Samples / docs /PDS136.md
TidorP's picture
Publish seven selected GDPVal, STEM and code samples with a unified Docker runner
700c7f4 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
12.7 kB

PDS136

Updated PDF dated 2026-11-18: justification requested; weighted rubric added after historical benchmark runs.

Prompt

For each $p\in{2,3}$ fix a splitting $p$-modular system $(K_p,\mathcal O_p,k_p)$ for every group below. Let $P=C_3^2$, let $W_r$ be the Weyl group of type $A_r$, and let $\mathcal W_{23}$ be the Steiner system $S(4,7,23)$. Set F={(3,P⋊C4),(2,2B2(32)),(3,[W6,W6]),(2,SL2(3)),(3,P⋊Q8),(3,PGL2(F9)),(2,C2×SL2(8)),(3,W6),(3,P⋊D8),(2,2B2(8)),(3,[W7,W7]),(3,Aut⁡(W23)),(2,SL2(5)),(3,Aut⁡(W5)),(3,P⋊C8)}, \begin{aligned} \mathcal F=\{& (3,P\rtimes C_4),(2,{}^2B_2(32)),(3,[W_6,W_6]),(2,SL_2(3)),\\ &(3,P\rtimes Q_8),(3,PGL_2(\mathbb F_9)),(2,C_2\times SL_2(8)),(3,W_6),\\ &(3,P\rtimes D_8),(2,{}^2B_2(8)),(3,[W_7,W_7]),(3,\operatorname{Aut}(\mathcal W_{23})),\\ &(2,SL_2(5)),(3,\operatorname{Aut}(W_5)),(3,P\rtimes C_8)\}, \end{aligned} where the indicated semidirect products use the standard faithful embeddings in $GL_2(\mathbb F_3)$. For $(p,H)\in\mathcal F$, form the graph whose vertices are the simple $k_pH$-modules, joining distinct $S,T$ when Ext⁡kpH1(S,T)≠0orExt⁡kpH1(T,S)≠0. \operatorname{Ext}^1_{k_pH}(S,T)\neq0 \quad\text{or}\quad \operatorname{Ext}^1_{k_pH}(T,S)\neq0. Let $\Sigma_{p,H}$ be the connected component containing the trivial module. For $S\in\Sigma_{p,H}$ let $P_S$ be its projective cover and $\widehat P_S$ the corresponding projective indecomposable $\mathcal O_pH$-lift, and set Qp,H=⨁S∈Σp,HP^S,Rp,H=End⁡OpH(Qp,H)op. Q_{p,H}=\bigoplus_{S\in\Sigma_{p,H}}\widehat P_S, \qquad R_{p,H}=\operatorname{End}_{\mathcal O_pH}(Q_{p,H})^{\mathrm{op}}. For an $\mathcal O$-algebra $R$, let $\mathscr W_{\mathcal O}(R)$ be the monoidal groupoid whose objects are $R$-$R$-bimodules $X$, finitely generated projective on both sides, satisfying λx=xλ(λ∈O, x∈X), \lambda x=x\lambda \qquad (\lambda\in\mathcal O,\ x\in X), for which there exists another such bimodule $Y$ with X⊗RY≅R≅Y⊗RX. X\otimes_RY\cong R\cong Y\otimes_RX. Morphisms are bimodule isomorphisms. Let $B_\otimes\mathscr W_{\mathcal O}(R)$ be the classifying space of the corresponding one-object bicategory and put Ω=∏(p,H)∈Fπ1 ⁣(B⊗WOp(Rp,H)). \Omega= \prod_{(p,H)\in\mathcal F} \pi_1\!\left(B_\otimes\mathscr W_{\mathcal O_p}(R_{p,H})\right). Let $N=#^5\mathbf{RP}^2$, and let $\mathfrak F_N(\Omega)$ be the groupoid of principal $\Omega$-bundles on $N$ and their isomorphisms. Compute $|\pi_0\mathfrak F_N(\Omega)|$ and provide the answer in prime-factorized form. Justify your answer.

