respondent explained the commit-
ment and competing priorities of PMT members as “. . .sometimes we reviewed the same problem repeatedly without a solution. We start to get
fed up and start to wonder when it will be solved. Sometimes, we skip the meeting inten-
tionally for this reason. (KI9, 29 years old) Another respondent pointed out that: Another respondent pointed out that: “The head of the facility lacks decisiveness and leadership qualities on this job. I don’t think
the problem is a gap in knowledge but rather an attitude problem.” (KI13, 34 years old) “The head of the facility lacks decisiveness and leadership qualities on this job. I don’t think
the problem is a gap in knowledge but rather an attitude problem.” (KI13, 34 years old) Another respondent pointed out “. . .if the head of the department or the facility do not uti-
lize data properly, other employees will not care about data use. Hence, the head at district,
region or at any other level should lead by example to motivate other staffs.” (KI2, 25 years old) COVID-19 effect on data use. The COVID-19 pandemic had direct and indirect effects
on data use practices at the health facilities. An informant explained the effect of COVID-19
pandemic on their day-to-day activity as “Due to the occurrence of COVID -19 outbreak, the nearby hospital was entirely devoted to
provide health care service for COVID-19 cases. Hence, all patients in the catchment area of
that hospital came to our health center. These conditions increased the workload and compro-
mised our routine activities.” (KI14, 39 years old) Another key informant stated “. . .due to COVID-19, the head of HMIS has been in quaran-
tine for the last two months which negatively affected the PMT activities.” (KI3, 27 years old) Another respondent pointed out that: “. . .health workers that reported incomplete or false data are not given any administrative
reprimands for their wrong doing.” (KI18, 30 years old) “. . .health workers that reported incomplete or false data are not given any administrative
reprimands for their wrong doing.” (KI18, 30 years old) “. . .health workers that reported incomplete or false data are not given any administrative
reprimands for their wrong doing.” (KI18, 30 years old) Furthermore, a major challenge reported was lack of understanding of data value by the
healthcare workers when using data for action. “Sometimes the PMT members’ attitude towards data is a challenge by itself. The notion that
a high-quality data can change the hospital is not understood equally among the staffs.” (KI9,
29 years old) “Sometimes the PMT members’ attitude towards data is a challenge by itself. The notion that
a high-quality data can change the hospital is not understood equally among the staffs.” (KI9,
29 years old) According to the participants, most of the health professionals have a poor understanding
and attitude regarding the importance of data in improving the quality of health services. Additionally, gaps in skills in analyzing data using electronic computing software, such as Dis-
trict Health Information System version 2 (DHIS2) was mentioned. “Disparity in understanding the importance of data among our staffs is the other problem. While some people have better understanding towards data, others do not see the value of it.”
(KI9, 29 years old) One respondent further noted: One respondent further noted: “There is a problem on registering the data and handling of a registers. Even after the data is
entered into the DHIS2, there is skill gap in analyzing it.” (KI10, 32 years old) Poor tracking of problems, and a lack of monitoring of action plans is frequently observed
according to the key informants. “The main problem is that we don’t strictly follow the action plans designed in the previous
PMT meetings.” (KI2, 25 Years old) Absenteeism and interruption due to competing priorities were also reported during PMT
meetings. “As I said earlier, even if it is a monthly meeting, the date and time should be notified ahead
of time. Sudden meetings will affect my routine activities and as a result some members of the PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 9 / 16 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams PMT tend to be absent and some interrupt the meeting to go back to their urgent activities.”
(KI13, 34 years old) Poor documentation practices were another challenge reported by the respondents. First,
in order to create a change in the data use culture, the priority should be changing the attitude
of the health care workers before other interventions are introduced. “Health professionals should believe documenting data primarily benefits patients, themselves
and their health facility. Therefore, working on the attitude change towards documentation
should be given more emphasis.” (KI11, 32 years old) Demotivating factors for effective data use practices were cited by the study participants
including a shortage of resources, inadequate salary, and inadequate follow-up. “Salary is one of the demotivating factors because it does not fit with the job that we under-
take.” (KI10, 28 years old) “There is no follow up mechanism after trainings are provided.” (KI8, 25 years old) “There is no follow up mechanism after trainings are provided.” (KI8, 25 years old) The managers’ leadership skills was one of the factors affecting data use in health facilities. Health managers’ and case-team/departments’ inadequate leadership skills, and lack of value
for data were also mentioned as demotivating factors. Others believed that incentives may not necessarily motivate staff to use the data or improve
service performance. Others believed that incentives may not necessarily motivate staff to use the data or improve
service performance. Others believed that incentives may not necessarily motivate staff to use the data or improve
service performance. “It is hard to say that the presence of incentives only positively affects data use. Providing
incentives before attitude change may even adversely affect the data use practice.” (KI11, 32
years old) 4. Recommended mechanisms to improve data use Performance-based recognition for health workers was recommended by all informants as a
major motivation mechanism to improve data use. Performance-based recognition for health workers was recommended by all informants as a
major motivation mechanism to improve data use. “There are those who register and report on time among the health extension workers. The
others will be motivated to do the same if you provide recognition or incentives. The incentive
can even be in the form of a certificate.” (KI15, 42 years old) “There are those who register and report on time among the health extension workers. The
others will be motivated to do the same if you provide recognition or incentives. The incentive
can even be in the form of a certificate.” (KI15, 42 years old) Another participant stated, “since the PMT members are the backbone of health facilities,
designing motivating mechanisms is important.” (KI9, 29 years old) Continuous supply of resources, improving the infrastructures, and strengthening the HIS. “Ensuring continuous supply of necessary materials and recognizing best performers should be
introduced.” (KI9, 29 years old) Enhancing the quality of routine data collected was also unanimously believed to enhance
data use practice. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 3. Facilitators of data use Motivation mechanism in place for PMT members at the facilities. This study identi-
fied several motivation mechanisms in place though not across all facilities and not conducted
regularly. The main motivation strategies reported were capacity building and performance-
based recognition. Capacity building practices for PMT members. According to participants, the primary
capacity building practices included in-service trainings, recognition for good performance,
and professional development. 10 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams “Capacity building on data quality and project development for the members of PMT has
been a very good incentive since we never had such experience before.” (KI7, 28 years old) Recognition and Non-monetary incentive mechanisms to motivate the PMT members in
the facility were reported. Participants indicated that these motivational mechanisms were
effective when directed towards improving the data use culture of the facilities. A participant pointed out that “performance-based recognition and motivation of staffs can
improve the data quality and subsequently the data use in the facility.” (KI6, 34 years old) However, in some health facilities there were not any motivation measures specific to PMT
members. “There are no capacity buildings, recognition mechanisms, and career enhancing educational
opportunities to motivate PMT members.” (KI4, 38 years old) “There are no capacity buildings, recognition mechanisms, and career enhancing educational
opportunities to motivate PMT members.” (KI4, 38 years old) Other participants reported that some sort of recognition and motivation mechanisms were
implemented in their facilities. “They awarded me this watch for my good performance for properly ensuring the quality of
data collected in my health facility.” (KI7, 30 years old) “They awarded me this watch for my good performance for properly ensuring the quality of
data collected in my health facility.” (KI7, 30 years old) Discussion This study explored experiences, facilitators and barriers of the PMT, using the adapted Con-
solidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR), to generate information for deci-
sion-making at points of healthcare delivery. The findings revealed that the PMT in most
facilities were established according to the standard criteria set by the Ministry of Health
(MOH) of Ethiopia [16]. In line with previous studies, our study indicated that the primary
responsibility of the PMT was to improve data quality and regularly monitor progress and
improve health service performance [15, 16]. Although some irregularities were reported, the monthly meetings were regularly con-
ducted right after each unit submitted their monthly report and before submitting their report
to the next level to monitor progress and improve performance. The MOH guideline indicates
that the meeting dates, venue and its members should officially be communicated in advance
and the meeting should be conducted at least a day ahead of submission of the monthly report
to the next level [15, 16, 26]. The present study found the PMT meetings focused on data quality, performance improve-
ment, and evaluation of previous action plans. Previous studies show PMT meetings should
start with follow-up activities for gaps highlighted from the previous PMT meeting as the first
item on the agenda, followed by an assessment of the progress on those gaps [16, 26]. Meetings
and collected data have no value unless action items from meetings are implemented and data
are analyzed into meaningful actions [21]. Health facilities should design strategies to minimize the number of committees and inte-
grate similar committees to improve their service provision. Most PMT members in our study
were usually involved in at least two other committees in their health facility. This creates poor
follow up of the activities set out by the PMT with the committee members being overbur-
dened by meetings and assignments, creating fatigue and a shortage of time to accomplish
PMT assignments. Evidence indicate that data triangulation using various sources, such as original research,
community feedback, expert opinions, vital registration, censuses, and routine HMIS data can
yield better results [16, 21, 26]. Although there were practice of use of routine internal data,
information use from external sources was limited in this study. Enhancing the quality of routine data collected was also unanimously believed to enhance
data use practice. “In order to use data for a decision, first I have to receive the data properly. A timely, reliable
and complete data should be collected.” (KI1, 34 years old) “In order to use data for a decision, first I have to receive the data properly. A timely, reliable
and complete data should be collected.” (KI1, 34 years old) 11 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 Discussion Previous studies indicated that an organizational context that supports data collection,
availability, and use, the technical aspects of data processes and tools, and the behavior of indi-
viduals who produce and/or use data are the main elements of health information use [26, 27]. The major challenges of data use reported in the present study emanate from organizational,
behavioral and technical sources including poor data quality, competing priorities, shortage of
skilled human power, and lack of performance-based motivation for the health workers. Healthcare organizations are increasingly required to gather and report data about their
performance and respond to the results of consequential quality measurements [28]. Quality
data enables healthcare organizations to monitor progress, making decisions for continuous
improvement, and provide effective and efficient health services [29]. Our study revealed that
although poor quality of data was one of the major challenges for an informed decision mak-
ing, it has been used for priority setting as well as designing and implementing action plans. This requires attention as decisions taken by healthcare managers might be misleading and
fails to address the actual problem. Previous study in Addis Ababa indicated that the PMT
meetings that were designed for the sole purpose of improving data quality were not effective
[30]. Another qualitative study to explore the facilitators and barriers of digital health technol-
ogy use also identified data quality as a potential barrier [31]. Moreover, lack of available data
for several indicators and a lack of validated indicators for important dimensions of quality PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 12 / 16 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams were identified as major challenges to improve Primary Health Care (PHC) Performance in
previous studies [6]. Behavioral factors provide crucial insight into the way in which health workers, managers
and policymakers use information [26]. The attitude, motivation, and value decision makers
attach to information play a big role in determining data use [2, 26]. Concurrent with these,
poor commitment, skill gap, lack of accountability for failing to accomplish tasks, work over-
load, poor documentation, and resource mismanagement were the main behavioural level
challenges reported in this study. Engagement with different committees increased PMT workload and compromised the
effectiveness of data use. Participation in quality improvement collaborative activities may
improve health professionals’ knowledge, problem-solving skills and attitude; teamwork;
shared leadership and habits for improvement. Discussion A review of literature indicated shifting roles
and expectations in the workplace for health care leadership and management as a major chal-
lenge for health leadership and workforce [1]. Interaction across quality improvement teams
may generate normative pressure and opportunities for capacity building and peer recognition
[15]. Health professionals either do not consider recording and reporting data as part of their
routine activities or they just give more priority to the clinical provision and lesser attention to
data [30]. Although there is a need to make significant investments in the workforce develop-
ment and training [32], tackling of behavioral factors require interventions that go beyond
simple trainings and should focus more on initiatives that enhances positive attitude towards
data value [26]. The individual determinants of motivation among healthcare workers are altruism, attain-
ing professionalism, educational opportunity, and being more experienced [33]. In the present
study, it was indicated that health facilities use capacity buildings, and some form of non-mon-
etary incentives to improve performance, while most informants indicated dissatisfaction with
the absence of such motivating mechanisms. Career development opportunities, in-service
trainings, and regular recognition for good performance were also reported to be practiced at
the health facilities which has to be expanded to more institutions. Provision of inputs necessary for HIS such as laptops, internet modems; as well as awarding
the best performing health facilities were other motivational methods. Since health profession-
als can be motivated by a range of extrinsic and intrinsic factors, policy makers need to look
beyond traditional financial incentives when designing policies to improve health service per-
formance [34]. Studies indicate training opportunities, transformative leaders, and nonmone-
tary incentives, staff development and promotion, availability of necessary resources, and ease
of communication are found to be effective motivation mechanisms for health care workers
[33, 35]. Author Contributions Conceptualization: Admas Abera, Tilahun Shiferaw, Alemayehu Girma, Rania Mohammed,
Yadeta Dessie. Data curation: Admas Abera, Biruk Shalmeno Tusa, Adisu Birhanu Weldesenbet, Assefa
Tola, Alemayehu Girma, Rania Mohammed. Data curation: Admas Abera, Biruk Shalmeno Tusa, Adisu Birhanu Weldesenbet, Assefa
Tola, Alemayehu Girma, Rania Mohammed. Formal analysis: Abebe Tolera, Biruk Shalmeno Tusa, Adisu Birhanu Weldesenbet, Assefa
Tola, Tilahun Shiferaw. Funding acquisition: Admas Abera, Rania Mohammed. Investigation: Admas Abera, Adisu Birhanu Weldesenbet, Alemayehu Girma. Methodology: Admas Abera, Abebe Tolera, Biruk Shalmeno Tusa, Assefa Tola, Tilahun Shi-
feraw, Alemayehu Girma, Rania Mohammed, Yadeta Dessie. Project administration: Admas Abera. Software: Abebe Tolera, Assefa Tola. Supervision: Admas Abera, Adisu Birhanu Weldesenbet, Alemayehu Girma, Rania Moham-
med, Yadeta Dessie. Validation: Admas Abera, Abebe Tolera. Validation: Admas Abera, Abebe Tolera. Visualization: Admas Abera. Writing – original draft: Admas Abera, Abebe Tolera, Assefa Tola. Writing – review & editing: Admas Abera, Biruk Shalmeno Tusa, Tilahun Shiferaw, Ale-
mayehu Girma, Rania Mohammed, Yadeta Dessie. Acknowledgments The authors are thankful to the Ethiopian Ministry of Health, Dire Dawa and Harari Regional
Health Bureaus. We are also grateful for participating health facilities and their healthcare
staffs for their time and voluntarily for contributing to the research. Moreover, we would like
to acknowledge our data collectors and logistic facilitators for their support throughout the
study. Conclusions This study has generated important insights into experiences of PMT including its establish-
ment, and implementation strategies, barriers to data use, and facilitators of using information
for decision at a point of service delivery. The study found that most performance monitoring
teams in health facilities were established and functioning according to the national standard. Additionally, the study revealed that the barriers to effective data use include the PMT attend-
ing multiple committee meetings (increasing workload), poor data quality, lack of accountabil-
ity, and poor documentation practices. Recommendations to enhance data use practices
include non-monetary incentives and recognition for exemplary health workers. Improving
routine data quality, integrating various teams into PMT for an efficient use of the limited PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 13 / 16 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams human resource, establishing an accountability framework, and designing documentation
methods will ultimately improve informed decision-making. While a comprehensive country-
wide study of PMTs is required, policymakers, stakeholders working on HIS, and health man-
agers should work on improving routine data quality and design motivational strategies,
including recognition and non-monetary incentives to improve data use which has the poten-
tial to improve health service performance. including recognition and non-monetary incentives to improve data use which has the poten-
tial to improve health service performance. References 1. Figueroa CA, Harrison R, Chauhan A, Meyer L. Priorities and challenges for health leadership and
workforce management globally: a rapid review. BMC Health Services Research. 2019; 19(1):239. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-019-4080-7 PMID: 31014349 2. Senkubuge F, Modisenyane M, Bishaw T. Strengthening health systems by health sector reforms. Global health action. 2014; 7(1):23568. https://doi.org/10.3402/gha.v7.23568 PMID: 24560261 3. Witter S, Anderson I, Annear P, Awosusi A, Bhandari NN, Brikci N, et al. What, why and how do health
systems learn from one another? Insights from eight low- and middle-income country case studies. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 14 / 16 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams Health Research Policy and Systems. 2019; 17(1):9. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12961-018-0410-1
PMID: 30665412 Health Research Policy and Systems. 2019; 17(1):9. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12961-018-0410-1
PMID: 30665412 4. Nordsteien A, Bystro¨m K. Transitions in workplace information practices and culture. Journal of Docu-
mentation. 2018; 74(4):827–43. 5. Veillard J, Cowling K, Bitton A, Ratcliffe H, Kimball M, Barkley S, et al. Better measurement for perfor-
mance improvement in Low-and Middle-Income countries: the primary health care performance Initia-
tive (PHCPI) experience of conceptual framework development and indicator selection. The Milbank
quarterly. 2017; 95(4):836–83. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0009.12301 PMID: 29226448 6. Tantivess S, Walt G. The role of state and non-state actors in the policy process: the contribution of pol-
icy networks to the scale-up of antiretroviral therapy in Thailand. Health policy and planning. 2008; 23
(5):328–38. https://doi.org/10.1093/heapol/czn023 PMID: 18658197 7. Fryatt R, Bennett S, Soucat A. Health sector governance: should we be investing more? BMJ global
health. 2017; 2(2):e000343. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2017-000343 PMID: 29225938 8. Lippeveld T. Routine health facility and community information systems: creating an information use
culture. Global Health: Science and Practice; 2017. p. 338–40. https://doi.org/10.9745/GHSP-D-17-
00319 PMID: 28963169 9. Nordsteien A, Bystro¨m K. Transitions in workplace information practices and culture: The influence of
newcomers on information use in healthcare. Journal of Documentation. 2018. 10. Jylha¨ V. Information management in health care: a model for connecting information culture and patient
safety. 2017. 11. Aqil A, Hozumi D, Lippeveld T. Tools for data demand and use in the health sector: Performance of
Routine Information Systems Management (PRISM) Tools. Measure Evaluation. 2011. 12. Watson DE, Broemeling A-M, Reid RJ, Black C. A results-based logic model for primary health care:
laying an evidence-based foundation to guide performance measurement, monitoring and evaluation. 2004. 13. References Endriyas M, Alano A, Mekonnen E, Ayele S, Kelaye T, Shiferaw M, et al. Understanding performance
data: health management information system data accuracy in Southern Nations Nationalities and Peo-
ple’s Region, Ethiopia. BMC Health Services Research. 2019; 19(1):175. https://doi.org/10.1186/
s12913-019-3991-7 PMID: 30885204 14. MOH. Guidance on developing key performance indicators and minimum data sets to monitor health-
care quality. 2013. 15. Adane T, Tadesse T, Endazenaw G. Assessment on Utilization of Health Management Information Sys-
tem at Public Health Centers Addis Ababa City Administrative, Ethiopia. Internet Things Cloud Comput. 2017; 5(1):7–18. 16. MOH. Information Use Training Module. In: PPMED. Addis Ababa; June 2018. 17. Rendell N, Lokuge K, Rosewell A, Field E. Factors That Influence Data Use to Improve Health Service
Delivery in Low- and Middle-Income Countries. Global Health: Science and Practice. 2020; 8(3):566. https://doi.org/10.9745/GHSP-D-19-00388 PMID: 33008864 18. Maphumulo WT, Bhengu BR. Challenges of quality improvement in the healthcare of South Africa post-
apartheid: A critical review. Curationis. 2019; 42(1):1–9. https://doi.org/10.4102/curationis.v42i1.1901
PMID: 31170800 19. Lee CH, Yoon H-J. Medical big data: promise and challenges. Kidney research and clinical practice. 2017; 36(1):3. https://doi.org/10.23876/j.krcp.2017.36.1.3 PMID: 28392994 20. Zamboni K, Baker U, Tyagi M, Schellenberg J, Hill Z, Hanson C. How and under what circumstances do
quality improvement collaboratives lead to better outcomes? A systematic review. Implementation Sci-
ence. 2020; 15(1):27. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13012-020-0978-z PMID: 32366269 21. Obwocha W, Ayodo G, Nyangura A, Thomas O. Utilization of Healthcare Information Among Health-
care Workers in Gucha Subcounty, Kisii County, Kenya. J Health Edu Res Dev. 2016; 4(192):2. 22. West M, Dawson J. Employee engagement and NHS performance: King’s Fund London; 2012. 23. CSA. Population and Housing Census Of Ethiopia. 2007. 23. CSA. Population and Housing Census Of Ethiopia. 2007. 24. Commission PC. Summary and statistical report of the 2007 population and housing census. Population
size by age and sex. 2008. 25. Damschroder LJ, Aron DC, Keith RE, Kirsh SR, Alexander JA, Lowery JC. Fostering implementation of
health services research findings into practice: a consolidated framework for advancing implementation
science. 2009; 15:1–15. 26. Mnistry Of Health. Information use participants manual, Training Module. In: Policy Plan, and Evaluation
Directorate. Addis Ababa. 2018. 15 / 16 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 PLOS ONE Barriers and facilitators of health data use by performance monitoring teams 27. Vaughn VM, Saint S, Krein SL, Forman JH, Meddings J, Ameling J, et al. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285662
May 11, 2023 References Characteristics of healthcare
organisations struggling to improve quality: results from a systematic review of qualitative studies. BMJ
Quality & Safety. 2019; 28(1):74. 28. Pine KH, Bossen C, Chen Y, Ellingsen G, Grisot M, Mazmanian M, et al., editors. Data work in health-
care: challenges for patients, clinicians and administrators2018. 29. MOH. Health Data Quality Training Module Participant Manual. In: Policy P, and monitoring and evalua-
tion Directorate editor. Addis Ababa: Federal democratic republic of Ethiopia ministry of health; Noveber
2018. 30. Haftu B, Taye G, Ayele W, Habtamu T, Biruk E. A mixed-methods assessment of routine health infor-
mation system (RHIS) data quality and factors affecting it, Addis Ababa City administration, Ethiopia,
2020. Ethiopian Journal of Health Development. 2021; 35(1). 31. Slevin P, Kessie T, Cullen J, Butler MW, Donnelly SC, Caulfield B. Exploring the barriers and facilitators
for the use of digital health technologies for the management of COPD: a qualitative study of clinician
perceptions. Qjm. 2020; 113(3):163–72. https://doi.org/10.1093/qjmed/hcz241 PMID: 31545374 32. Hripcsak G, Bloomrosen M, FlatelyBrennan P, Chute CG, Cimino J, Detmer DE, et al. Health data use,
stewardship, and governance: ongoing gaps and challenges: a report from AMIA’s 2012 Health Policy
Meeting. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association. 2014; 21(2):204–11. https://doi.org/
10.1136/amiajnl-2013-002117 PMID: 24169275 33. Muthuri RNDK, Senkubuge F, Hongoro C, editors. Determinants of motivation among healthcare work-
ers in the East African Community between 2009–2019: a systematic review 2020: Multidisciplinary
Digital Publishing Institute. 34. Lagarde M, Huicho L, Papanicolas I. Motivating provision of high quality care: it is not all about the
money. BMJ. 2019; 366. 35. Weldegebriel Z, Ejigu Y, Weldegebreal F, Woldie M. Motivation of health workers and associated fac-
tors in public hospitals of West Amhara, Northwest Ethiopia. Patient Prefer Adherence. 2016; 10:159–
69. https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S90323 PMID: 26929608 16 / 16
|
https://openalex.org/W3177322031
|
https://www.um.edu.mt/library/oar/bitstream/123456789/78054/1/The_impact_of_COVID-19_on_hospitalised_COPD_exacerbations_in_Malta_2021.pdf
|
English
| null |
The Impact of COVID-19 on Hospitalised COPD Exacerbations in Malta
|
Pulmonary medicine
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 5,797
|
Correspondence should be addressed to Yvette Farrugia; yvette.a.farrugia@gov.mt Correspondence should be addressed to Yvette Farrugia; yvette.a.farrugia@gov.mt Received 7 February 2021; Revised 3 June 2021; Accepted 12 June 2021; Published 29 June 2021 Academic Editor: Zsofia Lazar Copyright © 2021 Yvette Farrugia et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Introduction and Aims. The first COVID-19 case in Malta was confirmed on the 7th of March 2020. This study is aimed at
investigating a significant difference between the number of acute exacerbations of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
(AECOPD) admissions and their inpatient outcome at Mater Dei Hospital during the COVID-19 pandemic when compared to
the same period in 2019. Furthermore, we aim to determine predictors of mortality in AECOPD inpatients. Method. Data was
collected retrospectively from electronic hospital records during the periods 1st March until 10th May in 2019 and 2020. Results. There was a marked decrease in AECOPD admissions in 2020, with a 54.2% drop in admissions (n = 119 in 2020 vs. n = 259 in
2019). There was no significant difference in patient demographics or medical comorbidities. In 2020, there was a significantly
lower number of patients with AECOPD who received nebulised medications during admission (60.4% in 2020 vs. 84.9% in
2019; p ≤0:001). There were also significantly lower numbers of AECOPD patients admitted in 2020 who received controlled
oxygen via venturi masks (69.0% in 2020 vs. 84.5% in 2019; p = 0:006). There was a significant increase in inpatient mortality in
2020 (19.3% [n = 23] and 8.4% [n = 22] for 2020 and 2019, respectively, p = 0:003). Year was found to be the best predictor of
mortality outcome (p = 0:001). The lack of use of SABA pre-admission treatment (p = 0:002), active malignancy (p = 0:003), and
increased length of hospital stay (p = 0:046) were also found to be predictors of mortality for AECOPD patients; however, these
parameters were unchanged between 2019 and 2020 and therefore could not account for the increase in mortality. Conclusions. There was a decrease in the number of admissions with AECOPD in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic, when compared to
2019. The year 2020 proved to be a significant predictor for inpatient mortality, with a significant increase in mortality in 2020. Hindawi
Pulmonary Medicine
Volume 2021, Article ID 5533123, 7 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/5533123 Correspondence should be addressed to Yvette Farrugia; yvette.a.farrugia@gov.mt The decrease in nebuliser and controlled oxygen treatment noted in the study period did not prove to be a significant predictor
of mortality when corrected for other variables. Therefore, the difference in mortality cannot be explained with certainty in this
retrospective cohort study. Yvette Farrugia
, Bernard Paul Spiteri Meilak
, Neil Grech
, Rachelle Asciak
,
Liberato Camilleri, Stephen Montefort, and Christopher Zammit
Mater Dei Hospital, Triq id-Donaturi tad-Demm, Msida MSD2090, Malta Yvette Farrugia
, Bernard Paul Spiteri Meilak
, Neil Grech
, Rachelle Asciak
,
Liberato Camilleri, Stephen Montefort, and Christopher Zammit
Mater Dei Hospital, Triq id-Donaturi tad-Demm, Msida MSD2090, Malta 3. Method including nebulised bronchodilators. Therefore, patients
admitted with an acute exacerbation of COPD (AECOPD)
are at risk of being unable to access necessary treatment
due to a change in guidelines which could have adverse
effects on clinical outcomes [4]. This study was a retrospective, observational, cross-sectional
study. Data was collected from electronic hospital records. No patients were approached or contacted at any point for
the study, and no unique identifying information was col-
lected. The study protocol was approved by the local ethics
committee
(University
of
Malta,
reference
number:
FRECMDS_1920_182). During the pandemic, the first COVID-19 case in Malta
was confirmed on the 7th of March 2020, imported from Italy
[5]. The first cases of local transmission in Malta were later
recorded on the 16th of March 2020. As the COVID-19 pan-
demic began to affect the Maltese Islands, local guidelines
were implemented for inpatients judged to have a high risk
of carrying the virus. Until these patients were confirmed to
test negative for the SARS-CoV-2 virus, the use of nebulised
medications, venturi masks, and non-invasive ventilation
(NIV) was limited given the risk of aerosol production. Therefore, this led to the alteration of local treatment guide-
lines for patients who presented with a deterioration in their
pre-existing respiratory condition, primarily asthma and
COPD, who are the main subgroup of patients who use these
treatment modalities. All patients over the age of 18, admitted to Mater Dei
Hospital with AECOPD between the 1st of March and 10th
of May 2020, were included in this study. The same period
from 2019 was used as a control. The diagnosis of an
AECOPD was based on the following criteria: change in sta-
ble symptoms including increased exertional dyspnoea,
chronic cough, and wheeze; the patient’s own past medical
history and social history, with particular attention to smok-
ing history; imaging; and a response to inhalers and nebu-
lised medications. There were no exclusion criteria. Patients
were considered negative for COVID-19 based on results
using reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-
PCR). During the H1N1 pandemic, a study about social behav-
iour found that even in the early stages of the pandemic, peo-
ple in Hong Kong started to avoid going to hospital due to a
fear of contracting the virus. This fear stemmed from previ-
ous experience during the SARS pandemic [6]. 3. Method In March of
2020, during the first wave of COVID-19, this phenomenon
was also demonstrated in Malta, where there was a significant
decline in patients presenting with acute cardiac conditions
such as myocardial infarctions. A delay in presentation to
the Emergency Department (ED) was demonstrated due to
a fear of contracting COVID-19 from within the hospital
[7]. Containment measures have also impacted hospitaliza-
tion rates of strokes [8] and myocardial infarctions [9] in
centres abroad. A single-centre study in Germany noted a
decrease in AECOPD admissions, and the authors postulated
that the reasons were multifactorial. The factors discussed
include possible COVID-19 protection with COPD treat-
ment, improvement in air quality secondary to lockdown
measures, and reduced face-to-face interaction, altogether
contributing towards a reduction in AECOPD admissions
[10]. Leung et al. (2020) also noted that data for patients pre-
senting with an AECOPD during this pandemic may be
skewed because such patients abstain from presenting to hos-
pital due to fear of exposure to SARS-CoV-2, or may seek
help late in the disease course, resulting in delayed manage-
ment and excess mortality in this subgroup [11]. We
hypothesised that the decline and delay in presentation of
AECOPD admissions noted in other centres was mirrored
locally. Assuming a population of 20,000 (4% prevalence of the
Maltese population as based on the European Health Inter-
view Survey 2014) and a confidence level of 95%, a sample
size of 377 was needed. Statistical analyses were performed
using IBM SPSS (SPSS Inc., USA). Variables included gender,
locality, medical comorbidities, management modalities
used, and inpatient treatment. All variables between the
groups were compared using chi-square analysis, Kruskal-
Wallis test, and Spearman 2-tailed correlations, accepting a
p value ≤0.05 as significant. The Fisher exact test was used
in cases where sample size was small, such as in the case of
non-invasive ventilation use, intensive care admission, and
tracheal intubation rate. To determine predictors of mortality in both cohorts of
AECOPD inpatient admissions, a univariate analysis of mor-
tality was carried out using the chi-square test for categorical
datasets and independent samples t-test for continuous
variables. The major limitation of the chi-square test and indepen-
dent samples t-test is that they investigate the relationship
between mortality outcome and a single predictor. 1. Introduction an overhaul with respect to patient management and treat-
ment protocols, aiming to limit the spread of COVID-19
among patients and healthcare workers. The World Health Organization (WHO) declared COVID-
19 as a worldwide pandemic on the 11th of March 2020. Since the first case detected in Wuhan, Hubei Province of
China on 31st December 2019, there have been 150.99 mil-
lion confirmed cases and 3.17 million deaths registered
worldwide as of 1st May 2021 [1]. As a result, people’s lives
have been impacted dramatically, economic growth grinding
to a halt, sending the world into a deep recession [2]. The
pandemic has also generated a challenge in the routine care
of hospitalised patients. Hospital administrations underwent COVID-19 is propagated by the spread of droplets, par-
ticularly by aerosol-generating procedures (AGPs) [3]. A
conflict of opinion arose among guidelines, where some
favoured the use of nebulisers as it was felt that this treatment
should not be classified as an AGP, while others recom-
mended abstaining from nebuliser use. In this context,
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) patients
must be considered as they frequently suffer from acute exac-
erbations
requiring
hospital
admission
for
treatment Pulmonary Medicine Pulmonary Medicine 2 3. Method It is well
known that a lone predictor could be rendered a very impor-
tant contributor in explaining variations in the mortality out-
come but would be rendered unimportant in the presence of
other predictors. In other words, the suitability of a predictor
in a model fit often depends on what other predictors are
included with it. To address this limitation, a logistic regres-
sion model was fitted to relate mortality outcome (dependent
variable) to the predictors of mortality described above. A
forward stepwise procedure was used to identify the parsimo-
nious model. 2. Aim The aim of this study was to establish the impact of COVID-
19 pandemic on the number of AECOPD hospital admis-
sions and their inpatient outcome at Mater Dei Hospital,
Malta, between 1st March and 10th May 2020, by comparing
to the corresponding period in 2019. Furthermore, we aimed
to determine predictors of mortality in AECOPD inpatients. 4. Results A total of 119 and 260 patients were admitted with AECOPD
during the period of 1st March to 10th May 2020 and 2019, Pulmonary Medicine 3 Table 1: Demographics and comorbidities of patients hospitalised with AECOPD and COPD pre-admission treatment. Patient demographics
2019
2020
Chi-square
p value
n
%
n
%
Gender—male
199
76.5%
89
74.8%
0.137
0.711
Gender—female
61
23.5%
30
25.2%
Active smoker (within the last 6 months)
102
54.0%
38
43.7%
2.524
0.112
Comorbidity
Ischaemic heart disease
80
30.8%
28
23.5%
2.028
0.154
Chronic heart failure
103
39.6%
47
39.5%
0.000
0.986
Hypertension
159
61.1%
78
65.5%
0.879
0.349
Diabetes mellitus
71
27.3%
34
28.6%
0.057
0.812
Asthma
17
6.5%
5
4.2%
0.811
0.368
Cerebrovascular disease
22
8.4%
9
7.6%
0.086
0.770
Peripheral vascular disease
19
7.3%
5
4.2%
1.361
0.243
Pulmonary embolism/deep vein thrombosis
11
4.2%
3
2.5%
0.688
0.407
Active malignancy
27
10.4%
18
15.1%
1.771
0.183
Psychiatric history
44
16.9%
23
19.3%
0.257
0.612
COPD pre-admission treatment
SABA
179
71.0%
90
78.3%
2.108
0.146
LABA
136
54.0%
57
49.6%
0.614
0.433
SAMA
158
62.7%
77
67.0%
0.622
0.430
LAMA
32
12.7%
21
18.3%
1.977
0.160
ICS
122
48.4%
45
39.1%
2.744
0.098
Home nebulisers
21
8.3%
6
5.2%
1.167
0.280
Home NIV
6
2.4%
3
2.6%
0.014
0.906
Home LTOT
64
25.4%
29
25.0%
0.007
0.935
SABA: short-acting beta-agonist; LABA: long-acting beta-agonist; SAMA: short-acting muscarinic antagonist; LAMA: long-acting muscarinic antagonist; ICS:
inhaled corticosteroid use; NIV: non-invasive ventilation; LTOT: long-term oxygen therapy. Table 1: Demographics and comorbidities of patients hospitalised with AECOPD and COPD pre-adm Demographics and comorbidities of patients hospitalised with AECOPD and COPD pre-admission treatment. ort-acting beta-agonist; LABA: long-acting beta-agonist; SAMA: short-acting muscarinic antagonist; LAMA: long-acting musc
orticosteroid use; NIV: non-invasive ventilation; LTOT: long-term oxygen therapy. Number of active COVID-19 cases
400
300
200
100
0
Number of daily COPD admissions to hospital
5
4
3
2
1
0
R2 Linear = 0.030
y = 1.93–1.87E-3
⁎x
Figure 2: Number of active COVID-19 cases (total and per day) vs. number of AECOPD admissions/day. Number of active COVID-19 cases
400
300
200
100
0
Number of daily COPD admissions to hospital
5
4
3
2
1
0
R2 Linear = 0.030
y = 1.93–1.87E-3
⁎x
Figure 2: Number of active COVID-19 cases (total and per day) vs. number of AECOPD admissions/day. respectively, demonstrating a 54.2% drop in admissions. 4. Results There was no significant difference in the mean age of
patients (70.9 years in 2020, 71.7 years in 2019; p = 0:347). The mean hospital length of stay for patients with AECOPD
was 6.76 days (5.89-7.6 days, 95% CI) and 6.74 days (5.48-
8.04
days, 95%
CI) in 2020
and 2019,
respectively
(p = 0:704). The mean number of previous hospital admis-
sions due to AECOPD per patient was 4.79 (3.48-6.11) and
Number of active COVID-19 cases
400
300
200
100
0
Number of daily COPD admissions to hospital
5
4
3
2
1
0
R2 Linear = 0.030
y = 1.93–1.87E-3
⁎x
Figure 2: Number of active COVID-19 cases (total and per day) vs. number of AECOPD admissions/day. Year of admission
Patient admitted in 2019
Patient admitted in 2020
Mean onset of symptoms to presentation (Hrs)
400
300
200
100
0
Error bars: 95% CI
Figure 1: Graph showing the mean time between onsets of
symptoms prior to presentation in AECOPD hospitalisations in
2019 compared with 2020. Year of admission
Patient admitted in 2019
Patient admitted in 2020
Mean onset of symptoms to presentation (Hrs)
400
300
200
100
0
Error bars: 95% CI
Figure 1: Graph showing the mean time between onsets of
symptoms prior to presentation in AECOPD hospitalisations in
2019 compared with 2020. Year of admission
Patient admitted in 2019
Patient admitted in 2020
Mean onset of symptoms to presentation (Hrs)
400
300
200
100
0
Error bars: 95% CI
Figure 1: Graph showing the mean time between onsets of
symptoms prior to presentation in AECOPD hospitalisations in
2019 compared with 2020. Figure 2: Number of active COVID-19 cases (total and per day) vs. number of AECOPD admissions/day. Figure 1: Graph showing the mean time between onsets of
symptoms prior to presentation in AECOPD hospitalisations in
2019 compared with 2020. The mean hospital length of stay for patients with AECOPD
was 6.76 days (5.89-7.6 days, 95% CI) and 6.74 days (5.48-
8.04
days, 95%
CI) in 2020
and 2019,
respectively
(p = 0:704). The mean number of previous hospital admis-
sions due to AECOPD per patient was 4.79 (3.48-6.11) and respectively, demonstrating a 54.2% drop in admissions. There was no significant difference in the mean age of
patients (70.9 years in 2020, 71.7 years in 2019; p = 0:347). respectively, demonstrating a 54.2% drop in admissions. 4. Results There was no significant difference in the mean age of
patients (70.9 years in 2020, 71.7 years in 2019; p = 0:347). 4 Pulmonary Medicine Table 2: Oxygen treatment received in AECOPD inpatients during the study period. 2019, n (%)
2020, n (%)
Chi-square
p value
Venturi mask used (n)
120 (84.5%)
58 (69.0%)
7.541
0.006
Normal face mask/non-rebreather mask (n)
7 (4.9%)
16 (19.0%)
11.508
0.001
No oxygen mask (n)
15 (10.6%)
10 (11.9%)
0.097
0.756 4.05 (3.32-4.78) in 2020 and 2019, respectively (p = 0:148). There were no significant differences between the two study
groups with respect to demographics, comorbidities, or
COPD pre-admission treatment (Table 1). The mean time from onset of symptoms to hospital
admission was longer among patients admitted in 2020,
when compared to those admitted in 2019 (232.8 hours
(95% CI, 148.08-251.41) vs. 199.7 hours (95% CI, 83.53-
382.19)), although this difference did not reach statistical sig-
fi
(
) (
)
Table 2: Oxygen treatment received in AECOPD inpatients during the study period. 2019, n (%)
2020, n (%)
Chi-square
p value
Venturi mask used (n)
120 (84.5%)
58 (69.0%)
7.541
0.006
Normal face mask/non-rebreather mask (n)
7 (4.9%)
16 (19.0%)
11.508
0.001
No oxygen mask (n)
15 (10.6%)
10 (11.9%)
0.097
0.756
Table 3: Escalation of care of patients hospitalised with AECOPD
(analysed using Fisher’s exact test). Escalation of care
2019 2020 Fisher exact test Df
p value
NIV (n)
24
9
1.589
2
0.457
ICU admission (n)
8
6
Tracheal intubation (n)
4
3
NIV: non-invasive ventilation; ICU: intensive care unit. Table 2: Oxygen treatment received in AECOPD inpatients during the study period. Table 3: Escalation of care of patients hospitalised with AECOPD
(analysed using Fisher’s exact test). Escalation of care
2019 2020 Fisher exact test Df
p value
NIV (n)
24
9
1.589
2
0.457
ICU admission (n)
8
6
Tracheal intubation (n)
4
3
NIV: non-invasive ventilation; ICU: intensive care unit. Table 3: Escalation of care of patients hospitalised with AECOPD
(analysed using Fisher’s exact test). 4.05 (3.32-4.78) in 2020 and 2019, respectively (p = 0:148). There were no significant differences between the two study
groups with respect to demographics, comorbidities, or
COPD pre-admission treatment (Table 1). The mean time from onset of symptoms to hospital
admission was longer among patients admitted in 2020,
when compared to those admitted in 2019 (232.8 hours
(95% CI, 148.08-251.41) vs. 5. Discussion In this study, we noted a significant decrease in the number
of admissions to Mater Dei Hospital in 2020, compared to
2019. Furthermore, an increased mortality was noted among
the 2020 cohort, where the year 2020 was found to be a signif-
icant predictor for inpatient mortality. A significant reduc-
tion in nebuliser and controlled oxygen use was noted,
although this did not significantly impact mortality. There was a significant reduction in patients who were
administered
nebulised
treatment
(salbutamol ±
ipratropium bromide) as an inpatient in 2020, when com-
pared to 2019 (60.4% [n = 58] vs. 84.9% [n = 191]; chi −
square = 23:162, p ≤0:001). In addition, a higher proportion
of AECOPD patients in 2020 received supplemental oxygen
therapy via a normal face mask or a non-rebreather mask
during their hospital stay (19% vs. 4.9%, chi −square =
12:024, p = 0:002) (Table 2). g
g
y
p
y
The fall in the AECOPD hospital admission rate between
2019 and 2020 in Malta is likely multifactorial. It is difficult to
quantify any single contributing effect and may include
potentially improved air quality due to a reduction in air pol-
lution and particulate matter after the closure of businesses
and industry and reduced air, sea, and vehicular traffic,
increased use of facial masks with a potential resulting
decrease in other seasonal respiratory viruses, mandatory
shielding of people (including those with respiratory disease,
those over 65 years of age, and those on oral corticosteroids
and immunosuppressant medication), and fear of presenting
to health services due to risk of exposure to the SARS-CoV-2
virus. A similar trend was noted in a study conducted in
Hong Kong. Chan (2020) reported that during the first three
months of 2020, the admission rate for AECOPD decreased
by 44%, compared to the average admission rate in previous
years. In this study, the decrease was attributed to masking
and increased social distancing [12]. In contrast to Hong
Kong, during the period studied, mandatory mask wearing No difference in escalation of care was noted between
2020 and 2019 (p = 0:457) (Table 3). The proportion of inpatient deaths with an AECOPD was
significantly higher in 2020 compared to 2019 (19.3% [n = 23
] vs. 8.5% [n = 22], respectively, chi-square 9.125; p = 0:003),
as demonstrated in Figure 3. 4. Results 199.7 hours (95% CI, 83.53-
382.19)), although this difference did not reach statistical sig-
nificance (p = 0:076) (Figure 1). A negative correlation was not noted between the num-
ber of active COVID-19 cases and AECOPD admissions to
hospital (correlation coefficient of -0.208, R = 0:03, with a p
value approaching statistical significance at 0.082) as illus-
trated in Figure 2. To correct for other predictors of mortality, a logistic
regression model was fitted to relate mortality outcome to
predictors described above (Table 6). The logistic regression model identifies four significant
predictors. Year is the best predictor of mortality outcome
and is followed by the lack of use of SABA rescue treatment,
active malignancy, and increased length of stay. The Nagelk-
erke pseudo R-square value (0.654) indicates that this 4-
predictor parsimonious logistic regression model explains
65.4% of the total variation in the mortality outcome. None of the patients included in the study tested pos-
itive for the SARS-CoV-2 virus on RT-PCR testing; how-
ever, not all the patients were swabbed. Among the 2020
cohort, 83% (n = 99) of patients were screened for the
virus, 62% (n = 74) were swabbed once, 17% (n = 20) were
swabbed twice, and 4% (n = 5) were swabbed three times. The number of swabs were related to hospital protocols
in place at the time which were largely based on the clin-
ical suspicion of COVID-19, the persistence of fever or
symptoms despite conventional treatment, or suspicious
findings on computed tomography. Patients were kept in
isolation until a negative swab was confirmed, as per hos-
pital protocol at the time. 5. Discussion To determine predictors of mortality, 2020 and 2019
cohorts were both included in a logistic regression analysis. When analysed individually using the chi-square test and the
independent samples t-test, four continuous variables and
nine categorical variables were found to be significantly related
to mortality outcome (Tables 4 and 5). Other predictors yield-
ing p values larger than the 0.05 criterion were excluded. 5 Pulmonary Medicine Death during admission
No
Yes
Number of inpatients
250
200
150
100
50
0
Patient admitted in 2019
Patient admitted in 2020
Year of admitted patient
Figure 3: Mortality in 2019 and 2020 during admission. was noted. This could be explained by fear of hypoxaemia in
admitted patients suspected of having the SARS-CoV-2 viral
infection. As mentioned above, guidelines concerning the use
of nebulised treatment differ widely between academic bod-
ies. NICE advises that as the aerosol from nebulised medica-
tion is derived from a non-patient source, it therefore does
not carry patient-derived particles and does not carry risk
for transmission of COVID-19. There was a shift from con-
trolled oxygen administration to normal face mask and
non-rebreather mask supplemental oxygen when comparing
2019 to 2020. This was due to infection control measures
implemented at the hospital during the study period limiting
the use of venturi masks. Somogyi et al. (2004) demonstrated
that venturi oxygen masks can produce a flow of potentially
infectious exhaled air during patient expiration [22]. Accord-
ing to Hui et al. (2014), the maximum distances of exhaled air
during the application of venturi masks and non-rebreather
masks are 0.4 m and <0.1 m, respectively [23]. Following
the study period, hospital policies regarding treatment algo-
rithms mentioned above were changed. This study demonstrated a significant increase in mortality
for AECOPD patients admitted during the 2020 COVID-19
pandemic, even though none of these patients tested positive
for COVID-19. Based on our results, we hypothesised that
lack of controlled oxygen and nebulised treatment would be
the predictors towards explaining the difference in mortality. On univariate analysis, thirteen predictors were found to
be significant predictors of mortality among all AECOPD
inpatient admissions. Among these variables, only differ-
ences in oxygen given upon admission and nebulised ther-
apy were significantly different between 2019 and 2020. However, on logistic regression, these two variables did not
persist as predictors of mortality. 5. Discussion Furthermore, from the pre-
dictors found to be significant (active malignancy, length of
stay, and SABA pre-admission treatment), none were found
to be significantly different between the two cohorts. Figure 3: Mortality in 2019 and 2020 during admission. in public was not yet implemented in Malta. The enforce-
ment of mandatory wearing of masks in enclosed public
spaces began on the 3rd May 2020 [13]. During this time,
people above the age of 65 years and those immunocompro-
mised were encouraged to isolate and to work from home. As
of Saturday 17th October 2020, it became mandatory to wear
a face mask in indoor and outdoor spaces [14]. It is a well-known fact that pollution contributes heavily
to COPD exacerbations, morbidity, and mortality [15]. A
study exploring the air quality of the major capital cities
worldwide confirmed that with the lockdown measures
imposed during the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a reduc-
tion in the concentration of PM2.5 (particulate matter less
than 2.5 micrometers in diameter) and an improvement in
the overall air quality, providing a potential factor for the
reduced COPD admissions rate [16]. A study conducted in
Bergamo presented evidence that particulate matter may
increase transmission of COVID-19. These results may
explain why areas having high levels of air pollution also have
a higher COVID-19 case concentration [17]. In contrast to
expectations, PM2.5 in Malta did not show any reductions
following the implementation of COVID-19 measures,
unlike nitrogen dioxide (NO2), as a major source of PM2.5
is dust from the Sahara Desert [18]. g
y
Several meta-analyses indicate that COPD patients are at
an increased risk of disease severity and mortality if they con-
tract COVID-19 [11, 24–28]. It is therefore recommended
that strict adherence to preventer medications is maintained
to limit the risk of exacerbations at such a time. The Cana-
dian Thoracic Society highlights this in their updated guide-
lines [24]. Kaye et al. (2020) found that this recommendation
resulted in a general increase in treatment adherence [29]. Of
note, during the initial phase of the pandemic, fewer patients
attended the outpatient department, resulting in fewer
COPD patients being seen by a respiratory specialist. This
may have led to poorer control of COPD and contributed
to the outcomes. There
are
various
conflicting
guidelines
regarding
whether nebulised treatment is appropriate during the
COVID-19 pandemic. 5. Discussion NICE and the British Thoracic Society
(BTS) recognise that unlike NIV, nebulised medication may
not be a viral AGP and does not pose a significant risk for
infection with COVID-19 [19, 20]. Contrary, the Global Ini-
tiative for Asthma (GINA) advises against nebulised medica-
tion use, advocating for the use of pressurised meter dose
inhalers (pMDIs) [21]. We cannot therefore explain the difference in mortality
found through the results of this study. These results may
indicate that the study was relatively underpowered, despite
all AECOPD admissions during the study period being
included. 6. Limitations The decrease in
nebulised medication administered and controlled oxygen
treatment noted in the study period did not prove to be a sig-
nificant predictor of mortality when corrected for other var-
iables, and we cannot therefore explain with certainty the
difference in mortality found in this retrospective cohort
study. were not reviewed as these are not available online. A dis-
charge summary was not available for cases where inpatient
death occurred, limiting the data available on severity of the
AECOPD and treatment received during the hospital stay. Data collection was also limited by the accuracy and com-
pleteness of data documented in the discharge summary
and online medical records. This study did not evaluate any
difference in outpatient mortality in those suffering with
COPD, so no comment can be made on any increase in
out-of-hospital deaths due to the lack of presentation sug-
gested by the decrease in hospital admissions. 6. Limitations Between patient groups, a significant decrease in the use
of nebulised treatment was noted, as well as a reduction in
the administration of controlled oxygen via the venturi mask All data were collected from online medical records; there-
fore, the day-to-day ward round notes and treatment charts Pulmonary Medicine 6 Table 4: Continuous variables significantly related with inpatient mortality (analysed using independent samples t-test). Mortality
Sample size
Mean
Standard deviation
p value
Patient age on admission (years)
Yes
45
76.71
8.064
<0.001
No
333
70.75
9.091
Total number of previous AECOPD admissions (n)
Yes
45
1.47
1.791
<0.001
No
328
4.67
6.644
Length of stay in hospital (days)
Yes
45
11.73
12.027
0.003
No
333
6.05
5.717
Days since last admission (days)
Yes
45
2.07
0.863
0.049
No
325
1.79
0.888 Table 5: Categorical variables that were significantly related with inpatient mortality (analysed using the chi-square test). Death during admission Alive on discharge Chi-square p value
Year of admission (2019/2020, n)
22/23
237/96
9.125
0.003
Active malignancy (yes/no, n)
16/23
29/304
34.289
<0.001
Hypertension (yes/no, n)
35/6
201/132
9.803
0.002
Ischaemic heart disease (yes/no, n)
17/23
91/242
3.996
0.046
Oxygen given on admission (venturi/normal face mask/no oxygen, n)
2/5/1
175/18/24
25.228
<0.001
Nebuliser treatment (yes/no, n)
1/4
247/68
9.631
0.002
Admission to ICU (yes/no, n)
5/40
9/324
7.859
0.005
SABA pre-admission treatment (yes/no, n)
18/16
250/82
7.865
0.005
Diabetes (yes/no, n)
18/23
87/246
5.713
0.017
ICU: intensive care unit; SABA: short-acting beta-agonist. cal variables that were significantly related with inpatient mortality (analysed using the chi-square test). Table 6: Predictors of inpatient mortality identified by the logistic regression model. Model fitting criteria
Likelihood ratio tests
-2 log likelihood of reduced model
Chi-square
Df
p value
Intercept
14.583
0.000
0
Year of admission
26.393
11.810
1
0.001
SABA pre-admission treatment
24.360
9.777
1
0.002
Active malignancy
23.580
8.997
1
0.003
Length of stay
18.558
3.975
1
0.046
SABA: short-acting beta-agonist. Table 6: Predictors of inpatient mortality identified by the logistic regression model. COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, when compared to 2019. The year 2020 was proved to be a significant predictor for
inpatient mortality, with a significantly higher inpatient
mortality rate in 2020 compared to 2019. References [18] Malta, Environment and Resources Authority, “A preliminary
assessment related to the impact of Covid-19 measures on
air quality in Malta,” Environment and Resources Authority,
pp. 1–10, 2020, https://era.org.mt/wp-content/uploads/2020/
12/Covid-19-and-Air-Quality_MT-Report_Final.pdf. [1] WHO, “coronavirus disease (COVID-19) dashboard,” https://
covid19.who.int/. [2] A. Brodeur, D. M. Gray, A. Islam, and S. Bhuiyan, “A literature
review of the economics of Covid-19,” IZA Discussion Paper
No. 13411https://ssrn.com/abstract=3636640. [19] Public Health England, NHS: National Services Scotland, and
Department of Health and Social Care, & Public Health Wales
(PHW), “COVID-19: guidance for the remobilisation of ser-
vices within health and care settings,” Infection Prevention
and Control Recommendations, 2020, https://www.gov.uk/
government/publications/wuhan-novel-coronavirus-
infection-prevention-and-control. [3] N. van Doremalen, T. Bushmaker, D. H. Morris et al., “Aerosol
and surface stability of SARS-CoV-2 as compared with SARS-
CoV-1,” The New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 382,
no. 16, pp. 1564–1567, 2020. [4] V. G. Press, A. S. Gershon, F. C. Sciurba, and D. P. Blagev,
“Concerns about coronavirus disease-related collateral dam-
age for patients with COPD,” Chest, vol. 158, no. 3, pp. 866–
868, 2020, Epub 2020 May 28. [20] British Thoracic Society BTS, “COVID-19: information for the
respiratory community,” British Thoracic Society, 2020,
https://www.brit-thoracic.org.uk/covid-19/covid-19-
information-for-the-respiratory-community/. [5] “Times of Malta Website,” https://timesofmalta.com/articles/
view/first-coronavirus-case-reported-in-malta.776288. [21] M. Cazzola, J. Ora, A. Bianco, P. Rogliani, and M. G. Matera,
“Guidance on nebulization during the current COVID-19
pandemic,” Respiratory Medicine, vol. 176, p. 106236, 2021. [6] J. T. Lau, S. Griffiths, K. C. Choi, and H. Y. Tsui, “Avoidance
behaviors and negative psychological responses in the general
population in the initial stage of the H1N1 pandemic in Hong
Kong,” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 10, no. 1, p. 139, 2010. [22] R. Somogyi, A. Vesely, T. Azami et al., “Dispersal of respira-
tory droplets with open vs closed oxygen delivery masks,”
Chest, vol. 125, no. 3, pp. 1155–1157, 2004. [7] N. Grech, R. Xuereb, K. England, R. G. Xuereb, and
M. Caruana, “When the patients stayed home: the impact of
the COVID-19 pandemic on acute cardiac admissions and
cardiac mortality in Malta,” Journal of Public Health, 2021. [23] D. S. Hui, M. T. Chan, and B. Chow, “Aerosol dispersion dur-
ing various respiratory therapies: a risk assessment model of
nosocomial infection to health care workers,” Hong Kong
Medical Journal, vol. 20, Suppl 4, pp. 9–13, 2014. [8] A. P. Kansagra, M. S. Goyal, S. Hamilton, and G. W. References Albers,
“Collateral Effect of Covid-19 on Stroke Evaluation in the
United States,” New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 383,
no. 4, pp. 400-401, 2020. [24] M. Bhutani, P. Hernandez, J. Bourbeau et al., “Key highlights
of the Canadian Thoracic Society’s position statement on the
optimization of COPD management during the coronavirus
disease 2019 pandemic,” Chest, vol. 158, no. 3, pp. 869–872,
2020. [9] A. Truffa Giachet, U. Barbero, F. Ugo et al., “Reduced rate of
hospital admissions for ACS during Covid-19 outbreak in
Northern Italy,” The New England journal of medicine (United
States), vol. 383, no. 1, pp. 88-89, 2020. [25] J. S. Alqahtani, T. Oyelade, A. M. Aldhahir et al., “Prevalence,
severity and mortality associated with COPD and smoking in
patients with COVID-19: a rapid systematic review and
meta-analysis,” PLoS One, vol. 15, no. 5, p. e0233147, 2020. [10] T. M. Berghaus, P. Karschnia, S. Haberl, and M. Schwaiblmair,
“Disproportionate decline in admissions for exacerbated
COPD during the COVID-19 pandemic,” Respiratory Medi-
cine, p. 106120, 2020. [26] Q. Zhao, M. Meng, R. Kumar et al., “The impact of COPD and
smoking history on the severity of COVID-19: a systemic
review and meta-analysis,” Journal of Medical Virology,
vol. 92, no. 10, pp. 1915–1921, 2020. [11] J. M. Leung, M. Niikura, C. W. T. Yang, and D. D. Sin,
“COVID-19 and COPD,” European Respiratory Journal,
vol. 56, no. 2, p. 2002108, 2020. [27] D. C. Sanchez-Ramirez and D. Mackey, “Underlying respira-
tory diseases, specifically COPD, and smoking are associated
with severe COVID-19 outcomes: a systematic review and
meta-analysis,” Respiratory Medicine, vol. 171, p. 106096,
2020. [12] K. Chan, “Significant reduction in hospital admissions for
acute exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
in Hong Kong during coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic,”
Respiratory Medicine, vol. 171, p. 106085, 2020. [13] “Masks to be required when shopping or on the bus,” 2020,
April 2021, https://timesofmalta.com/articles/view/masks-to-
be-required-when-shopping-or-on-the-bus.789347. [28] J. Olloquequi, “COVID-19 susceptibility in chronic obstruc-
tive pulmonary disease,” European Journal of Clinical Investi-
gation, vol. 50, no. 10, p. e13382, 2020. [14] “COVID-19 frequently asked questions,” 2020, April 2021,
https://deputyprimeminister.gov.mt/en/health-promotion/
covid-19/Pages/frequently-asked-questions.aspx. [29] L. Kaye, B. Theye, I. Smeenk, R. Gondalia, M. A. Barrett, and
D. A. Stempel, “Changes in medication adherence among
patients with asthma and COPD during the COVID-19 pan-
demic,” The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology: In
Practice, vol. 8, no. 7, pp. 2384-2385, 2020. [15] N. N. Hansel, M. C. 7. Conclusions No publicly archived datasets were generated. All available
data are included within the manuscript. In conclusion, we noted a statistically significant decrease in
hospital admissions of patients with AECOPD during the Pulmonary Medicine 7 We have no conflict of interest to declare. We have no conflict of interest to declare. [17] L. Setti, F. Passarini, G. De Gennaro et al., “SARS-Cov-2RNA
found on particulate matter of Bergamo in Northern Italy: first
evidence,” Environmental Research, vol. 188, p. 109754, 2020. Conflicts of Interest capital cities in the world,” Environmental Pollution, vol. 266,
Part 1, p. 115042, 2020. References McCormack, and V. Kim, “The effects of
air pollution and temperature on COPD,” COPD: Journal of
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, vol. 13, no. 3,
pp. 372–379, 2016. [16] D. Rodríguez-Urrego and L. Rodríguez-Urrego, “Air quality
during the COVID-19: PM2.5 analysis in the 50 most polluted
|
https://openalex.org/W4366002489
|
https://riviste.unimi.it/index.php/glocalism/article/download/21303/18915
|
English
| null |
Address to “Glocalism” by the Mayor of Milan
|
Glocalism
| 2,014
|
cc-by-sa
| 486
|
ADDRESS TO “GLOCALISM”
BY THE MAYOR OF MILAN GIULIANO PISAPIA
Mayor of Milan It is now little less than a year until the appointment
with Expo 2015. It will be the global event that will put
Milan at the centre of the international debate on the
theme of the second Milanese Universal Exposition after
the one held in 1906: “Feeding the Planet. Energy for
Life”. Food assured for all, water as a common, the agri-
culture of the future, the struggle against waste, these are
the emergencies of the Third Millennium. We want Expo
Milan to contribute to finding some concrete answers to
guarantee the planet a more sustainable and fairer devel-
opment. p
With Expo our city can and must develop a strategic
role in the promotion of a global pact for the right to
healthy and secure food, together with the 140 countries
and numerous international organisations taking part. The Milanese exposition, unlike the past, will not only be
a showcase for products and technologies, but above all it
will be a showcase for ideas and contents. For this reason,
we are working on a document in which the discourse on
the merits and the concrete objectives that Milan wishes
to submit to the world’s attention on the occasion of the
Expo will be specified. p
p
In the so-called “Urban Century” it is at local level,
from the cities, that true revolutions can start off. And it is
for this reason that last autumn in Johannesburg, on the
occasion of the C40 Summit – the cities committed on the
front of environmental sustainability – I also proposed the
idea of a “Protocol on Food Policy” to the Mayors of the
great metropolises. A solemn pact among Mayors, to be
signed during Expo 2015, for an intelligent and sustaina-
ble management of cities’ food policies. g
p
This issue of Glocalism, with the precious articles and
contributions by researchers from all over the world, as
well as key authors such as Romano Prodi and major
players possessing important experiences, such as Slow ISSN 2283-7949
GLOCALISM: JOURNAL OF CULTURE, POLITICS AND INNOVATION
2014, 1-2, DOI: 10.12893/gjcpi.2014.1-2.4
Published online by “Globus et Locus“ at www.glocalismjournal.net
Some rights reserved 2 GIULIANO PISAPIA Food or the Barilla Center for Food and Nutrition, seems
to us to be a particularly important contribution to the
debate. The reactions of readers on these issues will be
equally important. ADDRESS TO “GLOCALISM”
BY THE MAYOR OF MILAN q
y
p
My wish is that the effort carried forward by Glocal-
ism, and by organisations such as Globus et Locus, the
promoter, will be successful and that we will be able to
gain useful indications from it to inspire the further defi-
nition of the message to the world that we wish to come
from Milan in 2015 and for the years to come. This will be
the greatest inheritance of Expo Milan.
|
https://openalex.org/W4200186211
|
https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS/article/download/702/508
|
English
| null |
INTERACTIVE POWERPOINTS IN ONLINE TGT-BASED MODELS ON THERMOCHEMICAL MATERIALS
|
International Journal of Social Science
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 5,761
|
ABSTRACT The closure of schools due to the Covid-19 pandemic has forced all schools in
Indonesia to be closed temporarily, therefore learning must be carried out online. Online learning is commonly carried out with teacher presentations and assignments
therefore this makes learning monotonous and boring for students. So we need a
medium that makes learning more interesting, namely with interactive powerpoints. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of using interactive
powerpoints in the online-based TGT model on thermochemistry material. This type
of research is quasi-experimental research with a post-test only control group
design. The data collection technique used the technique of daily test tests,
documentation, and student perception questionnaires. The data were analyzed
using the normality test, F test, and t test with a significance level of 5%. The results
showed that before being given the treatment, the two classes were normally
distributed, homogeneous variations and there was no difference in student
absorption. After being given the treatment, the two classes had significant
differences in absorption. Therefore it can be concluded that there is an effect of
using interactive powerpoints in the online-based TGT model on thermochemistry
material. Keywords:
Interactive powerpoint
Online learning
TGT Model Corresponding Author:
Ratna Kusumawardani
Faculty of Teacher Training and Education,
Mulawarman University,
Email: nana chemistry@yahoo com Corresponding Author:
Ratna Kusumawardani Email: nana_chemistry@yahoo.com Email: nana_chemistry@yahoo.com International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online) International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online) 279 INTERACTIVE POWERPOINTS IN ONLINE TGT-BASED
MODELS ON THERMOCHEMICAL MATERIALS By
Ratna Kusumawardani1, Muhamad Hamami Nata2, Iis Intan Widiyowati3
1,2,3Chemical Education, Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, Mulawarman University
Email: 1nana_chemistry@yahoo.com 1. INTRODUCTION Thermochemistry as a part of chemistry has been studied since high school through chemistry subjects. However, according to research conducted by Zakiyah, et al. [1]chemistry is a difficult subject for most high school
students. The results of the study stated that the cause of chemistry is considered difficult because chemistry requires
abstract thinking skills, requires mastery of mathematics, and has tiered concepts. These three factors are contained
in the thermochemical material in which students will learn about heat, and calculate enthalpy changes with the help
of stoichiometric concepts. Based on the results of research Verdina, et al. [2], Hidayat [3] and Aprialisa and
Mahdian[4], it is known that students' understanding of thermochemistry is still relatively low because most students
do not reach the school’srequired standard. Chemistry subjects that are considered difficult by students make chemistry lessons often associated with
boredom, reluctance and failure for some students [5]. Chemistry lessons are associated with failure because
according to Putri's research [6], thermochemical material is categorized as difficult material for students to
understand. This is because the thermochemical material contains more computational material, while the majority of
students avoid subject matter that contains calculations. In addition, the lack of variety of learning models carried out
by teachers can make chemistry learning in class unattractive for students, causing boredom and reluctance. This
shows that a variety of learning models are needed to help students understand the material. Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS 280 International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online) Thermochemistry learning is better when implemented using a cooperative learning model, one of the
variations of learning models that can be used by teachers to learn is the Teams Game Tournament (TGT) learning
model as stated by Doymus, et al. [7]. The TGT learning model is one type of cooperative learning model that
involves collaboration between students so that it focuses on students. This model also emphasizes games and
tournaments between students to increase student learning motivation and change learning to be not monotonous so
that it is not boring and is expected to improve student learning outcomes. The advantages of this model are that it
can increase the motivation and participation of students with low academic abilities, foster a sense of togetherness
and mutual respect, and increase students' enthusiasm for learning. 1. INTRODUCTION Previous research, conducted by Arham and Dwiningsih [14] showed
that the use of Edmodo can be used as a medium to carry out online learning. The closure of the school at MAN 1 Samarinda due to the Covid-19 pandemic caused learning to be done
online. Based on this description, researchers are interested in examining the effect of using interactive powerpoint
learning media in the online TGT learning model on student learning outcomes on thermochemistry material at
MAN 1 Samarinda. 1. INTRODUCTION In addition, according to Ravinah and
Kusumawardani [8] the existence of a tournament in this model makes learning more fun, students are more relaxed,
and fosters a sense of responsibility and healthy competition. The TGT model is included in student-centered learning, it also has its own problems [9]. Students will
discuss with each other and make the teacher's task to gather attention from students more difficult, so we need a
learning media that can attract students' attention so that they can pay attention to the direction of the teacher and do
the learning stages well. Focusing students' attention can be helped by using learning media. Learning media is very diverse, one of
which is powerpoint. Powerpoint media has the advantage that it can help achieve learning goals more effectively,
help present abstract concept messages for students to be clearer, thorough, and interesting, can create a learning
environment that is not monotonous, and can increase student learning motivation. PowerPoint media has been
widely used to improve student learning outcomes, including research by Anita [10] and Warass [11] showing the
use of powerpoint media can improve student learning outcomes. Furthermore, the results of research by Kartikasari
and Nugroho [12] show that the use of interactive powerpoint can make students excited to learn, focus on learning,
and improve learning outcomes. Interactive Powerpoint is very effective to be used as a learning medium. This is
supported by Dewantara's research [13], resulting in a difference in the average student learning outcomes in Biology
subjects, where the class that uses powerpoint media gets a score of 91.56 and the class that does not use powerpoint
gets a score of 68.39. g
Learning outcomes are also influenced by the way of teaching and learning carried out by students and
teachers. The pandemic situation that occurred throughout 2020 forced a change in the way of teaching and learning
for students and teachers around the world. Learning, which is generally done directly in schools, now has to be done
remotely. This makes learning that is generally outside the network (offline) into learning that is carried out in a
network (online). The solution that can be done by teachers is to do online learning with the help of websites or
learning applications. One of the applications and websites that have been widely used is Edmodo. Edmodo can be used to create
virtual classrooms for teachers and students. 2. RESEARCH METHOD
Research Design The type of research used is a quasi-experimental design using one experimental or treatment class and one
control class, which aims to see the effect on student learning outcomes in both classes. The design used is a static-
group comparison design. The implementation of this research was carried out by giving treatment to the
experimental class in the form of using interactive powerpoint learning media with both classes using the TGT
model. Research Target The target of this research is students in class XI IPA 1 and XI IPA 3 MAN 1 Samarinda, each class
consists of 36 students. 2.3 Research Data The research data used in this study are data on student test scores, teacher and student activity data, as well
as data on student responses to online learning and thermochemistry learning carried out by researchers. Student test
results are obtained through tests carried out by students on thermochemical material. The results of teacher and
student activity data are generated from the observation process by the observer. Student response data obtained
through a questionnaire given after the entire learning process has been implemented. Journal homepage: Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.53625/ijss.v1i4.4702 281 2.4.3. Test Questions The test technique used is formative test/daily test. This test was carried out at the fourth meeting, namely
after all the material ended, 20 multiple choice questions were given. Daily test questions are made based on learning
indicators in all meetings. This test was carried out by all students in the control class and the experimental class. 2.4.4. Questionnaire Questionnaires on students' perceptions of online learning and the use of interactive powerpoints were given
to students after the entire learning process ended. Questionnaires were given to students via google forms. In filling
out this questionnaire, the researcher gave a statement, then the students chose the statement of disagree, agree or
strongly agree with the statement. In addition to choosing disagree, agree and strongly agree, students were also
asked to explain the reasons for their choice. 2.4.2. Observation sheet The observation sheet consists of a student observation sheet and a teacher observation sheet, both of which
are useful for knowing the teaching activities carried out by the teacher and the activeness of students during the
learning process. The teacher's observation sheet uses the Guttman scale while the student's observation sheet uses
the Likert scale. 2.4.1. Dokumentasi Documentation is used to obtain information about student grades obtained from chemistry teachers
regarding daily chemistry tests on the hydrocarbon solution material used to perform homogeneity tests, determine
the division of groups so that they are heterogeneous and to find out the list of names of students in class XI MAN 1
Samarinda who were used as research objects. 2.4 Research Instruments The instruments used in this study were documentation, observation sheets, test questions, and
questionnaires. y
q
2.5.1. Data Analysis of Student Test Results 2.5.1. Data Analysis of Student Test Results Data analysis on student test results was carried out on the results of daily tests of thermochemistry subjects. The data was processed statistically, using the Liliefors test, F test and t test. The Liliefors test was used to see
whether the data used were normally distributed or not, then tested using the F test to see whether the sample was
homogeneous or heterogeneous, and finally tested using the t test to compare whether there was a difference in
absorption in the two classes before treatment and whether there was an effect of using media. interactive powerpoint
learning after treatment. 2.5.2. Observation sheet Data processing from student observation sheets in both classes is calculated using the formula Data processing from student observation sheets in both classes is calculated using the formula:
P = score/(total maximum score ) × 100% p
g
v
g
P = score/(total maximum score ) × 100% Based on the resulting percentage of learning activities in both classes, the results are then categorized
according to the percentage table of student activities according to [15] below. Table 1. Percentage of Student Activity in Learning Table 1. Percentage of Student Activity in Learning
Percentage (%)
Category
0-20
Very less
21-40
Less
41-60
Enough
61-80
Good
81-100
Very good Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS 282 3. RESULTS AND ANALYSIS 3.1 Learning Outcomes of Experiment Class and Control Class 3.1 Learning Outcomes of Experiment Class and Control Class
Student learning outcomes in the experimental class and control class were taken from the daily test scores
conducted at the fourth meeting. Learning in the experimental class and control class is carried out using the TGT
model and through the Edmodo application, the difference between the two is that in the experimental class the
learning process is assisted by using interactive powerpoint learning media. The learning outcomes can be seen in the
following figure: Figure1. Average Value of Learning Outcomes from
Experiment Class and Control Class
65.28
47.78
0
20
40
60
80
Eksperimen
Kontrol
Average
Learning outcomes
Experiment
Control Figure1. Average Value of Learning Outcomes from
Experiment Class and Control Class Based on Figure 1, it can be seen that the learning outcomes of the experimental class are higher than the
control class. y
q
2.5.1. Data Analysis of Student Test Results This can happen because with the interactive powerpoint in the experimental class, the tournament and
learning process as a whole becomes more interesting than in the control class which only uses google forms. Experimental class students get a game display that is different from other assignments so it doesn't feel monotonous,
additional visuals and audio are more interesting, as well as discussion of questions. This can be seen from the
number of students participating, the number of students participating in the experimental class is more than the
control class, and the total score obtained in the experimental class is also higher. This is because the use of
interactive powerpoint media can increase students' interest and motivation. The results on the questionnaire given
by the researcher are depicted in the following diagram: Figure2. Diagram of students' perceptions of the influence of powerpoint
interactive on interest and motivation to learn
13.90%
69.40%
16.70%
Sangat setuju
Setuju
Tidak setuju
Very agree
Agree
Disagree Figure2. Diagram of students' perceptions of the influence of powerpoint
interactive on interest and motivation to learn The results of the questionnaire in Figure 2 as many as 69.40% of students agreed that interactive powerpoint
media for thermochemical materials could increase students' interest and motivation in learning. One of the factors
that influence student interest and learning is a varied or different learning process from the previous one [16]. In this
case, interactive powerpoint can make a difference in the learning process because it has a non-monotonous display,
a more attractive color display with a blend of colors, more varied images, and additional audio when students are
working on questions, answering correctly or when students answer incorrectly. question. This is in accordance with
the statement of Darmawan [17] which states that interactive powerpoint media can increase students' learning
motivation. This is also evidenced by the research of Saida, et al [18] which shows an increase in student learning
motivation due to the use of interactive powerpoints and Nursyam's research [19] which states an increase in student
interest in learning due to the use of learning media. Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS Journal homepage: h International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.53625/ijss.v1i4.4702 283 Another factor that causes the value of learning outcomes in the experimental class to be higher is the
feedback provided by interactive powerpoint. 3.2 The Effect of Using Interactive Powerpoint Media on Learning Outcomes 3.2 The Effect of Using Interactive Powerpoint Media on Learning Outcomes
The effect of using interactive powerpoint on student learning outcomes can be proven through statistical
tests. Statistical tests used were liliefors test, F test, and t test. The test results are as follows:
bl 2
l
f
A
l
i Af g
g
The effect of using interactive powerpoint on student learning outcomes can be proven through statistical
tests. Statistical tests used were liliefors test, F test, and t test. The test results are as follows:
Table 2 Results of Data Analysis After Treatment Class
Score
Liliefors test
F test
T test
Lcount
Ltable
Fcount
Ftable
tcount
ttable
Experiment
65,28
0,10
0,11
1,97
1,78
5,39
1,67
Control
47,78 Based on Table 2, the results of the Liliefors statistical test, show the value of Lcount < Ltable, which indicates that
H0 is accepted, the sample is normally distributed, then the value of Fcount > Ftable, so that H0 is rejected and the
variance of both is heterogeneous. Then the t-test performed showed that tcount > ttable, so the hypothesis Ha was
accepted and proved that there was an effect of interactive powerpoint learning media in the online-based TGT
learning model on student learning outcomes at MAN 1 Samarinda on the subject of thermochemistry. Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS y
q
2.5.1. Data Analysis of Student Test Results When the experimental class students answer incorrectly from the
questions given in interactive powerpoint, the interactive powerpoint will raise a voice stating that it is wrong and
provide discussion of the questions by showing the stages of working on the right questions This was not obtained
for control class students who when they answered incorrectly, they would only be told that the answer was not quite
right without any discussion at all. This increase is supported by the findings of Nahadi, et al [20], Vollmeyer and
Rheinberg [21], and Febriyanti [22] which state that feedback provided by teachers can improve student performance
during the learning process. Thus, feedback not only serves to determine the progress and difficulties of student
learning, but can also increase students' self-confidence. Feedback is teacher behavior to help students who have
learning difficulties individually by responding to student work, so that students become better at mastering the
material presented. This teacher's behavior is outlined in a more interesting discussion contained in interactive
powerpoint media. 3.2 The Effect of Using Interactive Powerpoint Media on Learning Outcomes
The effect of using interactive powerpoint on student learning outcomes can be proven through statistical
tests. Statistical tests used were liliefors test, F test, and t test. The test results are as follows: e Effect of Using Interactive Powerpoint Media on Learning Outcomes 3.3 The Value of Student Learning Outcomes is Still Below School’s Required Standard Research by Nugroho, et al [25] shows that one of the problems faced Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online) 284 by students is the difficulty of having a comfortable psychological condition when studying online. This was also felt
by students in the experimental class and control class, 91% of students stated that they had difficulty concentrating
when learning online. The reasons given by students also varied, such as interference from cellphones and tv, helping
younger siblings to study, monotonous teaching methods, tired of looking at screens all day and the most frequently
stated was homework that had to be done simultaneously with the learning process. Cahyani, et al [26] explained that
the conditions of the learning environment were not conducive and the difficulty of finding time to study for students
caused student motivation to decrease. Decreased student motivation increasingly makes students reluctant to study independently. This is not good,
because the success of online learning is strongly influenced by the independence of students, as stated by Nugroho,
et al [25]. The low independence of students during online learning occurs because students are not ready to learn
independently, because they are still accustomed to teacher guidance in a teacher-centered classroom [27]. The
impact of this is that students become overwhelmed when doing assignments. Questionnaires on students showed
students were overwhelmed when doing assignments. The number of students who feel overwhelmed when working
on assignments from all subjects is illustrated by the following graph: Figure 3. Students' Perception of Tasks during Online Learning
22
17
13
11
0
10
20
30
40
Kelas eksperimen
Kelas kontrol
Students
Setuju
Sangat setuju
Experiment class
Control class
Agree
Very agree Figure 3. Students' Perception of Tasks during Online Learning Based on the results of the questionnaire, students stated that this feeling of being overwhelmed was due to
the short deadline for collecting assignments and colliding with each other, plus a lack of understanding of the
material provided, and difficulty in asking questions. In addition, students also feel overwhelmed because the tasks
given by the teacher are too many. As many as 94% of students stated that the assignments given during online
learning were too many. This feeling of being overwhelmed then makes students more emotional than usual, such as
being more easily sad, confused, and even annoyed. 3.3 The Value of Student Learning Outcomes is Still Below School’s Required Standard The value of student learning outcomes on thermochemical material in the experimental class and control
class is still below the MAN 1 Samarinda required standard. Based on the researchers' observations, the school’s
required standard score at MAN 1 Samarinda was 75, higher than the learning outcomes in the experimental class
(65.28) and the control class (47.78). This is greatly influenced by the condition of students who have to study online
at home due to the Covid-19 pandemic. This is because there are several things that can affect student learning
outcomes related to the condition of students when studying online. This condition was obtained by the researcher
from a questionnaire filled out by students. The first problem faced by students while studying online at home is worrying about the Covid-19 pandemic. Of the total 68 students used as samples, 91% are worried about the development of the virus in Indonesia. Furthermore, 92.6% expressed concern that their family members would be exposed to this virus. This certainly
affects the psychological condition of students at the time of learning. Where the psychological condition of students
is very influential on student learning outcomes. Psychological conditions are internal factors that affect student
learning outcomes. This is in accordance with the results of research conducted by Mardatila [23] that student
learning outcomes in Integrated Thematic Social Studies subjects are influenced by psychological factors by 71%
and 29% are influenced by other student factors. y
Not only due to the corona virus, the psychological condition of students is also affected by the closure of
schools due to Covid-19. Research by Ardan, et al [24] states that due to school closures, students become more
easily tired and bored. This also happened to the experimental class and control class which based on the results of
the questionnaire showed 75% of students felt bored while studying at home, with the most frequent reason being
that they had difficulty socializing, both for discussion and for joking between lessons. However, not a few students
also feel more comfortable when studying at home because they can study more calmly and can concentrate better. Comfortable conditions when studying at home are one of the advantages of learning at home, unfortunately
this is only felt by a small number of students. REFERENCES [1] Zakiyah, S. Ibnu, and Subandi, “Analisis Dampak Kesulitan Siswa pada Materi Stoikiometri Terhadap Hasil Belajar
Termokimia,” EduChemia (Jurnal Kim. dan Pendidikan), vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 119–134, 2018. [1] Zakiyah, S. Ibnu, and Subandi, “Analisis Dampak Kesulitan Siswa pada Materi Stoikiometri Terhadap Hasil Belajar
Termokimia,” EduChemia (Jurnal Kim. dan Pendidikan), vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 119–134, 2018. ,
(
)
pp
[2] R. Verdina, A. Gani, and Sulastri, “Improving students’ higher order thinking skills in thermochemistry concept using
worksheets based on 2013 curriculum,” J. Phys. Conf. Ser., vol. 1088, 2018, doi: 10.1088/1742-6596/1088/1/012105. [3] S. Hidayat, “Pengaruh Model Problem Based Learning terhadap Hasil Belajar Kimia Siswa pada Konsep Termokimia,”
Jakarta, 2011. Aprialisa and Mahdian, “Meningkatkan Pemahaman Matematika Siswa Melalui Model Pembelajaran Koo
wo Stay Two Stray,” QUANTUM. J. Inov. Pendidik. Sains, vol. 1, no. 1, p. 41, 2010, doi: 10.17509/md.v11i1.37 [4] M. Aprialisa and Mahdian, Meningkatkan Pemahaman Matematika Siswa Melalui Model Pembelajaran Kooperatif Tipe
Two Stay Two Stray,” QUANTUM. J. Inov. Pendidik. Sains, vol. 1, no. 1, p. 41, 2010, doi: 10.17509/md.v11i1.3788. [5]
Nurhadi Pembelajaran Kontekstual dan Penerapannya dalam KBK Malang: Universitas Negeri Malang 2004 Two Stay Two Stray, QUANTUM. J. Inov. Pendidik. Sains, vol. 1, no. 1, p. 41, 2010, doi: 10.17509/md.v11i1.3788. [5]
Nurhadi Pembelajaran Kontekstual dan Penerapannya dalam KBK Malang: Universitas Negeri Malang 2004 y
y, Q
,
,
, p
,
,
[5] Nurhadi, Pembelajaran Kontekstual dan Penerapannya dalam KBK. Malang: Universitas Negeri Malang, 2004. [5] Nurhadi, Pembelajaran Kontekstual dan Penerapannya dalam KBK. Malang: Universitas Negeri Mala belajaran Kontekstual dan Penerapannya dalam KBK. Malang: Universitas Negeri Malang, 2004. [6] S. D. Putri, “Pengembangan Modul Berorientasi unity of Sciences dengan Pendekatan Contextual Teaching and Learning
pada Materi Termokimia,” Semarang, 2016. Si
k A
d S Ad
“ ff
f
i
l
i
i
hi
d l
i ,
g,
U. Simsek, A. Karaçöp, and S. Ada, “Effects of two cooperative learning strategies on teaching and learnin
mochemistry,” World Appl. Sci. J., vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 34–42, 2008. [7] K. Doymus, U. Simsek, A. Karaçöp, and S. Ada, “Effects of two cooperative learning strategies on
topics of thermochemistry,” World Appl. Sci. J., vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 34–42, 2008. [8] W. R. Ravinah and R. 3.3 The Value of Student Learning Outcomes is Still Below School’s Required Standard This feeling can affect the psychological condition of students
which can affect student learning outcomes. Psychological conditions that are not good will result in poor learning
outcomes, and vice versa. Based on the explanation above, the researcher then asked more specifically about how students perceive the
learning process in the thermochemistry chapter. Opinions of the experimental class and control class are illustrated
by the following graph: Figure 4 Persepsi Siswa terhadap Materi TermokimiaMateri
86.11
64.44
90.63
87.5
0
20
40
60
80
100
Kewalahan mengerjakan
tugas
Kesulitan mengerjakan UH
Students (%)
eksperimen
kontrol
Overwhelmed with
tasks
Overwhelmed with
chapter test
Experiment
Control Figure 4. Persepsi Siswa terhadap Materi TermokimiaMateri g
p
p
The graph above shows that students feel overwhelmed by the many assignments given by the teacher in this
thermochemistry chapter. In addition, students also find it difficult when working on daily test questions given by the
teacher. Consistently, the number of students who felt overwhelmed or had difficulty in the thermochemistry chapter
in the control class was higher than the experimental class which was assisted by interactive PowerPoint media. g
p
y
The feeling of being overwhelmed by students is also influenced by the thermochemical material which from
the beginning has become one of the materials considered difficult by students. Sutisna [28] stated that the average g
p
y
The feeling of being overwhelmed by students is also influenced by the thermochemical material which from
the beginning has become one of the materials considered difficult by students. Sutisna [28] stated that the average Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.53625/ijss.v1i4.4702 International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.53625/ijss.v1i4.4702 285 value of students' tests on thermochemical material was the lowest compared to other class XI chemistry materials. The research by Dewi, et al [29] shows that most of the students score below the school’s required standard and more
specifically the research by Rednasari [30] states that 48.8% of the students have not achieved the school’s required
standard. score. In addition, learning must be carried out online, making thermochemistry learning more difficult. 3.3 The Value of Student Learning Outcomes is Still Below School’s Required Standard Yulia and Putra [31] in their research on students' difficulties in learning mathematics online stated that online
learning made students feel difficult, reluctant to participate actively, and easily gave up on problems that had
difficulties or errors. The questionnaire given by Farida, et al [32] to their students resulted in a statement in the form
of chemistry learning that was deemed unsuitable for chemistry learning and some students stated that they did not
like online learning. Based on the explanation above, the use of interactive powerpoint media in the online TGT model on
thermochemical material has an influence on student learning outcomes at MAN 1 Samarinda. This is because in
interactive powerpoint media students can interact directly with the media, get a non-monotonous display, additional
visuals and audio that are more interesting, and get feedback in the form of discussing questions when incorrectly
answered instantly. Meanwhile, student learning outcomes that are still less than the school’s required standard can
be caused by several factors. The factors in question are the conditions of the learning environment that are not
conducive, too many assignments, short deadlines, the questions given are still too difficult, and students'
unpreparedness to study independently. This condition causes students to become more emotional, anxious, and
decreased motivation to learn. 5. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The researcher would like to thank all those who have helped in the process of this re
MAN 1 Samarinda who have permitted for me to conduct research. 4.
CONCLUSION The conclusion obtained is that there is an influence of interactive PowerPoint learning media in the online
TGT learning model on the learning outcomes of class MAN 1 Samarinda students on the subject of
thermochemistry. Suggestions for further research are to give questions with gradually increasing difficulty levels,
provide sufficient assignments during a pandemic and focus more on communication with students, and choose
learning models that are easier to implement when online. REFERENCES D. Ningrum, “Upaya Meningkatkan Minat Belajar Siswa Melalui Penggunaan Media Audio Visual Pada Siswa Kelas V
Di Sdn Manggarai 09 Pagi …,” Pros. Semin. Dan Disk. Pendidik. …, pp. 307–313, 2018. [17] D. Darmawan, Teknologi Pembelajaran. Bandung: PT. Remaja Rosdakarya, 2011. [17] D. Darmawan, Teknologi Pembelajaran. Bandung: PT. Remaja Rosdakarya, 2011. [18] L. N. Saida, S. H. Wijoyo, and S. A. Wicaksono, “Pengaruh Penggunaan Media Pembelajaran Interaktif Berbasis Powerpoint
untuk Meningkatkan Motivasi Belajar , Kebiasaan Belajar , dan Hasil Belajar Siswa di SMK Negeri 3 Malang,” J. Pengemb. Teknol. Inf. dan Ilmu Komput., vol. 3, no. 9, pp. 8695–8705, 2019. [19] A. Nursyam, “Peningkatan Minat Belajar Siswa Melalui Media Pembelajaran Berbasis Teknologi Informasi,” Ekspose J. Penelit. Huk. dan Pendidik., vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 811–819, 2019, doi: 10.30863/ekspose.v18i1.371. [20] Nahadi, H. Firman, and J. Farina, “Effect of feedback in formative assessment in the student learning activities on chemical
course to the formation of habits of mind,” J. Pendidik. IPA Indones., vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 36–42, 2015, doi:
10.15294/jpii.v4i1.3499. jp
21] R. Vollmeyer and F. Rheinberg, “A surprising effect of feedback on learning,” Learn. Instr., vol. 15, n
2005, doi: 10.1016/j.learninstruc.2005.08.001. and F. Rheinberg, “A surprising effect of feedback on learning,” Learn. Instr., vol. 15, no. 6, pp. 589–602
1016/j.learninstruc.2005.08.001. j
[22] C. Febriyanti, “Pengaruh Bentuk Umpan Balik dan Gaya Kognitif terhadap Hasil Belajara Trigonometri,” Form. J. Ilm. Pendidik. MIPA, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 203–214, 2015, doi: 10.30998/formatif.v3i3.125. pp
[23] A. P. Mardatila, “Pengaruh faktor psikologi dan faktor sekolah terhadap hasil belajar siswa di smpn 1 Tanjungsari,”
Universitas Lampung, 2017. [24] M. Ardan, F. F. Rahman, and G. B. Geroda, “The influence of physical distance to student anxiety on COVID-19,
Indonesia,” J. Crit. Rev., vol. 7, no. 17, pp. 1126–1132, 2020, doi: 10.31838/jcr.07.17.141. [25] W. Nugroho, E. R. Malinda, M. J. Mustika Rani, and B. Basori, “An Exploratory Study on Implementation of Online
Learning by Students During the COVID-19 Pandemic,” Pancar. Pendidik., vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 25–38, 2020, doi:
10.25037/pancaran.v9i2.288. p
[26] A. Cahyani, I. D. Listiana, and S. P. D. Larasati, “Motivasi Belajar Siswa SMA pada Pembelajaran Daring di Masa Pandemi
Covid-19,” IQ (Ilmu Al-qur’an) J. Pendidik. Islam, vol. 3, no. 01, pp. 123–140, 2020, doi: 10.37542/iq.v3i01.57. q
)
pp
q
[27] F. Magfiroh, A. N. Wahyudi, R. Putri, and N. REFERENCES Kusumawardani, “PENGARUH MEDIA MONOPOLI TERHADAP HASIL BELAJAR SISWA SMA
INFLUENCE OF MONOPOLY TOWARD LEARNING OUTCOMES OF HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT ON THE
SUBJECT OF Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengetahui pengaruh media monopoli dalam model pembelajaran kooperatif
tipe tea,” vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 20–23, 2019. p
pp
[9] M. A. Ramdhani, “Perbandingan Strategi Pembelajaran Teacher Centered Learning Dengan Student Centered Learning
Terhadap Hasil Belajar Pada Mata Pelajaran Tarikh Siswa Kelas Viii Smp Muhammadiyah 4 Surakarta,” 2014, no. 1, p. 18,
2014. [10] I. Anita, “Pengaruh Penggunaan Media Interaktif Komputer terhadap Hasil Belajar Siswa pada Materi Larutan Penyangga di
SMA Negeri 1 Pasie Raja,” Banda Aceh, 2015. [11] R. D. Warass, “Pengaruh Media Pembelajaran Microsoft Powerpointterhadap Hasil Belajar Siswa pada Mata Pelajaran
Akuntansi Kelas I SMA Pasundan 2 Kota Cimahi,” Bandung, 2016. [12] D. Kartikasari and G. K. Nugroho, “Media Pembelajaran Interaktif Mata Pelajaran Bahasa Jawa Pokok Bahasan Aksara Jawa
pada Sekolah Menengah Pertama Negeri 2 Tawangsari Kabupaten Sukoharjo,” J. SPEED Sentra Penelit. Eng. dan Edukasi,
vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 1–6, 2010. Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS 286 286
International Journal of Social Science (IJSS)
Vol.1 Issue.4 December 2021, pp: 279-288
ISSN: 2798-3463 (Printed) | 2798-4079 (Online)
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. [13] R. B. Dewantara, T. Jalmo, and Y. Berti, “Pengembangan Animasi Flash dengan Soal Interaktif Berbasis Powerpoint Materi
Sistem Pernapasan Manusia Kelas XI,” Pros. Smnas Pendidik. IPA Pascasarj. UM, vol. 1, 2016. [14] U. U. Arham and K. Dwiningsih, “Kelayakan Multimedia Interaktif Berbasis Blended Learning pada Materi Pokok Kimia
Unsur,” UNE, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 345–352, 2016, doi: 10.1017/CBO9781107415324.004. [15] S. Arikunto, Dasar-Dasar Evaluasi Pendidikan. Jakarta: Bumi Aksara, 2009. [16] K. D. Ningrum, “Upaya Meningkatkan Minat Belajar Siswa Melalui Penggunaan Media Audio Visual Pada Siswa Kelas V
Di Sdn Manggarai 09 Pagi …,” Pros. Semin. Dan Disk. Pendidik. …, pp. 307–313, 2018. [13] R. B. Dewantara, T. Jalmo, and Y. Berti, “Pengembangan Animasi Flash dengan Soal Interaktif Berbasis Powerpoint Materi
Sistem Pernapasan Manusia Kelas XI,” Pros. Smnas Pendidik. IPA Pascasarj. UM, vol. 1, 2016. [14] U. U. Arham and K. Dwiningsih, “Kelayakan Multimedia Interaktif Berbasis Ble
Unsur,” UNE, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 345–352, 2016, doi: 10.1017/CBO9781107415324 [14] U. U. Arham and K. Dwiningsih, “Kelayakan Multimedia Interaktif Berbasis Blended Learning pada Materi Pokok Kimia
Unsur,” UNE, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 345–352, 2016, doi: 10.1017/CBO9781107415324.004. asar-Dasar Evaluasi Pendidikan. Jakarta: Bumi Aksara, 2009. [15] S. Arikunto, Dasar-Dasar Evaluasi Pendidikan. Jakarta: Bumi Aksara, 2009. [16] K. REFERENCES Puji, “Analysis of Changes in Student Activity and Learning Patterns During
the Pandemic : Case Study of High School Students in Jember Regency,” vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 11–22, 2020, doi:
10.25037/pancaran.v9i3.297. p
[28] A. Sutisna, “… Konflik Kognitif Untuk Memfasilitasi Perubahan Konseptual Dan Peningkatan Keterampilan Berpikir Kritis
Siswa Pada Materi termokimia,” Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia, 2013. [29] K. M. Dewi, I. W. Suja, and I. D. K. Sastrawidana, “Model Mental Siswa Tentang Termokimia,” J. Pendidik. Kim. Undiksha, vol. 2, no. 2, p. 45, 2018, doi: 10.23887/jjpk.v2i2.21165. ri, “Deskripsi Kesulitan Belajar Siswa Kelas XI IPA Pada Materi Termokimia di Mas Ar-Risalah Padang,”
egeri Padang, 2019. 30] E. P. Rednasari, “Deskripsi Kesulitan Belajar Siswa Kelas XI IPA Pada Materi Termokimia di Mas Ar
Universitas Negeri Padang, 2019. [31] I. B. Yulia and A. Putra, “Kesulitan Siswa Dalam Pembelajaran Matematika Secara Daring,” Refleks. Pembelajaran Inov. Vol. 2, No. 2, 2020, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 327–335, 2020. ,
,
, pp
,
[32] I. Farida, R. R. Sunarya, R. Aisyah, and I. Helsy, “Pembelajaran Kimia Sistem Daring di Masa Pandemi Covid-19 Bagi
Generasi Z,” KTI UIN Sunan Gunung Djati, pp. 1–11, 2020. Journal homepage: Journal homepage: https://bajangjournal.com/index.php/IJSS
|
W2317090586.txt
|
https://zenodo.org/records/1693031/files/article.pdf
|
de
|
Das Gräberfeld am Windmühlenberge bei Klein- Quenstedt, Kr. Halberstadt
|
Praehistorische Zeitschrift
| 1,911
|
public-domain
| 3,400
|
274
Das Gräberfeld am Windmühlenberge bei KleinQuenstedt, Kr. Halberstadt
Von Hugo Mötefindt
E i n e d u r c h ihren S i e d l u n g s r e i c h t u m für die V o r g e s c h i c h t s f o r s c h u n g
b e s o n d e r s w i c h t i g e G e g e n d ist die U m g e b u n g H a i b e r s t a d t s .
H i e r ist der
B e r n b u r g e r T y p u s h e i m i s c h , 1 ) hier ist die K u g e l a m p h o r e n e b s t b e g l e i t e n d e n
F o r m e n zahlreich v e r t r e t e n , 2 ) hier ist die B a n d k e r a m i k , aus d e m s ü d ö s t lichen D o n a u l a n d e s t a m m e n d , e b e n f a l l s stark v e r b r e i t e t , 3 ) e b e n s o die M i s c h stile d e s R ö s s e n e r T y p u s 4 ) u n d d e r s c h n i t t - , f u r c h e n s t i c h - u n d s c h n u r v e r z i e r t e n K e r a m i k 5 ) s o w i e die sporadisch w e i t v e r b r e i t e t e n k u p f e r z e i t l i c h e n
Zonenbecher.6)
Ganz b e s o n d e r s auffällig j e d o c h t r i t t d i e s e starke B e s i e d l u n g in der ä l t e s t e n B r o n z e z e i t " ) h e r v o r : die A u n j e t i t z e r K e r a m i k ist
1) Grabfunde: Lausehügel zwischen Mahndorf und Derenburg: 2G Gefässe im
Museum Wernigerode. — Kloster Groningen und Sargstedt im Museum Halberstadt.
Eine grosse Ansiedlung auf dem Bocksberge bei Derenburg; unter den Scherben auch
mehrere Bruchstücke von Xragenflaschen (Museum Halberstadt und Wernigerode).
Nach A. Götze ( r Übersicht über die Vor- und Frühgeschichte Thüringens" in GötzeHöfer-Zschiesche, Die vor- und frühgeschichtlichen Altertümer Thüringens S. XXII) begleiten diesen Typus durch Thüringen und durch Brandenburg kleine vierkantige Beile
aus Wiedaer Schiefer. Dieses Beil ist in der Halberstädter Gegend heimisch: hier
stellt der Schiefer an und ist ausserordentlich viel verarbeitet. Allein in Gross-Quenstedt sind 43 Exemplare gesammelt, auf den Spiegelsbergen 158. (Bärthold, Führer durch
die vorgeschichtliche Abteilung des städtischen Museums in Halberstadt. 1911. S. 22.)
2) Ρ. Ζ. II, 317ff. — Ausserdem besonders schöne Exemplare aus Sargstedt in der
Sammlung Germann-Sargstedt (Publikation wird vorbereitet). Ein Scherben von Mahndorf und ein „weitmundiger Topf" von Zilly, Kr. Halberstadt, im Museum Wernigerode.
3) Viele Einzelfunde aus Wohn- und Herdgruben im Museum Halberstadt und in
der Sammlung Germann-Sargstedt. Vielleicht gehört hierher auch ein Grabfund von
Harsleben, Kr. Halberstadt (Museum Halberstadt), den ich demnächst zu veröffentlichen
beabsichtige. Zwei Gefässe von Derenburg, Kr. Halberstadt, und Scherben von Sargstedt im Museum Wernigerode.
4) Mahndorf, ein kesseiförmiger Becher. Altgatersleben, ein Becher wie Ρ. Ζ. I,
Taf. XXXVIII, 3. Beide im Museum Wernigerode.
ö) Eine Amphore und ein Becher im Kloster Groningen, eine Scherbe von Sargstedt
im Museum Halberstadt. Haus Neindorf: 2 Amphoren. Halberstadt: 1 Becher. Dardesheim: 1 Amphore. Museum Wernigerode.
G) Grabfund von Schwanebeck im Museum Halberstadt. Armschutzplatte von Zilly,
Kr. Halberstadt, im Museum Wernigerode.
7) Vgl. A. Götze, Bronzezeitliche Hockergräber bei Halberstadt. Ρ. Ζ. II, 60ff. —
Höfer, Frühbronzezeitlicher Grabfund von Derenburg, Kr. Halberstadt, Jahresschrift für
die Vorgeschichte der sächsisch-thüringischen Länder IX. l'.llO, S. Gl.
— Derselbe, Depotfund von Ziegelsberge bei Halberstadt. Ebendort V, liKJG, S. 94ff.
— Derselbe, Funde von Derenburg. Ebendort V, 1H0G, S 92 ff.
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 6/21/15 11:11 PM
Das Gräberfeld am Windmüblenberge bei Klein-Quenstedt
275
hier so zahlreich in Gräbern gefunden, dass man sie nach ihrem stärksten
Auftreten in Deutschland nach dem Vorgange Höfers x ) mit gutem R e c h t
Halberstädter Typus nennen könnte.
Besonders reich an Schätzen dieses T\pus ist das städtische Museum
in Halberstadt.
Von seinen Funden war jedoch bisher noch nichts veröffentlicht. Durch die Freundlichkeit des Herrn Oberprediger Bärthold bin
£ag?plan
ber Gräber a n Windmühlen berge
bei Klein-Quensfrör.
0
5
2?
15«·
•w
20..
<§> Gräber mit Inhalt
Ο Gräber teer
/
/
Humusschicht /*/ 50 cm
4/
tiefer
nur 20 cm
Graben
Abb 1.
ich in der Lage, jetzt all diese Aunjetitzer Funde veröffentlichen zu können.
Den Anfang mache ich mit einem Gräberfeld, das neben dem Aunjetitzer
Typus auch Funde anderer Zeiten barg, das aber besonders durch ein Grab
mit zwei übereinanderliegenden Bestattungen von jenem Typus ausserordentlich interessant ist.
Am Windmiihlenberge bei Klein-Quenstedt,
K r . Halberstadt, wurde in
1) Jahresschrift I X , 1910, S. i)3.
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 6/21/15 11:11 PM
Hugo Mötefindt
276
der Halberstädter städtischen Kiesgrube (Lageplan Abb. 1) im August 1903
dieses Gräberfeld aufgedeckt. Die Ausgrabung leitete der Apotheker M a a k .
Durch die Vorbereitung meiner Veröffentlichung von Kugelamphoren a u s
dem H a l b e r s t ä d t e r Museum wurde ich darauf geführt, auch die Gefässe
aus diesem Gräberfelde zu bearbeiten.
E s standen mir weiter keine Notizen zur Verfügung als ein Plan des
Gräberfeldes (Abb. 1), eine Zeichnung des Doppelgrabes (Abb. 2), beide
im Museum befindlich und von der H a n d Maaks herrührend. Durch Herrn
Mittelschullehrer Hemprich erhielt ich eine Reihe von Photographien, die
Maak auf K a r t o n aufgezogen hatte, und die von seiner Hand einige B e merkungen trugen.
Vermutungen, dass dieser oder jener noch Notizen über die einzelnen
Gräber besitzen könne, erwiesen sich bei näherer Erkundigung als trügerisch. Ein Besuch der Kiesgrube
Trcj^l lies Gratas 1
war gleichfalls vergeblich, da die
Arbeiter inzwischen oft gewechselt
hatten. So blieb mir weiter n i c h t s
übrig, als die F u n d e selbst und
die bei ihnen liegenden E t i k e t t e n ,
die wenigstens teilweise neben der
Inventarnummer auch die N u m m e r
der Gräber angaben. Durch freundliche Unterstützung des Herrn
Oberprediger B ä r t h o l d , dem ich
auch an dieser Stelle meinen herzlichsten D a n k dafür ausspreche,
ist es mir mit vieler Mühe gelungen, den I n h a l t einiger Gräber
zusammenzustellen.
=
schwärze £rie
IlllllMi diluvialerSanö
G r a b 1. Von diesem Grabe befindet sich im Museum eine von Maak
Abb. 2. K l . Quenstedt, Windmiihlenberg.
gezeichnete Skizze; eine andere,
gleichfalls von Maak herrührende
Skizze dieses Grabes habe ich durch Herrn Mittelschullehrer Hemprich erhalten. Beide
Skizzen stimmen im wesentlichen überein; nur auf der letzteren sind die Gefässe
in anderer Zusammenstellung eingetragen; ich glaube aber, dass die im Museum
hängende Skizze, weil sie allein von Maaks Hand herrührende ausführlichere Angaben über die Form der Gefässe enthält, die allein richtige ist. Nach beiden
Skizzen hatte das Grab folgendes Profil (Abb. 2): Unter der oberen, etwa
50 cm starken Schicht schwarzer Erde ergab sich eine in den diluvialen Sand
eingelassene Grube; Tiefe unter dem Erdboden bis zur Sohle etwa 2,50 m, Breite
unter der Humusschicht 2,30 m, Breite an der tiefsten Stelle 1,20 m. Ob diese Grube
aber rund oder viereckig war, ist nicht angegeben; das letztere ist jedoch wohl
wahrscheinlicher. Unter der oberen Schicht schwarzer Erde folgte in der Grube
eine zweite von etwa 80 cm Stärke, aus feiner schwarzer Erde bestehend. Hierunter lag eine 20 cm dicke Steinpackung, darunter als obere Bestattung ein
Skelett 1 ) mit zwei Gefässen.
Von diesen Gefässen ist das eine ein kleiner Napf (Inv. 294), Höhe 6 cm,
Mündungsdurchmesser 8,5 cm, von einer F o r m , die sonst mit Verzierung im
1) Ob gestrecktes S k e l e t t oder liegender Hocker, ist nicht angegeben.
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 6/21/15 11:11 PM
Das Gräberfeld am Windmühlenberge bei Klein-Quenstedt
277
Bernburger Typus häufiger vorkommt 1 ). Ein gleiches Gefäss wurde zusammen
mit einem Aunjetitzer Topf bei Gross - Quenstedt, Kr. Halberstadt, gefunden
(Museum Halberstadt).
Das zweite Gefäss soll eine Tasse sein; dieses Gefäss Hess sich leider nicht
mehr ermitteln. Auf Hemprichs Tafeln sind vier Gefässe als „Beigabegefässe des
grossen Grabes" zusammengestellt. Darnach müsste es sich um die Inventarnummer 278 handeln; nach meinen Ermittlungen stammt aber dieses Gefäss, eine etwas abgeschwächte Form des Aunjetitzer Bechers, aus Grab 7 (siehe
dort). Auf einer anderen von den Tafeln steht folgende von«Maaks Hand herrührende Bemerkung: „Schalenurnen aus den flachen Gräbern, die Tassen aus
dem tiefen Grabe." Darnach könnte es sich nur um eine von den Tassen
J.-N. 316 oder 317 handeln, von denen es sich nicht mehr feststellen liess, in
welchem Grabe sie gefunden. Sicheres lässt sich über dieses Gefäss nicht mehr
aussagen.
Unter dieser ersten Bestattung folgte wieder eine etwa 20 cm starke Steinpackung, und darunter eine zweite Bestattung, ein Skelett mit folgenden Beigaben: zwei Gefässe, ein Feuersteinmesser, ein Feuersteinschaber, ein Knochenpfriemen. Die Beigabegefässe sind folgende: a) ein typischer Henkeltopf mit vier
Füssen 2 ) (J.-N. 312, Abb. 4), über dem Umbruch verziert mit drei eingeritzten Linien;
Abb. 3—4.
Becher von Kl. Quenstedt, Windmühlenberg.
Museum Halberstadt.
Etwa '/s nat. Gr.
alle drei Linien laufen unter dem Henkel hindurch. Die Höhe des Gefässes ist
11,5 cm, der Mündungsdurchmesser 14,5 cm, die Höhe jedes der vier Füsse etwa
2 cm. b) Das zweite Gefäss ist gleichfalls ein Henkeltopf typischer Form
(Abb. 3, J.-N. 315), Höhe 10 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 15 cm. Über dem scharfen
Umbruch ist eine schwache eingeritzte Linie sichtbar, und zwar tritt sie auf
der Photographie deutlicher hervor als auf dem Original. Die anderen Beigaben
dieser unteren Bestattung sind ein Knochenpfriemen mit sehr scharfer Spitze von
6 cm Länge, ein Feuersteinschaber von 7 cm Länge und ein Feuersteinmesser von
4,5 cm Länge.
Dieses Grab ist f ü r die Chronologie der Halberstädter Formen äusserst
wichtig. Es zeigt uns, dass die als lokale Eigentümlichkeit anzusehende
Form von Aunjetitzer Bechern mit Füssen unter die ältesten Formen zu
rechnen sind. Es ist nur zu bedauern, dass sich über das zweite Gefäss
aus der oberen Fundschicht nichts ermitteln lässt.
1) Ζ. B. Osterode am Fallstein: M. Wernigerode. Jaliresschr. VII, S. 27, Taf. VIII, 6.
2) Parallelen zu diesem Geiäss: Klein-Quenstedt (J.-Nr. 311 und 613, J.-Nr. 311
sogar mit fünf Füssen); im Museum Halberstadt, ebenfalls von Klein-Quenstedt ein
Becher der im Museum Halberstadt ausgestellten Sammlung Ahlfeldt, Nr. 10 ein Becher
mit der Bezeichnung Halberstadt im Museum Halle. — Publikation wird vorbereitet.
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 6/21/15 11:11 PM
Hugo Mötefindt
278
Nun mag folgen, was sich aus meinen Nachforschungen über die anderen
Gräber ermitteln liess: die Gräber Nr. 2 bis 13 waren zum grössten Teil
Flachgräber mit (wahrscheinlich gestreckten) Skeletten; die Skelette lagen
in der blossen Erde, neben ihnen standen die Gefässe. Mehrere Skelette
hatten jedoch keine Beigaben; vielleicht sind dies die Gräber Nr. 3, 6 und 10.
Torger hatte am meisten Interesse für die Skelette, so kam das andere zu kurz.
G r a b 2. Afis diesem Grabe stammt vielleicht die Urne Abb. 5 (Inv. 262).
Jedoch ist nach einer Mitteilung des Herrn Oberprediger Bärthold es wahrscheinlicher, dass sie in Grab 4 gefunden wurde. Unter den von Maak herrührenden
Photographien steht angegeben Grab 5. Es handelt sich um einen Rauhtopf der
La-Tene-Zeit, 1 ) der mit Leichenbrand angefüllt war. Höhe 27 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 18 cm.
G r a b 3. Inhalt unbekannt.
G r a b 4. In diesem Grabe befanden sich drei Gefässe, „eine grössere
Urne und zwei einhenklige Schalen". Mit der grösseren Urne könnte nur das
Abb. δ. Kl. Quenstedt, Windmühlenberg. '/5 nat. Gr.
Museum Halberstadt.
Abb. 6. Kl. Quenstedt, Windmühlenberg.
V, nat. Gr. — Museum Halberstadt
Gefäss Abb. 5 (Inv. 262) gemeint sein (siehe Grab 2); über die anderen Gefässe
ist überhaupt nichts zu ermitteln.
G r a b 5. Nach einer Notiz von Maaks Hand steht unter der Photographie
des Gefässes Abb. 5 (Inv. 262) Grab 5.
G r a b 6. Inhalt unbekannt.
G r a b 7. Aus diesem Grabe stammt ein Henkeltopf mit bedeutend in die
Höhe gezogenem Umbruch (Inv. 278). Höhe 12 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 12 cm.
G r a b 8 lieferte einen geschweiften Becher (Inv. 282). Höhe 14 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 15 cm. Eine Zeitbestimmung dieses Bechers ist mir ungewiss.
Man könnte ihn wie den ihm ähnlichen Becher von Eisleben 2 ) als Glockenbecher auffassen; seiner Form nach lässt er sich mit den verzierten Glocken1) Ein ähnliches Gefäss aus dem La-Tenezeitlichen Urnenfriedhof von Waltemienburg, (Tulidenhügel), Kr. Jerichow I. Jahresschrift VIII. Taf. X X I I 64/68. — Die Jahresschrift VI S. 89 ff. publizierten Funde vom Bernburg-Walternienburger Typus sind im
Prov.-Museum Halle auch unter der Bezeichnung „Urnenfriedhof Walternienburg" (sie!)
ausgestellt, trotzdem diese Funde doch aus Skelettgräbern ohne Steinschutz stammen.
2) Jahresschrift VIII, Taf. III, 21.
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 6/21/15 11:11 PM
Das Gräberfeld am Windmühlenbsrgo bei Klein-Quenstedt
279*
bechern von Bernburg, Weibsleben und Rottleben 1 ) vergleichen; auch die Masse
würden hier am besten herpassen. Andererseits zeigt er jedoch wieder Ähnlichkeiten mit gewissen Formen der Hallstattzeit.
G r a b 9. Aus diesem Grabe stammen zwei Gefässe. Das eine (Inv. 313),
ist ein Aunjetitzer Topf mit in die Höhe gezogenem Umbruch; der Henkel sitzt
mit seinem unteren Ansatz u n t e r dem Umbruch. Höhe 11cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 11,5 cm. Das zweite Gefäss ist ein kleiner, aus rotem Ton gefertigter
Becher ohne Henkel (Inv. 314), der mit acht eingeritzten Linien verziert ist,
eine neue Form der Beigefässe vom Aunjetitzer Typus. Höhe 7,5 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 9 cm.
G r a b 10. Inhalt unbekannt.
G r a b 11. Aus Grab 11 stammt das Gefäss Abb. 6 (Inv. 319), ein Bruchstück einer Lausitzer Amphore mit Hohlkehlen. Höhe 18 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser nicht angebbar, da das Gefäss nur halb erhalten ist. Der Hals und Rand
ist wahrscheinlich ähnlich der Amphore vom Pohlsberg 2 ) gewesen, wenn auch wohl
nicht der Rand ganz so wagerecht wie dort. Eine Parallele ist mir unbekannt; es
ist meinem Urteil nach etwa Periode IV—V zu datieren.
G r a b 12. Aus Grab 12 ist eine einhenklige Schale bekannt (Inv. 271),
Höhe 10,5 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 29 cm. Der Henkel ragt über den Schalenrand empor; zu jeder Seite des
Henkels sitzt je eine kleine warzenförmige Erhebung; sie sind kein
selbständiges Gebilde, sondern nur
hochgezogene Teile desGefässrandes.
Derartige warzenförmige Erhebungen am Rande neben dem Henkel
kommen bereits bei Gefässen des
Bernburger Typus vor 3 ).
G r a b 13. Aus Grab 13 ist
ein Bronzedolch und ein Gefäss bekannt. Der Bronzedolch (vielleicht
Kupfer) ist ungefähr 10 cm lang Abb. 7. Schale von Kl. Quenstedt, Windmühlen(Inv. 320).
Wahrscheinlich hat
berg. '/s n a t · Gr. — Museum Halberstadt.
er drei Niete gehabt, von denen
nur zwei noch erhalten sind.
Eine gleiche Klinge in dem bekannten Depotfund von Pile in Schonen (Montelius,
Chronologie, Abb. 158); eine andere, von Freyburg, Kr. Querfurt, stammend, ist
jetzt abgebildet im Thüringer Inventarwerk, Taf. X 155.
D a s G e f ä s s A b b . 7 ( I n v . 318) e r w e i t e r t u n s e r e K e n n t n i s d e r
K e r a m i k d e r ä l t e s t e n B r o n z e z e i t . Es ist eine 9,5 cm hohe und 19 cm
an der Mündung messende Schale mit einem über den Rand emporragenden
Henkel. Parallelen sind mir nicht bekannt. Die Zusammengehörigkeit der Funde
ist vollkommen sicher.
X
Von den Gräbern 14—20 ist nichts bekannt. Wie auf dem von Maak
herrührenden Plan des Gräberfeldes angedeutet ist, beträgt hier die Humusschicht nur 20 cm; daher sind wohl die Gräber der Zerstörung durch den
Pflug ausgesetzt gewesen.
Von den Gräbern 15—20 ist j a ausdrücklich
auch angegeben, dass sie bereits leer vorgefunden wurden. Über Grab 14
liess sich nichts ermitteln.
Zu besprechen bleiben noch die Gefässe Inv. 277, 316 und 317. Gefäss
Inv. 316 ist eine kleine Tasse mit einem zapfenförmigen Henkel.
Diese
Tasse ist deshalb äusserst interessant, weil sie aus einem Aunjetitzer Becher
1) Jahresschrift VITT, Taf. I, 4 u. 5; II, I I a .
2) Jahresschrift 1905, S. 72ff.
3) Stockhofhügel bei Gröna. Merkel-Höfer, Katalog des Bernburger Museums S 10.
Nr. 26, S. 17 Nr 56.
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 6/21/15 11:11 PM
280
Hugo Mötefindt: Das Gräberfeld am Windmühlenberge bei Klein-Quenstedt
hervorgegangen ist; der Umbruch ist noch vorhanden, wenn auch nicht
scharf und bereits stark in die Höhe gezogen. An dem Umbruch sitzt kein
Henkel, sondern ein Zapfen, der nach Art der ansae lunatae gegabelt ist.
Länge des Zapfens 1 cm, Breite 1,5 cm, Höhe des Gefässes 6,5 cm, Mündungsdurchmeser 9,5 cm.]
Gefäss Inv. 317 ist ein Aunjetitzer Becher der abgeschwächtesten Form.
Der Umbruch ist ganz verschwunden; oberhalb des Henkelansatzes eine
kleine Auskehlung, eine Vorstufe der Hohlkehle1). Höhe 6 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 7 cm.
Gefäss Inv. 277 ist gleichfalls ein Aunjetitzer Becher, der oberhalb des
Henkelansatzes dieselbe Auskehlung zeigt wie der vorige. Höhe 8 cm, Mündungsdurchmesser 9,5 cm. —
Das ganze Gräberfeld soll von einem 50 cm tiefen Graben umgeben
gewesen sein (Abb. 1); näheres liess sich nicht feststellen.
Interessant ist die V e r t e i l u n g d e r G r ä b e r :
Von den sicher der Aunjetitzer Kultur angehörigen Gräbern liegen
innerhalb des Grabens folgende: 1, 7, 9; hauptsächlich also im weitlichen
Teil. Ausserhalb des Grabens liegen von den gleichfalls dieser Kultur angehörigen Gräbern die zwei 12 und 13; von Grab 12 ist die Lage verschieden angegeben: auf dem einen Plan östlich, auf dem andern westlich an
Stelle des Grabes 14. Grab 13 liegt östlich. Das der Periode IV oder V
angehörige Grab 11 liegt gleichfalls ausserhalb des Grabens südöstlich.
Innerhalb des Grabens liegt dagegen wieder das Grab der Latene-Zeit
(Grab 2 oder 4). Aus diesem Gräberfelde werden noch Scherben der
Latene-Zeit 2 ) im Museum aufbewahrt, aus welchem Grabe sie aber stammen,
ist nicht bekannt.
Es ist höchst bedauerlich, dass über dieses Gräberfeld keine näheren
Notizen vorhegen. Wir müssen uns daher mit dem wenigen begnügen, das
sich noch ermitteln liess, und so bleibt uns die Beantwortung vieler Fragen
versagt. Aus diesem Gräberfelde stammen vermutlich noch viele Funde im
Halberstädter Museum3), die nur die Bezeichnung Klein-Quenstedt tragen.
Soweit sie dem Aunjetitzer Kulturkreise angehören, werde ich sie in einem
später erscheinenden Aufsatz behandeln. Auch im Privatbesitz eines Magdeburger Herrn sollen sich nach einer Mitteilung des Herrn H. Hahne viele
Aunjetitzer Funde aus der Kiesgrube befinden.
1) Erwähnen möchte ich, dass bereits ein Aunjetitzer Becher mit wirklichen Hohlkehlen bekannt, aber noch nicht veröffentlicht ist: Mus. Blankenburg a. H.
2) Wie Friederich, Beiträge zur Altertumskunde der Grafschaft Wernigerode. V.
1888. Taf. II, 7.
3) Über einen verzierten von hier stammenden Hirschhornhammer werde ich
besonders berichten.
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 6/21/15 11:11 PM
|
|
https://openalex.org/W4239333681
|
https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671/PDF
|
English
| null |
Use of mHealth Apps and Wearable Technology to Assess Changes and Predict Pain During Treatment of Acute Pain in Sickle Cell Disease (Preprint)
| null | 2,019
|
cc-by
| 11,546
|
Corresponding Author: Corresponding Author:
Amanda Johnson, MD, BA
Department of Pediatrics
Duke University
2301 Erwin Road
Durham, NC, 27710
United States
Phone: 1 651 207 3255
Email: amanda@ohsu.edu JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 1
(page number not for citation purposes) https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 1Department of Pediatrics, Duke University, Durham, NC, United States
2Department of Computer Science & Engineering, Wright State University, Dayton, OH, United States
3North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC, United States
4Engineering Sciences and Applied Mathematics, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, United States
5Social Work and Clinical and Translational Science, Department of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, United States
6Division of Hematology, Department of Medicine, Duke University, Durham, NC, United States
*these authors contributed equally Original Paper Original Paper Original Paper
Use of Mobile Health Apps and Wearable Technology to Assess
Changes and Predict Pain During Treatment of Acute Pain in
Sickle Cell Disease: Feasibility Study
Amanda Johnson1*, MD, BA; Fan Yang2*; Siddharth Gollarahalli3; Tanvi Banerjee2, PhD; Daniel Abrams4, PhD; Jude
Jonassaint5, RN; Charles Jonassaint5, PhD, MHS; Nirmish Shah6, MD
1Department of Pediatrics, Duke University, Durham, NC, United States
2Department of Computer Science & Engineering, Wright State University, Dayton, OH, United States
3North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC, United States
4Engineering Sciences and Applied Mathematics, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, United States
5Social Work and Clinical and Translational Science, Department of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, United States
6Division of Hematology, Department of Medicine, Duke University, Durham, NC, United States
*these authors contributed equally
Johnson et al
JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al Use of Mobile Health Apps and Wearable Technology to Assess
Changes and Predict Pain During Treatment of Acute Pain in
Sickle Cell Disease: Feasibility Study Use of Mobile Health Apps and Wearable Technology to Assess
Changes and Predict Pain During Treatment of Acute Pain in
Sickle Cell Disease: Feasibility Study Amanda Johnson1*, MD, BA; Fan Yang2*; Siddharth Gollarahalli3; Tanvi Banerjee2, PhD; Daniel Abrams4, PhD; Jude
Jonassaint5, RN; Charles Jonassaint5, PhD, MHS; Nirmish Shah6, MD 1Department of Pediatrics, Duke University, Durham, NC, United States
2Department of Computer Science & Engineering, Wright State University, Dayton, OH, United States
3North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC, United States
4Engineering Sciences and Applied Mathematics, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, United States
5Social Work and Clinical and Translational Science, Department of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, United States
6Division of Hematology, Department of Medicine, Duke University, Durham, NC, United States
*these authors contributed equally Background Sickle cell disease (SCD) is a hematologic disorder that can
cause a multitude of complications throughout a patient’s life,
with pain being the most common and a significant cause of
morbidity. The pain experienced by SCD patients is often
chronic with acute vaso-occlusive crises that are unpredictable
and lead to frequent visits to the emergency department (ED)
and day hospital for management [1]. Of these patients, 1 in 4
will be admitted and can result in unplanned hospitalizations
with missed days from work and school, significantly impairing
a patient’s quality of life [2]. Acute pain management is
palliative, with hydration and pain control via narcotic and
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). With pain
being inherently subjective, both medical providers and patients
express difficulty in determining ideal treatment and
management strategies for pain. In the face of the continued opioid crisis, the search for more
objective measures of pain continues to rapidly evolve in
medicine, and studies looking at a variety of objective measures
to predict pain have been published in recent years. Among
these studies, the types of objective data utilized to predict pain
vary in invasiveness (vital signs vs neuroimaging) but show
promise for utilizing such data to predict pain. Bendall et al [11]
examined prehospital vital signs to predict pain severity using
ordinal logistic regression and found that elevated respiratory
rate, HR, and systolic blood pressure (specifically in older
adults) were associated with more severe pain. A more invasive
study by Lee et al used multimodal neuroimaging and HR
variability with machine learning techniques to predict clinical
pain in patients with chronic low back pain [12]. Owing to the growing volume of clinical data and the
requirement of high accuracy predictive models, machine
learning techniques have been increasingly utilized in medicine. They have been applied to multiple health care domains, from
analgesic response prediction to postoperative pain estimation
[13-15]. Machine learning techniques have also previously been
utilized effectively in SCD studies [16,17]. Our previous study
has also shown promising results in pain assessment [18]. Using
nurse-obtained vital signs for patients with SCD admitted for
pain crisis, our best model predicted pain with an accuracy of
0.429 on an 11-point rating scale (0 to 10) and 0.681 on a 4-point
rating scale (none, mild, moderate, and severe) [18]. Background In these
studies, machine learning can be described as a computational
method to build efficient and accurate prediction models using
known past information [19]. In the last several years, there has been an increasing focus on
developing and implementing individualized pain plans [3]. However, in addition to the slow adoption of these
individualized plans, difficulty also lies in understanding the
patient’s degree of pain and response to pain management. With
at least 1 in 4 patients with SCD seen in the ED being admitted
to the hospital, it is critical to determine accurately which
patients require additional pain management and which patients
can be discharged. More recently, technology has been leveraged to use mobile
apps for recording symptoms in real time and wearable devices
to provide more frequent physiologic measurements. The field
of mobile health (mHealth) has continued to grow and has been
used in a variety of different clinical settings. Many studies
have attempted to help patients and providers connect using
mobile technology to better understand and treat a multitude of
symptoms, including pain [4-6]. Many of the initial mHealth
systems and apps are smartphone-based and allow patients to
self-report symptoms and activity in addition to recording
objective data [7-9]. JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al Conclusions: The Microsoft Band 2 allowed easy collection of objective, physiologic markers during an acute pain crisis in
adults with SCD. Features can be extracted from these data signals and matched with pain scores. Machine learning models can
then use these features to feasibly predict patient pain scores. KEYWORDS pain; sickle cell disease; SCD; machine learning pain; sickle cell disease; SCD; machine learning TRU-Pain now allows the integration of wearable devices such
as the Microsoft Band 2 to passively obtain physiologic data
such as heart rate (HR), accelerometer activity, and galvanic
skin response (GSR) using the AppleCare Kit platform. Abstract Background: Sickle cell disease (SCD) is an inherited red blood cell disorder affecting millions worldwide, and it results in
many potential medical complications throughout the life course. The hallmark of SCD is pain. Many patients experience daily
chronic pain as well as intermittent, unpredictable acute vaso-occlusive painful episodes called pain crises. These pain crises
often require acute medical care through the day hospital or emergency department. Following presentation, a number of these
patients are subsequently admitted with continued efforts of treatment focused on palliative pain control and hydration for
management. Mitigating pain crises is challenging for both the patients and their providers, given the perceived unpredictability
and subjective nature of pain. Objective: The objective of this study was to show the feasibility of using objective, physiologic measurements obtained from
a wearable device during an acute pain crisis to predict patient-reported pain scores (in an app and to nursing staff) using machine
learning techniques. Methods: For this feasibility study, we enrolled 27 adult patients presenting to the day hospital with acute pain. At the beginning
of pain treatment, each participant was given a wearable device (Microsoft Band 2) that collected physiologic measurements. Pain scores from our mobile app, Technology Resources to Understand Pain Assessment in Patients with Pain, and those obtained
by nursing staff were both used with wearable signals to complete time stamp matching and feature extraction and selection. Following this, we constructed regression and classification machine learning algorithms to build between-subject pain prediction
models. Results: Patients were monitored for an average of 3.79 (SD 2.23) hours, with an average of 5826 (SD 2667) objective data
values per patient. As expected, we found that pain scores and heart rate decreased for most patients during the course of their
stay. Using the wearable sensor data and pain scores, we were able to create a regression model to predict subjective pain scores
with a root mean square error of 1.430 and correlation between observations and predictions of 0.706. Furthermore, we verified
the hypothesis that the regression model outperformed the classification model by comparing the performances of the support
vector machines (SVM) and the SVM for regression. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 1
(page number not for citation purposes) JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 1
(page number not for citation purposes) XSL•FO
RenderX https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 2
(page number not for citation purposes) Recruitment and Data Collection Following Duke Institutional Review Board approval, patients
presenting for acute pain crisis to the day hospital were
approached and asked to participate in the study. A convenience
sample of eligible patients who were willing to participate was
consented. A small number of patients approached declined to
participate, but this specific number was not recorded, and no
patients withdrew from the study after consent. Of the 27
patients consented, 20 were included in this study because of
insufficient data from the wearable device in 7 patients. Patients
were consented Monday through Friday based on the availability
of study team members. Study duration was variable based on
patient’s length of stay in the day hospital. The study included
a one-time visit only. Patients might have had other chronic
medical conditions but were not excluded based on these
conditions, and subgroup analysis was not undertaken. Patients were also provided with an iPad with the TRU-Pain
app to record pain scores and other symptoms in conjunction
with nurse-reported pain scores using a visual analog scale from
0 (none) to 10 (worst). Each patient was instructed on the use
of the TRU-Pain app. The TRU-Pain app allowed patients to
use a slider bar to rate their pain on the visual analog scale from
0 to 10. The app also allowed patients to note other symptoms
and rate general health and mood (scale of 0 to 10). The
TRU-Pain app implemented these general health and mood
measures and a platform upgrade to AppleCare Kit, replacing
our previous app, Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Applications to
Record Symptoms via Technology. Nursing pain scores were
assumed to be entered at the time they were obtained. Following consent, a Microsoft Band 2 wearable was placed
on the patient’s wrist. The Microsoft Band 2 is a commercially
available smart band that is compatible with many smartphones;
it has multiple objective sensors including HR monitor, a 3-axis
accelerometer and gyrometer, a GSR sensor, and a skin
temperature sensor. The physiologic and activity measures
utilized in the study are shown in Textbox 1. Overall, we
adopted 8 wearable sensor signals to estimate pain scores (HR,
R-R interval [RR; time between peak of QRS complex of
electrocardiogram to subsequent QRS electrocardiogram peak],
GSR, skin temperature, accelerometer [Z axis], angular velocity
[Y axis], angular velocity [Z axis], and steps). Objectives Previous study by our group has supported
the use of temperature, systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood
pressure, oxygen saturation, and respiratory rate as statistically
significant predictors in pain for SCD patients [18]. from a wearable device and then utilize machine learning
techniques to accurately predict pain scores? from a wearable device and then utilize machine learning
techniques to accurately predict pain scores? Recruitment and Data Collection These 8 signals
were chosen partially based on signals readily available on the Both objective data from the Microsoft Band 2 and the
TRU-Pain app were uploaded to a Health Insurance Portability
and Accountability Act–compliant Citrix ShareFile cloud-based
server. Patients were continuously monitored while in the day
hospital, and at the time of discharge, the devices were returned. If patients were admitted, data before transfer were included
even if the devices traveled with the patient during admission. Patients were not provided specific questions regarding
acceptability and feasibility of participation, but the feasibility
of the study was determined by the accuracy of machine learning
algorithms in predicting pain scores. acceleration in Z direction is included in this study; angular velocity in X direction was not correctly captured and was excluded from the dataset). •
Heart rate
•
R-R interval
•
Galvanic skin response
•
Skin temperature
•
Acceleration in X direction
•
Acceleration in Y direction
•
Acceleration in Z direction
•
Angular velocity in X direction
•
Angular velocity in Y direction
•
Angular velocity in Z direction
•
Steps performed: time stamp matching, feature extraction, and feature
selection. In time stamp matching, pain scores had to be matched
with the wearable sensor data using the time stamp as close to
the exact time of data collection as possible. However, the
wearable sensor data samples were collected typically per Objectives We now aim to use physiologic data obtained from a wearable
device matched with mobile app and nurse-obtained pain scores
to predict pain scores at between-subject level using machine
learning techniques. The combination of mobile apps and
wearable sensors has been used in several studies to provide
novel solutions to different health problems [20-22]. To date,
there has been a paucity of research in SCD focused on pain
prediction, despite the critical need. The ability to objectively
and accurately predict pain severity and onset could result in
more prompt and effective treatment of pain crises, leading to
improved outcomes, as well as encouraging more diligent use
of medications [23,24]. Using our past experience, our
hypothesis for this study was as follows: For SCD patients
presenting in acute pain, can we feasibly obtain objective data We previously reported the usefulness and validity of our
mHealth app for patients with SCD [7-9]. The app has
undergone multiple upgrades in the user interface based on
feedback, as we continue to foster patient engagement. We have
included additional health and mood questions, and the app was
recently expanded to specific patient populations including bone
marrow transplant patients [10]. In this study, we used
Technology Resources to Understand Pain (TRU-Pain) app,
which allows patients to record pain and other symptoms
throughout their treatment, as described above [7]. In addition, XSL•FO
RenderX XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al Microsoft Band 2 as well as previously postulated physiologic
correlations with pain. Patients in more pain typically experience
higher HR and will move less frequently in the setting of pain
[25,26]. Furthermore, greater RR variability has been correlated
with better pain treatment outcomes [27]. However, these
objective measures have not been well established on their own
to correlate with pain. Previous study by our group has supported
the use of temperature, systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood
pressure, oxygen saturation, and respiratory rate as statistically
significant predictors in pain for SCD patients [18]. Microsoft Band 2 as well as previously postulated physiologic
correlations with pain. Patients in more pain typically experience
higher HR and will move less frequently in the setting of pain
[25,26]. Furthermore, greater RR variability has been correlated
with better pain treatment outcomes [27]. However, these
objective measures have not been well established on their own
to correlate with pain. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 3
(page number not for citation purposes) https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 Textbox 1. Physiologic and activity measures from Microsoft Band 2 (values for acceleration in X and Y directions equal that of Z direction—only
acceleration in Z direction is included in this study; angular velocity in X direction was not correctly captured and was excluded from the dataset). Data Preprocessing To apply machine learning analysis on the collected wearable
sensor data (physiologic and activity signals from the Microsoft
Band 2 in Textbox 1), 3 data preprocessing steps need to be https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 3
(page number not for citation purposes) JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 3
(page number not for citation purposes) XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al average filter was applied to raw sensor signals to remove noise. The moving average filter is the most common filter in digital
signal processing to reduce random noise [28]. Then, 8 statistical
features (as described in Table 1) were extracted for each of the
8 signals. These extracted features represented the properties
of the original raw signals while reducing the volume of data. second, and the pain scores were collected at varying times
throughout the stay, with time stamp formatted in hours and
minutes only. To complete this best possible match, each pain
score was matched with the 1-min long wearable sensor data
segment that was tracked at the same hour and minute. By
assuming that pain scores usually do not change rapidly within
a short period, we also matched the app pain scores without
exact time matching to the wearable sensor data when the time
stamp difference was less than 10 min. second, and the pain scores were collected at varying times
throughout the stay, with time stamp formatted in hours and
minutes only. To complete this best possible match, each pain
score was matched with the 1-min long wearable sensor data
segment that was tracked at the same hour and minute. By
assuming that pain scores usually do not change rapidly within
a short period, we also matched the app pain scores without
exact time matching to the wearable sensor data when the time
stamp difference was less than 10 min. The feature extraction yielded up to total 64 (8×8) features. Given the relatively small sample size (107), a feature selection
method was applied (wrapper method) to remove irrelevant or
redundant features and to further reduce the number of features
[29]. The wrapper method has been reported to be able to
improve the predictor performance when compared with variable
ranking methods [29]. Data Preprocessing The basic idea of the wrapper method is
selecting the subset of features that yields the best possible
performance of a given learning algorithm. A total of 2 types
of search strategies are widely adopted in the wrapper method:
forward selection and backward elimination. In forward
selection, one starts with an empty set and features are
progressively added into the subset, whereas in backward
elimination, one starts with the full feature set and progressively
eliminates the feature with worst performance [30]. We obtained 40 matched records containing a 1-min long
wearable sensor data segment and a pain score from the mobile
app that logged at the same (or approximately the same) period. However, a sample size of 40 was not sufficient for the intended
data analysis. To further increase the sample size, we included
nurse-documented pain scores in our dataset. Our group made
the assumption that nurse-documented scores were similar to
patient-reported scores in the app. Nurse-documented pain
scores were matched with wearable sensor data using the within
10-min time stamps methodology as described above. By
including nurse-documented pain scores, our final dataset
contained 107 data samples (40 mobile app and 67 nursing
notes). Table 2 shows the reduced feature set using the wrapper method
with forward selection. A total of 10 features were selected from
5 signals. The table also illustrates the reduced feature set with
backward elimination, which contains total 14 features from 7
signals. In both feature selection approaches, no features of
acceleration in Z direction (AccZ) were selected, which might
be because the information contained in AccZ was already
covered by Steps. After time stamp matching, each pain score was mapped to a
1-min long wearable sensor data segment that included 8 signals
as mentioned in Textbox 1 above. As the sensor signal was
recorded typically every second, a 1-min long segment having
8 signals contained 480 (8×60) data points. It is difficult to
process raw sensor signals directly in any analytical task. Therefore, we transformed raw sensor signals to a more suitable
data representation format by feature extraction. First, a moving Table 1. List of features extracted from wearable signals. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 4
(page number not for citation purposes) aRMS: root mean square. bNot applicable GPR is one of the Bayesian learning methods in which a
previous distribution over the mapping function between inputs
and outputs is conditioned on observations (training process). Then, the posterior distribution can be used to make predictions
[34]. GPR provides a powerful way to quantify the uncertainty
in model estimations to make more robust predictions on new
test data. Finally, SVM are usually applied to classification
problems. In classification, the SVM model maps the input
samples into the feature space, then creates a decision surface
among classes with the largest distance to any data point. However, it can also be applied to regression problems where
we seek to find a continuous function that maps input variables
to output variables, called SVR. For SVR, the goal is to find a
function that deviates from the training output by a value no
greater than a certain distance for each training point, and at the
same time, is as flat as possible [35]. The nonlinearity of the
algorithm can be obtained by utilizing kernel modulations. Machine Learning Techniques The prediction of numeric pain score, the main study outcome,
can be treated as either a regression problem or a classification
problem. As the pain scores from app data are float numbers,
it is more reasonable to build a regression model to provide
continuous estimation of the target variable. More importantly,
there is only 1 target variable (pain score) in the regression
model. In contrast, there will be 11 classes if pain is treated as
a classification problem, as there are 11 distinct possible pain
scores (0 to 10). The number of classes can be reduced by
employing a sparse rating scale. Using a widely adopted more
sparse 4-point rating scale, the 11-point pain scores can be
categorized as none (0), mild (1-3), moderate (4-6), and severe
(7-10) [31]. However, because of our small sample size, we
hold the hypothesis that the regression model is more appropriate
than the classification model in this study. We adopted 4 widely
used regression algorithms in our analyses: Ridge regression
(Ridge), Lasso regression (Lasso), Gaussian process for
regression (GPR), and support vector machines for regression
(SVR). In addition, we applied support vector machines (SVM)
to predict the pain scores using the 4-point rating scale and
compared the results with SVR. https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 5
(page number not for citation purposes) Data Preprocessing Description
Feature
Average value of the signal
Mean
Amount of variation of the signal
Standard deviation
Average rate of change of the signal
Mean of derivative
Square root of the mean of the squares of a set of values
RMSa
Difference between the maximum and minimum peak
Peak to peak
The ratio of the largest absolute value to the RMS value
Peak to RMS
Number of local maximums (peaks)
Number of peaks
Sum of the absolute squares of time-domain samples divided by the length
Power
aRMS: root mean square. Table 1. List of features extracted from wearable signals. https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 4
(page number not for citation purposes) XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Table 2. Signals and reduced feature sets. Feature
Signal
Backward elimination
Forward selection
Heart rate
•
•
Power
Mean of derivative
•
Number of peaks
R-R interval
•
•
Standard deviation
Number of peaks
•
Peak to RMSa
Galvanic skin response
•
•
Mean
Mean
•
•
Peak to RMS
Peak to peak
Steps
•
•
Number of peaks
Mean
•
•
RMS
Power
•
Peak to peak
Skin temperature
•
•
Power
Peak to RMS
•
Mean of derivative
•
Number of peaks
—b
Angular velocity in Y direction
•
RMS
•
Number of peaks
—
Angular velocity in Z direction
•
Peak to RMS
•
Number of peaks
aRMS: root mean square. b Table 2. Signals and reduced feature sets. Overview A total of 20 adult patients (of 27 consented) had complete data. Median age was 28 years, with a range of 20 years to 66 years
(Table 3). A total of 11 (11/20, 55%) patients were female,
whereas 9 (9/20, 45%) were male. Moreover, 10 patients (10/20,
50%) had type SS SCD, 8 (8/20, 40%) had type SC, and 2 (2/20,
10%) had S beta thalassemia. The average length of stay in the
day hospital was 3.79 (SD 2.23) hours. In addition, 2 patients
were subsequently admitted to the hospital. Nursing pain scores
decreased in 16 out of 20 patients (80%). Patients had an average
decrease in visual analog pain score of 2.75 (SD 2.34). A total For linear models, we utilized Ridge and Lasso [32,33]. Linear
models are easy to fit and interpret, but they cannot model the
nonlinear relationships between explanatory variables and the
outcome variable. The other 2 algorithms are nonlinear models. A Gaussian process (GP) is a collection of random variables
such that any finite subset of them has a joint multivariate
Gaussian distribution. A GP can be fully specified by a mean
function and a positive definite covariance function (or kernel). JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 5
(page number not for citation purposes) XSL•FO
RenderX XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al received during their day hospital stay are shown in Table 3. The last 3 columns are the number of visits each patient had to
the ED and day hospital as well as admissions over the past
calendar year. of 11 patients had multiple pain scores through the TRU-Pain
app, and 91% (10/11) of the patients had a decrease in pain
score, with an average decrease in pain score of 2.69 (SD 2.53). of 11 patients had multiple pain scores through the TRU-Pain
app, and 91% (10/11) of the patients had a decrease in pain
score, with an average decrease in pain score of 2.69 (SD 2.53). Patients presenting to the day hospital often receive intravenous
fluids, antiemetics, NSAIDs, and opioids. The opioid doses Table 3. Patient demographics. Overview bSC: type SC (hemoglobin S and hemoglobin C). cPublic: at least some portion of insurance is Medicare or Medicaid. dSS: type SS (hemoglobin S and hemoglobin S). eM: male. fSB+: type S beta thalassemia plus (hemoglobin S and beta thalassemia plus). gSS alpha: type SS with alpha thalassemia (hemoglobin S and hemoglobin S with alpha thalassemia). hPCA: patient-controlled analgesia. iSB0: type S beta thalassemia zero (hemoglobin S and beta thalassemia zero). Regression Results
A total of 4 regression algorithms were implemented on 2
reduced feature sets. Results were validated using 10-fold
cross-validation. Moreover, 2 evaluation metrics were applied
to evaluate the performance of algorithms—the root mean square
error (RMSE) and Pearson correlation [34]. RMSE is the square
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 6
https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671
(
b
t f
it ti
) aF: female. iSB0: type S beta thalassemia zero (hemoglobin S and beta thalassemia zero). cross-validation. Moreover, 2 evaluation metrics were applied
to evaluate the performance of algorithms—the root mean square
error (RMSE) and Pearson correlation [34]. RMSE is the square cross-validation. Moreover, 2 evaluation metrics were applied
to evaluate the performance of algorithms—the root mean square
error (RMSE) and Pearson correlation [34]. RMSE is the square JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 6
(page number not for citation purposes) https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 Overview Inpatient
stays in prior
year
Day hospital
visits in prior
year
Emergency de-
partment visits in
prior year
Medications
Insurance
Sickle cell
disease type
Sex
Age (years)
Patient
1
1
11
Dilaudid 6 mg; Oxycodone
5 mg
Publicc
SCb
Fa
21
1
3
8
3
Dilaudid 8 mg
Public
SSd
F
25
2
3
4
1
Dilaudid 8 mg
Private
SC
F
24
3
0
4
0
Dilaudid 16 mg; Oxycodone
5 mg
Public
SS
Me
40
4
2
2
3
Dilaudid 9 mg
Public
SB+f
M
48
5
0
3
1
Dilaudid 12 mg
Public
SS alphag
M
39
6
1
3
1
Dilaudid 9 mg
Public
SC
F
37
7
2
10
1
Dilaudid 8 mg
Public
SC
F
38
8
14
19
14
Dilaudid 4 mg; Dilaudid
PCAh
Public
SS
M
21
9g
16
8
5
Dilaudid 16 mg; Oxycodone
20 mg
Public
SS
F
28
10
17
1
23
Dilaudid 6 mg
Public
SS
M
36
11
0
0
0
Dilaudid 8 mg; Morphine 4
mg
Public
SS
M
66
12
6
12
10
Dilaudid 11 mg
Public
SC
M
44
13
12
7
19
Dilaudid 8 mg
Public
SB0i
F
28
14
10
6
18
Dilaudid 9 mg
Public
SC
F
20
15
4
30
12
Dilaudid 13 mg
Public
SS
F
26
16
2
22
0
Dilaudid 16 mg
Public
SS
F
38
17
3
8
51
Dilaudid 8 mg
Private
SC
M
22
18
8
4
7
Dilaudid 8 mg; Oxycodone
10 mg
Public
SC
M
28
19
7
10
0
Dilaudid 5 mg; Oxycodone
10 mg
Public
SS
F
21
20
aF: female Inpatient
stays in prior
year
Day hospital
visits in prior
year
Emergency de-
partment visits in
prior year
Medications
Insurance
Sickle cell
disease type
Sex
Age (years)
Patient
1
1
11
Dilaudid 6 mg; Oxycodone
5 mg
Publicc
SCb
Fa
21
1
3
8
3
Dilaudid 8 mg
Public
SSd
F
25
2
3
4
1
Dilaudid 8 mg
Private
SC
F
24
3
0
4
0
Dilaudid 16 mg; Oxycodone
5 mg
Public
SS
Me
40
4
2
2
3
Dilaudid 9 mg
Public
SB+f
M
48
5
0
3
1
Dilaudid 12 mg
Public
SS alphag
M
39
6
1
3
1
Dilaudid 9 mg
Public
SC
F
37
7
2
10
1
Dilaudid 8 mg
Public
SC
F
38
8
14
19
14
Dilaudid 4 mg; Dilaudid
PCAh
Public
SS
M
21
9g
16
8
5
Dilaudid 16 mg; Oxycodone
20 mg
Public
SS
F
28
10
17
1
23
Dilaudid 6 mg
Public
SS
M
36
11
0
0
0
Dilaudid 8 mg; Morphine 4
mg
Public
SS
M
66
12
6
12
10
Dilaudid 11 mg
Public
SC
M
44
13
12
7
19
Dilaudid 8 mg
Public
SB0i
F
28
14
10
6
18
Dilaudid 9 mg
Public
SC
F
20
15
4
30
12
Dilaudid 13 mg
Public
SS
F
26
16
2
22
0
Dilaudid 16 mg
Public
SS
F
38
17
3
8
51
Dilaudid 8 mg
Private
SC
M
22
18
8
4
7
Dilaudid 8 mg; Oxycodone
10 mg
Public
SC
M
28
19
7
10
0
Dilaudid 5 mg; Oxycodone
10 mg
Public
SS
F
21
20
aF: female. Regression Results A total of 4 regression algorithms were implemented on 2
reduced feature sets. Results were validated using 10-fold JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 6
(page number not for citation purposes) https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al SVR is further improved. The SVR model is slightly superior
to the GPR model, with an RMSE of 1.430 and correlation of
0.706, respectively, which are also the best performance results
obtained using regression methods. These data show that there
was a strong association between the subjective pain scores (via
app or nurse-obtained) and the predicted pain scores derived
from wearable sensor signals. root of the average of squared differences between predictions
and actual observations. It is measured on the same scale and
has the same units as the pain score. Another metric is the
Pearson correlation between predicted values and the actual
values, which has a value between +1 and −1, where 0 means
no linear correlation and +1 or −1 means total linear correlation. The higher the correlation value, the better the performance of
the regression model. Table 4 summarizes the performance of
the 4 algorithms on the 2 reduced feature sets. The result of the SVR model with the best performance can be
visualized in Figure 1. It is a scatter plot of the actual pain scores
and predicted pain scores using the SVR model with the least
squares regression line. The slope value of the least squares
regression line is the same as the correlation of 0.706 in Table
4 and demonstrates a strong correlation of values between the
actual pain scores and the predicted pain scores. For the dataset in our study, the standard deviation of 107 pain
scores is 2.013, which can be interpreted as the RMSE of using
the mean value as the predicted pain values. All the regression
models obtained RMSE lower than the mean-only model. With
10 features in the forward selection feature set, the SVR had
the best performance as the RMSE of 1.721 and the correlation
of 0.522, followed by the GPR obtaining the RMSE of 1.764
and the correlation of 0.475. These results demonstrate the
feasibility of using objective wearable sensor measurements to
estimate subjective pain scores. Regression Results With 14 features in the
backward elimination feature set, the performance of GPR and To better analyze the results of these regression methods, the
residual plots of 4 regression models using the backward
elimination feature set are illustrated in Figures 2-5. The dashed
lines show the positive and negative standard deviation (2.013)
of pain scores. The performances of Ridge and Lasso are nearly
the same, which can be seen from Figures 2 and 3. Table 4. Algorithm performances on 2 reduced feature sets using 4 regression methods. Backward elimination feature set
Forward selection feature set
Regression algorithm
Correlation
RMSE
Correlation
RMSEa
0.370
1.844
0.381
1.853
Ridge
0.370
1.891
0.358
1.871
Lasso
0.683
1.473
0.475
1.764
Gaussian process for regression
0.706b
1.430b
0.522
1.721
Support vector machines for regression
aRMSE: root mean square error. b Table 4. Algorithm performances on 2 reduced feature sets using 4 regression methods. bBest performed model as described in the text. Figure 1. Scatter plot of the predicted and actual pain scores using the support vector machines for regression model. Figure 1. Scatter plot of the predicted and actual pain scores using the support vector machines for regression model. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 7
https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671
(page number not for citation purposes)
•FO https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 7
(page number not for citation purposes) JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al reason for the poor performance of these 2 points is the lack of
training samples with lower pain values. It suggests that we can
further improve our model performances by training the model
with more samples having mild and moderate pain scores or
having a larger dataset. Although a larger dataset is possible to
obtain in future studies, an uneven distribution of pain scores
will likely persist when acute pain crises are analyzed, as SCD
patients will typically not present to medical care with lower
pain scores and will manage minor crises at home [36]. In either Figure 2 or 3, there is a roughly inverted U pattern,
suggesting a nonlinear relationship between predictor variables
and pain scores. Thus, performances of linear models were
notably lower than the other 2 nonlinear models. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 8
(page number not for citation purposes) Regression Results The
distributions of residuals in Figures 4 and 5 are similar, which
explains the comparable performance of the GPR model and
the SVR model. The SVR model slightly surpassed the GPR
model by having lower extreme residuals. Specifically, there
are 2 outliers in both Figures 4 and 5, marked as points 1 and
2 (with actual pain scores of 0.41 and 2, respectively). The Figure 2. Plot of the residuals versus predicted pain scores using the backward elimination feature set. Figure 2. Plot of the residuals versus predicted pain scores using the backward elimination feature set. Figure 3. Plot of the residuals versus predicted pain scores using the backward elimination feature set (lasso). Figure 3. Plot of the residuals versus predicted pain scores using the backward elimination feature set (lasso). JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 8
https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671
(page number not for citation purposes)
L•FO https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 8
(page number not for citation purposes) https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al Figure 4. Plot of the residuals versus predicted pain scores using the backward elimination feature set (gaussian process for regression). Figure 4. Plot of the residuals versus predicted pain scores using the backward elimination feature set (gaussian process for regression). Figure 5. Plot of the residuals versus predicted pain scores using the backward elimination feature set (support vector machines for regression). Figure 5. Plot of the residuals versus predicted pain scores using the backward elimination feature set (support vector machines for regression). of correctly predicted pain scores over total number of pain
scores. F1 score is the harmonic mean of precision and recall
for each pain score, where precision is the ratio of the number
of correctly identified entities with this pain score over the total
number of this particular pain score predicted by the model. Recall is the ratio of the number of correctly identified entities
with this pain score over the total number entities with this pain
score in the dataset [35]. The weighted average F1 scores is the
average of F1 score among all pain scores weighted by the
number of instances of each pain score, and it is a better choice
for evaluating datasets with multiple classes [37]. https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 9
(page number not for citation purposes) Classification Results To apply classification to the original dataset, pain scores
ranging from 0 to 10 were categorized into 4 classes as
mentioned above: none (0), mild (1-3), moderate (4-6), and
severe (7-10). The number of samples for the 4 pain levels are
2, 4, 34, and 67, respectively and indicates a high-class
imbalance among the 4 classes. As patients visit the hospital
because of pain management issues, the skewing to higher level
pain scores makes clinical sense. The SVM classifiers were applied on the categorized input
dataset and evaluated for accuracy. F1 scores as well as a
weighted F1 score were also evaluated. Accuracy is the ratio The classification result of the SVM model was compared with
that of the best performance model, which was the SVR model JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 9
(page number not for citation purposes) XSL•FO
RenderX XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al applied on the backward elimination feature set as described
above. In the experiment, both SVM and SVR were
implemented on the backward elimination feature set. For a fair
comparison, the same kernel was used in SVM and SVR. In
addition, the continuous predicted pain scores of the SVR model
were categorized into 4 classes. In this way, the accuracy, F1
scores, and weighted F1 score were calculated for the SVR
model. Table 5 shows the performance comparison between the
SVR model and the SVM model. Overall, the SVR model
outperformed the SVM model in each evaluation metric. single continuous variable, as opposed to treating the prediction
as a multiclass classifier. The SVR model obtained an F1 score
of 0.286 for mild pain even when there were only 4 training
samples with mild pain scores in the dataset. In addition, by
assuming pain as a continuous variable, there are ordinal
relationships between pain levels in SVR. For example, a pain
score 5 is greater than pain score 4 in this model. On the
contrary, the ordinal relationship is not considered in the SVM
model. Treating pain as an ordinal variable is a more reasonable
assumption, and it may be another reason why the regression
models outperform the classification model. Strengths and Limitations A more objective pain prediction model could significantly help
medical providers manage pain crises. As described, data
collected from wearable devices can be utilized to improve pain
management via advanced machine learning methods. In this
analysis, we aimed to build predictive models for pain based
on objective, physiologic wearable sensor data. This study is
of great value given that the data utilized were obtained from a
wearable device and provided minimal to no risk to patients. Furthermore, wearable sensor data were acquired frequently
and obtained passively from patients as compared with
nurse-documented vitals, which were obtained approximately
every 2 hours. Our predictive results are encouraging and provide insight into
potential techniques to predict pain and the understanding of
individual physiologic response to pain and treatment. A few
investigators have recently begun to evaluate the potential use
of physiologic data to develop digital phenotypes for pain and,
subsequently, an individualized pain prediction model. As
discussed previously, objective and physiologic data of varying
invasiveness have been utilized in medicine to better understand
disease processes and symptoms, including SCD. Coates et al
have extensively published on objective data in SCD, including
spin-tagged magnetic resonance imaging to assess cerebral
oxygen extraction and metabolic rate, biventricular dimensions
and function to assess cardiac iron load, and the use of a
graphical Lasso model to evaluate functional brain connectivity
in SCD [38-40]. This group has also published analysis of
laboratory measurements of carbon monoxide and heme
oxygenase for acute pain crisis prediction [41]. Other groups
have studied red blood cell mechanical sensitivity and biomarker
signatures of SCD severity [42,43]. The use of machine learning
in a variety of areas of medicine including outcome prediction
for chemoradiotherapy, breast cancer survival prediction, and Importantly, wearables and mobile apps (to track symptoms
and pain scores over time) paired together to form an mHealth
pain prediction system, as in this study, could fairly easily be
applied to the inpatient and outpatient settings. mHealth systems
are attractive for providers as pain can be tracked on a more
frequent basis and can provide more personalized care for
patients and potentially prevent ED visits, day hospital visits,
and hospital admissions. Further work is needed in this field to
continue to develop models with increasing accuracy in
predicting pain to help guide management and patient care [47]. Principal Findings This study demonstrates the feasibility of using physiologic
data collected on a wearable device and applying these data
using machine learning techniques to accurately predict
subjective pain scores. The best accuracy was found using the
machine learning technique SVR, with an accuracy of 0.729
prediction of pain on a 4-point scale. In addition, for patients
treated in the day hospital for pain, we found expected
improvement in pain and physiologic measures such as HR
from the beginning to the end of their stay. Classification Results In summary, our
results verified the hypothesis that the regression model (SVR)
would obtain a higher performance than the classification model
(SVM) with a small sample size and when there was a
class-imbalance problem in the dataset. applied on the backward elimination feature set as described
above. In the experiment, both SVM and SVR were
implemented on the backward elimination feature set. For a fair
comparison, the same kernel was used in SVM and SVR. In
addition, the continuous predicted pain scores of the SVR model
were categorized into 4 classes. In this way, the accuracy, F1
scores, and weighted F1 score were calculated for the SVR
model. Table 5 shows the performance comparison between the
SVR model and the SVM model. Overall, the SVR model
outperformed the SVM model in each evaluation metric. From Table 5, we can see that the performance of both the SVM
and SVR models were affected by the class-imbalance problem,
as the F1 scores for no pain and mild pain were much lower
than that for the higher pain scores. However, the SVR model
can better overcome this issue by treating the outcome as a Table 5. Prediction performances on the 4-level pain scale using support vector machines for regression and support vector machines. Weighted F1
score
F1 score of
severe pain
F1 score of moderate
pain
F1 score of
mild pain
F1 score of no
pain
Accuracy
Algorithm
0.663
0.786
0.537
0
0
0.682
Support vector machines
0.728a
0.803
0.675
0.286
0
0.729a
Support vector machines for regression
aBest performed model as described in the text. early prediction of asthma exacerbations have recently been
published [44-46]. However, to date, the combined use of
objective and physiologic data with machine learning techniques
for pain in SCD is lacking. https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 10
(page number not for citation purposes) Acknowledgments g
The authors would like to thank the SCD day hospital staff and patients for their assistance and participation. The authors would like to thank the SCD day hospital staff and patients for their assistance and participation. Conflicts of Interest NS is a speaker and consultant at Novartis and a speaker at Alexion. JJ is an Officer of Sicklesoft. Conclusions Future directions include refining the predictive model with a
larger dataset. We are continuing to troubleshoot our data
extraction procedure to minimize lost data. Furthermore, we
could attempt to expand our models by examining patient’s
disease severity (related to number of ED visits, day hospital
visits, and hospitalizations per year), length of stay in the day
hospital, etc, to obtain a more ideal model for pain score
prediction. Given that we combined app pain scores with nursing
pain scores, further study is needed to determine if these can be
treated as similar scores. Related to medication administration,
we could examine HR changes before and after medication,
time since last dose, total net dose of medications, etc, and
attempt to project pain score and the need for medication before
the patient requests medication. This would be an essential part
of a real-time pain forecasting system and allow a trial that
evaluates the timing of administration of additional doses of
opioids based on physiologic and objective data alone. Our
initial results indicate promise in pursuing each of these efforts,
and our study is a valuable addition to ongoing studies
investigating how physiologic and objective data can be used
to help providers better understand and treat pain. In addition, our group had to make the assumption that
nurse-documented pain scores and patient-reported pain scores
in the app were not dissimilar, but this is also an area for further
study. One hypothesis would be that the patients could report
a lower pain score to the nurse to look tough, but an alternative
hypothesis may be a patient elevating their pain score to be
given additional medication. There is also the assumption that
the physiologic measures from the wearable device are accurate. We attempted to take data averaged over 1 min (with recordings
typically every second) to minimize variability. We chose the
Microsoft Band 2 because of the ability to acquire the raw data
directly from the wearable and because of previous studies
showing its relative accuracy. Stahl et al [48] and Shcherbina
et al [49] have reported that wrist-based monitors, including the
Microsoft Band, provided an accurate measurement of HR in
most activity settings. Xie et al [50] further demonstrated that Strengths and Limitations There are limitations to our study, including obtaining a
convenience sample from our day hospital only and the small
number of patients. Patients with SS and SC can be treated the
same clinically, but the study included patients with thalassemia
who may have a more or less severe phenotype depending on https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 XSL•FO
RenderX XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al wearable devices had a high accuracy with respect to HR,
number of steps, distance, and sleep duration. the type of thalassemia. Specific analysis on these patients was
not performed for this feasibility study. The study is also limited
given that patients might have had underlying medical
conditions that could affect HR, and this was not controlled for
in our study. In addition, each patient had pain control achieved
through individualized pain protocols, which varied among
patients and were administered at various intervals. Therefore,
it was impossible to control for these pain medications during
this initial study. Medications administered, both opioid and
nonopioid, may affect vital sign parameters independently
(namely, opioids decreasing HR). The administration of pain
medication, however, provides an important future opportunity
to also evaluate pre- and postadministration objective datasets
for pain prediction. Although all patients were in the day hospital
either in a chair or bed, their environment was not completely
controlled, and HR changes might have occurred with movement
in and out of the bed or chair as well as to use the restroom, and
these movements were not accounted for. HR can also vary
outside of pain when a patient is at rest based on a multitude of
different factors including stress, excitement, and breathing. Utilizing mobile devices and technology have great promise as
we have discussed, but HR data and other physiologic
parameters should be interpreted in the clinical context of the
patient’s history and exam. For example, a tachycardic patient
should be thoroughly evaluated to rule out life-threatening
conditions before attributing tachycardia to pain. Although our
group has shown that wearable sensor data are feasible to obtain
and can be used to create models for predicting pain scores,
models and objective vital signs need to be paired with clinical
experience and judgment for ideal patient management. https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 11
(page number not for citation purposes) 5.
Sundararaman LV, Edwards RR, Ross EL, Jamison RN. Integration of mobile health technology in the treatment of chronic
pain: a critical review. Reg Anesth Pain Med 2017;42(4):488-498. [doi: 10.1097/AAP.0000000000000621] [Medline:
28570436] JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Conf
Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 2016 Aug;2016:2966-2969 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1109/EMBC.2016.7591352] [Medline:
28268935] 14. Tighe PJ, Harle CA, Hurley RW, Aytug H, Boezaart AP, Fillingim RB. Teaching a machine to feel postoperative pain:
combining high-dimensional clinical data with machine learning algorithms to forecast acute postoperative pain. Pain Med
2015 Jul;16(7):1386-1401 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1111/pme.12713] [Medline: 26031220] 15. Lötsch J, Ultsch A. Machine learning in pain research. Pain 2018 Apr
10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001118] [Medline: 29194126] 15. Lötsch J, Ultsch A. Machine learning in pain research. Pain 2018 Apr;159(4):623-630 [FREE Full text] [doi:
10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001118] [Medline: 29194126] 16. Milton JN, Gordeuk VR, Taylor JG, Gladwin MT, Steinberg MH, Sebastiani P. Prediction of fetal hemoglobin in sickle
cell anemia using an ensemble of genetic risk prediction models. Circ Cardiovasc Genet 2014 Apr;7(2):110-115 [FREE
Full text] [doi: 10.1161/CIRCGENETICS.113.000387] [Medline: 24585758] 17. Desai AA, Zhou T, Ahmad H, Zhang W, Mu W, Trevino S, et al. A novel molecular signature for elevated tricuspid
regurgitation velocity in sickle cell disease. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2012 Aug 15;186(4):359-368 [FREE Full text]
[doi: 10.1164/rccm.201201-0057OC] [Medline: 22679008] 18. Yang F, Banerjee T, Narine K, Shah N. Improving pain management in patients with sickle cell disease from physiological
measures using machine learning techniques. Smart Health (Amst) 2018 Jun;7-8:48-59 [FREE Full text] [doi:
10.1016/j.smhl.2018.01.002] [Medline: 30906841] 19. Mohri M, Rostamizadeh A, Talwalkar A. Foundations of Machine Learning. Second Edition. Cambridge, Massachusetts:
The Mit Press; 2018. 20. Banos O, Villalonga C, Damas M, Gloesekoetter P, Pomares H, Rojas I. PhysioDroid: combining wearable health sensors
and mobile devices for a ubiquitous, continuous, and personal monitoring. ScientificWorldJournal 2014;2014:490824
[FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1155/2014/490824] [Medline: 25295301] q
p
g
[FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1155/2014/490824] [Medline: 25295301] 21. Miao F, Cheng Y, He Y, He Q, Li Y. A wearable context-aware ECG monitoring system integrated with built-in kinematic
sensors of the smartphone. Sensors (Basel) 2015 May 19;15(5):11465-11484 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.3390/s150511465]
[Medline: 25996508] 22. Lieber B, Taylor BE, Appelboom G, McKhann G, Connolly ES. Motion sensors to assess and monitor medical and surgical
management of Parkinson disease. World Neurosurg 2015 Aug;84(2):561-566. [doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2015.03.024] [Medline:
25827041] 23. Payne J, Aban I, Hilliard LM, Madison J, Bemrich-Stolz C, Howard TH, et al. Impact of early analgesia on hospitalization
outcomes for sickle cell pain crisis. Pediatr Blood Cancer 2018 Dec;65(12):e27420. [doi: 10.1002/pbc.27420] [Medline:
30151977] ]
24. References 1. Brousseau DC, Owens PL, Mosso AL, Panepinto JA, Steiner CA. Acute care utilization and rehospitalizations for sickle
cell disease. J Am Med Assoc 2010 Apr 7;303(13):1288-1294. [doi: 10.1001/jama.2010.378] [Medline: 20371788] 1. Brousseau DC, Owens PL, Mosso AL, Panepinto JA, Steiner CA. Acute care utilization and rehospitalizations for sickle
cell disease. J Am Med Assoc 2010 Apr 7;303(13):1288-1294. [doi: 10.1001/jama.2010.378] [Medline: 20371788] 2. Cline DM, Silva S, Freiermuth CE, Thornton V, Tanabe P. Emergency Department (ED), ED observation, day hospital,
and hospital admissions for adults with sickle cell disease. West J Emerg Med 2018 Mar;19(2):311-318 [FREE Full text]
[doi: 10.5811/westjem.2017.9.35422] [Medline: 29560059] 3. Krishnamurti L, Smith-Packard B, Gupta A, Campbell M, Gunawardena S, Saladino R. Impact of individualized pain plan
on the emergency management of children with sickle cell disease. Pediatr Blood Cancer 2014 Oct;61(10):1747-1753. [doi:
10.1002/pbc.25024] [Medline: 24962217] 5. Sundararaman LV, Edwards RR, Ross EL, Jamison RN. Integration of mobile health technology in the treatment of chronic
pain: a critical review. Reg Anesth Pain Med 2017;42(4):488-498. [doi: 10.1097/AAP.0000000000000621] [Medline:
28570436] JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 11
(page number not for citation purposes) XSL•FO
RenderX https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Usability and feasibility of an mHealth intervention for monitoring and
managing pain symptoms in sickle cell disease: The Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Application to Record Symptoms via
Technology (SMART). Hemoglobin 2015;39(3):162-168. [doi: 10.3109/03630269.2015.1025141] [Medline: 25831427] gy (
)
g
;
( )
[
] [
]
8. Shah N, Jonassaint J, de Castro L. Patients welcome the Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Application to Record Symptoms via
Technology (SMART). Hemoglobin 2014;38(2):99-103. [doi: 10.3109/03630269.2014.880716] [Medline: 24512633] gy (
)
g
( )
8. Shah N, Jonassaint J, de Castro L. Patients welcome the Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Application to Record Symptoms via
Technology (SMART). Hemoglobin 2014;38(2):99-103. [doi: 10.3109/03630269.2014.880716] [Medline: 24512633] gy
g
9. Clinical Trials. Patient-Empowered Mobile Technology in Hospitalized Patients (TRU-PAIN) URL: https://clinicaltrials. gov/ct2/show/NCT02895841 [accessed 2019-10-02] 9. Clinical Trials. Patient-Empowered Mobile Technology in Hospitalized Patients (TRU-PAIN) URL: https://clinicaltrials. gov/ct2/show/NCT02895841 [accessed 2019-10-02] g
10. Vaughn J, Jonassaint J, Summers-Goeckerman E, Shaw RJ, Shah N. Customization of the TRU-PBMT App (Technology
recordings to better understand pediatric blood and marrow transplant). J Pediatr Nurs 2018;42:86-91. [doi:
10.1016/j.pedn.2018.07.007] [Medline: 30219304] 10. Vaughn J, Jonassaint J, Summers-Goeckerman E, Shaw RJ, Shah N. Customization of the TRU-PBMT App (Technology
recordings to better understand pediatric blood and marrow transplant). J Pediatr Nurs 2018;42:86-91. [doi:
10.1016/j.pedn.2018.07.007] [Medline: 30219304] j p
] [
]
11. Bendall JC, Simpson PM, Middleton PM. Prehospital vital signs can predict pain severity: analysis using ordinal logistic
regression. Eur J Emerg Med 2011 Dec;18(6):334-339. [doi: 10.1097/MEJ.0b013e328344fdf2] [Medline: 21407079] j p
11. Bendall JC, Simpson PM, Middleton PM. Prehospital vital signs can predict pain severity: analysis using ordinal logistic
regression. Eur J Emerg Med 2011 Dec;18(6):334-339. [doi: 10.1097/MEJ.0b013e328344fdf2] [Medline: 21407079] 12. Lee J, Mawla I, Kim J, Loggia ML, Ortiz A, Jung C, et al. Machine learning-based prediction of clinical pain using
multimodal neuroimaging and autonomic metrics. Pain 2019 Mar;160(3):550-560. [doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001417]
[Medline: 30540621] 12. Lee J, Mawla I, Kim J, Loggia ML, Ortiz A, Jung C, et al. Machine learning-based prediction of clinical pain using
multimodal neuroimaging and autonomic metrics. Pain 2019 Mar;160(3):550-560. [doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001417]
[Medline: 30540621] 13. Nickerson P, Tighe P, Shickel B, Rashidi P. Deep neural network architectures for forecasting analgesic response. Conf
Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 2016 Aug;2016:2966-2969 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1109/EMBC.2016.7591352] [Medline:
28268935] 13. Nickerson P, Tighe P, Shickel B, Rashidi P. Deep neural network architectures for forecasting analgesic response. JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al 6. Palermo TM, de la Vega R, Dudeney J, Murray C, Law E. Mobile health intervention for self-management of adolescent
chronic pain (WebMAP mobile): protocol for a hybrid effectiveness-implementation cluster randomized controlled trial. Contemp Clin Trials 2018 Nov;74:55-60 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1016/j.cct.2018.10.003] [Medline: 30290276]
7. Jonassaint CR, Shah N, Jonassaint J, de Castro L. Usability and feasibility of an mHealth intervention for monitoring and
managing pain symptoms in sickle cell disease: The Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Application to Record Symptoms via
Technology (SMART). Hemoglobin 2015;39(3):162-168. [doi: 10.3109/03630269.2015.1025141] [Medline: 25831427]
8. Shah N, Jonassaint J, de Castro L. Patients welcome the Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Application to Record Symptoms via
Technology (SMART). Hemoglobin 2014;38(2):99-103. [doi: 10.3109/03630269.2014.880716] [Medline: 24512633]
9. Clinical Trials. Patient-Empowered Mobile Technology in Hospitalized Patients (TRU-PAIN) URL: https://clinicaltrials. gov/ct2/show/NCT02895841 [accessed 2019-10-02] 6. Palermo TM, de la Vega R, Dudeney J, Murray C, Law E. Mobile health intervention for self-management of adolescent
chronic pain (WebMAP mobile): protocol for a hybrid effectiveness-implementation cluster randomized controlled trial. Contemp Clin Trials 2018 Nov;74:55-60 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1016/j.cct.2018.10.003] [Medline: 30290276] 6. Palermo TM, de la Vega R, Dudeney J, Murray C, Law E. Mobile health intervention for self-management of adolescent
chronic pain (WebMAP mobile): protocol for a hybrid effectiveness-implementation cluster randomized controlled trial. Contemp Clin Trials 2018 Nov;74:55-60 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1016/j.cct.2018.10.003] [Medline: 30290276] ,
g
,
y ,
y
,
g
chronic pain (WebMAP mobile): protocol for a hybrid effectiveness-implementation cluster randomized controlled trial. Contemp Clin Trials 2018 Nov;74:55-60 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1016/j.cct.2018.10.003] [Medline: 30290276]
7. Jonassaint CR, Shah N, Jonassaint J, de Castro L. Usability and feasibility of an mHealth intervention for monitoring and
managing pain symptoms in sickle cell disease: The Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Application to Record Symptoms via
Technology (SMART). Hemoglobin 2015;39(3):162-168. [doi: 10.3109/03630269.2015.1025141] [Medline: 25831427]
8. Shah N, Jonassaint J, de Castro L. Patients welcome the Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Application to Record Symptoms via
Technology (SMART) Hemoglobin 2014;38(2):99 103 [doi: 10 3109/03630269 2014 880716] [Medline: 24512633] p
j
7. Jonassaint CR, Shah N, Jonassaint J, de Castro L. Usability and feasibility of an mHealth intervention for monitoring and
managing pain symptoms in sickle cell disease: The Sickle Cell Disease Mobile Application to Record Symptoms via
Technology (SMART). Hemoglobin 2015;39(3):162-168. [doi: 10.3109/03630269.2015.1025141] [Medline: 25831427] p
j
7. Jonassaint CR, Shah N, Jonassaint J, de Castro L. JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH J Gen
Intern Med 2007 Oct;22(10):1453-1458 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1007/s11606-007-0321-2] [Medline: 17668269]
32. Rasmussen C. Gaussian processes for machine learning. In: Bousquet O, von Luburg U, Rätsch G, editors. Lecture Notes
in Computer Science, Vol 3176. Berlin: Springer; 2003. 32. Rasmussen C. Gaussian processes for machine learning. In: Bousquet O, von Luburg U, Rätsch G, editors. Lecture Notes
in Computer Science, Vol 3176. Berlin: Springer; 2003. 33. Smola AJ, Schölkopf B. A tutorial on support vector regression. Stat Comput 2004 Aug;14(3):199-222. [doi:
10.1023/b:stco.0000035301.49549.88] ]
34. Kuhn M, Johnson K. Applied Predictive Modeling. New York: Springer; 2013. 35. Mitchell T. Machine Learning. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1997. 35. Mitchell T. Machine Learning. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1997. 36. Marco CA, Kanitz W, Jolly M. Pain scores among emergency department (ED) patients: compariso
Emerg Med 2013 Jan;44(1):46-52. [doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2012.05.002] [Medline: 22795472] 37. Larsen B, Aone C. Fast and Effective Text Mining Using Linear-Time Document Clustering. In: Proceedings of the Fifth
ACM SIGKDD International Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining. 1999 Presented at: KDD'99; August
15-18, 1999; San Diego, California, USA p. 16-22. g
p
38. Bush AM, Coates TD, Wood JC. Diminished cerebral oxygen extraction and metabolic rate in sickle cell disease using T2
relaxation under spin tagging MRI. Magn Reson Med 2018 Jul;80(1):294-303 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1002/mrm.27015]
[Medline: 29194727] 39. Meloni A, Detterich J, Berdoukas V, Pepe A, Lombardi M, Coates TD, et al. Comparison of biventricular dimensions and
function between pediatric sickle-cell disease and thalassemia major patients without cardiac iron. Am J Hematol 2013
Mar;88(3):213-218 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1002/ajh.23376] [Medline: 23386313] 40. Coloigner J, Phlypo R, Coates TD, Lepore N, Wood JC. Graph Lasso-based test for evaluating functional brain connectivity
in sickle cell disease. Brain Connect 2017 Sep;7(7):443-453 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1089/brain.2016.0474] [Medline:
28747064] 41. Gomperts E, Belcher JD, Otterbein LE, Coates TD, Wood J, Skolnick BE, et al. The role of carbon monoxide and heme
oxygenase in the prevention of sickle cell disease vaso-occlusive crises. Am J Hematol 2017 Jun;92(6):569-582 [FREE
Full text] [doi: 10.1002/ajh.24750] [Medline: 28378932] j
42. Simmonds MJ, Suriany S, Ponce D, Detterich JA. Red blood cell mechanical sensitivity improves in patients with sickle
cell disease undergoing chronic transfusion after prolonged, subhemolytic shear exposure. Transfusion 2018
Dec;58(12):2788-2796. [doi: 10.1111/trf.14901] [Medline: 30325033] 43. Du M, van Ness S, Gordeuk V, Nouraie SM, Nekhai S, Gladwin M, et al. JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH How accurate are the wrist-based heart rate monitors during walking and
running activities? Are they accurate enough? BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med 2016;2(1):e000106 [FREE Full text] [doi:
10.1136/bmjsem-2015-000106] [Medline: 27900173] 48. Stahl SE, An H, Dinkel DM, Noble JM, Lee J. How accurate are the wrist-based heart rate monitors during walking and
running activities? Are they accurate enough? BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med 2016;2(1):e000106 [FREE Full text] [doi:
10.1136/bmjsem-2015-000106] [Medline: 27900173] j
49. Shcherbina A, Mattsson CM, Waggott D, Salisbury H, Christle JW, Hastie T, et al. Accuracy in wrist-worn, sensor-based
measurements of heart rate and energy expenditure in a diverse cohort. J Pers Med 2017 May 24;7(2):pii: E3 [FREE Full
text] [doi: 10.3390/jpm7020003] [Medline: 28538708] 49. Shcherbina A, Mattsson CM, Waggott D, Salisbury H, Christle JW, Hastie T, et al. Accuracy in wrist-worn, sensor-based
measurements of heart rate and energy expenditure in a diverse cohort. J Pers Med 2017 May 24;7(2):pii: E3 [FREE Full
text] [doi: 10.3390/jpm7020003] [Medline: 28538708] 50. Xie J, Wen D, Liang L, Jia Y, Gao L, Lei J. Evaluating the validity of current mainstream wearable devices in fitness
tracking under various physical activities: comparative study. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2018 Apr 12;6(4):e94 [FREE Full
text] [doi: 10.2196/mhealth.9754] [Medline: 29650506] 50. Xie J, Wen D, Liang L, Jia Y, Gao L, Lei J. Evaluating the validity of current mainstream wearable devices in fitness
tracking under various physical activities: comparative study. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2018 Apr 12;6(4):e94 [FREE Full
text] [doi: 10.2196/mhealth.9754] [Medline: 29650506] JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Biomarker signatures of sickle cell disease
severity. Blood Cells Mol Dis 2018 Sep;72:1-9 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1016/j.bcmd.2018.05.001] [Medline: 29778312] 43. Du M, van Ness S, Gordeuk V, Nouraie SM, Nekhai S, Gladwin M, et al. Biomarker signatures of sickle cell disease
severity. Blood Cells Mol Dis 2018 Sep;72:1-9 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1016/j.bcmd.2018.05.001] [Medline: 29778312]
44. Deist TM, Dankers FJ, Valdes G, Wijsman R, Hsu I, Oberije C, et al. Machine learning algorithms for outcome prediction
in (chemo)radiotherap : an empirical comparison of classifiers Med Ph s 2018 J l;45(7):3449 3459 [FREE F ll te t] [doi: 43. Du M, van Ness S, Gordeuk V, Nouraie SM, Nekhai S, Gladwin M, et al. Biomarker signatures of sickle cell disease
severity. Blood Cells Mol Dis 2018 Sep;72:1-9 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1016/j.bcmd.2018.05.001] [Medline: 29778312]
44. Deist TM, Dankers FJ, Valdes G, Wijsman R, Hsu I, Oberije C, et al. Machine learning algorithms for outcome prediction
in (chemo)radiotherapy: an empirical comparison of classifiers. Med Phys 2018 Jul;45(7):3449-3459 [FREE Full text] [doi:
10.1002/mp.12967] [Medline: 29763967] 44. Deist TM, Dankers FJ, Valdes G, Wijsman R, Hsu I, Oberije C, et al. Machine learning algorithms for outcome prediction
in (chemo)radiotherapy: an empirical comparison of classifiers. Med Phys 2018 Jul;45(7):3449-3459 [FREE Full text] [doi:
10.1002/mp.12967] [Medline: 29763967] p
] [
]
45. Montazeri M, Montazeri M, Montazeri M, Beigzadeh A. Machine learning models in breast cancer survival prediction. Technol Health Care 2016;24(1):31-42. [doi: 10.3233/THC-151071] [Medline: 26409558] p
45. Montazeri M, Montazeri M, Montazeri M, Beigzadeh A. Machine learning models in breast cancer survival prediction. Technol Health Care 2016;24(1):31-42. [doi: 10.3233/THC-151071] [Medline: 26409558] 46. Finkelstein J, Jeong IC. Machine learning approaches to personalize early prediction of asthma exacerbations. Ann N Y
Acad Sci 2017 Jan;1387(1):153-165 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1111/nyas.13218] [Medline: 27627195] 46. Finkelstein J, Jeong IC. Machine learning approaches to personalize early prediction of asthma exacerbations. Ann N Y
Acad Sci 2017 Jan;1387(1):153-165 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1111/nyas.13218] [Medline: 27627195] 47. Cowen R, Stasiowska MK, Laycock H, Bantel C. Assessing pain objectively: the use of physio
2015 Jul;70(7):828-847 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1111/anae.13018] [Medline: 25772783] 47. Cowen R, Stasiowska MK, Laycock H, Bantel C. Assessing pain objectively: the use of physiological markers. Anaesthes
2015 Jul;70(7):828-847 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1111/anae.13018] [Medline: 25772783] 48. Stahl SE, An H, Dinkel DM, Noble JM, Lee J. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 13
(page number not for citation purposes) JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Molokie RE, Montminy C, Dionisio C, Farooqui MA, Gowhari M, Yao Y, et al. Opioid doses and acute care utilization
outcomes for adults with sickle cell disease: ED versus acute care unit. Am J Emerg Med 2018 Jan;36(1):88-92. [doi:
10.1016/j.ajem.2017.07.037] [Medline: 28802541] j j
25. Tousignant-Laflamme Y, Rainville P, Marchand S. Establishing a link between heart rate and pain in healthy subjects: a
gender effect. J Pain 2005 Jun;6(6):341-347. [doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2005.01.351] [Medline: 15943955]
26. Hodges PW. Pain and motor control: From the laboratory to rehabilitation. J Electromyogr Kinesiol 2011 Apr;21(2):220-228. [doi: 10.1016/j.jelekin.2011.01.002] [Medline: 21306915] 25. Tousignant-Laflamme Y, Rainville P, Marchand S. Establishing a link between heart rate and pain in healthy subjects: a
gender effect. J Pain 2005 Jun;6(6):341-347. [doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2005.01.351] [Medline: 15943955]
26
Hodges PW Pain and motor control: From the laboratory to rehabilitation J Electromyogr Kinesiol 2011 Apr;21(2):220 228 26. Hodges PW. Pain and motor control: From the laboratory to reh
[doi: 10.1016/j.jelekin.2011.01.002] [Medline: 21306915] 27. Faye PM, de Jonckheere J, Logier R, Kuissi E, Jeanne M, Rakza T, et al. Newborn infant pain assessment using heart rate
variability analysis. Clin J Pain 2010;26(9):777-782. [doi: 10.1097/ajp.0b013e3181ed1058] [Medline: 20973153] 27. Faye PM, de Jonckheere J, Logier R, Kuissi E, Jeanne M, Rakza T, et al. Newborn infant pain assessment using heart rate
variability analysis. Clin J Pain 2010;26(9):777-782. [doi: 10.1097/ajp.0b013e3181ed1058] [Medline: 20973153]
28. Mitra S, Kuo Y. Digital Signal Processing: A Computer-based Approach. New York: McGraw-Hill; 2006. y
y
;
( )
[
jp
] [
]
28. Mitra S, Kuo Y. Digital Signal Processing: A Computer-based Approach. New York: McGraw-Hill; 2006. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 12
(page number not for citation purposes) https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 XSL•FO
RenderX XSL•FO
RenderX JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH Johnson et al 29. Kohavi R, John GH. Wrappers for feature subset selection. Artif Intell 1997 Dec;97(1-2):273-324. [doi:
10.1016/s0004-3702(97)00043-x] 30. Guyon I, Elisseeff A. An introduction to variable and feature selection. J Mach Learn Res 2003:1157-1182 [FREE Full
text] 31. Krebs EE, Carey TS, Weinberger M. Accuracy of the pain numeric rating scale as a screening test in primary care. J Gen
Intern Med 2007 Oct;22(10):1453-1458 [FREE Full text] [doi: 10.1007/s11606-007-0321-2] [Medline: 17668269] 31. Krebs EE, Carey TS, Weinberger M. Accuracy of the pain numeric rating scale as a screening test in primary care. Abbreviations AccZ: acceleration in Z direction
ED: emergency department
GP: Gaussian process
GPR: Gaussian process for regression JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 13
(page number not for citation purposes) https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 XSL•FO
RenderX Johnson et al JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019 | vol. 7 | iss. 12 | e13671 | p. 14
(page number not for citation purposes) JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH GSR: galvanic skin response
HR: heart rate
mHealth: mobile health
NSAID: nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug
RMSE: root mean square error
RR: R-R interval
SCD: sickle cell disease
SVM: support vector machines
SVR: support vector machines for regression
TRU-Pain: Technology Resources to Understand Pain Edited by G Eysenbach; submitted 09.02.19; peer-reviewed by S Creary, A Davoudi, L Crosby, A Majmundar; comments to author
27.04.19; revised version received 22.06.19; accepted 19.07.19; published 02.12.19 Please cite as:
Johnson A, Yang F, Gollarahalli S, Banerjee T, Abrams D, Jonassaint J, Jonassaint C, Shah N
Use of Mobile Health Apps and Wearable Technology to Assess Changes and Predict Pain During Treatment of Acute Pain in Sickle
Cell Disease: Feasibility Study
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2019;7(12):e13671
URL: https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671
doi: 10.2196/13671
PMID: 31789599 ©Amanda Johnson, Fan Yang, Siddharth Gollarahalli, Tanvi Banerjee, Daniel Abrams, Jude Jonassaint, Charles Jonassaint,
Nirmish Shah. Originally published in JMIR mHealth and uHealth (http://mhealth.jmir.org), 02.12.2019. This is an open-access
article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/),
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR
mhealth and uhealth, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on
http://mhealth.jmir.org/, as well as this copyright and license information must be included. https://mhealth.jmir.org/2019/12/e13671 XSL•FO
RenderX
|
https://openalex.org/W4391534304
|
https://www.scielo.br/j/acr/a/DYdXkqJGYzhTMT7Y5FvYkcq/?lang=en&format=pdf
|
English
| null |
Protective measures against COVID-19: communicative, social and emotional impacts on hearing aids users
|
Audiology - Communication Research
| 2,024
|
cc-by
| 7,900
|
RESUMO Purpose: to investigate the communicative, social, and emotional
impacts generated by adopting protective measures against COVID-19
and associate them with the degree of hearing loss and the time of use
of hearing aids. Methods: cross-sectional quantitative study, with 72
individuals, divided into adults and older adults, with bilateral hearing
loss up to moderately severe degree, users of hearing aids fitted before
the pandemic in a public hearing health program who had maintained
effective use of the devices. The participants were invited to participate
in the study while waiting for an appointment and signed the consent
form. After that, medical records were accessed to collect information
about audiological profiles and the fitting/use of hearing aids. Afterward,
a protocol with objective questions was orally applied in a silent room. Data were tabulated and subjected to Equality of Two Proportions
and Chi-Square statistical tests. Results: in both groups, a significant
number of users had communication impacted by the use of masks
and by social distancing, with difficulty with digital technologies (cell
phones/computers) predominating among adults, while older adults
more commonly experienced communicative impairments during
video calls. The communicative impediment existed regardless of the
audiological profile and device use time. When asked if they stopped
communicating and if the measures affected their social life, the sample
was divided between “yes/sometimes” and “no”. As for the emotional
impact of protective measures, there was a greater impact among adults. Conclusion: protective measures affected the communication of hearing
aids users but did not discourage communicative exchanges and social
interactions for approximately half of the sample, with the emotional
impact being more evident in adults. Such difficulties were not related
to the audiological profile and daily use of the devices. Objetivo: investigar os impactos comunicativos, sociais e emocionais gerados
pela adoção de medidas protetivas contra a COVID-19 e associá-los ao grau
da perda auditiva e ao tempo de uso dos aparelhos de amplificação sonora
individual. Métodos: estudo transversal e quantitativo, com 72 indivíduos,
divididos em adultos e idosos, com perda auditiva bilateral, de grau até
moderadamente severo, protetizados antes da pandemia em um programa
público de saúde auditiva e que mantiveram uso efetivo dos dispositivos. Os sujeitos foram convidados a participar do estudo enquanto aguardavam
consulta. Os prontuários foram acessados, a fim de coletar informações sobre
o perfil audiológico e adaptação/uso dos aparelhos de amplificação sonora
individual. Medidas de proteção contra a COVID-19: impactos comunicativos, sociais e
emocionais em usuários de aparelhos de amplificação sonora individual Medidas de proteção contra a COVID-19: impactos comunicativos, sociais e
emocionais em usuários de aparelhos de amplificação sonora individual Bruna Luísa Fornari1 , Fernanda Soares Aurélio Patatt2 Protective measures against COVID-19: communicative, social and
emotional impacts on hearing aids users Protective measures against COVID-19: communicative, social and
emotional impacts on hearing aids users ISSN 2317-6431 ISSN 2317-6431 Original Article Original Article https://doi.org/10.1590/2317-6431-2022-2722en https://doi.org/10.1590/2317-6431-2022-2722en RESUMO Face masks, because they cover the face, do not allow the
use of the communicator’s visual cues, making speech a murmur
difficult to understand and inefficient communication(10-12). Besides these barriers, protective masks and/or shields,
depending on the manufacturing material and the model, act
as an acoustic filter and attenuate speech sounds between the
frequencies of 2000 Hz and 16000 Hz, with this attenuation
being greater at high frequencies (above 4000 Hz), which also
impairs dialogue(13). Also, the need for constant distancing
between a speaker and their interlocutor further impairs
the oral message since the greater the distance between the
speaking subjects, the greater the dissipation and the lower
the transmission of sound energy(6). From the aforementioned eligibility criteria, 88 subjects
would be part of the sample; eleven individuals, however, were
excluded due to the speech intelligibility factor, and five due
to neurological and/or psychiatric impairments, resulting in
a final sample of 72 subjects, divided into two groups: adults
(n = 23) and older adults (n = 49). Among adults, 15 were female (65.2%), and eight were
male (34.8%), aged between 18 and 59 years, with a mean of
38.2 years. The prosthetization time of adult users ranged from
three to 14 years, with a mean time of use of the devices of
7.5 years. The older people group consisted of 32 male subjects
(65.3%) and 17 female subjects (34.7%), aged between 60 and
89 years, with a mean of 72.6 years. The prosthetization time in
this group ranged from two to 15 years, with a mean time of use
of amplification devices of 6.6 years. The mean prosthetization
time did not differ between groups (p=0.331). Furthermore, most people and organizations adopted virtual
means of communication to maintain contact with family
and friends and conduct their study and work activities at a
time when social distancing was essential(14). However, this
form of communication, especially video calls, can become
another obstacle to the insertion of the hearing-impaired
person in their social environment since the specificities of
these virtual environments, such as delays in relation to the
image and audio, the possibility of keeping the camera off
and/or the poor quality and proportion of the image hinder
their communication(6,11). Data collection was conducted between September and
December 2021. RESUMO 2024;29:e2722 Fornari BL, Patatt FSA INTRODUCTION METHODS The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that,
globally, more than 430 million people have hearing loss(1),
which results in several communicative difficulties in their
daily lives, making interventions necessary, such as the use
of individual sound amplification devices (hearing aids),
combined with communicative strategies, among which,
the most commonly used, such as approaching the sound
source, paying attention to facial expressions, and performing
orofacial reading(2,3). This is a quantitative study with a cross-sectional design,
conducted in a public health service in southern Brazil and
approved by the Human Research Ethics Committee of
Universidade Federal de Santa Maria - UFSM, under opinion
No. 4.844.159 (CAAE 48652721.0.0000.5346). This study included subjects of both genders, aged 18 years
or older, treated at the hearing aid outpatient clinic of a public
hearing health service, and with bilateral hearing loss of up to
moderately severe degree. The most recent WHO classification
was used to categorize the degree of hearing loss, which
considers the mean air thresholds of the frequencies of 500 Hz,
1000 Hz, 2000 Hz, and 4000 Hz(15). Also, to compose the sample,
all individuals should have been adapted to hearing aids for
at least one year before the beginning of the pandemic and,
according to self-report, have maintained the continuous use
of the devices in the pandemic period, in addition to consenting
to participate in the research voluntarily, signing the Free and
Informed Consent Form (FICF). With the emergence of COVID-19 and its high transmissibility,
it became necessary to implement collective and individual
preventive measures to reduce exposure to the virus and its
spread, such as the use of face masks and physical distancing
from the speaker(4,5). In the case of individuals with hearing
impairment, these measures bring additional barriers to
conversation, as they hinder and/or prevent them from using
the usual communicative strategies(6-10) – essential elements for
the hearing-impaired subject to understand the message more
easily and integrate better into the conversation and, therefore,
into society(11). Users with neurological and/or psychiatric impairments that
could affect the understanding of the questions were excluded,
as well as individuals who, at the time of data collection, were
unable to answer the interview due to communication difficulties
resulting from the use of masks by the interviewer(s) or physical
distancing since the low intelligibility of speech resulted in
damage to the quality of the data collected. RESUMO Em sala silenciosa, foi aplicado, oralmente, protocolo contendo
questões objetivas e os dados foram tabulados e submetidos aos testes estatísticos
Igualdade de Duas Proporções e Qui-Quadrado. Resultados: nos dois
grupos, um número significativo de usuários teve a comunicação impactada
pelo uso de máscaras e pelo distanciamento físico, predominando, entre os
adultos, a dificuldade com as tecnologias digitais (celulares/computadores),
enquanto nas videochamadas, os prejuízos comunicativos foram mais
experenciados pelos idosos. Os empecilhos comunicativos e sociais existiram,
independentemente do perfil audiológico e do tempo de uso dos dispositivos. Quando questionados se deixaram de se comunicar e se as medidas afetaram
a sua vida social, as respostas ficaram divididas entre “sim/às vezes” e “não”. Quanto ao impacto emocional das medidas protetivas, constatou-se maior
repercussão entre os adultos. Conclusão: As medidas protetivas afetaram a
comunicação dos usuários de aparelhos de amplificação sonora individual,
porém, não desencorajaram as trocas comunicativas e as interações sociais
de, aproximadamente, metade da amostra, sendo o impacto emocional mais
evidente nos adultos. Tais dificuldades não estiveram relacionadas ao perfil
audiológico e uso diário dos dispositivos. Palavras-chave: Perda auditiva; Auxiliares de audição; Barreiras de comunicação;
COVID-19; Equipamento de proteção individual; Distanciamento físico;
Tecnologia digital Keywords: Hearing loss; Hearing aids; Communication barriers; COVID-19;
Personal protective equipment; Physical distancing; Digital technology Study carried out at Universidade Federal de Santa Maria – UFSM – Santa Maria (RS), Brasil. 1 Curso de Fonoaudiologia, Departamento de Fonoaudiologia, Universidade Federal de Santa Maria – UFSM – Santa Maria (RS), Brasil. 2 Departamento de Fonoaudiologia, Universidade Federal de Santa Maria – UFSM – Santa Maria (RS), Brasil. Conflict of interests: No. l
Authors’ contributions: BLF participated in the conception of the study, carried out data collection, analysis and interpretation of results and writing of the
manuscript; FSAP participated, as a supervisor, in the conception of the study, analysis and interpretation of the results and review of the article. Funding: None. g
Correspondence address: Bruna Luísa Fornari. E-mail: luisabrunaf@gmail.com Correspondence address: Bruna Luísa Fornari. E-mail: luisabrunaf@gmail.com
Received: September 07, 2022; Accepted: October 30, 2023 p
@g
Received: September 07, 2022; Accepted: October 30, 2023 Received: September 07, 2022; Accepted: October 30, 2023 Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 1 | 10 1 | 1
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution license, which permits unrestricted use,
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Audiol Commun Res. RESULTS The audiological profile did not differ statistically between
the groups. The most prevalent type of hearing loss in both
the adult and older adult groups was sensorineural. As for the
degree of hearing loss, the prevalence among older adults and
in the right ear of adults was moderately severe; in the left ear
of adults, moderate predominated, followed by moderately
severe, with no statistical difference between them (Table 1).i The audiological profile did not differ statistically between
the groups. The most prevalent type of hearing loss in both
the adult and older adult groups was sensorineural. As for the
degree of hearing loss, the prevalence among older adults and
in the right ear of adults was moderately severe; in the left ear
of adults, moderate predominated, followed by moderately
severe, with no statistical difference between them (Table 1). Regarding the time of daily use of hearing aids, a significant
portion of the subjects in both groups reported using the devices
for a period equal to or greater than 12 hours per day; the finding
did not differ between the groups (Table 2). Also, in general, the adoption of face protection masks and
physical distancing from the interlocutor, and the intensification
of digital technologies for distance communication brought
communicative difficulties to a significant part of both age groups. However, when asked if the protective measures represented
obstacles to social life or if they resulted in the interruption
of their interactions, both adults and older adults presented
different opinions: approximately half of the sample of each
group said “yes/sometimes”, and the other half answered “no”. f
(
)
Regarding the time of daily use of hearing aids, a significant
portion of the subjects in both groups reported using the devices
for a period equal to or greater than 12 hours per day; the finding
did not differ between the groups (Table 2). Table 1. Audiological profile of the sample subjects, according to the groups
Variables
Adults
Older people
p-value
N
%
p-value
N
%
p-value
Degree of hearing loss RE** (n=72)
Mild
0
0.0%
<0.001*
4
8.2%
<0.001*
0.369
Moderate
7
30.4%
0.008*
14
28.6%
<0.001*
Mod. Severe
16
69.6%
Ref. 31
63.3%
Ref. Degree of hearing loss LE** (n=72)
Mild
0
0.0%
<0.001*
3
6.1%
<0.001*
0.046
Moderate
12
52.2%
Ref. 12
24.5%
<0.001*
Mod. Severe
11
47.8%
0.768
34
69.4%
Ref. RESUMO The subjects were approached at the reception
of the service while waiting for assistance at the hearing aid
outpatient clinic and invited to participate in the present study
after receiving clarifications about the objectives and procedures
that would be performed. Upon acceptance and signature of the
FICF, the participants’ medical records were accessed to verify
information related to their hearing aspects, such as type and
degree of hearing loss and date of diagnosis. Therefore, given the need for the continuous practice of
protective measures against COVID-19 in many places and the
potential emergence of new respiratory viruses that may require
the mandatory reintroduction of these measures, the objectives
of this study were to investigate the perception of adults and
older users of hearing aids regarding the communicative,
social, and emotional impacts resulting from the adaptations
imposed by the pandemic and to verify the existence of an
association between communicative and social difficulties
and the variables degree of hearing loss and the mean time
of daily use of the devices, to avoid the exclusion of these
people from social life. Subsequently, 42 questions were applied using a data collection
form (Appendix 1) prepared by the responsible researchers through
oral presentation in individual interviews conducted in a large,
silent room. During the collection, the necessary precautions were
taken to prevent COVID-19 in force in that period. The data obtained were tabulated in an Excel spreadsheet
and then submitted to statistical tests with a significance level
of 5% (p-value<0.05). 2 | 10 Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 Communicative impact of the pandemic With regard to protective measures against COVID-19,
all participants in the sample experienced communication
with people who wore face masks. In both groups, the
significant majority reported having difficulty understanding
what was said to them, which generated significant losses
in interpersonal communication. Also, most subjects in both
groups adopted physical distancing and faced problems of
a similar proportion. However, approximately half of them
reported not having experienced feelings of sadness and/or
frustration resulting from this experience. At the same time,
the other portion indicated feeling sad and/or frustrated at
some point (Table 3). RESUMO The Equality of Two Proportions statistical test was used to
describe the prevalence of the type and degree of hearing loss
in the studied sample, according to each ear; to characterize
the users regarding the mean time of daily use of the devices;
to analyze the frequency and impact of the adoption of face
protection masks; physical distancing from the sound source
and use of digital technologies.i To compare the audiological profile, the time of daily use
of hearing aids, and the communicative, social, and emotional
impacts of protective measures between adults and older adults,
the Chi-Square statistical test was used. The same test was used to
show whether there was an association between communicative
and social difficulties and the variables time of use of hearing
aids and degree of hearing loss. It is worth noting that, when
associating the degree of hearing loss and communicative and
social difficulties, the degree of hearing loss of the best ear of
each of the research participants was considered. As for digital technologies, most hearing aid users reported
using these resources since before the pandemic, including
participation in video calls. However, difficulties with cell
phones and/or computers were reported more frequently among
adults (yes and/or sometimes), while older adults mostly did
not mention them. Regarding video calls in particular, it was
found that the subjects of both groups mostly did not feel
losses in communication due to pre-existing hearing difficulty. However, when comparing the groups, it was noted that older
adults perceived the impact of hearing loss during video calls
more (Table 3). *Statistically significant values (p≤0.05) – Test of Equality of Two Proportions and Chi-Square; < less than; **Classification of th
Subtitle: n = sample number; % = percentage; RE = right ear; LE = left ear; Ref. = reference value; Mod. = moderately 5) – Test of Equality of Two Proportions and Chi-Square; < less than; **Classification of the degree of hearing loss according to WHO15
ercentage; RE = right ear; LE = left ear; Ref. = reference value; Mod. = moderately RESULTS Type of hearing loss RE (n=72)
Sensorineural
18
78.3%
Ref. 44
89.8%
Ref. 0.419
Mixed
4
17.4%
<0.001*
4
8.2%
<0.001*
Conductive
1
4.3%
<0.001*
1
2.0%
<0.001*
Type of hearing loss LE (n=72)
Sensorineural
17
73.9%
Ref. 45
91.8%
Ref. 0.081
Mixed
5
21.7%
<0.001*
4
8.2%
<0.001*
Conductive
1
4.3%
<0.001*
0
0.0%
<0.001*
*Statistically significant values (p≤0.05) – Test of Equality of Two Proportions and Chi-Square; < less than; **Classification of the degree of hearing loss according to WHO15
Subtitle: n = sample number; % = percentage; RE = right ear; LE = left ear; Ref. = reference value; Mod. = moderately Table 1. Audiological profile of the sample subjects, according to the groups Table 1. Audiological profile of the sample subjects, according to the groups
V
i bl
Adults *Statistically significant values (p≤0.05) – Test of Equality of Two Proportions and Chi-Square; < less than; **Classification of the degree of hearing loss according to WHO15
Subtitle: n = sample number; % = percentage; RE = right ear; LE = left ear; Ref. = reference value; Mod. = moderately Table 2. Characterization and comparison of the sample of both groups regarding the variable time of use of the devices
Time of daily use
Adult
Older people
p-value
n
%
p-value
n
%
p-value
Up to 6 hours
0
0.0%
<0.001*
7
14.3%
<0.001*
From 6 to 12 hours
6
26.1%
0.001*
15
30.6%
0.014*
0.116
12 hours or more
17
73.9%
Ref. 27
55.1%
Ref. *Statistically significant values (p≤0.05) – Test of Equality of Two Proportions and Chi-Square; < less than
Subtitle: n = sample number; % = percentage; Ref. = reference value 3 | 10 Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 Fornari BL, Patatt FSA Finally, no association was evident between the communicative
and social difficulties listed in this study due to the COVID-19
pandemic and the factors of time of daily use of hearing aids
and degree of hearing loss of the better ear, both in the adult
and older adult groups (Tables 4 and 5). There were also divergent perspectives between the groups regarding
the feelings arising from the adoption of protective measures; the
group of adults reported, for the most part, experiencing negative
feelings resulting from the adoption of these measures, while the
group of older people dealt better with the situation (Table 3). RESULTS ponses to questions regarding protective measures and comparison between groups Table 3. Distribution of users’ responses to questions regarding protective measures and comparison between groups
Questions
Adults
Older people
p-value
n
%
p-value
N
%
p-value
Masks: Did you have difficulty understanding what people were saying to you
while wearing masks? No
2
8.7%
0.001*
9
18.4% <0.001*
0.264
Sometimes
9
39.1%
0.375
11 22.4% <0.001*
Yes
12 52.2%
Ref. 29 59.2%
Ref. Masks: Do you believe that the fact that people wear masks when talking to you
makes it difficult to communicate with them? No
2
8.7%
<0.001*
7
14.3% <0.001*
0.781
Sometimes
5
21.7%
0.001*
9
18.4% <0.001*
Yes
16 69.6%
Ref. 33 67.3%
Ref. Distancing: Did you have difficulty understanding what was said to you when
distancing from the speaker? No
3
14.3%
0.001*
12 26.1% <0.001*
0.102
Sometimes
5
23.8%
0.013*
3
6.5%
<0.001*
Yes
13 61.9%
Ref. 31 67.4%
Ref. Distancing: Did you feel frustrated/sad when you did not understand what they
told you because they were keeping their distance? No
11 52.4%
Ref. 22 47.8%
Ref. 0.160
Sometimes
0
0.0%
<0.001*
7
15.2% <0.001*
Yes
10 47.6%
0.758
17 37.0%
0.291
Technologies: Before the pandemic, did you already use digital technologies to
communicate with others or to work? Yes
22 95.7%
Ref. 43 87.8%
Ref. 0.292
No
1
4.3%
<0.001*
6
12.2% <0.001*
Technologies: Did you have difficulties communicating through digital technologies? No
10 43.5%
Ref. 30 68.2%
Ref. 0.090
Sometimes
7
30.4%
0.359
5
11.4% <0.001*
Yes
6
26.1%
0.216
9
20.5% <0.001*
Technologies: Did you participate in video calls after the beginning of the pandemic? Yes
15 65.2%
Ref. 26 53.1%
Ref. 0.331
No
8
34.8%
0.039*
23 46.9%
0.544
Technologies: If you participated in video calls, did you feel your communication
was impaired due to hearing difficulties? No
8
53.3%
Ref. 14 53.8%
Ref. 0.038*
Sometimes
6
40.0%
0.464
3
11.5%
0.001*
Yes
1
6.7%
0.005*
9
34.6%
0.163
Overall, did you feel that protective measures made it difficult for you to
communicate with others? No
7
30.4%
0.134
11 22.4%
0.031*
0.316
Sometimes
4
17.4%
0.013*
17 34.7%
0.407
Yes
12 52.2%
Ref. 21 42.9%
Ref. Overall, did you feel frustrated/sad about not understanding what they wanted
to tell you because of the protective measures? No
6
26.1%
0.008*
30 61.2%
Ref. DISCUSSION had found: that masks become an obstacle to interpersonal
communication due to a combination of different factors since,
in addition to blocking orofacial reading and facial expressions
during conversation, depending on the material of manufacture,
they can attenuate the acoustic transmission of speech by up
to 13.7 dB, making it more muffled and increasing the effort
required to vocalize. This generates difficulties in maintaining
adequate pneumo-phono-articulatory coordination and results
in less intelligible speech(7,10,13,19,21-25). Thus, the compiled
literature may justify the reports of the adults and older adults
participating in this study. The data obtained from the interviews with 72 users
of sound amplification devices allowed us to assess the
communicative and social impacts generated by adopting
protective measures against COVID-19 in two age groups:
adults and older adults. In both groups, sensorineural hearing loss predominated,
similar to that found in other studies conducted in the same
service(16) or others(2,17). These results can be explained by the
many pathologies that damage the sensory cells of the cochlea,
such as metabolic diseases, prolonged noise exposure, and
presbycusis – a condition that mainly affects older adults(18).i Also, the literature highlights that the use of transparent
display masks and plastic face shields, despite allowing orofacial
reading, has the worst acoustic speech attenuation indices
(10.8 dB and 13.7 dB, respectively), while those made of other
materials, such as propylene (3.6 dB) and KN95 (4 dB) have
lower attenuation values(13). The compiled literature identified the incident degree of
hearing loss as moderate(2,16). However, the present study found
that the prevalent degree of hearing loss in the adult group was
moderately severe in the right ear and moderate in the left ear,
while in the older adult group, moderately severe in both ears. This result can be attributed to the use of different classifications. In this study, the most recent one, recommended by the WHO(15),
was used, denominating hearing loss as moderately severe,
whose quadritonal mean is equal to or greater than 50 dB and
less than 65 dB. Regarding speech intelligibility with and without the use
of masks, recent studies indicate that a transparent display
significantly reduces speech understanding, compared to
surgical and/or cloth masks, and worsens understanding
when there is an increase in environmental noise(9,23,26). RESULTS 0.020*
Sometimes
2
8.7%
<0.001*
3
6.1%
<0.001*
Yes
15 65.2%
Ref. 16 32.7%
0.005*
Overall, did you feel that protective measures made your social life difficult? No
11 47.8%
Ref. 24 49.0%
Ref. 0.938
Sometimes
3
13.0%
0.010*
5
10.2% <0.001*
Yes
9
39.1%
0.552
20 40.8%
0.417
Overall, did you stop communicating due to possible communication difficulties
caused by the changes imposed by the pandemic? No
11 47.8%
Ref. 25 51.0%
Ref. 0.847
Sometimes
3
13.0%
0.010*
8
16.3% <0.001*
Yes
9
39.1%
0.552
16 32.7%
0.065
*Statistically significant values (p≤0.05) – Test of Equality of Two Proportions; < less than
Subtitle: n = sample number; % = percentage; Ref = reference value e communicative difficulties generated by the protective measures and the variables time of use of the devices
oth groups Table 4. Association between the communicative difficulties generated by the protective measures and the var
and degree of hearing loss, in both groups and degree of hearing loss, in both groups
Overall, did you feel that protective measures made it difficult
for you to communicate with others? No
Sometimes
Yes
Total
p-value
n
%
n
%
n
%
n
%
Adults
Time of daily use of hearing aids
6-12 hours
2
28.6%
2
50.0%
2
16.7%
6
26.1%
0.415
12 hours or more
5
71.4%
2
50.0%
10
83.3%
17
73.9%
Degree of hearing loss BE*
Moderate
3
42.9%
2
50.0%
9
75.0%
14
60.9%
0.340
Moderately Severe
4
57.1%
2
50.0%
3
25.0%
9
39.1%
Older people
Time of daily use of hearing aids
Up to 6 hours
1
9.1%
2
11.8%
4
19.0%
7
14.3%
0.892
6-12 hours
3
27.3%
5
29.4%
7
33.3%
15
30.6%
12 hours or more
7
63.6%
10
58.8%
10
47.6%
27
55.1%
Degree of hearing loss BE*
Mild
2
18.2%
3
17.6%
0
0.0%
5
10.2%
0.234
Moderate
4
36.4%
5
29.4%
5
23.8%
14
28.6%
Moderately Severe
5
45.5%
9
52.9%
16
76.2%
30
61.2%
Chi-square test *Classification of the degree of hearing loss according to WHO(15) 4 | 10 Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 Communicative impact of the pandemic Table 5. Association between difficulties in socialization generated by protective measures and the variables time of use of devices and degree of
hearing loss, in both groups
Overall, did you feel that protective measures made your social
life difficult? Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 RESULTS No
Sometimes
Yes
Total
p-value
N
%
N
%
N
%
N
%
Adults
Time of daily use of hearing aids
From 6 to 12 hours
4
36.4%
0
0%
2
22.2%
6
26.1%
0.421
More than 12 hours
7
63.6%
3
100%
7
77.8%
17
73.9%
Degree of hearing loss BE*
Moderate
5
45.5%
1
33.3%
8
88.9%
14
60.9%
0.081
Mod. Severe
6
54.5%
2
66.7%
1
11.1%
9
39.1%
Older people Time of daily use of hearing aids
Up to 6 hours
3
12.5%
1
20.0%
3
15.0%
7
14.3%
0.591
From 6 to 12 hours
5
20.8%
2
40.0%
8
40.0%
15
30.6%
More than 12 hours
16
66.7%
2
40.0%
9
45.0%
27
55.1%
Degree of hearing loss BE*
Mild
4
16.7%
0
0.0%
1
5.0%
5
10.2%
0.593
Moderate
7
29.2%
2
40.0%
5
25.0%
14
28.6%
Mod. Severe
13
54.2%
3
60.0%
14
70.0%
30
61.2%
Chi-square test *Classification of the degree of hearing loss according to WHO(15)
Subtitle: n = sample number; % = percentage; HA = hearing aid; BE = both ears Table 5. Association between difficulties in socialization generated by protective measures and the variables time of use of devices and degree of
hearing loss, in both groups Table 5. Association between difficulties in socialization generated by protective measures and the variables time of use of devices and degree of
h
i
l
i
b
h Chi-square test *Classification of the degree of hearing loss according to WHO(15)
Subtitle: n = sample number; % = percentage; HA = hearing aid; BE = both ears DISCUSSION Counseling addresses different communication strategies
to establish a clearer and more effective dialogue and
minimize the consequences of hearing loss(3). Some of the
alternatives include reducing environmental noise; drawing
the subject’s attention; speaking slowly and using shorter
utterances; articulating sounds more clearly; preferring to
reformulate sentences instead of repeating the same words;
using assistive technologies, when possible, and/or writing
on paper or a cell phone, among other possibilities that do not
cancel the recommended measures to reduce contamination
by the virus(10,19,21). As for video calls, both adults and older adults, for the most
part, did not feel the communicative losses resulting from the
pre-existing hearing condition, differing from what is pointed
out in the literature(6,11), probably due to this resource favoring
orofacial reading since, in these communicative situations,
people are without masks covering the face. However, when
comparing the groups, the already existing hearing loss had a
greater consequence on video calls among older adults, which
can be justified by the particularities of this instrument, such
as the delays of the image relative to the audio or possible
cuts in transmission(6,11), impairing communication in this age
group due to issues inherent to the aging process, such as the
impairment of central auditory structures, important for the
understanding and synthesis of speech. Finally, the present study had some limitations, with the
lack of objective measures to assess the impact caused by the
use of masks, digital technologies, and physical distancing
being one of them. Another bias of this research was the
discrepancy between the groups regarding the number and
gender of participants, which may have predisposed some
findings. Also, only individuals attended by the Unified Health
System (SUS), with low income and education, and from the
Southern Region of Brazil participated in the study(30). It is
suggested that future research be conducted in other regions of
the country, with a more stratified sample, but homogeneous
in number and gender. Also, it would be beneficial to have
objective measures complementary to subjective ones, such
as tests with words and/or sentences to be repeated and/
or discriminated phonetically, to assist in measuring the
communicative impairment caused by using different types
of masks and physical distancing. DISCUSSION This contrast can be explained by the communicative needs of
each subject since people with a greater demand for dialogue
possibly felt the impact caused by the approach restrictions
more considerably. characteristic environments of bars and restaurants), allowing
better understanding and participation of hearing aid users in
conversations(6,28).f There was a difference between the groups regarding the
emotional aspect resulting from adopting these measures. While adults reported more negative emotional aspects,
many older adults did not experience them. This finding
may be because older adults were classified as a risk group
and, thus, were the most protected individuals with the
least social interactions; consequently, they had reduced
opportunities to experience the emotional repercussions of
the measures adopted in communication. On the other hand,
adults adhered less to social distancing and, therefore, used
protective masks more frequently, a finding also evidenced
in the literature(29). contrast, the other participants did not experience these feelings. This contrast can be explained by the communicative needs of
each subject since people with a greater demand for dialogue
possibly felt the impact caused by the approach restrictions
more considerably. With COVID-19, digital technologies have become essential
to keep in touch with loved ones during the social distancing
period(14). However, as previously explained and in the literature,
these means of communication can present themselves as
additional obstacles for people with hearing loss, especially
in the quality and synchronization of audio and image, which
often reproduce delays(6,11). COVID preventive measures, by preventing the processes
commonly adopted by hearing aid users, brought communicative
and social difficulties to both groups, regardless of the degree
of hearing loss and the mean time of daily use of the devices,
denoting that speech therapy guidance for all subjects who felt
these impairments in communication is essential in order to
minimize the impact(22).f Unlike, in a certain aspect, the compiled literature, no
significant difficulties were evidenced in the use of digital
technologies by older adults. In contrast, most adults alluded
to them at some point. This can be attributed to the greater
demand for adaptation (suffered by adults), which requires
abrupt adaptation to new regimes, tools, and ways of working
and may have contributed to the perceived difficulties related
to technologies. On the other hand, the older research subjects
who already had experience with some resources and were
familiar with their use and handling did not have their routine
so disturbed. DISCUSSION Therefore, masks with transparent displays and face shields
are not adequate resources for individuals with hearing loss,
so it is important to adopt efficient strategies that help in the
interpersonal communication of hearing aid users, such as
speaking more slowly, with shorter utterances, and better
articulation of sounds(9,23,26). Individuals with hearing loss, in addition to the need for
auditory rehabilitation through the use of electronic hearing
aids, among them hearing aids, lack communicative strategies
that favor understanding the content of the message, such as,
for example, observing facial expressions, performing orofacial
reading, and approaching the sound source(2,3,19). The physical distancing between the listener and the
speaker was pointed out as another impediment to interpersonal
communication by the subjects of this research, which caused
relevant communicative difficulties for both groups; this finding
is also in line with that observed in other recently published
studies(6,8-10). The finding demonstrates that sound energy, at
normal conversation distances of 0.5 to one meter, tends to
dissipate by about 6 dB before reaching the listener; with
increasing distance between people, this attenuation becomes
even greater, creating communicative barriers for users(6,10). Furthermore, it is possible to understand that distancing also
disadvantages the perception of facial expressions and orofacial
reading, in addition to making it difficult to capture sound through
the microphone of the amplification devices since sound loses
energy as a function of distance(6). With the advent of COVID-19, society had to reorganize
itself to curb the curve of contagion by the virus and avoid
overloading health systems. In this context, the use of face
protection masks, physical distancing, and the use of digital
technologies for distance communication became measures widely
adopted by the population(4,5,8,20,21), including the individuals
who made up the sample of the present study. However, such
measures compromise the usual communicative strategies and
the integration of hearing aid users with society(8,10,11,21). According to the analyses conducted, the percentage of
subjects who reported communicative difficulties resulting from
the interaction with the use of masks was significant in both
groups investigated. This finding confirms what the literature 5 | 10 Fornari BL, Patatt FSA Despite the above, only about half of the sample of each
group reported experiencing negative feelings, such as sadness
and/or frustration, resulting from the urgency of distancing. In
contrast, the other participants did not experience these feelings. DISCUSSION Regarding the impact of the adoption of protective
measures on social life, about which intra-group opinions
were divided, the present study argues that the low perception
of the negative effects of isolation in the pandemic in both
groups is justified by the easy access to digital technologies
that enabled maintaining social contact. This may have brought
these individuals closer to friends and family members with
whom they usually could not talk due to the distance and the
hustle and bustle of daily life, thus enabling greater social
interaction between these individuals(14). Additionally, it is
important to emphasize that adults and older adults generally
have a more family-centered life, which means that their social
circle tends to be more restricted. Therefore, it is possible
that these age groups felt less impact in this area compared
to adolescents and young adults, who used to have a more
active social life(27). REFERENCES 16. Petry T. Perfil epidemiológico dos pacientes atendidos no laboratório de
próteses auditivas da Universidade Federal de Santa Maria [monografia
de especialização]. Santa Maria: Programa de Pós-graduação em
Distúrbios da Comunicação Humana, Universidade Federal de Santa
Maria; 2007. 1. WHO: World Health Organization. World Report on Hearing [Internet]. Geneva: WHO; 2021 [citado em 2022 Jul 23]. Disponível em: https://
www.who.int/publications/i/item/world-report-on-hearing 17. Ribeiro UASL, Souza VC, Lemos SMA. Qualidade de vida e
determinantes sociais em usuários de aparelho de amplificação sonora
individual. CoDAS. 2019;2(31):1-9. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/2317-
1782/20182017287. PMid:30942286. 2. Viacelli SNA, da Costa-Ferreira MID. Perfil dos usuários de AASI
com vistas à amplificação, cognição e processamento auditivo. Rev
CEFAC. 2013;15(5):1125-36. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S1516-
18462012005000098. 18. Polanski JF. Presbiacusia. In: Piltcher OB, da Costa SS, Maahs GS,
Kuhl G, organizadores. Rotinas em Otorrinolaringologia. Porto Alegre:
ArtMed; 2015. p. 83-86. 3. Freire KGM. Estratégias de avaliação e reabilitação em deficientes
auditivos adultos. In: Boechat EM, Menezes PL, Couto CM, Frizzo ACF,
Scharlach RC, Anastasio ART, organizadores. Tratado de audiologia. 2. ed. Rio de Janeiro: Guanabara Koogan; 2015. p. 744-53. 19. Brotto D, Sorrentino F, Agostinelli A, Lovo E, Montino S, Trevisi P, et al. How great is the negative impact of masking and social distancing
and how can we enhance communication skills in the elderly people? Aging Clin Exp Res. 2021;33(5):1157-61. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/
s40520-021-01830-1. PMid:33725340. 4. Oliveira AC, Lucas TC, Iquiapaza RA. O que a pandemia da Covid-19
tem nos ensinado sobre adoção de medidas de precaução? Texto
Contexto Enferm. 2020;29:1-15. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1980-
265x-tce-2020-0106. 20. Sartoratto MC, Queiroz LPR, Almeida GS, Nascimento TB, Santos
CS, Gutierrez BAO, et al. Dilemas sobre o uso da máscara facial
no pós-pandemia: uma medida preventiva e controle de doenças
respiratórias infectocontagiosas. Mundo Saude. 2022;46:131-41. http://dx.doi.org/10.15343/0104-7809.202246131141. 5. OPAS: Organização Pan-Americana da Saúde. O uso de máscaras
no contexto da COVID-19. Orientação provisória. 1 de dezembro de
2020 [Internet]. 2020 [citado em 2022 Jul 23]. Disponível em: https://
iris.paho.org/handle/10665.2/53101 6. Naylor G, Burke LA, Holman JA. Covid-19 Lockdown affects hearing
disability and handicap in diverse ways: a rapid online survey study. Ear and Hearing. 2020;41(6):1442-9. http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/
AUD.0000000000000948. 21. Hulzen RDT, Fabry DA. Impact of hearing loss and universal face
masking in the COVID-19 Era. Mayo Clin Proc. 2020;95(10):2069-72. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mayocp.2020.07.027. PMid:33012338. 22. Bandaru SV, Augustine AM, Lepcha A, Sebastian S, Gowri M, Philip
A, et al. CONCLUSION The use of face masks and physical distancing from
the interlocutor significantly impacted the interpersonal
communication of hearing aid users in both groups, resulting in
impairments in communicative interaction. The difficulty with
using digital technologies, such as cell phones and computers,
was predominant among adults due to pre-existing hearing
loss. In contrast, older adults perceived the impact of hearing
alteration on video calls more. From another perspective, it is believed that the protective
measures did not impact the social life of approximately half
of the sample due to the change in the profile of the meetings,
which started to happen with a small number of people, favoring
social interactions in a domestic environment (a place where it
is possible to control environmental noise, different from the 6 | 10 Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 Communicative impact of the pandemic 13. Corey RM, Jones U, Singer AC. Acoustic effects of medical,
cloth, and transparent face masks on speech signals. J Acoust Soc
Am. 2020;148(4):2371-5. http://dx.doi.org/10.1121/10.0002279. PMid:33138498. As for the negative repercussion of protective measures
relative to social life, both for adults and older adults, opinions
were divided between those who perceived it, at least at
some point (“yes/sometimes”), and those who did not feel it. Regarding the emotional impact, adults experienced higher
rates of negative feelings (sadness and/or frustration) than
older adults. 14. Michereff V Jr, Feuerschutte SG, Sanchez PB. Comunicação nas
organizações no contexto da covid-19. Revista Gestão Organizacional. 2021;14(1):54-76. https://doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.22277/rgo. v14i1. Also, the communicative and social consequences of adopting
protective measures against COVID-19 were independent of the
degree of hearing loss and the time of daily use of individual
sound amplification devices. 15. WHO: World Health Organization. Basic ear and hearing care resource
[Internet]. Geneva: WHO; 2020 [citado em 2022 Jul 27]. Disponível
em: http://www.who.int/publications-detail/basic-ear-and-hearing-
care-resource REFERENCES The effects of N95 mask and face shield on speech perception
among healthcare workers in the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic
scenario. J Laryngol Otol. 2020;134(10):1-4. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/
S0022215120002108. PMid:32981539. 7. Saunders GH, Jackson IR, Visram AS. Impacts of face coverings
on communication: an indirect impact of COVID-19. Int J Audiol. 2021;60(7):495-506. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14992027.2020.1851
401. PMid:33246380. 8. Tavanai E, Rouhbakhsh N, Roghani Z. A review of the challenges
facing people with hearing loss during the COVID-19 outbreak:
toward the understanding the helpful solutions. Audit Vestib Res. 2021:30(2):62-73. https://doi.org/10.18502/avr.v30i2.6091. 23. Brown VA, van Engen KJ, Peelle JE. Face mask type affects audiovisual
speech intelligibility and subjective listening effort in young and older
adults. Cogn Res Princ Implic. 2021;6(1):49. http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/
s41235-021-00314-0. PMid:34275022. 9. Oosthuizen I, Saunders GH, Manchaiah V, Swanepoel DW. Impact
of SARS-CoV-2 Virus (COVID-19) preventative measures on
communication: a scoping review. Front Public Health. 2022;10:1-10. http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2022.815259. 24. Giovanelli E, Valzolgher C, Gessa E, Todeschini M, Pavani F. Unmasking
the difficulty of listening to talkers with masks: lessons from the
COVID-19 pandemic. Iperception. 2021;12(2):2041669521998393. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/2041669521998393. PMid:35145616. 10. Garg S, Deshmukh CP, Singh MM, Borle A, Wilson BS. Challenges
of the deaf and hearing impaired in the masked world of COVID-19. Indian J Community Med. 2021;46(1):11-4. http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/
ijcm.IJCM_581_20. PMid:34035568. 25. Ribeiro VV, Dassie-Leite AP, Pereira EC, Santos ADN, Martins P,
Irineu RA. Effect of wearing a face mask on vocal self-perception
during a pandemic. J Voice. 2020;20:1-7. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j. jvoice.2020.09.006. PMid:33011037. 11. Crume B. The silence behind the mask: My Journey as a deaf pediatric
resident amid a pandemic. Acad Pediatr. 2021;21(1):1-2. http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/j.acap.2020.10.002. PMid:33045413. 26. Maryn Y, Wuyts FL, Zarowski A. Are acoustic markers of voice and
speech signals affected by nose-and-mouth-covering respiratory
protective masks? J Voice. 2021;37(3):468.e1-e12. http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2021.01.013. PMid:33608184. 12. Trabant J. Viver com a máscara facial: murmúrio, murmúrio. Cad
Trad (Florianópolis). 2021;300-3. 7 | 10 Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 Fornari BL, Patatt FSA 27. Miranda GBS. Fatores associados ao estresse em isolamento social durante
a pandemia de Covid-19. Rev Soc Bras Fonoaudiol. 2021;13(2):166-72. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S1516-80342008000200011. 29. Barros AD, Victora CG, Menezes AMB, Horta BL, Hartwig F, Victora
G, et al. Social distancing patterns in nine municipalities of Rio Grande do
Sul, Brazil: the Epicovid19/RS study. Rev Saude Publica. 2020;54(75):1-14. http://dx.doi.org/10.11606/s1518-8787.2020054002810. PMid:32725098. 28. Dunn CC, Stangl E, Oleson J, Smith M, Chipara O, Wu YH. 8 | 10 REFERENCES How was your work routine after the beginning of the pandemic:__________________________ REFERENCES The
Influence of forced social isolation on the auditory ecology and
psychosocial functions of listeners with Cochlear Implants During
COVID-19 mitigation efforts. Ear Hear. 2020;42(1):20-8. http://dx.doi. org/10.1097/AUD.0000000000000991. PMid:33369590. 30. Vellozo FF, Didoné DD, Garcia MV, Fedosse E. Caracterização dos
candidatos ao uso de próteses auditivas em um serviço de saúde
auditiva regional do estado do Rio Grande do Sul. Saúde (Santa Maria). 2014;40(2):67-72. http://dx.doi.org/10.5902/2236583412878. Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 Communicative impact of the pandemic Appendix 1. Questions presented to users for data collection Appendix 1. Questions presented to users for data collection
DATA COLLECTION FORM (HEARING AID USER)
COLLECTION IDENTIFICATION
No. _________ Collection date: _______/_______/_______ Location: ____________________________________
SUBJECT IDENTIFICATION
Name: ______________________________________________________________________ Gender: __________
Age: _______ years Date of birth: _______/_______/_______ CPF: ____________________________
Arrived accompanied by: ___________________________________________________________________________
Phone: ____________ and ____________ Email: ____________________________________________________
Marital status: __________ Resides with: ____________________________________________________________
1. Performs medical follow-up/with other health professionals: ( ) Yes ( ) No
2. If yes, which:____________________________________________________________________________
AUDIOLOGICAL AND PROSTHETIZATION DATA
Date of last audiometry: _______/_______/_______ Date of prosthetization: _______/_______/_______
3. On average, how many hours per day did you use the hearing aids:
( ) maximum 3 hours per day ( ) from 3 to 6 hours per day ( ) from 6 to 9 hours per day ( ) from 9 to 12 hours per day ( ) from 12 to 15 hours per day
( ) more than 15 hours per day
4. Did not use the device in the last months: ( ) Yes ( ) No
If yes: 5. When_______/_______/_______ 6. How long: ______________________________
OCCUPATION
7. Do you work: ( ) Yes ( ) No 8. Where you work: _________________________________________________
9. Job function: ___________________________________________________________________________________
10. If you work, did you remain in the same job after the beginning of the pandemic: ( ) No ( ) Yes
11. How was your work routine after the beginning of the pandemic:________________________________________________
COVID-19 AND PROTECTIVE MEASURES
12. Did you adopt social isolation measures: ( ) No ( ) Yes _ Resides with: _ 2. If yes, which:____________________________________________________________________________
AUDIOLOGICAL AND PROSTHETIZATION DATA
Date of last audiometry: _______/_______/_______ Date of prosthetization: _______/_______/_______ AUDIOLOGICAL AND PROSTHETIZATION DATA _ Date of prosthetization: _ . On average, how many hours per day did you use the hearing aids: 10. If you work, did you remain in the same job after the beginning of the pandemic: ( ) No ( ) Yes
11. COVID-19 AND PROTECTIVE MEASURES ( ) Started to have tinnitus – If so, on which side: ( ) right ( ) left ( ) both ( ) Worsening of tinnitus – if you had it, on which side: ( ) right ( ) left ( ) both ( ) Otalgia – if you had it, on which side: ( ) right ( ) left ( ) both ( ) Otorrhea – if you had it, on which side: ( ) right ( ) left ( ) both ( ) Auricular Fullness – if you had it, on which side: ( ) right ( ) left ( ) both Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722 9 | 10 Fornari BL, Patatt FSA Appendix 1. Continued... DATA COLLECTION FORM (HEARING AID USER) DATA COLLECTION FORM (HEARING AID USER)
USE OF FACE PROTECTION MASKS
26. Did you communicate with others while wearing masks? ( ) No ( ) Yes
27. Did you have difficulty understanding what people were saying to you while wearing masks? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
28. Do you believe that the fact that people wear masks when talking to you makes it difficult to communicate with them? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
PHYSICAL DISTANCING
29. Have you communicated with anyone while distancing from them? ( ) Yes ( ) No
30. Did you have difficulty understanding what was said to you when distancing from the speaker? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
31. Did you feel frustrated/sad when you did not understand what they told you because they kept their distance? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
USE OF DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES
32. Did you use digital technologies to communicate with others at a distance? ( ) No ( ) Yes
33. Before the pandemic, did you already use digital technologies to communicate with others or to work? ( ) No ( ) Yes
34. Did you have difficulties communicating through digital technologies? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
35. Did you participate in video calls after the beginning of the pandemic? ( ) No ( ) Yes
36. If you participated in video calls, did you feel your communication was impaired due to hearing difficulties? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
PROTECTION MEASURES AND COMMUNICATION DIFFICULTIES
37. COVID-19 AND PROTECTIVE MEASURES Overall, do you feel that protective measures made it difficult for you to communicate with others? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
38. Overall, did you feel frustrated/sad about not understanding what they wanted to tell you because of the protective measures? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
39. Overall, do you feel protective measures made your social life difficult? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
40. Overall, if you work, do you feel the protective measures have made your professional life difficult? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
41. Overall, do the difficulties of understanding arising from protective measures cause you to interact less with other people? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes
42. Did you stop communicating with people at times due to possible communication difficulties caused by the changes imposed by the pandemic? ( ) No ( ) Sometimes ( ) Yes you communicate with others while wearing masks? ( ) No ( ) Yes 10 | 10 USE OF DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES Audiol Commun Res. 2024;29:e2722
|
https://openalex.org/W3212682533
|
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0259842&type=printable
|
English
| null |
Use of universal primers for the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and whole soil DNAs to reveal the taxonomic structures of soil nematodes by high-throughput amplicon sequencing
|
PloS one
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 20,000
|
PLOS ONE PLOS ONE Use of universal primers for the 18S
ribosomal RNA gene and whole soil DNAs to
reveal the taxonomic structures of soil
nematodes by high-throughput amplicon
sequencing Harutaro Kenmotsu1☯, Emi Takabayashi1☯, Akinori Takase1☯, Yuu Hirose1,2,
Toshihiko EkiID1,2* a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111
a1111111111 1 Molecular Genetics Laboratory, Department of Applied Chemistry and Life Science, Toyohashi University
of Technology, Toyohashi, Aichi, Japan, 2 Research Center for Agrotechnology and Biotechnology,
Toyohashi University of Technology, Toyohashi, Aichi, Japan ☯These authors contributed equally to this work. * eki@chem.tut.ac.jp Abstract Citation: Kenmotsu H, Takabayashi E, Takase A,
Hirose Y, Eki T (2021) Use of universal primers for
the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and whole soil DNAs
to reveal the taxonomic structures of soil
nematodes by high-throughput amplicon
sequencing. PLoS ONE 16(11): e0259842. https://
doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842 Nematodes are abundant metazoans that play crucial roles in nutrient recycle in the pedo-
sphere. Although high-throughput amplicon sequencing is a powerful tool for the taxonomic
profiling of soil nematodes, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers for amplification of
the 18S ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene and preparation of template DNAs have not been suffi-
ciently evaluated. We investigated nematode community structure in copse soil using four
nematode-specific (regions 1–4) and two universal (regions U1 and U2) primer sets for the
SSU gene regions with two DNAs prepared from copse-derived mixed nematodes and
whole soil. The major nematode-derived sequence variants (SVs) identified in each region
was detected in both template DNAs. Order level taxonomy and feeding type of identified
nematode-derived SVs were distantly related between the two DNA preparations, and
the region U2 was closely related to region 4 in the non-metric multidimensional scaling
(NMDS) based on Bray-Curtis dissimilarity. Thus, the universal primers for region U2 could
be used to analyze soil nematode communities. We further applied this method to analyze
the nematodes living in two sampling sites of a sweet potato-cultivated field, where the
plants were differently growing. The structure of nematode-derived SVs from the two sites
was distantly related in the principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) with weighted unifrac dis-
tances, suggesting their distinct soil environments. The resultant ecophysiological status of
the nematode communities in the copse and field on the basis of feeding behavior and matu-
rity indices was fairly consistent with those of the copse- and the cultivated house garden-
derived nematodes in prior studies. These findings will be useful for the DNA metabarcoding
of soil eukaryotes, including nematodes, using soil DNAs. Editor: Ebrahim Shokoohi, University of Limpopo,
SOUTH AFRICA ☯These authors contributed equally to this work.
