question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>Im working through Zee and I'm having a little trouble with some integrals. I'm trying to reproduce the analogue of the inverse square law for a 2+1 D universe and I figured I could start with the statement for the energy $$E=-\int \frac{d^2 k}{(2 \pi)^2}\frac{e^{i \vec{k}\cdot (\vec{x}-\vec{y})}}{k^2 + m^2}=-\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{k\,dk}{(2\pi)^2(k^2+m^2)}\int_{0}^{2\pi}e^{ik|x-y|\cos\phi}d\phi$$ which turns into $$=-\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{k\,J_{0}(k|x-y|)\, dk}{2\pi (k^2+m^2)}$$ Then contour integrated after seeing $k$ and $J_0$ were both odd to get $$-\frac{(2\pi i)(im)J_{0}(im|x-y|)}{4\pi (2im)}=-\frac{i\, J_{0}(im|x-y|)}{4}$$ but this is imaginary, where did I go wrong?</p>
g5832
[ -0.05172388628125191, -0.013194992206990719, -0.007993822917342186, -0.04808036983013153, -0.02688666619360447, -0.007370194420218468, 0.008941996842622757, 0.03746940940618515, -0.006264279596507549, 0.02067529410123825, -0.025462700054049492, 0.03657577559351921, 0.07324977964162827, 0.039983898401260376, -0.005196847021579742, 0.00485119316726923, 0.06089029461145401, 0.012538030743598938, 0.054295726120471954, -0.014734948053956032, -0.06965713202953339, 0.0014515859074890614, -0.02066866308450699, -0.010680940002202988, 0.03888330236077309, -0.03254515305161476, 0.03925516456365585, 0.0027086646296083927, -0.012510368600487709, 0.02697722055017948, -0.0009228339768014848, 0.027638724073767662, 0.04979203641414642, -0.03193468600511551, -0.02888134866952896, 0.07211101055145264, 0.057280853390693665, 0.020931614562869072, 0.029787689447402954, -0.007869224064052105, -0.019337765872478485, -0.07147111743688583, -0.019221043214201927, 0.06371952593326569, 0.03070325031876564, 0.025403795763850212, -0.03507373854517937, 0.03455082327127457, 0.016849718987941742, -0.021754639223217964, -0.011841504834592342, 0.087385393679142, 0.08375423401594162, -0.008250489830970764, -0.029531089588999748, 0.05753089115023613, -0.008196065202355385, -0.08270938694477081, 0.07051391899585724, 0.05070336163043976, -0.02978973276913166, -0.06412391364574432, -0.008915768936276436, 0.022657910361886024, 0.05984226614236832, -0.03478546440601349, -0.025584684684872627, 0.01615102030336857, -0.008347144350409508, 0.0005872956244274974, 0.051233697682619095, -0.021668361499905586, 0.01678682118654251, -0.0283042024821043, -0.0194797832518816, 0.00027913329540751874, 0.10040631145238876, 0.0038238721899688244, -0.025706740096211433, 0.013703243806958199, -0.04727218300104141, 0.022861042991280556, 0.02327888086438179, 0.01920436881482601, 0.027872290462255478, -0.03385958820581436, 0.06319031864404678, 0.01271059736609459, -0.005684300325810909, 0.01919630542397499, -0.02288489229977131, 0.01919551193714142, -0.04825417697429657, -0.06076805666089058, 0.04381689429283142, -0.0036230706609785557, -0.04170101135969162, -0.007776370272040367, -0.03664688020944595, 0.0006021244917064905, -0.00596837280318141, 0.003163800109177828, 0.04496927931904793, -0.02408071979880333, -0.014856035821139812, 0.014279450289905071, 0.025757255032658577, 0.006403897423297167, 0.058566778898239136, -0.019810877740383148, -0.031545598059892654, -0.005950277205556631, -0.00782084185630083, -0.03685487061738968, 0.036663275212049484, 0.019793696701526642, -0.033294130116701126, -0.04440948739647865, -0.03787137567996979, 0.08359157294034958, 0.032906901091337204, 0.006030523683875799, 0.030409254133701324, 0.07534131407737732, 0.021976208314299583, -0.011615332216024399, -0.032932721078395844, -0.01742248237133026, 0.04179507866501808, -0.03907497227191925, -0.05639878287911415, -0.02155529148876667, 0.007042511831969023, 0.0018142435001209378, -0.04643954336643219, -0.025111626833677292, -0.03993891924619675, -0.08508127182722092, -0.02405446581542492, 0.00845807883888483, -0.041123051196336746, -0.04790697246789932, -0.0220961794257164, -0.07998641580343246, -0.033519621938467026, -0.029101716354489326, 0.004634082783013582, -0.04271112009882927, -0.011618590913712978, -0.05183033645153046, -0.013300195336341858, 0.06883227080106735, 0.024179769679903984, 0.037561312317848206, -0.02089044637978077, -0.016509026288986206, 0.03040674701333046, -0.02259340137243271, -0.003387672360986471, -0.07450437545776367, 0.04248905926942825, 0.014727993868291378, 0.011189557611942291, 0.04532463476061821, 0.02568422257900238, 0.020487049594521523, 0.04419098049402237, -0.01478884182870388, 0.007778489962220192, -0.00318388850428164, -0.035917144268751144, -0.011360261589288712, 0.02040397934615612, 0.011872115544974804, -0.000665965722873807, 0.015855969861149788, -0.043302346020936966, 0.03367127850651741, 0.02424423210322857, 0.06515655666589737, -0.008557452820241451, 0.005155767779797316, -0.004342812113463879, -0.009765952825546265, -0.025125931948423386, -0.04724755138158798, 0.029680510982871056, 0.03020480088889599, -0.014533313922584057, -0.010312304832041264, 0.040542759001255035, 0.03004535287618637, 0.016672678291797638, 0.015219774097204208, 0.008464677259325981, 0.01450322475284338, 0.07719994336366653, -0.02421136200428009, -0.03804107382893562, -0.02261137031018734, 0.03410401940345764, 0.0359761007130146, 0.05358909070491791, 0.008321684785187244, 0.026810336858034134, 0.010903622023761272, -0.012636110186576843, -0.05588871240615845, 0.017534788697957993, 0.029308313503861427, 0.002747566206380725, -0.0546828955411911, -0.03963267803192139, 0.016132863238453865, 0.026875650510191917, -0.025625040754675865, 0.07362733036279678, -0.005775191821157932, -0.060571908950805664, 0.03365122154355049, -0.05468563362956047, 0.016058888286352158, 0.08618804812431335, -0.0065872385166585445, 0.06056319922208786, 0.017089279368519783, 0.006435267627239227, 0.017967278137803078, -0.023407844826579094, 0.01922616921365261, -0.10404493659734726, -0.04081384465098381, 0.059444278478622437, 0.01352891605347395, 0.04607684910297394, -0.0006359927938319743, 0.0041405558586120605, -0.01968407817184925, 0.029361510649323463, 0.028098000213503838, 0.010337015613913536, 0.012976761907339096, -0.015767350792884827, 0.007442548405379057, 0.014833744615316391, 0.03066086769104004, 0.02305249311029911, -0.033561427146196365, -0.06778480112552643, -0.019314853474497795, -0.0007903894875198603, 0.014687914401292801, -0.0675913468003273, 0.054615359753370285, -0.009936634451150894, -0.01850728690624237, 0.003479443257674575, 0.008380088023841381, -0.011027486994862556, 0.006914026569575071, 0.03296300768852234, -0.043475206941366196, 0.014158643782138824, 0.032354630529880524, -0.035943057388067245, -0.024841120466589928, 0.014892108738422394, 0.013870283961296082, 0.02460908703505993, -0.005538134835660458, -0.017740311101078987, 0.08192626386880875, -0.04465869441628456, 0.01327911950647831, 0.02693312242627144, -0.02291378378868103, 0.02595624513924122, -0.056988995522260666, 0.012789281085133553, -0.019367679953575134, 0.011281968094408512, 0.006882532965391874, -0.022633148357272148, 0.06952913850545883, 0.02952713333070278, -0.06402470171451569, 0.012502714060246944, 0.049447864294052124, -0.007028309162706137, 0.03239929676055908, -0.0661066472530365, -0.02104576863348484, -0.018756739795207977, 0.06926020979881287, -0.0163631159812212, -0.010435118339955807, 0.007490222342312336, -0.039169471710920334, 0.05149788782000542, 0.042388755828142166, 0.05625292286276817, -0.004164936486631632, 0.006940148305147886, -0.051661454141139984, -0.02177070826292038, -0.035532210022211075, 0.04516665264964104, -0.05927777662873268, -0.014736182056367397, 0.011752134189009666, 0.00375725282356143, 0.004787184298038483, 0.02965008281171322, 0.016105668619275093, 0.010218221694231033, 0.024957668036222458, -0.026842201128602028, -0.03008071519434452, 0.05785024166107178, 0.01478047389537096, -0.03319914638996124, 0.0011352261062711477, 0.0003808296169154346, 0.07230318337678909, 0.0243377648293972, -0.02554698847234249, -0.08608119934797287, -0.03590160235762596, -0.03686191886663437, 0.020937934517860413, -0.034718211740255356, 0.007350001018494368, 0.04819897562265396, -0.035066764801740646, -0.07687421143054962, -0.01092644315212965, -0.025301693007349968, -0.012742853723466396, 0.0031459447927773, 0.054225169122219086, -0.036774490028619766, -0.013911452144384384, -0.012253847904503345, -0.0068160295486450195, -0.020723646506667137, -0.042803362011909485, -0.05135529860854149, 0.10202763974666595, 0.01395336166024208, -0.02235722728073597, 0.008310842327773571, -0.018915753811597824, 0.05423707887530327, -0.015986012294888496, -0.004737650044262409, 0.0053473906591534615, 0.12324202060699463, 0.05640328302979469, -0.00976936798542738, -0.003819428849965334, 0.05880650505423546, -0.02515409328043461, 0.016173770651221275, -0.026401616632938385, -0.027896495535969734, -0.02843557670712471, 0.02908780425786972, 0.01661778800189495, -0.03578641265630722, 0.022963207215070724, 0.009649258106946945, -0.03159945085644722, -0.00047141226241365075, 0.02482222206890583, -0.005232986994087696, -0.060437459498643875, -0.036584991961717606, 0.0442853681743145, -0.00507707754150033, 0.05011220648884773, 0.055929239839315414, -0.005039046984165907, 0.030492449179291725, 0.04457644373178482, 0.04511705040931702, 0.01764422468841076, 0.0028119636699557304, -0.04131487011909485, 0.09221742302179337, -0.014521478675305843, 0.03700674697756767, 0.0122976740822196, -0.030971279367804527, 0.024001631885766983, -0.0002284396323375404, -0.00782629381865263, -0.034170955419540405, -0.055305272340774536, -0.0855991542339325, 0.029733845964074135, -0.006862357724457979, -0.017122158780694008, 0.03491376340389252, 0.00879377219825983, -0.027015818282961845, 0.0010227699531242251, 0.013013848103582859, -0.04797375947237015, 0.024111254140734673, -0.02468184381723404, -0.03142010420560837, -0.005340395029634237, 0.03273119777441025, -0.07820671051740646, 0.036931417882442474, -0.017893237993121147, 0.008437377400696278, -0.043406952172517776, -0.03920179605484009, -0.02053128182888031, 0.03370458260178566, 0.05963418632745743, -0.06210368499159813, -0.024564990773797035, 0.033253271132707596, 0.06542365998029709, 0.014401218853890896, -0.013826420530676842, 0.003669793950393796, 0.013774472288787365, -0.048399560153484344, -0.005740986205637455, -0.0006339333485811949, 0.03621378168463707, -0.07588014751672745, -0.027665887027978897, 0.027658803388476372, 0.013819586485624313, -0.022605348378419876, 0.06676031649112701, 0.04658961296081543, -0.02558186650276184, -0.03213845193386078, 0.022501373663544655, 0.04776991531252861, 0.07086823880672455, -0.05764699727296829, -0.02986285090446472, 0.0534355528652668, 0.006546559743583202, 0.00408839201554656, -0.003896445734426379, 0.021781282499432564, -0.012984990142285824, 0.08383908867835999, -0.02849232405424118, -0.030407749116420746, 0.03300393745303154, -0.008913855068385601, -0.006264075171202421, -0.04530508816242218, 0.017094943672418594, -0.0630529448390007, -0.007771202828735113, 0.017490580677986145, 0.0021317279897630215, -0.12316006422042847, 0.027410004287958145, -0.011934504844248295, 0.009435873478651047, 0.03456347435712814, 0.023031270131468773, 0.02055070362985134, -0.03461825102567673, 0.014886194840073586, 0.01722034439444542, -0.06016303226351738, 0.00037325831362977624, 0.02082592248916626, -0.006700723432004452, -0.03680095821619034, 0.0006477429415099323, -0.010228968225419521, 0.0177479051053524, 0.029754718765616417, 0.03005293570458889, -0.010762006975710392, 0.0025129960849881172, -0.015475189313292503, -0.04404783248901367, 0.028381070122122765, -0.0127171715721488, 0.004234683234244585, 0.002844559960067272, 0.02859865501523018, 0.05742108076810837, -0.0033332258462905884, -0.04707451909780502, -0.010549928061664104, 0.04214637354016304, -0.04660087451338768, 0.0033602924086153507, -0.061767611652612686, 0.02944057621061802, -0.018414828926324844, 0.020120874047279358, 0.058780375868082047, -0.04023730754852295, -0.02209881879389286, 0.05472301319241524, 0.05370752513408661, -0.04831422120332718, 0.048883359879255295, -0.00840794201940298, 0.020134620368480682, 0.007212999276816845, -0.01856483519077301, 0.02192397229373455, 0.010403258726000786, -0.00991459283977747, 0.050446681678295135, 0.027313828468322754, 0.003224273445084691, -0.0317625030875206, 0.01088598370552063, 0.0049166870303452015, 0.012423637323081493, -0.09678569436073303, 0.0011301286285743117, 0.0004904522793367505, -0.021986883133649826, -0.03207317367196083, -0.08025844395160675, -0.04092981666326523, 0.020486980676651, -0.02174658142030239, -0.04821270331740379, 0.043596647679805756, 0.006989313289523125, -0.004317169077694416, 0.045138414949178696, 0.002257492858916521, -0.02571537159383297, 0.010417584329843521, -0.05686752870678902, 0.029162075370550156, 0.02899114601314068, 0.01850138232111931, 0.08759800344705582, 0.013766712509095669, -0.008859101682901382, -0.07720492780208588, -0.009389678947627544, -0.008405291475355625, -0.006967189721763134, -0.008186914026737213, 0.004980378318578005, 0.026385044679045677, -0.026699325069785118, -0.006443144287914038, -0.017460567876696587, 0.002401415491476655, -0.01963554322719574, 0.04338008537888527, 0.009790805168449879, -0.060469985008239746, 0.050761375576257706, 0.018727803602814674, -0.03369366005063057, -0.013566570356488228, -0.014283265918493271, -0.03279203921556473, 0.045172370970249176, -0.005152758210897446, 0.0358295775949955, 0.04387994483113289, 0.03436044603586197, -0.030869487673044205, 0.019130578264594078, -0.006022988352924585, -0.003939524758607149, 0.010869072750210762, 0.058747220784425735, -0.03442664444446564, -0.009418862871825695, 0.029353050515055656, -0.0165440384298563, -0.05390024930238724, 0.004796204622834921, -0.061868373304605484, -0.04476992040872574, 0.01502781081944704, -0.019747182726860046, 0.018336221575737, -0.0039479113183915615, -0.03254306688904762, 0.05679285526275635, -0.004772125277668238, -0.010560981929302216, -0.01680757850408554, 0.009427360258996487, -0.009057418443262577, 0.07015782594680786, -0.0717836394906044, 0.08504000306129456, -0.0737990066409111, -0.032440874725580215, 0.012635927647352219, -0.06447313725948334, 0.03422197699546814, 0.0056180646643042564, 0.03978842869400978, -0.05834847688674927, 0.017405565828084946, 0.010765464045107365, -0.031965937465429306, 0.024683205410838127, 0.04459366947412491, 0.03983517736196518, -0.016153885051608086, 0.028620095923542976, 0.00454415800049901, -0.0017533795908093452, -0.014115697704255581, -0.005016885697841644, -0.0021875989623367786, -0.013152030296623707, 0.04273606464266777, -0.005639000330120325, 0.01025378704071045, 0.027927063405513763, -0.022240860387682915, -0.012772694230079651, -0.005067940801382065, -0.035164933651685715, 0.006977701559662819, 0.008012167178094387, 0.04266120120882988, 0.05460543930530548, 0.04131808131933212, -0.040351614356040955, 0.07751774787902832, 0.017370328307151794, -0.0294272992759943, -0.08534335345029831, -0.007510462310165167, -0.01531286258250475, -0.03974992409348488, -0.053209319710731506, 0.03174974024295807, 0.01923668384552002, -0.021370697766542435, -0.004872744902968407, -0.027097158133983612, -0.03730683773756027, 0.0014987447066232562, 0.035457924008369446, 0.002781868213787675, 0.04760555177927017, -0.08641883730888367, -0.020832937210798264, 0.0148328747600317, -0.0647539272904396, -0.02310105413198471, 0.01686628721654415, 0.006501894444227219, -0.00533333420753479, -0.004273034166544676, -0.009848994202911854, -0.025648821145296097, -0.03827675059437752, -0.035782042890787125, -0.05255379155278206, 0.018254734575748444, -0.012849055230617523, -0.0371810682117939, 0.04232317954301834, -0.012793408706784248, 0.003371130209416151, 0.01907338760793209, -0.0013021832564845681, 0.013357962481677532, -0.007935990579426289, 0.009726828895509243, -0.037007223814725876, 0.02437262050807476, -0.025474930182099342, -0.04043198004364967, -0.0637466087937355, 0.016693711280822754, -0.019607121124863625, -0.006193546112626791, 0.03632195666432381, 0.02042222209274769, 0.051351528614759445, 0.0009087330545298755, 0.06052712723612785, 0.01579246297478676, 0.04318041726946831, -0.013708824291825294, 0.06099846214056015, -0.007062642835080624, -0.011033489368855953, -0.004386059008538723, 0.009807616472244263, -0.002644201973453164, 0.009604132734239101, -0.05714329704642296, 0.05111200734972954, -0.0051101092249155045, -0.005724055226892233, 0.01172513049095869, -0.024550456553697586, 0.05032986402511597, 0.0737132877111435, 0.019398916512727737, -0.028475867584347725, -0.011121477000415325, 0.031867124140262604, -0.028455758467316628, -0.026124831289052963, 0.003582472214475274, -0.02219148725271225, -0.04622471332550049, -0.008694012649357319, -0.06419239938259125, -0.06398282200098038, 0.0015102495672181249, 0.03580646589398384, 0.03511225804686546, -0.024003662168979645, 0.03581280633807182, -0.04849116876721382, 0.04873527213931084, -0.07681494951248169, -0.032093778252601624, 0.01208845991641283, -0.05829983204603195, 0.022906547412276268, -0.0008321438799612224, 0.01631123758852482, -0.04586383327841759, 0.016084516420960426, -0.0548270046710968, 0.0018304340774193406, -0.0353386253118515, -0.024002674967050552, -0.006516675930470228, 0.06696522980928421, -0.010365072637796402, 0.0361262746155262, -0.03328792378306389, -0.0484510213136673, 0.04367716237902641, 0.0005386004922911525, -0.04230562224984169, 0.0022448236122727394, -0.013100643642246723, 0.015316719189286232, 0.005071604624390602, -0.015415862202644348, -0.027315465733408928, -0.060251813381910324, 0.009567869827151299, 0.01751551777124405, -0.059692975133657455, 0.030496101826429367, 0.0026459444779902697 ]
<p>Look at this <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subatomic_particle" rel="nofollow">here.</a> With respect to the sciences, the atom is obviously not the smallest piece of mass. Apparently, if people have already broken down the atom in to particles smaller than so, why haven't particles been understood yet?</p> <p>Old scholars reasoned that <a href="http://j.gs/4129297/smallerparts" rel="nofollow">everything has smaller parts</a>, so what's smaller than subatomic particles?</p> <p>Or is there a limit in the size of mass, only being able to be small to an extent?</p> <p>Because mass always seems to keep growing, but when scaling opposite in size we reach a limit. Therefore, big always gets bigger, but why does small have limits?</p>
g5833
[ 0.06895574182271957, 0.09928354620933533, 0.0031656185165047646, -0.012505226768553257, -0.003583140205591917, 0.05669056996703148, -0.007208942901343107, 0.008525303564965725, -0.07362808287143707, -0.07927530258893967, 0.01334221102297306, 0.01053876243531704, -0.01020104344934225, -0.003835537703707814, 0.004498480353504419, 0.011033779010176659, -0.010023104026913643, -0.05773955583572388, 0.03521957993507385, 0.05963291600346565, 0.06858974695205688, 0.029972035437822342, 0.023842426016926765, -0.04656510800123215, -0.05686061456799507, 0.04475516825914383, 0.008677826263010502, -0.02946263737976551, -0.027439698576927185, 0.0047147562727332115, 0.042844563722610474, -0.004540374502539635, 0.010613963939249516, -0.01856148988008499, 0.09155482053756714, -0.07694417238235474, 0.011210327036678791, 0.01888827607035637, 0.007603574078530073, 0.011206239461898804, 0.028247712180018425, -0.027262311428785324, 0.01998354122042656, -0.01799064502120018, -0.0024482819717377424, 0.015284270979464054, 0.020855143666267395, -0.002600749023258686, 0.03572431951761246, -0.04550359025597572, 0.004925986286252737, 0.021415675058960915, -0.0029956933576613665, 0.03832641616463661, 0.05867965891957283, -0.012092769145965576, 0.017889445647597313, -0.029216213151812553, 0.09087500721216202, 0.0014699402963742614, 0.021758241578936577, 0.04620252549648285, -0.021660830825567245, 0.03995205834507942, 0.036326587200164795, -0.019611703231930733, -0.057144828140735626, -0.008565815165638924, 0.02450362965464592, 0.028849931433796883, 0.012134775519371033, -0.049705732613801956, -0.051766686141490936, -0.04198301210999489, -0.016390439122915268, -0.016806375235319138, -0.008671625517308712, 0.051466092467308044, 0.03006867878139019, 0.02102787233889103, -0.022022515535354614, -0.059319403022527695, 0.020577292889356613, -0.005753996316343546, 0.04344348609447479, 0.02947230078279972, -0.055203620344400406, -0.06338253617286682, -0.029822301119565964, 0.0301956869661808, -0.008968055248260498, 0.021486470475792885, 0.028818748891353607, -0.04517402499914169, -0.023140819743275642, -0.02675308845937252, 0.02818986214697361, 0.025523414835333824, -0.07450257241725922, 0.011564875952899456, 0.03841142728924751, 0.03189743310213089, 0.022759217768907547, -0.006378189194947481, 0.0339958630502224, 0.01772972196340561, -0.017194781452417374, 0.01346140168607235, 0.0210538562387228, -0.005416448228061199, -0.007699861656874418, -0.02013896033167839, -0.05167517811059952, -0.03517359867691994, -0.07054527848958969, 0.027724631130695343, 0.07054601609706879, 0.011097565293312073, 0.0053843120113015175, 0.040268704295158386, -0.05808332562446594, -0.03386339172720909, -0.00321334321051836, -0.006409878842532635, -0.0851835310459137, -0.05132003501057625, 0.022261975333094597, 0.052067168056964874, -0.023386400192975998, -0.08071120828390121, 0.00903557799756527, 0.030563507229089737, -0.0689806342124939, -0.0028938977047801018, 0.036928292363882065, -0.006643494591116905, -0.04926081746816635, -0.040506284683942795, -0.029235102236270905, -0.02274429425597191, 0.02340194396674633, 0.05736006051301956, 0.033601514995098114, 0.021424993872642517, -0.017977848649024963, 0.011054513975977898, -0.012560485862195492, 0.03503328189253807, -0.06665969640016556, 0.06865811347961426, 0.0028725438751280308, 0.03732017055153847, -0.004855382721871138, -0.024268124252557755, -0.01654147356748581, 0.031237218528985977, 0.03804614394903183, -0.0143022695556283, 0.010933848097920418, 0.02216743864119053, -0.0031996830366551876, 0.04382012411952019, -0.05018315836787224, 0.005432207603007555, -0.07199517637491226, 0.08448562771081924, 0.01805000565946102, -0.0010717186378315091, -0.06201241537928581, -0.053447965532541275, -0.09236183017492294, -0.027204588055610657, 0.004365439526736736, 0.043964531272649765, -0.046408966183662415, 0.04782519489526749, 0.013564620167016983, -0.003332868916913867, 0.02338383160531521, 0.00782123114913702, -0.018580147996544838, -0.07767976075410843, 0.011647437699139118, -0.017593814060091972, 0.0001046338293235749, 0.00785273127257824, 0.0266217403113842, 0.04742877930402756, 0.045511431992053986, -0.03968602791428566, -0.013697867281734943, -0.083260677754879, -0.019137848168611526, 0.011402656324207783, 0.037889495491981506, -0.027930650860071182, -0.029356302693486214, -0.056489840149879456, -0.017526572570204735, -0.049429457634687424, -0.03099972940981388, 0.01194110419601202, 0.02082298882305622, 0.0243922621011734, 0.10443908721208572, -0.005451141856610775, -0.038487814366817474, 0.02642342634499073, -0.014902323484420776, 0.032983869314193726, 0.027632534503936768, -0.050015129148960114, 0.010910467244684696, -0.009100428782403469, 0.012202490121126175, 0.028734887018799782, 0.014294707216322422, 0.020590441301465034, 0.0416509285569191, -0.003374050371348858, 0.013638591393828392, -0.07416849583387375, 0.018411576747894287, -0.01848302222788334, 0.004652042873203754, 0.060445934534072876, -0.011368460021913052, -0.03105224296450615, 0.00214203167706728, 0.028028633445501328, -0.08975613862276077, 0.025858672335743904, -0.01775689423084259, -0.020628931000828743, 0.004854649305343628, -0.038638342171907425, 0.0019856493454426527, -0.07598505914211273, -0.05291297286748886, 0.009081319905817509, 0.02107485756278038, -0.0586918406188488, -0.00028772212681360543, 0.004873803351074457, 0.02575504221022129, -0.09231322258710861, 0.005226658657193184, -0.0397229865193367, -0.018404653295874596, 0.021532071754336357, 0.01857270672917366, -0.005963772069662809, -0.005709049291908741, 0.004187834914773703, -0.019413292407989502, -0.02524111047387123, 0.019244099035859108, 0.045687273144721985, -0.03972069174051285, -0.0585298128426075, 0.009427397511899471, 0.010830787010490894, -0.006796048954129219, 0.027391526848077774, -0.017181934788823128, -0.04612837731838226, -0.04122449457645416, 0.013270851224660873, 0.04524508863687515, 0.003164843888953328, -0.005779840052127838, 0.10325977206230164, -0.0225434098392725, -0.002437605755403638, -0.03864068537950516, 0.0522298738360405, 0.0146401422098279, -0.04329114779829979, 0.08006097376346588, -0.016594864428043365, -0.0016969558782875538, 0.03994511440396309, -0.051947563886642456, 0.0012536280555650592, 0.0511786974966526, -0.02312951348721981, -0.030109340324997902, -0.040950268507003784, -0.026437094435095787, 0.007530344650149345, -0.050121795386075974, 0.023881686851382256, 0.0815318301320076, 0.0016706505557522178, 0.030470820143818855, 0.03794640302658081, 0.04956948757171631, 0.00016954132297541946, -0.04230914264917374, 0.05462566763162613, 0.007907615974545479, -0.019180862233042717, -0.01742195524275303, -0.01851646415889263, -0.0035423862282186747, 0.05141516774892807, -0.014910122379660606, -0.012948419898748398, -0.0397987924516201, 0.004020388703793287, 0.04152689501643181, 0.06669926643371582, 0.01764417625963688, 0.025289984419941902, -0.04570472985506058, -0.010878607630729675, -0.00873499270528555, 0.05902041122317314, 0.0258011594414711, -0.04307283088564873, -0.03827790543437004, -0.01787867397069931, -0.0003013555542565882, -0.01536621805280447, -0.005512128584086895, -0.011098106391727924, -0.016706708818674088, -0.005398138426244259, 0.019422609359025955, -0.007215116173028946, -0.016527073457837105, -0.025770999491214752, -0.04035533219575882, 0.030307572335004807, -0.06067615747451782, -0.060941312462091446, 0.012864993885159492, 0.0024762803222984076, 0.02604735642671585, -0.04366869106888771, 0.02708321250975132, 0.030345134437084198, -0.046474210917949677, 0.005221284460276365, 0.007978636771440506, 0.048829108476638794, -0.028353407979011536, 0.008316578343510628, 0.010595039464533329, -0.033495962619781494, -0.018420225009322166, 0.05253972113132477, 0.02637188881635666, 0.03782958164811134, -0.01582668535411358, 0.05127429962158203, 0.018339654430747032, 0.035364653915166855, 0.01435695681720972, -0.044495511800050735, -0.018727241083979607, -0.023950986564159393, 0.052607279270887375, 0.041205212473869324, -0.0007694061496295035, 0.03525229170918465, -0.005275200121104717, 0.0018274125177413225, 0.05353434383869171, -0.05165932700037956, -0.007215368095785379, -0.021243920549750328, 0.01940295100212097, 0.026547115296125412, 0.002578151412308216, -0.025165511295199394, 0.03238602355122566, 0.03521188348531723, 0.0260333139449358, -0.07383720576763153, 0.035220667719841, 0.05421478673815727, 0.043672069907188416, -0.046351708471775055, -0.028231920674443245, -0.020905040204524994, -0.08115282654762268, -0.04518730938434601, -0.018895089626312256, -0.011579528450965881, -0.020895127207040787, -0.029776157811284065, -0.029967883601784706, -0.01747068762779236, 0.04737451300024986, 0.013348517939448357, 0.006174142472445965, -0.05198255181312561, 0.03914212808012962, 0.03778613731265068, -0.011557208374142647, 0.02731889858841896, -0.09603095799684525, -0.012635357677936554, 0.032890208065509796, 0.03841451182961464, -0.013401790522038937, 0.03356195241212845, -0.046429798007011414, -0.060072317719459534, 0.04124150425195694, 0.02226594276726246, 0.02023734524846077, 0.008451526053249836, -0.005846856161952019, -0.014016389846801758, -0.06392721086740494, -0.023092875257134438, 0.047357749193906784, 0.0207766555249691, -0.03945066034793854, 0.000251283694524318, -0.030655603855848312, -0.0274457186460495, -0.009323984384536743, 0.06444994360208511, -0.08387541770935059, 0.0035674823448061943, -0.008910794742405415, -0.007088460028171539, 0.024307457730174065, 0.0391433946788311, 0.015978189185261726, -0.029290614649653435, -0.04541359841823578, 0.01214202307164669, -0.013550357893109322, 0.05558386817574501, 0.0069518606178462505, 0.016362760215997696, 0.057144638150930405, 0.054262369871139526, -0.014003164134919643, 0.0896134078502655, 0.007975654676556587, 0.028685515746474266, 0.0033438263926655054, 0.02197757363319397, -0.01827252097427845, -0.016335252672433853, -0.05892506241798401, 0.02552291378378868, -0.04609553515911102, -0.10348875820636749, 0.008568079210817814, -0.03829197958111763, -0.04267273098230362, 0.034223783761262894, -0.014372165314853191, 0.07105386257171631, -0.06666185706853867, -0.024845536798238754, 0.020906638354063034, 0.019234489649534225, 0.020932363346219063, 0.015384561382234097, -0.05169433355331421, -0.015651531517505646, -0.04399117827415466, 0.03751605749130249, -0.05070263519883156, 0.05025935918092728, 0.023640772327780724, -0.019757535308599472, 0.015983853489160538, -0.03873062878847122, 0.0023688282817602158, -0.04477310553193092, 0.02452927827835083, -0.018323220312595367, -0.026979077607393265, 0.0055190883576869965, 0.005732094403356314, 0.05722888186573982, 0.007308798376470804, 0.04341932386159897, -0.07649628072977066, 0.04288297891616821, -0.03816838562488556, -0.026152558624744415, -0.015527291223406792, 0.00932235922664404, -0.01110044401139021, -0.002450712025165558, -0.007458700332790613, -0.016780532896518707, 0.020400578156113625, -0.030681932345032692, 0.024773895740509033, -0.028100095689296722, -0.0014044290874153376, -0.009199628606438637, -0.005228688940405846, 0.021198377013206482, 0.02454882487654686, 0.033062923699617386, 0.004856687039136887, -0.04400859400629997, 0.006022893823683262, -0.03709224984049797, 0.012304975651204586, 0.021465957164764404, -0.000749376427847892, -0.024211306124925613, 0.018515335395932198, -0.005115645471960306, -0.011553827673196793, 0.029210448265075684, -0.02466331422328949, 0.004831545986235142, 0.01255644578486681, -0.009735934436321259, 0.04409072548151016, -0.048547569662332535, 0.0053320047445595264, 0.026344455778598785, -0.009834540076553822, -0.03701154142618179, -0.03464562073349953, 0.05837502330541611, 0.054028742015361786, -0.004768489859998226, 0.014731552451848984, 0.029483867809176445, -0.03214846923947334, 0.08095241338014603, -0.06800404191017151, 0.03229552134871483, 0.027971584349870682, -0.014505856670439243, 0.0072868820279836655, -0.021875720471143723, -0.04424643516540527, 0.023289529606699944, 0.05555238574743271, -0.019763441756367683, 0.016812747344374657, 0.008936772122979164, 0.06474962085485458, -0.007687704171985388, 0.0032608704641461372, -0.006032908335328102, -0.01922999881207943, -0.03372849151492119, 0.01842893846333027, 0.0460018590092659, -0.000014045811440155376, 0.01976609416306019, -0.042348407208919525, -0.0517890490591526, 0.042536117136478424, -0.006989944260567427, 0.035780757665634155, -0.009904447942972183, -0.00046829989878460765, -0.06339888274669647, -0.016292056068778038, -0.021526530385017395, -0.012611333280801773, 0.026915518566966057, -0.03325830399990082, 0.013468426652252674, 0.05117504298686981, 0.036552730947732925, -0.006198052316904068, 0.014126617461442947, -0.033144641667604446, -0.04478948190808296, -0.0011812931625172496, -0.022710202261805534, 0.032399240881204605, 0.026732927188277245, -0.02407471276819706, -0.02025233581662178, -0.004886595066636801, 0.021763445809483528, -0.054646432399749756, -0.031877294182777405, 0.07154430449008942, 0.01080184243619442, 0.010065974667668343, -0.008396453224122524, -0.004880023188889027, -0.03300159052014351, -0.025709759443998337, -0.08918587863445282, -0.0017663484904915094, -0.06407052278518677, -0.017939560115337372, -0.0022589925210922956, -0.012109640054404736, 0.04072339087724686, 0.025646690279245377, 0.04186604171991348, 0.0293213352560997, 0.058005236089229584, 0.008743669837713242, 0.012254699133336544, 0.028147462755441666, 0.022802677005529404, -0.042299944907426834, 0.009971948340535164, 0.028055615723133087, -0.025559311732649803, 0.044842422008514404, -0.05775997415184975, -0.012725678272545338, 0.021858585998415947, -0.05708281323313713, -0.025846727192401886, 0.011595718562602997, 0.01710529811680317, -0.031062645837664604, -0.044108763337135315, -0.008180354721844196, 0.05284961685538292, 0.04860936477780342, 0.07756830006837845, 0.051405128091573715, 0.020844293758273125, 0.0020413105376064777, -0.013990727253258228, 0.006030470598489046, 0.08154506981372833, -0.03493919223546982, 0.0473538339138031, -0.03260060399770737, 0.003071142826229334, 0.0448995940387249, 0.017750678583979607, -0.0003210723225492984, -0.017524247989058495, -0.03233523294329643, 0.046120788902044296, -0.041211776435375214, 0.01992540992796421, 0.058251187205314636, 0.04590979963541031, -0.04451989009976387, -0.05667668953537941, -0.01155962236225605, 0.06284059584140778, -0.03065875545144081, -0.008298731409013271, 0.0016067511169239879, -0.00592842185869813, -0.017545297741889954, -0.009320666082203388, 0.03107398748397827, -0.033930569887161255, -0.04599354788661003, 0.047746434807777405, 0.04708758741617203, -0.0046885572373867035, 0.024072889238595963, 0.028565192595124245, 0.022171834483742714, -0.023027542978525162, -0.03417704254388809, -0.049416348338127136, -0.012755661271512508, -0.01867172308266163, -0.01951524056494236, -0.016128627583384514, 0.07437856495380402, -0.0023572887293994427, -0.006297271233052015, -0.016475219279527664, 0.030875397846102715, 0.03648960590362549, 0.062443193048238754, 0.04199660196900368, 0.016480019316077232, 0.020991358906030655, 0.019109239801764488, -0.000714864581823349, -0.09094665944576263, 0.009303257800638676, -0.016977358609437943, -0.015443804673850536, 0.02139580063521862, 0.013002611696720123, 0.006732824724167585, 0.023209964856505394, -0.02713838219642639, -0.008868139237165451, 0.01744970865547657, -0.005389832891523838, -0.027526168152689934, -0.019958598539233208, 0.024680549278855324, -0.03968922421336174, 0.038157425820827484, -0.04916633293032646, 0.03760961443185806, 0.056108977645635605, 0.006771318148821592, 0.0407429039478302, -0.018665751442313194, -0.05354195088148117, -0.06173068657517433, 0.003549412824213505, 0.035356272011995316, 0.001632428029552102, 0.025419319048523903, 0.03654050827026367, -0.007819755002856255, -0.060603924095630646, 0.0195335503667593, -0.03730116784572601, 0.06809847801923752, -0.0065974099561572075, -0.019857028499245644, -0.04687812924385071, -0.029267432168126106, -0.026762915775179863, 0.03041490539908409, 0.009519044309854507, -0.007061679381877184, -0.032359231263399124, -0.03735995292663574, 0.05041023716330528, -0.0023350019473582506, -0.026033315807580948, -0.05768948048353195, 0.05196075141429901, 0.038963790982961655, 0.0090691102668643, -0.03398163989186287, -0.011175851337611675, 0.028643352910876274, -0.034984003752470016, 0.01817982830107212, 0.06295844912528992, -0.036456212401390076, 0.0006942915497347713, -0.04774443432688713, 0.009536796249449253, 0.06015860289335251, 0.0011987528996542096, -0.06978907436132431, -0.017781060189008713, 0.02331925928592682, 0.02326870523393154, 0.03757568448781967, -0.021355152130126953, 0.02392287738621235, 0.06366641819477081, -0.008853132836520672, 0.009610669687390327, 0.003452959004789591, 0.04334789142012596, 0.05569174513220787, -0.038822390139102936, 0.02994087152183056, -0.043373625725507736, -0.03977326303720474, -0.029445547610521317 ]
<p>In my understanding the <a href="http://www.fyzikalni-experimenty.cz/en/mechanics/atmospheric-pressure-upside-down-glasses-of-water/" rel="nofollow">well-known</a> experiment of the glass full of water in equilibrium with a piece of paper, the atmospheric pressure acts on a small layer inside the glass (on the top) and under the paper (outside the glass), the hydrostatic pressure (basically the weight of the water) acts downward, so in term of forces I initially have a net force $$ \boldsymbol F = (p_A -p_A+\rho g h)A\hat z$$ where $A$ is the section of the glass, $\hat z$ is the vertical direction, and $h$ the height of the layer of water. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/XmiCy.jpg" alt="enter image description here"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/KOjYP.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Now, when the paper bends under the weight of the water, and the air layer on the top increases in volume, so I can apply (with good approximation) $$pV=nRT,\ V\ \uparrow\ \Rightarrow\ p\downarrow\ \Rightarrow\ p'&lt;p_A $$</p> <p>So we have: $$\boldsymbol F = A(p'-p_A+\rho g h)\hat z$$ and since $p'-p_A&lt;0$, it is possible to have $\boldsymbol F$ upward (clearly, depending on $h$ and $\rho$)</p> <p>Now, I made the experiment with water, and the bending of the paper was upward. Can I say that the only reason is the presence of the surface tension of water? Or my reasoning is lacking somewhere else too?</p> <p>Moreover, if instead of the paper I put a strongly stiff material, I can't have the same effect, no matter the weight, the geometry, etc? </p> <p>Thanks </p>
g5834
[ 0.056600797921419144, 0.0046417973935604095, -0.006670202594250441, -0.006206023506820202, 0.0010295769898220897, 0.0663084164261818, -0.002815375104546547, 0.0007483139634132385, -0.03590269759297371, -0.020580025389790535, 0.036145832389593124, -0.008886262774467468, -0.0591357946395874, 0.02854977175593376, -0.010770409367978573, 0.07093845307826996, 0.0781235545873642, -0.041948575526475906, -0.005009617190808058, -0.01478695496916771, -0.08332245796918869, -0.04079805687069893, -0.030613165348768234, -0.010776582174003124, -0.04689272493124008, -0.01537715271115303, 0.017000647261738777, -0.039902523159980774, -0.02891545370221138, 0.011796398088335991, -0.0027723019011318684, 0.020793654024600983, -0.0013515682658180594, -0.07429996132850647, -0.0025025198701769114, 0.01691613160073757, 0.06624758243560791, -0.02419089712202549, 0.015406177379190922, -0.020259413868188858, -0.027271078899502754, 0.04897783324122429, -0.0260066706687212, -0.0016334315296262503, -0.014348939061164856, 0.027315491810441017, -0.0381368026137352, 0.028196508064866066, -0.0325654074549675, -0.06016898527741432, 0.02321290783584118, 0.03643008694052696, -0.006818868685513735, -0.0029922965914011, 0.020350143313407898, 0.018196189776062965, 0.03959100693464279, 0.0424460805952549, 0.07949583232402802, 0.004263643175363541, -0.06338972598314285, 0.04635243862867355, 0.0047510722652077675, -0.0017747256206348538, 0.03257990628480911, 0.008828227408230305, -0.032177891582250595, -0.024753322824835777, 0.025605015456676483, -0.001438461011275649, 0.008009734563529491, -0.033386360853910446, -0.05473442003130913, -0.03937041759490967, -0.03545646741986275, 0.003798537654802203, -0.02183070033788681, 0.006398795172572136, 0.03250100463628769, -0.06263456493616104, 0.054092686623334885, 0.02865009568631649, -0.0025509661063551903, 0.011917605064809322, 0.05618891492486, -0.027094509452581406, 0.04642670974135399, -0.005424764938652515, 0.003551492700353265, -0.020958587527275085, -0.018255097791552544, -0.04712162911891937, 0.054566022008657455, 0.01906633749604225, 0.01959685981273651, -0.020267274230718613, 0.00393905071541667, 0.04146613925695419, -0.04828709363937378, -0.025816382840275764, -0.037721212953329086, -0.011440134607255459, 0.04131064936518669, 0.02947445586323738, -0.04384537786245346, -0.002241065725684166, 0.062212731689214706, 0.04852452874183655, -0.06752415001392365, -0.10507112741470337, -0.02526654116809368, 0.04643833264708519, -0.03974482789635658, -0.047020766884088516, 0.01721843332052231, -0.04649726301431656, 0.0469372384250164, 0.02160687744617462, 0.012601007707417011, 0.03158445656299591, -0.020588144659996033, 0.002948000328615308, 0.028805505484342575, 0.06393556296825409, -0.02494443766772747, 0.00020255062554497272, 0.03015037812292576, 0.06558477878570557, -0.01359787117689848, -0.05498218163847923, 0.07349716126918793, 0.02843715250492096, -0.016498342156410217, -0.014471313916146755, 0.05088696628808975, 0.007142804097384214, -0.05805696174502373, -0.010731540620326996, 0.036009158939123154, -0.010849036276340485, -0.0163408312946558, 0.00942703802138567, -0.012801703996956348, 0.009246611036360264, -0.015707746148109436, 0.021282820031046867, 0.0047083161771297455, 0.04731416702270508, 0.005505419801920652, -0.04775451123714447, -0.03464818373322487, 0.01703071780502796, -0.021722575649619102, -0.008981933817267418, 0.01526421494781971, -0.02090647630393505, 0.03198445960879326, -0.05618400126695633, 0.04173250123858452, 0.04076985642313957, 0.06409601122140884, -0.03867380693554878, 0.0023963311687111855, 0.0050688073970377445, -0.08932305872440338, 0.023319391533732414, -0.02006675861775875, 0.047099675983190536, -0.029305370524525642, -0.03879861161112785, -0.08199454843997955, 0.009288058616220951, 0.010012071579694748, 0.008450223132967949, -0.016867835074663162, 0.019323112443089485, 0.04115511104464531, 0.003692453494295478, 0.07129625231027603, 0.02896154299378395, -0.022584542632102966, 0.0018347138538956642, -0.030666295439004898, -0.04569865018129349, 0.015460348688066006, 0.0142437145113945, 0.011887059547007084, 0.028363078832626343, -0.05122462287545204, 0.009316332638263702, -0.03970843926072121, 0.027894675731658936, -0.01733853481709957, 0.0029866397380828857, -0.03804954141378403, -0.014398363418877125, 0.0648881271481514, -0.006433861330151558, -0.04527522251009941, 0.027527576312422752, -0.0024972311221063137, 0.02594514936208725, 0.04131544381380081, -0.027041396126151085, -0.01067569013684988, 0.026347778737545013, -0.03935862332582474, -0.0064971791580319405, -0.0043296413496136665, 0.05510871112346649, -0.03416330739855766, 0.00003325205761939287, -0.0041961572133004665, -0.030480829998850822, 0.04570075124502182, -0.00807838886976242, -0.026235898956656456, -0.005206394474953413, -0.044197820127010345, 0.05068088695406914, -0.02210475504398346, 0.010342955589294434, -0.026550324633717537, 0.027209695428609848, -0.08718828856945038, -0.005528546869754791, 0.018014121800661087, -0.01878306455910206, -0.029122697189450264, -0.035672396421432495, -0.02577792853116989, -0.0008180774166248739, 0.009364494122564793, -0.006341670174151659, 0.04708762839436531, 0.07946865260601044, 0.04029548913240433, 0.044237639755010605, -0.0007296371622942388, -0.017999649047851562, -0.03746910020709038, -0.07645709067583084, -0.049497902393341064, 0.0015669094864279032, 0.03254847601056099, 0.02419257164001465, -0.017391348257660866, -0.015982739627361298, 0.042667705565690994, 0.04224444925785065, 0.07333822548389435, -0.026088856160640717, 0.04570579528808594, 0.02893991954624653, -0.00900962483137846, -0.020440559834241867, -0.09070917963981628, 0.004856803920120001, -0.017917539924383163, -0.023771539330482483, 0.01770162582397461, -0.015400619246065617, 0.002691452158614993, -0.002289928263053298, -0.09003255516290665, 0.03439735248684883, -0.07844538241624832, -0.01491793617606163, 0.0599261112511158, 0.0504743754863739, 0.04457373544573784, 0.020295744761824608, -0.0071638901717960835, 0.05275258049368858, -0.013571562245488167, -0.001634184387512505, -0.06380169093608856, -0.012389100156724453, 0.027244282886385918, -0.024619130417704582, -0.009331301786005497, 0.0065384418703615665, -0.05203739181160927, -0.025159010663628578, -0.008719664998352528, -0.012201144360005856, -0.020991424098610878, 0.0156753771007061, -0.016774438321590424, 0.008764143101871014, 0.04908066615462303, 0.0018220256315544248, 0.030200788751244545, 0.026547720655798912, 0.04936164245009422, 0.04487382620573044, 0.006842963397502899, -0.0689065232872963, -0.028499985113739967, 0.028649158775806427, -0.028350340202450752, -0.011219698935747147, 0.03826325386762619, 0.030902104452252388, 0.0028130272403359413, 0.05014418438076973, -0.032964013516902924, -0.03011435829102993, -0.011396363377571106, 0.0022954416926950216, 0.02339445799589157, 0.033794522285461426, -0.011464796960353851, -0.01998588815331459, -0.07060450315475464, -0.00578295299783349, 0.0012737262295559049, -0.04113134369254112, -0.02186710201203823, -0.008740957826375961, -0.05449213832616806, -0.027650827541947365, -0.007259975653141737, 0.02508685365319252, 0.019105752930045128, 0.0184563547372818, -0.02699934132397175, 0.030193543061614037, -0.01488213986158371, -0.03242184594273567, 0.059326596558094025, 0.03224469721317291, 0.011072841472923756, -0.06330396234989166, -0.008610197342932224, 0.02512674778699875, 0.02563522756099701, 0.01922708749771118, 0.05444334074854851, 0.05219583213329315, -0.004447975195944309, -0.04000314325094223, 0.009406797587871552, -0.006546032149344683, -0.004026604816317558, -0.005048963241279125, 0.03516579791903496, 0.04322536289691925, 0.001858367002569139, 0.047429438680410385, 0.019523601979017258, 0.019003460183739662, 0.008615221828222275, -0.03701964020729065, 0.063898466527462, 0.008228507824242115, 0.03748545050621033, 0.024881575256586075, -0.015090939588844776, -0.0011000196682289243, 0.021251259371638298, 0.002475098008289933, 0.00741109624505043, 0.018240999430418015, -0.01896718330681324, 0.0001366694486932829, -0.010607981123030186, 0.07868032157421112, -0.04945460334420204, 0.012878536246716976, 0.021947860717773438, -0.04167227819561958, -0.023705603554844856, 0.038952093571424484, 0.0456986278295517, -0.00045962558942846954, 0.038273658603429794, -0.013169812969863415, 0.0251080971211195, 0.011009912006556988, 0.08944948762655258, 0.02745325118303299, 0.03657074645161629, 0.06710842996835709, 0.04587022215127945, 0.05132921412587166, -0.10831557214260101, -0.0009226843249052763, 0.053023286163806915, -0.026147939264774323, 0.007921796292066574, -0.0042130849324166775, -0.00465245870873332, 0.018820611760020256, 0.014010404236614704, 0.0322834849357605, 0.026199789717793465, -0.002025035908445716, -0.013178651221096516, -0.02527456544339657, 0.04229626804590225, -0.01679941453039646, -0.023506931960582733, 0.045298222452402115, -0.055398669093847275, 0.021348746493458748, 0.03722694143652916, -0.03757447749376297, -0.10971397161483765, -0.03389119729399681, 0.04475611075758934, -0.05220454931259155, -0.07142705470323563, -0.049276597797870636, -0.00020442504319362342, 0.03482981398701668, 0.014414513483643532, 0.04071856290102005, 0.001449501607567072, -0.010346527211368084, 0.021524595096707344, 0.06644411385059357, -0.03791457787156105, -0.023191208019852638, 0.005664278753101826, 0.024123597890138626, -0.021494537591934204, 0.005910803563892841, 0.05553092807531357, -0.029797272756695747, 0.006691245827823877, 0.021638859063386917, -0.03341452777385712, -0.035938650369644165, 0.012242645025253296, 0.06899020820856094, 0.02482474409043789, 0.015112074092030525, -0.000384403218049556, 0.05731137469410896, 0.005372460000216961, 0.002310649026185274, -0.004286792129278183, 0.009592217393219471, 0.04726189002394676, 0.033632807433605194, -0.04459775239229202, 0.006432793568819761, -0.007171077653765678, -0.03952544555068016, -0.09082139283418655, -0.011280779726803303, 0.020363111048936844, -0.022210007533431053, -0.00047563816769979894, 0.012835143133997917, -0.07168301939964294, 0.04216942936182022, -0.052370648831129074, -0.00748845050111413, -0.0004206485755275935, -0.0293397419154644, -0.029565097764134407, 0.012624720111489296, 0.0050489697605371475, -0.0036763413809239864, -0.07889796793460846, -0.036480359733104706, -0.009968182072043419, -0.005960884504020214, 0.040849924087524414, 0.04227011278271675, -0.008531330153346062, 0.09067076444625854, -0.02557416446506977, 0.030805019661784172, 0.005621012300252914, -0.017093362286686897, 0.028751546517014503, -0.04286181181669235, -0.011623403988778591, 0.09427890181541443, 0.031014006584882736, -0.002829179400578141, -0.007285583298653364, -0.024082615971565247, -0.042978376150131226, 0.020554719492793083, -0.007079523988068104, -0.036358848214149475, -0.01770669035613537, -0.008307518437504768, -0.05630861595273018, -0.01974003203213215, -0.04684344306588173, -0.018979523330926895, 0.012452156282961369, 0.028366858139634132, 0.02517990581691265, -0.03751590847969055, -0.06359464675188065, -0.04732581973075867, 0.03150368854403496, 0.014205115847289562, 0.03828522562980652, -0.00047269556671380997, 0.03356631100177765, -0.025019405409693718, 0.042827803641557693, 0.07229150831699371, 0.008646663278341293, -0.0485701821744442, 0.0352335125207901, 0.030777601525187492, 0.050451572984457016, 0.002852222416549921, -0.04602348431944847, 0.02589341625571251, -0.011784576810896397, 0.034158751368522644, 0.0632893443107605, 0.0013346639461815357, 0.01012011244893074, -0.01387044321745634, -0.026294365525245667, 0.038697872310876846, -0.05593917891383171, -0.013232914730906487, 0.030616503208875656, -0.005621137097477913, -0.007793170865625143, 0.04385676980018616, 0.022320756688714027, -0.003811443690210581, -0.0005212784162722528, -0.041329581290483475, -0.017734570428729057, 0.0026447479613125324, 0.08523236215114594, -0.0008119394187815487, 0.013177984394133091, -0.025786027312278748, 0.031148947775363922, 0.06276507675647736, 0.03338553011417389, 0.03361240401864052, -0.03704877197742462, -0.03681223839521408, 0.05980760231614113, 0.04251761734485626, 0.008669347502291203, 0.02366110123693943, -0.058901842683553696, 0.05061371996998787, -0.00003467076749075204, -0.019698843359947205, -0.0178647730499506, -0.09640185534954071, 0.0427202545106411, -0.05220619961619377, 0.06742416322231293, -0.003501248313114047, 0.00720295961946249, 0.007889965549111366, 0.007642955519258976, -0.05048392340540886, -0.006118725519627333, 0.04030970111489296, 0.022118007764220238, -0.01650845631957054, -0.022628378123044968, 0.02226324751973152, 0.020832030102610588, 0.051559001207351685, -0.016423707827925682, 0.030695410445332527, -0.009159893728792667, 0.053815629333257675, -0.01812109723687172, 0.0004480708157643676, 0.008564912714064121, 0.020311826840043068, -0.0013140266528353095, 0.013053088448941708, 0.04316321387887001, -0.04155224934220314, -0.0788368508219719, -0.025868527591228485, 0.05631490424275398, -0.039001863449811935, -0.06907982379198074, -0.0297511238604784, -0.023678604513406754, -0.002613543765619397, -0.01017765887081623, 0.004764210432767868, 0.027027776464819908, 0.01684652641415596, -0.016974402591586113, 0.07487867772579193, -0.0017552701756358147, 0.06343520432710648, 0.05840311199426651, -0.0850335955619812, 0.02502628043293953, -0.03822978213429451, 0.05421953275799751, 0.028484445065259933, 0.01494534220546484, -0.023668747395277023, -0.047282833606004715, 0.04527587071061134, -0.01289347093552351, 0.01231655478477478, -0.03495674207806587, -0.0476839654147625, 0.0022629573941230774, -0.030926061794161797, -0.00325055536814034, -0.05948884040117264, -0.00834624283015728, -0.005528261419385672, 0.03247891739010811, -0.09986454993486404, 0.027561768889427185, -0.015936866402626038, -0.07266329973936081, 0.012145131826400757, 0.023142758756875992, 0.0791105404496193, 0.0016737693222239614, -0.013542292639613152, -0.0010236016241833568, -0.023450618609786034, -0.003580252407118678, 0.02652718313038349, -0.02846441976726055, 0.027816981077194214, 0.0329684242606163, 0.0504857636988163, 0.00034933292772620916, -0.006303250789642334, -0.004623766988515854, -0.027370814234018326, -0.00705188512802124, 0.025633253157138824, -0.0018705569673329592, -0.029398730024695396, -0.06263434141874313, 0.00840560533106327, 0.05112580582499504, -0.05343414470553398, -0.03613612428307533, 0.0019840195309370756, -0.019873138517141342, 0.04247065261006355, -0.0016286976169794798, -0.005771097261458635, 0.03193940594792366, 0.02527325041592121, -0.027784045785665512, -0.0000587880531384144, 0.05039650946855545, 0.056503940373659134, -0.050655584782361984, 0.060057248920202255, -0.003924548160284758, -0.020034775137901306, -0.021550459787249565, -0.028893573209643364, -0.011589357629418373, -0.033891625702381134, 0.00764368986710906, -0.022236892953515053, 0.04103231057524681, 0.01003533136099577, 0.04207400232553482, 0.02416999079287052, -0.03308041766285896, 0.019345980137586594, -0.033381540328264236, -0.02093416638672352, 0.019815150648355484, -0.012233021669089794, -0.059449080377817154, -0.0030700485222041607, 0.005834947340190411, 0.030233275145292282, 0.02836340293288231, 0.010878642089664936, 0.03549172356724739, 0.03055790811777115, 0.0022792501840740442, 0.01305018924176693, -0.05986111983656883, 0.010912945494055748, 0.01901027001440525, 0.044605981558561325, -0.008508235216140747, -0.04202757030725479, -0.03046579472720623, -0.05081729590892792, -0.08635738492012024, -0.0376964807510376, 0.024892019107937813, 0.03698892891407013, -0.06221902742981911, -0.012821502983570099, 0.005063565447926521, -0.09187699109315872, 0.016732828691601753, -0.005776133853942156, 0.03269324079155922, -0.04001306742429733, 0.08403338491916656, -0.009135718457400799, -0.05552201718091965, -0.023915812373161316, -0.05379386991262436, -0.006746781058609486, -0.048915665596723557, -0.03224915638566017, -0.006139642558991909, -0.07943818718194962, -0.019452981650829315, 0.04128962382674217, -0.013293984346091747, -0.05632426589727402, -0.033947620540857315, 0.011925376020371914, -0.03238886222243309, -0.0475367046892643, -0.0055612241849303246, -0.017133628949522972, -0.020110081881284714, -0.010780379176139832, 0.07333829998970032, -0.010647543705999851, 0.02344083972275257, -0.04518252611160278, 0.004136187024414539, -0.01946350559592247, 0.014395087957382202, -0.0365220382809639, 0.02028646320104599, -0.06473024934530258, -0.031246265396475792, 0.030921217054128647, 0.04209942743182182, -0.03994990512728691, 0.00759202940389514, 0.014472143724560738, 0.043301887810230255, -0.022097738459706306, -0.017996475100517273, -0.019377771764993668, -0.007672038860619068, 0.022744236513972282, 0.058562349528074265, 0.005994218867272139, 0.0036996903363615274, -0.04122104495763779, -0.010320348665118217, -0.003371097845956683, 0.03679473325610161, 0.0008114907541312277, -0.023773085325956345, 0.003848046762868762 ]
<p>So, i'm going over the Thorne's derivation of the quadrupolar radiation term, and they write the core term as:</p> <p>$$ \frac{3 r_i r_j - 2 r^2 \delta_{ij}}{4 r^5} $$</p> <p>But if i try to obtain this term by <em>Covariant</em> deriving the dipole term;</p> <p>$$ \nabla_{ij}{ \frac{1}{r}} = - \nabla_{j}{ \frac{r_i}{2 r^3}} $$</p> <p>i am left with:</p> <p>$$ \frac{3 r_i r_j - 2 r^2 \delta_{ij}}{4 r^5} - \frac{\Gamma^i_{kj}r_k}{2r^3} $$</p> <p>Where the last term seems to be dismissed in the text with no good reason. Is there a reason why this term is being ignored?</p>
g5835
[ 0.017871558666229248, -0.007094383239746094, 0.007581921759992838, -0.05505818501114845, 0.0035957328509539366, 0.039908744394779205, 0.035359837114810944, -0.016830388456583023, -0.010665614157915115, 0.01342952810227871, -0.03086775541305542, 0.01734672673046589, 0.00590180279687047, -0.03236208111047745, 0.009429443627595901, -0.02314199134707451, 0.0021013575606048107, 0.01283023040741682, 0.041240520775318146, -0.02540390007197857, -0.09366979449987411, -0.03811611980199814, 0.007665014825761318, -0.06231863051652908, 0.033634770661592484, -0.00018171053670812398, -0.006985526531934738, 0.030732518061995506, -0.055406246334314346, -0.00946386344730854, 0.032733045518398285, 0.053512148559093475, 0.07892900705337524, -0.01314333826303482, -0.023776870220899582, -0.010219939984381199, 0.05159306526184082, 0.06421907991170883, -0.020896920934319496, -0.02673075534403324, -0.003220997517928481, -0.07217159122228622, 0.01164054125547409, 0.05098334699869156, -0.02685292810201645, 0.02262987196445465, 0.013598626479506493, 0.03437101095914841, -0.003034084802493453, 0.01241083350032568, 0.03359608352184296, -0.010945169255137444, 0.04231288284063339, -0.04154673591256142, 0.0037366440519690514, -0.025548962876200676, 0.004448727238923311, -0.04113144055008888, -0.024886611849069595, 0.04443495720624924, -0.008660485967993736, 0.012499167583882809, 0.003339668968692422, 0.037505391985177994, 0.10673155635595322, -0.0648396760225296, -0.06646373122930527, -0.04649606719613075, 0.018834266811609268, 0.015009358525276184, 0.019162343814969063, -0.05530054122209549, 0.006635405123233795, 0.006769533269107342, -0.012375874444842339, -0.012197182513773441, -0.014900273643434048, 0.02599654532968998, 0.0152442567050457, -0.019211212173104286, -0.015803048387169838, -0.022417455911636353, 0.01575726456940174, 0.08724777400493622, 0.10757321119308472, 0.0413094237446785, -0.039982330054044724, 0.03569214791059494, 0.003923726733773947, -0.02054394595324993, 0.08538230508565903, 0.007371401879936457, -0.004838847555220127, -0.00609977450221777, 0.021535074338316917, -0.051704008132219315, -0.02068464457988739, 0.007562145125120878, 0.018658488988876343, -0.002257916610687971, -0.002732886467128992, 0.02705172635614872, 0.03612087294459343, 0.05499478429555893, -0.020800426602363586, 0.004346604924649, -0.006269453559070826, 0.009036250412464142, 0.02970316633582115, -0.008704926818609238, -0.067962147295475, 0.030217820778489113, -0.0063935634680092335, -0.029442979022860527, -0.05453692004084587, -0.04451408609747887, 0.015204004012048244, -0.0542687252163887, -0.03958609327673912, 0.04303797706961632, -0.01739245466887951, -0.01256084069609642, 0.03860374912619591, 0.09334123134613037, 0.02176465466618538, -0.02116648480296135, -0.010643105022609234, 0.04907287657260895, 0.097494937479496, -0.016798801720142365, -0.036187540739774704, -0.0005671766703017056, 0.006343886721879244, 0.05437666177749634, 0.030415138229727745, 0.004663691855967045, 0.017699871212244034, 0.057307109236717224, -0.004435086157172918, -0.006537348497658968, 0.020378846675157547, 0.0003710280579980463, 0.029763558879494667, -0.03281795606017113, -0.013871325179934502, -0.009450914338231087, 0.02511732280254364, -0.05477850139141083, 0.05108419805765152, -0.029943333938717842, 0.045105088502168655, 0.0754355788230896, 0.007581337355077267, -0.0050353859551250935, 0.010057502426207066, 0.02531321905553341, 0.02692791260778904, -0.0683588981628418, -0.010914471000432968, 0.022188715636730194, 0.024714412167668343, -0.013250219635665417, 0.01845625415444374, 0.025417080149054527, 0.0041708373464643955, 0.029397277161478996, 0.04487947002053261, -0.06066223606467247, -0.013942583464086056, 0.007999583147466183, 0.012706749141216278, 0.007667525205761194, 0.03999966382980347, -0.051758505403995514, -0.021815460175275803, 0.07383894175291061, 0.0075358315370976925, -0.028878076002001762, -0.07166782021522522, 0.042491357773542404, -0.05062656104564667, -0.018560538068413734, -0.0383685827255249, 0.021396968513727188, 0.012632129713892937, -0.04505476728081703, -0.034993600100278854, -0.010853748768568039, -0.022093119099736214, -0.04109736531972885, -0.04108937829732895, 0.016667308285832405, 0.03418959304690361, 0.03145440295338631, 0.008926735259592533, 0.014968493953347206, -0.008757654577493668, -0.040619395673274994, 0.030800634995102882, 0.06939125806093216, 0.006773090455681086, -0.014063054695725441, 0.058862101286649704, 0.015383043326437473, 0.028766633942723274, -0.055306777358055115, -0.05055372789502144, 0.04645859822630882, 0.020097212865948677, -0.0052835955284535885, 0.009641559794545174, -0.029031218960881233, -0.04337935149669647, 0.04459438845515251, -0.009089424274861813, -0.036704953759908676, -0.01455133967101574, 0.04513225704431534, -0.055132802575826645, 0.03762068226933479, -0.08825676888227463, -0.023715300485491753, 0.030384955927729607, 0.03547542169690132, 0.0025379618164151907, 0.007934242486953735, 0.0031710544135421515, 0.012728829868137836, 0.006886060815304518, -0.019777556881308556, -0.10069426894187927, -0.05184759944677353, -0.03610239550471306, -0.034474633634090424, 0.025233102962374687, -0.013322439044713974, -0.02574962191283703, -0.007051425985991955, 0.0013774210819974542, 0.020704086869955063, -0.04631441831588745, 0.027090122923254967, -0.018615880981087685, -0.024582594633102417, 0.0009133997955359519, 0.05510491505265236, 0.04481856897473335, 0.013003963977098465, -0.06643589586019516, -0.02512923814356327, -0.004147632978856564, 0.0077155777253210545, -0.02281324751675129, 0.05402258038520813, -0.028096485882997513, -0.007582380436360836, 0.009604048915207386, -0.023364964872598648, -0.05965176597237587, -0.026354122906923294, -0.03524508327245712, -0.07225314527750015, 0.05762922391295433, 0.01205518003553152, -0.052412182092666626, 0.01303765270859003, 0.02984011173248291, 0.022192882373929024, 0.02635059878230095, 0.013624448329210281, -0.09088516980409622, 0.04226350784301758, 0.018971536308526993, 0.04808174818754196, -0.04550878703594208, 0.004065302666276693, 0.02963045984506607, 0.023699456825852394, 0.04004232957959175, 0.03251019865274429, -0.003872473258525133, 0.003584940219298005, 0.02435055747628212, 0.03532784432172775, 0.0054609146900475025, -0.0671120434999466, -0.06442192196846008, 0.039847228676080704, 0.011109668761491776, -0.03748275712132454, -0.02775457873940468, -0.03210042044520378, -0.014129717834293842, -0.041005250066518784, 0.01583823375403881, -0.021932130679488182, 0.04317179322242737, -0.03625865653157234, -0.018447736278176308, 0.08398089557886124, 0.03875637426972389, 0.003682769602164626, -0.02840806543827057, -0.045841749757528305, -0.005226662382483482, -0.0021918662823736668, 0.010114740580320358, -0.03750893846154213, -0.008105667307972908, -0.012741515412926674, 0.03935195133090019, 0.011987568810582161, 0.017991581931710243, -0.00584863917902112, 0.010567563585937023, -0.03914787992835045, 0.032540008425712585, -0.009742699563503265, 0.07632355391979218, 0.048804182559251785, -0.05399956554174423, 0.040213871747255325, -0.04312700405716896, 0.03578784316778183, -0.021467285230755806, 0.0361027792096138, -0.03617626056075096, 0.01887458749115467, -0.037247173488140106, -0.0172492153942585, 0.016354136168956757, -0.02897113747894764, 0.012868101708590984, -0.022891070693731308, -0.030554478988051414, -0.05757448449730873, -0.06766557693481445, 0.022850271314382553, -0.0037224905099719763, -0.032314036041498184, -0.002417465904727578, -0.031548451632261276, -0.03797348961234093, 0.022855179384350777, -0.005558824632316828, 0.022657953202724457, -0.04569251462817192, 0.04196513444185257, 0.010570390149950981, 0.024063823744654655, -0.014487093314528465, 0.04434824734926224, 0.02402575872838497, 0.016588740050792694, -0.04155397787690163, -0.006304286886006594, 0.016850460320711136, 0.08921203762292862, 0.023440688848495483, -0.04811445623636246, 0.021530184894800186, 0.006388575304299593, 0.017723947763442993, -0.009204866364598274, 0.0038537473883479834, 0.06045464798808098, 0.02134609967470169, 0.05872625485062599, -0.030126191675662994, -0.029109301045536995, -0.0007094330503605306, -0.0364261269569397, -0.010982213541865349, -0.010894238948822021, -0.013295101933181286, -0.09540361911058426, -0.02024381421506405, 0.061151862144470215, -0.03029484674334526, 0.03788794204592705, -0.0010454838629812002, 0.0028014029376208782, 0.04006991162896156, 0.057249993085861206, -0.032771434634923935, 0.07035049796104431, -0.0743374302983284, -0.02146247960627079, -0.020467719063162804, -0.001214166171848774, -0.018472108989953995, -0.0077621545642614365, -0.02665737457573414, 0.007369350176304579, -0.014443418942391872, -0.03622198477387428, 0.030926577746868134, 0.023718642070889473, -0.029999811202287674, 0.048155393451452255, -0.0191706083714962, -0.03397069126367569, 0.08138331025838852, -0.0565447174012661, -0.021061543375253677, 0.008230576291680336, 0.03092072904109955, -0.006502288393676281, 0.01659265346825123, 0.022033628076314926, -0.04960267245769501, -0.020804965868592262, 0.0169245395809412, -0.036973364651203156, 0.041050881147384644, -0.039507992565631866, 0.02337111160159111, -0.019787682220339775, -0.03874614089727402, -0.024990037083625793, 0.03052980825304985, 0.006340406369417906, 0.03993768244981766, -0.021598702296614647, 0.0529564768075943, 0.027963586151599884, 0.045348890125751495, 0.0035317663569003344, -0.028932882472872734, 0.0007279982673935592, 0.012976131401956081, 0.014508799649775028, -0.03673631697893143, -0.01186918094754219, -0.0793343260884285, 0.0021508082281798124, -0.12174016982316971, 0.028990522027015686, 0.01245488878339529, 0.0871570035815239, 0.06621765345335007, -0.038075584918260574, 0.08618500828742981, -0.01201510988175869, 0.02162376418709755, 0.05392947793006897, 0.0320313423871994, -0.014886027202010155, 0.03679553046822548, 0.01867755688726902, 0.020668810233473778, -0.019345851615071297, -0.008980357088148594, -0.05758163705468178, 0.06943827122449875, -0.040343523025512695, -0.03569205477833748, -0.022027457132935524, 0.05973626300692558, 0.04730631038546562, -0.08689777553081512, 0.013945861719548702, -0.0019294566009193659, -0.007133600767701864, 0.042838145047426224, 0.0049790129996836185, -0.053699709475040436, 0.008810503408312798, -0.02573898248374462, -0.056518372148275375, -0.00959761068224907, -0.01863529533147812, -0.024616779759526253, -0.04348638653755188, -0.020660867914557457, 0.05058394744992256, 0.004376208409667015, 0.017463795840740204, -0.026962606236338615, -0.027986779808998108, -0.0007922927616164088, -0.029088547453284264, -0.01805584877729416, 0.07029477506875992, 0.0022949078120291233, 0.05498089641332626, 0.04639589041471481, -0.04713105410337448, 0.0006396109820343554, 0.04562355950474739, 0.04471874237060547, 0.02218274213373661, 0.030801359564065933, -0.031039603054523468, -0.006139833014458418, 0.045292798429727554, 0.03223290294408798, 0.0014890232123434544, 0.0018083601025864482, 0.0358567051589489, -0.06307826936244965, -0.021852171048521996, -0.035233624279499054, 0.002396864350885153, 0.01851545460522175, 0.08102934807538986, 0.1070512905716896, -0.01127093005925417, -0.013110607862472534, -0.005173120182007551, 0.042544543743133545, -0.06671202927827835, 0.022335533052682877, -0.020901203155517578, -0.008795104920864105, 0.004061903804540634, -0.061134278774261475, 0.055828895419836044, -0.01710568554699421, -0.038795195519924164, 0.019018447026610374, 0.03317590430378914, 0.019623151049017906, -0.07415680587291718, -0.009360033087432384, 0.013407870195806026, 0.0021743779070675373, -0.058328304439783096, 0.030851192772388458, 0.011308885179460049, 0.00016467714158352464, 0.0025739206466823816, 0.037571366876363754, 0.06047919765114784, 0.04435475915670395, -0.026202714070677757, 0.013661855831742287, 0.010214862413704395, 0.005178807768970728, -0.018030080944299698, -0.01972116343677044, 0.017151067033410072, -0.010570901446044445, 0.05279884859919548, -0.060249485075473785, 0.055673886090517044, 0.008024080656468868, -0.028410907834768295, 0.04221242293715477, 0.005437531974166632, -0.01582476869225502, -0.028367087244987488, -0.018513958901166916, -0.0030298440251499414, 0.037920884788036346, -0.04006609693169594, 0.0507197305560112, 0.028335584327578545, -0.03774922713637352, -0.005903737153857946, -0.058153025805950165, -0.03052632510662079, -0.037278495728969574, 0.055977895855903625, 0.029563289135694504, -0.08564037829637527, -0.05109161138534546, -0.02718125656247139, 0.008061755448579788, -0.00437121232971549, -0.006634951569139957, 0.039458971470594406, -0.03487354516983032, 0.04347660765051842, 0.048243697732686996, 0.03948386758565903, 0.011678019538521767, -0.020661145448684692, -0.007908373139798641, -0.015257288701832294, 0.027220116928219795, -0.019247079268097878, 0.03590031713247299, -0.060845594853162766, -0.040741465985774994, 0.010335476137697697, -0.04750940948724747, 0.029818199574947357, 0.021191159263253212, -0.03479975461959839, -0.006236131768673658, -0.0047248671762645245, -0.040262918919324875, -0.0032513365149497986, -0.006896568462252617, -0.03739436715841293, -0.0181893203407526, 0.06423993408679962, -0.05358682572841644, 0.021559782326221466, 0.04002153128385544, -0.02509261481463909, 0.0004991911118850112, -0.032407891005277634, 0.058389224112033844, -0.00920302513986826, -0.02204945683479309, 0.0008362766238860786, -0.01604975201189518, 0.017033977434039116, 0.01288677379488945, 0.006506781559437513, 0.018453842028975487, 0.0242785457521677, 0.0155955720692873, -0.0842786580324173, -0.057001326233148575, 0.0649731457233429, 0.006012255325913429, -0.018868111073970795, 0.02828063815832138, -0.01623600907623768, 0.010839532129466534, 0.02253870479762554, 0.060234617441892624, 0.04295671358704567, -0.02913215011358261, 0.0008852023747749627, 0.0072717685252428055, 0.053350046277046204, -0.017919136211276054, 0.04692304506897926, -0.03597428649663925, 0.005539686419069767, 0.009366177953779697, 0.03126153722405434, -0.07118994742631912, 0.011689086444675922, -0.01643133908510208, -0.013452241197228432, -0.05929742008447647, 0.021516025066375732, 0.043583985418081284, -0.05116385594010353, -0.04302230477333069, 0.010584257543087006, 0.03784911707043648, 0.016930585727095604, -0.02344880811870098, 0.015534686855971813, 0.01798039861023426, -0.030814653262495995, 0.03867952153086662, -0.028450647369027138, -0.006161546800285578, -0.058590926229953766, 0.009154822677373886, 0.052200425416231155, 0.0056320419535040855, -0.0066409180872142315, -0.05268346145749092, -0.034454088658094406, -0.05553574860095978, 0.007572529837489128, -0.0014182868180796504, 0.033399857580661774, 0.06436377018690109, -0.035393960773944855, 0.02987060882151127, -0.010978496633470058, -0.02012595348060131, 0.021846139803528786, -0.008498774841427803, -0.0023397670593112707, 0.019571196287870407, -0.007683963049203157, -0.023900259286165237, 0.03620006516575813, 0.012265687808394432, 0.001136269886046648, -0.08409896492958069, -0.016122760251164436, 0.02642553672194481, -0.04806780442595482, -0.011369284242391586, -0.0026858642231673002, -0.014016252011060715, -0.04263940453529358, -0.004661381710320711, 0.051428209990262985, -0.029453229159116745, 0.06118724122643471, 0.03591199591755867, 0.01668325439095497, 0.005142260808497667, 0.025804556906223297, 0.04076316952705383, 0.019172124564647675, 0.027915749698877335, 0.02565023861825466, -0.013900130987167358, -0.0045935772359371185, -0.009945831261575222, -0.008238408714532852, 0.017634067684412003, -0.016919780522584915, 0.022442514076828957, 0.005092637147754431, -0.03796032443642616, -0.011904164217412472, 0.006524214521050453, -0.0016173130134120584, 0.006905976217240095, 0.025343837216496468, 0.03774813562631607, 0.01392107643187046, -0.006473860703408718, 0.07430610060691833, -0.025338182225823402, -0.08741382509469986, 0.007585650309920311, -0.013581911101937294, -0.03210410848259926, -0.04154052212834358, -0.020475003868341446, -0.02347411960363388, 0.001961655216291547, -0.0255324374884367, -0.0067224157974123955, -0.00847893487662077, -0.048311926424503326, 0.030262578278779984, -0.07652842253446579, 0.031877756118774414, -0.037582267075777054, 0.012720190919935703, -0.01602989435195923, 0.008556890301406384, 0.04267501085996628, 0.01481539849191904, -0.024036958813667297, -0.04542890563607216, 0.03180772438645363, -0.0007209202158264816, -0.08710385113954544, 0.006492541171610355, -0.008826310746371746, 0.022460011765360832, 0.0201699361205101, -0.025191379711031914, -0.04804542288184166, 0.06450879573822021, -0.04226815700531006, 0.015255632810294628, 0.05913589522242546, -0.004527518525719643, 0.030523128807544708, -0.0015148329548537731, 0.02392568625509739, 0.0027861865237355232, -0.014442693442106247, -0.03172317519783974, -0.02200780250132084, -0.005641796160489321, 0.006827374920248985, -0.04537317529320717, -0.03200005739927292, 0.012241929769515991 ]
<p>Building a bronze stature we make a mold and pour in the liquid bronze when the bronze hardens we remove the mold. The mold is made of 3 Kg of steel and the statue has a mas of 1 Kg. The specific heat of bronze is 360 and the specific heat of steel is 165 If we cool the statue and the mold from 500 degrees C by dropping it into a bucket with 10 Kg of water at 20 degrees C what will the final temperature of the water be? (ignore any steam). Specific heat of water is 4186.</p> <p>So far I have:</p> <p>(165)(3 kg)(change in temp) + (360)(1 kg)(change in temp) = (4186)(10 kg)(change in temp)</p> <p>Am I on the right track? Any tips for further help?</p>
g5836
[ 0.08429165929555893, -0.0479140467941761, 0.009324568323791027, -0.05852150544524193, -0.0063693709671497345, 0.01245393417775631, 0.04634248837828636, 0.05915006250143051, -0.007842171005904675, 0.05620201677083969, -0.04739804193377495, 0.06850296258926392, 0.038183506578207016, -0.0447552464902401, 0.013597765937447548, 0.02206241525709629, 0.033845383673906326, -0.09374997764825821, 0.013111389242112637, 0.043781280517578125, -0.004600115120410919, -0.02287316881120205, -0.01783807761967182, -0.006575178354978561, -0.036825522780418396, -0.04300567880272865, 0.020302768796682358, 0.05347995087504387, -0.0071849399246275425, 0.026113322004675865, -0.01855727657675743, 0.06952255964279175, -0.0181637741625309, 0.025322072207927704, -0.022300561890006065, 0.0006449870415963233, 0.06938811391592026, 0.030300913378596306, -0.06372024863958359, -0.022608263418078423, 0.024315791204571724, 0.00516645098105073, 0.005325980484485626, 0.05319172888994217, 0.025640979409217834, 0.024312490597367287, -0.03409341350197792, -0.025449294596910477, -0.043171413242816925, 0.02824653685092926, 0.015792110934853554, 0.042295072227716446, -0.03237328305840492, -0.048832643777132034, -0.10425599664449692, 0.008254233747720718, -0.02013147436082363, -0.054122742265462875, -0.0010074328165501356, 0.01703362539410591, 0.044190604239702225, -0.009206264279782772, -0.054873932152986526, -0.014824975281953812, 0.006023324094712734, -0.00251431530341506, -0.008943375200033188, 0.009504628367722034, -0.033566348254680634, 0.02567010186612606, -0.024111397564411163, 0.015791844576597214, 0.03718670830130577, -0.021896425634622574, -0.07198981940746307, -0.04303515702486038, 0.002977588912472129, -0.052631035447120667, 0.013828481547534466, -0.008853932842612267, -0.04143412038683891, 0.04203197732567787, 0.009661677293479443, 0.019494889304041862, -0.04484850913286209, 0.042109597474336624, -0.040252212435007095, 0.008002894930541515, -0.05695207417011261, 0.004730598535388708, -0.014986972324550152, -0.02457594685256481, 0.06654819846153259, 0.04381812363862991, 0.029329374432563782, -0.04640601575374603, 0.004063818603754044, 0.002820703899487853, -0.004843281116336584, 0.012088680639863014, 0.0129903769120574, 0.002951899077743292, -0.0022717418614774942, -0.0508066825568676, -0.07675594091415405, 0.013730937615036964, 0.01764153502881527, 0.011164096184074879, -0.03629429638385773, 0.03442984074354172, -0.01731417141854763, -0.0528634749352932, -0.08135689795017242, -0.003886546939611435, -0.02813444659113884, 0.007706844713538885, -0.003975916653871536, -0.010438218712806702, 0.017290595918893814, -0.04183289781212807, 0.05310315266251564, -0.03581000119447708, 0.03836829215288162, 0.07963687181472778, 0.018138447776436806, -0.008323115296661854, -0.0309902410954237, 0.03435191884636879, 0.04568035528063774, -0.03597148507833481, -0.0008680237224325538, 0.05873376503586769, 0.0403810515999794, -0.010020121932029724, 0.04791715741157532, 0.049230191856622696, -0.026393665000796318, 0.033760350197553635, -0.0036026674788445234, -0.005341553594917059, 0.047251589596271515, -0.004329467657953501, 0.009933068417012691, -0.035549942404031754, -0.06590478867292404, 0.024551384150981903, -0.012049318291246891, 0.025998206809163094, 0.051292385905981064, -0.012362568639218807, 0.031163601204752922, 0.007220511324703693, 0.028148069977760315, 0.0017388801788911223, 0.019759515300393105, -0.016242852434515953, -0.00442905118688941, -0.016708698123693466, 0.07768303155899048, -0.019495047628879547, -0.026515701785683632, 0.0011421511881053448, 0.04396720230579376, 0.010338702239096165, -0.037850458174943924, 0.008615694008767605, -0.047197818756103516, 0.014208980835974216, 0.010046242736279964, -0.07910178601741791, -0.05642128363251686, -0.019391875714063644, -0.10168854892253876, 0.06257156282663345, -0.03762999549508095, -0.06712284684181213, 0.038959961384534836, 0.030516861006617546, -0.0009087875369004905, -0.008974329568445683, -0.014050972647964954, -0.01822080835700035, 0.04665345698595047, -0.01831594482064247, -0.03348696976900101, 0.04189402982592583, 0.06725955009460449, -0.03213026374578476, -0.03391837701201439, -0.01798188127577305, -0.018849940970540047, -0.012423422187566757, 0.02493799291551113, 0.020593486726284027, 0.023345952853560448, 0.0026523247361183167, -0.0346006341278553, -0.012653437443077564, -0.009147228673100471, -0.016950547695159912, 0.06375902891159058, 0.025969594717025757, 0.00984019972383976, 0.02814556285738945, -0.015713345259428024, -0.009357866831123829, -0.042879607528448105, 0.023485545068979263, -0.0019106398103758693, -0.003458854276686907, -0.0012928275391459465, 0.02596471458673477, 0.04294164851307869, 0.03336619958281517, -0.00900659803301096, 0.07723990082740784, 0.008974608033895493, -0.00008998843259178102, -0.028958823531866074, 0.00480571249499917, 0.011233287863433361, 0.008888852782547474, -0.032136086374521255, 0.028746388852596283, -0.047357227653265, -0.012733385898172855, -0.00920924637466669, 0.00786923710256815, 0.06278591603040695, 0.0036892632488161325, -0.009708967059850693, -0.003934124018996954, 0.04596342146396637, -0.03096516989171505, 0.03366118296980858, 0.002394124399870634, -0.001829903107136488, 0.021112902089953423, 0.01985846273601055, 0.04540714994072914, 0.018818965181708336, -0.006467875093221664, -0.03057030774652958, -0.007526874076575041, 0.019970113411545753, 0.02553175762295723, 0.0439501628279686, 0.004031556658446789, 0.04668477922677994, 0.01828412339091301, -0.007948094978928566, 0.009903819300234318, -0.030960971489548683, 0.04846331104636192, -0.020798537880182266, -0.0017341451020911336, -0.10495435446500778, 0.05473295599222183, 0.009327271953225136, 0.00017082503472920507, -0.010102895088493824, -0.058987561613321304, -0.010721576400101185, -0.029781030490994453, -0.054741133004426956, 0.02325359359383583, -0.05047054961323738, -0.027165012434124947, 0.02897217497229576, 0.04193126782774925, 0.03967219591140747, 0.006754644680768251, 0.025736093521118164, 0.07926305383443832, -0.06783304363489151, 0.009329834021627903, 0.0015989374369382858, -0.025178546085953712, 0.035902973264455795, -0.027473630383610725, 0.02145080827176571, 0.0027915751561522484, -0.05937511846423149, -0.01780054345726967, 0.04973909631371498, -0.05912002921104431, -0.021681103855371475, 0.06026202067732811, 0.017182931303977966, -0.01800115779042244, -0.0061239455826580524, 0.05551353842020035, -0.0065199644304811954, 0.035718727856874466, 0.0421990230679512, 0.03617001324892044, 0.01029534824192524, -0.013808307237923145, 0.005559704732149839, 0.0006333148339763284, 0.030838556587696075, -0.0367729589343071, -0.020998729392886162, 0.021248992532491684, 0.02959398739039898, 0.04427487775683403, -0.0036296923644840717, 0.02679150365293026, 0.04650368168950081, -0.055694565176963806, -0.037429384887218475, -0.0034834996331483126, 0.047173041850328445, -0.06184503808617592, -0.06831598281860352, -0.014176967553794384, -0.03666363283991814, -0.03698018938302994, 0.019554834812879562, -0.012200133875012398, -0.013632392510771751, -0.0012066925410181284, 0.011461595073342323, -0.008483687415719032, 0.00452876603230834, -0.012155801057815552, 0.029229547828435898, -0.00846162997186184, -0.040898047387599945, -0.02833949774503708, 0.004872072953730822, -0.001581215881742537, -0.0947294607758522, -0.049530141055583954, -0.012798001989722252, 0.01915729232132435, 0.00823178794234991, -0.0140869515016675, 0.0036509670317173004, 0.008188956417143345, 0.0041069332510232925, -0.009971264749765396, -0.0028611733578145504, 0.021101485937833786, 0.011439829133450985, -0.0010490561835467815, 0.002750724321231246, 0.007913103327155113, -0.042624469846487045, -0.04228200390934944, 0.03515205532312393, -0.006780760828405619, -0.028195790946483612, -0.03549131006002426, -0.017172442749142647, 0.0461885929107666, 0.051833491772413254, 0.039194028824567795, -0.055909786373376846, 0.014248272404074669, 0.024308741092681885, -0.04340498894453049, 0.03991032764315605, -0.02108224853873253, -0.05455756187438965, -0.0020131641067564487, -0.05815305560827255, 0.00239327154122293, 0.013967728242278099, 0.03785206750035286, 0.012256577610969543, -0.07519718259572983, -0.04146238788962364, -0.021661894395947456, 0.08518047630786896, 0.034526485949754715, -0.008990690112113953, 0.040074776858091354, -0.02821843884885311, 0.029761673882603645, -0.002423299476504326, 0.021933430805802345, -0.024857768788933754, -0.026882922276854515, -0.026570478454232216, -0.002792227314785123, -0.00007913680747151375, 0.01701902411878109, 0.006675052456557751, -0.1081172451376915, 0.008401797153055668, -0.010855480097234249, 0.024888716638088226, 0.013460188172757626, 0.06534306704998016, 0.023050405085086823, 0.0618462897837162, -0.034694869071245193, -0.008850960060954094, -0.03776243329048157, -0.021553894504904747, 0.02124321646988392, 0.07564771175384521, 0.04303889349102974, -0.038886476308107376, -0.0422244518995285, 0.05552225559949875, -0.042540356516838074, -0.004644532222300768, -0.0021805104333907366, -0.015057409182190895, 0.018457163125276566, 0.017232779413461685, -0.02458261325955391, 0.022491658106446266, -0.050413578748703, -0.01831546053290367, -0.01216930616647005, -0.04796523600816727, 0.013729387894272804, -0.033855315297842026, 0.00023889364092610776, -0.0038662843871861696, -0.02380233444273472, 0.05281680449843407, 0.010302716866135597, -0.004019164480268955, -0.059035781770944595, 0.012708435766398907, -0.04592655599117279, -0.01675070822238922, -0.0013648594031110406, -0.036211684346199036, 0.02549426257610321, 0.040089163929224014, 0.0324835479259491, 0.0029756687581539154, 0.014967855997383595, -0.008710289373993874, 0.01293257437646389, -0.09513840079307556, 0.08953270316123962, -0.053495634347200394, 0.029261939227581024, -0.012740053236484528, 0.014616454020142555, -0.031386423856019974, -0.048020899295806885, 0.007006478030234575, -0.013654635287821293, 0.02493485063314438, 0.036730945110321045, -0.036410681903362274, -0.007355171721428633, -0.02522408403456211, 0.0680103451013565, 0.030523812398314476, 0.04413994029164314, -0.05543315410614014, 0.05364891514182091, 0.018158143386244774, 0.00014357450709212571, -0.0437469482421875, -0.016646618023514748, 0.0005814823671244085, -0.07844346016645432, 0.06155943125486374, 0.013347839005291462, 0.0012087359791621566, 0.030253535136580467, 0.01408474426716566, 0.026738084852695465, 0.012743954546749592, 0.028325917199254036, 0.02982284501194954, -0.006692919414490461, 0.04031328856945038, -0.041794195771217346, 0.15743273496627808, -0.0043962085619568825, -0.033362023532390594, 0.022324945777654648, -0.023535992950201035, 0.029243960976600647, 0.01983947493135929, -0.004541168455034494, -0.03704298660159111, 0.0004512698797043413, 0.07471834123134613, 0.005312531255185604, 0.03877323493361473, 0.005952812265604734, 0.029635285958647728, 0.003700381377711892, -0.04057532176375389, 0.000859232502989471, -0.02312483824789524, 0.019312335178256035, 0.07182963192462921, 0.009523311629891396, 0.019156550988554955, 0.03198860585689545, -0.056545861065387726, -0.03258034214377403, -0.02307342179119587, 0.020282279700040817, 0.04737309738993645, -0.012838638387620449, 0.033265162259340286, 0.03311247378587723, 0.06103803962469101, 0.013959134928882122, 0.08426688611507416, -0.044332608580589294, -0.013630938716232777, 0.03775981068611145, 0.060964010655879974, -0.004975678864866495, 0.016752449795603752, 0.0018881032010540366, 0.03661441430449486, -0.01852273941040039, -0.031018277630209923, -0.04168767109513283, -0.04162948951125145, -0.01206770446151495, 0.021073222160339355, -0.026262985542416573, 0.024553310126066208, 0.02120724879205227, -0.03791797533631325, -0.01232108473777771, -0.012393567711114883, 0.013727984391152859, -0.008142842911183834, 0.013552478514611721, 0.0029176336247473955, 0.010445168241858482, 0.03469863161444664, -0.015274371951818466, -0.0040153623558580875, 0.03907153382897377, 0.014595224522054195, 0.05631493031978607, 0.022387513890862465, 0.005442971363663673, 0.003221081802621484, -0.0695597231388092, 0.03402969613671303, 0.014783311635255814, 0.023232044652104378, 0.03575056046247482, -0.011153425090014935, 0.007206041365861893, 0.04496336728334427, 0.0023106092121452093, -0.025576310232281685, -0.06427760422229767, -0.00009127670637099072, 0.0017934940988197923, 0.005324494559317827, -0.02121647633612156, 0.014398966915905476, 0.010589457117021084, -0.023143133148550987, -0.0777617022395134, -0.08181652426719666, 0.047396205365657806, 0.04141995683312416, 0.015337415970861912, -0.02180079184472561, -0.03755541145801544, -0.006052291486412287, -0.07817606627941132, -0.008565293624997139, 0.01263655535876751, -0.06372182816267014, -0.02226526103913784, 0.022897187620401382, 0.0005105148302391171, 0.0010459385812282562, 0.039133213460445404, 0.029390715062618256, 0.021225109696388245, 0.004860587418079376, 0.012495182454586029, -0.07254698872566223, 0.015801437199115753, -0.07634873688220978, 0.021816829219460487, 0.01555747352540493, 0.03809032961726189, -0.03942999616265297, 0.041958287358284, 0.044543515890836716, -0.04771265387535095, -0.03032083809375763, 0.015818320214748383, -0.0006846411852166057, 0.015264925546944141, -0.015160314738750458, -0.03747381269931793, 0.05322684347629547, -0.028111601248383522, -0.005823012441396713, 0.0036424826830625534, 0.00868277344852686, 0.01917560026049614, 0.02862429991364479, -0.04028873145580292, 0.026103481650352478, -0.021182913333177567, 0.02612374536693096, -0.001396266045048833, 0.03043312020599842, -0.03219453990459442, 0.039988141506910324, 0.05363207310438156, -0.016774458810687065, -0.0004910025163553655, -0.009631415829062462, -0.01711421273648739, 0.011505931615829468, -0.03859587386250496, 0.028636164963245392, 0.01482424233108759, -0.03622716665267944, 0.06366194039583206, -0.012109552510082722, -0.00020233410759828985, -0.006924487184733152, 0.00932641327381134, -0.0005552265211008489, -0.03802045062184334, -0.009771497920155525, 0.06446802616119385, 0.025566965341567993, 0.05791934207081795, 0.06591089814901352, 0.08125528693199158, -0.014071407727897167, -0.015382146462798119, 0.005507817491889, 0.046009793877601624, -0.0554063580930233, 0.020586881786584854, 0.009013775736093521, 0.0037297389935702085, -0.06328174471855164, -0.006105485372245312, -0.03156832978129387, -0.0364198163151741, -0.027236714959144592, 0.02534535527229309, 0.03564387187361717, 0.010535708628594875, 0.009620722383260727, -0.04189923778176308, 0.015047387219965458, 0.039321403950452805, 0.007793216034770012, -0.07399661839008331, 0.03768698126077652, -0.005794703960418701, 0.02597331628203392, 0.031190892681479454, -0.04182956740260124, -0.03076484054327011, 0.02899005636572838, -0.037871554493904114, 0.008899647742509842, 0.014924624003469944, -0.017719263210892677, 0.025950729846954346, 0.04434719681739807, 0.023051869124174118, 0.0011897694785147905, 0.05658677592873573, -0.015681710094213486, 0.021886605769395828, -0.02712327241897583, -0.018088290467858315, -0.042752817273139954, -0.032717157155275345, 0.004302129615098238, -0.039445653557777405, -0.029892640188336372, -0.01840352453291416, 0.09285802394151688, 0.02793179079890251, -0.021996986120939255, 0.03237028047442436, -0.021752044558525085, 0.01653904654085636, -0.02791789546608925, 0.052143294364213943, 0.02546018920838833, 0.036227528005838394, 0.10584642738103867, 0.028917135670781136, 0.020314780995249748, -0.006652601063251495, 0.002999305259436369, 0.05609540268778801, -0.009914057329297066, 0.07130444794893265, -0.04704827442765236, 0.0019763815216720104, -0.029132742434740067, 0.005583828315138817, 0.0007363572367466986, 0.025588423013687134, 0.0035629188641905785, -0.0690343827009201, 0.04282853379845619, 0.03257475420832634, -0.11129921674728394, 0.006097724661231041, -0.010363906621932983, -0.059262461960315704, -0.10363298654556274, -0.004182100296020508, -0.05480280891060829, -0.019607173278927803, -0.02535618469119072, -0.05374939739704132, -0.022387800738215446, 0.002584681147709489, -0.03387415409088135, 0.056275203824043274, -0.0184611976146698, -0.00878864899277687, -0.025865960866212845, 0.00010929278505500406, 0.0071259113028645515, 0.008567921817302704, 0.006917825900018215, -0.027124129235744476, 0.009723459370434284, 0.030446507036685944, 0.002577217062935233, 0.009028943255543709, -0.01872646063566208, -0.03983786702156067, -0.04054395481944084, -0.02176153101027012, -0.04036980867385864, 0.04302322864532471, -0.029420243576169014, -0.07347071915864944, -0.02439797669649124, 0.03374079242348671, -0.05387596786022186, -0.05495722219347954, -0.05402158573269844, -0.08454782515764236, -0.0402086041867733, 0.02299449034035206, 0.007260380312800407, 0.000430942076491192, -0.04685002565383911, -0.061016686260700226, -0.012261549942195415, 0.01409592293202877, 0.017688678577542305, 0.012264036573469639, 0.018076147884130478, -0.02805044688284397 ]
<p>If the Higgs field permeates all space, why some claim, that total universe energy equals (or is very close to) zero?</p>
g5837
[ 0.09055385738611221, 0.032610099762678146, 0.005066532641649246, 0.004342881962656975, -0.04171415790915489, 0.009485709480941296, -0.007446986623108387, 0.07363856583833694, 0.005938209127634764, -0.07031873613595963, 0.002378050936385989, -0.042256537824869156, -0.019548583775758743, 0.059563133865594864, -0.010581708513200283, 0.0022542548831552267, 0.015318609774112701, -0.030369045212864876, 0.01275444496423006, -0.005667646881192923, -0.03498848155140877, -0.05456475168466568, -0.030774908140301704, -0.005324147641658783, -0.03191174939274788, -0.011380437761545181, 0.050990764051675797, -0.05926312878727913, -0.0046754395589232445, -0.02063675969839096, 0.09970183670520782, -0.007491947617381811, 0.013288171030580997, -0.0588398277759552, -0.0014476069482043386, -0.0029734629206359386, 0.019721264019608498, 0.016819076612591743, 0.038024961948394775, -0.03417050093412399, 0.005245737265795469, 0.005603809840977192, -0.0027853776700794697, -0.022900888696312904, -0.025675643235445023, 0.02418920025229454, -0.014249719679355621, 0.042072031646966934, 0.03236604854464531, -0.045382626354694366, -0.019480405375361443, -0.04057031497359276, 0.04743145778775215, 0.042191192507743835, 0.047436244785785675, 0.00865983683615923, -0.0077396417036652565, -0.02554113231599331, 0.04661204665899277, -0.010106508620083332, -0.002156980335712433, 0.022876866161823273, -0.016182349994778633, 0.02447628043591976, 0.020856624469161034, 0.03711356967687607, -0.08546740561723709, -0.02184067852795124, 0.05746883526444435, 0.0009907785570248961, 0.021086789667606354, -0.028531469404697418, -0.025616301223635674, 0.004818520043045282, -0.02442087046802044, 0.0355098694562912, -0.0020631111692637205, -0.021342605352401733, 0.002053274307399988, -0.021600821986794472, -0.049706652760505676, -0.030911091715097427, 0.0005567347398027778, 0.01758631132543087, 0.009650989435613155, -0.06871721148490906, 0.04262792691588402, -0.02184254862368107, 0.01685066521167755, 0.06456585973501205, -0.023678205907344818, 0.03512604534626007, 0.13653120398521423, -0.030730145052075386, 0.027810923755168915, 0.014885365031659603, 0.005437155719846487, 0.04174399748444557, -0.004152837675064802, -0.020576437935233116, -0.03989394009113312, 0.00322176911868155, 0.0284454133361578, -0.039905473589897156, 0.005727405659854412, -0.01847187615931034, 0.05620969086885452, -0.0032789441756904125, 0.08086001127958298, 0.012071069329977036, 0.0018475658725947142, 0.03349176421761513, -0.016811007633805275, -0.08168269693851471, 0.015291507355868816, 0.00411955127492547, 0.13595300912857056, -0.07030527293682098, -0.032994721084833145, 0.029111620038747787, -0.024390043690800667, -0.0037374659441411495, -0.004041168373078108, 0.031002817675471306, -0.053812239319086075, 0.01582951657474041, -0.01649368368089199, -0.0007495743338949978, -0.04522524029016495, -0.001986843766644597, -0.044229988008737564, -0.023566866293549538, -0.0345512218773365, 0.020702965557575226, 0.01650538295507431, -0.017969267442822456, -0.005163173191249371, -0.059655025601387024, -0.001893073320388794, 0.05059284344315529, -0.032058872282505035, -0.053860291838645935, -0.01454311702400446, 0.002725732745602727, 0.04398391395807266, -0.008144441992044449, -0.0031003705225884914, 0.041633520275354385, 0.004809526726603508, -0.004003092646598816, 0.00466163968667388, 0.05902371555566788, 0.012824849225580692, -0.007114953361451626, -0.015857549384236336, -0.0147827984765172, 0.04688647761940956, -0.034575365483760834, -0.007075378205627203, -0.028913240879774094, -0.030256809666752815, 0.0062668584287166595, 0.07162207365036011, -0.04669768735766411, -0.014228222891688347, 0.057096824049949646, 0.03455226868391037, -0.05339646711945534, -0.03869447484612465, -0.008565925061702728, -0.04094402492046356, 0.033043552190065384, -0.00910393800586462, 0.022524811327457428, 0.020519841462373734, 0.024008337408304214, 0.012954612262547016, 0.004218572750687599, -0.02256839908659458, 0.008041885681450367, 0.003818781580775976, -0.02817358449101448, 0.06872325390577316, 0.01958646811544895, -0.012428202666342258, -0.0334089994430542, -0.005710447672754526, -0.0574432872235775, 0.005151636432856321, 0.03476246818900108, 0.02964623272418976, -0.009879130870103836, 0.0347561277449131, -0.014122833497822285, 0.027874046936631203, 0.08274394273757935, 0.06719619780778885, -0.028150789439678192, -0.08781678974628448, -0.07156065106391907, 0.030259188264608383, 0.03726741299033165, -0.015350845642387867, -0.013540039770305157, 0.04507603868842125, 0.007877491414546967, 0.012408717535436153, 0.038961224257946014, 0.04629170149564743, -0.00618802709504962, -0.007099568843841553, -0.0513741560280323, 0.009566279128193855, 0.06178413704037666, -0.030681287869811058, -0.009551945142447948, -0.024132417514920235, 0.01450140681117773, -0.023556802421808243, 0.03070695698261261, -0.035573069006204605, 0.025049470365047455, 0.0445670522749424, -0.011936083436012268, 0.005017087794840336, -0.0007271001813933253, -0.03666207939386368, 0.007179774809628725, -0.053677577525377274, 0.03947354108095169, -0.018624981865286827, -0.04684775695204735, 0.01980980485677719, -0.024121135473251343, 0.04070412740111351, -0.006127456668764353, 0.01682751439511776, 0.02750229649245739, -0.02104346454143524, 0.06469108164310455, 0.05632222071290016, -0.019174469634890556, -0.056582000106573105, 0.008763475343585014, 0.09229999035596848, 0.0006269264267757535, 0.04979526624083519, -0.04101604223251343, -0.04080301150679588, -0.016882766038179398, 0.018145671114325523, 0.017177797853946686, -0.0011415855260565877, 0.008084727451205254, 0.012498986907303333, -0.037894874811172485, -0.005162458401173353, 0.022329766303300858, -0.027798570692539215, -0.053753383457660675, 0.08131464570760727, -0.04113750904798508, 0.023167835548520088, 0.017379578202962875, -0.016173211857676506, 0.026799680665135384, -0.06232123449444771, 0.014457201585173607, -0.021635662764310837, -0.045562319457530975, -0.016321144998073578, 0.02971738390624523, 0.02303161472082138, 0.020821884274482727, 0.01149043720215559, -0.012076055631041527, -0.005649881903082132, 0.005075643304735422, 0.07963095605373383, -0.08598831295967102, -0.054079022258520126, 0.03566712886095047, -0.00513685354962945, 0.04477338865399361, -0.0031655454076826572, -0.0810784250497818, -0.04020021855831146, -0.11874660849571228, 0.02406151406466961, -0.013395782560110092, 0.06788405030965805, 0.006682794075459242, 0.0053288876079022884, 0.06631060689687729, -0.004757470916956663, 0.0549706369638443, 0.008424453437328339, -0.005443194881081581, -0.013403143733739853, 0.001176917809061706, -0.029560228809714317, 0.040175605565309525, -0.0083871865645051, -0.028177499771118164, -0.021387020125985146, -0.036289237439632416, 0.03065156377851963, -0.02962774969637394, -0.03323443606495857, -0.018649959936738014, -0.032467328011989594, 0.004482695832848549, 0.00567293306812644, 0.0006056720740161836, 0.03383823484182358, 0.07463625818490982, 0.01985688880085945, 0.0042232307605445385, -0.024387521669268608, -0.003919596318155527, 0.03167979046702385, 0.030255425721406937, 0.04641146957874298, 0.03333726152777672, 0.0012948188232257962, 0.01792019233107567, -0.028772635385394096, 0.0016154191689565778, -0.06728765368461609, 0.018846647813916206, -0.00389749463647604, -0.0431785024702549, 0.011373673565685749, 0.037444598972797394, 0.027460480108857155, 0.0370430052280426, -0.01943490281701088, 0.03903815150260925, 0.050965264439582825, 0.07281529158353806, -0.10193416476249695, 0.023418746888637543, -0.05115879327058792, 0.06187161058187485, 0.019884616136550903, 0.08124198019504547, -0.020653143525123596, -0.028350962325930595, 0.03327688202261925, -0.02607354149222374, 0.03990871459245682, 0.03526608645915985, -0.01107769925147295, 0.011493068188428879, -0.04484056308865547, -0.0014014013577252626, -0.0594107061624527, -0.005386949982494116, 0.08833156526088715, -0.030510833486914635, 0.06243341043591499, 0.02878103032708168, 0.0092574842274189, -0.021784547716379166, -0.007385308388620615, 0.0019095191964879632, -0.0417754165828228, -0.03731721267104149, -0.02987940050661564, 0.006840930320322514, 0.03352969139814377, -0.0556914322078228, -0.034213148057460785, 0.0016386985080316663, 0.025589969009160995, -0.0834755077958107, 0.02165181376039982, -0.06012585759162903, -0.02127552591264248, 0.007369453087449074, 0.039688631892204285, 0.032356828451156616, -0.010017412714660168, 0.041468728333711624, -0.021949077025055885, 0.009555643424391747, -0.04120101034641266, -0.015342644415795803, -0.008836183696985245, 0.011534136720001698, -0.00875881314277649, 0.008917638100683689, -0.01280105859041214, 0.02639060467481613, -0.03715395927429199, -0.039494212716817856, -0.020839866250753403, -0.019561683759093285, 0.009138068184256554, 0.004994451068341732, 0.005661806091666222, -0.017894458025693893, 0.04718371853232384, -0.00991107989102602, 0.04272986948490143, -0.003474065801128745, 0.02348058484494686, -0.002683450235053897, -0.014921735040843487, -0.0318601168692112, 0.05676046386361122, 0.01560859102755785, -0.03486822172999382, -0.055520229041576385, 0.07270332425832748, -0.02949637547135353, 0.024391520768404007, -0.07202253490686417, 0.02955617941915989, -0.030529120936989784, 0.035324838012456894, -0.016123229637742043, -0.013673624023795128, -0.00418046023696661, 0.006260294932872057, 0.07688102126121521, -0.00040631252340972424, 0.06369790434837341, -0.05468442663550377, 0.013257471844553947, 0.019744601100683212, 0.021450655534863472, 0.014583776704967022, 0.06719395518302917, -0.034708794206380844, 0.007551796734333038, -0.015803121030330658, 0.07443676143884659, -0.02385282889008522, 0.04355796054005623, 0.06656772643327713, -0.047954462468624115, 0.010875632986426353, 0.01724395528435707, -0.01779453083872795, 0.05658390745520592, -0.03409380093216896, -0.05990291386842728, -0.016051040962338448, -0.003234208794310689, -0.027859892696142197, 0.0058628860861063, -0.053119733929634094, 0.023549282923340797, 0.023395845666527748, -0.05570351332426071, -0.017165040597319603, 0.06281064450740814, 0.01892888732254505, -0.014214613474905491, -0.08023948967456818, 0.009515480138361454, 0.006928042974323034, 0.06175655499100685, 0.04853232577443123, -0.02352561056613922, -0.01806105300784111, -0.04326594993472099, -0.040782734751701355, 0.003504662774503231, 0.039306458085775375, -0.005988124758005142, 0.014698215760290623, 0.024802852421998978, -0.02936721406877041, 0.010319606401026249, -0.03473827615380287, -0.031881507486104965, -0.0739007517695427, -0.01619194634258747, -0.012539294548332691, 0.0354674868285656, 0.010425448417663574, 0.035659145563840866, -0.028209717944264412, 0.08301892876625061, -0.07537990063428879, 0.012422741390764713, 0.0328330397605896, -0.012266428209841251, -0.009105161763727665, 0.02882624790072441, 0.04327528551220894, -0.020687194541096687, 0.03377049043774605, 0.047158773988485336, 0.01384175755083561, -0.04027510806918144, -0.034665387123823166, 0.036817971616983414, -0.009974371641874313, 0.03105287440121174, 0.005703868810087442, -0.047523412853479385, -0.03785770386457443, 0.034704048186540604, 0.020598500967025757, 0.02912331558763981, 0.025327272713184357, -0.044051557779312134, -0.00872560404241085, -0.03230033069849014, 0.02392672933638096, 0.03562431409955025, 0.04504704847931862, -0.08014894276857376, -0.025056030601263046, -0.01627754233777523, -0.00931350514292717, 0.0047150058671832085, -0.034773681312799454, -0.03435429558157921, 0.0037539952900260687, 0.03469902649521828, 0.08195165544748306, 0.021396666765213013, 0.02768009901046753, -0.05526406690478325, -0.0024764793924987316, 0.025992050766944885, 0.04211687669157982, 0.048269301652908325, 0.019157225266098976, 0.006205596029758453, 0.012678997591137886, 0.02929682843387127, -0.047649141401052475, -0.0035858154296875, 0.04406648874282837, 0.00741986371576786, -0.007853121496737003, -0.015610892325639725, 0.00931943953037262, -0.007404986768960953, -0.0049560172483325005, -0.017296114936470985, -0.06966102123260498, -0.0077486662194132805, 0.01714431308209896, -0.0710824504494667, -0.003129781922325492, 0.00843268632888794, 0.03903626278042793, 0.03118772991001606, 0.0051148803904652596, 0.0038984089624136686, 0.033257368952035904, 0.013816692866384983, -0.0050433301366865635, -0.026129504665732384, -0.009867644868791103, 0.015274717472493649, -0.04398563876748085, 0.003653221996501088, 0.0104496069252491, -0.0023468155413866043, 0.005456520244479179, -0.06715736538171768, 0.013383670710027218, -0.046069540083408356, 0.011355286464095116, 0.0050570047460496426, 0.03583640232682228, -0.03270171955227852, -0.05196782201528549, 0.011228854767978191, -0.010840581730008125, -0.007598075550049543, -0.04347609728574753, -0.008961133658885956, 0.021790437400341034, -0.08751785010099411, 0.00636646244674921, -0.06912625581026077, 0.01674717850983143, 0.01480255275964737, 0.015506991185247898, -0.04335702583193779, 0.07330963015556335, 0.04446178302168846, 0.005563464015722275, 0.007972261868417263, 0.0207791980355978, 0.011237803846597672, 0.011017028242349625, -0.01372410450130701, 0.025148238986730576, -0.05233974754810333, -0.06915062665939331, -0.00043454088154248893, -0.011160653084516525, -0.018809814006090164, 0.025936326012015343, -0.03551469370722771, 0.06844809651374817, 0.00922385510057211, -0.04861593618988991, 0.047083113342523575, -0.009130428545176983, 0.058862119913101196, -0.016682716086506844, 0.0003808473120443523, -0.0026072615291923285, -0.048804230988025665, -0.03355743736028671, -0.022274896502494812, 0.041707828640937805, -0.0036253088619560003, -0.012841642834246159, 0.003038574242964387, -0.011614895425736904, 0.008404678665101528, 0.009705454111099243, -0.016779817640781403, 0.021488038823008537, 0.015913715586066246, -0.027699735015630722, 0.05089246854186058, 0.022110173478722572, -0.025224460288882256, -0.0017772928113117814, 0.07679016888141632, 0.01885344088077545, -0.018950706347823143, -0.04233376681804657, 0.023855464532971382, -0.009075422771275043, -0.048887304961681366, -0.03313008323311806, -0.026329107582569122, -0.010430483147501945, 0.04293590411543846, 0.023770812898874283, -0.0018751590978354216, -0.007308165077120066, -0.010358622297644615, -0.01987086422741413, -0.009518970735371113, 0.011270550079643726, -0.011572394520044327, 0.020562369376420975, 0.027319377288222313, -0.002808953635394573, -0.05930393189191818, -0.04821793735027313, 0.012149450369179249, -0.07146025449037552, -0.034580573439598083, 0.013478572480380535, -0.04462897405028343, 0.044845663011074066, 0.0050020841881632805, -0.0077978172339499, 0.03251487389206886, -0.012275821529328823, 0.014013550244271755, -0.009062159806489944, -0.02605808712542057, 0.01559501327574253, -0.03851941227912903, 0.024645937606692314, -0.043479934334754944, -0.10444725304841995, 0.016131972894072533, -0.03841539844870567, -0.030187612399458885, -0.006147283595055342, 0.04513498395681381, 0.02054380439221859, -0.013760442845523357, 0.010184593498706818, 0.031667619943618774, -0.04174609109759331, 0.036519210785627365, -0.014497729949653149, 0.010449311695992947, 0.029509898275136948, -0.03132982924580574, -0.03082357905805111, 0.03904563561081886, 0.04410594701766968, 0.0008319491753354669, 0.0509440079331398, -0.04336804524064064, 0.03138221055269241, 0.048762138932943344, 0.02166895940899849, 0.0386497788131237, 0.008156564086675644, -0.09658762067556381, -0.0210416279733181, 0.026146195828914642, 0.019535133615136147, -0.035502463579177856, 0.04709314927458763, 0.031140800565481186, 0.05031578242778778, 0.010779425501823425, -0.047218747437000275, 0.0033539896830916405, 0.049820344895124435, 0.038997676223516464, 0.016220133751630783, -0.0022205295972526073, 0.03014312870800495, 0.020883765071630478, -0.05312756821513176, -0.04368668422102928, -0.02781016007065773, -0.07469919323921204, 0.008885554037988186, -0.021875176578760147, -0.019323104992508888, -0.02225923165678978, -0.03636857494711876, 0.028157023712992668, -0.039699118584394455, -0.033761732280254364, 0.01704576425254345, -0.026870856061577797, 0.00612647645175457, -0.009180523455142975, -0.026272360235452652, -0.001840242650359869, -0.08766171336174011, 0.0019174902699887753, -0.005443356465548277, -0.0005870643071830273, 0.041423022747039795, 0.02640066109597683, -0.005366580095142126, -0.0501137338578701, -0.003249344415962696, -0.007491720840334892, 0.02811061590909958, -0.06194821745157242, -0.00847840029746294, -0.011811762116849422, 0.035093992948532104, 0.0015515722334384918, 0.00667216582223773, -0.03794868290424347, -0.019906552508473396, 0.10218602418899536, 0.002795238047838211, -0.05731576308608055, 0.036278899759054184, -0.027791917324066162, -0.03620849549770355, 0.027972321957349777, 0.023855147883296013, -0.03845663368701935, 0.05026085302233696, -0.002329491777345538, 0.02017628587782383, -0.03132054954767227, 0.02086368016898632, 0.013235513120889664 ]
<p>I have read that holes in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semiconductor" rel="nofollow">semiconductor</a> are nothing but vacancies created by electrons. But how can this vacancy i.e. hole has a mass?</p>
g5838