Weighted rubric

10 points total, one per criterion. Accept valid alternative methods and equivalent representations. Criteria 1–9 require supporting reasoning, which may include correctly applied established theorems or reproducible exact computations. Standard block-Picard classification results may be cited without reproving them. The intermediate descriptions and counts below are grading aids and may be implicit in an equivalent argument. One argument may satisfy several criteria. Any valid method can earn full credit. Criteria 5–9 may also be satisfied jointly by a justified exact orbit count for the full group Ω that accounts for all of its factors. Separate evaluation or reporting of the five displayed factor contributions is not required. An unsupported final answer does not earn these reasoning points. [+1] 1. Principal block. Identifies the Ext-connected component containing the trivial module with the simple modules in the principal p-block, and consequently identifies R_{p,H} as O_p-Morita equivalent to B_0(O_p H), the principal block algebra. A valid equivalent identification of the algebra being used earns credit. [+1] 2. Group defined by the bimodules. Identifies π₁(B_⊗ W_{O_p}(R_{p,H})) with the group of isomorphism classes of invertible O_p-central bimodules, namely Pic_{O_p}(R_{p,H}), and uses the O_p-linear Morita equivalence to obtain the principal-block Picard group. Does not replace this group by the automorphism group of the unit object or allow non-O_p-central bimodules. [+1] 3. Finite group Ω. Correctly obtains, with justification from the groups in F, Ω ≅ C₂¹² × C₃² × C₅ × D₈² × SD₁₆ × S₃ × S₄. Here C_r is cyclic of order r, S_r is the symmetric group, D₈ = ⟨a,b | a⁴=b²=1, bab⁻¹=a⁻¹⟩, and SD₁₆ = ⟨a,b | a⁸=b²=1, bab⁻¹=a³⟩. Powers of groups denote direct products of that many copies. Any isomorphic decomposition is acceptable. [+1] 4. Bundle-counting rule. Counts isomorphism classes of bundles, equivalently simultaneous-conjugacy orbits of tuples (g₁,…,g₅) ∈ G⁵ satisfying g₁²⋯g₅²=1. For example, if h(J) denotes the number of such tuples in a finite group J, a valid rule is c(G)=|G|⁻¹ Σ_{g∈G} h(C_G(g)), where C_G(g) is the centralizer of g. This count is multiplicative over direct products. Simply using h(G)/|G| is not correct, since conjugation need not act freely. [+1] 5. Abelian contribution. Correctly evaluates the contribution of C₂¹² × C₃² × C₅ as 2⁶⁰·3⁸·5⁴. For example, for an abelian group A, the count is c(A)=|A|⁴|A[2]|, where A[2]={a∈A:2a=0} in additive notation. An equivalent direct count earns credit. [+1] 6. Dihedral contribution. Correctly obtains c(D₈)=4864=2⁸·19, so the two copies contribute 4864². One valid calculation is 2(2112)+128+2(256), obtained from the conjugacy-class centralizers. Any justified exact orbit count giving the same contribution is acceptable. [+1] 7. Semidihedral contribution. Correctly obtains c(SD₁₆)=37248=2⁷·3·97. One valid calculation is 2(16896)+3(1024)+256+128. The group must be the semidihedral group specified in criterion 3; replacing it by the dihedral or generalized quaternion group of order 16 is not valid. [+1] 8. S₃ contribution. Correctly obtains c(S₃)=502=2·251. One valid calculation is 459+16+27; an equivalent justified enumeration earns credit. [+1] 9. S₄ contribution. Correctly obtains c(S₄)=32923=11·41·73. One valid calculation is 30400+256+2112+27+128; an equivalent justified enumeration earns credit. [+1] 10. Final answer and requested form. Gives |π₀ F_N(Ω)|=2⁸⁴·3⁹·5⁴·11·19²·41·73·97·251 in prime-factorized form. Accept any ordering of these prime factors. An unfactorized integer alone does not satisfy the requested form. This criterion assesses the final answer; criteria 1–9 assess its justification.

