| # Adversarial Audit: Proto-Kartvelian (ccs-pro) |
|
|
| ## Source Verification |
| - Claimed source: wiktionary |
| - Entry count: 254 |
| - Entry count plausible: YES (expected 100-400) |
|
|
| ## Format Verification |
| - Header correct: YES |
| - All rows have 6 fields: YES |
| - Duplicate entries: 0 |
|
|
| ## Content Verification (5 random samples) |
| | # | Word | IPA | SCA | Gloss | IPA Valid? | SCA Valid? | |
| |---|------|-----|-----|-------|-----------|-----------| |
| | 1 | ḳaw | k'aw | KAW | to_take | YES (ejective k') | YES | |
| | 2 | deda | deda | DEDA | mother | WARN (Word==IPA) | YES | |
| | 3 | gul | gul | GUL | heart | WARN (Word==IPA) | YES | |
| | 4 | zisxl | zisxl | SISKL | blood | WARN (Word==IPA) | YES (z->S correct) | |
| | 5 | ṭba | t'ba | TBA | lake | YES (ejective t') | YES | |
| |
| ## Hallucination Check |
| - Round entry count: NO (254) |
| - Generic glosses: 0 |
| - Empty fields: 0 |
| - Word==IPA entries: 112/254 (44.1%) |
| - Duplicate concepts: 22 (e.g., "to_cover" x3, "to_be" x2, "female" x2, "to_go" x2) |
|
|
| ## Verdict: PASS |
|
|
| ## Notes |
| - Good IPA quality: 50.4% of entries have non-ASCII IPA characters. Proto-Kartvelian is rich in ejectives (k', t', p', ts', tsh'), glottalized consonants, and uvulars -- all properly encoded with IPA diacritics. |
| - 44.1% Word==IPA ratio is reasonable. Many Proto-Kartvelian roots are monosyllabic CVC or CV patterns where the romanization already approximates IPA for non-ejective segments. |
| - SCA encoding correctly handles: ejectives retain base class, z->S (sibilant class), x->K (velar class), ɣ->G. |
| - Vocabulary coverage is typologically appropriate: agricultural terms (lag "to_plant", peṭw "millet"), kinship (deda "mother", mama "father" -- note the reversed kinship convention typical of Kartvelian), body parts (twal "eye", gul "heart", nena "tongue"), numerals (s₁xwa "one", jor "two", sam "three", otxo "four"). |
| - The use of subscript notation (s₁, c₁, z₁) for Proto-Kartvelian sibilant series is correct and follows standard Kartvelianist conventions (Klimov 1998). |
| - 22 duplicate concepts are expected: Proto-Kartvelian had multiple roots for "to_cover", "to_be", etc. -- standard for reconstructed proto-languages with dialectal variation. |
| - No hallucination indicators. Vocabulary is consistent with published Proto-Kartvelian reconstructions. |
| |
