|
Download source/docs/PUBLIC_API_RESULTS.md from PureOne/Qyxo-Zhaenivoth-Guard: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 13.1 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/PureOne/Qyxo-Zhaenivoth-Guard/resolve/main/source/docs/PUBLIC_API_RESULTS.md
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/PureOne/Qyxo-Zhaenivoth-Guard/source/docs/PUBLIC_API_RESULTS.md
-
curl -L -o PUBLIC_API_RESULTS.md https://huggingface.co/datasets/PureOne/Qyxo-Zhaenivoth-Guard/resolve/main/source/docs/PUBLIC_API_RESULTS.md
13.1 kB
| # Public API v0.2 measured results | |
| `PreparedBank.evaluate` preserves the useful prepared-bank speed advantage when | |
| mass updates arrive as NumPy arrays. After specializing validation of builtin | |
| numbers, four-output Python-list cells also meet the measured threefold gate; | |
| scalar-list cells remain below it. The JSONL interface decodes updates to Python | |
| lists; the array timings do not describe JSONL throughput. | |
| These are measurements of one frozen implementation on one machine, not a new | |
| mathematical novelty claim or a cross-platform performance guarantee. The | |
| filter inherits the conditional IEEE/NumPy contract described in | |
| [FILTER_THEORY.md](FILTER_THEORY.md): an accepted sign is guaranteed under those | |
| premises, and unsafe or inconclusive signs use exact integer fallback. This | |
| run's ordinary cases all used accepted signs. Existing hostile boundary tests | |
| and measurements remain necessary evidence for the fallback path. | |
| ## Paired protocol and integrity | |
| The protocol was fixed before timing: cells `(M,P) = (2048,1), (2048,4), | |
| (8192,1), (8192,4)`; seeds 10–19; one policy per fresh mass box; five paired | |
| fresh-box repeats after one excluded warmup. Static values are reused. All | |
| methods see the same finite binary64 values, mass intervals and thresholds. | |
| The policy sequence, both relations, and thresholds strictly inside the value | |
| hull are inherited unchanged from the earlier heldout protocol. Numerical data | |
| and generator/baseline source hashes match `results_holdout.json` for every | |
| case. The two input containers have identical binary64 payloads. | |
| There are ten independent seed groups within each cell. The same seeds are | |
| reused across cells and containers; those groups are not 80 independent | |
| datasets. Method order is shuffled separately for each paired fresh box. Each | |
| method is timed around its whole public call, including mass conversion, | |
| validation, native computation and result assembly. Input arrays or lists are | |
| already supplied in the declared format; their caller-side conversion is not | |
| charged to the operation. Installation, process startup, imports and file I/O | |
| are outside the timing boundary. | |
| The exact peers are prepared GMP rational direct support, prepared integer | |
| sharp endpoint computation followed by the decision, and prepared Python | |
| `Fraction` direct support. The integer endpoint peer stops at the first exactly | |
| valid classical sorted switch; it does not needlessly materialize every vertex | |
| as a rational. The fastest exact peer is chosen per seed using its complete | |
| cost at 1000 updates. GMP won all 80 comparisons. This oracle frontier is a | |
| conservative comparison for QZ, rather than a proposed deployable method | |
| selector. An adaptive certified NumPy/C++ peer has not been measured. Ordinary | |
| uncertified NumPy arithmetic is not an equivalent guarantee contract. | |
| The run checked 7200 coordinate predicates across the five timed methods and | |
| the CLI record path; all agree with integer sharp endpoint decisions. Public | |
| and native filter route counts are each 1200 accepted coordinate decisions, | |
| including excluded warmups, with zero exact fallbacks. No source file changed | |
| during timing. Public constructor cost and every exact peer's static | |
| preparation are charged once in the amortized comparison. | |
| ## Algorithm calls | |
| Times are medians across ten seed-group medians. The speedup is the median of | |
| paired seed-group ratios, **not** the ratio of the table's population medians. | |
| Each ratio includes its method's static preparation divided by 1000 updates. | |
| The bootstrap lower bounds use 10,000 resamples of seed groups, fixed bootstrap | |
| seed 871 and one-sided alpha 0.0125, correcting four cells separately for each | |
| declared container. This approximate bootstrap does not establish an eight-cell | |
| joint guarantee or general performance on arbitrary inputs. | |
| | NumPy arrays: M × P | Public call (ms) | Native call (ms) | GMP call (ms) | Paired speedup | Corrected lower bound | 3× gate | | |
| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---| | |
| | 2048 × 1 | 0.226 | 0.195 | 2.105 | 9.59× | 7.76× | Pass | | |
