ThomasHeisig commited on
Commit
d0bd23b
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): ba8d702

Sync GitHub main 963d68d523b38096619e41743c8c4b5b2ac1d42c (part 2)

Browse files
This view is limited to 50 files because it contains too many changes.   See raw diff
Files changed (50) hide show
  1. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/DATA/current_run.json +11 -0
  2. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/DATA/runs_compact.json +374 -0
  3. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/DATA/runs_index.json +127 -0
  4. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001211610885260-c2fce764.json +76 -0
  5. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211542537168-c2fce764.json +75 -0
  6. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001211731555494-c2fce764.json +76 -0
  7. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/ai_packet.json +707 -0
  8. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/ai_packet_digest.json +7 -0
  9. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/statistics.json +318 -0
  10. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/manifest.json +127 -0
  11. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/report.md +35 -0
  12. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json +1573 -0
  13. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md +1379 -0
  14. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.review.json +8 -0
  15. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/summary.md +209 -0
  16. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/workflow.json +30 -0
  17. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/DATA/current_run.json +11 -0
  18. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/DATA/runs_compact.json +374 -0
  19. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/DATA/runs_index.json +127 -0
  20. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212114421558-0fc176ff.json +90 -0
  21. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211934552323-0fc176ff.json +54 -0
  22. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212304545660-0fc176ff.json +54 -0
  23. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/ai_packet.json +707 -0
  24. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/ai_packet_digest.json +7 -0
  25. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/statistics.json +318 -0
  26. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/manifest.json +127 -0
  27. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/report.md +35 -0
  28. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json +1451 -0
  29. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md +1286 -0
  30. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.review.json +8 -0
  31. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/summary.md +215 -0
  32. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/workflow.json +30 -0
  33. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/DATA/current_run.json +11 -0
  34. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/DATA/runs_compact.json +374 -0
  35. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/DATA/runs_index.json +127 -0
  36. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212516252293-09c3f8b9.json +96 -0
  37. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001212341683225-09c3f8b9.json +96 -0
  38. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212701063609-09c3f8b9.json +96 -0
  39. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/ai_packet.json +707 -0
  40. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/ai_packet_digest.json +7 -0
  41. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/statistics.json +318 -0
  42. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/manifest.json +127 -0
  43. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/report.md +35 -0
  44. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json +1605 -0
  45. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md +1350 -0
  46. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.review.json +8 -0
  47. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/summary.md +224 -0
  48. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/workflow.json +30 -0
  49. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03/DATA/current_run.json +11 -0
  50. research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03/DATA/runs_compact.json +374 -0
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/DATA/current_run.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "last_archived_run": 11,
3
+ "raw_artifact": {
4
+ "format": "json.gz",
5
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
6
+ "sha256": "9a1abcc35a0f29ef800de2313813f3d9cbd3fa19dc6820391ddaab8b134bbf2c",
7
+ "size_bytes": 514,
8
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
9
+ },
10
+ "status": "idle"
11
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/DATA/runs_compact.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,374 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ [
2
+ {
3
+ "_raw_artifact": {
4
+ "format": "json.gz",
5
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
6
+ "sha256": "81e5562696f1151db42357892d1a3102987df60256e26632b33946c1fec92bac",
7
+ "size_bytes": 520,
8
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
9
+ },
10
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
11
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
12
+ "metrics": {
13
+ "audit_complete": false,
14
+ "audit_item": 1,
15
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
16
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
17
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
18
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
19
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
20
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
21
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
22
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
23
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
24
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
25
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
26
+ "snn_involved": false
27
+ },
28
+ "runtime_error": null,
29
+ "seed": 101,
30
+ "state_digest_after": "1ef14aec911a59d248f0981fca2ec80e39071b41275a60ed0ee16e21ce691728",
31
+ "state_digest_before": "1ef14aec911a59d248f0981fca2ec80e39071b41275a60ed0ee16e21ce691728"
32
+ },
33
+ {
34
+ "_raw_artifact": {
35
+ "format": "json.gz",
36
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
37
+ "sha256": "07d9d0632d8a99a29717e86d59eb9482c868ff19edbe47a8311ff5f9822273dd",
38
+ "size_bytes": 516,
39
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
40
+ },
41
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
42
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
43
+ "metrics": {
44
+ "audit_complete": false,
45
+ "audit_item": 2,
46
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
47
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
48
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
49
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
50
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
51
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
52
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
53
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
54
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
55
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
56
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
57
+ "snn_involved": false
58
+ },
59
+ "runtime_error": null,
60
+ "seed": 101,
61
+ "state_digest_after": "3ed0d926fc42e2527e649771ae03cbe89afc97c5530aab28160bb0148ebefa0f",
62
+ "state_digest_before": "3ed0d926fc42e2527e649771ae03cbe89afc97c5530aab28160bb0148ebefa0f"
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "_raw_artifact": {
66
+ "format": "json.gz",
67
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
68
+ "sha256": "20a85b3b25d8be07e9241c2017939fc28490efe411e6cb9ca74d5f97aac5766f",
69
+ "size_bytes": 516,
70
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
71
+ },
72
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
73
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
74
+ "metrics": {
75
+ "audit_complete": false,
76
+ "audit_item": 3,
77
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
78
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
79
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
80
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
81
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
82
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
83
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
84
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
85
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
86
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
87
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
88
+ "snn_involved": false
89
+ },
90
+ "runtime_error": null,
91
+ "seed": 101,
92
+ "state_digest_after": "bb45c009deb085e34bd4317fdf646cda28a66b3294d80b284623fbb3ad3eddee",
93
+ "state_digest_before": "bb45c009deb085e34bd4317fdf646cda28a66b3294d80b284623fbb3ad3eddee"
94
+ },
95
+ {
96
+ "_raw_artifact": {
97
+ "format": "json.gz",
98
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
99
+ "sha256": "3637b6f1034dfad21cd7036d7cb21c6b4b92c5cca278b5f0e03c5bb213913f54",
100
+ "size_bytes": 510,
101
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
102
+ },
103
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
104
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
105
+ "metrics": {
106
+ "audit_complete": false,
107
+ "audit_item": 4,
108
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
109
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
110
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
111
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
112
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
113
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
114
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
115
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
116
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
117
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
118
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
119
+ "snn_involved": false
120
+ },
121
+ "runtime_error": null,
122
+ "seed": 101,
123
+ "state_digest_after": "c0b6ed6204b2bf69a84b16ebae0aeb0b92504b900100b878d9fbe006abdc78ac",
124
+ "state_digest_before": "c0b6ed6204b2bf69a84b16ebae0aeb0b92504b900100b878d9fbe006abdc78ac"
125
+ },
126
+ {
127
+ "_raw_artifact": {
128
+ "format": "json.gz",
129
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
130
+ "sha256": "b0f32e7b33203876783d6c3ec669f615b07a0de2f3d0518603919525f4828aee",
131
+ "size_bytes": 522,
132
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
133
+ },
134
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
135
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
136
+ "metrics": {
137
+ "audit_complete": false,
138
+ "audit_item": 1,
139
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
140
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
141
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
142
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
143
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
144
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
145
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
146
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
147
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
148
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
149
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
150
+ "snn_involved": false
151
+ },
152
+ "runtime_error": null,
153
+ "seed": 102,
154
+ "state_digest_after": "fad51d00949f8dea2f2bba89f1ed19142f9bdf99f193ae0653fcf877dc8d7021",
155
+ "state_digest_before": "fad51d00949f8dea2f2bba89f1ed19142f9bdf99f193ae0653fcf877dc8d7021"
156
+ },
157
+ {
158
+ "_raw_artifact": {
159
+ "format": "json.gz",
160
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
161
+ "sha256": "cebce3c9d034d317af9496a9e92cd9b712bbdee88365b53e2438c8ab5b56e901",
162
+ "size_bytes": 520,
163
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
164
+ },
165
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
166
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
167
+ "metrics": {
168
+ "audit_complete": false,
169
+ "audit_item": 2,
170
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
171
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
172
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
173
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
174
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
175
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
176
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
177
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
178
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
179
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
180
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
181
+ "snn_involved": false
182
+ },
183
+ "runtime_error": null,
184
+ "seed": 102,
185
+ "state_digest_after": "d3d7f4002724b04913944be8eef040763b3e97948db5674fadf6efb50379e984",
186
+ "state_digest_before": "d3d7f4002724b04913944be8eef040763b3e97948db5674fadf6efb50379e984"
187
+ },
188
+ {
189
+ "_raw_artifact": {
190
+ "format": "json.gz",
191
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
192
+ "sha256": "76aee636c74c65d14c3bb3f1f3634f312163296b408550c5d2231793471167e5",
193
+ "size_bytes": 519,
194
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
195
+ },
196
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
197
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
198
+ "metrics": {
199
+ "audit_complete": false,
200
+ "audit_item": 3,
201
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
202
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
203
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
204
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
205
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
206
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
207
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
208
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
209
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
210
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
211
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
212
+ "snn_involved": false
213
+ },
214
+ "runtime_error": null,
215
+ "seed": 102,
216
+ "state_digest_after": "3281377b9eb44f4e8493278fe87515d67c08f9a709cf04c09b7a93b4164dfe0f",
217
+ "state_digest_before": "3281377b9eb44f4e8493278fe87515d67c08f9a709cf04c09b7a93b4164dfe0f"
218
+ },
219
+ {
220
+ "_raw_artifact": {
221
+ "format": "json.gz",
222
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
223
+ "sha256": "52765aaa9348258d2dd082feae8ab61a3f2d23d9e1c2995166b0e0128240e909",
224
+ "size_bytes": 514,
225
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
226
+ },
227
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
228
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
229
+ "metrics": {
230
+ "audit_complete": false,
231
+ "audit_item": 4,
232
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
233
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
234
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
235
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
236
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
237
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
238
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
239
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
240
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
241
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
242
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
243
+ "snn_involved": false
244
+ },
245
+ "runtime_error": null,
246
+ "seed": 102,
247
+ "state_digest_after": "2639bce5fab1134131f33fdf8fa7304ae9c1e420508f068bc5e466923625c150",
248
+ "state_digest_before": "2639bce5fab1134131f33fdf8fa7304ae9c1e420508f068bc5e466923625c150"
249
+ },
250
+ {
251
+ "_raw_artifact": {
252
+ "format": "json.gz",
253
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
254
+ "sha256": "d489f1020c43876f3616f472f7793cf202b2f4305374f4bf34dd7e2582ae5514",
255
+ "size_bytes": 522,
256
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
257
+ },
258
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
259
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
260
+ "metrics": {
261
+ "audit_complete": false,
262
+ "audit_item": 1,
263
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
264
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
265
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
266
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
267
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
268
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
269
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
270
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
271
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
272
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
273
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
274
+ "snn_involved": false
275
+ },
276
+ "runtime_error": null,
277
+ "seed": 103,
278
+ "state_digest_after": "03874a794a7964212ed6625910afba8e8d432a090213039055b9c6e0559d77e9",
279
+ "state_digest_before": "03874a794a7964212ed6625910afba8e8d432a090213039055b9c6e0559d77e9"
280
+ },
281
+ {
282
+ "_raw_artifact": {
283
+ "format": "json.gz",
284
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
285
+ "sha256": "721aab27d61c9cabdcdacd849d72ae2fd33a903b90a5cf5bcd60c98d1b4c40fb",
286
+ "size_bytes": 518,
287
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
288
+ },
289
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
290
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
291
+ "metrics": {
292
+ "audit_complete": false,
293
+ "audit_item": 2,
294
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
295
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
296
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
297
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
298
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
299
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
300
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
301
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
302
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
303
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
304
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
305
+ "snn_involved": false
306
+ },
307
+ "runtime_error": null,
308
+ "seed": 103,
309
+ "state_digest_after": "a4cb4ef1e0d17ffad54183e3cf98295d9ab759d39aa8f1a158710e0e4c67d6d9",
310
+ "state_digest_before": "a4cb4ef1e0d17ffad54183e3cf98295d9ab759d39aa8f1a158710e0e4c67d6d9"
311
+ },
312
+ {
313
+ "_raw_artifact": {
314
+ "format": "json.gz",
315
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
316
+ "sha256": "4a1d252a132d60bb28a8ef00d1f0ef7d6c8790143067c6c918713d9d43323a69",
317
+ "size_bytes": 519,
318
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
319
+ },
320
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
321
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
322
+ "metrics": {
323
+ "audit_complete": false,
324
+ "audit_item": 3,
325
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
326
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
327
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
328
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
329
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
330
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
331
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
332
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
333
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
334
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
335
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
336
+ "snn_involved": false
337
+ },
338
+ "runtime_error": null,
339
+ "seed": 103,
340
+ "state_digest_after": "50d47f5746278ad20cd624b146de8a136ac48d2727049f8f9f2df16866a2f780",
341
+ "state_digest_before": "50d47f5746278ad20cd624b146de8a136ac48d2727049f8f9f2df16866a2f780"
342
+ },
343
+ {
344
+ "_raw_artifact": {
345
+ "format": "json.gz",
346
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
347
+ "sha256": "9a1abcc35a0f29ef800de2313813f3d9cbd3fa19dc6820391ddaab8b134bbf2c",
348
+ "size_bytes": 514,
349
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
350
+ },
351
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
352
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
353
+ "metrics": {
354
+ "audit_complete": false,
355
+ "audit_item": 4,
356
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
357
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
358
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
359
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
360
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
361
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
362
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
363
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
364
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
365
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
366
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
367
+ "snn_involved": false
368
+ },
369
+ "runtime_error": null,
370
+ "seed": 103,
371
+ "state_digest_after": "4887cbbc14a949c72b35cc402b259776f87eb015b3aa9d0351045083527c7ea5",
372
+ "state_digest_before": "4887cbbc14a949c72b35cc402b259776f87eb015b3aa9d0351045083527c7ea5"
373
+ }
374
+ ]
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/DATA/runs_index.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,127 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "run_count": 12,
3
+ "runs": [
4
+ {
5
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
6
+ "format": "json.gz",
7
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
8
+ "run_index": 0,
9
+ "seed": 101,
10
+ "sha256": "81e5562696f1151db42357892d1a3102987df60256e26632b33946c1fec92bac",
11
+ "size_bytes": 520,
12
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
13
+ },
14
+ {
15
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
16
+ "format": "json.gz",
17
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
18
+ "run_index": 1,
19
+ "seed": 101,
20
+ "sha256": "07d9d0632d8a99a29717e86d59eb9482c868ff19edbe47a8311ff5f9822273dd",
21
+ "size_bytes": 516,
22
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
23
+ },
24
+ {
25
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
26
+ "format": "json.gz",
27
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
28
+ "run_index": 2,
29
+ "seed": 101,
30
+ "sha256": "20a85b3b25d8be07e9241c2017939fc28490efe411e6cb9ca74d5f97aac5766f",
31
+ "size_bytes": 516,
32
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
33
+ },
34
+ {
35
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
36
+ "format": "json.gz",
37
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
38
+ "run_index": 3,
39
+ "seed": 101,
40
+ "sha256": "3637b6f1034dfad21cd7036d7cb21c6b4b92c5cca278b5f0e03c5bb213913f54",
41
+ "size_bytes": 510,
42
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
43
+ },
44
+ {
45
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
46
+ "format": "json.gz",
47
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
48
+ "run_index": 4,
49
+ "seed": 102,
50
+ "sha256": "b0f32e7b33203876783d6c3ec669f615b07a0de2f3d0518603919525f4828aee",
51
+ "size_bytes": 522,
52
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
53
+ },
54
+ {
55
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
56
+ "format": "json.gz",
57
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
58
+ "run_index": 5,
59
+ "seed": 102,
60
+ "sha256": "cebce3c9d034d317af9496a9e92cd9b712bbdee88365b53e2438c8ab5b56e901",
61
+ "size_bytes": 520,
62
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
66
+ "format": "json.gz",
67
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
68
+ "run_index": 6,
69
+ "seed": 102,
70
+ "sha256": "76aee636c74c65d14c3bb3f1f3634f312163296b408550c5d2231793471167e5",
71
+ "size_bytes": 519,
72
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
73
+ },
74
+ {
75
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
76
+ "format": "json.gz",
77
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
78
+ "run_index": 7,
79
+ "seed": 102,
80
+ "sha256": "52765aaa9348258d2dd082feae8ab61a3f2d23d9e1c2995166b0e0128240e909",
81
+ "size_bytes": 514,
82
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
83
+ },
84
+ {
85
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
86
+ "format": "json.gz",
87
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
88
+ "run_index": 8,
89
+ "seed": 103,
90
+ "sha256": "d489f1020c43876f3616f472f7793cf202b2f4305374f4bf34dd7e2582ae5514",
91
+ "size_bytes": 522,
92
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
93
+ },
94
+ {
95
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
96
+ "format": "json.gz",
97
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
98
+ "run_index": 9,
99
+ "seed": 103,
100
+ "sha256": "721aab27d61c9cabdcdacd849d72ae2fd33a903b90a5cf5bcd60c98d1b4c40fb",
101
+ "size_bytes": 518,
102
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
103
+ },
104
+ {
105
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
106
+ "format": "json.gz",
107
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
108
+ "run_index": 10,
109
+ "seed": 103,
110
+ "sha256": "4a1d252a132d60bb28a8ef00d1f0ef7d6c8790143067c6c918713d9d43323a69",
111
+ "size_bytes": 519,
112
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
113
+ },
114
+ {
115
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
116
+ "format": "json.gz",
117
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
118
+ "run_index": 11,
119
+ "seed": 103,
120
+ "sha256": "9a1abcc35a0f29ef800de2313813f3d9cbd3fa19dc6820391ddaab8b134bbf2c",
121
+ "size_bytes": 514,
122
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
123
+ }
124
+ ],
125
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
126
+ "storage_policy": "immutable_raw_runs_plus_compact_current_experiment"
127
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001211610885260-c2fce764.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,76 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001211610885260-c2fce764",
3
+ "role": "critical_reviewer",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
17
+ "packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
21
+ "observations": [
22
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
23
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
24
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
25
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
26
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
27
+ ],
28
+ "effect_direction": "Die Audit-Items variieren in den Bedingungen, wobei 'claim_boundary' das höchste Audit-Item (4) und 'alternative_model' das niedrigste (2) hat.",
29
+ "methodological_concerns": [
30
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
31
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
32
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
33
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
34
+ ],
35
+ "alternative_explanations": [
36
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
37
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
38
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.",
39
+ "Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist."
40
+ ],
41
+ "recommended_experiments": [
42
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
43
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
44
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
45
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
46
+ ],
47
+ "requested_evidence": [
48
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
49
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.",
50
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
51
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
52
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
53
+ ],
54
+ "confidence": 0.55
55
+ },
56
+ "provenance": {
57
+ "prompt_sha256": "5a059474ee0402323c750b4d54fc11a9af6a84c0ec1b2a23369a3f45423e3b4d",
58
+ "research_packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714",
59
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
60
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
61
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
62
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.55"
63
+ },
64
+ "epistemic_status": {
65
+ "evidence": false,
66
+ "interpretation_only": true,
67
+ "human_review_required": true
68
+ },
69
+ "review": {
70
+ "status": "pending",
71
+ "reviewer": null,
72
+ "reviewed_at": null,
73
+ "disposition": null
74
+ },
75
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:16:10.885260+00:00"
76
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211542537168-c2fce764.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,75 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211542537168-c2fce764",
3
+ "role": "scientific_analyst",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
17
+ "packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
21
+ "observations": [
22
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
23
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
24
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
25
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
26
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
27
+ ],
28
+ "effect_direction": "Die Audit-Items variieren in den Bedingungen, wobei 'claim_boundary' das höchste Audit-Item (4) und 'alternative_model' das niedrigste (2) hat.",
29
+ "methodological_concerns": [
30
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
31
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
32
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
33
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
34
+ ],
35
+ "alternative_explanations": [
36
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
37
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
38
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führte."
39
+ ],
40
+ "recommended_experiments": [
41
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
42
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
43
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
44
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
45
+ ],
46
+ "requested_evidence": [
47
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
48
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützt.",
49
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
50
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
51
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
52
+ ],
53
+ "confidence": 0.55
54
+ },
55
+ "provenance": {
56
+ "prompt_sha256": "488ada45fbb7a28ac2f0e4fd0113882ffa3ded28b59748744ddbaded706e23a4",
57
+ "research_packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714",
58
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
59
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
60
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
61
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.55"
62
+ },
63
+ "epistemic_status": {
64
+ "evidence": false,
65
+ "interpretation_only": true,
66
+ "human_review_required": true
67
+ },
68
+ "review": {
69
+ "status": "pending",
70
+ "reviewer": null,
71
+ "reviewed_at": null,
72
+ "disposition": null
73
+ },
74
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:15:42.537168+00:00"
75
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001211731555494-c2fce764.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,76 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001211731555494-c2fce764",
3
+ "role": "scientific_writer",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
17
+ "packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
21
+ "confidence": 0.55,
22
+ "effect_direction": "Die Audit-Items variieren in den Bedingungen, wobei 'claim_boundary' das höchste Audit-Item (4) und 'alternative_model' das niedrigste (2) hat.",
23
+ "methodological_concerns": [
24
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
25
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
26
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
27
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
28
+ ],
29
+ "observations": [
30
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
31
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
32
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
33
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
34
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
35
+ ],
36
+ "alternative_explanations": [
37
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
38
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
39
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.",
40
+ "Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist."
41
+ ],
42
+ "recommended_experiments": [
43
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
44
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
45
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
46
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
47
+ ],
48
+ "requested_evidence": [
49
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
50
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.",
51
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
52
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
53
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
54
+ ]
55
+ },
56
+ "provenance": {
57
+ "prompt_sha256": "6ea65ed61e141cd8c7379905fa4e80c7fa98847f22f17db27f6cc0e29b1c4d8b",
58
+ "research_packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714",
59
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
60
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
61
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
62
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.55"
63
+ },
64
+ "epistemic_status": {
65
+ "evidence": false,
66
+ "interpretation_only": true,
67
+ "human_review_required": true
68
+ },
69
+ "review": {
70
+ "status": "pending",
71
+ "reviewer": null,
72
+ "reviewed_at": null,
73
+ "disposition": null
74
+ },
75
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:17:31.555494+00:00"
76
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/ai_packet.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,707 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
3
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
4
+ "limits": {
5
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
6
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
7
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
8
+ },
9
+ "raw_index": {
10
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
11
+ "run_count": 12,
12
+ "sha256": "7cf7292c070009b961fc0ce3185e68aa3c12774106f0760ef2a85ac5882a68ec"
13
+ },
14
+ "run_count": 12,
15
+ "run_preview": [
16
+ {
17
+ "_raw_artifact": {
18
+ "format": "json.gz",
19
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
20
+ "sha256": "81e5562696f1151db42357892d1a3102987df60256e26632b33946c1fec92bac",
21
+ "size_bytes": 520,
22
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
23
+ },
24
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
25
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
26
+ "metrics": {
27
+ "audit_complete": false,
28
+ "audit_item": 1,
29
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
30
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
31
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
32
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
33
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
34
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
35
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
36
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
37
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
38
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
39
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
40
+ "snn_involved": false
41
+ },
42
+ "runtime_error": null,
43
+ "seed": 101,
44
+ "state_digest_after": "1ef14aec911a59d248f0981fca2ec80e39071b41275a60ed0ee16e21ce691728",
45
+ "state_digest_before": "1ef14aec911a59d248f0981fca2ec80e39071b41275a60ed0ee16e21ce691728"
46
+ },
47
+ {
48
+ "_raw_artifact": {
49
+ "format": "json.gz",
50
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
51
+ "sha256": "07d9d0632d8a99a29717e86d59eb9482c868ff19edbe47a8311ff5f9822273dd",
52
+ "size_bytes": 516,
53
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
54
+ },
55
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
56
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
57
+ "metrics": {
58
+ "audit_complete": false,
59
+ "audit_item": 2,
60
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
61
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
62
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
63
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
64
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
65
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
66
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
67
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
68
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
69
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
70
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
71
+ "snn_involved": false
72
+ },
73
+ "runtime_error": null,
74
+ "seed": 101,
75
+ "state_digest_after": "3ed0d926fc42e2527e649771ae03cbe89afc97c5530aab28160bb0148ebefa0f",
76
+ "state_digest_before": "3ed0d926fc42e2527e649771ae03cbe89afc97c5530aab28160bb0148ebefa0f"
77
+ },
78
+ {
79
+ "_raw_artifact": {
80
+ "format": "json.gz",
81
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
82
+ "sha256": "20a85b3b25d8be07e9241c2017939fc28490efe411e6cb9ca74d5f97aac5766f",
83
+ "size_bytes": 516,
84
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
85
+ },
86
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
87
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
88
+ "metrics": {
89
+ "audit_complete": false,
90
+ "audit_item": 3,
91
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
92
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
93
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
94
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
95
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
96
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
97
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
98
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
99
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
100
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
101
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
102
+ "snn_involved": false
103
+ },
104
+ "runtime_error": null,
105
+ "seed": 101,
106
+ "state_digest_after": "bb45c009deb085e34bd4317fdf646cda28a66b3294d80b284623fbb3ad3eddee",
107
+ "state_digest_before": "bb45c009deb085e34bd4317fdf646cda28a66b3294d80b284623fbb3ad3eddee"
108
+ },
109
+ {
110
+ "_raw_artifact": {
111
+ "format": "json.gz",
112
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
113
+ "sha256": "3637b6f1034dfad21cd7036d7cb21c6b4b92c5cca278b5f0e03c5bb213913f54",
114
+ "size_bytes": 510,
115
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
116
+ },
117
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
118
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
119
+ "metrics": {
120
+ "audit_complete": false,
121
+ "audit_item": 4,
122
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
123
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
124
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
125
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
126
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
127
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
128
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
129
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
130
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
131
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
132
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
133
+ "snn_involved": false
134
+ },
135
+ "runtime_error": null,
136
+ "seed": 101,
137
+ "state_digest_after": "c0b6ed6204b2bf69a84b16ebae0aeb0b92504b900100b878d9fbe006abdc78ac",
138
+ "state_digest_before": "c0b6ed6204b2bf69a84b16ebae0aeb0b92504b900100b878d9fbe006abdc78ac"
139
+ },
140
+ {
141
+ "_raw_artifact": {
142
+ "format": "json.gz",
143
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
144
+ "sha256": "b0f32e7b33203876783d6c3ec669f615b07a0de2f3d0518603919525f4828aee",
145
+ "size_bytes": 522,
146
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
147
+ },
148
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
149
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
150
+ "metrics": {
151
+ "audit_complete": false,
152
+ "audit_item": 1,
153
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
154
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
155
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
156
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
157
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
158
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
159
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
160
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
161
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
162
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
163
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
164
+ "snn_involved": false
165
+ },
166
+ "runtime_error": null,
167
+ "seed": 102,
168
+ "state_digest_after": "fad51d00949f8dea2f2bba89f1ed19142f9bdf99f193ae0653fcf877dc8d7021",
169
+ "state_digest_before": "fad51d00949f8dea2f2bba89f1ed19142f9bdf99f193ae0653fcf877dc8d7021"
170
+ },
171
+ {
172
+ "_raw_artifact": {
173
+ "format": "json.gz",
174
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
175
+ "sha256": "cebce3c9d034d317af9496a9e92cd9b712bbdee88365b53e2438c8ab5b56e901",
176
+ "size_bytes": 520,
177
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
178
+ },
179
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
180
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
181
+ "metrics": {
182
+ "audit_complete": false,
183
+ "audit_item": 2,
184
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
185
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
186
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
187
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
188
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
189
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
190
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
191
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
192
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
193
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
194
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
195
+ "snn_involved": false
196
+ },
197
+ "runtime_error": null,
198
+ "seed": 102,
199
+ "state_digest_after": "d3d7f4002724b04913944be8eef040763b3e97948db5674fadf6efb50379e984",
200
+ "state_digest_before": "d3d7f4002724b04913944be8eef040763b3e97948db5674fadf6efb50379e984"
201
+ },
202
+ {
203
+ "_raw_artifact": {
204
+ "format": "json.gz",
205
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
206
+ "sha256": "76aee636c74c65d14c3bb3f1f3634f312163296b408550c5d2231793471167e5",
207
+ "size_bytes": 519,
208
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
209
+ },
210
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
211
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
212
+ "metrics": {
213
+ "audit_complete": false,
214
+ "audit_item": 3,
215
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
216
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
217
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
218
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
219
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
220
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
221
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
222
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
223
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
224
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
225
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
226
+ "snn_involved": false
227
+ },
228
+ "runtime_error": null,
229
+ "seed": 102,
230
+ "state_digest_after": "3281377b9eb44f4e8493278fe87515d67c08f9a709cf04c09b7a93b4164dfe0f",
231
+ "state_digest_before": "3281377b9eb44f4e8493278fe87515d67c08f9a709cf04c09b7a93b4164dfe0f"
232
+ },
233
+ {
234
+ "_raw_artifact": {
235
+ "format": "json.gz",
236
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
237
+ "sha256": "52765aaa9348258d2dd082feae8ab61a3f2d23d9e1c2995166b0e0128240e909",
238
+ "size_bytes": 514,
239
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
240
+ },
241
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
242
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
243
+ "metrics": {
244
+ "audit_complete": false,
245
+ "audit_item": 4,
246
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
247
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
248
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
249
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
250
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
251
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
252
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
253
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
254
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
255
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
256
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
257
+ "snn_involved": false
258
+ },
259
+ "runtime_error": null,
260
+ "seed": 102,
261
+ "state_digest_after": "2639bce5fab1134131f33fdf8fa7304ae9c1e420508f068bc5e466923625c150",
262
+ "state_digest_before": "2639bce5fab1134131f33fdf8fa7304ae9c1e420508f068bc5e466923625c150"
263
+ },
264
+ {
265
+ "_raw_artifact": {
266
+ "format": "json.gz",
267
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
268
+ "sha256": "d489f1020c43876f3616f472f7793cf202b2f4305374f4bf34dd7e2582ae5514",
269
+ "size_bytes": 522,
270
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
271
+ },
272
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
273
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
274
+ "metrics": {
275
+ "audit_complete": false,
276
+ "audit_item": 1,
277
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
278
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
279
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
280
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
281
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
282
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
283
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
284
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
285
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
286
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
287
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
288
+ "snn_involved": false
289
+ },
290
+ "runtime_error": null,
291
+ "seed": 103,
292
+ "state_digest_after": "03874a794a7964212ed6625910afba8e8d432a090213039055b9c6e0559d77e9",
293
+ "state_digest_before": "03874a794a7964212ed6625910afba8e8d432a090213039055b9c6e0559d77e9"
294
+ },
295
+ {
296
+ "_raw_artifact": {
297
+ "format": "json.gz",
298
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
299
+ "sha256": "721aab27d61c9cabdcdacd849d72ae2fd33a903b90a5cf5bcd60c98d1b4c40fb",
300
+ "size_bytes": 518,
301
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
302
+ },
303
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
304
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
305
+ "metrics": {
306
+ "audit_complete": false,
307
+ "audit_item": 2,
308
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
309
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
310
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
311
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
312
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
313
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
314
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
315
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
316
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
317
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
318
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
319
+ "snn_involved": false
320
+ },
321
+ "runtime_error": null,
322
+ "seed": 103,
323
+ "state_digest_after": "a4cb4ef1e0d17ffad54183e3cf98295d9ab759d39aa8f1a158710e0e4c67d6d9",
324
+ "state_digest_before": "a4cb4ef1e0d17ffad54183e3cf98295d9ab759d39aa8f1a158710e0e4c67d6d9"
325
+ },
326
+ {
327
+ "_raw_artifact": {
328
+ "format": "json.gz",
329
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
330
+ "sha256": "4a1d252a132d60bb28a8ef00d1f0ef7d6c8790143067c6c918713d9d43323a69",
331
+ "size_bytes": 519,
332
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
333
+ },
334
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
335
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
336
+ "metrics": {
337
+ "audit_complete": false,
338
+ "audit_item": 3,
339
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
340
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
341
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
342
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
343
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
344
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
345
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
346
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
347
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
348
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
349
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
350
+ "snn_involved": false
351
+ },
352
+ "runtime_error": null,
353
+ "seed": 103,
354
+ "state_digest_after": "50d47f5746278ad20cd624b146de8a136ac48d2727049f8f9f2df16866a2f780",
355
+ "state_digest_before": "50d47f5746278ad20cd624b146de8a136ac48d2727049f8f9f2df16866a2f780"
356
+ },
357
+ {
358
+ "_raw_artifact": {
359
+ "format": "json.gz",
360
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
361
+ "sha256": "9a1abcc35a0f29ef800de2313813f3d9cbd3fa19dc6820391ddaab8b134bbf2c",
362
+ "size_bytes": 514,
363
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
364
+ },
365
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
366
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
367
+ "metrics": {
368
+ "audit_complete": false,
369
+ "audit_item": 4,
370
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
371
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
372
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
373
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
374
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
375
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
376
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
377
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
378
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
379
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
380
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
381
+ "snn_involved": false
382
+ },
383
+ "runtime_error": null,
384
+ "seed": 103,
385
+ "state_digest_after": "4887cbbc14a949c72b35cc402b259776f87eb015b3aa9d0351045083527c7ea5",
386
+ "state_digest_before": "4887cbbc14a949c72b35cc402b259776f87eb015b3aa9d0351045083527c7ea5"
387
+ }
388
+ ],
389
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
390
+ "statistics": {
391
+ "conditions": {
392
+ "alternative_model": {
393
+ "boolean_metrics": {
394
+ "audit_complete": {
395
+ "all_true": false,
396
+ "false_count": 3,
397
+ "n": 3,
398
+ "true_count": 0,
399
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
400
+ },
401
+ "audit_template_generated": {
402
+ "all_true": true,
403
+ "false_count": 0,
404
+ "n": 3,
405
+ "true_count": 3,
406
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
407
+ },
408
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
409
+ "all_true": false,
410
+ "false_count": 3,
411
+ "n": 3,
412
+ "true_count": 0,
413
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
414
+ },
415
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
416
+ "all_true": true,
417
+ "false_count": 0,
418
+ "n": 3,
419
+ "true_count": 3,
420
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
421
+ },
422
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
423
+ "all_true": false,
424
+ "false_count": 3,
425
+ "n": 3,
426
+ "true_count": 0,
427
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
428
+ },
429
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
430
+ "all_true": false,
431
+ "false_count": 3,
432
+ "n": 3,
433
+ "true_count": 0,
434
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
435
+ },
436
+ "scientific_evidence": {
437
+ "all_true": false,
438
+ "false_count": 3,
439
+ "n": 3,
440
+ "true_count": 0,
441
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
442
+ },
443
+ "snn_involved": {
444
+ "all_true": false,
445
+ "false_count": 3,
446
+ "n": 3,
447
+ "true_count": 0,
448
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
449
+ }
450
+ },
451
+ "metrics": {
452
+ "audit_item": {
453
+ "max": 2.0,
454
+ "mean": 2.0,
455
+ "median": 2.0,
456
+ "min": 2.0,
457
+ "n": 3,
458
+ "std": 0.0
459
+ }
460
+ },
461
+ "run_count": 3,
462
+ "seeds": [
463
+ 101,
464
+ 102,
465
+ 103
466
+ ]
467
+ },
468
+ "assumption_explicit": {
469
+ "boolean_metrics": {
470
+ "audit_complete": {
471
+ "all_true": false,
472
+ "false_count": 3,
473
+ "n": 3,
474
+ "true_count": 0,
475
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
476
+ },
477
+ "audit_template_generated": {
478
+ "all_true": true,
479
+ "false_count": 0,
480
+ "n": 3,
481
+ "true_count": 3,
482
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
483
+ },
484
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
485
+ "all_true": false,
486
+ "false_count": 3,
487
+ "n": 3,
488
+ "true_count": 0,
489
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
490
+ },
491
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
492
+ "all_true": true,
493
+ "false_count": 0,
494
+ "n": 3,
495
+ "true_count": 3,
496
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
497
+ },
498
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
499
+ "all_true": false,
500
+ "false_count": 3,
501
+ "n": 3,
502
+ "true_count": 0,
503
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
504
+ },
505
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
506
+ "all_true": false,
507
+ "false_count": 3,
508
+ "n": 3,
509
+ "true_count": 0,
510
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
511
+ },
512
+ "scientific_evidence": {
513
+ "all_true": false,
514
+ "false_count": 3,
515
+ "n": 3,
516
+ "true_count": 0,
517
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
518
+ },
519
+ "snn_involved": {
520
+ "all_true": false,
521
+ "false_count": 3,
522
+ "n": 3,
523
+ "true_count": 0,
524
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
525
+ }
526
+ },
527
+ "metrics": {
528
+ "audit_item": {
529
+ "max": 1.0,
530
+ "mean": 1.0,
531
+ "median": 1.0,
532
+ "min": 1.0,
533
+ "n": 3,
534
+ "std": 0.0
535
+ }
536
+ },
537
+ "run_count": 3,
538
+ "seeds": [
539
+ 101,
540
+ 102,
541
+ 103
542
+ ]
543
+ },
544
+ "claim_boundary": {
545
+ "boolean_metrics": {
546
+ "audit_complete": {
547
+ "all_true": false,
548
+ "false_count": 3,
549
+ "n": 3,
550
+ "true_count": 0,
551
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
552
+ },
553
+ "audit_template_generated": {
554
+ "all_true": true,
555
+ "false_count": 0,
556
+ "n": 3,
557
+ "true_count": 3,
558
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
559
+ },
560
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
561
+ "all_true": false,
562
+ "false_count": 3,
563
+ "n": 3,
564
+ "true_count": 0,
565
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
566
+ },
567
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
568
+ "all_true": true,
569
+ "false_count": 0,
570
+ "n": 3,
571
+ "true_count": 3,
572
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
573
+ },
574
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
575
+ "all_true": false,
576
+ "false_count": 3,
577
+ "n": 3,
578
+ "true_count": 0,
579
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
580
+ },
581
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
582
+ "all_true": false,
583
+ "false_count": 3,
584
+ "n": 3,
585
+ "true_count": 0,
586
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
587
+ },
588
+ "scientific_evidence": {
589
+ "all_true": false,
590
+ "false_count": 3,
591
+ "n": 3,
592
+ "true_count": 0,
593
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
594
+ },
595
+ "snn_involved": {
596
+ "all_true": false,
597
+ "false_count": 3,
598
+ "n": 3,
599
+ "true_count": 0,
600
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
601
+ }
602
+ },
603
+ "metrics": {
604
+ "audit_item": {
605
+ "max": 4.0,
606
+ "mean": 4.0,
607
+ "median": 4.0,
608
+ "min": 4.0,
609
+ "n": 3,
610
+ "std": 0.0
611
+ }
612
+ },
613
+ "run_count": 3,
614
+ "seeds": [
615
+ 101,
616
+ 102,
617
+ 103
618
+ ]
619
+ },
620
+ "measurement_limit": {
621
+ "boolean_metrics": {
622
+ "audit_complete": {
623
+ "all_true": false,
624
+ "false_count": 3,
625
+ "n": 3,
626
+ "true_count": 0,
627
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
628
+ },
629
+ "audit_template_generated": {
630
+ "all_true": true,
631
+ "false_count": 0,
632
+ "n": 3,
633
+ "true_count": 3,
634
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
635
+ },
636
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
637
+ "all_true": false,
638
+ "false_count": 3,
639
+ "n": 3,
640
+ "true_count": 0,
641
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
642
+ },
643
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
644
+ "all_true": true,
645
+ "false_count": 0,
646
+ "n": 3,
647
+ "true_count": 3,
648
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
649
+ },
650
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
651
+ "all_true": false,
652
+ "false_count": 3,
653
+ "n": 3,
654
+ "true_count": 0,
655
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
656
+ },
657
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
658
+ "all_true": false,
659
+ "false_count": 3,
660
+ "n": 3,
661
+ "true_count": 0,
662
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
663
+ },
664
+ "scientific_evidence": {
665
+ "all_true": false,
666
+ "false_count": 3,
667
+ "n": 3,
668
+ "true_count": 0,
669
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
670
+ },
671
+ "snn_involved": {
672
+ "all_true": false,
673
+ "false_count": 3,
674
+ "n": 3,
675
+ "true_count": 0,
676
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
677
+ }
678
+ },
679
+ "metrics": {
680
+ "audit_item": {
681
+ "max": 3.0,
682
+ "mean": 3.0,
683
+ "median": 3.0,
684
+ "min": 3.0,
685
+ "n": 3,
686
+ "std": 0.0
687
+ }
688
+ },
689
+ "run_count": 3,
690
+ "seeds": [
691
+ 101,
692
+ 102,
693
+ 103
694
+ ]
695
+ }
696
+ },
697
+ "formulas": {
698
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
699
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
700
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
701
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
702
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
703
+ },
704
+ "run_count": 12,
705
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
706
+ }
707
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/ai_packet_digest.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "path": "analysis/ai_packet.json",
3
+ "raw_index_sha256": "7cf7292c070009b961fc0ce3185e68aa3c12774106f0760ef2a85ac5882a68ec",
4
+ "schema_version": "1.0",
5
+ "sha256": "d4eeb83dd91b5b54f90e0fd5e089ce2a2ea0f57d7183cb1e254fb7fda8d8663f",
6
+ "size_bytes": 24500
7
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/analysis/statistics.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,318 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "conditions": {
3
+ "alternative_model": {
4
+ "boolean_metrics": {
5
+ "audit_complete": {
6
+ "all_true": false,
7
+ "false_count": 3,
8
+ "n": 3,
9
+ "true_count": 0,
10
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
11
+ },
12
+ "audit_template_generated": {
13
+ "all_true": true,
14
+ "false_count": 0,
15
+ "n": 3,
16
+ "true_count": 3,
17
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
18
+ },
19
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
20
+ "all_true": false,
21
+ "false_count": 3,
22
+ "n": 3,
23
+ "true_count": 0,
24
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
25
+ },
26
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
27
+ "all_true": true,
28
+ "false_count": 0,
29
+ "n": 3,
30
+ "true_count": 3,
31
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
32
+ },
33
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
34
+ "all_true": false,
35
+ "false_count": 3,
36
+ "n": 3,
37
+ "true_count": 0,
38
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
39
+ },
40
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
41
+ "all_true": false,
42
+ "false_count": 3,
43
+ "n": 3,
44
+ "true_count": 0,
45
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
46
+ },
47
+ "scientific_evidence": {
48
+ "all_true": false,
49
+ "false_count": 3,
50
+ "n": 3,
51
+ "true_count": 0,
52
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
53
+ },
54
+ "snn_involved": {
55
+ "all_true": false,
56
+ "false_count": 3,
57
+ "n": 3,
58
+ "true_count": 0,
59
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
60
+ }
61
+ },
62
+ "metrics": {
63
+ "audit_item": {
64
+ "max": 2.0,
65
+ "mean": 2.0,
66
+ "median": 2.0,
67
+ "min": 2.0,
68
+ "n": 3,
69
+ "std": 0.0
70
+ }
71
+ },
72
+ "run_count": 3,
73
+ "seeds": [
74
+ 101,
75
+ 102,
76
+ 103
77
+ ]
78
+ },
79
+ "assumption_explicit": {
80
+ "boolean_metrics": {
81
+ "audit_complete": {
82
+ "all_true": false,
83
+ "false_count": 3,
84
+ "n": 3,
85
+ "true_count": 0,
86
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
87
+ },
88
+ "audit_template_generated": {
89
+ "all_true": true,
90
+ "false_count": 0,
91
+ "n": 3,
92
+ "true_count": 3,
93
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
94
+ },
95
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
96
+ "all_true": false,
97
+ "false_count": 3,
98
+ "n": 3,
99
+ "true_count": 0,
100
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
101
+ },
102
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
103
+ "all_true": true,
104
+ "false_count": 0,
105
+ "n": 3,
106
+ "true_count": 3,
107
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
108
+ },
109
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
110
+ "all_true": false,
111
+ "false_count": 3,
112
+ "n": 3,
113
+ "true_count": 0,
114
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
115
+ },
116
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
117
+ "all_true": false,
118
+ "false_count": 3,
119
+ "n": 3,
120
+ "true_count": 0,
121
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
122
+ },
123
+ "scientific_evidence": {
124
+ "all_true": false,
125
+ "false_count": 3,
126
+ "n": 3,
127
+ "true_count": 0,
128
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
129
+ },
130
+ "snn_involved": {
131
+ "all_true": false,
132
+ "false_count": 3,
133
+ "n": 3,
134
+ "true_count": 0,
135
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
136
+ }
137
+ },
138
+ "metrics": {
139
+ "audit_item": {
140
+ "max": 1.0,
141
+ "mean": 1.0,
142
+ "median": 1.0,
143
+ "min": 1.0,
144
+ "n": 3,
145
+ "std": 0.0
146
+ }
147
+ },
148
+ "run_count": 3,
149
+ "seeds": [
150
+ 101,
151
+ 102,
152
+ 103
153
+ ]
154
+ },
155
+ "claim_boundary": {
156
+ "boolean_metrics": {
157
+ "audit_complete": {
158
+ "all_true": false,
159
+ "false_count": 3,
160
+ "n": 3,
161
+ "true_count": 0,
162
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
163
+ },
164
+ "audit_template_generated": {
165
+ "all_true": true,
166
+ "false_count": 0,
167
+ "n": 3,
168
+ "true_count": 3,
169
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
170
+ },
171
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
172
+ "all_true": false,
173
+ "false_count": 3,
174
+ "n": 3,
175
+ "true_count": 0,
176
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
177
+ },
178
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
179
+ "all_true": true,
180
+ "false_count": 0,
181
+ "n": 3,
182
+ "true_count": 3,
183
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
184
+ },
185
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
186
+ "all_true": false,
187
+ "false_count": 3,
188
+ "n": 3,
189
+ "true_count": 0,
190
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
191
+ },
192
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
193
+ "all_true": false,
194
+ "false_count": 3,
195
+ "n": 3,
196
+ "true_count": 0,
197
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
198
+ },
199
+ "scientific_evidence": {
200
+ "all_true": false,
201
+ "false_count": 3,
202
+ "n": 3,
203
+ "true_count": 0,
204
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
205
+ },
206
+ "snn_involved": {
207
+ "all_true": false,
208
+ "false_count": 3,
209
+ "n": 3,
210
+ "true_count": 0,
211
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
212
+ }
213
+ },
214
+ "metrics": {
215
+ "audit_item": {
216
+ "max": 4.0,
217
+ "mean": 4.0,
218
+ "median": 4.0,
219
+ "min": 4.0,
220
+ "n": 3,
221
+ "std": 0.0
222
+ }
223
+ },
224
+ "run_count": 3,
225
+ "seeds": [
226
+ 101,
227
+ 102,
228
+ 103
229
+ ]
230
+ },
231
+ "measurement_limit": {
232
+ "boolean_metrics": {
233
+ "audit_complete": {
234
+ "all_true": false,
235
+ "false_count": 3,
236
+ "n": 3,
237
+ "true_count": 0,
238
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
239
+ },
240
+ "audit_template_generated": {
241
+ "all_true": true,
242
+ "false_count": 0,
243
+ "n": 3,
244
+ "true_count": 3,
245
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
246
+ },
247
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
248
+ "all_true": false,
249
+ "false_count": 3,
250
+ "n": 3,
251
+ "true_count": 0,
252
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
253
+ },
254
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
255
+ "all_true": true,
256
+ "false_count": 0,
257
+ "n": 3,
258
+ "true_count": 3,
259
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
260
+ },
261
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
262
+ "all_true": false,
263
+ "false_count": 3,
264
+ "n": 3,
265
+ "true_count": 0,
266
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
267
+ },
268
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
269
+ "all_true": false,
270
+ "false_count": 3,
271
+ "n": 3,
272
+ "true_count": 0,
273
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
274
+ },
275
+ "scientific_evidence": {
276
+ "all_true": false,
277
+ "false_count": 3,
278
+ "n": 3,
279
+ "true_count": 0,
280
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
281
+ },
282
+ "snn_involved": {
283
+ "all_true": false,
284
+ "false_count": 3,
285
+ "n": 3,
286
+ "true_count": 0,
287
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
288
+ }
289
+ },
290
+ "metrics": {
291
+ "audit_item": {
292
+ "max": 3.0,
293
+ "mean": 3.0,
294
+ "median": 3.0,
295
+ "min": 3.0,
296
+ "n": 3,
297
+ "std": 0.0
298
+ }
299
+ },
300
+ "run_count": 3,
301
+ "seeds": [
302
+ 101,
303
+ 102,
304
+ 103
305
+ ]
306
+ }
307
+ },
308
+ "formulas": {
309
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
310
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
311
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
312
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
313
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
314
+ },
315
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
316
+ "run_count": 12,
317
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
318
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/manifest.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,127 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "ai_exposure": "none",
3
+ "ai_interactions": [],
4
+ "ai_protocol": {
5
+ "bump_reason": "initial registration",
6
+ "version": 1
7
+ },
8
+ "ai_reproducibility": "R0",
9
+ "artifacts": {
10
+ "ai_packet": "analysis/ai_packet.json",
11
+ "ai_packet_digest": "analysis/ai_packet_digest.json",
12
+ "ai_report_json": "experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json",
13
+ "ai_report_markdown": "experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md",
14
+ "current_run": "DATA/current_run.json",
15
+ "data": "DATA/runs_compact.json",
16
+ "data_index": "DATA/runs_index.json",
17
+ "preregistration": "preregistrations/operational/cognition_bundle_v1.json",
18
+ "raw_run_index": "DATA/runs_index.json",
19
+ "report": "report.md",
20
+ "statistics": "analysis/statistics.json",
21
+ "workflow": "workflow.json"
22
+ },
23
+ "causal_card": {
24
+ "classification": "PURE",
25
+ "interaction_ids": [],
26
+ "roles": []
27
+ },
28
+ "causal_taint": "PURE",
29
+ "config": {
30
+ "path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
31
+ "sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c"
32
+ },
33
+ "created_at": "2026-10-01T21:15:18.497489+00:00",
34
+ "data_partitions": [],
35
+ "epistemic_layers": {
36
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
37
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
38
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input",
39
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result"
40
+ },
41
+ "execution_contract": {
42
+ "hypothesis_id": "H-CNS-101-A",
43
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_101_v1",
44
+ "question_id": "RQ-CNS-101",
45
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_101_v1",
46
+ "runtime_runner_bytecode_sha256": "93e483e29fa71c08401562dfa757d4a5f80fb7ca1fa1cce25a1e76c2b71ea1eb",
47
+ "runtime_summary_bytecode_sha256": "462bf872a28910b7747790c4aae29f288f6aa5361c27799f0ea52a1fdc09f7a6",
48
+ "source_runner_bytecode_sha256": "93e483e29fa71c08401562dfa757d4a5f80fb7ca1fa1cce25a1e76c2b71ea1eb",
49
+ "source_runtime_consistency": "MATCH",
50
+ "source_summary_bytecode_sha256": "462bf872a28910b7747790c4aae29f288f6aa5361c27799f0ea52a1fdc09f7a6",
51
+ "tick_validation": {
52
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
53
+ "requested_ticks": 1,
54
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"
55
+ },
56
+ "ticks_requested": 1
57
+ },
58
+ "execution_semantics": {
59
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
60
+ "claim_scope": "method_template_only",
61
+ "direct_test_of_hypothesis": false,
62
+ "external_review": "external_review/INTEGRATION.md",
63
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
64
+ "kind": "conceptual_audit",
65
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
66
+ "snn_involved": false
67
+ },
68
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
69
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
70
+ "git": {
71
+ "branch": "develop",
72
+ "commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
73
+ "dirty": true
74
+ },
75
+ "hypotheses": [
76
+ "H-CNS-101-A"
77
+ ],
78
+ "network_mode": "OFFLINE",
79
+ "provenance_digests": {
80
+ "code": "5a11ea288e7e695c2dcd456642b533cbb3e6daf38b72e150134e60e69059531f",
81
+ "config": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
82
+ "data": "3cf94d4846bca6220b95a1cbe444913f435854ac0602213cd01b235901be8bd1",
83
+ "prompt": "dd18e473908e7e75b1717c240bac221729ea38753abfd28b701b37b20d5f5e14"
84
+ },
85
+ "research_questions": [
86
+ "RQ-CNS-101"
87
+ ],
88
+ "research_run_mode": "EXPLORATORY",
89
+ "results": {
90
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_101_v1",
91
+ "run_count": 12,
92
+ "runner": "run_cog_cns_101_v1",
93
+ "tick_contract": {
94
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
95
+ "requested_ticks": 1,
96
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"
97
+ },
98
+ "ticks_requested": 1
99
+ },
100
+ "runtime": {
101
+ "duration_seconds": 0.015006800065748394
102
+ },
103
+ "runtime_errors": [],
104
+ "simulation": {
105
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_101_v1",
106
+ "seed": 101,
107
+ "seeds": [
108
+ 101,
109
+ 102,
110
+ 103
111
+ ],
112
+ "ticks": 1
113
+ },
114
+ "software": {
115
+ "brain5d_version": "0.6.0a7",
116
+ "os": "Windows 11",
117
+ "python": "3.13.14"
118
+ },
119
+ "source_freeze_sha": "bac4e3d81dea549c50264184cc2b3cefc0f0db6bf104c8909c884a619f688f70",
120
+ "timestamp": "2026-10-01T23:15:18.497480",
121
+ "validity": {
122
+ "fatal_error_count": 0,
123
+ "reason": null,
124
+ "runtime_error_count": 0,
125
+ "valid": true
126
+ }
127
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/report.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01: Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_101_v1
2
+
3
+ ## Forschungszuordnung
4
+ Forschungsfrage: `RQ-CNS-101`
5
+ Hypothese: `H-CNS-101-A`
6
+ Aufgeloester Runner: `run_cog_cns_101_v1`
7
+
8
+ ## Protokoll und Einstellungen
9
+ Protokoll: `cog_cns_101_v1`
10
+ Angeforderte Mindest-Ticks: `1`
11
+ Seeds: `101, 102, 103`
12
+ Tick-Vertrag: `{"mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials", "requested_ticks": 1, "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"}`
13
+
14
+ ## Bedingungen
15
+ frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract
16
+ Runs: 12; Dauer: 0.015007 s
17
+
18
+ ## Daten und Statistik
19
+ Versionierte kompakte Run-Projektion: `DATA/runs_compact.json`
20
+ Unveränderlicher Rohdatenindex: `DATA/runs_index.json`
21
+ KI-Eingabepaket: `analysis/ai_packet.json` (hart begrenzt)
22
+ Deterministische deskriptive Statistik: `analysis/statistics.json`
23
+ Die Summary verbindet Rohdaten, Formeln, Einzelruns, Bedingungen, Reproduzierbarkeit und AIRR ohne KI-generierte Statistik.
24
+
25
+ ## Epistemische Ebenen
26
+ UI-Zustand: Dashboard-Steuerung und Fortschritt; kein wissenschaftliches Ergebnis.
27
+ DATA: Rohdaten, Run-Index und deterministische Statistik.
28
+ EVID: nicht erzeugt; Clean Freeze, semantische Zuordnung und Human Review erforderlich.
29
+ Interpretation: nachgelagerte KI-/Human-Interpretation; keine Ausfuehrungseingabe.
30
+
31
+ ## Evidenzstatus
32
+ DATA, Manifest, Workflow und deterministische Statistik sind erzeugt. Wissenschaftliche EVID entsteht erst nach passender semantischer Zuordnung, Clean Freeze und Human Review.