Reference solution

Step 1: For a finite-dimensional algebra, simple modules lying in different blocks have no extensions between them, while the Ext-quiver of each block is connected. Hence the connected components of the graph in the statement are precisely the blocks of $k_pH$. Since $\Sigma_{p,H}$ contains the trivial module, it consists exactly of the simple modules in the principal $p$-block. Therefore Qp,H=⨁S∈Σp,HP^S Q_{p,H}=\bigoplus_{S\in\Sigma_{p,H}}\widehat P_S is a projective generator for $B_0(\mathcal O_pH)$, and Rp,H=End⁡OpH(Qp,H)op R_{p,H}=\operatorname{End}_{\mathcal O_pH}(Q_{p,H})^{\mathrm{op}} is Morita equivalent to $B_0(\mathcal O_pH)$.

Step 2: Every object of $\mathscr W_{\mathcal O}(R)$ is tensor-invertible. Thus $\mathscr W_{\mathcal O}(R)$ is a grouplike monoidal groupoid, and the fundamental group of its one-object delooping is the group of isomorphism classes of its objects: π1 ⁣(B⊗WO(R))≅π0WO(R). \pi_1\!\left(B_\otimes\mathscr W_{\mathcal O}(R)\right) \cong \pi_0\mathscr W_{\mathcal O}(R). The condition $\lambda x=x\lambda$ says precisely that these invertible bimodules are $\mathcal O$-central, so π0WO(R)=Pic⁡O(R). \pi_0\mathscr W_{\mathcal O}(R) = \operatorname{Pic}_{\mathcal O}(R). The Morita equivalence in Step 1 is $\mathcal O_p$-linear and therefore induces Pic⁡Op(Rp,H)≅Pic⁡Op(B0(OpH)). \operatorname{Pic}_{\mathcal O_p}(R_{p,H}) \cong \operatorname{Pic}_{\mathcal O_p}\bigl(B_0(\mathcal O_pH)\bigr). Consequently Ω≅∏(p,H)∈FPic⁡Op(B0(OpH)). \Omega\cong \prod_{(p,H)\in\mathcal F} \operatorname{Pic}_{\mathcal O_p}\bigl(B_0(\mathcal O_pH)\bigr).

Step 3: The disguises in $\mathcal F$ give W6≅S7,W7≅S8,W5≅S6, W_6\cong S_7,\qquad W_7\cong S_8,\qquad W_5\cong S_6, and hence [W6,W6]≅A7,[W7,W7]≅A8,Aut⁡(W5)≅Aut⁡(S6). [W_6,W_6]\cong A_7,\qquad [W_7,W_7]\cong A_8,\qquad \operatorname{Aut}(W_5)\cong\operatorname{Aut}(S_6). Also $\operatorname{Aut}(\mathcal W_{23})\cong M_{23}$.

Step 4: We now use the required integral block-Picard computations from Claudio Marchi, \emph{Picard groups for blocks}, PhD thesis, University of Manchester, 2022. Section 2.1, in particular the summary table on pp. 58--59, gives HPic⁡O3(B0(O3H))P⋊C4C2×D8A7C22P⋊Q8S4PGL2(F9)C22S7C22P⋊D8D8A8C2M231Aut⁡(S6)C22P⋊C8SD16. \begin{array}{c|c} H&\operatorname{Pic}_{\mathcal O_3}(B_0(\mathcal O_3H))\\ \hline P\rtimes C_4&C_2\times D_8\\ A_7&C_2^2\\ P\rtimes Q_8&S_4\\ PGL_2(\mathbb F_9)&C_2^2\\ S_7&C_2^2\\ P\rtimes D_8&D_8\\ A_8&C_2\\ M_{23}&1\\ \operatorname{Aut}(S_6)&C_2^2\\ P\rtimes C_8&SD_{16}. \end{array} For the $2$-blocks, Corollary 2.2.9, Theorem 2.3.6, and Propositions 2.4.1--2.4.2 give HPic⁡O2(B0(O2H))2B2(32)C5SL2(3)S3C2×SL2(8)C2×C32B2(8)C3SL2(5)C2. \begin{array}{c|c} H&\operatorname{Pic}_{\mathcal O_2}(B_0(\mathcal O_2H))\\ \hline {}^2B_2(32)&C_5\\ SL_2(3)&S_3\\ C_2\times SL_2(8)&C_2\times C_3\\ {}^2B_2(8)&C_3\\ SL_2(5)&C_2. \end{array} Multiplying these factors yields Ω≅C212×C32×C5×D82×SD16×S3×S4. \Omega\cong C_2^{12}\times C_3^2\times C_5 \times D_8^2\times SD_{16}\times S_3\times S_4.