[ 0.037217892706394196, 0.03232308104634285, -0.024168990552425385, -0.04436545446515083, 0.04432069510221481, 0.08477170765399933, 0.018641619011759758, 0.02063065767288208, 0.03736497089266777, -0.030952252447605133, -0.0005016949726268649, 0.003703249152749777, 0.03532617166638374, -0.01854679547250271, -0.05456928908824921, 0.0051682135090231895, 0.04270949214696884, -0.00826413743197918, 0.02625204063951969, 0.010063105262815952, 0.03234183043241501, -0.030586523935198784, -0.026245228946208954, -0.0007608941523358226, -0.029928725212812424, 0.022217338904738426, 0.03446473926305771, -0.027189433574676514, 0.054219458252191544, -0.04341552034020424, 0.03359638527035713, 0.012185296975076199, 0.049254078418016434, -0.012937224470078945, 0.03259892761707306, -0.04673146456480026, 0.012767273001372814, 0.008032122626900673, 0.02044309303164482, 0.017881019040942192, -0.011423730291426182, -0.0729861781001091, 0.03443576395511627, -0.025483814999461174, -0.03852898254990578, 0.0021765839774161577, -0.01629154570400715, -0.00014663769979961216, 0.016401443630456924, -0.042035579681396484, 0.006363945081830025, 0.046924591064453125, 0.013675893656909466, -0.00956284161657095, 0.0013541601365432143, 0.0007012997521087527, 0.005836221389472485, 0.05875314772129059, 0.1016320064663887, 0.056692756712436676, -0.013892864808440208, 0.0009234635508619249, -0.019287655130028725, 0.053030747920274734, 0.02920025959610939, -0.017493095248937607, -0.005744664464145899, 0.017780419439077377, -0.036317676305770874, -0.013064911589026451, 0.015039699152112007, 0.010465385392308235, -0.04900265112519264, -0.054515499621629715, -0.028102939948439598, 0.004914211109280586, -0.023286892101168633, 0.06544020026922226, -0.0159662663936615, -0.000753844971768558, -0.023222383111715317, -0.01839791052043438, 0.05985003709793091, -0.010376594960689545, 0.03994079306721687, -0.03481663763523102, -0.027017967775464058, -0.016320746392011642, 0.014113234356045723, -0.015961317345499992, 0.027749909088015556, 0.03554254397749901, 0.0034865529742091894, 0.007553264498710632, -0.018675047904253006, -0.011304724030196667, -0.027147216722369194, 0.038710568100214005, -0.05519915744662285, -0.0394701287150383, 0.013666246086359024, -0.05142940953373909, 0.02502068504691124, -0.02946246601641178, 0.029634488746523857, 0.027433695271611214, -0.0642356351017952, 0.006295925937592983, 0.041860830038785934, 0.0929742306470871, 0.016198309138417244, 0.03328629210591316, -0.04121481627225876, -0.03942042961716652, -0.019888916984200478, 0.02069953829050064, 0.050297971814870834, 0.006589599419385195, 0.006975397001951933, 0.04340774193406105, 0.003075892338529229, 0.057226698845624924, -0.05035347118973732, 0.028626617044210434, 0.021807178854942322, 0.037730198353528976, 0.046021491289138794, -0.003746254136785865, -0.014980669133365154, -0.009615927934646606, -0.01001767162233591, -0.02247125469148159, 0.010490494780242443, 0.0016610465245321393, 0.04304281622171402, -0.023132095113396645, 0.041947636753320694, -0.010555815882980824, 0.01080859825015068, 0.020454758778214455, -0.01294519379734993, -0.009829810820519924, -0.01764410361647606, -0.01803295686841011, -0.003282088553532958, -0.022706039249897003, -0.0380394421517849, 0.04132124409079552, 0.00974211748689413, 0.02390550635755062, 0.0005820496007800102, 0.07066143304109573, -0.008079718798398972, -0.08460767567157745, 0.050812359899282455, -0.018852565437555313, 0.06335290521383286, -0.019708722829818726, 0.008146703243255615, -0.028967276215553284, 0.028060946613550186, -0.03057629056274891, 0.050364285707473755, 0.054607804864645004, -0.04918549582362175, -0.06524364650249481, -0.0005413443432189524, -0.049556028097867966, -0.025128843262791634, -0.07601836323738098, -0.006407236680388451, -0.008548620156943798, 0.014068352989852428, 0.05428833141922951, -0.0033594926353543997, 0.03589640185236931, -0.01137661375105381, -0.028518572449684143, 0.0934765487909317, -0.013617939315736294, 0.014619693160057068, -0.0026713607367128134, 0.03087451122701168, -0.019771281629800797, 0.04757871478796005, 0.022258197888731956, 0.0020809525158256292, -0.010210097767412663, -0.007260054349899292, 0.026816364377737045, -0.009275246411561966, -0.06286429613828659, 0.020002061501145363, 0.07624547183513641, 0.022190414369106293, 0.030135123059153557, 0.021071219816803932, -0.04277908802032471, -0.021224558353424072, -0.027025004848837852, -0.02261166088283062, -0.02435055561363697, 0.004498857539147139, -0.02068958804011345, 0.05134231597185135, 0.019609689712524414, -0.0338851660490036, -0.047198500484228134, -0.03269593045115471, 0.012349608354270458, 0.011824160814285278, 0.02855921909213066, 0.03518174961209297, 0.021343836560845375, -0.01717432402074337, -0.026964161545038223, -0.008406039327383041, -0.039341773837804794, 0.0032286460045725107, -0.050728630274534225, -0.05025690793991089, -0.03525840491056442, 0.005477610509842634, -0.0051432722248137, -0.0008481367840431631, 0.052133627235889435, 0.010200539603829384, -0.010629073716700077, -0.014449456706643105, 0.015934763476252556, -0.05414500832557678, -0.00730866240337491, -0.014757733792066574, -0.007405937649309635, 0.04613285884261131, 0.06906584650278091, -0.030765468254685402, 0.029956910759210587, -0.05153171345591545, 0.011953580193221569, 0.010950877331197262, 0.0011606591288000345, -0.06649517267942429, 0.01829509064555168, -0.023615762591362, -0.11530815064907074, 0.021919820457696915, 0.0025325685273855925, 0.00949618685990572, 0.01011157687753439, 0.026821434497833252, -0.06933025270700455, -0.003996322862803936, -0.0029139136895537376, 0.019979964941740036, -0.04156751185655594, 0.015150593593716621, 0.02120690420269966, 0.060775477439165115, 0.004615756217390299, -0.02905052714049816, 0.011597267352044582, 0.002642180072143674, -0.034092362970113754, -0.050612013787031174, -0.07433423399925232, -0.03539825230836868, -0.06226973980665207, -0.016564998775720596, -0.050397180020809174, -0.020010747015476227, 0.0498352013528347, 0.024060703814029694, -0.010896963998675346, 0.041522517800331116, -0.03201865032315254, 0.02350681833922863, 0.0750962644815445, 0.04998834803700447, -0.02512960135936737, -0.007473593112081289, 0.03799473121762276, -0.050995178520679474, -0.005131544545292854, 0.02127324417233467, 0.01304942648857832, -0.010557573288679123, -0.010191669687628746, -0.02204097807407379, 0.002823866670951247, -0.011810272000730038, -0.06262677907943726, 0.06541930884122849, 0.008750786073505878, 0.017534902319312096, -0.00039196875877678394, -0.008208167739212513, -0.006278440821915865, -0.04534086212515831, 0.04656064882874489, -0.019334107637405396, 0.022800808772444725, -0.0037043450865894556, -0.021475519984960556, 0.013529576361179352, 0.06670632213354111, 0.012217278592288494, -0.008591558784246445, -0.03016590140759945, -0.027428485453128815, 0.027838492766022682, 0.029006170108914375, -0.018966466188430786, 0.008131814189255238, -0.026819422841072083, 0.02522212825715542, -0.06529523432254791, 0.014887885190546513, 0.03568711504340172, -0.0643429234623909, -0.059626732021570206, -0.0029763688798993826, -0.0017291614785790443, -0.029944516718387604, 0.028877802193164825, 0.046252910047769547, -0.002643610117956996, -0.04232746735215187, -0.04573484882712364, -0.017448702827095985, 0.010441089048981667, -0.07123859971761703, -0.13907939195632935, -0.06147534027695656, 0.025063293054699898, -0.06678575277328491, 0.032981906086206436, 0.049539241939783096, 0.038066666573286057, 0.0019682717975229025, -0.028110653162002563, -0.008929777890443802, -0.050348348915576935, 0.0149315120652318, 0.012885788455605507, 0.0075795310549438, 0.0016831171233206987, -0.025137262418866158, 0.05499643087387085, -0.059598151594400406, 0.023524723947048187, -0.035275496542453766, 0.015188358724117279, 0.06662018597126007, -0.009633888490498066, 0.029574129730463028, -0.018021680414676666, -0.03110162355005741, 0.032282549887895584, 0.006575680337846279, 0.026825306937098503, -0.06657110899686813, 0.06244875118136406, 0.020675983279943466, -0.021872498095035553, 0.022103890776634216, 0.005518910009413958, 0.033628109842538834, 0.0903494730591774, -0.04267861321568489, -0.04332469031214714, -0.046742502599954605, 0.0037169228307902813, 0.00508322287350893, 0.047315847128629684, -0.025671090930700302, 0.02417060360312462, 0.07060443609952927, -0.05180664360523224, -0.006272849626839161, -0.0006882069283165038, -0.07930312305688858, -0.02130381017923355, -0.044048912823200226, -0.014981756918132305, -0.06957809627056122, 0.0036009361501783133, 0.0020037575159221888, -0.03557077795267105, -0.0514853298664093, 0.012656194157898426, 0.009036668576300144, -0.009338058531284332, 0.013898352161049843, 0.024385716766119003, -0.04490971192717552, 0.022739237174391747, -0.047639597207307816, 0.05285216122865677, -0.05467778071761131, 0.04518276825547218, 0.08160844445228577, 0.02233310602605343, 0.021119631826877594, 0.06642627716064453, 0.02863261103630066, 0.055843863636255264, 0.02090047486126423, 0.02153102122247219, -0.030918391421437263, -0.03053603321313858, 0.07014938443899155, 0.005147282034158707, 0.04962347075343132, 0.020968738943338394, -0.0011415221961215138, -0.030402183532714844, 0.032356105744838715, 0.0013817695435136557, 0.025947824120521545, -0.01824221760034561, 0.04446202889084816, 0.015363402664661407, 0.004576894920319319, 0.035501208156347275, 0.09959158301353455, -0.025829240679740906, -0.0663711205124855, 0.07623928785324097, -0.009213514626026154, -0.04141173139214516, 0.010158048011362553, 0.03516190126538277, -0.003046188037842512, -0.05067865923047066, 0.05017561465501785, -0.03410492464900017, -0.010590381920337677, 0.016973448917269707, 0.0566159263253212, 0.05196031928062439, -0.013951027765870094, 0.015484348870813847, -0.01589580997824669, 0.025218162685632706, 0.003892692970111966, -0.00036291489959694445, 0.006678787991404533, -0.0408066064119339, -0.019388766959309578, -0.012688313610851765, -0.032871101051568985, -0.021518079563975334, -0.05163061246275902, 0.015752272680401802, -0.006342054344713688, -0.07571978121995926, 0.008631084114313126, -0.016863761469721794, 0.04028477519750595, -0.08601756393909454, -0.010105674155056477, 0.024672573432326317, 0.03273135423660278, 0.02790912240743637, -0.05857827141880989, 0.059479668736457825, 0.005530990660190582, 0.02518177218735218, -0.01969296485185623, 0.010102987289428711, -0.0017773642903193831, -0.00047961698146536946, 0.0606500543653965, 0.05000492185354233, -0.03748515993356705, 0.020117660984396935, -0.051941633224487305, -0.02860025130212307, -0.0413634367287159, -0.0025507663376629353, -0.01177113689482212, 0.06665721535682678, 0.043257564306259155, 0.0031203327234834433, -0.014183986000716686, -0.04957966133952141, 0.05277308076620102, -0.010740108788013458, 0.022726062685251236, 0.013572882860898972, 0.02558961696922779, -0.03290145844221115, -0.020688721910119057, -0.002274214755743742, -0.015119015239179134, 0.008216104470193386, 0.07737037539482117, -0.058711081743240356, -0.008921741507947445, -0.007006388157606125, -0.03991565853357315, 0.03453889489173889, -0.023019786924123764, 0.029154980555176735, 0.04872743785381317, -0.03273668885231018, -0.024964995682239532, 0.03205941990017891, -0.061107855290174484, -0.017041819170117378, 0.04670271277427673, -0.012033628299832344, -0.0009422814473509789, 0.058234117925167084, -0.02773982472717762, 0.0006825488526374102, -0.035905640572309494, -0.019469214603304863, 0.01505339052528143, -0.034205418080091476, -0.02666587010025978, 0.05405264347791672, -0.005011180881410837, -0.014600754715502262, -0.031153196468949318, -0.04394354298710823, -0.07768217474222183, -0.022790823131799698, 0.034238673746585846, 0.010841337032616138, -0.06585226207971573, 0.0011086162412539124, -0.050477027893066406, -0.011418375186622143, -0.015938734635710716, 0.0277699027210474, -0.014466694556176662, -0.01591494493186474, 0.007846876047551632, 0.0012729935115203261, -0.045949678868055344, 0.002410249086096883, 0.07875920087099075, 0.04404684901237488, -0.043850451707839966, -0.0018874967936426401, 0.014224867336452007, 0.022776592522859573, -0.028236839920282364, -0.043034691363573074, 0.044644154608249664, 0.0031933868303894997, -0.00775454705581069, 0.0032299936283379793, 0.006192073225975037, -0.018285062164068222, 0.005255166441202164, -0.04767109081149101, -0.07450494915246964, 0.008331193588674068, 0.05922044813632965, -0.0024570536334067583, -0.01733078435063362, 0.04676035791635513, 0.039605699479579926, -0.0068511334247887135, 0.007494058925658464, 0.07708059996366501, -0.053187046200037, -0.028906378895044327, -0.03861215338110924, -0.031563762575387955, -0.0025089133996516466, -0.026204805821180344, 0.012695214711129665, 0.0003301855467725545, 0.05202525109052658, -0.028587771579623222, -0.025872375816106796, 0.04551418870687485, 0.008642852306365967, 0.062082916498184204, 0.04475448280572891, 0.03813791647553444, 0.042481858283281326, -0.03081604279577732, 0.002239491790533066, 0.06317979842424393, 0.04291533678770065, -0.041199296712875366, 0.03810682147741318, -0.004731269087642431, -0.004214202519506216, -0.05051972344517708, 0.0008982228464446962, -0.05601914972066879, 0.01886594109237194, 0.016645703464746475, -0.013542142696678638, 0.03471953421831131, 0.014775781892240047, 0.00546751543879509, 0.05352482199668884, 0.00970591139048338, 0.0016451992560178041, -0.009860909543931484, 0.0067671905271708965, -0.06358032673597336, -0.03989801183342934, -0.0470859669148922, 0.009785394184291363, -0.0008157148840837181, -0.056197524070739746, -0.00686611607670784, -0.011396646499633789, -0.02855297364294529, 0.07045990973711014, -0.009048291482031345, -0.014038088731467724, -0.024335943162441254, -0.022699560970067978, -0.016258899122476578, -0.0006351417396217585, 0.013720650225877762, 0.032776057720184326, -0.023397108539938927, 0.05287905037403107, 0.10039441287517548, -0.04373180493712425, -0.02992449514567852, -0.02001277171075344, -0.028620535507798195, -0.02790251187980175, 0.015257726423442364, 0.053851284086704254, 0.008864181116223335, -0.037047047168016434, 0.04601146653294563, -0.039037756621837616, -0.001410499680787325, -0.01786796562373638, 0.03417001664638519, 0.06022115424275398, 0.03223356977105141, 0.011016995646059513, -0.004970331210643053, 0.023272911086678505, -0.00518939970061183, -0.0670967698097229, -0.003060773713514209, 0.037907373160123825, -0.03074171021580696, 0.021196644753217697, 0.022244425490498543, 0.03805369883775711, -0.0500415600836277, -0.010716760531067848, 0.017227327451109886, -0.051350124180316925, -0.07579769939184189, 0.00666071055456996, 0.054259538650512695, -0.029443997889757156, 0.030898340046405792, 0.01408328302204609, 0.04316233471035957, -0.02791152149438858, 0.00004443409852683544, 0.03507106006145477, -0.032939180731773376, -0.013895544223487377, 0.033139418810606, 0.0007342362659983337, -0.07873432338237762, -0.019945180043578148, -0.010141145437955856, 0.09106935560703278, -0.0280672088265419, -0.06551610678434372, -0.00939231738448143, 0.05490772798657417, 0.023422816768288612, -0.0393105112016201, 0.0309761893004179, 0.007679821457713842, -0.020468156784772873, 0.04570340737700462, 0.06549136340618134, 0.0369589701294899, 0.07712016254663467, -0.0011596573749557137, 0.013419984839856625, -0.013707435689866543, -0.026692437008023262, -0.009953461587429047, -0.014797912910580635, -0.013388226740062237, -0.002171432366594672, -0.01308991014957428, -0.02530222199857235, 0.010768500156700611, 0.012528705410659313, -0.06417308747768402, 0.03018273413181305, -0.022210795432329178, 0.009359649382531643, 0.037577662616968155, -0.03330397978425026, 0.026076698675751686, 0.10419144481420517, -0.015647336840629578, -0.03607817366719246, -0.013474184088408947, 0.02659054473042488, -0.032867904752492905, -0.03605857491493225, 0.010834178887307644, -0.024218112230300903, -0.04267462342977524, -0.0009794593788683414, -0.0221035685390234, -0.008042504079639912, 0.06699801236391068, -0.02345193549990654, -0.002295420505106449, 0.05515206977725029, 0.07257271558046341, -0.025535786524415016, -0.003655586624518037, -0.032335806638002396, 0.02854468859732151, 0.02491510845720768, -0.04514313116669655, -0.0015801877016201615, -0.008940473198890686, 0.0482197105884552, -0.02733651176095009, -0.0036621748004108667, 0.015454413369297981, 0.014845204539597034, -0.06812728196382523, 0.014988504350185394, -0.0580444298684597, 0.005463550332933664, -0.025207597762346268, -0.04052085801959038, 0.010204066522419453, -0.022556602954864502, 0.0074812276288867, -0.04692155122756958, -0.030455468222498894, -0.015276930294930935, 0.03012046031653881, 0.02576175145804882, -0.04564490169286728, 0.005490443669259548, 0.021062567830085754, -0.0035773650743067265, 0.019390210509300232, 0.02343825250864029, 0.05452001094818115, -0.021165991201996803, -0.029620978981256485, 0.021081430837512016, -0.04651586711406708, 0.022739900276064873, -0.026624377816915512 ]
<p>The following question was posed at the end of Maury Goodman's June 2012 <a href="http://www.hep.anl.gov/ndk/longbnews/">long-baseline neutrino newsletter</a>.</p> <blockquote> <p>During the Venus transit of the sun, were more solar neutrinos absorbed in Venus, or focused toward us by gravity?</p> </blockquote> <p>As I don't know off the top of my head I thought I'd pass it along. Maybe latter I'll have time to look up the relevant figures for order of magnitude estimates.</p>
g5839
[ 0.04134141281247139, 0.05807524546980858, 0.022603219375014305, 0.03320934250950813, 0.011360829696059227, 0.056096259504556656, 0.044258326292037964, -0.001363398740068078, -0.02029464952647686, -0.049067649990320206, -0.014651203528046608, 0.06034805625677109, 0.08592228591442108, -0.002043472370132804, 0.009043554775416851, -0.031792476773262024, 0.11382482200860977, -5.880275466552121e-7, 0.017069971188902855, 0.022724227979779243, 0.01087170746177435, -0.01447067130357027, 0.0018600478069856763, -0.06123754009604454, -0.05364195257425308, 0.032310932874679565, 0.017230944707989693, 0.04380926489830017, -0.009272465482354164, -0.056516677141189575, 0.005041338969022036, 0.0007379906601272523, -0.005682861432433128, -0.026143457740545273, -0.06983888149261475, 0.005534464959055185, 0.012914421036839485, 0.004401342943310738, 0.017612017691135406, -0.034735627472400665, 0.02863394096493721, -0.023039182648062706, 0.001655374770052731, 0.05022900551557541, -0.015519240871071815, 0.03486218675971031, -0.06852361559867859, -0.03126295655965805, 0.017362724989652634, -0.007824401371181011, 0.02305232547223568, -0.017038902267813683, 0.012790622189640999, 0.04574616998434067, 0.10953638702630997, 0.055988859385252, 0.061280880123376846, -0.0698954164981842, 0.055913135409355164, 0.02477531135082245, 0.06426487118005753, -0.06274613738059998, -0.025575779378414154, -0.034788668155670166, 0.006899576168507338, -0.03228113427758217, -0.04095448926091194, 0.020607156679034233, 0.04590141400694847, -0.03085750713944435, 0.028657594695687294, -0.005773602519184351, -0.01888885162770748, -0.010786729864776134, 0.036690570414066315, -0.000846207607537508, -0.024576932191848755, -0.023388538509607315, -0.009089136496186256, -0.009401598945260048, -0.012356765568256378, -0.02817830629646778, -0.017757834866642952, 0.019080473110079765, 0.13721252977848053, -0.04793914034962654, 0.003350022714585066, 0.027950294315814972, -0.019582970067858696, -0.014195985160768032, 0.04800235852599144, -0.014078273437917233, 0.05213368684053421, -0.020347047597169876, -0.01640779711306095, -0.007597052957862616, 0.03638989478349686, -0.02762334793806076, 0.018028277903795242, -0.005941565614193678, -0.052103038877248764, 0.017146263271570206, -0.015610231086611748, 0.002837926149368286, 0.024548696354031563, -0.04587389528751373, 0.03506916016340256, -0.040899232029914856, -0.05725259706377983, -0.012220552191138268, -0.00491294963285327, -0.04690518602728844, 0.005423967260867357, 0.002352871000766754, -0.04184268042445183, 0.011509200558066368, 0.01865728758275509, -0.05827958509325981, -0.020533159375190735, 0.06411675363779068, 0.030636724084615707, 0.08026017248630524, -0.053724505007267, 0.07043204456567764, -0.045795612037181854, -0.043988484889268875, -0.02159375511109829, 0.002640683436766267, 0.0032655405811965466, 0.027517324313521385, -0.010033028200268745, 0.006667346227914095, 0.006864071357995272, 0.03686555474996567, 0.022314375266432762, 0.004192120395600796, 0.051505595445632935, 0.000907462032046169, 0.03854985535144806, 0.06819777935743332, 0.056869711726903915, -0.0825757086277008, 0.03941436856985092, -0.0065977186895906925, -0.0350065603852272, 0.03126104921102524, 0.017296036705374718, -0.012402504682540894, -0.0031567998230457306, 0.00946411769837141, -0.029496369883418083, 0.03647994250059128, -0.01595216803252697, -0.046535320580005646, 0.030064042657613754, -0.021352805197238922, 0.029777662828564644, -0.1023196429014206, -0.013168945908546448, 0.032582107931375504, 0.023465344682335854, -0.012067721225321293, 0.01644350402057171, -0.04285386577248573, -0.05245072394609451, -0.006944732274860144, 0.04161800444126129, -0.05846191197633743, 0.006120937876403332, -0.0009233247837983072, -0.042212143540382385, -0.01576353795826435, -0.03523007780313492, 0.039277397096157074, -0.03160608187317848, 0.03664634749293327, 0.07152450084686279, -0.019090428948402405, -0.006038866471499205, 0.03191234916448593, -0.012384445406496525, -0.0014960174448788166, -0.004477809648960829, -0.021214628592133522, 0.018555428832769394, -0.032531678676605225, -0.011032742448151112, 0.03535766527056694, -0.006757508963346481, 0.049583107233047485, -0.025446323677897453, 0.0389539897441864, 0.010665297508239746, 0.05109386146068573, -0.014406112022697926, -0.04197259992361069, -0.002487368416041136, -0.05361225828528404, -0.08573411405086517, 0.09861224889755249, -0.015907585620880127, 0.047110665589571, 0.004657302517443895, 0.032354287803173065, -0.025851693004369736, 0.015305929817259312, 0.0043649799190461636, -0.01137792132794857, 0.06194036453962326, -0.014521617442369461, 0.0031529711559414864, -0.017704514786601067, 0.027429236099123955, 0.015917114913463593, -0.051331136375665665, -0.006858641281723976, -0.01929650828242302, 0.043755751103162766, 0.04980888217687607, -0.005296224262565374, 0.004898510407656431, -0.0010344176553189754, 0.052168283611536026, -0.04270317405462265, -0.01633462868630886, 0.05587758123874664, 0.003806822933256626, -0.061774563044309616, 0.013224014081060886, 0.023461023345589638, -0.011305911466479301, 0.055176991969347, -0.029350263997912407, -0.004321317654103041, -0.05583612993359566, 0.020552294328808784, 0.020978620275855064, -0.02340933308005333, 0.0185744296759367, -0.0492728129029274, 0.02234780229628086, -0.05724910646677017, 0.02499033696949482, 0.03820839896798134, 0.032245784997940063, 0.002396378666162491, -0.0016547656850889325, 0.012054340913891792, -0.03425069898366928, 0.073032446205616, -0.010360488668084145, -0.029971277341246605, -0.01761193759739399, 0.026927607133984566, 0.06311802566051483, 0.01693017967045307, 0.0008112674113363028, 0.0022024239879101515, -0.08105286210775375, -0.05210302025079727, -0.009208540432155132, -0.025873126462101936, -0.0075037418864667416, 0.02865484729409218, 0.1002739891409874, 0.01657426729798317, -0.005437464453279972, -0.0039198617450892925, 0.057318929582834244, -0.025832049548625946, 0.04346383735537529, 0.04124633967876434, 0.07860894501209259, -0.002750336192548275, -0.0037417507264763117, 0.01714155450463295, 0.011310304515063763, -0.016410671174526215, -0.029534513130784035, -0.004833177197724581, -0.02724619023501873, -0.02200142666697502, 0.00578906387090683, -0.021193575114011765, 0.013468118384480476, -0.06224353238940239, -0.041072867810726166, -0.01387261413037777, 0.010353815741837025, 0.03478086739778519, 0.0642138123512268, -0.02111881412565708, 0.03435717523097992, 0.021830949932336807, 0.02206270955502987, 0.006934824399650097, 0.021226394921541214, 0.02527444064617157, -0.04803403466939926, 0.01343668345361948, 0.025929346680641174, -0.04152720049023628, -0.05239705368876457, 0.016518089920282364, -0.03135475143790245, -0.010049845091998577, -0.04655938595533371, -0.019727809354662895, 0.028671711683273315, -0.021093707531690598, -0.014919697307050228, 0.053404420614242554, -0.022611772641539574, 0.02866716869175434, -0.06412847340106964, -0.03781718760728836, -0.023806056007742882, 0.031422823667526245, 0.005337005481123924, -0.001728542149066925, 0.00806186068803072, -0.03911574184894562, 0.03778019919991493, 0.023085732012987137, 0.012171032838523388, 0.004836373031139374, -0.0079901572316885, 0.037985846400260925, 0.0031945521477609873, 0.00916136335581541, -0.01597621850669384, -0.022661088034510612, -0.01778111234307289, 0.0207388773560524, 0.006000080145895481, 0.05639221891760826, 0.011181557551026344, 0.05963661149144173, 0.05249108374118805, 0.005876036360859871, -0.04323330894112587, -0.0023031176533550024, -0.02661724016070366, -0.03165218606591225, 0.04037600755691528, -0.044027410447597504, 0.01278833020478487, -0.045857347548007965, -0.0025915871374309063, 0.036089081317186356, 0.02512064203619957, 0.014934638515114784, -0.010837324894964695, -0.024923810735344887, 0.03538864478468895, 0.008375074714422226, 0.014456486329436302, -0.0074245925061404705, -0.024127336218953133, 0.014951146207749844, -0.0032293114345520735, 0.02207089588046074, -0.043538898229599, 0.028299903497099876, 0.022032441571354866, -0.025950785726308823, -0.03512567654252052, 0.024262886494398117, 0.012490692548453808, 0.027767447754740715, -0.03297760337591171, -0.012527182698249817, -0.05449661985039711, 0.04688287898898125, 0.055042218416929245, -0.030092371627688408, 0.01922718435525894, 0.050738412886857986, 0.015002420172095299, 0.04592766612768173, 0.046492017805576324, 0.01523441169410944, -0.018442649394273758, -0.0003723742556758225, 0.02622225135564804, -0.038457613438367844, -0.03656117245554924, 0.001835011993534863, -0.044938139617443085, -0.07649573683738708, -0.0293240025639534, -0.05610981583595276, -0.04042176902294159, 0.020825985819101334, -0.015697209164500237, -0.041351139545440674, 0.03205282613635063, 0.04003313556313515, 0.00308556598611176, 0.004570920020341873, 0.0001983997062779963, -0.010650713928043842, 0.06890390813350677, -0.032881829887628555, -0.04802457615733147, 0.05740126594901085, 0.013108324259519577, -0.033354006707668304, -0.02962045557796955, -0.02317611686885357, 0.014078228734433651, -0.0026536169461905956, -0.09440578520298004, -0.028402887284755707, 0.02443232387304306, 0.028617754578590393, -0.017878463491797447, -0.00552485603839159, -0.025873852893710136, -0.009175265207886696, -0.03028624691069126, 0.023960785940289497, 0.0117488419637084, 0.0383460558950901, 0.021917039528489113, 0.1087498664855957, -0.0017799966735765338, -0.04957224056124687, -0.022963637486100197, -0.0036261549685150385, 0.02003331109881401, 0.000017615775504964404, -0.0390297956764698, 0.08083741366863251, -0.030393483117222786, 0.0258494783192873, 0.023943964391946793, 0.007349469233304262, 0.048437051475048065, 0.00797068327665329, 0.024249060079455376, -0.03764861077070236, 0.003909895662218332, -0.032801076769828796, -0.028809351846575737, 0.037027038633823395, 0.03543955460190773, 0.009794926270842552, 0.05148181691765785, 0.013784061186015606, -0.004057884681969881, -0.019540516659617424, -0.01225463766604662, 0.05328516662120819, 0.025721032172441483, 0.017626581713557243, 0.0006066692876629531, 0.01187099702656269, 0.007997107692062855, 0.03842097520828247, -0.026237813755869865, 0.013981848955154419, 0.06088348105549812, 0.02202293463051319, 0.07149309664964676, -0.04480736702680588, -0.003249531611800194, -0.003398388624191284, 0.008058695122599602, -0.011804712936282158, -0.04672827944159508, -0.010447867214679718, 0.04263245686888695, -0.03733748570084572, -0.004109525587409735, 0.025863008573651314, -0.011958036571741104, 0.010319017805159092, 0.010613270103931427, -0.020237592980265617, -0.0163778867572546, -0.021896876394748688, 0.01298716850578785, -0.025158045813441277, -0.05680307373404503, 0.08752521127462387, -0.04395216703414917, -0.03291550278663635, 0.03453280031681061, -0.04119153320789337, 0.024455556645989418, -0.021307382732629776, 0.018408698961138725, 0.01620086282491684, -0.04857953265309334, -0.028163980692625046, 0.013278166763484478, -0.0504223108291626, 0.031067293137311935, -0.006303179077804089, -0.06979306787252426, 0.026566585525870323, -0.04687468707561493, -0.035083554685115814, 0.017287477850914, -0.007705886848270893, -0.05267121642827988, 0.02612943947315216, -0.03266081213951111, 0.025833500549197197, 0.02987055666744709, 0.033949028700590134, -0.0001800809259293601, -0.006332982797175646, 0.002691369503736496, -0.01977728307247162, -0.011534935794770718, 0.022697117179632187, 0.004747954197227955, -0.014570802450180054, -0.01788466051220894, -0.022046755999326706, 0.006990485824644566, 0.03529025986790657, 0.05966489389538765, -0.062405120581388474, 0.017833400517702103, -0.043199170380830765, -0.029559874907135963, -0.08310715109109879, 0.016898203641176224, 0.03339693322777748, 0.04249654710292816, 0.032189562916755676, 0.008858165703713894, -0.048796724528074265, 0.02016497030854225, 0.012963675893843174, 0.039094675332307816, -0.023970745503902435, -0.05214949697256088, -0.0037750627379864454, 0.0037145577371120453, 0.08794260770082474, 0.019001083448529243, -0.00716469855979085, 0.020909156650304794, 0.021355265751481056, -0.036740634590387344, 0.01973884180188179, -0.07078228145837784, 0.04416247457265854, 0.02462839148938656, 0.008117159828543663, -0.0382331945002079, 0.030554218217730522, -0.008251616731286049, 0.02527567371726036, -0.01651342585682869, -0.05964075028896332, 0.00449204258620739, -0.0011030430905520916, 0.014605479314923286, 0.011874386109411716, -0.06376811861991882, 0.005282772239297628, -0.00987205933779478, -0.06472035497426987, 0.08124163001775742, -0.002600245177745819, 0.1120440810918808, -0.03843437880277634, -0.054543185979127884, -0.015605716966092587, 0.01688973233103752, 0.01300784945487976, -0.00225478271022439, -0.01716485247015953, -0.07094023376703262, -0.004747282713651657, -0.030916132032871246, -0.0366450771689415, -0.012485820800065994, 0.006466072518378496, 0.0022310041822493076, 0.10118099302053452, -0.002170508960261941, 0.05768046900629997, 0.0007510323193855584, -0.03153323754668236, 0.07033699005842209, -0.02889885939657688, 0.017923099920153618, 0.017999282106757164, -0.03230118751525879, -0.006012576166540384, -0.002844935515895486, -0.009137733839452267, -0.045507993549108505, 0.05478183925151825, -0.018846165388822556, 0.0301752258092165, 0.07914653420448303, -0.004578550811856985, 0.007152887061238289, -0.02504844032227993, 0.03938087448477745, 0.0046968720853328705, -0.0064653088338673115, -0.019219398498535156, 0.04688442125916481, 0.02767055667936802, 0.04037277027964592, -0.0013614434283226728, -0.014850142411887646, -0.06454598903656006, -0.05165001377463341, 0.0009120036265812814, 0.023300690576434135, 0.05381659418344498, 0.01848057471215725, -0.00674462178722024, 0.00042101790313608944, 0.004796187859028578, -0.02527344599366188, 0.05185505747795105, 0.01281777210533619, -0.049392636865377426, 0.034739721566438675, 0.011867172084748745, 0.03049798123538494, 0.0007075808243826032, -0.03629184514284134, 0.0433993861079216, 0.032948751002550125, -0.025387659668922424, 0.07612171024084091, -0.06802348047494888, 0.0014895552303642035, -0.015793098136782646, -0.045467909425497055, -0.029534202069044113, 0.0018843578873202205, 0.0000859128704178147, -0.024636730551719666, 0.062217094004154205, 0.004727492108941078, 0.06704777479171753, 0.024842843413352966, -0.004067303612828255, -0.010846101678907871, -0.006752628833055496, 0.029223445802927017, -0.07569064199924469, -0.04206924885511398, 0.03964657709002495, 0.025059303268790245, 0.03153044730424881, 0.0671306625008583, -0.07696903496980667, -0.016076458618044853, -0.04139786958694458, -0.02974230982363224, 0.02060014195740223, 0.03539585694670677, -0.014884029515087605, 0.0024640378542244434, 0.01282747182995081, -0.01674780808389187, -0.05330568924546242, -0.009022161364555359, -0.028440197929739952, -0.047794703394174576, -0.003751587588340044, -0.03065440244972706, -0.08099365234375, 0.007443105336278677, -0.08379378914833069, 0.016247540712356567, 0.02118692733347416, 0.022248469293117523, -0.025728536769747734, -0.04853956028819084, 0.03186008706688881, -0.014471900649368763, -0.06634826213121414, 0.005394876003265381, 0.003924388904124498, 0.011248819530010223, -0.005200431682169437, 0.00021526968339458108, 0.030791059136390686, 0.00009209832933265716, -0.012848883867263794, -0.0035452365409582853, -0.03942542523145676, -0.05084339901804924, 0.006415993440896273, -0.004004967398941517, 0.00392146548256278, -0.040466248989105225, 0.012640862725675106, -0.015310683287680149, -0.03478272259235382, 0.04531598463654518, -0.015586694702506065, 0.0070638894103467464, -0.01763322949409485, -0.046501174569129944, 0.0703158974647522, 0.020005857571959496, -0.000861732754856348, 0.0043071904219686985, 0.06515733897686005, 0.0364055261015892, 0.019341284409165382, -0.05149458348751068, 0.03314361721277237, 0.016626780852675438, 0.028743986040353775, -0.037328869104385376, -0.03857795521616936, 0.0030483452137559652, -0.03361072763800621, -0.04536142200231552, -0.04208351671695709, 0.013946712017059326, -0.02474522590637207, -0.00467020645737648, -0.07466720789670944, 0.037162695080041885, -0.0027462756261229515, -0.038432516157627106, -0.07239565253257751, 0.004411707632243633, -0.016887636855244637, -0.051590446382761, -0.014073463156819344, 0.004796814639121294, -0.02123131975531578, -0.02420070394873619, -0.02547004446387291, 0.010958550497889519, 0.014894451946020126, -0.013204677030444145, -0.008426934480667114, -0.02558983489871025, 0.06261245161294937, -0.02612525410950184, -0.055147379636764526, 0.05354674160480499, 0.0007860332843847573, 0.009016858413815498, 0.002253828104585409, -0.018554357811808586, -0.00859125331044197, -0.034955088049173355, -0.031328149139881134, -0.07052543759346008, -0.06309851258993149, -0.03662519156932831, -0.06158556044101715, 0.06980518251657486, -0.04173586890101433, 0.054428830742836, -0.028536902740597725, -0.00523398956283927, -0.026668576523661613 ]
<p>We might be killed if a bullet penetrates our brain. How about an elementary particle moving with high energy penetrates our brain? </p> <p>Assume that we can have exactly a single elementary particle for this imaginative experiment.</p>
g5840
[ 0.034119922667741776, 0.0667870044708252, 0.03031487762928009, 0.0026121879927814007, 0.055889446288347244, 0.014782500453293324, -0.03958925977349281, 0.023177603259682655, -0.02849525585770607, -0.05064589902758598, -0.015838302671909332, 0.01659294404089451, -0.03333272039890289, -0.018268851563334465, -0.061275701969861984, -0.01157217938452959, 0.03998081758618355, -0.041627850383520126, 0.02660161815583706, 0.04848141223192215, -0.018524160608649254, -0.008696380071341991, 0.013997512869536877, -0.034698501229286194, -0.015391840599477291, -0.03961746394634247, 0.03817484527826309, -0.007486972026526928, -0.060812219977378845, 0.04658499360084534, 0.037090376019477844, -0.024084120988845825, -0.02659756690263748, -0.0001825204089982435, -0.020685167983174324, -0.09599652141332626, 0.019917817786335945, 0.04716767743229866, -0.0059431688860058784, 0.0027884349692612886, -0.01517623569816351, -0.02570750191807747, -0.015620787627995014, -0.005504189524799585, 0.020745182409882545, 0.07470051944255829, 0.058874841779470444, -0.06651993840932846, 0.05796381086111069, -0.029461342841386795, -0.048030536621809006, -0.021011879667639732, 0.003392214886844158, 0.044056013226509094, 0.010033749043941498, 0.001685384544543922, 0.03853652998805046, -0.01147005520761013, 0.04720767214894295, 0.004705572035163641, 0.025139473378658295, 0.03461853787302971, 0.02644941955804825, -0.03273788094520569, 0.0023031081072986126, -0.02644568867981434, -0.08539025485515594, 0.054798778146505356, 0.02604423090815544, -0.023251425474882126, 0.043832480907440186, -0.09993746876716614, -0.05836375057697296, -0.014596273191273212, 0.010839425027370453, -0.012532508000731468, 0.03414568677544594, 0.008846101351082325, 0.006810251623392105, -0.008804592303931713, -0.03703044727444649, 0.015160748735070229, 0.04226423054933548, -0.03224317729473114, 0.00040717876981943846, -0.0058885980397462845, -0.03819356486201286, -0.05829716846346855, -0.03969097509980202, -0.03492783382534981, 0.010836645029485226, 0.003205779939889908, 0.04068787395954132, 0.04686971753835678, 0.056582238525152206, -0.05241520702838898, -0.02814370021224022, 0.05067847669124603, -0.04199995473027229, 0.0041349902749061584, -0.01132980827242136, -0.038403403013944626, -0.027698157355189323, -0.045770928263664246, 0.012507768347859383, -0.06091644987463951, 0.05506317317485809, -0.004107767250388861, -0.0480605810880661, 0.02488820254802704, 0.01835004612803459, -0.06047559902071953, 0.0036252124700695276, -0.042621299624443054, -0.007964386604726315, 0.014172688126564026, 0.07824068516492844, -0.011244604364037514, -0.004118978511542082, 0.06121094152331352, 0.010119832120835781, 0.020931731909513474, 0.0327012799680233, 0.053239498287439346, -0.015532949939370155, 0.020348452031612396, 0.030395077541470528, -0.012414111755788326, -0.03901468589901924, -0.03274235501885414, 0.017217539250850677, 0.00012299662921577692, 0.048080094158649445, 0.04960138350725174, 0.02935141697525978, 0.042865537106990814, 0.03948414698243141, 0.009057363495230675, 0.015036750584840775, -0.034301139414310455, 0.02285824343562126, 0.03156985342502594, 0.011974048800766468, 0.0373266376554966, -0.03824051842093468, 0.013269951567053795, -0.04412943124771118, 0.003055891953408718, -0.010896669700741768, 0.03924636170268059, 0.029413066804409027, 0.02538113109767437, -0.02192641794681549, -0.011652374640107155, 0.027614569291472435, -0.02226223424077034, 0.04150105640292168, 0.050119951367378235, -0.031457625329494476, 0.010462464764714241, -0.001660957233980298, -0.025183938443660736, -0.031159523874521255, 0.03691123053431511, -0.03485724702477455, 0.05194168910384178, -0.003506636479869485, 0.05722774565219879, 0.06986573338508606, -0.0415228009223938, -0.02646094374358654, -0.04320403188467026, -0.006597877014428377, 0.03243093192577362, 0.021304432302713394, -0.009226247668266296, -0.04588261619210243, -0.01426961924880743, -0.026208778843283653, -0.01682461053133011, -0.014007617719471455, -0.016606656834483147, 0.020280536264181137, -0.05452096462249756, 0.00008469937165500596, 0.0011684070341289043, -0.027079924941062927, 0.06999750435352325, -0.017699239775538445, 0.000008934898687584791, -0.029391149058938026, -0.0549546554684639, 0.0574856735765934, -0.028766276314854622, -0.032013434916734695, -0.07430510222911835, 0.09764768928289413, 0.0027538128197193146, 0.013128657825291157, 0.003565917257219553, 0.008170194923877716, 0.08100174367427826, -0.016596226021647453, 0.01456980686634779, 0.06376387178897858, 0.009762413799762726, -0.013678749091923237, 0.04641050472855568, 0.01574438251554966, -0.027132075279951096, 0.022089973092079163, -0.0016769705107435584, -0.0001930535217979923, 0.03908281773328781, -0.004313332494348288, -0.036593664437532425, 0.015558511950075626, 0.008107706904411316, -0.03861551731824875, 0.02809571661055088, 0.01897168718278408, 0.002110458444803953, -0.00863434374332428, -0.03213430568575859, 0.013902010396122932, 0.006794257089495659, -0.03560271114110947, -0.0749555304646492, -0.013829488307237625, 0.008989051915705204, -0.023540927097201347, 0.062004558742046356, 0.03734910488128662, -0.0182600487023592, 0.010441555641591549, 0.07548601180315018, 0.002271792618557811, -0.03163588047027588, 0.013557094149291515, 0.02592582255601883, 0.04082462564110756, -0.06342559307813644, -0.03128824010491371, 0.001677206950262189, 0.03479123115539551, -0.06497949361801147, -0.0028115955647081137, -0.0003845429455395788, -0.02139497920870781, 0.0032672856468707323, -0.054692596197128296, -0.04781198501586914, -0.051893800497055054, -0.02361202798783779, 0.042751651257276535, -0.0014922893606126308, 0.013866838067770004, 0.07291270047426224, -0.047746483236551285, -0.00819450430572033, 0.01827567256987095, -0.03438028320670128, -0.03610428422689438, 0.025835823267698288, -0.02608523704111576, -0.004277380649000406, -0.0006280516972765326, -0.0331534706056118, -0.0047798603773117065, -0.020822439342737198, -0.025718478485941887, 0.055328816175460815, -0.032744310796260834, -0.009232506155967712, 0.04110057279467583, 0.025022104382514954, 0.06585253775119781, 0.008949004113674164, -0.008785274811089039, -0.029954195022583008, -0.0821232870221138, 0.07046643644571304, -0.07253816723823547, 0.01892452873289585, 0.02267592027783394, -0.10922587662935257, 0.02790221758186817, -0.016728410497307777, -0.06723186373710632, -0.07110996544361115, -0.03238508477807045, -0.006336518097668886, 0.01658470369875431, 0.030548768118023872, 0.012212492525577545, 0.05706837400794029, 0.084339439868927, 0.03481929749250412, 0.011164662428200245, 0.0010487122926861048, -0.032925065606832504, 0.01563667133450508, -0.020252740010619164, -0.026844466105103493, -0.02139853686094284, 0.047252535820007324, -0.014636601321399212, -0.023911267518997192, -0.02372005768120289, -0.013440982438623905, -0.0009481126326136291, 0.09675424546003342, 0.048227518796920776, 0.011379245668649673, -0.0464080274105072, -0.05844584107398987, -0.03805066645145416, 0.013270976021885872, 0.04936893284320831, -0.013513350859284401, 0.06466937065124512, -0.02705409750342369, -0.006613662000745535, -0.005471405107527971, 0.03484903275966644, 0.031026871874928474, -0.04725810885429382, -0.03434516116976738, -0.0760885626077652, -0.004725225269794464, -0.02219802886247635, 0.02286086045205593, -0.004740560427308083, 0.012670439667999744, 0.03857690468430519, -0.05940007045865059, 0.0063716755248606205, 0.005824211984872818, 0.01545283105224371, 0.02061726525425911, 0.04755471274256706, -0.027548249810934067, -0.016063522547483444, -0.031029917299747467, 0.017633432522416115, 0.02116786129772663, 0.0398494191467762, 0.021319346502423286, 0.043176501989364624, -0.03283942490816116, 0.04083307459950447, -0.013473092578351498, -0.011823468841612339, -0.01676180772483349, 0.00892361719161272, -0.02991311252117157, 0.04975394904613495, 0.050924528390169144, -0.0019910428673028946, 1.9075505974797125e-7, 0.004029680509120226, 0.018228502944111824, 0.002794346073642373, 0.006532712373882532, -0.02374831959605217, 0.021293358877301216, -0.023837080225348473, 0.018444493412971497, 0.013628566637635231, -0.032214533537626266, -0.027956806123256683, -0.03319748118519783, -0.03630545362830162, 0.03162062168121338, 0.0457160510122776, 0.007704958785325289, 0.06540776789188385, 0.03169993683695793, -0.05712820589542389, -0.014108690433204174, -0.03772624582052231, 0.017428575083613396, 0.032620370388031006, 0.02818206325173378, 0.03471621498465538, -0.04068208858370781, -0.022396836429834366, -0.025628022849559784, -0.0026020931545645, 0.028740057721734047, 0.03139203041791916, -0.007155362516641617, -0.011357974261045456, 0.06257279962301254, 0.018775463104248047, -0.028118448331952095, 0.008948279544711113, -0.09990698099136353, 0.00025616868515498936, -0.003682721173390746, 0.020788008347153664, 0.011199277825653553, 0.025192338973283768, -0.008903425186872482, 0.005770611111074686, -0.0070326379500329494, 0.03718845546245575, -0.00879194401204586, -0.010818985290825367, 0.0017667945940047503, 0.04192352667450905, 0.0041930354200303555, 0.012579799629747868, -0.012670076452195644, 0.011830967850983143, 0.0416235588490963, 0.029076386243104935, 0.05065188556909561, -0.022891465574502945, 0.02125292271375656, -0.015789566561579704, 0.02444802038371563, -0.01303554605692625, 0.028441978618502617, -0.042239610105752945, -0.026199381798505783, -0.025850800797343254, -0.003533153096213937, -0.015579749830067158, 0.009384769015014172, 0.027830835431814194, 0.00498687569051981, -0.01995237171649933, -0.003759782761335373, 0.022700656205415726, -0.015345019288361073, -0.026521505787968636, -0.025280466303229332, 0.04019513353705406, 0.07223161309957504, 0.02149621583521366, 0.006098764017224312, 0.045814912766218185, -0.023853376507759094, 0.03568308427929878, 0.09134987741708755, 0.019739758223295212, 0.008098946884274483, 0.011520636267960072, 0.005260834004729986, 0.01712791621685028, 0.014538116753101349, -0.05747275799512863, 0.01095675677061081, 0.009621091187000275, 0.0034006850328296423, -0.03090861439704895, 0.019460050389170647, 0.0034501191694289446, 0.11029287427663803, -0.08054503798484802, 0.0342710018157959, -0.011670990847051144, 0.030249593779444695, -0.002103277947753668, 0.0023616389371454716, -0.012125756591558456, -0.08067332953214645, -0.010747677646577358, -0.05174868181347847, -0.012139523401856422, 0.0000778759567765519, 0.01519022136926651, 0.025688769295811653, 0.026565250009298325, -0.05601608380675316, -0.022720303386449814, -0.07362712919712067, 0.013718895614147186, -0.06892339885234833, -0.03381626680493355, -0.009124989621341228, 0.01966978795826435, -0.04520609602332115, 0.0386945940554142, 0.0026225748006254435, -0.09231282025575638, 0.053785014897584915, -0.03456689044833183, -0.04099379852414131, 0.023351851850748062, 0.007944272831082344, -0.0499744787812233, 0.015495329163968563, 0.05581683665513992, -0.05868097394704819, 0.006001145113259554, 0.020596958696842194, -0.012991717085242271, 0.036656517535448074, -0.04320330172777176, -0.03285382315516472, -0.00003803048821282573, 0.017779232934117317, -0.022118814289569855, 0.03506670147180557, -0.004017983563244343, -0.049798741936683655, -0.05696553736925125, -0.007699578069150448, -0.00020253787806723267, 0.019422737881541252, -0.038676828145980835, -0.0070154001004993916, -0.03192475438117981, 0.060810912400484085, 0.012834809720516205, 0.022646740078926086, -0.01808568276464939, -0.003830256871879101, 0.049006685614585876, -0.0010761035373434424, 0.03872157633304596, 0.030593719333410263, 0.01305515505373478, -0.0003380470152478665, -0.028835872188210487, -0.045306652784347534, 0.03264207765460014, 0.051169972866773605, 0.03420814871788025, -0.016166672110557556, -0.01001272164285183, 0.004266923293471336, -0.005381765775382519, 0.01530245877802372, 0.015934806317090988, -0.04491773620247841, 0.03072071447968483, -0.04047561064362526, -0.0030437465757131577, 0.0035439073108136654, 0.08800901472568512, 0.040884532034397125, -0.0017845313996076584, 0.03686040639877319, -0.05657874420285225, 0.06275121122598648, 0.019793696701526642, -0.03832855448126793, -0.03488549590110779, -0.017030712217092514, -0.030328543856739998, 0.009641043841838837, 0.02833244577050209, 0.04046225547790527, 0.007499059196561575, -0.029447052627801895, 0.015772651880979538, -0.00431761285290122, -0.04926881939172745, 0.00640402315184474, -0.005108990240842104, -0.013140479102730751, 0.013842450454831123, -0.017541328445076942, -0.024147633463144302, -0.0767931267619133, 0.049865175038576126, 0.004781297408044338, -0.00820555817335844, -0.012162371538579464, -0.03454398363828659, 0.0034469154197722673, 0.04198518395423889, -0.0051765539683401585, 0.023889344185590744, 0.023077331483364105, -0.02576310746371746, -0.004098926205188036, 0.027970490977168083, -0.022595258429646492, 0.02158387191593647, 0.010539505630731583, -0.03139020875096321, 0.017994333058595657, -0.08255168795585632, 0.025079159066081047, 0.03725886717438698, 0.00959813967347145, -0.002974137431010604, -0.03584063798189163, -0.01331694982945919, -0.07480089366436005, -0.09306425601243973, -0.001351844402961433, 0.05277399718761444, -0.07668185234069824, -0.02890923246741295, 0.02930053509771824, 0.01621120795607567, -0.024980369955301285, 0.006666284054517746, 0.044168222695589066, 0.010630159638822079, 0.07936573028564453, -0.015620063059031963, -0.006168952211737633, -0.010306340642273426, 0.02610095962882042, -0.016113735735416412, 0.030853405594825745, 0.01575513556599617, 0.01290902029722929, -0.026256456971168518, -0.02377556823194027, 0.046964097768068314, -0.030057450756430626, 0.02121817134320736, 0.06883253902196884, -0.014195319265127182, -0.003757615340873599, 0.02290366403758526, -0.04670454561710358, 0.02190995402634144, -0.058266859501600266, 0.015494391322135925, 0.028734246268868446, 0.0486704483628273, -0.017720326781272888, -0.04814393073320389, 0.013715268112719059, 0.04022066667675972, 0.03795759752392769, -0.04874897748231888, -0.00775071419775486, 0.0423690564930439, -0.003930659964680672, -0.009008676744997501, -0.04913949966430664, -0.0027483750600367785, 0.003768340917304158, 0.002871593926101923, 0.016489379107952118, -0.08903621137142181, 0.0302853025496006, 0.025441333651542664, 0.008190810680389404, -0.007931293919682503, 0.0006718729855492711, 0.010615693405270576, -0.025977198034524918, -0.010168570093810558, -0.047342751175165176, -0.027278102934360504, -0.03017425909638405, 0.0675206109881401, 0.025002188980579376, 0.06965872645378113, -0.038663599640131, 0.01799231767654419, 0.008834284730255604, -0.04418694227933884, -0.06664624065160751, -0.05582677572965622, -0.009337227791547775, 0.02871437929570675, -0.07803894579410553, 0.04682537540793419, 0.0022911468986421824, 0.031987499445676804, 0.027868550270795822, 0.005154510028660297, 0.025243911892175674, -0.01556189265102148, -0.06530407816171646, -0.04320117086172104, 0.028386656194925308, 0.046113524585962296, 0.030065802857279778, -0.012919719330966473, -0.008548606187105179, 0.041026439517736435, 0.030323971062898636, -0.0006700637750327587, 0.002521467162296176, 0.048607658594846725, 0.02268979512155056, -0.03586467728018761, -0.009737887419760227, 0.010310922749340534, -0.01690279133617878, -0.006111199036240578, 0.002708118874579668, -0.05300286039710045, 0.0037819636054337025, 0.013680041767656803, 0.039378367364406586, -0.003017634619027376, 0.04433870688080788, -0.04461497440934181, 0.029352840036153793, 0.08291689306497574, -0.030133401975035667, -0.037680044770240784, -0.0021103406324982643, -0.004163747653365135, -0.011155015788972378, -0.06042622774839401, -0.0463673397898674, 0.016695283353328705, 0.09824573248624802, 0.05527479946613312, 0.08420026302337646, -0.032913900911808014, -0.018966184929013252, 0.040035076439380646, -0.02638782002031803, 0.10350150614976883, -0.006189153529703617, 0.006908620707690716, -0.0008710173424333334, -0.057269152253866196, 0.015551350079476833, 0.03394787758588791, -0.09563414752483368, -0.0025903373025357723, -0.021205425262451172, 0.015273150987923145, -0.03868907317519188, 0.03315967321395874, -0.038909852504730225, -0.0068290154449641705, -0.01602134294807911, 0.011969763785600662, 0.005006017163395882, -0.02569875307381153, 0.014737242832779884, -0.032764796167612076, 0.03648073598742485, 0.036220014095306396, -0.0468505397439003, -0.04579100385308266, -0.02623344399034977, -0.019073421135544777, -0.050096284598112106, -0.041452959179878235, 0.0038469298742711544, 0.04670189321041107, 0.016779936850070953, 0.0429203025996685, -0.053212884813547134, -0.0883551687002182, 0.03181788697838783, 0.007465684786438942, -0.07746487855911255, 0.00019539093773346394, 0.013149366714060307, -0.014057784341275692, -0.034379977732896805, -0.011763794347643852, -0.004370412789285183, 0.03220110014081001, 0.011603213846683502, 0.015109604224562645, -0.0459088571369648, 0.04566808044910431, 0.003326895646750927 ]
<p>Here is a link to an article from phys.org describing what the scientists (M. Sonnleitner at the University of Innsbruck and Innsbruck Medical University in Austria, M. Ritsch-Marte at Innsbruck Medical University, and H. Ritsch at the University of Innsbruck) in the article call the blackbody force. <a href="http://phys.org/news/2013-07-blackbody-stronger-gravity.html" rel="nofollow">http://phys.org/news/2013-07-blackbody-stronger-gravity.html</a> </p> <p>My question is, are they suggesting that this blackbody force is a fundamental force i.e. it belongs to group of gravity, weak/electromagnetic, and strong forces. And if not, what of the fundamental forces might or do make up this blackbody force?</p>
g5841
[ 0.010290168225765228, 0.0056825317442417145, 0.007086196914315224, 0.011537253856658936, 0.03255946934223175, 0.049241483211517334, -0.02893090434372425, -0.007681510876864195, -0.009898792952299118, -0.0422523207962513, 0.017874788492918015, 0.016376839950680733, 0.005945015233010054, -0.03889919072389603, 0.008874810300767422, 0.036236442625522614, 0.008615515194833279, 0.031070882454514503, 0.074041947722435, -0.011446536518633366, 0.04841270670294762, 0.01957792602479458, -0.005289555061608553, -0.07650135457515717, -0.04496036097407341, 0.0027966347988694906, 0.07408304512500763, -0.01630595326423645, -0.05171831324696541, -0.04941744729876518, 0.05064824968576431, 0.07375534623861313, 0.07754791527986526, -0.032847315073013306, -0.026702914386987686, 0.03799780085682869, 0.0005008942098356783, 0.05349837616086006, -0.037236522883176804, 0.001404820941388607, 0.04051663726568222, -0.051479894667863846, -0.026312338188290596, 0.0016740660648792982, -0.04134359210729599, -0.004435396753251553, 0.032377589493989944, -0.030582036823034286, -0.016174208372831345, 0.008966963738203049, -0.002163283061236143, -0.043230313807725906, 0.055798016488552094, 0.022747401148080826, 0.026187604293227196, 0.007294041570276022, 0.0343833826482296, 0.03957168757915497, -0.035340987145900726, -0.0024371659383177757, -0.016158686950802803, 0.024748604744672775, 0.03699464723467827, -0.017730029299855232, 0.03274248167872429, 0.0006168953841552138, -0.022566737607121468, 0.021486254408955574, -0.00848960317671299, 0.015205626375973225, -0.028570642694830894, 0.004562981426715851, 0.0006371305789798498, 0.05813772976398468, -0.04864181950688362, 0.04765165597200394, -0.009730317629873753, 0.05816967785358429, 0.0019090708810836077, -0.05282385274767876, 0.07802978903055191, 0.03369561955332756, 0.021889589726924896, 0.049593161791563034, 0.05826392024755478, -0.08067148923873901, -0.03817704692482948, -0.011594726704061031, 0.039224691689014435, 0.09091956168413162, 0.04739780351519585, 0.024296168237924576, 0.055498428642749786, 0.03215063735842705, -0.010058029554784298, 0.0013088671257719398, 0.05886584147810936, 0.060186490416526794, -0.03689771518111229, -0.0002010488387895748, -0.053818847984075546, 0.018575523048639297, -0.01772182248532772, 0.006220735143870115, 0.03486815467476845, -0.013968447223305702, -0.02638983353972435, 0.03880501911044121, -0.053128715604543686, 0.017396273091435432, 0.002297439379617572, -0.00826498493552208, -0.0059064533561468124, 0.002974280621856451, -0.007792191114276648, -0.01499954704195261, 0.04081449657678604, -0.0073825581930577755, 0.010635019280016422, 0.07727084308862686, -0.047147154808044434, -0.018753573298454285, 0.07467803359031677, 0.012954404577612877, -0.010541140101850033, -0.10704647749662399, 0.03851255774497986, -0.002096855081617832, 0.003042967990040779, -0.06512339413166046, -0.0049172574654221535, -0.023606786504387856, -0.011777582578361034, 0.007646880112588406, 0.030431417748332024, 0.05327213183045387, 0.05823024734854698, 0.03554404526948929, -0.03356660529971123, 0.030014393851161003, -0.0328950472176075, 0.007206322625279427, 0.015940072014927864, -0.03440052643418312, 0.00622553052380681, 0.034866638481616974, -0.00760619156062603, 0.01920212060213089, 0.023261550813913345, 0.02812640368938446, -0.0005086755263619125, 0.03851150721311569, -0.047328293323516846, -0.041373975574970245, -0.014729311689734459, -0.0392000637948513, 0.04069971665740013, 0.04773460701107979, -0.016652513295412064, 0.03225228190422058, 0.01650235243141651, 0.01837177760899067, 0.03265149146318436, 0.004880390129983425, -0.006577891297638416, 0.0460798516869545, -0.04260670021176338, -0.018410664051771164, 0.03654477372765541, 0.02242053858935833, -0.032113030552864075, 0.02393033355474472, -0.017130952328443527, 0.06668440997600555, 0.044410329312086105, -0.03200436383485794, 0.01884482614696026, -0.04272807389497757, 0.028032980859279633, -0.06792580336332321, -0.021105268970131874, 0.011759298853576183, 0.0021176859736442566, -0.01133627537637949, -0.016658447682857513, -0.037902578711509705, 0.01839885115623474, 0.07934986799955368, 0.013168628327548504, 0.01798086054623127, -0.0803733840584755, 0.014999160543084145, 0.0036044293083250523, 0.060470957309007645, 0.03847920894622803, 0.0218051690608263, -0.029047049582004547, -0.02970379963517189, 0.0566047765314579, 0.03609127923846245, -0.01732100360095501, 0.04958363249897957, -0.0421401672065258, -0.006832024082541466, 0.006243448238819838, 0.02090536244213581, -0.013941982761025429, 0.009360226802527905, 0.044233597815036774, -0.003415385028347373, 0.0014231452951207757, 0.011809690855443478, 0.03100249543786049, 0.013164019212126732, -0.06428568810224533, -0.006317841820418835, -0.07270105928182602, 0.000701663491781801, -0.03728551045060158, 0.025940347462892532, -0.03283584490418434, -0.02137010172009468, -0.05295204743742943, 0.025325682014226913, -0.025497647002339363, -0.05131414905190468, -0.015476696193218231, -0.06726106256246567, 0.011062311008572578, -0.012446308508515358, -0.013901344500482082, -0.028557905927300453, 0.009679414331912994, 0.01689751446247101, 0.018804272636771202, 0.04644639790058136, 0.016315093263983727, 0.014027676545083523, -0.02466096170246601, 0.03425208106637001, 0.00792377907782793, -0.03928210213780403, 0.03661561757326126, -0.062210727483034134, 0.03105934150516987, 0.0013410536339506507, -0.030047981068491936, -0.045392218977212906, 0.0384933203458786, 0.020426543429493904, -0.0029460422229021788, -0.08369964361190796, -0.03309902921319008, 0.006180446594953537, 0.00766727514564991, -0.006300787441432476, -0.014233678579330444, 0.05619838088750839, -0.06171412393450737, -0.04777048900723457, 0.03813488036394119, 0.009728305041790009, 0.029556352645158768, 0.1035136952996254, -0.10168427228927612, -0.00739878136664629, -0.06677336245775223, -0.013985149562358856, 0.007054831366986036, -0.00006438188574975356, -0.05535006895661354, 0.0008958165999501944, -0.03519053012132645, -0.04584508016705513, -0.020918376743793488, 0.03218229487538338, -0.027913236990571022, 0.00000707404160493752, 0.022259386256337166, 0.012632783502340317, 0.015688253566622734, 0.003470114665105939, -0.034302614629268646, 0.021118519827723503, -0.03890114277601242, 0.015965649858117104, 0.012034776620566845, -0.06403470784425735, -0.07154867053031921, -0.04346852004528046, -0.016420844942331314, 0.015143954195082188, 0.04828291013836861, -0.012062535621225834, -0.009895062074065208, 0.021390307694673538, 0.016269207000732422, -0.05463631823658943, -0.02109818533062935, 0.033112671226263046, -0.01724022813141346, -0.0014667435316368937, 0.058528825640678406, 0.023910213261842728, -0.023766033351421356, -0.004416381008923054, -0.0604807548224926, -0.08654934167861938, -0.04989486560225487, 0.011601694859564304, -0.008153063245117664, 0.02837817557156086, 0.020720234140753746, 0.04697992280125618, -0.01994129829108715, 0.02178647182881832, 0.007246564142405987, -0.009478595107793808, -0.0063476720824837685, -0.07455901801586151, -0.026824109256267548, -0.08735943585634232, -0.0009615210583433509, 0.007970667444169521, 0.12307243049144745, 0.05890997499227524, -0.0007462595822289586, -0.0014229199150577188, -0.016526879742741585, -0.011331927962601185, 0.059025928378105164, 0.02419719286262989, -0.04199469834566116, 0.06152734532952309, -0.029019661247730255, -0.008715443313121796, -0.0007462852518074214, -0.014693555422127247, 0.049966633319854736, -0.015534901060163975, 0.056500572711229324, -0.0015379998367279768, 0.03589319810271263, 0.011104580014944077, 0.008799774572253227, 0.03458680212497711, -0.03545598313212395, -0.027449605986475945, 0.01934315264225006, -0.011335383169353008, -0.011492066085338593, 0.030724715441465378, 0.04891630634665489, -0.044696368277072906, 0.04468076303601265, -0.09098616987466812, 0.08677330613136292, -0.057350147515535355, -0.008527425117790699, 0.012850810773670673, -0.018262267112731934, 0.04643029347062111, 0.0366312600672245, -0.002608594484627247, -0.0791967436671257, -0.029352758079767227, 0.046421971172094345, 0.0192687027156353, -0.023400871083140373, -0.020949235185980797, 0.04589156061410904, -0.03932160139083862, -0.02835126221179962, 0.010323679074645042, 0.009206420741975307, -0.05817394703626633, 0.035051532089710236, 0.0010448027169331908, 0.01264277845621109, -0.02754773385822773, 0.06537359207868576, 0.08878754079341888, 0.03530802205204964, 0.034142132848501205, -0.005795502103865147, 0.020699115470051765, -0.024431873112916946, -0.009688829071819782, 0.03597884625196457, -0.0053920866921544075, -0.03931904956698418, 0.0003759159881155938, -0.038064368069171906, -0.004125716630369425, 0.04785561561584473, -0.008622879162430763, -0.005127019714564085, 0.009294423274695873, 0.03230947628617287, -0.011048529297113419, 0.02619088441133499, 0.037913113832473755, 0.029392117634415627, 0.03599914535880089, -0.02000504732131958, 0.02803982049226761, 0.004844308365136385, -0.018090827390551567, 0.008631127886474133, -0.02601679600775242, 0.048142384737730026, -0.007458478212356567, 0.0035219823475927114, -0.06482461839914322, 0.0659862831234932, 0.06740440428256989, -0.007621195632964373, -0.0400085411965847, -0.02229364775121212, -0.009387829340994358, 0.057143572717905045, -0.0015435522655025125, 0.041044674813747406, -0.005313675384968519, -0.050458747893571854, 0.031215118244290352, -0.020391130819916725, 0.02179875411093235, 0.004004223272204399, -0.005027390085160732, -0.03708676993846893, -0.001628216472454369, 0.02494261972606182, -0.0064242929220199585, -0.034895192831754684, 0.05465683341026306, -0.0028491979464888573, -0.03560784086585045, -0.010410074144601822, -0.005840233527123928, 0.05138317495584488, 0.02045391872525215, 0.005560111720114946, -0.01623166911303997, -0.010629894211888313, 0.045640602707862854, -0.022256163880228996, 0.017705930396914482, -0.024246567860245705, -0.0029241819866001606, 0.03642474487423897, -0.04478728398680687, 0.0012522925389930606, -0.014562699943780899, -0.030406884849071503, 0.02406005747616291, -0.008761698380112648, -0.026577867567539215, -0.02939552254974842, 0.004046136979013681, -0.03218001872301102, -0.025451485067605972, 0.016855208203196526, 0.08058362454175949, 0.013061534613370895, -0.04411190748214722, -0.04497402161359787, -0.002362801693379879, -0.0062649985775351524, -0.04185384511947632, -0.014964143745601177, -0.003666752018034458, -0.01895800791680813, -0.04322274401783943, -0.0040738387033343315, 0.0191955603659153, -0.0018805612344294786, -0.003060355084016919, -0.03651251643896103, -0.010814023204147816, 0.03781649470329285, 0.025673987343907356, 0.02905016578733921, -0.01115017756819725, -0.014748599380254745, -0.026999378576874733, -0.015560192056000233, 0.020101431757211685, -0.05021457001566887, -0.00647437060251832, 0.0004080598591826856, 0.05564716458320618, 0.041326068341732025, -0.06791368871927261, -0.0636676698923111, 0.0011953854700550437, 0.006110847927629948, -0.030802998691797256, 0.003097652457654476, 0.02587473951280117, -0.023817691951990128, 0.03247997537255287, 0.04335414990782738, 0.0310532096773386, 0.01373921986669302, 0.03139199689030647, 0.03670286014676094, 0.028044378384947777, 0.0003951967810280621, 0.05563950166106224, -0.05673858895897865, -0.03987180069088936, -0.03723178431391716, -0.017246346920728683, 0.010130268521606922, 0.023862170055508614, 0.05744151398539543, 0.020722519606351852, -0.012653060257434845, -0.01441932562738657, 0.03396627679467201, -0.02197432704269886, 0.08484328538179398, 0.0023378864862024784, 0.02244868502020836, -0.00688294880092144, -0.0314340777695179, 0.029942205175757408, 0.027807192876935005, 0.09153139591217041, 0.012193311005830765, -0.003231024369597435, 0.04471714049577713, -0.03683154657483101, 0.014420563355088234, 0.0060271876864135265, 0.05912964418530464, 0.00824563205242157, 0.014821844175457954, -0.021554140374064445, -0.03797127306461334, -0.013997080735862255, -0.015827905386686325, 0.03837720677256584, 0.03005153499543667, 0.04543023183941841, -0.018623601645231247, -0.03474105894565582, 0.033590782433748245, -0.01788460649549961, 0.0009431173675693572, 0.020487863570451736, -0.03020438924431801, -0.01414897944778204, 0.0073844208382070065, 0.012215905822813511, -0.01671123504638672, -0.05841416120529175, -0.012743046507239342, -0.07103732228279114, 0.021370891481637955, -0.015283836983144283, -0.05333824083209038, -0.033395662903785706, 0.004925636108964682, -0.03587967902421951, -0.006325804628431797, -0.04965870454907417, 0.020743222907185555, 0.008890869095921516, -0.028522934764623642, 0.0037188564892858267, -0.03720943257212639, 0.030239811167120934, -0.013384058140218258, -0.026989169418811798, 0.016731899231672287, 0.008938404731452465, -0.07063885778188705, 0.003237172495573759, 0.029903164133429527, -0.018764177337288857, 0.04750298708677292, -0.06453844159841537, -0.07726231962442398, 0.036967817693948746, -0.07057012617588043, 0.03325954079627991, 0.011868622153997421, -0.008031670935451984, 0.037367627024650574, 0.054458800703287125, -0.02551375702023506, -0.01242167130112648, -0.07449866831302643, -0.026516694575548172, 0.03975234925746918, 0.012071581557393074, -0.003206753870472312, -0.0011698323069140315, -0.017056401818990707, 0.029534107074141502, 0.00735526904463768, 0.04561638459563255, 0.02220563031733036, -0.036011166870594025, -0.00902891531586647, -0.00464067654684186, -0.011112346313893795, 0.010210776701569557, -0.020096052438020706, -0.004061365034431219, -0.06446655094623566, -0.003999331034719944, 0.0109968651086092, -0.048243116587400436, -0.03563017025589943, -0.02325967699289322, -0.011908892542123795, 0.03777628391981125, -0.019275449216365814, -0.012688364833593369, 0.0014742922503501177, -0.04832640662789345, 0.0268709696829319, 0.053985655307769775, -0.043038807809352875, 0.030159510672092438, 0.03169989585876465, 0.013570770621299744, -0.001697790459729731, -0.04685195907950401, -0.005501722451299429, -0.0028582485392689705, 0.0014194513205438852, 0.03118131123483181, -0.017006291076540947, -0.023565489798784256, 0.03146563097834587, -0.04079108685255051, -0.010892568156123161, -0.018383193761110306, 0.03235321864485741, -0.004243422765284777, -0.04315022751688957, 0.022796254605054855, 0.015798525884747505, 0.009332233108580112, -0.001749046379700303, 0.0057298955507576466, 0.038486842066049576, -0.08903776854276657, 0.04770701006054878, -0.04556722193956375, -0.07796508073806763, -0.014666705392301083, -0.008255193009972572, -0.03951996937394142, 0.04661371931433678, -0.07259677350521088, -0.01848532073199749, 0.011298492550849915, -0.01502649299800396, 0.01712571084499359, -0.020525554195046425, 0.051705267280340195, -0.017722228541970253, -0.0077957166358828545, 0.0024617728777229786, -0.023923782631754875, 0.040046945214271545, -0.07443949580192566, -0.023964228108525276, -0.029295342043042183, -0.044530220329761505, -0.04071605205535889, 0.02315043844282627, 0.04186353087425232, 0.06915447860956192, 0.0519828163087368, -0.0015770334284752607, 0.05534970387816429, -0.08008672297000885, 0.04202486202120781, -0.016272369772195816, 0.004774185363203287, 0.0025851901154965162, 0.001248216605745256, 0.025562938302755356, -0.0017194540705531836, -0.006039735395461321, -0.025600960478186607, -0.11255765706300735, -0.008716444484889507, -0.04357408359646797, -0.041329216212034225, -0.015048384666442871, 0.06136629730463028, 0.02248408831655979, -0.00009253019379684702, -0.016404889523983, -0.06888166069984436, -0.02858581393957138, -0.015889596194028854, 0.030410051345825195, 0.027866799384355545, -0.02052866481244564, -0.006481678690761328, -0.04109988361597061, -0.022072933614253998, 0.06187179312109947, 0.03833352401852608, 0.029580365866422653, -0.05991147831082344, -0.02455800026655197, 0.05388032644987106, 0.021073903888463974, -0.007912678644061089, 0.005955638829618692, -0.023254206404089928, 0.018552141264081, -0.014930273406207561, -0.015779001638293266, -0.08863227069377899, -0.10368600487709045, -0.008138992823660374, 0.013978936709463596, -0.049692559987306595, 0.020463038235902786, -0.05829435959458351, -0.029579058289527893, -0.02664169855415821, -0.02310689352452755, -0.04568348079919815, -0.003643970936536789, 0.0068124402314424515, -0.011441122740507126, 0.03086022287607193, 0.04167617857456207, 0.047299958765506744, -0.009936687536537647, -0.066554494202137, -0.018374187871813774, -0.009895148687064648, -0.004834506195038557, 0.0028585183899849653, -0.008661334402859211, 0.03748655691742897, 0.02114250138401985, 0.03092338889837265, 0.010273141786456108, 0.03954383730888367, 0.06134364753961563, 0.060864828526973724, 0.031507112085819244, -0.07588924467563629, -0.05468222498893738, 0.005522413179278374, 0.04396212473511696, 0.007016427349299192, -0.06875389814376831, 0.05462437868118286, 0.012569899670779705, -0.0037622086238116026, -0.0027987484354525805, 0.013290906324982643, 0.0020710185635834932, 0.011305625550448895 ]
<p>I'm trying to make an application for Hooke's law using a spring, but the law doesn't give any correct result with my spring, because when I hang a $100\,\mathrm{g}$ object on the spring it's elongates about $0.3\,\mathrm{cm}$ and when I hang a $200\,\mathrm{g}$ object the spring elongates about $1\,\mathrm{cm}$ while it should elongates only $0.6\,\mathrm{cm}$ .</p> <p>I'm sure that the problem is with the spring design.</p> <p>The spring I'm using is just like in picture below:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/VKmVt.jpg" alt="image of a tight-coiled spring"></p>
g5842
[ 0.022251393646001816, -0.014558668248355389, 0.023990487679839134, 0.021739976480603218, 0.019702570512890816, -0.013824705965816975, 0.01784820854663849, 0.009710434824228287, -0.045886531472206116, -0.04002903774380684, -0.029462995007634163, 0.01861358806490898, 0.03554713726043701, -0.02068316750228405, 0.04690716043114662, -0.008552373386919498, 0.044733960181474686, -0.026846257969737053, 0.008991565555334091, 0.04040626809000969, 0.049038976430892944, -0.05235084891319275, 0.0019672419875860214, -0.04311580955982208, -0.004185738507658243, 0.029984382912516594, -0.044975996017456055, 0.07036476582288742, -0.093589186668396, -0.014551371335983276, -0.023828653618693352, 0.01609424129128456, 0.0011809772113338113, -0.04277842491865158, -0.017085663974285126, 0.027769817039370537, -0.014766422100365162, 0.02483348548412323, 0.02371692843735218, -0.036201316863298416, 0.017671074718236923, -0.004083317704498768, -0.00042990889050997794, 0.018150925636291504, 0.01609405316412449, -0.04799274355173111, -0.032681990414857864, 0.08724720031023026, 0.013537473045289516, -0.047735001891851425, -0.01805906370282173, 0.02754673734307289, -0.018415996804833412, -0.0675591230392456, 0.0432497002184391, 0.052757300436496735, -0.0038258996792137623, 0.026247838512063026, 0.0648430809378624, 0.013648725114762783, 0.012372739613056183, 0.003919968847185373, -0.02354625053703785, 0.003365237032994628, 0.05492248758673668, 0.07347188144922256, 0.01233903132379055, -0.020138869062066078, 0.006051294505596161, 0.07727490365505219, -0.023988962173461914, -0.02413804829120636, 0.01029304787516594, -0.08268141746520996, -0.07690168917179108, -0.006208656821399927, -0.024325307458639145, 0.02542157843708992, -0.02365666814148426, -0.03952762857079506, -0.0027173757553100586, -0.0018333757761865854, -0.04358193278312683, 0.049903981387615204, -0.004566201940178871, 0.05951393023133278, 0.03536667302250862, 0.05624774098396301, 0.013402118347585201, 0.03701528161764145, 0.031534455716609955, -0.010365375317633152, 0.044337984174489975, 0.0068009779788553715, -0.021875789389014244, -0.055365871638059616, 0.04773816466331482, 0.04930197447538376, 0.04516805335879326, -0.005870930850505829, -0.006749867461621761, -0.0007202214328572154, -0.026892589405179024, 0.005658967420458794, -0.05298303812742233, 0.045375656336545944, 0.05147858336567879, 0.024882925674319267, -0.06742369383573532, -0.018726419657468796, -0.010172205977141857, -0.04592657834291458, -0.015744756907224655, -0.05312281474471092, 0.00536694098263979, -0.03558376431465149, 0.03899393975734711, -0.026194365695118904, 0.04928257316350937, 0.00906522385776043, 0.004699363373219967, -0.006857930216938257, 0.08316110819578171, 0.044919826090335846, -0.018271025270223618, -0.08163094520568848, 0.018040357157588005, -0.018801545724272728, 0.02604258805513382, -0.06477697938680649, -0.009051195345818996, -0.022602414712309837, -0.03383869305253029, 0.010478630661964417, 0.0050743031315505505, 0.020746640861034393, -0.009722182527184486, 0.0007516818586736917, -0.027758531272411346, -0.0184235330671072, 0.0006725415587425232, -0.05319511145353317, 0.05739494040608406, -0.02074480429291725, 0.02398166060447693, 0.030839627608656883, 0.007630225736647844, 0.0005770763382315636, 0.045515965670347214, -0.030148658901453018, -0.014224805869162083, 0.04505850747227669, -0.006171099375933409, -0.020932169631123543, 0.014668595045804977, 0.016710810363292694, 0.024557381868362427, -0.02256638929247856, 0.006370974704623222, 0.014591632410883904, 0.02636841870844364, -0.02548866532742977, 0.0015055104158818722, 0.01963440701365471, -0.045050084590911865, 0.014248724095523357, -0.009400831535458565, 0.026922354474663734, -0.030484283342957497, -0.05647667124867439, -0.09129883348941803, 0.026280172169208527, 0.06208691745996475, 0.008704639039933681, -0.00654872041195631, 0.007163147907704115, 0.07275000959634781, -0.029401468113064766, 0.029970016330480576, -0.02103523537516594, -0.0034143191296607256, 0.004076385870575905, -0.033167220652103424, -0.013386950828135014, -0.025725804269313812, 0.06876950711011887, 0.04194849357008934, -0.017787892371416092, -0.021987907588481903, -0.054062195122241974, -0.01953941397368908, -0.037929143756628036, -0.04663805663585663, 0.011505970731377602, -0.007767575792968273, 0.003748547285795212, 0.05917676165699959, -0.0550435371696949, -0.052090469747781754, 0.03880564123392105, 0.01053707581013441, 0.02158926986157894, 0.03622462972998619, 0.020653819665312767, 0.0069559658877551556, -0.031010394915938377, -0.057035863399505615, -0.07252202183008194, 0.031141797080636024, -0.01685357838869095, 0.015184870921075344, -0.0477776862680912, -0.028611060231924057, 0.05411701649427414, 0.014502442441880703, -0.007905320264399052, 0.018988382071256638, 0.0072671459056437016, -0.01196150854229927, 0.03614280745387077, 0.03834756836295128, 0.06690863519906998, -0.0059861172921955585, -0.02681048959493637, -0.0032653026282787323, -0.028267337009310722, -0.013038246892392635, -0.012731059454381466, 0.0060532353818416595, -0.004683516453951597, 0.0018545587081462145, 0.0047292886301875114, -0.029162833467125893, 0.02314513735473156, 0.027768166735768318, 0.00471605034545064, -0.05849450081586838, -0.005041231866925955, -0.029837939888238907, 0.00831827986985445, 0.01663610339164734, -0.025897767394781113, -0.0036674956791102886, -0.073350690305233, 0.043272603303194046, 0.013301324099302292, 0.048247456550598145, 0.02439741976559162, 0.011974967084825039, 0.09437821060419083, 0.020056793466210365, 0.009643138386309147, 0.02262534201145172, 0.0794370025396347, 0.013730027712881565, 0.04135304316878319, -0.0284590981900692, -0.00946100801229477, -0.00027632873388938606, -0.024508031085133553, -0.014276985079050064, -0.020176682621240616, 0.036789990961551666, -0.007577757816761732, -0.07868437469005585, -0.056067291647195816, 0.009292786940932274, -0.05123145878314972, 0.058337729424238205, 0.010007704608142376, -0.022614171728491783, 0.07482898980379105, -0.01376429758965969, 0.033161405473947525, 0.003302666125819087, -0.04865007847547531, -0.0033113297540694475, 0.012532162480056286, 0.016545845195651054, 0.028840506449341774, 0.0008708742680028081, 0.0003980831243097782, -0.053413860499858856, -0.003595815971493721, 0.008589398115873337, -0.0626554861664772, -0.02217329666018486, 0.028483830392360687, -0.036250967532396317, 0.005443159490823746, -0.021474340930581093, 0.02245882712304592, 0.029213223606348038, -0.03943370655179024, -0.0023201678413897753, 0.03314414620399475, -0.03683943301439285, 0.011746746487915516, -0.009265255182981491, 0.005172650329768658, -0.02641693316400051, -0.05618186667561531, 0.054717157036066055, 0.015571873635053635, -0.018961558118462563, -0.010998142883181572, 0.017790475860238075, -0.02163982018828392, 0.06374861299991608, 0.05403419956564903, -0.012078575789928436, -0.02153806947171688, 0.04019312188029289, -0.08933591842651367, -0.044955261051654816, 0.013529417105019093, 0.01669110171496868, 0.03013603202998638, -0.018945051357150078, -0.0550769604742527, 0.04234600439667702, -0.03620687499642372, -0.00004292806625016965, 0.0020381249487400055, -0.0429341159760952, 0.006405207794159651, -0.010208796709775925, 0.011098607443273067, 0.03671540319919586, -0.03380630537867546, -0.03426303341984749, 0.02440458908677101, 0.00889914482831955, 0.02143954671919346, 0.048001978546381, -0.033336091786623, 0.01775975525379181, 0.002207523910328746, 0.024676060304045677, 0.07561178505420685, -0.059721678495407104, -0.007730651646852493, -0.0034845087211579084, -0.038153473287820816, -0.019763361662626266, 0.02915266901254654, 0.0016879687318578362, 0.05274443328380585, -0.034452494233846664, -0.017544949427247047, 0.02532605640590191, -0.013712265528738499, -0.019942693412303925, 0.01938524842262268, 0.003947317600250244, 0.012023521587252617, -0.002831061603501439, 0.027051730081439018, -0.05311594530940056, -0.029175376519560814, 0.03618209436535835, 0.005701769143342972, -0.03589634224772453, 0.026127953082323074, 0.01583791896700859, -0.004121850710362196, 0.04267362132668495, 0.11171341687440872, -0.010075025260448456, -0.008737237192690372, -0.03515609726309776, 0.03117358684539795, 0.06544505059719086, -0.003721107030287385, 0.033304013311862946, -0.009278270415961742, 0.042734820395708084, 0.054924167692661285, 0.0066250902600586414, -0.0027422590646892786, 0.014129339717328548, 0.03078206069767475, -0.05045732483267784, -0.015997732058167458, -0.06371470540761948, -0.012596948072314262, 0.032032307237386703, -0.06586577743291855, 0.041640132665634155, -0.04183739796280861, -0.020763877779245377, -0.0440179705619812, -0.0075906808488070965, 0.005135903600603342, 0.021019630134105682, -0.011045679450035095, 0.017225006595253944, -0.003517552511766553, -0.07450242340564728, -0.04434317722916603, -0.023476101458072662, 0.007262316532433033, 0.0021510072983801365, -0.014007296413183212, -0.016818000003695488, 0.015324471518397331, 0.014191549271345139, -0.005963169503957033, -0.0037256234791129827, -0.0371917225420475, 0.042119354009628296, -0.0035110909957438707, -0.006708428263664246, -0.02387605793774128, 0.03937092050909996, -0.01714940182864666, 0.041533213108778, -0.0642189234495163, -0.033105384558439255, 0.009059794247150421, 0.04674892500042915, 0.053577423095703125, -0.032586757093667984, -0.03781738132238388, -0.01687135174870491, 0.061566244810819626, -0.05020831525325775, -0.0031166092958301306, 0.0022472955752164125, -0.03895823284983635, -0.054114196449518204, 0.038417667150497437, -0.003215355798602104, -0.03181840479373932, -0.06030146777629852, 0.061394065618515015, 0.02841457538306713, 0.08697304129600525, -0.014573588036000729, 0.014445730485022068, -0.02638847567141056, 0.008937289007008076, 0.006021026521921158, 0.019034959375858307, 0.0021819425746798515, 0.00780434999614954, -0.06349040567874908, 0.00290660816244781, -0.03590850532054901, 0.036472346633672714, 0.00966222956776619, -0.07550967484712601, 0.025022491812705994, -0.015700161457061768, 0.03308390825986862, -0.013723648153245449, -0.0437765009701252, -0.0023746350780129433, -0.0010305282194167376, 0.003849720349535346, -0.06857699155807495, 0.002319058170542121, -0.03364115580916405, 0.06330713629722595, 0.04854999855160713, 0.012074531055986881, -0.009449130855500698, -0.08366979658603668, 0.03297668695449829, 0.038169026374816895, -0.036955226212739944, 0.07316429913043976, -0.00494593707844615, 0.02181747741997242, 0.026081956923007965, 0.03051200695335865, 0.04989754781126976, 0.04526008665561676, -0.005010932218283415, -0.0222838893532753, -0.0820607841014862, -0.04032913222908974, -0.031027331948280334, -0.0027651838026940823, -0.0066626970656216145, -0.007352708373218775, 0.008847937919199467, 0.053394995629787445, 0.051809996366500854, -0.015343942679464817, 0.0757729560136795, -0.0007235629018396139, 0.016466334462165833, 0.013870940543711185, 0.020027969032526016, -0.004602161701768637, 0.037777066230773926, -0.04435297101736069, -0.018991954624652863, 0.0012974230339750648, -0.08015666902065277, -0.04257461801171303, -0.09179110825061798, 0.040410060435533524, -0.04723387956619263, 0.03101733885705471, -0.03308864310383797, 0.03878312557935715, 0.02275257185101509, -0.008904672227799892, 0.02145497128367424, 0.009373681619763374, 0.05447520315647125, -0.07694842666387558, -0.024229077622294426, 0.0012942837784066796, -0.05208978056907654, -0.014026913791894913, -0.03127587214112282, 0.01626003533601761, 0.09377720206975937, 0.03237272799015045, 0.03419172391295433, -0.02130608633160591, 0.03473315387964249, 0.05210558697581291, -0.022526754066348076, -0.03421448543667793, 0.02964726835489273, -0.001279482850804925, 0.013590151444077492, 0.033106107264757156, 0.023661846294999123, -0.043571680784225464, 0.0002434592170175165, 0.06194997578859329, 0.037864651530981064, -0.004784477408975363, -0.009824425913393497, 0.02941915951669216, 0.01111459732055664, -0.03205834701657295, 0.004200739320367575, 0.02143944427371025, -0.00009664375829743221, -0.026427119970321655, -0.01916513405740261, -0.030635029077529907, 0.07319695502519608, 0.012684129178524017, -0.015628963708877563, 0.0314137227833271, -0.04073093459010124, 0.02635621838271618, -0.01499200239777565, 0.09272929280996323, -0.005862697027623653, -0.026662040501832962, 0.01957036927342415, 0.04612872377038002, 0.03052832931280136, 0.045970503240823746, 0.013315033167600632, 0.027804799377918243, 0.05314149707555771, -0.04734986647963524, -0.07019946724176407, -0.006353341042995453, 0.028622867539525032, 0.028029855340719223, -0.0743064284324646, 0.0319909043610096, 0.020164573565125465, 0.008793255314230919, -0.0016922034556046128, 0.03695984184741974, -0.037647221237421036, -0.019789285957813263, 0.008534717373549938, -0.019135916605591774, -0.01793566159904003, 0.013964299112558365, 0.005690906662493944, -0.01638726145029068, -0.05362768843770027, 0.02046612650156021, -0.021075701341032982, -0.02786407805979252, 0.025963466614484787, -0.010498205199837685, -0.03924917057156563, 0.045987535268068314, -0.020910685881972313, 0.034114591777324677, 0.005325077101588249, -0.028135374188423157, 0.0019207504810765386, -0.0014646003255620599, -0.014664312824606895, -0.010923270136117935, 0.07336347550153732, -0.008099733851850033, 0.08318208903074265, -0.0511174201965332, 0.007491215597838163, 0.008522100746631622, -0.032927628606557846, 0.03902234509587288, 0.0019140413496643305, -0.020314328372478485, -0.01414641086012125, 0.056597016751766205, 0.006497337017208338, 0.018164025619626045, 0.008930599316954613, -0.008398707024753094, -0.005560982972383499, 0.060759130865335464, -0.015327241271734238, -0.03040657937526703, 0.03449343889951706, 0.035745128989219666, -0.025881951674818993, -0.020211929455399513, -0.023227140307426453, 0.059270549565553665, -0.08349122852087021, 0.045622605830430984, -0.011489314958453178, -0.04173760116100311, -0.0019238603999838233, -0.015288221649825573, -0.0660732164978981, 0.0003309387539047748, -0.008092228323221207, 0.0918075367808342, -0.018442073836922646, 0.06307576596736908, 0.04222267121076584, 0.13831470906734467, -0.019474130123853683, 0.008635139092803001, -0.005113144405186176, 0.033872053027153015, -0.048930566757917404, -0.049233727157115936, 0.04794470593333244, 0.024750353768467903, -0.08519692718982697, 0.030825309455394745, 0.0370497889816761, -0.040849342942237854, -0.023302320390939713, 0.005380124319344759, 0.051322564482688904, 0.0011528858449310064, -0.0038649782072752714, -0.07700298726558685, 0.05938505008816719, -0.046369001269340515, -0.024035608395934105, 0.02411975897848606, 0.030104167759418488, 0.013409562408924103, 0.002306079724803567, 0.04550548270344734, 0.0037080964539200068, 0.04834004119038582, -0.030782895162701607, 0.003410270204767585, 0.04026537016034126, 0.04460743069648743, -0.014953666366636753, -0.003676059888675809, 0.03786958381533623, 0.020022237673401833, -0.05877577140927315, -0.015447705052793026, 0.015703734010457993, -0.008760474622249603, 0.018850307911634445, 0.0008388697169721127, -0.05357230827212334, -0.00766595546156168, -0.017015693709254265, 0.014090929180383682, -0.04760625958442688, 0.009354853071272373, 0.03430619090795517, 0.0039601377211511135, -0.03270398825407028, 0.021935168653726578, -0.017885958775877953, -0.031183216720819473, -0.023417511954903603, 0.008491202257573605, 0.01636464148759842, -0.03774520754814148, 0.03759641572833061, -0.024715222418308258, 0.022444728761911392, -0.011061071418225765, -0.0499274805188179, 0.005567209795117378, 0.06211487948894501, 0.01932424306869507, -0.0723099634051323, 0.016246357932686806, -0.07002872228622437, -0.01863045245409012, -0.010583966039121151, 0.024124667048454285, -0.01400635577738285, 0.02148880623281002, 0.010055582039058208, 0.013091805391013622, 0.00653771823272109, -0.038986075669527054, 0.006021133158355951, -0.05452951043844223, -0.04934028163552284, -0.01162323821336031, 0.03127243369817734, -0.05490132048726082, -0.022059081122279167, -0.024919098243117332, -0.0328599251806736, 0.008844221942126751, -0.05422819405794144, 0.0019064467633143067, -0.06162869930267334, -0.051652222871780396, 0.002501528011634946, 0.028787938877940178, -0.02098969928920269, -0.0029187893960624933, 0.021580977365374565, -0.07405251264572144, 0.02041012793779373, -0.020070023834705353, -0.03390493243932724, -0.049791015684604645, -0.034040678292512894, -0.053190771490335464, 0.047424379736185074, -0.02498062700033188, -0.01647164672613144, 0.0622151754796505, 0.07467088103294373, 0.0020315914880484343, -0.05189710855484009, 0.018741104751825333, -0.017988834530115128, 0.036219578236341476, -0.019522320479154587, -0.06076856702566147, 0.006351873744279146, 0.009641038253903389, -0.00929616205394268, 0.03686858341097832, -0.03954910486936569, 0.0038627972826361656, -0.04608377814292908, 0.04107413813471794, 0.0015870875213295221, -0.046303268522024155, -0.016052326187491417, -0.0159654188901186 ]
<p>I mean, when you have a full bathtub and then let it empty, under what conditions does a whirlpool form?</p> <p>Could we devise an experiment and measure this effect? When it comes to fluids, I don't know why I can't think of anything to test a hypothesis.</p>
g135
[ 0.0011538526741787791, 0.02975357696413994, -0.0025195360649377108, -0.07615534216165543, -0.007153638172894716, 0.02268354780972004, 0.031235022470355034, 0.03290312737226486, -0.00985716376453638, -0.04872694984078407, -0.020583469420671463, -0.031168049201369286, 0.026884350925683975, 0.05209708586335182, -0.02086605876684189, -0.005517510697245598, 0.0278727225959301, -0.04842967540025711, 0.007231858558952808, 0.018335040658712387, 0.002386979293078184, -0.01950424164533615, 0.003084255615249276, 0.03346552699804306, -0.06838183104991913, 0.054276421666145325, -0.04041256755590439, 0.0039627025835216045, 0.0067887939512729645, 0.04447386413812637, -0.04103460907936096, 0.018117107450962067, -0.03486134111881256, -0.02519882656633854, -0.07871231436729431, -0.023493565618991852, -0.006785787642002106, -0.03810952231287956, 0.015369987115263939, -0.027797821909189224, -0.026808153837919235, 0.07319948822259903, -0.0012193601578474045, -0.0023265588097274303, -0.02908039651811123, 0.0364639088511467, -0.03780268877744675, 0.006128756795078516, -0.016337810084223747, -0.043245553970336914, -0.02667779102921486, -0.027345923706889153, 0.006219516042619944, 0.017427800223231316, 0.022003507241606712, -0.051921308040618896, 0.021627778187394142, 0.011094605550169945, 0.054126840084791183, 0.04665125533938408, -0.023237133398652077, -0.002846810035407543, 0.01948615536093712, -0.01464419811964035, 0.02445395477116108, 0.026849130168557167, -0.05681724473834038, -0.01839827559888363, 0.06283809244632721, 0.018013572320342064, 0.004699935205280781, -0.027995401993393898, -0.01505835261195898, -0.03450116887688637, -0.018508251756429672, 0.10163808614015579, -0.029715992510318756, 0.02508935146033764, 0.06258466839790344, -0.019058598205447197, 0.041841089725494385, 0.049589239060878754, -0.02189735695719719, -0.0027295334730297327, 0.011531451717019081, 0.017668701708316803, -0.003202298656105995, -0.036244701594114304, 0.01931620016694069, 0.04475342482328415, -0.0042159357108175755, -0.03290945664048195, 0.029475243762135506, -0.005437348037958145, -0.0037621995434165, -0.010661918669939041, 0.044912680983543396, 0.03156468644738197, -0.01880151778459549, 0.035060182213783264, -0.006251784041523933, 0.050519026815891266, 0.0120304049924016, -0.06716526299715042, -0.006394499912858009, -0.014675064012408257, -0.03770231455564499, -0.011307872831821442, -0.00007587957952637225, -0.042143866419792175, -0.039266642183065414, -0.0004563355178106576, -0.04323188215494156, 0.09428004920482635, 0.00485495338216424, -0.03599155321717262, 0.06253355741500854, 0.011343618854880333, -0.01695818081498146, 0.019316986203193665, 0.03776625171303749, 0.025577576830983162, -0.03753542900085449, 0.06028546392917633, 0.01648648828268051, 0.044859226793050766, -0.04603993892669678, 0.04326588660478592, 0.007175580132752657, 0.048768188804388046, 0.02530112862586975, 0.006721981801092625, -0.08847995847463608, -0.01661839708685875, 0.0862341895699501, 0.030671393498778343, -0.02203678898513317, -0.028224773705005646, -0.0009990789694711566, -0.03120911307632923, 0.04339965060353279, -0.02087523601949215, 0.00673277722671628, 0.021058540791273117, 0.04854217916727066, -0.006729475222527981, -0.007250560447573662, 0.04502668231725693, 0.004508123267441988, 0.05606261268258095, -0.05515062436461449, -0.0076970322988927364, 0.013680882751941681, -0.01290354784578085, 0.05325154960155487, -0.004093694034963846, -0.02890137769281864, -0.024184510111808777, 0.05240580067038536, 0.022303501144051552, -0.012341530993580818, -0.03612884134054184, 0.05165624991059303, 0.010118082165718079, -0.05500156059861183, 0.03270368650555611, 0.003568232525140047, 0.01684047095477581, -0.007668502163141966, -0.03818370774388313, -0.10111408680677414, -0.06265793740749359, -0.022153906524181366, 0.0715055912733078, 0.013500260189175606, 0.013918329030275345, 0.01271928008645773, -0.028556810691952705, 0.08408337086439133, 0.038881730288267136, 0.008744749240577221, -0.023612130433321, -0.00045927613973617554, -0.08174688369035721, 0.007029798347502947, 0.023786870762705803, -0.023790674284100533, 0.0019855268765240908, -0.08008228242397308, -0.023635588586330414, 0.01707935892045498, -0.03989231586456299, 0.03106597438454628, 0.012420512735843658, -0.014036782085895538, -0.05761463940143585, 0.005297380965203047, -0.03916438668966293, -0.013555587269365788, 0.01769266650080681, 0.005307435058057308, 0.018879957497119904, 0.07197888195514679, 0.04335172474384308, -0.03532544523477554, -0.005589868873357773, 0.0004620333784259856, 0.059760212898254395, 0.05652962625026703, -0.05182533711194992, 0.06265004724264145, 0.046425867825746536, 0.005918745882809162, 0.05393358692526817, -0.018465889617800713, 0.025092557072639465, -0.021575257182121277, 0.03005496971309185, -0.003508424386382103, 0.025511516258120537, 0.046344153583049774, -0.010778809897601604, -0.03625544160604477, 0.015551000833511353, -0.009440086781978607, -0.02050069160759449, -0.06071358919143677, -0.041001711040735245, -0.05440976098179817, -0.012461201287806034, 0.03969383239746094, -0.06748376786708832, 0.04726947098970413, -0.032074496150016785, 0.04114765673875809, 0.07338333874940872, 0.012166245840489864, -0.02933228574693203, 0.011530156247317791, -0.016049083322286606, -0.00918528065085411, -0.00437965989112854, -0.010816220194101334, -0.0018511932576075196, -0.001043362426571548, -0.0764208659529686, -0.036592449992895126, -0.0030473582446575165, 0.0832609012722969, 0.005724689923226833, -0.003919653594493866, -0.006351906340569258, 0.030203374102711678, 0.004400002304464579, -0.024297572672367096, -0.0029433192685246468, 0.00334866507910192, 0.06602299958467484, -0.06790860742330551, -0.06380859017372131, -0.0053712292574346066, 0.0016340936999768019, -0.0015197033062577248, 0.031180568039417267, 0.018886491656303406, -0.02062416262924671, -0.03878886252641678, -0.01851401850581169, 0.011935588903725147, 0.04820142313838005, 0.00031020757160149515, 0.025253988802433014, -0.029294107109308243, -0.006149803288280964, -0.029738908633589745, 0.0402432382106781, 0.010586848482489586, -0.021154357120394707, 0.04664996266365051, -0.030283248052001, -0.05025726929306984, 0.031049299985170364, -0.04404700547456741, 0.070075623691082, -0.022503843531012535, -0.036150749772787094, 0.02686324715614319, -0.027052544057369232, -0.004178348463028669, 0.006535624619573355, 0.04264012351632118, 0.0036709136329591274, -0.010012812912464142, 0.013673446141183376, 0.0026804301887750626, 0.05995822325348854, 0.0485750250518322, -0.03167439252138138, -0.01364886574447155, -0.003574185539036989, -0.02290842868387699, 0.027611995115876198, 0.021470267325639725, -0.015400206670165062, -0.026142867282032967, 0.023297378793358803, -0.009699640795588493, -0.01583910547196865, -0.021902838721871376, 0.007976128719747066, -0.020977891981601715, 0.028012847527861595, -0.02544374391436577, 0.00761814508587122, -0.02157372608780861, 0.03838187828660011, 0.052011638879776, -0.038085564970970154, 0.04258481413125992, -0.020793123170733452, 0.04171127825975418, 0.0023759661708027124, -0.0011065421858802438, 0.034859832376241684, -0.009346631355583668, 0.01473669521510601, 0.02751457877457142, -0.0019458276219666004, -0.08068762719631195, -0.028420554473996162, 0.008054062724113464, -0.028450604528188705, 0.01869850419461727, 0.004478862974792719, 0.009561826474964619, 0.007423801347613335, 0.00452833715826273, 0.04925290122628212, -0.019616737961769104, 0.04407843202352524, -0.006044465117156506, -0.03638937324285507, 0.01491964515298605, 0.00961348321288824, -0.03290436044335365, 0.05819635093212128, -0.007033166009932756, -0.02357790246605873, 0.05707452446222305, 0.016180692240595818, 0.07678130269050598, -0.014601928181946278, -0.00928277987986803, -0.07561106234788895, -0.005630258470773697, -0.0004562670656014234, 0.07762943208217621, 0.01762426272034645, 0.006467104889452457, -0.0016781541053205729, -0.004196639638394117, -0.07072851806879044, -0.004004041198641062, -0.07023917883634567, 0.0023032661993056536, 0.05279429629445076, 0.012287097983062267, 0.06654776632785797, -0.03928286209702492, -0.019952494651079178, -0.04924801364541054, 0.022124042734503746, -0.04989418387413025, 0.023071441799402237, 0.0425657257437706, 0.03968123719096184, 0.08516554534435272, 0.01716471090912819, -0.010467130690813065, 0.022290827706456184, 0.08287984877824783, 0.02731340378522873, -0.026427477598190308, -0.021695982664823532, -0.054063525050878525, -0.024548646062612534, -0.03519662469625473, 0.009842759929597378, -0.034637127071619034, -0.024262700229883194, 0.05453082546591759, 0.01831790618598461, 0.0023238076828420162, -0.038610316812992096, -0.013974894769489765, 0.021352866664528847, -0.013635535724461079, -0.0037612649612128735, -0.042320653796195984, -0.02156059630215168, -0.02488839067518711, 0.026438917964696884, -0.002796393586322665, 0.013764701783657074, 0.040528491139411926, -0.06064781919121742, 0.05746933072805405, -0.013747554272413254, -0.023263506591320038, -0.03069603256881237, -0.001593568827956915, -0.017207510769367218, -0.027409110218286514, -0.009996755979955196, -0.02093145251274109, -0.011924060061573982, -0.0017978916876018047, -0.0008903729030862451, 0.006201650947332382, 0.0065992469899356365, 0.036382704973220825, 0.0029608006589114666, -0.039840105921030045, 0.016336508095264435, -0.02100486122071743, -0.05069739371538162, -0.059480272233486176, -0.014616770669817924, -0.01985822059214115, -0.06693977117538452, 0.01920287124812603, -0.005255252588540316, -0.01769726164638996, 0.008868962526321411, 0.008670683018863201, -0.0026555638760328293, -0.02958131954073906, 0.04387471824884415, -0.046875134110450745, -0.004277336876839399, 0.02610158734023571, -0.003757793689146638, 0.013398607261478901, 0.034075021743774414, -0.0001651948841754347, 0.0824219286441803, 0.05206151679158211, -0.04952431097626686, 0.014579622074961662, 0.01778167299926281, -0.057346802204847336, 0.03683582320809364, -0.005617693532258272, -0.051679808646440506, -0.02037653513252735, 0.013948129490017891, 0.025737950578331947, 0.032625067979097366, -0.04248463362455368, 0.10948240756988525, -0.051265716552734375, -0.04003763198852539, -0.023324670270085335, 0.033012110739946365, 0.005374245345592499, -0.04409448429942131, 0.056895118206739426, -0.09828366339206696, -0.08746271580457687, 0.037191979587078094, 0.0014773305738344789, 0.0752507671713829, 0.026862436905503273, 0.07560563832521439, -0.001522979699075222, -0.029125379398465157, -0.010361219756305218, -0.016087135300040245, -0.010714277625083923, -0.02979174070060253, -0.018584299832582474, 0.010744525119662285, 0.05763974413275719, -0.015104972757399082, -0.0047568874433636665, 0.0057778628543019295, -0.03769516572356224, 0.039407599717378616, 0.011679833754897118, -0.050468116998672485, 0.000653161492664367, 0.07032081484794617, -0.022616446018218994, -0.02838936075568199, -0.02597956173121929, -0.03896327316761017, -0.015656577423214912, -0.04061415046453476, 0.0064099938608706, 0.03484604135155678, -0.008181216195225716, 0.060082655400037766, 0.0009564310894347727, -0.010385333560407162, -0.002779634902253747, 0.06392879039049149, -0.05147337168455124, -0.051309652626514435, -0.03617415577173233, 0.009373238310217857, -0.016130607575178146, 0.058967225253582, -0.08219590038061142, -0.02217046171426773, 0.1089945137500763, -0.000628292269539088, -0.007143744267523289, -0.02714608609676361, -0.025860056281089783, 0.032585643231868744, 0.007189176976680756, -0.014152763411402702, 0.00917126890271902, 0.0076329270377755165, -0.03180665522813797, 0.05617457628250122, -0.0860041156411171, -0.00046727462904527783, 0.02657984383404255, 0.021265892311930656, 0.02305518463253975, 0.017484674230217934, 0.020328033715486526, 0.024460403248667717, 0.009603177197277546, -0.047713860869407654, 0.025038234889507294, 0.014541800133883953, 0.055972207337617874, 0.0003221153747290373, 0.02447018399834633, -0.011328734457492828, 0.008966871537268162, 0.037587616592645645, 0.04966384544968605, -0.009405496530234814, -0.007690368220210075, -0.03954014182090759, 0.030139485374093056, -0.017529066652059555, -0.03337745741009712, 0.026571352034807205, -0.020272016525268555, 0.057553816586732864, -0.027851112186908722, -0.03264560177922249, -0.011782878078520298, -0.026060085743665695, -0.027888858690857887, 0.0034472658298909664, 0.030338214710354805, 0.0707828551530838, 0.061928145587444305, -0.02981380932033062, -0.013506777584552765, 0.02093333937227726, -0.01961016096174717, 0.024978630244731903, 0.05031794309616089, 0.05309998244047165, 0.00044816898298449814, -0.048250459134578705, 0.06298142671585083, -0.10781251639127731, -0.00779133103787899, -0.014261511154472828, 0.0019981623627245426, 0.03385490924119949, 0.039246559143066406, -0.0037446690257638693, 0.003664672840386629, -0.05587734654545784, 0.01791679486632347, 0.06606380641460419, 0.00032318432931788266, 0.02724103443324566, 0.030074624344706535, 0.013662288896739483, 0.0042069898918271065, 0.02332223765552044, -0.06455602496862411, 0.009249670431017876, -0.015623243525624275, -0.056770168244838715, 0.04501192644238472, -0.01776120439171791, -0.008438675664365292, -0.048410240560770035, -0.024414565414190292, 0.03390863165259361, -0.02512090466916561, 0.020639607682824135, -0.01663568802177906, -0.030292240902781487, -0.019405759871006012, 0.019296154379844666, 0.01351490244269371, -0.006237619556486607, -0.007557301316410303, 0.019662877544760704, -0.03421035408973694, 0.03305117413401604, 0.044071655720472336, -0.05661766603589058, -0.01591072417795658, -0.038694094866514206, 0.028351178392767906, -0.023382004350423813, 0.0819912776350975, 0.06379963457584381, 0.01952437125146389, -0.08390332758426666, 0.023213470354676247, -0.0801687240600586, 0.01160997711122036, 0.03728899359703064, -0.061226945370435715, 0.00467591593042016, 0.010635415092110634, 0.023588351905345917, -0.022502686828374863, -0.025761466473340988, -0.04756488278508186, -0.0013595031341537833, -0.07470207661390305, 0.0006391247734427452, -0.022994378581643105, 0.010379670187830925, 0.056424062699079514, 0.030459798872470856, 0.04581112787127495, 0.03672752529382706, -0.015592427924275398, 0.04085789993405342, -0.018646854907274246, 0.020930364727973938, 0.03612858057022095, -0.00984259881079197, -0.04334203898906708, 0.0257221981883049, 0.011195868253707886, -0.040179263800382614, -0.05189201608300209, 0.005223799962550402, -0.01875411719083786, 0.019659239798784256, -0.022799566388130188, -0.0018199440091848373, -0.026489069685339928, -0.017192276194691658, 0.030414363369345665, 0.030903717502951622, 0.027365097776055336, 0.03951862454414368, -0.03579108044505119, 0.0029556569643318653, 0.058016739785671234, 0.008697609417140484, 0.04772936925292015, 0.0023823699448257685, 0.016960298642516136, 0.014672541059553623, 0.000956272182520479, 0.0016908971592783928, 0.06321931630373001, -0.0376378633081913, 0.021233323961496353, 0.028368433937430382, 0.020541362464427948, 0.0052467514760792255, -0.0367312990128994, -0.03621187433600426, -0.00657454552128911, 0.022266212850809097, -0.06876389682292938, 0.013205860741436481, -0.02214975841343403, -0.007854320108890533, -0.03297269716858864, -0.0256503839045763, 0.0009457770502194762, 0.05583319813013077, 0.029425472021102905, -0.04193306341767311, -0.027434907853603363, 0.015961026772856712, 0.04226794093847275, -0.06975463032722473, 0.0029872835148125887, -0.004962090868502855, -0.004013973753899336, 0.013363809324800968, -0.008426512591540813, -0.013528259471058846, -0.03919040784239769, -0.004497920162975788, -0.061649877578020096, 0.020947925746440887, -0.09039786458015442, -0.037137746810913086, 0.011019955389201641, 0.058453816920518875, 0.0007593901245854795, -0.008697722107172012, 0.02494315803050995, -0.034085147082805634, -0.061045464128255844, -0.057217758148908615, 0.04285194352269173, 0.003701126668602228, -0.04365412890911102, -0.017224419862031937, -0.022419171407818794, -0.049170151352882385, 0.007322812918573618, 0.021565504372119904, -0.03584212064743042, -0.013086107559502125, -0.07445890456438065, -0.016016071662306786, -0.029813455417752266, -0.015144262462854385, -0.010195761919021606, -0.008553535677492619, 0.03694305941462517, -0.03021322935819626, 0.060446642339229584, -0.004908521194010973, -0.0338163897395134, -0.020081551745533943, -0.02383296564221382, 0.02061440981924534, 0.024611134082078934, -0.06913889944553375, 0.03279595449566841, -0.000032518051739316434, -0.03725430741906166, 0.05401942878961563, 0.03380560502409935, -0.08572369813919067, -0.0019839489832520485, 0.002681188052520156, 0.0282495878636837, 0.038288045674562454, 0.0467892661690712, -0.065501868724823, -0.08246729522943497, 0.029476633295416832, -0.02920127660036087, 0.033441703766584396, 0.014071723446249962, 0.013246803544461727, 0.0022601864766329527, 0.0030864800792187452, 0.012211227789521217, -0.010339518077671528, 0.03296972066164017, -0.014148096553981304 ]
<p>About a year ago I attended a talk at the University of Ottawa. The author described a method for achieving super time resolution images of a neuron firing. From what I can recall, the group found a small protein that acted as a photovoltaic cell (produced a voltage pulse in response to a photon) and engineered it to run in reverse, emitting a photon when it was subjected to a voltage pulse. They then cause this to be expressed in neurons, and were able to image action potentials moving through the network, heralded by emitted light from these proteins. Super resolution was achieved by careful timing and a lot of averaging. </p> <p>I have looked high and low for this paper for about a week now, with no luck. I don't remember the speaker's name (though he was a pretty young guy, a new prof at the time if I recall). If anyone is familiar with the research and can link me to the paper I would be very grateful.</p>
g5843