* eki@chem.tut.ac.jp 1 Molecular Genetics Laboratory, Department of Applied Chemistry and Life Science, Toyohashi University
of Technology, Toyohashi, Aichi, Japan, 2 Research Center for Agrotechnology and Biotechnology,
Toyohashi University of Technology, Toyohashi, Aichi, Japan Introduction and Economic Research Foundation (http://
takahashi-f.or.jp) to T.E. The funders had no role in
study design, data collection and analysis, decision
to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. and Economic Research Foundation (http://
takahashi-f.or.jp) to T.E. The funders had no role in
study design, data collection and analysis, decision
to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Soil ecosystem is composed of microbiota and soil [1]. Soil biota is influenced by soil
environments because soils are heterologous with different chemical and physical properties,
including pH, nutrients, and water contents. Therefore, the taxonomic composition of soil
organisms reflects the environmental conditions of soils. Soil biota, especially microbiome, is
influenced by plants (crops) [2, 3]. Thus, quantitative information on the taxa of soil organisms
is useful for assessing soil environments, including agricultural soils. Nematodes are abundant
animals with various species and feeding habitats and are widely distributed in freshwater,
marine, and terrestrial environments [4–7]. They play a crucial role in soil nutrient recycling
[8, 9] and occupy the ecological position in the pedosphere comparable to that of planktons in
the hydrosphere. Nematode taxonomic compositions are influenced by ecosystem type and
various factors, such as food availability and abundance, physical, and chemical parameters
(e.g., pH, temperature) [8, 9], soil properties [9, 10], latitude [11, 12], and agricultural condi-
tions (e.g., tillage, cultivated plants, fertilizers) [13–22]. Thus, the taxonomic composition and
abundance of nematodes have been used as an indicator of biological, environmental, and tox-
icological conditions in soils [4, 23, 24]. Competing interests: The authors have declared
that no competing interests exist. Traditional morphology-based methods of nematode taxonomic identification are labori-
ous, require high skills and experience, and produce poor analysis throughput. Thus, several
methods have been developed [25, 26]. DNA barcoding can accurately identify species on
the basis of the nucleotide sequences of DNA barcodes without the need for special experi-
ence on nematode morphologies [27]. Prior research by our laboratory demonstrated the
presence of distinct nematode taxonomic compositions in soybean-cultivated agricultural
and unmanaged follower bed soils using DNA barcoding by Sanger sequencing of the 18S
small subunit ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene and the cytochrome c oxidase I (COI) gene from
individual nematodes [28]. Editor: Ebrahim Shokoohi, University of Limpopo,
SOUTH AFRICA Received: June 16, 2021
Accepted: October 28, 2021
Published: November 15, 2021 Copyright: © 2021 Kenmotsu et al. This is an open
access article distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original
author and source are credited. Data Availability Statement: The sequences data
were deposited in the DDBJ Sequence Read
Archive database under accession number
DRA012120 with BioProject ID PRJDB11694 and
BioSample IDs SAMD00325389 to
SAMD00325398. All other relevant data are within
the paper and its Supporting information files. Funding: This work was supported by grants for
scientific research and education by Toyohashi
University of Technology and Takahashi Industrial 1 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes and Economic Research Foundation (http://
takahashi-f.or.jp) to T.E. The funders had no role in
study design, data collection and analysis, decision
to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Introduction In this study, the nucleotide sequences of polymerase chain reac-
tion (PCR)-amplified barcode DNAs from individual nematodes were determined using
Sanger-based DNA sequencing; the nematodes were then classified by their sequences into
taxonomic groups sharing identical DNA barcode sequences, known as operational taxo-
nomic units (OTUs). The number of OTUs indicates the number of taxonomic groups (i.e.,
nematode species diversity), and the number of nematodes in each OTU shows the propor-
tion of each taxonomic group in the nematode community. Despite successful profiling of
soil nematode taxa, DNA barcoding based on one-by-one sequencing is laborious and time
consuming, and the resultant quantitative data of nematode-derived OTUs are insufficient
and hardly cover the taxa of nematodes comprehensively because of limited sample process-
ing capacity. Recent advancement in massive DNA sequencing technology allows developing
the taxonomic profiling of organisms using the high-throughput amplicon sequencing of
DNA barcodes. This method has been further applied to the taxonomic analysis of soil nema-
todes. To assess suitable regions for this method among four SSU gene regions (regions 1–4,
337–388 base pair (bp) in length), Kenmotsu et al. (2020) clarified the taxa of 68 out of 96
individual nematodes isolated from copse soil using high-throughput amplicon sequencing
via the Illumina MiSeq platform [29]. In this study, region 4, located at the 3´-region of the
SSU gene, was suggested as the most suitable barcode among the four regions because of the
identification of the large number of nematode-derived sequence variants (SVs) and suffi-
cient reference sequence coverage in the DNA barcoding of individual nematodes. Recently,
Kenmotsu et al. have applied high-throughput amplicon sequencing using the genomic
DNAs of complex nematodes isolated from three sites (i.e., copse, uncultivated field, and
zucchini-cultivated house garden) and successfully clarified distinct proportions of nema-
tode taxa and the ecophysiological status of nematode families in each site [30]. This study PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 2 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes has also suggested that region 4 is the most suitable for the DNA barcoding of complex
mixed nematodes among the four regions. Currently, DNA barcoding of soil nematodes is performed using the high-throughput
sequencing of SSU gene-derived amplicons. Nematode-specific SSU primers are usually used
for amplifications from genomic DNAs purified from complex soil nematodes [11, 20, 22, 30,
31]. Introduction Moreover, universal SSU primers have been recently developed for the DNA barcoding of
eukaryotes through high-throughput amplicon sequencing [32, 33]. The amplicons by the uni-
versal SSU primers contain more heterologous species than those by the taxa-specific primers,
making them suitable for DNA metabarcoding. Therefore, taxonomic analyses of soil nema-
tode communities have been conducted through this method using universal primers and
complex nematode genomic DNAs [12, 21, 34]. In several studies, whole soil DNAs has been
used for amplifications in place of nematode genomic DNAs [35–38]. However, studies have
yet to determine whether or not these universal primers amplify nematode-derived DNAs
as observed in the amplicons using nematode-specific primers or if consistent results are
obtained from the analyses using soil and genomic DNAs of nematodes isolated from the soil. In the present work, approximately 340–450 bp fragments of the SSU gene were prepared by
PCR using two universal primer sets for regions U1 and U2 in addition to four previously eval-
uated nematode-specific primer sets for regions 1–4. These fragments were subjected to Illu-
mina sequencing to investigate whether or not the universal primers can be used in place of
nematode-specific primers for the taxonomic profiling of soil nematodes. Soil DNAs can be
directly prepared from soil samples and likely contain more nematode species because of puri-
fication without the bias-prone process of nematode isolation. Therefore, we simultaneously
tested whole soil DNAs as template DNAs for amplifying the six regions-derived fragments
and genomic DNAs from nematodes isolated from copse soils. Furthermore, the taxa of nema-
tode communities in the agricultural field were investigated by massive amplicon sequencing
using the universal primers and soil DNAs derived from two sites in the field, where the plants
were differently growing. This study could guide researchers working on the DNA metabar-
coding of soil eukaryotes, including nematodes, using soil DNAs. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Experimental design Two experiments were performed in this study (Figs 1 and 2): 1) testing of the suitable univer-
sal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene and soil DNA used as template DNA for
high-throughput amplicon sequencing to analyze the soil nematode communities and 2) appli-
cation of the developed method for taxonomic profiling of nematodes in the agricultural soils
with different depth and plantation. In the experiment 1, we tested six primer sets amplifying
each SSU region by PCR: four nematode-specific primer sets for regions 1–4 [29, 30] and two
universal eukaryotic primer sets for regions U1 and U2 (Fig 1B). In parallel, we compared the
taxonomic profiles of the nematodes living in the copse soils using the DNA prepared from
whole soils and complex nematodes isolated by flotation sieving method [28]. Nematode taxa
derived from 12 amplicons generated by six primer sets and two template DNAs were investi-
gated (Fig 1A). In the experiment 2, we conducted the taxonomic profiling of nematodes
through high-throughput amplicon sequencing using the universal primer set and whole soil
DNA in the sweet potato-cultivated field (Fig 2A). We analyzed eight soil samples used for
DNA purification were isolated from the surface and deep layers (Fig 2D) at the sampling
points with (plants) and without (control) sweet potato at two sites, where the plants were
growing differently (Fig 2B and 2C) in the agricultural field. These experiments were per-
formed once. 3 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Fig 1. Experimental scheme 1 for the copse-derived nematodes and PCR target regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene. The experimental scheme of
the high throughput sequencing of 12 amplicons prepared from six regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene using the copse derived nematode Fig 1. Experimental scheme 1 for the copse-derived nematodes and PCR target regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene. The experimental scheme of
the high-throughput sequencing of 12 amplicons prepared from six regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene using the copse-derived nematode
genomic DNA and whole soil DNA is shown (A). Experimental design Red colored codes in parentheses for sample DNA (e.g., Z03) represent the nematode genomic DNA
with the soil sample code (Z: copse) and the experimental ID (03), and the code Z03S indicates the soil DNA purified from the copse soil in the same
experiment (S: soil DNA). R1–R4, U1 and U2 in red are the abbreviations of PCR target regions in this study (A). Six PCR target regions with their
abbreviations and sizes of amplicons are shown by bold double-headed arrows in gray for nematode-specific primers and in dark red for universal primers
(B). The numbers indicating the nucleotide positions of the 5´-end of forward primers are shown on the entire SSU gene prepared from the nucleotide
sequence of C. elegans ribosomal RNA gene cluster (X03680). Teal colored boxes correspond to the hypervariable regions of eukaryotic SSU genes
reported by Hugerth et al. [33] and Hadziavdic et al. [32]. The regions amplified by two published nematode-specific primer sets (NF1/18Sr2b and NemF/
18Sr2b) [35, 60] and four eukaryotic universal primer sets (3NDf/1132rmod [34], 566-F/915-R [37], Ek-NS573/Ek-NSR951[58, 64], F-1183/R-1631 [58,
65], Euk1391f/EukBr [36, 66, 67]) are also indicated by double-headed arrows in gray and dark red with sizes of amplicons, respectively. Fig 1B has been
modified and prepared from the Fig 1B appearing in our previous paper [29]. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g001 Fig 1. Experimental scheme 1 for the copse-derived nematodes and PCR target regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene. The experimental scheme of
the high-throughput sequencing of 12 amplicons prepared from six regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene using the copse-derived nematode
genomic DNA and whole soil DNA is shown (A). Red colored codes in parentheses for sample DNA (e.g., Z03) represent the nematode genomic DNA
with the soil sample code (Z: copse) and the experimental ID (03), and the code Z03S indicates the soil DNA purified from the copse soil in the same
experiment (S: soil DNA). R1–R4, U1 and U2 in red are the abbreviations of PCR target regions in this study (A). Six PCR target regions with their
abbreviations and sizes of amplicons are shown by bold double-headed arrows in gray for nematode-specific primers and in dark red for universal primers
(B). The numbers indicating the nucleotide positions of the 5´-end of forward primers are shown on the entire SSU gene prepared from the nucleotide
sequence of C. elegans ribosomal RNA gene cluster (X03680). PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Experimental design Experimental scheme 2 for the field-derived nematodes by amplicon sequencing using the universal primers and soil DNA. The
experimental scheme of the high-throughput sequencing of amplicons prepared using the agricultural field-derived soil DNA (H03S) and the universal
SSU primers for region U2 is shown (A). Soil samples were isolated from the surface (0–10 cm in depth) and deep (20–30 cm) layers (D) of the distal
(control: without plants) and proximal (plants: with plants) points to the growing sweet potato (B, C) as indicated by red/white squares, at two different
sites in the field (B: site 1 and C: site 2). Growth of the plants at site 1 (B) was apparently dominated compared with that at site 2 (C). Regarding the code
H03S for template DNA, see the legend for Fig 1. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g002 Fig 2. Experimental scheme 2 for the field-derived nematodes by amplicon sequencing using the universal primers and soil DNA. The
experimental scheme of the high-throughput sequencing of amplicons prepared using the agricultural field-derived soil DNA (H03S) and the universal
SSU primers for region U2 is shown (A). Soil samples were isolated from the surface (0–10 cm in depth) and deep (20–30 cm) layers (D) of the distal
(control: without plants) and proximal (plants: with plants) points to the growing sweet potato (B, C) as indicated by red/white squares, at two different
sites in the field (B: site 1 and C: site 2). Growth of the plants at site 1 (B) was apparently dominated compared with that at site 2 (C). Regarding the code
H03S for template DNA, see the legend for Fig 1. Fig 2. Experimental scheme 2 for the field-derived nematodes by amplicon sequencing using the universal primers and soil DNA. The
experimental scheme of the high-throughput sequencing of amplicons prepared using the agricultural field-derived soil DNA (H03S) and the universal
SSU primers for region U2 is shown (A). Soil samples were isolated from the surface (0–10 cm in depth) and deep (20–30 cm) layers (D) of the distal
(control: without plants) and proximal (plants: with plants) points to the growing sweet potato (B, C) as indicated by red/white squares, at two different
sites in the field (B: site 1 and C: site 2). Growth of the plants at site 1 (B) was apparently dominated compared with that at site 2 (C). Regarding the code
H03S for template DNA, see the legend for Fig 1. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g002 Experimental design Teal colored boxes correspond to the hypervariable regions of eukaryotic SSU genes
reported by Hugerth et al. [33] and Hadziavdic et al. [32]. The regions amplified by two published nematode-specific primer sets (NF1/18Sr2b and NemF/
18Sr2b) [35, 60] and four eukaryotic universal primer sets (3NDf/1132rmod [34], 566-F/915-R [37], Ek-NS573/Ek-NSR951[58, 64], F-1183/R-1631 [58,
65], Euk1391f/EukBr [36, 66, 67]) are also indicated by double-headed arrows in gray and dark red with sizes of amplicons, respectively. Fig 1B has been
modified and prepared from the Fig 1B appearing in our previous paper [29]. https //doi org/10 1371/journal pone 0259842 g001 Fig 1. Experimental scheme 1 for the copse-derived nematodes and PCR target regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene. The experimental scheme of
the high-throughput sequencing of 12 amplicons prepared from six regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene using the copse-derived nematode
genomic DNA and whole soil DNA is shown (A). Red colored codes in parentheses for sample DNA (e.g., Z03) represent the nematode genomic DNA
with the soil sample code (Z: copse) and the experimental ID (03), and the code Z03S indicates the soil DNA purified from the copse soil in the same
experiment (S: soil DNA). R1–R4, U1 and U2 in red are the abbreviations of PCR target regions in this study (A). Six PCR target regions with their
abbreviations and sizes of amplicons are shown by bold double-headed arrows in gray for nematode-specific primers and in dark red for universal primers
(B). The numbers indicating the nucleotide positions of the 5´-end of forward primers are shown on the entire SSU gene prepared from the nucleotide
sequence of C. elegans ribosomal RNA gene cluster (X03680). Teal colored boxes correspond to the hypervariable regions of eukaryotic SSU genes
reported by Hugerth et al. [33] and Hadziavdic et al. [32]. The regions amplified by two published nematode-specific primer sets (NF1/18Sr2b and NemF/
18Sr2b) [35, 60] and four eukaryotic universal primer sets (3NDf/1132rmod [34], 566-F/915-R [37], Ek-NS573/Ek-NSR951[58, 64], F-1183/R-1631 [58,
65], Euk1391f/EukBr [36, 66, 67]) are also indicated by double-headed arrows in gray and dark red with sizes of amplicons, respectively. Fig 1B has been
modified and prepared from the Fig 1B appearing in our previous paper [29]. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g001 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 4 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Soil sampling
Fig 2. Preparations of nematode and whole soil DNAs Nematodes were isolated from 10 g copse soils using the improved flotation sieving method
with colloidal silica in accordance with the method described by Morise et al. [28], and this
procedure was repeated four times. Whole nematodes from approximately 40 g soil samples
were trapped on sieves and eluted into water in a watch glass. The nematodes were then picked
up using a micropipette (P-20, Gilson, Middleton, WI, USA) with a cut tip under an SZX16
stereomicroscope (Olympus) and collected into a DNA LoBind tube (Eppendorf, Hamburg,
Germany). Genomic DNAs from whole nematodes isolated from copse soils were purified
using a DNeasy PowerSoil Kit (QIAGEN, Venlo, Netherlands) in accordance with the manu-
facturer’s instructions. Whole soil DNAs were prepared from 10 g fresh copse and field soils
using a DNeasy PowerMax Soil Kit (QIAGEN) in accordance with the manufacturer’s instruc-
tions. Purified DNAs were stored at −20ºC until use in the following PCR experiment. Soil sampling Copse soil samples for the experiment 1 were collected from the copse on the campus of
Toyohashi University of Technology [29, 30] in July 2017 under clear climatic conditions 5 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes (temperature 32˚C and humidity 77%) in Toyohashi, Japan (137˚ 24’E, 34˚ 42’N). The copse
soil was sampled to a depth of 20–30 cm using a soil sampling auger (2.5 cm in diameter, Fuji-
wara Scientific Co., Tokyo, Japan). Field soil samples for the experiment 2 were collected in
July 2018 under cloudy conditions (temperature 32ºC and humidity 55%) from two sampling
sites (i.e., sites 1 and 2) in the sweet potato-cultivated field managed by the Research Center
for Agrotechnology and Biotechnology of the Toyohashi University of Technology [30]. Growth of plants at site 1 (Fig 2B) was apparently dominated compared with that at site 2 (Fig
2C). Four soil samples in each site were collected from the surface (0–10 cm in depth) and
deep (20–30 cm) layers at two sampling points (Fig 2B–2D) without (approximately 40 cm
apart from the plants; designated as “control”) and with (within 10 cm from the plants; desig-
nated as “plants”) plants. For both experiment 1 and 2, over-sized contaminants (e.g., stones
and plant roots) were removed by filtering the samples through a 0.7 mm sieve; the resulting
samples were used for nematode isolation or purification of whole soil DNAs within a day of
collection. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Table 1. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers used for amplifying the small subunit ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene regions. SSU gene regiona
Primer
Nucleotide sequence (50-to-30)b
Amplicon size (bp)c
Region 1
SSU18A-4F3_MiseqF
tcgtcggcagcgtcagatgtgtataagagacagGCTTRTCTCAAAGATTAAGCCATGCATG
388
SSU_R22_MiseqR
gtctcgtgggctcggagatgtgtataagagacagGCCTGCTGCCTTCCTTGGA
Region 2
SSUconsF1_MiseqF
tcgtcggcagcgtcagatgtgtataagagacagAGCAGCCGCGGTAATTCCAGCTC
384
SSU26Rplus4_MiseqR
gtctcgtgggctcggagatgtgtataagagacagAAGACATTCTTGGCAAATGCTTTCG
Region 3
Nem_18SR_ExtF_MiseqF
tcgtcggcagcgtcagatgtgtataagagacagGTTCGAAGGCGATYAGATACCGCC
337
SSU_R23plus7_MiseqR
gtctcgtgggctcggagatgtgtataagagacagTCGYTCGTTATCGGAATWAACCAGAC
Region 4
NF1_MiseqF
tcgtcggcagcgtcagatgtgtataagagacagGGTGGTGCATGGCCGTTCTTAGTT
368
18Sr2b_ExtR_MiseqR
gtctcgtgggctcggagatgtgtataagagacagGGTGTGTACAAAKSGCAGGGACGTA
Region U1
F574-18S_V4_MiseqF
tcgtcggcagcgtcagatgtgtataagagacagGCGGTAATTCCAGCTCCAA
368
R952-18S_V4_MiseqR
gtctcgtgggctcggagatgtgtataagagacagTTGGCAAATGCTTTCGC
Region U2
F1183-18S_V7-V8_MiseqF
tcgtcggcagcgtcagatgtgtataagagacagAATTTGACTCAACACGGG
446
R1631a-18S_V7-V8_MiseqR
gtctcgtgggctcggagatgtgtataagagacagTACAAAGGGCAGGGACG g
y
g
b Nucleotide sequences in lowercase letters indicate the tail sequence required for the attachment of P5 and P7 adaptors by the index PCR for Illumina sequencing. Details of the nematode-specific primers for four SSU regions (regions 1–4) were previously described by Kenmotsu et al. [29, 30]. Two universal eukaryotic primers for
SSU regions U1 and U2 were modified from F-574 and R-952, and F-1183 and R-1631a, respectively, which appeared in the paper by Hadziavdic et al. [32]. c The predicted length of amplicon without tail sequences generated from C. elegans genomic DNA is indicated in Fig 1B. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.t001 BioSample IDs SAMD00325389 to SAMD00325398. Details of the registered data are shown
in S1 Table. BioSample IDs SAMD00325389 to SAMD00325398. Details of the registered data are shown
in S1 Table. PCR and DNA sequencing Six sets of PCR primers with tail sequences for Illumina MiSeq sequencing were used in this
study (detailed in Table 1). The 18S ribosomal RNA gene fragments in the corresponding
regions were amplified using nematode-specific (regions 1–4) and universal primers (regions
U1 and U2), respectively (Fig 1B). The PCR reaction mixture (20 μL) contained 10 μL of
2 × Buffer for KOD FX Neo, 4 μL of 2 mM dNTPs, 0.4 units of KOD FX Neo DNA polymerase
(Toyobo, Tokyo, Japan), 2 μL of template DNA, and 0.3 μM each of the forward and reverse
primers. Amplification was initiated with denaturation at 94˚C for 2 min followed by 30 cycles
of denaturation at 94˚C for 10 s, annealing at 55˚C for 30 s, and extension at 68˚C for 60 s. The
amplified PCR products were purified with 0.8 volumes of AMPure XP beads in accordance
with the manufacturer’s instructions and eluted with 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH 8.5). Index PCR
was performed in a thermocycler for eight cycles using a Nextera XT Index Kit v2 (Illumina,
San Diego, CA, USA) in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions. The amplified
libraries were purified with 1.12 volumes of AMPure XP beads and eluted with 10 mM Tris-
HCl (pH 8.5). Equal amounts of the libraries were pooled and quantified using a Qubit
dsDNA HS Assay Kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA). Each 300 bp end of the
pooled library was sequenced using a MiSeq Reagent Kit v3 (600 cycles; Illumina) on a MiSeq
instrument (Illumina). The sequences were deposited in the DDBJ Sequence Read Archive
database under accession number DRA012120 with BioProject ID PRJDB11694 and PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 6 / 31 Identification of regional nematode sequence variants The frequency of the SVs in each sample were converted based on their relative abundance
of reads and visualized using phyloseq package in R (version 4.0.2) [44]. The phylum-level
compositions of the SV-derived reads (frequency >1% of the average) were shown as histo-
grams for each sample. The relative abundance of each regional nematode SV was determined
as the percentage of the reads of the SV in the total sequence reads of all regional nematode
SVs. The frequency of the SVs in each sample were converted based on their relative abundance
of reads and visualized using phyloseq package in R (version 4.0.2) [44]. The phylum-level
compositions of the SV-derived reads (frequency >1% of the average) were shown as histo-
grams for each sample. The relative abundance of each regional nematode SV was determined
as the percentage of the reads of the SV in the total sequence reads of all regional nematode
SVs. Taxonomic and phylogenetic analyses of regional nematode SVs The taxonomic analysis of regional nematode SVs was performed in two steps as previously
described [30]. First, the taxonomic ranks of the regional nematode SVs were determined
basing from the SILVA database [43]. Next, regional nematode SVs were assigned to an
order, family, and genus in accordance with their closest species match via the BLASTN
search against the non-redundant nucleotide sequence database of the National Center for
Biotechnology Information website (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) in January 2021. The
resulting entries with the smallest e-values, which represent hit significance in Expect value,
were only used to identify the closest species to the queried nematode SVs (i.e., matches
without genus data, such as environmental samples, were omitted even if they had the small-
est e-values). Six phylogenetic trees of the regional nematode SVs were constructed using
the corresponding regional sequences of Halobiotus crispae (phylum Tardigrada) as an out-
group as described previously [29, 30]. In brief, the nucleotide sequences were aligned, and
phylogenetic trees were constructed using the BOOTSTRAP N-J TREE algorithm (boot-
strap: 1000 replicates) with the ClustalX (version 2.1) package (http://www.clustal.org/
clustal2/) in the Genetyx-MAC software (version 19, Genetyx Co.) [45]. The resultant tree
files were used to draw the cladograms using the Genetyx-Tree software (version 2.2.6, Gen-
etyx Co.). In addition, the ATGC software (version 6, Genetyx Co., Tokyo, Japan) was used
to identify the copse-derived regional nematode SVs from region U2 with high sequence
similarities with a 99% match and minimum matching number of 100 bp, followed by man-
ual inspection. Identification of regional nematode sequence variants For the experiment 1, the sequence reads from 12 amplicons were obtained with primer sets
for six SSU regions and DNAs from nematodes and whole copse soils. For the experiment 2,
the sequence reads from eight amplicons were obtained with the universal primers for
region U2 and eight soil DNA samples. All sequence data were independently imported into
QIIME2 version 2020.2 (https://qiime2.org) [39] (S1 Table). The primer sequences were
removed by Cutadapt plugin (version 3.1) with the default parameters [40]. The forward and
reverse reads were joined, denoized, and chimera-checked using the dada2 plugin [41]. We
utilized the trimming parameters (—p-trunc-len-f and—p-trunc-len-r) of 220, 220 (region
1); 225, 200 (region 2); 220, 220 (region 3); 220, 220 (region 4); 230, 230 (region U1); and
229, 220 (region U2), respectively, and utilized the default parameters for the other options. To perform the reference-based detection and removal of the chimeric sequences, we further
processed the resultant SVs from dada2 with vsearch uchime ref command with a minimum
score option of—minh 0.5 using VSEARCH (version 2.13.3) [42] and the 18S rRNA refer-
ence from the SILVA database, version 132, with a 99% clustering threshold (https://www. arb-silva.de/download/archive/) [43]. The taxonomy of the SVs was assigned using a fea-
ture-classifier plugin that was trained with the 99% clustered 18S rRNA references in the
SILVA database. The taxonomic ranks of the nematode-derived SVs were curated by manual inspection. A
few questionable SVs found by BLASTN search were removed from the nematode-derived
SVs identified by the SILVA database, and the resultant SVs were used as nematode-derived
SVs for further taxonomic analyses. The resultant nematode-derived SVs in each region (i.e.,
regional nematode SVs) were named according to their region and SV number; for instance,
SV 1 in regions 1 and U2 were named as “R1_SV_1” and “U2_SV_1,” respectively. The SV PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 7 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes numbers (e.g., 75 of R1_SV_75) were counted along with the abundance of sequence reads of
SV, where a lower number represents the SV containing a larger number of reads. SV, where a lower number represents the SV containing a larger number of reads. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Diversity and ecophysiological analyses Beta diversity analyses were performed using phyloseq package [44]. For the analysis of 12
samples from the copse-derived nematode and soil DNAs, the nematode-derived reads (over
five reads at least in one region) in each order and feeding type were used. Then, non-metric
multidimensional scaling (NMDS) was conducted with the Bray–Curtis distance matrices
using the ordinate and plot ordination functions in R phyloseq to evaluate the differences in
order and feeding type among six regions and two copse-derived template DNAs. For beta
diversity analysis of the field-derived samples, the read abundances of nematode-derived SVs
were used for principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) based on weighted unifrac distances. Feed-
ing types of the regional nematode SVs were assigned according to their closest genus as iden-
tified by BLASTN searches based on the reference by Yeates et al. [46] and the Nematode
Ecophysiological Parameter Search at the Nemaplex homepage of UC Davis, USA (http://
nemaplex.ucdavis.edu/Ecology/EcophysiologyParms/EcoParameterMenu.html) in January
2021 [47]. Animal parasites were referred to previous publications [48–53]. The colonizer–
persister (cp) values of nematode families were classified as previously described by Bongers
[54, 55] and the Nematode Ecophysiological Parameter Search [47]. Maturity indices were cal-
culated as the weighted mean of the individual cp values as previously described by Bonger PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 8 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes [55]: Maturity Index ¼
Xn
i¼1 v ið Þ f ið Þ; Maturity Index ¼
Xn
i¼1 v ið Þ f ið Þ; where v(i) is the cp-value of family i and f(i) is the frequency of reads from the family com-
pared to those from all families without reads derived from unassigned families (NA) in a
sample. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.t002 Sequence variants identified by high-throughput amplicon sequencing
using six SSU primer sets and nematode and whole soil DNAs In the experiment 1, we performed high-throughput amplicon sequencing of copse soil using
six primer sets for amplifying the SSU gene: the nematode-specific primers for regions 1–4
and the universal eukaryotic primers for regions U1 and U2, respectively (Fig 1B). In addition,
template DNAs were prepared from nematodes isolates from 40 g of copse soil (nematode
DNA) and 10 g copse soil (soil DNA). Hundreds of SVs were identified by Illumina MiSeq-
assisted amplicon sequencing (Table 2): the largest (883) and smallest (338) numbers of SVs
from the nematode and soil DNAs were found in regions 1 and 3, respectively. Approximately
twofold larger numbers of SVs (250–739 SVs) were obtained from the soil DNA than those
from the nematode DNA (128–283 SVs). Results showed that 26–79 (12.0%–27.9% in total
SVs) and 25–41 (3.9%–16.4%) SVs derived from the phylum Nematoda were identified in the
nematode and soil DNAs, respectively. The smallest fractions of nematode-derived SVs were
found in region 1 in both template DNAs (12.0% in nematode DNA and 3.9% in soil DNA),
and the highest content of nematode-derived SVs was 27.9% in region U2 in nematode DNA
and 16.4% in region 3 in soil DNA, respectively. Numbers of regional nematode SVs identified from the nematode and/or soil DNAs were
slightly varied among the SSU regions. Comparable numbers (43–60) of regional nematode Table 2. Numbers of total and nematode-derived SVs from the copse-derived nematode and soil DNAs in each SSU region. Nematode and soil DNAsa
SSU region
Region 1
Region 2
Region 3
Region 4
Region U1
Region U2
Total SVs
883
547
338
721
494
678
Nematode-derived SVs
43b (4.9%c)
60 (11.0%)
50 (14.8%)
57 (7.9%)
52 (10.5%)
90 (13.3%)
Nematode DNAa
SSU region
Region 1
Region 2
Region 3
Region 4
Region U1
Region U2
Total SVs
266
212
128
263
193
283
Nematode-derived SVs
32b (12.0%c)
47 (22.2%)
26 (20.3%)
44 (16.7%)
39 (20.2%)
79 (27.9%)
Soil DNAa
SSU region
Region 1
Region 2
Region 3
Region 4
Region U1
Region U2
Total SVs
739
460
250
556
368
472
Nematode-derived SVs
29b (3.9%c)
34 (7.4%)
41 (16.4%)
35 (6.3%)
25 (6.8%)
31 (6.6%) Numbers of total and nematode-derived SVs from the copse-derived nematode and soil DNAs in each SSU region. Table 2. -derived SVs in total number of SVs derived from each template DNA. b Numbers of nematode-derived SVs in each region (i.e., regional nematode SVs) derived from each template DNA are shown. The regional nematode SVs are
determined based on the taxonomic ranks in the SILVA database and the BLASTN search. Note: Numbers of SVs in the nematode and soil DNAs are not identical to
the added numbers of those in the nematode and soil DNAs because of the SVs commonly identified in both DNAs. umber of nematode-derived SVs in total number of SVs derived from each template DNA. PLOS ONE PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Table 3. Numbers of regional nematode SVs derived from nematode genomic and whole soil DNAs. SSU region
Region 1
Region 2
Region 3
Region 4
Region U1
Region U2
Total
43a
60
50
57
52
90
Common
18(41.8%)b
21(35.0%)
17(34.0%)
22(38.6%)
12(23.1%)
20(22.2%)
Nematode alone
14(32.6%)
26(43.3%)
9(18.0%)
22(38.6%)
27(51.9%)
59(65.6%)
Soil alone
11(25.6%)
13(21.7%)
24(48.0%)
13(22.8%)
13(25.0%)
11(12.2%)
aTotal numbers of regional nematode SVs are shown in the “total” column for each region. bNumbers of regional nematode SVs exclusively detected in nematode genomic DNA, soil DNA, and both DNAs are indicated in the “nematode alone,” “soil alone,”
and “common” columns with their percentages in total regional nematode SVs in parentheses, respectively. Table 3. Numbers of regional nematode SVs derived from nematode genomic and whole soil DNAs. Total numbers of regional nematode SVs are shown in the total column for each region. bNumbers of regional nematode SVs exclusively detected in nematode genomic DNA, soil DNA, and both DNAs are indicated in the “nematode alone,” “soil alone,”
and “common” columns with their percentages in total regional nematode SVs in parentheses, respectively. SVs were detected in regions 1–4 and U1; however, a significantly large number (90) of nema-
tode SVs was found in region U2 (Table 2). The comparable or slightly larger numbers of
regional nematode SVs were identified in the nematode DNA by comparing with those in
the soil DNA in all regions, except for region 3. The resultant regional nematode SVs were
assigned to their derived template DNAs (Table 3). Less than 50% (22.2%–41.8%) of nematode
SVs were commonly detected in both template DNAs. Larger numbers of nematode SVs were
detected in the nematode DNAs alone than those in the soil DNA alone in the five regions
above. However, half of the nematode SVs in region 3 were only identified in the soil DNA. Moreover, >50% of the nematode SVs in regions U1 and U2 were derived from nematode
genomic DNA (Table 3). We further investigated the homologies of nucleotide sequences of
90 regional nematode SVs in region U2 and identified 11 clusters of SVs with high sequence
similarities (S2 Table). PLOS ONE Most of these SVs in each cluster were derived from the nematode
DNA but not from the soil DNA and contained differing one nucleotide in their sequences,
suggesting polymorphic alleles of the SSU gene as found in previous studies [28, 29]. Sequence variants identified by high-throughput amplicon sequencing
using six SSU primer sets and nematode and whole soil DNAs Numbers of total and nematode-derived SVs from the copse-derived nematode and soil DN b Numbers of nematode-derived SVs in each region (i.e., regional nematode SVs) derived from each template DNA are shown. The regional nematode SVs are
determined based on the taxonomic ranks in the SILVA database and the BLASTN search. Note: Numbers of SVs in the nematode and soil DNAs are not identical to
the added numbers of those in the nematode and soil DNAs because of the SVs commonly identified in both DNAs. c Percentage of the number of nematode-derived SVs in total number of SVs derived from each template DNA. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 9 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Taxonomic analyses of total and regional nematode SVs from copse-
derived amplicons The histograms of nematode SVs in regions 1 (Fig 4A), 2 (Fig 4B), and 4
(Fig 4D) were similar except for region 3 (Fig 4C). The numbers of SVs identified in regions
U1 and U2 were comparable to those in these three regions (Fig 4E and 4F), whereas large
numbers of nematode SVs were identified from the nematode DNA in region U2. In addition,
the Enoplida- and Monhysterida-derived SVs were undetected in regions U2 and U1, respec-
tively. The even or larger numbers of nematode SVs in seven orders were detected in the nem-
atode DNA (blue bars in Fig 4) by comparing with those in the soil DNA (red bars), but the
Monhysterida-derived SVs were only found in the soil DNA. In addition, the larger numbers
of Chromadorida-, Dorylaimida- and Triplonchida-derived SVs from the soil DNA were iden-
tified only in region 3 than those from the nematode DNA (Fig 4C). The relative abundance of
sequence reads from each region and template DNA was shown in each nematode order (Fig
5). The major fractions of reads were derived from orders Triplonchida, Dorylamida, and
Rhabditida, and the Triplonchida- and Dorylamida-derived reads occupied >70% of the total
reads from the nematode and soil DNAs (red and green boxes in Fig 5). Distinct compositions nematode SVs were classified into eight orders (i.e., Chromadorida, Dorylaimida, Enoplida,
Monhysterida, Mononchida, Plectida, Rhabditida, and Triplonchida) and unclassified SVs
(NA), and the majority of nematode SVs were derived from orders Rhabditida, Triplonchida,
and Dorylaimida. The histograms of nematode SVs in regions 1 (Fig 4A), 2 (Fig 4B), and 4
(Fig 4D) were similar except for region 3 (Fig 4C). The numbers of SVs identified in regions
U1 and U2 were comparable to those in these three regions (Fig 4E and 4F), whereas large
numbers of nematode SVs were identified from the nematode DNA in region U2. In addition,
the Enoplida- and Monhysterida-derived SVs were undetected in regions U2 and U1, respec-
tively. The even or larger numbers of nematode SVs in seven orders were detected in the nem-
atode DNA (blue bars in Fig 4) by comparing with those in the soil DNA (red bars), but the
Monhysterida-derived SVs were only found in the soil DNA. In addition, the larger numbers
of Chromadorida-, Dorylaimida- and Triplonchida-derived SVs from the soil DNA were iden-
tified only in region 3 than those from the nematode DNA (Fig 4C). Taxonomic analyses of total and regional nematode SVs from copse-
derived amplicons Taxonomic classification of SVs was Fig 3. Relative read abundances and phylum of sequence variants (SVs) in each region identified by high-throughput sequencing of the copse-
derived amplicons. Relative read abundance and phylum of the SVs obtained from the SSU gene regions 1 (R1), 2 (R2), 3 (R3), and 4 (R4) amplified by
the nematode-specific primers, and regions U1 and U2 amplified by the universal primers from the copse-derived nematode DNA (left panel) and soil
DNA (right panel) as templates. Boxes in the histogram indicate the read abundances; phyla are indicated by color. Taxonomic classification of SVs was
based on the SILVA database, and phyla with less than 1% of relative abundance are omitted. NA: Not assigned. Fig 3. Relative read abundances and phylum of sequence variants (SVs) in each region identified by high-throughput sequencing of the copse-
derived amplicons. Relative read abundance and phylum of the SVs obtained from the SSU gene regions 1 (R1), 2 (R2), 3 (R3), and 4 (R4) amplified by
the nematode-specific primers, and regions U1 and U2 amplified by the universal primers from the copse-derived nematode DNA (left panel) and soil
DNA (right panel) as templates. Boxes in the histogram indicate the read abundances; phyla are indicated by color. Taxonomic classification of SVs was
based on the SILVA database, and phyla with less than 1% of relative abundance are omitted. NA: Not assigned. Fig 3. Relative read abundances and phylum of sequence variants (SVs) in each region identified by high-throughput sequencing of the copse-
derived amplicons. Relative read abundance and phylum of the SVs obtained from the SSU gene regions 1 (R1), 2 (R2), 3 (R3), and 4 (R4) amplified by
the nematode-specific primers, and regions U1 and U2 amplified by the universal primers from the copse-derived nematode DNA (left panel) and soil
DNA (right panel) as templates. Boxes in the histogram indicate the read abundances; phyla are indicated by color. Taxonomic classification of SVs was
based on the SILVA database, and phyla with less than 1% of relative abundance are omitted. NA: Not assigned. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g003 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g003 nematode SVs were classified into eight orders (i.e., Chromadorida, Dorylaimida, Enoplida,
Monhysterida, Mononchida, Plectida, Rhabditida, and Triplonchida) and unclassified SVs
(NA), and the majority of nematode SVs were derived from orders Rhabditida, Triplonchida,
and Dorylaimida. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Taxonomic analyses of total and regional nematode SVs from copse-
derived amplicons The relative abundances of phylum with >1% abundance of nematode-derived sequence reads
were indicated in each region (Fig 3). In the amplicons from nematode genomic DNA, the
largest fractions (i.e., approximately 50%) of total reads were derived from the phylum Nema-
toda, followed by the Arthropoda (insects)-, Streptophyta (plants)-, and Ascomycota (fungi)-
derived reads as major fractions in the six SSU regions (left panel in Fig 3). Conversely, the
nematode-derived fractions occupied less than 10% in soil DNA-derived amplicons, except for
34% in region 3 (right panel in Fig 3). In addition, the fractions of reads derived from the
phyla Annelida (ringed or segmented worms), Ascomycota, Basidiomycota (filamentous
fungi), and Streptophyta were dominantly found. Similar compositions of the relative abun-
dance of phylum-derived reads were found in two regional groups: regions 1, 4, and U2 and
regions 2 and U1. The significant fractions of the phylum Ascomycota (red boxes) were
detected in both DNAs in the former group but not in the latter two regions and region 3. The
proportion of phylum-derived reads in region 3 was distinct from those in the five other
regions: significantly large and small fractions of nematode- and fungi-derived reads as well as
abundant Arthropoda-derived reads were detected in this region. Thus, the proportion of phy-
lum-derived reads in region U2 was comparable to that in region 4, which was suggested a
suitable region for amplicon sequencing with nematode DNAs [29, 30]. The taxa of regional nematode SVs identified in six regions were assigned by both SILVA-
derived taxonomic data and the BLASTN search (S3–S8 Tables). The numbers of regional
nematode SVs in orders are shown by histograms in each region (Fig 4). The resultant PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 10 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Fig 3. Relative read abundances and phylum of sequence variants (SVs) in each region identified by high-throughput sequencing of the copse-
derived amplicons. Relative read abundance and phylum of the SVs obtained from the SSU gene regions 1 (R1), 2 (R2), 3 (R3), and 4 (R4) amplified by
the nematode-specific primers, and regions U1 and U2 amplified by the universal primers from the copse-derived nematode DNA (left panel) and soil
DNA (right panel) as templates. Boxes in the histogram indicate the read abundances; phyla are indicated by color. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Taxonomic analyses of total and regional nematode SVs from copse-
derived amplicons The relative abundance of
sequence reads from each region and template DNA was shown in each nematode order (Fig
5). The major fractions of reads were derived from orders Triplonchida, Dorylamida, and
Rhabditida, and the Triplonchida- and Dorylamida-derived reads occupied >70% of the total
reads from the nematode and soil DNAs (red and green boxes in Fig 5). Distinct compositions PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 11 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Fig 4. Numbers of regional nematode SVs from six SSU regions in each order. The number of regional nematode SVs
identified from the nematode genomic DNA (blue bars) and soil DNA (red bars) from the copse soils is indicated in each
order by bar chart for regions 1–4, U1, and U2 (A–F), respectively. NA: not assigned to a single order (i.e., assigned to
multiple orders). Target SSU regions are indicated at the top right side of the bar charts. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g004 Fig 4. Numbers of regional nematode SVs from six SSU regions in each order. The number of regional nematode SVs
identified from the nematode genomic DNA (blue bars) and soil DNA (red bars) from the copse soils is indicated in each
order by bar chart for regions 1–4, U1, and U2 (A–F), respectively. NA: not assigned to a single order (i.e., assigned to
multiple orders). Target SSU regions are indicated at the top right side of the bar charts. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g004 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g004 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 12 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Fig 5. Relative abundance of nematode-derived sequence reads at the order level in each region. The percentage of
the abundance of sequence reads in each nematode order obtained from regions 1 (A), 2 (B), 3 (C), 4 (D), U1 (E), and
U2 (F) is indicated by colored horizontal histograms in each template DNA: copse-derived nematode genomic DNA
(Nema) and soil DNA (Soil). The colors corresponding to orders are indicated at the bottom of (F). Target SSU region
are indicated at the right side of the corresponding horizontal bar charts. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g005 Fig 5. Relative abundance of nematode-derived sequence reads at the order level in each region. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Phylogenetic and ecophysiological analyses of copse-derived regional
nematode SVs We further subjected the regional nematode SVs to phylogenetic and ecophysiological analy-
ses. First, a phylogenetic tree of the regional nematode SVs was prepared in each region inte-
grating with their orders, relative abundances of reads from the template DNAs, and predicted
feeding types (S1–S6 Figs). The phylogenetic trees contained three major clusters of SVs
derived from orders Triplonchida, Dorylaimida, and Rhabditida as described in the former
section. Major nematode SVs with abundant reads were commonly found in amplicons from
both nematode (“Nema” columns in S1–S6 Figs) and soil DNAs (“Soil” columns). However,
significant numbers of regional nematode SVs were found only in either nematode DNA- or
soil DNA-derived amplicons (Table 3). For instance, the Monhysterida-derived SVs were only
found in the soil DNA-derived amplicons in all regions, except for region U1 (S1–S4 and S6
Figs), and all of the animal parasitic Rhabditida-derived SVs, except for R4_SV_12, were
detected only in the amplicons from the nematode DNA. In addition, the phylogenetic tree
with the largest number of region U2-derived SVs contained two split clusters of the Rhabdi-
tida- and Triplonchida-derived SVs, which were mostly derived from the nematode genomic
DNA (S6 Fig). One of the Rhabditida-derived clusters contains animal parasite-derived
SVs, and the other is composed of plant and bacteria feeder-derived SVs. The Triplonchida-
derived SVs were separated into clusters of bacteria feeders and of plant and fungus feeders,
respectively. Second, the feeding types of the regional nematode SVs were predicted, and many of these
SVs were assigned to bacteria, fungus, and plant feeders, but only one or a few SVs were
derived from omnivores, predators, and eukaryotic feeders (S7 Fig). The numbers of SVs
derived from the six feeding types were largely comparable among the regions, except for the
animal parasite-derived SVs and the region U2-derived SVs. Except for R4_SV_12 in region 4,
the animal parasite-derived SVs were exclusively derived from the nematode DNA (S7D Fig),
and approximately twofold larger numbers of plant feeder- and animal parasite-derived SVs
(32 and 13 SVs) were identified from the nematode DNA in region U2 than those from the
soil DNA (S7F Fig). The relative abundances of reads in each feeding type were also deter-
mined in the six SSU regions and template DNAs (S8 Fig). Despite the similar horizontal bar
charts among the regions, the proportions of read abundances from the two template DNAs in
the feeding type were distinct. Taxonomic analyses of total and regional nematode SVs from copse-
derived amplicons The percentage of
the abundance of sequence reads in each nematode order obtained from regions 1 (A), 2 (B), 3 (C), 4 (D), U1 (E), and
U2 (F) is indicated by colored horizontal histograms in each template DNA: copse-derived nematode genomic DNA
(Nema) and soil DNA (Soil). The colors corresponding to orders are indicated at the bottom of (F). Target SSU regions
are indicated at the right side of the corresponding horizontal bar charts. htt
//d i
/10 1371/j
l
0259842 005 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 13 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes of order-derived reads were markedly found between the two template DNAs (“Nema” and
“Soil” columns in Fig 5). The relative abundances of Dorylamida-derived reads significantly
increased and those of Triplonchida-derived reads decreased in the nematode genomic DNA
across the regions and vice versa in soil DNAs. The compositions of order-derived reads in the
two template DNAs were similar in all regions, except for regions 1 and U1 (Fig 5B–5D and
5F), whose fractions of Rhabditida-derived reads were apparently small (Fig 5A and 5E). The
differences in compositions of the order-derived reads from the six regions and two DNAs
were further investigated by beta diversity analysis (Fig 6A), and the resultant NMDS plot of
the Bray–Curtis dissimilarity indicated close relations of the nematode DNA-derived reads
from all regions, except for region U1 (circles in Fig 6A). The region 4- and U2-derived reads
(red and blue triangles in Fig 6A) and region 1- and 3-derived reads (purple and pink trian-
gles) were also closely related. However, the soil DNA-derived reads from regions 2 (green tri-
angle) and U1 (yellow triangle) were clearly separated from those from the four other regions. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Phylogenetic and ecophysiological analyses of copse-derived regional
nematode SVs In specific, the eukaryote feeder-derived reads and approxi-
mately twofold increased bacteria feeder-derived reads were observed most exclusively in the
soil DNA, but the animal parasite-derived reads were only detected in the nematode DNA PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 14 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Fig 6. Beta diversity plots of 12 samples derived from two template DNAs and six SSU regions based on the relative
abundance of nematode-derived reads in each order and feeding type. The beta diversity of the sample was calculated
based on the relative abundances of nematode-derived reads in each order (A) and feeding type (B) using non-metric
multidimensional scaling (NMDS) with the Bray–Curtis distance matrices in the corresponding SSU region and template
DNA indicated in the right of figures. The nematode-derived reads in region 1 (R1, purple), 2 (R2, green), 3 (R3, pink), 4
(R4, red), U1 (orange), and U2 (blue) are derived from the nematode genomic DNA (circles) and soil DNA (triangles). The
target SSU region of each sample is indicated by the corresponding symbol. The samples with close relations described in
the text are surrounded by broken circles. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g006 Fig 6. Beta diversity plots of 12 samples derived from two template DNAs and six SSU regions based on the relative
abundance of nematode-derived reads in each order and feeding type. The beta diversity of the sample was calculated
based on the relative abundances of nematode-derived reads in each order (A) and feeding type (B) using non-metric
multidimensional scaling (NMDS) with the Bray–Curtis distance matrices in the corresponding SSU region and template
DNA indicated in the right of figures. The nematode-derived reads in region 1 (R1, purple), 2 (R2, green), 3 (R3, pink), 4
(R4, red), U1 (orange), and U2 (blue) are derived from the nematode genomic DNA (circles) and soil DNA (triangles). The
target SSU region of each sample is indicated by the corresponding symbol. The samples with close relations described in
the text are surrounded by broken circles. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g006 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g006 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 15 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes (S8 Fig). We further conducted beta diversity analysis using the read abundance in feeding
type. Phylogenetic and ecophysiological analyses of copse-derived regional
nematode SVs The close relation of region 4- and U2-derived reads in both template DNAs was indi-
cated by the resultant NMDS plot (Fig 6B). The feeding type’s compositions in regions 1 and 3
were distantly related in the two DNAs, unlike the beta diversity analysis with their order’s
compositions (Fig 6A and 6B). Third, the regional nematode SVs were assigned to 27 nematode families, but this number
is likely underestimated because of several SVs assigned to multiple families, which are classi-
fied into “not assigned (NA)” (S9 Table). The comparable numbers (12–18) of nematode fami-
lies were detected in the regions. Twenty-four and nineteen families were detected from the
soil and nematode DNAs, respectively, and eight (i.e., Alaimidae, Anguinidae, Aporcelaimi-
dae, Ecphyadophoridae, Monhysteridae, Meloidogynidae, Nygolaimidae, and Qudsianemati-
dae) and three (Thelastomatidae, Travassosinematidae, and Trischistomatidae) families were
undetected in the nematode DNA- and soil DNA-derived SVs, respectively (S9 Table). The rel-
ative read abundances in each family are shown along the corresponding cp values in the six
regions (S9A–S9F Fig). The cp values (1–5) have been used as indicators for the life strategy
characteristics of nematodes [54, 55]: nematodes with low cp values have a short generation
time and produce many small eggs, resulting in an explosive population growth under food-
rich conditions, whereas those with high cp values have a long life span and low production
rate, and are thus highly sensitive to environmental disturbances. The profiles of relative abun-
dances in families were similar across the regions, and the sequence reads derived from fami-
lies Prismatolaimidae (cp-3), Trichodoridae (cp-4), and Belondiridae (cp-5) were markedly
abundant. In addition, the relative abundances of reads from nematode families with high cp
values increased in the nematode DNA-derived amplicons (blue bars in S9 Fig) but not in the
amplicons from soil DNA (orange bars). Finally, we determined the maturity indices for each region-derived families based on their
cp values and frequencies in the population (Table 4). The maturity indices for the nematode
families identified from the copse-derived nematode DNA and whole soil DNA were 3.71–
3.94 and 3.11–3.50 in the six regions, respectively. PLOS ONE PLOS ONE Table 5. Numbers of total and nematode-derived SVs from eight soil samples at sites 1 and 2. Site 1
Controla
Plantsa
0–10 cmb
20–30 cmb
0–10 cm
20–30 cm
Total SVs
943
1069
983
1276
Nematode-derived SVs
34c (3.6%d)
37 (3.5%)
61 (6.2%)
53 (4.2%)
Site 2
Control
Plants
0–10 cm
20–30 cm
0–10 cm
20–30 cm
Total SVs
716
884
622
920
Nematode-derived SVs
19 (2.7%)
34 (3.8%)
22 (3.5%)
20 (2.2%)
a Soil samples isolated from the sampling point without (control) and with (plants) a growing sweet potato at each site in the agricultural field. b Soil samples isolated from the layer of 0–10 cm and 20–30 cm in depth. c Numbers of nematode-derived SVs are based on the taxonomic ranks in the SILVA database and the BLASN search. d Percentage of nematode-derived SVs in the total number of SVs. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.t005 Table 5. Numbers of total and nematode-derived SVs from eight soil samples at sites 1 and 2. a Soil samples isolated from the sampling point without (control) and with (plants) a growing sweet potato at each site in the agricultural field. b Soil samples isolated from the layer of 0–10 cm and 20–30 cm in depth. c Numbers of nematode-derived SVs are based on the taxonomic ranks in the SILVA database and the BLASN search. d Percentage of nematode-derived SVs in the total number of SVs. p
y
p
c Numbers of nematode-derived SVs are based on the taxonomic ranks in the SILVA database and the BLASN search. d Percentage of nematode-derived SVs in the total number of SVs. detected from the amplicons derived from the plant-associated soils at site 1 than those (34
and 37 SVs) from the control soils without plants, but a different phenomenon was observed
at site 2. detected from the amplicons derived from the plant-associated soils at site 1 than those (34
and 37 SVs) from the control soils without plants, but a different phenomenon was observed
at site 2. The relative abundance of sequence reads derived from each soil sample is indicated at the
phylum-level (Fig 7). The sequence reads derived from the phyla Streptophyta (plants), Asco-
mycota (fungi), and Cercozoa (single-celled eukaryotes) were abundantly found, and the nem-
atode-derived reads occupied as minor fractions: 5%–12% and <4% of the total reads derived
from sites 1 and 2, respectively. Taxonomic and ecophysiological analyses of soil nematodes in agricultural
field by amplicon sequencing using the universal primers and soil DNAs Comparable results were obtained from the analyses using universal primers and soil DNA
and those using nematode-specific primers and nematode DNA as described in the previous
section. Therefore, in the experiment 2, we applied this method to the taxonomic analyses of
soil nematode community in a sweet potato-cultivated agricultural field using the universal
primers for region U2 and whole soil DNAs (Fig 2A). In this experiment, we isolated eight soil
samples from two sites in the field, where the plants at site 1 were dominantly growing than
those at site 2, and four samples at each site were from the surface (0–10 cm in depth) and
deep (20–30 cm) layers with (plants) and without (control) plants (Fig 2B–2D). Larger num-
bers of total and nematode-derived SVs were identified from the amplicons derived from site
1 than those from site 2 (Table 5). Greater numbers (61 and 53) of nematode-derived SVs were Table 4. Maturity indices calculated by the families identified from the copse-derived nematode DNA and soil DNA in six SSU regions. SSU regions
Region 1
Region 2
Region 3
Region 4
Region U1
Region U2
Nematode DNA
3.90
3.71
3.89
3.76
3.94
3.71
Soil DNA
3.32
3.28
3.20
3.11
3.50
3.13
Maturity indices were calculated as described in the Materials and methods section based on the method described by Bongers [55]. lies identified from the copse-derived nematode DNA and soil DNA in six SSU regions. le 4. Maturity indices calculated by the families identified from the copse-derived nematode DNA and soil DNA in six SS PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 16 / 31 Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.t005 PLOS ONE The taxa of 101 nematode-derived SVs identified from eight soil samples were determined
(S10 Table), and the numbers of SVs identified from sites 1 and 2 are shown in each order by
horizontal bar charts (S10 Fig). These nematode-derived SVs were assigned to 10 orders; the
majorities of these SVs were derived from five orders (Rhabditida, Monhysterida, Dorylamida,
Triplonchida, and Chromadorida), and the Araeolaimida- and Mermithida-derived SVs were
very rare. The relative abundances of the Triplonchida-, Chromadoria- and Monhysterida-
derived reads in total reads were apparently distinguishable between the samples from sites 1
and 2 (Fig 8A). The fractions of the Triplonchida-derived reads occupied approximately 40%–
50% of the total reads from the site 1 samples, whereas those of the Chromadorida- and Mon-
hysterida-derived reads increased in the site 2 samples. The Plectida-derived reads, mainly
from U2_SV_101, were significantly abundant only in the plant-associated soils from the deep
layer at site 2 (#2_Plants_20–30 in Fig 8A), suggesting close relationship between the Plectida
species and plants growth and/or plants-associated bacteria because many of the Plectida-
derived nematodes are bacterivores. However, this phenomenon was difficult to describe
because the inconsistent observation was found at the comparable sample at site 1 The taxa of 101 nematode-derived SVs identified from eight soil samples were determined
(S10 Table), and the numbers of SVs identified from sites 1 and 2 are shown in each order by
horizontal bar charts (S10 Fig). These nematode-derived SVs were assigned to 10 orders; the
majorities of these SVs were derived from five orders (Rhabditida, Monhysterida, Dorylamida,
Triplonchida, and Chromadorida), and the Araeolaimida- and Mermithida-derived SVs were
very rare. The relative abundances of the Triplonchida-, Chromadoria- and Monhysterida-
derived reads in total reads were apparently distinguishable between the samples from sites 1
and 2 (Fig 8A). The fractions of the Triplonchida-derived reads occupied approximately 40%–
50% of the total reads from the site 1 samples, whereas those of the Chromadorida- and Mon-
hysterida-derived reads increased in the site 2 samples. The Plectida-derived reads, mainly
from U2_SV_101, were significantly abundant only in the plant-associated soils from the deep
layer at site 2 (#2_Plants_20–30 in Fig 8A), suggesting close relationship between the Plectida
species and plants growth and/or plants-associated bacteria because many of the Plectida-
derived nematodes are bacterivores. However, this phenomenon was difficult to describe
because the inconsistent observation was found at the comparable sample at site 1
(#1_Plants_20–30 in Fig 8A). PLOS ONE In addition, the increased fractions of the order Mononchida-
derived reads were commonly detected in the samples prepared from the surface layers by
comparing with those in the deep layer-derived samples (Fig 8A). The beta diversity analysis
was performed to assess the differences in compositions of nematode SVs in the eight soil sam-
ples, and the resultant PCoA plot with weighted unifrac distances indicated the distantly
related samples derived from site 1 (symbols in red) and site 2 (blue symbols), except for one
sample (#2_Plants_20–30) (Fig 8B). Regarding to the sampling depth, close relation between (#1_Plants_20–30 in Fig 8A). In addition, the increased fractions of the order Mononchida-
derived reads were commonly detected in the samples prepared from the surface layers by
comparing with those in the deep layer-derived samples (Fig 8A). The beta diversity analysis
was performed to assess the differences in compositions of nematode SVs in the eight soil sam-
ples, and the resultant PCoA plot with weighted unifrac distances indicated the distantly
related samples derived from site 1 (symbols in red) and site 2 (blue symbols), except for one
sample (#2_Plants_20–30) (Fig 8B). Regarding to the sampling depth, close relation between PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 17 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Fig 7. Relative read abundances and phylum of SVs obtained from high-throughput amplicon sequencing using the agricultural field-derived soil
DNAs. Relative read abundance and phylum of SVs obtained from the amplicon sequencing of region U2 of the SSU gene using soil DNAs derived from
the surface (0/10) and deep (20/30) layers at the sampling points without (control) and with (plants) plants at sites 1 and 2, respectively, as shown at the top
and bottom of the histograms. Boxes in the histogram indicate the read abundances; phylum is indicated by color as shown in the right legend box. Taxonomic classification of SVs was based on the SILVA database. Phyla with less than 1% of relative abundance were omitted. NA: Not assigned. Fig 7. Relative read abundances and phylum of SVs obtained from high-throughput amplicon sequencing using the agricultural field-derived soil
DNAs. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Relative read abundance and phylum of SVs obtained from the amplicon sequencing of region U2 of the SSU gene using soil DNAs derived from
the surface (0/10) and deep (20/30) layers at the sampling points without (control) and with (plants) plants at sites 1 and 2, respectively, as shown at the top
and bottom of the histograms. Boxes in the histogram indicate the read abundances; phylum is indicated by color as shown in the right legend box. Taxonomic classification of SVs was based on the SILVA database. Phyla with less than 1% of relative abundance were omitted. NA: Not assigned. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g007 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g007 the samples derived from the surface soils with and without plants at site 1 was found, but this
was not consistent with the samples at site 2. The numbers of nematode-derived SVs and their relative sequence reads in the feeding
type are shown in S11 and S12 Figs, respectively. First, these data notably indicated that the
bacteria feeder-derived SVs were the majority of the nematode population in the agricultural
field because over 60% of reads were assigned to bacteria feeder in all samples (S12 Fig). Sec-
ond, the fractions of reads from eukaryote feeder-derived SVs (e.g., U2_SV_40, 80, and 179),
which are closely related to the genus Achromadora (S10 Table), clearly increased in the sam-
ples from site 2. In addition, the numbers of nematode-derived SVs and their relative read
abundances in each family with cp-value are summarized in S13 and S14 Figs, respectively. Increased numbers of SVs identified from the samples were derived from the families Monhys-
teridae (cp-2) and Cyatholaimidae (cp-3) followed by Prismatolaimidae (cp-3) and Cephalobi-
dae (cp-2) (S13 Fig). The read abundances from these families were also the majority of
nematode-derived reads. In specific, the reads from the SVs (mainly U2_SV_11) were signifi-
cantly abundant in the site 1-derived samples (S14A Fig). U2_SV_11 was assigned to the genus PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 18 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Fig 8. Relative abundances of nematode-derived reads from the field-derived samples in each order and their be
diversity plots. The percentage of the abundance of sequence reads derived from the soil samples in each order is
shown by colored horizontal bar charts (A). PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Testing the universal SSU primers and soil DNAs for DNA amplifications
for taxonomic analyses of soil nematodes In prior taxonomic analyses of nematodes by high-throughput amplicon sequencing, genomic
DNAs of complex nematodes and nematode-specific primers have been often used as template
DNAs and PCR primers for amplification of the 18S ribosomal RNA (SSU) gene fragments
[11, 20, 22, 30, 31]. Recently, whole soil DNAs and/or the universal SSU primers have been
applied to DNA metabarcoding for terrestrial nematodes in several studies [12, 21, 34–38, 58]. Considering that PCR primers and template DNAs for the taxonomic analysis of soil nema-
todes have been poorly evaluated, we have tested four nematode-specific and two universal
primer sets as well as nematode and soil DNAs derived from copse soils for the DNA barcod-
ing of nematodes. Although the nematode genomic DNA contains concentrated nematodes
separated from other soil eukaryotes, the nematode population in the DNA is largely influ-
enced by nematode isolation methods, such as Baermann funnel method [59], which can pref-
erentially isolate the mobile nematodes in water. Conversely, bulk DNAs from soil samples
contain whole eukaryote-derived DNA including nematodes. However, the amount of soils
for DNA preparation is limited by DNA purification kits. Upon soil DNA purification, the
larger amount of soil samples is ideal for the taxonomic analysis because of the increased con-
tent of more complex eukaryotes. In this study, soil DNAs were purified using a DNeasy
PowerMax Soil Kit (QIAGEN) because of its highest capacity of up to 10 g soils among com-
mercially available soil DNA purification kits. We also used the eukaryotic universal primers
that amplify the 368 and 446 bp fragments spanning the variable regions V4 (region U1 in this
study) and V7–V8 (region U2) of the SSU gene [32, 33] (Fig 1B). The V4 [12, 21, 34, 37, 58]
and V7–V8 [11, 20, 22, 31, 35, 38, 58] regions were preferentially used for prior DNA metabar-
coding of terrestrial nematodes. We obtained the following observations on two template DNAs used. First, despite the
minor difference among the regions, except for regions 3 and U2, slightly larger numbers of
nematode-derived SVs were detected in nematode DNAs than in soil DNAs (Table 2). Second,
the largest fractions of reads from nematode genomic DNA were derived from the phylum
Nematode, but the fractions of the nematode-derived reads from soil DNA were less than 10%
of total reads (Figs 3 and 7). PLOS ONE Maturity indices for the corresponding soil samples from the surface (0–10 cm in depth) and deep layer (20–30 cm)
at the sampling point with (plants) and without (control) growing sweet potato at sites 1 and 2 in the field,
respectively. Maturity indices for the corresponding soil samples from the surface (0–10 cm in depth) and deep layer (20–30 cm)
at the sampling point with (plants) and without (control) growing sweet potato at sites 1 and 2 in the field,
respectively. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.t006 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.t006 Prismatolaimus, which is a bacteria feeder often found in moist soils [56, 57]. Finally, we deter-
mined the maturity indices of 2.51–2.96 for the nematode families identified from the eight
samples (Table 6). PLOS ONE Soil samples were isolated from the surface (0–10) and deep (20–30) laye
of the sampling points without (control) and with (plants) plants at sites 1 (#1) and 2 (#2), respectively, as shown in t
left of the corresponding histogram. Colors corresponding to orders are indicated at the bottom of figure. The
principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) plot with the weighted unifrac distances of eight samples derived from the
surface and deep layer at the point without (orange-colored circles and squares) and with (green-colored circles and
squares) plants from site 1 (circles) and 2 (squares) in the agricultural field (B). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g008 Fig 8. Relative abundances of nematode-derived reads from the field-derived samples in each order and their beta
diversity plots. The percentage of the abundance of sequence reads derived from the soil samples in each order is
shown by colored horizontal bar charts (A). Soil samples were isolated from the surface (0–10) and deep (20–30) layers
of the sampling points without (control) and with (plants) plants at sites 1 (#1) and 2 (#2), respectively, as shown in the
left of the corresponding histogram. Colors corresponding to orders are indicated at the bottom of figure. The
principal coordinate analysis (PCoA) plot with the weighted unifrac distances of eight samples derived from the
surface and deep layer at the point without (orange-colored circles and squares) and with (green-colored circles and
squares) plants from site 1 (circles) and 2 (squares) in the agricultural field (B). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g008 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842.g008 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 19 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Table 6. Maturity indices for nematode families from the field-derived soil samples. Control
Plants
0–10 cm
20–30 cm
0–10 cm
20–30 cm
Site 1
2.96
2.88
2.96
2.79
Site 2
2.75
2.68
2.73
2.51
Maturity indices for the corresponding soil samples from the surface (0–10 cm in depth) and deep layer (20–30 cm)
at the sampling point with (plants) and without (control) growing sweet potato at sites 1 and 2 in the field,
respectively. Table 6. Maturity indices for nematode families from the field-derived soil samples. Control
Plants
0–10 cm
20–30 cm
0–10 cm
20–30 cm
Site 1
2.96
2.88
2.96
2.79
Site 2
2.75
2.68
2.73
2.51 Table 6. Maturity indices for nematode families from the field-derived soil samples. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Testing the universal SSU primers and soil DNAs for DNA amplifications
for taxonomic analyses of soil nematodes Third, <40% of the nematode SVs, including major SVs, were
commonly detected in both template DNAs, and the remaining nematode SVs were uniquely
found in either nematode DNA or soil DNA (Table 3). Fourth, whereas the numbers of 20 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes regional nematode SVs (except for the region U2-derived SVs from nematode DNA) in each
order were comparable in both template DNAs (Fig 4), the compositions of relative read abun-
dances in order and feeding type were distinguishable by the DNAs (Fig 5 and S8 Fig). This
result was also confirmed by the beta diversity analyses based on the read abundances in order
and feeding type (Fig 6). Fifth, despite the quarter amount of the soils used for nematode isola-
tion, larger numbers of nematode families were identified from the soil DNA than from the
nematode genomic DNAs across the regions (S9 Table). The difference in the amount of soils
used may influence the results of this experiment, considering that the nematode genomic and
soil DNAs were derived from different amounts of soils (i.e., 40 and 10 g, respectively). The
influence of soil amount in amplicon-based taxonomic profiling remains an issue to be investi-
gated in the future. Thus, currently, it is difficult to determine which method using nematode
DNA or soil DNA is suitable for taxonomic analysis of soil nematodes because of potential
issues such as soil amounts. However, the DNA barcoding detected different nematode-
derived SVs (Table 3), and taxonomic variations in the cladograms (S1–S6 Figs) were found in
each template DNA, suggesting that both methods with nematode DNA and soil DNA could
be used complementary for nematode community analysis each other. Regarding the PCR primers tested, the following four findings were obtained. First, the rela-
tive abundances of the nematode-derived reads were largely comparable at the phylum-level
among all regions, except for region 3 (Fig 3). The primers for region 3 preferentially amplified
nematode-derived SSU fragments from both template DNAs, and this result is consistent with
previous observations in prior studies using complex nematode DNA [30] or individual nema-
tode DNA [29]. In addition, the SSU fragments derived from Ascomycota were differently
amplified by the primers for regions 1, 4, and U2 and regions 2, 3, and U1 (Fig 3). PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Testing the universal SSU primers and soil DNAs for DNA amplifications
for taxonomic analyses of soil nematodes Second, the
numbers of regional nematode SVs from the nematode and soil DNAs were similar among the
six regions, including region U2 with the large numbers of SVs (Table 3), because many of the
region U2-derived SVs were likely derived from allelic sequences in complex nematode DNAs
(S2 Table). The universal primers for region U2 may tend to amplify polymorphic SSU frag-
ments efficiently when complex nematode DNAs are used. Third, despite the presence of
minor differences, the compositions of relative read abundances in order and feeding type
were comparable among the regions (Fig 5 and S8 Fig). The majority of the copse-derived
nematode SVs was assigned to the orders Triplonchida, Dorylaimida, and Rhabditida (Figs 4
and 5) and were derived from plant and bacteria feeders (S7 and S8 Figs). The relative read
abundances in nematode families were also similar among the regions (S9 Fig). Fourth, the
beta diversity analyses of relative read abundances in order and feeding type clearly indicated
the close relation of region U2 and region 4 (Fig 6), which was suggested as the most suitable
nematode-specific target among the four regions by the taxonomic profiling of individual and
mixed nematodes [29, 30]. Finally, both primers for regions 4 and U2 identified comparable
total numbers of nematode SVs in two template DNAs if the allele-derived SVs are removed
(Table 3 and S2 Table), indicating that these primer sets are equally suitable for DNA metabar-
coding of soil nematodes. These observations on template DNAs and the SSU primers suggest that the universal SSU
primers for region U2, as the nematode-specific primers for region 4, could be used with soil
DNAs for the taxonomic analyses of soil nematodes by high-throughput amplicon sequencing. Prior studies have preferentially used nematode-specific primers and nematode community-
derived DNAs for amplicon preparations [11, 20, 22, 30, 31]. However, the universal primers
spanning the V4 region (3NDf and 1132rmod [12, 21, 34]; 566-F/915-R [37]; Ek-NS573/Ek-
NSR951 [58]) and the V7–V8 regions (F-1183/R-1631 [58]) of the SSU gene have been used to
amplify the SSU DNAs from nematode DNAs for Illumina MiSeq-assisted amplicon sequenc-
ing (Fig 1B). The universal SSU primer sets of Ek-NS573/Ek-NSR951 and F-1183/R-1631 that PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 21 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes have been used by Mu¨ller et al. Testing the universal SSU primers and soil DNAs for DNA amplifications
for taxonomic analyses of soil nematodes [58] are almost identical to the primer sets for regions U1 and
U2, respectively. Mu¨ller et al. also detected a small proportion (4.8%) of nematode-derived
OTUs in total eukaryotic OTUs derived from the Atlantic Forest soils as we observed in this
study. On the other hand, a few taxonomic studies focusing on soil nematodes by amplicon
sequencing with whole soil DNAs have been performed. For instance, Batista et al. investigated
the global distributions of soil invertebrates, including nematodes, by the MiSeq-assisted
sequencing of short amplicons spanning the V9 region with the universal primers (Euk1391f/
EukBr) [36] (Fig 1B). Sapkota and Nicolaisen developed nematode-specific primers (NemF/
18Sr2b) by modifying the published primer set NF1/18Sr2b [60] and clarified the taxonomic
profiles of nematodes through high-throughput amplicon sequencing using soil DNAs puri-
fied from 22 agricultural soils via the Roche 454 platform [35] (Fig 1B). Recently, Sikder et al. have analyzed nematode taxa in the soils isolated from maize-roots by Illumina MiSeq-assisted
amplicon sequencing using soil DNAs and the same primers used by Sapkota and Nicolaisen
[38]. Thus, nematode-specific primers and soil DNAs seem useful for the convenient analyses
of soil nematode communities without the laborious and bias-prone process of nematode iso-
lation, if the specific and unbiased quantitative amplifications of nematode species are ensured. However, loss of taxonomic information of other eukaryotes in the soils is a fundamental issue
of the nematode-focused method. By contrast, the amplicon sequencing using the universal
primers and soil DNAs can identify major nematode-derived SVs as well as other eukaryote-
derived SVs, providing taxonomic information covering the entire eukaryotes in parallel. However, the high depth of sequence reads may be required for this type of analysis to classify
nematodes with high taxonomic resolution. In addition, some nematode species may be lost in
the analyses using soil DNAs because most of the SVs with a feeding type of animal parasite
were undetected in the soil DNA among the regions (S1–S6 Figs). In addition, although soil
DNAs for amplifications were prepared from <0.25 g soils in prior studies using commercially
available soil DNA purification kits [35, 37, 38], whether or not these amounts of soils contain
sufficient numbers of soil animals, such as nematodes or earthworm, has yet to be determined. Nematode community structures in the copse and the cultivated
agricultural field In the analyses of the copse soil DNA-derived SVs,
their major feeding types and orders were assigned to bacteria and plant feeders, and Tri-
plonchida and Rhabditida (S8F Fig and Fig 5F). In a prior study using copse-derived individ-
ual nematodes, approximately 70% of total nematodes were derived from fungivores and plant
feeders [29]. The Dorylaimida- and Rhabditida-derived plant feeders were the most abundant
feeding types in a prior study that used copse-derived complex nematodes [30]. Abundant
plant feeders were consistently found in current and prior studies using copse soils [29, 30]. However, the abundances of bacteria feeders were discrepant between the analyses using the
soil and nematode DNAs. The fractions of bacteria feeder-derived reads commonly increased
and decreased across the regions in the analyses using soil and nematode DNAs, respectively
(S8 Fig), indicating that the relative abundances in feeding type and taxon (order) are influ-
enced by template DNAs used as described in the former section. In the analyses using the
field soils, the fractions of bacteria feeder-derived reads in the field samples were significantly
high and occupied >60% of the total reads (S12 Fig). Bacteria feeders have been often observed
as a major nematode group in agricultural field soils by amplicon sequencing [21, 22] and
morphology-based studies [9, 15, 61, 62]. For instance, Rhabditida-derived bacteria feeders
have been found as a major nematode group in house garden soils cultivating zucchini [30]. These previous findings agree with the observations from the sweet potato-cultivated field
soils. Nematodes can be classified by life-history strategy and by cp groups ranked from one to
five [54]. Colonizers with low cp values have short generation times, exploit transient niches,
lay eggs at high rates, and have high mobility and metabolic activity, and most bacteria feeders
belong to this group. Persisters with high cp values lay fewer eggs than colonizers and are
more susceptible to environmental disturbances, such as agricultural operations. Thus, the rel-
ative abundance of cp groups in the nematode population has been used to assess soil environ-
mental conditions [23, 55, 63]. In this study, distinct nematode communities in the copse and
field soils were shown by the relative abundances of reads derived from the families in each cp
group. The majority of the copse soil DNA-derived reads was assigned to the families with
high cp values, such as Prismatolaimidae (cp-3), Belondiridae (cp-5), and Trichodoridae (cp-
4) (S9 Fig). Nematode community structures in the copse and the cultivated
agricultural field As described in the former section, comparable results were obtained from the sequence analy-
ses of the amplicons from the copse-derived soil DNA using the universal primers for region
U2 and using the nematode-specific primers for region 4 that is suitable for the taxonomic
profiling of nematodes [29, 30]. Thus, amplicon sequencing with the universal primers and
soil DNA was conducted to analyze the taxonomy of the nematode community in the sweet
potato-cultivated agricultural field. Four soil samples from different depths and distances from
the plants were isolated at two sites of the field. The plants showed dominant and poor growth
at sites 1 and 2, respectively (Fig 2B and 2C). The fractions of the nematode-derived reads
were <10% of the total eukaryote-derived reads in the samples from both sites (Fig 7), as
observed in the analyses using the copse-derived soil DNAs (U2 column in the right of Fig 3). The sequence reads from the site 1-derived samples were largely occupied by the order Tri-
plonchida-derived reads. However, the contents of this order’s reads apparently decreased and
the fractions of the Chromadorida- and Monhysterida-derived reads increased in the samples
from site 2 (Fig 8A), suggesting distinct nematode communities in the two sampling sites. The
distinct compositions of the nematode SV-derived reads in the two sample groups of sites 1
and 2 were also confirmed by beta diversity analysis (Fig 8B). Thus, the nematode communi-
ties living in the two sites were distinct, and close relations were not found in the other sample
groups (i.e., distances from the plants and sampling depths) in this study. The taxonomic PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 22 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes difference in the two sampling sites could be ascribed to the different local conditions of the
soils, such as nutrient or fertility, at these sites. Considering that feeding behavior and maturity index are useful for the ecological classifi-
cation of nematodes [54], we further investigated the ecophysiological status of the nematodes
living in the copse and field soils on the basis of the feeding habitat of the region U2-derived
nematode SVs and the maturity index. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 Conclusion This study investigated nematode-derived SVs identified from complex nematode genomic
DNAs and whole soil DNAs prepared from copse soils by using high-throughput amplicon
sequencing with four nematode-specific and two universal primer sets for the 18S ribosomal
RNA (SSU) gene. Although the primer sets for regions 1, 4 and U2 and regions 2 and U1
showed slightly different amplification profiles at the phylum-level, the numbers and the rela-
tive read abundances of nematode-derived SVs in order and feeding type were largely compa-
rable among the six SSU regions (if the allele-derived SVs are removed). In addition, the
compositions of nematode orders and feeding types derived from the nematode genomic and
soil DNAs were distinct from each other. Although some different nematode SVs were found
in each template DNA, the major nematode SVs were commonly detected in both template
DNAs. Basing from these findings, we performed the taxonomic analyses of the nematode
community in the agricultural field using amplicon sequencing with the tailed eukaryotic uni-
versal SSU primers (F1183-18S_V7-V8_MiseqF/R1631a-18S_V7-V8_MiseqR) for region U2
and whole soil DNAs. The resultant compositions of the nematode-derived SVs in family,
order and feeding type, and the maturity indices virtually agree with previous findings on
nematodes living in agricultural fields. Despite the undetectable minor nematode-derived SVs
including allelic sequences, the resultant observations in this study suggest that the high-
throughput sequencing of the amplicons using the universal primers for region 2 and soil
DNA is a convenient tool for assessing the community structures of soil eukaryotes, including
nematodes. In the future, the improved version of this method could be widely applied to
assess the diversities and abundances of soil eukaryotes based on massive taxonomic data. Nematode community structures in the copse and the cultivated
agricultural field By contrast, most of the field soil DNA-derived reads were derived from the fami-
lies of low cp groups, including Cephalobidae, Monhysteridae (cp-2), Cyatholaimidae, and
Prismatolaimidae (cp-3) (S14 Fig). These findings are consistent with our previous observa-
tions obtained from the study using the copse- and the cultivated house garden-derived nema-
todes [30], suggesting undisturbed conditions of the copse soil and unstable conditions of the
field soil disturbed by the cultivation of sweet potato. Distinct nematode communities at the
copse and field were also identified using the maturity indices. The maturity indices for the
copse- and field-derived soil DNAs in region U2 were 3.13 and 2.51–2.96, respectively (Tables
4 and 6). These values are comparable to those obtained from the analyses using nematode
DNAs derived from the copse (3.86–4.23) and house garden (1.58–2.73) soils in a prior study
[30], although the data of the prior and current studies may be difficult to compare because of
different template DNAs (i.e., soil DNA in this study and nematode-derived DNA in the previ-
ous study) [30]. Moreover, the maturity indices were likely influenced by the template DNAs
used for amplification because the values of the index calculated using the nematode DNA-
derived SVs were larger than those calculated using the soil DNA-derived SVs (Table 4). 23 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes S1 Table. Information of the DRA-registered sequence data.
(PDF) S1 Table. Information of the DRA-registered sequence data. (PDF) S2 Table. Copse-derived regional nematode SVs from region U2 shared with high sequence
similarities. (PDF) S10 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from the agricultural soils (region U2) and their taxa
and feeding types based on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database.
(PDF) S10 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from the agricultural soils (region U2) and their taxa
and feeding types based on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF) S1 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region 1 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances in each template DNA. A cladogram was pre-
pared using nematode-derived SVs from region 1 and the corresponding SSU gene sequence
of H. crispae as the outgroup as described in the Materials and methods section. Bootstrap
numbers of over 500 per 1000 are indicated at the nodes of the cladogram. The name of the
nematode-derived SV in region 1 was indicated as R1_SV_number at the branch end of the
cladogram. Orders and feeding types of the SVs are indicated in the corresponding columns at
the right of the cladogram by colored boxes and abbreviations, as shown in the legend boxes. Relative read abundances of nematode-derived SVs in the nematode genomic DNA (Nema)
and soil DNA (Soil) from the copse soils are indicated by density boxes. A colored box for
order with a slashed line (R1_SV_289) indicates probable nematode order due to cross-hits to
the species in other phyla by BLASTN search (see S3 Table legend). (TIFF) S2 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region 2 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode-
derived SVs of region 2 as described in the Materials and methods section. Orders, feeding
types, and relative read abundances of the nematode-derived SVs are indicated in the corre-
sponding columns at the right of the cladogram by colored boxes, colored abbreviations, and
density boxes, respectively, as detailed in the caption of S1 Fig. (TIFF) S3 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region 3 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode-
derived SVs of region 3 as described in the Materials and methods section. Orders, feeding
types, and relative read abundances of the nematode-derived SVs are indicated in the corre-
sponding columns at the right of the cladogram by colored boxes, colored abbreviations, and
density boxes, respectively, as detailed in the caption of S1 Fig. (TIFF) S4 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region 4 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode-
derived SVs of region 4 as described in the Materials and methods section. S2 Table. Copse-derived regional nematode SVs from region U2 shared with high sequence
similarities. A colored box for
order with a slashed line (R1_SV_289) indicates probable nematode order due to cross-hits to
the species in other phyla by BLASTN search (see S3 Table legend). (TIFF)
S2 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region 2 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode-
derived SVs of region 2 as described in the Materials and methods section. Orders, feeding
types, and relative read abundances of the nematode-derived SVs are indicated in the corre-
sponding columns at the right of the cladogram by colored boxes, colored abbreviations, and
density boxes, respectively, as detailed in the caption of S1 Fig. (TIFF)
S3 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region 3 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode-
derived SVs of region 3 as described in the Materials and methods section. Orders, feeding
types, and relative read abundances of the nematode-derived SVs are indicated in the corre-
sponding columns at the right of the cladogram by colored boxes, colored abbreviations, and
density boxes, respectively, as detailed in the caption of S1 Fig. (TIFF)
S4 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region 4 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode-
derived SVs of region 4 as described in the Materials and methods section. Orders, feeding
types, and relative read abundances of the nematode-derived SVs are indicated in the corre-
sponding columns at the right of the cladogram by colored boxes, colored abbreviations, and
density boxes, respectively, as detailed in the caption of S1 Fig. (TIFF)
S5 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region U1 with the corresponding orders, S2 Table. Copse-derived regional nematode SVs from region U2 shared with high sequence
similarities. S3 Table. Nematode-derived sequence variants (SVs) from region 1 and their taxa and
feeding types based on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF) S4 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from region 2 and their taxa and feeding types based on
the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF) S5 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from region 3 and their taxa and feeding types based on
the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF) S5 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from region 3 and their taxa and feeding types based on
the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF) S6 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from region 4 and their taxa and feeding types based on
the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF) S7 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from region U1 and their taxa and feeding types based
on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF) 24 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes S8 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from region U2 and their taxa and feeding types based
on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF)
S9 Table. Numbers of regional nematode SVs by nematode family and colonizer–persister
(cp) value. (PDF)
S10 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from the agricultural soils (region U2) and their taxa
and feeding types based on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database. (PDF)
S1 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region 1 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances in each template DNA. A cladogram was pre-
pared using nematode-derived SVs from region 1 and the corresponding SSU gene sequence
of H. crispae as the outgroup as described in the Materials and methods section. Bootstrap
numbers of over 500 per 1000 are indicated at the nodes of the cladogram. The name of the
nematode-derived SV in region 1 was indicated as R1_SV_number at the branch end of the
cladogram. Orders and feeding types of the SVs are indicated in the corresponding columns at
the right of the cladogram by colored boxes and abbreviations, as shown in the legend boxes. Relative read abundances of nematode-derived SVs in the nematode genomic DNA (Nema)
and soil DNA (Soil) from the copse soils are indicated by density boxes. S10 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from the agricultural soils (region U2) and their taxa
and feeding types based on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database.
(PDF) Orders, feeding
types, and relative read abundances of the nematode-derived SVs are indicated in the corre-
sponding columns at the right of the cladogram by colored boxes, colored abbreviations, and
density boxes, respectively, as detailed in the caption of S1 Fig. (TIFF) S5 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region U1 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode- S5 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region U1 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode- 25 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes derived SVs of region U1 as described in the Materials and methods section. Orders, feeding
types, and relative read abundances of the nematode-derived SVs are indicated in the corre-
sponding columns at the right of the cladogram by colored boxes, colored abbreviations, and
density boxes, respectively, as detailed in the caption of S1 Fig. (TIFF) S6 Fig. Cladogram of nematode-derived SVs in region U2 with the corresponding orders,
feeding types, and relative read abundances. A cladogram was prepared using nematode-
derived SVs of region U2 as described in the Materials and methods section. Orders, feeding
types, and relative read abundances of the nematode-derived SVs are indicated in the corre-
sponding columns at the right of the cladogram by colored boxes, colored abbreviations, and
density boxes, respectively, as detailed in the caption of S1 Fig. (TIFF) S7 Fig. Numbers of regional nematode SVs from nematode and soil DNAs from the copse
soils in each feeding type. Regional nematode SVs derived from the copse-derived nematode
genomic DNA (blue bars) and soil DNA (red bars) were assigned to one of seven feeding types
(bacteria feeder, fungus feeder, plant feeder, omnivore, predator, eukaryote feeder, and animal
parasite) as described in the Materials and methods section. Numbers of regional nematode
SVs in feeding type are shown by colored bars in regions 1 (A), 2 (B), 3 (C), 4 (D), U1 (E), and
U2 (F), respectively. SVs with multiple feeding types are classified as “not assigned (NA).” Tar-
get SSU regions are indicated at the top right side of the corresponding bar charts. (TIFF) S8 Fig. Relative abundances of sequence reads from six SSU regions in feeding type. S10 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from the agricultural soils (region U2) and their taxa
and feeding types based on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database.
(PDF) Feed-
ing types of the regional nematode SVs were assigned as described in the legend for S7 Fig. The percentages of the sequence reads of nematode SVs identified from the copse-derived
nematode DNA (Nema) and soil DNA (Soil) in feeding type are shown by colored fractions of
horizontal bars in regions 1 (A), 2 (B), 3 (C), 4 (D), U1 (E), and U2 (F), respectively. Each feed-
ing type is indicated by color as shown at the bottom of (F). The fractions of SVs with multiple
feeding types are classified as “not assigned” and indicated in light gray. Target SSU regions
are indicated at the right side of the corresponding horizontal bar charts. (TIFF) S9 Fig. Relative abundance of sequence reads of regional nematode SVs in each family and
cp group. Percentages of sequence reads of regional nematode SVs identified from the copse-
derived nematode genomic DNA (blue bars) and soil DNA (orange bars) are indicated in each
family by histograms for regions 1–4, U1 and U2 (A–F), respectively. The cp-values, shown at
the bottom of figure, indicate the nematode’s life strategy characteristics as described in the
Materials and methods section. Nematode families are aligned by their cp values (1–5); unde-
fined cp values are indicated by a hyphen (-). NA: not assigned to a single family. Target SSU
regions are indicated at the top right side of the corresponding histograms. (TIFF) S10 Fig. Numbers of nematode-derived SVs in order identified from four samples from
sites 1 and 2 of the agricultural field. Nematode-derived SVs were obtained from four soil
samples isolated from the surface (0–10) and deep (20–30) layers at the sampling points with-
out (control) and with (plants) growing sweet potato at sites 1 (A) and 2 (B), respectively. The
number of nematode-derived SVs in each sample is indicated by colored horizontal bars; the
samples and colors are indicated in the legend box. (TIFF) S10 Fig. Numbers of nematode-derived SVs in order identified from four samples from
sites 1 and 2 of the agricultural field. Nematode-derived SVs were obtained from four soil
samples isolated from the surface (0–10) and deep (20–30) layers at the sampling points with-
out (control) and with (plants) growing sweet potato at sites 1 (A) and 2 (B), respectively. The
number of nematode-derived SVs in each sample is indicated by colored horizontal bars; the
samples and colors are indicated in the legend box. S10 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from the agricultural soils (region U2) and their taxa
and feeding types based on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database.
(PDF) (TIFF) 26 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes S11 Fig. Numbers of nematode-derived SVs in feeding type obtained from four samples
from sites 1 and 2 of the agricultural field. Nematode-derived SVs identified from four soil
samples at sites 1 (A) and 2 (B) of the agricultural field were assigned to one of six feeding types
as described in the Materials and methods section. Four soil samples were isolated from the sur-
face (0–10) and deep (20–30) layers at the sampling point with (plants) and without (control)
growing sweet potato at each site, as shown by colors in the legend box at the bottom of the fig-
ure. Number of nematode-derived SVs in feeding type is shown in each sample by the corre-
sponding color bar. The SVs with multiple feeding types are classified as “not assigned (NA)”. (TIFF) S11 Fig. Numbers of nematode-derived SVs in feeding type obtained from four samples
from sites 1 and 2 of the agricultural field. Nematode-derived SVs identified from four soil
samples at sites 1 (A) and 2 (B) of the agricultural field were assigned to one of six feeding types
as described in the Materials and methods section. Four soil samples were isolated from the sur-
face (0–10) and deep (20–30) layers at the sampling point with (plants) and without (control)
growing sweet potato at each site, as shown by colors in the legend box at the bottom of the fig-
ure. Number of nematode-derived SVs in feeding type is shown in each sample by the corre-
sponding color bar. The SVs with multiple feeding types are classified as “not assigned (NA)”. (TIFF) S12 Fig. Relative abundances of sequence reads in feeding type in the agricultural field-
derived eight soil samples. Feeding types of the nematode-derived SVs identified from
eight soil samples were assigned as described in the legend for S11 Fig. The percentages of the
sequence reads of nematode-derived SVs in feeding type are shown by colored fractions of
horizontal bars in eight soil samples isolated from the surface (0–10) and deep (20–30) layers
at the sampling point with (plants) and without (control) the growing sweet potato at site 1
(#1) and 2 (#2), respectively, as shown in the left of the corresponding histogram. S10 Table. Nematode-derived SVs from the agricultural soils (region U2) and their taxa
and feeding types based on the BLASTN search and the SILVA database.
(PDF) Each feeding
type is indicated by color as shown at the bottom of figure. The fractions of SVs with multiple
feeding types are classified as “not assigned (NA)” and indicated in light gray. (TIFF) S13 Fig. Numbers of nematode-derived SVs obtained from the agricultural field soils in
family and cp-value. Nematode-derived SVs identified from soil DNAs derived from sites 1
(A) and 2 (B) of the agricultural field were assigned to nematode families based on the closest
species identified by the BLASTN search. Nematode-derived SVs identified from four soil
samples: The surface (0–10) and deep (20–30) layers at the sampling point with (plants) and
without (control) the growing sweet potato, respectively, as shown by colors in the legend box. Number of nematode-derived SVs in family is shown by the corresponding color bar in each
sample. Families are aligned by their cp values (1–5); undefined cp values are indicated by a
hyphen (-). NA: not assigned to a single family. (TIFF) S14 Fig. Relative read abundance of nematode-derived SVs obtained from the agricultural
field soils in family and cp group. The relative abundance (%) of sequence reads of SVs
obtained from four soil samples at sites 1 (A) and 2 (B) in each family are shown by colored
horizontal bars. Soil samples were isolated from the surface (0–10) and deep (20–30) layers at
the proximal (plants) and distal (control) to the sweet potato at each site, as shown by colors in
the legend box. Families are aligned by their cp values (1–5); undefined cp values are indicated
by a hyphen (-). NA: not assigned to a single family. (TIFF) Acknowledgments The authors thank Dr. Takahiro Yamauchi (Research Center for Agrotechnology and Biotech-
nology, Toyohashi University of Technology) for helpful comments and providing an oppor-
tunity for soil sampling, as well as Tomokazu Nitta and Masahiro Ishikawa for their previous
contributions. Project administration: Toshihiko Eki. Resources: Akinori Takase. Software: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Yuu Hirose. Software: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Yuu Hirose. Supervision: Yuu Hirose, Toshihiko Eki. Supervision: Yuu Hirose, Toshihiko Eki. Visualization: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Toshihiko Eki. Visualization: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Toshihiko Eki. Writing – original draft: Toshihiko Eki. Writing – original draft: Toshihiko Eki. Writing – review & editing: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Yuu Hirose, Toshihiko Eki. References 1. Crowther TW, van den Hoogen J, Wan J, Mayes MA, Keiser AD, Mo L, et al. The global soil community
and its influence on biogeochemistry. Science. 2019; 365: 772. ARTN eaav0550 https://doi.org/10. 1126/science.aav0550 PMID: 31439761 2. Zhang R, Vivanco JM, Shen Q. The unseen rhizosphere root-soil-microbe interactions for crop produc-
tion. Curr Opin Microbiol. 2017; 37: 8–14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mib.2017.03.008 PMID: 28433932 3. Babalola OO, Emmanuel OC, Adeleke BS, Odelade KA, Nwachukwu BC, Ayiti OE, et al. Rhizosphere
microbiome cooperations: Strategies for sustainable crop production. Curr Microbiol. 2021; 78: 1069–
1085. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00284-021-02375-2 PMID: 33611628 4. Hodda M, Peters L, Traunspurger W. Nematode diversity in terresterial, freshwater aquatic and marine
systems. In: Wilson MJ, Kakouli-Duarte T, editors. Nematodes as environmental indicators. Oxford-
shire: CABI International; 2009. pp. 45–93. 5. Nielsen UN, Ayres E, Wall DH, Li G, Bardgett RD, Wu TH, et al. Global-scale patterns of assemblage
structure of soil nematodes in relation to climate and ecosystem properties. Global Ecol Biogeogr. 2014; 23: 968–978. https://doi.org/10.1111/geb.12177 6. Song DG, Pan KW, Tariq A, Sun F, Li ZL, Sun XM, et al. Large-scale patterns of distribution and diver-
sity of terrestrial nematodes. Appl Soil Ecol. 2017; 114: 161–169. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsoil.2017. 02.013 7. van den Hoogen J, Geisen S, Routh D, Ferris H, Traunspurger W, Wardle DA, et al. Soil nematode
abundance and functional group composition at a global scale. Nature. 2019; 572: 194–198. https://doi. org/10.1038/s41586-019-1418-6 PMID: 31341281 8. Procter DL. Global overview of the functional roles of soil-living nematodes in terrestrial communities
and ecosystems. J Nematol. 1990; 22: 1–7. PMID: 19287681 9. Yeates GW, Bongers T. Nematode diversity in agroecosystems. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 1999; 74:
113–135. 10. Gutie´rrez C, Ferna´ndez C, Escuer M, Campos-Herrera R, Rodrı´guez MEB, Carbonell G, et al. Effect of
soil properties, heavy metals and emerging contaminants in the soil nematodes diversity. Environ Pol-
lut. 2016; 213: 184–194. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2016.02.012 PMID: 26895540 11. Dong K, Moroenyane I, Tripathi B, Kerfahi D, Takahashi K, Yamamoto N, et al. Soil nematodes show a
mid-elevation diversity maximum and elevational zonation on Mt. Norikura, Japan. Sci Rep. 2017; 7. ARTN 3028 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-03655-3 PMID: 28596521 12. Wilschut RA, Geisen S, Martens H, Kostenko O, de Hollander M, Ten Hooven FC, et al. Latitudinal vari-
ation in soil nematode communities under climate warming-related range-expanding and native plants. Glob Chang Biol. 2019; 25: 2714–2726. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.14657 PMID: 31002208 13. Neher DA. Nematode communities in organically and conventionally managed agricultural soils. Author Contributions Conceptualization: Toshihiko Eki. 27 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes Data curation: Harutaro Kenmotsu. Formal analysis: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Toshihiko Eki. Funding acquisition: Toshihiko Eki. Investigation: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Emi Takabayashi, Akinori Takase. Methodology: Yuu Hirose. Project administration: Toshihiko Eki. Resources: Akinori Takase. Software: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Yuu Hirose. Supervision: Yuu Hirose, Toshihiko Eki. Visualization: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Toshihiko Eki. Writing – original draft: Toshihiko Eki. Writing – review & editing: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Yuu Hirose, Toshihiko Eki. Data curation: Harutaro Kenmotsu. Formal analysis: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Toshihiko Eki. Funding acquisition: Toshihiko Eki. Investigation: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Emi Takabayashi, Akinori Takase. Investigation: Harutaro Kenmotsu, Emi Takabayashi, Akinori Takase. References J
Nematol. 1999; 31: 142–154. PMID: 19270884 28 / 31 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes 14. Verschoor BC, Pronk TE, de Goede RGM, Brussaard L. Could plant-feeding nematodes affect the com-
petition between grass species during succession in grasslands under restoration management? J
Ecol. 2002; 90: 753–761. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2745.2002.00710.x 15. Okada H, Harada H. Effects of tillage and fertilizer on nematode communities in a Japanese soybean
field. Appl Soil Ecol. 2007; 35: 582–598. 16. Pan F, McLaughlin NB, Yu Q, Xue AG, Xu Y, Han X, et al. Responses of soil nematode community
structure to different long-term fertilizer strategies in the soybean phase of a soybeanewheatecorn rota-
tion. Eur J Soil Biol. 2010; 46: 105–111. 17. Zhao J, Neher DA. Soil nematode genera that predict specific types of disturbance. Appl Soil Ecol. 2013; 64: 135–141. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsoil.2012.11.008 18. Ito T, Araki M, Higashi T, Komatsuzaki M, Kaneko N, Ohta H. Responses of soil nematode community
structure to soil carbon changes due to different tillage and cover crop management practices over a
nine-year period in Kanto, Japan. Appl Soil Ecol. 2015; 89: 50–58. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsoil. 2014.12.010 19. Liu T, Chen XY, Hu F, Ran W, Shen QR, Li HX, et al. Carbon-rich organic fertilizers to increase soil bio-
diversity: Evidence from a meta-analysis of nematode communities. Agr Ecosyst Environ. 2016; 232:
199–207. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2016.07.015 20. Treonis AM, Unangst SK, Kepler RM, Buyer JS, Cavigelli MA, Mirsky SB, et al. Characterization of soil
nematode communities in three cropping systems through morphological and DNA metabarcoding
approaches. Sci Rep. 2018; 8. ARTN 2004 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-20366-5 PMID:
29386563 21. Bongiorno G, Bodenhausen N, Bu¨nemann EK, Brussaard L, Geisen S, Ma¨der P, et al. Reduced tillage,
but not organic matter input, increased nematode diversity and food web stability in European long-term
field experiments. Mol Ecol. 2019; 28: 4987–5005. https://doi.org/10.1111/mec.15270 PMID:
31618508 22. Herren GL, Habraken J, Waeyenberge L, Haegeman A, Viaene N, Cougnon M, et al. Effects of syn-
thetic fertilizer and farm compost on soil nematode community in long-term crop rotation plots: A mor-
phological and metabarcoding approach. PLoS One. 2020; 15. ARTN e0230153 https://doi.org/10. 1371/journal.pone.0230153 PMID: 32182269 23. Bongers T, Ferris H. Nematode community structure as a bioindicator in environmental monitoring. Trends Ecol Evol. 1999; 14: 224–228. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0169-5347(98)01583-3 PMID:
10354624 24. References Mulder C, Schouten AJ, Hund-Rinke K, Breure AM. The use of nematodes in ecological soil classifica-
tion and assessment concepts. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2005; 62: 278–289. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. ecoenv.2005.03.028 PMID: 15919114 25. Chen XY, Daniell TJ, Neilson R, O’Flaherty V, Griffiths BS. A comparison of molecular methods for
monitoring soil nematodes and their use as biological indicators. Eur J Soil Biol. 2010; 46: 319–324. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejsobi.2010.05.002 26. Seesao Y, Gay M, Merlin S, Viscogliosi E, Aliouat-Denis CM, Audebert C. A review of methods for nem-
atode identification. J Microbiol Methods. 2017; 138: 37–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mimet.2016.05. 030 PMID: 27262374 27. Cristescu ME. From barcoding single individuals to metabarcoding biological communities: towards an
integrative approach to the study of global biodiversity. Trends Ecol Evol. 2014; 29: 566–571. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2014.08.001 PMID: 25175416 28. Morise H, Miyazaki E, Yoshimitsu S, Eki T. Profiling nematode communities in unmanaged flowerbed
and agricultural field soils in Japan by DNA barcode sequencing. PLoS One. 2012; 7: e51785. https://
doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0051785 PMID: 23284767 29. Kenmotsu H, Uchida K, Hirose Y, Eki T. Taxonomic profiling of individual nematodes isolated from
copse soils using deep amplicon sequencing of four distinct regions of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene. PLoS One. 2020; 15: e0240336. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0240336 PMID: 33027282 30. Kenmotsu H, Ishikawa M, Nitta T, Hirose Y, Eki T. Distinct community structures of soil nematodes from
three ecologically different sites revealed by high-throughput amplicon sequencing of four 18S ribo-
somal RNA gene regions. PLoS One. 2021; 16: e0249571. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone. 0249571 PMID: 33857177 31. Du XF, Li YB, Han X, Ahmad W, Li Q. Using high-throughput sequencing quantitatively to investigate
soil nematode community composition in a steppe-forest ecotone. Appl Soil Ecol. 2020; 152. ARTN
103562 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsoil.2020.103562 32. Hadziavdic K, Lekang K, Lanzen A, Jonassen I, Thompson EM, Troedsson C. Characterization of the
18S rRNA gene for designing universal eukaryote specific primers. PLoS One. 2014; 9: e87624. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0087624 PMID: 24516555 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 29 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes 33. Hugerth LW, Muller EE, Hu YO, Lebrun LA, Roume H, Lundin D, et al. Systematic design of 18S rRNA
gene primers for determining eukaryotic diversity in microbial consortia. PLoS One. 2014; 9: e95567. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0095567 PMID: 24755918 34. Geisen S, Snoek LB, ten Hooven FC, Duyts H, Kostenko O, Bloem J, et al. References Integrating quantitative mor-
phological and qualitative molecular methods to analyse soil nematode community responses to plant
range expansion. Methods Ecol Evol. 2018; 9: 1366–1378. https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210x.12999 35. Sapkota R, Nicolaisen M. High-throughput sequencing of nematode communities from total soil DNA
extractions. BMC Ecol. 2015; 15: 3. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12898-014-0034-4 PMID: 25880249 36. Bastida F, Eldridge DJ, Abades S, Alfaro FD, Gallardo A, Garcı´a-Vela´zquez L, et al. Climatic vulnerabili-
ties and ecological preferences of soil invertebrates across biomes. Mol Ecol. 2020; 29: 752–761. https://doi.org/10.1111/mec.15299 PMID: 31697860 37. Matus-Acuña V, Caballero-Flores G, Martı´nez-Romero E. The influence of maize on the rhizosphere
eukaryotic community. FEMS Microbiol Ecol. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1093/femsec/fiab066 PMID:
33930111 38. Sikder MM, Vestergård M, Kyndt T, Fomsgaard IS, Kudjordjie EN, Nicolaisen M. Benzoxazinoids selec-
tively affect maize root-associated nematode taxa. J Exp Bot. 2021; 72: 3835–3845. https://doi.org/10. 1093/jxb/erab104 PMID: 33712814 39. Caporaso JG, Kuczynski J, Stombaugh J, Bittinger K, Bushman FD, Costello EK, et al. QIIME allows
analysis of high-throughput community sequencing data. Nat Methods. 2010; 7: 335–336. https://doi. org/10.1038/nmeth.f.303 PMID: 20383131 40. Martin M. Cutadapt removes adapter sequences from high-throughput sequencing reads. EMBnetjour-
nal. 2011; 17: 10–12. https://doi.org/10.14806/ej.17.1.200 41. Callahan BJ, McMurdie PJ, Rosen MJ, Han AW, Johnson AJ, Holmes SP. DADA2: High-resolution
sample inference from Illumina amplicon data. Nat Methods. 2016; 13: 581–583. https://doi.org/10. 1038/nmeth.3869 PMID: 27214047 42. Rognes T, Flouri T, Nichols B, Quince C, Mahe´ F. VSEARCH: a versatile open source tool for metage-
nomics. PeerJ. 2016; 4: e2584. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.2584 PMID: 27781170 43. Quast C, Pruesse E, Yilmaz P, Gerken J, Schweer T, Yarza P, et al. The SILVA ribosomal RNA gene
database project: improved data processing and web-based tools. Nucleic Acids Res. 2013; 41: D590–
596. https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gks1219 PMID: 23193283 44. McMurdie PJ, Holmes S. phyloseq: an R package for reproducible interactive analysis and graphics of
microbiome census data. PLoS One. 2013; 8: e61217. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0061217
PMID: 23630581 45. Larkin MA, Blackshields G, Brown NP, Chenna R, McGettigan PA, McWilliam H, et al. Clustal W and
Clustal X version 2.0. Bioinformatics. 2007; 23: 2947–2948. https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/
btm404 PMID: 17846036 46. Yeates GW, Bongers T, De Goede RG, Freckman DW, Georgieva SS. Feeding habits in soil nematode
families and genera-an outline for soil ecologists. J Nematol. 1993; 25: 315–331. PMID: 19279775 47. Ferris H. Nematode Ecophysiological Parameter Search 2020. http://nemaplex.ucdavis.edu/Ecology/
EcophysiologyParms/EcoParameterMenu.html. 48. Moravec F, Kaiser H. Description of Cosmocerca longispicula sp. nov. References (Nematoda: Cosmocercidae), a
parasite of a dendrobatid frog from Martinique, French Antilles. Parasitol Res. 1994; 80: 29–32. https://
doi.org/10.1007/BF00932620 PMID: 8153122 49. Hunt DJ. Travassosinema thyropygi sp. n. (Nematoda: Travassosinematidae) from a spirobolid milli-
pede from Vietnam with SEM observations on Heth imias Spiridonov, 1989 (Nematoda: Hethidae). Fund Appl Nematol. 1996; 19: 7–14. 50. Camino NB, Reboredo GR. Cephalobellus lobulata n. sp. (Oxyurida:Thelastomatidae) A parasite of
Neocurtilla claraziana Saussure (Orthoptera: gryllotalpidae) from Argentina. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz. 2000; 95: 49–51. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0074-02762000000100007 PMID: 10656704 51. Guzeeva EA. [Severianoia blapticola sp. n. (Oxyurida: Thelastomatidae): a new nematode species
from blaberid cockroaches]. Parazitologiia. 2009; 43: 299–308. PMID: 19807041 52. Singh N, Chaudhary A, Singh HS. Molecular phylogeny of nematodes (Oxyurida: Travassosinemati-
dae) from Orthoptera (Gryllotalpidae) inferred by mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 gene. Bioinformation. 2015; 11: 343–347. https://doi.org/10.6026/97320630011343 PMID: 26339150 53. Ozawa S, Morffe J, Vicente CS, Ikeda K, Shinya R, Hasegawa K. Morphological, molecular and devel-
opmental characterization of the thelastomatid nematode Thelastoma bulhoesi (de Magalhaes, 1900)
(Oxyuridomorpha: Thelastomatidae) parasite of Periplaneta americana (Linnaeus, 1758) (Blattodea:
Blattidae) in Japan. Acta Parasitol. 2016; 61: 241–254. https://doi.org/10.1515/ap-2016-0034 PMID:
27078647 PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 30 / 31 PLOS ONE Use of universal primers of the 18S ribosomal RNA gene and soil DNAs to analyze soil nematodes 54. Bongers T, Bongers M. Functional diversity of nematodes. Appl Soil Ecol. 1998; 10: 239–251. https://
doi.org/10.1016/S0929-1393(98)00123-1 55. Bongers T. The maturity index: an ecological measure of environmental disturbance based on nema-
tode species composition. Oecologia. 1990; 83: 14–19. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00324627 PMID:
28313236 56. Coomans AV, Raski DJ. Two new species of Prismatolaimus de Man, 1880 (Nemata: Prismatolaimi-
dae) in southern chile. J Nematol. 1988; 20: 288–303. PMID: 19290212 57. Liang W, Zhang X, Li Q, Jiang Y, Ou W, Neher DA. Vertical distribution of bacterivorous nematodes
under different land uses. J Nematol. 2005; 37: 254–258. PMID: 19262869 58. Mu¨ller CA, Pereira LD, Lopes C, Cares J, Borges LGD, Giongo A, et al. Meiofaunal diversity in the
Atlantic Forest soil: A quest for nematodes in a native reserve using eukaryotic metabarcoding analysis
Forest Ecol Manag. 2019; 453. ARTN 117591 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2019.117591 59. Baermann G. Eine einfache Methode zur Auffindung von Ancylostomum (Nematoden) Larven in Erd-
proben. Geneeskd Tijdschr Ned Indie. 1917; 57: 131–137. 60. Porazinska DL, Giblin-Davis RM, Faller L, Farmerie W, Kanzaki N, Morris K, et al. PLOS ONE | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0259842
November 15, 2021 References Evaluating high-
throughput sequencing as a method for metagenomic analysis of nematode diversity. Mol Ecol Resour. 2009; 9: 1439–1450. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1755-0998.2009.02611.x PMID: 21564930 61. Neher DA, Wu J, Barbercheck ME, Anas O. Ecosystem type affects interpretation of soil nematode
community measures. Appl Soil Ecol. 2005; 30: 47–64. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsoil.2005.01.002 62. Pothula SK, Grewal PS, Auge RM, Saxton AM, Bernard EC. Agricultural intensification and urbanization
negatively impact soil nematode richness and abundance: a meta-analysis. J Nematol. 2019; 51: 1–17. https://doi.org/10.21307/jofnem-2019-011 PMID: 31088023 63. Ritz K, Trudgill DL. Utility of nematode community analysis as an integrated measure of the functional
state of soils: perspectives and challenges—Discussion paper. Plant Soil. 1999; 212: 1–11. https://doi. org/10.1023/A:1004673027625 64. Mangot JF, Domaizon I, Taib N, Marouni N, Duffaud E, Bronner G, et al. Short-term dynamics of diver-
sity patterns: evidence of continual reassembly within lacustrine small eukaryotes. Environ Microbiol. 2013; 15: 1745–1758. https://doi.org/10.1111/1462-2920.12065 PMID: 23297806 65. Starke R, Kermer R, Ullmann-Zeunert L, Baldwin IT, Seifert J, Bastida F, et al. Bacteria dominate the
short-term assimilation of plant-derived N in soil. Soil Biol Biochem. 2016; 96: 30–38. https://doi.org/10. 1016/j.soilbio.2016.01.009 66. Amaral-Zettler LA, McCliment EA, Ducklow HW, Huse SM. A method for studying protistan diversity
using massively parallel sequencing of V9 hypervariable regions of small-subunit ribosomal RNA
genes. PLoS One. 2009; 4: e6372. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0006372 PMID: 19633714 67. Ramirez KS, Leff JW, Barbera´n A, Bates ST, Betley J, Crowther TW, et al. Biogeographic patterns in
below-ground diversity in New York City’s Central Park are similar to those observed globally. Proc R
Soc B. 2014; 281: 20141988. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2014.1988 PMID: 25274366 31 / 31
|
https://openalex.org/W2198484515
|
https://www.edscience.ru/jour/article/download/107/102
|
Russian
| null |
Interpreting the Social Order for the Moral Personality Upbringing in the Context of the New Educational Standards.
|
Obrazovanie i nauka
| 2,015
|
cc-by
| 1,950
|
1 Статья печатается при поддержке гранта РГНФ № 11–06–00230а «Проек-
тирование духовно-нравственной среды образовательных учреждений с использо-
ванием социо-культурного пространства региона». Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования 5. Строкова Т. А. Мониторинг в школьном образовании: моногр. 2-е изд. Тюмень: Изд-во Тюмен. гос. ун-та, 2008. 196 с. 6. Черепанов В. С. Экспертные оценки в педагогических ис-
следованиях. М.: Педагогика, 1989. 159 с. 5. Строкова Т. А. Мониторинг в школьном образовании: моногр. 2-е изд. Тюмень: Изд-во Тюмен. гос. ун-та, 2008. 196 с. 6. Черепанов В. С. Экспертные оценки в педагогических ис-
следованиях. М.: Педагогика, 1989. 159 с. УДК 37.01 О. А. Теплякова
ИНТЕРПРЕТАЦИЯ СОЦИАЛЬНОГО ЗАКАЗА НА
ВОСПИТАНИЕ ДУХОВНО-НРАВСТВЕННОЙ ЛИЧНОСТИ
В ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫХ ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛЬНЫХ СТАНДАРТАХ
НАЧАЛЬНОГО И ОСНОВНОГО ОБЩЕГО ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ1 Аннотация. Автор статьи делает попытку интерпретировать соци-
альный и государственный заказ на воспитание духовно-нравственной
личности, зафиксированный в государственных образовательных стан-
дартах нового поколения. Перечисляются причины актуализации такой
необходимости: всемирная глобализация, распространение техногенной
цивилизации, неблагополучная экология, грозящая самоуничтожением
человечеству, существующие противоречия и конфликты между носите-
лями разных взглядов, национальных культур, религиозных конфессий. Указывается на преемственность и взаимосвязь новых воспитательных
задач с классическими идеями отечественной педагогики и на новые тен-
денции в сфере воспитания личности. На основе анализа Примерных ос-
новных образовательных программ начального и основного общего обра-
зования в общем виде показаны путь становления духовно-нравственной
личности и механизмы формирования социально приемлемой модели по-
ведения учащихся. Ключевые слова: государственные образовательные стандарты, со-
циальный заказ, нравственное воспитание. Abstract. The author makes an attempt to interpret the social order for
upbringing the spiritually and morally developed personality in the light of
the new state educational standards. Such a necessity is caused by globaliza-
tion processes, technogenic civilization developments, ecological challenges, Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) 71 © О. А. Теплякова contradictions and conflicts of people with opposing views representing differ-
ent cultures and religious denominations. The author emphasizes the conti-
nuity and interrelations between the new challenges and classical ideas of
Russian pedagogy, as well as the new trends in moral education develop-
ments. Analyzing the approximate curricula of the primary and secondary
education, the author demonstrates the mechanisms for setting the socially
acceptable behavior patterns and developing the spiritually and morally ad-
vanced personality. Keywords: social order, state educational standards, moral education. Социальный заказ на воспитание духовно-нравственной лич-
ности вызван не только социально-экономическими, экологиче-
скими и др., большей частью негативными процессами, которые
происходят в нашей стране, но и глобальными проблемами миро-
вого уровня. В результате глобализации, т. е. постепенного стира-
ния политических, экономических, информационных, культурных
и т. п. границ между государствами и народами, мир становится
все более зависимым от всех его субъектов. Распространение же
техногенной цивилизации и истребление человеком природы дос-
тигли таких масштабов, что сделали сегодня вполне реальной угро-
зу самоуничтожения человечества. Идеи физического истребления
людей часто порождаются и из-за возникающих противоречий
и конфликтов между носителями иных взглядов, национальных
культур, религиозных конфессий. На данном этапе крайне важно
найти пути продуктивного существования человека и общества,
в основе которых будут лежать жизнеутверждающие ценности. Очевидно, что усилилось внимание нашего государства к пробле-
ме духовно-нравственного воспитания личности. Данная тенденция
в настоящее время стала причиной существенных корректив в базо-
вых документах и образовательных стандартах. Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) О. А. Теплякова
ИНТЕРПРЕТАЦИЯ СОЦИАЛЬНОГО ЗАКАЗА НА
ВОСПИТАНИЕ ДУХОВНО-НРАВСТВЕННОЙ ЛИЧНОСТИ
В ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫХ ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛЬНЫХ СТАНДАРТАХ
НАЧАЛЬНОГО И ОСНОВНОГО ОБЩЕГО ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ1 Значимость государ-
ственной политики в сфере духовно-нравственного воспитания лич-
ности, безусловно, велика, поскольку немаловажно, как будет выгля-
деть духовно-нравственный портрет будущего российского поколения. Воспитание нравственности выходит на уровень государственного за-
каза и становится ключевой социально-значимой компетенцией. Во вновь принятых федеральных государственных образова-
тельных стандартах начального и основного общего образования Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) 72 Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования задача нравственного воспитания буквально проходит «красной
нитью» через все разделы. Она установлена в качестве цели, веду-
щего направления процесса обучения и воспитания и, наконец,
в качестве результата образовательной деятельности. Следует отметить, что новые образовательные стандарты ба-
зируются на классических идеях и продолжают традиции, которые
уже сложились в отечественной школе. Обозначим данные идеи. Идея гуманизма содержит в своей основе понимание смысла
гуманных отношений, ценности человеческой жизни, развитие до-
брожелательности и эмоциональной отзывчивости, сопереживания
другим людям, стремления строить свои отношения с окружающи-
ми и поступать по законам совести, добра и справедливости. Идея гражданственности связана с формированием соци-
альной идентичности, воспитанием чувства гордости за свою Ро-
дину, народ и историю, осознанием ответственности человека за
благосостояние общества, интересом к общественным явлениям,
пониманием важности активной гражданской позиции, стремле-
нием проявлять социальную активность и инициативу. Идея толерантности направлена на привитие культуры ме-
жэтнического общения, уважения к языку, культурным, религиоз-
ным традициям, истории и образу жизни представителей различ-
ных народов. Воспитание в труде основывается на осознании ведущей ро-
ли трудовой деятельности в жизни человека, получении элемен-
тарных представлений об основных профессиях и современном
производстве, формировании уважения к труду и отрицательного
отношения к лени и небрежности в учебе и работе. Отношение к природе как ценности предполагает развитие
интереса к природным явлениям и формам жизни, понимание ак-
тивной роли человека в преобразовании природы, формирование
ценностного отношения к природе и всем формам жизни, приоб-
ретение опыта природоохранительной деятельности. Воспитание через красоту – это формирование эстетических
идеалов, развитие чувства прекрасного, умение видеть красоту
природы, труда и творчества, в целом окружающего мира, приоб-
щение воспитанников к художественно-творческим занятиям, со-
здание условий для творческой самореализации личности. 73 © О. А. Теплякова © О. А. Теплякова Воспитание через социальную деятельность включает ус-
воение в процессе деятельности социальных ролей, приобретение
опыта коллективного труда, овладение различными формами са-
моуправления при создании и поддержке общешкольного уклада. О. А. Теплякова
ИНТЕРПРЕТАЦИЯ СОЦИАЛЬНОГО ЗАКАЗА НА
ВОСПИТАНИЕ ДУХОВНО-НРАВСТВЕННОЙ ЛИЧНОСТИ
В ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫХ ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛЬНЫХ СТАНДАРТАХ
НАЧАЛЬНОГО И ОСНОВНОГО ОБЩЕГО ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ1 Идея сотрудничества зиждется на доброжелательности, до-
верии и внимании к людям, готовности к командной работе, диа-
логу, творческому совместному действию. Идея формирования социальной среды основывается на
взаимодействии школы с различными социальными институтами:
семьей, учреждениями дополнительного образования, обществен-
ными организациями, учреждениями культуры, детско-юношески-
ми объединениями. Идея педагогической поддержки процесса социализации лич-
ности требует разнообразия форм педагогического сопровождения
личности в образовательном пространстве на основе создания тра-
ектории личностного роста обучающихся. Перечисленные идеи в образовательных стандартах второго
поколения получают новое звучание, обусловленное тем, что в них
на первое место выдвигается формирование у личности поликуль-
турности мировосприятия, характер содержания образования ста-
новится метапредметным, обучение строится на принципах поли-
субъектности взаимодействия со средой, универсальности учебных
действий и одновременно многомерности деятельности, в которую
включается личность. В целом это можно обозначить как своего
рода глобализацию воспитания и обучения, суть которой заключа-
ется в тесной, неразделимой взаимозависимости всех сопутствую-
щих развитию личности факторов. Одним из необходимых усло-
вий эффективности и результативности образовательного процес-
са является формирование у учащего целостного восприятии себя
и мира, личной нравственной ответственности за свою судьбу и судь-
бу социума, к которому он принадлежит. К числу принципиальных новшеств в современных образо-
вательных стандартах относится и общая ориентация на про-
блемное обучение. Проблемы, с которыми сталкивается совре-
менный человек, многоплановые – от сугубо индивидуальных до
глобальных, и ни одна из этих проблем, как правило, не решается
сама собой. Поэтому научить умению видеть, правильно оцени- 74 Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования вать различные проблемы и самостоятельно находить способы их
устранения – важнейшая педагогическая задача. Для того чтобы справляться с проблемами и действовать при
этом эффективно и продуктивно, учащийся должен не просто ов-
ладеть знаниями и умениями, а обрести компетенции, которые по-
зволят ему грамотно ставить задачи и находить адекватные пути
решения. В Примерных основных образовательных программах
начального и основного общего образования универсальная духов-
но-нравственная компетенция обозначена формулировкой «стано-
виться лучше» [1, 2]. В стандартах особо акцентируется, что выбор
учащимися способа решения проблем должен осуществляться на
основе понимания объективных процессов и явлений и совершать-
ся с помощью нравственных средств. Отечественная образовательная система призвана формиро-
вать личность, способную добиваться поставленных целей, запла-
нированных результатов. Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) О. А. Теплякова
ИНТЕРПРЕТАЦИЯ СОЦИАЛЬНОГО ЗАКАЗА НА
ВОСПИТАНИЕ ДУХОВНО-НРАВСТВЕННОЙ ЛИЧНОСТИ
В ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫХ ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛЬНЫХ СТАНДАРТАХ
НАЧАЛЬНОГО И ОСНОВНОГО ОБЩЕГО ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ1 Это диктуется требованиями времени, со-
временными ритмами жизни, изменчивыми реалиями сегодняшних
дней. Заканчивая образовательное учреждение, вступая во взрос-
лую жизнь, человек попадает в достаточно жесткие условия кон-
куренции, касающейся прежде всего рынка труда. Целеустремлен-
ность, мобильность в принятии решений и умение достигать наме-
ченного дают возможность подняться на «социальном лифте», мак-
симально реализовать себя, завоевать жизненное пространство. У отечественной школы достаточно большой опыт коллективных
достижений, тема же личностной успешности требует серьезной
методической проработки и грамотного психолого-педагогического
сопровождения. Цели духовно-нравственного развития и воспитания, осуще-
ствляемых при социально-педагогической поддержке обучающих-
ся, на ступени начального общего образования и основного общего
образования идентичны: становление высоконравственного, твор-
ческого, компетентного гражданина России, принимающего судьбу
Отечества как свою личную, осознающего ответственность за на-
стоящее и будущее своей страны, бережно относящегося к духов-
ным и культурным традициям многонационального народа Рос-
сийской Федерации. 75 Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) 75 © О. А. Теплякова © О. А. Теплякова Идентичны и направления деятельности: гражданское, нрав-
ственное, трудовое, экологическое, эстетическое воспитание. Как
видим, данные направления не являются принципиально новыми
для отечественной школы. Они продолжают прочно сложившийся
еще в советский период курс организации образовательного про-
цесса. Отличие от прежней системы в том, что каждое отдельное
учебное учреждение может отдавать приоритет тому или иному
направлению, исходя из собственной общей концепции развития. В общем виде путь становления духовно-нравственной лич-
ности в период обучения в начальной и основной школе выглядит
следующим образом: ● получение представлений о нормах социального поведения
и отношений; ● опыт морально-нравственных переживаний; ● освоение социально приемлемой модели поведения. Данная модель должна складываться благодаря таким меха-
низмам, как продвижение ● от знания и признания прав и свобод человека через соци-
ально значимую деятельность к формированию социальной ответ-
ственности; ● от нравственных переживаний через морально-нравствен-
ный опыт к нравственным убеждениям; ● от воспитания трудолюбия через освоение различных форм
труда к сознательному выбору профессии; ● от восприятия природы как ценности через включение
в природоохранную деятельность к обретению экологической куль-
туры, культуры здорового и безопасного образа жизни; ● от формирования эстетических представлений через раз-
личные виды художественно-творческой самореализации к овла-
дению основами эстетической культуры. Общая миссия школы – дать обучающемуся представление об
общественных духовно-нравственных ценностях и ориентирован-
ных на эти ценности образцах поведения, включая школьника
в приемлемую для его возраста практику социальных отношений. Так, при перемещении со ступени начального образования на сту-
пень основного общего образования должен осуществляться пере-
ход от усвоения социальных нормативов к воспитанию социальной Образование и наука. 2012. О. А. Теплякова
ИНТЕРПРЕТАЦИЯ СОЦИАЛЬНОГО ЗАКАЗА НА
ВОСПИТАНИЕ ДУХОВНО-НРАВСТВЕННОЙ ЛИЧНОСТИ
В ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫХ ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛЬНЫХ СТАНДАРТАХ
НАЧАЛЬНОГО И ОСНОВНОГО ОБЩЕГО ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ1 № 9 (98) 76 Интерпретация социального заказа на воспитание духовно-нравственной личности в
государственных образовательных стандартах начального и основного общего
образования ответственности и стимуляции инициативы, основанной на глубо-
ком знании и понимании социально-культурных процессов, кото-
рые происходят в стране и в мире. ответственности и стимуляции инициативы, основанной на глубо-
ком знании и понимании социально-культурных процессов, кото-
рые происходят в стране и в мире. Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) Литература 1. Примерная основная образовательная программа образо-
вательного учреждения. Начальная школа. 2-е изд., перераб. /
сост. Е. С. Савинов. М., 2010. 2. Примерная основная образовательная программа образо-
вательного учреждения. Основная школа / сост. Е. С. Савинов. М.,
2011. 77 Образование и наука. 2012. № 9 (98) 77
|
https://openalex.org/W2964680331
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc6827534?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
Influence of Manually Adjustable Photovoltaic Array on the Performance of Water Pumping Systems
|
Global challenges
| 2,019
|
cc-by
| 6,210
|
Influence of Manually Adjustable Photovoltaic Array on the
Performance of Water Pumping Systems Vinamrita Singh water pump poses a limitation. Diesel
based water pumps require fuel to be
transported to the location, are noisy and
polluting, and have significant mainte-
nance requirements.[8] Altogether, these
pumping systems are not cost effective. This work presents a theoretical procedure to calculate various parameters
needed for the installation of a photovoltaic water pump (PVWP) system. Spe-
cifically, the monthly optimum tilt angle of PV arrays is calculated, which will
allow larger quantities of water to be pumped each month. For this, a simple
performance optimization procedure is developed using solar radiation data. The investigations are based on the solar radiation data of New Delhi, India. The total amount of water pumped is compared with that by keeping the
solar panels fixed throughout the year. The total amount of water that can
be extracted by using manually adjustable arrays is found to be greater by
3–5%. This may be an alternative to an automatic sun tracker, which is not
only expensive but also requires more space and maintenance. This method
allows for analyzing the performance of low-cost water pumping systems that
may be used for both domestic and irrigation purposes. Photovoltaic water pumping (PVWP)
systems are gaining popularity both in
the developed and developing countries. The developed countries aim to reduce
environmental pollution through the use
of this technology, while the developing
countries need PVWP as solar energy
may be the only available energy in some
underdeveloped places as well as remote
locations.[11] The use of PV based pumps
is also location dependent, as the perfor-
mance of photovoltaic devices is governed
by several factors such as total incident radiation and temper-
ature.[12] The rapid decline in the PV module prices over the
last five years has reduced the overall costs of PVWP system.[13]
Advancement in PVWP systems has resulted in its broad use
from irrigation to domestic use. Furthermore, systems which
are integrated either with batteries or storage tanks, make water
accessible even when sunlight is not available. The initial high-
cost factor associated with installing PVWPs hinders its wide-
spread use; however, these systems are very economical in the
long run as compared to diesel or electricity powered pumps. Full paper Full paper Photovoltaic Water Pump Influence of Manually Adjustable Photovoltaic Array on the
Performance of Water Pumping Systems Other advantages of PVWPs are their low environmental
impact, does not require on-site operator, are simple to operate,
and sustain longer with easy maintenance.[8] Moreover, modern
well-equipped systems come in a variety of designs and assem-
blies, providing a wide range of choices depending upon the
user’s requirements. radiation data. w Delhi, India. eeping the
ter that can
e greater by
which is not
. This method
ng systems that 1. Introduction The increasing energy demand of the world constantly requires
new technology, which is based on renewable energy resources. Out of the various renewable energy resources available, solar
energy is the most promising as the sun gives out an enormous
amount of heat and light. Many solar energy based applications
are available commercially, such as solar cells, solar heaters,
concentrators, distillers, etc.[1–4] These devices have further
been integrated with various appliances to achieve clean energy
driven technology. The photovoltaic powered water pump is
one such application, which has received great attention in the
past decades.[5–7] Water pumping is heavily required for many
purposes throughout the world, for which the conventional
electricity and diesel driven water pumps are dominantly used. However, electricity and diesel based water pumps have several
drawbacks.[8–10] In rural areas, where grid power is not acces-
sible, or power cuts are regular, traditional electricity based The basic components of a PVWP system, shown in Figure 1,
comprise PV modules, motor and pump. Other components
may include ac/dc converter, batteries, and storage tank. The PV
modules are chosen depending upon the power requirement; a
number of solar cells are connected in series and parallel com-
binations in order to provide the necessary voltage and current. The performance of PV devices, and subsequently, the water
pump, depends on the incident radiation. Fixed PV panels are
not able to fully utilize the solar radiation throughout the day. Therefore, automatic sun trackers and maximum power point
trackers (MPPT) may be used in order to increase the output.[14]
However, these significantly add to the cost of PVWP system. The PV array is connected to a motor either directly in case of
dc motors, or through an inverter (dc to ac converter) if an ac
motor is used. Direct coupling mode reduces the cost of the
system. The most cost-effective installation is the one which has © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA,
Weinheim. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License, which permits use, distribution and re-
production in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. DOI: 10.1002/gch2.201900009 © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.global-challenges.com www.global-challenges.com DOI: 10.1002/gch2.201900009 1900009 (1 of 8) © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.advancedsciencenews.com
www.global-ch
Figure 1. Schematic diagram of a solar water pump. Optional components are shown in dashed frames. www.advancedsciencenews.com www.global-challenges.com www.advancedsciencenews.com ematic diagram of a solar water pump. Optional components are shown in dashed frames. Figure 1. Schematic diagram of a solar water pump. Optional components are shown in dashed frames. of pumps used has also been done, which gives a strong insight
into the field of solar powered water systems.[15] a water storage tank. Excess water can be stored for use at night
or when the solar radiation is not sufficient to run the pump. A more expensive alternative to water storage is to connect the
PV arrays with batteries. During times when PV cells are not
working, the batteries provide the electricity to run the motor. Although this option is both expensive and requires mainte-
nance, it is more regulated in terms of the system output.[15] Theoretical studies have also been carried out to determine
the performance of water pumping systems. Gad et al. devel-
oped a program to simulate the functioning of a PVWP.[32]
Several authors have simulated the water pumped in terms of
various parameters such as insolation and individual compo-
nents.[33–36] Due to the high variability and dependency of the
PVWP performance on different parameters, modeling the
behavior of these systems is critical and needs more attention. One of the major challenges in installing PVWPs is that every
site requires different parameters. The reasons attributed to
this are that solar radiation, climate conditions, available space,
and individual requirements differ in every case. Therefore,
case studies have to be performed every time PVWP has to be
installed. Moreover, the preferences regarding the configuration
also change the output delivered by the system. This makes it
difficult to model the PVWP yield theoretically. Many studies
have been carried out on PVWP systems in different locations
of the world. Research has been focused on various aspects of
solar water pump functioning, designs, performance, degrada-
tion, etc.[5] Carr and Pryor studied the efficiency and degradation
of solar panels based on different materials.[16] Chandel et al. demonstrated the long term effect of field exposure on water
pumping system in the Himalayan region of India.[17] Katan et al. DOI: 10.1002/gch2.201900009 studied the effect of using MPPT and sun trackers.[18] Various
researchers analyzed the effect of orientation of PV arrays on
the output.[19–21] The socioeconomical as well as environmental
aspect has also been investigated, supporting the advantages of
using PVWP systems.[22–25] Various techniques for increasing
the efficiency of PVWPs has been highlighted in literature based
on both experimental and theoretical simulations.[26–30] Simple
methods of reducing the PV module temperature can increase
the amount of water pumped.[28,31] Studies based on using
inverters, comparison, and compatibility between different types In the present work, theoretical studies have been carried out to
predict the water pumped through a PVWP system. A simple opti-
mization procedure has been developed using solar radiation data. Optimum tilt angle has been calculated for each month of the year. The effect of manually varying the PV array angle on a monthly
basis has been analyzed, and has been compared with the amount
of water pumped by keeping the solar panels fixed throughout the
year. The method is developed for direct-coupled PV water pumps
and exhibit the performance of low-cost water pumping systems
that may be used for both domestic and irrigation purposes. Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 3. Theoretical Background where HB and HD are direct and diffused solar radiation com-
ponents on a horizontal plane; RB and RD are direct and dif-
fused radiation tilt factors, given by Static PV arrays are mounted facing south with a constant
slope that is equal to the site’s latitude. Although such instal-
lations are convenient in terms of system design and cost,
they result in significant power loss. On the other hand, the
use of automatic tracking system increases power output, but
makes the unit complex and unreliable as well, especially for
domestic use. In order to average out the advantages and dis-
advantages of the above two systems, a manual tracking system
can be constructed in such a way that it needs to be adjusted
only a few times during the year. Such a system gives higher
output as compared to the yearly constant slope system, does
not add appreciable cost, and can be handled by untrained
domestic users. The formulas below describe the methods
utilized for calculating an optimal monthly slope of the PV
array. The method can easily be extended for finding optimum
slopes which can be manually adjusted quarterly, every 15 days,
daily, etc. R
L
h
L
L
h
L
α
δ
α
δ
δ
δ
( )
( )
( )
( )
( )
( )
(
)
(
)
( )
( )
=
−
+
−
+
cos
cos
cos
sin
sin
cos
cos
cos
sin
sin
B
(2)
R
α
=
+
1 cos
2
D
(3) R
L
h
L
L
h
L
α
δ
α
δ
δ
δ
( )
( )
( )
( )
( )
( )
(
)
(
)
( )
( )
=
−
+
−
+
cos
cos
cos
sin
sin
cos
cos
cos
sin
sin
B
(2) (2) R
α
=
+
1 cos
2
D
(3) (3) Here, L is the latitude of site; α is the tilt angle of the PV array;
δ is the solar declination angle; h is solar hour angle. The decli-
nation and solar hour angle can be calculated using Here, L is the latitude of site; α is the tilt angle of the PV array;
δ is the solar declination angle; h is solar hour angle. 2. Site Survey In the present work, the site under investigation is the capital city
of India, i.e., Delhi. India receives a considerable amount of solar
radiation throughout the country, thus making it a wise place to
use solar-powered appliances. The average solar energy distribu-
tion in India is shown in Figure 2. India gets 5000 TWh of solar
insolation every year, with most regions receiving 4–7 kWh m−2
per day.[37] Delhi is one of the hottest regions in India, and receives
an annual average of about 5.20 kWh m−2 per day energy from 1900009 (2 of 8) © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 www.global-challenges.com www.advancedsciencenews.com gure 2 Average solar energy distribution in India [39] Figure 2. Average solar energy distribution in India.[39] the sun.[38] There is abundant use of groundwater for domestic
and agricultural use in Delhi. Considering the large water demand
as well as adequate solar energy available in Delhi, the use of PV
panels to power water pumping systems is a justifiable choice.i ambient temperature, total solar radiation, direct and diffuse
components of solar radiation, respectively, for one year. The
total solar radiation is usually given for a horizontal surface. Therefore, the direct and diffused components are required
in order to calculate the total incident radiation at any tilted
surface. It can be seen from the figures that the maximum
temperature and incident radiation are received for the months
of March to May and September and October. There is a signifi-
cant drop in both parameters during July and August. Since the efficiency of PV arrays depends on the incident
solar radiation and temperature, data taken at regular intervals
is essential for accurate configuration of PVWP systems. The
present work is based on the hourly data given by the National
Renewable Energy Laboratory, USA.[40] Figure 3a–d shows the © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 1900009 (3 of 8) Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 www.advancedsciencenews.com
www.global-challenges.com
Figure 3. a) Ambient temperature, b) total solar radiation, c) direct, and d) diffused components of solar radiation for each hour and day of the
year. www.advancedsciencenews.com Figure 3. a) Ambient temperature, b) total solar radiation, c) direct, and d) diffused components of solar radiation for each hour and day of the
year. 3.1. Total Radiation on Tilted Surface The total radiation on a tilted surface is given by[41] 3. Theoretical Background The decli-
nation and solar hour angle can be calculated using N
δ
(
)
=
+
23.5sin 360
365
284
(4) N
δ
(
)
=
+
23.5sin 360
365
284
(4)
h
t
(
)
=
−
×
°
12
15
(5) (4) h
t
(
)
=
−
×
°
12
15
(5) (5) where N is the number of the days from January 1st and t is the
time in hours. www.global-challenges.com
Figure 4. Daily incident total solar radiation for a yearly constant slope
(αy) and monthly varying slope (αm). www.advancedsciencenews.com I
I
I
L
qV
kT
=
−
−
e
1
0
(6) I
I
I
L
qV
kT
=
−
−
e
1
0
(6) where IL is the photocurrent I0 is the reverse saturation current,
and T is the cell temperature in Kelvin. The open circuit voltage
(VOC) and short circuit current (ISC) are important parameters
which determine the efficiency of solar cells, and can be deter-
mined by setting current and voltage to zero, respectively, in the
above equation. The photocurrent of a solar cell depends upon
the illumination intensity according to where IL is the photocurrent I0 is the reverse saturation current,
and T is the cell temperature in Kelvin. The open circuit voltage
(VOC) and short circuit current (ISC) are important parameters
which determine the efficiency of solar cells, and can be deter-
mined by setting current and voltage to zero, respectively, in the
above equation. The photocurrent of a solar cell depends upon
the illumination intensity according to I
H
H
H
I
H
L
S
L
S
(
)
(
) =
(7) (7) where the subscript “s” denotes the standard conditions of
1000 Wm−2 and 1.5 air mass ratio at 25 °C. The output power
of a photovoltaic cell is calculated by P = FIV; where F is the
fill factor. The maximum power deliverable by a solar cell is
Pm = ImVm. Figure 4. Daily incident total solar radiation for a yearly constant slope
(αy) and monthly varying slope (αm). pumped depends on the amount of solar radiation that falls on
PV array. The surplus water can be stored in water tanks for
use in times when the pump system is not operating. 3.3. Pump Characteristics The following approach has been used to calculate the
optimal monthly slope and hence the Ht. The available hourly
data was summed to obtain the day’s total radiation. This was
further added and divided by the number of days to find the
monthly average radiation in terms of direct and diffused
components. The values of RB and RD were calculated for
α = 0°–90° with a step size of 1°. The values thus obtained
were put in Equation (1) to determine Ht corresponding to
different αs. The monthly optimum slope then corresponds
to the angle at which Ht is maximum. The procedure is
repeated for each month of the year. The theoretically calcu-
lated values of αm are shown in Figure 5 for panels facing in
the south direction. The power consumption of a pump is given by P
nAP
gH
ρ
η
=
=
P
h
p
(8) P
nAP
gH
ρ
η
=
=
P
h
p
(8) where n is the number of cells per meter sq. of PV array; A
is the array area; ρ is the density; g is the acceleration due to
gravity; Hh is the total head; ηp is the pump overall efficiency. The water flow rate can be found as where n is the number of cells per meter sq. of PV array; A
is the array area; ρ is the density; g is the acceleration due to
gravity; Hh is the total head; ηp is the pump overall efficiency. The water flow rate can be found as q
nP
gH
η
ρ
=
p
m
h
(9) q
nP
gH
η
ρ
=
p
m
h (9) After estimating the optimal monthly slope, it is required to
model the output of both the PV arrays and the water pump
in order to determine how much water can be pumped each
month. The same calculations can be made using a yearly The above equations can be used to assemble an efficient
solar water pump system. The detailed calculations and para
meters used will be elaborated in Section 4. Figure 5. Theoretically calculated values of monthly optimum slopes. Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 3.2. Photovoltaic Array Characteristics H
R H
R H
=
+
t
B
B
D
D (1) The current–voltage characteristic of a solar cell is given by 1)
The current–voltage characteristic of a solar cell is given by Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim P
H
=
−
0.23109
5.25472
m The next step is to calculate the amount of water pumped
per unit array area. For this, we make use of Equation (9). The quantity “q” can be averaged over the whole day to obtain
the daily amount of water pumped. The calculations have
been made for n = 60, Hh = 50 m, and ηp = 85%. The pump
can operate only after the solar panels deliver a threshold cur-
rent. Therefore, water flow has to be calculated by averaging
over only the active hours, i.e., during the time the solar
panels are able to run the pump. The active hours will differ
throughout the year, and has to be taken into consideration. Table 2 gives the average values of the time the pump oper-
ates each month based on the minimum incident solar radia-
tion per unit area of the PV array and the average incident In order to understand the importance of adjusting the PV
arrays every month, we need to compare the total amount of
water pumped with that by keeping a constant PV array slope. Increase in the amount of water pumped for 300, 400, and
500 Wm−2 are ≈171, 176, and 239 m3, respectively, which cor-
responds to a percentage increase of 3–5%. There is a reason-
able difference in the amount of water obtained in the two
cases. If we take the average water consumption of a person
in urban India to be 135 L per day, even 171 m3 equates to an
extra 171 000 L per year; this is sufficient for the need of more
than 3.5 persons per day. So, a surplus of water can be extracted
using the same configuration of solar panels without much
labor and added cost. This highlights the importance of manual
tracking system. Thus, it is essential to adjust the slope of the
array in order to gain more value out of the cost invested in a
solar water pump system. 1900009 (6 of 8)
Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009
Table 1. Solar cell parameters for different illumination intensities. 200 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
600 Wm−2
800 Wm−2
1000 Wm−2
ISC [A]
1.59
3.29
4.97
6.58
8.27
VOC [V]
32.84
34.42
35.01
36.05
36.86
F [%]
79.36
77.96
76.11
74.54
74.86 Table 1. Solar cell parameters for different illumination intensities. 4. Results and Discussion Fixed PV array systems are installed facing south with an
optimal yearly angle equal to the site’s latitude. The latitude of
Delhi is L = 28.61°. In order to calculate the daily incident total
solar radiation, Ht, for a fixed slope of αy = L, Equations (1)–(5)
were used. The values of RB and RD were calculated for dif-
ferent values of h and δ from which Ht was obtained. The
daily incident total solar radiation for a yearly constant slope is
shown in Figure 4. Figure 4 also shows the Ht when the PV
array angle is adjusted every month. There is a considerable
difference between the Ht values corresponding to αy and αm,
especially from April to August. Ht is higher when the PV array
slope is varied monthly. This will increase the performance of
the water pump with an insignificant increase in system cost,
and it can be readily adjusted by nontechnical users. The differ-
ence is quite important considering that the quantity of water Figure 5. Theoretically calculated values of monthly optimum slopes. 1900009 (5 of 8)
Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 1900009 (5 of 8) © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 www.advancedsciencenews.com
www.global-challenges.com
Figure 6. a) IV-characteristics of a solar panel at different light intensities, b) straight line fit of maximum power point versus illumination
intensity. www.global-challenges.com www.advancedsciencenews.com Figure 6. a) IV-characteristics of a solar panel at different light intensities, b) straight line fit of maximum power point versus illumination
intensity. radiation. The calculations have been performed for three
different incident radiations, i.e., for more than 300, 400, and
500 Wm−2. Here, the data has been corrected using monthly
tilt angles throughout the calculations, and the active hours
have been calculated on the basis of time during which the
total incident radiation was greater than or equal to 300,
400 and 500 Wm−2. constant slope for comparative analysis. Figure 6a shows the
IV-characteristics of a multicrystalline solar module, which has
60 cells connected in series and parallel combinations. Each
cell area is 243.36 cm2. The IV-characteristics depend on the
illumination intensity as can be seen from the figure. As men-
tioned earlier, the important solar cells parameters are open cir-
cuit voltage, short circuit current and the fill factor. The values
of these parameters at different illumination intensities are
given in Table 1. 4. Results and Discussion constant slope for comparative analysis. Figure 6a shows the
IV-characteristics of a multicrystalline solar module, which has
60 cells connected in series and parallel combinations. Each
cell area is 243.36 cm2. The IV-characteristics depend on the
illumination intensity as can be seen from the figure. As men-
tioned earlier, the important solar cells parameters are open cir-
cuit voltage, short circuit current and the fill factor. The values
of these parameters at different illumination intensities are
given in Table 1. The daily average amount of water pumped for different
incident radiations during each month is given in Table 3. The data is shown for both static inclination and monthly
varying inclination at a minimum intensity of 300, 400, and
500 Wm−2. The maximum water is pumped during March–
April for all incident radiations, while the minimum water is
pumped during July. Thus, we see that the amount of water
pumped not only depends on the solar radiation each month
but is also dependent on the threshold operating radiation that
we set to turn on the machine. A color graph for the amount
of water pumped during active hours every month is shown in
Figure 7a,b. A PV array usually operates at a maximum power point (Pm). The Pm for each curve is also shown in Figure 6a. The relation
between different solar radiation intensity and the maximum
power point can be deduced by the straight line curve fit as
shown in Figure 6b. The following relation has been obtained
for the current data © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim P
H
=
−
0.23109
5.25472
m The above calculations have been performed considering the
specifications of any one type of PV array and pump. However, the
method presented above can be used to analyze the outcome of any
combination of solar panels and pumps with varying efficiencies. www.advancedsciencenews.com
www.global-challenges.com
Table 2. Active hours of the water pump along with average incident radiation. Ht yearly
Ht monthly
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
Δta)
Ha)
Δt
H
Δt
H
Δt
H
Δt
H
Δt
H
Jan
7
5.18
7
5.18
6
5.18
7
5.32
7
5.32
7
5.32
Feb
9
7.02
9
7.02
9
7.02
9
7.11
9
7.11
9
7.11
Mar
9
7.61
9
7.61
9
7.61
9
7.34
9
7.34
9
7.34
Apr
10
7.36
9
7.04
9
7.04
10
7.61
9
7.25
9
7.25
May
10
6.62
9
6.32
8
5.89
10
7.18
9
6.81
8
6.32
Jun
9
5.15
7
4.43
7
4.43
9
5.62
8
5.23
7
4.82
Jul
9
4.35
7
3.72
4
2.34
9
4.69
7
4.01
5
3.03
Aug
9
4.62
7
3.94
6
3.49
9
4.84
7
4.12
6
3.64
Sep
10
6.82
9
6.44
8
5.96
10
6.85
9
6.47
8
5.99
Oct
9
6.86
8
6.54
8
6.54
9
6.87
8
6.56
8
6.56
Nov
8
6.12
8
6.12
7
5.63
8
6.28
8
6.28
8
6.28
Dec
7
6.02
7
6.02
7
6.02
7
6.33
7
6.33
7
6.33
a)Unit of Δt is hours and H is kWh m−2. Table 3. Average quantity of water pumped (in m3) per day at different incident intensities. Ht yearly
Ht monthly
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
Jan
12.07
12.07
10.96
12.43
12.43
12.43
Feb
16.4
16.4
16.4
16.6
16.6
16.6
Mar
17.8
17.8
17.8
17.16
17.16
17.16
Apr
17.17
16.43
16.43
17.76
16.95
16.95
May
15.39
14.71
13.72
16.72
15.89
14.77
Jun
11.89
10.28
10.28
13.04
12.14
11.21
Jul
9.96
8.57
5.42
10.81
9.25
7.02
Aug
10.61
9.09
8.07
11.15
9.52
8.43
Sep
15.86
14.99
13.91
15.94
15.07
13.97
Oct
16.01
15.30
15.30
16.04
15.33
15.33
Nov
14.29
14.29
13.6
14.66
14.66
14.66
Dec
14.10
14.10
14.10
14.84
14.84
14.84
Total
5210.18
4981.12
4719.94
5381.27
5157.42
4959.28 www.global-challenges.com www.advancedsciencenews.com Table 2. Active hours of the water pump along with average incident radiation. Table 2. Active hours of the water pump along with average incident radiation. P
H
=
−
0.23109
5.25472
m Ht yearly
Ht monthly
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
Δta)
Ha)
Δt
H
Δt
H
Δt
H
Δt
H
Δt
H
Jan
7
5.18
7
5.18
6
5.18
7
5.32
7
5.32
7
5.32
Feb
9
7.02
9
7.02
9
7.02
9
7.11
9
7.11
9
7.11
Mar
9
7.61
9
7.61
9
7.61
9
7.34
9
7.34
9
7.34
Apr
10
7.36
9
7.04
9
7.04
10
7.61
9
7.25
9
7.25
May
10
6.62
9
6.32
8
5.89
10
7.18
9
6.81
8
6.32
Jun
9
5.15
7
4.43
7
4.43
9
5.62
8
5.23
7
4.82
Jul
9
4.35
7
3.72
4
2.34
9
4.69
7
4.01
5
3.03
Aug
9
4.62
7
3.94
6
3.49
9
4.84
7
4.12
6
3.64
Sep
10
6.82
9
6.44
8
5.96
10
6.85
9
6.47
8
5.99
Oct
9
6.86
8
6.54
8
6.54
9
6.87
8
6.56
8
6.56
Nov
8
6.12
8
6.12
7
5.63
8
6.28
8
6.28
8
6.28
Dec
7
6.02
7
6.02
7
6.02
7
6.33
7
6.33
7
6.33
a)U i
f Δ i h
d H i kWh
2 1900009 (7 of 8)
© 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009
Table 3. Average quantity of water pumped (in m3) per day at different incident intensities. Ht yearly
Ht monthly
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
Jan
12.07
12.07
10.96
12.43
12.43
12.43
Feb
16.4
16.4
16.4
16.6
16.6
16.6
Mar
17.8
17.8
17.8
17.16
17.16
17.16
Apr
17.17
16.43
16.43
17.76
16.95
16.95
May
15.39
14.71
13.72
16.72
15.89
14.77
Jun
11.89
10.28
10.28
13.04
12.14
11.21
Jul
9.96
8.57
5.42
10.81
9.25
7.02
Aug
10.61
9.09
8.07
11.15
9.52
8.43
Sep
15.86
14.99
13.91
15.94
15.07
13.97
Oct
16.01
15.30
15.30
16.04
15.33
15.33
Nov
14.29
14.29
13.6
14.66
14.66
14.66
Dec
14.10
14.10
14.10
14.84
14.84
14.84
Total
5210.18
4981.12
4719.94
5381.27
5157.42
4959.28
Figure 7. Amount of water pumped (in m3) during active hours every month for a) constant slope and b) for monthly varying slope. Table 3. Average quantity of water pumped (in m3) per day at different incident intensities. Table 3. Average quantity of water pumped (in m3) per day at different incident intensities. 1900009 (7 of 8)
© 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Acknowledgements [21] R. Wagdy, M. A. Nourb, J. Power Sources 1994, 50, l. [22] I. Odeh, Y. G. Yohanis, B. Norton, Sol. Energy 2006, 80, 850. The author wishes to thank Ambedkar Institute of Advanced
Communication Technologies & Research for its support and
encouragement. [23] M. Jamil, S. A. Ahmed, M. Rizwan, Am. J. Electr. Power Energy Syst. 2012, 1, 1. [24] A. Hamidat, Renewable Energy 1999, 18, 383. [25] K. Meah, S. Fletcher, S. Ula, Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev. 2008,
12, 472. 5. Conclusion [10] K. Meah, S. Ula, S. Barrett, Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev. 2008,
12, 1162. Solar-energy-based water pumps are environmentally friendly
and cost-effective in the long run. Therefore, attempts to
understand its performance have been made in the present
work. The investigations are based on the solar radiation data
of New Delhi, India. An alternative to an automatic sun tracker
has been presented, which only requires adjusting a solar
panel monthly. The total amount of water that can be extracted
by using a fixed array as well as the manually adjustable array
has been compared, and it is found that the latter method
increases the water quantity obtained by 3–5%. Thus, it is rec-
ommended that such provision be made available to the buyers
so that they can get the maximum benefit of their product. [11] Z. A. Firatoglu, B. Yesilata, Sol. Energy 2004, 77, 81. [12] A. E. Ghitas, NRIAG J. Astron. Geophys. 2012, 1, 165. [13] R. Foster, A. Cota, Energy Procedia 2014, 57, 1431. [14] N. Onat, Int. J. Photoenergy 2010, 2010, 11. [15] M. Abu-Aligah, Jordan J. Mech. Ind. Eng. 2011, 5, 273 [16] A. J. Carr, T. L. Pryor, Sol. Energy 2004, 76, 285. [17] S. S. Chandel, M. N. Naik, V. Sharma, R. Chandel, Renewable Energy
2015, 78, 193. [18] R. E. Katan, V. G. Agelidis, C. V. Nayar, in Proc. of the 1996 IEEE
Int. Conf. on Power Electronics, Drives, and Energy Systems for Indus-
trial Growth (PEDES) (Eds: S. S. Murthy, D. Divan, S. R. Doradla,
B. V. Murty, S. Roy), IEEE, New Delhi, India 1996, p. 81. [19] A. Mokeddem, A. Midoun, D. Kadri, H. Said, R. A. Iftikhar, Energy
Convers. Manage. 2011, 52, 3089. [20] K. Mohanlal, J. C. Joshi, D. P. Kothari, IEEE Trans. Power Delivery
2004, 19, 613. Conflict of Interest [26] I. Odeh, Y. G. Yohanis, B. Norton, Sol. Energy 2006, 80, 51. The author declares no conflict of interest. [27] M. Ziyad M, F. Dagher, IEEE Trans. Power Appar. Syst. 1990, 5, 4. [28] M. Abdolzadeh, M. Ameri, M. A. Mehrabian, Energy Sources, Part A
2011, 33, 1546. [29] K. Azadeh, Renewable Energy 2010, 35, 1098. www.global-challenges.com www.global-challenges.com [6] A. Ali, D. B. Rahut, B. Behera, Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev. 2016, 54, 48. The water needs are especially different for different purposes, so
accordingly, the number of solar cells, battery backup and/or water
storage tank can be set up to meet the individual demand. [7] M. Benghanem, K. O. Daffallah, S. N. Alamri, A. A. Joraid, Energy
Convers. Manage. 2014, 77, 334. [8] B. Eker, J. Sci. 2005, 3, 7. [9] D. Short, P. Thompson, Sol. Energy 2003, 75, 1. [5] S. S. Chandel, M. N. Naik, R. Chandel, Renewable Sustainable Energy
Rev. 2015, 49, 1084. [1] J. Khana, M. H. Arsalan, Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev. 2016, 55,
414. [2] V. Singh, S. Arora, P. Kumar, P. K. Bhatnagar, M. Arora,
R. P. Tandon, Phys. Scr. 2011, 84, 065803. [4] M. T. Chaichan, H. A. Kazem, Case Stud. Therm. Eng. 2015, 5, 151. [3] K. Rajarajeswari, A. Sreekumar, Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev.
2016, 57, 704. P
H
=
−
0.23109
5.25472
m Ht yearly
Ht monthly
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
Jan
12.07
12.07
10.96
12.43
12.43
12.43
Feb
16.4
16.4
16.4
16.6
16.6
16.6
Mar
17.8
17.8
17.8
17.16
17.16
17.16
Apr
17.17
16.43
16.43
17.76
16.95
16.95
May
15.39
14.71
13.72
16.72
15.89
14.77
Jun
11.89
10.28
10.28
13.04
12.14
11.21
Jul
9.96
8.57
5.42
10.81
9.25
7.02
Aug
10.61
9.09
8.07
11.15
9.52
8.43
Sep
15.86
14.99
13.91
15.94
15.07
13.97
Oct
16.01
15.30
15.30
16.04
15.33
15.33
Nov
14.29
14.29
13.6
14.66
14.66
14.66
Dec
14.10
14.10
14.10
14.84
14.84
14.84
Total
5210.18
4981.12
4719.94
5381.27
5157.42
4959.28
Figure 7. Amount of water pumped (in m3) during active hours every month for a) constant slope and b) for monthly varying slope. Table 3. Average quantity of water pumped (in m ) per day at different incident intensities. Ht yearly
Ht monthly
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
300 Wm−2
400 Wm−2
500 Wm−2
Jan
12.07
12.07
10.96
12.43
12.43
12.43
Feb
16.4
16.4
16.4
16.6
16.6
16.6
Mar
17.8
17.8
17.8
17.16
17.16
17.16
Apr
17.17
16.43
16.43
17.76
16.95
16.95
May
15.39
14.71
13.72
16.72
15.89
14.77
Jun
11.89
10.28
10.28
13.04
12.14
11.21
Jul
9.96
8.57
5.42
10.81
9.25
7.02
Aug
10.61
9.09
8.07
11.15
9.52
8.43
Sep
15.86
14.99
13.91
15.94
15.07
13.97
Oct
16.01
15.30
15.30
16.04
15.33
15.33
Nov
14.29
14.29
13.6
14.66
14.66
14.66
Dec
14.10
14.10
14.10
14.84
14.84
14.84
Total
5210.18
4981.12
4719.94
5381.27
5157.42
4959.28 Figure 7. Amount of water pumped (in m3) during active hours every month for a) constant slope and b) for monthly varying slope. Figure 7. Amount of water pumped (in m3) during active hours every month for a) constant slope and b) for monthly varying slope. © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim [1] J. Khana, M. H. Arsalan, Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev. 2016, 55,
414.
[2] V. Singh, S. Arora, P. Kumar, P. K. Bhatnagar, M. Arora,
R. P. Tandon, Phys. Scr. 2011, 84, 065803.
[3] K. Rajarajeswari, A. Sreekumar, Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev.
2016, 57, 704.
[4] M. T. Chaichan, H. A. Kazem, Case Stud. Therm. Eng. 2015, 5, 151.
[5] S. S. Chandel, M. N. Naik, R. Chandel, Renewable Sustainable Energy
Rev. 2015, 49, 1084. Keywords [30] M. Eduard, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl. 1997, 3, 714. 31] M. Abdolzadeh, M. Ameri, Renewable Energy 2009, 34, 9 photovoltaics, solar energy, solar water pumps, tilt angle [32] H. E. Gad, in Proc. of the Thirteenth Int. Water Technology Conf.,
Hurghada, Egypt 2009, p. 739. Received: January 31, 2019 [33] F. Loxsom, P. D. Veroj, Sol. Energy 1994, 52, 215. Revised: June 19, 2019 [34] B. Bouzidi, M. Haddadi, O. Belmokhtar, Renewable Sustainable
Energy Rev.. 2009, 13, 879. Published online: August 7, 2019 [35] A. Hadj Arab, F. Chenlo, K. Mukadam, J. L. Balenzategui, Renewable
Energy 1999, 18, 191. [36] A. A. Ghoneim, Energy Convers. Manage. 2006, 47, 1449. [37] MNRE, India, http://mnre.gov.in/schemes/grid-connected/solar/
(accessed: October 2018). [2] V. Singh, S. Arora, P. Kumar, P. K. Bhatnagar, M. Arora,
R. P. Tandon, Phys. Scr. 2011, 84, 065803. [38] Synergyenviron, http://www.synergyenviron.com/ (accessed: October
2018). [3] K. Rajarajeswari, A. Sreekumar, Renewable Sustainable Energy Rev. 2016, 57, 704. ] MNRE, India, http://mnre.gov.in/ (accessed: October 201 [4] M. T. Chaichan, H. A. Kazem, Case Stud. Therm. Eng. 2015, 5, 151. [40] NREL, USA, http://www.nrel.gov/rredc/solar_data.html (accessed:
October 2018). [5] S. S. Chandel, M. N. Naik, R. Chandel, Renewable Sustainable Energy
Rev. 2015, 49, 1084. [41] J. E. Hay, Sol. Energy 1979, 23, 301. 1900009 (8 of 8)
Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009 1900009 (8 of 8) © 2019 The Authors. Published by WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Global Challenges 2019, 3, 1900009
|
https://openalex.org/W2977123687
|
https://cfmetrologie.edpsciences.org/articles/metrology/pdf/2019/01/metrology_cim2019_20003.pdf
|
English
| null |
Influence of storage time of pulp and paper industry wastewaters in AOX determination
| null | 2,019
|
cc-by
| 3,600
|
Influence of storage time of pulp and paper
industry wastewaters in AOX determination Micaela A. R. Soares1,*, Manuela Marques1, and Maria Teresa Rodrigues1 AIZ – Instituto de Investigação da Floresta e Papel, Rua José Estevão, 3800-783 Aveiro, Portugal Abstract. The feasibility of storing wastewater samples from pulp and
paper industry during more than 5 days (time recommend by ISO 5667-
3:2018) for AOX determination was addresses in this study. Samples were
collected before and after the aerobic biological treatment of a Portuguese
industry. Experimental protocol included AOX measurements at days 4, 5,
6, 8, 11, 13, 15, 18 and 20 after sampling. Results obtained indicate that
storage time is not matrix-dependent and it can be extended up to 20 days,
which clearly improves management of laboratory activities concerning
AOX determination. * Corresponding author: micaela.soares@thenavigatorcompany.com © The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). 1 Introduction Adsorbable organically bound halogens (AOX) constitute a group of organic compounds
containing chlorine, bromine and iodine that are adsorbable by activated carbon. These
substances may pose a potential threat to the environment due to their propensity to bio-
accumulate, carcinogenicity or chronic toxicity [1–3]. Anthropogenic activities are the main source of AOX in the environment as a result of
several industrial process. For example, in water treatment industry, halogen-based oxidants
used for disinfection can react with naturally occurring organic matter, thus leading to the
formation of organohalogen by-products [4]. In pulp and paper production (P&P), AOX
formation is a side-effect of pulp bleaching as chlorine based oxidizing agents react with
residual lignin from wood fibers [5]. Analytical measure of AOX consists in the determination of organically bound chlorine,
bromine and iodine (expressed as chloride) adsorbable on activated carbon. ISO 9562:2004
is an international standard that describes the analytic method for AOX quantification in
liquid matrices, which comprises i) adsorption of organic compounds onto activated carbon,
ii) organic halides displacement, iii) combustion of activated carbon in oxygen stream and
iv) hydrogen halides absorption in an acceptor solution followed by microcoulometry [6]. Analytical measure of AOX consists in the determination of organically bound chlorine,
bromine and iodine (expressed as chloride) adsorbable on activated carbon. ISO 9562:2004
is an international standard that describes the analytic method for AOX quantification in
liquid matrices, which comprises i) adsorption of organic compounds onto activated carbon,
ii) organic halides displacement, iii) combustion of activated carbon in oxygen stream and
iv) hydrogen halides absorption in an acceptor solution followed by microcoulometry [6]. Sample handling, preservation and storage are critical points in AOX determination to
retard chemical and biological reactions, which unavoidably evolved after sampling from
source [7]. In fact, sample preservation for AOX determinations depend upon three aspects:
i) pH adjustment, ii) microbial inhibition and iii) suppress residual oxidant activity. Sample pH can affect hydrolysis reaction rate of AOX compounds depending on the
functional groups present, number and type of halogens. If hydrolysis reactions occur )
g
p
,
)
yg
iv) hydrogen halides absorption in an acceptor solution followed by microcoulometry [6]. Sample handling, preservation and storage are critical points in AOX determination to
retard chemical and biological reactions, which unavoidably evolved after sampling from
source [7]. 19th International Congress of Metrology, 20003 (2019) 19th International Congress of Metrology, 20003 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/metrology/201920003 1 Introduction In fact, sample preservation for AOX determinations depend upon three aspects:
i) pH adjustment, ii) microbial inhibition and iii) suppress residual oxidant activity. Sample pH can affect hydrolysis reaction rate of AOX compounds depending on the
functional groups present number and type of halogens If hydrolysis reactions occur Sample handling, preservation and storage are critical points in AOX determination to
retard chemical and biological reactions, which unavoidably evolved after sampling from
source [7]. In fact, sample preservation for AOX determinations depend upon three aspects:
i) pH adjustment, ii) microbial inhibition and iii) suppress residual oxidant activity. Sample pH can affect hydrolysis reaction rate of AOX compounds depending on the
functional groups present, number and type of halogens. If hydrolysis reactions occur 19th International Congress of Metrology, 20003 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/metrology/201920003 organic halides can be loss and thus AOX levels be underestimated, thus acidification until
pH<2 is recommended [6]. Microbial activity may enhance degradation of organohalogen
compounds, therefore the imposition of pH level that inhibit bacterial growth are usually
endorsed [6]. Residual oxidant presence in samples may enhanced formation of AOX
during holding time between sampling and analysis; thus quenching agent like NaSO3 are
usually added to neutralize oxidant activity after sample collection [6]. organic halides can be loss and thus AOX levels be underestimated, thus acidification until
pH<2 is recommended [6]. Microbial activity may enhance degradation of organohalogen
compounds, therefore the imposition of pH level that inhibit bacterial growth are usually
endorsed [6]. Residual oxidant presence in samples may enhanced formation of AOX
during holding time between sampling and analysis; thus quenching agent like NaSO3 are
usually added to neutralize oxidant activity after sample collection [6]. Despite the importance of sample storage, to the authors´ best knowledge the influence of
time storage of liquid matrices is scarcely addressed in literature. Preservation and handling
of water samples as established in ISO 5667-3:2018 [8] indicates 5 days as a best practice
(not validated) for AOX sample storage, however this standard is not referred by [6]. Additionally [6] gives no information in what concerns sample storage time, whenever
analysis is not possible right after sampling. This work aims to examine the viability of storing wastewater samples from pulp and paper
industry for more than 5 days (recommend by [8] for AOX determination. 1 Introduction In addition, this
study also focused on establishing a model that includes storage time to assess impact on
the overall management of laboratory activities concerning AOX determination. 2.2 AOX determination AOX determinations were performed following the shaking procedure described in [6]. Briefly, samples were shaken for 1 hour in the presence of sodium nitrate and active
charcoal; after adsorption, suspension was filtered and the mineral halides were shifted by
rinsing the filter and the charcoal with a diluted acidified sodium nitrate solution; filter and
charcoal residue were then incinerated in a AOX analyser (multi X® 2500 - Analytik Jena
AG) at 1050ºC in the presence of a O2 gas flow; hydrogen halides produced were measured
by microcoulometry. Quality control scheme for each day of analysis included the
parameters listed in Table 1. Previous validation studies lead to the method characteristics
presented in Table 2. In addition the statement on the validity of the method, detailing its
fitness for the intended use is also presented in the referred table. 2.1 Sampling and storage The samples used were collected at two points of a wastewater treatment process of a
Portuguese P&P manufacturer: before (EETS) and after (ESTS) the aerobic biological
treatment. After sampling 5 liters at each point (day 0), samples were immediately checked
for the presence of oxidizing agents as described in [6], preserved to pH<2 with nitric acid,
and thus transported to laboratory in cooling conditions. Then, each sample was divided in
ten portions, assuring homogeneity conditions, and analysed in triplicate (day 0). Subsequent triplicate measurements were carried out at days 4, 5, 6, 8, 11, 13, 15, 18 and
20 after sampling. Until analysis day, samples were maintained between 0 to 4ºC in high
density polyethylene containers. 2.3 Calculations The preservation time was considered to have been exceeded, according to the following
condition: ∆
∆𝑚𝑎𝑥> 1.0
(1) ∆
∆𝑚𝑎𝑥> 1.0 (1) 2 19th International Congress of Metrology, 20003 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/metrology/201920003 Where: is the difference between Xi (mean of the triplicate analysis in each day after sampling)
and X0 (triplicate analysis in sampling day). max is the maximum allowed difference between Xi and X0 and it represents the
measurement uncertainty associated to X0. Table 1. Quality control scheme established for routine analysis of AOX in wastewaters. Description
Nº
replicates
Frequency
Acceptance criteria
Titration
cell
Verification of factor a [6]
2
Each day
of analysis
0.97-1.03
Blank
sample
Same procedure as sample, but
with 100 ml of diluted HNO3
instead of sample
2
Each day
of analysis
|Replicate 1-Replicate 2|1.2
g/l
Sample
Replicates
3
Each
sample
analysed
Relative range 6.5%
Daily
Check
standards
Three standards:
1) 25g/l (LOQ); 2) 100 g/l; 3)
250 g/l
Standards prepared with 4-
chlorophenol or 2-chlorobenzoic
acid
2
Each day
of analysis
Acceptance criteria: 10% from
nominal value
Relative range:
1) 9.0%; 2) ) 7.0%; 3) )
1.8%. 1. Quality control scheme established for routine analysis of AOX in wastewaters. 2.4 Management of laboratory activities according to sample storage time for
AOX determination 2.4 Management of laboratory activities according to sample storage time for
AOX determination For evaluating the sample storage time in the laboratory capacity for processing AOX
determination, the following variables were established: Neq
Number of equipments available for AOX analysis (without auto-
sampler)
tprep
Time for sample and standard preparation, in hours
tads
Time for sample and standards adsorption by activated charcoal,
in hours
Nrep
Number of replicas for blanks, standards and samples analysis
tana
Time for replica analysis in AOX equipment, in hours
tQC
Time for daily quality control check, in hours
tava
Daily time available for analysis
ni
Time between sampling and analysis, in days
tpreserv
Maximum preservation time, in days
On a daily basis, the lab processing capacity for AOx determination is given by: tana
Time for replica analysis in AOX equipment, in hours tQC
Time for daily quality control check, in hours On a daily basis, the lab processing capacity for AOx determination is given by: 𝑁𝑠𝑎𝑚𝑝𝑙𝑒=
𝑁𝑒𝑞×[𝑡𝑎𝑣𝑎−(𝑡𝑄𝐶+𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑎×𝑁𝑟𝑒𝑝+𝑡𝑎𝑑𝑠+𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑝)]
𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑎×𝑁𝑟𝑒𝑝
(2) 𝑁𝑠𝑎𝑚𝑝𝑙𝑒=
𝑁𝑒𝑞×[𝑡𝑎𝑣𝑎−(𝑡𝑄𝐶+𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑎×𝑁𝑟𝑒𝑝+𝑡𝑎𝑑𝑠+𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑝)]
𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑎×𝑁𝑟𝑒𝑝
(2) 𝑁𝑠𝑎𝑚𝑝𝑙𝑒=
𝑁𝑒𝑞×[𝑡𝑎𝑣𝑎−(𝑡𝑄𝐶+𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑎×𝑁𝑟𝑒𝑝+𝑡𝑎𝑑𝑠+𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑝)]
𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑎×𝑁𝑟𝑒𝑝
(2) (2) Additionally, a number of samples able to be processed within the admissible storage time,
Nadm is given by: Additionally, a number of samples able to be processed within the admissible storage tim 𝑁𝑎𝑑𝑚= 𝑁𝑠𝑎𝑚𝑝𝑙𝑒(𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑒𝑟𝑣−𝑛𝑖)
(3) (3) 3 19th International Congress of Metrology, 20003 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/metrology/201920003 For comparison of the gain associated to the increases of tpreserv, the following parameter
was evaluated: For comparison of the gain associated to the increases of tpreserv, the following parameter
was evaluated:
𝐴𝑛𝑎𝑙𝑦𝑡𝑖𝑐 𝑝𝑟𝑜𝑐𝑒𝑠𝑠 𝑔𝑎𝑖𝑛=
𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑒𝑟𝑣_1−𝑛𝑖
𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑒𝑟𝑣_2− 𝑛𝑖
(4)
Table 2. Statement on the validity of the AOX method according to [6], detailing its fitness for the
intended use
Validation
parameter
Method validation in Lab
ISO 9562:2004 requirements [6]
Repeatability
Untreated
wastewater:
[AOX]=79
gCl/l;
CVr=3.2%; lim r=6.9 gCl/l
Treated
wastewater:
[AOX]=180
gCl/l;
CVr=2.3%; lim r=12 gCl/l
Standards:
[AOX]=25 gCl/l; CVr=3.4%; lim r=2.3 gCl/l
[AOX]=100 gCl/l; CVr=2.3% gCl/l; lim r=6.5
gCl/l
[AOX]=250 gCl/l; CVr=0.7%; lim r=4.6 gCl/l
CVr=5.7% (standard 100 g/l - p-
clorofenol); CVr=4.4% (sample 195
gCl/l)
Reproductibility
CVR=8.97%
CVR=13.0% (standard100 g/l);
CVR=9.82% (sample 195 gCl/l)
Participations in
interlaboratory
comparisons
17
participations;
average
9
participants;
measuring range: 2.63 to 9.06 mgCl/l; -0.87<Z-
score<1.61. Drms. rel (EIL)=4.95%
Not mentioned
Measurement
uncertainty1
15%
Not mentioned, but results must be
presented with two significant figures. 1-
The measurement uncertainty, does not include sampling, is expressed as the expanded relative uncertainty, which is
based on the combined relative standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor k = 2, which, for a normal
distribution, corresponds to a confidence level of approximately 95%. Calculation method used accordingly to [9].