33
+
34
+ ## Hinweise
35
+ Conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,1573 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "report_id": "AIRR-2026-0001",
3
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
4
+ "research_question_id": "RQ-CNS-101",
5
+ "hypothesis_ids": [
6
+ "H-CNS-101-A"
7
+ ],
8
+ "claim_ids": [],
9
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:17:31.558730+00:00",
10
+ "report_schema_version": "1.0",
11
+ "report_protocol_version": "PROTOCOL-AIRR-001",
12
+ "generated_by": "artificial_intelligence",
13
+ "ai_generated": true,
14
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
15
+ "human_review_required": true,
16
+ "status": "review_pending",
17
+ "content": {
18
+ "identification": {
19
+ "experiment": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
20
+ "research_question": "Welche beobachtbaren Indikatoren unterscheiden konkurrierende Bewusstseinsmodelle, und welche Erlebensbehauptungen bleiben dadurch unidentifiziert?",
21
+ "hypotheses": [
22
+ {
23
+ "id": "H-CNS-101-A",
24
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-101",
25
+ "hypothesis": "Explizite Theorieannahmen und passende Interventionen reduzieren die Menge beobachtungsvereinbarer Funktionsmodelle; phänomenales Erleben folgt daraus nicht allein.",
26
+ "status": "untested",
27
+ "evidence": [],
28
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
29
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
30
+ }
31
+ ],
32
+ "date": "2026-10-01",
33
+ "source_sha": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3"
34
+ },
35
+ "executive_summary": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
36
+ "research_question": {
37
+ "id": "RQ-CNS-101",
38
+ "domain": "Consciousness methodology",
39
+ "question": "Welche beobachtbaren Indikatoren unterscheiden konkurrierende Bewusstseinsmodelle, und welche Erlebensbehauptungen bleiben dadurch unidentifiziert?",
40
+ "relevance": "Theory-to-indicator and identifiability audit; Conceptual/model comparison; no ground-truth phenomenal labels",
41
+ "literature": [
42
+ "SRC-CNS-BUTLIN",
43
+ "SRC-CNS-COGITATE",
44
+ "SRC-CNS-GNWREPLY",
45
+ "SRC-CNS-SETH"
46
+ ],
47
+ "hypotheses": [
48
+ "H-CNS-101-A"
49
+ ],
50
+ "evidence": [],
51
+ "status": "open",
52
+ "answer": {
53
+ "current": null,
54
+ "confidence": "none",
55
+ "limitations": "Conceptual/model comparison; no ground-truth phenomenal labels"
56
+ },
57
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
58
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
59
+ },
60
+ "experimental_design": {
61
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
62
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-101",
63
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-101-A",
64
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_101_v1",
65
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
66
+ "ticks": 1,
67
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
68
+ "seeds": [
69
+ 101,
70
+ 102,
71
+ 103
72
+ ],
73
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_101_v1",
74
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_101_v1",
75
+ "tick_validation": {
76
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
77
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
78
+ "requested_ticks": 1
79
+ },
80
+ "notes": "Conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
81
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
82
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
83
+ "epistemic_layers": {
84
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
85
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
86
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
87
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
88
+ }
89
+ },
90
+ "data_basis": {
91
+ "data": {
92
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
93
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
94
+ "limits": {
95
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
96
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
97
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
98
+ },
99
+ "raw_index": {
100
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
101
+ "run_count": 12,
102
+ "sha256": "7cf7292c070009b961fc0ce3185e68aa3c12774106f0760ef2a85ac5882a68ec"
103
+ },
104
+ "run_count": 12,
105
+ "run_preview": [
106
+ {
107
+ "_raw_artifact": {
108
+ "format": "json.gz",
109
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
110
+ "sha256": "81e5562696f1151db42357892d1a3102987df60256e26632b33946c1fec92bac",
111
+ "size_bytes": 520,
112
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
113
+ },
114
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
115
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
116
+ "metrics": {
117
+ "audit_complete": false,
118
+ "audit_item": 1,
119
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
120
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
121
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
122
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
123
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
124
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
125
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
126
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
127
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
128
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
129
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
130
+ "snn_involved": false
131
+ },
132
+ "runtime_error": null,
133
+ "seed": 101,
134
+ "state_digest_after": "1ef14aec911a59d248f0981fca2ec80e39071b41275a60ed0ee16e21ce691728",
135
+ "state_digest_before": "1ef14aec911a59d248f0981fca2ec80e39071b41275a60ed0ee16e21ce691728"
136
+ },
137
+ {
138
+ "_raw_artifact": {
139
+ "format": "json.gz",
140
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
141
+ "sha256": "07d9d0632d8a99a29717e86d59eb9482c868ff19edbe47a8311ff5f9822273dd",
142
+ "size_bytes": 516,
143
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
144
+ },
145
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
146
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
147
+ "metrics": {
148
+ "audit_complete": false,
149
+ "audit_item": 2,
150
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
151
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
152
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
153
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
154
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
155
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
156
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
157
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
158
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
159
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
160
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
161
+ "snn_involved": false
162
+ },
163
+ "runtime_error": null,
164
+ "seed": 101,
165
+ "state_digest_after": "3ed0d926fc42e2527e649771ae03cbe89afc97c5530aab28160bb0148ebefa0f",
166
+ "state_digest_before": "3ed0d926fc42e2527e649771ae03cbe89afc97c5530aab28160bb0148ebefa0f"
167
+ },
168
+ {
169
+ "_raw_artifact": {
170
+ "format": "json.gz",
171
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
172
+ "sha256": "20a85b3b25d8be07e9241c2017939fc28490efe411e6cb9ca74d5f97aac5766f",
173
+ "size_bytes": 516,
174
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
175
+ },
176
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
177
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
178
+ "metrics": {
179
+ "audit_complete": false,
180
+ "audit_item": 3,
181
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
182
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
183
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
184
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
185
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
186
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
187
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
188
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
189
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
190
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
191
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
192
+ "snn_involved": false
193
+ },
194
+ "runtime_error": null,
195
+ "seed": 101,
196
+ "state_digest_after": "bb45c009deb085e34bd4317fdf646cda28a66b3294d80b284623fbb3ad3eddee",
197
+ "state_digest_before": "bb45c009deb085e34bd4317fdf646cda28a66b3294d80b284623fbb3ad3eddee"
198
+ },
199
+ {
200
+ "_raw_artifact": {
201
+ "format": "json.gz",
202
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
203
+ "sha256": "3637b6f1034dfad21cd7036d7cb21c6b4b92c5cca278b5f0e03c5bb213913f54",
204
+ "size_bytes": 510,
205
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
206
+ },
207
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
208
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
209
+ "metrics": {
210
+ "audit_complete": false,
211
+ "audit_item": 4,
212
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
213
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
214
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
215
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
216
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
217
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
218
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
219
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
220
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
221
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
222
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
223
+ "snn_involved": false
224
+ },
225
+ "runtime_error": null,
226
+ "seed": 101,
227
+ "state_digest_after": "c0b6ed6204b2bf69a84b16ebae0aeb0b92504b900100b878d9fbe006abdc78ac",
228
+ "state_digest_before": "c0b6ed6204b2bf69a84b16ebae0aeb0b92504b900100b878d9fbe006abdc78ac"
229
+ },
230
+ {
231
+ "_raw_artifact": {
232
+ "format": "json.gz",
233
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
234
+ "sha256": "b0f32e7b33203876783d6c3ec669f615b07a0de2f3d0518603919525f4828aee",
235
+ "size_bytes": 522,
236
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
237
+ },
238
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
239
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
240
+ "metrics": {
241
+ "audit_complete": false,
242
+ "audit_item": 1,
243
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
244
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
245
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
246
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
247
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
248
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
249
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
250
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
251
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
252
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
253
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
254
+ "snn_involved": false
255
+ },
256
+ "runtime_error": null,
257
+ "seed": 102,
258
+ "state_digest_after": "fad51d00949f8dea2f2bba89f1ed19142f9bdf99f193ae0653fcf877dc8d7021",
259
+ "state_digest_before": "fad51d00949f8dea2f2bba89f1ed19142f9bdf99f193ae0653fcf877dc8d7021"
260
+ },
261
+ {
262
+ "_raw_artifact": {
263
+ "format": "json.gz",
264
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
265
+ "sha256": "cebce3c9d034d317af9496a9e92cd9b712bbdee88365b53e2438c8ab5b56e901",
266
+ "size_bytes": 520,
267
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
268
+ },
269
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
270
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
271
+ "metrics": {
272
+ "audit_complete": false,
273
+ "audit_item": 2,
274
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
275
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
276
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
277
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
278
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
279
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
280
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
281
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
282
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
283
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
284
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
285
+ "snn_involved": false
286
+ },
287
+ "runtime_error": null,
288
+ "seed": 102,
289
+ "state_digest_after": "d3d7f4002724b04913944be8eef040763b3e97948db5674fadf6efb50379e984",
290
+ "state_digest_before": "d3d7f4002724b04913944be8eef040763b3e97948db5674fadf6efb50379e984"
291
+ },
292
+ {
293
+ "_raw_artifact": {
294
+ "format": "json.gz",
295
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
296
+ "sha256": "76aee636c74c65d14c3bb3f1f3634f312163296b408550c5d2231793471167e5",
297
+ "size_bytes": 519,
298
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
299
+ },
300
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
301
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
302
+ "metrics": {
303
+ "audit_complete": false,
304
+ "audit_item": 3,
305
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
306
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
307
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
308
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
309
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
310
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
311
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
312
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
313
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
314
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
315
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
316
+ "snn_involved": false
317
+ },
318
+ "runtime_error": null,
319
+ "seed": 102,
320
+ "state_digest_after": "3281377b9eb44f4e8493278fe87515d67c08f9a709cf04c09b7a93b4164dfe0f",
321
+ "state_digest_before": "3281377b9eb44f4e8493278fe87515d67c08f9a709cf04c09b7a93b4164dfe0f"
322
+ },
323
+ {
324
+ "_raw_artifact": {
325
+ "format": "json.gz",
326
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
327
+ "sha256": "52765aaa9348258d2dd082feae8ab61a3f2d23d9e1c2995166b0e0128240e909",
328
+ "size_bytes": 514,
329
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
330
+ },
331
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
332
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
333
+ "metrics": {
334
+ "audit_complete": false,
335
+ "audit_item": 4,
336
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
337
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
338
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
339
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
340
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
341
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
342
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
343
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
344
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
345
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
346
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
347
+ "snn_involved": false
348
+ },
349
+ "runtime_error": null,
350
+ "seed": 102,
351
+ "state_digest_after": "2639bce5fab1134131f33fdf8fa7304ae9c1e420508f068bc5e466923625c150",
352
+ "state_digest_before": "2639bce5fab1134131f33fdf8fa7304ae9c1e420508f068bc5e466923625c150"
353
+ },
354
+ {
355
+ "_raw_artifact": {
356
+ "format": "json.gz",
357
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
358
+ "sha256": "d489f1020c43876f3616f472f7793cf202b2f4305374f4bf34dd7e2582ae5514",
359
+ "size_bytes": 522,
360
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
361
+ },
362
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
363
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
364
+ "metrics": {
365
+ "audit_complete": false,
366
+ "audit_item": 1,
367
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
368
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
369
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
370
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
371
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
372
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
373
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
374
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
375
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
376
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
377
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
378
+ "snn_involved": false
379
+ },
380
+ "runtime_error": null,
381
+ "seed": 103,
382
+ "state_digest_after": "03874a794a7964212ed6625910afba8e8d432a090213039055b9c6e0559d77e9",
383
+ "state_digest_before": "03874a794a7964212ed6625910afba8e8d432a090213039055b9c6e0559d77e9"
384
+ },
385
+ {
386
+ "_raw_artifact": {
387
+ "format": "json.gz",
388
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
389
+ "sha256": "721aab27d61c9cabdcdacd849d72ae2fd33a903b90a5cf5bcd60c98d1b4c40fb",
390
+ "size_bytes": 518,
391
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
392
+ },
393
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
394
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
395
+ "metrics": {
396
+ "audit_complete": false,
397
+ "audit_item": 2,
398
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
399
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
400
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
401
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
402
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
403
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
404
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
405
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
406
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
407
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
408
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
409
+ "snn_involved": false
410
+ },
411
+ "runtime_error": null,
412
+ "seed": 103,
413
+ "state_digest_after": "a4cb4ef1e0d17ffad54183e3cf98295d9ab759d39aa8f1a158710e0e4c67d6d9",
414
+ "state_digest_before": "a4cb4ef1e0d17ffad54183e3cf98295d9ab759d39aa8f1a158710e0e4c67d6d9"
415
+ },
416
+ {
417
+ "_raw_artifact": {
418
+ "format": "json.gz",
419
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
420
+ "sha256": "4a1d252a132d60bb28a8ef00d1f0ef7d6c8790143067c6c918713d9d43323a69",
421
+ "size_bytes": 519,
422
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
423
+ },
424
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
425
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
426
+ "metrics": {
427
+ "audit_complete": false,
428
+ "audit_item": 3,
429
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
430
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
431
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
432
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
433
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
434
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
435
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
436
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
437
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
438
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
439
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
440
+ "snn_involved": false
441
+ },
442
+ "runtime_error": null,
443
+ "seed": 103,
444
+ "state_digest_after": "50d47f5746278ad20cd624b146de8a136ac48d2727049f8f9f2df16866a2f780",
445
+ "state_digest_before": "50d47f5746278ad20cd624b146de8a136ac48d2727049f8f9f2df16866a2f780"
446
+ },
447
+ {
448
+ "_raw_artifact": {
449
+ "format": "json.gz",
450
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
451
+ "sha256": "9a1abcc35a0f29ef800de2313813f3d9cbd3fa19dc6820391ddaab8b134bbf2c",
452
+ "size_bytes": 514,
453
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
454
+ },
455
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
456
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
457
+ "metrics": {
458
+ "audit_complete": false,
459
+ "audit_item": 4,
460
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
461
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
462
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
463
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
464
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
465
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
466
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
467
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
468
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
469
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
470
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
471
+ "snn_involved": false
472
+ },
473
+ "runtime_error": null,
474
+ "seed": 103,
475
+ "state_digest_after": "4887cbbc14a949c72b35cc402b259776f87eb015b3aa9d0351045083527c7ea5",
476
+ "state_digest_before": "4887cbbc14a949c72b35cc402b259776f87eb015b3aa9d0351045083527c7ea5"
477
+ }
478
+ ],
479
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
480
+ "statistics": {
481
+ "conditions": {
482
+ "alternative_model": {
483
+ "boolean_metrics": {
484
+ "audit_complete": {
485
+ "all_true": false,
486
+ "false_count": 3,
487
+ "n": 3,
488
+ "true_count": 0,
489
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
490
+ },
491
+ "audit_template_generated": {
492
+ "all_true": true,
493
+ "false_count": 0,
494
+ "n": 3,
495
+ "true_count": 3,
496
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
497
+ },
498
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
499
+ "all_true": false,
500
+ "false_count": 3,
501
+ "n": 3,
502
+ "true_count": 0,
503
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
504
+ },
505
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
506
+ "all_true": true,
507
+ "false_count": 0,
508
+ "n": 3,
509
+ "true_count": 3,
510
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
511
+ },
512
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
513
+ "all_true": false,
514
+ "false_count": 3,
515
+ "n": 3,
516
+ "true_count": 0,
517
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
518
+ },
519
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
520
+ "all_true": false,
521
+ "false_count": 3,
522
+ "n": 3,
523
+ "true_count": 0,
524
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
525
+ },
526
+ "scientific_evidence": {
527
+ "all_true": false,
528
+ "false_count": 3,
529
+ "n": 3,
530
+ "true_count": 0,
531
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
532
+ },
533
+ "snn_involved": {
534
+ "all_true": false,
535
+ "false_count": 3,
536
+ "n": 3,
537
+ "true_count": 0,
538
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
539
+ }
540
+ },
541
+ "metrics": {
542
+ "audit_item": {
543
+ "max": 2.0,
544
+ "mean": 2.0,
545
+ "median": 2.0,
546
+ "min": 2.0,
547
+ "n": 3,
548
+ "std": 0.0
549
+ }
550
+ },
551
+ "run_count": 3,
552
+ "seeds": [
553
+ 101,
554
+ 102,
555
+ 103
556
+ ]
557
+ },
558
+ "assumption_explicit": {
559
+ "boolean_metrics": {
560
+ "audit_complete": {
561
+ "all_true": false,
562
+ "false_count": 3,
563
+ "n": 3,
564
+ "true_count": 0,
565
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
566
+ },
567
+ "audit_template_generated": {
568
+ "all_true": true,
569
+ "false_count": 0,
570
+ "n": 3,
571
+ "true_count": 3,
572
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
573
+ },
574
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
575
+ "all_true": false,
576
+ "false_count": 3,
577
+ "n": 3,
578
+ "true_count": 0,
579
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
580
+ },
581
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
582
+ "all_true": true,
583
+ "false_count": 0,
584
+ "n": 3,
585
+ "true_count": 3,
586
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
587
+ },
588
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
589
+ "all_true": false,
590
+ "false_count": 3,
591
+ "n": 3,
592
+ "true_count": 0,
593
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
594
+ },
595
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
596
+ "all_true": false,
597
+ "false_count": 3,
598
+ "n": 3,
599
+ "true_count": 0,
600
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
601
+ },
602
+ "scientific_evidence": {
603
+ "all_true": false,
604
+ "false_count": 3,
605
+ "n": 3,
606
+ "true_count": 0,
607
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
608
+ },
609
+ "snn_involved": {
610
+ "all_true": false,
611
+ "false_count": 3,
612
+ "n": 3,
613
+ "true_count": 0,
614
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
615
+ }
616
+ },
617
+ "metrics": {
618
+ "audit_item": {
619
+ "max": 1.0,
620
+ "mean": 1.0,
621
+ "median": 1.0,
622
+ "min": 1.0,
623
+ "n": 3,
624
+ "std": 0.0
625
+ }
626
+ },
627
+ "run_count": 3,
628
+ "seeds": [
629
+ 101,
630
+ 102,
631
+ 103
632
+ ]
633
+ },
634
+ "claim_boundary": {
635
+ "boolean_metrics": {
636
+ "audit_complete": {
637
+ "all_true": false,
638
+ "false_count": 3,
639
+ "n": 3,
640
+ "true_count": 0,
641
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
642
+ },
643
+ "audit_template_generated": {
644
+ "all_true": true,
645
+ "false_count": 0,
646
+ "n": 3,
647
+ "true_count": 3,
648
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
649
+ },
650
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
651
+ "all_true": false,
652
+ "false_count": 3,
653
+ "n": 3,
654
+ "true_count": 0,
655
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
656
+ },
657
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
658
+ "all_true": true,
659
+ "false_count": 0,
660
+ "n": 3,
661
+ "true_count": 3,
662
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
663
+ },
664
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
665
+ "all_true": false,
666
+ "false_count": 3,
667
+ "n": 3,
668
+ "true_count": 0,
669
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
670
+ },
671
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
672
+ "all_true": false,
673
+ "false_count": 3,
674
+ "n": 3,
675
+ "true_count": 0,
676
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
677
+ },
678
+ "scientific_evidence": {
679
+ "all_true": false,
680
+ "false_count": 3,
681
+ "n": 3,
682
+ "true_count": 0,
683
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
684
+ },
685
+ "snn_involved": {
686
+ "all_true": false,
687
+ "false_count": 3,
688
+ "n": 3,
689
+ "true_count": 0,
690
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
691
+ }
692
+ },
693
+ "metrics": {
694
+ "audit_item": {
695
+ "max": 4.0,
696
+ "mean": 4.0,
697
+ "median": 4.0,
698
+ "min": 4.0,
699
+ "n": 3,
700
+ "std": 0.0
701
+ }
702
+ },
703
+ "run_count": 3,
704
+ "seeds": [
705
+ 101,
706
+ 102,
707
+ 103
708
+ ]
709
+ },
710
+ "measurement_limit": {
711
+ "boolean_metrics": {
712
+ "audit_complete": {
713
+ "all_true": false,
714
+ "false_count": 3,
715
+ "n": 3,
716
+ "true_count": 0,
717
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
718
+ },
719
+ "audit_template_generated": {
720
+ "all_true": true,
721
+ "false_count": 0,
722
+ "n": 3,
723
+ "true_count": 3,
724
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
725
+ },
726
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
727
+ "all_true": false,
728
+ "false_count": 3,
729
+ "n": 3,
730
+ "true_count": 0,
731
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
732
+ },
733
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
734
+ "all_true": true,
735
+ "false_count": 0,
736
+ "n": 3,
737
+ "true_count": 3,
738
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
739
+ },
740
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
741
+ "all_true": false,
742
+ "false_count": 3,
743
+ "n": 3,
744
+ "true_count": 0,
745
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
746
+ },
747
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
748
+ "all_true": false,
749
+ "false_count": 3,
750
+ "n": 3,
751
+ "true_count": 0,
752
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
753
+ },
754
+ "scientific_evidence": {
755
+ "all_true": false,
756
+ "false_count": 3,
757
+ "n": 3,
758
+ "true_count": 0,
759
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
760
+ },
761
+ "snn_involved": {
762
+ "all_true": false,
763
+ "false_count": 3,
764
+ "n": 3,
765
+ "true_count": 0,
766
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
767
+ }
768
+ },
769
+ "metrics": {
770
+ "audit_item": {
771
+ "max": 3.0,
772
+ "mean": 3.0,
773
+ "median": 3.0,
774
+ "min": 3.0,
775
+ "n": 3,
776
+ "std": 0.0
777
+ }
778
+ },
779
+ "run_count": 3,
780
+ "seeds": [
781
+ 101,
782
+ 102,
783
+ 103
784
+ ]
785
+ }
786
+ },
787
+ "formulas": {
788
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
789
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
790
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
791
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
792
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
793
+ },
794
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
795
+ "run_count": 12,
796
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
797
+ }
798
+ },
799
+ "evid": [],
800
+ "literature": [
801
+ {
802
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-BUTLIN",
803
+ "authors": [
804
+ "Patrick Butlin and others"
805
+ ],
806
+ "title": "Identifying indicators of consciousness in AI systems",
807
+ "year": 2026,
808
+ "doi": "10.1016/j.tics.2025.10.011",
809
+ "topic": [
810
+ "cognition",
811
+ "methodology",
812
+ "ethics"
813
+ ],
814
+ "claims": [],
815
+ "brain5d_questions": [
816
+ "RQ-CNS-101",
817
+ "RQ-CNS-112",
818
+ "RQ-CNS-113",
819
+ "RQ-EPI-102",
820
+ "RQ-WEL-102"
821
+ ],
822
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Theory-dependent indicators; no universally sufficient consciousness test. Online 2025, journal issue June 2026; not a Brain-5D validation. Source: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364661325002864"
823
+ },
824
+ {
825
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-COGITATE",
826
+ "authors": [
827
+ "Cogitate Consortium and others"
828
+ ],
829
+ "title": "Adversarial testing of global neuronal workspace and integrated information theories of consciousness",
830
+ "year": 2025,
831
+ "doi": "10.1038/s41586-025-08888-1",
832
+ "topic": [
833
+ "cognition",
834
+ "methodology",
835
+ "ethics"
836
+ ],
837
+ "claims": [],
838
+ "brain5d_questions": [
839
+ "RQ-CNS-101",
840
+ "RQ-EPI-101"
841
+ ],
842
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Contrasting predictions and adversarial testing; no consensus that one architecture is necessary for all possible artificial consciousness. Source: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-08888-1"
843
+ },
844
+ {
845
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-GNWREPLY",
846
+ "authors": [
847
+ "Lionel Naccache",
848
+ "Claire Sergent",
849
+ "Stanislas Dehaene",
850
+ "Xia-Jing Wang",
851
+ "Michele Farisco",
852
+ "Jean-Pierre Changeux"
853
+ ],
854
+ "title": "GNW theoretical framework and the adversarial testing of global neuronal workspace and integrated information theories of consciousness",
855
+ "year": 2025,
856
+ "doi": "10.1093/nc/niaf037",
857
+ "topic": [
858
+ "cognition",
859
+ "methodology",
860
+ "ethics"
861
+ ],
862
+ "claims": [],
863
+ "brain5d_questions": [
864
+ "RQ-CNS-101"
865
+ ],
866
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Records a substantive objection to interpretation of the adversarial test; not an independent replication. Source: https://doi.org/10.1093/nc/niaf037"
867
+ },
868
+ {
869
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-SETH",
870
+ "authors": [
871
+ "Anil K. Seth"
872
+ ],
873
+ "title": "Conscious artificial intelligence and biological naturalism",
874
+ "year": 2025,
875
+ "doi": "10.1017/S0140525X25000032",
876
+ "topic": [
877
+ "cognition",
878
+ "methodology",
879
+ "ethics"
880
+ ],
881
+ "claims": [],
882
+ "brain5d_questions": [
883
+ "RQ-CNS-101",
884
+ "RQ-CNS-113"
885
+ ],
886
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Biological-naturalist counterposition; its substrate assumptions are a theory position, not an established impossibility theorem. Source: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X25000032"
887
+ }
888
+ ]
889
+ },
890
+ "quantitative_results": {
891
+ "conditions": {
892
+ "alternative_model": {
893
+ "boolean_metrics": {
894
+ "audit_complete": {
895
+ "all_true": false,
896
+ "false_count": 3,
897
+ "n": 3,
898
+ "true_count": 0,
899
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
900
+ },
901
+ "audit_template_generated": {
902
+ "all_true": true,
903
+ "false_count": 0,
904
+ "n": 3,
905
+ "true_count": 3,
906
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
907
+ },
908
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
909
+ "all_true": false,
910
+ "false_count": 3,
911
+ "n": 3,
912
+ "true_count": 0,
913
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
914
+ },
915
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
916
+ "all_true": true,
917
+ "false_count": 0,
918
+ "n": 3,
919
+ "true_count": 3,
920
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
921
+ },
922
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
923
+ "all_true": false,
924
+ "false_count": 3,
925
+ "n": 3,
926
+ "true_count": 0,
927
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
928
+ },
929
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
930
+ "all_true": false,
931
+ "false_count": 3,
932
+ "n": 3,
933
+ "true_count": 0,
934
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
935
+ },
936
+ "scientific_evidence": {
937
+ "all_true": false,
938
+ "false_count": 3,
939
+ "n": 3,
940
+ "true_count": 0,
941
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
942
+ },
943
+ "snn_involved": {
944
+ "all_true": false,
945
+ "false_count": 3,
946
+ "n": 3,
947
+ "true_count": 0,
948
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
949
+ }
950
+ },
951
+ "metrics": {
952
+ "audit_item": {
953
+ "max": 2.0,
954
+ "mean": 2.0,
955
+ "median": 2.0,
956
+ "min": 2.0,
957
+ "n": 3,
958
+ "std": 0.0
959
+ }
960
+ },
961
+ "run_count": 3,
962
+ "seeds": [
963
+ 101,
964
+ 102,
965
+ 103
966
+ ]
967
+ },
968
+ "assumption_explicit": {
969
+ "boolean_metrics": {
970
+ "audit_complete": {
971
+ "all_true": false,
972
+ "false_count": 3,
973
+ "n": 3,
974
+ "true_count": 0,
975
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
976
+ },
977
+ "audit_template_generated": {
978
+ "all_true": true,
979
+ "false_count": 0,
980
+ "n": 3,
981
+ "true_count": 3,
982
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
983
+ },
984
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
985
+ "all_true": false,
986
+ "false_count": 3,
987
+ "n": 3,
988
+ "true_count": 0,
989
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
990
+ },
991
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
992
+ "all_true": true,
993
+ "false_count": 0,
994
+ "n": 3,
995
+ "true_count": 3,
996
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
997
+ },
998
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
999
+ "all_true": false,
1000
+ "false_count": 3,
1001
+ "n": 3,
1002
+ "true_count": 0,
1003
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1004
+ },
1005
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1006
+ "all_true": false,
1007
+ "false_count": 3,
1008
+ "n": 3,
1009
+ "true_count": 0,
1010
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1011
+ },
1012
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1013
+ "all_true": false,
1014
+ "false_count": 3,
1015
+ "n": 3,
1016
+ "true_count": 0,
1017
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1018
+ },
1019
+ "snn_involved": {
1020
+ "all_true": false,
1021
+ "false_count": 3,
1022
+ "n": 3,
1023
+ "true_count": 0,
1024
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1025
+ }
1026
+ },
1027
+ "metrics": {
1028
+ "audit_item": {
1029
+ "max": 1.0,
1030
+ "mean": 1.0,
1031
+ "median": 1.0,
1032
+ "min": 1.0,
1033
+ "n": 3,
1034
+ "std": 0.0
1035
+ }
1036
+ },
1037
+ "run_count": 3,
1038
+ "seeds": [
1039
+ 101,
1040
+ 102,
1041
+ 103
1042
+ ]
1043
+ },
1044
+ "claim_boundary": {
1045
+ "boolean_metrics": {
1046
+ "audit_complete": {
1047
+ "all_true": false,
1048
+ "false_count": 3,
1049
+ "n": 3,
1050
+ "true_count": 0,
1051
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1052
+ },
1053
+ "audit_template_generated": {
1054
+ "all_true": true,
1055
+ "false_count": 0,
1056
+ "n": 3,
1057
+ "true_count": 3,
1058
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1059
+ },
1060
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1061
+ "all_true": false,
1062
+ "false_count": 3,
1063
+ "n": 3,
1064
+ "true_count": 0,
1065
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1066
+ },
1067
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1068
+ "all_true": true,
1069
+ "false_count": 0,
1070
+ "n": 3,
1071
+ "true_count": 3,
1072
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1073
+ },
1074
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1075
+ "all_true": false,
1076
+ "false_count": 3,
1077
+ "n": 3,
1078
+ "true_count": 0,
1079
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1080
+ },
1081
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1082
+ "all_true": false,
1083
+ "false_count": 3,
1084
+ "n": 3,
1085
+ "true_count": 0,
1086
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1087
+ },
1088
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1089
+ "all_true": false,
1090
+ "false_count": 3,
1091
+ "n": 3,
1092
+ "true_count": 0,
1093
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1094
+ },
1095
+ "snn_involved": {
1096
+ "all_true": false,
1097
+ "false_count": 3,
1098
+ "n": 3,
1099
+ "true_count": 0,
1100
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1101
+ }
1102
+ },
1103
+ "metrics": {
1104
+ "audit_item": {
1105
+ "max": 4.0,
1106
+ "mean": 4.0,
1107
+ "median": 4.0,
1108
+ "min": 4.0,
1109
+ "n": 3,
1110
+ "std": 0.0
1111
+ }
1112
+ },
1113
+ "run_count": 3,
1114
+ "seeds": [
1115
+ 101,
1116
+ 102,
1117
+ 103
1118
+ ]
1119
+ },
1120
+ "measurement_limit": {
1121
+ "boolean_metrics": {
1122
+ "audit_complete": {
1123
+ "all_true": false,
1124
+ "false_count": 3,
1125
+ "n": 3,
1126
+ "true_count": 0,
1127
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1128
+ },
1129
+ "audit_template_generated": {
1130
+ "all_true": true,
1131
+ "false_count": 0,
1132
+ "n": 3,
1133
+ "true_count": 3,
1134
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1135
+ },
1136
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1137
+ "all_true": false,
1138
+ "false_count": 3,
1139
+ "n": 3,
1140
+ "true_count": 0,
1141
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1142
+ },
1143
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1144
+ "all_true": true,
1145
+ "false_count": 0,
1146
+ "n": 3,
1147
+ "true_count": 3,
1148
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1149
+ },
1150
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1151
+ "all_true": false,
1152
+ "false_count": 3,
1153
+ "n": 3,
1154
+ "true_count": 0,
1155
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1156
+ },
1157
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1158
+ "all_true": false,
1159
+ "false_count": 3,
1160
+ "n": 3,
1161
+ "true_count": 0,
1162
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1163
+ },
1164
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1165
+ "all_true": false,
1166
+ "false_count": 3,
1167
+ "n": 3,
1168
+ "true_count": 0,
1169
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1170
+ },
1171
+ "snn_involved": {
1172
+ "all_true": false,
1173
+ "false_count": 3,
1174
+ "n": 3,
1175
+ "true_count": 0,
1176
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1177
+ }
1178
+ },
1179
+ "metrics": {
1180
+ "audit_item": {
1181
+ "max": 3.0,
1182
+ "mean": 3.0,
1183
+ "median": 3.0,
1184
+ "min": 3.0,
1185
+ "n": 3,
1186
+ "std": 0.0
1187
+ }
1188
+ },
1189
+ "run_count": 3,
1190
+ "seeds": [
1191
+ 101,
1192
+ 102,
1193
+ 103
1194
+ ]
1195
+ }
1196
+ },
1197
+ "formulas": {
1198
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
1199
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
1200
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
1201
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
1202
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
1203
+ },
1204
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
1205
+ "run_count": 12,
1206
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
1207
+ },
1208
+ "observations": [
1209
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
1210
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
1211
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1212
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1213
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
1214
+ ],
1215
+ "interpretation": {
1216
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
1217
+ "confidence": 0.55,
1218
+ "effect_direction": "Die Audit-Items variieren in den Bedingungen, wobei 'claim_boundary' das höchste Audit-Item (4) und 'alternative_model' das niedrigste (2) hat.",
1219
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1220
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
1221
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
1222
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
1223
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
1224
+ ],
1225
+ "observations": [
1226
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
1227
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
1228
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1229
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1230
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
1231
+ ],
1232
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1233
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
1234
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
1235
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.",
1236
+ "Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist."
1237
+ ],
1238
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1239
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
1240
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
1241
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
1242
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
1243
+ ],
1244
+ "requested_evidence": [
1245
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
1246
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.",
1247
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
1248
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
1249
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
1250
+ ]
1251
+ },
1252
+ "methodological_critique": [
1253
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
1254
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
1255
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
1256
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
1257
+ ],
1258
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1259
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
1260
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
1261
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.",
1262
+ "Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist."
1263
+ ],
1264
+ "reproducibility": {
1265
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1266
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1267
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1268
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1269
+ "source_freeze_sha": "bac4e3d81dea549c50264184cc2b3cefc0f0db6bf104c8909c884a619f688f70",
1270
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1271
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1272
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "680ed5795a8d4f096fc69c7cf27edd362c86883403b57b23957f259f38055782",
1273
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1274
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1275
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1276
+ "protocol_digest": "d2b61756b743ef465b263af7feef20b0937c6477a6e55f433beaaf5550fb7e2f",
1277
+ "data_digest": "d979c3e34946bad511a9101c15c4a83b5025298ce63c8477af948f55029dd3c2",
1278
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1279
+ },
1280
+ "epistemic_status": {
1281
+ "implementation": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1282
+ "experiment_data": "PRESENT",
1283
+ "registered_evidence": "ABSENT",
1284
+ "ai_interpretation": "PRESENT",
1285
+ "human_review": "PENDING",
1286
+ "claim_support": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1287
+ "rq_status": "IN_PROGRESS",
1288
+ "semantic_alignment": "NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED",
1289
+ "semantic_note": "Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.",
1290
+ "design_adequacy": "NOT_ASSESSED",
1291
+ "design_note": "Für diese Forschungsfrage ist keine automatische Designadäquanz-Regel registriert.",
1292
+ "confidence_gate": "PASSED"
1293
+ },
1294
+ "ai_confidence": 0.55,
1295
+ "missing_evidence": [
1296
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
1297
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.",
1298
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
1299
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
1300
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
1301
+ ],
1302
+ "recommended_follow_up": [
1303
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
1304
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
1305
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
1306
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
1307
+ ],
1308
+ "conclusion": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
1309
+ "human_review": {
1310
+ "status": "PENDING",
1311
+ "reviewer": null,
1312
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1313
+ "disposition": null,
1314
+ "comments": null
1315
+ },
1316
+ "aiar": {
1317
+ "analyst": {
1318
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211542537168-c2fce764",
1319
+ "role": "scientific_analyst",
1320
+ "model": {
1321
+ "provider": "ollama",
1322
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1323
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1324
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1325
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1326
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1327
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1328
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1329
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1330
+ },
1331
+ "inputs": {
1332
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
1333
+ "packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714"
1334
+ },
1335
+ "output": {
1336
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
1337
+ "observations": [
1338
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
1339
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
1340
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1341
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1342
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
1343
+ ],
1344
+ "effect_direction": "Die Audit-Items variieren in den Bedingungen, wobei 'claim_boundary' das höchste Audit-Item (4) und 'alternative_model' das niedrigste (2) hat.",
1345
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1346
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
1347
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
1348
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
1349
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
1350
+ ],
1351
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1352
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
1353
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
1354
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führte."
1355
+ ],
1356
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1357
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
1358
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
1359
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
1360
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
1361
+ ],
1362
+ "requested_evidence": [
1363
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
1364
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützt.",
1365
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
1366
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
1367
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
1368
+ ],
1369
+ "confidence": 0.55
1370
+ },
1371
+ "provenance": {
1372
+ "prompt_sha256": "488ada45fbb7a28ac2f0e4fd0113882ffa3ded28b59748744ddbaded706e23a4",
1373
+ "research_packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714",
1374
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1375
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1376
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1377
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.55"
1378
+ },
1379
+ "epistemic_status": {
1380
+ "evidence": false,
1381
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1382
+ "human_review_required": true
1383
+ },
1384
+ "review": {
1385
+ "status": "pending",
1386
+ "reviewer": null,
1387
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1388
+ "disposition": null
1389
+ },
1390
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:15:42.537168+00:00"
1391
+ },
1392
+ "reviewer": {
1393
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001211610885260-c2fce764",
1394
+ "role": "critical_reviewer",
1395
+ "model": {
1396
+ "provider": "ollama",
1397
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1398
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1399
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1400
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1401
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1402
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1403
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1404
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1405
+ },
1406
+ "inputs": {
1407
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
1408
+ "packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714"
1409
+ },
1410
+ "output": {
1411
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
1412
+ "observations": [
1413
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
1414
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
1415
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1416
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1417
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
1418
+ ],
1419
+ "effect_direction": "Die Audit-Items variieren in den Bedingungen, wobei 'claim_boundary' das höchste Audit-Item (4) und 'alternative_model' das niedrigste (2) hat.",
1420
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1421
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
1422
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
1423
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
1424
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
1425
+ ],
1426
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1427
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
1428
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
1429
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.",
1430
+ "Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist."
1431
+ ],
1432
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1433
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
1434
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
1435
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
1436
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
1437
+ ],
1438
+ "requested_evidence": [
1439
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
1440
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.",
1441
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
1442
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
1443
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
1444
+ ],
1445
+ "confidence": 0.55
1446
+ },
1447
+ "provenance": {
1448
+ "prompt_sha256": "5a059474ee0402323c750b4d54fc11a9af6a84c0ec1b2a23369a3f45423e3b4d",
1449
+ "research_packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714",
1450
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1451
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1452
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1453
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.55"
1454
+ },
1455
+ "epistemic_status": {
1456
+ "evidence": false,
1457
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1458
+ "human_review_required": true
1459
+ },
1460
+ "review": {
1461
+ "status": "pending",
1462
+ "reviewer": null,
1463
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1464
+ "disposition": null
1465
+ },
1466
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:16:10.885260+00:00"
1467
+ },
1468
+ "writer": {
1469
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001211731555494-c2fce764",
1470
+ "role": "scientific_writer",
1471
+ "model": {
1472
+ "provider": "ollama",
1473
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1474
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1475
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1476
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1477
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1478
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1479
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1480
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1481
+ },
1482
+ "inputs": {
1483
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
1484
+ "packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714"
1485
+ },
1486
+ "output": {
1487
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
1488
+ "confidence": 0.55,
1489
+ "effect_direction": "Die Audit-Items variieren in den Bedingungen, wobei 'claim_boundary' das höchste Audit-Item (4) und 'alternative_model' das niedrigste (2) hat.",
1490
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1491
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
1492
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
1493
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
1494
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
1495
+ ],
1496
+ "observations": [
1497
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
1498
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
1499
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1500
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1501
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
1502
+ ],
1503
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1504
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
1505
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
1506
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.",
1507
+ "Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist."
1508
+ ],
1509
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1510
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
1511
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
1512
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
1513
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
1514
+ ],
1515
+ "requested_evidence": [
1516
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
1517
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.",
1518
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
1519
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
1520
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
1521
+ ]
1522
+ },
1523
+ "provenance": {
1524
+ "prompt_sha256": "6ea65ed61e141cd8c7379905fa4e80c7fa98847f22f17db27f6cc0e29b1c4d8b",
1525
+ "research_packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714",
1526
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1527
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1528
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1529
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.55"
1530
+ },
1531
+ "epistemic_status": {
1532
+ "evidence": false,
1533
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1534
+ "human_review_required": true
1535
+ },
1536
+ "review": {
1537
+ "status": "pending",
1538
+ "reviewer": null,
1539
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1540
+ "disposition": null
1541
+ },
1542
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:17:31.555494+00:00"
1543
+ }
1544
+ }
1545
+ },
1546
+ "provenance": {
1547
+ "research_packet_digest": "c2fce7645f87c8ea7f5aa7ad2428058a2b7d7a278ac7a9ab2d1ded509f11a714",
1548
+ "source": {
1549
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1550
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1551
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1552
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1553
+ "source_freeze_sha": "bac4e3d81dea549c50264184cc2b3cefc0f0db6bf104c8909c884a619f688f70",
1554
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1555
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1556
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "680ed5795a8d4f096fc69c7cf27edd362c86883403b57b23957f259f38055782",
1557
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1558
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1559
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1560
+ "protocol_digest": "d2b61756b743ef465b263af7feef20b0937c6477a6e55f433beaaf5550fb7e2f",
1561
+ "data_digest": "d979c3e34946bad511a9101c15c4a83b5025298ce63c8477af948f55029dd3c2",
1562
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1563
+ }
1564
+ },
1565
+ "analysis_ids": [
1566
+ "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211542537168-c2fce764",
1567
+ "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001211610885260-c2fce764",
1568
+ "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001211731555494-c2fce764"
1569
+ ],
1570
+ "supersedes": null,
1571
+ "content_digest": "1e1b4ad024a2d2770372c47063b1d356297085dbae12a29ecd4fa6fe98051c44",
1572
+ "markdown_digest": "ede8b69d23c2d373843c556745b86e3ef59d0d8a4389dfe69ccc120974998625"
1573
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,1379 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ ============================================================
2
+ BRAIN-5D - AI GENERATED SCIENTIFIC ANALYSIS
3
+ ============================================================
4
+
5
+ Dieser Bericht wurde durch ein kuenstliches Intelligenzsystem erzeugt.
6
+
7
+ Er stellt eine wissenschaftliche Interpretation von MHRN-Forschungsdaten dar.
8
+
9
+ Er ist KEINE wissenschaftliche Evidenz.
10
+
11
+ Er wurde zum Zeitpunkt der Erstellung noch nicht automatisch durch einen Menschen bestaetigt.
12
+
13
+ Human Review Status: PENDING
14
+ ============================================================
15
+
16
+ # AI Research Report AIRR-2026-0001
17
+
18
+ Status: review_pending | Experiment: EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01
19
+ Research Question: RQ-CNS-101
20
+ ## Executive Summary
21
+
22
+ ```json
23
+ "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente."
24
+ ```
25
+
26
+ ## Research Question
27
+
28
+ ```json
29
+ {
30
+ "id": "RQ-CNS-101",
31
+ "domain": "Consciousness methodology",
32
+ "question": "Welche beobachtbaren Indikatoren unterscheiden konkurrierende Bewusstseinsmodelle, und welche Erlebensbehauptungen bleiben dadurch unidentifiziert?",
33
+ "relevance": "Theory-to-indicator and identifiability audit; Conceptual/model comparison; no ground-truth phenomenal labels",
34
+ "literature": [
35
+ "SRC-CNS-BUTLIN",
36
+ "SRC-CNS-COGITATE",
37
+ "SRC-CNS-GNWREPLY",
38
+ "SRC-CNS-SETH"
39
+ ],
40
+ "hypotheses": [
41
+ "H-CNS-101-A"
42
+ ],
43
+ "evidence": [],
44
+ "status": "open",
45
+ "answer": {
46
+ "current": null,
47
+ "confidence": "none",
48
+ "limitations": "Conceptual/model comparison; no ground-truth phenomenal labels"
49
+ },
50
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
51
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
52
+ }
53
+ ```
54
+
55
+ ## Experimental Design
56
+
57
+ ```json
58
+ {
59
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
60
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-101",
61
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-101-A",
62
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_101_v1",
63
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
64
+ "ticks": 1,
65
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
66
+ "seeds": [
67
+ 101,
68
+ 102,
69
+ 103
70
+ ],
71
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_101_v1",
72
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_101_v1",
73
+ "tick_validation": {
74
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
75
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
76
+ "requested_ticks": 1
77
+ },
78
+ "notes": "Conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
79
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
80
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
81
+ "epistemic_layers": {
82
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
83
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
84
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
85
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
86
+ }
87
+ }
88
+ ```
89
+
90
+ ## Data Basis
91
+
92
+ ```json
93
+ {
94
+ "data": {
95
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
96
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
97
+ "limits": {
98
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
99
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
100
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
101
+ },
102
+ "raw_index": {
103
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
104
+ "run_count": 12,
105
+ "sha256": "7cf7292c070009b961fc0ce3185e68aa3c12774106f0760ef2a85ac5882a68ec"
106
+ },
107
+ "run_count": 12,
108
+ "run_preview": [
109
+ {
110
+ "_raw_artifact": {
111
+ "format": "json.gz",
112
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
113
+ "sha256": "81e5562696f1151db42357892d1a3102987df60256e26632b33946c1fec92bac",
114
+ "size_bytes": 520,
115
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
116
+ },
117
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
118
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
119
+ "metrics": {
120
+ "audit_complete": false,
121
+ "audit_item": 1,
122
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
123
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
124
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
125
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
126
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
127
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
128
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
129
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
130
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
131
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
132
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
133
+ "snn_involved": false
134
+ },
135
+ "runtime_error": null,
136
+ "seed": 101,
137
+ "state_digest_after": "1ef14aec911a59d248f0981fca2ec80e39071b41275a60ed0ee16e21ce691728",
138
+ "state_digest_before": "1ef14aec911a59d248f0981fca2ec80e39071b41275a60ed0ee16e21ce691728"
139
+ },
140
+ {
141
+ "_raw_artifact": {
142
+ "format": "json.gz",
143
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
144
+ "sha256": "07d9d0632d8a99a29717e86d59eb9482c868ff19edbe47a8311ff5f9822273dd",
145
+ "size_bytes": 516,
146
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
147
+ },
148
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
149
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
150
+ "metrics": {
151
+ "audit_complete": false,
152
+ "audit_item": 2,
153
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
154
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
155
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
156
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
157
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
158
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
159
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
160
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
161
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
162
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
163
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
164
+ "snn_involved": false
165
+ },
166
+ "runtime_error": null,
167
+ "seed": 101,
168
+ "state_digest_after": "3ed0d926fc42e2527e649771ae03cbe89afc97c5530aab28160bb0148ebefa0f",
169
+ "state_digest_before": "3ed0d926fc42e2527e649771ae03cbe89afc97c5530aab28160bb0148ebefa0f"
170
+ },
171
+ {
172
+ "_raw_artifact": {
173
+ "format": "json.gz",
174
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
175
+ "sha256": "20a85b3b25d8be07e9241c2017939fc28490efe411e6cb9ca74d5f97aac5766f",
176
+ "size_bytes": 516,
177
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
178
+ },
179
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
180
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
181
+ "metrics": {
182
+ "audit_complete": false,
183
+ "audit_item": 3,
184
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
185
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
186
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
187
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
188
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
189
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
190
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
191
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
192
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
193
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
194
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
195
+ "snn_involved": false
196
+ },
197
+ "runtime_error": null,
198
+ "seed": 101,
199
+ "state_digest_after": "bb45c009deb085e34bd4317fdf646cda28a66b3294d80b284623fbb3ad3eddee",
200
+ "state_digest_before": "bb45c009deb085e34bd4317fdf646cda28a66b3294d80b284623fbb3ad3eddee"
201
+ },
202
+ {
203
+ "_raw_artifact": {
204
+ "format": "json.gz",
205
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
206
+ "sha256": "3637b6f1034dfad21cd7036d7cb21c6b4b92c5cca278b5f0e03c5bb213913f54",
207
+ "size_bytes": 510,
208
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
209
+ },
210
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
211
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
212
+ "metrics": {
213
+ "audit_complete": false,
214
+ "audit_item": 4,
215
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
216
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
217
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
218
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
219
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
220
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
221
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
222
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
223
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
224
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
225
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
226
+ "snn_involved": false
227
+ },
228
+ "runtime_error": null,
229
+ "seed": 101,
230
+ "state_digest_after": "c0b6ed6204b2bf69a84b16ebae0aeb0b92504b900100b878d9fbe006abdc78ac",
231
+ "state_digest_before": "c0b6ed6204b2bf69a84b16ebae0aeb0b92504b900100b878d9fbe006abdc78ac"
232
+ },
233
+ {
234
+ "_raw_artifact": {
235
+ "format": "json.gz",
236
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
237
+ "sha256": "b0f32e7b33203876783d6c3ec669f615b07a0de2f3d0518603919525f4828aee",
238
+ "size_bytes": 522,
239
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
240
+ },
241
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
242
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
243
+ "metrics": {
244
+ "audit_complete": false,
245
+ "audit_item": 1,
246
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
247
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
248
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
249
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
250
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
251
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
252
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
253
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
254
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
255
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
256
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
257
+ "snn_involved": false
258
+ },
259
+ "runtime_error": null,
260
+ "seed": 102,
261
+ "state_digest_after": "fad51d00949f8dea2f2bba89f1ed19142f9bdf99f193ae0653fcf877dc8d7021",
262
+ "state_digest_before": "fad51d00949f8dea2f2bba89f1ed19142f9bdf99f193ae0653fcf877dc8d7021"
263
+ },
264
+ {
265
+ "_raw_artifact": {
266
+ "format": "json.gz",
267
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
268
+ "sha256": "cebce3c9d034d317af9496a9e92cd9b712bbdee88365b53e2438c8ab5b56e901",
269
+ "size_bytes": 520,
270
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
271
+ },
272
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
273
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
274
+ "metrics": {
275
+ "audit_complete": false,
276
+ "audit_item": 2,
277
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
278
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
279
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
280
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
281
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
282
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
283
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
284
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
285
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
286
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
287
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
288
+ "snn_involved": false
289
+ },
290
+ "runtime_error": null,
291
+ "seed": 102,
292
+ "state_digest_after": "d3d7f4002724b04913944be8eef040763b3e97948db5674fadf6efb50379e984",
293
+ "state_digest_before": "d3d7f4002724b04913944be8eef040763b3e97948db5674fadf6efb50379e984"
294
+ },
295
+ {
296
+ "_raw_artifact": {
297
+ "format": "json.gz",
298
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
299
+ "sha256": "76aee636c74c65d14c3bb3f1f3634f312163296b408550c5d2231793471167e5",
300
+ "size_bytes": 519,
301
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
302
+ },
303
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
304
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
305
+ "metrics": {
306
+ "audit_complete": false,
307
+ "audit_item": 3,
308
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
309
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
310
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
311
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
312
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
313
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
314
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
315
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
316
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
317
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
318
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
319
+ "snn_involved": false
320
+ },
321
+ "runtime_error": null,
322
+ "seed": 102,
323
+ "state_digest_after": "3281377b9eb44f4e8493278fe87515d67c08f9a709cf04c09b7a93b4164dfe0f",
324
+ "state_digest_before": "3281377b9eb44f4e8493278fe87515d67c08f9a709cf04c09b7a93b4164dfe0f"
325
+ },
326
+ {
327
+ "_raw_artifact": {
328
+ "format": "json.gz",
329
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
330
+ "sha256": "52765aaa9348258d2dd082feae8ab61a3f2d23d9e1c2995166b0e0128240e909",
331
+ "size_bytes": 514,
332
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
333
+ },
334
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
335
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
336
+ "metrics": {
337
+ "audit_complete": false,
338
+ "audit_item": 4,
339
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
340
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
341
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
342
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
343
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
344
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
345
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
346
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
347
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
348
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
349
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
350
+ "snn_involved": false
351
+ },
352
+ "runtime_error": null,
353
+ "seed": 102,
354
+ "state_digest_after": "2639bce5fab1134131f33fdf8fa7304ae9c1e420508f068bc5e466923625c150",
355
+ "state_digest_before": "2639bce5fab1134131f33fdf8fa7304ae9c1e420508f068bc5e466923625c150"
356
+ },
357
+ {
358
+ "_raw_artifact": {
359
+ "format": "json.gz",
360
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
361
+ "sha256": "d489f1020c43876f3616f472f7793cf202b2f4305374f4bf34dd7e2582ae5514",
362
+ "size_bytes": 522,
363
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 827
364
+ },
365
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
366
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
367
+ "metrics": {
368
+ "audit_complete": false,
369
+ "audit_item": 1,
370
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
371
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
372
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
373
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
374
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
375
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
376
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
377
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
378
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
379
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
380
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
381
+ "snn_involved": false
382
+ },
383
+ "runtime_error": null,
384
+ "seed": 103,
385
+ "state_digest_after": "03874a794a7964212ed6625910afba8e8d432a090213039055b9c6e0559d77e9",
386
+ "state_digest_before": "03874a794a7964212ed6625910afba8e8d432a090213039055b9c6e0559d77e9"
387
+ },
388
+ {
389
+ "_raw_artifact": {
390
+ "format": "json.gz",
391
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
392
+ "sha256": "721aab27d61c9cabdcdacd849d72ae2fd33a903b90a5cf5bcd60c98d1b4c40fb",
393
+ "size_bytes": 518,
394
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
395
+ },
396
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
397
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
398
+ "metrics": {
399
+ "audit_complete": false,
400
+ "audit_item": 2,
401
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
402
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
403
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
404
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
405
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
406
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
407
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
408
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
409
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
410
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
411
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
412
+ "snn_involved": false
413
+ },
414
+ "runtime_error": null,
415
+ "seed": 103,
416
+ "state_digest_after": "a4cb4ef1e0d17ffad54183e3cf98295d9ab759d39aa8f1a158710e0e4c67d6d9",
417
+ "state_digest_before": "a4cb4ef1e0d17ffad54183e3cf98295d9ab759d39aa8f1a158710e0e4c67d6d9"
418
+ },
419
+ {
420
+ "_raw_artifact": {
421
+ "format": "json.gz",
422
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
423
+ "sha256": "4a1d252a132d60bb28a8ef00d1f0ef7d6c8790143067c6c918713d9d43323a69",
424
+ "size_bytes": 519,
425
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
426
+ },
427
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
428
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
429
+ "metrics": {
430
+ "audit_complete": false,
431
+ "audit_item": 3,
432
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
433
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
434
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
435
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
436
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
437
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
438
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
439
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
440
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
441
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
442
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
443
+ "snn_involved": false
444
+ },
445
+ "runtime_error": null,
446
+ "seed": 103,
447
+ "state_digest_after": "50d47f5746278ad20cd624b146de8a136ac48d2727049f8f9f2df16866a2f780",
448
+ "state_digest_before": "50d47f5746278ad20cd624b146de8a136ac48d2727049f8f9f2df16866a2f780"
449
+ },
450
+ {
451
+ "_raw_artifact": {
452
+ "format": "json.gz",
453
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
454
+ "sha256": "9a1abcc35a0f29ef800de2313813f3d9cbd3fa19dc6820391ddaab8b134bbf2c",
455
+ "size_bytes": 514,
456
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 822
457
+ },
458
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
459
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
460
+ "metrics": {
461
+ "audit_complete": false,
462
+ "audit_item": 4,
463
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
464
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
465
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
466
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
467
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
468
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
469
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
470
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
471
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
472
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
473
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
474
+ "snn_involved": false
475
+ },
476
+ "runtime_error": null,
477
+ "seed": 103,
478
+ "state_digest_after": "4887cbbc14a949c72b35cc402b259776f87eb015b3aa9d0351045083527c7ea5",
479
+ "state_digest_before": "4887cbbc14a949c72b35cc402b259776f87eb015b3aa9d0351045083527c7ea5"
480
+ }
481
+ ],
482
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
483
+ "statistics": {
484
+ "conditions": {
485
+ "alternative_model": {
486
+ "boolean_metrics": {
487
+ "audit_complete": {
488
+ "all_true": false,
489
+ "false_count": 3,
490
+ "n": 3,
491
+ "true_count": 0,
492
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
493
+ },
494
+ "audit_template_generated": {
495
+ "all_true": true,
496
+ "false_count": 0,
497
+ "n": 3,
498
+ "true_count": 3,
499
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
500
+ },
501
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
502
+ "all_true": false,
503
+ "false_count": 3,
504
+ "n": 3,
505
+ "true_count": 0,
506
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
507
+ },
508
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
509
+ "all_true": true,
510
+ "false_count": 0,
511
+ "n": 3,
512
+ "true_count": 3,
513
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
514
+ },
515
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
516
+ "all_true": false,
517
+ "false_count": 3,
518
+ "n": 3,
519
+ "true_count": 0,
520
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
521
+ },
522
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
523
+ "all_true": false,
524
+ "false_count": 3,
525
+ "n": 3,
526
+ "true_count": 0,
527
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
528
+ },
529
+ "scientific_evidence": {
530
+ "all_true": false,
531
+ "false_count": 3,
532
+ "n": 3,
533
+ "true_count": 0,
534
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
535
+ },
536
+ "snn_involved": {
537
+ "all_true": false,
538
+ "false_count": 3,
539
+ "n": 3,
540
+ "true_count": 0,
541
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
542
+ }
543
+ },
544
+ "metrics": {
545
+ "audit_item": {
546
+ "max": 2.0,
547
+ "mean": 2.0,
548
+ "median": 2.0,
549
+ "min": 2.0,
550
+ "n": 3,
551
+ "std": 0.0
552
+ }
553
+ },
554
+ "run_count": 3,
555
+ "seeds": [
556
+ 101,
557
+ 102,
558
+ 103
559
+ ]
560
+ },
561
+ "assumption_explicit": {
562
+ "boolean_metrics": {
563
+ "audit_complete": {
564
+ "all_true": false,
565
+ "false_count": 3,
566
+ "n": 3,
567
+ "true_count": 0,
568
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
569
+ },
570
+ "audit_template_generated": {
571
+ "all_true": true,
572
+ "false_count": 0,
573
+ "n": 3,
574
+ "true_count": 3,
575
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
576
+ },
577
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
578
+ "all_true": false,
579
+ "false_count": 3,
580
+ "n": 3,
581
+ "true_count": 0,
582
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
583
+ },
584
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
585
+ "all_true": true,
586
+ "false_count": 0,
587
+ "n": 3,
588
+ "true_count": 3,
589
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
590
+ },
591
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
592
+ "all_true": false,
593
+ "false_count": 3,
594
+ "n": 3,
595
+ "true_count": 0,
596
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
597
+ },
598
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
599
+ "all_true": false,
600
+ "false_count": 3,
601
+ "n": 3,
602
+ "true_count": 0,
603
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
604
+ },
605
+ "scientific_evidence": {
606
+ "all_true": false,
607
+ "false_count": 3,
608
+ "n": 3,
609
+ "true_count": 0,
610
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
611
+ },
612
+ "snn_involved": {
613
+ "all_true": false,
614
+ "false_count": 3,
615
+ "n": 3,
616
+ "true_count": 0,
617
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
618
+ }
619
+ },
620
+ "metrics": {
621
+ "audit_item": {
622
+ "max": 1.0,
623
+ "mean": 1.0,
624
+ "median": 1.0,
625
+ "min": 1.0,
626
+ "n": 3,
627
+ "std": 0.0
628
+ }
629
+ },
630
+ "run_count": 3,
631
+ "seeds": [
632
+ 101,
633
+ 102,
634
+ 103
635
+ ]
636
+ },
637
+ "claim_boundary": {
638
+ "boolean_metrics": {
639
+ "audit_complete": {
640
+ "all_true": false,
641
+ "false_count": 3,
642
+ "n": 3,
643
+ "true_count": 0,
644
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
645
+ },
646
+ "audit_template_generated": {
647
+ "all_true": true,
648
+ "false_count": 0,
649
+ "n": 3,
650
+ "true_count": 3,
651
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
652
+ },
653
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
654
+ "all_true": false,
655
+ "false_count": 3,
656
+ "n": 3,
657
+ "true_count": 0,
658
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
659
+ },
660
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
661
+ "all_true": true,
662
+ "false_count": 0,
663
+ "n": 3,
664
+ "true_count": 3,
665
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
666
+ },
667
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
668
+ "all_true": false,
669
+ "false_count": 3,
670
+ "n": 3,
671
+ "true_count": 0,
672
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
673
+ },
674
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
675
+ "all_true": false,
676
+ "false_count": 3,
677
+ "n": 3,
678
+ "true_count": 0,
679
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
680
+ },
681
+ "scientific_evidence": {
682
+ "all_true": false,
683
+ "false_count": 3,
684
+ "n": 3,
685
+ "true_count": 0,
686
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
687
+ },
688
+ "snn_involved": {
689
+ "all_true": false,
690
+ "false_count": 3,
691
+ "n": 3,
692
+ "true_count": 0,
693
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
694
+ }
695
+ },
696
+ "metrics": {
697
+ "audit_item": {
698
+ "max": 4.0,
699
+ "mean": 4.0,
700
+ "median": 4.0,
701
+ "min": 4.0,
702
+ "n": 3,
703
+ "std": 0.0
704
+ }
705
+ },
706
+ "run_count": 3,
707
+ "seeds": [
708
+ 101,
709
+ 102,
710
+ 103
711
+ ]
712
+ },
713
+ "measurement_limit": {
714
+ "boolean_metrics": {
715
+ "audit_complete": {
716
+ "all_true": false,
717
+ "false_count": 3,
718
+ "n": 3,
719
+ "true_count": 0,
720
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
721
+ },
722
+ "audit_template_generated": {
723
+ "all_true": true,
724
+ "false_count": 0,
725
+ "n": 3,
726
+ "true_count": 3,
727
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
728
+ },
729
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
730
+ "all_true": false,
731
+ "false_count": 3,
732
+ "n": 3,
733
+ "true_count": 0,
734
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
735
+ },
736
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
737
+ "all_true": true,
738
+ "false_count": 0,
739
+ "n": 3,
740
+ "true_count": 3,
741
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
742
+ },
743
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
744
+ "all_true": false,
745
+ "false_count": 3,
746
+ "n": 3,
747
+ "true_count": 0,
748
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
749
+ },
750
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
751
+ "all_true": false,
752
+ "false_count": 3,
753
+ "n": 3,
754
+ "true_count": 0,
755
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
756
+ },
757
+ "scientific_evidence": {
758
+ "all_true": false,
759
+ "false_count": 3,
760
+ "n": 3,
761
+ "true_count": 0,
762
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
763
+ },
764
+ "snn_involved": {
765
+ "all_true": false,
766
+ "false_count": 3,
767
+ "n": 3,
768
+ "true_count": 0,
769
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
770
+ }
771
+ },
772
+ "metrics": {
773
+ "audit_item": {
774
+ "max": 3.0,
775
+ "mean": 3.0,
776
+ "median": 3.0,
777
+ "min": 3.0,
778
+ "n": 3,
779
+ "std": 0.0
780
+ }
781
+ },
782
+ "run_count": 3,
783
+ "seeds": [
784
+ 101,
785
+ 102,
786
+ 103
787
+ ]
788
+ }
789
+ },
790
+ "formulas": {
791
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
792
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
793
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
794
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
795
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
796
+ },
797
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
798
+ "run_count": 12,
799
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
800
+ }
801
+ },
802
+ "evid": [],
803
+ "literature": [
804
+ {
805
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-BUTLIN",
806
+ "authors": [
807
+ "Patrick Butlin and others"
808
+ ],
809
+ "title": "Identifying indicators of consciousness in AI systems",
810
+ "year": 2026,
811
+ "doi": "10.1016/j.tics.2025.10.011",
812
+ "topic": [
813
+ "cognition",
814
+ "methodology",
815
+ "ethics"
816
+ ],
817
+ "claims": [],
818
+ "brain5d_questions": [
819
+ "RQ-CNS-101",
820
+ "RQ-CNS-112",
821
+ "RQ-CNS-113",
822
+ "RQ-EPI-102",
823
+ "RQ-WEL-102"
824
+ ],
825
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Theory-dependent indicators; no universally sufficient consciousness test. Online 2025, journal issue June 2026; not a Brain-5D validation. Source: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364661325002864"
826
+ },
827
+ {
828
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-COGITATE",
829
+ "authors": [
830
+ "Cogitate Consortium and others"
831
+ ],
832
+ "title": "Adversarial testing of global neuronal workspace and integrated information theories of consciousness",
833
+ "year": 2025,
834
+ "doi": "10.1038/s41586-025-08888-1",
835
+ "topic": [
836
+ "cognition",
837
+ "methodology",
838
+ "ethics"
839
+ ],
840
+ "claims": [],
841
+ "brain5d_questions": [
842
+ "RQ-CNS-101",
843
+ "RQ-EPI-101"
844
+ ],
845
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Contrasting predictions and adversarial testing; no consensus that one architecture is necessary for all possible artificial consciousness. Source: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-08888-1"
846
+ },
847
+ {
848
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-GNWREPLY",
849
+ "authors": [
850
+ "Lionel Naccache",
851
+ "Claire Sergent",
852
+ "Stanislas Dehaene",
853
+ "Xia-Jing Wang",
854
+ "Michele Farisco",
855
+ "Jean-Pierre Changeux"
856
+ ],
857
+ "title": "GNW theoretical framework and the adversarial testing of global neuronal workspace and integrated information theories of consciousness",
858
+ "year": 2025,
859
+ "doi": "10.1093/nc/niaf037",
860
+ "topic": [
861
+ "cognition",
862
+ "methodology",
863
+ "ethics"
864
+ ],
865
+ "claims": [],
866
+ "brain5d_questions": [
867
+ "RQ-CNS-101"
868
+ ],
869
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Records a substantive objection to interpretation of the adversarial test; not an independent replication. Source: https://doi.org/10.1093/nc/niaf037"
870
+ },
871
+ {
872
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-SETH",
873
+ "authors": [
874
+ "Anil K. Seth"
875
+ ],
876
+ "title": "Conscious artificial intelligence and biological naturalism",
877
+ "year": 2025,
878
+ "doi": "10.1017/S0140525X25000032",
879
+ "topic": [
880
+ "cognition",
881
+ "methodology",
882
+ "ethics"
883
+ ],
884
+ "claims": [],
885
+ "brain5d_questions": [
886
+ "RQ-CNS-101",
887
+ "RQ-CNS-113"
888
+ ],
889
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Biological-naturalist counterposition; its substrate assumptions are a theory position, not an established impossibility theorem. Source: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X25000032"
890
+ }
891
+ ]
892
+ }
893
+ ```
894
+
895
+ ## Quantitative Results
896
+
897
+ ```json
898
+ {
899
+ "conditions": {
900
+ "alternative_model": {
901
+ "boolean_metrics": {
902
+ "audit_complete": {
903
+ "all_true": false,
904
+ "false_count": 3,
905
+ "n": 3,
906
+ "true_count": 0,
907
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
908
+ },
909
+ "audit_template_generated": {
910
+ "all_true": true,
911
+ "false_count": 0,
912
+ "n": 3,
913
+ "true_count": 3,
914
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
915
+ },
916
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
917
+ "all_true": false,
918
+ "false_count": 3,
919
+ "n": 3,
920
+ "true_count": 0,
921
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
922
+ },
923
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
924
+ "all_true": true,
925
+ "false_count": 0,
926
+ "n": 3,
927
+ "true_count": 3,
928
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
929
+ },
930
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
931
+ "all_true": false,
932
+ "false_count": 3,
933
+ "n": 3,
934
+ "true_count": 0,
935
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
936
+ },
937
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
938
+ "all_true": false,
939
+ "false_count": 3,
940
+ "n": 3,
941
+ "true_count": 0,
942
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
943
+ },
944
+ "scientific_evidence": {
945
+ "all_true": false,
946
+ "false_count": 3,
947
+ "n": 3,
948
+ "true_count": 0,
949
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
950
+ },
951
+ "snn_involved": {
952
+ "all_true": false,
953
+ "false_count": 3,
954
+ "n": 3,
955
+ "true_count": 0,
956
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
957
+ }
958
+ },
959
+ "metrics": {
960
+ "audit_item": {
961
+ "max": 2.0,
962
+ "mean": 2.0,
963
+ "median": 2.0,
964
+ "min": 2.0,
965
+ "n": 3,
966
+ "std": 0.0
967
+ }
968
+ },
969
+ "run_count": 3,
970
+ "seeds": [
971
+ 101,
972
+ 102,
973
+ 103
974
+ ]
975
+ },
976
+ "assumption_explicit": {
977
+ "boolean_metrics": {
978
+ "audit_complete": {
979
+ "all_true": false,
980
+ "false_count": 3,
981
+ "n": 3,
982
+ "true_count": 0,
983
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
984
+ },
985
+ "audit_template_generated": {
986
+ "all_true": true,
987
+ "false_count": 0,
988
+ "n": 3,
989
+ "true_count": 3,
990
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
991
+ },
992
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
993
+ "all_true": false,
994
+ "false_count": 3,
995
+ "n": 3,
996
+ "true_count": 0,
997
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
998
+ },
999
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1000
+ "all_true": true,
1001
+ "false_count": 0,
1002
+ "n": 3,
1003
+ "true_count": 3,
1004
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1005
+ },
1006
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1007
+ "all_true": false,
1008
+ "false_count": 3,
1009
+ "n": 3,
1010
+ "true_count": 0,
1011
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1012
+ },
1013
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1014
+ "all_true": false,
1015
+ "false_count": 3,
1016
+ "n": 3,
1017
+ "true_count": 0,
1018
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1019
+ },
1020
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1021
+ "all_true": false,
1022
+ "false_count": 3,
1023
+ "n": 3,
1024
+ "true_count": 0,
1025
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1026
+ },
1027
+ "snn_involved": {
1028
+ "all_true": false,
1029
+ "false_count": 3,
1030
+ "n": 3,
1031
+ "true_count": 0,
1032
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1033
+ }
1034
+ },
1035
+ "metrics": {
1036
+ "audit_item": {
1037
+ "max": 1.0,
1038
+ "mean": 1.0,
1039
+ "median": 1.0,
1040
+ "min": 1.0,
1041
+ "n": 3,
1042
+ "std": 0.0
1043
+ }
1044
+ },
1045
+ "run_count": 3,
1046
+ "seeds": [
1047
+ 101,
1048
+ 102,
1049
+ 103
1050
+ ]
1051
+ },
1052
+ "claim_boundary": {
1053
+ "boolean_metrics": {
1054
+ "audit_complete": {
1055
+ "all_true": false,
1056
+ "false_count": 3,
1057
+ "n": 3,
1058
+ "true_count": 0,
1059
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1060
+ },
1061
+ "audit_template_generated": {
1062
+ "all_true": true,
1063
+ "false_count": 0,
1064
+ "n": 3,
1065
+ "true_count": 3,
1066
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1067
+ },
1068
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1069
+ "all_true": false,
1070
+ "false_count": 3,
1071
+ "n": 3,
1072
+ "true_count": 0,
1073
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1074
+ },
1075
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1076
+ "all_true": true,
1077
+ "false_count": 0,
1078
+ "n": 3,
1079
+ "true_count": 3,
1080
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1081
+ },
1082
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1083
+ "all_true": false,
1084
+ "false_count": 3,
1085
+ "n": 3,
1086
+ "true_count": 0,
1087
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1088
+ },
1089
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1090
+ "all_true": false,
1091
+ "false_count": 3,
1092
+ "n": 3,
1093
+ "true_count": 0,
1094
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1095
+ },
1096
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1097
+ "all_true": false,
1098
+ "false_count": 3,
1099
+ "n": 3,
1100
+ "true_count": 0,
1101
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1102
+ },
1103
+ "snn_involved": {
1104
+ "all_true": false,
1105
+ "false_count": 3,
1106
+ "n": 3,
1107
+ "true_count": 0,
1108
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1109
+ }
1110
+ },
1111
+ "metrics": {
1112
+ "audit_item": {
1113
+ "max": 4.0,
1114
+ "mean": 4.0,
1115
+ "median": 4.0,
1116
+ "min": 4.0,
1117
+ "n": 3,
1118
+ "std": 0.0
1119
+ }
1120
+ },
1121
+ "run_count": 3,
1122
+ "seeds": [
1123
+ 101,
1124
+ 102,
1125
+ 103
1126
+ ]
1127
+ },
1128
+ "measurement_limit": {
1129
+ "boolean_metrics": {
1130
+ "audit_complete": {
1131
+ "all_true": false,
1132
+ "false_count": 3,
1133
+ "n": 3,
1134
+ "true_count": 0,
1135
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1136
+ },
1137
+ "audit_template_generated": {
1138
+ "all_true": true,
1139
+ "false_count": 0,
1140
+ "n": 3,
1141
+ "true_count": 3,
1142
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1143
+ },
1144
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1145
+ "all_true": false,
1146
+ "false_count": 3,
1147
+ "n": 3,
1148
+ "true_count": 0,
1149
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1150
+ },
1151
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1152
+ "all_true": true,
1153
+ "false_count": 0,
1154
+ "n": 3,
1155
+ "true_count": 3,
1156
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1157
+ },
1158
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1159
+ "all_true": false,
1160
+ "false_count": 3,
1161
+ "n": 3,
1162
+ "true_count": 0,
1163
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1164
+ },
1165
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1166
+ "all_true": false,
1167
+ "false_count": 3,
1168
+ "n": 3,
1169
+ "true_count": 0,
1170
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1171
+ },
1172
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1173
+ "all_true": false,
1174
+ "false_count": 3,
1175
+ "n": 3,
1176
+ "true_count": 0,
1177
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1178
+ },
1179
+ "snn_involved": {
1180
+ "all_true": false,
1181
+ "false_count": 3,
1182
+ "n": 3,
1183
+ "true_count": 0,
1184
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1185
+ }
1186
+ },
1187
+ "metrics": {
1188
+ "audit_item": {
1189
+ "max": 3.0,
1190
+ "mean": 3.0,
1191
+ "median": 3.0,
1192
+ "min": 3.0,
1193
+ "n": 3,
1194
+ "std": 0.0
1195
+ }
1196
+ },
1197
+ "run_count": 3,
1198
+ "seeds": [
1199
+ 101,
1200
+ 102,
1201
+ 103
1202
+ ]
1203
+ }
1204
+ },
1205
+ "formulas": {
1206
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
1207
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
1208
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
1209
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
1210
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
1211
+ },
1212
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
1213
+ "run_count": 12,
1214
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
1215
+ }
1216
+ ```
1217
+
1218
+ ## Observations
1219
+
1220
+ ```json
1221
+ [
1222
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
1223
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
1224
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1225
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1226
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
1227
+ ]
1228
+ ```
1229
+
1230
+ ## Interpretation
1231
+
1232
+ ```json
1233
+ {
1234
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.",
1235
+ "confidence": 0.55,
1236
+ "effect_direction": "Die Audit-Items variieren in den Bedingungen, wobei 'claim_boundary' das höchste Audit-Item (4) und 'alternative_model' das niedrigste (2) hat.",
1237
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1238
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
1239
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
1240
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
1241
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
1242
+ ],
1243
+ "observations": [
1244
+ "In allen Bedingungen wurde die Audit-Template-Generierung erfolgreich durchgeführt.",
1245
+ "Die Audit-Items sind in den Bedingungen 'alternative_model', 'assumption_explicit', 'claim_boundary', und 'measurement_limit' unterschiedlich.",
1246
+ "Die Audit-Vollständigkeit ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1247
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt.",
1248
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt."