Step 5: Put $c(G)=|\pi_0\mathfrak F_N(G)|$. Since π1(N)=⟨x1,x2,x3,x4,x5∣x12x22x32x42x52=1⟩, \pi_1(N)=\langle x_1,x_2,x_3,x_4,x_5\mid x_1^2x_2^2x_3^2x_4^2x_5^2=1\rangle, principal $G$-bundles on $N$ are classified by conjugacy classes of homomorphisms $\pi_1(N)\to G$. Thus c(G)=∣Hom⁡(π1(N),G)/G∣. c(G)=\left|\operatorname{Hom}(\pi_1(N),G)/G\right|. Burnside's lemma gives c(G)=1∣G∣∑g∈G∣Hom⁡(π1(N),CG(g))∣. c(G)=\frac1{|G|}\sum_{g\in G}\left|\operatorname{Hom}\bigl(\pi_1(N),C_G(g)\bigr)\right|. Grouping the sum by conjugacy classes gives the equivalent formula c(G)=∑[g]⊆G∣Hom⁡(π1(N),CG(g))∣∣CG(g)∣. c(G)=\sum_{[g]\subseteq G}\frac{\left|\operatorname{Hom}\bigl(\pi_1(N),C_G(g)\bigr)\right|}{|C_G(g)|}. Moreover $c$ is multiplicative under direct products.

Step 6: For a finite group $H$, define m(H)=∣Hom⁡(π1(N),H)∣∣H∣. m(H)=\frac{|\operatorname{Hom}(\pi_1(N),H)|}{|H|}. If $r(h)=|{x\in H:x^2=h}|$, then the Frobenius--Schur expansion is r=∑χ∈Irr⁡(H)ν2(χ)χ. r=\sum_{\chi\in\operatorname{Irr}(H)}\nu_2(\chi)\chi. Since a homomorphism $\pi_1(N)\to H$ is a $5$-tuple whose squares multiply to $1$, convolution of characters gives ∣Hom⁡(π1(N),H)∣=∣H∣4∑χ∈Irr⁡(H)ν2(χ)χ(1)3, |\operatorname{Hom}(\pi_1(N),H)|=|H|^4\sum_{\chi\in\operatorname{Irr}(H)}\frac{\nu_2(\chi)}{\chi(1)^3}, and hence m(H)=∣H∣3∑χ∈Irr⁡(H)ν2(χ)χ(1)3. m(H)=|H|^3\sum_{\chi\in\operatorname{Irr}(H)}\frac{\nu_2(\chi)}{\chi(1)^3}. Therefore the formula in Step 5 becomes c(G)=∑[g]⊆Gm(CG(g)). c(G)=\sum_{[g]\subseteq G}m(C_G(g)).

Step 7: If $A$ is abelian, conjugation is trivial, so $c(A)=|\operatorname{Hom}(\pi_1(N),A)|$. Writing $A$ additively, the relation is $2(x_1+x_2+x_3+x_4+x_5)=0$. The sum $x_1+\cdots+x_5$ can be any element of $A[2]$, and each prescribed sum has $|A|^4$ preimages. Thus c(A)=∣A∣4∣A[2]∣. c(A)=|A|^4|A[2]|. It follows that c(C212)=260,c(C32)=38,c(C5)=54. c(C_2^{12})=2^{60},\qquad c(C_3^2)=3^8,\qquad c(C_5)=5^4.