2-
Completeness of the total adsorption was verified by using 2 different test sample volumes and/or dilution steps with
the same active charcoal quantity;
3-
Analysis of blank sample and at least five samples within working range with further comparison of the measured
value and nominal value (recovery function); 3.1 Effect of storage time in AOX determination Figure 1 depicts the effect of storage time in AOX determination for P&P wastewaters. Fig. 1. Effect of storage time in preservation of P&P wastewaters: a) EETS b) ESTS. Fig. 1. Effect of storage time in preservation of P&P wastewaters: a) EETS b) ESTS. Results obtained clearly show that for P&P wastewaters before and after biological
treatment is possible to extend sample preservation between 0 to 4ºC up to 20 days after
sampling, without compromising the test specimen integrity for AOX quantification. Despite storage time is considered a critical aspect to retard chemical and biological
reactions, the preservation conditions imposed in this study to the samples after sampling
(pH<2 and inhibition of active chlorine) proved to be adequate. It must be highlighted that AOX is a lumped parameter [10] and the results obtained in this
study indicate that no relevant loss of organic halides occur or that formation of AOX is
prevented by neutralization of the residual oxidant present. In addition, storage time was
not matrix-dependent. Nevertheless, this behaviour can be dependent on the halogen type,
since according to [11] adsorbable organic chlorine is more stable than adsorbable organic
bromine or iodine. Thus maximum storage time cannot be extrapolated to other wastewater
proveniences since individual circumstances of the sample matrix like functional groups
present, number and type of halogens presents may condition sample storage requirements,
and should be individually investigated. 𝑁𝑠𝑎𝑚𝑝𝑙𝑒=
𝑁𝑒𝑞×[𝑡𝑎𝑣𝑎−(𝑡𝑄𝐶+𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑎×𝑁𝑟𝑒𝑝+𝑡𝑎𝑑𝑠+𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑝)]
𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑎×𝑁𝑟𝑒𝑝
(2) Recovery
Recovery range : 92 to 110 % (n=8)
Average Recovery: 101.8% sd=6.2%
Not mentioned
Completeness
of
the
total
adsorption2
Untreated wastewater: relative range=0.7-4.6%
(SD= 1.6%), n=8
Treated wastewater: relative range=0.1 a 4.9%
(SD=2%) , n=5
[AOX]<100g/l: absolute range 10
g/l
[AOX]100 g/l: relative range 10%
Initial
check
standards3
Correlation coefficient: 0.9993 a 1.0000 (n=6)
Slope: 1.003 a 1.028 (n=6)
Recover function:
Correlation coefficient 0.999
Slope: 0.95 to 1.05
Statement
on
the validity of
the method
From the results obtained, the Laboratory complies with the statistical performance
characteristics of the Test Standard, namely:
1) CVr lower than the one indicated in [6]
2) CVR of the laboratory lower than CVR present in [6]
3) Equipment stability over time was ensured by:
3.1) measured value vs nominal value of the standards in the working range (correlation
coefficient0.999, slope within the requirements of [6])
3.2) Daily verification of titration cell within limits (0.97 to 1.03) [6]
3.3) daily check of the control standard (100 g Cl / l) within the criteria (target deviation
of 0.8% that is below the limit of the 10% [6])
3.4) compliance with the criteria for complete adsorption with active carbon. 4) The measurement uncertainty allows to present the results with two significant figures, as
required by [6]
1-
The measurement uncertainty, does not include sampling, is expressed as the expanded relative uncertainty, which is
based on the combined relative standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor k = 2, which, for a normal
distribution, corresponds to a confidence level of approximately 95%. Calculation method used accordingly to [9]. 2-
Completeness of the total adsorption was verified by using 2 different test sample volumes and/or dilution steps with
the same active charcoal quantity; 𝐴𝑛𝑎𝑙𝑦𝑡𝑖𝑐 𝑝𝑟𝑜𝑐𝑒𝑠𝑠 𝑔𝑎𝑖𝑛=
𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑒𝑟𝑣_1−𝑛𝑖
𝑡𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑒𝑟𝑣_2− 𝑛𝑖
(4) (4) 4 https://doi.org/10.1051/metrology/201920003 19th International Congress of Metrology, 20003 (2019) 3.2 Effect of storage time in managing samples analysis for AOX
determination Variable
Definition
Value
Neq
Number of equipments available for AOX analysis (without auto-
sampler)
1
tprep
Time for sample and standard preparation, in hours
1
tads
Time for sample and standards adsorption by activated charcoal, in hours
1
Nrep
Number of replicas for blanks, standards and samples analysis
2
tana
Time for replica analysis in AOX equipment, in hours
0.25
tQC
Time for daily quality control check, in hours
1.5
tava
Daily time available for analysis
8
tpreserv
Maximum preservation time, in days
5 or 20
Nsample
Maximum daily sample processing (from eq. 2)
8 Figure 2 presents the gain associated to the increase of tpreserv from 5 to 20 days. Figure 2 presents the gain associated to the increase of tpreserv from 5 to 20 days. Fig. 2. Analytic process gain due when sample storage time is extended from 5 to 20 days. Fig. 2. Analytic process gain due when sample storage time is extended from 5 to 20 days. The gain for the scenario where the sample is analysed in the sampling day (day 0) is 4,
meaning that the lab could receive 160 and 40 samples when the time preservation is 20
and 5 days respectively, and this represents a good gain. Nevertheless, when there is a delay
between sampling and analysis, which is the typical scenario, the gain increases
exponentially reaching the value 16 when that delay is 4 days. In this situation, the lab
could only process 8 samples with a 5 days preservation time while the extension to a 20
days period for storage allowed processing 128 samples more. This gain is an outcome once
it allows the lab to fulfil the ISO 9562 requirements avoiding thereby method deviations. 3.2 Effect of storage time in managing samples analysis for AOX
determination The compliance of storage time for AOX determination may be demanding to a laboratory
and it depending on factors like i) number of available equipment, ii) time of measurement,
iii) requirements of method quality control, iv) number of incoming samples amongst
others. In this study, the scenario described in Table 3 was considered for evaluating the gain
obtained in the analytic process due to the increase in the maximum allowed sample
preservation time for AOX determination. 5 5 https://doi.org/10.1051/metrology/201920003 19th International Congress of Metrology, 20003 (2019) Table 3. Variable definition for the scenario evaluated. Variable
Definition
Value
Neq
Number of equipments available for AOX analysis (without auto-
sampler)
1
tprep
Time for sample and standard preparation, in hours
1
tads
Time for sample and standards adsorption by activated charcoal, in hours
1
Nrep
Number of replicas for blanks, standards and samples analysis
2
tana
Time for replica analysis in AOX equipment, in hours
0.25
tQC
Time for daily quality control check, in hours
1.5
tava
Daily time available for analysis
8
tpreserv
Maximum preservation time, in days
5 or 20
Nsample
Maximum daily sample processing (from eq. 2)
8
Figure 2 presents the gain associated to the increase of tpreserv from 5 to 20 days. Fig. 2. Analytic process gain due when sample storage time is extended from 5 to 20 days. Table 3. Variable definition for the scenario evaluated. Variable
Definition
Value
Neq
Number of equipments available for AOX analysis (without auto-
sampler)
1
tprep
Time for sample and standard preparation, in hours
1
tads
Time for sample and standards adsorption by activated charcoal, in hours
1
Nrep
Number of replicas for blanks, standards and samples analysis
2
tana
Time for replica analysis in AOX equipment, in hours
0.25
tQC
Time for daily quality control check, in hours
1.5
tava
Daily time available for analysis
8
tpreserv
Maximum preservation time, in days
5 or 20
Nsample
Maximum daily sample processing (from eq. 2)
8 Table 3. Variable definition for the scenario evaluated. 4 Conclusions Sample time storage for AOX determination in wastewater from P&P industry is of critical
importance to assure that chemical and biological reactions are hindered after sampling. On
the other hand, sample storage is an issue with relevant impact in managing laboratory
activities associated to AOX determination. The results obtained in this study show that extension of the preservation time up to 20 days
is feasible for samples collected before and after biological wastewater treatment in a P&P 6 6 6 19th International Congress of Metrology, 20003 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/metrology/201920003 industry. In addition, this finding clearly improves management of laboratory activities
concerning AOX determination, once it avoids method deviations by a factor of 16. industry. In addition, this finding clearly improves management of laboratory activities
concerning AOX determination, once it avoids method deviations by a factor of 16. [11]
G Hua, D A Reckhow, J. Am. Water Works Assoc. 104 (2012) References [1]
M Zhang, A Buekens, X Li, J. Hazard. Mater. 304 (2016). [2]
A Kinani, S Kinani, S Bouchonnet, TrAC - Trends Anal. Chem. 85 (2016)
[3]
Y Xie, L Chen, R Liu, J Tian, Bioresour. Technol. 265 (2018). [4]
A Kinani, H Salhi, S Bouchonnet, S Kinani J. Chromatogr. A 1539 (2018). [5]
F Torrades, E Cecilia, Analyst 126 (2001). [6]
International Organization for Standardization, ISO 9562:2004-Water quality—
Determination of adsorbable organically bound halogens (AOX) (2004). [7]
A Kinani, S Kinani, B Richard, M Lorthioy, S Bouchonnet TrAC - Trends Anal. Chem. 85 (2016). [8]
International Organization for Standardization, ISO 5667-3:2018 - Water quality -
Sampling -- Part 3: Preservation and handling of water samples (2018). [9]
International Organization for Standardization, ISO 11352:2012- Water quality --
Estimation of measurement uncertainty based on validation and quality control dat
(2012). [10]
S Cherif, Fradj R Ben, A Jrad, Accredit. Qual. Assur. 11 (2006). [11]
G Hua, D A Reckhow, J. Am. Water Works Assoc. 104 (2012) [1]
M Zhang, A Buekens, X Li, J. Hazard. Mater. 304 (2016). [2]
A Kinani, S Kinani, S Bouchonnet, TrAC - Trends Anal. Chem. 85 (2016) [3]
Y Xie, L Chen, R Liu, J Tian, Bioresour. Technol. 265 (2018). A Kinani, H Salhi, S Bouchonnet, S Kinani J. Chromatogr. A 1539 (2018). [5]
F Torrades, E Cecilia, Analyst 126 (2001). International Organization for Standardization, ISO 9562:2004-Water quality—
Determination of adsorbable organically bound halogens (AOX) (2004) [6]
International Organization for Standardization, ISO 9562:2004-Water quality—
Determination of adsorbable organically bound halogens (AOX) (2004). [7]
A Kinani, S Kinani, B Richard, M Lorthioy, S Bouchonnet TrAC - Trends Anal. Chem. 85 (2016). [8]
International Organization for Standardization, ISO 5667-3:2018 - Water quality --
Sampling -- Part 3: Preservation and handling of water samples (2018). [9]
International Organization for Standardization, ISO 11352:2012- Water quality --
Estimation of measurement uncertainty based on validation and quality control data
(2012). [10]
S Cherif, Fradj R Ben, A Jrad, Accredit. Qual. Assur. 11 (2006). [11]
G Hua, D A Reckhow, J. Am. Water Works Assoc. 104 (2012) 7 7
|
https://openalex.org/W2589244411
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc5324225?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
Performance of Firth-and logF-type penalized methods in risk prediction for small or sparse binary data
|
BMC Medical research methodology
| 2,017
|
cc-by
| 10,061
|
Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33
DOI 10.1186/s12874-017-0313-9 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33
DOI 10.1186/s12874-017-0313-9 © The Author(s). 2017 Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the
Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver
(http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated. *Correspondence: shafiq@isrt.ac.bd
Institute of Statistical Research and Training, University of Dhaka, Dhaka,
Bangladesh Abstract Background: When developing risk models for binary data with small or sparse data sets, the standard maximum
likelihood estimation (MLE) based logistic regression faces several problems including biased or infinite estimate of
the regression coefficient and frequent convergence failure of the likelihood due to separation. The problem of
separation occurs commonly even if sample size is large but there is sufficient number of strong predictors. In the
presence of separation, even if one develops the model, it produces overfitted model with poor predictive
performance. Firth-and log F-type penalized regression methods are popular alternative to MLE, particularly for solving
separation-problem. Despite the attractive advantages, their use in risk prediction is very limited. This paper evaluated
these methods in risk prediction in comparison with MLE and other commonly used penalized methods such as ridge. Methods: The predictive performance of the methods was evaluated through assessing calibration, discrimination
and overall predictive performance using an extensive simulation study. Further an illustration of the methods were
provided using a real data example with low prevalence of outcome. Results: The MLE showed poor performance in risk prediction in small or sparse data sets. All penalized methods
offered some improvements in calibration, discrimination and overall predictive performance. Although the Firth-and
log F-type methods showed almost equal amount of improvement, Firth-type penalization produces some bias in the
average predicted probability, and the amount of bias is even larger than that produced by MLE. Of the log F(1, 1) and
log F(2, 2) penalization, log F(2, 2) provides slight bias in the estimate of regression coefficient of binary predictor and
log F(1, 1) performed better in all aspects. Similarly, ridge performed well in discrimination and overall predictive
performance but it often produces underfitted model and has high rate of convergence failure (even the rate is higher
than that for MLE), probably due to the separation problem. Results: The MLE showed poor performance in risk prediction in small or sparse data sets. All penalized methods
offered some improvements in calibration, discrimination and overall predictive performance. Although the Firth-and
log F-type methods showed almost equal amount of improvement, Firth-type penalization produces some bias in the
average predicted probability, and the amount of bias is even larger than that produced by MLE. Abstract Of the log F(1, 1) and
log F(2, 2) penalization, log F(2, 2) provides slight bias in the estimate of regression coefficient of binary predictor and
log F(1, 1) performed better in all aspects. Similarly, ridge performed well in discrimination and overall predictive
performance but it often produces underfitted model and has high rate of convergence failure (even the rate is higher
than that for MLE), probably due to the separation problem. Conclusions: The log F-type penalized method, particularly log F(1, 1) could be used in practice when developing
risk model for small or sparse data sets. Keywords: Prediction model, Separation, Performance measures, Overfitting Keywords: Prediction model, Separation, Performance measures, Overfitting Performance of Firth-and log F-type
penalized methods in risk prediction for small
or sparse binary data M. Shafiqur Rahman* and Mahbuba Sultana Background Although the choice of this
cut-off has some criticisms [6] for not being based on sci-
entific reasoning except empirical evidence, it is found
useful for quantifying the amount of information in the
data relative to model complexity [7, 8]. However, the
requirement of minimum EPV is often difficult to achieve
when the risk models develop for low-dimensional data
with rare outcome or small-and moderate-size, and
for high-dimensional data where the number of pre-
dictors is usually higher than the number of sample
observations. based logistic regression faces several problems [16, 18]. These includes lack of convergence of maximum likeli-
hood and even if it converges it produces biased (some-
times infinite) estimate of the regression coefficient [17]. An alternative to the ML approach in this situation is
Firth’s penalized method [19]. This approach removes the
first order term (O(n−1)) in the asymptotic bias expansion
of the MLEs of the regression parameters by modifying
the score equation with a penalty terms known as Jef-
freys invariant prior. Heinze and Schemper [17] provided
an application of Firth’s method to the solution of the
problem of separation in the logistic regression. Further
the applications of Firth’s method have been provided to
proportional and conditional logistic regressions for sit-
uations with small-sample bias reduction and solution to
problem of separation [20, 21]. To overcome the problem related to overfitting, some
studies [9, 10] explored the use of penalized regression
methods in risk prediction. Of them Ambler et al. [9]
explored the use of two popular penalized regression
methods, such as ridge [11] and lasso [12], in risk pre-
diction for low-dimensional survival data with rare events
and found that both methods improve calibration and
discrimination compared with the ML based standard
Cox models. Pavlou et al. [10] reviewed and evaluated
ridge and lasso and their some extensions, such as elas-
tic net, adaptive lasso etc [13–15], in risk prediction for
low dimensional binary data with rare events and found
that these methods can offers improvement, particularly
for model overfitting, over the standard logistic regression
model. Although these studies showed some improve-
ment in risk prediction for rare-event data by using the
penalized methods, there is no specific guidelines how
risk prediction can be managed in the presence of separa-
tion, which frequently occur for such rare-event or sparse
data. Background to both doctor and patient in making joint decision on
future course of treatment. However, before using these
models in risk prediction it is essential to assess their pre-
dictive performance using data other than that used to
develop the models, which is termed as ‘validation’ [3, 4]. A good risk model is expected to demonstrate good cal-
ibration (accuracy of prediction) and discrimination (the
ability of model to distinguish between low-and-high risk
patients) in new dataset. A risk model that perform well
in development data (that used to fit the model called
‘training’ set) may not perform similar to the validation In many areas of clinical research, risk models for binary
data are usually developed in the maximum-likelihood
(ML) based logistic regression framework to predict the
risk of a patient’s future health status such as death or
illness [1, 2]. For example, in cardiology, models may
be developed to predict the risk of having cardiovascu-
lar disease. Predictions based on these models are useful Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 2 of 15 Page 2 of 15 Table 1 Example of separation due to a dichotomous predictor
X against outcome Y
Complete separation
Quazi-complete separation
Y
Y
1
0
1
0
X
A
10
0
X
A
10
0
B
0
10
B
2
8
Number in each cell indicates number of observations Table 1 Example of separation due to a dichotomous predictor
X against outcome Y Table 1 Example of separation due to a dichotomous predictor
X against outcome Y data (that used to validate the model called ‘test’ set). One
of the main reasons for not performing well in test data
is model overfitting which causes too high prediction for
high risk patients and too low for low risk patients. The
overfitting occurs frequently when the number of events
in training data is lower than the number of risk factors. After employing expert knowledge even if one fits the
model with reduced the number of predictors, the ratio of
the number of event to the number of predictors (EPV)
often very low. However, as a rule of thumb, it has been
suggested in literature that the risk model performs well
when EPV is at least 10 [5]. Penalized method based on log F prior To overcome these problems, Greenland and Mansournia
[23] proposed a class of penalty functions pen(β)
=
ln(|I(β)|−m) indexed by m ≥0, which produce MLE for
m = 0. Then the penalized log-likelihood is equal to
l(β) + mβ/2 −m ln(1 + eβ). They showed that the antilog
of the penalty term mβ/2 −m ln(1 + eβ) is proportional
to a log F(m, m) density for β, which is the conjugate fam-
ily for binomial logistic regression [24, 25]. It is noted that
the prior degrees of freedom m in log F prior is exactly
the number of observations added by the prior. Then the
corresponding penalized ML estimate can be obtained as
ˆβ = argmax
l(β) + mβ/2 −m ln(1 + eβ)
. This shows
that ˆβ has first order (O(n−1)) bias of zero for m = 1,
away from zero for m < 1, and shrinks toward zero for
m > 1. This showed that F(0, 0) is equivalent to MLE, and
F(1, 1) includes Jefrreys prior in one parameter model,
for example, matched pair case-control. Greenland and
Mansournia strongly argued against imposing a prior on
the intercept to make sure that the mean predicted prob-
ability of binary condition is equal to the proportion of
events. In this study, we focused on F(1, 1) and F(2, 2)
prior for computational simplicity. Maximum likelihood based logistic regression model Let Yi, (i = 1, 2, . . . , n), be a binary outcome (0/1) for the
ith subject which follows Bernoulli distribution with the
probability πi = Pr(Yi = 1). The logistic regression model
can be defined as logit[ πi|xi)] = ηi = βTxi, where βT is a vector of regression coefficients of length
(k+1), and xi is the ith row vector of the predictor matrix
x which has order n×(k+1). The term ηi = βTxi is called
as risk score or ‘prognostic index’. In standard MLE, the model is fitted by maximizing the
log likelihood denoted by l(β). Firth’s penalized method In order to remove first order bias in MLEs of the regres-
sion coefficient, Firth [19] suggested to use penalty term
1
2trace[ I(β)−1∂I(β)/∂βj] in the ML based score equation
U(βj) = ∂l(β)/∂βj = 0. The modified score equations are
then U(βj)∗= U(βj) + 1/2trace[ I(β)−1∂I(β)/∂βj] = 0
(j = 1, . . . , k), where I(β)−1 is the inverse of informa-
tion matrix evaluated at β. The corresponding penalized
log-likelihood function for the above modified score func-
tion is l(β) + 1/2 log |I(β)|. The penalty term used above
is known as Jeffreys invariant prior and its influence is
asymptotically negligible. The Firth type penalized MLE
of β is thus ˆβ
= argmax
l(β) + 1/2 log |I(β)|
. This
approach is known as bias preventive rather than cor-
rective. However, Greenland and Mansournia [23] identi-
fied some problems in Jeffreys prior (equivalent to Firth’s
penalty term). These includes i)Jeffrey’s prior is data-
dependent and includes correlation between covariates ii)
the marginal prior for a given β can change in opaque ways
as model covariates are added or deleted, which may pro-
vide surprising results in sparse dataset, and iii) it is not
clear how the penalty translate into prior probabilities for
odds ratios. Ridge penalized method Le Cessie and van Houwelingen [11] uses the penalty term
as λ2
k
j=1 β2
j , where λ2 is a tuning parameter that mod-
ulates the trade-off between the likelihood term and the
penalty term and is usually selected as data-driven pro-
cedure such as cross validation. The ridge log-likelihood
is thus defined as l(β) −λ2
k
j=1 β2
j and hence ˆβ
=
argmax
l(β) −λ2
k
j=1 β2
j
. Ridge was initially devel-
oped to solve the problems due to multicolinearity. How-
ever, it shrinks the regression coefficient towards nearly
zero and hence can be performed well to alleviate over-
fitting in risk prediction in the scenario with correlated
predictors. Penalized methods for logistic regression model Whereas in penalized methods, l(β) is maximized sub-
ject to constraints on the values of regression coefficients. Whereas in penalized methods, l(β) is maximized sub-
ject to constraints on the values of regression coefficients. The constraints are fixed in such a way so that the regres-
sion coefficient shrinks towards zero in comparison with
MLE, which may help to alleviate overfitting. More specif-
ically, the penalized regression coefficient is obtained by
maximizing the penalized log likelihood denoted by ł(β)−
pen(β), where pen(β) is the ‘penalty term’. The penalty
term is the functional form of constraints. The penal-
ized methods differ from each others in the choice of
penalty term. The following subsection briefly discusses
some popular penalized methods. Background More specifically, the problem of separation, first
reported by Albert and Anderson [16], is the case where
one or more predictors have strong effects on response
and hence (nearly ) perfectly predict the outcome of inter-
est. Table 1 presents an example of both complete (perfect
prediction) and quazi-complete separation (nearly perfect
prediction) caused by a dichotomous predictor X against
binary outcome Y. However, one of the criticisms of Firth-type penalty in
recent studies [22, 23] is that it depends on observed
covariate data which can lead to artifacts such as esti-
mates lying outside the range of prior median and the
MLE (which is known as Bayesian non-collapsibility). An
alternative to this, Greenland and Mansournia [22, 23]
suggested log F(1, 1) and log F(2, 2) priors as default prior
for logistic regression. As argued by the authors, the
proposed log F priors are transparent, computationally
simple, and reasonable for logistic regression. However,
despite the attractive advantages of these penalized meth-
ods including Firth’s method for sparse or small data sets,
limited studies have been conducted to explore their use
in risk prediction. This paper evaluates the predictive per-
formance of these penalized methods for sparse data and
compares the results with the ML based method and the
other commonly used penalized method such as ridge. Although lasso is a commonly used method, it is popular
for variable selection. Risk prediction and variable selec-
tion are different issues, and in this paper we have focused
on prediction and hence excluded lasso. This paper is organized as follows. The next section
briefly describes all penalized methods under study. Then
the following sections describe the simulation study, an
illustration of the methodologies using stress ecocardiog-
raphy data, and finally discussion and conclusions. Separation may occur even if the data is large but there
is sufficient number of strong predictors. The likelihood
of separation is higher for categorical predictors with
rare category compared to the continuous predictor [17]. When developing model in the presence of separation, ML Page 3 of 15 Page 3 of 15 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Methods Penalized method based on log F prior Evaluating predictive performance Three common approaches to evaluate the predictive per-
formance of a risk model [26]. These are i) calibration
(the agreement between the observed and predicted risk
in a group of subjects) ii) discrimination (the ability of
model to distinguish between low-and high-risk patients)
iii) overall prediction accuracy. Calibration: We assessed calibration by calculating cali-
bration slope, which can be obtained by re-fitting a binary
logistic regression model with linear predictor or prog-
nostic index (PI) derived from the original model as the
only predictor. The estimated slope ˆβPI is the calibration
slope. If ˆβPI = 1, it suggests perfect calibration; ˆβPI < 1
suggests overfitting, and ˆβPI > 1 suggest underfitting. Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 4 of 15 yes/no), history of prior MI (yes/no) and PTCA (yes/no),
status of DSE test (positive DSE:positive/negative), wall
motion anamoly on echocardiogram (rest WMA:yes/no),
ejection fraction on dobutamine(Dobutamine EF), and
base ejection fraction (base EF). Discrimination: We assessed discriminating ability of
the model by quantifying the area under receiver oper-
ating characteristic curve (AUC), graph of sensitivity
(true-positive rate) versus one minus specificity (true-
negative rate) evaluated at consecutive threshold val-
ues of the predicted risk score or probability derived
from the model. Alternatively AUC can be obtained
by quantifying the probability that, for a randomly
selected pair of subjects, the subject who experienced
the event of interest had higher predicted risk derived
from the model than those without experiencing the
event. A value AUC = 0.5 indicates no discrimination and
1 suggest perfect discrimination. Software All the analyses and simulations were conducted in Stata
version 12. Several Stata packages and functions were
used to fit the models in different methods under study. These includes ‘logit’, ‘firthlogit’, ‘penlogit’, and ‘plogit’
along with ‘plsearch’ for MLE, FIRTH, log F and RIDGE,
respectively. The calculation of calibration slope and Brier
score were performed using self written Stata code and
AUC using the package ‘roctab’. Assessing the properties of the regression coefficients To assess the properties of the regression coefficients such
as bias and mean squared error (MSE), we generated two
independent predictors of which one is continuous (X1 )
generated from standard normal and the other is dichoto-
mous (X2) generated from Bernoulli distribution with 50%
events. We then generated binary response from Bernoulli
distribution with probability πi (i = 1, . . . , n) calculated
from true logistic model logit(π) = β0 + β1X1 + β2X2,
where β1 = 0.30 and β2 = 0.9. With this combina-
tion, the binary covariate created separation for some
of the simulated datasets particularly with low preva-
lence. The value of β0 vary to generate data with varying
level of prevalence. The scenarios were created by vary-
ing the prevalence, on an average, (p) as 5.5, 11.5 20.4
and 39.6% for a fixed sample size n = 120. For each
scenario, 1000 datasets were generated and all regression
approaches under study were fitted to each dataset. When
fitting RIDGE the respective tuning parameters were
selected through 10-fold cross validation. The estimates of
the regression coefficients of the respective models were
obtained as the mean over the number of simulations
where convergence achieved. Noted that only MLE and
RIDGE were failed to converge (due to low prevalence
or separation or both) in some datasets, and the maxi-
mum failure rate for MLE and RIDGE were 13 and 51% ,
respectively for the lowest prevalence scenario. The fail-
ure rate decreases as the prevalence increases. Finally the
relative bias (%) and mean squared error (MSE) of the esti-
mates were reported and compared if the performance
vary across the scenarios. Simulation study The performance of the penalized methods in risk pre-
diction over standard ML based logistic regression were
investigated using a simulation study. We conducted sim-
ulation i) firstly to assess and compare the properties of
the regression coefficients of the different methods (MLE,
FIRTH, log F(1, 1), log F(2, 2), RIDGE) under study and
ii) secondly to assess and compare the predictive perfor-
mance between the methods. Overall predictive performance: The overall prediction
accuracy is quantified using Brier score, which is the mean
of the squared difference between the observed and pre-
dicted risk for each patient derived from the model. The
lower the BS, the better the prediction of a model and
BS=0 indicates perfect prediction. For ease of interpre-
tation we reported root BS(rBS). In addition to the rBS,
we also reported average predictive probability (APP) of
the model to see how the predicted value differ from the
corresponding observed value. Example data: stress echocardiography data The dataset used for simulation and illustration is in
public domain and originally extracted from the study
conducted by Krivokapich et al. [27] where the aim was
to quantify the prognostic value of dobutamine stress
echocardiography (DSE) in predicting cardiac events in
558 patients (male 220 and female 338) with known or
suspected coronary artery disease. The responses of inter-
est whether or not a patient suffered from either of ‘death
due to cardiac arrest’, or ‘ myocardial infarction (MI)’, or ‘
revascularization by percutaneous transluminal coronary
angioplasty (PTCA)’ or ‘coronary artery bypass grafting
surgery (CABG)’ over the next year after having the test. There were 24 patients with cardiac death, 28 with MI,
27 with PTCA, 33 with CABG and 89 with any cardiac
event (Cevent), which implies that the each of the events
was rare. The main predictor of interest are age, history
of hypertension (HT: yes/no) and diabetics mellitus (DM: The results in Table 2 showed that the RIDGE estima-
tor, in general, provides the highest amount of relative bias
(%), which is followed by the MLE and log F(2, 2) whereas
FIRTH and log F(2, 2) provides negligible bias. For the
coefficient of the dichotomous predictor (β2) log F(2, 2)
provides more bias compared to those for continuous pre-
dictor (β1). Assessing the predictive performance To assess the predictive performance of the methods, we
conducted two simulation series following the simula-
tion design in Pavlou et al. [10] used for similar type of
study. The first simulation series is based on the real stress
echocardiography data where only responses were gen-
erated and in the second simulation series we generated
both covariates and responses. The predictive performance of all regression methods
was investigated against EPV=2, 3, 5, 10 to see if the
performance vary across the scenarios. When the pre-
dictive performance against EPV was assessed by means
of calibration slope, the MLE showed poor performance
by producing overfitted model (calibration slope substan-
tially lower than 1) for EPV=2, 3, 5 (Fig. 1). All penalized
methods offered improvement to some extents except the
RIDGE which produced underfitted model ( the average
value of the calibration slope greater than 1 with high SD). In addition, the RIDGE failed to converge for the maxi-
mum 8.4% of the simulations particularly when EPV=2. Almost equal improvement was offered by the Firth-type
and both the log F(1, 1) and log F(2, 2) penalized meth-
ods. In general all methods including MLE showed almost
equal performance in terms of calibration for high EPV
(EPV=10). When the predictive performance (discrimi-
natory ability) was assessed through AUC, all penalized
methods showed better performance with greater AUC
than MLE for the low EPV scenarios (Fig. 2). Of them
the RIDGE provided highest AUC value. However, the
amount of improvement in the discrimination, in gen-
eral, was comparatively lower than that for calibration. All
methods perform almost equally for high EPV (EPV=10). Similarly the penalized methods offered improvement in
the overall predictive performance for individual predic-
tion assessed through rBS to some extents for low EPV
(Fig. 3). Of them, the RIDGE offered greater improve-
ment. However, for low EPV while both the log F(1, 1) and
log F(2, 2) penalized methods provided accurate estimate
of the true average predicted probability (APP) 15.2%,
the FIRTH-type penalized method overestimate the true
value. The amount of bias in FIRTH-type estimate is even
larger than that produced by MLE and RIDGE (Fig. 4). Example data: stress echocardiography data The amount of bias, in general, is the highest Page 5 of 15 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Table 2 Performance of the estimated regression coefficients of models fitted using different methods under study
Estimates
Relative bias (%)
MSE
Coefficient
Prev.(%)
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
5.5
0.33
0.29
0.30
0.28
0.26
10.84
-3.56
-1.29
-6.82
-14.72
0.25
0.19
0.20
0.18
0.10
11.5
0.33
0.31
0.32
0.31
0.26
8.71
2.68
5.46
2.44
-12.23
0.10
0.09
0.10
0.09
0.07
β1
20.4
0.30
0.29
0.29
0.29
0.24
0.14
-4.54
-1.81
-3.62
-19.50
0.07
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.05
39.6
0.31
0.30
0.31
0.30
0.25
4.13
-0.14
2.62
1.19
-16.32
0.04
0.04
0.04
0.04
0.03
59.9
0.31
0.29
0.30
0.30
0.25
1.68
-2.48
0.20
-1.19
-16.87
0.05
0.04
0.04
0.04
0.04
5.5
0.80
0.87
0.86
0.71
0.58
-11.19
-3.41
-4.19
-21.26
-35.13
0.66
0.76
0.75
0.50
0.36
11.5
0.98
0.91
0.91
0.82
0.78
8.92
1.50
0.67
-8.85
-13.36
0.48
0.42
0.42
0.33
0.29
β2
20.4
0.95
0.90
0.89
0.84
0.76
5.34
0.02
-0.74
-6.12
-15.61
0.27
0.23
0.23
0.21
0.23
39.6
0.92
0.89
0.89
0.86
0.75
2.19
-0.74
-1.50
-4.94
-16.14
0.18
0.16
0.16
0.15
0.18
59.9
0.92
0.89
0.89
0.86
0.75
2.36
-0.56
-1.33
-4.77
-16.36
0.15
0.14
0.14
0.13
0.17
Relative bias and MSE were calculated over number of simulations for which the convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence, out of 1000 simulations, for MLE was 13% for lowest prevalence, and for RIDGE it is Page 6 of 15 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 penalized regression methods under study) to each of
the training data sets and check whether convergence
was achieved. Then evaluate their predictive
performance (if convergence achieved) by means of
calibration slope, AUC, root Brier score, and average
predictive probability (APP) using the corresponding
test dataset. Summarize the predictive performance
over the number of simulations for which
convergence is achieved. for the low prevalence data and the lowest for the high
prevalence data. However, the RIDGE, in general, pro-
duces the lowest MSE, and the highest MSE is produced
by the MLE for β1 and by FIRTH for β2. The amount of
MSE, in general, decreases with the increasing prevalence. Stress echocardiography simulation In the first simulation series based on real data, we sim-
ulated data and evaluated the predictive performance of
the models for different EPV scenarios using the following
steps: (i) Fit the following logistic regression model for the
response “any cardiac event” with Firth’s penalized
method (to avoid bias in the estimate of the
regression coefficient) to obtain the true model: logit(Pr(Cevent=1)) = β0 + β1dobef + β2wma + β3posse
+ β4bsef + β5ht + β6age logit(Pr(Cevent=1)) = β0 + β1dobef + β2wma + β3posse
+ β4bsef + β5ht + β6age (ii) To create a training data, choose the EPV and
prevalence (prev), and then calculate sample size for
the respective EPV given the number of predictors p
as n = EPV×p
prev . Sample with replacement the n values
of the covariates in the true model from original data. For each of the n values of the covariates, simulate
new responses from Bernoulli distribution with the
probability calculated from the fitted model. However, replace the value of β0 by -0.65 to confirm
the prevalence of the response (prev), on an average,
15.5% for all EPV scenarios. (iii) With this combination, check and record if separation
occurred due to any of the binary covariates (‘posse’
or ‘wma’, or ‘ht’ or combination of them). Otherwise
to create separation, enlarge the true value of the
respective coefficient of the binary covariate to some
extents. Note that the chances of separation is
expected to increase with decreasing EPV value. (iii) With this combination, check and record if separation
occurred due to any of the binary covariates (‘posse’
or ‘wma’, or ‘ht’ or combination of them). Otherwise
to create separation, enlarge the true value of the
respective coefficient of the binary covariate to some
extents. Note that the chances of separation is
expected to increase with decreasing EPV value. Further simulation (iv) To create a test dataset, sample with replacement
m × n (m times of the original data of size n = 558,
we considered m = 2) values of the covariates. Then
simulate the corresponding new responses from the
same true model used for simulating training data. (iv) To create a test dataset, sample with replacement
m × n (m times of the original data of size n = 558,
we considered m = 2) values of the covariates. Then
simulate the corresponding new responses from the
same true model used for simulating training data. In the second simulation series with the same EPV scenar-
ios, we simulated both covariates and response under two
predictive models, one with weak predictive ability and
the other with strong predictive ability, using the following
steps: g
g
(v) Repeat the steps (ii)-(iii) to produce 1000 training and
1000 test datasets. (i) For creating training data, choose the EPV and
prevalence (prev) and calculate sample size (n) for (i) For creating training data, choose the EPV and
prevalence (prev) and calculate sample size (n) for (vi) Fit the risk models ( using MLE and all types of Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 7 of 15 Fig. 1 Performance of the methods was assessed using calibration slope and compared. Results were summarized over the number of simulations
for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE, out of 1000 simulations, is 8.4% when EPV=2. The values
outside the whisker were not plotted to make the plot readable. The horizontal dash line is the median calibration slope for MLE and the solide line is
the optimal value Fig. 1 Performance of the methods was assessed using calibration slope and compared. Results were summarized over the number of simulations
for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE, out of 1000 simulations, is 8.4% when EPV=2. The values
outside the whisker were not plotted to make the plot readable. The horizontal dash line is the median calibration slope for MLE and the solide line is
the optimal value the given EPV value and the number of predictors
using the same formula previously used. Further simulation (ii) For each observation in training data, first simulate
three continuous predictors (X1, X2, X3)
independently from standard normal distribution and
two binary predictors (X4, X5) independently from
Bernoulli distribution one with low (20%) and the
other with high (60%) prevalence. (iii) Simulate the corresponding responses from Bernoulli dis-
tribution with probability calculated from the true model:
Fig. 2 Performance of the methods was assessed using area under ROC (AUC) and compared. Results were summarized over the number of
simulations for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE, out of 1000 simulations, is 8.4% when EPV=2. The horizontal solide line is the median AUC for MLE two binary predictors (X4, X5) independently from
Bernoulli distribution one with low (20%) and the
other with high (60%) prevalence. two binary predictors (X4, X5) independently from
Bernoulli distribution one with low (20%) and the
other with high (60%) prevalence. (ii) For each observation in training data, first simulate
three continuous predictors (X1, X2, X3)
independently from standard normal distribution and (ii) For each observation in training data, first simulate
three continuous predictors (X1, X2, X3)
independently from standard normal distribution and g (
) p
(iii) Simulate the corresponding responses from Bernoulli dis-
tribution with probability calculated from the true model: Fig. 2 Performance of the methods was assessed using area under ROC (AUC) and compared. Results were summarized over the number of
simulations for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE, out of 1000 simulations, is 8.4% when EPV=2. The horizontal solide line is the median AUC for MLE Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 8 of 15 Fig. 3 Performance of the methods was assessed using root Brier score (rBS) and compared. Results were summarized over the number of
simulations for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE, out of 1000 simulations, is 8.4% when EPV=2. The horizontal solide line is the median rBS for MLE Fig. 3 Performance of the methods was assessed using root Brier score (rBS) and compared. Results were summarized over the number of
simulations for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE, out of 1000 simulations, is 8.4% when EPV=2. Further simulation The horizontal solide line is the median rBS for MLE logit(π) = β0 + β1X1 + β2X2 + β3X3 + β4X4 + β5X5. and for the model with strong predictive ability, the
corresponding true values were set as β0 = −3.5,
β1 = 1.2, β2 = −0.9β3 = 0.9, β4 = 1.2 and β5 = 1.2. In each case, the value of the β0 confirms the desired
prevalence of the response. With this combination, For the model with weak predictive ability, the values
of the regression coefficient were set as β0 = −1.5β1 =
0.2, β2 = 0.5β3 = −0.03, β4 = 0.05 and β5 = −0.6 Fig. 4 Performance of the methods was assessed using Average Predicted Probability (APP) and compared. Results were summarized over the
number of simulations for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE, out of 1000 simulations, is 8.4%
when EPV=2. The horizontal solide line is the observed APP Fig. 4 Performance of the methods was assessed using Average Predicted Probability (APP) and compared. Results were summarized over the
number of simulations for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE, out of 1000 simulations, is 8.4%
when EPV=2. The horizontal solide line is the observed APP Page 9 of 15 Page 9 of 15 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 the binary covarites X5 in the model with weak
predictive ability and X4 in the model with strong
predictive ability create separation in some of the
simulations. Check and record if separation occurred. 60% of total data randomly selected) and their predic-
tive performance were evaluated using test data (contains
rest of 40%). The associated predictors for each car-
diac event were selected based on the information from
literature and results of likelihood ratio test (LRT). Dif-
ferent combinations of predictors were tested using LRT
to come up with a final model for each cardiac event. Then the same model was then fitted in training data
using six different methods. Note that quasi-complete
separation due to binary predictors in training data was
identified for the responses ‘PTCA’ and ‘ cardiac death’,
and hence, in case of convergence failure for RIDGE
or MLE, the estimates reported are based on the last
iteration. The estimated coefficients of the respective
model are then summarized in Table 4. Further simulation For all types of
response, the estimated regression coefficients for MLE is
larger than all penalized methods. Because all the meth-
ods shrink the coefficient towards zero. The amount of
shrinking was higher for the RIDGE in the most of the
cases. However, the main purpose here is to evaluate
the predictive performance of the methods rather than
comparing their estimated regression coefficients. The
predictive performance of all models were then evalu-
ated using test data, and the results were summarized in
Table 5. (iv) Create test data with size 1000 (much larger than the
training data) for the similar level of EPV and
prevalence. For each observation in the test data,
simulate the same predictors as in the test data and
the corresponding response from the same true
model. (v) Repeat the steps (ii)-(iv) to produce 1000 training and
1000 test datasets (vi) Fit risk models (using all methods) using training
data, count if convergence was achieved for the
respective model, and evaluate their predictive
performance (if convergence was achieved in training
data) using test data as before. Finally summarize the
predictive performance over the number of
simulations for which convergence is achieved. The results revealed that, for both predictive models
(weak and strong predictive abilities), all the penalized
methods offered improvement in calibration over MLE
for low EPV, except for the RIDGE which in turn pro-
vided underfitted model (calibration slope grater than 1
with high SD) (Table 3). The amount of improvement by
the other penalized methods was almost equal. However,
all the penalized methods except the RIDGE offered neg-
ligible improvement in the discrimination for low EPV. Similarly all the penalized methods showed improvement
to some extents in the overall predictive performance by
lowering the rBS value compared to that for MLE. For
both predictive model, the average predicted probability
(APP) estimated by the both the log F(1, 1) and log F(2, 2)
were almost equal to the average observed probability,
however the Firth-type penalized method introduced pos-
itive bias in the estimate of the average probability. The
amount of bias was even larger than that for MLE and
RIDGE. In case of both models, the maximum failure of
convergence (due to separation or low EPV or both) was
reported for RIDGE. Further simulation It is observed from results in Table 5 that all models
faced the problem of overfitting (calibration slope <<
1) particularly for those response for which the EPV is
low (EPV<10). The amount of overfitting is lower for
all penalized methods compared to MLE. In terms of
discrimination all methods including MLE provided com-
parable results. For all types of response, the greater
improvement was observed in the calibration (calibration
slope) compared to those in both discrimination (AUC)
and overall performance (BS). Firth methods produced
higher value of the average predicted probability (APP) for
all type of responses. The probable reason for producing overfitted models
(very low value of the calibration slope) even for the penal-
ized methods is that the size of the test data and particu-
larly the number of events for all types of response were
very small compared to the number of events (approx-
imately 100) required for correct estimation of the pre-
dictive accuracy measures [28]. Therefore, further the
predictive performance of all models were evaluated in
test data consisting of larger sample size and number of
events compared to the previous test data. This was cre-
ated by expanding 5 times the original (previous) test data
so that the required number of events is achieved. In
this procedure each subject replaced his/her information
for the other 4 subjects. The results showed that calibra-
tion slope was comparatively more closer to 1 (suggesting
improvement in calibration) for the penalized methods
for all types of responses, particularly for which EPV was Illustration using stress echocardiography data The aim is to derive risk models using different penal-
ized methods discussed earlier and the standard MLE to
predict the risk of having a cardiac event and then to eval-
uate and compare their predictive performance. We fitted
separate models for predicting the risk of each of the four
cardiac events and a model for the risk of any of the events
using each regression approaches; that is, a total of five
models for each of the binary events were fitted using six
different regression methods under study and altogether
25 models for all five binary responses. The models were fitted using training data (contains Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 10 of 15 Page 10 of 15 Table 3 Performance measures for the model s with both weak and strong predictive ability. Results were summarized over the
number of simulations for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE with weak predictive
ability, out of 1000 simulations, is 40% for the lowest EPV Table 3 Performance measures for the model s with both weak and strong predictive ability. Results were summarized over the
number of simulations for which convergence is achieved. The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE with weak predictive
ability, out of 1000 simulations, is 40% for the lowest EPV number of simulations for which convergence is achieved. APP: Average Predicted Probability Illustration using stress echocardiography data The maximum failure rate of convergence for RIDGE with weak predictive
ability, out of 1000 simulations, is 40% for the lowest EPV
Model with weak predictive ability
Calibration slope, Max MCE=0.0235
AUC, Max MCE=0.0012
EPV (N)
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
2(67)
Mean
0.367
0.414
0.383
0.424
1.029
0.606
0.605
0.605
0.607
0.628
SD
0.277
0.303
0.281
0.302
0.847
0.060
0.058
0.059
0.059
0.042
3(100)
Mean
0.472
0.512
0.487
0.517
1.027
0.613
0.613
0.613
0.614
0.626
SD
0.305
0.326
0.311
0.324
0.757
0.054
0.054
0.054
0.054
0.041
5(167)
Mean
0.621
0.658
0.637
0.658
1.055
0.629
0.630
0.630
0.630
0.635
SD
0.317
0.328
0.317
0.323
0.667
0.046
0.046
0.046
0.046
0.039
10(334)
Mean
0.797
0.814
0.801
0.812
1.076
0.645
0.645
0.645
0.646
0.646
SD
0.286
0.289
0.282
0.286
0.504
0.037
0.037
0.037
0.037
0.035
root Brier Score, Max MCE=0.0007
APP (True 0.152), Max MCE=0.0015
EPV(N)
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
2(67)
Mean
0.370
0.369
0.367
0.365
0.360
0.159
0.178
0.154
0.153
0.156
SD
0.022
0.019
0.019
0.018
0.017
0.045
0.041
0.044
0.044
0.044
3(100)
Mean
0.363
0.362
0.361
0.360
0.358
0.156
0.171
0.154
0.154
0.155
SD
0.018
0.017
0.017
0.017
0.016
0.035
0.033
0.035
0.035
0.035
5 (167)
Mean
0.357
0.357
0.357
0.356
0.355
0.153
0.163
0.153
0.153
0.152
SD
0.017
0.016
0.017
0.016
0.016
0.028
0.027
0.027
0.027
0.027
10 (334)
Mean
0.354
0.354
0.354
0.354
0.354
0.151
0.157
0.151
0.151
0.151
SD
0.016
0.015
0.016
0.016
0.015
0.020
0.019
0.020
0.020
0.019
Model with strong predictive ability
Calibration slope, Max MCE=0.0344
AUC, Max MCE=0.0024
EPV (N)
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
2(67)
Mean
0.659
0.825
0.784
0.890
1.252
0.831
0.831
0.832
0.834
0.832
SD
0.296
0.310
0.268
0.273
0.742
0.039
0.039
0.038
0.037
0.037
3 (100)
Mean
0.774
0.888
0.857
0.931
1.125
0.845
0.845
0.846
0.846
0.845
SD
0.236
0.251
0.231
0.233
0.292
0.028
0.028
0.028
0.028
0.028
5(167)
Mean
0.868
0.934
0.917
0.963
1.066
0.854
0.854
0.854
0.855
0.854
SD
0.218
0.226
0.216
0.217
0.224
0.024
0.023
0.023
0.023
0.023
10(334)
Mean
0.933
0.959
0.955
0.979
1.016
0.860
0.860
0.860
0.860
0.860
SD
0.167
0.169
0.166
0.167
0.159
0.022
0.022
0.022
0.022
0.022
root Brier Score, Max MCE=0.0009
APP (True 0.162), Max MCE=0.0014
EPV (N)
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
2 (67)
Mean
0.338
0.331
0.330
0.327
0.328
0.172
0.182
0.164
0.163
0.167
SD
0.030
0.022
0.021
0.020
0.019
0.045
0.040
0.042
0.042
0.042
3(100)
Mean
0.323
0.321
0.321
0.320
0.320
0.165
0.175
0.163
0.163
0.164
SD
0.018
0.016
0.017
0.016
0.016
0.033
0.032
0.033
0.033
0.032
5(167)
Mean
0.316
0.315
0.315
0.315
0.315
0.163
0.170
0.163
0.163
0.163
SD
0.016
0.015
0.015
0.015
0.015
0.026
0.025
0.025
0.025
0.025
10(334)
Mean
0.310
0.310
0.310
0.310
0.310
0.163
0.166
0.163
0.163
0.163
SD
0.016
0.015
0.015
0.015
0.015
0.019
0.019
0.019
0.019
0.019
APP: Average Predicted Probability Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 11 of 15 Table 4 Modeling the risk of cardiac events. Discussion Penalized regression methods (such as RIDGE and
LASSO) has increasingly being used for developing mod-
els for high dimensional data where the number of predic-
tors is higher than the number of subjects. Furthermore
several studies [29, 30] have also been conducted to make
relative comparison between the methods for high dimen-
sional case and found that RIDGE performed well when
data have highly correlated predictors and LASSO per-
formed well when variable selection is required. Although
few studies [9, 10] evaluated RIDGE, LASSO and oth-
ers in risk prediction for low-dimensional survival and
binary data with few events, however, they often ignored
Firth-and log F-type (such as log F(1, 1) and log F(2, 2))
penalized methods, despite their attractive advantages
in reducing finite sample bias in the estimated regres-
sion coefficient and solving problem of separation that
commonly occurs in low-dimensional small or sparse
datasets. This paper explored the use of these methods in
risk prediction for small and sparse data and compared
their predictive performance with MLE and the other
penalized method (RIDGE). In particular we focused on
comparing the predictive performance of the methods
through assessing calibration, discrimination and over-
all predictive performance when EPV is less than 10 in
low-dimensional setting. Illustration using stress echocardiography data of HT
0.823
0.781
0.794
0.728
0.632
(0.393)
(0.384)
(0.384)
(0.302)
(0.276)
Intercept
0.107
0.115
0.151
0.0102
-0.0980
(0.833)
(0.818)
(0.829)
(0.655)
(0.611) Table 4 Modeling the risk of cardiac events. Estimate of the regression coefficients with SE in the parenthesis
Modeling the risk of any cardiac event k of cardiac events. Estimate of the regression coefficients with SE in the parenthesis (Continued)
Modeling the risk of any cardiac event tend to shrink the predicted probability towards the aver-
age compared with the MLE and hence the ordering of
the predicted probabilities with and without experiencing
the event in most patient pairs tends to remain unchanged
after shringkage, which resulted in small improvement
in AUC values of the penalized methods over MLE. All
the penalized methods offered some improvement in the
overall predictive performance (lower BS compared to
those with MLE). Although all penalized methods cor-
rectly estimate the average predicted probability, Firth-
type penalization introduced bias. The findings are similar
to what obtained in other studies [10] that explored the
use of some penalized methods such as ridge, lasso etc in
risk predictions for low-dimensional data. high (results not showed). Similar results were obtained
for the AUC and Brier score for all types of models of all
responses. high (results not showed). Similar results were obtained
for the AUC and Brier score for all types of models of all
responses. Illustration using stress echocardiography data Estimate of the regression coefficients with SE in the parenthesis
Modeling the risk of MI
MLE
FIRTH
log F(1, 1)
log F(2, 2)
RIDGE
Dobutamine EF
-0.0503
-0.0492
-0.0508
-0.0513
-0.0413
(0.0183)
(0.0178)
(0.0183)
(0.0182)
(0.0161)
Positive DSE
1.272
1.241
1.185
1.109
0.994
(0.549)
(0.531)
(0.533)
(0.518)
(0.469)
Hist. of HT
1.115
0.923
0.973
0.866
0.657
(0.789)
(0.716)
(0.716)
(0.662)
(0.542)
Intercept
-1.253
-1.028
-1.057
-0.901
-1.243
(1.351)
(1.284)
(1.307)
(1.275)
(1.132)
Modeling the risk of CABG
Dobutamine EF
-0.0634
-0.0506
-0.0518
-0.0523
-0.0420
(0.0181)
(0.0177)
(0.0181)
(0.0181)
(0.0161)
Positive DSE
1.568
1.190
1.137
1.068
0.971
(0.551)
(0.529)
(0.531)
(0.516)
(0.468)
Intercept
0.272
-0.224
-0.206
-0.145
-0.683
(1.122)
(1.120)
(1.140)
(1.131)
(1.029)
Modeling the risk of PTCA
Positive DSE
0.825
0.820
0.770
0.722
0.579
(0.498)
(0.481)
(0.483)
(0.470)
(0.409)
Base EF
-0.0381
-0.0375
-0.0389
-0.0396
-0.0306
(0.0204)
(0.0198)
(0.0202)
(0.0201)
(0.0168)
Hist. of MI
1.168
1.125
1.118
1.072
0.867
(0.533)
(0.517)
(0.515)
(0.499)
(0.412)
Hist of PTCA
1.304
1.310
1.211
1.127
1.087
(0.617)
(0.591)
(0.602)
(0.588)
(0.555)
Intercept
-1.754
-1.661
-1.646
-1.548
-1.809
(1.184)
(1.151)
(1.167)
(1.153)
(0.968)
Modeling the risk of cardiac death
Positive DSE
1.084
1.061
1.026
0.974
0.873
(0.489)
(0.474)
(0.478)
(0.467)
(0.436)
Hist. of DM
1.083
1.047
1.025
0.973
0.784
(0.495)
(0.480)
(0.481)
(0.468)
(0.419)
Age
0.0347
0.0328
0.0344
0.0342
0.0229
(0.0240)
(0.0236)
(0.0238)
(0.0236)
(0.0188)
Intercept
-6.040
-5.783
-5.965
-5.899
-4.960
(1.787)
(1.750)
(1.769)
(1.753)
(1.379)
Positive DSE
1.064
1.045
1.047
0.989
0.940
(0.332)
(0.327)
(0.327)
(0.264)
(0.248)
Dobutamine EF
-0.0381
-0.0372
-0.0384
-0.0364
-0.0333
(0.0131)
(0.0128)
(0.0130)
(0.0103)
(0.00941) ble 4 Modeling the risk of cardiac events. Estimate of the regression coefficients with SE in the parenthesis
Modeling the risk of MI Table 4 Modeling the risk of cardiac events. Estimate of the regression coefficients with SE in the parenthesis f cardiac events. Estimate of the regression coefficients with SE in the parenthesis Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33
Page 12 of 15 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 12 of 15 Table 4 Modeling the risk of cardiac events. Estimate of the regression coefficients with SE in the parenthesis (Continued)
Modeling the risk of any cardiac event
Rest WMA
-0.779
-0.758
-0.755
-0.839
-0.762
(0.429)
(0.421)
(0.419)
(0.336)
(0.293)
Hist. Conclusions Based on the findings of the study it can be recommended
to use log F-type penalized method instead of MLE in risk
prediction for low dimensional data small or sparse data. Because firstly this approach showed minimum bias in
the estimate of regression coefficient and greater improve-
ment in predictive performance than MLE, particularly
in calibration by removing the amount of overfitting to
some extents. Secondly, this approach has some addi-
tional advantage particularly for solving the problems due
to separation. Of the two types of log F penalization,
log F(1, 1) is preferable to log F(2, 2) because log F(2, 2)
though provides similar predictive performance but pro-
duces some bias in the regression coefficient particularly
for the dichotomous covariates. Although the Firth-type
penalized method have great advantage for solving the
problems related to separation and showed compara-
ble results with the log F-type penalized methods with
respect to calibration, discrimination and overall predic-
tive performance, it produced bias in the estimate of the
average predicted probability. The reason is that Firth’s
approach imposes prior on the intercept (which con-
trol the average predicted probability) and as a result it
shrink the average predicted probability towards 0.5 and
hence produced upward bias in the average predicted
probability. However, the log F make the intercept free
from the penalization and hence correctly estimates the The results from simulation studies and illustration
with real data revealed that while the MLE produced
overfitted model with poor predictive performance (in
terms of calibration), all penalized methods offered some
improvements except for the RIDGE which in turn pro-
duced underfitted models (calibration slope greater than 1
with large variability). All other penalized methods (Firth-
type and both log F(1, 1) and log F(2, 2)) offered simi-
lar amount of improvement in calibration. However, the
improvement in the discrimination in general was lower
than that in calibration. The reason can be explained sim-
ilarly with Pavlou et al. Conclusions [10] as that the penalized methods Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 13 of 15 Table 5 Performance of penalized methods in predicting cardiac events
Models for predicting the risk of MI (EPV ≈7)
Methods
Calibration Slope
AUC
Brier Score
APP
MLE
0.696(0.258)
0.768(0.051)
0.047
0.051
Firth
0.706(0.260)
0.766(0.052)
0.049
0.057
log F(1, 1)
0.713 (0.265)
0.769(0.051)
0.048
0.052
log F(2, 2)
0.723 (0.271)
0.769(0.051)
0.048
0.052
RIDGE
0.772(0.309)
0.762(0.053)
0.047
0.050
Models for predicting the risk of CABG (EPV ≈10)
MLE
0.912(0.219)
0.814(0.046)
0.057
0.056
Firth
0.909 (0.217)
0.814 (0.046)
0.056
0.059
log F(1, 1)
0.921(0.221)
0.814(0.046)
0.056
0.055
log F(2, 2)
0.926(0.223)
0.813(0.046)
0.057
0.055
RIDGE
0.886(0.217)
0.814(0.046)
0.057
0.055
Models for predicting the risk of PTCA (EPV ≈5)
MLE
0.718 (0.291)
0.730(0.108)
0.034
0.061
Firth
0.721(0.279)
0.729(0.108)
0.035
0.066
log F(1, 1)
0.721(0.298)
0.728(0.107)
0.034
0.061
log F(2, 2)
0.720(0.305)
0.728(0.107)
0.034
0.061
RIDGE
0.774(0.544)
0.727(0.107)
0.033
0.061
Models for predicting the risk of cardiac death (EPV ≈6)
MLE
0.661(0.529)
0.688(0.121)
0.024
0.062
Firth
0.680(0.545)
0.688 (0.121)
0.024
0.067
log F(1, 1)
0.645(0.535)
0.687(0.120)
0.024
0.062
log F(2, 2)
0.623 (0.538)
0.687 (0.120)
0.024
0.061
RIDGE
0.665 (0.608)
0.684 (0.121)
0.023
0.062
Models for predicting the risk of any cardiac event (EPV ≈15)
MLE
0.942(0.206)
0.771(0.044)
0.059
0.164
Firth
0.946(0.207)
0.767 (0.044)
0.059
0.167
log F(1, 1)
0.945(0.206)
0.770(0.044)
0.058
0.164
log F(2, 2)
0.946(0.207)
0.770 (0.044)
0.058
0.164
RIDGE
1.004(0.222)
0.769(0.044)
0.056
0.165
Event Per Variable (EPV) was calculated based on the number of event in training data. Estimates of the performance measures with SE in the parenthesis Table 5 Performance of penalized methods in predicting cardiac events
Models for predicting the risk In the presence of separation, developing a risk model
using any other penalized methods, except for the Firth-
type and log F-type methods, under study is challeng-
ing. Because RIDGE and LASSO-type penalized methods
were originally developed particularly either for shrinking
the regression coefficient or variable selection in high
dimensional data rather than solving separation prob-
lem. However, the main limitation of log F type penalized
approach is that it cannot be used directly for variable
selection. If small-to moderate-level of variable selec-
tion is required in low-dimensional data with sufficient
number of predictors, log F method can also be used average predicted probability. Funding
h
h 17. Heinze G, Scemper M. A solution to the problem of separation in logistic
regression. Stat Med. 2002;21(16):2409–19. The authors received no specific fund for this study. They did this research
based on their on interest and used data from secondary source. 18. Schaefer RL. Bias correction in maximum likelihood logistic regression. Stat Med. 1983;2:71–8. Abbreviations 11. Cessie SL, van Houwelingen JC. Ridge estimators in logistic regression. J R
Stat Soc Series C. 1992;41(1):191–201. APP: Average predicted probability; AUC: Area under receiver operating
characteristic curve; EPV: Event per variable; FIRTH: Firth’s penalized method;
MLE: Maximum likelihood estimation 12. Tibshirani R. Regression shrinkage and selection via the lasso. J R Stat Soc
Series B. 1996;58:267–88. 13. Zou H, Hastie T. Regularization and variable selection via the elastic net. J R Stat Soc Series B. 2005;67(2):301–20. Consent for publication
Not applicable. 24. Greenland S. Prior data for non-normal priors. Stat Med. 2007;26:3578–90. 25. Greenland S. Generalized conjugate priors for bayesian analysis of risk and
survival regressions. Biometrics. 2003;59:92–9. Ethics approval and consent to participate 26. Steyerberg EW, Vickers AJ, Cook NR, Gerds T, Gonen M, Obuchowski N,
Pencina MJ, Kattan MW. Assessing the performance of prediction models:
a framework for traditional and novel measures. Epidemiology. 2009;21(1):128–38. As the dataset is freely available in a public domain at http://biostat.mc. vanderbilt.edu/DataSets and is permitted to use in research publication, the
ethics approval and consent statement has been approved by the authority
who made the data available for public use. 27. Krivokapich J, Child J, Walter DO, Garfinkel A. Prognostic value of
dobutamine stress echocardiography in predicting cardiac events in
patients with known or suspected coronary artery disease. J Am Coll
Cardiol. 1999;33(3):708–16. Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge Alan Garfinkel and Frank Harrell for making available
the dataset used in this study in a public domain under the department of
biostatistics, Vanderbilt University, USA. In addition the authors thankful to
associate editors and the reviewers for the valuabale suggestion and
comments which strengthen the quality of the paper. 14. Zou H. The adaptive lasso and its oracle properties. J Am Stat Assoc. 2006;101(476):1418–29. 15. Zou H, Zhang HH. On the adaptive elastic-net with a diverging number of
parameters. Ann Stat. 2009;37(4):1733–51. 16. Albert A, Anderson JA. On the existence of maximum likelihood estimates
in logistic regression models. Biometrika. 1984;71(1):1–10. Received: 25 July 2016 Accepted: 16 February 2017 28. Collins GS, Ogundimu EO, Altman DG. Sample size considerations for the
external validation of a multivariable prognostic model: a resampling
study. Stat Med. 2016;35(2):214–26. Availability of data and materials 19. Firth D. Bias reduction of maximum likelihood estimates. Biomertika. 1993;80:27–38. y
The dataset used in this study can be downloaded freely from a public domain
at http://biostat.mc.vanderbilt.edu/DataSets under the authority of the
department of biostatistics, Vanderbilt University, USA. 20. Greenland S, Schwartzbaum JA, Finkle WD. Problems due to small
samples and sparse data in conditional logistic regression analysis. Am J Epidemiol. 2000;151(5):531–9. Authors’ contribution 21. Lipsitz SR, Fitzmaurice G, Regenbogen SE, Sinha D, Ibrahim JG, Gawande
AA. Bias correction for the proportional odds logistic regression model
with application to a study of surgical complications. J R Stat Soc Series C. 2013;62(2):233–50. MSR contributed to the design of the study; MSR and MS analyzed the data;
MSR and MS wrote the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the
final manuscript. 22. Greenland S, Mansournia MA, Altman DG. Sparse data bias: a problem
hiding in plain sight. BMJ. 2016;352:i1981. Conclusions Similarly although RIDGE
showed greater improvement in the discrimination and
the overall predictive performance, it often provides
under-fitted model. The striking disadvantages of RIDGE
is that it has frequent convergence failure for data with
low EPV or if there is separation. The rate was high (even
higher than MLE) if data have combination of both low
EPV and separation. This finding is similar to those [31]
which reported low EPV or separation or combination of
both as one of the reasons for the convergence-failure in
RIDGE, although other studies [32] reported it as wrong
choice (small value) of tuning parameter. Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Page 14 of 15 in risk prediction after selecting important predictors
using results from exploratory analysis of the data and
likelihood ratio test conducted in different combinations
of nested models. 6. Moons KG, de Groot JA, Linnet K, Reitsma JB, Bossuyt PM. Quantifying the
added value of a diagnostic test or marker. Clin Chem. 2012;58(10):
1408–17. 7. Bouwmeester W, Zuithoff N, Mallett S, Geerlings MI, Vergouwe Y,
Steyerberg EW, Altman DG, Moons KGM. Reporting and methods in
clinical prediction research: a systematic review. PLOS Medecine. 2012;9(5):e1001221. This study did not focus on the use of Firth-type and
log F-type penalized method in risk prediction for low-
dimensional survival data with few events where standard
Cox regression is reported to be unreliable [33]. Further
research may be possible to evaluate the predictive perfor-
mance of these methods in comparison with the standard
Cox model and the other penalized methods. 8. Steyerberg EW, Eijkemans MJC, Harrell FE, Habbema JDF. Prognostic
modelling with logistic regression analysis: a comparison of selection and
estimation methods in small data sets. Stat Med. 2000;19(8):1059–79. 9. Ambler G, Seaman S, Omar RZ. An evaluation of penalised survival
methods for developing prognostic models with rare events. Stat Med. 2012;31(11–12, SI):1150–61. 10. Pavlou M, Ambler G, Seaman S, De Iorio M, RZ O. Review and evaluation
of penalised regression methods for risk prediction in low-dimensional
data with few events. Stat Med. 2016;35(7):1159–77. Competing interests The authors declared that they have no competing interest. 23. Greenland S, Mansournia MA. Penalization, bias reduction, and default
priors in logistic and related categorical and survival regressions. Stat
Med. 2015;34(23):3133–43. 33. Ojeda FM, Müller C, D B, A TD, Schillert A, Heinig M, Zeller T, Schnabel RB.
Comparison of cox model methods in a low-dimensional setting with
few events. Genomics Proteomics Bioinforma. 2016;14(4):235–43. References 1. Abu-Hanna A, Lucas PJF. Prognostic models in medicine. Methods Inform
Med. 2001;40:1–5. 2. Moons KGM, Royston P, Vergouwe Y, Grobbee DE, Altman DG. Prognosis
and prognostic research: what, why and how?. BMJ. 2009a;338:1317–20. 3. Altman DG, Royston P. What do you mean by validating a prognostic
model?. Stat Med. 2000;19:453–73. 4. Moons KGM, Altman DG, Vergouwe Y, Royston P. Prognosis and
prognostic research: application and impact of prognostic models in
clinical practice. BMJ. 2009b;338:1487–90. 5. Peduzzi P, Concato J, Kemper E, Holford TR, Feinstein AR. A simulation
study of the number of events per variable in logistic regression analysis. J Clin Epidemiol. 1996;49:1373–9. 1. Abu-Hanna A, Lucas PJF. Prognostic models in medicine. Methods Inform
Med. 2001;40:1–5. 29. Benner A, Zucknick M, Hielscher T, Ittrich C, Mansmann U. High-dimensional cox models: the choice of penalty as part of the model
building process. Biometrical J. 2010;52:50–69. 30. van Wieringen WN, Kun D, Hampel AL R, Boulesteix. Survival prediction
using gene expression data: a review and comparison. Comput Stat Data
Anal. 2009;53:1590–603. 4. Moons KGM, Altman DG, Vergouwe Y, Royston P. Prognosis and
prognostic research: application and impact of prognostic models in
clinical practice. BMJ. 2009b;338:1487–90. 31. Shen J, Gao S. A solution to separation and multicollinearity in multiple
logistic regression. J Data Sci. 2008;6(4):515–31. 5. Peduzzi P, Concato J, Kemper E, Holford TR, Feinstein AR. A simulation
study of the number of events per variable in logistic regression analysis. J Clin Epidemiol. 1996;49:1373–9. 32. Goeman J, Meijer R, Chaturvedi N. L1 and L2 penalized regression models. R Package version 0.9-47; 2016. Retrieved from http://CRAN.R-project.org/
package=penalized. 32. Goeman J, Meijer R, Chaturvedi N. L1 and L2 penalized regression models. R Package version 0.9-47; 2016. Retrieved from http://CRAN.R-project.org/
package=penalized. Page 15 of 15 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Rahman and Sultana BMC Medical Research Methodology (2017) 17:33 Submit your next manuscript to BioMed Central
and we will help you at every step: • We accept pre-submission inquiries
• Our selector tool helps you to find the most relevant journal
• We provide round the clock customer support
• Convenient online submission
• Thorough peer review
• Inclusion in PubMed and all major indexing services
• Maximum visibility for your research
Submit your manuscript at
www.biomedcentral.com/submit
a d
e
e p you at e e y step
|
https://openalex.org/W2600584577
|
https://hal.science/hal-01605881/document
|
English
| null |
Quantitative Methods to Assess Differential Susceptibility of Arabidopsis thaliana Natural Accessions to Dickeya dadantii
|
Frontiers in plant science
| 2,017
|
cc-by
| 8,279
|
Quantitative methods to assess differential susceptibility
of arabidopsis thaliana natural accessions to dickeya
dadantii Martine Rigault, Amélie Buellet, Céline Masclaux-Daubresse, Mathilde
Fagard, Fabien Chardon, Alia Dellagi To cite this version: Martine Rigault, Amélie Buellet, Céline Masclaux-Daubresse, Mathilde Fagard, Fabien Chardon, et
al.. Quantitative methods to assess differential susceptibility of arabidopsis thaliana natural accessions
to dickeya dadantii. Frontiers in Plant Science, 2017, 8, pp.1-10. 10.3389/fpls.2017.00394. hal-
01605881 Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License HAL Id: hal-01605881
https://hal.science/hal-01605881v1
Submitted on 25 May 2020 L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers. Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License ORIGINAL RESEARCH
published: 28 March 2017
doi: 10.3389/fpls.2017.00394 Quantitative Methods to Assess
Differential Susceptibility of
Arabidopsis thaliana Natural
Accessions to Dickeya dadantii
Martine Rigault, Amélie Buellet, Céline Masclaux-Daubresse, Mathilde Fagard,
Fabien Chardon and Alia Dellagi* Institut Jean-Pierre Bourgin, UMR INRA- AgroParisTech 1318, ERL CNRS 3559, Saclay Plant Sciences, Versailles, France Among the most devastating bacterial diseases of plants, soft rot provoked by Dickeya
spp. cause crop yield losses on a large range of species with potato being the most
economically important. The use of antibiotics being prohibited in most countries in
the field, identifying tolerance genes is expected to be one of the most effective
alternate disease control approaches. A prerequisite for the identification of tolerance
genes is to develop robust disease quantification methods and to identify tolerant plant
genotypes. In this work, we investigate the feasibility of the exploitation of Arabidopsis
thaliana natural variation to find tolerant genotypes and to develop robust quantification
methods. We compared different quantification methods that score either symptom
development or bacterial populations in planta. An easy to set up and reliable bacterial
quantification method based on qPCR amplification of bacterial DNA was validated. This study demonstrates that it is possible to conduct a robust phenotyping of soft
rot disease, and that Arabidopsis natural accessions are a relevant source of tolerance
genes. INTRODUCTION Specialty section:
This article was submitted to
Plant Microbe Interactions,
a section of the journal
Frontiers in Plant Science Plants are exposed to biotic and abiotic stresses that lead to important crop yield losses. Considerable advances have been made recently that allow a better understanding of the
mechanisms underlying plant–pathogen interactions which determine disease severity at the end. On the one hand, pathogens deploy various virulence systems to invade the plant tissues either
by killing cells or by suppressing plant defenses. On the other hand, plants use different defense
strategies to counteract this invasion (Dangl et al., 2013). Characterizing the main processes
involved in virulence on the pathogen side and involved in defense on the plant side requires a
reliable system to score disease severity parameters (Brouwer et al., 2003; Trontin et al., 2011). Indeed, new sequencing technologies and phenotyping open the way to investigate plant genetic
determinants of resistance/tolerance to pathogens, but strictly depend on robust quantification
methods (Mutka and Bart, 2015). Quantification of disease can rely on different parameters that
vary according to the pathogen considered. In most cases, symptom severity is considered as
a good indicator of the pathogen’s impact on its host during disease. Another parameter that
can be considered, is the in planta pathogen growth or pathogen burden (Brouwer et al., 2003). Received: 05 December 2016
Accepted: 07 March 2017
Published: 28 March 2017 Edited by: Edited by:
Richard Berthomé,
Centre Toulouse Midi-Pyrénées
(INRA), France Reviewed by: Reviewed by:
Javier Plasencia,
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de
México (UNAM), Mexico
Oswaldo Valdes-Lopez,
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de
México (UNAM), Mexico Reviewed by:
Javier Plasencia,
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de
México (UNAM), Mexico
Oswaldo Valdes-Lopez, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de
México (UNAM), Mexico *Correspondence:
Alia Dellagi
dellagi@agroparistech.fr *Correspondence:
Alia Dellagi
dellagi@agroparistech.fr Keywords: natural variation, Arabidopsis thaliana, Dickeya dadantii, quantification, qPCR Keywords: natural variation, Arabidopsis thaliana, Dickeya dadantii, quantification, qPCR Citation: Citation:
Rigault M, Buellet A,
Masclaux-Daubresse C, Fagard M,
Chardon F and Dellagi A (2017)
Quantitative Methods to Assess
Differential Susceptibility
of Arabidopsis thaliana Natural
Accessions to Dickeya dadantii. Front. Plant Sci. 8:394. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2017.00394 March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 1 Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii Rigault et al. Monitoring the pathogen burden allows a better understanding
of the mechanisms controlling disease impact on host. Indeed,
plants can be tolerant or resistant to a certain pathogen. Resistance consists of reduced disease severity due to pathogen
growth restriction, and relies on specific recognition of pathogen
strains via the product of a resistance (R) gene. In the majority
of the cases, R genes contain two conserved domains: nucleotide
binding domain (NB) and a leucine rich repeat domain (LRR)
(St Clair, 2010). Tolerance consists in limiting detrimental effects
of disease without a strong reduction of pathogen burden. The
underlying mechanisms of tolerance are not specific and mobilize
different immunity processes. The outcomes of tolerance or
resistance on pathogen populations are different. Resistance can
lead to pathogen eradication, but increases the risks of emergence
of new hyper-virulent strains. In contrast, tolerance does not
reduce pathogen populations and does not favor arms race
between hosts and pathogens. Thus, combining quantification of
disease severity and pathogen populations in planta is crucial. to set up genetic screens, it is necessary to find differentially
susceptible plant genotypes by scoring robust quantitative traits. The use of Arabidopsis as a model plant to accelerate discovery
of tolerance or resistance genes in crops proved to be efficient in
several instances (Piquerez et al., 2014). The rationale of using the
model plant Arabidopsis rather than potato is the availability of
genetic tools such as fully sequenced genotypes, mutant libraries
allowing a rapid identification of candidate genes. In this work,
we investigated the feasibility of the exploitation of natural
variation in Arabidopsis thaliana L. (Arabidopsis) to highlight
differential susceptibilities by comparing different quantitative
traits. In addition, Arabidopsis is a host for D. dadantii displaying
a compatible interaction with spreading symptoms (Fagard et al.,
2007). In potato, candidate genes involved in tolerance QTLs to
Phytophthora infestans were found to be involved in tolerance
to the oomycete after expression in Arabidopsis (Pajerowska-
Mukhtar et al., 2008) indicating that common mechanisms of
tolerance do exist in Arabidopsis and potato. Citation: Bacterial pathogens have the peculiarity of being difficult to
control. Indeed, antibiotic use in agriculture is prohibited in
most European countries, due to the risk of resistance emergence
in the field that could be transferred to clinically important
bacteria isolates (Williams-Nguyen et al., 2016). Among the most
devastating bacterial diseases, soft rot causes crop yield losses in a
large range of species with potato being the most economically
important (Czajkowski et al., 2011). Soft rot can be caused by
Dickeya species or Pectobacterium species (Toth et al., 2003; Toth
et al., 2011). Bacteria survive in water or in plant organs like
potato tubers and infect growing plants in the field (Reverchon
et al., 2016). Bacteria multiply on the plant surface then enter
apoplastic spaces where they multiply. Typical symptoms are
maceration and rotting of infected tissues mainly caused by
the massive production of plant cell wall degrading enzymes
(PCWDE) that lead to tissue disorganization and then death. Cell wall degradation liberates sugars that are used as carbon
source for bacterial cells (Reverchon and Nasser, 2013). The
process by which Dickeya species infect their hosts corresponds
to what is generally described as a necrotrophic lifestyle (van
Kan, 2006). Production of these enzymes is tightly controlled
at the transcriptional and post transcriptional level in response
to environmental factors. Because control of soft rot species is
complex, it is a prerequisite to develop a robust and reliable
system to score the disease parameters (Czajkowski et al., 2011). For instance, breeding for resistance is hampered by the difficulty
to score symptoms and then to correlate this with the bacterial
population. The most studied disease quantitative trait in genetic studies
is the visible symptom. Another important trait, is the in planta
pathogen burden. In planta bacterial population estimation by
classical counting of bacterial colonies is tedious and time-
consuming. To improve bacterial population estimation in
planta, we designed primers to PCR-amplify bacterial DNA from
infected tissues. We have determined the correlation between
several disease parameters in different plant genotypes harboring
different tolerance levels to D. dadantii. Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org Plant and Pathogen Material Plant and Pathogen Material
Wild-type accessions of Arabidopsis Bur-0, Can-0, Col-0, Cvi-0,
Edi-0, Ge-0, Oy-0 and Sakata were obtained from the Versailles
Arabidopsis Stock Center (INRA Versailles France1). Arabidopsis
seeds were stratified by incubation for 2 days at 4◦C in 0.01%
agarose in water (w/v) in the dark, then, were sown in sand. Homogeneous germination occurred 2 days after sowing. Three
times per week, the pots were watered (by immersion of their
base) in a mineral solution containing 2 mM nitrate or 10 mM
nitrate (Supplementary Table 1). The pH of the watering solutions
remained between 5.1 and 5.5 (Lemaitre et al., 2008). During the
first 2 weeks, they were watered with the 2 mM nitrate containing
solution to avoid intoxication with excess nitrate. The four
following weeks, they were watered with a solution containing
10 mM nitrate (Supplementary Table 1). Plants were grown under
short days (8-h light/16-h dark) with 21◦C temperature and
70% relative humidity. Six- week-old plants were heavily watered
and covered with a transparent plastic 16 h before inoculation. The cover was kept in place throughout the assay to maintain
high-humidity conditions. Very few data about plant defense against Dickeya dadantii
are available (Reverchon et al., 2016). Accumulation of reactive
oxygen species is involved in reducing D. dadantii infection
on Saintpaulia ionantha and Arabidopsis (Santos et al., 2001;
Reverchon et al., 2002; Fagard et al., 2007). Jasmonic acid is
involved in bacterial attraction and defense (Fagard et al., 2007;
Antunez-Lamas et al., 2009). Iron homeostasis plays a pivotal role
in Arabidopsis defense against D. dadantii (Aznar et al., 2014,
2015; Nam Phuong et al., 2012). In order to gain insight into the
plant defense arsenal effective against Dickeya spp. and to identify
tolerance genes, genetic screens can be very powerful. To be able Bacterial Strain and Inoculation Method 1http://publiclines.versailles.inra.fr/ Bacterial Strain and Inoculation Method The experiments were performed with the D. dadantii 3937 strain
constitutively expressing a gfp fusion and resistant to gentamycin 1http://publiclines.versailles.inra.fr/ March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 2 Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii Rigault et al. (Asselbergh et al., 2008; Chapelle et al., 2015). Bacteria were
grown in Luria-Bertani medium supplemented with 10 µg/mL
gentamycin (Sigma). For plant inoculations, a small hole was
made with a needle in the leaf, and then, 5 µL of a bacterial
suspension at a density of 1 × 108 Colony Forming Unit/mL
(CFU) made up in 50 mM potassium phosphate buffer (pH 7)
was spotted on the top of the hole. In each experiment, six plants
were inoculated for each genotype and three leaves by plant were
inoculated. In order to avoid bias linked to symptom severity,
leaves were randomly chosen to be processed by each method of
bacterial quantification (CFU counting or qPCR). then DNA was precipitated by adding 300 µL of isopropanol. After centrifuging 15 min at 7000 rpm, the pellet was recovered
and washed with 70% ethanol then DNA was dissolved in 30 µL
of TE buffer. (Asselbergh et al., 2008; Chapelle et al., 2015). Bacteria were
grown in Luria-Bertani medium supplemented with 10 µg/mL
gentamycin (Sigma). For plant inoculations, a small hole was
made with a needle in the leaf, and then, 5 µL of a bacterial
suspension at a density of 1 × 108 Colony Forming Unit/mL
(CFU) made up in 50 mM potassium phosphate buffer (pH 7)
was spotted on the top of the hole. In each experiment, six plants
were inoculated for each genotype and three leaves by plant were
inoculated. In order to avoid bias linked to symptom severity,
leaves were randomly chosen to be processed by each method of
bacterial quantification (CFU counting or qPCR). Symptom Quantification on a Collection
of Arabidopsis Natural Accessions Visual symptom scoring is usually performed based on a disease
severity scale or based on surface measurement. We compared
these two methods for the quantification of visible symptoms
caused by D. dadantii on different Arabidopsis accessions. The
first method consists in attributing a disease severity index (DSI)
to each symptom based on the scale indicated in Figure 1A
as previously described (Fagard et al., 2007). The second
method consists in measuring the surface of the lesion hereafter
designated as “lesion surface” (LS). Surface Measurement Photographs of infected plants were taken for each individual
leaf. The surface of the lesions were analyzed using the open
source software ImageJ https://imagej.nih.gov/ij/. Quantitative PCR Amplification of
Bacterial DNA DNA from D. dadantii bacterial cultures was used as a standard. A standard curve was obtained by a fivefold serial dilution
starting from a concentration of 5 ng/µL. Amplifications
of DNA from infected leaves was performed on a 1/50th
of the purified DNA (see section above). Primers used
are: PelA-Forward: 5′-CCGCAACGTCTACATCCAAA-3′; PelA-
Reverse: 5′- CGTCGCCTTTTTCGTAATGC-3′; RpoB-Forward:
5′-
AATCGAAGGTTCCGGGATTC
-3′;
RpoB-Reverse:
5′-
GCCGTTACGGATATCGATGAG -3′. Two and a half microliters
of the 1/50th diluted DNA was subjected to real time qPCR using
SYBR Green PCR Mastermix (Eurogentec) and gene-specific
primers. Absolute DNA quantities were obtained based on the
standard curve of pure bacterial DNA. The DNA content in
each leaf was converted into Bacterial cell EqDNA according to
Supplementary Table 2 formulas. Count of Bacterial Colonies To monitor in planta viable bacterial populations, infected leaves
were individually harvested in 500 µL 0.9% NaCl. After grinding,
the suspension was diluted following a 10-fold dilution series up-
to 10−6 or 10−7 fold. Ten microliters droplets were then plated
out on LB medium containing 10 µg/mL gentamycin following
the drop-plate method (Herigstad et al., 2001). For each dilution
in the series, two 10-µL droplets were placed on LB plates and
incubated at 28◦C for 48 h. CFUs were counted on plated droplets
that contained between 4 and 40 colonies and the number of CFU
per leaf was calculated. Bacterial DNA Extraction Bacterial DNA was extracted from pure D. dadantii liquid
cultures. An overnight LB grown bacterial culture was pelleted
by centrifugation. The pellet was suspended in TE(Tris-EDTA)
buffer Proteinase K and SDS were added to a final concentration
of 100 µg/mL and 0.5%, respectively. The extract was thoroughly
mixed and incubated at 37◦C for 1 h, then NaCl was added
to a final concentration of 0.83 M. To precipitate cell debris,
cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB)/NaCl (10% CTAB,
0.7 M NaCl) was added to reach the final proportion of 8/70th of
the volume, then incubated 10 min at 65◦C. An equal volume of
chloroform/isoamylic alcohol was added, followed by mixing and
spinning for 5 min. The supernatant was recovered and subjected
to a phenol/chloroform/isoamylic alchohol extraction followed
by a precipitation in isopropanol. To minimize environmental effects potentially due to soil
composition, seedlings were grown on sand and watered with
a mineral solution as indicated. Leaves of 6-week-old seedlings
were inoculated by making a hole with a needle followed by the
application of 5 µL of a bacterial suspension to ensure that each
leaf was inoculated with the same number of bacteria. D. dadantii
infection causes tissue maceration visible 24–48 h post infection
(24–48 h p.i.). The maceration spreads starting from the hole. Symptoms are scored during the 1st days (here 3 days) using the
0–5 DSI scale (Figure 1A). To compare these two procedures,
photographs were taken at different time points after inoculation,
areas of maceration were measured by computer-assisted analysis
of the images. In order to compare the two methods, we
chose Arabidopsis accessions displaying different sensitivities to
infection based on symptom scoring (data not shown). These
accessions are Bur-0 displaying a reduced sensitivity and Cvi-0
displaying a high sensitivity. DNA Extraction from Infected Leaves After harvesting, infected leaves were individually frozen in liquid
nitrogen then ground. DNA extraction was performed using the
CTAB extraction method. In each tube containing one ground
leaf, 400 µL of CTAB buffer (2% cetyltrimethyl-ammonium
bromide, 1% polyvinylpyrrolidone, 100 mM Tris-HCl, 1.4 M
NaCl, 20 mM EDTA, 0.2% β-mercapto-ethanol) was added. The
samples were then incubated 30 min at 60◦C. Four hundred
microliters of chloroform: isoamylic alcohol (24:1) were then
added. The samples were centrifuged for 10 min at 7000 rpm in a
micro-centrifuge and 300 µL of the supernatant were harvested, The progression curves of LS and DSI indicated that the
relative susceptibilities of the two accessions were the same for March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org 3 igault et al. Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii
FIGURE 1 | Correlation between macerated surface and disease severity on Arabidopsis leaves infected with Dickeya dadantii. Leaves were
inoculated with 5 µL of bacterial suspension. (A) Image representing stages of the disease severity index scale. (B) Leaf symptoms were scored according to
the scale of 0–5 (Fagard et al., 2007). (C) Photographs were taken at indicated times after inoculation. Diseased areas were measured using the computer program
ImageJ. (D) Correlation between DSI and LS 48 h p.i. Experiments were repeated at least three times. Data from one representative experiment are shown. Error
bars: standard deviation. Mean were compared using Student’s T-test. n = 10–18. ∗p-value < 0.05, ∗∗p-value < 0.001. Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii Rigault et al. FIGURE 1 | Correlation between macerated surface and disease severity on Arabidopsis leaves infected with Dickeya dadantii. Leaves were
inoculated with 5 µL of bacterial suspension. (A) Image representing stages of the disease severity index scale. (B) Leaf symptoms were scored according to
the scale of 0–5 (Fagard et al., 2007). (C) Photographs were taken at indicated times after inoculation. Diseased areas were measured using the computer program
ImageJ. (D) Correlation between DSI and LS 48 h p.i. Experiments were repeated at least three times. Data from one representative experiment are shown. Error
bars: standard deviation. Mean were compared using Student’s T-test. n = 10–18. ∗p-value < 0.05, ∗∗p-value < 0.001. quantification methods (DSI and LS). Statistically significant
linear correlation was obtained between LS and DSI with a
Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.92 (Figure 1D). DNA Extraction from Infected Leaves Thus, DSI
and LS provide similar estimations of the Arabidopsis genotypes
susceptibility to D. dadantii. both symptom-scoring methods, Bur-0 being the most tolerant,
Cvi-0 being the most susceptible. However, significant differences
were observed between DSI and LS after 24 and 48 h following
infection. Indeed, the DSI progression curve shows a regular
increase over 3 days (Figure 1B) while the LS started to diminish
in Cvi-0 at 48 h p.i. (Figure 1C). This reduction could be
attributed to the fact that severe maceration causes shrinking
and folding of the leaf tissue. Thus, at later infection stages, LS
may not correctly reflect the severity of symptoms. We concluded
that the best time to highlight different sensitivity levels is at
48 h p.i. We determined the degree of correlation between both To determine whether the quantification of disease based
on symptom severity can be used to discriminate between
Arabidopsis genotypes, we studied D. dadantii infection on a
panel of eight accessions chosen for their different origins (data
not shown). For this purpose, bacterial infection was performed
on the accessions Bur-0, Can-0, Col-0, Cvi-0, Edi-0, Ge-0, and March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org 4 Rigault et al. Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii FIGURE 2 | Quantification of disease on a collection of Arabidopsis accessions. Disease severity was quantified by LS on the indicated Arabidopsis
genotypes 48 h p.i. Experiment was repeated three times with similar results. Representative data are shown. Means with different letters are significantly different at
p < 0.05 as determined using XLSTAT ANOVA Tukey HSD test. FIGURE 2 | Quantification of disease on a collection of Arabidopsis accessions. Disease severity was quantified by LS on the indicated Arabidopsis
genotypes 48 h p.i. Experiment was repeated three times with similar results. Representative data are shown. Means with different letters are significantly different at
p < 0.05 as determined using XLSTAT ANOVA Tukey HSD test. efficiencies with D. solani genomic DNA were out of acceptable
range thus confirming the specificity of our primers (data not
shown). Sequence alignments of pelA and rpoB primers with the
corresponding genes from D. solani show several mismatches
(Supplementary Figure 1). To quantify D. dadantii DNA, a
standard curve was obtained using a serial dilution of genomic
bacterial DNA from D. dadantii 3937. Bacterial Quantification In planta by
qPCR Amplification of Bacterial DNA To perform large scale phenotyping of plants, robust and simple
methods are needed. We were interested in phenotyping bacterial
burden in planta, which is a complementary trait to the visible
symptom. To investigate in planta bacterial populations, serial
dilutions of samples followed by plating and colony counting
are usually performed (Tornero and Dangl, 2001). However,
this method is time-consuming and requires the use of a
bacterial strain that harbors a resistance to an antibiotic. We
wanted to develop a system to quantify bacteria by qPCR
that could be easier to perform on a larger scale. For this
purpose, before quantifying unknown bacterial titers, we checked
whether DNA amplification allowed us to correctly determine a
known bacterial titer in planta. To obtain leaves with a known
bacterial titer, Arabidopsis leaves were inoculated with different
known amounts of bacteria, then were immediately frozen. Total
DNA was extracted as described, and two bacterial genes were
amplified (pelA and rpoB) to avoid artifacts related to primer
sequence. The pelA gene encodes a pectate lyase present in
pectinolytic bacteria (Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat et al., 2014). The
rpoB gene encodes an RNA polymerase which is a powerful
tool used for bacterial identification (Mollet et al., 1997). These
primers were used in a previous study (Nam Phuong et al., 2012),
and their specificity was checked using as a template DNA of
the closely related D. solani (Pedron et al., 2014). Amplification DNA Extraction from Infected Leaves Data on Figure 3 show
that bacterial DNA estimated by qPCR is in agreement with the
expected DNA in the inoculum (Supplementary Table 2) based
on the fact that a D. dadantii bacterial suspension of 0D600 = 0.1
contains approximately 5 × 108 CFU/mL (Antunez-Lamas
et al., 2009) and that a bacterial cell contains approximately
5 fg of DNA (Hutchison and Venter, 2006). Bacterial DNA
amounts estimated via pelA and rpoB amplification were similar
indicating that DNA quantification does not depend on the
primers’ sequence. A highly statistically significant correlation
was observed between experimentally quantified bacterial DNA
via qPCR and theoretically expected bacterial DNA (Figure 3B). These data indicate that our qPCR-based quantification method
is a reliable tool to estimate bacterial populations in planta at the
initial stage of infection. Bacterial populations estimated by qPCR
will be designated hereafter as “Bacterial cell EqDNA.” Oy-0. Disease severity estimated by LS at 48 h p.i. indicates that
three statistically distinct groups could be defined. According
to the LS criterion, the most tolerant accessions are Oy-0, Edi-
0, and Bur-0. The most susceptible ones are Ge-0, Sakata, and
Can-0 (Figure 2). These data indicate that natural accessions of
Arabidopsis display different levels of tolerance to D. dadantii
suggesting that tolerance associated loci might be found in this
plant species. Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org Individual Sample Analyses of Bacterial
Population and Symptom Severity As expected, bacterial
populations at 0 h p.i., quantified by both methods corresponded
to the inoculum, i.e., 25,000 bacteria/leaf (data not shown). Then,
at 24 and 48 h. p.i., the bacterial titers in each inoculated leaf were
determined, using either the DNA quantification method or the
serial dilution method. By this means, we were able to attribute
to each infected leaf 3 parameters: (1) DSI, (2) LS, (3) bacterial
titer/leaf either estimated via CFU or via Bacterial cell EqDNA. show, an important variability at the early stages of the infection,
which may explain why it is quite complex in some cases to
evaluate disease severity with this bacterium (Czajkowski et al.,
2011). We note that the estimated bacterial populations by
qPCR were in general higher than the bacterial populations
estimated by counting of CFU although immediately after the
inoculations, the initial inocula were identical. One possible
explanation for this difference is that qPCR-based estimation of
bacterial cells includes a part of the bacterial populations that
died during the infection process and thereby over-estimates the
amount of bacteria. Conversely, grinding the infected tissue then
diluting and counting growing colonies as CFU probably kills
a proportion of the bacterial cells and from the plant defense
system. y
To compare CFU/leaf and Bacterial Cell EqDNA/leaf, it
was not technically possible to have two different estimations
of the bacterial populations for the same leaf. To circumvent
this problem, we compared the CFU/leaf and Bacterial Cell
EqDNA/leaf for leaves displaying the same DSI. Indeed, this
parameter could be scored for every leaf. To be more precise in
our procedure, we divided the symptom stages as follows: Stage
0, Stage 0.5, Stage 1, Stage 1.5, Stage 2, Stage 2.5, Stage 3, Stage 3.5,
Stage 4 (In our data, there was no Stage 5 because we used data
for the 24 and 48 h p.i. time-points, when the symptoms rarely
reach stage 5). Thus, for each stage, we could determine a mean
bacterial population quantified as CFU/leaf and a mean bacterial
population as Bacterial Cell EqDNA/leaf. This allowed us to check
whether there is a correlation between these two parameters. Figure 4C shows that the Pearson correlation coefficient between
the two datasets is 0.814 with statistically significant correlation
indicating that the two bacterial quantification methods are
equivalent. Individual Sample Analyses of Bacterial
Population and Symptom Severity Quantifying disease based on symptoms or based on bacterial
populations provides different biological information. Indeed, it
is conceivable that some plants may harbor a high inoculum
without displaying symptoms. For instance, Dickeya species are
known to survive in a latent state in plant tissues without causing
symptoms (Toth et al., 2003; Czajkowski et al., 2011, 2015). Thus, we investigated possible correlations between bacterial
populations and visible symptoms in individual leaves. For this purpose, we quantified bacteria in planta using
two different methods. The first method is the classical count March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 5 Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii Rigault et al. FIGURE 3 | Bacterial population estimation by qPCR in samples with known bacterial titer. (A) Leaves were inoculated with 5 µL of a bacterial suspension
at increasing concentrations. Leaves were immediately frozen and total DNA extracted then qPCR was performed with primers amplifying RPOB or PELA. Bacterial
DNA quantities were determined based on a standard curve obtained with pure bacterial DNA. (B) Estimated bacterial DNA was plotted against expected values to
check reliability of the quantification method. FIGURE 3 | Bacterial population estimation by qPCR in samples with known bacterial titer. (A) Leaves were inoculated with 5 µL of a bacterial suspension
at increasing concentrations. Leaves were immediately frozen and total DNA extracted then qPCR was performed with primers amplifying RPOB or PELA. Bacterial
DNA quantities were determined based on a standard curve obtained with pure bacterial DNA. (B) Estimated bacterial DNA was plotted against expected values to
check reliability of the quantification method. of bacterial colonies after tissue grinding and serial dilutions
followed by plating and counting the CFUs which is widely
used in the literature (Tornero and Dangl, 2001; Lebeau et al.,
2008; Antunez-Lamas et al., 2009). The second method is based
on qPCR quantification of bacterial DNA in inoculated plants. We therefore compared these two methods, using plants at the
extremes of the gradient of sensitivity of our panel of differentially
susceptible accessions to investigate whether symptom severity
is related to bacterial populations when disease progression
has occurred (24 and 48 h p.i.). Leaves of Cvi-0 and Bur-0
plants were inoculated with 5 µL of a bacterial suspension at
5 × 108 CFU/mL. Leaves displaying different intensities of DSI
and of LS were harvested individually. Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org DISCUSSION Identifying novel genes involved in defense processes against the
necrotrophic pathogen D. dadantii is very challenging. Indeed,
this bacterium causes major economic losses but very few data are
available about potential tolerance genes. Taking advantage of the
available novel genomics tools and QTL mapping populations in
the model plant Arabidopsis opens new perspectives concerning
the identification of tolerance genes to this bacterium. The
feasibility of such approaches with D. dadantii is hampered by the
lack of availability of reliable disease quantification methods. We
addressed this issue by monitoring different disease parameters
in a detailed experimental design. This experimental design was
aimed at validating and comparing the different quantification
methods in order to allow the choice for their use at larger
scales (Table 1). We first supported our previously published
scoring system by a quantitative method based on measurements
of the macerated area. We then showed that quantifying bacterial
populations by qPCR in planta is a reliable method to phenotype
plant susceptibility to D. dadantii. FIGURE 4 | Correlation between lesion surface and bacterial
population estimated by CFU or DNA in Arabidopsis leaves. (A) Bacterial population estimated by CFU was plotted against LS. (B) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR was plotted against LS. (C) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR was plotted against bacterial
populations estimated by CFU in each class of symptoms (S0 = Stage 0,
S0.5 = Stage 0.5, etc). Experiment was repeated twice with similar results. Representative data are shown. Determined coefficients are indicated
(Spearman for A and B, Pearson for C). FIGURE 4 | Correlation between lesion surface and bacterial
population estimated by CFU or DNA in Arabidopsis leaves. FIGURE 4 | Correlation between lesion surface and bacterial
population estimated by CFU or DNA in Arabidopsis leaves. (A) Bacterial population estimated by CFU was plotted against LS. (B) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR was plotted against LS. (C) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR was plotted against bacterial
populations estimated by CFU in each class of symptoms (S0 = Stage 0,
S0.5 = Stage 0.5, etc). Experiment was repeated twice with similar results. Representative data are shown. Determined coefficients are indicated
(Spearman for A and B, Pearson for C). Our data and others’ shows that the infection process by
D. dadantii is quite complex and may result in asymptomatic
lesions containing large amounts of bacteria in some cases, and
important lesion development with limited bacterial populations
in other cases. DISCUSSION This asymptomatic phase led to the proposition
that soft rot causing bacteria may be considered as hemi-
biotrophs (Kraepiel and Barny, 2016). The asymptomatic phase
ends at the onset of pectinase production that is under the
control of a complex regulatory network in Dickeya spp. Signaling networks that sense environmental cues are activated
via transcription factors including KdgR, PecS, Fur, and PecT
responding to pectin fragments, immune signals, iron and
temperature, respectively (Reverchon et al., 2016). In D. dadantii,
a quorum sensing signal produced via a gene cluster named
Vfm; coordinates the production of PCWDE at high bacterial
density (Nasser et al., 2013). Notwithstanding the occurrence
of asymptomatic infections, we show here that it is possible to
obtain reliable estimations of bacterial populations by qPCR that
are equivalent to estimations monitored by the classical CFU Individual Sample Analyses of Bacterial
Population and Symptom Severity Although CFU and Bacterial cell EqDNA do not
derive from the same individuals, this comparison provides an
additional indication that both methods are consistent. To determine whether visible symptoms were correlated with
bacterial titers, we plotted LS against bacterial titers estimated
by CFU or by Bacterial cell EqDNA. Figures 4A,B indicate that
there was a statistically significant linear correlation between
bacterial populations either estimated as CFU or as Bacterial
Cell EqDNA and symptom severity (LS). Interestingly, measured
bacterial populations were most variable at the beginning of the
infection process, corresponding to LS below 0.2 cm2 (stages
1–2). Furthermore, we observed that in some cases bacterial
populations reached higher levels in leaves with low LS compared
to leaves with higher LS, indicating that in some cases bacteria
can survive in leaves under a latent state. Taken together, our
data show that bacterial populations are positively correlated
to disease symptoms. However, bacterial populations in planta March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 6 Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii Rigault et al. FIGURE 4 | Correlation between lesion surface and bacterial
population estimated by CFU or DNA in Arabidopsis leaves. (A) Bacterial population estimated by CFU was plotted against LS. (B) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR was plotted against LS. (C) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR was plotted against bacterial
populations estimated by CFU in each class of symptoms (S0 = Stage 0,
S0.5 = Stage 0.5, etc). Experiment was repeated twice with similar results. Representative data are shown. Determined coefficients are indicated
(Spearman for A and B, Pearson for C). displaying the highest bacterial population estimated by bacterial
cell EqDNA, are Ge-0 and Cvi-0 which are also found in the
most susceptible group according to the LS criterion. Disease
symptoms as LS were plotted against bacterial populations for
each accession to further determine the level of correlation
between these two criteria. We found that the LS and bacterial
DNA were significantly correlated with a correlation coefficient
of 0.62 indicating again that there is an overall consistency
between bacterial populations and visible disease symptoms
although LS is more discriminant in this experiment. Estimation
of bacterial populations provides complementary biological
information about the mechanisms underlying the interaction. Taken together, these data show that although, this pathosystem
presents a difficulty due to the presence of latent bacterial
populations during infection, Arabidopsis is a good model to
study genetic diversity of tolerance. Quantification of Bacterial Populations
on a Collection of Arabidopsis Natural
Accessions To assess whether differential symptom severity on the eight
accessions analyzed in Figure 2 was associated with a differential
pathogen growth, bacterial populations were quantified by qPCR
in these accessions. This allowed the definition of two statistically
distinct groups (Figure 5). According to the bacterial population
estimated by Bacterial cell EqDNA, the most tolerant accessions
are Bur-0 and Edi-0 which are also classified as the most
tolerant according to the LS criterion (Figure 2). The accessions March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org 7 Rigault et al. Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii FIGURE 5 | Quantification of disease and bacterial populations on a collection of Arabidopsis accessions. (A) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR on
the indicated Arabidopsis genotypes 48 h p.i. (B) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR was plotted against LS for each genotype. Experiment was repeated at
least twice with similar results. Representative data are shown. Means with different letters are significantly different at p < 0.05 as determined using XLSTAT ANOVA
Tukey HSD test. FIGURE 5 | Quantification of disease and bacterial populations on a collection of Arabidopsis accessions. (A) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR on
the indicated Arabidopsis genotypes 48 h p.i. (B) Bacterial population estimated by qPCR was plotted against LS for each genotype. Experiment was repeated at
least twice with similar results. Representative data are shown. Means with different letters are significantly different at p < 0.05 as determined using XLSTAT ANOVA
Tukey HSD test. TABLE 1 | Comparative analysis of the different methods to quantify Arabidopsis susceptibility levels against Dickeya dadantii. TABLE 1 | Comparative analysis of the different methods to quantify Arabidopsis susceptibility levels against Dickeya dadantii. Methods to score susceptibility
Advantages
Drawbacks
DSI
– Simple and quick
- Limited precision
LS
– Precise
– Time consuming
– Not informative at later infection stages
CFU/leaf
– Informative about bacterial titer
– Tedious and time consuming
– Cheap
– Underestimates bacterial populations
– Precise
– Requires the use of a strain resistant to an antibiotic
– Requires immediate processing
Bacterial Cell EqDNA/leaf
– Informative about bacterial titer
– Costly
– Simple and quick
– Frozen tissue can be processed after sampling
– Precise omparative analysis of the different methods to quantify Arabidopsis susceptibility levels against Dickeya dadantii. Quantification of Bacterial Populations
on a Collection of Arabidopsis Natural
Accessions TABLE 1 | Comparative analysis of the different methods to quantify Arabidopsis susceptibility levels against Dickeya counting, and that this quantification method is a good indicator
of the overall plant susceptibility (based on measurement of
symptoms). This is consistent with a recent study showing
that Pseudomonas sp. quantification in planta by qPCR is counting, and that this quantification method is a good indicator
of the overall plant susceptibility (based on measurement of
symptoms). This is consistent with a recent study showing
that Pseudomonas sp. quantification in planta by qPCR is correlated with counting of bacterial colonies estimated by
CFU in previously characterized susceptible Arabidopsis mutants
(Ross and Somssich, 2016). In our work, instead of validating the
quantification methods on previously characterized susceptible March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org 8 Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii Rigault et al. mutants, we were able to uncover significantly different
susceptibility groups within a collection of Arabidopsis natural
accessions uncharacterized previously following D. dadantii
infection. be involved in tolerance to bacterial wilt in Medicago truncatula
(Vailleau et al., 2007). By the present work, we provide a tool simple to set up in
order to phenotype sensitivity of Arabidopsis plant genotypes
to the bacterial pathogen D. dadantii. This study demonstrates
that it is possible to conduct a robust phenotyping of soft
rot disease despite the occurrence of latent bacteria, and that
Arabidopsis natural accessions are a relevant source of tolerance
genes. Thus, it would be of great interest to use our scoring
methods to identify tolerance genes either using QTL mapping
in a recombinant segregating population or by performing a
genome wide association study. Quantifying DNA as a phenotyping method is a well-known
method for fungal pathogens (Klosterman, 2012). Estimation
of pathogenic bacteria by qPCR is performed to determine the
level of natural contaminations in the field (Czajkowski et al.,
2015), but it is not routinely used for pathogenic bacteria in
an experimental setting. A previous work showed that it was
possible to use qPCR to study bacterial populations in planta
using Pseudomonas syringae and Pectobacterium carotovorum
as examples (Brouwer et al., 2003), but here we go further to
demonstrate the correlation with CFU and disease severity, a
prerequisite for the use of this technique in experimental plant
pathology. SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online
at: http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpls.2017.00394/
full#supplementary-material ACKNOWLEDGMENT We are grateful to C. R. Tinsley for critical reading of the
manuscript. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS AD: Designed experiments, analyzed the data, and wrote the
paper. MR and AB: performed experiments and analyzed the
data. AD, FC, MF, and CM-D: contributed writing the paper. Quantification of Bacterial Populations
on a Collection of Arabidopsis Natural
Accessions Although quantifying bacterial populations in planta
based on DNA includes dead bacteria, we were able to show
that this does not hamper the significant correlations between
CFU bacterial counting and Bacterial Cell EqDNA. Quantifying
bacterial RNA by RT-qPCR may allow the quantification of
living bacteria. However, this would require the use of a
constitutively expressed bacterial gene in planta, and would
require an additional expensive step, which is the reverse
transcription. FUNDING This work was supported by the grant INRA NITROPATH
BAP2014_63. For most necrotrophs and hemi-biotrophs infecting a large
range of hosts, the genetic determinants of plant immunity rely
on tolerance rather than specific resistance (Lai and Mengiste,
2013; Roux et al., 2014). Thus, it is likely that the plant
immunity against D. dadantii relies on tolerance processes. Because tolerance is a quantitative trait, the availability of
powerful quantification methods is crucial. Tolerance is usually
controlled by multiple loci and resistance is usually controlled
by a single locus encoding a resistance (R) gene (St Clair, 2010). However, some exceptions do exist especially with the example of
the bacterial wilt Ralstonia solanacearum (Huet, 2014). Tolerance
can be conferred by a single R gene like it is the case for the R
gene RRS-1 that confers tolerance in Arabidopsis accession Kil-0
(Van der Linden et al., 2013). Conversely, multiple R genes can REFERENCES (2008). The GacA global regulator is required for the appropriate
expression of Erwinia chrysanthemi 3937 pathogenicity genes during plant
infection. Environ. Microbiol. 10, 545–559. doi: 10.1111/j.1462-2920.2007. 01473.x Tornero, P., and Dangl, J. L. (2001). A high-throughput method for quantifying
growth of phytopathogenic bacteria in Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant J. 28,
475–481. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-313X.2001.01136.x Toth, I. K., Bell, K. S., Holeva, M. C., and Birch, P. R. J. (2003). Soft rot erwiniae:
from genes to genomes. Mol. Plant Pathol. 4, 17–30. doi: 10.1046/j.1364-3703. 2003.00149.x Lemaitre, T., Gaufichon, L., Boutet-Mercey, S., Christ, A., and Masclaux-
Daubresse, C. (2008). Enzymatic and metabolic diagnostic of nitrogen
deficiency in Arabidopsis thaliana Wassileskija accession. Plant Cell Physiol. 49,
1056–1065. doi: 10.1093/pcp/pcn081 Toth, I. K., van der Wolf, J. M., Saddler, G., Lojkowska, E., Helias, V., Pirhonen, M.,
et al. (2011). Dickeya species: an emerging problem for potato production in
Europe. Plant Pathol. 60, 385–399. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3059.2011.02427.x Trontin, C., Tisne, S., Bach, L., and Loudet, O. (2011). What does Arabidopsis
natural variation teach us (and does not teach us) about adaptation in plants? Curr. Opin. Plant Biol. 14, 225–231. doi: 10.1016/j.pbi.2011.03.024 Mollet, C., Drancourt, M., and Raoult, D. (1997). rpoB sequence analysis as a novel
basis for bacterial identification. Mol. Microbiol. 26, 1005–1011. doi: 10.1046/j. 1365-2958.1997.6382009.x Mutka, A. M., and Bart, R. S. (2015). Image-based phenotyping of plant disease
symptoms. Front. Plant Sci. 5:734. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2014.00734 Vailleau, F., Sartorel, E., Jardinaud, M. F., Chardon, F., Genin, S., Huguet, T., et al. (2007). Characterization of the interaction between the bacterial wilt pathogen
Ralstonia solanacearum and the model legume plant Medicago truncatula. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 20, 159–167. doi: 10.1094/mpmi-20-20-0159 Nam Phuong, K., Aznar, A., Segond, D., Rigault, M., Simond-Cote, E., Kunz, C.,
et al. (2012). Iron deficiency affects plant defence responses and confers
resistance to Dickeya dadantii and Botrytis cinerea. Mol. Plant Pathol. 13,
816–827. doi: 10.1111/j.1364-3703.2012.00790.x Van der Linden, L., Bredenkamp, J., Naidoo, S., Fouche-Weich, J., Denby, K. J.,
Genin, S., et al. (2013). Gene-for-gene tolerance to bacterial wilt in Arabidopsis. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 26, 398–406. doi: 10.1094/mpmi-07-12-0188-r Nasser, W., Dorel, C., Wawrzyniak, J., Van Gijsegem, F., Groleau, M. C., Deziel, E.,
et al. (2013). Vfm a new quorum sensing system controls the virulence of
Dickeya dadantii. Environ. Microbiol. 15, 865–880. doi: 10.1111/1462-2920. 12049 van Kan, J. A. L. (2006). Licensed to kill: the lifestyle of a necrotrophic plant
pathogen. Trends Plant Sci. 11, 247–253. REFERENCES Dickeya ecology, environment sensing and
regulation of virulence programme. Environ. Microbiol. Rep. 5, 622–636. doi:
10.1111/1758-2229.12073 Erwinia chrysanthemi. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 20, 794–805. doi: 10.1094/
mpmi-20-7-0794 Herigstad, B., Hamilton, M., and Heersink, J. (2001). How to optimize the drop
plate method for enumerating bacteria. J. Microbiol. Methods 44, 121–129. doi: 10.1016/s0167-7012(00)00241-4 Reverchon, S., Rouanet, C., Expert, D., and Nasser, W. (2002). Characterization of
indigoidine Biosynthetic genes in Erwinia chrysanthemi and role of this blue
pigment in pathogenicity. J. Bacteriol. 184, 654–665. doi: 10.1128/JB.184.3.654-
665.2002 Huet, G. (2014). Breeding for resistances to Ralstonia solanacearum. Front. Plant
Sci. 5:715. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2014.00715 Ross, A., and Somssich, I. E. (2016). A DNA-based real-time PCR assay for
robust growth quantification of the bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas syringae Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat, N., Condemine, G., and Shevchik, V. E. (2014). Bacterial
pectate lyases, structural and functional diversity. Environ. Microbiol. Rep. 6,
427–440. doi: 10.1111/1758-2229.12166 Ross, A., and Somssich, I. E. (2016). A DNA-based real-time PCR assay for
robust growth quantification of the bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas syringae
on Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Methods 12:48. doi: 10.1186/s13007-016-0149-z robust growth quantification of the bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas syringae
on Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Methods 12:48. doi: 10.1186/s13007-016-0149-z Hutchison, C. A., and Venter, J. C. (2006). Single-cell genomics. Nat. Biotechnol. 24, 657–658. doi: 10.1038/nbt0606-657 Roux, F., Voisin, D., Badet, T., Balague, C., Barlet, X., Huard-Chauveau, C., et al. (2014). Resistance to phytopathogens e tutti quanti: placing plant quantitative
disease resistance on the map. Mol. Plant Pathol. 15, 427–432. doi: 10.1111/
mpp.12138 Klosterman, S. J. (2012). “Real-time PCR for the quantification of fungi in planta,”
in Plant Fungal Pathogens: Methods and Protocols, Vol. 835, eds M. D. Bolton
and B. P. H. J. Thomma 121–132. doi: 10.1007/978-1-61779-501-5_8 Santos, R., Franza, T., Laporte, M. L., Sauvage, C., Touati, D., and Expert, D. (2001). Essential role of superoxide dismutase on the pathogenicity of Erwinia
chrysanthemi strain 3937. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 14, 758–767. doi: 10. 1094/MPMI.2001.14.6.758 Kraepiel, Y., and Barny, M. A. (2016). Gram-negative phytopathogenic bacteria,
all hemibiotrophs after all? Mol. Plant Pathol. 17, 313–316. doi: 10.1111/mpp. 12345 St Clair, D. A. (2010). Quantitative disease resistance and quantitative resistance
loci in breeding. Annu. Rev. Phytopathol. 48, 247–268. doi: 10.1146/annurev-
phyto-080508-081904 Lai, Z. B., and Mengiste, T. (2013). Genetic and cellular mechanisms regulating
plant responses to necrotrophic pathogens. Curr. Opin. Plant Biol. 16, 505–512. doi: 10.1016/j.pbi.2013.06.014 Lebeau, A., Reverchon, S., Gaubert, S., Kraepiel, Y., Simond-Cote, E., Nasser, W.,
et al. REFERENCES fluorescence PCR. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 228, 241–248. doi: 10.1016/s0378-
1097(03)00759-6 Antunez-Lamas, M., Cabrera-Ordonez, E., Lopez-Solanilla, E., Raposo, R., Trelles-
Salazar, O., Rodriguez-Moreno, A., et al. (2009). Role of motility and chemotaxis
in the pathogenesis of Dickeya dadantii 3937 (ex Erwinia chrysanthemi 3937). Microbiology 155, 434–442. doi: 10.1099/mic.0.022244-0 Chapelle, E., Alunni, B., Malfatti, P., Solier, L., Pedron, J., Kraepiel, Y., et al. (2015). A straightforward and reliable method for bacterial in planta transcriptomics:
application to the Dickeya dadantii/Arabidopsis thaliana pathosystem. Plant J. 82, 352–362. doi: 10.1111/tpj.12812 Czajkowski, R., Perombelon, M. C. M., Jafra, S., Lojkowska, E., Potrykus, M., van
der Wolf, J. M., et al. (2015). Detection, identification and differentiation
of
Pectobacterium
and
Dickeya
species
causing
potato
blackleg
and
tuber soft rot: a review. Ann. Appl. Biol. 166, 18–38. doi: 10.1111/aab. 12166 Asselbergh, B., Achuo, A. E., Hofte, M., and Van Gijsegem, F. (2008). Abscisic acid
deficiency leads to rapid activation of tomato defence responses upon infection
with Erwinia chrysanthemi. Mol. Plant Pathol. 9, 11–24. doi: 10.1111/j.1364-
3703.2007.00437.x Aznar, A., Chen, N. W. G., Rigault, M., Riache, N., Joseph, D., Desmaele, D.,
et al. (2014). Scavenging iron: a novel mechanism of plant immunity activation
by microbial siderophores. Plant Physiol. 164, 2167–2183. doi: 10.1104/pp.113. 233585 Czajkowski, R., Perombelon, M. C. M., van Veen, J. A., and van der Wolf,
J. M. (2011). Control of blackleg and tuber soft rot of potato caused by
Pectobacterium and Dickeya species: a review. Plant Pathol. 60, 999–1013. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3059.2011.02470.x Aznar, A., Chen, N. W. G., Thomine, S., and Dellagi, A. (2015). Immunity to plant
pathogens and iron homeostasis. Plant Sci. 240, 90–97. doi: 10.1016/j.plantsci. 2015.08.022 Dangl, J. L., Horvath, D. M., and Staskawicz, B. J. (2013). Pivoting the
plant immune system from dissection to deployment. Science 341, 746–751. doi: 10.1126/science.1236011 Brouwer, M., Lievens, B., Van Hemelrijck, W., Van den Ackerveken, G., Cammue,
B. P. A., and Thomma, B. (2003). Quantification of disease progression
of several microbial pathogens on Arabidopsis thaliana using real-time Fagard, M., Dellagi, A., Roux, C., Perino, C., Rigault, M., Boucher, V., et al. (2007). Arabidopsis thaliana expresses multiple lines of defense to counterattack March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org 9 Natural Variation of Arabidopsis Susceptibility to Dickeya dadantii Rigault et al. Erwinia chrysanthemi. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 20, 794–805. doi: 10.1094/
mpmi-20-7-0794 Reverchon, S., and Nasser, W. (2013). Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org REFERENCES doi: 10.1016/j.tplants.2006.03.005 Williams-Nguyen, J., Sallach, J. B., Bartelt-Hunt, S., Boxall, A. B., Durso,
L. M., McLain, J. E., et al. (2016). Antibiotics and antibiotic resistance in
agroecosystems: state of the science. J. Environ. Qual. 45, 394–406. doi: 10.2134/
jeq2015.07.0336 Pajerowska-Mukhtar, K. M., Mukhtar, M. S., Guex, N., Halim, V. A., Rosahl, S.,
Somssich, I. E., et al. (2008). Natural variation of potato allene oxide synthase 2
causes differential levels of jasmonates and pathogen resistance in Arabidopsis. Planta 228, 293–306. doi: 10.1007/s00425-008-0737-x Conflict of Interest Statement: The authors declare that the research was
conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could
be construed as a potential conflict of interest. Pedron, J., Mondy, S., des Essarts, Y. R., Van Gijsegem, F., and Faure, D. (2014). Genomic and metabolic comparison with Dickeya dadantii 3937 reveals the
emerging Dickeya solani potato pathogen to display distinctive metabolic
activities and T5SS/T6SS-related toxin repertoire. BMC Genomics 15:283. doi: 10.1186/1471-2164-15-283 Copyright © 2017 Rigault, Buellet, Masclaux-Daubresse, Fagard, Chardon and
Dellagi. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in
other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) or licensor are credited
and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted
academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not
comply with these terms. Piquerez, S. J. M., Harvey, S. E., Beynon, J. L., and Ntoukakis, V. (2014). Improving
crop disease resistance: lessons from research on Arabidopsis and tomato. Front. Plant Sci. 5:671. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2014.00671 Reverchon, S., Muskhelisvili, G., and Nasser, W. (2016). Virulence program of a
bacterial plant pathogen: the Dickeya model. Prog. Mol. Biol. Transl. Sci. 142,
51–92. doi: 10.1016/bs.pmbts.2016.05.005 March 2017 | Volume 8 | Article 394 Frontiers in Plant Science | www.frontiersin.org 10
|
https://openalex.org/W2916422292
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc6382824?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
CXCR4 signaling regulates metastatic onset by controlling neutrophil motility and response to malignant cells
|
Scientific reports
| 2,019
|
cc-by
| 14,128
|
CXCR4 signaling regulates
metastatic onset by controlling
neutrophil motility and response to
malignant cells Received: 9 May 2018
Accepted: 18 December 2018
Published: xx xx xxxx C. Tulotta, C. Stefanescu, Q. Chen, V. Torraca , A. H. Meijer & B. E. Snaar-Jagalska Developing tumors interact with the surrounding microenvironment. Myeloid cells exert both anti- and
pro-tumor functions and chemokines are known to drive immune cell migration towards cancer cells. It is documented that CXCR4 signaling supports tumor metastasis formation in tissues where CXCL12,
its cognate ligand, is abundant. On the other hand, the role of the neutrophilic CXCR4 signaling in
driving cancer invasion and metastasis formation is poorly understood. Here, we use the zebrafish
xenotransplantation model to study the role of CXCR4 signaling in driving the interaction between
invasive human tumor cells and host neutrophils, supporting early metastasis formation. We found
that zebrafish cxcr4 (cxcr4b) is highly expressed in neutrophils and experimental micrometastases fail
to form in mutant larvae lacking a functional Cxcr4b. We demonstrated that Cxcr4b controls neutrophil
number and motility and showed that Cxcr4b transcriptomic signature relates to motility and adhesion
regulation in neutrophils in tumor-naïve larvae. Finally, Cxcr4b deficient neutrophils failed to interact
with cancer cells initiating early metastatic events. In conclusion, we propose that CXCR4 signaling
supports the interaction between tumor cells and host neutrophils in developing tumor metastases. Therefore, targeting CXCR4 on tumor cells and neutrophils could serve as a double bladed razor to limit
cancer progression. Tumor-microenvironment interactions are crucial in cancer pathogenesis and several signals drive this com-
munication1. The composition of cancer microenvironments changes during cancer progression2. Fibroblasts,
endothelial and immune cells are main components of the tumor stroma, acting in concert with the extracellular
matrix (ECM), growth factors, proteases and cytokines3. The CXCR4-CXCL12 chemokine signaling axis sustains
tumor cell growth and directs the formation of distant metastases. It is established that cancer cells expressing
CXCR4 home to secondary organs where CXCL12 is highly secreted, mainly by mesenchymal stromal cells4. Moreover, CXCL12 guides the migration of stromal cells that express CXCR4 and locally infiltrate the tumor,
providing support by secretion of growth and angiogenic factors, as well as promoting metastasis through acti-
vation of epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) via mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK), phospho-
inositide 3-kinase/Protein kinase B (PI3K/AKT) and nuclear factor kappa-light-chain-enhancer of activated B
cells (NFKB) pathways3,5. A dual role in either supporting or inhibiting tumor progression has been linked with the immune system1. www.nature.com/scientificreports www.nature.com/scientificreports www.nature.com/scientificreports Received: 9 May 2018
Accepted: 18 December 2018
Published: xx xx xxxx CXCR4 signaling regulates
metastatic onset by controlling
neutrophil motility and response to
malignant cells CXCR4-CXCL12 signaling has been associated with the polarization towards an immune-suppressive microen-
vironment: the possible role of a CXCL12 shield that protects cancer cells from being recognized by cytotoxic
lymphocytes and activates regulatory T-cells has recently been described6. Polarization of macrophages towards
a M2 phenotype has also been associated with tumor survival. Recent studies have pointed at the role of perivas-
cular CXCR4-expressing M2 macrophages in creating tumor vascular networks after chemotherapy, leading to
tumor relapse, and confirmed CXCR4 as M2 marker7. It has been shown that CXCR4 can also be activated by
alternative ligands like MIF (Macrophage Migration Inhibitory Factor)8. MIF signalling has been associated to
inflammatory diseases. Upon binding to CXCR4 or CXCR2, MIF controls monocyte and T cell chemotaxis and its
blockade leads to plaque regression in atherosclerosis8. In zebrafish, MIF functions as a neurotrophin during the Institute of Biology, Leiden University, Gorlaeus Laboratories, Einsteinweg 55, 2333 CC, Leiden, The Netherlands. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to B.E.S.-J. (email: b.e.snaar-jagalska@biology. leidenuniv.nl) Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 1 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ development of the inner ear9. In cancer, MIF-CXCR4 signalling has been linked to Mesenchymal Stromal Cell
(MSC) homing to tumours both in vitro and in vivo10. The FDA-approved CXCR4 antagonist AMD3100 inhibits
MIF binding to CXCR4. However, because higher concentration of the antagonist is required to inhibit MIF bind-
ing to CXCR4 compared to CXCL12, it is likely that MIF binds to CXCR4 via a different mechanism compared
to CXCL12 binding11. We previously showed that metastasis formation is inhibited in a cxcl12 zebrafish mutant,
suggesting a pivotal role of the cxcl12-cxcr4 signaling axis in this process12.il gg
g
p
g
g
p
Neutrophils are the most abundant white blood cells and the major first responders during inflammation13. In cancer, neutrophils are recruited to neoplastic sites and together with other immune cells have been shown to
provide trophic signals that support tumor growth, angiogenesis, tumor cell motility and invasion of surrounding
tissues14–17. Neutrophils have been classified in N1 (anti-tumor) and N2 (pro-tumor) types18–20. The polarization
of neutrophils towards one or the other type is driven by a plethora of cytokines and chemokines that often direct
the same polarization in macrophages. CXCR4 signaling regulates
metastatic onset by controlling
neutrophil motility and response to
malignant cells In particular, pro-inflammatory molecules such as interferon β (IFNβ),
interleukin-1β (IL1β) and tumour necrosis factor α (TNFα) induce the polarization towards type 1 phenotypes,
while interleukin 10 (IL-10) and transforming growth factor β (TGFβ) are immunosuppressive and inhibitory of
inflammation, skewing neutrophil polarity towards N2. Pro-tumoral and pro-angiogenic N2 neutrophils express
high levels of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), metalloprotease 9 MMP9 and CXCR420. In addition,
amongst different metalloproteases, MMP9 plays a key role in HSCs mobilisation from the bone marrow. CXCR4
expression is regulated by MMP9. Simultaneously MMP9 and CXCL12 expression is reciprocally regulated in
bone marrow cells21. Neutrophils have been reported to display overlapping as well as complementary functions with macrophages
in infection and tumor relapse after chemotherapy22,23. Interestingly, tissue-resident macrophages, originated
from the fetal liver during embryo development, and monocyte-derived macrophages, originated from hemato-
poietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs) in the adult bone marrow, work in concert to regulate recruitment of
neutrophils in inflamed tissues, through epithelial layers24. Recent findings suggest that neutrophils work together
with macrophages to regulate the hematopoietic niche25. The bone microenvironment represent a favorable site
of metastatic growth for different tumor types, suggesting a possible involvement of the signals that regulate bone
marrow and hematopoietic niche homeostasis26. Among those, CXCR4-CXCL12 signaling is a major candidate,
considering its fundamental role in orchestrating HSPC and neutrophil retention in and mobilization from the
bone marrow, with the involvement of the CXCL1/CXCL2-CXCR2 chemokine axis27–29.hi The use of the zebrafish embryo as a xenotransplantation model has shown that hematogenously inoculated
tumor cells home in the caudal hematopoietic tissue (CHT), where tumor growth and invasion take place, initi-
ating early metastatic events30. The CHT is an intermediate site of hematopoiesis during zebrafish embryogenesis
and is the functional analogue of the fetal liver in mammalian development31. Previous work from our group
has suggested the role of neutrophils in preparing the metastatic niche by non-pathological transmigration from
the CHT to the tail fin and vice versa. In their random motility, neutrophils form paths in the collagen, favoring
tumor cell invasion30. We previously addressed the role of cell-autonomous CXCR4 signaling in early metastases
in the zebrafish xenograft model12. Here, we address the role of the host-dependent CXCR4 signaling in driving
the communication between tumor cells and neutrophils, during experimental metastasis formation in an in vivo
zebrafish xenogeneic model. Results
M
l id Myeloid cells support tumor early metastatic events. Immune cells play dual roles during cancer pro-
gression. Inhibitory and supportive functions of the immune system have been associated with tumor growth and
metastasis formation. Using the zebrafish embryo model we previously showed that myeloid cells, mainly neu-
trophils, support the establishment of tumor experimental micrometastasis, when the MAE-FGF2 transformed
cell line was inoculated into the blood circulation of 2-day-old embryos30. Therefore, we used the same approach
to investigate whether zebrafish myeloid cells exert similar tumor supportive functions, when other cell lines
were implanted. In particular, we used the osteotropic triple negative breast cancer line MDA-MB-231-B, derived
from bone metastases in a mouse xenograft model32. The zebrafish embryo model bears the great advantage of
studying the contribution of the innate immune system during early metastasis formation separately from the
adaptive immunity, which reaches full maturity in 3–4 week old juveniles33. To deplete both neutrophils and mac-
rophages, we injected Pu.1/Spi1b morpholino (1 mM) into 1–2 cell stage embryos. Subsequently, the MDA-MB-
231-B cell line was inoculated into the blood circulation of 2-day post fertilization (dpf) zebrafish embryos with
GFP-expressing neutrophils. The reporter line Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 34 was used to monitor neutrophil depletion, in
view of the time-limited efficacy of gene knock-down obtained with morpholino anti-sense oligos. Macrophage
depletion was not monitored as it already occurs with lower doses of the same morpholino (0.5 mM)30. Tumor
phenotype assessment was performed 2-day post implantation (dpi) by quantifying tumor cell invasion in each
larva. Depletion of myeloid cells in the Pu.1 morphants resulted in a reduced cancer cell invasion (68%) in the
tail fin in proximity of the caudal hematopoietic tissue (CHT) (Fig. 1). As previously found, the CHT, a site of
hematopoiesis and analogous to the fetal liver during mammalian development, is a preferential site of early can-
cer metastasis formation in the zebrafish xenotransplantation model. In conclusion, myeloid cells support triple
negative breast cancer early metastasis onset in zebrafish. Neutrophilic Cxcr4 signaling is involved in early tumor metastasis initiation. Therapeutic target-
ing of CXCR4 on tumor cells could be an effective strategy to limit tumor cell growth and metastasis. However,
CXCR4 signaling in the tumor microenvironment also plays a central role in cancer and further investigations are
needed to fully understand its contribution. y
In our model, teleost evolution has led to a cxcr4 gene duplication. Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 Results
M
l id Importantly, neu-
trophilic cxcr4b levels were at least 100-fold higher than neutrophilic cxcr4a, indicating that cxcr4b is the pre-
dominant human CXCR4 orthologue in zebrafish larval neutrophils (Fig. 2A). Therefore, to study if CXCR4
signaling in the tumor microenvironment supports cancer metastasis initiation, we engrafted the triple nega-
tive breast cancer cell line MDA-MB-231-B in the cxcr4bt26035 (odysseus or ody) mutant with deficient cxcr4b36. Xenogeneic transplantation into the blood circulation via the duct of Cuvier resulted in a strong proliferating and
invasive tumor phenotype, characterized by experimental micrometastasis formation in the CHT region in the
wild-type (wt) siblings, whereas a significant reduction was observed in the cxcr4b−/−, ody mutants (Fig. 2B–E). The establishment of early metastatic events defined by tumor mass formation and extravasation followed by
local tissue invasion was monitored by fluorescence at 2 (Fig. 2B,C) and 4 (Fig. 2D,E) days after engraftment and
tumor burden was found to be significantly inhibited in ody larvae (22.5% and 40.5% reduction at 2 and 4 dpi,
respectively). In order to test whether Cxcr4 signaling inhibition in the microenvironment could affect the met-
astatic cascade in other tumor types, we engrafted another triple negative breast cancer cell line MDA-MB-157
(Fig. 3A,B), as well as prostate cancer cells PC3-M-Pro4-Luc2 (Fig. 3C,D) and the Ewing sarcoma cell line WE68
(Fig. 3E,F). Tumor early metastasis establishment in the CHT region of 4 dpi zebrafish larvae was impaired in the
ody mutant line compared to the wt siblings, when each cell line was inoculated into the blood circulation (reduc-
tion of tumor burden was 52%, 38% and 70% in breast, prostate and Ewing sarcoma tumor cell lines, respectively)
(Fig. 3). Therefore, we suggest that neutrophilic Cxcr4 signaling plays a crucial role in the early steps of metastases
formation of triple negative breast cancer as well as other tumor types. Cxcr4b signaling inhibition attenuates neutrophil basal motility and development. CXCR4
signaling has been found to play an important role in regulating neutrophil retention in the CHT in the WHIM
syndrome, where neutropenia has been linked to increased susceptibility to infection in patients as well as in the
zebrafish model37,38. Therefore, as neutrophils express high levels of cxcr4b, we investigated whether the impair-
ment of Cxcr4 signaling affects the motility of neutrophils in the CHT region, altering their ability to prepare
the metastatic niche. Neutrophil migration under physiological conditions was recorded for 30 min as previ-
ously described30. Results
M
l id cxcr4a and cxcr4b paralogues are expre
by different cell types, although redundant functions have been reported35. The CXCL12-CXCR4 signalin Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 2 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 1. Myeloid cell depletion impairs tumor cell invasion. (A) Relative tumor invasion was compared at 2
dpi in Pu.1 morphants, depleted of neutrophils and macrophages, and larvae injected with control morpholino
(68% inhibition). Two-tailed un-paired t-test with Welch’s correction (****p < 0.0001) was performed on a
pool of two biological replicates (Control: n = 84, Pu.1: n = 67). Data are mean ± SEM. (B) Top panel shows
MDA-MB-231-B cells forming a tumor mass and invading the tail fin tissue (bright field image, top right), while
surrounded by GFP expressing neutrophils in 2 dpi Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 injected with a control morpholino. In the
bottom image, neutrophils are absent due to Pu.1 knockdown and a smaller tumor mass is formed compared to
the control condition, resulting in impaired invasion of the local tissue (bright field, top right). Scale bar: 50 µm. Micrographs were acquired using a Leica MZ16FA fluorescent microscope coupled to a DFC420C camera. Figure 1. Myeloid cell depletion impairs tumor cell invasion. (A) Relative tumor invasion was compared at 2
dpi in Pu.1 morphants, depleted of neutrophils and macrophages, and larvae injected with control morpholino
(68% inhibition). Two-tailed un-paired t-test with Welch’s correction (****p < 0.0001) was performed on a
pool of two biological replicates (Control: n = 84, Pu.1: n = 67). Data are mean ± SEM. (B) Top panel shows
MDA-MB-231-B cells forming a tumor mass and invading the tail fin tissue (bright field image, top right), while
surrounded by GFP expressing neutrophils in 2 dpi Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 injected with a control morpholino. In the
bottom image, neutrophils are absent due to Pu.1 knockdown and a smaller tumor mass is formed compared to
the control condition, resulting in impaired invasion of the local tissue (bright field, top right). Scale bar: 50 µm. Micrographs were acquired using a Leica MZ16FA fluorescent microscope coupled to a DFC420C camera. conserved between zebrafish and human: zebrafish Cxcr4 receptors display more than 60% identity with human
CXCR4 and zebrafish Cxcl12 ligands have more than 65% identity with human CXCL1212. We performed tran-
scriptome analysis of GFP positive, FACS-sorted neutrophils from 5 dpf Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 larvae and RNA deep
sequencing revealed high expression levels of the cxcr4 paralogues in neutrophils. Results
M
l id In particular, cxcr4a and cxcr4b
transcriptomic levels were higher in the GFP+ fractions compared to the GFP− populations. Importantly, neu-
trophilic cxcr4b levels were at least 100-fold higher than neutrophilic cxcr4a, indicating that cxcr4b is the pre-
dominant human CXCR4 orthologue in zebrafish larval neutrophils (Fig. 2A). Therefore, to study if CXCR4
signaling in the tumor microenvironment supports cancer metastasis initiation, we engrafted the triple nega-
tive breast cancer cell line MDA-MB-231-B in the cxcr4bt26035 (odysseus or ody) mutant with deficient cxcr4b36. Xenogeneic transplantation into the blood circulation via the duct of Cuvier resulted in a strong proliferating and
invasive tumor phenotype, characterized by experimental micrometastasis formation in the CHT region in the
wild-type (wt) siblings, whereas a significant reduction was observed in the cxcr4b−/−, ody mutants (Fig. 2B–E). The establishment of early metastatic events defined by tumor mass formation and extravasation followed by
local tissue invasion was monitored by fluorescence at 2 (Fig. 2B,C) and 4 (Fig. 2D,E) days after engraftment and
tumor burden was found to be significantly inhibited in ody larvae (22.5% and 40.5% reduction at 2 and 4 dpi,
respectively). In order to test whether Cxcr4 signaling inhibition in the microenvironment could affect the met-
astatic cascade in other tumor types, we engrafted another triple negative breast cancer cell line MDA-MB-157
(Fig. 3A,B), as well as prostate cancer cells PC3-M-Pro4-Luc2 (Fig. 3C,D) and the Ewing sarcoma cell line WE68
(Fig. 3E,F). Tumor early metastasis establishment in the CHT region of 4 dpi zebrafish larvae was impaired in the
ody mutant line compared to the wt siblings, when each cell line was inoculated into the blood circulation (reduc-
tion of tumor burden was 52%, 38% and 70% in breast, prostate and Ewing sarcoma tumor cell lines, respectively)
(Fig. 3). Therefore, we suggest that neutrophilic Cxcr4 signaling plays a crucial role in the early steps of metastases
formation of triple negative breast cancer as well as other tumor types. conserved between zebrafish and human: zebrafish Cxcr4 receptors display more than 60% identity with human
CXCR4 and zebrafish Cxcl12 ligands have more than 65% identity with human CXCL1212. We performed tran-
scriptome analysis of GFP positive, FACS-sorted neutrophils from 5 dpf Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 larvae and RNA deep
sequencing revealed high expression levels of the cxcr4 paralogues in neutrophils. In particular, cxcr4a and cxcr4b
transcriptomic levels were higher in the GFP+ fractions compared to the GFP− populations. Results
M
l id Neutrophils displayed reduced motility when Cxcr4b signaling was impaired in the ody mutant Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 3 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 2. cxcr4b is highly expressed in neutrophils and loss of function results in reduced triple negative
breast cancer burden. (A) cxcr4a and cxcr4b expression levels were quantified in neutrophils and compared to
the GFP negative cell population. Data are read counts from RNA sequencing performed on three biological
replicates. FACS-sorted neutrophils were obtained from 5 dpf Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 larvae. cxcr4a and cxcr4b gene
expression was enriched in neutrophils compared to GFP negative cells in zebrafish larvae (~4-fold and ~10-
fold, respectively). cxcr4b was highly expressed in neutrophils compared to cxcr4a (~100-fold increased gene
expression). (B) Relative metastatic tumor burden of MDA-MB-231-B-DsRed cells was quantified in ody and
wt siblings at 2 dpi. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 64, ody: n = 57). Un-paired
t-test ****p < 0.0001. (C) MDA-MB-231-B tumor cells established a secondary tumor mass, with initiation
of single cell extravasation, in wt larvae, whereas a phenotype inhibition was found in ody mutants at 2 dpi
(22.5% reduction). (D) MDA-MB-231-B tumor burden was measured in wt and cxcr4b null mutants at 4 dpi, at
the metastatic site where secondary growth began at 2 dpi. A 40.5% reduction in tumor burden was observed. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 59, ody: n = 43). Un-paired t-test, with Welch’s
correction ****p < 0.0001. (E) Highly invasive cancer cells displayed aggressive and metastatic features in wt
siblings, whereas few cells remained in the CHT region of 4 dpi ody larvae. Scale bars: 50 µm. Micrographs are
acquired using a Leica MZ16FA fluorescent microscope coupled to a DFC420C camera. Figure 2. cxcr4b is highly expressed in neutrophils and loss of function results in reduced triple negative
breast cancer burden. (A) cxcr4a and cxcr4b expression levels were quantified in neutrophils and compared to
the GFP negative cell population. Data are read counts from RNA sequencing performed on three biological
replicates. FACS-sorted neutrophils were obtained from 5 dpf Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 larvae. cxcr4a and cxcr4b gene
expression was enriched in neutrophils compared to GFP negative cells in zebrafish larvae (~4-fold and ~10-
fold, respectively). cxcr4b was highly expressed in neutrophils compared to cxcr4a (~100-fold increased gene
expression). Results
M
l id (B) Relative metastatic tumor burden of MDA-MB-231-B-DsRed cells was quantified in ody and
wt siblings at 2 dpi. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 64, ody: n = 57). Un-paired
t-test ****p < 0.0001. (C) MDA-MB-231-B tumor cells established a secondary tumor mass, with initiation
of single cell extravasation, in wt larvae, whereas a phenotype inhibition was found in ody mutants at 2 dpi
(22.5% reduction). (D) MDA-MB-231-B tumor burden was measured in wt and cxcr4b null mutants at 4 dpi, at
the metastatic site where secondary growth began at 2 dpi. A 40.5% reduction in tumor burden was observed. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 59, ody: n = 43). Un-paired t-test, with Welch’s
correction ****p < 0.0001. (E) Highly invasive cancer cells displayed aggressive and metastatic features in wt
siblings, whereas few cells remained in the CHT region of 4 dpi ody larvae. Scale bars: 50 µm. Micrographs are
acquired using a Leica MZ16FA fluorescent microscope coupled to a DFC420C camera. compared to the wt siblings (Fig. 4A–C). We have previously shown that neutrophils prepare the metastatic niche
by creating paths into the collagen, during the transmigration from the CHT to the tail fin. Hence, we hypothe-
sized that path formation is linked to metalloprotease activity. Therefore, we quantified mmp9 expression in ody
and wt siblings (whole body) and found decreased mRNA levels upon Cxcr4b inhibition (Fig. 4D).i g
y
g
Next, neutrophil number in the CHT and whole body was verified at 6 days post fertilization when metasta-
sis formation was assessed. Neutrophil number was lower in the CHT of ody mutants compared to wt siblings
(Fig. 4E,F). Moreover, at the same time point, the total body count of neutrophils was found to be lower (Fig. 4G),
suggesting that Cxcr4b controls neutrophil development.ii gg
g
p
p
During zebrafish development, primitive and definitive waves of hematopoiesis can be distinguished. In a
transition phase, between 24 and 36 hpf, neutrophils originate from the posterior blood island (PBI), which, with
the onset of the definitive wave, is replaced by the CHT39. Recent studies in zebrafish have revealed that CXCR4
signaling has a direct link with the development of HSPCs, mainly affecting their ability to colonize the CHT,
which functions as an intermediate hematopoietic site40. Results
M
l id In the same study, the use of the CXCR4 antagonist Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 4 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 3. cxcr4b deficient host blocks metastatic burden of different tumor types. (A) Metastatic burden was
assessed in 4 dpi zebrafish larvae engrafted with the triple negative breast line MDA-MB-157 mCherry. A 52%
reduction was found. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 42, ody: n = 28). Un-
paired t-test, with Welch’s correction ****p < 0.0001. (B) Secondary tumor mass, extravasation and invasion
failed to occur in ody mutants compared to wt siblings. (C) A significantly lower tumor burden in cxcr4b
deficient larvae was observed when the prostate cancer PC3-M-Pro4-Luc2 mCherry or td-tomato cell line was
implanted (38% reduction). Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 48, ody: n = 46). Un-paired t-test ****p < 0.0001. (D) Prostate cancer early metastasis formation, characterized by a solid tumor
mass formation in the CHT region of zebrafish larvae, occurred in wt siblings and was significantly decreased
when Cxcr4b signaling was impaired in the host. (E) Relative metastatic burden of Ewing sarcoma cell line
WE-68 td-tomato was affected in ody mutants compared to wt larvae at 4 dpi (70% reduction in tumor burden
in the tail fin). Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 69, ody: n = 39). Un-paired t-test,
with Welch’s correction ****p < 0.0001. (F) Ewing sarcoma cells formed a compact and expanding tumor mass
in the CHT region, between the dorsal aorta and the caudal vein. A reduced tumor cell aggregate was present in
the ody mutant line at 4 dpi. Scale bars: 50 µm. Micrographs were acquired using a Leica MZ16FA fluorescent
microscope coupled to a DFC420C camera. Figure 3. cxcr4b deficient host blocks metastatic burden of different tumor types. (A) Metastatic burden was
assessed in 4 dpi zebrafish larvae engrafted with the triple negative breast line MDA-MB-157 mCherry. A 52%
reduction was found. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 42, ody: n = 28). Un-
paired t-test, with Welch’s correction ****p < 0.0001. (B) Secondary tumor mass, extravasation and invasion
failed to occur in ody mutants compared to wt siblings. (C) A significantly lower tumor burden in cxcr4b
deficient larvae was observed when the prostate cancer PC3-M-Pro4-Luc2 mCherry or td-tomato cell line was
implanted (38% reduction). Results
M
l id Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 48, ody: n = 46). Un-paired t-test ****p < 0.0001. (D) Prostate cancer early metastasis formation, characterized by a solid tumor
mass formation in the CHT region of zebrafish larvae, occurred in wt siblings and was significantly decreased
when Cxcr4b signaling was impaired in the host. (E) Relative metastatic burden of Ewing sarcoma cell line
WE-68 td-tomato was affected in ody mutants compared to wt larvae at 4 dpi (70% reduction in tumor burden
in the tail fin). Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 69, ody: n = 39). Un-paired t-test,
with Welch’s correction ****p < 0.0001. (F) Ewing sarcoma cells formed a compact and expanding tumor mass
in the CHT region, between the dorsal aorta and the caudal vein. A reduced tumor cell aggregate was present in
the ody mutant line at 4 dpi. Scale bars: 50 µm. Micrographs were acquired using a Leica MZ16FA fluorescent
microscope coupled to a DFC420C camera. AMD3100, between 48 and 72 hpf, decreased cmyb/runx+ HSPCs numbers. Because neutrophils develop first
in the PBI, independently from the HSPCs, and subsequently in the CHT, dependently on the HSPCs with
self-renewal potential, we investigated whether the development of neutrophils could be affected in a host with a
non-functional Cxcr4b signaling. Neutrophil number was quantified during earlier stages of development (1 dpf),
before HSPCs colonize the CHT and initiate the definitive wave of hematopoiesis. An increase in neutrophil
number was found in the CHT of ody embryos, compared to wt siblings, whereas no difference was detected
on whole embryo level (Fig. S1A–C). Subsequently, neutrophil number was quantified in the whole zebrafish
embryo, as well as in the CHT region, in between the dorsal aorta and caudal vein, starting from the end of the
yolk extension, in 2 day old cxcr4b−/− and cxcr4b+/+ Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 embryos. We identified an increase (31%) in
neutrophil number in the CHT region of ody mutants compared to wt siblings (Fig. S1D,E) at 2 dpf. At the same
time, no difference in total neutrophil number was observed (Fig. S1F). f
p
g
These findings suggest that Cxcr4b controls neutrophil motility and development, in a putative
HSPCs-dependent and independent manner. The transcriptomic signature of Cxcr4b-deficient neutrophils links to defective cell motility. In this study (Fig. Results
M
l id 4A–C) we demonstrated that neutrophil motility is altered in physiological conditions when
Cxcr4b signaling is impaired. In order to define the contribution of neutrophilic Cxcr4b signaling axis involved Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 5 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 4. cxcr4b deficiency affects neutrophil physiological motility and development. (A) Neutrophil
movement was recorded for 30 minutes and tracks showed reduced motility in ody compared to wt siblings
in the tail fin region where tumor metastasis formation generally takes place. Scale bars: 50 µm. Time-lapse
microscopy was performed using a Leica TCS SPE confocal microscope with a HC APO 20x DRY objective
(0.7 N.A.). Neutrophil motility was assessed in wt and ody larvae at 3 dpf, measuring cumulative distance (B)
and average speed (C) of each phagocyte, localized in the CHT region. (B) Un-paired t-test **** p < 0.0001
and (C) Un-paired t-test, with Welch’s correction ****p < 0.0001. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent
experiments and values were calculated from 54 tracks (wt: n = 7) and 58 tracks (ody: n = 8). (D) mmp9
expression in 6 dpf ody and wt siblings. *p = 0.02, unpaired t-test. (E,F) Number of neutrophils in wt and ody in
the CHT region at 6 dpf is shown. A lower neutrophil number was found in the CHT region in cxcr4b −/− larvae
(32% reduction), as shown by top and bottom micrographs (E) and quantified in (F). Un-paired t-test ****
p < 0.0001. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 35, ody: n = 36). (G) A significant
reduction in total neutrophil number was found in ody larvae at 6 dpf. In (G) wt: n = 35, ody: n = 36. Data are
mean ± SEM (pool of two independent experiments). Un-paired t-test with Welch’s correction ***p = 0.0007. igure 4. cxcr4b deficiency affects neutrophil physiological motility and development. (A) Neutrophil
d d f
30
i
d
k
h
d
d
d
ili
i
d
d
ibli Figure 4. cxcr4b deficiency affects neutrophil physiological motility and development. (A) Neutrophil
movement was recorded for 30 minutes and tracks showed reduced motility in ody compared to wt siblings
in the tail fin region where tumor metastasis formation generally takes place. Scale bars: 50 µm. Time-lapse
microscopy was performed using a Leica TCS SPE confocal microscope with a HC APO 20x DRY objective
(0.7 N.A.). Results
M
l id Members of the Roundabout signaling path-
way (slit1b, sema4gb and srgap1), implicated among others in leukocyte chemotaxis and tumor angiogenesis42
were found to be up-regulated. Down-regulated genes were found to cluster in the metabolism of xenobiotics by
cytochrome p450 pathway. Subsequently, pathway analysis was extended to differentially expressed genes iden-
tified through statistical analysis performed in RStudio using the package DESeq2 paired. Overall, the analysis
performed in DESeq2 paired confirmed the enriched pathways identified with DESeq and edgeR. However, addi-
tional genes were identified, either belonging to previously described pathways (focal adhesion/ECM-Receptor
interaction) or clustering in a new pathway (MAPK pathway) (Table 2). Furthermore, NETRIN-1 (zebrafish
netrin1b), belonging to the family of laminin-secreted proteins and involved in neuronal chemotaxis43,44 and
leukocyte migration45, was found up-regulated in cxcr4−/− neutrophils (Log2FoldChange = 2.6 and p = 0.00009). in metastatic niche preparation and subsequent tumor cell invasion, RNA sequencing was performed from
FACS-sorted GFP positive neutrophils after dissociation of cxcr4b+/+ and cxcr4b−/− Tg (mpx:GFP)i144 6 dpf
larvae. An overall tendency towards upregulation of differentially expressed genes was found in neutrophils
from ody mutants (61% upregulated genes vs 39% downregulated genes) (Fig. 5), when a cutoff was considered
(p < 0.05 in DESeq and edgeR). More in details, in ody neutrophils 48% of the up-regulated genes showed an over
10-fold increase, whereas 57% of the down-regulated genes showed an over 10-fold decrease. Pathway analysis
was performed in DAVID, after selecting 615 differentially expressed genes (p < 0.05 in DESeq and edgeR) and
converting them to human orthologues with gPROFILER. Genes involved in focal adhesion and ECM-receptor
interaction were found up-regulated in neutrophils, together with genes involved in axon guidance, suggesting
impaired motility and anchoring properties (Table 1). In particular, integrins are involved in adhesion strength-
ening and arrest of leukocytes on the endothelium, during transendothelial migration41. Laminin, fibronectin
and collagen are components of the extracellular matrix and increased transcription levels suggest a tighter adhe-
sion ad consequently challenged immune cell motility (Table 1). Members of the Roundabout signaling path-
way (slit1b, sema4gb and srgap1), implicated among others in leukocyte chemotaxis and tumor angiogenesis42
were found to be up-regulated. Down-regulated genes were found to cluster in the metabolism of xenobiotics by
cytochrome p450 pathway. Subsequently, pathway analysis was extended to differentially expressed genes iden-
tified through statistical analysis performed in RStudio using the package DESeq2 paired. Results
M
l id Neutrophil motility was assessed in wt and ody larvae at 3 dpf, measuring cumulative distance (B)
and average speed (C) of each phagocyte, localized in the CHT region. (B) Un-paired t-test **** p < 0.0001
and (C) Un-paired t-test, with Welch’s correction ****p < 0.0001. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent
experiments and values were calculated from 54 tracks (wt: n = 7) and 58 tracks (ody: n = 8). (D) mmp9
expression in 6 dpf ody and wt siblings. *p = 0.02, unpaired t-test. (E,F) Number of neutrophils in wt and ody in
the CHT region at 6 dpf is shown. A lower neutrophil number was found in the CHT region in cxcr4b −/− larvae
(32% reduction), as shown by top and bottom micrographs (E) and quantified in (F). Un-paired t-test ****
p < 0.0001. Data are mean ± SEM of two independent experiments (wt: n = 35, ody: n = 36). (G) A significant
reduction in total neutrophil number was found in ody larvae at 6 dpf. In (G) wt: n = 35, ody: n = 36. Data are
mean ± SEM (pool of two independent experiments). Un-paired t-test with Welch’s correction ***p = 0.0007. in metastatic niche preparation and subsequent tumor cell invasion, RNA sequencing was performed from
FACS-sorted GFP positive neutrophils after dissociation of cxcr4b+/+ and cxcr4b−/− Tg (mpx:GFP)i144 6 dpf
larvae. An overall tendency towards upregulation of differentially expressed genes was found in neutrophils
from ody mutants (61% upregulated genes vs 39% downregulated genes) (Fig. 5), when a cutoff was considered
(p < 0.05 in DESeq and edgeR). More in details, in ody neutrophils 48% of the up-regulated genes showed an over
10-fold increase, whereas 57% of the down-regulated genes showed an over 10-fold decrease. Pathway analysis
was performed in DAVID, after selecting 615 differentially expressed genes (p < 0.05 in DESeq and edgeR) and
converting them to human orthologues with gPROFILER. Genes involved in focal adhesion and ECM-receptor
interaction were found up-regulated in neutrophils, together with genes involved in axon guidance, suggesting
impaired motility and anchoring properties (Table 1). In particular, integrins are involved in adhesion strength-
ening and arrest of leukocytes on the endothelium, during transendothelial migration41. Laminin, fibronectin
and collagen are components of the extracellular matrix and increased transcription levels suggest a tighter adhe-
sion ad consequently challenged immune cell motility (Table 1). Results
M
l id Overall, the analysis
performed in DESeq2 paired confirmed the enriched pathways identified with DESeq and edgeR. However, addi-
tional genes were identified, either belonging to previously described pathways (focal adhesion/ECM-Receptor
interaction) or clustering in a new pathway (MAPK pathway) (Table 2). Furthermore, NETRIN-1 (zebrafish
netrin1b), belonging to the family of laminin-secreted proteins and involved in neuronal chemotaxis43,44 and
leukocyte migration45, was found up-regulated in cxcr4−/− neutrophils (Log2FoldChange = 2.6 and p = 0.00009). Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 6 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 5. Cxcr4b transcriptomic signature in zebrafish neutrophils. (A) Heatmap showing up- and down-
regulated genes in cxcr4b−/− neutrophils compared to cxcr4b+/+ neutrophils. 61% is the percentage of up-
regulated genes, whereas 39% is the percentage of down-regulated genes. Genes involved in focal adhesion,
ECM-Receptor interaction and axon guidance are up-regulated. Percentages of up- or down-regulation are
calculated based on the total number of genes left after a cutoff of p < 0.05 in both DESeq and edgeR (neutrophil
dataset: from n = 21517 to n = 508). Before the analysis, 107 genes were manually removed in the neutrophil
dataset due to high variation among the triplicates. An alternative analysis method using DESeq2 paired
confirmed the affected pathways (Table 2). Figure 5. Cxcr4b transcriptomic signature in zebrafish neutrophils. (A) Heatmap showing up- and down-
regulated genes in cxcr4b−/− neutrophils compared to cxcr4b+/+ neutrophils. 61% is the percentage of up-
regulated genes, whereas 39% is the percentage of down-regulated genes. Genes involved in focal adhesion,
ECM-Receptor interaction and axon guidance are up-regulated. Percentages of up- or down-regulation are
calculated based on the total number of genes left after a cutoff of p < 0.05 in both DESeq and edgeR (neutrophil
dataset: from n = 21517 to n = 508). Before the analysis, 107 genes were manually removed in the neutrophil
dataset due to high variation among the triplicates. An alternative analysis method using DESeq2 paired
confirmed the affected pathways (Table 2). NETRIN-1 has previously been linked with reduced neutrophil and macrophage infiltration in a kidney injury
model46. Taken together, our sequencing data support the above described results that suggest motility alteration
in neutrophils bearing a cxcr4b mutation. Cxcr4b signaling affects the neutrophilic response to cancer cells during early metastasis for-
mation. Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 Results
M
l id Considering the involvement of Cxcr4b signaling in driving neutrophil motility and development in
tumor-naive conditions, next we investigated the ability of neutrophils to respond to cancer cells in ody mutants. Generally, emergency hematopoiesis is initiated upon systemic infections and neutrophils leave the bone marrow
in response to damage and danger signals, during inflammation and infection47–50. Emergency hematopoiesis,
dependents on Gcsf-Gcsfr signaling, has also been shown to occur in zebrafish larvae, resulting in expansion of
HSPCs and mobilization of neutrophils from the CHT in response to lipopolysaccharide (LPS) injection51 or bac-
terial infection52. Hence, the number of neutrophils in the CHT was quantified 3–6 hours after MDA-MB-231-B
tumor cells were inoculated into the blood circulation of embryos at 2 dpf. We found that the acute response
of neutrophils to tumor cell engraftment was characterized by a decreased number of neutrophils in the CHT
in the wt siblings and ody embryos, compared to uninjected control groups (Fig. S2A,B). These results suggest
that, at 2 dpf, the mobilization of neutrophils from the CHT in response to tumor engraftment is independent
from Cxcr4b. As tumor early metastatic events in the CHT region were primarily affected in ody mutants at 4
dpi and the CHT colonization by HSPCs is known to occur at 2 dpf, neutrophil response to cancer cells was also
assessed at 4 dpi (6 dpf). Like in 2 dpf embryos, we also observed a reduction of neutrophil number in the CHT
of tumor-engrafted wt siblings at 6 dpf, compared to the uninjected controls. In contrast, neutrophil numbers
were unchanged in tumor-engrafted ody mutants, compared to uninjected ody larvae (Fig. 6A). Therefore, Cxcr4b
signaling is required for the mobilization of neutrophils from the CHT as well tumor-invasive phenotype at 6 dpf. To further support the evidence that neutrophils display a different response towards cancer cells when
Cxcr4b signaling is not functional, we quantified neutrophil motility in the metastatic region at 4 dpi (6 dpf). Neutrophils displayed a motility pattern characterized by lower speed and diminished average distance, in
presence of MDA-MB-231-B in the wt siblings, compared to the uninjected controls (Fig. 6B,C,F,G). Results
M
l id On the
other hand, no differences in neutrophil speed and travelled distance were detected in ody larvae implanted with To further support the evidence that neutrophils display a different response towards cancer cells when
Cxcr4b signaling is not functional, we quantified neutrophil motility in the metastatic region at 4 dpi (6 dpf). Neutrophils displayed a motility pattern characterized by lower speed and diminished average distance, in
presence of MDA-MB-231-B in the wt siblings, compared to the uninjected controls (Fig. 6B,C,F,G). On the
other hand, no differences in neutrophil speed and travelled distance were detected in ody larvae implanted with Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 7 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 6. cxcr4b loss of function influences neutrophil response to cancer cells initiating early metastases. (A)
Neutrophil response to metastatic cancer cells was assessed by measuring neutrophil number in the CHT in wt
and ody larvae at 4 dpi (6 dpf). In control conditions, neutrophils left the CHT when tumor cells were present,
whereas they failed to respond, remaining in the CHT, in ody mutants (B). Kruskal-Wallis, with Dunn post hoc
test **** p < 0.0001 (number of uninjected embryos is the same as in graph in Fig. 4F; number of engrafted
embryos is wt: n = 29 and ody: n = 25). Images were acquired using Leica MZ16FA fluorescent microscope
coupled to a DFC420C camera. Scale bars: 50 µm. (B,C) Neutrophil tracking in 6 dpf larvae showed stationary
behavior of neutrophils in the presence of tumor cells in wt siblings compared to uninjected controls. (D,E)
Neutrophils maintained the same migratory behavior in ody mutants, in presence of MDA-MB-231-B and
in uninjected larvae. (F,G) Neutrophil motility was quantified for 30 minutes, measuring total distance and
average speed of each neutrophil in the CHT region. Data are mean ± SD (uninjected wt: n = 46 tracks from 7
larvae; MDA-MB-231-B wt: n = 32 tracks from 5 larvae; uninjected ody: n = 37 tracks from 7 larvae; MDA-MB-
231-B ody: n = 27 tracks from 5 larvae). One-way ANOVA, with Bonferroni post-hoc test. Figure 6. cxcr4b loss of function influences neutrophil response to cancer cells initiating early metastases. (A)
Neutrophil response to metastatic cancer cells was assessed by measuring neutrophil number in the CHT in wt
and ody larvae at 4 dpi (6 dpf). Results
M
l id In control conditions, neutrophils left the CHT when tumor cells were present,
whereas they failed to respond, remaining in the CHT, in ody mutants (B). Kruskal-Wallis, with Dunn post hoc
test **** p < 0.0001 (number of uninjected embryos is the same as in graph in Fig. 4F; number of engrafted
embryos is wt: n = 29 and ody: n = 25). Images were acquired using Leica MZ16FA fluorescent microscope
coupled to a DFC420C camera. Scale bars: 50 µm. (B,C) Neutrophil tracking in 6 dpf larvae showed stationary
behavior of neutrophils in the presence of tumor cells in wt siblings compared to uninjected controls. (D,E)
Neutrophils maintained the same migratory behavior in ody mutants, in presence of MDA-MB-231-B and
in uninjected larvae. (F,G) Neutrophil motility was quantified for 30 minutes, measuring total distance and
average speed of each neutrophil in the CHT region. Data are mean ± SD (uninjected wt: n = 46 tracks from 7
larvae; MDA-MB-231-B wt: n = 32 tracks from 5 larvae; uninjected ody: n = 37 tracks from 7 larvae; MDA-MB-
231-B ody: n = 27 tracks from 5 larvae). One-way ANOVA, with Bonferroni post-hoc test. MDA-MB-231-B compared to engrafted wt siblings (Fig. 6D–G). In conclusion, Cxcr4b signaling impairment
affects neutrophil response to cancer cells initiating early metastatic events. Discussion Chemokines are key mediators of directional cell migration and the CXCR4-CXCL12 chemokine axis is well
known to display major roles in tumor progression, guiding tumor cell homing to CXCL12 expressing organs53. Consequently, targeting the CXCR4 receptor expressed by cancer cells is a pharmacological approach that is
currently explored in the clinic to limit tumor spreading and metastases54. At the same time, it is important to
consider the effect of CXCR4 signaling on the tumor microenvironment, especially in view of the antagonizing
or supportive functions that myeloid cells are known to have on tumor progression55. Discussion We previously showed that Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 8 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ DESEq
edgeR
Gene ID
Gene symbol
Gene name
LogFC
p
LogFC
p
Focal adhesion/ECM-receptor interaction
ENSDARG00000056624
figf
c-fos induced growth factor
3.9
3.0E-02
3.9
3.0E-02
ENSDARG00000009014
col11a1b
collagen, type XI, alpha 1b
1.8
6.0E-03
1.8
5.0E-03
ENSDARG00000019815
fn1a
fibronectin 1a
1.9
3.0E-02
1.9
3.0E-02
ENSDARG00000007950
itga11b
integrin, alpha 11b
4.8
3.0E-03
4.6
3.0E-03
ENSDARG00000053232
itgb1b.1
integrin beta 1b.1
1.2
4.0E-02
1.2
4.0E-02
ENSDARG00000102277
lama1
laminin, alpha 1
3.1
9.0E-03
3.1
1.0E-02
ENSDARG00000099390
lama2
laminin, alpha 2
4
1.0E-02
3.9
2.0E-02
ENSDARG00000018110
pak4
p21 protein (Cdc42/Rac)-activated
kinase 4
1.5
2.0E-02
1.5
1.0E-02
ENSDARG00000038139
pdgfbb
platelet-derived growth factor beta
polypeptide b
6.8
8.0E-04
6.3
6.0E-03
ENSDARG00000078362
tnc
tenascin C
1.6
2.0E-02
1.6
3.0E-02
Axon guidance
ENSDARG00000007461
srgap1
SLIT-ROBO Rho GTPase activating
protein 1
2.9
4.0E-02
2.9
4.0E-02
ENSDARG00000045064
ablim1b
actin binding LIM protein 1b
1.3
2.0E-02
1.3
2.0E-02
ENSDARG00000089790
efna5a
ephrin-A5a
2.8
1.0E-02
2.8
3.0E-02
ENSDARG00000053232
itgb1b.1
integrin beta 1b.1
1.2
4.0E-02
1.2
4.0E-02
ENSDARG00000022531
ntn1b
netrin 1b
2.6
9.0E-05
2.6
7.0E-03
ENSDARG00000102556
nfat5b
nuclear factor of activated T-cells 5
3.6
1.0E-02
3.5
2.6E-02
ENSDARG00000076297
nfatc3a
nuclear factor of activated T-cells,
cytoplasmic 3a
1.6
2.6E-02
1.6
3.2E-02
ENSDARG00000018110
pak4
p21 protein (Cdc42/Rac)-activated
kinase 4
1.5
2.2E-02
1.5
1.1E-02
ENSDARG00000035132
rgs3b
regulator of G-protein signaling 3b
2.3
3.0E-03
2.3
5.0E-03
ENSDARG00000088143
sema4gb
semaphorin 4gb
1.00E + 06
5.9E-04
7.9
4.5E-04
ENSDARG00000099446
slit1b
slit homolog 1b
3.5
6.6E-03
3.5
2.3E-02
Metabolism of xenobiotics by cytochrome P450
ENSDARG00000006220
ugt1ab
UDP glucuronosyltransferase 1
family a, b
−2.6
4.9E-05
−2.6
8.2E-03
ENSDARG00000091211
adh8a
alcohol dehydrogenase 8a
−4.3
5.9E-03
−4.2
4.6E-03
ENSDARG00000098315
cyp1a
cytochrome P450, family 1, subfamily
A
−4.1
1.1E-10
−4.1
4.0E-03
ENSDARG00000101423
cyp2y3
cytochrome P450, family 2, subfamily
Y, polypeptide 3
−1.5
1.8E-02
−1.5
4.7E-02
ENSDARG00000103295
cyp3a65
cytochrome P450, family 3, subfamily
A, polypeptide 65
−2.7
3.3E-06
−2.7
4.5E-02
ENSDARG00000039832
zgc:173961
zgc:173961
−2.6
1.4E-05
−2.6
1.0E-02
ENSDARG00000090228
gstal
glutathione S-transferase
−2.7
1.1E-05
−2.7
8.7E-03
ENSDARG00000017388
gstt1b
glutathione S-transferase theta 1b
−2.8
1.9E-03
−2.8
8.4E-03 Table 1. Enriched pathways in cxcr4b −/− neutrophils (analysis performed with DESeq and edgeR). Pathway
analysis in Cxcr4b-deficient neutrophils. Genes selected with DESeq (p<0.05) and edgeR (p<0.05) analyses
in RStudio (from 21621 to 615 genes) were converted to the human orthologues using g:PROFILER and
uploaded in DAVID Bioinformatics. Resources 6.7 for pathway analysis. Discussion Up-regulation of genes involved in
focal adhesion/ECMReceptor interaction and axon guidance was identified, whereas down-regulation of genes
in the metabolism of xenobiotic by P450 was found. Additional analysis was performed using DESeq2 paired
(Table 2). The same pathways were identified with DESeq/edgeR (Table 1) and DESeq2 paired (Table 2) and
the genes listed in Table 2 were in addition to genes described in Table 1. Enriched pathways indicate alteration
in motility, as shown by the analysis performed with DESeq and edgeR and reveal members of the MAPK
signaling to be differentially expressed. the zebrafish xenograft model is a powerful tool to study tumor-microenvironment interactions as CXCR4-based
interspecies cross talk takes place12 and genetic and chemical inactivation of CXCR4 receptor on the engrafted
human cancer cells block metastatic onset in zebrafish xenograft model. Moreover, the role of neutrophils in
preparing the metastatic niche has been previously described by our group30. We found that the non-pathological
migration correlate with tumor cell invasion in the caudal hematopoietic tissue (CHT), functionally analogous to
the fetal liver in mammalian embryo development. Hence, we hypothesized the involvement of CXCR4 signaling
in controlling neutrophil motility and immune-tumor cell interactions involved in the initiation of early meta-
static events and micrometastasis formation. First, we found that in zebrafish larvae neutrophils express high lev-
els of cxcr4b, the homolog of human CXCR4 and paralog of zebrafish cxcr4a. Then, we used a cxcr4b homozygote the zebrafish xenograft model is a powerful tool to study tumor-microenvironment interactions as CXCR4-based
interspecies cross talk takes place12 and genetic and chemical inactivation of CXCR4 receptor on the engrafted
human cancer cells block metastatic onset in zebrafish xenograft model. Moreover, the role of neutrophils in
preparing the metastatic niche has been previously described by our group30. We found that the non-pathological
migration correlate with tumor cell invasion in the caudal hematopoietic tissue (CHT), functionally analogous to
the fetal liver in mammalian embryo development. Hence, we hypothesized the involvement of CXCR4 signaling
in controlling neutrophil motility and immune-tumor cell interactions involved in the initiation of early meta-
static events and micrometastasis formation. First, we found that in zebrafish larvae neutrophils express high lev-
els of cxcr4b, the homolog of human CXCR4 and paralog of zebrafish cxcr4a. Discussion Then, we used a cxcr4b homozygote Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 9 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ DESEq2 paired
Gene ID
Gene symbol
Gene name
LogFC
p
Focal adhesion/ECM-receptor interaction
ENSDARG00000032639
cd36
CD36 molecule (thrombospondin receptor)
−1.3
8.3E-03
ENSDARG00000012405
col1a1a
collagen, type I, alpha 1a
0.8
2.2E-02
ENSDARG00000061436
col6a2
collagen, type VI, alpha 2
1.0
4.5E-02
ENSDARG00000074316
itga1
integrin, alpha 1
1.1
8.8E-03
ENSDARG00000103056
itga4
integrin alpha 4
0.8
2.6E-02
ENSDARG00000020785
lama4
laminin, alpha 4
1.1
7.1E-03
ENSDARG00000093572
lamc3
laminin, gamma 3
1.5
5.2E-03
ENSDARG00000060711
sv2bb
synaptic vesicle glycoprotein 2Bb
1.7
3.4E-03
ENSDARG00000008867
rap1b
RAP1B, member of RAS oncogene family
−0.9
2.1E-02
ENSDARG00000007825
map2k1
mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase 1
−1.1
2.1E-02
ENSDARG00000098578
pdgfab
platelet-derived growth factor alpha polypeptide b
−1.0
2.1E-02
Cardiac muscle contraction
ENSDARG00000007739
atp1a1a.2
ATPase, Na+/K+ transporting, alpha 1a polypeptide
−1.6
5.8E-05
ENSDARG00000018259
atp1a3a
ATPase, Na+/K+ transporting, alpha 3a polypeptide
0.9
9.6E-03
ENSDARG00000076833
atp1b1b
ATPase, Na+/K+ transporting, beta 1b polypeptide
−1.5
4.0E-04
ENSDARG00000063905
mt-co1
cytochrome c oxidase I, mitochondrial
−0.7
9.3E-03
ENSDARG00000063908
mt-co2
cytochrome c oxidase II, mitochondrial
−0.6
4.1E-02
ENSDARG00000063911
mt-atp6
ATP synthase 6, mitochondrial
−0.7
2.0E-02
ENSDARG00000063912
mt-co3
cytochrome c oxidase III, mitochondrial
−0.7
1.7E-02
ENSDARG00000023886
cacna2d4b
calcium channel, voltage-dependent, alpha 2/delta subunit 4b
1.2
3.2E-02
ENSDARG00000045230
cox6b1
cytochrome c oxidase subunit VIb polypeptide 1
−1.2
4.2E-03
ENSDARG00000038075
cyc1
cytochrome c-1
−0.7
1.9E-02
ENSDARG00000079564
vmhc
ventricular myosin heavy chain
2.1
3.7E-05
Axon guidance
ENSDARG00000044029
efnb3a
ephrin-B3a
1.2
3.2E-02
MAPK signaling pathway
ENSDARG00000008867
rap1b
RAP1B, member of RAS oncogene family
−0.9
2.1E-02
ENSDARG00000035535
rasa1a
RAS p21 protein activator (GTPase activating protein) 1a
0.8
4.5E-02
ENSDARG00000005482
rapgef2
Rap guanine nucleotide exchange factor (GEF) 2
1.0
9.9E-03
ENSDARG00000043241
arrb1
arrestin, beta 1
1.3
3.1E-02
ENSDARG00000023886
cacna2d4b
calcium channel, voltage-dependent, alpha 2/delta subunit 4b
1.2
3.2E-02
ENSDARG00000102474
dusp16
dual specificity phosphatase 16
1.4
9.6E-04
ENSDARG00000061255
dusp3a
dual specificity phosphatase 3a
1.4
1.5E-02
ENSDARG00000009299
dusp8a
dual specificity phosphatase 8a
1.0
3.0E-03
ENSDARG00000092281
FLNB
filamin B
1.3
2.1E-02
ENSDARG00000007825
map2k1
mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase 1
−1.1
2.1E-02
ENSDARG00000001234
map4k2
mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase kinase kinase 2
−1.2
2.9E-02
ENSDARG00000071357
map4k3b
mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase kinase kinase 3b
1.3
3.2E-03
ENSDARG00000070454
pla2g12a
phospholipase A2, group XIIA
−1.4
1.4E-02
ENSDARG00000015662
pla2g12b
phospholipase A2, group XIIB
−1.4
1.4E-02
ENSDARG00000098578
pdgfab
platelet-derived growth factor alpha polypeptide b
−1.0
2.1E-02
ENSDARG00000060551
rps6ka5
ribosomal protein S6 kinase, polypeptide 5
1.5
8.7E-04
ENSDARG00000017494
tgfbr1a
transforming growth factor, beta receptor 1a
1.2
4.1E-02
Table 2. Discussion Enriched pathways in cxcr4b −/− neutrophils (analysis performed with DESeq2 paired). Pathway analysis
in Cxcr4b-deficient neutrophils Genes selected with DESeq (p<0 05) and edgeR (p<0 05) analyses in RStudio Table 2. Enriched pathways in cxcr4b −/− neutrophils (analysis performed with DESeq2 paired). Pathway analysis
in Cxcr4b-deficient neutrophils. Genes selected with DESeq (p < 0.05) and edgeR (p < 0.05) analyses in RStudio
(from 21621 to 615 genes) were converted to the human orthologues using g:PROFILER and uploaded in DAVID
Bioinformatics Resources 6.7 for pathway analysis. Up-regulation of genes involved in focal adhesion/ECM-Receptor
interaction and axon guidance was identified, whereas down-regulation of genes in the metabolism of xenobiotic
by P450 was found. Additional analysis was performed using DESeq2 paired (Table 2). The same pathways were
identified with DESeq/edgeR (Table 1) and DESeq2 paired (Table 2) and the genes listed in Table 2 were in addition
to genes described in Table 1. Enriched pathways indicate alteration in motility, as shown by the analysis performed
with DESeq and edgeR and reveal members of the MAPK signaling to be differentially expressed. Table 2. Enriched pathways in cxcr4b −/− neutrophils (analysis performed with DESeq2 paired). Pathway analysis
in Cxcr4b-deficient neutrophils. Genes selected with DESeq (p < 0.05) and edgeR (p < 0.05) analyses in RStudio
(from 21621 to 615 genes) were converted to the human orthologues using g:PROFILER and uploaded in DAVID
Bioinformatics Resources 6.7 for pathway analysis. Up-regulation of genes involved in focal adhesion/ECM-Receptor
interaction and axon guidance was identified, whereas down-regulation of genes in the metabolism of xenobiotic
by P450 was found. Additional analysis was performed using DESeq2 paired (Table 2). The same pathways were
identified with DESeq/edgeR (Table 1) and DESeq2 paired (Table 2) and the genes listed in Table 2 were in addition
to genes described in Table 1. Enriched pathways indicate alteration in motility, as shown by the analysis performed
with DESeq and edgeR and reveal members of the MAPK signaling to be differentially expressed. Table 2. Enriched pathways in cxcr4b −/− neutrophils (analysis performed with DESeq2 paired). Pathway analysis
in Cxcr4b-deficient neutrophils. Genes selected with DESeq (p < 0.05) and edgeR (p < 0.05) analyses in RStudio
(from 21621 to 615 genes) were converted to the human orthologues using g:PROFILER and uploaded in DAVID
Bioinformatics Resources 6.7 for pathway analysis. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Figure 7. Role of host-dependent CXCR4 signaling in experimental metastasis formation in the zebrafish
xenograft model. Inoculation of human tumor cells into the blood circulation of zebrafish embryos results
in experimental metastasis formation, characterized by tumor cell aggregates in the blood vessels, and
extravasation and invasion in the surrounding tissue, in the region of the caudal hematopoietic tissue
(CHT). During early metastatic events, endothelium alteration takes place and neutrophils localize in the
surrounding of the tumor cells. The CHT is a vascular plexus in the tail fin between the DA and the CV and is
a hematopoietic site. Upon disruption of the host CXCR4 (Cxcr4b) signaling, cancer cells are unable to initiate
early metastatic events. Neutrophils are preferentially retained in the CHT and fail to accumulate at tumor
metastatic sites. Figure 7. Role of host-dependent CXCR4 signaling in experimental metastasis formation in the zebrafish
xenograft model. Inoculation of human tumor cells into the blood circulation of zebrafish embryos results
in experimental metastasis formation, characterized by tumor cell aggregates in the blood vessels, and
extravasation and invasion in the surrounding tissue, in the region of the caudal hematopoietic tissue
(CHT). During early metastatic events, endothelium alteration takes place and neutrophils localize in the
surrounding of the tumor cells. The CHT is a vascular plexus in the tail fin between the DA and the CV and is
a hematopoietic site. Upon disruption of the host CXCR4 (Cxcr4b) signaling, cancer cells are unable to initiate
early metastatic events. Neutrophils are preferentially retained in the CHT and fail to accumulate at tumor
metastatic sites. Investigating a potential role of the host Cxcr4b signaling in the formation of early metastasis by affecting
immune cell motility was the next approach. We found a downregulation in mmp9 mRNA levels in ody and a
reduction in neutrophil motility in tumor-naïve cxcr4b deficient zebrafish embryos. These findings link with our
previous work on the role of neutrophil physiological migration in tumor invasion in the tail fin30. It has been
reported that in addition to its function as a protease, mmp9 plays a role as a chemoattractant. Mmp9 chemotac-
tic properties work in synergy with CXCL1221. Therefore, inhibition of CXCR4 signaling could lead to impaired
neutrophil motility and ability to respond to tumour cells also as a result of altered mmp9-driven chemotaxis. We
next investigated whether Cxcr4b signaling affects neutrophil development. Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 Discussion Up-regulation of genes involved in focal adhesion/ECM-Receptor
interaction and axon guidance was identified, whereas down-regulation of genes in the metabolism of xenobiotic
by P450 was found. Additional analysis was performed using DESeq2 paired (Table 2). The same pathways were
identified with DESeq/edgeR (Table 1) and DESeq2 paired (Table 2) and the genes listed in Table 2 were in addition
to genes described in Table 1. Enriched pathways indicate alteration in motility, as shown by the analysis performed
with DESeq and edgeR and reveal members of the MAPK signaling to be differentially expressed. mutant zebrafish (also known as odysseus or ody) and showed that engrafted human tumor cells failed to form
micrometastases in the CHT region. Therefore, myeloid cell impairment or a non-functional Cxcr4b signaling led
to experimental tumor micrometastasis inhibition. Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 10 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ www.nature.com/scientificreports/ www.nature.com/scientificreports/ same study, the mesenchymal cells express cxcl12a, whereas cxcr4b expression is mainly found in the CHT region
and treatment with the CXCR4 antagonist AMD3100 reduced the number of runx+ hematopoietic progenitors40. In line with their findings, we propose that the reduced number of neutrophils in the CHT of 6 dpf ody larvae
relates to the reduced number of HSPCs and suggest that further investigations should be carried on to confirm
this hypothesis. Importantly, a lower number of neutrophils in the CHT in 6 dpf ody mutants might result in a
reduced niche modification due to a lower number of paths traced into the collagen by neutrophils themselves. On the other end, the increased number of neutrophils in earlier stages suggests the potential role of Cxcr4b in
the primitive wave of hematopoiesis.iii p
p
In agreement with our findings, Cxcr4b signature in tumor-naïve zebrafish neutrophils confirmed Cxcr4b
role in cell motility and adhesion. Upregulation of the integrins, as well as increased interaction with the ECM
and alteration of the cytoskeleton reorganization were found in Cxcr4b deficient neutrophils. Members of the
Roundabout signaling pathway were also differentially expressed. Roundabout signaling is associated with
axon guidance mechanisms and its role in cancer metastasis has been reported58. Importantly, Slit1b, found
up-regulated in ody, functions as a repellent molecule that interferes with leukocyte chemotaxis59 and specifically
blocks the ability of circulating neutrophils to migrate directionally60. Moreover, we propose netrin1b as a can-
didate gene that links neutrophil ability to provide trophic signals to cancer cells. NETRIN-1 has been reported
to reduce neutrophil infiltration in ischemic acute kidney injury by inhibiting COX-2 and PGE2 production46. PGE2 has been identified as the trophic signal that sustains neoplastic transformation in a transgenic zebrafish
cancer model15.t After investigating the role of Cxcr4b in physiological neutrophil development and motility, we unrave-
led neutrophil behavior in presence of engrafted tumor cells, able to initiate early metastatic events. An acute
response to engrafted cancer cells into the blood circulation of 2 dpf zebrafish embryos resulted in no alteration
in Cxc4b-deficient neutrophils. To assess neutrophil acute response in tumor-engrafted larvae, the number of
mpx+ cells was counted in the CHT of zebrafish embryos few hours after tumor cell inoculation. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ As neutrophil
number decreased in the CHT of engrafted wt or ody embryos compared to uninjected larvae, we propose that
neutrophils mount an acute response upon tumor inoculation by leaving the CHT in line with previous obser-
vations of demand-driven granulopoiesis upon bacterial infection52 and that this response occurs in a Cxcr4b
independent manner. On the other hand, an altered response was found at later stages. In 6 dpf (4 dpi) zebrafish
larvae, tumor cells have formed a secondary tumor mass and initiated local tissue invasion. In response, wt sib-
lings diminished the number of neutrophils in the CHT, increasing their mobilization. Mobilized neutrophils
were found to migrate and in the surrounding of metastasizing cancer cells and to slow down and to interact with
human malignant cells. In contrast, cxcr4b deficient neutrophils remained in the CHT and failed to localize in the
surrounding of tailfin tumor micrometastases, suggesting a possibly diminished inflammatory response (Fig. 7). gi
gg
g
p
yl
y
p
( g
)
In conclusion, we demonstrate that CXCR4 signaling plays a major role in neutrophilic innate immune
response to early metastatic events and contributes to the establishment of tumor micrometastases. The develop-
ment of CXCR4-targeted therapies directed to the tumor microenvironment is therefore essential. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ In mammals, CXCR4 and CXCR2
chemokine signaling axes regulate hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) retention in and mobilization from the bone
marrow, respectively27,29. CXCR4 chemical inhibition upon AMD3100 treatment results in mobilized HSCs56. Furthermore, patients affected by WHIM syndrome, characterized by neutropenia and enhanced susceptibility
to infection, bear a CXCR4-gain-of-function mutation that causes neutrophil retention in hematopoietic sites,
in response to cognate ligand CXCL12, highly expressed in the bone marrow57. These findings have been con-
firmed in a zebrafish model of WHIM syndrome, where neutrophils expressing constitutively active Cxcr4b were
retained in the CHT and mobilized only upon cxcl12a knock down37. We found that the number of neutrophils
in the CHT in ody mutants was higher than in the wt siblings at 2 dpf. Because the overall neutrophil number was
not affected by the cxcr4b mutation, a higher number of neutrophils in the CHT surprisingly suggested enhanced
neutrophil retention. These findings show that receptor stimulation by cognate ligand is needed to activate cell
motility, despite of chemotaxis towards Cxcl12. Retention and reduced motility of neutrophils with impaired
Cxcr4b signaling at 2 and 3 dpf, respectively, support the hypothesis that neutrophil physiological behavior plays
an important role in cancer micrometastasis formation at early stages. p
y
g
Next we investigated if neutrophils played an important role in preparing the metastatic niche in later stages
of tumor micrometastasis formation, when tumor cell invasion has taken place. Therefore, neutrophil number
was counted in 6 dpf zebrafish larvae and, in contrast to the observations at 2 dpf, a reduction in neutrophils
localized in the CHT was found in ody mutants, with tendency towards a reduced overall number in a whole
larva. We hypothesize that the dichotomy in neutrophil numbers is linked to the role of CXCR4 signaling during
hematopoiesis. Using the zebrafish embryo model, it has recently been shown that HSPCs colonize the hemato-
poietic tissue, interacting with mesenchymal cells and inducing modification in the perivascular niche. In the Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 11 Materials and Methodsi For each larva tumor burden was calculated based on number of objects mul-
tiplied by mean area and mean intensity, generated with a macro designed by H. de Bont (Toxicology, LACDR,
Leiden University) and previously used to quantify tumor migration and proliferation63,64. Neutrophil number and motility. Neutrophil number was quantified by manual counting, using a Leica
MZ16FA fluorescent microscope. Neutrophil basal motility was assessed using a Leica TCS SPE confocal micro-
scope with a HC APO 20x DRY objective (0.7 N.A.). 3 dpf larvae were mounted on a 1% low melting point
agarose layer, containing tricaine and covering the glass surface of a Will-Co Dish® (Pelco®, Ted Pella, Inc). Egg
water containing anesthetic was added on top of each larva. Timelapse was performed for 30 minutes, with 1 min-
ute interval between frames. Maximum projections were generated, tail movements were corrected using Stack
Reg plugin and neutrophil tracking was performed using the Manual Tracking plugin in ImageJ-Fiji65. Neutrophil
motility in response to metastatic cancer cells was quantified with a Nikon A1 confocal laser scanning microscope
(Tokyo, Japan) using the 488 and 561 laser lines with 20 × (NA 0.75) lens. Images were acquired every minute
during timelapse. Videos were analyzed using NIS-Elements AR and tracking performed for the first 30 frames
in ImageJ, with Manual Tracking plugin. RNA isolation and real-time PCR. Expression levels of mmp9 were quantified in 6 dpf cxcr4bt26035
Tg(Kdrl:EGFP)s843 larvae. RNA was isolated using TRIZOL extraction method, according to the manufacturer’s
instruction from a pool of zebrafish larvae (10 < n < 15). DNase treatment was performed using RQ1 RNase
free-DNase (M6101 Promega). 1 μg input RNA was used for cDNA synthesis (i-Script™ cDNA synthesis kit,
Bio-Rad). Expression levels were measured by real-time PCR (iQ™ SYBR® Green Supermix, Bio-Rad), using the
Chromo4™ Four-Color Real-Time PCR system. Relative fold changes of gene expression were calculated using the
ΔΔCt method. The following primers were used: mmp9 forward 5′CATTAAAGATGCCCTGATGTATCCC -3′ and
mmp9 reverse 5′-AGTGGTGGTCCGTGGTTGAG-3′66. Peptidylprolyl isomerase A-like (ppiaI) was used as
housekeeping gene (forward 5′-ACACTGAAACACGGAGGCAAAG -3′ and reverse RV 5′- CATCCACA
ACCTTCCCGAACAC-3′). cxcr4b transcriptomic signature in neutrophils: from larval dissociation to RNA sequencing
analysis. Zebrafish line cxcr4bt26035 Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 was used to isolate neutrophils from 6 dpf larvae. After
harvesting, eggs were kept in Petri dishes (n ≤ 100) at 28.5 °C to allow synchronized embryo development. Materials and Methodsi Zebrafish husbandry. Zebrafish lines were kept in compliance with the local animal welfare regulations and
European directives. The study was approved by the local animal welfare committee (DEC) of the University of
Leiden (license number: 10612, protocol 14227). Zebrafish adults were maintained according to standard proto-
cols (zfin.org), in a 10/14-hour dark/light cycle. Embryos were maintained at 28 °C in Egg water (60 µg/ml Ocean
salt in distilled water), containing 0.003% PTU (1-phenyl-2-thiourea) to block pigmentation. Zebrafish lines. Zebrafish reporter lines used in this study were Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 34 and Tg(Kdrl:EGFP)s843 61. The cxcr4bt26035 line36 was outcrossed with each reporter line mentioned above. Homozygote cxcr4b−/− mutant
embryos (odysseus or ody) were distinguished from wild type cxcr4b+/+ and heterozygote cxcr4b+/− siblings by phe-
notype (incomplete lateral line deposition) and genotype identification. Genotyping of adult fish by KASP assay
was performed using the following primers A1 (reverse) 5′-TGACGGTGGTCTTCAGTGCCTT-3′, A2 (reverse)
5′-TGACGGTGGTCTTCAGTGCCTA-3′ and C1 (forward) 5′-CAAGAACTCCAAGGGTCAGACTCTA-3′ and
confirmed by sequencing using previously described primers62. Cell culture. Breast MDA-MB-231-B dsRed32 (kindly provided by P. ten Dijke and Y. Drabsch, LUMC,
Leiden, The Netherlands), MDA-MB-157 mCherry (ATCC®) and prostate PC3-M-Pro4-Luc2 (mCherry or tdTo-
mato) (kindly provided by G. van der Pluijm, LUMC, Leiden, The Netherlands) cancer cell lines were cultured
in DMEM medium complemented with 10% fetal calf serum (FCS), at 37 °C in a humidified atmosphere with
5% CO2. Cell lines were regularly tested for mycoplasma with Universal Mycoplasma Detection kit (30–1012 k,
ATCC). Pu.1 knock down. Pu.1 (Spi1b, 1 mM) and standard control morpholino injections (0.1 mM) were per-
formed to deplete neutrophils and macrophages as previously described30. Morpholino efficiency was assessed by
counting number of Mpx+ neutrophils in the Tg(mpx:GFP)i114 zebrafish line. Xenograft experiments. Tumor cells were inoculated in the blood circulation of 2 day post fertilization
(dpf) zebrafish embryos as previously described33. Tumor burden. Zebrafish embryos engrafted with fluorescently labelled tumor cells were screened for cor-
rect engraftment 5–6 hours after inoculation into the blood circulation at 2 dpf, using a Leica MZ16FA fluorescent
microscope coupled to a DFC420C camera. Larvae were positioned on a Petri dish with 1.5% agarose coating Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 12 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ and tumor burden was quantified at 4 dpi, acquiring monographs of the metastatic site, in the CHT region. LAS
AF Lite software was used to overlay the GFP and dsRed channels and snapshots were analyzed in Image-Pro
Analyzer 7.0 (Media Cybernetics). Materials and Methodsi Triplicates of GFP positive embryos (100–150 per replicate) were selected for dissociation, performed according
to67. Dissociation with 0.4 mg/ml collagenase/DPBS (Liberase TL, Roche, #05401020001) was alternatively used. Larvae were transferred directly from Egg water to collagenase solution. Dissociation was obtained mechanically
with pipetting and 2 incubation steps at 28.5 °C for 10 min. 10% FCS was added and sample preparation was con-
tinued as described in67. Sorting was performed with a BD FACSAria™ III Cell Sorter (BD Biosciences, San Jose,
CA, USA) with the BD FACSDiva software (version 6.1.3) and gates defined using GFP negative larvae. After sort-
ing, samples were stored in QIAzol at −80 °C. RNA isolation was performed using miRNeasy Mini kit (# 217004
Qiagen). On-column DNase digestion was performed, using RNase-Free DNase Set (# 79254 Qiagen). Agilent
Bioanalyzer 2100, RNA 6000 Pico kit (Agilent, Santa Clara) was used to assess RNA quality. cDNA synthesis and
amplification were performed with SMARTer® Ultra™ Low Input RNA Kit for Sequencing - v3 (Clontech) and
cDNA quality validated, using Agilent 2100 BioAnalyzer and the High Sensitivity DNA Chip from Agilent’s High
Sensitivity DNA Kit (#5067-4626, Agilent). cDNA shearing, library preparation and validation, and Illumina
sequencing (HiSeq2000) were performed as described in67 by ZF-SCREENS (Leiden, The Netherland). Reads
(18.684.327 is an average of 12 samples) were mapped to Ensembl transcripts (GRCz10.80) and statistical anal-
ysis based on negative binomial distribution performed in R Studio, using DESEq, DESEq2 paired and EdgeR
packages, available at Bioconductor.org. Pathway analysis was performed using DAVID Bioinformatics Resources
6.7. Identification of cxcr4a and cxcr4b expression levels in neutrophils by RNA sequencing shown in Fig. 2 was
performed as described in67. Statistics. Statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism (versions 5.0 and 6.0). Un-paired t-test
was used in datasets of two groups and Welch’s correction applied when group variances were significantly dif-
ferent (p < 0.05). One-way ANOVA with Bonferroni post hoc test was used in datasets of three or more groups
(continuous variable) and Kruskal-Wallis with Dunn’s post hoc test was used to estimate significant difference in
the case of counts (discrete variable). Data Availability y
Data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article (and its Supplementary Infor-
mation files). The datasets generated and/or analysed during the current study are available from the correspond-
ing author on reasonable request. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Journal of immunology 194, 3463–3474, https://doi.org/10.4049/jimmunol.1402097 ( ourenco, S. et al. Macrophage migration inhibitory factor-CXCR4 is the dominant chemotactic axis in human mesenchymal stem
ll recruitment to tumors. Journal of immunology 194, 3463–3474, https://doi.org/10.4049/jimmunol.1402097 (2015). p
g
g
y
y
cell recruitment to tumors. Journal of immunology 194, 3463–3474, https://doi.org/10.4049/jimmunol.1402097 (2015). 11. Rajasekaran, D. et al. Macrophage Migration Inhibitory Factor-CXCR4 Receptor Interactions: Evidence For Partial Allosteric
Agonism In Comparison With Cxcl12 Chemokine. The Journal of biological chemistry 291, 15881–15895, https://doi.org/10.1074/
jbc.M116.717751 (2016).i j
(
)
12. Tulotta, C. et al. Inhibition of signaling between human CXCR4 and zebrafish ligands by the small molecule IT1t impairs the
formation of triple-negative breast cancer early metastases in a zebrafish xenograft model. Disease models & mechanisms 9, 141–153,
https://doi.org/10.1242/dmm.023275 (2016).lifi p
g
13. Serhan, C. N. et al. Resolution of inflammation: state of the art, definitions and terms. FASEB journal: official publication of the
Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology 21, 325–332, https://doi.org/10.1096/fj.06-7227rev (2007). j
14. Bekes, E. M. et al. Tumor-recruited neutrophils and neutrophil TIMP-free MMP-9 regulate coordinately the levels of tumor
angiogenesis and efficiency of malignant cell intravasation. Am J Pathol 179, 1455–1470, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajpath.2011.05.031
(2011).i (
)
15. Feng, Y., Renshaw, S. & Martin, P. Live imaging of tumor initiation in zebrafish larvae reveals a trophic role for leukocyte-derived
PGE(2). Curr Biol 22, 1253–1259, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2012.05.010 (2012).fh p
g
j
6. Murdoch, C., Muthana, M., Coffelt, S. B. & Lewis, C. E. The role of myeloid cells in the promotion of tumour angiogenesis. Nat Rev
Cancer 8, 618–631, https://doi.org/10.1038/nrc2444 (2008).fl p
g
17. Rahat, M. A., Coffelt, S. B., Granot, Z., Muthana, M. & Amedei, A. Macrophages and Neutrophils: Regulation of the Inflammatory
Microenvironment in Autoimmunity and Cancer. Mediators of inflammation 2016, 5894347, https://doi.org/10.1155/2016/5894347
(2016).h (
)
18. Allavena, P., Sica, A., Garlanda, C. & Mantovani, A. The Yin-Yang of tumor-associated macrophages in neoplastic progression
immune surveillance. Immunol Rev 222, 155–161, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-065X.2008.00607.x (2008). 9. Fridlender, Z. G. et al. Polarization of Tumor-Associated Neutrophil Phenotype by TGF-beta: “N1” versus “N2” TAN. Cancer Cel
16, 183–194, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ccr.2009.06.017 (2009). p
g
j
0. Piccard, H., Muschel, R. J. & Opdenakker, G. On the dual roles and polarized phenotypes of neutrophils in tumor development and
progression. Crit Rev Oncol Hemat 82, 296–309, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.critrevonc.2011.06.004 (2012). 21. Kawai, K. et al. Matrix metalloproteinase-9 contributes to the mobilization of bone marrow cells in the injured liver. References 1. Quail, D. F. & Joyce, J. A. Microenvironmental regulation of tumor progression and metastasis. Nat Med 19, 1423–1437, https://doi
org/10.1038/nm.3394 (2013). cell.2011.02.013 (2011). 3. Guo, F. et al. CXCL12/CXCR4: a symbiotic bridge linking cancer cells and their stromal neighbors in oncogenic communication
networks. Oncogene, https://doi.org/10.1038/onc.2015.139 (2015). (
)
3. Guo, F. et al. CXCL12/CXCR4: a symbiotic bridge linking cancer cells and their stromal neighbors in oncogenic communication
networks. Oncogene, https://doi.org/10.1038/onc.2015.139 (2015). Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 13 Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ www.nature.com/scientificreports/ 4. Janowski, M. Functional diversity of SDF-1 splicing variants. Cell Adhes Migr 3, 243–249, https://doi.org/10.4161/cam.3.3.8260
(2009). 5. Duda, D. G. et al. CXCL12 (SDF1alpha)-CXCR4/CXCR7 pathway inhibition: an emerging sensitizer for anticancer therapies? Clin
Cancer Res 17, 2074–2080, https://doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-10-2636 (2011).i p
g
6. Feig, C. et al. Targeting CXCL12 from FAP-expressing carcinoma-associated fibroblasts synergizes with anti-P
in pancreatic cancer. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110, 20212–20217, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1320318110 (2 p
g
6. Feig, C. et al. Targeting CXCL12 from FAP-expressing carcinoma-associated fibroblasts synergizes with anti-PD-L1 immunotherapy
in pancreatic cancer Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110 20212–20217 https://doi org/10 1073/pnas 1320318110 (2013) p
g
6. Feig, C. et al. Targeting CXCL12 from FAP-expressing carcinoma-associated fibroblasts synergizes with anti-PD-L1 immunothe 6. Feig, C. et al. Targeting CXCL12 from FAP expressing carcinoma associated fibroblasts synergizes with anti PD L1 immunotherapy
in pancreatic cancer. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110, 20212–20217, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1320318110 (2013).t g
g
g
p
gi
y
g
in pancreatic cancer. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110, 20212–20217, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1320318110 (2013).t p
p
g
p
7. Hughes, R. et al. Perivascular M2 Macrophages Stimulate Tumor Relapse after Chemotherapy. Cancer Res 75, 3479–3491, https:/
doi.org/10.1158/0008-5472.CAN-14-3587 (2015).l g
8. Bernhagen, J. et al. MIF is a noncognate ligand of CXC chemokine receptors in inflammatory and atherogenic cell recruitment. Nat
Med 13, 587–596, https://doi.org/10.1038/nm1567 (2007).h p
g
(
)
9. Shen, Y. C. et al. The cytokine macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) acts as a neurotrophin in the developing in p
g
(
)
9. Shen, Y. C. et al. The cytokine macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) acts as a neurotrophin in the d
the zebrafish, Danio rerio. Developmental biology 363, 84–94, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ydbio.2011.12.023 (2 p
g
9. Shen, Y. C. et al. The cytokine macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) acts as a neurotrophin in the developing inner ear o
the zebrafish Danio rerio Developmental biology 363 84 94 https://doi org/10 1016/j ydbio 2011 12 023 (2012) 9. Shen, Y. C. et al. The cytokine macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) acts as a neurotrophin in the developing inner ear of
the zebrafish, Danio rerio. Developmental biology 363, 84–94, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ydbio.2011.12.023 (2012). h
y
p
g
g
y
p
p g
the zebrafish, Danio rerio. Developmental biology 363, 84–94, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ydbio.2011.12.023 (2012). 10. Lourenco, S. et al. Macrophage migration inhibitory factor-CXCR4 is the dominant chemotactic axis in human m
cell recruitment to tumors. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Cell
transplantation 21, 453–464, https://doi.org/10.3727/096368911X605367 (2012).h p
g
2. Rivera, L. B. et al. Intratumoral Myeloid Cells Regulate Responsiveness and Resistance to Antiangiogenic Therapy. Cell Rep 11
577–591, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2015.03.055 (2015). 3. Silva, M. T. When two is better than one: macrophages and neutrophils work in concert in innate immunity as complementary and
cooperative partners of a myeloid phagocyte system. J Leukocyte Biol 87, 93–106, https://doi.org/10.1189/jlb.0809549 (2010).h p
p
y
p
g
y
y
y
p
g
j
4. Kim, N. D. & Luster, A. D. The role of tissue resident cells in neutrophil recruitment. Trends Immunol. 36, 547–555, https://doi
org/10.1016/j.it.2015.07.007 (2015). 5. Casanova-Acebes, M., A-Gonzalez, N., Weiss, L. A. & Hidalgo, A. Innate immune cells as homeostatic regulators of the
hematopoietic niche. Int J Hematol 99, 685–694, https://doi.org/10.1007/s12185-014-1561-7 (2014). hematopoietic niche. Int J Hematol 99, 685–694, https://doi.org/10.1007/s12185-014-1561-7 (2014). 26. Shiozawa, Y., Eber, M. R., Berry, J. E. & Taichman, R. S. Bone marrow as a metastatic niche for disseminated tumor cells from solid
tumors Bonekey Rep 4 (2015) 6. Shiozawa, Y., Eber, M. R., Berry, J. E. & Taichman, R. S. Bone marrow as a metastatic niche for disseminated tumor cells from solid
tumors. Bonekey Rep. 4 (2015).fi y
p
7. Eash, K. J., Greenbaum, A. M., Gopalan, P. K. & Link, D. C. CXCR2 and CXCR4 antagonistically regulate neutrophil trafficking from
murine bone marrow. J Clin Invest 120, 2423–2431, https://doi.org/10.1172/Jci41649 (2010). p
g
28. Eash, K. J., Means, J. M., White, D. W. & Link, D. C. CXCR4 is a key regulator of neutrophil release fro
basal and stress granulopoiesis conditions. Blood 113, 4711–4719, https://doi.org/10.1182/blood-2008-0 8. Eash, K. J., Means, J. M., White, D. W. & Link, D. C. CXCR4 is a key regulator of neutrophil release from the bone marrow unde
basal and stress granulopoiesis conditions. Blood 113, 4711–4719, https://doi.org/10.1182/blood-2008-09-177287 (2009). 29. Martin, C. et al. Chemokines acting via CXCR2 and CXCR4 control the release of neutrophils from the bone marrow and their
return following senescence. Immunity 19, 583–593, https://doi.org/10.1016/S1074-7613(03)00263-2 (2003). 30. He, S. N. et al. Neutrophil-mediated experimental metastasis is enhanced by VEGFR inhibition in a zebrafish xenograft mo
Pathol 227, 431–445, https://doi.org/10.1002/path.4013 (2012).i p
p
Pathol 227, 431–445, https://doi.org/10.1002/path.4013 (2012) 1. Murayama, E. et al. Tracing hematopoietic precursor migration to successive hematopoietic organs during zebrafish development
Immunity 25, 963–975, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.immuni.2006.10.015 (2006). 31. Murayama, E. et al. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ 3. Dupin, I., Lokmane, L., Dahan, M., Garel, S. & Studer, V. Subrepellent doses of Slit1 promote Netrin-1 chemotactic responses in
subsets of axons. Neural Dev 10, 5, https://doi.org/10.1186/s13064-015-0036-8 (2015). 44. Round, J. & Stein, E. Netrin signaling leading to directed growth cone steering. Curr Opin Neurobiol 17, 15–21, https:/
org/10.1016/j.conb.2007.01.003 (2007). g
j
5. Ly, N. P. et al. Netrin-1 inhibits leukocyte migration in vitro and in vivo. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102, 14729–14734, https://doi
org/10.1073/pnas.0506233102 (2005). g
p
46. Ranganathan, P. V., Jayakumar, C., Mohamed, R., Dong, Z. & Ramesh, G. Netrin-1 regulates the inflammatory response of
neutrophils and macrophages, and suppresses ischemic acute kidney injury by inhibiting COX-2-mediated PGE2 production. Kidney Int 83, 1087–1098, https://doi.org/10.1038/ki.2012.423 (2013). y
p
g
47. Boettcher, S. & Manz, M. G. Sensing and translation of pathogen signals into demand-adapted myelopoiesis. Curr Opin Hemat
5–10, https://doi.org/10.1097/MOH.0000000000000201 (2016). p
g
(
)
48. Manz, M. G. & Boettcher, S. Emergency granulopoiesis. Nat Rev Immunol 14, 302–314, https://doi.org/10.1038/nri3660 (2014
T ki
H B
h
S & M
M G D
d d
d
l i
f
l h
i i i i f
i
d i fl
i
B 49. Takizawa, H., Boettcher, S. & Manz, M. G. Demand-adapted regulation of early hematopoiesis in infection and inflammation. B
119, 2991–3002, https://doi.org/10.1182/blood-2011-12-380113 (2012). 50. Wirths, S., Bugl, S. & Kopp, H. G. Neutrophil homeostasis and its regulation by danger signaling. Blood 123, 3563–3566, https://doi. org/10.1182/blood-2013-11-516260 (2014).i g
51. Liongue, C., Hall, C. J., O’Connell, B. A., Crosier, P. & Ward, A. C. Zebrafish granulocyte colony-stimulating factor receptor signaling
promotes myelopoiesis and myeloid cell migration. Blood 113, 2535–2546, https://doi.org/10.1182/blood-2008-07-171967 (2009).i p
y
p
y
g
,
,
p
g
52. Hall, C. J. et al. Infection-responsive expansion of the hematopoietic stem and progenitor cell compartment in
upon inducible nitric oxide. Cell Stem Cell 10, 198–209, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stem.2012.01.007 (2012).h p
y
p
y
g
p
g
(
)
2. Hall, C. J. et al. Infection-responsive expansion of the hematopoietic stem and progenitor cell compartment in zebrafish is dependen
d
bl
d
ll
ll
h
d
(
) gi
upon inducible nitric oxide. Cell Stem Cell 10, 198–209, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.stem.2012.01.007 (2012).h 3. Vandercappellen, J., Van Damme, J. & Struyf, S. The role of CXC chemokines and their receptors in cancer. Cancer Lett 267, 226–244
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.canlet.2008.04.050 (2008). p
g
j
4. Scala, S. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Nat Methods 9, 671–675 (2012)
6 van der Vaart M et al The DNA damage regulated autophagy modulator DRAM1 links mycobacterial recognition via TLP MYD88 5. Schneider, C. A., Rasband, W. S. & Eliceiri, K. W. NIH Image to ImageJ: 25 years of image analysis. Nat Methods 9, 671–675 (2012)
6. van der Vaart, M. et al. The DNA damage-regulated autophagy modulator DRAM1 links mycobacterial recognition via TLP-MYD88
to authophagic defense. Cell Host Microbe 15, 753–767, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chom.2014.05.005 (2014).ii 65. Schneider, C. A., Rasband, W. S. & Eliceiri, K. W. NIH Image to ImageJ: 25 years of image analysis. Nat Methods 9, 671–675 (2012). 66. van der Vaart, M. et al. The DNA damage-regulated autophagy modulator DRAM1 links mycobacterial recognition via TLP-MYD88 65. Schneider, C. A., Rasband, W. S. & Eliceiri, K. W. NIH Image to ImageJ: 25 years of image analysis. Nat Methods 9, 671–675 (2012). 66. van der Vaart, M. et al. The DNA damage-regulated autophagy modulator DRAM1 links mycobacterial recognition via TLP-MYD88
to authophagic defense. Cell Host Microbe 15, 753–767, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chom.2014.05.005 (2014).ii p
g
p
g
j
7. Rougeot, J. et al. RNA sequencing of FACS-sorted immune cell populations from zebrafish infection models to identify cell specific
responses to intracellular pathogens. Methods Mol Biol 1197, 261–274, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-1261-2_15 (2014). p
g
p
g
j
67. Rougeot, J. et al. RNA sequencing of FACS-sorted immune cell populations from zebrafish infection models to identify cell specific
responses to intracellular pathogens. Methods Mol Biol 1197, 261–274, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-1261-2_15 (2014). Author Contributions C.T., C.S. and Q.C. performed experiments and data analysis. V.T. contributed to immune cell sorting,
optimization of RNA sequencing analytical methods and scientific discussions. A.H.M. gave valuable suggestions
on data analysis and experimental design. C.T. and B.E.S.J. designed experiments and wrote the manuscript. All
authors approved the final version of this manuscript. Acknowledgementsh g
The authors would like to acknowledge Arwin Groenewood (Leiden University) for scientific discussion, Tomasz
Prajsnar (Leiden University) for helping with cell sorting and RNA sequencing analysis and Lanpeng Chen and
Daan Boreel (Leiden University) for PC3-Pro4-Luc and WE68-td-tomato engraftments, respectively. The authors
are grateful to Zakia Kanwal and Julien Rougeot for the initial RNA sequencing analysis of cxcr4a/b expression
levels on FACS-sorted neutrophils. The authors acknowledge all members of the fish care team and D. Gilmour
(EMBL, Heidelberg) and H. Knaut (Max-Plank-Institute, Tübingen) for providing the cxcr4bt26035 zebrafish line. The present work was supported by the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO) (TOP GO
Grant: 854.10.012). VT was supported by the European Marie-Curie Initial Training Network FishForPharma
(PITN-GA-2011–289209). www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Molecular Pathways: Targeting the CXCR4-CXCL12 Axis-Untapped Potential in the Tumor Microenvironment. Clin
Cancer Res, https://doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-14-0914 (2015). p
g
5. Galdiero, M. R. et al. Tumor associated macrophages and neutrophils in cancer. Immunobiology 218, 1402–1410, https://doi
org/10.1016/j.imbio.2013.06.003 (2013). g
j
6. Kessans, M. R., Gatesman, M. L. & Kockler, D. R. Plerixafor: a peripheral blood stem cell mobilizer. Pharmacotherapy 30, 485–492
https://doi.org/10.1592/phco.30.5.485 (2010).fi 57. Gulino, A. V. WHIM syndrome: a genetic disorder of leukocyte trafficking. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol 3, 443–450, https://doi. org/10.1097/01.all.0000104449.09202.d8 (2003). g
8. Ballard, M. S. & Hinck, L. A roundabout way to cancer. Adv Cancer Res 114, 187–235, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-386503
8.00005-3 (2012).h 9. Wu, J. Y. et al. The neuronal repellent Slit inhibits leukocyte chemotaxis induced by chemotactic factors. Nature 410, 948–952
https://doi.org/10.1038/35073616 (2001).h p
g
0. Tole, S. et al. The axonal repellent, Slit2, inhibits directional migration of circulating neutrophils. J Leukoc Biol 86, 1403–1415
https://doi.org/10.1189/jlb.0609391 (2009). p
g
j
1. Jin, S. W., Beis, D., Mitchell, T., Chen, J. N. & Stainier, D. Y. Cellular and molecular analyses of vascular tube and lumen formation in
zebrafish. Development 132, 5199–5209, https://doi.org/10.1242/dev.02087 (2005). i
p
p
g
2. Miyasaka, N., Knaut, H. & Yoshihara, Y. Cxcl12/Cxcr4 chemokine signaling is required for placode assembly and sensory axon i
p
p
g
62. Miyasaka, N., Knaut, H. & Yoshihara, Y. Cxcl12/Cxcr4 chemokine signaling is required for placode assembly and sensory axon
pathfinding in the zebrafish olfactory system. Development 134, 2459–2468, https://doi.org/10.1242/dev.001958 (2007). 2. Miyasaka, N., Knaut, H. & Yoshihara, Y. Cxcl12/Cxcr4 chemokine signaling is required for placode assembly and sensory axon
pathfinding in the zebrafish olfactory system. Development 134, 2459–2468, https://doi.org/10.1242/dev.001958 (2007). ii
63. Ghotra, V. P. S. et al. Automated Whole Animal Bio-Imaging Assay for Human Cancer Dissemination. Plos One 7, ARTN e31281
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0031281 (2012). ii
3. Ghotra, V. P. S. et al. Automated Whole Animal Bio-Imaging Assay for Human Cancer Dissemination. Plos One 7, ARTN e31281
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0031281 (2012). p
g
j
p
4. van der Ent, W. et al. Ewing sarcoma inhibition by disruption of EWSR1-FLI1 transcriptional activity and reactivation of p53. Pathol 233, 415–424, https://doi.org/10.1002/path.4378 (2014). p
g
p
(
)
5. Schneider, C. A., Rasband, W. S. & Eliceiri, K. W. NIH Image to ImageJ: 25 years of image analysis. www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Tracing hematopoietic precursor migration to successive hematopoietic or
Immunity 25, 963–975, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.immuni.2006.10.015 (2006). y
g
j
32. Wetterwald, A. et al. Optical Imaging of cancer metastasis to bone marrow - A mouse model of minimal residual disease. Am J
Pathol 160, 1143–1153, https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-9440(10)64934-6 (2002).it Pathol 160, 1143–1153, https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-9440(10 p
g
33. Tulotta, C. et al. Imaging of Human Cancer Cell Proliferation, Invasion, and Micrometastasis in a Zebrafish Xenogeneic Engraf
Model. Methods Mol Biol 1451, 155–169, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-3771-4_11 (2016).il p
g
4. Renshaw, S. A. et al. A transgenic zebrafish model of neutrophilic inflammation. Blood 108, 3976–3978, https://doi.org/10.1182
blood-2006-05-024075 (2006).i 35. Bussmann, J. & Raz, E. Chemokine-guided cell migration and motility in zebrafish development. Embo J 34, 1309–1318, https://doi. org/10.15252/embj.201490105 (2015).i g
j
6. Knaut, H., Werz, C., Geisler, R., Nusslein-Volhard, C. & Consortium, T. S. A zebrafish homologue of the chemokine receptor Cxcr4
is a germ-cell guidance receptor. Nature 421, 279–282, https://doi.org/10.1038/nature01338 (2003).i 7. Walters, K. B., Green, J. M., Surfus, J. C., Yoo, S. K. & Huttenlocher, A. Live imaging of neutrophil motility in a zebrafish model o
WHIM syndrome. Blood 116, 2803–2811, https://doi.org/10.1182/blood-2010-03-276972 (2010).i 38. Kawai, T. & Malech, H. L. WHIM syndrome: congenital immune deficiency disease. Curr Opin Hematol 16, 20–26, https
org/10.1097/MOH.0b013e32831ac557 (2009).i g
(
)
39. Chen, A. T. & Zon, L. I. Zebrafish blood stem cells. J Cell Biochem 108, 35–42, https://doi.org/10.1002/jcb.22251 (2009). i
0. Tamplin, O. J. et al. Hematopoietic stem cell arrival triggers dynamic remodeling of the perivascular niche. Cell 160, 241–252
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2014.12.032 (2015).l 41. Mitroulis, I. et al. Leukocyte integrins: role in leukocyte recruitment and as therapeutic targets in inflammatory disease. Pharmacol
Ther 147, 123–135, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pharmthera.2014.11.008 (2015). h
p
g
j p
2. Legg, J. A., Herbert, J. M., Clissold, P. & Bicknell, R. Slits and Roundabouts in cancer, tumour angiogenesis and endothelial cel
migration. Angiogenesis 11, 13–21, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10456-008-9100-x (2008). Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 14 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Additional Information Supplementary information accompanies this paper at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2.h Competing Interests: The authors declare no competing interests. Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and
institutional affiliations. Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 15 www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or
format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Cre-
ative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this
article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the
material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not per-
mitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the
copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. © The Author(s) 2019 Scientific Reports | (2019) 9:2399 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-38643-2 16
|
https://openalex.org/W2969883408
|
https://europepmc.org/articles/pmc6747555?pdf=render
|
English
| null |
Dual Beam In Situ Radiation Studies of Nanocrystalline Cu
|
Materials
| 2,019
|
cc-by
| 9,601
|
Received: 25 July 2019; Accepted: 21 August 2019; Published: 25 August 2019 Abstract: Nanocrystalline metals have shown enhanced radiation tolerance as grain boundaries serve
as effective defect sinks for removing radiation-induced defects. However, the thermal and radiation
stability of nanograins are of concerns since radiation may induce grain boundary migration and
grain coarsening in nanocrystalline metals when the grain size falls in the range of several to tens
of nanometers. In addition, prior in situ radiation studies on nanocrystalline metals have focused
primarily on single heavy ion beam radiations, with little consideration of the helium effect on
damage evolution. In this work, we utilized in situ single-beam (1 MeV Kr++) and dual-beam (1 MeV
Kr++ and 12 keV He+) irradiations to investigate the influence of helium on the radiation response
and grain coarsening in nanocrystalline Cu at 300 ◦C. The grain size, orientation, and individual
grain boundary character were quantitatively examined before and after irradiations. Statistic results
suggest that helium bubbles at grain boundaries and grain interiors may retard the grain coarsening. These findings provide new perspective on the radiation response of nanocrystalline metals. Keywords: in situ TEM; dual-beam irradiation; nanocrystalline; grain coarsening; helium bubbles materials materials materials www.mdpi.com/journal/materials Materials 2019, 12, 2721; doi:10.3390/ma12172721 Article
Dual Beam In Situ Radiation Studies of
Nanocrystalline Cu Cuncai Fan 1, Zhongxia Shang 1, Tongjun Niu 1, Jin Li 1, Haiyan Wang 1,2 and Xinghang Zhang 1,*
1
School of Materials Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
2
School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
*
Correspondence: xzhang98@purdue.edu Cuncai Fan 1, Zhongxia Shang 1, Tongjun Niu 1, Jin Li 1, Haiyan Wang 1,2 and Xinghang Zhang 1,*
1
School of Materials Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
2
School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
*
Correspondence: xzhang98@purdue.edu Received: 25 July 2019; Accepted: 21 August 2019; Published: 25 August 2019 1. Introduction Irradiation of metals and alloys produces supersaturated point defects (Frenkel pairs) and defect
clusters [1,2], and thus leads to the degradation in their physical and mechanical properties [3,4]. One effective strategy to alleviate radiation damage is to use various types of interfaces [5], such as grain
boundaries (GBs) [6,7], twin boundaries (TBs) [8,9], phase boundaries [10,11], and free surfaces [12,13]. These interfaces act as defect sinks and are expected to attract, absorb, and annihilate radiation-induced
defects [14]. There are increasing evidences showing that nanostructured materials with high volume
fraction of interfaces are more radiation-tolerant than conventional materials [15–19], in terms of
lower defect density [20,21], less radiation-induced hardening [22,23], and stronger resistance against
amorphization [24]. In spite of their enhanced radiation tolerance, nanostructured materials tend
to become thermally unstable because of the extra energy stored at interfaces [25]. For instance,
radiation-assisted GB and TB migration, accompanied by grain coarsening and detwinning, were
reported in nanocrystalline (NC) [26,27] and nanotwinned (NT) metals [28–31], especially when the
grain size or twin spacing reduces to several to tens of nanometers [29,32]. At the core of nuclear reactors, structural materials are exposed to intense fluxes of neutrons
at elevated temperatures [33]. In order to investigate such radiation damage in a safe, economic,
and efficient way, heavy ion irradiation technique was developed and has been widely adopted as a
surrogate for emulating neutron irradiation damage in the past decades [34]. However, there are various
challenges for the use of single heavy ion irradiation technique to emulate neutron-radiation-induced
damage [35]. For instance, a single type of heavy ion irradiation study often lacks helium (He),
inevitably arising from some nuclear reactions, like the D-T nuclear fusion reaction [36]. As an inert Materials 2019, 12, 2721; doi:10.3390/ma12172721 www.mdpi.com/journal/materials 2 of 14 Materials 2019, 12, 2721 gas, He is hardly soluble in solids and plays an important role in microstructure evolution [37–40]. Under irradiation, He can easily combine with excess vacancies and precipitate as bubbles in matrix,
dislocations, GBs, or heterointerfaces [41,42]. With increasing neutron fluxes and addition of He atoms,
the bubbles may keep growing, leading to void swelling, hardening, and embrittlement [4,43–45]. Therefore, to better simulate the neutron radiation damage with heavy ion irradiation technique, it
has been suggested that pre-injection or simultaneous implantation of He may be necessary while
conducting regular heavy ion irradiation studies [46]. 2. Materials and Methods NC Cu (99.995 at.%) films (~2 µm) were deposited on the HF-etched Si (111) substrates at room
temperature (RT) by direct current magnetron sputtering technique. Plan-view TEM specimens were
prepared and subsequently irradiated using the Intermediate Voltage Electron Microscope (IVEM)
Tandem Facility at the Argonne National Laboratory (Chicago, IL, USA), where an ion accelerator is
attached to a Hitachi 900 NAR microscope (Hitachi, Tokyo, Japan) operated at 200 kV. The ion source
included 1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+ with the ion beam incidented at 30◦from the electron beam
and 15◦from the foil normal, as schematically illustrated in Figure 1a. To explore the effect of He on
radiation damage, two independent irradiation experiments were conducted using the single heavy
ion beam of Kr++, and the dual beams of Kr++ plus He+. For single-beam irradiation, the specimen
was irradiated by 1 MeV Kr++ at 300 ◦C at a dose rate of 6.25 × 1011 ions cm−2 s−1 up to a fluence of
1 × 1015 ions cm−2. For dual-beam irradiation, the specimen was first implanted at RT by 12 keV He+,
with a dose rate of 1.25 × 1012 ions cm−2 s−1 and to a fluence of 6.7 × 1014 ions cm−2. The He-injected
specimen was then irradiated simultaneously by 1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+, and their dose rates
were 6.25 × 1011 ions cm−2 s−1 and 2.08 × 1010 ions cm−2 s−1, respectively, up to the same fluence of
1 × 1015 ions cm−2. Irradiation damage was calculated by the Stopping and Range of Ions in Matter (SRIM) with full
damage cascades and the displacement energy of 30 eV for Cu [47]. The calculated depth profiles of ion
concentration and radiation damage, in unit of displacements-per-atom (dpa), are given in Figure 1b,c. The TEM foil thickness is estimated to be ~100 nm, and the SRIM calculations reveal that most (~95%)
of the Kr++ transmitted through the TEM foil and caused a high radiation dose of ~5 dpa, while most
(~92%) of the He+ ions were injected into the foil with negligible damage, ~0.01 dpa. The average He
concentration is ~1.5 at.%. All the TEM specimens, as-deposited or irradiated, were characterized by a Thermo Fischer
Scientific/FEI Talos 200X microscope equipped with a NanoMEGAS ASTAR precession electron
diffraction system that allows for high-resolution crystal orientation mapping [48]. 1. Introduction In this work, we utilize in situ transmission electron microscope (TEM) technique to directly
compare the distinctions between single-beam heavy ion irradiation (1 MeV Kr++) and dual-beam
irradiation (by 1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+), and combine the recent advance in automated crystal
orientation mapping capability in transmission electron microscope, to explore the He effect on ion
irradiation-induced grain coarsening in NC Cu at 300 ◦C. The findings provide new insights for
understanding the irradiation response of NC metals and their potential applications in advanced
nuclear energy system. 2. Materials and Methods Multiple locations
with the same area (1.92 × 1.92 µm2) were selected and scanned for each specimen by using ASTAR
system. The spot size of electron beam for scanning is ~2 nm, and the scanning step size is ~5 nm. 3 of 14
diated 3 of 14
diated Materials 2019, 12, 2721
1g seems to be betw
specimen in Figure Figure 1. Singe- and dual-beam irradiations on nanocrystalline (NC) Cu at 300 °C. (a) Experimental
set up of in situ heavy ion TEM irradiations; (b,c) SRIM calculations of depth profiles of ion
concentration and corresponding radiation dose; (d) As-deposited NC Cu with some preexisting
nanovoids at grain boundaries (GBs); (e) Single-beam (1 MeV Kr++) irradiation at 300 °C for 5 dpa; (f)
He pre-injection at room temperature (RT); (g) Dual-beam (1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+) irradiation at
300 °C to 5 dpa
Figure 1. Singe- and dual-beam irradiations on nanocrystalline (NC) Cu at 300 ◦C. (a) Experimental set
up of in situ heavy ion TEM irradiations; (b,c) SRIM calculations of depth profiles of ion concentration
and corresponding radiation dose; (d) As-deposited NC Cu with some preexisting nanovoids at grain
boundaries (GBs); (e) Single-beam (1 MeV Kr++) irradiation at 300 ◦C for 5 dpa; (f) He pre-injection at
room temperature (RT); (g) Dual-beam (1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+) irradiation at 300 ◦C to 5 dpa. Figure 1. Singe- and dual-beam irradiations on nanocrystalline (NC) Cu at 300 °C. (a) Experimental
set up of in situ heavy ion TEM irradiations; (b,c) SRIM calculations of depth profiles of ion
concentration and corresponding radiation dose; (d) As-deposited NC Cu with some preexisting
nanovoids at grain boundaries (GBs); (e) Single-beam (1 MeV Kr++) irradiation at 300 °C for 5 dpa; (f)
He pre-injection at room temperature (RT); (g) Dual-beam (1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+) irradiation at
300 °C to 5 dpa. Figure 1. Singe- and dual-beam irradiations on nanocrystalline (NC) Cu at 300 ◦C. (a) Experimental set
up of in situ heavy ion TEM irradiations; (b,c) SRIM calculations of depth profiles of ion concentration
and corresponding radiation dose; (d) As-deposited NC Cu with some preexisting nanovoids at grain
boundaries (GBs); (e) Single-beam (1 MeV Kr++) irradiation at 300 ◦C for 5 dpa; (f) He pre-injection at
room temperature (RT); (g) Dual-beam (1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+) irradiation at 300 ◦C to 5 dpa. R
lt Figure 1. 2. Materials and Methods Singe- and dual-beam irradiations on nanocrystalline (NC) Cu at 300 °C. (a) Experimental
set up of in situ heavy ion TEM irradiations; (b,c) SRIM calculations of depth profiles of ion
concentration and corresponding radiation dose; (d) As-deposited NC Cu with some preexisting
nanovoids at grain boundaries (GBs); (e) Single-beam (1 MeV Kr++) irradiation at 300 °C for 5 dpa; (f)
He pre-injection at room temperature (RT); (g) Dual-beam (1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+) irradiation at
300 °C to 5 dpa
Figure 1. Singe- and dual-beam irradiations on nanocrystalline (NC) Cu at 300 ◦C. (a) Experimental set
up of in situ heavy ion TEM irradiations; (b,c) SRIM calculations of depth profiles of ion concentration
and corresponding radiation dose; (d) As-deposited NC Cu with some preexisting nanovoids at grain
boundaries (GBs); (e) Single-beam (1 MeV Kr++) irradiation at 300 ◦C for 5 dpa; (f) He pre-injection at
room temperature (RT); (g) Dual-beam (1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+) irradiation at 300 ◦C to 5 dpa. Figure 2 compares the TEM snapshots of NC Cu subje
irradiations to 5 dpa. Frequent GB migrations of small gr
3.1. In Situ Study of Irradiation-Induced Microstructure Evolution p
q
g
g
p
g
irradiation in Figure 2a–d, and the shrinkage rate of small grains tended to decrease with increasing
grain size. For instance, 7 representative tiny grains that are <100 nm are denoted by 1–7 in Figure 2a,
and they all shrank rapidly and disappeared when irradiated to 1.25 dpa, as shown in Figure 2b. In
contrast, another large grain marked as 8 in Figure 2a–d remained its triangular shape and shrank
gradually. Moreover, several other large grains barely shrank but evolved into polygons. Their
initially curved GBs became straight, as marked by the arrows in Figure 2a–c. Meanwhile, the angles
between adjacent grains evolved to an equilibrium angle of ~120°, as shown in Figure 2d. In
comparison, no obvious GB migrations were observed in dual-beam irradiated Cu shown in Figure
2e–h. Some of the grains slightly rearranged their geometry as shown by a typical outlined grain in
Figure 1d is a bright-field (BF) TEM micrograph of the as-deposited sample with a broad
distribution of grain sizes, ranging from tens of nm to a few hundred nm. The inset selected area
diffraction (SAD) pattern indicates the formation of polycrystalline metals, and the arrows denote
some nanovoids formed along GBs. Figure 1e shows the microstructure after single-beam irradiation
by 1 MeV Kr++ to 5 dpa at 300 ◦C. Compared with Figure 1d, grain sizes in Figure 1e have apparently
increased and the preexisting nanovoids have disappeared. Figure 1f shows the microstructure after
He-injection to a concentration of 1 at.% at RT and a low dose of only 0.007 dpa. Most of the preexisting
nanovoids retained. After irradiations with dual beams of 1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+ to 5 dpa at
300 ◦C, corresponding to a He concentration of 1.5 at.%, Figure 1g displays that most of the nanovoids
have disappeared. In addition, the average grain size after dual-beam irradiation in Figure 1g seems to
be between that of as-deposited specimen in Figure 1d and that of single-beam irradiated specimen in
Figure 1e. Figure 2 compares the TEM snapshots of NC Cu subjected to single-beam and dual-beam
irradiations to 5 dpa. Frequent GB migrations of small grains were captured in single-beam irradiation 4 of 14 Materials 2019, 12, 2721 in Figure 2a–d, and the shrinkage rate of small grains tended to decrease with increasing grain size. Figure 2 compares the TEM snapshots of NC Cu subje
irradiations to 5 dpa. Frequent GB migrations of small gr
3.1. In Situ Study of Irradiation-Induced Microstructure Evolution For instance, 7 representative tiny grains that are <100 nm are denoted by 1–7 in Figure 2a, and they
all shrank rapidly and disappeared when irradiated to 1.25 dpa, as shown in Figure 2b. In contrast,
another large grain marked as 8 in Figure 2a–d remained its triangular shape and shrank gradually. Moreover, several other large grains barely shrank but evolved into polygons. Their initially curved
GBs became straight, as marked by the arrows in Figure 2a–c. Meanwhile, the angles between adjacent
grains evolved to an equilibrium angle of ~120◦, as shown in Figure 2d. In comparison, no obvious
GB migrations were observed in dual-beam irradiated Cu shown in Figure 2e–h. Some of the grains
slightly rearranged their geometry as shown by a typical outlined grain in Figure 2e–h. He bubbles
emerged at 1.25 dpa with a He concentration of ~1.125 at.%, as shown by the inset in Figure 2f. Materials 2019, 12, x FOR PEER REVIEW
4 of 13
Figure 2e–h. He bubbles emerged at 1.25 dpa with a He concentration of ~1.125 at.%, as shown by the
inset in Figure 2f. Figure 2. In situ TEM snapshot displaying microstructural evolution of NC Cu under single-beam (a–
d) and dual-beam irradiation (e–h). GB migrations were frequently captured in single-beam
irradiation and grain coarsening occurred at the expense of small grains, as evidenced by the
shrinkage of several tiny grains marked by number 1–8 in (a–d). The arrows in (a) mark the curved
GBs for a large grain that became straight with increasing dose in (b, c). In contrast, the grains under
dual-beam irradiation only experienced slight rearrangement of their geometries, as shown by the
dotted lines in (e h)
Figure 2. In situ TEM snapshot displaying microstructural evolution of NC Cu under single-beam (a–d)
and dual-beam irradiation (e–h). GB migrations were frequently captured in single-beam irradiation
and grain coarsening occurred at the expense of small grains, as evidenced by the shrinkage of several
tiny grains marked by number 1–8 in (a–d). The arrows in (a) mark the curved GBs for a large grain
that became straight with increasing dose in (b, c). In contrast, the grains under dual-beam irradiation
only experienced slight rearrangement of their geometries, as shown by the dotted lines in (e–h). Figure 2. In situ TEM snapshot displaying microstructural evolution of NC Cu under single-beam (a–
d) and dual-beam irradiation (e–h). Figure 2 compares the TEM snapshots of NC Cu subje
irradiations to 5 dpa. Frequent GB migrations of small gr
3.1. In Situ Study of Irradiation-Induced Microstructure Evolution GB migrations were frequently captured in single-beam
irradiation and grain coarsening occurred at the expense of small grains, as evidenced by the
shrinkage of several tiny grains marked by number 1–8 in (a–d). The arrows in (a) mark the curved
GBs for a large grain that became straight with increasing dose in (b, c). In contrast, the grains under
dual-beam irradiation only experienced slight rearrangement of their geometries, as shown by the
Figure 2. In situ TEM snapshot displaying microstructural evolution of NC Cu under single-beam (a–d)
and dual-beam irradiation (e–h). GB migrations were frequently captured in single-beam irradiation
and grain coarsening occurred at the expense of small grains, as evidenced by the shrinkage of several
tiny grains marked by number 1–8 in (a–d). The arrows in (a) mark the curved GBs for a large grain
that became straight with increasing dose in (b, c). In contrast, the grains under dual-beam irradiation
only experienced slight rearrangement of their geometries, as shown by the dotted lines in (e–h). dotted lines in (e–h).