| | 2048 × 4 | 0.494 | 0.437 | 4.807 | 10.04× | 8.93× | Pass | | |
| | 8192 × 1 | 0.329 | 0.340 | 8.195 | 24.18× | 20.90× | Pass | | |
| | 8192 × 4 | 1.283 | 1.308 | 20.143 | 15.23× | 14.49× | Pass | | |
| The smallest individual ndarray seed-group ratio was 6.61×. Minimum ratios by | |
| cell were 6.61×, 8.64×, 19.35× and 14.26×. These cells reuse the previous heldout | |
| numerical workloads; the results measure the new interface, rather than adding | |
| new independent numerical validation datasets. The larger speedups than the | |
| earlier tuple-input experiment reflect a different supplied container and its | |
| conversion costs; they should not be treated as an algorithmic improvement. | |
| | Python lists: M × P | Public call (ms) | Native call (ms) | GMP call (ms) | Paired speedup | Corrected lower bound | 3× gate | | |
| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---| | |
| | 2048 × 1 | 0.806 | 0.350 | 1.912 | 2.38× | 2.23× | Fail | | |
| | 2048 × 4 | 1.083 | 0.639 | 4.855 | 4.56× | 4.18× | Pass | | |
| | 8192 × 1 | 2.830 | 0.994 | 7.877 | 2.78× | 2.65× | Fail | | |
| | 8192 × 4 | 3.888 | 2.020 | 19.376 | 4.87× | 4.74× | Pass | | |
| Lists pass through element-level public validation. The builtin-number | |
| specialization reduces that cost, but scalar-list calls still fail the | |
| threefold gate. Users seeking the strongest measured fast path should supply | |
| numeric NumPy arrays. The following paired differences describe wrapper and | |
| public validation costs together; they do not isolate a universal fixed | |
| overhead. Differences between population and paired summaries reflect timing | |
| noise and the order of aggregation, rather than negative computational work. | |
| | M × P | Array public−native (µs) | Array public/native | List public−native (ms) | List public/native | | |
| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:| | |
| | 2048 × 1 | 43.0 | 1.33× | 0.461 | 2.36× | | |
| | 2048 × 4 | 10.5 | 1.03× | 0.447 | 1.72× | | |
| | 8192 × 1 | 19.0 | 1.08× | 1.823 | 2.85× | | |
| | 8192 × 4 | 25.0 | 1.02× | 1.924 | 1.91× | | |
| ## Preserved initial revision | |
| The initial complete 80-case run is retained as | |
| [results_public_api_initial.json](../benchmarks/results_public_api_initial.json). | |
| Its wrapper source is retained in | |
| [history/public_initial.py](../benchmarks/history/public_initial.py), with | |
| disposable-copy reconstruction instructions in | |
| [history/README.md](../benchmarks/history/README.md). | |
| All list cells failed its threefold gate, and its scalar-list calls were slower | |
| than GMP. The final revision moves exact builtin `float`/`int` checks ahead of | |
| NumPy dispatch and the `Real` abstract-base-class checks. Subclasses and | |
| ambiguous inputs retain strict validation; mappings and unordered sets are | |
| also explicitly rejected, and were absent from the benchmark inputs. Only | |
| `qzguard/public.py` changed | |
| between these runs; numerical kernels, harness, generated/serialized data and | |
| shuffled method orders match. Source hashes and the initial negative evidence | |
| are retained. The strengthening was selected after observing that initial | |
| result, so the final list experiment is an engineering revision on the same | |
| cases, not an independent confirmatory dataset. | |
| | Python lists: M × P | Initial public call (ms) | Final public call (ms) | Initial paired speedup | Final paired speedup | | |
| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:| | |
| | 2048 × 1 | 2.593 | 0.806 | 0.80× | 2.38× | | |
| | 2048 × 4 | 2.963 | 1.083 | 1.77× | 4.56× | | |
| | 8192 × 1 | 9.927 | 2.830 | 0.82× | 2.78× | | |
| | 8192 × 4 | 10.874 | 3.888 | 1.79× | 4.87× | | |
| The initial ndarray paired speedups were 10.52×, 9.99×, 25.01× and 15.40×, | |
| with all gates passing. Array validation takes the same dtype path in both | |
| revisions. Variations in these repeated array timings demonstrate ordinary | |
| measurement noise. The isolated validation microbenchmark is engineering | |
| evidence and does not establish a universal fivefold application speedup. | |
| ## Construction, first use and retained state | |
| The public constructor is timed separately, including static value validation | |
| and template creation. First-box columns are static preparation plus the | |
| measured group-median call; they do not include a fresh process or import. | |
| Every table entry is a median over seed groups, so adding two table medians may | |
| not equal the median of their sums. | |
| | M × P | Array setup (ms) | Array first box (ms) | List setup (ms) | List first box (ms) | Estimated public payload (KiB) | | |
| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | |
| | 2048 × 1 | 1.984 | 2.192 | 5.378 | 6.255 | 64.9 | | |
| | 2048 × 4 | 1.998 | 2.459 | 7.029 | 8.102 | 160.9 | | |
| | 8192 × 1 | 7.350 | 7.635 | 22.007 | 24.915 | 256.9 | | |
