amaru-source / docs /wiring-rationale.md
betterwithage's picture
mirror github.com/szl-holdings/amaru@779a0d7e4e69
a8b4b87 verified

WIRING_RATIONALE.md — CHAKANA v3 Spine Canonical Wiring

Maxwell Rigidity Result

Parameter Value
Nodes (j) 9
Edges (b) 21
M = b − 3j + 6 0
Verdict PASS — isostatic (minimally rigid)

Directed vs. Undirected — Caveat

The Maxwell criterion (M = b − 3j + 6 = 0) is classically defined for undirected constraint graphs in structural mechanics (rigidity theory, Laman's theorem). Applying it to a directed graph is an architectural convention, not a formal proof of rigidity.

Our choice: directed edges.

AMARU is a directional cognitive pipeline; every edge carries a semantic flow direction (e.g., KALLPA → YACHAY means "energy primes retrieval", not the reverse). Collapsing that to undirected would erase architectural meaning.

Mitigating convention: The 21-edge count still satisfies M = 0 whether treated as directed or undirected (same count). The directed interpretation adds semantic precision without breaking the numeric criterion. Any future formal rigidity proof should use the undirected projection.


Bracing Edge Justifications (13 edges)

# Edge Justification
1 KALLPA → HATUN Sovereignty gate informs energy budget; the crown's continuum hash constrains how much energy the root may allocate in the next tick.
2 NAWI → RIMAY Toolcall results (external reads) flow back into the proposal layer; NAWI's boundary data reshapes what RIMAY can assert.
3 NAWI → YUYAY Toolcall results bypass proposal and pass directly to the critique gate; YUYAY can reject on boundary evidence alone.
4 YACHAY → YUYAY Retrieved priors (codex facts) are checked at the heart gate; YUYAY validates proposals against memory, not just logic.
5 YACHAY → RUWAY Codex updates that survive the gate are committed to the record via RUWAY; storage without serpent detour.
6 KALLPA → YUYAY Energy budget gates critique cost; YUYAY cannot run expensive multi-pass critique if KALLPA signals low energy.
7 KALLPA → RUWAY Commit action has an energy toll; RUWAY checks KALLPA's available budget before finalising any write.
8 HATUN → YUYAY The HUKLLA continuum hash flows to the heart gate so YUYAY can validate proposals against the canonical sovereign state.
9 MUSQUY → YUYAY If critique flags a simulation fault, YUYAY can request re-simulation; this edge carries the re-simulate signal.
10 MUSQUY → YACHAY Simulation consults the codex mid-flight; intermediate simulation states pull from YACHAY to avoid stale priors.
11 MUSQUY → KALLPA Simulation declares its energy cost upfront; KALLPA must acknowledge budget before MUSQUY proceeds.
12 HATUN → NAWI Sovereignty governs the external boundary; HATUN authorises which reads NAWI may open, preventing unbounded toolcall escalation.
13 TUKUY → NAWI Action-out is symmetric to action-in; an outbound action triggers the same boundary-crossing record in NAWI that an inbound toolcall would.

Edges Not Selected (and why)

Candidate Reason not chosen
YUYAY ↔ RUWAY (as brace) Already Serpent-5; would be a duplicate.
TUKUY → HATUN (as brace) Already Serpent-7; would be a duplicate — originally selected in error, replaced by HATUN→NAWI.
TUKUY ↔ SENTRA-egress SENTRA is infrastructure, not a chakra node; excluded per task specification.

Full Edge List (21)

Base Serpent (8)

# Edge Role
S1 KALLPA → YACHAY Energy primes retrieval
S2 YACHAY → MUSQUY Codex feeds simulation
S3 MUSQUY → RIMAY Simulation drives proposal
S4 RIMAY → YUYAY Proposal enters critique gate
S5 YUYAY → RUWAY Gate approval triggers commit
S6 RUWAY → TUKUY Commit hands off to action-out
S7 TUKUY → HATUN Outbound action crowned by sovereignty
S8 HATUN → KALLPA Cycle close — sovereign hash seeds next tick

Bracing (13)

# Edge
B1 KALLPA → HATUN
B2 NAWI → RIMAY
B3 NAWI → YUYAY
B4 YACHAY → YUYAY
B5 YACHAY → RUWAY
B6 KALLPA → YUYAY
B7 KALLPA → RUWAY
B8 HATUN → YUYAY
B9 MUSQUY → YUYAY
B10 MUSQUY → YACHAY
B11 MUSQUY → KALLPA
B12 HATUN → NAWI
B13 TUKUY → NAWI