3.2. Post-irradiation Analyses 3.2. Post-irradiation Analyses
To better characterize the evolution of GBs, an ASTAR automated crystal orientation mapping
system was used to analyze the as-deposited, single-beam irradiated, and dual-beam irradiated Cu
samples. Comparison of the orientation maps in Figure 3a–c clearly demonstrates prominent grain
growth in irradiated specimens. In addition, the grain boundary maps in Figure 3d,f reveal a large
fraction of Σ3 coherent TBs (yellow lines) in all samples. The enlarged view in Figure 3g reveals that
the as-deposited NC Cu is characterized by irregular and curved GBs. In comparison, the single-beam
irradiated NC Cu contains a significant number of straight boundaries often forming angles of 120°
at triple junctions, as shown in Figure 3h. The dual-beam irradiated NC Cu, on the other hand,
To better characterize the evolution of GBs, an ASTAR automated crystal orientation mapping
system was used to analyze the as-deposited, single-beam irradiated, and dual-beam irradiated Cu
samples. Comparison of the orientation maps in Figure 3a–c clearly demonstrates prominent grain
growth in irradiated specimens. In addition, the grain boundary maps in Figure 3d,f reveal a large
fraction of Σ3 coherent TBs (yellow lines) in all samples. The enlarged view in Figure 3g reveals that
the as-deposited NC Cu is characterized by irregular and curved GBs. In comparison, the single-beam
irradiated NC Cu contains a significant number of straight boundaries often forming angles of 120◦at
triple junctions, as shown in Figure 3h. The dual-beam irradiated NC Cu, on the other hand, maintains
curved GBs that are decorated with abundant He bubbles as shown in Figure 3i. 5 of 14
5 of 13 Materials 2019, 12, 2721
Materials 2019, 12, x FOR Figure 3. Microstructural characterization of as-deposited (a,d,g), single-beam irradiated (b,e,h), and
dual-beam irradiated samples (c,f,i). (a–c) Crystal orientation maps obtained from ASTAR system. (d–f) Grain boundary maps superimposed upon image quality maps. (g–i) TEM micrographs
showing enlarged views of representative GBs. Figure 3. Microstructural characterization of as-deposited (a,d,g), single-beam irradiated (b,e,h), and
dual-beam irradiated samples (c,f,i). (a–c) Crystal orientation maps obtained from ASTAR system. (d–f) Grain boundary maps superimposed upon image quality maps. (g–i) TEM micrographs showing
enlarged views of representative GBs. Figure 3. Microstructural characterization of as-deposited (a,d,g), single-beam irradiated (b,e,h), and
dual-beam irradiated samples (c,f,i). (a–c) Crystal orientation maps obtained from ASTAR system. (d–f) Grain boundary maps superimposed upon image quality maps. (g–i) TEM micrographs
showing enlarged views of representative GBs. Figure 3. dotted lines in (e–h).
3.2. Post-irradiation Analyses Microstructural characterization of as-deposited (a,d,g), single-beam irradiated (b,e,h), and
dual-beam irradiated samples (c,f,i). (a–c) Crystal orientation maps obtained from ASTAR system. (d–f) Grain boundary maps superimposed upon image quality maps. (g–i) TEM micrographs showing
enlarged views of representative GBs. The statistics of grain size evolutions were derived from a study of 1646 grains for the as-deposited
sample, 552 and 696 grains for the single-beam and dual-beam irradiated samples, respectively. The grain size is quantified by equivalent diameter D that equals to 2 √(A/π), where A refers to the
individual grain area. The grain size histograms for the three samples are shown in Figure 4a, and
their corresponding cumulative probabilities P are plotted in Figure 4b as a function of D. Note that
the probability curves shift rightward after irradiations due to grain growth, and the red curve for
dual-beam irradiated sample in Figure 4b is between that of as-deposited (black) and single-beam
irradiated sample (blue). The fraction of smaller grains that are less than 100 nm drops from 83% to
60 and 47% after dual-beam and single-beam irradiation, respectively. The corresponding median
grain size D0.5 (P = 0.5) increases from 56 ± 4 nm to 83 ± 2 nm after dual-beam irradiation, and to
103 ± 5 nm after single-beam irradiation. In particular, the lower right inset in Figure 4b reveals that
the fraction of grains smaller than 40 nm is around 30% in the as-deposited sample, and it decreases
drastically after either dual-beam or single-beam irradiation. Materials 2019, 12, 2721
(d–f) Grain bou 6 of 14
hs showing enlarged views of representative GBs. Figure 4. (a) Grain size (equivalent diameter) histograms for as-deposited (black), single-beam
irradiated (blue), and dual-beam irradiated (red) sample. (b) Cumulative probability versus grain
i
Figure 4. (a) Grain size (equivalent diameter) histograms for as-deposited (black), single-beam
irradiated (blue), and dual-beam irradiated (red) sample. (b) Cumulative probability versus grain size. Materials 2019, 12, x FOR PEER REVIEW
6 of 13 Figure 4. (a) Grain size (equivalent diameter) histograms for as-deposited (black), single-beam
irradiated (blue), and dual-beam irradiated (red) sample. (b) Cumulative probability versus grain
Figure 4. (a) Grain size (equivalent diameter) histograms for as-deposited (black), single-beam
irradiated (blue), and dual-beam irradiated (red) sample. (b) Cumulative probability versus grain size. aterials 2019, 12, x FOR PEER REVIEW
6 of 1 size. The misorientation angle (θ) distributions for the three specimens are compared in Figure 5a. dotted lines in (e–h).
3.2. Post-irradiation Analyses The GBs have been divided into three major categories according to their misorientation angle:
low-angle GBs (θ < 15◦), high-angle GBs (15◦< θ < 60◦), and special Σ3 coherent TBs (θ = 60◦). TBs account for one-quarter of all boundaries for the three specimens. The statistic results in Figure 5b,c
show that all GBs decreased in length after irradiations, and it was found that the high-angle GBs
(15◦< θ) in single-beam irradiated sample reduced the most. The detailed statistics on evolutions of
grain size and GB misorientation angles are summarized in Table 1. The misorientation angle (θ) distributions for the three specimens are compared in Figure 5a. The GBs have been divided into three major categories according to their misorientation angle: low-
angle GBs (θ < 15o), high-angle GBs (15° < θ < 60°), and special Σ3 coherent TBs (θ = 60°). TBs account
for one-quarter of all boundaries for the three specimens. The statistic results in Figure 5b,c show that
all GBs decreased in length after irradiations, and it was found that the high-angle GBs (15° < θ) in
single-beam irradiated sample reduced the most. The detailed statistics on evolutions of grain size
and GB misorientation angles are summarized in Table 1. Figure 5. (a) Misorientation angle (θ) histograms for as-deposited (black), single-beam irradiated
(blue), and dual-beam irradiated (red) samples. (b) Boundary length for low-angle (red bars, θ = 0–
15°) and high-angle (blue bars, θ = 15–60°) GBs, as well as Σ3 twin boundaries (TBs) (yellow bars, θ =
60°). (c) GB length reduction for dual-beam (red) and single-beam (blue) irradiated samples, relative
to the as-deposited sample. Figure 5. (a) Misorientation angle (θ) histograms for as-deposited (black), single-beam irradiated (blue),
and dual-beam irradiated (red) samples. (b) Boundary length for low-angle (red bars, θ = 0–15◦) and
high-angle (blue bars, θ = 15–60◦) GBs, as well as Σ3 twin boundaries (TBs) (yellow bars, θ = 60◦). (c) GB length reduction for dual-beam (red) and single-beam (blue) irradiated samples, relative to the
as-deposited sample. Figure 5. (a) Misorientation angle (θ) histograms for as-deposited (black), single-beam irradiated
(blue), and dual-beam irradiated (red) samples. (b) Boundary length for low-angle (red bars, θ = 0–
15°) and high-angle (blue bars, θ = 15–60°) GBs, as well as Σ3 twin boundaries (TBs) (yellow bars, θ =
60°). (c) GB length reduction for dual-beam (red) and single-beam (blue) irradiated samples, relative
to the as-deposited sample. dotted lines in (e–h).
3.2. Post-irradiation Analyses Figure 5. (a) Misorientation angle (θ) histograms for as-deposited (black), single-beam irradiated (blue),
and dual-beam irradiated (red) samples. (b) Boundary length for low-angle (red bars, θ = 0–15◦) and
high-angle (blue bars, θ = 15–60◦) GBs, as well as Σ3 twin boundaries (TBs) (yellow bars, θ = 60◦). (c) GB length reduction for dual-beam (red) and single-beam (blue) irradiated samples, relative to the
as-deposited sample. 7 of 14 Materials 2019, 12, 2721 Table 1. Summary of grain size and GB characters for as-deposited, dual-beam irradiated, and
single-beam irradiated NC Cu, collected from a large area (11.06 µm2) at three different locations. D0.5:
the median grain size when P = 0.5. Sample
Number of
Grains
Grain Size
D0.5 (nm)
Grain Boundary Length, LGB (µm)
0–15◦
15–60◦
60◦(Σ3)
As-deposited
1646
56 ± 4
6.2 ± 0.1
73.8 ± 4.4
26.2 ± 0.7
Dual-beam
696
83 ± 2
4.7 ± 0.2
38.9 ± 0.7
12.1 ± 0.1
Single-beam
552
103 ± 5
3.5 ± 0.1
24.6 ± 1.9
10.8 ± 2.0 4. Discussion Grain coarsening arises from GB migration. The migration velocity v of an isolated boundary in
one dimension can be described by [49]:
∂ Grain coarsening arises from GB migration. The migration velocity v of an isolated boundary in
one dimension can be described by [49]:
∂ v = −M∂µ
∂x
(1) (1) where M is the GB mobility and increases with increasing temperature, and ∂µ/∂x is the driving
force and increases with decreasing grain size due to the boundary curvature effect. There are
increasing experimental evidences that show GB migration velocity is accelerated considerably
under irradiation [27,32,50,51], and the irradiation-enhanced grain coarsening occurs even at room
temperature when thermal activation makes little contribution [26]. To describe the radiation effects
on grain coarsening, a thermal spike (damage cascade) model was proposed [26,49], according to
which the radiation-assisted GB migration occurs within thermal spikes through atomic jumps that
are biased by local GB curvature. Moreover, the radiation effects on GB structure and its migration
were also well studied by atomistic simulations [6,50,52–55]. It was found that the free volume in GBs
can accommodate extra interstitials [6,52], which makes interstitial-loaded GBs so unstable that they
frequently migrate to annihilate vacancy clusters nearby [53,54]. In addition, for small grains with
dimensions comparable to the thermal spike volume, their boundary area may overlap with thermal
spikes, so small grains may undergo drastic grain growth through disorder-driven mechanism [32,55]. These prior studies suggest that irradiation-induced grain growth is often determined by two major
factors: the GB curvature and the interaction between damage cascades and GBs. In the current study,
we found that the radiation-assisted grain coarsening can also be influenced by the He bubbles, and
the underlying mechanism will be discussed later in detail. The interaction between damage cascades and GBs can be simply divided into two scenarios
that are sink-dominated or recombination-dominated. For the former scenario, the majority of
radiation-induced defects, including equal numbers of vacancies and interstitials, are trapped and
annihilated by defect sinks; whereas for the latter case, defects are mostly eliminated through
vacancy-interstitial recombination. It was proposed that a dimensionless parameter E that considers
the defect recombination and fluxes into defect sinks can be used to evaluate which mechanism is
dominating [26]. 4. Discussion In the single-beam irradiation, the parameter E1 can be written as: E1 =
k2
GBDi
k2
GBDv
4K0Kiv
(2) (2) where Di and Dv are the diffusion coefficients for interstitials and vacancies, respectively. k2
GB is the GB
sink strength, estimated as [56]: where Di and Dv are the diffusion coefficients for interstitials and vacancies, respectively. k2
GB is the GB
sink strength, estimated as [56]: k2
GB = 60
D2
(3) k2
GB = 60
D2 (3) rials 2019, 12, 2721
8 of 1 Materials 2019, 12, 2721 Materials 2019, 12, 2721 8 of 14 where D is the grain size. K0 is the displacement rate (~0.003 dpa/s in current study), and Kiv is the
constant for interstitial-vacancy recombination rate and is given by: where D is the grain size. K0 is the displacement rate (~0.003 dpa/s in current study), and Kiv is the
constant for interstitial-vacancy recombination rate and is given by: Kiv = 4π(Di + Dv)
Ω
= Kiv0(Di + Dv)
(4) (4) where Ωis the atomic volume, and Kiv0, in cm−2, is a material constant, ~6.98 × 1016 cm−2 for Cu [26]. Substituting Equations (3) and (4) into Equation (2) yields: where Ωis the atomic volume, and Kiv0, in cm−2, is a material constant, ~6.98 × 1016 cm−2 for Cu [26]. Substituting Equations (3) and (4) into Equation (2) yields: E1 =
D4K0Kiv0
900
1
Di
+ 1
Dv
! (5) (5) As Di ≫Dv, for irradiation of Cu at 300 ◦C, Equation (5) is simplified to: As Di ≫Dv, for irradiation of Cu at 300 ◦C, Equation (5) is simplified to: E1 =
D4K0Kiv0
900Dv
(6) (6) Under dual-beam irradiation, He bubbles act as extra defect sinks that compete with GBs in
absorbing point defects. The effective parameter E2 in the presence of He bubbles is thus modified as: E2 =
k2
GBDi
k2
GBDv
4K0Kiv +
k2
BDi
k2
BDv
(7) (7) where k2
B is the sink strength for bubbles and is given by [57]: where k2
B is the sink strength for bubbles and is given by [57]: k2
B = 4πρR2
a
(8) (8) where ρ is the bubble density, R is the bubble radius, and a is the lattice parameter (~0.3615 nm for Cu). 4. Discussion Combining Equations (3)–(5) and (8), Equation (7) can be simplified into: where ρ is the bubble density, R is the bubble radius, and a is the lattice parameter (~0.3615 nm for Cu). Combining Equations (3)–(5) and (8), Equation (7) can be simplified into: E2 =
900Dva2
a2K0Kiv0 + 4πR4ρ2DvD4
(9) (9) Post-irradiation TEM study in Figure 3i shows that the bubble radius R is ~1 nm, and the bubble
density is around 0.0005 nm−3. The vacancy diffusivity Dv is estimated by [57]: Post-irradiation TEM study in Figure 3i shows that the bubble radius R is ~1 nm, and the bubble
density is around 0.0005 nm−3. The vacancy diffusivity Dv is estimated by [57]: Dv = a2υ exp
−Ev
m
kT
! (10) (10) where υ is the Debye frequency (~1013 s−1), Ev
m is the vacancy activation migration energy (0.8 eV for
Cu) [57], k is the Boltzmann constant, and T is the temperature (300 ◦C in current study). Substituting
all the parameters into in Equations (6) and (9) and plotting the values of E1 and E2 as a function of
grain size D result in Figure 6. The physical meaning of E in our calculations refers to the magnitude of radiation-induced defects
that can be trapped by preexisting GBs relative to the defects removed through recombination or He
bubbles. According to previous studies, it is plausible to assume that only when sufficient defects diffuse
into GBs, GBs can experience structure change and instability, followed by GB migration and grain
coarsening [53]. In principle, a value of E ≫1 indicates the radiation–GB interaction is sink-dominated,
whereas E ≪1 indicates the interaction is recombination-dominated. The curves obtained in Figure 6
suggest the interaction transits from sink-dominated regime to recombination-dominated regime with
increasing grain size D. There is a critical grain size, below which the interaction is sink-dominated and
the radiation-assisted grain coarsening is most likely to occur. Note that the red curve of dual-beam 9 of 14
Fe ion
diation Materials 2019, 12, 2721
He ion irradiation
radiation studies on irradiation is below the blue curve, and the critical grain size shifts from 25 nm to 50 nm, when He
bubbles are present. The plot also suggests that grain size D should be kept slightly larger than the
transition value, so that the nanograins can effectively enhance radiation tolerance while retaining
their structural stability. 4. Discussion studies that show TBs engage, interact, and eliminate radiation induced defect clusters [64,65]. For
instance, an in situ radiation study on NT Ag showed that there is indeed a defect denuded zone near
TBs based on the statistics of time accumulated defect cluster density [65]. These observations and
current study may offer a new strategy for improving radiation tolerance while maintaining
microstructural stability through the coupling of TB architectures with other defects sinks [60,66]. Figure 6. E parameter (logarithmic scale) versus grain size for single-beam (blue curve) and dual-beam
(red curve) irradiated Cu at 300 ◦C. Case 1: Single-beam irradiation on small grains. Case 2: Dual-beam
irradiation on small grains. Case 3: Irradiation of large grains. See the text for more details. Figure 6. E parameter (logarithmic scale) versus grain size for single-beam (blue curve) and dual-beam
(red curve) irradiated Cu at 300 ◦C. Case 1: Single-beam irradiation on small grains. Case 2: Dual-beam
irradiation on small grains. Case 3: Irradiation of large grains. See the text for more details. It is worth pointing out that the two curves in Figure 6 show little difference when the grain size
D is less than 5 nm. Our in situ observations in Figure 2 and post-irradiation statistics in Figure 4 also
indicate that nanograins rapidly disappeared under single-beam or dual-beam irradiation. The damage
cascade size D∗of 1 MeV Kr++ irradiation on Cu is estimated to be 7 nm (see Appendix A). Therefore,
the direct overlap of damage cascade with nanograins of similar dimension may lead to drastic grain
coarsening at the expense of fine grains through disorder-driven mechanism [32,55]. Next, we compare the radiation-assisted GB migration and grain coarsening under single-beam
and dual-beam irradiations. For simplicity, we divide the results into three cases according to the grain
size D, as schematically illustrated in Figure 6. Case 1: Radiation-assisted grain coarsening for small grains under single-beam irradiation. This case applies to sink-dominated interaction (E > 1), and damage cascade can entirely or partially
overlap with small grains. Sufficient point defects can diffuse into GBs, leading to GB structure change
and migration through disorder-driven [32,55] or thermal spike mechanism [26,49]. Case 2: Radiation-assisted grain coarsening for small grains under dual-beam irradiation. In this
case, the radiation-GB interaction is still sink-dominated (E > 1). 4. Discussion However, due to the formation of
high-density He bubbles at GBs or grain interiors, the fraction of defects contributing to GB structure
change and migration is reduced. Compared with single-beam irradiation, the radiation-assisted GB
migration in dual-beam irradiated specimen is inhibited for two reasons: first, the bubbles at grain
interiors can capture more point defects; second, the bubbles at GBs can exert pinning effect on GBs. Case 2: Radiation-assisted grain coarsening for small grains under dual-beam irradiation. In this
case, the radiation-GB interaction is still sink-dominated (E > 1). However, due to the formation of
high-density He bubbles at GBs or grain interiors, the fraction of defects contributing to GB structure
change and migration is reduced. Compared with single-beam irradiation, the radiation-assisted GB
migration in dual-beam irradiated specimen is inhibited for two reasons: first, the bubbles at grain
interiors can capture more point defects; second, the bubbles at GBs can exert pinning effect on GBs. Materials 2019, 12, 2721 10 of 14 10 of 14 Case 3: Irradiation on large grains with recombination-dominated interactions (E < 1). In this
case, most of the radiation-induced defects are removed through vacancy-interstitial recombination,
so they make little contribution to GB migrations. For single-beam irradiation, damage cascade may
occasionally occur near GBs. However, as the grain sizes are rather large, the local boundary curvature
change due to cascade may be too small to drive prominent GB migrations [54]. The GB migrations
may stop when GBs become straight, as shown in Figure 2. Meanwhile, the triple junctions can reach a
stable state with three equal angles of ~120◦, as shown in Figure 3h. For dual-beam irradiation, the
local GBs can hardly move because of the pinning effect arising from He bubbles. As a result, GBs
remain curved after irradiation, as shown in Figure 3i. g
Finally, it should be emphasized that, in addition to grain size, radiation-GB interaction and GB
migration may also be influenced by GB inherent structures [58]. For instance, compared with regular
high-angle GBs, coherent TBs (CTBs) exhibit remarkable thermal stability after annealing to 800 ◦C [59],
and they can retain their structural integrity during heavy irradiation [29,60]. Our post-irradiation
analyses in Figure 3 also reveal a large fraction of surviving Σ3 CTBs in single-beam and dual-beam
irradiated samples. A previous study on He ion irradiation response by Demkowicz et al. 4. Discussion [61] suggested
that TBs are not effective defect sinks, based on the observation that there were no defect denuded
zones near TBs in He ion irradiated NT Cu. A thorough analysis may be beneficial to compare the
density and dimension of He bubbles in bulk Cu irradiated to the same dose. Interestingly the atomistic
simulations by Demkowicz et al. revealed that Σ3 CTBs can promote Frenkel pair recombination
and decrease point defect production rate [61]. There are numerous prior studies that show TBs are
effective defect sinks [8,31,62,63]. For instance, in Kr ion irradiated NT Ag, the density of stacking fault
tetrahedrons is less in NT Ag with smaller twin spacing [62]. In other words, a clear size effect exists
in irradiated NT metals. Recently, it was reported that less He bubbles are produced in NT Cu with
nanovoids than annealed coarse-grained Cu, when subjected to identical He ion irradiation conditions
at RT [63]. Similar phenomenon was also reported in the Fe ion radiation studies on NT austenitic
stainless steel [8]. Meanwhile, there are increasing in situ radiation studies that show TBs engage,
interact, and eliminate radiation-induced defect clusters [64,65]. For instance, an in situ radiation
study on NT Ag showed that there is indeed a defect denuded zone near TBs based on the statistics of
time accumulated defect cluster density [65]. These observations and current study may offer a new
strategy for improving radiation tolerance while maintaining microstructural stability through the
coupling of TB architectures with other defects sinks [60,66]. Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest. Author Contributions: C.F. designed and conducted the preliminary experiments with Z.S., T.N., and J.L.; Z.S.
aided in ASTAR analysis; C.F. analyzed the data and wrote the manuscript under the supervision of X.Z. and H.W.
Funding: This research was funded by National Science Foundation, Civil, Mechanical and Manufacturing
Innovation, under grant number 1728419. This work was also supported by National Science Foundation, Division
of Materials Research, Metallic Materials and Nanostructures Program under grant number 1611380.
Acknowledgments: We acknowledge Meimei Li, Pete Baldo, and Wei-Ying Chen at Argonne National Laboratory
(Chicago, IL, USA) for their help in our radiation experiments.
Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest. Acknowledgments: We acknowledge Meimei Li, Pete Baldo, and Wei-Ying Chen at Argonne National Labora
Chicago, IL, USA) for their help in our radiation experiments. 5. Conclusions Nanocrystalline Cu films were irradiated with single-ion beam (1 MeV Kr++) and dual-ion beams
(1 MeV Kr++ and 12 keV He+). Substantial GB migration and grain coarsening were captured in
irradiated samples. The irradiation-induced GB migration is attributed to the interaction between
damage cascade and preexisting GBs. With increasing grain size, the interaction transits from
sink-dominated to recombination-dominated regime, and the radiation-assisted grain coarsening
occurs in sink-dominated region at the expense of small grains. In situ radiation experiments also show
that grain coarsening in dual-beam irradiated sample was retarded when He bubbles were introduced
at GBs and grain interiors. Author Contributions: C.F. designed and conducted the preliminary experiments with Z.S., T.N., and J.L.; Z.S. aided in ASTAR analysis; C.F. analyzed the data and wrote the manuscript under the supervision of X.Z. and H.W. Funding: This research was funded by National Science Foundation, Civil, Mechanical and Manufacturing
Innovation, under grant number 1728419. This work was also supported by National Science Foundation, Division
of Materials Research, Metallic Materials and Nanostructures Program under grant number 1611380. Acknowledgments: We acknowledge Meimei Li, Pete Baldo, and Wei-Ying Chen at Argonne National Laboratory
(Chicago, IL, USA) for their help in our radiation experiments. Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest. Materials 2019, 12, 2721
11 of 14 Materials 2019, 12, 2721 11 of 14 Appendix A Estimation of radiation cascade size D∗ Appendix A Estimation of radiation cascade size D∗ The description of ET is given by: ET =
p
γEiTmin
(A7) (A7) where Ei is the incident energy (1 MeV), Tmin is the minimum transferred energy that is equal to Cu
displacement energy Ed, ~30 eV, and γ is a mass ratio defined by atomic masses of incident particle m
and lattice atom M in the form of:
4 M where Ei is the incident energy (1 MeV), Tmin is the minimum transferred energy that is equal to Cu
displacement energy Ed, ~30 eV, and γ is a mass ratio defined by atomic masses of incident particle m
and lattice atom M in the form of: γ =
4mM
(m + M)2
(A8) (A8) where m is 83.80 u for Kr, and M is 63.55 u for Cu. where m is 83.80 u for Kr, and M is 63.55 u for Cu. Combining the Equations (A2)–(A8) yields ED = 41.13 keV, substituting which into Equation (A1)
gives the average thermal spike volume V = 162 nm3 and thermal spike size D∗= 7 nm. Appendix A Estimation of radiation cascade size D∗ The radiation cascade size, D∗, is determined by incident particle energy, and the average cascade
volume V is given by [57]:
3 V = 4
3π
1
2D∗
3
= ED
NUa
(A1) (A1) where N is the atom density, ~8.5 × 1022 atoms/cm3 for Cu, and Ua is the energy per atom that can be
estimated from the melting temperature of the target, ~0.3 eV for Cu. ED in Equation (A1) refers to the
damage energy stored in a cascade, given by [67]: ED =
ET
1 + f g(ε)
(A2) (A2) and the inelastic energy loss is calculated using a numerical approximation to the universal function
g(ε): and the inelastic energy loss is calculated using a numerical approximation to the universal function
g(ε): g(ε): ε) = 3.4008ε
1
6 + 0.40244ε
3
4 + ε
(A3)
f = 0.1337 Z
1
6
1
Z1
A1
! 1
2
(A4) g( )
g(ε) = 3.4008ε
1
6 + 0.40244ε
3
4 + ε
(A3)
f = 0.1337 Z
1
6
1
Z1
A1
! 1
2
(A4) (A3) (A4) The ε in Equation (A3) refers to the reduced energy described as: The ε in Equation (A3) refers to the reduced energy described as: The ε in Equation (A3) refers to the reduced energy described as: ε =
A2ET
A1 + A2
A
Z1Z2e2
(A5) (A5) A = A0
9π2
128
! 1
3
Z
2
3
1 + Z
2
3
2
(A6) (A6) where A0 is the Bohr radius (~0.053 nm), e is the electronic charge, Z1 and Z2 are the atomic numbers
of the projectile and target, and A1 and A2 are the mass numbers of the atoms. The term ET in Equation (A2) is the transferred energy to primary knock-on atom (PKA). For
the incident particles of 1 MeV Kr++, classified as heavy slow ions, the inverse square potential is
proper for calculating the average transferred energy, ET, to primary knock-on atom (PKA) in the Cu
lattice [57]. 1.
Zinkle, S. Radiation-Induced Effects on Microstructure. In Comprehensive Nuclear Materials, 1st ed.; Konings, R.,
Allen, T.R., Stoller, R.E., Yamanaka, S., Eds.; Elsevier: Oxford, UK, 2012; Chapter 1.03; pp. 65–98. Kiritani, M. Microstructure evolution during irradiation. J. Nucl. Mater. 1994, 216, 220–264. [CrossRef]
Zinkle, S.J.; Matsukawa, Y. Observation and analysis of defect cluster production and interactions with
dislocations. J. Nucl. Mater. 2004, 329, 88–96. [CrossRef] p
pp
Kiritani, M. Microstructure evolution during irradiation. J. Nucl. Mater. 1994, 216, 220–264. [CrossRef]
Zinkle, S.J.; Matsukawa, Y. Observation and analysis of defect cluster production and interactions with p
pp
.
Kiritani, M. Microstructure evolution during irradiation. J. Nucl. Mater. 1994, 216, 220–264. [CrossRef] References 1. Zinkle, S. Radiation-Induced Effects on Microstructure. In Comprehensive Nuclear Materials, 1st ed.; Konings, R.,
Allen, T.R., Stoller, R.E., Yamanaka, S., Eds.; Elsevier: Oxford, UK, 2012; Chapter 1.03; pp. 65–98. p
pp
2. Kiritani, M. Microstructure evolution during irradiation. J. Nucl. Mater. 1994, 216, 220–264. [CrossRef] g
3. Zinkle, S.J.; Matsukawa, Y. Observation and analysis of defect cluster production and interactions with
dislocations. J. Nucl. Mater. 2004, 329, 88–96. [CrossRef] Materials 2019, 12, 2721 12 of 14 12 of 14 4. Barnes, R. Embrittlement of stainless steels and nickel-based alloys at high temperature induced by neutron
radiation. Nature 1965, 206, 1307. [CrossRef] 5. Han, W.; Demkowicz, M.J.; Mara, N.A.; Fu, E.; Sinha, S.; Rollett, A.D.; Wang, Y.; Carpenter, J.S.; Beyerlein, I.J.;
Misra, A. Design of radiation tolerant materials via interface engineering. Adv. Mater. 2013, 25, 6975–6979. [CrossRef] [PubMed] 6. Bai, X.-M.; Voter, A.F.; Hoagland, R.G.; Nastasi, M.; Uberuaga, B.P. Efficient annealing of radiation damage
near grain boundaries via interstitial emission. Science 2010, 327, 1631–1634. [CrossRef] [PubMed] 7. Sun, C.; Zheng, S.; Wei, C.; Wu, Y.; Shao, L.; Yang, Y.; Hartwig, K.; Maloy, S.; Zinkle, S.; Allen, T. Superior
radiation-resistant nanoengineered austenitic 304L stainless steel for applications in extreme radiation
environments. Sci. Rep. 2015, 5, 7801. [CrossRef] [PubMed] 8. de Bellefon, G.M.; Robertson, I.; Allen, T.; van Duysen, J.-C.; Sridharan, K. Radiation-resistant nanotwinned
austenitic stainless steel. Scr. Mater. 2019, 159, 123–127. [CrossRef] 9. Li, J.; Xie, D.; Xue, S.; Fan, C.; Chen, Y.; Wang, H.; Wang, J.; Zhang, X. Superior twin stability and radiation
resistance of nanotwinned Ag solid solution alloy. Acta Mater. 2018, 151, 395–405. [CrossRef] 0. Demkowicz, M.; Hoagland, R.; Hirth, J. Interface structure and radiation damage resistance in Cu
multilayer nanocomposites. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2008, 100, 136102. [CrossRef] 1. Fan, Z.; Fan, C.; Li, J.; Shang, Z.; Xue, S.; Kirk, M.A.; Li, M.; Wang, H.; Zhang, X. An in situ study on
ion–irradiated crystalline Cu/amorphous-CuNb nanolaminates. J. Mater. Res. 2019, 34, 1–11. [CrossRef 12. Bringa, E.M.; Monk, J.; Caro, A.; Misra, A.; Zepeda-Ruiz, L.; Duchaineau, M.; Abraham, F.; Nastasi, M.;
Picraux, S.; Wang, Y. Are nanoporous materials radiation resistant? Nano Lett. 2011, 12, 3351–3355. [CrossRef]
[PubMed] 13. Li, J.; Fan, C.; Li, Q.; Wang, H.; Zhang, X. In situ studies on irradiation resistance of nanoporous Au through
temperature-jump tests. Acta Mater. 2018, 143, 30–42. [CrossRef] 14. Beyerlein, I.J.; Demkowicz, M.J.; Misra, A.; Uberuaga, B. Defect-interface interactions. Prog. Mater. References Fan, C.; Xie, D.; Li, J.; Shang, Z.; Chen, Y.; Xue, S.; Wang, J.; Li, M.; El-Azab, A.; Wang, H. 9R phase enabled
superior radiation stability of nanotwinned Cu alloys via in situ radiation at elevated temperature. Acta
Mater. 2019, 167, 248–256. [CrossRef] 0. Yu, K.Y.; Bufford, D.; Khatkhatay, F.; Wang, H.; Kirk, M.A.; Zhang, X. In situ studies of irradiation indu
twin boundary migration in nanotwinned Ag. Scr. Mater. 2013, 69, 385. [CrossRef] 31. Chen, Y.; Li, J.; Yu, K.; Wang, H.; Kirk, M.; Li, M.; Zhang, X. In situ studies on radiation tolerance of
nanotwinned Cu. Acta Mater. 2016, 111, 148–156. [CrossRef] 32. Zhang, Y.; Aidhy, D.S.; Varga, T.; Moll, S.; Edmondson, P.D.; Namavar, F.; Jin, K.; Ostrouchov, C.N.; Weber, W.J. The effect of electronic energy loss on irradiation-induced grain growth in nanocrystalline oxides. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2014, 16, 8051–8059. [CrossRef] [PubMed] y
3. Zinkle, S.J.; Was, G. Materials challenges in nuclear energy. Acta Mater. 2013, 61, 735–758. [CrossRef] 34. Was, G.; Jiao, Z.; Getto, E.; Sun, K.; Monterrosa, A.; Maloy, S.; Anderoglu, O.; Sencer, B.; Hackett, M. Emulation
of reactor irradiation damage using ion beams. Scr. Mater. 2014, 88, 33–36. [CrossRef] 35. Was, G.S. Challenges to the use of ion irradiation for emulating reactor irradiation. J. Mater. Res. 2015, 30,
1158–1182. [CrossRef] Knaster, J.; Moeslang, A.; Muroga, T. Materials research for fusion. Nat. Phys. 2016, 12, 424. [CrossRef] 36. Knaster, J.; Moeslang, A.; Muroga, T. Materials research for fusion. Nat. Phys. 2016, 12, 424. [CrossRef]
37
M
L C
hl
W M
h
i
f h li
i t
ti
ith
di ti
ff
t i
t l
d ll
A Mansur, L.; Coghlan, W. Mechanisms of helium interaction with radiation effects in metals and alloys: A
review. J. Nucl. Mater. 1983, 119, 1–25. [CrossRef] 38. Zinkle, S.; Wolfer, W.; Kulcinski, G.; Seitzman, L. II. Effect of oxygen and helium on void formation in metals. Philos. Mag. A 1987, 55, 127–140. [CrossRef] 39. Dai, Y.; Odette, G.; Yamamoto, T. The effects of helium in irradiated structural alloys. In Comprehensive
Nuclear Materials, 1st ed.; Konings, R., Allen, T.R., Stoller, R.E., Yamanaka, S., Eds.; Elsevier: Oxford, UK,
2012; Chapter 1.06; pp. 141–193. 40. Brimbal, D.; Décamps, B.; Henry, J.; Meslin, E.; Barbu, A. Single-and dual-beam in situ irradiations of
high-purity iron in a transmission electron microscope: Effects of heavy ion irradiation and helium injection. Acta Mater. References Sci. 2015,
74, 125–210. [CrossRef] 15. Beyerlein, I.; Caro, A.; Demkowicz, M.; Mara, N.; Misra, A.; Uberuaga, B. Radiation damage tolerant
nanomaterials. Mater. Today 2013, 16, 443–449. [CrossRef] 6. Misra, A.; Demkowicz, M.; Zhang, X.; Hoagland, R. The radiation damage tolerance of ultra-high stren
nanolayered composites. JOM 2007, 59, 62–65. [CrossRef] 7. Zhang, X.; Hattar, K.; Chen, Y.; Shao, L.; Li, J.; Sun, C.; Yu, K.; Li, N.; Taheri, M.L.; Wang, H. Radiation dam
in nanostructured materials. Prog. Mater. Sci. 2018, 96, 217–321. [CrossRef] 18. Nita, N.; Schaeublin, R.; Victoria, M. Impact of irradiation on the microstructure of nanocrystalline materials. J. Nucl. Mater. 2004, 329, 953–957. [CrossRef] 19. Wurster, S.; Pippan, R. Nanostructured metals under irradiation. Scr. Mater. 2009, 60, 1083–1087. [CrossRef] 20. Edwards, D.J.; Simonen, E.P.; Bruemmer, S.M. Evolution of fine-scale defects in stainless steels
neutron-irradiated at 275 C. J. Nucl. Mater. 2003, 317, 13–31. [CrossRef] 21. Song, M.; Wu, Y.; Chen, D.; Wang, X.; Sun, C.; Yu, K.; Chen, Y.; Shao, L.; Yang, Y.; Hartwig, K. Response of
equal channel angular extrusion processed ultrafine-grained T91 steel subjected to high temperature heavy
ion irradiation. Acta Mater. 2014, 74, 285–295. [CrossRef] 22. Yu, K.; Liu, Y.; Sun, C.; Wang, H.; Shao, L.; Fu, E.; Zhang, X. Radiation damage in helium ion irradiated
nanocrystalline Fe. J. Nucl. Mater. 2012, 425, 140–146. [CrossRef] 23. Cheng, G.; Xu, W.; Wang, Y.; Misra, A.; Zhu, Y. Grain size effect on radiation tolerance of nanocrystalline Mo. Scr. Mater. 2016, 123, 90–94. [CrossRef] 24. Shen, T.D.; Feng, S.; Tang, M.; Valdez, J.A.; Wang, Y.; Sickafus, K.E. Enhanced radiation tolerance in
nanocrystalline MgGa2O4. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2007, 90, 263115. [CrossRef] 25. Lu, K. Stabilizing nanostructures in metals using grain and twin boundary architectures. Nat. Rev. Mater. 2016, 1, 16019. [CrossRef] 26. Kaoumi, D.; Motta, A.; Birtcher, R. A thermal spike model of grain growth under irradiation. J. Appl. Phys. 2008, 104, 073525. [CrossRef] 27. Radiguet, B.; Etienne, A.; Pareige, P.; Sauvage, X.; Valiev, R. Irradiation behavior of nanostructured 316
austenitic stainless steel. J. Mater. Sci. 2008, 43, 7338–7343. [CrossRef] 28. Fan, C.; Li, J.; Fan, Z.; Wang, H.; Zhang, X. In Situ Studies on the Irradiation-Induced Twin Boundary-Defect
Interactions in Cu. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 2017, 48, 1–9. [CrossRef] 13 of 14 13 of 14 Materials 2019, 12, 2721 29. References 2014, 64, 391–401. [CrossRef] 41. Odette, G.; Alinger, M.; Wirth, B. Recent developments in irradiation-resistant steels. Annu. Rev. Mater. Res. 2008, 38, 471–503. [CrossRef] 2. Li, S.-H.; Li, J.-T.; Han, W.-Z. Radiation-induced helium bubbles in metals. Materials 2019, 12, 1036. [Cross 42. Li, S.-H.; Li, J.-T.; Han, W.-Z. Radiation-induced helium bubbles in metals. Materials 2019, 12, 1036. [CrossRef]
43. Zinkle, S.J.; Farrell, K. Void swelling and defect cluster formation in reactor-irradiated copper. J. Nucl. Mater. 1989, 168, 262–267. [CrossRef] Zinkle, S.J.; Farrell, K. Void swelling and defect cluster formation in reactor-irradiated copper. J. Nucl. Mater
1989, 168, 262–267. [CrossRef] 44. Knapp, J.; Follstaedt, D.; Myers, S. Hardening by bubbles in He-implanted Ni. J. Appl. Phys. 2008, 103,
013518. [CrossRef] 45. Hu, X.; Koyanagi, T.; Fukuda, M.; Kumar, N.K.; Snead, L.L.; Wirth, B.D.; Katoh, Y. Irradiation hardening of
pure tungsten exposed to neutron irradiation. J. Nucl. Mater. 2016, 480, 235–243. [CrossRef] 46. Taller, S.; Woodley, D.; Getto, E.; Monterrosa, A.M.; Jiao, Z.; Toader, O.; Naab, F.; Kubley, T.; Dwaraknath, S.;
Was, G.S. Multiple ion beam irradiation for the study of radiation damage in materials. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 2017, 412, 1–10. [CrossRef] 47. Ziegler, J.F. SRIM-2003. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 2004, 219, 1027–1036. [CrossRef] 48. Moeck, P.; Rouvimov, S.; Rauch, E.; Véron, M.; Kirmse, H.; Häusler, I.; Neumann, W.; Bultreys, D.;
Maniette, Y.; Nicolopoulos, S. High spatial resolution semi-automatic crystallite orientation and phase
mapping of nanocrystals in transmission electron microscopes. Cryst. Res. Technol. 2011, 46, 589–606. [CrossRef] 49. Alexander, D.E.; Was, G.S. Thermal-spike treatment of ion-induced grain growth: Theory and experimental
comparison. Phys. Rev. B 1993, 47, 2983. [CrossRef] 50. Zhang, Y.; Jiang, W.; Wang, C.; Namavar, F.; Edmondson, P.D.; Zhu, Z.; Gao, F.; Lian, J.; Weber, W.J. Grain
growth and phase stability of nanocrystalline cubic zirconia under ion irradiation. Phys. Rev. B 2010, 82,
184105. [CrossRef] 51. Bufford, D.; Abdeljawad, F.; Foiles, S.; Hattar, K. Unraveling irradiation induced grain growth with in situ
transmission electron microscopy and coordinated modeling. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2015, 107, 191901. [CrossRef] 51. Bufford, D.; Abdeljawad, F.; Foiles, S.; Hattar, K. Unraveling irradiation induced grain growth with in situ
transmission electron microscopy and coordinated modeling. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2015, 107, 191901. [CrossRef]
52. Samaras, M.; Derlet, P.; Van Swygenhoven, H.; Victoria, M. Computer simulation of displacement cascades
in nanocrystalline Ni. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2002, 88, 125505. [CrossRef] 52. References Samaras, M.; Derlet, P.; Van Swygenhoven, H.; Victoria, M. Computer simulation of displacement cascades
in nanocrystalline Ni. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2002, 88, 125505. [CrossRef] Materials 2019, 12, 2721 14 of 14 14 of 14 53. Jin, M.; Cao, P.; Yip, S.; Short, M.P. Radiation damage reduction by grain-boundary biased defect migration
in nanocrystalline Cu. Acta Mater. 2018, 155, 410–417. [CrossRef] 54. Jin, M.; Cao, P.; Short, M.P. Mechanisms of grain boundary migration and growth in nanocrystalline metals
under irradiation. Scr. Mater. 2019, 163, 66–70. [CrossRef] 55. Voegeli, W.; Albe, K.; Hahn, H. Simulation of grain growth in nanocrystalline nickel induced by ion irradiation. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 2003, 202, 230–235. [CrossRef] 56. Mansur, L. Theory and experimental background on dimensional changes in irradiated alloys. J. Nucl. Mater. 1994, 216, 97–123. [CrossRef] 7. Was, G.S. Fundamentals of Radiation Materials Science: Metals and Alloys; Springer: Berlin, Germany, 2016 58. Han, W.; Demkowicz, M.; Fu, E.; Wang, Y.; Misra, A. Effect of grain boundary character on sink efficiency. Acta Mater. 2012, 60, 6341–6351. [CrossRef] 59. Anderoglu, O.; Misra, A.; Wang, H.; Zhang, X. Thermal stability of sputtered Cu films with nanoscale growth
twins. J. Appl. Phys. 2008, 103, 094322. [CrossRef] 60. Jiao, S.; Kulkarni, Y. Radiation tolerance of nanotwinned metals–An atomistic perspective. Comput. Mater. Sci. 2018, 142, 290–296. [CrossRef] 61. Demkowicz, M.J.; Anderoglu, O.; Zhang, X.; Misra, A. The influence of P3 twin boundaries on the formation
of radiation-induced defect clusters in nanotwinned Cu. J. Mater. Res. 2011, 26, 1666–1675. [CrossRef] 62. Yu, K.; Bufford, D.; Sun, C.; Liu, Y.; Wang, H.; Kirk, M.; Li, M.; Zhang, X. Removal of stacking-fault tetrahedra
by twin boundaries in nanotwinned metals. Nat. Commun. 2013, 4, 1377. [CrossRef] 63. Fan, C.; Li, Q.; Ding, J.; Liang, Y.; Shang, Z.; Li, J.; Su, R.; Cho, J.; Chen, D.; Wang, Y. Helium irradiation
induced ultra-high strength nanotwinned Cu with nanovoids. Acta Mater. 2019, 177, 107–120. [CrossRef]
64. Li, J.; Chen, Y.; Wang, H.; Zhang, X. In situ studies on twin-thickness-dependent distribution of defect clusters
in heavy ion irradiated nanotwinned Ag Metall Mater Trans A 2017 48 1466 1473 [CrossRef] 63. Fan, C.; Li, Q.; Ding, J.; Liang, Y.; Shang, Z.; Li, J.; Su, R.; Cho, J.; Chen, D.; Wang, Y. Helium irradiation
induced ultra-high strength nanotwinned Cu with nanovoids. Acta Mater. 2019, 177, 107–120. [CrossRef] 64. Li, J.; Chen, Y.; Wang, H.; Zhang, X. © 2019 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access
article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution
(CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). References In situ studies on twin-thickness-dependent distribution of defect clusters
in heavy ion-irradiated nanotwinned Ag. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 2017, 48, 1466–1473. [CrossRef] 65. Li, J.; Yu, K.; Chen, Y.; Song, M.; Wang, H.; Kirk, M.; Li, M.; Zhang, X. In situ study of defect migration
kinetics and self-healing of twin boundaries in heavy ion irradiated nanotwinned metals. Nano Lett. 2015, 15,
2922–2927. [CrossRef] [PubMed] 66. Chen, Y.; Yu, K.Y.; Liu, Y.; Shao, S.; Wang, H.; Kirk, M.; Wang, J.; Zhang, X. Damage-tolerant nanotwinned
metals with nanovoids under radiation environments. Nat. Commun. 2015, 6, 7036. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
67
N
tt M R bi
M T
I A
d
th d f
l
l ti
di
l
t d
t
N
l E metals with nanovoids under radiation environments. Nat. Commun. 2015, 6, 7036. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
67. Norgett, M.; Robinson, M.; Torrens, I. A proposed method of calculating displacement dose rates. Nucl. Eng. Des. 1975, 33, 50–54. [CrossRef] 67. Norgett, M.; Robinson, M.; Torrens, I. A proposed method of calculating displacement dose rates. Nucl. Eng. Des. 1975, 33, 50–54. [CrossRef] © 2019 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access
article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution
(CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
|
https://openalex.org/W2180448528
|
https://www.matec-conferences.org/articles/matecconf/pdf/2015/12/matecconf_icmee2015_13001.pdf
|
English
| null |
The research of creep in tunnel which surrounding rock is expansion
|
MATEC web of conferences
| 2,015
|
cc-by
| 3,069
|
1 Introduction tunnel.So researches on creep properties of expansive
rock tunnel have great significance for design and
construction.For this reason, based on the expansive rock
tunnel in YiHe highway large cross section in GuangXi
province, this essay simulates the expansive rock tunnel’s
creep characteristics in the four kinds of excavation
methods.By analyzing and contrasting the simulation
results, it concludes the most suitable method for this
project, thus provides the technical guidance for the
tunnel construction. Expansive surrounding rock is softening when it meets
water.Accompanied
with
the
expansion
of
the
surrounding rock’s volume, the strength ratio of
surrounding rock reduces. In addition,because the
excavation unloading making the surrounding rock wall’s
stress release and redistribution, it causes significant
plastic deformation of surrounding rock and inflation
pressure and relaxation pressure.At the same time, the
expansive rock is swelling towards to the tunnel
headroom, and when the shear stress of surrounding rock
increases to a certain limit, the rock mass rheologic
happens, thus the surrounding rock is squashed[1].There
are some relationships between extrusion deformations
with rheological ageing properties of rock material.It
shows that the deformation of surrounding rock grows
over time in the excavation, which is the creep
phenomenon. Especially when the shear stress of
surrounding rock
reaches a certain limit,damage
phenomenon appears immediately[2].Expansive rock is a
kind of special soil which often brings serious difficulties
and
great
disaster
to
the
tunnel
engineering
construction.If the scientific researches and analysis on
the time-varying mechanics are lacked in expansive rock
tunnel’s dynamic construction, the improper construction
methods and inappropriate deformation control scheme
will lead to disaster[3,7].However, most scholars at home
and abroad use the simulation program to simulate the
space effect in tunnel construction[8,11],and few people
research the time-varying effect on expansive rock The research of creep in tunnel which surrounding rock is expansion
Junping Yang 1,2, Shengnan Li 1,Zhanyi Wang1
1 Guilin University of Technology, China
2 Guangxi Key Laboratory of Geomechanics and Geotechnical Engineering,China 1 Guilin University of Technology, China
2 Guangxi Key Laboratory of Geomechanics and Geotechnical Engineering,China Abstract.Selecting the highway tunnel project in GuangXi province as the experimental research object,using Matlab
numerical analysis software to analyze the creep data fitting,this essay concludes that the Generalized kelvin model is
proper for creep model.Through converting the creep formula of generalized kelvin model with the third creep
formula of implicit creep of ANSYS finite element software implicit creep,it determines the creep model
parameters.On this basis,by performing numerical simulations in four different construction methods on expansive
surrounding rock tunnel,fill-section excavation,CD excavation,bench cut method and double-side-drift method
applied,it researches properties of time-varying mechanical.The results shows that the construction mechanics
characteristics of expansive surrounding rock tunnel are effected by time.The deformation of surrounding rock is
enhanced with the growth of time,but it tends to be stabilized on the fourth day.Excavation ways have an effect on
expansive surrounding rock mechanics.The more one-off excavation rock area digs,the more changes in stress,strain
and creep change for the expansive surrounding rock.Among the four kinds of excavation methods,double-side-drift
method has best stress form and minimum creep variable. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0, which permits
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Article available at http://www.matec-conferences.org or http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/20153113001 DOI: 10.1051/
C
⃝Owned by the authors, published by EDP Sciences, 2015
/
0
(
2015)
201
conf
Web of Conferences
5
MATEC
atec
m
31,
1
3
0
1
0 0
1
1
1
3
3 DOI: 10.1051/
C
⃝Owned by the authors, published by EDP Sciences, 2015
/
0
(
2015)
201
conf
Web of Conferences
5
MATEC
atec
m
31,
1
3
0
1
0 0
1
1
1
3
3 DOI: 10.1051/
C
⃝Owned by the authors, published by EDP Sciences, 2015
/
0
(
2015)
201
conf
Web of Conferences
5
MATEC
atec
m
31,
1
3
0
1
0 0
1
1
1
3
3 research of creep in tunnel which surrounding rock is expansio
Junping Yang 1,2, Shengnan Li 1,Zhanyi Wang1
1 Guilin University of Technology, China
2 Guangxi Key Laboratory of Geomechanics and Geotechnical Engineering,China )
/
exp(
)
/
(
2
t
(6) (6) Using the matlab numerical analysis software to fit the
data of some creep models with viscoelastic,which results
showed that the generalized kelvin model higher fitting
precision and little error.Selecting the generalized kelvin
model as the creep model.The Generalized kelvin model
is shown in figure 2. Assuming that Eq.5 and Eq.6 is one formula,it will
attain this: 3
3
1
5
4
2
3
2
5
4
1/
exp
/
1
0
/
exp
/
C
C
C C
C
T
C
C
C
C
T
˄
˅
˄
˅
(7 (7) T is the absolute temperature in the system of
equation.T The temperature of swelling soil surrounding
rock is normal temperature,20ć,T=293K.Because the
Eq.6 have more solution,we can suppose C4=5.By
convering Eq.7 with the fitting creep curves of the
generalized
kelvin,we
can
attain
a
series
of
solutions:C1=2.518×10-9,C1=1,C4=5,
C =1 699 Figure2.The model of Generalized kelvin Figure2.The model of Generalized kelvin Constitutive equation of Generalized kelvin model is
shown as follows˖
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
2
1
(1) (1) C5=1.699. If the stress is constant in equation of Generalized
k l i
d l h
l
i
i
l i
i h i
i If the stress is constant in equation of Generalized
kelvin model,the volumetric strain relations with time is
shown as follows: 3.2 Selecting model parameters We can find that the Creep formula of generalized kelvin
model is similar to third creep formula of implicit creep
in ANSYS.So we select the implicit creep of ANSYS in
the simulation.It’s creep equation as Eq.3.In the Eq.3,r
equal to Eq.4.Using the Eq4 substitute into Eq.3)and the
result is shown as follow: )
exp(
2
1
rt
r
C
C
(3)
3
5
4
exp
/ T
C
r
C
C
(4)
t
T
C
C
T
C
C
C
c
C
C
)
/
exp(
exp
)
/
exp(
4
5
5
1
3
3
2
(5) )
exp(
2
1
rt
r
C
C
(3)
3
5
4
exp
/ T
C
r
C
C
(4) (3) (4)
t
T
C
C
T
C
C
C
c
C
C
)
/
exp(
exp
)
/
exp(
4
5
5
1
3
3
2
(5) (5) Figure 1.The section of swelling rock tunnel By doing derivation to creep Eq.2 of the generalized
kelvin model,we can get the creep rate formula of
Generalized kelvin is shown as follow: 2 The general situation of project The tunnel is located in the BaiSe basin,most of the
bedrock of Tunnel is exposed surface,and the part of
bedrock was covered with diluvial clay.The total length
of tunnel is 1217 meters,with the mileage from K43+930
to K44+562,it is located in the class IV surrounding
rock.Tunnel section is designed width of 16.72 m, clear
height of 12.25 m, with the excavation section area reach
167 m2, it’s belongs to the category of large cross section
tunnel.Tunnel excavation taking combined bolting and
shotcrete in advance,grouting surrounding rock as the
preliminary support ,making sure the support of small
catheter become effective before digging the hole,shoring
shall be carried out immediately after excavation.The
structure section of tunnel is shown in figure 1. 1Shengnan li: 2561720910@qq.com This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0, which permits
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
MATEC Web of Conferences Figure 1.The section of swelling rock tunnel 3.1Selecting creep model )
/
exp(
)
/
(
2
t
(6) ICMEE 2015 ICMEE 2015 Figure.5 Creep curve in the vault of the CD method(5d)
Figure.6Creep curve in the vault of the steps method(5d) Table 1. Selecting model elements Figure.5 Creep curve in the vault of the CD method(5d) Figure.5 Creep curve in the vault of the CD method(5d)
Figure.6Creep curve in the vault of the steps method(5d)
Figure.7Creep curve in the vault of the double wall pilot
tunnel method(5d) Table.2 Component calculation parameter
Item
elasticity
modulus(MPa)
Poisson's
ratio
Density
( kg/m3)
Surrounding
3.9×104
0.2
2041
Support
2.9×104
0.167
2347
Rock bolt
1.7×105
0.3
7959 Figure.5 Creep curve in the vault of the CD method(5d) 3.3
Model
parameters
and
calculation
assumptions of the finite element kelvin model,the volumetric strain relations with time is
shown as follows: Using ANSYS to simulate the construction of tunnel at
two-dimensional,and selecting the three times size of
the tunnel as calculating width of the model,
the
boundary of surface is free ,the both sides and bottom
edge is constrainted,which ignored the influence of
ground water and solved the nonlinear creep equation in
creep calculation via using the Newton-Raphson.In the
calculation ,we presume that the surrounding rock is
elastic-viscosity material,the spatial effect is caused by
tunnel excavation,the influence of tectonic stress and
external water pressure is ignored.Only the gravity stress
of surrounding rock is considered.Early and anchor
supporting is considered isotropic material,and the
secondary lining is not reflected in the selecting model
elements are shown in table 1.The calculation parameters
of component are shown in table 2. 2
1
2
1 exp
t
(2) (2) Using the Generalized kelvin curve model to fitting
the data is shown in figure 3. Figure.3 The creep curve fitting of Generalized kelvin model Figure.3 The creep curve fitting of Generalized kelvin model 13001-p.2 4 The calculation results and analysis Figure.6Creep curve in the vault of the steps method(5d) Figure.6Creep curve in the vault of the steps method(5d) Figure.4 Creep curve in the vault of The whole ection
excavation method (5d)
Figure.7Creep curve in the vault of the double wall pilot
tunnel method(5d)
13001-p.3 Figure.4 Creep curve in the vault of The whole ection Figure.7Creep curve in the vault of the double wall pilot
tunnel method(5d) Figure.4 Creep curve in the vault of The whole ection
excavation method (5d) 13001-p.3 MATEC Web of Conferences Table.5 The results of anchor,supporting force and surrounding
rock creep contrast with the different of excavation model
Excavation method
a
b
c
d
Maximum axial force
position
A
B
C
D
Anchor maximum axial
force
17
kN
12.2
kN
5.8
kN
10.5
kN
Supporting maximum
bending moment
A
B
C
D
Supporting maximum
bending moment value
278
kNЬ
m
2340
kNЬ
m
894
kNЬ
m
1320
kNЬ
m
Supporting maximum
axial force position
A
B
C
D
Supporting maximum
axial force value
1530
kN
2240
kN
1530
kN
1250
kN
Anchor maximum
shearing force position
A
B
C
D
Anchor maximum
shearing force value
2740
kN
1550
kN
1100
kN
1570
kN
Creep s maximum
value position
A
B
C
D
Creep maximum value
1.7
mm
1.0
mm
0.12
mm
0.35
mm Table.5 The results of anchor,supporting force and surrounding
rock creep contrast with the different of excavation model Table.5 The results of anchor,supporting force and surrounding
rock creep contrast with the different of excavation model Table.3 The calculation results of the maximum principal stress
in different excavation model
Method
Step
Maximum principal stress(10-2MPa)
A
B
C
D
E
F
a
1
44
68
67
78
78
85
2
68
81
82
95
95
150
b
1
52
7
7
84
83
85
2
49
73
73
93
93
23
3
57
59
57
82
83
95
c
1
45
64
64
72
7
72
2
35
53
5
55
6
41
3
42
57
53
81
85
9
d
1
54
71
72
82
82
85
2
61
68
53
86
87
100
3
63
5
53
8
82
100
4
43
61
64
92
94
29
5
43
61
65
91
94
23
The negative (positive) represent stress to pressure
(pull)stress. 4 The calculation results and analysis Selecting vault, hance, arch springing and tensile as the
research target,where we analysis stress distribution and
time-varying
effect
of
surrounding
rock
in
the
excavation.A represent surrounding rock in the vault.B,C
represent surrounding rock in the hance.D,E represent
surrounding rock in the arch springing.F,G represent
surrounding rock in the tensile.a,b,c,d represent whole
section excavation method,CD method,the benching
tunneling method,double-side-drift method sequential.the
later paper don’t description.Because of the limitation of
space,we just list the creep curve of point A (the dome of
the tunnel) in the 4 different excavation method as show
figures 4 through 7.In the 4 different excavation method,
we summarize the stress of surrounding rock,horizontal
displacement, vertical displacement,the stress of the
anchor and shotcrete in table 3 through 5.The positive
(negative) represent stress to pull (pressure) stress. 4 The calculation results and analysis Table.4 The calculation results of horizontal displacement in
different excavating model Table.4 The calculation results of horizontal displacement in
different excavating model
Method
step
Vertical displacement(mm)
A
B
C
D
E
F
a
1
34
32
32
30
30
27
2
160
148
146
134
135
87
Finish
126
116
114
104
105
60
b
1
23
20
20
18
18
18
2
28
22
22
19
19
9
3
43
30
29
18
19
2
Finish
20
10
9
0
1
20
c
1
20
18
18
16
16
15
2
29
21
21
18
18
10
3
25
19
19
17
17
8
Finish
5
1
1
1
1
7
d
1
23
20
20
18
18
17
2
24
21
21
18
18
18
3
25
22
22
18
18
18
4
28
22
22
19
19
13
5
28
22
22
19
19
12
Finish
5
2
2
1
1
-5
The negative(positive) represent vertical displacement
to up (down) in the table. 1.From the view of stress:the maximum principal
stress of CD method,bench cut method and both side drift
method are not different to each other.But maximum
principal stress of full-face tunneling method is greater
than the other three excavation method.It is bad for
excavation of swelling wall rock tunnel.In additional, full
face excavation method is single excavation,which the
excavation area is larger in terms of an excavation.What’s
more,the surrounding rock is disturbanced obviously,and
it makes the maximum principal stress changed
larger.Instead, both side drift method breaks down the
section of tunnel into four parts,which excavation area is
reduced greatly in an excavation.The maximum principal
stress rate turns lower between adjacent excavation
steps,it is better to control construction.The both side drift
method is the best construction scheme in the view of
stress. 2.From the view of strain and creep:In the process of
construction,different excavation method changed the
boundary conditions of surrounding rock stress,which
horizontal displacement of full face excavation method
are much higher than other three kinds of schemes,and its
variable displacement is larger in adjacent construction
step.In additional,through researching the creep curve of
excavation in 5 days,we can find that the creep variable
of full face excavation method is the largest(The time for
each step of the excavation is different, but the total time
of construction are five days).In the other three The negative(positive) represent vertical displacement
to up (down) in the table. The negative(positive) represent vertical displacement
to up (down) in the table. 4 The calculation results and analysis 1Shengnan li: 2561720910@qq.com 13001-p.4 ICMEE 2015 method is larger,it is up to 20 mm.So bench cut method excavation method,the subsidence displacement of CD
and both side drift method are more appropriate the
construction of expansive surrounding rock of the tunnel
in the view of strain and creep. excavation method,the subsidence displacement of CD
and both side drift method are more appropriate the
construction of expansive surrounding rock of the tunnel
in the view of strain and creep. Acknowledgments 3.From the view of the force at the anchor and
shotcreting:the axial force of the anchor of CD method
and both side drift method is larger,but they are in the
normal range.Shotcrete supporting axial force, bending
moment and shear force of CD method is smaller both
side drift method.So the CD method is the best way to
excavation. Special thanks to Natural Science Foundation of China
(NSFC),study Time-varying mechanics of the expansion
surrounding rock tunnel when it constructed in the hot
and rainy environment(51368014);and Natural Science
Foundation of GuangXi,analyse and control dynamic
response of large-section tunnel when it constructed and
operated in complicated condition (2011GXNSFA018023) References 1.The construction mechanics of expansion surrounding
rock
tunnel
has
time-varying
characteristics,
the
excavation break the stress distribution of surrounding
rock,and it makes the creep change.With the different
excavation method,the stress distribution, Creep variable
and ,the location of the maximum creep value are
different in the surrounding rock tunnel. 1. G.Barla,Int.Soc.Rock Mech.News J 2, 45 (1995)
2. T.T.Lim,H.Rahardjo,M.F.Chang,D.G.Fredlund,Can. Geotech. J 33, 628 (1996)
3. H.H.Einstein,Int.J. Rock.Meth..Minsci 3, 420 (1989)
4. A.A.Al-Rawas,Eng.Geol 53, 329 (1999)
5. H.H. Einstein,Tunn.Undergr.Sp.Tech 15, 20(2000)
6. Z.A.Erguler,R.Ulusay,Clay.Eng.Geol 67, 338( 2003)
7. P.C.Kariuki,F.vander Meer,Int.J.Appl.Earth.Obs 4,
235 (2003)
8. C.F.Lee,C.F.Wang,Z.F.Yang,Tunn.Undergr.Sp.Tech
11, 450 (1996)
9. F.T.Madsen, Int.J. Rock.Meth..Minsci 36, 301 (1999)
10. P.Wersina,E.Curtib,C.A.J.Appelo,Appl.Clay.Sci
26,
255(2004)
11. S.Batfdis,A.C.Lumsden,N.R.Barton,Int.J.rock.Meth. Minsci 18 18(1981) 1. G.Barla,Int.Soc.Rock Mech.News J 2, 45 (1995) 1. G.Barla,Int.Soc.Rock Mech.News J 2, 45 (1995) 2. T.T.Lim,H.Rahardjo,M.F.Chang,D.G.Fredlund,Can. Geotech. J 33, 628 (1996) 3. H.H.Einstein,Int.J. Rock.Meth..Minsci 3, 420 (1989) 3. H.H.Einstein,Int.J. Rock.Meth..Minsci 3, 420 (1989)
4. A.A.Al-Rawas,Eng.Geol 53, 329 (1999) 4. A.A.Al-Rawas,Eng.Geol 53, 329 (1999) 5. H.H. Einstein,Tunn.Undergr.Sp.Tech 15, 20(2000) 6. Z.A.Erguler,R.Ulusay,Clay.Eng.Geol 67, 338( 2003) 2.In the four types of method,the variation of creep is
decreasing,and the creep is basic to achieve stability on
the fourth day.they are belonging to the non-decaying
creep. 7. P.C.Kariuki,F.vander Meer,Int.J.Appl.Earth.Obs 4,
235 (2003) 8. C.F.Lee,C.F.Wang,Z.F.Yang,Tunn.Undergr.Sp.Tech
11, 450 (1996) 8. C.F.Lee,C.F.Wang,Z.F.Yang,Tunn.Undergr.Sp.Tech
11, 450 (1996) p
3.With the comprehensive consideration,we contrast
the stress, deformation, creep and bolt and force of the
support,and the result is that the both side drift method is
the best construction to the expansive surrounding rock
tunnel. 9. F.T.Madsen, Int.J. Rock.Meth..Minsci 36, 301 (1999) 9. F.T.Madsen, Int.J. Rock.Meth..Minsci 36, 301 (1999) 10. P.Wersina,E.Curtib,C.A.J.Appelo,Appl.Clay.Sci
26,
255(2004) 11. S.Batfdis,A.C.Lumsden,N.R.Barton,Int.J.rock.Meth. Minsci 18, 18(1981) 11. S.Batfdis,A.C.Lumsden,N.R.Barton,Int.J.rock.Meth. Minsci 18, 18(1981) 13001-p.5 13001-p.5
|
https://openalex.org/W3110213707
|
https://www.e3s-conferences.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202021303014/pdf
|
English
| null |
Stress Concentration Factors for Multi-planar Tubular Joints Subjected to Axial Loading
|
E3S web of conferences
| 2,020
|
cc-by
| 3,672
|
1 Introduction The substructure of
offshore wind turbine Fig. 1. The substructure of
offshore wind turbine Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of
tubular joints. Stress Concentration Factors for Multi-planar Tubular Joints
Subjected to Axial Loading Kai Zhou1, Jingjing Zuo1, Wenhua Wang2,*, Shiliu Bao2
1Powerchina Zhongnan Engineering Corporation Limited, Changsha, China 2State Key Laboratory of Coastal and Offshore Engineering Department, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China Abstract. The support structure for an offshore wind turbine is subjected to combined hydrodynamic loads
and aerodynamic loads. The tubular joints are the weakest component leading to fatigue failure of the whole
structure. Based on the multi-pile foundation structure which is used widely in China, the typical three-
planar tubular Y-joints is selected to study stress concentration factor (SCF). Then, the load types subjected
to axial loadings of three-planar tubular Y-joints are determined. The finite element models of three-planar
tubular Y-joints are established and used to calculate hot spot stresses. The stress concentration factors
along the weld of the three-planar tubular Y-joints under the axial forces are obtained. The effects of
geometrical parameters on SCFs are studied. © The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). 1 Introduction parametric stress analysis of the various configuration of
rack plate stiffened multi-planar KK-joints. Considering
the bending effect, Karamanos[5] computed SCFs of DT-
joint. Ahmadi[6] proposed a set of parametric SCFs
equations for the three-planar KT-joint under three axial
loading conditions. Offshore wind power development is rapidly growing to
satisfy the demand for sustainable energy. Fatigue is a
significant factor resulting in the failure of the support
structure of offshore wind turbines subjected to
combined aerodynamic and hydrodynamic loadings. Multi-pod piled substructure is widely used in China, as
shown in Fig. 1. The connection between diagonal braces
and the central column as the major loadbearing
components is defined as the multi-planar Y tubular joint. The weld itself and geometrical discontinuity around the
tubular joint cause stress concentration, which is a
detrimental impact on the fatigue performance of
offshore structures. Using solid elements, the finite element models of
three-planar Y-joints, as shown in Fig. 2, are established. The stress concentration factors along the weld of the
three-planar tubular Y-joints under the axial loads are
obtained. The effects of geometrical parameters on SCFs
are studied. Fig. 1. The substructure of
offshore wind turbine
Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of
tubular joints. Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of
tubular joints. Fig. 1. The substructure of
offshore wind turbine The fatigue design is based on S-N curves, which are
obtained from fatigue tests. In S-N curves, the number of
cycles that a tubular joint can sustain before a fatigue
failure is determined by the hot spot stress range. The
stress concentration due to the weld itself is included in
the S-N curve used, while the stress concentration due to
the geometry effect of the actual detail is determined by
means of calculation of hot spot stress. Generally, the hot
spot stress is calculated by multiplying the nominal stress
by
the
stress
concentration
factor
(SCF). The
determination of SCF has been an issue for tubular
structures in the past decades. At present, there are many
published parametric SCF equations for tubular joints
subjected to different basic loadings. The SCFs for
simple tubular joints are listed in the fatigue design codes
such as API[1] and DNV-RP-C203[2]. Hot spot stresses
at failure-critical locations for four types of multi-planar
tubular joints such as DK, DKT, X-type are derived, and
the effects of planar and non-planar braces are
considered by Dong[3]. Woghiren[4] carried out a Fig. 1. https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202021303014 https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202021303014 E3S Web of Conferences 213, 03014 (2020)
ACIC 2020 Stress Concentration Factors for Multi-planar Tubular Jo
Subjected to Axial Loading
Kai Zhou1, Jingjing Zuo1, Wenhua Wang2,*, Shiliu Bao2
1Powerchina Zhongnan Engineering Corporation Limited, Changsha, China
2State Key Laboratory of Coastal and Offshore Engineering Department, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China 2.2. Selection of geometrical parameters The joint is connected with three diagonal braces, and a
central column forms a three-planar tubular joint with an
angle of 120° among the diagonal braces by horizontal
projection. The numbering of the diagonal braces for
three-planar tubular Y-joints is displayed in Fig. 4. From
the extensive studies by the researchers, the geometrical
parameters that affect the SCFs of tubular joints include
the ratio of chord length to chord radius, α, the ratio of
brace diameter to chord diameter, β, the ratio of chord
radius to chord wall thickness, γ, the ratio of brace wall
thickness to chord wall thickness, τ, the angle between
the chord axis and brace axis, θ, and the angle among
diagonal braces, φ. g
g
T2
T1
T3
Fig. 4. The
numbering of
diagonal braces
Fig. 5. FEM model of 3-planar tubular
Y-joint g
g
T2
T1
T3
Fig. 4. The
numbering of
diagonal braces
Fig. 5. FEM model of 3-planar tubular
Y-joint
2.4. Determination of loading cases
Using SACS, some practical structures of offshore wind
turbines with tripod substructures subjected to the
aerodynamic and hydrodynamic loadings for fatigue
limit state are analyzed. From the results, the loading
cases for three-planar Y-joints under axial loadings are
determined and shown in Fig. 6. Fig. 5. FEM model of 3-planar tubular
Y-joint T2
T1
T3
Fig. 4. The
numbering of
diagonal braces Fig. 4. The
numbering of
diagonal braces Fig. 4. The
numbering of
diagonal braces Fig. 5. FEM model of 3-planar tubular
Y-joint 2.4. Determination of loading cases 2.4. Determination of loading cases Finite element (FE) modeling of the weld profile is the
most critical factor affecting the accuracy of SCF results. In the study, the welding size along the brace/chord
intersection satisfies the AWS D1.1 specification [7]. Using SACS, some practical structures of offshore wind
turbines with tripod substructures subjected to the
aerodynamic and hydrodynamic loadings for fatigue
limit state are analyzed. From the results, the loading
cases for three-planar Y-joints under axial loadings are
determined and shown in Fig. 6. Using ANSYS, the SOLID45 element type is used in
the study to model three-planar Y-joints composed of the
chord, braces, and weld profiles. Using three dimensional
solid elements will obtain more accurate and detailed
stress distribution near the intersection in comparison
with a shell element. The material is steel with elastic
modulus, E = 207GPa, Poisson’s ratio is 0.3. Fig. 7. Polar angle φ (c) LT3 (a) LT1
(b) LT2
(c) LT3
Fig. 6. Axial loadings cases of three-planar tubular Y-joints (b) LT2
oadings cases of three-planar (a) LT1
Fig. 6. Axia (a) LT1 (b) LT2 (c) LT3 1
(b) LT2
(c
Fig. 6. Axial loadings cases of three-planar tubular Y-joints Fig. 6. Axial loadings cases of three-planar tubular Y-joints Fig. 7. Polar angle φ 2.1. Calculation method The peak stress is calculated by extrapolating the
geometrical stresses at the two points to the weld toe
position in a linear way. According to DNV-RP-C203[2],
the minimum and maximum distances from the two
points to the weld toe for chord members are defined in *whwanghydro@dlut.edu.cn E3S Web of Conferences 213, 03014 (2020) E3S Web of Conferences 213, 03014 (2020)
ACIC 2020 https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202021303014 Fig. 3 and Table 1. Then, the SCF distribution along the
weld toe for each plane can be obtained. Fig. 3 and Table 1. Then, the SCF distribution along the
weld toe for each plane can be obtained. To guarantee the mesh quality, a sub-zone mesh
generation method is used during the FE modeling. In
this method, the entire joint is divided into several zones
according to the computational requirements. This
method can easily control the mesh quantity and quality
to avoid badly distorted elements. Fig. 3. Interpolation region
Tab. 1 Extrapolation points
location
Locati
on
Chord
Brace
Lr,min
0.2(DT/2)0.5
0.2(dt/2)0. 5
Lr,max
0.4(dtDT/4)
0.25
0.65(dt/2)
0.5 Fig. 3. Interpolation region
Tab. 1 Extrapolation points
location
Locati
on
Chord
Brace
Lr,min
0.2(DT/2)0.5
0.2(dt/2)0. 5
Lr,max
0.4(dtDT/4)
0.25
0.65(dt/2)
0.5 Tab. 1 Extrapolation points
location To verify the convergence of FE results, a
convergence test with different mesh densities is
conducted. The number of elements for both thickness of
the chord and thickness of the brace is 3. 90 elements are
used along the curve of the weld toe. The FE models of
three-planar tubular Y-joints are displayed in Fig.5. Both chord ends are assumed to be fixed; thus, the
three translational degrees of freedom such as Ux, Uy,
and Uz corresponding to end nodes are restrained. The
axial loading is applied to the brace end sections
according to different axial loading cases. Fig. 3. Interpolation region Fig. 3. Interpolation region 2.2. Selection of geometrical parameters 2.2. Selection of geometrical parameters 3.1. LT1 results Although the
SCFs distributions for Y-joint T1 and T2 are
unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the trend of SCFs
distribution for Y-joint T1 is the opposite of that for Y-
joint T2. The maximum SCF for Y-joint T1 occurs in φ =
100º, but that for Y-joint T2 in φ = 260º. Due to the
interaction between T1 and T2, the maximum SCFs from
T1 and T2 are larger than those from T3. ( )
or load case LT1
the crown of the weld in chord and brace. Although the
SCFs distributions for Y-joint T1 and T2 are
unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the trend of SCFs
distribution for Y-joint T1 is the opposite of that for Y-
joint T2. The maximum SCF for Y-joint T1 occurs in φ =
100º, but that for Y-joint T2 in φ = 260º. Due to the
interaction between T1 and T2, the maximum SCFs from
T1 and T2 are larger than those from T3. 3.2. LT2 results The maximum SCF for Y-joint T1 occurs in φ =
104º, but that for Y-joint T3 in φ = 256º. Due to the
interaction between T1 and T3, the maximum SCFs from
T1 and T3 are smaller than those from T2. 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(a) chord
(b) brace
Fig. 9. SCF distribution for load case LT2
f h
ld i
h
d
d b
Al h
h h 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(b) brace
case LT2 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(a) chord Φ(degree)
(a) chord Φ(degree) Φ(degree)
b) brace Φ(degree) (b) brace Fig. 9. SCF distribution for load case LT2 Fig. 9. SCF distribution for load case LT2 crown of the weld in chord and brace. Although the
SCFs distributions for Y-joint T1 and T3 are
unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the trend of SCFs
distribution for Y-joint T1 is the opposite of that for Y-
joint T3. The maximum SCF for Y-joint T1 occurs in φ =
104º, but that for Y-joint T3 in φ = 256º. Due to the
interaction between T1 and T3, the maximum SCFs from
T1 and T3 are smaller than those from T2. crown of the weld in chord and brace. Although the
SCFs distributions for Y-joint T1 and T3 are
unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the trend of SCFs
distribution for Y-joint T1 is the opposite of that for Y-
joint T3. The maximum SCF for Y-joint T1 occurs in φ =
104º, but that for Y-joint T3 in φ = 256º. Due to the
interaction between T1 and T3, the maximum SCFs from
T1 and T3 are smaller than those from T2. 3.2. LT2 results The SCFs distributions along the weld toe of each simple
Y-joint subjected to load case LT2 are displayed in Fig. 9. j
j
p y
g
The location of the maximum SCF is not at but close to
the saddle of the weld toe. For LT2, the applied axial
loadings are unsymmetrical to any plane from each
diagonal brace and the central column. Thus, the SCFs
distribution of each simple Y-joint is unsymmetrical to 0
360
0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(b) brace
Fig. 9. SCF distribution for load case LT2
toe of each simple
e displayed in Fig. saddle of the weld
dings. For LT3, the
l to the plane from
column. Thus, the
t i
l t
th
crown of the weld in chord and brace. Although the
SCFs distributions for Y-joint T1 and T3 are
unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the trend of SCFs
distribution for Y-joint T1 is the opposite of that for Y-
joint T3. The maximum SCF for Y-joint T1 occurs in φ =
104º, but that for Y-joint T3 in φ = 256º. Due to the
interaction between T1 and T3, the maximum SCFs from
T1 and T3 are smaller than those from T2. 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-12
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(a) chord
(b) brace
Fig. 9. SCF distribution for load case LT2
3.3. LT3 results
The SCFs distributions along the weld toe of each simple
Y-joint subjected to load case LT3 are displayed in Fig. 10. The maximum SCF locates in the saddle of the weld
toe for Y-joints subjected to axial loadings. For LT3, the
applied axial loadings are symmetrical to the plane from
the diagonal brace T2 and the central column. Thus, the
SCFs distribution of Y-joint T2 is symmetrical to the
crown of the weld in chord and brace. Although the
SCFs distributions for Y-joint T1 and T3 are
unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the trend of SCFs
distribution for Y-joint T1 is the opposite of that for Y-
joint T3. 3.1. LT1 results The maximum SCF for Y-joint T1 occurs in φ =
100º, but that for Y-joint T2 in φ = 260º. Due to the
interaction between T1 and T2, the maximum SCFs from
T1 and T2 are larger than those from T3. 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-18
-12
-6
0
6
12
18
24
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(a) chord
(b) brace
Fig. 8. SCF distribution for load case LT1
the crown of the weld in chord and brace Although the 12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3 300
360
T3
0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(b) brace
Fig. 8. SCF distribution for load case LT1
eld toe of each simple
are displayed in Fig. 9. is not at but close to
T2, the applied axial
ny plane from each
umn. Thus, the SCFs
t is unsymmetrical to
the crown of the weld in chord and brace. Although the
SCFs distributions for Y-joint T1 and T2 are
unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the trend of SCFs
distribution for Y-joint T1 is the opposite of that for Y-
joint T2. The maximum SCF for Y-joint T1 occurs in φ =
100º, but that for Y-joint T2 in φ = 260º. Due to the
interaction between T1 and T2, the maximum SCFs from
T1 and T2 are larger than those from T3. 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(b) brace
d
LT1 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-18
-12
-6
0
6
12
18
24
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
( ) h
d Φ(degree) Φ(degree) (b) brace Fig. 8. SCF distribution for load case LT1 ( )
Fig. 8. SCF distribution for load case LT1
eld toe of each simple
are displayed in Fig. 9. is not at but close to
T2, the applied axial
ny plane from each
umn. Thus, the SCFs
t i
t i
l t
the crown of the weld in chord and brace. 3.1. LT1 results The SCFs distributions along the weld toe of each simple
Y-joint subjected to load case LT1 are displayed in Fig. 8. The location of maximum SCF is not at but close to the
saddle of the weld toe due to the interaction between
three simple Y-joint. For LT1, the applied axial loadings
are symmetrical to the plane from the diagonal brace T1
and the central column. Thus, the SCFs distribution of Y- For three-planar Y-joints composed of the three simple
Y-joint, the numbering of the diagonal braces shown in
Fig. 4 is used to represent each uni-planar Y-joint. The
definition of polar angle φ along the weld's spatial curve
for each simple Y-joint is shown in Fig. 7. 2 2 E3S Web of Conferences 213, 03014 (2020) E3S Web of Conferences 213, 03014 (2020)
ACIC 2020 https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202021303014 joint T1 is symmetrical to the crown of the weld in chord
and brace. Although the SCFs distributions for Y-joint
T2 and T3 are unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the
trend of SCFs distribution for Y-joint T2 is the opposite of that for Y-joint T3. The maximum SCF for Y-joint T2
occurs in φ = 260º, but that for Y-joint T3 in φ = 100º. Due to the interaction between T2 and T3, the maximum
SCFs from T2 and T3 are larger than those from T1. 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-18
-12
-6
0
6
12
18
24
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-9
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(a) chord
(b) brace
Fig. 8. SCF distribution for load case LT1
3.2. LT2 results
The SCFs distributions along the weld toe of each simple
Y-joint subjected to load case LT2 are displayed in Fig. 9. The location of the maximum SCF is not at but close to
the saddle of the weld toe. For LT2, the applied axial
loadings are unsymmetrical to any plane from each
diagonal brace and the central column. Thus, the SCFs
distribution of each simple Y-joint is unsymmetrical to
the crown of the weld in chord and brace. Although the
SCFs distributions for Y-joint T1 and T2 are
unsymmetrical to the weld crown, the trend of SCFs
distribution for Y-joint T1 is the opposite of that for Y-
joint T2. 3.3. LT3 results The SCFs distributions along the weld toe of each simple
Y-joint subjected to load case LT3 are displayed in Fig. 10. The maximum SCF locates in the saddle of the weld
toe for Y-joints subjected to axial loadings. For LT3, the
applied axial loadings are symmetrical to the plane from
the diagonal brace T2 and the central column. Thus, the
SCFs distribution of Y-joint T2 is symmetrical to the 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
15
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-3
0
3
6
9
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(a) chord
(b) brace
Fig. 10. SCF distribution for load case LT3 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-3
0
3
6
9
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(b) brace 0
60
120
180
240
300
360
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
15
saddle
crown
T1
T2
T3
SCF
Φ(degree)
(a) chord Φ(degree)
(b) brace Φ(degree)
b) brace Φ(degree)
(a) chord Φ(degree) Φ(degree) )
( )
Fig. 10. SCF distribution for load case LT3 3 E3S Web of Conferences 213, 03014 (2020)
ACIC 2020 E3S Web of Conferences 213, 03014 (2020) https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202021303014 4 Geometrical effects on the SCFs Using FE simulation, the effects of geometrical
parameters on the SCFs of three-planar tubular Y-joints
subjected to axial loadings are analyzed. The following
conclusions can be drawn. (1) For three-planar tubular Y-joints subjected to
axial loadings, SCFs in the chord are larger than those in
braces. SCFs are maximum when all the diagonal braces
are applied to axial loadings, indicating that the
interaction among each simple Y-joints occurs. (2) For three-planar tubular Y-joints subjected to
axial loadings, the geometric parameters, i.e., α, β, γ, τ, θ,
and φ, have a significant influence on SCFs. (3) For the SCFs in chord and braces under the
condition that all diagonal braces are applied to axial
loadings, the results from DNV suitable for simple Y-
joint are smaller than FE results. Thus, if the SCFs in
chord from DNV is used to carry out fatigue checks of
multi-planar tubular Y-joints, the assessment will not be
conservative. Acknowledgement This research was supported by the National Natural
Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 52001052). 7.
American Welding Society (AWS). Structural
Welding Code, AWS D1.1. Miami, USA, 2009. References 1. API. Recommended Practice for Planning,
Designing, and Constructing Fixed Offshore
Platforms - Load and Resistance Factor Design. 1997. 2. DNV-RP-C203. Fatigue Design of Offshore Steel
Structures. 2011. 3. Dong WB, Moan T, Gao Z. Long-term fatigue
analysis of multi-planar tubular joints for jacket-
type offshore wind turbine in time domain. Engineering Structures, 2011, 33: 2001-2014. 4. Woghiren C O, Brennan F P. Weld toe stress
concentrations in multi-planar stiffened tubular
KK joints. International Journal of Fatigue. 2009,
31(1): 164-172. 5. Karamanos S A, Romeijn A, Wardenier J. SCF
equations in multi-planar welded tubular DT-
joints
including
bending
effects. Marine
structures. 2002, 15(2): 157-173. 6. Ahmadi H, Mohammad A L, Mohammad H A. The development of fatigue design formulas for
the outer brace SCFs in offshore three-planar
tubular KT-joints. Thin-Walled Structures, 2012,
58(67-78). 7. American Welding Society (AWS). Structural
Welding Code, AWS D1.1. Miami, USA, 2009. 4 4
|
https://openalex.org/W4390442419
|
https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s12035-023-03858-y.pdf
|
English
| null |
Presenilin2 D439A Mutation Induces Dysfunction of Mitochondrial Fusion/Fission Dynamics and Abnormal Regulation of GTPase Activity
|
Molecular neurobiology
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 16,915
|
Abstract Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is an age-related progressive neurodegenerative disease, and approximately 10% of AD cases
are early-onset familial AD (EOFAD), which is mainly linked to point mutations in genes encoding presenilins (PS1 and
PS2). Mutations in PS2 are extremely rare and have not received enough attention. Recently, studies have found that Rho
GTPase activity is closely related to the pathogenesis of AD. In this study, we used transcriptome sequencing in PS2 siRNA-
transfected SH-SY5Y cells and found a group of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) related to the regulation of GTPase
activity. Among those DEGs, the most significantly downregulated was Rho guanine nucleotide exchange factor 5 (ARH-
GEF5). GTPase activity in PS2 siRNA-transfected cells was significantly decreased. Then, we found that the expression of
ARHGEF5 and the GTPase activity of Mitochondrial Rho GTPase 2 (Miro2) in PS2 D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells were
significantly decreased. We found for the first time that PS2 can bind to Miro2, and the PS2 D439A mutation reduced the
binding between PS2 and Miro2, reduced the expression of Miro2, and resulted in an imbalance in mitochondrial fusion/
fission dynamics. In conclusion, PS2 gene knockdown may participate in the pathogenesis of AD through the regulation of
GTPase activity. The imbalance in mitochondrial dynamics mediated by the PS2 D439A mutation through regulation of the
expression and GTPase activity of Miro2 may be a potential pathogenic mechanism of AD. rds Presenilin 2 · Alzheimer’s disease · Transcriptome sequencing · Miro2 · Mitochondrial dynamic Abbreviations
AD
Alzheimer’s disease
Aβ
Amyloid-beta
APP
Amyloid precursor protein
APPsw
APP with Swedish mutation
ARHGEF5
Rho guanine nucleotide exchange factor 5
CCK8
Cell counting kit-8
Co-IP
Co-immunoprecipitation
DCFH-DA
2′,7′-Dichlorodihydro fluorescein diacetate
DEGs
Differential expression genes
DMEM
Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium
DO
Disease Ontology
DPBS
Dulbecco’s phosphate-buffered saline
EOFAD
Early-onset familial Alzheimer’s disease
FAD
Familial Alzheimer’s disease
FBS
Fetal bovine serum
FDR
False discovery rate
FPKM
Fragment per kilobase of transcript per mil-
lion mapped reads
GABA
Gamma-aminobutyric acid
GSH-Px
Glutathione peroxidase
GNG3
G protein subunit gamma 3
GO
Gene Ontology
GST
Glutathione S-transferase
JUN
Jun proto-oncogene/AP-1 transcription fac-
tor subunit
KEGG
Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes
PS
Presenilin
qRT-PCR
Quantitative real-time PCR
Chenhao Gao and Junkui Shang have contributed equally to this
work. Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12035-023-03858-y Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12035-023-03858-y Presenilin2 D439A Mutation Induces Dysfunction of Mitochondrial
Fusion/Fission Dynamics and Abnormal Regulation of GTPase Activity
Chenhao Gao1,2 · Junkui Shang1,3 · Zhengyu Sun1,3 · Mingrong Xia1 · Dandan Gao1 · Ruihua Sun1,2 · Wei Li1 ·
Fengyu Wang1,3 · Jiewen Zhang1,2,3 Received: 17 May 2023 / Accepted: 4 December 2023 / Published online: 30 December 2023
© The Author(s) 2023 Abstract * Jiewen Zhang
zhangjiewen9900@126.com
1
Department of Neurology, Zhengzhou University
People’s Hospital, Henan Provincial People’s Hospital,
Zhengzhou 450003, Henan, China
2
Academy of Medical Sciences, Zhengzhou University,
Zhengzhou 450003, Henan, China
3
Department of Neurology, Henan University People’s
Hospital, Henan Provincial People’s Hospital,
Zhengzhou 450003, Henan, China 3456789)
3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5048 TEM
Transmission electron microscopy
MDA
Malondialdehyde (MDA)
MEFs
Mouse embryonic fibroblasts
Mfn
Mitofusin
MMP
Mitochondrial membrane potential
MOI
Multiplicity of infection
NFTs
Neurofibrillary tangles
GAPs
GTPase-activating proteins
GEF
Guanine nucleotide exchange factors
OMM
Outer mitochondrial membrane
PLXNA4
Plexin A4
RAPGEF5
Rap guanine nucleotide exchange factor 5
RELN
Reelin
RGPD8
Glutamate receptor interaction domain 8
ROS
Reactive oxygen species
SFRP1
Secretory frizzled related protein 1
SPRY1
Sprout receptor tyrosine kinase signal
antagonist 1
SOD2
Human superoxide dismutase 2
WT
Wild type domains flanking a pair of EF-hand motifs and a C-terminal
transmembrane domain that anchors the protein to the outer
mitochondrial membrane (OMM) [10]. The functions of
Miro1/2 include maintaining mitochondrial morphogenesis,
mitochondria–endoplasmic reticulum (ER) communication,
and apoptosis [11]. Miro1/2 can also regulate mitochondrial
morphology and fission/fusion by interacting with mitofusin1
(Mfn1) and mitofusin2 (Mfn2) [11]. Structure‒function stud-
ies have indicated that the GTPase domains play a key role in
regulating mitochondrial morphology by regulating mitochon-
drial fusion and fission [12]. i
A previous study found that PS2 and PS1 can interact with
the small GTPase Rab11, and the interaction domain was
mapped to the C-terminal end of PS1 [13]. PS1 can also inter-
act with Rac1, which belongs to the Rho family of small G
proteins [14]. However, there is no relevant study on whether
PS2 can interact with Miro proteins. The PS2 D439A mutation
was first reported in 2001 in an early-onset AD patient with a
missense mutation in exon 12 C.439 A > C of the PS2 gene,
resulting in the substitution of the aspartic acid encoded by the
439 codon at the C-terminus of PS2 with alanine [15]. A previ-
ous study evaluated the effect of the PS2 D439A mutation on
Aβ levels when this PS2 mutant was co-expressed with APP
carrying the Swedish mutation (APPsw) in PS1/2−/− mouse
embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs); the PS2 D439A mutation did
not increase either the Aβ42 level or the Aβ42/40 ratio [16]. Abstract Polymorphism phenotype v2 (PolyPhen-2) software was used
to evaluate the pathogenicity of the variant PS2 D439A, the
result (score 0.961) showed that this mutation is probably dam-
aging, and Sorting Intolerant From Tolerant (SIFT) was used
to predict that an aspartate-to-alanine substitution in the PS2
D439A mutation may disrupt the encoded proteins [17]. How-
ever, few studies have conducted relevant experiments to verify
the pathogenic mechanism of the PS2 D439A mutation. 3 Cell Culture Human embryonic kidney 293 T cells were a gift from Pro-
fessor Fengmin Shao and maintained in Dulbecco’s modi-
fied Eagle’s medium (DMEM) (HyClone, USA) supple-
mented with 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS; Gibco, USA). Lentiviruses were produced in human embryonic kidney
293 T cells. The human neuroblastoma clonal SH-SY5Y
cell line was purchased from the Cell Resources Center of
Shanghai Institute of Life Science, Chinese Academy of Sci-
ences (Shanghai, China), and was grown in DMEM/F-12
(HyClone, USA) supplemented with 10% FBS (Gibco BRL,
USA). All culture media contained 100 IU/ml penicillin and
100 mg/ml streptomycin (Gibco, USA). All cells were cul-
tured at 37 °C in a humidified atmosphere of air containing
5% CO2. Introduction Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is an age-related progressive neu-
rodegenerative disease that mainly leads to cognitive impair-
ment. Approximately 10% of AD cases occur in patients
less than 65 years old and are called early-onset familial
AD (EOFAD). The neuropathological changes in patients
with AD are characterized by the deposition of extracel-
lular amyloid-beta (Aβ) plaques and neurofibrillary tangles
(NFTs) formed by intracellular phosphorylated tau protein
[1]. The majority of familial AD (FAD) cases have been
linked to point mutations in Presenilin genes, which encode
two homologous proteins, presenilin 1 (PS1) and preseni-
lin 2 (PS2) [2]. The best-characterized function of PS1 and
PS2 is cleaving amyloid precursor protein (APP) to form
Aβ as the catalytic component of the γ-secretase complex
[3]. More than 300 mutations in PS1 have been described
worldwide, but mutations in PS2 are extremely rare and have
not received enough attention [4]. In this study, we first conducted transcriptome sequencing
analysis of SH-SY5Y cells after PS2 gene knockdown and
then performed Gene Ontology (GO)/Kyoto Encyclopedia of
Genes and Genomes (KEGG) and Disease Ontology (DO)
enrichment analyses to screen the differentially expressed
genes (DEGs) possibly involved in the regulation of mito-
chondrial dynamics and the pathogenesis of AD. Next, the
relevant DEGs and their functions were verified in PS2 D439A
cells, and the changes in the expression of proteins related
to mitochondrial dynamics were verified to further explore
the potential mechanism by which the PS2 D439A mutation
leads to AD and investigate its correlation with imbalanced
mitochondrial dynamics. The complete function of PS2 and the mechanism by which
it contributes to FAD pathogenesis are undetermined [4]. Currently, extensive studies have revealed that mitochondrial
dysfunction exists independently and potentially lies upstream
of Aβ deposition or NFT formation in AD pathogenesis [5,
6]. Mitochondria in AD brains showed fractured cristae, a
reduced respiratory capacity, and increased fragmentation
[7]. Mitochondria are dynamic organelles that constantly
undergo fission, fusion and transport within cells [8]. Mito-
chondrial Rho GTPase (Miro) proteins belong to a family of
evolutionarily conserved atypical GTPases [9], and each of
the two homologs, Miro1 and Miro2, contain two GTPase 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5049 Construction of Expression Plasmids The interference vector pLKD-CMV-Puro-U6-shRNA
was purchased from OBiO Technology (Shanghai) Co.,
Ltd. After enzymatic digestion with AgeI and EcoRI, three
siRNA targets were designed, with the sequences CCC
TCAAATACGGAGCGAA, CCATCAAGTCTGTGCGCT
T, and GCCTCTGAGAATGCTGGTA. The sequence of
the designed nontargeting negative control (scramble) was
TTCTCCGAACGTGTCACGT. The full-length human
PS2 cDNA sequence (NCBI accession no. NM_000447)
was amplified from total genomic DNA extracted from SH-
SY5Y cells by PCR using the forward primer 5′-gaggcgcgc-
cgccaccATGCTCACATTCATGGCCTCTG-3′ and reverse
primer 5′-tggtggccacgtggatgtTCAGATGTAGAGCTGATG
GGAGG-3′. The lentiviral expression vector pLV-EF1a-
CFP-CMV-Puro-WPRE was purchased from BrainVTA
Co., Ltd. (Wuhan, China). Human PS2 cDNA was inserted
into pLV-EF1a-CFP-CMV-Puro-WPRE, and Phanta Max
Super-Fidelity DNA Polymerase (Vazyme Biotech, China)
was used to construct the pLV-EF1a-PS2 wild-type (WT)-
CFP-CMV-Puro-WPRE expression vector. Positive clones
were identified by colony PCR and double digestion, and
Sanger sequencing was then performed for further confirma-
tion. The PS2 D439A mutation was introduced into the pLV-
EF1a-PS2 WT-CFP-CMV-Puro-WPRE expression vector by
homologous recombination with primers (forward primer:
5′-tcgtgatctagaGGCGCGCCgccaccatgctcacattcatgg-3′,
reverse primer: 5′-ttgctcatggtggccacgtggatgtagagctgatgg-
gaggccagggtgGccatgaacggccgcac-3′) designed to target
both ends of the mutated sequence. Both the PS2 WT and
PS2 D439A mutant cDNA sequences were verified by direct
sequencing. When the SH-SY5Y cells reached 20–30% confluence in
6-well plates, the lentiviral supernatant was added to each
well to achieve a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 20. For
viral infection, the cells were incubated for 2 h with the
lentiviral supernatant in 1 ml of serum-free medium, and an
equal volume of DMEM/F-12 supplemented with 10% FBS
was added. The medium was replaced with fresh medium
24 h after infection. Selection was initiated 72 h after infec-
tion by adding 2 µg/ml puromycin (Sigma-Aldrich, USA). Recombinant cell lines were further subcultured in culture
medium containing 1 µg/ml puromycin, and the expression
profiles of the cells expressing PS2 siRNA, PS2 WT, and the
PS2 D439A mutant were monitored by quantitative real-time
PCR (qRT‒PCR) and Western blot analysis. Materials and Methods 293 T cells plated in 15 cm dishes were cotransfected with
20 µg of the recombinant PS2 lentiviral expression vectors,
15 µg of pHelper1.0, and 10 µg of pHelper2.0 using Lipo-
fectamine 3000 (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA). Six hours (h)
after transfection, the culture medium was refreshed. Virus-
containing supernatants were collected at 48 h and 72 h after
transfection, centrifuged at 3500 rpm for 10 min, filtered
with a 0.45-µm sterile filter, and transferred into an ultracen-
trifuge tube, which was placed into an ultracentrifuge, and
centrifuged at 30,000 rpm and 4 ℃ for 2 h. The samples were
then filtered through a low protein-binding filter (0.22 µm),
aliquoted, and stored at − 80 ℃. Then, 150 µl of precooled
Dulbecco’s phosphate-buffered saline (DPBS) was added to
each centrifuge tube, and the precipitate was resuspended,
transferred into a 1.5-ml sterile EP tube, and allowed to
stand overnight at 4 ℃. The viral suspension was collected,
centrifuged at 6000 rpm and 4 ℃ for 5 min, filtered through
a 0.22-µm sterile filter, and transferred to a new sterile EP
tube. After subpackaging, the lentivirus was stored in a − 80
℃ freezer.l Reverse Transcription and qRT‑PCR Analysis Total RNA was extracted with an RNAsimple Total RNA
Kit (DP419, Tiangen, China) according to the manufactur-
er’s instructions. Reverse transcription was performed using
PrimeScript™ RT Master Mix (RR036A, TaKaRa, USA). qRT-PCR was performed utilizing TB Green® Premix Ex
Taq™ II (RR820A, TaKaRa, USA) on a PCR instrument
(7500 Real-Time PCR Detection System, Applied Biosys-
tems, USA). Target cDNA expression was measured using
the relative quantification method. Specific primers (see
Table 1) were used for cDNA amplification. The thermal
cycling conditions used for qRT‒PCR were as follows:
95 °C for 30 s, followed by 40 cycles at 95 °C for 5 s and
60 °C for 34 s. 1 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5050 Table 1 Primers of qRT-PCR
Gene
Primer direction
Sequence (5′–3′)
PS2
Forward
TGCGCTCATGGCCCTAGTGTTCA
Reverse
TGGGCTCATTTCTCTCCTGGG
CAGTT
ARHGEF5
Forward
CAAACCTGCCATCTACAGCTC
Reverse
AAGAACCGTAGGCGGGAGA
GNG3
Forward
CCCCGGTGAACAGCACTATG
Reverse
GGCATCACAGTAAGTCATCAGG
JUN
Forward
TCCAAGTGCCGAAAAAGGAAG
Reverse
CGAGTTCTGAGCTTTCAAGGT
RAPGEF5
Forward
TCTTGTGCGTCTAACATCTGC
Reverse
GAATCTGGAACACTTTCGGCTT
SFRP1
Forward
ACGTGGGCTACAAGAAGATGG
Reverse
CAGCGACACGGGTAGATGG
PLXNA4
Forward
GTCATTTGTCACATTCCGAGGA
Reverse
GCTTGTAAATCCGATTGACGGC
KIAA1614
Forward
GGCTCCTCGTACCCAAAACC
Reverse
TGTCATGGTCAGGAAGTGTCC
RELN
Forward
CAACCCCACCTACTACGTTCC
Reverse
TCACCAGCAAGCCGTCAAAAA
SPRY1
Forward
GCAGTGGCAGTTCGTTAGTTG
Reverse
CAGTAGGCTGAATCTCTCTCTCA
RGPD8
Forward
GATATTAGGGGCCGGAAGAAGG
Reverse
AGGGGCTTCAGGTTCATTGTAG
β-actin
Forward
ATCATGTTTGAGACCTTCAACA
Reverse
CATCTCTTGCTCGAAGTCCA
GAPDH
Forward
GCAAATTCCATGGCACCGTCA
AGG
Reverse
CGCCAGCATCGCCCCACTTG Cat #A5838, 1:1000), rabbit anti-Miro2 (Proteintech, Cat
#11,237–1-AP, 1:2000), rabbit anti-Mfn1 (Proteintech, Cat
#13,798–1-AP, 1:1000), rabbit anti-Mfn2 (Proteintech, Cat
#12,186–1-AP, 1:1000), rabbit anti-Drp1 (Proteintech, Cat
#12,957–1-AP, 1:1000), rabbit anti-Cyt c (Proteintech, Cat
#10993–1-AP, 1:1000), rabbit anti-BCL-2 (Proteintech, Cat
#12789–1-AP, 1:1000), rabbit anti-BAX (Proteintech, Cat
#50599–2-Ig, 1:2000), and rabbit anti-VDAC1 (Proteintech,
Cat #55259–1-AP, 1:1000). The secondary antibodies used
were HRP-labeled goat anti-rabbit IgG (H + L) (Beyotime,
Cat #A0208, 1:1500) and HRP-labeled goat anti-mouse
IgG (H + L) (Beyotime, Cat #A0216, 1:1500). After a final
wash step, immunodetection was performed using enhanced
chemiluminescence (Immobilon™ Western Chemilumines-
cent HRP Substrate (ECL), Millipore, USA); immunoreac-
tive protein bands were digitally imaged and band densities
were quantified with UVP VisionWorks Acquisition/Analy-
sis Software (Analytik Jena, USA). Mitochondrial Protein Extraction A Qproteome Mitochondrial Isolation Kit (Qiagen, Ger-
many) was used in this experiment. SH-SY5Y cells (1 × 107)
were harvested and centrifuged at 500 × g for 10 min at 4 °C
and then washed using 0.9% sodium chloride solution. The
cell pellet was resuspended in 1 ml of ice-cold lysis buffer
containing protease inhibitor solution and incubated for
10 min at 4 °C on an end-over-end shaker. Next, each sam-
ple was centrifuged at 1,000 × g at 4 °C for 10 min, and the
supernatant containing the cytosolic proteins was collected
in a clear 1.5-ml tube for further analysis. The cell pellet was
resuspended in 1.5 ml ice-cold disruption buffer contain-
ing protease inhibitor solution. Then, the lysate was drawn
into a syringe using a blunt needle and ejected; this step
was repeated 10 times. The lysate was centrifuged again at
1000 × g and 4 °C for 10 min, and the supernatant was trans-
ferred to a new tube and centrifuged at 6000 × g for 10 min at
4 °C, and the resulting supernatant was removed. The pellet
containing the mitochondrial fraction was washed with 1 ml
of Mitochondria Storage Buffer, centrifuged at 6000 × g for
20 min at 4 °C, and resuspended in Mitochondria Storage
Buffer for further analysis. Western Blot Cells were lysed in Western and IP lysis buffer (Beyo-
time, China) supplemented with an EDTA-free complete
protease inhibitor cocktail tablet (Thermo, USA) on ice
for 30 min. The lysate was centrifuged at 13,000 rpm for
15 min at 4 °C, and then, the supernatant was transferred
to a fresh tube and stored at − 80 °C. Protein concentrations
were determined using a bicinchoninic acid (BCA) assay
(Thermo, USA). Proteins in the samples were separated by
8–12% sodium dodecyl sulfate–polyacrylamide gel electro-
phoresis (SDS‒PAGE) and transferred to 0.45-µm PVDF
Transfer Membranes (Millipore, USA). After blocking
in 5% nonfat milk, the membranes were incubated with a
primary antibody (4 °C, overnight) prior to washing and
incubation with horseradish peroxidase (HRP)–conju-
gated secondary antibodies (1 h, room temperature). The
following primary antibodies were used: rabbit anti-PS2
(Abcam, Cat #ab51249, 1:1000), rabbit anti-βActin (Beyo-
time, Cat #AF5003, 1:2000), rabbit anti-Miro1 (ABclonal, Synthesis of Miro2 Adenovirus (Ad‑Miro2) Ad-Miro2 and the corresponding normal control adenovi-
rus (Ad-NC) were constructed and synthesized by OBiO
Technology (Shanghai) Co., Ltd. Using the vector pAd-
eno-MCMV-MCS-Myc, the CDS of Miro2 was amplified
by PCR, and the pAdeno-MCMV-MCS-Myc-Miro2 over-
expression vector was then constructed. The overexpression
efficiency of Ad-Miro2 was verified by Western blotting. GST Pull Downs All DEGs were mapped to GO terms in the GO database
(http://www.geneontology.org/), gene numbers were calcu-
lated for each term, and hypergeometric tests were used to
identify significantly enriched GO terms in DEGs compared
to the genome background. The calculated p-value under-
went FDR correction, with a threshold of FDR ≤ 0.05. GO
terms that met this condition were defined as significantly
enriched GO terms in DEGs. KEGG is a leading public
pathway-related database, DO is a database (http://disease-
ontology.org/) that describes gene functions associated with
diseases, and KEGG and DO analysis methods are identical
to those used in GO analysis. The cDNAs encoding amino acids 1–87 and amino acids
271–361 of PS2 were ligated into the BamHI/XhoI sites
of the plasmid pGEX-4 T-3, and then expressed as a glu-
tathione S-transferase(GST)-tagged fusion protein trans-
formed in E. coli BL21. The cDNAs encoding amino acids
1–219 and 220–592 of Miro2 were inserted into the BamHI/
XhoI sites of the plasmid pET-32a, and then expressed as
a HIS-tagged fusion protein transformed in E. coli BL21. Recombinant GST fusion proteins and recombinant HIS
fusion proteins were induced using 0.1 mM isopropyl β-D-
thiogalactoside (IPTG) for 2 h at 30 °C and extracted and
purified as previously described [20]. Bound material was
eluted with 4 × SDS sample buffer and processed for SDS-
PAGE and Western blot. Detection of GTPase Activity A GTPase assay kit (ab270553, Abcam, USA) was used to
detect the changes in GTPase activity in SH-SY5Y cells
infected with various lentiviruses. The kit includes a GTP
reaction substrate and provides a simple and direct method
to measure GTPase activity in the sample to be tested. GTPases catalyze the hydrolysis of GTP to GDP and free
phosphate (Pi). The PiColorLock™ reagent in the kit and the
Pi released during the enzymatic reaction form a dark green
Pi-dye complex, and its color depth is directly proportional
to the enzyme activity. After reaction for 30 min, the absorb-
ance value was measured at 590–660 nm. All test steps were
carried out according to the instructions. As directed, no
reagent in contact with the sample to be tested contained
phosphate. Transcriptome Sequencing The specific steps were as follows: preparation of PS2
siRNA knockdown cell line samples infected by lentiviral
transduction, RNA extraction and detection, library con-
struction, quality inspection, sequencing, bioinformatics
analysis, etc. The libraries were sequenced using an Illumina
HiSeq™ 4000 instrument by Gene Denovo Biotechnology
Co., Ltd. (Guangzhou, China). The raw RNA sequencing
(RNA-seq) reads were mapped to the reference genome 1 3 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5051 using HISAT2 (version 2.1.0) [18]. With StringTie software,
a fragment per kilobase of transcript per million mapped
reads (FPKM) value was calculated for each transcription
region to quantify its expression abundance and variations. DEGs were identified using DESeq2 [19] based on the
parameters of false discovery rate (FDR) value < 0.05 and
|log2 fold change(FC)|> 1. Raw RNA sequencing data were
deposited in the NCBI Sequence Read Archive database
(PRJNA963881). overnight at 4 °C under constant rotation. Then, 25 μl of
beads was added to each pretreated protein sample, and the
mixture was incubated for 30 min at room temperature with
constant rotation. The immune complexes were washed three
times with 500 µl of PBST, denatured in 60 μl of sample
buffer and analyzed by western blotting. Total lysate (20 µg)
was used as input. Each experiment was performed at least
three times. Reactive Oxygen Species Analysis The Aβ25-35 peptide (MedChemExpress, USA) was dis-
solved in sterilized deionized water to a concentration of
1 mM and stored at − 80 ℃ until use. To prepare aggregated
Aβ25-35 fibrils, Aβ25-35 peptide was placed in a 37 ℃ incu-
bator for 7 days. Then, the Aβ25-35 fibril solutions were
diluted to 40 µM with serum-free DMEM-F12 and added to
the cultured cells for incubation in an incubator containing
5% CO2 at 37 °C for 48 h. Apoptotic cells were detected by
staining with the nuclear dye Hoechst 33,342 (Invitrogen,
USA), which reveals fragmented or intensely stained nuclei. Nuclear morphology was visualized under a fluorescence
microscope (BX53, Olympus, Japan). Images were exported
as TIFF files, subjected to background subtraction and ana-
lyzed with Image-Pro Plus 6.0 software (Media Cybernetics,
Rockville, MD, USA). A ROS assay kit (Beyotime, China) was used to detect ROS
using the fluorescent probe 2’,7’-dichlorodihydrofluorescein
diacetate (DCFH-DA). DCFH-DA itself has no fluorescence
and can freely pass through the cell membrane. After enter-
ing the cell, it can be hydrolyzed by esterases in the cell to
produce DCFH. ROS in cells can oxidize nonfluorescent
DCFH to produce fluorescent DCF. The level of ROS in
cells can be determined by detecting the fluorescence of
DCF. Samples were analyzed using a fluorescence micro-
scope (BX53, Olympus, Japan). Images were exported as
TIFF files, subjected to background subtraction and ana-
lyzed with Image-Pro Plus 6.0 software (Media Cybernetics,
Rockville, MD, USA). Cell Viability and Cell Apoptosis Analysis A cell counting kit-8 (CCK8) assay kit (Dojindo, Japan) was
used to assess cell viability. Cells (6 × 103 cells/well) were
seeded in 96-well plates and cultured for 24 h. Then, the
culture supernatant was removed, 10 μl of CCK8 solution in
100 µl of culture medium was added per well, and the cells
were incubated in 5% CO2 at 37 °C for 4 h. The absorbance
at 450 nm was measured with a microplate spectrophotom-
eter (Synergy H1, BioTek Instruments, USA). ATP Measurement ATP contents in SH-SY5Y cells were analyzed using an
ATP Chemiluminescence Assay Kit (Elabscience, E-BC-
F002, China) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. Briefly, cells were resuspended in extracting solution and
incubated in a boiling water bath for 10 min; after cooled,
the samples were centrifuged at 10,000 × g for 10 min at
4 °C. The supernatant was collected for further assays. Chemiluminescent signals were detected by Multifunctional
Microplate Reader Synergy H1 (BioTek, USA). Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) Analysis In brief, the culture medium of each group of cells was dis-
carded, and 2.5% glutaraldehyde solution was added to fix
the cells for 5 min at room temperature. Then, the cells were
gently harvested by scraping in one direction with a cell
scraper. The cell suspension was aspirated and transferred to
a centrifuge tube with a pasteurized pipette and centrifuged
at 2000 rpm for 2 min. The ideal size of the cell mass was
similar to that of a mung bean. After discarding the fixation
solution, new 2.5% glutaraldehyde solution was added, and
the cell mass was gently picked up and suspended in the
fixation solution for 1 h. Then, the cells were dehydrated in
an ethanol dilution series and embedded in epoxy embed-
ding medium (Sigma-Aldrich, USA). Ultrathin sections were
sliced at a 60-nm thickness and observed under an electron
microscope (Hitachi TEM system, Japan). Co‑immunoprecipitation (Co‑IP) A mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP) assay kit with
JC-1 (Beyotime, China) was used in this assay. SH-SY5Y
cells (2 × 105 cells/well) were seeded in six-well plates. For one well of the six-well plate, the culture medium
was removed, and the cells were washed once with PBS
or another appropriate solution according to the specific
experiment. Then, 1 ml of cell culture medium and 1 ml
JC-1 dyeing solution were added and mixed well. The cells
were incubated at 37 ℃ for 30 min. During incubation, every
1 ml of JC-1 staining buffer (5 ×) was added to 4 ml distilled
water to prepare JC-1 staining buffer (1 ×), which was placed
in an ice bath. After incubation at 37 ℃, the supernatant was
removed and washed twice with JC-1 staining buffer (1 ×),
and then, 2 ml of cell culture medium was added. The Cells were lysed in Western and IP Lysis Buffer (Beyotime,
China) supplemented with an EDTA-free complete protease
inhibitor cocktail tablet (Thermo, USA) on ice for 30 min,
the lysates were centrifuged (13,000 rpm, 15 min, 4 °C),
and the total protein in the supernatant was quantified. Then,
equal amounts of protein (300 ~ 500 μg) were added to 20 μl
of Pure Proteome Protein A/G Mix Magnetic Beads (Mil-
lipore, USA) and incubated with 1 μg of normal rabbit IgG
(Beyotime, Cat #A7016) for 2 h at 4 °C. Then, the beads
were incubated with 1 μg of a rabbit anti-PS2 (Abcam, Cat
#ab51249), rabbit anti-Miro1 (ABclonal, Cat #A5838), or
rabbit anti-Miro2 (Proteintech, Cat #11,237–1-AP) antibody 1 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5052 changes in MMP were observed by fluorescence microscopy. The results of JC-1 measurement were expressed as the ratio
of green/red mass fluorescent cells detected at 490 nm and
525 nm excitation. Samples were analyzed using a fluores-
cence microscope (BX53, Olympus, Japan). Images were
exported as TIFF, background subtracted and analyzed with
Image-Pro plus 6.0 software (Media Cybernetics, Rockville,
MD, USA). centrifuged at 1000 × g for 5 min, and 1 × 106 cells were
resuspended in 150 μl of cold PBS. The freeze–thaw pro-
cess was repeated several times until the cells were fully
lysed. After centrifugation for 10 min at 1500 × g at 4 °C,
the supernatant was collected for assay. Screening for the Best Interference Sequence Three siRNAs to individually knock down PS2 mRNA lev-
els in SH-SY5Y cells were examined. Using qRT‒PCR
analysis, we found that pLV-PS2-siRNA1 knocked down
PS2 mRNA expression most significantly (the interference
efficiencies of the pLV-PS2-siRNA1, pLV-PS2-siRNA2, and
pLV-PS2-siRNA3 lentiviral vectors were 92.16%, 91.86%,
and 88.18%, respectively, compared with the pLV-scramble
vector (Fig. 1A). Therefore, pLV-PS2-siRNA1 was used for
the subsequent experiments. In addition, the endogenous
PS2 level in SH-SY5Y cells infected with pLV-PS2-siRNA
lentivirus was measured, and the results showed that pLV-
PS2-siRNA1 lentivirus had the best interference effect
(Fig. 1B, C). Then, we performed an analysis on the top 20 GO terms
in the biological process category, and the results showed
that nervous system development was the GO term most sig-
nificantly enriched in the upregulated genes. The terms gen-
eration of neurons, neurogenesis, nerve development, neuron
differentiation, synapse organization, regulation of synapse
organization, neuron development, and terms related to other
biological processes of the nervous system were the main
terms enriched in the other DEGs (Fig. 2C). The main biochemical metabolic pathways and signal
transduction pathways in which DEGs are involved can be
determined through identification of significant enrichment
of KEGG pathways. KEGG pathway enrichment analysis
showed that 72 candidate pathways were enriched in the
DEGs between the scramble and PS2 siRNA groups. Among
the top 20 enriched pathways, the serotonergic synapse path-
way was the most significantly enriched. The hippocampal
signaling pathway, dopaminergic synapse, synaptic vesicle
cycle, gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA)ergic synapse, and
Rap1 signaling pathway were also significantly enriched
(Supplementary Fig. 2). Statistical Analysis Levels of oxidative stress–related factors were measured
using a malondialdehyde (MDA) ELISA kit (Elabsci-
ence, E-EL-0060c, China), human superoxide dismutase
2 (SOD2) ELISA kit (Elabscience, E-EL-H6188, China),
and glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px) ELISA kit (MEIM-
IAN, MM-0457H2, China), following the protocols of the
manufacturer. Briefly, cells were washed twice with PBS,
and harvested with 0.25% trypsin. The cell suspension was Statistical analysis was performed and graphs generated
with GraphPad Prism 6.0 software. Data normality was
assessed using the Shapiro–Wilk test. Data are expressed
as the means ± SDs. Two-tailed Student’s t test and either
one-way ANOVA followed by Dunnett’s post hoc test or
two-way ANOVA were used to analyze individual differ-
ences between two groups and among more than two groups, 1 3 3 5053 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 based on the functional classification of DEGs, GO func-
tional enrichment analysis was performed. The biological
processes (BPs) were associated with the following terms:
single organization process, cellular process, biological
regulation, positive regulation of biological process and
response to stimulus, etc. The cellular components (CCs)
were associated with the following terms: cell, cell part, cell
membrane, organelle, membrane part, synapse, synapse part,
etc. The molecular functions (MFs) were associated with the
following terms: cell binding, cell catalytic activity, molec-
ular transducer activity, molecular function regulator and
protein binding, etc. (Supplementary Fig. 1). respectively. P < 0.05 was considered to indicate a statisti-
cally significant difference. Analysis of Transcriptome Sequencing Results To explore the mechanism of PS2 in the pathogenesis of
AD, we used RNA-seq analysis based on high-throughput
sequencing to investigate the transcript changes in PS2
siRNA-transfected and scramble siRNA-transfected SH-
SY5Y cells. A total of 166 DEGs were identified, among
which 42 were upregulated and 124 were downregulated
(Fig. 2A). The cluster patterns of the PS2 siRNA and scram-
ble groups were significantly different (Fig. 2B). To fur-
ther clarify the basic functions of the related target mRNAs Fig. 1 Validation of PS2 siRNA lentiviral knockdown efficiency. A PS2 mRNA expression level in SH-SY5Y cells infected with
pLV-PS2siRNA1, pLV-PS2siRNA2, pLV-PS2siRNA3 and pLV-
scramble (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sample
per experiment; one-way ANOVA). B PS2 protein expression in
SH-SY5Y cells infected with pLV-PS2siRNA1, pLV-PS2siRNA2,
pLV-PS2siRNA3 and pLV-scramble. C Bar graph showing rela-
tive PS2 expression (fold change). (n = 3; three independent experi-
ments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data
are presented as the mean ± standard deviation (mean ± SD) values;
*P < 0.05, **P < 0.01 pLV-PS2siRNA3 and pLV-scramble. C Bar graph showing rela-
tive PS2 expression (fold change). (n = 3; three independent experi-
ments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data
are presented as the mean ± standard deviation (mean ± SD) values;
*P < 0.05, **P < 0.01 Fig. 1 Validation of PS2 siRNA lentiviral knockdown efficiency. A PS2 mRNA expression level in SH-SY5Y cells infected with
pLV-PS2siRNA1, pLV-PS2siRNA2, pLV-PS2siRNA3 and pLV-
scramble (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sample
per experiment; one-way ANOVA). B PS2 protein expression in
SH-SY5Y cells infected with pLV-PS2siRNA1, pLV-PS2siRNA2, 1 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5054 gy (
)
Fig. 2 Volcano plot and heatmap showing differential expression in
the scramble and PS2 siRNA groups. A Volcano plot of PS2 siRNA
samples against scramble samples. B Heatmap showing DEGs
between the scramble and PS2 siRNA groups. Each column repre-
l
d
h
Th
l
the expression levels of genes in each sample. C Bubble diagram of
the top 20 enriched GO biological processes. The bubble size is pro-
portional to the number of genes. Analysis of Transcriptome Sequencing Results The redder the color, the smaller is
the Q value Further analysis of these DEGs showed that multiple
KEGG pathways were enriched in a class of genes that
genes such as G protein subunit Gamma 3 (GNG3), Jun
proto oncogene/AP 1 transcription factor subunit (JUN)
Fig. 2 Volcano plot and heatmap showing differential expression in
the scramble and PS2 siRNA groups. A Volcano plot of PS2 siRNA
samples against scramble samples. B Heatmap showing DEGs
between the scramble and PS2 siRNA groups. Each column repre-
sents a sample, and each row represents a gene. The colors represent
the expression levels of genes in each sample. C Bubble diagram of
the top 20 enriched GO biological processes. The bubble size is pro-
portional to the number of genes. The redder the color, the smaller is
the Q value Fig. 2 Volcano plot and heatmap showing differential expression in
the scramble and PS2 siRNA groups. A Volcano plot of PS2 siRNA
samples against scramble samples. B Heatmap showing DEGs
between the scramble and PS2 siRNA groups. Each column repre-
sents a sample, and each row represents a gene. The colors represent the expression levels of genes in each sample. C Bubble diagram of
the top 20 enriched GO biological processes. The bubble size is pro-
portional to the number of genes. The redder the color, the smaller is
the Q value genes such as G protein subunit Gamma 3 (GNG3), Jun
proto oncogene/AP-1 transcription factor subunit (JUN),
Reelin (RELN), and Rap guanine nucleotide exchange factor Further analysis of these DEGs showed that multiple
KEGG pathways were enriched in a class of genes that
regulate GTPase binding or GTPase activity, containing 1 3 1 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5055 We next confirmed the expression of the genes regulating
GTPases by qPCR, and the verification results were con-
sistent with the RNA-seq results (Fig. 3B). In PS2 siRNA-
transfected SH-SY5Y cells, the mRNA levels of the posi-
tive regulators of GTPase activity Ran binding protein 2-like
and glutamate receptor interaction domain 8 (RGPD8) and
the negative regulators of GTPase activity sprout receptor
tyrosine kinase signal antagonist 1 (SPRY1) and RELN were
significantly increased (P < 0.05). However, the expression
of ARHGEF5, JUN, secretory frizzled–related protein 1
(SFRP1) and other genes that positively regulate GTPase
activity was decreased significantly (P < 0.05) (Fig. 3B). mRNA Expression and Significance
of GTPase‑Related DEGs According to the screening and analysis of the DEGs in the
PS2 siRNA cell transcriptome data, PS2 may be related to
the regulation of GTPases (see Table 3). Multiple KEGG
pathways, such as serotonergic synapse and Rap1 signaling
pathway, were enriched in genes related to GTPase regula-
tion, such as GNG3, JUN, RELN, and RAPGEF5. Analysis of Transcriptome Sequencing Results Moreover, GTPase activity in PS2 siRNA-transfected SH-
SY5Y cells was significantly lower than that in scramble
siRNA-transfected cells (P < 0.05) (Fig. 3C). 5 (RAPGEF5) (see Table 2), suggesting that these DEGs
related to the regulation of GTPase activity may play impor-
tant biological roles. In addition, all DEGs were mapped to DO terms in the
DO database. The most significantly enriched DO item
was cognitive disorder. In addition, these DEGs were
also involved in the occurrence and development of AD
(Fig. 3A). Expression of GTPase‑Related Genes and GTPase
Activity in PS2 D439A Mutant Cells The disease term most strongly enriched in the DEGs
in DO enrichment analysis was cognitive dysfunction
(Fig. 3A), which is also related to the pathogenesis of AD,
suggesting that when PS2 gene expression was knocked
down, these DEGs related to the regulation of GTPases may
play an important biological role, which may eventually lead
to cognitive dysfunction or the occurrence of AD. We successfully established stably transduced SH-SY5Y
cell lines expressing PS2 WT, PS2 D439A, or empty vec-
tor. The results of qPCR and Western blot analyses showed
that PS2 mRNA (Fig. 4A) and the PS2 protein (Fig. 4B,
C) were significantly overexpressed in the stable pLV-PS2
WT-transduced and pLV-PS2 D439A-transduced cell lines Table 2 Pathway notes
Scramble vs
PS2-siRNA
(n)
All (n)
Pathway
Genes
P value
Q value
5
115
Serotonergic synapse
GNG3; GABRB2; KCND2; SLC18A1;
MAOB
0.003103395
0.3956533
4
91
Complement and coagulation cascades
CD55; VWF; C7; PLAT
0.007835499
0.3956533
3
49
Cocaine addiction
SLC18A1; MAOB; JUN
0.00862324
0.3956533
4
95
Morphine addiction
GNG3; PDE3A; GABRB2; GABRG2
0.009095479
0.3956533
5
178
Tight junction
PARD6B; RUNX1; PPP2R2B; MSN; JUN
0.01873816
0.4592755
3
70
Drug metabolism cytochrome P450
MGST1; UGT2B4; MAOB
0.02252871
0.4592755
3
70
Amphetamine addiction
SLC18A1; MAOB; JUN
0.02252871
0.4592755
2
29
Hippo signaling pathway — multiple species
FAT4; DCHS2
0.02581512
0.4592755
4
135
Purine metabolism
GUCY1A2; PDE3A; ENPP4; ENPP1
0.02924684
0.4592755
4
136
Dopaminergic synapse
GNG3; PPP2R2B; SLC18A1; MAOB
0.0299413
0.4592755
3
79
Synaptic vesicle cycle
SLC1A2; SLC6A2; SLC18A1
0.03080993
0.4592755
4
140
Apelin signaling pathway
RYR2; APLNR; GNG3; PLAT
0.03281695
0.4592755
4
142
Fluid shear stress and atherosclerosis
MGST1; VEGFA; PLAT; JUN
0.03431369
0.4592755
8
447
PI3K-Akt signaling pathway
DDIT4; GNG3; VWF; ERBB4; PPP2R2B;
VEGFA; RELN; LPAR1
0.03848891
0.4599038
2
37
Starch and sucrose metabolism
ENPP1; GYG2
0.04051757
0.4599038
3
91
GABAergic synapse
GNG3; GABRB2; GABRG2
0.04400953
0.4599038
5
226
Rap1 signaling pathway
ID1; PARD6B; VEGFA; RAPGEF5; LPAR1 0.04565179
0.4599038
2
41
Nicotine addiction
GABRB2; GABRG2
0.04880135
0.4599038
3
96
TGF-beta signaling pathway
ID1; INHBA; ID3
0.05021938
0.4599038
4
167
Wnt signaling pathway
DKK1; LGR5; SFRP1; JUN
0.05636153
0.4709099 Genes 1 5056
Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070
Fig. 3 Bubble diagram of DO enrichment analysis results, verifica-
tion of RNA sequencing results by qRT‒PCR, and GTPase activity
measurement in SH-SY5Y cells. A Bubble diagram of the top 20
enriched DO terms. Expression of GTPase‑Related Genes and GTPase
Activity in PS2 D439A Mutant Cells B qRT‒PCR was performed to verify the DEGs
related to GTPase regulation in PS2 siRNA samples compared to
scramble samples (n = 3; three independent experiments with one
sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented
as the means ± SDs; *P < 0.05. C Compared with that in pLV-scram
ble-transfected cells, the GTPase activity in PS2 siRNA-transfected
SH-SY5Y cells was significantly decreased (n = 3; three independ
ent experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA)
The data are presented as the means ± SDs; *P < 0.05 5056 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 Fig. 3 Bubble diagram of DO enrichment analysis results, verifica-
tion of RNA sequencing results by qRT‒PCR, and GTPase activity
measurement in SH-SY5Y cells. A Bubble diagram of the top 20
enriched DO terms. B qRT‒PCR was performed to verify the DEGs
related to GTPase regulation in PS2 siRNA samples compared to
scramble samples (n = 3; three independent experiments with one
sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented
as the means ± SDs; *P < 0.05. C Compared with that in pLV-scram-
ble-transfected cells, the GTPase activity in PS2 siRNA-transfected
SH-SY5Y cells was significantly decreased (n = 3; three independ-
ent experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented as the means ± SDs; *P < 0.05 Fig. 3 Bubble diagram of DO enrichment analysis results, verifica-
tion of RNA sequencing results by qRT‒PCR, and GTPase activity
measurement in SH-SY5Y cells. A Bubble diagram of the top 20
enriched DO terms. B qRT‒PCR was performed to verify the DEGs
related to GTPase regulation in PS2 siRNA samples compared to
scramble samples (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented
as the means ± SDs; *P < 0.05. C Compared with that in pLV-scram-
ble-transfected cells, the GTPase activity in PS2 siRNA-transfected
SH-SY5Y cells was significantly decreased (n = 3; three independ-
ent experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). Expression of GTPase‑Related Genes and GTPase
Activity in PS2 D439A Mutant Cells The data are presented as the means ± SDs; *P < 0.05 1 3 5057 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 Table 3 Statistical table of DEGs related to GTPase regulation
Symbol
log2(fc)
FDR
GO function/process
RGPD8
1.726020088
< 0.05 GO:0005096//GTPase activator activity;
GO:0043547//positive regulation of GTPase activity;
SPRY1
1.625270489
< 0.05 GO:0034260//negative regulation of GTPase activity;
RELN
1.110806786
< 0.05 GO:0034260//negative regulation of GTPase activity;
KIAA1614
1.073794074
< 0.05 GO:0017048//Rho GTPase binding
PLXNA4
− 1.19710442
< 0.05 GO:0043087//regulation of GTPase activity;
SFRP1
− 1.25907173
< 0.05 GO:0043547//positive regulation of GTPase activity;
RAPGEF5
− 1.4265983
< 0.05 GO:0007264//small GTPase mediated signal transduction;GO:0030742//GTP-dependent protein binding
JUN
− 1.49471792
< 0.05 GO:0005096//GTPase activator activity;GO:0043547//positive regulation of GTPase activity;
GNG3
− 1.91177282
< 0.05 GO:0003924//GTPase activity
ARHGEF5
− 3.12553088
< 0.05 GO:0090630//activation of GTPase activity; GO:0043087//regulation of GTPase activity;GO:0043547//
positive regulation of GTPase activity;GO:0051056//regulation of small GTPase mediated signal
transduction;GO:0005089//Rho guanyl-nucleotide exchange factor activity;GO:0005525//GTP bind-
ing; 3 Statistical table of DEGs related to GTPase regulation compared with the empty vector-transduced cell line. The
DEGs related to the regulation of GTPases identified by
RNA-seq in PS2 siRNA-transfected SH-SY5Y cells were
verified in PS2 D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells. Compared
with those in PS2 WT cells, the mRNA level of ARHGEF5,
which is related to the positive regulation of GTPase activ-
ity, was significantly reduced by more than twofold, and the
mRNA levels of SPRY1 and RELN, which are related to the
negative regulation of GTPase activity, were also reduced
(P < 0.05). However, the mRNA expression of plexin A4
(PLXNA4) and GNG3, which are related to the regulation
of GTPase activity, was increased significantly (P < 0.05)
(Fig. 4D). We evaluated the changes in GTPase activity in
these cells and found that the GTPase activity in PS2 D439A
mutant SH-SY5Y cells was significantly lower than that in
PS2 WT SH-SY5Y cells (P < 0.05) (Fig. 4E). interacting regions. PS2 is composed of 448 amino acids
and contains 7 to 9 transmembrane domains in different
organelles [3, 22]. Based on the characteristics of the trans-
membrane structure and the possible interaction between the
extracellular domain of PS2 and Miro2, GST fusion proteins
containing each of the two domains of PS2 (amino acids
1–87 and 271–361) were constructed (GST-PS2(1–87) and
GST-PS2(271–361), respectively). Miro2 is composed of 618
amino acids and has a single transmembrane domain, and a
full-length Miro2 protein could not be constructed. Binding Analysis Between PS2 and Miro1/2 To verify whether PS2 can interact with Miro1/2, we first
used a Co-IP experiment to detect this binding interaction. The results indicated that endogenous PS2 can interact with
Miro2 but not Miro1 (Fig. 5A). In addition, Miro2 coim-
munoprecipitated with PS2 (Fig. 5B). Then, we used a
pulldown assay to determine whether there is a direct bind-
ing interaction between PS2 and Miro2 and to identify the Expression of GTPase‑Related Genes and GTPase
Activity in PS2 D439A Mutant Cells Thus, His
fusion proteins containing each of the two domains of Miro2
(amino acids 1–219 and 220–592) were constructed (His-
Miro2(1–219) and His-Miro2(220–592), respectively). These two
domains of Miro2 contain two GTPase domains. The results
of pulldown experiments suggested that GST-PS2(271–361) did
bind to His-Miro2(220–592) but not to His-Miro2(1–219) and that
GST-PS2(1–87) did not interact with either His-Miro2(1–219) or
His-Miro2(220–592) (Fig. 5C, D). The above results suggested
that PS2 can interact with Miro2. compared with the empty vector-transduced cell line. The
DEGs related to the regulation of GTPases identified by
RNA-seq in PS2 siRNA-transfected SH-SY5Y cells were
verified in PS2 D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells. Compared
with those in PS2 WT cells, the mRNA level of ARHGEF5,
which is related to the positive regulation of GTPase activ-
ity, was significantly reduced by more than twofold, and the
mRNA levels of SPRY1 and RELN, which are related to the
negative regulation of GTPase activity, were also reduced
(P < 0.05). However, the mRNA expression of plexin A4
(PLXNA4) and GNG3, which are related to the regulation
of GTPase activity, was increased significantly (P < 0.05)
(Fig. 4D). We evaluated the changes in GTPase activity in
these cells and found that the GTPase activity in PS2 D439A
mutant SH-SY5Y cells was significantly lower than that in
PS2 WT SH-SY5Y cells (P < 0.05) (Fig. 4E). Recent studies have found that Miro1/2 plays a central
role in mitochondrial fusion/fission and mitochondrial mor-
phological regulation through interactions with Mfn1/2 and
Drp1[11, 21], which are affected by GTPase activity [9]. Therefore, maintaining the balance of mitochondrial fusion/
fission requires an appropriate level of Miro2 GTPase activ-
ity. In our study, we found that the Miro2 GTPase activity in
PS2 D439A mutant cells was significantly lower than that in
PS2 WT cells (P < 0.05) (Fig. 4F). To explore the potential pathological mechanism underly-
ing the effect of the PS2 D439A mutation on mitochondrial
dynamic abnormalities in the pathogenesis of AD, we next
examined whether the PS2 D439A mutation could weaken
the interaction between PS2 and Miro2 and then dysregulate
mitochondrial dynamics. First, we found that overexpres-
sion of PS2 D439A significantly attenuated the interaction
between PS2 and Miro2 (Fig. 5E). PS2 D439A Mutation Adversely Affected
Mitochondrial Morphology and the Dysfunction
of Mitochondrial Fusion and Fission Dynamics We next examined whether the PS2 D439A mutant can
affect the expression of Miro1/2. The PS2 D439A muta-
tion decreased the expression of Miro2 but not Miro1, and 1 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5058 we also observed that the expression of Mfn1, Mfn2 and i
vs. 21.88 ± 1.08 a.u.) (Fig. 6E) and mean length of mito- we also observed that the expression of Mfn1, Mfn2 and
Drp1 decreased significantly (Fig. 6A). Next, by TEM, we
observed that PS2 D439A mutant overexpression caused
mitochondrial morphology changes (Fig. 6B), highlighted
by the significantly increased mean mitochondrial area
(0.43 ± 0.06 µm2 vs. 0.20 ± 0.02 µm2) (Fig. 6C). Sev-
eral swollen mitochondria were observed, whereas the
mean width of mitochondrial cristae (15.19 ± 0.95 a.u. vs. 21.88 ± 1.08 a.u.) (Fig. 6E) and mean length of mito-
chondria (0.59 ± 0.04 µm vs. 0.79 ± 0.06 µm) (Fig. 6D)
were significantly decreased compared with those in cells
expressing PS2 WT. The mean number of mitochondria
per cell in the PS2 D439A mutant group (14.80 ± 3.30)
was less than that in the PS2 WT group (22.80 ± 4.03), but
the difference was not statistically significant (Fig. 6F). we also observed that the expression of Mfn1, Mfn2 and
Drp1 decreased significantly (Fig. 6A). Next, by TEM, we
observed that PS2 D439A mutant overexpression caused
mitochondrial morphology changes (Fig. 6B), highlighted
by the significantly increased mean mitochondrial area
(0.43 ± 0.06 µm2 vs. 0.20 ± 0.02 µm2) (Fig. 6C). Sev-
eral swollen mitochondria were observed, whereas the
mean width of mitochondrial cristae (15.19 ± 0.95 a.u. vs. 21.88 ± 1.08 a.u.) (Fig. 6E) and mean length of mito-
chondria (0.59 ± 0.04 µm vs. 0.79 ± 0.06 µm) (Fig. 6D)
were significantly decreased compared with those in cells
expressing PS2 WT. The mean number of mitochondria
per cell in the PS2 D439A mutant group (14.80 ± 3.30)
was less than that in the PS2 WT group (22.80 ± 4.03), but
the difference was not statistically significant (Fig. 6F). 1 3 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5059 mitochondrial dynamics-related proteins after introduction
of the PS2 D439A mutation. The binding degrees of Miro2
to Mfn1/Mfn2 were decreased in cells overexpressing the
PS2 D439A mutant, while the binding degree of Miro2 to
Drp1 did not change significantly in these cells (Fig. 7C). Fig. PS2 D439A Mutation Affects Mitochondrial Function The dysfunction of mitochondrial fusion/fission dynamics
in defective mitochondria can lead to ultrastructural defects,
which in turn may have deleterious effects on MMP [25]. Therefore, we applied JC-1 staining to detect the changes in
MMP after introduction of the PS2 D439A mutation. The
MMP in PS2 D439A mutant cells was significantly lower
than that in PS2 WT cells (Fig. 8A, B). These results indi-
cated that mitochondrial functions were impaired in PS2
D439A mutant cells. The overall state of the cells and nucleus was also detected
by TEM (Supplementary Fig. 3). The TEM results showed that the decrease in the average
length of mitochondria in PS2 D439A mutant cells indi-
cated an increase in mitochondrial fission, while Western
blotting showed that the expression of total Drp1 protein
was decreased. Because the function of Drp1 in dividing
mitochondria is initiated mainly after its translocation from
the cytoplasm to the OMM, the amount of Drp1 causing
mitochondrial fission is determined by the number of Drp1
proteins in the OMM but not by the number of Drp1 proteins
in the cytoplasm [23]. Therefore, we isolated, extracted, and
purified total mitochondrial protein and compared the dif-
ferences in Drp1 expression between mitochondria and the
cytoplasm. The expression of Drp1 in mitochondria was
higher in PS2 D439A mutant cells than in PS2 WT cells;
thus, mitochondrial fission in PS2 D439A mutant cells may
be increased (Fig. 6G). Mitochondrial dynamics are essential for maintaining
mitochondrial integrity and functions, including regulation
of ROS generation and apoptosis, and excessive mitochon-
drial fission and/or subsequent mitochondrial structural
damage are associated with increased ROS production
[25]. Oxidative stress is considered a primary event in the
progression of AD [26]. Measurement of ROS levels after
introduction of the PS2 D439A mutation showed that ROS
levels were significantly increased (Fig. 8 C, D). In addition,
we estimated MDA, SOD2, GSH-Px, and ATP levels in PS2
WT and PS2 D439A mutant cells. SOD2, GSH-Px, and ATP
levels were decreased, while, MDA levels were increased
markedly in the PS2 D439A mutant cells compared with
PS2 WT cells (Fig. 8E, F, G, H). PS2 D439A Mutation Adversely Affected
Mitochondrial Morphology and the Dysfunction
of Mitochondrial Fusion and Fission Dynamics 4 Expression of GTPase-related genes and level of GTPase
activity in PS2 D439A mutant cells. A qPCR analysis of PS2 mRNA
expression in stably transduced SH-SY5Y cell lines expressing PS2
WT or the PS2 D439A mutant (n = 3; three independent experiments
with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). B, C The pro-
tein levels of PS2 in stably transduced SH-SY5Y cell lines expressing
PS2 WT, PS2 D439A mutant and empty vector control were meas-
ured by Western blotting (n = 3; three independent experiments with
one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). D Verification of the
DEGs related to GTPase regulation identified by RNA-seq in PS2
siRNA-transfected cells by qRT‒PCR in PS2 WT and PS2 D439A
mutant cells (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sample
per experiment; one-way ANOVA). E The GTPase activity in pLV-
PS2 D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells was compared with that in pLV-
PS2 WT cells. GTPase activity was measured at room temperature,
the reaction time was 30 min, and the absorbance was measured at
590 nm (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sample per
experiment; one-way ANOVA). F Comparison of Miro2 GTPase
activity in pLV-PS2 D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells with that in the
pLV-PS2 WT group. GTPase activity was measured at room tempera-
ture for 30 min. Finally, the absorbance was measured at 650 nm. The
catalytic GTPase activity of Miro2 was calculated based on the gener-
ated standard curve (n = 3; three independent experiments with one
sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented as
the means ± SDs; compared with pLV-PS2 WT, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01
◂ i
To further explore whether the changes in Mfn1/2 and
Drp1 expression in PS2 D439A mutant cells were caused
by changes in Miro2 expression, we infected PS2 D439A
mutant SH-SY5Y cells with Ad-Miro2. The levels of Mfn1
and Mfn2 increased significantly with increasing Miro2
expression in Ad-Miro2-infected PS2 D439A mutant cells
compared with Ad-NC-infected PS2 D439A mutant cells,
but there was no significant difference in the change in Drp1
expression between these cells (Fig. 7D). Role of PS2 and Miro2 in Mitochondrial Fusion
and Fission We explored whether PS2 can interact with Mfn1, Mfn2, and
Drp1 by using Co-IP. The results showed that PS2 could not
interact with Mfn1, Mfn2, or Drp1 (Fig. 7A), while Miro2
could interact with Mfn1, Mfn2, and Drp1 (Fig. 7B). Pre-
vious studies found that the changes in Mfn1 and Mfn2
expressions may be regulated by Miro2, which promotes the
fusion of mitochondria through its interactions with Mfn1/2
[11, 24]. We performed another Co-IP assay to explore
the changes in the binding between Miro2 and the above Disrupted mitochondrial dynamics and increased ROS gen-
eration may induce apoptosis, and many signals for cellu-
lar apoptosis are regulated by BCL-2 family proteins and
converge at mitochondria [27]. Next, we examined BCL-2
and BAX expression levels. In SH-SY5Y cells expressing
the PS2 D439A mutant, the BCL-2 level was significantly
decreased compared with that in PS2 WT cells, but no sig-
nificant change was observed in the level of BAX. Quantifi-
cation of protein band densities indicated that in PS2 D439A 1 5060 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 Fig. 5 The binding ability between PS2 and Miro1/2. A, B Deter-
gent lysates from SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 were immunopre-
cipitated (IP) with anti-Miro1, anti-Miro 2, or anti-PS2 antibodies or
control IgG. PS2 coimmunoprecipitated with Miro2 but not Miro1. Miro2 also coimmunoprecipitated with PS2, as detected by Western
blotting using anti-PS2 and anti-Miro2 antibodies. C, D SDS‒PAGE
images of the immunoprecipitates indicating the protein domains
involved in the interaction between PS2 and Miro2. E Detergent
lysates from SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT and PS2 D439A
were immunoprecipitated (IP) with an anti-Miro2 antibody or control
IgG. PS2 coimmunoprecipitated with Miro2, as detected by Western
blotting using anti-PS2 and anti-Miro2 antibodies, in PS2 WT cells,
but in PS2 D439A mutant cells, this interaction was significantly
attenuated involved in the interaction between PS2 and Miro2. E Detergent
lysates from SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT and PS2 D439A
were immunoprecipitated (IP) with an anti-Miro2 antibody or control
IgG. PS2 coimmunoprecipitated with Miro2, as detected by Western
blotting using anti-PS2 and anti-Miro2 antibodies, in PS2 WT cells,
but in PS2 D439A mutant cells, this interaction was significantly
attenuated Fig. 5 The binding ability between PS2 and Miro1/2. A, B Deter-
gent lysates from SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 were immunopre-
cipitated (IP) with anti-Miro1, anti-Miro 2, or anti-PS2 antibodies or
control IgG. PS2 coimmunoprecipitated with Miro2 but not Miro1. Role of PS2 and Miro2 in Mitochondrial Fusion
and Fission Miro2 also coimmunoprecipitated with PS2, as detected by Western
blotting using anti-PS2 and anti-Miro2 antibodies. C, D SDS‒PAGE
images of the immunoprecipitates indicating the protein domains mutant cells, the BCL-2 expression level was less than 50%
of that in PS2 WT cells (Fig. 9A). The mitochondrial apop-
totic pathway regulated by the BCL-2 family of proteins
promotes mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization
(MOMP), which allows the release of proapoptotic factors
such as cytochrome c (Cyt c) from mitochondria into the
cytosol to activate the caspase cascade [28]. Therefore, we
further examined the Cyt c levels in the mitochondrial and
cytosolic fractions in SH-SY5Y cells overexpressing PS2
WT and the PS2 D439A mutant. The Cyt c level was signifi-
cantly increased in the cytosol and decreased in mitochon-
dria in cells expressing the PS2 D439A mutant compared
with cells overexpressing PS2 WT (Fig. 9B). infected with the pLV-PS2 WT or pLV-PS2 D439A mutant
lentivirus to 40 μM Aβ25-35 for 48 h and then determined
the percentage of apoptotic cells. In the AD cell model
induced by Aβ25-35, apoptotic cells were detected by Hoe-
chst 33,342 staining and observed by fluorescence micros-
copy. The percentage of apoptotic cells in the PS2 D439A
mutant group (42.77 ± 4.02%) was significantly higher than
that in the PS2 WT group (22.72 ± 1.82%) in the AD cell
model induced by Aβ25-35 (P < 0.05) (Fig. 9D). 3 Discussion Not all pathogenic PS1/2 FAD mutations are thought to
affect the Aβ42 level or Aβ42/40 ratio [17]. Some elderly
people have obvious Aβ42 deposition but no cognitive
impairment, indicating that the cognitive impairment in AD
may be caused or modulated by factors other than insoluble
forms of Aβ [29]. Therefore, we conducted transcriptome
sequencing analysis on PS2 siRNA-transfected SH-SY5Y
cells to explore the potential role of PS2 in the pathogenesis A CCK8 assay was used to evaluate cell viability after
introduction of the PS2 D439A mutation and showed that
the viability of SH-SY5Y cells after infection with pLV-PS2
D439A was significantly lower than that after infection with
pLV-PS2 WT (Fig. 9C). A previous study found that the PS2
D439A mutation did not change the Aβ42/40 ratio or Aβ42
level [16]. To further clarify the synergistic effects of Aβ
and mitochondrial dysfunction, we exposed SH-SY5Y cells 1 3 3 5061 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 ig. 6 The PS2 D439A mutation affects the balance of mitochondrial
usion and fission and mitochondrial morphology. A The expression
f Miro1, Miro2, Mfn1, Mfn2 and Drp1 was determined by quanti-
ative Western blot analysis (n = 3; three independent experiments
with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). B TEM of mito-
hondria in SH-SY5Y cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT and pLV-
35 mitochondria in pLV-PS2 D439A-transduced cells. E Bar gra
showing the average mitochondrial cristae width determined fro
22 mitochondria in SH-SY5Y cells transduced with pLV-PS2 W
and from 21 mitochondria in pLV-PS2 D439A-transduced cells. Bar graph showing the average number of mitochondria in SH-SY
cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT and pLV-PS2 D439A. Scale ba Fig. 6 The PS2 D439A mutation affects the balance of mitochondrial
fusion and fission and mitochondrial morphology. A The expression
of Miro1, Miro2, Mfn1, Mfn2 and Drp1 was determined by quanti-
tative Western blot analysis (n = 3; three independent experiments
with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). B TEM of mito-
chondria in SH-SY5Y cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT and pLV-
PS2 D439A mutant (n = 3; three independent experiments with one
sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). C Bar graph showing the
average mitochondrial surface area determined from 22 mitochondria
in SH-SY5Y cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT and from 21 mito-
chondria in pLV-PS2 D439A mutant-transduced cells. Discussion B Protein lysates of SH-SY5Y cells with stable
expression of PS2 WT, Mfn1, Mfn2 and Drp1 were immunoprecipi-
tated with an anti-Miro2 antibody, and normal IgG was used as the
control. Miro2 bound to Mfn1, Mfn2, and Drp1. C Protein lysates of
SH-SY5Y cells with stable expression of PS2 D439A, Mfn1, Mfn2
and Drp1 were immunoprecipitated with an anti-Miro2 antibody,
with normal IgG as a control. Overexpression of the PS2D439A
mutant decreased Miro2/Mfn1 and Miro2/Mfn2 protein binding
but not Miro2/Drp1 binding. D PS2 D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells
were infected with Ad-Miro2 and Ad-NC, and protein was extracted
48 h after infection. Compared with Ad-NC, Ad-Miro2 significantly
increased the expression of Miro2, Mfn1 and Mfn2, but there was no
significant difference in the expression of Drp1. The gray values of
the bands were analyzed semiquantitatively, and the protein levels in
the cells infected with Ad-NC were standardized to 1.0 (n = 3; three
independent experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way
ANOVA). The data are presented as the means ± SDs; compared with
the Ad-NC group, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01 Fig. 7 Role of PS2 and Miro2 in mitochondrial fusion and fission. A Protein lysates of SH-SY5Y cells with stable expression of PS2
WT, Mfn1, Mfn2, and Drp1 were immunoprecipitated with an anti-
PS2 antibody, with normal IgG as a control. PS2 could not bind to
Mfn1, Mfn2, or Drp1. B Protein lysates of SH-SY5Y cells with stable
expression of PS2 WT, Mfn1, Mfn2 and Drp1 were immunoprecipi-
tated with an anti-Miro2 antibody, and normal IgG was used as the
control. Miro2 bound to Mfn1, Mfn2, and Drp1. C Protein lysates of
SH-SY5Y cells with stable expression of PS2 D439A, Mfn1, Mfn2
and Drp1 were immunoprecipitated with an anti-Miro2 antibody,
with normal IgG as a control. Overexpression of the PS2D439A mutant decreased Miro2/Mfn1 and Miro2/Mfn2 protein binding
but not Miro2/Drp1 binding. D PS2 D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells
were infected with Ad-Miro2 and Ad-NC, and protein was extracted
48 h after infection. Compared with Ad-NC, Ad-Miro2 significantly
increased the expression of Miro2, Mfn1 and Mfn2, but there was no
significant difference in the expression of Drp1. The gray values of
the bands were analyzed semiquantitatively, and the protein levels in
the cells infected with Ad-NC were standardized to 1.0 (n = 3; three
independent experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way
ANOVA). Discussion D Bar graph
showing the average mitochondrial length determined from 33 mito-
chondria in SH-SY5Y cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT and from 35 mitochondria in pLV-PS2 D439A-transduced cells. E Bar graph
showing the average mitochondrial cristae width determined from
22 mitochondria in SH-SY5Y cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT
and from 21 mitochondria in pLV-PS2 D439A-transduced cells. F
Bar graph showing the average number of mitochondria in SH-SY5Y
cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT and pLV-PS2 D439A. Scale bars,
1 μm in the left panels and 500 nm in the right panels. G Western
blot analysis of Drp1 expression in the mitochondrial and cytosolic
fractions in SH-SY5Y cells overexpressing PS2 WT and the PS2
D439A mutant (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sam-
ple per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented as the
means ± SDs; compared with pLV-PS2 WT, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01 35 mitochondria in pLV-PS2 D439A-transduced cells. E Bar graph
showing the average mitochondrial cristae width determined from
22 mitochondria in SH-SY5Y cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT
and from 21 mitochondria in pLV-PS2 D439A-transduced cells. F
Bar graph showing the average number of mitochondria in SH-SY5Y
cells transduced with pLV-PS2 WT and pLV-PS2 D439A. Scale bars,
1 μm in the left panels and 500 nm in the right panels. G Western
blot analysis of Drp1 expression in the mitochondrial and cytosolic
fractions in SH-SY5Y cells overexpressing PS2 WT and the PS2
D439A mutant (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sam-
ple per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented as the
means ± SDs; compared with pLV-PS2 WT, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01 significantly downregulated gene was ARHGEF5, which
plays a pivotal role in the positive regulation of GTPase
activity according to GO enrichment analysis. of AD. Subsequently, DEGs were analyzed in each KEGG
pathway and a set of genes that regulate GTPase binding
or GTPase activity was identified. Among them, the most 1 3 5062 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 Fig. 7 Role of PS2 and Miro2 in mitochondrial fusion and fission. A Protein lysates of SH-SY5Y cells with stable expression of PS2
WT, Mfn1, Mfn2, and Drp1 were immunoprecipitated with an anti-
PS2 antibody, with normal IgG as a control. PS2 could not bind to
Mfn1, Mfn2, or Drp1. Discussion The data are presented as the means ± SDs; compared with
the Ad-NC group, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01 Recently, diverse alterations in Rho GTPase modula-
tion and mitochondrial functionality have been consistently
reported at early stages of AD, but the underlying mecha-
nisms are poorly understood [11, 30]. GTPase is a key sig-
nal transduction enzyme that links extracellular signals with
neuronal responses required for the construction of neuronal
networks, synaptic function and plasticity [31]. GTPase
activity is also involved in the regulation of mitochondrial
function; GTP hydrolysis is very important for the transloca-
tion of proteins into the mitochondrial matrix, and the pro-
teins entering mitochondria regulate different pathways in
mitochondria [32]. The dynamic processes of fusion and fis-
sion of mitochondria are mediated by several GTPases [33]. Miro1/2 and large GTPases such as Mfn1/2 and Drp1
have been shown to play an essential role in regulating the
balance between fusion and fission to control mitochondrial
morphology, and they also mediate mitochondrial homeosta-
sis and anterograde and retrograde mitochondrial transport
[11, 34]. These proteins contain GTPase domains, and their
functions can be affected by GTPase activity [34]. Small
GTPases, such as Ras homolog (Rho) family proteins, con-
stitute major branches of the Ras superfamily; among them, RhoA, Rac1, and Cdc42 have been extensively studied, and
they can regulate the growth of axons and are closely related
to neuronal development and the molecular neuropathogen-
esis of AD [35]. Rho GTPases are related to almost all basic
cellular processes of brain development, from neurogen-
esis to axon guidance [31]. Rho GTPases are also directly
involved in the regulation of cell morphology, adhesion and
migration [31]. The above biological processes involving
regulation by Rho GTPases were highly consistent with the
top 20 GO biological process terms (Fig. 2; Supplementary
Fig. 1). DO enrichment analysis suggested that the changes
in the expression of the DEGs eventually lead to the occur-
rence and development of cognitive dysfunction and AD
(Fig. 3A), further suggesting that PS2 may participate in the
pathological processes related to cognitive dysfunction and
AD by regulating the expression of GTPase-related genes. Recently, diverse alterations in Rho GTPase modula-
tion and mitochondrial functionality have been consistently
reported at early stages of AD, but the underlying mecha-
nisms are poorly understood [11, 30]. 3 Discussion GTPase is a key sig-
nal transduction enzyme that links extracellular signals with
neuronal responses required for the construction of neuronal
networks, synaptic function and plasticity [31]. GTPase
activity is also involved in the regulation of mitochondrial
function; GTP hydrolysis is very important for the transloca-
tion of proteins into the mitochondrial matrix, and the pro-
teins entering mitochondria regulate different pathways in
mitochondria [32]. The dynamic processes of fusion and fis-
sion of mitochondria are mediated by several GTPases [33]. Miro1/2 and large GTPases such as Mfn1/2 and Drp1
have been shown to play an essential role in regulating the
balance between fusion and fission to control mitochondrial
morphology, and they also mediate mitochondrial homeosta-
sis and anterograde and retrograde mitochondrial transport
[11, 34]. These proteins contain GTPase domains, and their
functions can be affected by GTPase activity [34]. Small
GTPases, such as Ras homolog (Rho) family proteins, con-
stitute major branches of the Ras superfamily; among them, Rho GTPase activity is regulated by three proteins: gua-
nine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs), GTPase-activating
proteins (GAPs) and GDP dissociation inhibitors (GDIs)
[36]. Ras superfamily members and other GTPases contain
a core guanine binding domain, which can bind with high
affinity to GTP and GDP and has the ability to hydrolyze 3 3 5063
Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070
GTP [36]. The activation of Rho GTPases is regulated by
GEFs to exchange nonactivated GDP for activated GTP
[37] I
dditi
th GTP/GDP
l
b
l t d b
interactions between GTPases and other proteins, and the
related binding proteins activate downstream targets by
i
i
th i fl
f GEF
i hibiti
th
l
f
Fig. 8 The PS2 D439A mutation affects mitochondrial function. A Detection of JC-1 signals in SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT
and the PS2 D439A mutant by fluorescence microscopy. B The data
are expressed as the ratio of green fluorescence/red fluorescence
integrated optical density (IOD) values (n = 3; three independent
experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA) C
Measurement of ROS levels in SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT
and the PS2 D439A mutant. D The data are expressed as probe oxida-
tion (%). E Up-regulation of MDA in PS2 D439A mutant cells was
validated by ELISAs. F Down-regulation of SOD2 in PS2 D439A
mutant cells was validated by ELISAs. G Down-regulation of GSH-
Px in PS2 D439A mutant cells was validated by ELISAs. Discussion H Measure-
ment of ATP levels in SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT and the
PS2 D439A mutant. (n = 3; three independent experiments with one
sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented as
the means ± SDs, compared with the pLV-PS2 WT group, *P < 0.05,
**P < 0.01 5063 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 validated by ELISAs. F Down-regulation of SOD2 in PS2 D439A
mutant cells was validated by ELISAs. G Down-regulation of GSH-
Px in PS2 D439A mutant cells was validated by ELISAs. H Measure-
ment of ATP levels in SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT and the
PS2 D439A mutant. (n = 3; three independent experiments with one
sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data are presented as
the means ± SDs, compared with the pLV-PS2 WT group, *P < 0.05,
**P < 0.01 Fig. 8 The PS2 D439A mutation affects mitochondrial function. A Detection of JC-1 signals in SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT
and the PS2 D439A mutant by fluorescence microscopy. B The data
are expressed as the ratio of green fluorescence/red fluorescence
integrated optical density (IOD) values (n = 3; three independent
experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA) C
Measurement of ROS levels in SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT
and the PS2 D439A mutant. D The data are expressed as probe oxida-
tion (%). E Up-regulation of MDA in PS2 D439A mutant cells was Fig. 8 The PS2 D439A mutation affects mitochondrial function. A Detection of JC-1 signals in SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT
and the PS2 D439A mutant by fluorescence microscopy. B The data
are expressed as the ratio of green fluorescence/red fluorescence
integrated optical density (IOD) values (n = 3; three independent
experiments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA) C
Measurement of ROS levels in SH-SY5Y cells expressing PS2 WT
and the PS2 D439A mutant. D The data are expressed as probe oxida-
tion (%). E Up-regulation of MDA in PS2 D439A mutant cells was interactions between GTPases and other proteins, and the
related binding proteins activate downstream targets by
increasing the influence of GEFs or inhibiting the role of GTP [36]. The activation of Rho GTPases is regulated by
GEFs to exchange nonactivated GDP for activated GTP
[37]. In addition, the GTP/GDP cycle can be regulated by 1 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5064 Fig. 9 The PS2 D439A mutation affects cell viability and induces
apoptosis. Discussion A Protein expression levels of BCL-2 and BAX in SH-
SY5Y cells overexpressing PS2 WT and the PS2 D439A mutant. Quantitative analysis of data from three independent experiments was
performed to assess expression levels. B Protein expression levels of
Cyt c in the mitochondrial and cytosolic fractions in SH-SY5Y cells
overexpressing PS2 WT and the PS2 D439A mutant. The ACTIN
and VDAC1 proteins were used as loading controls, and quantita-
tive analysis of data from three independent experiments was per-
formed to assess expression levels. C The viability of SH-SY5Y cells
expressing PS2 WT and the PS2 D439A mutant was measured by a
CCK8 assay (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sample
per experiment; one-way ANOVA). D Apoptotic cells were detected
by staining with the nuclear dye Hoechst 33,342, which reveals frag-
mented or intensely stained nuclei (n = 3; three independent experi-
ments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data
are presented as the means ± SDs; compared with the pLV-PS2 WT
group, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01 Fig. 9 The PS2 D439A mutation affects cell viability and induces
apoptosis. A Protein expression levels of BCL-2 and BAX in SH-
SY5Y cells overexpressing PS2 WT and the PS2 D439A mutant. Quantitative analysis of data from three independent experiments was
performed to assess expression levels. B Protein expression levels of
Cyt c in the mitochondrial and cytosolic fractions in SH-SY5Y cells
overexpressing PS2 WT and the PS2 D439A mutant. The ACTIN
and VDAC1 proteins were used as loading controls, and quantita-
tive analysis of data from three independent experiments was per- formed to assess expression levels. C The viability of SH-SY5Y cells
expressing PS2 WT and the PS2 D439A mutant was measured by a
CCK8 assay (n = 3; three independent experiments with one sample
per experiment; one-way ANOVA). D Apoptotic cells were detected
by staining with the nuclear dye Hoechst 33,342, which reveals frag-
mented or intensely stained nuclei (n = 3; three independent experi-
ments with one sample per experiment; one-way ANOVA). The data
are presented as the means ± SDs; compared with the pLV-PS2 WT
group, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01 important to further explore the relationship between PS2
and the mitochondrial dynamics-related proteins Miro1/2,
Mfn1/2, and Drp1. Whether the PS2 D439A mutation affects
mitochondrial fusion/fission by regulating GTPase activity
deserves further study.i GAPs[38]. 3 Discussion Our study found that after PS2 gene knockdown,
ARHGEF5 expression decreased significantly. ARHGEF5
plays an important role in the regulation of endogenous
Rho GTPases [38], and aberrant regulation of Rho GTPases
plays a key role in neurodegenerative diseases such as AD
[39]. Here, we found that GTPase activity was significantly
decreased in PS2 siRNA-transfected SH-SY5Y cells. GAPs[38]. Our study found that after PS2 gene knockdown,
ARHGEF5 expression decreased significantly. ARHGEF5
plays an important role in the regulation of endogenous
Rho GTPases [38], and aberrant regulation of Rho GTPases
plays a key role in neurodegenerative diseases such as AD
[39]. Here, we found that GTPase activity was significantly
decreased in PS2 siRNA-transfected SH-SY5Y cells. Then, we verified the expression of genes related to the
regulation of GTPase activity in PS2 D439A mutant cells. The expression of ARHGEF5 in PS2 D439A mutant cells
was lower than that in PS2 WT cells, and the overall GTPase
activity in the mutant cells was also significantly decreased. Previous studies found that large GTPases such as Mfn1/2
and Drp1 can hydrolyze GTP and regulate the GTP/GDP
cycle independently of separate GEFs or GAPs [41]. How-
ever, members of the small GTPase family usually need
assistance from GEFs or GAPs in releasing tightly bound
GDP or enhancing GTPase activity [42]. Vimar, encoding
an atypical GEF, can function as a GEF of Miro, in which
Miro can mediate the increase in mitochondrial fission in the Extensive contradictory studies have indicated that mito-
chondrial dysfunction exists independently of Aβ and poten-
tially lies upstream of Aβ deposition; the authors of these
studies proposed a primary mitochondrial cascade hypoth-
esis that assumes that mitochondrial pathology hierarchi-
cally supersedes Aβ pathology [6]. Indeed, mitochondrial
dysfunction was proven to be one of the earliest and most
prominent features of AD [40]. The dysfunction of mito-
chondrial dynamics and the aberrant regulation of GTPase
activity all contribute to AD pathogenesis [5, 39]. Based
on the primary mitochondrial cascade hypothesis, it is very 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5065 an increase in the oxidative stress level, which finally leads
to the degeneration and death of neurons in the hippocampus
and cortex [47]. These pathological changes are indeed the
pathological characteristics of AD [34]. Discussion In the pyramidal
neurons of the CA1 region in 8-week-old Mfn2 KO mice,
swollen mitochondria with an increased volume and area and
fragmented mitochondrial cristae were observed, and many
mitochondria also exhibited vacuolization [47]. Defective
mitochondrial cristae (narrow in width and few in number)
were observed in PS2-KO cells but not in PS1-KO cells
[48]. In our experiments, the TEM results showed that the
average length of mitochondria was significantly decreased,
suggesting a trend toward increased mitochondrial fission. context of vimar deletion [42]. In addition to the significant
decrease in the expression of ARHGEF5, Miro2 GTPase
activity was significantly reduced in PS2 D439A mutant
cells. The Rho GTPase activity of Miro is closely related
to the regulation of mitochondrial fusion/fission and other
physiological functions [43]. Therefore, the PS2 D439A
mutation may lead to a decrease in Miro2 GTPase activity
by regulating the decrease in ARHGEF5 expression, which
may then affect the balance of mitochondrial dynamics. f
To verify this hypothesis, we next explored the poten-
tial functional relationship between PS2 and Miro1/2 and
found that PS2 can interact with Miro2 but not Miro1. The results of pulldown experiments indicated that GST-
PS2(271–361) can interact specifically with His-Miro2(220–592),
a region containing a GTPase domain. Collectively, our
data demonstrate that PS2 interacts directly with Miro2
in vitro and in cultured cells. Miro presumably interacts
with Mfn1/2 or other unknown factors to influence mito-
chondrial morphology [21]. Other research found that Miro2
can promote mitochondrial fusion and increase the mean
mitochondrial circularity and area, effects controlled by its
GTPase domains [43]. The function of Miro in regulating
mitochondrial morphology is conserved in plants [43] and
has also been observed in Drosophila [44]. The molecular
mechanism of Miro regulates mitochondrial morphology is
unclear, overexpression of Miro can lead to mitochondrial
aggregation excessively or fusion phenotype [21]. In this
study, Co-IP experiments indicated that the PS2 D439A
mutation decreased the interaction between PS2 and Miro2. Moreover, we found that the PS2 D439A mutation decreased
the expression of Miro2. A previous study found that the
protein level of Miro in the brains of FAD PS1 mutation
patients was decreased, suggesting that Miro may be related
to the progression of AD [45]; however, this research did
not identify a mechanism linking Miro2 and AD progres-
sion. Discussion Previous studies have found that Miro overexpression
promotes mitochondrial fusion by increasing the expres-
sion of the mitochondrial fusion proteins Mfn1/2 [24] and
inhibiting the expression of the mitochondrial fission protein
Drp1 [11]. The expression levels of Drp1 and Mfn1/2 in
fibroblasts and the brains of AD patients were decreased
[46]. Our study further found that the expression of Mfn1,
Mfn2, and Drp1 was decreased after introduction of the PS2
D439A mutation. i
Drp1 in mammals is mainly expressed in the cytoplasm,
and mitochondrial division depends on the number of Drp1
proteins recruited to the OMM by fission1 and other proteins
[49]. Therefore, we further found that the expression of Drp1
in mitochondria was higher in PS2 D439A mutant cells than
in PS2 WT cells. Therefore, the balance of mitochondrial
fusion/fission in PS2 D439A mutant cells tends to be skewed
toward fission. Miro2 and Drp1 play antagonistic roles in the
regulation of mitochondrial fusion/fission [21]. Members of
a family of proteins containing large GTPase domains play
critical roles in enhancing mitochondrial fission (e.g., Drp1)
or promoting mitochondrial fusion (e.g., Mfn1 and Mfn2)
[50]. A previous study in a mammalian model found physi-
cal interactions between Mfn1/Mfn2 and Miro1/Miro2 and
observed the strongest interaction between Mfn2 and Miro2
[51]. Miro increases mitochondrial size by inhibiting Drp1
expression under normal cellular conditions; therefore, Miro
can mediate mitochondrial fission/fusion dynamics by inter-
acting with other GTPases, such as Mfn1/Mfn2 and Drp1
[11, 52]. Whether the Miro protein can regulate mitochondrial
fusion/fission through its interactions with Mfn1/2 in human
cells has not been studied. In our study, we found that PS2
failed to bind to Mfn1, Mfn2, or Drp1 in PS2 WT cells,
while Miro2 interacted with Mfn1, Mfn2, and Drp1. Moreo-
ver, the binding degrees of Miro2 to Mfn1 and Mfn2 in PS2
D439A mutant cells were lower than those in PS2 WT cells. The above results indicated that in addition to regulating
mitochondrial fusion/fission by affecting the expression of
Mfn1/2 and Drp1, Miro2 may also mediate mitochondrial
dynamics by regulating its interaction with Mfn1 or Mfn2,
and these results are consistent with previous studies [53]. Miro protein expression was reduced in an AD Dros-
ophila model compared to normal Drosophila. Moreover,
the overexpression of Miro in normal Drosophila signifi-
cantly increased Mfn mRNA expression, and overexpres-
sion of Miro in the Drosophila AD model increased the
average length of mitochondria [24]. Discussion Therefore, downregulation of BCL-2 expression would
be expected to promote the release of Cyt c from mitochon-
dria into the cytosol. Indeed, our results showed that the
Cyt c level was significantly increased in the cytosol and
was decreased in mitochondria in PS2 D439A mutant cells
compared with PS2 WT cells. This observation explains the
decrease in the viability of PS2 D439A mutant cells. Moreo-
ver, the release of Cyt C from mitochondria occurs before
caspase activation [66]. i
The maintenance of normal mitochondrial function
depends on an intact mitochondrial structure, and increased
production of mitochondrial ROS, impaired mitochondrial
function, and apoptosis are related to an abnormal internal
structure of mitochondria and an imbalance in the fission/
fusion machinery [55, 56]. In PS2 D439A mutant cells, the
MMP was significantly lower than that in PS2 WT cells,
which indicated that mitochondrial function was impaired
in PS2 D439A mutant cells. Mitochondrial fission or fusion
deficiency may reduce the MMP [25]. Maintenance of
the membrane potential of the inner mitochondrial mem-
brane (IMM) is necessary for mitochondrial fusion [56]. In
PS2−/− MEFs, the MMP was significantly decreased, indi-
cating that the deletion of PS2 significantly increased the
proportion of nonfunctional mitochondria, which suggests
that the deletion of PS2 is directly associated with deleteri-
ous mitochondrial changes [57]. In AD, mitochondrial dysfunction has been considered
the main cause of ROS production; reciprocally, mitochon-
dria are the main target of oxidative damage [40]. In our
study, the level of ROS was significantly increased in PS2
D439A mutant cells. More than 90% of ROS are generated
in mitochondria, and excessive mitochondrial fragmen-
tation causes increased ROS production [58]. Oxidative
stress further leads to glycolysis inhibition and mitochon-
drial dysfunction [59]. In PS2 D439A mutant cells, the
decrease in mitochondrial length and the structural damage
to mitochondrial cristae indicated excessive fragmentation
of mitochondria, which may be the main source of ROS gen-
eration. Oxidative stress continually reduces GSH-Px and
SOD2 levels, while increasing MDA levels [26, 60]. SOD2,
existing in mitochondrial spaces, is known to be one of the
most important endogenous antioxidants [60]. We found that
PS2 D439A mutant cells had higher MDA levels but lower The amyloid cascade hypothesis does not easily account
for various parameters associated with AD [67], while the
primary mitochondrial cascade hypothesis assumes mito-
chondrial pathology hierarchically supersedes Aβ pathology
[6]. Discussion After infection of PS2
D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells with Ad-Miro2 adenovirus,
the increased expression of Miro2 resulted in increases in Whether the Miro protein can regulate mitochondrial
fusion/fission through its interactions with Mfn1/2 in human
cells has not been studied. In our study, we found that PS2
failed to bind to Mfn1, Mfn2, or Drp1 in PS2 WT cells,
while Miro2 interacted with Mfn1, Mfn2, and Drp1. Moreo-
ver, the binding degrees of Miro2 to Mfn1 and Mfn2 in PS2
D439A mutant cells were lower than those in PS2 WT cells. The above results indicated that in addition to regulating
mitochondrial fusion/fission by affecting the expression of
Mfn1/2 and Drp1, Miro2 may also mediate mitochondrial
dynamics by regulating its interaction with Mfn1 or Mfn2,
and these results are consistent with previous studies [53]. Miro1/2, Mfn1/2, and Drp1 are involved in the mainte-
nance of mitochondrial morphology, size and number and
physiological function by regulating mitochondrial fusion
and fission dynamics [11, 34]. The increase in the average
mitochondrial area may be caused by the increase in swollen
mitochondria in PS2 D439A mutant cells (Fig. 6B). Recent
studies have shown that Mfn2 knockout (KO) mice exhibit
significant dysfunction of mitochondrial fusion/fission
dynamics due to a decrease in Mfn2 expression, followed by Miro protein expression was reduced in an AD Dros-
ophila model compared to normal Drosophila. Moreover,
the overexpression of Miro in normal Drosophila signifi-
cantly increased Mfn mRNA expression, and overexpres-
sion of Miro in the Drosophila AD model increased the
average length of mitochondria [24]. After infection of PS2
D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells with Ad-Miro2 adenovirus,
the increased expression of Miro2 resulted in increases in 1 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5066 SOD2 and GSH-Px levels than PS2 WT cells (Fig. 8E, F, G),
suggesting the presence of an imbalance in oxidant related
parameters after introduction of the PS2 D439A mutation. In AD, increased ROS production can lead to the accumula-
tion of Aβ protein, eventually causing neuronal death [61]. Increased production of free radicals and lipid peroxida-
tion preceded the formation of Aβ plaques in an AD animal
model [62]. Mitochondrial Aβ production is regulated by
mitochondrial biogenesis, suggesting that mitochondrial
dysfunction is an upstream event in the pathological progres-
sion of AD [63]. In addition, the ATP level was decreased
markedly in the PS2 D439A mutant cells (Fig. 8H). Discussion Mito-
chondrial dysfunction was correlated with the concentration
of intracellular ATP and the energy balance of the cell [64]. the Mfn1 and Mfn2 levels but not the Drp1 level compared
to those in the Ad-NC group. These results verified that the
expression level of Miro2 can affect the dynamics of mito-
chondrial fusion/fission. Other studies have indicated that
the dynamic balance of mitochondrial fission and fusion is
shifted toward fission, which may result in the presence of
dysfunctional mitochondria in damaged neurons [50]. Ultrastructural morphometric analysis revealed that mito-
chondria have significant structural damage, such as frag-
mented cristae or nearly total loss of the inner structure,
which probably contributes to mitochondrial dysfunction
and increased ROS levels in the AD brain [53]. In the AD
brain, the mitochondrial size was also observed to be sig-
nificantly increased and the mitochondrial number decreased
[53]. In AD neurons, a significantly reduced mitochondrial
length but increased width were observed, and the overall
mitochondrial size was significantly increased [54]. Our
TEM results in PS2 D439A mutant SH-SY5Y cells con-
firmed the above observations. gy
[
]
Mitochondrial oxidative stress further promotes the
opening of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore
(MPTP), which triggers the release of Cyt c from mitochon-
dria into the cytosol, leading to a decrease in the MMP and
to ROS burst, thus forming a vicious cycle and further aggra-
vating mitochondrial damage and cell apoptosis [60, 63]. Key molecules in the apoptotic pathway include the BCL-2
family and caspase cysteine protease family proteins, and the
overexpression of the FAD-associated mutant PS2 N141I
was found to increase the sensitivity of neurons to apoptotic
stimulation compared with PS2 WT overexpression; in addi-
tion, neurons expressing the PS2 N141I mutant exhibited a
reduced BCL-2 expression level [65]. Our results showed
that the PS2 D439A mutant significantly decreased the
BCL-2 protein level compared with that in PS2 WT cells. The BCL-2/BAX ratio was decreased in PS2 D439A mutant
cells, indicating that the PS2 D439A mutation affects the
balance of apoptosis regulation. BCL-2 and mitochondrial
fission and fusion proteins may form a regulatory network
whose function is to sense the health status of cells [62]. Antiapoptotic BCL-2 family members such as BCL-2 pro-
mote cell survival by preventing BAX from multimerizing
on the mitochondrial surface to allow the release of Cyt c
[66]. Discussion The debate about the origin of mitochondrial changes
in AD continues, and some argue that Aβ induces mito-
chondrial dysfunction in AD [6]. Membrane-associated 3 1 3 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5067 hypothesis” of AD pathogenesis. With these insights, poten-
tial therapeutic strategies for AD can be developed. oxidative stress, mitochondrial alterations and apoptosis are
present during Aβ-mediated neuronal degeneration during
the AD process [68]. Hence, the possibility of a feedback
loop between mitochondrial pathology and Aβ pathology
cannot be eliminated. A previous study found that the PS2
D439A mutation did not change the Aβ42/40 ratio or Aβ42
level [16]. We found that the percentage of apoptotic cells
in the PS2 D439A mutant group was significantly higher
than that in the PS2 WT group in the AD cell model induced
by Aβ25-35. Although mitochondrial dysfunction precedes
Aβ formation, once Aβ penetrates the cell membrane after
aggregation, it further exacerbates the decline in mitochon-
drial function [53]. Previous research results indicated that
the increased production of Aβ and the interaction of Aβ
with Drp1 are crucial factors in mitochondrial fragmentation
and the imbalance in mitochondrial dynamics in patients
with AD [69]. Therefore, increased Aβ deposition may fur-
ther lead to mitochondrial dysfunction and then increase
apoptosis in PS2 D439A-mutant SH-SY5Y cells. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplemen-
tary material available at https://doi.org/10.1007/s12035-023-03858-y. Acknowledgements We thank the Henan Provincial Key Laboratory of
Kidney Disease and Immunology, Henan Provincial People’s Hospital,
Zhengzhou University People’s Hospital, Zhengzhou University for
technical assistance. Author Contribution C-hG performed experiments, analysed data,
and finished the manuscript. J-kS performed experiments, analysed
data, provided experiments suggestions. Z-yS and F-yW were provided
experiments suggestions. M-rX involved in review and revision of the
manuscript. D-dG, R-hS, and WL were involved in analysis and inter-
pretation of data. J-wZ programmed the whole work and modified the
final manuscript. All authors contributed to the article and approved
the submitted version. Funding This work was supported by National Natural Science Foun-
dation of China (Grants 81671068, 81873727, 82171196), Key Sci-
ence and Technology Program of Henan Province, China (Grants
201701020, 20210231008), and China International Medical Founda-
tion (CIMF-Z-2016–20-1801). Competing Interests The authors declare no competing interests. Competing Interests The authors declare no competing interests. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attri-
bution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adapta-
tion, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long
as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source,
provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes
were made. The images or other third party material in this article are
included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated
otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in
the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not
permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will
need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a
copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Discussion Taken together, our results indicate that alterations in
the interaction between PS2 and Miro2, decreased Miro2
expression and GTPase activity and dysfunction of mito-
chondrial fission/fusion dynamics in the setting of the PS2
D439A mutation may have a profound impact on the patho-
genesis of AD (Supplementary Fig. 4). However, the extrap-
olation of the present results of a single in vitro cell-level
experiment to the pathogenesis of AD appears premature. Therefore, further studies are needed at the animal level to
verify the pathogenic role of the imbalance in mitochondrial
dynamics caused by the PS2 D439A mutation in the patho-
genesis of AD. Data Availability The data that support the findings of this study are
openly available in NCBI SRA (BioProject ID: PRJNA963881): https://
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/bioproject/PRJNA963881. Further inquiries
can be directed to the corresponding author. Conclusions In summary, the results from RNA-sequencing analysis sug-
gest that PS2 gene knockdown may participate in the patho-
genesis of AD by affecting the regulation of GTPase activ-
ity. Additionally, our study found for the first time that PS2
can bind to Miro2, which is a key player in mitochondrial
dynamics in AD, and the PS2 D439A mutation weakens
the interaction between PS2 and Miro2 and decreases the
expression of Miro2, Mfn1, and Mfn2 and the GTPase activ-
ity of Miro2, while the number of Drp1 molecules localized
on the OMM increases, which leads to dysfunction of mito-
chondrial fusion and fission dynamics and changes in mito-
chondrial morphology. These changes result in increased
oxidative stress and apoptosis, which are closely related to
the pathogenesis of AD. Thus, our findings imply that the
PS2 D439A mutation may be a major trigger for the imbal-
ance of mitochondrial fusion/fission dynamics, offering new
molecular insights into the “primary mitochondrial cascade Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate Not applicable. Consent for Publication All authors have read and approve the manu-
script and consent to its publication. References Mol Cell 83(6):819–823. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2023.02.030 p
g
25. Grel H, Woznica D, Ratajczak K, Kalwarczyk E, Anchimowicz
J, Switlik W, Olejnik P, Zielonka P et al (2023) Mitochondrial
dynamics in neurodegenerative diseases: unraveling the role of
fusion and fission processes. Int J Mol Sci 24(17):13033. https://
doi.org/10.3390/ijms241713033i 9. Zinsmaier KE (2021) Mitochondrial Miro GTPases coordinate
mitochondrial and peroxisomal dynamics. Small GTPases 12(5–
6):372–398. https://doi.org/10.1080/21541248.2020.1843957 26. Rummel NG, Butterfield DA (2021) Altered metabolism in Alz-
heimer disease brain: role of oxidative stress. Antioxid Redox
Signal. https://doi.org/10.1089/ars.2021.0177 10. König T, Nolte H, Aaltonen MJ, Tatsuta T, Krols M, Stroh T,
Langer T, McBride HM (2021) MIROs and DRP1 drive mito-
chondrial-derived vesicle biogenesis and promote quality con-
trol. Nat Cell Biol 23(12):1271–1286. https://doi.org/10.1038/
s41556-021-00798-4 27. Ma K, Chen G, Li W, Kepp O, Zhu Y, Chen Q (2020) Mitophagy,
mitochondrial homeostasis, and cell fate. Front Cell Dev Biol
8:467. https://doi.org/10.3389/fcell.2020.00467 11. Panchal K, Tiwari AK (2021) Miro (Mitochondrial Rho GTPase),
a key player of mitochondrial axonal transport and mitochondrial
dynamics in neurodegenerative diseases. Mitochondrion 56:118–
135. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mito.2020.10.005 28. Peña-Blanco A, García-Sáez AJ (2018) Bax, Bak and beyond -
mitochondrial performance in apoptosis. Febs J 285(3):416–431. https://doi.org/10.1111/febs.14186 p
g
j
12. Kraus F, Roy K, Pucadyil TJ, Ryan MT (2021) Function and
regulation of the divisome for mitochondrial fission. Nature
590(7844):57–66. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03214-x 29. Iacono D, Resnick SM, O’Brien R, Zonderman AB, An Y, Plet-
nikova O, Rudow G, Crain B et al (2014) Mild cognitive impair-
ment and asymptomatic Alzheimer disease subjects: equivalent
β-amyloid and tau loads with divergent cognitive outcomes. J
Neuropathol Exp Neurol 73(4):295–304. https://doi.org/10.1097/
nen.0000000000000052 13. Dumanchin C, Czech C, Campion D, Cuif MH, Poyot T, Martin
C, Charbonnier F, Goud B et al (1999) Presenilins interact with
Rab11, a small GTPase involved in the regulation of vesicular
transport. Hum Mol Genet 8(7):1263–1269. https://doi.org/10.