[ 0.05444638058543205, 0.0723797157406807, 0.010619079694151878, 0.005042102187871933, 0.039958007633686066, -0.07905028760433197, 0.008810367435216904, 0.018544098362326622, -0.027445022016763687, 0.01186349056661129, 0.015551756136119366, 0.067552350461483, 0.01834634505212307, -0.009159593842923641, -0.01526462472975254, -0.06428449600934982, 0.0647238940000534, -0.012659077532589436, -0.03281816467642784, -0.00673189340159297, 0.020001191645860672, 0.007066409569233656, -0.004133314825594425, 0.006457456853240728, -0.009696714580059052, 0.04038438946008682, -0.017669763416051865, -0.047473613172769547, -0.021267106756567955, -0.06195228919386864, 0.028147714212536812, -0.08490683883428574, -0.0332796573638916, -0.01231859065592289, -0.0075329807586967945, -0.0065324273891747, 0.008333062753081322, -0.00327168102376163, 0.04141690954566002, 0.0356120802462101, 0.0021788666490465403, -0.006297424901276827, 0.033551398664712906, -0.004777109250426292, 0.042452313005924225, 0.047510385513305664, -0.007614402566105127, -0.028382347896695137, -0.012109409086406231, -0.04524075239896774, 0.018935225903987885, 0.01154360268265009, -0.0302891805768013, -0.013566972687840462, 0.04700580611824989, -0.00866748858243227, -0.031146002933382988, 0.02005809172987938, 0.054018378257751465, 0.015866434201598167, -0.0013205446302890778, 0.01892530545592308, 0.03296557068824768, -0.021731561049818993, 0.040729571133852005, 0.008815621957182884, -0.0006469266954809427, -0.0395854152739048, 0.03569701686501503, -0.027064809575676918, -0.02101762965321541, -0.020751094445586205, -0.03792359307408333, 0.0016341805458068848, 0.10281987488269806, -0.04311716556549072, 0.017115755006670952, -0.05584504455327988, -0.07433272153139114, 0.03979991003870964, -0.04318268969655037, -0.05631913244724274, -0.03958682715892792, 0.03459424898028374, 0.059929605573415756, 0.0319175198674202, -0.009703017771244049, 0.020751098170876503, 0.004939465783536434, 0.03581005707383156, 0.06460488587617874, 0.06192551180720329, 0.0620170421898365, -0.032517239451408386, 0.022090550512075424, 0.029337434098124504, -0.004941102582961321, 0.027745002880692482, 0.0028233304619789124, 0.023021705448627472, -0.05644045025110245, -0.024565327912569046, 0.0421784333884716, -0.0054791150614619255, -0.059935957193374634, 0.015178783796727657, 0.016754616051912308, -0.1028391569852829, -0.028393790125846863, 0.003383033676072955, -0.04718798026442528, -0.05278495326638222, 0.00701966043561697, 0.006445132661610842, -0.0630112737417221, -0.01385847944766283, 0.0329536534845829, 0.037782810628414154, 0.006150277331471443, 0.012998771853744984, 0.034061674028635025, -0.016175396740436554, -0.02512192353606224, 0.0071218619123101234, 0.012774351984262466, 0.009655240923166275, 0.05209137871861458, 0.002098115161061287, -0.015669558197259903, 0.05857463926076889, -0.010124806314706802, 0.022025737911462784, -0.019937163218855858, 0.030999401584267616, 0.005655516870319843, 0.06900849938392639, 0.0021803895942866802, -0.045502640306949615, 0.009089997969567776, 0.014858832582831383, 0.03490874543786049, -0.06100486218929291, -0.01925637200474739, 0.0013855918077751994, 0.03474811837077141, -0.023177023977041245, -0.0014144142623990774, -0.01290612481534481, 0.013173670507967472, 0.0023939895909279585, -0.02174309827387333, 0.025634245947003365, -0.04220011830329895, -0.08456119894981384, 0.05118969827890396, 0.01170750055462122, 0.019106321036815643, 0.004003723617643118, -0.047068577259778976, 0.01718318648636341, 0.0047245146706700325, 0.03681669011712074, -0.016889145597815514, -0.0740877017378807, -0.020289381965994835, -0.09286487102508545, 0.07212086021900177, -0.0549217090010643, -0.004397391341626644, -0.015632014721632004, -0.00046011575614102185, 0.01002203207463026, 0.020759398117661476, 0.03408615663647652, -0.00515994057059288, 0.0377211757004261, 0.04323989897966385, -0.016668740659952164, -0.003897466929629445, 0.013837234117090702, -0.08945900946855545, -0.013029176741838455, -0.048018358647823334, -0.033465512096881866, 0.016811147332191467, 0.022270431742072105, -0.03193357586860657, 0.02777985855937004, 0.005737444385886192, -0.031486086547374725, -0.054272640496492386, 0.0017864881083369255, -0.004886241629719734, -0.05026905983686447, -0.0378619059920311, 0.023278862237930298, 0.023132743313908577, -0.057414568960666656, 0.013876781798899174, 0.002401511650532484, -0.04048769548535347, -0.01816681958734989, 0.018560439348220825, 0.050531283020973206, 0.06425166130065918, -0.014758910983800888, -0.03935997560620308, -0.0160340815782547, 0.007065769750624895, -0.000254751619650051, -0.02120785601437092, 0.026250507682561874, -0.03252393752336502, 0.0201759971678257, -0.05042068660259247, -0.05460613593459129, -0.0030786192510277033, 0.000031651150493416935, 0.06376940757036209, -0.02763994038105011, -0.03413477540016174, 0.017824385315179825, 0.045791931450366974, 0.006678513251245022, -0.0055908323265612125, -0.004440989810973406, 0.008433417417109013, -0.05330289900302887, -0.002301381202414632, 0.022276848554611206, -0.061541154980659485, 0.07521573454141617, -0.010402273386716843, -0.03681709244847298, -0.0014145842287689447, -0.006043343339115381, -0.06374972313642502, 0.03143197298049927, -0.014451594091951847, -0.041341062635183334, -0.00032816140446811914, -0.012175904586911201, -0.056062523275613785, 0.015600292943418026, -0.026094313710927963, 0.003840309102088213, 0.04545899108052254, -0.019280148670077324, -0.023158779367804527, -0.003611830295994878, 0.013842500746250153, -0.04590490460395813, 0.03980347886681557, -0.009827785193920135, 0.004303195979446173, 0.012940675020217896, 0.07840342074632645, 0.03160873055458069, -0.002927797846496105, 0.008780260570347309, 0.03352734073996544, 0.00936008058488369, -0.0013981799129396677, -0.0149987256154418, 0.09242270886898041, -0.043534208089113235, 0.030935557559132576, -0.015593085438013077, -0.043710287660360336, 0.01227131113409996, 0.004515611566603184, 0.026031959801912308, 0.007133947219699621, -0.053065940737724304, -0.011408781632781029, 0.02253088727593422, 0.032175213098526, 0.04648880660533905, 0.04806680232286453, -0.019911158829927444, -0.06901530176401138, -0.06295245885848999, -0.04995318502187729, -0.022087950259447098, -0.006575265433639288, -0.051951345056295395, 0.021759912371635437, 0.025943901389837265, 0.03341970965266228, 0.00477256253361702, -0.05642075464129448, -0.005756122525781393, 0.024139337241649628, -0.020046688616275787, -0.0636194497346878, 0.017516229301691055, 0.08157950639724731, -0.0067146853543818, 0.008633735589683056, 0.02238723449409008, -0.009501513093709946, -0.0005410136072896421, 0.008078753016889095, 0.020620109513401985, 0.044870298355817795, -0.031381700187921524, -0.05577666312456131, 0.02030140534043312, 0.0020252028480172157, 0.05000939965248108, -0.012046253308653831, 0.011426553130149841, -0.010155524127185345, -0.0011789965210482478, 0.01689320243895054, -0.028016945347189903, 0.02619187720119953, -0.02491525001823902, 0.023296168074011803, 0.00996018573641777, 0.004767847713083029, 0.009400413371622562, 0.030662069097161293, 0.019903576001524925, 0.01378154382109642, 0.015330103226006031, -0.057947393506765366, 0.037119824439287186, -0.006512699648737907, -0.005286274943500757, -0.012723882682621479, -0.022506562992930412, 0.005579870194196701, 0.02870161272585392, 0.0345744788646698, -0.029772408306598663, -0.05061952769756317, 0.08262975513935089, 0.04327310621738434, -0.017970645800232887, -0.01915385201573372, -0.04580497741699219, -0.0753408744931221, -0.05366592854261398, 0.07750315219163895, 0.030243946239352226, -0.06118328496813774, -0.034857749938964844, -0.059329405426979065, -0.05927525460720062, 0.029103226959705353, 0.02015998214483261, 0.014797980897128582, -0.0010694167576730251, 0.048140931874513626, 0.03995798900723457, 0.03263010457158089, -0.013408295810222626, -0.020366787910461426, 0.01341793593019247, -0.048736393451690674, 0.004991005640476942, 0.00877736322581768, -0.05707210302352905, 0.01071865763515234, -0.015878446400165558, -0.018222112208604813, 0.05686363950371742, -0.019858943298459053, -0.042633626610040665, 0.022572217509150505, -0.029769016429781914, -0.025402352213859558, 0.009734242223203182, -0.07912256568670273, -0.02544015273451805, -0.06412869691848755, -0.0017506660660728812, 0.00744175910949707, 0.06786184012889862, -0.0462619848549366, 0.03853354603052139, 0.04971229285001755, -0.03138618543744087, 0.04941178113222122, 0.004513198975473642, -0.027937570586800575, -0.0205601304769516, -0.029936302453279495, -0.005185773596167564, -0.03058270737528801, 0.019883854314684868, -0.047295402735471725, -0.054764166474342346, -0.04456314817070961, 0.002261991612613201, 0.0024412856437265873, 0.0033041718415915966, 0.01850680261850357, -0.007535176817327738, 0.005839529447257519, 0.02571730874478817, -0.0030126217752695084, -0.0004046037793159485, -0.0024096316192299128, 0.02081635408103466, 0.017999939620494843, -0.019949613139033318, -0.016856687143445015, 0.027394071221351624, -0.03316278010606766, 0.021862352266907692, 0.012560381554067135, -0.08269263803958893, 0.002573543693870306, 0.05122184753417969, 0.10801632702350616, 0.024459874257445335, -0.031526800245046616, 0.03001270443201065, 0.003448307979851961, 0.05883723124861717, 0.011209839954972267, -0.03076937422156334, -0.011590584181249142, 0.034082893282175064, -0.018917933106422424, -0.0014333919389173388, -0.016688494011759758, 0.014616679400205612, 0.060897767543792725, 0.0006328947492875159, -0.06933270394802094, 0.007539309561252594, -0.020304491743445396, 0.0046004643663764, 0.03629586100578308, 0.013071661815047264, 0.08977727591991425, 0.07835046947002411, 0.08248689770698547, -0.05571514740586281, 0.09816671162843704, -0.030908439308404922, 0.04743504151701927, 0.0628538504242897, -0.023764286190271378, -0.01884377747774124, -0.01896219328045845, 0.028688298538327217, 0.07442640513181686, -0.004417682997882366, -0.006208422593772411, 0.018184861168265343, 0.013434414751827717, -0.02368927001953125, -0.025971919298171997, -0.009724950417876244, 0.042000360786914825, 0.060632143169641495, -0.01637430675327778, -0.02448040246963501, -0.01991223357617855, 0.031631458550691605, 0.061197616159915924, 0.04921506717801094, -0.0556376576423645, -0.02748885378241539, -0.029177304357290268, -0.04889948293566704, 0.00911235623061657, -0.030090665444731712, -0.004336258862167597, 0.0787380188703537, -0.02274835668504238, -0.031173210591077805, 0.011011556722223759, 0.0183205995708704, 0.0690000131726265, 0.03821331262588501, -0.026814600452780724, 0.00850234180688858, -0.007054328452795744, -0.02682974748313427, 0.05310104787349701, 0.005826612934470177, -0.05433320999145508, 0.015570849180221558, -0.008727062493562698, -0.055480435490608215, -0.029231345281004906, -0.018287546932697296, 0.037682581692934036, -0.03569215163588524, 0.04975006356835365, -0.0511600486934185, 0.04333486035466194, 0.03262355923652649, -0.019081423059105873, 0.0317319855093956, -0.025059878826141357, 0.020844072103500366, -0.04472823813557625, -0.0008072440978139639, -0.010402224026620388, 0.02959408611059189, -0.028510333970189095, 0.0064605604857206345, -0.08148349821567535, 0.015609422698616982, -0.048253029584884644, 0.002398007083684206, -0.013911952264606953, 0.0526948980987072, -0.04883242025971413, -0.05294814333319664, -0.02539217658340931, 0.012004613876342773, -0.036605797708034515, -0.07156156748533249, 0.03223280608654022, -0.029363084584474564, -0.008047644048929214, 0.03520255163311958, 0.016705404967069626, 0.03158638998866081, -0.005139579996466637, -0.01728210039436817, 0.09076675027608871, -0.018017351627349854, 0.0006585699738934636, -0.012392641976475716, 0.019802317023277283, -0.012185439467430115, -0.057606592774391174, 0.005017137620598078, 0.04266371205449104, 0.014422863721847534, -0.039544470608234406, -0.046141963452100754, 0.06319216638803482, -0.013975811190903187, 0.031310729682445526, -0.034419018775224686, -0.028352104127407074, -0.010898849926888943, 0.03190917521715164, -0.012963216751813889, -0.03462822362780571, -0.006654568947851658, 0.032293930649757385, -0.007575748488306999, 0.016181131824851036, -0.008653459139168262, -0.00012437674740795046, 0.06538118422031403, -0.016971278935670853, -0.04849019646644592, 0.03375124931335449, 0.025946125388145447, 0.05203208699822426, 0.04510714113712311, -0.021832261234521866, -0.02511276677250862, 0.0066339909099042416, 0.024056700989603996, -0.006337741389870644, -0.01991887576878071, 0.023593151941895485, 0.03513919562101364, 0.06616786122322083, 0.008925773203372955, 0.0004997886135242879, -0.00549235288053751, -0.021978534758090973, -0.0163627490401268, 0.07040970772504807, 0.0032135285437107086, -0.0737675130367279, -0.051530543714761734, 0.006895861122757196, -0.01961977407336235, -0.013916099444031715, -0.017583530396223068, 0.04875786229968071, -0.0732339397072792, 0.02726718783378601, 0.048626042902469635, 0.02020578272640705, -0.053576115518808365, -0.008180560544133186, -0.0468066968023777, -0.08810973912477493, -0.041668087244033813, -0.006038052495568991, -0.00951323751360178, -0.02743626944720745, -0.013855823315680027, -0.04769492149353027, 0.0366346575319767, -0.0028580997604876757, 0.0017094945069402456, -0.013916871510446072, -0.06829039007425308, 0.003557237097993493, 0.07943367213010788, -0.023192960768938065, 0.053550221025943756, 0.0466642826795578, 0.018595336005091667, -0.03141358494758606, -0.02018698863685131, 0.01482539065182209, -0.00761669734492898, 0.03568676859140396, -0.02966710738837719, -0.009100522845983505, -0.04576559737324715, 0.012989362701773643, 0.03148183971643448, 0.026593444868922234, 0.03540104627609253, 0.03785233944654465, 0.02397189661860466, -0.04341902956366539, 0.006399471312761307, 0.012690162286162376, 0.012973910197615623, 0.04709980636835098, 0.07088740170001984, -0.012611901387572289, 0.005798869300633669, 0.015460042282938957, 0.08377756923437119, -0.030924418941140175, -0.000530583958607167, -0.03681298345327377, 0.04281095787882805, 0.025819001719355583, -0.04120158776640892, 0.017183389514684677, 0.003152945777401328, -0.01727938838303089, -0.023305226117372513, -0.004176049493253231, 0.011972528882324696, -0.010473381727933884, 0.016107050701975822, 0.007415585219860077, 0.0019194430205971003, 0.07671168446540833, -0.007088147569447756, -0.0755227729678154, -0.0015408191829919815, -0.03595292195677757, 0.03257947787642479, -0.0006574344588443637, -0.029683008790016174, 0.016303617507219315, -0.029337987303733826, -0.06992600858211517, -0.06150079891085625, -0.01935511641204357, -0.013041063211858273, 0.024030020460486412, 0.02055068127810955, -0.0034082154743373394, 0.023173362016677856, 0.018840065225958824, -0.01038646325469017, 0.035219188779592514, 0.01549767516553402, 0.0026752997655421495, 0.030947523191571236, -0.02300584316253662, -0.0020656639244407415, -0.028131024911999702, 0.08317313343286514, -0.04886573180556297, -0.04680571332573891, 0.019722893834114075, 0.0255565345287323, -0.041509732604026794, -0.0777069628238678, 0.009088299237191677, -0.015580689534544945, -0.031498733907938004, -0.00871649943292141, -0.002504423027858138, 0.004858178552240133, -0.028321847319602966, 0.025327501818537712, -0.013683670200407505, -0.0015547978691756725, 0.02373298816382885, 0.04218735545873642, 0.06235049292445183, 0.01592038944363594, 0.05207456275820732, 0.04524625465273857, 0.00451041990891099, 0.005187359172850847, -0.002335062948986888, 0.021245524287223816, -0.05064278468489647, -0.018874522298574448, -0.014265884645283222, -0.025010189041495323, 0.03725660964846611, -0.017037339508533478, 0.0007698862464167178, 0.020148655399680138, 0.017225876450538635, 0.004043212626129389, 0.03596392273902893, 0.03966404125094414, -0.020820945501327515, 0.016945386305451393, 0.02920662611722946, 0.059617627412080765, -0.008862410672008991, 0.05161840468645096, -0.06056820601224899, -0.009965027682483196, 0.049445249140262604, -0.03523240610957146, 0.01024710014462471, 0.043469227850437164, 0.04532951861619949, -0.029254188761115074, 0.03531188890337944, -0.053468383848667145, -0.0043065813370049, 0.002543248701840639, 0.002040645806118846, 0.007394583895802498, -0.023987548425793648, -0.010472712107002735, 0.0006024143658578396, -0.018389970064163208, -0.012913689017295837, -0.05589241907000542, -0.02566649578511715, -0.07323522120714188, 0.034490086138248444, -0.003451054682955146, -0.0558849461376667, -0.01909441500902176, 0.05062085762619972, -0.047597259283065796, 0.014797746203839779, 0.02808493934571743, -0.045324042439460754, 0.0007587095606140792, 0.06701306253671646, 0.02978290431201458, 0.05071680620312691, 0.056354355067014694, -0.004506130702793598, -0.04727688059210777, -0.06241406872868538, -0.05570601671934128, 0.049460481852293015, 0.00995207205414772, 0.01776062697172165, -0.028207309544086456, 0.02640380710363388, -0.010785580612719059 ]
<p>In Nekrasov et al's series papers <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9803265" rel="nofollow">MNS</a>, they calculate such kinds of integral $$ \frac{E_1 E_2}{N(2\pi i)^N(E_1+E_2) }\oint d\phi_1 \wedge d\phi_2\wedge \ldots\wedge d\phi_N \prod_{i&lt;N} (-\phi_i) \prod_{i}(\phi_i+E_1+E_2) $$ $$\times \frac{\prod_{i\neq j}\phi_{ij} }{\prod_{i}(-\phi_i)(\phi_i+E_1+E_2) }\ {\prod}_{i,j} {{(\phi_{ij} +E_1+E_2)}\over{({\phi}_{ij}+ E_1)(\phi_{ij}+ E_2)}}.\tag{6.4} $$</p> <ol> <li><p>The residues are given by $$\phi_i \rightarrow \phi_{(\alpha,\beta)}=(\alpha-1)E_1+(\beta-1)E_2.\tag{6.9}$$ MNS claims that the evalution of the above integral is equivalent to use of fixed point techniques. They also give some references. I can not understand their trick here after skimming over the references. Can this integral be solved by residue theorem?</p></li> <li><p>In order to calculate the sum of critical points, they use an equality from <a href="http://www.kurims.kyoto-u.ac.jp/~nakajima/" rel="nofollow">Nakajima</a>'s <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0821819569" rel="nofollow">Lecture</a> (Ref. 18): $$ \Sigma_{i,j \in D}[ e^{\phi_{ij}} +e^{\phi_{ij} +E_1+E_2}-e^{\phi_{ij}-E_1}-e^{\phi_{ij}-E_2}] - \Sigma_{i\in D} [ e^{-\phi_{i}} + e^{\phi_{i}+E_1+E_2}] \tag{6.10}$$ $$~=~-\Sigma_{(\alpha,\beta \in D)}e^{(\nu_\beta-\alpha+1 )E_1+(\beta-\nu_\alpha^{'})E_2 }+e^{(-\nu_\beta+\alpha )E_1+(-\beta+\nu_\alpha^{'}+1)E_2 }. \tag{6.11} $$ Since I am not familiar with Nakajima's topic, I did not find the equality in Nakajima's lecture. Which chapter does the equality (6.10+11) come from? Thanks for pointing me out.</p></li> </ol>
g5844
[ -0.0013987430138513446, -0.05464499071240425, -0.0035709943622350693, -0.01962624303996563, 0.0233183354139328, -0.018896501511335373, 0.07349579781293869, 0.026392536237835884, -0.014036821201443672, 0.06915164738893509, -0.027055883780121803, 0.0257369764149189, 0.026135388761758804, 0.04688827320933342, -0.001409146934747696, -0.003377222456037998, 0.00671821553260088, 0.02364061400294304, -0.028597762808203697, -0.01829211413860321, -0.03887675330042839, 0.03605739027261734, -0.05389361456036568, 0.004430980887264013, 0.06059709191322327, -0.00047195557272061706, 0.006710239220410585, 0.05072072893381119, -0.10211706161499023, 0.04084382206201553, 0.030299188569188118, 0.02841685526072979, 0.04011917859315872, 0.019502930343151093, -0.028577448800206184, -0.0026808646507561207, 0.042660944163799286, 0.03861509636044502, 0.007216433063149452, -0.09369595348834991, -0.008463378064334393, -0.01432859431952238, 0.029336972162127495, 0.03942028433084488, 0.004149045329540968, -0.0053091952577233315, -0.012828297913074493, 0.014903898350894451, 0.0018279595533385873, -0.008677818812429905, 0.03626435622572899, 0.049665551632642746, 0.026626572012901306, -0.04872366786003113, -0.023854371160268784, 0.02592029981315136, -0.00447801873087883, -0.008914767764508724, 0.02904215082526207, 0.039460331201553345, -0.022989539429545403, -0.018400967121124268, -0.021885063499212265, -0.011251777410507202, 0.03192050755023956, -0.048234157264232635, 0.016895856708288193, 0.021918006241321564, -0.03242449089884758, 0.020835058763623238, -0.02139858715236187, -0.014762837439775467, -0.016405392438173294, -0.02322952076792717, 0.013216489925980568, 0.008972029201686382, 0.06880675256252289, 0.03416939824819565, -0.01785157062113285, -0.027489978820085526, -0.05391250178217888, -0.0320783369243145, -0.004362822510302067, -0.0038975065108388662, 0.0394345223903656, -0.03475676849484444, -0.000519428460393101, 0.021962838247418404, -0.008337385021150112, -0.017628656700253487, 0.027988014742732048, -0.016191735863685608, -0.04392257705330849, 0.029481295496225357, -0.009014190174639225, 0.001042783260345459, 0.04466275870800018, -0.057263147085905075, -0.030428500846028328, -0.02413472719490528, -0.005419045686721802, 0.00792422704398632, 0.06479037553071976, 0.01216807495802641, 0.00686375517398119, 0.03582553192973137, 0.051053229719400406, 0.01164019014686346, -0.02482506074011326, -0.012816770933568478, -0.006856725551187992, 0.01988920383155346, -0.06651489436626434, 0.012062663212418556, -0.023438934236764908, 0.008914108388125896, -0.021936289966106415, 0.010623875074088573, -0.01592460833489895, 0.03872064873576164, 0.02174089103937149, -0.003619022201746702, 0.022978903725743294, 0.09263929724693298, 0.002609911607578397, 0.015642253682017326, 0.01776077039539814, -0.002948027802631259, 0.040239885449409485, -0.008198723196983337, -0.06654980778694153, -0.02046569436788559, 0.05877049267292023, 0.01380904857069254, -0.002887644339352846, 0.060699012130498886, -0.0012053314130753279, 0.02984957955777645, -0.003942423965781927, -0.01968965120613575, -0.06081099435687065, -0.0037638216745108366, -0.07138606160879135, -0.014034364372491837, -0.010468895547091961, 0.02612348273396492, 0.0010322289308533072, -0.011494589038193226, -0.02928248606622219, 0.03498836234211922, -0.013365499675273895, 0.051372457295656204, -0.050576891750097275, -0.03208809718489647, 0.0040209642611444, 0.035617657005786896, -0.01414987538009882, -0.036487363278865814, -0.00573276961222291, 0.012251422740519047, -0.015165005810558796, -0.03638633340597153, 0.03491414338350296, 0.06458166241645813, -0.017697513103485107, 0.008757781237363815, 0.008121170103549957, -0.018252717331051826, -0.006512448191642761, -0.04585815593600273, -0.06620970368385315, 0.08292693644762039, 0.03672759234905243, 0.012098971754312515, 0.07555707544088364, 0.0014467715518549085, -0.028632942587137222, -0.001731758937239647, 0.07122773677110672, 0.012164975516498089, -0.0171557255089283, 0.01568409986793995, -0.049341995269060135, 0.039992835372686386, -0.06770364195108414, 0.00895620882511139, 0.016040712594985962, 0.003464563749730587, 0.027610071003437042, -0.012059473432600498, -0.010705968365073204, 0.057754792273044586, -0.06547774374485016, -0.007431183010339737, 0.05132259428501129, 0.05927911028265953, 0.04188194125890732, -0.08281373977661133, 0.0027850132901221514, 0.012800878845155239, -0.02240889146924019, -0.007484696805477142, 0.04456694424152374, -0.017570391297340393, 0.031909067183732986, 0.032416220754384995, 0.10478971153497696, -0.04743336886167526, -0.02126837708055973, 0.039536960422992706, -0.06389278173446655, -0.00300157000310719, -0.0003024869365617633, 0.029341254383325577, -0.03150478005409241, 0.013468209654092789, 0.027542594820261, 0.009245130233466625, -0.054982252418994904, -0.009206965565681458, -0.05703788623213768, 0.03325996547937393, 0.020284801721572876, -0.042495641857385635, 0.002985352883115411, 0.02638815902173519, -0.011417045257985592, 0.0009050891385413706, 0.004590955562889576, -0.00883839838206768, -0.08715885877609253, -0.06623908877372742, -0.0500665120780468, -0.010075370781123638, -0.0055005233734846115, -0.027855563908815384, 0.0003625639365054667, -0.006244930438697338, 0.04417068883776665, 0.004965782631188631, 0.014096091501414776, 0.008981255814433098, -0.08867204189300537, 0.04789752513170242, -0.04323433339595795, 0.0009061967139132321, 0.06443952023983002, 0.01145873311907053, -0.051683276891708374, -0.006198913790285587, -0.026250159367918968, 0.001533612492494285, -0.04565110802650452, 0.05586409568786621, 0.004946792032569647, -0.01857604645192623, 0.04984290152788162, -0.03326508030295372, 0.01059690397232771, 0.07706943899393082, -0.02413281798362732, -0.04387989267706871, -0.025739897042512894, -0.022007524967193604, -0.04939403757452965, 0.04118593409657478, -0.04317464306950569, -0.03720647841691971, 0.023359445855021477, -0.010363740846514702, -0.09206429123878479, 0.03899017348885536, 0.018170127645134926, 0.04131830111145973, 0.004677593242377043, -0.05209590867161751, 0.017578791826963425, 0.023230716586112976, 0.07618027180433273, -0.0005557209369726479, -0.03549215942621231, 0.04096740484237671, -0.005489685107022524, 0.03900041803717613, -0.00011248872033320367, 0.012197648175060749, -0.01279762014746666, 0.004804174415767193, 0.007722661830484867, 0.01741885393857956, -0.01247934065759182, -0.0325169637799263, 0.012027657590806484, 0.013538162223994732, 0.03774149343371391, 0.05675790086388588, -0.011274919845163822, -0.03762887790799141, 0.04265015572309494, 0.03850385919213295, 0.038114164024591446, 0.039909765124320984, -0.010137807577848434, -0.03816009685397148, 0.07453488558530807, 0.03982410579919815, 0.037739451974630356, -0.04392295330762863, 0.005504271015524864, -0.011376404203474522, 0.011122153140604496, 0.04141702130436897, 0.052857786417007446, -0.06948030740022659, -0.012614819221198559, 0.05414772033691406, 0.030801989138126373, -0.018269231542944908, 0.01603466086089611, 0.039508406072854996, -0.029681911692023277, -0.05726604536175728, 0.03741930425167084, 0.00791382696479559, 0.0159600842744112, -0.028531404212117195, -0.0454586036503315, -0.019720684736967087, 0.029779190197587013, 0.005526116117835045, 0.006030567921698093, -0.0017560082487761974, -0.008964844048023224, 0.021679090335965157, -0.03391611576080322, -0.04679369926452637, -0.04276400804519653, 0.020736001431941986, 0.05454351007938385, 0.032443929463624954, -0.08657381683588028, 0.009491595439612865, 0.008630654774606228, -0.03523950278759003, 0.03924140706658363, -0.03710555285215378, 0.013039660640060902, 0.052062422037124634, 0.014657794497907162, -0.004770586267113686, 0.011281232349574566, 0.007784037850797176, -0.024603327736258507, -0.02623068541288376, 0.004284537862986326, 0.017869556322693825, 0.039886847138404846, -0.01894315518438816, 0.00814150646328926, -0.031054111197590828, 0.047735922038555145, -0.0043752240017056465, 0.053591612726449966, -0.014478691853582859, 0.023639226332306862, -0.02383873611688614, 0.018728487193584442, 0.045118484646081924, -0.0143966656178236, -0.020763404667377472, 0.04619883745908737, 0.005861775483936071, 0.07328496873378754, -0.022648192942142487, -0.03283805772662163, 0.0038369952235370874, -0.019694389775395393, 0.009513712488114834, 0.002846387680619955, 0.05572274327278137, 0.03230588138103485, -0.007066886872053146, -0.038076482713222504, 0.0037325453013181686, 0.04442162811756134, 0.03733650967478752, 0.013095124624669552, -0.0358336977660656, 0.0375777967274189, -0.042972490191459656, -0.05317234992980957, 0.019160930067300797, -0.0354188047349453, -0.021482300013303757, -0.0004773114633280784, 0.030228719115257263, -0.030873194336891174, 0.011186379939317703, -0.06618358939886093, 0.03259902074933052, -0.02715926244854927, 0.011688907630741596, 0.015373464673757553, 0.004738542716950178, 0.03457401692867279, -0.008112186565995216, -0.025050394237041473, 0.06244988739490509, 0.09655632078647614, -0.040359511971473694, -0.018544305115938187, 0.0019045778317376971, 0.0029681080486625433, -0.002367923269048333, -0.03130306303501129, -0.031750377267599106, -0.04813041165471077, -0.051208365708589554, -0.00402450654655695, -0.06175777688622475, -0.03269525617361069, -0.03324505314230919, -0.07013191282749176, -0.04301462322473526, 0.05005457252264023, 0.03014368750154972, 0.022771432995796204, 0.0955115258693695, 0.05637843534350395, -0.04384825751185417, 0.02210470847785473, 0.0533326119184494, -0.06152753531932831, -0.01435603853315115, -0.03987061604857445, 0.056902166455984116, -0.05493644252419472, 0.02638140507042408, -0.0057660434395074844, -0.023332132026553154, -0.02604673057794571, 0.03875561058521271, -0.031008552759885788, 0.01882212609052658, 0.029203349724411964, 0.031180985271930695, -0.03209691867232323, -0.067807637155056, 0.041120607405900955, 0.003678718348965049, -0.01723165437579155, -0.04960798844695091, 0.09102807939052582, 0.02488788403570652, 0.05725793167948723, -0.012742705643177032, -0.06372661143541336, 0.009158812463283539, 0.0038656024262309074, 0.015822606161236763, -0.027663761749863625, 0.022366393357515335, 0.021441645920276642, 0.012785932049155235, 0.02044295333325863, -0.01283256895840168, -0.04980340600013733, 0.024248117581009865, -0.009699264541268349, 0.026835618540644646, 0.033577460795640945, 0.007962153293192387, 0.018101612105965614, -0.0949803963303566, 0.0287045706063509, -0.004198216833174229, -0.03780156373977661, 0.04872129112482071, -0.039766207337379456, -0.04623047634959221, -0.07869767397642136, -0.05006583780050278, -0.010078019462525845, -0.02786964736878872, 0.04675891995429993, -0.03241519257426262, -0.01713566854596138, -0.03884245082736015, 0.007008756510913372, -0.002962540602311492, 0.05408293753862381, 0.02275202050805092, 0.04383048787713051, -0.04722204431891441, -0.003046702593564987, -0.02485056221485138, 0.03804667294025421, 0.006136068142950535, -0.004719678312540054, 0.004046680871397257, -0.02390848845243454, 0.015474303625524044, -0.02849956601858139, -0.034851763397455215, 0.03076143190264702, 0.029775720089673996, 0.031598757952451706, 0.00932216178625822, -0.006881287787109613, -0.021638495847582817, 0.02380627579987049, -0.013640828430652618, 0.014071887359023094, -0.01456228643655777, 0.05354928597807884, 0.043802376836538315, -0.03888555243611336, -0.016392214223742485, -0.031781163066625595, -0.03321380913257599, 0.029384104534983635, -0.020799480378627777, -0.0170609038323164, -0.0019108025589957833, 0.034038152545690536, -0.03538887947797775, -0.00447714002802968, -0.09454165399074554, 0.015663817524909973, 0.0509190708398819, -0.036759309470653534, -0.11514580994844437, -0.06945092231035233, 0.06284044682979584, 0.08834593743085861, -0.04919471591711044, -0.0481058731675148, 0.009235603734850883, 0.01943713240325451, -0.007236834149807692, -0.013905574567615986, 0.001020527328364551, 0.06710502505302429, 0.043357331305742264, -0.08771418780088425, 0.023192625492811203, 0.012691553682088852, -0.0028780752327293158, 0.03440142422914505, -0.009190693497657776, -0.03025178238749504, -0.03383423388004303, -0.003005074569955468, -0.0854312926530838, -0.01626722887158394, 0.021922625601291656, 0.015505961142480373, 0.02326113171875477, -0.021930409595370293, -0.032051775604486465, -0.018579084426164627, -0.11170841008424759, -0.0017474759370088577, 0.0007083773380145431, 0.0072938064113259315, -0.0876239761710167, 0.013934736140072346, 0.05274849757552147, -0.039083097130060196, 0.014205223880708218, 0.030037883669137955, 0.029550524428486824, -0.01295088417828083, 0.01514524407684803, 0.024929460138082504, 0.04397419095039368, -0.024887260049581528, -0.014787468127906322, 0.02757878229022026, -0.011870330199599266, -0.02836758643388748, 0.02226083166897297, 0.028583260253071785, -0.001536239986307919, -0.035744331777095795, 0.01292870007455349, -0.028550781309604645, -0.07080131024122238, -0.02941877767443657, 0.00805647298693657, -0.04644554853439331, 0.019995510578155518, -0.03364242985844612, 0.04783445596694946, 0.022961748763918877, 0.01184022892266512, 0.02510656975209713, 0.061656683683395386, 0.02537333033978939, 0.021330729126930237, 0.03689906746149063, -0.026302069425582886, 0.014133503660559654, -0.03689492866396904, -0.0605386346578598, 0.018202010542154312, -0.028495900332927704, -0.02423696778714657, -0.03125961497426033, 0.038844626396894455, -0.00045013788621872663, 0.06775249540805817, -0.013800246641039848, 0.005288381595164537, 0.013808274641633034, -0.01357692014425993, 0.005140035878866911, 0.006990571040660143, -0.021509522572159767, -0.014429436065256596, 0.025470850989222527, 0.0194802675396204, 0.056405019015073776, -0.07260522991418839, -0.03176087141036987, 0.025365617126226425, 0.022426476702094078, -0.05959426984190941, -0.0065075610764324665, 0.005925554316490889, -0.05268685147166252, 0.03717901185154915, -0.019257888197898865, 0.07169564813375473, -0.0367492251098156, -0.013558389618992805, -0.036800581961870193, 0.008814762346446514, -0.030331220477819443, 0.026126891374588013, -0.01681319624185562, 0.03979285806417465, 0.014001600444316864, 0.018980851396918297, -0.056853536516427994, -0.0011561731807887554, -0.01770719327032566, 0.003321354743093252, -0.11487052589654922, 0.03552725538611412, 0.06810610741376877, 0.014143828302621841, 0.020567525178194046, -0.004217149224132299, -0.05183987691998482, -0.015034450218081474, 0.04832177609205246, -0.00686498312279582, 0.0031299199908971786, -0.0015907582128420472, -0.00012722126848530024, 0.06770133227109909, 0.011155478656291962, 0.022355780005455017, 0.017009343951940536, 0.011365589685738087, -0.01471778191626072, 0.010831193067133427, 0.018518706783652306, -0.01975027658045292, 0.013754968531429768, -0.052548911422491074, -0.03911750391125679, 0.013375760987401009, 0.0014415739569813013, -0.018770502880215645, 0.030915087088942528, -0.05151893571019173, -0.042579926550388336, 0.008446169085800648, 0.02463778667151928, 0.0057233842089772224, 0.0067576258443295956, -0.05548220872879028, -0.03166079521179199, -0.02902013063430786, -0.06024867296218872, -0.04816603660583496, -0.013251706026494503, 0.05016731843352318, 0.022498277947306633, -0.039764855057001114, 0.03277919813990593, 0.04548171907663345, 0.0032625384628772736, 0.006935837212949991, 0.0603056438267231, -0.007929980754852295, 0.013470874167978764, -0.015293236821889877, 0.050367336720228195, 0.0300588458776474, 0.01530116144567728, -0.018293065950274467, -0.036924079060554504, -0.0036945869214832783, 0.003741434309631586, 0.02304510772228241, -0.003769629169255495, -0.035841237753629684, 0.014206175692379475, -0.028258293867111206, -0.03298411890864372, 0.034909091889858246, 0.03963881731033325, -0.020101778209209442, -0.0029536057263612747, 0.017890658229589462, -0.0036845554132014513, 0.02507805824279785, 0.03866536542773247, -0.0061049130745232105, -0.012216174975037575, -0.03839641064405441, 0.0013303207233548164, -0.017438309267163277, 0.009810127317905426, 0.03878817707300186, 0.03535447269678116, 0.044784147292375565, -0.03142271935939789, -0.07969898730516434, -0.02207251824438572, 0.010049768723547459, -0.10177434235811234, 0.009740778245031834, 0.020622912794351578, -0.07711359113454819, 0.0016004176577553153, 0.0007911243010312319, -0.0256901104003191, -0.048088815063238144, 0.02365601807832718, 0.02247730642557144, -0.02152295969426632, -0.021703530102968216, -0.012558409944176674, 0.03179643675684929, 0.05040132999420166, 0.04837968200445175, 0.03807215020060539, -0.003460619132965803, -0.002704272046685219, 0.01876140385866165, 0.05038628354668617, -0.00907967984676361, 0.020573703572154045, -0.008027026429772377, 0.04117501527070999, 0.04025398567318916, -0.0006865631439723074, -0.028462056070566177, -0.07164449244737625, -0.0023534982465207577, 0.02542245388031006, -0.05985013023018837, 0.028266629204154015, -0.03478557989001274 ]
<p>I am having a bit of a tough time understanding the following:</p> <pre><code>|____O____| &lt;- 0A |____O____| &lt;- 12A |____O____| &lt;- 24A | | &lt;- 36A |_[|||||]_| &lt;- 36A Legend: O - A small lamp with 1Ω resistance. [|||||] - A 12V battery. </code></pre> <p>There is 12V flowing across each of the lamps and with resistance of 1Ω, and, therefore, there is 12 Amps of current flowing across each one. So, if the current is flowing from right side, up, over and down the left side, there is a total of 36 Amps flowing through the battery itself to supply the three connected lamps. At the top portion of either side of the top lamp (above the points where middle lamp connects) there is only 12 Amps of current; to either side of the middle lamp (above the points where the bottom lamp connects) there is 24 Amps; and to either side of the bottom lamp (below the points where the bottom lamp connects) there is 36 Amps.</p> <p>Does it mean that a battery that could not shock us, could in fact if we connected several lamps in parallel circuit to raise the amount of current flowing through the circuit at the bottom portion? I'm just trying to wrap my head around circuits and electricity and this popped into my head. I've looked around, but couldn't find a clear answer to help me understand.</p>
g5845
[ 0.014179833233356476, 0.05180250108242035, -0.02935202047228813, -0.05224287509918213, 0.028654251247644424, 0.0014765291707590222, 0.06232188269495964, 0.018336938694119453, -0.028402145951986313, 0.0004736645787488669, -0.06831047683954239, 0.06034531071782112, -0.0006922841421328485, -0.0045260656625032425, 0.03127063065767288, -0.01191604696214199, 0.03873332962393761, 0.018389923498034477, 0.04728401079773903, -0.0010678390972316265, -0.02453133463859558, 0.03795759379863739, -0.03866662085056305, -0.06216205283999443, -0.0018082507885992527, 0.00032275193370878696, -0.01949263922870159, -0.034189946949481964, -0.05768376216292381, -0.05136334151029587, -0.00920303724706173, -0.04435179382562637, 0.06831633299589157, -0.029954584315419197, -0.05573466420173645, -0.017315207049250603, 0.010263011790812016, 0.027402929961681366, 0.008990846574306488, 0.02349063567817211, 0.022106507793068886, 0.018374457955360413, 0.07816038280725479, 0.0028087920509278774, 0.008889489807188511, -0.02532394975423813, -0.002676368225365877, 0.011910191737115383, -0.022250767797231674, -0.03874153271317482, -0.010549004189670086, 0.011798960156738758, -0.024666115641593933, 0.036174215376377106, -0.0002417843643343076, 0.007967856712639332, 0.04365820065140724, -0.0223589688539505, 0.0104141253978014, 0.09949813038110733, -0.011227450333535671, 0.015043865889310837, 0.02745925448834896, 0.04554425925016403, 0.04682016000151634, -0.013325348496437073, 0.007381711155176163, -0.0412866473197937, 0.05157293379306793, 0.002558512846007943, -0.0010982425883412361, -0.03738095238804817, -0.056312523782253265, -0.0457204170525074, 0.06393428891897202, 0.025426430627703667, 0.03371894732117653, 0.031060343608260155, 0.015303508378565311, 0.02065732516348362, 0.001599287847056985, -0.06049888953566551, 0.012392537668347359, -0.00794560369104147, 0.010959025472402573, 0.027971068397164345, -0.03271213546395302, 0.018400663509964943, -0.04342455044388771, -0.014015795662999153, 0.02947745844721794, -0.06635001301765442, 0.1311221569776535, -0.06383165717124939, -0.011971700936555862, -0.02416517771780491, -0.038108617067337036, 0.03305865824222565, 0.017394987866282463, 0.0044016288593411446, -0.033673129975795746, -0.01172677706927061, -0.014955529943108559, -0.020145799964666367, -0.10000575333833694, 0.012324526906013489, -0.005309887230396271, 0.03821590915322304, -0.006908160634338856, -0.07309428602457047, -0.03588255122303963, -0.03913498669862747, -0.019809218123555183, -0.0271069947630167, -0.0330883152782917, -0.010725072585046291, 0.06623299419879913, 0.025844749063253403, 0.017565147951245308, -0.012668016366660595, -0.03405476734042168, -0.0016655641375109553, 0.04695775359869003, 0.03485448658466339, -0.038048285990953445, 0.018480047583580017, -0.00993458554148674, 0.04540706053376198, 0.0540042407810688, 0.0034937821328639984, -0.010114368051290512, -0.0013130807783454657, -0.038506463170051575, 0.0008024355629459023, 0.06460586190223694, -0.007519437465816736, 0.011318443343043327, -0.0023465484846383333, -0.01852782629430294, 0.0474538579583168, 0.03951910510659218, -0.04140350967645645, -0.013770938850939274, -0.05966413766145706, 0.01404185127466917, 0.04939635843038559, -0.04166049510240555, 0.008565805852413177, 0.03691840544342995, 0.022503798827528954, 0.039753932505846024, 0.0784652903676033, -0.012307691387832165, -0.03565596044063568, 0.02356644533574581, -0.0013306653127074242, 0.020295392721891403, -0.036513857543468475, -0.007840247824788094, -0.019212430343031883, -0.0008461008546873927, 0.009908155538141727, 0.028770381584763527, -0.024054616689682007, -0.07428179681301117, -0.026273850351572037, 0.034153979271650314, 0.015338494442403316, -0.05045280605554581, 0.04563860222697258, -0.008881510235369205, -0.017812302336096764, 0.03171181306242943, 0.06820131838321686, 0.006464383099228144, 0.04484090581536293, 0.07654271274805069, -0.011348879896104336, 0.010458406060934067, 0.030727336183190346, -0.038660142570734024, 0.004571103490889072, 0.0018493524985387921, -0.011142482049763203, -0.022785255685448647, 0.004413980059325695, -0.07586300373077393, 0.013712883926928043, -0.037973616272211075, -0.0697641596198082, -0.07010596990585327, -0.0016404862981289625, -0.0041707297787070274, 0.026523396372795105, -0.009995988570153713, -0.0394655242562294, -0.033138081431388855, -0.017819847911596298, -0.011477957479655743, -0.06355071812868118, 0.0031613362953066826, -0.024277962744235992, 0.05449146404862404, 0.03365909308195114, 0.05260533094406128, 0.031264498829841614, -0.018881509080529213, -0.0057557797990739346, 0.025751296430826187, -0.010267602279782295, -0.003738971659913659, -0.005149253644049168, 0.030018720775842667, 0.04865243658423424, -0.04384993389248848, -0.1029052659869194, -0.007034900598227978, -0.012375744059681892, -0.04474921524524689, -0.027276448905467987, -0.01840963214635849, -0.037923336029052734, 0.021382085978984833, -0.04070834442973137, -0.05398447439074516, 0.008359276689589024, 0.034620415419340134, -0.061774782836437225, -0.07668663561344147, -0.014043265022337437, -0.05645483732223511, -0.014594941399991512, -0.01408353354781866, -0.06474833935499191, -0.02413218840956688, 0.07024501264095306, 0.017897777259349823, 0.012364077381789684, -0.04916910454630852, 0.012520749121904373, -0.018834156915545464, -0.030712231993675232, 0.03599046915769577, 0.051765333861112595, 0.031708069145679474, 0.019457155838608742, 0.06243471801280975, 0.06962637603282928, -0.0593385249376297, 0.03798414766788483, -0.024782542139291763, -0.019701039418578148, 0.0023740751203149557, 0.03876349329948425, -0.056693755090236664, -0.016210999339818954, -0.012017848901450634, 0.03156720846891403, -0.0051748910918831825, 0.014637884683907032, 0.011092837899923325, 0.018099837005138397, 0.007710580714046955, 0.011617365293204784, -0.05667618662118912, 0.02374756522476673, -0.0074094985611736774, -0.06382668763399124, 0.015005717985332012, -0.005818585399538279, 0.004008247517049313, 0.06371616572141647, 0.00815882720053196, -0.0036805886775255203, 0.010408284142613411, 0.004081790801137686, 0.017439428716897964, -0.02891729213297367, 0.022952882573008537, 0.008729803375899792, 0.04194646328687668, -0.022460123524069786, -0.018436560407280922, 0.007421350106596947, 0.021848037838935852, -0.022814875468611717, 0.016600869596004486, -0.0424954891204834, -0.016536708921194077, 0.024355808272957802, -0.04984533414244652, -0.06516949832439423, 0.040444813668727875, -0.011478683911263943, 0.008163112215697765, -0.005679814610630274, 0.023650450631976128, -0.020173830911517143, -0.04541945457458496, 0.052193477749824524, -0.06259418278932571, 0.00499926321208477, 0.00495594646781683, -0.03569032996892929, -0.014628911390900612, 0.0450669564306736, -0.007535412907600403, -0.03908022493124008, 0.010007625445723534, 0.051274996250867844, -0.06715609133243561, -0.007240023463964462, -0.004841544199734926, 0.000674528069794178, -0.022019121795892715, -0.026876091957092285, -0.06149514019489288, 0.05341204255819321, -0.034895285964012146, -0.024375069886446, -0.02251916192471981, -0.00726969912648201, -0.033941369503736496, 0.00363824306987226, 0.009913408197462559, -0.022293007001280785, -0.013512943871319294, -0.015083071775734425, -0.018436187878251076, -0.06326452642679214, -0.003618275746703148, 0.047308459877967834, 0.03146775811910629, 0.022089755162596703, 0.06112440302968025, 0.024035293608903885, -0.035353824496269226, 0.018895864486694336, 0.02050892263650894, -0.0030691898427903652, 0.04634531959891319, -0.053385015577077866, -0.06395430117845535, -0.04675857722759247, -0.03703652322292328, 0.039259620010852814, 0.001008567283861339, 0.03345726057887077, -0.0032410109415650368, -0.05179724097251892, 0.06552646309137344, -0.006207225378602743, -0.013575985096395016, -0.01038501225411892, 0.02400582656264305, 0.04063112661242485, 0.007288149558007717, 0.055700115859508514, -0.016929134726524353, 0.017369557172060013, 0.02249773032963276, 0.012193179689347744, 0.040973398834466934, 0.03082680143415928, 0.025592731311917305, -0.015736626461148262, 0.024137001484632492, 0.02705976366996765, 0.031360168009996414, -0.11331720650196075, -0.0016561370575800538, -0.042232610285282135, -0.05729431286454201, -0.04383871704339981, 0.018209801986813545, -0.047841399908065796, 0.03535984456539154, 0.022127406671643257, -0.050549913197755814, 0.10567415505647659, 0.01556451991200447, -0.004827594850212336, 0.019845783710479736, -0.014661598019301891, 0.059093546122312546, 0.022378483787178993, -0.009201761335134506, -0.0028088230174034834, -0.047537997364997864, -0.013207913376390934, -0.02041986957192421, 0.017577681690454483, -0.03882472589612007, -0.04035205766558647, 0.0009675186593085527, -0.013171118684113026, 0.0186395812779665, -0.015482692047953606, -0.04148954525589943, 0.07897714525461197, 0.013044278137385845, 0.0027747764252126217, 0.03281756117939949, -0.043057359755039215, -0.009906084276735783, 0.010243001393973827, 0.07409293204545975, 0.010299723595380783, 0.0030334354378283024, -0.000189708880498074, 0.01413190271705389, -0.024484606459736824, 0.010193883441388607, -0.02999104931950569, 0.014914813451468945, 0.014573638327419758, 0.08114071190357208, 0.05834517255425453, 0.042027004063129425, 0.02287950925529003, 0.0038686778862029314, 0.03433451056480408, -0.0073567903600633144, -0.020943524315953255, 0.009787517599761486, 0.006224333308637142, 0.04174690321087837, -0.006474883295595646, 0.03966711461544037, -0.025207828730344772, 0.007799631450325251, 0.07778710126876831, -0.017762938514351845, -0.033316001296043396, 0.011318902485072613, 0.026676274836063385, -0.023249169811606407, 0.08333998918533325, -0.001596089918166399, 0.12144080549478531, 0.07550494372844696, 0.011467385105788708, -0.02282743714749813, 0.022575965151190758, 0.009109766222536564, 0.011236191727221012, -0.08396421372890472, -0.0032319948077201843, -0.05560220777988434, -0.0009139709873124957, -0.03650866821408272, -0.009912338107824326, -0.008055410347878933, -0.06904336810112, 0.029048483818769455, 0.00056156434584409, 0.04364433512091637, 0.01474023424088955, 0.01180568989366293, 0.024690082296729088, -0.07884993404150009, -0.0312698557972908, 0.0049705239944159985, 0.008703147061169147, 0.07117726653814316, -0.04740940406918526, 0.026802750304341316, -0.04265056550502777, -0.0396813340485096, -0.01128760538995266, 0.031123915687203407, 0.005656687542796135, -0.022666404023766518, 0.027308335527777672, -0.02342817932367325, -0.017956769093871117, 0.04483170062303543, -0.024218151345849037, -0.015189073979854584, -0.029106492176651955, 0.022542370483279228, 0.01621517725288868, -0.036882299929857254, 0.040535349398851395, 0.0197885911911726, 0.014264857396483421, -0.02818300947546959, 0.002897398779168725, -0.012210038490593433, 0.01598898135125637, 0.002672972157597542, 0.05256485566496849, -0.007996169850230217, 0.01749122329056263, -0.0033869503531605005, 0.017955869436264038, 0.03095296584069729, 0.02121853083372116, -0.012821887619793415, 0.007642597425729036, -0.03420940041542053, 0.031377073377370834, 0.008410579524934292, 0.01853744499385357, -0.0004503255186136812, 0.03275340795516968, 0.015290452167391777, -0.027675438672304153, 0.006300568114966154, -0.009754265658557415, 0.00020127488824073225, 0.003598018316552043, -0.007359904237091541, -0.024990281090140343, 0.04033447429537773, -0.021451182663440704, -0.04596392810344696, -0.017826858907938004, -0.017046496272087097, 0.023786121979355812, 0.02516423724591732, -0.060371819883584976, -0.0024201313499361277, 0.004997776355594397, -0.025137126445770264, 0.007499410305172205, -0.03574396297335625, -0.002390373032540083, 0.02659650333225727, 0.04682847112417221, 0.014773665927350521, 0.05186279118061066, 0.008151138201355934, -0.06694871187210083, -0.03817770630121231, -0.05357944592833519, 0.07040823996067047, 0.007934851571917534, 0.045367803424596786, -0.02548794448375702, 0.013290117494761944, -0.02103256992995739, 0.027681447565555573, 0.08461353182792664, -0.003561507910490036, -0.06466022878885269, -0.030672771856188774, -0.05013400316238403, 0.0016747894696891308, 0.02245073951780796, -0.001948568387888372, 0.07317329943180084, -0.00965053029358387, 0.04595578834414482, 0.004440649878233671, 0.01146071869879961, -0.004321344196796417, -0.028224952518939972, 0.032511599361896515, -0.01834217831492424, 0.036439813673496246, -0.012578464113175869, -0.0254041887819767, 0.014429185539484024, 0.03079845756292343, -0.052136436104774475, -0.004964808933436871, 0.027922166511416435, 0.00480120861902833, -0.004027624148875475, 0.028672456741333008, -0.08964704722166061, 0.0005963212461210787, -0.007327907718718052, 0.057308945804834366, 0.004384391475468874, -0.0744621530175209, -0.01149901282042265, -0.01943349465727806, 0.021931704133749008, -0.02807391993701458, 0.0008103086147457361, 0.005929619073867798, -0.0346389003098011, 0.06497274339199066, -0.014098101295530796, -0.020531684160232544, -0.02556971088051796, -0.02797003649175167, -0.07568415254354477, -0.03193069249391556, 0.03338241204619408, -0.014377199113368988, -0.06872870773077011, 0.024544134736061096, 0.027363372966647148, 0.01612158492207527, 0.039373986423015594, 0.030524466186761856, 0.011373876594007015, 0.03689988702535629, -0.00030315047479234636, 0.037479467689991, -0.0042556957341730595, 0.03034348599612713, 0.00859163049608469, -0.051968976855278015, 0.022855864837765694, -0.0015507697826251388, 0.025741904973983765, 0.05643942579627037, 0.03385920450091362, 0.04150279611349106, -0.0651603415608406, -0.03724636882543564, -0.01445743627846241, -0.021663304418325424, 0.015303760766983032, 0.06107832118868828, 0.09881851077079773, 0.03241888806223869, 0.03700539842247963, -0.027565469965338707, -0.01814213953912258, 0.07399731129407883, 0.0046790293417871, 0.043696630746126175, 0.05550270900130272, 0.0252043679356575, 0.023504314944148064, -0.05642983317375183, 0.014052391052246094, -0.02080295979976654, 0.016320234164595604, 0.022985992953181267, 0.0026150362100452185, -0.03339948505163193, 0.014323703944683075, 0.0035680076107382774, 0.03201030567288399, 0.0357934795320034, 0.028548475354909897, -0.024356752634048462, 0.08409684151411057, 0.027351507917046547, -0.06634622812271118, 0.07959786802530289, 0.06392861157655716, 0.012136494740843773, -0.009154330007731915, -0.004370393697172403, -0.026851581409573555, -0.053749412298202515, 0.07899196445941925, -0.07599133998155594, 0.009345810860395432, -0.0024696746841073036, 0.000004766956408275291, 0.01683516427874565, 0.008501176722347736, 0.04370901733636856, -0.02163766138255596, -0.008503101766109467, 0.019350705668330193, 0.027234025299549103, 0.043628793209791183, 0.027964521199464798, -0.04310855269432068, 0.012565331533551216, -0.0027398651000112295, -0.012832009233534336, -0.01344074122607708, -0.02125922404229641, -0.0011237567523494363, -0.021025631576776505, 0.015513669699430466, 0.026200829073786736, 0.08177797496318817, -0.0294755008071661, -0.0410582534968853, -0.010572632774710655, -0.04155365750193596, -0.02570366859436035, -0.06305982917547226, -0.0402224101126194, -0.013524651527404785, -0.030931178480386734, -0.04220370575785637, 0.025079134851694107, -0.022804556414484978, 0.012507971376180649, 0.012172113172709942, 0.03475616127252579, 0.026665080338716507, -0.013738816604018211, 0.10419144481420517, -0.005943009164184332, -0.017523815855383873, 0.005352063570171595, 0.03345785662531853, 0.05170954391360283, 0.0014778667828068137, 0.04510995373129845, 0.018056241795420647, 0.010481922887265682, 0.008639715611934662, -0.030937474220991135, 0.03672869876027107, -0.007113523315638304, -0.08205876499414444, -0.05398416146636009, -0.0041218348778784275, -0.05811529979109764, 0.006889530457556248, 0.01921955496072769, -0.016277246177196503, 0.012722201645374298, -0.00436218548566103, -0.013059073127806187, -0.003465186106041074, -0.05409126356244087, -0.0017990003107115626, -0.031806863844394684, -0.014558077789843082, 0.009064696729183197, -0.029863519594073296, -0.014295939356088638, 0.0475141666829586, -0.06403537839651108, -0.05082549527287483, -0.004783481825143099, -0.03829851746559143, -0.015321369282901287, -0.021991055458784103, -0.03664061054587364, 0.02828693576157093, 0.006578441243618727, -0.0011693645501509309, 0.05698929727077484, 0.022719433531165123, -0.0073435623198747635, -0.07380779087543488, -0.003015731694176793, -0.038977447897195816, 0.0030142273753881454, -0.015889164060354233, -0.08234848827123642, 0.007631202694028616, 0.005595701280981302, 0.019237134605646133, 0.0047029233537614346, 0.008814954198896885, -0.03967925161123276, -0.027521593496203423, 0.010687565430998802, -0.029702572152018547, -0.04583203047513962, 0.04341430217027664, -0.018142085522413254, -0.008150909096002579, -0.028172696009278297, 0.01940370723605156, 0.02569408342242241, -0.02404267154633999, 0.026272298768162727, -0.0172040406614542, -0.08881759643554688, -0.0623701848089695 ]
<p>I'm looking for a way to construct a representation for a simple Lie group such that one particular subgroup is manifest. I learned the branching rules from Cahn, Georgi and Slansky, but I'm still not sure how to derive the explicit representation from the weight system deformed by extended Dynkin diagram?</p> <p>To decompose a irreducible representation under a maximal regular subalgebra, we look at the extended Dynkin diagram, which has one more node from the minus highest root added on the original Dynkin diagram, and we then eliminate another node to deform the extended Dynkin diagram into the Dynkin diagram for the maximal regular subalgebra. The key point is to replace the Dynkin coefficient corresponding to the eliminated node by the one corresponding to the extra node of the minus highest root. Thus, deforming the weight system of the given irrep with above replacement gives us the branching rules and the Cartan matrices for the subalgebra in the given irrep. For example, under the subgroup $SU(2)\times SU(2)\times SU(2) \Subset SO(7)$, we have the 8 dimensional irrep of SO(7) deformed as $8 \rightarrow (1,2,2) + (2,1,2)$, see P33-34 <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1206.6379" rel="nofollow">LieART</a>.</p> <p>To construct the explicit matrix representation, we define the coordinates for each simple roots in an orthonormal basis (Cartan-Weyl basis) and therefore the coordinates for the fundamental weights as well. Thus, the generators corresponding to Cartan matrices have its matrix entries as the coordinate of every weights. Now, my question is what are the fundamental weights for the deformed Dynkin diagram? Should I keep the old fundamental weights except the replaced one or the new fundamental weights are resolved from the deformed Dynkin diagram? Most importantly, what's the new fundamental weight corresponding to the extended root?</p> <p>I would also need help to reveal how generators of the subalgebra are in the subset of generators of the mother algebra. When I replace the Dynkin coefficient with the extended root, how could the corresponding Cartan matrix belong to linear combination of Cartan matrices of the mother algebra? </p> <p>I'm a Physics student with poor knowledge in Lie algebra. Please reinterpret my description with proper language whenever you needed to.</p>
g5846
[ 0.0005085611483082175, 0.008635061793029308, -0.02433473989367485, -0.054247546941041946, -0.01650381274521351, -0.07682739198207855, -0.03802873566746712, 0.04312337934970856, -0.021735796704888344, -0.02578297257423401, 0.016145998612046242, 0.004729206208139658, 0.027278097346425056, 0.05367444083094597, 0.010187799111008644, 0.058320317417383194, 0.056514572352170944, 0.045063432306051254, 0.04083649814128876, -0.05124173313379288, -0.010357913561165333, -0.017165252938866615, 0.005005107261240482, -0.052199989557266235, 0.019591199234128, -0.04141995310783386, 0.026164650917053223, 0.023803144693374634, -0.09337058663368225, -0.025334490463137627, 0.0060780104249715805, -0.0007265503518283367, 0.060764990746974945, -0.02570417709648609, -0.027482004836201668, 0.023693304508924484, 0.07755818963050842, 0.052620548754930496, 0.061798762530088425, 0.017643773928284645, -0.0011781242210417986, -0.040874168276786804, -0.003912814427167177, 0.03659820556640625, -0.09475668519735336, 0.011871364898979664, -0.013573923148214817, -0.051624298095703125, -0.05453106760978699, -0.018161246553063393, -0.021309947595000267, -0.014189230278134346, 0.008230553939938545, -0.06308919191360474, -0.017789719626307487, 0.005911089014261961, -0.00937653612345457, -0.019759757444262505, 0.02078816667199135, 0.013061877340078354, -0.045269645750522614, 0.03748060017824173, -0.0001940751972142607, -0.029031969606876373, 0.022779803723096848, 0.0005146819166839123, 0.015317657962441444, -0.0028321389108896255, 0.006541662849485874, -0.002392789116129279, 0.02888866700232029, -0.05360793694853783, 0.0459962897002697, -0.05020134523510933, -0.03607301414012909, -0.006494625471532345, -0.006416999269276857, -0.023112192749977112, 0.023251449689269066, 0.02651127800345421, -0.0008831334416754544, 0.010100027546286583, -0.034275121986866, 0.029567277058959007, -0.027479922398924828, 0.0066195158287882805, -0.007898502051830292, 0.025120537728071213, -0.008200310170650482, 0.0386601984500885, 0.05233488976955414, 0.015911517664790154, -0.001701120170764625, 0.015318231657147408, -0.02820197306573391, -0.0036134396214038134, 0.013956647366285324, 0.04172653332352638, 0.003166662296280265, 0.00044349170639179647, 0.007380813360214233, 0.013212856836616993, -0.014758924953639507, -0.02469794824719429, -0.03269479423761368, -0.013596761040389538, 0.035670045763254166, -0.06675927340984344, -0.015141070820391178, 0.015927758067846298, -0.053083404898643494, 0.009058459661900997, -0.010532009415328503, 0.032821960747241974, 0.004985308740288019, -0.07269857823848724, 0.025939982384443283, 0.04290252551436424, 0.023689528927206993, 0.025395460426807404, 0.02173648029565811, -0.005754598416388035, 0.04902416840195656, 0.031698886305093765, 0.03584007918834686, -0.05730505287647247, -0.02392605133354664, 0.03942451253533363, -0.028932150453329086, -0.02773323841392994, -0.035543255507946014, -0.04438147321343422, -0.024728218093514442, 0.02328675240278244, 0.0025951543357223272, -0.012636738829314709, 0.02881660684943199, 0.0516400970518589, -0.04868178814649582, -0.034128811210393906, -0.02888619527220726, 0.03696996346116066, -0.028035901486873627, 0.015310618095099926, -0.003382801776751876, -0.029264280572533607, 0.10186217725276947, -0.045565422624349594, -0.027418717741966248, 0.018694566562771797, -0.00198914110660553, -0.005633845459669828, -0.023076076060533524, -0.031244641169905663, 0.029344310984015465, 0.008305883035063744, 0.07822702080011368, -0.018825190141797066, -0.006733518559485674, 0.006902151275426149, 0.045307815074920654, 0.02461535856127739, -0.011778376996517181, -0.024840334430336952, -0.02694186568260193, -0.057500049471855164, -0.005869959481060505, -0.03635304421186447, 0.020411888137459755, -0.00027779326774179935, 0.010112575255334377, 0.008103425614535809, -0.010163984261453152, 0.05750632658600807, -0.027984557673335075, 0.06195099651813507, -0.009140564128756523, 0.03307708725333214, 0.059105657041072845, -0.019115792587399483, -0.045441634953022, 0.048189498484134674, 0.04417935758829117, 0.028502561151981354, -0.008141158148646355, 0.045501578599214554, 0.011766381561756134, 0.041024211794137955, -0.020952560007572174, 0.009694217704236507, -0.008622790686786175, 0.06014849618077278, 0.026853928342461586, 0.08475273102521896, -0.03125044330954552, -0.01585511863231659, -0.007120268419384956, -0.0663830116391182, 0.0062410724349319935, -0.0055029685609042645, 0.03712249919772148, -0.006430348847061396, 0.004925562534481287, 0.032034557312726974, 0.027033600956201553, -0.013808556832373142, -0.0006842812872491777, -0.007580569013953209, 0.01383659802377224, 0.009943559765815735, -0.010797490365803242, 0.037678446620702744, 0.008466816507279873, 0.025192473083734512, -0.05303126573562622, -0.04895685613155365, 0.027242368087172508, 0.02374378591775894, 0.016613660380244255, -0.055804114788770676, -0.006792641244828701, -0.0384066179394722, -0.01786859519779682, 0.03714907541871071, 0.0006189908599480987, -0.0028411317616701126, 0.014740617014467716, -0.033682774752378464, -0.009366551414132118, 0.05682220682501793, -0.04506964981555939, 0.0007864277577027678, -0.004866317845880985, -0.04809657484292984, -0.00951415579766035, -0.044918645173311234, -0.06383199244737625, -0.03528256341814995, 0.039937421679496765, 0.08855211734771729, 0.008496461436152458, -0.05377914384007454, 0.01824517548084259, -0.02801697514951229, 0.0321415439248085, -0.002243584720417857, 0.11631045490503311, 0.0027386045549064875, -0.006926021073013544, 0.07709308713674545, -0.045990996062755585, 0.030139073729515076, -0.04310977831482887, -0.03713863715529442, 0.02160070464015007, 0.008924114517867565, -0.02313316985964775, 0.01673758216202259, 0.01590334065258503, -0.009825591929256916, -0.005144292023032904, -0.024376792833209038, -0.010238601826131344, 0.018470555543899536, -0.06091752648353577, -0.01872941665351391, 0.03446485847234726, -0.07226359099149704, -0.039624448865652084, -0.051313504576683044, -0.07204324752092361, 0.016547570005059242, 0.007736870553344488, -0.05061020329594612, -0.00384528492577374, 0.03359270468354225, -0.01691151037812233, -0.001465276931412518, -0.055542800575494766, 0.052167054265737534, 0.06246234476566315, -0.020764939486980438, -0.0012221025535836816, 0.0120054567232728, 0.05079929903149605, -0.008500456809997559, 0.02464408427476883, -0.006113849114626646, -0.02510542795062065, -0.00708229374140501, -0.052071601152420044, -0.003770973067730665, 0.008805123157799244, -0.021768946200609207, -0.023820040747523308, 0.035964105278253555, -0.006841906346380711, 0.02243271842598915, 0.0012741911923512816, 0.03418358042836189, 0.048876404762268066, -0.041343145072460175, -0.017084423452615738, 0.02399025484919548, 0.032157160341739655, 0.04291900247335434, -0.03178846091032028, 0.016070596873760223, 0.06703078001737595, 0.022439027205109596, -0.04116254299879074, -0.03873732313513756, 0.029919132590293884, -0.04526923596858978, 0.002914556534960866, -0.02636871114373207, -0.021289100870490074, -0.007944969460368156, -0.025396686047315598, -0.06742385029792786, -0.037233930081129074, -0.02085953578352928, 0.001701303175650537, 0.028593912720680237, 0.04104141518473625, 0.030055033043026924, -0.014804943464696407, 0.03358194977045059, 0.009604867547750473, -0.017835553735494614, -0.01962747797369957, -0.02611539512872696, 0.009184163995087147, 0.01632985658943653, -0.08730889111757278, -0.04866056889295578, -0.0262142363935709, -0.04573984071612358, 0.00274486793205142, -0.05134325101971626, 0.013880694285035133, -0.022219272330403328, 0.017589019611477852, -0.02196572534739971, 0.018338989466428757, -0.054085444658994675, -0.027206141501665115, 0.01189291849732399, -0.04043625295162201, -0.024241313338279724, -0.044356536120176315, -0.016471419483423233, 0.038233209401369095, 0.004863585811108351, 0.04356693476438522, 0.01440693624317646, 0.06829759478569031, 0.020278440788388252, -0.03755177929997444, -0.006836945656687021, 0.030918806791305542, -0.002207263372838497, 0.007279886864125729, 0.05016183480620384, -0.04002225399017334, 0.049754731357097626, -0.013022085651755333, 0.010135544463992119, 0.009638029150664806, 0.03555787727236748, 0.06056862697005272, -0.03668365254998207, -0.07599147409200668, -0.006271966267377138, -0.05345575138926506, 0.03252727910876274, 0.0963190495967865, 0.05559944361448288, -0.008894363418221474, 0.060665056109428406, 0.025998838245868683, -0.010577810928225517, 0.051937028765678406, 0.03990231826901436, -0.040127258747816086, 0.007924933917820454, -0.04545225948095322, 0.031156716868281364, 0.010048184543848038, 0.0830456018447876, 0.0192811768501997, -0.044882696121931076, 0.08909820765256882, 0.09946240484714508, 0.0008150849025696516, 0.007801251485943794, 0.03437181934714317, 0.012636883184313774, -0.06903894990682602, 0.004421250429004431, -0.07960810512304306, 0.04133386164903641, 0.0006865072064101696, -0.003640658687800169, 0.0011620436562225223, 0.02460889331996441, 0.004543948452919722, -0.047153834253549576, 0.05544736608862877, 0.04140020161867142, 0.011735341511666775, 0.04016425833106041, 0.07071483880281448, -0.05160735547542572, -0.0026579995173960924, 0.041779644787311554, 0.03467718884348869, -0.0053129964508116245, -0.017314473167061806, -0.024615071713924408, -0.033785443753004074, 0.04272305592894554, -0.006962152663618326, 0.04673845320940018, -0.015190559439361095, 0.016689255833625793, -0.038109179586172104, -0.041760340332984924, 0.021157940849661827, 0.026564115658402443, 0.0028979782946407795, -0.00482443580403924, -0.012944217771291733, 0.022387832403182983, -0.08218491077423096, 0.025208186358213425, 0.01367579959332943, 0.07848984748125076, -0.03524044156074524, 0.034180596470832825, 0.05759545415639877, -0.034527454525232315, 0.030022121965885162, -0.03527067229151726, -0.0338234007358551, -0.03231172636151314, 0.031717173755168915, -0.0031749659683555365, -0.02079630270600319, -0.04828866198658943, -0.03036489151418209, 0.07125344127416611, 0.08847648650407791, -0.00018040464783553034, -0.007436906918883324, -0.013633621856570244, 0.004619072191417217, 0.0025287282187491655, -0.0015098453732207417, 0.008144945837557316, -0.008753164671361446, -0.039964500814676285, 0.006263261195272207, -0.02121071331202984, 0.03169306740164757, -0.0168995913118124, -0.09723976999521255, 0.05423576012253761, 0.03426383063197136, -0.022561853751540184, 0.009177827276289463, -0.018986333161592484, 0.016079379245638847, -0.008444237522780895, -0.010777111165225506, 0.022582896053791046, -0.03519260138273239, -0.03155661001801491, -0.021473705768585205, -0.0001721977605484426, 0.01508835144340992, 0.0021384763531386852, -0.012052319012582302, -0.02625129558146, -0.0007291755173355341, 0.047266971319913864, 0.010228941217064857, -0.04602198302745819, -0.009974787011742592, 0.011152113787829876, -0.030215075239539146, -0.02026304416358471, 0.0032530566677451134, -0.0023179869167506695, 0.015844246372580528, -0.02405526489019394, 0.03302175924181938, -0.009576124139130116, 0.03564894571900368, -0.03607156500220299, 0.039059653878211975, 0.044654492288827896, 0.06031172350049019, 0.03903062641620636, 0.011317459866404533, -0.0004224489675834775, 0.06585289537906647, 0.012240615673363209, -0.039917971938848495, 0.002113980706781149, 0.00012055228580720723, 0.017296481877565384, 0.036066751927137375, -0.060401901602745056, 0.0062753185629844666, -0.0096521507948637, -0.02879687398672104, 0.013104608282446861, -0.038577850908041, -0.057887665927410126, 0.01924261264503002, -0.07567417621612549, -0.002163985511288047, -0.07660450786352158, 0.0549808032810688, 0.0034778157714754343, -0.04234660789370537, -0.07326725125312805, 0.028113098815083504, 0.017428487539291382, 0.02509400248527527, -0.09116465598344803, 0.0024088651407510042, -0.01574579067528248, 0.018017616122961044, -0.06532330065965652, 0.016029592603445053, -0.033622875809669495, 0.0008535381639376283, -0.034970562905073166, 0.01668724976480007, -0.0681535005569458, 0.023917654529213905, 0.06281717121601105, -0.04451298341155052, 0.012448250316083431, 0.015589648857712746, -0.018619706854224205, 0.004017180763185024, 0.037239450961351395, -0.03435851261019707, -0.0025369988288730383, 0.004085887689143419, -0.0032810091506689787, 0.010036994703114033, 0.008484206162393093, -0.006634614430367947, -0.04362162947654724, -0.02781497873365879, 0.021508121863007545, -0.027456587180495262, -0.014564750716090202, 0.02782217226922512, -0.044615183025598526, 0.030636204406619072, -0.007850569672882557, 0.006761707365512848, -0.04949815198779106, 0.10039309412240982, 0.05038270726799965, 0.03157711401581764, 0.023204805329442024, 0.01783706806600094, 0.013406312093138695, -0.028260311111807823, 0.01071196235716343, 0.01580941118299961, -0.04877660796046257, 0.017874669283628464, 0.018471630290150642, -0.0751233622431755, -0.003462966764345765, 0.02758319117128849, -0.05451314523816109, -0.0366031713783741, 0.020077303051948547, -0.11749985814094543, -0.015133474953472614, 0.016199689358472824, -0.013882981613278389, 0.02395392209291458, 0.06593228131532669, -0.06347419321537018, 0.037255484610795975, -0.007143279071897268, 0.04122818633913994, 0.033704739063978195, 0.01806187815964222, 0.03157130628824234, -0.02005203627049923, 0.00017969630425795913, -0.017020951956510544, 0.06116228923201561, 0.0023642692249268293, 0.049235738813877106, 0.05384649708867073, 0.028975199908018112, 0.013599506579339504, 0.0027877106331288815, -0.04282252863049507, 0.00733209727331996, 0.01708553545176983, -0.009238088503479958, -0.05600578337907791, 0.024194009602069855, -0.015781112015247345, -0.03141861781477928, -0.015715446323156357, -0.019624844193458557, 0.002570581855252385, 0.008787008933722973, -0.016927121207118034, 0.05695259943604469, -0.0439382940530777, -0.008586487732827663, 0.051008664071559906, 0.028868447989225388, 0.025924038141965866, -0.02202896773815155, 0.012105650268495083, 0.022633245214819908, -0.03634624183177948, -0.015196206979453564, -0.06336656957864761, 0.03549804538488388, 0.041231490671634674, -0.0453839972615242, 0.11149026453495026, 0.03313262760639191, 0.041070207953453064, -0.035366687923669815, 0.05641584470868111, 0.011148475110530853, 0.027374951168894768, 0.012377222068607807, -0.11190124601125717, 0.005378548055887222, 0.037421926856040955, -0.009010792709887028, -0.0026174939703196287, 0.05639088898897171, 0.001190949697047472, -0.004608554299920797, 0.022951632738113403, -0.02003560960292816, -0.005343311466276646, 0.0004817049775738269, 0.03693853318691254, -0.018457233905792236, -0.02569340169429779, -0.0627070814371109, -0.01129526924341917, 0.026725497096776962, -0.04536944627761841, -0.02553037740290165, 0.04419359564781189, 0.005188330076634884, 0.01653359830379486, 0.04133303463459015, 0.03909432888031006, -0.03127467632293701, -0.09146144986152649, 0.018171051517128944, -0.05112549290060997, -0.0025076079182326794, 0.00760220130905509, -0.008974520489573479, 0.044631924480199814, 0.019723279401659966, -0.021363390609622, -0.048439305275678635, 0.031075458973646164, 0.00677262619137764, -0.010211478918790817, -0.0433015413582325, -0.028499476611614227, 0.005074567627161741, 0.06440664827823639, 0.009092397056519985, 0.06940136849880219, -0.010292412713170052, -0.008633289486169815, -0.05118556320667267, -0.016992269083857536, -0.049124229699373245, -0.018023895099759102, -0.04779965430498123, 0.02418636716902256, 0.02520843967795372, 0.019462881609797478, 0.014765980653464794, -0.029910489916801453, -0.07406571507453918, 0.0014707313384860754, -0.017946463078260422, -0.014203374274075031, -0.03956083580851555, -0.008487860672175884, -0.046419184654951096, -0.023024864494800568, -0.018595129251480103, 0.017748048529028893, -0.017723336815834045, 0.0012457204284146428, 0.0062714796513319016, 0.0603129044175148, 0.018085241317749023, -0.03738700971007347, -0.004205120727419853, 0.05223308503627777, -0.016525786370038986, 0.012916338630020618, -0.02909540943801403, -0.0028451899997889996, -0.047929007560014725, -0.06534793972969055, 0.002976124407723546, 0.011145371943712234, 0.08036034554243088, 0.050349220633506775, 0.014033019542694092, -0.010999051854014397, 0.0035618196707218885, 0.0029770086985081434, 0.005054856650531292, -0.006388070527464151, -0.007639899849891663, -0.05173826962709427, -0.05889830365777016, 0.017917824909090996, -0.03014194592833519, -0.08172093331813812, 0.0012220267672091722, 0.051853276789188385, 0.047803401947021484, 0.029563546180725098, -0.0320652574300766, 0.06381265819072723, 0.007945929653942585, -0.0426284484565258, 0.02707511931657791, 0.05843476206064224, 0.037563979625701904, 0.021824557334184647, 0.0101116131991148, 0.0032700879964977503, -0.005147267132997513, -0.009704966098070145, 0.031047863885760307, -0.0736008882522583, -0.012233221903443336, 0.019480440765619278, -0.02747299149632454, -0.008473329246044159, -0.016215357929468155, 0.01581270433962345, -0.02086232416331768, 0.0016808935906738043 ]
<p>Is there any way to affect a particle's momentum value?</p>
g5847
[ -0.0010448356624692678, 0.030153648927807808, 0.0010049656266346574, -0.039339978247880936, 0.08062221854925156, 0.032970599830150604, -0.04913773387670517, 0.02506530098617077, -0.05231174826622009, -0.022994589060544968, 0.012393145821988583, 0.011863801628351212, -0.021802475675940514, 0.03719969093799591, -0.013957432471215725, 0.010753673501312733, 0.11551384627819061, 0.007261230144649744, -0.00926551129668951, 0.03497565910220146, -0.01787768304347992, -0.05706192925572395, -0.019736865535378456, -0.019468527287244797, 0.01888381317257881, -0.01788795180618763, -0.0564202144742012, -0.036179229617118835, -0.05053503438830376, 0.0874202772974968, -0.014021213166415691, -0.025334542617201805, -0.014996584504842758, -0.0042120530270040035, -0.05849195644259453, -0.0467967763543129, 0.05035048723220825, -0.019354917109012604, 0.039325084537267685, 0.03772503137588501, -0.018646059557795525, -0.05232245847582817, 0.017323901876807213, -0.014296116307377815, -0.01912730559706688, 0.03317614644765854, 0.005478432402014732, 0.014567842707037926, -0.04564781114459038, -0.0014442855026572943, -0.0331852100789547, -0.0012131126131862402, -0.01638716831803322, -0.0009671776788309216, 0.032929375767707825, 0.012245088815689087, 0.008692615665495396, 0.020512593910098076, 0.022381840273737907, 0.0815306007862091, -0.002553120721131563, -0.032055020332336426, -0.010266050696372986, 0.02794819511473179, -0.010172951966524124, -0.007994581945240498, -0.05041581764817238, -0.05517007037997246, -0.05829527601599693, 0.02135118655860424, 0.056087762117385864, 0.027048932388424873, -0.056892890483140945, -0.05154867097735405, -0.017538022249937057, -0.0006829085759818554, -0.04922273010015488, -0.0152466194704175, 0.013378432020545006, 0.003011287422850728, -0.02637869119644165, -0.01331286784261465, 0.04251345247030258, -0.049051735550165176, -0.004380844999104738, -0.03744322434067726, 0.06055163964629173, 0.020567212253808975, -0.06348374485969543, -0.0937696173787117, -0.0017448625294491649, -0.04617583751678467, -0.008764279074966908, -0.0006363668944686651, 0.010651960968971252, -0.016100844368338585, -0.012137618847191334, 0.06497369706630707, -0.027660634368658066, 0.01712496019899845, 0.003470559138804674, 0.07766185700893402, 0.015108346939086914, 0.014256010763347149, -0.002623307052999735, -0.03829274699091911, -0.0011747878743335605, 0.0009553158888593316, 0.07781096547842026, -0.07787523418664932, 0.008561469614505768, -0.09189268946647644, 0.014666750095784664, 0.004175629932433367, -0.0889371782541275, -0.10041610896587372, 0.05900542810559273, -0.04446924477815628, -0.09155270457267761, 0.017385657876729965, 0.059925924986600876, 0.042858682572841644, -0.025240221992135048, 0.12343724071979523, -0.011718149296939373, 0.015398258343338966, -0.032165348529815674, 0.018581751734018326, 0.021950822323560715, 0.004965995904058218, -0.0077302842400968075, -0.05078817531466484, -0.016662292182445526, 0.0006513930857181549, -0.08149490505456924, -0.000893924618139863, -0.018720241263508797, 0.0396803542971611, -0.0177009217441082, 0.0032131948973983526, 0.04969308152794838, -0.001411068020388484, 0.06972432136535645, 0.029357226565480232, 0.002407424384728074, -0.033082153648138046, -0.026467397809028625, 0.018556978553533554, 0.0020539613906294107, 0.0509452149271965, 0.06329979747533798, 0.010819170624017715, 0.0003272777539677918, 0.03380144014954567, 0.02051869034767151, 0.012312225066125393, 0.05021147057414055, 0.07444646209478378, -0.02030055783689022, 0.0695154145359993, 0.0558929443359375, 0.03949543461203575, 0.03855272755026817, -0.027145616710186005, -0.04603452980518341, 0.021066272631287575, -0.005446130875498056, -0.011844628490507603, -0.07389508187770844, -0.0156157361343503, -0.03689612075686455, -0.03286784887313843, 0.009013873524963856, 0.0013731119688600302, 0.020872551947832108, 0.00675862655043602, -0.05062384903430939, 0.029778916388750076, 0.046300895512104034, 0.048261258751153946, -0.016627809032797813, 0.003916480112820864, 0.021411987021565437, -0.03105609491467476, 0.0016333882231265306, 0.054044123739004135, -0.06542669236660004, 0.0556454062461853, -0.061248183250427246, -0.006065711844712496, -0.020537003874778748, 0.01415409054607153, -0.010405171662569046, 0.026644056662917137, -0.0017186240293085575, -0.01907176524400711, 0.0354018434882164, -0.01793106645345688, -0.005588136613368988, 0.05197768658399582, -0.000062157581851352, 0.05230585113167763, 0.02737683616578579, 0.034299496561288834, 0.03787258639931679, -0.06327114999294281, 0.03657214716076851, 0.008217173628509045, -0.04045002534985542, -0.022035274654626846, 0.10998917371034622, -0.017455046996474266, -0.02243964374065399, 0.07200253009796143, -0.021995659917593002, -0.010455272160470486, 0.025690041482448578, 0.05137979984283447, 0.046882592141628265, 0.014002094976603985, -0.09945013374090195, -0.001054630964063108, 0.005179376807063818, 0.04405521601438522, -0.04846229404211044, 0.04354856535792351, 0.010185065679252148, 0.0032558361999690533, 0.012339342385530472, 0.07180389761924744, -0.07913938164710999, 0.013755692169070244, -0.029538489878177643, 0.030499564483761787, 0.04704669862985611, 0.05366412177681923, -0.0027956278063356876, -0.0023855804465711117, -0.006248231511563063, 0.005317823030054569, 0.023204369470477104, -0.05576668679714203, -0.013074642978608608, -0.010015073232352734, -0.007373560685664415, 0.0022931748535484076, -0.0172335896641016, 0.009264147840440273, -0.048493970185518265, -0.023491885513067245, 0.026762813329696655, 0.008011788129806519, 0.017093300819396973, -0.013582964427769184, 0.01747976429760456, 0.008278707042336464, -0.04956277832388878, 0.027747830376029015, -0.0532146655023098, -0.016390321776270866, 0.016126152127981186, -0.007384421303868294, 0.01121048629283905, 0.057506587356328964, -0.013015160337090492, 0.01093294844031334, 0.01193214114755392, 0.031222792342305183, 0.010258306749165058, 0.04609811678528786, 0.0006157737807370722, 0.059958793222904205, 0.0004297534469515085, 0.08550991117954254, -0.00998409278690815, 0.016971580684185028, 0.016023335978388786, -0.058856841176748276, 0.013749448582530022, -0.05944036319851875, -0.023943699896335602, 0.05220777541399002, -0.0791439637541771, 0.02913331426680088, 0.01070310641080141, -0.06335358321666718, -0.0025193621404469013, -0.038271449506282806, -0.01419917494058609, 0.022701840847730637, 0.025363819673657417, 0.017975063994526863, 0.026437556371092796, 0.012928571552038193, 0.032981958240270615, 0.023620640859007835, 0.01976882293820381, -0.03614678978919983, 0.0354703813791275, 0.013239596039056778, 0.016842037439346313, -0.007665985729545355, -0.05402093380689621, 0.022673822939395905, 0.022556645795702934, 0.021073870360851288, -0.05883484706282616, 0.054886069148778915, 0.043248746544122696, 0.013039587996900082, -0.04532289132475853, 0.08845920860767365, -0.03261036425828934, 0.003849729197099805, -0.024266008287668228, -0.04047815501689911, -0.02996898628771305, -0.0027183196507394314, -0.0005154335522092879, -0.021542690694332123, 0.004959173500537872, -0.0357646569609642, 0.032512366771698, -0.018316036090254784, 0.030578574165701866, 0.03056151047348976, -0.034884948283433914, 0.020297490060329437, -0.00669201510027051, -0.03195994347333908, 0.02620645798742771, 0.024574188515543938, 0.013267691247165203, -0.03651949763298035, -0.00535084493458271, -0.006077118217945099, 0.0521203987300396, -0.04548340290784836, 0.035125549882650375, 0.009647401981055737, -0.018994620069861412, -0.020877620205283165, -0.04888853803277016, 0.03798418864607811, -0.009115273132920265, -0.016142405569553375, 0.037830814719200134, -0.0005512870266102254, 0.01092912070453167, -0.006280476227402687, 0.034936826676130295, 0.03451943397521973, -0.015952294692397118, 0.0026848686393350363, 0.06758717447519302, 0.00921153649687767, 0.056046951562166214, 0.047748297452926636, -0.032821398228406906, 0.00009468041389482096, -0.021857671439647675, -0.03396937623620033, 0.00852992758154869, 0.03150596097111702, -0.01446767058223486, 0.0448329858481884, -0.047855496406555176, 0.008155168034136295, -0.002726325299590826, -0.008926931768655777, -0.019468240439891815, -0.019674578681588173, -0.0031759669072926044, 0.04072098433971405, -0.014850456267595291, -0.007591775618493557, 0.028824711218476295, -0.031041722744703293, -0.04496743157505989, 0.0348600298166275, 0.016493389382958412, -0.030563829466700554, -0.01085032057017088, 0.023136096075177193, -0.03865163400769234, 0.05125226825475693, -0.06869270652532578, -0.009285135194659233, 0.06815032660961151, 0.00861784815788269, -0.00435144267976284, -0.04929572716355324, -0.038838207721710205, 0.00888961274176836, 0.044176600873470306, -0.00394594669342041, -0.002926166169345379, -0.07404526323080063, 0.027741720899939537, -0.004374121315777302, -0.03956926241517067, 0.0187210850417614, -0.011630634777247906, -0.036018677055835724, 0.04316883534193039, 0.030224034562706947, 0.08201161026954651, 0.01815866120159626, -0.07783587276935577, -0.011130216531455517, -0.014299267902970314, -0.016042251139879227, 0.007575074210762978, -0.02657831460237503, -0.05420558527112007, -0.02143365703523159, -0.06301914900541306, -0.00006203634984558448, 0.038146428763866425, -0.0019583753310143948, 0.037716276943683624, 0.046956866979599, -0.01683526113629341, 0.0021185565274208784, 0.004728623665869236, 0.0031485450454056263, -0.02918410860002041, 0.01642528921365738, -0.020103605464100838, 0.009295900352299213, 0.021129891276359558, 0.0588391050696373, 0.005666377022862434, -0.0074448054656386375, 0.011460432782769203, 0.029271936044096947, -0.013563975691795349, -0.03617417439818382, 0.024873988702893257, 0.06452105939388275, 0.06398226320743561, 0.02661701664328575, 0.008674983866512775, -0.018435148522257805, -0.0026005744002759457, 0.042487770318984985, -0.017825864255428314, -0.016861528158187866, 0.009189730510115623, 0.023411845788359642, -0.04122820869088173, -0.06992632150650024, -0.07051338255405426, -0.022268949076533318, 0.00276770256459713, 0.052542563527822495, -0.04220170900225639, 0.011971106752753258, -0.030365165323019028, -0.01965448074042797, -0.0940643772482872, 0.0061447820626199245, -0.019934989511966705, -0.008322416804730892, -0.004925734829157591, -0.005138427019119263, -0.09205877035856247, 0.023106060922145844, -0.018694059923291206, -0.031364306807518005, 0.02668876014649868, 0.010203327983617783, -0.011258555576205254, 0.05024440214037895, -0.02718609757721424, -0.02317441813647747, -0.040798287838697433, 0.0020577532704919577, 0.017408471554517746, -0.04785525053739548, -0.03669331222772598, 0.002710967091843486, -0.016188668087124825, -0.02320806309580803, 0.007549960166215897, 0.007129781413823366, -0.08132526278495789, 0.043873872607946396, 0.02066102996468544, -0.06839350610971451, -0.0019259944092482328, 0.06607507169246674, 0.0018709806026890874, 0.008284698240458965, 0.02191893942654133, 0.03973294794559479, -0.02320418879389763, -0.001058815629221499, 0.006272824946790934, 0.02151077799499035, -0.012016109190881252, -0.04621385782957077, 0.008060150779783726, -0.008612503297626972, 0.004240849521011114, 0.0061528622172772884, 0.018495729193091393, -0.014935902319848537, -0.024620382115244865, -0.012723641470074654, -0.0020336643792688847, 0.045801665633916855, 0.05742569640278816, -0.015522773377597332, -0.013890208676457405, 0.052733685821294785, -0.024929648265242577, 0.0035536906216293573, -0.03448321297764778, -0.013426749967038631, 0.020180227234959602, -0.0537622794508934, 0.03556938096880913, -0.016848430037498474, -0.01125563494861126, -0.01488023716956377, -0.048877086490392685, -0.0761752724647522, 0.021358510479331017, 0.05492834001779556, 0.0056562828831374645, -0.06793038547039032, 0.021133726462721825, 0.019071169197559357, -0.03362240269780159, -0.09554438292980194, 0.0007228912436403334, 0.04968017712235451, -0.020666874945163727, -0.02067561261355877, 0.02212359756231308, -0.04772890359163284, 0.004271569196134806, 0.055220238864421844, 0.0031579933129251003, 0.0026498278602957726, -0.02361590601503849, -0.012193533591926098, 0.0418177954852581, -0.07347916811704636, 0.0071494863368570805, 0.04246239736676216, -0.05694788694381714, -0.02792087197303772, 0.016931813210248947, 0.024858029559254646, 0.045791201293468475, -0.00904136337339878, 0.02843787893652916, -0.009940255433321, -0.0027449687477201223, -0.06501663476228714, 0.060979440808296204, -0.020197544246912003, 0.033745910972356796, 0.01902376301586628, -0.03964673727750778, -0.03975364938378334, 0.025050809606909752, -0.04349658638238907, -0.019650842994451523, 0.04541601613163948, 0.005565200466662645, -0.031333278864622116, -0.02423905022442341, 0.007713773753494024, -0.022677671164274216, -0.0005817628116346896, -0.03515281155705452, -0.001113411388359964, -0.040087562054395676, 0.0575241893529892, 0.027449678629636765, -0.024118011817336082, -0.0007779198349453509, 0.037973079830408096, -0.02738926373422146, 0.03418263420462608, 0.05814052373170853, 0.049705300480127335, -0.012481783516705036, 0.018270520493388176, -0.035249870270490646, 0.0006582582136616111, -0.014372769743204117, 0.017703639343380928, -0.03890388086438179, 0.0004777055000886321, -0.019385814666748047, 0.052982211112976074, 0.06104452162981033, 0.011688265949487686, -0.012059221975505352, 0.0039350478909909725, -0.014728087931871414, 0.022698936983942986, -0.046739403158426285, 0.0281224362552166, -0.0034153256565332413, 0.01768447458744049, -0.0637122243642807, -0.00822040718048811, 0.032728102058172226, -0.00559431966394186, -0.007945118471980095, -0.04634445533156395, 0.028333226218819618, 0.010308521799743176, -0.014018681831657887, -0.010897119529545307, 0.011896437034010887, -0.021521389484405518, -0.01641298271715641, -0.060203857719898224, 0.07516837120056152, -0.008668778464198112, -0.05757995322346687, 0.011431107297539711, 0.015451469458639622, -0.004987409804016352, -0.011021745391190052, -0.009603874757885933, 0.035343851894140244, -0.008793805725872517, -0.007055249065160751, 0.06832371652126312, -0.001139315078034997, 0.04935554414987564, 0.027919379994273186, 0.05445610359311104, 0.0864303708076477, 0.03370610624551773, 0.013773469254374504, 0.007138995453715324, -0.05697554349899292, -0.0162260290235281, -0.00919845700263977, 0.030143316835165024, -0.02208363637328148, -0.018847115337848663, 0.01159980334341526, 0.008742183446884155, 0.017233816906809807, 0.05004136264324188, 0.027680521830916405, 0.01375565305352211, 0.0004393249982967973, 0.03508034721016884, 0.0542430616915226, 0.0016458792379125953, -0.025360291823744774, -0.06824661046266556, 0.018748672679066658, -0.016722027212381363, 0.03084278106689453, 0.01775241270661354, -0.0011417306959629059, 0.0010023118229582906, 0.020730024203658104, 0.016401883214712143, -0.033360984176397324, -0.07789288461208344, -0.08983855694532394, -0.003629253711551428, 0.011655443347990513, -0.009856028482317924, -0.01513325609266758, 0.0532396174967289, -0.06660531461238861, 0.02451416291296482, 0.06630513072013855, 0.024626921862363815, -0.0015970872482284904, -0.020561303943395615, -0.02556413598358631, -0.011636997573077679, -0.049801796674728394, 0.0414239726960659, -0.00395268015563488, -0.04382918030023575, -0.010592593811452389, 0.008131338283419609, 0.03957716375589371, -0.006400518584996462, -0.059318993240594864, -0.02582431025803089, -0.008470856584608555, 0.054631900042295456, -0.002359875477850437, -0.023722749203443527, -0.008735868148505688, -0.03517661243677139, 0.04185851290822029, 0.0073262471705675125, 0.03360297530889511, 0.01228391658514738, -0.030326779931783676, -0.015758967027068138, -0.058928534388542175, -0.027693312615156174, -0.030074208974838257, -0.011547800153493881, -0.014023419469594955, 0.0128306420519948, 0.015281543135643005, -0.006015978287905455, 0.050603240728378296, 0.04358551278710365, 0.02242451161146164, 0.02452930435538292, 0.01275042723864317, 0.004894401412457228, -0.025298502296209335, -0.00776855880394578, -0.01691710390150547, -0.03522862493991852, -0.039935849606990814, 0.04802381247282028, 0.029750576242804527, 0.06067905202507973, -0.005398517940193415, 0.014659570530056953, -0.04628520458936691, 0.016099784523248672, -0.061475951224565506, -0.009320610202848911, 0.003482891945168376, 0.016772551462054253, -0.0007392826955765486, 0.01886109448969364, -0.053359437733888626, -0.05824942886829376, -0.004891536198556423, 0.030647888779640198, 0.03829823434352875, 0.024461062625050545, -0.005687260068953037, 0.076950803399086, 0.02286360412836075, 0.04354270547628403, -0.009436782449483871, 0.05847784876823425, -0.048431020230054855, 0.04827119782567024, -0.027348076924681664, -0.025713840499520302, -0.06362176686525345, 0.008328884840011597, -0.05780988559126854, -0.07017451524734497, 0.03936036676168442, 0.0153953330591321, -0.009174371138215065, -0.0002501625567674637, -0.007936549372971058, -0.02305503934621811, 0.019377874210476875, -0.015356353484094143 ]
<p>For example, let's consider a $N$ spin-1/2 system on a lattice described by the Hamiltonian $H$. My questions are:</p> <p>(1) If $H$ has <em>either</em> global $SU(2)$ spin-rotation symmetry <em>or</em> time-reversal symmetry, then $\forall $ <strong>finite</strong> $N=$odd, there must be <strong>exact degenerate</strong> ground states (GS). From this point of view, can we infer that in the thermodynamic limit ($N\rightarrow \infty $), the GSs of the above $H$ must be <em>degenerate</em> ??</p> <p>(2) This is a question about the definition of GS degeneracy. Assuming $H$ is <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/4930/what-does-it-mean-for-a-hamiltonian-or-system-to-be-gapped-or-gapless/29166#29166">gapped</a>, such that the GS degeneracy can be well defined. My question is: No matter how the sites number $N$ approaches $\infty $, for instance, either $N(=\text{odd})\rightarrow \infty $ or $N(=\text{even})\rightarrow \infty $, they should both give <strong>the same</strong> (exact or approximate) GS degeneracy in the thermodynamic limit, right ?? Since, at least from the math side, otherwise the GS degeneracy would depend on the <em>way</em> that $N\rightarrow \infty $ and it is thus <em>not</em> well defined.</p> <p>Referring to Q.(2), let's consider the spin-1/2 Kitaev honeycomb model in a gapped phase (i.e., $\left | J_z \right |&gt;\left | J_x \right |+\left | J_y \right |$ and $J_xJ_yJ_z\neq0$). If we take a sequence of sizes of the system $N$=odd (odd number of total spins or total lattice sites) in the thermodynamic limit, such that there always exist exact <strong>Kramer's degeneracy</strong> (due to time-reversal symmetry) as $N$ approaches $\infty $. Therefore, this kind of sequence would give rise to a <strong>ground state degeneracy (Kramer's degeneracy)</strong> in the thermodynamic limit, right? On the other hand, as pointed out by the author, both Lieb's theorem and the author's numerical study suggest that the zero-flux configuration is the <strong>unique</strong> sector minimizing the ground state (GS) energy, indicating that the GS of Kitaev model is <strong>nondegenerate</strong> or <strong>unique</strong>. This is <em>in contrary to</em> the above <strong>Kramer's degeneracy</strong>. While it seems that the original paper didn't mention that what kind of sequence of sizes of the system is chosen as taking the thermodynamic limit. So I guess that a 'reasonable' sequence should be at least ensuring the number of total lattice sites $N=$even (e.g., we may take the number of unit cells $\rightarrow \infty $ for the thermodynamic limit), which make the GS <strong>uniqueness</strong> possible. Is my understanding correct? </p> <p>Thank you very much.</p>
g5848
[ -0.07249683886766434, 0.03439636155962944, 0.003171689109876752, 0.02166215144097805, -0.006408927030861378, -0.012381484732031822, 0.03118402510881424, 0.037310440093278885, -0.020927315577864647, -0.019288117066025734, -0.0018622818170115352, -0.019145159050822258, -0.02316831611096859, 0.006921318359673023, 0.003561008721590042, 0.04435805603861809, 0.0964171290397644, 0.04564645141363144, 0.014838384464383125, 0.04172918573021889, -0.00866690929979086, -0.021005013957619667, 0.0034723293501883745, -0.07798749953508377, 0.011463601142168045, 0.005975100211799145, 0.032872386276721954, -0.018348759040236473, -0.004697146359831095, 0.018016885966062546, -0.0035899882204830647, -0.006820566486567259, 0.029316753149032593, -0.06313914060592651, -0.025177082046866417, 0.046679962426424026, 0.08033812046051025, 0.00808003917336464, 0.01246924139559269, -0.033453669399023056, 0.02346200868487358, 0.006124560721218586, 0.038954395800828934, -0.009677055291831493, -0.06784088164567947, 0.02619856595993042, -0.007318674121052027, -0.0022524064406752586, -0.00009304438572144136, -0.01184188574552536, 0.01752619445323944, 0.058928076177835464, 0.06493852287530899, -0.051039911806583405, 0.011614528484642506, 0.028017470613121986, -0.04458100348711014, -0.01941831409931183, 0.044463638216257095, 0.043614085763692856, 0.018102867528796196, -0.002577020786702633, -0.04398377612233162, 0.03499657288193703, 0.010160068981349468, 0.013746448792517185, -0.06626400351524353, 0.020777415484189987, -0.003568843472748995, -0.026291634887456894, 0.001415171893313527, -0.010087097994983196, 0.032535701990127563, -0.015149785205721855, -0.015105089172720909, 0.047095492482185364, -0.008407928049564362, 0.014343994669616222, 0.06465333700180054, 0.03674041107296944, -0.04697760194540024, 0.0320764034986496, -0.008905099704861641, -0.03206867724657059, -0.00009229496208718047, -0.0387023501098156, -0.015404706820845604, -0.000402847450459376, 0.046678945422172546, 0.05881895497441292, -0.016803929582238197, 0.03827843815088272, 0.05728870630264282, 0.02293417416512966, -0.03206877410411835, 0.03963223099708557, 0.04674408212304115, 0.02427273616194725, -0.052934739738702774, 0.04323630407452583, -0.040905848145484924, -0.015450743027031422, 0.0006260330555960536, -0.016215471550822258, -0.02231958881020546, 0.001692869234830141, 0.0461762435734272, -0.008186737075448036, 0.008173040114343166, -0.040374211966991425, 0.004174340516328812, 0.04030943661928177, -0.042865652590990067, 0.04723050072789192, -0.049097418785095215, 0.014650956727564335, 0.011495189741253853, 0.016290780156850815, -0.05304301902651787, 0.047577399760484695, 0.04354177415370941, -0.0439763180911541, -0.00759109016507864, 0.020720163360238075, -0.023276835680007935, -0.005380783695727587, -0.0556618794798851, -0.022669069468975067, 0.04053856059908867, 0.0085080461576581, -0.009982271119952202, -0.02618262730538845, 0.006413041613996029, 0.03472059220075607, 0.028249045833945274, -0.01598510891199112, 0.06448329240083694, 0.030486678704619408, 0.01474482286721468, -0.005195133853703737, -0.016414398327469826, -0.07161936163902283, -0.027025625109672546, -0.04120370000600815, 0.0013398928567767143, 0.06817993521690369, 0.009403121657669544, -0.03978024423122406, 0.03999771922826767, 0.014208940789103508, -0.009191048331558704, 0.05573967471718788, 0.028117556124925613, -0.005323694087564945, -0.0036691115237772465, -0.03336363285779953, 0.019333334639668465, 0.008291075937449932, -0.0010816832073032856, 0.02435944974422455, 0.04236488789319992, 0.006620433181524277, -0.018982354551553726, -0.0028194666374474764, -0.025680026039481163, -0.0350121334195137, -0.03358835354447365, -0.05356874316930771, -0.0129037294536829, -0.07926463335752487, -0.031132951378822327, 0.020358607172966003, 0.041244301944971085, 0.040208544582128525, -0.0006189118139445782, 0.020424799993634224, -0.036448024213314056, -0.03706465661525726, 0.04898035153746605, -0.021555999293923378, -0.03837210312485695, 0.00033570328378118575, 0.04491320252418518, 0.05527316406369209, -0.05647680163383484, 0.05550190806388855, 0.051936130970716476, -0.017090141773223877, -0.0046821110881865025, 0.010303367860615253, 0.002963986247777939, 0.044528115540742874, -0.03182979300618172, 0.05466613173484802, 0.016839150339365005, -0.0009530651732347906, 0.04789397865533829, -0.049667540937662125, -0.06313495337963104, -0.01880788616836071, 0.036724187433719635, -0.004072442650794983, 0.021196434274315834, 0.0011590056819841266, -0.0066156587563455105, 0.04913405701518059, -0.029699446633458138, 0.0561247244477272, 0.008499093353748322, 0.0061304643750190735, 0.02838216722011566, 0.007118977606296539, -0.03913465514779091, 0.06015988439321518, 0.01717359945178032, -0.061750296503305435, -0.016369841992855072, -0.02987624518573284, 0.055535297840833664, -0.030515268445014954, -0.0002293650177307427, 0.027378402650356293, 0.028186677023768425, 0.06088145449757576, -0.027009332552552223, 0.043955013155937195, -0.013153093867003918, -0.0027368066366761923, -0.03451802209019661, 0.021878838539123535, -0.05016778036952019, 0.02862655557692051, -0.023647502064704895, -0.11090520024299622, 0.020561860874295235, 0.027412116527557373, -0.01101191621273756, -0.015753015875816345, 0.002824212657287717, 0.0010945359244942665, 0.00473852688446641, -0.030469782650470734, -0.0328875370323658, 0.03293376788496971, 0.02077174372971058, -0.020699962973594666, 0.013832846656441689, -0.032670386135578156, 0.04682202637195587, 0.026219327002763748, 0.056738581508398056, 0.01071690209209919, -0.017374271526932716, -0.021717146039009094, -0.017725853249430656, -0.0013495174935087562, -0.024106880649924278, 0.06591901928186417, -0.02652495913207531, -0.06154152378439903, 0.012399445287883282, -0.04192235693335533, -0.002246993128210306, 0.04715543985366821, -0.03856079652905464, 0.010971618816256523, -0.005733448080718517, -0.05933293700218201, -0.03367278724908829, -0.034441765397787094, 0.01519335899502039, 0.08159364759922028, 0.011017831973731518, 0.09673517197370529, -0.04315763711929321, -0.018914682790637016, -0.02397722564637661, -0.04807886853814125, 0.01242924202233553, -0.029115993529558182, -0.05887988582253456, -0.04543179273605347, 0.019054187461733818, 0.050339799374341965, 0.03068753331899643, -0.034325677901506424, -0.022803276777267456, 0.014440987259149551, 0.018416233360767365, 0.05946984142065048, -0.0353144109249115, 0.024463074281811714, 0.11435825377702713, 0.0015950914239510894, -0.03746102750301361, -0.03148585930466652, -0.06413909047842026, -0.02817416377365589, 0.041933365166187286, 0.08442724496126175, 0.07135744392871857, -0.053125739097595215, -0.04435926303267479, 0.010091811418533325, 0.02244757115840912, 0.0041185300797224045, -0.0185841117054224, -0.0028338932897895575, -0.009025626815855503, -0.0029752112459391356, -0.04172700271010399, 0.07711266726255417, 0.025849489495158195, -0.03371185064315796, -0.017838560044765472, 0.09556318819522858, -0.0194080863147974, -0.012554754503071308, 0.03216513246297836, 0.0056043933145701885, -0.0036137488204985857, -0.02772037871181965, -0.002671360271051526, -0.030008982867002487, 0.009149384684860706, 0.039986029267311096, -0.08696938306093216, -0.024642812088131905, -0.11080463230609894, 0.043266452848911285, -0.0007259101839736104, -0.004515886306762695, -0.009506196714937687, 0.010195346549153328, -0.034710969775915146, -0.03974767029285431, -0.03724196180701256, -0.021147381514310837, 0.04887903109192848, -0.0057747988030314445, -0.08907106518745422, 0.0210020262748003, 0.02988039143383503, 0.010138056240975857, 0.0639384537935257, -0.014817919582128525, -0.040761735290288925, -0.01828068681061268, -0.061581000685691833, 0.0719662681221962, 0.017503878101706505, -0.02683206833899021, 0.0446053110063076, -0.013661322183907032, -0.03681918606162071, -0.00217591249383986, -0.0059396084398031235, 0.0818488821387291, -0.023271918296813965, -0.007356906309723854, 0.04711494967341423, -0.05594002455472946, 0.07003821432590485, -0.0323927104473114, 0.023571733385324478, 0.05554540827870369, 0.02743283472955227, -0.024530690163373947, 0.04615141823887825, -0.07218697667121887, 0.00035862997174263, -0.0179654099047184, 0.018210487440228462, -0.04590349644422531, 0.0468740239739418, -0.03939841687679291, 0.04376790672540665, 0.026884639635682106, -0.059928204864263535, 0.013424301519989967, 0.04727489873766899, -0.003966475836932659, 0.042419277131557465, 0.03354876860976219, 0.012684246525168419, 0.01555077638477087, 0.007047083228826523, 0.00044153290218673646, -0.07150481641292572, -0.060648441314697266, -0.021306883543729782, 0.024087756872177124, -0.0005579019198194146, 0.054093822836875916, -0.014759195037186146, -0.014596243388950825, 0.008306065574288368, -0.012279579415917397, -0.01809649169445038, 0.06913158297538757, -0.00042269332334399223, -0.05626210197806358, -0.08217508345842361, -0.05649568885564804, 0.04358837753534317, -0.05837060883641243, -0.021490849554538727, -0.050789736211299896, -0.02725047431886196, -0.04029961675405502, -0.008661989122629166, -0.004815362859517336, 0.07167588919401169, -0.016945961862802505, 0.011662703938782215, -0.01917860470712185, -0.025894755497574806, -0.03262424096465111, 0.04815245047211647, -0.024737108498811722, 0.06391719728708267, 0.04897936433553696, 0.00931380596011877, -0.0030487121548503637, 0.03903018683195114, -0.029212964698672295, -0.010847847908735275, -0.012147900648415089, -0.023417504504323006, -0.06138189136981964, 0.02263951674103737, 0.010165554471313953, -0.0017036816570907831, 0.02420695684850216, -0.06596136838197708, -0.0015813991194590926, -0.046593982726335526, 0.027495549991726875, -0.009675751440227032, 0.07215651869773865, 0.04768930375576019, 0.012656835839152336, 0.006029164418578148, 0.004451236687600613, -0.00215353025123477, 0.01268776599317789, -0.030538778752088547, -0.003580385120585561, -0.0010714931413531303, -0.017172956839203835, -0.021027326583862305, -0.0006302274996414781, -0.01099119521677494, 0.009937784634530544, -0.001576212584041059, -0.05178605020046234, -0.04550822451710701, 0.08401329070329666, -0.02590104565024376, 0.023733027279376984, -0.017404705286026, -0.04606098309159279, 0.026863398030400276, -0.004467892926186323, -0.004930265247821808, 0.029503004625439644, -0.05298934504389763, 0.03850887715816498, -0.040697578340768814, -0.0035559439565986395, 0.0003987408708781004, -0.001177069265395403, 0.023919612169265747, 0.043929100036621094, 0.002709649968892336, 0.025291332975029945, -0.026909830048680305, -0.04524704068899155, -0.007058996241539717, 0.020529475063085556, -0.044066667556762695, 0.017042797058820724, 0.023777145892381668, 0.07577496021986008, 0.02056024968624115, 0.02259557880461216, 0.030381223186850548, -0.03311740979552269, -0.03981400653719902, 0.007301121484488249, 0.007899494841694832, -0.016431529074907303, 0.018775440752506256, 0.03466939181089401, 0.003509489819407463, -0.004981092177331448, 0.022891661152243614, -0.041356880217790604, -0.05277302488684654, -0.02330271154642105, 0.012723803520202637, 0.020961711183190346, 0.04814283177256584, 0.07783679664134979, -0.0026021699886769056, 0.03258718550205231, 0.07653467357158661, -0.0565803162753582, -0.051564618945121765, -0.0453302338719368, -0.03130640834569931, 0.006203690078109503, 0.07068990170955658, 0.03539430722594261, 0.06462100893259048, -0.024107923731207848, -0.06511668860912323, -0.017692754045128822, 0.0038107968866825104, -0.07610391825437546, 0.01719471998512745, 0.03608231991529465, 0.02482949197292328, -0.05197644606232643, -0.006478324998170137, 0.017320511862635612, -0.027728894725441933, -0.03523530066013336, -0.037170637398958206, 0.06394746899604797, 0.01380690187215805, -0.0002704366052057594, -0.0312543585896492, 0.01225595735013485, -0.009170089848339558, 0.030640961602330208, -0.03664245456457138, 0.026398541405797005, 0.005740903317928314, 0.003851574379950762, -0.023789314553141594, -0.048427075147628784, 0.025307457894086838, 0.008428317494690418, -0.006245160009711981, -0.05730574205517769, -0.012572838924825191, -0.08406023681163788, -0.02055872231721878, 0.013776647858321667, -0.05494679510593414, -0.028613831847906113, 0.02243196591734886, -0.07439888268709183, -0.001881555188447237, 0.0371641144156456, 0.013015580363571644, 0.0016457460587844253, 0.033643562346696854, 0.01638934761285782, 0.01298515871167183, 0.0031294142827391624, 0.006278481800109148, 0.022001244127750397, 0.027962705120444298, 0.010262434370815754, -0.04192658141255379, -0.04403194412589073, 0.017128102481365204, -0.005087755154818296, 0.021998368203639984, -0.005734819918870926, 0.019120140001177788, -0.0015503856120631099, 0.021035078912973404, -0.005310878623276949, -0.043826740235090256, -0.035832300782203674, -0.045339446514844894, 0.040709421038627625, -0.03008326329290867, -0.0468691848218441, -0.00237527908757329, -0.014876851812005043, -0.01433686725795269, 0.038704849779605865, -0.020555589348077774, 0.012580674141645432, -0.002680982928723097, 0.001026773825287819, -0.02180713415145874, -0.0010552618186920881, -0.008394373580813408, 0.022662322968244553, 0.013996156863868237, 0.01051554549485445, 0.024638162925839424, -0.050717905163764954, -0.05756170675158501, 0.01309910137206316, -0.008634286001324654, -0.07460629194974899, 0.04407450929284096, -0.05555136501789093, -0.03194175660610199, 0.04296015575528145, -0.0343162901699543, 0.023469608277082443, -0.020050309598445892, -0.014950888231396675, 0.01379543635994196, -0.03854801505804062, 0.012929286807775497, -0.017934085801243782, 0.008653703145682812, -0.05948686599731445, 0.04353638365864754, -0.01950899139046669, 0.010450280271470547, 0.013040679506957531, -0.0003825714811682701, -0.011688548140227795, -0.04220246151089668, -0.028679342940449715, 0.041137173771858215, 0.04042044281959534, -0.017960811033844948, 0.028401145711541176, 0.02398931235074997, 0.03466314449906349, 0.08575737476348877, 0.006085614673793316, -0.06849057972431183, -0.0010929388226941228, 0.020704150199890137, 0.026788949966430664, -0.05810040235519409, 0.04378422349691391, 0.024303557351231575, -0.02453458495438099, -0.03511485084891319, 0.008924482390284538, -0.0047459290362894535, 0.050873514264822006, 0.04313403740525246, 0.04471831023693085, -0.029111865907907486, -0.01253222394734621, -0.020214520394802094, 0.01871521957218647, 0.01525904517620802, -0.05472322180867195, -0.09975118190050125, 0.03815298154950142, 0.00021230720449239016, -0.00392848439514637, 0.016375279054045677, -0.024696704000234604, 0.060238707810640335, -0.033191975206136703, 0.007752244360744953, -0.009011860005557537, 0.0008585072937421501, -0.018900057300925255, -0.06523678451776505, 0.06874646991491318, 0.018833277747035027, 0.00679570809006691, 0.0061350008472800255, -0.036638952791690826, 0.013635793700814247, -0.05813995376229286, -0.027990687638521194, -0.005959542468190193, -0.037836287170648575, 0.0009188564145006239, 0.028588395565748215, 0.033163126558065414, 0.02788163535296917, -0.01274445466697216, 0.02471722476184368, 0.04883940517902374, -0.019119255244731903, 0.00804037693887949, -0.004471577238291502, 0.015887945890426636, -0.0470605306327343, 0.010225015692412853, -0.017545780166983604, -0.0022235666401684284, -0.012415176257491112, 0.020366724580526352, -0.017361775040626526, 0.0666179284453392, 0.014871126040816307, 0.015483022667467594, -0.0036593787372112274, 0.04218680039048195, -0.015913577750325203, -0.010465290397405624, 0.05968545004725456, 0.030576692894101143, -0.04406378045678139, 0.04514419287443161, -0.025343157351017, 0.0010204408317804337, 0.004008547402918339, -0.04593030735850334, -0.009393416345119476, -0.009443933144211769, 0.010093390010297298, 0.018593087792396545, -0.010920461267232895, 0.0146873090416193, 0.046889498829841614, 0.04755505546927452, -0.07199960201978683, -0.05023663863539696, 0.07748029381036758, -0.011551715433597565, -0.03573589026927948, -0.04075738042593002, 0.00242508202791214, -0.025094879791140556, -0.03818851709365845, -0.07068443298339844, 0.015230358578264713, -0.00527750700712204, 0.040333814918994904, 0.04739950969815254, -0.004039337392896414, 0.0197896845638752, -0.03367772325873375, 0.04552589729428291, 0.0019382837926968932, 0.00830414891242981, -0.050358954817056656, -0.0739765465259552, 0.0284061711281538, 0.010345078073441982, -0.04298786818981171, 0.00630550691857934, 0.03226560354232788, -0.00524550536647439, 0.0180086400359869, 0.07031618803739548, -0.0387348048388958, 0.041571710258722305, -0.021275965496897697, -0.04334094002842903, -0.04298441484570503, -0.009741115383803844, 0.05627130717039108, 0.013501524925231934, 0.013654216192662716, 0.008311871439218521, 0.021639281883835793, 0.056016914546489716, -0.03304019570350647, 0.031127754598855972, -0.007158888503909111, -0.006389736197888851, -0.020660627633333206, 0.02753819152712822, -0.020677756518125534, -0.0657636746764183, -0.06142148748040199, 0.02789582498371601 ]
<p>In <a href="http://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?47559" rel="nofollow">the 1944 SF story “Off the Beam” by George O. Smith</a>, an electron gun is constructed along the length of a spaceship. In order to avoid being constrained by a net charge imbalance, it is built to also fire the same number of protons in the other direction, dissipating the mass of the “cathode”.</p> <p>With current knowledge, is this plausible? That is,</p> <ul> <li>Can a practical (i.e., not built with unobtanium insulators) electrostatic device like an electron gun separate and accelerate electrons and protons in this manner?</li> <li>Can it actually disassemble solid matter? If so, how does the composition of the cathode affect the difficulty?</li> </ul>
g5849
