PrivacyBench-Plus / SCORECARD.md
adamrida's picture
PrivacyBench+ 1.0
4c52bbf
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
4.58 kB

Scorecard

Results on the recommended evaluation set: the human-annotated records of megan_donovan_eli_lilly and nora_caterpillar. Scores are computed with score.py on masked characters, with entity type ignored.

Column Definition
Precision, Recall, F1 PII detection, on the 1,877 records without unresolved spans
Not fully hidden Share of labelled spans with at least one character left visible
Anonymization-grade F1 Labels and indirect identifiers both required, on all 1,962 records (112 indirect identifiers)
Indirect identifiers hidden Share of indirect identifiers fully masked
Records with a leak Share of the 1,488 records with something to hide in which a required span is partly visible

The configuration column gives the label set or prompt used for each system. Open models were run with the entity types listed; other configurations may give different results.

Token classifiers and span models

System Configuration Precision Recall F1 Not fully hidden % Anonymization-grade F1 Indirect identifiers hidden % Records with a leak %
PIIX-560m default 96.5 97.2 96.9 4.0 96.2 4.5 13.8
PIIX-560m recall=4 92.1 98.5 95.2 2.5 94.7 18.8 9.2
PIIX-560m recall=8 82.0 99.4 89.8 1.3 89.6 58.0 5.3
Fastino GLiNER2.5-base 10 benchmark types 89.3 83.4 86.2 20.6 85.9 22.3 44.8
Fastino GLiNER2-multi 10 benchmark types 85.2 84.4 84.8 18.6 83.6 48.2 42.3
Fastino GLiNER2.5-multi 10 short queries 79.8 84.1 81.9 20.4 82.6 17.0 41.4
Fastino GLiNER2-large 10 benchmark types 78.5 85.5 81.8 12.6 81.6 42.9 29.1
Perplexity PII-Tracer native labels 86.1 72.9 79.0 26.7 78.2 8.9 56.5
GLiNER multi-PII 53 published types 72.8 85.8 78.7 16.7 79.7 8.0 36.0
Fastino GLiNER2.5-multi 10 benchmark types 85.7 69.3 76.6 41.2 77.7 9.8 61.2
OpenAI Privacy Filter native labels 87.6 64.1 74.1 33.7 72.2 17.0 62.6
Fastino GLiNER2 privacy-filter PII multi 42 native labels 70.6 75.6 73.0 23.1 73.0 42.9 45.0
Fastino GLiNER2 Guardrails PII Multi 42 native labels 67.2 77.6 72.0 21.5 71.9 52.7 41.2
NuMind NuNER Zero 16 short queries 61.4 79.7 69.4 25.1 71.0 31.2 22.2
OpenMed privacy-filter-nemotron 55 native labels 66.8 72.0 69.3 30.4 68.9 1.8 59.5
GLiNER large v2.1 16 short queries 59.7 81.6 68.9 21.5 70.2 38.4 51.1
Liquid LFM2.5 Encoder 350M PII 40 native labels 91.6 54.3 68.2 58.6 67.8 1.8 71.6
PIIBench DeBERTa base 82 native labels 53.1 94.5 68.0 10.4 68.7 9.8 27.1
Knowledgator GLiNER PII-large v1.0 40 published types 77.3 56.7 65.4 48.3 63.1 28.6 53.4
Fastino GLiNER2.5-multi 28 ai4privacy types 77.4 56.3 65.2 56.3 64.7 65.2 73.3
Microsoft Presidio 2.2.364 English, spaCy en_core_web_lg 52.6 83.7 64.6 16.3 65.8 43.8 44.8
Fastino GLiNER2.5-base 28 ai4privacy types 68.3 60.5 64.1 48.3 63.9 68.8 82.5
Davlan XLM-R base NER HRL 4 native labels 74.8 56.1 64.1 36.3 66.2 1.8 77.8
NVIDIA GLiNER-PII 55 native labels 52.1 79.3 62.9 21.1 62.4 27.7 37.7
Knowledgator GLiNER bi-large v1.0 16 short queries 46.5 95.6 62.6 10.7 64.6 93.8 33.8
GLiNER multi v2.1 16 short queries 60.5 64.1 62.2 31.0 62.6 9.8 58.9
Piiranha 17 native labels 75.4 49.8 60.0 59.5 61.2 1.8 69.4
Fastino GLiNER2-multi 28 ai4privacy types 53.6 67.3 59.7 37.8 59.5 27.7 55.3
Fastino GLiNER2-large 28 ai4privacy types 51.1 69.7 59.0 29.1 58.8 50.9 48.6
Gretel GLiNER bi-large v1.0 42 published types 88.3 37.3 52.4 67.2 50.2 3.6 71.9
SpanMarker mBERT MultiNERD 15 native labels 64.2 39.7 49.0 54.1 51.7 1.8 89.7

Large language models

System Configuration Precision Recall F1 Not fully hidden % Anonymization-grade F1 Indirect identifiers hidden % Records with a leak %
GPT-6 Astra prompted 99.4 96.9 98.1 6.4 97.8 0.9 22.2
GPT-6.1 Sol prompted 99.3 96.8 98.1 6.6 97.7 0.9 22.4
DeepSeek V4.1 Flash span-extraction prompt 79.3 93.4 85.7 9.0 85.6 95.5 22.2