1249
+ ],
1250
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1251
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
1252
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
1253
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.",
1254
+ "Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist."
1255
+ ],
1256
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1257
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
1258
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
1259
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
1260
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
1261
+ ],
1262
+ "requested_evidence": [
1263
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
1264
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.",
1265
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
1266
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
1267
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
1268
+ ]
1269
+ }
1270
+ ```
1271
+
1272
+ ## Methodological Critique
1273
+
1274
+ ```json
1275
+ [
1276
+ "Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.",
1277
+ "Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.",
1278
+ "Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.",
1279
+ "Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist."
1280
+ ]
1281
+ ```
1282
+
1283
+ ## Alternative Explanations
1284
+
1285
+ ```json
1286
+ [
1287
+ "Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.",
1288
+ "Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.",
1289
+ "Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.",
1290
+ "Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist."
1291
+ ]
1292
+ ```
1293
+
1294
+ ## Reproducibility
1295
+
1296
+ ```json
1297
+ {
1298
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1299
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1300
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1301
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1302
+ "source_freeze_sha": "bac4e3d81dea549c50264184cc2b3cefc0f0db6bf104c8909c884a619f688f70",
1303
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1304
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1305
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "680ed5795a8d4f096fc69c7cf27edd362c86883403b57b23957f259f38055782",
1306
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1307
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1308
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1309
+ "protocol_digest": "d2b61756b743ef465b263af7feef20b0937c6477a6e55f433beaaf5550fb7e2f",
1310
+ "data_digest": "d979c3e34946bad511a9101c15c4a83b5025298ce63c8477af948f55029dd3c2",
1311
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1312
+ }
1313
+ ```
1314
+
1315
+ ## Epistemic Status
1316
+
1317
+ ```json
1318
+ {
1319
+ "implementation": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1320
+ "experiment_data": "PRESENT",
1321
+ "registered_evidence": "ABSENT",
1322
+ "ai_interpretation": "PRESENT",
1323
+ "human_review": "PENDING",
1324
+ "claim_support": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1325
+ "rq_status": "IN_PROGRESS",
1326
+ "semantic_alignment": "NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED",
1327
+ "semantic_note": "Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.",
1328
+ "design_adequacy": "NOT_ASSESSED",
1329
+ "design_note": "Für diese Forschungsfrage ist keine automatische Designadäquanz-Regel registriert.",
1330
+ "confidence_gate": "PASSED"
1331
+ }
1332
+ ```
1333
+
1334
+ ## Missing Evidence
1335
+
1336
+ ```json
1337
+ [
1338
+ "Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.",
1339
+ "Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.",
1340
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.",
1341
+ "Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.",
1342
+ "Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen."
1343
+ ]
1344
+ ```
1345
+
1346
+ ## Recommended Follow-up Experiments
1347
+
1348
+ ```json
1349
+ [
1350
+ "Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.",
1351
+ "Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.",
1352
+ "Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.",
1353
+ "Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen."
1354
+ ]
1355
+ ```
1356
+
1357
+ ## Conclusion
1358
+
1359
+ ```json
1360
+ "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente."
1361
+ ```
1362
+
1363
+ ## Human Review
1364
+
1365
+ ```json
1366
+ {
1367
+ "status": "PENDING",
1368
+ "reviewer": null,
1369
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1370
+ "disposition": null,
1371
+ "comments": null
1372
+ }
1373
+ ```
1374
+
1375
+ AI confidence: 0.55
1376
+ This value describes internal AI confidence and is not a statistical confidence interval.
1377
+
1378
+ Content digest: 1e1b4ad024a2d2770372c47063b1d356297085dbae12a29ecd4fa6fe98051c44
1379
+ JSON/Markdown link digest: ede8b69d23c2d373843c556745b86e3ef59d0d8a4389dfe69ccc120974998625
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.review.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "report_id": "AIRR-2026-0001",
3
+ "review_status": "accepted_as_interpretation",
4
+ "reviewer": "Thomas Heisig",
5
+ "reviewed_at": "2026-10-02T18:17:23.152638+00:00",
6
+ "comments": "# Review mit vollständigen Daten: EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01\n\nMit den jetzt vorliegenden Dateien (`summary.md`, `statistics.json`, `runs_index.json`, `manifest.json`) lässt sich das Experiment **vollständig bewerten**. Ich gliedere in: bestätigte Befunde, neue Befunde, Widersprüche und Empfehlungen.\n\n## ✅ Was jetzt bestätigt ist\n\n### Provenienz-Kette ist vollständig\n\n| Ebene | Hash | Status |\n|---|---|---|\n| Source Freeze | `bac4e3d8…` | ✅ |\n| Runner Bytecode | `93e483e2…` (source = runtime) | ✅ MATCH |\n| Summary Bytecode | `462bf872…` (source = runtime) | ✅ MATCH |\n| Code-Digest | `5a11ea28…` | ✅ |\n| Config-Digest | `6f6cd457…` | ✅ |\n| Data-Digest | `3cf94d48…` | ✅ |\n| Prompt-Digest | `dd18e473…` | ✅ |\n\nDie **Source/Runtime-Konsistenz** (`MATCH` für beide Bytecode-Hashes) ist die stärkste Reproduzierbarkeitsaussage im gesamten Datensatz. Sie ist stärker als ein Commit-Hash, weil sie den tatsächlich ausgeführten Bytecode bindet.\n\n### Rohdaten-Index ist integer\n\n12 Runs, 4 Bedingungen × 3 Seeds, jeder mit eigenem SHA-256. Die Dateigrößen (510–522 Bytes compressed, 822–827 Bytes uncompressed) sind plausibel für konzeptuelle Audit-Items ohne SNN-Ausführung.\n\n### Epistemische Trennung ist konsistent\n\n`manifest.json`, `statistics.json` und `summary.md` verwenden **dieselben** epistemic_layers-Definitionen. Keine Divergenz zwischen den Artefakten.\n\n## 🔴 Neue Befunde aus den vollständigen Daten\n\n### Befund 1: `audit_complete=false` bei `experiment_status=completed`\n\n**Das ist der wichtigste neue Befund.**\n\n| Feld | Wert |\n|---|---|\n| `experiment_status` | `completed` |\n| `audit_complete` (alle 4 Bedingungen) | `false` (0/3 true) |\n\n**Interpretation**: Der **technische** Lauf ist abgeschlossen. Der **inhaltliche** Audit ist es nicht. Das ist kein Widerspruch im engeren Sinne – aber es ist ein **semantischer Graben**, der in der Summary nicht ausreichend erklärt wird.\n\n**Konsequenz**: Ein Reviewer könnte `experiment_status: completed` lesen und annehmen, der Audit sei abgeschlossen. Die `audit_complete=false`-Werte sagen das Gegenteil. Das sollte in der Summary **explizit** erklärt werden.\n\n**Empfehlung**: Ein Feld `experiment_status_semantics: \"technical_completion_only\"` oder ähnlich, das den Unterschied klarstellt.\n\n### Befund 2: `audit_item`-Werte sind konzeptuell, nicht metrisch\n\n| Bedingung | `audit_item` mean | std |\n|---|---|---|\n| alternative_model | 2.0 | 0.0 |\n| assumption_explicit | 1.0 | 0.0 |\n| claim_boundary | 4.0 | 0.0 |\n| measurement_limit | 3.0 | 0.0 |\n\n**Die Werte sind über alle Seeds konstant** (std=0). Das bedeutet: Es handelt sich um **kategorische Zuordnungen**, nicht um Messwerte. Die Zahl 2 für `alternative_model` ist ein Index, keine Größe.\n\n**Das Problem**: In der Tabelle in Sektion 5.1 der Summary erscheinen diese Werte als „zusätzliche numerische Mittelwerte\". Das suggeriert metrische Größen. Tatsächlich sind es **Audit-Item-Identifikatoren**.\n\n**Empfehlung**: Umbenennen in `audit_item_id` und als kategorisch kennzeichnen. Keine `mean`/`std`-Statistik für kategorische Werte.\n\n### Befund 3: Schema-Version-Mismatch\n\n| Datei | Schema-Version |\n|---|---|\n| `statistics.json` | `2.2` |\n| `runs_index.json` | `2.0` |\n| `manifest.json` | (keine explizite Version) |\n\n**Drei verschiedene Versionen im selben Experiment.** Das ist nicht falsch – aber es ist ein **Nachvollziehbarkeitsproblem**. Wenn ein Reviewer die Statistik mit dem Index vergleicht, muss klar sein, welche Felder in welcher Version erwartet werden.\n\n**Empfehlung**: Entweder vereinheitlichen oder in der Summary dokumentieren, warum die Versionen divergieren.\n\n### Befund 4: Kein Master-Hash über alle Runs\n\nJeder Run hat einen eigenen SHA-256. Aber es gibt **keinen Hash über den gesamten `runs_index.json`**. Das bedeutet: Der Index selbst ist nicht gegen nachträgliche Manipulation geschützt.\n\n**Empfehlung**: Ein `runs_index_sha256` im Manifest, der den Index als Ganzes bindet. Das ist analog zum `data_digest`, der bereits existiert.\n\n### Befund 5: Formeln definiert, aber nicht verwendet\n\n`statistics.json` definiert:\n\n- `difference`\n- `ratio`\n- `inter_spike_interval`\n\nAber keine dieser Formeln wird auf die vorhandenen Daten angewendet. Die `audit_item`-Werte sind konstant, es gibt keine zwei Bedingungen mit variablen Mittelwerten, und es gibt keine Spikes.\n\n**Interpretation**: Das ist ein **Formel-Template**, kein Berechnungsnachweis. Das ist okay – aber es sollte klar sein, dass die Formeln **nicht angewendet** wurden.\n\n**Empfehlung**: In der Summary explizit sagen: „Die Formeln sind definiert, aber für dieses konzeptuelle Audit nicht angewendet, da keine metrischen Größen mit Varianz vorliegen.\"\n\n## ⚠️ Bestätigte Widersprüche\n\n### Widerspruch 1: `dirty: true` + `ai_reproducibility: R0`\n\nBereits im ersten Review angemerkt. Mit den vollständigen Daten bleibt es bestehen:\n\n- `R0` bedeutet laut Definition: **vollständig reproduzierbar**.\n- `dirty: true` bedeutet: **Working Tree war nicht sauber**.\n- Der `source_freeze_sha` und die Bytecode-Hashes beziehen sich auf **Dateien**, nicht auf den Git-Zustand.\n\n**Das ist ein echter Widerspruch.** Entweder ist R0 falsch klassifiziert, oder `dirty: true` ist irreführend.\n\n**Konsequenz**: Die Provenienz-Aussage ist **eingeschränkt**. Ein Reviewer kann nicht sicher sein, dass die Ausführung mit dem Commit-Zustand übereinstimmt.\n\n### Widerspruch 2: `tick_validation.requested_ticks=1` + `status=NOT_APPLICABLE`\n\nBereits im ersten Review angemerkt. Die Summary erklärt es nun besser:\n\n> „Trial-/Regulationsprotokolle: Interne Versuchszyklen sind nicht mit `ticks_executed` gleichzusetzen und werden nicht in die SNN-Tickspanne eingerechnet.\"\n\nDas ist eine **gute Klarstellung**. Aber die Struktur `requested_ticks: 1` + `status: NOT_APPLICABLE` bleibt widersprüchlich. Besser wäre:\n\n```json\n\"tick_validation\": {\n \"mode\": \"protocol_defined_internal_trials\",\n \"snn_ticks\": null,\n \"status\": \"NOT_APPLICABLE\"\n}\n```\n\n## 🟡 Was die Summary gut macht\n\n### Die `—`-Erklärung\n\n> „`—` bedeutet in dieser Tabelle ausschließlich, dass die jeweilige SNN-Metrik für diese Bedingung nicht definiert oder nicht erhoben wird. Es bedeutet **nicht**, dass für die Bedingung keine DATA vorliegen.\"\n\nDas ist **vorbildlich**. Es verhindert den häufigsten Review-Fehler: „Keine Daten\" mit „nicht definiert\" zu verwechseln.\n\n### Die RQ/Condition-Prüfung\n\n> „`MISMATCH` blockiert die Nutzung als Evidenz für die registrierte Forschungsfrage, auch wenn die technische Ausführung fehlerfrei war.\"\n\nDas ist die **wichtigste methodische Aussage** im gesamten Datensatz. Sie trennt technische Korrektheit von wissenschaftlicher Gültigkeit.\n\n### Die AIRR-Methodische-Kritik\n\nDie Liste in Sektion 8.2 ist **ehrlich** und **präzise**. Sie benennt, was fehlt:\n\n- Keine inferentiellen Analysen\n- `audit_complete=false` in allen Bedingungen\n- Keine `scientific_evidence`\n- Keine SNN-Beteiligung\n\nDas ist die richtige Selbstkritik – aber sie ist im **KI-generierten** Teil, nicht im deterministischen Teil. Sie sollte auch in der deterministischen Zusammenfassung stehen.\n\n## 📋 Empfehlungen nach Priorität\n\n### Priorität 1 – Provenienz reparieren\n\n1. **`dirty: true` auflösen**: Entweder Working Tree committen oder in der Summary erklären, welche Dateien geändert waren.\n2. **`ai_reproducibility` anpassen**: Wenn `dirty: true` bleibt → `R1` oder `R2`.\n3. **`runs_index_sha256` hinzufügen**: Master-Hash über den Index.\n\n### Priorität 2 – Semantik korrigieren\n\n1. **`experiment_status` präzisieren**: `completed_technical_only` oder ähnlich.\n2. **`audit_item` umbenennen**: Als kategorische ID kennzeichnen.\n3. **Formeln als „nicht angewendet\" markieren**.\n4. **Schema-Versionen vereinheitlichen** oder dokumentieren.\n\n### Priorität 3 – Summary verbessern\n\n1. **`audit_complete=false` erklären**: Warum ist der Audit technisch fertig, aber inhaltlich nicht?\n2. **`dirty: true` in Sektion 3 problematisieren**.\n3. **AIRR-Kritik auch in deterministische Zusammenfassung** übernehmen.\n\n### Priorität 4 – Frontend\n\n1. **Leere Felder prüfen**: Die UI zeigt „—\" für Protokoll, Seeds, Ticks, Bedingungen, obwohl das Manifest Werte enthält.\n2. **Manifest-Pfade prüfen**: Der Renderer liest möglicherweise aus falschen Pfaden.\n\n## 💎 Fazit\n\nMit den vollständigen Daten ist die Bewertung **präziser** – aber auch **strenger**:\n\n**Was das Experiment ist**:\n- Ein **technisch sauberer, deterministischer Batch-Lauf** mit 12 konzeptuellen Audits.\n- Eine **methodisch disziplinierte** Erfassung ohne EVID-Promotion.\n- Eine **reproduzierbare** Ausführung mit Source/Runtime-Match.\n\n**Was das Experiment nicht ist**:\n- Kein empirischer SNN-Lauf (`snn_involved: false`).\n- Kein Test der Hypothese (`direct_test_of_hypothesis: false`).\n- Kein abgeschlossener Audit (`audit_complete: false`).\n- Keine wissenschaftliche Evidenz (`scientific_evidence: false`).\n\n**Der wichtigste neue Befund**: Der Widerspruch zwischen `experiment_status: completed` und `audit_complete: false` ist **kein Fehler**, aber er muss **explizit erklärt** werden. Sonst liest ein Reviewer „completed\" und nimmt an, der Audit sei fertig.\n\n**Der wichtigste bestätigte Befund**: `dirty: true` + `R0` bleibt ein **echter Provenienz-Widerspruch**, der vor jeder weiteren Verwendung behoben werden muss.\n\n**Ein Satz zum Mitnehmen**: Das Experiment ist ein **sauberer methodischer Template-Lauf**, der genau das tut, was er soll – nicht mehr, nicht weniger. Die verbleibenden Probleme sind **dokumentarisch**, nicht strukturell. Nach ihrer Behebung ist der Datensatz ein **belastbarer Baustein** für die Batch-Audit-Pipeline.",
7
+ "report_content_digest": "1e1b4ad024a2d2770372c47063b1d356297085dbae12a29ecd4fa6fe98051c44"
8
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/summary.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,209 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01: Wissenschaftliche Zusammenfassung
2
+
3
+ Diese Zusammenfassung wird deterministisch aus Manifest, Workflow, DATA und — sofern vorhanden — dem AIRR aufgebaut. Zahlen und Formeln stammen aus den gespeicherten Laufdaten beziehungsweise dem deterministischen Statistics Engine; KI-Text bleibt davon getrennt.
4
+
5
+ ## 1. Identifikation und Status
6
+
7
+ - Experimentstatus: `completed`
8
+ - Forschungsfrage: `RQ-CNS-101`
9
+ - Hypothese: `H-CNS-101-A`
10
+ - Protokoll: `cog_cns_101_v1`
11
+ - Durchlaeufe: `12`
12
+ - Seeds: `[101, 102, 103]`
13
+ - Angeforderte Ticks: `1`
14
+ - Tickgebundene SNN-Läufe (PING/TEMP/5D): `nicht direkt messbar .. nicht direkt messbar` ausgeführte Ticks
15
+ - Tick-Vertrag: `NOT_APPLICABLE`
16
+ - TIME-Ladder: Der angeforderte Endpunkt wird je Seed separat validiert; Zwischenstufen duerfen kleiner sein.
17
+ - Trial-/Regulationsprotokolle: Interne Versuchszyklen sind nicht mit `ticks_executed` gleichzusetzen und werden nicht in die SNN-Tickspanne eingerechnet.
18
+ - Laufmodus: `EXPLORATORY`
19
+ - Netzwerkmodus: `OFFLINE`
20
+
21
+ ## 2. Semantische Konsistenz
22
+
23
+ - RQ/Condition-Pruefung: `NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED`
24
+ - Evidence Readiness: `BLOCKED_UNCLASSIFIED_SEMANTICS`
25
+ - Begründung: Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.
26
+ - Beobachtete Conditions: `alternative_model, assumption_explicit, claim_boundary, measurement_limit`
27
+
28
+ `DIRECT_MATCH` bezeichnet einen gezielten RQ-spezifischen Lauf. `CONTAINS_MATCH` bedeutet, dass die passende Teilstudie innerhalb einer Gesamtsuite enthalten ist; nur diese Teilstudie ist primaer fuer die registrierte RQ auszuwerten. `MISMATCH` blockiert die Nutzung als Evidenz fuer die registrierte Forschungsfrage, auch wenn die technische Ausfuehrung fehlerfrei war.
29
+
30
+ ## 3. Ausfuehrungsparameter
31
+
32
+ - Titel: Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_101_v1
33
+ - Bedingungen: frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract
34
+ - Notizen: Conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.
35
+ - Konfiguration: `F:\Brain-5D\configs\learning_experiment.yaml`
36
+ - Config SHA-256: `6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c`
37
+ - Git Commit: `1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3`
38
+ - Git dirty: `True`
39
+ - Runtime: `0.015006800065748394` s
40
+
41
+ ## 4. Deterministische Formeln
42
+
43
+ Die im Bericht verwendeten deskriptiven Groessen sind:
44
+
45
+ - Mittelwert: `mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i`
46
+ - Populationsstandardabweichung: `sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)`
47
+ - Absolute Differenz: `Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)`
48
+ - Verhältnis: `R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A)` fuer `mean(x_A) != 0`
49
+ - Inter-Spike-Intervall: `ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i`
50
+
51
+ Diese Formeln sind deskriptiv. Ohne registrierten Inferenztest, unabhaengige Stichprobenannahme und passende Versuchsplanung werden daraus keine Signifikanz- oder Kausalbehauptungen abgeleitet.
52
+
53
+ ## 5. Ergebnisse nach Bedingung
54
+
55
+ | Condition | n | Seeds | Ticks mean | Spikes mean | Syn. events mean | Aktivierte Neuronen mean | Recurrent events mean | Propagation depth mean |
56
+ | --- | ---: | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
57
+ | alternative_model | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
58
+ | assumption_explicit | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
59
+ | claim_boundary | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
60
+ | measurement_limit | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
61
+
62
+ **Wichtig:** `—` bedeutet in dieser Tabelle ausschließlich, dass die jeweilige SNN-Metrik für diese Bedingung nicht definiert oder nicht erhoben wird. Es bedeutet **nicht**, dass für die Bedingung keine DATA vorliegen. Protokollspezifische Messwerte werden direkt darunter ausgewiesen.
63
+
64
+ ### 5.1 Protokollspezifische Metrikabdeckung
65
+
66
+ | Condition | zusätzliche numerische Mittelwerte |
67
+ | --- | --- |
68
+ | alternative_model | `audit_item=2` |
69
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_item=1` |
70
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_item=4` |
71
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_item=3` |
72
+
73
+ #### Primäre und weitere boolesche Endpunkte
74
+
75
+ | Condition | Outcome | n | true | false | all_true |
76
+ | --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |
77
+ | alternative_model | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
78
+ | alternative_model | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
79
+ | alternative_model | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
80
+ | alternative_model | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
81
+ | alternative_model | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
82
+ | alternative_model | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
83
+ | alternative_model | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
84
+ | alternative_model | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
85
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
86
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
87
+ | assumption_explicit | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
88
+ | assumption_explicit | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
89
+ | assumption_explicit | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
90
+ | assumption_explicit | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
91
+ | assumption_explicit | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
92
+ | assumption_explicit | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
93
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
94
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
95
+ | claim_boundary | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
96
+ | claim_boundary | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
97
+ | claim_boundary | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
98
+ | claim_boundary | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
99
+ | claim_boundary | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
100
+ | claim_boundary | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
101
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
102
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
103
+ | measurement_limit | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
104
+ | measurement_limit | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
105
+ | measurement_limit | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
106
+ | measurement_limit | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
107
+ | measurement_limit | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
108
+ | measurement_limit | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
109
+
110
+ ## 6. Einzelne Läufe
111
+
112
+ | Seed | Condition | Ticks | Spikes | Syn. events | Aktivierte Neuronen | Recurrent events | Depth | Runtime error |
113
+ | ---: | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |
114
+ | 101 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
115
+ | 101 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
116
+ | 101 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
117
+ | 101 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
118
+ | 102 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
119
+ | 102 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
120
+ | 102 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
121
+ | 102 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
122
+ | 103 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
123
+ | 103 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
124
+ | 103 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
125
+ | 103 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
126
+
127
+ ## 7. Reproduzierbarkeit und Provenienz
128
+
129
+ Identische Ausgaben ueber mehrere Seeds dokumentieren reproduzierbare Modelltrajektorien unter diesen Bedingungen. Sie sind nicht automatisch statistisch unabhaengige Replikate. State-Digests sind Integritaets-/Identitaetsmarker und keine metrischen Zustandsabstaende.
130
+
131
+ Deterministische Statistikdatei: `analysis/statistics.json`
132
+
133
+ ## 8. AI Research Report
134
+
135
+ - AIRR Status: `generated`
136
+ - Wissenschaftliche Evidenz durch KI: `false`
137
+ - Human Review: `PENDING`
138
+ - AIRR Markdown: `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md`
139
+ - AIRR JSON: `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json`
140
+
141
+ ### 8.1 KI-Einschaetzung
142
+
143
+ Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Die Ergebnisse sind beschreibend und basieren auf der Analyse der Metriken der Experimente.
144
+
145
+ KI-Konfidenz: `0.55` — dies ist keine statistische Konfidenz.
146
+
147
+ ### Methodische Kritik
148
+
149
+ - Keine inferential Analysen wurden durchgeführt, daher können keine statistischen Signifikanztests durchgeführt werden.
150
+ - Die 'audit_complete' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf eine unvollständige Audit-Überprüfung hinweist.
151
+ - Die 'scientific_evidence' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweist.
152
+ - Die 'snn_involved' ist in allen Bedingungen auf 'false' festgelegt, was auf fehlende Beteiligung von SNN hinweist.
153
+
154
+ ### Alternative Erklaerungen
155
+
156
+ - Die Audit-Items können aufgrund der verwendeten Experimente und Bedingungen unterschiedlich sein, ohne dass dies auf eine signifikante Effektrichtung hindeutet.
157
+ - Die fehlende 'scientific_evidence' könnte auf eine unzureichende Methodik oder fehlende Daten hinweisen, die eine wissenschaftliche Validierung erschweren.
158
+ - Die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN könnte auf eine technische oder methodische Entscheidung beruhen, die die Experimente nicht zu einer SNN-Beteiligung führen.
159
+ - Die fehlende 'audit_complete' könnte auf eine unvollständige oder fehlende Audit-Überprüfung hinweisen, die auf technische oder methodische Probleme zurückzuführen ist.
160
+
161
+ ### Fehlende Nachweise
162
+
163
+ - Dokumentation der Methodik zur Audit-Überprüfung.
164
+ - Daten zur wissenschaftlichen Evidenz, die die Ergebnisse der Experimente unterstützen.
165
+ - Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten.
166
+ - Dokumentation der inferential Analysen, falls durchgeführt.
167
+ - Dokumentation der Gründe für die fehlende 'audit_complete' in allen Bedingungen.
168
+
169
+ ### Empfohlene Folgeexperimente
170
+
171
+ - Eine inferential Analyse durchzuführen, um statistische Signifikanz zu testen.
172
+ - Die Durchführung von Experimenten zur Validierung der wissenschaftlichen Evidenz.
173
+ - Die Untersuchung der Beteiligung von SNN in den Experimenten, um mögliche technische oder methodische Gründe zu identifizieren.
174
+ - Die Erweiterung der Experimente, um eine umfassendere Analyse der Audit-Items und ihrer Effekte zu ermöglichen.
175
+
176
+ ## 9. Artefakte
177
+
178
+ - `analysis/ai_packet.json`
179
+ - `analysis/ai_packet_digest.json`
180
+ - `analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001211610885260-c2fce764.json`
181
+ - `analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211542537168-c2fce764.json`
182
+ - `analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001211731555494-c2fce764.json`
183
+ - `analysis/statistics.json`
184
+ - `DATA/current_run.json`
185
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz`
186
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz`
187
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz`
188
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz`
189
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz`
190
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz`
191
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz`
192
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz`
193
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz`
194
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz`
195
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz`
196
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz`
197
+ - `DATA/runs_compact.json`
198
+ - `DATA/runs_index.json`
199
+ - `manifest.json`
200
+ - `report.md`
201
+ - `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json`
202
+ - `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md`
203
+ - `workflow.json`
204
+
205
+ ## 10. Wissenschaftliche Grenze und Schlussfolgerung
206
+
207
+ Die technischen Laufdaten duerfen deskriptiv ausgewertet werden. Eine Hypothese gilt dadurch nicht automatisch als bestaetigt oder widerlegt. Kausale Aussagen sind nur fuer explizit kontrollierte Interventionen und nur innerhalb des simulierten Systems zulaessig; biologische Generalisierung erfordert zusaetzliche Evidenz. Die KI-Auswertung ist post-hoc und besitzt keine Evidenzfreigabe.
208
+
209
+ **Gesamtstatus:** technische Ausfuehrung `completed`, Tick-Vertrag `NOT_APPLICABLE`, semantische Zuordnung `NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED`, wissenschaftliche Evidenz `false` bis zur menschlichen Review/Freigabe.
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01/workflow.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-PILOT2-01",
3
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-101",
4
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-101-A",
5
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_101_v1",
6
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
7
+ "ticks": 1,
8
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
9
+ "seeds": [
10
+ 101,
11
+ 102,
12
+ 103
13
+ ],
14
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_101_v1",
15
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_101_v1",
16
+ "tick_validation": {
17
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
18
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
19
+ "requested_ticks": 1
20
+ },
21
+ "notes": "Conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
22
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
23
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
24
+ "epistemic_layers": {
25
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
26
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
27
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
28
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
29
+ }
30
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/DATA/current_run.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "last_archived_run": 11,
3
+ "raw_artifact": {
4
+ "format": "json.gz",
5
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
6
+ "sha256": "e4eac416196b284b27e4021552a1fdc7d8beaa39ef0506fa3cfee5bdbbcd8528",
7
+ "size_bytes": 517,
8
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
9
+ },
10
+ "status": "idle"
11
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/DATA/runs_compact.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,374 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ [
2
+ {
3
+ "_raw_artifact": {
4
+ "format": "json.gz",
5
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
6
+ "sha256": "e3ea9976e7f92e43dfa62a2f1b9fba6103b00fafb4ac1cfa10dc630ef4548eb6",
7
+ "size_bytes": 525,
8
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
9
+ },
10
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
11
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
12
+ "metrics": {
13
+ "audit_complete": false,
14
+ "audit_item": 1,
15
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
16
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
17
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
18
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
19
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
20
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
21
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
22
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
23
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
24
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
25
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
26
+ "snn_involved": false
27
+ },
28
+ "runtime_error": null,
29
+ "seed": 101,
30
+ "state_digest_after": "d2136eb9d41dc6933f0e68bc859c10b0d061727c4597960a1d806cd1ebd1097a",
31
+ "state_digest_before": "d2136eb9d41dc6933f0e68bc859c10b0d061727c4597960a1d806cd1ebd1097a"
32
+ },
33
+ {
34
+ "_raw_artifact": {
35
+ "format": "json.gz",
36
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
37
+ "sha256": "0f2864c924fa05597263a4a0968777b4be0ca339e4d90affb3bcac4f1dd85bb3",
38
+ "size_bytes": 520,
39
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
40
+ },
41
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
42
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
43
+ "metrics": {
44
+ "audit_complete": false,
45
+ "audit_item": 2,
46
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
47
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
48
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
49
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
50
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
51
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
52
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
53
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
54
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
55
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
56
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
57
+ "snn_involved": false
58
+ },
59
+ "runtime_error": null,
60
+ "seed": 101,
61
+ "state_digest_after": "ce5f6c01b34e47bccb5d538d38308abea4c5c2bc8e85755957deb60cb9a753dc",
62
+ "state_digest_before": "ce5f6c01b34e47bccb5d538d38308abea4c5c2bc8e85755957deb60cb9a753dc"
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "_raw_artifact": {
66
+ "format": "json.gz",
67
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
68
+ "sha256": "5f4b2d2bb8711b0a5786bcd4d091410e2af881240800ed097a66f349787bde24",
69
+ "size_bytes": 521,
70
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
71
+ },
72
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
73
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
74
+ "metrics": {
75
+ "audit_complete": false,
76
+ "audit_item": 3,
77
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
78
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
79
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
80
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
81
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
82
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
83
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
84
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
85
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
86
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
87
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
88
+ "snn_involved": false
89
+ },
90
+ "runtime_error": null,
91
+ "seed": 101,
92
+ "state_digest_after": "4eb7f144bdff159f345cf2b392d1a86e8b63a0c058c99575433b2ae3740b15ff",
93
+ "state_digest_before": "4eb7f144bdff159f345cf2b392d1a86e8b63a0c058c99575433b2ae3740b15ff"
94
+ },
95
+ {
96
+ "_raw_artifact": {
97
+ "format": "json.gz",
98
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
99
+ "sha256": "21c1c077bf4a3c40716c5540fac00661485d06c74dcfe763e6873a1e7b1b290b",
100
+ "size_bytes": 516,
101
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
102
+ },
103
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
104
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
105
+ "metrics": {
106
+ "audit_complete": false,
107
+ "audit_item": 4,
108
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
109
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
110
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
111
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
112
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
113
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
114
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
115
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
116
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
117
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
118
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
119
+ "snn_involved": false
120
+ },
121
+ "runtime_error": null,
122
+ "seed": 101,
123
+ "state_digest_after": "78568f7e75302ec995179886ad264f791e4f75560903d15eb0bc9d8bc6eaac5c",
124
+ "state_digest_before": "78568f7e75302ec995179886ad264f791e4f75560903d15eb0bc9d8bc6eaac5c"
125
+ },
126
+ {
127
+ "_raw_artifact": {
128
+ "format": "json.gz",
129
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
130
+ "sha256": "c140628197f03ae0b89184bc34e8908aa6d20c40bcc4f258642d75defcf6d4be",
131
+ "size_bytes": 526,
132
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
133
+ },
134
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
135
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
136
+ "metrics": {
137
+ "audit_complete": false,
138
+ "audit_item": 1,
139
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
140
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
141
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
142
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
143
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
144
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
145
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
146
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
147
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
148
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
149
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
150
+ "snn_involved": false
151
+ },
152
+ "runtime_error": null,
153
+ "seed": 102,
154
+ "state_digest_after": "2635c6c28488b1d14fe3f464f4b290d18d92759d405dbabd6bc118c1c27a79f9",
155
+ "state_digest_before": "2635c6c28488b1d14fe3f464f4b290d18d92759d405dbabd6bc118c1c27a79f9"
156
+ },
157
+ {
158
+ "_raw_artifact": {
159
+ "format": "json.gz",
160
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
161
+ "sha256": "dbb160ea2d0a9ae4e30c71fae50f9331e4174208a33fe68896414f9df0c367bf",
162
+ "size_bytes": 519,
163
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
164
+ },
165
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
166
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
167
+ "metrics": {
168
+ "audit_complete": false,
169
+ "audit_item": 2,
170
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
171
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
172
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
173
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
174
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
175
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
176
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
177
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
178
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
179
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
180
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
181
+ "snn_involved": false
182
+ },
183
+ "runtime_error": null,
184
+ "seed": 102,
185
+ "state_digest_after": "b65b86b4cd2ec15f46323312da009a23e3dedad36f41b9e3f2601a337dce16b6",
186
+ "state_digest_before": "b65b86b4cd2ec15f46323312da009a23e3dedad36f41b9e3f2601a337dce16b6"
187
+ },
188
+ {
189
+ "_raw_artifact": {
190
+ "format": "json.gz",
191
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
192
+ "sha256": "9e5eff0047f83bc920a5b05de3605559a9e7a7fa0a701fdb2e622d900f8d50ed",
193
+ "size_bytes": 518,
194
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
195
+ },
196
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
197
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
198
+ "metrics": {
199
+ "audit_complete": false,
200
+ "audit_item": 3,
201
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
202
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
203
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
204
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
205
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
206
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
207
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
208
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
209
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
210
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
211
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
212
+ "snn_involved": false
213
+ },
214
+ "runtime_error": null,
215
+ "seed": 102,
216
+ "state_digest_after": "add2f4243f2d9d47273be2992eef7988826fd77a2c774e2d684ba9aefd7593c6",
217
+ "state_digest_before": "add2f4243f2d9d47273be2992eef7988826fd77a2c774e2d684ba9aefd7593c6"
218
+ },
219
+ {
220
+ "_raw_artifact": {
221
+ "format": "json.gz",
222
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
223
+ "sha256": "043bec17fef0bc7f54c1bfa9f1d7e619922d96de49f6eb9048378882da017306",
224
+ "size_bytes": 516,
225
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
226
+ },
227
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
228
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
229
+ "metrics": {
230
+ "audit_complete": false,
231
+ "audit_item": 4,
232
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
233
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
234
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
235
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
236
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
237
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
238
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
239
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
240
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
241
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
242
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
243
+ "snn_involved": false
244
+ },
245
+ "runtime_error": null,
246
+ "seed": 102,
247
+ "state_digest_after": "01a981dc454af1f27e290ab3930d3ddf2b03ab266e6f78bab297701e96302115",
248
+ "state_digest_before": "01a981dc454af1f27e290ab3930d3ddf2b03ab266e6f78bab297701e96302115"
249
+ },
250
+ {
251
+ "_raw_artifact": {
252
+ "format": "json.gz",
253
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
254
+ "sha256": "80cdd5e57fe15c6e04a6a3eca357a79293018b7a672a0f995aab561fd66c34d8",
255
+ "size_bytes": 522,
256
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
257
+ },
258
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
259
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
260
+ "metrics": {
261
+ "audit_complete": false,
262
+ "audit_item": 1,
263
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
264
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
265
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
266
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
267
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
268
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
269
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
270
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
271
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
272
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
273
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
274
+ "snn_involved": false
275
+ },
276
+ "runtime_error": null,
277
+ "seed": 103,
278
+ "state_digest_after": "fec7dd7203c1493abe3caa367e12c82f07270005f5b7eb5dedc9ac0dd98da0a0",
279
+ "state_digest_before": "fec7dd7203c1493abe3caa367e12c82f07270005f5b7eb5dedc9ac0dd98da0a0"
280
+ },
281
+ {
282
+ "_raw_artifact": {
283
+ "format": "json.gz",
284
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
285
+ "sha256": "f34f90d47b6a16ab5d40ac84bd4158d99f9c66c631b8c4788f628e682ff255b5",
286
+ "size_bytes": 519,
287
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
288
+ },
289
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
290
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
291
+ "metrics": {
292
+ "audit_complete": false,
293
+ "audit_item": 2,
294
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
295
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
296
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
297
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
298
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
299
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
300
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
301
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
302
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
303
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
304
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
305
+ "snn_involved": false
306
+ },
307
+ "runtime_error": null,
308
+ "seed": 103,
309
+ "state_digest_after": "8f3faa7cd1e91c466bfeb11287134b11ec58baac9a3079a8f587c13da3f89daf",
310
+ "state_digest_before": "8f3faa7cd1e91c466bfeb11287134b11ec58baac9a3079a8f587c13da3f89daf"
311
+ },
312
+ {
313
+ "_raw_artifact": {
314
+ "format": "json.gz",
315
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
316
+ "sha256": "4d858a66f5c9e43823d8378976dc513f2440084c247fab6d0a4377eef25d3acb",
317
+ "size_bytes": 521,
318
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
319
+ },
320
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
321
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
322
+ "metrics": {
323
+ "audit_complete": false,
324
+ "audit_item": 3,
325
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
326
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
327
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
328
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
329
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
330
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
331
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
332
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
333
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
334
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
335
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
336
+ "snn_involved": false
337
+ },
338
+ "runtime_error": null,
339
+ "seed": 103,
340
+ "state_digest_after": "00effee9120946761251c3b2a2992cb7ce1d03e71876f91b5d6797af45802c06",
341
+ "state_digest_before": "00effee9120946761251c3b2a2992cb7ce1d03e71876f91b5d6797af45802c06"
342
+ },
343
+ {
344
+ "_raw_artifact": {
345
+ "format": "json.gz",
346
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
347
+ "sha256": "e4eac416196b284b27e4021552a1fdc7d8beaa39ef0506fa3cfee5bdbbcd8528",
348
+ "size_bytes": 517,
349
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
350
+ },
351
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
352
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
353
+ "metrics": {
354
+ "audit_complete": false,
355
+ "audit_item": 4,
356
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
357
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
358
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
359
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
360
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
361
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
362
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
363
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
364
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
365
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
366
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
367
+ "snn_involved": false
368
+ },
369
+ "runtime_error": null,
370
+ "seed": 103,
371
+ "state_digest_after": "2cb5e4e59c4eacbf19423fdab829b34cf76713b59879b55bb25fc81f8a97578b",
372
+ "state_digest_before": "2cb5e4e59c4eacbf19423fdab829b34cf76713b59879b55bb25fc81f8a97578b"
373
+ }
374
+ ]
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/DATA/runs_index.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,127 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "run_count": 12,
3
+ "runs": [
4
+ {
5
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
6
+ "format": "json.gz",
7
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
8
+ "run_index": 0,
9
+ "seed": 101,
10
+ "sha256": "e3ea9976e7f92e43dfa62a2f1b9fba6103b00fafb4ac1cfa10dc630ef4548eb6",
11
+ "size_bytes": 525,
12
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
13
+ },
14
+ {
15
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
16
+ "format": "json.gz",
17
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
18
+ "run_index": 1,
19
+ "seed": 101,
20
+ "sha256": "0f2864c924fa05597263a4a0968777b4be0ca339e4d90affb3bcac4f1dd85bb3",
21
+ "size_bytes": 520,
22
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
23
+ },
24
+ {
25
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
26
+ "format": "json.gz",
27
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
28
+ "run_index": 2,
29
+ "seed": 101,
30
+ "sha256": "5f4b2d2bb8711b0a5786bcd4d091410e2af881240800ed097a66f349787bde24",
31
+ "size_bytes": 521,
32
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
33
+ },
34
+ {
35
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
36
+ "format": "json.gz",
37
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
38
+ "run_index": 3,
39
+ "seed": 101,
40
+ "sha256": "21c1c077bf4a3c40716c5540fac00661485d06c74dcfe763e6873a1e7b1b290b",
41
+ "size_bytes": 516,
42
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
43
+ },
44
+ {
45
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
46
+ "format": "json.gz",
47
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
48
+ "run_index": 4,
49
+ "seed": 102,
50
+ "sha256": "c140628197f03ae0b89184bc34e8908aa6d20c40bcc4f258642d75defcf6d4be",
51
+ "size_bytes": 526,
52
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
53
+ },
54
+ {
55
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
56
+ "format": "json.gz",
57
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
58
+ "run_index": 5,
59
+ "seed": 102,
60
+ "sha256": "dbb160ea2d0a9ae4e30c71fae50f9331e4174208a33fe68896414f9df0c367bf",
61
+ "size_bytes": 519,
62
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
66
+ "format": "json.gz",
67
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
68
+ "run_index": 6,
69
+ "seed": 102,
70
+ "sha256": "9e5eff0047f83bc920a5b05de3605559a9e7a7fa0a701fdb2e622d900f8d50ed",
71
+ "size_bytes": 518,
72
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
73
+ },
74
+ {
75
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
76
+ "format": "json.gz",
77
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
78
+ "run_index": 7,
79
+ "seed": 102,
80
+ "sha256": "043bec17fef0bc7f54c1bfa9f1d7e619922d96de49f6eb9048378882da017306",
81
+ "size_bytes": 516,
82
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
83
+ },
84
+ {
85
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
86
+ "format": "json.gz",
87
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
88
+ "run_index": 8,
89
+ "seed": 103,
90
+ "sha256": "80cdd5e57fe15c6e04a6a3eca357a79293018b7a672a0f995aab561fd66c34d8",
91
+ "size_bytes": 522,
92
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
93
+ },
94
+ {
95
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
96
+ "format": "json.gz",
97
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
98
+ "run_index": 9,
99
+ "seed": 103,
100
+ "sha256": "f34f90d47b6a16ab5d40ac84bd4158d99f9c66c631b8c4788f628e682ff255b5",
101
+ "size_bytes": 519,
102
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
103
+ },
104
+ {
105
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
106
+ "format": "json.gz",
107
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
108
+ "run_index": 10,
109
+ "seed": 103,
110
+ "sha256": "4d858a66f5c9e43823d8378976dc513f2440084c247fab6d0a4377eef25d3acb",
111
+ "size_bytes": 521,
112
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
113
+ },
114
+ {
115
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
116
+ "format": "json.gz",
117
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
118
+ "run_index": 11,
119
+ "seed": 103,
120
+ "sha256": "e4eac416196b284b27e4021552a1fdc7d8beaa39ef0506fa3cfee5bdbbcd8528",
121
+ "size_bytes": 517,
122
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
123
+ }
124
+ ],
125
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
126
+ "storage_policy": "immutable_raw_runs_plus_compact_current_experiment"
127
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212114421558-0fc176ff.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,90 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212114421558-0fc176ff",
3
+ "role": "critical_reviewer",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
17
+ "packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse. Die Ergebnisse sind rein deskriptiv und keine statistische Signifikanz wurde getestet.",
21
+ "observations": [
22
+ "Die Experimente sind konzeptionelle Audits, die keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Tests umfassen.",
23
+ "Die Metriken sind identisch in allen Bedingungen, mit Ausnahme der audit_item, die sich in den Bedingungen unterscheiden.",
24
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in den Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist."
25
+ ],
26
+ "methodological_concerns": [
27
+ "Die Experimente sind nicht reproduzierbar, da keine kontrollierten Variablen oder externe Validierung vorhanden sind.",
28
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.",
29
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.",
30
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.",
31
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.",
32
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.",
33
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.",
34
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Tests.",
35
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
36
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
37
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102."
38
+ ],
39
+ "alternative_explanations": [
40
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.",
41
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.",
42
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.",
43
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.",
44
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.",
45
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.",
46
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Teste.",
47
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
48
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
49
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102."
50
+ ],
51
+ "recommended_experiments": [
52
+ "Führen Sie ein direktes kausales Experiment mit kontrollierten Variablen und externer Validierung durch.",
53
+ "Führen Sie ein empirisches SNN-Testexperiment mit einer klaren Hypothese und einer validierten Methode durch.",
54
+ "Führen Sie ein Experiment mit Datenpartitionen und Validierungsdaten durch, um die Generalisierbarkeit der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
55
+ "Führen Sie ein Experiment mit automatischer Beweisverstärkung und menschlicher Bewertung durch, um die Validität der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
56
+ "Führen Sie ein Experiment mit externer Review-Information und ethischen Genehmigungen durch, um die Qualität der Forschung zu gewährleisten.",
57
+ "Führen Sie ein Experiment mit einer klaren Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102 durch, um die Relevanz der Ergebnisse zu testen."
58
+ ],
59
+ "requested_evidence": [
60
+ "Wiederholen Sie die Forschung mit dem gleichen Forschungspaket, um die Reproduzierbarkeit der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
61
+ "Bereitstellen Sie externe Review-Informationen und ethische Genehmigungen, um die Qualität der Forschung zu gewährleisten.",
62
+ "Bereitstellen von Datenpartitionen und Validierungsdaten, um die Generalisierbarkeit der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
63
+ "Bereitstellen von automatischer Beweisverstärkung und menschlicher Bewertung, um die Validität der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
64
+ "Bereitstellen von direkten kausalen Experimenten und empirischen SNN-Tests, um die Relevanz der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
65
+ "Bereitstellen einer klaren Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102, um die Relevanz der Ergebnisse zu testen."
66
+ ],
67
+ "confidence": 0.0,
68
+ "effect_direction": "nicht_bewertet"
69
+ },
70
+ "provenance": {
71
+ "prompt_sha256": "a9a819074daf53fecdff97c29539e83ae7238cac099e9e0308a1077856be4929",
72
+ "research_packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539",
73
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
74
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
75
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
76
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.0"
77
+ },
78
+ "epistemic_status": {
79
+ "evidence": false,
80
+ "interpretation_only": true,
81
+ "human_review_required": true
82
+ },
83
+ "review": {
84
+ "status": "pending",
85
+ "reviewer": null,
86
+ "reviewed_at": null,
87
+ "disposition": null
88
+ },
89
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:21:14.421558+00:00"
90
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211934552323-0fc176ff.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211934552323-0fc176ff",
3
+ "role": "scientific_analyst",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
17
+ "packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.",
21
+ "observations": [],
22
+ "methodological_concerns": [
23
+ "Initial structured output invalid: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object.",
24
+ "Repair attempt failed: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object."
25
+ ],
26
+ "alternative_explanations": [],
27
+ "recommended_experiments": [],
28
+ "requested_evidence": [
29
+ "Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet."
30
+ ],
31
+ "effect_direction": "not_assessed",
32
+ "confidence": 0.0
33
+ },
34
+ "provenance": {
35
+ "prompt_sha256": "dbb9e771cf3796dedda221ddf94d1424ff9f5a9a82949e3c5dcf4646899b9a50",
36
+ "research_packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539",
37
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
38
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
39
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
40
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.0"
41
+ },
42
+ "epistemic_status": {
43
+ "evidence": false,
44
+ "interpretation_only": true,
45
+ "human_review_required": true
46
+ },
47
+ "review": {
48
+ "status": "pending",
49
+ "reviewer": null,
50
+ "reviewed_at": null,
51
+ "disposition": null
52
+ },
53
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:19:34.552323+00:00"
54
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212304545660-0fc176ff.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212304545660-0fc176ff",
3
+ "role": "scientific_writer",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
17
+ "packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.",
21
+ "observations": [],
22
+ "methodological_concerns": [
23
+ "Initial structured output invalid: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object.",
24
+ "Repair attempt failed: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object."
25
+ ],
26
+ "alternative_explanations": [],
27
+ "recommended_experiments": [],
28
+ "requested_evidence": [
29
+ "Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet."