[ 0.0015637283213436604, 0.06194620579481125, -0.010494631715118885, -0.016916222870349884, 0.05372290685772896, 0.025161275640130043, -0.07130295783281326, 0.054513413459062576, -0.03369934856891632, -0.0035707808565348387, -0.0026877832133322954, -0.004557764157652855, 0.0014221728779375553, 0.010413754731416702, 0.04253594949841499, 0.014361477456986904, 0.08461938798427582, -0.015913954004645348, 0.008353893645107746, 0.050551410764455795, 0.06215597316622734, 0.01667998731136322, -0.0002231827238574624, -0.0521206371486187, 0.004073831718415022, 0.002895601559430361, -0.02358296327292919, -0.0496336966753006, -0.026812393218278885, -0.04618086665868759, -0.0059090256690979, -0.06475195288658142, -0.02758174203336239, -0.04591760039329529, -0.0784936398267746, -0.046263039112091064, 0.029277892783284187, 0.02323952317237854, 0.004173903726041317, -0.015665996819734573, -0.02808854915201664, -0.007519523613154888, -0.018968993797898293, -0.03919508308172226, 0.0634704977273941, 0.05554088205099106, 0.0356355756521225, -0.02043173648416996, -0.0479649193584919, -0.029479119926691055, -0.05703026428818703, 0.01882036030292511, -0.03240794315934181, -0.029428930953145027, 0.03197770193219185, 0.00004859841283177957, -0.043218862265348434, 0.014932134188711643, 0.07968886941671371, 0.00026458947104401886, 0.009406439028680325, 0.017506932839751244, 0.003776624333113432, -0.018040018156170845, 0.02354079857468605, -0.02792668342590332, -0.028935888782143593, 0.029817016795277596, 0.023237524554133415, -0.037264805287122726, 0.01672980934381485, -0.06025434657931328, -0.06509522348642349, -0.019932424649596214, 0.0017365890089422464, 0.039646927267313004, -0.0056390115059912205, 0.030810661613941193, 0.009609520435333252, 0.02464960888028145, -0.026164749637246132, -0.009497017599642277, 0.0009900815784931183, 0.003369311336427927, 0.04944019019603729, 0.009352161549031734, -0.004363871645182371, 0.01142360270023346, -0.023226618766784668, 0.0015268930001184344, -0.007029979955404997, 0.016077036038041115, 0.01979723945260048, -0.02529243566095829, -0.06196305528283119, 0.023582467809319496, -0.010879868641495705, -0.005243715364485979, -0.01921294815838337, -0.005198560189455748, -0.03766750544309616, -0.07852841913700104, 0.02118792198598385, -0.03854997456073761, -0.013063701801002026, -0.004955569747835398, 0.02116614580154419, -0.007068702019751072, 0.004402064718306065, -0.011536657810211182, -0.011713712476193905, -0.07669100165367126, -0.06675435602664948, -0.03691722825169563, 0.013620981946587563, 0.027219325304031372, 0.05593620613217354, -0.03775004670023918, -0.03630356118083, -0.019342288374900818, 0.014833603985607624, 0.01205277070403099, -0.04987223818898201, -0.012762987986207008, -0.07170732319355011, -0.024822918698191643, -0.010266752913594246, 0.028828155249357224, 0.043962206691503525, 0.020160196349024773, -0.03933609649538994, -0.005545967724174261, -0.021138155832886696, -0.010835539549589157, -0.05126651003956795, 0.03737897053360939, -0.014291919767856598, -0.005685782991349697, -0.016679750755429268, -0.04427468776702881, 0.05241908133029938, -0.011161149479448795, -0.04538093879818916, 0.04119305685162544, 0.0022530248388648033, 0.0646023228764534, -0.03077743947505951, 0.05869441106915474, 0.000124177779071033, 0.09322188794612885, -0.03251670300960541, 0.015613322146236897, 0.026848264038562775, 0.004674902185797691, 0.060264140367507935, -0.028742212802171707, 0.10766275227069855, -0.02318844199180603, 0.0031201522797346115, -0.05190232768654823, 0.0023948794696480036, -0.0140409916639328, -0.029614267870783806, -0.0011935703223571181, -0.044072624295949936, -0.03410864248871803, 0.03898320347070694, -0.017842719331383705, 0.06885186582803726, -0.006219831760972738, -0.03306869789958, -0.02455485612154007, 0.029957205057144165, 0.07500497996807098, 0.03956767916679382, 0.037894077599048615, 0.04816180095076561, -0.016142774373292923, -0.03542299196124077, -0.012082215398550034, -0.011979336850345135, 0.028251389041543007, 0.005075021181255579, 0.01949998177587986, 0.001249378197826445, 0.005355966743081808, -0.023950817063450813, 0.046573325991630554, 0.025032175704836845, 0.010733512230217457, -0.016409877687692642, 0.03795041888952255, -0.06175319477915764, 0.04615741968154907, 0.008808718994259834, -0.04962768033146858, -0.015059771947562695, 0.02894051931798458, 0.046471007168293, -0.028018545359373093, -0.0035081945825368166, 0.06616920232772827, -0.05026806518435478, 0.05570778250694275, 0.10620477795600891, -0.07652255147695541, -0.05651741847395897, -0.04768979921936989, 0.015775704756379128, 0.0280644278973341, 0.10997101664543152, 0.019902238622307777, 0.0034217708744108677, 0.015551136806607246, 0.03356926515698433, -0.07346391677856445, -0.005501860287040472, 0.009006225503981113, -0.035600773990154266, -0.0108218714594841, -0.03127047419548035, -0.02356642112135887, 0.02884512022137642, -0.005097309127449989, 0.022586490958929062, -0.02403216063976288, 0.021867182105779648, -0.005129433237016201, -0.05582575500011444, -0.00936068594455719, -0.01689581200480461, 0.07466548681259155, -0.011170207522809505, -0.05712408572435379, 0.0489029586315155, 0.049353498965501785, 0.0037212586030364037, 0.00671648932620883, -0.027058590203523636, -0.0032574692741036415, 0.0396796353161335, -0.04483398422598839, -0.01530041266232729, -0.0644383430480957, 0.03201298415660858, -0.056948669254779816, 0.03628034144639969, 0.04481213539838791, -0.039622943848371506, -0.0394570492208004, 0.009039053693413734, -0.04500548914074898, -0.079749196767807, -0.0025749437045305967, -0.03684931993484497, -0.055650871247053146, -0.0005713278660550714, 0.006702621467411518, -0.05681350827217102, -0.024740027263760567, 0.019389094784855843, -0.0129232844337821, -0.032508205622434616, 0.02441360242664814, -0.07146304100751877, -0.0020502512343227863, 0.007815410383045673, 0.003916042856872082, 0.0753968358039856, 0.003476383863016963, 0.02905985340476036, 0.009605810046195984, 0.027944592759013176, 0.012105603702366352, -0.020655518397688866, 0.03318522498011589, 0.012559414841234684, -0.0810631811618805, 0.052514951676130295, 0.010483486577868462, 0.0028619340155273676, 0.04234422743320465, -0.08960483223199844, 0.02031022123992443, 0.01733989268541336, 0.005801237188279629, -0.010492189787328243, -0.05135970190167427, 0.0004198361129965633, 0.0317251943051815, -0.05336218327283859, -0.029320506379008293, 0.0466768704354763, -0.0416969433426857, 0.023986581712961197, -0.022165831178426743, -0.004186559468507767, -0.05405433475971222, -0.02079208940267563, -0.017206747084856033, -0.005491988267749548, -0.031039034947752953, -0.043674249202013016, 0.019494574517011642, -0.009635998867452145, 0.036867737770080566, -0.054328519850969315, 0.024471202865242958, -0.05012618750333786, -0.0178147554397583, 0.006549007259309292, 0.024442261084914207, 0.06003069877624512, 0.07535075396299362, -0.045769281685352325, -0.036115892231464386, 0.008842812851071358, -0.024781495332717896, 0.024462753906846046, 0.03906236216425896, -0.04399440810084343, 0.014128764159977436, 0.025376299396157265, -0.03314577043056488, 0.027690459042787552, 0.049914147704839706, 0.04853580519556999, -0.008677738718688488, 0.010374965146183968, 0.030454590916633606, 0.01991613768041134, 0.006841171067208052, 0.04887526482343674, -0.008178798481822014, -0.029702194035053253, 0.01923339255154133, 0.05915777012705803, 0.06058775261044502, 0.032089319080114365, 0.011838583275675774, 0.00620273407548666, 0.000491046579554677, -0.023603850975632668, -0.011560644023120403, -0.03644265979528427, 0.03029833361506462, 0.0037494509015232325, -0.02339497022330761, 0.016552934423089027, -0.03612419217824936, 0.04701123386621475, -0.019095422700047493, 0.03557940945029259, 0.011979606002569199, 0.01830650120973587, -0.008928805589675903, -0.011798250488936901, 0.05586163327097893, 0.010735392570495605, 0.030661029741168022, -0.025405695661902428, -0.017213499173521996, 0.03510601818561554, -0.02663109079003334, -0.011662811040878296, -0.009470188990235329, -0.03343624621629715, 0.045820485800504684, -0.06331969052553177, -0.03817809745669365, -0.02758289873600006, -0.05654321610927582, -0.01341145858168602, -0.0035513907205313444, -0.010118614882230759, 0.026759473606944084, 0.04988805577158928, 0.0010747886262834072, -0.05689045041799545, 0.005267214961349964, -0.012402617372572422, 0.040468811988830566, 0.06933905184268951, -0.020450038835406303, -0.016368240118026733, 0.01210781093686819, -0.04944756627082825, -0.024580296128988266, -0.0515119731426239, -0.05354582518339157, 0.05040602385997772, -0.028744123876094818, -0.06502702832221985, -0.0027069407515227795, -0.005179548170417547, 0.021326111629605293, -0.01941196620464325, -0.04038149490952492, -0.006776178255677223, -0.00929223746061325, 0.07101298868656158, 0.081093929708004, 0.012529865838587284, -0.01437321212142706, 0.018474891781806946, 0.03650585561990738, 0.017495352774858475, -0.05133925750851631, -0.04021582752466202, -0.05535071715712547, 0.019188791513442993, -0.005298918578773737, -0.020956993103027344, -0.012644646689295769, -0.02010197564959526, -0.052318502217531204, -0.028065362945199013, 0.05945389345288277, -0.019100360572338104, -0.008781730197370052, 0.018569666892290115, 0.06623177975416183, 0.04721202328801155, 0.013850855641067028, -0.02520507574081421, 0.04107659310102463, 0.03207268938422203, 0.03109617717564106, 0.00952202919870615, 0.015529457479715347, 0.005725933704525232, -0.012348217889666557, -0.00246084644459188, -0.004409976303577423, -0.011933495290577412, -0.01509864442050457, -0.028679337352514267, 0.03404293581843376, -0.02820401079952717, 0.10397687554359436, 0.04840037599205971, -0.030365144833922386, 0.020139051601290703, 0.006563567090779543, 0.05886787548661232, 0.01676223799586296, -0.06825007498264313, 0.00528469355776906, -0.06870882958173752, -0.005406923126429319, -0.001379102119244635, -0.061180006712675095, -0.05267593264579773, -0.008546674624085426, 0.017421945929527283, 0.006731552537530661, -0.052270423620939255, -0.019736148416996002, 0.037427257746458054, 0.07296093553304672, -0.03588922321796417, -0.05150667950510979, 0.05605242773890495, 0.020701568573713303, 0.01829010806977749, -0.037066761404275894, -0.06115132197737694, -0.035227932035923004, -0.04780087620019913, 0.04520975053310394, -0.0007290021749213338, 0.02419469505548477, 0.00330934370867908, 0.028322583064436913, -0.017679588869214058, -0.055507734417915344, 0.0019401698373258114, -0.011925209313631058, -0.06789306551218033, 0.0040041361935436726, 0.01856297440826893, 0.014234805479645729, -0.01682804897427559, -0.05425749346613884, -0.0003233898605685681, -0.002346352906897664, 0.011706015095114708, 0.017479106783866882, -0.004709606058895588, -0.05314967408776283, 0.0009053839021362364, 0.013749143108725548, 0.015787692740559578, -0.021161509677767754, 0.025346938520669937, -0.00011230424570385367, 0.0593828447163105, -0.043273624032735825, -0.01289101131260395, 0.05529968440532684, 0.03407847881317139, -0.019677244126796722, -0.030519019812345505, 0.023022226989269257, 0.00888882391154766, -0.013789218850433826, 0.03843710571527481, -0.026336761191487312, -0.051203757524490356, 0.015543621964752674, -0.0013600739184767008, 0.03558541461825371, 0.018357226625084877, -0.005201533902436495, 0.05283311754465103, -0.05756346508860588, -0.01476619765162468, -0.00294502847827971, 0.003341920441016555, -0.028049811720848083, 0.03899231553077698, 0.027364272624254227, -0.0028408202342689037, -0.015868792310357094, -0.013148432597517967, 0.025389637798070908, 0.011207853443920612, -0.020421287044882774, 0.018742425367236137, 0.06106814742088318, 0.07421451061964035, -0.0012937852879986167, -0.02094608172774315, -0.03412169590592384, -0.035787343978881836, -0.042123790830373764, -0.01980784349143505, 0.04524345323443413, 0.019832825288176537, 0.012355883605778217, -0.01756749302148819, -0.012258685193955898, 0.02326437272131443, 0.1011977270245552, 0.047151967883110046, -0.01115469541400671, -0.04535234719514847, 0.021320765838027, 0.0793965682387352, -0.0798567607998848, -0.04795660451054573, -0.017742184922099113, -0.008828307501971722, -0.004524856805801392, 0.02210385911166668, -0.007954160682857037, 0.023835787549614906, -0.028504423797130585, 0.035793937742710114, -0.06668533384799957, 0.008034934289753437, 0.03195810317993164, 0.023239709436893463, 0.04182363674044609, 0.02341964840888977, -0.009799188002943993, 0.006828939076513052, 0.021787159144878387, 0.00496716657653451, 0.023629631847143173, 0.003354207379743457, -0.013446560129523277, -0.037208009511232376, 0.0244920551776886, 0.047475121915340424, -0.04865565150976181, 0.028707625344395638, 0.013655411079525948, 0.0005899967509321868, 0.04464061185717583, -0.0023231704253703356, 0.018900007009506226, -0.019870851188898087, 0.027000799775123596, -0.03702003136277199, 0.02526317723095417, -0.016430867835879326, 0.01846238784492016, 0.046952035278081894, -0.06880989670753479, 0.045104917138814926, -0.04416581615805626, 0.008163061924278736, -0.016380038112401962, -0.09855597466230392, 0.04625905677676201, 0.022544723004102707, -0.006639956030994654, 0.03669428825378418, 0.030698759481310844, 0.006650070659816265, 0.08345356583595276, 0.006995534989982843, 0.03638572618365288, 0.07773284614086151, 0.03261325880885124, 0.016878195106983185, 0.05406857281923294, 0.006208581849932671, -0.007759389001876116, -0.024153320118784904, 0.06199605017900467, -0.017057232558727264, -0.032962534576654434, -0.0018289663130417466, -0.011446278542280197, -0.012877976521849632, 0.0309331975877285, 0.0068579125218093395, 0.0644460991024971, 0.013599395751953125, -0.026629377156496048, -0.022601500153541565, 0.019179143011569977, -0.016924036666750908, -0.021433718502521515, 0.01851009763777256, 0.013784143142402172, 0.055823326110839844, 0.04326159507036209, -0.011863086372613907, 0.004788021091371775, 0.04509831964969635, 0.008922858163714409, 0.02551036700606346, 0.033734459429979324, -0.02777089551091194, 0.06476844847202301, 0.03382366895675659, -0.014315381646156311, -0.02334597334265709, -0.023869244381785393, 0.025676188990473747, 0.05249166488647461, -0.07239864021539688, 0.0604851171374321, 0.052755095064640045, -0.06693946570158005, -0.03595007583498955, -0.007878714241087437, -0.056423984467983246, -0.029337016865611076, -0.06304009258747101, -0.05445503070950508, -0.02099221758544445, 0.020985782146453857, -0.00673525920137763, 0.012320337817072868, 0.0006719075608998537, -0.05666561424732208, 0.015305536799132824, -0.015890641137957573, 0.05956125259399414, -0.07234832644462585, 0.027568349614739418, 0.017635416239500046, -0.046426642686128616, -0.008974883705377579, -0.0267353355884552, -0.01951279118657112, -0.0191524438560009, -0.041574761271476746, -0.05151243507862091, -0.005056662485003471, 0.011453626677393913, 0.006685442756861448, 0.04050542414188385, 0.016757171601057053, 0.01871206983923912, -0.0018326709978282452, 0.009384178556501865, 0.07907943427562714, -0.0018859992269426584, 0.03871816769242287, -0.03606557101011276, -0.022860117256641388, -0.039366792887449265, 0.047232918441295624, 0.049286242574453354, -0.02264418639242649, 0.06584112346172333, 0.005131118465214968, 0.06774680316448212, -0.009813901036977768, 0.053528375923633575, 0.0042146858759224415, 0.011411141604185104, 0.04082716256380081, 0.06425406783819199, -0.019650747999548912, -0.019041037186980247, 0.03843497857451439, 0.0326552614569664, 0.013809057883918285, 0.013057860545814037, 0.03725482150912285, -0.004017157014459372, -0.00912412814795971, -0.0058163488283753395, -0.047750018537044525, 0.005107232369482517, 0.0431831032037735, -0.016535263508558273, -0.010132348164916039, 0.0595439076423645, -0.00860018189996481, -0.0056915609166026115, 0.051842525601387024, 0.03531699627637863, 0.05784854665398598, -0.016453392803668976, 0.02109384909272194, 0.020832329988479614, 0.0007524861139245331, 0.010703831911087036, -0.02177933230996132, 0.006648925133049488, 0.005873131565749645, 0.014978663995862007, -0.026809431612491608, -0.01866576075553894, -0.005913270637392998, -0.0035365051589906216, -0.021770521998405457, 0.0577312596142292, -0.03399910405278206, -0.027109619230031967, -0.052069567143917084, -0.03670003265142441, -0.026865163818001747, 0.022722091525793076, -0.04157600924372673, -0.03235206753015518, -0.06561913341283798, -0.02474754862487316, 0.0065675717778503895, -0.06593965739011765, 0.025144211947917938, 0.01966598816215992, 0.02314099483191967, 0.04598270356655121, -0.027096103876829147, -0.03261851519346237, -0.02787325531244278, 0.058646250516176224, -0.04984888806939125, -0.028042737394571304, 0.004148759879171848, 0.01869654282927513, -0.010066543705761433, 0.006593223195523024, -0.021964527666568756, -0.04212801158428192, -0.016403596848249435, -0.03808828443288803, -0.052167195826768875, 0.0010997873032465577, -0.0019033419666811824 ]
<p>I was trying to reproduce example 3.3 of <a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/0001106v1.pdf" rel="nofollow">Quantum Computation by Adiabatic Evolution</a> by Edward Farhi et. al. This is an adiabatic algorithm to solve an instance of three qubits 2-SAT problem.</p> <p>I think I have created the initial Hamiltonian, $H_B$ correctly.</p> <p>$$H_B = \left(\frac{1}{2}\left(I_2 - \sigma_x \right)\right)\otimes I_2\otimes I_2+I_2\otimes \left(\frac{1}{2}\left(I_2 - \sigma_x \right)\right)\otimes I_2+\left(\frac{1}{2}\left(I_2 - \sigma_x \right)\right)\otimes I_2\otimes I_2+I_2\otimes I_2\otimes \left(\frac{1}{2}\left(I_2 - \sigma_x \right)\right)+I_2\otimes \left(\frac{1}{2}\left(I_2 - \sigma_x \right)\right)\otimes I_2+I_2\otimes I_2\otimes \left(\frac{1}{2}\left(I_2 - \sigma_x \right)\right)$$</p> <p>When I evaluate it, the matrx is:</p> <p>$$H_B=\left( \begin{array}{cccccccc} 3 &amp; -1 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 \\ -1 &amp; 3 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 \\ -1 &amp; 0 &amp; 3 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 \\ 0 &amp; -1 &amp; -1 &amp; 3 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 \\ -1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 3 &amp; -1 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 \\ 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 3 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 \\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; 3 &amp; -1 \\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; -1 &amp; 3 \\ \end{array} \right)$$</p> <p>According to the example, the unique satisfying assignment is $011$. The problem Hamiltonian is a sum of three sub-Hamiltonians each correspond to a clause.</p> <p>$$H_P = H^{12}_{imply} + H^{13}_{disagree}+H^{23}_{agree}$$</p> <p>Here are my results for sub-Hamiltonians.</p> <p>$H^{12}_{imply}$ clause can be satisfied with any of $00$, $01$ or $11$. So,</p> <p>$$H^{12}_{imply} = I_8 - \left(\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}\right)\left(|000\rangle+|001\rangle+|010\rangle+|011\rangle+|110\rangle+|111\rangle\right)\right) \left(\left(\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}\right)\left(|000\rangle+|001\rangle+|010\rangle+|011\rangle+|110\rangle+|111\rangle\right)\right)\right)^{\dagger} $$</p> <p>The ground state of this Hamiltonian satisfies the assignment constraint.</p> <p>$H^{13}_{disagree}$ clause can be satisfied with any of $01$ or $10$. So,</p> <p>$$H^{13}_{disagree} = I_8 -\left(\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)\left(|001\rangle+|011\rangle+|100\rangle+|110\rangle\right)\right) \left(\left(\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)\left(|001\rangle+|011\rangle+|100\rangle+|110\rangle\right)\right)\right)^{\dagger}$$</p> <p>The ground state of this Hamiltonian satisfies the assignment constraint.</p> <p>$H^{23}_{agree}$ clause can be satisfied with any of $00$ or $11$. So,</p> <p>$$H^{23}_{agree} = I_8 - \left(\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)\left(|001\rangle+|011\rangle+|100\rangle+|110\rangle\right)\right) \left(\left(\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)\left(|001\rangle+|011\rangle+|100\rangle+|110\rangle\right)\right)\right)^{\dagger}$$</p> <p>The ground state of this Hamiltonian satisfies the assignment constraint.</p> <p>So, $$H_P = \left( \begin{array}{cccccccc} \frac{17}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} \\ -\frac{1}{6} &amp; \frac{7}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{2}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{2} &amp; 0 &amp; -\frac{2}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} \\ -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; \frac{17}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} \\ -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{2}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; \frac{7}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{2} &amp; 0 &amp; -\frac{2}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} \\ 0 &amp; -\frac{1}{2} &amp; 0 &amp; -\frac{1}{2} &amp; \frac{5}{2} &amp; 0 &amp; -\frac{1}{2} &amp; 0 \\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 3 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 \\ -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{2}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{2}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{2} &amp; 0 &amp; \frac{7}{3} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} \\ -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -\frac{1}{6} &amp; \frac{17}{6} \\ \end{array} \right)$$</p> <p>This Hamiltonian, which represents the instance of the problem is expected to be satisfied only with the assignment 011. So, the ground state should be $|011\rangle$.</p> <p>But in reality, the ground eigenvalue is greater than $0$ and the ground state is $\left(1,4,1,4,3,0,4,1\right)^{\dagger}$.</p> <p>Here, $I_n$ is the $n \times n$ identity matrix.</p> <p><strong>What was I doing wrong?</strong> <a href="http://bit.ly/1rrfICz" rel="nofollow">My Mathematica code is available here</a>.</p>
g5850
[ 0.02086658589541912, 0.0005977290566079319, 0.005843379069119692, -0.022412121295928955, 0.021514447405934334, -0.009575522504746914, 0.050137683749198914, -0.0014199838042259216, -0.0547085739672184, 0.07054119557142258, 0.005946569610387087, 0.0630003809928894, -0.03221258521080017, 0.0068607088178396225, -0.016034452244639397, 0.082565076649189, 0.06974799185991287, 0.010369166731834412, 0.03897392749786377, -0.016855495050549507, -0.027754396200180054, 0.0727781280875206, -0.021199755370616913, -0.015654459595680237, 0.014335689134895802, -0.06030948832631111, -0.0007841113256290555, -0.0758604109287262, -0.02707274630665779, 0.018293747678399086, 0.003077322617173195, 0.038043130189180374, 0.06496910005807877, -0.048690684139728546, -0.016413545235991478, -0.0047722794115543365, 0.09479065984487534, 0.019484564661979675, -0.012926521711051464, -0.044031329452991486, -0.011168994009494781, -0.039577461779117584, 0.0005863986443728209, 0.00197257986292243, -0.036268748342990875, -0.06259042769670486, 0.02649766020476818, 0.024236299097537994, -0.01034451276063919, 0.02590157464146614, 0.027644988149404526, 0.03706268221139908, 0.06059647351503372, -0.033634740859270096, 0.027329562231898308, 0.08022485673427582, -0.0463014654815197, -0.03775438293814659, -0.00017254737031180412, 0.019262682646512985, 0.000227243042900227, -0.07777875661849976, 0.04440498352050781, -0.01399302389472723, 0.012024822644889355, -0.01129962783306837, 0.011181282810866833, -0.0018560887547209859, 0.0010029947152361274, 0.013931697234511375, -0.007424195762723684, -0.05131091549992561, 0.025271134451031685, 0.01770859584212303, 0.04188342019915581, -0.01925075612962246, 0.04517703875899315, 0.008451970294117928, -0.002048879163339734, 0.002219474408775568, -0.0203119907528162, -0.026528533548116684, -0.008830669336020947, -0.027592727914452553, -0.02660379558801651, 0.025667818263173103, -0.02441631816327572, 0.016264084726572037, 0.0001543784310342744, -0.0024453941732645035, -0.038064952939748764, 0.012093457393348217, 0.04572642594575882, -0.002442560624331236, -0.02395753562450409, 0.017344264313578606, -0.018870050087571144, 0.0779152661561966, -0.013771831057965755, 0.014208491891622543, -0.046962905675172806, -0.004148291423916817, 0.01824873872101307, -0.008992860093712807, -0.02115538902580738, 0.005896028596907854, 0.01072162389755249, 0.06026701629161835, -0.017549807205796242, 0.04135415703058243, 0.004498658236116171, 0.07233325392007828, 0.01130207534879446, -0.022717587649822235, -0.049342382699251175, 0.02019469067454338, 0.005039222538471222, -0.02216213010251522, 0.02060563676059246, 0.012867746874690056, -0.007479019928723574, 0.00020175740064587444, 0.03942105174064636, -0.01797189936041832, -0.012641718611121178, -0.016203375533223152, -0.04561031982302666, -0.011166224256157875, 0.026666680350899696, -0.022018585354089737, -0.006174081936478615, -0.027616988867521286, 0.011524340137839317, 0.013761683367192745, -0.010081876069307327, -0.00012807841994799674, -0.016481516882777214, 0.010520881973206997, 0.014195865951478481, 0.041013095527887344, -0.023945298045873642, -0.026248715817928314, -0.026425952091813087, -0.026407968252897263, -0.02779749035835266, -0.02302580140531063, 0.03171636536717415, -0.026930613443255424, 0.012951686978340149, 0.011475364677608013, -0.009441898204386234, 0.030768219381570816, 0.004828152246773243, 0.028911177068948746, -0.009388061240315437, 0.053371939808130264, 0.0483393669128418, -0.02614508755505085, 0.007459576241672039, 0.02749697118997574, 0.023912472650408745, 0.006460771895945072, 0.021850649267435074, 0.005125975236296654, 0.010891160927712917, 0.07721751928329468, -0.0026743614580482244, -0.02725139632821083, 0.07190049439668655, -0.023860406130552292, -0.02907119318842888, -0.05408704653382301, 0.014692826196551323, 0.028237884864211082, -0.006837440654635429, 0.06765995174646378, -0.003932442050427198, 0.034930042922496796, 0.032672371715307236, 0.03416048735380173, 0.021463995799422264, -0.006631302647292614, -0.010453257709741592, 0.020508602261543274, -0.01213757786899805, 0.03396952524781227, -0.00412270613014698, 0.020495431497693062, -0.014460970647633076, -0.0493423156440258, -0.033892665058374405, 0.050964970141649246, 0.037905290722846985, 0.034039273858070374, -0.024226350709795952, 0.04806151241064072, 0.050336167216300964, -0.0820387452840805, 0.011410295963287354, -0.029402602463960648, 0.03076527826488018, 0.03628760948777199, 0.044843658804893494, -0.03827338293194771, 0.0163346566259861, -0.02675171010196209, 0.01187183242291212, -0.002699883421882987, -0.0318816676735878, 0.02256845124065876, -0.047062404453754425, 0.016515621915459633, -0.0337655134499073, 0.04732381924986839, 0.033259931951761246, -0.049554239958524704, 0.038332659751176834, 0.031241174787282944, -0.018055278807878494, 0.016265293583273888, 0.011308460496366024, -0.008355747908353806, 0.021245718002319336, -0.012372584082186222, -0.035813480615615845, 0.011864735744893551, -0.048493243753910065, -0.009671448729932308, -0.07338787615299225, -0.007143585477024317, -0.007355649024248123, 0.019117446616292, -0.007263716775923967, -0.05324873700737953, 0.03625186160206795, 0.05572975054383278, 0.002506641671061516, -0.00726742809638381, 0.01420503668487072, 0.026584047824144363, -0.017089273780584335, 0.028457781299948692, 0.0040008737705647945, -0.03628769516944885, 0.06784181296825409, 0.0003401408903300762, 0.02974477782845497, 0.010049068368971348, -0.04927832633256912, 0.006381618324667215, -0.004151394125074148, -0.04736283794045448, -0.04551215469837189, -0.043905068188905716, -0.006424682680517435, -0.02478725090622902, 0.03547761216759682, -0.023655736818909645, 0.03523631766438484, -0.025361554697155952, -0.023261073976755142, -0.024018337950110435, -0.012795405462384224, 0.027960825711488724, -0.011377496644854546, 0.010489900596439838, 0.026156650856137276, -0.10001865029335022, -0.010429243557155132, -0.04011814668774605, -0.017100712284445763, 0.045089371502399445, -0.03320956602692604, 0.0376058928668499, 0.0022560313809663057, -0.022326763719320297, 0.0034230335149914026, 0.020382309332489967, -0.027186671271920204, 0.0048637171275913715, -0.046878132969141006, -0.04298991709947586, -0.024496102705597878, 0.06040012091398239, 0.04410290718078613, -0.04301399365067482, -0.023682672530412674, 0.01944371685385704, -0.01414902787655592, 0.0010448249522596598, 0.021283626556396484, 0.000004248239747539628, 0.029520308598876, 0.007542664650827646, 0.0009434075327590108, -0.02035742625594139, -0.009015283547341824, -0.0480702668428421, 0.015256602317094803, 0.08822519332170486, 0.012208301573991776, 0.0595366545021534, -0.0032921291422098875, -0.008236635476350784, 0.08383622020483017, -0.0405607670545578, -0.02965700440108776, -0.03353120759129524, 0.0030598146840929985, -0.0015675610629841685, -0.0025083364453166723, -0.043311309069395065, 0.0021808724850416183, -0.018618203699588776, -0.05114186927676201, -0.008045436814427376, -0.019118065014481544, -0.04955611377954483, 0.046765636652708054, -0.09227286279201508, -0.03355560451745987, -0.017941785976290703, -0.012459591962397099, -0.012539402581751347, 0.07075835019350052, 0.004206947050988674, -0.11004818230867386, -0.020021677017211914, -0.026578616350889206, -0.056151553988456726, -0.017371119931340218, 0.04351697489619255, -0.007956456393003464, -0.0008263166528195143, -0.026180319488048553, -0.11738739162683487, -0.01739473082125187, 0.017748380079865456, 0.022303719073534012, -0.012105708010494709, -0.0030256446916610003, 0.0004967155982740223, 0.06855367124080658, -0.05599919334053993, -0.0182777252048254, -0.013722340576350689, -0.0010844928910955787, 0.04080089181661606, 0.01577701047062874, -0.0007907372200861573, 0.06698161363601685, -0.03626006841659546, 0.033474598079919815, 0.05832483991980553, 0.0019076375756412745, 0.022807125002145767, -0.027722179889678955, 0.043669067323207855, 0.012295009568333626, -0.028348255902528763, -0.005654818378388882, -0.031281717121601105, 0.007642270531505346, 0.05845770612359047, 0.04522594437003136, -0.005872419103980064, -0.026867596432566643, 0.023457709699869156, 0.041398949921131134, -0.022144990041851997, 0.01994059421122074, -0.05161084979772568, 0.021021056920289993, -0.05778545141220093, 0.06206222623586655, -0.04727550223469734, 0.016667332500219345, -0.03033525124192238, -0.018633436411619186, 0.011476270854473114, 0.0008299108594655991, 0.01660333387553692, -0.005650226026773453, 0.022207191213965416, 0.019971909001469612, 0.037716954946517944, -0.004478816408663988, -0.013812878169119358, -0.09947444498538971, 0.021893003955483437, -0.016219748184084892, -0.03466375172138214, -0.016557106748223305, 0.018925676122307777, -0.011151120066642761, 0.02210446260869503, 0.04256153479218483, -0.019192731007933617, -0.021217379719018936, 0.07111188024282455, -0.09633376449346542, -0.020653316751122475, -0.06157780811190605, 0.030123533681035042, -0.07409732043743134, -0.050565604120492935, 0.009845121763646603, 0.0088962959125638, 0.037133995443582535, 0.012461025267839432, -0.019282951951026917, -0.015403696335852146, 0.006699653808027506, -0.003691373858600855, -0.022772571071982384, -0.014999483712017536, 0.009772288613021374, 0.00683854054659605, 0.004497790243476629, -0.024292947724461555, 0.01123171765357256, 0.06351406872272491, 0.0521918423473835, -0.022810233756899834, 0.029709255322813988, -0.003768299240618944, 0.009763810783624649, -0.00885823555290699, 0.05983775854110718, 0.037852782756090164, -0.014850996434688568, 0.014722778461873531, 0.04100729897618294, 0.015781516209244728, -0.05739196762442589, -0.02248401753604412, -0.043291348963975906, 0.004038040526211262, -0.013544186018407345, -0.012804556638002396, 0.09585251659154892, 0.026777779683470726, -0.04993639886379242, 0.003918073605746031, 0.04466089606285095, 0.0203756932169199, -0.06106336787343025, -0.04596887156367302, -0.0038477701600641012, 0.00014705240027979016, 0.05287802219390869, 0.017765475437045097, 0.018317708745598793, 0.05087481811642647, -0.038805168122053146, -0.026378564536571503, -0.061294373124837875, 0.040715403854846954, -0.005793045274913311, 0.09514224529266357, -0.06517218053340912, -0.0040583242662250996, -0.05541020259261131, 0.03872201219201088, 0.027534952387213707, -0.05001257359981537, -0.032829511910676956, 0.05354753136634827, -0.017932286486029625, -0.05488196015357971, 0.018122555688023567, 0.011171994730830193, 0.03469514846801758, -0.029027098789811134, -0.06931185722351074, -0.0028243453707545996, 0.032482512295246124, -0.009319708682596684, 0.0536842942237854, 0.009732497856020927, -0.00628609349951148, 0.025530364364385605, 0.050220850855112076, 0.04964064434170723, 0.03998260572552681, -0.03361691161990166, 0.025476491078734398, -0.04661461338400841, -0.015895692631602287, -0.03696947917342186, 0.025745674967765808, -0.00559508940204978, 0.03644288703799248, 0.018216636031866074, -0.018649840727448463, 0.0000506440264871344, 0.013944778591394424, -0.0108748534694314, 0.002217349363490939, -0.002719078678637743, -0.07673552632331848, 0.02569887787103653, -0.009660549461841583, 0.011070960201323032, -0.020102111622691154, 0.005481040570884943, 0.050724711269140244, 0.014987594448029995, 0.0034701842814683914, -0.01370212621986866, -0.05142340809106827, -0.032935235649347305, 0.03207411989569664, -0.023843642324209213, 0.04244093969464302, 0.01779010146856308, 0.04724760353565216, 0.011734704487025738, -0.031019216403365135, -0.06663230061531067, 0.07699686288833618, 0.019488753750920296, 0.012625173665583134, -0.02348688803613186, 0.05037279427051544, 0.007818360812962055, -0.05062790587544441, -0.09937616437673569, -0.01805349811911583, 0.08327482640743256, -0.01788371242582798, 0.0640886053442955, -0.02635890804231167, -0.0025396710261702538, 0.03928936645388603, 0.013824069872498512, -0.04905864968895912, -0.013865848071873188, 0.019769083708524704, 0.00996080506592989, 0.03580419346690178, -0.06591366976499557, -0.0016072987345978618, 0.04360225796699524, -0.07020261883735657, -0.017987241968512535, -0.046630728989839554, -0.018913887441158295, 0.02674678899347782, -0.021182263270020485, -0.015640869736671448, -0.026989314705133438, -0.0517224483191967, -0.06371675431728363, 0.03719443082809448, 0.033538948744535446, -0.009801370091736317, 0.008798615075647831, 0.020921269431710243, 0.030099909752607346, -0.009384967386722565, -0.00667148269712925, 0.041608937084674835, -0.024396227672696114, 0.017585039138793945, 0.02100992016494274, -0.008437195792794228, 0.028540655970573425, -0.0007326948107220232, 0.011046802625060081, -0.021924760192632675, 0.028023898601531982, -0.0084808599203825, -0.015543900430202484, 0.03152575343847275, 0.016467353329062462, -0.04862328618764877, -0.07392638921737671, -0.05343130975961685, -0.017339732497930527, -0.05003830045461655, 0.04365546628832817, 0.040528152137994766, -0.027452746406197548, -0.03378697484731674, 0.052960239350795746, -0.01218604389578104, 0.01992574706673622, 0.0372852198779583, -0.028405411168932915, -0.06345254927873611, 0.02230929769575596, -0.05683622881770134, -0.0490441732108593, -0.014956970699131489, 0.031109096482396126, 0.08804818987846375, -0.06497793644666672, -0.05211099237203598, 0.006941432133316994, 0.05079970881342888, -0.008093221113085747, 0.05224166065454483, 0.0044848122633993626, -0.03519022464752197, 0.052421700209379196, -0.029357613995671272, -0.0296026598662138, -0.041063711047172546, 0.008915318176150322, -0.021716643124818802, 0.018519911915063858, 0.00873493030667305, 0.02143525891005993, -0.01154550351202488, -0.07959951460361481, 0.039635416120290756, 0.046687353402376175, 0.01160688791424036, -0.01710212603211403, 0.04769596830010414, 0.03404233977198601, 0.01785028725862503, -0.027890492230653763, -0.0012611921411007643, 0.04634329676628113, 0.02493092231452465, 0.010493546724319458, 0.008315091021358967, -0.0031014280393719673, 0.039832424372434616, -0.010375994257628918, -0.02070523239672184, 0.03984811529517174, -0.007002903148531914, -0.04819733649492264, -0.045119766145944595, 0.019759124144911766, -0.013938311487436295, 0.04826483502984047, -0.009442252106964588, 0.06848184019327164, 0.028617816045880318, -0.01943083107471466, -0.04417206719517708, 0.0034265024587512016, 0.017687296494841576, 0.02217578887939453, -0.08545275777578354, 0.01694495789706707, 0.06873395293951035, 0.03789381682872772, -0.026891088113188744, 0.026592468842864037, 0.01363557018339634, -0.0244270209223032, -0.032103635370731354, -0.028407366946339607, 0.017588438466191292, -0.0037296442314982414, -0.05547916516661644, -0.028731994330883026, 0.018429534509778023, 0.06627938896417618, 0.06492647528648376, 0.049032799899578094, 0.011215800419449806, -0.0006925953784957528, 0.015159949660301208, -0.04859311506152153, -0.024241989478468895, -0.035145312547683716, -0.011933301575481892, 0.04181478172540665, -0.003275591880083084, -0.023086700588464737, 0.020238107070326805, 0.08976194262504578, -0.020837347954511642, -0.08665157854557037, -0.007513823918998241, 0.024422507733106613, 0.006719441153109074, -0.02491161972284317, -0.009524406865239143, 0.006246716249734163, -0.01966002769768238, -0.025726893916726112, -0.030185658484697342, 0.02308735065162182, 0.014660578221082687, 0.020095154643058777, 0.02713802270591259, 0.02686074562370777, 0.007510949391871691, 0.02817584201693535, 0.050868887454271317, -0.013166505843400955, 0.11390767246484756, 0.02680540457367897, -0.0004834613937418908, -0.03376007080078125, 0.012809980660676956, -0.01350115891546011, -0.024804359301924706, -0.011823926120996475, 0.014600098133087158, 0.014602319337427616, -0.018534192815423012, -0.02664312534034252, -0.03380279242992401, 0.010038071312010288, -0.02236134745180607, -0.02296016551554203, 0.07062185555696487, -0.009418599307537079, -0.02856067568063736, 0.05684961378574371, 0.01422584056854248, -0.05144251510500908, -0.00483162933960557, -0.03420101851224899, -0.09020248800516129, 0.019370367750525475, -0.033949144184589386, -0.04962585121393204, 0.026463733986020088, -0.006281069479882717, 0.011729580350220203, -0.04337172582745552, -0.02954298071563244, -0.02588801085948944, -0.0526244230568409, 0.03640664368867874, 0.0024340911768376827, 0.04699763283133507, -0.01584087871015072, -0.012215724214911461, 0.03742239996790886, 0.01712210290133953, -0.03992442041635513, -0.017827743664383888, 0.038352902978658676, -0.08077197521924973, 0.034863103181123734, -0.058787859976291656, -0.06791235506534576, 0.042242057621479034, 0.07586584985256195, -0.07104796916246414, -0.030765360221266747, 0.004914907272905111, -0.04271218553185463, -0.0064473929814994335, 0.02956222929060459, 0.007784685585647821, 0.05288980156183243, 0.01589711755514145, 0.07343731820583344, 0.00612449599429965, -0.08969438821077347, -0.037988658994436264, -0.01692850887775421, -0.028777584433555603, 0.00050289899809286, -0.054460156708955765, -0.0018500430742278695, 0.034503161907196045 ]
<p>A radio antenna creates EM waves through switching the polarization in the antenna at a certain frequency. I assume the the energy of the photons produced in this process amount to E=hf for each photon. So good so far, but classically, i read that the EM field is an oscillation of the electric field between positive and negative values, as would seem reasonable from what the antenna is doing. If individual photons simply have a single positive energy relating to the frequency of the wave, how is this positive-negative oscillation represented in that stream of photons?</p> <p>I guess to put it simply, how is a changing electric field represented in a stream of photons in general, and from a radio antenna specifically?</p>
g5851
[ -0.01910097524523735, 0.024241281673312187, -0.027208726853132248, 0.007127448916435242, 0.03797784447669983, 0.015727633610367775, 0.013293646275997162, 0.024461697787046432, -0.028153467923402786, 0.01570812426507473, 0.015449507161974907, 0.038298629224300385, 0.06127312406897545, -0.04805673658847809, 0.011269922368228436, -0.04495910555124283, 0.04326208308339119, 0.04829398915171623, 0.006247350014746189, 0.022459041327238083, 0.0004024742229375988, 0.019934704527258873, -0.004640393890440464, -0.039724692702293396, -0.02778904139995575, 0.007791254203766584, 0.050700072199106216, -0.031075425446033478, -0.017717568203806877, -0.05325814336538315, -0.027955470606684685, 0.009006080217659473, 0.036462053656578064, -0.015483781695365906, -0.06758078932762146, -0.007876209914684296, -0.022357115522027016, 0.0708179622888565, -0.03157963976264, 0.06624117493629456, 0.0478159599006176, -0.011772911064326763, -0.016485918313264847, -0.0014985392335802317, 0.03141966462135315, -0.03879887983202934, 0.024870997294783592, 0.04285477474331856, 0.0026832805015146732, -0.02065645344555378, -0.016256853938102722, -0.02458146959543228, 0.008537827990949154, 0.007960869930684566, 0.05622371658682823, 0.02424454875290394, 0.0065891738049685955, -0.010775409638881683, 0.06758259981870651, 0.0033852802589535713, -0.03672268986701965, 0.006181708537042141, -0.007359302137047052, 0.0023811832070350647, 0.032767437398433685, 0.0041160620748996735, -0.029732169583439827, -0.02217504009604454, -0.04499318450689316, 0.013920736499130726, -0.0077958437614142895, 0.006684341933578253, -0.05573451891541481, 0.02209515869617462, 0.013251119293272495, 0.007249557413160801, -0.0030965656042099, -0.006762093864381313, 0.01319270022213459, 0.028369789943099022, 0.0028785844333469868, 0.012510519474744797, -0.013519291765987873, -0.012761218473315239, 0.06842108070850372, 0.04023829475045204, 0.021600645035505295, -0.00631385063752532, -0.005535197909921408, -0.07504107058048248, -0.007180618122220039, -0.019647793844342232, 0.04596387594938278, -0.008981537073850632, 0.00030399509705603123, -0.035925716161727905, -0.044362202286720276, 0.06543885171413422, -0.027388134971261024, -0.006765491794794798, 0.02566307969391346, -0.03896092623472214, -0.012911047786474228, -0.01864783838391304, -0.05351864919066429, 0.0411495566368103, -0.01575520634651184, -0.04261934012174606, 0.02307254448533058, 0.012378690764307976, -0.06765501946210861, -0.023916590958833694, -0.05881596729159355, -0.019549855962395668, -0.03975312411785126, -0.02014913223683834, 0.06564673781394958, -0.024765118956565857, -0.01631658524274826, 0.065399669110775, 0.0015286548295989633, -0.02330627106130123, -0.03889002650976181, 0.03691329434514046, 0.028768636286258698, 0.0343572162091732, -0.01060683373361826, 0.023870522156357765, 0.05218452215194702, 0.012502788566052914, 0.00923627708107233, -0.013838943094015121, -0.01683231256902218, -0.032378118485212326, 0.05510234087705612, 0.011615495197474957, 0.047143109142780304, -0.011347003281116486, 0.04251832515001297, -0.05553813651204109, 0.03504142910242081, -0.039604440331459045, 0.024376310408115387, -0.06523393839597702, -0.023290909826755524, 0.0655713751912117, 0.014522450044751167, -0.03296353295445442, 0.052239857614040375, 0.05409613624215126, 0.01585877314209938, 0.04417816549539566, -0.00425415625795722, -0.08084016293287277, 0.06668674200773239, -0.023224249482154846, 0.0015992820262908936, 0.021817190572619438, -0.058643776923418045, 0.0007085271063260734, 0.08909643441438675, -0.02418445236980915, 0.08385311812162399, 0.003256774041801691, -0.037074699997901917, 0.01286855898797512, -0.041304949671030045, 0.008080500178039074, -0.0271742083132267, 0.005970506463199854, 0.049163613468408585, -0.04136572778224945, -0.030708931386470795, -0.03223416209220886, -0.021742230281233788, 0.05546294152736664, 0.05632532387971878, -0.021887987852096558, 0.02696509100496769, 0.03836248442530632, -0.07539960741996765, -0.025354556739330292, 0.03583449125289917, -0.021816859021782875, 0.02806069143116474, -0.025594471022486687, -0.04391911253333092, 0.04224530607461929, -0.10759001225233078, -0.0007629687315784395, -0.03205551579594612, 0.026443136855959892, -0.03000424988567829, 0.013243825174868107, -0.029152093455195427, -0.00935401301831007, -0.006026660092175007, -0.023795032873749733, 0.04894713684916496, 0.040451716631650925, 0.00005362676893128082, 0.07154927402734756, 0.004245941527187824, 0.07055747509002686, 0.026694606989622116, -0.044136904180049896, 0.009497134014964104, -0.028533166274428368, -0.01708533614873886, -0.026796715334057808, 0.00702362647280097, -0.014073913916945457, 0.022238411009311676, -0.0062972609885036945, 0.01713033765554428, 0.04859799146652222, -0.031311556696891785, 0.0041280644945800304, -0.018215779215097427, -0.018846867606043816, -0.04829249531030655, -0.03712930530309677, 0.019967688247561455, -0.022643612697720528, -0.045442789793014526, -0.02772551402449608, -0.050450779497623444, -0.015458494424819946, -0.010650116950273514, 0.02824893407523632, -0.07130734622478485, 0.07156383991241455, -0.05186021700501442, -0.041460875421762466, 0.0037712936755269766, 0.000052980612963438034, -0.008657771162688732, 0.031793415546417236, 0.017326053231954575, -0.06188958138227463, 0.011954446323215961, -0.03938727453351021, 0.0035299472510814667, 0.051741670817136765, -0.038428161293268204, -0.052674517035484314, 0.07805006951093674, -0.029509399086236954, -0.049348264932632446, 0.02898324653506279, 0.030081916600465775, -0.048034366220235825, -0.005736634135246277, 0.060355521738529205, -0.009518280625343323, -0.07344736903905869, -0.07995780557394028, 0.04728960618376732, -0.03540124371647835, 0.058880969882011414, -0.013003941625356674, -0.06006757542490959, -0.0012923514004796743, 0.06271963566541672, -0.013020701706409454, -0.059988658875226974, 0.03632652759552002, -0.004252052400261164, 0.024474751204252243, -0.035460151731967926, -0.019053777679800987, 0.03455013409256935, -0.028195278719067574, -0.0016890008701011539, 0.0008583356393501163, -0.09917981177568436, 0.010877996683120728, -0.017182962968945503, 0.0020828917622566223, -0.035257529467344284, 0.02609059028327465, 0.011516273953020573, -0.0186015572398901, -0.01494122389703989, -0.03542263060808182, -0.09903175383806229, 0.04363179951906204, 0.0037690557073801756, -0.04016025736927986, 0.06070590019226074, -0.039137765765190125, 0.018960412591695786, 0.014194456860423088, -0.05447233468294144, -0.06086340919137001, -0.0064277322962880135, 0.03881807625293732, -0.04310346022248268, -0.034171245992183685, 0.07032139599323273, -0.0031053058337420225, 0.014964219182729721, -0.040658582001924515, -0.055288925766944885, 0.05190538242459297, 0.03385232761502266, -0.06371739506721497, -0.03652721643447876, 0.04707110673189163, 0.0021781488321721554, -0.03191431239247322, 0.016380731016397476, -0.0016432860866189003, -0.006243465468287468, -0.035502977669239044, -0.003034105757251382, -0.04822060838341713, 0.023999599739909172, 0.028301719576120377, 0.022169534116983414, -0.07252594083547592, -0.03233049809932709, 0.019290972501039505, -0.021830836310982704, 0.02219994366168976, 0.024529125541448593, 0.030246829614043236, 0.024656031280755997, -0.03339263051748276, -0.01888119988143444, 0.0034746320452541113, -0.04640363156795502, -0.040106162428855896, -0.0015277342172339559, 0.0346071757376194, 0.005051090847700834, -0.037183672189712524, -0.014850073494017124, -0.02904975414276123, -0.015690088272094727, 0.021111834794282913, -0.03262535482645035, -0.048663657158613205, -0.040266066789627075, -0.0053161634132266045, 0.01333551574498415, -0.023616299033164978, -0.029750579968094826, 0.04826803877949715, -0.0651729553937912, -0.03900861740112305, -0.0031894962303340435, 0.0004123728722333908, 0.048476822674274445, -0.050003498792648315, 0.01459833886474371, -0.004101237747818232, 0.00013561508967541158, 0.03854033350944519, 0.037966322153806686, -0.008739897981286049, -0.07646894454956055, 0.05127890780568123, 0.00934462621808052, -0.05080607533454895, 0.007083703763782978, -0.04075351357460022, 0.03369996324181557, -0.028344079852104187, 0.007389598060399294, 0.011487831361591816, -0.07195412367582321, -0.029514089226722717, 0.004157230723649263, -0.0054130591452121735, -0.015437351539731026, 0.0017570429481565952, 0.04377761110663414, 0.01692773588001728, 0.055800534784793854, -0.08031834661960602, -0.00846200529485941, 0.03458055108785629, -0.010740987956523895, 0.02514605224132538, 0.040069110691547394, 0.0009753044578246772, 0.0017303607892245054, 0.009082878939807415, 0.01222629752010107, -0.03314181789755821, -0.016446327790617943, -0.0058805919252336025, 0.0013350776862353086, 0.06637421995401382, -0.03617178648710251, 0.0017662846948951483, -0.03285602852702141, 0.03155191242694855, 0.045034460723400116, 0.059422705322504044, 0.07726515829563141, 0.019190289080142975, -0.013736346736550331, 0.021189749240875244, 0.02940387651324272, 0.04120534285902977, -0.02739134430885315, -0.06208719313144684, -0.03809717670083046, -0.017481807619333267, 0.03766539692878723, 0.0390782356262207, -0.05816427245736122, 0.017430128529667854, 0.0829537957906723, 0.04644761234521866, -0.025661667808890343, 0.05334565415978432, -0.01701844111084938, 0.07804165035486221, 0.02959773689508438, -0.006924964487552643, -0.015314477495849133, 0.006814538035541773, 0.10330361872911453, 0.0821007490158081, 0.0178860891610384, 0.020581059157848358, -0.041432932019233704, -0.004105753265321255, 0.014388383366167545, 0.052401404827833176, 0.03439799323678017, -0.037858996540308, 0.025839857757091522, -0.0349380224943161, -0.0249976497143507, 0.011308722198009491, 0.04274517670273781, 0.0998292937874794, -0.05465400964021683, 0.0013581247767433524, -0.04190225526690483, 0.005616764072328806, 0.0074288430623710155, -0.021750401705503464, -0.02657461352646351, -0.03531648591160774, 0.02331298030912876, 0.004950434900820255, 0.0760110393166542, 0.0041599213145673275, -0.07436855882406235, -0.009417252615094185, 0.022712450474500656, -0.01167908962816, -0.03473864123225212, 0.0201424453407526, -0.010786748491227627, -0.025490155443549156, 0.03742736577987671, 0.006904803682118654, 0.02255629189312458, 0.049288954585790634, -0.004133875481784344, -0.04492596536874771, -0.02178049087524414, -0.0361289419233799, -0.016769366338849068, 0.04869797080755234, 0.012065090239048004, 0.004980496130883694, -0.00571901211515069, -0.0004639853141270578, -0.0469808503985405, -0.06955976784229279, -0.05134972557425499, -0.016794495284557343, 0.02097635343670845, 0.0237391646951437, -0.04684797301888466, 0.015389270149171352, -0.0020471198949962854, -0.0528440959751606, -0.014207998290657997, -0.0035143322311341763, 0.04392862319946289, 0.0006820925045758486, -0.05316072329878807, -0.022890791296958923, 0.017343934625387192, 0.029671071097254753, -0.031504709273576736, -0.03308039903640747, -0.030372608453035355, -0.014006183482706547, 0.011796564795076847, -0.06773511320352554, -0.04460520297288895, -0.0350584052503109, -0.0010854420252144337, -0.059477683156728745, 0.0065445746295154095, 0.02134440653026104, 0.011327479034662247, 0.01566433347761631, 0.0017085932195186615, 0.025783957913517952, 0.03512353450059891, 0.013258476741611958, -0.009952696040272713, -0.03226501867175102, 0.03169069439172745, 0.030168307945132256, -0.02685748226940632, -0.08405771106481552, 0.03922481834888458, -0.03747957572340965, 0.011697988025844097, -0.021343650296330452, 0.006230102386325598, 0.03430480882525444, -0.03074321523308754, 0.04058004170656204, 0.03873395547270775, -0.08672279119491577, 0.003820568323135376, 0.0684872716665268, -0.016068998724222183, 0.034822799265384674, 0.04541248828172684, -0.008229997009038925, 0.05535212904214859, 0.009796923026442528, -0.04467500001192093, 0.07619654387235641, 0.0209035724401474, 0.045497819781303406, 0.06242382153868675, 0.01049749180674553, 0.012817831709980965, 0.06952712684869766, 0.024791045114398003, 0.0249320138245821, 0.0020666136406362057, 0.01659267768263817, -0.01981550268828869, -0.010869024321436882, 0.038079001009464264, -0.017907721921801567, -0.018818030133843422, 0.07662978023290634, 0.017140936106443405, 0.022314928472042084, 0.0458906888961792, 0.053322985768318176, -0.024497345089912415, 0.033100005239248276, -0.05680534616112709, 0.04979587346315384, 0.02475607395172119, 0.025411777198314667, 0.013469867408275604, 0.043053217232227325, 0.03991013765335083, 0.06053467094898224, -0.010344012640416622, 0.028466176241636276, 0.06392978876829147, 0.020249266177415848, 0.06240731477737427, 0.007546485401690006, 0.0015208214754238725, -0.059103719890117645, 0.023509562015533447, 0.02748141624033451, -0.005907396785914898, -0.061360541731119156, 0.006776013411581516, 0.04168110340833664, 0.011854732409119606, 0.041863568127155304, -0.03051394410431385, -0.019835161045193672, -0.009480231441557407, -0.04680278152227402, 0.004010741598904133, 0.03043307736515999, 0.030703702941536903, -0.02826962247490883, -0.016365626826882362, 0.02879822626709938, -0.019175972789525986, 0.011546961963176727, -0.05795511230826378, -0.03267323970794678, -0.013429151847958565, 0.041459761559963226, 0.010951480828225613, 0.028018292039632797, 0.001969653880223632, -0.002850208431482315, 0.0181282889097929, 0.0290671456605196, 0.00649921502918005, -0.0190404262393713, 0.004361520055681467, -0.032156456261873245, -0.018398072570562363, 0.042315904051065445, -0.015101399272680283, -0.03289008513092995, -0.02143351174890995, 0.006269767880439758, 0.0018756119534373283, 0.03794145584106445, 0.035354699939489365, 0.008545374497771263, 0.011755409650504589, -0.07091274112462997, -0.02258254960179329, 0.026400942355394363, 0.013164248317480087, 0.012877114117145538, 0.05055495724081993, 0.010870395228266716, 0.06440682709217072, -0.010229640640318394, -0.032485611736774445, 0.0023724103812128305, 0.016957351937890053, -0.05484902486205101, 0.0369533933699131, 0.0004703615850303322, 0.01904328353703022, -0.0026487382128834724, 0.024553067982196808, 0.01513010635972023, 0.007826590910553932, -0.021370774134993553, 0.08405635505914688, 0.0840093269944191, 0.019296793267130852, -0.026145055890083313, 0.057175714522600174, 0.006895854603499174, -0.028717033565044403, -0.032659053802490234, 0.04184683412313461, -0.05261356011033058, -0.021163422614336014, 0.02258015051484108, 0.02374216914176941, 0.012801527045667171, 0.032488930970430374, 0.015258228406310081, 0.04650867357850075, -0.034431472420692444, -0.04660472646355629, -0.017641108483076096, -0.04982241243124008, -0.038596924394369125, 0.04249722138047218, 0.032999634742736816, 0.0075597092509269714, 0.010814987123012543, -0.05009812116622925, 0.019797997549176216, 0.011296075768768787, -0.003274626564234495, -0.04138144478201866, 0.00416018720716238, 0.0068654888309538364, -0.034344084560871124, -0.02554379776120186, -0.054751187562942505, 0.05894003435969353, -0.0308671984821558, -0.023317040875554085, 0.00006435441900976002, 0.018233664333820343, -0.008395371958613396, -0.04287721961736679, 0.002857600338757038, 0.0390014611184597, -0.05964181199669838, 0.02998645044863224, 0.004737191833555698, 0.006879695691168308, -0.017649289220571518, -0.024977102875709534, -0.016081122681498528, 0.01932031475007534, -0.03756857290863991, -0.010627908632159233, -0.0037913129199296236, 0.016413932666182518, 0.015056109987199306, 0.001174706150777638, 0.02128886990249157, -0.006692132446914911, -0.006669790484011173, 0.004836117848753929, -0.01282184012234211, 0.017158368602395058, 0.016222134232521057, -0.08586939424276352, -0.06090318039059639, -0.051447492092847824, -0.03232801333069801, 0.018442848697304726, 0.02866910770535469, -0.008951961994171143, -0.009146731346845627, 0.03744018077850342, -0.020714784041047096, 0.03812030702829361, -0.026002684608101845, -0.03742167353630066, 0.003597608767449856, 0.02246510423719883, -0.04242074862122536, -0.017774129286408424, 0.010291830636560917, 0.027618592604994774, -0.011600985191762447, -0.006762329488992691, 0.05843883752822876, -0.02132452465593815, -0.024606209248304367, 0.010231967084109783, -0.0003956776927225292, -0.0013155665947124362, 0.01864217408001423, 0.04269417002797127, -0.021661415696144104, 0.04102947562932968, -0.03907692804932594, 0.02273460477590561, 0.06795927882194519, -0.04045567288994789, -0.04134413227438927, -0.030053183436393738, 0.013150458224117756, -0.0396769642829895, -0.02332106977701187, 0.009127785451710224, 0.02965030074119568, -0.021493012085556984, -0.040064066648483276, -0.020879190415143967, -0.01786811277270317, 0.09880517423152924, 0.053671784698963165, -0.03663259372115135, -0.027040300890803337, 0.005402502603828907, 0.031767502427101135, -0.031292036175727844, 0.04127506539225578, 0.0063999490812420845, -0.026114270091056824, -0.05060407519340515, -0.0759231448173523, -0.023954546079039574, 0.002994297770783305, 0.05557447299361229 ]
<p>So sound is a wave and is basically just vibrations, an atom vibrates causing another next to it vibrate and so on until it finally reaches our ears to become sound.</p> <p>If that's normally how waves behaves, what about light? I understand it's also a particle but <strong>something must have caused its starting point to influence its next point in space thereby allowing it to travel through space</strong>. what is the cause and effect relationship that allows light to propagate through space? I ruled out matter because most visible light is blocked by matter.</p>
g206
[ 0.03430655971169472, 0.013461495749652386, 0.003363346215337515, 0.030684862285852432, 0.021549956873059273, 0.04250117018818855, 0.024088287726044655, 0.03423763066530228, 0.026563528925180435, -0.0535837821662426, -0.013119174167513847, -0.009960106573998928, 0.03706672787666321, 0.06281842291355133, -0.012455172836780548, 0.0156987477093935, 0.09171492606401443, 0.02689705416560173, -0.010694961063563824, 0.017709463834762573, 0.011931494809687138, 0.02534675784409046, -0.009302993305027485, -0.07389412820339203, -0.062316205352544785, 0.0002857691724784672, 0.021327819675207138, -0.062075208872556686, 0.04796424135565758, -0.006667969282716513, 0.08170152455568314, -0.018379131332039833, 0.05768483132123947, -0.013178824447095394, -0.024853549897670746, -0.06852385401725769, -0.0274830125272274, 0.035796210169792175, 0.03089861385524273, 0.006430359557271004, 0.00792862568050623, -0.017514875158667564, -0.0152742313221097, -0.025478629395365715, 0.0006124174688011408, -0.0416894257068634, -0.03401783108711243, -0.013638181611895561, -0.030844571068882942, -0.03736775368452072, -0.05205370858311653, 0.014320340007543564, 0.012494956143200397, 0.06830808520317078, 0.02552216500043869, 0.03831424191594124, -0.01747973822057247, -0.01596016250550747, 0.12286863476037979, 0.04009179770946503, -0.009242832660675049, 0.06795091181993484, 0.01380543690174818, 0.04447784274816513, 0.046279311180114746, -0.03483057767152786, -0.03173278644680977, -0.04964306578040123, 0.04136273264884949, 0.0274357907474041, 0.0479653924703598, -0.06150834634900093, -0.03471774607896805, -0.055320288985967636, 0.031861890107393265, -0.011200951412320137, 0.005418378859758377, 0.054358240216970444, -0.035610150545835495, 0.022099429741501808, 0.007820392958819866, -0.10093755275011063, 0.030886175110936165, -0.04993719607591629, 0.04705147445201874, -0.07976789772510529, -0.044048797339200974, -0.02046564593911171, 0.011111630126833916, -0.02904018945991993, 0.04337286204099655, -0.011621592566370964, -0.005591596011072397, 0.012266355566680431, -0.04826249182224274, -0.012734226882457733, -0.049604665488004684, -0.004114528652280569, -0.0003444553294684738, 0.03335442766547203, -0.016696704551577568, -0.016118191182613373, 0.0073683070950210094, 0.012936762534081936, 0.03654298931360245, 0.014008269645273685, 0.03738971799612045, -0.008761201053857803, 0.0036931540817022324, 0.04442448541522026, -0.06337284296751022, -0.04198586195707321, 0.02533912844955921, -0.018942633643746376, -0.024816840887069702, -0.07088499516248703, 0.0515374094247818, 0.05445948615670204, 0.042756009846925735, 0.0779472142457962, -0.014448669739067554, 0.05308610200881958, 0.003861165838316083, 0.019185399636626244, -0.03401149436831474, -0.01313001662492752, 0.01108384970575571, -0.04587266966700554, -0.0070586856454610825, 0.015858279541134834, 0.03741200640797615, 0.04866506904363632, -0.015498560853302479, 0.031095759943127632, 0.042522307485342026, -0.002037669066339731, 0.03972722217440605, -0.024141468107700348, -0.047014445066452026, -0.01297781616449356, 0.044779032468795776, -0.009762493893504143, 0.000470802653580904, -0.04213660955429077, -0.038855355232954025, 0.009818248450756073, 0.01871201954782009, 0.0017681169556453824, -0.004365942440927029, 0.003354875138029456, 0.004579470027238131, 0.04953894764184952, -0.014899072237312794, 0.005293357651680708, 0.008422931656241417, -0.04374586418271065, 0.06881341338157654, 0.01598348468542099, -0.010646618902683258, 0.00797742884606123, 0.06380722671747208, 0.024889301508665085, -0.026487058028578758, 0.01460942905396223, -0.015548582188785076, -0.022469963878393173, 0.01959456503391266, -0.10166552662849426, 0.007555903401225805, 0.0038021772634238005, -0.04210390895605087, -0.008554684929549694, 0.00020113431673962623, 0.0951327383518219, 0.019981887191534042, 0.022227024659514427, 0.040555696934461594, 0.0062875342555344105, -0.016319693997502327, -0.006259698886424303, -0.02892257273197174, -0.04719802737236023, -0.0060850284062325954, -0.052871204912662506, -0.03583262115716934, -0.0014705201610922813, -0.02549288049340248, -0.0635584145784378, -0.09430395066738129, 0.027942508459091187, -0.041573576629161835, -0.07577367126941681, 0.03651027753949165, 0.004124152008444071, 0.003270908957347274, -0.01804199069738388, -0.025172101333737373, 0.013787891715765, -0.0014997209655120969, 0.0698024332523346, -0.02003493532538414, 0.03258475661277771, 0.032203610986471176, -0.012983945198357105, 0.044741030782461166, 0.03194219991564751, -0.040504761040210724, -0.004259128589183092, -0.009547312743961811, 0.048779040575027466, -0.0078209787607193, -0.008004492148756981, 0.0005858301883563399, 0.0344354547560215, -0.04323846101760864, 0.017109708860516548, -0.033825866878032684, -0.011041889898478985, 0.012871911749243736, 0.024318916723132133, -0.0027074364479631186, -0.027422554790973663, 0.005592665635049343, -0.0445595309138298, -0.017421158030629158, 0.01448358315974474, -0.04022061079740524, -0.005895974580198526, 0.008370562456548214, 0.026296166703104973, -0.0426257960498333, 0.020905042067170143, 0.03257013112306595, -0.04988420009613037, 0.04682094603776932, 0.011587574146687984, -0.04933485388755798, -0.05272030085325241, -0.02654368430376053, -0.005956142209470272, -0.009636475704610348, -0.02712372876703739, -0.023272868245840073, -0.024940967559814453, -0.0010277553228661418, -0.06667792797088623, -0.021270327270030975, -0.05607082322239876, -0.010354533791542053, -0.041059594601392746, 0.07766953855752945, -0.004043824039399624, -0.01968875154852867, -0.017177140340209007, 0.014082019217312336, -0.025740746408700943, 0.0152500681579113, 0.09876592457294464, -0.05409325286746025, -0.0351233035326004, -0.012756074778735638, -0.008320153690874577, -0.010258559137582779, -0.018703259527683258, -0.030231067910790443, -0.004989636596292257, 0.017758067697286606, -0.022781580686569214, -0.04742646589875221, -0.019047129899263382, -0.02369491569697857, 0.02983374521136284, 0.007414910476654768, -0.014078193344175816, -0.007029196713119745, -0.002648694906383753, 0.01000488456338644, 0.021130206063389778, 0.018989555537700653, 0.0017346579115837812, 0.010385480709373951, 0.02703438326716423, -0.0744333565235138, -0.021826591342687607, 0.04827626422047615, -0.0710015520453453, 0.02471383474767208, -0.028179554268717766, -0.0014623029856011271, -0.03717843443155289, 0.030100766569375992, 0.030686944723129272, 0.043627750128507614, 0.05821167677640915, -0.014607874676585197, 0.04011605307459831, 0.014476379379630089, -0.009149063378572464, -0.04344654828310013, 0.016449715942144394, 0.009287619031965733, -0.006921112071722746, 0.02697080932557583, 0.0015483737224712968, -0.02946622669696808, 0.029580339789390564, -0.009595510549843311, -0.026016591116786003, -0.016326507553458214, 0.04925163462758064, 0.03441714867949486, 0.06997045874595642, -0.00417941203340888, 0.04479067772626877, -0.034108005464076996, -0.014583243988454342, -0.017414316534996033, 0.017296332865953445, -0.012432177551090717, -0.030722392722964287, -0.006587849464267492, -0.04486699029803276, -0.004809589125216007, -0.029861487448215485, 0.06812739372253418, -0.01786871626973152, -0.0024461434222757816, -0.003777602221816778, -0.03148498013615608, -0.04070992022752762, -0.02945607528090477, -0.039349477738142014, -0.05874559283256531, 0.00753385853022337, -0.031861692667007446, -0.03678767755627632, 0.009492747485637665, 0.02055385522544384, 0.005211540963500738, 0.024142727255821228, 0.055801358073949814, 0.004618511535227299, -0.03159355744719505, 0.03714537248015404, -0.024944204837083817, 0.05439777672290802, 0.0200923103839159, -0.029648879542946815, -0.002337701851502061, -0.055921345949172974, 0.024896033108234406, 0.013746445067226887, -0.04181370139122009, 0.011771366000175476, -0.005456168670207262, 0.04289140924811363, 0.07515649497509003, 0.03296884149312973, 0.02657991833984852, -0.0857735201716423, -0.03841116651892662, -0.03996625542640686, 0.05851829797029495, -0.011424316093325615, -0.03439933434128761, 0.004188681486994028, 0.066283218562603, -0.005628162529319525, 0.043714623898267746, 0.010190067812800407, 0.05340716242790222, -0.01541681494563818, -0.055204104632139206, 0.006745926104485989, 0.03432036563754082, 0.0033671343699097633, 0.004354385193437338, -0.006780962459743023, -0.09515132755041122, 0.02321021445095539, 0.03915980085730553, 0.05750131607055664, 0.1160091906785965, 0.015875477343797684, 0.026097320020198822, -0.019276082515716553, -0.05580750107765198, 0.026904623955488205, -0.00905432179570198, -0.027406983077526093, -0.05457844212651253, -0.040655869990587234, -0.012301415205001831, -0.03708174079656601, 0.0404360294342041, -0.041444264352321625, 0.023692281916737556, 0.051923010498285294, -0.012642432935535908, 0.02392200008034706, -0.00031911148107610643, 0.02212301269173622, -0.017275501042604446, -0.017544398084282875, 0.01580515317618847, -0.0063858553767204285, 0.009727869182825089, -0.050169676542282104, -0.06690818816423416, 0.01485421322286129, 0.002861190587282181, -0.008769222535192966, -0.07829423993825912, -0.03775908052921295, -0.06239871680736542, -0.0021724787075072527, 0.029187282547354698, 0.007311330176889896, 0.04464887082576752, 0.055686354637145996, 0.007114510517567396, 0.03102569840848446, 0.019708724692463875, -0.0005571530200541019, 0.017057597637176514, 0.08946045488119125, 0.05199158936738968, -0.0736822783946991, -0.023931730538606644, -0.025591576471924782, -0.05449369549751282, 0.04064035415649414, 0.024410905316472054, 0.03619924187660217, -0.01751670427620411, 0.09664417803287506, -0.03920743986964226, 0.051094140857458115, 0.005024557933211327, 0.0013917131582275033, 0.0632738322019577, -0.028966903686523438, 0.025911690667271614, 0.0023332913406193256, -0.007912954315543175, 0.05447154864668846, -0.02646576426923275, -0.0056777168065309525, 0.015162475407123566, -0.058193717151880264, -0.06334257870912552, 0.0336151123046875, -0.030555659905076027, -0.02910713292658329, 0.009917180053889751, 0.028781848028302193, -0.027387984097003937, 0.03280123323202133, -0.018973659723997116, -0.020171301439404488, -0.00601681275293231, -0.05114290863275528, 0.0623059943318367, 0.023630622774362564, 0.0024278247728943825, -0.030140556395053864, -0.0136891333386302, -0.06493093073368073, -0.05425996333360672, 0.06847698241472244, 0.011846974492073059, 0.0066584874875843525, -0.02190462313592434, 0.03711685165762901, 0.01638801582157612, -0.008569685742259026, -0.06866349279880524, -0.006554893217980862, -0.03865036368370056, -0.06539701670408249, 0.04228809103369713, -0.001164762070402503, 0.047961656004190445, -0.0208793543279171, -0.03185373172163963, -0.02290523797273636, -0.050371795892715454, 0.09643018245697021, -0.040766648948192596, -0.04388746619224548, -0.007340817246586084, -0.0431983657181263, -0.0314643457531929, -0.008068245835602283, 0.014220668002963066, -0.030428612604737282, -0.0410001277923584, 0.00049013044917956, -0.0353233739733696, -0.017006073147058487, -0.019547641277313232, -0.02308725193142891, 0.017203541472554207, -0.004682259634137154, -0.04495133459568024, -0.0015548710944131017, 0.01588759571313858, -0.026117170229554176, -0.053324345499277115, 0.021414143964648247, -0.0012022454757243395, 0.017285894602537155, -0.08756314963102341, 0.030045758932828903, 0.03383558616042137, -0.008892778307199478, 0.023982513695955276, 0.05007627233862877, 0.03395434468984604, 0.016233278438448906, -0.023414507508277893, -0.025233449414372444, 0.02030738815665245, 0.0039919232949614525, 0.053252510726451874, 0.0006262556416913867, -0.046798478811979294, 0.05840425193309784, 0.05474177375435829, 0.061987973749637604, 0.01756754331290722, 0.028406452387571335, 0.04248221591114998, 0.027405479922890663, 0.019657595083117485, -0.0528448224067688, 0.023851238191127777, 0.014294777065515518, -0.043993692845106125, 0.02034471370279789, -0.027604442089796066, -0.028565693646669388, -0.0103813661262393, 0.053666286170482635, -0.006986236199736595, 0.03043222613632679, 0.023716777563095093, -0.008061488159000874, -0.00020920699171256274, -0.020292429253458977, -0.03471067175269127, 0.03790684789419174, 0.003407636657357216, 0.025736458599567413, -0.01474151574075222, 0.027988925576210022, -0.02166391909122467, -0.05969750136137009, -0.02017342858016491, -0.021718516945838928, 0.05253031477332115, 0.06272222846746445, -0.022505225613713264, -0.024538816884160042, 0.04612164571881294, 0.02504635602235794, 0.02250000461935997, -0.04897105693817139, 0.026307743042707443, 0.050611235201358795, 0.0006698821089230478, 0.07091370224952698, 0.010076714679598808, -0.01964063197374344, -0.0010136733762919903, 0.04021911695599556, -0.026701005175709724, -0.07548415660858154, -0.08506318926811218, 0.010762444697320461, 0.037457000464200974, 0.009992665611207485, -0.0015586616937071085, 0.0034573834855109453, -0.03362802788615227, -0.014834553003311157, -0.003039313480257988, -0.004930140916258097, 0.07785684615373611, -0.04139786958694458, 0.00588854169473052, -0.03357020393013954, -0.09188338369131088, -0.03346521407365799, 0.001292983302846551, -0.014604571275413036, 0.04858584329485893, -0.008599048480391502, 0.03050943836569786, 0.05339425802230835, 0.05471063777804375, -0.009210623800754547, 0.025228308513760567, 0.011479201726615429, 0.006425843108445406, 0.0013732841471210122, -0.03854287788271904, 0.004713068716228008, 0.04732569679617882, 0.012430203147232533, -0.026352860033512115, 0.006262648850679398, 0.04004970192909241, -0.012249302119016647, -0.01439379621297121, -0.016520906239748, -0.027163701131939888, -0.03660271689295769, -0.009413559921085835, 0.0007276178803294897, -0.02578151412308216, -0.00616373959928751, -0.002582359127700329, -0.00013496485189534724, 0.007587997708469629, 0.04995977133512497, -0.01432435680180788, 0.023746853694319725, 0.026778684929013252, 0.03272295743227005, -0.012658839114010334, 0.018261244520545006, 0.06704077124595642, 0.022434772923588753, -0.016143430024385452, 0.036500077694654465, 0.004234497435390949, -0.014897345565259457, 0.046279024332761765, -0.0013521736254915595, 0.03560659661889076, 0.005677967797964811, -0.04451989382505417, 0.06601063162088394, -0.020017312839627266, -0.03700640797615051, 0.06215348839759827, -0.05523335561156273, -0.03922787681221962, -0.03519388288259506, -0.03496642783284187, -0.035794034600257874, -0.06485167145729065, -0.0010022775968536735, 0.010175412520766258, 0.005072656087577343, 0.0008573142695240676, 0.05605529248714447, -0.010200504213571548, -0.036210156977176666, -0.06542481482028961, -0.005906468722969294, -0.015460392460227013, 0.04190565273165703, 0.00397328520193696, 0.05593876540660858, 0.018274126574397087, -0.045215412974357605, 0.0037772960495203733, 0.012277282774448395, 0.021127497777342796, -0.05562025308609009, 0.03601253032684326, 0.05002817511558533, -0.02665150724351406, 0.02945157326757908, -0.039720479398965836, -0.014357050880789757, 0.0427996926009655, 0.003579051000997424, 0.01765604317188263, 0.02343306876718998, -0.00010477911564521492, -0.020690498873591423, 0.02831224352121353, 0.011704045347869396, -0.0246296264231205, -0.027745645493268967, -0.04654403403401375, -0.05192386731505394, -0.03710580989718437, -0.01061953604221344, -0.054145123809576035, -0.01705881580710411, -0.0028214501217007637, -0.030454600229859352, 0.08259185403585434, 0.07167868316173553, -0.008889935910701752, 0.010613405145704746, -0.05409589037299156, -0.015599309466779232, -0.048781946301460266, -0.009020424447953701, 0.0643562451004982, -0.030839839950203896, 0.015644511207938194, -0.028538882732391357, -0.0052728960290551186, -0.012567797675728798, 0.042156923562288284, 0.04697542265057564, 0.004416028968989849, 0.008275514468550682, 0.009366977959871292, 0.023983146995306015, 0.04511799290776253, 0.05760038271546364, 0.012188776396214962, 0.02997235581278801, 0.012335767038166523, 0.021004240959882736, -0.038268059492111206, -0.02988307923078537, -0.007296562660485506, 0.02226828783750534, 0.0722339004278183, -0.051929205656051636, 0.001269002677872777, 0.012610025703907013, -0.015542627312242985, 0.01602991670370102, 0.04441870003938675, -0.04174571484327316, -0.028997475281357765, 0.008873294107615948, 0.028502456843852997, -0.0107923224568367, 0.011501631699502468, 0.028453974053263664, 0.00992888305336237, 0.0195251926779747, -0.00841591041535139, -0.0003667312557809055, 0.006809443235397339, -0.03675129637122154, 0.021090876311063766, 0.00662201689556241, 0.029015399515628815, -0.041984740644693375, -0.010525924153625965, 0.06964381039142609, -0.029523663222789764, 0.01911027729511261, 0.04029545933008194, -0.08123841881752014, -0.031098641455173492, 0.019695434719324112, 0.028385909274220467, -0.03738447651267052, -0.012934372760355473, 0.021271532401442528, 0.006566730327904224, -0.017286745831370354, -0.04181317985057831, 0.0019225814612582326, -0.05572326481342316, -0.017791923135519028 ]
<p>When considering the Doppler shift, the 'canonical equation' is $$f=\frac{c+vr}{c+vs}f_0$$</p> <p>However, this equation seems to run into trouble in the following situation: A light source inside water is moving at a speed $v$ towards a receiver outside the water. Can we modify the above equation to deal with a transition between two media? Or is there a completely different formula that applies here?</p>
g807
[ 0.008713091723620892, -0.029863737523555756, -0.011256597004830837, -0.02643941529095173, 0.029490523040294647, 0.022926369681954384, 0.04187989979982376, -0.02690119482576847, -0.05840513855218887, -0.017939817160367966, 0.015795143321156502, 0.03957263007760048, 0.018029291182756424, 0.023716576397418976, -0.06163353845477104, -0.0347016416490078, 0.03074803575873375, -0.0028777692932635546, 0.01921708509325981, 0.01742495223879814, -0.035350020974874496, -0.01281877513974905, 0.022260650992393494, -0.05905001237988472, 0.014598113484680653, -0.051836997270584106, 0.006272623315453529, -0.011234423145651817, -0.04351085051894188, 0.01913755014538765, 0.021282708272337914, -0.008432737551629543, 0.0069456747733056545, 0.011944674886763096, -0.018850630149245262, -0.029562072828412056, -0.026237914338707924, 0.005509542766958475, 0.009683338925242424, 0.004007020033895969, 0.0039005863945931196, 0.0449812225997448, 0.021185318008065224, 0.0038138132076710463, 0.041745174676179886, -0.020159924402832985, -0.051901910454034805, -0.051647890359163284, -0.055960580706596375, -0.01558863464742899, -0.0010354684200137854, 0.0544855073094368, -0.04020468890666962, 0.04583357647061348, -0.04432397708296776, 0.05022913217544556, -0.008730757050216198, 0.009293877519667149, 0.05658229440450668, -0.004855101462453604, -0.013392824679613113, -0.054561469703912735, 0.011196168139576912, -0.011133452877402306, 0.06566249579191208, -0.022691551595926285, -0.030571890994906425, -0.030653495341539383, 0.01803974248468876, -0.036728981882333755, -0.0034468788653612137, -0.016542654484510422, -0.0004888991825282574, -0.030887611210346222, -0.019336579367518425, -0.0480382926762104, -0.03273957595229149, -0.07762712240219116, -0.009496414102613926, -0.06908252835273743, -0.004939541686326265, 0.009431409649550915, 0.0333993174135685, 0.049127280712127686, 0.04148957133293152, 0.021838579326868057, 0.05301966518163681, 0.053496524691581726, -0.004075584001839161, -0.05979037284851074, -0.04050312936306, -0.06677157431840897, 0.0480099581182003, -0.04374168813228607, 0.010777527466416359, -0.0592925027012825, -0.04003976285457611, 0.05957217141985893, 0.008406764827668667, -0.023077310994267464, 0.0021993564441800117, -0.013040623627603054, -0.021046672016382217, 0.020226698368787766, -0.04407288879156113, -0.0773516595363617, 0.013083560392260551, 0.018579456955194473, -0.04023011401295662, -0.058968354016542435, -0.00630317535251379, -0.07527991384267807, 0.00010605961142573506, -0.0052582873031497, -0.022909196093678474, -0.06216936185956001, -0.0288191270083189, 0.04745204746723175, 0.0001771646784618497, 0.0654364824295044, -0.0279286690056324, 0.01898428052663803, 0.009974475018680096, 0.08337494730949402, 0.0642981082201004, 0.032495517283678055, -0.03957842290401459, 0.00894111581146717, 0.09080640226602554, 0.0003058159491047263, -0.03383355587720871, 0.0009109777165576816, 0.05214434862136841, 0.01339263841509819, -0.024115869775414467, -0.0033009483013302088, 0.028272679075598717, 0.030199596658349037, 0.024248788133263588, 0.04089316725730896, 0.05187850445508957, -0.05539405345916748, 0.043256763368844986, -0.02437721937894821, -0.03050968609750271, 0.009054521098732948, -0.02919198013842106, -0.03567231073975563, 0.03195744380354881, -0.06505277007818222, 0.04834870994091034, 0.05588766932487488, 0.029364444315433502, 0.03702256456017494, -0.0021933745592832565, 0.0240156389772892, 0.06378505378961563, -0.006083949934691191, -0.028043236583471298, -0.017482027411460876, 0.04147340729832649, -0.020916908979415894, -0.0023170437198132277, 0.008673745207488537, -0.013775911182165146, 0.03154827654361725, -0.03290371224284172, 0.03757159039378166, -0.03970818966627121, -0.08007214218378067, -0.0297028087079525, 0.05260727182030678, -0.02763703465461731, 0.057354629039764404, -0.0039059468545019627, 0.03204623982310295, 0.04400338977575302, 0.01960540935397148, -0.08239186555147171, 0.0667419508099556, -0.11082763224840164, -0.03727242350578308, 0.006967624183744192, -0.06934714317321777, -0.015532086603343487, -0.012463334016501904, -0.019429383799433708, -0.013134179636836052, -0.09925217926502228, 0.012274728156626225, -0.04083125293254852, -0.01657113991677761, -0.00024981252499856055, 0.06227627396583557, -0.035755455493927, 0.02143086865544319, -0.02082762122154236, -0.03299853205680847, 0.004189705476164818, 0.0159660205245018, 0.0313328318297863, 0.05256153643131256, 0.07223357260227203, -0.009844564832746983, 0.04334096983075142, -0.026435302570462227, 0.009699694812297821, -0.02920263260602951, 0.01428225263953209, 0.005657858215272427, 0.034879300743341446, -0.006048957817256451, -0.06332948803901672, 0.06366429477930069, -0.029099827632308006, -0.0055316113866865635, -0.02050401270389557, 0.02938263677060604, -0.03710528090596199, 0.027817025780677795, -0.04039947688579559, 0.06068209186196327, 0.011598763056099415, 0.023450477048754692, -0.04405299946665764, -0.04320897161960602, -0.004050679039210081, -0.0035468300338834524, 0.04495376721024513, 0.04003934562206268, -0.017457321286201477, 0.02624100260436535, -0.017550146207213402, -0.0007701622089371085, 0.018289176747202873, 0.07277175039052963, -0.044048137962818146, 0.05357182025909424, 0.021180881187319756, 0.041011400520801544, 0.02677578665316105, -0.008287041448056698, -0.047655873000621796, 0.020358284935355186, 0.002853425219655037, 0.02054738439619541, 0.022932061925530434, -0.0038869704585522413, 0.03438437730073929, 0.006711032707244158, 0.05643772706389427, -0.015095965936779976, -0.009302482008934021, -0.026922786608338356, -0.053593724966049194, -0.022399425506591797, -0.04037575423717499, 0.011073431931436062, -0.1042349636554718, 0.000197754314285703, -0.06663279235363007, -0.00813046284019947, 0.020841039717197418, 0.00047772220568731427, -0.03466297313570976, 0.038784176111221313, 0.011053318157792091, 0.0773429274559021, 0.017473118379712105, 0.0244006160646677, 0.02380244992673397, -0.014020461589097977, 0.007319112773984671, 0.06892402470111847, -0.04286345839500427, -0.008976287208497524, 0.02796323038637638, -0.03351682424545288, 0.025920387357473373, 0.037815261632204056, -0.06017862632870674, -0.008797446265816689, -0.030836492776870728, -0.03841489925980568, 0.012537217698991299, -0.03595789521932602, 0.04398460313677788, 0.0899859368801117, 0.017791977152228355, 0.03165125101804733, 0.005327471066266298, 0.03468756377696991, 0.012215772643685341, 0.027306975796818733, 0.029894478619098663, 0.02912820316851139, 0.06662379950284958, -0.004779652692377567, 0.05897533893585205, 0.05320902541279793, 0.02276548556983471, -0.019929012283682823, -0.010026304982602596, 0.02188892476260662, -0.019521310925483704, -0.054721325635910034, -0.028797805309295654, -0.06389120221138, 0.08097098022699356, 0.0019587466958910227, -0.01054322998970747, 0.023529721423983574, -0.0137384794652462, -0.02664281241595745, 0.04514249041676521, -0.030203010886907578, -0.025566359981894493, 0.010660883039236069, 0.01572577841579914, -0.0029369511175900698, -0.019113516435027122, 0.01636396162211895, 0.0003052343090530485, 0.02891833335161209, -0.008904662914574146, -0.0376984179019928, 0.00840627122670412, 0.04798426851630211, -0.041324105113744736, 0.017165223136544228, 0.007353292778134346, 0.02670697681605816, 0.012635457329452038, -0.07955174148082733, -0.031022032722830772, -0.03796757385134697, 0.008348903618752956, 0.07244065403938293, 0.017818795517086983, -0.013312592171132565, -0.03231518715620041, -0.010950901545584202, -0.07036565244197845, 0.05180412903428078, 0.012509487569332123, -0.0052281771786510944, 0.014894657768309116, 0.03539939224720001, -0.042824942618608475, -0.0386120043694973, 0.012025851756334305, -0.008697389625012875, 0.000522674061357975, 0.027998950332403183, -0.003234302159398794, -0.009419833309948444, 0.03659776225686073, 0.02797912433743477, -0.00806749239563942, 0.000821376743260771, 0.03766678646206856, -0.05259862542152405, 0.03227663040161133, 0.02304413728415966, -0.007761115673929453, -0.010826405137777328, -0.05322079733014107, 0.0656600221991539, -0.09608841687440872, 0.011531743220984936, 0.001896401634439826, -0.04209497198462486, -0.034482866525650024, -0.012622637674212456, 0.018124300986528397, -0.02812732383608818, -0.019629763439297676, -0.010128351859748363, -0.02708340436220169, 0.03369550779461861, 0.007572266273200512, -0.021457603201270103, -0.013948267325758934, -0.011232617311179638, 0.025206400081515312, 0.02242417447268963, -0.048481907695531845, -0.03473033383488655, 0.0626833587884903, -0.04005704075098038, 0.03553842380642891, -0.0020935211796313524, -0.013447529636323452, 0.018964173272252083, 0.034483082592487335, 0.015805169939994812, -0.007742733228951693, 0.018051911145448685, -0.06456690281629562, 0.0009014474344439805, -0.0007638936513103545, 0.009188818745315075, 0.0017322431085631251, -0.03893883898854256, -0.06748270988464355, 0.013125232420861721, 0.017537390813231468, -0.04601716995239258, -0.05904768407344818, 0.00934428721666336, -0.03566982224583626, -0.0524248443543911, -0.09227435290813446, -0.04086219519376755, 0.012098577804863453, -0.02974831312894821, 0.008742621168494225, -0.01308307982981205, 0.040500424802303314, 0.02597777731716633, 0.017205122858285904, 0.049605920910835266, 0.004407593049108982, 0.02371176704764366, -0.011134314350783825, 0.04561259225010872, 0.07300291210412979, 0.008686310611665249, 0.005742461886256933, -0.04844042658805847, -0.0012353882193565369, 0.017831284552812576, 0.018467357382178307, 0.07870589941740036, 0.01877487450838089, 0.10033078491687775, -0.01331169530749321, -0.0222026277333498, 0.01106418576091528, 0.016386624425649643, 0.016393912956118584, -0.06236318126320839, 0.02815469168126583, -0.02599659189581871, -0.0010331468656659126, 0.1016707494854927, 0.03607458248734474, -0.033598609268665314, 0.025851594284176826, -0.06475046277046204, -0.020222250372171402, 0.04524834081530571, 0.008625860325992107, 0.009342214092612267, 0.011109048500657082, 0.03534294664859772, -0.0010272643994539976, 0.003758825361728668, 0.005694803316146135, -0.023248793557286263, 0.004474985413253307, 0.06618919968605042, -0.021352019160985947, -0.05415356904268265, 0.03835226222872734, 0.02003675512969494, -0.021678496152162552, 0.006009233649820089, -0.03475400060415268, -0.017039192840456963, 0.017807725816965103, -0.0019646708387881517, 0.001244027866050601, -0.007070360705256462, 0.023781200870871544, 0.025251170620322227, 0.0088067427277565, -0.005314796697348356, -0.008465053513646126, -0.04958989471197128, -0.020021436735987663, 0.014963396824896336, 0.007273227442055941, 0.015411145985126495, -0.011598417535424232, 0.028772884979844093, -0.012510942295193672, 0.018088556826114655, 0.014287824742496014, -0.052052438259124756, 0.03203233331441879, -0.017029738053679466, -0.04597630724310875, 0.020999165251851082, 0.03150670602917671, 0.11787383258342743, 0.05925249308347702, 0.002669376553967595, -0.020992761477828026, 0.04187770560383797, -0.061587292701005936, 0.030241794884204865, -0.021942663937807083, 0.03912711143493652, 0.015646249055862427, 0.0807805061340332, 0.05236028507351875, 0.025859041139483452, -0.003981230314821005, 0.0943356603384018, 0.034092169255018234, -0.03550942614674568, -0.010022544302046299, 0.0011765946401283145, 0.040621768683195114, -0.06055682897567749, -0.026472069323062897, -0.06560645997524261, -0.016726385802030563, -0.10356268286705017, 0.0017279351595789194, -0.006704309955239296, 0.007297569420188665, 0.05147978663444519, 0.008533674292266369, 0.02352842316031456, -0.08265768736600876, -0.005667306482791901, -0.014134230092167854, -0.019431577995419502, 0.035775136202573776, 0.02410067804157734, -0.0007807811489328742, 0.023533567786216736, -0.02914382331073284, -0.04348824545741081, -0.04405251145362854, -0.02800428308546543, 0.027308784425258636, 0.0033145220950245857, -0.09429565817117691, -0.0048605590127408504, -0.0011676131980493665, 0.05342454835772514, -0.022719023749232292, 0.05021814629435539, 0.010334230959415436, 0.018953926861286163, -0.006601210217922926, -0.01918007805943489, -0.03247331827878952, 0.004660625476390123, -0.009302939288318157, 0.052363861352205276, 0.04790400341153145, -0.023762814700603485, -0.012341092340648174, 0.000467694248072803, -0.04231996834278107, -0.0072464109398424625, 0.01056093629449606, -0.014714483171701431, 0.02752256952226162, -0.027504703029990196, 0.04024985060095787, -0.043831221759319305, 0.0371740385890007, 0.037077128887176514, 0.05770885571837425, 0.004129142500460148, -0.05117224529385567, -0.02611529640853405, -0.0017648201901465654, -0.039451539516448975, -0.004905499052256346, 0.020075775682926178, -0.02003590017557144, -0.03953210636973381, -0.00832791905850172, 0.043398357927799225, -0.04325616732239723, -0.005461918190121651, -0.01922968029975891, -0.003663969924673438, -0.05533444508910179, -0.012159982696175575, -0.019184349104762077, -0.03190463408827782, 0.029051678255200386, -0.02352703921496868, 0.013641931116580963, -0.006947959307581186, -0.0342603474855423, 0.0020006299018859863, -0.00933102611452341, -0.02387869916856289, -0.019223857671022415, -0.008296608924865723, -0.024735720828175545, 0.06858888268470764, 0.0376439243555069, 0.0080477399751544, 0.03390812128782272, -0.01909356378018856, -0.004315303638577461, -0.06618150323629379, -0.028084002435207367, 0.04314328357577324, 0.05830491706728935, -0.012423749081790447, 0.03216078132390976, 0.023691192269325256, 0.048881895840168, -0.02657805010676384, -0.0019105442333966494, -0.02912093512713909, 0.010308707132935524, 0.01642531529068947, 0.04018927738070488, 0.027234520763158798, 0.027718855068087578, -0.06295634061098099, 0.06407666206359863, -0.017675010487437248, -0.026945997029542923, 0.02118769660592079, -0.08321981132030487, -0.009760948829352856, 0.006778528913855553, 0.02396829053759575, 0.07310401648283005, -0.02326161228120327, -0.023280631750822067, -0.047556180506944656, 0.04314781352877617, 0.03177597373723984, 0.0259532630443573, -0.02334837056696415, 0.028508439660072327, 0.0053764041513204575, 0.04401938617229462, 0.042116980999708176, 0.05487734451889992, 0.017476636916399002, -0.044792015105485916, 0.024950740858912468, 0.07315532863140106, -0.06241593882441521, -0.04678940400481224, 0.026995830237865448, 0.007946564815938473, -0.056363675743341446, -0.031206266954541206, 0.03705140948295593, -0.039162274450063705, 0.044805798679590225, 0.017209114506840706, 0.0340256467461586, -0.0029389304108917713, 0.004903871100395918, -0.02339346520602703, -0.05933321639895439, 0.0292205773293972, 0.04171974956989288, 0.03754604980349541, 0.04027825966477394, -0.011395871639251709, -0.05032883211970329, 0.018069660291075706, 0.004639725666493177, 0.023893749341368675, 0.0051286774687469006, 0.015556336380541325, 0.03750339522957802, 0.048426803201436996, 0.023065892979502678, -0.02597990073263645, 0.06117852404713631, 0.004688700661063194, 0.018360042944550514, 0.052825089544057846, -0.019643325358629227, -0.018696526065468788, -0.030031517148017883, -0.006705833598971367, 0.01752520725131035, -0.0198730006814003, -0.0110090970993042, 0.026772065088152885, -0.009135515429079533, -0.025844329968094826, -0.0019786797929555178, 0.031426507979631424, 0.018497517332434654, -0.015476686879992485, 0.005805137101560831, -0.048491958528757095, 0.04216698557138443, 0.023120831698179245, -0.01882253587245941, 0.0018584300996735692, -0.001297920593060553, -0.03034866973757744, 0.026102431118488312, -0.011546453461050987, -0.003990684170275927, -0.039822015911340714, -0.049728453159332275, 0.02958744764328003, -0.0714096650481224, -0.0005920268595218658, 0.03863120824098587, 0.0034539070911705494, -0.034435003995895386, 0.023451099172234535, -0.04275352880358696, -0.026201851665973663, 0.029651042073965073, -0.007733851205557585, 0.019631678238511086, -0.04641927033662796, -0.05376478284597397, -0.04094535484910011, -0.05112721398472786, 0.022799784317612648, -0.021190322935581207, -0.020766470581293106, -0.0667424276471138, -0.02275141142308712, -0.022898852825164795, -0.04421485960483551, -0.03025517798960209, -0.01938759908080101, -0.04136284068226814, -0.011113329790532589, -0.02110166661441326, 0.0031612557359039783, 0.029359940439462662, 0.00940622203052044, 0.007156456355005503, -0.029635529965162277, 0.013575027696788311, -0.0018160255858674645, 0.02099817991256714, 0.019090015441179276, -0.012415517121553421, 0.05986553058028221, 0.015813352540135384, 0.012798265554010868, -0.04591011255979538, 0.04231524467468262, 0.03081950545310974, -0.019773300737142563, 0.017457161098718643, 0.05442091450095177, 0.00007987376011442393, -0.011226853355765343, 0.014741754159331322, 0.01861337572336197, -0.05361529439687729, -0.023730136454105377, -0.0067391181364655495, -0.044975362718105316, 0.044592272490262985, -0.022302648052573204, -0.009493703953921795, -0.06383755058050156, 0.051967546343803406 ]
<p>Powerful <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LASER" rel="nofollow">lasers</a> are highly intense, diverge negligibly and are also coherent. These radiations are emitted through partially reflecting mirrors after simultaneous reflections within the lasing medium. Don't these EM radiations affect the lasing medium or reflecting mirrors?</p> <p>Also, How is <a href="http://laserstars.org/history/plasma.html" rel="nofollow">plasma</a> used as a lasing medium in certain lasers?</p>
g5852
[ 0.007488836534321308, -0.006027282681316137, -0.004133856389671564, 0.02696709707379341, -0.003485148772597313, 0.030828844755887985, 0.004728886764496565, 0.0894344225525856, -0.022737398743629456, -0.03351660445332527, 0.002084671054035425, 0.025268059223890305, 0.04288400709629059, -0.0019659316167235374, -0.018151720985770226, -0.051293306052684784, 0.07524236291646957, 0.059684306383132935, 0.03993075713515282, 0.1038878932595253, -0.13341467082500458, -0.0011268581729382277, -0.032351188361644745, -0.09843213856220245, -0.005208127200603485, -0.01979910396039486, 0.023257054388523102, -0.07233114540576935, -0.0031517641618847847, -0.029506390914320946, -0.0033974149264395237, -0.01678665168583393, 0.023241456598043442, -0.05177553743124008, 0.0025741516146808863, -0.016372622922062874, 0.012177317403256893, 0.0425906665623188, -0.04878956452012062, 0.04500710964202881, -0.03706462308764458, 0.00432869466021657, 0.020146174356341362, -0.0157138891518116, -0.012247207574546337, 0.018717769533395767, -0.027311017736792564, -0.024657951667904854, -0.004828568082302809, -0.04007089510560036, -0.039994675666093826, -0.031254928559064865, 0.002620261162519455, 0.008052244782447815, 0.0493030846118927, -0.01111657079309225, -0.060089197009801865, 0.04820125922560692, 0.06979437917470932, -0.0787830725312233, 0.028090473264455795, -0.04635371267795563, -0.028137557208538055, 0.07144593447446823, 0.004543952643871307, -0.029437080025672913, -0.05476978421211243, -0.028786778450012207, 0.02548721432685852, -0.019493509083986282, 0.017638731747865677, -0.000602877524215728, -0.06682868301868439, -0.05863993987441063, -0.004223447293043137, 0.01350325532257557, 0.06323090195655823, -0.006704279687255621, -0.02180323377251625, 0.03866434842348099, -0.047323159873485565, -0.02531699277460575, -0.007724148686975241, 0.024497253820300102, 0.009773618541657925, 0.03497486561536789, 0.0034710390027612448, 0.021377306431531906, 0.06966441124677658, 0.01818823628127575, 0.02449117787182331, 0.045290518552064896, 0.07386583834886551, 0.03979723900556564, -0.030014168471097946, -0.011048133485019207, 0.0025518881157040596, 0.03534587845206261, 0.00870966911315918, -0.015784000977873802, -0.0006986900116316974, 0.005998185370117426, 0.0221406240016222, 0.021901573985815048, 0.03161377087235451, -0.022133536636829376, 0.033704280853271484, 0.03242572769522667, -0.052004124969244, -0.03533338010311127, -0.027941901236772537, -0.03999974578619003, -0.07340161502361298, -0.0031502465717494488, 0.010025045834481716, 0.001796658500097692, 0.041297268122434616, 0.03443049266934395, -0.05064370483160019, 0.040648721158504486, 0.09929510205984116, -0.022243546321988106, 0.0202260110527277, 0.042000193148851395, -0.0016402950277552009, 0.057378824800252914, 0.07209698855876923, -0.039354510605335236, 0.08796330541372299, -0.01219956111162901, -0.034999214112758636, 0.016357673332095146, -0.003635890083387494, 0.016814230009913445, 0.0446980744600296, 0.017965594306588173, -0.024397483095526695, -0.004250942729413509, 0.035706643015146255, 0.00934908539056778, 0.035467877984046936, -0.015611990354955196, 0.026624351739883423, -0.025763515383005142, -0.04810402914881706, -0.00777438236400485, -0.07044444978237152, 0.0001553991751279682, 0.08070019632577896, 0.020589308813214302, 0.01988777332007885, 0.03253782540559769, 0.04140350595116615, -0.06915552169084549, -0.010218444280326366, 0.007100946269929409, 0.0032785963267087936, -0.05809827148914337, -0.006992567330598831, 0.0027354892808943987, 0.006418109871447086, -0.0016994052566587925, 0.01618199050426483, -0.028196267783641815, -0.04446374624967575, 0.019685886800289154, 0.033662132918834686, -0.08176741003990173, 0.0015502204187214375, 0.02533828280866146, -0.03502323478460312, 0.028474561870098114, -0.006826078984886408, -0.020201073959469795, 0.057889726012945175, 0.08800593763589859, 0.0751495286822319, -0.014948591589927673, -0.018764406442642212, -0.02424074523150921, -0.0902308002114296, -0.011019318364560604, -0.04441223293542862, -0.07417971640825272, 0.0030021262355148792, 0.015959935262799263, -0.02303709089756012, -0.09011361002922058, -0.042308274656534195, 0.03089671954512596, -0.01236539613455534, -0.009276393800973892, -0.007117151748389006, 0.01978566311299801, -0.03421373292803764, -0.014782494865357876, -0.015409347601234913, -0.0047743059694767, -0.03391571715474129, 0.02851659618318081, -0.012372312135994434, 0.034589916467666626, 0.0009269674774259329, 0.04677589610219002, 0.01816665753722191, 0.024880044162273407, 0.005264649633318186, -0.03346093371510506, -0.021843833848834038, -0.0022958882618695498, 0.0013830206589773297, 0.028446342796087265, 0.03738577663898468, 0.01053710374981165, 0.026040665805339813, 0.01894926279783249, -0.037762124091386795, 0.0068172793835401535, -0.012210019864141941, 0.0024589980021119118, -0.029743816703557968, 0.07340822368860245, 0.04805672541260719, -0.004284306429326534, -0.07702291011810303, 0.00895710103213787, -0.03468194603919983, 0.05347833409905434, -0.017801307141780853, 0.009298092685639858, -0.03398200869560242, -0.04774707555770874, -0.005605278071016073, -0.041513267904520035, 0.0663594976067543, -0.018791988492012024, 0.013596571050584316, 0.05069611221551895, -0.01230834424495697, 0.028749952092766762, 0.028209690004587173, -0.0741824358701706, 0.011778893880546093, -0.01557072252035141, -0.0622362457215786, -0.07644172012805939, -0.022064803168177605, -0.00856578815728426, -0.02660208009183407, -0.04650217667222023, -0.040508732199668884, -0.037222541868686676, 0.011343668214976788, -0.04038330540060997, -0.02940092608332634, 0.022553320974111557, -0.012297515757381916, 0.03780212998390198, -0.051832787692546844, 0.006687171757221222, 0.015466044656932354, 0.009423081763088703, -0.01703791506588459, -0.024061575531959534, -0.019773386418819427, -0.012441415339708328, 0.018656320869922638, 0.02758956514298916, 0.023427490144968033, 0.0017006353009492159, -0.04948528856039047, 0.08831554651260376, 0.009826770052313805, -0.012664994224905968, 0.03395802900195122, 0.05106847360730171, 0.015018313191831112, -0.08814868330955505, 0.03424059599637985, -0.04958701133728027, -0.04307278245687485, 0.029900625348091125, -0.01670748181641102, -0.025215422734618187, 0.013400997035205364, -0.030545271933078766, 0.04621746018528938, -0.005711797159165144, 0.005558887962251902, 0.007970649749040604, -0.029485948383808136, -0.005085368640720844, 0.018365606665611267, -0.02445654384791851, -0.07102739065885544, -0.033516883850097656, 0.021631287410855293, -0.01429735403507948, 0.0032910408917814493, -0.0026548882015049458, 0.021559694781899452, -0.027440406382083893, -0.008582890033721924, -0.008043390698730946, -0.020269688218832016, -0.013692891225218773, -0.04524615406990051, -0.04967593401670456, 0.08574894070625305, 0.035312470048666, -0.040348224341869354, 0.0529317632317543, -0.0003798405232373625, 0.02543237805366516, -0.0011343230726197362, -0.024348335340619087, -0.030248958617448807, -0.0640016719698906, 0.028333105146884918, 0.04485680162906647, -0.049713339656591415, -0.029475560411810875, 0.039612941443920135, -0.06554944068193436, -0.012732774950563908, 0.02602267451584339, 0.04747333750128746, -0.008766544982790947, -0.005271778907626867, 0.05388887599110603, -0.00028883517370559275, 0.012423713691532612, 0.01081844512373209, 0.012106773443520069, -0.04047532007098198, 0.0039176312275230885, -0.04762735217809677, 0.015093142166733742, 0.03461013734340668, 0.030726641416549683, -0.0005066294106654823, -0.05986761301755905, -0.023875147104263306, -0.015454648062586784, 0.04838798940181732, 0.021405642852187157, 0.02408447302877903, -0.02758704125881195, 0.0015393714420497417, -0.0021378686651587486, 0.06739920377731323, 0.011946242302656174, 0.017733285203576088, -0.02945428341627121, -0.01996595598757267, -0.020317500457167625, 0.01475647371262312, 0.0392221063375473, -0.007334429305046797, -0.04413433372974396, -0.0004467678372748196, -0.02007933333516121, 0.011229567229747772, -0.06163652613759041, -0.004071028903126717, 0.012173669412732124, 0.025134557858109474, 0.02842184714972973, 0.020530134439468384, 0.0729369968175888, 0.008125017397105694, -0.03953296318650246, -0.017520427703857422, -0.02949286252260208, 0.00431504100561142, -0.006077347788959742, 0.05870014801621437, 0.048318542540073395, -0.05785650387406349, 0.00046648128773085773, 0.032019585371017456, -0.01485090795904398, 0.027331264689564705, 0.017366163432598114, -0.03612638637423515, 0.030437083914875984, 0.001248300657607615, -0.003910505212843418, -0.019794989377260208, -0.061980076134204865, 0.05685539171099663, -0.0047849188558757305, -0.003827546024695039, 0.011106200516223907, -0.012527021579444408, -0.009302656166255474, 0.044489964842796326, -0.008566107600927353, 0.01883063092827797, 0.04260091111063957, 0.03555988892912865, 0.05711076781153679, -0.016133930534124374, 0.03382669389247894, 0.008445365354418755, 0.0320742167532444, 0.007213628850877285, 0.00735767325386405, -0.043107323348522186, 0.010889778845012188, -0.0034619157668203115, 0.0001902634830912575, -0.03184061497449875, -0.03110312856733799, 0.008656613528728485, 0.04090084508061409, 0.004774886649101973, 0.0007119362126104534, 0.022337425500154495, 0.01769961789250374, 0.010172957554459572, -0.010216974653303623, 0.026462813839316368, 0.046940527856349945, 0.02692476287484169, 0.04983854666352272, 0.022130480036139488, 0.018422553315758705, 0.040776997804641724, -0.013892397284507751, 0.05446849763393402, 0.011465582065284252, -0.050871558487415314, 0.01763681322336197, 0.01832064986228943, -0.01787564530968666, -0.020534440875053406, 0.017029857262969017, 0.05543317273259163, 0.09855026751756668, 0.06503138691186905, -0.049270134419202805, -0.008103194646537304, 0.009805654175579548, -0.01821761392056942, 0.042596008628606796, -0.07145696878433228, -0.014254067093133926, -0.028802160173654556, -0.0752006471157074, -0.09602072089910507, -0.02357480488717556, -0.025212401524186134, -0.03546254709362984, -0.0424785241484642, 0.00414449255913496, 0.011877771466970444, 0.01437326893210411, 0.05975576490163803, 0.004521685652434826, -0.03489607200026512, -0.014482551254332066, 0.023488188162446022, -0.0535101443529129, 0.025947879999876022, -0.01173743512481451, -0.019653700292110443, 0.04802900180220604, -0.033070582896471024, -0.04973829537630081, 0.02999504841864109, -0.01078855525702238, 0.029953602701425552, 0.06712979078292847, 0.0032655366230756044, -0.053882695734500885, -0.002441283781081438, -0.05858195573091507, -0.031798314303159714, 0.009289865382015705, 0.007013633381575346, -0.018596651032567024, 0.08150196075439453, -0.011223675683140755, -0.02733004465699196, -0.0006330551696009934, -0.03314093127846718, 0.02605130709707737, 0.026323683559894562, 0.0004069785645697266, -0.05904765427112579, 0.0015556784346699715, -0.05021214112639427, -0.022436242550611496, 0.0008412999450229108, 0.02269096113741398, 0.03201223909854889, -0.009629560634493828, -0.029717985540628433, 0.008096322417259216, 0.0035366045776754618, -0.006269027013331652, -0.02912692353129387, -0.0017860950902104378, -0.017849378287792206, -0.01456756703555584, 0.034338150173425674, -0.04681570082902908, 0.023702697828412056, 0.0004966052365489304, -0.023650435730814934, -0.08268968015909195, -0.011599354445934296, -0.02496018074452877, 0.038365527987480164, -0.07395177334547043, -0.04333173856139183, 0.04393770918250084, -0.011179943569004536, -0.0005554184317588806, 0.016442514955997467, 0.010631902143359184, 0.04872766137123108, -0.00023910950403660536, 0.05828312039375305, -0.021369317546486855, -0.032375987619161606, 0.006617242470383644, -0.059640124440193176, 0.05890156701207161, 0.024063419550657272, 0.052273206412792206, 0.01096213236451149, 0.004668544512242079, 0.04815012216567993, -0.027093371376395226, 0.05166849121451378, 0.018551545217633247, -0.05127110704779625, -0.02779487520456314, -0.016518820077180862, 0.044017404317855835, -0.026401249691843987, 0.06431613117456436, -0.020937416702508926, -0.011879228055477142, 0.006009567994624376, -0.01995665952563286, 0.034314170479774475, -0.012781613506376743, 0.005421140231192112, -0.02111254632472992, 0.021546171978116035, -0.0102426428347826, 0.04536331817507744, 0.035747963935136795, 0.032677166163921356, 0.0287355687469244, -0.0030138350557535887, -0.07454638928174973, 0.02377091348171234, 0.023159628733992577, 0.029004409909248352, -0.04877450317144394, 0.04034741222858429, -0.011938613839447498, 0.023304522037506104, 0.005813005845993757, 0.018673336133360863, 0.02804316207766533, 0.00887694489210844, -0.003611857770010829, -0.04421692714095116, -0.0741877630352974, -0.002163350349292159, 0.055784404277801514, -0.04868723452091217, -0.0251118466258049, -0.036248575896024704, 0.012229260057210922, 0.009993193671107292, -0.06281335651874542, 0.08116215467453003, -0.027193255722522736, -0.018194856122136116, -0.06416962295770645, -0.04360019788146019, 0.015356960706412792, 0.045572541654109955, 0.009222016669809818, -0.05894092842936516, -0.020665617659687996, 0.02867605909705162, -0.008158320561051369, -0.022132089361548424, -0.04349686950445175, -0.03285026550292969, 0.061963245272636414, -0.023569006472826004, -0.022074520587921143, 0.04814354330301285, 0.028264760971069336, -0.01214568316936493, -0.001290661166422069, -0.010513344779610634, -0.00414813868701458, -0.0007975057233124971, 0.013563599437475204, -0.012851758860051632, 0.06763868778944016, 0.027007337659597397, 0.045221634209156036, 0.011320199817419052, 0.02508009783923626, -0.08248894661664963, -0.03544935956597328, -0.04445725679397583, 0.0031044105999171734, 0.05563764646649361, -0.00006139592005638406, -0.0032147737219929695, -0.09670522063970566, 0.0448189415037632, 0.020111029967665672, 0.02676200494170189, 0.025506123900413513, -0.07744747400283813, 0.016892287880182266, 0.024357497692108154, 0.008008127100765705, 0.05647965893149376, -0.01242702268064022, 0.01916898787021637, -0.015086101368069649, 0.011881749145686626, 0.025120476260781288, -0.01678924448788166, 0.018431134521961212, 0.010091706179082394, -0.024691266939044, -0.00004510176586336456, 0.029058411717414856, 0.03343058377504349, 0.05548837408423424, 0.003370861755684018, 0.03537750989198685, -0.04747254028916359, 0.01276093814522028, -0.05494190379977226, 0.06954441964626312, 0.007685098331421614, -0.04133810102939606, -0.03198752924799919, 0.01010296680033207, 0.006663171574473381, 0.07692254334688187, -0.00005207914364291355, 0.051133718341588974, -0.007734683807939291, -0.02250508777797222, -0.016721351072192192, -0.01383095234632492, -0.04757925868034363, -0.017793912440538406, 0.03571860119700432, 0.018193867057561874, 0.025852879509329796, -0.0014674930134788156, -0.009580702520906925, 0.05803736671805382, 0.022249313071370125, -0.06480918079614639, 0.02300569787621498, -0.031128350645303726, -0.033713459968566895, -0.02581496350467205, -0.042740438133478165, 0.02237068861722946, 0.04862244054675102, 0.05646618828177452, -0.055156514048576355, 0.009610628709197044, 0.03305049240589142, 0.003472276031970978, -0.006360148079693317, -0.006541789975017309, -0.022916777059435844, 0.012813636101782322, 0.03851354867219925, -0.10419414937496185, 0.00872045662254095, -0.021205497905611992, 0.002177623100578785, 0.019211027771234512, 0.007304472383111715, -0.012168515473604202, 0.02935943752527237, 0.04471183940768242, -0.0349402092397213, -0.04492441192269325, -0.022943971678614616, 0.02276935987174511, 0.029865747317671776, -0.0043683964759111404, -0.00037638022331520915, 0.05761387571692467, 0.04473024979233742, -0.006398633122444153, 0.04928400367498398, -0.01773434691131115, -0.07539675384759903, 0.023049429059028625, 0.03945569321513176, -0.006806953810155392, -0.0142279751598835, -0.035420309752225876, 0.01940837688744068, 0.004367460962384939, 0.0074914321303367615, -0.010725258849561214, -0.01997194066643715, 0.0003460760635789484, 0.03643854334950447, -0.024001440033316612, 0.025006260722875595, -0.017644697800278664, 0.0016089691780507565, -0.03406602889299393, 0.028325853869318962, 0.03731779381632805, -0.00003286988066975027, 0.030055074021220207, -0.035082850605249405, 0.028344204649329185, 0.005031566601246595, -0.054221462458372116, 0.05879722535610199, -0.005639215465635061, 0.012820607982575893, 0.015824303030967712, 0.05840179696679115, -0.03091248869895935, -0.04724586009979248, -0.006817288231104612, -0.003007559571415186, -0.003700732719153166, -0.04159126803278923, -0.00038646181928925216, -0.03599092364311218, -0.01031201146543026, -0.040599849075078964, 0.028024381026625633, -0.023607861250638962, 0.044807370752096176, 0.07577918469905853, -0.004672969691455364, -0.014671058394014835, 0.006327814422547817, 0.06436217576265335, -0.0213673934340477, -0.030404558405280113, -0.007284003775566816, -0.031051265075802803, -0.021190768107771873, 0.0030081216245889664, -0.024869121611118317, -0.06384345144033432, -0.026387915015220642 ]
<p>How can I show explicitly that the bell state $$|\psi^{-}&gt;=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(|0&gt;|1&gt;-|1&gt;|0&gt;)$$ is invariant under local unitary transformations $U_{1}\otimes U_{2}$ ?</p>
g5853