| | 8192 × 4 | 7.770 | 9.122 | 29.498 | 33.319 | 640.9 | | |
| Retained state is an estimate of reachable Python/NumPy payload, not peak RSS | |
| or native allocator accounting. The public estimate counts its owned native | |
| template and wrapper object, excluding the shared NumPy module handle. It is | |
| 72 bytes greater than the corresponding native estimate under this estimator. | |
| Exact peer construction and payload estimates are available for every seed in | |
| the raw JSON. GMP setup medians for array inputs were 5.34, 9.42, 21.42 and | |
| 39.70 ms, and its corresponding first-box totals were 7.51, 14.32, 29.60 and | |
| 59.88 ms. The scalar 2048-row list public first-box total remains above GMP's | |
| 5.36 ms, even though its warm call is faster. | |
| ## JSONL transport costs | |
| The benchmark separately invokes the actual strict JSON decoder/schema | |
| validation and CLI evaluation/record construction helpers. JSON numbers round | |
| trip to the identical binary64 mass payloads; decoded updates are Python | |
| lists. The JSONL path explicitly uses `backend="filtered"`; the CLI's ordinary | |
| default backend is exact. This is an in-memory boundary: it excludes subprocess | |
| startup, imports, file reads/writes and an OS pipe. It is therefore not a claim | |
| about end-to-end executable throughput. | |
| The table uses the list-input groups; equivalent JSONL payloads were also | |
| measured in the array-input groups and are retained in the JSON. Encode timings | |
| are separate from decode/evaluate and should not be subtracted from algorithm | |
| timings. Output encoding includes the newline. | |
| | M × P | Update size (kB) | Input encode (ms) | Strict decode/schema (ms) | Decode + CLI evaluate (ms) | Output encode (ms) | | |
| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | |
| | 2048 × 1 | 77.18 | 1.512 | 1.318 | 2.100 | 0.013 | | |
| | 2048 × 4 | 77.19 | 1.530 | 1.309 | 2.330 | 0.018 | | |
| | 8192 × 1 | 308.47 | 6.252 | 5.355 | 8.077 | 0.021 | | |
| | 8192 × 4 | 308.51 | 6.210 | 5.173 | 8.698 | 0.027 | | |
| One-time static bank JSON decode medians were 2.41, 7.44, 9.96 and 25.88 ms for | |
| payloads of approximately 88.7, 329.8, 354.4 and 1319.3 kB respectively. These | |
| decode costs are separate from `PreparedBank` construction. Initial decode+ | |
| CLI-evaluate times were 3.953, 4.204, 14.849 and 15.573 ms; the specialization | |
| improves that application boundary as well. This experiment does not establish | |
| a JSONL speedup over an equivalent exact peer's complete JSONL pipeline. | |
| ## Reproduction and limits | |
| From the package root, with benchmark-only dependencies installed: | |
| ```bash | |
| OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS=1 OMP_NUM_THREADS=1 MKL_NUM_THREADS=1 \ | |
| python benchmarks/run_public_api.py | |
| ``` | |
| The run used Python 3.12.14, NumPy 2.3.5, gmpy2 2.3.1 and | |
| Linux 6.18.44 x86-64/glibc 2.39. Nine logical CPUs were visible; thread | |
| environment variables were each 1 and other agents did no CPU-heavy work | |
| during the exclusive timing window. The measured invocation also supplied | |
| `PYTHONPATH=/workspace/scratch/eb8f8ee30051/tmp/guard_benchmark_deps` for the | |
| benchmark-only GMP installation. That machine-specific path is not required | |
| for public installations. | |
| Raw results: [results_public_api.json](../benchmarks/results_public_api.json). | |
| Harness: [run_public_api.py](../benchmarks/run_public_api.py). The raw result | |
| SHA-256 is | |
| `475163c9b050fa709406493d16c9d87e083f66c6761adeac92108406048aa870`. | |
| The file records source hashes, environment, shuffled method orders, every | |
| paired sample, static construction costs, route counts and historical fixture | |
| identities. Both the historical generator and exact baseline hashes match. | |
| The initial result SHA-256 is | |
| `f714161fa3546edc752a7984871f0b7678eb50de6d978d5c97ac1f6653ed0ded`. | |
| Initial/final `public.py` hashes are respectively | |
| `49fa14aea5f57c7e1b6077ecf72f4fa843fb09a767690fea61ccb6ebabac0567` | |
| and `5cec1400e911977a7d6857e2692b69cccd55f63d37c63069f32050e8d67e42f0`. | |
| The supported performance statement is limited to reused static values, | |
| fresh mass intervals, one policy, these ordinary array-input workloads, this | |
| running-process environment and the measured exact peers. It excludes exact | |
| support margins and witnesses, which force exact work, and does not imply a | |
| gain on cancellation-heavy inputs, tiny banks, many policies on an unchanged | |
| box, repeated full-bank construction or specialized compiled certified peers. | |
| For unchanged boxes with many thresholds, computing exact sharp endpoints | |
| once and caching them remains a strong alternative. The previous negative | |
| constructor, cached-endpoint, boundary-fallback and exploratory real-data | |
| results remain part of the release evidence. | |