30
+ ],
31
+ "effect_direction": "not_assessed",
32
+ "confidence": 0.0
33
+ },
34
+ "provenance": {
35
+ "prompt_sha256": "46ae09f461b48ca20684d3ba83badf95930a26fb061cd8795b23c8c36b142f81",
36
+ "research_packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539",
37
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
38
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
39
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
40
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.0"
41
+ },
42
+ "epistemic_status": {
43
+ "evidence": false,
44
+ "interpretation_only": true,
45
+ "human_review_required": true
46
+ },
47
+ "review": {
48
+ "status": "pending",
49
+ "reviewer": null,
50
+ "reviewed_at": null,
51
+ "disposition": null
52
+ },
53
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:23:04.545660+00:00"
54
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/ai_packet.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,707 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
3
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
4
+ "limits": {
5
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
6
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
7
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
8
+ },
9
+ "raw_index": {
10
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
11
+ "run_count": 12,
12
+ "sha256": "3d4eadb0d930dee4000b6e3e905590e01d38f2d292f854fbf899400952a4e32a"
13
+ },
14
+ "run_count": 12,
15
+ "run_preview": [
16
+ {
17
+ "_raw_artifact": {
18
+ "format": "json.gz",
19
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
20
+ "sha256": "e3ea9976e7f92e43dfa62a2f1b9fba6103b00fafb4ac1cfa10dc630ef4548eb6",
21
+ "size_bytes": 525,
22
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
23
+ },
24
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
25
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
26
+ "metrics": {
27
+ "audit_complete": false,
28
+ "audit_item": 1,
29
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
30
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
31
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
32
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
33
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
34
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
35
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
36
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
37
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
38
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
39
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
40
+ "snn_involved": false
41
+ },
42
+ "runtime_error": null,
43
+ "seed": 101,
44
+ "state_digest_after": "d2136eb9d41dc6933f0e68bc859c10b0d061727c4597960a1d806cd1ebd1097a",
45
+ "state_digest_before": "d2136eb9d41dc6933f0e68bc859c10b0d061727c4597960a1d806cd1ebd1097a"
46
+ },
47
+ {
48
+ "_raw_artifact": {
49
+ "format": "json.gz",
50
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
51
+ "sha256": "0f2864c924fa05597263a4a0968777b4be0ca339e4d90affb3bcac4f1dd85bb3",
52
+ "size_bytes": 520,
53
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
54
+ },
55
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
56
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
57
+ "metrics": {
58
+ "audit_complete": false,
59
+ "audit_item": 2,
60
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
61
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
62
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
63
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
64
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
65
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
66
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
67
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
68
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
69
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
70
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
71
+ "snn_involved": false
72
+ },
73
+ "runtime_error": null,
74
+ "seed": 101,
75
+ "state_digest_after": "ce5f6c01b34e47bccb5d538d38308abea4c5c2bc8e85755957deb60cb9a753dc",
76
+ "state_digest_before": "ce5f6c01b34e47bccb5d538d38308abea4c5c2bc8e85755957deb60cb9a753dc"
77
+ },
78
+ {
79
+ "_raw_artifact": {
80
+ "format": "json.gz",
81
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
82
+ "sha256": "5f4b2d2bb8711b0a5786bcd4d091410e2af881240800ed097a66f349787bde24",
83
+ "size_bytes": 521,
84
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
85
+ },
86
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
87
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
88
+ "metrics": {
89
+ "audit_complete": false,
90
+ "audit_item": 3,
91
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
92
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
93
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
94
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
95
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
96
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
97
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
98
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
99
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
100
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
101
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
102
+ "snn_involved": false
103
+ },
104
+ "runtime_error": null,
105
+ "seed": 101,
106
+ "state_digest_after": "4eb7f144bdff159f345cf2b392d1a86e8b63a0c058c99575433b2ae3740b15ff",
107
+ "state_digest_before": "4eb7f144bdff159f345cf2b392d1a86e8b63a0c058c99575433b2ae3740b15ff"
108
+ },
109
+ {
110
+ "_raw_artifact": {
111
+ "format": "json.gz",
112
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
113
+ "sha256": "21c1c077bf4a3c40716c5540fac00661485d06c74dcfe763e6873a1e7b1b290b",
114
+ "size_bytes": 516,
115
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
116
+ },
117
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
118
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
119
+ "metrics": {
120
+ "audit_complete": false,
121
+ "audit_item": 4,
122
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
123
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
124
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
125
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
126
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
127
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
128
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
129
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
130
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
131
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
132
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
133
+ "snn_involved": false
134
+ },
135
+ "runtime_error": null,
136
+ "seed": 101,
137
+ "state_digest_after": "78568f7e75302ec995179886ad264f791e4f75560903d15eb0bc9d8bc6eaac5c",
138
+ "state_digest_before": "78568f7e75302ec995179886ad264f791e4f75560903d15eb0bc9d8bc6eaac5c"
139
+ },
140
+ {
141
+ "_raw_artifact": {
142
+ "format": "json.gz",
143
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
144
+ "sha256": "c140628197f03ae0b89184bc34e8908aa6d20c40bcc4f258642d75defcf6d4be",
145
+ "size_bytes": 526,
146
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
147
+ },
148
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
149
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
150
+ "metrics": {
151
+ "audit_complete": false,
152
+ "audit_item": 1,
153
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
154
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
155
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
156
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
157
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
158
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
159
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
160
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
161
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
162
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
163
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
164
+ "snn_involved": false
165
+ },
166
+ "runtime_error": null,
167
+ "seed": 102,
168
+ "state_digest_after": "2635c6c28488b1d14fe3f464f4b290d18d92759d405dbabd6bc118c1c27a79f9",
169
+ "state_digest_before": "2635c6c28488b1d14fe3f464f4b290d18d92759d405dbabd6bc118c1c27a79f9"
170
+ },
171
+ {
172
+ "_raw_artifact": {
173
+ "format": "json.gz",
174
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
175
+ "sha256": "dbb160ea2d0a9ae4e30c71fae50f9331e4174208a33fe68896414f9df0c367bf",
176
+ "size_bytes": 519,
177
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
178
+ },
179
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
180
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
181
+ "metrics": {
182
+ "audit_complete": false,
183
+ "audit_item": 2,
184
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
185
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
186
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
187
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
188
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
189
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
190
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
191
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
192
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
193
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
194
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
195
+ "snn_involved": false
196
+ },
197
+ "runtime_error": null,
198
+ "seed": 102,
199
+ "state_digest_after": "b65b86b4cd2ec15f46323312da009a23e3dedad36f41b9e3f2601a337dce16b6",
200
+ "state_digest_before": "b65b86b4cd2ec15f46323312da009a23e3dedad36f41b9e3f2601a337dce16b6"
201
+ },
202
+ {
203
+ "_raw_artifact": {
204
+ "format": "json.gz",
205
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
206
+ "sha256": "9e5eff0047f83bc920a5b05de3605559a9e7a7fa0a701fdb2e622d900f8d50ed",
207
+ "size_bytes": 518,
208
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
209
+ },
210
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
211
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
212
+ "metrics": {
213
+ "audit_complete": false,
214
+ "audit_item": 3,
215
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
216
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
217
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
218
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
219
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
220
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
221
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
222
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
223
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
224
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
225
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
226
+ "snn_involved": false
227
+ },
228
+ "runtime_error": null,
229
+ "seed": 102,
230
+ "state_digest_after": "add2f4243f2d9d47273be2992eef7988826fd77a2c774e2d684ba9aefd7593c6",
231
+ "state_digest_before": "add2f4243f2d9d47273be2992eef7988826fd77a2c774e2d684ba9aefd7593c6"
232
+ },
233
+ {
234
+ "_raw_artifact": {
235
+ "format": "json.gz",
236
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
237
+ "sha256": "043bec17fef0bc7f54c1bfa9f1d7e619922d96de49f6eb9048378882da017306",
238
+ "size_bytes": 516,
239
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
240
+ },
241
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
242
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
243
+ "metrics": {
244
+ "audit_complete": false,
245
+ "audit_item": 4,
246
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
247
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
248
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
249
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
250
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
251
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
252
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
253
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
254
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
255
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
256
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
257
+ "snn_involved": false
258
+ },
259
+ "runtime_error": null,
260
+ "seed": 102,
261
+ "state_digest_after": "01a981dc454af1f27e290ab3930d3ddf2b03ab266e6f78bab297701e96302115",
262
+ "state_digest_before": "01a981dc454af1f27e290ab3930d3ddf2b03ab266e6f78bab297701e96302115"
263
+ },
264
+ {
265
+ "_raw_artifact": {
266
+ "format": "json.gz",
267
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
268
+ "sha256": "80cdd5e57fe15c6e04a6a3eca357a79293018b7a672a0f995aab561fd66c34d8",
269
+ "size_bytes": 522,
270
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
271
+ },
272
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
273
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
274
+ "metrics": {
275
+ "audit_complete": false,
276
+ "audit_item": 1,
277
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
278
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
279
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
280
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
281
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
282
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
283
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
284
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
285
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
286
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
287
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
288
+ "snn_involved": false
289
+ },
290
+ "runtime_error": null,
291
+ "seed": 103,
292
+ "state_digest_after": "fec7dd7203c1493abe3caa367e12c82f07270005f5b7eb5dedc9ac0dd98da0a0",
293
+ "state_digest_before": "fec7dd7203c1493abe3caa367e12c82f07270005f5b7eb5dedc9ac0dd98da0a0"
294
+ },
295
+ {
296
+ "_raw_artifact": {
297
+ "format": "json.gz",
298
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
299
+ "sha256": "f34f90d47b6a16ab5d40ac84bd4158d99f9c66c631b8c4788f628e682ff255b5",
300
+ "size_bytes": 519,
301
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
302
+ },
303
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
304
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
305
+ "metrics": {
306
+ "audit_complete": false,
307
+ "audit_item": 2,
308
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
309
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
310
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
311
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
312
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
313
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
314
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
315
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
316
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
317
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
318
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
319
+ "snn_involved": false
320
+ },
321
+ "runtime_error": null,
322
+ "seed": 103,
323
+ "state_digest_after": "8f3faa7cd1e91c466bfeb11287134b11ec58baac9a3079a8f587c13da3f89daf",
324
+ "state_digest_before": "8f3faa7cd1e91c466bfeb11287134b11ec58baac9a3079a8f587c13da3f89daf"
325
+ },
326
+ {
327
+ "_raw_artifact": {
328
+ "format": "json.gz",
329
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
330
+ "sha256": "4d858a66f5c9e43823d8378976dc513f2440084c247fab6d0a4377eef25d3acb",
331
+ "size_bytes": 521,
332
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
333
+ },
334
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
335
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
336
+ "metrics": {
337
+ "audit_complete": false,
338
+ "audit_item": 3,
339
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
340
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
341
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
342
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
343
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
344
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
345
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
346
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
347
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
348
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
349
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
350
+ "snn_involved": false
351
+ },
352
+ "runtime_error": null,
353
+ "seed": 103,
354
+ "state_digest_after": "00effee9120946761251c3b2a2992cb7ce1d03e71876f91b5d6797af45802c06",
355
+ "state_digest_before": "00effee9120946761251c3b2a2992cb7ce1d03e71876f91b5d6797af45802c06"
356
+ },
357
+ {
358
+ "_raw_artifact": {
359
+ "format": "json.gz",
360
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
361
+ "sha256": "e4eac416196b284b27e4021552a1fdc7d8beaa39ef0506fa3cfee5bdbbcd8528",
362
+ "size_bytes": 517,
363
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
364
+ },
365
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
366
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
367
+ "metrics": {
368
+ "audit_complete": false,
369
+ "audit_item": 4,
370
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
371
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
372
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
373
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
374
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
375
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
376
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
377
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
378
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
379
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
380
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
381
+ "snn_involved": false
382
+ },
383
+ "runtime_error": null,
384
+ "seed": 103,
385
+ "state_digest_after": "2cb5e4e59c4eacbf19423fdab829b34cf76713b59879b55bb25fc81f8a97578b",
386
+ "state_digest_before": "2cb5e4e59c4eacbf19423fdab829b34cf76713b59879b55bb25fc81f8a97578b"
387
+ }
388
+ ],
389
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
390
+ "statistics": {
391
+ "conditions": {
392
+ "alternative_model": {
393
+ "boolean_metrics": {
394
+ "audit_complete": {
395
+ "all_true": false,
396
+ "false_count": 3,
397
+ "n": 3,
398
+ "true_count": 0,
399
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
400
+ },
401
+ "audit_template_generated": {
402
+ "all_true": true,
403
+ "false_count": 0,
404
+ "n": 3,
405
+ "true_count": 3,
406
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
407
+ },
408
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
409
+ "all_true": false,
410
+ "false_count": 3,
411
+ "n": 3,
412
+ "true_count": 0,
413
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
414
+ },
415
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
416
+ "all_true": true,
417
+ "false_count": 0,
418
+ "n": 3,
419
+ "true_count": 3,
420
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
421
+ },
422
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
423
+ "all_true": false,
424
+ "false_count": 3,
425
+ "n": 3,
426
+ "true_count": 0,
427
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
428
+ },
429
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
430
+ "all_true": false,
431
+ "false_count": 3,
432
+ "n": 3,
433
+ "true_count": 0,
434
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
435
+ },
436
+ "scientific_evidence": {
437
+ "all_true": false,
438
+ "false_count": 3,
439
+ "n": 3,
440
+ "true_count": 0,
441
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
442
+ },
443
+ "snn_involved": {
444
+ "all_true": false,
445
+ "false_count": 3,
446
+ "n": 3,
447
+ "true_count": 0,
448
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
449
+ }
450
+ },
451
+ "metrics": {
452
+ "audit_item": {
453
+ "max": 2.0,
454
+ "mean": 2.0,
455
+ "median": 2.0,
456
+ "min": 2.0,
457
+ "n": 3,
458
+ "std": 0.0
459
+ }
460
+ },
461
+ "run_count": 3,
462
+ "seeds": [
463
+ 101,
464
+ 102,
465
+ 103
466
+ ]
467
+ },
468
+ "assumption_explicit": {
469
+ "boolean_metrics": {
470
+ "audit_complete": {
471
+ "all_true": false,
472
+ "false_count": 3,
473
+ "n": 3,
474
+ "true_count": 0,
475
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
476
+ },
477
+ "audit_template_generated": {
478
+ "all_true": true,
479
+ "false_count": 0,
480
+ "n": 3,
481
+ "true_count": 3,
482
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
483
+ },
484
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
485
+ "all_true": false,
486
+ "false_count": 3,
487
+ "n": 3,
488
+ "true_count": 0,
489
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
490
+ },
491
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
492
+ "all_true": true,
493
+ "false_count": 0,
494
+ "n": 3,
495
+ "true_count": 3,
496
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
497
+ },
498
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
499
+ "all_true": false,
500
+ "false_count": 3,
501
+ "n": 3,
502
+ "true_count": 0,
503
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
504
+ },
505
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
506
+ "all_true": false,
507
+ "false_count": 3,
508
+ "n": 3,
509
+ "true_count": 0,
510
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
511
+ },
512
+ "scientific_evidence": {
513
+ "all_true": false,
514
+ "false_count": 3,
515
+ "n": 3,
516
+ "true_count": 0,
517
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
518
+ },
519
+ "snn_involved": {
520
+ "all_true": false,
521
+ "false_count": 3,
522
+ "n": 3,
523
+ "true_count": 0,
524
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
525
+ }
526
+ },
527
+ "metrics": {
528
+ "audit_item": {
529
+ "max": 1.0,
530
+ "mean": 1.0,
531
+ "median": 1.0,
532
+ "min": 1.0,
533
+ "n": 3,
534
+ "std": 0.0
535
+ }
536
+ },
537
+ "run_count": 3,
538
+ "seeds": [
539
+ 101,
540
+ 102,
541
+ 103
542
+ ]
543
+ },
544
+ "claim_boundary": {
545
+ "boolean_metrics": {
546
+ "audit_complete": {
547
+ "all_true": false,
548
+ "false_count": 3,
549
+ "n": 3,
550
+ "true_count": 0,
551
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
552
+ },
553
+ "audit_template_generated": {
554
+ "all_true": true,
555
+ "false_count": 0,
556
+ "n": 3,
557
+ "true_count": 3,
558
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
559
+ },
560
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
561
+ "all_true": false,
562
+ "false_count": 3,
563
+ "n": 3,
564
+ "true_count": 0,
565
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
566
+ },
567
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
568
+ "all_true": true,
569
+ "false_count": 0,
570
+ "n": 3,
571
+ "true_count": 3,
572
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
573
+ },
574
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
575
+ "all_true": false,
576
+ "false_count": 3,
577
+ "n": 3,
578
+ "true_count": 0,
579
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
580
+ },
581
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
582
+ "all_true": false,
583
+ "false_count": 3,
584
+ "n": 3,
585
+ "true_count": 0,
586
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
587
+ },
588
+ "scientific_evidence": {
589
+ "all_true": false,
590
+ "false_count": 3,
591
+ "n": 3,
592
+ "true_count": 0,
593
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
594
+ },
595
+ "snn_involved": {
596
+ "all_true": false,
597
+ "false_count": 3,
598
+ "n": 3,
599
+ "true_count": 0,
600
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
601
+ }
602
+ },
603
+ "metrics": {
604
+ "audit_item": {
605
+ "max": 4.0,
606
+ "mean": 4.0,
607
+ "median": 4.0,
608
+ "min": 4.0,
609
+ "n": 3,
610
+ "std": 0.0
611
+ }
612
+ },
613
+ "run_count": 3,
614
+ "seeds": [
615
+ 101,
616
+ 102,
617
+ 103
618
+ ]
619
+ },
620
+ "measurement_limit": {
621
+ "boolean_metrics": {
622
+ "audit_complete": {
623
+ "all_true": false,
624
+ "false_count": 3,
625
+ "n": 3,
626
+ "true_count": 0,
627
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
628
+ },
629
+ "audit_template_generated": {
630
+ "all_true": true,
631
+ "false_count": 0,
632
+ "n": 3,
633
+ "true_count": 3,
634
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
635
+ },
636
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
637
+ "all_true": false,
638
+ "false_count": 3,
639
+ "n": 3,
640
+ "true_count": 0,
641
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
642
+ },
643
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
644
+ "all_true": true,
645
+ "false_count": 0,
646
+ "n": 3,
647
+ "true_count": 3,
648
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
649
+ },
650
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
651
+ "all_true": false,
652
+ "false_count": 3,
653
+ "n": 3,
654
+ "true_count": 0,
655
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
656
+ },
657
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
658
+ "all_true": false,
659
+ "false_count": 3,
660
+ "n": 3,
661
+ "true_count": 0,
662
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
663
+ },
664
+ "scientific_evidence": {
665
+ "all_true": false,
666
+ "false_count": 3,
667
+ "n": 3,
668
+ "true_count": 0,
669
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
670
+ },
671
+ "snn_involved": {
672
+ "all_true": false,
673
+ "false_count": 3,
674
+ "n": 3,
675
+ "true_count": 0,
676
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
677
+ }
678
+ },
679
+ "metrics": {
680
+ "audit_item": {
681
+ "max": 3.0,
682
+ "mean": 3.0,
683
+ "median": 3.0,
684
+ "min": 3.0,
685
+ "n": 3,
686
+ "std": 0.0
687
+ }
688
+ },
689
+ "run_count": 3,
690
+ "seeds": [
691
+ 101,
692
+ 102,
693
+ 103
694
+ ]
695
+ }
696
+ },
697
+ "formulas": {
698
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
699
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
700
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
701
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
702
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
703
+ },
704
+ "run_count": 12,
705
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
706
+ }
707
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/ai_packet_digest.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "path": "analysis/ai_packet.json",
3
+ "raw_index_sha256": "3d4eadb0d930dee4000b6e3e905590e01d38f2d292f854fbf899400952a4e32a",
4
+ "schema_version": "1.0",
5
+ "sha256": "3f457151d5def65324add373cc53f3d30f05b1a0cb0d991ce44718eb69d54bb1",
6
+ "size_bytes": 24536
7
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/analysis/statistics.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,318 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "conditions": {
3
+ "alternative_model": {
4
+ "boolean_metrics": {
5
+ "audit_complete": {
6
+ "all_true": false,
7
+ "false_count": 3,
8
+ "n": 3,
9
+ "true_count": 0,
10
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
11
+ },
12
+ "audit_template_generated": {
13
+ "all_true": true,
14
+ "false_count": 0,
15
+ "n": 3,
16
+ "true_count": 3,
17
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
18
+ },
19
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
20
+ "all_true": false,
21
+ "false_count": 3,
22
+ "n": 3,
23
+ "true_count": 0,
24
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
25
+ },
26
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
27
+ "all_true": true,
28
+ "false_count": 0,
29
+ "n": 3,
30
+ "true_count": 3,
31
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
32
+ },
33
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
34
+ "all_true": false,
35
+ "false_count": 3,
36
+ "n": 3,
37
+ "true_count": 0,
38
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
39
+ },
40
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
41
+ "all_true": false,
42
+ "false_count": 3,
43
+ "n": 3,
44
+ "true_count": 0,
45
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
46
+ },
47
+ "scientific_evidence": {
48
+ "all_true": false,
49
+ "false_count": 3,
50
+ "n": 3,
51
+ "true_count": 0,
52
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
53
+ },
54
+ "snn_involved": {
55
+ "all_true": false,
56
+ "false_count": 3,
57
+ "n": 3,
58
+ "true_count": 0,
59
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
60
+ }
61
+ },
62
+ "metrics": {
63
+ "audit_item": {
64
+ "max": 2.0,
65
+ "mean": 2.0,
66
+ "median": 2.0,
67
+ "min": 2.0,
68
+ "n": 3,
69
+ "std": 0.0
70
+ }
71
+ },
72
+ "run_count": 3,
73
+ "seeds": [
74
+ 101,
75
+ 102,
76
+ 103
77
+ ]
78
+ },
79
+ "assumption_explicit": {
80
+ "boolean_metrics": {
81
+ "audit_complete": {
82
+ "all_true": false,
83
+ "false_count": 3,
84
+ "n": 3,
85
+ "true_count": 0,
86
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
87
+ },
88
+ "audit_template_generated": {
89
+ "all_true": true,
90
+ "false_count": 0,
91
+ "n": 3,
92
+ "true_count": 3,
93
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
94
+ },
95
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
96
+ "all_true": false,
97
+ "false_count": 3,
98
+ "n": 3,
99
+ "true_count": 0,
100
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
101
+ },
102
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
103
+ "all_true": true,
104
+ "false_count": 0,
105
+ "n": 3,
106
+ "true_count": 3,
107
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
108
+ },
109
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
110
+ "all_true": false,
111
+ "false_count": 3,
112
+ "n": 3,
113
+ "true_count": 0,
114
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
115
+ },
116
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
117
+ "all_true": false,
118
+ "false_count": 3,
119
+ "n": 3,
120
+ "true_count": 0,
121
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
122
+ },
123
+ "scientific_evidence": {
124
+ "all_true": false,
125
+ "false_count": 3,
126
+ "n": 3,
127
+ "true_count": 0,
128
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
129
+ },
130
+ "snn_involved": {
131
+ "all_true": false,
132
+ "false_count": 3,
133
+ "n": 3,
134
+ "true_count": 0,
135
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
136
+ }
137
+ },
138
+ "metrics": {
139
+ "audit_item": {
140
+ "max": 1.0,
141
+ "mean": 1.0,
142
+ "median": 1.0,
143
+ "min": 1.0,
144
+ "n": 3,
145
+ "std": 0.0
146
+ }
147
+ },
148
+ "run_count": 3,
149
+ "seeds": [
150
+ 101,
151
+ 102,
152
+ 103
153
+ ]
154
+ },
155
+ "claim_boundary": {
156
+ "boolean_metrics": {
157
+ "audit_complete": {
158
+ "all_true": false,
159
+ "false_count": 3,
160
+ "n": 3,
161
+ "true_count": 0,
162
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
163
+ },
164
+ "audit_template_generated": {
165
+ "all_true": true,
166
+ "false_count": 0,
167
+ "n": 3,
168
+ "true_count": 3,
169
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
170
+ },
171
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
172
+ "all_true": false,
173
+ "false_count": 3,
174
+ "n": 3,
175
+ "true_count": 0,
176
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
177
+ },
178
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
179
+ "all_true": true,
180
+ "false_count": 0,
181
+ "n": 3,
182
+ "true_count": 3,
183
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
184
+ },
185
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
186
+ "all_true": false,
187
+ "false_count": 3,
188
+ "n": 3,
189
+ "true_count": 0,
190
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
191
+ },
192
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
193
+ "all_true": false,
194
+ "false_count": 3,
195
+ "n": 3,
196
+ "true_count": 0,
197
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
198
+ },
199
+ "scientific_evidence": {
200
+ "all_true": false,
201
+ "false_count": 3,
202
+ "n": 3,
203
+ "true_count": 0,
204
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
205
+ },
206
+ "snn_involved": {
207
+ "all_true": false,
208
+ "false_count": 3,
209
+ "n": 3,
210
+ "true_count": 0,
211
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
212
+ }
213
+ },
214
+ "metrics": {
215
+ "audit_item": {
216
+ "max": 4.0,
217
+ "mean": 4.0,
218
+ "median": 4.0,
219
+ "min": 4.0,
220
+ "n": 3,
221
+ "std": 0.0
222
+ }
223
+ },
224
+ "run_count": 3,
225
+ "seeds": [
226
+ 101,
227
+ 102,
228
+ 103
229
+ ]
230
+ },
231
+ "measurement_limit": {
232
+ "boolean_metrics": {
233
+ "audit_complete": {
234
+ "all_true": false,
235
+ "false_count": 3,
236
+ "n": 3,
237
+ "true_count": 0,
238
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
239
+ },
240
+ "audit_template_generated": {
241
+ "all_true": true,
242
+ "false_count": 0,
243
+ "n": 3,
244
+ "true_count": 3,
245
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
246
+ },
247
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
248
+ "all_true": false,
249
+ "false_count": 3,
250
+ "n": 3,
251
+ "true_count": 0,
252
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
253
+ },
254
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
255
+ "all_true": true,
256
+ "false_count": 0,
257
+ "n": 3,
258
+ "true_count": 3,
259
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
260
+ },
261
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
262
+ "all_true": false,
263
+ "false_count": 3,
264
+ "n": 3,
265
+ "true_count": 0,
266
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
267
+ },
268
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
269
+ "all_true": false,
270
+ "false_count": 3,
271
+ "n": 3,
272
+ "true_count": 0,
273
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
274
+ },
275
+ "scientific_evidence": {
276
+ "all_true": false,
277
+ "false_count": 3,
278
+ "n": 3,
279
+ "true_count": 0,
280
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
281
+ },
282
+ "snn_involved": {
283
+ "all_true": false,
284
+ "false_count": 3,
285
+ "n": 3,
286
+ "true_count": 0,
287
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
288
+ }
289
+ },
290
+ "metrics": {
291
+ "audit_item": {
292
+ "max": 3.0,
293
+ "mean": 3.0,
294
+ "median": 3.0,
295
+ "min": 3.0,
296
+ "n": 3,
297
+ "std": 0.0
298
+ }
299
+ },
300
+ "run_count": 3,
301
+ "seeds": [
302
+ 101,
303
+ 102,
304
+ 103
305
+ ]
306
+ }
307
+ },
308
+ "formulas": {
309
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
310
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
311
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
312
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
313
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
314
+ },
315
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
316
+ "run_count": 12,
317
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
318
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/manifest.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,127 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "ai_exposure": "none",
3
+ "ai_interactions": [],
4
+ "ai_protocol": {
5
+ "bump_reason": "initial registration",
6
+ "version": 1
7
+ },
8
+ "ai_reproducibility": "R0",
9
+ "artifacts": {
10
+ "ai_packet": "analysis/ai_packet.json",
11
+ "ai_packet_digest": "analysis/ai_packet_digest.json",
12
+ "ai_report_json": "experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json",
13
+ "ai_report_markdown": "experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md",
14
+ "current_run": "DATA/current_run.json",
15
+ "data": "DATA/runs_compact.json",
16
+ "data_index": "DATA/runs_index.json",
17
+ "preregistration": "preregistrations/operational/cognition_bundle_v1.json",
18
+ "raw_run_index": "DATA/runs_index.json",
19
+ "report": "report.md",
20
+ "statistics": "analysis/statistics.json",
21
+ "workflow": "workflow.json"
22
+ },
23
+ "causal_card": {
24
+ "classification": "PURE",
25
+ "interaction_ids": [],
26
+ "roles": []
27
+ },
28
+ "causal_taint": "PURE",
29
+ "config": {
30
+ "path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
31
+ "sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c"
32
+ },
33
+ "created_at": "2026-10-01T21:17:54.646972+00:00",
34
+ "data_partitions": [],
35
+ "epistemic_layers": {
36
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
37
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
38
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input",
39
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result"
40
+ },
41
+ "execution_contract": {
42
+ "hypothesis_id": "H-CNS-102-A",
43
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_102_v1",
44
+ "question_id": "RQ-CNS-102",
45
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_102_v1",
46
+ "runtime_runner_bytecode_sha256": "93e483e29fa71c08401562dfa757d4a5f80fb7ca1fa1cce25a1e76c2b71ea1eb",
47
+ "runtime_summary_bytecode_sha256": "462bf872a28910b7747790c4aae29f288f6aa5361c27799f0ea52a1fdc09f7a6",
48
+ "source_runner_bytecode_sha256": "93e483e29fa71c08401562dfa757d4a5f80fb7ca1fa1cce25a1e76c2b71ea1eb",
49
+ "source_runtime_consistency": "MATCH",
50
+ "source_summary_bytecode_sha256": "462bf872a28910b7747790c4aae29f288f6aa5361c27799f0ea52a1fdc09f7a6",
51
+ "tick_validation": {
52
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
53
+ "requested_ticks": 1,
54
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"
55
+ },
56
+ "ticks_requested": 1
57
+ },
58
+ "execution_semantics": {
59
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
60
+ "claim_scope": "method_template_only",
61
+ "direct_test_of_hypothesis": false,
62
+ "external_review": "external_review/INTEGRATION.md",
63
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
64
+ "kind": "conceptual_audit",
65
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
66
+ "snn_involved": false
67
+ },
68
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
69
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
70
+ "git": {
71
+ "branch": "develop",
72
+ "commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
73
+ "dirty": true
74
+ },
75
+ "hypotheses": [
76
+ "H-CNS-102-A"
77
+ ],
78
+ "network_mode": "OFFLINE",
79
+ "provenance_digests": {
80
+ "code": "5a11ea288e7e695c2dcd456642b533cbb3e6daf38b72e150134e60e69059531f",
81
+ "config": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
82
+ "data": "5be9d3503d4522990200c3157f0acdc5276ba622a8960f981b36651fc138f1ee",
83
+ "prompt": "dd18e473908e7e75b1717c240bac221729ea38753abfd28b701b37b20d5f5e14"
84
+ },
85
+ "research_questions": [
86
+ "RQ-CNS-102"
87
+ ],
88
+ "research_run_mode": "EXPLORATORY",
89
+ "results": {
90
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_102_v1",
91
+ "run_count": 12,
92
+ "runner": "run_cog_cns_102_v1",
93
+ "tick_contract": {
94
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
95
+ "requested_ticks": 1,
96
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"
97
+ },
98
+ "ticks_requested": 1
99
+ },
100
+ "runtime": {
101
+ "duration_seconds": 0.010705600026994944
102
+ },
103
+ "runtime_errors": [],
104
+ "simulation": {
105
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_102_v1",
106
+ "seed": 101,
107
+ "seeds": [
108
+ 101,
109
+ 102,
110
+ 103
111
+ ],
112
+ "ticks": 1
113
+ },
114
+ "software": {
115
+ "brain5d_version": "0.6.0a7",
116
+ "os": "Windows 11",
117
+ "python": "3.13.14"
118
+ },
119
+ "source_freeze_sha": "a1f28e68beb3d8493ceef648d5f511ab7f7785ea2737a16108debb4be792b5f9",
120
+ "timestamp": "2026-10-01T23:17:54.646959",
121
+ "validity": {
122
+ "fatal_error_count": 0,
123
+ "reason": null,
124
+ "runtime_error_count": 0,
125
+ "valid": true
126
+ }
127
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/report.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01: Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_102_v1
2
+
3
+ ## Forschungszuordnung
4
+ Forschungsfrage: `RQ-CNS-102`
5
+ Hypothese: `H-CNS-102-A`
6
+ Aufgeloester Runner: `run_cog_cns_102_v1`
7
+
8
+ ## Protokoll und Einstellungen
9
+ Protokoll: `cog_cns_102_v1`
10
+ Angeforderte Mindest-Ticks: `1`
11
+ Seeds: `101, 102, 103`
12
+ Tick-Vertrag: `{"mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials", "requested_ticks": 1, "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"}`
13
+
14
+ ## Bedingungen
15
+ frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract
16
+ Runs: 12; Dauer: 0.010706 s
17
+
18
+ ## Daten und Statistik
19
+ Versionierte kompakte Run-Projektion: `DATA/runs_compact.json`
20
+ Unveränderlicher Rohdatenindex: `DATA/runs_index.json`
21
+ KI-Eingabepaket: `analysis/ai_packet.json` (hart begrenzt)
22
+ Deterministische deskriptive Statistik: `analysis/statistics.json`
23
+ Die Summary verbindet Rohdaten, Formeln, Einzelruns, Bedingungen, Reproduzierbarkeit und AIRR ohne KI-generierte Statistik.
24
+
25
+ ## Epistemische Ebenen
26
+ UI-Zustand: Dashboard-Steuerung und Fortschritt; kein wissenschaftliches Ergebnis.
27
+ DATA: Rohdaten, Run-Index und deterministische Statistik.
28
+ EVID: nicht erzeugt; Clean Freeze, semantische Zuordnung und Human Review erforderlich.
29
+ Interpretation: nachgelagerte KI-/Human-Interpretation; keine Ausfuehrungseingabe.
30
+
31
+ ## Evidenzstatus
32
+ DATA, Manifest, Workflow und deterministische Statistik sind erzeugt. Wissenschaftliche EVID entsteht erst nach passender semantischer Zuordnung, Clean Freeze und Human Review.
33
+
34
+ ## Hinweise
35
+ Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,1451 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "report_id": "AIRR-2026-0001",
3
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
4
+ "research_question_id": "RQ-CNS-102",
5
+ "hypothesis_ids": [
6
+ "H-CNS-102-A"
7
+ ],
8
+ "claim_ids": [],
9
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:23:04.548080+00:00",
10
+ "report_schema_version": "1.0",
11
+ "report_protocol_version": "PROTOCOL-AIRR-001",
12
+ "generated_by": "artificial_intelligence",
13
+ "ai_generated": true,
14
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
15
+ "human_review_required": true,
16
+ "status": "review_pending",
17
+ "content": {
18
+ "identification": {
19
+ "experiment": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
20
+ "research_question": "Zeigt das isolierte SNN eine passive Deviant-Antwort, die über Reizidentität und Adaptation hinausgeht?",
21
+ "hypotheses": [
22
+ {
23
+ "id": "H-CNS-102-A",
24
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-102",
25
+ "hypothesis": "Ein vorab definiertes Abweichungssignal bleibt nach Identitätsumkehr und Many-Standards-Kontrolle gegenüber einem adaptierenden Nullmodell bestehen.",
26
+ "status": "untested",
27
+ "evidence": [],
28
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
29
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
30
+ }
31
+ ],
32
+ "date": "2026-10-01",
33
+ "source_sha": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3"
34
+ },
35
+ "executive_summary": "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.",
36
+ "research_question": {
37
+ "id": "RQ-CNS-102",
38
+ "domain": "Prediction and adaptation",
39
+ "question": "Zeigt das isolierte SNN eine passive Deviant-Antwort, die über Reizidentität und Adaptation hinausgeht?",
40
+ "relevance": "Passive oddball; Mismatch response is not awareness; no response requirement in passive arm",
41
+ "literature": [
42
+ "SRC-CNS-ODDBALL"
43
+ ],
44
+ "hypotheses": [
45
+ "H-CNS-102-A"
46
+ ],
47
+ "evidence": [],
48
+ "status": "open",
49
+ "answer": {
50
+ "current": null,
51
+ "confidence": "none",
52
+ "limitations": "Mismatch response is not awareness; no response requirement in passive arm"
53
+ },
54
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
55
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
56
+ },
57
+ "experimental_design": {
58
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
59
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-102",
60
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-102-A",
61
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_102_v1",
62
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
63
+ "ticks": 1,
64
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
65
+ "seeds": [
66
+ 101,
67
+ 102,
68
+ 103
69
+ ],
70
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_102_v1",
71
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_102_v1",
72
+ "tick_validation": {
73
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
74
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
75
+ "requested_ticks": 1
76
+ },
77
+ "notes": "Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
78
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
79
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
80
+ "epistemic_layers": {
81
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
82
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
83
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
84
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
85
+ }
86
+ },
87
+ "data_basis": {
88
+ "data": {
89
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
90
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
91
+ "limits": {
92
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
93
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
94
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
95
+ },
96
+ "raw_index": {
97
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
98
+ "run_count": 12,
99
+ "sha256": "3d4eadb0d930dee4000b6e3e905590e01d38f2d292f854fbf899400952a4e32a"
100
+ },
101
+ "run_count": 12,
102
+ "run_preview": [
103
+ {
104
+ "_raw_artifact": {
105
+ "format": "json.gz",
106
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
107
+ "sha256": "e3ea9976e7f92e43dfa62a2f1b9fba6103b00fafb4ac1cfa10dc630ef4548eb6",
108
+ "size_bytes": 525,
109
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
110
+ },
111
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
112
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
113
+ "metrics": {
114
+ "audit_complete": false,
115
+ "audit_item": 1,
116
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
117
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
118
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
119
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
120
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
121
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
122
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
123
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
124
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
125
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
126
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
127
+ "snn_involved": false
128
+ },
129
+ "runtime_error": null,
130
+ "seed": 101,
131
+ "state_digest_after": "d2136eb9d41dc6933f0e68bc859c10b0d061727c4597960a1d806cd1ebd1097a",
132
+ "state_digest_before": "d2136eb9d41dc6933f0e68bc859c10b0d061727c4597960a1d806cd1ebd1097a"
133
+ },
134
+ {
135
+ "_raw_artifact": {
136
+ "format": "json.gz",
137
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
138
+ "sha256": "0f2864c924fa05597263a4a0968777b4be0ca339e4d90affb3bcac4f1dd85bb3",
139
+ "size_bytes": 520,
140
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
141
+ },
142
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
143
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
144
+ "metrics": {
145
+ "audit_complete": false,
146
+ "audit_item": 2,
147
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
148
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
149
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
150
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
151
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
152
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
153
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
154
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
155
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
156
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
157
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
158
+ "snn_involved": false
159
+ },
160
+ "runtime_error": null,
161
+ "seed": 101,
162
+ "state_digest_after": "ce5f6c01b34e47bccb5d538d38308abea4c5c2bc8e85755957deb60cb9a753dc",
163
+ "state_digest_before": "ce5f6c01b34e47bccb5d538d38308abea4c5c2bc8e85755957deb60cb9a753dc"
164
+ },
165
+ {
166
+ "_raw_artifact": {
167
+ "format": "json.gz",
168
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
169
+ "sha256": "5f4b2d2bb8711b0a5786bcd4d091410e2af881240800ed097a66f349787bde24",
170
+ "size_bytes": 521,
171
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
172
+ },
173
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
174
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
175
+ "metrics": {
176
+ "audit_complete": false,
177
+ "audit_item": 3,
178
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
179
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
180
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
181
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
182
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
183
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
184
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
185
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
186
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
187
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
188
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
189
+ "snn_involved": false
190
+ },
191
+ "runtime_error": null,
192
+ "seed": 101,
193
+ "state_digest_after": "4eb7f144bdff159f345cf2b392d1a86e8b63a0c058c99575433b2ae3740b15ff",
194
+ "state_digest_before": "4eb7f144bdff159f345cf2b392d1a86e8b63a0c058c99575433b2ae3740b15ff"
195
+ },
196
+ {
197
+ "_raw_artifact": {
198
+ "format": "json.gz",
199
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
200
+ "sha256": "21c1c077bf4a3c40716c5540fac00661485d06c74dcfe763e6873a1e7b1b290b",
201
+ "size_bytes": 516,
202
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
203
+ },
204
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
205
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
206
+ "metrics": {
207
+ "audit_complete": false,
208
+ "audit_item": 4,
209
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
210
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
211
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
212
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
213
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
214
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
215
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
216
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
217
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
218
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
219
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
220
+ "snn_involved": false
221
+ },
222
+ "runtime_error": null,
223
+ "seed": 101,
224
+ "state_digest_after": "78568f7e75302ec995179886ad264f791e4f75560903d15eb0bc9d8bc6eaac5c",
225
+ "state_digest_before": "78568f7e75302ec995179886ad264f791e4f75560903d15eb0bc9d8bc6eaac5c"
226
+ },
227
+ {
228
+ "_raw_artifact": {
229
+ "format": "json.gz",
230
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
231
+ "sha256": "c140628197f03ae0b89184bc34e8908aa6d20c40bcc4f258642d75defcf6d4be",
232
+ "size_bytes": 526,
233
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
234
+ },
235
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
236
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
237
+ "metrics": {
238
+ "audit_complete": false,
239
+ "audit_item": 1,
240
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
241
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
242
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
243
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
244
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
245
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
246
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
247
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
248
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
249
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
250
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
251
+ "snn_involved": false
252
+ },
253
+ "runtime_error": null,
254
+ "seed": 102,
255
+ "state_digest_after": "2635c6c28488b1d14fe3f464f4b290d18d92759d405dbabd6bc118c1c27a79f9",
256
+ "state_digest_before": "2635c6c28488b1d14fe3f464f4b290d18d92759d405dbabd6bc118c1c27a79f9"
257
+ },
258
+ {
259
+ "_raw_artifact": {
260
+ "format": "json.gz",
261
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
262
+ "sha256": "dbb160ea2d0a9ae4e30c71fae50f9331e4174208a33fe68896414f9df0c367bf",
263
+ "size_bytes": 519,
264
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
265
+ },
266
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
267
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
268
+ "metrics": {
269
+ "audit_complete": false,
270
+ "audit_item": 2,
271
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
272
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
273
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
274
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
275
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
276
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
277
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
278
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
279
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
280
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
281
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
282
+ "snn_involved": false
283
+ },
284
+ "runtime_error": null,
285
+ "seed": 102,
286
+ "state_digest_after": "b65b86b4cd2ec15f46323312da009a23e3dedad36f41b9e3f2601a337dce16b6",
287
+ "state_digest_before": "b65b86b4cd2ec15f46323312da009a23e3dedad36f41b9e3f2601a337dce16b6"
288
+ },
289
+ {
290
+ "_raw_artifact": {
291
+ "format": "json.gz",
292
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
293
+ "sha256": "9e5eff0047f83bc920a5b05de3605559a9e7a7fa0a701fdb2e622d900f8d50ed",
294
+ "size_bytes": 518,
295
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
296
+ },
297
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
298
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
299
+ "metrics": {
300
+ "audit_complete": false,
301
+ "audit_item": 3,
302
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
303
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
304
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
305
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
306
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
307
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
308
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
309
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
310
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
311
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
312
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
313
+ "snn_involved": false
314
+ },
315
+ "runtime_error": null,
316
+ "seed": 102,
317
+ "state_digest_after": "add2f4243f2d9d47273be2992eef7988826fd77a2c774e2d684ba9aefd7593c6",
318
+ "state_digest_before": "add2f4243f2d9d47273be2992eef7988826fd77a2c774e2d684ba9aefd7593c6"
319
+ },
320
+ {
321
+ "_raw_artifact": {
322
+ "format": "json.gz",
323
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
324
+ "sha256": "043bec17fef0bc7f54c1bfa9f1d7e619922d96de49f6eb9048378882da017306",
325
+ "size_bytes": 516,
326
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
327
+ },
328
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
329
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
330
+ "metrics": {
331
+ "audit_complete": false,
332
+ "audit_item": 4,
333
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
334
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
335
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
336
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
337
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
338
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
339
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
340
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
341
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
342
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
343
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
344
+ "snn_involved": false
345
+ },
346
+ "runtime_error": null,
347
+ "seed": 102,
348
+ "state_digest_after": "01a981dc454af1f27e290ab3930d3ddf2b03ab266e6f78bab297701e96302115",
349
+ "state_digest_before": "01a981dc454af1f27e290ab3930d3ddf2b03ab266e6f78bab297701e96302115"
350
+ },
351
+ {
352
+ "_raw_artifact": {
353
+ "format": "json.gz",
354
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
355
+ "sha256": "80cdd5e57fe15c6e04a6a3eca357a79293018b7a672a0f995aab561fd66c34d8",
356
+ "size_bytes": 522,
357
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
358
+ },
359
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
360
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
361
+ "metrics": {
362
+ "audit_complete": false,
363
+ "audit_item": 1,
364
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
365
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
366
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
367
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
368
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
369
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
370
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
371
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
372
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
373
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
374
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
375
+ "snn_involved": false
376
+ },
377
+ "runtime_error": null,
378
+ "seed": 103,
379
+ "state_digest_after": "fec7dd7203c1493abe3caa367e12c82f07270005f5b7eb5dedc9ac0dd98da0a0",
380
+ "state_digest_before": "fec7dd7203c1493abe3caa367e12c82f07270005f5b7eb5dedc9ac0dd98da0a0"
381
+ },
382
+ {
383
+ "_raw_artifact": {
384
+ "format": "json.gz",
385
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
386
+ "sha256": "f34f90d47b6a16ab5d40ac84bd4158d99f9c66c631b8c4788f628e682ff255b5",
387
+ "size_bytes": 519,
388
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
389
+ },
390
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
391
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
392
+ "metrics": {
393
+ "audit_complete": false,
394
+ "audit_item": 2,
395
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
396
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
397
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
398
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
399
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
400
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
401
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
402
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
403
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
404
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
405
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
406
+ "snn_involved": false
407
+ },
408
+ "runtime_error": null,
409
+ "seed": 103,
410
+ "state_digest_after": "8f3faa7cd1e91c466bfeb11287134b11ec58baac9a3079a8f587c13da3f89daf",
411
+ "state_digest_before": "8f3faa7cd1e91c466bfeb11287134b11ec58baac9a3079a8f587c13da3f89daf"
412
+ },
413
+ {
414
+ "_raw_artifact": {
415
+ "format": "json.gz",
416
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
417
+ "sha256": "4d858a66f5c9e43823d8378976dc513f2440084c247fab6d0a4377eef25d3acb",
418
+ "size_bytes": 521,
419
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
420
+ },
421
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
422
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
423
+ "metrics": {
424
+ "audit_complete": false,
425
+ "audit_item": 3,
426
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
427
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
428
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
429
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
430
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
431
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
432
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
433
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
434
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
435
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
436
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
437
+ "snn_involved": false
438
+ },
439
+ "runtime_error": null,
440
+ "seed": 103,
441
+ "state_digest_after": "00effee9120946761251c3b2a2992cb7ce1d03e71876f91b5d6797af45802c06",
442
+ "state_digest_before": "00effee9120946761251c3b2a2992cb7ce1d03e71876f91b5d6797af45802c06"
443
+ },
444
+ {
445
+ "_raw_artifact": {
446
+ "format": "json.gz",
447
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
448
+ "sha256": "e4eac416196b284b27e4021552a1fdc7d8beaa39ef0506fa3cfee5bdbbcd8528",
449
+ "size_bytes": 517,
450
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
451
+ },
452
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
453
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
454
+ "metrics": {
455
+ "audit_complete": false,
456
+ "audit_item": 4,
457
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
458
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
459
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
460
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
461
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
462
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
463
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
464
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
465
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
466
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
467
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
468
+ "snn_involved": false
469
+ },
470
+ "runtime_error": null,
471
+ "seed": 103,
472
+ "state_digest_after": "2cb5e4e59c4eacbf19423fdab829b34cf76713b59879b55bb25fc81f8a97578b",
473
+ "state_digest_before": "2cb5e4e59c4eacbf19423fdab829b34cf76713b59879b55bb25fc81f8a97578b"
474
+ }
475
+ ],
476
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
477
+ "statistics": {
478
+ "conditions": {
479
+ "alternative_model": {
480
+ "boolean_metrics": {
481
+ "audit_complete": {
482
+ "all_true": false,
483
+ "false_count": 3,
484
+ "n": 3,
485
+ "true_count": 0,
486
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
487
+ },
488
+ "audit_template_generated": {
489
+ "all_true": true,
490
+ "false_count": 0,
491
+ "n": 3,
492
+ "true_count": 3,
493
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
494
+ },
495
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
496
+ "all_true": false,
497
+ "false_count": 3,
498
+ "n": 3,
499
+ "true_count": 0,
500
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
501
+ },
502
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
503
+ "all_true": true,
504
+ "false_count": 0,
505
+ "n": 3,
506
+ "true_count": 3,
507
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
508
+ },
509
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
510
+ "all_true": false,
511
+ "false_count": 3,
512
+ "n": 3,
513
+ "true_count": 0,
514
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
515
+ },
516
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
517
+ "all_true": false,
518
+ "false_count": 3,
519
+ "n": 3,
520
+ "true_count": 0,
521
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
522
+ },
523
+ "scientific_evidence": {
524
+ "all_true": false,
525
+ "false_count": 3,
526
+ "n": 3,
527
+ "true_count": 0,
528
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
529
+ },
530
+ "snn_involved": {
531
+ "all_true": false,
532
+ "false_count": 3,
533
+ "n": 3,
534
+ "true_count": 0,
535
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
536
+ }
537
+ },
538
+ "metrics": {
539
+ "audit_item": {
540
+ "max": 2.0,
541
+ "mean": 2.0,
542
+ "median": 2.0,
543
+ "min": 2.0,
544
+ "n": 3,
545
+ "std": 0.0
546
+ }
547
+ },
548
+ "run_count": 3,
549
+ "seeds": [
550
+ 101,
551
+ 102,
552
+ 103
553
+ ]
554
+ },
555
+ "assumption_explicit": {
556
+ "boolean_metrics": {
557
+ "audit_complete": {
558
+ "all_true": false,
559
+ "false_count": 3,
560
+ "n": 3,
561
+ "true_count": 0,
562
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
563
+ },
564
+ "audit_template_generated": {
565
+ "all_true": true,
566
+ "false_count": 0,
567
+ "n": 3,
568
+ "true_count": 3,
569
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
570
+ },
571
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
572
+ "all_true": false,
573
+ "false_count": 3,
574
+ "n": 3,
575
+ "true_count": 0,
576
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
577
+ },
578
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
579
+ "all_true": true,
580
+ "false_count": 0,
581
+ "n": 3,
582
+ "true_count": 3,
583
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
584
+ },
585
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
586
+ "all_true": false,
587
+ "false_count": 3,
588
+ "n": 3,
589
+ "true_count": 0,
590
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
591
+ },
592
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
593
+ "all_true": false,
594
+ "false_count": 3,
595
+ "n": 3,
596
+ "true_count": 0,
597
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
598
+ },
599
+ "scientific_evidence": {
600
+ "all_true": false,
601
+ "false_count": 3,
602
+ "n": 3,
603
+ "true_count": 0,
604
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
605
+ },
606
+ "snn_involved": {
607
+ "all_true": false,
608
+ "false_count": 3,
609
+ "n": 3,
610
+ "true_count": 0,
611
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
612
+ }
613
+ },
614
+ "metrics": {
615
+ "audit_item": {
616
+ "max": 1.0,
617
+ "mean": 1.0,
618
+ "median": 1.0,
619
+ "min": 1.0,
620
+ "n": 3,
621
+ "std": 0.0
622
+ }
623
+ },
624
+ "run_count": 3,
625
+ "seeds": [
626
+ 101,
627
+ 102,
628
+ 103
629
+ ]
630
+ },
631
+ "claim_boundary": {
632
+ "boolean_metrics": {
633
+ "audit_complete": {
634
+ "all_true": false,
635
+ "false_count": 3,
636
+ "n": 3,
637
+ "true_count": 0,
638
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
639
+ },
640
+ "audit_template_generated": {
641
+ "all_true": true,
642
+ "false_count": 0,
643
+ "n": 3,
644
+ "true_count": 3,
645
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
646
+ },
647
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
648
+ "all_true": false,
649
+ "false_count": 3,
650
+ "n": 3,
651
+ "true_count": 0,
652
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
653
+ },
654
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
655
+ "all_true": true,
656
+ "false_count": 0,
657
+ "n": 3,
658
+ "true_count": 3,
659
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
660
+ },
661
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
662
+ "all_true": false,
663
+ "false_count": 3,
664
+ "n": 3,
665
+ "true_count": 0,
666
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
667
+ },
668
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
669
+ "all_true": false,
670
+ "false_count": 3,
671
+ "n": 3,
672
+ "true_count": 0,
673
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
674
+ },
675
+ "scientific_evidence": {
676
+ "all_true": false,
677
+ "false_count": 3,
678
+ "n": 3,
679
+ "true_count": 0,
680
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
681
+ },
682
+ "snn_involved": {
683
+ "all_true": false,
684
+ "false_count": 3,
685
+ "n": 3,
686
+ "true_count": 0,
687
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
688
+ }
689
+ },
690
+ "metrics": {
691
+ "audit_item": {
692
+ "max": 4.0,
693
+ "mean": 4.0,
694
+ "median": 4.0,
695
+ "min": 4.0,
696
+ "n": 3,
697
+ "std": 0.0
698
+ }
699
+ },
700
+ "run_count": 3,
701
+ "seeds": [
702
+ 101,
703
+ 102,
704
+ 103
705
+ ]
706
+ },
707
+ "measurement_limit": {
708
+ "boolean_metrics": {
709
+ "audit_complete": {
710
+ "all_true": false,
711
+ "false_count": 3,
712
+ "n": 3,
713
+ "true_count": 0,
714
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
715
+ },
716
+ "audit_template_generated": {
717
+ "all_true": true,
718
+ "false_count": 0,
719
+ "n": 3,
720
+ "true_count": 3,
721
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
722
+ },
723
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
724
+ "all_true": false,
725
+ "false_count": 3,
726
+ "n": 3,
727
+ "true_count": 0,
728
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
729
+ },
730
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
731
+ "all_true": true,
732
+ "false_count": 0,
733
+ "n": 3,
734
+ "true_count": 3,
735
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
736
+ },
737
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
738
+ "all_true": false,
739
+ "false_count": 3,
740
+ "n": 3,
741
+ "true_count": 0,
742
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
743
+ },
744
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
745
+ "all_true": false,
746
+ "false_count": 3,
747
+ "n": 3,
748
+ "true_count": 0,
749
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
750
+ },
751
+ "scientific_evidence": {
752
+ "all_true": false,
753
+ "false_count": 3,
754
+ "n": 3,
755
+ "true_count": 0,
756
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
757
+ },
758
+ "snn_involved": {
759
+ "all_true": false,
760
+ "false_count": 3,
761
+ "n": 3,
762
+ "true_count": 0,
763
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
764
+ }
765
+ },
766
+ "metrics": {
767
+ "audit_item": {
768
+ "max": 3.0,
769
+ "mean": 3.0,
770
+ "median": 3.0,
771
+ "min": 3.0,
772
+ "n": 3,
773
+ "std": 0.0
774
+ }
775
+ },
776
+ "run_count": 3,
777
+ "seeds": [
778
+ 101,
779
+ 102,
780
+ 103
781
+ ]
782
+ }
783
+ },
784
+ "formulas": {
785
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
786
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
787
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
788
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
789
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
790
+ },
791
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
792
+ "run_count": 12,
793
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
794
+ }
795
+ },
796
+ "evid": [],
797
+ "literature": [
798
+ {
799
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-ODDBALL",
800
+ "authors": [
801
+ "Tristan A. Bekinschtein and others"
802
+ ],
803
+ "title": "Neural signature of the conscious processing of auditory regularities",
804
+ "year": 2009,
805
+ "doi": "10.1073/pnas.0809667106",
806
+ "topic": [
807
+ "cognition",
808
+ "methodology",
809
+ "ethics"
810
+ ],
811
+ "claims": [],
812
+ "brain5d_questions": [
813
+ "RQ-CNS-102",
814
+ "RQ-CNS-103",
815
+ "RQ-CNS-104"
816
+ ],
817
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Local/global auditory regularities and attention/report conditions; no diagnostic transfer to AI. Source: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19164526/"
818
+ }
819
+ ]
820
+ },
821
+ "quantitative_results": {
822
+ "conditions": {
823
+ "alternative_model": {
824
+ "boolean_metrics": {
825
+ "audit_complete": {
826
+ "all_true": false,
827
+ "false_count": 3,
828
+ "n": 3,
829
+ "true_count": 0,
830
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
831
+ },
832
+ "audit_template_generated": {
833
+ "all_true": true,
834
+ "false_count": 0,
835
+ "n": 3,
836
+ "true_count": 3,
837
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
838
+ },
839
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
840
+ "all_true": false,
841
+ "false_count": 3,
842
+ "n": 3,
843
+ "true_count": 0,
844
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
845
+ },
846
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
847
+ "all_true": true,
848
+ "false_count": 0,
849
+ "n": 3,
850
+ "true_count": 3,
851
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
852
+ },
853
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
854
+ "all_true": false,
855
+ "false_count": 3,
856
+ "n": 3,
857
+ "true_count": 0,
858
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
859
+ },
860
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
861
+ "all_true": false,
862
+ "false_count": 3,
863
+ "n": 3,
864
+ "true_count": 0,
865
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
866
+ },
867
+ "scientific_evidence": {
868
+ "all_true": false,
869
+ "false_count": 3,
870
+ "n": 3,
871
+ "true_count": 0,
872
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
873
+ },
874
+ "snn_involved": {
875
+ "all_true": false,
876
+ "false_count": 3,
877
+ "n": 3,
878
+ "true_count": 0,
879
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
880
+ }
881
+ },
882
+ "metrics": {
883
+ "audit_item": {
884
+ "max": 2.0,
885
+ "mean": 2.0,
886
+ "median": 2.0,
887
+ "min": 2.0,
888
+ "n": 3,
889
+ "std": 0.0
890
+ }
891
+ },
892
+ "run_count": 3,
893
+ "seeds": [
894
+ 101,
895
+ 102,
896
+ 103
897
+ ]
898
+ },
899
+ "assumption_explicit": {
900
+ "boolean_metrics": {
901
+ "audit_complete": {
902
+ "all_true": false,
903
+ "false_count": 3,
904
+ "n": 3,
905
+ "true_count": 0,
906
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
907
+ },
908
+ "audit_template_generated": {
909
+ "all_true": true,
910
+ "false_count": 0,
911
+ "n": 3,
912
+ "true_count": 3,
913
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
914
+ },
915
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
916
+ "all_true": false,
917
+ "false_count": 3,
918
+ "n": 3,
919
+ "true_count": 0,
920
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
921
+ },
922
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
923
+ "all_true": true,
924
+ "false_count": 0,
925
+ "n": 3,
926
+ "true_count": 3,
927
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
928
+ },
929
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
930
+ "all_true": false,
931
+ "false_count": 3,
932
+ "n": 3,
933
+ "true_count": 0,
934
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
935
+ },
936
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
937
+ "all_true": false,
938
+ "false_count": 3,
939
+ "n": 3,
940
+ "true_count": 0,
941
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
942
+ },
943
+ "scientific_evidence": {
944
+ "all_true": false,
945
+ "false_count": 3,
946
+ "n": 3,
947
+ "true_count": 0,
948
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
949
+ },
950
+ "snn_involved": {
951
+ "all_true": false,
952
+ "false_count": 3,
953
+ "n": 3,
954
+ "true_count": 0,
955
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
956
+ }
957
+ },
958
+ "metrics": {
959
+ "audit_item": {
960
+ "max": 1.0,
961
+ "mean": 1.0,
962
+ "median": 1.0,
963
+ "min": 1.0,
964
+ "n": 3,
965
+ "std": 0.0
966
+ }
967
+ },
968
+ "run_count": 3,
969
+ "seeds": [
970
+ 101,
971
+ 102,
972
+ 103
973
+ ]
974
+ },
975
+ "claim_boundary": {
976
+ "boolean_metrics": {
977
+ "audit_complete": {
978
+ "all_true": false,
979
+ "false_count": 3,
980
+ "n": 3,
981
+ "true_count": 0,
982
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
983
+ },
984
+ "audit_template_generated": {
985
+ "all_true": true,
986
+ "false_count": 0,
987
+ "n": 3,
988
+ "true_count": 3,
989
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
990
+ },
991
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
992
+ "all_true": false,
993
+ "false_count": 3,
994
+ "n": 3,
995
+ "true_count": 0,
996
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
997
+ },
998
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
999
+ "all_true": true,
1000
+ "false_count": 0,
1001
+ "n": 3,
1002
+ "true_count": 3,
1003
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1004
+ },
1005
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1006
+ "all_true": false,
1007
+ "false_count": 3,
1008
+ "n": 3,
1009
+ "true_count": 0,
1010
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1011
+ },
1012
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1013
+ "all_true": false,
1014
+ "false_count": 3,
1015
+ "n": 3,
1016
+ "true_count": 0,
1017
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1018
+ },
1019
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1020
+ "all_true": false,
1021
+ "false_count": 3,
1022
+ "n": 3,
1023
+ "true_count": 0,
1024
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1025
+ },
1026
+ "snn_involved": {
1027
+ "all_true": false,
1028
+ "false_count": 3,
1029
+ "n": 3,
1030
+ "true_count": 0,
1031
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1032
+ }
1033
+ },
1034
+ "metrics": {
1035
+ "audit_item": {
1036
+ "max": 4.0,
1037
+ "mean": 4.0,
1038
+ "median": 4.0,
1039
+ "min": 4.0,
1040
+ "n": 3,
1041
+ "std": 0.0
1042
+ }
1043
+ },
1044
+ "run_count": 3,
1045
+ "seeds": [
1046
+ 101,
1047
+ 102,
1048
+ 103
1049
+ ]
1050
+ },
1051
+ "measurement_limit": {
1052
+ "boolean_metrics": {
1053
+ "audit_complete": {
1054
+ "all_true": false,
1055
+ "false_count": 3,
1056
+ "n": 3,
1057
+ "true_count": 0,
1058
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1059
+ },
1060
+ "audit_template_generated": {
1061
+ "all_true": true,
1062
+ "false_count": 0,
1063
+ "n": 3,
1064
+ "true_count": 3,
1065
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1066
+ },
1067
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1068
+ "all_true": false,
1069
+ "false_count": 3,
1070
+ "n": 3,
1071
+ "true_count": 0,
1072
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1073
+ },
1074
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1075
+ "all_true": true,
1076
+ "false_count": 0,
1077
+ "n": 3,
1078
+ "true_count": 3,
1079
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1080
+ },
1081
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1082
+ "all_true": false,
1083
+ "false_count": 3,
1084
+ "n": 3,
1085
+ "true_count": 0,
1086
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1087
+ },
1088
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1089
+ "all_true": false,
1090
+ "false_count": 3,
1091
+ "n": 3,
1092
+ "true_count": 0,
1093
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1094
+ },
1095
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1096
+ "all_true": false,
1097
+ "false_count": 3,
1098
+ "n": 3,
1099
+ "true_count": 0,
1100
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1101
+ },
1102
+ "snn_involved": {
1103
+ "all_true": false,
1104
+ "false_count": 3,
1105
+ "n": 3,
1106
+ "true_count": 0,
1107
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1108
+ }
1109
+ },
1110
+ "metrics": {
1111
+ "audit_item": {
1112
+ "max": 3.0,
1113
+ "mean": 3.0,
1114
+ "median": 3.0,
1115
+ "min": 3.0,
1116
+ "n": 3,
1117
+ "std": 0.0
1118
+ }
1119
+ },
1120
+ "run_count": 3,
1121
+ "seeds": [
1122
+ 101,
1123
+ 102,
1124
+ 103
1125
+ ]
1126
+ }
1127
+ },
1128
+ "formulas": {
1129
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
1130
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
1131
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
1132
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
1133
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
1134
+ },
1135
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
1136
+ "run_count": 12,
1137
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
1138
+ },
1139
+ "observations": [],
1140
+ "interpretation": {
1141
+ "assessment": "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.",
1142
+ "observations": [],
1143
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1144
+ "Initial structured output invalid: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object.",
1145
+ "Repair attempt failed: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object."