1093/hmg/8.7.1263 30. Bolognin S, Lorenzetto E, Diana G, Buffelli M (2014) The
potential role of rho GTPases in Alzheimer’s disease pathogen-
esis. Mol Neurobiol 50(2):406–422. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s12035-014-8637-5 14. Borin M, Saraceno C, Catania M, Lorenzetto E, Pontelli V, Pater-
lini A, Fostinelli S, Avesani A et al (2018) Rac1 activation links
tau hyperphosphorylation and Aβ dysmetabolism in Alzheimer’s
disease. Acta Neuropathol Commun 6(1):61. https://doi.org/10.
1186/s40478-018-0567-4 31. Zamboni V, Jones R, Umbach A, Ammoni A, Passafaro M, Hirsch
E (2018) Rho GTPases in intellectual disability: from genetics to
therapeutic opportunities. Int J Mol Sci 19(6):1821. https://doi.
org/10.3390/ijms19061821 15. References 1. Deaton CA, Johnson GVW (2020) Presenilin 1 regulates mem-
brane homeostatic pathways that are dysregulated in Alzheimer’s
disease. J Alzheimers Dis 77(3):961–977. https://doi.org/10.3233/
jad-200598 2. Essayan-Perez S, Südhof TC (2023) Neuronal γ-secretase regu-
lates lipid metabolism, linking cholesterol to synaptic dysfunction 1 3 1 3 5068 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 in Alzheimer’s disease. Neuron S0896–6273(23):00513–00515. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2023.07.005 in Alzheimer’s disease. Neuron S0896–6273(23):00513–00515. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2023.07.005 in Alzheimer’s disease. Neuron S0896–6273(23):00513–00515. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2023.07.005 19. Love MI, Huber W, Anders S (2014) Moderated estimation of fold
change and dispersion for RNA-seq data with DESeq2. Genome
Biol 15(12):550. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13059-014-0550-8 19. Love MI, Huber W, Anders S (2014) Moderated estimation of fold
change and dispersion for RNA-seq data with DESeq2. Genome
Biol 15(12):550. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13059-014-0550-8 3. Escamilla-Ayala A, Wouters R, Sannerud R, Annaert W (2020)
Contribution of the presenilins in the cell biology, structure and
function of γ-secretase. Semin Cell Dev Biol 105:12–26. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.semcdb.2020.02.005 20. Annaert WG, Esselens C, Baert V, Boeve C, Snellings G, Cupers
P, Craessaerts K, De Strooper B (2001) Interaction with telen-
cephalin and the amyloid precursor protein predicts a ring struc-
ture for presenilins. Neuron 32(4):579–589. https://doi.org/10.
1016/s0896-6273(01)00512-8 4. Jiang H, Jayadev S, Lardelli M, Newman M (2018) A review of
the familial Alzheimer’s disease locus PRESENILIN 2 and its
relationship to PRESENILIN 1. J Alzheimers Dis 66:1323–1339. https://doi.org/10.3233/jad-180656 21. Lee KS, Lu B (2014) The myriad roles of Miro in the nervous
system: axonal transport of mitochondria and beyond. Front Cell
Neurosci 8:330. https://doi.org/10.3389/fncel.2014.00330 5. Tang J, Oliveros A, Jang MH (2019) Dysfunctional mitochondrial
bioenergetics and synaptic degeneration in Alzheimer disease. Int
Neurourol J 23(Suppl 1):S5-10. https://doi.org/10.5213/inj.19380
36.018 22. Wolfe MS (2021) Targeting γ-secretase for familial Alzheimer’s
disease. Med Chem Res 30(7):1321–1327. https://doi.org/10.
1007/s00044-021-02744-3 6. Swerdlow RH (2018) Mitochondria and mitochondrial cascades in
Alzheimer’s disease. J Alzheimers Dis 62(3):1403–1416. https://
doi.org/10.3233/jad-170585 23. Ji WK, Hatch AL, Merrill RA, Strack S, Higgs HN (2015) Actin
filaments target the oligomeric maturation of the dynamin GTPase
Drp1 to mitochondrial fission sites. Elife 4:e11553. https://doi.org/
10.7554/eLife.11553 7. Pires M, Rego AC (2023) Apoe4 and Alzheimer’s disease patho-
genesis-mitochondrial deregulation and targeted therapeutic strat-
egies. Int J Mol Sci 24(1):778. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms240107
78 24. Panchal K, Tiwari AK (2020) Miro, a Rho GTPase genetically
interacts with Alzheimer’s disease-associated genes (Tau, Aβ(42)
and Appl) in Drosophila melanogaster. Biol Open 9(9):bio049569. https://doi.org/10.1242/bio.049569 8. Pucadyil TJ, Chipuk JE, Liu Y, O’Neill L, Chen Q (2023) The
multifaceted roles of mitochondria. References Cell Death Differ
27(9):2620–2634. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41418-020-0527-y 39. Niftullayev S, Lamarche-Vane N (2019) Regulators of Rho
GTPases in the nervous system: molecular implication in axon
guidance and neurological disorders. Int J Mol Sci 20(6):1497. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms20061497 56. Misrani A, Tabassum S, Yang L (2021) Mitochondrial dysfunction
and oxidative stress in Alzheimer’s disease. Front Aging Neurosci
13:617588–617588. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnagi.2021.617588 p
g
j
40. Swerdlow RH (2020) The mitochondrial hypothesis: Dysfunction,
bioenergetic defects, and the metabolic link to Alzheimer’s disease. Int Rev Neurobiol 154:207–233. https://doi.org/10.1016/bs.irn.2020.
01.008 57. Behbahani H, Shabalina IG, Wiehager B, Concha H, Hultenby K,
Petrovic N, Nedergaard J, Winblad B et al (2006) Differential role
of presenilin-1 and -2 on mitochondrial membrane potential and
oxygen consumption in mouse embryonic fibroblasts. J Neurosci
Res 84(4):891–902. https://doi.org/10.1002/jnr.20990 41. Chandhok G, Lazarou M, Neumann B (2018) Structure, function,
and regulation of mitofusin-2 in health and disease. Biol Rev Camb
Philos Soc 93(2):933–949. https://doi.org/10.1111/brv.12378 58. Boguszewska K, Szewczuk M, Kaźmierczak-Barańska J, Karwowski
BT (2020) The similarities between human mitochondria and bac-
teria in the context of structure, genome, and base excision repair
system. Molecules 25(12):2857. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules2
5122857 p
g
42. Ding L, Lei Y, Han Y, Li Y, Ji X, Liu L (2016) Vimar is a novel
regulator of mitochondrial fission through miro. PLoS Genet
12(10):e1006359. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1006359 p
g
j
pg
43. White RR, Lin C, Leaves I (2020) Miro2 tethers the ER to mitochon-
dria to promote mitochondrial fusion in tobacco leaf epidermal cells. Commun Biol 3(1):161. https://doi.org/10.1038/s42003-020-0872-x 59. Johri A (2021) Disentangling mitochondria in Alzheimer’s disease. Int J Mol Sci 22(21):11520. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms222111520 p
g
44. Mattedi F, Lloyd-Morris E, Hirth F, Vagnoni A (2023) Optogenetic
cleavage of the Miro GTPase reveals the direct consequences of
real-time loss of function in Drosophila. PLoS Biol 21(8):e3002273. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3002273 60. Kowalczyk P, Sulejczak D, Kleczkowska P, Bukowska-Ośko I,
Kucia M, Popiel M, Wietrak E, Kramkowski K et al (2021) Mito-
chondrial oxidative stress-a causative factor and therapeutic target in
many diseases. Int J Mol Sci 22(24):13384. https://doi.org/10.3390/
ijms222413384 45. Sepulveda-Falla D, Barrera-Ocampo A, Hagel C, Korwitz A,
Vinueza-Veloz MF, Zhou K, Schonewille M, Zhou H, et al. (2014)
Familial Alzheimer’s disease-associated presenilin-1 alters cerebel-
lar activity and calcium homeostasis. J Clin Invest 124(4):1552–
1567. https://doi.org/10.1172/jci66407 61. Cheignon C, Tomas M, Bonnefont-Rousselot D, Faller P, Hureau
C, Collin F (2018) Oxidative stress and the amyloid beta peptide
in Alzheimer’s disease. Redox Biol 14:450–464. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.redox.2017.10.014 62. References Lleó A, Blesa R, Gendre J, Castellví M, Pastor P, Queralt R, Oliva
R (2001) A novel presenilin 2 gene mutation (D439A) in a patient
with early-onset Alzheimer’s disease. Neurology 57(10):1926–
1928. https://doi.org/10.1212/wnl.57.10.1926 32. Sepuri NB, Schülke N, Pain D (1998) GTP hydrolysis is essential
for protein import into the mitochondrial matrix. J Biol Chem
273(3):1420–1424. https://doi.org/10.1074/jbc.273.3.1420 33. Murata D, Arai K, Iijima M, Sesaki H (2020) Mitochondrial divi-
sion, fusion and degradation. J Biochem 167(3):233–241. https://
doi.org/10.1093/jb/mvz106 16. Walker ES, Martinez M, Brunkan AL, Goate A (2005) Presenilin
2 familial Alzheimer’s disease mutations result in partial loss of
function and dramatic changes in Abeta 42/40 ratios. J Neurochem
92(2):294–301. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-4159.2004.02858.x 34. Flannery PJ, Trushina E (2019) Mitochondrial dynamics and
transport in Alzheimer’s disease. Mol Cell Neurosci 98:109–120. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mcn.2019.06.009 17. Hsu S, Pimenova AA, Hayes K, Villa JA, Rosene MJ, Jere M,
Goate AM, Karch CM (2020) Systematic validation of variants
of unknown significance in APP, PSEN1 and PSEN2. Neurobiol
Dis 139:104817. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nbd.2020.104817 35. Rajaei S, Karima S (2020) Conformational change and GTPase
activity of human tubulin: a comparative study on Alzheimer’s
disease and healthy brain. J Neurochem 155(2):207–224. https://
doi.org/10.1111/jnc.15009 18. Kim D, Langmead B, Salzberg SL (2015) HISAT: a fast spliced
aligner with low memory requirements. Nat Methods 12(4):357–
360. https://doi.org/10.1038/nmeth.3317 36. Osaka N, Hirota Y, Ito D, Ikeda Y, Kamata R, Fujii Y, Chirasani
VR, Campbell SL et al (2021) Divergent mechanisms activating
RAS and small GTPases through post-translational modification. 1 3 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 5069 Front Mol Biosci 8:707439. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmolb.2021.
707439 53. Ashleigh T, Swerdlow RH, Beal MF (2023) The role of mitochon-
drial dysfunction in Alzheimer’s disease pathogenesis. Alzheimers
Dement 19(1):333–342. https://doi.org/10.1002/alz.12683 37. Mosaddeghzadeh N, Ahmadian MR (2021) The RHO fam-
ily GTPases: mechanisms of regulation and signaling. Cells
10(7):1831. https://doi.org/10.3390/cells10071831 p
g
54. Wang X, Su B, Siedlak SL, Moreira PI, Fujioka H, Wang Y,
Casadesus G, Zhu X (2008) Amyloid-beta overproduction causes
abnormal mitochondrial dynamics via differential modulation of
mitochondrial fission/fusion proteins. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
105(49):19318–19323. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0804871105 p
g
38. Bernadzki KM, Daszczuk P, Rojek KO, Pęziński M, Gawor M,
Pradhan BS, de Cicco T, Bijata M et al (2020) Arhgef5 Binds
α-dystrobrevin 1 and regulates neuromuscular junction integrity. Front Mol Neurosci 13:104. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnmol.2020.
00104 55. Peña-Blanco A, Haschka MD, Jenner A, Zuleger T, Proikas-
Cezanne T, Villunger A, García-Sáez AJ (2020) Drp1 modulates
mitochondrial stress responses to mitotic arrest. References Cao K, Riley JS, Heilig R, Montes-Gómez AE, Vringer E, Berthenet
K, Cloix C, Elmasry Y et al (2022) Mitochondrial dynamics regulate
genome stability via control of caspase-dependent DNA damage. Dev Cell 57(10):1211-1225.e1216. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.
2022.03.019 g
j
46. Chen H, Chen F, Jiang Y, Zhang L, Hu G, Sun F, Zhang M, Ji Y
et al (2022) A review of ApoE4 interference targeting mitophagy
molecular pathways for Alzheimer’s disease. Front Aging Neurosci
14:881239. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnagi.2022.881239 p
g
g
47. Jiang S, Nandy P, Wang W, Ma X, Hsia J, Wang C, Wang Z, Niu M
et al (2018) Mfn2 ablation causes an oxidative stress response and
eventual neuronal death in the hippocampus and cortex. Mol Neu-
rodegener 13(1):5–5. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13024-018-0238-8 63. Li X, Chen M, Yang Z, Wang W, Lin H, Xu S (2018) Selenoprotein
S silencing triggers mouse hepatoma cells apoptosis and necrosis
involving in intracellular calcium imbalance and ROS-mPTP-ATP. Biochim Biophys Acta Gen Subj 1862(10):2113–2123. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.bbagen.2018.07.005 48. Contino S, Porporato PE, Bird M, Marinangeli C, Opsomer R, Son-
veaux P, Bontemps F, Dewachter I et al (2017) Presenilin 2-depend-
ent maintenance of mitochondrial oxidative capacity and morphol-
ogy. Front Physiol 8:796–796. https://doi.org/10.3389/fphys.2017.
00796 64. Lozhkin A, Vendrov AE, Ramos-Mondragón R, Canugovi C, Ste-
venson MD, Herron TJ, Hummel SL, Figueroa CA et al (2022)
Mitochondrial oxidative stress contributes to diastolic dysfunction
through impaired mitochondrial dynamics. Redox Biol 57:102474. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.redox.2022.102474 49. Colpman P, Dasgupta A, Archer SL (2023) The role of mitochon-
drial dynamics and mitotic fission in regulating the cell cycle in can-
cer and pulmonary arterial hypertension: implications for dynamin-
related protein 1 and mitofusin2 in hyperproliferative diseases. Cells
12(14):1897. https://doi.org/10.3390/cells12141897 65. Araki W, Yuasa K, Takeda S, Takeda K, Shirotani K, Takahashi
K, Tabira T (2001) Pro-apoptotic effect of presenilin 2 (PS2) over-
expression is associated with down-regulation of Bcl-2 in cultured
neurons. J Neurochem 79(6):1161–1168. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.
1471-4159.2001.00638.x 50. Gowda P, Reddy PH, Kumar S (2022) Deregulated mitochondrial
microRNAs in Alzheimer’s disease: focus on synapse and mitochon-
dria. Ageing Res Rev 73:101529. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arr.2021.
101529 66. Wolf P, Schoeniger A (1869) Edlich F (2022) Pro-apoptotic com-
plexes of BAX and BAK on the outer mitochondrial membrane. Biochim Biophys Acta Mol Cell Res 10:119317. https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.bbamcr.2022.119317 51. Misko A, Jiang S, Wegorzewska I, Milbrandt J, Baloh RH (2010)
Mitofusin 2 is necessary for transport of axonal mitochondria and
interacts with the Miro/Milton complex. J Neurosci 30(12):4232–
4240. https://doi.org/10.1523/jneurosci.6248-09.2010 67. 68. Cadonic C, Sabbir MG, Albensi BC (2016) Mechanisms of mito-
chondrial dysfunction in Alzheimer’s disease. Mol Neurobiol
53(9):6078–6090. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12035-015-9515-5 ( )
p
g
69. Reddy PH, Oliver DM (2019) Amyloid beta and phosphorylated tau-
induced defective autophagy and mitophagy in Alzheimer’s disease.
Cells 8(5):488. https://doi.org/10.3390/cells8050488 References Chakravorty A, Jetto CT, Manjithaya R (2019) Dysfunctional mito-
chondria and mitophagy as drivers of Alzheimer’s disease patho-
genesis. Front Aging Neurosci 11:311–311. https://doi.org/10.3389/
fnagi.2019.00311 52. Kay L, Pienaar IS, Cooray R, Black G, Soundararajan M (2018)
Understanding miro GTPases: implications in the treatment of neu-
rodegenerative disorders. Mol Neurobiol 55(9):7352–7365. https://
doi.org/10.1007/s12035-018-0927-x 1 3 5070 Molecular Neurobiology (2024) 61:5047–5070 Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. 1 3 3
|
https://openalex.org/W3172642099
|
https://ejim.springeropen.com/counter/pdf/10.4103/ejim.ejim_4_19
|
English
| null |
Association of new obesity indices; visceral adiposity index and body adiposity index, with metabolic syndrome parameters in obese patients with or without type 2 diabetes mellitus
|
The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine/The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine
| 2,019
|
cc-by
| 6,213
|
620
Original article 620
Original article © 2020 The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow Background Obesity is the cornerstone of metabolic syndrome (MetS); it is not possible to use
BMI to differentiate between lean mass and fat mass. We aimed to investigate, for
the first time, the possible association of new obesity indices; visceral adiposity
index (VAI) and body adiposity index (BAI), with parameters of MetS in Egyptian
obese patients. Correspondence to Nearmeen M. Rashad, MD,
Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of
Medicine, Zagazig University, 44519, Zagazig,
Egypt. Tel: +20 122 424 8642; e-mails:
nrashad78@yahoo.com, n.rashad@zu.edu.eg This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under the terms
of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0
License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work
non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new
creations are licensed under the identical terms. Keywords:
b d
di
i Keywords:
body adiposity index, BMI, metabolic syndrome, obesity, visceral adiposity index Keywords:
body adiposity index, BMI, metabolic syndrome, obesity, visceral adiposity index Egypt J Intern Med 31:620–628
© 2020 The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine
1110-7782 apnea, and respiratory problems, as well as some
types of cancers [9,10]. Patients and methods Received 3 January 2019
Accepted 6 February 2019
Published: 18 August 2020 Received 3 January 2019
Accepted 6 February 2019
Published: 18 August 2020 This was a case–control study that included unrelated 150 obese patients and 50
healthy controls. Obese patients were then subdivided into two subgroups,
nondiabetic patients (n=85) and 65 patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. We
measured the anthropometric measures; BMI, waist/hip ratio, waist/height ratio,
BAI, and VAI. The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine
2019, 31:620–628 The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine
2019, 31:620–628 Results Among obese patients, we found significant positive correlations between
parameters of MetS and obesity indices. Among obesity indiced, the highly
significant positive correlations were found between VAI and parameters of
MetS. After adjusting for the traditional risk factors, logistic regression analysis
test found that the VAI value was the best predictor of type 2 diabetes mellitus in
comparison with BMI and BAI. Receiver operating characteristic curve was used to
assess the power of obesity indices; the sensitivity and the specificity of BMI were
94.7 and 99.9%, for VAI, they were 74.4 and 99.9%, and, for BAI, they were 83.3
and 58%, respectively. Association of new obesity indices; visceral adiposity index and
body adiposity index, with metabolic syndrome parameters in
obese patients with or without type 2 diabetes mellitus
Nearmeen M Rashad George Emad Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of
Medicine, Zagazig University, Zagazig, Egypt Department of Internal Medicine, Faculty of
Medicine, Zagazig University, Zagazig, Egypt Conclusion BMI is still the most powerful diagnostic tool for obesity. Although, in certain
conditions, where there are limitations of using BMI, we can use other obesity
indices, VAI and BAI could be used to discriminate cardiovascular risk among
obese patients. Introduction The metabolic syndrome (MetS) is a set of interrelated
risk factors including hypertension, dyslipidemia,
obesity, and high blood glucose [1,2]. Obesity is a
key phenotype leading to atherogenic and diabetogenic
profiles [3]. Insulin resistance, together with central/
abdominal or visceral obesity, have been proposed as
key risk factors in the development of the MetS [4–6]. BMI is the widely used measure of obesity. However,
BMI is unable to differentiate between lean mass and
fat mass, and hence it is limited by differences in body
adiposity for a given BMI across age, sex, and ethnicity
[11]. Waist circumference (WC), waist-to-hip ratio
(WHR), and waist-to-height ratio (WHtR) have been
developed and studied. WC has been proposed to be
the
best
among
these
measures,
with
excellent
correlation
with
abdominal
imaging
and
high
association with cardiovascular disease risk factors,
especially diabetes [12,13]. However, WC does not
account for differences in height, thereby, potentially, Obesity is actually an epidemic problem in the world; it
has become truly a global problem affecting countries
rich and poor. An estimated 500 million adults
worldwide are obese, and 1.5 billion are overweight
or obese [7]. Particularly the prevalence of obesity in
Egypt has increased at an alarming rate during the last
three decades, affecting 22% of adult male individuals
and 48% of adult female individuals [8]. It is associated
with several comorbidities including hypertension,
dyslipidemia, type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM),
coronary heart disease, stroke, osteoarthritis, sleep DOI: 10.4103/ejim.ejim_4_19 Association of new obesity indices Rashad and Emad 621 overevaluating and underevaluating risk for tall and
short individuals, respectively [14]. Consequently,
several
researchers
independently
proposed
the
WHtR as an alternative to WC. from diabetes and endocrinology outpatient clinic of
Internal Medicine Department of Zagazig University
Hospitals and 50 healthy lean controls, who were
matched to cases by age, sex, and ethnic origin. Obese patients were stratified into two subgroups:
nondiabetic patients (n=85) and T2DM patients
(n=65), The diagnosis of T2DM was according to
the American Diabetes Association criteria reported in
2017: fasting plasma glucose levels of more than or
equal to 126 mg/dl (7.0 mmol/l) or 2-h postprandial
plasma glucose levels of more than or equal to 200 mg/
dl (11.1 mmol/l). All patients were subjected to
thorough history taking and full clinical assessment
including blood pressure, WC (a level midway between
the
lowest
rib
and
the
iliac
crest),
and
hip
circumference
(widest diameter
over
the
greater
trochanters). Introduction Anthropometric
variables
including
BMI were calculated as weight (kg)/height (m2),
WHR as WC (cm)/hip circumference (cm), and
WHtR was calculated as waist (cm)/height (cm). Moreover, VAI in female individuals was calculated
as follows:
WC
36:58þ 1:89 × BMI! ð
Þ
×
TG
0:81
×
1:52
HDLC
. It
normally equals 1 in healthy nonobese patients with
normal adipose distribution and normal TG and HDL
levels [15]. Finally, BAI, which is approximately equal
to the percentage of body fat for adult men and women
of
differing
ethnicities,
was
calculated
as
HipcircuferanceðcmÞ
heightðmÞ1:5
18 [16]. Notably, the body adiposity index (BAI) was proposed
in 2011 [15]. This is a composite index based on
hip circumference and height. The authors suggested
that this index showed a high correlation with body
fat
measured
using
dual-energy
radiography
absorptiometry. They added that this correlation was
higher than the correlation between BMI and body fat,
measured
using
dual-energy
radiography
absorptiometry among both African–American and
Mexican–American men and women [15]. Thus,
BAI
overcomes
the
limitation
of
BMI
in
differentiating between fat and lean mass. Thus,
they concluded that the BAI is a useful predictor of
obesity and suggested that it involves more simple
measurements because weight is not needed [15]. In addition, visceral adiposity index (VAI) is a
mathematical model that uses both anthropometric
(BMI and WC) and functional [triglycerides (TG)
and
high-density
lipoprotein
(HDL)
cholesterol]
simple parameters [16]. This index, which could be
considered a simple surrogate marker of visceral
adipose dysfunction, showed a strong association with
both the rate of peripheral glucose utilization during the
euglycemic–hyperinsulinemic clamp and with visceral
adipose tissue measured with MRI. Interestingly, it
showed a strong independent association with both
cardiovascular and cerebrovascular events [14] and
showed better predictive power for incident diabetes
events than its individual components (WC, BMI,
TG, and HDL cholesterol) [17]. Introduction The MetS was diagnosed according to International
Diabetes Federation criteriaas WC more than or equal
to 80 cm in women and more than or equal to 94 cm in
men and the presence of at least two of the following
characteristics: (a) fasting blood glucose more than or
equal to 100 mg/dl or previously diagnosed impaired
fasting glucose; (b) blood pressure more than or equal
to 130/85 mmHg or treated for hypertension; (c) TG
more than or equal to 150 mg/dl; (d) HDL cholesterol
less than 40 mg/dl in men or less than 50 mg/dl in
women or taking treatment for low HDL [17]. On the basis of the previous facts, obesity is the
cornerstone
of
the
MetS;
BMI
is
unable
to
differentiate between lean mass and fat mass. Further
research is warranted, and, to address this need, we have
focused on various anthropometric measures including
the recently proposed BAI and VAI, which have not
been extensively analyzed and compared with BMI. Therefore, the purpose of this current novel study is
to clarify the possible relationships of traditional obesity
indices(WC,BMI,andWHtR)andnewobesityindices
(BAI and VAI) with parameters of MetS in Egyptian
obese women. Patients with cancer, stroke, or liver, kidney, thyroid,
and cardiovascular or any active inflammatory diseases
were excluded from this study. None of the participants
had history of abdominal surgery that could have an
impact on abdominal fat distribution, as well as
receiving
medications
that
affect
endocrine
parameters, glucose metabolism, and/or for weight
reduction or participating in a dietary or exercise
program during the preceding 6 months or the
immediately
preceding
month
(anti-inflammatory
drugs). There was no concurrent minor infection
reported during the study or during the month Patients This study included 200 unrelated patients. One
hundred fifty obese patients (BMI>30) recruited The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine, Vol. 31 No. 4, October-December 2019 622 We considered P to be significant at less than 0.05 with
a 95% confidence interval (CI). preceding the study. The ethical committee of Faculty
of Medicine, Zagazig University, approved our study
protocol, and all participants signed the written
informed consent. Immunochemical assays Fasting serum insulin (FSI) concentrations were
measured
using
high-sensitivity
linked
immunosorbent assay kit provided by (Biosource
Europe S.A., Nivelles, Belgium). Homeostasis model
assessments of insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) were
calculated as follows: [FSI (mU/ml)×FPG (mg/dl)/
405], and β-cell function (HOMA-β) was calculated
as {20×[FSI (lU/ml)]/[FPG (mmol/l)−3.5]} [19]. Blood sampling Blood samples were drawn from all patients after an
overnight fast and divided into three portions: 1 ml of
whole blood was collected into evacuated tubes
containing
EDTA
for
glycated
hemoglobin
(HbA1c), and 1 ml of whole blood was collected
into evacuated tubes containing potassium oxalate
and sodium fluoride (2 : 1) for fasting blood plasma
glucose (FPG). Serum were separated immediately
from the remaining part of the sample and stored at
−20°C until analysis. Anthropometric and biochemical characteristics of the
study patients are summarized in Table 1. Obese
patients had significantly higher values of systolic
blood
pressure,
diastolic
blood
pressure,
fasting
blood glucose, HbA1c values, FSI, HOMA-IR,
total cholesterol, LDL, and TG levels compared
with lean controls. Moreover, all obesity indices and
parameters (WC, BMI, WHR, WHtR, BAI, and
VAI) were significantly higher in obese women
compared with lean patients. On the contrary, obese
patients
had
significantly
lower
levels
of
HDL
cholesterol
and
HOMA-B
than
healthy
lean
individuals (P<0.001). Biochemical analysis We determined FPG levels using the glucose oxidase
method (Spinreact, Girona, Spain). Total cholesterol,
HDL cholesterol, and TG levels were measured by
routine enzymatic methods (Spinreac). The low-
density
lipoprotein
(LDL)
cholesterol
level
was
calculated using the Friedewald formula [18]. Table 1 Anthropometric and biochemical characteristics of
the studied groups
Lean healthy
control (N=50)
Obese
patients
(N=150)
P value
Age (years)
45.58±11.4
44.64±8.2
0.15
Sex (male/female)
15/35
42/108
0.93
BMI (kg/m2)
22.2±3.182
35.01±7.21
<0.001*
Waist
circumference (cm)
91.4±14.71
111.01±13.8
<0.001*
Waist/hip ratio
0.94±0.013
1.25±0.176
<0.001*
Waist/height ratio
0.54±0.09
0.64±0.089
<0.001*
Body adiposity
index
22.97±8.7
35.86±15.4
<0.001*
Visceral adiposity
index
0.89±0.14
5.92.±1.34
<0.001*
Systolic blood
pressure (mmHg)
110.2±4.79
129.5±16.2
<0.001*
Diastolic blood
pressure (mmHg)
75.4±4.21
84.43±9.13
<0.001*
Total cholesterol
(mg/dl)
176.1±7.85
221.2±75.2
<0.001*
Triglycerides (mg/
dl)
129.5±12.3
189.9±34.6
<0.001*
LDL cholesterol
(mg/dl)
94.8±0.98
139.3±73.9
<0.001*
HDL cholesterol
(mg/dl)
48.4±4.41
46.6±8.95
0.178
Fasting blood
glucose (mg/dl)
86.8±5.08
147.9±55.9
<0.001*
Fasting serum
insulin (μU/ml)
7.4±1.82
13.18±6.37
<0.001*
HbA1c (%)
5.36±0.41
7.26±1.76
<0.001*
HOMA-IR
1.57±0.40
5.8±4.14
<0.001*
HOMA-β
118.6±37.1
84.8±27.9
<0.001*
Data are presented as mean±SD. HbA1c, glycated hemoglobin;
HDL, high-density lipoprotein; HOMA-IR, homeostasis model
assessments of insulin resistance; HOMA-β, an index of β-cell
function; LDL, low-density lipoprotein. *P value less than 0.05
when compared with control group. Table 1 Anthropometric and biochemical characteristics of
the studied groups General characteristics of obese patients stratified by
fasting blood plasma glucose as diabetic and
nondiabetic obese patients Table 2 Laboratory and anthropometric parameters in
nondiabetic obese and type 2 diabetes mellitus obese
patients’ groups We found statistically significant higher values of
obesity indices BMI, WC, WHR, WHtR VAI, and
BAI in obese T2DM patients than in nondiabetic
obese patients (P<0.001). Moreover, obese T2DM
patients had statistically significant higher values of
systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood pressure, TC,
LDL, FPG, FSI, HbA1c, and HOMA-IR. On the
contrary, obese T2DM patients had significantly lower
levels of HOMA-β than nondiabetic obese patients
(P<0.001). Correlations between anthropometric measures
and parameters of metabolic syndrome in obese
patients Our results showed significant positive correlations
between parameters of MetS, including WC, systolic
and diastolic blood pressure, low HDL as well as TG,
and all anthropometric measures in obese cases (BMI,
WHR, WHtR, BAI, and VAI). Interestingly, among
obesity indices, the highest positive correlation was
found
between
VAI
and
parameters
of
MetS
(P<0.001) (Tables 2 and 3). Multiple stepwise linear regression analyses in obese
patients to assess the main independent parameters
associated with visceral adiposity index
Stepwise linear regression analysis test revealed that
VAI was independently correlated with TGs, HDL,
fasting blood glucose, HOMA-IR, and HOMA-B
(P<0.001) (Table 4). Multiple stepwise linear regression analyses in obese
patients to assess the main independent parameters
associated with visceral adiposity index Stepwise linear regression analysis test revealed that
VAI was independently correlated with TGs, HDL,
fasting blood glucose, HOMA-IR, and HOMA-B
(P<0.001) (Table 4). Multiple stepwise linear regression analyses in obese
patients to assess the main independent parameters
associated with body adiposity index Statistical analysis Statistical analyses were performed using the statistical
package for the social sciences for Windows (version
17.0; SPSS Inc., Chicago, Illinois, USA). Data were
expressed using descriptive statistics (mean±SD) and
were analyzed using the t test. Pearson’s correlation
coefficient was used to assess the association between
obesity indices and other studied metabolic parameters
in obese women. Receiver operating characteristic
(ROC)
analysis
was
performed
to
assess
the
potential accuracy of BMI, VAI, and BAI, the area
under the curve (AUC), and the cutoff values for
diagnosis
of
T2DM
among
obese
patients. A
stepwise
multiple
linear
regression
analysis
was
performed to detect the main predictors of VAI and
BAI values in the obese group. Logistic regression
analysis
was performed
to assess
the
predictive
powers of VAI as well as BAI in the diagnosis
of MetS in obese patients with and without T2DM. Association of new obesity indices Rashad and Emad 623 Table 2 Laboratory and anthropometric parameters in
nondiabetic obese and type 2 diabetes mellitus obese
patients’ groups
Obese
nondiabetic
patients (N=85)
Obese diabetic
patients (N=65)
P value
Age (years)
43.3±5.8
42.5±8.02
0.49
Sex (male/
female)
22/48
20/60
0.49
BMI (kg/m2)
35.3±8.01
33.78±6.25
0.009
Waist
circumference
(cm)
113.2±15.35
103.8±10.22
<0.001*
Waist/hip ratio
1.02±0.15
1.079±0.19
0.050
Waist/height
ratio
0.67±0.09
0.6±0.065
<0.001*
Body adiposity
index
26.6±4.4
43.9±11.4
<0.001*
Visceral
adiposity index
6.98±1.28
8.74±0.96
<0.001*
Systolic blood
pressure
(mmHg)
122.1±4.77
158.12±8.39
<0.001*
Diastolic blood
pressure
(mmHg)
78.2±5.32
90.8±7.46
<0.001*
Total cholesterol
(mg/dl)
222.9±95.96
256.7±41.55
<0.001*
Triglycerides
(mg/dl)
193.12±46.7
197.9±17.4
<0.359
LDL cholesterol
(mg/dl)
159.9±93.7
174.6±42.11
<0.001*
HDL cholesterol
(mg/dl)
37.4±8.94
35.9±9.02
0.324
Fasting blood
glucose (mg/dl)
84.3±12.37
196.1±9.24
<0.001*
Fasting serum
insulin (μIU/ml)
7.78±2.98
17.9±4.46
<0.001*
HbA1c (%)
5.07±0.47
9.23±1.3
<0.001*
HOMA-IR
2.9±0.45
5.9±0.67
<0.001*
HOMA-β
97.5±10.03
61.4±12.07
<0.001*
Data are presented as mean±SD. HbA1c, glycated hemoglobin;
HDL, high-density lipoprotein; HOMA-IR, homeostasis model
assessments of insulin resistance; HOMA-β, an index of β-cell
functions; LDL, low-density lipoprotein. *P value less than 0.05
when compared with obese nondiabetic patients’ group. General characteristics of obese patients stratified by
fasting blood plasma glucose as diabetic and
nondiabetic obese patients General characteristics of obese patients stratified by
fasting blood plasma glucose as diabetic and
nondiabetic obese patients Multiple stepwise linear regression analyses in obese
patients to assess the main independent parameters
associated with body adiposity index Data are presented as mean±SD. HbA1c, glycated hemoglobin;
HDL, high-density lipoprotein; HOMA-IR, homeostasis model
assessments of insulin resistance; HOMA-β, an index of β-cell
functions; LDL, low-density lipoprotein. *P value less than 0.05
when compared with obese nondiabetic patients’ group. Stepwise linear regression analysis test found that BAI
was independently correlated with fasting blood
glucose, BMI, total cholesterol TGs, and diastolic
blood pressure (P<0.001) (Table 5). Accuracy of visceral adiposity index and BMI for
discriminating type 2 diabetes risk among obese
patients by receiver operating characteristic analysis
We further investigated the potential diagnostic value
of VAI and BMI by ROC curves, which are presented
in Fig. 1. In obese patients, when we discriminate type
2 diabetes among nondiabetic patients, the cutoff
values of BMI and VAI were 28.82 and 7.31, and
the AUC values were 0.958 (95% CI=0.931–0.985)
and 0.952 (95% CI=0.923–0.980), respectively. In
addition, the sensitivity and the specificity of BMI
were 94.7 and 99.9% and those of VAI were 74.4 and
99.9%, respectively. Thus VAI as well as BMI could be
useful diagnostic tests to discriminate T2DM from
nondiabetic obese patients. Logistic regression analysis evaluating the association
of BMI, visceral adiposity index, and body adiposity
index with type 2 diabetes mellitus among obese
patients After adjusting for the traditional risk factors, logistic
regression analysis test was carried out to evaluate the
predictor of T2DM among obese patients. VAI,
BAI,
and
BMI
were
statistically
significant
predictors
of
T2DM
among
obese
patients
(P<0.001) (Table 6), whereas the odds ratio of
VAI (odds ratio=3.498, 95% CI=1.987–6.158) was
higher than that of BAI and BMI (odds ratio=1.149,
95%
CI=1.085–1.218;
odds
ratio=0.791,
95%
CI=0.728–0.860, respectively). 624
The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine, Vol. 31 No. Multiple stepwise linear regression analyses in obese
patients to assess the main independent parameters
associated with body adiposity index 4, October-December 2019 Table 3 Pearson’s correlation coefficient between anthropometric indices and parameters of metabolic syndrome among obese
patients
BMI (kg/m2)
Waist/hip ratio
Waist/height ratio
BAI
VAI
Waist circumference (cm)
r
0.747
0.121
0.983
0.125
0.228
P
<0.001*
0.139
<0.001*
0.128
<0.001*
Systolic blood pressure (mmHg)
r
0.255
0.125
0.235
0.527
0.326
P
<0.01*
<0.062
0.004
<0.001*
0.062
Diastolic blood pressure (mmHg)
r
0.140
0.122
0.103
0.139
0.471
P
0.089
0.138
0.212
<0.091
<0.001*
Triglycerides (mg/dl)
r
0.833
0.389
0.425
0.230
0.804
P
<0.001*
<0.001*
<0.001*
<0.01*
<0.001*
HDL cholesterol (mg/dl)
r
−0.383
−0.356
−0.020
−0.383
−0.592
P
<0.001*
<0.001*
0.811
<0.001*
<0.001*
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
r
0.355
0.362
0.144
0.539
0.243
P
<0.001*
<0.001*
<0.080
<0.001*
<0.01*
BAI, body adiposity index; HDL, high-density lipoprotein; VAI, visceral adiposity index. *P value less than 0.05. Multiple stepwise linear regression analyses in obese
patients to assess the main independent parameters
associated with body adiposity index s correlation coefficient between anthropometric indices and parameters of metabolic syndrome among obese Table 3 Pearson’s correlation coefficient between anthropometric indices and parameters of metabolic sy
patients tween anthropometric indices and parameters of metabolic syndrome among obese Table 4 Multiple stepwise linear regression analysis testing the influence of the main independent variables against visceral
adiposity index (dependent variable) in obese women
Model
Unstandardized
coefficients
Standardized coefficients
t
P value
95% CI
B
SE
B
Lower bound
Upper bound
1
Constant
0.985
0.459
2.148
<0.05*
0.079
1.892
Triglycerides (mg/dl)
0.039
0.002
0.804
16.417
<0.001*
0.034
0.044
2
Constant
5.067
0.669
7.578
<0.001*
3.745
6.388
Triglycerides (mg/dl)
0.033
0.002
0.678
15.052
<0.001*
0.028
0.037
HDL cholesterol (mg/dl)
−0.062
0.008
0.339
−7.523
<0.001*
−0.079
−0.046
3
Constant
3.335
0.617
5.402
<0.001*
2.115
4.555
Triglycerides (mg/dl)
0.034
0.002
0.708
18.298
<0.001*
0.031
0.038
HDL cholesterol (mg/dl)
−0.056
0.007
0.306
−7.89
<0.001*
−0.071
−0.042−
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
0.008
0.001
0.267
7.408
<0.001*
0.006
0.010
4
Constant
3.236
0.591
5.477
<0.001*
2.068
4.404
Triglycerides (mg/dl)
0.033
0.002
0.685
18.267
<0.001*
0.030
0.037
HDL cholesterol (mg/dl)
−0.060
0.007
−0.326
−8.717
<0.001*
−0.074
−0.046
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
0.016
0.002
0.539
6.804
<0.001*
0.011
0.021
HOMA-IR
0.122−
0.032
0.306
3.818
<0.001*
0.185
−0.059
5
Constant
1.859
0.872
2.133
<0.05*
0.137
3.582
Triglycerides (mg/dl)
0.033
0.002
0.691
18.600
<0.001*
0.030
0.037
HDL cholesterol (mg/dl)
−0.058
0.007
−0.315
−8.426
<0.001*
−0.072
−0.044
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
0.021
0.003
0.713
6.303
<0.001*
0.014
0.028
HOMA-IR
0.155
0.035
0.388
4.405
<0.001*
0.224
0.085
HOMA-B
−0.008
0.004
−0.128
−2.127
<0.05*
−0.001
0.015
CI, confidence interval; HDL, high-density lipoprotein; HOMA-IR, homeostasis model assessments of insulin resistance. *P value less than
0.05. Multiple stepwise linear regression analyses in obese
patients to assess the main independent parameters
associated with body adiposity index tepwise linear regression analysis testing the influence of the main independent variables against visceral
ependent variable) in obese women Table 4 Multiple stepwise linear regression analysis testing the influence of the main independent variables a
adiposity index (dependent variable) in obese women Association of new obesity indices Rashad and Emad
625 625 Table 5 Multiple stepwise linear regression analysis testing the influence of the main independent variables against body
adiposity index (dependent variable) in obese women
Model
Unstandardized
coefficients
Standardized coefficients
t
P value
95% CI
β
SE
B
Lower bound
Upper bound
1
Constant
14.483
2.981
4.858
<0.001*
8.592
20.374
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
0.146
0.019
0.539
7.749
<0.001*
0.109
0.183
2
Constant
3.573
5.272
0.678
0.499
13.993
6.847
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
0.173
0.019
0.640
9.058
<0.001*
0.136
0.211
BMI (kg/m2)
0.376
0.093
0.287
4.062
<0.001*
0.193
0.559
3
Constant
4.224
5.205
0.812
0.418
14.511
6.063
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
0.176
0.019
0.651
9.326
<0.001*
0.139
0.214
BMI (kg/m2)
0.837
0.221
0.639
3.793
<0.001*
0.401
1.273
Total cholesterol (mg/dl)
0.076
0.033
0.379
2.295
<0.05*
0142
0.011
4
Constant
25.692
7.310
3.514
<0.01*
40.141
11.242
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
0.132
0.021
0.486
6.211
<0.001*
0.090
0.174
BMI (kg/m2)
0.749
0.211
0.572
3.545
<0.01*
0.331
1.166
Total cholesterol (mg/dl)
0.203
0.045
1.009
4.531
<0.001*
0.292
0.115
Triglycerides (mg/dl)
0.313
0.078
0.706
3.994
<0.001*
0.158
0.467
5
Constant
51.112
12.157
4.204
<0.001*
75.143
27.082
Fasting blood glucose (mg/dl)
0.086
0.027
0.317
3.135
<0.01*
0.032
0.140
BMI (kg/m2)
0.648
0.211
0.495
3.074
<0.01*
0.231
1.064
Total cholesterol (mg/dl)
0.209
0.044
1.037
4.741
<0.001*
0.296
0.122
Triglycerides (mg/dl)
0.351
0.078
0.793
4.491
<0.001*
0.197
0.506
Diastolic blood pressure (mmHg)
0.356
0.137
0.215
2.589
<0.05*
0.084
0.627
CI, confidence interval. *P value less than 0.05. Multiple stepwise linear regression analyses in obese
patients to assess the main independent parameters
associated with body adiposity index Table 5 Multiple stepwise linear regression analysis testing the influence of the main independent variables against body
adiposity index (dependent variable) in obese women near regression analysis testing the influence of the main independent variables against body
variable) in obese women Table 5 Multiple stepwise linear regression analysis testing the influence of the main independent variables
adiposity index (dependent variable) in obese women Table 6 Logistic regression analysis of body adiposity index, visceral adiposity index and BMI in type 2 diabetic versus
nondiabetic obese women
β
SE
t
P value
Odds ratio
95% CI
Lower
Upper
Constant
−6.363
1.812
12.331
<0.001*
0.002
VAI
1.252
0.289
18.835
<0.001*
3.498
1.987
6.158
BAI
0.139
0.029
22.282
<0.001*
1.149
1.085
1.218
BMI
−0.234
0.042
30.566
<0.001*
0.791
0.728
0.860
BAI, body adiposity index; CI, confidence interval; VAI, visceral adiposity index. *P value less than 0.05. regression analysis of body adiposity index, visceral adiposity index and BMI in type 2 diabetic versus
e women Table 6 Logistic regression analysis of body adiposity index, visceral adiposity index and BMI in type 2 diab
nondiabetic obese women Accuracy of body adiposity index and BMI for
discriminating type 2 diabetes risk among obese
patients by receiver operating characteristic analysis Discussion ROC curve for both BMI and VAI in discriminating obese women with
T2DM from those without diabetes. ROC, receiver operating char-
acteristic; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; VAI, visceral adiposity
index. In the current study, we found a significant positive
correlation between BAI and all parameters of MetS,
except WC and diastolic blood pressure among obese
cases. first time, the possible association of new obesity
indices, BAI and VAI, as well as traditional obesity
indices (WC, BMI, WHtR) and parameters of MetS
in Egyptian obese patients. Similar to our results, Bergman et al. [16] reported that
BAI is a good tool to estimate adiposity in the
Caucasian population. Furthermore, they suggested
that it is more practical and easier than other
complex mechanical methods. The results presented herein are innovative, as this
study performs a robust evaluation of new obesity
indices VAI and BAI as diagnostic tests of MetS. Noteworthy, our results confirmed that VAI and
BAI
values
were
significantly
higher
in
obese
patients compared with the lean group. Moreover, in
the T2DM group, the values of VAI and BAI were
higher compared with the nondiabetic group. As regards traditional obesity indices (WC, BMI, and
WHR), our results revealed that, among them, BMI
had the best positive correlation with MetS parameters. Nonetheless, the new obesity indices had the best
positive correlation with MetS parameters. As regards correlation of anthropometric measures
with the parameters of MetS, we found significant
positive correlations between parameters of MetS,
including WC, systolic and diastolic blood pressure,
low HDL, as well as TG, and all anthropometric
measures in obese cases (BMI, WHR, WHtR, BAI,
and VAI). Interestingly, among obesity indices, the
highest positive correlation was found between VAI
and parameters of MetS. Gharipour et al. [21] suggested that WC could be
considered as a useful anthropometric assessment for
prediction of T2DM and MetS. These results were in
accordance with two prospective studies showing that
WC and WHtR performed equally well in their ability
to predict T2DM in Pima Indians [22–24]. In this study, we attempted to point out the association
between MetS and WHtR and to compare between
WHtR and BMI. Our results revealed that BMI had a
strong positive correlation with parameters of MetS
compared with WHtR. In agreement with our finding, Amato et al. Discussion Obesity plays a key role in the pathophysiology of all
MetS parameters and can be considered as an
independent predictor of MetS [6]. Pradeep et al. [20] suggested that central obesity as an indicator of
body fat can be easily and cost-effectively estimated by
measuring BMI and WC, which might discriminate
MetS from non-MetS status. We further investigated the potential diagnostic
value of BAI and BMI using ROC curves, which
are presented in Fig. 2. In obese patients, when we
discriminate type 2 diabetes among nondiabetic
patients, the cutoff values of BMI and BAI were
28.82 and 27.58 and the AUC values were 0.958
(95%
CI=0.931–0.985)
and
0.770
(95%
CI=0.703–0.837),
respectively. In
addition,
the
sensitivity and the specificity of BMI were 94.7 and
99.9% and those of BAI were 83.3 and 58%,
respectively. BMI was not a good indicator of MetS risk, particularly
when it is the only indicator, because it is not able to
differentiate between adipose and muscle tissue. Taken
together, we investigated, in the present study, for the 626
The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine, Vol. 31 No. 4, October-December 2019 626 Figure 1
ROC curve for both BMI and VAI in discriminating obese women with
T2DM from those without diabetes. ROC, receiver operating char-
acteristic; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; VAI, visceral adiposity
index. Figure 2
ROC curve for both BMI and BAI in discriminating obese women with
T2DM from those without diabetes. BAI, body adiposity index; ROC,
receiver operating characteristic; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus. Figure 1
ROC curve for both BMI and VAI in discriminating obese women with
T2DM from those without diabetes. ROC, receiver operating char-
acteristic; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; VAI, visceral adiposity
index. Figure 2
ROC curve for both BMI and BAI in discriminating obese women with
T2DM from those without diabetes. BAI, body adiposity index; ROC,
receiver operating characteristic; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus. Figure 2
ROC curve for both BMI and BAI in discriminating obese women with
T2DM from those without diabetes. BAI, body adiposity index; ROC,
receiver operating characteristic; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus. Figure 2 Figure 1 Figure 1 g ROC curve for both BMI and BAI in discriminating obese women with
T2DM from those without diabetes. BAI, body adiposity index; ROC,
receiver operating characteristic; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus. References 1 Kirkendoll K, Clark PC, Grossniklaus D, Igho-Pemu P, Mullis R, Dunbar SB. Metabolic syndrome in African Americans: views on making lifestyle
changes. J Transcult Nurs 2010; 21:104–113. 2 Yamaoka K, Tango T. Effects of lifestyle modification on metabolic
syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Med 2012;
10:138–148. 3 Walther G, Obert P, Dutheil F, Chapier R, Lesourd B, Naughton G, et al. Metabolic syndrome individuals with and without type 2 diabetes mellitus
present
generalized
vascular
dysfunction:
cross-sectional
study. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2015; 35:1022–1029. 4 Anderson PJ, Critchley JA, Chan JC, Cockram CS, Lee ZS, Thomas GN,
Tomlinson B. Factor analysis of the metabolic syndrome: obesity vs insulin
resistance as the central abnormality. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 2001;
25:1782–1788. The main finding in the current study is that BMI is
still the most powerful diagnostic tool for obesity. Although, in certain conditions where there are
limitations of using BMI, for example, heart failure
and ascites, we can use other obesity indices; VAI and
BAI could be used to discriminate cardiovascular risk
among obese patients. Interestingly, the power of VAI
was sensitive and specific in parallel to BMI in the
diagnosis of metabolic risk among T2DM patients. Our study explored that after adjusting for the
traditional risk factors, the logistic regression analysis
test found that the odds ratio of VAI value was the best
predictor of T2DM in comparison with BMI and BAI
among obese patients, P value less than 0.05. 5 Mottillo S, Filion KB, Genest J, Joseph L, Pilote L, Poirier P, et al. The
metabolic syndrome and cardiovascular risk a systematic review and meta-
analysis. J Am Coll Cardiol 2010; 56:1113–1132. 6 Kassi E, Pervanidou P, Kaltsas G, Chrousos G. Metabolic syndrome:
definitions and controversies. BMC Med 2011; 9: 48–61. 7 Finucane MM, Stevens GA, Cowan MJ, Danaei G, Lin JK, Paciorek CJ, et
al. National, regional, and global trends in body-mass index since 1980:
systematic analysis of health examination surveys and epidemiological
studies with 960 country-years and 9 · 1 million participants. Lancet 2011;
377:557–567. 8 Badran M, Laher I. Obesity in Arabic-speaking countries. J Obesity 2011. 24:1–9. 9 Frühbeck G. Obesity: screening for the evident in obesity. Nat Rev
Endocrinol 2012; 8:570–572. 10 Ng M, Fleming T, Robinson M, Thomson B, Graetz N, Margono C, et
al. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest. There are no conflicts of interest. References Global, regional, and national prevalence of overweight and
obesity
in
children
and
adults
during
1980–2013:
a
systematic
analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2013. Lancet
2014; 384:766–781. In a study by Amato et al. [16] among an age-stratified
Caucasian Sicilian population, the cut-off points of
VAI were proved to be strongly associated with MetS. 11 Jackson AS, Stanforth PR, Gagnon J, Rankinen T, Leon AS, Rao DC, et al. The effect of sex, age and race on estimating percentage body fat from
body mass index: The Heritage Family Study. Int J Obes Relat Metab
Disord 2002; 26:789–796. 12 Cornier MA, Després JP, Davis N, Grossniklaus DA, Klein S, Lamarche B,
et al. Assessing adiposity: a scientific statement from the American Heart
Association. Circulation 2011; 124:1996–2019. On the contrary, Bennasar-Veny and colleagues
reported that BAI does not overcome the limitations
of BMI and that it is not a good tool to measure
metabolic risk in the Caucasian population. They
concluded that BAI is less useful not only than BMI
but also than other adiposity indexes such as WHtR,
WHR, and WC [31]. 13 InterAct C, Langenberg C, Sharp SJ, Schulze MB, Rolandsson O, Overved
K, et al. Long-term risk of incident type 2 diabetes and measures of overall
and regional obesity: the EPIC-InterAct case cohort study. PLoS Med 2012;
9:e1001230. 14 Browning LM, Hsieh SD, Ashwell M. A systematic review of waist-to-height
ratio as a screening tool for the prediction of cardiovascular disease and
diabetes: 0.5 could be a suitable global boundary value. Nutr Res Rev
2010; 23:247–269. 15 Amato MC, Giordano C, Galia M, Criscimanna A, Vitabile S, Midiri M,
et al. Visceral adiposity index: a reliable indicator of visceral fat
function associated with cardiometabolic risk. Diabetes Care 2010;
33:920–922. Financial support and sponsorship
Nil. Although the BMI could be used as a diagnostic test of
obesity and its related metabolic complications, we still
indeed need other obesity indices to overcome the
limitations of BMI with regard to measurement of
excess fat. Accordingly, we analyzed our data by ROC
to estimate the sensitivity and specificity of VAI as well
as BAI. Our results detected that the cutoff values of
BMI, VAI, and BAI were 28.82, 7.31, and 27.58 and
the AUC values were 0.958 (95% CI=0.931–0.985),
0.952
(95%
CI=0.923–0.980),
and
0.770
(95%
CI=0.703–0.837),
respectively. In
addition,
the
sensitivity and specificity of BMI were 94.7 and
99.9%, those of VAI were 74.4 and 99.9%, and
those of BAI were 83.3 and 58%. Discussion [15],
among
an
age-stratified
Caucasian
Sicilian
population, found that the cut-off points of VAI
were proved to be strongly associated with MetS;
they explained that VAI represents physical (BMI
and WC) and metabolic parameters (TG and HDL
cholesterol),
and
may
indirectly
reflect
other
nonclassical
risk
factors,
that
is,
cytokines
and
plasma-free fatty acids. On the contrary, study by Hsieh et al. [25] found that
WHtR was a practical and simple anthropometric
measurement for identifying patients of both sexes
with higher metabolic risk. Association of new obesity indices Rashad and Emad 627 In contrast to our results, previous studies found that
WHtR was the most predictive measure of T2DM,
followed
by
BMI
[26–30]. The
diverse
results
summarized above contributed to differences in race/
ethnicity. In contrast to our results, previous studies found that
WHtR was the most predictive measure of T2DM,
followed
by
BMI
[26–30]. The
diverse
results
summarized above contributed to differences in race/
ethnicity. risk factors associated with the development of obesity-
related
comorbidities. Further
future
multicenter
studies
with
bigger
sample
size
are
needed
to
validate our findings. Conclusion In conclusion, unusual anthropometric measurements
such as BAI and VAI, which represent physical (BMI
and WC) and metabolic parameters (TG and HDL
cholesterol), may indirectly reflect other nonclassical 16 Bergman RN, Stefanovski D, Buchanan TA, Sumner AE, Reynolds JC,
Sebring NG, et al. A better index of body adiposity. Obesity (Silver Spring)
2011; 19:1083–1089. 17 Alberti KGM, Zimmet P, Shaw J, Group I. The metabolic syndrome −a new
worldwide definition. Lancet 2005; 366:1059–1062. 628
The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine, Vol. 31 No. 4, October-December 2019 628
The Egyptian Journal of Internal Medicine, Vol. 31 No. 4, October-December 2019 25 Hsieh SD, Yoshinaga H, Muto T. Waist-to-height ratio, a simple and
practical index for assessing central fat distribution and metabolic risk in
Japanese men and women. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 2003;
27:610–616 18 Friedewald WT, Levy RI, Fredrickson DS. Estimation of the concentration of
low-density lipoprotein cholesterol in plasma, without use of the preparative
ultracentrifuge. Clin Chem 1972; 18:499–502. 19 Matthews DR, Hosker JP, Rudenski AS, Naylor BA, Treacher DF, Turner
RC. Homeostasis model assessment: insulin resistance and b-cell function
from
fasting
plasma
glucose
and
insulin
concentrations
in
man. Diabetologia 1985; 28:412–419. 26 MacKay MF, Haffner SM, Wagenknecht LE, D’Agostino RB Jr, Hanley AJ. Prediction of type 2 diabetes using alternate anthropometric measures in a
multi-ethnic cohort: the insulin resistance atherosclerosis study. Diabetes
Care 2009; 32:956–958. 20 Pradeep AR, Nagpal K, Karvekar S, Patnaik K. Levels of lipocalin-2 in
crevicular fluid and tear fluid in chronic periodontitis and obesity subjects. J
Investig Clin Dent 2015; 19:1–7. 27 He YH, Chen YC, Jiang GX, Huang HE, Li R, Li XY. Evaluation of
anthropometric indices for metabolic syndrome in Chinese adults aged
40 years and over. Eur J Nutr 2012; 51:81–87. 21 Gharipour M, Sarrafzadegan N, Sadeghi M, Andalib E, Talaie M, Shafie D. PredictorsofmetabolicsyndromeintheIranianpopulation:waistcircumference,
body mass index, or waist to hip ratio? Cholesterol 2013; 24:2013. 28 Bosy-Westphal A, Geisler C, Onur S, Korth O, Selberg O, Schrezenmeir
J. Value of body fat mass vs anthropometric obesity indices in the
assessment
of
metabolic
risk
factors. Int
J
Obes
(Lond)
2006;
30:475–483. 22 Beydoun MA, Kuczmarski MT, Wang Y, Mason MA, Evans MK, Zonderman
AB. Receiver-operating
characteristics
of
adiposity
for
metabolic
syndrome: the Healthy Aging in Neighborhoods of Diversity across the
Life Span (HANDLS) study. Public Health Nutr 2011; 14:77–92. Conclusion 29 Sayeed M, Mahtab H, Latif Z, Khanam P, Ahsan K, Banu A, et al. Waist-to-
height ratio is a better obesity index than body mass index and waist-to-hip
ratio for predicting diabetes, hypertension and lipidemia. Bangladesh Med
Res Counc Bull 2003; 29:1. 23 Tulloch-Reid MK, Williams DE, Looker HC, Hanson RL, Knowler WC. Do
measures of body fat distribution provide information on the risk of type 2
diabetes in addition to measures of general obesity? Comparison of
anthropometric predictors of type 2 diabetes in Pima Indians. Diabetes
Care 2003; 26:2556–2561. 30 Kahn HS. Choosing an index for abdominal obesity: an opportunity for
epidemiologic clarification. J Clin Epidemiol 1993; 46:491–494. 31 Bennasar-Veny M, Lopez-Gonzalez AA, Tauler P, Cespedes ML, Vicente-
Herrero T, Yañez A, et al. Body adiposity index and cardiovascular health
risk factors in Caucasians: a comparison with the body mass index and
others. PLoS One 2013; 8:e63999. 24 Warne DK, Charles MA, Hanson RL, Jacobsson LT, McCance DR, Knowler
WC. Comparison of body size measurements as predictors of NIDDM in
Pima Indians. Diabetes Care 1995; 18:435–439.
|
https://openalex.org/W4231097000
|
https://figshare.com/articles/thesis/Financial_Socialization_for_Digital_Natives_A_New_Way_to_Teach_Children_About_Money/14651556/1/files/28133280.pdf
|
English
| null |
Financial Socialization for Digital Natives: A New Way to Teach Children About Money
| null | 2,021
|
cc-by
| 11,601
|
by Anika Chowdhury AUTHOR’S DECLARATION I hereby declare that I am the sole author of this MRP. This is a true copy of the MRP, including
any required final revisions. I authorize Ryerson University to lend this MRP to other institutions
or individuals for the purpose of scholarly research. I further authorize Ryerson University to
reproduce this MRP by photocopying or by other means, in total or in part, at the request of other
institutions or individuals for the purpose of scholarly research. I understand that my MRP may
be made electronically available to the public. ii ii ABSTRACT This study hypothesizes that there is a need to disrupt traditional methods by which families
teach children about money and illustrates a design solution that could effectively solve the
problem. In doing so, it explores how technology can play a role in children’s financial
upbringing through a review of literature and a generative study conducted on 8 Toronto families
with children between ages 5-12. Specifically, it explores what methods parents are currently
using to teach children various financial life skills and why such methods work or do not work. The study reveals three major themes: 1) Children cannot fully make the connection between
physical money they put in their piggy banks and digital money they see being used in the real
world. 2) Parents find it difficult to consistently implement money practices at home such as
chores and allowances, often due to time constraints and convenience factors. 3) Children get
easily influenced by their peers and surroundings when it comes to their purchase decisions,
making it hard for them to delay gratification. The project culminates in a conceptual design of
an app that addresses these themes in the following ways: 1) Provides children a digital way to
manage money that aligns with what they observe in the real world. 2) Enables parents to keep Helps children focus on their goals and make informed choices that supersede external
influences such as peer pressure. The app works as a family tool, providing a way for all players
in a child’s financial life (parents, grandparents, siblings and other significant adults) to work
towards a common goal and pass on values and skills of money management between iii generations. This study and the accompanying prototype contribute to the field of children’s
education technology and aid further research on the subject of digitizing financial education. generations. This study and the accompanying prototype contribute to the field of children’s
education technology and aid further research on the subject of digitizing financial education. Keywords: financial socialization, digital natives, money, children, technology, education,
family, parenting, generation alpha, personal finance, apps iv iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This project has been a dream of mine for a very long time and the dream would not have come
true without the help of some very special individuals. I am extremely thankful to have found a
supervisor like Alevtina Naumova (Alya) who not only shared my passion for this project, but
offered her expertise, knowledge and mentorship to help bring my work to fruition. I would like
to thank Professor Paul Moore, who has provided me the support and inspiration to turn ideas
into words, and words into action. It is because of Paul and Alya that I now have a passion for
research, and I am eternally grateful for all the time they have invested in helping me solidify my
research skills. I would also like to thank my MDM professors Asma Arsalan, Naimul Khan,
Richard Lachman, Sean Wise and Steve Cober for sharing their unique areas of expertise that
have inspired and informed my final work. I am grateful to Ahmed Sagarwala, Lissa Quaglia and
Alex Ferworn for their consistent support to our cohort during the academic year. Finally, I
would like to thank MDM 6.0 cohort who I now call my second family. Thank you for the great
times we have shared learning, collaborating and supporting each other – it is truly an honor to
be able to celebrate this milestone with each of you! v TABLE OF CONTENTS AUTHOR’S DECLARATION .....................................................................................................................ii
ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................................iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ..........................................................................................................................v
INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................................01
RATIONALE ..............................................................................................................................................03
LITERATURE REVIEW ...........................................................................................................................05
METHODOLOGY…………………………...............................................................................................16
FINDINGS …………………………………..............................................................................................22
DISUCSSION……………………………………………………………………………………………..28
SOLUTION……………………………………………………………………………………………......31
IMPLEMENTATION & FUTURE WORK………………………………………………………………32
CONCLUSION……………………………………………………………………………………………33
REFERENCES…………………………………………………………………………………………….34 vi INTRODUCTION Financial socialization is the process through which individuals develop their money
habits, attitudes, and skills. This is primarily achieved through modeling behaviors, creating
discussions and curating practical experiences at home (LeBaron et al., 2019). Indeed, the path to
becoming a financially independent adult is a life-long journey shaped by social factors – eg. family, culture, peers, media and community. However, the world around us is changing. The
prevalence of today’s rapidly evolving technology is fast transforming all aspects of life and
society, from the way we communicate to the way we spend time at home, at school, and out in
the community (National Association for the Education of Young Children [NAEYC] & Fred
Rogers Center, 2012). How then is a child’s financial upbringing evolving with the new world? The term digital native was coined by education expert Marc Prensky (2001a) to describe
the generation of children growing up in the age of ubiquitous technology; these children speak
“digital” as a primary language that they learn, communicate, and interact in. In his two-part
article “Digital Natives Digital Immigrants”, Prensky (2001a, 2001b) draws upon theories in
neuroplasticity and social psychology to suggest that there has been a fundamental shift in the
brain structures and thinking patterns of the new generation – and the magnitude of this change is
comparable to when humans first switched from verbal communication to reading and writing. To put it simply, digital natives are hard-wired to think and process information differently than
their parents’ generation, and that is unlikely to change. Therefore, the onus is on the parents,
educators and policy makers to find new ways to educate the new generation (Prensky, 2001a). As the title “Financial Socialization for Digital Natives" suggests, this paper is
constructed on the hypothesis that there is a need to evolve traditional financial socializing
methods to fit the context, culture, reference points and learning patterns of digital natives. Digital natives are major consumers of digital products such as apps, games and videos starting 1 1 from a very young age (Rideout, 2017). Even before they take their first steps or say their first
words, they intuitively know how to swipe and tap on screens to make things happen instantly,
such as play their favourite cartoons or games. This style of consumption happens without
having to wait or putting in any effort, and it is a world where seemingly everything is free. INTRODUCTION Admittedly, digital natives are growing up very disconnected from the economic realities of life,
which could have detrimental effects on their financial future. Therefore, in order to effectively
teach today’s children about money, parents must connect the dots between the digital world and
the physical world. from a very young age (Rideout, 2017). Even before they take their first steps or say their first
words, they intuitively know how to swipe and tap on screens to make things happen instantly,
such as play their favourite cartoons or games. This style of consumption happens without
having to wait or putting in any effort, and it is a world where seemingly everything is free. To substantiate this idea, I first argue that there is a strong need to promote financial
literacy among children. I then provide evidence through literature analysis that the most
effective way to teach children about money is through experiences that are aligned with the real
world. I validate this further through a generative study, identifying the common gaps in
financial education for children today - namely technological gap, implementation gap and
generational gap. Finally, I provide the proof of concept of a digital app that aims to bridge these
gaps in financial socialization for digital natives. The recommendations generated in this paper
have been used to design a high-fidelity prototype of the app named Pocket Buddies, that serves
as an example of a financial education tool for future generations. 2 better approaches to financial education that align with the realities of today’s world. RATIONALE Poor financial literacy among children and young adults is a rising concern worldwide
(e.g. Garg & Singh, 2018; Jorgensen and Savla, 2010; Mandell, 2008; OECD, 2017;). Canada is
no different. We are a nation suffering from record high consumer debt, rising housing prices,
dwindling job prospects and soaring student loans – and yet, we feel better prepared to talk to our
children about sex than we do about money (Dollars and Smart Sense, 2018). We are also often
oblivious of our own lack of financial savvy (Ipsos, 2017) which could carry over to our
children. To help with this, the Government of Canada employed a Task Force on Financial
Literacy in 2009 with the aim of providing us with the “knowledge, skills and confidence to
make responsible financial decisions” (Government of Canada, 2019). But given that we are
behind on adult financial literacy, it will take a long time for these policies to meaningfully
impact children. The current state of children’s financial education in Canadian schools is either non-
existent, outdated, or inadequate, depending on the province (Marr, 2016; Soman, 2017). The
province of Ontario, for example, has only recently implemented a pilot project that will add
financial literacy to the grade 10 curriculum (Gordon, 2017). At a younger age, the gap is being
haphazardly filled by various non-profit organizations through daylong workshops and summer
camps such as Money School Canada, Cent$ible Students and Junior Achievement. In the
meantime, as these programs and policies slowly make their way into our education system one
school at a time, the world around us is changing rapidly. Canada is now ranked the number 1
most cashless society in the world (Osler, 2018). Before our eyes, retail stores are disappearing,
cashiers are turning into robots and all our life’s necessities are being instantly delivered to us at
our doorsteps. With all these changes, it won’t be long before the kids “lemonade stand” goes out
of business because, frankly, nobody carries cash anymore! We ought to come up with newer, 3 3 better approaches to financial education that align with the realities of today’s world. Fortunately, we don’t have to wait for the government or our school system to intervene, because
the best place for children to learn about money is at home (LeBaron et al., 2019; Schuchardt et
al., 2009; Totenhagen, 2015). 4 LITERATURE REVIEW Financial socialization theories suggest that children learn from “observation, instruction,
and practice” (Whitebread & Bingham, 2013, p. 17). In section 1 of the literature review, I
expand upon these three principles of financial learning, providing evidence that learning
through practice or experience is the optimal method. In section 2, I provide specific examples of
how experiential learning can be applied to financial socialization. Finally, in section 3, I discuss
the role of technology in financial socialization for digital natives, grounded in contemporary
influences and examples. The literature review will later inform the discussions section of this
study, connecting existing theory to new findings, thus providing the guiding principles of the
prototype design. SECTION 1: HOW CHILDREN LEARN FINANCIAL SOCIALIZATION Research has shown three primary methods through which children learn from their
parents about money: i) Learning by observation. ii) Learning by discussion iii) Learning
through experience. Each of these have been discussed below: Learning by Observation Learning by Observation One of the earliest ways in which children learn from adults is through observation and
imitation. Much like how an infant would mimic the facial expressions and gestures of an adult
(Meltzoff, 1998), each of us has the innate ability to learn from our surroundings through
observation. Bandura (1977), who calls this social learning, stated: 5 Most human behavior is learned observationally through modeling: from observing others,
one forms an idea of how new behaviors are performed, and on later occasions this coded
information serves as a guide for action. (Bandura, 1977, p. 22) This is particularly true for children who implicitly acquire their parents’ behaviours and
attitudes through day-to-day observation. LeBaron et al. (2019) further linked observational
learning to financial socialization explaining: This is particularly true for children who implicitly acquire their parents’ behaviours and
attitudes through day-to-day observation. LeBaron et al. (2019) further linked observational
learning to financial socialization explaining: Children whose parents model sound financial behaviors will likely imitate those
behaviors not only in childhood but also into emerging adulthood and beyond. (LeBaron
et al., 2019, p. 437) Children whose parents model sound financial behaviors will likely imitate those
behaviors not only in childhood but also into emerging adulthood and beyond. (LeBaron
et al., 2019, p. 437) Therefore, if children grow up observing their parents making financially responsible
decisions such as putting money aside for a rainy day or living within a budget, they could
inadvertently acquire similar values and behaviors in life (Serido & Deenanath, 2016; Hira et al.,
2013). However, the same would hold true if parents model poor financial habits. Therefore,
parents who are aware of this implicit learning method can use it to their advantage by modelling
behaviors they would like to see in their children and minimizing those they do not wish to pass
on. In other words, they can act as a good role model. Learning by Discussion As opposed to learning by observation, which is implicit, learning by discussion is an
explicit way in which children can learn through conversation with their parents. It is primarily
how they are able to “make sense of their social worlds”. (Djik et al., 2018, p. 1908). There is
evidence of parent-child discussions being a beneficial technique in teaching social behaviors
(Djik et al., 2018; Moschis, 1985), morals (Berkowitz & Grych, 1998), beliefs (Werner et al., 6 2014), life choices (Wilson et al., 2010) and habits (Backett & Alexander, 1991). This includes
examples of learning about health, sexuality, empathy, advertisements, media and violence. Furthermore, there is evidence of parent-child discussions bearing positive outcomes in
financial socialization. (LeBaron et al., 2019; Danes & Dunrud, 2005). Whitebread & Bringham
(2013) recommend that parents find opportunities in daily decisions to have a conversation. For
instance, if a child wants to go to the movies, parents could talk about the various costs
associated with the activity which includes monetary costs (such as paying for gas, snacks,
drinks and tickets) and non-monetary costs (such as time and energy). This could also be an
opportunity to discuss other alternatives such as renting a movie and evaluating which option
would be considered a better financial decision. The key, therefore, is to find teachable moments
in everyday situations where parents and children can discuss money in a meaningful way. Furthermore, there is evidence of parent-child discussions bearing positive outcomes in
financial socialization. (LeBaron et al., 2019; Danes & Dunrud, 2005). Whitebread & Bringham
(2013) recommend that parents find opportunities in daily decisions to have a conversation. For
instance, if a child wants to go to the movies, parents could talk about the various costs Learning by Doing Learning by Doing The process of learning by doing is known as experiential learning (Felicia, 2011). A
body of literature suggests that children learn best through experience (Kirkham et. al, 2002;
Watkins, 2001; LeBaron 2019; Whitebread & Bringham, 2013). The theory of inductive learning
reasons that learning from experience is more effective than learning through instruction because
it allows a child to apply the knowledge acquired from past experiences to new situations
(Kirkham et. al, 2002). Experiential learning can further lead to metacognition, or learning to
learn (Watkins, 2001), where children are able to evaluate their experiences in conjunction with
their “goals, strategies, effects, feelings and context of learning” (p.7). Therefore, whereas
learning through observation or discussion can help children repeat actions and mimic behaviors, 7 7 7 learning through experience can go much deeper as it enables children to internalize, reflect and
keep learning. LeBaron et al. (2019) explains this as a cyclical process: learning through experience can go much deeper as it enables children to internalize, reflect and
keep learning. LeBaron et al. (2019) explains this as a cyclical process: [A child] gains external experience, reflects on the observations of that experience, forms
new abstract concepts from that reflection, and reapplies what is learned to new
experiences. (LeBaron et al., 2019, p. 438) [A child] gains external experience, reflects on the observations of that experience, forms
new abstract concepts from that reflection, and reapplies what is learned to new
experiences. (LeBaron et al., 2019, p. 438) Many studies have provided evidence of experiential learning in the context of financial
socialization. Tang and Peter (2015) discovered that hands-on financial experience has a direct
and significant impact on financial knowledge. Jorgensen & Savla (2010) found that children
who handled their own money and made their own transactions at the supermarket were
financially more knowledgeable, responsible and confident in their decisions. In a 2018 study,
LeBaron et al. found that early experiences in working, saving, having a bank account and living
within a budget, all led individuals to grow up as financially responsible adults. Work by Kim
and Chatterjee (2013) further established that the experience of owning a bank account and
managing spending habits in childhood led to an increased propensity to save in adulthood. Learning by Doing In
recognition of this, the “Bank at School” program in the US has enabled students to “open a
saving account at school, make deposits, calculate simple interest and track their saving balance”
(Tang & Peter, 2015, p. 123). According to LeBaron et. al (2019), not providing children with
sufficient economic experiences in their childhood may impede their financial abilities in
adulthood. Work by Schug and Birkey (1985) further adds that these experiences could help
children combat the influences of consumerism propagated by media and advertisement (Schug
and Birkey 1985). Indeed, there is much evidence rooted in literature that tie experiential learning to
financial socialization. However, there is yet to be studies conducted to explore what these early 8 8 financial experiences for children may look like in the context of digital money, such as online
banks and payment methods. In the following section, we will review some existing examples of
experiential learning in financial socialization. financial experiences for children may look like in the context of digital money, such as online
banks and payment methods. In the following section, we will review some existing examples of
experiential learning in financial socialization. SECTION 2: USING EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING IN FINANCIAL SOCIALIZATION Children are social learners, largely influenced by parents, siblings, peers, school, media
and other social agents (Schuchardt et al., 2009). While it is still common today for adults to
curate financial lessons at home using pocket money and piggy banks, children find it more
exciting to participate in practical activities such as going to the real bank or taking weekly
grocery trips (Whitebread & Bringham, 2013). So, what kind of financial experiences can
parents create for their children? Whitebread & Bringhan (2013) provide a few practical examples for parents. For
instance, a dollar-shopping trip can be arranged in order to teach a child concepts related to value
and exchange. The child will only have $1 to spend and experience the dilemma and decision-
making that comes with having a budget. Similarly, to teach concepts of earning an income,
children can be allowed to complete tasks that require them to give up time and effort in
exchange for money. To put simply, they can be given jobs. This lesson could be further tied
with experience in window shopping that shows a child what they can and cannot afford with the
wage they earned. Delaying gratification can be taught by setting up a savings jar for the next
item a child desires to purchase something, and a chart can be made to visually track progress. Some examples of digital solutions that attempt to deliver such experiences have been provided
in the next section. 9 9 In my research, I found a few examples of children displaying financially responsible
attitudes and behaviors as a direct result of the experiences provided by their parents. For
instance, a 9-year-old whose parents took him to the thrift store once learned that for the same
amount of money he would use buying one toy at ToysRUs, he would get 5 equally nice toys at
Value Village. As a result of this experience, he started spending his money wisely. Another 12-
year-old was allowed to go into the bank and exchange his Canadian dollars for U.S. dollars
during their visit to Disney World, Florida. Watching his money shrink not only helped him
grasp the complex idea behind currency exchange but also discouraged him from spending all his
money because he understood that the U.S. dollar was more expensive. However, Whitebread & Bringham (2013) also warn that the experiences curated need to
be age-appropriate. SECTION 3: USING TECHNOLOGY IN EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING In this section, I review Presnky’s (2001) theory on how digital natives learn and what
role technology currently plays in their education. I then specifically explore educational apps,
categorizing them into educational games, gamified educational apps and productivity apps. In this section, I review Presnky’s (2001) theory on how digital natives learn and what
role technology currently plays in their education. I then specifically explore educational apps,
categorizing them into educational games, gamified educational apps and productivity apps. From this review, I conclude that productivity apps are the most ideal when it comes to teaching
children about money. From this review, I conclude that productivity apps are the most ideal when it comes to teaching
children about money. SECTION 2: USING EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING IN FINANCIAL SOCIALIZATION For instance, a child younger than 5 years old may understand that you need
to pay money in exchange for things but may not be able to comprehend that certain things cost
more than others. Similarly, it could be challenging for a child younger than 7 to understand that
using a credit card to pay is also an exchange similar to cash. This concept of age appropriate
money experiences was expanded upon by author Beth Kobliner (2013) in the book “Making
Your Child A Money Genius (Even If You’re Not)” where she provides parents with age-by-age
financial socialization strategies substantiated by a myriad of research. To sum up, experiential
learning could be a powerful tool in financial socialization when the experiences are rooted in
everyday settings with age appropriate practices. 10 How Digital Natives Learn Children today think, learn and process information very differently from their parents
According to Prensky (2001a): Children today think, learn and process information very differently from their parents. According to Prensky (2001a): Digital Natives are used to receiving information really fast. They like to parallel process
and multi-task. They prefer their graphics before their text rather than the opposite. They
prefer random access (like hypertext). They function best when networked. They thrive
on instant gratification and frequent rewards. They prefer games to “serious” work. (Prensky, 2001a, p.2) In contrast, digital immigrants (those who did not grow up with technology but rather
‘immigrated’ into it) tend to learn “slowly, step-by-step, one thing at a time, individually, and
above all, seriously” (Prensky, 2001a, p.2). Prensky compares this dichotomy to a language
barrier, emphasizing that digital immigrants must learn the language of digital natives in order to
be able to provide them education. He argues that every subject can be and needs to be taught in
a new way because digital natives are simply unable to learn the old way – their brains are
physically different (Prensky, 2001b). 11 11 Using Technology in Education Using Technology in Education Using Technology in Education Many studies have correlated the use of technology at home to higher educational
attainment (Danby et al., 2018; NAEYC & Fred Rogers Center, 2012; Takeuchi, 2011). A
qualitative study on preschoolers in central Scotland found that the use of technology at home
can significantly augment learning in children, but only when it is used in collaboration with
family members (Stephen, et. al, 2013). Takeuchi (2011) adds that technology should “let
parents interactively participate in media activities with their children, whether one room or one
thousand miles apart” (p.6). Moreover, technological tools are most effective when they are
“hands-on, engaging and empowering” (NAEYC & Fred Rogers, 2012, p.6). Based on this
evidence, the types of digital tools that afford hands-on, collaborative and real-time experiences
(i.e. mobile devices such as smartphone and tablets) could be deemed the best educational tools. Furthermore, a study by Danby et. al (2018) found that most parents feel that tablet devices,
particularly educational apps, help children’s learning as well as social and emotional
development. It is therefore no surprise that the ownership of tablets among children in America
have gone up 6 times between 2013-2017 (Rideout, 2017). Fortunately, there is also evidence
that mobile and tablet devices have improved young children’s “fine motor skills,
communication and opportunity for learning and cognitive engagement (Danby et. Al, 2018, p. 167). communication and opportunity for learning and cognitive engagement (Danby et. Al, 2018, p. 167). communication and opportunity for learning and cognitive engagement (Danby et. Al, 2018, p. 167). 167). Example of Technology in Learning Thus far, I have found three kinds of apps that have provided experiential learning for
children – games, gamified apps and productivity apps. 12 Among children’s educational games, Minecraft is a favorite these days. It is a game that
allows players to build worlds together from remote locations using simple building blocks. Among children’s educational games, Minecraft is a favorite these days. It is a game that
allows players to build worlds together from remote locations using simple building blocks. While the world they build is virtual, the experience of teamwork, collaboration and working
with the community are real social skills that children learn from the game. Using Technology in Education Furthermore, the
game allows children to build complex machines and environments which have been used by
educators to teach spatial geometry, digital story-telling and project management to name just a
few (Nebel, et al 2016). Gamification is different from games in that it makes the education game-like through
rewards and challenges, but the app in and of itself is not a game. This has implications in
learning both hard skills such as language (eg. Duo Lingo for kids), soft skills such as time
management (eg. HabitRPG) and healthy life habits (eg. Zombie, Run!). Although not originally
created as a fitness app, Pokémon Go can be used as an example of a gamified experiences to
attain healthy habits. In this augmented reality version of the popular children’s cartoon, players
can walk outdoors in the real world and collect virtual creatures called Pokémon. The more they
walk, the more they can catch and the more in-game rewards they earn. It is perhaps the most
closely studied app in gamification and benefits have been associated with factors such as
increased physical activity, more time spent outdoors, improved mood, socialization skills and
spatial awareness (Marquet et al. 2017). The third category of educational apps are productivity apps such as Purp To-Do List &
Goal Tracker (app that helps children stay organized), MyScript Calculator (for Math help) and
PizMo Go – Instant Text Capture (for reading help). Contrary to popular ideas of how children
need rewards for everything, these productivity apps are not driven by any extrinsic reward but
would merely act as a tool for productivity. The motivation to use such an app therefore would
be similar to why an adult would use a productivity app – it would solve a problem that user has. 13 This category of apps is built to solve real world problems, which aligns best with the literature
on experiential learning and financial socialization reviewed in the previous section. This category of apps is built to solve real world problems, which aligns best with the literature
on experiential learning and financial socialization reviewed in the previous section. Example of Technology in Financial Education Example of Technology in Financial Education Some games available through the app store simulate some aspect of financial education. For instance, Super Market Cash Register enables children to role-play as cashiers and Bank
ATM Simulator that teaches children to use an ATM machine. However, these have done very
poorly in the app store with little or no downloads and ratings. On one hand, as games, they
don’t do a very good job in creating continuous challenge and excitement for children. On the
other hand, the games seem too far detached from what literature suggests parents would like to
teach their children – for instance, playing with a virtual, cash registry while fun, does not teach
any norms, values or behaviors that are fundamental to financial socialization. In my research, I
found that the financial values that parents wanted to teach their children were related to their
long-term success - such as learning about opportunity cost, delaying gratification and saving for
a goal, none of which were reflected in these games. The type of games that I found in the
category of children’s financial education were more or less virtual simulations of items or
symbols related to money that did not teach any valuable lesson or experience. In the category of gamification, I found Peter Pig’s Money Counter that teaches children
how to count coins and then use the rewards to buy props to dress a pig. This, at the very least,
has some educational value when it comes to understanding money. However, once a child
learns all the coins, there is no motivation to play despite the in-game rewards. Moreover, in my
research I found that money counting, while also taught in school, does not have implication in
real life as few families use physical cash to pay for things. Therefore, parents are unable to
model behaviors and curate practical experiences using physical money unless they go out of 14 14 their way to obtain cash. Most financial educational apps that I found under the gamification
category were related to math and counting (eg. Amazing Coin, Counting Money & Money
Grabber) and therefore did not reflect the principles of financial socialization. The best apps that I found in the category of children’s financial education are the
productivity apps that deliver well on the real-life aspects of money. Example of Technology in Financial Education For instance, RoosterMoney
is an allowance tracker and chore manager that has been highly rated by The Wall Street Journal,
Forbes and The Huffington Post. The reason this style of app has done better than gamification
and games is because children feel intrinsically rewarded when lessons are based on their own
money. The app then merely becomes a tool, and the lesson comes from the real world – which
is reflective of the theories of financial socialization and experiential learning that I have
reviewed earlier in this paper. 15 Research Methodology Research Methodology This project explores the problem of children’s financial education and identifies a
technological solution. As such, I chose a target group of young Toronto families with children
between ages 5-12 years old, with the presumption that a broad age group would reveal a
diversity of thoughts and insights. I conducted a generative study on a total of 8 families and
assessed their needs in terms of family dynamics, learning styles, relationship with money and
technology. Specifically, I explored what methods parents are currently using to teach their
children various financial life skills at home and why such methods work or do not work. This project explores the problem of children’s financial education and identifies a
technological solution. As such, I chose a target group of young Toronto families with children
between ages 5-12 years old, with the presumption that a broad age group would reveal a
diversity of thoughts and insights. I conducted a generative study on a total of 8 families and
assessed their needs in terms of family dynamics, learning styles, relationship with money and
technology. Specifically, I explored what methods parents are currently using to teach their
children various financial life skills at home and why such methods work or do not work. Furthermore, I considered the unique needs of each generation that influences a child’s financial
upbringing, identifying friction points that could be avoided and common goals that could be
incorporated in the technological solution. The findings were reviewed in conjunction with the
literature analysis to identify an app-based solution that could serve the family financial
socialization practices. All necessary approvals were obtained from the Ryerson University
Research Ethics Board (RB) prior to starting the research study. Furthermore, I considered the unique needs of each generation that influences a child’s financial
upbringing, identifying friction points that could be avoided and common goals that could be
incorporated in the technological solution. The findings were reviewed in conjunction with the
literature analysis to identify an app-based solution that could serve the family financial
socialization practices. All necessary approvals were obtained from the Ryerson University
Research Ethics Board (RB) prior to starting the research study. METHODOLOGY The recommendations generated in this paper have been used to design a high-fidelity
prototype of a digital app as an example of a financial education tool for future generations. Therefore, there are two types of methodology that have been used: 1) Research Methodology 2)
Design Methodology. Sample A total of 8 participants were recruited via online flyers posted on various parents’ groups
on Facebook. There were 2 criteria for eligibility: 1) Parents living within the Greater Toronto 16 Region. 2) Parents with children between ages 5-12. This age group of children, sometimes
referred to as grade schoolers, are post pre-school and pre-high school students. According to the
American Academy of Pediatrics, at this stage of development, children are introduced to
various real-world challenges and develop life experiences and cognitive functions that help
them build confidence (Ages & Stages, n.d.). The rationale behind such a broad age group for
children was to obtain a diversity of insights into financial socialization practices in families with
younger, older and multiple children and get a deeper understanding of children’s knowledge,
attitude and behavior towards money matters at various ages. This helped in envisioning a
solution that could grow with the child as their level of understanding and responsibilities
evolve. The age range, coupled with recruitment via social media, also helped obtain a pool of
participants with a high level of diversity in terms of participant income, cultural background and
family composition. Participants included single and dual income households of low, medium
and high incomes. Among the parents were first- and second-generation immigrants, single
parents and same-sex couples. The households had 2 or 3 children of both genders, but none with
a single child. There were children going to both public and private school as well as families
living in the city and in the suburbs. Participants who volunteered, however, were all female
parents, although in some cases their significant other was around and contributed to the
contextual insights gained. Procedure Generative research is a methodology used in the field of User Experience (UX) that
helps researchers define a problem that they are trying to design a solution for. It involves
obtaining a deep contextual understanding of participant’s lives, behaviors, attitudes and 17 perceptions without a specific problem or solution in mind (Estes, 2019). This discovery-based
approach was fitting for my project as financial literacy and education technology are both broad
topics. My objective was to explore parents’ attitudes, preferences and opinions about children’s
financial education, technology use and money practices at home and uncover what problems
existed, what solutions they were using and what were the gaps. Therefore, it was important that
I familiarized myself with all aspects of their family life – starting from everyday routines to
special occasions, house rules, family culture, technology use and conversations and practices
around money. This required in-depth face-to-face interviews within the context of participant’s
home and family settings. Therefore, I designed hour-long interview sessions in participants
homes. The interview style was semi-structured, and fully adaptable to each participant, taking
cues from their situations and surroundings. The interview questions were of three types: The interview questions were of three types: The interview questions were of three types: 1) Guided Questions: Each session typically included some variations of open-ended
questions that guided the conversation around money, education and technology. For
instance: i) What lessons are you currently teaching your children about money? ii)
What are your house rules around screen-time? iii) What was the last purchase your
child made? These were conversation starters to then delve into the whys and hows of
the topics and uncover the culture, values, norms and beliefs that drove their everyday
parenting decisions. 1) Guided Questions: Each session typically included some variations of open-ended
questions that guided the conversation around money, education and technology. For
instance: i) What lessons are you currently teaching your children about money? ii)
What are your house rules around screen-time? iii) What was the last purchase your
child made? These were conversation starters to then delve into the whys and hows of
the topics and uncover the culture, values, norms and beliefs that drove their everyday
parenting decisions. 2) Situational Questions: Every time a parent shared an example or an anecdote, it was
an opportunity to ask specific situational questions such as “So what did your child do
with the $100 grandma gave on his birthday?” or “What happened after you refused
to buy your child another set of Pokémon cards?”. These were instrumental in 18 18 uncovering day to day friction points and overall pain points that parents face. uncovering day to day friction points and overall pain points that parents face. Moreover, they helped unpack some of the more generic answers provided by parents
and revealed what things were like in reality. Moreover, they helped unpack some of the more generic answers provided by parents
and revealed what things were like in reality. 3) Observational Questions: Since the interviews took place in participant’s homes, I
had the opportunity to make observations above and beyond the scope of interview
questions and answers. For instance, if a child was watching something during the
interview, or there were collections of toys or artwork displayed, or if grandma called
mid-interview, I had an opportunity to ask questions and learn more about them. This
gave me a deeper understanding of their home situation, family life, and relationship
dynamics. Moreover, being in their own homes put the participants in a more relaxed
state of mind, contextualized their narratives and minimized self-reporting bias. Data Collection and Analyses All interviews were audio-recorded with REB approval and parents’ consent. The audio files
were transcribed into scripts where each participant was assigned a pseudonym. The pseudonym
key was kept in a separate file away from the transcripts. In addition, some photos of toys and
artifacts (such as piggy banks, toy collections and artwork) were collected with the consent of
parents in order to help with the analysis of the data, but no participant or their children were
photographed. These measures ensured that the data was appropriately deidentified before
analysis began and participant privacy and confidentiality complied with REB guidelines. An affinity diagram was used to study the data to find themes and patterns. Affinity
diagramming is a popular method used in design research where insights from interviews are
recorded in post-it notes which are then organized and reorganized into clusters until a story
emerges (Hanington & Martin, 2012, p. 12). While using this method, I recorded around 30-50 19 observations per participant and organized them into 4 broad categories 1) Problem 2) Emotions
3) Channels 4) Deficiencies. Problems would entail anything that would curtail parents’ efforts
to raise their children to act responsibly - for instance, peer pressure, time constraint, controlling
screen time etc. These were obtained through guided and situational questions. Emotions such as
pride, fear, guilt were recorded primarily through observation, tone and body language. Channels
included all tools, resources, items and places that were relevant to a child’s financial circumstances - such as Dollarama, Piggy Bank and YouTube Toy Reviews. Deficiencies were
specific examples of the problem with existing solution parents were using to teach their children
about money - for instance lack of physical cash. As patterns began to emerge, I reorganized the
post-its, grouping similar observations together, putting the most observed occurrences on top of
the diagram till I found distinct themes. Theme 1: Technology Gap This theme revealed that there is a need for a digital tool for children to manage and keep
track of their money. Currently, in the absence of such tools, parents are implementing old
generation’s methods to solve the problem for a new generation, which is not working well. Moreover, the technology that parents are using for their own money management is far more
advanced than what they are using to help their children practice money. The findings pertaining
to technology gap are discussed in the sections below. Design Methodology Design Methodology The principles of Design Thinking (Dam & Siang, 2019) were used to identify best
practices and guide the creative process of the app. I used insights from my user interview,
contextual notes from the interview settings and guiding principles from my literature review to
empathize with my users, define the problem, ideate a solution and develop a prototype. At the
empathy stage, I identified the key players in a child’s financial upbringing as the child, the
parent and grandparent and learned about their unique goals, motivations, actions and emotions. The insights from the affinity diagram was used to identify three distinct themes that helped
define the problem. At the ideation stage, I created a journey map that brought together the three
users and the three themes into a single experience that was inspired by one of the interview 20 20 anecdotes. The journey map helped me create wireframes and ultimately a prototype of an app
using the software Adobe XD. 21 FINDINGS FINDINGS There were three recurring themes that emerged from the generative study. I have
categorized them as: i) Technology Gap ii) Implementation Gap and iii) Generation Gap. Theme 1: Technology Gap Lack of Technology Piggy banks were used in every household, primarily to store cash and coins received as
gifts or allowances. However, most children could not fully make the connection between
physical money they put in their piggy banks and the digital money they saw being used by their
parents in the real world. Below are some examples: Lamisa, a stay-at-home mother of two girls shared about her 6-year-old daughter: isa, a stay-at-home mother of two girls shared about her 6-year-old daughter: My daughter recently learned how to count money in school. It was the first time she
saw any cash or coins because she is used to seeing us use debit or credit cards….I
don’t think she understood it was the same money. My daughter recently learned how to count money in school. It was the first time she
saw any cash or coins because she is used to seeing us use debit or credit cards….I
don’t think she understood it was the same money. Heather, a single mother of two girls 5 and 9-year-old noted: Heather, a single mother of two girls 5 and 9-year-old noted: They have wallets and piggy banks, but they are not best at counting or keeping
them [the money] safe. They end up playing with it….When we go to Dollarama, They have wallets and piggy banks, but they are not best at counting or keeping
them [the money] safe. They end up playing with it….When we go to Dollarama, 22 they want everything they see….I say I don’t have cash, they ask “oh where is your
credit card?”. They don’t get the concept yet. It’s too abstract. they want everything they see….I say I don’t have cash, they ask “oh where is your
credit card?”. They don’t get the concept yet. It’s too abstract. Theme 2: Implementation Gap Theme 2: Implementation Gap Theme 2: Implementation Gap This theme revealed that there is a need for an easy way for busy parents to implement
and keep track of their chosen method of financial education for their children. Moreover, they
can’t do it alone. They need help from all the participants in their children’s financial upbringing
- this entails both parents and grandparents (if involved) to be on the same page. The findings
pertaining to implementation gap are discussed in the sections below. Solutions in the Absence of Technology Darleen, who has a 12-year-old son and a 10-year-old daughter had a solution to this
problem. She suggested: Farmers markets are great for kids because it’s all cash. They can see physical
[money being used]. In a world where even monopoly is electronic, it’s so hard to
show them that money diminishing. In fact, Darlene went through great lengths to bridge the gap between physical and
digital money to teach her children the concepts of budgeting. Every week, she filled a
bucket with a $1000 in loonies with an empty bucket next to it. She told the kids that their
budget as a household was $1000 a week – and every time a bill was paid, food was
purchased or service was incurred, they had to physically count and transfer the money
from the full bucket to the empty bucket. She wanted her children to watch the money
diminish with every purchase decision. Her plan worked to some extent, but the model
was not sustainable long-term as it took up space, time and energy to implement. Most parents agreed that cash was no longer a part of their everyday lives. Some
said they had to go out of their way to withdraw cash from the bank to keep the allowance
going, but it wasn’t always feasible. In fact, there were occasions when parents found
themselves in need of cash (for instance to tip for pizza delivery person) and ended up
dipping into their children’s piggy bank. 23 Lack of Consistency So, when my parents come over,
he sits on their lap and says “can I have some money?” he sits on their lap and says “can I have some money?” Darlene said this was a constant source of friction between her and her parents: Darlene said this was a constant source of friction between her and her parents: My kids have been given a lot of money [by their grandparents] for a long time – my
parents get mad because I go and put it in the bank. My parents send them a cheque, I put it
away. Now they send him cash and cheque. Therefore, the implementation gap not only came from the parents own busy lives, but also
from the fact that not all the players in the child’s financial social life were on the same page. This broke consistency and led to conflicts. Theme 3: Generation Gap Lack of Consistency Just like Darlene and her money-bucket lesson, many parents admitted to not being able
to remain consistent in the financial practices they established for their children at home. Others
said they had a problem getting started as they could not find the time to, for example, take the
children to the bank to open accounts or set the terms and expectations for allowance. Below are
some examples: Heather talked about her multiple failed attempts with allowance with her daughters: I tried allowance a few times, couldn’t stick with it. With my older kid I was planning to
give $5 [based on good behavior each week]. She forgot to ask, I never followed up, it [the
allowance system] kind of disappeared. Janine, who had a chore chart hanging on the fridge for her two daughters explained: Janine, who had a chore chart hanging on the fridge for her two daughters explained: We are super busy in the morning and I need to get out the door. So, it’s faster if I do it [the
chore]. I guess it’s my fault I need to be more consistent. 24 Lack of Unity Many also felt that their financial lessons were being undermined by the grandparents
who would purchase toys or give the children extra cash without any reason or occasion. Below
are some examples: Monica, mother of 3 boys (4, 6 and 9 years old), complained: The grandparents spoil them….my parents buy them gifts sometimes weekly….I would
like them [my children] to have new toys only on special occasions. The influx is constant,
and this is beyond my control. The grandparents spoil them….my parents buy them gifts sometimes weekly….I would
like them [my children] to have new toys only on special occasions. The influx is constant,
and this is beyond my control. Fariha, mother of 2 boys (5 and 9 years old) had a similar story: Fariha, mother of 2 boys (5 and 9 years old) had a similar story: My younger one has now equated that grandma=money. So, when my parents come over, My younger one has now equated that grandma=money. So, when my parents come over,
he sits on their lap and says “can I have some money?” My younger one has now equated that grandma money. Theme 3: Generation Gap Bringing back Prensky’s (2001) theory on Digital natives vs. Digital Immigrants, the
third theme (Generation Gap) reveals the gap in what is deemed valuable by the two generations. The values of digital natives are driven by their peers, which in turn is influenced by media and
advertisement (eg. popstars, social media influencers, trending games, toys or merchandize). 25 Whereas their parents have their own set of values, shaped by their personal beliefs, life
experiences, culture and parenting goals that they hope to pass on to their children. Theme 3
reveals some of the intergenerational frictions and compromises that I found to be common in
the families. Whereas their parents have their own set of values, shaped by their personal beliefs, life
experiences, culture and parenting goals that they hope to pass on to their children. Theme 3
reveals some of the intergenerational frictions and compromises that I found to be common in
the families. Peer Pressure Kathy, mother of a 7-year-old boy and a 4-year-old girl who values frugal living shared
that her son frequently succumbs to peer pressure: “Beyblades are $20 each. That’s what the kids in school are into right now. It’s a whole
world of peer pressure… If you don’t have a Beyblade, you fall out of the boy group,
because that’s what all these boys are doing every recess and lunch. So, if we are
financially able, we want our kids to be a part of whichever group they want to be in”
Monica who has three boys added: Peer pressure also comes from the siblings. My younger wants what the other two have. There was a time when you would need 3 of something. Siblings have their mini
collections because they are not sharing all the time. Generational Conflicts In order to avoid conflict, some families said they try to avoid shopping with kids. Fariha
shared: I don’t go to the grocery shop in-person anymore as it would come with these extra
purchases….Even at a grocery store, there are hot wheels, that they [my children]
potentially ‘need’…So now we have Walmart groceries just delivered. 26 Materialism and clutter continued to be a common friction point, especially among families
living downtown: At least once a week they [my children] want to go to the dollar store…but it [the toys]
ends up in the trash, nobody uses it….Even the donation centers don’t accept because they
have so much Another parent, Janine, said whenever she tried to get her daughters to give away their toys the
girls would protest and claim they needed everything they owned. Even when they were
explained that the toy could be shared with somebody less fortunate, the girls pushed back. So,
she started donating the toys secretly hoping that the girls wouldn’t notice – and they didn’t. Monica shared a similar story about her three boys who always complained when they saw their
mother give away their toys. But once the moment passed, they would quickly forget about it. Emotional Compromises The study identified guilt (eg. I don’t want my child to feel sad that I gave away their toy)
and fear (eg. I don’t want my child to be an outcast in his social group) to be the overriding
emotions that made parents overlook financial values they were trying to teach. This often led to
avoidance tactics such as not going to the shopping mall or stealthily donating toys to declutter. Most parents wished that their children would make good decisions on their own – for instance
decide not to make an impulse purchase or willingly donate a toy. “My son has no impulse-
control” said one mother “He is responsible with his own money now because we buy him
things, but I fear once he is on his own, he will spend it all”. 27 27 DISCUSSION It can be understood from the first theme (Technology Gap), that if we want children to
be money savvy, they need to at the very least take their own money seriously. However, this
cannot be achieved if the money they own remains physical while the rest of the world uses
digital money. Bills and coins in the piggy bank simply do not align with how digital natives
understand money. Moreover, the process of counting and keeping track of money in the piggy
bank is too slow and tedious. Revisiting Prensky’s (2001b) theory on how the digital natives are
hard-wired to think fast and act instantly, whether it is $50 or $500 that a child owns, the money
needs to be stored, tracked and accessed digitally. Therefore, the technological solution that
arises from this theme is a digital wallet. It is also interesting to note that not being able to see physical money could potentially
lead to a false, and even contradictory assumptions of how money really works. For instance, one
parent shared that her son has “always” loved the chiming payment sound at the checkout
counter whenever something was purchased. “It is exciting for [my son]” she said, explaining
how it meant for the child that he would now get to go home with new things. Whitebread &
Bringham (2013) found that these early life experiences form a child’s fundamental assumption
of how the world works. Therefore, the child in this case would assume – you go to the store,
you put things in your cart, you hear the chiming sound and you go home with new things. The
chime would be perceived to serve the exact opposite of its true purpose. This suggests the need
for the digital wallet to visually depict the inflow and outflow of cash with every saving and
purchase decision, which informs one of the features of the prototype design. Theme 2 (Implementation Gap) suggests that piggy-bank cash system is not convenient
for parents either. For instance, most family shopping trips end with parents paying with their 28 cards at the checkout. Even if there is an understanding that the child will pay the parent back for
their purchase, it is a hard process to keep track of. Due to this inefficiency, a perfectly good
teachable moment in spending might be lost. DISCUSSION In order to tackle the problem from both ends,
parents and kids, money itself needs to exist on the same platform. If the real world of money is
cashless and digital, then kids’ world should not be any different. Once a common platform has
been established, only then can various foundations (eg. saving, spending and sharing) be laid. This finding underlies a key feature of the app design where parents (and even grandparents) are
able to use the same platform to establish a unified approach to their family financial
socialization needs. A technological solution may not be hard to implement, as observing families in their
home atmosphere confirmed my assumption that technology was a big part of every household. Two of the households were fully smart homes with voice commands and cameras performing
tasks such as turning on the lights and checking who was at the door. The rest were varying
degrees of technology assimilation – starting from a device in every room to a more digitized
version of the central family TV room. All children but 1 owned or shared a tablet with a sibling,
while 3 of them had their own cellphones. Regardless of age, gender or personality of a child,
they were all extremely comfortable using all mobile and digital device. Theme 3 (Generation Gap) brings to surface the world of peer pressure and consumer
mindset that today’s children are a part of. While this is perhaps the toughest pain point to
address, my findings were concurrent with LeBaron’s (2019) theory on experiential learning
suggesting that when children are empowered with their own purchase decisions, they put more
thought into what they buy. Sometimes, that means a child will decide against a frivolous
purchase even though all the kids have the item in question. Other times they could spend all 29 they have on frivolous items – both experiences can teach valuable lessons. Darleen shared that
her daughter who wanted an American Girl toy for $28 because all her friends had it put it right
back on the shelf when she was asked to spend her own cash. The app design therefore has a
decision-making component that helps children understand opportunity cost real-time. In addition to being responsible for their own money, if a child actually earns the money,
there will be an even deeper sense of responsibility when it comes to making financial choices. DISCUSSION Applying Kirkham’s (2002) theory of inductive learning, it can be predicted that if a child
experiences earning a wage for a job, putting that money aside for something they want, and
finally using it to buy their desired item – the experience could then be replicated once they are
in college, for instance, and want their first car. It will not cross their minds to buy first and pay
later as their formative experiences would have taught them to save first. Therefore, I have
included a way for parents to assign jobs to their children and for children to experience all the
decisions that come with earning a paycheque - which is an excellent practice for the future. 30 SOLUTION SOLUTION Based on the discussion of the various problems that hinder financial socialization for
digital natives, the solution I have designed is a productivity-style app for kids. It draws on
today’s educational/life management style tools that are well suited for this generation. The app
addresses the three themes of the study in the following ways: 1) Provides children a digital way
to manage money that matches what they observe in the real world. 2) Enables parents to keep
track of their children’s finances and implement money practices easily and consistently. 3)
Helps children make good choices through personal experience, sense of ownership and a visual
depiction of their progress that would make them place their personal goals above external
influences such as peer pressure and media ads. The app also solves for the intergenerational
tension observed in regard to money by aligning family members on financial education. Based on the discussion of the various problems that hinder financial socialization for
digital natives, the solution I have designed is a productivity-style app for kids. It draws on
today’s educational/life management style tools that are well suited for this generation. The app
addresses the three themes of the study in the following ways: 1) Provides children a digital way
to manage money that matches what they observe in the real world. 2) Enables parents to keep
track of their children’s finances and implement money practices easily and consistently. 3) The prototype has been designed based on three layers of users - the child, the parent and
the grandparent. The underlying objective is to help the child reach his goal with the help of the
parent and grandparent. The user journey of the prototype addresses the three major themes of
technology gap, implementation gap and generation gap in the following ways: 1) The app helps
the child organize his funds and visualize how his hard work is contributing towards his goals. 2)
The mother easily assigns a job and follows through with the weekly salary transfer without
breaking consistency. 3)The grandma can see what his grandson is saving for and give him a
little boost without getting into a conflict situation with the parents. Everyone is working
together to teach the child the value of hard work, saving and delaying gratification. 31 31 IMPLICATIONS AND FUTURE RESEARCH This is a small-scale study, but to my knowledge the first of its kind to research financial
socialization for digital natives. Previous studies such as LeBaron (2019), Jorgensen & Savla
(2010) and Danes & Dunrud (2005) have extensively reviewed various social aspects of raising
financially responsible children. Other studies (e.g. Danby et al., 2018; NAEYC & Fred Rogers
Center, 2012 and Takeuchi, 2011) provided evidence for the use of technology in education. However, the role of technology in financial socialization lacks research to date. Therefore, I
hope my findings and the accompanying prototype will contribute to the field of children’s
education technology and aid further research on the subject of digitizing financial education for
children. Looking forward, the prototype will undergo iterative testing to validate and build on
the design and interaction choices made as a result of the generative study. It is essential in
design thinking to test prototypes early and often to ensure the end product developed accurately
meets the users’ needs. As such, future versions will home in on the various ages and stages of a
child’s life, customizing the solutions further so the tool can evolve with the generation. 32 CONCLUSION This study suggests that there is a need for a technological intervention in children’s
financial education. This is guided by the literature that financial education is largely a social
process and our social landscape has been disrupted by technology. The study reveals that there
is a technological gap between the tools to teach money concepts at home and the realities of
money today, an implementation gap between parents desire to help children practice money at
home and the reality of their day-to-day busy lives and a generation gap that drives a wedge
between parents & grandparents and children & their peers. The solution proposed is a design
that bridges all three gaps through one app. 33 References Ages & Stages [online]. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-
stages/Pages/default.aspx Backett, K., & Alexander, H. (1991). Talking to young children about health: methods and
findings. Health Education Journal, 50(1), 34 38. https://doi.org/10.1177/001789699105000110 Bandura, A., & Walters, R. H. (1977). Social learning theory(Vol. 1). Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-hall. Berkowitz, M. W., & Grych, J. H. (1998). Fostering goodness: Teaching parents to facilitate
children's moral development. Journal of Moral Education, 27(3), 371-391. doi:10.1080/0305724980270307 Dam, R., & Siang, T. (2019). 5 Stages in the Design Thinking Process. Retrieved from
https://www.interaction-design.org/literature/article/5-stages-in-the-design-thinking-
process Danby, Susan (Professor of education), Fleer, M., Davidson, C., & Hatzigianni, M. (2018). Digital childhoods: Technologies and children's everyday lives. Springer. Danes, S. M., & Dunrud, T. (1993). Teaching children money habits for life. University of
Minnesota, Minneapolis Dijk, A. , Poorthuis, A. M., Thomaes, S. and Castro, B. O. (2018), Does Parent–Child Discussion
of Peer Provocations Reduce Young Children's Hostile Attributional Bias?. Child Dev,
89: 1908-1920. doi:10.1111/cdev.13087 Dollars and smart sense: Why every Canadian child needs to be financially literate (2018,
February 08). The Globe and Mail. Retrieved from https://www.theglobeandmail.com/ Estes, J. (2019). Generative vs. Evaluative Research: What’s the Difference and Why Do We
Need Each? | UserTesting Blog. [online] UserTesting Blog. Available at:
https://www.usertesting.com/blog/generative-vs-evaluative-research/ [Accessed 25 Jul. 2019]. Felicia,P. (Ed.). (2011). Handbook of Research on Improving Learning and Motivation through
Educational Games: Multidisciplinary Approaches: Multidisciplinary Approaches. iGi
Global. Garg, N., & Singh, S. (2018). Financial literacy among youth. International Journal of Social
Economics, 45(1), 173-186. doi:10.1108/IJSE-11-2016-0303 Gordon, A. (2017, March 23). Ontario launches plan to teach high school kids financial skills. The Star. Retrieved from https://www.thestar.com/ Government of Canada. (2019, April 16). Financial Consumer Agency of Canada. Retrieved
from https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/programs/financial-
literacy/financial-literacy-history.html Jorgensen, B. CONCLUSION L., & Savla, J. (2010). Financial literacy of young adults: The importance of
parental socialization. Family Relations, 59(4), 465-478. doi:10.1111/j.1741-
3729.2010.00616.x 34 Kobliner, Beth. (2017). Lead Make Your Kid A Money Genius (Even If You're Not): A Parents'
Guide for Kids 3 to 23. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster. LeBaron, A. B., Hill, E. J., Rosa, C. M., & Marks, L. D. (2018). Whats and hows of family
financial socialization: Retrospective reports of emerging adults, parents, and
grandparents.Family Relations, 67(4), 497-509. doi:10.1111/fare.12335 LeBaron, A. B., Runyan, S. D., Jorgensen, B. L., Marks, L. D., Li, X., & Hill, E. J. (2019). Practice Makes Perfect: Experiential Learning as a Method for Financial
Socialization. Journal of Family Issues, 40(4), 435–463. Mandell, L., & Klein, L. S. (2009). The impact of financial literacy education on subsequent
financial behavior. Journal of Financial Counseling and Planning, 20(1), 15. National Association for the Education of Young Children & Fred Rogers Center for Early
Learning and Children’s Media at Saint Vincent College. (2012). Technology and
interactive media as tools in early childhood programs serving children birth through
age 8 . Washington, DC: NAEYC. Retrieved from
http://www.naeyc.org/files/naeyc/file/positions/PS_technology_ WEB2.pdf . Prensky, M. (2001a). Digital natives, digital immigrants part 1. On the Horizon, 9(5), 1-6. doi:10.1108/10748120110424816 Prensky, M. (2001b). Digital natives, digital immigrants part 2: Do they really think differently? On the Horizon, 9(6), 1-6. doi:10.1108/10748120110424843 Hanington, B., & Martin, B. (2012). Universal methods of design: 100 ways to research complex
problems, develop innovative ideas, and design effective solutions. Rockport Publishers. Hira, T. K., Sabri, M. F., & Loibl, C. (2013). Financial socialization's impact on investment
orientation and household net worth. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 37(1),
29-35. doi:10.1111/ijcs.12003 Ipsos. (2017 ). Most Canadians feel they’re financially literate. Our survey says otherwise. Retrieved from https://www.lowestrates.ca/reports/lr-financial-literacy-canada-report.pdf Kim, J., & Chatterjee, S. (2013). Childhood financial socialization and young adults' financial
management. Journal of Financial Counseling and Planning, 24(1), 61. Kirkham, N. Z., Slemmer, J. A., & Johnson, S. P. (2002). Visual statistical learning in infancy:
Evidence for a domain general learning mechanism. Cognition, 83(2), B35-B42. doi:10.1016/S0010-0277(02)00004-5 Marquet, O., Alberico, C., Adlakha, D., & Hipp, J. A. (2017). Examining motivations to play
pokémon GO and their influence on perceived outcomes and physical activity. JMIR
Serious Games, 5(4), e21. doi:10.2196/games.8048 Marr, G. (2016, September 2). How Canadian kids are taught financial literacy from coast to
coast. Financial Post. Retrieved from https://business.financialpost.com/ Meltzoff, A.N. CONCLUSION (1988). Infant imitation and memory: Nine-month olds in immediate and deferred
tests. Child Development, 59, p. 217-225. Chicago. Moschis, G. (1985). The Role of Family Communication in Consumer Socialization of Children
and Adolescents. Journal of Consumer Research, 11(4), 898-913. Nebel, S., Schneider, S., & Rey, G. D. (2016). Mining learning and crafting scientific
experiments: A literature review on the use of minecraft in education and
research. Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 19(2), 355-366. 35 Osler, J. (2018, November 30). The future of cash in Canada. CBC News. Retrieved from
https://www.cbc.ca/ Rideout, V. (2017). The Common Sense census: Media use by kids age zero to eight. San
Francisco, CA: Common Sense Media. Schuchardt, J., Hanna, S. D., Hira, T. K., Lyons, A. C., Palmer, L., & Xiao, J. J. (2009). Financial literacy and education research priorities. Journal of Financial Counseling and
Planning, 20(1), 84. Schug, M. C., & Birkey, C. J. (1985). The development of children's economic
reasoning. Theory & Research in Social Education, 13(1), 31-42. doi:10.1080/00933104.1985.10505494 Soman, D. (2017, December 6). Why financial literacy should be taught in every school [Web
log post]. Retrieved from https://theconversation.com/why-financial-literacyshould-be-
taught-in-every-school-88458 Serido, J., & Deenanath, V. (2016). Financial parenting: Promoting financial self-reliance of
young consumers. In J. J. Xiao (Ed.), Handbook of consumer finance research (2nd ed.,
pp. 291-300). New York, NY: Springer. Stephen, C., Stevenson, O., & Adey, C. (2013). Young children engaging with technologies at home: The influence of family context. Journal of Early Childhood Research,
11(2), 149-164. doi:10.1177/1476718X12466215 Takeuchi, L. (2011). Families matter: Designing media for a digital age. In New York: The Joan
Ganz Cooney Center at Sesame Workshop. Tang, N., & Peter, P. (2015). Financial knowledge acquisition among the young: The role of
financial education, financial experience, and parents’ financial experience. Financial
Services Review, 24, 119-137. Totenhagen, C. J., Casper, D. M., Faber, K. M., Bosch, L. A., Wiggs, C. B., & Borden, L. M. (2015). Youth financial literacy: A review of key considerations and promising delivery Watkins, C. (2001) Learning about Learning enhances Performance, Institute of Education
School Improvement Network (Research Matters series no. 13) Werner, N. E., Eaton, A. D., Lyle, K., Tseng, H., & Holst, B. (2014). Maternal social coaching
quality interrupts the development of relational aggression during early childhood:
Coaching and relational aggression. Social Development, 23(3), 470-486. doi:10.1111/sode.12048 Whitebread, David and Sue Bingham. 2013. Habit Formation and Learning in Young Children. Wilson, E. K., Dalberth, B. T., Koo, H. P. and Gard, J. C. (2010), Parents' Perspectives on
Talking to Preteenage Children About Sex. Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive
Health, 42: 56-63. doi:10.1363/4205610 CONCLUSION London: Money Advice Service. Wilson, E. K., Dalberth, B. T., Koo, H. P. and Gard, J. C. (2010), Parents' Perspectives on
Talking to Preteenage Children About Sex. Perspectives on Sexual and Reproductive
Health, 42: 56-63. doi:10.1363/4205610 36
|
https://openalex.org/W2944508336
|
https://www.biorxiv.org/content/biorxiv/early/2019/03/08/352344.full.pdf
|
English
| null |
A highly predictive signature of cognition and brain atrophy for progression to Alzheimer's dementia
|
Gigascience
| 2,019
|
cc-by
| 15,820
|
.
CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019.
;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Abstract Clinical trials in Alzheimer’s disease need to enroll patients whose cognition will decline
over time, if left untreated, in order to demonstrate the efficacy of an intervention. Machine
learning models used to screen for patients at risk of progression to dementia should therefore
favor specificity (detecting only progressors) over sensitivity (detecting all progressors),
especially when the prevalence of progressors is low. Here, we explore whether such
high-risk patients can be identified using cognitive assessments and structural neuroimaging,
by training machine learning tools in a high specificity regime. A multimodal signature of
Alzheimer's dementia was first extracted from ADNI1. We then validated the predictive
value of this signature on ADNI1 patients with mild cognitive impairment (N=235). The
signature was optimized to predict progression to dementia over three years with low
sensitivity (55.1%) but high specificity (95.6%), resulting in only moderate accuracy (69.3%)
but high positive predictive value (80.4%, adjusted for a "typical" 33% prevalence rate of true
progressors). These results were replicated in ADNI2 (N=235), with 87.8% adjusted positive
predictive value (96.7% specificity, 47.3% sensitivity, 85.1% accuracy). We found that
cognitive measures alone could identify high-risk individuals, with structural measurements
providing
a
slight
improvement. The
signature
had comparable receiver operating
characteristics to standard machine learning tools, yet a marked improvement in positive
predictive value was achieved over the literature by selecting a high specificity operating
point. The multimodal signature can be readily applied for the enrichment of clinical trials. Short running title: Signature of future Alzheimer’s dementia Short running title: Signature of future Alzheimer’s dementia Angela Tam1,2,3,†, Christian Dansereau1,4, Yasser Itturia-Medina3, Sebastian Urchs3, Pierre
Orban1,5,6, Hanad Sharmarke1, John Breitner2,3, Pierre Bellec1,4,†, for the Alzheimer’s Disease
Neuroimaging Initiative* 1. Centre de Recherche de l'Institut Universitaire de Gériatrie de Montréal, Montréal,
CA 2. Douglas Hospital Research Centre, McGill University, Montréal, CA 3. McGill University, Montréal, CA 4. Département d'Informatique et de recherche opérationnelle, Université de Montréal,
Montréal, CA 5. Centre de Recherche de l'Institut Universitaire en Santé Mentale de Montréal,
Montréal, CA 6. Département de Psychiatrie, Université de Montréal, Montréal, CA *Data used in preparation of this article were obtained from the Alzheimer's Disease
Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) database (adni.loni.usc.edu). As such, the investigators
within the ADNI contributed to the design and implementation of ADNI and/or provided data
but did not participate in analysis or writing of this report. A complete listing of ADNI
investigators
can
be
found
at: http://adni.loni.usc.edu/wp-content/uploads/how_to_apply/ADNI_Acknowledgement_List.pd †Corresponding authors:
angela.tam@mail.mcgill.ca
pierre.bellec@criugm.qc.ca
4545 Queen Mary Rd
Montreal QC
Canada H3W 1W6 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Keywords Alzheimer's disease, mild cognitive impairment, machine learning, neuroimaging, cognition 1 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Introduction CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint enrichment in clinical trials, a more relevant metric is positive predictive value (PPV), which
is the proportion of subjects that actually progress to dementia when they have been
identified as such by the model. The PPV of a model is dependent on the baseline rate of
progression in the sample, with a typical rate (within three years or more) in MCI patients
being 33.6% [1]. Assuming a 33.6% baseline rate, it is possible to calculate the PPVs of
published models in the literature, based on reported sensitivity and specificity scores. The
adjusted PPV for models using cognitive and structural measures ranged from 50 to 75%
[7,8,10–16]. In other words, up to half of subjects who were identified as progressors by
published algorithms would not actually progress to dementia in a typical MCI sample. We
therefore aimed to adapt the training regimen of predictive models to favor specificity over
sensitivity, with the hypothesis that in this regime the models will identify progressors with
high PPV. We expected that optimizing for high specificity will result in a low number of
false positives, which is particularly important when the prevalence of progressors is low and
therefore the susceptibility of the predictive model to identify false positive progressors is
high. enrichment in clinical trials, a more relevant metric is positive predictive value (PPV), which
is the proportion of subjects that actually progress to dementia when they have been
identified as such by the model. The PPV of a model is dependent on the baseline rate of
progression in the sample, with a typical rate (within three years or more) in MCI patients
being 33.6% [1]. Assuming a 33.6% baseline rate, it is possible to calculate the PPVs of
published models in the literature, based on reported sensitivity and specificity scores. Introduction Alzheimer’s disease (AD), a leading cause of dementia, is marked by the abnormal
accumulation of amyloid 𝛽(A𝛽) and hyperphosphorylated tau proteins in the brain, which
leads to widespread neurodegeneration. AD has a long prodromal phase, and it has been
difficult to predict which individuals will decline and experience AD dementia. While mild
cognitive impairment (MCI) puts individuals at risk, only a fraction (33.6% on average) of
MCI patients will develop dementia within a period of three years, as shown in a
meta-analysis of 41 studies [1]. Identifying MCI patients who will progress to AD dementia
with enough specificity has thus been a challenge for clinical trials [2]. This lack of
prognostic power may be due to individual variability. Different clinical phenotypes have
been described where patients will exhibit distinct cognitive deficits [3]. Previous work has
also characterized neuropathological subtypes based on the distribution of neurofibrillary
tangles [4], which correspond well to distinct patterns of brain atrophy [5]. Different subtypes
of brain atrophy have also been associated with different rates of progression to dementia [6]. The implications for prognosis are profound: only a subgroup of patients will experience a
sharp cognitive decline that can be reliably predicted. We therefore propose to identify a
subset of individuals with a homogenous signature of brain atrophy and cognitive deficits
who will progress to AD dementia with high precision. There is a large field focused on using machine learning to automatically detect MCI
patients who will progress to AD dementia based on imaging and cognitive features. For
models combining structural MRI and cognition, state-of-the-art performance is 79%
accuracy (76% specificity, 83% sensitivity) [7]. Some groups have achieved higher
accuracies ranging from 82-97% when using other imaging methods, such as A𝛽positron
emission tomography [8] or resting-state functional MRI [9]. Although this increase in
accuracy may suggest that A𝛽imaging and resting-state functional MRI are better features,
these imaging measures are more invasive, costly, and currently lack the large scale of
validation of tools that are already widely used in clinical settings, such as cognitive
assessments and structural MRI. Given the need to develop tools that will easily scale up in
clinical settings, we propose to focus on predictive models that use structural imaging and
cognition as features. Models are typically trained to maximize accuracy, defined as the proportion of
subjects that were correctly identified, either as progressors or non-progressors. For 2 . Main findings We used unsupervised clustering
on atrophy maps generated from
structural images in AD and CN
subjects. Seven distinct patterns of atrophy
were identified, some of which
were strongly associated with a
diagnosis of AD (Figure 1b). 2a) Replicate previous findings
from works that used cognitive
and structural features to predict
progression to AD from MCI A linear support vector machine,
that was optimized for accuracy,
was trained on the following
features: 1) structural atrophy
patterns, 2) multi-domain
cognitive assessments, and 3) a
combination of both. The support vector machine
based on cognitive features had
higher predictive value than the
structural MRI signature, similar
to previous findings [7]. See
Figures 2 and 3. The two-stage algorithm resulted
in a model that achieved high
specificity and high PPV, with
reduced sensitivity (Figure 2). Three high-risk signatures were
generated (Figure 5). We used a two-stage algorithm to
ensure we were maximizing
specificity over sensitivity. We
trained on the following features:
1) structural atrophy patterns, 2)
multi-domain cognitive
assessments, and 3) a combination
of both. The model achieved high
specificity and high PPV, again at
the cost of sensitivity and
accuracy (Figures 2 and 4). We measured PPV, specificity,
sensitivity, and accuracy of the
model in predicting progressors in
two separate MCI cohorts. We compared the ROC
performance of the two-stage
algorithm against standard
algorithms (e.g. KNN, GNB,
SVM with a RBF kernel). The performance of the two-stage
algorithm did not differ from
standard algorithms, in terms of
area under a ROC curve, but was
the only one to operate in a
high-specificity, low sensitivity
regime (Figure 3). 5) Validate whether this high-risk
signature represents a prodromal
phase of AD 5) Validate whether this high-risk
signature represents a prodromal
phase of AD Tagged high-risk individuals
experienced sharper cognitive
decline and higher levels of
amyloid and tau than non-tagged
individuals (Figure 4). We compared cognitive decline,
amyloid and tau burden in tagged
high-risk individuals against those
who were not. 6) Assess the complementarity of
cognitive and structural measures We examined whether there was
overlap in the subjects that were
identified by the three high-risk
signatures. The majority of subjects that were
identified by the multimodal
high-risk signature had been
identified as such by the unimodal
cognitive and unimodal structural
signatures. The unimodal
cognitive signature identified the
majority of all high-risk subjects
(Figure 6). 2b) Train a model in a high
specificity regime to identify high
confidence AD subjects with a
high-risk signature The two-stage algorithm resulted
in a model that achieved high
specificity and high PPV, with
reduced sensitivity (Figure 2).
Three high-risk signatures were
generated (Figure 5). Introduction The performance of the two-stage
algorithm did not differ from
standard algorithms, in terms of
area under a ROC curve, but was
the only one to operate in a
high specificity low sensitivity Table 1. Summary of objectives, experiments, and main findings Introduction The
adjusted PPV for models using cognitive and structural measures ranged from 50 to 75%
[7,8,10–16]. In other words, up to half of subjects who were identified as progressors by
published algorithms would not actually progress to dementia in a typical MCI sample. We
therefore aimed to adapt the training regimen of predictive models to favor specificity over
sensitivity, with the hypothesis that in this regime the models will identify progressors with
high PPV. We expected that optimizing for high specificity will result in a low number of
false positives, which is particularly important when the prevalence of progressors is low and
therefore the susceptibility of the predictive model to identify false positive progressors is
high. The overall goal of this work was to develop a model to identify individuals who are
at high risk of progression to AD dementia with high PPV and specificity, using structural
MRI and cognitive features. We aimed to show that by training standard machine learning
tools in a high specificity regime, we can identify the most robust progressor MCI patients
with high confidence. We further wanted to assess whether those high risk individuals had
prodromal AD, by examining longitudinal cognitive decline, as well as A𝛽and tau burden in
these individuals. We finally aimed to evaluate the complementarity of features derived from
cognition and atrophy patterns by examining the overlap of high risk individuals who were
identified as such by each modality. Although the complementarity of cognitive and
structural measures has been extensively studied for prognosis of dementia in a general MCI
population, the main contribution of this work is to examine their complementarity in the
specific context of a high risk signature which achieves high specificity and PPV, at the cost
of low sensitivity when the class of interest is relatively rare. Specific aims, as well as a
summary of experiments and the main results, are listed in Table 1. 3 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. Introduction It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Table 1. Summary of objectives, experiments, and main findings
Specific objectives
Experiments
Main findings
1) Identify subtypes of brain
atrophy patterns
We used unsupervised clustering
on atrophy maps generated from
structural images in AD and CN
subjects. Seven distinct patterns of atrophy
were identified, some of which
were strongly associated with a
diagnosis of AD (Figure 1b). 2a) Replicate previous findings
from works that used cognitive
and structural features to predict
progression to AD from MCI
A linear support vector machine,
that was optimized for accuracy,
was trained on the following
features: 1) structural atrophy
patterns, 2) multi-domain
cognitive assessments, and 3) a
combination of both. The support vector machine
based on cognitive features had
higher predictive value than the
structural MRI signature, similar
to previous findings [7]. See
Figures 2 and 3. 2b) Train a model in a high
specificity regime to identify high
confidence AD subjects with a
high-risk signature
We used a two-stage algorithm to
ensure we were maximizing
specificity over sensitivity. We
trained on the following features:
1) structural atrophy patterns, 2)
multi-domain cognitive
assessments, and 3) a combination
of both. The two-stage algorithm resulted
in a model that achieved high
specificity and high PPV, with
reduced sensitivity (Figure 2). Three high-risk signatures were
generated (Figure 5). 3) Assess if the high-risk signature
generated by the two-stage
algorithm can identify progressors
in MCI subjects within a three
year period
We measured PPV, specificity,
sensitivity, and accuracy of the
model in predicting progressors in
two separate MCI cohorts. The model achieved high
specificity and high PPV, again at
the cost of sensitivity and
accuracy (Figures 2 and 4). 4) Test the performance of the
two-stage algorithm against
standard algorithms
We compared the ROC
performance of the two-stage
algorithm against standard
algorithms (e.g. KNN, GNB,
SVM with a RBF kernel). 6) Assess the complementarity of
cognitive and structural measures The model achieved high
specificity and high PPV, again at
the cost of sensitivity and
accuracy (Figures 2 and 4). Data Data used in the preparation of this article were obtained from the Alzheimer's
Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) database (adni.loni.usc.edu). The ADNI was
launched in 2003 as a public-private partnership, led by Principal Investigator Michael W. Weiner, MD. The primary goal of ADNI has been to test whether serial magnetic resonance
imaging (MRI), positron emission tomography (PET), other biological markers, and clinical
and neuropsychological assessment can be combined to measure the progression of mild
cognitive impairment (MCI) and early Alzheimer's disease (AD). For up-to-date information,
see www.adni-info.org. We took baseline T1-weighted MRI scans from the ADNI1 (228 CN, 397 MCI, 192
AD) and ADNI2 (218 CN, 354 MCI, 103 AD) studies. For a detailed description of MRI
acquisition
details,
see
http://adni.loni.usc.edu/methods/documents/mri-protocols/. All
subjects gave informed consent to participate in these studies, which were approved by the
research ethics committees of the institutions involved in data acquisition. Consent was
obtained for data sharing and secondary analysis, the latter being approved by the ethics
committee at the CRIUGM. For the MCI groups, each individual must have had at least 36
months of follow-up for inclusion in our analysis. We also further stratified the MCI groups
into stable (sMCI), who never received any change in their diagnosis, and progressors
(pMCI), who received a diagnosis of AD dementia within 36 months of follow-up. pMCI
who progressed to AD dementia after 36 months were excluded. After applying these
inclusion/exclusion criteria, we were left with 280 and 268 eligible MCI subjects in ADNI1
and ADNI2 respectively. Main findings We examined whether there was
overlap in the subjects that were
identified by the three high-risk
signatures. 4 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Structural features from voxel-based morphometry Images were processed with the NeuroImaging Analysis Kit (NIAK) version 0.18.1
(https://hub.docker.com/r/simexp/niak-boss/), the MINC toolkit (http://bic-mni.github.io/)
version
0.3.18,
and
SPM12
(http://www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm/software/spm12/)
under
CentOS with Octave (http://gnu.octave.org) version 4.0.2. Preprocessing of MRI data was
executed in parallel on the Cedar supercomputer (https://docs.computecanada.ca/wiki/Cedar), 5 5 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint using the Pipeline System for Octave and Matlab (PSOM) [21]. Each T1 image was linearly
co-registered to the Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) ICBM152 stereotaxic symmetric
template [22], using the CIVET pipeline [23], and then re-oriented to the AC-PC line. Each
image was segmented into grey matter, white matter, and CSF probabilistic maps. The
DARTEL toolbox [24] was used to normalize the grey matter segmentations to a predefined
grey matter template in MNI152 space. Each map was modulated to preserve the total
amount of signal and smoothed with a 8 mm isotropic Gaussian blurring kernel. After quality
control of the normalized grey matter segmentations, we were left with 621 subjects in
ADNI1 (out of 700, 88.7% success rate) and 515 subjects in ADNI2 (out of 589, 87.4%
success rate). using the Pipeline System for Octave and Matlab (PSOM) [21]. Each T1 image was linearly
co-registered to the Montreal Neurological Institute (MNI) ICBM152 stereotaxic symmetric
template [22], using the CIVET pipeline [23], and then re-oriented to the AC-PC line. Each
image was segmented into grey matter, white matter, and CSF probabilistic maps. The
DARTEL toolbox [24] was used to normalize the grey matter segmentations to a predefined
grey matter template in MNI152 space. Each map was modulated to preserve the total
amount of signal and smoothed with a 8 mm isotropic Gaussian blurring kernel. After quality
control of the normalized grey matter segmentations, we were left with 621 subjects in
ADNI1 (out of 700, 88.7% success rate) and 515 subjects in ADNI2 (out of 589, 87.4%
success rate). Structural features from voxel-based morphometry We extracted subtypes to characterize variability of grey matter distribution with the
CN and AD samples from ADNI1. In order to reduce the impact of factors of no interest that
may have influenced the clustering procedure, we regressed out age, sex, mean grey matter
volume (GMV), and total intracranial volume (TIV), using a mass univariate linear regression
model at each voxel. We then derived a spatial Pearson's correlation coefficient between all
pairs of individual maps after confound regression. This defined a subject x subject (377 x
377) similarity matrix which was entered into a Ward hierarchical clustering procedure
(Figure 1a). Based on visual inspection of the similarity matrix, we identified 7 subgroups
(Figure 1b). Each subtype was defined as the average map of each subgroup. For each
subject, we computed spatial correlations between their map and each subtype, which we call
weights (Figure 1a). The weights formed a n subject x m subtypes (n=377, m=7) matrix,
which was included in the feature space for all predictive models including voxel-based
morphometry (VBM) throughout this work. As in our previous works [20,25], we chose to
use weights, which can be interpreted as continuous measures for subtype affinity, over
discrete subtype membership because the latter is less informative as most individuals
express similarity to multiple subtypes [26]. Note that although we chose to present our
findings with 7 subtypes, we examined how the number of subtypes may impact our
subsequent predictions. There was no significant difference in model performance when we
changed the number of subtypes (see Table S1 in supplementary material). 6 6 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Figure 1. Subtyping procedure and resulting subtypes. a) A hierarchical clustering procedure
identified 7 subtypes, or subgroups, of individuals with similar patterns of grey matter topography
within the ADNI1 cohort of CN and AD subjects (top). Structural features from voxel-based morphometry A measure of spatial similarity, called subtype
weight, between a single individual’s grey matter volume map and the average of a given subtype was
calculated for all individuals and all subtypes (bottom). b) Maps of the 7 subtypes showing the
distribution of grey matter across all voxels relative to the average. CN* and AD* denote significant
associations between the subtype weights and diagnoses of cognitively normal (CN) or Alzheimer's
dementia (AD) respectively. Figure 1. Subtyping procedure and resulting subtypes. a) A hierarchical clustering procedure
identified 7 subtypes, or subgroups, of individuals with similar patterns of grey matter topography
within the ADNI1 cohort of CN and AD subjects (top). A measure of spatial similarity, called subtype
weight, between a single individual’s grey matter volume map and the average of a given subtype was
calculated for all individuals and all subtypes (bottom). b) Maps of the 7 subtypes showing the
distribution of grey matter across all voxels relative to the average. CN* and AD* denote significant
associations between the subtype weights and diagnoses of cognitively normal (CN) or Alzheimer's
dementia (AD) respectively. Cognitive features We took baseline neuropsychological scores for each subject from several cognitive
domains: memory from the composite score ADNI-MEM [27], executive function from the
composite score ADNI-EF [28], language from the Boston Naming Test (BNT), visuospatial
from the clock drawing test, and global cognition from the Alzheimer's Disease Assessment
Scale-Cognitive (ADAS13). We chose measures that span multiple cognitive domains as it
has been suggested that the use of a combination of neuropsychological measures is likely the
best approach to predicting incipient dementia [29]. These scores were included as features
for the predictive models involving cognition. Thirteen subjects across both ADNI1 and 7 7 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint ADNI2 (8 AD, 5 MCI) had to be excluded due to missing values in their cognitive
assessments. See Table 2 for demographic information of subjects who were included in
analyses. Table 2. Demographic information for post-QC subjects in ADNI1 and ADNI2. ADNI1
CN
sMCI
pMCI
AD
N
205
88
147
165
Age ± SD
76.1 ± 5.0
74.0 ± 7.6
74.3 ± 7.1
75.4 ± 7.5
Female %
51.7
40.9
40.8
51.5
APOE4+ %
27.8
37.5
68.7
65.4
ADAS13 ± SD
9.5 ± 4.3
14.3 ± 5.5
21.3 ± 5.3
28.6 ± 7.1
MMSE ± SD
29.1 ± 1.0
27.7 ± 1.7
26.7 ± 1.7
23.4 ± 2.0
ADNI2
CN
sMCI
pMCI
AD
N
188
180
55
89
Age ± SD
72.8 ± 6.1
70.8 ± 7.3
72.1 ± 7.1
74.4 ± 7.8
Female %
54.0
47.8
49.1
46.1
APOE4+ %
29.4
35.6
65.4
71.3
ADAS13 ± SD
9.1 ± 4.2
11.8 ± 5.3
21.4 ± 6.5
31.6 ± 8.7
MMSE ± SD
29.1 ± 1.1
28.4 ± 1.6
27.3 ± 1.9
23.1 ± 2.3
ADAS13=Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale - Cognitive subscale (13 items);
MMSE=Mini Mental State Examination Table 2. Cognitive features Demographic information for post-QC subjects in ADNI1 and ADNI2. ADAS13=Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale - Cognitive subscale (13 items); Prediction of high confidence AD dementia cases in ADNI1 We trained a linear support vector machine (SVM) model with a linear kernel, as
implemented by Scikit-learn [30] version 0.18 to classify AD vs CN from ADNI1 to get a
baseline prediction accuracy. We then used a two-step method to select an operating point for
the linear SVM to obtain a highly precise and specific classification [20]. This was done by
replicating the SVM prediction via subsampling and identifying the patients with highly 8 8 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint robust prediction outcomes, i.e. who are consistently identified as true AD cases (true
positives) during testing, regardless of the training subsample. This approach was found, in
practice, to lead to a highly specific prediction, in addition to offering a guarantee of
robustness; see [20] for more information. Specifically here, a tenfold cross-validation loop
was used to estimate the performance of the trained model. Classes were balanced inversely
proportional to class frequencies in the input data for the training. A nested cross-validation
loop (stratified shuffle split with 50 splits and 20% test size, i.e. a random permutation
cross-validator was used to split the data into 50 training and test sets, where the size of the
test set was always 20% of the original sample size) was used for the grid search of the SVM
hyperparameter C (grid was 10-2 to 101 with 15 equal steps). We randomly selected
subsamples of the dataset, retaining a set percentage of participants in each subsample. For
each subsample, a separate SVM model was trained to predict AD or CN in ADNI1. The
SVM training was replicated a number of times. Both the subsample size and the number of
subsamples were selected to maximize the positive predictive value of the prediction of
sMCI vs pMCI in ADNI1, as described below. Prediction of high confidence AD dementia cases in ADNI1 Predictions were made on the remaining
subjects that were not used for training, and, for each subject, we calculated a hit probability
defined as the frequency of correct classification across all SVM replications in which the test
set contained that subject. High confidence AD cases were defined as individuals with 100%
hit probabilities with the AD label. Next, we trained a logistic regression classifier [31], with
L1 regularization on the coefficients, to predict the high confidence AD cases. A stratified
shuffle split (500 splits, 50% test size) was used to estimate the performance of the model for
the grid search of the hyperparameter C (grid was 10-2 to 101 with 15 equal steps) on the
overall ADNI1 sample, and the same hyperparameters were used for all SVM replications. We used the entire CN and AD sample from ADNI1 to obtain three highly predictive
signatures (HPS) (i.e. models), 1) one using VBM subtype weights as features (VBM only),
2) one using only cognitive features (COG only), 3) and one using the combination of VBM
subtype weights and cognitive features (VCOG). In all three signatures, age, sex, mean
GMV, and TIV were also included as features. Prediction of progression to AD dementia from the MCI stage in ADNI1 The ADNI2 sample was then used as an independent replication (test) set, to
establish
the
performance of the two-stage model without further changes to the
hyperparameters. Prediction of progression to AD dementia from the MCI stage in ADNI1 The logistic regression trained on AD vs CN was used to identify MCI patients who
have a HPS of AD dementia in ADNI1. Our hyperparameters for this logistic regression were 9 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint optimized based on the number of subsamples and subsample size that produced the
maximum specificity and PPV for the classification of sMCI (n=89) vs pMCI (n=155) in
ADNI1, while maintaining a minimum of 30% sensitivity. We varied the number of
subsamples (100, 500, 1000) and subsample size (10%, 20%, 30%, 50%) to perturb the
model and identify subjects that had robust outcomes during the testing phase regardless of
the training subsample. We then re-trained our models to classify AD vs CN in ADNI1 with
these optimized hyperparameters. This was done for all three signatures. In brief, we used the
AD and CN sample from ADNI1 as a training set, and the MCI subjects from ADNI1 as a
validation set. The ADNI2 sample was then used as an independent replication (test) set, to
establish
the
performance of the two-stage model without further changes to the
hyperparameters. optimized based on the number of subsamples and subsample size that produced the
maximum specificity and PPV for the classification of sMCI (n=89) vs pMCI (n=155) in
ADNI1, while maintaining a minimum of 30% sensitivity. We varied the number of
subsamples (100, 500, 1000) and subsample size (10%, 20%, 30%, 50%) to perturb the
model and identify subjects that had robust outcomes during the testing phase regardless of
the training subsample. We then re-trained our models to classify AD vs CN in ADNI1 with
these optimized hyperparameters. This was done for all three signatures. In brief, we used the
AD and CN sample from ADNI1 as a training set, and the MCI subjects from ADNI1 as a
validation set. Statistical test of differences in model performance We
used
Monte-Carlo
simulations
to
generate
confidence
intervals
on
the
performance (i.e. accuracy, PPV, specificity and sensitivity) of both linear SVM and HPS
models for their predictions of AD vs CN and pMCI vs sMCI. Taking the observed
sensitivity and specificity, and using similar sample sizes to our experiment, we replicated the
number of true and false positive detection 100000 times using independent Bernoulli
variables, and derived replications of PPV, specificity and sensitivity. By comparing these
replications to the accuracy, sensitivity, specificity and PPV observed in both models, we
estimated a p-value for differences in model performance [32]. A p-value smaller than 0.05
was interpreted as evidence of a significant difference in performance, and 0.001 as strong
evidence. We also used this approach to compare the performance of the combined features
(VCOG) to the models containing VBM features (VBM) or cognitive features (COG) only. Note that, based on our hypotheses regarding the behaviour of the HPS model, the tests were
one-sided for increased accuracy, specificity and PPV, and one-sided for decreased
sensitivity. To assess the performance of the HPS models against standard machine learning
algorithms, we used four algorithms (SVM with a RBF kernel, K nearest neighbors, random
forest, and Gaussian naive Bayes) to train models to classify AD vs CN in the ADNI1
dataset. We then tested and validated these models on classifying AD vs CN in ADNI2 and
finally pMCI vs sMCI in both ADNI1 and ADNI2 separately. See the supplementary material 10 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint for details of the implementations of these latter algorithms. We then generated ROC curves
and calculated the area under the curve (AUC) for each model and classification (AD vs CN;
pMCI vs sMCI) in both ADNI1 and ADNI2. high confidence MCI subjects CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint ANOVAs comparing the likelihood ratio suggested a significant improvement in model fit. All tests were performed separately on the ADNI1 and ADNI2 datasets. These tests were
implemented in R version 3.3.2 with the library nlme version 3.1.128 [36]. high confidence MCI subjects Based on the classifications resulting from the linear SVM and HPS models, we
separated the MCI subjects into three different groups: 1) High confidence, subjects who
were selected by the HPS model as hits, 2) Low confidence, subjects who were selected by
the linear SVM model as hits but were not selected by the HPS model, and 3) Negative,
subjects who were not selected as hits by either algorithm. In order to validate whether the high confidence subjects represented individuals who
were in a prodromal phase of AD, we tested if this subgroup was enriched for progression to
dementia, APOE4 carriers, females, and subjects who were positive for A𝛽and tau
pathology. Positivity of AD pathology was determined by CSF measurements of A𝛽1-42
peptide and total tau with cut-off values of less than 192 pg/mL and greater than 93 pg/mL
respectively [33]. We implemented Monte-Carlo simulations, where we selected 100000
random subgroups out of the original MCI sample. By comparing the proportion of
progressors, APOE4 carriers, females, A𝛽-positive, and tau-positive subjects in these null
replications to the actual observed values in the HPS subgroup, we estimated a p-value [32]
(one sided for increase). A p-value smaller than 0.05 was interpreted as evidence of a
significant enrichment, and 0.001 as strong evidence. One-way ANOVAs were used to evaluate differences between the HPS groupings
with respect to age. Post-hoc Tukey's HSD tests were done to assess pairwise differences
among the three classes (high confidence, low confidence, negative). These tests were
implemented in Python with the SciPy library [34] version 0.19.1 and StatsModels library
[35] version 0.8.0. To explore the impact of HPS grouping on cognitive trajectories, linear mixed effects
models were performed to evaluate the main effects of and interactions between the HPS
groups and time on ADAS13 scores up to 36 months of follow-up. The models were first fit
with a random effect of participant and then were fit with random slopes (time | participant) if 11 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . Public code, data availability and reproducibility We then generated a number of multivariate normal data points
that matched the number of subjects found in each subgroup, using the empirical mean and
covariance matrix of each subgroup. Finally, the range of the simulated data was clipped to
the range of the original real data, and the simulated sex data points were binarized by nearest
neighbour. the 16 variables of interest. We then generated a number of multivariate normal data points
that matched the number of subjects found in each subgroup, using the empirical mean and
covariance matrix of each subgroup. Finally, the range of the simulated data was clipped to
the range of the original real data, and the simulated sex data points were binarized by nearest
neighbour. The statistics from the predictive model in the original implementation are similar to
that of the simulated data. The model predicted the progression of dementia from MCI in
ADNI1 with a PPV of 93.1% (specificity of 93.2%) on real data. This coincides with a 93.3%
PPV (specificity of 94.3%) that we get when using the simulated data. Similarly, with the
ADNI2 dataset the model achieved a 81.3% PPV (specificity of 96.7%) from the real data
and a 75.7% PPV (specificity of 95.0%) from the simulated data. Public code, data availability and reproducibility The
code
used
in
this
experiment
is
available
on
a
GitHub
repository
(https://github.com/SIMEXP/vcog_hps_ad)
and
zenodo
(https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1444081). and We shared a notebook replicating all the machine learning experiments, starting after
the generation of VBM subtypes. However, in order to protect the privacy of the study
participants, we could not share individual subtype weights alongside other behavioural data
and diagnostic information. We thus created parametric (Gaussian) bootstrap simulations,
based on group statistics alone, that will allow interested readers to replicate results similar to
those presented in this manuscript, using the exact same code and computational environment
that were used on real data, but with purely synthetic data instead. The notebook can be
executed online via the binder platform (http://mybinder.org), and runs into a docker
container (https://mybinder.org/v2/gh/SIMEXP/vcog_hps_ad/master?filepath=%2Fvcog_hpc_predictio
n_simulated_data.ipynb), built from a configuration file that is available on GitHub
(https://github.com/SIMEXP/vcog_hps_ad/blob/master/Dockerfile). The container itself is
available on Docker Hub (https://hub.docker.com/r/simexp/vcog_hps_ad/). The simulated
data
was
archived
on
figshare
(https://figshare.com/articles/Simulated_cognitive_and_structural_MRI_data_from_ADNI/71
32757). (https://mybinder.org/v2/gh/SIMEXP/vcog_hps_ad/master?filepath=%2Fvcog_hpc_predictio
n_simulated_data.ipynb), built from a configuration file that is available on GitHub
(https://github.com/SIMEXP/vcog_hps_ad/blob/master/Dockerfile). The container itself is
available on Docker Hub (https://hub.docker.com/r/simexp/vcog_hps_ad/). The simulated
data
was
archived
on
figshare
(https://figshare.com/articles/Simulated_cognitive_and_structural_MRI_data_from_ADNI/71
32757). The simulation included the following 16 variables: age, sex, mean grey matter
volume, total intracranial volume, 5 cognitive assessment scores and 7 VBM subtype weights
from both ADNI1 and ADNI2. Subjects that had missing values for these variables were
discarded from the simulation, leaving N=1115 subjects. We stratified the population into 12
subgroups: the four clinical labels (AD, pMCI, sMCI, CN), each further subdivided by the
three prediction subclasses identified in this paper (negative, low confidence, high
confidence). For each subgroup, we estimated the average and covariance matrices between 12 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint the 16 variables of interest. Subtypes of brain atrophy Subtype 1 was characterized by reduced relative GMV in the occipital, parietal and
posterior temporal lobes. Subtype 2 displayed reduced relative GMV across the cortex,
except for the medial parts of the parietal and occipital lobes and the cingulate. Subtype 3 had
increased relative GMV in the medial and lateral temporal lobes, insula, and striatum. Subtype 4 had decreased relative GMV in the temporal lobes, inferior parietal lobes, posterior
cingulate, and the prefrontal cortices. Subtype 5 was characterized by greater relative GMV
in the temporal lobes, while Subtype 6 had the opposite pattern of reduced relative GMV in
the temporal lobes. Subtype 7 displayed greater relative GMV in the parietal lobes, posterior
lateral temporal lobes, medial temporal lobes, and medial occipital lobes. See Figure 1b for
surface representations of the subtypes. Diagnosis (CN, sMCI, pMCI, AD) accounted for a
substantial amount of variance in subtype weights for subtypes 1 (F=8.51, p=1.30 ✕10-5), 2
(F=10.32, p=1.00 ✕10-6), 4 (F=14.53, p=2.60 ✕10-9), 5 (F=13.86, p=6.77 ✕10-9), 6
(F=34.27, p=2.57 ✕10-21), and 7 (F=37.02, p=5.85 ✕10-23). Post-hoc t-tests showed AD
subjects had significantly higher weights compared to CN (Figure 1b) for subtypes 1 (t=2.88,
p=0.02), 2 (t=4.05, p=3.0 ✕10-4), 4 (t=4.83, p<1.0 ✕10-4), and 6 (t=7.86, p=<1.0 10-4),
making these subtypes associated with a diagnosis of AD. CN subjects had significantly 13 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint higher weights compared to AD for subtypes 5 (t=-4.86, p<1.0 ✕10-4) and 7 (t=-6.95, p<1.0
✕ 10-4), making these subtypes associated with a cognitively normal status. Prediction of AD dementia vs cognitively normal individuals The linear SVM model trained using the VCOG features achieved 94.5% PPV (95.6%
specificity, 93.9% sensitivity, 94.9% accuracy) when classifying AD vs CN in ADNI1. Such
high performance was expected given the marked cognitive deficits associated with clinical
dementia. COG features only actually reached excellent performance as well (97.6% PPV,
98.0% specificity, 96.4% sensitivity, 97.3% accuracy), while using VBM features only
yielded markedly lower performances (86.4% PPV, 89.3% specificity, 79.6% sensitivity,
84.8% accuracy) (see Figures 2 and ROC analysis in Figure 3). Note that the performance
metrics in ADNI1 were estimated through cross-validation, and represent an average
performance for several models trained on different subsets of ADNI1. We then trained a
model on all of ADNI1, and estimated its performance on an independent dataset, ADNI2. Using VCOG predictors, the ADNI1 model reached 92.0% PPV (96.3% specificity, 92.0%
sensitivity, 94.5% accuracy), when applied on ADNI2 AD vs CN data. Again the
performance was comparable with COG predictors only (92.2% PPV, 96.3% specificity,
94.3% sensitivity, 95.6% accuracy), and VBM features only achieved lower performance
(57.3% PPV, 79.8% specificity, 56.7% sensitivity, 72.3% accuracy) (see Figures 2 and ROC
analysis in Figure 3). Note that PPV is dependent on the proportion of patients and controls
for a given sensitivity and specificity. Since the ADNI2 sample had a substantially smaller
proportion of AD subjects compared to ADNI1, the resulting PPV was reduced. When we
adjusted the baseline rate of AD subjects in ADNI2 to the same rate in ADNI1, the PPVs
were 95.2%, 95.3%, and 70.2% for the VCOG, COG, and VBM models respectively. Identification of high confidence AD cases for prediction The VCOG HPS model achieved 99.2% PPV (99.5% specificity, 77.6% sensitivity,
89.7% accuracy) in classifying high confidence AD subjects in ADNI1. These performance
scores were estimated by cross-validation of the entire two-stage process (training of SVM,
estimation of hit probability, identification of HPS). However, the hyperparameters of the
two-stage model were optimized on classifying pMCI vs sMCI in ADNI1, as described 14 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint previously. We next trained a single model on all of ADNI1, which we applied on an
independent sample (ADNI2). The ADNI1 AD VCOG HPS model reached 98.6% PPV
(99.5% specificity, 79.5% sensitivity, 93.1% accuracy) on ADNI2. As was previously
observed with the conventional SVM analysis, the VCOG HPS model had similar
performance to the COG HPS model (ADNI1: 100% PPV, 100% specificity, 87.3%
sensitivity, 94.2% accuracy; ADNI2: 98.7% PPV, 99.5% specificity, 88.6% sensitivity,
96.0% accuracy), and outperformed the VBM HPS model (ADNI1: 92.3% PPV, 96.1%
specificity, 54.6% sensitivity, 77.2% accuracy; ADNI2: 65.2% PPV, 91.5% specificity,
33.3% sensitivity, 72.7% accuracy); see Figure 2. When adjusted to the same baseline rate of
AD subjects as ADNI1, the PPVs in ADNI2 were 99.2%, 99.3%, and 76.7% for the VCOG,
COG, and VBM HPS models respectively. 15 15 15 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Figure 2. Identification of high confidence AD cases for prediction Accuracy, specificity, sensitivity, and positive predictive value (PPV) for different
classifiers: linear SVM, highly predictive signature (HPS), and the linear SVM thresholded at 0.95
(SVM 0.95), for the classifications of patients with AD dementia (AD) and cognitively normal
individuals (CN) and patients with mild cognitive impairment who progress to AD (pMCI) and stable
MCI (sMCI) in ADNI1 and ADNI2. VBM represents the model trained with VBM subtypes, COG
represents the model trained with baseline cognitive scores, and VCOG represents the model trained
with both VBM subtypes and cognition. Positive predictive value was adjusted (PPV (adj)) for a
prevalence of 33.6% pMCI in a sample of MCI subjects for both ADNI1 and ADNI2 MCI cohorts. Significant differences are denoted by * for p<0.05 and ** for p<0.001). High confidence prediction of progression to AD dementia When using the full VCOG features, 87 MCI patients were selected as high
confidence in ADNI1, out of which 81 (93.1% PPV) were pMCI within 36 months of
follow-up. This represented a large, significant increase over the baseline rate of progressors
in the entire ADNI1 MCI sample (37.4%) (p<0.001). This was also a significant increase
over the SVM's predictions, where 83.9% of subjects that it had labeled as hits were true
progressors (p<0.001). When adjusted to a 33.6% baseline rate of progressors, more typical
of MCI populations, the PPV of high confidence subjects for prognosis of dementia was
80.4% (93.2% specificity, 55.1% sensitivity, 69.3% accuracy). We replicated these analyses in the MCI sample from ADNI2 (N=235). Using VCOG
features, 32 subjects were identified as high confidence, 26 of which progressed to AD
dementia within 36 months follow-up (81.2% PPV, specificity of 96.7%, sensitivity of
47.3%, 85.1% accuracy, 87.8% PPV adjusted to a 33.6% baseline rate). This represented a
significantly higher prevalence than the 30.6% baseline rate in the entire ADNI2 MCI cohort
(p<0.001). This was also a significant increase over the SVM's predictions, where 67.8% of
subjects it had labeled as hits were true progressors (p<0.001). As in the classifications of AD vs CN, the VCOG HPS model tended to have higher
performance compared to the VBM HPS (ADNI1: 89.9% specificity, 42.9% sensitivity,
60.5% accuracy, 87.7% PPV, 68.2% adjusted PPV; ADNI2: 90.1% specificity, 47.3%
sensitivity, 80.2% accuracy, 59.1% PPV, 70.7% adjusted PPV) in classifying pMCI vs sMCI. The VCOG HPS also had similar performance compared to the COG HPS (ADNI1: 87.5%
specificity, 64.6% sensitivity, 73.2% accuracy, 89.6% PPV, 72.3% adjusted PPV; ADNI2:
95.0% specificity, 56.4% sensitivity, 86.0% accuracy, 77.5% PPV, 85.1% adjusted PPV) for 16 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint distinguishing between pMCI and sMCI. High confidence prediction of progression to AD dementia Notably, the VCOG features lead to higher PPV
than VBM and COG features taken independently, both in ADNI1 and ADNI2. That increase
was large and significant between VCOG and VBM (up to 17%) and marginal and
non-significant between VCOG and COG (up to 8%); see Figure 2. Trade-off between sensitivity and specificity of different algorithms The HPS models consistently outperformed the linear SVM classifiers with respect to
specificity (p<0.001) in the classifications of AD vs CN and pMCI vs sMCI in both ADNI1
and ADNI2, regardless of the features that the models contained. The HPS also had greater
PPV (p<0.05) adjusted for a typical prevalence of 33.6% pMCI in a given sample of MCI
subjects [1]. However, these increases in specificity and PPV for the HPS model came at a
significant cost of reduced sensitivity compared to the linear SVM classifier, across all
models in both ADNI1 and ADNI2 (p<0.05) (Figure 2). Note that this shift towards lower
sensitivity and higher specificity and PPV could be achieved by adjusting the threshold of the
SVM analysis (see Figure 2 and ROC analysis in Figure 3), and is not unique to the two-stage
procedure we implemented. This trade-off between sensitivity and specificity is universal
across machine learning algorithms and similar results can be achieved by adjusting the
prediction threshold of different strategies. As shown by the ROC curves and AUC values in
Figure 3, other machine learning algorithms (SVM with a radial basis function kernel, K
nearest neighbors, random forest, and Gaussian naive Bayes) also performed similarly to the
HPS. Thus, the value of the HPS is in the selection of a threshold point in order to operate in
a high specificity regime. 17 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Figure 3. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves for various machine learning algorithms
with different features (VBM for VBM subtypes only, COG for cognitive features only, VCOG for a
combination of VBM subtypes and cognitive features). Trade-off between sensitivity and specificity of different algorithms Algorithms included a support vector machine
with a radial basis function kernel (RBF SVM), K nearest neighbors (KNN), random forest (RF),
Gaussian naive Bayes (GNB), a support vector machine with a linear kernel representing the first
stage (Linear SVM) of the two-stage predictive model, and the two-stage highly predictive signature
(HPS). TPR refers to true positive rate, FPR refers to false positive rate, and AUC refers to area under
the curve. Figure 3. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves for various machine learning algorithms
with different features (VBM for VBM subtypes only, COG for cognitive features only, VCOG for a
combination of VBM subtypes and cognitive features). Algorithms included a support vector machine
with a radial basis function kernel (RBF SVM), K nearest neighbors (KNN), random forest (RF),
Gaussian naive Bayes (GNB), a support vector machine with a linear kernel representing the first
stage (Linear SVM) of the two-stage predictive model, and the two-stage highly predictive signature
(HPS). TPR refers to true positive rate, FPR refers to false positive rate, and AUC refers to area under
the curve. aracteristics of MCI subjects with a highly predictive VCOG signature of AD High confidence MCI subjects with the VCOG signature were more likely to be
progressors (Figure 4a) compared to low confidence subjects and negative subjects (ADNI1:
p<0.001; ADNI2: p<0.001). High confidence MCI subjects were also more likely to be 18 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint APOE4 carriers (Figure 4b) (ADNI1: p<0.005; ADNI2: p<0.05). There was no difference in
sex across the HPS groupings in the MCI subjects of either the ADNI1 or ADNI2 cohorts
(Figure 4c). This was consistent with the whole sample, where there were equal proportions
of progressors across both sexes in each dataset (ADNI1: χ2=0.015, p=0.90; ADNI2:
χ2=0.0002, p=0.99). The high confidence class was also significantly enriched for A𝛽-positive
subjects in ADNI1 (p<0.05). However, this result was not replicated in the ADNI2 MCI
subjects (Figure 4d). Similarly with tau, we found a significant increase in tau-positive
subjects in the high confidence group of ADNI1 (p<0.05), but not in ADNI2 (Figure 4e). We
found a significant age difference across the HPS classes in ADNI2 (F=5.68, p<0.005), where
the high confidence subjects were older than the Negative subjects by a mean of 4.4 years. However, age did not differ across the HPS classes in ADNI1 (Figure 4f). Finally, high
confidence subjects had significantly steeper cognitive declines compared to the low
confidence and negative groups (Figure 4g): there were significant interactions between the
HPS groupings and time in ADNI1: (high confidence 𝛽=-0.147, t=-7.56, p<0.001; low
confidence 𝛽=-0.055, t=-2.46, p<0.05) and ADNI2 (high confidence 𝛽=-0.194, t=-8.69,
p<0.001; low confidence 𝛽=-0.072, t=-3.31, p=0.001). The high confidence subjects in
ADNI1 and ADNI2 respectively gained 1.8 and 2.3 more points each year on the ADAS13
compared to the low confidence and negative groups. Note that higher scores on the
Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale - Cognitive subscale (13 items) (ADAS13) represent
worse cognitive function. aracteristics of MCI subjects with a highly predictive VCOG signature of AD We sho
e percentage of MCI subjects who a) progressed to dementia, were b) APOE4 carriers, c) female,
sitive for A𝛽 measured by a cut-off of 192 pg/mL in the CSF [22], and e) positive for tau measur
a cut-off of 93 pg/mL in the CSF [22] in each classification (High confidence, Low confidence,
d Negative). f) Age and g) cognitive trajectories, measured by the Alzheimer's Disease Assessme
ale - Cognitive subscale with 13 items (ADAS13), across the three classes. Significant difference
e denoted by * for family wise error rate corrected p<0 05 re 4. Characteristics of MCI subjects with the VCOG signature in ADNI1 and ADNI2. We sh
percentage of MCI subjects who a) progressed to dementia, were b) APOE4 carriers, c) female
tive for A𝛽 measured by a cut-off of 192 pg/mL in the CSF [22], and e) positive for tau measu
cut-off of 93 pg/mL in the CSF [22] in each classification (High confidence, Low confidence
Negative). f) Age and g) cognitive trajectories, measured by the Alzheimer's Disease Assessm
e - Cognitive subscale with 13 items (ADAS13), across the three classes. Significant differenc
denoted by * for family-wise error rate-corrected p<0 05 Figure 4. Characteristics of MCI subjects with the VCOG signature in ADNI1 and ADNI2. We show
the percentage of MCI subjects who a) progressed to dementia, were b) APOE4 carriers, c) female, d)
positive for A𝛽 measured by a cut-off of 192 pg/mL in the CSF [22], and e) positive for tau measured
by a cut-off of 93 pg/mL in the CSF [22] in each classification (High confidence, Low confidence,
and Negative). f) Age and g) cognitive trajectories, measured by the Alzheimer's Disease Assessment
Scale - Cognitive subscale with 13 items (ADAS13), across the three classes. Significant differences
are denoted by * for family-wise error rate-corrected p<0.05. Figure 4. Characteristics of MCI subjects with the VCOG signature in ADNI1 and ADNI2. We show
the percentage of MCI subjects who a) progressed to dementia, were b) APOE4 carriers, c) female, d)
positive for A𝛽 measured by a cut-off of 192 pg/mL in the CSF [22], and e) positive for tau measured
by a cut-off of 93 pg/mL in the CSF [22] in each classification (High confidence, Low confidence,
and Negative). f) Age and g) cognitive trajectories, measured by the Alzheimer's Disease Assessment
Scale - Cognitive subscale with 13 items (ADAS13), across the three classes. aracteristics of MCI subjects with a highly predictive VCOG signature of AD APOE4 carriers (Figure 4b) (ADNI1: p<0.005; ADNI2: p<0.05). There was no difference in
sex across the HPS groupings in the MCI subjects of either the ADNI1 or ADNI2 cohorts
(Figure 4c). This was consistent with the whole sample, where there were equal proportions
of progressors across both sexes in each dataset (ADNI1: χ2=0.015, p=0.90; ADNI2:
χ2=0.0002, p=0.99). The high confidence class was also significantly enriched for A𝛽-positive
subjects in ADNI1 (p<0.05). However, this result was not replicated in the ADNI2 MCI
subjects (Figure 4d). Similarly with tau, we found a significant increase in tau-positive
subjects in the high confidence group of ADNI1 (p<0.05), but not in ADNI2 (Figure 4e). We
found a significant age difference across the HPS classes in ADNI2 (F=5.68, p<0.005), where
the high confidence subjects were older than the Negative subjects by a mean of 4.4 years. However, age did not differ across the HPS classes in ADNI1 (Figure 4f). Finally, high
confidence subjects had significantly steeper cognitive declines compared to the low
confidence and negative groups (Figure 4g): there were significant interactions between the
HPS groupings and time in ADNI1: (high confidence 𝛽=-0.147, t=-7.56, p<0.001; low
confidence 𝛽=-0.055, t=-2.46, p<0.05) and ADNI2 (high confidence 𝛽=-0.194, t=-8.69,
p<0.001; low confidence 𝛽=-0.072, t=-3.31, p=0.001). The high confidence subjects in
ADNI1 and ADNI2 respectively gained 1.8 and 2.3 more points each year on the ADAS13
compared to the low confidence and negative groups. Note that higher scores on the
Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale - Cognitive subscale (13 items) (ADAS13) represent
worse cognitive function. 19 19 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint gure 4. Characteristics of MCI subjects with the VCOG signature in ADNI1 and ADNI2. aracteristics of MCI subjects with a highly predictive VCOG signature of AD Significant differences
are denoted by * for family-wise error rate-corrected p<0.05. 20 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint COG, VBM and VCOG highly predictive signatures ADAS13=Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale - Cognitive, MEM=ADNI-MEM
score; EXEC=ADNI-EF score, BNT=Boston Naming Test, CLOCK=clock drawing test, VBM
1-7=VBM subtype weights, GMV=mean grey matter volume, TIV=total intracranial volume. Figure 5. Coefficients of the high confidence prediction a) VCOG HPS model, b) COG HPS model, c)
VBM HPS model. ADAS13=Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale - Cognitive, MEM=ADNI-MEM
score; EXEC=ADNI-EF score, BNT=Boston Naming Test, CLOCK=clock drawing test, VBM
1-7=VBM subtype weights, GMV=mean grey matter volume, TIV=total intracranial volume. Figure 5. Coefficients of the high confidence prediction a) VCOG HPS model, b) COG HPS model, c)
VBM HPS model. ADAS13=Alzheimer’s Disease Assessment Scale - Cognitive, MEM=ADNI-MEM
score; EXEC=ADNI-EF score, BNT=Boston Naming Test, CLOCK=clock drawing test, VBM
1-7=VBM subtype weights, GMV=mean grey matter volume, TIV=total intracranial volume. COG, VBM and VCOG highly predictive signatures The COG signature was mainly driven by scores from the ADAS13, which measures
overall cognition, ADNI-MEM, a composite score that measures memory [27], and
ADNI-EF, a composite score that measures executive function [37] (coefficients were 5.49,
-4.80 and -2.50 respectively). In this model, sex, age, mean GMV, and TIV contributed very
little, relative to the cognitive features (Figure 5b). Note that these coefficients should be
interpreted as pseudo z-scores as the features had been normalized to zero mean and unit
variance. Almost all grey matter subtypes contributed to the VBM signature. Mean GMV,
subtype 1 (reduced relative GMV in the occipital, parietal and posterior temporal lobes) and
subtype 6 (reduced relative GMV in the temporal lobes, notably the medial temporal regions)
had the highest weights in the model (coefficients were -5.07, 4.87, and 3.98 respectively)
(Figure 5c). We had anticipated the larger contribution of these two subtypes as they have
been described in previous AD subtyping work [5,17–19]. The ADAS13, memory (ADNI-MEM) and executive function (ADNI-EF) scores
contributed the most to the VCOG signature (coefficients were 6.27, -7.43 and -3.95
respectively, Figure 5a). Of the VBM features, subtypes 2, 3 and 7 contributed the most to the
signature (coefficients were 1.36, -2.12 and -2.83 respectively). Subtypes 1 and 6, which had
the highest positive weights in the VBM HPS model, were given marginal weights in the
VCOG HPS model, which is potentially indicative of redundancy with COG features. Note
that the weights for subtypes 3 and 7 were negative in the model, which means that predicted
AD and pMCI cases had brain atrophy patterns that were spatially dissimilar to those
subtypes. 21 21 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Figure 5. Coefficients of the high confidence prediction a) VCOG HPS model, b) COG HPS model, c)
VBM HPS model. Comparison of COG, VBM and VCOG high confidence subjects We found substantial overlap of subjects labeled as high confidence in the MCI
cohorts across the VBM, COG and VCOG signatures (Figure 6). There were very few
subjects that were labeled as high confidence exclusively by the VCOG signature. As to be
expected, the majority of subjects labeled as high confidence by the VCOG signature
(ADNI1: 97.7%; ADNI2: 100%) were also labeled as high confidence by either the VBM
only or COG only signatures or both. Of the subjects that were labeled as high confidence by
the VBM only signature, 23.6% and 55.2% in ADNI1 and ADNI2 respectively were
identified exclusively by the VBM HPS. There were relatively few subjects (7 and 2 subjects
in ADNI1 and ADNI2 respectively) that were captured by VBM and VCOG but missed by
the COG HPS. The COG HPS actually identified the majority of all high confidence subjects
across the three signatures (ADNI1: 106 of 132 total subjects, ADNI2: 40 of 65 total
subjects). From Figure 6, we can see that the VCOG HPS acts as a refinement of the COG 22 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint signature, as the VCOG HPS captures a subset of subjects that were labeled by the COG
HPS. signature, as the VCOG HPS captures a subset of subjects that were labeled by the COG
HPS. Out of the high confidence subjects labeled by all three signatures, 97.9% and 93.7%
from ADNI1 and ADNI2 respectively progressed to dementia (Supplementary Table S2). These subjects had worse cognition based on the MMSE and higher proportions of APOE4
carriers, A𝛽positive and tau positive individuals, compared to the baseline rates in all MCI
subjects. Of the high confidence subjects who were labeled only by the VBM model, 70.6%
and 43.4% from ADNI1 and ADNI2 respectively were progressors. This group of subjects
had less A𝛽and tau positive individuals compared to the baseline rates. Of the high
confidence subjects who were labeled only the COG model, 70.4% and 57.1% from ADNI1
and ADNI2 respectively progressed to dementia. This group appeared to have a greater
proportion of A𝛽positive individuals compared to the baseline rates in both ADNI1 and
ADNI2 cohorts. The majority of these COG high confidence subjects were also male. Given
the distinct characteristics among the exclusively COG, exclusively VBM, and VCOG high
confidence subjects, these groups may represent subgroups with different risks for AD
dementia. As it appears that a greater proportion of pMCI is captured when cognitive and
structural MRI features are combined, these findings may support joining multiple modalities
together in order to achieve higher positive predictive value. However, these results are
qualitative and of an exploratory nature due to low sample sizes. Figure 6. Venn diagram depicting the number of MCI subjects labeled as high confidence by the
VBM, COG, and VCOG HPS models in ADNI1 and ADNI2. Figure 6. Venn diagram depicting the number of MCI subjects labeled as high confidence by the
VBM, COG, and VCOG HPS models in ADNI1 and ADNI2. 23 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Discussion CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint the advantage of a principled approach to train the prediction model in order to maximize
specificity, based on samples that are robust and easily classifiable, without testing a range of
prediction thresholds. The choice of a L1 regularized logistic regression also led to a compact
and interpretable subset of features for the HPS. Favoring specificity over sensitivity is useful in settings where false positives need to
be minimized and PPV needs to be high, such as expensive clinical trials. Here, with our
VCOG HPS model, we report the highest PPVs for progression to AD from the MCI stage
(up to 87.8%, adjusted for 33.6% prevalence of progressors) for models that included
structural MRI and cognitive features, which are, importantly, modalities that are already
widely used by clinicians. The present work could be used as a screening tool for recruitment
in clinical trials that target MCI subjects who are likely to progress to dementia within three
years. The implementation of an automated selection algorithm could also result in groups of
MCI subjects with more homogeneous brain pathology. However, we note that high
confidence subjects did not all present with significant amyloid burden (92.0% and 68.4% of
high confidence subjects in ADNI1 and ADNI2 respectively, Figure 4), which means that not
all high confidence individuals are likely to have prodromal AD, even when progressing to
dementia. When we trained our model with cognitive features only, tests for general cognition,
memory, and executive function were chosen as the strongest predictors of AD dementia. Our
COG HPS model thus supports previous research that reported general cognition, memory,
and executive function as important neuropsychological predictors of dementia [7,29,38,39]. Discussion We developed a MRI and cognitive-based model to predict AD dementia with high
PPV and specificity. Specifically, our two-stage predictive model reached 93.2% specificity
and 93.1% PPV (80.4% when adjusted for 33.6% prevalence of progressors) in ADNI1 when
classifying progressor vs stable MCI patients (within 3 years follow-up). We replicated these
results in ADNI2 where the model reached 96.7% specificity and 81.2% PPV (87.8%
adjusted PPV). With respect to specificity and PPV, these results are a substantial
improvement over previous works combining structural MRI and cognition on the same
prediction task, that have reported up to 76% specificity and 65% PPV (adjusted for 33.6%
prevalence of progressors) [7]. Finally, our results also reproduced our past work which
developed a model that optimizes specificity and PPV [20]. However, it appears that a
combination of structural and functional MRI measures may lead to an improved prediction
as two studies have reported 90-100% PPV with these measures [9,20], with the limitation of
smaller sample sizes (56 total MCI subjects in [20], 86 total MCI subjects in [9]) due to the
limited availability of functional MRI data in ADNI. Our proposed signature is based on
widely available measures, and can be readily tested in many clinical trials. Functional MRI
measures, by contrast, are only gaining traction in large clinical studies, and will at the
minimum require more time to get widely adopted, if the very high PPVs are replicated in
larger samples. An ideal model to predict conversion to AD dementia would have both high
sensitivity and specificity. However, the pathophysiological heterogeneity of clinical
diagnosis will prevent highly accurate prediction linking brain features to clinical trajectories. We argue that, faced with heterogeneity, it is necessary to sacrifice sensitivity to focus on a
subgroup of individuals with similar brain abnormalities. Due to the expected trade-off
between specificity and sensitivity, the high specificity of our two-stage model indeed came
at a cost of reduced sensitivity (55.1% in ADNI1 and 47.3% in ADNI2 for classifying pMCI
vs sMCI), which is much lower than sensitivity values of 64%-95% reported by other groups
[7,8,10–16]. The two-stage procedure did not offer gains compared to a simpler SVM model,
if the threshold of the SVM model could be selected a priori to match the specificity of the
two-stage procedure (see ROC curves in Figure 3). The two-stage prediction model offered 24 . Discussion Compared to the state-of-the-art multi-domain cognition-based predictive model, which
reported 87.1% specificity and 81.8% PPV (77.5% when adjusted to 33.6% pMCI
prevalence) [40], our COG HPS model achieved similar performance reaching between
87.5%-95% specificity and 72.3%-85.1% (adjusted) PPV. As general cognition was the
strongest feature in our model to predict progression, this supports previous findings that
MCI patients with deficits across multiple domains are at the highest risk for dementia
[39,41]. For our VBM model, we extracted a number of gray matter atrophy subtypes that
recapitulated previously reported subtypes, namely the medial temporal lobe and parietal
dominant subtypes [5,17–19], which were associated strongly with a diagnosis of AD
dementia. Weights for the parietal dominant and medial temporal lobe subtypes (Subtypes 1 25 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint and 6 from Figure 1b, respectively) contributed substantially to the highly predictive
signature in the VBM model. The atrophy pattern of subtype 6 is spatially similar to the
spread of neurofibrillary tangles in Braak stages III and IV [42], which may support previous
findings that tau aggregation mediates neurodegeneration [43]. The contributions of the
parietal dominant and medial temporal lobe subtypes in the VBM HPS model are also in line
with previous works, which have reported that cortical thickness and volumes of the medial
temporal lobes, inferior parietal cortex, and precuneus are strong predictors of progression to
dementia [7,11]. When combined with cognitive tests in the VCOG model, the structural subtypes
were given marginal weights. This suggests some redundancy between atrophy and
cognition, and that cognitive features have higher predictive power than structural features in
the ADNI MCI sample. This conclusion is consistent with the observation that the COG
model significantly outperformed the VBM model, similar to previous work [7]. Discussion Although
cognitive markers were stronger features, the VCOG model assigned large negative weights
for the structural subtypes 3, which showed greater relative GMV in the temporal lobes, and
7, which showed greater relative GMV in the parietal, occipital, and temporal lobes. This
means that these features were predictive of stable MCI in the VCOG model, in line with
previous work showing that atrophy in these regions is predictive of progression to dementia
[7,11]. Furthermore, we demonstrated that combining MRI data with cognitive markers
significantly improves upon a model based on MRI features alone. This result is again in line
with the literature [7,10], yet was shown for the first time for a model specifically trained for
high PPV. Note that in the current study, the predictive model was trained exclusively on
images acquired on 1.5T scanners from ADNI1. Good generalization to ADNI2 with 3T
scanners demonstrates robustness of imaging structural subtypes across scanner makes. The VCOG highly predictive signature might reflect a late disease stage. We looked
at the ratio of early to late MCI subjects in the ADNI2 sample (note that ADNI1 did not have
early MCI subjects). Of the MCI subjects identified as high confidence by the VCOG model,
84.4% were late MCI subjects, compared to a rate of 34.9% of late MCI subjects in the entire
ADNI2 MCI sample (Supplementary Figure S1). This approach may not be optimal for early
detection of future cognitive decline. Training a model to classify MCI progressors and
non-progressors to dementia could be done in order to capture future progressors in earlier
preclinical
stages
(e.g. early
MCI). Finally,
we
focused
on
structural
MRI
and 26 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint neuropsychological batteries as features in our models due to their wide availability and
established status as clinical tools. Discussion However, we believe adding other modalities such as PET
imaging, CSF markers, functional MRI, genetic factors, or lifestyle factors could result in
higher predictive power, especially at earlier preclinical stages of AD. neuropsychological batteries as features in our models due to their wide availability and
established status as clinical tools. However, we believe adding other modalities such as PET
imaging, CSF markers, functional MRI, genetic factors, or lifestyle factors could result in
higher predictive power, especially at earlier preclinical stages of AD. Competing interests The authors declare no conflicts of interest. Conclusion In summary, we found a subgroup of patients with MCI who share a signature of
cognitive deficits and brain atrophy, that put them at very high risk to progress from MCI to
AD dementia within a time span of three years. We validated the signature in two separate
cohorts that contained both stable MCI patients and MCI patients who progressed to
dementia. The model was able to predict progression to dementia in MCI patients with up to
93.1% PPV and up to 96.7% specificity. The signature was present in about half of all
progressors, demonstrating that gains in PPV can be made by focusing on a homogeneous,
yet relatively common subgroup. Our model could potentially improve subject selection in
clinical trials and identify individuals at a higher risk of AD dementia for early intervention
in clinical settings. Acknowledgments We thank Sylvia Villeneuve, Alexa Pichet-Binette and Jacob Vogel for providing us
with data to help start our preliminary analyses for this project. We thank Hien Nguyen for
advising us on parts of the statistical analyses. Data collection and sharing for this project was funded by the Alzheimer's Disease
Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) (National Institutes of Health Grant U01 AG024904) and
DOD ADNI (Department of Defense award number W81XWH-12-2-0012). ADNI is funded
by the National Institute on Aging, the National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and
Bioengineering,
and
through
generous
contributions
from
the
following:
AbbVie,
Alzheimer’s Association; Alzheimer’s Drug Discovery Foundation; Araclon Biotech; 27 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint BioClinica, Inc.; Biogen; Bristol-Myers Squibb Company; CereSpir, Inc.; Cogstate; Eisai
Inc.; Elan Pharmaceuticals, Inc.; Eli Lilly and Company; EuroImmun; F. Hoffmann-La
Roche Ltd and its affiliated company Genentech, Inc.; Fujirebio; GE Healthcare; IXICO Ltd.;
Janssen Alzheimer Immunotherapy Research & Development, LLC.; Johnson & Johnson
Pharmaceutical Research & Development LLC.; Lumosity; Lundbeck; Merck & Co., Inc.;
Meso Scale Diagnostics, LLC.; NeuroRx Research; Neurotrack Technologies; Novartis
Pharmaceuticals Corporation; Pfizer Inc.; Piramal Imaging; Servier; Takeda Pharmaceutical
Company; and Transition Therapeutics. The Canadian Institutes of Health Research is
providing funds to support ADNI clinical sites in Canada. Private sector contributions are
facilitated by the Foundation for the National Institutes of Health (www.fnih.org). The
grantee organization is the Northern California Institute for Research and Education, and the
study is coordinated by the Alzheimer’s Therapeutic Research Institute at the University of
Southern California. ADNI data are disseminated by the Laboratory for Neuro Imaging at the
University of Southern California. The computational resources used to perform the data analysis were provided by
Compute Canada
(www.computecanada.org). Acknowledgments This project was funded by NSERC grant
number RN000028 and the Canadian Consortium on Neurodegeneration in Aging (CCNA,
www.ccna-ccnv.ca), through a grant from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and
funding from several partners including SANOFI-ADVENTIS R&D. AT was supported by a
bursary from the Centre de recherche de l'institut universitaire de gériatrie de Montréal and
the Courtois foundation. CD was supported by a salary award from the Lemaire foundation
and Courtois foundation. PB was supported by a salary award from Fonds de recherche du
Québec -- Santé and the Courtois foundation. 2. Visser P-J, Scheltens P, Verhey FRJ. Do MCI criteria in drug trials accurately identify
subjects with predementia Alzheimer’s disease? J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry.
2005;76:1348–54. 1. Mitchell AJ, Shiri-Feshki M. Rate of progression of mild cognitive impairment to dementia
- meta-analysis of 41 robust inception cohort studies. Acta Psychiatr Scand.
2009;119:252–65. References 1. Mitchell AJ, Shiri-Feshki M. Rate of progression of mild cognitive impairment to dementia
- meta-analysis of 41 robust inception cohort studies. Acta Psychiatr Scand. 2009;119:252–65. 1. Mitchell AJ, Shiri-Feshki M. Rate of progression of mild cognitive impairment to dementia
- meta-analysis of 41 robust inception cohort studies. Acta Psychiatr Scand. 2009;119:252–65. 28 28 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint 3. Scheltens NME, Galindo-Garre F, Pijnenburg YAL, van der Vlies AE, Smits LL, Koene T,
et al. The identification of cognitive subtypes in Alzheimer’s disease dementia using latent
class analysis. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2016;87:235–43. 4. Murray ME, Graff-Radford NR, Ross OA, Petersen RC, Duara R, Dickson DW. Neuropathologically defined subtypes of Alzheimer’s disease with distinct clinical
characteristics: a retrospective study. Lancet Neurol. 2011;10:785–96. 5. Hwang J, Kim CM, Jeon S, Lee JM, Hong YJ, Roh JH, et al. Prediction of Alzheimer’s
disease pathophysiology based on cortical thickness patterns. Alzheimer’s & dementia
(Amsterdam, Netherlands). 2016;2:58–67. 6. Dong A, Toledo JB, Honnorat N, Doshi J, Varol E, Sotiras A, et al. Heterogeneity of
neuroanatomical patterns in prodromal Alzheimer’s disease: links to cognition, progression
and biomarkers. Brain. 2017;140:735–47. 7. Korolev IO, Symonds LL, Bozoki AC, for the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging
Initiative. Predicting Progression from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer’s Dementia
Using Clinical, MRI, and Plasma Biomarkers via Probabilistic Pattern Classification. PLoS
One. 2016;11:e0138866–25. 8. Mathotaarachchi S, Pascoal TA, Shin M, Benedet AL, Kang MS, Beaudry T, et al. Identifying incipient dementia individuals using machine learning and amyloid imaging. Neurobiol Aging. 2017;59:80–90. 9. Hojjati SH, Ebrahimzadeh A, Khazaee A, Babajani-Feremi A, Alzheimer’s Disease
Neuroimaging Initiative. Predicting conversion from MCI to AD by integrating rs-fMRI and
structural MRI. Comput Biol Med. 2018;102:30–9. 10. Moradi E, Pepe A, Gaser C, Huttunen H, Tohka J, Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging
Initiative. Machine learning framework for early MRI-based Alzheimer’s conversion
prediction in MCI subjects. Neuroimage. References 2015;104:398–412. 11. Eskildsen SF, Coupé P, García-Lorenzo D, Fonov V, Pruessner JC, Collins DL, et al. Prediction of Alzheimer’s disease in subjects with mild cognitive impairment from the ADNI
cohort using patterns of cortical thinning. Neuroimage. 2013;65:511–21. 12. Wee C-Y, Yap P-T, Shen D, for the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative. Prediction of Alzheimer’s disease and mild cognitive impairment using cortical
morphological patterns. Hum Brain Mapp. 2013;34:3411–25. 13. Gaser C, Franke K, Klöppel S, Koutsouleris N, Sauer H, for the Alzheimer’s Disease
Neuroimaging Initiative. BrainAGE in Mild Cognitive Impaired Patients: Predicting the
Conversion to Alzheimer’s Disease. PLoS One. 2013;8:e67346–15. 14. Davatzikos C, Bhatt P, Shaw LM, Batmanghelich KN, Trojanowski JQ. Prediction of
MCI to AD conversion, via MRI, CSF biomarkers, and pattern classification. NBA. 2011;32:2322.e19–2322.e27. 15. Koikkalainen J, Lötjönen J, Thurfjell L, Rueckert D, Waldemar G, Soininen H, et al. 29 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which wa
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Multi-template tensor-based morphometry: application to analysis of Alzheimer’s disease. Neuroimage. 2011;56:1134–44. 16. Misra C, Fan Y, Davatzikos C. Baseline and longitudinal patterns of brain atrophy in
MCI patients, and their use in prediction of short-term conversion to AD: Results from
ADNI. Neuroimage. 2009;44:1415–22. 17. Noh Y, Jeon S, Lee JM, Seo SW, Kim GH, Cho H, et al. Anatomical heterogeneity of
Alzheimer disease Based on cortical thickness on MRIs. Neurology. 2014;83:1936–44. 18. Park J-Y, Na HK, Kim S, Kim H, Kim HJ, Seo SW, et al. Robust Identification of
Alzheimer’s Disease subtypes based on cortical atrophy patterns. Sci Rep. 2017;7:43270. 19. Varol E, Sotiras A, Davatzikos C, Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative. HYDRA: Revealing heterogeneity of imaging and genetic patterns through a multiple
max-margin discriminative analysis framework. Neuroimage. 2017;145:346–64. 20. Dansereau C, Tam A, Badhwar A, Urchs S, Orban P, Rosa-Neto P, et al. A brain
signature highly predictive of future progression to Alzheimer’s dementia. arXiv preprint
arXiv:1712 08058. 2017; 21. References Bellec P, Lavoie-Courchesne S, Dickinson P, Lerch JP, Zijdenbos AP, Evans A. The
pipeline system for Octave and Matlab (PSOM): a lightweight scripting framework and
execution engine for scientific workflows. Front Neuroinform. 2012;6:7. 22. Fonov V, Evans A, Botteron K, Almli CR, McKinstry RC, Collins DL. Unbiased average
age-appropriate atlases for pediatric studies. Neuroimage. 2011;54:313–27. 23. Ad-Dab’bagh Y, Einarson D, Lyttelton O, Muehlboeck JS, Mok K, Ivanov O, et al. The
CIVET image-processing environment: a fully automated comprehensive pipeline for
anatomical neuroimaging research. Proceedings of the 12th annual meeting of the
organization for human brain mapping. 2006;2266. 24. Ashburner J. A fast diffeomorphic image registration algorithm. Neuroimage. 2007;38:95–113. 25. Orban P, Tam A, Urchs S, Savard M, Madjar C, Badhwar A, et al. Subtypes of functional
brain connectivity as early markers of neurodegeneration in Alzheimer’s disease. bioRxiv. 2017;195164. 26. Zhang X, Mormino EC, Sun N, Sperling RA, Sabuncu MR, Yeo BTT, et al. Bayesian
model reveals latent atrophy factors with dissociable cognitive trajectories in Alzheimer’s
disease. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2016;113:E6535–44. 27. Crane PK, Carle A, Gibbons LE, Insel P, Mackin RS, Gross A, et al. Development and
assessment of a composite score for memory in the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging
Initiative (ADNI). Brain Imaging Behav. 2012;6:502–16. 28. Gibbons LE, Carle AC, Mackin RS, Harvey D, Mukherjee S, Insel P, et al. A composite
score for executive functioning, validated in Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative
(ADNI) participants with baseline mild cognitive impairment. Brain Imaging Behav. 30 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint .
CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019.
;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint 42. Braak H, Braak E. Neuropathological stageing of Alzheimer-related changes. Acta 43. Spillantini MG, Goedert M. Tau pathology and neurodegeneration. Lancet Neurol.