[ 0.01212617103010416, 0.005259346216917038, -0.021193433552980423, -0.012159320525825024, 0.009163880720734596, 0.01894272491335869, 0.0281490720808506, 0.05716582387685776, 0.031031033024191856, 0.022336207330226898, -0.03935931622982025, 0.08078925311565399, -0.0791274905204773, -0.021057473495602608, -0.015369574539363384, -0.026314862072467804, 0.05687624588608742, 0.01743386872112751, 0.03050730936229229, -0.013019858859479427, -0.05563819780945778, 0.011529427021741867, -0.01918857917189598, -0.016649484634399414, 0.10203927755355835, -0.03393017128109932, 0.05486178770661354, 0.05379476398229599, 0.0069589028134942055, 0.002855453873053193, 0.019166160374879837, -0.02248821221292019, 0.04600134491920471, -0.021675286814570427, 0.0401177778840065, -0.05363824963569641, 0.042648959904909134, 0.0000938129160203971, 0.07529759407043457, 0.03120625577867031, -0.021845128387212753, 0.0015253808815032244, -0.028658390045166016, -0.0041696070693433285, -0.016864454373717308, -0.014622576534748077, 0.02590174600481987, 0.030289748683571815, -0.04953445866703987, 0.010455211624503136, 0.02130316011607647, -0.004498821683228016, 0.10881412774324417, -0.02963300235569477, -0.007454155012965202, 0.006719161756336689, -0.009784381836652756, 0.038379620760679245, 0.06850497424602509, 0.035872019827365875, -0.03473716974258423, -0.08847537636756897, 0.06535214185714722, 0.03560702130198479, 0.0050647747702896595, 0.008094201795756817, -0.021817579865455627, -0.007024517748504877, -0.008390328846871853, 0.053352437913417816, -0.07978793233633041, -0.050074219703674316, 0.017217380926012993, 0.03433344513177872, -0.03890826925635338, -0.025205668061971664, -0.004998465999960899, -0.0499161034822464, -0.011433477513492107, -0.025740347802639008, -0.03075653873383999, 0.013693495653569698, 0.059650667011737823, -0.03449515998363495, 0.025140808895230293, -0.024984899908304214, 0.02116451971232891, -0.02072182483971119, -0.030662663280963898, 0.03426297381520271, 0.0022956624161452055, -0.03784733638167381, -0.009211343713104725, 0.07533843070268631, 0.015566873364150524, -0.05218954384326935, -0.025671564042568207, 0.06241850554943085, -0.023638684302568436, -0.018416397273540497, -0.04943421855568886, 0.022166337817907333, 0.026843637228012085, 0.03784053772687912, -0.02041725255548954, 0.013577844947576523, 0.03557537868618965, -0.03689362481236458, 0.008161945268511772, -0.007147501688450575, -0.03509221225976944, 0.012562050484120846, 0.010881106369197369, -0.032023005187511444, -0.05861363559961319, 0.011100267991423607, 0.05459237098693848, -0.011631385423243046, -0.03155294433236122, 0.06584403663873672, 0.012437223456799984, 0.010438047349452972, 0.07659011334180832, 0.03573447838425636, 0.0055777630768716335, 0.034241024404764175, -0.0560096874833107, 0.02617551200091839, 0.05282214283943176, -0.008634007535874844, 0.023981807753443718, -0.009100842289626598, -0.004720275290310383, -0.01781662553548813, 0.03516224026679993, 0.00984093639999628, 0.0047695147804915905, 0.01601308211684227, -0.017462633550167084, 0.024602733552455902, -0.05751301348209381, 0.007739837747067213, -0.00698035629466176, 0.022109661251306534, 0.0018181696068495512, -0.04400906711816788, -0.026003682985901833, -0.044980768114328384, 0.01900777406990528, -0.0001076706248568371, 0.0020679787266999483, 0.009903531521558762, 0.012223911471664906, -0.04574042186141014, -0.016770778223872185, -0.0332404226064682, 0.050853926688432693, 0.05365040525794029, 0.010341712273657322, 0.0007838629535399377, 0.01889699697494507, 0.007018122356384993, 0.023395150899887085, 0.013941481709480286, -0.05228248983621597, -0.01758890599012375, -0.016069192439317703, 0.021824544295668602, 0.006570837460458279, -0.034587860107421875, 0.03852172568440437, 0.023450296372175217, 0.008941990323364735, 0.049735818058252335, 0.0293071661144495, -0.003095623105764389, -0.03877943754196167, 0.008142172358930111, 0.023386230692267418, 0.030965019017457962, 0.03960425406694412, -0.05533229932188988, -0.005245075095444918, -0.02254372090101242, 0.014623173512518406, -0.007144072558730841, 0.0008030436583794653, 0.04238821193575859, -0.03370815888047218, 0.026604091748595238, -0.04913128912448883, -0.032585687935352325, 0.01275697909295559, -0.00972230639308691, 0.003009178675711155, -0.013069658540189266, 0.009747139178216457, -0.008537545800209045, 0.004778087604790926, -0.010587148368358612, 0.05455022305250168, 0.005500244442373514, 0.02821929380297661, -0.0805610716342926, -0.016658734530210495, 0.006833231076598167, 0.03820832818746567, -0.018378011882305145, 0.0018703527748584747, 0.005702141206711531, -0.01423691213130951, -0.039190519601106644, -0.03615548089146614, 0.0032720020972192287, -0.00514834001660347, -0.00950984563678503, -0.004737173207104206, -0.035887304693460464, -0.008835980668663979, -0.02088027261197567, 0.051403552293777466, 0.06578665226697922, -0.035679735243320465, 0.02598879672586918, 0.01377303060144186, -0.00852214265614748, -0.05070502683520317, 0.0372224859893322, -0.030598783865571022, 0.002846485935151577, -0.013853911310434341, 0.04534037783741951, 0.020190227776765823, -0.050460658967494965, 0.03454986959695816, 0.06492522358894348, -0.016543636098504066, 0.040329717099666595, 0.0020302010234445333, -0.03715426102280617, 0.03861163556575775, -0.06051389127969742, -0.037456635385751724, 0.01926819607615471, 0.0383058525621891, 0.03190550208091736, -0.015809763222932816, -0.005888670217245817, -0.010851786471903324, 0.027808083221316338, -0.03486551344394684, -0.03556196764111519, -0.039977431297302246, -0.041867487132549286, -0.017153164371848106, -0.06820393353700638, 0.02207275852560997, -0.013580176047980785, 0.026105787605047226, -0.0149692352861166, -0.022863712161779404, -0.02342989481985569, 0.009065186604857445, 0.024241216480731964, -0.04625358060002327, -0.006594443693757057, 0.021325185894966125, 0.010851298458874226, -0.009452162310481071, -0.018619125708937645, 0.022811219096183777, 0.05421227961778641, -0.010181136429309845, 0.05764974281191826, -0.013117513619363308, -0.08201103657484055, 0.004663197789341211, 0.0026803347282111645, -0.01998576521873474, -0.043349672108888626, -0.04313557222485542, 0.02327725850045681, -0.06419062614440918, 0.009425870142877102, 0.043655410408973694, -0.08380797505378723, -0.07331766188144684, -0.0008506877347826958, 0.06086022034287453, -0.03397258743643761, 0.030531400814652443, 0.01734447106719017, 0.017285732552409172, 0.011471417732536793, -0.032319482415914536, 0.006827952805906534, -0.012664792127907276, -0.06832904368638992, 0.028601061552762985, 0.008907197043299675, 0.002756386296823621, -0.0427425391972065, -0.0008235174464061856, -0.012139532715082169, 0.030013227835297585, -0.05225682258605957, -0.024956705048680305, -0.04521971568465233, -0.06965736299753189, 0.02624378725886345, -0.01937353052198887, 0.017526820302009583, -0.01578984037041664, -0.03485700488090515, -0.045633334666490555, 0.018342427909374237, -0.04278802126646042, -0.0012107943184673786, -0.018993426114320755, -0.014462742954492569, -0.03290063142776489, -0.027006451040506363, 0.03272886574268341, -0.03349754586815834, 0.009146887809038162, -0.07360763102769852, -0.024710852652788162, 0.05058549717068672, -0.012442922219634056, -0.08693461865186691, 0.03715164586901665, -0.012015964835882187, 0.03777988627552986, -0.019844437018036842, -0.010093342512845993, -0.03000095672905445, -0.0781177282333374, -0.021803298965096474, 0.003157643834128976, -0.008024084381759167, -0.05594882741570473, 0.002833600388839841, -0.024309195578098297, 0.08432571589946747, -0.02289915271103382, 0.004799749236553907, 0.0031055747531354427, 0.02360435388982296, 0.005378796253353357, -0.00871663074940443, -0.010983229614794254, 0.015918057411909103, 0.05258616432547569, 0.011033113114535809, 0.006862647831439972, 0.054199088364839554, 0.0713624358177185, 0.002028238959610462, -0.012567785568535328, -0.011501130647957325, 0.020337412133812904, -0.04296407476067543, 0.006444796919822693, 0.012325271964073181, -0.017664728686213493, -0.03050455078482628, -0.054990772157907486, 0.004847447853535414, 0.05500439554452896, 0.07126160711050034, -0.027850063517689705, -0.045555680990219116, -0.00877294596284628, 0.025516342371702194, -0.031224964186549187, -0.061756432056427, -0.014805261977016926, -0.022335276007652283, 0.005252582021057606, 0.007620396092534065, 0.01665310189127922, -0.05385870486497879, 0.014796524308621883, 0.0014312014682218432, 0.025075571611523628, 0.01889874041080475, -0.01869896426796913, -0.030866632238030434, 0.05177982524037361, -0.021307026967406273, 0.02861347794532776, -0.05060628056526184, -0.015384365804493427, 0.03854501247406006, 0.054914169013500214, 0.037820905447006226, 0.053114913403987885, 0.004898555111140013, -0.07592684775590897, 0.05956388637423515, -0.024224592372775078, -0.03440500423312187, 0.03705114126205444, -0.0020047591533511877, -0.06535474210977554, -0.030611198395490646, 0.02602657489478588, -0.04546200484037399, -0.0027739079669117928, -0.04950888827443123, 0.004634705372154713, 0.0022801090963184834, 0.017862029373645782, -0.050201576203107834, -0.011707884259521961, 0.008274435997009277, -0.007862057536840439, -0.031745024025440216, -0.0013332217931747437, 0.002590024610981345, -0.04086321219801903, 0.00736151821911335, 0.06069212406873703, 0.004365752916783094, 0.03238796070218086, 0.039737194776535034, 0.032994531095027924, 0.011433395557105541, 0.023859195411205292, -0.020042549818754196, 0.013859330676496029, 0.015896977856755257, 0.009901332668960094, 0.041096217930316925, -0.002582758665084839, -0.015241153538227081, -0.05200643837451935, 0.030458685010671616, -0.03434710204601288, 0.004815416876226664, 0.025140995159745216, -0.045832984149456024, -0.05510415509343147, 0.0003164574736729264, -0.030879952013492584, -0.022704051807522774, 0.0025037862360477448, -0.018342362716794014, 0.025451187044382095, -0.013415113091468811, -0.014912347309291363, 0.07420693337917328, 0.021246381103992462, -0.06947632879018784, 0.02888236939907074, -0.007746862713247538, -0.06780016422271729, 0.01690581813454628, 0.006972688715904951, -0.029982825741171837, -0.012232267297804356, -0.043189581483602524, -0.03697424754500389, 0.018499495461583138, 0.016852840781211853, -0.020819665864109993, -0.08698879927396774, 0.0662536472082138, -0.03252461180090904, -0.06407607346773148, 0.020091241225600243, 0.02016773447394371, 0.006690945476293564, -0.061188001185655594, 0.0760425329208374, 0.038614824414253235, -0.029939385131001472, 0.011085260659456253, 0.05300651490688324, -0.025533165782690048, 0.015573287382721901, 0.027539528906345367, -0.0034046790096908808, 0.02881566248834133, 0.02530497871339321, 0.0563865527510643, -0.022084347903728485, -0.037952784448862076, -0.04544822499155998, -0.04857997968792915, 0.007671399973332882, 0.04810817539691925, 0.04277725890278816, 0.028655948117375374, 0.03592725470662117, 0.03487876430153847, -0.001716132741421461, 0.009612539783120155, -0.011455767787992954, 0.019574277102947235, -0.08542992919683456, 0.06303245574235916, 0.03112030029296875, 0.05099615827202797, -0.011929841712117195, 0.04127231985330582, 0.07025571167469025, 0.030372563749551773, -0.036035772413015366, 0.02265564166009426, -0.013925299048423767, -0.017746051773428917, -0.019750148057937622, -0.06312981992959976, 0.060236819088459015, 0.020426126196980476, 0.0030402608681470156, 0.01481389719992876, -0.04684159904718399, -0.009749272838234901, 0.035682544112205505, 0.027339113876223564, 0.03866785392165184, -0.06574037671089172, -0.019220618531107903, 0.03856968879699707, -0.029442213475704193, -0.09977414458990097, -0.01857265830039978, 0.021068409085273743, 0.004232435487210751, -0.01828876882791519, -0.018421094864606857, 0.02987130731344223, 0.041842926293611526, -0.001572163077071309, -0.017008211463689804, -0.022269049659371376, -0.000650846108328551, 0.00004575290950015187, -0.007582096382975578, -0.06435083597898483, 0.005406984128057957, 0.010311508551239967, -0.0048662154003977776, 0.04110788181424141, -0.04234898090362549, 0.0014216997660696507, -0.04258525371551514, 0.01126883551478386, 0.01084783487021923, -0.03882740065455437, -0.06861720979213715, -0.03681546077132225, 0.030049877241253853, 0.03569771721959114, 0.07970825582742691, -0.023764753714203835, 0.046038709580898285, 0.03667052090167999, 0.07497721910476685, 0.014040829613804817, 0.0464373417198658, -0.014989803545176983, 0.006225022487342358, -0.06371041387319565, -0.026366615667939186, 0.018467478454113007, 0.057433538138866425, 0.02471083402633667, 0.06173434108495712, 0.01973091997206211, -0.02958695776760578, -0.009458348155021667, -0.06864668428897858, 0.01915130205452442, -0.03666587173938751, -0.03296700492501259, 0.03763502091169357, 0.00725949602201581, -0.06309526413679123, 0.007286327891051769, 0.058325111865997314, -0.04332192987203598, -0.059462569653987885, 0.08549366891384125, 0.03737832233309746, 0.005420083645731211, 0.03422117978334427, 0.0626847892999649, -0.06568394601345062, 0.01678183302283287, -0.038225241005420685, 0.0564841702580452, 0.04707097262144089, 0.01848641224205494, -0.0024778954684734344, 0.043618593364953995, -0.03427920490503311, -0.01778326742351055, 0.012414224445819855, -0.03060513362288475, 0.033112745732069016, 0.0019180625677108765, -0.02395493909716606, 0.022437896579504013, -0.07484331727027893, 0.0006671229493804276, 0.03246460109949112, 0.0654078796505928, -0.0013383635086938739, -0.00411234749481082, -0.024959394708275795, 0.011463804170489311, 0.019021356478333473, -0.09060908108949661, -0.0034497869201004505, 0.038758356124162674, -0.07478667795658112, 0.0009546270011924207, 0.09385772049427032, 0.006218044552952051, 0.009521646425127983, -0.01633739098906517, 0.004216312430799007, 0.026052087545394897, -0.019742326810956, 0.0025249740574508905, 0.033375851809978485, -0.024939198046922684, -0.012881039641797543, -0.010708378627896309, 0.006984731648117304, -0.017446547746658325, -0.045852892100811005, 0.03685088828206062, -0.020551299676299095, 0.05558447912335396, 0.04956113174557686, -0.005721750669181347, 0.034163642674684525, 0.05918555334210396, 0.008939113467931747, -0.024071181192994118, -0.06526003032922745, 0.027960989624261856, 0.030437031760811806, 0.027205195277929306, -0.0463993065059185, 0.06587384641170502, 0.05017487704753876, 0.06587271392345428, -0.03216300532221794, -0.051874399185180664, -0.03789201378822327, -0.017840618267655373, 0.012961297295987606, 0.015108056366443634, 0.04295392334461212, -0.03546726331114769, 0.008633921854197979, -0.016247352585196495, -0.01952430047094822, 0.007851410657167435, 0.03251839429140091, 0.05867495387792587, 0.01279863528907299, -0.08911741524934769, 0.06590870767831802, -0.08302558958530426, 0.024525180459022522, -0.0164605975151062, -0.00162914686370641, 0.0015025498578324914, 0.022478997707366943, -0.017419520765542984, -0.01052096951752901, 0.08977379649877548, -0.025224190205335617, 0.013120780698955059, 0.036501675844192505, 0.01329227164387703, -0.023127829656004906, -0.000798437453340739, -0.029825642704963684, 0.01999008283019066, -0.001130983466282487, -0.012529939413070679, 0.00635895412415266, 0.027252713218331337, -0.014248653315007687, 0.011837697587907314, 0.028003908693790436, 0.015953240916132927, -0.02729385532438755, -0.047871194779872894, 0.04421759769320488, 0.016884610056877136, 0.018602048978209496, -0.021170618012547493, 0.029503263533115387, 0.02199275977909565, -0.03925999999046326, 0.00026099872775375843, 0.041921716183423996, -0.06688840687274933, -0.014833105728030205, -0.0453241690993309, 0.010165616869926453, -0.00572273600846529, 0.025336921215057373, -0.003874631132930517, 0.030008675530552864, 0.005220210645347834, 0.107430100440979, -0.040477532893419266, -0.06674277782440186, 0.04665820300579071, 0.0391574390232563, 0.04351114481687546, -0.016449278220534325, -0.02884962223470211, -0.019976329058408737, -0.015509276650846004, -0.0008640500600449741, -0.035722602158784866, 0.06883936375379562, 0.022086137905716896, 0.0015070884255692363, 0.00960040558129549, -0.045446764677762985, 0.0004483696538954973, -0.0012441705912351608, -0.004494948778301477, -0.0552782267332077, 0.0024330271407961845, -0.017352759838104248, -0.03809657320380211, 0.019569840282201767, -0.016149813309311867, -0.02531532570719719, -0.017416058108210564, -0.002037457190454006, 0.005734408739954233, -0.014795989729464054, -0.02169598639011383, -0.013390769250690937, 0.05924637243151665, 0.015253121964633465, -0.09128309041261673, 0.05782940238714218, 0.006664356216788292, -0.020267268642783165, 0.03160169720649719, 0.04946556314826012, -0.04523887112736702, 0.02834508568048477, 0.014941586181521416, 0.004391264636069536, 0.011083461344242096, 0.02014351636171341, 0.01780971698462963, -0.03281325101852417, -0.06487778574228287, -0.06530588120222092, -0.035927608609199524, 0.01359992753714323, 0.0051282779313623905 ]
<p>Is it true that whenever an action takes place it is dependent on both its past and future? I mean if we already know that whatever we are doing is dependent on future as much as it is dependent on the past. If that is the case how can you not tell what I will be typing next?</p>
g5854
[ 0.009282682090997696, 0.035909369587898254, 0.022994183003902435, 0.027219068259000778, 0.01369903702288866, 0.017425155267119408, 0.03442617505788803, 0.017650552093982697, -0.006491503212600946, -0.01931651681661606, -0.029591349884867668, -0.015565525740385056, -0.04193191975355148, 0.004384304862469435, -0.009779127314686775, -0.01746416464447975, 0.06743192672729492, -0.021899642422795296, -0.05050336569547653, 0.060496918857097626, -0.01222284510731697, 0.05272374674677849, -0.004334902390837669, 0.013436144217848778, -0.05075255408883095, 0.0035262242890894413, 0.056687112897634506, -0.07370645552873611, -0.040902115404605865, -0.04693193361163139, 0.044216711074113846, 0.01751924306154251, -0.00561064388602972, -0.06550070643424988, -0.025432681664824486, -0.030667444691061974, 0.03531401604413986, -0.022047599777579308, 0.057450346648693085, -0.017038598656654358, -0.037044771015644073, 0.053862717002630234, -0.014958961866796017, -0.0330062210559845, -0.03662439435720444, -0.06869252026081085, -0.00695390161126852, -0.04210248216986656, -0.023098522797226906, 0.02857206016778946, -0.03945428133010864, 0.022641584277153015, -0.04884052276611328, 0.002440705196931958, 0.07580604404211044, 0.024802718311548233, 0.07626354694366455, 0.003616556990891695, -0.00240738270804286, -0.014439188875257969, 0.036818113178014755, 0.019257422536611557, -0.0017173858359456062, 0.01901371404528618, 0.003782166400924325, -0.025418967008590698, -0.036252692341804504, -0.008986984379589558, -0.03397746384143829, -0.006119603291153908, -0.07163440436124802, -0.02089906483888626, -0.0561111755669117, 0.02797478809952736, 0.04877866804599762, 0.039674170315265656, 0.053680140525102615, -0.044633232057094574, 0.032009609043598175, 0.059655386954545975, 0.008879102766513824, -0.03551875799894333, 0.06498588621616364, 0.0369662344455719, 0.027171585708856583, -0.0017080565448850393, -0.01681165210902691, 0.003565783379599452, -0.03975869342684746, -0.002243796596303582, 0.07427645474672318, 0.01740366406738758, 0.042031336575746536, 0.054135315120220184, 0.014798218384385109, -0.004821899812668562, 0.02258998714387417, 0.00692077586427331, 0.010030907578766346, 0.05291289836168289, -0.018407095223665237, 0.016268502920866013, 0.0044265370815992355, -0.044186897575855255, 0.009351006709039211, -0.0694979578256607, 0.035132043063640594, -0.040851566940546036, -0.028480440378189087, -0.06660983711481094, -0.008904418908059597, 0.03795045241713524, -0.07529008388519287, 0.044450972229242325, -0.06437088549137115, -0.059466443955898285, 0.007790869101881981, 0.027647120878100395, -0.00426264014095068, -0.043825164437294006, -0.037771742790937424, -0.039095815271139145, 0.002131309825927019, 0.016336582601070404, -0.05515192449092865, 0.014506528154015541, -0.05985566973686218, 0.022784844040870667, -0.004736288916319609, 0.0007165734423324466, 0.04023672267794609, 0.030088646337389946, 0.07769466191530228, 0.12243181467056274, -0.0006187238031998277, -0.007018728647381067, -0.03191833570599556, 0.03813556581735611, 0.005599428899586201, 0.01357653271406889, 0.020105712115764618, 0.02354470267891884, -0.008366318419575691, -0.009860497899353504, -0.002369646681472659, 0.030369430780410767, -0.008595426566898823, 0.013331425376236439, 0.014104358851909637, 0.0018046905752271414, -0.05198938399553299, 0.011868927627801895, -0.0016827614745125175, 0.013623282313346863, 0.028809113427996635, -0.044439367949962616, -0.04382660612463951, 0.0005496185622178018, 0.01432749629020691, -0.030807744711637497, 0.06591977924108505, 0.024495309218764305, 0.09866230189800262, 0.008484247140586376, -0.05578747019171715, -0.05274152383208275, 0.018998675048351288, 0.019623780623078346, -0.045050837099552155, -0.01695823110640049, -0.031316399574279785, -0.001141405082307756, 0.027990728616714478, -0.032164353877305984, 0.04520126059651375, 0.01350255124270916, -0.015952887013554573, -0.02756047248840332, 0.01590985246002674, 0.006101110950112343, -0.031546905636787415, 0.018835879862308502, -0.0397915318608284, -0.008009057492017746, -0.03146252781152725, -0.009288092143833637, -0.06356900930404663, 0.040419839322566986, -0.02756708674132824, -0.04940267279744148, -0.0630754604935646, -0.020057741552591324, 0.0386819951236248, 0.024619650095701218, -0.019013483077287674, -0.011581956408917904, -0.031378962099552155, -0.019763164222240448, -0.028651246801018715, 0.05229965224862099, 0.016353972256183624, 0.05068889632821083, -0.004499634727835655, 0.026344528421759605, -0.02674701251089573, 0.08153828978538513, -0.012756177224218845, -0.009225443936884403, 0.011439678259193897, 0.014131751842796803, 0.0780147835612297, 0.04178671911358833, -0.03220408037304878, -0.004514193627983332, 0.007325053680688143, 0.008147681131958961, -0.004352951887995005, 0.005889557301998138, 0.0274028517305851, -0.011481620371341705, -0.009481385350227356, -0.003303281031548977, 0.08645201474428177, -0.012121913023293018, -0.04911425709724426, 0.006969326641410589, 0.028039731085300446, -0.04214858636260033, -0.04088809713721275, 0.05150260031223297, -0.017985325306653976, -0.06611049920320511, -0.02076708897948265, -0.007822677493095398, 0.006028276868164539, 0.023413246497511864, 0.016226155683398247, 0.015966763719916344, -0.007706571836024523, 0.03105611726641655, -0.001974451821297407, -0.05798301845788956, -0.027665384113788605, 0.01790565438568592, 0.02683492936193943, -0.08631943166255951, 0.03857008367776871, -0.02377924509346485, -0.021920669823884964, 0.03312961757183075, 0.009842699393630028, -0.05108223855495453, -0.053400203585624695, 0.00009522016625851393, -0.038257189095020294, -0.026356512680649757, 0.021809663623571396, 0.03826132416725159, -0.0806453749537468, -0.047759827226400375, 0.0343005508184433, 0.005287490785121918, 0.000843749032355845, 0.003892229637131095, 0.060414720326662064, 0.004873021971434355, 0.028877295553684235, 0.00841557513922453, 0.013240654952824116, -0.020150206983089447, -0.013587163761258125, -0.013429536484181881, 0.018930966034531593, -0.011334004811942577, -0.034947581589221954, 0.0021365100983530283, -0.05533498898148537, -0.06619282066822052, 0.05677764490246773, 0.02070271410048008, -0.012875931337475777, -0.00446738488972187, -0.019510796293616295, 0.016186702996492386, 0.015662945806980133, 0.006151131354272366, 0.041167501360177994, -0.009067102335393429, -0.013585345819592476, 0.02295161597430706, -0.021210499107837677, -0.012193663977086544, 0.010109763592481613, -0.027391934767365456, -0.007276682648807764, 0.04789574816823006, -0.007165811024606228, -0.03107665851712227, -0.018461311236023903, 0.030221659690141678, 0.008985543623566628, -0.05672893673181534, -0.008960799314081669, 0.04497908800840378, 0.06584184616804123, -0.015243730507791042, -0.023146264255046844, -0.06775379180908203, 0.001981233712285757, -0.011542432941496372, -0.0740930512547493, 0.040122102946043015, -0.011488888412714005, -0.008907139301300049, -0.04894952476024628, 0.03058440051972866, -0.042403027415275574, -0.007720734924077988, -0.042048946022987366, 0.022308794781565666, -0.002923778258264065, -0.014647554606199265, 0.0059080771170556545, 0.02823481895029545, -0.008955463767051697, 0.000356135715264827, -0.000590447336435318, 0.02789630927145481, -0.02996734529733658, 0.021107777953147888, -0.017500005662441254, -0.005171306896954775, -0.001493637915700674, -0.017262952402234077, 0.022269021719694138, -0.040598947554826736, 0.05839109420776367, 0.031218506395816803, -0.07075367867946625, 0.03484025225043297, 0.062366560101509094, -0.012779955752193928, 0.03304234892129898, 0.029426923021674156, 0.061800867319107056, 0.03725355491042137, 0.00670961569994688, 0.02412090264260769, 0.02838009223341942, 0.016127998009324074, 0.009067175909876823, -0.011975101195275784, -0.07228687405586243, -0.007141373585909605, 0.049050670117139816, 0.06268414855003357, 0.0009877998381853104, 0.02526581846177578, -0.0743754580616951, 0.014248154126107693, -0.021227151155471802, -0.0645095556974411, -0.01475856639444828, 0.006717375945299864, 0.07242538779973984, 0.08604355156421661, 0.0007325339829549193, -0.031755201518535614, 0.04389799386262894, 0.007249935995787382, 0.08501092344522476, -0.02399161458015442, 0.0067895520478487015, 0.017916101962327957, -0.000960668723564595, 0.033305540680885315, 0.03353245556354523, 0.008652281947433949, -0.010541862808167934, -0.0045468369498848915, 0.07034336775541306, 0.0715390145778656, -0.005695275496691465, 0.06435293704271317, 0.007067336235195398, 0.0032849956769496202, 0.01095522753894329, 0.010037342086434364, -0.013241967186331749, -0.006848418619483709, 0.03690454736351967, 0.03300315514206886, 0.025828564539551735, 0.011157527565956116, 0.024750979617238045, -0.006432993337512016, 0.02821493148803711, -0.017894592136144638, 0.05646010860800743, -0.0015809654723852873, 0.03614843264222145, -0.0295079555362463, -0.028309699147939682, -0.02149854600429535, -0.03995285928249359, -0.0022565368562936783, 0.01881285011768341, -0.07805466651916504, -0.030013933777809143, -0.054621320217847824, -0.007739468477666378, 0.0027040657587349415, -0.04243212938308716, 0.03701670467853546, 0.044061142951250076, 0.013564846478402615, -0.011603026650846004, 0.014240491203963757, -0.008479802869260311, 0.043286848813295364, 0.03536226227879524, 0.07654214650392532, 0.01704140193760395, -0.04573816433548927, 0.026246806606650352, 0.012733730487525463, 0.025412337854504585, -0.08758354187011719, 0.010967935435473919, -0.024122757837176323, -0.07906500995159149, 0.0795573964715004, 0.002371227601543069, 0.004151489119976759, -0.04994305223226547, 0.02823561057448387, -0.03659781068563461, -0.015615810640156269, 0.03754286468029022, 0.02262263558804989, 0.021008940413594246, 0.005853621754795313, -0.039980579167604446, 0.08523907512426376, 0.032900262624025345, 0.02904321439564228, -0.020240454003214836, 0.012450912036001682, 0.05040465295314789, -0.03247435390949249, -0.06902549415826797, 0.04451717436313629, 0.011568468064069748, -0.05829349905252457, 0.021489843726158142, 0.007436802145093679, -0.016392800956964493, 0.007083652541041374, -0.030600305646657944, -0.016644978895783424, 0.01935233548283577, -0.039429593831300735, 0.05691816657781601, 0.054550863802433014, -0.05001302808523178, -0.017218252643942833, -0.04338262975215912, -0.04765435680747032, -0.06186402216553688, 0.051021598279476166, 0.002528435317799449, 0.036051712930202484, 0.001296787871979177, 0.014333040453493595, 0.02101893164217472, -0.030141681432724, 0.024588748812675476, -0.0008317044121213257, 0.015214004553854465, 0.05655853822827339, -0.049836982041597366, -0.04605354741215706, 0.03152954578399658, -0.005981724709272385, -0.03993761166930199, -0.003088564146310091, -0.0016257523093372583, -0.003823692910373211, 0.0176498182117939, 0.0003658506611827761, 0.04442546144127846, 0.04387993738055229, 0.021680867299437523, -0.014279177412390709, -0.076128289103508, -0.029978420585393906, -0.014040381647646427, 0.029443588107824326, -0.004257881548255682, 0.027696071192622185, -0.051253966987133026, -0.008547167293727398, 0.035001158714294434, -0.01365612167865038, -0.010792256332933903, 0.02796229161322117, 0.03299211338162422, -0.03764481097459793, -0.044159356504678726, -0.0030410655308514833, 0.016980502754449844, 0.06532894819974899, -0.041336316615343094, -0.004402445629239082, 0.027492955327033997, 0.00801869947463274, 0.0340760312974453, -0.04645545780658722, -0.04208103194832802, 0.02358357235789299, -0.015223556198179722, 0.026854241266846657, 0.03509692847728729, 0.007892617024481297, 0.033957768231630325, -0.04877431318163872, -0.02029319852590561, -0.019662385806441307, 0.021792961284518242, 0.020763196051120758, 0.04014717787504196, 0.028033411130309105, 0.05020184442400932, -0.05288781225681305, 0.009667443111538887, 0.01788553223013878, -0.023040801286697388, -0.028210436925292015, 0.06869238615036011, 0.015305009670555592, -0.03847894072532654, -0.06488063931465149, -0.009973290376365185, 0.08325186371803284, -0.005290585570037365, -0.012855230830609798, -0.020453594624996185, 0.0002946770400740206, -0.013986813835799694, -0.06482502073049545, 0.048029810190200806, 0.057869575917720795, -0.004636544268578291, 0.0133903119713068, -0.08452389389276505, 0.07434846460819244, -0.04407113045454025, -0.003376690438017249, 0.0009279843070544302, -0.059819091111421585, 0.022699618712067604, 0.015223712660372257, -0.027124546468257904, -0.023150883615016937, 0.033513668924570084, -0.051682014018297195, -0.0005781578947789967, 0.018065420910716057, 0.030635740607976913, 0.004347039852291346, 0.05632505193352699, -0.027010666206479073, -0.03598766028881073, 0.016692187637090683, -0.018261348828673363, -0.03572719916701317, -0.052799370139837265, 0.003994476981461048, 0.013776188716292381, 0.009269087575376034, 0.029712270945310593, -0.04067417234182358, 0.03400276228785515, 0.015788162127137184, -0.0017622191226109862, 0.02372562140226364, 0.032917238771915436, 0.014220763929188251, -0.02129393443465233, 0.022186756134033203, -0.01744670234620571, 0.039101555943489075, -0.0250385869294405, -0.015492964535951614, 0.05345556512475014, 0.022558843716979027, -0.002911688294261694, -0.00935608521103859, 0.0015226667746901512, 0.028180796653032303, -0.004886365961283445, -0.022826017811894417, 0.03706546872854233, -0.08263827115297318, -0.0038490514270961285, 0.06627420336008072, -0.014037585817277431, 0.04112226143479347, -0.012791607528924942, -0.01189418788999319, -0.05084840580821037, -0.044537074863910675, 0.03474341705441475, 0.048530030995607376, 0.033120669424533844, -0.02773001231253147, -0.027823936194181442, 0.0018516953568905592, -0.03159730136394501, 0.02044099010527134, 0.06982532143592834, 0.01784476451575756, -0.04878703132271767, -0.06792529672384262, -0.07891935855150223, 0.029934167861938477, -0.017287181690335274, -0.008920053020119667, -0.04993866756558418, 0.037273794412612915, 0.026809385046362877, 0.03055192343890667, -0.049292318522930145, 0.07176665961742401, -0.010260043665766716, 0.034332986921072006, -0.012121261097490788, 0.039299484342336655, -0.056967731565237045, 0.006432389374822378, 0.026587018743157387, 0.007174889091402292, 0.009432891383767128, 0.030681122094392776, -0.007963585667312145, 0.07836564630270004, 0.030260508880019188, -0.02621915377676487, -0.0704776719212532, -0.029460519552230835, 0.003014853224158287, -0.005228674039244652, -0.004734188783913851, -0.0336635485291481, 0.013664262369275093, 0.0036872942000627518, -0.000723575649317354, -0.008907005190849304, -0.07496229559183121, -0.04827144742012024, -0.022302092984318733, -0.0347752720117569, -0.08188965916633606, 0.028154557570815086, -0.07263561338186264, 0.02854844555258751, 0.039263125509023666, -0.07166250795125961, 0.012771503999829292, -0.03842178359627724, -0.023075588047504425, -0.044829271733760834, 0.020759975537657738, -0.024070611223578453, -0.042095135897397995, 0.013036750257015228, 0.009647426195442677, -0.01617933064699173, -0.005038389936089516, 0.04586150124669075, 0.06324136257171631, -0.009981556795537472, 0.030610201880335808, -0.0660887286067009, -0.02566150203347206, 0.03380823880434036, -0.0048587447963654995, -0.0319240465760231, -0.030663589015603065, -0.0938216969370842, -0.03726200759410858, -0.04037166386842728, -0.015531458891928196, -0.010346603579819202, 0.04232504963874817, -0.043257828801870346, 0.043939925730228424, 0.08877244591712952, 0.002434512134641409, 0.0068887206725776196, -0.004041410516947508, 0.0024201844353228807, -0.018957337364554405, -0.005701132118701935, -0.022259468212723732, -0.006347699090838432, -0.015777144581079483, 0.012756654061377048, 0.025989554822444916, -0.0301101952791214, 0.0037377735134214163, 0.04680599272251129, -0.024346720427274704, 0.031036807224154472, -0.02316788025200367, -0.0181407630443573, 0.028186874464154243, -0.008723866194486618, 0.003458575578406453, 0.06141570955514908, 0.018120476976037025, -0.0337938629090786, -0.04197705537080765, -0.08235560357570648, -0.008410518057644367, 0.025764402002096176, 0.01960720494389534, -0.020043732598423958, 0.003556100884452462, 0.020319603383541107, 0.006833064369857311, -0.055580079555511475, 0.005889692809432745, 0.017161980271339417, 0.023844530805945396, 0.03132842481136322, -0.030885621905326843, 0.0029718121513724327, 0.001858354196883738, -0.0724247619509697, 0.03444002941250801, -0.00716749019920826, -0.059953492134809494, 0.05104093998670578, -0.05851951614022255, 0.0038732397370040417, 0.02697003073990345, -0.009494906291365623, 0.03142045810818672, 0.01685503125190735, -0.026711219921708107, -0.015513169579207897, 0.009630553424358368, 0.010186107829213142, -0.020412035286426544, -0.014094348065555096, -0.07404130697250366, 0.030941957607865334, 0.04616810008883476, 0.04914581775665283, 0.0077049764804542065, 0.06052297726273537, -0.009650789201259613, -0.03513607010245323, -0.0165968406945467, -0.022658536210656166, 0.008324877358973026, -0.021504824981093407 ]
<p>I remember hearing about this in one of the programs in discovery science. The physicist claimed that the maximum possible information in the universe is (10)^(10^123) whereas the maximum possible information that can be known by man is (10)^(10^90). Can anyone explain to me how can we arrive at such a specific number, and also how can information be represented by only numbers?</p>
g5855
[ 0.025481276214122772, 0.02742641419172287, -0.0027064175810664892, -0.029976950958371162, 0.049361567944288254, -0.022160325199365616, -0.01943931169807911, 0.030992653220891953, -0.031029829755425453, -0.048663005232810974, 0.012071737088263035, -0.04429570585489273, 0.06699326634407043, 0.008803734555840492, 0.040820859372615814, 0.007577415090054274, 0.04800820350646973, -0.07564409077167511, 0.015199892222881317, -0.0011401978554204106, 0.006294241640716791, 0.03180548921227455, 0.0002482700510881841, 0.0035368623211979866, -0.0650641992688179, -0.04329517111182213, 0.019084930419921875, -0.017779020592570305, -0.04055725410580635, -0.0065896776504814625, 0.006050078198313713, 0.023952588438987732, 0.0038102474063634872, 0.012959204614162445, -0.025015229359269142, -0.04041963443160057, -0.03163117170333862, -0.012400049716234207, 0.06140943616628647, -0.015965661033988, -0.021396823227405548, 0.0031255711801350117, 0.0190559271723032, -0.03242194652557373, -0.03254042565822601, 0.03062369115650654, 0.0101030757650733, 0.020407969132065773, 0.05206526070833206, -0.03445049747824669, -0.003000511322170496, -0.0030591790564358234, 0.02120634913444519, 0.04762855917215347, 0.004522666800767183, -0.014469698071479797, 0.0014340607449412346, -0.07976938039064407, 0.10760129243135452, 0.02162822335958481, 0.035210274159908295, 0.0060729156248271465, -0.02125445008277893, 0.021240515634417534, 0.05854260176420212, 0.016841506585478783, -0.05171627551317215, 0.07156705111265182, -0.035084277391433716, -0.018745172768831253, 0.057474978268146515, -0.0632878914475441, 0.017962297424674034, -0.00820558238774538, -0.0001523179089417681, 0.007682336959987879, 0.0741422101855278, 0.019421344622969627, 0.009459071792662144, 0.05356711149215698, 0.0011995319509878755, -0.030569272115826607, 0.037189189344644547, -0.07368253171443939, -0.0030163228511810303, -0.0163128525018692, -0.05513842776417732, -0.04057398438453674, -0.05490364134311676, 0.041309911757707596, -0.014948836527764797, -0.01180206798017025, 0.040887463837862015, 0.010837661102414131, 0.018950793892145157, 0.04039386659860611, -0.0321517139673233, 0.007467132061719894, 0.006815571803599596, 0.02442164719104767, 0.003136927727609873, -0.015636298805475235, 0.010703389532864094, 0.003472608746960759, -0.026337895542383194, 0.00421857787296176, 0.02261360175907612, -0.038646306842565536, 0.0004888673429377377, -0.011818732134997845, 0.014750438742339611, -0.06916039437055588, -0.01786917634308338, 0.00490879500284791, -0.03868418186903, 0.015231523662805557, 0.08671455830335617, 0.01105412282049656, -0.029192689806222916, 0.03989066928625107, -0.035797424614429474, 0.055730439722537994, 0.01002372708171606, 0.04874546080827713, -0.012728501111268997, -0.03194694593548775, 0.0258563831448555, 0.031170383095741272, 0.0028932704590260983, -0.05956153944134712, 0.015462581999599934, -0.018623221665620804, 0.013827437534928322, 0.035332031548023224, -0.028904249891638756, -0.007847288623452187, -0.013594534248113632, 0.04950165003538132, 0.046025194227695465, 0.013140251860022545, -0.01751665212213993, -0.015120419673621655, -0.02317114919424057, 0.014339097775518894, -0.0060122194699943066, -0.020840005949139595, -0.03756655752658844, 0.031448911875486374, -0.03159205615520477, 0.014509818516671658, 0.03181185573339462, 0.01068898942321539, 0.05953564867377281, -0.04952893778681755, 0.005409545265138149, -0.04710252955555916, 0.04178844392299652, 0.08596017956733704, -0.03475962579250336, 0.02812894806265831, 0.0774870365858078, 0.015380991622805595, -0.03071664087474346, 0.016500625759363174, -0.01805814541876316, -0.008117671124637127, -0.006583902984857559, -0.04821661114692688, 0.00025540104252286255, -0.03162282705307007, -0.03308355435729027, -0.0017480844398960471, 0.02731575071811676, 0.06484568864107132, -0.0012644011294469237, 0.04906676337122917, 0.006007467396557331, -0.0006764053250662982, -0.028878219425678253, 0.024291714653372765, -0.01786859706044197, -0.06799938529729843, -0.008531440049409866, 0.008080565370619297, -0.019655741751194, 0.005390125792473555, 0.011017993092536926, 0.044980164617300034, 0.03653018921613693, 0.002211502520367503, -0.09783360362052917, 0.0148639976978302, 0.030778169631958008, -0.009770411998033524, 0.041098061949014664, -0.0006104225176386535, 0.05955612286925316, -0.05525050684809685, -0.03673933446407318, 0.04947931692004204, -0.004491602070629597, 0.021161016076803207, -0.019073057919740677, -0.015756109729409218, 0.0270597692579031, -0.026746327057480812, -0.01448009442538023, 0.05958961695432663, 0.053790632635354996, -0.02664543129503727, 0.016440197825431824, -0.04443122446537018, 0.05741020292043686, 0.04357335343956947, 0.008302963338792324, -0.00596891762688756, 0.004483664408326149, 0.0027497371193021536, 0.012184850871562958, -0.005831726361066103, 0.014607718214392662, -0.05921678617596626, 0.009059220552444458, 0.0061227683909237385, 0.0037683092523366213, 0.002395591465756297, -0.04120131954550743, -0.05398104339838028, -0.004206682089716196, 0.05828028917312622, -0.09037911891937256, -0.008648589253425598, 0.012270370498299599, 0.03436936438083649, -0.027647828683257103, 0.014468563720583916, 0.011149212718009949, 0.032033421099185944, 0.01425470132380724, 0.002749495906755328, 0.0032046702690422535, -0.012012463994324207, -0.05030857399106026, 0.03234804421663284, -0.07248333841562271, -0.0440637469291687, 0.01174444891512394, 0.016679413616657257, -0.05216846987605095, 0.05100071430206299, -0.016877729445695877, -0.053193598985672, -0.008575187996029854, 0.02408589795231819, 0.0029468906577676535, 0.007526712957769632, -0.014169994741678238, 0.012976250611245632, -0.07977412641048431, -0.0024350606836378574, 0.01025770977139473, -0.004574116785079241, 0.03032842092216015, -0.00318056158721447, -0.023515107110142708, -0.024703554809093475, -0.07189235091209412, 0.0050125629641115665, -0.07120992988348007, 0.02003384754061699, 0.02147364616394043, 0.025720177218317986, -0.023467497900128365, -0.006100750062614679, -0.043904438614845276, -0.014781330712139606, 0.012178556993603706, -0.007980736903846264, -0.016439929604530334, -0.03640410304069519, -0.016124336048960686, 0.015383468009531498, -0.03354464843869209, -0.024637682363390923, -0.01583508774638176, -0.052228935062885284, -0.011392750777304173, -0.01209868211299181, 0.005186973139643669, 0.0412866473197937, 0.0021653794683516026, -0.005967931356281042, 0.02449025958776474, 0.006773790810257196, 0.014400633051991463, -0.03102097660303116, 0.010843451134860516, 0.03972679376602173, 0.014438115991652012, -0.04086286574602127, 0.0016729705967009068, -0.005977068096399307, 0.011849732138216496, -0.0418427512049675, -0.03548614680767059, -0.01899273507297039, 0.023702621459960938, 0.0010469445260241628, -0.027144810184836388, -0.022932888939976692, 0.014336266554892063, 0.03611666336655617, 0.03229280933737755, 0.04205891489982605, -0.0018932247767224908, 0.06620181351900101, -0.010426254011690617, 0.026159804314374924, 0.03764987364411354, -0.03328152000904083, -0.03909144550561905, -0.0009307173895649612, -0.004553322680294514, -0.0335879810154438, 0.04638056829571724, 0.03435413911938667, -0.08051861077547073, -0.02021830901503563, -0.07269011437892914, -0.021123131737113, 0.028389835730195045, -0.023491300642490387, -0.02921626716852188, 0.004549229983240366, -0.063948854804039, -0.0014569289050996304, -0.012051046825945377, -0.01809997670352459, 0.05382901802659035, 0.03131183609366417, 0.0282104704529047, -0.004446721635758877, -0.07893158495426178, -0.02480125054717064, 0.020379688590765, 0.06646554917097092, -0.056249842047691345, 0.002635134384036064, 0.04239022731781006, -0.01899532787501812, 0.042446233332157135, 0.07822881639003754, -0.022447586059570312, -0.01247631385922432, 0.016042668372392654, 0.03855793550610542, -0.043225787580013275, 0.06252652406692505, 0.05212382599711418, -0.003856964409351349, 0.025875704362988472, -0.01723492704331875, 0.06690942496061325, -0.008688262663781643, -0.005956533830612898, -0.04200747609138489, 0.022639716044068336, -0.025093110278248787, 0.015042140148580074, 0.02703462541103363, -0.025946611538529396, -0.030576391145586967, 0.014959181658923626, -0.06093563511967659, 0.05451269820332527, -0.038490377366542816, -0.0016663557616993785, -0.056410711258649826, 0.013001919724047184, 0.05497518554329872, 0.006424131337553263, -0.015479838475584984, 0.023952845484018326, -0.04123997688293457, 0.051638904958963394, -0.0034393465612083673, 0.023694030940532684, -0.046820782124996185, 0.02501654624938965, -0.027569085359573364, 0.03821786865592003, -0.11634135991334915, -0.0006884050089865923, -0.023631617426872253, -0.014317245222628117, -0.06699173897504807, -0.023403430357575417, 0.030446244403719902, 0.033751267939805984, 0.025936968624591827, 0.0048151020891964436, 0.030390074476599693, 0.059235040098428726, 0.03131381794810295, 0.07429178059101105, 0.02235870435833931, 0.04121994227170944, -0.024492597207427025, 0.020145520567893982, -0.012089823372662067, 0.02394331619143486, 0.044544417411088943, -0.039181437343358994, -0.030271217226982117, 0.06099987402558327, 0.044667016714811325, 0.0010859825415536761, -0.0874762162566185, -0.00027018104447051883, 0.030203038826584816, 0.0366969108581543, 0.019554225727915764, -0.04486359283328056, -0.01132595632225275, 0.0018035718239843845, 0.02146141603589058, 0.019608890637755394, -0.01849687285721302, 0.00533168064430356, 0.050128377974033356, 0.05567840114235878, 0.03992302343249321, 0.027217000722885132, 0.07618491351604462, -0.03682293742895126, 0.0389796681702137, 0.025319136679172516, 0.029703866690397263, 0.02214938774704933, 0.0033286926336586475, 0.05474485456943512, -0.048221975564956665, 0.012276831082999706, -0.02191956341266632, 0.03934331238269806, 0.007394809275865555, -0.03971552103757858, -0.03457963839173317, -0.0881347507238388, 0.020802423357963562, -0.000370976107660681, -0.07713818550109863, -0.009823251515626907, -0.017334790900349617, 0.03137148544192314, -0.040647659450769424, -0.018692074343562126, 0.01604549027979374, 0.06700608879327774, 0.04228658974170685, -0.05488921329379082, 0.014798514544963837, 0.007231465540826321, 0.04266461730003357, 0.06369751691818237, 0.025478705763816833, -0.02418007329106331, -0.012610330246388912, -0.09858126938343048, 0.04317003861069679, -0.036071524024009705, 0.03562822937965393, 0.06599289178848267, 0.007999151013791561, -0.03713038191199303, 0.0005501515697687864, -0.0550566166639328, -0.04347584396600723, -0.0334017239511013, -0.016279466450214386, -0.0729365199804306, 0.046250808984041214, -0.03969081863760948, 0.05723710358142853, 0.0020625994075089693, 0.023462768644094467, -0.0842864140868187, -0.015205157920718193, -0.0037327753379940987, -0.0058666495606303215, 0.04982896149158478, 0.006180781405419111, 0.09524282068014145, -0.027121348306536674, -0.0012553613632917404, -0.05368805304169655, 0.0026788306422531605, -0.06742798537015915, -0.050753191113471985, 0.012069416232407093, 0.01085484679788351, 0.03133770078420639, -0.025629181414842606, -0.03474469110369682, -0.02878156118094921, 0.045813366770744324, 0.018468806520104408, 0.02166677825152874, 0.009403078816831112, 0.034846171736717224, 0.014145511202514172, 0.011578557081520557, 0.005120806861668825, -0.003143514273688197, 0.02004762925207615, -0.019189946353435516, 0.020436787977814674, 0.030701788142323494, 0.013568426482379436, -0.03071710839867592, 0.0034170132130384445, -0.04331836476922035, 0.0890297219157219, 0.015332275070250034, 0.00397013733163476, -0.05463898926973343, -0.0635661631822586, -0.06308625638484955, 0.03329229727387428, 0.03421252965927124, 0.07056915760040283, 0.05650024861097336, 0.03231970965862274, -0.021685272455215454, -0.0023528509773314, 0.044519826769828796, 0.0031776181422173977, -0.010850033722817898, 0.028008557856082916, 0.05157960206270218, 0.04448700696229935, -0.035489220172166824, 0.03338169679045677, 0.040598683059215546, 0.009639449417591095, 0.0022520346101373434, -0.0578654520213604, 0.0047445534728467464, 0.0027763615362346172, -0.003160410560667515, -0.02041797712445259, 0.01793169602751732, -0.010631684213876724, -0.0022643005941063166, -0.02014422044157982, -0.007811061572283506, 0.05144522339105606, 0.07602710276842117, -0.029903003945946693, 0.0032353894785046577, -0.010254709981381893, 0.03453512862324715, -0.007325729355216026, -0.0034598475322127342, -0.07799772918224335, -0.01462493371218443, 0.026760147884488106, -0.07000172138214111, -0.012788183987140656, 0.0323520228266716, -0.014952092431485653, 0.010419858619570732, -0.012293324805796146, -0.010554969310760498, 0.005652120802551508, 0.006815874949097633, -0.009482725523412228, -0.027691397815942764, -0.004335625097155571, -0.0008046304574236274, -0.04920279607176781, -0.00790348555892706, -0.03067079186439514, -0.04810335859656334, 0.031651079654693604, 0.04389219358563423, -0.06137704476714134, 0.0060843201354146, -0.03297660872340202, -0.019315946847200394, 0.021055178716778755, 0.0014215351548045874, 0.01745116338133812, -0.03771631792187691, -0.022445611655712128, -0.04499514773488045, 0.019207993522286415, -0.026872863993048668, -0.005120786838233471, -0.0016371906967833638, 0.024340834468603134, 0.023257877677679062, 0.058172497898340225, 0.05136781185865402, 0.09388133138418198, 0.029095392674207687, -0.026133447885513306, -0.009660462848842144, 0.03854537382721901, -0.02475583925843239, 0.005186362657696009, -0.027578279376029968, -0.033263612538576126, 0.024271458387374878, -0.024133583530783653, -0.020657582208514214, 0.011220565065741539, -0.04676951840519905, -0.021882137283682823, -0.03785420209169388, 0.016674958169460297, 0.0037594125606119633, 0.015903854742646217, -0.02248237282037735, -0.018127676099538803, 0.011599529534578323, 0.007853301241993904, 0.07247761636972427, 0.043852806091308594, 0.025299204513430595, 0.005094671156257391, -0.0289632435888052, 0.06496164202690125, 0.04449969902634621, 0.0385625883936882, 0.040289003401994705, -0.019197016954421997, 0.022365834563970566, 0.01046189945191145, 0.031276993453502655, -0.013896407559514046, -0.03069847822189331, 0.01863746903836727, 0.0252385251224041, 0.014516078867018223, -0.010965674184262753, 0.04274163395166397, 0.0031927404925227165, -0.02218426764011383, 0.03613955155014992, -0.001360241207294166, 0.013658116571605206, -0.05126868933439255, 0.04724491760134697, -0.10019880533218384, -0.0211072638630867, -0.06126060709357262, 0.03662138804793358, -0.006514411885291338, -0.053647417575120926, 0.024838918820023537, 0.06893904507160187, -0.028194831684231758, -0.04438842087984085, 0.06227228417992592, -0.0060902927070856094, -0.02056116610765457, -0.06527621299028397, -0.06394531577825546, -0.032501183450222015, 0.003751616459339857, -0.02021906152367592, -0.04467572271823883, -0.0017537969397380948, -0.02087981626391411, -0.01661829650402069, -0.04408973082900047, -0.03197803720831871, -0.04627213999629021, 0.03370927274227142, -0.00964133720844984, 0.04985787346959114, -0.004412966314703226, -0.055922288447618484, -0.016138887032866478, 0.029749641194939613, 0.012846501544117928, -0.0019820313900709152, -0.005642256233841181, -0.030721763148903847, -0.04889757186174393, -0.10390568524599075, 0.004252824932336807, 0.04171307384967804, -0.02946854755282402, 0.06613905727863312, -0.051763102412223816, 0.01438629999756813, 0.04451706260442734, -0.04548449069261551, 0.020068921148777008, -0.022415272891521454, -0.013793151825666428, -0.003442770102992654, 0.03898172080516815, -0.001419226173311472, 0.026495471596717834, 0.0040663545951247215, -0.01893620565533638, -0.02925734780728817, -0.002590056275948882, 0.0005592384841293097, -0.042301129549741745, 0.022133715450763702, 0.021326864138245583, 0.04764651507139206, -0.03794320672750473, 0.0033793949987739325, -0.0013388680526986718, -0.026199202984571457, 0.031054025515913963, 0.009543893858790398, -0.026809006929397583, -0.08607123792171478, -0.06551007926464081, 0.03556567803025246, -0.003616624977439642, -0.025535842403769493, -0.06438124924898148, 0.006212467327713966, 0.011063426733016968, -0.054897379130125046, -0.015764566138386726, 0.004152046982198954, -0.0030769321601837873, 0.037507735192775726, -0.05197105184197426, -0.04123784601688385, -0.00943782925605774, 0.0029531812760978937, 0.004392561502754688, -0.009973331354558468, 0.04051724448800087, 0.006759337615221739, -0.024912944063544273, -0.09682191908359528, -0.06295278668403625, 0.02475404180586338, 0.06563054770231247, -0.06056715548038483, -0.0007299010176211596, 0.0026287504006177187, 0.0019511354621499777, 0.08997244387865067, 0.06990817189216614, -0.041304249316453934, 0.019764332100749016, 0.006368952803313732, -0.020004037767648697, 0.019983511418104172, 0.020638270303606987, 0.025505416095256805, -0.016970328986644745, 0.012244144454598427, 0.040926892310380936, -0.02411377616226673, 0.02255924604833126, 0.030258113518357277 ]
<p>Inspired by <a href="http://what-if.xkcd.com/7/" rel="nofollow">this xkcd</a>, which calculated the energy requirements for accelerating individual humans to escape velocity (regardless of consideration for what that would do to your organs), I am interested to know if a trebuchet (or catapult) could be built that could launch things out off the Earth. Escape velocity isn't necessary, as I'd consider a stable orbit 'off earth'.</p> <ol> <li><p>What would be some design considerations / challenges? Do we have materials that could withstand this type of force?</p></li> <li><p>What would be maximum weight limits, ignoring air resistance (a tennis ball? a human? a satellite? a human in a metal survival pod?)</p></li> <li><p>What would be the speed at which these objects would need to reach at the earth's surface to be into a stable orbital velocity by the time they exit the atmosphere? (factoring gravitational slowdown and air resistance)</p></li> <li><p>Is it ever conceivable that we could 'launch' supplies to the ISS or orbit this way? What about launching satellites like this?</p></li> </ol> <h1>Edit</h1> <p>I misspoke when I said catapult, a string tension driven device. I meant a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trebuchet" rel="nofollow">trebuchet</a>, a gravity-powered heavy-object thrower. <a href="http://quicklaunchinc.com/media/cannons-to-the-planets/" rel="nofollow">QuickLaunch, Inc.</a> has plans to do just this launching a SSTO rocket at 6 km/s, which then fires after launch and provides the necessary correction for orbital insertion. Basically, I just need a trebuchet that will accelerate a mass (they're trying 1kg, 10kg, 50kg and 500kg masses) to 6 km/s at launch.</p> <p><img src="http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b2/Trebuchet_Castelnaud.jpg/762px-Trebuchet_Castelnaud.jpg" alt="Trebuchet"></p>
g5856
[ -0.00010333728278055787, 0.08946356177330017, 0.01592663675546646, 0.018866926431655884, -0.017100034281611443, 0.021093273535370827, -0.031079869717359543, -0.0057953763753175735, -0.058519039303064346, -0.02213330939412117, -0.026738237589597702, 0.030347714200615883, 0.02257751114666462, -0.05273008719086647, 0.029987512156367302, 0.014551552012562752, 0.07381755858659744, -0.07932458072900772, 0.03685968741774559, 0.052471183240413666, 0.052426960319280624, -0.025188816711306572, -0.008480199612677097, -0.009642299264669418, -0.029701363295316696, 0.027960697188973427, -0.012877254746854305, -0.034403156489133835, -0.06407523900270462, 0.01767812855541706, -0.0052151158452034, -0.09387999773025513, -0.0021385180298238993, -0.0464940220117569, -0.03855816274881363, 0.01678995043039322, -0.014337924309074879, -0.02812906913459301, -0.035276398062705994, 0.009978799149394035, -0.06205041706562042, -0.048157624900341034, -0.03797445073723793, -0.0474100224673748, 0.036332763731479645, 0.06738685071468353, 0.024279098957777023, -0.001160454354248941, 0.04598512500524521, -0.03287697210907936, -0.02759816125035286, 0.003962348215281963, -0.018398070707917213, -0.04047709330916405, -0.04233931005001068, 0.013570860028266907, -0.016392534598708153, -0.022133005782961845, 0.020737918093800545, -0.07790712267160416, -0.06674754619598389, -0.0008424783009104431, -0.03041909821331501, -0.024956535547971725, 0.0581604428589344, -0.028951680287718773, -0.01741267926990986, 0.03576004132628441, 0.05506322532892227, 0.04229431971907616, 0.08244634419679642, -0.016064846888184547, -0.06347839534282684, -0.029292616993188858, -0.016797155141830444, 0.016191300004720688, -0.009532497264444828, 0.0016087060794234276, -0.011166626587510109, 0.027927568182349205, 0.04120803624391556, 0.02364448271691799, -0.008569196797907352, -0.035757143050432205, -0.00005340287316357717, -0.006361696869134903, -0.029194636270403862, 0.01602945476770401, 0.014858431182801723, 0.030595960095524788, 0.01305321417748928, 0.03174879401922226, 0.007107897661626339, 0.01799628511071205, -0.026659924536943436, 0.010902107693254948, 0.0017391726141795516, 0.01637188345193863, -0.018205108121037483, -0.04620307311415672, 0.03519613668322563, -0.013629985973238945, -0.005878917407244444, -0.01646490953862667, 0.0031048443634063005, -0.06302357465028763, 0.042876068502664566, -0.024964824318885803, 0.023576388135552406, -0.015705714002251625, 0.040766824036836624, 0.004791944287717342, -0.05658562481403351, 0.02386864274740219, 0.0004164138517808169, -0.0337560698390007, 0.028091758489608765, -0.032657038420438766, -0.022968871518969536, 0.05293342098593712, 0.02592306211590767, -0.028604811057448387, 0.02250467799603939, 0.013092289678752422, -0.04133227467536926, -0.03767731040716171, -0.0028906408697366714, -0.01730191335082054, -0.026025380939245224, -0.04723344370722771, -0.03275254741311073, 0.0027169727254658937, 0.014610563404858112, -0.016423413529992104, 0.00023415269970428199, 0.0069276089780032635, -0.04241647198796272, -0.023041194304823875, -0.024762341752648354, -0.023559104651212692, 0.058242104947566986, -0.0012615860905498266, -0.01254101563245058, 0.06075120344758034, -0.04666117578744888, 0.04627346247434616, -0.023129446431994438, 0.05668068677186966, 0.012120909988880157, 0.07052066922187805, 0.023524140939116478, 0.0630415752530098, -0.0006200025673024356, 0.03129617124795914, 0.00573609909042716, 0.0219776201993227, 0.07133183628320694, 0.018080921843647957, -0.006072294898331165, -0.054397862404584885, 0.04494354873895645, 0.031461168080568314, -0.046328190714120865, 0.008901556953787804, -0.06094323471188545, -0.004394834395498037, 0.00839401688426733, 0.017288919538259506, 0.04893731698393822, 0.0030812076292932034, -0.0385371595621109, -0.0524720773100853, -0.014334865845739841, 0.09221848100423813, -0.03450224921107292, -0.03328712657094002, 0.029327357187867165, 0.0027961963787674904, -0.06087172031402588, -0.041441068053245544, 0.01449638046324253, -0.08709781616926193, 0.028318457305431366, -0.0459788553416729, -0.05152364447712898, -0.0304646547883749, 0.009158499538898468, 0.015806835144758224, 0.020824505016207695, 0.04858408123254776, -0.012318718247115612, 0.003580974880605936, 0.0027580976020544767, -0.00841284729540348, -0.009043034166097641, -0.0402153804898262, 0.05607697367668152, -0.04266707971692085, 0.05108492076396942, 0.030032560229301453, 0.087242491543293, 0.04505632445216179, -0.012767440639436245, -0.03492135554552078, 0.031005997210741043, -0.06964543461799622, 0.012937069870531559, 0.009808487258851528, 0.030963296070694923, -0.06611654162406921, 0.08986324071884155, 0.006060814950615168, 0.02272218093276024, 0.025489285588264465, 0.03981269896030426, -0.020896535366773605, 0.000986620201729238, 0.048477403819561005, 0.040511131286621094, -0.030501825734972954, 0.028325924649834633, -0.007189660798758268, -0.010988617315888405, -0.010668423026800156, 0.002676238538697362, -0.011320888996124268, -0.029911749064922333, -0.017993828281760216, 0.011857563629746437, -0.021887129172682762, -0.011511249467730522, 0.021330012008547783, 0.037309009581804276, -0.08642532676458359, 0.07804328203201294, 0.0342269167304039, 0.04865746200084686, -0.0384429469704628, 0.0001307947823079303, 0.01985590159893036, 0.0676557868719101, -0.06012246385216713, -0.028513813391327858, -0.05715661495923996, 0.0327780619263649, -0.10453375428915024, 0.027284134179353714, 0.026211481541395187, 0.011976439505815506, -0.020608238875865936, 0.019970832392573357, -0.06887273490428925, -0.0711883082985878, 0.021204156801104546, -0.0359795019030571, -0.025860609486699104, -0.04948730021715164, 0.07845007628202438, -0.07588916271924973, 0.014883941039443016, -0.018989987671375275, 0.010730373673141003, 0.017023025080561638, 0.04221171513199806, -0.0744515061378479, 0.018069593235850334, -0.013002549298107624, -0.03493337333202362, -0.0036179814487695694, 0.008136056363582611, -0.04037231579422951, -0.03339734300971031, -0.009218862280249596, 0.04049144312739372, -0.006309705786406994, -0.03634314984083176, 0.0007684107404202223, -0.021194422617554665, 0.011694296263158321, 0.04411487281322479, 0.00925213098526001, 0.00803195871412754, -0.011628266423940659, 0.0731404572725296, 0.010267364792525768, -0.03241359069943428, 0.03786364942789078, 0.04516641050577164, 0.01187555119395256, -0.018057726323604584, 0.016041850671172142, 0.03281354904174805, 0.04322894290089607, -0.03230440616607666, 0.029456593096256256, 0.040573447942733765, -0.02021089754998684, -0.01579703576862812, -0.011477387510240078, -0.021180083975195885, 0.0019433146808296442, -0.055918559432029724, -0.0045384750701487064, 0.03615456819534302, -0.06982364505529404, 0.011616354808211327, -0.04757887125015259, -0.06448546051979065, 0.008135849609971046, -0.018768388777971268, 0.010791764594614506, 0.08711161464452744, 0.0008506205049343407, 0.050646256655454636, -0.02852657251060009, -0.003950085490942001, 0.04011126607656479, 0.030402427539229393, -0.005326372571289539, -0.07804901897907257, -0.01116777304559946, -0.06411924958229065, 0.018246952444314957, -0.009386975318193436, -0.033128924667835236, 0.028751598671078682, -0.04701317846775055, 0.004425276070833206, -0.050744641572237015, -0.04457249119877815, 0.04048117995262146, 0.06935726851224899, 0.034926820546388626, 0.003937602508813143, -0.03794623911380768, -0.007900012657046318, 0.059961698949337006, 0.005906699690967798, 0.04925038665533066, 0.03372204676270485, 0.012613975442945957, 0.0008185980259440839, 0.04000687971711159, 0.026048585772514343, -0.008920970372855663, 0.026403965428471565, 0.030821146443486214, 0.022405944764614105, -0.019120866432785988, -0.06177935376763344, 0.06416013836860657, -0.04536464810371399, 0.0021739574149250984, 0.028566930443048477, -0.0179015900939703, 0.004879455082118511, 0.030429918318986893, 0.032086651772260666, 0.02134869433939457, -0.0653427466750145, -0.026521997526288033, 0.049669671803712845, 0.044834185391664505, 0.016304200515151024, 0.013039776124060154, -0.00032914389157667756, -0.023738425225019455, 0.07596895843744278, -0.00023538339883089066, -0.010519436560571194, 0.038204777985811234, -0.047158293426036835, -0.03335510566830635, -0.06391877681016922, 0.025881396606564522, 0.012279286049306393, 0.07187487185001373, -0.00895758531987667, -0.03614281117916107, 0.032959237694740295, 0.019598213955760002, -0.005292451474815607, -0.0014952173223719, 0.028150243684649467, 0.002279006177559495, 0.011680345050990582, -0.01931658945977688, -0.014798996038734913, -0.029236020520329475, 0.004655224736779928, -0.01962251588702202, -0.08427277207374573, -0.04719739407300949, -0.010519414208829403, -0.007266821805387735, 0.021013790741562843, -0.04387713223695755, -0.04795221611857414, -0.051800381392240524, 0.022512521594762802, 0.06370808184146881, 0.0037114268634468317, -0.034603238105773926, 0.01655546762049198, -0.0005441413959488273, -0.013699744828045368, -0.006562423426657915, 0.01552243996411562, -0.03867880254983902, -0.03289501368999481, 0.030640672892332077, -0.0073242890648543835, -0.018666816875338554, -0.03974766656756401, -0.04113168641924858, -0.013462215662002563, -0.021618930622935295, -0.005689247511327267, 0.028776271268725395, 0.013758840039372444, -0.008145289495587349, 0.02085879258811474, 0.013406463898718357, -0.01635890081524849, -0.023386336863040924, 0.05448123812675476, 0.042901765555143356, -0.0227559432387352, 0.04355610907077789, 0.006123272702097893, 0.030244002118706703, 0.04894426837563515, -0.037619952112436295, 0.026456790044903755, 0.026450010016560555, 0.04669792950153351, 0.02891017310321331, 0.023740846663713455, 0.05866897851228714, 0.007909429259598255, 0.018589116632938385, 0.04764094948768616, 0.01489989273250103, 0.040564246475696564, 0.004466219339519739, 0.08940853178501129, -0.007393455132842064, 0.026013124734163284, -0.014727155677974224, 0.022445693612098694, 0.0070619164034724236, -0.017047390341758728, 0.017398642376065254, 0.011793493293225765, -0.02203240618109703, -0.0021507807541638613, -0.03639812394976616, -0.0021464908495545387, 0.0364045687019825, -0.014008508995175362, -0.04945223778486252, -0.07739192247390747, 0.05289432033896446, 0.009930535219609737, 0.01071777381002903, -0.019341494888067245, 0.007406960241496563, -0.020148973912000656, -0.006538833025842905, -0.024472899734973907, -0.03161570429801941, 0.0046712723560631275, 0.03175167739391327, 0.04248639941215515, -0.07678138464689255, -0.013777568005025387, -0.0027305991388857365, -0.035213544964790344, 0.04984288662672043, -0.0035762053448706865, 0.008047315292060375, 0.042225126177072525, -0.07666999101638794, 0.004625833127647638, 0.01825810968875885, -0.040534086525440216, -0.05508394539356232, -0.02752644382417202, 0.009825393557548523, 0.03693515062332153, -0.07735690474510193, 0.0083187036216259, -0.020553551614284515, -0.01983056217432022, 0.016032183542847633, -0.015477324835956097, 0.04778731241822243, -0.03599895164370537, -0.010715692304074764, -0.024656139314174652, -0.04467543214559555, 0.00832050945609808, -0.004463845398277044, 0.024440724402666092, -0.02413238026201725, -0.007151537574827671, 0.028354575857520103, 0.012077881954610348, -0.004695887211710215, 0.055585868656635284, -0.031997498124837875, 0.0729522630572319, -0.06345092505216599, -0.032454945147037506, 0.013375361450016499, -0.050941351801157, -0.009311490692198277, 0.015265065245330334, 0.03207120671868324, -0.06725313514471054, 0.053823672235012054, -0.0244998037815094, 0.032607048749923706, 0.04380001127719879, 0.007951775565743446, 0.03400180861353874, -0.03211033344268799, -0.010572933591902256, -0.04906858876347542, 0.060832202434539795, 0.04043726995587349, -0.03231523185968399, -0.013803349807858467, -0.03566218912601471, -0.034528955817222595, 0.0066499775275588036, 0.008696776814758778, 0.049704596400260925, 0.003352634608745575, -0.04346609488129616, -0.057944633066654205, -0.021460313349962234, 0.03365721553564072, 0.07681947946548462, 0.04301745817065239, -0.011939593590795994, -0.0030446273740381002, 0.04914892092347145, 0.0028322082944214344, -0.03446647897362709, -0.0497204028069973, 0.029338892549276352, -0.015929194167256355, 0.026859581470489502, -0.05544515699148178, 0.05557449162006378, -0.03198743239045143, 0.037111688405275345, -0.0025910462718456984, -0.03357251361012459, 0.05887692794203758, 0.03596651554107666, 0.048396121710538864, 0.039263252168893814, 0.04051700606942177, -0.0010670138290151954, -0.00012818898539990187, -0.03580145537853241, 0.029083337634801865, 0.023660877719521523, 0.0735979974269867, 0.0026648156344890594, -0.034475620836019516, 0.007270819041877985, 0.020280273631215096, -0.039643656462430954, -0.023336786776781082, -0.0376075841486454, -0.012599306181073189, -0.007191209588199854, -0.025156285613775253, -0.00709997583180666, 0.04303942620754242, -0.03922438248991966, -0.051161814481019974, 0.01757512055337429, -0.017162172123789787, -0.01545417495071888, 0.0054642814211547375, -0.07553756237030029, 0.013863199390470982, 0.02104760892689228, -0.01752670295536518, -0.015957269817590714, -0.0372261144220829, -0.009423385374248028, -0.0024281537625938654, 0.0331808403134346, -0.017240090295672417, 0.06114405393600464, 0.015769317746162415, 0.0024793443735688925, 0.04639138653874397, -0.03762216866016388, 0.022495243698358536, 0.04927537590265274, 0.06951822340488434, 0.037716131657361984, 0.07133778929710388, -0.05376329645514488, -0.00921090878546238, 0.01492000836879015, 0.040252067148685455, -0.02901449054479599, -0.0017143230652436614, 0.03776908665895462, -0.019871728494763374, -0.0254848413169384, -0.02332300692796707, 0.07110626250505447, 0.050823651254177094, -0.0013824852649122477, 0.014220381155610085, 0.00045405005221255124, -0.046303264796733856, -0.03367607668042183, 0.021412318572402, 0.06679937988519669, 0.022118566557765007, -0.012694517150521278, -0.0011831015581265092, 0.024627290666103363, 0.021682919934391975, -0.004010635428130627, -0.014855047687888145, 0.0687304213643074, -0.02345556579530239, 0.041600555181503296, 0.0031221285462379456, -0.059401217848062515, 0.03259536623954773, -0.023573383688926697, -0.020001037046313286, 0.008137589320540428, -0.04868035763502121, 0.03746957331895828, 0.028941083699464798, -0.01640833169221878, 0.03126705810427666, -0.0381799042224884, -0.022748202085494995, -0.08337559551000595, -0.11119824647903442, -0.04886690899729729, -0.0007333268295042217, 0.004159300122410059, -0.014807000756263733, 0.005506083834916353, -0.012182140722870827, -0.0321512445807457, 0.04620532691478729, 0.07007534801959991, 0.05262678861618042, -0.04944569617509842, 0.012028816156089306, 0.017711397260427475, -0.01897483691573143, 0.022120054811239243, -0.027882901951670647, 0.04046536982059479, 0.022171128541231155, 0.024563465267419815, -0.04871013015508652, -0.0027539061848074198, -0.015035082586109638, 0.03158385306596756, -0.03169559687376022, -0.004827217198908329, 0.0057302312925457954, -0.01798631250858307, -0.03278212994337082, -0.027690811082720757, 0.0032589228358119726, 0.048161581158638, 0.022557739168405533, 0.002493120962753892, 0.012933563441038132, 0.05581538379192352, -0.005090582650154829, -0.038261860609054565, 0.03505508974194527, 0.09663990885019302, 0.02024957723915577, -0.0029324849601835012, 0.02744237333536148, -0.021990785375237465, 0.0023945332504808903, -0.006120711099356413, 0.06043871119618416, 0.01191681157797575, -0.040964823216199875, 0.07795567810535431, 0.04961162433028221, -0.007568463683128357, 0.008207408711314201, 0.026440540328621864, -0.021705584600567818, 0.017841098830103874, -0.07869887351989746, -0.005801294930279255, -0.01055908203125, 0.016282854601740837, -0.03407219052314758, -0.022207461297512054, 0.030038485303521156, -0.018000278621912003, -0.009764675982296467, 0.054051391780376434, -0.011737543158233166, 0.010734105482697487, -0.0012728619622066617, 0.04172072932124138, 0.015266718342900276, -0.03020595945417881, -0.014302084222435951, -0.003706196090206504, 0.0268303994089365, -0.009344634599983692, -0.011115450412034988, -0.02545604109764099, 0.01617681048810482, -0.028375523164868355, -0.016804883256554604, -0.0035061410162597895, -0.008150070905685425, 0.021613508462905884, -0.010605938732624054, -0.005177157931029797, -0.0683203935623169, 0.011298230849206448, 0.01102688629180193, 0.020118700340390205, -0.046306923031806946, -0.018325377255678177, 0.047704704105854034, -0.03388739749789238, -0.011914189904928207, 0.04885973036289215, -0.003451169468462467, 0.0072148023173213005, 0.06779687106609344, 0.007385951466858387, -0.017978662624955177, -0.02380964159965515, -0.05136384442448616, -0.056218329817056656, -0.023016158491373062, -0.0013233927311375737, -0.042040374130010605, -0.04266846925020218, -0.0071913753636181355, 0.024507155641913414, 0.010759891010820866, -0.05044497549533844, -0.04137304052710533, -0.06690234690904617, -0.004646826535463333, 0.033812493085861206 ]
<p>The experiment goes like this: </p> <p><img src="http://i.imgur.com/p4EtV.png" alt=""></p> <p>Allow a moving cart to move from the top of an incline plane ($x_0$) downwards. The time taken will be recorded by the picket fence (those things you see wired up). Distance ($D$) is reduced by 10cm each time. And a set of recordings are recored as follows: </p> <p><img src="http://i.imgur.com/35Sai.png" alt=""></p> <p>Does the recording seem logical? </p> <ul> <li>As $D$ decreases, $v$ increases? Why, I thought $v$ should reduce as there will be less effect from gravity? </li> <li>As $D$ decreases the standard error decreases. It kind of makes sense as the time interval will be smaller and thus less chance of error. However, I would think if the $D$ is too small, the cart may not have stabalized or something? But that doesn't sound scientific. </li> <li>Is my calculation of standard error right? Or should it be standard deviation here? When do I use which? </li> </ul>
g5857
[ 0.04420184716582298, 0.025353476405143738, -0.018800677731633186, -0.011929329484701157, 0.04465663060545921, 0.047764040529727936, 0.07475138455629349, 0.0018194647273048759, -0.12690280377864838, -0.023323053494095802, -0.014652031473815441, -0.005164439789950848, 0.03129139542579651, 0.022766221314668655, 0.0002807636046782136, 0.017532892525196075, 0.08333874493837357, -0.07427381724119186, 0.044206809252500534, -0.025606879964470863, 0.006157904397696257, 0.03853359445929527, -0.03604496270418167, -0.06358841061592102, 0.014916625805199146, -0.008535890839993954, 0.012618839740753174, 0.0443718247115612, -0.08249492198228836, 0.0742046982049942, -0.011297770775854588, -0.03005862422287464, 0.020807528868317604, -0.021026557311415672, -0.07161654531955719, -0.055892959237098694, 0.06653895229101181, 0.02478468418121338, 0.01517932303249836, -0.0232279971241951, 0.016187354922294617, -0.06322002410888672, 0.030936608090996742, -0.003723950358107686, 0.03105905093252659, -0.024925217032432556, -0.004502567462623119, -0.0005707458476535976, 0.05953999608755112, 0.01737886480987072, -0.026415059342980385, 0.003500869730487466, -0.016552869230508804, 0.029210474342107773, 0.031997837126255035, 0.006442922633141279, -0.028990374878048897, -0.02376430295407772, -0.04616621881723404, 0.015292294323444366, -0.0008289192919619381, -0.059908732771873474, 0.00947799813002348, -0.02587011270225048, 0.06878486275672913, 0.02731376141309738, -0.05167248472571373, -0.05288581922650337, 0.024026991799473763, 0.002031114883720875, 0.008136316202580929, -0.01681528240442276, -0.009628171101212502, -0.018452877178788185, -0.049039289355278015, 0.033319197595119476, 0.026359781622886658, -0.00978572852909565, 0.01944676600396633, 0.025719936937093735, -0.09658510982990265, 0.005865249317139387, -0.02947225049138069, 0.01426914893090725, 0.05832194909453392, 0.02680056355893612, 0.024655241519212723, 0.009166959673166275, -0.021027104929089546, 0.05078791826963425, 0.019593870267271996, -0.07328003644943237, 0.12199971079826355, 0.04574687033891678, -0.047341637313365936, -0.019558757543563843, -0.06013444811105728, 0.11438266932964325, 0.03095216304063797, 0.0688963234424591, -0.02582649327814579, -0.01541106402873993, -0.02372489683330059, -0.0279843807220459, -0.031670086085796356, 0.03839389234781265, 0.02475256472826004, 0.017523447051644325, -0.022193506360054016, -0.08914706856012344, 0.008349561132490635, -0.003183935070410371, -0.04556760564446449, -0.08442728221416473, 0.0195310078561306, -0.019750535488128662, 0.05081414803862572, -0.012244022451341152, 0.04891304671764374, -0.03371435031294823, 0.03324894979596138, 0.008885789662599564, -0.006649762857705355, 0.07641644030809402, -0.008982162922620773, -0.029213080182671547, -0.02043762244284153, 0.036427248269319534, 0.04373728856444359, 0.01046961173415184, -0.043189637362957, 0.025244174525141716, -0.04446669667959213, 0.016035690903663635, 0.0035242759622633457, 0.022626809775829315, 0.03577084466814995, 0.016676025465130806, -0.013155251741409302, 0.012771379202604294, -0.03596487641334534, 0.008257911540567875, -0.013952418230473995, -0.08426807820796967, -0.03367030248045921, 0.015087208710610867, 0.010175488889217377, 0.021921174600720406, 0.024770062416791916, -0.019253961741924286, 0.00127508956938982, 0.06747704744338989, 0.009235672652721405, 0.04103429615497589, -0.037854406982660294, 0.02202278934419155, 0.04184011369943619, 0.005163397639989853, 0.03648384287953377, -0.009031726978719234, 0.033832669258117676, -0.03729378059506416, -0.014266745187342167, 0.01211224589496851, -0.05272841826081276, 0.06414472311735153, 0.0626867413520813, -0.020478447899222374, 0.037259478121995926, -0.07191343605518341, -0.00627233786508441, -0.029453452676534653, 0.03156478703022003, 0.015434667468070984, -0.023446260020136833, 0.050631649792194366, 0.05861937627196312, -0.012949514202773571, -0.001419802545569837, -0.0019694222137331963, 0.03506581485271454, 0.02467844821512699, -0.0172889307141304, -0.074851393699646, -0.0022969439160078764, -0.034531112760305405, 0.06436411291360855, -0.06912826746702194, -0.12177950888872147, -0.04448354244232178, -0.016843238845467567, -0.013977034017443657, -0.06129426509141922, 0.0017954373033717275, -0.08706896007061005, -0.018982717767357826, 0.03612419217824936, -0.03580847382545471, -0.06647505611181259, 0.04202646017074585, -0.008713671937584877, -0.0013166690478101373, 0.06712907552719116, -0.016617797315120697, -0.03416655585169792, -0.05319001525640488, -0.008876653388142586, -0.01520657166838646, -0.01421551126986742, -0.020961914211511612, 0.02136620134115219, 0.0462825633585453, -0.010599944740533829, 0.0013414804125204682, 0.007422816939651966, -0.0257783941924572, 0.04650071635842323, 0.02800164557993412, 0.019569765776395798, 0.0010336774867027998, -0.02566634491086006, -0.015077468939125538, 0.06034720316529274, -0.0250229649245739, 0.00035595925874076784, -0.04242154210805893, -0.003221540478989482, -0.02819906920194626, 0.03435077145695686, -0.005723944865167141, -0.024733208119869232, 0.017323831096291542, -0.04651704430580139, -0.010167951695621014, 0.04171771556138992, 0.037319645285606384, -0.003480140585452318, -0.0035883921664208174, 0.04539716616272926, 0.01076080184429884, 0.014327800832688808, -0.006346992217004299, -0.027908828109502792, 0.001313215703703463, -0.014090125449001789, -0.0036576646380126476, 0.010106210596859455, 0.01761612296104431, -0.0015561837935820222, -0.01696845516562462, 0.03229657933115959, 0.043033357709646225, -0.02085672877728939, -0.0067260731011629105, 0.005800907500088215, -0.011843189597129822, -0.0474436990916729, 0.02295888029038906, -0.03833445906639099, 0.016854597255587578, -0.026458948850631714, -0.006139284465461969, 0.04740990698337555, 0.021632282063364983, -0.018589185550808907, -0.02996841073036194, -0.035999443382024765, 0.03033459559082985, 0.041511427611112595, -0.004715560004115105, 0.008311046287417412, -0.02235238440334797, 0.032477349042892456, 0.07755804806947708, 0.0272535253316164, 0.0019273357465863228, -0.0056726327165961266, 0.03986240550875664, 0.04054670408368111, -0.008812694810330868, 0.020208539441227913, -0.013083091005682945, -0.06343408674001694, 0.011469267308712006, 0.0377989336848259, -0.0012133159907534719, 0.035666365176439285, -0.01139786746352911, -0.06142828240990639, -0.0015505197225138545, -0.06660906970500946, 0.05372803658246994, 0.03314211219549179, 0.032671354711055756, 0.035072069615125656, 0.035675715655088425, 0.05159767344594002, 0.0025445285718888044, 0.012795407325029373, -0.010935095138847828, -0.020434370264410973, 0.0006211840081959963, -0.00963040255010128, -0.012094506993889809, -0.012348976917564869, 0.03708593547344208, 0.023633072152733803, 0.0032278401777148247, -0.012628449127078056, 0.001883892109617591, 0.0010318421991541982, 0.016376521438360214, 0.015735238790512085, -0.036286208778619766, -0.06588337570428848, -0.04893486574292183, 0.05716927349567413, 0.014552329666912556, -0.05080153048038483, 0.01727581024169922, 0.02663756161928177, -0.05329279974102974, -0.1119089424610138, 0.023561740294098854, 0.02436221018433571, 0.03084750659763813, -0.060341913253068924, 0.03049922175705433, -0.015541352331638336, 0.004914441145956516, 0.03172306343913078, 0.05110066384077072, 0.029707517474889755, -0.011353365145623684, -0.0010133808245882392, -0.05258304253220558, -0.015690458938479424, 0.009916242212057114, -0.02100064978003502, 0.0434306338429451, -0.06025915592908859, 0.010772835463285446, -0.0468108244240284, -0.03430190682411194, 0.010614678263664246, 0.03030639886856079, 0.010892783291637897, 0.03589418902993202, -0.024405911564826965, 0.005233845207840204, 0.04502370208501816, -0.03517938405275345, -0.0013884836807847023, -0.0260159894824028, 0.0030193852726370096, 0.022711388766765594, -0.022215690463781357, 0.029714161530137062, -0.05505218729376793, 0.005435197614133358, 0.023711824789643288, 0.005911989603191614, -0.02279648743569851, 0.035062436014413834, -0.002575869672000408, 0.001165043911896646, -0.030116841197013855, 0.09300604462623596, -0.012419424951076508, -0.03074072115123272, -0.018448064103722572, 0.039110369980335236, -0.025572367012500763, -0.04273412749171257, -0.001015141955576837, 0.0034583494998514652, 0.0474238395690918, 0.0009151248959824443, -0.017216967418789864, 0.043668411672115326, 0.024069206789135933, 0.014905239455401897, -0.050799183547496796, -0.04795197769999504, 0.02987854927778244, 0.0071846493519842625, -0.01957310177385807, -0.014731108210980892, -0.029326995834708214, 0.0033426221925765276, -0.02239225246012211, -0.023378407582640648, -0.01662893407046795, 0.003222439903765917, 0.015507688745856285, 0.021296976134181023, -0.002039720769971609, 0.04395505040884018, 0.0062669189646840096, -0.008686642162501812, 0.04140886291861534, 0.020321935415267944, 0.018387723714113235, 0.0298644807189703, 0.023838672786951065, -0.007745780982077122, 0.03703385218977928, 0.035549551248550415, 0.02045038901269436, 0.06413524597883224, -0.01729561761021614, -0.05463976040482521, -0.07344409823417664, -0.09364712238311768, 0.04404788091778755, -0.023143591359257698, 0.03885740041732788, 0.056449681520462036, -0.0008682518964633346, 0.007158024702221155, 0.05897677689790726, 0.08041339367628098, -0.008641642518341541, -0.037423137575387955, -0.0645308867096901, 0.023113731294870377, -0.015617533586919308, -0.014679796993732452, -0.024122029542922974, -0.03956267982721329, 0.022135136649012566, 0.04545573890209198, 0.010812082327902317, 0.019229883328080177, -0.049135614186525345, 0.061514582484960556, 0.06506437063217163, 0.03455580770969391, -0.018260382115840912, 0.03043425641953945, 0.01920182816684246, -0.033413514494895935, -0.020935053005814552, -0.05199369788169861, -0.021328290924429893, 0.07664559036493301, -0.03137205168604851, -0.06333804875612259, 0.0815989151597023, -0.00894832517951727, 0.00291838264092803, 0.060177914798259735, 0.029931565746665, 0.03549161180853844, 0.096213199198246, -0.026220982894301414, 0.03277117758989334, 0.04980845749378204, 0.026501799002289772, -0.011870043352246284, -0.02334623597562313, 0.02475731074810028, -0.07616166025400162, -0.038632746785879135, -0.045030105859041214, -0.02386414259672165, -0.03348769620060921, -0.09877254068851471, -0.011350160464644432, 0.01067978423088789, -0.02121254801750183, 0.0024013586807996035, 0.013986768200993538, 0.033501990139484406, -0.038326751440763474, 0.04198676720261574, -0.022569216787815094, 0.045077525079250336, 0.062437158077955246, -0.10626338422298431, -0.07018882781267166, -0.019663700833916664, -0.0064137643203139305, -0.03952958062291145, 0.012520454823970795, 0.018109092488884926, -0.04703516885638237, -0.058805204927921295, 0.0651250034570694, -0.010390288196504116, 0.060384150594472885, -0.03792592138051987, 0.02909976989030838, -0.02756788767874241, -0.041662294417619705, -0.008639761246740818, 0.0031135519966483116, -0.012873200699687004, -0.01848873682320118, -0.04194936528801918, -0.048599425703287125, 0.02006782405078411, 0.023264454677700996, -0.019872160628437996, -0.02488092891871929, 0.030003616586327553, 0.030937597155570984, 0.01675029844045639, -0.016098225489258766, 0.07771874964237213, 0.0022971027065068483, 0.019321752712130547, 0.07520312070846558, 0.011956346221268177, -0.024112815037369728, -0.0035770463291555643, 0.03533751145005226, 0.03995145857334137, -0.020992480218410492, -0.008969872258603573, 0.06360959261655807, -0.03493156656622887, 0.019895678386092186, -0.026449622586369514, -0.0022530003916472197, -0.04509657993912697, -0.05299500748515129, -0.007719830609858036, -0.009384598582983017, -0.024150090292096138, 0.02246048115193844, -0.011168306693434715, 0.013547379523515701, 0.01411077193915844, -0.03262130543589592, 0.020788589492440224, -0.0028431201353669167, -0.009670177474617958, 0.03563385829329491, -0.06543675065040588, -0.06536377966403961, 0.003159496933221817, -0.03224172443151474, 0.04875420778989792, 0.014935980550944805, -0.045010555535554886, -0.01706521585583687, -0.051138658076524734, 0.02608291059732437, -0.07504529505968094, -0.024143991991877556, 0.04164647310972214, 0.00942134764045477, 0.045588765293359756, -0.030882487073540688, 0.024780727922916412, -0.02579616941511631, 0.01556473970413208, 0.0029713159892708063, 0.006534632295370102, 0.01797323301434517, 0.007719766814261675, -0.03174765035510063, 0.034093666821718216, 0.02470521070063114, -0.03818685561418533, 0.032861679792404175, -0.0014917156659066677, -0.0003418004489503801, 0.04714028909802437, -0.026819510385394096, -0.005995241925120354, 0.023846011608839035, 0.046391118317842484, -0.038354068994522095, 0.019195755943655968, -0.007361054886132479, -0.04469802975654602, -0.03289993479847908, -0.059247564524412155, -0.02450244501233101, -0.06393569707870483, 0.0008296354790218174, -0.055402982980012894, -0.029032055288553238, 0.06139456480741501, -0.04923989251255989, -0.033220186829566956, 0.023365819826722145, -0.05076440051198006, -0.025422358885407448, 0.015454871580004692, 0.03327714279294014, -0.012022885493934155, -0.027518119663000107, -0.018949566408991814, -0.03639644756913185, -0.025067754089832306, 0.012186245061457157, 0.02136075310409069, 0.03562062233686447, 0.0361110158264637, 0.044015072286129, -0.033136919140815735, 0.011725271120667458, 0.04451534524559975, -0.023701205849647522, 0.04210049659013748, 0.06807263940572739, -0.05122635141015053, 0.05804670229554176, 0.04718337953090668, 0.051255494356155396, 0.04908983036875725, -0.012427831068634987, 0.026409203186631203, 0.048384081572294235, 0.00003967378142988309, 0.015994343906641006, -0.01161737460643053, 0.004853814374655485, -0.00016089646669570357, -0.03809327259659767, 0.02978476881980896, -0.04870368540287018, 0.0329965315759182, -0.030560987070202827, -0.04155609756708145, 0.04410769045352936, 0.019657960161566734, -0.03322731703519821, 0.016327673569321632, -0.02210293523967266, 0.044456906616687775, -0.059491440653800964, 0.044983357191085815, -0.026579009369015694, 0.04627732187509537, -0.018653756007552147, 0.04521946981549263, 0.00807968620210886, 0.0367087684571743, -0.00803320948034525, -0.0052423314191401005, -0.030381720513105392, -0.004149417858570814, 0.015789099037647247, 0.010899955406785011, -0.02370825782418251, -0.025474628433585167, -0.0027529578655958176, 0.017598871141672134, -0.017485899850726128, -0.008091463707387447, 0.02505992352962494, 0.03130485117435455, 0.015393209643661976, 0.01360519602894783, 0.07721512764692307, -0.027617089450359344, -0.04529291018843651, -0.08383552730083466, -0.05980546399950981, -0.02782517857849598, 0.026515904814004898, 0.011948887258768082, -0.08700266480445862, -0.02109578810632229, -0.03170498088002205, -0.015491674654185772, 0.024651629850268364, -0.005624720361083746, 0.016432149335741997, 0.011114673689007759, 0.05052907019853592, 0.006682910490781069, -0.0062609948217868805, -0.008502254262566566, -0.020715991035103798, -0.0033685427624732256, 0.02245979942381382, -0.022596199065446854, -0.012209860607981682, -0.050445932894945145, -0.026254650205373764, 0.0412721149623394, -0.03509553521871567, -0.03686165809631348, -0.00209430162794888, -0.011389585211873055, -0.02421017549932003, 0.024609824642539024, -0.013672338798642159, 0.020442629233002663, -0.03345697745680809, -0.011948157101869583, 0.023837674409151077, 0.017352135851979256, 0.03082403540611267, -0.00892835296690464, 0.02567858248949051, 0.03727075830101967, -0.0015335790812969208, 0.05286276713013649, -0.046512093394994736, 0.026680007576942444, 0.007082164287567139, -0.01935042254626751, -0.04372195899486542, -0.01157445553690195, 0.004553826525807381, 0.05403523147106171, 0.001325770397670567, 0.005016698502004147, 0.014119611121714115, 0.01368040032684803, -0.0011009342269971967, -0.04413377866148949, -0.03139825537800789, -0.010846661403775215, -0.020118139684200287, -0.0008414056501351297, 0.010349723510444164, -0.019687030464410782, 0.007033718749880791, -0.040679775178432465, -0.005691549275070429, -0.015841016545891762, 0.030149444937705994, -0.006387620698660612, 0.012741710059344769, -0.026791945099830627, -0.030356543138623238, -0.0047929780557751656, 0.016588520258665085, 0.010123123414814472, 0.03815622627735138, 0.03776449337601662, -0.009779155254364014, 0.052471041679382324, -0.04678869992494583, -0.018225692212581635, -0.00636765081435442, 0.015993723645806313, 0.020917406305670738, -0.010338540188968182, 0.03633423149585724, 0.00242483988404274, -0.00181399448774755, -0.0518331415951252, 0.02675008587539196, -0.010156181640923023, -0.03964070603251457, 0.02496323734521866, 0.024887440726161003, -0.011522453278303146, 0.024365290999412537, -0.041658516973257065, 0.03674328699707985, -0.0037510704714804888, 0.002243621274828911, -0.024673037230968475, 0.009954270906746387, -0.004257502034306526, -0.02241230383515358, -0.017505018040537834, 0.02250896580517292, 0.022930340841412544 ]
<p>For example: let's consider a static sphere on an horizontal rough surface. I apply an impulse $J$ parallel to the ground and in the middle of the sphere. If, like my book says, the friction is not an impulsive force, then I can use $J=\Delta p=mv_{CM}-0$, so $v_{cm}(0)=J/m$. But this is counterintuitive, because if I apply a small impulse ,for instance $J=1 Ns$, to a sphere of $m=10^{10} Kg$, the static friction force ($F=\mu_{s}mg$) is surely enough to keep the sphere static.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/iXkCV.png" alt="sphere"></p> <p>You can repeat the reasoning without a sphere: an impulse $J_{x}=1 Ns $ on a point mass of $m=10^{10} Kg$ on a rough surface. If friction is not impulsive, then you move the object (of course, only for a very short time, because you have a dynamic friction that slow the motion) no matter what the mass is.</p> <p>EDIT: The definition given in my book is: "very intense forces that act on a short time, compared to the observation time".</p>
g5858
[ 0.08323608338832855, 0.04735211655497551, -0.001659195520915091, -0.01903023198246956, 0.023161612451076508, -0.00577454874292016, 0.10011274367570877, -0.02256343699991703, -0.056071314960718155, -0.043876782059669495, -0.013808177784085274, -0.003338085487484932, -0.029016682878136635, -0.00170660181902349, -0.025400325655937195, 0.01056304108351469, 0.06399153918027878, -0.01980302669107914, 0.012644455768167973, 0.06468990445137024, -0.002104108454659581, -0.03779888525605202, -0.011919387616217136, -0.03284349665045738, -0.007217687088996172, 0.0013733929954469204, 0.028280451893806458, -0.04104246571660042, -0.011998840607702732, 0.03186606615781784, -0.01584739051759243, -0.04140263795852661, 0.02629130892455578, -0.025747589766979218, -0.040772851556539536, 0.01262113731354475, 0.03809424117207527, -0.0301490668207407, 0.04432616010308266, -0.041362594813108444, 0.029662439599633217, -0.048124007880687714, 0.06545320898294449, -0.017052019014954567, 0.013840284198522568, 0.01708177849650383, 0.0016676402883604169, 0.005892654415220022, -0.01928807981312275, -0.0463162325322628, -0.02240414172410965, 0.022762684151530266, 0.031511805951595306, 0.006583487614989281, -0.03760422021150589, 0.01281074807047844, 0.04502151906490326, -0.06056329980492592, 0.0033120373263955116, 0.03183256462216377, 0.014513133093714714, -0.05359122157096863, 0.022796789184212685, -0.05395721271634102, 0.05174781382083893, -0.012672082521021366, -0.08724616467952728, -0.002800028072670102, 0.0071446276269853115, 0.0021422766149044037, -0.03207219019532204, 0.032085269689559937, -0.00931540410965681, -0.017203200608491898, -0.07777776569128036, 0.02307879365980625, 0.012594233267009258, 0.010053797625005245, 0.017985664308071136, -0.008025623857975006, 0.011189430020749569, -0.006979459896683693, 0.004620418883860111, -0.016410619020462036, 0.08354130387306213, -0.02724425308406353, 0.024775898084044456, -0.011545117944478989, 0.007205871399492025, 0.0185378510504961, 0.05941502004861832, -0.024955151602625847, 0.04253567010164261, 0.058046188205480576, -0.027059955522418022, -0.0240479689091444, -0.007849404588341713, 0.08352169394493103, -0.004673298913985491, 0.02039112150669098, -0.07669657468795776, -0.043315909802913666, -0.003258796175941825, -0.012469232082366943, 0.02092548832297325, -0.05340662971138954, 0.03150002285838127, 0.04804296791553497, -0.003476816928014159, -0.04378608986735344, 0.02058851718902588, 0.016248278319835663, -0.017777353525161743, -0.03853243589401245, 0.011959549970924854, -0.032775238156318665, 0.014093459583818913, 0.016169942915439606, -0.014950733631849289, 0.051975175738334656, 0.026726849377155304, -0.01121535710990429, 0.025174090638756752, 0.053629517555236816, -0.018442610278725624, -0.031215153634548187, -0.003706513438373804, 0.02251022309064865, 0.03811978921294212, -0.03745509311556816, -0.014785157516598701, 0.06565018743276596, -0.008655230514705181, -0.025895439088344574, -0.042052894830703735, 0.024823389947414398, -0.009962925687432289, -0.03696228191256523, -0.005178476218134165, 0.04761969670653343, 0.009295867756009102, 0.024683132767677307, -0.03755006566643715, -0.021436965093016624, -0.039578877389431, 0.043542515486478806, -0.044847745448350906, 0.0164191797375679, 0.03876299411058426, 0.013932895846664906, 0.052082180976867676, 0.07700623571872711, 0.032082051038742065, -0.038666557520627975, 0.02580258809030056, 0.030772238969802856, 0.09744542837142944, 0.03273026645183563, -0.00604377081617713, -0.017131248489022255, 0.05330595746636391, 0.05496479198336601, 0.060205042362213135, -0.014573652297258377, -0.0503963977098465, 0.04206828027963638, -0.054059963673353195, -0.024347905069589615, -0.013898326084017754, -0.06136538088321686, -0.09898632764816284, 0.012734811753034592, 0.07632628083229065, 0.04363463446497917, -0.016768641769886017, -0.009186630137264729, 0.020146390423178673, -0.05327853932976723, 0.016670163720846176, 0.03447660803794861, 0.0018856999231502414, -0.0554293729364872, 0.0020851397421211004, -0.005311585031449795, 0.012693220749497414, 0.044674213975667953, 0.03664261847734451, 0.02742765098810196, -0.014822238124907017, 0.025098701938986778, -0.025903718546032906, -0.01937258429825306, 0.00038442914956249297, 0.04336656257510185, -0.023800350725650787, 0.024016976356506348, -0.008443063125014305, -0.06218457221984863, -0.05867423489689827, 0.022798364982008934, -0.018123647198081017, 0.06836108863353729, -0.007476418744772673, 0.0077725606970489025, -0.010202835313975811, 0.05006455257534981, 0.02000405825674534, -0.028017133474349976, 0.051014747470617294, 0.013888890855014324, 0.10154306888580322, 0.01902030222117901, 0.00007716778054600582, -0.0028009742964059114, -0.02264673262834549, -0.07249301671981812, 0.011811475269496441, -0.039783649146556854, 0.019930308684706688, -0.03697306662797928, -0.05041614547371864, -0.006365202832967043, 0.059427108615636826, -0.058910418301820755, -0.047064125537872314, -0.005505502223968506, -0.04300292208790779, -0.0016707219183444977, -0.0026134399231523275, 0.04335976392030716, 0.009722713381052017, -0.027203964069485664, -0.01301009114831686, 0.0017693843692541122, 0.0306505486369133, 0.11223536729812622, 0.00970314722508192, -0.011689881794154644, -0.00921208132058382, 0.014445758424699306, 0.012297747656702995, -0.0830773189663887, -0.003635390428826213, -0.04881085455417633, -0.04669847711920738, -0.09083821624517441, 0.004026802722364664, 0.0001889569393824786, 0.05162009224295616, 0.03744697943329811, -0.00566941499710083, -0.002370493719354272, 0.012800329364836216, 0.010897466912865639, 0.03614567965269089, -0.01568920537829399, -0.048397280275821686, 0.013093831948935986, -0.06157616153359413, -0.0224497988820076, 0.004110165871679783, -0.0029869303107261658, 0.006394500378519297, 0.03334975615143776, -0.04622764512896538, -0.03900505229830742, -0.04067177698016167, 0.05437823757529259, 0.0538390651345253, 0.04726080968976021, -0.04508553445339203, 0.020817261189222336, 0.006094436161220074, 0.0491148978471756, -0.03646647185087204, -0.002969958819448948, 0.0022124280221760273, 0.011410489678382874, -0.0174019243568182, 0.005450285039842129, 0.018550502136349678, 0.005062594078481197, -0.04112081602215767, 0.018160568550229073, 0.02048373967409134, -0.06709287315607071, 0.029511110857129097, 0.010012201964855194, -0.0635845810174942, -0.011521725915372372, -0.038406357169151306, 0.06079443171620369, 0.0490608885884285, 0.022512659430503845, -0.008768010884523392, 0.04410175606608391, 0.01811809465289116, -0.05169450119137764, -0.0006899427971802652, 0.06730979681015015, 0.022023126482963562, -0.013355862349271774, -0.001205178676173091, 0.05617673322558403, 0.03320447728037834, -0.023487474769353867, -0.02350373938679695, -0.05574386939406395, 0.02052856795489788, -0.01565723307430744, 0.03462919220328331, 0.06110357120633125, -0.03848894685506821, -0.0015878358390182257, -0.08910386264324188, -0.026015084236860275, 0.03252897784113884, 0.03228640556335449, 0.006849972531199455, 0.04903731122612953, -0.03808172792196274, -0.07354684174060822, 0.019798822700977325, -0.009665648452937603, 0.012925519607961178, 0.03561701625585556, -0.03391680493950844, -0.034581515938043594, -0.007809740491211414, 0.006179036572575569, 0.04532860964536667, 0.05328890681266785, -0.029208393767476082, -0.012233853340148926, -0.053140927106142044, -0.06147131323814392, 0.022593988105654716, -0.0013129882281646132, -0.013477957807481289, 0.07158801704645157, 0.029031431302428246, -0.023381784558296204, -0.07573893666267395, -0.008248052559792995, -0.009086374193429947, 0.05529172718524933, -0.034102071076631546, -0.010960671119391918, 0.002843943890184164, -0.029828965663909912, 0.07503119856119156, -0.006437770556658506, 0.04600874334573746, -0.062382303178310394, 0.011197246611118317, 0.03645363450050354, 0.00906978826969862, 0.0418999157845974, -0.014150728471577168, -0.030094902962446213, 0.009981186129152775, 0.009408793412148952, -0.019219128414988518, 0.020935513079166412, 0.025100717321038246, 0.036761943250894547, 0.011490997858345509, 0.09721798449754715, -0.024352090433239937, -0.027290644124150276, 0.0032587440218776464, -0.015833912417292595, 0.02434426173567772, 0.031846784055233, 0.030926166102290154, -0.03531980141997337, 0.04310436546802521, -0.014965705573558807, 0.028807152062654495, 0.024642804637551308, 0.06478122621774673, 0.050326839089393616, -0.057898860424757004, 0.049367956817150116, 0.025381503626704216, 0.048078808933496475, -0.04043842852115631, 0.018693065270781517, 0.07446438074111938, 0.002205135300755501, 0.03886125981807709, -0.016680719330906868, 0.006095788441598415, -0.0002930757182184607, 0.03213837370276451, -0.022831643000245094, 0.02941885031759739, -0.008810375817120075, 0.01995456963777542, -0.03859524428844452, 0.019346533343195915, 0.01099306158721447, -0.04428023099899292, 0.04636427387595177, -0.044341109693050385, 0.026120083406567574, 0.035353418439626694, -0.037911996245384216, 0.005861015524715185, -0.027643050998449326, 0.03700901195406914, -0.05185379460453987, -0.04061083123087883, -0.04976237937808037, -0.030843209475278854, -0.022579893469810486, 0.047161638736724854, 0.02015877328813076, -0.021137017756700516, -0.01019727997481823, -0.0009879199787974358, 0.09581400454044342, -0.006070411764085293, 0.0056771994568407536, -0.025668049231171608, 0.03855108469724655, 0.04972260817885399, 0.036343324929475784, 0.004980846773833036, -0.07301278412342072, -0.030597109347581863, 0.013836446218192577, -0.015424719080328941, -0.018701128661632538, -0.05111837759613991, 0.03718108683824539, -0.04252776503562927, 0.03163580223917961, -0.006993716582655907, 0.025842949748039246, 0.025491125881671906, 0.10501183569431305, 0.055291444063186646, 0.001129378448240459, 0.0012363255955278873, 0.041573259979486465, 0.013010576367378235, -0.04474097490310669, -0.034058697521686554, -0.04545275866985321, -0.051805246621370316, 0.002219314919784665, 0.002461602445691824, -0.038879603147506714, -0.052441198378801346, 0.004678403493016958, -0.0209006667137146, 0.028223717585206032, -0.06719490140676498, -0.005003351718187332, -0.029458893463015556, -0.0024632380809634924, -0.004585853312164545, -0.007716412656009197, 0.024524299427866936, 0.019234981387853622, -0.04993777349591255, -0.040952667593955994, -0.05561386048793793, 0.006665082182735205, 0.04459157958626747, 0.037736132740974426, 0.004809901583939791, 0.00276463502086699, 0.037976980209350586, 0.017791612073779106, 0.05241643264889717, 0.013686951249837875, 0.013829829171299934, -0.06213010847568512, 0.002586149610579014, -0.015463179908692837, 0.053214285522699356, -0.0068016801960766315, 0.03730008378624916, -0.043548714369535446, -0.017184877768158913, -0.02162873186171055, -0.013881021179258823, 0.0027871597558259964, 0.07561967521905899, 0.0011361242504790425, -0.06680035591125488, 0.012421034276485443, -0.026921646669507027, -0.021217105910182, -0.021264757961034775, -0.0075039975345134735, -0.050585389137268066, 0.0384669229388237, -0.04290268197655678, 0.004200262948870659, 0.004251622594892979, 0.021897735074162483, -0.03278101608157158, -0.002216566586866975, 0.022737253457307816, -0.031397782266139984, 0.042235150933265686, 0.06836321949958801, -0.011501194909214973, 0.05618419125676155, 0.008120208978652954, -0.005803641863167286, -0.015260259620845318, 0.009678141213953495, 0.01474259328097105, -0.016336992383003235, -0.03959902003407478, -0.03265421837568283, 0.08162984997034073, -0.030205458402633667, -0.021809762343764305, 0.027070507407188416, -0.028351543471217155, 0.033072106540203094, -0.04526131600141525, -0.018672658130526543, -0.05254486948251724, 0.06939510256052017, 0.0376741848886013, -0.05718773230910301, 0.013855944387614727, -0.023276090621948242, -0.027612343430519104, -0.009331008419394493, 0.01371678989380598, 0.026262862607836723, 0.008834811858832836, -0.07470420747995377, -0.045427169650793076, -0.046989310532808304, 0.008923745714128017, -0.04580990970134735, -0.032872553914785385, 0.022653313353657722, -0.000271779514150694, -0.006726960651576519, 0.044804275035858154, -0.024603623896837234, -0.02386755496263504, 0.03966839611530304, -0.032825175672769547, -0.033005475997924805, 0.01498875766992569, 0.008071820251643658, -0.015189377591013908, -0.03565901890397072, 0.004000295419245958, -0.03212666139006615, 0.0021636250894516706, 0.016457894816994667, 0.0015109300147742033, 0.01992778293788433, 0.046008139848709106, -0.06901517510414124, 0.042490094900131226, -0.00639177905395627, 0.004985736217349768, 0.015835488215088844, -0.011596664786338806, 0.057237811386585236, -0.009728874079883099, 0.026297621428966522, 0.051940374076366425, 0.027918891981244087, -0.018259800970554352, 0.001938788453117013, -0.05394423007965088, 0.03415361046791077, -0.01184625644236803, 0.024673206731677055, 0.043091870844364166, -0.015598006546497345, -0.018373727798461914, -0.004251557402312756, -0.029614608734846115, 0.008076448924839497, 0.022616488859057426, -0.06671944260597229, -0.006083589047193527, 0.017669932916760445, -0.025176387280225754, 0.004999859258532524, -0.025356288999319077, -0.02684454247355461, 0.008078014478087425, 0.03840912878513336, 0.00550697511062026, -0.0042254067957401276, 0.05356336012482643, 0.003389807417988777, 0.03787623718380928, -0.005617739632725716, 0.024478338658809662, -0.008526245132088661, 0.018700934946537018, -0.014174657873809338, 0.022877680137753487, 0.03887023776769638, -0.06303732097148895, 0.03249116986989975, 0.003921158146113157, -0.007631632965058088, -0.0376918651163578, 0.009723484516143799, -0.049024809151887894, -0.046231649816036224, 0.007570852991193533, -0.07160084694623947, -0.022283030673861504, 0.03637758269906044, 0.06565127521753311, -0.03134716674685478, 0.008155987598001957, -0.02814682386815548, -0.028997128829360008, 0.017218440771102905, 0.006352060008794069, -0.0028486535884439945, 0.03728658705949783, -0.009379922412335873, 0.0006849747733213007, 0.056956179440021515, -0.06757912039756775, 0.04935348406434059, -0.0811617448925972, 0.05186590179800987, -0.021787308156490326, 0.019330477342009544, -0.034471165388822556, -0.000529701414052397, -0.011128709651529789, 0.040263764560222626, -0.03542407602071762, -0.030559822916984558, 0.05409545823931694, 0.06468503922224045, -0.054519832134246826, -0.02517932653427124, -0.007364457007497549, -0.03132335841655731, -0.0009125269134528935, 0.005885058082640171, -0.03872579708695412, 0.030909288674592972, 0.0007069310522638261, 0.04350588098168373, 0.019270023331046104, 0.02647979184985161, -0.04231623560190201, 0.05293786898255348, 0.012426638975739479, -0.011757276020944118, 0.024374129250645638, 0.032159578055143356, -0.017268892377614975, -0.014030744321644306, -0.03579748421907425, 0.01695556379854679, 0.05319938436150551, -0.055466074496507645, 0.003976374864578247, 0.0030868707690387964, 0.028674261644482613, 0.02169407717883587, 0.012966342270374298, -0.0076326183043420315, 0.015909887850284576, 0.05084531381726265, 0.022711744531989098, 0.03731819614768028, -0.01059013232588768, 0.017577137798070908, -0.044075045734643936, 0.01091888640075922, -0.030333684757351875, 0.013542195782065392, 0.002810829319059849, -0.049519311636686325, 0.002043997636064887, 0.062196627259254456, 0.024322815239429474, -0.0017470027087256312, 0.010189183056354523, -0.02193167433142662, 0.06570351123809814, 0.02856082282960415, -0.009356384165585041, -0.010034610517323017, -0.0408267006278038, -0.0484338216483593, 0.015636814758181572, -0.001423062989488244, -0.02229989506304264, 0.01398104801774025, -0.046718839555978775, -0.03297028690576553, -0.0333077572286129, -0.014005239121615887, 0.05401409789919853, 0.025351613759994507, -0.029962964355945587, -0.012597773224115372, -0.02036425657570362, -0.002879091538488865, -0.060860440135002136, -0.017683209851384163, 0.011381471529603004, -0.04245734587311745, 0.02430552802979946, -0.034282438457012177, 0.02398099936544895, -0.0800139456987381, -0.039716076105833054, -0.03636324033141136, -0.06212279573082924, -0.0563187412917614, 0.060120727866888046, -0.03153569996356964, -0.009546362794935703, -0.05932638794183731, 0.02922283299267292, 0.010846586897969246, -0.032368168234825134, 0.013540666550397873, 0.04089297726750374, -0.008762374520301819, -0.0121780289337039, 0.06323882192373276, -0.01911798305809498, -0.05629759654402733, -0.04752851277589798, -0.016996564343571663, 0.03740725666284561, -0.03444061428308487, -0.002205179538577795, 0.027201546356081963, 0.07518593221902847, 0.008757242932915688, 0.03660327196121216, -0.007453713100403547, -0.03224746510386467, -0.07329043000936508, 0.00342888617888093, -0.028129415586590767, -0.0410490408539772, -0.0005215007113292813, 0.02293229289352894, -0.02861105650663376, -0.03461557626724243, -0.01566295139491558, -0.009664970450103283, 0.00204923446290195, 0.007328777574002743, -0.09025856852531433, -0.020283589139580727, 0.005705843213945627 ]
<p>I have been trying to learn about the randomness in Quantum Physics. But of the many sources I referred to, some say about "Randomness in Quantum physics" and some others say about "Quantum indeterminacy". So my question is do these two mean the same or are they completely different? Is randomness because of that indeterminacy or that randomness is actually "there" and that causes the indeterminacy in Quantum Physics? Or are they just two ways of referring to the same thing and if yes then what are they actually referring to? </p>
g5859