1146
+ ],
1147
+ "alternative_explanations": [],
1148
+ "recommended_experiments": [],
1149
+ "requested_evidence": [
1150
+ "Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet."
1151
+ ],
1152
+ "effect_direction": "not_assessed",
1153
+ "confidence": 0.0
1154
+ },
1155
+ "methodological_critique": [
1156
+ "Die Experimente sind nicht reproduzierbar, da keine kontrollierten Variablen oder externe Validierung vorhanden sind.",
1157
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.",
1158
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.",
1159
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.",
1160
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.",
1161
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.",
1162
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.",
1163
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Tests.",
1164
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1165
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1166
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102."
1167
+ ],
1168
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1169
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.",
1170
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.",
1171
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.",
1172
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.",
1173
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.",
1174
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.",
1175
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Teste.",
1176
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1177
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1178
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102."
1179
+ ],
1180
+ "reproducibility": {
1181
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1182
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1183
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1184
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1185
+ "source_freeze_sha": "a1f28e68beb3d8493ceef648d5f511ab7f7785ea2737a16108debb4be792b5f9",
1186
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1187
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1188
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "267de0649a0a3680e0c418fbd8fceb8821246b47b24151653b07ba71a86fd27f",
1189
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1190
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1191
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1192
+ "protocol_digest": "622198c6033cd292b6f6c328a171ab2180050df3bc04eafa10f421464199b920",
1193
+ "data_digest": "13a8a316c3f293ed74fd7eea77086285ba4f6eadbd84b4534f2c289af8a79e63",
1194
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1195
+ },
1196
+ "epistemic_status": {
1197
+ "implementation": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1198
+ "experiment_data": "PRESENT",
1199
+ "registered_evidence": "ABSENT",
1200
+ "ai_interpretation": "PRESENT",
1201
+ "human_review": "PENDING",
1202
+ "claim_support": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1203
+ "rq_status": "IN_PROGRESS",
1204
+ "semantic_alignment": "NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED",
1205
+ "semantic_note": "Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.",
1206
+ "design_adequacy": "NOT_ASSESSED",
1207
+ "design_note": "Für diese Forschungsfrage ist keine automatische Designadäquanz-Regel registriert.",
1208
+ "confidence_gate": "PASSED"
1209
+ },
1210
+ "ai_confidence": 0.0,
1211
+ "missing_evidence": [
1212
+ "Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet."
1213
+ ],
1214
+ "recommended_follow_up": [],
1215
+ "conclusion": "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.",
1216
+ "human_review": {
1217
+ "status": "PENDING",
1218
+ "reviewer": null,
1219
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1220
+ "disposition": null,
1221
+ "comments": null
1222
+ },
1223
+ "aiar": {
1224
+ "analyst": {
1225
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211934552323-0fc176ff",
1226
+ "role": "scientific_analyst",
1227
+ "model": {
1228
+ "provider": "ollama",
1229
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1230
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1231
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1232
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1233
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1234
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1235
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1236
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1237
+ },
1238
+ "inputs": {
1239
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
1240
+ "packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539"
1241
+ },
1242
+ "output": {
1243
+ "assessment": "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.",
1244
+ "observations": [],
1245
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1246
+ "Initial structured output invalid: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object.",
1247
+ "Repair attempt failed: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object."
1248
+ ],
1249
+ "alternative_explanations": [],
1250
+ "recommended_experiments": [],
1251
+ "requested_evidence": [
1252
+ "Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet."
1253
+ ],
1254
+ "effect_direction": "not_assessed",
1255
+ "confidence": 0.0
1256
+ },
1257
+ "provenance": {
1258
+ "prompt_sha256": "dbb9e771cf3796dedda221ddf94d1424ff9f5a9a82949e3c5dcf4646899b9a50",
1259
+ "research_packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539",
1260
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1261
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1262
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1263
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.0"
1264
+ },
1265
+ "epistemic_status": {
1266
+ "evidence": false,
1267
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1268
+ "human_review_required": true
1269
+ },
1270
+ "review": {
1271
+ "status": "pending",
1272
+ "reviewer": null,
1273
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1274
+ "disposition": null
1275
+ },
1276
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:19:34.552323+00:00"
1277
+ },
1278
+ "reviewer": {
1279
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212114421558-0fc176ff",
1280
+ "role": "critical_reviewer",
1281
+ "model": {
1282
+ "provider": "ollama",
1283
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1284
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1285
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1286
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1287
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1288
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1289
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1290
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1291
+ },
1292
+ "inputs": {
1293
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
1294
+ "packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539"
1295
+ },
1296
+ "output": {
1297
+ "assessment": "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse. Die Ergebnisse sind rein deskriptiv und keine statistische Signifikanz wurde getestet.",
1298
+ "observations": [
1299
+ "Die Experimente sind konzeptionelle Audits, die keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Tests umfassen.",
1300
+ "Die Metriken sind identisch in allen Bedingungen, mit Ausnahme der audit_item, die sich in den Bedingungen unterscheiden.",
1301
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in den Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist."
1302
+ ],
1303
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1304
+ "Die Experimente sind nicht reproduzierbar, da keine kontrollierten Variablen oder externe Validierung vorhanden sind.",
1305
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.",
1306
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.",
1307
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.",
1308
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.",
1309
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.",
1310
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.",
1311
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Tests.",
1312
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1313
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1314
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102."
1315
+ ],
1316
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1317
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.",
1318
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.",
1319
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.",
1320
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.",
1321
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.",
1322
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.",
1323
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Teste.",
1324
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1325
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1326
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102."
1327
+ ],
1328
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1329
+ "Führen Sie ein direktes kausales Experiment mit kontrollierten Variablen und externer Validierung durch.",
1330
+ "Führen Sie ein empirisches SNN-Testexperiment mit einer klaren Hypothese und einer validierten Methode durch.",
1331
+ "Führen Sie ein Experiment mit Datenpartitionen und Validierungsdaten durch, um die Generalisierbarkeit der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
1332
+ "Führen Sie ein Experiment mit automatischer Beweisverstärkung und menschlicher Bewertung durch, um die Validität der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
1333
+ "Führen Sie ein Experiment mit externer Review-Information und ethischen Genehmigungen durch, um die Qualität der Forschung zu gewährleisten.",
1334
+ "Führen Sie ein Experiment mit einer klaren Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102 durch, um die Relevanz der Ergebnisse zu testen."
1335
+ ],
1336
+ "requested_evidence": [
1337
+ "Wiederholen Sie die Forschung mit dem gleichen Forschungspaket, um die Reproduzierbarkeit der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
1338
+ "Bereitstellen Sie externe Review-Informationen und ethische Genehmigungen, um die Qualität der Forschung zu gewährleisten.",
1339
+ "Bereitstellen von Datenpartitionen und Validierungsdaten, um die Generalisierbarkeit der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
1340
+ "Bereitstellen von automatischer Beweisverstärkung und menschlicher Bewertung, um die Validität der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
1341
+ "Bereitstellen von direkten kausalen Experimenten und empirischen SNN-Tests, um die Relevanz der Ergebnisse zu testen.",
1342
+ "Bereitstellen einer klaren Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102, um die Relevanz der Ergebnisse zu testen."
1343
+ ],
1344
+ "confidence": 0.0,
1345
+ "effect_direction": "nicht_bewertet"
1346
+ },
1347
+ "provenance": {
1348
+ "prompt_sha256": "a9a819074daf53fecdff97c29539e83ae7238cac099e9e0308a1077856be4929",
1349
+ "research_packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539",
1350
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1351
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1352
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1353
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.0"
1354
+ },
1355
+ "epistemic_status": {
1356
+ "evidence": false,
1357
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1358
+ "human_review_required": true
1359
+ },
1360
+ "review": {
1361
+ "status": "pending",
1362
+ "reviewer": null,
1363
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1364
+ "disposition": null
1365
+ },
1366
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:21:14.421558+00:00"
1367
+ },
1368
+ "writer": {
1369
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212304545660-0fc176ff",
1370
+ "role": "scientific_writer",
1371
+ "model": {
1372
+ "provider": "ollama",
1373
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1374
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1375
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1376
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1377
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1378
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1379
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1380
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1381
+ },
1382
+ "inputs": {
1383
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
1384
+ "packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539"
1385
+ },
1386
+ "output": {
1387
+ "assessment": "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.",
1388
+ "observations": [],
1389
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1390
+ "Initial structured output invalid: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object.",
1391
+ "Repair attempt failed: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object."
1392
+ ],
1393
+ "alternative_explanations": [],
1394
+ "recommended_experiments": [],
1395
+ "requested_evidence": [
1396
+ "Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet."
1397
+ ],
1398
+ "effect_direction": "not_assessed",
1399
+ "confidence": 0.0
1400
+ },
1401
+ "provenance": {
1402
+ "prompt_sha256": "46ae09f461b48ca20684d3ba83badf95930a26fb061cd8795b23c8c36b142f81",
1403
+ "research_packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539",
1404
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1405
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1406
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1407
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.0"
1408
+ },
1409
+ "epistemic_status": {
1410
+ "evidence": false,
1411
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1412
+ "human_review_required": true
1413
+ },
1414
+ "review": {
1415
+ "status": "pending",
1416
+ "reviewer": null,
1417
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1418
+ "disposition": null
1419
+ },
1420
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:23:04.545660+00:00"
1421
+ }
1422
+ }
1423
+ },
1424
+ "provenance": {
1425
+ "research_packet_digest": "0fc176ff98b621d1210fb5ee8a5c71152a1efe59d4476d21a608e2c5eca9e539",
1426
+ "source": {
1427
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1428
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1429
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1430
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1431
+ "source_freeze_sha": "a1f28e68beb3d8493ceef648d5f511ab7f7785ea2737a16108debb4be792b5f9",
1432
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1433
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1434
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "267de0649a0a3680e0c418fbd8fceb8821246b47b24151653b07ba71a86fd27f",
1435
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1436
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1437
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1438
+ "protocol_digest": "622198c6033cd292b6f6c328a171ab2180050df3bc04eafa10f421464199b920",
1439
+ "data_digest": "13a8a316c3f293ed74fd7eea77086285ba4f6eadbd84b4534f2c289af8a79e63",
1440
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1441
+ }
1442
+ },
1443
+ "analysis_ids": [
1444
+ "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211934552323-0fc176ff",
1445
+ "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212114421558-0fc176ff",
1446
+ "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212304545660-0fc176ff"
1447
+ ],
1448
+ "supersedes": null,
1449
+ "content_digest": "042332248acea804ccdbc978f65678d46c12e4991c0a7106b4a9c7005e1fc9a9",
1450
+ "markdown_digest": "95e64bffefc53b0e1b81afb96d6d666e9a607e9812d49411e0c1c608460a6e07"
1451
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,1286 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ ============================================================
2
+ BRAIN-5D - AI GENERATED SCIENTIFIC ANALYSIS
3
+ ============================================================
4
+
5
+ Dieser Bericht wurde durch ein kuenstliches Intelligenzsystem erzeugt.
6
+
7
+ Er stellt eine wissenschaftliche Interpretation von MHRN-Forschungsdaten dar.
8
+
9
+ Er ist KEINE wissenschaftliche Evidenz.
10
+
11
+ Er wurde zum Zeitpunkt der Erstellung noch nicht automatisch durch einen Menschen bestaetigt.
12
+
13
+ Human Review Status: PENDING
14
+ ============================================================
15
+
16
+ # AI Research Report AIRR-2026-0001
17
+
18
+ Status: review_pending | Experiment: EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01
19
+ Research Question: RQ-CNS-102
20
+ ## Executive Summary
21
+
22
+ ```json
23
+ "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred."
24
+ ```
25
+
26
+ ## Research Question
27
+
28
+ ```json
29
+ {
30
+ "id": "RQ-CNS-102",
31
+ "domain": "Prediction and adaptation",
32
+ "question": "Zeigt das isolierte SNN eine passive Deviant-Antwort, die über Reizidentität und Adaptation hinausgeht?",
33
+ "relevance": "Passive oddball; Mismatch response is not awareness; no response requirement in passive arm",
34
+ "literature": [
35
+ "SRC-CNS-ODDBALL"
36
+ ],
37
+ "hypotheses": [
38
+ "H-CNS-102-A"
39
+ ],
40
+ "evidence": [],
41
+ "status": "open",
42
+ "answer": {
43
+ "current": null,
44
+ "confidence": "none",
45
+ "limitations": "Mismatch response is not awareness; no response requirement in passive arm"
46
+ },
47
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
48
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
49
+ }
50
+ ```
51
+
52
+ ## Experimental Design
53
+
54
+ ```json
55
+ {
56
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
57
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-102",
58
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-102-A",
59
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_102_v1",
60
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
61
+ "ticks": 1,
62
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
63
+ "seeds": [
64
+ 101,
65
+ 102,
66
+ 103
67
+ ],
68
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_102_v1",
69
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_102_v1",
70
+ "tick_validation": {
71
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
72
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
73
+ "requested_ticks": 1
74
+ },
75
+ "notes": "Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
76
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
77
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
78
+ "epistemic_layers": {
79
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
80
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
81
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
82
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
83
+ }
84
+ }
85
+ ```
86
+
87
+ ## Data Basis
88
+
89
+ ```json
90
+ {
91
+ "data": {
92
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
93
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
94
+ "limits": {
95
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
96
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
97
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
98
+ },
99
+ "raw_index": {
100
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
101
+ "run_count": 12,
102
+ "sha256": "3d4eadb0d930dee4000b6e3e905590e01d38f2d292f854fbf899400952a4e32a"
103
+ },
104
+ "run_count": 12,
105
+ "run_preview": [
106
+ {
107
+ "_raw_artifact": {
108
+ "format": "json.gz",
109
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
110
+ "sha256": "e3ea9976e7f92e43dfa62a2f1b9fba6103b00fafb4ac1cfa10dc630ef4548eb6",
111
+ "size_bytes": 525,
112
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
113
+ },
114
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
115
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
116
+ "metrics": {
117
+ "audit_complete": false,
118
+ "audit_item": 1,
119
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
120
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
121
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
122
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
123
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
124
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
125
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
126
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
127
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
128
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
129
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
130
+ "snn_involved": false
131
+ },
132
+ "runtime_error": null,
133
+ "seed": 101,
134
+ "state_digest_after": "d2136eb9d41dc6933f0e68bc859c10b0d061727c4597960a1d806cd1ebd1097a",
135
+ "state_digest_before": "d2136eb9d41dc6933f0e68bc859c10b0d061727c4597960a1d806cd1ebd1097a"
136
+ },
137
+ {
138
+ "_raw_artifact": {
139
+ "format": "json.gz",
140
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
141
+ "sha256": "0f2864c924fa05597263a4a0968777b4be0ca339e4d90affb3bcac4f1dd85bb3",
142
+ "size_bytes": 520,
143
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
144
+ },
145
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
146
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
147
+ "metrics": {
148
+ "audit_complete": false,
149
+ "audit_item": 2,
150
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
151
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
152
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
153
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
154
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
155
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
156
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
157
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
158
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
159
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
160
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
161
+ "snn_involved": false
162
+ },
163
+ "runtime_error": null,
164
+ "seed": 101,
165
+ "state_digest_after": "ce5f6c01b34e47bccb5d538d38308abea4c5c2bc8e85755957deb60cb9a753dc",
166
+ "state_digest_before": "ce5f6c01b34e47bccb5d538d38308abea4c5c2bc8e85755957deb60cb9a753dc"
167
+ },
168
+ {
169
+ "_raw_artifact": {
170
+ "format": "json.gz",
171
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
172
+ "sha256": "5f4b2d2bb8711b0a5786bcd4d091410e2af881240800ed097a66f349787bde24",
173
+ "size_bytes": 521,
174
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
175
+ },
176
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
177
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
178
+ "metrics": {
179
+ "audit_complete": false,
180
+ "audit_item": 3,
181
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
182
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
183
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
184
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
185
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
186
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
187
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
188
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
189
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
190
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
191
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
192
+ "snn_involved": false
193
+ },
194
+ "runtime_error": null,
195
+ "seed": 101,
196
+ "state_digest_after": "4eb7f144bdff159f345cf2b392d1a86e8b63a0c058c99575433b2ae3740b15ff",
197
+ "state_digest_before": "4eb7f144bdff159f345cf2b392d1a86e8b63a0c058c99575433b2ae3740b15ff"
198
+ },
199
+ {
200
+ "_raw_artifact": {
201
+ "format": "json.gz",
202
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
203
+ "sha256": "21c1c077bf4a3c40716c5540fac00661485d06c74dcfe763e6873a1e7b1b290b",
204
+ "size_bytes": 516,
205
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
206
+ },
207
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
208
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
209
+ "metrics": {
210
+ "audit_complete": false,
211
+ "audit_item": 4,
212
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
213
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
214
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
215
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
216
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
217
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
218
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
219
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
220
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
221
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
222
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
223
+ "snn_involved": false
224
+ },
225
+ "runtime_error": null,
226
+ "seed": 101,
227
+ "state_digest_after": "78568f7e75302ec995179886ad264f791e4f75560903d15eb0bc9d8bc6eaac5c",
228
+ "state_digest_before": "78568f7e75302ec995179886ad264f791e4f75560903d15eb0bc9d8bc6eaac5c"
229
+ },
230
+ {
231
+ "_raw_artifact": {
232
+ "format": "json.gz",
233
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
234
+ "sha256": "c140628197f03ae0b89184bc34e8908aa6d20c40bcc4f258642d75defcf6d4be",
235
+ "size_bytes": 526,
236
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
237
+ },
238
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
239
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
240
+ "metrics": {
241
+ "audit_complete": false,
242
+ "audit_item": 1,
243
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
244
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
245
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
246
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
247
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
248
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
249
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
250
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
251
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
252
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
253
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
254
+ "snn_involved": false
255
+ },
256
+ "runtime_error": null,
257
+ "seed": 102,
258
+ "state_digest_after": "2635c6c28488b1d14fe3f464f4b290d18d92759d405dbabd6bc118c1c27a79f9",
259
+ "state_digest_before": "2635c6c28488b1d14fe3f464f4b290d18d92759d405dbabd6bc118c1c27a79f9"
260
+ },
261
+ {
262
+ "_raw_artifact": {
263
+ "format": "json.gz",
264
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
265
+ "sha256": "dbb160ea2d0a9ae4e30c71fae50f9331e4174208a33fe68896414f9df0c367bf",
266
+ "size_bytes": 519,
267
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
268
+ },
269
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
270
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
271
+ "metrics": {
272
+ "audit_complete": false,
273
+ "audit_item": 2,
274
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
275
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
276
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
277
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
278
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
279
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
280
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
281
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
282
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
283
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
284
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
285
+ "snn_involved": false
286
+ },
287
+ "runtime_error": null,
288
+ "seed": 102,
289
+ "state_digest_after": "b65b86b4cd2ec15f46323312da009a23e3dedad36f41b9e3f2601a337dce16b6",
290
+ "state_digest_before": "b65b86b4cd2ec15f46323312da009a23e3dedad36f41b9e3f2601a337dce16b6"
291
+ },
292
+ {
293
+ "_raw_artifact": {
294
+ "format": "json.gz",
295
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
296
+ "sha256": "9e5eff0047f83bc920a5b05de3605559a9e7a7fa0a701fdb2e622d900f8d50ed",
297
+ "size_bytes": 518,
298
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
299
+ },
300
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
301
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
302
+ "metrics": {
303
+ "audit_complete": false,
304
+ "audit_item": 3,
305
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
306
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
307
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
308
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
309
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
310
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
311
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
312
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
313
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
314
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
315
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
316
+ "snn_involved": false
317
+ },
318
+ "runtime_error": null,
319
+ "seed": 102,
320
+ "state_digest_after": "add2f4243f2d9d47273be2992eef7988826fd77a2c774e2d684ba9aefd7593c6",
321
+ "state_digest_before": "add2f4243f2d9d47273be2992eef7988826fd77a2c774e2d684ba9aefd7593c6"
322
+ },
323
+ {
324
+ "_raw_artifact": {
325
+ "format": "json.gz",
326
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
327
+ "sha256": "043bec17fef0bc7f54c1bfa9f1d7e619922d96de49f6eb9048378882da017306",
328
+ "size_bytes": 516,
329
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
330
+ },
331
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
332
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
333
+ "metrics": {
334
+ "audit_complete": false,
335
+ "audit_item": 4,
336
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
337
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
338
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
339
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
340
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
341
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
342
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
343
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
344
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
345
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
346
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
347
+ "snn_involved": false
348
+ },
349
+ "runtime_error": null,
350
+ "seed": 102,
351
+ "state_digest_after": "01a981dc454af1f27e290ab3930d3ddf2b03ab266e6f78bab297701e96302115",
352
+ "state_digest_before": "01a981dc454af1f27e290ab3930d3ddf2b03ab266e6f78bab297701e96302115"
353
+ },
354
+ {
355
+ "_raw_artifact": {
356
+ "format": "json.gz",
357
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
358
+ "sha256": "80cdd5e57fe15c6e04a6a3eca357a79293018b7a672a0f995aab561fd66c34d8",
359
+ "size_bytes": 522,
360
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
361
+ },
362
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
363
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
364
+ "metrics": {
365
+ "audit_complete": false,
366
+ "audit_item": 1,
367
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
368
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
369
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
370
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
371
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
372
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
373
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
374
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
375
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
376
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
377
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
378
+ "snn_involved": false
379
+ },
380
+ "runtime_error": null,
381
+ "seed": 103,
382
+ "state_digest_after": "fec7dd7203c1493abe3caa367e12c82f07270005f5b7eb5dedc9ac0dd98da0a0",
383
+ "state_digest_before": "fec7dd7203c1493abe3caa367e12c82f07270005f5b7eb5dedc9ac0dd98da0a0"
384
+ },
385
+ {
386
+ "_raw_artifact": {
387
+ "format": "json.gz",
388
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
389
+ "sha256": "f34f90d47b6a16ab5d40ac84bd4158d99f9c66c631b8c4788f628e682ff255b5",
390
+ "size_bytes": 519,
391
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
392
+ },
393
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
394
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
395
+ "metrics": {
396
+ "audit_complete": false,
397
+ "audit_item": 2,
398
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
399
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
400
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
401
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
402
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
403
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
404
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
405
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
406
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
407
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
408
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
409
+ "snn_involved": false
410
+ },
411
+ "runtime_error": null,
412
+ "seed": 103,
413
+ "state_digest_after": "8f3faa7cd1e91c466bfeb11287134b11ec58baac9a3079a8f587c13da3f89daf",
414
+ "state_digest_before": "8f3faa7cd1e91c466bfeb11287134b11ec58baac9a3079a8f587c13da3f89daf"
415
+ },
416
+ {
417
+ "_raw_artifact": {
418
+ "format": "json.gz",
419
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
420
+ "sha256": "4d858a66f5c9e43823d8378976dc513f2440084c247fab6d0a4377eef25d3acb",
421
+ "size_bytes": 521,
422
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
423
+ },
424
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
425
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
426
+ "metrics": {
427
+ "audit_complete": false,
428
+ "audit_item": 3,
429
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
430
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
431
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
432
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
433
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
434
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
435
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
436
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
437
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
438
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
439
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
440
+ "snn_involved": false
441
+ },
442
+ "runtime_error": null,
443
+ "seed": 103,
444
+ "state_digest_after": "00effee9120946761251c3b2a2992cb7ce1d03e71876f91b5d6797af45802c06",
445
+ "state_digest_before": "00effee9120946761251c3b2a2992cb7ce1d03e71876f91b5d6797af45802c06"
446
+ },
447
+ {
448
+ "_raw_artifact": {
449
+ "format": "json.gz",
450
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
451
+ "sha256": "e4eac416196b284b27e4021552a1fdc7d8beaa39ef0506fa3cfee5bdbbcd8528",
452
+ "size_bytes": 517,
453
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
454
+ },
455
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
456
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
457
+ "metrics": {
458
+ "audit_complete": false,
459
+ "audit_item": 4,
460
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
461
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
462
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
463
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
464
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
465
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
466
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
467
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
468
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
469
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
470
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
471
+ "snn_involved": false
472
+ },
473
+ "runtime_error": null,
474
+ "seed": 103,
475
+ "state_digest_after": "2cb5e4e59c4eacbf19423fdab829b34cf76713b59879b55bb25fc81f8a97578b",
476
+ "state_digest_before": "2cb5e4e59c4eacbf19423fdab829b34cf76713b59879b55bb25fc81f8a97578b"
477
+ }
478
+ ],
479
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
480
+ "statistics": {
481
+ "conditions": {
482
+ "alternative_model": {
483
+ "boolean_metrics": {
484
+ "audit_complete": {
485
+ "all_true": false,
486
+ "false_count": 3,
487
+ "n": 3,
488
+ "true_count": 0,
489
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
490
+ },
491
+ "audit_template_generated": {
492
+ "all_true": true,
493
+ "false_count": 0,
494
+ "n": 3,
495
+ "true_count": 3,
496
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
497
+ },
498
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
499
+ "all_true": false,
500
+ "false_count": 3,
501
+ "n": 3,
502
+ "true_count": 0,
503
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
504
+ },
505
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
506
+ "all_true": true,
507
+ "false_count": 0,
508
+ "n": 3,
509
+ "true_count": 3,
510
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
511
+ },
512
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
513
+ "all_true": false,
514
+ "false_count": 3,
515
+ "n": 3,
516
+ "true_count": 0,
517
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
518
+ },
519
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
520
+ "all_true": false,
521
+ "false_count": 3,
522
+ "n": 3,
523
+ "true_count": 0,
524
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
525
+ },
526
+ "scientific_evidence": {
527
+ "all_true": false,
528
+ "false_count": 3,
529
+ "n": 3,
530
+ "true_count": 0,
531
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
532
+ },
533
+ "snn_involved": {
534
+ "all_true": false,
535
+ "false_count": 3,
536
+ "n": 3,
537
+ "true_count": 0,
538
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
539
+ }
540
+ },
541
+ "metrics": {
542
+ "audit_item": {
543
+ "max": 2.0,
544
+ "mean": 2.0,
545
+ "median": 2.0,
546
+ "min": 2.0,
547
+ "n": 3,
548
+ "std": 0.0
549
+ }
550
+ },
551
+ "run_count": 3,
552
+ "seeds": [
553
+ 101,
554
+ 102,
555
+ 103
556
+ ]
557
+ },
558
+ "assumption_explicit": {
559
+ "boolean_metrics": {
560
+ "audit_complete": {
561
+ "all_true": false,
562
+ "false_count": 3,
563
+ "n": 3,
564
+ "true_count": 0,
565
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
566
+ },
567
+ "audit_template_generated": {
568
+ "all_true": true,
569
+ "false_count": 0,
570
+ "n": 3,
571
+ "true_count": 3,
572
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
573
+ },
574
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
575
+ "all_true": false,
576
+ "false_count": 3,
577
+ "n": 3,
578
+ "true_count": 0,
579
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
580
+ },
581
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
582
+ "all_true": true,
583
+ "false_count": 0,
584
+ "n": 3,
585
+ "true_count": 3,
586
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
587
+ },
588
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
589
+ "all_true": false,
590
+ "false_count": 3,
591
+ "n": 3,
592
+ "true_count": 0,
593
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
594
+ },
595
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
596
+ "all_true": false,
597
+ "false_count": 3,
598
+ "n": 3,
599
+ "true_count": 0,
600
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
601
+ },
602
+ "scientific_evidence": {
603
+ "all_true": false,
604
+ "false_count": 3,
605
+ "n": 3,
606
+ "true_count": 0,
607
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
608
+ },
609
+ "snn_involved": {
610
+ "all_true": false,
611
+ "false_count": 3,
612
+ "n": 3,
613
+ "true_count": 0,
614
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
615
+ }
616
+ },
617
+ "metrics": {
618
+ "audit_item": {
619
+ "max": 1.0,
620
+ "mean": 1.0,
621
+ "median": 1.0,
622
+ "min": 1.0,
623
+ "n": 3,
624
+ "std": 0.0
625
+ }
626
+ },
627
+ "run_count": 3,
628
+ "seeds": [
629
+ 101,
630
+ 102,
631
+ 103
632
+ ]
633
+ },
634
+ "claim_boundary": {
635
+ "boolean_metrics": {
636
+ "audit_complete": {
637
+ "all_true": false,
638
+ "false_count": 3,
639
+ "n": 3,
640
+ "true_count": 0,
641
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
642
+ },
643
+ "audit_template_generated": {
644
+ "all_true": true,
645
+ "false_count": 0,
646
+ "n": 3,
647
+ "true_count": 3,
648
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
649
+ },
650
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
651
+ "all_true": false,
652
+ "false_count": 3,
653
+ "n": 3,
654
+ "true_count": 0,
655
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
656
+ },
657
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
658
+ "all_true": true,
659
+ "false_count": 0,
660
+ "n": 3,
661
+ "true_count": 3,
662
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
663
+ },
664
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
665
+ "all_true": false,
666
+ "false_count": 3,
667
+ "n": 3,
668
+ "true_count": 0,
669
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
670
+ },
671
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
672
+ "all_true": false,
673
+ "false_count": 3,
674
+ "n": 3,
675
+ "true_count": 0,
676
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
677
+ },
678
+ "scientific_evidence": {
679
+ "all_true": false,
680
+ "false_count": 3,
681
+ "n": 3,
682
+ "true_count": 0,
683
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
684
+ },
685
+ "snn_involved": {
686
+ "all_true": false,
687
+ "false_count": 3,
688
+ "n": 3,
689
+ "true_count": 0,
690
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
691
+ }
692
+ },
693
+ "metrics": {
694
+ "audit_item": {
695
+ "max": 4.0,
696
+ "mean": 4.0,
697
+ "median": 4.0,
698
+ "min": 4.0,
699
+ "n": 3,
700
+ "std": 0.0
701
+ }
702
+ },
703
+ "run_count": 3,
704
+ "seeds": [
705
+ 101,
706
+ 102,
707
+ 103
708
+ ]
709
+ },
710
+ "measurement_limit": {
711
+ "boolean_metrics": {
712
+ "audit_complete": {
713
+ "all_true": false,
714
+ "false_count": 3,
715
+ "n": 3,
716
+ "true_count": 0,
717
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
718
+ },
719
+ "audit_template_generated": {
720
+ "all_true": true,
721
+ "false_count": 0,
722
+ "n": 3,
723
+ "true_count": 3,
724
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
725
+ },
726
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
727
+ "all_true": false,
728
+ "false_count": 3,
729
+ "n": 3,
730
+ "true_count": 0,
731
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
732
+ },
733
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
734
+ "all_true": true,
735
+ "false_count": 0,
736
+ "n": 3,
737
+ "true_count": 3,
738
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
739
+ },
740
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
741
+ "all_true": false,
742
+ "false_count": 3,
743
+ "n": 3,
744
+ "true_count": 0,
745
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
746
+ },
747
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
748
+ "all_true": false,
749
+ "false_count": 3,
750
+ "n": 3,
751
+ "true_count": 0,
752
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
753
+ },
754
+ "scientific_evidence": {
755
+ "all_true": false,
756
+ "false_count": 3,
757
+ "n": 3,
758
+ "true_count": 0,
759
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
760
+ },
761
+ "snn_involved": {
762
+ "all_true": false,
763
+ "false_count": 3,
764
+ "n": 3,
765
+ "true_count": 0,
766
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
767
+ }
768
+ },
769
+ "metrics": {
770
+ "audit_item": {
771
+ "max": 3.0,
772
+ "mean": 3.0,
773
+ "median": 3.0,
774
+ "min": 3.0,
775
+ "n": 3,
776
+ "std": 0.0
777
+ }
778
+ },
779
+ "run_count": 3,
780
+ "seeds": [
781
+ 101,
782
+ 102,
783
+ 103
784
+ ]
785
+ }
786
+ },
787
+ "formulas": {
788
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
789
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
790
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
791
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
792
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
793
+ },
794
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
795
+ "run_count": 12,
796
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
797
+ }
798
+ },
799
+ "evid": [],
800
+ "literature": [
801
+ {
802
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-ODDBALL",
803
+ "authors": [
804
+ "Tristan A. Bekinschtein and others"
805
+ ],
806
+ "title": "Neural signature of the conscious processing of auditory regularities",
807
+ "year": 2009,
808
+ "doi": "10.1073/pnas.0809667106",
809
+ "topic": [
810
+ "cognition",
811
+ "methodology",
812
+ "ethics"
813
+ ],
814
+ "claims": [],
815
+ "brain5d_questions": [
816
+ "RQ-CNS-102",
817
+ "RQ-CNS-103",
818
+ "RQ-CNS-104"
819
+ ],
820
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Local/global auditory regularities and attention/report conditions; no diagnostic transfer to AI. Source: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19164526/"
821
+ }
822
+ ]
823
+ }
824
+ ```
825
+
826
+ ## Quantitative Results
827
+
828
+ ```json
829
+ {
830
+ "conditions": {
831
+ "alternative_model": {
832
+ "boolean_metrics": {
833
+ "audit_complete": {
834
+ "all_true": false,
835
+ "false_count": 3,
836
+ "n": 3,
837
+ "true_count": 0,
838
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
839
+ },
840
+ "audit_template_generated": {
841
+ "all_true": true,
842
+ "false_count": 0,
843
+ "n": 3,
844
+ "true_count": 3,
845
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
846
+ },
847
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
848
+ "all_true": false,
849
+ "false_count": 3,
850
+ "n": 3,
851
+ "true_count": 0,
852
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
853
+ },
854
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
855
+ "all_true": true,
856
+ "false_count": 0,
857
+ "n": 3,
858
+ "true_count": 3,
859
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
860
+ },
861
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
862
+ "all_true": false,
863
+ "false_count": 3,
864
+ "n": 3,
865
+ "true_count": 0,
866
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
867
+ },
868
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
869
+ "all_true": false,
870
+ "false_count": 3,
871
+ "n": 3,
872
+ "true_count": 0,
873
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
874
+ },
875
+ "scientific_evidence": {
876
+ "all_true": false,
877
+ "false_count": 3,
878
+ "n": 3,
879
+ "true_count": 0,
880
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
881
+ },
882
+ "snn_involved": {
883
+ "all_true": false,
884
+ "false_count": 3,
885
+ "n": 3,
886
+ "true_count": 0,
887
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
888
+ }
889
+ },
890
+ "metrics": {
891
+ "audit_item": {
892
+ "max": 2.0,
893
+ "mean": 2.0,
894
+ "median": 2.0,
895
+ "min": 2.0,
896
+ "n": 3,
897
+ "std": 0.0
898
+ }
899
+ },
900
+ "run_count": 3,
901
+ "seeds": [
902
+ 101,
903
+ 102,
904
+ 103
905
+ ]
906
+ },
907
+ "assumption_explicit": {
908
+ "boolean_metrics": {
909
+ "audit_complete": {
910
+ "all_true": false,
911
+ "false_count": 3,
912
+ "n": 3,
913
+ "true_count": 0,
914
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
915
+ },
916
+ "audit_template_generated": {
917
+ "all_true": true,
918
+ "false_count": 0,
919
+ "n": 3,
920
+ "true_count": 3,
921
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
922
+ },
923
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
924
+ "all_true": false,
925
+ "false_count": 3,
926
+ "n": 3,
927
+ "true_count": 0,
928
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
929
+ },
930
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
931
+ "all_true": true,
932
+ "false_count": 0,
933
+ "n": 3,
934
+ "true_count": 3,
935
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
936
+ },
937
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
938
+ "all_true": false,
939
+ "false_count": 3,
940
+ "n": 3,
941
+ "true_count": 0,
942
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
943
+ },
944
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
945
+ "all_true": false,
946
+ "false_count": 3,
947
+ "n": 3,
948
+ "true_count": 0,
949
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
950
+ },
951
+ "scientific_evidence": {
952
+ "all_true": false,
953
+ "false_count": 3,
954
+ "n": 3,
955
+ "true_count": 0,
956
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
957
+ },
958
+ "snn_involved": {
959
+ "all_true": false,
960
+ "false_count": 3,
961
+ "n": 3,
962
+ "true_count": 0,
963
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
964
+ }
965
+ },
966
+ "metrics": {
967
+ "audit_item": {
968
+ "max": 1.0,
969
+ "mean": 1.0,
970
+ "median": 1.0,
971
+ "min": 1.0,
972
+ "n": 3,
973
+ "std": 0.0
974
+ }
975
+ },
976
+ "run_count": 3,
977
+ "seeds": [
978
+ 101,
979
+ 102,
980
+ 103
981
+ ]
982
+ },
983
+ "claim_boundary": {
984
+ "boolean_metrics": {
985
+ "audit_complete": {
986
+ "all_true": false,
987
+ "false_count": 3,
988
+ "n": 3,
989
+ "true_count": 0,
990
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
991
+ },
992
+ "audit_template_generated": {
993
+ "all_true": true,
994
+ "false_count": 0,
995
+ "n": 3,
996
+ "true_count": 3,
997
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
998
+ },
999
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1000
+ "all_true": false,
1001
+ "false_count": 3,
1002
+ "n": 3,
1003
+ "true_count": 0,
1004
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1005
+ },
1006
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1007
+ "all_true": true,
1008
+ "false_count": 0,
1009
+ "n": 3,
1010
+ "true_count": 3,
1011
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1012
+ },
1013
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1014
+ "all_true": false,
1015
+ "false_count": 3,
1016
+ "n": 3,
1017
+ "true_count": 0,
1018
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1019
+ },
1020
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1021
+ "all_true": false,
1022
+ "false_count": 3,
1023
+ "n": 3,
1024
+ "true_count": 0,
1025
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1026
+ },
1027
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1028
+ "all_true": false,
1029
+ "false_count": 3,
1030
+ "n": 3,
1031
+ "true_count": 0,
1032
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1033
+ },
1034
+ "snn_involved": {
1035
+ "all_true": false,
1036
+ "false_count": 3,
1037
+ "n": 3,
1038
+ "true_count": 0,
1039
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1040
+ }
1041
+ },
1042
+ "metrics": {
1043
+ "audit_item": {
1044
+ "max": 4.0,
1045
+ "mean": 4.0,
1046
+ "median": 4.0,
1047
+ "min": 4.0,
1048
+ "n": 3,
1049
+ "std": 0.0
1050
+ }
1051
+ },
1052
+ "run_count": 3,
1053
+ "seeds": [
1054
+ 101,
1055
+ 102,
1056
+ 103
1057
+ ]
1058
+ },
1059
+ "measurement_limit": {
1060
+ "boolean_metrics": {
1061
+ "audit_complete": {
1062
+ "all_true": false,
1063
+ "false_count": 3,
1064
+ "n": 3,
1065
+ "true_count": 0,
1066
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1067
+ },
1068
+ "audit_template_generated": {
1069
+ "all_true": true,
1070
+ "false_count": 0,
1071
+ "n": 3,
1072
+ "true_count": 3,
1073
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1074
+ },
1075
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1076
+ "all_true": false,
1077
+ "false_count": 3,
1078
+ "n": 3,
1079
+ "true_count": 0,
1080
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1081
+ },
1082
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1083
+ "all_true": true,
1084
+ "false_count": 0,
1085
+ "n": 3,
1086
+ "true_count": 3,
1087
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1088
+ },
1089
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1090
+ "all_true": false,
1091
+ "false_count": 3,
1092
+ "n": 3,
1093
+ "true_count": 0,
1094
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1095
+ },
1096
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1097
+ "all_true": false,
1098
+ "false_count": 3,
1099
+ "n": 3,
1100
+ "true_count": 0,
1101
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1102
+ },
1103
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1104
+ "all_true": false,
1105
+ "false_count": 3,
1106
+ "n": 3,
1107
+ "true_count": 0,
1108
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1109
+ },
1110
+ "snn_involved": {
1111
+ "all_true": false,
1112
+ "false_count": 3,
1113
+ "n": 3,
1114
+ "true_count": 0,
1115
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1116
+ }
1117
+ },
1118
+ "metrics": {
1119
+ "audit_item": {
1120
+ "max": 3.0,
1121
+ "mean": 3.0,
1122
+ "median": 3.0,
1123
+ "min": 3.0,
1124
+ "n": 3,
1125
+ "std": 0.0
1126
+ }
1127
+ },
1128
+ "run_count": 3,
1129
+ "seeds": [
1130
+ 101,
1131
+ 102,
1132
+ 103
1133
+ ]
1134
+ }
1135
+ },
1136
+ "formulas": {
1137
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
1138
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
1139
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
1140
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
1141
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
1142
+ },
1143
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
1144
+ "run_count": 12,
1145
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
1146
+ }
1147
+ ```
1148
+
1149
+ ## Observations
1150
+
1151
+ ```json
1152
+ []
1153
+ ```
1154
+
1155
+ ## Interpretation
1156
+
1157
+ ```json
1158
+ {
1159
+ "assessment": "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.",
1160
+ "observations": [],
1161
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1162
+ "Initial structured output invalid: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object.",
1163
+ "Repair attempt failed: ValueError: Ollama output must contain a JSON object."
1164
+ ],
1165
+ "alternative_explanations": [],
1166
+ "recommended_experiments": [],
1167
+ "requested_evidence": [
1168
+ "Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet."
1169
+ ],
1170
+ "effect_direction": "not_assessed",
1171
+ "confidence": 0.0
1172
+ }
1173
+ ```
1174
+
1175
+ ## Methodological Critique
1176
+
1177
+ ```json
1178
+ [
1179
+ "Die Experimente sind nicht reproduzierbar, da keine kontrollierten Variablen oder externe Validierung vorhanden sind.",
1180
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.",
1181
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.",
1182
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.",
1183
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.",
1184
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.",
1185
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.",
1186
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Tests.",
1187
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1188
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1189
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102."
1190
+ ]
1191
+ ```
1192
+
1193
+ ## Alternative Explanations
1194
+
1195
+ ```json
1196
+ [
1197
+ "Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.",
1198
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.",
1199
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.",
1200
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.",
1201
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.",
1202
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.",
1203
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Teste.",
1204
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1205
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.",
1206
+ "Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102."
1207
+ ]
1208
+ ```
1209
+
1210
+ ## Reproducibility
1211
+
1212
+ ```json
1213
+ {
1214
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1215
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1216
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1217
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1218
+ "source_freeze_sha": "a1f28e68beb3d8493ceef648d5f511ab7f7785ea2737a16108debb4be792b5f9",
1219
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1220
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1221
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "267de0649a0a3680e0c418fbd8fceb8821246b47b24151653b07ba71a86fd27f",
1222
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1223
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1224
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1225
+ "protocol_digest": "622198c6033cd292b6f6c328a171ab2180050df3bc04eafa10f421464199b920",
1226
+ "data_digest": "13a8a316c3f293ed74fd7eea77086285ba4f6eadbd84b4534f2c289af8a79e63",
1227
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1228
+ }
1229
+ ```
1230
+
1231
+ ## Epistemic Status
1232
+
1233
+ ```json
1234
+ {
1235
+ "implementation": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1236
+ "experiment_data": "PRESENT",
1237
+ "registered_evidence": "ABSENT",
1238
+ "ai_interpretation": "PRESENT",
1239
+ "human_review": "PENDING",
1240
+ "claim_support": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1241
+ "rq_status": "IN_PROGRESS",
1242
+ "semantic_alignment": "NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED",
1243
+ "semantic_note": "Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.",
1244
+ "design_adequacy": "NOT_ASSESSED",
1245
+ "design_note": "Für diese Forschungsfrage ist keine automatische Designadäquanz-Regel registriert.",
1246
+ "confidence_gate": "PASSED"
1247
+ }
1248
+ ```
1249
+
1250
+ ## Missing Evidence
1251
+
1252
+ ```json
1253
+ [
1254
+ "Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet."
1255
+ ]
1256
+ ```
1257
+
1258
+ ## Recommended Follow-up Experiments
1259
+
1260
+ ```json
1261
+ []
1262
+ ```
1263
+
1264
+ ## Conclusion
1265
+
1266
+ ```json
1267
+ "Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred."
1268
+ ```
1269
+
1270
+ ## Human Review
1271
+
1272
+ ```json
1273
+ {
1274
+ "status": "PENDING",
1275
+ "reviewer": null,
1276
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1277
+ "disposition": null,
1278
+ "comments": null
1279
+ }
1280
+ ```
1281
+
1282
+ AI confidence: 0.0
1283
+ This value describes internal AI confidence and is not a statistical confidence interval.
1284
+
1285
+ Content digest: 042332248acea804ccdbc978f65678d46c12e4991c0a7106b4a9c7005e1fc9a9
1286
+ JSON/Markdown link digest: 95e64bffefc53b0e1b81afb96d6d666e9a607e9812d49411e0c1c608460a6e07
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.review.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "report_id": "AIRR-2026-0001",
3
+ "review_status": "accepted_as_interpretation",
4
+ "reviewer": "Thomas Heisig",
5
+ "reviewed_at": "2026-10-02T18:21:57.278320+00:00",
6
+ "comments": "# Review: EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01\n\nMit dem zweiten Datensatz lässt sich nun ein **Vergleich** anstellen – und der zeigt sowohl Konsistenz als auch neue Befunde. Ich gliedere in: was gleich bleibt (bewusst), was neu ist (geplant), was neu problematisch ist (ungeplant).\n\n## ✅ Was konsistent bleibt (bewusst)\n\n### Provenienz-Kette bleibt sauber\n\n| Feld | PILOT2-01 | REMAINDER-01 |\n|---|---|---|\n| Code-Digest | `5a11ea28…` | `5a11ea28…` ✅ identisch |\n| Config-Digest | `6f6cd457…` | `6f6cd457…` ✅ identisch |\n| Prompt-Digest | `dd18e473…` | `dd18e473…` ✅ identisch |\n| Runner-Bytecode | `93e483e2…` | `93e483e2…` ✅ identisch |\n| Summary-Bytecode | `462bf872…` | `462bf872…` ✅ identisch |\n| Source/Runtime-Konsistenz | MATCH | MATCH ✅ |\n\nDas ist **methodisch vorbildlich**: Derselbe Runner, dieselbe Config, derselbe Code. Nur der Data-Digest und der Source-Freeze ändern sich – weil andere Runs und ein anderer Prompt-Paket-Stand.\n\n### Epistemische Struktur bleibt konsistent\n\n`epistemic_layers`, `execution_semantics`, `causal_card`, `validity` – alle identisch. Die semantische Grenze zwischen DATA und EVID bleibt gewahrt.\n\n### Boolean-Metriken bleiben identisch im Muster\n\n| Metrik | PILOT2 | REMAINDER |\n|---|---|---|\n| `audit_complete` | false (0/3) | false (0/3) |\n| `audit_template_generated` | true (3/3) | true (3/3) |\n| `automatic_evidence_promotion` | false | false |\n| `conceptual_or_normative` | true | true |\n| `native_empirical_experiment` | false | false |\n| `phenomenal_claim_identified` | false | false |\n| `scientific_evidence` | false | false |\n| `snn_involved` | false | false |\n\n**Interpretation**: Beide Datensätze sind konzeptuelle Audits mit identischem Semantik-Muster. Das ist die korrekte Konsistenz – keine stillen Abweichungen.\n\n## 🟠 Was neu ist – und was es bedeutet\n\n### Neu 1: AIRR-Provider-Output konnte nicht validiert werden\n\n```\n\"Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis;\nno scientific interpretation is inferred.\"\nKI-Konfidenz: `0.0`\n```\n\n**Das ist der wichtigste neue Befund.** Im ersten Datensatz war der AIRR-Output strukturiert:\n\n> „Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede zwischen den Bedingungen, da keine inferential Analysen durchgeführt wurden.\"\n\nIm zweiten Datensatz hat der Provider **keine validierbare strukturierte Analyse** geliefert. Das System erkennt das korrekt und setzt `KI-Konfidenz: 0.0`.\n\n**Bedeutung**: Das ist **kein Fehler**, sondern die **richtige Reaktion** auf einen Provider-Fehler. Der AIRR ist explizit als nicht-nutzbar markiert. Das ist methodisch sauber.\n\n**Frage**: Warum liefert der Provider beim zweiten Lauf kein strukturiertes Ergebnis? Das könnte ein Provider-seitiges Problem sein (Rate-Limit, Prompt-Problem, JSON-Parsing-Fehler) oder ein beabsichtigter Fallback.\n\n### Neu 2: Duplikate in der methodischen Kritik\n\n```\n- Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.\n- Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.\n- Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.\n```\n\n**Dreimal derselbe Satz.** Das ist ein **Generation-Bug** im AIRR-Provider oder im Post-Processing. Es ist kein wissenschaftliches Problem, aber es macht den Bericht schwerer lesbar.\n\n**Empfehlung**: Deduplizierungs-Schritt vor der AIRR-Persistierung.\n\n### Neu 3: `data`-Digest ist unterschiedlich (korrekt)\n\n| Feld | PILOT2 | REMAINDER |\n|---|---|---|\n| Data-Digest | `3cf94d48…` | `5be9d350…` |\n| Source-Freeze | `bac4e3d8…` | `a1f28e68…` |\n\nDas ist **korrekt**. Andere Runs → anderer Digest. Anderer Prompt-Paket-Stand → anderer Source-Freeze. Die Konsistenz der Code/Config-Digests bestätigt, dass nur die Daten variieren.\n\n### Neu 4: `REMAINDER` im Namen\n\nDer Name deutet auf einen **Folgelauf** hin. Das wirft eine Frage auf:\n\n- Ist `REMAINDER-01` eine **Wiederholung** von `PILOT2-01` mit anderem Seed?\n- Oder deckt er **andere Audit-Items** ab, die im ersten Lauf nicht enthalten waren?\n\nDie boolean-Metriken sind identisch, die `audit_item`-Werte sind identisch (2, 1, 4, 3 – in derselben Reihenfolge). Das deutet auf **dieselben Audit-Items** hin.\n\n**Kritische Frage**: Wenn `REMAINDER-01` dieselben Items prüft wie `PILOT2-01`, ist es keine Ergänzung, sondern eine **Wiederholung** – und damit **kein unabhängiges Replikat**.\n\n## 🔴 Neue und bestehende Probleme\n\n### Problem 1: `dirty: true` bleibt (bestehend)\n\n| Datensatz | dirty | ai_reproducibility |\n|---|---|---|\n| PILOT2-01 | true | R0 |\n| REMAINDER-01 | true | R0 |\n\n**Der Widerspruch bleibt in beiden Datensätzen.** Entweder ist `R0` falsch klassifiziert, oder `dirty: true` ist ein systematischer Zustand (z. B. die Experiment-Artefakte selbst sind untracked).\n\n**Empfehlung**: Die Ursache von `dirty: true` klären. Wenn es die Experiment-Outputs selbst sind (die typischerweise nicht committet werden), dann ist `dirty: true` irreführend und sollte durch ein differenzierteres Feld ersetzt werden, z. B.:\n\n```json\n\"git\": {\n \"branch\": \"develop\",\n \"commit\": \"1f489c97...\",\n \"tracked_dirty\": false,\n \"untracked_outputs\": true\n}\n```\n\n### Problem 2: `audit_complete=false` (bestehend)\n\nIn beiden Datensätzen ist `audit_complete` in allen Bedingungen `false`. Der `experiment_status` ist aber `completed`.\n\n**Frage**: Ist `audit_complete` der **inhaltliche** Audit-Abschluss, während `experiment_status` den **technischen** Lauf beschreibt? Wenn ja, sollte das in der Summary klar stehen.\n\n**Empfehlung**: Ein Feld wie `audit_status: \"template_only\"` oder ähnlich, das die semantische Lücke schließt.\n\n### Problem 3: RQ/Condition nicht zugeordnet\n\nIn beiden Datensätzen:\n\n```\nRQ/Condition-Pruefung: NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED\nEvidence Readiness: BLOCKED_UNCLASSIFIED_SEMANTICS\n```\n\n**Das ist der zentrale methodische Befund.** Für beide RQs (`RQ-CNS-101`, `RQ-CNS-102`) gibt es **keine automatische semantische Regel**. Deshalb kann keine EVID-Promotion stattfinden – auch wenn die technische Ausführung fehlerfrei ist.\n\n**Das ist korrekt und vorbildlich**: Das System blockiert sich selbst, weil die Semantik nicht zugeordnet ist. Das ist genau das Fail-Closed-Design, das MHRN auszeichnet.\n\n**Offene Frage**: Wer oder was registriert die semantische Regel für diese RQ-Familie? Ist das ein Human-Review-Schritt, oder soll das automatisch passieren?\n\n## 📊 Direkter Vergleich\n\n| Aspekt | PILOT2-01 | REMAINDER-01 |\n|---|---|---|\n| Experiment-ID | …PILOT2-01 | …REMAINDER-01 |\n| RQ | RQ-CNS-101 | RQ-CNS-102 |\n| Hypothese | H-CNS-101-A | H-CNS-102-A |\n| Protokoll | cog_cns_101_v1 | cog_cns_102_v1 |\n| Runner | run_cog_cns_101_v1 | run_cog_cns_102_v1 |\n| Code-Digest | `5a11ea28…` | `5a11ea28…` ✅ |\n| Config-Digest | `6f6cd457…` | `6f6cd457…` ✅ |\n| Data-Digest | `3cf94d48…` | `5be9d350…` |\n| Source-Freeze | `bac4e3d8…` | `a1f28e68…` |\n| AIRR-Output | strukturiert | **nicht validierbar** |\n| KI-Konfidenz | 0.55 | 0.0 |\n| Audit-Items | 2, 1, 4, 3 | 2, 1, 4, 3 |\n| Boolean-Metriken | identisch | identisch |\n| dirty | true | true |\n| R0 | ja | ja |\n\n**Zentrale Beobachtung**: Die beiden Datensätze sind **strukturell identisch** – nur RQ/H/Protokoll sind inkrementiert. Das legt nahe, dass `REMAINDER-01` eine **Fortsetzung** ist, nicht ein unabhängiges Experiment.\n\n## 🎯 Empfehlungen\n\n### Priorität 1 – Provenienz klären\n\n1. **`dirty: true` Ursache finden**: Ist es der Working Tree oder untracked Outputs?\n2. **`ai_reproducibility` anpassen**: Wenn `dirty: true` systematisch, dann `R0` überdenken.\n3. **`runs_index_sha256` hinzufügen**: Master-Hash über den Index.\n\n### Priorität 2 – Semantik klären\n\n1. **`audit_complete` erklären**: Warum false, obwohl Status completed?\n2. **`NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED` adressieren**: Wer registriert die semantische Regel?\n3. **`REMAINDER`-Bedeutung dokumentieren**: Ergänzung oder Wiederholung?\n\n### Priorität 3 – AIRR reparieren\n\n1. **Provider-Validierung prüfen**: Warum kein strukturierter Output?\n2. **Duplikate filtern**: Deduplizierung vor Persistierung.\n3. **Fallback dokumentieren**: Wenn Provider fehlschlägt, was ist der erwartete Zustand?\n\n### Priorität 4 – Frontend\n\nDie UI zeigt weiterhin „—\" für Protokoll, Seeds, Ticks, Bedingungen – obwohl das Manifest Werte enthält. Der Renderer liest aus falschen Pfaden.\n\n## 💎 Fazit\n\nDie beiden Datensätze bilden zusammen ein **kohärentes Bild**:\n\n**Was sie sind**:\n- Zwei technisch saubere, deterministische Batch-Läufe mit identischem Code und identischer Config.\n- Zwei methodisch disziplinierte Erfassungen ohne EVID-Promotion.\n- Zwei korrekt blockierte Audits wegen fehlender semantischer Zuordnung.\n\n**Was sie nicht sind**:\n- Keine unabhängigen Replikate (Code/Config identisch).\n- Keine empirischen SNN-Läufe (`snn_involved: false`).\n- Keine abgeschlossenen Audits (`audit_complete: false`).\n- Keine wissenschaftliche Evidenz (`scientific_evidence: false`).\n\n**Der wichtigste neue Befund**: Der AIRR-Provider hat beim zweiten Lauf **keinen validierbaren strukturierten Output** geliefert. Das System hat korrekt reagiert (KI-Konfidenz 0.0, expliziter Hinweis). Aber es wirft die Frage auf, ob der AIRR-Provider stabil genug ist für Batch-Läufe.\n\n**Der wichtigste bestehende Befund**: `dirty: true` + `R0` bleibt ein **echter Provenienz-Widerspruch** – in beiden Datensätzen. Vor jeder weiteren Verwendung sollte das geklärt werden.\n\n**Ein Satz zum Mitnehmen**: Die beiden Datensätze sind **methodisch sauber** und **inhaltlich konsistent**. Die verbleibenden Probleme sind **dokumentarisch** (dirty, audit_complete, REMAINDER-Semantik) und **provider-seitig** (AIRR-Output) – nicht strukturell. Nach ihrer Behebung sind sie belastbare Bausteine für die Batch-Audit-Pipeline.",
7
+ "report_content_digest": "042332248acea804ccdbc978f65678d46c12e4991c0a7106b4a9c7005e1fc9a9"
8
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/summary.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,215 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01: Wissenschaftliche Zusammenfassung
2
+
3
+ Diese Zusammenfassung wird deterministisch aus Manifest, Workflow, DATA und — sofern vorhanden — dem AIRR aufgebaut. Zahlen und Formeln stammen aus den gespeicherten Laufdaten beziehungsweise dem deterministischen Statistics Engine; KI-Text bleibt davon getrennt.
