srt-depth-probe-artifacts / sugarcrepe_layer_sweep.json
RiverRider's picture
depth-probe artifacts: probe-dependent layer ranking, scaling curves, SugarCrepe fitted re-test, banked null
9497609 verified
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
5.64 kB
{
"question": "does the object/arrangement spectrum shift with depth",
"arm": "head-free, pool-mean centred cosine on raw states",
"control": "L47 must reproduce sugarcrepe_diagnostic_20260806.json sep: swap_obj 0.396, replace_obj 0.582, swap_att 0.498, replace_rel 0.485",
"sep_note": "sep = mean cos(positive, negative caption), lower is better separated",
"backbone": "google/gemma-4-31B-it",
"layers": [
4,
12,
20,
28,
36,
44,
47,
54,
60
],
"results": {
"L4": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.5679,
"sep": 0.5654,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.5436,
"sep": 0.3819,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5457,
"sep": 0.5877,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.5139,
"sep": 0.4983,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.522,
"sep": 0.5185,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.488,
"sep": 0.5789,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.4531,
"sep": 0.5517,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.5192
},
"L12": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.5332,
"sep": 0.649,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.5466,
"sep": 0.5035,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5508,
"sep": 0.6551,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.5285,
"sep": 0.6039,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.4957,
"sep": 0.5967,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.4775,
"sep": 0.6318,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.4449,
"sep": 0.6076,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.511
},
"L20": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.5289,
"sep": 0.7108,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.5752,
"sep": 0.5293,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5533,
"sep": 0.7096,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.5708,
"sep": 0.6664,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.6017,
"sep": 0.5633,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.5135,
"sep": 0.6603,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.4776,
"sep": 0.6152,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.5459
},
"L28": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.4855,
"sep": 0.6382,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.5407,
"sep": 0.4193,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5368,
"sep": 0.6512,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.5333,
"sep": 0.6085,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.5455,
"sep": 0.4954,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.5225,
"sep": 0.5494,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.5429,
"sep": 0.4414,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.5296
},
"L36": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.5029,
"sep": 0.6385,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.5917,
"sep": 0.4463,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5381,
"sep": 0.6378,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.5611,
"sep": 0.6106,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.6017,
"sep": 0.4958,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.47,
"sep": 0.5449,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.5673,
"sep": 0.4561,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.5475
},
"L44": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.4957,
"sep": 0.6146,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.5689,
"sep": 0.4452,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5343,
"sep": 0.6336,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.6168,
"sep": 0.5973,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.6024,
"sep": 0.5022,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.536,
"sep": 0.513,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.5143,
"sep": 0.4154,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.5526
},
"L47": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.5058,
"sep": 0.5973,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.5684,
"sep": 0.4326,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5381,
"sep": 0.616,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.6138,
"sep": 0.5826,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.5996,
"sep": 0.4854,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.5465,
"sep": 0.4975,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.4939,
"sep": 0.3949,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.5523
},
"L54": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.5694,
"sep": 0.5229,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.5664,
"sep": 0.3895,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5939,
"sep": 0.5514,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.6659,
"sep": 0.518,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.6095,
"sep": 0.4494,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.527,
"sep": 0.4402,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.4531,
"sep": 0.3432,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.5693
},
"L60": {
"add_att": {
"acc": 0.5202,
"sep": 0.4547,
"n": 692
},
"add_obj": {
"acc": 0.4777,
"sep": 0.3392,
"n": 2062
},
"replace_att": {
"acc": 0.5431,
"sep": 0.4894,
"n": 788
},
"replace_obj": {
"acc": 0.5406,
"sep": 0.4587,
"n": 1652
},
"replace_rel": {
"acc": 0.5128,
"sep": 0.4254,
"n": 1406
},
"swap_att": {
"acc": 0.5435,
"sep": 0.3654,
"n": 666
},
"swap_obj": {
"acc": 0.5184,
"sep": 0.2617,
"n": 245
},
"macro_acc": 0.5223
}
},
"n_images": 1560,
"n_captions": 11844,
"n_pairs": 7511
}