[ -0.009176111780107021, 0.0011896335054188967, 0.047658711671829224, -0.02511407434940338, 0.0368458591401577, 0.020320579409599304, 0.02400139532983303, 0.03875727578997612, 0.024082856252789497, -0.02085486613214016, -0.0022045897785574198, -0.02367408387362957, -0.010384869761765003, 0.007635004352778196, -0.03217228502035141, -0.04412662610411644, 0.09337414801120758, 0.00040283999987877905, -0.03381684422492981, 0.04737390577793121, 0.013467934913933277, 0.01744387485086918, -0.006649221293628216, 0.01168686430901289, -0.0068227751180529594, -0.04377852380275726, -0.08505475521087646, -0.07752001285552979, 0.018388058990240097, 0.02444905787706375, -0.04410787299275398, -0.009971226565539837, 0.02505103126168251, -0.04318877309560776, -0.025977754965424538, -0.021837143227458, 0.009345142170786858, 0.0070718699134886265, 0.038672640919685364, -0.04000360518693924, -0.011402355507016182, -0.003538690507411957, -0.011255666613578796, -0.028986504301428795, -0.04156516492366791, 0.014465202577412128, -0.06879465281963348, 0.07317882776260376, -0.0076981037855148315, 0.01716775819659233, 0.052657246589660645, -0.00806054100394249, 0.030272657051682472, 0.029133589938282967, 0.04897351562976837, 0.006748449523001909, 0.040248092263936996, -0.008973258547484875, 0.03357306495308876, 0.045875269919633865, 0.05090221390128136, 0.02476116083562374, -0.02094421163201332, -0.010872927494347095, 0.01844203844666481, 0.0037502325139939785, 0.015602576546370983, 0.015518793836236, -0.017994511872529984, 0.006993571761995554, 0.029230568557977676, -0.012687664479017258, -0.00245713465847075, 0.002130156848579645, -0.006000314839184284, 0.020933957770466805, 0.043031178414821625, 0.009778975509107113, 0.0009285080013796687, 0.02387181669473648, -0.04035850241780281, -0.05939394608139992, 0.061836905777454376, 0.040091440081596375, 0.11392208188772202, 0.025394052267074585, 0.013212047517299652, -0.003868652507662773, 0.00867016427218914, 0.004674558527767658, 0.0006412246730178595, -0.037379976361989975, 0.0495775043964386, 0.03924086317420006, -0.022958606481552124, -0.010413339361548424, -0.005206467118114233, 0.029607271775603294, -0.0615035742521286, 0.0005282571655698121, -0.05107434093952179, -0.0020697382278740406, 0.018022937700152397, -0.0009149134857580066, -0.019822174683213234, -0.02144007571041584, -0.025278659537434578, -0.005237951874732971, -0.006259010173380375, -0.011806429363787174, -0.049535274505615234, 0.0018328602891415358, 0.015331474132835865, 0.01498959306627512, -0.0361577533185482, -0.01089058443903923, 0.04738874360918999, -0.004794679116457701, 0.035415053367614746, 0.03543612360954285, 0.020571555942296982, 0.053989604115486145, -0.035357438027858734, 0.014564392156898975, -0.02475721761584282, 0.008410561829805374, -0.01257248967885971, -0.03316676244139671, 0.026554834097623825, -0.011989474296569824, 0.02429278939962387, 0.013693428598344326, 0.02230074815452099, -0.025617774575948715, -0.02437344565987587, 0.0032350546680390835, 0.0760195404291153, 0.009649352170526981, 0.06744149327278137, -0.005107037257403135, 0.020108381286263466, 0.004526876844465733, -0.009385557845234871, 0.0045321942307055, -0.04152842238545418, -0.026660628616809845, 0.005759403109550476, 0.004756753332912922, 0.0077904826030135155, 0.04243685305118561, 0.08361507207155228, -0.029494337737560272, -0.05094003677368164, -0.06837478280067444, 0.020373404026031494, 0.034543782472610474, -0.011297304183244705, 0.03055618703365326, -0.005228354595601559, 0.037831101566553116, 0.058031171560287476, 0.01755904033780098, 0.046009551733732224, -0.01041784044355154, 0.013388815335929394, 0.005266567692160606, 0.004304369445890188, -0.040014635771512985, -0.018439283594489098, -0.07333123683929443, -0.04708478972315788, -0.011340046301484108, -0.04379739984869957, 0.039205681532621384, 0.04244280979037285, 0.0476270355284214, 0.019247237592935562, -0.02505427971482277, -0.05881377309560776, -0.018021894618868828, -0.016275346279144287, 0.025449691340327263, -0.022050976753234863, -0.04007178544998169, -0.04009494185447693, -0.010738804936408997, 0.011449220590293407, -0.02056659571826458, -0.05493812635540962, -0.0045992364175617695, -0.03549570217728615, -0.027464810758829117, 0.008004250936210155, -0.05273642763495445, 0.03474561497569084, -0.005545883439481258, -0.0187539029866457, 0.005244544707238674, 0.007595508359372616, -0.025899674743413925, 0.029323507100343704, -0.02449110336601734, -0.0206257626414299, -0.019679933786392212, -0.014697261154651642, 0.024751272052526474, -0.035194359719753265, 0.004989714827388525, 0.009921046905219555, 0.009873883798718452, 0.03709102049469948, -0.010030345059931278, 0.03632203862071037, 0.0005601131706498563, 0.024194443598389626, -0.010418451391160488, 0.06355568766593933, 0.002531737321987748, 0.011865179985761642, -0.024693559855222702, 0.01256305631250143, 0.011826662346720695, 0.03473813831806183, -0.016333749517798424, 0.028457757085561752, 0.02601322904229164, -0.08230210840702057, -0.02610146626830101, -0.01827896013855934, 0.05173997953534126, -0.03842918574810028, -0.05069269239902496, -0.021388158202171326, 0.0120706120505929, 0.004502448718994856, 0.046871036291122437, 0.07788436114788055, -0.008237157948315144, 0.008425095118582249, -0.01075719017535448, -0.03868032619357109, -0.0023544554132968187, 0.020550284534692764, 0.040201764553785324, -0.002516579581424594, -0.05952505022287369, 0.0433097667992115, -0.05999796465039253, -0.01853012852370739, -0.0029705374035984278, 0.026594923809170723, -0.07752560079097748, -0.04979299008846283, -0.04265541583299637, 0.028491485863924026, -0.017562687397003174, 0.037354402244091034, 0.017801489681005478, -0.03754476085305214, -0.004633687902241945, 0.01269458420574665, -0.07366146147251129, 0.012498985044658184, 0.01037153135985136, -0.058123525232076645, 0.032039474695920944, 0.021586637943983078, 0.039813410490751266, -0.01871766708791256, 0.011748678982257843, -0.027727879583835602, 0.013605370186269283, 0.02598525956273079, 0.00036150371306575835, 0.04978771507740021, -0.015470348298549652, -0.06088342145085335, -0.020665569230914116, -0.016456883400678635, -0.003974725026637316, 0.005824499297887087, 0.0225429255515337, -0.04157830774784088, 0.035723134875297546, 0.008546367287635803, -0.0439881905913353, 0.005994280334562063, -0.06644387543201447, -0.0003051015955861658, 0.02225799858570099, 0.006676224991679192, -0.032228294759988785, 0.058535926043987274, 0.021181249991059303, -0.035308413207530975, 0.00796100590378046, -0.03593594580888748, 0.0010324600152671337, -0.005464976653456688, 0.04521830752491951, 0.020761562511324883, -0.004680863115936518, -0.03070669248700142, 0.07628480345010757, 0.06443541496992111, 0.05655893310904503, 0.014161022379994392, -0.015984555706381798, -0.0394490584731102, -0.049219172447919846, -0.03907151520252228, 0.03552618622779846, -0.04184894263744354, 0.03701278567314148, 0.03936760500073433, -0.006229983177036047, -0.028756603598594666, 0.06440672278404236, 0.028062468394637108, -0.0525454543530941, -0.0907367467880249, -0.0018289725994691253, 0.004778582137078047, 0.006616860628128052, 0.03526074066758156, 0.027061739936470985, 0.0009631675202399492, -0.006772847846150398, -0.028533637523651123, -0.04463398456573486, -0.017907997593283653, -0.015735575929284096, -0.042065028101205826, -0.05276862904429436, -0.06190381199121475, -0.07986007630825043, -0.02234005741775036, -0.004834228660911322, 0.03236608952283859, -0.03576965630054474, 0.07651679962873459, 0.0287373885512352, -0.029348941519856453, 0.05578325316309929, -0.05633535236120224, 0.04433001950383186, -0.0012919320724904537, -0.023617180064320564, 0.027220703661441803, 0.03631581366062164, 0.06322184950113297, 0.004477027337998152, 0.002878148341551423, 0.04935140162706375, -0.098942331969738, 0.01997917704284191, -0.042562086135149, 0.018516071140766144, 0.009172319434583187, -0.018824633210897446, -0.009763699024915695, -0.08110400289297104, 0.06532628834247589, -0.0011466400464996696, -0.01099055539816618, -0.03815962374210358, 0.010696250945329666, -0.026606379076838493, -0.011628272011876106, -0.007427072152495384, -0.019394971430301666, 0.040763210505247116, -0.02681473270058632, -0.030592171475291252, 0.00830621737986803, -0.013087640516459942, 0.04776908829808235, -0.014673858880996704, 0.0012818074319511652, -0.02777990512549877, -0.015324961394071579, -0.028900515288114548, 0.04392209276556969, 0.04901623725891113, 0.020923487842082977, 0.04639028385281563, -0.032787106931209564, 0.028311612084507942, -0.009015481919050217, -0.054754406213760376, -0.018344726413488388, -0.022293739020824432, -0.019008280709385872, 0.03405240550637245, 0.08315218240022659, 0.04824957996606827, 0.062130093574523926, 0.03319081664085388, 0.06009070575237274, 0.018629373982548714, -0.043545763939619064, -0.05613815411925316, -0.051815129816532135, 0.05559128150343895, 0.020569095388054848, 0.040878091007471085, 0.0649934783577919, 0.001697380910627544, -0.038106806576251984, -0.056728657335042953, 0.00006770891195628792, 0.02295382134616375, -0.035248443484306335, -0.00998280756175518, -0.005213659256696701, 0.01038247998803854, -0.007585640996694565, -0.01457578781992197, 0.04730762913823128, 0.012516324408352375, 0.0012079591397196054, -0.0066215344704687595, 0.059136003255844116, 0.0036823349073529243, 0.004575391300022602, 0.021586949005723, 0.05609115958213806, 0.026736143976449966, -0.012927213683724403, -0.024505849927663803, 0.001771561219356954, 0.012297658249735832, 0.05807448551058769, 0.029833363369107246, -0.020977305248379707, -0.02340136468410492, -0.03862510994076729, 0.010222933255136013, 0.08656659722328186, -0.0623403936624527, 0.07496777176856995, -0.014115206897258759, 0.03502211719751358, 0.050975166261196136, -0.03676494583487511, -0.00939173623919487, -0.06194167211651802, 0.005898090545088053, -0.019386369735002518, 0.020704234018921852, -0.042052723467350006, 0.005333685781806707, -0.028505094349384308, -0.07575120776891708, -0.043504685163497925, -0.0034528817050158978, 0.016538651660084724, 0.0417887344956398, -0.030276771634817123, -0.003431488759815693, -0.0997663289308548, 0.01385943777859211, 0.014111990109086037, 0.02017412893474102, -0.013395114801824093, 0.04119008406996727, -0.03309766575694084, -0.02287309616804123, -0.09017971903085709, -0.0037682754918932915, 0.017238978296518326, 0.014952446334064007, 0.017230883240699768, 0.0664692223072052, 0.037768684327602386, -0.001037467154674232, 0.03405269235372543, 0.0019936005119234324, -0.037939172238111496, -0.0197459664195776, -0.05301906540989876, -0.05226521193981171, 0.041657693684101105, -0.018038030713796616, -0.02581202983856201, 0.005268266424536705, 0.008982149884104729, 0.037403006106615067, -0.005728037096560001, -0.04138759523630142, 0.02183227799832821, 0.024605991318821907, 0.07408344745635986, 0.0001250211789738387, -0.010633007623255253, -0.05591757223010063, 0.001490666763857007, -0.0014115277444943786, -0.04905419796705246, -0.0015903335297480226, 0.002596741309389472, 0.08542867749929428, -0.0068021477200090885, -0.06111668795347214, -0.037083860486745834, 0.020284321159124374, 0.04702534154057503, 0.012106344103813171, -0.005645190365612507, 0.0010653146309778094, -0.023310963064432144, 0.036853909492492676, -0.05086115375161171, -0.024695290252566338, 0.005905143450945616, 0.07499457895755768, 0.015795014798641205, 0.004445729311555624, 0.051556218415498734, 0.004142866935580969, -0.011227761395275593, 0.023375052958726883, 0.00785687193274498, -0.017038539052009583, -0.003468222450464964, -0.046597838401794434, -0.09528256952762604, 0.0012753368355333805, 0.07159575074911118, 0.008210704661905766, 0.026134276762604713, 0.059933070093393326, 0.035125378519296646, -0.02333143539726734, -0.04410369694232941, 0.005823663901537657, -0.04914531111717224, 0.020775338634848595, -0.036302030086517334, 0.09468373656272888, -0.027310285717248917, 0.01907293312251568, 0.026423178613185883, -0.021199341863393784, 0.06215608865022659, -0.03452354669570923, 0.012736201286315918, -0.030583230778574944, 0.013776359148323536, -0.056957561522722244, -0.03420285880565643, 0.056380804628133774, -0.04341309890151024, -0.0025212885811924934, -0.039224445819854736, 0.03630680590867996, 0.006419038400053978, -0.01049428153783083, -0.05334046855568886, 0.03316229581832886, -0.023401398211717606, -0.0028752062935382128, -0.016260772943496704, -0.07164481282234192, -0.042406629770994186, 0.01333399023860693, -0.04352904483675957, -0.06083628162741661, -0.01647990010678768, 0.05061955749988556, 0.00708195473998785, 0.004798565059900284, -0.01886911503970623, 0.023509720340371132, 0.03987961262464523, -0.0011618705466389656, -0.005338801071047783, -0.018669230863451958, -0.06139244884252548, -0.008636664599180222, -0.03153400868177414, 0.06242018938064575, 0.033004578202962875, -0.0627564787864685, -0.06919796019792557, 0.06325706094503403, -0.003201266983523965, 0.03948964551091194, 0.024467742070555687, -0.01557103730738163, -0.013611972332000732, 0.025237275287508965, 0.0135762644931674, 0.012917072512209415, -0.09359005093574524, -0.008434155024588108, 0.008990124799311161, 0.04921996593475342, -0.0637122243642807, 0.009276474826037884, -0.03467661887407303, -0.07486806809902191, 0.010328901000320911, -0.002909641247242689, 0.011935239657759666, 0.06234622374176979, -0.0025512881111353636, 0.008354950696229935, -0.045902084559202194, 0.05574684590101242, -0.03474234417080879, 0.03043196350336075, -0.02486584521830082, -0.010813706554472446, -0.00939973909407854, -0.03612252697348595, -0.059926003217697144, 0.002030680887401104, 0.015047126449644566, -0.0151113485917449, 0.07537862658500671, -0.01066779438406229, 0.047974132001399994, 0.05161583423614502, 0.041087228804826736, 0.08183648437261581, -0.026550544425845146, 0.037793032824993134, 0.01426953449845314, -0.05905437842011452, -0.02272309549152851, -0.04797450080513954, 0.016354553401470184, 0.0976942628622055, 0.01864936575293541, 0.048046912997961044, -0.03490845859050751, -0.04444975405931473, 0.0068954103626310825, 0.04527457430958748, 0.0010146483546122909, -0.005925449542701244, 0.042557213455438614, -0.010299685411155224, 0.00879871379584074, 0.020838646218180656, 0.016502488404512405, 0.009865207597613335, -0.05570415407419205, -0.01548703946173191, -0.05807492509484291, 0.01675570011138916, -0.011225886642932892, 0.008317979983985424, 0.021230923011898994, 0.033183712512254715, 0.007721079047769308, -0.005986195523291826, -0.008242422714829445, -0.030135760083794594, -0.020902760326862335, 0.022428328171372414, -0.05481445789337158, -0.002461344003677368, -0.011646013706922531, 0.019944895058870316, 0.011854349635541439, -0.012383216992020607, -0.030908511951565742, 0.016108963638544083, 0.039038874208927155, -0.0512521006166935, -0.0796099305152893, 0.008076755329966545, 0.007596722338348627, -0.003065837314352393, 0.004788199905306101, 0.03432314470410347, -0.03424329683184624, -0.01925175078213215, -0.030251868069171906, 0.035806022584438324, 0.000863148074131459, -0.0073058572597801685, -0.006017039995640516, 0.034749165177345276, 0.0209013931453228, -0.08101273328065872, -0.027824116870760918, -0.0820014476776123, -0.008821457624435425, -0.028051134198904037, 0.026088159531354904, -0.03754570335149765, -0.005583503749221563, 0.014830346219241619, 0.05547101050615311, 0.05130954086780548, -0.008965804241597652, -0.024575794115662575, -0.02692228928208351, 0.07358570396900177, 0.010493190959095955, -0.01688729226589203, 0.016338270157575607, -0.013393942266702652, 0.02475452423095703, 0.02703915908932686, -0.0016140706138685346, -0.0011093943612650037, -0.025353172793984413, -0.0678626298904419, 0.02801215648651123, 0.023145360872149467, -0.06474347412586212, -0.039283741265535355, 0.006840575486421585, 0.019570374861359596, 0.01594637893140316, -0.0454886220395565, 0.00498700886964798, -0.01581149362027645, 0.03185003995895386, -0.0021633796859532595, -0.05245598033070564, 0.05817609280347824, 0.012808317318558693, 0.0009286361746490002, -0.002603952307254076, -0.01409071870148182, 0.01620456576347351, -0.02308526821434498, 0.01531678531318903, 0.03406663239002228, 0.03477435186505318, 0.05213546380400658, 0.03400924429297447, 0.016889698803424835, 0.04004838690161705, 0.00461379811167717, 0.029625538736581802, -0.013099909760057926, 0.006420873571187258, 0.0030512786470353603, -0.0616694800555706, -0.05449315160512924, 0.005098158027976751, -0.003968167584389448, -0.03191162645816803, -0.05192616209387779, -0.04429243505001068, 0.04829917848110199, -0.0077093979343771935, 0.08716422319412231, 0.05193318426609039, -0.07551722973585129, 0.029480716213583946, 0.05198418349027634, 0.027967914938926697, 0.0370972640812397, 0.04469379782676697, 0.01965169608592987, -0.041866932064294815, -0.006180546712130308, -0.0667695477604866, 0.019448529928922653, -0.04680509865283966, -0.011272887699306011 ]
<p>I'm currently trying to familiarize myself with the physics of ion and particle traps, especially with linear Paul traps. Many scientific experiments I've come across use segmented electrodes (like in <a href="http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/130807/ncomms3290/fig_tab/ncomms3290_F1.html" rel="nofollow" title="this image">this image</a> from a Nature article). My question is <em>what do you gain by segmenting the electrodes?</em> I could imagine that you can move the trapped particles along the axis to some extent, or determine their position in the trap. But in both cases I believe there are more precise methods.</p>
g5860
[ 0.013961237855255604, 0.029676765203475952, -0.021879544481635094, -0.018562449142336845, 0.07126349955797195, -0.01966288313269615, 0.05549531802535057, 0.02101496048271656, -0.017088746652007103, 0.025138236582279205, -0.02290624938905239, 0.0032004467211663723, 0.008115880191326141, -0.04821467399597168, 0.014540612697601318, -0.023576075211167336, 0.0627598986029625, -0.032795410603284836, 0.021335585042834282, 0.024384083226323128, 0.08448965847492218, 0.05252554640173912, -0.036334749311208725, 0.01458987407386303, 0.02529001235961914, -0.04304290935397148, 0.005661866627633572, -0.006301959976553917, -0.03189467638731003, -0.014999636448919773, -0.01900460012257099, -0.05877838656306267, -0.01711634360253811, 0.016043249517679214, -0.07012595981359482, -0.03166329488158226, -0.013019606471061707, -0.008252105675637722, -0.026945482939481735, -0.03572122007608414, 0.033517833799123764, -0.0736905187368393, 0.02204764075577259, -0.04004746302962303, -0.02290497161448002, -0.014213988557457924, 0.0023792446590960026, -0.10041330009698868, -0.028902867808938026, -0.0007326094200834632, -0.015262947417795658, 0.0009282109094783664, -0.020364506170153618, 0.06323584169149399, 0.04404180869460106, -0.01525153685361147, 0.00931533146649599, 0.009574760682880878, 0.09119025617837906, -0.008042257279157639, 0.07047905772924423, 0.0723736584186554, -0.029655568301677704, -0.02741744928061962, 0.009978743270039558, 0.02773159183561802, -0.06047286093235016, 0.05230944976210594, -0.018080759793519974, 0.007316518574953079, -0.002364708110690117, 0.004228288307785988, -0.02320733480155468, -0.015901699662208557, -0.05909968912601471, 0.05114447697997093, -0.004907167516648769, 0.014475672505795956, 0.00023805504315532744, 0.023632412776350975, -0.018659157678484917, 0.004718906246125698, -0.032570503652095795, -0.03390661999583244, 0.12344532459974289, 0.008510003797709942, -0.03865531086921692, 0.034677159041166306, -0.03725428134202957, -0.01446933951228857, -0.011802622117102146, -0.046168360859155655, 0.0400935523211956, -0.03118341974914074, -0.0759533941745758, -0.0009404709562659264, -0.008645067922770977, 0.014537024311721325, 0.06908217072486877, 0.07113087922334671, -0.014509188942611217, 0.03490715101361275, -0.0019125090911984444, -0.023927832022309303, 0.0015721960226073861, -0.0012046691263094544, 0.05620942637324333, -0.035026561468839645, 0.03646402060985565, -0.04718005284667015, 0.002264736918732524, -0.04304065182805061, -0.1210595965385437, 0.003850313136354089, -0.03161625564098358, 0.054293494671583176, 0.07361896336078644, 0.006232664920389652, -0.0059741465374827385, 0.048605505377054214, 0.05564132332801819, 0.08172908425331116, 0.035194724798202515, 0.004056922160089016, -0.05955769121646881, 0.03573043271899223, 0.008359257131814957, 0.052803099155426025, 0.02057853527367115, 0.04475826770067215, 0.0440218485891819, -0.021434154361486435, -0.056528735905885696, -0.0536828450858593, -0.06718175113201141, -0.006051985081285238, -0.029576057568192482, 0.010574381798505783, 0.041080448776483536, -0.029631422832608223, 0.0015428925398737192, 0.0003530560643412173, -0.012286742217838764, 0.004309708718210459, 0.02925189957022667, 0.01308185514062643, -0.04589129611849785, 0.01654301956295967, -0.00982567761093378, 0.07374534755945206, -0.010958242230117321, 0.03238343447446823, 0.030266964808106422, -0.023150311782956123, 0.027523845434188843, -0.04708892107009888, 0.0773361474275589, 0.005874697118997574, 0.015326067805290222, -0.020461810752749443, 0.05473194643855095, 0.010103309527039528, 0.03601090610027313, -0.03132205083966255, -0.03618331626057625, -0.025866525247693062, 0.012734964489936829, -0.006314526312053204, 0.01658022589981556, -0.047931019216775894, 0.033774446696043015, 0.010456625372171402, 0.010760395787656307, 0.02491580881178379, 0.020642714574933052, 0.07879707962274551, -0.014924338087439537, -0.0513346791267395, 0.07234252989292145, -0.041966117918491364, 0.018372012302279472, 0.036909304559230804, 0.0315096452832222, -0.008779732510447502, 0.011590532958507538, -0.011139586567878723, -0.005160235799849033, 0.01990373432636261, -0.013326143845915794, -0.04204219952225685, 0.01938335970044136, -0.014202186837792397, -0.028569959104061127, -0.023864753544330597, -0.026506299152970314, -0.02777552418410778, 0.018939794972538948, -0.1063830554485321, -0.06144031137228012, 0.0010626170551404357, -0.028832240030169487, 0.0008613053942099214, -0.021221598610281944, -0.007405088283121586, 0.020664425566792488, -0.03460974991321564, -0.02013484761118889, -0.03153962269425392, -0.002605585614219308, -0.03568248078227043, 0.016414543613791466, 0.0503881610929966, 0.030957145616412163, -0.01978941820561886, -0.05834796279668808, -0.026554133743047714, 0.017662666738033295, -0.0025119162164628506, 0.039641957730054855, -0.04315498471260071, -0.01950974576175213, -0.08703689277172089, -0.02049567736685276, 0.007559952326118946, 0.026588767766952515, 0.04329978674650192, 0.062405917793512344, -0.005062154959887266, -0.04511523246765137, 0.0426475815474987, -0.062133509665727615, 0.014885719865560532, -0.03549293056130409, -0.04982135444879532, 0.04547373577952385, 0.02073884941637516, -0.010152479633688927, -0.00028213689802214503, 0.0047613633796572685, -0.03477828577160835, 0.030118297785520554, -0.06600538641214371, -0.021760515868663788, -0.02174425683915615, 0.015977144241333008, 0.009997480548918247, 0.08323250710964203, 0.013722344301640987, -0.024913230910897255, -0.003072917927056551, 0.04454486817121506, -0.010955638252198696, 0.0028010434471070766, -0.006342027336359024, -0.025179103016853333, -0.04332634061574936, 0.013138934969902039, 0.08473433554172516, 0.008044474758207798, -0.03871534764766693, -0.003800575388595462, 0.03845405578613281, -0.04046094790101051, 0.010056027211248875, -0.04364827275276184, -0.04119490459561348, -0.008405285887420177, -0.020933236926794052, -0.005490749608725309, -0.03090025670826435, -0.0001329732040176168, -0.0012971583055332303, 0.047805726528167725, 0.039826393127441406, 0.027361217886209488, -0.023618124425411224, 0.07092558592557907, -0.044237762689590454, 0.03791208937764168, -0.05552522465586662, -0.00039971762453205884, 0.0373627133667469, -0.017203010618686676, 0.024550599977374077, 0.015388153493404388, -0.011465228162705898, 0.055610187351703644, -0.05581343173980713, -0.009869360364973545, -0.003191160736605525, -0.024707721546292305, -0.05792298913002014, 0.0558026060461998, -0.08303718268871307, -0.02606526017189026, 0.04190124198794365, 0.01579057052731514, -0.08543173968791962, -0.025980953127145767, 0.002171639120206237, -0.013280547223985195, 0.007856051437556744, 0.04595465585589409, -0.03848479315638542, 0.05175652727484703, 0.009507426992058754, -0.0032590802293270826, 0.01630314067006111, 0.004009440541267395, -0.014054326340556145, 0.009454576298594475, 0.04504850134253502, 0.05200137570500374, 0.03235660120844841, 0.034656986594200134, -0.03302967548370361, -0.040853772312402725, -0.01966550573706627, -0.025214914232492447, 0.01838034577667713, 0.02497848868370056, 0.0027822256088256836, 0.03786947578191757, 0.013708310201764107, 0.044153012335300446, -0.0100701954215765, 0.012404206208884716, -0.07794796675443649, 0.0010285438038408756, 0.03887581452727318, 0.02578473463654518, 0.07358797639608383, 0.04147426038980484, -0.05264011397957802, 0.014190755784511566, -0.10580921173095703, -0.013550321571528912, 0.002494075568392873, 0.024745991453528404, -0.049765586853027344, -0.020096544176340103, -0.020924514159560204, -0.059615179896354675, -0.03862250596284866, -0.010951245203614235, -0.03513365611433983, 0.06624553352594376, 0.007804259192198515, 0.017078278586268425, -0.0310197900980711, -0.007734484504908323, 0.045900408178567886, -0.02008710615336895, -0.02382771484553814, -0.02038402669131756, -0.018182791769504547, 0.008365962654352188, -0.02503962628543377, -0.007995355874300003, 0.05824713408946991, 0.002647106070071459, -0.004611809737980366, -0.009806686080992222, 0.01681910827755928, 0.017401937395334244, -0.01953274942934513, -0.0016004357021301985, 0.004422126803547144, -0.030651412904262543, -0.030306890606880188, -0.00810263678431511, 0.025965342298150063, -0.01709825173020363, -0.014035943895578384, -0.025916092097759247, -0.027593238279223442, -0.018352018669247627, -0.01200980693101883, 0.029214974492788315, -0.02169205993413925, -0.07346215844154358, -0.027939878404140472, 0.032211046665906906, -0.06288617849349976, -0.0025959014892578125, -0.011339369229972363, -0.02443183772265911, 0.0414084866642952, -0.051384035497903824, -0.008927916176617146, 0.002651127288118005, 0.0038648194167762995, -0.05251017212867737, -0.03867117688059807, -0.0033340577501803637, -0.016827963292598724, 0.03004276007413864, 0.013334762305021286, 0.027543053030967712, -0.013977495022118092, 0.050648752599954605, 0.020735999569296837, -0.0602140799164772, -0.014432879164814949, 0.04032132402062416, -0.011728552170097828, 0.00989436637610197, 0.02896379865705967, -0.005343610420823097, -0.00692781200632453, -0.0700959712266922, 0.028062842786312103, -0.0032634157687425613, -0.03400808572769165, 0.016040677204728127, 0.021282121539115906, -0.011166932061314583, 0.021051647141575813, 0.011159135028719902, -0.019842008128762245, 0.0031416290439665318, 0.01905815862119198, -0.0535142719745636, 0.00011277796147624031, -0.01618197374045849, 0.05254054069519043, 0.029420819133520126, -0.03471722453832626, 0.012463914230465889, -0.03972935676574707, 0.027128614485263824, -0.05070279538631439, 0.04291432723402977, -0.00339470780454576, -0.01134724821895361, -0.004685020539909601, -0.07505960762500763, 0.040336791425943375, 0.015910882502794266, 0.07870055735111237, 0.0747629702091217, 0.04961087182164192, 0.02062215656042099, 0.0030839748214930296, -0.04377518594264984, 0.02902993932366371, -0.01805828884243965, 0.009010802023112774, -0.020817698910832405, -0.01906616799533367, -0.01734752021729946, 0.0459921695291996, -0.0269546490162611, -0.04624776169657707, 0.02241000346839428, -0.06919305771589279, 0.008191948756575584, 0.03073040209710598, 0.07052695751190186, 0.035188596695661545, 0.012192241847515106, 0.009991477243602276, 0.016543162986636162, -0.0018612309359014034, 0.04267340525984764, -0.005250372923910618, -0.019730346277356148, -0.005074834916740656, -0.008670956827700138, -0.04554047808051109, -0.0004688105545938015, 0.053197965025901794, 0.04021371528506279, 0.0008904985152184963, -0.011016204953193665, -0.012145214714109898, 0.0004812069528270513, -0.0020563709549605846, -0.032982487231492996, -0.02768845111131668, -0.04750645533204079, 0.013887402601540089, 0.029510335996747017, -0.025758136063814163, -0.03381679207086563, -0.015487580560147762, -0.057668816298246384, -0.033160679042339325, -0.03350672125816345, -0.011644349433481693, 0.01073071826249361, 0.06683634221553802, 0.0058437529951334, -0.04037805646657944, -0.0027803631965070963, -0.008588593453168869, -0.005619973875582218, 0.013338453136384487, 0.006965106353163719, 0.031022410839796066, 0.06575463712215424, -0.002897192956879735, 0.01288490742444992, -0.0037780290003865957, -0.053633756935596466, 0.025393126532435417, 0.059596139937639236, -0.038802240043878555, -0.016483137384057045, -0.03896325081586838, -0.016509288921952248, 0.0015434316592290998, -0.04094716161489487, 0.026802247390151024, 0.0023111552000045776, 0.06269016861915588, -0.049563489854335785, 0.008678867481648922, -0.04384103789925575, -0.003796042874455452, 0.046176131814718246, 0.029650012031197548, 0.03216689079999924, -0.03486406430602074, 0.017715569585561752, -0.04785947874188423, -0.07756111770868301, 0.010090934112668037, -0.004889857489615679, -0.006284558679908514, 0.030407201498746872, 0.04040144756436348, -0.0031041130423545837, 0.019318511709570885, 0.00787708256393671, -0.040556650608778, 0.008039018139243126, -0.027864161878824234, 0.04673714563250542, 0.01008911244571209, -0.00444684736430645, -0.020158719271421432, 0.00932695809751749, 0.034273117780685425, 0.021330242976546288, -0.03272470086812973, 0.03674480691552162, 0.03105761855840683, 0.07080870121717453, -0.0166183989495039, -0.06372132152318954, -0.0289227943867445, -0.024554384872317314, -0.01574377901852131, -0.008686636574566364, 0.06157172471284866, -0.016718892380595207, -0.0413394458591938, -0.027645062655210495, -0.04507981613278389, -0.03260628134012222, -0.009839306585490704, 0.013088860549032688, -0.0004733421665150672, -0.027126632630825043, -0.02586539275944233, -0.03514360263943672, 0.05430183559656143, 0.028647197410464287, 0.05929792672395706, 0.045774370431900024, -0.06328345835208893, 0.00811542198061943, 0.044914327561855316, -0.020900700241327286, -0.015699485316872597, -0.03480725735425949, 0.07480333000421524, -0.051343902945518494, 0.09973358362913132, -0.032675523310899734, 0.04465847834944725, -0.020859962329268456, 0.004327049944549799, 0.028062408789992332, 0.04785820096731186, -0.06951097398996353, -0.0249317716807127, 0.04433182626962662, -0.03257570043206215, -0.03826550394296646, -0.03723808750510216, -0.027658719569444656, -0.006688688416033983, -0.02184777706861496, -0.04323345050215721, -0.01366617251187563, -0.008364413864910603, 0.0026579645927995443, 0.026174291968345642, -0.011709261685609818, 0.008544093929231167, -0.019699588418006897, 0.025401374325156212, 0.023095393553376198, 0.006063952576369047, -0.008357115089893341, -0.0014114811783656478, -0.035494327545166016, 0.004060949664562941, -0.02261357195675373, 0.0007468648254871368, -0.05597337707877159, -0.042749542742967606, 0.005900453310459852, 0.02203928865492344, 0.04504824057221413, -0.07233522087335587, 0.02958565019071102, 0.00015064286708366126, -0.006062167230993509, 0.0191291905939579, 0.01349968183785677, -0.005115577019751072, 0.0037964312359690666, 0.04857587441802025, 0.035276804119348526, 0.007058243732899427, -0.01649731956422329, -0.012131688185036182, 0.0023605406749993563, 0.04198623076081276, 0.017816659063100815, 0.05937376990914345, -0.011230849660933018, -0.020274968817830086, 0.017514165490865707, 0.002669514622539282, 0.05153854563832283, 0.04500854015350342, -0.024213168770074844, 0.0209531057626009, 0.026466771960258484, -0.01784401386976242, -0.05167714133858681, -0.0013272053329274058, -0.019508197903633118, 0.09008102864027023, -0.03946680575609207, 0.001106484793126583, -0.026890549808740616, -0.04529108479619026, -0.023727748543024063, 0.02678515762090683, 0.04196624457836151, 0.034118667244911194, -0.026323705911636353, 0.033573515713214874, 0.014687886461615562, -0.04422762989997864, -0.06725501269102097, -0.032919131219387054, 0.005724561400711536, 0.00758817745372653, -0.01992310769855976, -0.007905089296400547, -0.02036840282380581, 0.01970451883971691, -0.02779277227818966, 0.018833259120583534, -0.017931118607521057, -0.06732205301523209, 0.023223157972097397, 0.03402623161673546, 0.06102798879146576, 0.04604064300656319, 0.02333725430071354, -0.0014848926803097129, -0.07758817821741104, -0.024788590148091316, 0.008506184443831444, 0.05624330788850784, 0.015028979629278183, -0.08209062367677689, -0.042804840952157974, 0.0011000018566846848, -0.06774639338254929, 0.04104110971093178, -0.0009412863291800022, 0.0016362648457288742, 0.030522843822836876, 0.05210341513156891, 0.03572240471839905, 0.007264404091984034, -0.01770072616636753, -0.007781677879393101, 0.03411257266998291, 0.07103367149829865, 0.040352243930101395, 0.058905258774757385, 0.005980798043310642, -0.007736921310424805, 0.05847031995654106, 0.002875039353966713, 0.046621039509773254, -0.012256261892616749, -0.04800773784518242, 0.016406601294875145, -0.0050499821081757545, 0.01780145801603794, -0.002671954920515418, 0.09236081689596176, 0.04256622493267059, 0.020612815394997597, 0.055437635630369186, -0.005689832381904125, -0.042430561035871506, 0.06757529079914093, 0.0482422336935997, 0.020737027749419212, -0.016544252634048462, 0.06286944448947906, 0.027911730110645294, -0.006530628073960543, 0.034681711345911026, -0.04390120506286621, 0.03306758403778076, 0.04520465061068535, -0.009689021855592728, 0.00032972448389045894, 0.05526283383369446, 0.024362612515687943, -0.0008536361274309456, 0.012974166311323643, -0.020370643585920334, -0.013332143425941467, 0.0663728415966034, -0.035938166081905365, -0.03994155302643776, -0.0016144810942932963, 0.0016943514347076416, -0.0744270458817482, -0.00851560290902853, -0.06254997104406357, 0.022556142881512642, 0.024951232597231865, -0.026185177266597748, 0.05080202594399452, -0.01728241518139839, 0.03267541155219078, -0.022800832986831665, 0.013579955324530602, -0.02319539338350296, 0.009422771632671356, -0.004157585557550192, -0.07602619379758835, -0.05820668861269951, 0.034921616315841675, 0.05678234621882439, 0.03468438237905502, 0.028576955199241638, 0.011118538677692413, 0.02052662894129753, -0.023741554468870163, -0.01915917359292507, -0.016052093356847763, 0.01940510980784893, 0.005312538240104914 ]
<p>In standard 3+1 dimensional spacetime, the metric tensor is of order 4 and had ten independent coefficients, hence there are 6 terms off the diagonal in the corresponding $4\times 4$ real symmetric matrix. On the other hand, superstring theory postulates that there are 6 additional spatial dimensions that have to be compactified in a Calabi-yau manifold. My question is thus: are these two facts somehow related or is it just mere coincidence? For example, would the observable dimensions correspond to eigenvalues of the metric tensor? </p>
g5861
[ 0.0293594803661108, 0.06711648404598236, -0.013550805859267712, -0.04120822995901108, -0.027229633182287216, 0.05634528771042824, 0.03373149409890175, 0.034854378551244736, -0.06127544119954109, -0.040966931730508804, -0.040084514766931534, -0.062917560338974, 0.0696789026260376, -0.02803710103034973, 0.017309365794062614, -0.027930116280913353, 0.03192419558763504, 0.011759587563574314, -0.02397996187210083, -0.05240222439169884, -0.04386482015252113, 0.004519538022577763, -0.004085057880729437, -0.01897052489221096, 0.03035210631787777, -0.021629486232995987, 0.03720182925462723, -0.01748085767030716, -0.03994673117995262, -0.007932184264063835, 0.05983801931142807, -0.024472590535879135, -0.001163422828540206, -0.00891457125544548, -0.01881277561187744, 0.0029395257588475943, 0.06305226683616638, 0.031295277178287506, 0.028727009892463684, -0.02031904272735119, 0.0012999407481402159, -0.06994523853063583, 0.04533116891980171, -0.006369235459715128, 0.02964334562420845, 0.026545006781816483, -0.03577745705842972, -0.0025413520634174347, 0.04208941385149956, -0.007759014144539833, 0.010709390975534916, 0.053374890238046646, 0.03830353170633316, -0.04775666818022728, 0.01060149073600769, 0.07277751713991165, 0.03761305660009384, -0.012481926009058952, 0.00438438868150115, 0.037960607558488846, -0.00010534770990489051, -0.009927300736308098, 0.0023472257889807224, 0.04213957116007805, 0.07270617038011551, -0.030272377654910088, 0.005049881990998983, 0.010829080827534199, 0.0003646690456662327, -0.021221060305833817, 0.049761272966861725, -0.045493245124816895, 0.06291354447603226, -0.0027560649905353785, -0.007652472238987684, 0.058358535170555115, 0.029625242576003075, -0.010813086293637753, -0.04486003890633583, 0.012523289769887924, 0.0156217310577631, 0.012430701404809952, 0.025082075968384743, 0.002421000739559531, 0.07578578591346741, -0.04757468029856682, 0.009531588293612003, 0.04085921496152878, 0.030720099806785583, 0.05677396059036255, 0.007251032628118992, 0.024778258055448532, 0.0034015194978564978, 0.0633653774857521, 0.021629128605127335, 0.0007560357335023582, 0.04835740849375725, 0.062211327254772186, -0.0314655564725399, -0.05973345786333084, 0.009636042639613152, 0.06223207339644432, 0.013164729811251163, -0.01642126590013504, 0.019376114010810852, -0.05265607312321663, 0.021433150395751, -0.010683689266443253, 0.03729631379246712, -0.040096648037433624, -0.0705595463514328, 0.03456229344010353, -0.07888631522655487, -0.009900483302772045, -0.012782287783920765, 0.03746972605586052, 0.04063427075743675, -0.04831983894109726, -0.00850073155015707, 0.020644554868340492, -0.0028191017918288708, -0.014890084974467754, 0.02305830642580986, 0.05247519537806511, -0.006946058012545109, 0.03491663560271263, 0.030712924897670746, 0.059032779186964035, 0.017297791317105293, 0.0066529386676847935, -0.04931764304637909, -0.002683644648641348, 0.013981536962091923, 0.021288417279720306, -0.015268363989889622, 0.0045644789934158325, -0.0024355652276426554, 0.018265100196003914, -0.0608380064368248, 0.011519765481352806, -0.03508343920111656, -0.009892323985695839, -0.009736677631735802, 0.005589307751506567, 0.000031223491532728076, -0.010248284786939621, -0.04024045914411545, -0.074322909116745, -0.03333873674273491, -0.010792596265673637, 0.05493205413222313, 0.07951906323432922, -0.03353030979633331, -0.026878053322434425, -0.013572721742093563, 0.02102842926979065, 0.003742857137694955, -0.05908533185720444, 0.051084838807582855, -0.04517548158764839, -0.016301730647683144, -0.04195733740925789, 0.053493935614824295, 0.04609588533639908, -0.053467947989702225, -0.017579078674316406, 0.04980199784040451, -0.02733621746301651, -0.029694829136133194, -0.004325926303863525, -0.04081425443291664, 0.018103521317243576, 0.017419766634702682, 0.02634461224079132, -0.0265413299202919, 0.041541893035173416, -0.05309049040079117, -0.020495379343628883, 0.006932643707841635, 0.002578224055469036, -0.01784737966954708, 0.024646935984492302, -0.021794527769088745, -0.08629626780748367, 0.026147225871682167, -0.006231037434190512, -0.02201475389301777, 0.015595328994095325, -0.0394592359662056, 0.011922182515263557, -0.01665014959871769, 0.01685674674808979, 0.018143782392144203, 0.0596294067800045, 0.04404423385858536, -0.010154934599995613, -0.0037528176326304674, 0.005687447730451822, -0.017228566110134125, 0.04732508212327957, -0.021923338994383812, 0.048898715525865555, 0.029324335977435112, -0.026553897187113762, 0.0009296810021623969, 0.02552000992000103, -0.05799475684762001, 0.023844964802265167, 0.036633022129535675, -0.004119532648473978, 0.0012051257072016597, -0.00800492987036705, 0.022217901423573494, -0.001999217551201582, -0.025444865226745605, 0.007000635843724012, 0.06967835873365402, -0.015661893412470818, 0.008896457962691784, 0.035889673978090286, 0.022552747279405594, 0.0037451027892529964, 0.02739570662379265, -0.020764628425240517, -0.060885895043611526, -0.04030163586139679, -0.07982515543699265, 0.004805546719580889, 0.02451193518936634, -0.04360000789165497, -0.0728747695684433, -0.014032603241503239, 0.051524028182029724, 0.036526307463645935, 0.029407991096377373, 0.05333346873521805, -0.019820349290966988, -0.02124807797372341, 0.040873169898986816, 0.051425691694021225, 0.07702414691448212, 0.021886644884943962, -0.019807353615760803, 0.026653213426470757, 0.034663666039705276, 0.015510301105678082, 0.002585003850981593, -0.044921960681676865, -0.04382210224866867, 0.014479679986834526, -0.05693604424595833, 0.021550558507442474, 0.009448421187698841, 0.014414123259484768, 0.0037119658663868904, -0.01859498769044876, 0.009137180633842945, -0.03150801360607147, -0.08083187788724899, -0.006332668010145426, -0.05124160274863243, -0.006000171415507793, 0.013287527486681938, -0.0008638600702397525, -0.034680742770433426, 0.013552648946642876, 0.020341502502560616, 0.03962750732898712, -0.0306252334266901, -0.03226866200566292, 0.02921336516737938, 0.03669026866555214, 0.044678740203380585, 0.0035210701171308756, -0.07054588198661804, 0.028096066787838936, -0.004809940699487925, 0.005717137362807989, -0.02781338430941105, -0.0031414655968546867, -0.08994868397712708, 0.06068730354309082, -0.10492366552352905, -0.029020609334111214, 0.07157310098409653, -0.03255992755293846, -0.009443141520023346, 0.009786631911993027, -0.0009169222321361303, 0.04325634241104126, -0.008454384282231331, 0.03533121943473816, 0.016260357573628426, 0.009039570577442646, 0.005566755309700966, 0.048141565173864365, -0.011145989410579205, -0.014752736315131187, -0.018218673765659332, 0.07300539314746857, 0.0258010383695364, 0.016291391104459763, 0.045274216681718826, -0.036214325577020645, -0.01892913319170475, -0.01754411868751049, -0.0384814590215683, -0.01776857301592827, 0.006790073588490486, -0.0468270368874073, -0.04712178558111191, 0.021097509190440178, 0.008271698839962482, -0.007775865960866213, -0.024695441126823425, -0.07400954514741898, 0.00025873881531879306, 0.009483679197728634, -0.0395551361143589, 0.0021254210732877254, -0.03445430099964142, 0.010688737034797668, 0.019391369074583054, 0.01376907154917717, 0.025808049365878105, 0.019708113744854927, -0.07938947528600693, 0.0187064278870821, 0.0013972551096230745, 0.034068189561367035, -0.06267620623111725, -0.03051569312810898, -0.04562878608703613, 0.06089480221271515, -0.08721639961004257, 0.0064567807130515575, -0.022153576835989952, -0.012807811610400677, 0.011348098516464233, 0.012392546981573105, -0.02288052812218666, -0.0024842077400535345, -0.04977799579501152, -0.04121238738298416, 0.016715332865715027, 0.04149441048502922, -0.025625456124544144, 0.005065407138317823, 0.019589589908719063, 0.04896959289908409, -0.01659322716295719, 0.05955139175057411, 0.03038010746240616, 0.013256208039820194, 0.02651781029999256, 0.0770573765039444, 0.037732549011707306, 0.11237580329179764, -0.011591311544179916, -0.012460261583328247, 0.04208436980843544, 0.03006783314049244, -0.007894488051533699, -0.05411302670836449, -0.031443867832422256, 0.03416530415415764, 0.024813750758767128, -0.018810199573636055, 0.01763193868100643, 0.0441669337451458, 0.03780399262905121, -0.04589752480387688, -0.04896441474556923, -0.045625995844602585, 0.04760827496647835, -0.01869969815015793, 0.010898442007601261, -0.025279803201556206, 0.01059567742049694, 0.004345467779785395, 0.03703244775533676, 0.0001331676758127287, 0.0013106366386637092, -0.026650987565517426, -0.003136394312605262, -0.014917469583451748, -0.02672176994383335, -0.016281934455037117, -0.05232992768287659, -0.061955712735652924, -0.027164200320839882, -0.020741412416100502, -0.046194180846214294, -0.0819363221526146, 0.0074171884916722775, -0.006745444145053625, 0.025244761258363724, 0.008902088738977909, -0.0573846735060215, -0.024706343188881874, 0.017663482576608658, 0.02663954719901085, 0.04174378886818886, -0.024085896089673042, -0.05120997130870819, -0.005598483607172966, 0.05836295709013939, 0.005896446295082569, 0.03826166316866875, 0.031538225710392, -0.028638044372200966, -0.00821513682603836, -0.040634702891111374, -0.10397471487522125, 0.0961814895272255, 0.037203349173069, -0.03201974928379059, -0.0424954779446125, 0.016921933740377426, 0.0006449733045883477, 0.04530193284153938, 0.0328223779797554, 0.004074125085026026, 0.030928391963243484, 0.05270637199282646, 0.08648162335157394, 0.07423601299524307, 0.0006180402124300599, -0.08664960414171219, 0.005020551383495331, 0.05112716183066368, -0.008118513971567154, 0.01170441135764122, 0.030647186562418938, -0.04169270396232605, -0.0233905091881752, -0.06057993322610855, 0.043489452451467514, -0.021618295460939407, -0.02498459629714489, 0.038202546536922455, 0.07740111649036407, 0.018736593425273895, -0.08141418546438217, 0.01630263216793537, -0.00397505285218358, -0.025159567594528198, -0.03620966151356697, -0.006068418733775616, 0.02423252910375595, -0.019956961274147034, 0.05118856579065323, -0.02390167862176895, -0.04135241359472275, 0.006964193191379309, 0.031447771936655045, -0.01107841357588768, 0.010737396776676178, 0.034087106585502625, 0.006241817958652973, -0.020236238837242126, -0.035867951810359955, -0.007134921848773956, 0.02357889711856842, 0.0031432670075446367, -0.029750347137451172, -0.03324234485626221, 0.012568291276693344, -0.057577814906835556, 0.0004959592479281127, 0.028402190655469894, 0.001005198573693633, -0.041712939739227295, -0.04827903211116791, 0.0027868212200701237, 0.027717245742678642, -0.07568427175283432, 0.00035418375045992434, -0.022749416530132294, -0.001629392383620143, 0.02558095008134842, -0.02840765379369259, 0.01570957340300083, -0.007922878488898277, -0.00534573569893837, 0.028283122926950455, -0.010349379852414131, -0.0820315033197403, -0.0941188856959343, -0.03496598079800606, -0.06705993413925171, -0.026140298694372177, 0.020629437640309334, 0.03546474874019623, -0.03189389780163765, 0.00435100169852376, 0.00044136837823316455, -0.056255318224430084, -0.03320436552166939, 0.015259877778589725, -0.021193532273173332, 0.004039965569972992, 0.020945340394973755, -0.01433185301721096, -0.004248916637152433, 0.03578634187579155, 0.08923107385635376, 0.010586480610072613, -0.030461130663752556, 0.03023366443812847, 0.00612164381891489, 0.03976878896355629, -0.05630356818437576, -0.01662992686033249, 0.007411453872919083, -0.04284828528761864, -0.001539887860417366, 0.03945251181721687, 0.039799828082323074, 0.00005969347330392338, -0.02466820739209652, 0.0030583094339817762, 0.015220380388200283, -0.029692167416214943, -0.0017118548275902867, 0.06746118515729904, -0.012672950513660908, 0.020381884649395943, 0.04658746346831322, -0.015039042569696903, 0.04292627424001694, 0.02332979068160057, 0.041155435144901276, 0.023925989866256714, 0.05368969216942787, -0.0355834998190403, 0.027526212856173515, -0.012605449184775352, 0.05506288632750511, 0.033781345933675766, -0.023082692176103592, -0.026787925511598587, -0.03885911777615547, 0.026377543807029724, 0.0035324236378073692, -0.0011113766813650727, -0.0005345635581761599, 0.02556084655225277, 0.00938140507787466, -0.04207732155919075, -0.08519952744245529, 0.026467345654964447, -0.049875810742378235, 0.010821167379617691, -0.020183071494102478, -0.00833902321755886, -0.039624691009521484, -0.0575728602707386, -0.03943813592195511, 0.005771148018538952, 0.05923689529299736, 0.037986233830451965, 0.023423675447702408, -0.005356939043849707, -0.04366125166416168, -0.01967546157538891, 0.061793096363544464, -0.007483967579901218, 0.06280312687158585, -0.004822643008083105, -0.022844694554805756, 0.03871889412403107, 0.03976258262991905, 0.004544900730252266, 0.011304139159619808, -0.004395756870508194, 0.02272084541618824, -0.03184480592608452, -0.017979696393013, 0.03827067092061043, -0.006004791706800461, 0.0037973937578499317, 0.06398462504148483, -0.05916330963373184, 0.014709476381540298, 0.01645437441766262, -0.04334153234958649, -0.047689396888017654, 0.0124838100746274, 0.02681269310414791, -0.005406427197158337, -0.022006310522556305, -0.004114153794944286, 0.015221026726067066, -0.0006382225546985865, 0.023088524118065834, -0.02289002016186714, 0.055478595197200775, -0.08110459893941879, 0.00059144152328372, 0.042432572692632675, 0.011794613674283028, 0.08153679966926575, 0.02602834440767765, -0.013054216280579567, 0.037876855581998825, -0.01750234141945839, -0.015196388587355614, -0.03426067531108856, 0.05704706907272339, 0.048440661281347275, 0.027806062251329422, 0.039297815412282944, 0.05632125586271286, -0.0008325614035129547, -0.04708443582057953, 0.05869966000318527, -0.004161142278462648, 0.040224120020866394, 0.01741676591336727, 0.12028554826974869, 0.016621261835098267, -0.02387746423482895, -0.01606297306716442, -0.020773332566022873, 0.021213874220848083, 0.00785032007843256, -0.0470641553401947, -0.0006584194488823414, 0.027398787438869476, -0.022382166236639023, -0.03910144791007042, 0.029672401025891304, 0.03375333175063133, 0.011527951806783676, 0.003566770814359188, -0.057321760803461075, 0.0263129360973835, 0.010402393527328968, -0.02260829508304596, -0.0032590567134320736, -0.05087757483124733, 0.052819523960351944, -0.06675484031438828, 0.005933433771133423, 0.04540282115340233, 0.060554344207048416, 0.007015591487288475, -0.08542206138372421, 0.008078346960246563, 0.015586931258440018, 0.003912134096026421, -0.035094261169433594, 0.008410888724029064, -0.05957553908228874, -0.04810495674610138, -0.06342775374650955, 0.0017142888391390443, 0.031846970319747925, -0.027982179075479507, -0.0029328956734389067, 0.007985386997461319, -0.01970895379781723, -0.029838431626558304, -0.04638822004199028, 0.0510074608027935, 0.048372089862823486, -0.03826890140771866, 0.01986674778163433, 0.018948549404740334, -0.018303463235497475, -0.010108069516718388, -0.013896100223064423, -0.013543516397476196, 0.02821272239089012, 0.01827225647866726, -0.019328052178025246, 0.0002782217343337834, 0.0019579005893319845, 0.025396281853318214, 0.03815414756536484, 0.05162977799773216, -0.014697514474391937, 0.03146060183644295, -0.03347237780690193, 0.061709802597761154, 0.031720105558633804, -0.040116891264915466, -0.012096145190298557, -0.0012956294231116772, 0.06326717883348465, -0.03566928207874298, -0.028840498998761177, 0.008418699726462364, 0.022294389083981514, -0.017483700066804886, 0.031736329197883606, 0.010804075747728348, -0.05224144086241722, 0.015959439799189568, -0.007824531756341457, 0.008964399807155132, -0.0406336709856987, -0.009116047993302345, 0.017695553600788116, -0.005528385750949383, -0.030826760455965996, -0.04004335403442383, -0.05019969865679741, 0.004316831938922405, 0.016253266483545303, -0.00018896696565207094, -0.013192296028137207, 0.021194491535425186, -0.007592950481921434, 0.017874600365757942, -0.04571561887860298, -0.023154407739639282, 0.04766364023089409, -0.05822965130209923, -0.023487061262130737, -0.029854485765099525, 0.0015811106422916055, -0.05455857887864113, -0.0726156011223793, 0.0004773842229042202, 0.00888137798756361, -0.02618967369198799, 0.022168846800923347, 0.004113704897463322, -0.07232767343521118, 0.04790186136960983, -0.018807271495461464, -0.00336864753626287, 0.0020061498507857323, 0.024997778236865997, -0.016519905999302864, 0.005586178973317146, -0.035611342638731, -0.01983642391860485, 0.006114006973803043, -0.03733905777335167, -0.035890765488147736, 0.01365269161760807, -0.0370781384408474, -0.0011995236855000257, -0.03855101764202118, 0.003622882068157196, -0.03539818897843361, -0.09694065153598785, 0.007564553525298834, 0.007269217167049646, 0.002892008051276207, 0.0318496972322464, 0.056848324835300446, -0.002675381489098072, 0.03787864372134209, -0.019500574097037315, 0.004908743780106306, -0.023882891982793808, 0.02985786274075508, -0.015540208667516708, -0.03585997223854065, -0.023211726918816566, 0.006790598388761282, -0.012260673567652702, -0.0053452192805707455, 0.04966216906905174 ]
<p>According to $F = ma$, force is a result of acceleration and mass, right? </p> <p>However, I don't understand why velocity is not used instead of acceleration. A train moving at 100 miles/hour will still impart a great force on you even though it has no acceleration. Further, dropping a book at 10ft will impart a greater force on the gorund than dropping it at 1ft. So it seems that velocity would influence the force more than the acceleration would.</p> <p>Why is this not the case?</p>
g5862
[ 0.03573852404952049, 0.07201887667179108, 0.009383417665958405, 0.02773364633321762, 0.04616371542215347, 0.045887552201747894, 0.05295950919389725, 0.06800549477338791, -0.10217883437871933, -0.055723343044519424, 0.04916078969836235, -0.09060453623533249, 0.01576162502169609, 0.018331918865442276, -0.0029622777365148067, 0.03928331658244133, 0.04797545447945595, -0.011133636347949505, 0.038267143070697784, 0.019359152764081955, -0.031420059502124786, 0.036694929003715515, -0.036495838314294815, -0.0041201491840183735, -0.003623168682679534, 0.049680136144161224, 0.013535001315176487, -0.04961901903152466, -0.06608735769987106, -0.015008142217993736, 0.028826158493757248, 0.010504232719540596, 0.006517122499644756, -0.044161975383758545, -0.028238654136657715, -0.04934602230787277, 0.00752684473991394, -0.0022522134240716696, 0.027171075344085693, -0.025221215561032295, -0.006538850720971823, -0.06012320891022682, -0.011193027719855309, -0.013661602512001991, 0.018189363181591034, -0.0061407312750816345, -0.037041373550891876, -0.032680727541446686, -0.025756483897566795, -0.014358501881361008, -0.0346011221408844, 0.0043988339602947235, 0.02011231705546379, -0.005586425773799419, 0.016367044299840927, 0.038429100066423416, -0.028780505061149597, -0.005063221789896488, -0.025316854938864708, -0.014791907742619514, -0.02227403223514557, -0.050561826676130295, 0.017456332221627235, -0.06927166879177094, 0.05572093650698662, -0.01578235812485218, -0.025357123464345932, 0.02257111854851246, 0.020922238007187843, 0.004306569695472717, 0.039088353514671326, -0.01951664313673973, -0.04067431017756462, -0.00371322943829, -0.015165439806878567, -0.003944810014218092, -0.01273832842707634, -0.009071707725524902, -0.024057602509856224, 0.04420348256826401, -0.024028277024626732, -0.009295753203332424, 0.031765978783369064, 0.05909167230129242, 0.05399921536445618, -0.02602999471127987, -0.00488101365044713, 0.020984208211302757, 0.045842450112104416, 0.022946195676922798, 0.020762061700224876, -0.03318115696310997, 0.07079954445362091, 0.027890074998140335, -0.019783461466431618, -0.072293721139431, 0.00013964762911200523, 0.02479940466582775, 0.08422146737575531, 0.013999409042298794, -0.010171032510697842, 0.002699239645153284, 0.022661250084638596, 0.03025154583156109, 0.05448384955525398, -0.055367328226566315, 0.006255604792386293, 0.0630415603518486, -0.04359852522611618, -0.031491588801145554, 0.012323972769081593, -0.044596750289201736, -0.04006180539727211, -0.036850251257419586, -0.018007146194577217, -0.036476824432611465, 0.03368781507015228, 0.02429494820535183, -0.008519538678228855, 0.016296667978167534, -0.025433514267206192, 0.021655406802892685, -0.015697453171014786, 0.030196763575077057, -0.05164581164717674, -0.053278978914022446, 0.01866143010556698, -0.0036967864725738764, 0.007641243282705545, -0.03571661561727524, 0.002464671852067113, 0.029511354863643646, 0.020045846700668335, -0.014079672284424305, -0.0174651388078928, 0.02834509126842022, -0.04374045133590698, -0.02384060062468052, -0.012350235134363174, 0.011554713360965252, 0.0044360775500535965, 0.018847867846488953, 0.002168719656765461, -0.004445897880941629, -0.06665105372667313, 0.09197396039962769, -0.059858255088329315, 0.067681223154068, 0.07553427666425705, 0.042692042887210846, 0.009770097211003304, 0.07850154489278793, -0.01434131059795618, 0.02607947587966919, 0.023691654205322266, -0.013609318062663078, 0.07046207785606384, 0.0189311895519495, -0.01293548196554184, -0.01525123417377472, 0.08332426846027374, 0.01993962749838829, -0.002720116637647152, -0.003715741215273738, -0.05974394083023071, -0.001599763287231326, -0.0436248816549778, 0.03788258880376816, -0.005430637858808041, -0.008726129308342934, -0.054633915424346924, 0.026387955993413925, 0.06328537315130234, 0.0798431858420372, -0.034610357135534286, -0.048637475818395615, 0.06695210188627243, 0.013155452907085419, -0.023668039590120316, 0.02152630314230919, 0.0424782857298851, -0.02307373471558094, 0.025331316515803337, -0.06452973932027817, 0.009172733873128891, 0.011251144111156464, -0.04509307071566582, 0.04928375408053398, -0.0790739431977272, 0.039189357310533524, -0.007400888483971357, -0.05080818757414818, -0.01733190193772316, 0.04123855009675026, -0.06003695726394653, 0.03493732959032059, -0.029681134968996048, -0.030200323089957237, -0.030490033328533173, 0.08196953684091568, 0.009878194890916348, 0.047683823853731155, -0.005087964702397585, -0.0089363818988204, 0.02936846949160099, -0.04825594276189804, -0.014722988940775394, 0.0011376204201951623, 0.01862332597374916, -0.03518003225326538, 0.009916141629219055, 0.02740228921175003, 0.005989782512187958, 0.021060645580291748, 0.013085291720926762, -0.027695374563336372, 0.004546476528048515, 0.012964384630322456, -0.016184331849217415, 0.027062751352787018, 0.0007324257167056203, -0.0422595851123333, 0.026456313207745552, -0.02884315513074398, -0.07531479001045227, -0.03810291737318039, -0.014310810714960098, -0.07038848847150803, -0.04803626984357834, 0.012101957574486732, -0.06227130815386772, 0.031178845092654228, -0.02760949358344078, 0.04691073298454285, 0.021664995700120926, 0.026257574558258057, 0.02867729403078556, 0.00957329198718071, -0.005995338317006826, -0.007144737523049116, 0.045306310057640076, -0.04331955313682556, 0.0029229572974145412, -0.04547065123915672, -0.014884009957313538, -0.028810417279601097, -0.006833646912127733, -0.009697215631604195, 0.053511086851358414, -0.03763684630393982, 0.01110004261136055, -0.014962571673095226, -0.0013419524766504765, 0.00326915318146348, 0.04563296586275101, 0.012813643552362919, -0.08439197391271591, 0.01069791242480278, -0.06476440280675888, -0.004106962587684393, 0.0013034828007221222, 0.057942647486925125, 0.03286164253950119, 0.04474586620926857, -0.021448956802487373, 0.05983605608344078, 0.007117863744497299, 0.017713336274027824, 0.01072657573968172, 0.01477365754544735, -0.03388877585530281, 0.016139091923832893, -0.020825767889618874, 0.009085634723305702, -0.013955078087747097, -0.045995887368917465, -0.007011876441538334, -0.07170655578374863, 0.018652446568012238, -0.0012491177767515182, -0.04168929159641266, -0.02579975500702858, -0.027924194931983948, 0.017004001885652542, 0.013160578906536102, -0.060635995119810104, 0.07200096547603607, 0.011436177417635918, -0.004462653771042824, -0.07355369627475739, -0.006711144931614399, 0.06504438072443008, 0.02634582296013832, -0.02750052884221077, 0.03009866178035736, 0.050448741763830185, -0.00018193158030044287, -0.01704118214547634, -0.0642605796456337, -0.012505349703133106, 0.022009974345564842, -0.02072199620306492, 0.007103694602847099, 0.07167475670576096, -0.06440790742635727, 0.021334072574973106, 0.011756236664950848, -0.043280988931655884, -0.037408992648124695, -0.0021665904205292463, 0.01921911910176277, 0.07139313220977783, 0.05886532738804817, -0.010241333395242691, -0.06961383670568466, -0.0635988861322403, 0.012393385171890259, 0.0059660617262125015, 0.007087489124387503, 0.013384905643761158, -0.022586144506931305, -0.0582154281437397, 0.012498973868787289, -0.07289160043001175, -0.008198942057788372, 0.04710641875863075, -0.012050258927047253, 0.0360245406627655, 0.04214394465088844, 0.0032613116782158613, 0.006815014872699976, 0.0435602106153965, -0.004612836986780167, -0.01549326442182064, -0.007337804418057203, -0.023438647389411926, 0.016047310084104538, 0.012990739196538925, 0.02779385633766651, 0.0001263123849639669, -0.030403047800064087, -0.0210834052413702, -0.0242634117603302, 0.023347796872258186, 0.005577669013291597, 0.07330421358346939, 0.014874717220664024, 0.00611244747415185, 0.0006355330697260797, -0.040424894541502, 0.06834545731544495, -0.054401446133852005, 0.00855460949242115, -0.024780115112662315, -0.024436431005597115, -0.011741260066628456, 0.023486889898777008, 0.02883308380842209, -0.045932937413454056, 0.002255456754937768, 0.019039561972022057, 0.030385851860046387, -0.03051159717142582, 0.06445509195327759, 0.004190367646515369, 0.01116149127483368, -0.05656442418694496, 0.09733112156391144, -0.053533896803855896, -0.002257897052913904, 0.005385605152696371, -0.09341198205947876, 0.018291087821125984, 0.005608196370303631, 0.04598954692482948, -0.008105609565973282, 0.05658735707402229, 0.012097294442355633, 0.01609145663678646, -0.0018437542021274567, 0.10208293050527573, 0.024444034323096275, -0.03879103809595108, 0.027662238106131554, 0.02298172004520893, -0.0428890697658062, -0.0919598713517189, -0.01809457689523697, 0.01845858432352543, 0.007987837307155132, -0.0033903091680258512, -0.053641900420188904, -0.007308586500585079, 0.008711935952305794, 0.010495980270206928, -0.041891295462846756, -0.006411594804376364, -0.04735370725393295, 0.04640484228730202, 0.05037534609436989, -0.037944018840789795, 0.03382531553506851, -0.06789974868297577, 0.020859647542238235, -0.03552534803748131, 0.03420829400420189, 0.015258138068020344, -0.010980010963976383, 0.024981683120131493, -0.003408239921554923, 0.013293133117258549, -0.03516658395528793, -0.07245190441608429, -0.023172516375780106, -0.01755167357623577, -0.015214500948786736, 0.03121568262577057, 0.03887413069605827, -0.04706795886158943, 0.004628577269613743, -0.022271472960710526, 0.022357532754540443, 0.006078985519707203, -0.03168554976582527, 0.006226014345884323, 0.06056369096040726, 0.0345672182738781, -0.029940038919448853, 0.02998265065252781, 0.004429830238223076, -0.03526267036795616, 0.023307692259550095, -0.01451221015304327, 0.018211813643574715, -0.00838393997400999, 0.08926916122436523, 0.03613799437880516, 0.06330351531505585, 0.07606516778469086, 0.044745996594429016, 0.05264751985669136, 0.04254632443189621, -0.006413650698959827, 0.037271901965141296, -0.03646973893046379, 0.03470758721232414, -0.029651904478669167, -0.029617341235280037, -0.005661047529429197, -0.021941963583230972, -0.003997753374278545, -0.021411364898085594, -0.028501655906438828, -0.0027302419766783714, 0.010276124812662601, 0.02299734763801098, -0.054124847054481506, -0.02374856360256672, 0.06210232153534889, -0.00665840320289135, -0.06760814040899277, 0.03755977749824524, -0.008155770599842072, 0.04299459606409073, -0.02130560576915741, 0.0026437542401254177, 0.028369564563035965, -0.0273667611181736, -0.03267437964677811, 0.03513706102967262, 0.018604537472128868, -0.01084380317479372, -0.0068231383338570595, 0.009336773306131363, 0.10820174962282181, 0.055739667266607285, 0.03643510863184929, -0.019231479614973068, 0.019086239859461784, -0.04685355722904205, -0.026453962549567223, -0.02257770113646984, 0.05066950246691704, -0.03992130234837532, 0.012192570604383945, -0.02178753912448883, 0.005867526400834322, 0.004991231486201286, 0.012301725335419178, -0.03910073637962341, 0.03756621852517128, 0.019497327506542206, -0.0416366383433342, -0.056167520582675934, -0.012774361297488213, 0.029563356190919876, 0.06119529530405998, 0.002681303070858121, 0.00855707935988903, -0.052211422473192215, -0.08829368650913239, -0.03879145532846451, -0.02497340925037861, 0.004200765863060951, -0.017780832946300507, 0.042368099093437195, 0.06300058960914612, 0.012583744712173939, -0.010291284881532192, 0.05586237832903862, -0.024069324135780334, 0.06263241916894913, 0.027729446068406105, -0.020699894055724144, 0.023115010932087898, 0.0022846281062811613, 0.018836233764886856, -0.0029500555247068405, 0.016824418678879738, 0.04898406192660332, 0.0768628790974617, -0.03078330121934414, 0.0336068831384182, 0.006156055722385645, 0.002736583584919572, -0.006998690310865641, 0.010194866918027401, -0.017211809754371643, -0.02342177741229534, 0.018734900280833244, 0.02647232636809349, -0.023650184273719788, 0.038284771144390106, -0.014940575696527958, -0.04449980705976486, 0.017966575920581818, 0.0477614551782608, -0.026570681482553482, -0.002147007966414094, -0.01149776577949524, -0.02623574249446392, -0.01593826152384281, -0.019683727994561195, 0.07343088835477829, 0.03344438225030899, 0.027412360534071922, 0.010263204574584961, -0.0008768822299316525, 0.003817502176389098, -0.06524229049682617, -0.03478892147541046, 0.010982668027281761, -0.04743805527687073, -0.028924623504281044, -0.03336871415376663, 0.045757412910461426, 0.0011408055434003472, -0.026571044698357582, -0.025136571377515793, -0.017001193016767502, 0.012643260881304741, -0.010983501560986042, 0.061370376497507095, 0.046374544501304626, 0.06577205657958984, 0.0021000909619033337, 0.03207087516784668, 0.038108523935079575, 0.012588701210916042, -0.025217581540346146, 0.0003542727208696306, 0.03294124826788902, -0.056556638330221176, -0.02561883069574833, 0.0461701937019825, -0.00006898071296745911, -0.02045130543410778, -0.022310571745038033, -0.04210861772298813, -0.01105584017932415, 0.008976171724498272, -0.04102242738008499, 0.0056384350173175335, -0.054046884179115295, -0.0081308763474226, -0.0801132544875145, -0.034481629729270935, 0.014680306427180767, 0.06997382640838623, -0.014644546434283257, -0.014560525305569172, -0.017130590975284576, 0.026680869981646538, -0.026104122400283813, -0.07015521824359894, -0.02632446400821209, -0.019736913964152336, 0.013176986016333103, 0.014534439891576767, -0.052237845957279205, -0.010430415160953999, 0.0596776083111763, 0.029660923406481743, -0.01794327050447464, 0.040067803114652634, 0.0033139451406896114, 0.0005482621490955353, -0.03191349282860756, -0.008283300325274467, 0.04678730294108391, -0.056949809193611145, 0.07257580012083054, -0.023841485381126404, 0.039480626583099365, -0.01994585618376732, 0.0186307430267334, -0.025440387427806854, -0.024095918983221054, -0.029868323355913162, -0.02599962428212166, -0.006875905208289623, -0.024836700409650803, 0.05527826398611069, -0.0385686419904232, 0.012718325480818748, 0.004381144884973764, -0.06369683146476746, 0.07928398996591568, 0.04852868989109993, -0.03992966189980507, -0.03171701729297638, -0.022695226594805717, -0.06738670915365219, 0.01717422716319561, -0.026413602754473686, 0.05009522661566734, 0.05233116075396538, 0.006004533730447292, 0.025255247950553894, 0.033311355859041214, -0.02380681410431862, 0.004858018830418587, -0.04043658822774887, -0.005358390975743532, -0.056501541286706924, -0.0005057610687799752, 0.012753255665302277, 0.03098110668361187, -0.0121077261865139, -0.008893059566617012, -0.023212291300296783, -0.016454605385661125, -0.011784878559410572, 0.04096189886331558, -0.021170107647776604, 0.014398226514458656, -0.018843691796064377, 0.018022848293185234, -0.012697439640760422, -0.005433541722595692, -0.03896349295973778, -0.045268505811691284, 0.05138169601559639, 0.022806238383054733, 0.02176501974463463, 0.05981955677270889, -0.03585239499807358, -0.029394907876849174, 0.030114637687802315, 0.032304272055625916, 0.025527816265821457, -0.016491543501615524, -0.008278359659016132, 0.0012887055054306984, 0.027782727032899857, 0.01467737928032875, -0.06391974538564682, -0.027740608900785446, 0.010178758762776852, -0.030645007267594337, -0.01858632266521454, 0.0532945916056633, 0.01680838130414486, -0.015928840264678, -0.00047684760647825897, 0.00808752328157425, -0.03138069808483124, 0.03541429713368416, 0.05019739642739296, -0.07240281999111176, 0.017358552664518356, 0.01963821053504944, 0.009743470698595047, 0.017035895958542824, -0.04597719386219978, -0.03425117954611778, 0.008609534241259098, 0.015835992991924286, -0.013176098465919495, 0.004886164329946041, 0.022715918719768524, -0.057146716862916946, -0.032428864389657974, 0.03215157985687256, 0.0046667722053825855, 0.043063245713710785, -0.003718702821061015, 0.037482522428035736, -0.03585831820964813, -0.01580706425011158, -0.008158319629728794, 0.0012226940598338842, 0.03335973620414734, 0.0141456825658679, 0.04086609184741974, 0.005145756062120199, 0.05369586497545242, 0.04972578212618828, 0.0011885155690833926, -0.034684278070926666, 0.03147849813103676, -0.03511873632669449, 0.043031640350818634, -0.0543123260140419, -0.04993696138262749, -0.0360683910548687, 0.011299223639070988, -0.013601768761873245, -0.06213270127773285, -0.002480930183082819, -0.005212067160755396, -0.04227505996823311, 0.014314099214971066, -0.02617736905813217, -0.054459795355796814, -0.016685960814356804, 0.08032724261283875, 0.003535311436280608, -0.03889748081564903, 0.02256898209452629, 0.0007222256972454488, -0.015161161310970783, -0.021562451496720314, 0.0366421714425087, 0.008134950883686543, -0.06752634048461914, -0.040121641010046005, 0.04900534451007843, 0.007449976168572903, 0.006102508399635553, 0.045763179659843445, -0.009866900742053986, -0.08893679827451706, -0.03954840078949928, -0.03286381810903549, -0.010738419368863106, 0.011665903963148594, -0.0030847296584397554, 0.007837319746613503, -0.029181553050875664, 0.01116771437227726, -0.003929218277335167, 0.025856181979179382, -0.06576050072908401, 0.0019387461943551898, -0.019905133172869682, -0.010548064485192299, -0.04075790196657181 ]
<p>This questions stems from Axiomatic Quantum Field Theory and is mathematical in nature. However, I feel that an answer from physicists is more in line with what I will be asking. </p> <p>Let $\phi$ be a real quantum field, namely $\phi$ is an operator-valued distribution. One of the requirements of $\phi$ is that it is <em>local</em>. </p> <p>In case $f\in C{^\infty _0 }_{real}$, then the assumption of locality requires that $$\phi(f)\phi(g)=\phi(g)\phi(f)$$ when the supports of f and g cannot be connected by a light ray. One says that such supports are <em>space-like separated</em>.</p> <p><strong>Reference</strong>: Page 7 <a href="http://www.arthurjaffe.com/Assets/pdf/Quantum-Theory_Relativity.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.arthurjaffe.com/Assets/pdf/Quantum-Theory_Relativity.pdf</a> </p> <p>I'd like to gather further insight into this statement. Namely, how does one picture the supports? Should I have light cones in mind? </p>
g5863
[ 0.021660609170794487, 0.0661957859992981, -0.006987373810261488, -0.09828664362430573, 0.03694793954491615, 0.012983152642846107, 0.0003512258408591151, 0.034010883420705795, 0.04807184636592865, -0.002384690335020423, -0.006840042304247618, -0.0009968995582312346, -0.010863437317311764, -0.03428664058446884, 0.007883313111960888, -0.039680544286966324, 0.04265490546822548, 0.0007889401749707758, 0.0573873445391655, -0.019953353330492973, -0.05824548006057739, 0.013467554934322834, -0.006970797665417194, -0.05823105573654175, 0.05218084901571274, -0.013210511766374111, 0.029669329524040222, -0.051506783813238144, -0.0025740363635122776, -0.02098461613059044, 0.026161925867199898, 0.005862487480044365, 0.07198411226272583, -0.08334525674581528, -0.027376899495720863, -0.01375820767134428, 0.030626071617007256, 0.04339594766497612, 0.003970074467360973, -0.00012480319128371775, 0.0238801296800375, -0.0191499013453722, -0.029649410396814346, -0.06673362851142883, -0.023415159434080124, 0.025435522198677063, -0.045154422521591187, 0.07048512250185013, -0.01863938942551613, -0.007712068036198616, -0.01732201874256134, 0.069268599152565, 0.03246255964040756, 0.027095479890704155, 0.0681542307138443, 0.05154837295413017, 0.03743575140833855, -0.004813631996512413, 0.03536964952945709, -0.004053804092109203, -0.008232535794377327, 0.01697482354938984, 0.0101351048797369, 0.018298152834177017, 0.04450123757123947, 0.03493193909525871, -0.051326967775821686, -0.011864679865539074, -0.02196836844086647, 0.020591631531715393, -0.05837908014655113, -0.026454534381628036, 0.0017062060069292784, 0.0028604622930288315, -0.04299719259142876, 0.001154392259195447, -0.0291804987937212, 0.0291519146412611, -0.024195116013288498, 0.0577998012304306, -0.005738747771829367, -0.016408126801252365, 0.03217073902487755, -0.008850688114762306, 0.020921478047966957, 0.039568010717630386, 0.04649979993700981, -0.0339813306927681, 0.016966070979833603, 0.02336762472987175, 0.01807907223701477, -0.020561592653393745, 0.07089026272296906, 0.04435662180185318, -0.0128257367759943, -0.0005831302260048687, -0.04537978768348694, 0.004941641818732023, -0.09422232955694199, -0.01326984353363514, -0.002608379814773798, -0.013168559409677982, 0.018053779378533363, -0.009096493013203144, -0.01995105855166912, 0.0005274616996757686, 0.025464529171586037, 0.05142419785261154, 0.018703389912843704, 0.050599634647369385, -0.0532827153801918, 0.006127977278083563, -0.04473033919930458, -0.09723743796348572, -0.054346080869436264, -0.055423203855752945, 0.07705716788768768, -0.0601312480866909, -0.03214721009135246, 0.04399077594280243, 0.024323951452970505, 0.03144704923033714, 0.046853404492139816, 0.09807692468166351, -0.008796926587820053, 0.012713913805782795, 0.01689254306256771, -0.024860402569174767, 0.043787647038698196, -0.020926237106323242, 0.027975216507911682, -0.0449560172855854, 0.04975549131631851, 0.027040846645832062, -0.05075731500983238, 0.018422530964016914, 0.005345066078007221, 0.00952854286879301, 0.00444839708507061, -0.02643515355885029, 0.007250017952173948, -0.016642984002828598, 0.028926173225045204, -0.03356100246310234, 0.0021685597021132708, -0.05537472292780876, 0.003798421937972307, -0.022884517908096313, 0.06698645651340485, 0.05251967906951904, -0.010008774697780609, 0.06730663031339645, -0.08107567578554153, 0.01026572473347187, -0.0013814914273098111, -0.024014592170715332, 0.07192082703113556, -0.011704408563673496, -0.0014717085286974907, -0.029874073341488838, 0.060199640691280365, 0.04463351517915726, 0.01965634524822235, -0.008293240331113338, -0.02347305603325367, -0.022193819284439087, 0.035411860793828964, -0.06366986036300659, -0.0005480166873894632, -0.09334231913089752, 0.040718112140893936, -0.020691143348813057, 0.011089331470429897, 0.018272845074534416, -0.018882952630519867, 0.005666361656039953, -0.008371025323867798, 0.010249664075672626, 0.02774403616786003, 0.045208368450403214, -0.012073853984475136, 0.013026115484535694, -0.008605381473898888, -0.07349605113267899, 0.004531567916274071, -0.004217371344566345, -0.05289888381958008, 0.0011887883301824331, -0.03539697453379631, -0.0052055357955396175, -0.03321365267038345, -0.007582873106002808, 0.0317644327878952, 0.049590956419706345, -0.019903231412172318, 0.01254766434431076, 0.020291633903980255, -0.05590931698679924, 0.02113179862499237, 0.008154239505529404, 0.012779626995325089, 0.04947465658187866, -0.0036772838793694973, 0.04286689683794975, 0.03920384496450424, -0.00375070096924901, -0.042631447315216064, -0.039067503064870834, 0.003144265851005912, 0.006897417828440666, 0.034705523401498795, -0.10143233090639114, 0.02221023663878441, 0.02269921638071537, -0.006633201614022255, -0.04650472104549408, -0.0069879223592579365, 0.03239356726408005, -0.021660039201378822, 0.046001091599464417, -0.06260406970977783, 0.006146969739347696, 0.053615182638168335, -0.04947410523891449, 0.0070571331307291985, -0.04411768540740013, -0.005655317567288876, 0.009642279706895351, -0.011308347806334496, 0.05197768658399582, -0.05818009749054909, -0.004577786196023226, -0.015836579725146294, 0.049968209117650986, 0.038913942873477936, 0.009749760851264, -0.027756700292229652, 0.04445136338472366, -0.00022149890719447285, 0.021155506372451782, 0.01837606355547905, 0.009231101721525192, -0.018383000046014786, -0.029890762642025948, 0.021319357678294182, 0.006884175352752209, 0.040252685546875, -0.0005892846384085715, -0.02676493674516678, 0.005800851155072451, 0.014070367440581322, 0.03420253470540047, 0.010170594789087772, 0.024579640477895737, 0.020964328199625015, -0.03296361863613129, 0.055479876697063446, 0.015344145707786083, -0.032460711896419525, -0.015364089049398899, -0.0249384343624115, -0.030577898025512695, 0.004585801158100367, -0.0025024949572980404, -0.018000027164816856, 0.024954892694950104, 0.02651664800941944, 0.04441189393401146, 0.044827356934547424, -0.030117737129330635, -0.016760528087615967, 0.0771985799074173, 0.0051212068647146225, 0.05782699957489967, 0.04997069016098976, -0.056373417377471924, -0.051303666085004807, -0.01020151749253273, -0.03791924938559532, 0.013034711591899395, 0.025141846388578415, -0.025818482041358948, -0.012968197464942932, -0.04406973719596863, -0.0030225920490920544, -0.05135191231966019, 0.0359598845243454, 0.017837928608059883, 0.08980202674865723, -0.011321869678795338, -0.014653326943516731, 0.02707328461110592, 0.01405175682157278, 0.005003960803151131, -0.08164432644844055, 0.01391671970486641, 0.04614262282848358, -0.051736410707235336, 0.01810634694993496, 0.07150063663721085, -0.00016198708908632398, -0.01807704009115696, 0.04347618296742439, 0.009611760266125202, 0.03188245743513107, -0.012369572184979916, -0.04935162141919136, -0.034440431743860245, -0.005926338490098715, -0.018906008452177048, 0.02448548935353756, 0.011425739154219627, 0.017484107986092567, -0.0006644742679782212, 0.0031859176233410835, 0.035449251532554626, -0.013206555508077145, -0.0007933583692647517, -0.008813180029392242, -0.09378279745578766, 0.043007366359233856, -0.014413231052458286, -0.035587046295404434, 0.029239755123853683, 0.05537986755371094, 0.02501673623919487, -0.019841667264699936, 0.042800627648830414, 0.009657368063926697, -0.027412163093686104, -0.020340144634246826, -0.04235681891441345, 0.02407972142100334, -0.05273248627781868, -0.07235544919967651, -0.03405550867319107, -0.019901160150766373, 0.010780767537653446, 0.05680868774652481, -0.03490312397480011, -0.014291303232312202, 0.031067388132214546, -0.03366683050990105, -0.00008860862726578489, -0.01078424695879221, -0.003053076798096299, 0.000696251227054745, 0.03947707638144493, 0.04843350872397423, 0.009252047166228294, -0.0141917048022151, -0.04619883745908737, 0.04833564907312393, -0.01641712337732315, 0.006944967433810234, 0.0394698902964592, 0.01574474573135376, -0.001965148374438286, 0.07251732796430588, -0.0611005574464798, 0.04968476668000221, -0.012817890383303165, 0.03813493251800537, 0.04066593572497368, -0.03468839079141617, -0.01208065077662468, -0.01615608111023903, 0.0032303761690855026, 0.023896746337413788, 0.0027060694992542267, 0.037097714841365814, -0.008074197918176651, -0.02127821370959282, 0.005014846567064524, 0.024553285911679268, -0.03759745880961418, 0.022462928667664528, -0.04020075872540474, -0.0208207368850708, 0.00539561128243804, 0.04081615060567856, 0.052052244544029236, 0.007078087422996759, -0.0031713752541691065, 0.022298332303762436, 0.03628893941640854, -0.06327564269304276, -0.0057548899203538895, -0.009753771126270294, 0.015067712403833866, -0.007532874122262001, -0.06317683309316635, -0.043600473552942276, -0.01817445084452629, 0.02252015471458435, -0.005607138387858868, 0.015606211498379707, -0.0525318868458271, -0.029643775895237923, 0.014933972619473934, 0.02227393351495266, -0.0009421925060451031, 0.04149051383137703, 0.008505864068865776, -0.00589857529848814, -0.020943863317370415, -0.03245005011558533, -0.013169270008802414, 0.0004584737471304834, -0.026119520887732506, 0.051716163754463196, -0.04976721107959747, 0.0027036829851567745, -0.11298146098852158, 0.0424329899251461, 0.001060851034708321, 0.04743954911828041, -0.01926322840154171, -0.0023308240342885256, -0.032987941056489944, 0.024711893871426582, -0.007579138036817312, 0.0727367028594017, -0.002174618188291788, -0.008336546830832958, 0.08378162235021591, 0.01774393953382969, 0.01912451535463333, -0.011694035492837429, -0.04799260199069977, 0.014529882930219173, 0.034052617847919464, 0.016953427344560623, -0.011252861469984055, -0.01515206042677164, 0.028761057183146477, -0.09835944324731827, 0.0033365695271641016, -0.012042328715324402, -0.017743993550539017, 0.055222947150468826, 0.0031895379070192575, 0.05489424988627434, -0.031582143157720566, 0.0011525757145136595, 0.0009578828467056155, -0.04341791942715645, 0.03283633664250374, 0.00912459846585989, -0.007090939208865166, -0.019271323457360268, -0.0023575564846396446, 0.025269679725170135, -0.048509322106838226, 0.06029488146305084, 0.01838036999106407, -0.06667187064886093, -0.02803901955485344, 0.02655896544456482, -0.04280967637896538, 0.017580613493919373, -0.027959180995821953, -0.012334913946688175, 0.030247170478105545, 0.04122588783502579, 0.0010259713744744658, -0.12578880786895752, 0.007653345819562674, -0.035600706934928894, -0.0803178921341896, -0.005685488227754831, 0.002052599797025323, 0.035578738898038864, -0.05867848917841911, 0.018410177901387215, 0.010523210279643536, -0.007092429790645838, -0.008312278427183628, -0.024447722360491753, -0.06052596867084503, -0.01719602942466736, 0.017466383054852486, 0.004712847527116537, -0.013316280208528042, 0.009332530200481415, 0.020423268899321556, 0.005618677940219641, -0.021035654470324516, -0.01322954148054123, -0.026324987411499023, 0.020311884582042694, 0.018850522115826607, -0.026849178597331047, 0.049207720905542374, 0.006112268194556236, -0.04830120503902435, 0.001873894827440381, 0.010216880589723587, -0.0013836371945217252, -0.02966536208987236, -0.045140840113162994, 0.010432695038616657, 0.02595914900302887, -0.03072640672326088, -0.021032564342021942, 0.023956192657351494, 0.10236258059740067, -0.01587434858083725, -0.011506658978760242, 0.017210641875863075, 0.01154717430472374, -0.018747691065073013, 0.03386352211236954, 0.004025253467261791, -0.000505088537465781, -0.06723377853631973, -0.04705328121781349, 0.04667922109365463, -0.04297515004873276, -0.02685789205133915, 0.015275652520358562, 0.009310241788625717, 0.055038101971149445, -0.07377733290195465, 0.042518094182014465, -0.02057245373725891, -0.04332343861460686, -0.05845819041132927, 0.01679326966404915, -0.011713541112840176, 0.028512675315141678, 0.019118422642350197, 0.010515274479985237, -0.025527317076921463, -0.007670084945857525, -0.054359015077352524, 0.09073591232299805, 0.015373577363789082, 0.009153504855930805, -0.008965820074081421, -0.07287806272506714, -0.055440135300159454, -0.002887361217290163, 0.027654463425278664, -0.013599108904600143, 0.015466650947928429, -0.030331118032336235, 0.009770467877388, 0.05653543397784233, -0.012713211588561535, -0.0382404625415802, -0.018763843923807144, -0.0288747139275074, 0.03289841488003731, 0.05247429758310318, -0.009849593043327332, 0.03920569270849228, -0.0050825015641748905, -0.0390845462679863, -0.0028947077225893736, 0.009383125230669975, -0.01155776809900999, 0.007314598653465509, -0.0256377961486578, 0.008741548284888268, 0.0071065546944737434, 0.003209406277164817, -0.00030169179080985487, 0.02535039372742176, 0.018268592655658722, -0.03040141612291336, 0.013633116148412228, 0.01731793023645878, 0.00764466030523181, 0.022024741396307945, 0.003416512394323945, 0.04737261310219765, -0.0007753866957500577, -0.04923693835735321, 0.04483921825885773, -0.028294922783970833, 0.025216814130544662, 0.05214318633079529, -0.08201994746923447, -0.04662252217531204, 0.07810642570257187, -0.04533929005265236, -0.01869598962366581, 0.06654218584299088, -0.09309757500886917, 0.008483326993882656, -0.01784840039908886, -0.0403895266354084, 0.01693015545606613, -0.03746013715863228, 0.05298727750778198, -0.0016292217187583447, 0.024906611070036888, -0.03333096206188202, -0.00030976947164162993, 0.018082356080412865, 0.00817849114537239, 0.06255306303501129, -0.05144725739955902, 0.036702387034893036, 0.025323566049337387, -0.03735177591443062, -0.017823047935962677, -0.023648397997021675, -0.009671115316450596, 0.01528111845254898, 0.009141107089817524, 0.022027261555194855, 0.005652192980051041, 0.010534115135669708, -0.04444360360503197, -0.047997742891311646, 0.0206900704652071, -0.06020808592438698, 0.01232558861374855, 0.06130862236022949, -0.009935381822288036, -0.061940524727106094, 0.03465786576271057, 0.017246177420020103, 0.07766350358724594, -0.009973734617233276, -0.003772168653085828, 0.03797140717506409, 0.03308996558189392, 0.05223013088107109, -0.0006430719513446093, -0.017338979989290237, 0.03350967913866043, -0.0007662546122446656, 0.07656490802764893, -0.057522136718034744, -0.028003139421343803, 0.019839249551296234, 0.028675174340605736, -0.003975317347794771, 0.0712745189666748, 0.0577651672065258, -0.003838921431452036, 0.02153972163796425, -0.02071266435086727, 0.02608354203402996, -0.006146143190562725, -0.04840588942170143, -0.034929849207401276, -0.0018616801826283336, 0.015016813762485981, 0.018325651064515114, -0.0536247193813324, -0.04544839262962341, 0.015676341950893402, -0.015473763458430767, -0.022142725065350533, -0.06986548751592636, -0.09989578276872635, -0.03426478058099747, -0.03950128331780434, -0.0625266283750534, -0.0223299041390419, -0.03311916068196297, 0.03426358103752136, -0.018617114052176476, -0.03663153946399689, -0.05060557276010513, -0.010674810037016869, 0.017608975991606712, -0.03425375744700432, -0.03899145498871803, -0.011023198254406452, 0.009004793129861355, 0.0007669448386877775, -0.02864074893295765, 0.07472080737352371, 0.012472244910895824, -0.043299704790115356, -0.028018800541758537, 0.07799374312162399, -0.03863868862390518, -0.02033746987581253, -0.008345188573002815, 0.02423284575343132, -0.014328580349683762, -0.0633595734834671, 0.0409088097512722, 0.011310509406030178, 0.03598878160119057, -0.012800171039998531, 0.0038037418853491545, -0.0005054262583144009, 0.007401134353131056, 0.013290640898048878, 0.01910855993628502, 0.03058096021413803, 0.021881327033042908, -0.003200154984369874, -0.004358100239187479, 0.014508986845612526, -0.039738111197948456, -0.03785251826047897, 0.06416883319616318, -0.042119015008211136, 0.007552608847618103, -0.0409056581556797, -0.03248909115791321, 0.011347826570272446, 0.06584079563617706, 0.03626953065395355, 0.042538195848464966, -0.020905500277876854, 0.03312411904335022, 0.01479477621614933, -0.07259529083967209, 0.03911880776286125, 0.015148692764341831, -0.023152239620685577, -0.01834055781364441, 0.005980789195746183, 0.00472504086792469, -0.011450096033513546, 0.01558789610862732, 0.017755616456270218, 0.025414152070879936, -0.04079878702759743, 0.037837740033864975, 0.03766223043203354, -0.06500384211540222, -0.04335298761725426, -0.0342445969581604, 0.04113459214568138, -0.06485651433467865, -0.0037025276105850935, -0.007352023851126432, 0.010096467100083828, 0.04573643207550049, -0.043646190315485, -0.02773527428507805, -0.029786374419927597, 0.020159658044576645, 0.005678136367350817, 0.018769485875964165, 0.010295790620148182, -0.017604142427444458, 0.018329709768295288, 0.056290507316589355, 0.017741341143846512, -0.028224727138876915, 0.04851747676730156, -0.07269930839538574, 0.052651356905698776, 0.04976735636591911, -0.06512555480003357, 0.019878219813108444, -0.005901375785470009, 0.0659966692328453, 0.04164644703269005, 0.005071067251265049, -0.014550338499248028, -0.005245557054877281, -0.012120235711336136, -0.02457435429096222, -0.047541599720716476, 0.005762984976172447, 0.029108483344316483 ]
<p>It's my understanding that whenever an object gains or loses electric charge this actually corresponds to losing/gaining electrons (protons do not move). So how can a positive charge always move from higher to lower potential?</p>
g5864
[ 0.019304031506180763, -0.0045854770578444, -0.00005612515815300867, 0.06295938044786453, 0.10593683272600174, 0.05333248898386955, -0.023752745240926743, 0.02149370312690735, -0.04286785051226616, -0.0329224169254303, -0.08737310767173767, 0.02947063371539116, 0.030090002343058586, 0.005154326092451811, -0.02687765844166279, -0.03353627398610115, 0.005516445264220238, -0.01478525809943676, -0.0003337652306072414, 0.031054066494107246, 0.043078918009996414, 0.051540978252887726, 0.012237882241606712, 0.004955440293997526, -0.07004248350858688, 0.011920257471501827, 0.01419110782444477, 0.006106323562562466, 0.01747983507812023, -0.032107163220644, 0.00768409576267004, -0.010337252169847488, -0.004491166677325964, -0.019609665498137474, -0.02761143632233143, -0.05950837582349777, 0.08513055741786957, -0.02630028873682022, 0.04612953960895538, -0.006518458016216755, 0.01156244520097971, -0.033371977508068085, 0.026484770700335503, -0.0363239087164402, 0.023653702810406685, -0.014568169601261616, 0.013314622454345226, -0.02537252940237522, 0.0003055707202292979, -0.0429915189743042, -0.023111091926693916, 0.04547809436917305, -0.01281132735311985, 0.03711601346731186, 0.06896348297595978, -0.0018112105317413807, 0.007789064198732376, -0.01714222878217697, 0.018501197919249535, 0.035162024199962616, 0.039616018533706665, 0.037787679582834244, 0.054529089480638504, 0.04525558277964592, 0.05939669534564018, 0.0053995405323803425, -0.10174956917762756, -0.032996561378240585, -0.02545788697898388, 0.013648495078086853, -0.0068678585812449455, -0.019710415974259377, -0.09645545482635498, -0.01379366498440504, -0.0038104604464024305, 0.011529505252838135, 0.027804750949144363, -0.05259733274579048, 0.08240239322185516, -0.04115373268723488, -0.021264035254716873, -0.01200904231518507, 0.05164914205670357, 0.04173700138926506, 0.11115352809429169, -0.0047981091775000095, -0.0037548639811575413, 0.015175760723650455, -0.05001349747180939, -0.03384106606245041, -0.012693589553236961, 0.0029945808928459883, 0.07843929529190063, -0.0019996389746665955, -0.029541704803705215, -0.014647364616394043, -0.035043396055698395, 0.0026294405106455088, -0.0032521195244044065, -0.06114692613482475, -0.017472265288233757, -0.05754467844963074, 0.061253100633621216, 0.012977556325495243, -0.03869370371103287, 0.03237110376358032, 0.009490514174103737, -0.022608933970332146, 0.040743425488471985, 0.019056709483265877, 0.04264282435178757, -0.04322754219174385, -0.040266405791044235, -0.07335163652896881, -0.05001334473490715, 0.020418211817741394, 0.056788455694913864, -0.02642720378935337, 0.014504640363156796, -0.014053957536816597, -0.022941013798117638, 0.0639922171831131, -0.014173016883432865, 0.016519512981176376, -0.04450768604874611, -0.018935520201921463, -0.007026516366750002, -0.03670395910739899, 0.01855422370135784, 0.05272466689348221, 0.051719631999731064, 0.002744661644101143, -0.02766832895576954, 0.044275589287281036, 0.004931205417960882, 0.028544390574097633, 0.04459243267774582, -0.006967872381210327, 0.029884809628129005, -0.013101678341627121, 0.050258293747901917, -0.010295690037310123, 0.019225236028432846, -0.03176305815577507, 0.018701346591114998, 0.018506772816181183, 0.020484067499637604, 0.04008585959672928, 0.02130749076604843, -0.031233204528689384, 0.027479086071252823, 0.015902632847428322, 0.039635684341192245, -0.06406500935554504, 0.08792579919099808, -0.09829176962375641, 0.09786916524171829, 0.003106002928689122, -0.003696996485814452, 0.017327148467302322, 0.07569606602191925, -0.0043114833533763885, -0.0340765044093132, 0.02397170290350914, -0.053279809653759, -0.05381779000163078, -0.0015809187898412347, -0.017758410423994064, 0.007754813879728317, -0.021503809839487076, 0.012169050984084606, -0.0008038138621486723, 0.01904321275651455, 0.04216413572430611, 0.006026838440448046, 0.022756168618798256, -0.06321912258863449, -0.02968795970082283, 0.037400126457214355, -0.01378039550036192, -0.0674380213022232, -0.02249642089009285, 0.04123132675886154, -0.0009225474204868078, 0.026438714936375618, 0.028951827436685562, -0.05512671917676926, 0.029004080221056938, -0.0003016884147655219, -0.010909036733210087, -0.0336894765496254, -0.07034770399332047, 0.021495271474123, -0.01714765466749668, 0.005293874070048332, -0.03578457608819008, -0.014482539147138596, -0.05230582505464554, -0.015109911561012268, 0.02275736629962921, -0.03940071910619736, -0.023470135405659676, 0.0074800485745072365, -0.00965922325849533, 0.06542983651161194, -0.03661695122718811, -0.00019622025138232857, -0.04765332490205765, 0.037897609174251556, -0.012039577588438988, -0.02040375955402851, 0.007255414500832558, -0.029201680794358253, 0.036676302552223206, 0.026042265817523003, -0.032387979328632355, -0.04773674160242081, 0.009380844421684742, 0.013247285038232803, -0.00356997549533844, -0.049464527517557144, -0.0712200179696083, 0.018831433728337288, 0.04491935670375824, -0.022688334807753563, 0.0473344586789608, 0.013861378654837608, -0.04347994551062584, -0.04149474576115608, 0.013913451693952084, -0.01898716762661934, 0.06260153651237488, -0.019634375348687172, -0.020058942958712578, 0.027478855103254318, 0.043992213904857635, -0.011189673095941544, 0.009705718606710434, 0.00025919239851646125, -0.058880116790533066, -0.05326269194483757, -0.013823075219988823, -0.01983998715877533, 0.06504397839307785, 0.0034824081230908632, -0.021857988089323044, 0.020701268687844276, 0.00518783601000905, -0.0519862063229084, 0.02342171035706997, 0.08140268176794052, -0.04760688915848732, -0.014352126978337765, 0.01908423751592636, -0.00839434377849102, -0.0036382204852998257, -0.02738644741475582, 0.013598929159343243, -0.01861242949962616, -0.060272037982940674, -0.018829967826604843, -0.03195016086101532, 0.007207952905446291, -0.02056664414703846, -0.05842059105634689, -0.012821259908378124, -0.0490935854613781, -0.01658589020371437, -0.00777931185439229, 0.001379462075419724, -0.027340861037373543, 0.07298445701599121, 0.017460986971855164, 0.0075632259249687195, -0.009638048708438873, -0.01880689524114132, 0.024104043841362, -0.011038490571081638, 0.021754903718829155, -0.05699801445007324, 0.03176224231719971, 0.019660187885165215, -0.06093081459403038, -0.04733877629041672, -0.019762102514505386, 0.012177009135484695, 0.060909055173397064, -0.04377318546175957, -0.07415969669818878, -0.03709392249584198, -0.03737018629908562, 0.023521477356553078, 0.05761200562119484, -0.03174636512994766, -0.00492876535281539, 0.029158320277929306, 0.03386318311095238, -0.04306136444211006, -0.03597547113895416, 0.0010119156213477254, 0.009707369841635227, 0.06645912677049637, 0.029976312071084976, 0.030049068853259087, 0.07523038983345032, 0.07865677773952484, -0.0023618536069989204, 0.024238215759396553, -0.05797429382801056, 0.014642808586359024, -0.03561685234308243, 0.040331460535526276, -0.040341999381780624, 0.03996099531650543, -0.034778330475091934, -0.026448892429471016, 0.005299210082739592, 0.03548184037208557, -0.013680296950042248, 0.0023479219526052475, 0.014395308680832386, -0.05932823568582535, -0.0356539785861969, 0.010021277703344822, 0.05567392334342003, -0.0038337220903486013, -0.06719144433736801, -0.0020939859095960855, 0.029439808800816536, 0.0003294637717772275, 0.038059718906879425, 0.03332189843058586, 0.024428129196166992, -0.027880625799298286, 0.0017660062294453382, -0.007837721146643162, 0.032016463577747345, -0.004841230344027281, 0.03731699660420418, -0.006133285351097584, -0.000876747420988977, -0.01897662691771984, -0.09090171009302139, 0.012035015039145947, -0.008854195475578308, 0.021469920873641968, -0.006158022675663233, -0.0107842106372118, -0.003036187496036291, -0.015431166626513004, 0.01402774453163147, -0.000592634838540107, 0.015957165509462357, 0.055969152599573135, -0.04667317122220993, -0.023867709562182426, -0.0362977534532547, -0.008030605502426624, -0.06789569556713104, 0.05457591265439987, -0.01495630294084549, -0.018821343779563904, 0.034394510090351105, 0.005693439859896898, -0.023753758519887924, 0.011159755289554596, -0.06543349474668503, 0.08172193169593811, 0.00469456659629941, -0.012248110957443714, 0.05688951164484024, 0.023728422820568085, -0.020961502566933632, 0.0052103144116699696, 0.01842285506427288, -0.013557353056967258, 0.02839287929236889, -0.0015651414869353175, -0.057042159140110016, -0.020133117213845253, 0.047025784850120544, -0.007190498989075422, 0.04726501926779747, -0.0005385353579185903, -0.011564209125936031, -0.007570996414870024, -0.022392595186829567, 0.014479496516287327, 0.025057081133127213, -0.008928295224905014, -0.028795665130019188, 0.05046632140874863, 0.009827501140534878, 0.02041018009185791, 0.051716335117816925, -0.05904924497008324, 0.019886380061507225, -0.010506464168429375, 0.03639667481184006, -0.0006501455791294575, 0.02528180554509163, 0.0379536971449852, -0.05832671746611595, -0.06182919442653656, 0.02983313798904419, -0.01859348453581333, 0.035462234169244766, -0.011086610145866871, -0.011736738495528698, -0.06325093656778336, 0.0022247545421123505, 0.06939204037189484, -0.0027994425036013126, -0.031493209302425385, -0.030020127072930336, -0.010616712272167206, 0.016164477914571762, 0.0012482269667088985, -0.010129754431545734, 0.0504487045109272, 0.038514625281095505, 0.06047295033931732, 0.025553276762366295, 0.01991850882768631, -0.00021330152230802923, 0.03379898890852928, 0.0068863434717059135, 0.018716704100370407, 0.002960141748189926, -0.026257028803229332, -0.04454034939408302, 0.04446946084499359, 0.03375699371099472, 0.015973100438714027, -0.04091579094529152, 0.06004219502210617, 0.0001498464262112975, -0.0004834938736166805, -0.03838672861456871, 0.025877878069877625, 0.09620533883571625, 0.04676198586821556, -0.011677628383040428, 0.010438885539770126, -0.010850523598492146, 0.026684150099754333, -0.03784552961587906, 0.05222756788134575, 0.039624933153390884, -0.06354743987321854, -0.051282744854688644, 0.07744007557630539, -0.022929420694708824, -0.04002286493778229, -0.0012704506516456604, -0.046497806906700134, -0.021377678960561752, -0.03622789308428764, -0.006138401105999947, -0.025161199271678925, -0.04501400887966156, -0.004657406359910965, 0.009073716588318348, -0.028987908735871315, -0.013052531518042088, -0.019511643797159195, -0.02584485150873661, -0.049914296716451645, -0.01969580166041851, 0.016286207363009453, -0.02559133619070053, 0.024974703788757324, 0.01986299827694893, 0.03235640004277229, 0.05730883404612541, -0.026748981326818466, 0.03192644938826561, -0.031374990940093994, 0.004411984235048294, -0.05497230216860771, -0.034240417182445526, -0.005851446185261011, -0.014024882577359676, -0.010941294953227043, -0.07699882984161377, -0.022391751408576965, 0.0021987981162965298, 0.04460832104086876, -0.014285453595221043, -0.05759112536907196, 0.04864700511097908, 0.019750036299228668, 0.03696293383836746, 0.04478893801569939, -0.019160885363817215, 0.004559215623885393, -0.04298402741551399, 0.07159825414419174, -0.04373815283179283, 0.03500722348690033, -0.04577288404107094, -0.08522781729698181, 0.0058977301232516766, -0.00562435993924737, 0.01872505620121956, -0.028174372389912605, 0.0603506937623024, -0.040043264627456665, -0.023990241810679436, -0.012608934193849564, -0.004797345492988825, 0.0649903416633606, 0.0026488753501325846, 0.06368646025657654, 0.018998440355062485, -0.027148647233843803, -0.07044179737567902, -0.0010733755771070719, -0.04726897552609444, 0.03821520507335663, -0.015073546208441257, 0.009298821911215782, 0.06434817612171173, -0.03482278063893318, 0.03753745183348656, 0.06119093298912048, -0.06789463758468628, 0.0009176605963148177, 0.07149691134691238, 0.04039617255330086, 0.032127149403095245, -0.01658562570810318, 0.00328306807205081, 0.015398946590721607, -0.03036859817802906, -0.007228518836200237, -0.012699209153652191, -0.007560841739177704, 0.018412986770272255, 0.03879933059215546, 0.02779240719974041, -0.03193864971399307, 0.00038347658119164407, 0.06956592947244644, 0.023484887555241585, -0.0018076217966154218, -0.063501738011837, 0.007999398745596409, 0.0589587539434433, -0.052795521914958954, -0.060021620243787766, 0.03596490994095802, -0.04114760458469391, -0.007595043163746595, -0.004910046700388193, 0.010784872807562351, 0.0185431856662035, -0.06998984515666962, -0.00642025051638484, -0.025005044415593147, 0.014456064440310001, -0.029080161824822426, 0.04214480146765709, 0.001342884497717023, 0.06362342089414597, -0.051167480647563934, 0.0028615633491426706, 0.009447873570024967, 0.049105871468782425, 0.08323295414447784, -0.030166903510689735, 0.03507627546787262, 0.03185637295246124, -0.002248878590762615, -0.01228755060583353, 0.025109296664595604, -0.09695035964250565, -0.010889601893723011, -0.015353173017501831, -0.05128810927271843, 0.022975752130150795, 0.011852732859551907, -0.016278231516480446, -0.0010935839964076877, -0.05335721746087074, 0.048743341118097305, 0.017780933529138565, -0.0021387788001447916, 0.04567447677254677, -0.003742195200175047, -0.013823529705405235, 0.04651936516165733, 0.025540130212903023, -0.058800991624593735, -0.03521895408630371, -0.004096446558833122, -0.05665617436170578, -0.05391830578446388, -0.002054557204246521, 0.010848972015082836, 0.008613941259682178, 0.025762246921658516, 0.007821415551006794, 0.008636541664600372, 0.05239807069301605, 0.02488713152706623, 0.025631505995988846, 0.05150535702705383, -0.006483516655862331, 0.05130568891763687, -0.08814206719398499, 0.011609289795160294, 0.04588892683386803, -0.04124541953206062, -0.0009516216232441366, -0.012193109840154648, 0.050430700182914734, 0.03994206711649895, -0.03973175212740898, -0.011156314983963966, -0.07651831954717636, 0.012489638291299343, -0.013505320064723492, 0.03786519542336464, 0.03660629689693451, -0.01568862609565258, 0.02057371474802494, 0.02697448618710041, 0.002670789137482643, -0.0068770223297178745, -0.05086178332567215, 0.05165543779730797, -0.009552495554089546, 0.04845074191689491, 0.016123006120324135, 0.0219427477568388, -0.01730320043861866, 0.02310911938548088, 0.018022170290350914, -0.002575655234977603, -0.014842831529676914, -0.03040558472275734, -0.006564110983163118, -0.02702264115214348, -0.028700945898890495, -0.004470340441912413, -0.010791202075779438, -0.017367495223879814, -0.06215007230639458, -0.03326134756207466, 0.01880679652094841, -0.029620202258229256, -0.017617348581552505, 0.021611835807561874, -0.025251032784581184, 0.015226679854094982, -0.016455013304948807, 0.03249826654791832, 0.00810407754033804, -0.033309996128082275, -0.01186465471982956, -0.030283035710453987, 0.00162581168115139, 0.027670208364725113, 0.006112582515925169, -0.0019315333338454366, -0.017145125195384026, -0.04475114494562149, 0.015126229263842106, -0.033749379217624664, 0.011492650024592876, 0.02295692078769207, -0.00481648463755846, 0.04024525731801987, 0.0025582790840417147, -0.011584222316741943, -0.03660842031240463, 0.05844515189528465, -0.011888950131833553, 0.00018204074876848608, -0.002616133540868759, 0.0022358386777341366, 0.05104374140501022, 0.024949895218014717, -0.03230740502476692, -0.018409473821520805, -0.10610197484493256, 0.043711770325899124, 0.008060753345489502, -0.007673065643757582, -0.0026515142526477575, -0.04708842933177948, 0.014924954622983932, 0.022626865655183792, -0.02367555908858776, 0.010725555941462517, 0.008869282901287079, 0.023264845833182335, 0.04000196233391762, 0.005497731268405914, -0.015295447781682014, -0.036257822066545486, 0.034463394433259964, 0.00709791574627161, 0.04832051694393158, -0.02990555390715599, -0.045644666999578476, -0.014053523540496826, -0.036696843802928925, -0.02831815369427204, 0.010079296305775642, 0.02351672761142254, 0.03145849332213402, -0.00020281110482756048, 0.04446791857481003, 0.018868664279580116, 0.04659924656152725, -0.009604807943105698, -0.0697835385799408, 0.06695713847875595, 0.02542422153055668, 0.01971704140305519, 0.007620035670697689, -0.05182214081287384, -0.035021036863327026, -0.018574822694063187, 0.011357628740370274, -0.037588734179735184, 0.000608088041190058, 0.01028053741902113, -0.0615224651992321, 0.02652454376220703, -0.029920728877186775, -0.007688180543482304, 0.0009386775782331824, 0.021575214341282845, 0.0131348492577672, -0.002514418214559555, 0.018248451873660088, 0.01100530568510294, 0.0034793063532561064, -0.051117900758981705, -0.011135278269648552, 0.01226762868463993, -0.03647754341363907, -0.013910208828747272, -0.004469194449484348, 0.07245991379022598, 0.07803874462842941, 0.005408627912402153, -0.0024031836073845625, -0.026640526950359344, -0.037052497267723083, 0.0532553568482399, 0.013596024364233017, 0.006541554816067219, -0.023609468713402748, 0.038542915135622025, -0.0245344415307045, 0.04587498679757118, 0.034491557627916336, 0.01756707765161991, -0.01083617564290762, -0.04429703950881958, -0.02357441931962967, -0.03755781799554825, -0.06608474999666214, 0.03568808734416962 ]
<p>I am having some trouble understanding how to use the tetrad formalism. I will start with what I have so far, my question will be after that.</p> <p>I begin with the metric</p> <p>$$ \text{d}s^2 = e^{2a} \text{ d}t^2 - e^{2b} \text{ d}r^2 - r^2 \text{ d} \theta^2 - r^2 \sin^2 \theta \text{ d} \phi^2 $$</p> <p>Where $a$ and $b$ are functions of the coordinate $r$ only. Now I want to find the basis one-forms $\theta^{a}$ such that</p> <p>$$ \text{d}s^2 = \eta_{ab} \theta^{a} \otimes \theta^{b} $$</p> <p>where $\eta_{ab} = \operatorname{diag} (+1, -1, -1, -1)$. So</p> <p>$$ \theta^{t} = e^{a} \text{ d} t\\ \theta^{r} = e^{b} \text{ d} r\\ \theta^{\theta} = r \text{ d} \theta \\ \theta^{\phi} = r \sin \theta \text{ d} \phi $$</p> <p>Now I take the exterior derivatives of each basis one-form</p> <p>$$ \begin{align} \text{d} \theta^{t} &amp;= a' e^{a} \text{ d} r \wedge \text{ d} t \\ \text{d} \theta^{r} &amp;= b' e^{b} \text{ d} r \wedge \text{ d} r = 0 \\ \text{d} \theta^{\theta} &amp;= \text{ d} r \wedge \text{ d} \theta \\ \text{d} \theta^{\phi} &amp;= \sin \theta \text{ d} r \wedge \text{ d} \phi + r \cos \theta \text{ d} \theta \wedge \text{ d} \phi \end{align} $$</p> <p>Up to here, I am pretty sure my results are correct. Where I am confused is when it comes to computing the spin connection one-forms from the no-torsion condition</p> <p>$$ \omega^{a}_{\phantom{a} b} \wedge \theta^{b} = - \text{d} \theta^{a} $$</p> <p>How can I use this to find the connection one-forms? My naive guess is that, for example,</p> <p>$$ \omega^{t}_{\phantom{a} b} \wedge \theta^{b} = - \text{d} \theta^{t} = - a' e^{a} \text{ d} r \wedge \text{ d} t $$</p> <p>so that this picks out the term on the left side of the form $\text{ d} r \wedge \text{ d} t$ so that </p> <p>$$ e^{a} \omega^{t}_{\phantom{a} t} = - a' e^{a} \text{ d} r \implies \omega^{t}_{\phantom{a} t} = - a' \text{ d} r $$</p> <p>But the wedge product is anticommutative, so this should also say that</p> <p>$$ \omega^{t}_{\phantom{a} b} \wedge \theta^{b} = a' e^{a} \text{ d} t \wedge \text{ d} r $$</p> <p>Am I reading this incorrectly? Is there some symmetry property that I'm missing?</p>
g5865