2013;12:609–22. 2012;6:517–27. 29. Belleville S, Fouquet C, Hudon C, Zomahoun HTV, Croteau J, Consortium for the Early
Identification of Alzheimer\textquoterights disease-Quebec. Neuropsychological Measures
that Predict Progression from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer’s type dementia in
Older Adults: a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Neuropsychol Rev. 2017;27:328–53. 30. Pedregosa F, Varoquaux G, Gramfort A, Michel V, Thirion B, Grisel O, et al. Scikit-learn: Machine Learning in Python. J Mach Learn Res. 2011;2825–30. 31. Fan R-E, Chang K-W, Hsieh C-J, Wang X-R, Lin C-J. LIBLINEAR: A library for large
linear classification. J Mach Learn Res. 2008;9:1871–4. 32. Phipson B, Smyth GK. Permutation P-values should never be zero: calculating exact
P-values when permutations are randomly drawn. Stat Appl Genet Mol Biol. 2010;9. 33. Shaw LM, Vanderstichele H, Knapik-Czajka M, Clark CM, Aisen PS, Petersen RC, et al. Cerebrospinal fluid biomarker signature in Alzheimer’s disease neuroimaging initiative
subjects. Ann Neurol. 2009;65:403–13. 34. Jones E, Oliphant T, Peterson P. SciPy: open source scientific tools for Python,
http://www.scipy.org/. 2001; 35. Seabold S, Perktold J. Statsmodels: Econometric and statistical modeling with python. Proceedings of the 9th Python in Science Conference. SciPy society Austin; 2010. 36. Pinheiro J, Bates D, DebRoy S, Sarkar D, R Core Team. nlme: linear and nonlinear mixed
effects models. R package version 3.1-117, https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=nlme. 2018; 37. Gibbons LE, Carle AC, Mackin RS, Harvey D, Mukherjee S, Insel P, et al. A composite
score for executive functioning, validated in Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative
(ADNI) participants with baseline mild cognitive impairment. Brain Imaging Behav. 2012;6:517–27. 38. Dickerson BC, Sperling RA, Hyman BT, Albert MS, Blacker D. Clinical prediction of
Alzheimer disease dementia across the spectrum of mild cognitive impairment. Arch Gen
Psychiatry. 2007;64:1443–50. 39. Tabert MH, Manly JJ, Liu X, Pelton GH, Rosenblum S, Jacobs M, et al. Neuropsychological prediction of conversion to Alzheimer disease in patients with mild
cognitive impairment. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2006;63:916–24. 40. Belleville S, Gauthier S, Lepage É, Kergoat M-J, Gilbert B. Predicting decline in mild
cognitive impairment: A prospective cognitive study. Neuropsychology. 2014;28:643–52. 41. Mitchell J, Arnold R, Dawson K, Nestor PJ, Hodges JR. Outcome in subgroups of mild
cognitive impairment (MCI) is highly predictable using a simple algorithm. J Neurol. 2009;256:1500–9. 42. Braak H, Braak E. Neuropathological stageing of Alzheimer-related changes. Acta 31 . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. 2012;6:517–27. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint . CC-BY 4.0 International license
available under a
not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprint (which was
this version posted March 8, 2019. ;
https://doi.org/10.1101/352344
doi:
bioRxiv preprint Neuropathol. 1991;82:239–59. 32 32
|
https://openalex.org/W4214636866
|
https://www.epj-conferences.org/articles/epjconf/pdf/2022/04/epjconf_nic16th2022_01002.pdf
|
English
| null |
The <sup>12</sup>C+<sup>12</sup>C fusion reaction at stellar energies
|
EPJ web of conferences
| 2,022
|
cc-by
| 5,383
|
∗e-mail: xtang@impcas.ac.cn
∗∗e-mail: rulonghui@impcas.ac.cn Xiaodong Tang1,2,3,∗and Longhui Ru1,2,∗∗ Xiaodong Tang1,2,3,∗and Longhui Ru1,2,∗∗ 1Institute of modern physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Lanzhou, 730000, China 1Institute of modern physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Lanzhou, 730000, China
2School of Nuclear Science and Technology, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing
100049, China 3Joint department of nuclear physics, Lanzhou University and institute of modern physics, Lanzhou,
730000 China 3Joint department of nuclear physics, Lanzhou University and institute of modern physics, Lanzhou,
730000, China Abstract. The carbon fusion reaction is crucial in stellar evolution. Despite six
decades of studies, there is still a large uncertainty in the reaction rate which
limits our understanding of various stellar objects, such as massive stars, type
Ia supernovae, and superbursts. In this paper, we review the experimental and
theoretical studies of the carbon fusion reaction at sub-barrier energies. An
outlook for future studies is also presented. EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022) EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022) EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 1 Introduction Stars with a mass of more than 8 solar masses and less than 10 solar masses can ignite the
12C+12C fusion reaction and proceed with carbon burning inside of their cores. These stars
end up their lives as Ne/O white dwarfs. More massive stars will continue with Ne-, O-
and Si-burnings in their cores and shells and eventually become supernovae. During these
hydrostatic and explosive burning processes, 12C+12C is one of the primary reactions of the
burning processes which shape the stellar evolution and the final nucleosynthesis. The typical
temperature ranges span from 0.6 to 2.5 GK [1, 2]. The 12C+12C fusion reaction is considered to be the ignition reaction of type Ia supernova
and superburst. In type Ia supernova, the ignition happens in the core of white dwarf typically
at T∼0.15-0.7 GK. In superburst, the heating sources in the crust of neutron star raise the
temperature of the ash and eventually start carbon ignition at a temperature of ∼0.5 GK[3]. The ignition conditions mentioned above strongly depend on the 12C+12C reaction rate as
well as the treatment of reaction rate estimation in dense matter[4–6]. © The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). ∗∗e-mail: rulonghui@impcas.ac.cn 2 Experimental progress To get a cleaner background, the particle-γ coincidence tech-
nique has been used to measure the cross section of the p1 and α1 channels [13–15]. But
the statistics was limited by the lower detection efficiency and the available beam current. The total fusion cross section can only be obtained by the theoretical branching ratios which
introduce systematic uncertainties as shown later in this paper. A recent direct measurement
of 12C(12C,n)23Mg has been performed at stellar energies, providing a reliable rate[16]. The
12C(12C,8Be)16O is an open channel that has been overlooked due to the lack of experimental
work[17]. The results of some measurements are shown in Fig. 1 as the modified S factor,
S ∗(Ec.m.) = σ(Ec.m.)Ec.m.exp( 87.21
√Ec.m. + 0.46Ec.m.). Figure 1. (Color online) S* factors of 12C+12C. The 12C+12C data from Ref. [7], [9], [11], [12],
[14] and [15] shown as blue, red, green diamond, magenta, blue, green square and orange points,
respectively. Model calculations, CC-M3Y+Rep (thick dark red), SPP(oragen), TDWP(light blue) and
hindrance(blue dashed) are also shown, respectively. The recommended averaged S* factor by CF88
is shown as red dashed line. The THM result and the fit are shown as black dashed and solid lines,
respectively. Figure 1. (Color online) S* factors of 12C+12C. The 12C+12C data from Ref. [7], [9], [11], [12],
[14] and [15] shown as blue, red, green diamond, magenta, blue, green square and orange points,
respectively. Model calculations, CC-M3Y+Rep (thick dark red), SPP(oragen), TDWP(light blue) and
hindrance(blue dashed) are also shown, respectively. The recommended averaged S* factor by CF88
is shown as red dashed line. The THM result and the fit are shown as black dashed and solid lines,
respectively. 2 Experimental progress At sub-barrier energies, the main products of 12C+12C are n, p and α. To obtain the fu-
sion reaction cross section at such energies, two different techniques had been used. One is
the particle spectroscopy and the other is the characteristic γ-ray spectroscopy. Patterson[7],
Mazarakis[8], Becker[9] and Zickefoose[19] extended the measurements below 2.7 MeV by
counting the protons and/or alphas from the fusion reaction process. As energy approaches EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022) https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 the astrophysical region, backgrounds arising from the target impurity and other sources pro-
duce a significant background. Some proton and alpha channels could not be identified,
leading to underestimation of the total fusion cross sections. Kettner[10], Aguilera[11] and
Spillane[12] measured the cross sections of the characteristic γ-rays of the fusion residues,
23Na, 20Ne and 23Mg. Since some decays of the fusion residues bypass the decay of the char-
acteristic γ-rays, the sum of the characteristic γ-ray cross sections reflects only a fraction of
the total fusion cross section. To get a cleaner background, the particle-γ coincidence tech-
nique has been used to measure the cross section of the p1 and α1 channels [13–15]. But
the statistics was limited by the lower detection efficiency and the available beam current. The total fusion cross section can only be obtained by the theoretical branching ratios which
introduce systematic uncertainties as shown later in this paper. A recent direct measurement
of 12C(12C,n)23Mg has been performed at stellar energies, providing a reliable rate[16]. The
12C(12C,8Be)16O is an open channel that has been overlooked due to the lack of experimental
work[17]. The results of some measurements are shown in Fig. 1 as the modified S factor,
S ∗(Ec.m.) = σ(Ec.m.)Ec.m.exp( 87.21
√Ec.m. + 0.46Ec.m.). the astrophysical region, backgrounds arising from the target impurity and other sources pro-
duce a significant background. Some proton and alpha channels could not be identified,
leading to underestimation of the total fusion cross sections. Kettner[10], Aguilera[11] and
Spillane[12] measured the cross sections of the characteristic γ-rays of the fusion residues,
23Na, 20Ne and 23Mg. Since some decays of the fusion residues bypass the decay of the char-
acteristic γ-rays, the sum of the characteristic γ-ray cross sections reflects only a fraction of
the total fusion cross section. 3 Data compilation Here we discuss three important factors in the compilation of the S* factor of the 12C+12C
fusion reaction: energy calibration, background evaluation and the branching ratios of the
observed/missing channels. An accurate and precision energy calibration is the basic to compare the data set. Due
to the Coulomb barrier tunneling effect, the reaction cross section has a strong dependence
on the reaction energy. For example, at Ec.m.=3 MeV, a 0.2% change in Ec.m. results in a
5% change in the reaction cross section. The measurement of Mazarakis found an upturn-
ing trend of the S* factor at the lower energies. It was interpreted as absorption under the 2 2 EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 Coulomb barrier. By aligning the resonances at higher energies with latter measurements,
an energy shift of +100 keV was found for the data of Mazarakis and the upturning trend
disappeared[10, 20]. Coulomb barrier. By aligning the resonances at higher energies with latter measurements,
an energy shift of +100 keV was found for the data of Mazarakis and the upturning trend
disappeared[10, 20]. Barrón-Palos et al. reported an upturning trend in their measured S* factor. As they used
a smoothing procedure to wash out the resonance structure, one can not check their energy
calibration with the reported S* factor. We compared the thick target yields of the 1634-
keV transition measured by Spillane et al. and Barrón-Palos et al.. The result is shown in
Fig.2. Although the resonant peaks in the two measurements seem to be aligned with each
other, the measurement of Barrón-Palos et al. is generally higher than the measurement of
Spillane et al. except the agreement around the resonance at Ec.m.=3.2 MeV. For example, the
thick target yield of Barrón-Palos et al. at Ec.m.=2.4 MeV is more than a factor of 10 higher
than the measurement of Spillane et al., resulting in the upturning trend of the S* factor at
astrophysical energies. Such a discrepancy may arise from the unknown backgrounds. The
strong resonance reported by Spillane et al. has not been confirmed by any experiment yet. It
will be useful to re-do the measurement, clarify the discrepancy and draw conclusion on the
resonances at stellar energies. Figure 2. (Color online) Comparison of the thick target yields of the 1634-keV transition measured by
Barrón-Palos et al. (blue points) and Spillane et al. (orange points). Figure 2. 3 Data compilation (Color online) Comparison of the thick target yields of the 1634-keV transition measured by
Barrón-Palos et al. (blue points) and Spillane et al. (orange points). Limited by the detection capability, some channels have to be missed in every experi-
ment. Lacking systematic studies, the correction of the missing channels has been done in
various ways. For example, it was thought that the p0 and α0 channels were the only missing
channels in the γ-spectroscopy measurement[11]. We have performed a systematic analysis
to investigate the fractions of missing channels based on a statistical model [21]. In this study,
the spin population of the entrance channel was taken from the coupled channel calculation. The decay branching ratio of each channel was evaluated with Talys and calibrated using
the experimental data of Becker [9]. Our study shows that the branching ratios of p1/ptot,
γ440/ptot, α1/γ1634, and γ1634/αtot are not constants and the average trends of these branching
ratios can be well described with the calibrated statical model prediction. Here ptot and αtot
refer to the summed cross sections of the proton and α channels, respectively. We also found
the fluctuations around these predictions decrease as the branching ratios increase. Some of
the results are shown in Fig. 3. Taking the proton channel as an example, at Ec.m.=5 MeV, the
ratio of p1/ptot is round 0.2 with a relative fluctuation of 42%(σ) around the prediction. By
including more observable channels, the ratio of P5
i=0 pi/ptot increases to about 0.5 while the
corresponding relative fluctuation decreases to 12%(σ). And this relative fluctuation of this 3 EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 ratio decrease as this ratio increases towards lower energies. Therefore, future experiments
are needed to measure as many channels as possible to reduce this systematical uncertainty. ratio decrease as this ratio increases towards lower energies. Therefore, future experiments
are needed to measure as many channels as possible to reduce this systematical uncertainty. After applying corrections based on branching ratios predicted by the statistical model,
the compilation of the experimental S* factors are shown in Fig. 4. An agreement within
±30% is achieved among the total S* factors obtained using the experimental data sets at
Ec.m. > 4 MeV, while some discrepancies remain at lower energies. For example, the recent
measurement of α1 by Tan [14] is about one tenth of the result of Fruet [15] at Ec.m. <3 MeV. 3 Data compilation Such kind of discrepancies hinder the development of reliable models and should be resolved
by better measurements in the near future. Figure 3. The comparison of the branching ratios calculated with experimental data [9] for the p-
channel. (left) The calculated σp0/σp, σp1/σp, (σp0 + σp1)/σp, P5
i=0 σpi/σp ratios are displayed with
experimental data of Becker et al. [9]. Theory1 is the present calculation by Talys, Theory2 takes
the condition of the cut-offexist in the experiment of Becker et al. [9] into consideration. (right) The
values of Becker/Theory2 for the ratios shown in (left) are calculated and displayed. The statistics are
also achieved with average value (Mean=1) and standard deviation (σ). The standard deviation (σ)
according to Mean=1.0 is given together with the Becker/Theory2. Figure 3. The comparison of the branching ratios calculated with experimental data [9] for the p-
channel. (left) The calculated σp0/σp, σp1/σp, (σp0 + σp1)/σp, P5
i=0 σpi/σp ratios are displayed with
experimental data of Becker et al. [9]. Theory1 is the present calculation by Talys, Theory2 takes
the condition of the cut-offexist in the experiment of Becker et al. [9] into consideration. (right) The
values of Becker/Theory2 for the ratios shown in (left) are calculated and displayed. The statistics are
also achieved with average value (Mean=1) and standard deviation (σ). The standard deviation (σ)
according to Mean=1.0 is given together with the Becker/Theory2. Another systematic uncertainty often overlooked is the angular distribution of the detected
particles or γ-rays. At the deep sub-barrier energies, as the dominated angular momenta of Another systematic uncertainty often overlooked is the angular distribution of the detected
particles or γ-rays. At the deep sub-barrier energies, as the dominated angular momenta of 4 4 EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 Figure 4. (Color online) The modified S factors of the proton, alpha, neutron channels and their sum
are shown as (a), (b), (c) and (d), respectively. The branching ratio corrections have been applied. The
explaination of legends can be found in Ref. [21]. Figure 4. (Color online) The modified S factors of the proton, alpha, neutron channels and their sum
are shown as (a), (b), (c) and (d), respectively. The branching ratio corrections have been applied. The
explaination of legends can be found in Ref. [21]. the entrance channel are Li =0 and 2, the angular distribution of the emitted charged particles,
p and α, can be anisotropic. 3 Data compilation The allowed orders of the angular distribution coefficients are 0,
2 and 4. The angular distributions of the exit channels require a complete measurement using
a charged particle array and good statistics. They have only been measured by the limited
amount of experiments at sub-barrier energies. When the angular distribution coefficient of
the fourth order can be ignored, one may approximate the averaged differential cross sec-
tion by using the differential cross section at 55 or 125 degrees in the center of mass frame. An isotropic angular distribution was assumed to get the integrated cross section. Measure-
ments performed at other angles often use this assumption to determine the integrated cross
section, resulting in an unknown systematic uncertainty. More experimental and theoretical
investigations are needed to quantify this uncertainty. 4 Test of extrapolating model and the establishment of the upper
limit Modeling 12C+12C heavy ion fusion cross sections at deep sub-barrier energies has been
a long standing challenge for nuclear reaction theory [20]. The Gamow energy window for
most astrophysical applications typically spans 500 keV or more, and with no reliable method
for predicting the resonances at lower energies, the standard reaction rate (CF88) was estab-
lished by modeling the averaged S* factor,S ∗(E) = S (E)exp(0.46E), with a constant value
corresponding to a S(E) with a rising trend towards lower energies [7, 22]. The rising trend of
S-factor towards lower energies is supported by various phenomenological and microscopic
models, such as density-constrained time dependent Hartree-Fock method (DC-TDHF) [23],
wave-packet dynamics (TDWP) [24], barrier penetration model based on the global São Paulo
potentials (SPP) [5] or the Krappe-Nix-Sierk potential (KNS) [11], and coupled channel cal-
culations [25, 26] such as CC-M3Y+Rep (Fig. 1(a)). However, the hindrance model, a global 5 EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022) https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 phenomenological model based on the systematics observed in systems with 64≳A≳30, pre-
dicts that the 12C+12C S-factor reaches its maximum at Ec.m.=3.68±0.38 MeV [13, 27–29]. At lower energies, this model predicts a rapid drop in the S-factor leading to a reduced reac-
tion rate that is many orders of magnitude smaller than the standard rate used for astrophysical
modeling. However, the complicated resonant structure makes it difficult to test the predic-
tive power of the extrapolating models. As we demonstrated in Fig.5 and Table 1, all the
models yield similarly poor reduced-χ2s of about 5−9.5. Recently, the cross sections were
determined indirectly for Ec.m.= 0.8 MeV to 2.7 MeV using the Trojan Horse Method [30],
recommending a new S-factor with a slope rising faster than any models presented in Fig. 1,
resulting in a new rate which is 1 or 2 orders of magnitude higher than the standard one. The large uncertainty of the 12C+12C rate drastically impacts a number of models such as
late-time massive star evolution, the ignition dynamics of type Ia supernovae and x-ray su-
perbursts [5, 6]. Figure 5. (Color online) The best fits of various models to the experimental S* factor of Spillane in
the range of Ec.m.= 2.68 to 3.97 MeV. The resulting reduced-χ2 for the models, M3Y-Rep, Hindrance,
TDHF, and CF88, are listed in Table 1. Figure 5. 4 Test of extrapolating model and the establishment of the upper
limit (Color online) The best fits of various models to the experimental S* factor of Spillane in
the range of Ec.m.= 2.68 to 3.97 MeV. The resulting reduced-χ2 for the models, M3Y-Rep, Hindrance,
TDHF, and CF88, are listed in Table 1. Table 1. The reduced-χ2 for different models (scenario 1: No normalization; scenario 2: with
renormalization;)
Models
M3Y-Rep
Hind
TDHF
CF88
scenario 1
1888
680
3232
915
scenario 2
6.69
9.47
5.03
6.01 Table 1. The reduced-χ2 for different models (scenario 1: No normalization; scenario 2: with
renormalization;) Models
M3Y-Rep
Hind
TDHF
CF88
scenario 1
1888
680
3232
915
scenario 2
6.69
9.47
5.03
6.01 While the complicated resonance-like structure in 12C+12C and the lack of reliable mea-
surements at lower energies prevent us from drawing a clear conclusion [13], the isotope
fusion reaction 12C+13C offers an ideal opportunity to constrain the 12C+12C S-factor. It has
been observed at energies below and above the Coulomb barrier that 12C+13C and 13C+13C
cross sections are upper bounds of the 12C+12C cross sections, and match the maxima of the
resonance-like structure seen in 12C+12C in a wide range from 10−8 b to 1 b [31]. This strong
correlation among the three systems has been well explained by coupled channel calculations
and the significantly different level densities of the compound states [32]. At sub-barrier en-
ergies, the valence neutron(s) in 12C+13C and 13C+13C increase the level densities of their
compound states by at least one order of magnitude in comparison to 12C+12C and result in 6 EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022) EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 smooth cross sections. According to the following equation [32], According to the following equation [32], σ =
X
J
σJ
cc
1 −exp(1 −2πΓJ/DJ)
,
(1) (1) the upper limit of the 12C+12C cross section is reached using the high level density limit
and can be modeled consistently with the other C+C isotope systems [32]. The average of
the 12C+12C fusion cross section is also predicted by modulating the upper limit with the
averaged ratio of the level width <Γ> and the level spacing <D> of 24Mg [32]. Since the
effect of < Γ/D > is not sensitive to the energy, the shape of the averaged cross section is
essentially determined by the model used for the upper limit prediction. 5 Extrapolation towards stellar energies and Reaction Rate We proposed a new extrapolation based on the lower and upper limits for the S* factor of
12C+12C in parallel to the other existing extrapolation [21]. The KNS extrapolation based on
the non-resonant component of the existing S* at higher energies is one of the lower limits
we considered. The current TDWP approach does not include the cluster effect which may
account for the resonances at deep sub-barrier energies. Therefore it can provide the other
lower limit. It is interesting to note that the TDWP calculation agrees with the empirical
lower limit (KNS) with a deviation below 33% at energies below 3 MeV. Combining our
upper limits with the lower limit based on the prediction of TDWP, the 12C+12C S* factors
are better constrained despite the unknown resonances within the unmeasured energy range as
shown in Fig. 4(d). The reaction rate of 12C+12C was calculated with the measured S* factors
at E≥2.7 MeV, where a reasonable agreement among the experimental total S* factors exists,
and using the random S* factor limited by the lower and upper limits for <2.7 MeV. The
average of these two limits is used to estimate the mean value of the S* factor. The resulting
reaction rates are shown in Fig. 6 together with the rates obtained with the hindrance model
and the THM indirect measurement. 4 Test of extrapolating model and the establishment of the upper
limit Therefore, a model
well constrained by 12C+13C is crucial for us to set a reliable upper limit and constrain the
shape of the averaged cross section for 12C+12C. 12
13 We performed an activity measurement in SLANIC mine for the 12C+13C system with
energies down to Ec.m.=2.323 MeV, at which the 12C(13C,p)24Na cross section is found to
be 0.22(7) nb. The 12C+13C fusion cross section is derived with a statistical model cali-
brated using experimental data. Our result of the 12C+13C fusion cross section provided the
first decisive evidence in the carbon isotope systems which rules out the existence of the as-
trophysical S-factor maximum predicted by the phenomenological hindrance model, while
confirming the rising trend of the S-factor towards lower energies predicted by other models,
such as CC-M3Y+Rep, DC-TDHF, KNS, SPP and ESW. After normalizing the model pre-
dictions with our data, a more reliable upper limit is established for the 12C+12C fusion cross
sections at stellar energies [33]. However, this upper limit is lower than the strong resonance
observed by Spillane at 2.14 MeV and the indirect THM measurement based on the PWIA
assumption. Experimental and theoretical efforts are needed to resolve the issues. 6 New approaches The precise measurement of the tiny reaction cross section demands new experimental tech-
niques with lower background, higher detection efficiency and higher luminosity. The mea-
surement of the channels with the γ-ray emissions is being planned at the LUNA underground
laboratory. Jingpin Underground Nuclear Astrophysics collaboration (JUNA) is also pushing 7 7 7 factor towa
such as CC
[32]. A rec
of hindranc
α1
or online) (top) S
* factors of
channel ob
EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI other models,
PP, and ESW
ms the absence
https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 es between 2.45 to 2.6 MeV;
es much lower than the direct
gies. Based on this comparis-
we may conclude that neither
e direct measurement at ener-
e and better direct measure-
n are needed at energies below
lopment of the indirect meas-
tal
12C+
12C S
* factor
ing energies range from a few
Extrapolating the averaged
on down to stellar energies is
ated resonance structure in
liable measurements at lower
rawing a clear conclusion [39-
rate (CF88 [42]) was estab-
(E) based on the square well
tems provides a great opportunity to establish an upper
ured by Spillane et al. (black);
ld measured by Spillane et al. ck target yields based on THM
ets; (bottom) Thick target ratios
on THM (red) or corrected THM
d by Spillane et al. Fig. 13. (color online) Rates relative to CF88 rate [42] ob-
tained in the present study (red) along with rates based on
the THM measurement [35] (blue) and hindrance model
[43] (Green). Temperatures for the type Ia supernovae (T =
0.15-0.7 GK), core carbon burning (T = 0.6-1.0 GK), hy-
drostatic shell carbon burning (T = 1.0-1.2 GK), and explos-
ive shell carbon burning (T = 1.8-2.5 GK) are marked by
colored bands. Figure 6. The relative reaction rate obtained in the current work (Red) together with the rates based on
the THM measurement [30] (Blue) and hindrance model [28] (Green) to the CF88 rate [22]. Tempera-
tures for core carbon burning (T = 0.6-1.0 GK), hydrostatic shell carbon burning (T = 1.0-1.2 GK), and
explosive shell carbon burning (T = 1.8-2.5 GK) are marked by colored bands. tems provides a great opportunity to establish an upper
Fig 13
(color online) Rates relative to CF88 rate [42] ob Extrapolating the averaged
n down to stellar energies is
ted resonance structure in
liable measurements at lower
awing a clear conclusion [39-
rate (CF88 [42]) was estab-
E) b
d
th
ll
tained in the present study (red) along with rates based on
the THM measurement [35] (blue) and hindrance model
[43] (Green). 7 Temperatures for the type Ia supernovae (T =
0.15-0.7 GK), core carbon burning (T = 0.6-1.0 GK), hy-
drostatic shell carbon burning (T = 1.0-1.2 GK), and explos-
ive shell carbon burning (T = 1.8-2.5 GK) are marked by
l
d b
d
Figure 6. The relative reaction rate obtained in the current work (Red) together with the rates based on
the THM measurement [30] (Blue) and hindrance model [28] (Green) to the CF88 rate [22]. Tempera-
tures for core carbon burning (T = 0.6-1.0 GK), hydrostatic shell carbon burning (T = 1.0-1.2 GK), and
explosive shell carbon burning (T = 1.8-2.5 GK) are marked by colored bands. the project of upgrading their accelerator to study the heavy ion fusion reactions at stellar
energies. As a complementary approach, we are developing a charged-particle measurement
based on the Low Energy Accelerator Facility (LEAF) at IMP [34]. Using the state of art
LINAC and powerful ECR sources, LEAF has delivered 50-pµA carbon beam on target, the
highest beam intensity ever realized in the carbon fusion experiments. We plan to reach 100
pµA by optimizing the transmission efficiency. To suppress the beam induced backgrounds
and the natural background, we developed a new experimental technique using the Time Pro-
jection Chamber. With the supreme tracking capability and particle identification, the pre-
liminary thick target yield of 12C(12C,α0)20Ne has been determined to 1.4(1.4)E-17 evt/12C
at Ec.m.=2.22 MeV. We are planning to check the strong resonance reported at Ec.m.=2.14
MeV in the near future. The indirect measurement like THM offers a way of extrapolation. But this approach
needs to be validated with the direct measurement before applying it at the deep sub-barrier
energies [35]. Lacking reliable information of the resonances at deep sub-barrier energies,
extrapolating models are not able to provide more precise extrapolation. It has been pointed
out theoretically that the molecular resonances in the channel of 12C+12C can be populated
via the isoscalar transitions. Therefore, the 24Mg(α,α′)24Mg∗offers another opportunity to
access the resonances at the deep sub-barriers which is not accessible by direct measurement. Such measurements carried out at RCNP [36] and iThemba will provide the important nuclear
structure information for the extrapolation at stellar energies. 7 Summary The 12C+12C reaction is one of the most important reactions in stellar evolution. Despite
some progress being made in recent years, there is no satisfactory answer yet for the reaction
rate to be used in the astrophysical models. Reliable measurement of the major reaction
channels of 12C+12C at energies below 3 MeV, complimentary indirect measurements and
standardized data compilation are essential to resolve the existing discrepancies and guide
the theory towards the right direction. New experimental and theoretical approaches are 8 8 8 EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022) https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 being developed to push the measurement further at deep sub-barrier energies and model the
complicated resonance beyond the reach of measurement. With all these efforts, one expects
to achieve a more reliable reaction rate for the interest of astrophysics. being developed to push the measurement further at deep sub-barrier energies and model the
complicated resonance beyond the reach of measurement. With all these efforts, one expects
to achieve a more reliable reaction rate for the interest of astrophysics. References [1] S. Woosley, A. Heger, and T. Weaver, Rev. Mod. Phys. 74, p. 1015 (2002) [2] C. Iliadis, Nuclear Physics of Stars (WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, 2 [3] R. Cooper, A. Steiner, and E. Brown, Apj. 702, p. 660 (2009) [4] L. R. Gasques, A. V. Afanasjev, E. F. Aguilera, M. Beard, L. C. Chamon, P. Ring, M. Wiescher, and D. G. Yakovlev, Phys. Rev. C 72, p. 025806 (2005) [5] L. R. Gasques, Phys. Rev. C 76, p. 035802 (2007) [6] K. Mori, M. A. Famiano, T. Kajino, M. Kusakabe, and X.D. Tang, Monthly Notices of
the Royal Astronomical Society 482, Pages L70–L74(2019) [7] J. R. Patterson, H. Winkler, and C. S. Zaidins, Ap.J. 157, p. 367(1969) [8] M.G.Mazarakis and W.E.Stephens, Phys.Rev. C 7, 1280 (1973) [9] H.W. Becker, K. U. Kettner, C. Rolfs, and H. P. Trautvetter, Zeitschrift für Physik A 303,
305–312 (1981) [10] K. Kettner, H. Lorenz-Wirzba, and C. Rolls, Z. Phys. A 298, p. 65 (1980) [11] E. F. Aguilera, P. Rosales, E. Martinez-Quiroz, G. Murillo, M. Fernndez, H. Berdejo,
D. Lizcano, A. Gmez- Camacho, R. Policroniades, A. Varela, E. Moreno, E. Chvez, M. E. Ortz, A. Huerta, T. Belyaeva, and M. Wiescher, Phys. Rev. C 73, p. 064601 (2006) Ortz, A. Huerta, T. Belyaeva, and M. Wiescher, Phys. Rev. C 73, p. 064601 (2006) [12] T. Spillane et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, p. 122501 (2007) [12] T. Spillane et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, p. 122501 (2007) [13] C. L. Jiang et al., Phys. Rev. C 97, 012801(R) (2018) [14] W.P. Tan et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 124,192702 (2020) [15] G. Fruet et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 192701 (2020) [15] G. Fruet et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 192701 (2020) [16] B. Bucher etal., Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, p. 251102 (2015) [17] B.Cujec, I.Hunyadi, and I.M.Szoghy, Phys.Rev. C 39, 1326 (1989) [18] L. Barrón-Palos etal., Nucl. Phys. A 779, P.318 (2006) [19] J.Zickefoose et al., Phys.Rev. C 97, 065806 (2018) 0] C. A. Barnes, S. Trentalange, and S. C. Wu, “Treatise on heavy-ion science,” (Plenum
Preess, New York, 1985) Chap. 1„ pp. 3–60. [20] C. A. Barnes, S. Trentalange, and S. C. Wu, “Treatise on heavy-ion science,” (Plenum
Preess, New York, 1985) Chap. 1„ pp. 3–60. [21] Y. J. Li, X. Fang, B. Bucher, K. A. Li, L. H. Ru and X. D. Tang, Chin. Phys. 8 Acknowledgment This work was supported in part by the National Key Research and Development Program
of China (No. 2016YFA0400501), the Strategic Priority Research Program of Chinese
Academy of Sciences (No. XDB34020200). References C 44,
115001 (2020) [22] G. R. Caughlan and W. A. Fowler, Atomic Data And Nuclear Data Tables 40, p. 283
(1988) [23] K.Godbey, C.Simenel, and A.S.Umar, Phys.Rev. C 100, 024619 (2019) [24] A.Diaz-Torres and M.Wiescher, Phys. Rev. C 97, 055802 (2018) [25] M. Assuncao and P. Descouvemont, Phys. Lett. B 723, 355–359 (2013) [26] H. Esbensen, X. Tang and C.L. Jiang, Phys. Rev. C 84, 064613 (2011) [27] B. B. Back, H. Esbensen, C. L. Jiang, and K. E. Rehm, Rev. Mod. Phys. 86, 317 (2014) 9 EPJ Web of Conferences 260, 01002 (2022)
NIC-XVI https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/202226001002 [28] C. L. Jiang, K. E. Rehm, B. B. Back, and R. V. F. Janssens, Phys. Rev. C 75, 015803
(2007) [28] C. L. Jiang, K. E. Rehm, B. B. Back, and R. V. F. Janssens, Phys. Rev. C 75, 015803
(2007) [29] C. L. Jiang, B. B. Back, K. E. Rehm, K. Hagino, G. Montagnoli and A. M. Stefanini,
Eur. Phys. J. A 57, 235 (2021) [29] C. L. Jiang, B. B. Back, K. E. Rehm, K. Hagino, G. Montagnoli and A. M. Stefanini,
Eur. Phys. J. A 57, 235 (2021) [30] A. Tumino et al., Nature 557, 687 (2018) [30] A. Tumino et al., Nature 557, 687 (2018) [31] M. Notani et al., Phys. Rev. C 85 (2012) 014607 [31] M. Notani et al., Phys. Rev. C 85 (2012) 014607 [31] M. Notani et al., Phys. Rev. C 85 (2012) 014607 [32] C.L. Jiang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 072701 (2013) [32] C.L. Jiang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 072701 (2013) [33] N.T. Zhang et al., Phys. Lett. B 801, 135170(2020) [33] N.T. Zhang et al., Phys. Lett. B 801, 135170(2020) [34] Y. Yang et al., J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1401, 01201(2020) [34] Y. Yang et al., J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 1401, 01201(2020) [35] A.M. Mukhamedzhanov, A.S. Kadyrov and D.Y. Pang, Eur. Phys. J. A 56, 233 (2020) [35] A.M. Mukhamedzhanov, A.S. Kadyrov and D.Y. Pang, Eur. Phys. J. A 56, 233 (202 [36] T. Kawabata et al., Few-Body Systems 54, 93 (2013) [36] T. Kawabata et al., Few-Body Systems 54, 93 (2013) 10
|
https://openalex.org/W2750585180
|
https://wnus.edu.pl/cto/file/article/view/6412.pdf
|
Polish
| null |
Księga Mądrości na dziś (Maneat Questio 26), Poznań 2014, ss. 141
|
Colloquia Theologica Ottoniana/Colloquia Theologica Ottoniania
| 2,016
|
cc-by-sa
| 784
|
1 Ks. dr Tomasz Zaklukiewicz – specjalizuje się w teologii biblijnej. E-mail: zakluk@szcze-
cin.opoka.org.pl. COLLOQUIA THEOLOGICA OTTONIANA 2/2016, s. 239–241 COLLOQUIA THEOLOGICA OTTONIANA 2/2016, s. 239–241 DOI: 10.18276/cto.2016.2-14 DOI: 10.18276/cto.2016.2-14 BOGDAN PONIŻY, KSIĘGA MĄDROŚCI NA DZIŚ
(MANEAT QUESTIO 26), POZNAŃ 2014, SS. 141 Tomasz Zaklukiewicz1
Szczecin W 2014 roku na rynku wydawniczym ukazała się książka polskiego nie-
kwestionowanego znawcy Księgi Mądrości, ks. prof. Bogdana Poniżego Księga
Mądrości na dziś. Autor, który od czterdziestu lat prowadzi wykłady z biblistyki,
w sposób szczególny zajmując się w swoich badaniach naukowych najmłodszą
księgą Starego Testamentu, przeprowadził sondę wśród osób uczestniczących
we Mszach św. na temat znajomości Księgi Mądrości. Wnioski nie napawały
radością, jak sam autor pisze we wstępie do książki: „Mało kto wiedział, że taka
księga istnieje” (s. 9). Stąd zrodził się pomysł napisania książki skierowanej do
szerokiego grona czytelników , tym bardziej że problematyka Księgi Mądrości jest
aktualna także dzisiaj. Na wstępie lektury narzuca się pytanie: czy można przekazać współ-
czesnemu człowiekowi zawartość księgi biblijnej w interesujący sposób? Wydaje
się, że nasz autor poradził sobie z tym bez problemu. Treść tej pracy zawarta
została w czternastu rozdziałach. Całość napisana jest w formie wywiadu rzeki. Wprowadzając fikcyjnego rozmówcę (dziennikarza? ucznia?), zadającego mu
pytania, Poniży udziela odpowiedzi, w których ukazuje treść Księgi Mądrości i jej
przesłanie teologiczne. Stawiane pytania są jednocześnie wstępem do omawianej
kwestii, gdyż pytający wykazuje się wiedzą na temat przedmiotu rozmowy. 240 Tඈආൺඌඓ Zൺඅඎංൾඐංർඓ Tඈආൺඌඓ Zൺඅඎංൾඐංർඓ Tytuł każdego rozdziału, oprócz pierwszego, jest cytatem zaczerpniętym
z Księgi Mądrości. Poszczególne rozdziały stanowią zamkniętą całość i dzięki
temu czytelnik może wracać do tematów poruszanych w książce. Każdy z nich ma
podobną budowę – tytuł jest cytatem z Księgi Mądrości, podtytuł wyjaśnieniem
cytatu. Dalej odnajdujemy rozważanie tekstu Księgi Mądrości, omówione jest
Sitz im Leben danego fragmentu, wyjaśnienie kwestii teologicznych, odniesienie
do współczesności. Rozdziały kończą się kolejnym cytatem z Księgi Mądrości,
niosącym przesłanie do życia czytelnika. W pierwszym rozdziale, różniącym się od pozostałych, czytelnik odnajdzie
wprowadzenie do lektury Księgi Mądrości – omówione jest jej autorstwo,
adresaci, okoliczności powstania. Tło historyczne będzie powracać w całej
książce, w poszczególnych rozdziałach. Poniży odwołuje się często do wydarzeń
historycznych towarzyszących powstawaniu księgi. Jest to potrzebne, by czy-
telnik mógł uświadomić sobie sytuację bytową hagiografa i adresatów tej księgi
biblijnej. Oprócz wyjaśnień historycznych znajdujemy objaśnienia figur retoryki
hebrajskiej i greckiej występujących na kartach Księgi Mądrości. Autor biblijny
musiał bowiem użyć greckiego sposobu przekazu, by był zrozumiałym przez
sobie współczesnych. Kwestie teologiczne poruszone w Księdze Mądrości znajdują wyjaśnienia
w omawianej książce. Poniży pisze w poszczególnych rozdziałach o darze
mądrości, o losie człowieka sprawiedliwego, o jego prześladowaniu, o śmierci,
która jest dziełem diabła, o nieśmiertelności, idolatrii, Bożej opatrzności i grzechu. W ostatnich dwóch rozdziałach autor zajmuje się omówieniem występującej
w Księdze Mądrości retoryki i poezji, wspomina także nauki filozofów greckich. Chcąc pomóc czytelnikowi odczytać Księgę Mądrości, autor odnosi się
do współczesności i momentami wpada w ton kaznodziejski. Tego typu roz-
ważania, podobnie jak upomnienia, by nie pytać o „muchy i komary” (s. 47),
czy wtrącone pytanie: „skąd wzięło się na świecie kłamstwo?” (s. 113), mogą
powodować rozdrażnienie czytelnika, który książkę Poniżego traktuje jak lite-
raturę popularnonaukową. Trzeba też zwrócić uwagę na pewne nieścisłości występujące w tej pracy. Omawiając dwa filozoficzne terminy – athnasia i aftharsia – autor nie wskazuje,
które wyjaśnienie odnosi się do pierwszego terminu (s. 46); omawiając odstępstwa
Izraelitów, błędnie w tekście podano rok, zamiast miejsca cytowania Księgi
Wyjścia (s. 51). Poniży, tłumacząc, czym jest występujący w Księdze Mądrości
asyndeton, raz twierdzi, że polega on na stosowaniu części zdań bez użycia prze- Bඈൽൺඇ Pඈඇංඒ, Kਓਉੈਇਁ Mਾਏ੧ਃਉ ਁ ਚਉ੧... 241 cinków (s. 128), a innym razem podaje przykład tej figury retorycznej, w której
znajdują się przecinki (s. 130). Reasumując, należy stwierdzić, że Księga Mądrości na dziś jest pierwszą
pozycją popularnonaukową dotyczącą najmłodszej księgi Starego Testamentu
skierowaną do szerokiego grona czytelników. Tඈආൺඌඓ Zൺඅඎංൾඐංർඓ Jej celem jest przybliżenie prze-
słania Księgi Mądrości i zmobilizowanie współczesnych do jej lektury. Dzięki zastosowaniu formy wywiadu udało się autorowi uniknąć napisania
kolejnego akademickiego podręcznika o Księdze Mądrości. Całość czyta się
jak gawędę, opowiadanie Mistrza, mające pouczyć ucznia, w tym wypadku
interlokutora i czytelnika. Autor z erudycją wynajduje i wyjaśnia wiele figur
retorycznych, które znajdujemy na kartach Księgi Mądrości, wprowadza nas
w atmosferę wydarzeń w Aleksandrii w 38 roku po Chr., ukazując, jak ważne
jest w życiu człowieka bycie sprawiedliwym mimo niesprzyjających warunków
zewnętrznych. Uświadamia czytelnikowi działanie Bożej opatrzności. Poniży
wszystko to czyni po to, by ukazać nam aktualność Księgi Mądrości. Jako że książka Poniżego stanowi zachętę do lektury Księgi Mądrości, na
zakończenie zacytujmy z tej pracy odpowiedź na pytanie, jak dzisiaj należy ją
czytać: „Można ją czytać na wielu poziomach: czytać jako tekst uniwersalny, jako
tekst z kluczem, tekst historyczny i jako dramat klasyczny, i oczywiście – również
w sposób dowolny” (s. 121).
|
https://openalex.org/W4388826577
|
https://geusbulletin.org/index.php/geusb/article/download/8353/14403
|
English
| null |
Machine learning-based estimation and clustering of statistics within stratigraphic models as exemplified in Denmark
|
GEUS bulletin
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 5,447
|
METHOD ARTICLE | SHORT METHOD ARTICLE | SHORT METHOD ARTICLE | SHORT Frederik Alexander Falk*1
, Rasmus Bødker Madsen2 Frederik Alexander Falk*1
, Rasmus Bødker Madsen2 1Department of Geoscience, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark; 2Department of Near Surface Land and Marine Geology, Geological Survey of
Denmark and Greenland (GEUS), Aarhus, Denmark *Correspondence: frederikfalk@geo.au.dk
Received: 31 May 2023
Revised: 23 Aug 2023
Accepted: 26 Sep 2023
Published: 17 Nov 2023 Abstract Estimating a covariance model for kriging purposes is traditionally done using semivariogram
analyses, where an empirical semivariogram is calculated, and a chosen semivariogram model,
usually defined by a sill and a range, is fitted. We demonstrate that a convolutional neural network
can estimate such a semivariogram model with comparable accuracy and precision by training
it to recognise the relationship between realisations of Gaussian random fields and the sill and
range values that define it, for a Gaussian type semivariance model. We do this by training the
network with synthetic data consisting of many such realisations with the sill and range as the
target variables. Because training takes time, the method is best suited for cases where many
models need to be estimated since the actual estimation itself is about 70 times faster with the
neural network than with the traditional approach. We demonstrate the viability of the method in
three ways: (1) we test the model’s performance on the validation data, (2) we do a test where we
compare the model to the traditional approach and (3) we show an example of an actual applica
tion of the method using the Danish national hydrostratigraphic model. Keywords: convolutional neural network,
covariance model, Semivariogram
modelling, machine learning, local
stationarity Keywords: convolutional neural network,
covariance model, Semivariogram
modelling, machine learning, local
stationarity Abbreviations
CNN: convolutional neural network
ML: machine learning
NN: neural network GEUS Bulletin (eISSN: 2597-2154) is an
open access, peer-reviewed journal
published by the Geological Survey of
Denmark and Greenland (GEUS). This
article is distributed under a CC-BY 4.0
licence, permitting free redistribution,
and reproduction for any purpose, even
commercial, provided proper citation of the
original work. Author(s) retain copyright. Tabular abstract
Geographical coverage
Fyn, Denmark
Temporal coverage
N/A
Subject(s) covered
Geophysics, Computational geoscience, informatics and
remote sensing
Method type
A new machine learning-based method for estimating
locally optimised semivariogram parameters for grid
cells in stratigraphic models followed by clustering for
the introduction of the assumption of local stationarity. Method name
Machine learning-based semivariogram model estima
tion and clustering
Instruments and equipment
used
Equipment Used:
- A sufficiently effective computer
- MATLAB® software license
• Machine Learning Toolbox for MATLAB
• SIPPI Geostatistics Toolbox for MATLAB
• mGstat Geostatistics Toolbox for MATLAB
Related publications
None
Potential application(s) for this
method
This method may be used to infer a statistical model
from one stratigraphic model, which is useful for uncer
tainty quantification. Abstract The method is also useful for very
fast semivariogram modelling whenever the advantage
of doing so outweighs the time it takes to train the
model. Tabular abstract
Geographical coverage
Fyn, Denmark
Temporal coverage
N/A
Subject(s) covered
Geophysics, Computational geoscience, informatics and
remote sensing
Method type
A new machine learning-based method for estimating
locally optimised semivariogram parameters for grid
cells in stratigraphic models followed by clustering for
the introduction of the assumption of local stationarity. Method name
Machine learning-based semivariogram model estima
tion and clustering
Instruments and equipment
used
Equipment Used:
- A sufficiently effective computer
- MATLAB® software license
• Machine Learning Toolbox for MATLAB
• SIPPI Geostatistics Toolbox for MATLAB
• mGstat Geostatistics Toolbox for MATLAB
Related publications
None
Potential application(s) for this
method
This method may be used to infer a statistical model
from one stratigraphic model, which is useful for uncer
tainty quantification. The method is also useful for very
fast semivariogram modelling whenever the advantage
of doing so outweighs the time it takes to train the
model. Edited by: Julian Koch (GEUS, Copenhagen,
Denmark) Methodological protocolsfi We use the CNN’s ability to efficiently detect structural
patterns in an image, and as such, it needs a regular
grid as input. We consider two cases: one where data
constitute a full grid and one with scattered point data
interpolated to produce a grid. For the network input,
we chose the grid size 31 × 31 cells with a cell size of 100
m, and we adapted the neural Network (NN) architec
ture from the SqueezeNet convolutional neural network
(Iandola et al. 2016), which is a native architecture in the
MATLAB Machine Learning Toolbox. Producing training, validation and test data Producing training, validation and test data
We produced synthetic data for the NN using the
SIPPI toolbox in MATLAB (Hansen et al. 2013) by taking
150 000 values for sill and range from uniform distribu
tions, such that the sills vary between 0 m2 and 1100 m2,
and the ranges vary between 100 m and 3000 m. We propose a new method of estimating the sill and
range given a set of spatially distributed data using
machine learning (ML), specifically a convolutional neu
ral network (CNN), which is more efficient when esti
mating many models. A CNN is trained to recognise the
approximate mapping from a realisation of a Gaussian
random field to the semivariogram model that defines
its probability density function. This mapping is not
bijective in nature, and as such, it is not a function. However, the network should still be able to approxi
mate a function that resembles the mapping to some
degree. We then simulate a realisation from each of the Gauss
ian random fields that have the Gaussian semivariance
functions defined by the pairs of sill and range values. Each realisation is on the 31 × 31 grid with a cell size
of 100 m. To include some component of noise, we simulated
and added one more realisation to each existing reali
sation, with the same effective range, and the sill being
random between 0 m2 and the sill of the original realisa
tion itself. Figure 1 shows nine examples of the synthetic
data. The idea of using a CNN for semivariogram mod
elling has been proposed before. One study used
separate networks for interpolation and parameter
estimation (Jo & Pyrcz 2022). Others skipped parame
terised models and directly estimated semivariograms
for kriging (Li et al. 2022). Methodological protocolsfi We have chosen to focus
on estimating Gaussian model parameters using one
network to infer their spatial distribution within large
models and make the process computationally feasi
ble. We test the method on the Danish national hydro
stratigraphic model (DK-model; Stisen et al. 2020). We
show that where local stationarity may be assumed,
we can define regions within the hydrostratigraphic
model with reasonable accuracy by clustering the
models. The synthetic data are saved both as full grids and
sets of 120 points with an x-coordinate, a y-coordinate
and a z-coordinate. We split the synthetic data into a
training set, consisting of 90% of the data, as well as a
validation and a training set, each being 5% of the data. Introduction The properties of the subsurface are highly non-sta
tionary, that is, they vary significantly depending on the
location. Consequently, in statistical descriptions of the
subsurface, there is a need for mapping non-stationarity
in the statistical properties and for practical purposes
also defining regions wherein local stationarity can be
assumed (Boisvert et al. 2009). • A sufficiently effective computer • A sufficiently effective computer • MATLAB® 2022b or newer – older versions have
not been tested for this method. Also, the Machine
Learning Toolbox for MATLAB, SIPPI Geostatistics
Toolbox for MATLAB and the mGstat Geostatistics
Toolbox for MATLAB Estimating the statistical properties of spatially dis
tributed data is conventionally done through semivar
iogram analysis, where an experimental semivariogram
is calculated as half the average squared difference
between points separated by some distance, h (Math
eron 1963). A model is fitted to the semivariogram,
which is typically defined by two parameters – a range
and a sill, and oftentimes also a nugget effect (Cressie
1993). Alternatively, it is possible to estimate a semivar
iogram model by determining the maximum-likelihood
combination of sill and range given the type of model. The likelihood for a semivariogram model is obtained
by populating a covariance matrix using the model and
taking the probability density of the corresponding mul
tivariate normal distribution at the point defined by the
data (Mardia 1990). Fitting a semivariogram and estimat
ing the maximum-likelihood model share the drawbacks
of being computationally intensive when many models
need to be estimated. • Data in the form of scattered points with a value
for each point, either with irregular spacing or as a
regular grid Required resources Required resources
The required resources are as follows: Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 Edited by: Julian Koch (GEUS, Copenhagen,
Denmark) Reviewed by: Jacob Skauvold (Norwegian
Computing Center, Norway)
Funding: See page 7
Competing interests: See page 7
Additional files: None Reviewed by: Jacob Skauvold (Norwegian
Computing Center, Norway) Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 1 of 7 Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 www.geusbulletin.org Validation on synthetic data We take a set of 1000 new synthetic realisations of size
31 × 31, each with 120 randomly drawn points, and we
use these points to: 1. Perform a traditional semivariogram analysis with
the following steps: 1. Perform a traditional semivariogram analysis with
the following steps: 1. Perform a traditional semivariogram analysis with
the following steps: for 100 epochs. The total training time for the network is
about 1 h. We also found that model training time could
be reduced to only a few minutes if we included the fast
Fourier transform as a second image input channel. Ulti
mately, we chose not to do this because that requires us
to calculate the Fourier transform of the data input every
time we want to use the model. This is a disadvantage
because it slows down the prediction process, which
becomes an issue when applied to very large models. The Fourier transform could be useful if training data are
scarce, which could be the case with non-synthetic train
ing data. At this point, the network is ready to use, and
only requires a 31 × 31 grid input. The training can also
be done with point data. However, as the CNN is based
on image convolution, one should choose an interpola
tion method and convert the point data to a grid. for 100 epochs. The total training time for the network is
about 1 h. We also found that model training time could
be reduced to only a few minutes if we included the fast
Fourier transform as a second image input channel. Ulti
mately, we chose not to do this because that requires us
to calculate the Fourier transform of the data input every
time we want to use the model. This is a disadvantage
because it slows down the prediction process, which
becomes an issue when applied to very large models. The Fourier transform could be useful if training data are
scarce, which could be the case with non-synthetic train
ing data. At this point, the network is ready to use, and
only requires a 31 × 31 grid input. The training can also
be done with point data. However, as the CNN is based
on image convolution, one should choose an interpola
tion method and convert the point data to a grid. a. Calculate an empirical semivariogram from
the points. b. Validation on synthetic data Fit a Gaussian semivariance model to the
semivariogram using a weighted least-
squares approach, where points closer to the
origin have greater weight. 2. Predict the sill and range directly with our CNN with
the following steps: a. Interpolate the 120 points onto the entire
grid. b. Pass the interpolated grid through the CNN. We then compare the accuracy of the estimates with
these two methods as well as the time it takes to com
plete. The result of the accuracy comparison is shown
in Fig. 3 for eight different realisations. Depending
on the specific realisation, it varies whether the fit
ted model (black line) or CNN (blue line) is better at
resolving the true model (red line). Across all 1000
realisations, we see that the CNN is slightly better at
approximating large values for the range than the tra
ditional approach, whereas the traditional method is
slightly better at low values. In general, both methods
have similar performance. Training the network The network is trained with the ‘Adam’ optimisation
algorithm, and the loss function is represented by the
mean squared error. We used a constant learning rate of
0.0005 and a batch size of 1000 whilst training the model Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 2 of 7 www.geusbulletin.org Fig. 1 Synthetic training data produced using Gaussian semivariance
models with random sill and range, with a component of noise. The
circles show 120 randomly drawn points from each realisation. Shading:
smallest values are shown in blue and largest values are shown in
yellow, with in-between values shown in green. Sill: 455.4 Range: 2713
Sill: 499.1 Range: 1577
Sill: 1054 Range: 1900
Sill: 431 Range: 2327
Sill: 389.5 Range: 1374
Sill: 1080 Range: 411.2
Sill: 187 Range: 1002
Sill: 575.7 Range: 2446
Sill: 206.6 Range: 455.1 range and sill for the validation data set. A common way to
estimate the sill is to simply take the sample variance of the
scattered points, which is also shown in Fig. 2. The predicted range values are very close to the true
values for both scattered data and full grids. The pre
dictions using full grids are a little more accurate, which
we expected since the scattered points are drawn from
the full grids and thus contain less information. The
predictions for the sill are equally precise between the
two cases and even share the same apparent biases. For example, at sill values of 500 to 1500, the ML model
over-estimates, whilst it underestimates for sill values
above 2000. Although we did not use bias description,
it is possible by fitting a suitable polynomial function
between prediction and actual values. Correcting the
estimates to account for bias is then straightforward. Alternatively, it is reasonable to assume that improve
ments in the NN itself could eliminate the bias. The vari
ance estimate is less precise but has no bias. Sill: 187 Range: 1002 Sill: 575.7 Range: 2446 Fig. 1 Synthetic training data produced using Gaussian semivariance
models with random sill and range, with a component of noise. The
circles show 120 randomly drawn points from each realisation. Shading:
smallest values are shown in blue and largest values are shown in
yellow, with in-between values shown in green. Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 Validation We demonstrate the advantage of using ML for the esti
mation of the semivariogram model with a synthetic
example, where the method is compared to the clas
sic method of fitting an experimental semivariogram. We then demonstrate the advantage of applying the
method given an actual use case. The 5% of the data, which we set aside for validation,
are fed to the network and serve as an initial validation test. The size of the validation set is 7500 data points. Figure 2
shows the distribution of true to predicted values for the However, the time that the methods need to reach
the predictions is not the same. During the test, we Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 3 of 7 www.geusbulletin.org
Fig. 2 The panels show the precision and accuracy of the ML model in predicting range and sill. Red dots show values predicted using the scattered
points and blue dots using full grids, and green dots show the estimation of sill using the sample variance from the 120 scattered points. The black
trend lines indicate where points are in exact agreement with the true values. The colour-shaded regions highlight the interval within which 95%
of predictions are made, bounded by the 2.5 percentile (lowermost coloured lines), 50 percentile (median; middle coloured lines) and 97.5 percentile
(uppermost coloured lines). www.geusbulletin.org Fig. 2 The panels show the precision and accuracy of the ML model in predicting range and sill. Red dots show values predicted using the scattered
points and blue dots using full grids, and green dots show the estimation of sill using the sample variance from the 120 scattered points. The black
trend lines indicate where points are in exact agreement with the true values. The colour-shaded regions highlight the interval within which 95%
of predictions are made, bounded by the 2.5 percentile (lowermost coloured lines), 50 percentile (median; middle coloured lines) and 97.5 percentile
(uppermost coloured lines). Discussion and outlook The sample variance is used to estimate the sill in this
example because an unbiased estimation is prioritised
over a precise estimation for the purpose of clustering. As such, the example focuses on the predicted ranges
and the final clustering. The top left panel in Fig. 3 shows
the ranges predicted with a 31 × 31 sliding window,
whilst the top right panel shows the subsequent clus
tering result. In a subsurface model with a large spatial extent, the
assumption of stationarity in the subsurface properties
breaks down. To do proper geostatistical modelling in
such a case, non-stationarity must be considered (Hig
don et al. 2022). Non-stationarity can be modelled by
introducing locally varying anisotropy (e.g. Boisvert &
Deutsch 2011; Bongajum et al. 2013; Pereira et al. 2023),
but these methods can be computationally challeng
ing for large models. Thus, practical tools needed for
estimating the non-stationarity are currently sparse
and not easily deployed for practitioners (Madsen et al. 2020). Here, we briefly presented a computationally effi
cient ML-based method that can infer Gaussian prop
erties from a stratigraphic layer model, adding a new
tool to the geostatistician’s toolbox to solve issues of
non-stationarity. Figure 4 illustrates how the ML algorithm iden
tifies areas of low range where the layer has more
high-frequency variation and areas of high range
where the layer resembles more of a smooth curve. Of course, this should be seen in the context of the
chosen window size, which is about 3100 m, and
larger ranges than this cannot be resolved. This lim
itation should not pose a problem since any subse
quent kriging and simulation will be modelling the
residual around the sliding mean from the layer
using the same window. During testing, several different ML approaches were
tried, including regression trees, random forest and a
classical NN, but the deployment and adoption of a CNN
were the most successful. It is known that Neural Net
works in general are universal approximators that can
approximate any continuous Lebesgue integrable func
tion. This was proven for networks with a fixed number
of hidden layers and an arbitrary number of neurons,
also known as the arbitrary width case (Hornik 1991). Validation by application of the method recorded the time spent for each approach and cal
culated the average time spent per model. The CNN
approach based on existing 31 × 31 grids was able to
estimate 130 semivariogram models per second, whilst
for scattered data, 111 models could be estimated per
second. Meanwhile, the traditional semivariogram
analysis, where a model is fitted to an experimental
semivariogram, could only estimate 1.72 models per
second. Of course, these numbers depend on the com
putational resources available, but the important point
is the relative difference in computation time between
the methods. Besides the validation on synthetic data, we also val
idate our method by demonstrating how it can be
used to solve a real problem of obtaining non-station
ary statistical properties. When dealing with models
with non-stationary statistics, such as very large mod
els like the DK-model (Stisen et al. 2020), using a single
semivariogram for kriging does not usually produce
realistic geological structures. In our validation exam
ple, we employ the ML approach to estimate local
values for the range and the sill and then use a clus
tering algorithm to divide the model into local regions
with similar statistical properties. The algorithm is a
type of unsupervised classification algorithm known
as the Kohonen self-organising map (Kohonen 1991),
which is featured as a built-in function in MAT
LAB. With this approach, the ML algorithm enables
kriging with a locally optimised semivariogram model,
which should be better at handling non-stationary
models than approaches with a fixed semivariogram
model. The time consumption of the ML approach is only
slightly larger when interpolating point data, suggesting
that the CNN consumes most of the time and not the
interpolation itself. Meanwhile, the traditional approach
of fitting takes about 60 times more computation time. The time consumption varies quite a bit for the tra
ditional semivariogram analysis approach, depending on
the number of data points used. By using only 60 points,
it may complete as many as 30 models per second; how
ever, this is still about one-fourth of the speed of the CNN
and with a significant loss of accuracy. Furthermore, the
CNN may also be optimised to become more efficient. For the validation example, we employ this approach
to the first layer in the hydrostratigrahic model on
the Danish island of Fyn, covering roughly 3100 km2. Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. Validation by application of the method https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 4 of 7 www.geusbulletin.org Synthetic example
10
20
30
Y [m]
Semivariance [m2]
Synthetic example
Semivariance [m2]
10
20
30
Y [m]
10
20
30
Y [m]
10
20
30
X [m]
10
20
30
Y [m]
0
1000
2000
3000
Distance [m]
10
20
30
X [m]
0
1000
2000
3000
Distance [m]
Synthetic data
Data
True model
ML model
Fitted model
Fig. 3 Synthetic examples: 8 realisations are shown – each of their own Gaussian semivariogram model with some component of noise. The semivari
ance models show a high level of accuracy for the traditional fitting approach as well as the ML approach. True model ML model Fig. 3 Synthetic examples: 8 realisations are shown – each of their own Gaussian semivariogram model with some component of noise. The semivari
ance models show a high level of accuracy for the traditional fitting approach as well as the ML approach. Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 Discussion and outlook Recently, it was also proven for ReLU NNs with a fixed The example layer shown here contains 497 369
individual grid cells, which means that the machine
learning algorithm can complete the semivariance
model estimation in about 1 h and 15 min, given a
computation rate of 111 models per second. Mean
while, the traditional semivariogram analysis takes
about 80 h to do the same, given a rate of 1.72 models
per second. Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 5 of 7 www.geusbulletin.org Fig. 4 Method results of a layer covering the Danish island of Fyn. (a) Predicted ranges. (b) Ranges clustered into regions. (c) Layer elevation across
the black profile shown in (a) and (b) and the predicted ranges (green/white line) across the same profile. The colour scale in (c) matches the colour
scale in (b), showing where individual clusters are located. (a) Range map
5.6
5.8
6
6.2
UTM X [m]
6.08
6.1
6.12
6.14
6.16
UTM Y [m]
×106
0
1000
2000
3000
Range [m]
(b) Cluster map
5.6
5.8
6
6.2
UTM X [m]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Cluster index
(c) Profile view
5.65
5.7
5.75
5.8
5.85
5.9
5.95
6
6.05
6.1
UTM X [m]
0
20
40
60
80
100
Elevation [m]
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Range [m]
×105
×105
×105 (a) Range map
5.6
5.8
6
6.2
UTM X [m]
6.08
6.1
6.12
6.14
6.16
UTM Y [m]
×106
0
1000
2000
3000
Range [m]
(b) Cluster map
5.6
5.8
6
6.2
UTM X [m]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Cluster index
×105
×105 (c) Profile view
5.65
5.7
5.75
5.8
5.85
5.9
5.95
6
6.05
6.1
UTM X [m]
0
20
40
60
80
100
Elevation [m]
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Range [m]
×105 Fig. 4 Method results of a layer covering the Danish island of Fyn. (a) Predicted ranges. (b) Ranges clustered into regions. (c) Layer elevation across
the black profile shown in (a) and (b) and the predicted ranges (green/white line) across the same profile. The colour scale in (c) matches the colour
scale in (b), showing where individual clusters are located. Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 Discussion and outlook The presented approach also has the major advan
tage of having limitless training data available, although
a reasonable amount of training data should be cho
sen for computational feasibility. The network can also
be trained to a larger grid than the 31 × 31 grid used
here, giving a lot of flexibility for the specific model
for which inference is needed. The 31 × 31 grid posed
some issues for estimating ranges over a certain
length. This limitation to the method can be remedied
by increasing the grid size, but at the cost of increas
ing computation time during training of the CNN. To
determine the right size of the grid in a practical case,
we suggest training two preliminary networks with
a small grid and a slightly larger grid. If predictions
with these two networks deviate significantly when
applied on real data, the grid size must be increased to
accommodate all possible ranges. The process can be
repeated iteratively until the same range interval is pre
dicted for both networks, indicating a reasonable min
imum grid size. Using this strategy for the DK-model,
a 31 × 31 grid was deemed suitable as showcased. number of neurons (fixed width) and an arbitrary num
ber of hidden layers, also known as the arbitrary depth
case (Zhou et al. 2017). In the presented use-case, the
CNN probably produced better estimates compared to
the other ML approaches because the convolution of
different layers makes the CNN better at analysing the
spatial information in the training data. With the rapid
development in ML algorithms, the CNN might soon be
outperformed; however, the methodology of training
the ML model to recognise Gaussian covariances from
point data does not change but can only improve its pre
cision with new algorithms. This presents an improve
ment over, for example, a traditional semivariogram
analysis, the performance of which comes with a trade-
off between the ability to accurately predict shorter
versus longer ranges. This trade-off occurs due to the
constraints imposed by the weights on the experimental
variogram at different range intervals. number of neurons (fixed width) and an arbitrary num
ber of hidden layers, also known as the arbitrary depth
case (Zhou et al. 2017). Acknowledgements The authors would like to acknowledge the Geological Survey of Den
mark and Greenland (GEUS) for providing funding for writing the
manuscript as the method development was carried out in a consul
tancy project without funding for scientific publication. Jo, H. & Pyrcz, M.J. 2022: Automatic semivariogram modeling by convo
lutional neural network. Mathematical Geosciences 54(1), 177–205. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11004-021-09962-w Kohonen, T. 1991: Self-organising maps: ophmization approaches. In:
Kohonen, T., et al. (eds): Artificial Neural Networks. Pp. 981–990. Amster
dam: North-Holland. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-444-89178-5.50003-8 www.geusbulletin.org Bongajum, E.L., Boisvert, J. & Sacchi, M.D. 2013: Bayesian linearized seis
mic inversion with locally varying spatial anisotropy. Journal of Applied
Geophysics 88, 31–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jappgeo.2012.10.001 computation time as showcased in the final validation
example to account for non-stationarity. The subsequent
clustering also makes it possible to define regions with
comparable statistics in the stratigraphical model. For
further application of the estimated statistical models,
one could infer the local statistics from the sill and range
estimates within each cluster and use these for, for exam
ple, localised geostatistical estimation (kriging) or simula
tion of each cluster instead of using a stationary model
as done in Madsen et al. (2022) for a hydrostratigraphic
model. Geophysics 88, 31–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jappgeo.2012.10.001 Cressie, N.A.C. 1993: Statistics for spatial data. New York: Wiley. Hansen et al. 2013: SIPPI: A MATLAB toolbox for sampling the solu
tion to inverse problems with complex prior information: Part 1 –
Methodology. Computational Geoscience 52, 470–480. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.cageo.2012.09.004 Higdon D., Swall, J., & Kern, J. 1999: Non-stationary spatial modeling. In:
Bernado, J.M. et al. (eds). Bayesian Statistics (6 ed.). 761–768. Oxford:
Oxford University Press. Hornik, K. 1991: Approximation capabilities of multilayer feed
forward networks. Neural Networks 4(2), 251–257. https://doi. org/10.1016/0893-6080(91)90009-T Iandola, F.N., Moskewicz, M.W., Ashraf, K., Han, S., Dally, W.J. &
Keutzer, K. 2016: SqueezeNet: AlexNet-level accuracy with 50x fewer
parameters and <1MB model size. ArXiv, abs/1602.07360. https://doi. org/10.48550/arXiv.1602.07360 Additional information Li, Y., Baorong, Z., Xiaohong, X. & Zijun, L. 2022: Application of a semi
variogram based on a deep neural network to ordinary kriging inter
polation of elevation data. PLoS One 17(4), e0266942. https://doi. org/10.1371/journal.pone.0266942 Additional files Pereira, Â. et al. 2023: Updating local anisotropies with template match
ing during geostatistical seismic inversion. Mathematical Geosciences
55(4), 497–519, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11004-023-10051-3 None provided Stisen, S., Ondracek, M., Troldborg, L., Schneider, R.J.M. & Til, M.J.V. 2020:
National Vandressource Model. Modelopstilling og kalibrering af
DK-model 2019. Danmarks og Grønlands Geologiske Undersøgelse
Rapport 2019/31, 23–27, https://doi.org/10.22008/gpub/32631 Funding statement The method was developed during consultancy work for the Danish
EPA, whilst the hours for turning the results into a scientific contri
bution and writing the manuscript were provided by the Geological
Survey of Greenland and Denmark (GEUS). Madsen, R.B., Hansen, T.M. & Omre, H. 2020: Estimation of a non-
stationary prior covariance from seismic data. Geophysical Prospect
ing 68(2), 393–410. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2478.12848 Madsen, R.B., Høyer, A.S., Andersen, L.T., Møller, I. & Hansen, T.M. 2022:
Geology-driven modelling: A new probabilistic approach for incor
porating uncertain geological interpretations in 3D geological mod
elling. Engineering Geology 309, 106833. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. enggeo.2022.106833 Author contributions FAF: Methodology, Software, Investigation, Writing – Original draft
preparation RBM: Conceptualisation, Methodology, Writing – Reviewing and
Editing Mardia, K.V. 1990: Maximum likelihood estimation for spatial models
in Spatial statistics: Past, present, and future. 203–253. https://doi. org/10.1068/a270615 Discussion and outlook In the presented use-case, the
CNN probably produced better estimates compared to
the other ML approaches because the convolution of
different layers makes the CNN better at analysing the
spatial information in the training data. With the rapid
development in ML algorithms, the CNN might soon be
outperformed; however, the methodology of training
the ML model to recognise Gaussian covariances from
point data does not change but can only improve its pre
cision with new algorithms. This presents an improve
ment over, for example, a traditional semivariogram
analysis, the performance of which comes with a trade-
off between the ability to accurately predict shorter
versus longer ranges. This trade-off occurs due to the
constraints imposed by the weights on the experimental
variogram at different range intervals. The NN architecture used from SqueezeNet (Iandola
et al. 2016) is ideal for obtaining good predictions
by training the model using a conventional gradient
descent algorithm with a sufficiently large training data
set. We found that optimal results are obtained when
training on at least 100 000 independent realisations,
with performance severely decreasing when training on
less than 10 000 realisations. Our results in the synthetic case suggest that the
deployed CNN has the same accuracy as a traditional
automatic semivariogram fitting, but with a substan
tial improvement in speed, which now makes it feasible
to analyse large grids within a reasonable amount of Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 6 of 7 www.geusbulletin.org Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353 Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Matheron, G. 1963: Principles of geostatistics. Economic Geology 58(8),
1246–1266. https://doi.org/10.2113/gsecongeo.58.8.1246 References Boisvert, J.B. & Deutsch, C.V. 2011: Programs for kriging and sequential
Gaussian simulation with locally varying anisotropy using non-Euclid
ean distances. Computers & Geosciences 37(4), 495–510. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.cageo.2010.03.021 Boisvert, J.B. & Deutsch, C.V. 2011: Programs for kriging and sequential
Gaussian simulation with locally varying anisotropy using non-Euclid
ean distances. Computers & Geosciences 37(4), 495–510. https://doi. org/10.1016/j.cageo.2010.03.021 Rapport 2019/31, 23–27, https://doi.org/10.22008/gpub/32631 Zhou, L., Hongming, P., Wang, F., Zhiqiang, H. & Wang, L. 2017: The expres
sive power of neural networks: A view from the width. In: Guyon, I. et al. (eds.) Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 30,
7–8. New York: Curran Associates Inc. https://proceedings.neurips.cc/
paper_files/paper/2017/file/32cbf687880eb1674a07bf717761dd3a-Pa
per.pdf (accessed October 2023) Boisvert, J.B., Manchuk, J. & Deutsch, C.V. 2009: Kriging in the presence of
locally varying anisotropy using non-Euclidean distances. Mathematical
Geosciences 41, 585–601. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11004-009-9229-1 7 of 7 Falk & Madsen 2023: GEUS Bulletin 53. 8353. https://doi.org/10.34194/geusb.v53.8353
|
https://openalex.org/W2092121466
|
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01608554/document
|
French
| null |
Rapid and quantitative assessment of trout spermatozoa motility using stroboscopy
|
Aquaculture
| 1,985
|
cc-by-sa
| 130
|
To cite this version: Marie-Paule Cosson, Roland Billard, J.L. Gatti, R. Christen. Rapid and quantitative assessment of
trout spermatozoa motility using stroboscopy. Aquaculture, 1985, 46 (1), pp.71-75. 10.1016/0044-
8486(85)90178-4. hal-01608554 HAL Id: hal-01608554
https://hal.science/hal-01608554v1
Submitted on 2 Jun 2020 L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers. Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution - ShareAlike 4.0 International License
|
https://openalex.org/W4320495066
|
https://hal.science/hal-03986050/document
|
English
| null |
Challenges and perspectives in MS-based omics approaches for ecotoxicology studies: An insight on Gammarids sentinel amphipods
|
Frontiers in analytical science
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 7,651
|
Challenges and perspectives in MS-based omics
approaches for ecotoxicology studies: An insight on
Gammarids sentinel amphipods Valentina Calabrese, Arnaud Salvador, Yohann Clément, Thomas Alexandre
Brunet, Anabelle Espeyte, Arnaud Chaumot, Olivier Geffard, Davide
Degli-Esposti, Sophie Ayciriex To cite this version: Valentina Calabrese, Arnaud Salvador, Yohann Clément, Thomas Alexandre Brunet, Anabelle Es-
peyte, et al.. Challenges and perspectives in MS-based omics approaches for ecotoxicology studies:
An insight on Gammarids sentinel amphipods. Frontiers in Analytical Science, 2023, 3, pp.1118494. 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494. hal-03986050 Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License Challenges and perspectives in
MS-based omics approaches for
ecotoxicology studies: An insight
on Gammarids sentinel
amphipods OPEN ACCESS
EDITED BY
Martin Giera,
Leiden University Medical Center (LUMC),
Netherlands
REVIEWED BY
Carmen Bedia,
Institute of Environmental Assessment
and Water Research (CSIC), Spain
Sara Long,
RMIT University, Australia
*CORRESPONDENCE
Valentina Calabrese,
valentina.calabrese@univ-lyon1.fr
Sophie Ayciriex,
sophie.ayciriex@univ-lyon1.fr
SPECIALTY SECTION
This article was submitted to Omics,
a section of the journal
Frontiers in Analytical Science
RECEIVED 07 December 2022
ACCEPTED 03 February 2023
PUBLISHED 13 February 2023
CITATION
Calabrese V, Salvador A, Clément Y,
Brunet TA, Espeyte A, Chaumot A,
Geffard O, Degli-Esposti D and Ayciriex S
(2023), Challenges and perspectives in
MS-based omics approaches for
ecotoxicology studies: An insight on
Gammarids sentinel amphipods. Front. Anal. Sci. 3:1118494. doi: 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 OPEN ACCESS
EDITED BY
Martin Giera,
Leiden University Medical Center (LUMC),
Netherlands
REVIEWED BY
Carmen Bedia,
Institute of Environmental Assessment
and Water Research (CSIC), Spain
Sara Long,
RMIT University, Australia
*CORRESPONDENCE
Valentina Calabrese,
valentina.calabrese@univ-lyon1.fr
Sophie Ayciriex,
sophie.ayciriex@univ-lyon1.fr
SPECIALTY SECTION
This article was submitted to Omics,
a section of the journal
Frontiers in Analytical Science
RECEIVED 07 December 2022
ACCEPTED 03 February 2023
PUBLISHED 13 February 2023
CITATION
Calabrese V, Salvador A, Clément Y,
Brunet TA, Espeyte A, Chaumot A,
Geffard O, Degli-Esposti D and Ayciriex S
(2023), Challenges and perspectives in
MS-based omics approaches for
ecotoxicology studies: An insight on
Gammarids sentinel amphipods. Front. Anal. Sci. 3:1118494. doi: 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 Valentina Calabrese1*, Arnaud Salvador1, Yohann Clément1,
Thomas Alexandre Brunet1, Anabelle Espeyte2, Arnaud Chaumot2,
Olivier Geffard2, Davide Degli-Esposti2 and Sophie Ayciriex1* 1Université de Lyon, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Institut des Sciences Analytiques, CNRS UMR 5280,
Villeurbanne, France, 2INRAE, UR RiverLy, Laboratoire d’écotoxicologie, Villeurbanne, France The aquatic environment is one of the most complex biosystems, as organism at
all trophic levels may be exposed to a multitude of pollutants. As major goals,
ecotoxicology typically investigates the impact of toxic pollutants on the
ecosystems through the study of sentinel organisms. Over the past decades,
Mass Spectrometry (MS)-based omics approaches have been extended to sentinel
species
both
in
laboratory
and
field
exposure
conditions. Single-omics
approaches enable the discovery of biomarkers mirroring the health status of
an organism. By covering a restricted set of the molecular cascade, they turn out
to only partially satisfy the understanding of complex ecotoxicological effects. In
contrast, a more complete understanding of the ecotoxicity pathways can be
accessed through multi-omics approaches. ecotoxicology, Gammarids, mass spectrometry, omics, MS imaging ecotoxicology, Gammarids, mass spectrometry, omics, MS imaging HAL Id: hal-03986050
https://hal.science/hal-03986050v1
Submitted on 13 Feb 2023 L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers. Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License TYPE Perspective
PUBLISHED 13 February 2023
DOI 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 Challenges and perspectives in
MS-based omics approaches for
ecotoxicology studies: An insight
on Gammarids sentinel
amphipods In this perspective, we provide a
state-of-the-art and a critical evaluation on further developments in MS-based
single and multi-omics studies in aquatic ecotoxicology. As case example,
literature regarding Gammarids freshwater amphipods, non-model sentinel
organisms sensitive to pollutants and environmental changes and crucial
species for downstream ecosystems, will be reviewed. CITATION
Calabrese V, Salvador A, Clément Y,
Brunet TA, Espeyte A, Chaumot A,
Geffard O, Degli-Esposti D and Ayciriex S
(2023), Challenges and perspectives in
MS-based omics approaches for
ecotoxicology studies: An insight on
Gammarids sentinel amphipods. Front. Anal. Sci. 3:1118494. doi: 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 © 2023 Calabrese, Salvador, Clément,
Brunet, Espeyte, Chaumot, Geffard,
Degli-Esposti and Ayciriex. This is an
open-access article distributed under the
terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution License (CC BY). The use,
distribution or reproduction in other
forums is permitted, provided the original
author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are
credited and that the original publication
in this journal is cited, in accordance with
accepted academic practice. No use,
distribution or reproduction is permitted
which does not comply with these terms. Introduction More
recently, Scout-MRM (renamed scout-triggered MRM or stMRM)
has enabled a more reliable multiplexing method for both
quantification
and
identification
(Rougemont
et
al.,
2017;
Ayciriex et al., 2020; Salvador et al., 2020). Monitoring of
concurrent MRM transitions is triggered by marker transitions of
known/exogenous compounds (scout compounds), instead of
retention time windows. When spiked into the biological sample,
scout
compounds
ideally
distribute
uniformly
along
the
chromatogram, allowing the monitoring of concomitant MRM
transitions of analytes during an acquisition window spanning
from the first scout triggering transition to a second one
exceeding a chosen intensity threshold. Faugere et al. (2020)
optimized and applied for the first time in aquatic ecotoxicology,
a method based on Scout-MRM mode for broad and multiplex State-of-the-art on omics approaches for
ecotoxicological research on Gammarids Gammarids represent the most abundant macroinvertebrate
species, in terms of biomass, in freshwater environments. More
importantly, they represent keystone species being involved in the
detritus cycle, providing prey for secondary consumers, and
intervening in the food web. Furthermore, Gammarids are very
sensitive to diverse chemical compounds as metals, organics, or oil
spills, and may be subjected to bioaccumulation of toxic compounds. Since almost a century, Gammarids have been used as bioindicator
species in freshwater ecotoxicological assessment. Considering these
peculiarities and drawing on our own experience in the field, we
focus on Gammarids to present the advancements and perspective
on the use of MS-based omics in ecotoxicology research. Introduction Since the advent of industrialization, human activities have increased as a result of
human population growth, leading to the release of novel entities into the environment
(Persson et al., 2022). Water, an essential substance on Earth for living organisms, is also one
of the most heavily polluted environments. In the biosphere, freshwater ecosystems
represent one of the most delicate compartments, hosting around 10% of the animal
kingdom (Balian et al., 2008; Brondizio et al., 2019). The toxicological effects on
freshwater
organisms
caused
by
exposure
to
pollutants
may
include
altered
reproduction, changes in nutrition habits, physiological or morphological anomalies,
migration, death, and extinction (Ahmed et al., 2022). Adverse effects on living
organisms
are
related
to
modifications
at
different
biological
levels,
including
modulation of gene expression, protein synthesis or metabolic pathways. During the past Frontiers in Analytical Science 01 frontiersin.org Calabrese et al. 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 Indeed, for quantification purposes, improvements in both
sensitivity and selectivity have been reached using targeted MS
employing the multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) acquisition
mode (Liebler and Zimmerman, 2013). This MS-based technique
relies on the use of low-resolution mass spectrometers (triple
quadrupole or hybrid quadrupole-linear ion trap) which enables
three stages of analyses constituted by precursor ion selection,
fragmentation, and fragments ions selection, namely, MRM
transition. Only ions satisfying both m/z criteria (precursor and
fragment ions) are detected, allowing increasing specificity and
signal
to
noise
ratio
in
complex
samples
analysis. Ecotoxicological research has made profit of MRM for the
discovery
and
quantification
of
vitellogenin-related
potential
ecotoxicological biomarkers in Gammarus fossarum (Simon et al.,
2010). However, classic MRM mode limits the number of monitored
transitions as a compromise between dwell time transition and the
total duty cycle (Rodriguez-Aller et al., 2013). While dwell time
corresponds to the time necessary for the acquisition of an MRM
transition, the duty cycle is the time spent monitoring an analyte. Importantly, the higher the duty cycle, the greater number of
acquired points for chromatographic peak analysis which results
in better quality data. In opposition, an increase of monitored
transitions for a single analysis (multiplexing ability) may lead to
poor reproducibility due to lower duty cycles, especially in coupling
with Ultra High-Pressure Liquid Chromatography (UHPLC) which
implies narrower peak widths. The MRM3 approach enables
increased sensitivity and selectivity by monitoring in addition to
the classic approach, second generation of product ions without any
further improvement in the multiplexing ability (Jaffuel et al., 2013). Introduction A first step towards increased multiplexing has been reached out
through the scheduled MRM algorithm. In this operational mode,
narrow retention time windows are set up to acquire the MRM
transitions only during the expected analyte chromatographic
elution (Bertsch et al., 2010). While a prior knowledge of the
retention
time
is
required,
algorithms
adapt
dwell
times
maintaining optimal duty cycles. This allows the monitoring of
hundreds of compounds in a single analysis without sacrificing
signal-to-noise ratio and reproducibility (Leprêtre et al., 2022). This
multiplexing approach is mainly based on the reliance of measured
retention times and suffers of matrix effects which can cause time-
window shifts. Despite tedious complications in terms of use for
consumables, instrument time and operator work, this may
represent a problem both for intra-laboratory reproducibility and
method transferability among different analytical platforms. More
recently, Scout-MRM (renamed scout-triggered MRM or stMRM)
has enabled a more reliable multiplexing method for both
quantification
and
identification
(Rougemont
et
al.,
2017;
Ayciriex et al., 2020; Salvador et al., 2020). Monitoring of
concurrent MRM transitions is triggered by marker transitions of
known/exogenous compounds (scout compounds), instead of
retention time windows. When spiked into the biological sample,
scout
compounds
ideally
distribute
uniformly
along
the
chromatogram, allowing the monitoring of concomitant MRM
transitions of analytes during an acquisition window spanning
from the first scout triggering transition to a second one
exceeding a chosen intensity threshold. Faugere et al. (2020)
optimized and applied for the first time in aquatic ecotoxicology, decades, ecotoxicological research has relied on the use of robust
analytical techniques and modern bioinformatics approaches for the
discovery of genes, proteins, metabolites, lipids involved in stress
responses. Among these technologies, mass spectrometry (MS)-
based omics represents a gold standard for both structural and
quantitative analysis of thousands of compounds down to ultra-
trace levels (Girolamo et al., 2013; Groh and Suter, 2020). The past
years of research have been mainly based on the use of single omics
(proteomics, lipidomics, or metabolomics, to name a few) leading to
a limited view of the investigated system. More recently, multi-omics
approaches, based on the integration of multiple omics data on a
same sample have been implemented in ecotoxicology studies
leading to a more performant elucidation of complex processes
(Nam et al., 2022; Faugere et al., 2023). Introduction deed,
o
qua t cat o
pu poses,
p ove
e ts
bot
sensitivity and selectivity have been reached using targeted MS
employing the multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) acquisition
mode (Liebler and Zimmerman, 2013). This MS-based technique
relies on the use of low-resolution mass spectrometers (triple
quadrupole or hybrid quadrupole-linear ion trap) which enables
three stages of analyses constituted by precursor ion selection,
fragmentation, and fragments ions selection, namely, MRM
transition. Only ions satisfying both m/z criteria (precursor and
fragment ions) are detected, allowing increasing specificity and
signal
to
noise
ratio
in
complex
samples
analysis. Ecotoxicological research has made profit of MRM for the
discovery
and
quantification
of
vitellogenin-related
potential
ecotoxicological biomarkers in Gammarus fossarum (Simon et al.,
2010). However, classic MRM mode limits the number of monitored
transitions as a compromise between dwell time transition and the
total duty cycle (Rodriguez-Aller et al., 2013). While dwell time
corresponds to the time necessary for the acquisition of an MRM
transition, the duty cycle is the time spent monitoring an analyte. Importantly, the higher the duty cycle, the greater number of
acquired points for chromatographic peak analysis which results
in better quality data. In opposition, an increase of monitored
transitions for a single analysis (multiplexing ability) may lead to
poor reproducibility due to lower duty cycles, especially in coupling
with Ultra High-Pressure Liquid Chromatography (UHPLC) which
implies narrower peak widths. The MRM3 approach enables
increased sensitivity and selectivity by monitoring in addition to
the classic approach, second generation of product ions without any
further improvement in the multiplexing ability (Jaffuel et al., 2013). A first step towards increased multiplexing has been reached out
through the scheduled MRM algorithm. In this operational mode,
narrow retention time windows are set up to acquire the MRM
transitions only during the expected analyte chromatographic
elution (Bertsch et al., 2010). While a prior knowledge of the
retention
time
is
required,
algorithms
adapt
dwell
times
maintaining optimal duty cycles. This allows the monitoring of
hundreds of compounds in a single analysis without sacrificing
signal-to-noise ratio and reproducibility (Leprêtre et al., 2022). This
multiplexing approach is mainly based on the reliance of measured
retention times and suffers of matrix effects which can cause time-
window shifts. Despite tedious complications in terms of use for
consumables, instrument time and operator work, this may
represent a problem both for intra-laboratory reproducibility and
method transferability among different analytical platforms. Metabolomics and lipidomics approaches The literature reviewed previously focuses on Gammarids
species. It is only a case study and reflects the need for
ecotoxicology
to
move
towards
the
application
of
high
throughput analytical methods that are well established in other
application areas such as phytochemistry,
pharmacology or
medicine. To
reiterate
an
already
expressed
concept,
the
identification of compounds in the absence of isolated and
characterized compounds is a challenge in omics sciences. Data
dependent analysis (DDA) and data independent analysis (DIA) are
nowadays routinely used to acquire high-resolution fragmentation
spectra for thousands of compounds in one single measurement
(Fernández-Costa
et
al.,
2020). While
DDA-MS
performs
fragmentation only for selected precursor ions above a certain
intensity threshold defined by the operator, DIA-MS enables an
indiscriminate fragmentation of all precursor ions. Sequential
window acquisition of all theoretical mass spectra (SWATH-MS)
is a modified version of DIA-MS in which ions fragmentation is
triggered by specific isolation windows (Anjo et al., 2017). In this
acquisition mode, all precursors which fall in the m/z mass detection
range are fragmented without prior detection, assuring in-depth
acquisition for a broad range of compounds in complex samples. The method has been specifically optimized for the identification
and quantification of non-labelled protein, but it has recently shown
potential applications in metabolomics and lipidomics (Raetz et al.,
2020). In all cases, the annotation of the compounds depends strictly
on the possibility to compare them with reference fragmentation
spectra. Molecular networking (available on GNPS, MetGem and
MS-DIAL platform), is a bioinformatic tool permitting the grouping
of structurally correlated compounds which fragment similarly
(Tsugawa et al., 2015; Olivon et al., 2018; Nothias et al., 2020). These tools allow faster compound annotation as match with
database fragmentation spectra. Similarly to proteomics, metabolomics and lipidomics give
access to an in-depth perception of stress responses acting on
metabolites
and
lipids
in
exposed
organisms. Importantly,
metabolites
and
lipids
present
extremely
diverse
chemical
compounds with different polarity and a great structural diversity
resulting in the presence of different isobaric and isomeric forms. MS-based metabolomics and lipidomics present many advantages
over historical NMR-based analyses, principally relying on the
greater sensitivity and the possibility to combine hyphenated
techniques (i.e., liquid chromatography) for the detection and
characterization of compounds in complex biological samples. Moreover, MS enables faster analyses and reduces needed sample
quantity (Letertre et al., 2021). Proteomics approaches Proteomics, i.e., the large-scale study of proteins expressed by an
organism, has been largely investigated in ecotoxicology for
biomarker discovery. Protein sequence identification has been
historically performed through shotgun approaches in which
peptide proxies, obtained after proteins have undergone tryptic
digestion, are analyzed through liquid chromatography tandem
mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). The first studies performed on
model organisms were conducted by comparing experimental and
in silico fragmentation spectra of peptides derived from nucleoside
sequences, for protein annotation. Proteogenomics, based on high
resolution MS (i.e., shotgun proteomics), have enabled protein
identification in the absence of genomic data from unfinished
genome or from species-specific RNA sequences, also for non-
model organisms (Armengaud et al., 2014). In the case of
Gammarus
fossarum,
proteogenomics
has
enabled
the
identification of 1,873 proteins involved in reproductive pathway
(Trapp et al., 2014), to characterize the female core-proteome
(Trapp et al., 2016), and to identify proteins related to endocrine
perturbation caused by exposure to xenobiotics (Trapp et al., 2015,
Koenig et al., 2021). Even if proteogenomics has in part gained
prevalence in ecotoxicology research, the technique remains costly,
suffers from poor reproducibility and reduced sensitivity (Aggarwal
et al., 2022). Frontiers in Analytical Science 02 frontiersin.org 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 Calabrese et al. lipid biomarkers involved in female G. fossarum reproductive
function perturbation caused by the exposition to fenoxycarb, a
carbamate insecticide (Arambourou et al., 2018). Despite these
studies being relatively recent, biomarker discovery has not been
always followed by identification or structural characterization. A
single study performed on G. pulex has allowed to get a hint on
metabolites identity through molecular formula attribution on exact
mass measurements and KEGG database screening (Sheikholeslami
et al., 2020). analysis of proteins in adult Gammarids. Based on preliminary
optimization of 44 labelled peptides (Gouveia et al., 2017), Scout-
MRM method enabled 157-protein multiplex quantification and
identification. The study represents a good example in which low
resolution mass spectrometers serves both for robust quantification
(increased signal to noise ratio and specificity) and identification
based on the simultaneous monitoring of 4 MRM transitions per
analyte. The relevance of optimized method was demonstrated
through its application on adult Gammarids exposed to pesticides
contamination, and on the modulation of proteins involved in key
physiological pathways. “Old is the new black”: what is the contribution of other MS and
bioinformatics tools in ecotoxicology studies? frontiersin.org Challenges and advancements on multi-
omics approach for ecotoxicological
research While these MS tools are nowadays routinely applied in
metabolomics for the characterization of natural compounds in
plants (Calabrese et al., 2022, 2023) or human biofluids (Zhu et al.,
2021), applications in ecotoxicological research remains still very
limited (Taylor et al., 2009; Duarte, et al., 2022) and totally
unexplored in Gammarids. Omics approaches pave the way for an initial understanding of
ecotoxicological adverse responses but lack of the ability to predict
complex mechanisms underlying stressed organisms. There is
nowadays a growing consciousness for the need to apply multi-
omics approaches based on the use of multi-layers analysis to obtain
high-value
integrative
information. Although
multi-omics
approaches are increasingly spreading, some scientific challenges
have still to be faced. Beside from large investments in terms of
diverse analytical platforms, qualified operators, time and resources,
multi-omics need optimized analytical protocols and modern tools
for data analysis and integration. For example, an effort should be
made towards the reduction of biases among the different omics
layers, upstream the analysis. In ecotoxicology, different organs or
organisms are used to obtain pertinent samples specific for each
single-omics layer, introducing biological variability in the analysis. On the other hand, additional analytical variability could arise from
multiple sample extraction steps and instrumental runs. Thus,
reduction of variability can be reached either by getting multi-
omics information from a unique sample and in the ideal case, from
a single organism, down to a single cell (Li et al., 2021). In these
conditions it is possible to obtain optimized correlation of results for
a better understanding of ecotoxicological effects. Recently, Faugere
et al. developed a procedure based on a liquid-liquid extraction step In all the aforementioned techniques, spatial information of
interesting compounds in biological tissue is missing. MS imaging is
an emerging field in life science allowing real label-free molecular
imaging of biological tissue sections. In this approach, information
on the spatial distribution of the molecules within a tissue or whole
organism can be attained, giving another level of omics information
and hints on metabolic pathway (Amstalden van Hove et al., 2010). Despite the fact that this technique has been widely used in biology,
MS imaging is relatively new in the ecotoxicology field (Fu et al.,
2021). Nano-Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (nanoSIMS)
imaging has been used to study the selective distribution of
silver and gold toxic nanoparticles respectively in the cuticle and
the gut area of G. Metabolomics and lipidomics approaches While the use of MRM based
techniques is mainly used in for quantitative analysis, the advent
of high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) has enabled ions
exact mass measurements and the acquisition of fragmentation mass
spectra at high precision for the identification of potential
biomarkers
(Rampler
et
al.,
2020;
Heiles,
2021). Coupling
separative techniques (liquid or gas chromatography) to MS in a
targeted or non-targeted approach is routinely used to investigate
respectively
a
known
subset
of
compounds
or
to
obtain
undiscriminating information on the whole range of analytes
present in the examined sample (Bletsou et al., 2015). Modern
MS platforms providing high resolving power, mass accuracy and
sensitivity have shed light on alternative approaches, such as
shotgun metabolomics, lipidomics, glycomics (Hu et al., 2020;
Bui et al., 2022). These techniques enable fast characterization
and quantification of metabolites and lipids in crude extracts
ionized through direct injection into an electrospray (ESI) source
and resolved through the utilization of high-resolution analyzers
(Han and Gross, 2005; García-Sevillano et al., 2015). In this extent,
the terms diverge from the expression “shotgun proteomics”, which
indicates bottom-up techniques for the digestion of crude protein
extracts and analysis through LC-MS/MS (Wu and Maccoss, 2002). While proteomics has been widely applied to study stress responses
on Gammarids, metabolomics and lipidomics applications remain
limited. Targeted metabolomics has been applied to measure
changes in the concentration of 29 selected metabolites in G. pulex exposed to xenobiotics (Gómez-Canela et al., 2016), while
combination of non-targeted metabolomics and chemometrics have
highlighted putative metabolic biomarkers of G. fossarum male and
female organisms exposed to pharmaceuticals (Bonnefoy et al.,
2019). Similar approaches have been applied to the discovery of The use of ultrahigh-resolution analyzers as Fourier Transform
Cyclotron Ion Resonance (FTICR) and Orbitrap can offer unrivaled
resolution (~106 at m/z 200 for FTICR in direct infusion mode),
mass precision typically below 1 ppm, high sensitivity and good
dynamic range enabling the detection of thousands of peaks in a
few-minutes run, isobar resolution and access to the fine isotopic
peak distribution (Hernández et al., 2012). Unique formula
assignment for thousand peaks allows global molecular profiling
through the use of van Krevelen diagrams (Laszakovits and MacKay,
2021). In addition, ion mobility mass spectrometry (IMS) enables
separation of isomers based on their tridimensional conformation
in gas phase, expressed by their collision cross section (CCS) (Kanu Frontiers in Analytical Science 03 frontiersin.org Calabrese et al. Metabolomics and lipidomics approaches 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 FIGURE 1
Summary of MS-based techniques for a high multiplexing and throughput multi-omics approach applied to freshwater sentinel organism such as
Gammarids in ecotoxicology. FIGURE 1
Summary of MS-based techniques for a high multiplexing and throughput multi-omics approach applied to freshwater sentinel organism such as
Gammarids in ecotoxicology. The integration of all the aforementioned approaches can lead to
improvements in the optic of both high throughput MS-based single
layer and multiple layers-omics approaches (Figure 1). et al., 2008). IMS has been successfully integrated into classic LC-MS
set up offering more confident identification of potential biomarkers
(either protein, peptides, or small molecules) based on the
comparison of experimental and database/theoretical CCS values
(Zhou et al., 2022). Challenges and advancements on multi-
omics approach for ecotoxicological
research fossarum tissue sections (Mehennaoui et al., 2018)
and Time-of-Flight Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (ToF-SIMS)
has been employed to assess the dynamic changes in lipid
composition during the maturation of oocytes in G. fossarum
(Fu et al., 2021). IMS has been also integrated in MSI offering in
situ separation and mapping of isobaric and isomeric lipids in the
muscle and oocytes of females of G. fossarum and disclosing
differential lipid composition and abundance in the different
organs (Fu et al., 2020). Frontiers in Analytical Science 04 frontiersin.org Calabrese et al. 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 TABLE 1 Principal platforms for MS data exploration, integration and visualization in single and multi-omics applications. Name
Features
Type of
datasets
Type of
omics data
Handling
of MS data
Main advantages
Programming
language/
Platform
Latest
release
Ref. Galaxy
Data
exploration,
dimension
Single and
multi-
omics
Genomics,
proteomics,
transcriptomics,
metabolomics,
Imaging
Yes, as tabular
data, or
mzXML,
mzML,
mzData raw
data
High throughput tools for
data processing and
analysis of both core
JavaScript, HTML,/
Web-based interface
2020
Boekel
et al., 2015
Reduction, data
integration and
visualisation
-omics (genomics and
transcriptomics) and MS-
or NMR-based -omics
(through
Workflow4Metabolomics
module)
Giacomoni
et al. Challenges and advancements on multi-
omics approach for ecotoxicological
research 2015
Adapted to handle ion
mobility mass spectrometry
and mass spectrometry
imaging data
Continuously updated with
new tools for data
processing and integration
Possibility to share
workflows and results
MetaboAnalyst
5.0
Spectra
processing,
multi-omics
integration and
covariate
adjustment of
global
metabolomics
data
Single and
multi-
omics
Principally
metabolomics and
lipidomics, but
also proteomics,
genomics,
transcriptomics,
Time-course and
longitudinal
omics data
Yes, as tabular
data, or
mzML,
mzXML,
mzData raw
data
Highly focused on data
processing, integration and
visualization of MS-based
single and multi-omics data
R language and Java
language/(Web-
based interface)
2022
Pang et al.,
2022
User-friendly and intuitive
interface
Semi-automatized
processing
High number of supervised
and unsupervised statistical
methods for multi-omics
MixOmics
Data
exploration,
dimension
reduction and
visualisation
Single- and
multi-
omics
Genomics,
proteomics,
RNAomics
Yes, as tabular
data
Wide range of multivariate
methods for the exploration
and integration of
biological datasets with a
particular focus on variable
selection
R package
2017 with
recurrent
updates
Rohart
et al., 2017
Metabolomics
Integration through two
DIABLO and MINT
integration methods for
N-integration and
P-integration
Singh et al.,
2019
Lipidomics
Glycomics
Spectral imaging
Time-course and
longitudinal
omics data (in
progress)
MiBiOmics
Data
exploration,
integration,
analysis and
visualization
Single- and
multi-
omics
Genomics,
proteomics,
RNAomics
Yes, as tabular
data
Widely applicable multi-
omics analyses; easy access
to exploratory ordination
techniques and to the
inference of (multilayer)
correlation networks
R package/web-
based and stand-
alone application
with user-friendly
interface
2021
Zoppi
et al., 2021
Metabolomics
Possibility to compare
results from different
(Continued on following page) 05 Frontiers in Analytical Science frontiersin.org Calabrese et al. 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 TABLE 1 (Continued) Principal platforms for MS data exploration, integration and visualization in single and multi-omics applications. Name
Features
Type of
datasets
Type of
omics data
Handling
of MS data
Main advantages
Programming
language/
Platform
Latest
release
Ref. approaches and cross-
validate multi-omics
signatures
Lipidomics,
glycomics
timeOMICS
Data pre-
processing,
integration,
visualization
Multi-
omics
Genomics,
proteomics,
RNAomics
Yes, as tabular
data
Possibility to integrate
longitudinal multi-omics
data
R package
2022
Bodein
et al., 2022
Metabolomics
Lipidomics,
glycomics
Time-course
multi-omics
longitudinal data
OmicsAnalyst/
OmicsNet
Data
integration,
analysis and
visualization
Single and
multi-
omics
Genomics,
proteomics,
Transcriptomics
Yes, as tabular
data
Includes advanced
statistical integration
methods, as DIABLO and
MINT
R package/Web-
based interface
2022
Zhou and
Xia (2018)
RNAomics
Possibility to explore multi-
omics data within the
context of molecular
interaction knowledge
Zhou et al. Frontiers in Analytical Science frontiersin.org Data availability statement All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors
and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations,
or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product
that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its
manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher. The original contributions presented in the study are included in
the article/supplementary material, further inquiries can be directed
to the corresponding authors. References Bertsch, A., Jung, S., Zerck, A., Pfeifer, N., Nahnsen, S., Henneges, C., et al. Optimal de
novo design of MRM experiments for rapid assay development in targeted proteomics. J. Proteome Res. (2010) 9:2696–2704. doi:10.1021/pr1001803 Aggarwal, S., Raj, A., Kumar, D., Dash, D., and Yadav, A. K. False discovery rate: The
achilles’ heel of proteogenomics. Brief. Bioinform (2022) 23:bbac163. doi:10.1093/bib/
bbac163 Ahmed, S. F., Kumar, P. S., Kabir, M., Zuhara, F. T., Mehjabin, A., Tasannum, N., et al. Threats, challenges and sustainable conservation strategies for freshwater biodiversity. Environ. Res. (2022) 214:113808. doi:10.1016/j.envres.2022.113808 Bletsou, A. A., Jeon, J., Hollender, J., Archontaki, E., and Thomaidis, N. S. Targeted and
non-targeted liquid chromatography-mass spectrometric workflows for identification of
transformation products of emerging pollutants in the aquatic environment. TrAC -
Trends Anal. Chem. (2015) 66:32–44. doi:10.1016/j.trac.2014.11.009 Trends Anal. Chem. (2015) 66:32–44. doi:10.1016/j.trac.2014.11.009 Amstalden van Hove, E. R., Smith, D. F., and Heeren, R. M. A. A concise review of
mass spectrometry imaging. J. Chromatogr. A (2010) 1217:3946–3954. doi:10.1016/j. chroma.2010.01.033 Amstalden van Hove, E. R., Smith, D. F., and Heeren, R. M. A. A concise review of
mass spectrometry imaging. J. Chromatogr. A (2010) 1217:3946–3954. doi:10.1016/j. chroma.2010.01.033 Bodein, A., Scott-Boyer, M. P., Perin, O., Lê Cao, K. A., and Droit, A. timeOmics: an R
package for longitudinal multi-omics data integration. Bioinformatics (2022) 38(2):
577–579. doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/btab664 Anjo, S. I., Santa, C., and Manadas, B. SWATH-MS as a tool for biomarker discovery:
From basic research to clinical applications. Proteomics (2017) 17:1600278. doi:10.1002/
pmic.201600278 Anjo, S. I., Santa, C., and Manadas, B. SWATH-MS as a tool for biomarker discovery:
From basic research to clinical applications. Proteomics (2017) 17:1600278. doi:10.1002/
pmic.201600278 Boekel, J., Chilton, J. M., Cooke, I. R., Horvatovich, P. L., Jagtap, P. D., Käll, L., et al. Multi-omic data analysis using Galaxy. Nat. Biotechnol. (2015) 33(2):137–139. doi:10. 1038/nbt.3134 Arambourou, H., Fuertes, I., Vulliet, E., Daniele, G., Noury, P., Delorme, N., et al. Fenoxycarb exposure disrupted the reproductive success of the amphipod Gammarus
fossarum with limited effects on the lipid profile. PLoS One (2018) 13:e0196461. doi:10. 1371/journal.pone.0196461 Bonnefoy, C., Fildier, A., Buleté, A., Bordes, C., Garric, J., Vulliet, E., et al. Untargeted
analysis of nanoLC-HRMS data by ANOVA-PCA to highlight metabolites in
Gammarus fossarum after in vivo exposure to pharmaceuticals. Talanta (2019) 202:
221–229. doi:10.1016/j.talanta.2019.04.028 Armengaud, J., Trapp, J., Pible, O., Geffard, O., Chaumot, A., and Hartmann, E. M. Non-model organisms, a species endangered by proteogenomics. J. Conflict of interest The authors declare that the research was conducted in the
absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be
construed as a potential conflict of interest. Conclusion VC was supported by a post-doctoral fellowship of the SENS
research funding of the Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1. This
work was also supported by the French National Research Agency
(ANR) (young investigator grant, ANR-18-CE34-0008 PLAN-TOX
and ANR-18-CE34-0013 APPROve), and the French GDR “Aquatic
Ecotoxicology” framework which aims at fostering stimulating
discussions and collaborations for more integrative approaches. The journey to a better understanding of freshwater ecosystems
and gammarid species has just begun. In the near future, the main
efforts in ecotoxicology studies should be addressed to the use of
alternative mass spectrometry platforms, for identification and
quantification of entire metabolome, lipidome, and proteome. From another perspective, the optimization and validation of
universal sample treatments compatible with high-throughput
multi-omics analyses have still to be developed, with the highest
expectative in single-cell analysis. To go much further, the use of
novel and progressively complete integration methods of large
datasets based on MS-omics (and other non-MS-based omics)
data can fill the gap between molecular response, toxicity
pathways and apical physiological effects in exposed organisms
and provide a more holistic view in ecotoxicology. Challenges and advancements on multi-
omics approach for ecotoxicological
research (2020)
Metabolomics
Highly devoted to data
visualization and
correlation network
analysis graphics (3D force-
directed layout, 2D
perspective layout,
spherical layout, etc.)
Lipidomics
Glycomics
Microbial Taxa
SNPs (MTBE/MeOH) for the simultaneous extraction of proteins, lipids,
and metabolites from a unique sample of G. fossarum, which turned
out to improve compound recovery and repeatability, with respect to
classic independent fractions sample preparation (Faugere et al.,
2023). In the study, MS-based multi-omics in combination with
multivariate
data
analysis
revealed
specific
proteomics,
metabolomics and lipidomics signatures of the different female
reproductive stages. Besides from this illustration, rare examples
of multi-omics development for ecotoxicology application have been
published and most of the present literature on MS-based multi-
omics approaches in freshwater ecotoxicology is restrained to the
study of model organisms, such as zebrafish (Danio rerio) or
organisms belonging to the Daphniidae family (Huang et al.,
2017; Wang et al., 2019; Jia et al., 2022; Marana et al., 2022). been developed based on the expansion of classic chemometrics,
artificial intelligence and machine learning. Among these, “data
integration
analysis
for
biomarker
discovery
using
latent
components”
(DIABLO)
and
“mining
interesting
numerical
pattern sets” (MINT) enable respectively N-integration (same
biological N samples measured on different ‘omics platforms)
and the P-integration (several independent data sets or studies
measured on the same predictors) of multi-omics datasets
(Rohart et al., 2017). These methods consider complex factors as
heterogeneity between omics platforms and give adequate weight to
different-omics layers. In addition, weighted correlation network
analysis (WGCNA) has been extended to MS-based proteomics and
metabolomics to find clusters of highly correlated proteins and
metabolites
(lipids,
sugars,
and
so
on),
and
to
highlight
connection between specific pollutants and adverse outcomes (Pei
et al., 2017; Degli Esposti et al., 2019). Efforts are being made also
towards the analysis of complex multi-omics datasets sampled
frequently over time in longitudinal studies (Bodein et al., 2022). On another side, there is the question concerning multi-omics
data integration and the development of predictive models for
highly complex datasets with intrinsic variability. In the last
years, progressively sophisticated and appealing approaches have 06 frontiersin.org Calabrese et al. Calabrese et al. 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 Author contributions Among
the available
platforms,
MetaboAnalyst
5.0
and
Workflow4Metabolomics (within the Galaxy framework) are
distinguished
thanks
to
their
user-friendly
and
MS-driven
workflows, from single-omics data exploration and analysis to
comprehensive
integration
and
visualization
of
multi-omics
datasets. Table 1 gathers the principal platforms for MS data
integration in single and multi-omics applications, together with
a summarized description and advantages. VC and SA designed the concept and wrote the article, with
contributions from AS, YC, TAB, AE, AC, OG, and DD-E. VC
prepared the figure. All authors contributed to manuscript revision,
read and approved the submitted version. References Shotgun metabolomic approach based on mass spectrometry for
hepatic mitochondria of mice under arsenic exposure. BioMetals (2015) 28:341–351. doi:10.1007/s10534-015-9837-9 Pei, G., Chen, L., and Zhang, W., WGCNA application to proteomic and metabolomic
data analysisMethods Enzym. 585. Academic Press (2017). p. 135–158. doi:10.1016/bs. mie.2016.09.016 Giacomoni, F., Le Corguille, G., Monsoor, M., Landi, M., Pericard, P., Petera, M., et al. Workflow4Metabolomics: A collaborative research infrastructure for computational
metabolomics. Bioinformatics (2015) 31(9):1493–1495. doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/
btu813 Persson, L., Carney Almroth, B. M., Collins, C. D., Cornell, S., de Wit, C. A., Diamond,
M. L., et al. Outside the safe operating space of the planetary boundary for novel entities. Environ. Sci. Technol. (2022) 56(3):1510–1521. doi:10.1021/acs.est.1c04158 Girolamo, F. D., Lante, I., Muraca, M., and Putignani, L. The role of mass
spectrometry in the “omics” era. Curr. Org. Chem. (2013) 17(23):2891–2905. doi:10. 2174/1385272817888131118162725 Raetz, M., Bonner, R., and Hopfgartner, G. SWATH-MS for metabolomics and
lipidomics: Critical aspects of qualitative and quantitative analysis. Metabolomics (2020)
16:71. doi:10.1007/s11306-020-01692-0 Gómez-Canela, C., Miller, T. H., Bury, N. R., Tauler, R., and Barron, L. P. Targeted
metabolomics of Gammarus pulex following controlled exposures to selected
pharmaceuticals in water. Sci. Total Environ. (2016) 562:777–788. doi:10.1016/j. scitotenv.2016.03.181 Rampler, E., Abiead, Y. E., Schoeny, H., Rusz, M., Hildebrand, F., Fitz, V., et al. Recurrent
topics
in
mass
spectrometry-based
metabolomics
and
lipidomics—Standardization, coverage, and throughput. Anal. Chem. (2020) 93(1):
519–545. doi:10.1021/acs.analchem.0c04698 Gouveia, D., Chaumot, A., Charnot, A., Almunia, C., François, A., Navarro, L., et al. Ecotoxico-proteomics for aquatic environmental monitoring: First in situ application of
a new proteomics-based multibiomarker assay using caged amphipods. Environ. Sci. Technol. (2017) 51(22):13417–13426. doi:10.1021/acs.est.7b03736
Han, X., and Gross, R. W. Shotgun lipidomics: Multidimensional MS analysis of
cellular lipidomes. Expert Rev. Proteomics (2005) 2:253–264. doi:10.1586/14789450.2. 2.253 Gouveia, D., Chaumot, A., Charnot, A., Almunia, C., François, A., Navarro, L., et al. Ecotoxico-proteomics for aquatic environmental monitoring: First in situ application of
a new proteomics-based multibiomarker assay using caged amphipods. Environ. Sci. Technol. (2017) 51(22):13417–13426. doi:10.1021/acs.est.7b03736 Rodriguez-Aller, M., Gurny, R., Veuthey, J. L., and Guillarme, D. Coupling ultra-
high-pressure liquid chromatography with mass spectrometry: Constraints and possible
applications. J. Chromatogr. A (2013) 1292:2–18. doi:10.1016/j.chroma.2012.09.061 Rohart, F., Gautier, B., Singh, A., and Lê Cao, K. A. mixOmics: An R package for
‘omics feature selection and multiple data integration. PLoS Comput. Biol. (2017)
13(11):e1005752. doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1005752 Han, X., and Gross, R. W. Shotgun lipidomics: Multidimensional MS analysis of
cellular lipidomes. Expert Rev. Proteomics (2005) 2:253–264. doi:10.1586/14789450.2. References H., Poulsen, R., Thormar, E. A., Clausen, C. G., Thit, A., Mathiessen, H.,
et al. Plastic nanoparticles cause mild inflammation, disrupt metabolic pathways,
change the gut microbiota and affect reproduction in zebrafish: A full generation
multi-omics study. J. Hazard Mater (2022) 424:127705. doi:10.1016/j.jhazmat.2021. 127705 Faugere, J., Brunet, T. A., Clément, Y., Espeyte, A., Geffard, O., Lemoine, J., et al. Development of a multi-omics extraction method for ecotoxicology: Investigation of the
reproductive cycle of Gammarus fossarum. Talanta (2023) 253:123806. doi:10.1016/j. talanta.2022.123806 Mehennaoui, K., Cambier, S., Serchi, T., Ziebel, J., Lentzen, E., Valle, N., et al. Do the
pristine physico-chemical properties of silver and gold nanoparticles influence uptake
and molecular effects on Gammarus fossarum (Crustacea Amphipoda)? Sci. Total
Environ. (2018) 643:1200–1215. doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.06.208 Faugere, J., Gouveia, D., Ayciriex, S., Chaumot, A., Almunia, C., François, A., et al. High-multiplexed monitoring of protein biomarkers in the sentinel Gammarus
fossarum by targeted scout-MRM assay, a new vision for ecotoxicoproteomics. J. Proteomics (2020) 226:103901. doi:10.1016/j.jprot.2020.103901 Nam, S.-E., Bae, D.-Y., Ki, J.-S., Ahn, C.-Y., and Rhee, J.-S. The importance of multi-
omics approaches for the health assessment of freshwater ecosystems. Mol. Cell Toxicol. (2022). doi:10.1007/s13273-022-00286-2 Fernández-Costa, C., Martínez-Bartolomé, S., McClatchy, D. B., Saviola, A. J., Yu, N. K., and Yates, J. R. Impact of the identification strategy on the reproducibility of the
DDA and DIA results. J. Proteome Res. (2020) 19:3153–3161. doi:10.1021/acs. jproteome.0c00153 Nothias, L.-F., Petras, D., Schmid, R., Dührkop, K., Rainer, J., Sarvepalli, A., et al. Feature-based molecular networking in the GNPS analysis environment. Nat. Methods
(2020) 17:905–908. doi:10.1038/s41592-020-0933-6 Fu, T., Knittelfelder, O., Geffard, O., Clément, Y., Testet, E., Elie, N., et al. Shotgun
lipidomics and mass spectrometry imaging unveil diversity and dynamics in Gammarus
fossarum lipid composition. iScience (2021) 24:102115. doi:10.1016/j.isci.2021.102115 Olivon, F., Elie, N., Grelier, G., Roussi, F., Litaudon, M., and Touboul, D. MetGem
software for the generation of molecular networks based on the t-SNE algorithm. Anal. Chem. (2018) 90:13900–13908. doi:10.1021/acs.analchem.8b03099 Fu, T., Oetjen, J., Chapelle, M., Verdu, A., Szesny, M., Chaumot, A., et al. In situ
isobaric lipid mapping by MALDI–ion mobility separation–mass spectrometry
imaging. J. Mass Spectrom. (2020) 55:e4531. doi:10.1002/jms.4531 Pang, Z., Zhou, G., Ewald, J., Chang, L., Hacariz, O., Basu, N., et al. Using
MetaboAnalyst 5.0 for LC–HRMS spectra processing, multi-omics integration and
covariate adjustment of global metabolomics data. Nat. Protoc. (2022) 17(8):1735–1761. doi:10.1038/s41596-022-00710-w García-Sevillano, M. A., García-Barrera, T., Navarro, F., Montero-Lobato, Z., and
Gómez-Ariza, J. L. References proteomics (2014)
105:5–18. doi:10.1016/j.jprot.2014.01.007 Brondizio, E. S., Settele, J., Díaz, S., and Ngo, H. T. Global assessment report on biodiversity
and ecosystem services of the intergovernmental science-policy platform on biodiversity and
ecosystem services. Bonn, Germany: IPBES (2019). doi:10.5281/zenodo.3831673 Ayciriex, S., Carrière, R., Bardet, C., Blanc, J. Y. L., Salvador, A., Fortin, T., et al. Streamlined development of targeted mass spectrometry-based method combining
scout-MRM and a web-based tool indexed with scout peptides. Proteomics (2020) 20(2):
1900254. doi:10.1002/pmic.201900254 Bui, D. T., Jung, J., Kitova, E. N., Li, Z., Willows, S. D., Boddington, M. E., et al. Mass
spectrometry-based shotgun glycomics using labeled glycan libraries. Anal. Chem. (2022) 94(12):4997–5005. doi:10.1021/acs.analchem.1c04779 Balian, E. v., Segers, H., Lévèque, C., and Martens, K. The freshwater animal diversity
assessment: An overview of the results. Hydrobiologia (2008) 595:627–637. doi:10.1007/
s10750-007-9246-3 Calabrese, V., Schmitz-Afonso, I., Prevost, C., Afonso, C., and Elomri, A. Molecular
networking and collision cross section prediction for structural isomer and unknown
compound identification in plant metabolomics: A case study applied to Zhanthoxylum Frontiers in Analytical Science frontiersin.org 07 Calabrese et al. 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 Calabrese et al. heitzii extracts. Anal. Bioanal. Chem. (2022) 414(14):4103–4118. doi:10.1007/s00216-
022-04059-7 modulated proteins in an aquatic invertebrate sentinel species, Gammarus fossarum. Gammarus Fossarum. Environ. Pollut. (2022) 315:120393. doi:10.1016/j.envpol.2022. 120393 Calabrese, V., Schmitz-Afonso, I., Riah-Anglet, W., Trinsoutrot-Gattin, I., Pawlak, B.,
and Afonso, C. Direct introduction MALDI FTICR MS based on dried droplet
deposition applied to non-targeted metabolomics on Pisum Sativum root exudates. Talanta (2023) 253:123901. doi:10.1016/j.talanta.2022.123901 Letertre, M. P., Giraudeau, P., and De Tullio, P. Nuclear magnetic resonance
spectroscopy
in
clinical
metabolomics
and
personalized
medicine:
Current
challenges and perspectives. Front. Mol. Biosci. (2021) 8:698337. doi:10.3389/fmolb. 2021.698337 Degli Esposti, D., Almunia, C., Guery, M. A., Koenig, N., Armengaud, J., Chaumot, A.,
et al. Co-expression network analysis identifies gonad-and embryo-associated protein
modules in the sentinel species Gammarus fossarum. Sci. Rep. (2019) 9(1):7862. doi:10. 1038/s41598-019-44203-5 Li, Y., Li, H., Xie, Y., Chen, S., Qin, R., Dong, H., et al. An integrated strategy for mass
spectrometry-based multiomics analysis of single cells. Anal. Chem. (2021) 93:
14059–14067. doi:10.1021/acs.analchem.0c05209 Liebler, D. C., and Zimmerman, L. J. Targeted quantitation of proteins by mass
spectrometry. Biochemistry (2013) 52:3797–3806. doi:10.1021/bi400110b Duarte, B., Feijão, E., Cruz de Carvalho, R., Duarte, I. A., Marques, A. P., Maia, M.,
et
al. Untargeted
metabolomics
reveals
antidepressant
effects
in
a
marine
photosynthetic organism: The diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum as a case study. Biology (2022) 11(12):1770. doi:10.3390/biology11121770 Marana, M. References 2.253 Rougemont, B., Bontemps Gallo, S., Ayciriex, S., Carrière, R., Hondermarck, H.,
Lacroix, J. M., et al. Scout-MRM: Multiplexed targeted mass spectrometry-based assay
without retention time scheduling exemplified by Dickeya dadantii proteomic analysis
during plant infection. Anal. Chem. (2017) 89(3):1421–1426. doi:10.1021/acs.analchem. 6b03201 Heiles,
S. Advanced
tandem
mass
spectrometry
in
metabolomics
and
lipidomics—Methods and applications. Anal. Bioanal. Chem. (2021) 413(24):
5927–5948. doi:10.1007/s00216-021-03425-1 Hernández, F., Sancho, J. v., Ibáñez, M., Abad, E., Portolés, T., and Mattioli, L. Current
use of high-resolution mass spectrometry in the environmental sciences. Anal. Bioanal. Chem. (2012) 403:1251–1264. doi:10.1007/s00216-012-5844-7 Salvador, A., Carrière, R., Ayciriex, S., Margoum, C., Leblanc, Y., and Lemoine, J. Scout-multiple
reaction
monitoring:
A
liquid
chromatography
tandem
mass
spectrometry approach for multi-residue pesticide analysis without time scheduling. J. Chromatogr. A (2020) 1621:461046. doi:10.1016/j.chroma.2020.461046 Hu, C., Duan, Q., and Han, X. Strategies to improve/eliminate the limitations in
shotgun lipidomics. Proteomics (2020) 20(11):1900070. doi:10.1002/pmic.201900070 Huang, S. S. Y., Benskin, J. P., Veldhoen, N., Chandramouli, B., Butler, H., Helbing, C. C.,
et al. A multi-omic approach to elucidate low-dose effects of xenobiotics in zebrafish (Danio
rerio) larvae. Aquat. Toxicol. (2017) 182:102–112. doi:10.1016/j.aquatox.2016.11.016 Sheikholeslami, M. N., Gómez-Canela, C., Barron, L. P., Barata, C., Vosough, M., and
Tauler, R. Untargeted metabolomics changes on Gammarus pulex induced by
propranolol, triclosan, and nimesulide pharmaceutical drugs. Chemosphere (2020)
260:127479. doi:10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127479 Jia, J., Dong, C., Han, M., Ma, S., Chen, W., Dou, J., et al. Multi-omics perspective on
studying reproductive biology in Daphnia sinensis. Genomics (2022) 114:110309. doi:10. 1016/j.ygeno.2022.110309 Simon, R., Jubeaux, G., Chaumot, A., Lemoine, J., Geffard, O., and Salvador, A. Mass
spectrometry assay as an alternative to the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay test for
biomarker quantitation in ecotoxicology: Application to vitellogenin in Crustacea
(Gammarus fossarum). J. Chromatogr. A (2010) 1217:5109–5115. doi:10.1016/j. chroma.2010.06.015 Kanu, A. B., Dwivedi, P., Tam, M., Matz, L., and Hill, H. H. Ion mobility-mass
spectrometry. J. Mass Spectrom. (2008) 43:1–22. doi:10.1002/jms.1383 Laszakovits, J. R., and MacKay, A. A. Data-based chemical class regions for van
krevelen diagrams. J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom. (2021) 33(1):198–202. doi:10.1021/jasms. 1c00230 Singh, A., Shannon, C. P., Gautier, B., Rohart, F., Vacher, M., Tebbutt, S. J., et al. Diablo: An integrative approach for identifying key molecular drivers from multi-omics
assays. Bioinformatics (2019) 35(17):3055–3062. doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/bty1054 Leprêtre, M., Geffard, O., Espeyte, A., Faugere, J., Ayciriex, S., Salvador, A., et al. Multiple reaction monitoring mass spectrometry for the discovery of environmentally Taylor, N. S., Weber, R. J. M., Southam, A. References D., Payne, T. G., Hrydziuszko, O.,
Arvanitis, T. N., et al. A new approach to toxicity testing in Daphnia magna: Application Frontiers in Analytical Science 08 frontiersin.org Calabrese et al. 10.3389/frans.2023.1118494 of high throughput FT-ICR mass spectrometry metabolomics. Metabolomics (2009)
5(1):44–58. doi:10.1007/s11306-008-0133-3 Wu, C. C., and Maccoss, M. J. Shotgun proteomics: Tools for the analysis of complex
biological systems. Curr. Opin. Mol. Ther. (2002) 4:242–250. Trapp, J., Almunia, C., Gaillard, J. C., Pible, O., Chaumot, A., Geffard, O., et al. Proteogenomic insights into the core-proteome of female reproductive tissues from
crustacean amphipods. J. Proteomics (2016) 135:51–61. doi:10.1016/j.jprot.2015.06.017 Zhou, G., Pang, Z., Lu, Y., Ewald, J., and Xia, J. OmicsNet 2.0: A web-based platform
for multi-omics integration and network visual analytics. Nucleic Acids Res. (2022) 50:
W527–W533. doi:10.1093/nar/gkac376 Trapp, J., Armengaud, J., Pible, O., Gaillard, J. C., Abbaci, K., Habtoul, Y., et al. Proteomic investigation of male Gammarus fossarum, a freshwater crustacean, in response
to endocrine disruptors. J. Proteome Res. (2015) 14:292–303. doi:10.1021/pr500984z Zhou, G., and Xia, J. OmicsNet: A web-based tool for creation and visual analysis of
biological networks in 3D space. Nucleic acids Res. (2018) 46(W1):W514–W522. doi:10. 1093/nar/gky510 Trapp, J., Geffard, O., Imbert, G., Gaillard, J. C., Davin, A. H., Chaumot, A., et al. Proteogenomics of Gammarus fossarum to document the reproductive system of
amphipods. Mol. Cell. Proteomics (2014) 13:3612–3625. doi:10.1074/mcp.M114. 038851 Zhou, Z., Luo, M., Chen, X., Yin, Y., Xiong, X., Wang, R., et al. Ion mobility collision
cross-section atlas for known and unknown metabolite annotation in untargeted
metabolomics. Nat. Commun. (2020) 11(1):4334. doi:10.1038/s41467-020-18171-8 Zhu, Y., Wancewicz, B., Schaid, M., Tiambeng, T. N., Wenger, K., Jin, Y., et al. Ultrahigh-resolution mass spectrometry-based platform for plasma metabolomics
applied to type 2 diabetes research. J. Proteome Res. (2021) 20(1):463–473. doi:10. 1021/acs.jproteome.0c00510 Tsugawa, H., Cajka, T., Kind, T., Ma, Y., Higgins, B., Ikeda, K., et al. MS-DIAL: Data-
independent MS/MS deconvolution for comprehensive metabolome analysis. Nat. methods (2015) 12(6):523–526. doi:10.1038/nmeth.3393 Zoppi, J., Guillaume, J. F., Neunlist, M., and Chaffron, S. MiBiOmics: An interactive
web application for multi-omics data exploration and integration. BMC Bioinforma. (2021) 22(1):6–14. doi:10.1186/s12859-020-03921-8 Wang, P., Ng, Q., Zhang, B., Wei, Z., Hassan, M., He, Y., et al. Employing multi-omics
to elucidate the hormetic response against oxidative stress exerted by nC60 on Daphnia
pulex. Environ. Pollut. (2019) 251:22–29. doi:10.1016/j.envpol.2019.04.097 09 Frontiers in Analytical Science Frontiers in Analytical Science 09 frontiersin.org
|
https://openalex.org/W3145567274
|
https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-03244564/document
|
English
| null |
COVID-19–Related National Re-confinement: Recommendations From the National French Observatory for Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS)
|
Journal of physical activity & health
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 3,582
|
To cite this version: David Thivel, Michele Tardieu, Pauline Genin, Alicia Fillon, Benjamin Larras, et al.. COVID-19-
Related National Re-confinement: Recommendations From the National French Observatory for Phys-
ical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS). Journal of Physical Activity and Health (JPAH),
2021, 18 (5), pp.474-476. 10.1123/jpah.2020-0735. hal-03244564 COVID-19-Related National Re-confinement:
Recommendations From the National French
Observatory for Physical Activity and Sedentary
Behaviors (ONAPS)
David Thivel, Michele Tardieu, Pauline Genin, Alicia Fillon, Benjamin Larras,
Pierre Melsens, Julien Bois, Frederic Dutheil, Francois Carre, Gregory Ninot,
et al.
To cite this version:
David Thivel, Michele Tardieu, Pauline Genin, Alicia Fillon, Benjamin Larras, et al.. COVID-19-
Related National Re-confinement: Recommendations From the National French Observatory for Phys-
ical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS). Journal of Physical Activity and Health (JPAH), To cite this version:
David Thivel, Michele Tardieu, Pauline Genin, Alicia Fillon, Benjamin Larras, et al.. COVID-19-
Related National Re-confinement: Recommendations From the National French Observatory for Phys-
ical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS). Journal of Physical Activity and Health (JPAH)
2021, 18 (5), pp.474-476. 10.1123/jpah.2020-0735. hal-03244564 Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License COVID-19–Related National Re-confinement:
Recommendations From the National French Observatory
for Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS)
David Thivel, Michéle Tardieu, Pauline Genin, Alicia Fillon, Benjamin Larras, Pierre Melsens,
Julien Bois, Frédéric Dutheil, Francois Carré, Gregory Ninot, Jean-Francois Toussaint,
Daniel Rivière, Yves Boirie, Bruno Pereira, Angelo Tremblay, and Martine Duclos On top of their well-known impact on physical and metabolic
health in both healthy individuals and patients,1 both PA and
sedentary behaviors have been shown to be strongly associated
(in an opposite way) with depression, anxiety, stress, and overall
wellbeing.2–4 Decline of PA and increase of SED during the first
confinement period have been clearly related to a deterioration
of several mental health indicators at all ages.5–9 Moreover, Thivel, Tardieu, Genin, Fillon, Larras, Melsens, Bois, Carré, Ninot, Toussaint,
Rivière, Boirie, Pereira, Tremblay, and Duclos are with the National Observatory for
Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS), Clermont-Ferrand, France. Dutheil is with Occupational Medicine, University Hospital CHU G. Montpied,
Clermont-Ferrand, France; University Clermont 1, UFR Medicine, Clermont-
Ferrand, France; and Université Clermont Auvergne, CNRS, LaPSCo, Physiologi-
cal and Psychosocial Stress. Thivel is also with Clermont Auvergne University, EA
3533, Laboratory of the Metabolic Adaptations to Exercise under Physiological and
Pathological Conditions (AME2P), CRNH Auvergne, Clermont-Ferrand, France. Bois is also with the Universite de Pau & des Pays de l’Adour, e2s UPPA, MEPS,
Tarbes, France. Boire and Duclos are also with University Clermont 1, UFR
Medicine, Clermont-Ferrand, France. Carré is also with Cardiologie et maladies
vasculaires, médecine du sport, CHU Pontchaillou, université Rennes 1, Inserm
1099, Rennes, France. Ninot is also with Unité de recherche IDESP, Université de
Montpellier, Institut du Cancer de Montpellier, Montpellier, France. Toussaint is
also with the Institut de Recherche Biomédicale et d’Épidémiologie du Sport
(IRMES), Institut National du Sport, de l’Expertise et de la Performance (INSEP);
EA7329 Institut de Recherche BioMédicale et d’Épidémiologie du Sport (IRMES);
and the Centre d’Investigation en Médecine du Sport, Paris, France. Boirie is
also with the Departement of Human Nutrition, Clermont-Ferrand University
Hospital, G. Montpied Hospital, Clermont-Ferrand, France; and INRA, UMR
1019, Clermont-Ferrand, France. Pereira and Duclos are also with Clermont-Ferrand
University Hospital, Biostatistics unit (DRCI), Clermont-Ferrand, France. Duclos is
also with the Department of Sport Medicine and Functional Explorations, Clermont-
Ferrand University Hospital, G. Montpied Hospital, Clermont-Ferrand, France. Tremblay is also with the Département de l’éducation Physique, Faculté des
Sciences de l’éducation, Université Laval, Québec City, QC, G1V 0A6, Canada. Thivel (david.thivel@uca.fr) is corresponding author. HAL Id: hal-03244564
https://hal.science/hal-03244564v1
Submitted on 13 Jun 2022 L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés. HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers. Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License COMMENTARY Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 2021, 18, 474-476
https://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.2020-0735
© 2021 Human Kinetics, Inc. COVID-19–Related National Re-confinement:
Recommendations From the National French Observatory
for Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS)
David Thivel, Michéle Tardieu, Pauline Genin, Alicia Fillon, Benjamin Larras, Pierre Melsens,
Julien Bois, Frédéric Dutheil, Francois Carré, Gregory Ninot, Jean-Francois Toussaint,
Daniel Rivière, Yves Boirie, Bruno Pereira, Angelo Tremblay, and Martine Duclos While a declined physical activity level (PAL) and an increase
of sedentary behaviors at all ages during the COVID-19–induced
first confinement period have been unanimously observed world-
wide, the lately instituted new social distancing strategies and
lockdowns around the world require the formulation and dissemi-
nation of adapted and accessible recommendations to promote
physical activity (PA) and limit the progression of sedentary time
(SED) in the upcoming weeks. From a public health perspective, it
appears imperative to encourage the adoption of healthy movement
behaviors despite the new activity restrictions imposed by govern-
ments to slow down the alarming progression of the SARS-CoV-2
pandemic. sedentariness plays a major role in COVID-19 mortality world-
wide, while inactivity partly determines the proportion of patients
requiring intensive care due its subsequent metabolic disorders
(obesity, hypertension, diabetes).10 It appears then necessary to
elaborate effective strategies to maintain the PAL of already active
individuals but also to encourage inactive people to improve their
activity, while, obviously, fighting against the instauration of a sort
of “supra-sedentariness” favored by social distancing and increased
teleworking. Maintaining and encouraging PA during a confine-
ment period appears indeed essential to preserve our health capital
but also to reinforce our immunity, which seems actually of high
importance to face the COVID-19 virus. In order to face this worrying situation induced by the first
quarantine period related to the COVID-19 virus, the World Health
Organization (WHO) proposed some recommendations aimed at
improving individuals’ total daily activity level.11,12 Briefly, WHO
encouraged adults to increase their household chores, to integrate
online PA programs, to exercise while listening to enjoyable music,
to climb stairs as much as possible and to perform resistance
exercises. For children and adolescents (5 to 17 years old), WHO
recommended participation in online physical activities, active
plays, indoor challenging games, the realization of activities
mobilizing muscle groups, and the development of new motor
abilities and skills. Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 2021, 18, 474-476
https://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.2020-0735
© 2021 Human Kinetics, Inc. COVID-19–Related National Re-confinement:
Recommendations From the National French Observatory
for Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS)
David Thivel, Michéle Tardieu, Pauline Genin, Alicia Fillon, Benjamin Larras, Pierre Melsens,
Julien Bois, Frédéric Dutheil, Francois Carré, Gregory Ninot, Jean-Francois Toussaint,
Daniel Rivière, Yves Boirie, Bruno Pereira, Angelo Tremblay, and Martine Duclos Since the first confinement, some authors proposed adapted
PA and SED recommendations for older adults,13–15 for children
and adolescents,14–16 and for the overall population.17–19 Briefly, all
these recommendations underlined the need for home-based
adapted versions of the usual PA recommendations, proposing
adequate durations and intensities and stressing the particular need
to adopt some sedentary break strategies. p
y
g
The French National Observatory for Physical Activity and
Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS), altogether with the French Minis-
ter of Sports, conducted one of the largest worldwide surveys
evaluating the impact of the first confinement on PA and SED.20
Importantly, this survey questioned the impacts of the lockdown
from childhood to elderly and the conducted analysis also explored
whether these changes were associated with the initial levels of PA
and SED of individuals (for complete and detailed results, see
ONAPS’ position stand20). Briefly this survey showed, altogether
with an alarming general reduction of PA, a dramatic increase in
sitting time per day in nearly 50% of participants (reaching +72% in
initially sedentary children and adolescents) and, except in older
people, a huge increase in screen time per day (children and
adolescents: +62 to 69%, adults: +57%). According to our results,
a very large proportion of initially active individuals decreased 474 ONAPS Physical Activity Recommendations and COVID-19 475 general PA guidelines, but propose an adapted approach to avoid
the already observed negative impacts of a lockdown on our daily
active and sedentary behaviors. their PAL during the confinement while previously inactive ones
tended to start exercising, mainly following online training classes
that remain to be considered with caution as non-individualized
and adapted to everyone (especially inactive people). Interestingly,
people who maintained or increased their PAL during the first days
of the previous lockdown were more likely to remain active and
less sedentary during the whole confinement (which was positively
associated with overall mental health and wellbeing). Our results
also pointed out the necessity to help children and adolescents to
remain active as they showed a dramatic increase of their overall
unhealthy movement behaviors (decreased PAL and increased
screen time). The main results of this survey have been previously
detailed.20 While not exhaustive, these advices should be considered as
simple strategies proposed to avoid the observed confinement-
induced decline of PAL and rise of SED. Recommendation or Advice • Favor any daily movement, whatever its intensity and duration, keeping in mind that our overall level of p
simple movement. • Favor any daily movement, whatever its intensity and duration, keeping in mind that our overall level of physical activity needs every single and
simple movement. • We encourage the adoption of an active daily lifestyle from the very early days of this new confinement. should be given to our sedentary behaviors from the first days, to avoid their instauration and adopt healt • As for the first confinement, it remains possible to perform 1 hour of outside physical activity per day. We encourage the adoption of daily walks
or runs. Several days a week, we encourage to share these outdoor activities with the other members who compose the family home. • As for the first confinement, it remains possible to perform 1 hour of outside physical activity per day. We encourage the adoption of daily walks
or runs. Several days a week, we encourage to share these outdoor activities with the other members who compose the family home. • As for the first confinement, it remains possible to perform 1 hour of outside physical activity per day. or runs. Several days a week, we encourage to share these outdoor activities with the other members • Initially active individuals must be careful to maintain their level of practice, keeping in mind that our usual daily activities related to active
transportation and occupational activities will be drastically decreased and should be compensated for by favoring other kinds of activities
such as active plays with kids, walking, and housekeeping. • Initially active individuals must be careful to maintain their level of practice, keeping in mind that our usual daily activities related to active
transportation and occupational activities will be drastically decreased and should be compensated for by favoring other kinds of activities
such as active plays with kids, walking, and housekeeping. mportant to warm up and stretch 5 to 10 minutes before setting up at your desk, emphasizing on the back,
p of the main muscle groups is also recommended. • In case of telecommuting, it is important to warm up and stretch 5 to 10 minutes before setting up at you
shoulders, and pelvis. A warm-up of the main muscle groups is also recommended. COVID-19–Related National Re-confinement:
Recommendations From the National French Observatory
for Physical Activity and Sedentary Behaviors (ONAPS)
David Thivel, Michéle Tardieu, Pauline Genin, Alicia Fillon, Benjamin Larras, Pierre Melsens,
Julien Bois, Frédéric Dutheil, Francois Carré, Gregory Ninot, Jean-Francois Toussaint,
Daniel Rivière, Yves Boirie, Bruno Pereira, Angelo Tremblay, and Martine Duclos There is no one-size-
fits-all solution, but everyone has to realize the importance of
maintaining an active lifestyle despite such particular circum-
stances. Importantly, according to what was observed during the
previous lockdown, initially active people with a low or moderate
time devoted to sedentary behaviors are particularly at risk of
adopting unhealthy movement behaviors, as well as adolescents,
older people, and women. p
p
Although highly restrictive, this new wave of the COVID-19
pandemic and the instituted new confinement (for at least several
weeks) should be considered as a potential opportunity to analyze
our usual daily activities and sedentary behaviors, and to adopt new
habits, on an individual and/or family basis, to improve our PAL,
reduce our time spent sedentary, and then enhance our overall
mental and physical health. At the dawn of a new generalized episode of confinement,
ONAPS proposes here some new key recommendations and
advices, based on the actually available evidences and on the
results of its COVID-19 national survey,20 to prevent the decline
in active behaviors and rise in SED that have been observed during
the first confinement (from March to May 2020). Importantly, these
recommendations and advices (Table 1) are not substitutes to the Recommendation or Advice • Initially inactive individuals, or those with a low level of physical activity, should engage in a gradual and a step-by-step approach to
progressively reach the recommendations. A brutal engagement in an important volume of physical activity has been shown counterproductive
and does not favor a long-term adoption of physical activity behaviors. • Online physical activity classes can be followed and have to be encouraged keeping in mind that they might not be individualized and that
everyone has to auto-adapt their practice based on their own physical and exertion sensations. Exercising does not have to be painful and we
have to listen to our own feelings and capacities to progressively improve. A scale of perceived difficulty (0 to 10) can be used instead of
proper intensities; a rating between 5 and 7 being appropriate to ensure long-term engagement. • Online physical activity classes can be followed and have to be encouraged keeping in mind that they might not be individualized and that
everyone has to auto-adapt their practice based on their own physical and exertion sensations. Exercising does not have to be painful and we
have to listen to our own feelings and capacities to progressively improve. A scale of perceived difficulty (0 to 10) can be used instead of
proper intensities; a rating between 5 and 7 being appropriate to ensure long-term engagement. • Parents and legal representatives should encourage physical activity among children and adolescents. Performing active games 1 hour or so
per day with our young kids, even combined with 1 hour of outdoor walk or play, is not enough to maintain their daily physical activity
level. Regular short blocks of games and activities should be encouraged (which could join up with the active breaks recommended to break
our sedentary time). • In order to break this sedentary time in both youth and parents, we suggest the adoption of active breaks that involve the whole family (or
several members), based on small active plays and games. We also encourage the instauration of relatively short periods of relaxing activities
such as stretching before and after a whole day of teleworking. • In order to break this sedentary time in both youth and parents, we suggest the adoption of active breaks that involve the whole family (or
several members), based on small active plays and games. References 11. World Health Organization. Global Strategy on Diet, Physical Activity
and Health. 2020. https://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/background/
en/2020. Accessed September 12, 2020. 1. Zhao M, Veeranki SP, Magnussen CG, Xi B. Recommended physical
activity and all cause and cause specific mortality in US adults:
prospective cohort study. BMJ. 2020;370(1):m203. 12. World Health Organization. #HealthyAtHome – Physical Activity. 2020. https://www.who.int/news-room/campaigns/connecting-the-
world-to-combat-coronavirus/healthyathome/healthyathome---physical-
activity. Accessed August 25, 2020. 2. Netz Y. Is the comparison between exercise and pharmacologic
treatment of depression in the clinical practice guideline of the
American College of Physicians evidence-based? Front Pharmacol. 2017;8:257. PubMed ID: 28555108 doi:10.3389/fphar.2017.00257 13. Jiménez-Pavo´n D, Carbonell-Baeza A, Lavie CJ. Physical exercise
as therapy to fight against the mental and physical consequences of
COVID-19 quarantine: Special focus in older people. Prog Cardi-
ovasc Dis. 2020;63(3):386–388. PubMed ID: 32220590 doi:10.1016/
j.pcad.2020.03.009 3. Omorou AY, Vuillemin A, Menai M, et al. 10-year cumulative and
bidirectional associations of domain-specific physical activity and
sedentary behaviour with health-related quality of life in French
adults: Results from the SU.VI.MAX studies. Prev Med. 2016;88:
66–72. PubMed ID: 27058941 doi:10.1016/j.ypmed.2016.03.023 14. Lakicevic N, Moro T, Paoli A, et al. Stay fit, don’t quit: geriatric
exercise prescription in COVID-19 pandemic. Aging Clin Exp Res. 2020;32(7):1209–1210. PubMed ID: 32449107 doi:10.1007/s40520-
020-01588-y 4. Stubbs B, Vancampfort D, Thompson T, et al. Pain and severe sleep
disturbance in the general population: Primary data and meta-analysis
from 240,820 people across 45 low- and middle-income countries. Gen Hosp Psychiatry. 2018;53:52–58. PubMed ID: 29807277 doi:
10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2018.05.006 15. Hammami A, Harrabi B, Mohr M, Krustrup P. Physical activity and
coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): Specific recommendations
for home-based physical training [published online ahead of print
April 20, 2020]. Manag Sport Leis. doi:10.1080/23750472.2020. 1757494 5. Ugbolue UC, Duclos M, Urzeala C, et al. An assessment of the novel
COVISTRESS Questionnaire: COVID-19 impact on physical activ-
ity, sedentary action and psychological emotion. J Clin Med. 2020;
9(10):E3352. PubMed ID: 33086648 doi:10.3390/jcm9103352 16. Guan H, Okely AD, Aguilar-Farias N, et al. Promoting healthy
movement behaviours among children during the COVID-19 pan-
demic. Lancet Child Adolesc Health. 2020;4(6):416–418. PubMed
ID: 32458805 doi:10.1016/S2352-4642(20)30131-0 6. Carriedo A, Cecchini JA, Fernández-Río J, Méndez-Giménez A. Resilience and physical activity in people under home isolation due
to COVID-19: a preliminary evaluation. Ment Health Phys Act. 2020;
19:100361. PubMed ID: 33024452 doi:10.1016/j.mhpa.2020.100361 17. Ricci F, Izzicupo P, Moscucci F, et al. Recommendations for physical
inactivity and sedentary behavior during the coronavirus disease
(COVID-19) pandemic. Recommendation or Advice We also encourage the instauration of relatively short periods of relaxing activities
such as stretching before and after a whole day of teleworking. • On top of the recommended active breaks, homemade active desks can be created to turn our usual tables or desk into standing desk, for
instance. When possible cycling drives can be purchased. Simple strategies could be adopted such as systematically walking while on the
phone. • Families and peers should regularly, on a daily basis, encourage older people to engage in simple activities such as walking. The government
gives the opportunity to visit individuals who necessitate help and support and we believe that the maintenance of our elders’ physical activity
is a challenge that has to be considered during this new lockdown. • Importantly, the practice of physical activity should be conditioned to our health status. Fever, persistent
or not to COVID-19), as well as muscle or joint pain, should lead everyone to adapt their activity. • Importantly, the practice of physical activity should be conditioned to our health status. Fever, persistent fatigue, and other symptoms (related
or not to COVID-19), as well as muscle or joint pain, should lead everyone to adapt their activity. • Importantly, the practice of physical activity should be conditioned to our health status. Fever, persistent fatigue, and other symptoms (related
or not to COVID-19), as well as muscle or joint pain, should lead everyone to adapt their activity. • Patients with chronic disease should not stop physical activity that is an integral part of their treatment. T
outdoor physical activity to reach at least 30 minutes of physical activity every day and to break regularly JPAH Vol. 18, No. 5, 2021 Thivel et al 476 References Front Public Health. 2020;8:199. PubMed
ID: 32574294 doi:10.3389/fpubh.2020.00199 7. Chouchou F, Augustini M, Caderby T, Caron N, Turpin NA, Dalleau
G. The importance of sleep and physical activity on well-being during
COVID-19 lockdown: reunion island as a case study. Sleep Med. 2021;77:297–301. PubMed ID: 33020037 doi:10.1016/j.sleep.2020. 09.014 18. Chtourou H, Trabelsi K, H’mida C, et al. Staying physically active
during the quarantine and self-isolation period for controlling and
mitigating the COVID-19 pandemic: A systematic overview of the
literature. Front Psychol. 2020;11:1708. PubMed ID: 33013497 doi:
10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01708 8. Werneck AO, Silva DR, Malta DC, et al. Changes in the clustering of
unhealthy movement behaviors during the COVID-19 quarantine and
the association with mental health indicators among Brazilian adults. Transl Behav Med. 2020;6:ibaa095. doi:10.1093/tbm/ibaa095 19. Jurak G, Morrison SA, Leskošek B, et al. Physical activity recom-
mendations during the coronavirus disease-2019 virus outbreak. J Sport Health Sci. 2020;9(4):325–327. PubMed ID: 32426171 doi:
10.1016/j.jshs.2020.05.003 9. Alves JM, Yunker AG, DeFendis A, Xiang AH, Page KA. Associa-
tions between affect, physical activity, and anxiety among US children
during COVID-19. medRxiv. 2020;23:20216424. 20. Genin PM, Dutheil F, Larras B, et al. Promoting physical activity and
reducing sedentary time among tertiary workers: Position stand from
the French National Observatory for Physical Activity and Sedentary
Behaviors (ONAPS). J Phys Act Health. 2020;16(9):677–678. doi:
10.1123/jpah.2019-0154 10. De Larochelambert Q, Marc A, Antero J, Le Bourg E, Toussaint JF. Covid-19 mortality worldwide: a matter of vulnerability among na-
tions facing limited margins of adaptation. Front Public Health. 2020;
8:604339. PubMed ID: 33330343 doi:10.3389/fpubh.2020.604339 JPAH Vol. 18, No. 5, 2021 Copyright of Journal of Physical Activity & Health is the property of Human Kinetics
Publishers, Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a
listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print,
download, or email articles for individual use. Copyright of Journal of Physical Activity & Health is the property of Human Kinetics
Publishers, Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a
listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print,
download, or email articles for individual use.
|
https://openalex.org/W2790327029
|
https://wnus.usz.edu.pl/frfu/file/article/view/11392.pdf
|
Polish
| null |
Motives for Trade Credit Use by Micro-enterprises
|
Finanse, Rynki Finansowe, Ubezpieczenia
| 2,016
|
cc-by-sa
| 3,982
|
Finanse, Rynki Finansowe, Ubezpieczenia nr 4/2016 (82/1) Finanse, Rynki Finansowe, Ubezpieczenia nr 4/2016 (82/1) Finanse, Rynki Finansowe, Ubezpieczenia nr 4/2016 (82/1) DOI: 10.18276/frfu.2016.4.82/1-46 s. 559–567 * dr Katarzyna Ziętek-Kwaśniewska, Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawła II, Instytut Ekonomii i Zarządza-
nia, e-mail: kwasniewska@kul.lublin.pl. Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego
przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa Katarzyna Ziętek-Kwaśniewska* Streszczenie: Cel – Celem artykułu jest identyfikacja i ocena znaczenia czynników stanowiących o k
staniu z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa. Metodologia badania – W artykule dokonano przeglądu literatury przedmiotu podejmującej kwestię moty-
wów korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez przedsiębiorstwa. W artykule przedstawiono również wyniki
własnych badań ankietowych zrealizowanych na próbie mikroprzedsiębiorstw z województwa lubelskiego. Metodologia badania – W artykule dokonano przeglądu literatury przedmiotu podejmującej kwestię moty-
wów korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez przedsiębiorstwa. W artykule przedstawiono również wyniki
własnych badań ankietowych zrealizowanych na próbie mikroprzedsiębiorstw z województwa lubelskiego. Wynik – Przeprowadzone badanie własne potwierdza złożony charakter motywów korzystania z kredytu Wynik – Przeprowadzone badanie własne potwierdza złożony charakter motywów korzystania z kredytu
kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa. Czynnikami najsilniej wpływającymi na korzystanie z kredytu
kupieckiego przez badanych były: możliwość lepszego zarządzania środkami pieniężnymi w przedsiębior-
stwie, możliwość dokonywania zakupów pomimo tymczasowego braku środków pieniężnych oraz szybkość
i łatwość pozyskania.i Oryginalność/wartość – Autorka identyfikuje i ocenia znaczenie powodów korzystania z kredytu kupieckie-
go przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa. W polskiej literaturze przedmiotu dostrzega się niedostatek prac koncen-
trujących się na powyższym problemie. Słowa kluczowe: kredyt kupiecki, mikroprzedsiębiorstwo, źródło finansowania Wprowadzenie W literaturze przedmiotu spotkać można różne spojrzenia na kredyt kupiecki. Przykłado-
wo, M.I. Nadiri (1969, s. 409) podkreśla analogię kredytu kupieckiego do reklamy. R. Pike
i N. Cheng (2002, s. 3) zwracają uwagę, że kredyt kupiecki może być postrzegany jako
kontraktowe rozwiązanie dla problemów informacyjnych związanych z jakością produktu
oraz wiarygodnością kredytową nabywcy. Z kolei B. Summers i N. Wilson (2003, s. 439)
zauważają, że kredytowanie nabywców może być wykorzystane jako złożone narzędzie
marketingowe/zarządzania relacjami i/lub jako sposób przesyłania informacji na rynek lub
do poszczególnych odbiorców na temat firmy, jej produktów, kondycji finansowej czy przy-
szłych perspektyw/zaangażowania w branżę. Różne ujęcia kredytu kupieckiego, akcentujące korzyści z tytułu jego funkcjonowania
w przedsiębiorstwie, dowodzą, że u podstaw udzielania i korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego
leży wiele czynników. Odnosząc się do powyższej kwestii, w artykule skoncentrowano się
na perspektywie biorcy kredytu kupieckiego. 560 Katarzyna Ziętek-Kwaśniewska Poznanie motywów korzystania przez przedsiębiorstwa z odroczonych terminów płat-
ności jest istotne, bowiem o ile rozwiązanie to generuje dla nabywcy wiele pozytywnych
efektów, to równocześnie niesie ze sobą określone koszty, jak i inne negatywne pozakosz-
towe skutki (szerzej w: Kreczmańska-Gigol 2013, s. 93). W szczególności zauważa się, że
korzystanie z kredytu kupieckiego, choć często postrzegane jako bezpłatne, w rzeczywi-
stości może wiązać się z kosztem przewyższającym koszt kredytu bankowego (Bień 2011,
s. 169). Ponadto, ze względu na fakt, że przedsiębiorstwom nierzadko zdarza się regulować
zobowiązania po wyznaczonym terminie, ważną kwestią są także negatywne następstwa
własnej nierzetelności płatniczej, odczuwalne zarówno w wymiarze finansowym (np. kosz-
ty odsetek z tytułu opóźnienia w zapłacie), jak i pozafinansowym (np. utrata zaufania ze
strony kontrahentów, pogorszenie wizerunku przedsiębiorstwa). Potrzeba zwrócenia uwagi na czynniki motywujące przedsiębiorstwa do korzystania
z odroczonych terminów płatności podyktowana jest również skalą jego stosowania w dzia-
łalności przedsiębiorstw. Zgodnie z danymi GUS1, na koniec 2014 roku zobowiązania z ty-
tułu dostaw i usług stanowiły 12,5% pasywów ogółem przedsiębiorstw w Polsce oraz 25,0%
zobowiązań i rezerw na zobowiązania ogółem. Z analizy struktury zobowiązań krótkoter-
minowych wynika, że prawie co drugi ich złoty był udziałem zobowiązań z tytułu dostaw
i usług (48,3%)2. Celem artykułu jest identyfikacja i ocena znaczenia czynników stanowiących o korzy-
staniu z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa. Choć najmniejsze podmioty
stanowią dominującą grupę w strukturze przedsiębiorstw, rozmiar sektora mikroprzedsię-
biorstw oraz jego heterogeniczność sprawiają, że grupa podmiotów mikro jest wciąż nie-
dostatecznie poznana. Dotyczy to również sfery korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego. Arty-
kuł składa się z pięciu części. 1 Dane zawarte w publikacji Bilansowe wyniki finansowe podmiotów gospodarczych w 2014 r. dotyczą jedno-
stek o liczbie pracujących równej co najmniej 10 osób, prowadzących księgi rachunkowe lub podatkową księgę
przychodów i rozchodów. Powyższe dane nie obejmują podmiotów prowadzących działalność bankową, maklerską,
ubezpieczeniową oraz towarzystw inwestycyjnych i emerytalnych, szkół wyższych, gospodarstw indywidualnych
w rolnictwie, a także samodzielnych publicznych zakładów opieki zdrowotnej i instytucji kultury posiadających
osobowość prawną.i 3 Zaprezentowane wyniki stanowią element szerszego badania poświęconego płatnościom mikroprzedsię-
biorstw z tytułu kredytu kupieckiego. Jego wyniki autorka zawarła w rozprawie doktorskiej pt. Płatności mikro-
przedsiębiorstw z tytułu kredytu kupieckiego. p
ą
2 Obliczenia własne na podstawie: Bilansowe wyniki finansowe… (2015), s. 91. Wprowadzenie Po wprowadzeniu w jego tematykę wskazano źródła danych
oraz zastosowane metody badawcze. W dalszej kolejności – na podstawie studiów literatury
przedmiotu – omówiono czynniki motywujące przedsiębiorstwa do korzystania z odroczo-
nych terminów płatności w transakcjach z dostawcami. Następnie zaprezentowano wyniki
badania ankietowego, przeprowadzonego na próbie mikroprzedsiębiorstw z województwa
lubelskiego, w zakresie motywów korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego3. W uwagach końco-
wych zawarto główne wnioski płynące z przeprowadzonych badań. 561 Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa 1. Źródła danych i metody badawcze Do realizacji celu artykułu wykorzystano studia krajowej i zagranicznej literatury przed-
miotu podejmującej kwestię motywów korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez przed-
siębiorstwa. W artykule odwołano się również do wyników własnych badań ankietowych
przeprowadzonych na próbie mikroprzedsiębiorstw z województwa lubelskiego. Badanie
zrealizowane zostało w okresie od grudnia 2014 roku do kwietnia 2015 roku. W wyniku
przeprowadzonych badań zgromadzono 81 wypełnionych kwestionariuszy ankiety. Więk-
szość badanych mikroprzedsiębiorstw stanowiły podmioty najmniejsze, o liczbie zatrud-
nionych do 5 osób (76,5%). Pod względem formy prawnej dominowała działalność osób
fizycznych (75,3%). Ze względu na przeważający rodzaj prowadzonej działalności najsilniej
reprezentowane były sekcje: handel hurtowy i detaliczny; naprawa pojazdów samochodo-
wych, włączając motocykle (24,7%), pozostała działalność usługowa (23,5%) oraz budow-
nictwo (14,8%). Biorąc pod uwagę płeć respondentów, w badanej grupie przeważali męż-
czyźni (2/3 mężczyzn wobec 1/3 kobiet). 2. Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego w działalności przedsiębiorstw
– przegląd literatury Kwerenda literatury przedmiotu poświęconej zagadnieniom kredytu kupieckiego przeko-
nuje, że jego funkcjonowanie w przedsiębiorstwie jest wypadkową różnych motywacji znaj-
dujących się tak po stronie dostawcy – udzielającego kredytu kupieckiego, jak i po stronie
nabywcy – jego biorcy. Przyjmując perspektywę podmiotu korzystającego z odroczonych terminów płatno-
ści, istotne znaczenie przypisuje się motywowi finansowemu. Zauważa się, że głównym
powodem korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego jest przezwyciężanie ograniczeń finanso-
wych (Huyghebaert 2006, s. 306). Podmioty mające trudności z pozyskaniem środków
z zewnętrznych źródeł (np. pozyskaniem kredytu bankowego) mogą wykorzystać kredyt
kupiecki w charakterze ich substytutu. Zainteresowanie przedsiębiorstw kredytowaniem
swoich klientów można przy tym tłumaczyć przewagą kosztową dostawców nad instytucja-
mi finansowymi w oferowaniu kredytu, na co zwrócili uwagę M.A. Petersen i R.G. Rajan
(1997, s. 663–664). Zauważyli oni, że dostawcy mają przewagę nad instytucjami finan-
sowymi w zakresie pozyskiwania informacji, kontrolowania nabywców oraz możliwości
odzyskania wierzytelności. Przedsiębiorstwo korzystające z kredytu kupieckiego podejmuje decyzję finansową,
która dotyczy powstania zobowiązań z tytułu dostaw i usług w strukturze źródeł finanso-
wania (Zawadzka 2009, s. 14). O atrakcyjności kredytu kupieckiego jako źródła finansowa-
nia działalności stanowią pozytywne efekty, jakie jego wykorzystanie wywołuje w przed-
siębiorstwie nabywcy (szerzej w: Kreczmańska-Gigol 2013, s. 93). Atrakcyjność kredytu
kupieckiego określają również pewne charakterystyki związane z formalno-organizacyjną 562 Katarzyna Ziętek-Kwaśniewska sferą jego pozyskania. W tym zakresie uwagę zwraca to, że kredyt kupiecki jest spontanicz-
nym źródłem finansowania, generowanym w trakcie przeprowadzania zwykłych transakcji
handlowych (Ehrhardt, Brigham 2008, s. 565). W porównaniu z innymi źródłami finanso-
wania kredyt kupiecki zajmuje wysoką pozycję ze względu na takie kryteria, jak: szybkość
zaciągania, łatwość zmiany wielkości zadłużenia, możliwość wydłużenia terminu spłaty,
zakres kontroli przedsiębiorstwa ze strony wierzycieli (Kubiak 2005, s. 66). Jest to też źró-
dło, które ze względu na kryterium dostępności jest oceniane jako najbardziej atrakcyjne
spośród źródeł krótkoterminowego finansowania przedsiębiorstw (Kubiak 2005, s. 64). Ważnym motywem korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego, obok motywu finansowego, jest
również motyw transakcyjny4, nawiązujący do korzyści w obszarze zarządzania gotówką. Jak zauważył R.A. Schwartz (1974, s. 643), nabywca może odnosić korzyść z tytułu aku-
mulacji płatności i ich okresowego regulowania. Nadto, kredyt kupiecki umożliwia przed-
siębiorstwu zaplanowanie płatności w sytuacji nieoczekiwanych zakupów, sprawia, że na-
bywca z większą pewnością może przewidzieć przyszłe wydatki oraz ułatwia zarządzanie
gotówką (Schwartz 1974, s. 643). 4 Motyw finansowy i motyw transakcyjny kredytu kupieckiego wyróżnił R.A. Schwartz (1974). Motywem
transakcyjnym wykorzystania kredytu kupieckiego zajmował się np. J.S. Ferris (1981). 2. Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego w działalności przedsiębiorstw
– przegląd literatury W wymiarze transakcyjnym zwraca się uwagę, że kredyt
kupiecki pozwala na zmniejszenie ostrożnościowych zasobów środków pieniężnych oraz
umożliwia zaplanowanie zamiany płynnych aktywów na gotówkę w najbardziej opłacalny
sposób (Summers, Wilson 2002, s. 259). Modelowe ujęcie popytu na kredyt handlowy zaprezentowali między innymi E.M. Chant
i D.A. Walker (1988) czy G.E. Ellienhausen i J.D. Wolken (1993). Ci ostatni, na podsta-
wie przeprowadzonych badań, stwierdzili, że zarówno motywy finansowe, jak i motywy
transakcyjne wyjaśniają wykorzystanie kredytu kupieckiego przez małe przedsiębiorstwa
(Ellienhausen, Wolken 1993, s. 16). Na gruncie polskim próbę identyfikacji i oceny czynni-
ków determinujących popyt na kredyt handlowy w grupie małych przedsiębiorstw podjęła
D. Zawadzka (2009). W wyniku zrealizowanych badań sformułowała ona wniosek, że mo-
tywy transakcyjne w większym stopniu niż motywy finansowe wpływają na prawdopo-
dobieństwo skorzystania z kredytu kupieckiego oraz na poziom jego wykorzystania przez
małe przedsiębiorstwa (Zawadzka 2009, s. 259). Wśród czynników determinujących korzystanie z kredytu kupieckiego wymienia się
również motyw weryfikacji jakości produktu, określany też jako motyw gwarancyjny (zob. Zawadzka 2009, s. 19; Kreczmańska-Gigol 2013, s. 89). W sytuacji asymetrii informacyjnej
co do jakości oferowanych przez dostawcę dóbr i usług kupujący może być zmotywowany
do skorzystania z kredytu kupieckiego, dającego mu możliwość sprawdzenia jakości dosta-
wy przed uregulowaniem zobowiązania. Zgodnie z tym ujęciem kredyt kupiecki stanowi
więc gwarancję jakości nabywanych produktów, towarów lub usług (Kreczmańska-Gigol
2013, s. 89). Oferuje zatem ochronę przed nadmiernym przenoszeniem na nabywcę ryzyka
związanego z produktem (Zawadzka 2009, s. 19). W literaturze przedmiotu do motywu 563 Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa weryfikacji jakości produktu nawiązali między innymi Y.W. Lee i J.D. Stowe (1993) czy
M.S. Long, I.B. Malitz i S.A. Ravid (1993). Wymienianym w literaturze motywem korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego jest tak-
że motyw związany z korzyściami finansowymi nabywcy. Jak zauważyli B. Summers
i N. Wilson (2002, s. 259–260), przedsiębiorstwo otrzymujące odroczony termin płatności
może – w okresie między dostawą zakupionych dóbr a dokonaniem zapłaty – zainwesto-
wać pozostawione w przedsiębiorstwie środki. Ponadto korzyścią nabywcy jest uniknięcie
kosztów finansowych związanych z zadłużeniem się. B. Summers i N. Wilson (2002, s. 260)
wskazali również, że popyt na kredyt handlowy może być związany z czynnikami o cha-
rakterze operacyjnym. W tym zakresie zauważyli oni, że długość cyklu produkcyjnego oraz
poziom utrzymywanych zapasów mogą wpływać na zapotrzebowanie przedsiębiorstwa na
kredyt kupiecki. 5 W skali od 1 do 5, gdzie 1 – „nie ma znaczenia”, a 5 – „bardzo duże znaczenie”. 3. Motywy korzystania z odroczonych terminów płatności
przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa – wyniki badań W badanej grupie 79,0% respondentów przyznało, że – z różną częstotliwością – korzysta
z odroczonych terminów płatności w transakcjach z dostawcami. Dążąc do odpowiedzi na
pytanie o to, jakie czynniki motywują badanych do sięgania po kredyt kupiecki, ankietowa-
nych poproszono o ocenę w 5-stopniowej skali5 znaczenia poszczególnych powodów korzy-
stania z odroczonych terminów zapłaty w transakcjach z dostawcami. Rozkład odpowiedzi
respondentów deklarujących korzystanie z kredytu kupieckiego (w %) oraz znaczenie po-
szczególnych powodów, ustalone na podstawie średniej z przyznanych ocen, przedstawiono
w tabeli 1. Analiza odpowiedzi respondentów pozwala stwierdzić, że badani kierują się różnymi
motywami, podejmując decyzję o korzystaniu z odroczonych terminów płatności. Czyn-
nikiem wysoko cenionym przez biorców kredytu kupieckiego, którego znaczenie uznało
95,2% z nich, okazała się możliwość lepszego zarządzania środkami pieniężnymi w przed-
siębiorstwie. Przeszło 70,0% sięgających po kredyt kupiecki przypisało mu duże lub bardzo
duże znacznie. Oznacza to, że korzystanie z kredytu kupieckiego przez badane mikroprzed-
siębiorstwa w znacznym stopniu powodowane było motywem transakcyjnym. Czynnikiem mającym szczególne znaczenie dla biorców kredytu kupieckiego okazała
się być również możliwość dokonywania zakupów pomimo tymczasowego braku środków
pieniężnych, a zatem czynnik nawiązujący do aspektu finansowego korzystania z kredytu
kupieckiego. Znaczenie tego czynnika uznało 93,5% biorców kredytu kupieckiego, a blisko
70,0% z nich przypisało mu co najmniej duże znaczenie. Deklaracje respondentów suge-
rują więc, że dla badanych mikroprzedsiębiorstw istotną wartością kredytu kupieckiego 564 Katarzyna Ziętek-Kwaśniewska jest zapewnienie ciągłości działania przedsiębiorstwa poprzez umożliwienie dokonywania
zakupów w sytuacji czasowego niedoboru środków. jest zapewnienie ciągłości działania przedsiębiorstwa poprzez umożliwienie dokonywania
zakupów w sytuacji czasowego niedoboru środków. Tabela 1
Znaczenie powodów korzystania z odroczonych terminów płatności dla badanych
mikroprzedsiębiorstw (%)
Powód
Bardzo
duże
znaczenie
Duże
znaczenie
Średnie
znaczenie
Małe
znaczenie
Nie ma
znaczenia
Znaczenie
powodu
Możliwość lepszego zarządzania
środkami pieniężnymi w przed-
siębiorstwie
30,6
40,3
17,7
6,5
4,8
3,85
Możliwość dokonywania zakupów
pomimo tymczasowego braku
środków pieniężnych
32,3
37,1
19,4
4,8
6,5
3,84
Szybkość i łatwość pozyskania (bez
skomplikowanych procedur)
24,2
46,8
19,4
6,5
3,2
3,82
Elastyczna forma finansowania
działalności
22,6
45,2
17,7
11,3
3,2
3,73
Niski koszt finansowania działalno-
ści firmy
26,2
32,8
19,7
14,8
6,6
3,57
Duża dostępność
14,5
37,1
35,5
8,1
4,8
3,48
Możliwość budowania wiarygod-
ności finansowej firmy jako
rzetelnego płatnika
17,2
32,8
26,6
12,5
10,9
3,33
Trudności w dostępie do innych
form finansowania działalności
(np. 6 Dla przykładu, według danych Barometru płatności na świecie 2015, w Polsce na koniec 2014 roku jedynie
44,3% faktur było płaconych w terminie (Barometr płatności… 2015, s. 5). Zgodnie z danymi Raportu BIG. Indeks
zatorów płatniczych BIG z listopada 2015 roku prawie połowa badanych przedsiębiorstw miała problem z termino-
wym odzyskiwaniem należności od swoich kontrahentów (Raport BIG… 2015, s. 3). Z kolei, jak wynika z badania
Portfel należności polskich przedsiębiorstw przeprowadzonego w styczniu 2016 roku, 80,5% badanych firm przy-
znało, że występuje u nich problem z regulowaniem zobowiązań przez klientów/kontrahentów (Białowolski 2016,
s. 4). 3. Motywy korzystania z odroczonych terminów płatności
przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa – wyniki badań kredytu bankowego)
16,1
24,2
27,4
19,4
12,9
3,11
Możliwość sprawdzenia jakości
towaru/usługi przed dokonaniem
płatności
11,3
21,0
27,4
21,0
19,4
2,84
Źródło: opracowanie własne na podstawie wyników badań autorki. Znaczenie powodów korzystania z odroczonych terminów płatności dla badanych
mikroprzedsiębiorstw (%) Deklaracje ankietowanych pozwalają stwierdzić, że duże znaczenie dla zainteresowania
mikroprzedsiębiorstw korzystaniem z kredytu kupieckiego mają jego walory o charakte-
rze formalno-organizacyjnym. Dla prawie 97,0% korzystających z odroczonych terminów
płatności istotnym powodem sięgania po kredyt kupiecki była szybkość i łatwość jego po-
zyskania (brak konieczności przechodzenia przez skomplikowane procedury), przy czym
dla 71,0% z nich czynnik ten miał co najmniej duże znaczenie. Zdecydowana większość
korzystających z odroczonych terminów płatności jako znaczącą uznała również elastycz-
ność kredytu kupieckiego jako formy finansowania działalności przedsiębiorstwa (96,8%
uznających znaczenie czynnika, przy czym 67,8% przypisujących mu duże lub bardzo duże
znaczenie). W omawianym obszarze ankietowani jako powód korzystania z kredytu ku-
pieckiego dość wysoko oceniali też jego dużą dostępność, która okazała się być istotna dla
95,2% korzystających z odroczonych terminów płatności, a dla przeszło co drugiego z nich
miała co najmniej duże znaczenie. 565 Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa Dla 93,4% korzystających z odroczonych terminów płatności czynnikiem motywują-
cym do korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego okazał się być niski koszt finansowania dzia-
łalności firmy. Na jego duże lub bardzo duże znaczenie wskazało 59,0% biorców kredytu
kupieckiego. Choć w literaturze przedmiotu podkreśla się, że kredyt kupiecki może wiązać
się z kosztem przewyższającym koszt kredytu bankowego, możliwym wyjaśnieniem znacz-
nego odsetka wskazań dla czynnika „niski koszt finansowania działalności firmy” jest to,
że większość badanych nie spotykała się z ofertą skonta za wcześniejszą płatność. Na uwagę zasługują odpowiedzi respondentów w odniesieniu do powodu „możliwość
budowania wiarygodności finansowej firmy jako rzetelnego płatnika”. Choć czynnik ten
nie znalazł się wśród czołowych determinant korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego, to jego
znaczenie uznało dziewięciu na dziesięciu korzystających z odroczonych terminów płat-
ności, przy czym co drugi z nich przypisał mu co najmniej duże znaczenie. Odpowiedzi
respondentów wskazują więc, że znaczna część z nich dostrzega w możliwości korzystania
z kredytu kupieckiego sposobność kreowania wizerunku firmy rzetelnie wywiązującej się
ze swoich zobowiązań. Tym samym deklaracje ankietowanych potwierdzają, że kredyt ku-
piecki może stanowić nośnik informacji o przedsiębiorstwie, sygnał potwierdzający jego
wiarygodność płatniczą. Białowolski P. (2016), Portfel należności polskich przedsiębiorstw. Styczeń 2016. Informacja sygnalna. Projekt
badawczy Konferencji Przedsiębiorstw Finansowych w Polsce oraz Krajowego Rejestru Długów. Pobrano z:
http://krd.pl/Centrum-prasowe/Raporty/2016/PORTFEL-NALEZNOSCI-POLSKICH-PRZEDSIEBIORSTW-
--STYCZEN-2016 (2.04.2016).ii Uwagi końcowe Analiza literatury przedmiotu przekonuje, że funkcjonowanie kredytu kupieckiego
w przedsiębiorstwie jest wynikiem oddziaływania różnych czynników po stronie dostawcy
i odbiorcy, które nie muszą mieć charakteru wzajemnie wykluczającego, lecz mogą współ-
występować, tworząc wiązkę motywów. Artykuł zorientowany był na identyfikację i ocenę znaczenia czynników stanowiących
o korzystaniu z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa. W wyniku przeprowa-
dzonego badania własnego ustalono, że walorami kredytu kupieckiego najsilniej motywu-
jącymi badane mikroprzedsiębiorstwa do jego wykorzystania były: możliwość lepszego
zarządzania środkami pieniężnymi w przedsiębiorstwie, możliwość dokonywania zakupów
pomimo tymczasowego braku środków pieniężnych oraz szybkość i łatwość pozyskania. Ankietowani dość wysoko oceniali również znaczenie takich charakterystyk kredytu ku-
pieckiego, jak: elastyczność, duża dostępność oraz niski koszt finansowania. Czynnikiem
zamykającym hierarchię motywów korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego była możliwość
sprawdzenia jakości towaru/usługi przed dokonaniem płatności. Przeprowadzone badanie eksponuje złożoność motywacji leżących u podstaw korzysta-
nia z odroczonych terminów płatności przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa, nawiązujących zarów-
no do aspektu finansowego, jak i transakcyjnego. Niewątpliwie tym, co skłania podmioty
do korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego w transakcjach z dostawcami, jest jego atrakcyjność
w obszarze formalno-organizacyjnym. Barometr płatności na świecie 2015 (2015). Bisnode D&B Polska. Pobrano z: http://www.bisnode.pl/blog/wp-con-
tent/uploads/2015/05/Bisnode-Polska-Barometr-p%C5%82atno%C5%9Bci-na-%C5%9Bwiecie_Europa.pdf
(20.03.2016). 3. Motywy korzystania z odroczonych terminów płatności
przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa – wyniki badań Powyższa kwestia jest tym bardziej interesująca, że, jak wynika
z wielu badań, nierzadkim zjawiskiem, skutkującym szeregiem negatywnych następstw,
jest dokonywanie przez przedsiębiorstwa opóźnionych płatności za dostarczone dobra/wy-
konane usługi (dokonywanie zapłaty po wyznaczonym terminie płatności)6, które niewąt-
pliwie nie służy budowaniu wiarygodności płatniczej podmiotu. Ze względu na fakt, że w literaturze przedmiotu zwraca się uwagę na ograniczone moż-
liwości mniejszych podmiotów w zakresie pozyskiwania środków z zewnętrznych źródeł,
wśród czynników motywujących do korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego uwzględniono rów-
nież trudności w dostępie do alternatywnych form finansowania działalności. Jak wynika
z odpowiedzi badanych, powyższy czynnik nie stanowił jednak wiodącej determinanty
korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego. Jego znaczenie uznało 87,1% mikroprzedsiębiorstw się-
gających po odroczone terminy płatności, a 40,3% z nich wskazało na jego duże lub bardzo
duże znaczenie. Najmniejsze znaczenie jako czynnikowi wpływającemu na korzystanie z odroczonych
terminów płatności badani przypisali możliwości sprawdzenia jakości towaru/usługi przed
dokonaniem płatności. Dla co piątego korzystającego z kredytu kupieckiego czynnik ten
nie miał żadnego znaczenia. Co trzeci z nich uznał jego duże lub bardzo duże znaczenie. 566 Katarzyna Ziętek-Kwaśniewska Motyw weryfikacji jakości produktu nie był więc tak istotną determinantą sięgania po kre-
dyt kupiecki, jak wyróżnione wcześniej czynniki. Motyw weryfikacji jakości produktu nie był więc tak istotną determinantą sięgania po kre-
dyt kupiecki, jak wyróżnione wcześniej czynniki. (
)
pp
Ehrhardt M.C., Brigham E.F. (2008). Corporate Finance: A Focused Approach. Third Edition. Mason: South-We-
stern Cengage Learning. Bilansowe wyniki finansowe podmiotów gospodarczych w 2014 r. (2015). Warszawa: Główny Urząd Statystyczny.
Chant E.M., Walker D.A. (1988). Small Business Demand for Trade Credit. Applied Economics, 20, 861–876. Elliehausen G.E., Wolken J.D. (1993). The Demand for Trade Credit: An Investigation of Motives for Trade Credit
Use by Small Business. Washington: Board of Governors of Federal Reserve System. (
)
y
Q
y
f
( )
Huyghebaert N. (2006). On the Determinants and Dynamics of Trade Credit Use: Empirical Evidence from Business
Start-ups. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 33 (1/2), 305–328. Motives For Trade Credit Use By Micro-Enterprises bstract: Purpose – The aim of this article is to identify and assess the importance of factors that determi
he use of trade credit by micro-enterprises. the use of trade credit by micro-enterprises. Design/methodology/approach – The article reviews the literature regarding the motives for trade credit
use by enterprises. The article also presents the results of the author’s own survey conducted among micro-
enterprises from the Lubelskie Province.i Findings – The author’s own survey confirms the complexity of motives underlying the use of trade credit by
micro-enterprises. The most important factors influencing the use of trade credit by respondents were: the
ability to better cash management, the ability to make purchases despite a temporary lack of cash, the speed
and ease of obtaining trade credit. Originality/value – The author identifies and evaluates the motives for trade credit use by micro-enterpris-
es. In the Polish literature there is a lack of works focusing on the above problem. Keywords: trade credit; micro-enterprise; source of finance Literatura The Determinants of Trade Credit in the U.S. Total Manufacturing Sector. Econometrica, 37 (3),
408–423. Petersen M.A., Rajan R.G. (1997). Trade Credit: Theories and Evidence. The Review of Financial Studies, 10 (3),
661–691. Pike R., Cheng N. (2002). Trade Credit, Late Payment and Asymmetric Information. Working Paper, 02/09. Pobrano
z: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.200.5264&rep=rep1&type=pdf (15.03.2016). y
rt BIG. Indeks zatorów płatniczych BIG. 29. edycja. Listopad 2015 (2015). BIG InfoMonitor SA. Pobrano Raport BIG. Indeks zatorów płatniczych BIG. 29. edycja. Listopad 2015 (2015). BIG InfoMonitor SA. P
https://www big pl/download/raporty/2015 11 raportbig pdf (2 04 2016) Raport BIG. Indeks zatorów płatniczych BIG. 29. edycja. Listopad 2015 (2015). BIG InfoMoni
https://www.big.pl/download/raporty/2015_11_raportbig.pdf (2.04.2016). t BIG. Indeks zatorów płatniczych BIG. 29. edycja. Listopad 2015 (2015). BIG InfoMonitor SA. Pobrano
ttps://www.big.pl/download/raporty/2015_11_raportbig.pdf (2.04.2016). Schwartz R.A. (1974). An Economic Model of Trade Credit. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 9 (4),
643–657. Summers B., Wilson N. (2002). An Empirical Investigation of Trade Credit Demand. International Journal of the
Economics of Business, 9 (2), 257–270. Summers B., Wilson N. (2003). Trade Credit and Customer Relationship. Managerial and Decision Economics, 24,
439–455.i Zawadzka D. (2009). Determinanty popytu małych przedsiębiorstw na kredyt handlowy. Identyfikacja i ocena. Po-
znań: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego w Poznaniu. Literatura Barometr płatności na świecie 2015 (2015). Bisnode D&B Polska. Pobrano z: http://www.bisnode.pl/blog/wp-con-
tent/uploads/2015/05/Bisnode-Polska-Barometr-p%C5%82atno%C5%9Bci-na-%C5%9Bwiecie_Europa.pdf
(20.03.2016). Białowolski P. (2016), Portfel należności polskich przedsiębiorstw. Styczeń 2016. Informacja sygnalna. Projekt
badawczy Konferencji Przedsiębiorstw Finansowych w Polsce oraz Krajowego Rejestru Długów. Pobrano z:
http://krd.pl/Centrum-prasowe/Raporty/2016/PORTFEL-NALEZNOSCI-POLSKICH-PRZEDSIEBIORSTW-
--STYCZEN-2016 (2.04.2016).ii Bień W. (2011). Zarządzanie finansami przedsiębiorstwa. Warszawa: Difin.i Bilansowe wyniki finansowe podmiotów gospodarczych w 2014 r. (2015). Warszawa: Główny Urząd Statystyczny. Chant E M Walker D A (1988) Small Business Demand for Trade Credit Applied Economics 20 861–876 (
)
pp
Ehrhardt M.C., Brigham E.F. (2008). Corporate Finance: A Focused Approach. Third Edition. Mason: South-We-
stern Cengage Learning. en G.E., Wolken J.D. (1993). The Demand for Trade Credit: An Investigation of Motives for Trade Credit
by Small Business. Washington: Board of Governors of Federal Reserve System. ,
(
)
f
g
f
f
Use by Small Business. Washington: Board of Governors of Federal Reserve System. y
g
y
(1981). A Transactions Theory of Trade Credit Use. The Quarterly Journal of Economic, 96 (2), 243–270. N (2006) O
h D
i
d D
i
f T d C di U
E
i i
l E id
f
B
i Ferris J.S. (1981). A Transactions Theory of Trade Credit Use. The Quarterly Journal of Economic, 96 (2), 243–270. Huyghebaert N. (2006). On the Determinants and Dynamics of Trade Credit Use: Empirical Evidence from Business
Start-ups. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 33 (1/2), 305–328. Ferris J.S. (1981). A Transactions Theory of Trade Credit Use. The Quarterly Journal of Economic, 96 (2), 243 270. Huyghebaert N. (2006). On the Determinants and Dynamics of Trade Credit Use: Empirical Evidence from Business
S
J
l f B
F
& A
33 (1/2) 305 328 Huyghebaert N. (2006). On the Determinants and Dynamics of Trade Credit Use: Empirical Evidence from Business
Start-ups. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 33 (1/2), 305–328. 567 Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa Kreczmańska-Gigol K. (2013). Faktoring jako jeden z instrumentów zarządzania należnościami i zobowi
handlowymi a struktura kapitału. Warszawa: Difin.i y
pi
ubiak J. (2005). Hierarchia źródeł krótkoterminowego finansowania przedsiębiorstwa. Poznań: Wydawn
Akademii Ekonomicznej w Poznaniu. Lee Y.W., Stowe J.D. (1993). Product Risk, Asymmetric Information, and Trade Credit. Journal of Financial and
Quantitative Analysis, 28 (2), 285–300. Q
y
( )
Long M.S., Malitz I.B., Ravid S.A. (1993). Trade Credit, Quality Guarantees, and Product Marketability. Financial
Management, 22 (4), 117–127. Nadiri M.I. (1969). Ziętek-Kwaśniewska K. (2016). Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa. Finanse,
Rynki Finansowe, Ubezpieczenia, 4 (82/1), 559–567. DOI: 10.18276/frfu.2016.4.82/1-46. Cytowanie Ziętek-Kwaśniewska K. (2016). Motywy korzystania z kredytu kupieckiego przez mikroprzedsiębiorstwa. Finanse,
Rynki Finansowe, Ubezpieczenia, 4 (82/1), 559–567. DOI: 10.18276/frfu.2016.4.82/1-46.
|
https://openalex.org/W4362464156
|
https://zenodo.org/records/7793422/files/43147.pdf
|
Polish
| null |
Effective motor learning and coordination abilities of girls and boys aged 9-10
|
Journal of Education, Health and Sport
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 9,315
|
Introduction Learning is a complex and multi-dimensional process that depends on cognitive and emotional processes and the
development of functional systems of the human body. One type of learning is motor learning. Its course and effects
depend on many factors. One of the factors may be coordination abilities. p
The cognitive aim of the study is to assessment of the effectiveness (speed, efficiency) of learning complex motor
activity in relation to the selected aspect of physical development (coordination abilities) of a selected group of girls
and boys. Dawid Matczak orcid 0000-0002-1978-4699, Marta Wieczorek orcid 0000-0003-3933-246X Dawid Matczak orcid 0000-0002-1978-4699, Marta Wieczorek orcid 0000-0003-3933-246X Department of Physical Education and Sports, Calisia University, Poland Department of Methodology of School Physical Culture, Wroclaw University of Health and Sport Sciences, Poland MATCZAK, Dawid & WIECZOREK, Marta. Effective motor learning and coordination abilities of girls and boys aged 9-10. Journal of
Education, Health and Sport. 2023;18(1):49-61. eISSN 2391-8306. DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/JEHS.2023.18.01.006
https://apcz.umk.pl/JEHS/article/view/43147
https://zenodo.org/record/7793422 MATCZAK, Dawid & WIECZOREK, Marta. Effective motor learning and coordination abilities of girls and boys aged 9-10. Journal of
Education, Health and Sport. 2023;18(1):49-61. eISSN 2391-8306. DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/JEHS.2023.18.01.006
https://apcz.umk.pl/JEHS/article/view/43147
https://zenodo.org/record/7793422 MATCZAK, Dawid & WIECZOREK, Marta. Effective motor learning and coordination abilities of girls and boys age
Education, Health and Sport. 2023;18(1):49-61. eISSN 2391-8306. DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/JEHS.2023.18.01.006
https://apcz umk pl/JEHS/article/view/43147 The journal has had 40 points in Ministry of Education and Science of Poland parametric evaluation. Annex to the announcement of the Minister of Education and Science of December 21, 2021. No. 32343. Has a Journal's Unique Identifier: 201159. Scientific disciplines assigned: Physical Culture Sciences (Field of Medical sciences and health sciences); Health Sciences (Field of Medical Sciences and Health Sciences). Punkty Ministerialne z 2019 - aktualny rok 40 punktów. Załącznik do komunikatu Ministra Edukacji i Nauki z dnia 21 grudnia 2021 r. Lp. 32343. Posiada Unikatowy Identyfikator Czasopisma: 201159. Przypisane dyscypliny naukowe: Nauki o kulturze fizycznej (Dziedzina nauk medycznych i nauk o zdrowiu); Nauki o zdrowiu (Dziedzina nauk medycznych i nauk o zdrowiu). © The Authors 2023; ;
This article is published with open access at Licensee Open Journal Systems of Nicolaus Copernicus University in Torun, Poland
Open Access. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided th
original author (s) and source are credited. This is an open access article licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non commercial license Share alike. (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/) which permits unrestricted, non commercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the work is properly cited. The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper. Received: 15.03.2023. Revised: 15.03.2023. Accepted: 02.04.2023. Published: 02.04.2023. Skuteczne uczenie się motoryczne a zdolności koordynacyjne chłopców i dziewcząt w wieku 9-10 lat
Effective motor learning and coordination abilities of girls and boys aged 9-10 © The Authors 2023;
This article is published with open access at Licensee Open Journal Systems of Nicolaus Copernicus University in Torun, Poland
Open Access. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the
original author (s) and source are credited. This is an open access article licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non commercial license Share alike.
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/) which permits unrestricted, non commercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the work is properly cited.
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.
Received: 15.03.2023. Revised: 15.03.2023. Accepted: 02.04.2023. Published: 02.04.2023. Cele pracy: Z powyższych rozważań teoretycznych wynika cel poznawczy przeprowadzonych badań, którym jest ocena
elementów skuteczności uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej (szybkość, efektywność) w odniesieniu do zdolności
koordynacyjnych wybranej grupy dziewcząt i chłopców. Postawiono następujące pytania badawcze: 1. Jaki jest poziom koordynacji oko-ręka (test 2hand) badanych dziewcząt i chłopców ? 2. Jaki jest poziom precyzyjnych ruchów rąk (test MLS) badanych dziewcząt i chłopców? kie zależności występują między precyzyjnymi ruchami rąk badanych dziewcząt i chłopców a
utecznym uczeniem się złożonej czynności ruchowej? 3. Jakie zależności występują między precyzyjnymi ruchami rąk badanych dziewcząt i chł
skutecznym uczeniem się złożonej czynności ruchowej? y
ę
j
y
j
4. Jakie zależności występują między poziomem koordynacji oko-ręka badanych dziewcząt i chłopców a
skutecznym uczeniem się złożonej czynności ruchowej? 4. Jakie zależności występują między poziomem koordynacji oko-ręka badanych dziewcząt i chłopców a
skutecznym uczeniem się złożonej czynności ruchowej? Materiał i metody Badania realizowane były w Szkole Podstawowej w Koźminku w województwie Wielkopolskim. Grupę badaną
stanowiło 73 uczniów (44 chłopców i 29 dziewcząt) w wieku 9 – 10 lat (byli to wszyscy uczniowie tej szkoły, którzy
uczęszczali do klas IV). Ta grupa wiekowa nazywana jest ,,złotym wiekiem dziecka”. Ten okres życia sprzyja
rozwojowi wszystkich zdolności motorycznych, w szczególności zdolności koordynacyjnych (Osiński 2003, Ignasiak
2013, Raczek 2010). )
Do badań nad szybkością, efektywnością i trwałością uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej wykorzystano
metodę eksperymentu pedagogicznego w warunkach naturalnych. Zastosowano technikę jednej grupy. Wybraną
złożoną czynnością ruchową było żonglowanie trzema piłeczkami tenisowymi. Żonglowanie piłeczkami tenisowymi
jest czynnością złożoną koordynacyjnie a jednocześnie dostępną do opanowania dla dzieci 9 –10- letnich. Badania
odbywały się w trzech etapach: I etap – sześć lekcji wychowania fizycznego (w czasie trzech tygodni); po trzech
miesiącach II etap – cztery lekcje (w czasie dwóch tygodni); po kolejnych trzech miesiącach III etap – dwie lekcje (w
jednym tygodniu). Przy ocenie szybkości wykorzystano Wskaźnik Szybkości Uczenia się (WSU) opracowany przez Wieczorek
(1999). Wyższa wartość WSU świadczy o szybszym uczeniu się. Efektywność określono na podstawie efektu
(opanowanego kroku) osiągniętego na ostatniej lekcji danego etapu badania. Zgodnie z zastosowaną metodyką uczenia
się żonglowania opanowanie 4. kroku uważane jest za elementarne opanowanie tej złożonej czynności ruchowej
(Wieczorek 1997). Do oceny wybranych zdolności motorycznych wybrano metodę obserwacji bezpośredniej, skategoryzowanej
(Rubacha 2016). Jako narzędzie wykorzystano Testy Wiedeńskiego Systemu Wiedeński system testów zawiera około
90 prób, które pozwalają diagnozować różne aspekty koordynacji motorycznej. Bazują one na koncepcji
motoryczności Fleishmana. Fleishman rozróżnia pojęcie motoryki precyzyjnej i ogólnej. Materials and methods The study was conducted among 73 children (44 boys and 29 girls) aged 9 - 10 years. Authors used the pedagogical
experiment method and the research tool was the program for learning how to juggle three tennis balls. To assess the
selected aspects of physical development we chose the direct categorized observation method. As research tools
Authors used the Vienna Test System (VTS) and 2hand test. R
lt Boys achieved a higher average level of eye-hand coordination (2-hand test), but the differences between them and
girls were not statistically significant. Girls achieved, on average, higher results than boys in terms of precise hand
movements (MLS test). Statistically significant differences in their favor occurred in most of the tests performed. Conclusion There are functions between the speed and efficiency of learning a complex motor activity and coordination abilities. They are more pronounced than boys. It is important to develop coordination abilities in the didactic process to
support motor learning. Key words: coordination, learning, Vienna test system Jednym z rodzajów uczenia się przez człowieka jest uczenie się motoryczne, które to według Raczka (2010, s. 206) rozumiane jest jako ,,wewnętrzne procesy, wynikające z ćwiczenia lub nabytego doświadczenia, które prowadzą
do względnie trwałych zmian w zdolnościach służących rozwojowi umiejętności ruchowych”. Uczenie się motoryczne
jest procesem złożonym i wielowymiarowym, zależnym od procesów poznawczych i emocjonalnych, rozwoju 49 funkcjonalnych układów organizmu człowieka (np. układu wzrokowego, słuchowego, kostno-stawowo-mięśniowego)
jak również fizycznych cech rozwoju uczącego się (np. wysokość, masa ciała, wskaźniki morfologiczne). Czabański
(2000), Osiński (2003), Raczek (2010) podkreślają szczególną rolę zdolności motorycznych w procesie motorycznego
uczenia się. Zdolności motoryczne dzielone są najczęściej na dwie podstawowe grupy (Raczek 1986). Są to zdolności:
kondycyjne (energetyczne) – określone głównie cechami
morfo-strukturalnymi i procesami energetyczno-
metabolicznymi; koordynacyjne (informacyjne) określone głównie psychicznymi i neurosensorycznymi procesami
sterująco-regulacyjnymi i kognitywnymi. Wyróżnia się także (Raczek 1993, Juras i Waśkiewicz 1998, Mynarski 2000,
Waśkiewicz 2002, Raczek i wsp. 2002, Raczek 2010) trzecią grupę, a mianowicie zdolności kompleksowe (hybrydowe)
określone czynnikami energetyczno-metabolicznymi
jak i sterująco-regulacyjnymi, bez wyraźnej dominanty. Przedmiotem zainteresowania niniejszych badań są zdolności koordynacyjne. W dotychczasowych badaniach
eksperymentalnych wielokrotnie udowodniono ścisłą zależność między poziomem zdolności koordynacyjnych a
efektami motorycznego uczenia się (Kubaszczyk 1996, Dybińska 2003a, Barczynski, Zaporozhanov 2011, Biotteau i
wsp 2016). Wysoki poziom zdolności koordynacyjnych to skrócenie czasu uczenia się motorycznego, zwiększenie
stopnia opanowania i bardziej skuteczne wykorzystanie umiejętności ruchowych w zmieniających się warunkach i
sytuacjach (Raczek 2010). Materials and methods y
j
(
)
Wydaje się, że szczególną rolę w procesie uczenia się odgrywa koordynacja oko-ręka. Jak podają badacze,
może ona być związana z dokładnością i szybkością opanowania nowych umiejętności ruchowych, zwłaszcza u dzieci
w wieku szkolnym (Szopa i wsp. 2000, Raczek i wsp. 2002). Raczek (2010) wymienia kryteria, które najczęściej
stosuje się w ocenie skuteczności motorycznego uczenia się. Są to: szybkość (czas potrzebny do wykonania zadania,
skutkujący zmniejszeniem liczby prób); poziom uczenia się (efektywność) (wymiar, który określa stopień wprawy i
wykonania, przypisanie wyników do norm i wzorców); trwałość uczenia się (przechowywanie w pamięci, odporność
na zmęczenie i zakłócenie doświadczeń uczenia się obecnego na uczenie się późniejsze). Cele pracy: Motoryka ogólna według tego
autora wymaga użycia wielu partii mięśni lub całego ciała. Natomiast w motoryce precyzyjnej jako najważniejsze
aspekty wymienia: precyzyjne i szybkie ruchy wykonane w małej przestrzeni, niewymagające użycia dużej siły (za:
Guła-Kubiszewska 2007). Testy Wiedeńskiego Systemu mogą wykonywać wszystkie osoby powyżej 5. roku życia. 50 Testy te charakteryzują się dużą obiektywnością, dzięki korzystaniu z systemów komputerowych, wysoką trafnością
pomiarów oraz rzetelnością (Fugiel 2014). Testy te charakteryzują się dużą obiektywnością, dzięki korzystaniu z systemów komputerowych, wysoką trafnością
pomiarów oraz rzetelnością (Fugiel 2014). Pierwszy wykorzystany test to „2hand”. Służy do określenia szybkości, dokładności i koordynacji ruchów obu
rąk. Pozwala ocenić predyspozycje wyznaczające koordynację wzrokowo-ruchową, która wymaga precyzji ruchów z
równoczesnym wykorzystaniem prawej i lewej kończyny (Fugiel 2014). Przy użyciu joysticków należy przeprowadzić
czerwoną kropkę z punktu A do punktu B po wyznaczonej trasie. Jeden kontroler (joystick) pozwalał poruszać się
horyzontalnie, drugi wertykalnie. W teście są oceniane następujące parametry: Liczba błędów (LB) – suma błędów –
błędem jest każde uderzenie rylcem w ścianę wyznaczonej trasy; Czas błędów (CB) – suma czasu trwania błędów –
całkowity czas przylegania rylca do ściany wyznaczonej trasy;
Czas testu (CT) – czas trwania testu od momentu
rozpoczęcia zadania (Fugiel 2014). Drugi wykorzystany test to MLS (Motor Performance Serie). Służy do oceny określonych subtelnych
(precyzyjnych) sprawności motorycznych kończyn górnych (celowanie, drżenie rąk, stukanie, śledzenie liniowe,
wstawianie długich szpilek). Test MLS wykonuje się osobno prawą i lewą kończyną górną (dla każdej z prób). W
pracy skorzystałem z czterech prób testu MLS (celowanie, drżenie rąk, stukanie, wstawienie długich szpilek), które
wydają się kluczowe dla wykonania złożonej czynności ruchowej, jaką jest żonglowanie trzema piłeczkami. Uczniowie
wykonywali
test
indywidualnie,
w
osobnym
pomieszczeniu
w
celu
skupienia
się
na
wykonywanym zadaniu (w dni w których nie było wychowania fizycznego). Każdą osobę poinformowano o sposobie
wykonywania testu. Wszyscy uczniowie wykonywali również próbę testu, która umożliwiła zapoznanie się ze
specyfiką wykonania. Po zakończeniu próby uczeń przechodził do właściwego wykonania testu. Testy były
wykonywane podczas I etapu badan. Analizę statystyczną wyników przeprowadzono z wykorzystaniem pakietu statystycznego Statistica 13.5 dla
systemu Windows 10. Analiza objęła podstawowe statystyki opisowe [średnią arytmetyczną (M), odchylenie
standardowe (SD), medianę (Me), wskaźnik zmienności (V)] analizowanych zmiennych z uwzględnieniem płci. Podano również wartości maksymalne (max) oraz minimalne (min) zmiennych. Różnice średnich arytmetycznych oraz
wartości współczynników korelacji uznano za istotne statystycznie przy poziomie istotności wynoszącym 5% (p<0,05). Dla oceny różnić międzygrupowych (wyniki MTSF, 2hand, MLS) zastosowano test t-Studenta. Cele pracy: W przypadku
niezgodności z rozkładem normalnym stosowano test U Manna-Whitneya, którego wyniki potwierdzały obserwacje
uzyskane za pomocą testu t-Studenta. Dla wszystkich badanych zmiennych obliczono współczynniki korelacji rang
Spearmana, ponieważ niektóre z analizowanych zmiennych wykazywały asymetrie rozkładów lub miały charakter
rangowy. Współczynnik korelacji rang Spearmana pozwolił na właściwą analizę związków nawet w przypadku
odstających obserwacji. Współczynnik korelacji umożliwił
ustalenie siły związków między badanymi cechami
(wskaźnikami skutecznego uczenia się a wymienionymi wcześniej aspektami rozwoju fizycznego). Wyniki y
Porównanie średnich wyników prób testu 2hand badanych dziewcząt i chłopców nie wykazało występowania
istotnych statystycznie różnic. Jednak to chłopcy potrzebowali mniej czasu na ukończenie testu niż dziewczęta i
popełniali również mniej błędów (tab. 1.). Tabela 1. Porównanie średnich wyników testu koordynacji oko-ręka badanych dziewcząt i chłopców
Wynik
M chłopców
SD
chłopców
M
dziewcząt
SD
dziewcząt
p*
Czas testu (CT) [s]
34,63
31,10
43,97
70,51
0,069
Czas błędu (CB) [s]
7,30
57,89
10,60
115,48
0,103
Procent czasu błędów (CB%)
[%]
21,67
55,77
22,77
52,23
0,702
M – średnia arytmetyczna, SD – odchylenie standardowe, p – poziom istotności różnic, *różnica istotna dla p<0,05 Tabela 1. Porównanie średnich wyników testu koordynacji oko-ręka badanych dziewcząt i chłopców Porównanie średnich wyników testu MLS badanych dziewcząt i chłopców wykazało, że istotna statystyczna
różnica na korzyść dziewcząt występuje w próbach: celowanie (w parametrach: RD – liczba błędów, RP – liczba
błędów, RP – czas błędu, RP – czas całkowity) i drżenie (RD – liczba błędów). Chłopcy osiągnęli istotnie wyższy
wynik w próbie celowanie (RP – liczba trafień). Dziewczęta osiągnęły lepsze wyniki niż chłopcy we wszystkich próbach ręką dominującą. Wyjątek to próba
stukanie. Dziewczęta również osiągnęły lepsze wyniki w próbach ręką przeciwną prócz testu celowanie RP – liczba
trafień. Istotne statystyczne różnice między chłopcami a dziewczynami wystąpiły w próbach: celowanie RD – liczba
błędów, celowanie RP– liczba błędów, celowanie RP – liczba trafień, celowanie RP – czas błędu, celowanie RP – czas
całkowity oraz drżenie RD – liczba błędów (tab. 2.). Dziewczęta osiągnęły lepsze wyniki niż chłopcy we wszystkich próbach ręką dominującą. Wyjątek to próba
stukanie. Dziewczęta również osiągnęły lepsze wyniki w próbach ręką przeciwną prócz testu celowanie RP – liczba
trafień. Istotne statystyczne różnice między chłopcami a dziewczynami wystąpiły w próbach: celowanie RD – liczba
błędów, celowanie RP– liczba błędów, celowanie RP – liczba trafień, celowanie RP – czas błędu, celowanie RP – czas
całkowity oraz drżenie RD – liczba błędów (tab. 2.). 51 2. Cele pracy: Porównanie średnich wyników testu MLS badanych dziewcząt i chłopców. Nazwa
M
dziewcząt
SD
M chłopców
SD
p*
Celowanie RD – liczba błędów
0,862
1,832
1,886 1,432
0,013*
Celowanie RP – liczba błędów
2,689
4,105
5,454 2,965
0,002*
Celowanie RD – liczba trafień
19,931
3,097
19,613 0,752
0,590
Celowanie RP – liczba trafień
17,620
3,345
20,136 7,242
0,048*
Celowanie RD – czas błędu
0,044
0,104
0,082 0,102
0,121
Celowanie RP – czas błędu
0,136
0,307
0,295 0,187
0,015*
Celowanie RD – czas całkowity
11,821
3,010
12,355 2,928
0,455
Celowanie RP – czas całkowity
10,338
4,284
13,365 4,801
0,006*
Drżenie RD – liczba błędów
20,413
19,281
32,636 19,680
0,010*
Drżenie RP – liczba błędów
24,965
19,087
32,227 18,486
0,111
Drżenie RD – czas błędu
4,946
7,925
6,528 6,629
0,376
Drżenie RP – czas błędu
5,540
8,888
7,900 6,874
0,230
Wstawianie RP
55,442
11,973
58,436 7,046
0,229
Wstawianie RD
50,813
11,189
54,294 11,112
0,196
Stukanie RD
168,655
22,765
170,318 17,593
0,740
Stukanie RP
142,344
25,002
137,318 16,720
0,345
RD – ręka dominująca, RP – ręka przeciwna, M – średnia arytmetyczna, p – poziom istotności różnic,
*różnica istotna dla p<0,05 Tabela 2. Porównanie średnich wyników testu MLS badanych dziewcząt i chłopców. Kolejno poszukiwano zależności między szybkością uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej, wyrażonej
WSU, a średnimi wynikami testu koordynacji oko-ręka (2hand). ,
y
y
j
ę
(
)
Między WSU1 a średnimi wynikami testu 2hand istotne korelacje wystąpiły jedynie wśród dziewcząt. Występujące u chłopców korelacje są słabe (tab. 3.). Tabela 3. Zależności między WSU1 a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand
Współczynnik rang Spearmana
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
WSU 1. & 2HANDS – czas błędów
0,064
-0,101
WSU 1. & 2HANDS – czas przejścia
-0,423*
0,162
WSU 1. & 2HANDS – % czas bł. -0,460*
0,215
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05 WSU 1 – wskaźnik szybkości uczenia się na I etapie badań Tabela 3. Zależności między WSU1 a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand Między WSU2 a średnimi wynikami testu 2hand istotne korelacje wystąpiły ponownie
jedynie wśród
dziewcząt. Korelacje
te
są
przeciętne. Występujące
u
chłopców
korelacje
są
słabe
(tab. 4.). Tabela 4. Zależność między WSU2 a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand
Współczynnik rang Spearmana
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
WSU 2. & 2HANDS – czas błędów
-0,369*
-0,136
WSU 2. & 2HANDS – czas przejścia
-0,381*
-0,140
WSU 2. & 2HANDS – % czas bł. Między WSU3 a średnimi wynikami testu 2hand wystąpiła jedna istotna korelacja ponownie wśród dziewcząt.