Step 8: For the nonabelian factors, first record the masses needed for their centralizers. From Step 6, m(C2)=16,m(C3)=27,m(C4)=128,m(C8)=1024,m(C22)=256. m(C_2)=16,\qquad m(C_3)=27,\qquad m(C_4)=128,\qquad m(C_8)=1024,\qquad m(C_2^2)=256. The group $D_8$ has four real linear characters and one real character of degree $2$, so m(D8)=83(4+18)=2112. m(D_8) = 8^3\left(4+\frac18\right) = 2112. Its conjugacy classes have centralizers D8, D8, C4, C22, C22. D_8,\ D_8,\ C_4,\ C_2^2,\ C_2^2. Therefore c(D8)=2(2112)+128+2(256)=4864=28⋅19. c(D_8)= 2(2112)+128+2(256) = 4864 = 2^8\cdot19.

For SD16=⟨a,b∣a8=b2=1, bab−1=a3⟩, SD_{16}= \langle a,b\mid a^8=b^2=1,\ bab^{-1}=a^3\rangle, there are four real linear characters and three degree-$2$ characters. Two of the latter form a nonreal conjugate pair, while the remaining one has Frobenius--Schur indicator $1$. Hence m(SD16)=163(4+18)=16896. m(SD_{16}) = 16^3\left(4+\frac18\right) =16896. Its seven conjugacy classes have centralizers SD16, SD16, C8, C8, C8, C22, C4. SD_{16},\ SD_{16},\ C_8,\ C_8,\ C_8,\ C_2^2,\ C_4. Thus c(SD16)=2(16896)+3(1024)+256+128=37248=27⋅3⋅97. c(SD_{16}) = 2(16896)+3(1024)+256+128 = 37248 = 2^7\cdot3\cdot97.

Step 9: All irreducible characters of $S_3$ and $S_4$ are realizable over $\mathbb R$. Their degree lists are $1,1,2$ and $1,1,2,3,3$, respectively, so m(S3)=63(2+18)=459, m(S_3) = 6^3\left(2+\frac18\right) = 459, and m(S4)=243(2+18+227)=30400. m(S_4) = 24^3\left(2+\frac18+\frac{2}{27}\right) = 30400. The three conjugacy classes of $S_3$ have centralizers $S_3,\ C_2,\ C_3$, hence c(S3)=459+16+27=502=2⋅251. c(S_3)=459+16+27=502=2\cdot251. The five conjugacy classes of $S_4$, corresponding to cycle types 1,(12),(12)(34),(123),(1234), 1,\quad(12),\quad(12)(34),\quad(123),\quad(1234), have centralizers $S_4,\quad C_2^2,\quad D_8,\quad C_3,\quad C_4$. Therefore c(S4)=30400+256+2112+27+128=32923=11⋅41⋅73. c(S_4) = 30400+256+2112+27+128 = 32923 = 11\cdot41\cdot73.

Step 10: Using the direct-product decomposition from Step 4 and multiplicativity of $c$, ∣π0FN(Ω)∣=260⋅38⋅54⋅(28⋅19)2⋅(27⋅3⋅97)⋅(2⋅251)⋅(11⋅41⋅73). \begin{aligned} \left|\pi_0\mathfrak F_N(\Omega)\right| &= 2^{60}\cdot3^8\cdot5^4 \cdot(2^8\cdot19)^2 \cdot(2^7\cdot3\cdot97)\\ &\qquad\cdot(2\cdot251) \cdot(11\cdot41\cdot73). \end{aligned} Collecting prime powers gives ∣π0FN(Ω)∣=284⋅39⋅54⋅11⋅192⋅41⋅73⋅97⋅251. \left|\pi_0\mathfrak F_N(\Omega)\right| = 2^{84}\cdot3^9\cdot5^4 \cdot11\cdot19^2\cdot41\cdot73\cdot97\cdot251.

Final Answer: $2^{84}\cdot3^9\cdot5^4\cdot11\cdot19^2\cdot41\cdot73\cdot97\cdot251$