[ -0.010650279000401497, -0.02077595517039299, -0.027435146272182465, -0.06166773661971092, 0.05272430554032326, -0.007403634022921324, 0.13075940310955048, 0.03940785676240921, 0.0011809078278020024, 0.01952572911977768, -0.007933520711958408, -0.022907935082912445, 0.041363317519426346, -0.03544207289814949, 0.009386028163135052, 0.024725671857595444, 0.040677063167095184, -0.0066432650201022625, 0.04192531108856201, -0.04945378378033638, -0.10892239212989807, -0.02719890885055065, 0.020514141768217087, -0.017162062227725983, 0.006431255955249071, -0.028102122247219086, 0.03103615902364254, -0.029276488348841667, 0.0021880518179386854, 0.0076897707767784595, 0.005403734743595123, 0.031947240233421326, 0.06679235398769379, 0.0023784402292221785, -0.011191003024578094, -0.04070594161748886, 0.06051430478692055, 0.055160608142614365, -0.02648627571761608, 0.004314859863370657, 0.022968603298068047, -0.04869654402136803, -0.019989708438515663, -0.040468621999025345, 0.008603195659816265, -0.014185233041644096, 0.012617744505405426, -0.020066794008016586, -0.06024577468633652, 0.023099981248378754, 0.02565537951886654, 0.04815942049026489, 0.028849920257925987, -0.04384494572877884, -0.05845733359456062, 0.017983658239245415, 0.03181121498346329, -0.007478129118680954, 0.04598512500524521, 0.04645917937159538, -0.03718673065304756, -0.024337129667401314, -0.02061782032251358, 0.03654459863901138, 0.04816489294171333, -0.06742024421691895, -0.030239766463637352, 0.007788431830704212, 0.05290086939930916, 0.018859514966607094, 0.0006173140718601644, -0.039317525923252106, 0.08961816132068634, -0.01195590477436781, -0.04911381006240845, 0.008909162133932114, 0.03390319272875786, -0.04327826201915741, -0.0216726865619421, 0.00338364508934319, 0.015384544618427753, -0.01823953539133072, -0.008556431159377098, 0.0008508494938723743, 0.09358973056077957, 0.022733472287654877, 0.016729295253753662, 0.039548736065626144, 0.0036952942609786987, 0.0395992211997509, -0.02606896311044693, -0.03936794772744179, 0.003536566160619259, 0.005270248744636774, 0.06030289828777313, -0.0017201779410243034, -0.03595311939716339, -0.008366617374122143, -0.03937886655330658, -0.050014927983284, -0.02067067101597786, 0.04582950100302696, 0.030451763421297073, -0.015989134088158607, -0.03688465431332588, 0.012021642178297043, 0.005775232799351215, 0.036138568073511124, 0.019007401540875435, 0.002291688695549965, -0.051230624318122864, 0.05617935210466385, -0.049629729241132736, 0.005665114615112543, -0.03730360046029091, -0.017923634499311447, -0.02397703193128109, -0.0433630496263504, 0.004287156742066145, 0.00022143054229672998, -0.01336437277495861, -0.052883047610521317, 0.04959386587142944, 0.07404349744319916, -0.013528458774089813, 0.030697710812091827, -0.0258446354418993, -0.0420532152056694, 0.023282641544938087, -0.04131491482257843, 0.016370367258787155, 0.013598443008959293, 0.050135765224695206, 0.03109835274517536, -0.004028652794659138, 0.05286988615989685, -0.022664636373519897, 0.02011243626475334, 0.0245833657681942, -0.026777613908052444, -0.06406496465206146, 0.01688052900135517, -0.05365249887108803, -0.010838411748409271, 0.01791740208864212, -0.0006648371345363557, 0.018061719834804535, -0.08892317861318588, 0.029729166999459267, 0.019141560420393944, -0.0006937046418897808, 0.032362427562475204, -0.04635467007756233, -0.003686032025143504, 0.02959655039012432, 0.03719281777739525, 0.04788203164935112, -0.08017782866954803, 0.025477340444922447, -0.007682499010115862, 0.0638318583369255, -0.02305409125983715, 0.012608221732079983, 0.00227836100384593, -0.02054496482014656, -0.050196073949337006, 0.0021444240119308233, -0.012035316787660122, 0.01516888290643692, -0.09041590243577957, -0.043084390461444855, 0.0033011336345225573, 0.0007071070722304285, -0.009185547940433025, -0.0011244046036154032, 0.017004096880555153, -0.07498607784509659, -0.05245780944824219, 0.011157767847180367, 0.05476265773177147, -0.0043927147053182125, 0.02147793583571911, 0.010687094181776047, 0.08811923116445541, -0.0038048524875193834, -0.012306248769164085, 0.05715044587850571, -0.04937385767698288, 0.015207154676318169, 0.03950459510087967, -0.030541829764842987, 0.010451878421008587, -0.003763416316360235, 0.023088090121746063, -0.016322266310453415, 0.06544152647256851, 0.00933531392365694, -0.036673977971076965, -0.030479609966278076, 0.017966007813811302, -0.0005350449355319142, 0.03882821649312973, 0.01406314317137003, -0.014903050847351551, -0.018607936799526215, -0.003968055825680494, -0.0019132547313347459, -0.05394775792956352, 0.012872908264398575, 0.0620930977165699, 0.030575590208172798, -0.01787247508764267, 0.00951341912150383, 0.000228192177019082, -0.045385103672742844, -0.03833726793527603, 0.07794436067342758, 0.039188120514154434, -0.0734286978840828, -0.005253641400486231, -0.02540380321443081, -0.01182644534856081, 0.0014070929028093815, 0.0027007630560547113, -0.03602084890007973, 0.07585739344358444, 0.021813713014125824, 0.02080375887453556, -0.01928289234638214, -0.0039525143802165985, -0.02831943705677986, -0.02893541380763054, -0.02751453034579754, 0.00923171266913414, 0.028755581006407738, 0.019486933946609497, -0.010377313010394573, 0.0027903937734663486, 0.048876937478780746, 0.015349163673818111, 0.03509936481714249, 0.007218725513666868, -0.016781281679868698, 0.0033646090887486935, 0.01716351881623268, -0.015790635719895363, 0.0316675640642643, 0.0352044440805912, -0.007322351913899183, 0.01947939395904541, 0.02124071680009365, -0.014213175512850285, -0.031812574714422226, -0.020827678963541985, 0.04100603610277176, 0.0035169695038348436, -0.0035844468511641026, 0.015769310295581818, 0.010423356667160988, -0.008553401567041874, -0.03499549627304077, -0.0537879653275013, 0.042111534625291824, 0.04051162302494049, -0.10314348340034485, -0.02735675498843193, -0.004612183663994074, 0.00534785445779562, 0.06207990273833275, -0.04543545842170715, -0.02111358568072319, 0.05028191953897476, 0.02491827867925167, 0.029406053945422173, -0.0276869498193264, -0.057235319167375565, -0.026746051385998726, -0.03172942250967026, -0.027998004108667374, -0.005822553765028715, -0.004675343167036772, -0.011146345175802708, 0.03316422551870346, -0.00397912273183465, 0.01718577742576599, -0.0433763787150383, 0.01756749115884304, 0.04950646311044693, -0.021474091336131096, 0.04180843010544777, -0.07877975702285767, 0.03209593519568443, 0.016990650445222855, -0.030646147206425667, 0.02315058931708336, 0.03789372369647026, -0.027887795120477676, -0.057160478085279465, -0.014069768600165844, 0.04149576276540756, -0.0405648872256279, 0.0020154553931206465, 0.03161827102303505, -0.04085807129740715, 0.0067304144613444805, -0.02032400667667389, -0.0644187182188034, -0.02395913191139698, -0.0013106096303090453, 0.005302834790199995, -0.024847833439707756, 0.013059070333838463, 0.024343300610780716, -0.030935028567910194, -0.01625571772456169, 0.02535712905228138, 0.010758893564343452, -0.04215472564101219, -0.004907289519906044, 0.018048087134957314, -0.035246171057224274, -0.03378279134631157, 0.018732624128460884, -0.013102785684168339, -0.005564381368458271, 0.00833848211914301, -0.05242367088794708, -0.01029692217707634, -0.005563261918723583, -0.02427435666322708, 0.022820623591542244, -0.010103010572493076, 0.054317012429237366, -0.007808877620846033, -0.10153589397668839, -0.004602593835443258, -0.07933328300714493, 0.003103968920186162, 0.014839084818959236, -0.05599912256002426, -0.07449761033058167, -0.03780412673950195, -0.01213080808520317, 0.026659097522497177, 0.02653989940881729, 0.006453629583120346, 0.013170670717954636, 0.047249067574739456, 0.007610573899000883, 0.021786529570817947, -0.040784724056720734, -0.03472740575671196, 0.04625390097498894, 0.04740742966532707, -0.0011837868951261044, 0.0663226991891861, 0.023628653958439827, 0.03508472442626953, 0.039322949945926666, -0.004993140231817961, 0.01822943426668644, 0.009467813186347485, -0.01255450677126646, 0.048649806529283524, -0.008445682004094124, 0.008571424521505833, 0.02631179615855217, -0.03242553398013115, 0.010077989660203457, 0.012022895738482475, 0.0791933685541153, -0.014509343542158604, 0.06631722301244736, -0.003919839393347502, 0.02459670789539814, -0.011742356233298779, -0.05090244859457016, -0.02262190356850624, 0.002009070012718439, 0.06884976476430893, -0.03869311884045601, -0.004443650599569082, 0.033456288278102875, 0.046580083668231964, 0.05736999586224556, 0.049520060420036316, -0.0018257253104820848, 0.04319366067647934, -0.044670190662145615, 0.010625158436596394, -0.0073568373918533325, -0.009879265911877155, 0.023610549047589302, -0.013457912020385265, 0.013574891723692417, -0.020788539201021194, -0.011778545565903187, 0.028963984921574593, -0.07157813757658005, -0.009596440941095352, -0.013652604073286057, -0.012970528565347195, 0.03987972065806389, -0.022889118641614914, -0.010403439402580261, 0.007087844889611006, -0.03528478741645813, 0.009752455167472363, -0.005005220416933298, -0.053669046610593796, -0.0004118097713217139, 0.05266418308019638, 0.062253400683403015, -0.03980691730976105, 0.06051594763994217, 0.029387690126895905, 0.021651621907949448, -0.0662652924656868, 0.009172470308840275, -0.012656246311962605, 0.020434841513633728, -0.027834409847855568, 0.009974333457648754, -0.0033372342586517334, 0.07413622736930847, 0.07858967781066895, 0.014468999579548836, 0.0034123242367058992, -0.03302759304642677, -0.02080446481704712, -0.0510675311088562, 0.018764689564704895, -0.06530563533306122, 0.021325690671801567, -0.052057042717933655, 0.020631127059459686, -0.014900265261530876, 0.0868881344795227, -0.02419721707701683, 0.001794288633391261, -0.04684564471244812, 0.010956152342259884, 0.04186924919486046, -0.0757148489356041, 0.005376365035772324, 0.04229595139622688, -0.026253238320350647, -0.029119815677404404, 0.04242189973592758, -0.012029966339468956, 0.002579946769401431, -0.012266766279935837, 0.052882954478263855, -0.021983375772833824, -0.016944032162427902, -0.01005139946937561, -0.06443051248788834, 0.0334223248064518, -0.004666004329919815, -0.00785931758582592, -0.031570352613925934, -0.012590224854648113, -0.029075872153043747, 0.026295844465494156, -0.029512152075767517, -0.059705913066864014, -0.03195514529943466, 0.039281487464904785, 0.016997627913951874, -0.05739416182041168, -0.00043564551742747426, -0.0029859384521842003, -0.0013695968082174659, -0.012806984595954418, 0.03136657550930977, 0.0853305235505104, 0.015537677332758904, -0.008636715821921825, -0.04700625687837601, -0.056386757642030716, 0.002949367044493556, 0.0020167981274425983, -0.03008430264890194, 0.0181285310536623, 0.0276777446269989, -0.02957352250814438, 0.057962898164987564, -0.04876337945461273, -0.0692746713757515, 0.0734514370560646, 0.03279441222548485, 0.012710063718259335, 0.003207023721188307, -0.013093189336359501, -0.030939584597945213, -0.01587183028459549, -0.004157638177275658, -0.0010576852364465594, -0.010764953680336475, 0.035545941442251205, -0.012790428474545479, 0.029518233612179756, -0.04614601284265518, -0.018523992970585823, 0.08125408738851547, 0.054211825132369995, 0.03902873396873474, -0.0018144038040190935, -0.007519167382270098, 0.02654985524713993, -0.006608606781810522, -0.02324753999710083, 0.04707873612642288, -0.018724068999290466, -0.026381123811006546, 0.026403704658150673, -0.011750586330890656, 0.026003791019320488, -0.03697595000267029, -0.044329650700092316, 0.023110873997211456, 0.012484732083976269, -0.0333576500415802, -0.02705356664955616, 0.020600350573658943, 0.010901695117354393, 0.013076519593596458, -0.06312625855207443, -0.021817702800035477, 0.00703019043430686, -0.005763093009591103, -0.023935547098517418, -0.01753471978008747, -0.0014513187343254685, 0.02563551254570484, -0.06240413337945938, -0.015227953903377056, -0.002160307951271534, -0.0005099804257042706, -0.02748475782573223, 0.005194198340177536, -0.009342417120933533, 0.03379237651824951, -0.004249081946909428, -0.056048016995191574, 0.03762446716427803, 0.026102378964424133, -0.006842033471912146, -0.019336560741066933, 0.04128160700201988, -0.037849076092243195, -0.00011703433119691908, -0.05035409703850746, -0.0216104406863451, 0.012707076035439968, -0.0017947573214769363, -0.009852185845375061, -0.05025580897927284, -0.005970893427729607, -0.019152386114001274, 0.022198574617505074, -0.06694944947957993, -0.01619328185915947, 0.030976956710219383, -0.03744902461767197, -0.012970171868801117, 0.05066315084695816, 0.021728796884417534, -0.03133406117558479, -0.028604863211512566, 0.04744022339582443, 0.0120465699583292, 0.030504196882247925, -0.01899346150457859, 0.019247902557253838, 0.045689139515161514, -0.016331346705555916, -0.03665228188037872, 0.00018258260388392955, 0.020866239443421364, 0.048966944217681885, -0.004989889450371265, -0.038414888083934784, 0.024752208963036537, 0.008745510131120682, 0.0818481594324112, -0.045776817947626114, -0.09086310863494873, 0.023175621405243874, -0.05516085773706436, -0.06505228579044342, 0.003275464288890362, -0.04255658760666847, 0.04746368154883385, 0.05647292360663414, 0.011208467185497284, 0.019161226227879524, 0.07994929701089859, 0.003823165548965335, -0.044060252606868744, 0.06221584230661392, 0.008682158775627613, -0.008450198918581009, 0.00745433708652854, -0.014853386208415031, 0.05325474962592125, 0.0031616047490388155, -0.044136032462120056, -0.027163483202457428, 0.035889968276023865, 0.04725044593214989, 0.04929634928703308, -0.033001601696014404, 0.060436345636844635, 0.009943421930074692, -0.028623275458812714, -0.05317108705639839, 0.05608402565121651, 0.0005671430844813585, -0.009354367852210999, 0.06323812901973724, 0.041593026369810104, -0.015694422647356987, -0.033167824149131775, 0.0295697171241045, 0.03426875174045563, -0.002749071689322591, -0.020929206162691116, -0.037690170109272, -0.02024082839488983, 0.006051917094737291, -0.007735482882708311, -0.05008694902062416, 0.010004906915128231, -0.03419940173625946, -0.019722802564501762, -0.04615349695086479, 0.0816805362701416, 0.01899799518287182, 0.13701725006103516, -0.024130983278155327, 0.005454752128571272, 0.015948612242937088, 0.004085822030901909, -0.01894567534327507, 0.024929378181695938, 0.005412784870713949, 0.029949631541967392, -0.12400797009468079, 0.013696701265871525, 0.06746868044137955, 0.03227448835968971, -0.016203906387090683, 0.03830287605524063, -0.014838078990578651, -0.03255052864551544, 0.03737317770719528, -0.018573565408587456, -0.0394587516784668, -0.008548908866941929, -0.04169388860464096, 0.002153705805540085, -0.029728176072239876, -0.031104419380426407, -0.027662158012390137, 0.05833657830953598, -0.03582809492945671, -0.0010252646170556545, 0.035058919340372086, -0.0027459668926894665, -0.014364403672516346, -0.01674938015639782, -0.019136471673846245, 0.030394956469535828, 0.006485490128397942, 0.039571620523929596, 0.016254086047410965, 0.028908193111419678, -0.012140409089624882, -0.051855072379112244, -0.01605035550892353, 0.020184187218546867, -0.04763396829366684, -0.0074171628803014755, -0.02159070037305355, 0.04379437863826752, -0.025561440736055374, 0.026603860780596733, 0.005213091149926186, 0.014527382329106331, 0.012787624262273312, 0.06299480050802231, -0.024827031418681145, 0.05461982265114784, -0.04910513386130333, -0.01415762398391962, 0.032325781881809235, 0.02259843982756138, -0.08980219066143036, 0.027986468747258186, 0.008643949404358864, -0.027017824351787567, -0.0096814576536417, 0.007663717493414879, 0.0597449466586113, -0.010871329344809055, 0.012461137026548386, 0.021130818873643875, -0.047389864921569824, 0.03158746287226677, 0.04810664430260658, -0.01324999239295721, -0.00566127011552453, -0.02620619162917137, 0.008586276322603226, 0.05126972123980522, -0.03989510238170624, 0.030353860929608345, 0.018734119832515717, 0.026346243917942047, -0.019437963142991066, -0.020637892186641693, 0.05540616437792778, -0.03341694176197052, -0.04272492602467537, 0.0002936208911705762, -0.031847696751356125, 0.0159683208912611, 0.012223383411765099, 0.038087397813797, -0.08464019000530243, -0.00928469281643629, -0.03477603569626808, 0.042373474687337875, -0.02009306289255619, 0.02367723360657692, 0.008727881126105785, -0.10111070424318314, 0.03145725652575493, -0.0018301473464816809, 0.015116882510483265, 0.004388580098748207, 0.038618288934230804, -0.023867283016443253, -0.017714962363243103, -0.026282846927642822, 0.018232332542538643, 0.012980027124285698, 0.03354857116937637, 0.062650166451931, -0.033350586891174316, 0.06364699453115463, 0.0188301894813776, -0.0008554317173548043, -0.03709235042333603, -0.04927387461066246, 0.01881307363510132, 0.02302323654294014, 0.031064124777913094, 0.0032831947319209576, -0.0344550795853138, 0.023645956069231033, -0.0662030279636383, 0.04087486490607262, -0.050539445132017136, -0.03334460034966469, -0.05265110358595848, 0.06373697519302368 ]
<p>How was the polarization experimentally measured in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BICEP_and_Keck_Array#BICEP2" rel="nofollow">BICEP2</a> experiments and why did they look specifically at <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B-modes" rel="nofollow">B-modes</a>? Why is it implying the existence of gravitational waves and the need to quantize gravity? Moreover, why is it implying inflation as a unique option?</p>
g5866
[ 0.011380870826542377, 0.07561908662319183, -0.027487874031066895, -0.02082035318017006, 0.10217702388763428, 0.023481370881199837, 0.03527691960334778, -0.013146303594112396, -0.048257939517498016, -0.00621621822938323, -0.0024706304538995028, 0.044392507523298264, 0.02792898565530777, -0.005047380458563566, 0.04122690111398697, -0.05512445792555809, 0.004622415639460087, 0.039811618626117706, 0.04065023362636566, -0.05230136960744858, -0.01760164462029934, 0.018566124141216278, 0.02082006074488163, -0.02317671850323677, 0.026533091440796852, -0.007103515323251486, 0.03990134969353676, -0.02416953071951866, -0.032415322959423065, -0.0381866917014122, -0.014972284436225891, -0.03578389436006546, 0.0787757858633995, -0.044787146151065826, -0.02870342694222927, -0.04469640552997589, 0.026621442288160324, 0.05235900729894638, -0.011992992833256721, -0.005119850393384695, -0.04320133104920387, -0.021730108186602592, -0.04151322320103645, 0.001618591952137649, -0.00023837793560232967, -0.017255259677767754, 0.027031034231185913, 0.013974525034427643, 0.041332460939884186, -0.036567334085702896, 0.019235948100686073, 0.02886395901441574, 0.12152014672756195, 0.030348222702741623, 0.04542896896600723, 0.04565596580505371, 0.0028333915397524834, 0.06899979710578918, 0.06000727042555809, 0.003360878210514784, -0.013519464991986752, 0.042178306728601456, 0.06428191065788269, 0.03756346553564072, -0.014149889349937439, -0.03079199232161045, -0.06153104826807976, -0.0317835733294487, -0.04155001789331436, 0.015284031629562378, 0.04352060332894325, -0.07630444318056107, 0.0017839930951595306, -0.01688230037689209, -0.020924648270010948, 0.0443640872836113, 0.00945271272212267, -0.02162938006222248, -0.0008048223680816591, -0.007911104708909988, 0.012831068597733974, -0.020712103694677353, -0.027112694457173347, -0.011676397174596786, 0.09513390064239502, -0.0042249360121786594, 0.04470280930399895, 0.0004166378639638424, 0.013107416220009327, 0.03727395087480545, -0.014706348069012165, -0.015449810773134232, 0.07729519158601761, 0.08247756958007812, -0.02227475680410862, -0.03621344640851021, -0.01449856162071228, 0.0565197728574276, -0.009919201023876667, 0.0026225929614156485, -0.033443860709667206, 0.0593847930431366, -0.07398281246423721, 0.006205393932759762, 0.031026193872094154, 0.01339367963373661, -0.018111221492290497, 0.0013162314426153898, 0.03306717425584793, -0.01371949166059494, -0.046562980860471725, 0.04405985400080681, 0.009972410276532173, -0.03387966379523277, -0.0664745345711708, -0.04982968792319298, 0.036405228078365326, -0.004666093271225691, -0.03739199787378311, 0.025015046820044518, -0.041573960334062576, 0.03502858430147171, -0.02796805649995804, 0.047390010207891464, -0.059461500495672226, 0.023253342136740685, -0.027587130665779114, -0.04090273752808571, 0.0674121081829071, -0.03312186896800995, 0.006103119347244501, -0.0023027926217764616, -0.0357348695397377, -0.019430367276072502, 0.01030763704329729, -0.03380731865763664, -0.001774742384441197, -0.03567568585276604, -0.05731862038373947, 0.028368528932332993, -0.0328206941485405, -0.03881898894906044, 0.002536200452595949, -0.07550268620252609, 0.029862627387046814, -0.011219849810004234, 0.02760894224047661, 0.011593926697969437, 0.030810611322522163, 0.026497259736061096, -0.03416408598423004, 0.10249866545200348, 0.04114754498004913, -0.011810002848505974, -0.03478327393531799, -0.021766308695077896, 0.01824016682803631, 0.019440678879618645, 0.005925639998167753, 0.052834492176771164, 0.04932013154029846, 0.00567662063986063, -0.009280030615627766, 0.007766926195472479, -0.02186422236263752, 0.05476252734661102, 0.046242985874414444, -0.061330247670412064, 0.08897871524095535, -0.0027543024625629187, -0.07568158209323883, -0.03493112325668335, -0.01653989404439926, 0.021702639758586884, 0.07536624372005463, 0.07173743098974228, -0.03316548466682434, -0.040922392159700394, 0.005337691865861416, 0.0001551043678773567, -0.016676435247063637, 0.032269470393657684, 0.005366828292608261, -0.007607277482748032, 0.03358078375458717, -0.009732303209602833, 0.025722891092300415, 0.011859305202960968, -0.036239951848983765, -0.02936222217977047, -0.0002606888010632247, -0.017497984692454338, -0.04474521800875664, 0.011172023601830006, 0.020417409017682076, -0.0054415808990597725, 0.06304659694433212, 0.0004912202130071819, -0.05883921682834625, 0.079149030148983, -0.017127910628914833, 0.003395633539184928, 0.0902605727314949, -0.05977809801697731, -0.04071003198623657, -0.0034104168880730867, -0.0007907975814305246, 0.02171407639980316, 0.028720255941152573, -0.053004782646894455, -0.0015970476670190692, 0.005842703394591808, -0.012489569373428822, -0.012877793051302433, -0.02069101855158806, 0.06564344465732574, 0.032287437468767166, 0.030128803104162216, -0.010902299545705318, 0.036079831421375275, -0.03107292950153351, 0.00900401920080185, 0.030137518420815468, 0.05037124082446098, 0.0029865861870348454, 0.0010665521258488297, -0.10872483998537064, -0.014106454327702522, -0.0184419434517622, -0.0059190127067267895, -0.02368495799601078, 0.03912542760372162, 0.05097712203860283, -0.027822643518447876, 0.008701571263372898, -0.008539658971130848, 0.027655521407723427, 0.009087934158742428, 0.004443739540874958, -0.03548812121152878, 0.022119516506791115, -0.013104324229061604, 0.015415339730679989, 0.007307069841772318, 0.01429137121886015, 0.03197461739182472, 0.022990643978118896, 0.0023124669678509235, 0.014206855557858944, 0.03289415314793587, 0.012614678591489792, -0.02032593823969364, -0.04986124858260155, -0.047516919672489166, 0.007973473519086838, 0.012024917639791965, 0.058805953711271286, 0.02417273446917534, -0.08091394603252411, -0.007906707003712654, 0.006782183889299631, -0.06338833272457123, 0.048930805176496506, -0.013688215985894203, -0.058681078255176544, 0.00038684619357809424, -0.04459740221500397, -0.0032615603413432837, -0.034712739288806915, -0.018404122442007065, -0.034049488604068756, 0.06480368971824646, 0.009656360372900963, 0.053355101495981216, -0.013734978623688221, -0.0011701363837346435, 0.023955218493938446, 0.048016924411058426, -0.0297401063144207, 0.0012837824178859591, -0.0840584859251976, 0.05335474759340286, -0.030365977436304092, 0.010128929279744625, 0.01231403835117817, -0.016121290624141693, -0.0360490046441555, 0.020900405943393707, 0.013175509870052338, 0.021854456514120102, 0.04418057203292847, 0.03793976455926895, -0.04481163248419762, 0.028486672788858414, -0.02070123888552189, 0.02762070670723915, 0.023213475942611694, -0.07218030840158463, -0.04161174222826958, -0.0008532261126674712, 0.007413947023451328, 0.0465056374669075, -0.014200597070157528, 0.03958369791507721, -0.02010544389486313, -0.019541503861546516, -0.06608212739229202, -0.06092078983783722, -0.05327471345663071, 0.03797709196805954, 0.035529397428035736, 0.06087780371308327, -0.005733591970056295, 0.04768114537000656, 0.008010831661522388, -0.0011519681429490447, -0.05581168457865715, -0.015321123413741589, -0.003089673351496458, -0.014512673951685429, -0.022001072764396667, -0.001968974247574806, 0.02175392024219036, 0.01490213256329298, 0.015935031697154045, 0.042299482971429825, -0.018021905794739723, 0.023803548887372017, -0.0007565718260593712, -0.05291358381509781, 0.0046458132565021515, -0.0171905979514122, -0.0065129040740430355, 0.03371929004788399, -0.024419622495770454, -0.05453382432460785, -0.04226073622703552, 0.04580872133374214, 0.03592103719711304, 0.0028827234636992216, 0.02321852371096611, -0.011899488978087902, 0.012097209692001343, -0.02991107851266861, 0.03363597393035889, 0.0441674143075943, -0.006548894569277763, -0.0009160289773717523, 0.0015581747284159064, -0.006765961181372404, -0.017235370352864265, -0.02702581323683262, 0.02369183860719204, 0.02406063675880432, -0.07980728894472122, -0.002947971224784851, 0.08258815109729767, -0.0029640982393175364, 0.049556098878383636, -0.01781194470822811, -0.025769973173737526, 0.03601522743701935, 0.02207154966890812, 0.03908282890915871, -0.03845539689064026, -0.07940129190683365, -0.006251825485378504, -0.037547431886196136, -0.0679086297750473, 0.0080196438357234, 0.01462490577250719, -0.025641275569796562, 0.018112923949956894, 0.01982749067246914, 0.03876662999391556, -0.06841609627008438, 0.0344582162797451, 0.011069261468946934, -0.028024915605783463, 0.03029269352555275, -0.0393398217856884, 0.010612085461616516, 0.08135925233364105, 0.0447256937623024, 0.004874847829341888, -0.00983282271772623, -0.03223935142159462, -0.003661381546407938, 0.03065299615263939, -0.029916130006313324, -0.0028361803852021694, 0.008660813793540001, -0.00528314895927906, 0.0043806168250739574, -0.017801139503717422, -0.0064033158123493195, 0.03232260048389435, -0.040817517787218094, 0.038436319679021835, 0.02614402584731579, -0.04083263874053955, 0.019788281992077827, 0.009739313274621964, -0.026305081322789192, -0.03333735838532448, -0.015595062635838985, 0.022623876109719276, 0.025848936289548874, -0.015695104375481606, 0.007770849391818047, 0.020492127165198326, 0.0069860792718827724, 0.03361692652106285, -0.09915216267108917, 0.049219246953725815, 0.013097129762172699, 0.008711799047887325, -0.020070653408765793, 0.06675630062818527, -0.009698301553726196, 0.08574853092432022, 0.028233254328370094, -0.03507176786661148, -0.06410941481590271, -0.03342002257704735, 0.07267393171787262, 0.04462321475148201, -0.00618910975754261, -0.008201224729418755, -0.014558114111423492, 0.04584724083542824, -0.0836973637342453, 0.021087568253278732, 0.01969771273434162, -0.0378299318253994, -0.001922599389217794, -0.07350219041109085, 0.02039359323680401, -0.006567148957401514, 0.019190948456525803, 0.09578721225261688, -0.05381755903363228, 0.0033235670998692513, -0.06262613832950592, 0.02030560001730919, 0.03622424975037575, 0.0014238451840355992, -0.023299016058444977, -0.06656424701213837, 0.02898380160331726, 0.0004824480274692178, 0.004899260587990284, -0.012958096340298653, -0.011364135891199112, 0.016743693500757217, -0.005694403313100338, 0.019764108583331108, 0.06993106752634048, -0.007988075725734234, 0.026780515909194946, -0.07472338527441025, -0.04886215925216675, -0.025483930483460426, 0.023243628442287445, -0.025459548458456993, 0.0024087161291390657, -0.002558934036642313, -0.023118792101740837, -0.021020973101258278, 0.019524691626429558, -0.013066332787275314, -0.016718197613954544, 0.05748768150806427, 0.06218215450644493, -0.017346274107694626, 0.04716460779309273, 0.007717720232903957, -0.02355063520371914, 0.012070850469172001, -0.04284432902932167, -0.045314986258745193, 0.004196737427264452, 0.017949851229786873, 0.02880971133708954, -0.010500933974981308, 0.016763653606176376, -0.0710931047797203, 0.010888698510825634, -0.07747118920087814, -0.001517738215625286, 0.016908610239624977, -0.0010443298378959298, 0.024150941520929337, -0.05106746405363083, -0.035075053572654724, -0.03010566346347332, 0.008879505097866058, -0.03548583760857582, 0.051290228962898254, -0.009218486957252026, -0.013686316087841988, 0.055174507200717926, 0.002067272551357746, -0.0032286890782415867, -0.022829251363873482, 0.004809368401765823, 0.038065921515226364, 0.0022034524008631706, -0.0010977090569213033, 0.04902244731783867, -0.03322539106011391, 0.003409571945667267, -0.027508040890097618, 0.0503394678235054, 0.05149037018418312, -0.033120784908533096, 0.05692438408732414, 0.022478748112916946, -0.018952373415231705, -0.05269908905029297, 0.024846596643328667, -0.036877915263175964, 0.026819244027137756, -0.03103620372712612, 0.06301680207252502, 0.008348549716174603, -0.06527722626924515, -0.011066891252994537, 0.05102397873997688, -0.01906285062432289, 0.021023636683821678, 0.03371276333928108, 0.10087551921606064, 0.031703732907772064, -0.0031415382400155067, 0.003865632927045226, 0.05980188027024269, 0.014856439083814621, 0.006305119022727013, -0.004227649420499802, -0.044528618454933167, -0.0010039445478469133, 0.012812021188437939, 0.05301569029688835, 0.02413836307823658, -0.026140639558434486, -0.012468508444726467, -0.04230516031384468, -0.008221343159675598, -0.09918195754289627, -0.05324636772274971, -0.0214823130518198, 0.023706823587417603, 0.028311312198638916, -0.03131970763206482, 0.008268999867141247, -0.054924145340919495, -0.054694823920726776, -0.062340330332517624, -0.025123853236436844, 0.04202853888273239, 0.038336776196956635, 0.017554236575961113, -0.001632512779906392, 0.006006896961480379, -0.04143676534295082, 0.026596609503030777, -0.03899102285504341, 0.028507882729172707, 0.03562363609671593, -0.05065489932894707, 0.0497581921517849, 0.039003919810056686, 0.07012463361024857, 0.021854329854249954, 0.0450432151556015, 0.007300901226699352, 0.0048421830870211124, 0.0051902602426707745, -0.032868392765522, 0.05105603113770485, 0.0008620120352134109, 0.059012968093156815, -0.03311946243047714, -0.03416438400745392, 0.025270674377679825, -0.008295462466776371, 0.010111406445503235, 0.009156484156847, 0.002062169136479497, -0.025527091696858406, -0.06103048101067543, -0.026278706267476082, -0.06679082661867142, -0.020254021510481834, 0.022945310920476913, -0.012107363902032375, -0.019050702452659607, -0.07599903643131256, -0.02277786284685135, -0.02044781669974327, 0.006495377514511347, -0.005852579604834318, 0.018679844215512276, -0.0025687897577881813, 0.005477860104292631, -0.01431800052523613, -0.02348511479794979, -0.027626819908618927, 0.05579037964344025, -0.037213802337646484, 0.01684935763478279, -0.04118944704532623, 0.015743209049105644, 0.01669679395854473, -0.003298589028418064, -0.0405706986784935, -0.007057209499180317, -0.031487900763750076, 0.06376916170120239, 0.03772549331188202, -0.027997588738799095, -0.005875297822058201, -0.05232720449566841, 0.03521811217069626, -0.008932930417358875, 0.020320629701018333, 0.02541179768741131, 0.017922857776284218, 0.011354714632034302, -0.0558747835457325, 0.06885691732168198, 0.004138587508350611, 0.007441231980919838, -0.027141589671373367, 0.012987522408366203, -0.02887599915266037, -0.019821343943476677, 0.026222575455904007, -0.030858205631375313, -0.017958512529730797, 0.04243962839245796, 0.043522968888282776, -0.038330644369125366, -0.031234383583068848, 0.09532831609249115, -0.014393812976777554, -0.04390765726566315, -0.01836361177265644, 0.002151814056560397, -0.044262006878852844, 0.013504683040082455, -0.011597010307013988, 0.027000650763511658, -0.01871435157954693, 0.03350814804434776, 0.031125495210289955, 0.020969796925783157, 0.024085143581032753, -0.06415929645299911, -0.031649451702833176, -0.02623779885470867, -0.04798612371087074, 0.004926044028252363, -0.0031801401637494564, -0.048887383192777634, -0.07101918756961823, -0.02303660474717617, -0.0069743008352816105, -0.00036136581911705434, 0.004255492705851793, 0.019168343394994736, -0.04159155115485191, -0.011791129596531391, -0.04041063040494919, -0.031737878918647766, -0.03298129513859749, -0.052704911679029465, -0.0019283466972410679, 0.06502945721149445, 0.014909669756889343, 0.038821883499622345, 0.007883390411734581, 0.05847157910466194, -0.024570541456341743, -0.01177214551717043, -0.021912379190325737, -0.0197263415902853, -0.0007871073321439326, 0.03990809991955757, -0.00910353846848011, 0.019342567771673203, -0.018727270886301994, 0.008706487715244293, 0.034329745918512344, -0.02551589347422123, -0.00721985986456275, 0.007935701869428158, 0.03158681094646454, -0.015577071346342564, 0.04412083700299263, 0.014466327615082264, -0.024895615875720978, -0.02302221767604351, 0.038188640028238297, 0.030965056270360947, 0.06375186145305634, -0.052813198417425156, -0.03726036474108696, 0.032243143767118454, -0.02254251390695572, 0.0044463262893259525, 0.013009399175643921, 0.0022833487018942833, -0.009991382248699665, -0.01807571016252041, -0.08403543382883072, -0.05150172859430313, -0.04483954235911369, -0.04096394032239914, -0.0025182454846799374, 0.007085287477821112, -0.008447195403277874, -0.005833532195538282, -0.010578617453575134, 0.011156298220157623, -0.028087686747312546, 0.010912546887993813, 0.01604257896542549, 0.007553888484835625, -0.022348910570144653, -0.026243971660733223, -0.011964436620473862, 0.013140125200152397, -0.008939596824347973, 0.05712110921740532, -0.016462014988064766, 0.015151049941778183, 0.0015100905438885093, 0.021072091534733772, 0.017127932980656624, -0.037091001868247986, 0.013135330751538277, -0.0012885137693956494, -0.016055388376116753, 0.0012854353990405798, -0.03284239396452904, 0.05602189525961876, 0.01614236645400524, -0.04056630656123161, 0.026537885889410973, 0.05383271723985672, -0.006389239802956581, 0.02195720374584198, 0.015352968126535416, -0.031500741839408875, -0.03559868782758713, -0.037010468542575836, 0.04031896963715553, -0.04727208614349365, 0.012648086063563824, -0.01482569519430399, 0.02014770545065403, -0.04768485575914383, -0.06807403266429901, -0.04728291183710098, 0.045111168175935745, 0.022464673966169357 ]
<p>I am using constant density wave propagators to model seismic waves in the subsurface. What I want with these acoustic waves is to estimate the energy of them at a certain grid point at a given time. One approach is using Poynting vectors based on the pressure distribution of the wave </p> <p>$$ \vec{S} = \dot{p} \nabla p. $$</p> <p>The absolute value $|\vec{S}|$ resembles the energy of the wave. Another way (and that's the problem) is based on the accoustic energy flux </p> <p>$$ \vec{I} = p \vec{v},$$ </p> <p>where $\vec{v} = \frac{\vec{k}}{\rho \omega} = \frac{p}{\rho c} $ and $\rho$ is the density of the medium and $c$ is the medium velocity.</p> <p>I want to compare $|\vec{I}|$ and $|\vec{S}|$ but stumble over the problem, that I do not specify $\rho$ in the wave modelling. As I want to compare both energies and use one of them as a threshold for the other, I can not simply assume $\rho$ to be a certain constant.</p> <p>Is there another way to determine $\vec{v}$ without using the density?</p>
g5867
[ 0.04850472882390022, -0.05337042361497879, -0.02379385009407997, -0.06004670262336731, 0.02339300513267517, -0.01623697206377983, 0.021689029410481453, 0.0023024752736091614, -0.06728652864694595, 0.03991754353046417, 0.003474124241620302, -0.03018660843372345, -0.06171663478016853, 0.048768892884254456, 0.0046285041607916355, -0.012647127732634544, 0.03783057630062103, -0.04005436599254608, -0.0034721926786005497, -0.06678842008113861, -0.07964469492435455, -0.06604212522506714, 0.04503369331359863, 0.0017498317174613476, 0.023310910910367966, -0.032465387135744095, -0.03156336769461632, -0.003205531043931842, -0.01758355088531971, -0.01929105445742607, 0.0014282821211963892, -0.01703665778040886, 0.09716819226741791, -0.0704575777053833, -0.014819851145148277, -0.011006318964064121, 0.0660615935921669, 0.06451187282800674, 0.02137199230492115, -0.00801783986389637, 0.01540461741387844, -0.05833166092634201, 0.030234118923544884, 0.04499717429280281, -0.03525209054350853, -0.03144427761435509, -0.04939980432391167, -0.02557813934981823, -0.05567004159092903, -0.016901392489671707, 0.040825407952070236, 0.021789023652672768, -0.007974366657435894, 0.018316593021154404, -0.0307620856910944, 0.049512170255184174, -0.05080830305814743, -0.0077432566322386265, 0.015613952651619911, 0.01789446361362934, -0.016818560659885406, -0.001963441725820303, 0.01776779629290104, -0.025943929329514503, 0.025055991485714912, 0.01527668721973896, -0.06710094213485718, -0.02164629101753235, -0.014513549394905567, -0.010917558334767818, 0.0039596655406057835, -0.0144905811175704, -0.007581578101962805, -0.02775708958506584, -0.04322931542992592, -0.03167670592665672, 0.013574465177953243, -0.029077015817165375, -0.017340723425149918, 0.0054847123101353645, -0.006639012601226568, -0.02501736208796501, 0.06484641879796982, -0.019714822992682457, 0.019709663465619087, -0.010150706395506859, 0.046437907963991165, 0.04176650941371918, 0.023803388699889183, 0.027009716257452965, -0.03176048770546913, 0.01823877915740013, 0.04933938756585121, 0.021607594564557076, 0.011961360462009907, 0.015797371044754982, -0.06233139708638191, 0.10605624318122864, 0.021300794556736946, -0.00012971667456440628, -0.03560802713036537, -0.01354668103158474, -0.0017556882230564952, -0.0016398646403104067, -0.011972666718065739, -0.05339443311095238, -0.009397352114319801, -0.04341603443026543, 0.024769822135567665, -0.021873949095606804, 0.03583377227187157, 0.008258652873337269, -0.00949985533952713, -0.03804391622543335, -0.06512042880058289, -0.0933370366692543, 0.06699801236391068, 0.005152774974703789, -0.03976868838071823, 0.007657743990421295, -0.020354432985186577, 0.011319326236844063, 0.010221780277788639, 0.09463710337877274, 0.00700170174241066, 0.05916990712285042, -0.010996315628290176, 0.029823919758200645, 0.0013569972943514585, -0.010075068101286888, 0.033369533717632294, -0.025584803894162178, -0.0077471304684877396, 0.024909039959311485, 0.04486947879195213, 0.016443172469735146, -0.03524787724018097, 0.017852751538157463, -0.002572923433035612, 0.05378134176135063, -0.010980500839650631, -0.012244828045368195, -0.0016612252220511436, -0.03850806504487991, 0.0018807889427989721, -0.013680199161171913, -0.010932368226349354, -0.03878723457455635, 0.007720979396253824, 0.029478929936885834, 0.033051081001758575, 0.09366387128829956, 0.03159036859869957, 0.013383137062191963, 0.014183002524077892, 0.04544529318809509, 0.08557126671075821, -0.030199596658349037, -0.05913422256708145, 0.013933595269918442, -0.007107107434421778, -0.005386598873883486, 0.09119881689548492, 0.004366748966276646, 0.06009463220834732, 0.02595069259405136, 0.024947425350546837, -0.01361148338764906, 0.03738844022154808, -0.011649795807898045, -0.08317374438047409, 0.01603633537888527, 0.044077616184949875, -0.046280134469270706, 0.0008461739635095, 0.017678216099739075, 0.029230037704110146, -0.03317156806588173, 0.0017994812224060297, 0.02873643860220909, 0.022124573588371277, 0.01004575751721859, 0.04933491721749306, -0.0327824242413044, -0.007585788145661354, 0.042747996747493744, 0.004132475703954697, -0.04259682819247246, -0.037601813673973083, 0.04389282688498497, -0.005634264089167118, -0.02714504487812519, -0.09025293588638306, 0.05150315538048744, -0.032882049679756165, 0.04763316735625267, 0.016025880351662636, -0.033290181308984756, -0.04879436269402504, 0.019829925149679184, -0.0017019120277836919, 0.034463778138160706, 0.07468560338020325, -0.010558846406638622, 0.06504566222429276, 0.008527740836143494, 0.031074339523911476, -0.0408940427005291, 0.00476237665861845, 0.03248805180191994, -0.03031603991985321, -0.059766385704278946, -0.056920476257801056, 0.06920664757490158, -0.01240971963852644, -0.019805289804935455, -0.016629435122013092, 0.052625689655542374, -0.04010825231671333, -0.025227144360542297, -0.1255931705236435, 0.01830919273197651, 0.01942882500588894, 0.021162910386919975, -0.046802762895822525, -0.03606748953461647, 0.009768994525074959, 0.046908389776945114, -0.010186953470110893, -0.031647469848394394, -0.0020321521442383528, -0.006676842458546162, 0.033584028482437134, -0.014084585942327976, 0.010706059634685516, 0.024330252781510353, -0.043773140758275986, -0.004395029973238707, -0.014342468231916428, 0.0248369462788105, -0.0018493961542844772, -0.06984665244817734, -0.03816757723689079, 0.01958315633237362, 0.0764799416065216, -0.008982984349131584, 0.012164274230599403, 0.04686060547828674, 0.032891642302274704, 0.0096584502607584, 0.005741436965763569, 0.01163043174892664, -0.009495150297880173, -0.00857141800224781, 0.02203298546373844, -0.008265959098935127, -0.009269418194890022, -0.003830048954114318, 0.011247815564274788, -0.0036185234785079956, -0.030285993590950966, 0.031241009011864662, 0.059689220041036606, 0.025134844705462456, -0.0020927025470882654, 0.008913232944905758, 0.0266106054186821, 0.028814906254410744, -0.0044816951267421246, 0.001579653238877654, 0.024015028029680252, 0.044273559004068375, 0.029484286904335022, 0.008819379843771458, 0.014014949090778828, 0.015020475722849369, 0.006340000778436661, -0.008210607804358006, 0.019859880208969116, -0.019602244719862938, -0.055423613637685776, 0.008184714242815971, 0.050211671739816666, 0.047759294509887695, 0.06405314058065414, -0.03497958183288574, 0.040900394320487976, -0.018678288906812668, 0.01761949062347412, -0.010452289134263992, -0.04641341045498848, 0.06522388011217117, -0.08007898181676865, 0.00568155013024807, -0.03142494708299637, -0.009225580841302872, 0.02966754510998726, -0.06825697422027588, 0.05855574086308479, 0.026689475402235985, 0.00563663337379694, -0.06452862173318863, -0.038941752165555954, -0.0038021656218916178, 0.035859040915966034, -0.029827982187271118, -0.026466084644198418, 0.00876157358288765, -0.016852324828505516, 0.009997710585594177, -0.011294572614133358, -0.012976614758372307, 0.04326602816581726, -0.03498787805438042, -0.002788916463032365, -0.007721077650785446, 0.01945357397198677, -0.03573007881641388, 0.010442533530294895, -0.03919811546802521, -0.004493759945034981, -0.009206796064972878, 0.039276737719774246, -0.00861282367259264, 0.00007825760258128867, 0.05196574330329895, -0.08055429905653, 0.01958087459206581, -0.10166175663471222, -0.03775940090417862, 0.006883768830448389, -0.015347247011959553, 0.006482147611677647, -0.032690100371837616, -0.019004683941602707, -0.06688016653060913, -0.01345859281718731, -0.0059221051633358, -0.004181477706879377, 0.0632835105061531, -0.03702978417277336, 0.039785876870155334, -0.0597846582531929, -0.008074342273175716, -0.06376216560602188, 0.003058105008676648, 0.0057934788055717945, -0.009935308247804642, 0.016636665910482407, -0.040425579994916916, 0.012245813384652138, 0.002131200861185789, 0.07251358032226562, -0.006423137616366148, -0.018452471122145653, 0.024690674617886543, 0.06571010500192642, 0.02456711418926716, 0.011228442192077637, -0.013897757045924664, 0.02324560098350048, -0.006982685066759586, 0.042169079184532166, -0.06527187675237656, 0.030643219128251076, -0.014894197694957256, 0.008862684480845928, 0.0016220583347603679, 0.012315765954554081, -0.012158868834376335, 0.037160247564315796, -0.024424798786640167, 0.05242948606610298, 0.006706086453050375, 0.027420910075306892, -0.06444035470485687, -0.008555147796869278, 0.00732909981161356, 0.001580169890075922, 0.04770111292600632, 0.011403495445847511, -0.007996542379260063, 0.011899329721927643, 0.03198578953742981, -0.039127372205257416, -0.022204432636499405, -0.01777036115527153, 0.032204076647758484, 0.04501059278845787, -0.025586122646927834, 0.04262946918606758, -0.05911999195814133, -0.03799974173307419, 0.03776363283395767, -0.011799612082540989, -0.02560194581747055, -0.014069918543100357, 0.0005470218020491302, -0.048975661396980286, 0.09986602514982224, -0.03794162720441818, -0.0028398267459124327, -0.012561945244669914, -0.012304610572755337, 0.00521079869940877, 0.027463138103485107, 0.0480271652340889, -0.0043076518923044205, -0.04616349935531616, -0.0030891636852174997, -0.02887316234409809, -0.021250462159514427, 0.0074358428828418255, -0.028860347345471382, -0.018463386222720146, -0.024160461500287056, 0.05942203849554062, -0.024319838732481003, 0.046006761491298676, 0.0453401654958725, -0.023157337680459023, 0.07818757742643356, -0.011829297058284283, -0.0643417239189148, -0.04983236640691757, 0.07300268113613129, 0.05454883724451065, 0.0048621161840856075, 0.012392980046570301, -0.06117177754640579, -0.0038483012467622757, 0.01569564826786518, 0.029010411351919174, 0.02401772327721119, -0.05836385488510132, 0.06540010124444962, -0.026995206251740456, -0.010721982456743717, 0.01668483577668667, -0.06520599126815796, -0.008270170539617538, 0.013002160005271435, 0.011355985887348652, 0.007253431715071201, 0.013098248280584812, 0.10337384045124054, -0.005551033187657595, -0.031112924218177795, -0.064395010471344, -0.03635932877659798, -0.02378341555595398, -0.03585679456591606, 0.019529147073626518, -0.05372565984725952, -0.002690503839403391, 0.016296736896038055, -0.013441676273941994, -0.00020341599883977324, 0.042486224323511124, 0.0026740648318082094, -0.043683383613824844, -0.006664852611720562, -0.0470983162522316, -0.028473693877458572, 0.0645064041018486, -0.014059563167393208, -0.07998576015233994, 0.012729075737297535, 0.006221182644367218, -0.0354643389582634, 0.07220403105020523, -0.041223566979169846, 0.020146150141954422, 0.004248755518347025, -0.028229333460330963, 0.0256801825016737, 0.009260905906558037, 0.01006409153342247, -0.03811183199286461, -0.05065721645951271, 0.005965512711554766, 0.005030957516282797, -0.019452596083283424, 0.01979157142341137, -0.015728529542684555, 0.03198067843914032, -0.008368290960788727, -0.007454832084476948, 0.021668143570423126, 0.026701845228672028, 0.026870518922805786, -0.0013903651852160692, -0.012209583073854446, 0.03901113197207451, 0.029044467955827713, -0.007800266146659851, 0.03816937655210495, -0.060491085052490234, -0.03574688360095024, 0.05660285800695419, -0.0032352865673601627, 0.001110390410758555, -0.0548010990023613, 0.005799697712063789, 0.006099618040025234, 0.0295240581035614, 0.07652111351490021, 0.05412803217768669, -0.001861297874711454, 0.05559423193335533, 0.024645913392305374, 0.004052025731652975, 0.01622559316456318, -0.018124589696526527, 0.003465348156169057, -0.037405796349048615, 0.01464209333062172, 0.012906092219054699, -0.08394622802734375, -0.058377403765916824, 0.07150254398584366, 0.0052534970454871655, 0.029980283230543137, 0.025995098054409027, 0.027560178190469742, -0.025472979992628098, -0.06973705440759659, -0.05926165729761124, 0.013071706518530846, -0.0076497141271829605, 0.02641155757009983, -0.024954454973340034, 0.005116830579936504, -0.024295415729284286, -0.030023306608200073, 0.006058205850422382, -0.05882018059492111, 0.014958149753510952, -0.013672420755028725, -0.05197574570775032, -0.04318917542695999, -0.03449486568570137, 0.03888827934861183, -0.018331393599510193, -0.042883630841970444, 0.049067217856645584, -0.04543209820985794, 0.007992798462510109, -0.0005372589221224189, -0.03583652153611183, -0.04199059680104256, 0.02795942686498165, -0.018606796860694885, -0.019319195300340652, 0.02483239956200123, -0.02576122246682644, -0.003597293049097061, -0.003551112487912178, -0.016975276172161102, 0.03171009197831154, -0.022457018494606018, -0.0010986075503751636, -0.005766782443970442, 0.02729650028049946, 0.004329772666096687, -0.06195901706814766, 0.022817904129624367, -0.01354283094406128, 0.010710913687944412, -0.030271949246525764, -0.01660485379397869, -0.009094045497477055, 0.02363417111337185, -0.040596820414066315, 0.026950974017381668, -0.009882528334856033, 0.005078637506812811, -0.02371806837618351, -0.06415201723575592, 0.016737932339310646, -0.009768124669790268, -0.004871791228652, 0.008651728741824627, 0.04618717357516289, -0.020518969744443893, -0.00826936960220337, -0.003273392328992486, -0.03956618905067444, 0.01097286306321621, 0.034709539264440536, -0.013305381871759892, -0.013249336741864681, -0.03637043386697769, 0.008293671533465385, -0.011312720365822315, -0.04014115780591965, -0.03248647227883339, -0.006134773138910532, -0.02459622174501419, 0.05500417202711105, 0.05260656028985977, 0.020837876945734024, -0.01575186476111412, -0.0031207629945129156, -0.0024256666656583548, -0.014269630424678326, 0.04566467925906181, 0.008891355246305466, -0.02913672849535942, 0.014269589446485043, -0.031948767602443695, 0.04478996992111206, 0.05278518423438072, 0.022257190197706223, 0.022663189098238945, 0.027036193758249283, -0.03303630277514458, 0.02332468330860138, 0.04942762479186058, 0.002469779457896948, 0.045109428465366364, 0.029658915475010872, 0.02361009083688259, 0.012055362574756145, 0.10761738568544388, 0.001417563296854496, -0.07455337792634964, -0.0142302131280303, 0.09117813408374786, -0.018121499568223953, -0.0021842496935278177, 0.0204282496124506, 0.0006692486349493265, 0.07171592116355896, -0.009466946125030518, 0.024533823132514954, -0.027974063530564308, 0.05286091938614845, 0.054018329828977585, 0.0003678450593724847, 0.03731102868914604, 0.0558597706258297, 0.07666788250207901, 0.012959304265677929, -0.017361260950565338, -0.011279886588454247, -0.003616217989474535, -0.016907576471567154, -0.014772632159292698, 0.037187252193689346, 0.043799735605716705, -0.017338596284389496, 0.004886629991233349, -0.02689940296113491, -0.05115773528814316, 0.08263234049081802, 0.014928962104022503, -0.012942490167915821, 0.026759803295135498, 0.04599960893392563, 0.03688659146428108, -0.031076937913894653, 0.03146396204829216, -0.047661423683166504, -0.004402696620672941, 0.013089079409837723, -0.023069798946380615, -0.05597132816910744, 0.04158192127943039, 0.004450974520295858, 0.04489400237798691, -0.05473794788122177, -0.05856563150882721, -0.015442983247339725, 0.018468355759978294, -0.008944347500801086, 0.010417601093649864, 0.013126049190759659, -0.01071274932473898, -0.022987181320786476, 0.0009160485351458192, 0.004679097793996334, -0.023898208513855934, -0.027818765491247177, 0.05314142256975174, 0.07029939442873001, -0.015297789126634598, -0.05596224591135979, 0.03130457177758217, 0.02772584930062294, -0.003827870124951005, 0.0012404285371303558, 0.05351822078227997, 0.004519869573414326, -0.010574517771601677, -0.023602880537509918, 0.018897071480751038, 0.04958539456129074, 0.005332873668521643, 0.00201483815908432, 0.006608759518712759, 0.032390497624874115, 0.01772872544825077, 0.03265639394521713, -0.09975714236497879, -0.032000258564949036, 0.02292632684111595, -0.08896554261445999, -0.014038451947271824, -0.029252564534544945, 0.017869465053081512, 0.014092732220888138, -0.03230692073702812, 0.0020060869865119457, 0.012305975891649723, 0.04955977573990822, -0.07775391638278961, 0.037252094596624374, -0.004559588152915239, -0.047512952238321304, -0.05059197545051575, -0.05752190575003624, -0.000506543496157974, -0.027985194697976112, 0.05451130121946335, -0.00109673454426229, -0.06682271510362625, -0.017103688791394234, 0.004005391616374254, 0.021616926416754723, -0.029071293771266937, -0.017910528928041458, 0.003479279112070799, -0.04222632572054863, -0.034656163305044174, -0.025145575404167175, 0.05076512321829796, 0.03750448301434517, 0.06101597100496292, 0.03195931017398834, -0.0776677206158638, -0.015812447294592857, 0.0175564493983984, 0.05690208449959755, 0.02647237852215767, 0.034332260489463806, -0.01282743364572525, 0.030323274433612823, 0.026902107521891594, -0.031542230397462845, 0.01698373071849346, -0.020123189315199852, 0.0015928286593407393, 0.034428685903549194, -0.007303633261471987, -0.058080531656742096, 0.04998190328478813, -0.05781339481472969, 0.025041304528713226, -0.039450887590646744, -0.04142788425087929, -0.01786969229578972, 0.004285972565412521, -0.03331253305077553, -0.004552190657705069, -0.01860857754945755, -0.002448128769174218, -0.04827297478914261 ]
<p>This is probably a question with a very simple answer, but I want to make sure before I write too much.</p> <p>I'm doing an investigation on Electromagnetic fields, in particular eddy currents and how they decelerate magnets, by sliding a magnet down an incline, recording the time taken and changing the thickness of the aluminium foil that the magnet is running over the top of. My results clearly show that the thicker the foil is the longer the magnet takes to travel down the incline, but I am having a hard time finding theory to back the results up with. So far all I've been able to find so far is the equation below on Wikipedia, despite my best efforts not to rely on it:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/S4DUb.png" alt="Power dissipation"> which finds power dissipation, where</p> <p>P is the power lost per unit mass (W/kg), Bp is the peak magnetic field (T), d is the thickness of the sheet or diameter of the wire (m), f is the frequency (Hz), k is a constant equal to 1 for a thin sheet and 2 for a thin wire, ρ is the resistivity of the material (Ω m), and D is the density of the material (kg/m3).</p> <p>My question is whether this is the function I'm looking for, as thickness is the only one of these variables I'm changing and the rest I can measure, and P=F x V when force is constant, in which case higher thickness=more power lost=decreased velocity - theoretically supporting my results. I'm just not sure though, as I haven't been able to find anywhere saying that this power lost has any relation to what I'm measuring and I don't want to write a few thousand words to be told I had the wrong equation.</p> <p>Thanks, sorry for the wordy post, and if you know any sites that will help me with this other than Wikipedia I'd appreciate it.</p>
g5868
[ 0.07981567084789276, -0.0002657680306583643, -0.007640024181455374, 0.0028525162488222122, 0.060178741812705994, -0.0020607360638678074, 0.07080309092998505, 0.018464382737874985, -0.07157227396965027, 0.019708774983882904, -0.042776063084602356, -0.01982734724879265, -0.041421856731176376, 0.037049196660518646, 0.03673433139920235, 0.020731111988425255, 0.04757770150899887, -0.0326511487364769, 0.044196613132953644, -0.0006439752178266644, 0.0334697850048542, -0.0007157825748436153, -0.01754049025475979, -0.0313342921435833, 0.013636917807161808, -0.012132911011576653, -0.0471854992210865, -0.03345613181591034, -0.061217665672302246, -0.03541453927755356, -0.016179053112864494, -0.008690421469509602, 0.05080564692616463, -0.02327217347919941, -0.04514585807919502, 0.03031611070036888, 0.05216946825385094, 0.050775762647390366, 0.03578837215900421, 0.02430102601647377, -0.001994829624891281, -0.036580171436071396, 0.04605035483837128, 0.058250654488801956, 0.019650964066386223, -0.02252686582505703, -0.08991081267595291, 0.0036893964279443026, -0.051837723702192307, 0.00851436797529459, -0.029506945982575417, -0.03100353479385376, 0.05805692449212074, 0.03334136679768562, -0.06724938005208969, -0.05583302676677704, 0.010654393583536148, -0.07988248020410538, 0.008538924157619476, 0.06108176335692406, -0.011010552756488323, -0.033009905368089676, -0.014359379187226295, -0.04181375727057457, 0.062053997069597244, -0.016951071098446846, -0.00839854683727026, -0.06966814398765564, 0.03779292479157448, -0.022512497380375862, -0.014774578623473644, -0.02872517518699169, -0.03941899165511131, -0.02159811183810234, 0.007182460278272629, 0.0010416149161756039, 0.03218752518296242, -0.012378217652440071, 0.00593323539942503, -0.00024168755044229329, -0.0749778002500534, 0.04962998256087303, 0.007091100327670574, 0.06840502470731735, 0.06850133091211319, 0.007251440081745386, 0.010503269731998444, 0.015503091737627983, 0.0008072697091847658, -0.007070609834045172, 0.010837959125638008, -0.03501104563474655, 0.03087492287158966, -0.04577331244945526, 0.010624542832374573, 0.01481704507023096, 0.046086110174655914, 0.035132020711898804, 0.04401161149144173, 0.03616867959499359, 0.0004281981964595616, -0.062013059854507446, -0.0348348543047905, -0.014173425734043121, -0.015514723025262356, -0.0020444397814571857, 0.03788338601589203, -0.01938968151807785, -0.013491978868842125, 0.03125354275107384, 0.009202364832162857, -0.04914378002285957, -0.07980192452669144, -0.004798021167516708, -0.006081548519432545, -0.08030714094638824, 0.017110589891672134, -0.021113302558660507, -0.007532665040344, 0.024532945826649666, 0.017098620533943176, -0.015169169753789902, -0.002643573097884655, 0.07169323414564133, -0.0071921320632100105, 0.011946582235395908, -0.018284805119037628, 0.056060947477817535, 0.00932127982378006, 0.04459632188081741, -0.001226399908773601, 0.009777987375855446, -0.02810877189040184, 0.015424808487296104, 0.009206922724843025, 0.019033020362257957, -0.005915786139667034, 0.03034251742064953, -0.04543779417872429, 0.026829924434423447, -0.02606315352022648, -0.050696052610874176, 0.06405800580978394, -0.04148238152265549, -0.052239079028367996, 0.02571127377450466, -0.014300908893346786, 0.0029283463954925537, 0.08228688687086105, -0.058763064444065094, 0.05759463459253311, 0.043588314205408096, 0.03055834397673607, -0.07741003483533859, 0.02729884162545204, -0.0010509636485949159, 0.007336349226534367, -0.031217461451888084, 0.041957270354032516, 0.005113921593874693, 0.0317855067551136, -0.02634456939995289, 0.03344716504216194, -0.007877320051193237, -0.011635741218924522, 0.007547276560217142, -0.011382214725017548, 0.04437735304236412, -0.0007739902939647436, -0.03066989593207836, -0.05365389958024025, 0.02125309780240059, 0.0846279114484787, 0.05558125302195549, -0.03511390835046768, 0.0286371149122715, 0.09593009948730469, -0.04397740215063095, -0.03163870796561241, -0.007129899226129055, -0.00968928448855877, 0.04215860739350319, 0.06974205374717712, -0.04180218651890755, 0.04466361179947853, 0.02981272153556347, 0.006379059515893459, -0.03291929513216019, -0.07889897376298904, -0.02580573782324791, 0.003087754361331463, -0.044598013162612915, 0.014651280827820301, -0.001522408565506339, -0.015279044397175312, -0.027239978313446045, -0.012994220480322838, 0.020541375502943993, -0.038902707397937775, -0.03995252773165703, -0.009538714773952961, 0.00847990345209837, 0.10664143413305283, 0.02308487705886364, -0.0036089036148041487, -0.029517799615859985, -0.05967193841934204, 0.038124460726976395, 0.05322642996907234, -0.020445799455046654, 0.017842188477516174, 0.048984985798597336, -0.015204946510493755, 0.04246725142002106, 0.04405923932790756, -0.006929856259375811, -0.03290560841560364, 0.018334070220589638, -0.003786518005654216, 0.010336406528949738, -0.017482830211520195, -0.0162129495292902, 0.04653993621468544, 0.04159926995635033, -0.09725026041269302, -0.0861281156539917, 0.002022558357566595, -0.02502559684216976, 0.0001893359876703471, -0.05724409222602844, -0.05582405626773834, 0.033120494335889816, -0.029220324009656906, -0.026786264032125473, 0.03375697508454323, 0.01076124794781208, -0.016033172607421875, -0.01800677180290222, 0.02063797414302826, -0.02318224497139454, 0.015875430777668953, -0.008597079664468765, -0.04493151605129242, -0.029802914708852768, 0.010292191058397293, -0.008798123337328434, 0.0029329999815672636, 0.0024924571625888348, 0.022504156455397606, 0.04308760166168213, 0.03403017297387123, -0.008814902044832706, -0.03014080971479416, 0.028792306780815125, -0.0028357296250760555, -0.004446317441761494, -0.03260325640439987, 0.0027140239253640175, -0.025656340643763542, -0.027464551851153374, 0.014237664639949799, -0.026473838835954666, 0.015998097136616707, 0.047026872634887695, -0.04753768444061279, -0.0018004687735810876, -0.060384683310985565, -0.0010423838393762708, 0.022676436230540276, -0.0029977678786963224, 0.0018865243764594197, 0.083415687084198, -0.026520388200879097, 0.03847481310367584, 0.01833571307361126, -0.016426758840680122, 0.060935333371162415, -0.021569300442934036, 0.03833154961466789, 0.03215319663286209, 0.01875954493880272, -0.040389616042375565, -0.031810879707336426, -0.014330905862152576, 0.0018288320861756802, -0.006676720920950174, 0.00717516615986824, -0.0037894088309258223, -0.053870197385549545, 0.013620523735880852, -0.025729741901159286, 0.00465710973367095, 0.08558797836303711, -0.003480265848338604, -0.0016007437370717525, 0.08199634402990341, 0.07461562752723694, -0.09130512177944183, -0.019316568970680237, -0.036703020334243774, 0.013773300684988499, 0.01074599102139473, -0.014709994196891785, -0.011488781310617924, 0.011481428518891335, 0.05712291970849037, -0.018393736332654953, -0.05192367732524872, 0.01187437865883112, 0.01314518041908741, -0.02259964309632778, 0.000006010005563439336, 0.08288609981536865, 0.012777871452271938, -0.044134512543678284, -0.05720359832048416, 0.012811186723411083, 0.005647249985486269, 0.010968126356601715, 0.008561085909605026, -0.032256949692964554, -0.04249100014567375, -0.00833908561617136, 0.002866019494831562, 0.033613421022892, 0.03596613183617592, -0.03662960231304169, 0.02058594860136509, -0.06056612357497215, -0.01720505952835083, -0.007983478717505932, 0.03331543505191803, 0.003477460937574506, -0.04048306122422218, -0.024155013263225555, 0.0423811674118042, 0.05615922808647156, 0.034756459295749664, 0.028197456151247025, 0.04145000874996185, 0.017061907798051834, -0.045740555971860886, -0.06677545607089996, 0.03032221831381321, -0.011474848724901676, -0.000056146491260733455, -0.015038139186799526, -0.014464416541159153, -0.008200309239327908, 0.013824187219142914, 0.05001595988869667, 0.01780891790986061, 0.024768603965640068, -0.04973820224404335, -0.010752098634839058, -0.021443922072649002, 0.03063654899597168, -0.006833850406110287, -0.011436793021857738, 0.045140527188777924, 0.0208186786621809, -0.03455878421664238, 0.004548080265522003, -0.04165104031562805, -0.041006237268447876, 0.03418511152267456, -0.005070743151009083, 0.08431319892406464, -0.07834652811288834, -0.04752226918935776, -0.005134982522577047, -0.00321855116635561, -0.050160013139247894, 0.017671290785074234, -0.00558186462149024, -0.03775709494948387, -0.0053933714516460896, -0.0013344463659450412, -0.03264395147562027, 0.05703653022646904, 0.01838012784719467, 0.06801654398441315, -0.0204455703496933, 0.020589856430888176, -0.0283220037817955, -0.004580318927764893, -0.02564341202378273, -0.0225577000528574, 0.009750832803547382, -0.000934997049625963, -0.028062064200639725, 0.008545564487576485, -0.01584361121058464, 0.020710257813334465, 0.012370798736810684, -0.003318587550893426, -0.05626925826072693, 0.03725128620862961, -0.0006151451962068677, -0.0033139511942863464, 0.015360656194388866, 0.06472966820001602, -0.0245125163346529, 0.06885004043579102, 0.03089446946978569, 0.013905864208936691, 0.06524006277322769, -0.04491342976689339, 0.018261175602674484, 0.014843452721834183, -0.013048876076936722, -0.08994854986667633, -0.05330810323357582, -0.029935011640191078, -0.029250618070364, 0.012978668324649334, 0.029249487444758415, 0.02884405292570591, 0.01858161948621273, -0.017230527475476265, 0.038150396198034286, 0.047808632254600525, -0.013893296010792255, -0.021167540922760963, -0.027292361482977867, 0.008095303550362587, 0.0166424959897995, 0.04710172489285469, 0.010861155577003956, 0.016066137701272964, -0.0226798914372921, 0.024276724085211754, -0.005575213115662336, 0.0003343784192111343, -0.03361130505800247, 0.06862328201532364, 0.01348915509879589, 0.017344510182738304, -0.013165406882762909, 0.04501214623451233, 0.03157472983002663, -0.011134175583720207, 0.005769526585936546, -0.0443502739071846, -0.05861552059650421, 0.020224163308739662, -0.04933555796742439, -0.002945988206192851, -0.033559177070856094, -0.03114723041653633, -0.031066909432411194, 0.012400099076330662, -0.06600285321474075, 0.014406713657081127, -0.0281491968780756, -0.028623584657907486, 0.022721271961927414, -0.04504894092679024, 0.06702516227960587, 0.02788718231022358, -0.06130502000451088, 0.04319079592823982, -0.03085341490805149, -0.013514142483472824, -0.07380226254463196, 0.02008369192481041, -0.006640515755861998, -0.03176036849617958, -0.05486828461289406, 0.041571762412786484, 0.023547539487481117, -0.042072247713804245, 0.009309964254498482, -0.00040992911090143025, 0.015082317404448986, 0.02059057727456093, 0.005042579025030136, 0.054318808019161224, -0.03208792954683304, -0.03159838542342186, -0.03709506243467331, 0.04411588981747627, 0.04376215860247612, -0.06475457549095154, 0.0002394635375821963, 0.036723699420690536, -0.06976193934679031, -0.013772095553576946, 0.0753571093082428, -0.10367374867200851, 0.017124930396676064, -0.0236344076693058, 0.028400026261806488, 0.0063794273883104324, -0.025739483535289764, 0.01482430100440979, 0.0553879514336586, 0.04912393167614937, -0.038752343505620956, 0.02474597468972206, 0.021531200036406517, 0.045500773936510086, -0.04719216004014015, -0.005376775283366442, -0.03145667538046837, 0.030507152900099754, 0.05731179565191269, -0.011701695621013641, 0.05998387560248375, 0.09708308428525925, -0.03462884947657585, 0.05709715560078621, 0.04160318523645401, -0.0006370287155732512, -0.01754751428961754, 0.0019645579159259796, -0.0410890057682991, 0.04616944491863251, -0.02872517518699169, 0.014820891432464123, 0.05964909866452217, 0.02740621194243431, 0.08147062361240387, -0.019547244533896446, -0.025200720876455307, 0.038158584386110306, -0.09022855758666992, 0.03285770118236542, 0.031786397099494934, -0.047319311648607254, 0.05720454454421997, 0.008508301340043545, -0.035491712391376495, -0.029386820271611214, -0.06916370242834091, 0.0011910817120224237, 0.06921511888504028, -0.04270944744348526, -0.002502942457795143, -0.013781847432255745, -0.04051554948091507, 0.013678769581019878, 0.013184992596507072, 0.03532588109374046, -0.004658309277147055, 0.015232337638735771, 0.024900099262595177, -0.05512681603431702, 0.04275122657418251, -0.064472995698452, -0.04612063989043236, -0.011986682191491127, 0.022099552676081657, 0.06895145028829575, -0.03921088948845863, 0.005038147326558828, 0.08095823228359222, -0.01849609613418579, 0.04158879444003105, 0.013931146822869778, -0.010401284322142601, -0.0361967608332634, -0.016249854117631912, 0.02128269337117672, 0.03760922700166702, -0.034333888441324234, 0.03242138773202896, 0.00882093608379364, 0.02654106169939041, 0.02287551574409008, -0.025596484541893005, 0.018084533512592316, 0.008824951946735382, 0.02684326283633709, -0.004427683539688587, 0.0217688400298357, -0.08097391575574875, -0.045083217322826385, -0.0025602292735129595, -0.0531967394053936, -0.017449287697672844, 0.024440014734864235, 0.027836252003908157, -0.0037614128086715937, 0.0055644577369093895, -0.0032597468234598637, -0.057185664772987366, -0.036800652742385864, 0.08038078993558884, -0.04047407954931259, -0.008457808755338192, 0.02559453435242176, 0.03529161214828491, -0.008704866282641888, -0.047655194997787476, 0.02903810143470764, -0.013979678973555565, -0.015811175107955933, 0.008380129002034664, 0.038756340742111206, 0.007990103214979172, -0.027505602687597275, 0.008221566677093506, -0.02216021530330181, 0.05125368759036064, -0.03626253083348274, 0.06310758739709854, -0.00974301714450121, -0.009681536816060543, -0.0513390451669693, 0.016149180009961128, 0.04446735978126526, -0.01019987091422081, 0.03568393364548683, -0.03815633803606033, -0.03827890381217003, 0.009862018749117851, -0.012157399207353592, -0.016108306124806404, 0.0020309120882302523, -0.010530248284339905, -0.043833401054143906, -0.020341036841273308, -0.03946375101804733, 0.03899938240647316, 0.024241453036665916, -0.0035989019088447094, 0.009037695825099945, -0.00025318615371361375, -0.028219003230333328, -0.018869344145059586, 0.04027734324336052, -0.04376904293894768, 0.03598816320300102, 0.011978904716670513, 0.030067037791013718, 0.019740363582968712, 0.013646175153553486, 0.016988039016723633, 0.011721685528755188, -0.004952582530677319, 0.013904212974011898, 0.009189577773213387, 0.0683242455124855, -0.06821863353252411, -0.059562645852565765, 0.0032792678102850914, 0.03983267396688461, -0.012570176273584366, 0.020731836557388306, 0.03226907178759575, 0.03746294602751732, -0.023335421457886696, 0.009262687526643276, -0.0018270591972395778, -0.0011656206334009767, -0.018303394317626953, -0.008756914176046848, 0.0239007156342268, -0.019231896847486496, -0.01065993495285511, -0.08813921362161636, -0.0005940630217082798, -0.004701403435319662, -0.03738469257950783, 0.0022162040695548058, -0.002387697109952569, -0.010364254005253315, 0.004117946140468121, -0.01554465014487505, 0.003499830374494195, -0.011332293972373009, 0.0028649151790887117, -0.03269096091389656, 0.0027740790974348783, -0.012861141934990883, -0.015276354737579823, -0.044266484677791595, -0.011266703717410564, 0.0023421025834977627, -0.03260856121778488, 0.0017340085469186306, 0.007943731732666492, -0.012946365401148796, -0.006334576290100813, 0.0012266389094293118, -0.07756509631872177, 0.035329654812812805, 0.02568672224879265, 0.05208948254585266, -0.06555595993995667, -0.006270349491387606, 0.07051511853933334, 0.022606778889894485, 0.0011575751705095172, 0.002819398185238242, 0.0037339499685913324, 0.009925813414156437, 0.047230884432792664, 0.0006466920021921396, 0.035385746508836746, -0.004505358170717955, 0.029615797102451324, 0.02653764933347702, -0.06358781456947327, 0.03739168122410774, -0.03364862874150276, -0.023332646116614342, -0.08216645568609238, 0.009267587214708328, 0.04247148334980011, 0.02226267382502556, 0.03817499056458473, 0.007276593241840601, 0.05079125985503197, 0.05237066373229027, -0.061101656407117844, -0.06132035702466965, -0.03622191399335861, -0.028748340904712677, 0.002486293902620673, 0.013069982640445232, -0.000024653370928717777, -0.053846172988414764, 0.018686659634113312, -0.030609533190727234, -0.007758827414363623, -0.011233908124268055, -0.03248590603470802, 0.00010721527360146865, -0.012665697373449802, -0.027204936370253563, -0.01897405833005905, -0.034645482897758484, -0.005621934775263071, -0.053607743233442307, 0.05725787952542305, 0.023925691843032837, -0.021999046206474304, 0.015457214787602425, 0.021973296999931335, 0.007431682199239731, -0.04549434781074524, 0.018463557586073875, 0.007363281212747097, 0.0019719921983778477, -0.015748700127005577, 0.07517301291227341, 0.03947225585579872, -0.018818456679582596, 0.01592320390045643, 0.04414502903819084, -0.04564020782709122, 0.027074657380580902, 0.005502958782017231, -0.03887978568673134, 0.0273487139493227, 0.030334964394569397, 0.001885027508251369, -0.014764169231057167, -0.04922302067279816, -0.01762918196618557, -0.026788482442498207, -0.009182224981486797, -0.011836242862045765, -0.04425963759422302, 0.0009622728684917092, 0.04872933775186539 ]
<p><strong>Can we get the information of things that are gone in black hole?</strong></p>
g207
[ 0.009656321257352829, -0.017275087535381317, -0.003150606993585825, -0.00838039256632328, 0.03402501344680786, 0.025449451059103012, -0.035384878516197205, 0.006916753016412258, -0.003808715147897601, -0.017778007313609123, 0.005884252488613129, 0.04182404652237892, 0.017856217920780182, 0.0027827282901853323, -0.039881348609924316, -0.026425354182720184, 0.03870739787817001, -0.05067303031682968, 0.03537660837173462, 0.004546445794403553, 0.04926539957523346, -0.03636643663048744, 0.06697682291269302, -0.03308757394552231, -0.0401085689663887, 0.013768204487860203, 0.046676501631736755, -0.02482043020427227, -0.04633690416812897, 0.009889830835163593, 0.030779022723436356, -0.028392931446433067, 0.013839208520948887, -0.002537280786782503, -0.0008149989880621433, -0.029944438487291336, 0.08460140228271484, 0.031771570444107056, 0.0203187707811594, 0.01707427203655243, 0.01633487083017826, -0.05050688609480858, -0.007794909179210663, -0.027657685801386833, -0.03418952599167824, -0.028982095420360565, 0.04353383556008339, 0.022773468866944313, -0.001962758833542466, -0.07768090069293976, -0.0037309848703444004, 0.017894789576530457, 0.04392404481768608, 0.016150537878274918, 0.05671548843383789, 0.003064357675611973, -0.009000284597277641, -0.0459400936961174, 0.05983876809477806, -0.017958927899599075, -0.027020150795578957, 0.0004911855794489384, 0.05326918512582779, 0.018879935145378113, 0.022211497649550438, 0.028941750526428223, -0.10696829855442047, -0.007269762456417084, -0.07701138406991959, 0.010630566626787186, 0.07358676195144653, 0.07785552740097046, 0.006647147238254547, 0.04839261248707771, -0.043325647711753845, 0.04557332396507263, -0.04563480615615845, 0.02467266656458378, -0.006680038757622242, 0.002712295623496175, 0.004647756926715374, -0.006775042973458767, 0.0015556091675534844, -0.016943076625466347, 0.04897519201040268, 0.027523037046194077, -0.01095557026565075, 0.024574454873800278, 0.014127206988632679, 0.05461026728153229, 0.06222091242671013, -0.03100399486720562, 0.057603079825639725, 0.028469089418649673, 0.024990614503622055, 0.07958881556987762, 0.011716672219336033, -0.013935767114162445, 0.00428258441388607, -0.009235595352947712, -0.05823444947600365, -0.035960301756858826, -0.06833824515342712, -0.04229192063212395, 0.03568486124277115, -0.008202040567994118, -0.018552297726273537, 0.014443785883486271, -0.019450725987553596, 0.06088598817586899, 0.029966626316308975, -0.03973463177680969, -0.0035723557230085135, 0.037808969616889954, 0.011771093122661114, -0.028751762583851814, 0.06861776858568192, -0.029072783887386322, -0.05307391285896301, 0.05678084120154381, -0.0627288818359375, 0.017797451466321945, 0.06897786259651184, 0.03690659999847412, 0.053742554038763046, -0.08240175247192383, 0.008817820809781551, -0.01533643901348114, 0.04077201709151268, 0.006210222374647856, -0.04886476695537567, -0.0015106239588931203, -0.031077265739440918, 0.0967027023434639, -0.03236788883805275, -0.01729998178780079, 0.04203012213110924, 0.010756694711744785, 0.029193630442023277, 0.0204574316740036, 0.016543788835406303, 0.03524861857295036, -0.010601047426462173, 0.03633951023221016, 0.03512285649776459, -0.03581782802939415, 0.031464021652936935, -0.01044598687440157, -0.00006306542491074651, -0.0576259084045887, 0.032492730766534805, 0.04331732168793678, 0.022761927917599678, 0.007743181195110083, -0.018031029030680656, -0.04438137635588646, 0.014102634973824024, 0.010097152553498745, 0.018359553068876266, 0.07058130204677582, 0.044710688292980194, -0.0007197430822998285, 0.005702268332242966, 0.07515872269868851, -0.004034003708511591, -0.03359948843717575, 0.024454718455672264, -0.024790413677692413, 0.062408383935689926, 0.03397662565112114, -0.025175265967845917, 0.017249222844839096, 0.041250213980674744, 0.0073561351746320724, -0.001974507700651884, 0.0220323633402586, 0.014167413115501404, -0.01931046135723591, 0.03688376024365425, 0.022193921729922295, 0.0047853910364210606, -0.016490066424012184, 0.030284876003861427, 0.011838261038064957, 0.009295198135077953, -0.0006520157912746072, -0.014978381805121899, 0.04043768718838692, 0.052256014198064804, 0.022584358230233192, -0.06107226386666298, -0.033193059265613556, 0.0374177023768425, 0.012464700266718864, 0.04529504477977753, -0.010849973186850548, 0.026271753013134003, -0.015815945342183113, -0.0012217055773362517, 0.053109992295503616, -0.005518235731869936, 0.022203968837857246, -0.008112654089927673, 0.006791446823626757, -0.008148357272148132, -0.05688020586967468, 0.034999072551727295, 0.0566154345870018, -0.03978773579001427, 0.015552164055407047, 0.036566831171512604, -0.009396519511938095, 0.012557962909340858, 0.01364099606871605, -0.03145599737763405, 0.036634661257267, -0.044945478439331055, 0.019860822707414627, 0.01466180756688118, 0.0016651758924126625, -0.023058418184518814, -0.0138201043009758, -0.03356074169278145, -0.04753466695547104, 0.00036770279984921217, 0.06938328593969345, -0.006263382267206907, -0.06960155814886093, -0.03711175173521042, -0.04911103844642639, -0.06047174334526062, -0.002592365490272641, 0.018195740878582, 0.011081219650804996, 0.001061228453181684, 0.014002821408212185, 0.014512071385979652, -0.03277422860264778, 0.026030754670500755, 0.07894419133663177, -0.0032206596806645393, 0.0005676919245161116, -0.03903419151902199, -0.04167965054512024, 0.004495291505008936, 0.04991685599088669, -0.04147936776280403, -0.014117777347564697, 0.03806203231215477, 0.03081401251256466, -0.00553593086078763, -0.03962216153740883, 0.05543278530240059, 0.024781430140137672, -0.02297113835811615, 0.001172205084003508, 0.014190226793289185, -0.022199923172593117, -0.057946257293224335, -0.054533254355192184, 0.03705306351184845, 0.004098277539014816, 0.03050083853304386, 0.04393019154667854, -0.021432295441627502, -0.041990164667367935, -0.017454929649829865, -0.042260896414518356, 0.002010663505643606, 0.025766657665371895, -0.0725494846701622, 0.011930763721466064, 0.032258301973342896, 0.022975517436861992, 0.0155952712520957, 0.05806998908519745, -0.0634431391954422, 0.039014168083667755, -0.02312723733484745, 0.00039075405220501125, -0.05780421197414398, 0.06337282061576843, -0.0684390515089035, 0.006211784202605486, -0.06740526854991913, -0.04930143058300018, -0.017776114866137505, 0.017839737236499786, -0.05514294281601906, 0.014385076239705086, -0.007163090165704489, 0.024297095835208893, 0.045197878032922745, 0.07930485159158707, -0.01511047501116991, -0.0014710873365402222, -0.006658199243247509, -0.00691599166020751, 0.018865667283535004, -0.04514350742101669, 0.09365180134773254, -0.0056912899017333984, -0.06602698564529419, 0.020712560042738914, 0.007204788271337748, -0.011458395048975945, 0.010860880836844444, 0.0083426209166646, 0.03578878939151764, -0.03493739664554596, 0.046520862728357315, 0.009265163913369179, 0.04865242913365364, 0.06774178147315979, -0.033797185868024826, 0.0329497791826725, 0.011918623931705952, 0.010407812893390656, -0.00409771129488945, 0.005622211378067732, 0.017827142030000687, -0.02591722644865513, -0.004214562010020018, -0.01293802261352539, 0.051344674080610275, 0.001074406085535884, -0.015880314633250237, -0.0586763471364975, -0.0317126028239727, 0.014185844920575619, -0.03408271446824074, 0.002814151346683502, 0.020123088732361794, 0.01594727113842964, -0.05879947543144226, 0.04800734296441078, -0.05072472244501114, -0.036318499594926834, 0.0598314106464386, -0.013464244082570076, 0.06787965446710587, -0.009016831405460835, -0.03500429913401604, 0.06661050766706467, -0.03360847011208534, 0.007777789141982794, -0.02806771546602249, -0.03902319446206093, 0.008020022884011269, -0.04678861051797867, 0.03242862597107887, -0.0039061056450009346, 0.05104716494679451, -0.07914584875106812, -0.017237965017557144, 0.028070783242583275, 0.06323008239269257, -0.01870807260274887, 0.056844014674425125, -0.0062509821727871895, -0.0316811241209507, -0.05237605795264244, 0.05088524520397186, -0.02627343125641346, -0.06439314037561417, 0.018398094922304153, 0.028956757858395576, 0.014646531082689762, 0.017626116052269936, 0.0012479766737669706, 0.03631019592285156, 0.027835320681333542, -0.029552480205893517, 0.014169564470648766, -0.02459706924855709, -0.04958109185099602, 0.030063195154070854, -0.007047433406114578, 0.0040467348881065845, -0.0007925920654088259, 0.09251061081886292, 0.011359971947968006, 0.03425860032439232, 0.004698419477790594, -0.04246673360466957, -0.03154303506016731, -0.00022059434559196234, -0.027974305674433708, -0.048137400299310684, -0.04998621717095375, -0.035786278545856476, -0.03407258912920952, -0.022102104499936104, -0.027696384117007256, -0.022386912256479263, -0.07212313264608383, 0.017772197723388672, 0.010540658608078957, 0.018792754039168358, -0.013709760271012783, -0.05162160471081734, 0.02734249271452427, 0.0432184673845768, 0.026353763416409492, 0.029972121119499207, 0.004729743115603924, -0.02301284670829773, -0.06738723069429398, 0.005013144109398127, -0.033229760825634, -0.007145253475755453, -0.018976744264364243, -0.02849501185119152, -0.045515164732933044, -0.017664717510342598, -0.0460689477622509, 0.00982265267521143, -0.0360763780772686, 0.025500787422060966, -0.057019513100385666, 0.08595138043165207, -0.006187279708683491, 0.029535258188843727, 0.03241851180791855, -0.058717817068099976, -0.011187496595084667, -0.02496027573943138, -0.02201678790152073, 0.012582572177052498, -0.009193765930831432, 0.020097557455301285, 0.0019949551206082106, 0.0032115464564412832, 0.022388005629181862, -0.04184362292289734, 0.04931141063570976, -0.03664262220263481, -0.008526436053216457, -0.03554106876254082, 0.06791136413812637, 0.02386385016143322, -0.03292585909366608, 0.04243915155529976, -0.056295327842235565, 0.0013226527953520417, 0.018015868961811066, 0.0339287593960762, 0.09658678621053696, -0.002578477608039975, -0.012954618781805038, 0.0009653843590058386, -0.02699429728090763, 0.0050636036321520805, -0.055055875331163406, 0.028053799644112587, 0.040008023381233215, -0.0305760707706213, 0.0013560184743255377, -0.022602304816246033, 0.03553110361099243, -0.06309724599123001, -0.01696164347231388, 0.03226565942168236, 0.03318362310528755, -0.026396287605166435, -0.05324305593967438, -0.07962335646152496, -0.025342268869280815, -0.028903529047966003, 0.01056031882762909, -0.04329520836472511, 0.01458254735916853, 0.043879974633455276, 0.015078842639923096, -0.07872157543897629, 0.037835173308849335, -0.0623595267534256, -0.029664508998394012, 0.007063743192702532, -0.00782211683690548, -0.029423445463180542, 0.036178234964609146, -0.00156476313713938, -0.01441244687885046, -0.00296600884757936, 0.03288170322775841, -0.05151115357875824, 0.049800336360931396, -0.05892225354909897, 0.0053583006374537945, -0.03170888498425484, 0.009367651306092739, 0.04064272344112396, 0.005940716248005629, -0.03718390688300133, -0.05055175721645355, -0.00300564500503242, -0.029088351875543594, -0.006827831733971834, 0.0413527712225914, -0.018693100661039352, 0.013893232680857182, -0.002927399706095457, 0.02783595584332943, -0.02426585927605629, 0.026517469435930252, 0.0032081855461001396, -0.014800021424889565, -0.01634654402732849, 0.017337646335363388, 0.02957833744585514, 0.038557711988687515, -0.05693585053086281, 0.019955329596996307, -0.012497258372604847, -0.004674247931689024, 0.03173041716217995, 0.058750443160533905, -0.026599636301398277, -0.027321182191371918, -0.032639481127262115, 0.015963761135935783, 0.08013615757226944, 0.009822104126214981, 0.01576288230717182, -0.017984725534915924, -0.05298824980854988, 0.022799473255872726, 0.07510864734649658, -0.010389401577413082, 0.04354371130466461, 0.04040960967540741, -0.04481876268982887, 0.010012893006205559, 0.031478919088840485, -0.027769386768341064, 0.04340674728155136, -0.007856711745262146, 0.0016238255193457007, -0.03621785342693329, 0.0011328959371894598, 0.008028039708733559, -0.04428777098655701, 0.05332095921039581, 0.02587934397161007, -0.0262526273727417, -0.04847964271903038, -0.02571794204413891, 0.025318939238786697, -0.0036580804735422134, -0.004870683420449495, -0.03000938892364502, 0.013270190916955471, -0.00466872937977314, -0.08986722677946091, -0.043171823024749756, 0.031231651082634926, -0.028362467885017395, -0.02296563982963562, -0.034516192972660065, -0.03022860921919346, 0.008074413053691387, 0.010727187618613243, 0.02278594858944416, -0.008261382579803467, -0.034349437803030014, 0.009780357591807842, 0.024460557848215103, 0.014858025126159191, -0.008326432667672634, -0.03618716076016426, 0.02645762637257576, -0.014737997204065323, -0.011232076212763786, 0.022244242951273918, 0.009175301529467106, -0.007552395109087229, 0.02432931587100029, 0.0029990070033818483, -0.05754968523979187, -0.050899919122457504, 0.004504004027694464, 0.07637180387973785, -0.02551412209868431, -0.00630264263600111, -0.01248590275645256, -0.0236564539372921, 0.04626483470201492, 0.0457170270383358, -0.005877737421542406, 0.05348416790366173, 0.036155059933662415, 0.054551247507333755, -0.05807258561253548, -0.09713465720415115, 0.004983169957995415, -0.0320727713406086, -0.03580574691295624, 0.0026892314199358225, -0.029180733487010002, -0.06690051406621933, 0.032045911997556686, 0.011052303947508335, 0.019358579069375992, 0.0010696311946958303, 0.0050582741387188435, -0.004216204397380352, -0.0772232636809349, 0.017592014744877815, -0.018672065809369087, 0.03060556948184967, -0.013323026709258556, -0.06634809821844101, 0.022987719625234604, -0.01089661754667759, -0.04350826516747475, -0.018648922443389893, -0.06736961007118225, -0.004632947966456413, -0.03528787940740585, 0.01294991560280323, 0.011026994325220585, -0.009023169986903667, -0.026700908318161964, 0.056412409991025925, 0.02480962499976158, -0.010823915712535381, 0.0032527740113437176, -0.04452965036034584, 0.043628282845020294, 0.0365554615855217, 0.06623353064060211, 0.026755964383482933, -0.03210890293121338, 0.02732684649527073, 0.07228706777095795, -0.042973387986421585, 0.06645761430263519, -0.001467847148887813, -0.04233213886618614, 0.050890516489744186, -0.053473882377147675, -0.0067123910412192345, 0.006435740739107132, -0.04246794804930687, 0.04992310702800751, 0.06612096726894379, 0.046128809452056885, -0.05873033031821251, -0.010093620978295803, 0.06045880913734436, 0.01113404706120491, -0.029044881463050842, -0.04045308753848076, -0.05074036121368408, -0.04375477880239487, -0.047608308494091034, 0.0157058946788311, -0.06130019947886467, -0.049796417355537415, 0.031097909435629845, -0.029147014021873474, -0.07331573218107224, -0.036873627454042435, -0.0026607548352330923, 0.02114369161427021, 0.03965038061141968, -0.036440975964069366, -0.017279384657740593, 0.005547074601054192, 0.006035372149199247, -0.04121549427509308, -0.0627879798412323, -0.014570706523954868, -0.026702499017119408, -0.06996404379606247, 0.017415840178728104, 0.03927522897720337, 0.0015076770214363933, 0.02801705338060856, 0.04700874537229538, 0.019666900858283043, -0.014931942336261272, 0.042185209691524506, -0.02007371000945568, 0.02001781389117241, -0.038589172065258026, 0.008748275227844715, -0.006612851284444332, 0.025796005502343178, -0.0320965014398098, -0.016473468393087387, 0.006235214415937662, -0.064401775598526, 0.013515434227883816, -0.05501211807131767, -0.01845029555261135, 0.005043309647589922, -0.034229177981615067, -0.02980460599064827, 0.02877279929816723, 0.02950149029493332, 0.008865159004926682, -0.022151309996843338, -0.013340339995920658, 0.0012563351774588227, 0.0009013052913360298, -0.04439811408519745, -0.002032139804214239, 0.025940988212823868, 0.03150557354092598, 0.01904052123427391, -0.02642384171485901, -0.009331224486231804, -0.02173861861228943, 0.02568759024143219, 0.04824342951178551, -0.019450780004262924, 0.011774946935474873, -0.003994851838797331, -0.025081148371100426, 0.02922835573554039, -0.08783937990665436, 0.004843174479901791, -0.050041329115629196, 0.012160824611783028, 0.015212628059089184, 0.07522601634263992, -0.05595603212714195, 0.017799513414502144, -0.0325777567923069, 0.011485056020319462, -0.026209870353341103, 0.015751298516988754, 0.028031282126903534, 0.03182061016559601, -0.004130971152335405, 0.02411412075161934, -0.020976241677999496, 0.02535439468920231, 0.01380078960210085, -0.029668426141142845, 0.02426329255104065, -0.013600326143205166, -0.011160260997712612, -0.057561688125133514, -0.010332458652555943, 0.024683112278580666, 0.04895061254501343, -0.02726525068283081, 0.058907754719257355, 0.0118830231949687, 0.03493085131049156, 0.030110718682408333, -0.049881987273693085, -0.028184091672301292, -0.003269537817686796, -0.0754665955901146, -0.04190216213464737, 0.011731919832527637, 0.033334050327539444, 0.059729017317295074, -0.017455238848924637, 0.018204886466264725, 0.047756679356098175, -0.01767260581254959, 0.04782850667834282, 0.015842774882912636 ]
<p>In the 2-slit experiment, is it possible to "account" for all of the energy in the incoming beam - i.e. does all of the incoming energy show up in the bright spots or is some of it "destroyed" when destructive interference takes place?</p> <p>If it is destroyed, what form is it converted into?</p> <p>If it's NOT destroyed, what would happen if you allowed the light to pass through a hole where the dark spot had been, then, exploiting the different angle that each path arrived from, organised things such that these waves now reinforced each other? We would then have a situation where more energy comes out than goes in. Which is impossible. Or does "spooky action at a distance" come into play and the overall brightness of the previous spots slightly dim to account for the new path?</p>
g5869
[ 0.006554107181727886, -0.01785757765173912, 0.008159302175045013, -0.008773134090006351, -0.0013798060826957226, -0.0032332336995750666, 0.01050033699721098, 0.061905115842819214, 0.002483433112502098, -0.0378551222383976, 0.04744178429245949, 0.007959356531500816, -0.016775814816355705, -0.025419950485229492, 0.0014479057863354683, -0.013002282939851284, 0.08274219930171967, -0.017267148941755295, 0.017837626859545708, 0.03165849670767784, -0.011800911277532578, -0.02549831196665764, -0.00922799576073885, -0.02112864889204502, -0.047706834971904755, 0.01332601998001337, 0.02193385176360607, -0.05559203028678894, -0.03949544206261635, -0.043591175228357315, 0.03019811026751995, 0.0008719395846128464, 0.029020769521594048, -0.061631444841623306, -0.07501674443483353, 0.003131846897304058, 0.0030250365380197763, 0.01322587113827467, -0.010821707546710968, 0.022844064980745316, -0.0397801510989666, -0.0426776222884655, -0.030843570828437805, -0.03027253970503807, -0.012371296063065529, -0.03884541243314743, 0.018917128443717957, -0.01744508184492588, 0.009840387850999832, -0.0236052293330431, -0.02010343410074711, 0.030261382460594177, 0.046001311391592026, 0.04832960292696953, 0.06731592863798141, 0.043678414076566696, -0.034276362508535385, -0.0536842867732048, 0.10785960406064987, 0.045707933604717255, -0.012237859889864922, -0.03115108050405979, 0.0063339462503790855, 0.03071041963994503, 0.0033879342954605818, -0.010181490331888199, -0.08361135423183441, -0.005130941513925791, -0.005694789811968803, -0.0084670539945364, 0.03672861307859421, -0.005880950950086117, -0.014494026079773903, -0.011452194303274155, 0.028970662504434586, 0.002557104919105768, 0.03265218064188957, 0.021886298432946205, -0.01836797222495079, 0.04775585979223251, -0.033327341079711914, -0.023813113570213318, -0.016940360888838768, -0.042994167655706406, 0.029081370681524277, 0.0021122414618730545, 0.0369388647377491, -0.0006776797235943377, 0.016324618831276894, 0.023327384144067764, 0.02640029974281788, 0.011792927980422974, 0.05553383752703667, -0.014714446850121021, -0.03765203803777695, 0.06312040239572525, -0.017780136317014694, 0.03167849779129028, -0.04895995184779167, -0.0018471975345164537, 0.0045723216608166695, -0.05552079156041145, -0.007559026591479778, 0.03909807279706001, 0.01209473330527544, -0.03905840218067169, 0.012782045640051365, -0.029894376173615456, 0.02123207598924637, 0.04862719401717186, -0.03552035242319107, -0.031825821846723557, -0.04497136175632477, -0.026507051661610603, 0.011628576554358006, -0.062063392251729965, 0.10275771468877792, -0.035772718489170074, 0.02830377407371998, 0.049854230135679245, 0.04841439053416252, 0.042492128908634186, -0.020086366683244705, 0.00016183902334887534, 0.019231880083680153, 0.03049180656671524, -0.04269524663686752, 0.030656151473522186, 0.05604300647974014, 0.011956441216170788, -0.00821828655898571, -0.009894872084259987, 0.0005384000251069665, 0.04152757301926613, 0.067410409450531, -0.03355911746621132, 0.0685286670923233, -0.03450727090239525, 0.011509575881063938, -0.0146985724568367, -0.03125254809856415, -0.020596710965037346, -0.02214265987277031, -0.006987236440181732, -0.011020000092685223, 0.010408719070255756, -0.0027806914877146482, 0.01784113235771656, 0.036187026649713516, 0.05345577374100685, -0.007652918808162212, 0.028469905257225037, -0.044117290526628494, -0.06031069904565811, -0.006296531762927771, 0.01785895973443985, 0.016949016600847244, -0.026988254860043526, -0.03886888176202774, 0.034098684787750244, 0.05287456512451172, -0.016924940049648285, 0.010952398180961609, 0.01615064963698387, -0.03213595598936081, -0.007184658665210009, 0.03774320334196091, -0.047923896461725235, 0.08026883751153946, -0.0044867051765322685, -0.03405454754829407, 0.004519980866461992, 0.011748898774385452, -0.011423368006944656, 0.018727967515587807, 0.08907842636108398, 0.0376758873462677, 0.0000676857162034139, 0.02650490030646324, 0.04378243908286095, -0.03971897065639496, 0.04609024524688721, -0.011898107826709747, -0.08326505869626999, 0.0939963236451149, -0.07380755990743637, 0.0350366085767746, -0.03834324702620506, -0.020060203969478607, 0.008378919214010239, -0.0026165423914790154, -0.03766115754842758, -0.035859398543834686, 0.028094273060560226, 0.015654096379876137, -0.031214861199259758, 0.03299397975206375, 0.006067982874810696, -0.00652833329513669, 0.01844206638634205, -0.02348381280899048, 0.04641430824995041, 0.06448890268802643, -0.02606348693370819, 0.04220648482441902, 0.07329753041267395, -0.04109009727835655, 0.010191395878791809, -0.011400105431675911, -0.02239464409649372, -0.004546341020613909, 0.0008495172369293869, -0.015580503270030022, -0.021035468205809593, -0.02146279066801071, -0.00636552507057786, -0.022091222926974297, 0.027584921568632126, 0.007226134650409222, -0.052864331752061844, -0.03650587424635887, 0.06264413148164749, 0.03818501532077789, -0.028653766959905624, -0.0012179664336144924, 0.03842867910861969, -0.05767394229769707, -0.011825240217149258, -0.05757318437099457, 0.011331314221024513, -0.00911607127636671, 0.021104630082845688, -0.009221090003848076, -0.0503888800740242, 0.04613044857978821, -0.017383364960551262, -0.046238839626312256, 0.06515255570411682, 0.03293779492378235, -0.023821141570806503, 0.024291057139635086, -0.022551804780960083, -0.06134631857275963, 0.016230562701821327, 0.014109392650425434, -0.04702926054596901, 0.029744047671556473, 0.03425587713718414, -0.0033256197348237038, -0.01030250545591116, 0.0457644984126091, -0.018719647079706192, 0.011475546285510063, -0.00039794883923605084, -0.023568540811538696, -0.02940766140818596, -0.02216472662985325, 0.07775446027517319, -0.06222860887646675, 0.0031775350216776133, 0.03184095025062561, 0.03580425679683685, 0.019031545147299767, -0.01855597458779812, 0.008568632416427135, -0.040289297699928284, 0.09008470922708511, -0.039946749806404114, -0.023734038695693016, -0.026310300454497337, -0.048653535544872284, 0.05804114788770676, 0.021543990820646286, 0.023695336654782295, 0.06637785583734512, 0.02984987571835518, -0.0374588780105114, -0.05851466953754425, 0.0626366063952446, -0.061369266360998154, -0.060209017246961594, 0.02084416151046753, -0.06796634197235107, 0.06745012104511261, 0.053796544671058655, -0.06226519122719765, 0.024438126012682915, -0.00047956634080037475, 0.004424443934112787, 0.031419724225997925, -0.0483400896191597, -0.016863100230693817, 0.007337578106671572, 0.012547209858894348, -0.07746385037899017, -0.04743817448616028, -0.009192796424031258, -0.01536798756569624, 0.013616159558296204, -0.02254509925842285, -0.03471745178103447, 0.006800857372581959, -0.05347145348787308, -0.03601216524839401, 0.021397607401013374, 0.05385180190205574, -0.05927520617842674, 0.0059673660434782505, -0.034145209938287735, -0.025693148374557495, -0.0780673697590828, 0.04618862271308899, -0.0037102203350514174, -0.003520246362313628, -0.04523840174078941, 0.00590735487639904, 0.015504001639783382, -0.003331811400130391, 0.03805376961827278, 0.03073044680058956, 0.011687425896525383, 0.0782432109117508, 0.011400480754673481, -0.017861545085906982, 0.0003260466328356415, -0.03641897439956665, 0.018347661942243576, -0.06302320957183838, -0.06548554450273514, 0.006735309027135372, 0.003931976389139891, -0.03547310829162598, -0.06810317188501358, 0.01671702414751053, 0.04493861645460129, 0.017704350873827934, 0.022102907299995422, 0.020488455891609192, 0.06378626823425293, 0.05140623450279236, 0.015549912117421627, -0.02966298721730709, -0.057151809334754944, -0.018497589975595474, 0.013839193619787693, -0.022889912128448486, 0.00325764250010252, -0.010588192380964756, -0.000987285515293479, -0.05478360876441002, 0.07546288520097733, -0.02984875813126564, -0.006674047559499741, -0.020697057247161865, -0.005971023812890053, 0.010627956129610538, -0.005538978148251772, 0.05454830452799797, 0.04537525773048401, -0.0378260537981987, -0.009945632889866829, -0.049319442361593246, 0.04122977703809738, -0.10211464017629623, -0.07509993016719818, -0.02963605709373951, -0.00850185938179493, -0.03234202042222023, 0.002405136590823531, -0.024535857141017914, 0.010359221138060093, -0.025879299268126488, -0.024397041648626328, -0.002622001338750124, 0.00624199490994215, -0.005051967687904835, 0.02940252423286438, 0.01514697726815939, -0.024347534403204918, 0.054249946027994156, 0.001423968467861414, 0.013807147741317749, 0.03989022597670555, -0.003753204829990864, -0.03330349922180176, 0.00021648000983987004, -0.0061445096507668495, -0.0056596361100673676, -0.015447587706148624, 0.016662724316120148, -0.031817223876714706, -0.001345008728094399, -0.017991580069065094, 0.014417463913559914, 0.027024928480386734, -0.05181856080889702, 0.0037771868519484997, -0.03541208803653717, -0.013270608149468899, 0.052306778728961945, 0.06650740653276443, 0.03650795668363571, -0.017576592043042183, -0.0328821986913681, 0.00652054138481617, -0.0004282200534362346, 0.03931775689125061, -0.027941565960645676, -0.030429597944021225, -0.003253252012655139, 0.031875915825366974, -0.012830528430640697, -0.006232301238924265, -0.07498586177825928, 0.01355586014688015, -0.03057112917304039, 0.033054910600185394, -0.009209779091179371, 0.05415116250514984, 0.027640817686915398, 0.012579203583300114, 0.021194113418459892, -0.011455432511866093, -0.017488496378064156, -0.03151647001504898, 0.02956811711192131, -0.006000000983476639, -0.05179474875330925, -0.0642332136631012, -0.059263136237859726, 0.03196285292506218, 0.0009772914927452803, 0.005576654337346554, -0.0022110454738140106, -0.04235944151878357, 0.04220454394817352, -0.04757082462310791, -0.011739915236830711, 0.011606525629758835, 0.078881174325943, 0.060767728835344315, -0.016226543113589287, 0.008126581087708473, -0.01158901583403349, 0.025974076241254807, 0.03920635208487511, -0.03781623765826225, -0.052231837064027786, 0.02238970808684826, -0.0020737142767757177, -0.07131718844175339, 0.00894654169678688, 0.03331403061747551, -0.01611500047147274, 0.018024152144789696, 0.03266207128763199, -0.05667297914624214, 0.03312750905752182, -0.0020538493990898132, 0.04399481788277626, -0.02874145098030567, -0.0047712079249322414, -0.029618918895721436, 0.028407787904143333, 0.07930248230695724, -0.018632160499691963, -0.03140419349074364, -0.055046550929546356, -0.07165171205997467, -0.000504538300447166, 0.003272936213761568, -0.0016782758757472038, -0.02068985253572464, -0.02003825083374977, 0.026676738634705544, -0.021700162440538406, -0.08180688321590424, -0.018435167148709297, -0.015682071447372437, -0.045635297894477844, 0.005261131562292576, -0.007893352769315243, 0.047074321657419205, 0.00018034616368822753, -0.020659686997532845, -0.011658187955617905, -0.0516759529709816, 0.05967378243803978, 0.04633818566799164, -0.01393120363354683, -0.02298823930323124, 0.04408726096153259, -0.005820959806442261, -0.01641286164522171, 0.011130554601550102, 0.055760644376277924, 0.04191191494464874, -0.005762351676821709, -0.04201216995716095, 0.008298149332404137, 0.011385263875126839, -0.007296041585505009, -0.024984441697597504, -0.06799930334091187, -0.00907826330512762, -0.002763274824246764, 0.039937425404787064, -0.03589654713869095, -0.025418423116207123, 0.013711425475776196, -0.05068628489971161, -0.0268670916557312, -0.04345635324716568, 0.006353232078254223, 0.07493996620178223, -0.0603279173374176, 0.025367971509695053, 0.08309464901685715, -0.032206445932388306, -0.04366274178028107, 0.02066929079592228, 0.03486572206020355, -0.015250450000166893, -0.011608242057263851, 0.11494231224060059, 0.030362961813807487, -0.07609089463949203, -0.011358303017914295, 0.028325162827968597, -0.0209816824644804, 0.016696829348802567, 0.01189194992184639, -0.09028620272874832, 0.04892239719629288, 0.022056380286812782, -0.05824500694870949, 0.007527629844844341, 0.014451904222369194, -0.022904671728610992, 0.0015126325888559222, 0.02361523173749447, -0.007389932870864868, 0.058158598840236664, 0.04758230969309807, -0.044610679149627686, -0.04334874451160431, 0.0006195190944708884, -0.011142742820084095, -0.018317947164177895, -0.029194151982665062, -0.0033920484129339457, -0.01907981000840664, 0.011904909275472164, 0.0038846442475914955, -0.026690667495131493, 0.03891737386584282, 0.009047174826264381, -0.044759079813957214, -0.0029789190739393234, -0.0511576384305954, -0.006004443392157555, 0.03454754874110222, -0.020460903644561768, 0.0319722518324852, 0.05708187073469162, 0.004989780951291323, -0.020247725769877434, -0.06537015736103058, 0.041549067944288254, -0.017611302435398102, 0.006743310950696468, -0.011137821711599827, 0.01129113044589758, -0.009738119319081306, 0.015150965191423893, -0.01206502690911293, 0.04151911661028862, 0.01034777145832777, -0.03594965115189552, -0.015136015601456165, 0.021634280681610107, 0.01475011371076107, 0.03914254531264305, 0.020088141784071922, -0.0035662881564348936, 0.040653061121702194, -0.050131674855947495, 0.024479852989315987, 0.03993446007370949, -0.011644846759736538, -0.03746938705444336, -0.01676817052066326, 0.039246704429388046, -0.01346600241959095, -0.034307073801755905, -0.017044449225068092, 0.0005934379296377301, -0.008575480431318283, -0.017094066366553307, 0.04696067422628403, -0.04554249346256256, -0.022972984239459038, 0.03466794639825821, 0.028387216851115227, 0.04325787350535393, -0.0009503402980044484, 0.019994378089904785, -0.027603356167674065, 0.005253101233392954, -0.008656815625727177, -0.009519264101982117, 0.06646063178777695, -0.011809142306447029, 0.017517251893877983, -0.03125416114926338, 0.0011412906460464, 0.012591248378157616, -0.034453071653842926, 0.0796559527516365, -0.033485740423202515, 0.02508935146033764, -0.06323704123497009, -0.050986986607313156, -0.006304578855633736, 0.0041689397767186165, 0.020430678501725197, -0.006371644325554371, 0.023142009973526, 0.058638639748096466, 0.02172536589205265, 0.00882669910788536, 0.022794783115386963, 0.03824382275342941, 0.02224600501358509, -0.007915094494819641, 0.05376267433166504, -0.023127885535359383, 0.07115479558706284, -0.04701700806617737, 0.006588383112102747, 0.0823846086859703, 0.04090454801917076, 0.03536935895681381, -0.010085969232022762, -0.03344706445932388, 0.05239134281873703, 0.007530231028795242, -0.012198243290185928, -0.04359525069594383, -0.027198433876037598, -0.018234409391880035, -0.04120281711220741, -0.007164081558585167, -0.05002812296152115, -0.0069820168428123, 0.03050638921558857, -0.03647501394152641, 0.06637945026159286, 0.02153521403670311, -0.04206797853112221, 0.04954851046204567, -0.025828411802649498, -0.03409967198967934, -0.04471735283732414, -0.0039097340777516365, 0.011064648628234863, 0.04375772178173065, -0.01882782019674778, 0.013074342161417007, -0.0006446199840866029, 0.028743382543325424, -0.051650021225214005, -0.06168435513973236, 0.04298251494765282, -0.031187621876597404, -0.05976947769522667, 0.022908521816134453, 0.039810020476579666, 0.027660829946398735, -0.02217039465904236, 0.008079848252236843, 0.017001958563923836, 0.005555670242756605, -0.0006311206961981952, 0.0020039824303239584, 0.00627173762768507, -0.03961549699306488, 0.008011027239263058, -0.05022052675485611, -0.016229435801506042, -0.0014647665666416287, 0.027042336761951447, 0.014013842679560184, -0.05081057921051979, -0.007847337983548641, 0.011503170244395733, 0.05140751227736473, 0.0922529548406601, -0.02154603786766529, -0.009643472731113434, 0.019750837236642838, 0.03741980344057083, -0.02110000140964985, 0.016385935246944427, 0.04019248113036156, -0.010491212829947472, 0.0541810467839241, -0.042836617678403854, -0.008536259643733501, -0.00525543512776494, 0.06364692747592926, 0.10931339114904404, 0.01632675528526306, 0.058843180537223816, 0.0020579153206199408, 0.006237504538148642, -0.034270212054252625, 0.021536054089665413, 0.030152874067425728, 0.030067138373851776, -0.0053468188270926476, 0.02090490236878395, -0.054599083960056305, 0.023325063288211823, 0.07231080532073975, 0.008900830522179604, 0.046993281692266464, 0.016232376918196678, 0.03824688494205475, 0.0013504910748451948, 0.0033772517926990986, 0.005647632759064436, -0.03445848450064659, -0.06297756731510162, 0.01479379553347826, -0.0009315998177044094, 0.02248833142220974, -0.012873711064457893, -0.025661678984761238, -0.013660235330462456, 0.03194791451096535, -0.04729721322655678, -0.035683050751686096, -0.03351334482431412, -0.022908318787813187, -0.018031207844614983, 0.0005774245364591479, -0.0023925548885017633, 0.023294374346733093, -0.00029036865453235805, 0.03798012435436249, -0.013302952982485294, -0.032933782786130905, 0.03651028126478195, 0.09938864409923553, -0.053207773715257645, -0.07156918942928314, -0.03269440680742264, -0.053174786269664764, 0.002285708673298359, 0.028035299852490425, 0.027620498090982437, -0.00032916443888098, -0.07219130545854568, -0.038629546761512756, -0.024819668382406235, 0.03367326036095619, 0.0008829773869365454 ]
<p>The following is a question from a practice Physics GRE exam (found online at ETS's website).</p> <blockquote> <p>The circuit shown in the figure consists of eight resistors, each with resistance <em>R</em>, and a battery with terminal voltage <em>V</em> and negligible internal resistance. What is the current flowing through the battery?</p> </blockquote> <p>Here is the figure in question:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/I4bR2.png" alt="Resistors"></p> <p>In case the figure doesn't load, here's the problem from ETS: <a href="https://www.ets.org/s/gre/pdf/practice_book_physics.pdf" rel="nofollow">https://www.ets.org/s/gre/pdf/practice_book_physics.pdf</a>, page 54, problem 68.</p> <p>Since this is a GRE question I figured there was a shorter approach than a brute-force, Kirchoff's Voltage Law around every loop. I've been trying to figure out what a simpler solution would be by reducing parallel/series resistors, which currently there aren't any that can be reduced that way. Then I tried a triangle-star conversion, where I basically reduced each closed square in the diagram (each square was essentially a triangle because each had a resistor-less wire on one of the sides) but that also didn't lend itself to parallel/series reduction. I couldn't figure out another approach after that.</p> <p>The correct answer is 3/2*<em>V/R</em>, and an abbreviated solution I saw someone else put online (<a href="http://physicsworks.files.wordpress.com/2012/09/gr0877_solutions.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://physicsworks.files.wordpress.com/2012/09/gr0877_solutions.pdf</a>, problem 68, if you're interested) said to treat the problem as 3 separate 2 <em>R</em> resistors in parallel, but I am not sure how that works, because there are still the two horizontal resistors. Could someone explain to me either why this approach to the problem is correct or an alternative approach to the problem? Thank you!</p>
g5870