4
+
5
+ ## 1. Identifikation und Status
6
+
7
+ - Experimentstatus: `completed`
8
+ - Forschungsfrage: `RQ-CNS-102`
9
+ - Hypothese: `H-CNS-102-A`
10
+ - Protokoll: `cog_cns_102_v1`
11
+ - Durchlaeufe: `12`
12
+ - Seeds: `[101, 102, 103]`
13
+ - Angeforderte Ticks: `1`
14
+ - Tickgebundene SNN-Läufe (PING/TEMP/5D): `nicht direkt messbar .. nicht direkt messbar` ausgeführte Ticks
15
+ - Tick-Vertrag: `NOT_APPLICABLE`
16
+ - TIME-Ladder: Der angeforderte Endpunkt wird je Seed separat validiert; Zwischenstufen duerfen kleiner sein.
17
+ - Trial-/Regulationsprotokolle: Interne Versuchszyklen sind nicht mit `ticks_executed` gleichzusetzen und werden nicht in die SNN-Tickspanne eingerechnet.
18
+ - Laufmodus: `EXPLORATORY`
19
+ - Netzwerkmodus: `OFFLINE`
20
+
21
+ ## 2. Semantische Konsistenz
22
+
23
+ - RQ/Condition-Pruefung: `NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED`
24
+ - Evidence Readiness: `BLOCKED_UNCLASSIFIED_SEMANTICS`
25
+ - Begründung: Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.
26
+ - Beobachtete Conditions: `alternative_model, assumption_explicit, claim_boundary, measurement_limit`
27
+
28
+ `DIRECT_MATCH` bezeichnet einen gezielten RQ-spezifischen Lauf. `CONTAINS_MATCH` bedeutet, dass die passende Teilstudie innerhalb einer Gesamtsuite enthalten ist; nur diese Teilstudie ist primaer fuer die registrierte RQ auszuwerten. `MISMATCH` blockiert die Nutzung als Evidenz fuer die registrierte Forschungsfrage, auch wenn die technische Ausfuehrung fehlerfrei war.
29
+
30
+ ## 3. Ausfuehrungsparameter
31
+
32
+ - Titel: Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_102_v1
33
+ - Bedingungen: frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract
34
+ - Notizen: Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.
35
+ - Konfiguration: `F:\Brain-5D\configs\learning_experiment.yaml`
36
+ - Config SHA-256: `6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c`
37
+ - Git Commit: `1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3`
38
+ - Git dirty: `True`
39
+ - Runtime: `0.010705600026994944` s
40
+
41
+ ## 4. Deterministische Formeln
42
+
43
+ Die im Bericht verwendeten deskriptiven Groessen sind:
44
+
45
+ - Mittelwert: `mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i`
46
+ - Populationsstandardabweichung: `sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)`
47
+ - Absolute Differenz: `Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)`
48
+ - Verhältnis: `R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A)` fuer `mean(x_A) != 0`
49
+ - Inter-Spike-Intervall: `ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i`
50
+
51
+ Diese Formeln sind deskriptiv. Ohne registrierten Inferenztest, unabhaengige Stichprobenannahme und passende Versuchsplanung werden daraus keine Signifikanz- oder Kausalbehauptungen abgeleitet.
52
+
53
+ ## 5. Ergebnisse nach Bedingung
54
+
55
+ | Condition | n | Seeds | Ticks mean | Spikes mean | Syn. events mean | Aktivierte Neuronen mean | Recurrent events mean | Propagation depth mean |
56
+ | --- | ---: | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
57
+ | alternative_model | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
58
+ | assumption_explicit | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
59
+ | claim_boundary | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
60
+ | measurement_limit | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
61
+
62
+ **Wichtig:** `—` bedeutet in dieser Tabelle ausschließlich, dass die jeweilige SNN-Metrik für diese Bedingung nicht definiert oder nicht erhoben wird. Es bedeutet **nicht**, dass für die Bedingung keine DATA vorliegen. Protokollspezifische Messwerte werden direkt darunter ausgewiesen.
63
+
64
+ ### 5.1 Protokollspezifische Metrikabdeckung
65
+
66
+ | Condition | zusätzliche numerische Mittelwerte |
67
+ | --- | --- |
68
+ | alternative_model | `audit_item=2` |
69
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_item=1` |
70
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_item=4` |
71
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_item=3` |
72
+
73
+ #### Primäre und weitere boolesche Endpunkte
74
+
75
+ | Condition | Outcome | n | true | false | all_true |
76
+ | --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |
77
+ | alternative_model | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
78
+ | alternative_model | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
79
+ | alternative_model | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
80
+ | alternative_model | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
81
+ | alternative_model | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
82
+ | alternative_model | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
83
+ | alternative_model | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
84
+ | alternative_model | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
85
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
86
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
87
+ | assumption_explicit | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
88
+ | assumption_explicit | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
89
+ | assumption_explicit | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
90
+ | assumption_explicit | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
91
+ | assumption_explicit | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
92
+ | assumption_explicit | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
93
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
94
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
95
+ | claim_boundary | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
96
+ | claim_boundary | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
97
+ | claim_boundary | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
98
+ | claim_boundary | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
99
+ | claim_boundary | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
100
+ | claim_boundary | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
101
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
102
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
103
+ | measurement_limit | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
104
+ | measurement_limit | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
105
+ | measurement_limit | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
106
+ | measurement_limit | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
107
+ | measurement_limit | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
108
+ | measurement_limit | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
109
+
110
+ ## 6. Einzelne Läufe
111
+
112
+ | Seed | Condition | Ticks | Spikes | Syn. events | Aktivierte Neuronen | Recurrent events | Depth | Runtime error |
113
+ | ---: | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |
114
+ | 101 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
115
+ | 101 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
116
+ | 101 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
117
+ | 101 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
118
+ | 102 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
119
+ | 102 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
120
+ | 102 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
121
+ | 102 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
122
+ | 103 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
123
+ | 103 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
124
+ | 103 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
125
+ | 103 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
126
+
127
+ ## 7. Reproduzierbarkeit und Provenienz
128
+
129
+ Identische Ausgaben ueber mehrere Seeds dokumentieren reproduzierbare Modelltrajektorien unter diesen Bedingungen. Sie sind nicht automatisch statistisch unabhaengige Replikate. State-Digests sind Integritaets-/Identitaetsmarker und keine metrischen Zustandsabstaende.
130
+
131
+ Deterministische Statistikdatei: `analysis/statistics.json`
132
+
133
+ ## 8. AI Research Report
134
+
135
+ - AIRR Status: `generated`
136
+ - Wissenschaftliche Evidenz durch KI: `false`
137
+ - Human Review: `PENDING`
138
+ - AIRR Markdown: `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md`
139
+ - AIRR JSON: `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json`
140
+
141
+ ### 8.1 KI-Einschaetzung
142
+
143
+ Provider output could not be validated as structured analysis; no scientific interpretation is inferred.
144
+
145
+ KI-Konfidenz: `0.0` — dies ist keine statistische Konfidenz.
146
+
147
+ ### Methodische Kritik
148
+
149
+ - Die Experimente sind nicht reproduzierbar, da keine kontrollierten Variablen oder externe Validierung vorhanden sind.
150
+ - Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.
151
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.
152
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.
153
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.
154
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.
155
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.
156
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Tests.
157
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.
158
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.
159
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.
160
+
161
+ ### Alternative Erklaerungen
162
+
163
+ - Die audit_item-Werte sind in allen Bedingungen konstant, was auf eine fehlende Varianz in den Daten hinweist.
164
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine inferenziellen Analysen oder deterministischen Ergebnisse, was eine Interpretation der Ergebnisse erschwert.
165
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine wissenschaftlichen Beweise, die auf die Hypothese H-CNS-102-A verweisen.
166
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine externe Review-Informationen oder ethische Genehmigungen.
167
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Datenpartitionen oder Validierungsdaten.
168
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine automatische Beweisverstärkung oder menschliche Bewertung.
169
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine direkten kausalen Experimente oder empirischen SNN-Teste.
170
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.
171
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.
172
+ - Die Forschungspakete enthalten keine Antwort auf die Forschungsfrage RQ-CNS-102.
173
+
174
+ ### Fehlende Nachweise
175
+
176
+ - Repeat provider analysis from the same immutable research packet.
177
+
178
+ ### Empfohlene Folgeexperimente
179
+
180
+ - Keine expliziten Folgeexperimente im AIRR angegeben.
181
+
182
+ ## 9. Artefakte
183
+
184
+ - `analysis/ai_packet.json`
185
+ - `analysis/ai_packet_digest.json`
186
+ - `analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212114421558-0fc176ff.json`
187
+ - `analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001211934552323-0fc176ff.json`
188
+ - `analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212304545660-0fc176ff.json`
189
+ - `analysis/statistics.json`
190
+ - `DATA/current_run.json`
191
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz`
192
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz`
193
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz`
194
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz`
195
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz`
196
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz`
197
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz`
198
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz`
199
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz`
200
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz`
201
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz`
202
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz`
203
+ - `DATA/runs_compact.json`
204
+ - `DATA/runs_index.json`
205
+ - `manifest.json`
206
+ - `report.md`
207
+ - `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json`
208
+ - `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md`
209
+ - `workflow.json`
210
+
211
+ ## 10. Wissenschaftliche Grenze und Schlussfolgerung
212
+
213
+ Die technischen Laufdaten duerfen deskriptiv ausgewertet werden. Eine Hypothese gilt dadurch nicht automatisch als bestaetigt oder widerlegt. Kausale Aussagen sind nur fuer explizit kontrollierte Interventionen und nur innerhalb des simulierten Systems zulaessig; biologische Generalisierung erfordert zusaetzliche Evidenz. Die KI-Auswertung ist post-hoc und besitzt keine Evidenzfreigabe.
214
+
215
+ **Gesamtstatus:** technische Ausfuehrung `completed`, Tick-Vertrag `NOT_APPLICABLE`, semantische Zuordnung `NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED`, wissenschaftliche Evidenz `false` bis zur menschlichen Review/Freigabe.
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01/workflow.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-01",
3
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-102",
4
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-102-A",
5
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_102_v1",
6
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
7
+ "ticks": 1,
8
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
9
+ "seeds": [
10
+ 101,
11
+ 102,
12
+ 103
13
+ ],
14
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_102_v1",
15
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_102_v1",
16
+ "tick_validation": {
17
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
18
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
19
+ "requested_ticks": 1
20
+ },
21
+ "notes": "Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
22
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
23
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
24
+ "epistemic_layers": {
25
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
26
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
27
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
28
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
29
+ }
30
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/DATA/current_run.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "last_archived_run": 11,
3
+ "raw_artifact": {
4
+ "format": "json.gz",
5
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
6
+ "sha256": "4ce7011d1170d35a87339351d1a2a3937ce99ec12a859dcc78c1c843a3003a9f",
7
+ "size_bytes": 517,
8
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
9
+ },
10
+ "status": "idle"
11
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/DATA/runs_compact.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,374 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ [
2
+ {
3
+ "_raw_artifact": {
4
+ "format": "json.gz",
5
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
6
+ "sha256": "57995dbbf923c83ba027ae13f628d9bc7494a0e4bccbb478333d432205e5fd03",
7
+ "size_bytes": 525,
8
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
9
+ },
10
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
11
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
12
+ "metrics": {
13
+ "audit_complete": false,
14
+ "audit_item": 1,
15
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
16
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
17
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
18
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
19
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
20
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
21
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
22
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
23
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
24
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
25
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
26
+ "snn_involved": false
27
+ },
28
+ "runtime_error": null,
29
+ "seed": 101,
30
+ "state_digest_after": "3facf879e515c8168e512133acac6dd23b9768453c18032a480a21738b4678d1",
31
+ "state_digest_before": "3facf879e515c8168e512133acac6dd23b9768453c18032a480a21738b4678d1"
32
+ },
33
+ {
34
+ "_raw_artifact": {
35
+ "format": "json.gz",
36
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
37
+ "sha256": "74100a7069f39de4bb4b81a4673ad3f623e5fad456276d56af48fb4e49bee539",
38
+ "size_bytes": 521,
39
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
40
+ },
41
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
42
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
43
+ "metrics": {
44
+ "audit_complete": false,
45
+ "audit_item": 2,
46
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
47
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
48
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
49
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
50
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
51
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
52
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
53
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
54
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
55
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
56
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
57
+ "snn_involved": false
58
+ },
59
+ "runtime_error": null,
60
+ "seed": 101,
61
+ "state_digest_after": "7c0489a18ccda3ddc27319a734aea3ce84570f40050a211b097b92f81fb397cc",
62
+ "state_digest_before": "7c0489a18ccda3ddc27319a734aea3ce84570f40050a211b097b92f81fb397cc"
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "_raw_artifact": {
66
+ "format": "json.gz",
67
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
68
+ "sha256": "7a28fdce82f24f1fd9076591d9413347c7ad927fc3de3cdbc088635ef321e69b",
69
+ "size_bytes": 520,
70
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
71
+ },
72
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
73
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
74
+ "metrics": {
75
+ "audit_complete": false,
76
+ "audit_item": 3,
77
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
78
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
79
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
80
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
81
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
82
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
83
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
84
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
85
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
86
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
87
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
88
+ "snn_involved": false
89
+ },
90
+ "runtime_error": null,
91
+ "seed": 101,
92
+ "state_digest_after": "f4e9664aa1cfac4df986899ed5f28dad27e31eb2278b54c1beec233cf3c90148",
93
+ "state_digest_before": "f4e9664aa1cfac4df986899ed5f28dad27e31eb2278b54c1beec233cf3c90148"
94
+ },
95
+ {
96
+ "_raw_artifact": {
97
+ "format": "json.gz",
98
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
99
+ "sha256": "e97356ef9df242bcb4bbb00cafe25a11362d56577c195feecc33cbc5c560f6bc",
100
+ "size_bytes": 514,
101
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
102
+ },
103
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
104
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
105
+ "metrics": {
106
+ "audit_complete": false,
107
+ "audit_item": 4,
108
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
109
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
110
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
111
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
112
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
113
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
114
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
115
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
116
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
117
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
118
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
119
+ "snn_involved": false
120
+ },
121
+ "runtime_error": null,
122
+ "seed": 101,
123
+ "state_digest_after": "55e11537a1163df39baacdf679cce8712f276e3052a5cbeff110d303dd788f67",
124
+ "state_digest_before": "55e11537a1163df39baacdf679cce8712f276e3052a5cbeff110d303dd788f67"
125
+ },
126
+ {
127
+ "_raw_artifact": {
128
+ "format": "json.gz",
129
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
130
+ "sha256": "64aba07cd48458a6a2e7b4129669489f09b5918579c95d2cbfffdb3652f14e91",
131
+ "size_bytes": 524,
132
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
133
+ },
134
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
135
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
136
+ "metrics": {
137
+ "audit_complete": false,
138
+ "audit_item": 1,
139
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
140
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
141
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
142
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
143
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
144
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
145
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
146
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
147
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
148
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
149
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
150
+ "snn_involved": false
151
+ },
152
+ "runtime_error": null,
153
+ "seed": 102,
154
+ "state_digest_after": "28dc2f759d9be275a7af979adda4b9d62eae9ba188eb62ae66ae61ec57e03029",
155
+ "state_digest_before": "28dc2f759d9be275a7af979adda4b9d62eae9ba188eb62ae66ae61ec57e03029"
156
+ },
157
+ {
158
+ "_raw_artifact": {
159
+ "format": "json.gz",
160
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
161
+ "sha256": "b46852a23f99f6065d0c15af9b7ce8a5a3cedc47752c579509ea6451d16ce958",
162
+ "size_bytes": 520,
163
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
164
+ },
165
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
166
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
167
+ "metrics": {
168
+ "audit_complete": false,
169
+ "audit_item": 2,
170
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
171
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
172
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
173
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
174
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
175
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
176
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
177
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
178
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
179
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
180
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
181
+ "snn_involved": false
182
+ },
183
+ "runtime_error": null,
184
+ "seed": 102,
185
+ "state_digest_after": "c2e57a9288669ab58c1ae658f21cae38c121608835b36d36259c5b927209bc00",
186
+ "state_digest_before": "c2e57a9288669ab58c1ae658f21cae38c121608835b36d36259c5b927209bc00"
187
+ },
188
+ {
189
+ "_raw_artifact": {
190
+ "format": "json.gz",
191
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
192
+ "sha256": "ed42b90c8d82d15c3ad057ea1a9a49895662fa1d077106caa22f0edced8108a6",
193
+ "size_bytes": 520,
194
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
195
+ },
196
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
197
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
198
+ "metrics": {
199
+ "audit_complete": false,
200
+ "audit_item": 3,
201
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
202
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
203
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
204
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
205
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
206
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
207
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
208
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
209
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
210
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
211
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
212
+ "snn_involved": false
213
+ },
214
+ "runtime_error": null,
215
+ "seed": 102,
216
+ "state_digest_after": "d11a131b2610419bfa8247b3ac00129bf73dff3f2149ac8b7f4aca5d9c31c10f",
217
+ "state_digest_before": "d11a131b2610419bfa8247b3ac00129bf73dff3f2149ac8b7f4aca5d9c31c10f"
218
+ },
219
+ {
220
+ "_raw_artifact": {
221
+ "format": "json.gz",
222
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
223
+ "sha256": "a0515313f2b98a429c431843b72264bc7bb61f11bf402834713f2971c7b6895f",
224
+ "size_bytes": 516,
225
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
226
+ },
227
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
228
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
229
+ "metrics": {
230
+ "audit_complete": false,
231
+ "audit_item": 4,
232
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
233
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
234
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
235
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
236
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
237
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
238
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
239
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
240
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
241
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
242
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
243
+ "snn_involved": false
244
+ },
245
+ "runtime_error": null,
246
+ "seed": 102,
247
+ "state_digest_after": "c52bea79aa4852a82ccb4d035294f50ae2564223c55e48696356aad7a77f52a2",
248
+ "state_digest_before": "c52bea79aa4852a82ccb4d035294f50ae2564223c55e48696356aad7a77f52a2"
249
+ },
250
+ {
251
+ "_raw_artifact": {
252
+ "format": "json.gz",
253
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
254
+ "sha256": "eb8e0b0fbf849cdcf65629f2e7d04e9aeb69d3b5d31ee375551684c7b465d843",
255
+ "size_bytes": 526,
256
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
257
+ },
258
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
259
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
260
+ "metrics": {
261
+ "audit_complete": false,
262
+ "audit_item": 1,
263
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
264
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
265
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
266
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
267
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
268
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
269
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
270
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
271
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
272
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
273
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
274
+ "snn_involved": false
275
+ },
276
+ "runtime_error": null,
277
+ "seed": 103,
278
+ "state_digest_after": "47b8a9e85e3f10c15cabbe719b218485293644c6887bf9961e5f4003f413ca77",
279
+ "state_digest_before": "47b8a9e85e3f10c15cabbe719b218485293644c6887bf9961e5f4003f413ca77"
280
+ },
281
+ {
282
+ "_raw_artifact": {
283
+ "format": "json.gz",
284
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
285
+ "sha256": "db1de0e235657617ce755d48ebd81f0051c76359691e1dea087de910ff29a68c",
286
+ "size_bytes": 519,
287
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
288
+ },
289
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
290
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
291
+ "metrics": {
292
+ "audit_complete": false,
293
+ "audit_item": 2,
294
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
295
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
296
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
297
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
298
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
299
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
300
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
301
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
302
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
303
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
304
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
305
+ "snn_involved": false
306
+ },
307
+ "runtime_error": null,
308
+ "seed": 103,
309
+ "state_digest_after": "ce7a03e9a37d39949eb6eec32fa6e018e43c9095e5680638d9fe0a86cb427153",
310
+ "state_digest_before": "ce7a03e9a37d39949eb6eec32fa6e018e43c9095e5680638d9fe0a86cb427153"
311
+ },
312
+ {
313
+ "_raw_artifact": {
314
+ "format": "json.gz",
315
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
316
+ "sha256": "c5361d083e3184ddd2b0f663fd0b410a7496e139799ea6fac763aec9fee5cc61",
317
+ "size_bytes": 521,
318
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
319
+ },
320
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
321
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
322
+ "metrics": {
323
+ "audit_complete": false,
324
+ "audit_item": 3,
325
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
326
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
327
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
328
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
329
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
330
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
331
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
332
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
333
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
334
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
335
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
336
+ "snn_involved": false
337
+ },
338
+ "runtime_error": null,
339
+ "seed": 103,
340
+ "state_digest_after": "8badc1585f187a7b840231216fa7da37148c2cb26f7aac521daf68ad3c909453",
341
+ "state_digest_before": "8badc1585f187a7b840231216fa7da37148c2cb26f7aac521daf68ad3c909453"
342
+ },
343
+ {
344
+ "_raw_artifact": {
345
+ "format": "json.gz",
346
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
347
+ "sha256": "4ce7011d1170d35a87339351d1a2a3937ce99ec12a859dcc78c1c843a3003a9f",
348
+ "size_bytes": 517,
349
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
350
+ },
351
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
352
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
353
+ "metrics": {
354
+ "audit_complete": false,
355
+ "audit_item": 4,
356
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
357
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
358
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
359
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
360
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
361
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
362
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
363
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
364
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
365
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
366
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
367
+ "snn_involved": false
368
+ },
369
+ "runtime_error": null,
370
+ "seed": 103,
371
+ "state_digest_after": "24ab478280b801364482455f3458bbd413b886cc8b927fcfbb815ebdd5083210",
372
+ "state_digest_before": "24ab478280b801364482455f3458bbd413b886cc8b927fcfbb815ebdd5083210"
373
+ }
374
+ ]
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/DATA/runs_index.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,127 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "run_count": 12,
3
+ "runs": [
4
+ {
5
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
6
+ "format": "json.gz",
7
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
8
+ "run_index": 0,
9
+ "seed": 101,
10
+ "sha256": "57995dbbf923c83ba027ae13f628d9bc7494a0e4bccbb478333d432205e5fd03",
11
+ "size_bytes": 525,
12
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
13
+ },
14
+ {
15
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
16
+ "format": "json.gz",
17
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
18
+ "run_index": 1,
19
+ "seed": 101,
20
+ "sha256": "74100a7069f39de4bb4b81a4673ad3f623e5fad456276d56af48fb4e49bee539",
21
+ "size_bytes": 521,
22
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
23
+ },
24
+ {
25
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
26
+ "format": "json.gz",
27
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
28
+ "run_index": 2,
29
+ "seed": 101,
30
+ "sha256": "7a28fdce82f24f1fd9076591d9413347c7ad927fc3de3cdbc088635ef321e69b",
31
+ "size_bytes": 520,
32
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
33
+ },
34
+ {
35
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
36
+ "format": "json.gz",
37
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
38
+ "run_index": 3,
39
+ "seed": 101,
40
+ "sha256": "e97356ef9df242bcb4bbb00cafe25a11362d56577c195feecc33cbc5c560f6bc",
41
+ "size_bytes": 514,
42
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
43
+ },
44
+ {
45
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
46
+ "format": "json.gz",
47
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
48
+ "run_index": 4,
49
+ "seed": 102,
50
+ "sha256": "64aba07cd48458a6a2e7b4129669489f09b5918579c95d2cbfffdb3652f14e91",
51
+ "size_bytes": 524,
52
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
53
+ },
54
+ {
55
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
56
+ "format": "json.gz",
57
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
58
+ "run_index": 5,
59
+ "seed": 102,
60
+ "sha256": "b46852a23f99f6065d0c15af9b7ce8a5a3cedc47752c579509ea6451d16ce958",
61
+ "size_bytes": 520,
62
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
66
+ "format": "json.gz",
67
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
68
+ "run_index": 6,
69
+ "seed": 102,
70
+ "sha256": "ed42b90c8d82d15c3ad057ea1a9a49895662fa1d077106caa22f0edced8108a6",
71
+ "size_bytes": 520,
72
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
73
+ },
74
+ {
75
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
76
+ "format": "json.gz",
77
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
78
+ "run_index": 7,
79
+ "seed": 102,
80
+ "sha256": "a0515313f2b98a429c431843b72264bc7bb61f11bf402834713f2971c7b6895f",
81
+ "size_bytes": 516,
82
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
83
+ },
84
+ {
85
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
86
+ "format": "json.gz",
87
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
88
+ "run_index": 8,
89
+ "seed": 103,
90
+ "sha256": "eb8e0b0fbf849cdcf65629f2e7d04e9aeb69d3b5d31ee375551684c7b465d843",
91
+ "size_bytes": 526,
92
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
93
+ },
94
+ {
95
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
96
+ "format": "json.gz",
97
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
98
+ "run_index": 9,
99
+ "seed": 103,
100
+ "sha256": "db1de0e235657617ce755d48ebd81f0051c76359691e1dea087de910ff29a68c",
101
+ "size_bytes": 519,
102
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
103
+ },
104
+ {
105
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
106
+ "format": "json.gz",
107
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
108
+ "run_index": 10,
109
+ "seed": 103,
110
+ "sha256": "c5361d083e3184ddd2b0f663fd0b410a7496e139799ea6fac763aec9fee5cc61",
111
+ "size_bytes": 521,
112
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
113
+ },
114
+ {
115
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
116
+ "format": "json.gz",
117
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
118
+ "run_index": 11,
119
+ "seed": 103,
120
+ "sha256": "4ce7011d1170d35a87339351d1a2a3937ce99ec12a859dcc78c1c843a3003a9f",
121
+ "size_bytes": 517,
122
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
123
+ }
124
+ ],
125
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
126
+ "storage_policy": "immutable_raw_runs_plus_compact_current_experiment"
127
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212516252293-09c3f8b9.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,96 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212516252293-09c3f8b9",
3
+ "role": "critical_reviewer",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
17
+ "packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.",
21
+ "confidence": 0.05,
22
+ "effect_direction": "Es wurden keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung beobachtet, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden.",
23
+ "methodological_concerns": [
24
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
25
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
26
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
27
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
28
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
29
+ ],
30
+ "observations": [
31
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 3 für 'measurement_limit' und 4 für 'claim_boundary'.",
32
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
33
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
34
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
35
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
36
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
37
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
38
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
39
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
40
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
41
+ ],
42
+ "alternative_explanations": [
43
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
44
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
45
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
46
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
47
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
48
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
49
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
50
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
51
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
52
+ ],
53
+ "recommended_experiments": [
54
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
55
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
56
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
57
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
58
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
59
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
60
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
61
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
62
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
63
+ ],
64
+ "requested_evidence": [
65
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
66
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
67
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
68
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
69
+ "Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
70
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
71
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
72
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
73
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
74
+ ]
75
+ },
76
+ "provenance": {
77
+ "prompt_sha256": "e5fa179046d1de57b4e10be091e795bfacadb368147f5137f0fee93b3acd84ce",
78
+ "research_packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad",
79
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
80
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
81
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
82
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.05"
83
+ },
84
+ "epistemic_status": {
85
+ "evidence": false,
86
+ "interpretation_only": true,
87
+ "human_review_required": true
88
+ },
89
+ "review": {
90
+ "status": "pending",
91
+ "reviewer": null,
92
+ "reviewed_at": null,
93
+ "disposition": null
94
+ },
95
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:25:16.252293+00:00"
96
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001212341683225-09c3f8b9.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,96 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001212341683225-09c3f8b9",
3
+ "role": "scientific_analyst",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
17
+ "packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede in der diskriminativen Leistung unter den untersuchten Bedingungen. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten. Die Ergebnisse sind daher beschreibend und nicht inferenzfähig.",
21
+ "observations": [
22
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 4 für 'claim_boundary' und 3 für 'measurement_limit'.",
23
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
24
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
25
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
26
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
27
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
28
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
29
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
30
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
31
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
32
+ ],
33
+ "effect_direction": "Es wurden keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung beobachtet, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden.",
34
+ "methodological_concerns": [
35
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
36
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
37
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
38
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
39
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
40
+ ],
41
+ "alternative_explanations": [
42
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
43
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
44
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
45
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
46
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
47
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
48
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
49
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
50
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metri, die auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt sind, könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
51
+ ],
52
+ "recommended_experiments": [
53
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
54
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
55
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
56
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
57
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
58
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
59
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
60
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
61
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
62
+ ],
63
+ "requested_evidence": [
64
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
65
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
66
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
67
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
68
+ "Daten, die die native_emp, experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
69
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
70
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
71
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
72
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
73
+ ],
74
+ "confidence": 0.05
75
+ },
76
+ "provenance": {
77
+ "prompt_sha256": "820c08ed34e159fb2231e924512b613e9a4ccc5d769e6bff25b8c9fe89dabf51",
78
+ "research_packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad",
79
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
80
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
81
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
82
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.05"
83
+ },
84
+ "epistemic_status": {
85
+ "evidence": false,
86
+ "interpretation_only": true,
87
+ "human_review_required": true
88
+ },
89
+ "review": {
90
+ "status": "pending",
91
+ "reviewer": null,
92
+ "reviewed_at": null,
93
+ "disposition": null
94
+ },
95
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:23:41.683225+00:00"
96
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212701063609-09c3f8b9.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,96 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212701063609-09c3f8b9",
3
+ "role": "scientific_writer",
4
+ "model": {
5
+ "provider": "ollama",
6
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
7
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
8
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
9
+ "context_length": "unknown",
10
+ "temperature": 0.0,
11
+ "top_p": 0.9,
12
+ "seed": "not_reported",
13
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
14
+ },
15
+ "inputs": {
16
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
17
+ "packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad"
18
+ },
19
+ "output": {
20
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.",
21
+ "confidence": 0.05,
22
+ "effect_direction": "Es wurden keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung beobachtet, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden.",
23
+ "methodological_concerns": [
24
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
25
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
26
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
27
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
28
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
29
+ ],
30
+ "observations": [
31
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 3 für 'measurement_limit' und 4 für 'claim_boundary'.",
32
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
33
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
34
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
35
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
36
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
37
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
38
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
39
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
40
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
41
+ ],
42
+ "alternative_explanations": [
43
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
44
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
45
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
46
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
47
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
48
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
49
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
50
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
51
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
52
+ ],
53
+ "recommended_experiments": [
54
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
55
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
56
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
57
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
58
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
59
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
60
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
61
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
62
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
63
+ ],
64
+ "requested_evidence": [
65
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
66
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
67
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
68
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
69
+ "Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
70
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
71
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
72
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
73
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
74
+ ]
75
+ },
76
+ "provenance": {
77
+ "prompt_sha256": "bc6e29d6f427d0ead99f2fa120a91cc6f11cbdc7edee71e326cc06f2bb14e1f9",
78
+ "research_packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad",
79
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
80
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
81
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
82
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.05"
83
+ },
84
+ "epistemic_status": {
85
+ "evidence": false,
86
+ "interpretation_only": true,
87
+ "human_review_required": true
88
+ },
89
+ "review": {
90
+ "status": "pending",
91
+ "reviewer": null,
92
+ "reviewed_at": null,
93
+ "disposition": null
94
+ },
95
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:27:01.063609+00:00"
96
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/ai_packet.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,707 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
3
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
4
+ "limits": {
5
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
6
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
7
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
8
+ },
9
+ "raw_index": {
10
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
11
+ "run_count": 12,
12
+ "sha256": "e8bf8c5077c072dc32be4e1528646316a6aca067d3a82053cf98f7a97ebce700"
13
+ },
14
+ "run_count": 12,
15
+ "run_preview": [
16
+ {
17
+ "_raw_artifact": {
18
+ "format": "json.gz",
19
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
20
+ "sha256": "57995dbbf923c83ba027ae13f628d9bc7494a0e4bccbb478333d432205e5fd03",
21
+ "size_bytes": 525,
22
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
23
+ },
24
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
25
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
26
+ "metrics": {
27
+ "audit_complete": false,
28
+ "audit_item": 1,
29
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
30
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
31
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
32
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
33
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
34
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
35
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
36
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
37
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
38
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
39
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
40
+ "snn_involved": false
41
+ },
42
+ "runtime_error": null,
43
+ "seed": 101,
44
+ "state_digest_after": "3facf879e515c8168e512133acac6dd23b9768453c18032a480a21738b4678d1",
45
+ "state_digest_before": "3facf879e515c8168e512133acac6dd23b9768453c18032a480a21738b4678d1"
46
+ },
47
+ {
48
+ "_raw_artifact": {
49
+ "format": "json.gz",
50
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
51
+ "sha256": "74100a7069f39de4bb4b81a4673ad3f623e5fad456276d56af48fb4e49bee539",
52
+ "size_bytes": 521,
53
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
54
+ },
55
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
56
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
57
+ "metrics": {
58
+ "audit_complete": false,
59
+ "audit_item": 2,
60
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
61
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
62
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
63
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
64
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
65
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
66
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
67
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
68
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
69
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
70
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
71
+ "snn_involved": false
72
+ },
73
+ "runtime_error": null,
74
+ "seed": 101,
75
+ "state_digest_after": "7c0489a18ccda3ddc27319a734aea3ce84570f40050a211b097b92f81fb397cc",
76
+ "state_digest_before": "7c0489a18ccda3ddc27319a734aea3ce84570f40050a211b097b92f81fb397cc"
77
+ },
78
+ {
79
+ "_raw_artifact": {
80
+ "format": "json.gz",
81
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
82
+ "sha256": "7a28fdce82f24f1fd9076591d9413347c7ad927fc3de3cdbc088635ef321e69b",
83
+ "size_bytes": 520,
84
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
85
+ },
86
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
87
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
88
+ "metrics": {
89
+ "audit_complete": false,
90
+ "audit_item": 3,
91
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
92
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
93
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
94
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
95
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
96
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
97
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
98
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
99
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
100
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
101
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
102
+ "snn_involved": false
103
+ },
104
+ "runtime_error": null,
105
+ "seed": 101,
106
+ "state_digest_after": "f4e9664aa1cfac4df986899ed5f28dad27e31eb2278b54c1beec233cf3c90148",
107
+ "state_digest_before": "f4e9664aa1cfac4df986899ed5f28dad27e31eb2278b54c1beec233cf3c90148"
108
+ },
109
+ {
110
+ "_raw_artifact": {
111
+ "format": "json.gz",
112
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
113
+ "sha256": "e97356ef9df242bcb4bbb00cafe25a11362d56577c195feecc33cbc5c560f6bc",
114
+ "size_bytes": 514,
115
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
116
+ },
117
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
118
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
119
+ "metrics": {
120
+ "audit_complete": false,
121
+ "audit_item": 4,
122
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
123
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
124
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
125
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
126
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
127
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
128
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
129
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
130
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
131
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
132
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
133
+ "snn_involved": false
134
+ },
135
+ "runtime_error": null,
136
+ "seed": 101,
137
+ "state_digest_after": "55e11537a1163df39baacdf679cce8712f276e3052a5cbeff110d303dd788f67",
138
+ "state_digest_before": "55e11537a1163df39baacdf679cce8712f276e3052a5cbeff110d303dd788f67"
139
+ },
140
+ {
141
+ "_raw_artifact": {
142
+ "format": "json.gz",
143
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
144
+ "sha256": "64aba07cd48458a6a2e7b4129669489f09b5918579c95d2cbfffdb3652f14e91",
145
+ "size_bytes": 524,
146
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
147
+ },
148
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
149
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
150
+ "metrics": {
151
+ "audit_complete": false,
152
+ "audit_item": 1,
153
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
154
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
155
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
156
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
157
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
158
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
159
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
160
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
161
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
162
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
163
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
164
+ "snn_involved": false
165
+ },
166
+ "runtime_error": null,
167
+ "seed": 102,
168
+ "state_digest_after": "28dc2f759d9be275a7af979adda4b9d62eae9ba188eb62ae66ae61ec57e03029",
169
+ "state_digest_before": "28dc2f759d9be275a7af979adda4b9d62eae9ba188eb62ae66ae61ec57e03029"
170
+ },
171
+ {
172
+ "_raw_artifact": {
173
+ "format": "json.gz",
174
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
175
+ "sha256": "b46852a23f99f6065d0c15af9b7ce8a5a3cedc47752c579509ea6451d16ce958",
176
+ "size_bytes": 520,
177
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
178
+ },
179
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
180
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
181
+ "metrics": {
182
+ "audit_complete": false,
183
+ "audit_item": 2,
184
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
185
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
186
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
187
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
188
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
189
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
190
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
191
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
192
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
193
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
194
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
195
+ "snn_involved": false
196
+ },
197
+ "runtime_error": null,
198
+ "seed": 102,
199
+ "state_digest_after": "c2e57a9288669ab58c1ae658f21cae38c121608835b36d36259c5b927209bc00",
200
+ "state_digest_before": "c2e57a9288669ab58c1ae658f21cae38c121608835b36d36259c5b927209bc00"
201
+ },
202
+ {
203
+ "_raw_artifact": {
204
+ "format": "json.gz",
205
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
206
+ "sha256": "ed42b90c8d82d15c3ad057ea1a9a49895662fa1d077106caa22f0edced8108a6",
207
+ "size_bytes": 520,
208
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
209
+ },
210
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
211
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
212
+ "metrics": {
213
+ "audit_complete": false,
214
+ "audit_item": 3,
215
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
216
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
217
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
218
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
219
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
220
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
221
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
222
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
223
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
224
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
225
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
226
+ "snn_involved": false
227
+ },
228
+ "runtime_error": null,
229
+ "seed": 102,
230
+ "state_digest_after": "d11a131b2610419bfa8247b3ac00129bf73dff3f2149ac8b7f4aca5d9c31c10f",
231
+ "state_digest_before": "d11a131b2610419bfa8247b3ac00129bf73dff3f2149ac8b7f4aca5d9c31c10f"
232
+ },
233
+ {
234
+ "_raw_artifact": {
235
+ "format": "json.gz",
236
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
237
+ "sha256": "a0515313f2b98a429c431843b72264bc7bb61f11bf402834713f2971c7b6895f",
238
+ "size_bytes": 516,
239
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
240
+ },
241
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
242
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
243
+ "metrics": {
244
+ "audit_complete": false,
245
+ "audit_item": 4,
246
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
247
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
248
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
249
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
250
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
251
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
252
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
253
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
254
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
255
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
256
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
257
+ "snn_involved": false
258
+ },
259
+ "runtime_error": null,
260
+ "seed": 102,
261
+ "state_digest_after": "c52bea79aa4852a82ccb4d035294f50ae2564223c55e48696356aad7a77f52a2",
262
+ "state_digest_before": "c52bea79aa4852a82ccb4d035294f50ae2564223c55e48696356aad7a77f52a2"
263
+ },
264
+ {
265
+ "_raw_artifact": {
266
+ "format": "json.gz",
267
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
268
+ "sha256": "eb8e0b0fbf849cdcf65629f2e7d04e9aeb69d3b5d31ee375551684c7b465d843",
269
+ "size_bytes": 526,
270
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
271
+ },
272
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
273
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
274
+ "metrics": {
275
+ "audit_complete": false,
276
+ "audit_item": 1,
277
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
278
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
279
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
280
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
281
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
282
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
283
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
284
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
285
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
286
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
287
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
288
+ "snn_involved": false
289
+ },
290
+ "runtime_error": null,
291
+ "seed": 103,
292
+ "state_digest_after": "47b8a9e85e3f10c15cabbe719b218485293644c6887bf9961e5f4003f413ca77",
293
+ "state_digest_before": "47b8a9e85e3f10c15cabbe719b218485293644c6887bf9961e5f4003f413ca77"
294
+ },
295
+ {
296
+ "_raw_artifact": {
297
+ "format": "json.gz",
298
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
299
+ "sha256": "db1de0e235657617ce755d48ebd81f0051c76359691e1dea087de910ff29a68c",
300
+ "size_bytes": 519,
301
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
302
+ },
303
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
304
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
305
+ "metrics": {
306
+ "audit_complete": false,
307
+ "audit_item": 2,
308
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
309
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
310
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
311
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
312
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
313
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
314
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
315
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
316
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
317
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
318
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
319
+ "snn_involved": false
320
+ },
321
+ "runtime_error": null,
322
+ "seed": 103,
323
+ "state_digest_after": "ce7a03e9a37d39949eb6eec32fa6e018e43c9095e5680638d9fe0a86cb427153",
324
+ "state_digest_before": "ce7a03e9a37d39949eb6eec32fa6e018e43c9095e5680638d9fe0a86cb427153"
325
+ },
326
+ {
327
+ "_raw_artifact": {
328
+ "format": "json.gz",
329
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
330
+ "sha256": "c5361d083e3184ddd2b0f663fd0b410a7496e139799ea6fac763aec9fee5cc61",
331
+ "size_bytes": 521,
332
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
333
+ },
334
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
335
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
336
+ "metrics": {
337
+ "audit_complete": false,
338
+ "audit_item": 3,
339
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
340
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
341
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
342
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
343
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
344
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
345
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
346
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
347
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
348
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
349
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
350
+ "snn_involved": false
351
+ },
352
+ "runtime_error": null,
353
+ "seed": 103,
354
+ "state_digest_after": "8badc1585f187a7b840231216fa7da37148c2cb26f7aac521daf68ad3c909453",
355
+ "state_digest_before": "8badc1585f187a7b840231216fa7da37148c2cb26f7aac521daf68ad3c909453"
356
+ },
357
+ {
358
+ "_raw_artifact": {
359
+ "format": "json.gz",
360
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
361
+ "sha256": "4ce7011d1170d35a87339351d1a2a3937ce99ec12a859dcc78c1c843a3003a9f",
362
+ "size_bytes": 517,
363
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
364
+ },
365
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
366
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
367
+ "metrics": {
368
+ "audit_complete": false,
369
+ "audit_item": 4,
370
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
371
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
372
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
373
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
374
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
375
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
376
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
377
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
378
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
379
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
380
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
381
+ "snn_involved": false
382
+ },
383
+ "runtime_error": null,
384
+ "seed": 103,
385
+ "state_digest_after": "24ab478280b801364482455f3458bbd413b886cc8b927fcfbb815ebdd5083210",
386
+ "state_digest_before": "24ab478280b801364482455f3458bbd413b886cc8b927fcfbb815ebdd5083210"
387
+ }
388
+ ],
389
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
390
+ "statistics": {
391
+ "conditions": {
392
+ "alternative_model": {
393
+ "boolean_metrics": {
394
+ "audit_complete": {
395
+ "all_true": false,
396
+ "false_count": 3,
397
+ "n": 3,
398
+ "true_count": 0,
399
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
400
+ },
401
+ "audit_template_generated": {
402
+ "all_true": true,
403
+ "false_count": 0,
404
+ "n": 3,
405
+ "true_count": 3,
406
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
407
+ },
408
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
409
+ "all_true": false,
410
+ "false_count": 3,
411
+ "n": 3,
412
+ "true_count": 0,
413
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
414
+ },
415
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
416
+ "all_true": true,
417
+ "false_count": 0,
418
+ "n": 3,
419
+ "true_count": 3,
420
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
421
+ },
422
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
423
+ "all_true": false,
424
+ "false_count": 3,
425
+ "n": 3,
426
+ "true_count": 0,
427
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
428
+ },
429
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
430
+ "all_true": false,
431
+ "false_count": 3,
432
+ "n": 3,
433
+ "true_count": 0,
434
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
435
+ },
436
+ "scientific_evidence": {
437
+ "all_true": false,
438
+ "false_count": 3,
439
+ "n": 3,
440
+ "true_count": 0,
441
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
442
+ },
443
+ "snn_involved": {
444
+ "all_true": false,
445
+ "false_count": 3,
446
+ "n": 3,
447
+ "true_count": 0,
448
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
449
+ }
450
+ },
451
+ "metrics": {
452
+ "audit_item": {
453
+ "max": 2.0,
454
+ "mean": 2.0,
455
+ "median": 2.0,
456
+ "min": 2.0,
457
+ "n": 3,
458
+ "std": 0.0
459
+ }
460
+ },
461
+ "run_count": 3,
462
+ "seeds": [
463
+ 101,
464
+ 102,
465
+ 103
466
+ ]
467
+ },
468
+ "assumption_explicit": {
469
+ "boolean_metrics": {
470
+ "audit_complete": {
471
+ "all_true": false,
472
+ "false_count": 3,
473
+ "n": 3,
474
+ "true_count": 0,
475
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
476
+ },
477
+ "audit_template_generated": {
478
+ "all_true": true,
479
+ "false_count": 0,
480
+ "n": 3,
481
+ "true_count": 3,
482
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
483
+ },
484
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
485
+ "all_true": false,
486
+ "false_count": 3,
487
+ "n": 3,
488
+ "true_count": 0,
489
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
490
+ },
491
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
492
+ "all_true": true,
493
+ "false_count": 0,
494
+ "n": 3,
495
+ "true_count": 3,
496
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
497
+ },
498
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
499
+ "all_true": false,
500
+ "false_count": 3,
501
+ "n": 3,
502
+ "true_count": 0,
503
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
504
+ },
505
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
506
+ "all_true": false,
507
+ "false_count": 3,
508
+ "n": 3,
509
+ "true_count": 0,
510
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
511
+ },
512
+ "scientific_evidence": {
513
+ "all_true": false,
514
+ "false_count": 3,
515
+ "n": 3,
516
+ "true_count": 0,
517
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
518
+ },
519
+ "snn_involved": {
520
+ "all_true": false,
521
+ "false_count": 3,
522
+ "n": 3,
523
+ "true_count": 0,
524
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
525
+ }
526
+ },
527
+ "metrics": {
528
+ "audit_item": {
529
+ "max": 1.0,
530
+ "mean": 1.0,
531
+ "median": 1.0,
532
+ "min": 1.0,
533
+ "n": 3,
534
+ "std": 0.0
535
+ }
536
+ },
537
+ "run_count": 3,
538
+ "seeds": [
539
+ 101,
540
+ 102,
541
+ 103
542
+ ]
543
+ },
544
+ "claim_boundary": {
545
+ "boolean_metrics": {
546
+ "audit_complete": {
547
+ "all_true": false,
548
+ "false_count": 3,
549
+ "n": 3,
550
+ "true_count": 0,
551
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
552
+ },
553
+ "audit_template_generated": {
554
+ "all_true": true,
555
+ "false_count": 0,
556
+ "n": 3,
557
+ "true_count": 3,
558
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
559
+ },
560
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
561
+ "all_true": false,
562
+ "false_count": 3,
563
+ "n": 3,
564
+ "true_count": 0,
565
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
566
+ },
567
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
568
+ "all_true": true,
569
+ "false_count": 0,
570
+ "n": 3,
571
+ "true_count": 3,
572
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
573
+ },
574
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
575
+ "all_true": false,
576
+ "false_count": 3,
577
+ "n": 3,
578
+ "true_count": 0,
579
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
580
+ },
581
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
582
+ "all_true": false,
583
+ "false_count": 3,
584
+ "n": 3,
585
+ "true_count": 0,
586
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
587
+ },
588
+ "scientific_evidence": {
589
+ "all_true": false,
590
+ "false_count": 3,
591
+ "n": 3,
592
+ "true_count": 0,
593
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
594
+ },
595
+ "snn_involved": {
596
+ "all_true": false,
597
+ "false_count": 3,
598
+ "n": 3,
599
+ "true_count": 0,
600
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
601
+ }
602
+ },
603
+ "metrics": {
604
+ "audit_item": {
605
+ "max": 4.0,
606
+ "mean": 4.0,
607
+ "median": 4.0,
608
+ "min": 4.0,
609
+ "n": 3,
610
+ "std": 0.0
611
+ }
612
+ },
613
+ "run_count": 3,
614
+ "seeds": [
615
+ 101,
616
+ 102,
617
+ 103
618
+ ]
619
+ },
620
+ "measurement_limit": {
621
+ "boolean_metrics": {
622
+ "audit_complete": {
623
+ "all_true": false,
624
+ "false_count": 3,
625
+ "n": 3,
626
+ "true_count": 0,
627
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
628
+ },
629
+ "audit_template_generated": {
630
+ "all_true": true,
631
+ "false_count": 0,
632
+ "n": 3,
633
+ "true_count": 3,
634
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
635
+ },
636
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
637
+ "all_true": false,
638
+ "false_count": 3,
639
+ "n": 3,
640
+ "true_count": 0,
641
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
642
+ },
643
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
644
+ "all_true": true,
645
+ "false_count": 0,
646
+ "n": 3,
647
+ "true_count": 3,
648
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
649
+ },
650
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
651
+ "all_true": false,
652
+ "false_count": 3,
653
+ "n": 3,
654
+ "true_count": 0,
655
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
656
+ },
657
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
658
+ "all_true": false,
659
+ "false_count": 3,
660
+ "n": 3,
661
+ "true_count": 0,
662
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
663
+ },
664
+ "scientific_evidence": {
665
+ "all_true": false,
666
+ "false_count": 3,
667
+ "n": 3,
668
+ "true_count": 0,
669
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
670
+ },
671
+ "snn_involved": {
672
+ "all_true": false,
673
+ "false_count": 3,
674
+ "n": 3,
675
+ "true_count": 0,
676
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
677
+ }
678
+ },
679
+ "metrics": {
680
+ "audit_item": {
681
+ "max": 3.0,
682
+ "mean": 3.0,
683
+ "median": 3.0,
684
+ "min": 3.0,
685
+ "n": 3,
686
+ "std": 0.0
687
+ }
688
+ },
689
+ "run_count": 3,
690
+ "seeds": [
691
+ 101,
692
+ 102,
693
+ 103
694
+ ]
695
+ }
696
+ },
697
+ "formulas": {
698
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
699
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
700
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
701
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
702
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
703
+ },
704
+ "run_count": 12,
705
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
706
+ }
707
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/ai_packet_digest.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "path": "analysis/ai_packet.json",
3
+ "raw_index_sha256": "e8bf8c5077c072dc32be4e1528646316a6aca067d3a82053cf98f7a97ebce700",
4
+ "schema_version": "1.0",
5
+ "sha256": "106f2df66059de1a9aa7d6dbd3c8091046cd14baed4d8d9e9e17825c3438cb22",
6
+ "size_bytes": 24536
7
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/analysis/statistics.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,318 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "conditions": {
3
+ "alternative_model": {
4
+ "boolean_metrics": {
5
+ "audit_complete": {
6
+ "all_true": false,
7
+ "false_count": 3,
8
+ "n": 3,
9
+ "true_count": 0,
10
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
11
+ },
12
+ "audit_template_generated": {
13
+ "all_true": true,
14
+ "false_count": 0,
15
+ "n": 3,
16
+ "true_count": 3,
17
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
18
+ },
19
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
20
+ "all_true": false,
21
+ "false_count": 3,
22
+ "n": 3,
23
+ "true_count": 0,
24
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
25
+ },
26
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
27
+ "all_true": true,
28
+ "false_count": 0,
29
+ "n": 3,
30
+ "true_count": 3,
31
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
32
+ },
33
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
34
+ "all_true": false,
35
+ "false_count": 3,
36
+ "n": 3,
37
+ "true_count": 0,
38
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
39
+ },
40
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
41
+ "all_true": false,
42
+ "false_count": 3,
43
+ "n": 3,
44
+ "true_count": 0,
45
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
46
+ },
47
+ "scientific_evidence": {
48
+ "all_true": false,
49
+ "false_count": 3,
50
+ "n": 3,
51
+ "true_count": 0,
52
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
53
+ },
54
+ "snn_involved": {
55
+ "all_true": false,
56
+ "false_count": 3,
57
+ "n": 3,
58
+ "true_count": 0,
59
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
60
+ }
61
+ },
62
+ "metrics": {
63
+ "audit_item": {
64
+ "max": 2.0,
65
+ "mean": 2.0,
66
+ "median": 2.0,
67
+ "min": 2.0,
68
+ "n": 3,
69
+ "std": 0.0
70
+ }
71
+ },
72
+ "run_count": 3,
73
+ "seeds": [
74
+ 101,
75
+ 102,
76
+ 103
77
+ ]
78
+ },
79
+ "assumption_explicit": {
80
+ "boolean_metrics": {
81
+ "audit_complete": {
82
+ "all_true": false,
83
+ "false_count": 3,
84
+ "n": 3,
85
+ "true_count": 0,
86
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
87
+ },
88
+ "audit_template_generated": {
89
+ "all_true": true,
90
+ "false_count": 0,
91
+ "n": 3,
92
+ "true_count": 3,
93
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
94
+ },
95
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
96
+ "all_true": false,
97
+ "false_count": 3,
98
+ "n": 3,
99
+ "true_count": 0,
100
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
101
+ },
102
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
103
+ "all_true": true,
104
+ "false_count": 0,
105
+ "n": 3,
106
+ "true_count": 3,
107
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
108
+ },
109
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
110
+ "all_true": false,
111
+ "false_count": 3,
112
+ "n": 3,
113
+ "true_count": 0,
114
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
115
+ },
116
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
117
+ "all_true": false,
118
+ "false_count": 3,
119
+ "n": 3,
120
+ "true_count": 0,
121
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
122
+ },
123
+ "scientific_evidence": {
124
+ "all_true": false,
125
+ "false_count": 3,
126
+ "n": 3,
127
+ "true_count": 0,
128
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
129
+ },
130
+ "snn_involved": {
131
+ "all_true": false,
132
+ "false_count": 3,
133
+ "n": 3,
134
+ "true_count": 0,
135
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
136
+ }
137
+ },
138
+ "metrics": {
139
+ "audit_item": {
140
+ "max": 1.0,
141
+ "mean": 1.0,
142
+ "median": 1.0,
143
+ "min": 1.0,
144
+ "n": 3,
145
+ "std": 0.0
146
+ }
147
+ },
148
+ "run_count": 3,
149
+ "seeds": [
150
+ 101,
151
+ 102,
152
+ 103
153
+ ]
154
+ },
155
+ "claim_boundary": {
156
+ "boolean_metrics": {
157
+ "audit_complete": {
158
+ "all_true": false,
159
+ "false_count": 3,
160
+ "n": 3,
161
+ "true_count": 0,
162
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
163
+ },
164
+ "audit_template_generated": {
165
+ "all_true": true,
166
+ "false_count": 0,
167
+ "n": 3,
168
+ "true_count": 3,
169
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
170
+ },
171
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
172
+ "all_true": false,
173
+ "false_count": 3,
174
+ "n": 3,
175
+ "true_count": 0,
176
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
177
+ },
178
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
179
+ "all_true": true,
180
+ "false_count": 0,
181
+ "n": 3,
182
+ "true_count": 3,
183
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
184
+ },
185
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
186
+ "all_true": false,
187
+ "false_count": 3,
188
+ "n": 3,
189
+ "true_count": 0,
190
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
191
+ },
192
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
193
+ "all_true": false,
194
+ "false_count": 3,
195
+ "n": 3,
196
+ "true_count": 0,
197
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
198
+ },
199
+ "scientific_evidence": {
200
+ "all_true": false,
201
+ "false_count": 3,
202
+ "n": 3,
203
+ "true_count": 0,
204
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
205
+ },
206
+ "snn_involved": {
207
+ "all_true": false,
208
+ "false_count": 3,
209
+ "n": 3,
210
+ "true_count": 0,
211
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
212
+ }
213
+ },
214
+ "metrics": {
215
+ "audit_item": {
216
+ "max": 4.0,
217
+ "mean": 4.0,
218
+ "median": 4.0,
219
+ "min": 4.0,
220
+ "n": 3,
221
+ "std": 0.0
222
+ }
223
+ },
224
+ "run_count": 3,
225
+ "seeds": [
226
+ 101,
227
+ 102,
228
+ 103
229
+ ]
230
+ },
231
+ "measurement_limit": {
232
+ "boolean_metrics": {
233
+ "audit_complete": {
234
+ "all_true": false,
235
+ "false_count": 3,
236
+ "n": 3,
237
+ "true_count": 0,
238
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
239
+ },
240
+ "audit_template_generated": {
241
+ "all_true": true,
242
+ "false_count": 0,
243
+ "n": 3,
244
+ "true_count": 3,
245
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
246
+ },
247
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
248
+ "all_true": false,
249
+ "false_count": 3,
250
+ "n": 3,
251
+ "true_count": 0,
252
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
253
+ },
254
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
255
+ "all_true": true,
256
+ "false_count": 0,
257
+ "n": 3,
258
+ "true_count": 3,
259
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
260
+ },
261
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
262
+ "all_true": false,
263
+ "false_count": 3,
264
+ "n": 3,
265
+ "true_count": 0,
266
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
267
+ },
268
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
269
+ "all_true": false,
270
+ "false_count": 3,
271
+ "n": 3,
272
+ "true_count": 0,
273
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
274
+ },
275
+ "scientific_evidence": {
276
+ "all_true": false,
277
+ "false_count": 3,
278
+ "n": 3,
279
+ "true_count": 0,
280
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
281
+ },
282
+ "snn_involved": {
283
+ "all_true": false,
284
+ "false_count": 3,
285
+ "n": 3,
286
+ "true_count": 0,
287
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
288
+ }
289
+ },
290
+ "metrics": {
291
+ "audit_item": {
292
+ "max": 3.0,
293
+ "mean": 3.0,
294
+ "median": 3.0,
295
+ "min": 3.0,
296
+ "n": 3,
297
+ "std": 0.0
298
+ }
299
+ },
300
+ "run_count": 3,
301
+ "seeds": [
302
+ 101,
303
+ 102,
304
+ 103
305
+ ]
306
+ }
307
+ },
308
+ "formulas": {
309
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
310
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
311
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
312
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
313
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
314
+ },
315
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
316
+ "run_count": 12,
317
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
318
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/manifest.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,127 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "ai_exposure": "none",
3
+ "ai_interactions": [],
4
+ "ai_protocol": {
5
+ "bump_reason": "initial registration",
6
+ "version": 1
7
+ },
8
+ "ai_reproducibility": "R0",
9
+ "artifacts": {
10
+ "ai_packet": "analysis/ai_packet.json",
11
+ "ai_packet_digest": "analysis/ai_packet_digest.json",
12
+ "ai_report_json": "experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json",
13
+ "ai_report_markdown": "experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md",
14
+ "current_run": "DATA/current_run.json",
15
+ "data": "DATA/runs_compact.json",
16
+ "data_index": "DATA/runs_index.json",
17
+ "preregistration": "preregistrations/operational/cognition_bundle_v1.json",
18
+ "raw_run_index": "DATA/runs_index.json",
19
+ "report": "report.md",
20
+ "statistics": "analysis/statistics.json",
21
+ "workflow": "workflow.json"
22
+ },
23
+ "causal_card": {
24
+ "classification": "PURE",
25
+ "interaction_ids": [],
26
+ "roles": []
27
+ },
28
+ "causal_taint": "PURE",
29
+ "config": {
30
+ "path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
31
+ "sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c"
32
+ },
33
+ "created_at": "2026-10-01T21:23:04.909963+00:00",
34
+ "data_partitions": [],
35
+ "epistemic_layers": {
36
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
37
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
38
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input",
39
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result"
40
+ },
41
+ "execution_contract": {
42
+ "hypothesis_id": "H-CNS-103-A",
43
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_103_v1",
44
+ "question_id": "RQ-CNS-103",
45
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_103_v1",
46
+ "runtime_runner_bytecode_sha256": "93e483e29fa71c08401562dfa757d4a5f80fb7ca1fa1cce25a1e76c2b71ea1eb",
47
+ "runtime_summary_bytecode_sha256": "462bf872a28910b7747790c4aae29f288f6aa5361c27799f0ea52a1fdc09f7a6",
48
+ "source_runner_bytecode_sha256": "93e483e29fa71c08401562dfa757d4a5f80fb7ca1fa1cce25a1e76c2b71ea1eb",
49
+ "source_runtime_consistency": "MATCH",
50
+ "source_summary_bytecode_sha256": "462bf872a28910b7747790c4aae29f288f6aa5361c27799f0ea52a1fdc09f7a6",
51
+ "tick_validation": {
52
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
53
+ "requested_ticks": 1,
54
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"
55
+ },
56
+ "ticks_requested": 1
57
+ },
58
+ "execution_semantics": {
59
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
60
+ "claim_scope": "method_template_only",
61
+ "direct_test_of_hypothesis": false,
62
+ "external_review": "external_review/INTEGRATION.md",
63
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
64
+ "kind": "conceptual_audit",
65
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
66
+ "snn_involved": false
67
+ },
68
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
69
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
70
+ "git": {
71
+ "branch": "develop",
72
+ "commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
73
+ "dirty": true
74
+ },
75
+ "hypotheses": [
76
+ "H-CNS-103-A"
77
+ ],
78
+ "network_mode": "OFFLINE",
79
+ "provenance_digests": {
80
+ "code": "5a11ea288e7e695c2dcd456642b533cbb3e6daf38b72e150134e60e69059531f",
81
+ "config": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
82
+ "data": "53f2bb334a222d78a55a09db409be5a167b6e144fe3a1bd022600c0b56b12fba",
83
+ "prompt": "dd18e473908e7e75b1717c240bac221729ea38753abfd28b701b37b20d5f5e14"
84
+ },
85
+ "research_questions": [
86
+ "RQ-CNS-103"
87
+ ],
88
+ "research_run_mode": "EXPLORATORY",
89
+ "results": {
90
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_103_v1",
91
+ "run_count": 12,
92
+ "runner": "run_cog_cns_103_v1",
93
+ "tick_contract": {
94
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
95
+ "requested_ticks": 1,
96
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"
97
+ },
98
+ "ticks_requested": 1
99
+ },
100
+ "runtime": {
101
+ "duration_seconds": 0.013018399942666292
102
+ },
103
+ "runtime_errors": [],
104
+ "simulation": {
105
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_103_v1",
106
+ "seed": 101,
107
+ "seeds": [
108
+ 101,
109
+ 102,
110
+ 103
111
+ ],
112
+ "ticks": 1
113
+ },
114
+ "software": {
115
+ "brain5d_version": "0.6.0a7",
116
+ "os": "Windows 11",
117
+ "python": "3.13.14"
118
+ },
119
+ "source_freeze_sha": "8d50b86a6a8130cdd21c80a91c7823fcfbf1514dd0072d25e7a853e7f1a54739",
120
+ "timestamp": "2026-10-01T23:23:04.909954",
121
+ "validity": {
122
+ "fatal_error_count": 0,
123
+ "reason": null,
124
+ "runtime_error_count": 0,
125
+ "valid": true
126
+ }
127
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/report.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02: Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_103_v1
2
+
3
+ ## Forschungszuordnung
4
+ Forschungsfrage: `RQ-CNS-103`
5
+ Hypothese: `H-CNS-103-A`
6
+ Aufgeloester Runner: `run_cog_cns_103_v1`
7
+
8
+ ## Protokoll und Einstellungen
9
+ Protokoll: `cog_cns_103_v1`
10
+ Angeforderte Mindest-Ticks: `1`
11
+ Seeds: `101, 102, 103`
12
+ Tick-Vertrag: `{"mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials", "requested_ticks": 1, "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE"}`
13
+
14
+ ## Bedingungen
15
+ frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract
16
+ Runs: 12; Dauer: 0.013018 s
17
+
18
+ ## Daten und Statistik
19
+ Versionierte kompakte Run-Projektion: `DATA/runs_compact.json`
20
+ Unveränderlicher Rohdatenindex: `DATA/runs_index.json`
21
+ KI-Eingabepaket: `analysis/ai_packet.json` (hart begrenzt)
22
+ Deterministische deskriptive Statistik: `analysis/statistics.json`
23
+ Die Summary verbindet Rohdaten, Formeln, Einzelruns, Bedingungen, Reproduzierbarkeit und AIRR ohne KI-generierte Statistik.