Korelacja ta jest przeciętne. W grupie chłopców po raz kolejny nie wystąpiły zależności istotne statystycznie między
tymi zmiennymi. Występujące u chłopców korelacje są słabe (tab. 5.). Cele pracy: -0,097
-0,122
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05 WSU 2 – wskaźnik szybkości uczenia się na II etapie badań Tabela 4. Zależność między WSU2 a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand Między WSU3 a średnimi wynikami testu 2hand wystąpiła jedna istotna korelacja ponownie wśród dziewcząt. Korelacja ta jest przeciętne. W grupie chłopców po raz kolejny nie wystąpiły zależności istotne statystycznie między
tymi zmiennymi. Występujące u chłopców korelacje są słabe (tab. 5.). 52 Tabela 5. Zależność między WSU3 a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand Współczynnik rang Spearmana
Zależność
dziewczęta
chłopcy
WSU3. & 2HANDS – czas błędów
-0,412*
-0,113
WSU3. & 2HANDS – czas przejścia
-0,238
-0,168
WSU3. & 2HANDS – % czas bł. 0,049
-0,173
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05 WSU 3 – wskaźnik szybkości uczenia się na III etapie badań *Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05 WSU 3 – wskaźnik szybkości uczenia się na III etapie ba Podsumowując zależności między WSU na kolejnych etapach uczenia się a średnimi wynikami testu 2hand
można stwierdzić, że zależności te są mocniejsze u dziewcząt –szczególnie na początkowym i środkowym etapie
uczenia się.. ę
Kolejno sprawdzono, jakie zależności występują między średnimi wynikami testu 2hand a uzyskanymi
efektami uczenia się w kolejnych etapach badawczych. W przypadku efektu uczenia się na I etapie badań (Efekt1)
wystąpiły korelacje istotne statystycznie pomiędzy wynikami testu 2hand w grupie badanych dziewcząt i chłopców. W
grupie dziewcząt korelacje były przeciętne i wysokie, a wśród chłopców słabe i przeciętne (tab. 6.). Tabela 6. Zależność między efektem uczenia się a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand na I etapie badań Współczynnik rang Spearmana
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
2HANDS – czas błędów & efekt 1. -0,088
-0,075
2HANDS – czas przejścia & efekt 1. -0,522*
-0,316*
2HANDS – % czas bł. & efekt 1. -0,447*
-0,300*
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, Efekt1- efekt uczenia się na I etapie badań Analizując zależność między efektem uczenia się (Efekt2) a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand na II etapie
badań, można stwierdzić, że jedynie w grupie dziewcząt wystąpiła korelacja istotna statystycznie o sile przeciętnej
(tab. 7.). abela 7. Zależność między efektem uczenia się a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand na II etapie badań. Tabela 7. Zależność między efektem uczenia się a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand na II etapie badań. Współczynnik rang Spearmana
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
Efekt 2. & 2HANDS – czas błędów
-0,385*
-0,008
Efekt 2. & 2HANDS – czas przejścia
-0,319
-0,116
Efekt 2. Cele pracy: & 2HANDS –% czas bł. -0,013
-0,145
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, Efekt2 – efekt uczenia się na II etapie badań. Analizując zależności między efektem uczenia się (Efekt3) a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand na III etapie
badań,
stwierdza się, że po raz kolejny wystąpiła tylko jedna korelacja istotna statystycznie o sile przeciętnej i
ponownie w grupie dziewcząt (tab. 8.). la 8. Zależność między efektem uczenia się a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand na III etapie badań Tabela 8. Zależność między efektem uczenia się a średnimi wynikami prób testu 2hand na III etapie badań
Współczynnik rang Spearmana
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
Efekt 3. & 2HANDS – czas błędów
-0,412*
-0,080
Efekt 3. & 2HANDS – czas przejścia
-0,238
-0,202
Efekt 3. & 2HANDS – % czas bł. 0,049
-0,224
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, Efekt3 – efekt uczenia się na III etapie badań Podsumowując zależności między efektem uczenia się na kolejnych etapach badań a średnimi wynikami testu
2hand, można stwierdzić, że zależności te mocniej występowały w początkowym i środkowym etapie uczenia się u obu
płci, natomiast w końcowym etapie zaczęły słabnąć. Poszukiwanie zależności między szybkością uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej, wyrażonej WSU, a
średnimi wynikami testu MLS w grupie dziewcząt wykazało istnienie istotnej statystycznie korelacji między WSU1 a
jedynie jedną z badanych zmiennych (WSU 1 & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba trafień). W grupie chłopców nie
wykazano żadnych istotnych statystycznie korelacji Występujące korelacje są nikłe, słabe i przeciętne zarówno u
chłopców, jak i u dziewcząt (tab. 9). 53 Tabela 9. Zależność między WSU1 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS
Siła korelacji
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
WSU 1. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba błędów
-0,064
-0,253
WSU 1. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
-0,405*
-0,059
WSU 1. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba trafień
-0,209
-0,016
WSU 1. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba trafień
-0,215
-0,087
WSU 1. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas błędu
-0,076
-0,254
WSU 1. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,309
-0,048
WSU 1. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas całkowity
0,303
0,083
WSU 1. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas całkowity
-0,025
0,033
WSU 1. & Drżenie Dominująca – liczba błędów
-0,235
-0,127
WSU 1. & Drżenie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
-0,204
-0,082
WSU 1. & Drżenie Dominująca – czas błędu
-0,143
-0,128
WSU 1. & Drżenie Przeciwna – czas błędu
0,023
-0,139
WSU 1. & Wstawianie Przeciwna
0,044
-0,175
WSU 1. & Wstawianie Dominująca
0,086
-0,058
WSU 1. Analizując zależności między WSU3 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS
stwierdza, że w grupie chłopców i
dziewcząt dominują korelacje słabe i nikłe. W grupie dziewcząt wystąpiły korelacje istotne statystycznie o sile
przeciętnej (tab. 11.). Cele pracy: & Stukanie Dominująca
-0,046
0,282
WSU 1. & Stukanie Przeciwna
0,133
0,249
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, WSU1 – wskaźnik szybkiego uczenia na I etapie badań Tabela 9. Zależność między WSU1 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS Tabela 9. Zależność między WSU1 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS W przypadku korelacji WSU2 ze średnimi wynikami testu MLS pojawiły się istotne statystycznie zależności
w grupie chłopców w czterech badanych zmiennych. Wszystkie wyniki o istotności statystycznej są o sile przeciętnej. Reszta korelacji w grupie chłopców jest nikła lub słaba. W grupie dziewcząt nie wystąpiły korelacje istotne
statystycznie, dominują korelacje o sile nikłej i słabej (tab. 10.). Tabela 10. Zależność między WSU2 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS
Siła korelacji
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
WSU 2. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba błędów
0,015
-0,078
WSU 2. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
-0,127
-0,179
WSU 2. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba trafień
0,023
0,422*
WSU 2. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba trafień
-0,198
-0,162
WSU 2. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas błędu
0,074
-0,122
WSU 2. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,067
-0,235
WSU 2. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas całkowity
0,055
-0,136
WSU 2. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas całkowity
-0,243
-0,247
WSU 2. & Drżenie Dominująca – liczba błędów
-0,206
-0,221
WSU 2. & Drżenie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
-0,247
0,029
WSU 2. & Drżenie Dominująca – czas błędu
-0,258
-0,155
WSU 2. & Drżenie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,290
-0,193
WSU 2. & Wstawianie Przeciwna
-0,062
-0,197
WSU 2. & Wstawianie Dominująca
0,122
-0,331*
WSU 2. & Stukanie Dominująca
-0,059
0,414*
WSU 2. & Stukanie Przeciwna
-0,039
0,457*
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, WSU2 – wskaźnik szybkiego uczenia na II etapie badań Analizując zależności między WSU3 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS
stwierdza, że w grupie chłopców i
dziewcząt dominują korelacje słabe i nikłe. W grupie dziewcząt wystąpiły korelacje istotne statystycznie o sile
przeciętnej (tab. 11.). 54 Tabela 11. Zależność między WSU3 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS
Siła korelacji
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
WSU 3. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba błędów
0,089
-0,004
WSU 3. & Celowanie Przeciwna liczba – błędów
0,009
-0,041
WSU 3. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba trafień
0,369*
0,036
WSU 3. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba trafień
-0,014
-0,136
WSU 3. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas błędu
0,001
0,061
WSU 3. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,071
-0,035
WSU 3. Cele pracy: & Celowanie Dominująca – czas całkowity
-0,184
-0,069
WSU 3. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas całkowity
-0,155
-0,277
WSU 3. & Drżenie Dominująca – liczba błędów
0,144
-0,172
WSU 3. & Drżenie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
0,151
-0,202
WSU 3. & Drżenie Dominująca – czas błędu
0,049
-0,359
WSU 3. & Drżenie Przeciwna – czas błędu
0,061
-0,254
WSU 3. & Wstawianie Przeciwna
-0,257
-0,096
WSU 3. & Wstawianie Dominująca
-0,169
-0,025
WSU 3. & Stukanie Dominująca
0,336*
-0,107
WSU 3. & Stukanie Przeciwna
0,282
0,117
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0 05 WSU3 – wskaźnik szybkiego uczenia na III etapie badań Tabela 11. Zależność między WSU3 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS Tabela 11. Zależność między WSU3 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS *Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, WSU3 – wskaźnik szybkiego uczenia na III etapie b Podsumowując, można stwierdzić, że nie występują wyraźne, mocno zaznaczone zależności między WSU a
średnimi wynikami prób test MLS. W obu grupach dominują korelacje nikłe lub słabe. Jedynie korelacje, które są
istotnie statystyczne, mają siłę przeciętną. Kolejno obliczono zależność między uzyskanym efektem końcowym etapów badań a średnimi wynikami testu
MLS MLS. MLS. Między efektem uczenia się w I etapie badań (Efekt1) a średnimi wynikami testu MLS tylko w grupie
chłopców wystąpiła zależność istotna statystycznie o sile przeciętnej. Dominowały korelacje słabe. W grupie dziewcząt
korelacje były bardziej zróżnicowane - o sile nikłej, słabej lub przeciętnej (tab. 12.). Tabela 12. Zależność między efektem1 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS Tabela 12. Zależność między efektem1 a średnimi wynikami testu MLS
Siła korelacji
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
Efekt1. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba błędów
0,131
-0,091
Efekt1. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
-0,256
0,128
Efekt1. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba trafień
-0,086
0,097
Efekt1. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba trafień
-0,303
-0,054
Efekt1. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas błędu
0,173
-0,192
Efekt1. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,131
0,103
Efekt1. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas całkowity
0,022
-0,134
Efekt1. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas całkowity
-0,210
0,008
Efekt1. & Drżenie Dominująca – liczba błędów
-0,307
0,005
Efekt1. & Drżenie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
-0,334
0,065
Efekt1. & Drżenie Dominująca – czas błędu
-0,189
0,044
Efekt1. & Drżenie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,110
-0,032
Efekt1. & Wstawianie Przeciwna
0,024
-0,303*
Efekt1. & Wstawianie Dominująca
0,058
-0,245
Efekt1. & Stukanie Dominująca
0,010
0,271
Efekt1. & Stukanie Przeciwna
0,090
0,266
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, Efekt1 – efekt uczenia się na danym etapie badań 55 Między efektem uczenia się na II etapie badań (Efekt2) a średnimi wynikami testu MLS korelacje istotne
statystycznie występują w pięciu zmiennych. Ich siła jest przeciętna. W grupie dziewcząt w dalszym ciągu nie ma
korelacji istotnych statystycznie, dominują korelacje nikłe lub słabe (tab. 13.). Między efektem uczenia się na II etapie badań (Efekt2) a średnimi wynikami testu MLS korelacje istotne
statystycznie występują w pięciu zmiennych. Ich siła jest przeciętna. W grupie dziewcząt w dalszym ciągu nie ma
korelacji istotnych statystycznie, dominują korelacje nikłe lub słabe (tab. 13.). Tabela 13. Zależność między efektem II etapu badań a średnimi wynikami testu MLS
Siła korelacji
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
Efekt2. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba błędów
-0,042
-0,007
Efekt2. & Celowanie Przeciwna liczba – błędów
-0,076
-0,157
Efekt2. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba trafień
0,046
0,356*
Efekt2. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba trafień
-0,212
-0,231
Efekt2. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas błędu
0,023
-0,081
Efekt2. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,049
-0,240
Efekt2. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas całkowity
0,004
-0,170
Efekt2. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas całkowity
-0,290
-0,254
Efekt2. *Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, Efekt3 – efekt uczenia się na III etapie badań MLS. & Drżenie Dominująca – liczba błędów
-0,275
-0,144
Efekt2. & Drżenie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
-0,296
-0,078
Efekt2. & Drżenie Dominująca – czas błędu
-0,346
-0,169
Efekt2. & Drżenie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,300
-0,117
Efekt2. & Wstawianie Przeciwna
-0,105
-0,329*
Efekt2. & Wstawianie Dominująca
0,056
-0,348*
Efekt2. & Stukanie Dominująca
-0,030
0,364*
Efekt2. & Stukanie Przeciwna
0,036
0,425*
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, Efekt2- efekt uczenia się na II etapie badań abela 13. Zależność między efektem II etapu badań a średnimi wynikami testu MLS Między efektem uczenia się na III etapie badań (Efekt3) a średnimi wynikami testu MLS po raz kolejny, tylko w
grupie chłopców, pojawią się korelacje istotne statystycznie o sile przeciętnej. Reszta korelacji jest nikła lub słaba. W
grupie dziewcząt w dalszym ciągu nie zaobserwowałem korelacji istotnych statystycznie. Dominują korelacje nikłe i
słabe (tab. 14.). Tabela 14. Zależność między efektem III etapu badań a średnimi wynikami testu MLS
Siła korelacji
Zależność
Dziewczęta
Chłopcy
Efekt3. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba błędów
-0,004
0,201
Efekt3. & Celowanie Przeciwna liczba – błędów
-0,041
0,032
Efekt3. & Celowanie Dominująca – liczba trafień
0,036
0,313*
Efekt3. & Celowanie Przeciwna – liczba trafień
-0,136
-0,028
Efekt3. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas błędu
0,061
0,108
Efekt3. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,035
-0,052
Efekt3. & Celowanie Dominująca – czas całkowity
-0,069
-0,184
Efekt3. & Celowanie Przeciwna – czas całkowity
-0,277
-0,169
Efekt3. & Drżenie Dominująca – liczba błędów
-0,172
0,025
Efekt3. & Drżenie Przeciwna – liczba błędów
-0,202
0,113
Efekt3. & Drżenie Dominująca – czas błędu
-0,359
0,087
Efekt3. & Drżenie Przeciwna – czas błędu
-0,254
0,069
Efekt3. & Wstawianie Przeciwna
-0,096
-0,175
Efekt3. & Wstawianie Dominująca
-0,025
-0,164
Efekt3. & Stukanie Dominująca
-0,107
0,270
Efekt3. & Stukanie Przeciwna
0,117
0,220
*Współczynniki korelacji są istotne dla p<0,05, Efekt3 – efekt uczenia się na III etapie badań Tabela 14. Zależność między efektem III etapu badań a średnimi wynikami testu MLS 56 Dyskusja: y
j
Jednym z rodzajów uczenia się jest ten służący opanowaniu czynności ruchowych, zwany uczeniem się
motorycznym (Szopa i wsp. 2000, Sankowski 2001,Osiński 2003, Raczek 2010, Magill i Anderson 2017), powiązany w
sposób szczególny z uczeniem się umiejętności szkolnych (pisanie, czytanie, słuchanie, mówienie), a różnice między
nimi zacierają się zwłaszcza podczas uczenia się złożonych czynności ruchowych (np. żonglowanie trzema piłeczkami)
(Beck i wsp. 2016, Macdonald i wsp. 2018, Coker 2018). MLS. W diagnozowaniu przejawów motoryczności człowieka powinno dojść do oceny koordynacja oko-ręka, która jest
składową predyspozycji koordynacyjnych (Szopa i wsp. 2000). Rynkiewicz (2003), Migasiewicz (2006) ocenili
poziom zdolności koordynacyjnych wśród studentów III i IV roku Instytutu Wychowania Fizycznego filii poznańskiej
Akademii Wychowania Fizycznego w Gorzowie Wlkp. oraz dzieci i młodzieży w wieku 7,5-18,5 lat. W
wymienionych grupach badanych nie wykazano silnej zależności między zdolnościami koordynacyjnymi a rozwojem
somatycznym czy płcią, tak jak niejednokrotnie związek ten był wskazywany w przypadku zdolności kondycyjnych
(Koszczyc 1991, Rynkiewicz 2003, Fugiel 2014). Jak się okazuje, dla rozwoju zdolności koordynacyjnych bardziej
znaczące są dotychczasowe doświadczenia ruchowe oraz prawidłowy w ontogenezie rozwój układu nerwowego
(Fugiel 2014). Do oceny koordynacji oko-ręka coraz powszechniej wykorzystywany jest Wiedeński System Testów
(WST), uważany za wysoko specjalistyczne narzędzie do oceny psychomotorycznych właściwości człowieka (Juras i
Waśkiewicz 1998, Raczek i wsp. 2000, Guła-Kubiszewska 2007, Domaradzki i Ignasiak 2009, Gierczuk i Ljach 2012,
Koźlenia i wsp. 2018). WST jest stosowany od 1987 roku i początkowo służył tylko do badań w psychologii klinicznej
i eksperymentalnej. Obecnie jest coraz popularniejszy i stosowany jest także w badaniach z dyscypliny nauk o kulturze
fizycznej (Raczek i wsp. 2003). W skład WST wchodzi wiele testów np. test koordynacji oko-ręka -2hand oraz test
precyzyjnych ruchów rąk – MLS (Łuczak 2005, Guła-Kubiszewska 2007). Autor w pracy wykorzystał właśnie te dwa
testy. Wyniki testu MLS posłużyły autorowi do oceny czynników, które według koncepcji Fleishmana są
wyznacznikiem do wykonania określonych precyzyjnych czynności ruchowych (szybkość przegub-palec, sprawność
palca, szybkość ruchów ramienia, tremor, czas reakcji, celowanie, zręczność ręki, kontrola prędkości) (za Guła-
Kubiszewska 2007). Oprócz tego, wyniki uzyskane w teście MLS posłużyły również do ustalenia modelu ręczności
badanych. y
W literaturze często test 2hand jest nazywany testem koordynacji ruchów rąk lub testem oko-ręka. Pozwala on
określić poziom koordynacji oko-ręka przy współpracy prawej i lewej ręki podczas przesuwania kursora po
wyznaczonej trasie, widocznej na monitorze komputera. (Fugiel 2014, Wawrzyniak 2016). W nawiązaniu do badań
innych autorów, którzy używają tego samego testu, mogą pojawiać się w literaturze przedmiotu zamiennie
określenia,,oko-ręka” i ,,koordynacja rąk”. Podczas
analizy
uzyskanych
danych
za
pomocą
testu
2hand
zauważono,
że
chłopcy
w
porównaniu
do
dziewcząt
osiągnęli
wyższy
poziom
koordynacji
oko-ręka,
jednak
wyniki
te nie różniły się istotnie statystycznie. Zbliżone wyniki odnotowano w badaniach nad koordynacją obu rąk, które
przeprowadzone zostały przez Domaradzkiego i Ignasiak (2009). MLS. Fugiel (2014) w swoich badaniach zaobserwował różnice istotnie statystyczne między ręką dominującą a 57 przeciwną w próbie ,,stukanie” u chłopców i dziewcząt w wieku 9 i 10 lat. W teście ,,celowanie” w parametrze ,,czas
całkowity” zarówno grupa dziewcząt jak i chłopców w wieku 9 i 10 lat nie uzyskała wyników istotnych statystycznie
między ręką dominującą a przeciwną. W parametrze ,,liczba błędów” chłopcy i dziewczęta w wieku 9 i 10 lat uzyskali
wyniki, które różniły się istotnie statystycznie między ręką dominującą i przeciwną. W badaniach własnych, w
obydwóch grupach zauważyłem różnice istotne statystycznie między ręką dominującą a przeciwną w teście ,,stukanie”. W teście ,,celowanie” w parametrze ,,czas całkowity” nie zauważyłem różnic istotnych statystycznie w grupie
dziewcząt i chłopców w obrębie badanych kończyn górnych. Istotne statystycznie różnice między ręką dominującą a
przeciwną wystąpiły w parametrze ,,liczba błędów” w obydwu grupach. p
ą
y ąp y
p
ę
y
g
p
Sebastjan i wsp. (2017) w swoich badaniach przeprowadzonych wśród osób po 50 roku życia zauważyli
różnice istotnie statystycznie między ręką dominującą a przeciwną w teście ,,stukanie" oraz ,,wstawianie”. W
uzyskanych
wynikach
zauważono
różnice
istotne
statystycznie
między
ręką
dominującą
a
przeciwną
w
teście ,,stukanie”. W teście ,wstawianie” chłopcy i dziewczęta szybciej wstawiali kołki ręką dominującą, różnice te
jednak nie były istotne statystycznie. Wyniki trudno jednak porównać ze względu na dużą różnicę w wieku badanych
dzieci (badania własne) i osób dorosłych (Sebastjan i wsp. 2017). Jednym z uwarunkowań skutecznego uczenia się złożonych czynności ruchowych jest poziom zdolności
koordynacyjnych. Wielu autorów poszukuje zależności między poziomem koordynacyjnym zdolności motorycznych
(KZM) a skutecznym uczeniem się czynności ruchowej (Juras i Waśkiewicz 1998, Klocek i Żak 2001, Hirtz i Starosta
2002, Ljach i Witkowski 2004, Boraczyński i wsp. 2008, Zatoń i wsp. 2008. Jednym z pierwszych naukowców, który
zainteresował się KZM jako wymiarem informacyjnej sfery potencjału motorycznego, był w 1968 roku Gundlachow
(za Mynarski 2003). Wyróżnił on dwie podstawowe grupy zdolności motorycznych: kondycyjne, oparte na
mechanizmach energetycznych i koordynacyjne, zdeterminowane przez procesy sterująco - regulącyjne i kognitywne. Współcześnie KZM są interpretowane jako ,,względnie utrwalone i uogólnione formy przebiegu psychofizycznych
procesów
regulacji
ruchowej. Odzwierciedlają
one
złożone
stosunki
zachodzące
pomiędzy
procesami
neuropsychicznymi” (Raczek i wsp. 2002, s. 13). Rozwijanie KZM może warunkować szybsze i skuteczniejsze
uczenie się różnorodnych czynności ruchowych (Bajdziński i Starosta 2002). Podobne wnioski sformułowali
Boraczyński i Zaporozhanov (2011). Do badań nad efektywnością uczenia się wybrali oni umiejętność trafienia
piłeczką golfową do celu. MLS. Na podstawie opracowanych wskaźników ilościowych i jakościowych stwierdzili, że
poprawa zdolności koordynacyjnych skutkuje większą efektywnością motorycznego uczenia się. Podobne wnioski w
swoich badaniach
z udziałem 66 studentów II roku AWF we Wrocławiu przedstawił Wołk (2001). Osoby o
najwyższym poziomie różnicowania kinestetycznego osiągnęły największy postęp w uczeniu się czynności ruchowej
(jazda na nartach). Dybińska (2002) badała natomiast chłopców w młodszym wieku szkolnym. Jak się okazało,
uczniowie o wyższych wynikach prób oceniających poziom koordynacji uczyli się szybciej i skuteczniej techniki
pływackiej niż uczniowie o niższym poziomie koordynacji. Podobne rezultaty otrzymali Waade i wsp. (2001) podczas
oceny zależności między poziomem koordynacji ruchowej a opanowanymi umiejętnościami pływackimi w wyniku
procesu dydaktycznego u dzieci w wieku szkolnym. Również Szczepanik i Szopa (1993), zauważyli zależności między
zdolnościami koordynacyjnymi a szybkością i trwałością uczenia się techniki ruchu w siatkówce. Autorzy stwierdzili
wysoką zależność między skutecznością gry w piłkę siatkową a poziomem orientacji przestrzennej i koordynacji
wzrokowo-ruchowej. j
W odniesieniu do uzyskanych wyników przez autora, istotne korelacje wystąpiły między uzyskanymi
wynikami testu 2hand a szybkością uczenia się w grupie dziewcząt, szczególnie na początku badań. Korelacje stawały
się jednak coraz słabsze w późniejszych etapach uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej. W badaniach Zatonia i wsp. (2008) również udowodniono, że doskonalenie czucia kinestetycznego ma duży wpływ na uczenie się złożonej
czynności ruchowej (jazda na nartach). Chaloupská i Hrušová (2017) w swoich badaniach dokonały obserwacji
postępu w uczeniu się dyscypliny sportowej polegającej na chodzeniu i wykonywaniu trików na taśmie (slacking). Dyscyplina ta jest zbiorem złożonych czynności ruchowych. Jest ona wymagająca pod względem koordynacji pracy
mięśni i stabilizacji postawy ciała w odniesieniu do zmiennych warunków zewnętrznych i ich przewidywania
(Shumway-Cook i Woollacott 2007). Do określenia poziomu koordynacji wykorzystano próbę stania na jednej nodze
(1 leg standing balance test) oraz baterie testów Iowa-Brace. Osoby badane, na podstawie uzyskanych wyników testów,
zostały podzielone na dwie grupy. Okazało się, że grupa o wyższym poziomie koordynacji uczyła się szybciej i
skuteczniej niż grupa o niższym poziomie koordynacji. Różnica okazała się istotna statystycznie. Zetou i wsp. (2012)
sprawdzili, czy program treningu koordynacyjnego usprawni proces uczenia się umiejętności gry w tenisa (backhand i
forehand). Badanie przeprowadzili wśród 48 zawodników klubu tenisowego w wieku od 9 do 13 roku życia. Dzieci
zostały podzielone na dwie grupy. Grupa eksperymentalna przed nauką umiejętności tenisowych brała udział w 20-
minutowym programie treningu koordynacyjnego. Grupa kontrolna uczyła się tylko umiejętności technicznych gry w
tenisa. Pomiędzy grupami zauważono istotną różnicę. MLS. Celem ich badań była próba oceny poziomu rozwoju
i zróżnicowania płciowego wybranych predyspozycji koordynacyjnych dzieci w wieku 8-9 lat przy użyciu testu 2hand. Uzyskali oni w swoich badaniach wyższe wyniki dla oceny poziomu koordynacji chłopców w porównaniu do
dziewcząt, jednak wyniki nie różniły się istotnie statystycznie. Także Fugiel (2014) nie odnotował różnic istotnych
statystycznie w swoich badaniach nad koordynacją ruchów rąk (test 2hand) między chłopcami a dziewczętami w wieku
9- 10 lat. Rokita i wsp. (2014) ocenili poziom koordynacji oko-ręka dziewcząt i chłopców w wieku 14-16 lat
trenujących szermierkę. Autorzy nie stwierdzili różnic istotnych statystycznie między tymi dwoma grupami. Wyniki
wszystkich wymienionych badaczy pokrywają się z uzyskanymi przez autora i świadczą o tym, że płeć nie różnicuje
poziomu koordynacji oko-ręka wśród dzieci i młodzieży. p
y
j
ę
y
Podczas analizy danych, uzyskanych z testu MLS, zauważono, że dziewczęta w porównaniu do chłopców
osiągnęły istotnie wyższe wyniki dla poszczególnych czynników: Celowanie
RD – liczba błędów, Celowanie RP –
liczba błędów, Celowanie RP – czas błędu, Celowanie RP – czas całkowity, Drżenie RD – liczba błędów, natomiast
chłopcy osiągnęli istotnie wyższy wynik w Celowanie RP – liczba trafień. Fugiel (2014) w swoich badaniach nie
odnotował różnic istotnych statystycznie w wybranych próbach MLS (stukanie, celowanie i śledzenie liniowe) wśród
dziewcząt i chłopców w wieku 9-10 lat. W badaniach Domaradzkiego i Ignasiak (2009) wykorzystano dwie próby z
testów MLS: stuknięcie piórem oraz celowanie. Autorzy zaobserwowali różnicę we wszystkich parametrach
próby ,,celowanie piórem w punkt” między dziewczętami a chłopcami w wieku 8-9 lat. Mleczko (1991) podkreśla, że do analizy predyspozycji koordynacyjnych, które mogą być oceniane poprzez
test 2hand i MLS, powinno się podchodzić ostrożnie. Ocena wyników predyspozycji koordynacyjnych często
uzależniona jest od wielu czynników zewnętrznych (np. środowiskowych) i wewnętrznych (genetycznych). Złożoność
procedury wymaga zatem, by uzyskane wyniki zawsze interpretować w odniesieniu do wybranej grupy badanej, która
posiada specyficzne dla siebie cechy (Mleczko 1991). Wyniki uzyskane przez autora za pośrednictwem testu MLS
dostarczyły także informacji o jakości wykonania zadania (szybkość i dokładność) u badanych dziewcząt i chłopców. Okazało się, że zarówno dziewczęta, jak i chłopcy skuteczniej wykonują zadania ręką dominującą niż ręką przeciwną. Takie wyniki są zgodne z doniesieniami z literatury (Carson i wsp. 1990, Riolo-Quinn 1991, Sainburg 2002). Mogą
świadczyć także o wystąpieniu asymetrii cech (szybkość i dokładność), które diagnozuje się z wykorzystaniem tego
testu. Podsumowanie i wnioski W wyniku przeprowadzonych badań oraz opracowania ich wyników, zrealizowano cel poznawczy, którym
była ocena skuteczności (szybkości, efektywności) uczenia się złożonej
czynności ruchowej w odniesieniu do
zdolności koordynacyjnych wybranej grupy dziewcząt i chłopców. Podsumowując wyniki można stwierdzić: W wyniku przeprowadzonych badań oraz opracowania ich wyników, zrealizowano cel poznawczy, którym
była ocena skuteczności (szybkości, efektywności) uczenia się złożonej
czynności ruchowej w odniesieniu do
zdolności koordynacyjnych wybranej grupy dziewcząt i chłopców. Podsumowując wyniki można stwierdzić: y
yj y
y
j g
py
ą
p
ją
y
1. Chłopcy osiągnęli wyższy średni poziom koordynacji oko-ręka (test 2hand), jednak różnice między nimi a
dziewczętami nie były istotne statystycznie. 1. Chłopcy osiągnęli wyższy średni poziom koordynacji oko-ręka (test 2hand), jednak różnice między nimi a
dziewczętami nie były istotne statystycznie. ę
y y
y y
iewczęta osiągnęły średnio wyższe wyniki niż chłopcy w zakresie precyzyjnych ruchów rąk (test MLS
żnice istotne statystycznie na ich korzyść wystąpiły w większości wykonanych prób testu 2. Dziewczęta osiągnęły średnio wyższe wyniki niż chłopcy w zakresie precyzyjnych ruchów rąk (test MLS). Różnice istotne statystycznie na ich korzyść wystąpiły w większości wykonanych prób testu. l
i
i d
k
d
j
k
k
(
i
k
i
h
d)
bk
i
i 2. Dziewczęta osiągnęły średnio wyższe wyniki niż chłopcy w zakresie precyzyjnych ruchów rąk (test MLS). Różnice istotne statystycznie na ich korzyść wystąpiły w większości wykonanych prób testu. 3
l
ś i
i d
k
d
j
k
k
(
i
k
i
2h
d)
bk ś i
i 3. Zależności pomiędzy koordynacją oko-ręka (ocenianą z wykorzystaniem testu 2hand) a szybkością i
efektywnością uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej ujawniają się jedynie u dziewcząt jednak nie są one
istotne statystycznie. 3. Zależności pomiędzy koordynacją oko-ręka (ocenianą z wykorzystaniem testu 2hand) a szybkością i
efektywnością uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej ujawniają się jedynie u dziewcząt jednak nie są one
istotne statystycznie. y y
4. Zależności pomiędzy precyzyjnymi ruchami rąk (ocenianą z wykorzystaniem testu MLS) a szybkością i
efektywnością uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej ujawniają się jedynie u chłopców jednak nie są one
istotne statystycznie 4. Zależności pomiędzy precyzyjnymi ruchami rąk (ocenianą z wykorzystaniem testu MLS) a szybkością i
efektywnością uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej ujawniają się jedynie u chłopców jednak nie są one
istotne statystycznie Na podstawie uzyskanych wyników badań można sformułować następujące wnioski: Na podstawie uzyskanych wyników badań można sformułować następujące wnioski: 1. Podsumowanie i wnioski Występują zależności
między szybkością i efektywnością uczenia się złożonej czynności ruchowej a
poziomem zdolności koordynacyjnych. Mocniej ujawniają się one u dziewcząt niż chłopców. p
y
yj y
j j
ją
ę
ą
p
2. Ważne jest, aby nauczyciele w procesie dydaktycznym, rozwijali zdolności koordynacyjnych u uczniów,
aby podnieść skuteczność ich uczenia się motorycznego. MLS. Natomiast między szybkością uczenia się a wynikami testu MLS nie
stwierdziłem wyraźnych zależności. MLS. Badane dzieci z grupy eksperymentalnej opanowały backhand i
forehand na wyższym poziomie. Wydaje się, że szczególną rolę w procesie uczenia się odgrywa też koordynacja oko-ręka. Jak podają badacze,
może ona być związana z dokładnością i szybkością opanowania nowych umiejętności ruchowych, zwłaszcza u dzieci
w wieku szkolnym (Szopa i wsp. 2000, Raczek i wsp. 2002). Giles i wsp. (2018) zbadali 309 dzieci w wieku od 5 do
11 roku życia. Do oceny poziomu koordynacji oko-ręka wykorzystano testy komputerowe, które obejmowały
sterowanie, celowanie i śledzenie obiektów na ekranie komputera. Autorzy stwierdzili, że dzieci, które miały wyższe
wyniki w testach koordynacji wzrokowo-ruchowej osiągały lepsze wyniki w czytaniu, pisaniu i matematyce. Wardana 58 i wsp. (2017) zbadali zależności między koordynacją oko-ręka a efektywnym wykonaniem czynności ruchowej u
studentów V semestru na Uniwersytecie Surakarta w Indonezji. Zadaniem badanych studentów było wykonanie rzutów
wolnych w koszykówce. Autorzy stwierdzili, że studenci, którzy mieli wysoki poziom koordynacji oko-ręka, uzyskali
wyższe wyniki w rzutach wolnych niż studenci o niższym poziomie omawianej koordynacji oko-ręka. Ostrowski (2011)
zauważył, że dzieci, które miały wyższy poziom koordynacji oko-ręka opanowały technikę pływacką na wyższym
poziomie, co demonstrowały podczas sprawdzianów na lekcjach pływania. W badaniach autor zaobserwował
zależności między wynikami testu 2hand a efektywnym uczeniem się, szczególnie w I etapie badań, w grupie
dziewcząt i chłopców. W kolejnych etapach zależności te nie były już tak wyraźne. W analizie zależności między
wynikami testu MLS a efektywnym uczeniem się zauważyłem najwięcej zależności w II etapie badań, w grupie
chłopców. Były to korelacje o sile przeciętnej. Natomiast między szybkością uczenia się a wynikami testu MLS nie
stwierdziłem wyraźnych zależności. i wsp. (2017) zbadali zależności między koordynacją oko-ręka a efektywnym wykonaniem czynności ruchowej u
studentów V semestru na Uniwersytecie Surakarta w Indonezji. Zadaniem badanych studentów było wykonanie rzutów
wolnych w koszykówce. Autorzy stwierdzili, że studenci, którzy mieli wysoki poziom koordynacji oko-ręka, uzyskali
wyższe wyniki w rzutach wolnych niż studenci o niższym poziomie omawianej koordynacji oko-ręka. Ostrowski (2011)
zauważył, że dzieci, które miały wyższy poziom koordynacji oko-ręka opanowały technikę pływacką na wyższym
poziomie, co demonstrowały podczas sprawdzianów na lekcjach pływania. W badaniach autor zaobserwował
zależności między wynikami testu 2hand a efektywnym uczeniem się, szczególnie w I etapie badań, w grupie
dziewcząt i chłopców. W kolejnych etapach zależności te nie były już tak wyraźne. W analizie zależności między
wynikami testu MLS a efektywnym uczeniem się zauważyłem najwięcej zależności w II etapie badań, w grupie
chłopców. Były to korelacje o sile przeciętnej. PISMIENNICTWO 1. Bajdziński M., Starosta W. Kinestetyczne różnicowanie ruchu i jego uwarunkowania. Międzynarodowe
Stowarzyszenie Motoryki Sportowej. Warszawa-Gorzów 2002 1. Bajdziński M., Starosta W. Kinestetyczne różnicowanie ruchu i jego uwarunkowania. Międzynarodowe
Stowarzyszenie Motoryki Sportowej. Warszawa-Gorzów 2002 2. Beck M., Lind R., Geertsen S., Ritz C., Lundbye-Jensen J., Wienecke J., Motor-enriched learning activities
can improve mathematical performance in preadolescent children. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2016;
10(645), 1-14, doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2016.00645 2. Beck M., Lind R., Geertsen S., Ritz C., Lundbye-Jensen J., Wienecke J., Motor-enriched learning activities
can improve mathematical performance in preadolescent children. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2016;
10(645), 1-14, doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2016.00645 (
),
,
3. Biotteau M., Chaix Y., Albaret J.M. (2016) What do we really know about motor learning in children with
Developmental Coordination Disorder?. Current Developmental Disorders Reports 2016; 3(2), 152-160. 3. Biotteau M., Chaix Y., Albaret J.M. (2016) What do we really know about motor learning in children with
Developmental Coordination Disorder?. Current Developmental Disorders Reports 2016; 3(2), 152-160. 4. Boraczyński T., Zaporozhanov V. Uczenie się motoryczne jako kryterium oceny koordynacyjnych zdolności
badanych [Motor learning as a criterion for assessing the coordination abilities of the subjects]. Pedagogics,
psychology, medical-biological problems of physical training and sports 2011; 10, s. 110-118. 4. Boraczyński T., Zaporozhanov V. Uczenie się motoryczne jako kryterium oceny koordynacyjnych zdolności
badanych [Motor learning as a criterion for assessing the coordination abilities of the subjects]. Pedagogics,
psychology, medical-biological problems of physical training and sports 2011; 10, s. 110-118. 5. Boraczyński T., Urniaż J., Boraczyńska L.B., Sawicki A., Crowski D. Ocena zdolności kinestetycznego
różnicowania ruchów piłkarzy ręcznych [Kinesthetic differentiation of movement and its conditions. International Sport Motoring Association]. W: J. Urniaż (red.), Współczesne trendy rozwoju sportu a idee
humanizmu olimpijskiego (ss. 119-128). Olsztyńska Szkoła Wyższa im. Józefa Rusieckiego. Olsztyn 2008. 5. Boraczyński T., Urniaż J., Boraczyńska L.B., Sawicki A., Crowski D. Ocena zdolności kinestetycznego
różnicowania ruchów piłkarzy ręcznych [Kinesthetic differentiation of movement and its conditions. International Sport Motoring Association]. W: J. Urniaż (red.), Współczesne trendy rozwoju sportu a idee
humanizmu olimpijskiego (ss. 119-128). Olsztyńska Szkoła Wyższa im. Józefa Rusieckiego. Olsztyn 2008. p j
g (
)
y
y
g
6. Carson R.G., Chua R., Elliot D., Goodman D. The construbution of vision to assymetries in ma
Neuropsychologia 1990; 28, 1215-1220. n R.G., Chua R., Elliot D., Goodman D. The construbution of vision to assymetries in manual aiming. psychologia 1990; 28, 1215-1220. 7. Chaloupská P., Hrušová D. PISMIENNICTWO Giles O.T., Shire K.A., Hill L.J.B., Mushtaq F., Waterman A., Holt R.J., Culmer PR, Williams J.H.G., Wilkie
R.M., Mon-Williams M. Hitting the Target: Mathematical Attainment in Children Is Related to Interceptive-
Timing Ability. Psychological Science 2018, 29(8),1334-1345. doi: 10.1177/0956797618772502. g
y
y
g
,
( ),
16. Guła-Kubiszewska H. Efekty Dydaktyczne samoregulowanego uczenia się motorycznego [Didactic effects of
self-regulated motor learning]. AWF, Wrocław 2007. 17. Hirtz P., Starosta W. Sensitive and critical periods of motor co-ordination development and its relation to
motor learning. Journal of Human Kinetics 2002, 7, 19–28. 18. Ignasiak Z. Anatomia układu ruchu [Anatomy of the locomotor system]. Edra Urban & Partner, Wrocław
2013. 19. Juras G., Waśkiewicz Z. Czasowe, przestrzenne oraz dynamiczne aspekty koordynacyjnyc
motorycznych [Temporal, spatial and dynamic aspects of coordination motor skills]. AWF, Katow
Ż 20. Klocek T., Żak S. Strukturalne I motoryczne determinanty skuteczności gry w piłce siatkowej kobiet
[Structural and motor determinants of game effectiveness in women's volleyball]. Antropomotoryka 2001, 22,
65-80. 21. Koszczyc S. Asymetria morfologiczna i dynamiczna oraz możliwości jej kształtowania u dzieci w młodszym
wieku szkolnym [Morphological and dynamic asymmetry and the possibility of its shaping in children at a
younger school age]. AWF, Wrocław 1991. y
g
g ]
22. Koźlenia D., Wierzbicka-Damska I., Trojanowska I., Domaradzki J. Change of precision of hand movements
in young men after short-term (anaerobic) exercise. Journal of Education, Health and Sport 2018; 8(11), 253-
260. 23. Kubaszczyk A. Poziom koordynacyjnych zdolności motorycznych a sprawność specjalna koszykarzy na
różnych etapach szkolenia sportowego [The level of coordination motor skills and the special fitness of
basketball players at various stages of sports training]. AWF, Katowice 1996. p y
g
p
g
24. Macdonald K., Milne N., Orr R., Pope R. Relationships between Motor Proficiency and Academic
Performance in Mathematics and Reading in School-Aged Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review
Int J Environ Res Public Health 2018; 15(8), 1-28, doi: 10.3390/ijerph15081603. 25. Magill R., Anderson D. Motor learning and control. Concepts and Apllications. McGraw-Hill Edu
York 2017. 26. Mleczko E. Przebieg i uwarunkowania rozwoju funkcjonalnego dzieci krakowskich między 7 a 14 rokiem
życia [The course and conditions of functional development of Krakow children between 7 and 14 years of
age]. AWF, Kraków 1991. 27. Migasiewicz J. PISMIENNICTWO Effect Of Level Of Coordination Abilities On Motor Learning Progress In
Slacklining. The European Proceedings of Social & Behavioural Sciences EpSB 2017; 24, 27-35. doi:10.15405/epsbs.2017.06.4. 7. Chaloupská P., Hrušová D. Effect Of Level Of Coordination Abilities On Motor Learning Progress In
Slacklining. The European Proceedings of Social & Behavioural Sciences EpSB 2017; 24, 27-35. doi:10.15405/epsbs.2017.06.4. p
8. Coker CH.A. Motor Learning and Control for Practitioners. Routledge 711 Third Avenue, Ne 9. Czabański B. Kształcenie psychomotoryczne [Psychomotor education]. AWF, Wrocław 2000. 9. Czabański B. Kształcenie psychomotoryczne [Psychomotor education]. AWF, Wrocław 2000 10. Domaradzki J., Ignasiak I. Zróżnicowanie płciowe wybranych predyspozycji koordynacyjnych dzieci w
młodszym wieku szkolnym - wyniki Wiedeńskiego Systemu Testowego [Gender differentiation of selected 10. Domaradzki J., Ignasiak I. Zróżnicowanie płciowe wybranych predyspozycji koordynacyjnych dzieci w
młodszym wieku szkolnym - wyniki Wiedeńskiego Systemu Testowego [Gender differentiation of selected 59 coordination predispositions of children at an early school age - results of the Vienna Test System]. Antropomotoryka 2009; 45, 83-87. coordination predispositions of children at an early school age - results of the Vienna Test System]. Antropomotoryka 2009; 45, 83-87. 11. Dybińska E. Wybrane czynniki somatyczno-funkcjonalne a szybkość uczenia się i nauczania czynności
pływackich chłopców w wieku szkolnym [Selected somatic and functional factors and the speed of learning
and teaching swimming activities to school-aged boys]. Antropomotoryka 2002; 24, 89-101. 11. Dybińska E. Wybrane czynniki somatyczno-funkcjonalne a szybkość uczenia się i nauczania czynności
pływackich chłopców w wieku szkolnym [Selected somatic and functional factors and the speed of learning
and teaching swimming activities to school-aged boys]. Antropomotoryka 2002; 24, 89-101. 12. Dybińska E. Ocena sprawności uczenia się i nauczania czynności pływackich dzieci w młodszym wieku
szkolnym w odniesieniu do poziomu wybranych zdolności motorycznych [Evaluation of the efficiency of
learning and teaching swimming activities to children at an early school age in relation to the level of selected
motor skills]. W: R. Bartoszewicz, T. Koszczyc, A. Nowak ( red.), Kontrola i ocena w wychowaniu
fizycznym 2003 (ss. 321-331). AWF, Wrocław, s. 321-331. y
y
13. Fugiel J. Zmienność rozwoju wybranych zdolności koordynacyjnych na tle budowy morfofunkcjonalnej
dzieci i młodzieży z terenów przemysłowych [The variability of the development of selected coordination
abilities against the background of the morphofunctional structure of children and adolescents from industrial
areas]. AWF, Wrocław, 2014. 14. Gierczuk D., Ljach W. Evaluating the coordination of motor abilities in Greco-Roman wrestlers by computer
testing. Human Movement 2012; 13(4), 323-329. 15. PISMIENNICTWO Wybrane przejawy sprawności motorycznej dziewcząt i chłopców w wieku 7-18 lat na tle ich
rozwoju morfologicznego [Selected manifestations of motor skills of girls and boys aged 7-18 against the
background of their morphological development]. AWF, Wrocław 2006. g
p
g
p
]
,
28. Mynarski W. Struktura wewnętrzna zdolności motorycznych dzieci i młodzieży w wieku 8–18 lat [The
internal structure of children's motor skills and young people aged 8-18]. AWF, Katowice 2000. 29. Łuczak A. Wiedeński System Testów w doborze osób do zawodów trudnych i niebezpiecznych [Viennese
Testing System in the selection of people for difficult professions and dangerous]. Bezpieczeństwo Pracy
2005; 2, 18-21. 30. Ostrowski A. Szybkość uczenia się pływania a wybrane uwarunkowania osobnicze dzieci w wieku 9-10 lat
[The speed of learning to swim and selected individual conditions of children aged 9-10]. AWF, Kraków 2011. 30. Ostrowski A. Szybkość uczenia się pływania a wybrane uwarunkowania osobnicze dzieci w wieku 9-10 lat
[The speed of learning to swim and selected individual conditions of children aged 9-10]. AWF, Kraków 2011. 31. Osiński W. Antropomotoryka. Wydanie II rozszerzone [Anthropomotorics. Second edition, extended]. AWF, 31. Osiński W. Antropomotoryka. Wydanie II rozszerzone [Anthropomotorics. Second edition, extended]. AWF,
Poznań 2003. 32. Raczek J. Tendencje przemian w rozwoju sprawności motorycznej populacji szkolnej [Tendencies of changes
in the development of motor skills of the school population.]. W: J. Raczek (red.), Motoryczność dzieci i
młodzieży – aspekty teoretyczne oraz implikacje metodyczne (ss. 257-265). AWF, Katowice 1986. 60 33. Raczek J. Koncepcja strukturalizacji i klasyfikacji motoryczności człowieka. W: W. Osiński (red.),
Motoryczność człowieka – jej struktura, zmienność i uwarunkowania (ss. 63-80). AWF, Poznań 1993. 34. Raczek J., Mynarski W., Ljach W. Kształtowanie i diagnozowanie koordynacyjnych zdolności motorycznych
[ Shaping and diagnosing coordination motor skills]. Podręcznik dla nauczycieli, trenerów i studentów. AWF,
Katowice 2002. 35. Raczek J. Antropomotoryka. Teoria motoryczności człowieka w zarysie [Anthropomotorics. Outline of the
theory of human motor skills]. PZWL, Warszawa 2010. 36. Riolo – Quinn L. (1991) Relationship of hand preference to accuracy on a thumb positioning task. Percept
Mot Skills 1991; 83, 267-273. 37. Rokita A., Bronikowski M., Popowczak M., Cichy I., Witkowski M. Precision and coordination parameters
of Polish elite cadet fencers. Medicina dello Sport 2014; 67(3), 369-381. 38. Rynkiewicz Struktura zdolności motorycznych oraz jej globalne i lokalne przejawy [Selected manifestations
of motor skills of girls. The structure of motor skills and its global and local manifestations]. AWF, Poznań
2003. 39. Rubacha K. PISMIENNICTWO Metodologia badań nad edukacją [Education research methodology]. Editions Spotkania Społka,
Warszawa 2016. 40. Sainburg R.L. Evidence for a dynamic-dominance hypothesis of handedness. Experimental Brain Research
2002; 142, 241-258. 41. Sankowski T. Wybrane psychologiczne aspekty aktywności sportowej [Selected psychological aspects of
sports activity]. AWF, Poznań 2001. y
42. Shumway-Cook, A., Woollacott, M. H. Motor control: Translating research into clinical practice. Wi
Wilkins, Philadelphia 2007. p
43. Sebastjan A., Skrzek A., Ignasiak Z., Sławińska T. Age-related changes in hand dominance and functional
asymmetry in older adults. PLoS ONE 2017; 12(5), 1-15, doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0177845. 44. Szopa J., Mleczko E., Żak S
Podstawy antropomotoryki [Fundamentals of anthropomotorics]. PWN,
Warszawa-Kraków 2000. 45. Waade B., Chrościelewski J., Przybylski S. Poziom koordynacji ruchowej a wynik pływacki u dzieci w
czteroletnim okresie wstępnego szkolenia pływackiego [The level of motor coordination and swimming score
in children in the four-year period of initial swimming training]. W: J. Migasiewicz, K. Zatoń ( red.), Sport
pływacki i lekkoatletyczny (ss. 75-83). AWF, Wrocław 2001 46. Wardana P., Hidayatullah M.F., Kiyatno K. The Influence of Learning Approach and Hand-Eye Coordination
on the Free Throw Results in Basketball Games. International Journal of Recent Engineering Science 2017;
4(4), 10-15. ( ),
47. Waśkiewicz Z. Wpływ wysiłków anaerobowych na wybrane aspekty koordynacji motorycznej [The impact of
anaerobic efforts on selected aspects of motor coordination]. AWF, Katowice 2002. 48. Wawrzyniak S. Sprawność grafomotoryczna, koordynacja oko-ręka i orientacja czasowo-przestrzenna
uczniów
klasy
pierwszej
szkół
podstawowej
uczestniczących
w
zajęciach
ruchowych
z
piłkami
edukacyjnymi ,,eduball". Maszynopis pracy doktorskiej, Wrocław 2016 yj y
y
p
p
y
j
49. Wieczorek, M. Uczymy się żonglowania [We learn to juggle]. Wychowanie Fizyczne i Zdrowotne 1999; 2: 9–
43. 50. Wieczorek M. Szybkość uczenia się złożonych czynności ruchowych a asymetria funkcjonalna i dynamiczna
dzieci 10-letnich [The speed of learning complex motor activities a functional and dynamic asymmetry of 10-
year-old children]. Maszynopis pracy doktorskiej, Wrocław 1997 51. Wołk R. Zdolność różnicowania kinestetycznego a szybkość motorycznego uczenia się [Kinesthetic
differentiation ability and speed of motor learning]. W: Jakubowski J., Wątroba J. (red.), Zastosowanie metod
statystycznych w badaniach naukowych (ss. 195-208). StatSoft, Kraków 2011. 52. Zetou E., Vernadakis N., Tsetseli M., Kampas A., Michalopoulou M. The effect of coordination training
program on learning tennis skills. The Sport Journal 2012; 15(1), 1-9. Attainment in Children Is Related to
Interceptive-Timing Ability. Psychological Science, 29(8),1334-1345. doi: 10.1177/0956797618772502. 61
|
https://openalex.org/W2188405496
|
https://jds-online.org/journal/JDS/article/590/file/pdf
|
English
| null |
Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates
|
Journal of data science
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 5,216
|
Journal of Data Science 9(2011), 625-637 Journal of Data Science 9(2011), 625-637 Lin Zhang1, Yan D. Zhao2∗and Jack D. Tubbs3
1Quintiles Inc., 2University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center and
3Baylor University Abstract: In this paper we consider clinical trials with two treatments and
a non-normally distributed response variable. In addition, we focus on ap-
plications which include only discrete covariates and their interactions. For
such applications, the semi-parametric Area Under the ROC Curve (AUC)
regression model proposed by Dodd and Pepe (2003) can be used. However,
because a logistic regression procedure is used to obtain parameter estimates
and a bootstrapping method is needed for computing parameter standard
errors, their method may be cumbersome to implement. In this paper we
propose to use a set of AUC estimates to obtain parameter estimates and
combine DeLong’s method and the delta method for computing parameter
standard errors. Our new method avoids heavy computation associated with
the Dodd and Pepe’s method and hence is easy to implement. We conduct
simulation studies to show that the two methods yield similar results. Fi-
nally, we illustrate our new method using data from urinary incontinence
clinical trials. Key words: AUC, discrete covariates, interaction, NAOV, ROC curve, semi-
parametric regression. ∗Corresponding author. 1. Introduction The Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test is a widely used nonparametric method
for comparing two treatments in clinical trials. In the presence of a discrete con-
founding stratum effect, the van Elteren (vE) test (van Elteren, 1960) is used to
adjust for the stratum effect. However, the vE test does not handle the inter-
action between treatment and the stratum effect. In this case, Dodd and Pepe
(2003) proposed an area under the curve (AUC) regression model which can test
the interaction. Their method can also be applied to models with both discrete
and continuous covariates. 626 Lin Zhang, Yan D. Zhao and Jack D. Tubbs The AUC regression model utilizes concepts relevant to the Receiver Oper-
ating Characteristic (ROC) curve. The ROC curve is a widely used statistical
tool for assessing the performance of a binary classifier with continuous or ordi-
nal variables. Its use has gained increased attention in various biostatistics areas
such as evaluating diagnostic tests, finding potential biomarkers, or analyzing
controlled clinical trials. The use of this statistical method has been extensively
developed since 1990’s. Pepe (2003) and Zhou et al. (2002) provide excellent
review on the ROC and its use. A useful application of ROC curve is in diagnostic testing when one has a
continuous variable Y , which will be used to classify the subjects into either
diseased (D) or non-diseased ( ¯D) groups according to some classification rule:
Y > c for the threshold c. The ROC(c) curve is the function given by plotting
P(Y > c | D) vs P(Y > c | ¯D) in a square from vertices (0, 0) to (1, 1) for all
possible thresholds, which displays how the true positive rate (TPR) is changed
as false positive rate (FPR) and provides a visible inspection of the accuracy of
the diagnostic test to make decision about the optimal threshold for the output
relying on the requirement for the relative importance of sensitivity and specificity
in the application (Dodd and Pepe, 2003). 1. Introduction In the two most extreme situations,
if the distribution of Y in the diseased group is exactly overlapped with the
distribution of Y in the non-diseased group, the ROC curve will be a diagonal
line from vertices (0, 0) to (1, 1), which means that the test with output Y is
same for FPR and TPR for all thresholds and is useless in classification; if the
distributions of Y in the two groups are totally separated from each other, the
ROC curve will be a curve passing through the vertex (0, 1), which means that
the test can easily select the threshold to guarantee the best classification in
sensitivity and specificity. The commonly used summary index for ROC curve is the area under the
ROC curve (AUC). It can be shown that AUC = P(YD > Y ¯D). Therefore, in the
worst case, the AUC is 0.5, that is, the ability to classify a subject into a right
group for this test is no more than by chance. While in the perfect case, the AUC
equals to 1, which represents that the probability of correct classification for a
proper threshold is 1. The estimated AUC can be derived from the Mann-Whitney U statistic for
testing the equality of two distributions. Based on this property Dodd and Pepe
(2003) proposed an AUC regression model for data with a non-normally dis-
tributed response variable which can adjust for continuous and discrete covari-
ates. In the model, the response variable is a cross-correlated bernoulli variable. Because the usual standard errors derived from a logistic regression model are
incorrect, they proposed to use bootstrapping method to estimate the variance
of non-parametric AUC and the model parameters. Because a logistic regression Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 627 procedure is used to obtain parameter estimates and a bootstrapping method is
needed for computing parameter standard errors, their method may be cumber-
some to implement. In practice, there are many applications which involves only discrete covariates
and their interactions. Such applications include testing the interaction between
treatment and subgroup variable in typical subgroup analysis in clinical trials. For such applications, we aim to alleviate the computation burden associated with
Dodd and Pepe. We propose to use a set of AUC estimates to obtain parameter
estimates and combine Delong’s method and the delta method for computing
parameter standard errors. 1. Introduction The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. The AUC regression
model by Dodd and Pepe is introduced in Section 2. DeLong’s method (DeLong,
DeLong and Clarke, 1998) for standard error estimation of the unadjusted AUC
is described in Section 3. Our newly proposed method for computing parame-
ter estimates and standard errors is developed in Section 4. Simulation studies
comparing Dodd and Pepe’s method and our method are presented in Section 5. A real data example is shown in Section 6 to illustrate our new method. Some
discussions can be found in Section 7. 2. Semi-Parametric AUC Regression Model In this section we review the semi-parametric AUC regression model proposed
by Dodd and Pepe. Assume that one needs to adjust the AUC for a covariate X,
the covariate-specific AUC can be expressed as AUCij = P
Y D
i
> Y
¯D
j
| Xi, Xj
, where Y D
i
is the ith response in diseased (or treatment) group with covariate value
Xi (i = 1, · · · , ND) and Y ¯D
j
is the jth response in non-diseased (or control) group
with covariate value Xj (j = 1, · · · , N ¯D). Often one is interested in estimating
the AUC at a specified covariate level, i.e. P
Y D
i
> Y ¯D
j
| Xi = Xj = X
. j
j
Dodd and Pepe applied this model to the Generalized Linear Model (GLM)
framework which allows one to model the AUC with covariates, in which case
their model can be written as, g(AUCij) = XT
ijβ,
(2.1) (2.1) where g is a monotone link function such as the probit or logit link, Xij is a
vector function of Xi and Xj, and β is a vector fixed and unknown parameters
to be estimated. Note that E
I
Y D
i
> Y
¯D
j
| Xij
= AUCij. 628 Lin Zhang, Yan D. Zhao and Jack D. Tubbs Thus, for estimating the parameters in the model, Dodd and Pepe proposed the
use of the logistic regression model where the response variable is a Bernoulli
variable I
Y D
i
> Y ¯D
j
. Dodd and Pepe demonstrated that the estimates of
parameters are found as solution to the usual score equations given by ND
X
i
N ¯
D
X
j
(Iij −AUCij)
V (Iij)
∂AUCij
∂β
,
(2.2) (2.2) where Iij = I(Y D
i
> Y ¯D
j ). Therefore, one obtains this estimate using standard
statistical software, such as SAS PROC GENMOD or PROC LOGISTIC. How-
ever, the usual standard errors of the estimates can not be used since the binary
variables Iij in equation (2.2) are not independent. Dodd and Pepe recommended
the bootstrap for obtaining the needed standard errors. Their procedure can be
summarized in the following steps in the presence of covariates: 1. Stratify the range of the covariate variable as S strata. 2. Semi-Parametric AUC Regression Model If the covariate is
discrete, each level of the covariate becomes a stratum. While for continuous
variable, it is impossible to make each covariate value a stratum. Cluster
the adjacent values into a stratum to ensure enough fitting data in each
stratum. 2. For discrete covariate, within each stratum s (s = 1, · · · , S), generate all of
the 0 or 1 indicator data as I(Y D
is > Y ¯D
js )(i = 1, · · · , ns
D ; j = 1, · · · , ns¯D). In this case, the model is g(AUCij) = β0 + βs. 3. If there is a continuous covariate in addition to the discrete covariate, other
parameters should be included in the model in order to fit the data obtained
by comparing two responses from different covariate values, such as I(Y D
is >
Y ¯D
js ) (the ith and jth outputs are from different covariate value but in the
same stratum s). The model can be expressed as g(AUCij) = β0 + β1Xi +
β2(Xi −Xj). 4. Use the standard logistic regression procedure to fit the data with strata as
covariate to obtain parameter estimates. 5. Bootstrap the original data within each stratum to compute the parameter
standard errors. The above procedure involves bootstrap so it is difficult to implement. For models
with only discrete covariates and their interactions, we aim to simplify the above
model fitting procedure. We propose a new algorithm which involves computing
variance of a non-parametric AUC estimate which was first proposed by the Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 629 DeLong, DeLong and Clarke (1998). This algorithm is described in detail in the
next section. DeLong, DeLong and Clarke (1998). This algorithm is described in detail in the
next section. 3. DeLong’s Method for Computing the Variance of Unadjusted AUC Several approaches have been proposed to compute the variance of the unad-
justed AUC. See Hanley and Hajian-Tilakin (1997) for a review. Among them,
the method provided by DeLong, DeLong, and Clarke (1988) is most widely used
and has the plain analytical structure, which completely relies on the Mann-
Whitney statistic. Bamber (1975) provided the equivalence between Mann-Whitney two-sample
rank sum statistic and the empirical estimate of AUC. When the outputs in
disease group and non-diseased group have ties, the nonparametric AUC can be
expressed as: [
AUC =
PND
i=1
PN ¯
D
j=1 Iij
NDN ¯D
,
(3.1) (3.1) where where Iij =
1,
Y D
i
> Y ¯D
j ,
1
2,
Y D
i
= Y ¯D
j ,
0,
Y D
i
< Y ¯D
j . Iij =
1,
Y D
i
> Y ¯D
j ,
1
2,
Y D
i
= Y ¯D
j ,
0,
Y D
i
< Y ¯D
j . The variance for (3.1) by DeLong’s method involves in two components which
are defined as
N V D
i
=
1
N ¯D
N ¯
D
X
j=1
Iij,
i = 1, · · · , ND,
V
¯D
j
=
1
ND
ND
X
i=1
Iij,
j = 1, · · · , N ¯D. V D
i
=
1
N ¯D
N ¯
D
X
j=1
Iij,
i = 1, · · · , ND,
V
¯D
j
=
1
ND
ND
X
i=1
Iij,
j = 1, · · · , N ¯D. and V
¯D
j
=
1
ND
ND
X
i=1
Iij,
j = 1, · · · , N ¯D. V D
i
is the percentage of Y ¯D’s that Y D
i
is bigger or equal to. It measures the
relative rank of the ith output of diseased group in the non-diseased group (i.e. its
relative percentile when Y D
i
is put into the non-diseased group). The explanation
for V ¯D
j
is similar. 3. DeLong’s Method for Computing the Variance of Unadjusted AUC j
An estimate of the variance of the nonparametric AUC is ˆV ( [
AUC) = s2
D
ND
+ s2¯D
N ¯D
,
(3.2) (3.2) where s2
D and s2¯D are the sample variances of
V D
i , i = 1, · · · , ND
and
V ¯D
j , j =
1, · · · , N ¯D
, respectively. 630 Lin Zhang, Yan D. Zhao and Jack D. Tubbs 4. A New Algorithm for Estimating Parameters and Standard Errors
for the AUC Regression Model 4. A New Algorithm for Estimating Parameters and Standard Errors
for the AUC Regression Model Our new algorithm is best described using an example. Let the covariate be
X with 2 levels specified as 0 and 1. The logistic regression model with link
function g can be expressed as g(AUC|X) = β0 + β1X. When X = 0, When X = 0, When X = 0,
g( [
AUC | X = 0) = g( [
AUC0) = ˆβ0,
and X = 1,
g( [
AUC | X = 1) = g( [
AUC1) = ˆβ0 + ˆβ1. ˆβ1 = g( [
AUC1) −g( [
AUC0), where [
AUC0 and [
AUC1 are computed using (3.1) and subseting observations
with X = 0 and X = 1, respectively. We see that the parameter estimates are
explicit functions of the AUC estimates at each stratum. Therefore, our new
method avoids the logistic regression procedure necessary by Dodd and Pepe’s
method. In the following we describe how to compute the standard errors for these
parameter estimates ˆβ0 and ˆβ1. Because the observations from two strata are
independent, the variance of ˆβ0 and ˆβ1 are, respectively, V (ˆβ0) = V (g( [
AUC0)), and and V (ˆβ1) = V (g( [
AUC1)) + V (g( [
AUC0)). and
V (ˆβ1) = V (g( [
AUC1)) + V (g( [
AUC0)). The above variance can be estimated by combining the delta method and (3.2). In
what follows we provide the variance estimates (standard errors) of the parameter
estimates for logit and probit links. When g is logit function, ˆV (g( [
AUCi)) =
ˆV ( [
AUCi)
[
AUC
2
i (1 −[
AUC
2
i )
. Let f(·) and Φ(·) be the PDF and the CDF of the standard normal distribution,
respectively. When g is probit function, ˆV (g( [
AUCi)) =
ˆV ( [
AUCi)
f2(Φ−1( [
AUCi))
. Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 631 Therefore, consistent estimators of V (ˆβ0) and V (ˆβ1) are ˆV (ˆβ0) = ˆV (g( [
AUC0)),
ˆV (ˆβ1) = ˆV (g( [
AUC0)) + ˆV (g( [
AUC1)), respectively. Finally, Wald-type 100(1 −α)% confidence intervals for βi, i = 1, 2,
can be constructed as ˆβi ± Zα/2
q
ˆV (ˆβi), where Zα/2 is the upper α/2th quantile of the standard normal distribution. The above procedure can be readily generalized to models with more than one
discrete covariates and their interactions. 4. A New Algorithm for Estimating Parameters and Standard Errors
for the AUC Regression Model First, computing AUC estimates using
(3.1) for each stratum resulting from all possible combinations of the covariates. Then, by equating the model parameters to these AUC estimates through the link
function, we can solve for parameter estimates. Finally, by combining (3.2) and
the delta method we obtain standard error estimates. In spirit, this approach is
very similar to the analysis of variance model in the normal-theory linear models. Therefore, we term our method as nonparametric analysis of variance method
(NAOV). 5. Simulation Study We conduct simulation studies to compare the Dodd and Pepe method and our
new NAOV method for estimating model parameters and their standard errors. In addition, we compare the two methods in terms of coverage probabilities of
the 95% confidence intervals for each parameter. Data are generated from models
with probit link and logit link, respectively. For each link function, we illustrate
the model using a discrete covariate with 3 strata. 5.1 Probit Link When the link function is probit, data is generated such that Y ¯D
ij ∼N(µ1i, σ2
1),
Y D
ij ∼N(µ2i, σ2
2), i = 1, · · · , S; j = 1, · · · , n, where µ1i = δ0 + δ2i and µ2i =
(δ0 + δ1) + (δ2i + δ3i). The parameters of the model with probit link can be
derived based on: AUCi = Φ
δ1 + δ3i
p
σ2
1 + σ2
2
! . (5.1) (5.1) When i = 1, let δ3i = 0, then AUC1 = Φ(β0) Lin Zhang, Yan D. Zhao and Jack D. Tubbs 632 AUCi = Φ (β0 + βi−1) , where β0 =
δ1
√
σ2
1+σ2
2
and βj =
δ3(j+1)
√
σ2
1+σ2
2
−β0 (j = 1, · · · , S −1). √
1
2
√
1
2
We choose δ0 = 0, δ1 = 0.15, δ2i = 0, δ32 = 0.5, δ33 = 1, σ1 = 1 and σ2 = 1.2
to compare the two methods. The simulation size is 1,000 and the number of
bootstrap samples is 200. Table 1 gives the comparison results for n = 30 and
n = 100. We see that both methods produce almost identical parameter estimates
and very similar standard error estimates. In addition, the coverage probabilities
of the 95% CIs are close to the nominal levels for both methods. Table 1: Comparison of parameter estimates, standard errors, and 95% CIs
for the model with probit link with 30 or 100 samples each group each level. Results represent 1000 realizations of the model and 200 bootstrap samples
each Dodd and Pepe
NAOV
n
Parameter
True
Estimate
Standard
Coverage
Standard
Coverage
Value
Error
95% CI
Error
95% CI
30
β0
0.15
0.16
0.20
0.965
0.19
0.958
β1
0.50
0.52
0.29
0.951
0.28
0.945
β2
1.00
1.03
0.32
0.970
0.30
0.951
100
β0
0.15
0.15
0.10
0.952
0.10
0.950
β1
0.50
0.50
0.15
0.937
0.15
0.939
β2
1.00
1.00
0.16
0.954
0.16
0.954 5.2 Logit Link When logit link is used, we generate data Y ¯D
i
= −log(u1) + δ1i and Y D
i
=
−log(u2) + δ0 + (δ1i + δ2i), where u1 ∼exponential(1) and u2 ∼exponential(1). The parameters in the model can be derived based on: AUCi = F(δ0 + δ2i),
(5.2) (5.2) where F(·) is a CDF of a logistic r.v. ∼Lo(0, π2/3) and F(x) =
1
1+e−x (see
reference from Balakrishnan and Nevzorov, 2003). where F(·) is a CDF of a logistic r.v. ∼Lo(0, π2/3) and F(x) =
1
1+e−x (see
reference from Balakrishnan and Nevzorov, 2003). When i = 1, let δ2i = 0, then When i = 1, let δ2i = 0, then AUC1 = F(β0) AUC1 = F(β0) Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 633 Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 633 Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 633
nd when i = 2, · · · , S, Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 633
and when i = 2, · · · , S, and when i = 2, · · · , S, AUCi = F (β0 + βi−1) , where β0 = δ0 and βj = δ2(j+1) (j = 1, · · · , S −1). where β0 = δ0 and βj = δ2(j+1) (j = 1, · · · , S −1). where β0 = δ0 and βj = δ2(j+1) (j = 1, · · · , S −1). j
(j+ ) (
)
We choose δ0 = 0.15, δ1i = 0, δ22 = 0.5 and δ23 = 1. The number of bootstrap
samples is 200. Table 2 gives the comparison results for n = 30 and n = 100
in each group in each level, respectively. We see that both methods produce
almost identical parameter estimates and very similar standard error estimates. In addition, the coverage probabilities of the 95% CIs are close to the nominal
levels for both methods. Table 2: Comparison of parameter estimates, standard errors, and 95% CIs for
the model with logit link with 30 or 100 samples each group each level. 5.2 Logit Link Results
represent 1000 realizations of the model and 200 bootstrap samples each Dodd and Pepe
NAOV
n
Parameter
True
Estimate
Standard
Coverage
Standard
Coverage
Value
Error
95% CI
Error
95% CI
30
β0
0.15
0.14
0.32
0.963
0.31
0.959
β1
0.50
0.53
0.46
0.958
0.45
0.947
β2
1.00
1.03
0.49
0.971
0.47
0.955
100
β0
0.15
0.15
0.17
0.956
0.17
0.952
β1
0.50
0.51
0.24
0.952
0.24
0.950
β2
1.00
1.00
0.25
0.957
0.25
0.951 6. Real Data Example The overall model is logit(AUC(HORM50, BIEF)) = β0 + g (
(
,
))
β0 +
β1I(HORM50 = 0) + β2I(BIEF = 1) + β3I(BIEF = 2) + β4I(BIEF = 3) +
β5I(BIEF = 1 & HORM50 = 0)+β6I(BIEF = 2 & HORM50 = 0)+β7I(BIEF =
3 & HORM50 = 0). Table 3 shows the AUC estimates, 95% CI of the AUC, and the expression
of AUC in terms of the model parameters by the combination levels of the two
covariates. By equating the third column and the fifth column of Table 3, we
can solve for estimates for the model parameters β0, · · · , β7. These parameter
estimates are presented in the third column of Table 4. The standard errors and
95% CIs for the model parameters are computed using the procedure described in
Section 4 and displayed in the fourth and fifth columns of Table 4. By examining
these CIs we see that the main effect of HORM50 and the interaction effects are
not significant at .05 level, indicating there are no interactions between BIEF and
HORM 50 and HORM50 is not predictive of treatment effect. The CI for β3 does
not include 0, indicating BIEF is predictive of treatment effect. We fit another model with only BIEF main effect and the results are shown
in Table 5. The CIs indicate that β1 and β2 are significantly different from 0 at
.05 level, which means BIEF is a predictive of treatment effect. Note that β3 is
not significantly different from 0 at .05 level, possibly due to thet fact that only
a small percentage of patients are in that very severe stratum. Parameters β1 to
β3 have meaningful interpretations. For example, eβ1 is the odds ratio that the
active drug is better than placebo in the second stratum of BIEF compared with
that in the first stratum of BIEF. In this case, that odds ratio is estimated as
eˆβ1 = 1.4. 6. Real Data Example In this section we illustrate our new NAOV method using real data from
clinical trials. The purpose of the clinical trials is to investigate the efficacy
of an active drug to treat stress urinary incontinence in women by comparing
with placebo. The data are provided by a pharmaceutical company and not
publicly available. The response variable is the per cent (relative) reduction
in incontinence episode frequency (PIEF) from baseline to the last postbaseline
visit. There is a variable reflecting the disease severity at the baseline (BIEF)
with 4 strata. The variable BIEF takes values from 1 (mild) to 4 (severe). Also,
the consistency of treatment effect across another covariate of interest HORM50
needs to be considered. The variable HORM50 indicates whether a woman has
hormone replacement (yes or no). In summary, we are interested in analyzing the
joint predictive and prognostic effects of BIEF and HORM50. For this analysis a
total of 4940 subjects with nonmissing PIEF, BIEF, and HORM50 are included. 634 Lin Zhang, Yan D. Zhao and Jack D. Tubbs The distribution of PIEF variable is very skewed in each group. In a nat-
ural way, we can use AUC regression model to adjust the covariate effect to
treatment effect. The overall model is logit(AUC(HORM50, BIEF)) = β0 +
β1I(HORM50 = 0) + β2I(BIEF = 1) + β3I(BIEF = 2) + β4I(BIEF = 3) +
β5I(BIEF = 1 & HORM50 = 0)+β6I(BIEF = 2 & HORM50 = 0)+β7I(BIEF =
3 & HORM50 = 0). The distribution of PIEF variable is very skewed in each group. In a nat-
ural way, we can use AUC regression model to adjust the covariate effect to
treatment effect. The overall model is logit(AUC(HORM50, BIEF)) = β0 +
β1I(HORM50 = 0) + β2I(BIEF = 1) + β3I(BIEF = 2) + β4I(BIEF = 3) +
β5I(BIEF = 1 & HORM50 = 0)+β6I(BIEF = 2 & HORM50 = 0)+β7I(BIEF =
3 & HORM50 = 0). The distribution of PIEF variable is very skewed in each group. In a nat-
ural way, we can use AUC regression model to adjust the covariate effect to
treatment effect. 6. Real Data Example Table 3: Estimates of AUC for the example
BIEF
HORM50
AUC Estimate
95% CI by DeLong
AUC in terms of model parameters
1
0
.467
(.306, .629)
1/(1 + exp(−β0 −β4 −β1 −β5))
1
.531
(.393, .670)
1/(1 + exp(−β0 −β1))
2
0
.583
(.510, .657)
1/(1 + exp(−β0 −β4 −β2 −β6))
1
.519
(.447, .592)
1/(1 + exp(−β0 −β2))
3
0
.589
(.507, .671)
1/(1 + exp(−β0 −β4 −β3 −β7))
1
.713
(.628, .798)
1/(1 + exp(−β0 −β3))
4
0
.606
(.534, .679)
1/(1 + exp(−β0 −β4))
1
.667
(.604, .731)
1/(1 + exp(−β0)) Table 3: Estimates of AUC for the example Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 635
Table 4: Parameter estimates and 95% CI by NOAV with interactions for the
example Parameter
Level
Estimate
SE
95% CI
β0
Intercept
−0.70
0.15
(−0.99, −0.41)
β1
HORM50 = 0
0.27
0.21
(−0.15, 0.68)
β2
BIEF = 1
0.57
0.32
(−0.05, 1.20)
β3
BIEF = 2
0.62
0.21
(0.21, 1.03)
β4
BIEF = 3
−0.21
0.26
(−0.72, 0.29)
β5
BIEF = 1 and HORM50 = 0
−0.01
0.53
(−1.04, 1.02)
β6
BIEF = 2 and HORM50 = 0
−0.52
0.37
(−1.24, 0.19)
β7
BIEF = 3 and HORM50 = 0
0.29
0.40
(−0.50, 1.08)
Table 5: Parameter estimates and 95% CI by NOAV with only BIEF main
effect for the example Table 5: Parameter estimates and 95% CI by NOAV with only BIEF main
effect for the example Parameter
Level
Estimate
SE
95% CI
β0
Intercept
−0.56
0.06
(−0.67, −0.45)
β1
BIEF = 1
0.37
0.15
(0.07, 0.67)
β2
BIEF = 2
0.19
0.08
(0.03, 0.35)
β3
BIEF = 3
0.09
0.09
(−0.08, 0.27) 7. Discussion In this article, we developed an analytical NAOV method to computing pa-
rameter estimates and standard errors for the semi-parametric AUC regression
model with only discrete covariates. The NAOV method involves only straight-
forward computations and is much easier to implement than the Dodd and Pepe
method. Simulation studies have shown that both methods yield similar results. The NAOV method involves computing AUC estimates and standard errors
at each cell of combination levels of all the covariates. Therefore, it requires a
reasonable amount of observations at each cell. When there are empty cells, a
saturated model can not be fitted and so some terms need to be dropped from
the model. This is the same problem suffered by linear models and the Dodd and
Pepe’s method. Note that in Tables 1 and 2, we set the true parameters values to be different
than zero. However, even when the sample size is 100, some of the 95% confidence
intervals of these parameters contain zero. This may yield a conclusion that
the parameters are not significantly away from zero. We remark that this is a
phenomenon we often encounter when the sample size is not sufficiently large. So if we increase the sample size, then these confidence intervals will become
narrower and exclude zero. 636 Lin Zhang, Yan D. Zhao and Jack D. Tubbs Note that Tables 1 and 2 are based on different models, so it may not be
appropriate to compare results between Table 1 and 2. In our experience, for the
same model, using probit or logit links gives very similar results. This is also true
from the literature for generalized linear models. In general, researchers tend to
use logit links because it is easier to interpret the parameters. Although Dodd and Pepe’s method can be used for models with both discrete
and continuous covariates, their method involves somewhat arbitrary grouping
of observations in the presence of continuous covariates. For future research,
we intend to generalize the NAOV method to models with both discrete and
continuous covariates. Acknowledgements We thank the editor and anonymous referees for the insightful and construc-
tive comments which have improved the presentation of this paper. References Balakrishnan, N. and Nevzorov, V. B. (2003). A Primer on Statistical Distri-
butions. Wiley, Hoboken, New Jersey. Bamber, D. (1975). The area above the ordinal dominance graph and the area
below the receiver operating characteristic graph. Journal of Mathematical
Psychology 12, 387-415. Brumback, L. C., Pepe, M. S. and Alonzo, T. A. (2006). Using the ROC curve
for gauging treatment effect in clinical trials. Statistics in Medicine 25,
575-590. DeLong, E. R., DeLong, D. and Clarke-Pearson, D. (1988). Comparing the
areas under two or more correlated receiver operating characteristic curves:
a nonparametric approach. Biometrics 44, 837-845. Dodd, L. E. and Pepe, M. S. (2003). Semiparametric regression for the area
under the receiver operating characteristic curve. Journal of the American
Statistical Association 98, 409-417. Hanley, J. A. and Hajian-Tilaki, K. O. (1997). Sampling variability of nonpara-
metric estimate of the areas under receiver operating characteristic curves:
an update. Academic Radiology 4, 49-58. Inference for Semiparametric AUC Regression Models with Discrete Covariates 637 Pepe, M. S. (2003). The Statistical Evaluation of Medical Tests for Classification
and Prediction. Oxford Statistical Science Series 28, Oxford University
Press, New York. Van Elteren P. H. (1960). On the combination of independent two sample tests
of Wilcoxon. Bulletin of the Institute of International Statistics 37, 351-
361. Zhou, X. H., McClish, D. K. and Obuchowski, N. A. (2002). Statistical Methods
in Diagnostic Medicine. Wiley, New York. Zhou, X. H., McClish, D. K. and Obuchowski, N. A. (2002). Statistical Methods
in Diagnostic Medicine. Wiley, New York. Received January 12, 2010; accepted May 4, 2011. Lin Zhang
Quintiles Inc. Overland Park, KS 66213, USA
lin.zhang@quintiles.com. Yan D. Zhao
Department of Clinical Sciences and Simmons Cancer Center
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center
Dallas, TX 75390, USA
yandzhao@gmail.com Yan D. Zhao
Department of Clinical Sciences and Simmons Cancer Center
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center
Dallas, TX 75390, USA
yandzhao@gmail.com Jack D. Tubbs
Department of Statistical Science
Baylor University
Waco, TX 76798, USA
Jack Tubbs@baylor.edu Jack D. Tubbs
Department of Statistical Science
Baylor University
Waco, TX 76798, USA
Jack Tubbs@baylor.edu
|
https://openalex.org/W2530873173
|
http://journals.iucr.org/e/issues/2016/11/00/pk2592/pk2592.pdf
|
English
| null |
Synthesis and crystal structure of La<sub>21</sub>Cr<sub>8−2<i>a</i></sub>Al<sub><i>b</i></sub>Ge<sub>7−<i>b</i></sub>C<sub>12</sub>[<i>a</i>= 0.22 (2) and<i>b</i>= 0.758 (19)]
|
Acta crystallographica. Section E, Crystallographic communications
| 2,016
|
cc-by
| 5,297
|
research communications research communications Jaskarun Pabla, Yuri Janssen and Jack W. Simonson* Department of Physics, Farmingdale State College, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA. *Correspondence e-mail:
jack.simonson@farmingdale.edu Received 9 September 2016
Accepted 4 October 2016 Received 9 September 2016
Accepted 4 October 2016 Single crystals of a new multinary chromium carbide, La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12
(henicosalanthanum
octachromium
aluminium
hexagermanium
dodeca-
carbide), were grown from an La-rich self flux and were characterized by
single-crystal X-ray diffraction. The face-centered cubic crystal structure is
composed of isolated and geometrically frustrated regular Cr tetrahedra that are
co-centered within regular C octahedra. These mutually separated Cr4aC6
clusters are distributed throughout a three-dimensional framework of Al, Ge,
and La. The title compound is isotypic with La21Mn8X7C12 and R21Fe8X7C12
(R = La, Ce, Pr; X = Al, Bi, Ge, Sn, Sb, Te) and represents the first example of a
Cr-based compound with this structure-type. Edited by S. Parkin, University of Kentucky, USA Keywords: crystal structure; geometric frustra-
tion; multinary chromium carbides. CCDC reference: 1508202 Supporting information: this article has
supporting information at journals.iucr.org/e Supporting information: this article has
supporting information at journals.iucr.org/e 1. Chemical context Synthesis and crystal structure of
La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12 [a = 0.22 (2) and
b = 0.758 (19)] ISSN 2056-9890 ISSN 2056-9890 research communications Synthesis and crystal structure of
La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12 [a = 0.22 (2) and
b = 0.758 (19)] research communications the ab plane. The structure can be thought to be composed of
three building blocks – a geometrically frustrated and Cr-
deficient Cr4aC6 unit (Fig. 1c), an La9Ge6 unit (Fig. 1d), and
an La12AlbGe1b unit (Fig. 1e). These substructures are
arranged on four interpenetrating face-centered cubic lattices
that originate within the unit cell at (1
4, 1
4, 1
4) and (3
4, 1
4, 1
4) for the
Cr4aC6 unit, (1
2, 0, 0) for the La9Ge6 unit, and (0, 0, 0) for the
La12AlbGe1-b
unit. Accordingly,
La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12
adopts a structure that is effectively a polyatomic analog of
the Heusler structure (Graf et al., 2011) with composition
X2YZ, where X = Cr4aC6, Y = La9Ge6, and Z = La12AlbGe1b
units. Taken together with the appropriate site occupancies,
the
title
composition
is
thus
obtained
as
X2YZ
=
La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12. similar cusps occurring at T = 3 K and 6 K in 0 exhibit no such
dependence, even over four orders of magnitude in f,
suggesting that only local antiferromagnetic ordering within
the Mn4C6 cluster arises while the spin glass state remains
absent down to T = 1.8 K (Zaikina et al., 2011). With the aim of
unveiling a new avenue to explore frustrated states within this
class of compounds, we present here the synthesis and crystal
structure of a new Cr-based analog that is isostructural and
likewise geometrically frustrated, La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12,
[a = 0.22 (2), b = 0.758 (19)]. similar cusps occurring at T = 3 K and 6 K in 0 exhibit no such
dependence, even over four orders of magnitude in f,
suggesting that only local antiferromagnetic ordering within
the Mn4C6 cluster arises while the spin glass state remains
absent down to T = 1.8 K (Zaikina et al., 2011). With the aim of
unveiling a new avenue to explore frustrated states within this
class of compounds, we present here the synthesis and crystal
structure of a new Cr-based analog that is isostructural and
likewise geometrically frustrated, La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12,
[a = 0.22 (2), b = 0.758 (19)]. 1. Chemical context Geometric frustration arises when crystallographic degen-
eracies lead to the near equalization of competing interatomic
interactions. Often, such frustration results in the suppression
to an arbitrarily low temperature of any eventual phase
transition to an ordered ground state (Gilbert et al., 2016). In
the simplest case, this phenomenon occurs when three anti-
ferromagnetic exchange-coupled Ising spins are arranged on
the vertices of an equilateral triangle, their counterbalanced
interactions thereby precluding the transition to mutually
energetically favorable magnetic order. The ability to tune the
onset of order via geometric frustration has been shown to
lead to a variety of intriguing properties, including magnetic
monopoles (Pan et al., 2016), spin ice states (Hirschberger et
al., 2015; Huang et al., 2016), tricritical phenomena (McNally
et al., 2015), and quantum criticality (Miiller et al., 2016), with
applications ranging from neural networks (Grass et al., 2016),
to quantum computing (Katzgraber et al., 2015), to uncon-
ventional superconductivity (Glasbrenner et al., 2015). Over
the last decades, a class of materials known as pyrochlores has
provided a rich ground for studying magnetic frustration due
to geometric degeneracies arising from their vertex-linked,
regular tetrahedral building blocks (Gardner et al., 2010). The
structure of the La21Fe8Sn7C12 system also consists regular
tetrahedra of Fe, but in this case they are mutually isolated
from one another. Here too, geometric frustration has been
observed to manifest itself in a spin glass ground state, as
inferred from a frequency f-dependent cusp in the real part of
measurements of ac magnetic susceptibility 0 near tempera-
ture T = 5 K (Benbow et al., 2009). On the other hand, if Fe is
replaced with Mn as in isostructural La21Mn8Ge6.2Al0.8C12, http://dx.doi.org/10.1107/S2056989016015668
15 Acta Cryst. (2016). E72, 1565–1568 research communications research communications Table 1
Experimental details. Crystal data
Chemical formula
La21Cr7.556Al0.758Ge6.242C12
Mr
3927.6
Crystal system, space group
Cubic, Fm3m
Temperature (K)
294
a (A˚ )
16.4048 (6)
V (A˚ 3)
4414.8 (5)
Z
4
Radiation type
Mo K
(mm1)
25.76
Crystal size (mm)
0.12 0.11 0.07
Data collection
Diffractometer
Bruker APEXII CCD
Absorption correction
Numerical (SADABS; Bruker,
2008)
Tmin, Tmax
0.342, 0.527
No. of measured, independent and
observed [I > 3(I)] reflections
40979, 328, 321
Rint
0.041
(sin /)max (A˚ 1)
0.670
Refinement
R[F > 3(F)], wR(F), S
0.012, 0.045, 1.91
No. of reflections
328
No. of parameters
21
max, min (e A˚ 3)
1.07, 0.83
Computer programs: APEX2 and SAINT (Bruker, 2007), SUPERFLIP (Palatinus &
Chapuis, 2007), JANA2006 (Petrˇı`cˇek et al., 2014), VESTA (Momma & Izumi, 2011) and
publCIF (Westrip, 2010). Table 1
Experimental details. Crystal data
Chemical formula
La21Cr7.556Al0.758Ge6.242C12
Mr
3927.6
Crystal system, space group
Cubic, Fm3m
Temperature (K)
294
a (A˚ )
16.4048 (6)
V (A˚ 3)
4414.8 (5)
Z
4
Radiation type
Mo K
(mm1)
25.76
Crystal size (mm)
0.12 0.11 0.07
Data collection
Diffractometer
Bruker APEXII CCD
Absorption correction
Numerical (SADABS; Bruker,
2008)
Tmin, Tmax
0.342, 0.527
No. of measured, independent and
observed [I > 3(I)] reflections
40979, 328, 321
Rint
0.041
(sin /)max (A˚ 1)
0.670
Refinement
R[F > 3(F)], wR(F), S
0.012, 0.045, 1.91
No. of reflections
328
No. of parameters
21
max, min (e A˚ 3)
1.07, 0.83
Computer programs: APEX2 and SAINT (Bruker, 2007), SUPERFLIP (Palatinus &
Chapuis, 2007), JANA2006 (Petrˇı`cˇek et al., 2014), VESTA (Momma & Izumi, 2011) and
publCIF (Westrip, 2010). wise, all Cr—Cr distances within the substructure are similarly
identical at 2.4821 (9) A˚ , only slightly smaller than the 2.512 A˚
nearest neighbor distance observed in Cr metal (Gorbunoff et
al., 2009). Perhaps more interesting, however, is this relative
proximity when compared with the 2.878 A˚ that separates
neighboring
Cr
in
the
frustrated
Kagome´
planes
of
SrCr8xGa4+xO19, a seminal example of a geometrically
frustrated magnetic system (Broholm et al., 1990). La21Cr7.556Al0.758Ge6.242C12
3927.6
Cubic, Fm3m
294
16.4048 (6)
4414.8 (5)
4
Mo K
25.76
0.12 0.11 0.07 The remaining substructures, namely the La9Ge6 unit
shown in Fig. 1d and the La12AlbGe1b unit shown in Fig. 1e
form cages about their central La3 and Al2/Ge2 sites
respectively. research communications Synthesis and crystallization 3. Synthesis and crystallization La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12 crystals were grown from a self flux of
excess La (Alfa Aesar, 00175) and the following chemicals: Cr
(Alfa Aesar, 38494), Ge (Strategic Metal, SM1301-B), and
graphite (McMaster-Carr 9121K71) in an La:Cr:Ge:C atomic
ratio of 561:214:76:149. The growth process was carried out in
Al2O3 crucibles sealed within fused quartz ampoules under
high purity Ar gas. Ampoules were heated to 1423 K over a
period of four h, left to soak at that temperature for an
additional four h, and cooled to 1173 K over 50 h to induce
nucleation and to promote crystal growth. The ampoule was
then quickly centrifuged at 2000 r.p.m. for several seconds to
separate the solid crystals from the liquid La-rich solution. Crystals took the form of well-faceted tablets with metallic
luster. In addition to mixing on the Al2/Ge2 site, excess charge was
observed in Fourier maps when the Cr site was constrained to
full occupancy, and the refinement was substantially improved
when this parameter was subsequently freed. Permitting
instead partial occupancy of Al on the Cr site did not appre-
ciably improve the refinement. No evidence for mixed or non-
unity occupancy was found for any of the La sites, despite
previously published density functional theory calculations
that found a composition of La20Mn8Te7C12 to be stabilized by
the shift of the Fermi energy to a pseudogap in the density of
states (Zaikina et al., 2011). Our final refined composition is 2. Structural commentary Fig. 1 shows a polyhedral representation of the crystal struc-
ture of the title compound, the geometrically frustrated
substructure of which consists of a Cr-capped regular tetra-
hedron enclosed within a C-capped regular octahedron. Fig. 1a
is a depiction of the unit cell from along the crystallographic a
axis, and Fig. 1b shows the same from a generic angle above The geometrically frustrated Cr-deficient Cr4aC6 unit
shown in Fig. 1c is composed of a single inequivalent Cr
position and a single C position. Accordingly, nearest neighbor
Cr—C distances are uniformly 1.949 (5) A˚ , in good agreement
with nearest neighbor distances in binary Cr carbides. Like- Figure 1
a) A view of the crystal structure of La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12 along [100]. (b) The same crystal structure from an arbitrary view above the ab plane. (c)
Cr-deficient Cr4aC6 substructure depicted as four tetrahedrally arranged and vertex-linked CrC3 plaquettes. (d) La3 coordination polyhedron. (e) Al2/
Ge2 coordination polyhedron. In all sub-figures, colors are as follows: La (white), Cr (red), Al (green), Ge (blue), and C (black). Polyhedra are colored
ccording to the central element. In c–e, the ellipsoids correspond to 99% probability. 1 Figure 1 Figure 1
(a) A view of the crystal structure of La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12 along [100]. (b) The same crystal structure from an arbitrary view above the ab plane. (c)
Cr-deficient Cr4aC6 substructure depicted as four tetrahedrally arranged and vertex-linked CrC3 plaquettes. (d) La3 coordination polyhedron. (e) Al2/
Ge2 coordination polyhedron. In all sub-figures, colors are as follows: La (white), Cr (red), Al (green), Ge (blue), and C (black). Polyhedra are colored
according to the central element. In c–e, the ellipsoids correspond to 99% probability. 1566
Pabla et al. La21Cr7.556Al0.758Ge6.242C12 Acta Cryst. (2016). E72, 1565–1568 research communications research communications The cage-like nature of this configuration is clear
from the large anisotropic displacement parameters Ueq
corresponding to these two central sites, as has been
previously observed in isostructural materials (Benbow et al.,
2009; Zaikina et al., 2011). These sites are likely characterized
by strong rattling modes of the central loosely bound atom,
such as is observed in skutterudite compounds (Sergueev et al.,
2015). Not surprisingly, the distance between central La3 and
its nearest neighbor Ge1 is a rather long, 3.41450 (13) A˚ . The
central Al2/Ge2 site is even further – 3.8858 (2) A˚ from its
nearest neighbor La1. A brief review of the crystallographic
literature finds nearest neighbor bond lengths in La—Ge
binaries to be typically on the order of only 3.0 to 3.2 A˚ , far
smaller than either of these distances, which lends credence to
the emerging picture of a stuffed, skutterudite-like arrange-
ment. Tmin, Tmax
No. of measured, independent and
observed [I > 3(I)] reflections
Rint
(sin /)max (A˚ 1) Refinement
R[F > 3(F)], wR(F), S
No. of reflections
No. of parameters
max, min (e A˚ 3) Refinement
R[F > 3(F)], wR(F), S
No. of reflections
No. of parameters
max, min (e A˚ 3) Computer programs: APEX2 and SAINT (Bruker, 2007), SUPERFLIP (Palatinus &
Chapuis, 2007), JANA2006 (Petrˇı`cˇek et al., 2014), VESTA (Momma & Izumi, 2011) and
publCIF (Westrip, 2010). The refinement was improved when the Ge2 site was
permitted to be mixed with Al. In this case, Al and Ge
coordinates and displacement parameters were constrained to
be equal, and the sum of the Al and Ge occupancies was
constrained
to
unity. The
refined
Al:Ge
ratio
0.758 (19):6.242 (19) is in excellent agreement with observed
ratios of 0.83 (2):6.17 (2) in La21MnAlbGe7bC12 (Zaikina et
al., 2011) and somewhat lower than the reported ratio of
2.1:4.9 in La21FeAlbGe7-bC12 (Benbow et al., 2009). Like the
Mn-based analog, however, we observe no evidence to suggest
that the Ge1 site is mixed, as was the case with the more Al-
rich La21FeAlbGe7bC12. Regardless of any quantitative
differences, the potential for Al – apparently extracted by an
La-rich flux from Al2O3 growth crucibles – to mix with Ge
appears to be a universal phenomenon in this class of
compounds. It remains unclear if Al is required to stabilize the
Ge-containing examples of these phases, which have not been
reported in its absence. 3. Acknowledgements Acknowledgment is made to the Donors of the American
Chemical Society Petroleum Research Fund for support of
this research under contract 56764-UNI10. We are likewise
grateful to M. C. Aronson for providing access to the Bruker
APEXII single-crystal diffractometer at Brookhaven National
Laboratory. JWS was supported in part by a Provost’s
Research Fellowship from Farmingdale State College. Hirschberger, M., Krizan, J. W., Cava, R. J. & Ong, N. P. (2015). Science, 348, 106–109. Huang, Y., Chen, K., Deng, Y., Prokof’ev, N. & Svistunov, B. (2016). Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 177203. Katzgraber, H. G., Hamze, F., Zhu, Z., Ochoa, A. J. & Munoz-Bauza,
H. (2015). Phys. Rev. X, 5, 031026. (
)
y
McNally, D. E., Simonson, J. W., Kistner-Morris, J. J., Smith, G. J., Hassinger, J. E., DeBeer-Schmitt, L., Kolesnikov, A. I., Zaliznyak, I. A. & Aronson, M. C. (2015). Phys. Rev. B, 91, 180407. Miiller, W., Wu, L. S., Kim, M. S., Orvis, T., Simonson, J. W., (
)
Miiller, W., Wu, L. S., Kim, M. S., Orvis, T., Simonson, J. W., Gamz˙a, M., McNally, D. M., Nelson, C. S., Ehlers, G., Podlesnyak, A.,
Helton, J. S., Zhao, Y., Qiu, Y., Copley, J. R. D., Lynn, J. W.,
Zaliznyak, I. & Aronson, M. C. (2016). Phys. Rev. B, 93, 104419. research communications then La21Cr82aAlbGe7bC12 with the occupancy parameters
a = 0.22 (2) and b = 0.758 (19). Gorbunoff, A., Levin, A. A. & Meyer, D. C. (2009). J. Alloys Compd. 480, 152–156. Graf, T., Felser, C. & Parkin, S. S. P. (2011). Prog. Solid State Chem. 39, 1–50. Grass, T., Ravento´s, D., Julia´-Dı´az, B., Gogolin, C. & Lewenstein, M. (2016). Nat. Commun. 7, 11524. 4. Refinement details Details regarding the crystal itself, as well as data collection
and structural refinement are presented in Table 1. No
evidence for twin domains was observed, and all sites with the
exception of C were refined with anisotropic displacement
parameters. Here permitting anisotropic displacement para-
meters did not appreciably improve the refinement. Two
reflections, (111) and (002), required manual culling due to
beamstop clipping. Pabla et al. La21Cr7.556Al0.758Ge6.242C12 1567 Acta Cryst. (2016). E72, 1565–1568 Acta Cryst. (2016). E72, 1565–1568 Fernandes, R. M. & Valentı´, R. (2015). Nat. Phys. 11, 953–958. Jaskarun Pabla, Yuri Janssen and Jack W. Simonson Computing details Data collection: APEX2 (Bruker, 2007) and SAINT (Bruker, 2007); cell refinement: APEX2 (Bruker, 2007) and SAINT
(Bruker, 2007); data reduction: APEX2 (Bruker, 2007) and SAINT (Bruker, 2007); program(s) used to solve structure:
SUPERFLIP (Palatinus & Chapuis, 2007); program(s) used to refine structure: JANA2006 (Petřìček et al., 2014);
molecular graphics: VESTA (Momma & Izumi, 2011); software used to prepare material for publication: publCIF
(Westrip, 2010). Henicosalanthanum octachromium alumimium hexagermanium dodecacarbide Crystal data
La21Cr7.556Al0.758Ge6.242C12
Mr = 3927.6
Cubic, Fm3m
Hall symbol: -F 4 2 3
a = 16.4048 (6) Å
V = 4414.8 (5) Å3
Z = 4
F(000) = 6639.4
Dx = 5.909 Mg m−3
Mo Kα radiation, λ = 0.71073 Å
Cell parameters from 9327 reflections
θ = 5.0–56.7°
µ = 25.76 mm−1
T = 294 K
Plate, metallic_black
0.12 × 0.11 × 0.07 mm Crystal data
La21Cr7.556Al0.758Ge6.242C12
Mr = 3927.6
Cubic, Fm3m
Hall symbol: -F 4 2 3
a = 16.4048 (6) Å
V = 4414.8 (5) Å3
Z = 4
F(000) = 6639.4 References Benbow, E. M., Dalal, N. S. & Latturner, S. E. (2009). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 131, 3349–3354. Broholm, C., Aeppli, G., Espinosa, G. P. & Cooper, A. S. (1990). Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 3173–3176. Bruker (2007). APEX2 and SAINT. Bruker AXS Inc., Madison,
Wisconsin, USA. Bruker (2008). SADABS. Bruker AXS Inc., Madison, Wisconsin,
USA. Gardner, J. S., Gingras, M. J. P. & Greedan, J. E. (2010). Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 53–107. Gilbert, I., Nisoli, C. & Schiffer, P. (2016). Phys. Today, 69, 54–59. Glasbrenner, J. K., Mazin, I. I., Jeschke, H. O., Hirschfeld, P. J.,
Fernandes R M & Valentı´ R (2015) Nat Phys 11 953–958 Benbow, E. M., Dalal, N. S. & Latturner, S. E. (2009). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 131, 3349–3354. Benbow, E. M., Dalal, N. S. & Latturner, S. E. (2009). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 131, 3349–3354. Broholm, C., Aeppli, G., Espinosa, G. P. & Cooper, A. S. (1990). Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 3173–3176. Bruker (2007). APEX2 and SAINT. Bruker AXS Inc., Madison,
Wisconsin, USA. Bruker (2008). SADABS. Bruker AXS Inc., Madison, Wisconsin,
USA. Gardner, J. S., Gingras, M. J. P. & Greedan, J. E. (2010). Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 53–107. Gilbert, I., Nisoli, C. & Schiffer, P. (2016). Phys. Today, 69, 54–59. Glasbrenner, J. K., Mazin, I. I., Jeschke, H. O., Hirschfeld, P. J.,
Fernandes R M & Valentı´ R (2015) Nat Phys 11 953 958 a, K. & Izumi, F. (2011). J. Appl. Cryst. 44, 1272–1276. Palatinus, L. & Chapuis, G. (2007). J. Appl. Cryst. 40, 786–790. Pan, L., Laurita, N. J., Ross, K. A., Gaulin, B. D. & Armitage, N. P. (2016). Nat. Phys. 12, 361–366. Bruker (2007). APEX2 and SAINT. Bruker AXS Inc., Madison,
Wisconsin, USA. Petrˇı`cˇek, V., Dusˇek, M. & Palatinus, L. (2014). Z. Kristallogr. 229,
345–352. Sergueev, I., Glazyrin, K., Kantor, I., McGuire, M. A., Chumakov,
A. I., Klobes, B., Sales, B. C. & Hermann, R. P. (2015). Phys. Rev. B,
91, 224304. Gardner, J. S., Gingras, M. J. P. & Greedan, J. E. (2010). Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 53–107. Westrip, S. P. (2010). J. Appl. Cryst. 43, 920–925. Zaikina, J. V., Schellenberg, I., Benbow, E. M., Po¨ttgen, R. &
Latturner, S. E. (2011). Chem. Mater. 23, 1768–1778. 1568
Pabla et al. La21Cr7.556Al0.758Ge6.242C12 Acta Cryst. (2016). E72, 1565–1568 supporting information supporting information Acta Cryst. (2016). E72, 1565-1568 [https://doi.org/10.1107/S2056989016015668] Synthesis and crystal structure of La21Cr8−2aAlbGe7−bC12 [a = 0.22 (2) and b =
0.758 (19)] Synthesis and crystal structure of La21Cr8−2aAlbGe7−bC12 [a = 0.22 (2) and b =
0.758 (19)] Refinement Weighting scheme based on measured s.u.'s w =
1/(σ2(I) + 0.0004I2)
(Δ/σ)max = 0.015
Δρmax = 1.07 e Å−3
Δρmin = −0.83 e Å−3
Extinction correction: B-C type 2 (Becker &
Coppens, 1974)
Extinction coefficient: 810 (150) Weighting scheme based on measured s.u.'s w = Weighting scheme based on measured s.u.'s w = Refinement on F2
R[F > 3σ(F)] = 0.012
wR(F) = 0.045
S = 1.91
328 reflections
21 parameters
0 restraints
1 constraint sup-1 Acta Cryst. (2016). E72, 1565-1568 supporting information
2
A
C
(
1 ) E
1
1
Fractional atomic coordinates and isotropic or equivalent isotropic displacement parameters (Å2)
x
y
z
Uiso*/Ueq
Occ. (<1)
La1
0
0.167496 (14)
0.167496 (14)
0.01125 (10)
La2
0.369379 (15)
0.369379 (15)
0.369379 (15)
0.00984 (9)
La3
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.0384 (3)
Ge1
0.29186 (6)
0
0
0.0121 (2)
Cr1
0.19651 (4)
0.19651 (4)
0.19651 (4)
0.0068 (2)
0.944 (5)
Ge2
0
0
0
0.0323 (12)
0.242 (19)
Al2
0
0
0
0.0323 (12)
0.758 (19)
C1
0.1049 (4)
0.25
0.25
0.0127 (11)*
Atomic displacement parameters (Å2)
U11
U22
U33
U12
U13
U23
La1
0.0074 (2)
0.01315 (17)
0.01315 (17)
0
0
0.00046 (13)
La2
0.00984 (15)
0.00984 (15)
0.00984 (15)
−0.00052 (8)
−0.00052 (8)
−0.00052 (8)
La3
0.0384 (4)
0.0384 (4)
0.0384 (4)
0
0
0
Ge1
0.0139 (5)
0.0112 (3)
0.0112 (3)
0
0
0
Cr1
0.0068 (3)
0.0068 (3)
0.0068 (3)
0.0008 (2)
0.0008 (2)
0.0008 (2)
Ge2
0.032 (2)
0.032 (2)
0.032 (2)
0
0
0
Al2
0.032 (2)
0.032 (2)
0.032 (2)
0
0
0
Geometric parameters (Å, º)
La1—La1i
3.8282 (4)
La2—Ge1xiii
3.2864 (5)
La1—La1ii
3.8859 (3)
La2—Ge1xiv
3.2864 (5)
La1—La1iii
3.8859 (3)
La2—Cr1vi
3.2216 (7)
La1—La1iv
3.8859 (3)
La2—Cr1vii
3.2216 (7)
La1—La1v
3.8859 (3)
La2—Cr1i
3.2216 (7)
La1—La2vi
3.9907 (4)
La2—C1vi
2.8015 (9)
La1—La2vii
3.9907 (4)
La2—C1xv
2.8015 (9)
La1—La2viii
3.9907 (4)
La2—C1xvi
2.8015 (9)
La1—La2ix
3.9907 (4)
Cr1—Cr1vi
2.4821 (9)
La1—Cr1
3.2932 (7)
Cr1—Cr1vii
2.4821 (9)
La1—Cr1x
3.2932 (7)
Cr1—Cr1i
2.4821 (9)
La1—C1
2.574 (4)
Cr1—C1
1.949 (5)
La1—C1xi
2.574 (4)
Cr1—C1ii
1.949 (5)
La2—La3
3.7115 (3)
Cr1—C1iv
1.949 (5)
La2—Ge1xii
3.2864 (5)
La1i—La1—La1ii
120.000 (6)
La3—La2—Cr1vii
153.589 (14)
La1i—La1—La1iii
120.000 (6)
La3—La2—Cr1i
153.589 (14)
La1i—La1—La1iv
120.000 (6)
La3—La2—C1vi
136.07 (12)
La1i—La1—La1v
120.000 (6)
La3—La2—C1xv
136.07 (12)
La1i—La1—La2vi
61.339 (6)
La3—La2—C1xvi
136.07 (12)
La1i—La1—La2vii
61.339 (6)
Ge1xii—La2—Ge1xiii
94.557 (15)
La1i—La1—La2viii
61.339 (6)
Ge1xii—La2—Ge1xiv
94.557 (15) supporting information supporting information Fractional atomic coordinates and isotropic or equivalent isotropic displacement parameters (Å2) Atomic displacement parameters (Å2) Acta Cryst. (2016). supporting information E72, 1565-1568 sup-2 supporting information La1i—La1—La2ix
61.339 (6)
Ge1xii—La2—Cr1vi
La1i—La1—Cr1
78.207 (12)
Ge1xii—La2—Cr1vii
La1i—La1—Cr1x
78.207 (12)
Ge1xii—La2—Cr1i
La1i—La1—C1
41.96 (10)
Ge1xii—La2—C1vi
La1i—La1—C1xi
41.96 (10)
Ge1xii—La2—C1xv
La1ii—La1—La1iii
90.000 (7)
Ge1xii—La2—C1xvi
La1ii—La1—La1iv
60.000 (5)
Ge1xiii—La2—Ge1xiv
La1ii—La1—La1v
120.000 (7)
Ge1xiii—La2—Cr1vi
La1ii—La1—La2vi
60.865 (6)
Ge1xiii—La2—Cr1vii
La1ii—La1—La2vii
101.955 (5)
Ge1xiii—La2—Cr1i
La1ii—La1—La2viii
165.127 (7)
Ge1xiii—La2—C1vi
La1ii—La1—La2ix
105.813 (7)
Ge1xiii—La2—C1xv
La1ii—La1—Cr1
53.844 (12)
Ge1xiii—La2—C1xvi
La1ii—La1—Cr1x
142.596 (13)
Ge1xiv—La2—Cr1vi
La1ii—La1—C1
84.21 (8)
Ge1xiv—La2—Cr1vii
La1ii—La1—C1xi
147.63 (4)
Ge1xiv—La2—Cr1i
La1iii—La1—La1iv
120.000 (7)
Ge1xiv—La2—C1vi
La1iii—La1—La1v
60.000 (5)
Ge1xiv—La2—C1xv
La1iii—La1—La2vi
105.813 (7)
Ge1xiv—La2—C1xvi
La1iii—La1—La2vii
165.127 (7)
Cr1vi—La2—Cr1vii
La1iii—La1—La2viii
101.955 (5)
Cr1vi—La2—Cr1i
La1iii—La1—La2ix
60.865 (6)
Cr1vi—La2—C1vi
La1iii—La1—Cr1
142.596 (13)
Cr1vi—La2—C1xv
La1iii—La1—Cr1x
53.844 (12)
Cr1vi—La2—C1xvi
La1iii—La1—C1
147.63 (4)
Cr1vii—La2—Cr1i
La1iii—La1—C1xi
84.21 (8)
Cr1vii—La2—C1vi
La1iv—La1—La1v
90.000 (7)
Cr1vii—La2—C1xv
La1iv—La1—La2vi
101.955 (5)
Cr1vii—La2—C1xvi
La1iv—La1—La2vii
60.865 (6)
Cr1i—La2—C1vi
La1iv—La1—La2viii
105.813 (7)
Cr1i—La2—C1xv
La1iv—La1—La2ix
165.127 (7)
Cr1i—La2—C1xvi
La1iv—La1—Cr1
53.844 (12)
C1vi—La2—C1xv
La1iv—La1—Cr1x
142.596 (13)
C1vi—La2—C1xvi
La1iv—La1—C1
84.21 (8)
C1xv—La2—C1xvi
La1iv—La1—C1xi
147.63 (4)
La2—La3—La2xix
La1v—La1—La2vi
165.127 (7)
La2—La3—La2xx
La1v—La1—La2vii
105.813 (7)
La2—La3—La2xxi
La1v—La1—La2viii
60.865 (6)
La2—La3—La2xxii
La1v—La1—La2ix
101.955 (5)
La2—La3—La2xxiii
La1v—La1—Cr1
142.596 (13)
La2—La3—La2xxiv
La1v—La1—Cr1x
53.844 (12)
La2—La3—La2xxv
La1v—La1—C1
147.63 (4)
La2xix—La3—La2xx
La1v—La1—C1xi
84.21 (8)
La2xix—La3—La2xxi
La2vi—La1—La2vii
87.896 (6)
La2xix—La3—La2xxii
La2vi—La1—La2viii
122.677 (8)
La2xix—La3—La2xxiii
La2vi—La1—La2ix
64.952 (7)
La2xix—La3—La2xxiv
La2vi—La1—Cr1
51.418 (12)
La2xix—La3—La2xxv
La2vi—La1—Cr1x
115.315 (13)
La2xx—La3—La2xxi La1i—La1—La2ix
61.339 (6)
Ge1xii—La2—Cr1vi
131.521 (19)
La1i—La1—Cr1
78.207 (12)
Ge1xii—La2—Cr1vii
131.521 (19)
La1i—La1—Cr1x
78.207 (12)
Ge1xii—La2—Cr1i
95.56 (2)
La1i—La1—C1
41.96 (10)
Ge1xii—La2—C1vi
165.90 (12)
La1i—La1—C1xi
41.96 (10)
Ge1xii—La2—C1xv
95.00 (8)
La1ii—La1—La1iii
90.000 (7)
Ge1xii—La2—C1xvi
95.00 (8)
La1ii—La1—La1iv
60.000 (5)
Ge1xiii—La2—Ge1xiv
94.557 (15)
La1ii—La1—La1v
120.000 (7)
Ge1xiii—La2—Cr1vi
131.521 (19)
La1ii—La1—La2vi
60.865 (6)
Ge1xiii—La2—Cr1vii
95.56 (2)
La1ii—La1—La2vii
101.955 (5)
Ge1xiii—La2—Cr1i
131.521 (19)
La1ii—La1—La2viii
165.127 (7)
Ge1xiii—La2—C1vi
95.00 (8)
La1ii—La1—La2ix
105.813 (7)
Ge1xiii—La2—C1xv
165.90 (12)
La1ii—La1—Cr1
53.844 (12)
Ge1xiii—La2—C1xvi
95.00 (8)
La1ii—La1—Cr1x
142.596 (13)
Ge1xiv—La2—Cr1vi
95.56 (2)
La1ii—La1—C1
84.21 (8)
Ge1xiv—La2—Cr1vii
131.521 (19)
La1ii—La1—C1xi
147.63 (4)
Ge1xiv—La2—Cr1i
131.521 (19)
La1iii—La1—La1iv
120.000 (7)
Ge1xiv—La2—C1vi
95.00 (8)
La1iii—La1—La1v
60.000 (5)
Ge1xiv—La2—C1xv
95.00 (8)
La1iii—La1—La2vi
105.813 (7)
Ge1xiv—La2—C1xvi
165.90 (12)
La1iii—La1—La2vii
165.127 (7)
Cr1vi—La2—Cr1vii
45.314 (17)
La1iii—La1—La2viii
101.955 (5)
Cr1vi—La2—Cr1i
45.314 (17)
La1iii—La1—La2ix
60.865 (6)
Cr1vi—La2—C1vi
36.93 (9)
La1iii—La1—Cr1
142.596 (13)
Cr1vi—La2—C1xv
36.93 (9)
La1iii—La1—Cr1x
53.844 (12)
Cr1vi—La2—C1xvi
70.34 (12)
La1iii—La1—C1
147.63 (4)
Cr1vii—La2—Cr1i
45.314 (17)
La1iii—La1—C1xi
84.21 (8)
Cr1vii—La2—C1vi
36.93 (9)
La1iv—La1—La1v
90.000 (7)
Cr1vii—La2—C1xv
70.34 (12)
La1iv—La1—La2vi
101.955 (5)
Cr1vii—La2—C1xvi
36.93 (9)
La1iv—La1—La2vii
60.865 (6)
Cr1i—La2—C1vi
70.34 (12)
La1iv—La1—La2viii
105.813 (7)
Cr1i—La2—C1xv
36.93 (9)
La1iv—La1—La2ix
165.127 (7)
Cr1i—La2—C1xvi
36.93 (9)
La1iv—La1—Cr1
53.844 (12)
C1vi—La2—C1xv
73.86 (13)
La1iv—La1—Cr1x
142.596 (13)
C1vi—La2—C1xvi
73.86 (13)
La1iv—La1—C1
84.21 (8)
C1xv—La2—C1xvi
73.86 (13)
La1iv—La1—C1xi
147.63 (4)
La2—La3—La2xix
109.471 (6)
La1v—La1—La2vi
165.127 (7)
La2—La3—La2xx
109.471 (6)
La1v—La1—La2vii
105.813 (7)
La2—La3—La2xxi
109.471 (6)
La1v—La1—La2viii
60.865 (6)
La2—La3—La2xxii
70.529 (6)
La1v—La1—La2ix
101.955 (5)
La2—La3—La2xxiii
180.0 (5)
La1v—La1—Cr1
142.596 (13)
La2—La3—La2xxiv
70.529 (6)
La1v—La1—Cr1x
53.844 (12)
La2—La3—La2xxv
70.529 (6)
La1v—La1—C1
147.63 (4)
La2xix—La3—La2xx
109.471 (6)
La1v—La1—C1xi
84.21 (8)
La2xix—La3—La2xxi
109.471 (6)
La2vi—La1—La2vii
87.896 (6)
La2xix—La3—La2xxii
180.0 (5)
La2vi—La1—La2viii
122.677 (8)
La2xix—La3—La2xxiii
70.529 (6)
La2vi—La1—La2ix
64.952 (7)
La2xix—La3—La2xxiv
70.529 (6)
La2vi—La1—Cr1
51.418 (12)
La2xix—La3—La2xxv
70.529 (6)
La2vi—La1—Cr1x
115.315 (13)
La2xx—La3—La2xxi
109.471 (6) sup-3 Acta Cryst. supporting information E72, 1565-1568 supporting information La2vi—La1—C1
44.302 (12)
La2xx—La3—La2xxii
70.529 (6)
La2vi—La1—C1xi
90.13 (7)
La2xx—La3—La2xxiii
70.529 (6)
La2vii—La1—La2viii
64.952 (7)
La2xx—La3—La2xxiv
180.0 (5)
La2vii—La1—La2ix
122.677 (8)
La2xx—La3—La2xxv
70.529 (6)
La2vii—La1—Cr1
51.418 (12)
La2xxi—La3—La2xxii
70.529 (6)
La2vii—La1—Cr1x
115.315 (13)
La2xxi—La3—La2xxiii
70.529 (6)
La2vii—La1—C1
44.302 (12)
La2xxi—La3—La2xxiv
70.529 (6)
La2vii—La1—C1xi
90.13 (7)
La2xxi—La3—La2xxv
180.0 (5)
La2viii—La1—La2ix
87.896 (6)
La2xxii—La3—La2xxiii
109.471 (6)
La2viii—La1—Cr1
115.314 (13)
La2xxii—La3—La2xxiv
109.471 (6)
La2viii—La1—Cr1x
51.418 (12)
La2xxii—La3—La2xxv
109.471 (6)
La2viii—La1—C1
90.13 (7)
La2xxiii—La3—La2xxiv
109.471 (6)
La2viii—La1—C1xi
44.302 (12)
La2xxiii—La3—La2xxv
109.471 (6)
La2ix—La1—Cr1
115.314 (13)
La2xxiv—La3—La2xxv
109.471 (6)
La2ix—La1—Cr1x
51.418 (12)
La2xxvi—Ge1—La2i
134.47 (3)
La2ix—La1—C1
90.13 (7)
La2xxvi—Ge1—La2xxvii
81.389 (12)
La2ix—La1—C1xi
44.302 (12)
La2xxvi—Ge1—La2xxviii
81.389 (12)
Cr1—La1—Cr1x
156.414 (18)
La2i—Ge1—La2xxvii
81.389 (12)
Cr1—La1—C1
36.25 (10)
La2i—Ge1—La2xxviii
81.389 (12)
Cr1—La1—C1xi
120.16 (10)
La2xxvii—Ge1—La2xxviii
134.47 (3)
Cr1x—La1—C1
120.16 (10)
La1—Cr1—La1ii
72.313 (15)
Cr1x—La1—C1xi
36.25 (10)
La1—Cr1—La1iv
72.313 (15)
C1—La1—C1xi
83.91 (14)
La1—Cr1—La2vi
75.541 (15)
La1vi—La2—La1vii
57.323 (6)
La1—Cr1—La2vii
75.541 (15)
La1vi—La2—La1xv
113.653 (7)
La1—Cr1—La2i
139.88 (2)
La1vi—La2—La1xvii
58.269 (6)
La1—Cr1—Cr1vi
142.60 (3)
La1vi—La2—La1xvi
113.653 (7)
La1—Cr1—Cr1vii
142.60 (3)
La1vi—La2—La1xviii
150.254 (8)
La1—Cr1—Cr1i
101.79 (3)
La1vi—La2—La3
104.871 (7)
La1—Cr1—C1
51.34 (11)
La1vi—La2—Ge1xii
147.964 (10)
La1—Cr1—C1ii
113.23 (9)
La1vi—La2—Ge1xiii
97.605 (8)
La1—Cr1—C1iv
113.23 (9)
La1vi—La2—Ge1xiv
55.083 (13)
La1ii—Cr1—La1iv
72.313 (15)
La1vi—La2—Cr1vi
53.041 (13)
La1ii—Cr1—La2vi
75.541 (15)
La1vi—La2—Cr1vii
76.602 (13)
La1ii—Cr1—La2vii
139.88 (2)
La1vi—La2—Cr1i
98.244 (13)
La1ii—Cr1—La2i
75.541 (15)
La1vi—La2—C1vi
39.92 (8)
La1ii—Cr1—Cr1vi
142.60 (3)
La1vi—La2—C1xv
79.52 (2)
La1ii—Cr1—Cr1vii
101.79 (3)
La1vi—La2—C1xvi
113.23 (10)
La1ii—Cr1—Cr1i
142.60 (3)
La1vii—La2—La1xv
150.254 (8)
La1ii—Cr1—C1
113.23 (9)
La1vii—La2—La1xvii
113.653 (7)
La1ii—Cr1—C1ii
51.34 (11)
La1vii—La2—La1xvi
58.269 (6)
La1ii—Cr1—C1iv
113.23 (9)
La1vii—La2—La1xviii
113.653 (7)
La1iv—Cr1—La2vi
139.88 (2)
La1vii—La2—La3
104.871 (7)
La1iv—Cr1—La2vii
75.541 (15)
La1vii—La2—Ge1xii
147.964 (10)
La1iv—Cr1—La2i
75.541 (15)
La1vii—La2—Ge1xiii
55.083 (13)
La1iv—Cr1—Cr1vi
101.79 (3)
La1vii—La2—Ge1xiv
97.605 (8)
La1iv—Cr1—Cr1vii
142.60 (3)
La1vii—La2—Cr1vi
76.602 (13)
La1iv—Cr1—Cr1i
142.60 (3)
La1vii—La2—Cr1vii
53.041 (13)
La1iv—Cr1—C1
113.23 (9) 44.302 (12)
La2xx—La3—La2xxii
70.529 (6)
90.13 (7)
La2xx—La3—La2xxiii
70.529 (6)
64.952 (7)
La2xx—La3—La2xxiv
180.0 (5)
122.677 (8)
La2xx—La3—La2xxv
70.529 (6)
51.418 (12)
La2xxi—La3—La2xxii
70.529 (6)
115.315 (13)
La2xxi—La3—La2xxiii
70.529 (6)
44.302 (12)
La2xxi—La3—La2xxiv
70.529 (6)
90.13 (7)
La2xxi—La3—La2xxv
180.0 (5)
87.896 (6)
La2xxii—La3—La2xxiii
109.471 (6)
115.314 (13)
La2xxii—La3—La2xxiv
109.471 (6)
51.418 (12)
La2xxii—La3—La2xxv
109.471 (6)
90.13 (7)
La2xxiii—La3—La2xxiv
109.471 (6)
44.302 (12)
La2xxiii—La3—La2xxv
109.471 (6)
115.314 (13)
La2xxiv—La3—La2xxv
109.471 (6)
51.418 (12)
La2xxvi—Ge1—La2i
134.47 (3)
90.13 (7)
La2xxvi—Ge1—La2xxvii
81.389 (12)
44.302 (12)
La2xxvi—Ge1—La2xxviii
81.389 (12)
156.414 (18)
La2i—Ge1—La2xxvii
81.389 (12)
36.25 (10)
La2i—Ge1—La2xxviii
81.389 (12)
120.16 (10)
La2xxvii—Ge1—La2xxviii
134.47 (3)
120.16 (10)
La1—Cr1—La1ii
72.313 (15)
36.25 (10)
La1—Cr1—La1iv
72.313 (15)
83.91 (14)
La1—Cr1—La2vi
75.541 (15)
57.323 (6)
La1—Cr1—La2vii
75.541 (15)
113.653 (7)
La1—Cr1—La2i
139.88 (2)
58.269 (6)
La1—Cr1—Cr1vi
142.60 (3)
113.653 (7)
La1—Cr1—Cr1vii
142.60 (3)
150.254 (8)
La1—Cr1—Cr1i
101.79 (3)
104.871 (7)
La1—Cr1—C1
51.34 (11)
147.964 (10)
La1—Cr1—C1ii
113.23 (9)
97.605 (8)
La1—Cr1—C1iv
113.23 (9)
55.083 (13)
La1ii—Cr1—La1iv
72.313 (15)
53.041 (13)
La1ii—Cr1—La2vi
75.541 (15)
76.602 (13)
La1ii—Cr1—La2vii
139.88 (2)
98.244 (13)
La1ii—Cr1—La2i
75.541 (15)
39.92 (8)
La1ii—Cr1—Cr1vi
142.60 (3)
79.52 (2)
La1ii—Cr1—Cr1vii
101.79 (3)
113.23 (10)
La1ii—Cr1—Cr1i
142.60 (3)
150.254 (8)
La1ii—Cr1—C1
113.23 (9)
113.653 (7)
La1ii—Cr1—C1ii
51.34 (11)
58.269 (6)
La1ii—Cr1—C1iv
113.23 (9)
113.653 (7)
La1iv—Cr1—La2vi
139.88 (2)
104.871 (7)
La1iv—Cr1—La2vii
75.541 (15)
147.964 (10)
La1iv—Cr1—La2i
75.541 (15)
55.083 (13)
La1iv—Cr1—Cr1vi
101.79 (3)
97.605 (8)
La1iv—Cr1—Cr1vii
142.60 (3)
76.602 (13)
La1iv—Cr1—Cr1i
142.60 (3)
53.041 (13)
La1iv—Cr1—C1
113.23 (9) sup-4 Acta Cryst. supporting information (2016). supporting information (2016). E72, 1565-1568 supporting information La1vii—La2—Cr1i
98.244 (13)
La1iv—Cr1—C1ii
113.23 (9)
La1vii—La2—C1vi
39.92 (8)
La1iv—Cr1—C1iv
51.34 (11)
La1vii—La2—C1xv
113.23 (10)
La2vi—Cr1—La2vii
118.56 (2)
La1vii—La2—C1xvi
79.52 (2)
La2vi—Cr1—La2i
118.56 (2)
La1xv—La2—La1xvii
57.323 (6)
La2vi—Cr1—Cr1vi
118.32 (3)
La1xv—La2—La1xvi
113.653 (7)
La2vi—Cr1—Cr1vii
67.34 (2)
La1xv—La2—La1xviii
58.269 (6)
La2vi—Cr1—Cr1i
67.34 (2)
La1xv—La2—La3
104.871 (7)
La2vi—Cr1—C1
59.74 (2)
La1xv—La2—Ge1xii
55.083 (13)
La2vi—Cr1—C1ii
59.74 (2)
La1xv—La2—Ge1xiii
147.964 (10)
La2vi—Cr1—C1iv
168.77 (11)
La1xv—La2—Ge1xiv
97.605 (8)
La2vii—Cr1—La2i
118.56 (2)
La1xv—La2—Cr1vi
76.602 (13)
La2vii—Cr1—Cr1vi
67.34 (2)
La1xv—La2—Cr1vii
98.244 (13)
La2vii—Cr1—Cr1vii
118.32 (3)
La1xv—La2—Cr1i
53.041 (13)
La2vii—Cr1—Cr1i
67.34 (2)
La1xv—La2—C1vi
113.23 (10)
La2vii—Cr1—C1
59.74 (2)
La1xv—La2—C1xv
39.92 (8)
La2vii—Cr1—C1ii
168.77 (11)
La1xv—La2—C1xvi
79.52 (2)
La2vii—Cr1—C1iv
59.74 (2)
La1xvii—La2—La1xvi
150.254 (8)
La2i—Cr1—Cr1vi
67.34 (2)
La1xvii—La2—La1xviii
113.653 (7)
La2i—Cr1—Cr1vii
67.34 (2)
La1xvii—La2—La3
104.871 (7)
La2i—Cr1—Cr1i
118.32 (3)
La1xvii—La2—Ge1xii
97.605 (8)
La2i—Cr1—C1
168.77 (11)
La1xvii—La2—Ge1xiii
147.964 (10)
La2i—Cr1—C1ii
59.74 (2)
La1xvii—La2—Ge1xiv
55.083 (13)
La2i—Cr1—C1iv
59.74 (2)
La1xvii—La2—Cr1vi
53.041 (13)
Cr1vi—Cr1—Cr1vii
60.00 (3)
La1xvii—La2—Cr1vii
98.244 (13)
Cr1vi—Cr1—Cr1i
60.00 (3)
La1xvii—La2—Cr1i
76.602 (13)
Cr1vi—Cr1—C1
103.11 (10)
La1xvii—La2—C1vi
79.52 (2)
Cr1vi—Cr1—C1ii
103.11 (10)
La1xvii—La2—C1xv
39.92 (8)
Cr1vi—Cr1—C1iv
50.45 (11)
La1xvii—La2—C1xvi
113.23 (10)
Cr1vii—Cr1—Cr1i
60.00 (3)
La1xvi—La2—La1xviii
57.323 (6)
Cr1vii—Cr1—C1
103.11 (10)
La1xvi—La2—La3
104.871 (7)
Cr1vii—Cr1—C1ii
50.45 (11)
La1xvi—La2—Ge1xii
97.605 (8)
Cr1vii—Cr1—C1iv
103.11 (10)
La1xvi—La2—Ge1xiii
55.083 (13)
Cr1i—Cr1—C1
50.45 (11)
La1xvi—La2—Ge1xiv
147.964 (10)
Cr1i—Cr1—C1ii
103.11 (10)
La1xvi—La2—Cr1vi
98.244 (13)
Cr1i—Cr1—C1iv
103.11 (10)
La1xvi—La2—Cr1vii
53.041 (13)
C1—Cr1—C1ii
119.45 (4)
La1xvi—La2—Cr1i
76.602 (13)
C1—Cr1—C1iv
119.45 (4)
La1xvi—La2—C1vi
79.52 (2)
C1ii—Cr1—C1iv
119.45 (4)
La1xvi—La2—C1xv
113.23 (10)
La1—C1—La1i
96.09 (19)
La1xvi—La2—C1xvi
39.92 (8)
La1—C1—La2vi
95.78 (7)
La1xviii—La2—La3
104.871 (7)
La1—C1—La2vii
95.78 (7)
La1xviii—La2—Ge1xii
55.083 (13)
La1—C1—Cr1
92.41 (2)
La1xviii—La2—Ge1xiii
97.605 (8)
La1—C1—Cr1i
171.5 (2)
La1xviii—La2—Ge1xiv
147.964 (10)
La1i—C1—La2vi
95.78 (7)
La1xviii—La2—Cr1vi
98.244 (13)
La1i—C1—La2vii
95.78 (7)
La1xviii—La2—Cr1vii
76.602 (13)
La1i—C1—Cr1
171.5 (2)
La1xviii—La2—Cr1i
53.041 (13)
La1i—C1—Cr1i
92.41 (2)
La1xviii—La2—C1vi
113.23 (10)
La2vi—C1—La2vii
162.7 (2) sup-5 Acta Cryst. (2016). Symmetry codes: (i) x, −y+1/2, −z+1/2; (ii) z, x, y; (iii) −z, −x, y; (iv) y, z, x; (v) −y, z, −x; (vi) −x+1/2, −y+1/2, z; (vii) −x+1/2, y, −z+1/2; (viii) y−1/2, x,
−z+1/2; (ix) y−1/2, −x+1/2, z; (x) −y, x, z; (xi) −x, z, y; (xii) x, y+1/2, z+1/2; (xiii) z+1/2, x, y+1/2; (xiv) y+1/2, z+1/2, x; (xv) z, −x+1/2, −y+1/2; (xvi)
−y+1/2, z, −x+1/2; (xvii) −z+1/2, −x+1/2, y; (xviii) y, −z+1/2, −x+1/2; (xix) −x+1, −y+1, z; (xx) −x+1, y, −z+1; (xxi) x, −y+1, −z+1; (xxii) y, x, −z+1;
(xxiii) −y+1, −x+1, −z+1; (xxiv) y, −x+1, z; (xxv) −y+1, x, z; (xxvi) x, y−1/2, z−1/2; (xxvii) y, x−1/2, −z+1/2; (xxviii) y, −x+1/2, z−1/2. supporting information E72, 1565-1568 supporting information
La1xviii—La2—C1xv
79.52 (2)
La2vi—C1—Cr1
83.33 (10)
La1xviii—La2—C1xvi
39.92 (8)
La2vi—C1—Cr1i
83.33 (10)
La3—La2—Ge1xii
58.029 (15)
La2vii—C1—Cr1
83.33 (10)
La3—La2—Ge1xiii
58.029 (15)
La2vii—C1—Cr1i
83.33 (10)
La3—La2—Ge1xiv
58.029 (15)
Cr1—C1—Cr1i
79.1 (2)
La3—La2—Cr1vi
153.589 (14)
Symmetry codes: (i) x, −y+1/2, −z+1/2; (ii) z, x, y; (iii) −z, −x, y; (iv) y, z, x; (v) −y, z, −x; (vi) −x+1/2, −y+1/2, z; (vii) −x+1/2, y, −z+1/2; (viii) y−1/2, x,
−z+1/2; (ix) y−1/2, −x+1/2, z; (x) −y, x, z; (xi) −x, z, y; (xii) x, y+1/2, z+1/2; (xiii) z+1/2, x, y+1/2; (xiv) y+1/2, z+1/2, x; (xv) z, −x+1/2, −y+1/2; (xvi)
−y+1/2, z, −x+1/2; (xvii) −z+1/2, −x+1/2, y; (xviii) y, −z+1/2, −x+1/2; (xix) −x+1, −y+1, z; (xx) −x+1, y, −z+1; (xxi) x, −y+1, −z+1; (xxii) y, x, −z+1;
(xxiii) −y+1, −x+1, −z+1; (xxiv) y, −x+1, z; (xxv) −y+1, x, z; (xxvi) x, y−1/2, z−1/2; (xxvii) y, x−1/2, −z+1/2; (xxviii) y, −x+1/2, z−1/2. supporting information La1xviii—La2—C1xv
79.52 (2)
La2vi—C1—Cr1
83.33 (10)
La1xviii—La2—C1xvi
39.92 (8)
La2vi—C1—Cr1i
83.33 (10)
La3—La2—Ge1xii
58.029 (15)
La2vii—C1—Cr1
83.33 (10)
La3—La2—Ge1xiii
58.029 (15)
La2vii—C1—Cr1i
83.33 (10)
La3—La2—Ge1xiv
58.029 (15)
Cr1—C1—Cr1i
79.1 (2)
La3—La2—Cr1vi
153.589 (14) Symmetry codes: (i) x, −y+1/2, −z+1/2; (ii) z, x, y; (iii) −z, −x, y; (iv) y, z, x; (v) −y, z, −x; (vi) −x+1/2, −y+1/2, z; (vii) −x+1/2, y, −z+1/2; (viii) y−1/2, x,
−z+1/2; (ix) y−1/2, −x+1/2, z; (x) −y, x, z; (xi) −x, z, y; (xii) x, y+1/2, z+1/2; (xiii) z+1/2, x, y+1/2; (xiv) y+1/2, z+1/2, x; (xv) z, −x+1/2, −y+1/2; (xvi)
−y+1/2, z, −x+1/2; (xvii) −z+1/2, −x+1/2, y; (xviii) y, −z+1/2, −x+1/2; (xix) −x+1, −y+1, z; (xx) −x+1, y, −z+1; (xxi) x, −y+1, −z+1; (xxii) y, x, −z+1;
(xxiii) −y+1, −x+1, −z+1; (xxiv) y, −x+1, z; (xxv) −y+1, x, z; (xxvi) x, y−1/2, z−1/2; (xxvii) y, x−1/2, −z+1/2; (xxviii) y, −x+1/2, z−1/2. sup-6 Acta Cryst. (2016). E72, 1565-1568 sup-6
|
https://openalex.org/W4389616337
|
https://isegoria.revistas.csic.es/index.php/isegoria/article/download/1341/1699
|
es
|
Con manos de ángel: figuras del cuidado en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno
|
Isegoría
| 2,023
|
cc-by
| 8,689
|
ISEGORÍA. Revista de Filosofía moral y política
N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19
ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376
https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
ARTÍCULOS
Con manos de ángel: figuras del cuidado en la obra de
Miguel de Unamuno
With Angel’s Hands: Figures of Care in Miguel de Unamuno’s Plays
Olaya Fernández Guerrero
Universidad de La Rioja
olaya.fernandez@unirioja.es
ORCID iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8795-0858
Álvaro Ledesma de la Fuente
Universidad de La Rioja
alvaro.ledesma@unirioja.es
ORCID iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1742-8399
Resumen: La literatura especializada sobre Unamuno ha prestado poca atención a la dimensión del cuidado latente
en la obra de este filósofo. El presente estudio ofrece una aportación en ese sentido, para ello parte de los planteamientos éticos contemporáneos relacionados con el cuidado y analiza varios textos de Unamuno a la luz de ese
marco teórico. El resultado es una lectura novedosa de su obra donde se identifica la presencia de aspectos vinculados a la eticidad del ser-para-otro, se plasma el ejercicio del cuidado ejercido a través del lenguaje y del tacto, y
se profundiza en el alcance ético de la actitud maternal omnipresente en los relatos del bilbaíno.
Palabras clave: Ética del cuidado; nivola; Unamuno.
Cómo citar este artículo / Citation: Fernández Guerrero, Olaya y Ledesma de la Fuente, Álvaro (2023) “Con manos de ángel: figuras del cuidado en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno”. Isegoría, 69: e19. https://doi.org/10.3989/
isegoria.2023.69.19
Abstract: Specialized literature on Unamuno has paid little attention to the dimension of care latent in this philosopher’s plays. This paper provides a contribution in that regard. It departs from contemporary ethical approaches
related to care, and it analyzes several texts by Unamuno in the light of this theoretical framework. The result is a
novel reading of his work that identifies the presence of aspects linked to the ethical nature of being-for-another, it
shows the exercise of care exercised through language and touch is shown, and it emphasizes the ethical scope of
the omnipresent maternal attitude in Unamuno’s writings.
Keywords: Care Ethics; Nivola; Unamuno.
Recibido: 27 junio 2023. Aceptado: 8 agosto 2023.
Copyright: © 2023 CSIC. Este es un artículo de acceso abierto distribuido bajo los términos de la licencia de uso
y distribución Creative Commons Reconocimiento 4.0 Internacional (CC BY 4.0).
1
Olaya Fernández Guerrero / Álvaro Ledesma de la Fuente
1. INTRODUCCIÓN
En el debate filosófico contemporáneo, gracias a
voces como las de Martin Heidegger, Emmanuel
Lévinas, Martin Buber, Carol Gilligan, Virginia
Held o Joan Tronto, la reflexión sobre el cuidado ha
cobrado gran relevancia. A partir de esta inquietud,
en este estudio analizaremos la cuestión del cuidado
en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno. Para ello hemos
rastreado la extensa producción del autor bilbaíno,
incluyendo tanto sus ensayos y nivolas como sus
relatos cortos, con el fin de identificar la presencia
de elementos relacionados con la ética del cuidado
en sus personajes, tramas y reflexiones.
El componente afectivo está muy presente en la
nivola unamuniana, en la que los personajes están
sometidos a intensas pasiones descarnadas. Esta
dimensión intersubjetiva y dialógica de su obra ha
sido estudiada con detenimiento en la bibliografía
especializada, en especial en aquellos trabajos que
analizan la relación entre filosofía y literatura como
Unamuno, narrador, de Robert Nicholas (1987),
Alegorías de la voluntad de Francisco La Rubia
Prado (1996), Unamuno y el pensamiento dialógico, de Iris Zavala (1991), o Los espejos del yo, de
Luis Álvarez Castro (2015). La ética voluntariosa y
heroica de raíz filoprotestante de Unamuno ha sido
objeto de múltiples análisis, en especial el clásico
de Pedro Cerezo (1996) Las máscaras de lo trágico,
y también en Unamuno y los protestantes liberales
(1912), de Nelson Orringer (1985). No obstante,
a pesar de esta atención al aspecto ético, la teoría
y praxis de los cuidados en la obra de Unamuno
apenas ha sido trabajada con anterioridad, y las
aproximaciones al respecto se refieren a acciones
concretas de atención de algunos personajes hacia
otros, especialmente al cuidado maternal que prestan
varias protagonistas a sus vástagos, sean de carne
o de espíritu. En este artículo nos proponemos
paliar esa deficiencia y comentar, desde la óptica
de la ética del cuidado, cómo esta dimensión de la
subjetividad está presente en nuestro autor. Nuestro
análisis se centra en los textos Amor y pedagogía
(1902), Niebla (1914), Dos madres, presente en
Tres novelas ejemplares y un prólogo (1920) y San
Manuel Bueno, mártir (1931), así como el cuento
breve En manos de la cocinera (1912).
2. EL CUIDADO COMO UNA MODALIDAD
ÉTICA DEL SER-PARA-OTRO
Como es sabido, la filosofía continental contemporánea se vertebra en torno a la dimensión existencial
y fenomenológica del ser-para-otro y describe las
vivencias asociadas a esa apertura constitutiva de
2
la subjetividad volcada hacia otras subjetividades y
expuesta a ellas. El pensamiento de la alteridad pone
el acento en la perspectiva relacional y abierta de
la subjetividad, y reflexiona sobre las dimensiones
y posibilidades que se derivan de ahí. La hipótesis
de partida de esta corriente es que no es posible
fundamentar la identidad a partir de presupuestos
solipsistas, sino que para dar cuenta de esta de forma
adecuada es imprescindible tomar en consideración
la exterioridad y los variados modos de relación con
ella. La filosofía de la alteridad pretende superar la
separación radical entre sujeto y objeto promovida
por el racionalismo de cuño cartesiano, y replantear
los límites entre el yo que piensa y el contenido de
lo que es pensado, mostrando que esas fronteras
no son tan claras como pudiese parecer a priori, y
que más bien hay una cierta continuidad entre el
sujeto y el mundo, entre el yo y el contexto vital
en que está situado.
El punto inicial de la ética del cuidar es esa
experiencia de la alteridad, de sentirse interpelado
por un sujeto distinto, que lleva al individuo a
sentirse responsable ante el otro y del otro, ya que
descubre que no está solo en el mundo y que se
debe moralmente a sus semejantes (Torralba, 2002).
Cuidar implica responder a la llamada de alguien
que sufre o padece, actuando de forma solidaria y
empática. El cuidado es una forma valiosa de estar
en el mundo, puesto que nos humaniza y nos lleva
a fundar un cosmos de relaciones éticas regidas por
la solidaridad, la empatía y la preocupación por el
bienestar de quienes nos rodean, ahuyentando el
fantasma de la deshumanización.
Esta práctica ética adquiere muchas veces un
carácter de urgencia, pues la necesidad de cuidados
surge en un contexto de inmediatez y es difícilmente
aplazable: «Lo ético es responder aquí y ahora al
sufrimiento de otro» (Martínez Ques, 2019, p. 3).
La persona inmovilizada por una enfermedad, el
bebé que no puede alimentarse ni asearse por sí
solo, la paciente hospitalizada en estado grave,
requieren de una respuesta solícita en el momento
actual, aquí y ahora, que les ayude a subsistir y
vivir dignamente. Cuidar también tiene que ver
con no abandonar al otro, darle esperanza y velar
por su calidad de vida. Este imperativo moral no se
presta a demora, pues raramente el cuidado admite
un mañana por respuesta.
En la creación literaria de Unamuno apreciamos
esta faceta del cuidado en numerosos pasajes, en
especial aquellos en los que se describe la atención
a bebés y recién nacidos. El caso más reconocido se
encuentra en La tía Tula, un ejemplo de la actitud
maternal y del cuidado. En esta nivola conocemos
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
Con manos de ángel: figuras del cuidado en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno
la historia de dos hermanas, Gertrudis y Rosa:
la primera convence a su pretendiente, Ramiro,
para que en lugar de a ella tome a su hermana por
esposa, a pesar de estar enamorado de Gertrudis,
que le rechaza. El matrimonio de Rosa y Ramiro
tiene varios hijos, y la tía Tula, como es llamada
cariñosamente por sus sobrinos, se instala en la
casa para ayudar en las labores de crianza, a la vez
que insta a su hermana a concebir más hijos. En el
último parto la madre biológica pierde la vida y los
niños quedan al cuidado de su padre y su tía, quien
se niega a ocupar el lugar de su difunta hermana
en el lecho de Ramiro. Es entonces cuando la voluntad de Gertrudis se impone a la de su cuñado,
obligándole a tomar una nueva esposa y casándolo
con la hospiciana que ayudaba con las tareas del
hogar, con la que pronto tendrá más hijos. Al morir
también esta segunda esposa, Gertrudis y Ramiro
quedan al cuidado de sus cinco hijos e hijas de dos
madres distintas —aunque para Gertrudis siempre
serán sus hijos, sean o no de su hermana—, con una
protagonista totalmente volcada en esta maternidad.
La práctica de los cuidados es omnipresente en
todo el relato; Gertrudis, tras el duro parto de su
primer sobrino, hace las veces de comadrona en
los instantes inmediatamente posteriores al alumbramiento. El carácter voluntarioso y decidido de
la protagonista se manifiesta en este trance, en el
que su cualidad como criadora brilla por encima
del resto de personajes de la escena:
Recogiolo Gertrudis con avidez, y como si nunca
hubiera hecho otra cosa, lo lavó y envolvió en
sus pañales.
―Es usted comadrona de nacimiento ―le dijo
el médico.
Tomó la criaturita y se la llevó a su padre, que en
un rincón, aterrado y como contrito de una falta,
aguardaba la noticia de la muerte de su mujer.
―¡Aquí tienes tu primer hijo, Ramiro; mírale qué
hermoso! (Unamuno, 1995a, p. 816).
La relación de cuidado que se narra aquí, así
como en muchas otras ocasiones, cuenta con un
carácter asimétrico en el que no hay posibilidad para
la reciprocidad: una persona proporciona cuidados
a otra en situación de desvalimiento de manera
altruista, sin esperar nada a cambio, pues sabe que
el destinatario de esas atenciones es un ser frágil
que no está en condiciones de corresponder a esa
dedicación, al menos no en el momento en que ese
apoyo es brindado. Esta actitud de cuidado emerge
cuando es captada la vulnerabilidad y fragilidad del
otro, cuando se explicita el padecimiento de otra
persona y brota un sentimiento de empatía hacia ella.
El otro vulnerable es susceptible de ser herido,
de recibir un daño o perjuicio, y de padecer alguna
lesión física o moral; en definitiva, de padecer sufrimiento, enfermedad, dolor y finalmente muerte,
condición común que compartimos todos los seres
humanos. La ética del cuidado se funda, precisamente, en ese sufrimiento, a través del cual emerge
la posibilidad de una relación con el otro (Mèlich,
2010). El acto de cuidar, en suma: «es una respuesta a la experiencia de tantos hombres y mujeres
cargados de vulnerabilidad, de enfermabilidad y
doloribilidad» (López Alonso, 2011, p. 314). Paul
Ricoeur se refiere a la espontaneidad de esa actitud
de cuidado, está estrechamente conectada con la
noción de «solicitud», respuesta solícita ante el otro
que comparece ante mí: «Lo que el sufrimiento del
otro, tanto como la conminación moral nacida del
otro, destella en el sí, son sentimientos dirigidos
espontáneamente hacia otro» (Ricoeur, 1996, p. 199).
Siguiendo con este argumento, cabe afirmar que
la compasión es el fundamento ético del cuidar, en
la medida en que: «los seres humanos se cuidan
unos a otros porque sienten compasión ajena»
(Torralba, 2002, p. 86). Esta compasión consiste
en la sensibilidad que se muestra para comprender
el sufrimiento de otra persona, combinado con la
voluntad de ayudar y promover el bienestar de
esa persona e intentar buscar una solución a su
situación (Martínez Ques, 2019). Para Unamuno la
compasión, el padecimiento común en una misma
matriz de afecto, se identifica plenamente con el
sentimiento amoroso, entendido en términos de
filantropía. Tal es su convencimiento que en el
capítulo VII de Del sentimiento trágico de la vida
en los hombres y en los pueblos, “Amor, dolor,
compasión y personalidad”, declara:
Amar en espíritu es compadecer, y quien más
compadece más ama. Los hombres encendidos
en ardiente caridad hacia sus prójimos, es porque
llegaron al fondo de su propia miseria, de su
propia aparencialidad, de su nadería, y volviendo
luego sus ojos así abiertos hacia sus semejantes,
los vieron también miserables, aparenciales,
anonadables, y los compadecieron y los amaron
(Unamuno, 2009, p. 384).
En la narrativa unamuniana la figura que mejor
refleja este ideal de entrega a los demás es Manuel
Bueno, protagonista de la nivola homónima. San
Manuel Bueno, mártir cuenta la historia de un
párroco cuyo drama es que es incapaz de creer en
lo que predica y ha de cargar con el lastre espiritual
de este secreto, pues sabe por propia experiencia
que es preferible vivir con las respuestas que
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
3
Olaya Fernández Guerrero / Álvaro Ledesma de la Fuente
proporciona la fe antes que sufrir la incertidumbre
que él mismo padece. Así, encamina su labor en
cuerpo y alma a ayudar a su pueblo, y de esta forma evitarle ese sufrimiento: «Yo estoy para hacer
vivir a las almas de mis feligreses, para hacerles
felices, para hacerles que se sueñen inmortales y
no para matarles» (Unamuno, 1995b, p. 330). El
cuidado a su comunidad, físico y espiritual, es lo
que caracteriza su magisterio sacerdotal, lo que
le había hecho adquirir fama en la diócesis de
Renada: «¡Cómo quería a los suyos! Su vida era
arreglar matrimonios desavenidos, reducir a sus
padres a hijos indómitos o reducir los padres a
sus hijos, y sobre todo consolar a los amargados
y atediados y ayudar a todos a bien morir» (Unamuno, 1995b, p. 315). La beatitud de Don Manuel
se hallaba en la cotidianeidad de sus actos diarios
y se explicita en las innumerables tareas que lleva a cabo a favor de su parroquia: «Su vida era
activa y no contemplativa, huyendo cuanto podía
de no tener nada que hacer» (Unamuno, 1995b, p.
319). La narradora de la obra, Ángela Carballino,
rememora cómo el clérigo ayudaba con las cosechas y en la escuela, estaba presente en la vida
cotidiana y festiva de su comunidad e incluso en
una ocasión había salido al monte a recuperar la
res extraviada de un joven pastor de la aldea. El
pastor de almas, Manuel Bueno, se entregaba a su
rebaño de feligreses sin esperar nada a cambio, un
sacrificio que, en términos unamunianos, garantiza
su inmortalidad en el alma de su pueblo. Era tal el
empeño que ponía en su tarea que los lugareños
lo consideraban un santo en la tierra. El reflejo
filosófico de esta ética perseverante y entregada se
encuentra en Diario íntimo, texto que recoge las
tribulaciones de Unamuno tras su crisis de 1897:
«Dedicaos a una vida virtuosa, a hacer obras de
verdadera caridad, a ser buenos, realmente buenos,
a ser buenos y no meramente a hacer el bien; dedicaos a acallar vuestras pasiones, a ahogar hasta
los gérmenes de ellas, las malas ideas, las meras
intenciones» (Unamuno, 2005, p. 343).
En uno de los episodios más emotivos de San
Manuel Bueno, mártir una familia de titiriteros acude
al pueblo con una mujer embarazada que fallece en
el parto. Tras saber que la difunta había sido asistida
por Don Manuel, el viudo, todavía sumido en el
trance de la reciente pérdida, quiso agradecérselo,
a lo que este responde: «El santo eres tú, honrado
payaso; te vi trabajar y comprendí que no sólo lo
haces para dar pan a tus hijos, sino también para
dar alegría a los de los otros» (Unamuno, 1995b, p.
321). Este hermoso fragmento atestigua la filantropía
unamuniana: la santidad entendida como aporte
4
desinteresado al otro, que pone remedio al dolor y
la angustia vital del inocente delito de haber nacido.
Y es que es preferible gozar de una ilusión activa y
lenitiva que enfrentarse a la ausencia de referentes
y al abismo de la duda. En palabras de Don Manuel
en su sermón de despedida, en el que se dirige tanto
a su pueblo como a la propia vida que abandona,
«Sed buenos, que esto basta» (Unamuno, 1995b,
p. 340). La criatura nivolesca retrata con precisión
la actitud compasiva ante la vulnerabilidad de los
otros, rasgo característico de la ética del cuidado
unamuniana.
Desde la reflexión ética el acto de cuidar es
caracterizado como hábito y como virtud. La tesis
de que la excelencia moral se puede enseñar y
adquirir, ya que se ejercita y refuerza mediante los
buenos hábitos, aparece originalmente en los primeros planteamientos sobre la paideia formulados
primero por los sofistas, y más tarde por Platón y
Aristóteles. De hecho, la educación proporcionada
tanto por los maestros sofistas como por el propio
Aristóteles en su Liceo se centra en formar a su
alumnado para ser «buen ciudadano», es decir,
inculcar las virtudes cívicas que favorecen la vida
en comunidad política (Cadavid Ramírez, 2014)
y mejoran la integración en la polis. Partiendo de
estas consideraciones se infiere que el cuidado es
un hábito provechoso para la comunidad, ya que
contribuye a entretejer y consolidar redes de apoyo
y reciprocidad. El cuidado, además, constituye un
hábito en tanto que comprende una multiplicidad
de acciones variadas y repetidas, prolongadas en
el tiempo, y enfocadas a proporcionar bienestar.
Asimismo, el cuidado es una virtud; implica una
modalidad de ser-con-otros profundamente valiosa, abierta a las demandas y necesidades de otras
personas frágiles y vulnerables. Se trata de una
virtud compleja en la que concurren «la comunidad interpersonal, la comprensión, el encuentro, el
diálogo y la compasión» (Torralba, 2002, p. 166).
De nuevo en La tía Tula ese virtuosismo se plasma
en una metodología cuasi religiosa apreciable en el
rigor con que la protagonista se ocupa de su sobrina
recién nacida. Esta costumbre se revela como un
imperativo ético, que Gertrudis pone en práctica
de forma litúrgica:
Fue un culto, un sacrificio, casi un sacramento.
El biberón, ese artefacto industrial, llegó a ser
para Gertrudis el símbolo y el instrumento de un
rito religioso. Limpiaba los botellines, cocía los
pisgos cada vez que los había empleado, preparaba y esterilizaba la leche con el ardor recatado
y ansioso con que una sacerdotisa cumpliría un
sacrificio ritual. [...]
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
Con manos de ángel: figuras del cuidado en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno
Se acostaba con la niña, a la que daba calor con
su cuerpo, y contra este guardaba el frasco de
la leche por si de noche se despertaba aquélla
pidiendo alimento. Y se le antojaba que el calor
de su carne, enfebrecida a ratos por la fiebre de
la maternidad virginal, de la virginidad maternal,
daba a aquella leche industrial una virtud de vida
materna… (Unamuno, 1995a, p. 876).
Al ubicar el cuidado en el núcleo de la vida
moral se enfatiza la necesidad de «dar al ejercicio
del cuidar —en tanto deber— un fundamento racional» (López Alonso, 2011, p. 314). No basta con
el impulso originario e instintivo de responder a la
llamada del otro —si bien ese movimiento es imprescindible para que aflore la actitud de cuidado—,
sino que se requiere también de una organización
y planificación de los cuidados, un planteamiento
sobre el método que permita atender las necesidades de la otra persona de la forma más completa
y eficaz. Así, cabe entender el cuidado como una
práctica social que da lugar a nuevas fuentes de
sabiduría práctica, o incluso nuevas modalidades
de la actividad racional de cuidar (Mackay, 2001,
p. 136), como la que se reflejaba en nuestro pasaje
de La Tía Tula.
3. EL EJERCICIO DEL CUIDADO A TRAVÉS
DEL LENGUAJE Y EL DIÁLOGO
Emmanuel Lévinas (1999), entre otros filósofos,
sostiene que a través del lenguaje nos abrimos a la
alteridad; la palabra siempre es una interpelación
que el otro me lanza y a la que yo respondo o, al
menos, tengo el imperativo ético de responder.
Así, la dimensión comunicativa es primordial
para construir ese «entre», ese mundo compartido
en el que transcurre nuestra existencia. Martin
Buber equipara la vida con «ser interpelado» y
plantea que «necesitamos situarnos, escuchar tan
sólo» (Buber, 1997, pp. 28-29), porque «sólo hay
auténtica responsabilidad allí donde hay responder verdadero» (p. 35). Esa reivindicación de la
dimensión dialógica, de gran presencia en la ética
contemporánea, entronca con una larga tradición
que arranca del método socrático y se desarrolla
en los diálogos de Platón. El diálogo al que nos
referimos aquí consiste en el arte de saber conversar auténticamente, entablando una genuina
conversación articulada a partir de una estructura
de pregunta y respuesta (Mensa, 2014). La responsabilidad del cuidado, ampliamente analizada en
el ámbito de la ética contemporánea por autores
como Hans Jonas (1995), alude etimológicamente
a la respuesta, esto es, a la capacidad de contestar y
asumir radicalmente el compromiso que la llamada
del otro me plantea.
El cuidado consiste en la acogida hospitalaria del
otro, que se plasma comunicativamente en la palabra
de bienvenida y aceptación. Para que surja esa hospitalidad es necesario que se constituya un espacio
habitable, una apertura que dé cabida al otro (Derrida
y Dufourmantelle, 1997, pp. 57-59). Esa práctica de la
acogida es un elemento nuclear de la ética del cuidar,
ya que supone aceptar al otro asumiendo su condición
de enfermedad, de vulnerabilidad o fragilidad. De
ahí se sigue que el diálogo, la escucha activa del otro
y de las necesidades que plantea, es imprescindible
para poder desplegar el cuidado de modo valioso.
La capacidad de escucha es una virtud central en
este sentido, ya que escuchando al otro mostramos
respeto e interés por lo que refiere, e implica adoptar
una actitud de apertura y solicitud a lo que el otro
demanda: «Escuchar tiene que ver con la voluntad,
con la disponibilidad de abrirse y de dejarse tocar
por la voz del otro» (Torralba, 2002, p. 108).
La apertura comunicativa es primordial para que
el auxilio brindado a otra persona sea de calidad y se
ajuste plenamente a sus necesidades, ya que supone
dejar que el otro exprese sus peticiones, deseos,
temores e incertidumbres, es decir, que verbalice su
sufrimiento y vulnerabilidad y la exponga ante quien
desea proporcionarle ayuda a través del cuidado.
En el contexto puramente asistencial cabe destacar
también que el lenguaje es una herramienta poderosa
para iniciar, favorecer, implementar y mantener el
proceso de humanización de los cuidados (Martínez
Ques, 2019), pues los pacientes no han de ser solo
atendidos sino también reconocidos a partir de un
diálogo sincero (Ausín, 2019).
El aspecto oral del cuidado se aprecia de forma
paradigmática en San Manuel Bueno, mártir, donde
aparece el poder terapéutico de la palabra que cuida
y mitiga la angustia de los feligreses. La herramienta
que usa el protagonista para pastorear a su rebaño y
consolar al pueblo es la palabra, el «bello discurso»
(epidé, en griego), un razonamiento persuasivo o
mito sugerente que induce la sophrosyne —equilibrio— en el alma (Gil Fernández, 2004). Manuel
Bueno hace uso tanto del don sanador de su voz:
«Y era tal la acción de su presencia, de sus miradas, y tal sobre todo la dulcísima autoridad de sus
palabras y sobre todo de su voz — ¡qué milagro
de voz!» (Unamuno, 1995b, p. 316) como de la
cautela del silencio, cuando calla sobre aquello
con potencial destructivo para la comunidad: «¿La
verdad? La verdad, Lázaro, es acaso algo terrible,
algo intolerable, algo mortal; la gente sencilla no
podría vivir con ella» (Unamuno, 1995b, p. 330).
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
5
Olaya Fernández Guerrero / Álvaro Ledesma de la Fuente
Otra cuestión importante referida a la palabra
como expresión de afecto y cuidado es la que aflora
en el acto de nombrar a otra persona, que es un modo
de tomarla en cuenta y mostrar interés por su situación. Tal y como afirma Buber a este respecto: «La
relación puede subsistir aun cuando el ser humano
a quien digo Tú no lo perciba en su experiencia»
(Buber, 1995, p. 11). Nombrar al otro y dirigirse a
él a través de la palabra inaugura una apertura ética
y determina una predisposición a acoger la alteridad
y a situarse en una actitud de cuidado. La importancia del nombre propio, así como su influencia
en la construcción de la identidad emocional de la
criatura, es un aspecto que Unamuno no pasa por
alto, y se reflejará en Amor y pedagogía, novela a la
que nos referiremos con más detalle posteriormente. Quedémonos ahora con que el protagonista de
este relato, despojado de todo rastro afectivo por la
severa pedagogía paterna a la que se ve sometido,
está privado incluso del refugio de poseer un nombre
propio e inequívoco: ante su padre recibe el nombre
de Apolodoro, una denominación acorde a sus dones
y lo que se espera de él; en cambio su madre prefiere
referirse a su hijo con un cariñoso Luis, que carece
del componente etimológico a cambio de una mayor
cercanía y conexión:
Mientras el padre se encierra con el filósofo, enciérrase la madre con el hijo y allí es el besuquear
al sueño de su sueño.
—Mamá, di querido.
—¡Querido! ¡querido mío! ¡rico! ¡rey de la casa!
¡cielo! ¡querido! ¡querido...! Luis, Luisito, Luisito. Mi Luis...
Porque al bautizarle hizo le pusieran Luis, el
nombre de su abuelo materno, del padre de Marina, en vez de aquel feo Apolodoro, y es Luis
el nombre prohibido, el vergonzante, el íntimo.
—Luis, mi Luis. Luis mío. Luisito, mi Luisito —y
se lo come a besos. (Unamuno, 1995a, p. 350).
El acto de nombrar es además una manifestación
de poder, una acción según la cual después del parto
como inicio de la existencia biológica del neonato se
le concede además una entidad e identidad biográfica
por medio de un nombre. El antropónimo que no solo
menciona, sino que también rubrica pertenencia a
un linaje. El ejemplo de esta potestad se halla en la
poderosa Raquel del relato breve Dos madres. Este
texto hace una relectura en clave veterotestamentaria
del tópico bíblico de la maternidad delegada en otra
mujer, y como tal está trufado de referencias veladas
a distintos pasajes de las Escrituras (Nicholas, 1987,
p. 63). Su protagonista es un trasunto más de la voluntad de maternidad de las criaturas unamunianas
6
ejercida a través de otro personaje de la nivola; así,
Raquel pontifica cómo ha de llamarse la criatura
que a la postre será su hija pero que no había salido
de sus entrañas:
En aquel momento se oyó un grito desgarrador.
Doña Marta corrió al lado de su hija, y Raquel se
quedó escuchando al silencio que siguió al grito.
Luego se sentó. Y al sentir, al poco, que pasaba
Juan a su lado, le detuvo cogiéndole de un brazo
y le interrogó con un «¿qué?» de ansia.
DON JUAN. —Una niña...
RAQUEL. —¡Se llamará Raquel! (Unamuno,
1995b, p. 227).
Por último, es preciso señalar que la escucha
referida al cuidado no opera solamente en un sentido literal, sino también de forma figurada, pues
en muchos contextos la persona en situación de
vulnerabilidad carece de la posibilidad de expresarse
verbalmente. En este escenario, la práctica ética de
la escucha implica una actitud de observación y
apertura hacia las necesidades del otro respondiendo
solícitamente al llanto, el lamento, el gesto dolorido
o el padecimiento silencioso del que somos testigos
y ante el que nos sentimos interpelados, incluso si
no hay una verbalización explícita que exponga la
demanda de cuidado. Los personajes de Unamuno
ya referidos —Gertrudis, Raquel o Manuel Bueno— y otros que se citarán a continuación encajan
en esta caracterización, pues se muestran solícitos y
disponibles para captar y atender las necesidades de
otras personas que requieren de su auxilio, aunque
estas no formulen una petición expresa de ayuda.
4. LA DIMENSIÓN HÁPTICA DEL CUIDADO:
TACTO Y PROXIMIDAD
Cuando nos referimos al cuidado, una de sus condiciones de emergencia y posibilidad consiste precisamente en su arraigo en un plano material y carnal,
somático, del que surge la necesidad de cuidado a
la vez que las opciones de darle respuesta. Somos
seres corpóreos, tal y como la filosofía ha destacado reiteradamente con Spinoza, Merleau-Ponty,
Foucault o Deleuze entre muchas otras referencias.
Esta corporalidad nos hace seres vulnerables y
dependientes en la medida en que «el cuerpo es el
estar-expuesto del ser» (Nancy, 1992, p. 32), que
nos ancla al mundo y hace que nuestro cuerpo sea
afectado por este. Como nos recuerda Merleau-Ponty
(1945, p. 101): «El anonimato de nuestro cuerpo
es inseparablemente libertad y servidumbre», y
es que procesos como la enfermedad o la muerte
explicitan que nuestro cuerpo puede ser experimen-
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
Con manos de ángel: figuras del cuidado en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno
tado como vulnerable, doliente o falible, según el
análisis fenomenológico trazado por Xabier Escribano (2015). En nuestra estructura ontológica se
hace patente, ya desde el nacimiento, la fragilidad
y vulnerabilidad que nos sitúa a merced de otras
personas, convirtiéndonos en seres que requieren
de constantes cuidados.
En sus primeros años de vida un niño o niña
necesita la protección constante de otras personas
—habitualmente sus progenitores— para subsistir,
desarrollarse y convertirse en un adulto con plena
autonomía. Además de cubrir las necesidades materiales de alimento, vestido y cobijo, durante la infancia es imprescindible para el desarrollo emocional
el contacto físico, la demostración directa de afecto
por parte de sus figuras de apego, que generan seguridad y confort en esa etapa inicial de la existencia.
Este cuidado se ejerce desde la inmediatez, tanto en
el sentido temporal, ya comentado anteriormente,
como en términos espaciales, pues resulta difícil
cuidar desde la lejanía. Las relaciones de cuidado
se basan en la contigüidad, recortan la distancia
interpersonal y permiten fundar una cercanía que
es simultáneamente física y metafísica, orgánica
y afectiva. Además de la dimensión lingüística y
dialógica, cuidar incluye también una vertiente primordialmente táctil, pues es preciso tocar el cuerpo
de otra persona para administrarle un medicamento,
darle de beber, desinfectar sus heridas, alimentarla,
asearla, vestirla y desvestirla, ayudarla a levantarse
o cambiar de postura. Los cuidados más básicos,
íntimos y delicados se realizan siempre de manera
manual, y su mecanización y automatización —tanto
literal como figurada— puede desembocar en una
deshumanización y despersonalización que incide
negativamente en su calidad.
La dimensión táctil de nuestra corporalidad
es esencial a todos los niveles, porque la propia
administración de los cuidados requiere muchas
veces necesariamente de esa tangibilidad, pero
también porque, de manera simbólica, sentir ese
contacto permite percibir explícitamente la cercanía
y la proximidad de otra persona dispuesta a cuidar
y acompañar a quien lo requiera. Y es que, como
señala Francesc Torralba (2002, p. 100): «Precisamente porque el ser humano es frágil, necesita
el contacto epidérmico de otro ser humano, pues
de este modo no se siente solo ni abandonado».
El tacto apunta a la cordialidad y el respeto en el
contacto con el otro (Caneda, 2019). La relevancia
de esa proximidad protectora se trasluce en varios
pasajes de La Tía Tula ya comentados aquí, donde
se describen las acciones físicas que explicitan el
vínculo afectivo entre Gertrudis y sus sobrinos, o
en Niebla, una de las nivolas más conocidas, cuyo
protagonista rememora nostálgicamente los besos
y abrazos que le prodigaba su madre. En el momento de la muerte el estrecho contacto físico entre
los dos personajes de la nivola adquiere un papel
central y representa metafóricamente la despedida
entre ambos: «Murió con su mano en la mano de
su hijo, con sus ojos en los ojos de él. Sintió Augusto que la mano se enfriaba, sintió que los ojos
se inmovilizaban. Soltó la mano después de haber
dejado en su frialdad un beso cálido, y cerró los
ojos» (Unamuno, 1995a, p. 509).
En otras situaciones unamunianas se reitera
esta alusión metonímica a las manos como epifanía del contacto físico y de la relación de cuidado
establecida entre los personajes. Es el caso de En
manos de la cocinera, donde se narran escenas de
cuidados en un entorno doméstico: «Cuando la pobre
criada le renovaba los vendajes o le arreglaba la
postura de la pierna, no parecían sus manos ni aun
manos de mujer, sino alas de ángel por lo suaves»
(Unamuno, 1995b, p. 541). El propio título de este
brevísimo cuento publicado en el diario madrileño
El Imparcial es ilustrativo al respecto, ya que emplea
la expresión «en manos de», que alude a la relación
de dependencia y al hecho de estar a merced de otra
persona. El protagonista, Vicente, está en manos de
su cocinera, que en esta historia equivale a estar en
buenas manos. La empleada, Ignacia, movida por
el afecto y la compasión, lo atiende con diligencia
y delicadeza, y la actitud de la muchacha acaba
conmoviendo el corazón de Vicente, que decide
romper su compromiso matrimonial para casarse
con la sirvienta. Las manos de la mujer son vehículo
de expresión táctil de sus sentimientos por él, ya
que es un hombre comprometido y al que ella está
subordinada, de modo que cualquier otra forma de
manifestarle su pasión resultaría ilícita. En cualquier
caso, entre los dos personajes existe una relación de
proximidad y convivencia, de conocimiento mutuo,
que propicia el surgimiento de una mayor intimidad
entre ambos, pues como señala Torralba: «Confiar
en alguien es creer en él, es ponerse en sus manos,
es ponerse a su disposición» (2002, p. 92). Vicente
confía en Ignacia, se pone en sus manos, y ella logra
transmitirle a través de esas manos cuidadoras el
amor que le profesa, y que acaba por ser recíproco.
En definitiva, el cuidado se manifiesta y hace
tangible a través del contacto físico, cuerpo con
cuerpo, conexión epidérmica que se explicita afectivamente en la caricia, como afirma Lévinas, pero
también en el despliegue táctil de todas las tareas de
cuidado. Más allá —o más acá— de las limitaciones
de lo lingüístico —porque el lenguaje es contado
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
7
Olaya Fernández Guerrero / Álvaro Ledesma de la Fuente
a través de una distancia, y entabla una relación
con lo que no se toca (Lévinas, 1999)—, el tacto
nos abre a otra modalidad de acción e interacción
intersubjetiva que, si se ejercita con perspectiva
ética, desemboca en el cuidado.
5. EL CUIDADO, LO FEMENINO Y LA
ACTITUD MATERNAL
Hemos visto que cuidar implica la recuperación de
categorías éticas como la solicitud, la atención, la
relación, la interdependencia o la vulnerabilidad
(Domingo Moratalla, 2019), y que conlleva una
actitud de protección y ayuda al desarrollo de otro
ser que se encuentra en situación de dependencia.
Autoras como Carol Gilligan (2006) comprueban
que ese tipo de actitud está más presente en mujeres
que en hombres: en las pautas morales femeninas se
detecta mayor atención a lo concreto y al contexto de
la acción, mientras que en los hombres predominan
los principios de autonomía y justicia.
La desconexión entre el individuo y sus relaciones y la separación de lo público y lo privado define
un ámbito de la actividad humana que solo puede
ser mantenido en tanto que alguien se ocupe de las
relaciones y de la esfera privada, y que se sienta
vinculado a otras personas. Históricamente esta tarea
de cuidar ha sido la obligación específica y la labor
no remunerada de las mujeres, hasta el punto de que
en las sociedades patriarcales las mujeres han sido
forzadas a asumir ese rol (Gilligan, 2003, p. 157).
La filósofa estadounidense critica esta situación,
enfatizando que el cuidado no está esencialmente
asociado a la naturaleza femenina, sino que es atribuible a los diversos patrones de socialización de
género. Según reivindica la corriente ética iniciada
por la autora, el principio de cuidado tiene valor per
se porque permite mejorar las condiciones de vida
y dignidad de quienes reciben ese cuidado, pero
su aplicación no puede exigirse únicamente a las
mujeres —que son las que lo han ejercido y siguen
ejerciendo mayoritariamente—, sino que ha de ser
una actitud fomentada entre toda la ciudadanía y
reforzada desde las instituciones. El compromiso
de cuidado no ha de ser adoptado únicamente a
título individual, sino que el feminismo promueve
el cuidado como algo que debe institucionalizarse,
pues es valioso en sí mismo y con pretensiones de
universalidad (Fernández Guerrero, 2011; Ausín
y Triviño, 2022).
Hacer una revisión crítica de la obra de Unamuno desde la perspectiva de la ética feminista actual
puede resultar anacrónico, y además se aleja del
foco de interés de este estudio; lo que sí nos parece
pertinente es resaltar la fuerte presencia de rasgos
8
y actitudes de cuidado en los personajes femeninos
que pueblan los relatos de este autor. En muchas
mujeres del universo unamuniano, ya sean madres,
esposas, hijas o sirvientas, es frecuente percibir
una actitud de preocupación, protección y afecto
amoroso y cuasi maternal hacia los personajes
masculinos. Es notorio en el caso de las madres,
que encarnan de modo paradigmático el rol de
cuidadoras. Sirva como ejemplo Niebla, donde el
personaje de la madre de Augusto Pérez representa
arquetípicamente el cuidado abnegado y volcado
hacia el hijo. En este sentido se puede citar el valor
expresivo de la exclamación «¡Hijo mío!»1, que
pervive en el recuerdo de Augusto incluso años
después de fallecida su madre, y que atestigua que
esa presencia protectora es percibida por el hijo
aunque ella, físicamente, ya no está junto a él. Para
el protagonista de Niebla la madre es un referente
de seguridad, pragmatismo y certidumbre que contrasta con la idiosincrasia dubitativa y escéptica de
Augusto Pérez. Así, es la madre, que conoce bien
su carácter, la que le recomienda encarecidamente
que se case y que además escoja como esposa a una
mujer resuelta y con determinación, para contrarrestar las divagaciones metafísicas del hijo. También
Marina Carbajosa, madre del pequeño Apolodoro
de Amor y pedagogía, oponiéndose al criterio de su
esposo, amamanta al bebé y le proporciona un trato
afectuoso que refleja el modelo maternal tradicional
y que contrasta con la «pedagogía científica» que
desarrolla su marido, don Avito Carrascal. Este
personaje se propone el objetivo de engendrar al
genio definitivo según las leyes del cientificismo,
diseñando para ello un meticuloso plan que incluye la elección de la futura madre, una educación
doméstica exhaustiva y una severa disciplina de
ejercicios físicos y mentales. Para lograr que su
joven vástago desarrolle al máximo su intelecto,
don Avito considera necesario desprenderse de todo
componente emocional. La obra refiere el fracaso
estrepitoso de este proyecto pedagógico, que resulta
en un jovencito confuso, incapaz de relacionarse
con el mundo, que es blanco de todo tipo de mofas
Nos remitimos aquí a la conocida como crisis del noventa y siete, circunstancia muy comentada en los estudios
unamunianos debido al enorme impasse que supuso en
su pensamiento. Los hechos acaecieron la noche del 21
al 22 de marzo de 1897, cuando, motivado por una serie
de problemas familiares y personales que llevaban meses
aquejándolo, padeció una intensa crisis nocturna. Entonces su esposa Concha Lizárraga lo acunó entre sus brazos
mientras exclamaba: «¡Hijo mío!». Esta escena, con distintas variaciones, se va a repetir a lo largo de su obra en los
pasajes en los que un personaje, casi siempre una mujer,
lleva a cabo prácticas de cuidado.
1
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
Con manos de ángel: figuras del cuidado en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno
y que pone fin a su vida con una acción trágica. Esta
nivola expone la importancia que confiere Unamuno
a la dimensión afectiva y amorosa, representada por
la omnipresente figura materna.
Otras figuras femeninas, como Gertrudis de La
Tía Tula, Ignacia de En manos de la cocinera o Raquel y Berta, de Dos madres, si bien no son madres
biológicas, adoptan un papel maternal que es clave
en el relato. De Gertrudis, dedicada al cuidado de sus
sobrinos, ya hemos hablado anteriormente. Ignacia,
empleada doméstica de Vicente en En manos de la
cocinera, asume el rol de benefactora con respecto
al protagonista cuando éste sufre un accidente que
lo mantiene inmovilizado, y le prodiga todas las
atenciones necesarias para su recuperación. De
nuevo en Dos madres:
Y entonces Raquel se puso a mecer y a abrazar
a la criaturita, cantándole extrañas canciones en
una lengua desconocida de Berta y de los suyos,
así como de Juan. ¿Qué le cantaba? Y se hizo un
silencio espeso en torno de aquellas canciones
de cuna que parecían venir de un mundo lejano,
muy lejano, perdido en la bruma de los ensueños
(Unamuno, 1995b, p. 229).
Incluso Ángela Carballino, narradora de San
Manuel Bueno, mártir, es partícipe de esos desvelos, y así lo descubrimos cuando se confiesa a sí
misma: «Empezaba yo a sentir una especie de afecto
maternal hacia mi padre espiritual; quería aliviarle
del peso de su cruz de nacimiento» (Unamuno,
1995b, p. 325). Nuestro autor reproduce así, quizás
de modo inconsciente y acrítico, los estereotipos
de género tradicionales y plenamente vigentes en
su época, que atribuyen a las mujeres las actitudes
de abnegación, sacrificio, entrega y cuidado2. Estos
casos se contraponen a los personajes masculinos
surgidos de su pluma, de los que la dimensión de
cuidado está ausente, con la excepción de San
Manuel Bueno, mártir y del cuidado intensivo,
aunque repleto de excentricidades, de don Avito
en Amor y pedagogía.
En los relatos unamunianos la actitud compasiva y protectora de los personajes femeninos tiene
2
Como muestra tenemos «A una aspirante a escritora», un
breve artículo en el que Unamuno hace una distinción radical entre la lengua literaria y la lengua popular o vulgar, y
descarta la posibilidad de que las mujeres puedan dedicarse
a la literatura, al ser este un instrumento de hombres. Apunta
que la mujer se desempeña mejor en lo objetivo y no en lo
subjetivo, y que es más más capaz de objetivarse y por eso
es más independiente. Por último, declara que la mujer es,
ante todo madre, pues en ella el instinto de maternidad prima
sobre el de sexualidad (Unamuno, 2008, pp. 332-338).
generalmente un papel positivo —con la excepción
de Dos madres, donde el fervor maternal de las
protagonistas adquiere un cariz negativo—, puesto
que generan bienestar y seguridad, dan resguardo y
confortan a otros personajes que se sienten desvalidos y vulnerables, etcétera. Esto se percibe intensamente en muchas de las madres retratadas por el
autor, que asumen con gran dedicación la tarea de
amparar a sus criaturas en el plano físico, afectivo,
educativo y asistencial. Tal y como ha demostrado
la psicopedagogía, la infancia y adolescencia son
las etapas en que se fragua la personalidad adulta,
pero son fases de gran fragilidad porque aún no
se han desarrollado los mecanismos psicológicos
de autoprotección, por ello es fundamental crecer
un entorno estable y que proporcione seguridad al
menor (cf. Coronado, 2018; o Landale, McHale y
Booth, 2013). De ahí la relevancia de la dimensión afectiva, pues los niños y niñas «tienen una
necesidad vital del amor y de la responsabilidad
de los adultos, en primer lugar, de los padres», y
«ser amado es, tal vez, la necesidad más profunda
de un niño» (Reis Monteiro, 2008, pp. 191-192).
El papel del amor en el proceso de aprendizaje es
destacado por Unamuno en Amor y pedagogía, como
ya hemos señalado, y reivindica la importancia de
los afectos y las emociones a los que la filosofía
ha concedido tradicionalmente un rol secundario.
El trato afectuoso, además de brotar de un impulso
ético que los padres y madres suelen experimentar
hacia sus vástagos, conlleva también una dimensión
de obligatoriedad, de cuidar y educar a los hijos,
vigente ya desde la época de los diálogos platónicos
(López Alonso, 2011) y que en el contexto contemporáneo se explicita en lo que Reis Monteiro (2008,
p. 193) denomina «responsabilidad pedagógica».
Si nos desplazamos del plano ético al metafísico,
Torralba se refiere a la paternidad y maternidad como
una cualidad ontológica: «Su modo de ver la realidad
y de estar en el mundo ya no pueden desvincularse
del hecho de ser padre» (2002, p. 68). Esto implica
la plena asunción de la responsabilidad ineludible
adquirida al procrear, actitud que se percibe en muchas
de las madres retratadas por Unamuno y ya citadas
aquí. Para esos personajes femeninos la tarea de cuidar
a sus descendientes es fundamental y ocupa el núcleo
de su existencia; todo lo demás pasa a un segundo
plano. El ejemplo más reseñable se encuentra en
Niebla: cuando enviuda, la madre de Augusto Pérez
declara que su única motivación para existir es velar
por su hijo: «Tengo que vivir para ti, para ti sólo —le
decía por las noches, antes de acostarse—» (Unamuno, 1995a, p. 507). En el relato somos espectadores
también de cómo la madre apoya incansablemente a
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
9
Olaya Fernández Guerrero / Álvaro Ledesma de la Fuente
su hijo durante toda su etapa escolar y comparte con
él tanto los momentos importantes de su vida como
las acciones cotidianas más triviales, reflejando así
la incondicionalidad del amor materno. Este tema
aparece asimismo en Amor y pedagogía, donde la
madre reparte equitativamente sus afectos entre su
hijo y su hija mientras que el interés del esposo en la
paternidad es mucho más selectivo: se desvive por
su primogénito, pero cuando nace Rosa, la segunda
hija, le presta escasa atención porque considera
que su condición femenina impedirá que alcance la
excelencia intelectual. Para ella, su padre no tiene
ni amor ni pedagogía.
de ayuda desinteresada al prójimo como acto más
prístino y carnal de su habitar en el nivolesco mundo
de ficciones. El cuidado se convierte en tarea central y
leitmotiv que vertebra las historias y da sentido a sus
personajes. En el entramado de la intrahistoria, tan
cara a nuestro autor, las relaciones cotidianas están
marcadas por la reciprocidad, el mutuo auxilio y los
vínculos de proximidad; en definitiva, se basan en
el cuidado que para Unamuno brota y se ejerce de
manera discreta, silente y espontánea, y acaba por
confundirse con la vida misma.
6. CONCLUSIONES
Álvarez Castro, Luis (2015). Los espejos del yo.
Existencialismo y metaficción en la narrativa de
Unamuno. Ediciones Universidad de Salamanca.
En las diversas secciones de este estudio se ha desplegado un análisis de la obra de Unamuno articulado
en torno a las propuestas contemporáneas de la ética
del cuidado, lo cual permite recuperar la vigencia de
este autor a la luz de la filosofía actual y poner de
relieve que, a pesar del conservadurismo de algunos
de sus planteamientos, ofrece también elementos
valiosos para repensar éticamente varios aspectos de
la relación con la alteridad. En el universo surgido de
su pluma este autor recrea una y otra vez el espacio
íntimo de los afectos, donde las relaciones basadas en
actitudes de responsabilidad, compromiso y entrega
a los demás pasan a primer plano. Es por ello que
nos parece pertinente releer a Unamuno a través del
prisma de la ética del cuidado, ya que sus personajes
y situaciones ilustran en la praxis muchas de las
cuestiones teóricas planteadas por esta corriente de
la filosofía contemporánea. En la creación literaria
unamunesca, el cuidado se ejerce a través de la palabra
y a través del tacto, es verbal y háptico, y se asocia
estrechamente con una actitud solícita que se abre a
la alteridad y que acoge y responde diligentemente
a sus demandas de atención y auxilio.
Otro aspecto reseñable de nuestra propuesta es
que reivindica el filosofar a partir de un andamiaje
literario, habilidad que Unamuno dominaba con
maestría y que forma parte de las señas de identidad
de la filosofía en lengua castellana. Las situaciones y
personajes de ficción propician que lo inteligible se
haga sensible y, en el enfoque adoptado en este estudio, ello implica la confluencia de la ética y la estética.
En ese sentido la obra unamuniana ofrece multitud
de posibilidades, pues el formato propio de la nivola
permite vehicular reflexiones al mismo tiempo que
son representadas en las acciones de los personajes.
El discurso literario concede una dimensión práctica
a la reflexión ética, un hacer hacia los demás en el
que los personajes, en forma de fragmentos de la
voluntad de su creador, manifiestan una dimensión
10
BIBLIOGRAFÍA
Ausín, Txetxu (2019). “Las palabras y los cuidados”, en
Roldán, Triviño, Navarro, Rodríguez-Arias y Roldán
(eds.). Hacer justicia haciendo compañía. Homenaje
a M.ª Teresa López de la Vieja. Universidad de
Salamanca, 281-290.
Ausín, Txetxu y Triviño, Rosana (2022). Responsabilidad
por los cuidados. Bajo Palabra, II Época, 30, 155174. https://doi.org/10.15366/bp2022.30.008
Buber, Martin (1995). Yo y tú. Caparrós Editores.
Buber, Martin (1997). “Diálogo”, en Diálogo y otros
escritos. Riopiedras.
Cadavid Ramírez, Lina Marcela (2014). Los
Sofistas: maestros del areté en la paideia griega.
Revista Perseitas, 2 (1), 37-61. https://doi.
org/10.21501/23461780.1128
Caneda Lowry, Santiago (2019). De corazón - Lo
intocable. A partir de “Le toucher, Jean-Luc
Nancy”. Escritura e imagen, 15, 253-266. https://
doi.org/10.5209/esim.66741
Cerezo Galán, Pedro (1996). Las máscaras de lo trágico:
filosofía y tragedia en Miguel de Unamuno. Trotta.
Coronado-Hijón, Antonio (2018). Infancia: vulnerabilidad y
resiliencia. Revista Infancia, Educación y Aprendizaje,
4 (2), 10-21. https://doi.org/10.22370/ieya.2018.4.2.640
Derrida, Jacques y Dufourmantelle, Anne (1997). De
l’hospitalité. Calmann-Lévy.
Domingo Moratalla, Agustín (2019). Cuidado y
responsabilidad: de Hans Jonas a Carol Gilligan.
Pensamiento. Revista de investigación e información
filosófica, 283(75), 357-373. https://doi.org/10.14422/
pen.v75.i283.y2019.019
Escribano, Xabier (2015). Poética del movimiento
corporal y vulnerabilidad: una reflexión desde la
fenomenología de la enfermedad. Co-herencia:
revista de humanidades, 12, (23), 71-88. https://
doi.org/10.17230/co-herencia.12.23.3
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
Con manos de ángel: figuras del cuidado en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno
Fernández Guerrero, Olaya (2011). Sobre la alteridad
y la diferencia sexual. Logos. Anales del seminario
de metafísica, 45, 293-317. https://doi.org/10.5209/
rev_ASEM.2012.v45.40417
Gil Fernández, Luis (2004). Pedro Laín Entralgo y la
Historia de la Medicina Griega. Cuadernos de filología
clásica: Estudios griegos e indoeuropeos, 14, 9-14.
Gilligan, Carol (2003). Hearing the difference: Theorizing
connection. Anuario de Psicología, 34 (2), 155-161.
Gilligan, Carol (2006). “Con otra voz: las concepciones
femeninas del yo y de la moralidad”, en López
de la Vieja, Barrios, Figueruelo, Velayos y
Carbajo (eds.), Bioética y feminismo. Estudios
multidisciplinares de género. Universidad de
Salamanca, 15-56.
Jonas, Hans (1995). El principio de responsabilidad.
Ensayo de una ética para la civilización tecnológica.
Herder.
de los cuidados, 12, 1-4 (editorial). http://ciberindex.
com/index.php/et/article/view/e90865/e90865
Mélich, Joan-Carles (2010). Ética de la compasión.
Herder.
Mensa, Jaume (2014). Platón y Sócrates, psicagogos.
Las “palabras mágicas” de Sócrates y la cura del
alma (Cármides 157a). Ápeiron: estudios de filosofía,
1, 242-268. https://vixra.org/pdf/1409.0225v3.pdf
Merleau-Ponty, Maurice (1945). Phénoménologie de la
Perception. Gallimard.
Nancy, Jean-Luc (1992). Corpus. Métailié.
Nicholas, Robert (1987). Unamuno, narrador. Castalia.
Orringer, Nelson R. (1985). Unamuno y los protestantes
liberales (1912). Sobre las fuentes de «Del sentimiento
trágico de la vida». Gredos.
Reis-Monteiro, Antonio (2008). La revolución de los
Derechos del Niño. Editorial Popular.
La Rubia Prado, Francisco (1996). Alegorías de la
voluntad. Pensamiento orgánico, retórica y
deconstrucción en la obra de Miguel de Unamuno.
Libertarias/Prodhufi.
Ricoeur, Paul (1996). Sí mismo como otro. Siglo XXI.
Landale, Nancy; McHale, Susan y Booth, Alan (eds.)
(2013). Families and Child Health. Springer. https://
doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-6194-4
Unamuno, Miguel de (1995a). Obras Completas I.
Narrativa. Fundación José Antonio de Castro.
Lévinas, Emmanuel (1999). Totalidad e infinito. Ensayo
sobre la exterioridad. Sígueme.
López Alonso, Marta (2011). El cuidado: un imperativo
para la bioética. Relectura filosófico-teológica desde
la epiméleia. Universidad Pontificia de Comillas.
Mackay, Fiona (2001). Love and Politics. Women
Politicians and the Ethics of Care. Continuum.
Martínez Ques, Ángel Alfredo (2019). La ética de
la compasión en el cuidado de otros. Ética de los
cuidados. Revista para el estudio y reflexión ética
Torralba i Roselló, Francesc (2002). Ética del cuidar.
Fundamentos, contextos y problemas. Institut Borja
de Bioètica y Fundación MAPFRE Medicina.
Unamuno, Miguel de (1995b). Obras Completas II.
Narrativa. Fundación José Antonio de Castro.
Unamuno, Miguel de (2005). Obras Completas VII. Paisajes
y recuerdos. Fundación José Antonio de Castro.
Unamuno, Miguel de (2008). Obras completas, IX.
Ensayos, artículos y conferencias. Fundación José
Antonio de Castro.
Unamuno, Miguel de (2009). Obras Completas X.
Ensayos. Fundación José Antonio de Castro.
Zavala, Iris (1991). Unamuno y el pensamiento dialógico.
Anthropos.
ISEGORÍA, N.º 69, julio-diciembre, 2023, e19, ISSN-L: 1130-2097 | eISSN: 1988-8376, https://doi.org/10.3989/isegoria.2023.69.19
11
|
|
https://openalex.org/W4294091459
|
https://figshare.com/articles/preprint/Payload-Byte_A_Tool_for_Extracting_and_Labeling_Packet_Capture_Files_of_Modern_Network_Intrusion_Detection_Datasets/20714221/2/files/38302704.pdf
|
English
| null |
Payload-Byte: A Tool for Extracting and Labeling Packet Capture Files of Modern Network Intrusion Detection Datasets
| null | 2,022
|
cc-by
| 9,120
|
This paper was downloaded from TechRxiv (https://www.techrxiv.org). LICENSE CC BY 4.0 SUBMISSION DATE / POSTED DATE
29-08-2022 / 30-11-2022 Payload-Byte: A Tool for Extracting and Labeling
Packet Capture Files of Modern Network Intrusion
Detection Datasets Yasir Ali Farrukh
Clean and Resilient Energy System Lab
Texas A&M University
College Station, TX, USA
yasir.ali@tamu.edu
Irfan Khan
Clean and Resilient Energy System Lab
Texas A&M University
Galveston, TX, USA
irfankhan@tamu.edu
Syed Wali
Clean and Resilient Energy System Lab
Texas A&M University
College Station, TX, USA
syedwali@tamu.edu Yasir Ali Farrukh
Clean and Resilient Energy System Lab
Texas A&M University
College Station, TX, USA
yasir.ali@tamu.edu
Irfan Khan
Clean and Resilient Energy System Lab
Texas A&M University
Galveston, TX, USA
irfankhan@tamu.edu
Syed Wali
Clean and Resilient Energy System Lab
Texas A&M University
College Station, TX, USA
syedwali@tamu.edu David Bierbrauer
Army Cyber Institute
United States Military Academy
West Point, NY, USA
david.bierbrauer@westpoint.edu John A. Pavlik
Army Cyber Institute
United States Military Academy
West Point, NY, USA
john.pavlik@westpoint.edu Nathaniel D. Bastian
Army Cyber Institute
United States Military Academy
West Point, NY, USA
nathaniel.bastian@westpoint.edu technological adaptations, as it impacts every aspect of society
and people’s lives in one way or another. The world we used
to know is no longer similar, as it has transformed into a
collaborative network in which everything is interconnected
[1]. This inter-connectivity has led to an increase in cyber-
attacks on ICT [2] and OT systems [3]. Cyber-attacks on
the network of ICT systems often lead to data breaches and
operational halts for the company [4], [5]. Therefore, ICT
systems require effective and robust security solutions. Abstract—Adapting modern approaches for network intrusion
detection is becoming critical, given the rapid technological
advancement and adversarial attack rates. Therefore, packet-
based methods utilizing payload data are gaining much pop-
ularity due to their effectiveness in detecting certain attacks. However, packet-based approaches suffer from a lack of stan-
dardization, resulting in incomparability and reproducibility
issues. Unlike flow-based datasets, no standard labeled dataset
exists, forcing researchers to follow bespoke labeling pipelines
for individual approaches. Without a standardized baseline,
proposed approaches cannot be compared and evaluated with
each other. One cannot gauge whether the proposed approach
is a methodological advancement or is just being benefited
from the proprietary interpretation of the dataset. Addressing
comparability and reproducibility issues, we introduce Payload-
Byte, an open-source tool for extracting and labeling network
packets in this work. Payload-Byte utilizes metadata information
and labels raw traffic captures of modern intrusion detection
datasets in a generalized manner. Moreover, we transformed the
labeled data into a byte-wise feature vector that can be utilized for
training machine learning models. CITATION Farrukh, Yasir Ali; Khan, Irfan; Wali, Syed; Bierbrauer, David; Pavlik, John; Bastian, Nathaniel (2022):
Payload-Byte: A Tool for Extracting and Labeling Packet Capture Files of Modern Network Intrusion Detection
Datasets. TechRxiv. Preprint. https://doi.org/10.36227/techrxiv.20714221.v2 10.36227/techrxiv.20714221.v2 10.36227/techrxiv.20714221.v2 Payload-Byte: A Tool for Extracting and Labeling
Packet Capture Files of Modern Network Intrusion
Detection Datasets The whole cycle of processing
and labeling is explicitly stated in this work. Furthermore, source
code and processed data are made publicly available so that it
may act as a standardized baseline for future research work. Lastly, we present a brief comparative analysis of machine
learning models trained on packet-based and flow-based data. Network Intrusion Detection System (NIDS) is often con-
sidered a feasible option to protect against network-based
attacks [6], as it identifies attack behavior by analyzing the
network traffic of vital nodes in a network. NIDS utilizes
various approaches for the detection of malicious attack in-
stances. The most prominent of these approaches are rule-
based, flow-based, and packet-based methods [7]. Rule-based
methods are typically based on feature selection to construct
domain-specific rules. Anomalies are detected by comparing
the extracted signature of network flow with predefined rules. Rule-based methods are effective for detecting known attacks
but they heavily rely on in-depth domain knowledge. Recently, much attention has been diverted toward applying
machine learning (ML) approaches to NIDS as ML algorithms
are achieving striking results in domains where it is hard to
specify a set of rules for their procedures [8]. One of the
reasons for this shift from human-dependent approaches to
ML is that humans cannot incorporate every possible scenario,
and there will always be an unanticipated condition that might
be devastating for the system. Since ML approaches operate
differently, it utilizes the data it gets and attempts to learn
the patterns between occurrences [9]. Thus, ML approaches Index Terms—Network intrusion detection, Traffic classifica-
tion, Packet capture, Cyber attack datasets, Payload extraction I. INTRODUCTION Advancement in Information and Communication Technolo-
gies (ICT) brings exceptional convenience to our daily life. However, the world is becoming more dependent on these become dynamic and adaptive to various scenarios without
human intervention [10]. Lately, many ML approaches have
been proposed in the domain of NIDS; however, most of
these approaches utilize flow-based information. In flow-based
methods, network traffic is analyzed over a period to extract
flow-based behavior features [11]. This approach can be imple-
mented in a centralized server to monitor massive traffic. The
anomalies are detected utilizing the correlation between the
traffic behavior and the corresponding characteristics. These
approaches require subject matter experts to select useful fea-
tures from data to detect malicious network traffic. Moreover,
the extracted features require a pre-processing application,
often requiring mathematical techniques to prepare the data
for the ML model [12], [13]. Another significant issue with
flow-based approaches is that they might end up learning
which IP addresses send malicious traffic or which ports are
frequently attacked. Flow-based approaches basically monitor
threats at the lower level of the TCP/IP protocol stack, thereby
diminishing the chance of detecting higher-level threats [14]. For such approaches, the methods used to extract and represent
the information in a packet are crucial and can affect the output
of ML models. on their own set of rules. Therefore, addressing the issue of
standardization, we developed a tool (Payload-Byte) capable
of extracting and labeling raw packet data from PCAP files
of already available datasets like UNSW and CICIDS. This
tool, which is based upon initial work by Bierbrauer et al. [16], is publicly available, and researchers can utilize the tool
to generate the data, which can be treated as a baseline for
future exploration in packet-based approaches. Our goal is
to provide standardization solution to the future researchers
so that reproducibility and comparability can be enhanced. This will also enable researchers to directly compare new
approaches with the previous ones. The main contribution for
this paper is as follows: • We developed a tool (Payload-Byte) for extracting and
labeling raw packet data of NIDS datasets. The complete
cycle of processing and labeling is explicitly stated in
this paper for ease of usage. This tool addresses the major
issue of comparability and reproducibility in packet-based
NIDS. • Transformation of payload data into byte-wise data utiliz-
ing a generalized feature vector has been presented. I. INTRODUCTION This
feature vector is independent of any protocol structure. On the other hand, packet-based approaches can unveil
malicious network flow by inspecting the packet payload,
which refers to the network packet’s user data. The packet-
based approach tries to learn characteristics of normal as
well as possible attack instances that have potential abnormal
characteristics in the packet payload. The anomalies in attack
instances might appear as a number of specific strings. For
example, an SQL injection attack injects anomalous codes
such as “ or 1 = 1 - - ” into SQL queries to make
them always true [7]. Moreover, many attacks such as Worms,
Ransomware, and Trojans are based on payload delivery,
and these types of attacks might be hidden from flow-based
approaches. In short, models that utilize flow-based approaches
rely upon the tool’s correctness that extracts information from
packets. Thus, an inadequacy in the dependent tool propa-
gates to a complete failure whereas rule-based approaches
are completely dependent on in-depth domain knowledge and
can not cater every possible scenario. Therefore, packet-based
approaches seems like a viable option for NIDS. • A processed packet-based dataset1 along with the tool is
made publically available2 3 to facilitate researchers. • A brief comparative analysis has been performed utiliz-
ing the extracted payload data and flow-based data for
network intrusion detection. The rest of this paper is organized as follows: Section
II covers the background knowledge related to the packet
structure. In Section III, an overview of related work and
gaps has been highlighted. Working and methodology has been
presented in Section IV. Furthermore, results are shown in
Section V. Finally, Section VI concludes the paper. II. BACKGROUND Libcap (PCAP) format is considered as the de facto standard
for network packet capture, which is widely utilized in packet
sniffers and analyzers [17]. This format is based on binary for-
mat, supporting nanosecond precision timestamps. Although it
may vary from implementation to implementation. A general
structure for PCAP format is shown in Fig.1. Network packet payload analysis might be an effective
solution for detecting network attacks since application attacks
are embedded in the payload rather than the header portion of
the Internet Protocol (IP) packet [15]. However, the ability to
detect payload embedded attacks remains a challenge due to
the absence of properly labeled packet data, a standardized
dataset baseline, and dynamic structuring of protocols. Unlike
flow-based NIDS datasets, which are easily available and can
be utilized as a baseline for developing and comparing any
new proposition, packet-based datasets do not have standard
labeling or dedicated dataset publicly available for everyone. This lack of standardization leads towards incomparable and
irreproducible research. In addition, there is a lot of ambiguity
in the process of labeling the raw packet capture (PCAP)
file, as every paper adopts its own processing method based Fig. 1. The general structure of PCAP format Fig. 1. The general structure of PCAP format 1Dataset DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.7258579
2Code DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.7259078
3GitHub: https://github.com/Yasir-ali-farrukh/Payload-Byte.git 1Dataset DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.7258579
2Code DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.7259078
3GitHub: https://github.com/Yasir-ali-farrukh/Payload-Byte.git For understanding the information extraction from a raw
packet file, it is essential to develop an understanding of
the format in which packets are stored. The PCAP format
contains a global header followed by multiple packets con-
taining packet header and packet data. The global header
identifies the generic PCAP format and byte order using the
“Magic Number”, validates the time information stored for
each capture, and permits length checks to accommodate the
maximum length of captured packets (in octets). However,
the individual packet header comprises packet information,
like its origin, destination IP addresses, protocol, total length,
and other similar features. The packet data is the actual data
which is often referred as payload, containing the raw data. In practice, packets have more than one header, and each
header is utilized by a different part of the networking pro-
cess. Simply, packet headers are attached by certain types of
networking protocols. B. Approaches Based on Modern Data Much work has been done in the domain of NIDS utiliz-
ing ML approaches. However, most proposed methods use
packet header information to extract features for training the
model, also known as flow-based approaches. The authors
in [18] present a comprehensive overview of the flow-based
techniques. However, in our work, we have only focused on
packet-based approaches. Since future research utilizes modern datasets containing
updated attacks and data instances, our goal is to provide
a standard baseline for researchers, just like flow-based ap-
proaches. Few works based on packet-based approaches have
utilized updated datasets such as UNSW-NB15 and CICIDS
datasets. A method based on a Recurrent Neural Network
(RNN) with the attention mechanism ATPAD is proposed in
[28]. This method employs the word embedding and RNN
to extract features used to capture the correlation between
detection results and the potential byte of the payload. This
approach makes use of the CIC-IDS2017 dataset and utilizes
binary classification. Moreover, no information is given regard-
ing the extraction and labeling of raw packet files. Similarly,
[7] also utilizes the CIC-IDS2017 dataset. In this approach,
the author employs the payload data to construct a block
sequence that contains two kinds of information that retain
short-term and long-term dependency relationships among the
malicious byte in payload data. In this approach, the author has
stated the number of instances utilized for model training and
testing. However, the amount of information given regarding
the payload extraction is minimal. In terms of the UNS-NB15
dataset, an approach utilizing the header and payload data has
been proposed in [8]. The authors have used a raw byte in
conjunction with a specified feature vector comprising only
TCP/UDP protocols. Since individual protocols have different
header byte numbers, authors have fixed a feature vector to
avoid ambiguity. Labeling information has been stated in this II. BACKGROUND Dividing packet into header and data is
high level representation of packets, whereas if we dive deeper
then there are several layers of additional information present
within the raw network data. Following the TCP/IP model,
each packet can be divided into four individual layers: Data
Link Layer, Network Layer, Transport Layer and Application
Layer. By referring to packet header, we are actually extracting
information from Network Layer and Transport Layer header
in our approach, which is covered in detail in Section IV. The
PCAP format packets are layered following the TCP/IP model. packet data using Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) and
Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) deep learning architectures
is proposed as HAST-IDS in [23]. This approach captures low-
level spatial and high-level temporal features through CNN
and LSTM. Utilizing the same concept, the authors in [24]
proposed AEIDS, based on an Autoencoder (AE), in which
a reconstruction error and modified z-score are employed for
classifying the incoming traffic instead of CNN and LSTM. Other than these approaches, some modified approaches also
curtail the total length of payload on some basis. PCNAD
[25], modified version PAYL, utilizes Content-based portion-
ing (CPP) to determine the length of payloads for different
profiles. Similarly, authors in [26] proposed a payload-based
attribution scheme named Compressed Bitmap Index and Traf-
fic Down-sampling (CBID). CBID extracts feature utilizing
the combination of bitmap index table and bloom filters
from down-sampled traffic. Although all these approaches
use payload data to detect anomalies, there is still a huge
reproducibility and comparison analysis gap. Most methods
in the literature utilize proprietary data or datasets that have
been outdated and are already labeled. However, the obsolete
dataset is not the issue here. The main problem is compara-
bility and reproducibility. Since every method has utilized a
different approach for extracting and labeling raw data without
explicitly mentioning the whole process and assumptions, this
has led to branching of the same tasks in several different
ways [27]. A. Network Intrusion Detection Datasets There are many publicly available datasets for researchers in
the domain of cybersecurity. However, most network intrusion
detection datasets only contain header information of network
packets. Several datasets comprising real network traffic either
do not have payload data or it has been removed due to privacy
concerns [6]. The unavailability of labeled packet data is a
significant issue in the packet-based NIDS. As a result, packet-
based approaches are evaluated on proprietary or self-labeled
data, resulting in reproducibility and comparability problems. Table I provides a comprehensive summary of the available
datasets based on nine features. The features comprise the year
of publication, accessibility of the dataset (whether the dataset
is publicly available or not), format of the dataset (either flow
or packet), size of the dataset, availability of labeled packet
data, kind of traffic (real or emulated), whether the data is
balanced or not, availability of modern network attacks, and
whether the data contain metadata or not. In short, every approach proposed in the literature utilizes
its own methodology for extracting and labeling raw packet
files for available data or its own proprietary dataset. In
addition, most of the approaches used for labeling do not
seem adequate and have a complication, as they use the 5-
tuple approach. There is no doubt that packet-based NIDS has
the potential to detect attacks in a network. Still, to gauge
the true applicability, researchers need a standardized baseline
that can utilized for the proposed scheme. In this way, the
problem of reproducibility and comparability will be resolved. In this work, we developed a tool after undergoing a complex
process of in-depth analysis of the datasets and methodology
to provide a baseline solution for future researchers. The
objective of the developed tool is to provide a generalized
packet-based dataset that can be utilized by anyone according
to their model. The detail of our adopted methodology is
presented in Section IV. Moreover, labeled raw packet data
has also been made available for researchers’ ease. However, many datasets contain raw packet data informa-
tion, and not every dataset is being utilized in the ongoing
research. The reason is that every dataset has limitations and
challenges due to the methods and environment used for
creating them. Moreover, many of these datasets are outdated
due to the technological advancement accompanied by new
and more complex software and network structures. A. Approaches Based on Outdated Data Prior research has been performed utilizing several methods
for detecting anomalies in a network payload. As per [15],
the packet-based processing was first performed by [19], in
which the authors utilized the Self Organizing Map (SOM)
to distinguish between normal and abnormal characteristics of
the network employing payload data. Building upon it, many
payload-based approaches are presented based on Natural
Language Processing (NLP) concept called n-gram. PAYL,
an anomaly detector based on payload data, is presented in
[20]. This approach utilizes the byte frequency distribution of
normal packets to form a centroid model. However, the author
use a knowledge-based structure to store the probability range
occurrences of the n-gram technique to extract sequences from
payload data. McPAD proposed in [21] uses a modified n-gram
method to extract the features from the payload. Incorporating
neural networks with ann-gram approach, the authors in [22]
proposed Packet2Vec approach. In this approach, the authors
utilize Word2Vec to develop a vector representation for indi-
vidual most frequent n-grams. Another approach based on raw Fig. 2. Workflow representation of developed tool (Payload-Byte). Raw PCAP files are passed with available metadata for labeling and transformation of raw
PCAP data into ML model readable form. Fig. 2. Workflow representation of developed tool (Payload-Byte). Raw PCAP files are passed with available metadata for labeling and transformation of raw
PCAP data into ML model readable form. detection datasets and their characteristics is also presented. Lastly, a brief overview of the selected approach for evaluating
packet-based approaches is also presented in this section. paper. However, the authors utilized only eight files of their
own choice for their model training and validation. Moreover,
there are more than 130 protocols in the UNSW-NB15 dataset
that the author neglects. Another approach covering additional
ICMP protocols has been presented in [29]. The authors
presented a unified packet representation using raw packet
information in this approach. The authors conducted their
evaluation over ten different datasets. However, the proposed
method utilizes every byte of the raw packet file, including
headers containing information about IP addresses and ports. Using every byte of the packet may simply train the model to
learn which IP addresses send malicious traffic or which port
are attacked frequently, which is not a robust approach. A. Network Intrusion Detection Datasets But still,
the most widely used and up-to-date datasets available are
CICIDS 2017 and UNSW-NB15 [30]. Therefore, we selected
these two datasets for the explanation of our tool. TABLE I TABLE I TABLE I
OVERVIEW OF THE WIDELY UTILIZED INTRUSION DETECTION DATASET IN THE LITERATURE Dataset
Year of Publication
Accessibility
Format
Size Count
Traffic
Modern Attacks
Balanced
Metadata
Labeled Packets
NSL-KDD [31]
1998
Public
Other
150k points
Emulated
No
No
No
-
DARPA [32], [33]
1998
Public
Packets, logs
4.9M points
Emulated
No
No
Yes
Yes
KYOTO 2006+ [34]
2006
Public
Other
93M points
Real
No
No
No
-
UNIBS [35]
2009
On Request
Flow
79k flows
Real
No
No
No
-
Botnet [36]
2010
Public
Packet
14GB packets
Emulated
No
No
Yes
Yes
ISCX 2012 [37]
2012
Public
Packet, Flow
2M flows
Emulated
No
No
Yes
No
CIC DoS [38]
2012
Public
Packet
4.6GB packets
Emulated
No
No
No
Yes
CTU-13 [39]
2013
Public
Packet, Flow
81M flows
Real
No
No
Yes
No
UNSW-NB15 [40]
2015
Public
Packet,Flow
2M points
Emulated
Yes
No
Yes
No
CIC-IDS2017 [41]
2017
Public
Packet, Flow
4.6GB packets
Emulated
Yes
No
Yes
No
CIC-IDS2018 [42]
2018
Public
Packet, Flow, logs
450GB logs
Emulated
Yes
No
Yes
No utilizing raw bytes for the header would lead to learning
complications for the model. Moreover, IP addresses in the
network layer and port fields in the transport layer can cause
the ML model to form an unreliable bias towards these bytes. Since these features are commonly associated with preferences
and specific services, they can create a communication pattern. But they can change anytime; therefore, these features are
unreliable for training a model. Unlike [12], in which the
authors limited their information extraction to the transport
layer and only involved two protocols, TCP and UDP, the
developed parser can extract information from the application
layer too. A pictorial representation of extracted feature and
feature vector utilized in training the model is presented in
Fig. 3. As shown in Fig. 3, IP addresses and ports are only
extracted for labeling the raw PCAP file data with reference
to available metadata. Since the length of the payload changes
with each packet, the maximum length that a packet can attain
is considered to avoid any overflowing or truncation of the
payload byte. As per the de facto packet size limit of 1500
bytes [44], [45], we set a 1500 bytes range for the payload
to incorporate every byte. B. Workflow Overview A detailed overview of the adopted procedure for extracting
and labeling raw packet data is provided in this Section. Since
our goal is to provide ease and a frame of reference to future
researchers, we only considered the modern and preferred
network intrusion detection dataset to explain our tool. In
addition, a concise summary of available network intrusion The developed tool, Payload-Byte, consists of three main
components: python-based parser, labeling module, and pay-
load transformation module. Python-based parser and payload
transformation module are generalized components, and their
methodology and approach are similar for every dataset. How-
ever, the labeling module is dataset specific, and its approach Fig. 3. Feature Vector representation of extracted data and data utilized for training the ML model. T-delta in employed feature vector is the time difference
between packets. Fig. 3. Feature Vector representation of extracted data and data utilized for training the ML model. T-delta in employed feature vector is the time difference
between packets. TABLE I Protocol feature was
not included as there are more than 130 different protocols. However, the obtained results were not satisfactory. Therefore,
different protocols having exact naming to the ones present in
the CSV file were incorporated into the python based parser. Since these protocols are from different layers, python based
parser is programmed to extract the application layer protocols. The top 45 protocols concerning attacks label counts are hard
coded in the program, and the rest of the protocols are mapped
under others. As the number of data instances after the top
20 protocols is insignificant, they are mapped under other
category. Similar mapping is performed for the CSV file too. In
addition to protocol, dur feature from CSV and t-delta feature
from pcap files is also utilized for mapping. Subsequently, the
results obtained are not to par. Manual data exploration was
performed and it was deduced that the dur feature also has
ambiguity. Therefore, t-delta feature is added to starting time
of the PCAP file to attain the ending time. Both of the Unix
time stamps are rounded-off to transform them into integers. Here type casting is not performed directly, as type casting
would truncate the floating points, which is not the case in
the CSV file. While exploring data, it is also inferred that the
Time to Live (TTL) feature of the pcap file maps to the source
TTL feature of CSV. Therefore, eight different features are
utilized for comparing and labeling pcap files. These features
are: Source IP, Destination IP, Source Port, Destination Port,
starting time, ending time, protocol and time to live. The next step after extraction is labeling, which is performed
by comparing the extracted features from the PCAP file and
features from the ground truth table. However, the generalized
labeling approach is not possible for both datasets due to
dataset-specific complications explained in their respective
subheading. Inner merge (utilizing the divide and conquer
algorithm) is adopted for comparing and labeling the PCAP
file with CSV while preserving the order of PCAP files. Since
PCAP data has packets in the range of microseconds, the
number of labeled PCAP data is higher than the data instance
in the CSV file which is shown in Section V. Further, to
facilitate the availability of data publicly and ease the data
usage process, data reduction is carried out. TABLE I Our goal is to extract the data in
such a way that it is complete and researchers can reduce this
range as per their need. Furthermore, the payload was divided
with respect to bytes, transforming into 1500 features. This
transformation is necessary for the training of the ML model. The utilization of NLP techniques for payload data is not
adopted; instead, the payload is transformed from hex value to
integer having a range of 0-255. Zero padding was employed
where the number of payload bytes are less than 1500 to
maintain the standard structure of the feature vector. Further differs from dataset to dataset, which is explained later. An
overview of the workflow is illustrated in Fig. 2. Raw PCAP
files and metadata are fed into Payload-Byte as input, where
processed and labeled payload data is received at the output. Payload-Byte can also obtain parsed PCAP files in the form of
CSV and labeled PCAP file without transformation. Provision
of these files enables researchers to employ their own inferring
for the extracted payload data while still having that standard
baseline. Several tools are available for analyzing and extracting in-
formation from packet capture files, such as Wireshark, Chaos
Reader, Tcpflow, Network miner, and many others. However,
most of these tools are Graphical User Interface (GUI) based
and require a lot of computation and processing power, which
is unsuitable for any tactical environment. A programming-
based parser is preferred for such an environment, which
can be operated on any resource-constraint device. Keeping
this need in view, we developed our parser based on the
Scapy python module [43]. Since the first step in labeling any
packet capture files is extracting information, we developed a
generalized PCAP file parser that can be utilized for parsing
PCAP format files. There are many approaches for extracting information, as
mentioned in Section III. Since our focus is on a payload-
based intrusion detection system, we laid out our feature vector
for packet-based approaches in such a way that raw bytes are
captured from packet data, and features are extracted from the
packet header. We have not utilized the raw bytes of header
due to its dynamic structure. As there are many protocols,
each protocol’s header size and order are distinct. Therefore, detail on parsing concerning individual datasets is provided in
their subsequent heading. Destination Port, and Starting time. TABLE I All the data
instances whose packet data has no payload are removed. Moreover, normal data instances are under-sampled to mitigate
the unbalanced issue of the dataset. The processed payload
data for both datasets are made available along with the source
code of the developed tool so that researchers can cross-check
the procedure or utilize it to generate the complete data without
data reduction. The further detail of labeling and parsing for
the individual dataset is explained below. 1) UNSW-NB15: The UNSW-NB15 intrusion detection
dataset encompasses nine modern attacks and network traffic
emulated in a small environment. The network traffic is
captured for more than 31 hours and is spread out in 79
different PCAP files, having more than 99GB of data. The
dataset comprises raw network traffic in the PCAP file format
and labeled flow-based data with additional attributes. We
have utilized the PCAP and CSV files having labeled data
instances for our tool. Moreover, an in-depth dataset analysis
was performed by deploying various approaches for accurate
and effective comparison and labeling. However, several am-
biguities were found in the dataset, which is discussed next. Since ICMP protocol has corrupted destination port and
source port, it was labeled without including these two fea-
tures. Similarly, ARP protocols also do not have a destination
or source port. Moreover, there are some protocols whose IP
addresses are not available in PCAP file format; therefore,
they were not labeled automatically. After labeling, duplicate
data instances are removed, and benign data is under-sampled
to 1.5 times of second highest attack instances. After that,
data is transformed into 1504 features, converting payload hex
string into 1500 byte-wise data represented in integers. The
remaining 4 features are from packet header as shown in Fig. 3. First of all, CSV data requires a lot of prepossessing. There
are many missing and null values in the dataset. Furthermore,
there is inconsistency in the labeling of data instances. Similar
attack classes are labeled differently. Around 480,630 data
instances are duplicated, and more than 130 protocols are
present in the dataset. The protocols are from different layers:
the transport layer and the application layer. Secondly, some
corrupted data are present in the dataset, such as the source
and destination ports of ICMP protocols are in hex values. Thirdly, the time stamping in the UNSW-NB15 dataset is in
Unix epoch format and has a starting and ending time for
the packets. TABLE II
MODEL ARCHITECTURE FOR THE CNN-LSTM AND DNN TABLE II
MODEL ARCHITECTURE FOR THE CNN-LSTM AND DNN Parameter
Description
Activation Function
Softmax
Loss Function
Categorical cross entropy
Optimizer
Adam & lr=default
Epochs
30
DNN
CNN-LSTM
Number of Layers
3
5
Layer 1
Fully Connected (None,1024)
Conv1D (None, 1504, 64)
Layer 2
Fully Connected (None,512)
Maxpooling1D (None, 752, 64)
Layer 3
Fully Connected (None,10)
BatchNormalization (None, 752, 64)
Layer 4
-
LSTM (None, 64)
Layer 5
-
Fully Connected (None,10) parameter tuning has been performed for the approaches,
and default parameters are used. The goal here is not to
achieve the best results but to provide a brief comparison. Moreover, the results are not compared with recent available
payload-based approaches as they have not explicitly stated
their data extraction and assumptions approach. Therefore, it is
not a feasible option. Additionally, available approaches have
only utilized binary class classification and presented it as an
anomaly detector. However, we have performed a multi-class
classification and results are provided in the results Section. The approaches that are adopted are: Random Forest, Lo-
gistic Regression, K-Nearest Neighbour, AdaboostClassifier,
Multilayer Perceptron, Deep Neural Network (DNN) and a
simple combination of Convolutional Neural Network (CNN)
and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM). The architecture
utilized for DNN and CNN-LSTM is shown in Table II. Similar architecture is utilized for the CSV and labeled PCAP
files. However, input of the model is different for CSV and
PCAP files. Keeping these issues in mind, we dropped the time stamp
feature as our tool’s comparison base for CIC-IDS2017. We
utilized the Source IP, Destination IP, Source Port, Desti-
nation Port, and Protocol feature for matching the packets
with labeled CSV data. After data instances are matched,
we utilized the time duration of each attack as specified in
metadata to cross-validate the data instances. Here we used
the time-stamp of the CSV file rather than the PCAP file
since metadata is based on CSV file time-stamps. For the
given time of attacks as per metadata, we removed benign
instances from them to eliminate complications. However, the
CSV file also contains benign data instances in the time frame
of attacks as specified by metadata. After cross-validation of
labeled PCAP data, duplicated values are removed and benign
data is under-sampled to 1.5 times of second highest attack
instances. After that, data was transformed into 1504 features,
converting payload hex string into byte-wise data represented
in integers. Fig. 4. V. RESULTS A comprehensive overview in the form of quantitative
data is presented in this Section, along with the comparative
analysis of results obtained by packet and flow-based data. For the implementation of our developed tool, CSV files of
both datasets are pre-processed before passing them into the
Payload-Byte, whereas PCAP files are directly fed into it. The
output of the Payload-Byte is a transformed and labeled pcap
file, having 1504 features as shown in Fig. 3. However, initial
stage files can also be extracted from the tool, such as parsed TABLE I But the epoch time is rounded up to integers,
losing its microseconds which could be useful for accurately
labeling the packets. Also, the dataset has a feature duration
which was used to generate the ending time for packets, but
for some data instances, this feature does not add up correctly. Fourthly, several protocols, such as udt and any do not exist. 2) CIC-IDS2017: The CIC-IDS2017 intrusion detection
dataset is specifically developed to represent more modern net-
work flows, and attacks than the preceding datasets mentioned
in Table I [41]. The dataset consists of 48.8GB of network
traffic captured in five separate files over five days. The dataset
is released in two different formats: raw network traffic in the
PCAP file format and extracted flow-based data having a set of
different features in CSV format. The authors have additionally
provided metadata about IP addresses and attack duration. We
utilized the PCAP and CSV files having labeled data instances
for our tool. However, some ambiguity in the CSV data files
and PCAP files led to labeling based on flow-ID (Source IP,
Destination IP, Source Port, Destination Port, and Protocol). Some of the prominent ambiguities are highlighted below. First of all, CSV data requires a lot of prepossessing, there
are several missing values in the dataset, and four columns
are duplicated. Secondly, only three protocols are available in TABLE II
MODEL ARCHITECTURE FOR THE CNN-LSTM AND DNN
Parameter
Description
Activation Function
Softmax
Loss Function
Categorical cross entropy
Optimizer
Adam & lr=default
Epochs
30
DNN
CNN-LSTM
Number of Layers
3
5
Layer 1
Fully Connected (None,1024)
Conv1D (None, 1504, 64)
Layer 2
Fully Connected (None,512)
Maxpooling1D (None, 752, 64)
Layer 3
Fully Connected (None,10)
BatchNormalization (None, 752, 64)
Layer 4
-
LSTM (None, 64)
Layer 5
-
Fully Connected (None,10) the CSV file: TCP, UDP, and others. Whereas, in PCAP files,
we found that there are Address Resolution Protocol (ARP),
Link Layer Discovery Protocol (LLDP), and Cisco Discovery
Protocol (CDP) which are not part of IPv4 or IPv6. Moreover,
the PCAP file also contains Internet Control Message Proto-
col (ICMP), Internet Group Management Protocol (IGMP),
and Stream Control Transmission Protocol (SCTP) packets. These protocols are neglected as they are not included in the
CSV file. Thirdly, time-stamping in the CSV file is in the
general format of “dd/MM/YYYY HH:mm:ss” rather than
Unix epoch time stamping as in the UNSW-NB15 dataset. TABLE II
MODEL ARCHITECTURE FOR THE CNN-LSTM AND DNN An overview of the data processing and achieved outcome of the
Payload-Byte. Both of the datasets are plotted side by side for better inferring. Fig. 4. An overview of the data processing and achieved outcome of the
Payload-Byte. Both of the datasets are plotted side by side for better inferring. The adopted approach for both datasets is deduced after
extensive exploration of the dataset and methods. Therefore,
the extracted data can be utilized as a standard baseline for
future and current work. The finding of the processed data is
presented in the next Section. TABLE I However, 529,450 data instances (around 19%) in the CSV file
are missing seconds in time format. This leads to inaccurate
time calculation for comparison and labeling of the PCAP
file. Moreover, the time format in the CSV file follows the
12-hour clock format, but it is found that every data instance
is in AM, which is not the case with the PCAP file. Just
for experimentation, we labeled the data with the inclusion of
time-stamping, and found that only 80 data instances were
matched and labeled for one PCAP file. That is why we
have not utilized time stamping in our labeling approach
for CIC-IDS2017. Furthermore, one important thing observed
while labeling is that the time stamping in PCAP files is in
UTC±0:00. In contrast, the CSV files are in Atlantic Daylight
Time (ADT) which is equivalent to UTC−03:00. Therefore,
time stamping in CSV files are converted accordingly for
proper execution. A. Data Processing Available CSV files for both datasets are distributed among
several files. Therefore, they are combined into a single file
for an individual dataset before any processing. Data prepos-
sessing is also performed, cleaning and removing erroneous
data instances. The crux of the whole processing is illustrated
in Fig. 4 where data in CSV file represents the data instances
in the available CSV file before prepossessing it. The total
number of available packets in all PCAP files is shown as
data in the PCAP file. Moreover, labeled data represents data
instances obtained after labeling and removing non-payload
data instances. TABLE IV
SUMMARY OF CIC-IDS2017 PCAP FILES
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Data Instances in CSV
306794
335,415
590,692
285,825
675,965
Data Instances in PCAP
11,626,492
11,469,736
13,705,555
9,240,723
9,915,680
Unprocessed Labeled PCAP
17,096,760
20,692,983
48,931,426
15,727,986
19,740,075
Processed Labeled PCAP
5,633,567
3,516,569
16,436,931
4,071,767
5,848,193 TABLE IV
SUMMARY OF CIC-IDS2017 PCAP FILES Data instances obtained after labeling involve several du-
plicated values and instances where packets have no payload. Since the number of labeled packets is extensively high, they
are processed by removing duplicates and instances having
no payload. Afterward, the data is under-sampled to reduce
its size by decreasing normal instances. The data obtained
after labeling has a high number of normal instances, since
normal instances in CSV files are also in significant quantity. Consequently, attack instances are not under-sampled to avoid
any information loss. The total number of data instances
for each attack class in CSV file and labeled PCAP file is
illustrated in Fig. 5. In the figure, data labels on bar graph
show the number of data instances in labeled PCAP files. The number of data instances shown in Fig. 5 is of the
finalized file, processed and under-sampled. The final version
of both the datasets is publicly available and can be utilized
by future research work as a standard baseline. Furthermore,
the complete data can also be generated by using the Payload-
Byte. It can be deduced by looking at the statistical data provided
in Fig. 4 that labeled data is dependent on the number of
data instances present in the CSV file rather than the PCAP
file. Moreover, the data instance in the PCAP file of UNSW
is exceptionally high due to the number of available PCAP
files. There are 79 PCAP files for the USNW-NB15 dataset,
whereas only 5 PCAP files in CIC-IDS2017. A. Data Processing Another reason
for more labeled data instances in the CIC-IDS2017 dataset is
that we only utilize five features for comparing and labeling,
whereas eight features are utilized in UNSW-NB15. TABLE III
SUMMARY OF UNSW-NB15 PCAP FILES
22-01-2015
17-02-2015
Data Instances in CSV
1,082,221
1,036,218
Data Instances in PCAP
93,384,964
92,559,915
Unprocessed Labeled PCAP
11,084,503
9,745,079
Processed Labeled PCAP
6,691,105 A detail summary of data processing based on individual
PCAP files for respective dataset is presented in Table III and
Table IV. Since there are 79 PCAP files in the UNSW-NB15
dataset, collective results are shown based on a particular day. On the other hand, CIC-IDS2017 only contain 5 PCAP files C. Incorporated Models We performed a comparative analysis using several ML
approaches between packet-based and extracted flow-based
data. The objective of this comparative analysis is to provide a
comparison between both types of data. Therefore, no hyper- Fig. 5. A comparison of data instances for individual attack classes in Labeled PCAP and Processed CSV file. Numbers on the bar graph represents the data
instances in labeled PCAP file. Normal instances are under-sampled for ease of data representation and usage. Fig. 5. A comparison of data instances for individual attack classes in Labeled PCAP and Processed CSV file. Numbers on the bar graph represents the data
instances in labeled PCAP file. Normal instances are under-sampled for ease of data representation and usage. Fig. 5. A comparison of data instances for individual attack classes in Labeled PCAP and Processed CSV file. Numbers
instances in labeled PCAP file. Normal instances are under-sampled for ease of data representation and usage. for individual attack classes in Labeled PCAP and Processed CSV file. Numbers on the bar graph represents the data
instances are under-sampled for ease of data representation and usage. PCAP files and labeled PCAP files having hex valued payload. An overview of the processed data is presented in the next
heading. PCAP files and labeled PCAP files having hex valued payload. An overview of the processed data is presented in the next
heading. spanning over 5 days; therefore, they are shown individually. Data Instances in CSV in Table III and Table IV represents
number of data points that CSV file contain in the time span of
that individual PCAP file. Unprocessed Labeled PCAP depicts
the number of packet instances labeled and Processed Labeled
PCAP shows the number of remaining packets after processing
and removal of non-payload data from Unprocessed Labeled
PCAP. B. Comparative Analysis Labeled PCAP files and processed CSV files of the UNSW-
NB15 dataset are utilized to compare both approaches briefly. The processing of CSV files include removal of features Fig. 6. A comparison of macro averaged F1-score for several ML model,
utilizing packet(PCAP Data) and flow(CSV Data) based data. All models
utilized have default parameters and no hyper-parameter tuning is performed. explicitly stating the whole process and notion, which leads to
branching the same tasks in many different ways. Addressing
the issue, we developed an open-source tool (Payload-Byte)
for parsing and labeling modern raw network traffic datasets. Payload-Byte standardizes dataset curation and provides a
standardized baseline for future researchers to reproduce and
compare other packet-based proposed approaches. Payload-
Byte eliminates the engineering and language errors that stem
from current datasets. Our tool can also parse high-level layers,
extracting information from application layers. Since UNSW-
NB15 datasets involve application layer protocols, Payload-
Byte can extract and label every available protocol, which is
being done for the first time. Moreover, any future datasets
can also be parsed utilizing Payload-Byte as we developed
a generalized parsing approach that is applicable for every
packet capture file. Fig. 6. A comparison of macro averaged F1-score for several ML model,
utilizing packet(PCAP Data) and flow(CSV Data) based data. All models
utilized have default parameters and no hyper-parameter tuning is performed. Furthermore, we stated the complete cycle of parsing and
labeling of CIC-IDS2017 and UNSW-NB15 datasets so that
it can be adopted for future research work. Payload-Byte
can be utilized to reproduce the entire data and transform it
accordingly. However, for ease of usage, we transform the
payload data into a feature vector comprising features from
the packet header and payload data, transformed into byte-
wise (1500) features. Lastly, a brief comparison of flow-based
and transformed packet-based data has been presented to show
the effectiveness of packet-based approaches. Source IP, Destination IP, Start time, and Last time, as
they can force the ML model to learn the relation between
these features and attacks. Moreover, there are many missing
values for the feature ct ftp cmd, therefore, it is also omitted
from the CSV file. Additionally, normal data instances of
CSV files are under-sampled just as PCAP files to maintain
coherence. Both approaches’ data is scaled utilizing Standard-
Scaler before being implemented into the ML models. The
resulting outcome of the comparison is shown in Fig 6. B. Comparative Analysis However, the overall performance of individual models can
be improved by tuning hyper-parameter, which will be carried
out in our future research work. The F1-score illustrated in
Fig 6 is macro averaged, as it represents performance better
in terms of multi-class classification. Through Fig 6 it can be
deduced that PCAP data is performing well for almost every
model compared to the available CSV data. A detailed result
comprising of macro averaged Precision, Recall and F1-score
for each model is presented in Table V. For our future work, we will carry out an in-depth compari-
son analysis of available proposed approaches on the extracted
data. Moreover, we will look into additional transformation
methods that can result in effective solution for packet-based
approaches. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work was supported in part by the U.S. Mili-
tary Academy (USMA) under Cooperative Agreement No. W911NF-22-2-0081, the U.S. Army Combat Capabilities De-
velopment Command (DEVCOM) C5ISR Center under Sup-
port Agreement No. USMA21056, and the National Security
Agency Laboratory for Advanced Cybersecurity Research
under Interagency Agreement No. USMA21035. The views
and conclusions expressed in this paper are those of the
authors and do not reflect the official policy or position of
the U.S. Military Academy, U.S. Army, U.S. Department
of Defense, or U.S. Government. The U.S. Government is
authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for Government
purposes notwithstanding any copyright notation herein. The
U.S. Government reserves a royalty-free, nonexclusive and
irrevocable right to reproduce, publish, or otherwise use this
data for Federal purposes, and to authorize others to do so in
accordance with 2 CFR 200.315(b). TABLE V
DETAIL RESULT FOR PERFORMANCE COMPARISON
Models
CSV Data
PCAP Data
Precision
Recall
F1-Score
Precision
Recall
F1-Score
Random Forest
62%
56%
58%
66%
67%
67%
Logistic Regression
48%
42%
42%
57%
55%
55%
K-Nearest Neighbour
54%
44%
47%
63%
62%
62%
AdaboostClassifier
37%
54%
40%
34%
34%
31%
Multilayer Perceptro
54%
51%
52%
72%
68%
67%
DNN
56%
51%
52%
74%
66%
66%
CNN LSTM
61%
56%
56%
75%
69%
69% TABLE V
DETAIL RESULT FOR PERFORMANCE COMPARISON VI. CONCLUSION Ma, and Y.-J. Wang, “Attentional payload anomaly
detector for web applications,” in Neural Information Processing,
L. Cheng, A. C. S. Leung, and S. Ozawa, Eds. Cham: Springer
International Publishing, 2018, pp. 588–599. [6] M. Hassan, M. E. Haque, M. E. Tozal, V. Raghavan, and R. Agrawal,
“Intrusion Detection Using Payload Embeddings,” IEEE Access, vol. 10,
pp. 4015–4030, 2022. [7] J. Liu, X. Song, Y. Zhou, X. Peng, Y. Zhang, P. Liu, D. Wu, and C. Zhu,
“Deep anomaly detection in packet payload,” Neurocomputing, vol. 485,
pp. 205–218, 5 2022. [29] J. Holland, P. Schmitt, N. Feamster, and P. Mittal, “New Directions in
Automated Traffic Analysis,” Proceedings of the ACM Conference on
Computer and Communications Security, pp. 3366–3383, 11 2021. [8] E. Alhajjar, P. Maxwell, and N. Bastian, “Adversarial machine learning
in Network Intrusion Detection Systems,” Expert Systems with Applica-
tions, vol. 186, p. 115782, 12 2021. [30] M. Ring, S. Wunderlich, D. Scheuring, D. Landes, and A. Hotho, “A
survey of network-based intrusion detection data sets,” Computers &
Security, vol. 86, pp. 147–167, 9 2019. [9] F. Dimitrios Tsokos Supervisor and P. Georgios, “Network Dataset Gen-
eration and Implementation of a Network Intrusion Detection System
using Neural Networks,” 2021. [31] M. Tavallaee, E. Bagheri, W. Lu, and A. A. Ghorbani, “A Detailed
Analysis of the KDD CUP 99 Data Set.” [Online]. Available:
http://nsl.cs.unb.ca/NSL-KDD/ [10] R. R. Mehdi, E. A. Mendiola, A. Sears, J. Ohayon, G. Choudhary,
R. Pettigrew, and R. Avazmohammadi, “Comparison of three machine
learning methods to estimate myocardial stiffness.” [32] R. P. Lippmann, D. J. Fried, I. Graf, J. W. Haines, K. R. Kendall,
D. McClung, D. Weber, S. E. Webster, D. Wyschogrod, R. K. Cun-
ningham, and M. A. Zissman, “Evaluating intrusion detection systems:
The 1998 DARPA off-line intrusion detection evaluation,” Proceedings
- DARPA Information Survivability Conference and Exposition, DISCEX
2000, vol. 2, pp. 12–26, 2000. [11] J. T. Zhou, H. Zhang, D. Jin, and X. Peng, “Dual Adversarial Transfer
for Sequence Labeling,” IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and
Machine Intelligence, vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 434–446, 2 2021. [12] M. De Lucia, P. E. Maxwell, N. D. Bastian, A. Swami, B. Jalaian, and
N. Leslie, “Machine learning raw network traffic detection,” p. 24, 4
2021. [33] R. Lippmann, J. W. Haines, D. J. Fried, J. Korba, and K. VI. CONCLUSION Das, “The
1999 DARPA off-line intrusion detection evaluation,” Computer Net-
works: The International Journal of Computer and Telecommunications
Networking, vol. 34, no. 4, pp. 579–595, 10 2000. [13] P. Maxwell, E. Alhajjar, and N. D. Bastian, “Intelligent feature engi-
neering for cybersecurity,” in 2019 IEEE International Conference on
Big Data (Big Data), 2019, pp. 5005–5011. [34] J. Song, H. Takakura, Y. Okabe, M. Eto, D. Inoue, and K. Nakao,
“Statistical Analysis of Honeypot Data and Building of Kyoto 2006+
Dataset for NIDS Evaluation.” [14] W. Lee, S. J. Stolfo, P. K. Chan, E. Eskin, W. Fan, M. Miller,
S. Hershkop, and J. Zhang, “Real time data mining-based intrusion
detection,” Proceedings - DARPA Information Survivability Conference
and Exposition II, DISCEX 2001, vol. 1, pp. 89–100, 2001. [35] F. Gringoli, L. Salgarelli, M. Dusi, N. Cascarano, F. Risso, and K. C. Claffy, “GT: Picking up the Truth from the Ground for Internet Traffic
*.” [15] A. F. Mercurio, “A Critical Analysis of Payload Anomaly-Based
Intrusion Detection Systems,” p. 363, 2010. [Online]. Available:
https://epublications.regis.edu/theses/363 [36] E. B. Beigi, H. H. Jazi, N. Stakhanova, and A. A. Ghorbani, “Towards
effective feature selection in machine learning-based botnet detection
approaches,” 2014 IEEE Conference on Communications and Network
Security, CNS 2014, pp. 247–255, 12 2014. [16] R. K. P. M. . N. D. B. David A Bierbrauer, Michael J De Lucia,
“Transfer learning for raw network traffic detection. expert systems with
applications,” unpublished. [37] A. Shiravi, H. Shiravi, M. Tavallaee, and A. A. Ghorbani, “Toward
developing a systematic approach to generate benchmark datasets for
intrusion detection,” Computers and Security, vol. 31, no. 3, pp. 357–
374, 5 2012. [17] L. F. Sikos, “Packet analysis for network forensics: A comprehensive
survey,” Forensic Science International: Digital Investigation, vol. 32,
3 2020. [38] H. H. Jazi, H. Gonzalez, N. Stakhanova, and A. A. Ghorbani, “Detecting
HTTP-based application layer DoS attacks on web servers in the
presence of sampling,” Computer Networks, vol. 121, pp. 25–36, 7 2017. [18] F. Pacheco, E. Exp´osito, M. Gineste, C. Baudoin, J. Aguilar, E. Exposito,
and C. Baudoin, “Towards the Deployment of Machine Learning
Solutions in Network Traffic Classification: A Systematic Survey,”
Communications Surveys and Tutorials, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 1988–2014,
2018. [Online]. Available: https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02423375 [39] S. Garc´ıa, M. Grill, J. Stiborek, and A. Zunino, “An empirical compar-
ison of botnet detection methods,” Computers and Security, vol. 45, pp. 100–123, 2014. [40] N. VI. CONCLUSION In this work, we highlighted the issue of comparability
and reproducibility for packet-based NIDS. Since payload-
based approaches can be an effective solution for detecting
different network attacks, several works have been proposed
in the literature. However, the data utilized for such work
is either proprietary or processed data based on undefined
procedures and assumptions. Moreover, there is no properly
labeled packet-based dataset available that can be utilized as a
standard baseline. Therefore, every new approach follows its
own method for extracting and labeling packet data without REFERENCES
[1] M. A. Khan,
M. R. Karim,
and
Y. Kim,
“A
Scalable
and
Hybrid Intrusion Detection System Based on the Convolutional-LSTM
Network,” Symmetry 2019, Vol. 11, Page 583, vol. 11, no. 4,
p. 583, 4 2019. [Online]. Available: https://www.mdpi.com/2073-
8994/11/4/583/htm https://www.mdpi.com/2073-8994/11/4/583 [2] S. Wali and I. Khan, “Explainable ai and random forest based reliable
intrusion detection system,” 2021. [24] B. A. Pratomo, P. Burnap, and G. Theodorakopoulos, “Unsupervised
Approach for Detecting Low Rate Attacks on Network Traffic with
Autoencoder,” 2018 International Conference on Cyber Security and
Protection of Digital Services, Cyber Security 2018, 12 2018. [3] H. Ibrahim, J. Ramos-Ruiz, J. Kim, W. H. Ko, T. Huang, P. Enjeti, P. R. Kumar, and L. Xie, “An active detection scheme for sensor spoofing in
grid-tied pv systems,” in 2021 IEEE Energy Conversion Congress and
Exposition (ECCE), 2021, pp. 1433–1439. [25] S. A. Thorat, A. K. Khandelwal, B. Bruhadeshwar, and K. Kishore,
“Payload content based network anomaly detection,” 1st International
Conference on the Applications of Digital Information and Web Tech-
nologies, ICADIWT 2008, pp. 127–132, 2008. [4] L. Yu, J. Dong, L. Chen, M. Li, B. Xu, Z. Li, L. Qiao, L. Liu,
B. Zhao, and C. Zhang, “PBCNN: Packet Bytes-based Convolutional
Neural Network for Network Intrusion Detection,” Computer Networks,
vol. 194, p. 108117, 7 2021. [26] S. M. Hosseini and A. H. Jahangir, “An Effective Payload Attribution
Scheme for Cybercriminal Detection Using Compressed Bitmap Index
Tables and Traffic Downsampling,” IEEE Transactions on Information
Forensics and Security, vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 850–860, 4 2018. [5] Y. A. Farrukh, Z. Ahmad, I. Khan, and R. M. Elavarasan, “A sequential
supervised machine learning approach for cyber attack detection in a
smart grid system,” in 2021 North American Power Symposium (NAPS),
2021, pp. 1–6. [27] J. Holland, P. Schmitt, P. Mittal, and N. Feamster, “Towards Repro-
ducible Network Traffic Analysis,” 3 2022. [28] Z.-Q. Qin, X.-K. VI. CONCLUSION Moustafa and J. Slay, “UNSW-NB15: A comprehensive data set for
network intrusion detection systems (UNSW-NB15 network data set),”
2015 Military Communications and Information Systems Conference,
MilCIS 2015 - Proceedings, 12 2015. [19] “A
neural
network
approach
wowards
intrusion
de-
tection
—
CiNii
Research.”