24
+
25
+ ## Epistemische Ebenen
26
+ UI-Zustand: Dashboard-Steuerung und Fortschritt; kein wissenschaftliches Ergebnis.
27
+ DATA: Rohdaten, Run-Index und deterministische Statistik.
28
+ EVID: nicht erzeugt; Clean Freeze, semantische Zuordnung und Human Review erforderlich.
29
+ Interpretation: nachgelagerte KI-/Human-Interpretation; keine Ausfuehrungseingabe.
30
+
31
+ ## Evidenzstatus
32
+ DATA, Manifest, Workflow und deterministische Statistik sind erzeugt. Wissenschaftliche EVID entsteht erst nach passender semantischer Zuordnung, Clean Freeze und Human Review.
33
+
34
+ ## Hinweise
35
+ Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,1605 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "report_id": "AIRR-2026-0001",
3
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
4
+ "research_question_id": "RQ-CNS-103",
5
+ "hypothesis_ids": [
6
+ "H-CNS-103-A"
7
+ ],
8
+ "claim_ids": [],
9
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:27:01.065413+00:00",
10
+ "report_schema_version": "1.0",
11
+ "report_protocol_version": "PROTOCOL-AIRR-001",
12
+ "generated_by": "artificial_intelligence",
13
+ "ai_generated": true,
14
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
15
+ "human_review_required": true,
16
+ "status": "review_pending",
17
+ "content": {
18
+ "identification": {
19
+ "experiment": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
20
+ "research_question": "Verändert Aufgabenrelevanz die Oddball-Verarbeitung bei gleichem sensorischen Input?",
21
+ "hypotheses": [
22
+ {
23
+ "id": "H-CNS-103-A",
24
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-103",
25
+ "hypothesis": "Aktive Zielerkennung verbessert diskriminative Leistung gegenüber passiver und yoked-kontrollierter Verarbeitung, ohne externes LLM-Wissen.",
26
+ "status": "untested",
27
+ "evidence": [],
28
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
29
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
30
+ }
31
+ ],
32
+ "date": "2026-10-01",
33
+ "source_sha": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3"
34
+ },
35
+ "executive_summary": "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.",
36
+ "research_question": {
37
+ "id": "RQ-CNS-103",
38
+ "domain": "Attention and discrimination",
39
+ "question": "Verändert Aufgabenrelevanz die Oddball-Verarbeitung bei gleichem sensorischen Input?",
40
+ "relevance": "Active oddball; Task, report and motor effects must be separated from access claims",
41
+ "literature": [
42
+ "SRC-CNS-ODDBALL"
43
+ ],
44
+ "hypotheses": [
45
+ "H-CNS-103-A"
46
+ ],
47
+ "evidence": [],
48
+ "status": "open",
49
+ "answer": {
50
+ "current": null,
51
+ "confidence": "none",
52
+ "limitations": "Task, report and motor effects must be separated from access claims"
53
+ },
54
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
55
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
56
+ },
57
+ "experimental_design": {
58
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
59
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-103",
60
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-103-A",
61
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_103_v1",
62
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
63
+ "ticks": 1,
64
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
65
+ "seeds": [
66
+ 101,
67
+ 102,
68
+ 103
69
+ ],
70
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_103_v1",
71
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_103_v1",
72
+ "tick_validation": {
73
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
74
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
75
+ "requested_ticks": 1
76
+ },
77
+ "notes": "Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
78
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
79
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
80
+ "epistemic_layers": {
81
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
82
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
83
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
84
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
85
+ }
86
+ },
87
+ "data_basis": {
88
+ "data": {
89
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
90
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
91
+ "limits": {
92
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
93
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
94
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
95
+ },
96
+ "raw_index": {
97
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
98
+ "run_count": 12,
99
+ "sha256": "e8bf8c5077c072dc32be4e1528646316a6aca067d3a82053cf98f7a97ebce700"
100
+ },
101
+ "run_count": 12,
102
+ "run_preview": [
103
+ {
104
+ "_raw_artifact": {
105
+ "format": "json.gz",
106
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
107
+ "sha256": "57995dbbf923c83ba027ae13f628d9bc7494a0e4bccbb478333d432205e5fd03",
108
+ "size_bytes": 525,
109
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
110
+ },
111
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
112
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
113
+ "metrics": {
114
+ "audit_complete": false,
115
+ "audit_item": 1,
116
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
117
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
118
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
119
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
120
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
121
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
122
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
123
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
124
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
125
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
126
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
127
+ "snn_involved": false
128
+ },
129
+ "runtime_error": null,
130
+ "seed": 101,
131
+ "state_digest_after": "3facf879e515c8168e512133acac6dd23b9768453c18032a480a21738b4678d1",
132
+ "state_digest_before": "3facf879e515c8168e512133acac6dd23b9768453c18032a480a21738b4678d1"
133
+ },
134
+ {
135
+ "_raw_artifact": {
136
+ "format": "json.gz",
137
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
138
+ "sha256": "74100a7069f39de4bb4b81a4673ad3f623e5fad456276d56af48fb4e49bee539",
139
+ "size_bytes": 521,
140
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
141
+ },
142
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
143
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
144
+ "metrics": {
145
+ "audit_complete": false,
146
+ "audit_item": 2,
147
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
148
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
149
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
150
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
151
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
152
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
153
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
154
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
155
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
156
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
157
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
158
+ "snn_involved": false
159
+ },
160
+ "runtime_error": null,
161
+ "seed": 101,
162
+ "state_digest_after": "7c0489a18ccda3ddc27319a734aea3ce84570f40050a211b097b92f81fb397cc",
163
+ "state_digest_before": "7c0489a18ccda3ddc27319a734aea3ce84570f40050a211b097b92f81fb397cc"
164
+ },
165
+ {
166
+ "_raw_artifact": {
167
+ "format": "json.gz",
168
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
169
+ "sha256": "7a28fdce82f24f1fd9076591d9413347c7ad927fc3de3cdbc088635ef321e69b",
170
+ "size_bytes": 520,
171
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
172
+ },
173
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
174
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
175
+ "metrics": {
176
+ "audit_complete": false,
177
+ "audit_item": 3,
178
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
179
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
180
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
181
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
182
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
183
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
184
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
185
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
186
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
187
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
188
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
189
+ "snn_involved": false
190
+ },
191
+ "runtime_error": null,
192
+ "seed": 101,
193
+ "state_digest_after": "f4e9664aa1cfac4df986899ed5f28dad27e31eb2278b54c1beec233cf3c90148",
194
+ "state_digest_before": "f4e9664aa1cfac4df986899ed5f28dad27e31eb2278b54c1beec233cf3c90148"
195
+ },
196
+ {
197
+ "_raw_artifact": {
198
+ "format": "json.gz",
199
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
200
+ "sha256": "e97356ef9df242bcb4bbb00cafe25a11362d56577c195feecc33cbc5c560f6bc",
201
+ "size_bytes": 514,
202
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
203
+ },
204
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
205
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
206
+ "metrics": {
207
+ "audit_complete": false,
208
+ "audit_item": 4,
209
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
210
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
211
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
212
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
213
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
214
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
215
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
216
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
217
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
218
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
219
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
220
+ "snn_involved": false
221
+ },
222
+ "runtime_error": null,
223
+ "seed": 101,
224
+ "state_digest_after": "55e11537a1163df39baacdf679cce8712f276e3052a5cbeff110d303dd788f67",
225
+ "state_digest_before": "55e11537a1163df39baacdf679cce8712f276e3052a5cbeff110d303dd788f67"
226
+ },
227
+ {
228
+ "_raw_artifact": {
229
+ "format": "json.gz",
230
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
231
+ "sha256": "64aba07cd48458a6a2e7b4129669489f09b5918579c95d2cbfffdb3652f14e91",
232
+ "size_bytes": 524,
233
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
234
+ },
235
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
236
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
237
+ "metrics": {
238
+ "audit_complete": false,
239
+ "audit_item": 1,
240
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
241
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
242
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
243
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
244
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
245
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
246
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
247
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
248
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
249
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
250
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
251
+ "snn_involved": false
252
+ },
253
+ "runtime_error": null,
254
+ "seed": 102,
255
+ "state_digest_after": "28dc2f759d9be275a7af979adda4b9d62eae9ba188eb62ae66ae61ec57e03029",
256
+ "state_digest_before": "28dc2f759d9be275a7af979adda4b9d62eae9ba188eb62ae66ae61ec57e03029"
257
+ },
258
+ {
259
+ "_raw_artifact": {
260
+ "format": "json.gz",
261
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
262
+ "sha256": "b46852a23f99f6065d0c15af9b7ce8a5a3cedc47752c579509ea6451d16ce958",
263
+ "size_bytes": 520,
264
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
265
+ },
266
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
267
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
268
+ "metrics": {
269
+ "audit_complete": false,
270
+ "audit_item": 2,
271
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
272
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
273
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
274
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
275
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
276
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
277
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
278
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
279
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
280
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
281
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
282
+ "snn_involved": false
283
+ },
284
+ "runtime_error": null,
285
+ "seed": 102,
286
+ "state_digest_after": "c2e57a9288669ab58c1ae658f21cae38c121608835b36d36259c5b927209bc00",
287
+ "state_digest_before": "c2e57a9288669ab58c1ae658f21cae38c121608835b36d36259c5b927209bc00"
288
+ },
289
+ {
290
+ "_raw_artifact": {
291
+ "format": "json.gz",
292
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
293
+ "sha256": "ed42b90c8d82d15c3ad057ea1a9a49895662fa1d077106caa22f0edced8108a6",
294
+ "size_bytes": 520,
295
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
296
+ },
297
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
298
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
299
+ "metrics": {
300
+ "audit_complete": false,
301
+ "audit_item": 3,
302
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
303
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
304
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
305
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
306
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
307
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
308
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
309
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
310
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
311
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
312
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
313
+ "snn_involved": false
314
+ },
315
+ "runtime_error": null,
316
+ "seed": 102,
317
+ "state_digest_after": "d11a131b2610419bfa8247b3ac00129bf73dff3f2149ac8b7f4aca5d9c31c10f",
318
+ "state_digest_before": "d11a131b2610419bfa8247b3ac00129bf73dff3f2149ac8b7f4aca5d9c31c10f"
319
+ },
320
+ {
321
+ "_raw_artifact": {
322
+ "format": "json.gz",
323
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
324
+ "sha256": "a0515313f2b98a429c431843b72264bc7bb61f11bf402834713f2971c7b6895f",
325
+ "size_bytes": 516,
326
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
327
+ },
328
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
329
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
330
+ "metrics": {
331
+ "audit_complete": false,
332
+ "audit_item": 4,
333
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
334
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
335
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
336
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
337
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
338
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
339
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
340
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
341
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
342
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
343
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
344
+ "snn_involved": false
345
+ },
346
+ "runtime_error": null,
347
+ "seed": 102,
348
+ "state_digest_after": "c52bea79aa4852a82ccb4d035294f50ae2564223c55e48696356aad7a77f52a2",
349
+ "state_digest_before": "c52bea79aa4852a82ccb4d035294f50ae2564223c55e48696356aad7a77f52a2"
350
+ },
351
+ {
352
+ "_raw_artifact": {
353
+ "format": "json.gz",
354
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
355
+ "sha256": "eb8e0b0fbf849cdcf65629f2e7d04e9aeb69d3b5d31ee375551684c7b465d843",
356
+ "size_bytes": 526,
357
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
358
+ },
359
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
360
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
361
+ "metrics": {
362
+ "audit_complete": false,
363
+ "audit_item": 1,
364
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
365
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
366
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
367
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
368
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
369
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
370
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
371
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
372
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
373
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
374
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
375
+ "snn_involved": false
376
+ },
377
+ "runtime_error": null,
378
+ "seed": 103,
379
+ "state_digest_after": "47b8a9e85e3f10c15cabbe719b218485293644c6887bf9961e5f4003f413ca77",
380
+ "state_digest_before": "47b8a9e85e3f10c15cabbe719b218485293644c6887bf9961e5f4003f413ca77"
381
+ },
382
+ {
383
+ "_raw_artifact": {
384
+ "format": "json.gz",
385
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
386
+ "sha256": "db1de0e235657617ce755d48ebd81f0051c76359691e1dea087de910ff29a68c",
387
+ "size_bytes": 519,
388
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
389
+ },
390
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
391
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
392
+ "metrics": {
393
+ "audit_complete": false,
394
+ "audit_item": 2,
395
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
396
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
397
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
398
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
399
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
400
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
401
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
402
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
403
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
404
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
405
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
406
+ "snn_involved": false
407
+ },
408
+ "runtime_error": null,
409
+ "seed": 103,
410
+ "state_digest_after": "ce7a03e9a37d39949eb6eec32fa6e018e43c9095e5680638d9fe0a86cb427153",
411
+ "state_digest_before": "ce7a03e9a37d39949eb6eec32fa6e018e43c9095e5680638d9fe0a86cb427153"
412
+ },
413
+ {
414
+ "_raw_artifact": {
415
+ "format": "json.gz",
416
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
417
+ "sha256": "c5361d083e3184ddd2b0f663fd0b410a7496e139799ea6fac763aec9fee5cc61",
418
+ "size_bytes": 521,
419
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
420
+ },
421
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
422
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
423
+ "metrics": {
424
+ "audit_complete": false,
425
+ "audit_item": 3,
426
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
427
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
428
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
429
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
430
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
431
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
432
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
433
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
434
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
435
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
436
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
437
+ "snn_involved": false
438
+ },
439
+ "runtime_error": null,
440
+ "seed": 103,
441
+ "state_digest_after": "8badc1585f187a7b840231216fa7da37148c2cb26f7aac521daf68ad3c909453",
442
+ "state_digest_before": "8badc1585f187a7b840231216fa7da37148c2cb26f7aac521daf68ad3c909453"
443
+ },
444
+ {
445
+ "_raw_artifact": {
446
+ "format": "json.gz",
447
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
448
+ "sha256": "4ce7011d1170d35a87339351d1a2a3937ce99ec12a859dcc78c1c843a3003a9f",
449
+ "size_bytes": 517,
450
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
451
+ },
452
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
453
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
454
+ "metrics": {
455
+ "audit_complete": false,
456
+ "audit_item": 4,
457
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
458
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
459
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
460
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
461
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
462
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
463
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
464
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
465
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
466
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
467
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
468
+ "snn_involved": false
469
+ },
470
+ "runtime_error": null,
471
+ "seed": 103,
472
+ "state_digest_after": "24ab478280b801364482455f3458bbd413b886cc8b927fcfbb815ebdd5083210",
473
+ "state_digest_before": "24ab478280b801364482455f3458bbd413b886cc8b927fcfbb815ebdd5083210"
474
+ }
475
+ ],
476
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
477
+ "statistics": {
478
+ "conditions": {
479
+ "alternative_model": {
480
+ "boolean_metrics": {
481
+ "audit_complete": {
482
+ "all_true": false,
483
+ "false_count": 3,
484
+ "n": 3,
485
+ "true_count": 0,
486
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
487
+ },
488
+ "audit_template_generated": {
489
+ "all_true": true,
490
+ "false_count": 0,
491
+ "n": 3,
492
+ "true_count": 3,
493
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
494
+ },
495
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
496
+ "all_true": false,
497
+ "false_count": 3,
498
+ "n": 3,
499
+ "true_count": 0,
500
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
501
+ },
502
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
503
+ "all_true": true,
504
+ "false_count": 0,
505
+ "n": 3,
506
+ "true_count": 3,
507
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
508
+ },
509
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
510
+ "all_true": false,
511
+ "false_count": 3,
512
+ "n": 3,
513
+ "true_count": 0,
514
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
515
+ },
516
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
517
+ "all_true": false,
518
+ "false_count": 3,
519
+ "n": 3,
520
+ "true_count": 0,
521
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
522
+ },
523
+ "scientific_evidence": {
524
+ "all_true": false,
525
+ "false_count": 3,
526
+ "n": 3,
527
+ "true_count": 0,
528
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
529
+ },
530
+ "snn_involved": {
531
+ "all_true": false,
532
+ "false_count": 3,
533
+ "n": 3,
534
+ "true_count": 0,
535
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
536
+ }
537
+ },
538
+ "metrics": {
539
+ "audit_item": {
540
+ "max": 2.0,
541
+ "mean": 2.0,
542
+ "median": 2.0,
543
+ "min": 2.0,
544
+ "n": 3,
545
+ "std": 0.0
546
+ }
547
+ },
548
+ "run_count": 3,
549
+ "seeds": [
550
+ 101,
551
+ 102,
552
+ 103
553
+ ]
554
+ },
555
+ "assumption_explicit": {
556
+ "boolean_metrics": {
557
+ "audit_complete": {
558
+ "all_true": false,
559
+ "false_count": 3,
560
+ "n": 3,
561
+ "true_count": 0,
562
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
563
+ },
564
+ "audit_template_generated": {
565
+ "all_true": true,
566
+ "false_count": 0,
567
+ "n": 3,
568
+ "true_count": 3,
569
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
570
+ },
571
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
572
+ "all_true": false,
573
+ "false_count": 3,
574
+ "n": 3,
575
+ "true_count": 0,
576
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
577
+ },
578
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
579
+ "all_true": true,
580
+ "false_count": 0,
581
+ "n": 3,
582
+ "true_count": 3,
583
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
584
+ },
585
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
586
+ "all_true": false,
587
+ "false_count": 3,
588
+ "n": 3,
589
+ "true_count": 0,
590
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
591
+ },
592
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
593
+ "all_true": false,
594
+ "false_count": 3,
595
+ "n": 3,
596
+ "true_count": 0,
597
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
598
+ },
599
+ "scientific_evidence": {
600
+ "all_true": false,
601
+ "false_count": 3,
602
+ "n": 3,
603
+ "true_count": 0,
604
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
605
+ },
606
+ "snn_involved": {
607
+ "all_true": false,
608
+ "false_count": 3,
609
+ "n": 3,
610
+ "true_count": 0,
611
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
612
+ }
613
+ },
614
+ "metrics": {
615
+ "audit_item": {
616
+ "max": 1.0,
617
+ "mean": 1.0,
618
+ "median": 1.0,
619
+ "min": 1.0,
620
+ "n": 3,
621
+ "std": 0.0
622
+ }
623
+ },
624
+ "run_count": 3,
625
+ "seeds": [
626
+ 101,
627
+ 102,
628
+ 103
629
+ ]
630
+ },
631
+ "claim_boundary": {
632
+ "boolean_metrics": {
633
+ "audit_complete": {
634
+ "all_true": false,
635
+ "false_count": 3,
636
+ "n": 3,
637
+ "true_count": 0,
638
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
639
+ },
640
+ "audit_template_generated": {
641
+ "all_true": true,
642
+ "false_count": 0,
643
+ "n": 3,
644
+ "true_count": 3,
645
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
646
+ },
647
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
648
+ "all_true": false,
649
+ "false_count": 3,
650
+ "n": 3,
651
+ "true_count": 0,
652
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
653
+ },
654
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
655
+ "all_true": true,
656
+ "false_count": 0,
657
+ "n": 3,
658
+ "true_count": 3,
659
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
660
+ },
661
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
662
+ "all_true": false,
663
+ "false_count": 3,
664
+ "n": 3,
665
+ "true_count": 0,
666
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
667
+ },
668
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
669
+ "all_true": false,
670
+ "false_count": 3,
671
+ "n": 3,
672
+ "true_count": 0,
673
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
674
+ },
675
+ "scientific_evidence": {
676
+ "all_true": false,
677
+ "false_count": 3,
678
+ "n": 3,
679
+ "true_count": 0,
680
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
681
+ },
682
+ "snn_involved": {
683
+ "all_true": false,
684
+ "false_count": 3,
685
+ "n": 3,
686
+ "true_count": 0,
687
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
688
+ }
689
+ },
690
+ "metrics": {
691
+ "audit_item": {
692
+ "max": 4.0,
693
+ "mean": 4.0,
694
+ "median": 4.0,
695
+ "min": 4.0,
696
+ "n": 3,
697
+ "std": 0.0
698
+ }
699
+ },
700
+ "run_count": 3,
701
+ "seeds": [
702
+ 101,
703
+ 102,
704
+ 103
705
+ ]
706
+ },
707
+ "measurement_limit": {
708
+ "boolean_metrics": {
709
+ "audit_complete": {
710
+ "all_true": false,
711
+ "false_count": 3,
712
+ "n": 3,
713
+ "true_count": 0,
714
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
715
+ },
716
+ "audit_template_generated": {
717
+ "all_true": true,
718
+ "false_count": 0,
719
+ "n": 3,
720
+ "true_count": 3,
721
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
722
+ },
723
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
724
+ "all_true": false,
725
+ "false_count": 3,
726
+ "n": 3,
727
+ "true_count": 0,
728
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
729
+ },
730
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
731
+ "all_true": true,
732
+ "false_count": 0,
733
+ "n": 3,
734
+ "true_count": 3,
735
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
736
+ },
737
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
738
+ "all_true": false,
739
+ "false_count": 3,
740
+ "n": 3,
741
+ "true_count": 0,
742
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
743
+ },
744
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
745
+ "all_true": false,
746
+ "false_count": 3,
747
+ "n": 3,
748
+ "true_count": 0,
749
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
750
+ },
751
+ "scientific_evidence": {
752
+ "all_true": false,
753
+ "false_count": 3,
754
+ "n": 3,
755
+ "true_count": 0,
756
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
757
+ },
758
+ "snn_involved": {
759
+ "all_true": false,
760
+ "false_count": 3,
761
+ "n": 3,
762
+ "true_count": 0,
763
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
764
+ }
765
+ },
766
+ "metrics": {
767
+ "audit_item": {
768
+ "max": 3.0,
769
+ "mean": 3.0,
770
+ "median": 3.0,
771
+ "min": 3.0,
772
+ "n": 3,
773
+ "std": 0.0
774
+ }
775
+ },
776
+ "run_count": 3,
777
+ "seeds": [
778
+ 101,
779
+ 102,
780
+ 103
781
+ ]
782
+ }
783
+ },
784
+ "formulas": {
785
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
786
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
787
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
788
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
789
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
790
+ },
791
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
792
+ "run_count": 12,
793
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
794
+ }
795
+ },
796
+ "evid": [],
797
+ "literature": [
798
+ {
799
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-ODDBALL",
800
+ "authors": [
801
+ "Tristan A. Bekinschtein and others"
802
+ ],
803
+ "title": "Neural signature of the conscious processing of auditory regularities",
804
+ "year": 2009,
805
+ "doi": "10.1073/pnas.0809667106",
806
+ "topic": [
807
+ "cognition",
808
+ "methodology",
809
+ "ethics"
810
+ ],
811
+ "claims": [],
812
+ "brain5d_questions": [
813
+ "RQ-CNS-102",
814
+ "RQ-CNS-103",
815
+ "RQ-CNS-104"
816
+ ],
817
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Local/global auditory regularities and attention/report conditions; no diagnostic transfer to AI. Source: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19164526/"
818
+ }
819
+ ]
820
+ },
821
+ "quantitative_results": {
822
+ "conditions": {
823
+ "alternative_model": {
824
+ "boolean_metrics": {
825
+ "audit_complete": {
826
+ "all_true": false,
827
+ "false_count": 3,
828
+ "n": 3,
829
+ "true_count": 0,
830
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
831
+ },
832
+ "audit_template_generated": {
833
+ "all_true": true,
834
+ "false_count": 0,
835
+ "n": 3,
836
+ "true_count": 3,
837
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
838
+ },
839
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
840
+ "all_true": false,
841
+ "false_count": 3,
842
+ "n": 3,
843
+ "true_count": 0,
844
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
845
+ },
846
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
847
+ "all_true": true,
848
+ "false_count": 0,
849
+ "n": 3,
850
+ "true_count": 3,
851
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
852
+ },
853
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
854
+ "all_true": false,
855
+ "false_count": 3,
856
+ "n": 3,
857
+ "true_count": 0,
858
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
859
+ },
860
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
861
+ "all_true": false,
862
+ "false_count": 3,
863
+ "n": 3,
864
+ "true_count": 0,
865
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
866
+ },
867
+ "scientific_evidence": {
868
+ "all_true": false,
869
+ "false_count": 3,
870
+ "n": 3,
871
+ "true_count": 0,
872
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
873
+ },
874
+ "snn_involved": {
875
+ "all_true": false,
876
+ "false_count": 3,
877
+ "n": 3,
878
+ "true_count": 0,
879
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
880
+ }
881
+ },
882
+ "metrics": {
883
+ "audit_item": {
884
+ "max": 2.0,
885
+ "mean": 2.0,
886
+ "median": 2.0,
887
+ "min": 2.0,
888
+ "n": 3,
889
+ "std": 0.0
890
+ }
891
+ },
892
+ "run_count": 3,
893
+ "seeds": [
894
+ 101,
895
+ 102,
896
+ 103
897
+ ]
898
+ },
899
+ "assumption_explicit": {
900
+ "boolean_metrics": {
901
+ "audit_complete": {
902
+ "all_true": false,
903
+ "false_count": 3,
904
+ "n": 3,
905
+ "true_count": 0,
906
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
907
+ },
908
+ "audit_template_generated": {
909
+ "all_true": true,
910
+ "false_count": 0,
911
+ "n": 3,
912
+ "true_count": 3,
913
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
914
+ },
915
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
916
+ "all_true": false,
917
+ "false_count": 3,
918
+ "n": 3,
919
+ "true_count": 0,
920
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
921
+ },
922
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
923
+ "all_true": true,
924
+ "false_count": 0,
925
+ "n": 3,
926
+ "true_count": 3,
927
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
928
+ },
929
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
930
+ "all_true": false,
931
+ "false_count": 3,
932
+ "n": 3,
933
+ "true_count": 0,
934
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
935
+ },
936
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
937
+ "all_true": false,
938
+ "false_count": 3,
939
+ "n": 3,
940
+ "true_count": 0,
941
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
942
+ },
943
+ "scientific_evidence": {
944
+ "all_true": false,
945
+ "false_count": 3,
946
+ "n": 3,
947
+ "true_count": 0,
948
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
949
+ },
950
+ "snn_involved": {
951
+ "all_true": false,
952
+ "false_count": 3,
953
+ "n": 3,
954
+ "true_count": 0,
955
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
956
+ }
957
+ },
958
+ "metrics": {
959
+ "audit_item": {
960
+ "max": 1.0,
961
+ "mean": 1.0,
962
+ "median": 1.0,
963
+ "min": 1.0,
964
+ "n": 3,
965
+ "std": 0.0
966
+ }
967
+ },
968
+ "run_count": 3,
969
+ "seeds": [
970
+ 101,
971
+ 102,
972
+ 103
973
+ ]
974
+ },
975
+ "claim_boundary": {
976
+ "boolean_metrics": {
977
+ "audit_complete": {
978
+ "all_true": false,
979
+ "false_count": 3,
980
+ "n": 3,
981
+ "true_count": 0,
982
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
983
+ },
984
+ "audit_template_generated": {
985
+ "all_true": true,
986
+ "false_count": 0,
987
+ "n": 3,
988
+ "true_count": 3,
989
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
990
+ },
991
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
992
+ "all_true": false,
993
+ "false_count": 3,
994
+ "n": 3,
995
+ "true_count": 0,
996
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
997
+ },
998
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
999
+ "all_true": true,
1000
+ "false_count": 0,
1001
+ "n": 3,
1002
+ "true_count": 3,
1003
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1004
+ },
1005
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1006
+ "all_true": false,
1007
+ "false_count": 3,
1008
+ "n": 3,
1009
+ "true_count": 0,
1010
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1011
+ },
1012
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1013
+ "all_true": false,
1014
+ "false_count": 3,
1015
+ "n": 3,
1016
+ "true_count": 0,
1017
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1018
+ },
1019
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1020
+ "all_true": false,
1021
+ "false_count": 3,
1022
+ "n": 3,
1023
+ "true_count": 0,
1024
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1025
+ },
1026
+ "snn_involved": {
1027
+ "all_true": false,
1028
+ "false_count": 3,
1029
+ "n": 3,
1030
+ "true_count": 0,
1031
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1032
+ }
1033
+ },
1034
+ "metrics": {
1035
+ "audit_item": {
1036
+ "max": 4.0,
1037
+ "mean": 4.0,
1038
+ "median": 4.0,
1039
+ "min": 4.0,
1040
+ "n": 3,
1041
+ "std": 0.0
1042
+ }
1043
+ },
1044
+ "run_count": 3,
1045
+ "seeds": [
1046
+ 101,
1047
+ 102,
1048
+ 103
1049
+ ]
1050
+ },
1051
+ "measurement_limit": {
1052
+ "boolean_metrics": {
1053
+ "audit_complete": {
1054
+ "all_true": false,
1055
+ "false_count": 3,
1056
+ "n": 3,
1057
+ "true_count": 0,
1058
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1059
+ },
1060
+ "audit_template_generated": {
1061
+ "all_true": true,
1062
+ "false_count": 0,
1063
+ "n": 3,
1064
+ "true_count": 3,
1065
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1066
+ },
1067
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1068
+ "all_true": false,
1069
+ "false_count": 3,
1070
+ "n": 3,
1071
+ "true_count": 0,
1072
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1073
+ },
1074
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1075
+ "all_true": true,
1076
+ "false_count": 0,
1077
+ "n": 3,
1078
+ "true_count": 3,
1079
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1080
+ },
1081
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1082
+ "all_true": false,
1083
+ "false_count": 3,
1084
+ "n": 3,
1085
+ "true_count": 0,
1086
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1087
+ },
1088
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1089
+ "all_true": false,
1090
+ "false_count": 3,
1091
+ "n": 3,
1092
+ "true_count": 0,
1093
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1094
+ },
1095
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1096
+ "all_true": false,
1097
+ "false_count": 3,
1098
+ "n": 3,
1099
+ "true_count": 0,
1100
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1101
+ },
1102
+ "snn_involved": {
1103
+ "all_true": false,
1104
+ "false_count": 3,
1105
+ "n": 3,
1106
+ "true_count": 0,
1107
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1108
+ }
1109
+ },
1110
+ "metrics": {
1111
+ "audit_item": {
1112
+ "max": 3.0,
1113
+ "mean": 3.0,
1114
+ "median": 3.0,
1115
+ "min": 3.0,
1116
+ "n": 3,
1117
+ "std": 0.0
1118
+ }
1119
+ },
1120
+ "run_count": 3,
1121
+ "seeds": [
1122
+ 101,
1123
+ 102,
1124
+ 103
1125
+ ]
1126
+ }
1127
+ },
1128
+ "formulas": {
1129
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
1130
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
1131
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
1132
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
1133
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
1134
+ },
1135
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
1136
+ "run_count": 12,
1137
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
1138
+ },
1139
+ "observations": [
1140
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 4 für 'claim_boundary' und 3 für 'measurement_limit'.",
1141
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1142
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1143
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1144
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
1145
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1146
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1147
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1148
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
1149
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
1150
+ ],
1151
+ "interpretation": {
1152
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.",
1153
+ "confidence": 0.05,
1154
+ "effect_direction": "Es wurden keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung beobachtet, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden.",
1155
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1156
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
1157
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
1158
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
1159
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
1160
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
1161
+ ],
1162
+ "observations": [
1163
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 3 für 'measurement_limit' und 4 für 'claim_boundary'.",
1164
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1165
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1166
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1167
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
1168
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1169
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1170
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1171
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
1172
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
1173
+ ],
1174
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1175
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
1176
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
1177
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
1178
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
1179
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
1180
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
1181
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
1182
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
1183
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
1184
+ ],
1185
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1186
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
1187
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
1188
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
1189
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
1190
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
1191
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
1192
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
1193
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
1194
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
1195
+ ],
1196
+ "requested_evidence": [
1197
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
1198
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
1199
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
1200
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
1201
+ "Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
1202
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
1203
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
1204
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
1205
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
1206
+ ]
1207
+ },
1208
+ "methodological_critique": [
1209
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
1210
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
1211
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
1212
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
1213
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
1214
+ ],
1215
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1216
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
1217
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
1218
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
1219
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
1220
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
1221
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
1222
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
1223
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
1224
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
1225
+ ],
1226
+ "reproducibility": {
1227
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1228
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1229
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1230
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1231
+ "source_freeze_sha": "8d50b86a6a8130cdd21c80a91c7823fcfbf1514dd0072d25e7a853e7f1a54739",
1232
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1233
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1234
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "d82332eeae933bdbfbb384424e95aff8fc59dc69e1d47d5244605655e9b85cbc",
1235
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1236
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1237
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1238
+ "protocol_digest": "3d8364461bee2e9e25d2eeff615bb482b2c930460b28c4d034e898c95360a6fd",
1239
+ "data_digest": "4e749b40a2c84c37bbeb7300035794f68ab2ca25328157a97e30ec71729fdca5",
1240
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1241
+ },
1242
+ "epistemic_status": {
1243
+ "implementation": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1244
+ "experiment_data": "PRESENT",
1245
+ "registered_evidence": "ABSENT",
1246
+ "ai_interpretation": "PRESENT",
1247
+ "human_review": "PENDING",
1248
+ "claim_support": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1249
+ "rq_status": "IN_PROGRESS",
1250
+ "semantic_alignment": "NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED",
1251
+ "semantic_note": "Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.",
1252
+ "design_adequacy": "NOT_ASSESSED",
1253
+ "design_note": "Für diese Forschungsfrage ist keine automatische Designadäquanz-Regel registriert.",
1254
+ "confidence_gate": "PASSED"
1255
+ },
1256
+ "ai_confidence": 0.05,
1257
+ "missing_evidence": [
1258
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
1259
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
1260
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
1261
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
1262
+ "Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
1263
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
1264
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
1265
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
1266
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
1267
+ ],
1268
+ "recommended_follow_up": [
1269
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
1270
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
1271
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
1272
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
1273
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
1274
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
1275
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
1276
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
1277
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
1278
+ ],
1279
+ "conclusion": "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.",
1280
+ "human_review": {
1281
+ "status": "PENDING",
1282
+ "reviewer": null,
1283
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1284
+ "disposition": null,
1285
+ "comments": null
1286
+ },
1287
+ "aiar": {
1288
+ "analyst": {
1289
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001212341683225-09c3f8b9",
1290
+ "role": "scientific_analyst",
1291
+ "model": {
1292
+ "provider": "ollama",
1293
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1294
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1295
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1296
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1297
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1298
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1299
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1300
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1301
+ },
1302
+ "inputs": {
1303
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
1304
+ "packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad"
1305
+ },
1306
+ "output": {
1307
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine signifikanten Unterschiede in der diskriminativen Leistung unter den untersuchten Bedingungen. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten. Die Ergebnisse sind daher beschreibend und nicht inferenzfähig.",
1308
+ "observations": [
1309
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 4 für 'claim_boundary' und 3 für 'measurement_limit'.",
1310
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1311
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1312
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1313
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
1314
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1315
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1316
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1317
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
1318
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
1319
+ ],
1320
+ "effect_direction": "Es wurden keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung beobachtet, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden.",
1321
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1322
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
1323
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
1324
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
1325
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
1326
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
1327
+ ],
1328
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1329
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
1330
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
1331
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
1332
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
1333
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
1334
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
1335
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
1336
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
1337
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metri, die auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt sind, könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
1338
+ ],
1339
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1340
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
1341
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
1342
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
1343
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
1344
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
1345
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
1346
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
1347
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
1348
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
1349
+ ],
1350
+ "requested_evidence": [
1351
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
1352
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
1353
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
1354
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
1355
+ "Daten, die die native_emp, experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
1356
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
1357
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
1358
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
1359
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
1360
+ ],
1361
+ "confidence": 0.05
1362
+ },
1363
+ "provenance": {
1364
+ "prompt_sha256": "820c08ed34e159fb2231e924512b613e9a4ccc5d769e6bff25b8c9fe89dabf51",
1365
+ "research_packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad",
1366
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1367
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1368
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1369
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.05"
1370
+ },
1371
+ "epistemic_status": {
1372
+ "evidence": false,
1373
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1374
+ "human_review_required": true
1375
+ },
1376
+ "review": {
1377
+ "status": "pending",
1378
+ "reviewer": null,
1379
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1380
+ "disposition": null
1381
+ },
1382
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:23:41.683225+00:00"
1383
+ },
1384
+ "reviewer": {
1385
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212516252293-09c3f8b9",
1386
+ "role": "critical_reviewer",
1387
+ "model": {
1388
+ "provider": "ollama",
1389
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1390
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1391
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1392
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1393
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1394
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1395
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1396
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1397
+ },
1398
+ "inputs": {
1399
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
1400
+ "packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad"
1401
+ },
1402
+ "output": {
1403
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.",
1404
+ "confidence": 0.05,
1405
+ "effect_direction": "Es wurden keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung beobachtet, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden.",
1406
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1407
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
1408
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
1409
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
1410
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
1411
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
1412
+ ],
1413
+ "observations": [
1414
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 3 für 'measurement_limit' und 4 für 'claim_boundary'.",
1415
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1416
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1417
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1418
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
1419
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1420
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1421
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1422
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
1423
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
1424
+ ],
1425
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1426
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
1427
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
1428
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
1429
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
1430
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
1431
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
1432
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
1433
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
1434
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
1435
+ ],
1436
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1437
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
1438
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
1439
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
1440
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
1441
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
1442
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
1443
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
1444
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
1445
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
1446
+ ],
1447
+ "requested_evidence": [
1448
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
1449
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
1450
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
1451
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
1452
+ "Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
1453
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
1454
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
1455
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
1456
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
1457
+ ]
1458
+ },
1459
+ "provenance": {
1460
+ "prompt_sha256": "e5fa179046d1de57b4e10be091e795bfacadb368147f5137f0fee93b3acd84ce",
1461
+ "research_packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad",
1462
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1463
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1464
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1465
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.05"
1466
+ },
1467
+ "epistemic_status": {
1468
+ "evidence": false,
1469
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1470
+ "human_review_required": true
1471
+ },
1472
+ "review": {
1473
+ "status": "pending",
1474
+ "reviewer": null,
1475
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1476
+ "disposition": null
1477
+ },
1478
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:25:16.252293+00:00"
1479
+ },
1480
+ "writer": {
1481
+ "analysis_id": "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212701063609-09c3f8b9",
1482
+ "role": "scientific_writer",
1483
+ "model": {
1484
+ "provider": "ollama",
1485
+ "model_name": "qwen3:8b",
1486
+ "model_digest": "not_reported",
1487
+ "quantization": "not_reported",
1488
+ "context_length": "unknown",
1489
+ "temperature": 0.0,
1490
+ "top_p": 0.9,
1491
+ "seed": "not_reported",
1492
+ "backend_version": "unknown"
1493
+ },
1494
+ "inputs": {
1495
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
1496
+ "packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad"
1497
+ },
1498
+ "output": {
1499
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.",
1500
+ "confidence": 0.05,
1501
+ "effect_direction": "Es wurden keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung beobachtet, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden.",
1502
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1503
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
1504
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
1505
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
1506
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
1507
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
1508
+ ],
1509
+ "observations": [
1510
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 3 für 'measurement_limit' und 4 für 'claim_boundary'.",
1511
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1512
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1513
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1514
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
1515
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1516
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1517
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1518
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
1519
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
1520
+ ],
1521
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1522
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
1523
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
1524
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
1525
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
1526
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
1527
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
1528
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
1529
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
1530
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
1531
+ ],
1532
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1533
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
1534
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
1535
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
1536
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
1537
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
1538
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
1539
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
1540
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
1541
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
1542
+ ],
1543
+ "requested_evidence": [
1544
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
1545
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
1546
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
1547
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
1548
+ "Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
1549
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
1550
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
1551
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
1552
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
1553
+ ]
1554
+ },
1555
+ "provenance": {
1556
+ "prompt_sha256": "bc6e29d6f427d0ead99f2fa120a91cc6f11cbdc7edee71e326cc06f2bb14e1f9",
1557
+ "research_packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad",
1558
+ "prompt_protocol_version": "research_assistant_v1",
1559
+ "assistant_schema_version": "1.3",
1560
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1561
+ "model_self_confidence": "0.05"
1562
+ },
1563
+ "epistemic_status": {
1564
+ "evidence": false,
1565
+ "interpretation_only": true,
1566
+ "human_review_required": true
1567
+ },
1568
+ "review": {
1569
+ "status": "pending",
1570
+ "reviewer": null,
1571
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1572
+ "disposition": null
1573
+ },
1574
+ "generated_at": "2026-10-01T21:27:01.063609+00:00"
1575
+ }
1576
+ }
1577
+ },
1578
+ "provenance": {
1579
+ "research_packet_digest": "09c3f8b93866d36e4d1dbca0a80e430666bda3e0459aa4f031ad94e44b4c4aad",
1580
+ "source": {
1581
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1582
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1583
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1584
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1585
+ "source_freeze_sha": "8d50b86a6a8130cdd21c80a91c7823fcfbf1514dd0072d25e7a853e7f1a54739",
1586
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1587
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1588
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "d82332eeae933bdbfbb384424e95aff8fc59dc69e1d47d5244605655e9b85cbc",
1589
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1590
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1591
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1592
+ "protocol_digest": "3d8364461bee2e9e25d2eeff615bb482b2c930460b28c4d034e898c95360a6fd",
1593
+ "data_digest": "4e749b40a2c84c37bbeb7300035794f68ab2ca25328157a97e30ec71729fdca5",
1594
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1595
+ }
1596
+ },
1597
+ "analysis_ids": [
1598
+ "AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001212341683225-09c3f8b9",
1599
+ "AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212516252293-09c3f8b9",
1600
+ "AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212701063609-09c3f8b9"
1601
+ ],
1602
+ "supersedes": null,
1603
+ "content_digest": "37e062e9ffe2cee329772a37f52934aad85f1f26accbcf399ab5888244dd7b5e",
1604
+ "markdown_digest": "d5199bdc259db558f8e670d6444af29ee6cbf6fbd8156f87bc85cb9ca2b5ac4e"
1605
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,1350 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ ============================================================
2
+ BRAIN-5D - AI GENERATED SCIENTIFIC ANALYSIS
3
+ ============================================================
4
+
5
+ Dieser Bericht wurde durch ein kuenstliches Intelligenzsystem erzeugt.
6
+
7
+ Er stellt eine wissenschaftliche Interpretation von MHRN-Forschungsdaten dar.
8
+
9
+ Er ist KEINE wissenschaftliche Evidenz.
10
+
11
+ Er wurde zum Zeitpunkt der Erstellung noch nicht automatisch durch einen Menschen bestaetigt.
12
+
13
+ Human Review Status: PENDING
14
+ ============================================================
15
+
16
+ # AI Research Report AIRR-2026-0001
17
+
18
+ Status: review_pending | Experiment: EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02
19
+ Research Question: RQ-CNS-103
20
+ ## Executive Summary
21
+
22
+ ```json
23
+ "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten."