[Online]. Available:
https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1572543024790112512 [20] K. Wang and S. J. Stolfo, “Anomalous payload-based network intrusion
detection,” in Recent Advances in Intrusion Detection, E. Jonsson,
A. Valdes, and M. Almgren, Eds. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin
Heidelberg, 2004, pp. 203–222. [41] I. Sharafaldin, A. H. Lashkari, and A. A. Ghorbani, “Toward Generating
a New Intrusion Detection Dataset and Intrusion Traffic Characteriza-
tion,” 2018. [42] “IDS 2018 — Datasets — Research — Canadian Institute for Cybersecu-
rity — UNB.” [Online]. Available: https://www.unb.ca/cic/datasets/ids-
2018.html [21] R. Perdisci, D. Ariu, P. Fogla, G. Giacinto, and W. Lee, “McPAD: A
multiple classifier system for accurate payload-based anomaly detec-
tion,” Computer Networks, vol. 53, no. 6, pp. 864–881, 4 2009. [43] “Scapy.” [Online]. Available: https://scapy.net/ [22] E. L. Goodman, C. Zimmerman, and C. Hudson, “Packet2Vec: Utilizing
Word2Vec for Feature Extraction in Packet Data,” 4 2020. [Online]. Available: http://arxiv.org/abs/2004.14477 [44] N. M. Garcia, M. M. Freire, and P. P. Monteiro, “The ethernet frame
payload size and its effect on IPv4 and IPv6 traffic,” 2008 International
Conference on Information Networking, ICOIN, 2008. [23] W. Wang, Y. Sheng, J. Wang, X. Zeng, X. Ye, Y. Huang, and M. Zhu,
“HAST-IDS: Learning Hierarchical Spatial-Temporal Features Using
Deep Neural Networks to Improve Intrusion Detection,” IEEE Access,
vol. 6, pp. 1792–1806, 12 2017. [45] R. J. Anthony, “The Resource View,” Systems Programming, pp. 203–
276, 1 2016.
|
https://openalex.org/W2611123435
|
https://ojs.cvut.cz/ojs/index.php/ap/article/download/1015/847
|
English
| null |
Automatic Compensation of Workpiece Positioning Tolerances for Precise Laser
|
Acta Polytechnica
| 2,008
|
cc-by
| 5,010
|
Acta Polytechnica Vol. 48 No. 3/2008 Acta Polytechnica Vol. 48 No. 3/2008 Automatic Compensation of Workpiece
Positioning Tolerances for Precise Laser
Welding N. C. Stache, T. P. Nguyen Precise laser welding plays a fundamental role in the production of high-tech goods, particularly in precision engineering. In this working
field, precise adjustment and compensation of positioning tolerances of the parts to be welded with respect to the laser beam is of paramount
importance. This procedure mostly requires tedious and error-prone manual adjustment, which additionally results in a sharp increase in
production costs. We therefore developed a system which automates and thus accelerates this procedure significantly. To this end, the welding
machine is equipped with a camera to acquire high resolution images of the parts to be welded. In addition, a software framework is
developed which enables precise automatic position detection of these parts and adjusts the position of the welding contour correspondingly. As a result, the machine is rapidly prepared for welding, and it is much more flexible in adapting to unknown parts. This paper describes the entire concept of extending a conventional welding machine with means for image acquisition and position
estimation. In addition to this description, the algorithms, the results of an evaluation of position estimation, and a final welding result are
presented p
y p p
f
g
f
p
g
p
This paper describes the entire concept of extending a conventional welding machine with means for image acquisition and position
estimation. In addition to this description, the algorithms, the results of an evaluation of position estimation, and a final welding result are
presented. Keywords: Video-based position estimation, automatic laser adjustment, compensation of positioning tolerances, precise welding, robust
fitting, contour point detection. ments concerning accuracy and production costs. We there-
fore aim to simplify the production process by equipping an
existing assembly system with sensors and intelligence. To
avoid an excessive increase in costs, we try to make efficient
use of system-immanent components. More precisely – firstly,
we enable the machine to acquire high-resolution images of
the workpieces with a single camera, secondly we enable the
positions of the workpiece to be estimated automatically, and
finally we adapt the position of the laser to possible offsets be-
tween nominal and detected positions. 1 Introduction Despite significant advances in micro-technology lasting
recent decades, precise and cost-efficient welding still poses a
big challenge. Usually, tedious and error-prone manual in-
teraction is required to adjust currently available welding
machines to precisely join two parts with a laser beam. This
adjustment is additionally exacerbated if flexible parts or
parts with loosely fixed counter pieces (see Fig. 1) are to be
welded. In these cases each part has to be adjusted indi-
vidually or clamped precisely, which leads to an increase in
production costs. The paper is organized as follows: First, the hardware
setup for welding and image acquisition is described. Second,
the concept for position estimation and for transforming the
welding contours is introduced. Finally, an evaluation of posi-
tion estimation and a typical welding result is presented. The
paper concludes with a summary and conclusions. One of the major applicatios of laser welding is the pro-
duction of medical devices, e.g., welding the housing for
cardiac pacemakers or endoscopes. Other applications are in
environmental engineering, e.g., water filters that are capable
of filtering harmful microorganisms out of drinking water,
see Fig. 1. Fig. 1: Prototype of a clear water filter: (a) filter membrane, (b) fil-
ter body with deepening, (c) membrane loosely positioned
within the deepening. To prevent it from warping, the
membrane has to be welded exactly along its edge. © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ 5. Welding. First, as already mentioned, image tiles have to be ac-
quired and stitched to an overall image. Since the scanner
knows the positions of these tiles with sub-pixel accuracy, we
can omit time-consuming matching and position estimation
steps and directly stitch the tiles at the correct positions. How-
ever, to avoid artifacts at the image junctions due to different
brightnesses, single-band blending is used, which smoothly
blends one image into the adjacent image. Fig. 2: Scheme of a galvanometer-driven scanner [4] Fig. 4: Image tiles and stitched panorama of the clear water filter,
Fig. 1 In addition to laser positioning, this setup can be ben-
eficially used for high-resolution image acquisition with a
standard camera. To this end, we employ specially designed
beam splitter optics, which allows the optical path of the laser
through the scanner to be shared with that of the camera (see
Fig. 3). Thus, the camera field-of-view (FOV) can be moved
within the plane of the workpiece just like the laser. With this
system we acquire high resolution image tiles and corre-
sponding information about the FOV positions in order to
stitch the tiles to an overall image. In contrast to systems
which use static cameras, we can hence create an overall
picture with much greater resolution or size. High resolution Fig. 4: Image tiles and stitched panorama of the clear water filter,
Fig. 1 Fig. 3: Scanner-based welding and image acquisition system. The
beam splitter optics comprises a beam splitter mirror and
a dichroit. The dichroit is a wavelength dependent mirror,
which, in our case, reflects the Nd:YAG laser for welding
and lets the illumination rays for image acquisition pass
through. The second step is to define and extract the features to be
used for identifying the position of the workpiece. These
features have once to be defined by the user, since it is difficult
to automatically omit features which are not relevant for esti-
mating the subsequent position. The filter part in Fig. 1
provides a good example of this: The aim is to weld the
loosely positioned membrane along its rim to the body of the
filter. Therefore, it is essential to use only features of the mem-
brane, e.g. its edge, instead of features of the body of the filter,
which would hamper the correct detection of the membrane’s
position. 2 Hardware setup To perform laser welding with an assembly machine, one
of the most important problems concerns the positioning of
the focused laser beam on the object to be welded. The solu-
tions to this problem are highly diverse, ranging from moving
workpieces via translation stages to static workpieces with fi-
ber lasers moved by robots. We chose a constellation which is
close to the latter. The workpiece is immobile and the laser
adapts to the position of the workpiece. To achieve a high
dynamics of the assembly machine, a so-called scanner is em-
ployed instead of a robotic arm. This scanner consists of two
orthogonal turnable mirrors, which are capable of precisely
positioning the laser beam in the plane of the workpieces (see
Fig. 2). Corresponding to the reduced moving mass of the
mirrors in comparison to a robotic arm, the dynamics and
thus the throughput rates of the welding parts can be signifi-
cantly increased. Fig. 1: Prototype of a clear water filter: (a) filter membrane, (b) fil-
ter body with deepening, (c) membrane loosely positioned
within the deepening. To prevent it from warping, the
membrane has to be welded exactly along its edge. To provide these high-tech goods for emerging markets, a
production technology is needed which meets the require- 55 Acta Polytechnica Vol. 48 No. 3/2008 is required because the size of the workpieces is approxi-
mately 6 orders of magnitude higher than the sought accu-
racy of position detection. Since the diameter of the welding
spot is approximately 300 m, an offset of 50 m is in most
cases tolerable. Fig. 2: Scheme of a galvanometer-driven scanner [4] © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ 3 Structure of the software framework In order to implement the adaptation of the welding laser
to the position of the workpiece, several steps have to be car-
ried out, as follows: 1. Image acquisition and stitching. 2. Feature extraction. 3. Feature based position estimation and computation
of the offset to nominal position. 4. Transformation of the welding contour. 5. Welding. 4 Feature extraction The Sobel edge model utilizes the well-known filter kernel
from the Sobel operator [1]. Here, it is assumed that an edge
is defined as a sharp transition orthogonal to the edge and a
small transition in the direction of the edge. This model is
transferred to the Sobel filter kernel, which consists of Gaussi-
an smoothing combined with a derivation in the orthogonal
direction. To apply this model to contour point detection, we
first rotated the filter kernel so that the derivation is com-
puted in the direction of the profile and the smoothing is
computed orthogonally to the profile. Then, this rotated filter
is applied to each pixel of the profile and its neighborhood. This procedure yields an optimal response to edges orthogo-
nal to the profiles. A simplification of this procedure may
be to compute the dot product of the gradient and the unit
vector pointing in the direction of the profile. However, this
procedure would lack the directional smoothing of the ro-
tated Sobel kernel, and would therefore yield a lower degree
of robustness. The Sobel edge model is suitable for detecting
edges, when the step edge model cannot be applied because
the constraint of large adjacent and homogeneous areas is
violated. The feature extraction algorithm is required to achieve
high robustness, high accuracy and a high throughput rate. Since the user is required to explicitly define the features to be
selected for position estimation, for the reasons given above,
it is not too time-consuming to also select a region of interest
(ROI) that is big enough to cover position tolerances. Within
the ROI, the desired feature is extracted robustly and with
sub-pixel accuracy, as described in greater detail below. The
detection of only one feature per ROI may be seen as a restric-
tion, but it inherently avoids ambiguity of feature detection
and matching within one ROI. In addition, it has not shown
to be adverse in practice. After defining the ROI and selecting one of five possible
features – such as line, circle, arc of a circle, ellipse, corner –
the next step is robust and sub-pixel accurate extraction. Since the size of the overall image can exceed 10 million pix-
els, the ROI-size may still be about 1 megapixel and more. 5. Welding. A further aspect that motivates the proposed feature
based position estimation is related to the third step in the
item list. Here, the difficulty is to obtain nominal values for
the positions which are later used to determine the offsets,
and to transform the welding contour correspondingly. Since
these nominal values are usually available from CAD-data
(Computer Aided Design), it is meaningful to use a procedure
that is “compatible” with this data. As the appearance of
surfaces is still only coarsely modeled in present-day CAD-
-Programs, and it is often far from reality, only edges and their
geometric representations appear to be suitable for being Fig. 3: Scanner-based welding and image acquisition system. The
beam splitter optics comprises a beam splitter mirror and
a dichroit. The dichroit is a wavelength dependent mirror,
which, in our case, reflects the Nd:YAG laser for welding
and lets the illumination rays for image acquisition pass
through. Fig. 3: Scanner-based welding and image acquisition system. The
beam splitter optics comprises a beam splitter mirror and
a dichroit. The dichroit is a wavelength dependent mirror,
which, in our case, reflects the Nd:YAG laser for welding
and lets the illumination rays for image acquisition pass
through. 56 © Acta Polytechnica Vol. 48 No. 3/2008 The step edge approach is most suitable to robustly detect
the transition between two adjacent areas of slightly different
gray values, even in noisy images. matched with real images. Thus, the nominal values for lines,
circles, arcs of circles, corners and ellipses can be extracted
from CAD-data without excessive effort. 4 Feature extraction Well-known algorithms such as the Canny edge detector [2] in
combination with the Hough Transform [7] for line or circle
fitting are too costly, since they are not perfectly adapted to
the problem at hand and they evaluate the entire ROI. To ob-
tain the required throughput in detection, further speedup is
needed. To this end, we have developed an approach which
is time-efficient and robust. This approach consists of two
steps: estimating the positions of contour points, and fitting a
chosen model to the points determined in this way. This
approach can be used for robust estimations of the parame-
ters of the mentioned features, except for the edge, which is
determined using the SUSAN corner detector [12]. 4.1 Contour point estimation To estimate the contour points, a predetermined number
of line profiles is evaluated. These profiles are roughly po-
sitioned orthogonally and equally spaced to the sought
contour, when defining the ROI. Thus, the sought contour is
sampled by only considering the pixels of the line profiles
(and their neighborhoods), instead of evaluating the entire
ROI. To make a robust estimate of the contour points within
these profiles, we applied two different models. The algebraic model of a circle in the plane can be ex-
pressed as [5] a
c
T
T
p p
b p
0
(1) (1) with a 0, p ( , )
x y T and b ( ,
)
b b
T
1
2
, p b
,
2. The center
of the circle c and the radius r can be determined from these
parameters as 4.2 Model fitting Since the detected contour points may not be free from
outliers, it seems reasonable to use robust methods for fitting
the geometric models to the points. To this end, the RANSAC
algorithm (RANdom SAmple Consensus) [3, 11] is used. This
algorithm is able to eliminate outliers and hence use the
points that are assumed to be undisturbed for fitting. To
this end, we need mathematical definitions of the geometric
primitives to be fitted and a measure for assessing the dis-
tance of each contour point to the given model. A description
of all four models (circle, circle arc, ellipse, line) would go
beyond the scope of this paper. We therefore elaborate more
on the example of circle detection, since the basic steps are
similar to the algorithms for the other models. © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ 4.1.1 Step edge model This model consists of a set of step edges with pre-
defined edge positions, which are correlated with the line
profiles [10]. The resulting position of the contour point is
determined by evaluating which step edge model corre-
sponds to the maximal correlation value. Thus, the position
of the step edge in this model defines the position of the
sought contour point. Since the models always cover entire
profiles and, consequently, all pixels are considered, a high
degree of robustness is achieved – outliers due to noise are
canceled out. In addition, the step edge approach is well
tailored to the problem, since it finds the one sought contour
point for each profile. c
b
a
b
a
T
1
2
2
2
,
,
(2)
r
b
b
a
c
a
1
2
2
2
2
4
. (3) (2) (3) The insertion of n 3 contour points pi
i
i
T
x y
(
, ) ( i
n
1 )
in (1) results in an overdetermined linear system of equations,
which is The insertion of n 3 contour points pi
i
i
T
x y
(
, ) ( i
n
1 )
in (1) results in an overdetermined linear system of equations,
which is Bu
0
(4) (4) 57 © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ Acta Polytechnica Vol. 48 No. 3/2008 with B
x
y
x
y
x
y
x
y
n
n
n
n
1
2
1
2
1
1
2
2
1
1
, u
a
b
b
c
1
2
. In order to apply our direct algebraic approach, which
uses the RANSAC algorithm and the similarity transform [9],
the different features have first to be brought to a uniform
level. To this end, an examination of the descriptions of the
feature is replaced by considering (center) points and angles. Thus, e.g. an ellipse is represented by its centroid and an
angle, a circle is represented by its center, and so on. B is the matrix of the contour points and u is the vector of the
sought circle parameters. Thus, the problem to be minimized
can be formulated as In the next step, the RANSAC algorithm is used to elimi-
nate outliers. 4.1.1 Step edge model In the case of circle fitting, the procedure is
s follows [3]: where ui
xi
yi
T
u
u
(
,
) , and vi
xi
yi
T
v
v
(
,
) , i
m
1
, build a set
of m point pairs, which are composed of the detected points
such as the centers of the circles and their corresponding
nominal values. The parameters a, b, c, d form the matrix of
the similarity transform and encode the sought rotation and a
scaling. The rotation angle can be computed by determin-
ing the pseudoinverse of A, e.g., via singular value decompo-
sition and the computation of where ui
xi
yi
T
u
u
(
,
) , and vi
xi
yi
T
v
v
(
,
) , i
m
1
, build a set 1. Select a set of at least three determined contour
points randomly, 2. Construct a circle through these (e.g. with least
squares circle fitting), 3. Count the number of points which lie within a pre-
determined error tolerance to the circle (so-called
inliers), arctan ( , )
2 b a . (8) (8) 4. If the number of inliers is greater than some pre-
defined threshold, do least squares circle fitting (as
explained above) for all inliers, else repeat the pro-
cess, i.e. start again at 1., until a maximum number of
trials is reached. Between this value and the angles, possibly determined
directly by the features (e.g. the angles of lines and ellipses),
the weighted average is computed. After the computation of
this result, the points of the feature are rotated inversely and
the translation is determined as the mean of the distances
between the point pairs. With this procedure, a circle can be correctly fitted even in
challenging images. Hence, the sought rotation and the offset are determined
robustly and without iterative optimization steps. Finally, the
welding contour has to be transformed correspondingly. This
is straightforwardly implemented as a multiplication of the
welding coordinates with an adapted transformation matrix. The use of line-shaped profiles for contour point de-
tection instead of entire images or ROIs permits a speed up,
which is required for executing one detection and welding
cycle per second (detection with a standard PC, 2.6 GHz,
Dual-Core, C implementation). 6 Experimental results To evaluate the accuracy of the position estimation, im-
ages of real workpieces were acquired using a galvanometer
scanner and stitched (see Fig. 5). These images were syntheti-
cally rotated and shifted with sub-pixel accuracy. Hence, a
reliable ground truth is created. Within these images, the pro- 4.1.1 Step edge model In addition, sub-pixel ac-
curacy is accomplished by means of least squares fitting to the
RANSAC-Inliers. 4.1.1 Step edge model Then, at first, a rotation is computed by only
considering the mentioned points and their corresponding
nominal values (angles are considered later). Hence, we use
the similarity transform in order to obtain a linear set of
equations and thus avoid sine and cosine terms. The structure
of the linear equation set is Q
B
B
B
B B
T
T
T
( )
(
)
min
u
u
u
u
u
u
2
2
,
(5) (5) with the constraint of u 2
1
to avoid obtaining the trivial so-
lution. This can be reformulated as Q
B B
i
i
T
T
i
i
(
)
min
v
v
v
,
(6) (6) ea equat o
set s
u
u
u
u
v
v
v
v
x
y
xm
ym
x
y
y
x
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
v
v
v
v
a
b
c
d
xm
ym
ym
xm
1
0
0
1
,
(7) where the eigenvector vopt of BTB, which belongs to the
smallest eigenvalue 4, equals the sought parameter vector u. Thus, the circle parameters c and r can be determined. q
u
u
u
u
v
v
v
v
x
y
xm
ym
x
y
y
x
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
v
v
v
v
a
b
c
d
xm
ym
ym
xm
1
0
0
1
,
(7) (7) As already mentioned, the detected contour points may be
subject to gross outliers, which can corrupt the fitting result
and thus deteriorate the accuracy of the position estimation. Therefore, we utilize the RANSAC algorithm for robust out-
lier elimination. In the case of circle fitting, the procedure is
as follows [3]: y
p
Therefore, we utilize the RANSAC algorithm for robust out-
ier elimination. 5 Offset computation and correction The lines in the boxes mark the medians, the boxes encompass the two inner quartiles of the quantity of re-
sults, while the “whiskers” and crosses mark the two remaining outer quartiles. posed algorithms for feature extraction and offset estimation
are applied. The results obtained with the images in Fig. 5 are
presented in the boxplot [8] in Fig. 6. accuracy. The image of the ellipse is affected by strong arti-
facts which hamper higher accuracy. In addition, the ellipse
has the highest number of degrees of freedom. Since the
number of contour points which are used for fitting is con-
stant, the relative number (related to the degrees of freedom)
for the ellipse is lower. This causes a decay in accuracy. Despite the challenging real world images, the range of
deviations for circle detection is smaller than 2 pixels, which is
in our case less than 13 m. In case of the arc of a circle, the
same image is used but only a quarter of a circle is employed
for position detection. This is more time efficient, since only a
quarter of the overall image has to be acquired, but the accu-
racy is significantly decreased. In position estimation with two
orthogonally intersecting lines, the worst case scenario is a de-
viation of 9 pixels, which corresponds to 60 m. However, the
image used for line detection depicts an SMD-chip (Surface
Mounted Device), where the lines are fitted to the rows of
pins. The rows are fragmented due to the gaps between the
pins. This complicates the task of fitting a line with such high The results of the algorithm for offset computation are
used for rotating and shifting the welding contour corre-
spondingly. The final aim is to execute the welding process at
the correct position. In order to obtain preliminary evidence,
three of the filter membranes in Fig. 1 have been welded at
position variations of about 1 mm. The final position devia-
tion of the overall system did not exceed 30 m. An example
of successive welding obtained with our system is presented in
Fig. 7. 5 Offset computation and correction In the case of extracting a single feature, e.g. a circle, it is
easy to determine an offset between the detected value and a
given nominal value. Since the system is restricted to the cor-
rection of translation and rotation, one circle only contributes
to translation estimation. Thus, correction of the welding
contour is a simple shift in its coordinates. Fig. 5: Stitched images used for evaluating the accuracy in posi-
tion estimation In the case of two or more detected circles with different
center positions, a rotation may be additionally determined. To avoid approaches such as chamfer matching [6], which re-
quire costly iterative optimization for position estimation, we
used a direct algebraic and model-oriented way. In contrast to
(local) optimization approaches, we thus avoid missing the
global optimum, which represents the sought position. Fig. 5: Stitched images used for evaluating the accuracy in posi-
tion estimation © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ 58 © Czech Technical University Publishing House © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ Acta Polytechnica Vol. 48 No. 3/2008 Fig. 6: Boxplot, illustrating the deviations of 20 measurements from ground truth (“Circle x” e.g. denotes the deviations in the x-direc-
tion, when a circle is used for position estimation. “Lines rot.” denotes the deviation of the determined rotation from ground
truth, in degrees). The lines in the boxes mark the medians, the boxes encompass the two inner quartiles of the quantity of re-
sults, while the “whiskers” and crosses mark the two remaining outer quartiles. Fig. 6: Boxplot, illustrating the deviations of 20 measurements from ground truth (“Circle x” e.g. denotes the deviations in the x-direc-
tion, when a circle is used for position estimation. “Lines rot.” denotes the deviation of the determined rotation from ground
truth, in degrees). The lines in the boxes mark the medians, the boxes encompass the two inner quartiles of the quantity of re-
sults, while the “whiskers” and crosses mark the two remaining outer quartiles. Fig. 6: Boxplot, illustrating the deviations of 20 measurements from ground truth (“Circle x” e.g. denotes the deviations in the x-direc-
tion, when a circle is used for position estimation. “Lines rot.” denotes the deviation of the determined rotation from ground
truth, in degrees). © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ 7 Summary, conclusions © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/
Fig. 7: Welding result: Filter part and its weld seam This paper addresses the problem of tedious and er-
ror-prone adjustment of present-day laser welding machines. Especially for high-tech goods in medical or environmental
applications, high precision is required at moderate levels
of production costs. To this end, a conventional welding
machine has been equipped with the capability to react auto-
matically to varying positions of the parts to be welded. In this
way, costly manual adjustment can be reduced to a minimum
and high-tech goods could become more attractive for emer-
ging markets. The proposed procedure can be subdivided into the steps
of image acquisition, stitching, feature extraction, position es-
timation, transformation of the welding contour and, finally,
successful welding. These steps have been described and eval- Fig. 7: Welding result: Filter part and its weld seam 59 © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ Acta Polytechnica Vol. 48 No. 3/2008 Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, Vol. 10 (1988),
No. 6, p. 849–865, November 1988. uated in detail. The evaluation results show that high stan-
dards of accuracy can be achieved by the entire system. [7]
Hough, P. V. C., Arbor, A.: Method and Means for
Recognizing Complex Patterns. United States Patent and
Trademark Office, 3069654, 1962. Acknowledgments The authors would like to thank Professor Dr.-Ing. Til
Aach, Institute of Imaging and Computer Vision, RWTH
Aachen University, and Dr.-Ing. Alexander Olowinsky, Fraun-
hofer Institute for Laser Technology, who supervised this
project. The authors would also like to thank Dipl.-Ing. Jens
Gedicke, Fraunhofer Institute for Laser Technology who,
among others, was involved in creating the hardware setup,
for his kind support. [8]
McGill, R., Tukey, W. J., Larsen, W. A.: Variations of
Box Plots. In The American Statistician, Vol. 32 (1978),
p. 12–16, Feb. 1978. [9]
Werman, M., Weinshall, D.: Similarity and Affine Dis-
tance Between 2D Point Sets. In Proceedings of the
12th IAPR International Conference on Pattern Recognition,
Vol. 1 (1994), p. 723 – 725, Jerusalem, Israel, October
1994. IEEE. This work is funded by the “INTAKT” collaborative re-
search project in the “InnoNet” program, funded by German
Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology (BMWi) with
VDI/VDE-IT. The authors gratefully acknowledge this sup-
port as well as the active cooperation of all project partners. [10] Stache, N. C., Zimmer, H., Gedicke, J., Olowinsky, A.,
Aach, T.: Robust High-Speed Melt Pool Measurements
for Laser Welding with Sputter Detection Capability. In DAGM07: 29th Annual Symposium of the German Associa-
tion for Pattern Recognition, Heidelberg, September 2007. German Association for Pattern Recognition, Springer
Verlag. Nicolaj C. Stache
e-mail: Nicolaj.Stache@lfb.rwth-aachen.de © Czech Technical University Publishing House © Czech Technical University Publishing House
http://ctn.cvut.cz/ap/ Nicolaj C. Stache
e-mail: Nicolaj.Stache@lfb.rwth-aachen.de
Thi Porn Nguyen
Institute of Imaging & Computer Vision
RWTH Aachen University
D-52056 Aachen, Germany References [1]
Jähne, B.: Digitale Bildverarbeitung. Springer Verlag,
Berlin, Heidelberg, 6. edition, 2005. [11] Hartley, R., Zisserman, A.: Multiple View Geometry in Com-
puter Vision. Cambridge University Press, 2000. [2]
Canny, J.: A Computational Approach to Edge Detec-
tion. IEEE Trans. Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,
Vol. 8 (1986), p. 679–714. [12] Smith, S. M., Brady, J. M.: SUSAN – A New Approach
to
Low
Level
Image
Processing. Technical
Report
TR95SMS1c, Oxford University, Chertsey, Surrey, UK,
1995. [3]
Fischler, M. A., Bolles, R. C.: Random Sample Consen-
sus: a Paradigm for Model Fitting with Applications to
Image Analysis and Automated Cartography. Commun. ACM, Vol. 24 (1981), No. 6, p. 381–395. [4]
Furlong, B., Motakef, S.: Scanning Lenses and Systems. News form CVI Melles Griot, November, 28 2007. Thi Porn Nguyen [5]
Gander, W., Golub, G. H., Strebel, R.: Least-Squares Fit-
ting of Circles and Ellipses. In Numerical analysis (in hon-
our of Jean Meinguet), 1996 p. 63–84. [6]
Borgefors, G.: Hierarchical Chamfer Matching: A Para-
metric Edge Matching Algorithm. IEEE Transaction on 60
|
https://openalex.org/W3164818910
|
https://ejnpn.springeropen.com/counter/pdf/10.1186/s41983-021-00302-7
|
English
| null |
Impact of gender, depression severity and type of depressive episode on efficacy and safety of escitalopram: an observational study on major depressive disorder patients in southern India
|
The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery /The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery
| 2,021
|
cc-by
| 8,224
|
RESEARCH Open Access The Egyptian Journal of Neurology,
Psychiatry and Neurosurgery The Egyptian Journal of Neurology,
Psychiatry and Neurosurgery Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery
(2021) 57:47 https://doi.org/10.1186/s41983-021-00302-7 ttps://doi.org/10.1186/s41983-021-00302-7 Abstract 2021 Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License,
which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give
appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if
changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons
licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons
licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain
permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. © The Author(s). 2021 Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License,
which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give
appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if
changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons
licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons
licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain
permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Impact of gender, depression severity and
type of depressive episode on efficacy and
safety of escitalopram: an observational
study on major depressive disorder
patients in southern India Tatiyana Mandal1*
, Laxminarayana Kurady Bairy2, Podila Satya Venkata Narasimha Sharma3 a
Vijaya Lakshmi Valaparla4 Tatiyana Mandal1*
, Laxminarayana Kurady Bairy2, Podila Satya Venkata Narasimha Sharma3 and
Vijaya Lakshmi Valaparla4 * Correspondence: tatiyana.mandal@gmail.com;
tatiyana.mandal@manipal.edu
1Department of Pharmacology, Melaka Manipal Medical College (Manipal
Campus), Manipal Academy of Higher Education (MAHE), Manipal, Karnataka
576 104, India
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article Abstract Background: Antidepressant response is a complex trait influenced by clinical, demographic and genetic factors. Objectives: To explore the influences of baseline depression severity, gender and type of depressive episode on
efficacy and safety of escitalopram (10–20 mg/day) in South Indian patients with major depressive disorder (MDD). Methods: The study was conducted on 18–65-year-old patients (n = 151) suffering from a first or recurrent episode of
MDD with a 17-item Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS-17) score of ≥18 at baseline. Efficacy assessments were
done using HDRS-17, Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS), and Clinical Global Impression (CGI) at
baseline and weeks 4, 8 and 12. Patients were monitored for adverse drug reactions (ADRs). Clinical outcomes were
compared among various groups based on gender, type of depressive episode (first or recurrent episode) and baseline
HDRS-17 scores (moderate depression—score between 17 and 23; severe depression—score ≥24). Results: Among the 148 subjects who completed the 12-week study, 43.9% and 42.6% achieved response and
remission, respectively. The decline in HDRS-17 and MADRS scores from baseline was significant (p value < 0.05) at all
follow-up visits and a similar pattern was seen with CGI. Efficacy outcomes were better in the moderate baseline
depression group compared with severe depression. There were no associations of efficacy with gender and type of
depressive episode. A total of 247 adverse drug reactions (ADR) were reported and 119 (80.41%) subjects experienced
at least one ADR during the study period. No serious ADR was reported. Male patients experienced more ADRs
compared with females. The safety profile of escitalopram was similar across various groups based on baseline
depression severity and type of depressive episode. Conclusion: The study revealed that escitalopram is efficacious in south Indian MDD patients with a favourable safety
profile. The efficacy was influenced by baseline depression severity whereas more ADRs were reported by male patients. Keywords: Depressive disorder, major, Efficacy, Escitalopram, Indians, south, Safety * Correspondence: tatiyana.mandal@gmail.com;
tatiyana.mandal@manipal.edu
1Department of Pharmacology, Melaka Manipal Medical College (Manipal
Campus), Manipal Academy of Higher Education (MAHE), Manipal, Karnataka
576 104, India
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © The Author(s). Introduction drug-associated factors, treatment response and ADRs
might vary in different populations [21]. Several studies
have also reported an association between antidepressant
response and baseline disease severity [22]. According to the World Health Organization, globally
approximately 264 million people are affected by major
depressive disorder (MDD) [1]. In India, the National
Mental Health Survey has estimated that at any given
point, nearly 23 million adults would require care for
depressive disorders [2]. The burden of MDD is further
amplified by the high suicide rate (up to 15%), stress-
related complications and associated deleterious effects
on the cardiovascular system [3, 4]. Statistical data
suggests that by 2030, unipolar depression will become
the second highest contributor to the global disease
burden [5]. Presently in routine clinical practice, psychiatrists have
a wide choice of antidepressants. Therefore, it is essen-
tial to create a population-specific evidence base for
efficacy and tolerability profile of antidepressants which
will help clinicians to make the best choice for individual
patients. Further, identification of variables predicting
antidepressant treatment outcomes has become one of
the major focuses of current scientific research because
this might hold the potential to transform the otherwise
lengthy process of antidepressant selection for individual
patients and thereby might reduce the overall burden
and financial loss. There is an inadequacy of data on
escitalopram treatment response and the plausible influ-
ence of disease severity in modulating this, specifically in
a south Indian population. Data regarding influence of
other patient and disease-related factors on treatment
response is also rare. Therefore, we intended to explore
the treatment response and ADR profile of escitalopram
in South Indian MDD patients. The influences of the
baseline severity of depression, gender and type of de-
pressive episode on treatment response and safety profile
were also assessed. Over the last few decades, SSRIs have emerged as the
first line of treatment for depressive disorders because of
their effectiveness and relatively low toxicity [6, 7]. Vari-
ous comparative trials have suggested that escitalopram,
the S-enantiomer of citalopram has better efficacy and
tolerability in MDD patients compared with other SSRIs
[8–10]. Escitalopram is known to produce only mild and
transient adverse drug reactions (ADR) [9]. The most
common ADRs reported with escitalopram therapy were
insomnia, fatigue, somnolence, nausea, headache, dry
mouth, excessive sweating and sexual dysfunction [9, 11]. In India, studies have found escitalopram being frequently
prescribed as a first-line antidepressant [12]. Materials and methods This
12-week,
prospective,
open-label,
observational
study was conducted at the Department of Psychiatry,
Kasturba Medical College Hospital, Manipal, India. The
study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Commit-
tee of Kasturba Hospital, Manipal (Registration no. ECR/
146/Inst/KA/2013; Study approval number: IEC 317/
2013). Written informed consent was obtained from all
the participants after explaining the full procedure. Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Page 2 of 10 Page 2 of 10 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Introduction There is a considerable debate on the efficacy and toler-
ability of SSRIs in MDD patients. A substantial proportion
(up to 30–50%) of depressed patients shows insufficient
response to SSRI treatment [13]. Sixty to seventy percent
of MDD patients are presented with treatment-resistant
depression (TRD) which is an important contributor of
significant morbidity and mortality associated with MDD
[14]. Several socio-demographic factors that predispose
patients to TRD include old age, patients with poor eco-
nomic resources, lack of education, poor social support
and family networks and lower function and quality of life
[15]. Specific clinical features of the MDD episode such as
longer duration and recurrent episode, higher severity,
high suicidal risk are potentially predictive indicators of
TRD [16]. Non-adherence to antidepressant therapy is
another important reason for treatment failure [17]. Many
patients fail to adhere to antidepressant therapy because
of adverse drug reactions (ADR) [18]. Psychiatric and
somatic comorbidities (anxiety or panic disorder, sub-
stance abuse, higher level of objective stress, personality
disorders, neurodegenerative or autoimmune diseases etc.)
are also associated with treatment non-response and
higher risk of TRD [19]. Further, genetic variants within
the serotonin transporter-serotonin receptors and anti-
depressant metabolizing enzymes or genes involved in
neurodevelopment have been found to modulate the risk
of TRD [20]. Since antidepressant response is a complex
trait influenced by clinical, environmental, genetic and Subjects The study subjects were patients who were diagnosed
with a current episode of unipolar depression and were
on
escitalopram
monotherapy. The
diagnosis
was
verified by DSM-IV (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition) criteria [23]. A
thorough neuro-psychiatric interview was conducted
during screening. After the initial diagnosis, the treat-
ment regimen was decided for all MDD patients and it
was solely at the discretion of the treating psychiatrist
who was not involved in the study. Later, only those
MDD patients prescribed with escitalopram monother-
apy were screened for the exclusion and inclusion
criteria. Patients were recruited for the study if they had
fulfilled these criteria and had given consent to participate
in our study. The study had the following inclusion
criteria: (a) Patients having baseline 17-item Hamilton Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery Page 3 of 10 Page 3 of 10 (2021) 57:47 Depression Rating Scale (HDRS-17) score of 18 and
above, (b) South Indian ethnicity, (c) Either gender, (d)
Age between 18 and 65 years, (e) Patients with first epi-
sode or recurrent episode of MDD. Patients were excluded
if they were diagnosed with other co-morbid mental ill-
nesses such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, schizoaf-
fective disorders, alcohol/drug abuse–related disorder or
dementia within 12 months from week 0. Additional ex-
clusion criteria included patients with significant suicide
risk, liver or renal impairment, unstable serious illness,
contraindications to escitalopram, pregnant or lactating
women. Patients were enrolled from both inpatient and
outpatient settings. Ethnicity of the patient was verified by
taking a detailed family history. All study subjects were
treated with escitalopram once daily at a flexible dose of
10–20 mg. Treatment was initiated with a once-daily dos-
age of 10 mg escitalopram. If adequate response was not
observed during the follow-up visits, doses were titrated
up to 20 mg per day. Patients were not allowed to take
any other psychotropic medications except zolpidem or
zopiclone or clonazepam for insomnia and/or anxiety. However, patients were allowed to take medications for
general illnesses like diabetes, hypertension etc. provided
those are not contraindicated with escitalopram. Con-
comitant medications and dosages were recorded. Adher-
ence to medication was ascertained when patients came
for follow-up by patients’ self-report and also by counting
unused drugs. Subjects Any patient who had not taken 20% of the
prescribed drug was considered non-compliant and ex-
cluded from the study. The study subjects received the
standard treatment throughout the study period and the
treatment regimen was supervised independently by the
psychiatrist treating the patient. This study received no
specific grant from any funding agency and the cost of the
treatment was borne solely by the patients. (first or recurrent episode). Clinical outcomes were com-
pared among various groups. (first or recurrent episode). Clinical outcomes were com-
pared among various groups. Safety assessment After patient recruitment, a baseline review was done to
identify any symptoms which were present prior to the
drug therapy. The frequency and type of suspected ad-
verse drug reactions (ADRs) were noted. Inpatients were
monitored for ADR throughout their hospital stay while
outpatients were monitored during their subsequent
visits to the outpatient department over a period of 12
weeks. Weight and other vital signs were also monitored
each time. Causality assessments of ADRs were done
using the Naranjo ADR Probability Scale [24]. The scale
consists of a list of 10 weighed questions addressing
various aspects of the suspected ADR such as temporal
association of drug administration and ADR occurrence,
drug levels in the body, alternative causes for the ADR,
change in severity with dose changes, previous patient
experience with the same drug, effect of drug discon-
tinuation, specific antagonist or drug rechallenge and
availability of objective evidence. These questions can be
answered with ‘yes’, ‘no’ or ‘do not know’ and each
answer is attached to prefixed numerical scores which
result in a cumulative value. The ADR is assigned to one
of the following probability categories based on the cu-
mulative score: definite (≥9), probable (5–8), possible
(1–4) and doubtful (0). A modified Hartwig and Siegel
Severity Assessment Scale was used to assess the severity
of ADRs [25]. The scale classifies the severity of
suspected ADR as mild, moderate and severe and there
are 7 levels. Mild—level 1 severity requires no change in
drug therapy whereas mild—level 2 requires the sus-
pected drug to be withheld, discontinued or changed. For moderate—level 3, along with change of drug ther-
apy, administration of an antidote or other therapeutic
agents is required. If there is an increase in the length of
hospital stay by at least one day, the ADR belongs to the
moderate level 4(a) category. The ADR is classified as
moderate—level 4(b) if the patient is hospitalized due to
the ADR. Severe—level 5 ADRs warrant intensive care
for the patient. If the ADR has caused permanent harm
to the patient, it is a severe—level 6 ADR. The most
severe ADR, i.e. level 7 ADRs, are those which lead to
the death of the patient either directly or indirectly. Efficacy assessment HDRS-17, Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale
(MADRS) and Clinical Global Impression (CGI) were
used for efficacy assessments. The primary efficacy out-
comes were the remission rate and response rate. Cri-
teria for remission were MADRS score less than 12 and
HDRS-17 score less than 8. At least a 50% decline in
HDRS 17 and MADRS total scores from baseline was
considered as treatment response. Secondary efficacy
outcomes were changes in HDRS-17, MADRS and CGI
from baseline to week 12. The Columbia-Suicide Sever-
ity Rating Scale was used to assess the suicidal tendency
of the patients. Based on the baseline HDRS-17 scores,
the subjects were categorized into two groups: group 1
(moderate depression)—HDRS-17 score between 17 and
23 (n = 91), group 2 (severe depression)—HDRS-17
score ≥24 (n = 57). Grouping was also done based on
gender (male and female) and type of depressive episode Remission and response rate According to the criteria for response, at the end of
week 12, out of 148 study subjects, 83 (56.08%) patients Statistical analysis Student’s t test and Chi-square test were used to analyse
quantitative
and
qualitative
data,
respectively. The
changes in treatment response over time was analysed
by one-way ANOVA followed by Bonferroni’s post hoc
test. The other efficacy outcomes and ADR-related
assessments were analysed descriptively. SPSS 19.0 was Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:4 Page 4 of 10 Page 4 of 10 (2021) 57:47 used for statistical analysis and p value < 0.05 was
considered statistically significant. were non-responders and 65 (43.9%) patients were
responders. Sixty-three (96.9%) patients fulfilled the
criteria of remission. Figure 1 shows the week-wise
remission and response rates in the total study popula-
tion and patients with different baseline depression
levels. Response and remission rates were higher in
group 1 compared with that of group 2 at weeks 4, 8
and 12 (Fig. 1). However, a comparison of the number
of responders and remitters among studied groups
(group 1 and group 2) using Chi-square test or Fisher’s
exact test revealed that the association between baseline
depression severity and treatment response and remis-
sion was not statistically significant. Relationship of efficacy with gender and type of depressive
episode Table 1 Baseline demographic and clinical characteristics of
patients
Characteristic, N = 148*
Female, n (%)
87 (58.8)
Male, n (%)
61 (41.2)
Ethnicity
South Indian
Age in years, mean ± SD
42.2 ± 10.7
Patients experiencing first episode, n (%)
102 (68.9)
Patients experiencing recurrent episode n (%),
46 (31.1)
HDRS-17 score, mean ± SD
22.56 ± 3.22
MADRS score, mean ± SD
33.22 ± 4.23
CGI-S score, n (%)
4 = Moderately ill
47 (31.5)
5 = Markedly ill
52 (34.9)
6 = Severely ill
49 (32.9)
Patients having suicidal ideation, n (%)
23 (15.5)
Patients having suicidal tendency, n (%)
0(0)
*N - Total number of study subjects Efficacy outcomes were similar across different genders
(p >.05). No significant difference (p >.05) was observed
in efficacy outcomes between patients experiencing a
first episode and patients experiencing a recurrent
episode. Changes in HDRS-17, MADRS and CGI scores Changes in HDRS-17, MADRS and CGI scores
Figures 2 and 3 represent the change in mean HDRS-17
scores and MADRS scores during escitalopram therapy
in different groups. The decline in HDRS-17 and MADR
S scores in the total study population was significant (p
value 0.0001) at week 4 and was sustained till week 12. Changes in CGI-severity and CGI-improvement ratings
are given in Table 2. A similar pattern of improvement
was seen with CGI-S and CGI-I scores compared with
that seen with the HDRS-17 and MADRS total scores. Group-wise analysis revealed that, in both groups,
HDRS-17 and MADRS scores were significantly reduced
at different time-points compared with baseline. The de-
cline in HDRS-17 and MADRS scores was significantly
(p value 0.0001) higher in group 1 at weeks 4, 8 and 12
compared with group 2 (Figs. 2 and 3) which was indica-
tive of better treatment response in patients with lower
baseline depression severity. Efficacy outcomes Remission and response rate Results
Demographic and clinical characteristics of study subjects
at baseline A total of 151 depressive patients were recruited in the
study among which 3 patients were excluded from the
study as they did not participate in the follow-up evalu-
ation. All the subjects were of South Indian ethnicity
and were from states of Karnataka, Kerala and Andhra
Pradesh. The demographic and clinical characteristics of
the subjects at baseline are presented in Table 1. 15.5%
of patients had suicidal ideation at baseline, but it de-
creased to 6.08% at the end of 12 weeks. The intensity of
ideation was least severe as assessed by the Columbia
Suicide Severity Rating Scale and these patients did not
require any additional psychotropic medications. None
of the subjects were found to have suicidal tendencies
during the study period. Escitalopram therapy was
started with an initial dose of 10 mg once daily for all
patients. Later, the escitalopram dose was adjusted to a
maximum of 20 mg/day for 124 (83.78%) patients during
the treatment period and the rest were maintained with
the initial dose till the completion of the study. At least
one concomitant drug was taken by 47 (31.8%) patients. The most common concomitant drug prescribed to the
patients was clonazepam (7.4%) for insomnia. Safety and tolerability Out of 148 study subjects, 119 (80.41%) subjects experi-
enced at least 1 adverse drug reaction (ADR) during the
study period. The maximum number of patients (66.9%)
experienced ADR at week 4 followed by week 8 (29.1%)
and week 12 (7.4%). Most of the ADRs (except insom-
nia) were mild requiring no change of treatment or drug
withdrawal. Insomnia was moderate in 11 (7.4%) patients
and was treated with clonazepam. There were no serious
ADRs reported. Causality analysis revealed that 196
(79.4%) ADRs were probable whereas 51 (34.6%) ADRs
were possible in nature. Doubtful ADRs were excluded
from analysis. A total of 247 ADRs were reported during Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47
Page 5 of Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Page 5 of 10 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Fig. 1 Percentage of patients showing response and remission during escitalopram therapy. Overall: total study population (n = 148). Group 1:
baseline HDRS-17 score between 18 and 23 (n = 91). Group 2—HDRS 17 score ≥24 (n = 57) Fig. 1 Percentage of patients showing response and remission during escitalopram therapy. Overall: total study populat
baseline HDRS-17 score between 18 and 23 (n = 91). Group 2—HDRS 17 score ≥24 (n = 57) the proportion of patients experiencing ADRs among dif-
ferent groups based on baseline disease severity, gender and
type of depressive episode. The mean number of ADRs was
similar across patients having different baseline depression
severity and types of depressive episodes. The mean
number of ADRs experienced by male patients (mean ±
SEM—1.97 ± 0.19) was significantly higher (p value: .025) the 12-week study period. 67.2% of ADRs were reported
at the 4th week of treatment followed by the 8th week
(26.3%) and the 12th week (6.5%). Escitalopram was well
tolerated by the study subjects and treatment withdrawal
due to ADRs was not required for any patients. The com-
mon ADRs observed during the study period are summa-
rized in Table 3. There were no significant differences in Fig. 2 Mean change in HDRS-17 scores with escitalopram therapy. Group 1: baseline HDRS-17 score between 18 and 23 (n = 91). Group
2—HDRS-17 score ≥24 (n = 57). *p value < 0.05 HDRS-17 scores at weeks 4, 8 and 12 compared with week 0. Safety and tolerability #p value < 0.05 compared with
respective scores in group 2 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47
Page 6 of 10 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery Page 6 of 10 (2021) 57:47 Fig. 3 Mean change in MADRS scores with escitalopram therapy. Group 1: baseline HDRS-17 score between 18 and 23 (n = 91). Group 2—HDRS-
17 score ≥24 (n = 57). *p value < 0.05 HDRS-17 scores at weeks 4, 8 and 12 compared with week 0. #p value < 0.05 compared with respective
scores in group 2 compared with female patients (mean ± SEM—1.46 ± 0.13)
in our study population. The more prevalent ADRs among
males (reported by ≥4% of male patients) as compared
with female patients were nausea, diarrhoea, fatigue, consti-
pation, sweating, drowsiness and abdominal pain. Sexual
dysfunction was reported exclusively by male patients. *N - Total number of study subjects Discussion In the present study, 36.5%
of patients showed very much improvement after 12
weeks of treatment according to the CGI Improvement
Scale, whereas 18.9% of patients showed very much
improvement at 8 weeks of treatment. Therefore, the
duration of escitalopram therapy can be considered as an
important
determinant
of
treatment
remission
and
severely
depressed
patients
might
require
a
longer
duration of treatment for achieving remission. Consider-
ing a substantial percentage (32.9%) of severely depressed
patients at baseline, we might expect an increase in remis-
sion rate if the study would have continued for a longer
duration. Moreover, most of the responders at week 8
achieved remission at the end of 12 weeks. Therefore, the
treatment response observed at week 8 may be used to
predict remission in MDD patients. higher decline (– 26.2) in MADRS scores from baseline
[11]. Studies have found that with continued treatment,
patients not showing response at week 8 had achieved
remission at week 24 [11, 30]. In the present study, 36.5%
of patients showed very much improvement after 12
weeks of treatment according to the CGI Improvement
Scale, whereas 18.9% of patients showed very much
improvement at 8 weeks of treatment. Therefore, the
duration of escitalopram therapy can be considered as an
important
determinant
of
treatment
remission
and
severely
depressed
patients
might
require
a
longer
duration of treatment for achieving remission. Consider-
ing a substantial percentage (32.9%) of severely depressed
patients at baseline, we might expect an increase in remis-
sion rate if the study would have continued for a longer
duration. Moreover, most of the responders at week 8
achieved remission at the end of 12 weeks. Therefore, the
treatment response observed at week 8 may be used to
predict remission in MDD patients. We have found that patients with baseline moderate
depression (HDRS-17 score 17–23) showed better re-
sponse and remission rate compared with patients with
severe depression (HDRS-17 score ≥24). The decline in
HDRS-17 and MADRS scores was also significantly
higher in moderate depression. These findings are in line
with four trials of escitalopram in MDD patients in the
Chinese population [29]. However, several studies re-
ported that escitalopram showed better treatment re-
sponse compared with other SSRIs in patients having
severe depression at baseline as well [10, 32]. Discussion However,
the absence of a placebo or another treatment group for
comparison of treatment efficacy can be considered as a
limitation of this study. N, total study population; n, number of patients reporting ADR
aPercentage is calculated out of male patients only (n = 61) response assessed by HDRS-17, MADRS and CGI scores
were consistent which is suggestive of minimal bias, thus
establishes the clinical relevance of treatment response and
remission. The response and remission rate observed in
our study is lower compared with studies reported in the
Indian population. These studies reported a response rate
and remission rate of more than 70% and 60% respectively
at week 8 [26, 27]. Another multicenter trial of escitalopram
in MDD patients found 80% response and remission rates
at week 8 [28]. A pooled analysis of four Chinese clinical
trials reported a 68.4% response rate and a 48.4% remission
rate at the end of 7 weeks [29]. The differences in response
and remission rates found in our study could be attributed
to variability in study design, sample size, study population,
duration of treatment and type of depressive disease. In our study, remission was achieved at a dose of 10–
20 mg of escitalopram which is consistent with several
trials of escitalopram [26, 30]. Out of 148 patients, dose
was increased to 20 mg/day for 124 patients which
include all non-responders (n = 83) and 41 (out of 65)
responders during the 12-week treatment period. Since
dose was increased for more than 80% of study subjects,
we have not done any dose-wise analysis of treatment
response and remission. An earlier study suggests that
escalation of escitalopram dose beyond 20 mg might
have a beneficial effect on treatment response [33]. However, we could not explore this effect in our study
as the escitalopram dose was maintained at a maximum
of 20 mg. In our study, the mean changes in HDRS 17 and
MADRS were observed in week 4 and there was a steady
decline in scores in the next follow-up visits. The
changes were statistically significant at each time point
compared with baseline. The mean decline in HDRS-17
and MADRS scores at 12 weeks was – 10.4 and – 18.8
respectively. At the end of 8 weeks, the mean decline of
HDRS-17 and MADRS was – 12.2 and – 16.8 respect-
ively. Discussion Perusal of the data collected shows that escitalopram
was effective in the treatment of MDD patients and it
was well tolerated. At the end of 12 weeks, a response
rate of 43.9% and a remission rate of 42.6% were
achieved in the present study. The pattern of treatment Table 2 Changes of clinical global impression during escitalopram therapy (N = 148*)
CGI
Week 4, n (%)
Week 8, n (%)
Week 12, n (%)
CGI-S (severity)
Normal
0 (0)
4 (2.70)
36 (24.32)
Marginally ill
1 (0.68)
27 (18.24)
24 (16.22)
Mildly ill
93 (62.84)
79 (53.38)
61 (41.22)
Moderately ill
24 (16.22)
23 (15.54)
16 (10.81)
Markedly ill
27 (18.24)
15 (10.14)
11 (7.43)
Severely ill
3 (2.03)
0 (0)
0 (0)
Most extremely ill
0 (0)
0 (0)
0 (0)
CGI-I (improvement)
Very much improved
2 (1.35)
28 (18.92)
54 (36.49)
Much improved
57 (38.51)
52 (35.14)
36 (24.32)
Minimally improved
64 (43.24)
60 (40.54)
53 (35.81)
No change
25 (16.89)
8 (5.41)
5 (3.38)
Minimally worse
0 (0)
0 (0)
0 (0)
Much worse
0 (0)
0 (0)
0 (0)
Very much worse
0 (0)
0 (0)
0 (0)
*N - Total number of study subjects Table 2 Changes of clinical global impression during escitalopram therapy (N = 148*)
CGI
Week 4, n (%)
Week 8, n (%) Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Page 7 of 10 Page 7 of 10 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery Table 3 Summary of adverse drug reactions (ADRs) seen in ≥
3% of patients (N = 148)
ADR
n (%)
Nausea
29 (19.6)
Headache
26 (17.6)
Diarrhoea
22 (14.9)
Dry mouth
20 (13.5)
Decreased appetite
18 (12.2)
Insomnia
16 (10.8)
Fatigue
14 (9.5)
Constipation
14 (9.5)
Dizziness
12 (8.1)
Tremors
9 (6.1)
Vomiting
9 (6.1)
Sweating
8 (5.4)
Drowsiness
8 (5.4)
Abdominal pain
6 (4.1)
Anxiety
5 (3.4)
Sexual dysfunctiona
3 (4.9)
N, total study population; n, number of patients reporting ADR
aPercentage is calculated out of male patients only (n = 61) higher decline (– 26.2) in MADRS scores from baseline
[11]. Studies have found that with continued treatment,
patients not showing response at week 8 had achieved
remission at week 24 [11, 30]. Discussion Patients with significant suicide risk
such as those with other co-morbid psychiatric or medical
conditions, severe somatic illness, adverse life situations,
previous suicide attempts, family history of suicide or psy-
chosocial risk factors were excluded from our study as the
management of these patients include close monitoring,
psychotherapy and use of other psychotropic medications
(lithium, antipsychotics, anxiolytics) along with antidepres-
sants [41]. Hence, from our study findings, we could not
establish the therapeutic efficiency of escitalopram in pa-
tients with significant suicide risk. where escitalopram was reported to have lower drop-out
cases due to ADR compared with other SSRIs [8, 44]. Our study also demonstrated that the frequency of ADR
was not associated with baseline disease severity, gender
and type of depressive episode. yp
p
p
Escitalopram is the S-enantiomer of citalopram having
30 to 40 times more potency compared with the R-
enantiomer in binding to serotonin transporter [45]. This ‘chiral-switching’ allowed escitalopram to have a
more selective action on the serotonin transporter than
other SSRIs [46]. Therefore, it can inhibit the serotonin
reuptake more effectively resulting in better treatment
efficacy. The low affinity of escitalopram towards cholin-
ergic,
alpha-adrenergic
and
histaminergic
receptors
might account for its better safety and tolerability profile
[47]. Thus, escitalopram is presumed to be highly effica-
cious and safe for the treatment of MDD patients. This
presumption is supported by the results of our study. However, these results cannot be extrapolated for all
MDD patients because patients with co-morbid psychi-
atric disorders, anxiety disorders and high suicide risk
were excluded from our study. Therefore, our study
population may not be fully exemplary of MDD patient
population. This could be another limitation of our
study. Further a multi-centric, large-scale, longer duration,
prospective, comparative study in a variety of patient pop-
ulations will be required to establish the efficacy and safety
of escitalopram for the treatment of MDD. Robust
scientific
evidence
suggests
that
genetic
polymorphisms have a crucial role in determining the
antidepressant response and adverse effects of escitalo-
pram in different populations [48–50]. Considering the
south Indian population to have a distinct genetic make-
up [51], we explored the treatment response and ADR
profile of escitalopram exclusively in MDD patients of
South Indian origin. We can infer that the lower
response and remission rate with escitalopram observed
in our study population compared with other popula-
tions could be due to the genotypic differences. Discussion This finding is consistent with several comparative
studies of escitalopram versus other SSRIs or placebo in
MDD patients [30, 31]. However, one Indian study
reported a higher decline in MADRS score (– 20.8)
compared with our study at week 8 [26]. This could be
due to the higher proportion of non-responders in our
study population. A 24-week study reported a much Sub-group analysis of treatment response revealed that
efficacy outcomes were similar in all patients irrespective
of their gender or type of depressive episode. Although
we did not find any statistically significant associations
of these factors with treatment response in our study,
but there are conflicting reports in the literature [29, 34,
35]. Hence, future studies are needed to substantiate these Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 Page 8 of 10 Page 8 of 10 reports. Another limitation of our study is that we have
not investigated the effect of other factors such as age, dur-
ation of depressive episode and concomitant anxiety symp-
toms which are also known to influence the treatment
response [11, 36, 37]. Moreover, the presence of suicidality
can attenuate the clinical response to antidepressant treat-
ment, independently of clinical confounders or the type of
antidepressant [38]. A systematic review of several ran-
domized clinical trials raised concerns regarding the in-
crease in suicidality in young psychiatric patients receiving
SSRIs
[39],
whereas
several
pharmacoepidemiological
studies have demonstrated the protective effects of antide-
pressants with respect to suicidal behaviour in depressive
patients [40]. This controversial context demands clinical
trials to be designed specifically for depressed patients at
significant risk for suicide. In our study, 15.5% of study
subjects were found to have suicidal ideation at baseline
and we had observed a decline in suicidal ideation at the
end of 12 weeks with escitalopram treatment. The intensity
of the ideation was found to be the least severe as assessed
by the Columbia Suicide Severity Rating Scale. None of the
study subjects were found to have suicidal tendencies at
baseline or developed it during the study period. However,
it is important to note that we had recruited only those
patients with suicidal ideation who do not require any
other psychotropic medications and can be managed by
escitalopram itself. Discussion We
cannot confirm this at this stage due to a lack of
pharmacokinetic and genotypic data. Further large-scale
genetic association studies of several pharmacokinetic
and pharmacodynamics candidate genes with treatment
response will be required to prove this hypothesis. In this study, adverse drug reactions to escitalopram
doses of 10-20 mg were mild to moderate in nature and
tolerable. Serious ADRs and unexpected safety issues
were not reported. The common side effects were
related
to
the
gastrointestinal
system. In
addition,
headache, insomnia and fatigue were also commonly re-
ported. No adverse cardiac outcomes were observed in
our study, though there are some conflicting reports
regarding cardiac safety of escitalopram [42, 43]. Most of
the ADRs did not require any treatment and were sub-
sided or reduced on their own over few days or weeks. Majority of the adverse effects were reported during the
first 4 weeks of therapy. These findings are consistent
with the earlier studies of escitalopram in patients with
MDD in India and other Asian countries [9, 11, 26–28]. There was no patient withdrawal in our study due to
ADR. This finding is also in line with various studies Availability of data and materials 13. Steimer W. Pharmacogenetics and psychoactive drug therapy: ready for the
patient? Ther Drug Monit. 2010;32(4):381–6. https://doi.org/10.1097/FTD. 0b013e3181e1a78d. The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available
from the corresponding author on reasonable request. 14. Fava M. Diagnosis and definition of treatment-resistant depression. Biol
Psychiatry. 2003;53(8):649–59. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3223(03
)00231-2. Acknowledgements We sincerely acknowledge the assistance provided by Dr. Amritavarshini R
and Dr. Linda Thomas from the Department of Psychiatry, KMC, Manipal,
during data collection. We are thankful to Dr. Smita Shenoy, Department of
Pharmacology, KMC, Manipal, and Dr. Ravindra Munoli, Department of
Psychiatry, KMC, Manipal, for their valuable inputs on the study. 9. Kirino E. Escitalopram for the management of major depressive disorder: a
review of its efficacy, safety, and patient acceptability. Patient Prefer
Adherence. 2012;6:853–61. https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S22495. 10. Boulenger JP, Huusom AKT, Florea I, Bæmadraskdal T, Sarchiapone M. A
comparative study of the efficacy of long-term treatment with escitalopram
and paroxetine in severely depressed patients. Curr Med Res Opin. 2006;
22(7):1331–41. https://doi.org/10.1185/030079906X115513. Funding This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the
public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors. This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the
public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors. 12. Grover S, Avasth A, Kalita K, Dalal P, Rao G, Chadda R, et al. IPS multicentric
study: antidepressant prescription patterns. Indian J Psychiatry. 2013;55(1):
41–5. https://doi.org/10.4103/0019-5545.105503. Author details
1 Author details
1Department of Pharmacology, Melaka Manipal Medical College (Manipal
Campus), Manipal Academy of Higher Education (MAHE), Manipal, Karnataka
576 104, India. 2Department of Pharmacology, RAK College of Medical
Sciences, RAK Medical & Health Sciences University, Ras Al Khaimah, UAE. 3Department of Psychiatry, Kasturba Medical College, Manipal Academy of
Higher Education (MAHE), Manipal, Karnataka 576 104, India. 4Department of
Neurology, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, TX, USA. 18. Masand PS. Tolerability and adherence issues in antidepressant therapy. Clin
Ther. 2003;25(8):2289–304. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0149-2918(03)80220-5. 19. Bennabi D, Aouizerate B, El-Hage W, Doumy O, Moliere F, Courtet P, et al. Risk factors for treatment resistance in unipolar depression: a systematic
review. J Affect Disord. 2015;171:137–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2014. 09.020. 20. Porcelli S, Drago A, Fabbri C, Gibiino S, Calati R, Serretti A. Pharmacogenetics of antidepressant response. J Psychiatry Neurosci. 2011;
36(2):87–113. https://doi.org/10.1503/jpn.100059. Received: 5 August 2020 Accepted: 22 March 2021 Received: 5 August 2020 Accepted: 22 March 2021 21. Kemp AH, Gordon E, Rush AJ, Williams LM. Improving the prediction of
treatment response in depression: integration of clinical, cognitive,
psychophysiological, neuroimaging, and genetic measures. CNS Spectr. 2008;13(12):1066–86. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1092852900017120. Abbreviations
d MDD: Major depressive disorder; SSRI: Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor;
ADR: Adverse drug reaction; DSM IV: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition; HDRS-17: 17-item Hamilton Depression
Rating Scale; MADRS: Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale;
CGI: Clinical Global Impression; CGI-S: Clinical Global Impression-Severity; CGI-
I: Clinical Global Impression-Improvement 7. Anderson IM, Ferrier IN, Baldwin RC, Cowen PJ, Howard L, Lewis G, et al. Evidence-based guidelines for treating depressive disorders with
antidepressants: a revision of the 2000 British Association for
Psychopharmacology guidelines. J Psychopharmacol. 2008;22(4):343–96. https://doi.org/10.1177/0269881107088441. 7. Anderson IM, Ferrier IN, Baldwin RC, Cowen PJ, Howard L, Lewis G, et al. Evidence-based guidelines for treating depressive disorders with
antidepressants: a revision of the 2000 British Association for
Psychopharmacology guidelines. J Psychopharmacol. 2008;22(4):343–96. https://doi.org/10.1177/0269881107088441. 8. Lalit V, Appaya PM, Hegde RP, Mital AK, Mittal S, Nagpal R, et al. Escitalopram versus citalopram and sertraline: a double-blind controlled,
multi-centric trial in Indian patients with unipolar major depression. Indian J
Psychiatry. 2004;46(4):333–41. Consent for publication
Not applicable 17. Bull SA, Hu XH, Hunkeler EM, Lee JY, Ming EE, Markson LE, et al. Discontinuation of use and switching of antidepressants: influence of
patient-physician communication. J Am Med Assoc. 2002;288(11):1403–9. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.288.11.1403. Authors’ contributions TM was involved in study design, data collection, analysis and interpretation
and preparation of the manuscript. LKB, PSVNS and VLV were involved in
study design, data analysis and interpretation and critical revision of the
manuscript. The author(s) read and approved the final manuscript. 11. Jiang K, Li L, Wang X, Fang M, Shi J, Cao Q, et al. Efficacy and
tolerability of escitalopram in treatment of major depressive disorder
with anxiety symptoms: A 24-week, open-label, prospective study in
Chinese population. Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat. 2017;13:515–26. https://
doi.org/10.2147/NDT.S120190. Conclusion Projections of global mortality and burden of disease
from 2002 to 2030. PLoS Med. 2006;3(11):2011–30. 6. Preskorn SH. Clinically relevant pharmacology of selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitors. An overview with emphasis on pharmacokinetics
and effects on oxidative drug metabolism. Clin Pharmacokinet. 1997;
32(Suppl 1):1–21. 6. Preskorn SH. Clinically relevant pharmacology of selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitors. An overview with emphasis on pharmacokinetics
and effects on oxidative drug metabolism. Clin Pharmacokinet. 1997;
32(Suppl 1):1–21. Ethics approval and consent to participate 15. Balestri M, Calati R, Souery D, Kautzky A, Kasper S, Montgomery S, et al. Socio-demographic and clinical predictors of treatment resistant depression:
a prospective European multicenter study. J Affect Disord. 2016;189:224–32. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2015.09.033. The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee of Kasturba
Hospital, Manipal (Registration no. ECR/146/Inst/KA/2013), and the approval
number of our study is IEC 317/2013. Written informed consent was
obtained from all the participants after explaining the full procedure. 16. Souery D, Oswald P, Massat I, Bailer U, Bollen J, Demyttenaere K, et al. Clinical factors associated with treatment resistance in major depressive
disorder: results from a European multicenter study. J Clin Psychiatry. 2007;
68(7):1062–70. https://doi.org/10.4088/JCP.v68n0713. Conclusion Based on our study results, we can conclude that escita-
lopram is an efficacious SSRI for the treatment of MDD
in South Indian patients with favourable safety and toler-
ability profile. It was also observed that the treatment re-
sponse of escitalopram can be influenced by baseline
depression severity. This prospective surveillance study
provides a representative data of treatment response and
ADR profile of escitalopram likely to be encountered in Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery Page 9 of 10 Page 9 of 10 Page 9 of 10 (2021) 57:47 South Indian patients with MDD. Our findings would be
useful to clinicians in rational prescribing by providing
an estimate of efficacy at multiple time points for com-
parison. This study data might serve as an evidence base
to assist clinicians in predicting clinical outcomes. It also
might help in the early detection of ADRs and their
subsequent management thereby improving the overall
health outcomes and quality of life of patients with
major depressive disorder. South Indian patients with MDD. Our findings would be
useful to clinicians in rational prescribing by providing
an estimate of efficacy at multiple time points for com-
parison. This study data might serve as an evidence base
to assist clinicians in predicting clinical outcomes. It also
might help in the early detection of ADRs and their
subsequent management thereby improving the overall
health outcomes and quality of life of patients with
major depressive disorder. Multisite population-based cross-sectional study. BMJ Open. 2019;9(6):
e027250. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2018-027250. Multisite population-based cross-sectional study. BMJ Open. 2019;9(6):
e027250. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2018-027250. 3. Dhar AK, Barton DA. Depression and the link with cardiovascular disease. Front Psychiatry. 2016;7(MAR):1. 3. Dhar AK, Barton DA. Depression and the link with cardiovascular disease. Front Psychiatry. 2016;7(MAR):1. 4. Xin LM, Chen L, Su YA, Yang FD, Wang G, Fang YR, et al. Risk factors for
recent suicide attempts in major depressive disorder patients in China:
results from a National Study. Front Psychiatry. 2018;9:300. https://doi.org/1
0.3389/fpsyt.2018.00300. 4. Xin LM, Chen L, Su YA, Yang FD, Wang G, Fang YR, et al. Risk factors for
recent suicide attempts in major depressive disorder patients in China:
results from a National Study. Front Psychiatry. 2018;9:300. https://doi.org/1
0.3389/fpsyt.2018.00300. 5. Mathers CD, Loncar D. Projections of global mortality and burden of disease
from 2002 to 2030. PLoS Med. 2006;3(11):2011–30. 5. Mathers CD, Loncar D. References 22. Locher C, Kossowsky J, Gaab J, Kirsch I, Bain P, Krummenacher P. Moderation of antidepressant and placebo outcomes by baseline severity in 2. Arvind BA, Gururaj G, Loganathan S, Amudhan S, Varghese M, Benegal V, Page 10 of 10 Page 10 of 10 Page 10 of 10 Mandal et al. The Egyptian Journal of Neurology, Psychiatry and Neurosurgery (2021) 57:47 late-life depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Affect Disord. 2015;181:50–60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2015.03.062. late-life depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Affect Disord. 2015;181:50–60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2015.03.062. 43. Thase ME, Larsen KG, Reines E, Kennedy SH. The cardiovascular safety profile
of escitalopram. Eur Neuropsychopharmacol. 2013;23(11):1391–400. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.euroneuro.2013.05.011. late-life depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Affect Disord. 2015;181:50–60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2015.03.062. 23. Association AP. Association, AP Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental
disorders. 1995. 44. Shinde M, Reddy P, Kulmi M, Goyal C. Efficacy and tolerability of milnacipran
and escitalopram: a comparative study among patients of depression. Int J
Basic Clin Pharmacol. 2018;7(5):839. https://doi.org/10.18203/2319-2003. ijbcp20181489. 24. Naranjo CA, Busto U, Sellers EM, Sandor P, Ruiz I, Roberts EA, et al. A
method for estimating the probability of adverse drug reactions. Clin
Pharmacol Ther. 1981;30(2):239–45. https://doi.org/10.1038/clpt.1981.154. 25. Hartwig SC, Siegel J, Schneider PJ. Preventability and severity assessment in
reporting adverse drug reactions. Am J Hosp Pharm. 1992;49:2229–32. 45. Sánchez C, Bergqvist PBF, Brennum LT, Gupta S, Hogg S, Larsen A, et al. Escitalopram, the S-(+)-enantiomer of citalopram, is a selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitor with potent effects in animal models predictive of
antidepressant and anxiolytic activities. Psychopharmacology (Berl). 2003;
167(4):353–62. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00213-002-1364-z. 26. Patel M, Patel V, Tiwari D, Shah VR, Patel D, Chanpa N. Efficacy and safety of
escitalopram in first episode of major depressive disorder - a tertiary care
Indian center experience. J Depress anxiety. 2018;7:1–5. 46. Zhong H, Haddjeri N, Sánchez C. Escitalopram, an antidepressant with an
allosteric effect at the serotonin transporter--a review of current
understanding of its mechanism of action. Psychopharmacology (Berl). 2012;219(1):1–13. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00213-011-2463-5. 27. Pinto C, Trivedi JK, Vankar GK, Sharma PS, Narasimha V. An open-label
multicentric study of the tolerability and response to escitalopram
treatment in Indian patients with major depressive disorder. J Indian Med
Assoc. 2007;105(7):364–8. 47. Culpepper L. Escitalopram: A new SSRI for the treatment of depression in
primary care. Prim Care Companion J Clin Psychiatry. 2002;4(6):209–14. https://doi.org/10.4088/PCC.v04n0601. 28. Mao PX, Tang YL, Jiang F, Shu L, Gu X, Li M, et al. References Escitalopram in major
depressive disorder: a multicenter, randomized, double-blind, fixed-dose,
parallel trial in a Chinese population. Depress Anxiety. 2008;25(1):46–54. https://doi.org/10.1002/da.20222. 48. Basu A, Chadda RK, Sood M, Kaur H, Kukreti R. A preliminary association
study between serotonin transporter (5-HTTLPR), receptor polymorphisms
(5-HTR1A, 5-HTR2A) and depression symptom-clusters in a north Indian
population suffering from Major Depressive Disorder (MDD). Asian J
Psychiatr. 2019;43:184–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajp.2019.05.028. 29. Li G, Shen Y, Luo J, Li H. Efficacy of escitalopram monotherapy in the
treatment of major depressive disorder: a pooled analysis of 4 Chinese
clinical trials. Medicine. 2017;96(39):e8142. https://doi.org/10.1097/MD. 0000000000008142. 49. Mandal T, Bairy LK, Sharma PSVN. Association between functional
polymorphisms in serotonin transporter gene (SLC6A4) and escitalopram
treatment response in depressive patients in a South Indian population. Eur
J of Clin Pharmacol. 2020;76(6):807–14. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00228-020-
02866-4. 30. Colonna L, Andersen HF, Reines EH. A randomized, double-blind, 24-week
study of escitalopram (10 mg/day) versus citalopram (20 mg/day) in primary
care patients with major depressive disorder. Curr Med Res Opin. 2005;
21(10):1659–68. https://doi.org/10.1185/030079905X65484. 31. Wade A, Michael Lemming O, Bang Hedegaard K. Escitalopram 10 mg/day
is effective and well tolerated in a placebo-controlled study in depression in
primary care. Int Clin Psychopharmacol. 2002;17(3):95–102. https://doi.org/1
0.1097/00004850-200205000-00001. 50. Tsai MH, Lin KM, Hsiao MC, Shen WW, Lu ML, Tang HS, et al. Genetic
polymorphisms of cytochrome P450 enzymes influence metabolism of the
antidepressant escitalopram and treatment response. Pharmacogenomics. 2010;11(4):537–46. https://doi.org/10.2217/pgs.09.168. 32. Cipriani A, Santilli C, Furukawa TA, Signoretti A, Nakagawa A, McGuire H,
et al. Escitalopram versus other antidepressive agents for depression. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;2:CD006532. 51. Rajkumar R, Kashyap VK. Genetic structure of four socio-culturally diversified
caste populations of southwest India and their affinity with related Indian
and global groups. BMC Genet. 2004;5(1):23. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-21
56-5-23. 33. Wade AG, Crawford GM, Yellowlees A. Efficacy, safety and tolerability of
escitalopram in doses up to 50 mg in Major Depressive Disorder (MDD): an
open-label, pilot study. BMC Psychiatry. 2011;11(1):42. https://doi.org/10.11
86/1471-244X-11-42. Publisher’s Note 34. Trivedi MH, Rush AJ, Wisniewski SR, Nierenberg AA, Warden D, Ritz L, et al. Evaluation of outcomes with citalopram for depression using measurement-
based care in STAR*D: Implications for clinical practice. Am J Psychiatry. 2006;163(1):28–40. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.163.1.28. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in
published maps and institutional affiliations. 35. Joffe RT, Young LT, Levitt AJ, MacQueen G, Marriott MJ, Robb J. Number of
episodes and antidepressant response in major depression. Int J
Neuropsychopharmacol. 1999;2(2):111–3. https://doi.org/10.1017/S146114
5799001443. 36. Fava M, Rush AJ, Alpert JE, Balasubramani GK, Wisniewski SR, Carmin CN,
et al. Difference in treatment outcome in outpatients with anxious versus
nonanxious depression: A STAR*D report. Am J Psychiatry. 2008;165(3):342–
51. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2007.06111868. 37. Mulder RT, Watkins WGA, Joyce PR, Luty SE. Age may affect response to
antidepressants with serotonergic and noradrenergic actions. J Affect
Disord. 2003;76(1–3):143–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0165-0327(02)00083-6. 38. Lopez-Castroman J, Jaussent I, Gorwood P, Courtet P. Suicidal depressed
patients respond less well to antidepressants in the short term. Depress
Anxiety. 2016;33(6):483–94. https://doi.org/10.1002/da.22473. 39. Fergusson D, Doucette S, Glass KC, Shapiro S, Healy D, Hebert P, et al. Association between suicide attempts and selective serotonin reuptake
inhibitors: systematic review of randomised controlled trials. BMJ. 2005;
330(7488):396. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.330.7488.396. 40. Isacsson G, Rich CL, Jureidini J, Raven M. The increased use of
antidepressants has contributed to the worldwide reduction in suicide
rates. Br J Psychiatry. 2010;196(6):429–33. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.bp.1
09.076166. 41. Griffiths JJ, Zarate CA Jr, Rasimas JJ. Existing and novel biological
therapeutics in suicide prevention. Am J Prev Med. 2014;47(3 Suppl 2):S195–
203. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2014.06.012. 41. Griffiths JJ, Zarate CA Jr, Rasimas JJ. Existing and novel biological
therapeutics in suicide prevention. Am J Prev Med. 2014;47(3 Suppl 2):S195–
203. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2014.06.012. 42. Ozdilek B. Escitalopram-induced bradycardia in elderly individuals: a case
series report. Klin Psikofarmakol Bul. 2015;25(2):183–5. https://doi.org/10.54
55/bcp.20140304090654. 42. Ozdilek B. Escitalopram-induced bradycardia in elderly individuals: a case
series report. Klin Psikofarmakol Bul. 2015;25(2):183–5. https://doi.org/10.54
55/bcp.20140304090654.
|
https://openalex.org/W4238158638
|
https://repository.library.noaa.gov/view/noaa/24495/noaa_24495_DS1.pdf
|
English
| null |
Simulating secondary organic aerosol in a regional air quality model using the statistical oxidation model – Part 2: Assessing the influence of vapor wall losses
| null | 2,015
|
cc-by
| 18,233
|
Correspondence to: Christopher D. Cappa (cdcappa@ucdavis.edu) Correspondence to: Christopher D. Cappa (cdcappa@ucdavis.edu) Received: 21 October 2015 – Published in Atmos. Chem. Phys. Discuss.: 3 November 2015
Revised: 29 January 2016 – Accepted: 19 February 2016 – Published: 9 March 2016 Abstract. The influence of losses of organic vapors to cham-
ber walls during secondary organic aerosol (SOA) formation
experiments has recently been established. Here, the influ-
ence of such losses on simulated ambient SOA concentra-
tions and properties is assessed in the University of Califor-
nia at Davis / California Institute of Technology (UCD/CIT)
regional air quality model using the statistical oxidation
model (SOM) for SOA. The SOM was fit to laboratory cham-
ber data both with and without accounting for vapor wall
losses following the approach of Zhang et al. (2014). Two va-
por wall-loss scenarios are considered when fitting of SOM
to chamber data to determine best-fit SOM parameters, one
with “low” and one with “high” vapor wall-loss rates to
approximately account for the current range of uncertainty
in this process. Simulations were run using these different
parameterizations (scenarios) for both the southern Califor-
nia/South Coast Air Basin (SoCAB) and the eastern United
States (US). Accounting for vapor wall losses leads to sub-
stantial increases in the simulated SOA concentrations from
volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in both domains, by fac-
tors of ∼2–5 for the low and ∼5–10 for the high scenar-
ios. The magnitude of the increase scales approximately in-
versely with the absolute SOA concentration of the no loss
scenario. In SoCAB, the predicted SOA fraction of total or- ganic aerosol (OA) increases from ∼0.2 (no) to ∼0.5 (low)
and to ∼0.7 (high), with the high vapor wall-loss simula-
tions providing best general agreement with observations. In
the eastern US, the SOA fraction is large in all cases but in-
creases further when vapor wall losses are accounted for. The
total OA / 1CO ratio captures the influence of dilution on
SOA concentrations. The simulated OA / 1CO in SoCAB
(specifically, at Riverside, CA) is found to increase substan-
tially during the day only for the high vapor wall-loss sce-
nario, which is consistent with observations and indicative of
photochemical production of SOA. Simulated O : C atomic
ratios for both SOA and for total OA increase when vapor
wall losses are accounted for, while simulated H : C atomic
ratios decrease. Correspondence to: Christopher D. Cappa (cdcappa@ucdavis.edu) The agreement between simulations and ob-
servations of both the absolute values and the diurnal profile
of the O : C and H : C atomic ratios for total OA was greatly
improved when vapor wall-losses were accounted for. These
results overall demonstrate that vapor wall losses in cham-
bers have the potential to exert a large influence on simu-
lated ambient SOA concentrations, and further suggest that
accounting for such effects in models can explain a number
of different observations and model–measurement discrep-
ancies. Christopher D. Cappa1, Shantanu H. Jathar2, Michael J. Kleeman1, Kenneth S. Docherty3, Jose L. Jimenez4,
John H. Seinfeld5, and Anthony S. Wexler1 1Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of California, Davis, CA, USA
2Department of Mechanical Engineering, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, USA
3Alion Science and Technology, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
4Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences and Department Chemistry and Biochemistry 1Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of California, Davis, CA, USA
2Department of Mechanical Engineering, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, USA
3Ali
S i
d T
h
l
R
h T i
l P k NC USA p
g
g,
y,
3Alion Science and Technology, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA 3Alion Science and Technology, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA
4Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences and Department Chemistry and Biochemistry,
University of Colorado, Boulder, CO, USA gy
g
4Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences and Department Chemistry and Biochemistry,
University of Colorado, Boulder, CO, USA y
5Division of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering and Division of Engineering and Applied Science,
California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA 5Division of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering and Division of Engineering and Applied Science,
California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA 1
Introduction Particulate organic matter, or organic aerosol (OA), is de-
rived from primary emissions or from secondary chemical
production in the atmosphere from the oxidation of volatile
organic compounds (VOCs). OA makes up a substantial frac-
tion of atmospheric submicron particulate matter (Zhang et
al., 2007), influencing the atmospheric fate and impact of
PM on regional and global scales. Gas-phase oxidation of
VOCs leads to the formation of oxygenated product species
that can condense onto existing particles or nucleate with
other species to form new particles (e.g. Ziemann and Atkin-
son, 2012). Much of the understanding regarding the forma-
tion of secondary organic aerosol (SOA) via condensation
has been derived from experiments conducted in laboratory
chambers. In a typical experiment, a precursor VOC is added
to the chamber and exposed to an oxidant (e.g OH, O3 or
NO3). As both the precursor VOC and the oxidation prod-
ucts react with the oxidant, SOA is formed. The amount of
SOA formed per amount of precursor reacted (i.e. the SOA
mass yield) can then be quantified (e.g. Odum et al., 1996). Such SOA yield measurements form the basis of most pa-
rameterizations of SOA formation in regional air quality and
global chemical-transport and climate models (Tsigaridis et
al., 2014). However, too often simulated SOA concentra-
tions underestimate observed values, especially in polluted
regions, and sometimes dramatically so (Heald et al., 2005;
Volkamer et al., 2006; Ensberg et al., 2014). There have been
various efforts to account for model–measurement dispari-
ties including, most notably, (i) the addition of new SOA
precursors in the form of so-called semi-volatile and inter-
mediate volatility organic compounds, S/IVOCs, including
treating primary organic aerosol as semi-volatile (Robinson
et al., 2007); (ii) the addition of ad hoc “ageing” schemes on
top of existing parameterizations of SOA from VOCs (Lane
et al., 2008b; Tsimpidi et al., 2010; Dzepina et al., 2011);
(iii) updating of aromatic SOA yields (Dzepina et al., 2009);
and (iv) production of SOA in the aqueous phase in aerosol–
water, clouds and fogs (Ervens et al., 2011). More recently,
concerns over the influence of vapor wall losses on the exper-
imental chamber data used to develop the parameterizations
have arisen (Matsunaga and Ziemann, 2010; Zhang et al.,
2014). C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3042 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model tions. Indeed, Zhang et al. (2014) observed that SOA yields
from toluene + OH photooxidation depend explicitly on the
seed particle surface area, all other conditions being equal. They interpreted these observations using a dynamic model
of particle growth coupled with a parameterizable gas-phase
chemical mechanism, the statistical oxidation model (SOM;
Cappa and Wilson, 2012). They determined that substantial
vapor wall losses were most likely the cause of this depen-
dence, with biases of up to a factor of ∼4 for these ex-
periments. Further, they estimated for this system that the
vapor wall-loss rate coefficient (kwall) was ∼2 × 10−4 s−1
for their 25 m3 chamber. This value of kwall is in reasonable
agreement both with theoretical expectations – so long as the
vapor-wall accommodation coefficient (αwall) is > 10−5 – and
with results of Ziemann and colleagues (Matsunaga and Zie-
mann, 2010; Yeh and Ziemann, 2015), who estimated kwall
∼6 × 10−4 s−1 for their 8 m3 chamber. Kokkola et al. (2014)
have also suggested vapor wall losses can impact SOA yields,
although they determined a much larger kwall of ∼10−2 s−1
for their 4 m3 chamber. Recent direct measurements of kwall
for a range of oxidized VOCs (OVOCs), produced from reac-
tions of VOCs in traditional chambers, suggest that kwall can
vary by an order of magnitude (∼2 × 10−6–3 × 10−5 s−1)
and that kwall is dependent on the OVOC vapor pressure
(Zhang et al., 2015); such low kwall values imply that the αwall
is < 10−5 and controls the rate of vapor loss to the walls. Published by Copernicus Publications on behalf of the European Geosciences Union. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 2.2
Statistical oxidation model for SOA SOA formation from six VOC classes was simulated using
the statistical oxidation model (Cappa and Wilson, 2012;
Cappa et al., 2013), which was recently implemented in the
UCD/CIT model (Jathar et al., 2015a). The VOC classes
considered are long alkanes, benzene, high-yield aromatics
(i.e. toluene), low-yield aromatics (i.e. m-xylene), isoprene
and terpenes (including both mono- and sesquiterpenes). SOM is a parameterizable model that simulates the multi-
generational oxidation of the product species formed from
reaction of the SOA precursor VOCs. In SOM, a “species”
is defined as a molecule with a specific number of carbon
and oxygen atoms (NC and NO, respectively), and where
the VOC-specific properties of these SOM species are de-
termined through fitting to laboratory observations. Reac-
tions of a SOM species lead to either functionalization (i.e. addition of oxygen atoms while conserving the number of
carbon atoms) or fragmentation (i.e. the production of two
species, which individually have fewer carbon atoms but
where the total carbon is conserved, and where each new
species adds one additional oxygen atom). The particular
tunable parameters in SOM are the probability of adding
one, two, three or four oxygen atoms per reaction, referred
to as pXO; the decrease in vapor pressure per added oxygen,
referred to as 1LVP; and the probability of fragmentation,
which is related to the O : C atomic ratio of a given species
as Pfrag = (O : C)mfrag and where mfrag is the tunable param-
eter. SOA formation from the semi-volatile SOM species as-
sumes that partitioning is described according to absorptive
gas-particle partitioning theory (Pankow, 1994), and the gas-
particle mass transfer has been simulated using dynamic par-
titioning (Kleeman and Cass, 2001; Zhang et al., 2014; Jathar
et al., 2015a). The parameters used in the current work have
been determined by fitting them to time-dependent data from
SOA formation experiments conducted in the Caltech cham-
ber both with and without accounting for vapor wall losses
during the fitting process (discussed further below); refer-
ences for the specific experiments considered are provided
in Table S1 in the Supplement. The specific influence of con-
sidering multi-generational ageing on simulated SOA con-
centrations and properties is discussed in a companion paper
(Jathar et al., 2016). 2.2
Statistical oxidation model for SOA The use of the SOM to represent SOA
formation leads to an increase of about a factor of 2.5 or less
in computer processing time required compared to use of the
two-product model. In this study, the SOM SOA model (Cappa and Wilson,
2012) is utilized to examine the influence of vapor wall losses
on simulated SOA concentrations and O : C atomic ratios in
a 3-D regional air quality model, specifically the University
of California at Davis / California Institute of Technology
(UCD/CIT) (Kleeman and Cass, 2001). What distinguishes
the present approach is that the potential influence of vapor
wall losses is inherently accounted for during the develop-
ment of the SOM SOA parameterization (Zhang et al., 2014). This can be contrasted with a simple scaling of an exist-
ing parameterization. The current approach allows for more
detailed characterization of different precursor species, reac-
tion conditions (e.g. NOx sensitivities) and the complex in-
terplay of various timescales (reaction, gas/wall partitioning
and gas/particle partitioning). This also allows for examina-
tion of the extent to which different assumptions regarding
the value of kwall (i.e. the first-order rate constant for vapor
loss to chamber walls) during development of the SOA pa-
rameterization impact simulations of ambient SOA concen-
trations. Further, the SOM framework simulates O : C atomic
ratios in addition to OA mass concentrations, and thus al-
lows for more detailed assessment of the simulated OA and
comparison with observations. Our results demonstrate that
accounting for vapor wall losses can have a substantial im-
pact on simulated SOA concentrations and suggest that there
may be regionally specific differences. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model in the eastern US (36 km × 36 km) to account for the differ-
ent domain sizes. creasing the yields of the semi-volatile products from their
originally parameterized values increases the simulated SOA
concentration, but quantitative interpretation of the results is
difficult. This is an especially important consideration given
that different SOA systems may exhibit different sensitivi-
ties to vapor wall losses, owing to differences in the product
species volatility distribution and the extent to which multi-
generational ageing influences the SOA formation. More ro-
bust assessment of the influence of vapor wall losses on sim-
ulated SOA concentrations in regional air quality models is
thus needed. 1
Introduction The influence of erroneously low SOA yields due to
vapor wall losses on simulated SOA concentrations in three-
dimensional (3-D) regional models and properties is the fo-
cus of the current work. p
Although the exact value of kwall is likely chamber-specific
(which likely contributes to some of the abovementioned
variability in kwall) and thus the exact influence of vapor
wall losses on chamber SOA measurements remains some-
what uncertain, the preponderance of evidence suggests that
such effects are important. Existing SOA parameterizations
have typically not been determined with explicit accounting
for vapor wall losses. Consequently, they likely underesti-
mate actual SOA formation in the atmosphere where walls
are much less important (although dry deposition of vapors
may still be a factor; Hodzic et al., 2014). Two recent ef-
forts have attempted to estimate the influence of vapor wall
losses on SOA concentrations in the atmosphere (Baker et
al., 2015; Hayes et al., 2015). One of the studies (Baker
et al., 2015) builds on the existing two-product parameteri-
zation of SOA formation in the Community Multiscale Air
Quality (CMAQ) model and simply scales the yields of the
semi-volatile products up by factors of 4. In the two-product
model, a given VOC reacts to form two semi-volatile prod-
ucts that partition to the condensed phase. The semi-volatile
products are formed with mass yields, yi, and partitioning co-
efficients, Ki, that have been determined by fitting the model
to data from chamber experiments in which vapor wall losses
were not accounted for. The other study (Hayes et al., 2015)
used a similar yield-scaling approach, but within the volatil-
ity basis set (VBS) four-product framework to represent SOA
formation, and they scaled the mass yields for only the semi-
volatile product species from aromatics. Not surprisingly,
these simple ad hoc scaling methods demonstrated that in- Recent observations have demonstrated that organic va-
pors can be lost to Teflon chamber walls, and that the extent
of loss is related to the compound vapor pressures with lower
vapor pressure compounds partitioning more strongly to the
walls than higher vapor pressure compounds (Matsunaga and
Ziemann, 2010; Kokkola et al., 2014; Krechmer et al., 2015;
Yeh and Ziemann, 2015; Zhang et al., 2015). These results
suggest that vapor wall losses during SOA formation ex-
periments could potentially bias observed SOA concentra- www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 3043 2.1
Air quality model Regional air quality simulations were performed using the
UCD/CIT chemical-transport model (Kleeman and Cass,
2001) for two geographical domains: (i) the Southern Cal-
ifornia Air Basin (SoCAB) and (ii) the eastern United States
(US). Details regarding the general model configuration and
emissions inventory used have been previously discussed
(Jathar et al., 2015a), and the reader is referred to that work
for further information. Details specific to the current work
are provided in the following sections. Model simulations
were run for SoCAB from 20 July to 2 August 2005 and for
the eastern US from 20 August to 2 September 2006. Model
spatial resolution was higher in SoCAB (8 km × 8 km) than Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 2.3.2
Two-product model Ideally, SOA levels from the SOM-based simulations can
be compared with similar results based on the commonly
used two-product model. To do so involves determining new
parameters for the two-product model in which vapor wall
losses are explicitly accounted for. Therefore, vapor wall-
loss-corrected SOA yield curves (i.e. [SOA] vs. [1HC],
where 1HC is the concentration of reacted hydrocarbon)
were generated with SOM using the parameters determined
by fitting SOM to the original chamber data when kwall > 0,
but now where kwall is set to zero. The two-product model
could then be fit to these “corrected” yield curves to deter-
mine vapor wall-loss-corrected yields and partitioning co-
efficients. These new fits would inherently account for the
influence of vapor wall loss since the two-product model
is being fit to the corrected “wall-less” data and thus dif-
fer from ad hoc scaling of yields. However, it was deter-
mined that the two-product fits were not sufficiently robust
across the entire suite of compounds and vapor wall-loss
conditions considered to be implemented in the atmospheric
model. An example for SOA from dodecane + OH under
low-NOx reaction conditions is shown in Fig. S2. We have
determined that this lack of robustness is a result of the lim-
ited dynamic range of the two-product model. This can be
contrasted with the SOM, which includes many more species
that span a wider, more continuous volatility range, making it
more flexible when fitting the laboratory data. More specif-
ically, the SOA concentrations from the chamber observa-
tions, both uncorrected and corrected, ranged from ∼1 to
500 µg m−3, often with few data points at concentrations less
than ∼10 µg m−3. Thus, when fits were performed, incon-
sistent behavior between the different vapor wall-loss condi-
tions was obtained over the atmospherically relevant concen-
tration range (∼0.1–20 µg m−3). Attempts were made to fit
the two-product model over a restricted concentration range
or to fit using log([SOA]) instead of [SOA]. However, neither An important aspect of vapor wall loss is that the impact it
has on SOA concentrations is dependent upon the timescale
associated with vapor-particle equilibration (τv-p; McVay et
al., 2014; Zhang et al., 2014). The τv-p is related to the ac-
commodation coefficient associated with vapor condensation
on particles, αparticle. Above a vapor-particle accommodation
coefficient of αparticle ∼0.1 variations in the exact value of
αparticle does not influence the effects of vapor wall losses. 2.3
Accounting for vapor wall loss et al. (2013) and Zhang et al. (2014). Observed suspended
particle concentrations have been corrected only for physi-
cal deposition on chamber walls, which is appropriate since
vapor wall losses are accounted for separately by SOM. Best-
fit values for the SOM parameters for the base case (SOM-
no) are given in Jathar et al. (2015a) and values for SOM-
low and SOM-high determined here are given in Table S1,
along with the sources of the experimental data. Parame-
ters have been separately determined for experiments con-
ducted under low-NOx and high-NOx conditions since the
SOA yields differ. Example results that illustrate the influ-
ence of vapor wall losses on simulated SOA yields are pre-
sented in Fig. S1 in the Supplement for box model simu-
lations that have been conducted using the best-fit parame-
ters determined for toluene SOA (low-NOx conditions), but
where the simulations are run assuming there are no walls
(i.e. by setting kwall = 0). 2.3.1
SOM Vapor wall losses have been accounted for using SOM, as
detailed in Zhang et al. (2014). Vapor wall loss is treated
as a reversible, absorptive process with vapor uptake spec-
ified using a first-order rate coefficient (kwall) and the des-
orption rate related to the effective saturation concentration,
C∗, of the organic species and the effective absorbing mass
of the walls (Matsunaga and Ziemann, 2010). Unique SOM
fits (i.e. values of mfrag, 1LVP and pXO) have been deter-
mined for different assumed values of kwall. Best-fit values
are provided in Table S1. It should be noted that the influ-
ence of vapor wall losses is inherent in the fit parameters,
and in the absence of walls (i.e. in the atmosphere) the pre-
dicted SOA formed will be larger when the fits account for
vapor wall losses. A base case set of parameters with no va-
por wall losses assumed during fitting (termed SOM-no) was
determined using kwall = 0. In Zhang et al. (2014), an op-
timal value of kwall = 2 × 10−4 s−1 was determined for the
California Institute of Technology chamber based on simul-
taneous fitting of the SOM to a set of toluene photooxidation
experiments conducted at different seed particle concentra-
tions. Unlike in Zhang et al. (2014), the values of kwall used
here were not determined during model fitting. This is be-
cause the absolute value of kwall is not well constrained by
a single experiment, and the simulations require vapor wall-
loss-corrected parameters for VOCs besides toluene. There-
fore, two specific bounding cases that account for vapor wall
loss are instead considered based on the results from Zhang
et al. (2014). Specifically, values of kwall = 1 × 10−4 and
2.5 × 10−4 s−1 are considered, corresponding to a low va-
por wall-loss case (SOM-low) and high vapor wall-loss case
(SOM-high), respectively. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3044 2.4
Primary organic aerosol and IVOCs Primary organic aerosol (POA) derived from anthropogenic
(e.g. vehicular activities, food cooking) or pyrogenic (e.g. wood combustion) sources are simulated assuming that the
POA is non-volatile. This is the standard assumption in the
CMAQ model framework (Simon and Bhave, 2011), and
thus is adopted here. It is known that some POA is semi-
volatile, not non-volatile as assumed here. Had POA been
treated within a semi-volatile framework (Robinson et al.,
2007), such that some fraction of the POA can evaporate (i.e. SVOCs) and react within the gas-phase and be converted to
SOA (sometimes improperly referred to as “oxidized POA”),
then the amount of POA would likely decrease (due to evap-
oration) and the amount of simulated SOA would increase
(due to condensation of oxidized SVOC vapors); the total
OA concentration (POA + SOA) may or may not increase
as a result, depending on the details of the parameteriza-
tion and the atmospheric conditions. Additionally, nearly all
modeling efforts in which POA is treated as semi-volatile
have also included contributions from gas-phase IVOCs as
an added class of SOA precursors; these two issues are rarely
implemented independently in models, although their contri-
butions can be separately tracked. Whereas simply treating
POA as semi-volatile may or may not lead to an increase in
the total OA concentration, the introduction of new SOA pre-
cursor mass in the form of IVOCs will inevitably lead to pro-
duction of more SOA in the model. The relative importance
of IVOCs will depend on the amount of added IVOC mass
and the propensity of these IVOC vapors to form SOA in the
model (i.e. their effective SOA yield). In the current study,
we do not explicitly consider the potential for IVOCs to con-
tribute to the ambient SOA burden, focusing instead on how
vapor wall losses influence SOA formation from VOCs. We
will aim to consider contributions from IVOCs and how they
are influenced by vapor wall losses in future studies. Regard-
less, the implications of our particular treatment (non-volatile
POA excluding IVOCs) are discussed below. y
(
)total
As noted above, unique sets of SOM parameters were fit to
experiments conducted under either low- or high-NOx con-
ditions assuming a particular value for kwall. Since each sim-
ulation used a single set of SOM fit parameters (e.g. 2.5
Model simulations and outputs effort led to sufficiently robust results (although both did lead
to improvements). This null result suggests that simple scal-
ing of two-product yields (Baker et al., 2015) to account for
the effects of vapor wall losses may not be appropriate. This
may similarly apply to scaling of VBS parameters (Hayes et
al., 2015), although the greater flexibility of the VBS (com-
monly implemented with four products, instead of two) can
potentially allow for unique “wall-less” fits to be determined
(Hodzic et al., 2015). The extent to which such alternative
methods can robustly account for vapor wall losses that are
computationally less intensive than SOM will be explored in
future work. Six individual model simulations have been carried out to
determine the spatial distribution of SOA concentrations. Each simulation used one of the SOM parameterizations,
i.e. SOM-no, SOM-low or SOM-high with either the low-
or high-NOx parameters. Each precursor VOC is allowed
to react with either OH, O3 or NO3 as characterized by an
oxidant-specific rate coefficient, although the products and
product distributions of the first-generation products are as-
sumed to be oxidant independent. This simplification is iden-
tical to that employed in CMAQv4.7 (Carlton et al., 2010). Reactions of subsequent oxidized SOM products then occur
only via reaction with OH radicals according to the SOM
parameterization associated with that precursor VOC (as de-
termined by fitting the photooxidation experiments). Besides
the absolute SOA concentration, SOM also allows for ex-
plicit calculation of the average (and precursor-specific) O : C
and H : C atomic ratios and of the SOA volatility distribution,
which characterizes the distribution of particulate and gas-
phase mass concentrations with respect to C∗. To estimate
the O : C of the total OA (POA + SOA), it is assumed that the
non-volatile POA has a constant O : C = 0.2 and H : C = 2.0
(Ng et al., 2011). Since the simulated (O : C)total is just a
combination of (O : C)SOA and (O : C)POA, assuming a differ-
ent value for (O : C)POA would change the absolute value of
(O : C)total but not any dependence on simulation conditions. This is similarly true for (H : C)total. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3045 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 2.3.2
Two-product model This is not to say that vapor wall losses have no influence
on the amount of SOA formed when αparticle ≥0.1, only that
the net impact does not depend on αparticle. Below this value,
vapor-particle equilibration is slowed and the effects of loss
of vapors to the walls are accentuated. Thus, a conservative
estimate that minimizes the influence of vapor wall losses on
SOA formation is obtained using αparticle ≥0.1. Here, data
fitting and parameter determination was performed assuming
that αparticle = 1, and is thus a conservative estimate. p
SOM was fit to time-dependent SOA formation experi-
ments conducted in the California Institute of Technology
chamber, following the methodologies described in Cappa Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3046 Figure 1. 14-day averaged SOA concentrations, in µg m−3, for (a) SoCAB and (d) the eastern US for the SOM-no simulations. The averaging
time periods are from 20 July to 2 August 2005 for SoCAB and from 20 August to 2 September 2006 for the eastern US. Panels (b, e) show
the ratio between the SOA concentrations for the SOM-low and the SOM-no simulations and panels (c, f) show the ratio between the SOM-
high and SOM-no simulations. Results shown in all panels are the average of the low- and high-NOx simulations. Note that the color scale
for the absolute SOA concentration is continuous whereas the color scale in the ratio plots is discrete. Figure 1. 14-day averaged SOA concentrations, in µg m−3, for (a) SoCAB and (d) the eastern US for the SOM-no simulations. The averaging
time periods are from 20 July to 2 August 2005 for SoCAB and from 20 August to 2 September 2006 for the eastern US. Panels (b, e) show
the ratio between the SOA concentrations for the SOM-low and the SOM-no simulations and panels (c, f) show the ratio between the SOM-
high and SOM-no simulations. Results shown in all panels are the average of the low- and high-NOx simulations. Note that the color scale
for the absolute SOA concentration is continuous whereas the color scale in the ratio plots is discrete. ing the average from the simulations carried out using the
low- and high-NOx parameterizations (Fig. 1a–b; again, the
low- and high-NOx designations here refer only to the ex-
perimental conditions under which the SOM parameters
were determined, not the actual NOx conditions in the
UCD/CIT model). For SoCAB, predicted SOA concentra-
tions are largest in and around downtown Los Angeles and
in the forested regions of the Los Padres National Forest
and the Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area
in the northwest (NW) quadrant. The spatial distribution of
SOA is similar to that obtained using the conventional two-
product SOA parameterization (Jathar et al., 2015a, b). For
the eastern US, predicted SOA concentrations are largest in
the southeast, in particular around Atlanta, Georgia. Overall,
the simulated SOA concentrations with the SOM-no model
are larger in the eastern US than in SoCAB, reflecting the
relatively strong influence of biogenic emissions in this re-
gion. 3
Results and discussion 3.1
General influence of vapor wall loss on simulated
SOA C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model it is experimentally established that the NOx condition (and
more specifically, the NO / HO2 ratio) influences SOA yields
for both aromatic and biogenic compounds (e.g. Ng et al.,
2007a, b). For most VOCs, the functional dependence of the
SOA yield on the VOC / NOx ratio or the NO / HO2 ratio is
not well established, making it difficult to understand how
well the interpolation methods work (SOA formation from
isoprene is a notable exception; e.g. Xu et al., 2014). Further,
modeled NO / HO2 ratios may be off by orders of magnitude,
most likely due to poor representation of HO2 concentrations
(Carlton et al., 2010), making it difficult to understand how
well the conditions of the laboratory translate to the model
environment. By considering the low- and high-NOx param-
eterizations separately, i.e. the approach used in the current
study, bounds on the overall influence of NOx on the simu-
lated SOA can be established. However, this approach will
not capture how the simulated SOA may vary due to spatial
and temporal variations in the model NOx and oxidant fields. Future efforts will aim to account for the NOx dependence of
SOA formation in a more continuously varying manner, and
to account for recent updates to the detailed isoprene oxida-
tion mechanism (Pye et al., 2013). The influence of vapor wall losses on the simulated ambi-
ent SOA concentrations is illustrated in Fig. 1c–f as the ratio
between the SOA from the SOM-low and SOM-high simu-
lations to the SOM-no (no wall losses) simulation. This ratio
will be referred to generally as the wall loss impact (Rwall,low
or Rwall,high). Values of Rwall larger than 1 indicate that ac-
counting for vapor wall losses as part of the SOM parame-
terization leads to an increase in the predicted SOA concen-
trations. In the SoCAB, the Rwall,low varies from 1.5 to 4.5,
while the Rwall,high varies from 3 to more than 10. The largest
ratios (indicating the largest impact of accounting for vapor
wall losses) tend to occur in more remote locations as this 2.4
Primary organic aerosol and IVOCs SOM-no
fit to low-NOx experiments), the SOA NOx parameterization
used in a given simulation is independent of the actual simu-
lated ambient NOx concentrations or NO / HO2 ratio. Conse-
quently, comparison between the simulations conducted us-
ing the low- and high-NOx parameterizations gives an indi-
cation of the range expected from variability in NOx levels,
and the average between the two simulations provides a rep-
resentation that is intermediate between these two extremes. Unless otherwise specified, reported values are for the av-
erage of the simulations run using the low- and high-NOx
parameterizations. This approach towards understanding the
influence of NOx is different than some previous approaches
that attempted to account for the SOA NOx dependence in a
more continuously variable manner. For example, some sim-
ulations using the two-product approach have used the in-
stantaneous NO / HO2 ratios predicted by the model to al-
low for distinguishing between low- and high-NOx products
and SOA yields for aromatic VOCs (Carlton et al., 2010). Similarly, instantaneous VOC / NOx ratios have been used
with VBS-type models for aromatic VOCs to allow for in-
terpolation between the two regimes (Lane et al., 2008a). Typically, these efforts have not considered the NOx depen-
dence of monoterpene and sesquiterpene yields even though www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Mod C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model There is again a general, although not exact, in-
verse relationship between Rwall and the absolute SOA con-
centrations; the greater scatter in the eastern US compared to
SoCAB at low SOA concentrations likely reflects the larger
spatial range considered. The smallest simulated Rwall val-
ues occur across the southeast and up the eastern seaboard
(Rwall,low ∼2.5 and Rwall,high ∼5) while the largest values
occur over the Great Lakes and Michigan, Nebraska, and the
Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic Ocean; there is a steep increase
going from land to sea. If Rwall values are calculated using
the simulated SOA concentrations from either the low-NOx
or high-NOx parameterizations individually, as opposed to
the average values used above, very similar results are ob-
tained (Fig. S3). 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
10
2
Rwall
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
[SOA]SOM-no (µg m
-3)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
10
2
Rwall
5
4
3
2
1
0
[SOA]SOM–no (µg m
-3)
(a)
(b)
SOM–low/SOM–no
SOM–high/SOM–no
SoCAB
Eastern US
SOM–low/SOM–no
SOM–high/SOM–no Regional air quality models have historically overesti-
mated the urban-to-regional gradient in total OA concen-
trations. Robinson et al. (2007) showed that the simu-
lated urban-to-regional gradient could be reduced and made
more consistent with observations by treating POA as semi-
volatile and adding SVOCs and IVOCs as SOA-forming
species. The current results suggest a complementary ex-
planation, namely that the urban-to-regional gradient, can
be reduced when vapor wall losses are accounted for since
Rwall generally increases with decreasing SOA concentration
and since POA is identical between the different model pa-
rameterizations. Consequently, larger Rwall are found outside
of the major source regions, which decreases the urban-to-
regional contrast. Indeed, the ratio between the predicted av-
erage SOA in downtown LA (urban) to that over the Pacific
Ocean near the coast of LA (regional) and decreases from
2.3 (SOM-no) to 1.5 (SOM-low) to 1.3 (SOM-high), for ex-
ample. Additionally, it has been suggested that the typical
underprediction of SOA by air quality and chemical trans-
port models relative to observations might increase with pho-
tochemical age (Volkamer et al., 2006). C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model The current results
suggest the possibility that the SOA concentrations in more
remote (lower concentration) regions may be underestimated
in models to a greater extent in a relative sense than in high-
source (higher concentration) regions due to a lack of ac-
counting for vapor wall losses, although the absolute differ-
ences in SOA concentrations may be larger in regions where
absolute concentrations are larger. Figure 2. Variation of the ratio between simulated SOA concen-
trations from SOM-low (red) and SOM-high (blue) simulations to
SOM-no simulations for (a) SoCAB and (b) the eastern US as a
function of the absolute SOA concentration from the SOM-no sim-
ulations. Results shown are the average of the low- and high-NOx
simulations. Individual data points are shown along with box and
whisker plots. and ∼0.4–0.9 for the eastern US. This difference between
regions results from the substantial POA emissions in So-
CAB and the large emissions of biogenic VOCs across the
southeast US. Consequently, accounting for vapor wall losses
has a larger impact on the absolute total OA (SOA + POA)
concentrations in the eastern US than it does in SoCAB, al-
though the impact in both regions is substantial. For SoCAB,
the predicted 24 h average fSOA range increases to ∼0.2–0.5
for SOM-low and to ∼0.4–0.8 for SOM-high simulations. These model results can be compared with measurements
from the 2005 SOAR field study in Riverside, CA, which
overlaps with the simulation period. The observed fSOA dur-
ing SOAR ranged from ∼0.6 in early morning to ∼0.9 in
midday, with a campaign-average of ∼0.78 (Docherty et al.,
2011). Measurements at Pasadena, CA, during a later time
period, June 2010 during the CalNex study, give similar re- C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3047 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
10
2
Rwall
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
[SOA]SOM-no (µg m
-3)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
10
2
Rwall
5
4
3
2
1
0
[SOA]SOM–no (µg m
-3)
(a)
(b)
SOM–low/SOM–no
SOM–high/SOM–no
SoCAB
Eastern US
SOM–low/SOM–no
SOM–high/SOM–no
Figure 2. Variation of the ratio between simulated SOA concen-
trations from SOM-low (red) and SOM-high (blue) simulations to
SOM-no simulations for (a) SoCAB and (b) the eastern US as a
function of the absolute SOA concentration from the SOM-no sim-
ulations. Results shown are the average of the low- and high-NOx
simulations. Individual data points are shown along with box and
whisker plots. is where concentrations are lower (Fig. 2). However, the im-
pact is still large in downtown Los Angeles and the greater
LA region (average Rwall,low ∼2.5 and Rwall,high ∼5). In the
eastern US, the simulated Rwall vary over a similar range as
in SoCAB, with Rwall,low varying from 1.5 to 5 and Rwall,high
from 3 to 10. There is again a general, although not exact, in-
verse relationship between Rwall and the absolute SOA con-
centrations; the greater scatter in the eastern US compared to
SoCAB at low SOA concentrations likely reflects the larger
spatial range considered. The smallest simulated Rwall val-
ues occur across the southeast and up the eastern seaboard
(Rwall,low ∼2.5 and Rwall,high ∼5) while the largest values
occur over the Great Lakes and Michigan, Nebraska, and the
Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic Ocean; there is a steep increase
going from land to sea. If Rwall values are calculated using
the simulated SOA concentrations from either the low-NOx
or high-NOx parameterizations individually, as opposed to
the average values used above, very similar results are ob-
tained (Fig. S3). is where concentrations are lower (Fig. 2). However, the im-
pact is still large in downtown Los Angeles and the greater
LA region (average Rwall,low ∼2.5 and Rwall,high ∼5). In the
eastern US, the simulated Rwall vary over a similar range as
in SoCAB, with Rwall,low varying from 1.5 to 5 and Rwall,high
from 3 to 10. 3.2
OA composition and concentrations The simulated fraction of total OA that is SOA (fSOA) is
substantially smaller in SoCAB than in the eastern US, es-
pecially the southeast US (Fig. 3). The predicted fSOA val-
ues vary spatially within a given region, with the SOM-no
simulations in the general range of ∼0.1–0.3 for SoCAB www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ 3.1
General influence of vapor wall loss on simulated
SOA The spatial distribution of the SOM-no model SOA con-
centrations is shown for SoCAB and the eastern US us- Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model For the eastern US STN sites, an av-
erage of the SOM-low and SOM-high simulations provides
the best agreement. For the eastern US IMPROVE sites, the
SOM-low simulations provide the best agreement, although
with some overprediction. (If the eastern US STN and IM-
PROVE measurements do underestimate the actual OA con-
centrations, the degree to which accounting for vapor wall
losses improves the model–measurement comparison will in-
crease.) The simulated anthropogenic–biogenic SOA split is
found to be approximately the same at sites within both net-
works (e.g. Fig. 4). This occurs even though the IMPROVE
sites tend to be more remote than the STN sites in the eastern
US, and reflects the regional character of SOA in that region. Ultimately, the comparisons suggest that accounting for va-
por wall losses can improve model–measurement agreement,
although there are differences in terms of whether the SOM-
high simulations or SOM-low simulations produce the best
agreement. That the OA concentrations for the SOM-high
simulations remains slightly lower than the observations for
STN sites in SoCAB could potentially result from the non-
volatile treatment of POA, the exclusion of IVOCs in the cur-
rent model or uncertainty in the POA emission inventory. The simulated total OA concentrations are compared to
ambient OA measurements made at the STN (Speciated
Trends Network) and IMPROVE (Interagency Monitoring
of Protected Visual Environments; The Visibility Informa-
tion Exchange Web System (VIEWS 2.0), 2015) air quality
monitoring sites in SoCAB and the eastern US; the regional
differences in fSOA should be kept in mind for this model–
measurement comparison. A map of sites is shown in Fig. S4. STN sites tend to be more urban and have higher OA con-
centrations compared to IMPROVE sites, which tend to be
more remote. OA concentrations are estimated as the mea-
sured organic carbon (OC) concentrations times 2.1 for IM-
PROVE sites and as 1.6 × ([OC]–0.5 µg m−3) for STN sites
(Turpin and Lim, 2001). The −0.5 µg m−3 offset for the STN
sites arises because the IMPROVE data are both artifact and
blank corrected while the STN data are only artifact cor-
rected (Subramanian et al., 2004). The difference in scaling
factors (2.1 vs. 1.6) approximately accounts for differences
in the OA/OC conversion between more urban and more ru-
ral networks (Turpin and Lim, 2001). C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model PROVE monitoring networks. Fractional bias is calculated
as: sults with the campaign-average fSOA = 0.6 (Hayes et al.,
2013). (Note that here we are equating SOA with the “oxy-
genated organic aerosol,” or OOA factors that are obtained
from positive matrix factorization of the measured OA time
series, and equating POA with the sum of hydrocarbon-like
OA (HOA), cooking-derived OA (COA), and “local” OA
(LOA).) The SOM-high simulations in SoCAB are most con-
sistent with these observations. Fractional bias = 2
COA,sim −COA,obs
COA,sim + COA,obs
(1) (1) and the NMSE as NMSE =
COA,sim −COA,obs
2
COA,sim × COA,obs
,
(2) (2) For the eastern US, the predicted fSOA range increases
from 0.4–0.9 for SOM-no to ∼0.7–0.9 for SOM-low and
to ∼0.8–1 for SOM-high. These predicted values can be
compared with measurements made at a few locations in the
southeastern US (specifically, sites in Alabama and Georgia),
which show that the fSOA in this region exhibits a strong
seasonal dependence and some spatial variation (Xu et al.,
2015b). The measurements in spring and summer indicate
that the total OA is dominated by SOA, with fSOA mea-
surements ranging from 0.7 to 1 and with the smaller values
observed at the more urban sites. The predicted fSOA from
the SOM-low and SOM-high simulations are most consis-
tent with this range, with the fSOA from the SOM-no simu-
lations being on the low side, especially in comparison with
the more rural sites. where the subscripts sim and obs refer to the simulated and
observed OA concentrations, respectively. The concordance
correlation coefficients (ρc) are calculated as ρc =
2ssim,obs
s2
sim + s2
obs +
COA,sim −COA,obs
2 ,
(3) (3) where COA,sim and COA,obs indicate the mean, s2
sim and s2
obs
are the variance and ssim,obs is the covariance of the simulated
and observed OA concentrations. Scatter plots are shown
in Figs. S5 and S6; many more sites are considered in the
eastern US than in the SoCAB given the larger geograph-
ical domain and distribution of sites. In both regions, the
SOM-no simulations underpredict the STN and IMPROVE
observations, especially in the SoCAB. The negative bias
of the SOM-no simulations is generally improved as va-
por wall losses are accounted for. For both the STN and
IMPROVE sites in the SoCAB the SOM-high simulations
give best agreement. www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 3048 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model Model performance metrics determined for the three simulation groupings (SOM-no, SOM-low and SOM-high) for the low-NOx,
high-NOx and average parameterizations for STN and IMPROVE sites in SoCAB and the eastern US. Fractional bias is calculated as 2
(COA,sim-COA,obs)/(COA,sim + COA,obs) and NMSE as abs[(COA,sim-COA,obs)2/(COA,sim × COA,obs)], and the reported values are the
averages over all data points as percentages. Note that a negative fractional bias indicates observed [SOA] > simulated [SOA], i.e. that the
simulations are underpredicting. ρc are the concordance correlation coefficients from Eq. (3). Southern California
Eastern US
STNa
IMPROVEb
STNa
IMPROVEb,c
Simulation
NOx
Frac. NMSE
ρc
Frac. NMSE
ρc
Frac. NMSE
ρc
Frac. NMSE
ρc
parameterization
Bias
Bias
Bias
Bias
low
−70
88
0.03
−75
114
0.36
−81
206
0.04
−55
105
0.31
SOM-no
high
−61
69
0.02
−60
85
0.41
−58
166
0.12
−24
84
0.48
average
−65
78
0.02
−67
97
0.39
−68
180
0.08
−38
89
0.43
low
−52
64
−0.21
−45
65
0.36
−26
154
0.08
15
85
0.15
SOM-low
high
−39
49
−0.29
−27
47
0.27
−4
171
0.07
38
128
0.10
average
−45
55
−0.25
−36
54
0.32
−14
160
0.08
28
105
0.12
low
−25
51
−0.03
−8
46
0.44
26
236
0.15
69
189
0.40
SOM-high
high
−10
38
−0.08
16
43
0.46
45
298
0.15
86
295
0.25
average
−17
43
−0.05
5
42
0.46
36
265
0.16
79
241
0.31
a Observed [OA] for STN sites estimated as 1.6 ([OC]–0.5 µg m−3). b Observed [OA] for IMPROVE sites estimated as 2.1 [OC]. c Observed [OA] may be biased low by ∼25 % in
the SE US summer due to evaporation after sampling (Kim et al., 2015). CO is relatively long-lived, normalization of the calculated
and observed OA to the concurrent background-corrected
CO helps to minimize the impacts of uncertainties in bound-
ary layer dynamics and accounts for variability in emissions
and transport to some extent (De Gouw and Jimenez, 2009). The background-corrected CO concentration is calculated
as 1[CO] = [CO]–[CO]bgd. The estimated [CO]bgd for the
observations is 105 ppb (with a plausible range from 85 to
125 ppb; Hayes et al., 2013). In contrast, the [CO]bgd for the
model is estimated to be 130 ppb based on the simulated
[CO] over the open ocean west of Los Angeles. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model Given the generally re-
gional character of OA in much of the eastern US, it may be
that the difference in OM/OC (the organic matter to organic
carbon ratio) between the STN and IMPROVE sites may be
smaller than assumed here (most likely with the 1.6 being
too low, leading potentially to an underestimate in the OA at
the STN sites). We note that IMPROVE data may also be bi-
ased low by ∼25 % in the southeast (SE) US summer due to
evaporation after sampling (Kim et al., 2015). The simulations can also be compared with observations
of the OA-to-1CO concentration ratio (OA / 1CO) during
the Study of Organic Aerosols at Riverside (SOAR) cam-
paign (Docherty et al., 2008, 2011), and where 1CO indi-
cates the background-corrected CO concentration. Because Table 1 lists statistical metrics of fractional bias, normal-
ized mean square error (NMSE) and the concordance cor-
relation coefficients that capture model performance for OA
for all simulations for both domains across the STN and IM- www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3049 Figure 3. 14-day averaged fSOA, the ratio between SOA and total OA concentrations, for (top panels, a, b, c) SoCAB and (bottom panels,
d, e, f) the eastern US for the (a, d) SOM-no, (b, e) SOM-low and (c, f) SOM-high simulations. Figure 3. 14-day averaged fSOA, the ratio between SOA and total OA concentrations, for (top panels, a, b, c) SoCAB and (bottom panels,
d, e, f) the eastern US for the (a, d) SOM-no, (b, e) SOM-low and (c, f) SOM-high simulations. Table 1. Model performance metrics determined for the three simulation groupings (SOM-no, SOM-low and SOM-high) for the low-NOx,
high-NOx and average parameterizations for STN and IMPROVE sites in SoCAB and the eastern US. Fractional bias is calculated as 2
(COA,sim-COA,obs)/(COA,sim + COA,obs) and NMSE as abs[(COA,sim-COA,obs)2/(COA,sim × COA,obs)], and the reported values are the
averages over all data points as percentages. Note that a negative fractional bias indicates observed [SOA] > simulated [SOA], i.e. that the
simulations are underpredicting. ρc are the concordance correlation coefficients from Eq. (3). Table 1. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model The ob-
served diurnal profile of OA / 1CO during SOAR exhibits
a distinct peak around midday, corresponding to the peak in photochemical activity. This indicates a substantial in-
fluence of SOA production on the total OA concentration
(Fig. 5; Docherty et al., 2008). The simulated OA / 1CO
diurnal profiles around Riverside for the SOM-high simula-
tions are most consistent with the observations, exhibiting
a distinct peak around midday that is similar to the observa-
tions (Fig. 5). Unlike the observations, the diurnal OA / 1CO
profile for the SOM-no simulation exhibits almost no in-
crease during midday and the SOM-low simulation exhibits
only a slightly larger daytime increase. The slope of a one-
sided linear fit to a graph of the observed [OA] vs. [CO]
during daytime (10:00 to 20:00 LT is 69 ± 2 µg m−3 ppm−1
(Fig. 5) when constrained to go through the assumed CO is relatively long-lived, normalization of the calculated
and observed OA to the concurrent background-corrected
CO helps to minimize the impacts of uncertainties in bound-
ary layer dynamics and accounts for variability in emissions
and transport to some extent (De Gouw and Jimenez, 2009). The background-corrected CO concentration is calculated
as 1[CO] = [CO]–[CO]bgd. The estimated [CO]bgd for the
observations is 105 ppb (with a plausible range from 85 to
125 ppb; Hayes et al., 2013). In contrast, the [CO]bgd for the
model is estimated to be 130 ppb based on the simulated
[CO] over the open ocean west of Los Angeles. The ob-
served diurnal profile of OA / 1CO during SOAR exhibits
a distinct peak around midday, corresponding to the peak www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ 3.3.1
Source/VOC precursor dependence Results
are shown for (top) average, (middle) high-NOx, low-yield and
(bottom) low-NOx, high-yield simulations. Each panel shows re-
sults from the 14-day average (left-to-right) SOM-no, SOM-low
and SOM-high simulations. The average SOA concentration (in
µg m−3) is for each location and simulation is given in parenthe-
ses above each panel. [CO]bgd. This can be compared with the simulation results,
which have constrained slopes of 23.0 ± 0.4, 34.0 ± 0.8 and
55 ± 2 µg m−3 ppm−1 for SOM-no, SOM-low and SOM-
high, respectively (Fig. 5g–i). Clearly the SOM-high simu-
lations are in best overall agreement with the SOAR obser-
vations. However, the maximum in the simulated OA / 1CO
peaks at a smaller value than was observed. The simulated
peak also occurs slightly earlier than the maximum in the ob-
servations, which could be due to discrepancies in the trans-
port to the Riverside site or to too fast SOA formation in
the model. Nonetheless, these results clearly indicate that
accounting for vapor wall losses has the potential to rec-
oncile simulated SOA diurnal behavior with observations. Alternatively or complementarily, daytime increases in the
OA / 1CO ratio from SOA production can be achieved with
the introduction of additional SOA precursor material such
as S/IVOCs (Zhao et al., 2014; Hayes et al., 2015), which
are not considered here. The addition of S/IVOCs would in-
crease the daytime OA / 1CO for all of the simulations. The
magnitude of the increase would depend on the amount of
added S/IVOCs and the properties assigned to the S/IVOCs
regarding their SOA formation timescale and yield. Consid-
eration of SOA from S/IVOCs in the SoCAB using the SOM
framework will be the subject of future work. In SoCAB, the predicted average isoprene SOA fraction
in central LA is relatively large for the SOM-low (36 %)
and SOM-high (47 %) simulations, compared to the SOM-no
simulations (12 %). There is a large difference in SoCAB be-
tween the simulations that use the low-NOx and high-NOx
parameterizations, with the isoprene SOA fractions being
much larger with the high-NOx parameterizations (e.g. 58 %
for high-NOx vs. 36 % for low-NOx for the SOM-high simu-
lations). Measurements at Pasadena during the 2010 CalNex
study did not distinctly identify IEPOX SOA, which is in-
terpreted as the IEPOX SOA contribution being lower than
∼5 % of the OA (Hu et al., 2015). 3.3.1
Source/VOC precursor dependence Accounting for vapor wall losses leads to regionally spe-
cific changes in the simulated contributions from the dif-
ferent VOC classes (e.g. TRP1, ARO1) to the SOA burden,
as illustrated in Fig. 4 for two sites in SoCAB (central Los
Angeles and Riverside) and two in the eastern US (Atlanta
and the Smoky Mountains). Focusing first on contributions
from the biogenic VOCs, at all locations accounting for va-
por wall losses leads to an increase in the fractional contribu-
tion of isoprene SOA, typically at the expense of terpene and
sesquiterpene SOA. This is true for both the low- and high-
NOx simulations. Recent observations suggest that isoprene
SOA produced via the low-NO IEPOX (isoprene epoxydiol)
pathway can be uniquely identified from analysis of aerosol
mass spectrometer measurements when the relative contribu-
tion is sufficiently large (> ∼5 %; e.g. Budisulistiorini et al.,
2013; Hu et al., 2015). This observed IEPOX SOA accounts
for around 30 % (May) and 40 % (August) of total SOA or
around 20 % (May) and 30 % (August) of total OA in Atlanta
in the summer (Xu et al., 2015a), albeit not during the same
time period as simulated here. IEPOX SOA was also found
to account for 17 % of total OA at a rural site in Alabama in
2013 (Hu et al., 2015). The SOM-low and SOM-high sim-
ulation results for Atlanta are most consistent with the ob-
servations, with a predicted isoprene SOA fraction of 27 and
35 %, respectively, compared to only 17 % for the SOM-no
simulations and where the reported values are for the simu-
lations that use the low-NOx parameterizations since this is
the pathway that leads to IEPOX SOA. The related isoprene
OA fractions are 10, 21 and 31 % for the SOM-no, -low and
-high simulations, respectively. (These isoprene SOA frac-
tions change only marginally for SOM-low and SOM-high
simulations when the high-NOx parameterizations are used,
to 25 and 37 %, respectively. The SOM-no simulations ex-
hibit somewhat greater sensitivity to the NOx parameteri-
zation, with the high-NOx parameterization giving an SOA
fraction of 7 %.) Figure 4. Bar charts showing the fractional contribution from the
various VOC precursor classes to the total simulated SOA for two
locations in SoCAB (central Los Angeles and Riverside) and two
in the eastern US (Atlanta and the Smoky Mountains). C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3050 Figure 4. Bar charts showing the fractional contribution from the
various VOC precursor classes to the total simulated SOA for two
locations in SoCAB (central Los Angeles and Riverside) and two
in the eastern US (Atlanta and the Smoky Mountains). Results
are shown for (top) average, (middle) high-NOx, low-yield and
(bottom) low-NOx, high-yield simulations. Each panel shows re-
sults from the 14-day average (left-to-right) SOM-no, SOM-low
and SOM-high simulations. The average SOA concentration (in
µg m−3) is for each location and simulation is given in parenthe-
ses above each panel. www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3051 Figure 5. Simulated and observed diurnal profiles for the OA / 1CO ratio (top panels) at Riverside, CA, during the SOAR-2005 campaign
for (a) SOM-no, (b) SOM-low and (c) SOM-high simulations. For the observations, the mean (solid orange line) and the 1σ variability range
(grey band) are shown for [CO]bgd = 0.105 ppm, and only mean values are shown for [CO]bgd = 0.085 ppm (short dashed orange line) and
[CO]bgd = 0.125 ppm (long dashed orange line). For the simulations, box and whisker plots are shown with the median (red –), mean (blue
squares), lower and upper quartile (boxes), and 9th and 91st percentile (whiskers). The bottom panels (e–f) show scatter plots of [OA] vs. [CO]
for both the ambient measurements (open orange circles) and for the model results (blue circles) for daytime hours (10:00–20:00 LT). The
lines are linear fits where the x axis intercept has been constrained to go through the assumed [CO]bgd (dashed = observed; solid = model). The derived slopes are 69 ± 2 (observed), 23.0 ± 0.4 (SOM-no), 34.0 ± 0.8 (SOM-low) and 55 ± 2 (SOM-high) µg m−3 ppm−1 and where
the uncertainties are fit errors. Figure 5. Simulated and observed diurnal profiles for the OA / 1CO ratio (top panels) at Riverside, CA, during the SOAR-2005 campaign
for (a) SOM-no, (b) SOM-low and (c) SOM-high simulations. For the observations, the mean (solid orange line) and the 1σ variability range
(grey band) are shown for [CO]bgd = 0.105 ppm, and only mean values are shown for [CO]bgd = 0.085 ppm (short dashed orange line) and
[CO]bgd = 0.125 ppm (long dashed orange line). For the simulations, box and whisker plots are shown with the median (red –), mean (blue
squares), lower and upper quartile (boxes), and 9th and 91st percentile (whiskers). The bottom panels (e–f) show scatter plots of [OA] vs. [CO]
for both the ambient measurements (open orange circles) and for the model results (blue circles) for daytime hours (10:00–20:00 LT). The
lines are linear fits where the x axis intercept has been constrained to go through the assumed [CO]bgd (dashed = observed; solid = model). D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model The derived slopes are 69 ± 2 (observed), 23.0 ± 0.4 (SOM-no), 34.0 ± 0.8 (SOM-low) and 55 ± 2 (SOM-high) µg m−3 ppm−1 and where
the uncertainties are fit errors. fied as a uniquely isoprene-derived SOA component, instead
contributing generically to the overall oxygenated OA pool. The concentration of isoprene SOA from specific high-NOx
pathways may, however, be limited at higher temperatures,
such as found in summertime Pasadena, due to thermal de-
composition of intermediate gas-phase species (Worton et
al., 2013), although it is not clear to what extent this influ-
enced the CalNex observations or would have affected the
model results had it been explicitly considered. Additionally,
it should be kept in mind that the ambient NOx concentra-
tions in SoCAB have decreased substantially from 2005 to
2013 (Russell et al., 2012). Thus, although the CalNex mea-
surements do not provide direct support for such a large iso-
prene SOA fraction, they also do not rule it out. and thus accounting for vapor wall losses has a limited influ-
ence on the simulated sesquiterpene SOA concentrations. There are some changes in the anthropogenic fraction of
SOA when vapor wall losses are accounted for. The an-
thropogenic fraction of SOA is defined here as the sum of
the SOA from long alkanes and aromatics, which are emit-
ted from combustion of fossil fuels, divided by the sum of
the total SOA, which additionally includes SOA from iso-
prene, monoterpenes and sesquiterpenes emitted by trees,
plants and other natural sources. The 14C isotopic signa-
ture of fossil-derived VOCs is different from that of biogeni-
cally derived VOCs, and thus their respective contributions
to SOA can be partially constrained via experimental anal-
ysis of the 14C content of OA (Zotter et al., 2014). We as-
sume the anthropogenic fraction is equivalent to the fossil
fraction of SOA (termed FSOA,fossil). At the two eastern US
sites (Atlanta and Smokey Mountains) the average FSOA,fossil
increases slightly from 14 % (SOM-no) to 22 % (SOM-low)
and 25 % (SOM-high). At the two SoCAB sites (downtown
LA and Riverside) the predicted average FSOA,fossil decreases While the predicted isoprene SOA fraction increased, the
predicted terpene and sesquiterpene SOA fractions decreased
in the simulations that accounted for vapor wall losses. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model Addi-
tionally, the terpene SOA / sesquiterpene SOA ratio increased
at all locations for the SOM-low and SOM-high simulations,
in large part because the sesquiterpene yield is already large 3.3.1
Source/VOC precursor dependence It is possible that ad-
ditional isoprene SOA had been formed under higher NOx
conditions (compared to the southeast US) such that it is
chemically different from IEPOX-SOA and was not identi- www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 3.3.2
The oxygen-to-carbon ratio The O : C atomic ratios of the SOA have been calculated
from the simulated distributions of compounds in NC and
NO space; the O : C atomic ratio is an inherent property of
the SOM model and (O : C)SOA values from box model sim-
ulations using SOM exhibit generally good agreement with
observations (Cappa and Wilson, 2012; Cappa et al., 2013). Few air quality models attempt to simulate O : C ratios for
SOA (e.g. Murphy et al., 2011), although a dramatic expan-
sion in observations of O : C ratios for ambient OA has re-
cently occurred (Ng et al., 2011; Canagaratna et al., 2015;
Chen et al., 2015). Comparison between intensive properties
such as O : C, in addition to absolute OA concentrations, can
provide further constraints on the transformation processes
and OA sources in a given region. The simulated (O : C)SOA
in the SOM-no simulations are generally larger in SoCAB
than in the eastern US (Fig. 6). The simulated (O : C)SOA
from isoprene and aromatics individually are larger than
those from mono- or sesquiterpenes due, in large part, to
the smaller carbon backbone and the need to add more oxy-
gens to produce sufficiently low volatility species that parti-
tion substantially to the particle phase (Chhabra et al., 2011;
Cappa and Wilson, 2012; Tkacik et al., 2012). Thus, the
larger (O : C)SOA in SoCAB results from larger relative con-
tributions from isoprene and aromatic compounds to the total
SOA burden in this region. The (O : C)SOA is also generally
larger in regions where SOA concentrations are smaller. This
may reflect some relationship between SOA source and con-
centration, but it also reflects the role that continued multi-
generational oxidation has on the SOA composition, since
lower concentrations can reflect greater dilution and overall
more aged SOA. The SoCAB FSOA,fossil values can be compared with es-
timates of the fossil fraction of “oxidized organic carbon”
(FOOC,fossil) from measurements made during CalNex in
Pasadena (Zotter et al., 2014). It should be noted that while
FSOA,fossil includes contributions from both oxygen and car-
bon mass the FOOC,fossil includes only the carbon mass. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3052 slightly, from 35 (SOM-no) to 29 % (SOM-low) and 30 %
(SOM-high), respectively. In SoCAB the FSOA,fossil values
differ between the low- and high-NOx parameterizations,
with FSOA,fossil typically larger for the low-NOx parameter-
izations (e.g. 35 % for low-NOx and 25 % for high-NOx). In the eastern US, the predicted FSOA,fossil exhibit a stronger
response to vapor wall losses for the high-NOx parameteriza-
tion than the low-NOx parameterization, although the abso-
lute values are reasonably similar. Of the anthropogenic SOA
(aromatics + alkanes), the high-NOx parameterizations indi-
cate an increasing alkane SOA fraction as vapor wall losses
are accounted for in both regions. In contrast, the low-NOx
parameterizations indicate minor contributions from alkane
SOA for all of the simulations. In general, chamber SOA
yields from aromatic compounds are larger for low-NOx con-
ditions (Ng et al., 2007a), which could help to explain these
differences. slightly, from 35 (SOM-no) to 29 % (SOM-low) and 30 %
(SOM-high), respectively. In SoCAB the FSOA,fossil values
differ between the low- and high-NOx parameterizations,
with FSOA,fossil typically larger for the low-NOx parameter-
izations (e.g. 35 % for low-NOx and 25 % for high-NOx). In the eastern US, the predicted FSOA,fossil exhibit a stronger
response to vapor wall losses for the high-NOx parameteriza-
tion than the low-NOx parameterization, although the abso-
lute values are reasonably similar. Of the anthropogenic SOA
(aromatics + alkanes), the high-NOx parameterizations indi-
cate an increasing alkane SOA fraction as vapor wall losses
are accounted for in both regions. In contrast, the low-NOx
parameterizations indicate minor contributions from alkane
SOA for all of the simulations. In general, chamber SOA
yields from aromatic compounds are larger for low-NOx con-
ditions (Ng et al., 2007a), which could help to explain these
differences. than the peak daytime value and that the 24 h average best-
estimate FOOC,fossil = 44 %. This is somewhat larger than the
average predicted FSOC,fossil (e.g. 31 % for SOM-high). The
difference between the observed FOOC,fossil and predicted
FSOC,fossil could indicate a role for SOA formed from fossil-
derived S/IVOC species in the atmosphere but which are not
considered here. 3.3.2
The oxygen-to-carbon ratio The
fossil fraction of secondary organic carbon (SOC) can be cal-
culated from the simulated SOA concentrations by account-
ing for the differences in the O : C atomic ratios of the differ-
ent SOA types to facilitate more direct comparison between
the simulations and observations. Specifically, the SOC mass
concentration (CSOC) is related to the SOA mass concentra-
tion (CSOA) for a given SOA type through the relationship: CSOC = CSOA × NC × MWC
MWSOA
=
NC × MWC
NC × MWC + NO × MWO + NH × MWH
=
CSOA
4
3 (O : C) + 1
12 (H : C) + 1
,
(4) CSOC = CSOA × NC × MWC
MWSOA
=
NC × MWC
NC × MWC + NO × MWO + NH × MWH
=
CSOA
4
3 (O : C) + 1
12 (H : C) + 1
,
(4) (4) where MWC, MWO, MWH are the molecular weights of car-
bon, oxygen and hydrogen atoms, respectively. The O : C and
H : C values of the different SOA types are not constant in the
SOM due to the continuous evolution of the product distribu-
tion. However, for a given SOA type the simulated O : C and
H : C values vary over a relatively narrow range (Cappa et al.,
2013) and thus an average value can be used. The resulting
FSOC,fossil values are compared with the FSOA,fossil values in
Table S2 and are found to be very similar. The FOOC,fossil val-
ues were determined from 14C analysis of particles collected
on filters to allow for determination of the fossil fraction of
the total carbonaceous material coupled with positive matrix
factorization to allow separation of the contributions from
the various fossil and non-fossil POA and SOA sources. The
uncertainty in the fossil fraction of total OC was reported as
9 %; the uncertainty in the FOOC,fossil will be larger. Zotter et
al. (2014) determined the nighttime FOOC,fossil was smaller where MWC, MWO, MWH are the molecular weights of car-
bon, oxygen and hydrogen atoms, respectively. The O : C and
H : C values of the different SOA types are not constant in the
SOM due to the continuous evolution of the product distribu-
tion. www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3053 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model
3053
Figure 6. 14-day averaged O : C atomic ratios for SOA for (a) SoCAB and (d) the eastern US for the SOM-no simulations. The difference in
O : C between the SOM-low or SOM-high and SOM-no simulations, termed 1(O : C), is shown in panels (b–c) for SoCAB and (e–f) for the
eastern US. Figure 6. 14-day averaged O : C atomic ratios for SOA for (a) SoCAB and (d) the eastern US for the SOM-no simulations. The difference in
O : C between the SOM-low or SOM-high and SOM-no simulations, termed 1(O : C), is shown in panels (b–c) for SoCAB and (e–f) for the
eastern US. determines (O : C)total with an absolute uncertainty of ±30 %
but with very high precision (Docherty et al., 2008; Dzepina
et al., 2009). Values reported here have been corrected ac-
cording to Canagaratna et al. (2015). The campaign-average
observed (O : C)total was ∼0.45. The SOM-high (O : C)total
is in very good agreement with the observations, whereas
(O : C)total is too small for both SOM-no and SOM-low. This
good correspondence is, of course, sensitive to the assumed
(O : C)POA, here 0.2 based on (Ng et al., 2011). If a smaller
(O : C)POA had been assumed, then either a greater amount
of SOA would be required or the simulated (O : C)SOA
would need to be larger to match the SOAR measure-
ments. Docherty et al. (2011) determined there were three
POA types during SOAR, with a weighted-average-corrected
O : C = 0.095, suggesting that the assumed 0.2 is too large. In
contrast, Hayes et al. (2013) determined a weighted-average-
corrected O : C = 0.25 for the three POA types identified at
Pasadena during CalNex. It has been suggested that at least
some of the difference in the (O : C)POA between SOAR and
CalNex results from greater heterogeneous ageing of the
Pasadena POA. Regardless of the exact (O : C)POA, a strong
improvement in the model-measurement agreement when
vapor wall losses are accounted for is evident. Of additional
consideration is the diurnal dependence of the (O : C)total. The observed (O : C)total exhibited a distinct diurnal depen-
dence, with low values at night, a minimum at ∼7:00 LT
and maximum values around midday (Fig. 8). C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model The simu-
lated (O : C)total diurnal profile for the SOM-high simulations
agrees reasonably well with the SOAR observations in terms
of both the magnitude of the day–night difference and the ab-
solute (O : C)total (Fig. 8). In contrast, both the SOM-no and
SOM-low exhibit only minor variations with time-of-day due
to the controlling influence of (O : C)POA. ence in simulated (O : C)SOA between isoprene and monoter-
penes is substantial (Jathar et al., 2015a). p
The simulated O : C for the total OA also differs sub-
stantially between simulations (Fig. 7), especially in regions
where the simulated increase in fSOA is largest (Fig. 2). The
simulated (O : C)total in both the SoCAB and eastern US in-
creases substantially when vapor wall losses are accounted
for. For example, the simulated (O : C)total values at River-
side were 0.22, 0.3 and 0.42 and at Atlanta were 0.45, 0.65
and 0.85 for SOM-no, SOM-low and SOM-high simulations,
respectively. The increase in (O : C)total is mostly driven by
an associated increase in fSOA. The (O : C)total value is a
weighted average of the (O : C)SOA and (O : C)POA, with
(O : C)total = (nO,SOA+ nO,POA)/(nC,SOA+nC,POA) where nO
and nC indicate the number of oxygen and carbon atoms,
respectively, that comprise all SOA types and POA. For
conceptual purposes, this exact expression for (O : C)total
can be approximated as (O : C)total ∼fSOA(O : C)SOA + (1 −
fSOA)(O : C)POA, where (O : C)SOA represents the average
over the different SOA types. Thus, changes in fSOA lead to
changes in (O : C)total, with some additional smaller changes
due to variation in the weighted average (O : C)SOA between
the various simulations (since each SOA type has a partic-
ular O : C range). The predicted eastern US (O : C)total are
generally larger than in SoCAB due to the larger fSOA in
the eastern US and since (O : C)SOA is typically larger than
(O : C)POA. For example, the average (O : C)total in Atlanta
for the SOM-no simulations was 0.4 whereas it was 0.22 in
Riverside. The simulated results at Riverside can be compared with
bulk, campaign average (O : C)total values measured dur-
ing the SOAR campaign using an Aerodyne high-resolution
time-of-flight aerosol mass spectrometer (HR-AMS), which 3.3.2
The oxygen-to-carbon ratio However, for a given SOA type the simulated O : C and
H : C values vary over a relatively narrow range (Cappa et al.,
2013) and thus an average value can be used. The resulting
FSOC,fossil values are compared with the FSOA,fossil values in
Table S2 and are found to be very similar. The FOOC,fossil val-
ues were determined from 14C analysis of particles collected
on filters to allow for determination of the fossil fraction of
the total carbonaceous material coupled with positive matrix
factorization to allow separation of the contributions from
the various fossil and non-fossil POA and SOA sources. The
uncertainty in the fossil fraction of total OC was reported as
9 %; the uncertainty in the FOOC,fossil will be larger. Zotter et
al. (2014) determined the nighttime FOOC,fossil was smaller The (O : C)SOA for the SOM-low and SOM-high simula-
tions are substantially larger than that from the SOM-no sim-
ulations in both SoCAB and the eastern US (Fig. 6). This re-
flects two phenomena: (i) the increased relative contribution
of isoprene to the total simulated SOA burden in the SOM-
low and SOM-high simulations and (ii) differences in the
SOM chemical pathways (i.e. the SOM parameters) that lead
to the production of condensed-phase material between the
parameterizations that do/do not include vapor wall losses. The influence of the latter has been confirmed through box
model simulations, although the exact behavior is both pre-
cursor specific and somewhat dependent on the reaction con-
ditions (e.g. [OH] and the initial precursor concentration). Overall, the former effect likely dominates since the differ- www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 appa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Mod C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3054 3054
C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model
Figure 7. 14-day averaged O : C atomic ratios for total OA (POA + SOA) for (a) SoCAB and (d) the eastern US for the SOM-no simulations. The normalized difference in O : C, 1(O : C), between the SOM-low or SOM-high and SOM-no simulations, where 1(O : C) is defined as
((O : C)SOM-low/high-(O : C)SOM-no)/(O : C)SOM-no), is shown in panels (b–c) for SoCAB and (e–f) for the eastern US. In all cases, the O : C
for POA was assumed to be 0.2. Figure 7. 14-day averaged O : C atomic ratios for total OA (POA + SOA) for (a) SoCAB and (d) the eastern US for the SOM-no simulations. The normalized difference in O : C, 1(O : C), between the SOM-low or SOM-high and SOM-no simulations, where 1(O : C) is defined as
((O : C)SOM-low/high-(O : C)SOM-no)/(O : C)SOM-no), is shown in panels (b–c) for SoCAB and (e–f) for the eastern US. In all cases, the O : C
for POA was assumed to be 0.2. The simulated (O : C)total values in the eastern US can also
be compared with recent observations, with the caveat that
in this case the measurements were not made over the same
time-period as the simulations were run. Nonetheless, mea-
surements made in summer and winter of 2012 and 2013 at
various locations in Alabama and Georgia indicate the O : C
values for total OA were relatively constant, around 0.6–0.7,
although it should be noted that these values were estimated
from measurements made using an Aerodyne aerosol chem-
ical speciation monitor, which increases the uncertainty (Xu
et al., 2015b). Measurements made around the southeast US
using an HR-AMS onboard the NASA DC8 as part of the
SEAC4RS field study indicate the average (O : C)total = 0.8
when the plane was flying below 1 km (SEAC4RS, 2014). As noted above, the simulated (O : C)total around Atlanta was
0.45 for SOM-no, increasing to ∼0.65 for SOM-low and
∼0.85 for SOM-high. www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ As with the SoCAB comparison, the
general level of agreement between the observed and simu-
lated (O : C)tot was improved when vapor wall losses were
accounted for. quently, had S/IVOCs been included in the simulations the
(O : C)total would have likely decreased. The magnitude of
the decrease would depend on the exact extent to which the
S/IVOCs contributed to the overall SOA burden, the extent
to which the simulated POA decreased (due to the semi-
volatile treatment), and on the simulated (O : C)S/IVOC. In
the limit that SOA from S/IVOCs dominates the SOA bud-
get, very little variation in the (O : C)total ratio with time of
day would have likely been predicted because (O : C)POA ∼
(O : C)S/IVOC. Additionally, the simulated daytime (O : C)total
values would have likely been close to 0.2. A lack of diurnal
variability and a small (O : C)total would both be inconsistent
with the SOAR observations. Consequently, this implies that
accounting for vapor wall losses has a stronger potential to
allow for simultaneous reconciliation of the diurnal behav-
ior of both the simulated OA / 1CO and (O : C)total with ob-
servations than does consideration of oxidation of S/IVOCs
alone. This is not to say that S/IVOC contributions to the
SOA and total OA burden are not important, only that it
seems unlikely that they could dominate the SOA budget. Ultimately, it seems likely that consideration of both vapor
wall losses (as done here) and of SOA from S/IVOCs will be
necessary to fully close the model–measurement gap. The above simulations included SOA only from VOCs, ne-
glecting contributions from S/IVOCs including oxidation of
semi-volatile POA vapors. S/IVOCs and semi-volatile POA
vapors are likely ≥C14 carbon species (Jathar et al., 2014;
Zhao et al., 2014). As such, little added oxygen is required
to produce low-volatility species that will form SOA. Since
these species also have relatively large number of carbon
atoms, the O : C of the SOA formed from them will be rel-
atively small, most likely with (O : C)S/IVOC < 0.2 in the ab-
sence of strong heterogeneous oxidation (Cappa and Wilson,
2012; Tkacik et al., 2012); note that this range is lower than
what was assumed for the non-volatile POA here. Conse- 4
Conclusions The influence of chamber vapor wall losses on simulated
SOA concentrations and properties has been assessed. The
statistical oxidation model was used to parameterize SOA
formation from laboratory chamber experiments both with
and without accounting for vapor wall losses using data from
experiments conducted under both high-NOx and low-NOx www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3055 Figure 8. Simulated and observed diurnal profiles for the total OA O : C (a, b, c) and H : C (d, e, f) atomic ratios at Riverside, CA, during the
SOAR-2005 campaign for (a, d) SOM-no, (b, e) SOM-low and (c, f) SOM-high simulations. For the observations, the mean (orange line)
and the 1σ variability range (dark grey band) are shown along with bands indicating the measurement uncertainty (light grey band), taken as
±28 % for O : C and 13 % for H : C (Canagaratna et al., 2015). Observed values have been corrected according to Canagaratna et al. (2015). For the simulations, box and whisker plots are shown with the median (red –), lower and upper quartile (boxes), and 9th and 91st percentile
(whiskers). For reference, the assumed O : C for POA was 0.2 and for H : C was 2.0. Figure 8. Simulated and observed diurnal profiles for the total OA O : C (a, b, c) and H : C (d, e, f) atomic ratios at Riverside, CA, during the
SOAR-2005 campaign for (a, d) SOM-no, (b, e) SOM-low and (c, f) SOM-high simulations. For the observations, the mean (orange line)
and the 1σ variability range (dark grey band) are shown along with bands indicating the measurement uncertainty (light grey band), taken as
±28 % for O : C and 13 % for H : C (Canagaratna et al., 2015). Observed values have been corrected according to Canagaratna et al. (2015). For the simulations, box and whisker plots are shown with the median (red –), lower and upper quartile (boxes), and 9th and 91st percentile
(whiskers). For reference, the assumed O : C for POA was 0.2 and for H : C was 2.0. conditions. “Low” and a “high” vapor wall-loss cases were
considered in addition to the “no” vapor wall-loss case. 4
Conclusions The
best-fit SOM parameters under these different conditions
were used as input to SOA simulations in the 3-D UCD/CIT
regional air quality model, in which SOM has been recently
implemented (Jathar et al., 2015a). Simulations were run for
southern California and for the eastern US. Explicit account-
ing for vapor wall losses led to increases in simulated SOA
concentrations, by a factor of ∼2–5 for the “low” simula-
tions and ∼5–10 for the “high” simulations. The magnitude
of the increase was inversely related to the simulated absolute
SOA concentration. This suggests that the extent to which
SOA concentrations are underpredicted may be greater in
more remote regions. Comparison of the OA / 1CO from the SoCAB simulations
with observations form the SOAR campaign (Docherty et al.,
2008) indicate that accounting for vapor wall losses leads to
substantially improved agreement in terms of the diurnal be-
havior, in particular the magnitude of the daytime increase
in OA / 1CO. Accounting for vapor wall losses also leads to
location-specific changes in the major contributing VOC pre-
cursors to the SOA burden. In general, accounting for vapor
wall losses leads to an increase in the predicted relative con-
tribution of isoprene SOA and a decrease in the relative con-
tribution of monoterpene and sesquiterpene SOA. The rel-
ative contribution of total anthropogenic VOCs to SOA is
reasonably insensitive to vapor wall losses, especially in So-
CAB, although the apportionment between aromatic VOCs
and alkanes does vary with vapor wall losses. The simulated
anthropogenic SOA fraction is, however, somewhat smaller
than suggested by 14C observations during CalNex (Zotter et
al., 2014). In general, the simulated O : C atomic ratio of the
SOA increased for the low and high vapor wall-loss simula-
tions, compared to the base case. The simulated O : C of the
total OA (SOA + POA) in both SoCAB and the eastern US This increase in simulated SOA when vapor wall losses
are accounted for leads to a substantial increase in the simu-
lated SOA fraction of total OA. This is especially seen in So-
CAB where fSOA is very small for the base model but > 50 %
for the simulations that account for vapor wall losses. The
simulated fSOA in SoCAB is found to agree reasonably well
with observations when vapor wall losses are accounted for. The Supplement related to this article is available online
at doi:10.5194/acp-16-3041-2016-supplement. Cappa, C. D., Zhang, X., Loza, C. L., Craven, J. S., Yee, L. D., and
Seinfeld, J. H.: Application of the Statistical Oxidation Model
(SOM) to Secondary Organic Aerosol formation from photoox-
idation of C12 alkanes, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 13, 1591–1606,
doi:10.5194/acp-13-1591-2013, 2013. Carlton, A. G., Bhave, P. V., Napelenok, S. L., Edney, E. O., Sar-
war, G., Pinder, R. W., Pouliot, G. A., and Houyoux, M.: Model
Representation of Secondary Organic Aerosol in CMAQv4.7,
Environ. Sci. Technol., 44, 8553–8560, doi:10.1021/es100636q,
2010. Author contributions. The manuscript was written through contri-
butions of all authors. Christopher D. Cappa, Shantanu H. Jathar,
Michael J. Kleeman, John H. Seinfeld and Anthony S. Wexler de-
signed the project. Shantanu H. Jathar and Michael J. Kleeman car-
ried out the simulations. Christopher D. Cappa determined model
parameters using laboratory data collected by John H. Seinfeld. Kenneth S. Docherty and Jose L. Jimenez collected and processed
the SOAR data. All authors have given approval to the final version
of the manuscript. Chen, Q., Heald, C. L., Jimenez, J. L., Canagaratna, M. R., Qi, Z.,
Ling-Yan, H., Xiao-Feng, H., Campuzano-Jost, P., Palm, B. B.,
Poulain, L., Kuwata, M., Martin, S. T., Abbatt, J. P. D., Lee, A. K. Y., and Liggio, J.: Elemental composition of organic aerosol: the
gap between ambient and laboratory measurements, Geophys. Res. Lett., 42, 4182–4189, doi:10.1002/2015gl063693, 2015. Chhabra, P. S., Ng, N. L., Canagaratna, M. R., Corrigan, A. L., Rus-
sell, L. M., Worsnop, D. R., Flagan, R. C., and Seinfeld, J. H.: El-
emental composition and oxidation of chamber organic aerosol,
Atmos. Chem. Phys., 11, 8827–8845, doi:10.5194/acp-11-8827-
2011, 2011. Acknowledgements. The authors thank Pedro Campuzano-Jost
for the SEAC4RS data. This study was funded by the Califor-
nia Air Resources Board, contract 12-312 and NOAA grant
NA13OAR4310058. Jose L. Jimenez was supported by CARB
11-305 and EPA STAR 83587701-0. This manuscript has not been
reviewed by the funding agencies and no endorsement should be
inferred. De Gouw, J. and Jimenez, J. L.: Organic Aerosols in the
Earth’s Atmosphere, Environ. Sci. Technol., 43, 7614–7618,
doi:10.1021/es9006004, 2009. Docherty, K. S., Stone, E. A., Ulbrich, I. M., DeCarlo, P. F., Snyder,
D. C., Schauer, J. J., Peltier, R. E., Weber, R. J., Murphy, S. M.,
Seinfeld, J. H., Grover, B. D., Eatough, D. J., and Jimenez, J. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3056 are in better agreement with observations when vapor wall
losses are accounted for. S., Brune, W. H., Lin, Y.-H., Rubitschun, C. L., and Surratt, J. D.: Gas and aerosol carbon in California: comparison of mea-
surements and model predictions in Pasadena and Bakersfield,
Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15, 5243–5258, doi:10.5194/acp-15-5243-
2015, 2015. Overall, the generally improved model performance when
vapor wall losses are accounted for – in terms of both abso-
lute and relative concentrations and in terms of SOA prop-
erties – suggests that accounting for this chamber effect in
atmospheric simulations of SOA is important, although cer-
tainly requiring further examination. Our results qualitatively
agree with other recent efforts to assess the influence of va-
por wall losses on ambient SOA concentrations (Baker et al.,
2015; Hayes et al., 2015), but as our accounting for vapor
wall loss is inherent in the SOA parameterization the simu-
lations here serve to provide a more robust assessment. The
results presented here additionally suggest that there may be
no need to invoke ad hoc “ageing” schemes for aromatics
(Tsimpidi et al., 2010) to achieve increases in simulated SOA
concentrations in urban environments. Further, these results
suggest that the contribution of S/IVOCs to urban SOA might
be somewhat limited, albeit still important, although this is-
sue certainly requires further investigation. Budisulistiorini, S. H., Canagaratna, M. R., Croteau, P. L., Marth, g
W. J., Baumann, K., Edgerton, E. S., Shaw, S. L., Knipping,
E. M., Worsnop, D. R., Jayne, J. T., Gold, A., and Surratt, J. D.: Real-Time Continuous Characterization of Secondary Or-
ganic Aerosol Derived from Isoprene Epoxydiols in Down-
town Atlanta, Georgia, Using the Aerodyne Aerosol Chemi-
cal Speciation Monitor, Environ. Sci. Technol., 47, 5686–5694,
doi:10.1021/es400023n, 2013. Canagaratna, M. R., Jimenez, J. L., Kroll, J. H., Chen, Q., Kessler,
S. H., Massoli, P., Hildebrandt Ruiz, L., Fortner, E., Williams, L. R., Wilson, K. R., Surratt, J. D., Donahue, N. M., Jayne, J. T.,
and Worsnop, D. R.: Elemental ratio measurements of organic
compounds using aerosol mass spectrometry: characterization,
improved calibration, and implications, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15,
253–272, doi:10.5194/acp-15-253-2015, 2015. Cappa, C. D. and Wilson, K. R.: Multi-generation gas-phase oxida-
tion, equilibrium partitioning, and the formation and evolution of
secondary organic aerosol, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 12, 9505–9528,
doi:10.5194/acp-12-9505-2012, 2012. The Supplement related to this article is available online
at doi:10.5194/acp-16-3041-2016-supplement. L.:
Apportionment of Primary and Secondary Organic Aerosols in
Southern California during the 2005 Study of Organic Aerosols
in Riverside (SOAR-1), Environ. Sci. Technol., 42, 7655–7662,
doi:10.1021/es8008166, 2008. Edited by: K. Lehtinen Edited by: K. Lehtinen www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model 3057 Study of Organic Aerosols at Riverside (SOAR-1): instrumental
intercomparisons and fine particle composition, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 11, 12387–12420, doi:10.5194/acp-11-12387-2011, 2011. Hu, W. W., Campuzano-Jost, P., Palm, B. B., Day, D. A., Ortega,
A. M., Hayes, P. L., Krechmer, J. E., Chen, Q., Kuwata, M.,
Liu, Y. J., de Sá, S. S., McKinney, K., Martin, S. T., Hu, M.,
Budisulistiorini, S. H., Riva, M., Surratt, J. D., St. Clair, J. M.,
Isaacman-Van Wertz, G., Yee, L. D., Goldstein, A. H., Carbone,
S., Brito, J., Artaxo, P., de Gouw, J. A., Koss, A., Wisthaler, A.,
Mikoviny, T., Karl, T., Kaser, L., Jud, W., Hansel, A., Docherty,
K. S., Alexander, M. L., Robinson, N. H., Coe, H., Allan, J. D.,
Canagaratna, M. R., Paulot, F., and Jimenez, J. L.: Characteri-
zation of a real-time tracer for isoprene epoxydiols-derived sec-
ondary organic aerosol (IEPOX-SOA) from aerosol mass spec-
trometer measurements, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15, 11807–11833,
doi:10.5194/acp-15-11807-2015, 2015. Study of Organic Aerosols at Riverside (SOAR-1): instrumental
intercomparisons and fine particle composition, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 11, 12387–12420, doi:10.5194/acp-11-12387-2011, 2011. Dzepina, K., Volkamer, R. M., Madronich, S., Tulet, P., Ulbrich,
I. M., Zhang, Q., Cappa, C. D., Ziemann, P. J., and Jimenez, J. L.: Evaluation of recently-proposed secondary organic aerosol
models for a case study in Mexico City, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 9,
5681–5709, doi:10.5194/acp-9-5681-2009, 2009. Canagaratna, M. R., Paulot, F., and Jimenez, J. L.: Characteri-
zation of a real-time tracer for isoprene epoxydiols-derived sec-
ondary organic aerosol (IEPOX-SOA) from aerosol mass spec-
trometer measurements, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15, 11807–11833,
doi:10.5194/acp-15-11807-2015, 2015. Dzepina, K., Cappa, C. D., Volkamer, R. M., Madronich, S., De-
Carlo, P. F., Zaveri, R. A., and Jimenez, J. L.: Modeling the Mul-
tiday Evolution and Aging of Secondary Organic Aerosol Dur-
ing MILAGRO 2006, Environ. Sci. Technol., 45, 3496–3503,
doi:10.1021/es103186f, 2011. Ensberg, J. J., Hayes, P. L., Jimenez, J. L., Gilman, J. B., Kuster,
W. C., de Gouw, J. A., Holloway, J. S., Gordon, T. D., Jathar, S.,
Robinson, A. L., and Seinfeld, J. H.: Emission factor ratios, SOA
mass yields, and the impact of vehicular emissions on SOA for-
mation, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 14, 2383–2397, doi:10.5194/acp-
14-2383-2014, 2014. Jathar, S. H., Gordon, T. D., Hennigan, C. J., Pye, H. O. T.,
Pouliot, G., Adams, P. J., Donahue, N. M., and Robinson, A. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model Phys.,
15, 10411–10433, doi:10.5194/acp-15-10411-2015, 2015. Schwarz, J. P., Markovic, M. Z., and Perring, A. E.: Sources,
seasonality, and trends of southeast US aerosol: an integrated
analysis of surface, aircraft, and satellite observations with the
GEOS-Chem chemical transport model, Atmos. Chem. Phys.,
15, 10411–10433, doi:10.5194/acp-15-10411-2015, 2015. Hayes, P. L., Carlton, A. G., Baker, K. R., Ahmadov, R., Washen-
felder, R. A., Alvarez, S., Rappenglück, B., Gilman, J. B., Kuster,
W. C., de Gouw, J. A., Zotter, P., Prévôt, A. S. H., Szidat, S.,
Kleindienst, T. E., Offenberg, J. H., Ma, P. K., and Jimenez, J. L.:
Modeling the formation and aging of secondary organic aerosols
in Los Angeles during CalNex 2010, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15,
5773–5801, doi:10.5194/acp-15-5773-2015, 2015. Kleeman, M. J. and Cass, G. R.: A 3-D Eulerian Source-Oriented
Model for an Externally Mixed Aerosol, Environ. Sci. Technol.,
35, 4834–4848, doi:10.1021/es010886m, 2001. Kokkola, H., Yli-Pirilä, P., Vesterinen, M., Korhonen, H., Keskinen,
H., Romakkaniemi, S., Hao, L., Kortelainen, A., Joutsensaari, J.,
Worsnop, D. R., Virtanen, A., and Lehtinen, K. E. J.: The role
of low volatile organics on secondary organic aerosol formation,
Atmos. Chem. Phys., 14, 1689–1700, doi:10.5194/acp-14-1689-
2014, 2014. Heald, C. L., Jacob, D. J., Park, R. J., Russell, L. M., Huebert, B. J.,
Seinfeld, J. H., Liao, H., and Weber, R. J.: A large organic aerosol
source in the free troposphere missing from current models, Geo-
phys. Res. Lett., 32, L18809, doi:10.1029/2005GL023831, 2005. Krechmer, J. E., Coggon, M. M., Massoli, P., Nguyen, T. B.,
Crounse, J. D., Hu, W., Day, D. A., Tyndall, G. S., Henze, D. K., Rivera-Rios, J. C., Nowak, J. B., Kimmel, J. R., Mauldin,
R. L., Stark, H., Jayne, J. T., Sipilä, M., Junninen, H., Clair,
J. M. S., Zhang, X., Feiner, P. A., Zhang, L., Miller, D. O.,
Brune, W. H., Keutsch, F. N., Wennberg, P. O., Seinfeld, J. H., Worsnop, D. R., Jimenez, J. L., and Canagaratna, M. R.:
Formation of Low Volatility Organic Compounds and Sec-
ondary Organic Aerosol from Isoprene Hydroxyhydroperoxide
Low-NO Oxidation, Environ. Sci. Technol., 49, 10330–10339,
doi:10.1021/acs.est.5b02031, 2015. Hodzic, A., Aumont, B., Knote, C., Lee-Taylor, J., Madronich,
S., and Tyndall, G.: Volatility dependence of Henry’s law con-
stants of condensable organics: Application to estimate deposi-
tional loss of secondary organic aerosols, Geophys. Res. Lett.,
41, 4795–4804, doi:10.1002/2014gl060649, 2014. Hodzic, A., Kasibhatla, P. S., Jo, D. S., Cappa, C., Jimenez, J. L., Madronich, S., and Park, R. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model L.: Unspeciated organic emissions from combustion sources and
their influence on the secondary organic aerosol budget in the
United States, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 111, 10473–10478,
doi:10.1073/pnas.1323740111, 2014. Ervens, B., Turpin, B. J., and Weber, R. J.: Secondary or-
ganic aerosol formation in cloud droplets and aqueous parti-
cles (aqSOA): a review of laboratory, field and model stud-
ies, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 11, 11069–11102, doi:10.5194/acp-11-
11069-2011, 2011. Jathar, S. H., Cappa, C. D., Wexler, A. S., Seinfeld, J. H., and Klee-
man, M. J.: Multi-generational oxidation model to simulate sec-
ondary organic aerosol in a 3-D air quality model, Geosci. Model
Dev., 8, 2553–2567, doi:10.5194/gmd-8-2553-2015, 2015a. Jathar, S. H., Cappa, C. D., Wexler, A. S., Seinfeld, J. H., and Klee-
man, M. J.: Simulating secondary organic aerosol in a regional
air quality model using the statistical oxidation model – Part 1:
Assessing the influence of constrained multi-generational age-
ing, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 2309–2322, doi:10.5194/acp-16-
2309-2016, 2016. Hayes, P. L., Ortega, A. M., Cubison, M. J., Froyd, K. D., Zhao,
Y., Cliff, S. S., Hu, W. W., Toohey, D. W., Flynn, J. H., Lefer,
B. L., Grossberg, N., Alvarez, S., Rappenglück, B., Taylor, J. W.,
Allan, J. D., Holloway, J. S., Gilman, J. B., Kuster, W. C., de
Gouw, J. A., Massoli, P., Zhang, X., Liu, J., Weber, R. J., Corri-
gan, A. L., Russell, L. M., Isaacman, G., Worton, D. R., Kreis-
berg, N. M., Goldstein, A. H., Thalman, R., Waxman, E. M.,
Volkamer, R., Lin, Y. H., Surratt, J. D., Kleindienst, T. E., Of-
fenberg, J. H., Dusanter, S., Griffith, S., Stevens, P. S., Brioude,
J., Angevine, W. M., and Jimenez, J. L.: Organic aerosol com-
position and sources in Pasadena, California, during the 2010
CalNex campaign, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 118, 9233–9257,
doi:10.1002/jgrd.50530, 2013. Kim, P. S., Jacob, D. J., Fisher, J. A., Travis, K., Yu, K., Zhu, L.,
Yantosca, R. M., Sulprizio, M. P., Jimenez, J. L., Campuzano-
Jost, P., Froyd, K. D., Liao, J., Hair, J. W., Fenn, M. A., But-
ler, C. F., Wagner, N. L., Gordon, T. D., Welti, A., Wennberg,
P. O., Crounse, J. D., St. Clair, J. M., Teng, A. P., Millet, D. B.,
Schwarz, J. P., Markovic, M. Z., and Perring, A. E.: Sources,
seasonality, and trends of southeast US aerosol: an integrated
analysis of surface, aircraft, and satellite observations with the
GEOS-Chem chemical transport model, Atmos. Chem. References Docherty, K. S., Aiken, A. C., Huffman, J. A., Ulbrich, I. M., De-
Carlo, P. F., Sueper, D., Worsnop, D. R., Snyder, D. C., Peltier,
R. E., Weber, R. J., Grover, B. D., Eatough, D. J., Williams, B. J., Goldstein, A. H., Ziemann, P. J., and Jimenez, J. L.: The 2005 Baker, K. R., Carlton, A. G., Kleindienst, T. E., Offenberg, J. H.,
Beaver, M. R., Gentner, D. R., Goldstein, A. H., Hayes, P. L.,
Jimenez, J. L., Gilman, J. B., de Gouw, J. A., Woody, M. C., Pye,
H. O. T., Kelly, J. T., Lewandowski, M., Jaoui, M., Stevens, P. Baker, K. R., Carlton, A. G., Kleindienst, T. E., Offenberg, J. H.,
Beaver, M. R., Gentner, D. R., Goldstein, A. H., Hayes, P. L.,
Jimenez, J. L., Gilman, J. B., de Gouw, J. A., Woody, M. C., Pye,
H. O. T., Kelly, J. T., Lewandowski, M., Jaoui, M., Stevens, P. www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Mod 3058 SEAC4RS: Studies of Emissions and Atmospheric Composi-
tion, Clouds and Climate Coupling by Regional Surveys,
NASA
Langley
Research
Center,
Hampton,
VA,
USA,
doi:10.5067/Aircraft/SEAC4RS/Aerosol-TraceGas-Cloud,
2014. Lane, T. E., Donahue, N. M., and Pandis, S. N.: Effect of NOx on
Secondary Organic Aerosol Concentrations, Environ. Sci. Tech-
nol., 42, 6022–6027, doi:10.1021/es703225a, 2008a. Lane, T. E., Donahue, N. M., and Pandis, S. N.: Simulating sec-
ondary organic aerosol formation using the volatility basis-set
approach in a chemical transport model, Atmos. Environ., 42,
7439–7451, doi:10.1016/j.atmosenv.2008.06.026, 2008b. Simon, H. and Bhave, P. V.: Simulating the Degree of Oxidation in
Atmospheric Organic Particles, Environ. Sci. Technol., 46, 331–
339, doi:10.1021/es202361w, 2011. Matsunaga, A. and Ziemann, P. J.: Gas-Wall Partitioning of Organic
Compounds in a Teflon Film Chamber and Potential Effects on
Reaction Product and Aerosol Yield Measurements, Aerosol Sci. Technol., 44, 881–892, doi:10.1080/02786826.2010.501044,
2010. Subramanian, R., Khlystov, A. Y., Cabada, J. C., and Robin-
son, A. L.: Positive and Negative Artifacts in Particulate Or-
ganic Carbon Measurements with Denuded and Undenuded
Sampler Configurations, Aerosol Sci. Technol., 38, 27–48,
doi:10.1080/02786820390229354, 2004. McVay, R. C., Cappa, C. D., and Seinfeld, J. H.: Vapor–Wall De-
position in Chambers: Theoretical Considerations, Environ. Sci. Technol., 48, 10251–10258, doi:10.1021/es502170j, 2014. The Visibility Information Exchange Web System (VIEWS 2.0):
The Visibility Information Exchange Web System, Colorado
State University, http://views.cira.colostate.edu/web/, last ac-
cess: 11 February 2015. Murphy, B. N., Donahue, N. M., Fountoukis, C., and Pandis, S. N.:
Simulating the oxygen content of ambient organic aerosol with
the 2D volatility basis set, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 11, 7859–7873,
doi:10.5194/acp-11-7859-2011, 2011. Tkacik, D. S., Presto, A. A., Donahue, N. M., and Robin-
son, A. L.: Secondary Organic Aerosol Formation from
Intermediate-Volatility Organic Compounds: Cyclic, Linear, and
Branched Alkanes, Environ. Sci. Technol., 46, 8773–8781,
doi:10.1021/es301112c, 2012. Ng, N. L., Chhabra, P. S., Chan, A. W. H., Surratt, J. D., Kroll, J. H., Kwan, A. J., McCabe, D. C., Wennberg, P. O., Sorooshian,
A., Murphy, S. M., Dalleska, N. F., Flagan, R. C., and Seinfeld,
J. H.: Effect of NOx level on secondary organic aerosol (SOA)
formation from the photooxidation of terpenes, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 7, 5159–5174, doi:10.5194/acp-7-5159-2007, 2007a. Tsigaridis, K., Daskalakis, N., Kanakidou, M., Adams, P. J., Ar-
taxo, P., Bahadur, R., Balkanski, Y., Bauer, S. E., Bellouin, N.,
Benedetti, A., Bergman, T., Berntsen, T. K., Beukes, J. P., Bian, Tsigaridis, K., Daskalakis, N., Kanakidou, M., Adams, P. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Mod J., Ar-
taxo, P., Bahadur, R., Balkanski, Y., Bauer, S. E., Bellouin, N.,
Benedetti, A., Bergman, T., Berntsen, T. K., Beukes, J. P., Bian,
H., Carslaw, K. S., Chin, M., Curci, G., Diehl, T., Easter, R. C., Ghan, S. J., Gong, S. L., Hodzic, A., Hoyle, C. R., Iversen,
T., Jathar, S., Jimenez, J. L., Kaiser, J. W., Kirkevåg, A., Koch,
D., Kokkola, H., Lee, Y. H, Lin, G., Liu, X., Luo, G., Ma, X.,
Mann, G. W., Mihalopoulos, N., Morcrette, J.-J., Müller, J.-F.,
Myhre, G., Myriokefalitakis, S., Ng, N. L., O’Donnell, D., Pen-
ner, J. E., Pozzoli, L., Pringle, K. J., Russell, L. M., Schulz, M.,
Sciare, J., Seland, Ø., Shindell, D. T., Sillman, S., Skeie, R. B.,
Spracklen, D., Stavrakou, T., Steenrod, S. D., Takemura, T., Ti-
itta, P., Tilmes, S., Tost, H., van Noije, T., van Zyl, P. G., von
Salzen, K., Yu, F., Wang, Z., Wang, Z., Zaveri, R. A., Zhang,
H., Zhang, K., Zhang, Q., and Zhang, X.: The AeroCom eval-
uation and intercomparison of organic aerosol in global mod-
els, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 14, 10845–10895, doi:10.5194/acp-14-
10845-2014, 2014. H., Carslaw, K. S., Chin, M., Curci, G., Diehl, T., Easter, R. Ng, N. L., Kroll, J. H., Chan, A. W. H., Chhabra, P. S., Flagan,
R. C., and Seinfeld, J. H.: Secondary organic aerosol formation
from m-xylene, toluene, and benzene, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 7,
3909–3922, doi:10.5194/acp-7-3909-2007, 2007b. C., Ghan, S. J., Gong, S. L., Hodzic, A., Hoyle, C. R., Iversen, T., Jathar, S., Jimenez, J. L., Kaiser, J. W., Kirkevåg, A., Koch,
D., Kokkola, H., Lee, Y. H, Lin, G., Liu, X., Luo, G., Ma, X., Ng, N. L., Canagaratna, M. R., Jimenez, J. L., Chhabra, P. S., Se-
infeld, J. H., and Worsnop, D. R.: Changes in organic aerosol
composition with aging inferred from aerosol mass spectra, At-
mos. Chem. Phys., 11, 6465–6474, doi:10.5194/acp-11-6465-
2011, 2011. Mann, G. W., Mihalopoulos, N., Morcrette, J.-J., Müller, J.-F., Myhre, G., Myriokefalitakis, S., Ng, N. L., O’Donnell, D., Pen- ner, J. E., Pozzoli, L., Pringle, K. J., Russell, L. M., Schulz, M., Odum, J. R., Hoffmann, T., Bowman, F., Collins, D., Flagan, R. C., and Seinfeld, J. H.: Gas/particle partitioning and secondary
organic aerosol yields, Environ. Sci. Technol., 30, 2580–2585,
doi:10.1021/es950943+, 1996. Pankow, J. F.: An absorption-model of the gas aerosol partition-
ing involved in the formation of secondary organic aerosol, At-
mos. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model J.: Rethinking the global sec-
ondary organic aerosol (SOA) budget: stronger production, faster
removal, shorter lifetime, Atmos. Chem. Phys. Discuss., 15,
32413–32468, doi:10.5194/acpd-15-32413-2015, 2015. www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model A. A., Russell, L. M., Kristensen, K., Glasius, M., Mao, J., Ren,
X., Brune, W., Browne, E. C., Pusede, S. E., Cohen, R. C., Se-
infeld, J. H., and Goldstein, A. H.: Observational Insights into
Aerosol Formation from Isoprene, Environ. Sci. Technol., 47,
11403–11413, doi:10.1021/es4011064, 2013. Zhang, X., Cappa, C. D., Jathar, S. H., McVay, R. C., Ensberg,
J. J., Kleeman, M. J., and Seinfeld, J. H.: Influence of va-
por wall loss in laboratory chambers on yields of secondary
organic aerosol, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 111, 5802–5807,
doi:10.1073/pnas.1404727111, 2014. Zhang, X., Schwantes, R. H., McVay, R. C., Lignell, H., Coggon,
M. M., Flagan, R. C., and Seinfeld, J. H.: Vapor wall deposi-
tion in Teflon chambers, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15, 4197–4214,
doi:10.5194/acp-15-4197-2015, 2015. Xu, L., Kollman, M. S., Song, C., Shilling, J. E., and Ng, N. L.:
Effects of NOx on the Volatility of Secondary Organic Aerosol
from Isoprene Photooxidation, Environ. Sci. Technol., 48, 2253–
2262, doi:10.1021/es404842g, 2014. g
Xu, L., Guo, H., Boyd, C. M., Klein, M., Bougiatioti, A., Cerully,
K. M., Hite, J. R., Isaacman-VanWertz, G., Kreisberg, N. M.,
Knote, C., Olson, K., Koss, A., Goldstein, A. H., Hering, S. V., de Gouw, J., Baumann, K., Lee, S.-H., Nenes, A., Weber,
R. J., and Ng, N. L.: Effects of anthropogenic emissions on
aerosol formation from isoprene and monoterpenes in the south-
eastern United States, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 112, 37–42,
doi:10.1073/pnas.1417609112, 2015a. Zhao, Y., Hennigan, C. J., May, A. A., Tkacik, D. S., de Gouw, J. A.,
Gilman, J. B., Kuster, W. C., Borbon, A., and Robinson, A. L.:
Intermediate-Volatility Organic Compounds: A Large Source of
Secondary Organic Aerosol, Environ. Sci. Technol., 48, 13743–
13750, doi:10.1021/es5035188, 2014. Ziemann, P. J. and Atkinson, R.: Kinetics, products, and mecha-
nisms of secondary organic aerosol formation, Chem. Soc. Rev.,
41, 6582–6605, doi:10.1039/C2CS35122F, 2012. Xu, L., Suresh, S., Guo, H., Weber, R. J., and Ng, N. L.: Aerosol
characterization over the southeastern United States using high-
resolution aerosol mass spectrometry: spatial and seasonal varia-
tion of aerosol composition and sources with a focus on organic
nitrates, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15, 7307–7336, doi:10.5194/acp-
15-7307-2015, 2015b. Zotter, P., El-Haddad, I., Zhang, Y., Hayes, P. L., Zhang, X.,
Lin, Y.-H., Wacker, L., Schnelle-Kreis, J., Abbaszade, G., Zim-
mermann, R., Surratt, J. D., Weber, R., Jimenez, J. L., Szi-
dat, S., Baltensperger, U., and Prévôt, A. S. C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Model H.: Diurnal cy-
cle of fossil and nonfossil carbon using radiocarbon analy-
ses during CalNex, J. Geophys. Res.-Atmos., 119, 6818–6835,
doi:10.1002/2013JD021114, 2014. Yeh, G. K. and Ziemann, P. J.: Gas-wall partitioning of
oxygenated
organic
compounds:
Measurements,
structure-
activity relationships, and correlation with gas chromato-
graphic retention factor, Aerosol Sci. Technol., 49, 727–738,
doi:10.1080/02786826.2015.1068427, 2015. Zhang, Q., Jimenez, J. L., Canagaratna, M. R., Allan, J. D., Coe,
H., Ulbrich, I., Alfarra, M. R., Takami, A., Middlebrook, A. M., Sun, Y. L., Dzepina, K., Dunlea, E., Docherty, K., De-
Carlo, P. F., Salcedo, D., Onasch, T., Jayne, J. T., Miyoshi,
T., Shimono, A., Hatakeyama, S., Takegawa, N., Kondo, Y.,
Schneider, J., Drewnick, F., Borrmann, S., Weimer, S., Demer-
jian, K., Williams, P., Bower, K., Bahreini, R., Cottrell, L.,
Griffin, R. J., Rautiainen, J., Sun, J. Y., Zhang, Y. M., and
Worsnop, D. R.: Ubiquity and dominance of oxygenated species
in organic aerosols in anthropogenically-influenced Northern
Hemisphere midlatitudes, Geophys. Res. Lett., 34, L13801,
doi:10.1029/2007GL029979, 2007. Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ C. D. Cappa et al.: Simulating Secondary Organic Aerosol in a Regional Air Quality Mod Environ., 28, 189–193, doi:10.1016/1352-2310(94)90094-
9, 1994. Tsimpidi, A. P., Karydis, V. A., Zavala, M., Lei, W., Molina, L.,
Ulbrich, I. M., Jimenez, J. L., and Pandis, S. N.: Evaluation of the
volatility basis-set approach for the simulation of organic aerosol
formation in the Mexico City metropolitan area, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 10, 525–546, doi:10.5194/acp-10-525-2010, 2010. Pye, H. O. T., Pinder, R. W., Piletic, I. R., Xie, Y., Capps, S. L.,
Lin, Y.-H., Surratt, J. D., Zhang, Z., Gold, A., Luecken, D. J.,
Hutzell, W. T., Jaoui, M., Offenberg, J. H., Kleindienst, T. E.,
Lewandowski, M., and Edney, E. O.: Epoxide Pathways Im-
prove Model Predictions of Isoprene Markers and Reveal Key
Role of Acidity in Aerosol Formation, Environ. Sci. Technol.,
47, 11056–11064, doi:10.1021/es402106h, 2013. Turpin, B. J. and Lim, H.-J.: Species Contributions to PM2.5
Mass Concentrations: Revisiting Common Assumptions for Es-
timating Organic Mass, Aerosol Sci. Technol., 35, 602–610,
doi:10.1080/02786820119445, 2001. Volkamer, R., Jimenez, J. L., San Martini, F., Dzepina, K., Zhang,
Q., Salcedo, D., Molina, L. T., Worsnop, D. R., and Molina, M. J.: Secondary organic aerosol formation from anthropogenic air
pollution: Rapid and higher than expected, Geophys. Res. Lett.,
33, L17811, doi:10.1029/2006gl026899, 2006. Robinson, A. L., Donahue, N. M., Shrivastava, M. K., Weitkamp,
E. A., Sage, A. M., Grieshop, A. P., Lane, T. E., Pierce, J. R.,
and Pandis, S. N.: Rethinking organic aerosols: Semivolatile
emissions and photochemical aging, Science, 315, 1259–1262,
doi:10.1126/science.1133061, 2007. Russell, A. R., Valin, L. C., and Cohen, R. C.: Trends in OMI NO2
observations over the United States: effects of emission control
technology and the economic recession, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 12,
12197–12209, doi:10.5194/acp-12-12197-2012, 2012. Worton, D. R., Surratt, J. D., LaFranchi, B. W., Chan, A. W. H.,
Zhao, Y., Weber, R. J., Park, J.-H., Gilman, J. B., de Gouw, J.,
Park, C., Schade, G., Beaver, M., Clair, J. M. S., Crounse, J.,
Wennberg, P., Wolfe, G. M., Harrold, S., Thornton, J. A., Farmer,
D. K., Docherty, K. S., Cubison, M. J., Jimenez, J.-L., Frossard, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016 www.atmos-chem-phys.net/16/3041/2016/ 3059 Atmos. Chem. Phys., 16, 3041–3059, 2016
|
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.