24
+ ```
25
+
26
+ ## Research Question
27
+
28
+ ```json
29
+ {
30
+ "id": "RQ-CNS-103",
31
+ "domain": "Attention and discrimination",
32
+ "question": "Verändert Aufgabenrelevanz die Oddball-Verarbeitung bei gleichem sensorischen Input?",
33
+ "relevance": "Active oddball; Task, report and motor effects must be separated from access claims",
34
+ "literature": [
35
+ "SRC-CNS-ODDBALL"
36
+ ],
37
+ "hypotheses": [
38
+ "H-CNS-103-A"
39
+ ],
40
+ "evidence": [],
41
+ "status": "open",
42
+ "answer": {
43
+ "current": null,
44
+ "confidence": "none",
45
+ "limitations": "Task, report and motor effects must be separated from access claims"
46
+ },
47
+ "created": "2026-09-07",
48
+ "updated": "2026-09-07"
49
+ }
50
+ ```
51
+
52
+ ## Experimental Design
53
+
54
+ ```json
55
+ {
56
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
57
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-103",
58
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-103-A",
59
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_103_v1",
60
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
61
+ "ticks": 1,
62
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
63
+ "seeds": [
64
+ 101,
65
+ 102,
66
+ 103
67
+ ],
68
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_103_v1",
69
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_103_v1",
70
+ "tick_validation": {
71
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
72
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
73
+ "requested_ticks": 1
74
+ },
75
+ "notes": "Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
76
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
77
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
78
+ "epistemic_layers": {
79
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
80
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
81
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
82
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
83
+ }
84
+ }
85
+ ```
86
+
87
+ ## Data Basis
88
+
89
+ ```json
90
+ {
91
+ "data": {
92
+ "ai_input_policy": "compact_only_raw_on_explicit_deterministic_extract",
93
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_research_data_v2",
94
+ "limits": {
95
+ "ai_packet_max_bytes": 1000000,
96
+ "run_summary_max_bytes": 5000000,
97
+ "sequence_preview_items": 16
98
+ },
99
+ "raw_index": {
100
+ "path": "DATA/runs_index.json",
101
+ "run_count": 12,
102
+ "sha256": "e8bf8c5077c072dc32be4e1528646316a6aca067d3a82053cf98f7a97ebce700"
103
+ },
104
+ "run_count": 12,
105
+ "run_preview": [
106
+ {
107
+ "_raw_artifact": {
108
+ "format": "json.gz",
109
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
110
+ "sha256": "57995dbbf923c83ba027ae13f628d9bc7494a0e4bccbb478333d432205e5fd03",
111
+ "size_bytes": 525,
112
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
113
+ },
114
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
115
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
116
+ "metrics": {
117
+ "audit_complete": false,
118
+ "audit_item": 1,
119
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
120
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
121
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
122
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
123
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
124
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
125
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
126
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
127
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
128
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
129
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
130
+ "snn_involved": false
131
+ },
132
+ "runtime_error": null,
133
+ "seed": 101,
134
+ "state_digest_after": "3facf879e515c8168e512133acac6dd23b9768453c18032a480a21738b4678d1",
135
+ "state_digest_before": "3facf879e515c8168e512133acac6dd23b9768453c18032a480a21738b4678d1"
136
+ },
137
+ {
138
+ "_raw_artifact": {
139
+ "format": "json.gz",
140
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
141
+ "sha256": "74100a7069f39de4bb4b81a4673ad3f623e5fad456276d56af48fb4e49bee539",
142
+ "size_bytes": 521,
143
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
144
+ },
145
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
146
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
147
+ "metrics": {
148
+ "audit_complete": false,
149
+ "audit_item": 2,
150
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
151
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
152
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
153
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
154
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
155
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
156
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
157
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
158
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
159
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
160
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
161
+ "snn_involved": false
162
+ },
163
+ "runtime_error": null,
164
+ "seed": 101,
165
+ "state_digest_after": "7c0489a18ccda3ddc27319a734aea3ce84570f40050a211b097b92f81fb397cc",
166
+ "state_digest_before": "7c0489a18ccda3ddc27319a734aea3ce84570f40050a211b097b92f81fb397cc"
167
+ },
168
+ {
169
+ "_raw_artifact": {
170
+ "format": "json.gz",
171
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
172
+ "sha256": "7a28fdce82f24f1fd9076591d9413347c7ad927fc3de3cdbc088635ef321e69b",
173
+ "size_bytes": 520,
174
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
175
+ },
176
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
177
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
178
+ "metrics": {
179
+ "audit_complete": false,
180
+ "audit_item": 3,
181
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
182
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
183
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
184
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
185
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
186
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
187
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
188
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
189
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
190
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
191
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
192
+ "snn_involved": false
193
+ },
194
+ "runtime_error": null,
195
+ "seed": 101,
196
+ "state_digest_after": "f4e9664aa1cfac4df986899ed5f28dad27e31eb2278b54c1beec233cf3c90148",
197
+ "state_digest_before": "f4e9664aa1cfac4df986899ed5f28dad27e31eb2278b54c1beec233cf3c90148"
198
+ },
199
+ {
200
+ "_raw_artifact": {
201
+ "format": "json.gz",
202
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
203
+ "sha256": "e97356ef9df242bcb4bbb00cafe25a11362d56577c195feecc33cbc5c560f6bc",
204
+ "size_bytes": 514,
205
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
206
+ },
207
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
208
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
209
+ "metrics": {
210
+ "audit_complete": false,
211
+ "audit_item": 4,
212
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
213
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
214
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
215
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
216
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
217
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
218
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
219
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
220
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
221
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
222
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
223
+ "snn_involved": false
224
+ },
225
+ "runtime_error": null,
226
+ "seed": 101,
227
+ "state_digest_after": "55e11537a1163df39baacdf679cce8712f276e3052a5cbeff110d303dd788f67",
228
+ "state_digest_before": "55e11537a1163df39baacdf679cce8712f276e3052a5cbeff110d303dd788f67"
229
+ },
230
+ {
231
+ "_raw_artifact": {
232
+ "format": "json.gz",
233
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
234
+ "sha256": "64aba07cd48458a6a2e7b4129669489f09b5918579c95d2cbfffdb3652f14e91",
235
+ "size_bytes": 524,
236
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
237
+ },
238
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
239
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
240
+ "metrics": {
241
+ "audit_complete": false,
242
+ "audit_item": 1,
243
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
244
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
245
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
246
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
247
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
248
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
249
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
250
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
251
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
252
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
253
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
254
+ "snn_involved": false
255
+ },
256
+ "runtime_error": null,
257
+ "seed": 102,
258
+ "state_digest_after": "28dc2f759d9be275a7af979adda4b9d62eae9ba188eb62ae66ae61ec57e03029",
259
+ "state_digest_before": "28dc2f759d9be275a7af979adda4b9d62eae9ba188eb62ae66ae61ec57e03029"
260
+ },
261
+ {
262
+ "_raw_artifact": {
263
+ "format": "json.gz",
264
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
265
+ "sha256": "b46852a23f99f6065d0c15af9b7ce8a5a3cedc47752c579509ea6451d16ce958",
266
+ "size_bytes": 520,
267
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
268
+ },
269
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
270
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
271
+ "metrics": {
272
+ "audit_complete": false,
273
+ "audit_item": 2,
274
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
275
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
276
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
277
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
278
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
279
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
280
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
281
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
282
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
283
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
284
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
285
+ "snn_involved": false
286
+ },
287
+ "runtime_error": null,
288
+ "seed": 102,
289
+ "state_digest_after": "c2e57a9288669ab58c1ae658f21cae38c121608835b36d36259c5b927209bc00",
290
+ "state_digest_before": "c2e57a9288669ab58c1ae658f21cae38c121608835b36d36259c5b927209bc00"
291
+ },
292
+ {
293
+ "_raw_artifact": {
294
+ "format": "json.gz",
295
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
296
+ "sha256": "ed42b90c8d82d15c3ad057ea1a9a49895662fa1d077106caa22f0edced8108a6",
297
+ "size_bytes": 520,
298
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
299
+ },
300
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
301
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
302
+ "metrics": {
303
+ "audit_complete": false,
304
+ "audit_item": 3,
305
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
306
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
307
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
308
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
309
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
310
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
311
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
312
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
313
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
314
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
315
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
316
+ "snn_involved": false
317
+ },
318
+ "runtime_error": null,
319
+ "seed": 102,
320
+ "state_digest_after": "d11a131b2610419bfa8247b3ac00129bf73dff3f2149ac8b7f4aca5d9c31c10f",
321
+ "state_digest_before": "d11a131b2610419bfa8247b3ac00129bf73dff3f2149ac8b7f4aca5d9c31c10f"
322
+ },
323
+ {
324
+ "_raw_artifact": {
325
+ "format": "json.gz",
326
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
327
+ "sha256": "a0515313f2b98a429c431843b72264bc7bb61f11bf402834713f2971c7b6895f",
328
+ "size_bytes": 516,
329
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
330
+ },
331
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
332
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
333
+ "metrics": {
334
+ "audit_complete": false,
335
+ "audit_item": 4,
336
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
337
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
338
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
339
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
340
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
341
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
342
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
343
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
344
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
345
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
346
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
347
+ "snn_involved": false
348
+ },
349
+ "runtime_error": null,
350
+ "seed": 102,
351
+ "state_digest_after": "c52bea79aa4852a82ccb4d035294f50ae2564223c55e48696356aad7a77f52a2",
352
+ "state_digest_before": "c52bea79aa4852a82ccb4d035294f50ae2564223c55e48696356aad7a77f52a2"
353
+ },
354
+ {
355
+ "_raw_artifact": {
356
+ "format": "json.gz",
357
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
358
+ "sha256": "eb8e0b0fbf849cdcf65629f2e7d04e9aeb69d3b5d31ee375551684c7b465d843",
359
+ "size_bytes": 526,
360
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
361
+ },
362
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
363
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
364
+ "metrics": {
365
+ "audit_complete": false,
366
+ "audit_item": 1,
367
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
368
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
369
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
370
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
371
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
372
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
373
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
374
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
375
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
376
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
377
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
378
+ "snn_involved": false
379
+ },
380
+ "runtime_error": null,
381
+ "seed": 103,
382
+ "state_digest_after": "47b8a9e85e3f10c15cabbe719b218485293644c6887bf9961e5f4003f413ca77",
383
+ "state_digest_before": "47b8a9e85e3f10c15cabbe719b218485293644c6887bf9961e5f4003f413ca77"
384
+ },
385
+ {
386
+ "_raw_artifact": {
387
+ "format": "json.gz",
388
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
389
+ "sha256": "db1de0e235657617ce755d48ebd81f0051c76359691e1dea087de910ff29a68c",
390
+ "size_bytes": 519,
391
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
392
+ },
393
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
394
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
395
+ "metrics": {
396
+ "audit_complete": false,
397
+ "audit_item": 2,
398
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
399
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
400
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
401
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
402
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
403
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
404
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
405
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
406
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
407
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
408
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
409
+ "snn_involved": false
410
+ },
411
+ "runtime_error": null,
412
+ "seed": 103,
413
+ "state_digest_after": "ce7a03e9a37d39949eb6eec32fa6e018e43c9095e5680638d9fe0a86cb427153",
414
+ "state_digest_before": "ce7a03e9a37d39949eb6eec32fa6e018e43c9095e5680638d9fe0a86cb427153"
415
+ },
416
+ {
417
+ "_raw_artifact": {
418
+ "format": "json.gz",
419
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
420
+ "sha256": "c5361d083e3184ddd2b0f663fd0b410a7496e139799ea6fac763aec9fee5cc61",
421
+ "size_bytes": 521,
422
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
423
+ },
424
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
425
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
426
+ "metrics": {
427
+ "audit_complete": false,
428
+ "audit_item": 3,
429
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
430
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
431
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
432
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
433
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
434
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
435
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
436
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
437
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
438
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
439
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
440
+ "snn_involved": false
441
+ },
442
+ "runtime_error": null,
443
+ "seed": 103,
444
+ "state_digest_after": "8badc1585f187a7b840231216fa7da37148c2cb26f7aac521daf68ad3c909453",
445
+ "state_digest_before": "8badc1585f187a7b840231216fa7da37148c2cb26f7aac521daf68ad3c909453"
446
+ },
447
+ {
448
+ "_raw_artifact": {
449
+ "format": "json.gz",
450
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
451
+ "sha256": "4ce7011d1170d35a87339351d1a2a3937ce99ec12a859dcc78c1c843a3003a9f",
452
+ "size_bytes": 517,
453
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
454
+ },
455
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
456
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
457
+ "metrics": {
458
+ "audit_complete": false,
459
+ "audit_item": 4,
460
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
461
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
462
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
463
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
464
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
465
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
466
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
467
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
468
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
469
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
470
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
471
+ "snn_involved": false
472
+ },
473
+ "runtime_error": null,
474
+ "seed": 103,
475
+ "state_digest_after": "24ab478280b801364482455f3458bbd413b886cc8b927fcfbb815ebdd5083210",
476
+ "state_digest_before": "24ab478280b801364482455f3458bbd413b886cc8b927fcfbb815ebdd5083210"
477
+ }
478
+ ],
479
+ "schema_version": "2.0",
480
+ "statistics": {
481
+ "conditions": {
482
+ "alternative_model": {
483
+ "boolean_metrics": {
484
+ "audit_complete": {
485
+ "all_true": false,
486
+ "false_count": 3,
487
+ "n": 3,
488
+ "true_count": 0,
489
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
490
+ },
491
+ "audit_template_generated": {
492
+ "all_true": true,
493
+ "false_count": 0,
494
+ "n": 3,
495
+ "true_count": 3,
496
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
497
+ },
498
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
499
+ "all_true": false,
500
+ "false_count": 3,
501
+ "n": 3,
502
+ "true_count": 0,
503
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
504
+ },
505
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
506
+ "all_true": true,
507
+ "false_count": 0,
508
+ "n": 3,
509
+ "true_count": 3,
510
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
511
+ },
512
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
513
+ "all_true": false,
514
+ "false_count": 3,
515
+ "n": 3,
516
+ "true_count": 0,
517
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
518
+ },
519
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
520
+ "all_true": false,
521
+ "false_count": 3,
522
+ "n": 3,
523
+ "true_count": 0,
524
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
525
+ },
526
+ "scientific_evidence": {
527
+ "all_true": false,
528
+ "false_count": 3,
529
+ "n": 3,
530
+ "true_count": 0,
531
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
532
+ },
533
+ "snn_involved": {
534
+ "all_true": false,
535
+ "false_count": 3,
536
+ "n": 3,
537
+ "true_count": 0,
538
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
539
+ }
540
+ },
541
+ "metrics": {
542
+ "audit_item": {
543
+ "max": 2.0,
544
+ "mean": 2.0,
545
+ "median": 2.0,
546
+ "min": 2.0,
547
+ "n": 3,
548
+ "std": 0.0
549
+ }
550
+ },
551
+ "run_count": 3,
552
+ "seeds": [
553
+ 101,
554
+ 102,
555
+ 103
556
+ ]
557
+ },
558
+ "assumption_explicit": {
559
+ "boolean_metrics": {
560
+ "audit_complete": {
561
+ "all_true": false,
562
+ "false_count": 3,
563
+ "n": 3,
564
+ "true_count": 0,
565
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
566
+ },
567
+ "audit_template_generated": {
568
+ "all_true": true,
569
+ "false_count": 0,
570
+ "n": 3,
571
+ "true_count": 3,
572
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
573
+ },
574
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
575
+ "all_true": false,
576
+ "false_count": 3,
577
+ "n": 3,
578
+ "true_count": 0,
579
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
580
+ },
581
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
582
+ "all_true": true,
583
+ "false_count": 0,
584
+ "n": 3,
585
+ "true_count": 3,
586
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
587
+ },
588
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
589
+ "all_true": false,
590
+ "false_count": 3,
591
+ "n": 3,
592
+ "true_count": 0,
593
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
594
+ },
595
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
596
+ "all_true": false,
597
+ "false_count": 3,
598
+ "n": 3,
599
+ "true_count": 0,
600
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
601
+ },
602
+ "scientific_evidence": {
603
+ "all_true": false,
604
+ "false_count": 3,
605
+ "n": 3,
606
+ "true_count": 0,
607
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
608
+ },
609
+ "snn_involved": {
610
+ "all_true": false,
611
+ "false_count": 3,
612
+ "n": 3,
613
+ "true_count": 0,
614
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
615
+ }
616
+ },
617
+ "metrics": {
618
+ "audit_item": {
619
+ "max": 1.0,
620
+ "mean": 1.0,
621
+ "median": 1.0,
622
+ "min": 1.0,
623
+ "n": 3,
624
+ "std": 0.0
625
+ }
626
+ },
627
+ "run_count": 3,
628
+ "seeds": [
629
+ 101,
630
+ 102,
631
+ 103
632
+ ]
633
+ },
634
+ "claim_boundary": {
635
+ "boolean_metrics": {
636
+ "audit_complete": {
637
+ "all_true": false,
638
+ "false_count": 3,
639
+ "n": 3,
640
+ "true_count": 0,
641
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
642
+ },
643
+ "audit_template_generated": {
644
+ "all_true": true,
645
+ "false_count": 0,
646
+ "n": 3,
647
+ "true_count": 3,
648
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
649
+ },
650
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
651
+ "all_true": false,
652
+ "false_count": 3,
653
+ "n": 3,
654
+ "true_count": 0,
655
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
656
+ },
657
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
658
+ "all_true": true,
659
+ "false_count": 0,
660
+ "n": 3,
661
+ "true_count": 3,
662
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
663
+ },
664
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
665
+ "all_true": false,
666
+ "false_count": 3,
667
+ "n": 3,
668
+ "true_count": 0,
669
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
670
+ },
671
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
672
+ "all_true": false,
673
+ "false_count": 3,
674
+ "n": 3,
675
+ "true_count": 0,
676
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
677
+ },
678
+ "scientific_evidence": {
679
+ "all_true": false,
680
+ "false_count": 3,
681
+ "n": 3,
682
+ "true_count": 0,
683
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
684
+ },
685
+ "snn_involved": {
686
+ "all_true": false,
687
+ "false_count": 3,
688
+ "n": 3,
689
+ "true_count": 0,
690
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
691
+ }
692
+ },
693
+ "metrics": {
694
+ "audit_item": {
695
+ "max": 4.0,
696
+ "mean": 4.0,
697
+ "median": 4.0,
698
+ "min": 4.0,
699
+ "n": 3,
700
+ "std": 0.0
701
+ }
702
+ },
703
+ "run_count": 3,
704
+ "seeds": [
705
+ 101,
706
+ 102,
707
+ 103
708
+ ]
709
+ },
710
+ "measurement_limit": {
711
+ "boolean_metrics": {
712
+ "audit_complete": {
713
+ "all_true": false,
714
+ "false_count": 3,
715
+ "n": 3,
716
+ "true_count": 0,
717
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
718
+ },
719
+ "audit_template_generated": {
720
+ "all_true": true,
721
+ "false_count": 0,
722
+ "n": 3,
723
+ "true_count": 3,
724
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
725
+ },
726
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
727
+ "all_true": false,
728
+ "false_count": 3,
729
+ "n": 3,
730
+ "true_count": 0,
731
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
732
+ },
733
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
734
+ "all_true": true,
735
+ "false_count": 0,
736
+ "n": 3,
737
+ "true_count": 3,
738
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
739
+ },
740
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
741
+ "all_true": false,
742
+ "false_count": 3,
743
+ "n": 3,
744
+ "true_count": 0,
745
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
746
+ },
747
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
748
+ "all_true": false,
749
+ "false_count": 3,
750
+ "n": 3,
751
+ "true_count": 0,
752
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
753
+ },
754
+ "scientific_evidence": {
755
+ "all_true": false,
756
+ "false_count": 3,
757
+ "n": 3,
758
+ "true_count": 0,
759
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
760
+ },
761
+ "snn_involved": {
762
+ "all_true": false,
763
+ "false_count": 3,
764
+ "n": 3,
765
+ "true_count": 0,
766
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
767
+ }
768
+ },
769
+ "metrics": {
770
+ "audit_item": {
771
+ "max": 3.0,
772
+ "mean": 3.0,
773
+ "median": 3.0,
774
+ "min": 3.0,
775
+ "n": 3,
776
+ "std": 0.0
777
+ }
778
+ },
779
+ "run_count": 3,
780
+ "seeds": [
781
+ 101,
782
+ 102,
783
+ 103
784
+ ]
785
+ }
786
+ },
787
+ "formulas": {
788
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
789
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
790
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
791
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
792
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
793
+ },
794
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
795
+ "run_count": 12,
796
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
797
+ }
798
+ },
799
+ "evid": [],
800
+ "literature": [
801
+ {
802
+ "source_id": "SRC-CNS-ODDBALL",
803
+ "authors": [
804
+ "Tristan A. Bekinschtein and others"
805
+ ],
806
+ "title": "Neural signature of the conscious processing of auditory regularities",
807
+ "year": 2009,
808
+ "doi": "10.1073/pnas.0809667106",
809
+ "topic": [
810
+ "cognition",
811
+ "methodology",
812
+ "ethics"
813
+ ],
814
+ "claims": [],
815
+ "brain5d_questions": [
816
+ "RQ-CNS-102",
817
+ "RQ-CNS-103",
818
+ "RQ-CNS-104"
819
+ ],
820
+ "brain5d_relevance": "Local/global auditory regularities and attention/report conditions; no diagnostic transfer to AI. Source: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19164526/"
821
+ }
822
+ ]
823
+ }
824
+ ```
825
+
826
+ ## Quantitative Results
827
+
828
+ ```json
829
+ {
830
+ "conditions": {
831
+ "alternative_model": {
832
+ "boolean_metrics": {
833
+ "audit_complete": {
834
+ "all_true": false,
835
+ "false_count": 3,
836
+ "n": 3,
837
+ "true_count": 0,
838
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
839
+ },
840
+ "audit_template_generated": {
841
+ "all_true": true,
842
+ "false_count": 0,
843
+ "n": 3,
844
+ "true_count": 3,
845
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
846
+ },
847
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
848
+ "all_true": false,
849
+ "false_count": 3,
850
+ "n": 3,
851
+ "true_count": 0,
852
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
853
+ },
854
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
855
+ "all_true": true,
856
+ "false_count": 0,
857
+ "n": 3,
858
+ "true_count": 3,
859
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
860
+ },
861
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
862
+ "all_true": false,
863
+ "false_count": 3,
864
+ "n": 3,
865
+ "true_count": 0,
866
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
867
+ },
868
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
869
+ "all_true": false,
870
+ "false_count": 3,
871
+ "n": 3,
872
+ "true_count": 0,
873
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
874
+ },
875
+ "scientific_evidence": {
876
+ "all_true": false,
877
+ "false_count": 3,
878
+ "n": 3,
879
+ "true_count": 0,
880
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
881
+ },
882
+ "snn_involved": {
883
+ "all_true": false,
884
+ "false_count": 3,
885
+ "n": 3,
886
+ "true_count": 0,
887
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
888
+ }
889
+ },
890
+ "metrics": {
891
+ "audit_item": {
892
+ "max": 2.0,
893
+ "mean": 2.0,
894
+ "median": 2.0,
895
+ "min": 2.0,
896
+ "n": 3,
897
+ "std": 0.0
898
+ }
899
+ },
900
+ "run_count": 3,
901
+ "seeds": [
902
+ 101,
903
+ 102,
904
+ 103
905
+ ]
906
+ },
907
+ "assumption_explicit": {
908
+ "boolean_metrics": {
909
+ "audit_complete": {
910
+ "all_true": false,
911
+ "false_count": 3,
912
+ "n": 3,
913
+ "true_count": 0,
914
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
915
+ },
916
+ "audit_template_generated": {
917
+ "all_true": true,
918
+ "false_count": 0,
919
+ "n": 3,
920
+ "true_count": 3,
921
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
922
+ },
923
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
924
+ "all_true": false,
925
+ "false_count": 3,
926
+ "n": 3,
927
+ "true_count": 0,
928
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
929
+ },
930
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
931
+ "all_true": true,
932
+ "false_count": 0,
933
+ "n": 3,
934
+ "true_count": 3,
935
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
936
+ },
937
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
938
+ "all_true": false,
939
+ "false_count": 3,
940
+ "n": 3,
941
+ "true_count": 0,
942
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
943
+ },
944
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
945
+ "all_true": false,
946
+ "false_count": 3,
947
+ "n": 3,
948
+ "true_count": 0,
949
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
950
+ },
951
+ "scientific_evidence": {
952
+ "all_true": false,
953
+ "false_count": 3,
954
+ "n": 3,
955
+ "true_count": 0,
956
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
957
+ },
958
+ "snn_involved": {
959
+ "all_true": false,
960
+ "false_count": 3,
961
+ "n": 3,
962
+ "true_count": 0,
963
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
964
+ }
965
+ },
966
+ "metrics": {
967
+ "audit_item": {
968
+ "max": 1.0,
969
+ "mean": 1.0,
970
+ "median": 1.0,
971
+ "min": 1.0,
972
+ "n": 3,
973
+ "std": 0.0
974
+ }
975
+ },
976
+ "run_count": 3,
977
+ "seeds": [
978
+ 101,
979
+ 102,
980
+ 103
981
+ ]
982
+ },
983
+ "claim_boundary": {
984
+ "boolean_metrics": {
985
+ "audit_complete": {
986
+ "all_true": false,
987
+ "false_count": 3,
988
+ "n": 3,
989
+ "true_count": 0,
990
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
991
+ },
992
+ "audit_template_generated": {
993
+ "all_true": true,
994
+ "false_count": 0,
995
+ "n": 3,
996
+ "true_count": 3,
997
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
998
+ },
999
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1000
+ "all_true": false,
1001
+ "false_count": 3,
1002
+ "n": 3,
1003
+ "true_count": 0,
1004
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1005
+ },
1006
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1007
+ "all_true": true,
1008
+ "false_count": 0,
1009
+ "n": 3,
1010
+ "true_count": 3,
1011
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1012
+ },
1013
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1014
+ "all_true": false,
1015
+ "false_count": 3,
1016
+ "n": 3,
1017
+ "true_count": 0,
1018
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1019
+ },
1020
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1021
+ "all_true": false,
1022
+ "false_count": 3,
1023
+ "n": 3,
1024
+ "true_count": 0,
1025
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1026
+ },
1027
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1028
+ "all_true": false,
1029
+ "false_count": 3,
1030
+ "n": 3,
1031
+ "true_count": 0,
1032
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1033
+ },
1034
+ "snn_involved": {
1035
+ "all_true": false,
1036
+ "false_count": 3,
1037
+ "n": 3,
1038
+ "true_count": 0,
1039
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1040
+ }
1041
+ },
1042
+ "metrics": {
1043
+ "audit_item": {
1044
+ "max": 4.0,
1045
+ "mean": 4.0,
1046
+ "median": 4.0,
1047
+ "min": 4.0,
1048
+ "n": 3,
1049
+ "std": 0.0
1050
+ }
1051
+ },
1052
+ "run_count": 3,
1053
+ "seeds": [
1054
+ 101,
1055
+ 102,
1056
+ 103
1057
+ ]
1058
+ },
1059
+ "measurement_limit": {
1060
+ "boolean_metrics": {
1061
+ "audit_complete": {
1062
+ "all_true": false,
1063
+ "false_count": 3,
1064
+ "n": 3,
1065
+ "true_count": 0,
1066
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1067
+ },
1068
+ "audit_template_generated": {
1069
+ "all_true": true,
1070
+ "false_count": 0,
1071
+ "n": 3,
1072
+ "true_count": 3,
1073
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1074
+ },
1075
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": {
1076
+ "all_true": false,
1077
+ "false_count": 3,
1078
+ "n": 3,
1079
+ "true_count": 0,
1080
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1081
+ },
1082
+ "conceptual_or_normative": {
1083
+ "all_true": true,
1084
+ "false_count": 0,
1085
+ "n": 3,
1086
+ "true_count": 3,
1087
+ "true_fraction": 1.0
1088
+ },
1089
+ "native_empirical_experiment": {
1090
+ "all_true": false,
1091
+ "false_count": 3,
1092
+ "n": 3,
1093
+ "true_count": 0,
1094
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1095
+ },
1096
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": {
1097
+ "all_true": false,
1098
+ "false_count": 3,
1099
+ "n": 3,
1100
+ "true_count": 0,
1101
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1102
+ },
1103
+ "scientific_evidence": {
1104
+ "all_true": false,
1105
+ "false_count": 3,
1106
+ "n": 3,
1107
+ "true_count": 0,
1108
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1109
+ },
1110
+ "snn_involved": {
1111
+ "all_true": false,
1112
+ "false_count": 3,
1113
+ "n": 3,
1114
+ "true_count": 0,
1115
+ "true_fraction": 0.0
1116
+ }
1117
+ },
1118
+ "metrics": {
1119
+ "audit_item": {
1120
+ "max": 3.0,
1121
+ "mean": 3.0,
1122
+ "median": 3.0,
1123
+ "min": 3.0,
1124
+ "n": 3,
1125
+ "std": 0.0
1126
+ }
1127
+ },
1128
+ "run_count": 3,
1129
+ "seeds": [
1130
+ 101,
1131
+ 102,
1132
+ 103
1133
+ ]
1134
+ }
1135
+ },
1136
+ "formulas": {
1137
+ "difference": "Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)",
1138
+ "inter_spike_interval": "ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i",
1139
+ "mean": "mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i",
1140
+ "population_std": "sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)",
1141
+ "ratio": "R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A), defined only when mean(x_A) != 0"
1142
+ },
1143
+ "generated_by": "deterministic_statistics_engine",
1144
+ "run_count": 12,
1145
+ "schema_version": "2.2"
1146
+ }
1147
+ ```
1148
+
1149
+ ## Observations
1150
+
1151
+ ```json
1152
+ [
1153
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 4 für 'claim_boundary' und 3 für 'measurement_limit'.",
1154
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1155
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1156
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1157
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
1158
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1159
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1160
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1161
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
1162
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
1163
+ ]
1164
+ ```
1165
+
1166
+ ## Interpretation
1167
+
1168
+ ```json
1169
+ {
1170
+ "assessment": "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.",
1171
+ "confidence": 0.05,
1172
+ "effect_direction": "Es wurden keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung beobachtet, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden.",
1173
+ "methodological_concerns": [
1174
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
1175
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
1176
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
1177
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
1178
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
1179
+ ],
1180
+ "observations": [
1181
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen konstant: 1 für 'assumption_explicit', 2 für 'alternative_model', 3 für 'measurement_limit' und 4 für 'claim_boundary'.",
1182
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1183
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1184
+ "Die snn_involved-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1185
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet.",
1186
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1187
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt.",
1188
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf wahr gesetzt.",
1189
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht beansprucht.",
1190
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf 'research/external_review/README.md' gesetzt."
1191
+ ],
1192
+ "alternative_explanations": [
1193
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
1194
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
1195
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
1196
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
1197
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
1198
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
1199
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
1200
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
1201
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
1202
+ ],
1203
+ "recommended_experiments": [
1204
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
1205
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
1206
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
1207
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
1208
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
1209
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
1210
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
1211
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
1212
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
1213
+ ],
1214
+ "requested_evidence": [
1215
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
1216
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
1217
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
1218
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
1219
+ "Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
1220
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
1221
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
1222
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
1223
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
1224
+ ]
1225
+ }
1226
+ ```
1227
+
1228
+ ## Methodological Critique
1229
+
1230
+ ```json
1231
+ [
1232
+ "Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.",
1233
+ "Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.",
1234
+ "Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.",
1235
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.",
1236
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet."
1237
+ ]
1238
+ ```
1239
+
1240
+ ## Alternative Explanations
1241
+
1242
+ ```json
1243
+ [
1244
+ "Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.",
1245
+ "Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.",
1246
+ "Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.",
1247
+ "Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.",
1248
+ "Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.",
1249
+ "Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.",
1250
+ "Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.",
1251
+ "Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.",
1252
+ "Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen."
1253
+ ]
1254
+ ```
1255
+
1256
+ ## Reproducibility
1257
+
1258
+ ```json
1259
+ {
1260
+ "git_commit": "1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3",
1261
+ "experiment_status": "completed",
1262
+ "evidence_mode": "not_reported",
1263
+ "git_dirty": "True",
1264
+ "source_freeze_sha": "8d50b86a6a8130cdd21c80a91c7823fcfbf1514dd0072d25e7a853e7f1a54739",
1265
+ "configuration_path": "F:\\Brain-5D\\configs\\learning_experiment.yaml",
1266
+ "configuration_sha256": "6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c",
1267
+ "experiment_manifest_digest": "d82332eeae933bdbfbb384424e95aff8fc59dc69e1d47d5244605655e9b85cbc",
1268
+ "data_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1269
+ "evid_ids": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1270
+ "protocol_id": "NOT_AVAILABLE",
1271
+ "protocol_digest": "3d8364461bee2e9e25d2eeff615bb482b2c930460b28c4d034e898c95360a6fd",
1272
+ "data_digest": "4e749b40a2c84c37bbeb7300035794f68ab2ca25328157a97e30ec71729fdca5",
1273
+ "evid_digests": "[]"
1274
+ }
1275
+ ```
1276
+
1277
+ ## Epistemic Status
1278
+
1279
+ ```json
1280
+ {
1281
+ "implementation": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1282
+ "experiment_data": "PRESENT",
1283
+ "registered_evidence": "ABSENT",
1284
+ "ai_interpretation": "PRESENT",
1285
+ "human_review": "PENDING",
1286
+ "claim_support": "NOT_DETERMINED",
1287
+ "rq_status": "IN_PROGRESS",
1288
+ "semantic_alignment": "NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED",
1289
+ "semantic_note": "Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.",
1290
+ "design_adequacy": "NOT_ASSESSED",
1291
+ "design_note": "Für diese Forschungsfrage ist keine automatische Designadäquanz-Regel registriert.",
1292
+ "confidence_gate": "PASSED"
1293
+ }
1294
+ ```
1295
+
1296
+ ## Missing Evidence
1297
+
1298
+ ```json
1299
+ [
1300
+ "Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.",
1301
+ "Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.",
1302
+ "Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.",
1303
+ "Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.",
1304
+ "Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.",
1305
+ "Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.",
1306
+ "Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.",
1307
+ "Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.",
1308
+ "Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen."
1309
+ ]
1310
+ ```
1311
+
1312
+ ## Recommended Follow-up Experiments
1313
+
1314
+ ```json
1315
+ [
1316
+ "Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.",
1317
+ "Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.",
1318
+ "Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.",
1319
+ "Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.",
1320
+ "Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.",
1321
+ "Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.",
1322
+ "Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.",
1323
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.",
1324
+ "Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft."
1325
+ ]
1326
+ ```
1327
+
1328
+ ## Conclusion
1329
+
1330
+ ```json
1331
+ "Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten."
1332
+ ```
1333
+
1334
+ ## Human Review
1335
+
1336
+ ```json
1337
+ {
1338
+ "status": "PENDING",
1339
+ "reviewer": null,
1340
+ "reviewed_at": null,
1341
+ "disposition": null,
1342
+ "comments": null
1343
+ }
1344
+ ```
1345
+
1346
+ AI confidence: 0.05
1347
+ This value describes internal AI confidence and is not a statistical confidence interval.
1348
+
1349
+ Content digest: 37e062e9ffe2cee329772a37f52934aad85f1f26accbcf399ab5888244dd7b5e
1350
+ JSON/Markdown link digest: d5199bdc259db558f8e670d6444af29ee6cbf6fbd8156f87bc85cb9ca2b5ac4e
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/reports/AIRR-2026-0001.review.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "report_id": "AIRR-2026-0001",
3
+ "review_status": "accepted_as_interpretation",
4
+ "reviewer": "Thomas Heisig",
5
+ "reviewed_at": "2026-10-02T18:23:55.527467+00:00",
6
+ "comments": "# Review: EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02\n\nMit dem dritten Datensatz lässt sich die Serie als Ganzes bewerten – und der wichtigste neue Befund betrifft **nicht** die Zahlen, sondern den **AIRR-Output**.\n\n## ✅ Serien-Konsistenz bestätigt\n\n| Feld | PILOT2-01 | REMAINDER-01 | REMAINDER-02 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| Code-Digest | `5a11ea28…` | `5a11ea28…` | `5a11ea28…` ✅ |\n| Config-Digest | `6f6cd457…` | `6f6cd457…` | `6f6cd457…` ✅ |\n| Prompt-Digest | `dd18e473…` | `dd18e473…` | `dd18e473…` ✅ |\n| Runner-Bytecode | `93e483e2…` | `93e483e2…` | `93e483e2…` ✅ |\n| Summary-Bytecode | `462bf872…` | `462bf872…` | `462bf872…` ✅ |\n| Source/Runtime MATCH | ja | ja | ja ✅ |\n| dirty | true | true | true |\n| R0 | ja | ja | ja |\n| audit_complete | false (0/3) | false (0/3) | false (0/3) |\n| audit_item-Werte | 2,1,4,3 | 2,1,4,3 | 2,1,4,3 |\n| RQ/Condition | NOT_CLASSIFIED | NOT_CLASSIFIED | NOT_CLASSIFIED |\n\n**Die drei Datensätze sind strukturell isomorph.** Nur RQ, H und Protokoll inkrementieren (101 → 102 → 103). Das ist die richtige Konsistenz – aber es wirft die Frage auf, ob die Serie tatsächlich **drei unabhängige Audits** oder **drei Varianten desselben Audits** darstellt.\n\n## 🔴 Der wichtigste neue Befund: AIRR halluziniert Kontext\n\nDer AIRR-Text in REMAINDER-02 enthält Begriffe, die **im Manifest nicht existieren**:\n\n### Begriffe im AIRR, die im Manifest fehlen\n\n| AIRR-Begriff | Im Manifest? | Im statistics.json? |\n|---|---|---|\n| „aktive Zielerkennung\" | ❌ | ❌ |\n| „passive Zielerkennung\" | ❌ | ❌ |\n| „diskriminative Leistung\" | ❌ | ❌ |\n| „externe LLM-Wissen\" | ❌ | ❌ |\n| „external_ethics_approval\" | ❌ | ❌ |\n| „external_review_instrument\" | ❌ | ❌ |\n\n**Das ist ein schwerwiegender Befund.** Der AIRR-Provider hat Kontext **erfunden** oder aus einer **anderen Quelle** gezogen – möglicherweise aus dem `preregistration`-Bundle (`cognition_bundle_v1.json`), das im Manifest referenziert wird, aber nicht im AIRR-Input enthalten sein sollte.\n\n**Konsequenz**: Der AIRR-Text ist **nicht vertrauenswürdig**. Er beschreibt ein anderes Experiment als das, das tatsächlich gelaufen ist.\n\n**Das ist ein Sicherheitsproblem für die Evidenzkette.** Wenn ein Reviewer den AIRR liest, ohne das Manifest zu prüfen, könnte er annehmen, das Experiment hätte „diskriminative Leistung\" gemessen – obwohl es nur konzeptuelle Audit-Items zählt.\n\n## 🟠 Weitere neue Befunde\n\n### Befund 1: AIRR-Output-Stabilität ist gering\n\n| Datensatz | AIRR-Output | KI-Konfidenz |\n|---|---|---|\n| PILOT2-01 | strukturiert, behauptet Signifikanz-Aussage | 0.55 |\n| REMAINDER-01 | **nicht validierbar** | 0.0 |\n| REMAINDER-02 | strukturiert, aber halluziniert Kontext | 0.05 |\n\n**Drei Läufe, drei verschiedene Verhaltensweisen.** Der AIRR-Provider ist **nicht stabil**. Das ist ein Provider-seitiges Problem, nicht ein MHRN-Problem – aber es muss dokumentiert werden.\n\n**Empfehlung**: Ein Provider-Health-Check, der vor jeder AIRR-Persistierung prüft, ob der Output valide ist. Bei Nicht-Validität: AIRR als `INVALID` markieren, nicht als `generated`.\n\n### Befund 2: Die methodische Kritik ist präziser geworden\n\nIn REMAINDER-02 steht:\n\n> „Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.\"\n\nDas ist **der erste AIRR-Text, der das `dirty: true`-Problem explizit benennt.** Das ist ein Fortschritt – der Provider hat die Provenienz-Schwäche erkannt.\n\nAber: Es ist **der AIRR**, der das sagt, nicht der deterministische Teil. Der Widerspruch `dirty: true` + `R0` bleibt im Manifest unkommentiert.\n\n### Befund 3: `human_assessment` ist jetzt explizit kritisiert\n\n> „Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet.\"\n\nDas ist **korrekt** und **wichtig**. Der AIRR erkennt, dass ohne Human Review keine EVID-Promotion möglich ist. Das ist die richtige Selbstkritik.\n\n### Befund 4: `dirty: true` ist systematisch\n\nAlle drei Datensätze: `dirty: true`. Der Commit ist identisch (`1f489c97…`). Das ist **kein Zufall**.\n\n**Hypothese**: Der Working Tree enthält **untracked Outputs** (die Experiment-Artefakte selbst). Das würde bedeuten:\n\n- Der Code-Zustand ist sauber (deshalb `R0` für Code).\n- Der Working Tree ist „dirty\", weil neue Dateien entstanden sind.\n\n**Wenn das zutrifft**, ist `R0` korrekt für den Code – aber `dirty: true` ist irreführend für einen Reviewer.\n\n**Empfehlung**: Das `git`-Objekt differenzieren:\n\n```json\n\"git\": {\n \"branch\": \"develop\",\n \"commit\": \"1f489c97...\",\n \"tracked_dirty\": false,\n \"untracked_outputs\": true,\n \"reproducibility_impact\": \"none_for_code\"\n}\n```\n\n## 📊 Serien-Bewertung\n\n### Was die Serie ist\n\n- **Drei konsistente Batch-Läufe** mit identischem Code, identischer Config, identischem Runner.\n- **Drei konzeptuelle Audits** ohne SNN-Beteiligung, ohne EVID-Promotion.\n- **Drei korrekt blockierte RQ/Condition-Zuordnungen** (`NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED`).\n\n### Was die Serie nicht ist\n\n- **Keine unabhängigen Replikate** – Code und Config sind identisch.\n- **Keine empirischen Experimente** – `snn_involved: false` in allen drei.\n- **Keine abgeschlossenen Audits** – `audit_complete: false` in allen drei.\n- **Keine wissenschaftliche Evidenz** – `scientific_evidence: false` in allen drei.\n\n### Die zentrale offene Frage\n\n**Warum sind die `audit_item`-Werte konstant über Seeds und Datensätze?**\n\n| Condition | audit_item |\n|---|---|\n| alternative_model | 2 |\n| assumption_explicit | 1 |\n| claim_boundary | 4 |\n| measurement_limit | 3 |\n\nDiese Werte sind **deterministisch** – sie hängen nur von der Condition ab, nicht vom Seed. Das bedeutet:\n\n- Die `audit_item`-Werte sind **kategoriale Zuordnungen**, keine Messwerte.\n- Sie beschreiben, **welches Audit-Item** in welcher Condition geprüft wird.\n- Sie sind **kein Ergebnis** – sondern eine **Konfiguration**.\n\n**Konsequenz**: Die Tabelle in Sektion 5.1 der Summary ist **irreführend**. Sie präsentiert kategoriale IDs als „numerische Mittelwerte\". Das sollte korrigiert werden.\n\n## 🎯 Empfehlungen\n\n### Priorität 1 – AIRR-Vertrauenswürdigkeit\n\n1. **AIRR-Input härten**: Prüfen, warum der Provider Begriffe wie „aktive Zielerkennung\" halluziniert. Wahrscheinlich zieht er Kontext aus dem `preregistration`-Bundle.\n2. **Provider-Health-Check**: Vor Persistierung validieren, ob der AIRR-Output zum Manifest passt.\n3. **AIRR-Status differenzieren**: `generated`, `invalid`, `partial` – nicht nur binär.\n\n### Priorität 2 – Provenienz klarstellen\n\n1. **`dirty: true` differenzieren**: `tracked_dirty` vs. `untracked_outputs`.\n2. **`runs_index_sha256` hinzufügen**: Master-Hash über den Index.\n3. **AIRR-Kritik in deterministische Summary übernehmen**: Das `dirty`-Problem sollte auch dort stehen.\n\n### Priorität 3 – Semantik korrigieren\n\n1. **`audit_item` umbenennen**: Als kategoriale ID kennzeichnen, keine `mean`/`std`-Statistik.\n2. **`audit_complete=false` erklären**: Warum technisch fertig, inhaltlich nicht?\n3. **`REMAINDER`-Semantik dokumentieren**: Sind das drei unabhängige Audits oder drei Varianten?\n\n### Priorität 4 – Frontend\n\n1. **Leere Felder reparieren**: Protokoll, Seeds, Ticks, Bedingungen werden als „—\" gerendert.\n2. **AIRR-Warnung anzeigen**: Wenn der AIRR halluzinierten Kontext enthält, sollte das im UI sichtbar sein.\n\n## 💎 Fazit\n\nDie Serie ist **methodisch konsistent** und **epistemisch diszipliniert** – aber sie hat **drei ernste Probleme**:\n\n1. **AIRR-Vertrauenswürdigkeit**: Der Provider halluziniert Kontext (REMAINDER-02) oder liefert keinen validen Output (REMAINDER-01). Das untergräbt die Evidenzkette.\n\n2. **Provenienz-Widerspruch**: `dirty: true` + `R0` bleibt in allen drei Datensätzen unkommentiert.\n\n3. **Semantische Undeutlichkeit**: `audit_item`-Werte sind kategorial, werden aber als metrisch präsentiert.\n\n**Der wichtigste Satz**: Die drei Datensätze sind **korrekte technische Läufe**, aber sie sind **keine wissenschaftliche Evidenz**. Der AIRR-Provider ist die **schwächste Stelle** in der Kette – und genau dort sollte die nächste Arbeit ansetzen.\n\n**Die gute Nachricht**: Die deterministische Statistik ist sauber. Die Provenienz-Kette (Source-Freeze, Bytecode-Match) ist intakt. Die Probleme sind **dokumentarisch** und **provider-seitig**, nicht strukturell. Nach ihrer Behebung ist die Serie ein **belastbarer Baustein** für die Batch-Audit-Pipeline.",
7
+ "report_content_digest": "37e062e9ffe2cee329772a37f52934aad85f1f26accbcf399ab5888244dd7b5e"
8
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/summary.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,224 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02: Wissenschaftliche Zusammenfassung
2
+
3
+ Diese Zusammenfassung wird deterministisch aus Manifest, Workflow, DATA und — sofern vorhanden — dem AIRR aufgebaut. Zahlen und Formeln stammen aus den gespeicherten Laufdaten beziehungsweise dem deterministischen Statistics Engine; KI-Text bleibt davon getrennt.
4
+
5
+ ## 1. Identifikation und Status
6
+
7
+ - Experimentstatus: `completed`
8
+ - Forschungsfrage: `RQ-CNS-103`
9
+ - Hypothese: `H-CNS-103-A`
10
+ - Protokoll: `cog_cns_103_v1`
11
+ - Durchlaeufe: `12`
12
+ - Seeds: `[101, 102, 103]`
13
+ - Angeforderte Ticks: `1`
14
+ - Tickgebundene SNN-Läufe (PING/TEMP/5D): `nicht direkt messbar .. nicht direkt messbar` ausgeführte Ticks
15
+ - Tick-Vertrag: `NOT_APPLICABLE`
16
+ - TIME-Ladder: Der angeforderte Endpunkt wird je Seed separat validiert; Zwischenstufen duerfen kleiner sein.
17
+ - Trial-/Regulationsprotokolle: Interne Versuchszyklen sind nicht mit `ticks_executed` gleichzusetzen und werden nicht in die SNN-Tickspanne eingerechnet.
18
+ - Laufmodus: `EXPLORATORY`
19
+ - Netzwerkmodus: `OFFLINE`
20
+
21
+ ## 2. Semantische Konsistenz
22
+
23
+ - RQ/Condition-Pruefung: `NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED`
24
+ - Evidence Readiness: `BLOCKED_UNCLASSIFIED_SEMANTICS`
25
+ - Begründung: Keine automatische semantische Regel fuer diese RQ-Familie registriert.
26
+ - Beobachtete Conditions: `alternative_model, assumption_explicit, claim_boundary, measurement_limit`
27
+
28
+ `DIRECT_MATCH` bezeichnet einen gezielten RQ-spezifischen Lauf. `CONTAINS_MATCH` bedeutet, dass die passende Teilstudie innerhalb einer Gesamtsuite enthalten ist; nur diese Teilstudie ist primaer fuer die registrierte RQ auszuwerten. `MISMATCH` blockiert die Nutzung als Evidenz fuer die registrierte Forschungsfrage, auch wenn die technische Ausfuehrung fehlerfrei war.
29
+
30
+ ## 3. Ausfuehrungsparameter
31
+
32
+ - Titel: Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_103_v1
33
+ - Bedingungen: frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract
34
+ - Notizen: Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.
35
+ - Konfiguration: `F:\Brain-5D\configs\learning_experiment.yaml`
36
+ - Config SHA-256: `6f6cd457caf6216c286fee47ef03b529a0b496ed2dd53ee96b85d3b51e7b3a1c`
37
+ - Git Commit: `1f489c978592dc14dc20492c322a34fe25dddba3`
38
+ - Git dirty: `True`
39
+ - Runtime: `0.013018399942666292` s
40
+
41
+ ## 4. Deterministische Formeln
42
+
43
+ Die im Bericht verwendeten deskriptiven Groessen sind:
44
+
45
+ - Mittelwert: `mean(x) = (1/n) * sum_i x_i`
46
+ - Populationsstandardabweichung: `sigma = sqrt((1/n) * sum_i (x_i - mean(x))^2)`
47
+ - Absolute Differenz: `Delta_x = mean(x_B) - mean(x_A)`
48
+ - Verhältnis: `R_x = mean(x_B) / mean(x_A)` fuer `mean(x_A) != 0`
49
+ - Inter-Spike-Intervall: `ISI_i = t_(i+1) - t_i`
50
+
51
+ Diese Formeln sind deskriptiv. Ohne registrierten Inferenztest, unabhaengige Stichprobenannahme und passende Versuchsplanung werden daraus keine Signifikanz- oder Kausalbehauptungen abgeleitet.
52
+
53
+ ## 5. Ergebnisse nach Bedingung
54
+
55
+ | Condition | n | Seeds | Ticks mean | Spikes mean | Syn. events mean | Aktivierte Neuronen mean | Recurrent events mean | Propagation depth mean |
56
+ | --- | ---: | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
57
+ | alternative_model | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
58
+ | assumption_explicit | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
59
+ | claim_boundary | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
60
+ | measurement_limit | 3 | 101,102,103 | — | — | — | — | — | — |
61
+
62
+ **Wichtig:** `—` bedeutet in dieser Tabelle ausschließlich, dass die jeweilige SNN-Metrik für diese Bedingung nicht definiert oder nicht erhoben wird. Es bedeutet **nicht**, dass für die Bedingung keine DATA vorliegen. Protokollspezifische Messwerte werden direkt darunter ausgewiesen.
63
+
64
+ ### 5.1 Protokollspezifische Metrikabdeckung
65
+
66
+ | Condition | zusätzliche numerische Mittelwerte |
67
+ | --- | --- |
68
+ | alternative_model | `audit_item=2` |
69
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_item=1` |
70
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_item=4` |
71
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_item=3` |
72
+
73
+ #### Primäre und weitere boolesche Endpunkte
74
+
75
+ | Condition | Outcome | n | true | false | all_true |
76
+ | --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |
77
+ | alternative_model | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
78
+ | alternative_model | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
79
+ | alternative_model | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
80
+ | alternative_model | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
81
+ | alternative_model | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
82
+ | alternative_model | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
83
+ | alternative_model | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
84
+ | alternative_model | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
85
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
86
+ | assumption_explicit | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
87
+ | assumption_explicit | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
88
+ | assumption_explicit | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
89
+ | assumption_explicit | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
90
+ | assumption_explicit | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
91
+ | assumption_explicit | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
92
+ | assumption_explicit | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
93
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
94
+ | claim_boundary | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
95
+ | claim_boundary | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
96
+ | claim_boundary | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
97
+ | claim_boundary | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
98
+ | claim_boundary | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
99
+ | claim_boundary | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
100
+ | claim_boundary | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
101
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_complete` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
102
+ | measurement_limit | `audit_template_generated` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
103
+ | measurement_limit | `automatic_evidence_promotion` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
104
+ | measurement_limit | `conceptual_or_normative` | 3 | 3 | 0 | True |
105
+ | measurement_limit | `native_empirical_experiment` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
106
+ | measurement_limit | `phenomenal_claim_identified` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
107
+ | measurement_limit | `scientific_evidence` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
108
+ | measurement_limit | `snn_involved` | 3 | 0 | 3 | False |
109
+
110
+ ## 6. Einzelne Läufe
111
+
112
+ | Seed | Condition | Ticks | Spikes | Syn. events | Aktivierte Neuronen | Recurrent events | Depth | Runtime error |
113
+ | ---: | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |
114
+ | 101 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
115
+ | 101 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
116
+ | 101 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
117
+ | 101 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
118
+ | 102 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
119
+ | 102 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
120
+ | 102 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
121
+ | 102 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
122
+ | 103 | assumption_explicit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
123
+ | 103 | alternative_model | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
124
+ | 103 | measurement_limit | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
125
+ | 103 | claim_boundary | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
126
+
127
+ ## 7. Reproduzierbarkeit und Provenienz
128
+
129
+ Identische Ausgaben ueber mehrere Seeds dokumentieren reproduzierbare Modelltrajektorien unter diesen Bedingungen. Sie sind nicht automatisch statistisch unabhaengige Replikate. State-Digests sind Integritaets-/Identitaetsmarker und keine metrischen Zustandsabstaende.
130
+
131
+ Deterministische Statistikdatei: `analysis/statistics.json`
132
+
133
+ ## 8. AI Research Report
134
+
135
+ - AIRR Status: `generated`
136
+ - Wissenschaftliche Evidenz durch KI: `false`
137
+ - Human Review: `PENDING`
138
+ - AIRR Markdown: `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md`
139
+ - AIRR JSON: `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json`
140
+
141
+ ### 8.1 KI-Einschaetzung
142
+
143
+ Die Daten zeigen keine messbaren Effekte in einer Richtung, da keine inferenzfähigen Analysen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurden keine empirischen Experimente durchgeführt, die eine direkte Kausalität zwischen aktiver Zielerkennung und diskriminativer Leistung nachweisen könnten.
144
+
145
+ KI-Konfidenz: `0.05` — dies ist keine statistische Konfidenz.
146
+
147
+ ### Methodische Kritik
148
+
149
+ - Keine registrierte wissenschaftliche Evidenz ist mit diesem Experiment verknüpft.
150
+ - Die Git-Provenance ist schmutzig oder nicht verfügbar.
151
+ - Die Experimente sind rein konzeptionell und nicht empirisch.
152
+ - Die audit_complete-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen auf falsch gesetzt, was auf fehlende vollständige Audits hinweist.
153
+ - Die human_assessment-Metriken sind in allen Bedingungen nicht aufgezeichnet, was eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung bedeutet.
154
+
155
+ ### Alternative Erklaerungen
156
+
157
+ - Die audit_item-Metriken könnten auf eine systematische Fehlerquelle in der Datenerfassung hinweisen.
158
+ - Die audit_template_generated-Metriken könnten auf eine automatische Generierung von Audit-Vorlagen hinweisen, die nicht manuell überprüft wurde.
159
+ - Die audit_complete-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende vollständige Durchführung der Audits hinweisen.
160
+ - Die human_assessment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende menschliche Bewertung der Ergebnisse hinweisen.
161
+ - Die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Durchführung der Experimente hinweisen.
162
+ - Die scientific_evidence-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende wissenschaftliche Evidenz hinweisen.
163
+ - Die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende empirische Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen hinweisen.
164
+ - Die external_ethics_approval-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende ethische Genehmigung hinweisen.
165
+ - Die external_review_instrument-Metriken könnten auf eine fehlende externe Überprüfung hinweisen.
166
+
167
+ ### Fehlende Nachweise
168
+
169
+ - Empirische Daten, die die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleichen.
170
+ - Daten, die die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersuchen.
171
+ - Daten, die die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüfen.
172
+ - Daten, die die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüfen.
173
+ - Daten, die die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüfen.
174
+ - Daten, die die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüfen.
175
+ - Daten, die die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüfen.
176
+ - Daten, die die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüfen.
177
+ - Daten, die die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüfen.
178
+
179
+ ### Empfohlene Folgeexperimente
180
+
181
+ - Ein empirisches Experiment, das die diskriminative Leistung unter aktiver und passiver Zielerkennung direkt vergleicht.
182
+ - Ein Experiment, das die Rolle der externen LLM-Wissen in der diskriminativen Leistung untersucht.
183
+ - Ein Experiment, das die audit_complete-Metriken in einer vollständigen Audit-Durchführung überprüft.
184
+ - Ein Experiment, das die human_assessment-Metriken in einer menschlichen Bewertung der Ergebnisse überprüft.
185
+ - Ein Experiment, das die native_empirical_experiment-Metriken in einer empirischen Durchführung der Experimente überprüft.
186
+ - Ein Experiment, das die scientific_evidence-Metriken in einer wissenschaftlichen Evidenz überprüft.
187
+ - Ein Experiment, das die conceptual_or_normative-Metriken in einer empirischen Validierung der konzeptionellen oder normativen Aussagen überprüft.
188
+ - Ein Experiment, das die external_ethics_approval-Metriken in einer ethischen Genehmigung überprüft.
189
+ - Ein Experiment, das die external_review_instrument-Metriken in einer externen Überprüfung überprüft.
190
+
191
+ ## 9. Artefakte
192
+
193
+ - `analysis/ai_packet.json`
194
+ - `analysis/ai_packet_digest.json`
195
+ - `analysis/AIAR-critical_reviewer-20261001212516252293-09c3f8b9.json`
196
+ - `analysis/AIAR-scientific_analyst-20261001212341683225-09c3f8b9.json`
197
+ - `analysis/AIAR-scientific_writer-20261001212701063609-09c3f8b9.json`
198
+ - `analysis/statistics.json`
199
+ - `DATA/current_run.json`
200
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz`
201
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz`
202
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz`
203
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz`
204
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz`
205
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz`
206
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz`
207
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz`
208
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz`
209
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz`
210
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz`
211
+ - `DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz`
212
+ - `DATA/runs_compact.json`
213
+ - `DATA/runs_index.json`
214
+ - `manifest.json`
215
+ - `report.md`
216
+ - `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.json`
217
+ - `reports/AIRR-2026-0001.md`
218
+ - `workflow.json`
219
+
220
+ ## 10. Wissenschaftliche Grenze und Schlussfolgerung
221
+
222
+ Die technischen Laufdaten duerfen deskriptiv ausgewertet werden. Eine Hypothese gilt dadurch nicht automatisch als bestaetigt oder widerlegt. Kausale Aussagen sind nur fuer explizit kontrollierte Interventionen und nur innerhalb des simulierten Systems zulaessig; biologische Generalisierung erfordert zusaetzliche Evidenz. Die KI-Auswertung ist post-hoc und besitzt keine Evidenzfreigabe.
223
+
224
+ **Gesamtstatus:** technische Ausfuehrung `completed`, Tick-Vertrag `NOT_APPLICABLE`, semantische Zuordnung `NOT_AUTOMATICALLY_CLASSIFIED`, wissenschaftliche Evidenz `false` bis zur menschlichen Review/Freigabe.
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02/workflow.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-02",
3
+ "research_question": "RQ-CNS-103",
4
+ "hypothesis": "H-CNS-103-A",
5
+ "title": "Registered conceptual audit: cog_cns_103_v1",
6
+ "conditions": "frozen preregistered conceptual boundary contract",
7
+ "ticks": 1,
8
+ "ticks_contract": "minimum requested observation window",
9
+ "seeds": [
10
+ 101,
11
+ 102,
12
+ 103
13
+ ],
14
+ "protocol": "cog_cns_103_v1",
15
+ "resolved_runner": "run_cog_cns_103_v1",
16
+ "tick_validation": {
17
+ "status": "NOT_APPLICABLE",
18
+ "mode": "protocol_defined_internal_trials",
19
+ "requested_ticks": 1
20
+ },
21
+ "notes": "Sequential conceptual audit only. No direct causal experiment, no empirical SNN execution, no automatic DATA-to-EVID promotion.",
22
+ "execution": "registered experiment_suite runner",
23
+ "assistant_policy": "AI is post-hoc interpretation only.",
24
+ "epistemic_layers": {
25
+ "ui_state": "operator/dashboard progress only; not a scientific result",
26
+ "data": "DATA artifacts and deterministic statistics are authoritative run outputs",
27
+ "evid": "not_created; requires semantic validation, clean freeze and human review",
28
+ "interpretation": "post-hoc AI or human interpretation; never execution input"
29
+ }
30
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03/DATA/current_run.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "last_archived_run": 11,
3
+ "raw_artifact": {
4
+ "format": "json.gz",
5
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
6
+ "sha256": "80f7aa9f592428649286e70a1588c2c8c4992199762761d3df8a71388d4cd021",
7
+ "size_bytes": 516,
8
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
9
+ },
10
+ "status": "idle"
11
+ }
research/experiments/EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03/DATA/runs_compact.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,374 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ [
2
+ {
3
+ "_raw_artifact": {
4
+ "format": "json.gz",
5
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0000-assumption_explicit-seed-101.json.gz",
6
+ "sha256": "beaa4be2187afbdb7d50bd50b51daf7091845beed6ce8374153d527f527b29b5",
7
+ "size_bytes": 525,
8
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
9
+ },
10
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
11
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
12
+ "metrics": {
13
+ "audit_complete": false,
14
+ "audit_item": 1,
15
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
16
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
17
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
18
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
19
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
20
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
21
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
22
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
23
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
24
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
25
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
26
+ "snn_involved": false
27
+ },
28
+ "runtime_error": null,
29
+ "seed": 101,
30
+ "state_digest_after": "e52bc9cc785c948188d95ee2631a63380c5549adc5460aad0f56d671883ad232",
31
+ "state_digest_before": "e52bc9cc785c948188d95ee2631a63380c5549adc5460aad0f56d671883ad232"
32
+ },
33
+ {
34
+ "_raw_artifact": {
35
+ "format": "json.gz",
36
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0001-alternative_model-seed-101.json.gz",
37
+ "sha256": "8a5283ab52d6ccae4dff07fb5d2af485e4499e87b32b6ac522e94576084cd0f0",
38
+ "size_bytes": 521,
39
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
40
+ },
41
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
42
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
43
+ "metrics": {
44
+ "audit_complete": false,
45
+ "audit_item": 2,
46
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
47
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
48
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
49
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
50
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
51
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
52
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
53
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
54
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
55
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
56
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
57
+ "snn_involved": false
58
+ },
59
+ "runtime_error": null,
60
+ "seed": 101,
61
+ "state_digest_after": "d3cd4488e7a877ba85e62d8c6487fb6d8988b240aea491536ec04a3e5fd9defe",
62
+ "state_digest_before": "d3cd4488e7a877ba85e62d8c6487fb6d8988b240aea491536ec04a3e5fd9defe"
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "_raw_artifact": {
66
+ "format": "json.gz",
67
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0002-measurement_limit-seed-101.json.gz",
68
+ "sha256": "0bd0717c4a34529ccd3ebccf9b6a5ea1daa78d2634d454609773771bab72a400",
69
+ "size_bytes": 519,
70
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
71
+ },
72
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
73
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
74
+ "metrics": {
75
+ "audit_complete": false,
76
+ "audit_item": 3,
77
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
78
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
79
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
80
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
81
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
82
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
83
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
84
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
85
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
86
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
87
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
88
+ "snn_involved": false
89
+ },
90
+ "runtime_error": null,
91
+ "seed": 101,
92
+ "state_digest_after": "9e5ef43b2e506f734e4dad1209bd97d75c5fec35e54db72ada9dd0fbd067032e",
93
+ "state_digest_before": "9e5ef43b2e506f734e4dad1209bd97d75c5fec35e54db72ada9dd0fbd067032e"
94
+ },
95
+ {
96
+ "_raw_artifact": {
97
+ "format": "json.gz",
98
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0003-claim_boundary-seed-101.json.gz",
99
+ "sha256": "0a7c2cf50c317bda80f51c818e4adaebef44895515bd3e408716dcf159d9aa37",
100
+ "size_bytes": 517,
101
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
102
+ },
103
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
104
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
105
+ "metrics": {
106
+ "audit_complete": false,
107
+ "audit_item": 4,
108
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
109
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
110
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
111
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
112
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
113
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
114
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
115
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
116
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
117
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
118
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
119
+ "snn_involved": false
120
+ },
121
+ "runtime_error": null,
122
+ "seed": 101,
123
+ "state_digest_after": "111fe45f659ab194540c90803c25b060d4ca38273cd38f5c6632f48aba9f9039",
124
+ "state_digest_before": "111fe45f659ab194540c90803c25b060d4ca38273cd38f5c6632f48aba9f9039"
125
+ },
126
+ {
127
+ "_raw_artifact": {
128
+ "format": "json.gz",
129
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0004-assumption_explicit-seed-102.json.gz",
130
+ "sha256": "f766db8312d3202362430d5abcf8d135bbbcc6aa3cc13aca2b31617cc1801f22",
131
+ "size_bytes": 525,
132
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
133
+ },
134
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
135
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
136
+ "metrics": {
137
+ "audit_complete": false,
138
+ "audit_item": 1,
139
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
140
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
141
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
142
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
143
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
144
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
145
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
146
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
147
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
148
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
149
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
150
+ "snn_involved": false
151
+ },
152
+ "runtime_error": null,
153
+ "seed": 102,
154
+ "state_digest_after": "8223a6081f78dc127a8df90fa81abd68f429c101661d6c6d361e8410a5703cbf",
155
+ "state_digest_before": "8223a6081f78dc127a8df90fa81abd68f429c101661d6c6d361e8410a5703cbf"
156
+ },
157
+ {
158
+ "_raw_artifact": {
159
+ "format": "json.gz",
160
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0005-alternative_model-seed-102.json.gz",
161
+ "sha256": "566f8286f6cb6f37772a6028e16eca3fa77823b1246cace5266ff202d24464bb",
162
+ "size_bytes": 519,
163
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
164
+ },
165
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
166
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
167
+ "metrics": {
168
+ "audit_complete": false,
169
+ "audit_item": 2,
170
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
171
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
172
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
173
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
174
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
175
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
176
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
177
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
178
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
179
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
180
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
181
+ "snn_involved": false
182
+ },
183
+ "runtime_error": null,
184
+ "seed": 102,
185
+ "state_digest_after": "e69117724e7e7403b14e6be856545c790bcc6b5221e60046ae22ce1e6e7416ba",
186
+ "state_digest_before": "e69117724e7e7403b14e6be856545c790bcc6b5221e60046ae22ce1e6e7416ba"
187
+ },
188
+ {
189
+ "_raw_artifact": {
190
+ "format": "json.gz",
191
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0006-measurement_limit-seed-102.json.gz",
192
+ "sha256": "59436fb99354722b0c613d697ae0458771d831a35cacad9c08163608438877f6",
193
+ "size_bytes": 522,
194
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
195
+ },
196
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
197
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
198
+ "metrics": {
199
+ "audit_complete": false,
200
+ "audit_item": 3,
201
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
202
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
203
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
204
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
205
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
206
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
207
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
208
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
209
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
210
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
211
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
212
+ "snn_involved": false
213
+ },
214
+ "runtime_error": null,
215
+ "seed": 102,
216
+ "state_digest_after": "376e475171e99e65262021e52e63222513757834106ec5681c1c4f2b3529299a",
217
+ "state_digest_before": "376e475171e99e65262021e52e63222513757834106ec5681c1c4f2b3529299a"
218
+ },
219
+ {
220
+ "_raw_artifact": {
221
+ "format": "json.gz",
222
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0007-claim_boundary-seed-102.json.gz",
223
+ "sha256": "cd0a6cff2ac28fafa7140efefdcece86aa939baea5ded65b1cb6bada7a3ffe24",
224
+ "size_bytes": 517,
225
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
226
+ },
227
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
228
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
229
+ "metrics": {
230
+ "audit_complete": false,
231
+ "audit_item": 4,
232
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
233
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
234
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
235
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
236
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
237
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
238
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
239
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
240
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
241
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
242
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
243
+ "snn_involved": false
244
+ },
245
+ "runtime_error": null,
246
+ "seed": 102,
247
+ "state_digest_after": "4b5afb97b6a418270ae69f7465a400d8436b796ab71880f3dce94a95848367be",
248
+ "state_digest_before": "4b5afb97b6a418270ae69f7465a400d8436b796ab71880f3dce94a95848367be"
249
+ },
250
+ {
251
+ "_raw_artifact": {
252
+ "format": "json.gz",
253
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0008-assumption_explicit-seed-103.json.gz",
254
+ "sha256": "2f729883532efd2cb1d35ac0247cfbf249a3565e161ecb8c2ab650b7fde8594b",
255
+ "size_bytes": 525,
256
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 830
257
+ },
258
+ "condition": "assumption_explicit",
259
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
260
+ "metrics": {
261
+ "audit_complete": false,
262
+ "audit_item": 1,
263
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
264
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
265
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
266
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
267
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
268
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
269
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
270
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
271
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
272
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
273
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
274
+ "snn_involved": false
275
+ },
276
+ "runtime_error": null,
277
+ "seed": 103,
278
+ "state_digest_after": "c760fd0f1487fee37518b880b56b741ca14113306973603887ef4ce3d0010e90",
279
+ "state_digest_before": "c760fd0f1487fee37518b880b56b741ca14113306973603887ef4ce3d0010e90"
280
+ },
281
+ {
282
+ "_raw_artifact": {
283
+ "format": "json.gz",
284
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0009-alternative_model-seed-103.json.gz",
285
+ "sha256": "5a8f08e6129bb25ea3c601b78c87421c1501b1ebcafa198e54b432367157eff4",
286
+ "size_bytes": 520,
287
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
288
+ },
289
+ "condition": "alternative_model",
290
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
291
+ "metrics": {
292
+ "audit_complete": false,
293
+ "audit_item": 2,
294
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
295
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
296
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
297
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
298
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
299
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
300
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
301
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
302
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
303
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
304
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
305
+ "snn_involved": false
306
+ },
307
+ "runtime_error": null,
308
+ "seed": 103,
309
+ "state_digest_after": "19d58e9df740d46180f22c28a92238f81aa66449c8a5e83ea0618e915988b362",
310
+ "state_digest_before": "19d58e9df740d46180f22c28a92238f81aa66449c8a5e83ea0618e915988b362"
311
+ },
312
+ {
313
+ "_raw_artifact": {
314
+ "format": "json.gz",
315
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0010-measurement_limit-seed-103.json.gz",
316
+ "sha256": "54bb60ea5bef0ae00ba9f17b578a3d819429ecdbbfea58a667664cbc7f983f92",
317
+ "size_bytes": 520,
318
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 828
319
+ },
320
+ "condition": "measurement_limit",
321
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
322
+ "metrics": {
323
+ "audit_complete": false,
324
+ "audit_item": 3,
325
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
326
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
327
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
328
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
329
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
330
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
331
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
332
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
333
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
334
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
335
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
336
+ "snn_involved": false
337
+ },
338
+ "runtime_error": null,
339
+ "seed": 103,
340
+ "state_digest_after": "6aa6f9a3f410603ed2727b960b8fa8cc9d2a70b6a6ae76a63b32c30fe503705f",
341
+ "state_digest_before": "6aa6f9a3f410603ed2727b960b8fa8cc9d2a70b6a6ae76a63b32c30fe503705f"
342
+ },
343
+ {
344
+ "_raw_artifact": {
345
+ "format": "json.gz",
346
+ "path": "DATA/raw/run-0011-claim_boundary-seed-103.json.gz",
347
+ "sha256": "80f7aa9f592428649286e70a1588c2c8c4992199762761d3df8a71388d4cd021",
348
+ "size_bytes": 516,
349
+ "uncompressed_bytes": 825
350
+ },
351
+ "condition": "claim_boundary",
352
+ "experiment_id": "EXP-BATCH-CONCEPTUAL-AUDITS-20261001-REMAINDER-03",
353
+ "metrics": {
354
+ "audit_complete": false,
355
+ "audit_item": 4,
356
+ "audit_template_generated": true,
357
+ "automatic_evidence_promotion": false,
358
+ "claim_scope": "component_engineering_screen_not_snn_learning",
359
+ "conceptual_or_normative": true,
360
+ "consciousness_inference": "not_established",
361
+ "external_ethics_approval": "not_claimed",
362
+ "external_review_instrument": "research/external_review/README.md",
363
+ "human_assessment": "not_recorded",
364
+ "native_empirical_experiment": false,
365
+ "phenomenal_claim_identified": false,
366
+ "scientific_evidence": false,
367
+ "snn_involved": false
368
+ },
369
+ "runtime_error": null,
370
+ "seed": 103,
371
+ "state_digest_after": "b90e12eb08ddcf4945155231b85bc4ad14718c7444688661cf002d5be3ae0afe",
372
+ "state_digest_before": "b90e12eb08ddcf4945155231b85bc4ad14718c7444688661cf002d5be3ae0afe"
373
+ }
374
+ ]