[ 0.020388692617416382, -0.010576988570392132, -0.017409546300768852, -0.04207831248641014, 0.054815031588077545, 0.012722491286695004, 0.021118981763720512, 0.06111941859126091, -0.04050244390964508, 0.018493777140975, -0.0019820877350866795, 0.06805414706468582, -0.02365821972489357, 0.01838092692196369, 0.06951651722192764, 0.009364543482661247, 0.039659351110458374, 0.012246834114193916, 0.03452945128083229, -0.04771113023161888, -0.04397653415799141, -0.002302645007148385, -0.0428691990673542, -0.0028484065551310778, -0.003562401747331023, -0.04215595871210098, 0.009836511686444283, -0.01943066529929638, -0.08571774512529373, -0.03675398230552673, -0.008123647421598434, 0.0022811151575297117, 0.07445106655359268, -0.05356452986598015, -0.04125489294528961, 0.03969614580273628, 0.00838264636695385, 0.04160556569695473, -0.016193104907870293, 0.06820383667945862, 0.0025227582082152367, -0.039683662354946136, 0.028447650372982025, 0.006183014716953039, 0.012912014499306679, -0.015555517747998238, -0.011938170529901981, -0.007539623416960239, -0.02728818543255329, 0.0130223473533988, 0.0037031646352261305, 0.03724677860736847, 0.042187031358480453, -0.002946040825918317, -0.004310629330575466, -0.020457517355680466, 0.017251383513212204, -0.017319032922387123, 0.04759589582681656, 0.04858998954296112, -0.008243786171078682, -0.011274655349552631, 0.00783474650233984, 0.008255996741354465, 0.01546765211969614, 0.006941927131265402, 0.005830057896673679, 0.04108859598636627, 0.02594413422048092, 0.04654468595981598, 0.015104353427886963, -0.036950670182704926, 0.014823047444224358, -0.047496866434812546, 0.05536377429962158, 0.04295475780963898, -0.0013883647043257952, 0.015556175261735916, 0.016691813245415688, -0.006768840365111828, -0.032933302223682404, -0.013716557994484901, 0.007511865813285112, 0.08478085696697235, 0.06376983225345612, -0.011392810381948948, 0.028416065499186516, 0.002468449529260397, -0.025040866807103157, 0.0021190571133047342, 0.0113416388630867, 0.026220880448818207, 0.10524819046258926, -0.06095172092318535, -0.017445677891373634, -0.027339356020092964, -0.012697761878371239, 0.061352718621492386, 0.04090867191553116, 0.005168726667761803, -0.00574252987280488, 0.017969191074371338, -0.0037425607442855835, -0.05785883590579033, -0.06483390182256699, 0.028608614578843117, 0.07007152587175369, -0.013478351756930351, -0.03464793413877487, -0.028953958302736282, -0.10105081647634506, -0.08421336859464645, -0.05364508181810379, -0.022894226014614105, 0.04613436758518219, 0.04049038514494896, 0.08718491345643997, -0.022552257403731346, 0.001290870481170714, -0.016067305579781532, -0.02793269418179989, -0.008028951473534107, 0.037477221339941025, -0.013465170748531818, -0.05877517908811569, -0.012447012588381767, 0.0001492096926085651, 0.031305234879255295, 0.05367942154407501, 0.006712837144732475, -0.0011766855604946613, -0.0016975277103483677, -0.04794469103217125, -0.006374959833920002, 0.01723094843327999, 0.005933067295700312, -0.02184688113629818, -0.028379784896969795, 0.0019485417287796736, -0.016274893656373024, -0.03953751176595688, -0.014386500231921673, -0.05726124346256256, 0.01842561550438404, 0.022381767630577087, 0.009239931590855122, -0.07178443670272827, -0.012396428734064102, 0.03968316316604614, -0.04384626820683479, 0.07580777257680893, 0.053227320313453674, -0.006099100690335035, -0.03973013535141945, 0.010082694701850414, -0.01367280539125204, 0.014766521751880646, -0.06220578774809837, 0.030934777110815048, 0.0009185235248878598, -0.027788864448666573, 0.0009480777662247419, -0.038953762501478195, 0.0006466773920692503, -0.048049431294202805, 0.042659252882003784, -0.007240535691380501, -0.023079318925738335, -0.016627507284283638, -0.04746720939874649, -0.04600068926811218, -0.030528897419571877, 0.003458925988525152, 0.08673073351383209, -0.012303266674280167, 0.06434813141822815, 0.08467505127191544, -0.020011985674500465, -0.005785749759525061, 0.014218862168490887, -0.013597425073385239, 0.00638531194999814, 0.06832578033208847, 0.0016318823909386992, 0.025585796684026718, -0.036744579672813416, -0.015616127289831638, 0.04908282682299614, -0.06282849609851837, -0.06693866848945618, -0.033998485654592514, -0.0028670893516391516, -0.03345656022429466, 0.0526883527636528, 0.000829031749162823, -0.04323994368314743, 0.0021174473222345114, -0.0425926148891449, -0.03520866855978966, -0.030706867575645447, 0.02293921448290348, -0.015263778157532215, 0.08089345693588257, 0.012811636552214622, 0.021012619137763977, 0.011340809985995293, -0.028877755627036095, -0.06731534004211426, 0.0479649119079113, -0.009044286794960499, -0.038149040192365646, 0.010200945660471916, 0.017651161178946495, 0.014988907612860203, -0.034539323300123215, -0.05769903585314751, 0.015989599749445915, 0.025111820548772812, -0.04393334314227104, 0.03326631337404251, -0.019882945343852043, -0.028268199414014816, -0.022808559238910675, -0.019048260524868965, -0.0018352604238316417, -0.005420612171292305, 0.018399955704808235, -0.02946234680712223, -0.05266083404421806, -0.06292979419231415, -0.023012185469269753, 0.004180955234915018, -0.07007390260696411, -0.06706984341144562, 0.0073089199140667915, 0.020078593865036964, 0.010300012305378914, 0.037817761301994324, -0.04982859641313553, -0.005851390305906534, 0.017879759892821312, -0.009430311620235443, 0.04690556973218918, 0.012164256535470486, 0.057790596038103104, -0.0019781850278377533, 0.014705142006278038, 0.04877400025725365, -0.02325046807527542, 0.021114950999617577, 0.018220990896224976, 0.01873968541622162, -0.028140421956777573, 0.03166462853550911, -0.004802518989890814, 0.032547976821660995, 0.02695038728415966, -0.0006863621529191732, 0.0592477023601532, 0.014746141619980335, -0.022324519231915474, -0.037166085094213486, 0.0033811205066740513, 0.049624957144260406, -0.09557570517063141, 0.0036335850600153208, -0.020938033238053322, -0.008439399302005768, 0.08497444540262222, 0.020258260890841484, -0.05012500286102295, 0.04073333367705345, -0.008241098374128342, -0.03951282054185867, 0.008954962715506554, -0.03368739038705826, 0.08603717386722565, 0.002124121878296137, 0.011110078543424606, 0.07849287241697311, 0.06359510123729706, -0.010135747492313385, -0.07480163872241974, -0.005171115044504404, 0.01606404222548008, -0.013556723482906818, 0.049017760902643204, -0.046971000730991364, -0.01568368636071682, 0.03883066028356552, -0.0366038903594017, -0.061214759945869446, 0.04203997179865837, -0.020601799711585045, -0.005805906839668751, 0.029059123247861862, 0.01861121691763401, -0.037127744406461716, 0.007253673858940601, 0.04144342616200447, -0.039432525634765625, -0.021287210285663605, 0.04052646458148956, 0.00852152705192566, -0.01854640059173107, 0.021508140489459038, -0.04340516775846481, 0.017747625708580017, -0.015880553051829338, 0.04895234853029251, 0.025452343747019768, -0.03936631232500076, 0.06635348498821259, -0.00842293445020914, 0.013044032268226147, 0.01571754738688469, -0.05283096805214882, -0.0006124266074039042, -0.0052610901184380054, 0.002838878659531474, -0.05248554050922394, 0.04441948980093002, 0.029828578233718872, 0.02150771953165531, -0.0038897672202438116, 0.06130235269665718, -0.02152898907661438, 0.05499116703867912, -0.01070829201489687, -0.012850023806095123, -0.04242289066314697, 0.007524929940700531, 0.024699047207832336, -0.03881074860692024, -0.011541164480149746, 0.013669660314917564, -0.03473334014415741, 0.0523802824318409, 0.021778056398034096, -0.012755743227899075, -0.018945159390568733, -0.012332850135862827, -0.09277912229299545, -0.023749113082885742, 0.012459016405045986, -0.011877591721713543, -0.03658029064536095, 0.010874791070818901, 0.005806939210742712, -0.0038422229699790478, 0.0035738684237003326, 0.028957510367035866, 0.016240470111370087, -0.005874286871403456, -0.02701578661799431, -0.03354361653327942, -0.04147211089730263, 0.05285843089222908, -0.017714308574795723, -0.006596165243536234, -0.0009181690402328968, -0.022458072751760483, -0.025274520739912987, 0.018349632620811462, -0.007090875878930092, -0.016859138384461403, 0.035875990986824036, -0.04046470671892166, -0.034788284450769424, -0.07266116887331009, 0.0039013626519590616, -0.011255458928644657, -0.03649525344371796, 0.00977381132543087, 0.0008186593186110258, -0.07714034616947174, 0.007598494179546833, 0.02517128735780716, -0.029740752652287483, 0.07472793012857437, -0.012046027928590775, -0.034040603786706924, -0.011145130731165409, -0.02757352963089943, 0.07383771240711212, 0.020731354132294655, 0.011112242937088013, 0.00851972121745348, -0.036173295229673386, -0.022860659286379814, -0.08145081996917725, 0.0389668308198452, -0.05165557935833931, -0.013926989398896694, -0.03328732028603554, 0.023593297228217125, 0.04549102112650871, -0.02430729754269123, -0.052049607038497925, 0.04959123954176903, -0.0027639346662908792, -0.023430384695529938, 0.020030302926898003, 0.010257522575557232, -0.024615934118628502, 0.025209419429302216, 0.006720561999827623, -0.01597031019628048, 0.05542983487248421, 0.05352705344557762, -0.03855966404080391, -0.015519420616328716, 0.020803334191441536, -0.04414839297533035, 0.06922277808189392, 0.010571898892521858, 0.03617816045880318, 0.05099145323038101, 0.002674008486792445, -0.036663737148046494, 0.04357972741127014, 0.00651364354416728, -0.03921567648649216, -0.03268367424607277, 0.01075049676001072, 0.04598388820886612, 0.025959022343158722, -0.010060668922960758, 0.01507398672401905, 0.025901412591338158, 0.024335898458957672, -0.007458832114934921, -0.029473738744854927, 0.014583881944417953, -0.028249990195035934, -0.0218818262219429, -0.017561297863721848, 0.010714522562921047, 0.01402579341083765, 0.0842006728053093, 0.033914461731910706, -0.048288535326719284, -0.028672052547335625, -0.022326817736029625, -0.01856454834342003, 0.033304862678050995, -0.04727672040462494, -0.021214285865426064, -0.009936824440956116, 0.026645516976714134, -0.04209774732589722, -0.018745306879281998, -0.009367045015096664, -0.018846074119210243, -0.01968996971845627, -0.0550239272415638, 0.036027539521455765, 0.013513934798538685, 0.050658006221055984, 0.04086070880293846, -0.03451826795935631, 0.014664270915091038, -0.05290405452251434, 0.022056030109524727, 0.03835489973425865, -0.017149994149804115, -0.01235282700508833, -0.0044526527635753155, -0.021123776212334633, -0.03690377622842789, 0.02319481037557125, -0.010138599202036858, -0.014812023378908634, 0.023202652111649513, 0.004721033852547407, -0.03808517009019852, 0.046189386397600174, 0.00026405006065033376, -0.013986925594508648, -0.03648390993475914, -0.0245787613093853, -0.008820848539471626, 0.017092928290367126, 0.01840016432106495, 0.0028978229966014624, 0.029774369671940804, -0.005159342661499977, -0.010657640174031258, -0.02309962920844555, 0.00640266016125679, -0.022180043160915375, 0.0942707359790802, 0.0278225876390934, -0.02412363700568676, -0.020407048985362053, 0.014811917208135128, 0.04947640374302864, 0.0573364794254303, -0.0011070026084780693, 0.018579138442873955, 0.004004999995231628, -0.010854312218725681, 0.03512722998857498, 0.02534138783812523, -0.00927844736725092, 0.05741901323199272, -0.021962950006127357, 0.0011545661836862564, 0.032993149012327194, 0.029245596379041672, -0.024459782987833023, -0.03173660486936569, 0.013888119719922543, -0.05627186968922615, -0.01915263757109642, 0.002060051541775465, -0.07469218224287033, -0.01288837380707264, 0.021728312596678734, -0.006187726743519306, 0.10989265143871307, -0.022997787222266197, -0.010007083415985107, -0.02130155637860298, -0.006706424988806248, 0.015688356012105942, -0.0575857013463974, -0.017210952937602997, -0.0196766909211874, 0.014912856742739677, -0.019229860976338387, 0.018187204375863075, -0.012514610774815083, -0.0016928884433582425, -0.06693769991397858, -0.027850117534399033, 0.06439269334077835, -0.023330863565206528, 0.053638022392988205, -0.018811723217368126, 0.021388959139585495, 0.03426435589790344, 0.02785666100680828, 0.004641063045710325, -0.07070352882146835, -0.014639381319284439, 0.008344396948814392, -0.07608853280544281, -0.02811378240585327, -0.028451012447476387, -0.0654958114027977, 0.011048770509660244, -0.023449044674634933, 0.010741987265646458, -0.00437321700155735, 0.0023805322125554085, 0.01991523802280426, -0.06708627939224243, 0.0347650870680809, 0.03676619380712509, 0.007003307342529297, -0.027812950313091278, -0.01411977969110012, 0.02212211862206459, 0.041973527520895004, -0.04599081352353096, -0.0020582806318998337, 0.0326676070690155, 0.02320498786866665, 0.0177962277084589, -0.008304311893880367, -0.05957695469260216, 0.02129647694528103, 0.054866429418325424, 0.05813499167561531, -0.035140909254550934, -0.016037650406360626, -0.02228890359401703, 0.014820683747529984, 0.030537405982613564, -0.044199585914611816, -0.01962549425661564, 0.0036765877157449722, 0.0024092283565551043, 0.07386749237775803, 0.03822494298219681, -0.03592286258935928, -0.025746092200279236, -0.008884632959961891, -0.014725489541888237, -0.0456155389547348, 0.00038530572783201933, -0.013576037250459194, 0.03807774931192398, 0.03225798159837723, 0.03125527873635292, 0.03675154596567154, 0.05321216210722923, 0.007029751781374216, 0.04771596938371658, 0.028857851400971413, -0.05143676698207855, 0.06362366676330566, -0.02074265293776989, -0.004497744608670473, 0.006494853645563126, -0.053761906921863556, 0.005598809104412794, -0.06427694112062454, -0.03923257440328598, 0.05361412838101387, 0.025237202644348145, 0.03246624022722244, -0.03809851408004761, -0.010406006127595901, -0.0036792755126953125, 0.031993795186281204, 0.04893886670470238, 0.0005053249769844115, 0.02679312229156494, -0.03010709211230278, -0.003340841270983219, -0.0070561934262514114, 0.021569039672613144, 0.001690555363893509, 0.05335903540253639, 0.04288127273321152, -0.011974751949310303, 0.045782484114170074, -0.013035007752478123, -0.02071353979408741, 0.0028062977362424135, -0.052975334227085114, 0.005940934643149376, 0.07376135885715485, 0.05480971187353134, -0.005832316819578409, -0.00170842744410038, 0.01028908509761095, 0.04025045037269592, -0.015478824265301228, 0.004386659245938063, -0.04591246694326401, 0.10415659099817276, -0.03537748381495476, -0.06266067177057266, 0.10662175714969635, 0.051148127764463425, -0.034310877323150635, -0.04117562621831894, 0.03219270333647728, -0.0015541481552645564, -0.06611749529838562, -0.005446847062557936, -0.043172720819711685, 0.009616558440029621, 0.05545664578676224, 0.041643232107162476, 0.04200229048728943, -0.032667376101017, -0.040911126881837845, -0.08010576665401459, 0.02234284020960331, 0.030805591493844986, 0.016339411959052086, 0.09783956408500671, -0.04315802454948425, -0.045757271349430084, -0.0016125672264024615, -0.021896181628108025, -0.0221556406468153, -0.009767423383891582, 0.06976167857646942, 0.03309540078043938, 0.018780408427119255, 0.007888388819992542, 0.02555561438202858, -0.01506185345351696, -0.025797564536333084, -0.017313428223133087, -0.027237243950366974, -0.0045365155674517155, 0.002722350647673011, -0.04568634554743767, -0.01940287835896015, 0.030862316489219666, -0.05745594948530197, 0.006063731387257576, 0.010976159013807774, 0.0006196257309056818, 0.006020060274749994, 0.05457136780023575, 0.06801360845565796, 0.029306283220648766, 0.061916936188936234, 0.06287755072116852, -0.04303782805800438, -0.02519644983112812, 0.01931409165263176, -0.018982408568263054, 0.03982982784509659, 0.011626654304564, -0.008417226374149323, 0.0023073467891663313, -0.004867722745984793, 0.007192372810095549, -0.0714513510465622, -0.05954679846763611, -0.0005019697709940374, -0.010653063654899597, 0.015280229039490223, 0.06770489364862442, -0.036657143384218216, -0.029601989313960075, 0.03716873750090599, -0.037129394710063934, -0.00548298517242074, 0.02388891763985157, -0.003258543089032173, -0.053439121693372726, -0.03904736042022705, -0.011084037832915783, -0.03483890742063522, 0.001895869616419077, -0.02571525052189827, -0.05156540125608444, 0.052640099078416824, -0.017681730911135674, 0.002094920724630356, -0.06432485580444336, -0.03515837714076042, -0.03749928995966911, 0.02275335229933262, 0.047532252967357635, 0.02124696411192417, 0.01995399035513401, -0.0855499804019928, -0.003971600905060768, 0.0015286564594134688, 0.008891921490430832, 0.0026010279543697834, -0.03162754699587822, -0.021832652390003204, -0.0012094281846657395, -0.0020757040474563837, -0.01407066360116005, -0.04017346724867821, 0.0074824257753789425, -0.011506279930472374, 0.005003045313060284, -0.016899142414331436, -0.003124488051980734, -0.07808002829551697, -0.014705912210047245, 0.0779818743467331, -0.014920572750270367, 0.00816725380718708, 0.020182617008686066, 0.031222941353917122, 0.024452218785881996, -0.024543743580579758, 0.01823713816702366, -0.044283170253038406, 0.053173989057540894, 0.06672859191894531, -0.038280367851257324, 0.0046051498502492905, -0.04220236465334892 ]
<p>I've been watching a video about dark mater and a lot of the mass is missing in our universe. Astronomers got to this by measuring the speed that stars orbit the center of the galaxy and when they did this it didn't match the amount of gravity/mass in the galaxy. </p> <p>However I thought that the mass of the black hole in the Center of the galaxy was measured by the stars orbiting it? To me it sounds like a catch 22? But I don't understand it very well. So could someone explain it further?</p>
g5871
[ 0.02081437222659588, -0.00513452710583806, -0.010629096999764442, -0.03491070494055748, 0.06717212498188019, 0.04192299023270607, 0.02419440448284149, 0.008010083809494972, 0.0033244777005165815, 0.005120087414979935, 0.03542225807905197, 0.011044313199818134, 0.06490937620401382, -0.028539787977933884, 0.038620106875896454, -0.01755601353943348, 0.03019295632839203, 0.005291587207466364, 0.0044439854100346565, 0.00921495072543621, 0.027688518166542053, -0.04323798790574074, -0.020009450614452362, -0.0325932651758194, -0.02150592766702175, -0.028050146996974945, 0.04607411101460457, -0.012017725966870785, -0.01573558710515499, -0.007295464165508747, 0.04809973016381264, -0.04535356163978577, 0.033705610781908035, -0.04625391960144043, 0.010302328504621983, -0.012694145552814007, -0.017856435850262642, -0.02854737639427185, -0.012125927023589611, 0.01366072054952383, 0.025158526375889778, -0.06724844127893448, -0.04834844917058945, 0.004746579099446535, -0.021946579217910767, 0.046055566519498825, 0.002246825722977519, -0.025437237694859505, 0.0030150844249874353, -0.028689606115221977, -0.008897117339074612, -0.047124430537223816, 0.06159387528896332, 0.036860670894384384, -0.057997580617666245, 0.040589820593595505, 0.007897921837866306, -0.012717180885374546, 0.026114944368600845, 0.023117903620004654, 0.036930669099092484, 0.020934350788593292, 0.018245521932840347, 0.020900661125779152, 0.019870728254318237, -0.014940707944333553, -0.020386409014463425, 0.04824130982160568, -0.03169887885451317, 0.008243243210017681, -0.02409798838198185, 0.008410211652517319, 0.011575664393603802, -0.029661551117897034, -0.03781696408987045, 0.023486481979489326, -0.016212984919548035, -0.004933652468025684, -0.04835512116551399, -0.007050955202430487, -0.001087385811842978, -0.0107719199731946, 0.009219115599989891, 0.046377308666706085, 0.09173538535833359, 0.007262771483510733, -0.05788109824061394, 0.025571094825863838, -0.026776624843478203, 0.06211851164698601, 0.07106418162584305, -0.010592414997518063, 0.06093330308794975, -0.012436609715223312, 0.0028937302995473146, -0.009972155094146729, -0.05174194648861885, 0.07522518187761307, -0.031098250299692154, -0.0010972525924444199, -0.04337095841765404, 0.055949192494153976, -0.01904284581542015, -0.02337087318301201, 0.020428171381354332, 0.06964468210935593, 0.018343506380915642, 0.03212870657444, 0.026846198365092278, 0.04769273102283478, -0.010035314597189426, -0.052500128746032715, 0.02754145860671997, -0.02902715466916561, -0.043746981769800186, -0.009167551063001156, 0.0921771228313446, 0.045620162039995193, 0.027860647067427635, 0.040003880858421326, -0.03947777301073074, 0.029850900173187256, 0.022852063179016113, 0.018647385761141777, -0.06603238731622696, -0.06851918995380402, 0.045605774968862534, -0.0020853113383054733, 0.012163926847279072, -0.011653074994683266, -0.025546757504343987, -0.017193419858813286, -0.056000061333179474, 0.0006555467844009399, -0.019248031079769135, -0.006786982994526625, 0.01901850476861, -0.008745391853153706, -0.05046548321843147, 0.016588246449828148, -0.022567816078662872, -0.017718156799674034, 0.061262860894203186, -0.014478866010904312, -0.05226680263876915, 0.03799169510602951, -0.0062485323287546635, -0.0176777895539999, 0.021106086671352386, -0.007446190807968378, 0.026258736848831177, 0.04688192903995514, -0.033073704689741135, -0.018322786316275597, 0.015145579352974892, -0.03839198872447014, 0.0609966479241848, 0.051756761968135834, -0.010972348041832447, -0.007709802128374577, 0.08966147154569626, -0.031225595623254776, 0.013271305710077286, 0.013222401030361652, -0.03619178757071495, -0.021421583369374275, 0.018863003700971603, -0.060195442289114, 0.02226099744439125, -0.023586222901940346, -0.054100025445222855, -0.012885318137705326, -0.010624215006828308, 0.035668060183525085, 0.012411591596901417, 0.01704137772321701, 0.06336145848035812, -0.01628563180565834, 0.011498933658003807, 0.009494008496403694, 0.008937036618590355, -0.02601093426346779, 0.0026379248593002558, -0.027641478925943375, 0.02845226414501667, -0.013030510395765305, 0.044818732887506485, -0.007441292982548475, 0.021631795912981033, 0.04082362726330757, -0.048414576798677444, 0.009724735282361507, 0.057820312678813934, 0.08812317997217178, 0.01910138875246048, 0.006744150072336197, 0.01073032058775425, -0.002944977255538106, -0.000913801253773272, 0.054849185049533844, -0.0023440823424607515, -0.04084832966327667, 0.01874244585633278, -0.011569940485060215, 0.0035859225317835808, -0.03188319131731987, -0.03265589103102684, 0.06507422775030136, 0.037133146077394485, -0.02462860941886902, -0.022761333733797073, -0.010486090555787086, -0.008312727324664593, -0.0073236688040196896, -0.08850172907114029, 0.058115001767873764, -0.03620234504342079, 0.06803026050329208, 0.03878214210271835, 0.033319998532533646, -0.03594020754098892, -0.03255458548665047, 0.012630005367100239, -0.058821383863687515, 0.0024952550884336233, 0.05546841770410538, -0.02045036107301712, -0.05823448300361633, 0.00446502398699522, 0.012530877254903316, -0.03618663549423218, -0.0007259988924488425, 0.019270751625299454, 0.03498973697423935, 0.02720436453819275, 0.002701613586395979, 0.04184349253773689, 0.016801273450255394, -0.018990742042660713, 0.04708832874894142, 0.019095279276371002, -0.02718980982899666, -0.03999887779355049, 0.017053773626685143, 0.02924267016351223, -0.002475410932675004, 0.024942532181739807, -0.05353782698512077, -0.041775383055210114, 0.041561659425497055, 0.0059236325323581696, -0.020755385980010033, -0.010331538505852222, -0.0850398987531662, 0.014638453722000122, -0.02612658217549324, -0.04453396797180176, 0.010323863476514816, -0.07539279758930206, -0.006491739768534899, 0.009935647249221802, 0.014634468592703342, 0.06158865615725517, -0.016009407117962837, -0.03219755366444588, -0.03428121283650398, -0.06256735324859619, -0.026698892936110497, 0.015376093797385693, 0.01133021991699934, 0.0018851475324481726, -0.0089394086971879, 0.022175176069140434, -0.02152756042778492, -0.024588845670223236, 0.028928982093930244, -0.03549440577626228, -0.028332911431789398, 0.07248907536268234, -0.00640395563095808, -0.007943621836602688, 0.02562139369547367, -0.05289056897163391, -0.02027243934571743, -0.0016018287278711796, -0.0207649115473032, -0.052371155470609665, 0.023241112008690834, -0.01206450629979372, -0.008754950016736984, 0.0599251314997673, 0.01938689686357975, 0.021586129441857338, 0.05256161093711853, 0.037693534046411514, 0.05082554742693901, 0.051470596343278885, 0.028692282736301422, -0.06275710463523865, -0.025499258190393448, 0.013314571231603622, 0.0029845566023141146, 0.0003965237410739064, -0.018729230388998985, -0.004292171914130449, 0.01045796275138855, 0.032071612775325775, 0.030776934698224068, 0.01902708224952221, -0.0781259760260582, 0.08263583481311798, -0.007217000238597393, 0.006372452713549137, 0.025222137570381165, -0.002189084654673934, -0.006361332256346941, -0.010098177939653397, 0.0025979578495025635, -0.0033565619960427284, 0.002235963474959135, -0.046192772686481476, 0.01995014026761055, -0.050249312072992325, -0.04469805955886841, 0.06344206631183624, 0.006553528364747763, 0.021754562854766846, -0.021690500900149345, -0.06759914010763168, -0.020418034866452217, 0.001562457880936563, -0.017808984965085983, -0.07578056305646896, 0.05325508117675781, -0.021259944885969162, 0.001266191597096622, -0.025789212435483932, -0.017454063519835472, 0.09403496235609055, -0.0454166978597641, -0.020190199837088585, -0.006298104301095009, -0.020878387615084648, -0.003712230594828725, -0.0010902259964495897, -0.01986350491642952, 0.025613542646169662, -0.04590645059943199, 0.02838682383298874, -0.006092408671975136, -0.03291808068752289, 0.008814896456897259, -0.013246315531432629, -0.0036748158745467663, -0.03701034188270569, 0.01487748883664608, 0.005501880310475826, 0.03407546505331993, -0.0010011510457843542, 0.0016180829843506217, 0.028560683131217957, -0.004439228679984808, -0.00837122742086649, 0.024978362023830414, 0.008618689142167568, -0.029306743294000626, 0.00252823019400239, -0.014061735942959785, -0.009421274997293949, 0.015754438936710358, -0.0502624474465847, 0.01604536361992359, 0.007213725708425045, 0.004961888771504164, 0.025946665555238724, -0.09027135372161865, 0.03904150798916817, 0.05068167671561241, 0.004826750140637159, 0.00019531573343556374, 0.021278321743011475, 0.015620755031704903, -0.024687349796295166, 0.011646052822470665, -0.009555693715810776, -0.008903651498258114, -0.008104221895337105, -0.0689275711774826, 0.019035253673791885, -0.06341491639614105, -0.015082836151123047, -0.02801215462386608, -0.01201487798243761, -0.024499157443642616, 0.06409351527690887, -0.02855597622692585, 0.049261610954999924, -0.002323832828551531, 0.07683950662612915, 0.0006696557393297553, 0.0216477382928133, 0.03735441714525223, 0.02581828087568283, -0.03452075272798538, 0.03199724853038788, 0.04162262752652168, 0.003977001644670963, -0.03361986577510834, 0.018146291375160217, 0.05141611769795418, -0.0033273338340222836, 0.004852265119552612, 0.030705055221915245, -0.006471933797001839, 0.05856836214661598, 0.023105457425117493, -0.0017361866775900126, 0.025647789239883423, -0.03054136410355568, 0.012288856320083141, 0.030874624848365784, 0.015880053862929344, -0.05122251808643341, -0.04037808999419212, 0.008977735415101051, 0.0439048707485199, -0.04494606330990791, -0.0041304659098386765, -0.004877887666225433, 0.02416488341987133, 0.04056443274021149, -0.02326168864965439, 0.012314151972532272, 0.09327518939971924, -0.08107760548591614, 0.07173853367567062, -0.033191196620464325, 0.018883710727095604, 0.006650646682828665, 0.011967530474066734, 0.057983431965112686, -0.015365767292678356, -0.09010091423988342, -0.024616926908493042, -0.0025161379016935825, -0.009458718821406364, -0.012307984754443169, -0.008264197036623955, -0.04818464070558548, -0.029258672147989273, 0.0015685402322560549, -0.00647360272705555, -0.010443487204611301, -0.04924371466040611, -0.04061383754014969, 0.03517496958374977, -0.032104965299367905, 0.049315065145492554, -0.044752806425094604, 0.028406420722603798, -0.0016833696281537414, 0.0033694745507091284, 0.004368932452052832, 0.03154515475034714, 0.06643451005220413, -0.06787820905447006, -0.01780153624713421, -0.0448281392455101, -0.04582441225647926, 0.02590794488787651, -0.04093950241804123, 0.00659263227134943, 0.001420712098479271, 0.04302754998207092, 0.002862101886421442, 0.03459392115473747, -0.0245477594435215, -0.03452014923095703, 0.026647644117474556, -0.021584728732705116, -0.01822848431766033, 0.030330421403050423, 0.037515364587306976, 0.0290678720921278, 0.001354586100205779, 0.07860327512025833, -0.044103849679231644, -0.00201888894662261, -0.0014795460738241673, -0.010337053798139095, 0.016345907002687454, -0.015830745920538902, 0.03157873824238777, -0.04064258933067322, 0.0057352022267878056, 0.011379052884876728, -0.0404885932803154, -0.05763645097613335, 0.02120182290673256, -0.03985646739602089, -0.01318393275141716, 0.062199559062719345, -0.007101033348590136, 0.05557740479707718, -0.0028174910694360733, 0.030987275764346123, 0.026987139135599136, 0.022321633994579315, 0.021750448271632195, 0.04073858633637428, 0.0038262330926954746, 0.026977209374308586, 0.015064318664371967, 0.009829503484070301, 0.013835608027875423, -0.07660625129938126, 0.052494149655103683, 0.0323672778904438, 0.04617691412568092, 0.016467496752738953, -0.09120737016201019, -0.0049887667410075665, 0.02404494769871235, 0.050435785204172134, 0.08478964865207672, -0.05587514862418175, -0.029145458713173866, 0.055228136479854584, 0.007331994827836752, -0.04721139371395111, 0.03374386206269264, -0.07914145290851593, 0.058046575635671616, -0.02873411402106285, -0.005607787985354662, -0.012256200425326824, -0.006976675242185593, 0.026770781725645065, 0.07333429902791977, -0.02079113759100437, -0.014292258769273758, -0.0072975740768015385, 0.0037730985786765814, 0.010003062896430492, 0.04029059410095215, 0.03745650127530098, -0.002915332093834877, -0.03980714827775955, 0.030088163912296295, -0.05712735652923584, -0.019332295283675194, 0.03157801181077957, -0.031579844653606415, 0.022341741248965263, -0.047433577477931976, 0.03409913182258606, -0.016111237928271294, -0.014139681123197079, -0.09395437687635422, -0.04521487280726433, -0.03113977238535881, 0.007419241592288017, 0.011257817968726158, 0.029729047790169716, 0.02683252841234207, -0.024105273187160492, 0.008739831857383251, 0.0004873985017184168, 0.05337651073932648, -0.083821602165699, -0.013903017155826092, -0.00536009669303894, -0.05977918207645416, 0.032817814499139786, 0.0009371390915475786, 0.018185997381806374, -0.04184933006763458, 0.021757641807198524, -0.010101978667080402, -0.061883509159088135, 0.07809930294752121, -0.04615034535527229, 0.050520867109298706, -0.0875408872961998, 0.06252677738666534, 0.001387870404869318, -0.02236606925725937, 0.04713943973183632, 0.02764902450144291, -0.021290499716997147, -0.03315789997577667, 0.04128623381257057, 0.005402513779699802, 0.0036057927645742893, -0.10463902354240417, -0.026980366557836533, -0.05069597065448761, -0.03210017457604408, 0.00815019104629755, -0.06033961847424507, -0.030591826885938644, -0.0018985195783898234, 0.0008240925380960107, -0.01562631130218506, 0.019456636160612106, -0.02706611342728138, -0.01692727766931057, -0.06807172298431396, 0.009184781461954117, 0.01827656850218773, 0.024950290098786354, 0.02856419049203396, -0.04236014559864998, 0.015499353408813477, -0.027911104261875153, 0.013959326781332493, -0.003569819265976548, 0.0057139466516673565, -0.05215904489159584, 0.023366577923297882, 0.0158854890614748, 0.05214406177401543, -0.010135871358215809, -0.0850905328989029, 0.09022630751132965, 0.010401693172752857, -0.03821735456585884, -0.0004890005220659077, 0.03067333810031414, -0.012343375943601131, -0.011384321376681328, 0.04940599575638771, -0.05159853771328926, -0.014095502905547619, -0.0037208511494100094, 0.013999354094266891, -0.004791540559381247, 0.040522146970033646, 0.059836700558662415, -0.050773486495018005, 0.009697379544377327, -0.06827986240386963, -0.026986438781023026, -0.0007794000557623804, -0.027883198112249374, 0.05349397659301758, 0.01700151152908802, 0.01847734861075878, -0.05391962081193924, -0.015572009608149529, -0.0476701483130455, 0.003003279911354184, 0.029395004734396935, -0.023026060312986374, -0.05962323769927025, 0.0016874732682481408, 0.04148022085428238, 0.006520204711705446, -0.008584123104810715, -0.0819767639040947, -0.03257548436522484, 0.04607497528195381, -0.05773074924945831, -0.013304946012794971, 0.034107889980077744, -0.0028946329839527607, 0.07531274855136871, -0.06216778606176376, -0.008821411058306694, -0.037768106907606125, 0.018453488126397133, -0.030618079006671906, -0.10172297060489655, 0.04438263550400734, -0.014855561777949333, -0.030374154448509216, -0.02584291249513626, 0.013726477511227131, 0.00557940686121583, 0.03496003523468971, 0.002940607722848654, 0.004576554987579584, -0.01279387902468443, 0.049711696803569794, -0.059395790100097656, -0.009108123369514942, -0.02870800718665123, 0.035526860505342484, 0.06192928925156593, 0.03767923638224602, 0.01730240508913994, 0.012015758082270622, 0.025174330919981003, -0.03464891016483307, -0.03292929381132126, -0.030565163120627403, 0.005847995635122061, 0.07870571315288544, -0.00619956199079752, -0.00936620682477951, -0.021313102915883064, -0.03602223098278046, 0.013064590282738209, -0.016931449994444847, 0.06401888281106949, 0.039549633860588074, -0.02603590115904808, -0.011725624091923237, -0.031012259423732758, 0.014572308398783207, 0.05917039513587952, 0.0015427484177052975, -0.027900632470846176, -0.04921781271696091, -0.004927832633256912, -0.01211119256913662, 0.0015975208953022957, 0.0034108380787074566, -0.058995429426431656, -0.10060597211122513, -0.017284996807575226, 0.02164454199373722, 0.03812446817755699, -0.03029964677989483, -0.016202658414840698, 0.01767090894281864, 0.050369665026664734, 0.033362772315740585, -0.03197251260280609, -0.014191627502441406, -0.017292162403464317, 0.017436377704143524, -0.03065832331776619, -0.029105445370078087, 0.0368889681994915, 0.0029765756335109472, -0.006583790760487318, -0.011768212541937828, -0.005010195076465607, -0.010569256730377674, 0.022174591198563576, -0.06786683201789856, 0.025433175265789032, -0.03978073596954346, -0.003886708989739418, -0.004657653160393238, -0.023778807371854782, 0.0483846440911293, 0.07094275951385498, 0.0019923201762139797, 0.04346010088920593, 0.0632806047797203, 0.017878888174891472, 0.051854878664016724, 0.011144692078232765, -0.04522671550512314, 0.03867754712700844, -0.05216075852513313, -0.09603457897901535, -0.013572880998253822, 0.01426609791815281, 0.03299790248274803, 0.02025478519499302, -0.024286990985274315, 0.0376352034509182, -0.005434053018689156, 0.02380785532295704, 0.027138469740748405 ]
<p>Is there a tutorial explanation as to how decoherence transforms a wavefunction (with a superposition of possible observable values) into a set of well-defined specific "classical" observable values <em>without</em> the concept of the wavefunction undergoing "collapse"?</p> <p>I mean an explanation which is less technical than that decoherence is </p> <blockquote> <p><em>the decay or rapid vanishing of the off-diagonal elements of the partial trace of the joint system's density matrix, i.e. the trace, with respect to any environmental basis, of the density matrix of the combined system and its environment [...]</em> (<a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decoherence#Density_matrix_approach" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia</a>).</p> </blockquote>
g5872
[ 0.020158711820840836, 0.004880101885646582, -0.011053571477532387, -0.03186670318245888, 0.011767776682972908, 0.020031088963150978, 0.05168403685092926, 0.05509156733751297, -0.029108727350831032, -0.022830776870250702, -0.020653214305639267, -0.0023315935395658016, 0.06048262119293213, 0.00860243383795023, 0.011780132539570332, -0.014536249451339245, 0.05068817362189293, 0.06761374324560165, 0.05078478530049324, 0.036697231233119965, -0.0341193825006485, -0.015666499733924866, 0.019820421934127808, 0.0434868261218071, -0.04595830664038658, -0.0020623125601559877, 0.05646520480513573, -0.010270138271152973, -0.03702675178647041, -0.020021460950374603, -0.0043246024288237095, 0.0017226454801857471, 0.011166623793542385, 0.0176262054592371, 0.010646691545844078, 0.018057702109217644, 0.001353343715891242, 0.022419745102524757, 0.03160595893859863, 0.009574576281011105, -0.013581523671746254, -0.03405483439564705, 0.048281479626894, -0.021616138517856598, -0.00291261519305408, 0.04507932439446449, -0.03863009065389633, -0.02995465137064457, -0.05474548786878586, -0.07025741040706635, 0.015980245545506477, -0.01441251952201128, 0.03992929309606552, 0.036774877458810806, -0.0051576606929302216, 0.01702072098851204, 0.029945552349090576, -0.01476252544671297, 0.06396947801113129, -0.022990968078374863, 0.00023206773039419204, -0.00559126865118742, 0.029022524133324623, -0.03756888583302498, 0.054468221962451935, 0.007036563474684954, -0.03899099677801132, -0.025822099298238754, 0.022001191973686218, -0.024653621017932892, 0.02246284671127796, -0.012073110789060593, -0.0938793495297432, -0.02941020391881466, 0.04404226690530777, -0.014820314943790436, -0.012545853853225708, -0.029270777478814125, 0.033249564468860626, 0.022221211344003677, -0.05686386674642563, -0.02792155183851719, 0.018160998821258545, 0.0044171856716275215, 0.025808004662394524, 0.036451637744903564, -0.048919644206762314, 0.009827634319663048, -0.011687946505844593, 0.015962213277816772, 0.03403007611632347, -0.021585557609796524, 0.011703206226229668, -0.00972085352987051, -0.018486198037862778, 0.0006044768379069865, -0.017485618591308594, 0.01145805325359106, -0.004641713574528694, -0.050949495285749435, -0.008360389620065689, -0.025150436908006668, 0.003104412229731679, -0.05307037755846977, 0.009374739602208138, -0.004045695532113314, -0.049344368278980255, 0.0049423109740018845, 0.005571555346250534, 0.033988140523433685, -0.03885827213525772, -0.00042756632319651544, -0.04657236114144325, 0.023092536255717278, -0.00214270013384521, -0.004406161606311798, 0.030946675688028336, -0.04139024019241333, -0.053165946155786514, 0.0011382224038243294, 0.005484867375344038, 0.008270141668617725, 0.06314517557621002, -0.009572677314281464, 0.009700839407742023, 0.0236170943826437, 0.03547373786568642, 0.01752965711057186, 0.041418615728616714, 0.009735358878970146, 0.011052769608795643, 0.056710388511419296, -0.03683619573712349, 0.015535571612417698, 0.0002513696381356567, -0.012159350328147411, 0.017090212553739548, 0.006787519436329603, -0.014515719376504421, 0.018884500488638878, 0.030960464850068092, -0.03851298615336418, -0.029645822942256927, -0.015616584569215775, 0.04576687142252922, -0.06208373233675957, 0.010806431993842125, -0.022441549226641655, 0.054437100887298584, 0.05237996205687523, 0.030974430963397026, 0.07178457826375961, -0.04216880351305008, -0.0888187363743782, 0.055433545261621475, 0.018320981413125992, 0.027820158749818802, -0.04586376994848251, -0.032412089407444, -0.012660429812967777, 0.04052425175905228, 0.026497051119804382, 0.0011881666723638773, 0.011853991076350212, -0.0318441204726696, -0.0265217162668705, 0.0016151609597727656, -0.08104535937309265, 0.005036831367760897, -0.07030735164880753, -0.01118429284542799, -0.004707591142505407, -0.012057102285325527, 0.08045428991317749, -0.019826512783765793, 0.07837949693202972, 0.02359967865049839, -0.02614550292491913, 0.05739283189177513, 0.017630401998758316, 0.0018265587277710438, 0.0529937669634819, -0.006144585553556681, -0.026561612263321877, 0.06402494013309479, 0.02482154220342636, 0.0040192995220422745, 0.057339493185281754, -0.041347768157720566, -0.014097507111728191, -0.012380591593682766, -0.02834801748394966, 0.013146916404366493, 0.06312564015388489, 0.016658829525113106, -0.02315814420580864, -0.0020204633474349976, 0.010970065370202065, -0.031284939497709274, -0.019878292456269264, 0.002600800944492221, 0.008571370504796505, 0.02105124108493328, 0.04736372083425522, -0.019824761897325516, 0.01931498944759369, -0.05609980225563049, 0.053319308906793594, -0.012798784300684929, -0.013788391835987568, 0.017705535516142845, -0.057169828563928604, -0.053903404623270035, -0.030138039961457253, -0.013781484216451645, -0.017733808606863022, -0.010799904353916645, -0.017735401168465614, -0.049550868570804596, 0.012983174063265324, -0.034952312707901, -0.008184660226106644, 0.0010989443399012089, 0.028294308111071587, -0.006084953434765339, 0.04047222062945366, -0.007771438919007778, -0.019866831600666046, 0.008047841489315033, 0.018921390175819397, -0.0687660351395607, -0.028801389038562775, -0.06997823715209961, -0.044242799282073975, 0.0371556282043457, 0.1122581958770752, -0.018227308988571167, -0.03630697354674339, 0.07057970017194748, 0.04376315698027611, 0.05703400820493698, -0.036323823034763336, -0.027382802218198776, -0.0015836579259485006, 0.060224585235118866, -0.08802228420972824, 0.005975616164505482, -0.02737341821193695, 0.036286696791648865, -0.0519290566444397, -0.07182610034942627, -0.05371147021651268, -0.022231575101614, -0.057590924203395844, -0.03188994526863098, -0.03537381812930107, 0.004961234983056784, 0.012522794306278229, 0.017844604328274727, -0.013666678220033646, -0.01227391604334116, 0.04812401905655861, -0.027600400149822235, 0.014901375398039818, -0.034548964351415634, -0.020130746066570282, 0.010020123794674873, -0.02481822669506073, -0.06464452296495438, -0.007311027962714434, 0.015334947034716606, 0.04474654421210289, 0.025244275107979774, 0.04143783822655678, -0.03676497936248779, 0.035078469663858414, -0.06670767813920975, 0.0013346632476896048, 0.007371207699179649, -0.026084961369633675, -0.051484666764736176, -0.018398988991975784, -0.0002547909098211676, -0.013219834305346012, 0.04867428541183472, -0.10747236013412476, -0.0006106399814598262, 0.04241330549120903, 0.050958458334207535, 0.0020678371656686068, -0.0533699207007885, 0.057764556258916855, -0.007243046071380377, 0.0285195205360651, -0.05710352957248688, 0.01499499473720789, -0.005489683710038662, -0.046621039509773254, 0.012949244119226933, 0.02888329327106476, 0.0064664497040212154, -0.04829030483961105, -0.014012422412633896, -0.0599139966070652, 0.015747467055916786, 0.07514163106679916, -0.05048918351531029, 0.03829101100564003, -0.07902944087982178, 0.020312635228037834, 0.001112661906518042, -0.001807160908356309, -0.0448216013610363, -0.01577076129615307, -0.0036158619914203882, -0.009953673928976059, 0.0021296688355505466, -0.06633473187685013, 0.013138544745743275, -0.039825744926929474, -0.04243941977620125, -0.04707182198762894, -0.013746481388807297, -0.011827966198325157, 0.06123827397823334, 0.0069628432393074036, -0.07008551806211472, 0.030201738700270653, 0.03633301705121994, -0.023065226152539253, 0.016634203493595123, -0.010165749117732048, 0.032868947833776474, -0.004345107823610306, -0.06891265511512756, -0.02889535017311573, -0.053187064826488495, 0.028983397409319878, 0.013151992112398148, 0.029559170827269554, 0.010120932012796402, -0.031128806993365288, 0.017092231661081314, 0.00607410678640008, -0.015490931458771229, 0.014426193200051785, -0.03558606654405594, -0.04354150965809822, 0.04596566781401634, -0.05238819122314453, -0.01375348400324583, -0.004907459020614624, 0.02080243080854416, -0.037522245198488235, -0.05699840188026428, 0.012308763340115547, 0.03866889327764511, -0.02686341106891632, 0.05835801362991333, 0.0623166523873806, -0.0006346252048388124, -0.05191659554839134, 0.03701276332139969, 0.0026044663973152637, -0.004456916358321905, 0.0077348616905510426, -0.013571458868682384, 0.0628318339586258, -0.025561150163412094, -0.021285302937030792, 0.03842844069004059, -0.014255878515541553, -0.007237548474222422, 0.02116134949028492, 0.009198775514960289, -0.05503767728805542, 0.02190890908241272, -0.007754597347229719, -0.013822088949382305, 0.05882144719362259, 0.03310152515769005, 0.039155930280685425, 0.03964187204837799, -0.01867762766778469, 0.06974185258150101, 0.007689015474170446, -0.015350395813584328, -0.054086048156023026, 0.005107962992042303, -0.01984582468867302, 0.024617396295070648, -0.028103169053792953, 0.0059858523309230804, -0.009675360284745693, 0.04546387121081352, 0.039671070873737335, -0.025414401665329933, 0.03114928863942623, -0.0711415708065033, 0.035943403840065, -0.0003071530372835696, -0.0038726571947336197, -0.05926702916622162, 0.006691735237836838, 0.04559214040637016, -0.012236338108778, 0.014181502163410187, -0.047391388565301895, -0.0043577454052865505, -0.04205610975623131, 0.011555999517440796, -0.0017377258045598865, 0.03413514792919159, -0.06786927580833435, 0.0267677903175354, 0.03234751895070076, 0.12440662831068039, 0.012587119825184345, 0.015434176661074162, 0.007031869143247604, -0.044244397431612015, 0.032763879746198654, -0.07467059046030045, -0.0003112784761469811, 0.006112616043537855, 0.057606711983680725, 0.004924714099615812, -0.08310605585575104, 0.004465830512344837, 0.017650289461016655, 0.014563445933163166, 0.03960255905985832, -0.008405296131968498, 0.04178036004304886, -0.057285454124212265, -0.010270101949572563, -0.03866508975625038, 0.08452828228473663, -0.019309870898723602, 0.08973265439271927, 0.03575800731778145, -0.03878011927008629, -0.01796439103782177, 0.01750580407679081, 0.020470984280109406, 0.06492611020803452, 0.05180583894252777, -0.018370458856225014, 0.006413872819393873, -0.037798333913087845, -0.0649026483297348, 0.09712982922792435, -0.0013496105093508959, -0.031116515398025513, -0.009719223715364933, -0.06278055161237717, -0.0023030396550893784, 0.06343069672584534, -0.03150162473320961, 0.017834151163697243, -0.011285604909062386, -0.03750982880592346, -0.03895501792430878, -0.028585156425833702, 0.010005071759223938, -0.0014326943783089519, -0.09135840833187103, 0.022525040432810783, -0.029631957411766052, -0.005671127233654261, 0.019598232582211494, -0.03697851300239563, 0.020200036466121674, -0.05544136464595795, 0.0053238109685480595, 0.04014462232589722, -0.008568361401557922, -0.012452295981347561, 0.05443450063467026, -0.023219428956508636, 0.01754789426922798, 0.04203661158680916, 0.014478897675871849, -0.01784498244524002, 0.0103065250441432, 0.023257730528712273, 0.0064310431480407715, -0.04248500615358353, -0.014378625899553299, -0.018524153158068657, 0.01419398095458746, 0.018894314765930176, 0.0241489727050066, 0.029061168432235718, -0.0019393484108150005, -0.0967647135257721, 0.01910603977739811, -0.017243316397070885, -0.06028104946017265, -0.03493116423487663, -0.033056844025850296, -0.005770895164459944, -0.023318979889154434, 0.05490398034453392, -0.032846275717020035, 0.028367172926664352, 0.08483634144067764, 0.009415356442332268, -0.004971588961780071, 0.021995550021529198, -0.020024772733449936, -0.006425837054848671, 0.008271541446447372, 0.03784135356545448, 0.0172666534781456, -0.013628521002829075, -0.06857068091630936, -0.011006119661033154, -0.06076629087328911, -0.05851699784398079, -0.0545857809484005, 0.0021710521541535854, -0.03401050344109535, -0.008678121492266655, 0.027072938159108162, 0.019493848085403442, -0.03846009820699692, -0.02601490542292595, -0.010814005509018898, 0.10172367841005325, 0.03994065150618553, -0.02222428098320961, 0.028089262545108795, -0.031614914536476135, 0.0008569060009904206, -0.033878058195114136, -0.04166071116924286, 0.010316786356270313, -0.0015812288038432598, 0.05766965448856354, -0.013659690506756306, 0.02768326923251152, -0.00987892597913742, 0.021761983633041382, -0.0076433345675468445, -0.006983391474932432, -0.01780577190220356, 0.0010553330648690462, 0.04274410754442215, -0.007487935945391655, -0.009042847901582718, -0.02172267809510231, -0.018846986815333366, -0.018378552049398422, 0.038522541522979736, 0.016126714646816254, 0.010804117657244205, 0.026121722534298897, -0.03091433458030224, -0.01594984158873558, 0.00893768947571516, 0.07449046522378922, 0.03708644211292267, 0.019239820539951324, 0.06779602915048599, -0.031090764328837395, -0.017700040712952614, 0.016583086922764778, 0.006893415004014969, 0.025464287027716637, -0.020229822024703026, 0.007638567592948675, 0.051538657397031784, 0.014016901142895222, -0.03284456953406334, 0.040085744112730026, -0.02723338082432747, -0.025258544832468033, -0.01566655933856964, -0.0065133036114275455, 0.027074629440903664, -0.047884270548820496, 0.09207212924957275, -0.0012543747434392571, -0.05529748275876045, -0.017666665837168694, -0.03232457861304283, -0.02067738026380539, 0.03868953883647919, 0.08890105783939362, 0.0341767780482769, 0.041245974600315094, -0.007631426211446524, 0.03707067668437958, 0.03334981948137283, -0.025201963260769844, -0.023104017600417137, 0.08104681968688965, 0.012238116934895515, -0.03617066517472267, -0.004490656312555075, 0.02525029331445694, 0.062136705964803696, -0.03320028632879257, 0.0898096039891243, 0.034582044929265976, 0.0007852619746699929, -0.0021336213685572147, 0.022451719269156456, -0.014282502233982086, -0.02975573018193245, 0.029674053192138672, 0.04064776748418808, 0.020281098783016205, 0.061051901429891586, -0.04312445968389511, -0.0033938181586563587, 0.0007890100823715329, -0.06472915410995483, 0.039532482624053955, 0.006034074351191521, -0.020937535911798477, 0.057910848408937454, 0.0017573647201061249, 0.0040095956064760685, 0.04294035956263542, 0.09628400206565857, -0.062310442328453064, 0.037245817482471466, 0.05738220363855362, 0.006895214784890413, -0.055801231414079666, 0.0485382005572319, 0.04228693246841431, -0.045978013426065445, 0.07106097042560577, -0.04527181386947632, 0.0640190988779068, 0.07851322740316391, 0.030669549480080605, 0.049087222665548325, 0.02019798941910267, 0.04223886877298355, -0.04773159325122833, -0.04431093484163284, 0.02487155608832836, 0.05789242684841156, -0.060578733682632446, -0.04777192696928978, 0.01196349784731865, 0.04177098721265793, -0.012164386920630932, -0.02015766128897667, 0.05216497927904129, -0.022734899073839188, 0.03716963157057762, 0.029245788231492043, 0.009665420278906822, 0.013134671375155449, -0.011285203509032726, -0.03570355102419853, -0.0071197268553078175, 0.029133785516023636, -0.015884820371866226, 0.009597417898476124, 0.00921009574085474, 0.02274332568049431, -0.05115080252289772, -0.008128330111503601, -0.002605798887088895, -0.0075834025628864765, -0.03374641761183739, -0.05361929535865784, -0.014740046113729477, 0.03579862043261528, 0.014183803461492062, 0.002407579915598035, 0.0484565794467926, 0.006920988671481609, -0.042989686131477356, 0.0360453724861145, 0.05847855284810066, 0.026237208396196365, -0.050857849419116974, -0.005018413532525301, 0.01922169141471386, 0.012771818786859512, -0.0002971515350509435, -0.005005587823688984, 0.020508963614702225, -0.018340472131967545, -0.009006875567138195, -0.009443848393857479, -0.030231507495045662, -0.04240398854017258, 0.001989944837987423, 0.027427637949585915, 0.007286654785275459, 0.004742951598018408, 0.03664860501885414, -0.022292036563158035, -0.02290535531938076, -0.03021843172609806, -0.002224159659817815, -0.01901676319539547, -0.02460971288383007, -0.006312576588243246, -0.07694312930107117, -0.033850643783807755, -0.021038861945271492, -0.022852474823594093, 0.03736693039536476, -0.014536270871758461, -0.05484870821237564, -0.009060009382665157, 0.019893325865268707, -0.023125426843762398, 0.008834728971123695, -0.0001722112065181136, -0.006635013036429882, -0.015668166801333427, -0.0013337957207113504, -0.007326650898903608, -0.001259723911061883, -0.06403708457946777, 0.012956629507243633, 0.013852248899638653, -0.007045082747936249, 0.026164699345827103, 0.006030500400811434, -0.033300384879112244, 0.005559359211474657, -0.010784801095724106, 0.02555699460208416, 0.007078659255057573, 0.03812458738684654, 0.00466331047937274, 0.03636091947555542, -0.07375819236040115, 0.035343848168849945, -0.013287343084812164, -0.04156577214598656, -0.04144405201077461, -0.012540459632873535, -0.01066471915692091, 0.004408346954733133, 0.005606678314507008, 0.008422899059951305, 0.017797963693737984, -0.040779415518045425, -0.03827214613556862, 0.017152821645140648, 0.03724197670817375, 0.005024777725338936, 0.0256042443215847, -0.00030946923652663827, -0.019904593005776405, -0.03428611531853676, 0.07687486708164215, -0.008518927730619907, 0.012743016704916954, -0.025744076818227768, -0.009168746881186962, -0.04873095452785492, -0.06997963786125183, -0.050039295107126236, -0.0141293341293931, 0.0000054644456213281956 ]
<p>Very quick question, does a magnet contain energy? The general consensus seems to be, it does not. And this is generally confirmed by the fact that it would break the first law of thermodynamics. Whatever the hell that is (joke:)</p> <p>The reason I ask is because a) I'm no genius and b) because I'm perplexed. So maybe some of you smart people could help me out please.</p> <p>Here's the scenario;</p> <p>Now, if I took, oh I dunno, say a metal ball and lifted it say six inches. I have converted some of my man boob calories into energy that is now stored in the ball. When I release it and it drops to original level, the energy is released. Makes sense.</p> <p>Now if I took the same metal ball and rolled it along the ground, it would continue to roll until the kinetic energy was depleted, through friction and stuff like that.</p> <p>Now if I take the same ball and roll it along the ground, but this time with a magnet suspended 6 inches from the ground and directly in the line of movement. The magnet is strong enough to attract the ball and is therefore lifted 6 inches and sticks to the magnet. Where has that energy come from? It can't have come from me putting the magnet there, as once I put the magnet back on the ground, I have released that energy.</p> <p>As I said, I'm not smart, nor educated, just been pondering this question for a couple of days.</p> <p>Would be great if you could allow my brain to get back to menial tasks.</p> <p>Thanks</p>
g5873
[ 0.06746748834848404, 0.035490624606609344, 0.01590145379304886, -0.016235530376434326, -0.005106290336698294, 0.05212115868926048, -0.01953195407986641, 0.05766897648572922, -0.04650963097810745, 0.0060696667060256, -0.05510445311665535, -0.011192995123565197, -0.031099792569875717, -0.05436655879020691, 0.0008610814111307263, -0.039457373321056366, 0.05708705261349678, -0.015728935599327087, 0.03919195011258125, -0.006952465977519751, -0.01783605106174946, -0.0022753123193979263, 0.004370656330138445, -0.05554187670350075, -0.05372640863060951, 0.0023354992736130953, -0.013212478719651699, 0.004206505604088306, -0.008538085967302322, 0.0009309531305916607, -0.027856474742293358, -0.03777555748820305, 0.030976464971899986, -0.0824137032032013, -0.06003689393401146, -0.035654034465551376, 0.03982227295637131, 0.0063792141154408455, 0.007102465257048607, -0.018098371103405952, -0.03769124671816826, -0.019392667338252068, -0.0033020898699760437, -0.030264906585216522, 0.0408504456281662, 0.05296218767762184, -0.0024651854764670134, -0.0007192271295934916, -0.008237344212830067, -0.012130237184464931, -0.0031292333733290434, 0.05130936950445175, 0.018578408285975456, 0.03231365233659744, -0.0023549962788820267, -0.014319071546196938, 0.05760839954018593, -0.011569558642804623, 0.07072167843580246, 0.030784497037529945, 0.024664055556058884, -0.0024586543440818787, -0.021591516211628914, -0.011780424043536186, -0.005403680726885796, -0.02167774736881256, -0.06167282164096832, 0.015897255390882492, -0.025505509227514267, 0.011264053173363209, -0.00014262199692893773, 0.0024475993122905493, -0.035437874495983124, -0.05988769605755806, -0.00521863205358386, 0.024732206016778946, 0.0722033679485321, -0.05062965303659439, 0.052097074687480927, 0.01216151937842369, -0.0437772311270237, 0.04198698699474335, 0.05717603489756584, 0.010127781890332699, 0.04449671506881714, 0.01753399148583412, -0.04941719397902489, 0.015978822484612465, -0.004982855636626482, 0.022181080654263496, 0.06502993404865265, 0.013486393727362156, 0.07800114154815674, 0.04581543058156967, -0.03332880884408951, -0.03918936848640442, 0.0388277992606163, 0.06829142570495605, -0.034727420657873154, -0.013532302342355251, -0.04827161133289337, -0.08368821442127228, -0.012697284109890461, -0.009142066352069378, 0.008377932012081146, -0.04574042558670044, 0.007899541407823563, 0.02937961369752884, 0.00531453313305974, 0.03333897516131401, 0.01270109973847866, -0.02567632496356964, -0.016754239797592163, 0.010992326773703098, -0.013849289156496525, -0.009197286330163479, 0.09042835980653763, 0.020319389179348946, -0.012532302178442478, 0.01830999366939068, 0.04319765418767929, 0.037659902125597, 0.016781629994511604, 0.005252906121313572, -0.044027093797922134, -0.015990231186151505, 0.0030224889051169157, -0.012813129462301731, -0.02854914590716362, -0.011219944804906845, -0.0397598035633564, -0.00924533512443304, -0.0188442412763834, -0.011771200224757195, 0.012445015832781792, 0.03681308403611183, 0.0193558931350708, -0.0025444861967116594, -0.021577419713139534, 0.009955150075256824, 0.023333443328738213, -0.057220231741666794, 0.059297312051057816, -0.00104744010604918, -0.06258004903793335, 0.06675015389919281, 0.026503922417759895, 0.0028745573945343494, 0.06587827950716019, 0.05822854861617088, 0.0017780468333512545, 0.007307691965252161, -0.010121910832822323, -0.09395231306552887, 0.07977305352687836, -0.03842401131987572, -0.0009726716671139002, 0.014984630979597569, 0.013637764379382133, -0.014772727154195309, 0.08700073510408401, -0.03773999214172363, 0.076081283390522, -0.017188765108585358, 0.010438338853418827, 0.032415278255939484, 0.08656811714172363, -0.013884936459362507, -0.02712668664753437, 0.026106324046850204, -0.06326844543218613, -0.03268568962812424, 0.0016028607496991754, 0.001729934592731297, -0.040441811084747314, 0.0588214136660099, 0.010802875272929668, -0.04798004776239395, 0.018460195511579514, -0.05338512361049652, 0.0072709498926997185, 0.009225394576787949, 0.04718654230237007, -0.03685934469103813, 0.007006391882896423, 0.017671264708042145, -0.028659271076321602, 0.009237297810614109, -0.01667756587266922, -0.012409436516463757, -0.007195226848125458, 0.040827132761478424, -0.0269935205578804, 0.00796582456678152, -0.0064600142650306225, -0.05014007166028023, -0.01017831638455391, -0.021878613159060478, -0.026571203023195267, 0.028038617223501205, 0.02932334691286087, 0.004470242653042078, -0.0037476634606719017, -0.003647128352895379, -0.021877191960811615, 0.01153663732111454, 0.023507878184318542, 0.009642642922699451, 0.0405077263712883, -0.024357208982110023, 0.048320870846509933, 0.02153070643544197, -0.003396183019503951, -0.005864481441676617, -0.004280725959688425, -0.02541825734078884, 0.0002687734959181398, 0.020590471103787422, -0.01306578703224659, 0.003982446622103453, -0.013071159832179546, 0.043559666723012924, 0.04977401718497276, -0.0278040561825037, -0.01085553877055645, -0.03695369139313698, -0.07096169888973236, -0.042838454246520996, -0.071648970246315, 0.027721811085939407, -0.05410059168934822, 0.04316648468375206, 0.003949644975364208, -0.010468407534062862, 0.03186888247728348, 0.07131990790367126, 0.0018951927777379751, 0.005433954764157534, -0.020181668922305107, -0.015780294314026833, -0.0028018972370773554, -0.008187275379896164, 0.04947401583194733, -0.007539502345025539, 0.04799225926399231, -0.004485839977860451, 0.072184719145298, 0.0046522649936378, 0.045751892030239105, 0.007956421934068203, 0.08685079216957092, -0.04308606684207916, -0.030780622735619545, 0.004645356442779303, 0.007141760550439358, 0.007857903838157654, -0.051673825830221176, -0.008677697740495205, -0.11300159245729446, -0.028365015983581543, 0.03915475308895111, -0.06539227813482285, 0.022670364007353783, 0.05666917562484741, -0.04866742342710495, -0.053330183029174805, 0.0035800067707896233, -0.02890194021165371, -0.008778441697359085, -0.028596317395567894, -0.06537742912769318, 0.016314195469021797, 0.020924553275108337, 0.06225457414984703, 0.010289555415511131, -0.040030207484960556, 0.01828787662088871, -0.01531657762825489, 0.03686493635177612, -0.05489867925643921, -0.02255498804152012, -0.02484055981040001, -0.0568203441798687, 0.0011145989410579205, 0.0066728596575558186, 0.005549740977585316, -0.017660239711403847, -0.058042239397764206, -0.004721815697848797, -0.02845107391476631, -0.04171513766050339, 0.009520105086266994, 0.05519101023674011, -0.003176005557179451, -0.058150023221969604, 0.048580069094896317, 0.01823326200246811, 0.005621021613478661, -0.04689217731356621, 0.03688868135213852, 0.0014007689896970987, 0.00811702199280262, -0.03885234519839287, -0.013321416452527046, 0.0013886468950659037, 0.054546285420656204, -0.05932219326496124, -0.045256488025188446, 0.029419884085655212, -0.025253908708691597, -0.05473579093813896, 0.10108780860900879, 0.0427837073802948, 0.03500783443450928, -0.06991054862737656, 0.01269097812473774, -0.0490436814725399, -0.003222050378099084, 0.010837993584573269, 0.01378551498055458, -0.008752869442105293, -0.018507355824112892, -0.005535706877708435, -0.02113887295126915, 0.02269294112920761, 0.006544878706336021, -0.014166267588734627, -0.014584929682314396, 0.03406570479273796, -0.0371582917869091, 0.008051102980971336, 0.040239445865154266, -0.02722378447651863, -0.014394641853868961, -0.04989831522107124, 0.013161594048142433, -0.013859166763722897, -0.007937881164252758, 0.029666896909475327, 0.042741067707538605, 0.008538756519556046, 0.04561668634414673, -0.015529962256550789, -0.02194097824394703, 0.02368118241429329, 0.08411780744791031, -0.03761768341064453, -0.023493163287639618, -0.014726382680237293, 0.00886570941656828, 0.07309494912624359, 0.020005052909255028, 0.015292705968022346, -0.058812256902456284, -0.03526962175965309, -0.0169899333268404, 0.0016585147241130471, 0.0017700651660561562, -0.05441363528370857, 0.02248723804950714, -0.020956695079803467, 0.040633827447891235, 0.02167406491935253, -0.019405363127589226, -0.01012734416872263, 0.06641948968172073, -0.04605443403124809, 0.015455997548997402, -0.0004796712310053408, -0.0029413814190775156, -0.027322854846715927, -0.056207768619060516, -0.015432488173246384, 0.03847983852028847, -0.0008015253697521985, -0.00970518495887518, 0.042158689349889755, -0.023601306602358818, -0.05157289654016495, -0.028709687292575836, -0.011183084920048714, 0.011438868008553982, 0.007801539730280638, 0.03146307170391083, 0.03943534940481186, 0.03194274753332138, -0.02602272480726242, 0.01988687925040722, 0.0159686841070652, 0.0070150066167116165, -0.0008538268739357591, 0.008368408307433128, 0.023908361792564392, -0.00014498979726340622, 0.02231459692120552, 0.03510340303182602, -0.021963130682706833, -0.023037783801555634, 0.03775707632303238, 0.024404896423220634, 0.007165673654526472, 0.03679525479674339, 0.002204020507633686, -0.05195631459355354, 0.02298976294696331, 0.02278398722410202, 0.07036244124174118, -0.07000204175710678, -0.05664850026369095, -0.017575832083821297, 0.010567665100097656, -0.0536700114607811, -0.02187824249267578, -0.027674971148371696, 0.01643289439380169, -0.027563901618123055, 0.006687126122415066, 0.015428151935338974, -0.030874401330947876, -0.02109890803694725, 0.029221776872873306, 0.012817304581403732, -0.0056724753230810165, -0.030517635866999626, -0.041885219514369965, 0.06002180278301239, 0.05327574908733368, -0.0020487040746957064, -0.044947847723960876, 0.012947315350174904, -0.020630162209272385, 0.03251006826758385, 0.02604345977306366, -0.007336052600294352, -0.020920775830745697, 0.0005392058519646525, -0.05720851570367813, 0.035418059676885605, 0.029317501932382584, -0.022116784006357193, 0.08668437600135803, 0.036111019551754, 0.005657330621033907, 0.0023809117265045643, -0.04743146151304245, 0.021183030679821968, -0.012433454394340515, 0.010328319855034351, -0.06214633211493492, -0.07888060063123703, 0.006429220549762249, 0.025162970647215843, -0.03446146100759506, 0.03431711718440056, -0.00911517534404993, -0.023235661908984184, -0.0008587909978814423, -0.034535620361566544, 0.02117251418530941, 0.03691203147172928, -0.04977348446846008, 0.003491821000352502, 0.058976102620363235, -0.009754457511007786, -0.036310967057943344, -0.033212367445230484, 0.057942040264606476, -0.03382902219891548, -0.018278319388628006, -0.023302381858229637, 0.02300291880965233, 0.01902574673295021, -0.012361724860966206, -0.009813938289880753, 0.06405212730169296, -0.007271494250744581, 0.035948652774095535, -0.027943406254053116, 0.05271394923329353, -0.07830594480037689, -0.02798391878604889, 0.03387913480401039, -0.002964588114991784, 0.021858368068933487, -0.0035703552421182394, -0.012781181372702122, -0.04374425485730171, 0.051327578723430634, 0.1028912365436554, -0.004495237022638321, -0.028348157182335854, 0.030071422457695007, -0.005645140539854765, -0.05225248262286186, -0.023194700479507446, -0.05237777531147003, -0.01713102124631405, -0.029906226322054863, -0.05646533519029617, 0.0012906012125313282, -0.05724719911813736, -0.01830913871526718, -0.01878758706152439, 0.05049603059887886, 0.0012330638710409403, 0.020518528297543526, -0.00341362995095551, 0.00981820933520794, -0.014864834025502205, 0.045779451727867126, -0.06698928773403168, 0.01925870031118393, -0.040338266640901566, 0.004817214794456959, 0.014261949807405472, -0.014013700187206268, 0.02942551299929619, 0.02201821096241474, 0.030193990096449852, 0.04200148209929466, 0.007192711811512709, -0.0250330101698637, 0.10268673300743103, -0.06325683742761612, -0.05676095560193062, 0.03566864877939224, -0.06631145626306534, 0.027908219024538994, -0.008504856377840042, 0.07966820150613785, 0.022603588178753853, 0.0081724151968956, 0.02747335284948349, 0.021267298609018326, -0.03507804498076439, -0.00765994843095541, 0.016350209712982178, -0.017389768734574318, 0.022159898653626442, 0.022389275953173637, 0.04087352380156517, -0.06540331244468689, 0.01458451896905899, 0.0029625827446579933, -0.013864043168723583, -0.03431737422943115, -0.04618186131119728, -0.031252119690179825, 0.057926252484321594, -0.04617209732532501, 0.0036789262667298317, 0.04224138706922531, 0.024997137486934662, 0.017996102571487427, -0.007030122447758913, 0.010040097869932652, -0.03266848623752594, 0.0108651639893651, -0.002853581914678216, -0.05523233115673065, -0.002780516631901264, 0.032842252403497696, 0.03049980290234089, 0.016141531988978386, 0.05984921380877495, -0.01987437903881073, -0.0032798205502331257, -0.05536564067006111, 0.03785981610417366, 0.05917894095182419, 0.060555387288331985, 0.05625942349433899, -0.015190638601779938, 0.035255663096904755, 0.045225877314805984, -0.048165611922740936, -0.0289751123636961, -0.0224769227206707, -0.06842128932476044, 0.010830849409103394, 0.04053322970867157, -0.012862334959208965, -0.016963018104434013, 0.010150841437280178, -0.02553517185151577, 0.0054641650058329105, -0.07437781244516373, 0.03408382087945938, 0.03283970057964325, -0.034222375601530075, -0.020440176129341125, -0.0017474694177508354, 0.002338525140658021, 0.00921124592423439, -0.041649747639894485, -0.01226277556270361, -0.027110764756798744, -0.04370002821087837, -0.004547298885881901, 0.027557985857129097, -0.04720925912261009, -0.04409923404455185, -0.00015536483260802925, -0.04264761880040169, 0.0023042093962430954, 0.01662440411746502, 0.00024247953842859715, 0.026164043694734573, -0.03644177317619324, -0.018203934654593468, -0.05469242483377457, 0.031083818525075912, 0.007154551800340414, 0.021275680512189865, -0.016531527042388916, 0.003155107842758298, 0.03886323422193527, -0.008503415621817112, 0.017916936427354813, -0.029648104682564735, -0.07725770771503448, 0.004748764913529158, 0.055976852774620056, -0.06302908062934875, 0.06418698281049728, -0.033954374492168427, -0.048183079808950424, 0.08620861172676086, 0.033993542194366455, 0.01197847444564104, -0.02389555610716343, 0.014583469368517399, -0.0233936607837677, 0.06629813462495804, -0.01051163300871849, 0.02344673126935959, 0.020613431930541992, -0.011849465779960155, 0.050964534282684326, 0.00037248857552185655, -0.07973577827215195, 0.024016041308641434, -0.009499473497271538, 0.04432820528745651, -0.023592406883835793, 0.029783444479107857, 0.02636515349149704, 0.023997392505407333, -0.015600110404193401, 0.01806895062327385, -0.023932846263051033, -0.060249414294958115, -0.06768958270549774, -0.016530996188521385, -0.04735911265015602, 0.03439003601670265, -0.07812448590993881, 0.0046391296200454235, 0.04012918472290039, -0.048450764268636703, -0.0009165368974208832, -0.0008055226062424481, 0.024952059611678123, -0.023077409714460373, -0.032524220645427704, 0.01998576894402504, 0.07400452345609665, -0.03351392596960068, 0.024455174803733826, 0.006917374674230814, 0.014956976287066936, -0.05851016938686371, -0.012295681051909924, -0.011863963678479195, -0.01482311636209488, 0.030083302408456802, 0.0032637366093695164, -0.045887645334005356, 0.051653727889060974, -0.012179994024336338, -0.053271472454071045, 0.019807804375886917, 0.02610865794122219, 0.008083590306341648, -0.00256648613139987, 0.03831588849425316, -0.016084201633930206, -0.010904657654464245, 0.03849997743964195, 0.04985329508781433, 0.005744060035794973, 0.01945393532514572, 0.09723484516143799, 0.011353733949363232, -0.026617104187607765, -0.06395265460014343, 0.06364481151103973, 0.011712444946169853, 0.042806971818208694, -0.00308764330111444, 0.02445375733077526, 0.00595873175188899, -0.016232803463935852, 0.00993487797677517, -0.008945689536631107, 0.035147298127412796, -0.014006122015416622, 0.005573335103690624, -0.0876084715127945, 0.0061691016890108585, 0.013538367114961147, 0.005412147380411625, 0.06210813671350479, 0.029619423672556877, 0.04029759019613266, 0.03602880984544754, -0.04438353329896927, 0.027239389717578888, 0.07119473814964294, -0.0016039521433413029, -0.03836362063884735, 0.039362914860248566, -0.017179911956191063, -0.09520208835601807, -0.0013995521003380418, 0.026643378660082817, -0.011870691552758217, 0.004239839036017656, 0.00018109014490619302, -0.030202003195881844, 0.03576122596859932, -0.05673860013484955, -0.01479305699467659, -0.07310362905263901, -0.0039693694561719894, -0.048062656074762344, 0.02193307690322399, -0.030728576704859734, 0.02946878969669342, -0.03537667542695999, -0.02044038660824299, -0.03491440415382385, 0.030012838542461395, -0.012864316813647747, 0.0005045803263783455, -0.00530776334926486, -0.08817095309495926, 0.07766521722078323, 0.022436128929257393, -0.02051280252635479, 0.011561816558241844, -0.05540904402732849, -0.03241851180791855, 0.03567274659872055, 0.05012373998761177, -0.01861724629998207, -0.0053734006360173225, 0.03416088595986366, 0.01458734180778265, 0.01662164367735386, -0.014342982321977615, -0.019842753186821938, 0.04038086533546448, 0.01208106242120266, 0.011235917918384075, 0.016570284962654114, -0.011206209659576416, 0.05800939351320267 ]
<p>Say I have a bipartite state</p> <p>$\rho = \sum_ip_i|\psi_{i}\rangle \langle \psi_{i}|_{AB}$</p> <p>Where $\{|\psi_{i}\rangle_{AB}\}$ forms an orthonormal basis.</p> <p>I now perform some local quantum operation on subsystem B, bringing my system to a new state:</p> <p>$\rho' = \sum_iq_i|\phi_{i}\rangle \langle \phi_{i}|_{AB}$</p> <p>Where, again, $\{|\phi_{i}\rangle_{AB}\}$ forms an orthonormal basis.</p> <p>Of course, for any entanglement measure $E$ we must have $E(\rho') \leq E(\rho)$. But is it possible to have:</p> <p>$\max\limits_i E(|\phi_{i}\rangle\langle \phi_{i}|_{AB}) &gt; \max\limits_i E(|\psi_{i}\rangle\langle \psi_{i}|_{AB})$ ?</p>
g5874
[ -0.0369226410984993, 0.019626781344413757, -0.0054236119613051414, -0.08109896630048752, 0.02753492258489132, -0.06781244277954102, -0.05219518393278122, 0.014724231325089931, 0.011351294815540314, 0.047926872968673706, -0.012538494542241096, -0.006230355706065893, -0.02298692986369133, -0.024149207398295403, -0.03763020783662796, 0.010244453325867653, 0.056095805019140244, 0.0033025923185050488, 0.00902350340038538, -0.007968921214342117, -0.07789888978004456, 0.02822408266365528, 0.02337385155260563, 0.0024024934973567724, 0.08210276812314987, -0.016370022669434547, 0.051723185926675797, -0.016158390790224075, -0.0806407630443573, -0.0028612304013222456, -0.03457684442400932, -0.06441700458526611, 0.025653554126620293, -0.043488308787345886, -0.021218879148364067, -0.013034338131546974, 0.0770568996667862, -0.05340658128261566, 0.0056836712174117565, -0.003998633474111557, -0.021437566727399826, -0.05363740026950836, 0.018134983256459236, -0.036282729357481, -0.01626880280673504, -0.008223272860050201, 0.04749741777777672, 0.04433197155594826, -0.016657955944538116, -0.009015703573822975, -0.035399336367845535, -0.002229674020782113, 0.02772331051528454, -0.01064388919621706, 0.023331137374043465, 0.07099322229623795, 0.0036472545471042395, -0.01905791461467743, -0.005980244372040033, 0.03017798624932766, -0.0036782030947506428, -0.046197935938835144, -0.012358651496469975, -0.002899759216234088, 0.007756772916764021, 0.026089895516633987, -0.0612960159778595, 0.026452917605638504, -0.05087900534272194, 0.0276991818100214, -0.02513410896062851, -0.03468722477555275, -0.004331720527261496, -0.03508185222744942, 0.010397104546427727, 0.024432828649878502, 0.0331326462328434, 0.026956645771861076, 0.06305138766765594, 0.12925364077091217, -0.057066239416599274, -0.05779241770505905, -0.0011946028098464012, -0.004222076386213303, 0.02244347333908081, -0.0005997305852361023, 0.045733410865068436, 0.010069272480905056, -0.02589242532849312, 0.07926914095878601, -0.037671059370040894, -0.008062481880187988, -0.0034078764729201794, 0.023761937394738197, -0.013735270127654076, -0.03542003780603409, -0.008889083750545979, 0.017893830314278603, 0.017869049683213234, -0.039983104914426804, -0.027477776631712914, -0.00527943903580308, 0.04587528854608536, -0.03807465359568596, -0.04367632791399956, -0.020400185137987137, 0.07713096588850021, -0.04613634943962097, 0.021800773218274117, -0.0017118783434852958, 0.0003035322588402778, -0.031102072447538376, -0.0384550504386425, -0.003300111973658204, -0.08572650700807571, 0.07755604386329651, -0.030986087396740913, 0.00011702202027663589, -0.06219770759344101, 0.053114816546440125, 0.03863322362303734, -0.006227630190551281, 0.05147803574800491, 0.04638410359621048, -0.03907786309719086, 0.09434710443019867, -0.01638142764568329, 0.047821346670389175, 0.022070353850722313, -0.04336735978722572, 0.03538667783141136, -0.020731305703520775, -0.008741172030568123, 0.0017014831537380815, -0.029329458251595497, -0.007651427295058966, 0.004709071479737759, 0.011151045560836792, 0.03172987326979637, -0.006086619105190039, -0.050510223954916, -0.03439668193459511, 0.008920280262827873, -0.010481685400009155, 0.024006158113479614, -0.013492404483258724, 0.061592403799295425, 0.003413326805457473, -0.013472634367644787, 0.0820799395442009, 0.013790961354970932, -0.023648884147405624, 0.03851114958524704, 0.0031275555957108736, 0.0037443137262016535, 0.03322211652994156, 0.02794742025434971, 0.03925703838467598, 0.016952866688370705, 0.016181882470846176, 0.03187626600265503, 0.0610075481235981, -0.014357052743434906, 0.020688656717538834, -0.031434763222932816, 0.026357252150774002, -0.0032842967193573713, 0.0002431226021144539, -0.015340144746005535, -0.0726068913936615, -0.04439091309905052, -0.01272397581487894, -0.03123018890619278, -0.015104038640856743, 0.028191395103931427, 0.04529714211821556, -0.04385475441813469, -0.032628532499074936, 0.05259530618786812, 0.041550446301698685, -0.012942131608724594, 0.017753995954990387, -0.014987979084253311, 0.04315733537077904, -0.02073136903345585, -0.008010146208107471, -0.0389399379491806, 0.026965031400322914, 0.01634066365659237, 0.004297591745853424, -0.04745456576347351, 0.06926973164081573, 0.04848508536815643, -0.029122784733772278, -0.05225299298763275, -0.007479470688849688, 0.0121357012540102, -0.05333864316344261, -0.013351397588849068, -0.06765743345022202, 0.011463500559329987, 0.03270919248461723, 0.03218797221779823, 0.004414075054228306, 0.01593509502708912, -0.057190824300050735, 0.005890467669814825, 0.017787085846066475, 0.02626163139939308, -0.00854874774813652, 0.034083228558301926, -0.06438997387886047, -0.04206385836005211, 0.03588082641363144, 0.05636946111917496, 0.006304928567260504, 0.05836467072367668, -0.0035415750462561846, 0.012227362021803856, -0.0018827995518222451, -0.05263691022992134, -0.00325852376408875, 0.035495270043611526, 0.016270030289888382, -0.003139554290100932, -0.016189513728022575, -0.008876532316207886, 0.016656726598739624, -0.00975111871957779, 0.04193372279405594, -0.06944175809621811, -0.018744010478258133, 0.06837746500968933, -0.06399228423833847, -0.011110042221844196, 0.03511721268296242, 0.00891549326479435, 0.009108965285122395, -0.04599001258611679, -0.02479810267686844, 0.048274893313646317, 0.008211642503738403, -0.016444003209471703, 0.032009515911340714, -0.026621138677001, -0.012073946185410023, -0.05776960775256157, -0.008890512399375439, -0.019968505948781967, 0.0760120078921318, 0.005551008973270655, -0.028103096410632133, -0.009376000612974167, 0.03800505772233009, -0.04701158404350281, 0.009453883394598961, 0.057365886867046356, 0.026641875505447388, 0.0035358003806322813, -0.01905144564807415, -0.03424811363220215, 0.07176302373409271, -0.0125955268740654, 0.011147545650601387, -0.009282533079385757, 0.04364971071481705, -0.02122504822909832, -0.032140057533979416, -0.00891174003481865, 0.04541284218430519, -0.022104304283857346, 0.10679351538419724, 0.023362567648291588, 0.05939377471804619, 0.022603923454880714, -0.0598282627761364, -0.029635632410645485, -0.005518930032849312, -0.024741388857364655, 0.012608899734914303, -0.07906365394592285, -0.026601867750287056, -0.00544695183634758, 0.019380297511816025, -0.023369500413537025, -0.0635598748922348, -0.012949060648679733, -0.012041561305522919, 0.023680895566940308, 0.055800676345825195, -0.05437015742063522, 0.06666705012321472, 0.023808050900697708, 0.021848419681191444, -0.04653050750494003, 0.006919398903846741, 0.019884994253516197, -0.05880725383758545, 0.0030431407503783703, 0.10230115801095963, -0.016716482117772102, -0.05104430764913559, -0.027587376534938812, 0.02744079753756523, 0.03021256998181343, 0.004887847695499659, -0.04296319931745529, 0.018181519582867622, -0.0080927275121212, 0.01894485391676426, 0.020209359005093575, -0.03615286201238632, 0.007397063076496124, -0.04202386364340782, -0.0006819923873990774, 0.004876637831330299, -0.026652129366993904, -0.03926007077097893, -0.0026309683453291655, -0.021207524463534355, 0.013666344806551933, -0.043790023773908615, 0.0001400406617904082, 0.023177528753876686, 0.06559557467699051, -0.009091987274587154, -0.0565200075507164, 0.05368543043732643, -0.042284898459911346, -0.02974013425409794, -0.007615010254085064, -0.029074309393763542, 0.09328252822160721, 0.020773550495505333, -0.041125666350126266, -0.018816133961081505, -0.007410306483507156, -0.03453565016388893, 0.024782558903098106, 0.0040827058255672455, -0.01300409622490406, -0.006820314563810825, 0.011170817539095879, 0.003033917397260666, -0.020874036476016045, 0.011565441265702248, -0.05513088032603264, 0.023271428421139717, -0.0016069451812654734, 0.03366836905479431, 0.00895272009074688, 0.012657114304602146, 0.019639721140265465, -0.022235991433262825, 0.04329953342676163, 0.013125407509505749, 0.07355770468711853, 0.05425168573856354, -0.03718294948339462, -0.025531986728310585, 0.024503115564584732, -0.0028110698331147432, -0.03084176778793335, -0.03654750809073448, -0.0020284242928028107, -0.01917312853038311, -0.0060736569575965405, 0.0241902694106102, -0.005212095566093922, 0.027390383183956146, -0.014258039183914661, -0.02567269280552864, 0.03628680482506752, 0.061545390635728836, -0.011663936078548431, -0.0597614161670208, 0.042913056910037994, -0.021864907816052437, 0.015915025025606155, 0.00492314575240016, 0.005005797371268272, -0.04065018147230148, 0.02375175803899765, -0.039709124714136124, -0.014704053290188313, -0.0005298087489791214, -0.0053580086678266525, -0.03880542144179344, 0.0011578076519072056, -0.0020092667546123266, -0.06478053331375122, -0.10365835577249527, 0.01358705386519432, 0.008267024531960487, 0.029887216165661812, -0.0047872005961835384, 0.012653659097850323, -0.019121522083878517, -0.049788814038038254, 0.048443447798490524, -0.03897055238485336, -0.0565154142677784, -0.043873131275177, 0.0034727484453469515, -0.046527620404958725, -0.04619121924042702, 0.022294707596302032, 0.037762369960546494, -0.00042445064173080027, -0.04567332565784454, 0.011598985642194748, -0.020391596481204033, 0.020256662741303444, 0.03691115975379944, 0.015643909573554993, -0.01786557212471962, 0.021822236478328705, 0.013850478455424309, -0.04130507633090019, -0.029946979135274887, -0.005298806354403496, 0.020636526867747307, 0.0547921285033226, 0.04942075535655022, 0.05588642880320549, 0.03700340539216995, -0.02446412667632103, -0.005814626347273588, 0.024469127878546715, -0.009864786639809608, -0.007611053995788097, -0.024145931005477905, -0.02038254402577877, 0.03788451477885246, -0.027268970385193825, 0.0053399004973471165, -0.04383854195475578, 0.01784491539001465, 0.03154367208480835, -0.0476539321243763, 0.00959667470306158, 0.002846261253580451, -0.01712680235505104, 0.03945312649011612, 0.0007125818519853055, 0.006357699632644653, 0.037524111568927765, -0.038871996104717255, 0.0027600752655416727, -0.005080976523458958, -0.011442420072853565, -0.004521468188613653, 0.012644336558878422, -0.046226538717746735, -0.0017122771823778749, 0.008808229118585587, -0.04476362094283104, 0.05387523025274277, 0.024985313415527344, 0.0011481876717880368, -0.003130042925477028, -0.033697109669446945, -0.0476003997027874, 0.019307320937514305, 0.002629847964271903, 0.05251280590891838, -0.06330813467502594, 0.07178525626659393, -0.08035337179899216, -0.052346885204315186, 0.03680221363902092, -0.0040373243391513824, 0.030879149213433266, -0.00820921454578638, -0.04055370017886162, 0.024184120818972588, -0.03437819704413414, -0.01132834143936634, -0.02590934745967388, 0.011510739102959633, -0.03679792210459709, -0.06369597464799881, -0.0248795785009861, 0.053594913333654404, 0.04293873906135559, 0.027409981936216354, -0.009514865465462208, -0.041721172630786896, -0.018934058025479317, -0.02672509290277958, -0.02013249695301056, 0.07480810582637787, 0.01331863459199667, 0.03217708691954613, 0.01175640244036913, 0.012532118707895279, 0.015922509133815765, -0.008911006152629852, -0.01062037330120802, 0.07824323326349258, -0.014508246444165707, 0.05549473688006401, 0.023419655859470367, 0.02155923657119274, -0.010687289759516716, 0.00026475475169718266, 0.044113706797361374, 0.01241279486566782, -0.014557518064975739, 0.018987692892551422, -0.05088132619857788, 0.029660338535904884, -0.005101809743791819, -0.010430039837956429, 0.013228664174675941, -0.06969185918569565, 0.010655220597982407, 0.02068730816245079, -0.055050939321517944, -0.0498015321791172, 0.027712924405932426, -0.07397740334272385, 0.018815934658050537, -0.04985200613737106, -0.05345839262008667, 0.040853988379240036, -0.03575439378619194, -0.056484900414943695, 0.021085789427161217, 0.028952233493328094, 0.07078414410352707, 0.010639237239956856, -0.0016924183582887053, -0.02952445112168789, 0.0033659294713288546, -0.016874507069587708, -0.061977677047252655, -0.04568253085017204, -0.02702728658914566, 0.002235814230516553, 0.042680829763412476, -0.07413694262504578, -0.003418358974158764, 0.09384136646986008, 0.04104231297969818, 0.02010270394384861, -0.05454321950674057, -0.04198799282312393, -0.025066489353775978, 0.05036918818950653, 0.0035373379942029715, 0.018917547538876534, -0.0637551099061966, -0.03176405280828476, 0.02410425804555416, 0.033336490392684937, 0.017432816326618195, 0.009491421282291412, -0.03132863715291023, 0.03766189515590668, 0.05178651586174965, -0.027135031297802925, 0.0822538211941719, 0.01594475284218788, -0.00788723211735487, -0.019154462963342667, -0.0038135165814310312, 0.011995445936918259, 0.03848743811249733, 0.036782946437597275, 0.04319087788462639, -0.012761985883116722, 0.02355075068771839, -0.021841270849108696, 0.04173142835497856, 0.02716110646724701, -0.007395785767585039, -0.042890485376119614, 0.07495494931936264, -0.03765438124537468, -0.09382101148366928, 0.001583697972819209, 0.0006468614446930587, -0.004269726574420929, 0.004347979556769133, 0.04435126110911369, -0.015109640546143055, 0.022373327985405922, 0.011694157496094704, -0.007098916918039322, -0.04424203187227249, 0.014128027483820915, -0.009342256933450699, -0.012270689941942692, -0.0151801947504282, -0.013422118499875069, 0.006110785529017448, -0.024459803476929665, -0.0010839613387361169, -0.022564824670553207, 0.025889169424772263, -0.010596031323075294, 0.025556489825248718, -0.022770270705223083, -0.039118412882089615, 0.10404162853956223, -0.040764499455690384, 0.005084458738565445, -0.02035326324403286, -0.013485818170011044, 0.00921728927642107, -0.07398886978626251, 0.02166239358484745, 0.02968597784638405, -0.0049376292154192924, -0.06327126175165176, 0.010769172571599483, 0.0009762200061231852, 0.012889714911580086, 0.004145456477999687, 0.06731395423412323, -0.02298525907099247, -0.011609707958996296, -0.04362025111913681, -0.02457421086728573, 0.06391094624996185, 0.000030571947718271986, -0.010111595503985882, 0.02397853136062622, 0.03366199880838394, 0.08154386281967163, -0.01532227173447609, -0.06740586459636688, 0.018082426860928535, -0.03953274339437485, 0.028305189684033394, -0.02203012816607952, -0.004771905485540628, 0.02401946857571602, 0.037186842411756516, 0.007894085720181465, 0.07690667361021042, 0.00784272700548172, 0.0032608883921056986, 0.004468922968953848, 0.0072934189811348915, 0.07785804569721222, 0.04428766667842865, -0.054738618433475494, -0.013717450201511383, 0.03583983704447746, 0.005843448452651501, -0.044096119701862335, -0.00328689138405025, -0.013319270685315132, -0.0729459822177887, 0.021504148840904236, -0.04903843253850937, 0.017480745911598206, -0.06077627092599869, 0.012398614548146725, 0.0020668834913522005, 0.025125864893198013, -0.016777249053120613, 0.02411196008324623, 0.04995041340589523, -0.004005299881100655, -0.037154316902160645, -0.01225860882550478, -0.08419995754957199, 0.011227624490857124, -0.046973783522844315, -0.0274713933467865, -0.03608880937099457, 0.00435254443436861, 0.007885756902396679, 0.020842963829636574, 0.044408027082681656, -0.010268309153616428, 0.01575344055891037, 0.03464947268366814, 0.021288497373461723, -0.01122627966105938, 0.003414188977330923, -0.02908838540315628, -0.003525438020005822, 0.05009564012289047, 0.05764589086174965, 0.035346511751413345, -0.015322075225412846, -0.00011515639198478311, 0.0075757065787911415, 0.0012811205815523863, 0.044185854494571686, -0.01623198576271534, 0.035412922501564026, 0.009608373045921326, 0.031143881380558014, 0.02163710817694664, -0.040944285690784454, 0.027119845151901245, 0.015799613669514656, -0.023537268862128258, -0.002228671917691827, 0.04825311526656151, -0.06373468041419983, 0.0010474795708432794, -0.02430209144949913, 0.029247336089611053, 0.030234944075345993, -0.021088724955916405, 0.001415422884747386, -0.05610591918230057, 0.009259254671633244, -0.002032029442489147, -0.01745479740202427, -0.06026051566004753, -0.019902393221855164, 0.023955659940838814, -0.016434093937277794, 0.01989857107400894, 0.02587517909705639, -0.02944359742105007, 0.004161916207522154, -0.07244352996349335, -0.02688802406191826, 0.012002195231616497, 0.02888825535774231, -0.023468313738703728, -0.005750669166445732, -0.00040516944136470556, -0.0939803197979927, -0.07208279520273209, -0.03242224454879761, 0.002377993194386363, 0.012094414792954922, -0.04801402986049652, 0.018717085942626, 0.03327082470059395, -0.018279263749718666, -0.017148781567811966, -0.03239540755748749, -0.005350613500922918, 0.06117831915616989, 0.04740132391452789, -0.01978689804673195, -0.014344848692417145, 0.017507050186395645, 0.04978235810995102, 0.05942617729306221, -0.06684548407793045, 0.022332454100251198, 0.01544230803847313, 0.04613826051354408, 0.029650036245584488, 0.024402758106589317, 0.04953405261039734, 0.03202574700117111, 0.08351773768663406, -0.0009593966533429921, -0.015730585902929306, 0.01308471616357565, 0.01369284838438034, -0.04452401399612427, 0.04277157783508301, -0.003819685894995928, 0.04408586025238037, 0.014922930859029293 ]
<p>Recently, there was a rapid communication published in Phys.Rev.D (<a href="http://prd.aps.org/abstract/PRD/v83/i2/e021502">PRD 83, 021502</a>), titled <em>"Gravity is not an entropic force"</em>, that claimed that <a href="http://prd.aps.org/abstract/PRD/v67/i10/e102002">an experiment performed in 2002 with ultra cold neutrons in a gravitational field</a>, disprove Verlinde's entropic approach to Gravity.</p> <p>The neutrons experiment gave results consistent with the predictions of Newtonian gravity for the lowest energy state. </p> <p>As I understand it, the author claims that the fact that Verlinde's entropic force comes from a thermodynamic process that is irreversible (or approximately reversible), leads to non-unitarity in the evolution of quantum systems. The non-unitarity then exponentially suppresses the eigenfunctions, predicting results very much different than the Newtonian. Thus, that experiment is in contradictions to what is expected if Verlinde's approach is correct.</p> <p>My questions are, </p> <ol> <li>First of all, is there anything else essential that I am missing?</li> <li>Is there any response to that argument? </li> <li>Is that a fatal problem with Verlinde's entropic approach? </li> <li>Is that a fatal problem for any entropic approach?</li> </ol> <p>updates on the discussion: </p> <ol> <li>There is also this recent comment <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1104.4650">arxiv.org/abs/1104.4650</a></li> <li>Once more: gravity is not an entropic force <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1108.4161">arxiv.org/abs/1108.4161</a></li> </ol>
g708
[ 0.04250980168581009, 0.03517922759056091, 0.008007658645510674, -0.0341782383620739, 0.05987219139933586, 0.02187301404774189, 0.011809575371444225, 0.02443697676062584, -0.016822991892695427, -0.004485466051846743, 0.05845832824707031, -0.007440795190632343, -0.0022820718586444855, -0.0030606857035309076, -0.04170156270265579, 0.022189928218722343, 0.10366527736186981, -0.01429695263504982, 0.027409322559833527, -0.007273003458976746, -0.02444775588810444, 0.01168410200625658, -0.0408206582069397, -0.045228686183691025, 0.06435035914182663, -0.03368188440799713, 0.05384599417448044, -0.010740986093878746, -0.08319836854934692, 0.017435502260923386, 0.048845887184143066, -0.04609326273202896, 0.034068088978528976, -0.06255131959915161, -0.04950851947069168, 0.012144681997597218, 0.03490240126848221, 0.013331111520528793, 0.030038492754101753, -0.03912132978439331, -0.005175580736249685, 0.013198211789131165, -0.026897383853793144, -0.0013527912087738514, 0.020292330533266068, 0.008211889304220676, -0.018973153084516525, -0.014483096078038216, -0.015030428767204285, -0.030291711911559105, 0.05022680386900902, 0.01713375560939312, 0.013927407562732697, 0.00036820617970079184, -0.028161747381091118, -0.0004939836217090487, 0.017087265849113464, 0.054521240293979645, -0.015994416549801826, 0.014377344399690628, 0.04821178689599037, -0.038801152259111404, 0.05551386997103691, -0.02738068997859955, 0.032701026648283005, -0.06619533151388168, -0.05069059878587723, -0.0645921528339386, 0.058186087757349014, 0.0006419229903258383, 0.009759241715073586, -0.00852638017386198, -0.05094278231263161, 0.02969224750995636, 0.03325141221284866, 0.046094320714473724, 0.016219930723309517, -0.020020723342895508, -0.009396716021001339, -0.006656726356595755, -0.033868610858917236, -0.02738146483898163, 0.01633266918361187, -0.017809126526117325, 0.04786223918199539, -0.03227779641747475, -0.014934501610696316, -0.00872995425015688, 0.05253257229924202, 0.060647152364254, 0.010284673422574997, -0.02224111184477806, 0.0674888864159584, 0.027928762137889862, -0.032365284860134125, 0.008304640650749207, 0.0064126900397241116, 0.05040954053401947, 0.027622412890195847, 0.009279454126954079, 0.024402186274528503, -0.016312703490257263, 0.01515223365277052, -0.016911737620830536, -0.028398461639881134, -0.014759037643671036, -0.0216639656573534, 0.013100674375891685, -0.019256815314292908, 0.015510967932641506, -0.07480107992887497, 0.02127249725162983, -0.012260877527296543, -0.0406438410282135, -0.04055057466030121, 0.004159439355134964, 0.03490583598613739, -0.04871749505400658, -0.02356100268661976, 0.06691117584705353, -0.001832700101658702, 0.07897955179214478, 0.045225054025650024, 0.04359622672200203, -0.054529618471860886, -0.023664873093366623, -0.005468335468322039, -0.012088052928447723, 0.0013948834966868162, -0.0519636869430542, -0.011788374744355679, 0.023368600755929947, -0.032661277800798416, 0.035270001739263535, 0.004358496982604265, -0.002279972191900015, 0.024005919694900513, 0.002870679832994938, 0.010973650962114334, -0.00022681195696350187, -0.04846304655075073, -0.014273653738200665, -0.021554969251155853, -0.03571450710296631, -0.007094267290085554, -0.020713774487376213, -0.026689020916819572, 0.04488867148756981, -0.015501633286476135, -0.018396079540252686, 0.003256050404161215, 0.014767211861908436, 0.03302969038486481, -0.10971112549304962, -0.02494548261165619, -0.030835742130875587, 0.028623713180422783, 0.013420329429209232, -0.033211641013622284, -0.004052087664604187, 0.03492473065853119, 0.02368973009288311, 0.06350745260715485, -0.006079037673771381, -0.009734035469591618, 0.05789680778980255, -0.02463492564857006, -0.04516300559043884, 0.03048771806061268, -0.032632976770401, -0.15061692893505096, -0.003427690826356411, -0.02062465064227581, 0.08270460367202759, -0.025735709816217422, -0.016746515408158302, -0.002081036102026701, -0.031121470034122467, -0.05194789171218872, -0.029939666390419006, -0.028035305440425873, 0.027868594974279404, 0.07170162349939346, 0.03518373519182205, -0.021863268688321114, -0.0014839350478723645, 0.015332482755184174, 0.09069256484508514, -0.03712434321641922, 0.015601790510118008, -0.00758147519081831, 0.02821316197514534, -0.0029113921336829662, -0.010566488839685917, -0.002589142881333828, 0.040323734283447266, -0.0068975347094237804, -0.03790227696299553, -0.03294410556554794, 0.02699417620897293, -0.006753520108759403, 0.01856955699622631, -0.011202649213373661, -0.011651779524981976, -0.02129942551255226, -0.013150431215763092, -0.04334966838359833, 0.04956412687897682, 0.07366736978292465, 0.03674839809536934, 0.019528809934854507, -0.043890878558158875, 0.006502779666334391, 0.03934744745492935, -0.02137788198888302, -0.00906522199511528, 0.0021218270994722843, 0.0024271695874631405, -0.05771704390645027, 0.021152883768081665, -0.0021041783038526773, 0.024629084393382072, -0.027453208342194557, 0.03779767453670502, -0.01243009977042675, 0.016046447679400444, -0.0925111472606659, -0.031073901802301407, -0.019233116880059242, -0.0004349439113866538, -0.028514884412288666, 0.027404282242059708, 0.005309360567480326, -0.013137447647750378, 0.04706709086894989, 0.05684937909245491, 0.045218970626592636, -0.014039704576134682, 0.03152826428413391, 0.010771512985229492, 0.047924887388944626, -0.00733179971575737, -0.04085233435034752, 0.019587121903896332, 0.07160714268684387, -0.006753146182745695, 0.010023023001849651, -0.03309028968214989, -0.007443257141858339, -0.05234065279364586, 0.0049190279096364975, -0.014683212153613567, -0.038188617676496506, 0.034026701003313065, 0.0037727439776062965, 0.05156572535634041, -0.01924239657819271, 0.01044978853315115, -0.017666969448328018, -0.01855400577187538, -0.00781947746872902, -0.020681088790297508, 0.020878901705145836, 0.028307832777500153, -0.013751083984971046, 0.0018122104229405522, -0.06327357888221741, -0.026925815269351006, 0.021924810484051704, -0.006966305896639824, -0.016321498900651932, 0.005231999792158604, -0.04626475274562836, 0.06709691137075424, 0.006103266030550003, -0.006200606469064951, -0.01905311457812786, 0.07334894686937332, 0.00033534495742060244, -0.031164029613137245, -0.00922380294650793, 0.013538352213799953, -0.01720547117292881, 0.00822157971560955, 0.08769494295120239, 0.0013821139000356197, -0.043436091393232346, -0.006225509103387594, -0.012877855449914932, -0.014334981329739094, -0.0058114174753427505, -0.009222510270774364, 0.020892620086669922, -0.008488133549690247, -0.036155134439468384, 0.007773892488330603, 0.01761382631957531, -0.03176936134696007, -0.03298363462090492, -0.013831515796482563, -0.05600671097636223, 0.026588302105665207, 0.03265335038304329, 0.017601191997528076, -0.01686353236436844, -0.017799055203795433, -0.06608067452907562, -0.09259511530399323, -0.01468781940639019, -0.017055977135896683, -0.06359351426362991, 0.06490249186754227, -0.022687003016471863, -0.009677632711827755, -0.05695246905088425, 0.013287481851875782, 0.022023838013410568, 0.03437194228172302, 0.05280623212456703, -0.04780106619000435, -0.0016458345344290137, 0.013314827345311642, 0.016429536044597626, 0.009223041124641895, 0.07239240407943726, 0.03588032349944115, -0.05522671341896057, 0.020718475803732872, -0.003958211746066809, 0.006989574525505304, 0.04152708128094673, 0.01837889291346073, 0.02863437496125698, 0.007325722370296717, -0.07162058353424072, -0.040525976568460464, -0.021888768300414085, 0.003882154356688261, 0.01402310561388731, 0.0304751917719841, 0.004293660167604685, -0.031857680529356, -0.014245809055864811, 0.0342814065515995, -0.006285449024289846, 0.03947664052248001, -0.03431235998868942, -0.023134008049964905, 0.012066083960235119, 0.02956179901957512, -0.012936096638441086, -0.025997987017035484, 0.07054087519645691, -0.005992475431412458, 0.03090547025203705, -0.04174262285232544, 0.05856812745332718, -0.005603984463959932, 0.0013825383502990007, 0.005737165920436382, -0.029888974502682686, -0.04022100195288658, 0.06695008277893066, 0.06600676476955414, -0.023381177335977554, 0.052820149809122086, -0.03220464289188385, 0.002674395451322198, -0.007283489219844341, -0.007674905005842447, -0.025161171332001686, -0.05839657783508301, 0.020088031888008118, -0.024367190897464752, 0.031915679574012756, -0.06274507939815521, 0.07618176937103271, -0.04849044606089592, -0.025408389046788216, 0.01881001889705658, 0.04568557068705559, 0.00038722623139619827, 0.059426672756671906, -0.03741394355893135, 0.09095315635204315, 0.016442464664578438, -0.07181054353713989, -0.0455571673810482, 0.047943320125341415, -0.013690514490008354, 0.02432272769510746, -0.0009438431588932872, -0.032671838998794556, 0.03576911613345146, 0.0023309963289648294, 0.050698697566986084, 0.005756946746259928, 0.010062876157462597, 0.026786746457219124, -0.026099689304828644, -0.029950205236673355, -0.05643608421087265, -0.03167784959077835, 0.04831457510590553, -0.007660201750695705, 0.027328813448548317, 0.017879171296954155, -0.030484208837151527, -0.03465430438518524, -0.03301366791129112, 0.08331980556249619, -0.018567506223917007, 0.01711312122642994, -0.0693785697221756, -0.04207345098257065, -0.09269842505455017, 0.008455093018710613, 0.020320627838373184, -0.019777385517954826, 0.030215635895729065, 0.018192870542407036, 0.081997811794281, -0.02915121801197529, -0.014303622767329216, 0.004803644958883524, 0.035012997686862946, 0.01577170379459858, 0.014979475177824497, -0.057074982672929764, -0.009076886810362339, 0.03566640987992287, 0.01376461423933506, 0.033987924456596375, 0.0013673115754500031, -0.01110580563545227, 0.020612087100744247, 0.020563121885061264, 0.005503852851688862, 0.027942461892962456, 0.02215881273150444, 0.0832335576415062, 0.022296208888292313, -0.014157368801534176, 0.04207874462008476, 0.015155038796365261, 0.061610594391822815, 0.038581714034080505, -0.014202401973307133, -0.020566768944263458, -0.008457078598439693, 0.02121005207300186, -0.017733408138155937, -0.016119331121444702, -0.02663455158472061, -0.061810288578271866, -0.01882782392203808, -0.010586125776171684, 0.11039949208498001, -0.02024194598197937, -0.01017244253307581, -0.038648705929517746, -0.041580069810152054, 0.0381622277200222, 0.04854508489370346, -0.022033385932445526, -0.003821589285507798, -0.07177704572677612, 0.017446139827370644, -0.030109083279967308, -0.05068331956863403, 0.01958867907524109, 0.01567639410495758, 0.06007876247167587, 0.044804733246564865, 0.0056628454476594925, 0.006744934245944023, 0.05092743784189224, 0.03981645405292511, 0.04952182248234749, -0.02121010795235634, -0.006266176700592041, -0.05919290706515312, -0.02098328061401844, 0.04293592646718025, 0.03872789070010185, -0.01358787715435028, -0.021801209077239037, 0.003818450728431344, -0.025640886276960373, -0.0010710681090131402, -0.02265070378780365, -0.016296297311782837, 0.036917295306921005, 0.02035333588719368, -0.012021207250654697, 0.014490624889731407, -0.045077625662088394, 0.016194025054574013, 0.00722630275413394, 0.023351535201072693, -0.0810043066740036, 0.009769931435585022, -0.038295645266771317, -0.03386963531374931, -0.020209161564707756, -0.028809959068894386, 0.056747615337371826, 0.002739957068115473, -0.03933066502213478, 0.02132224291563034, -0.038033436983823776, 0.012557430192828178, 0.019982565194368362, 0.027731020003557205, -0.0024166421499103308, 0.012558123096823692, -0.030255448073148727, -0.015609425492584705, -0.011180424131453037, -0.06255760788917542, 0.02528691478073597, 0.022797493264079094, 0.026622792705893517, -0.018137013539671898, 0.014000642113387585, -0.010890177451074123, -0.00038859350024722517, -0.025615867227315903, -0.04844221845269203, 0.05996876209974289, 0.03673671558499336, 0.013376042246818542, 0.051520656794309616, -0.006061422172933817, 0.0006318933446891606, -0.02742859534919262, 0.0225567277520895, 0.000722000899259001, -0.014062018133699894, -0.05420537292957306, 0.012808592990040779, 0.004690847359597683, -0.04423731938004494, -0.00009189044067170471, -0.03719021752476692, 0.048661209642887115, -0.04289468750357628, 0.02163781225681305, 0.036486733704805374, -0.04476194828748703, -0.012437247671186924, 0.02632654830813408, 0.01014737132936716, 0.029231585562229156, 0.028658028692007065, -0.03738228231668472, 0.010342255234718323, -0.042045626789331436, -0.00027421762933954597, 0.005811559036374092, 0.019963057711720467, -0.00828300416469574, 0.01836206763982773, 0.008571762591600418, 0.04272116348147392, -0.039414115250110626, 0.005997020751237869, -0.02854853868484497, -0.06735112518072128, 0.09367626905441284, 0.0423804447054863, 0.07097302377223969, -0.0009104436030611396, 0.030071958899497986, 0.011190725490450859, -0.04699154943227768, -0.01539098285138607, -0.037292927503585815, -0.013434669002890587, -0.08409101516008377, -0.055157046765089035, -0.04457812011241913, 0.01907087117433548, -0.04939485341310501, -0.028003700077533722, -0.011669074185192585, -0.018835777416825294, 0.06412788480520248, 0.0032462349627166986, -0.050220660865306854, 0.0008667698130011559, -0.024679793044924736, -0.07671433687210083, 0.04429160803556442, -0.05577339231967926, -0.01703004725277424, 0.01678864285349846, 0.01979638636112213, -0.027136653661727905, 0.03382210060954094, 0.016727332025766373, 0.04398869350552559, 0.03177255019545555, 0.0037794269155710936, -0.0194036103785038, 0.04535839334130287, -0.03298824653029442, 0.007621990516781807, 0.021511230617761612, 0.006588529795408249, -0.03992098197340965, 0.02729509398341179, 0.0381539911031723, -0.046801164746284485, 0.0001124236368923448, -0.05862440913915634, 0.017799369990825653, 0.03509575501084328, -0.01667478121817112, 0.027546709403395653, -0.041319455951452255, 0.0032704700715839863, 0.06723687052726746, -0.033174779266119, 0.06262179464101791, 0.03197697922587395, -0.030479229986667633, -0.005788815673440695, 0.05883025377988815, -0.001202717307023704, -0.010936139151453972, 0.008470219559967518, 0.03836853802204132, 0.037035271525382996, -0.018595101311802864, 0.005722437519580126, -0.02804812230169773, 0.025901347398757935, 0.0966014489531517, -0.021116845309734344, -0.035258371382951736, 0.01628120243549347, 0.0014820428332313895, -0.0009583188220858574, -0.06392741203308105, 0.08210661262273788, -0.003964040894061327, -0.006737736985087395, -0.04540881887078285, 0.029179275035858154, 0.05237352102994919, -0.02802424691617489, -0.008368133567273617, 0.01569369249045849, -0.034843169152736664, 0.10639768838882446, -0.00682545593008399, 0.018605133518576622, 0.026584230363368988, -0.056584682315588, -0.02185649611055851, -0.0346171036362648, 0.01921295002102852, 0.031125588342547417, -0.06678750365972519, 0.004063168074935675, -0.002952937502413988, -0.0076947519555687904, 0.04702165350317955, -0.028242474421858788, 0.051458731293678284, -0.07363911718130112, -0.0009001406142488122, -0.014224344864487648, -0.06504758447408676, 0.000696483242791146, -0.036115244030952454, 0.023770172148942947, 0.054546356201171875, 0.03991100192070007, -0.02260037697851658, 0.000410042965086177, 0.03498072177171707, 0.017202554270625114, -0.0875328779220581, 0.037408750504255295, -0.05752165615558624, 0.03528575971722603, -0.04938419908285141, 0.06182200834155083, -0.018810326233506203, 0.06035175174474716, -0.0097881518304348, 0.03342650458216667, -0.0370178185403347, -0.03759628161787987, -0.07681045681238174, 0.08076389878988266, 0.009349023923277855, -0.025702808052301407, -0.01793096959590912, 0.04526025056838989, -0.041506797075271606, -0.010671374388039112, 0.003939971327781677, 0.007452025078237057, -0.0587107390165329, 0.022070080041885376, -0.022682638838887215, -0.01612175814807415, 0.05457691475749016, -0.027113810181617737, -0.0026976149529218674, -0.032677434384822845, 0.029009832069277763, -0.00021147691586520523, -0.054633695632219315, -0.019455252215266228, 0.039258234202861786, -0.022707153111696243, -0.03210049867630005, 0.0024017079267650843, -0.06492125242948532, -0.008176310919225216, -0.03164643421769142, -0.026029663160443306, 0.004461956210434437, 0.04180479794740677, 0.014305789954960346, -0.01447144616395235, -0.020073793828487396, -0.020240258425474167, 0.01691788248717785, -0.007725316099822521, -0.018172679468989372, 0.03838452324271202, -0.028927983716130257, -0.019168728962540627, 0.010871915146708488, 0.011818795464932919, -0.020786479115486145, 0.009935782290995121, 0.02916809916496277, -0.043414343148469925, 0.031480174511671066, -0.04037497937679291, -0.06759198009967804, -0.038933999836444855, -0.012875660322606564, 0.02015337534248829, -0.005738431587815285, 0.025569288060069084, -0.03223773092031479, 0.06744622439146042, 0.05967135727405548, -0.044426266103982925, 0.022248582914471626, 0.006308289244771004, 0.018648218363523483, -0.0360679104924202, -0.03544905036687851, 0.020215654745697975, 0.008870548568665981, -0.015061655081808567, -0.022236138582229614, 0.007060932461172342, 0.025462470948696136, 0.04799417406320572 ]
<p>So I am trying to reproduce results in <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1007.1031" rel="nofollow">this</a> article, precisely the 3rd chapter 'Virasoro algebra for AdS$_3$'. I have the metric in this form:</p> <p>$$ds^2=-\left(1+\frac{r^2}{l^2}\right)dt^2+\left(1+\frac{r^2}{l^2}\right)^{-1}dr^2+r^2d\phi^2$$</p> <p>And I have the boundary conditions. So if I'm correct, I should find the most general diffeomorphism, by solving $\mathcal{L}_\xi g_{\mu\nu}=\mathcal{O}(h_{\mu\nu})$, where $h_{\mu\nu}$ are the boundary conditions (subleading terms).</p> <p>So, if I'm doing things right, I get 5 equations. Because the $t\phi$ term of Lie derivative vanishes. Now, I should use the power expansion of $\xi$, as given in the paper, and solve these 5 differential equations or? </p> <p>I'm not certain if I'm on a right path, so any advice is welcome...</p>
g5875
[ 0.043125685304403305, 0.01744748465716839, -0.018595712259411812, 0.023937536403536797, 0.004670099355280399, 0.008814720436930656, 0.057369086891412735, -0.01663212664425373, -0.020819300785660744, 0.024282032623887062, 0.030996032059192657, 0.03345493972301483, 0.018864603713154793, -0.009604651480913162, -0.021308187395334244, 0.025394903495907784, 0.033274535089731216, -0.08840831369161606, -0.019073566421866417, -0.022723523899912834, -0.018758513033390045, 0.004032419063150883, -0.006518104579299688, -0.011987511068582535, 0.08416862040758133, -0.02062150277197361, 0.03340119868516922, -0.029776250943541527, -0.07659268379211426, -0.003749793628230691, 0.04104997217655182, 0.04238278791308403, 0.05095025151968002, -0.01088018249720335, -0.033741407096385956, 0.007378888316452503, 0.05571566894650459, 0.03223717212677002, 0.060783494263887405, -0.0051133353263139725, 0.02006598189473152, -0.04278802499175072, 0.043280795216560364, 0.06949706375598907, -0.005279000848531723, -0.05330326408147812, -0.05056409910321236, 0.014831210486590862, 0.03038247860968113, -0.03654240071773529, -0.005216940306127071, 0.07956745475530624, -0.03395281359553337, -0.033906515687704086, -0.079543337225914, 0.06341713666915894, 0.020897341892123222, -0.019437864422798157, 0.013054544106125832, 0.01599077694118023, -0.04726685956120491, 0.005223683547228575, -0.01201433502137661, 0.032022785395383835, 0.06315387040376663, -0.025592008605599403, -0.025519223883748055, -0.06329506635665894, -0.034222546964883804, -0.042219243943691254, 0.043102167546749115, 0.00979792233556509, 0.0854320079088211, -0.03692209720611572, -0.014774652197957039, 0.010189811699092388, 0.02174389734864235, -0.007619955111294985, -0.013026656582951546, -0.027881518006324768, -0.017848074436187744, -0.01476799976080656, 0.06824615597724915, 0.017300067469477654, -0.02119474858045578, 0.02859174832701683, -0.0007336796843446791, -0.026469547301530838, 0.0011135260574519634, -0.021783534437417984, 0.01969032548367977, -0.03279205784201622, 0.007012632675468922, -0.03333795443177223, 0.05439261719584465, -0.0025174948386847973, -0.009921177290380001, -0.005698013585060835, -0.0728439912199974, -0.031750861555337906, -0.009942029602825642, 0.024289807304739952, 0.03751761093735695, 0.027363615110516548, -0.003070455277338624, -0.03610793873667717, 0.05815498158335686, 0.019221918657422066, 0.040818873792886734, 0.01918920874595642, -0.03492055833339691, 0.030870068818330765, 0.01746426336467266, -0.03623173385858536, -0.004401310347020626, -0.011113216169178486, -0.03752277046442032, 0.051713742315769196, -0.013640929944813251, 0.000731789565179497, -0.03698229417204857, -0.00562485633417964, 0.024860909208655357, 0.009490802884101868, 0.010110397823154926, 0.008239863440394402, 0.017357932403683662, 0.002705414080992341, 0.04932552948594093, -0.030645456165075302, 0.07810956984758377, 0.023826995864510536, 0.03171302378177643, 0.04512922838330269, 0.00219778623431921, 0.04755751043558121, 0.03632126748561859, -0.031061310321092606, -0.04322148486971855, -0.0015665176324546337, -0.04292421415448189, -0.018112672492861748, 0.008566542528569698, -0.00848053302615881, -0.06927718967199326, -0.007895182818174362, 0.0844259262084961, -0.07480688393115997, 0.0022333338856697083, -0.031562887132167816, 0.0015967771178111434, 0.0586458295583725, -0.012008658610284328, 0.04265419766306877, 0.006750975735485554, 0.023191453889012337, 0.018030280247330666, -0.020319638773798943, -0.022726407274603844, -0.0012396699748933315, 0.010545546188950539, 0.025125723332166672, 0.00282592442817986, -0.005801851861178875, -0.01767783612012863, 0.011840643361210823, 0.03500040993094444, -0.027544213458895683, 0.02322418801486492, -0.055455006659030914, -0.03873931244015694, 0.020468229427933693, 0.026790430769324303, 0.008220956660807133, 0.03694706782698631, 0.011560599319636822, -0.03745841979980469, 0.012454520910978317, 0.011726951226592064, 0.057826995849609375, -0.006943085230886936, -0.07205789536237717, 0.026843013241887093, -0.007357580587267876, -0.0010041873902082443, -0.02596425823867321, -0.00011678721784846857, -0.038655467331409454, -0.04001212492585182, 0.056054625660181046, 0.03558579087257385, 0.088965505361557, 0.08790449798107147, 0.041543666273355484, -0.024801472201943398, 0.050482142716646194, 0.04339170455932617, -0.07602318376302719, 0.02900594100356102, 0.011652007699012756, -0.008470951579511166, 0.04992135241627693, 0.02899778075516224, -0.0006265333504416049, 0.019916923716664314, -0.029206939041614532, -0.06718386709690094, 0.007655833847820759, 0.02076995000243187, -0.0259846244007349, -0.01143470499664545, -0.10683874785900116, 0.02911367639899254, -0.000959330762270838, -0.031139329075813293, -0.02275674231350422, -0.010125734843313694, 0.017121585085988045, -0.0031576394103467464, 0.03343653306365013, -0.026799356564879417, 0.009112164378166199, 0.0275906790047884, 0.019478071480989456, -0.03310292586684227, 0.03676043823361397, -0.01905292086303234, -0.017139874398708344, 0.01719336211681366, -0.05890155956149101, -0.024761570617556572, -0.05414101481437683, 0.042087163776159286, -0.05507231876254082, 0.036866553127765656, -0.0049369498156011105, -0.010109512135386467, 0.034613944590091705, 0.031980983912944794, 0.02712247334420681, 0.017569176852703094, 0.05231102928519249, 0.008015700615942478, 0.02473888173699379, 0.024782083928585052, -0.0021604623179882765, 0.03222482278943062, 0.06560995429754257, -0.013182807713747025, 0.005796094425022602, 0.04361860081553459, -0.002522978000342846, 0.04260726273059845, 0.022521764039993286, 0.022614246234297752, -0.04681681841611862, -0.04338948428630829, -0.03285612165927887, 0.0574156790971756, -0.00975315272808075, -0.08423522114753723, -0.03726287931203842, 0.03347010165452957, 0.03068295121192932, -0.05687518045306206, 0.0005717405001632869, 0.026192259043455124, -0.04381648823618889, 0.00038053884054534137, 0.03793526068329811, 0.05112083628773689, 0.036388564854860306, -0.06124760955572128, 0.02928253449499607, -0.08431321382522583, 0.0024882289581000805, 0.0026795833837240934, 0.00860404223203659, -0.046873994171619415, 0.0678047463297844, 0.04948624595999718, -0.04254740849137306, 0.019707927480340004, -0.0316627211868763, 0.0384698323905468, -0.042825911194086075, -0.011149512603878975, 0.041758451610803604, -0.01142025925219059, 0.03690004348754883, -0.04587095230817795, -0.015324466861784458, 0.0027055684477090836, 0.02287379465997219, -0.015192830935120583, 0.006404178217053413, -0.026986174285411835, -0.007439459674060345, 0.0003656807239167392, 0.016020534560084343, 0.010919975116848946, -0.041112951934337616, 0.01098887249827385, -0.029979106038808823, -0.009215433150529861, -0.018722208216786385, 0.009549800306558609, -0.017624830827116966, 0.08063369244337082, 0.006898744031786919, 0.031108731403946877, -0.0714988261461258, -0.016881631687283516, -0.057725969702005386, 0.01830735243856907, -0.012471760623157024, 0.05438551306724548, -0.029986195266246796, -0.04614835977554321, -0.055918511003255844, -0.002819087589159608, -0.019547609612345695, -0.025143727660179138, 0.03859347477555275, -0.014340145513415337, 0.02288094349205494, -0.04512816295027733, 0.03525043651461601, -0.04135637357831001, 0.011431857012212276, 0.02152123674750328, -0.012911786325275898, 0.030862074345350266, -0.03177867829799652, -0.03668321669101715, -0.018457112833857536, -0.045636821538209915, 0.055335406213998795, 0.04311363771557808, -0.0702015832066536, -0.03212974593043327, 0.0035006229300051928, -0.05675680562853813, 0.04470955580472946, 0.01764790154993534, -0.053244590759277344, -0.02636902593076229, 0.11714757978916168, -0.003344356780871749, 0.022561578080058098, -0.04799119383096695, -0.033569999039173126, -0.03132791072130203, -0.0180561114102602, 0.00809265486896038, -0.007531418930739164, 0.024500243365764618, 0.06515512615442276, 0.06271852552890778, -0.013071049936115742, 0.0511278361082077, -0.012479111552238464, -0.02855794131755829, 0.029871881008148193, 0.03436117246747017, 0.005689350422471762, 0.027644135057926178, -0.034170571714639664, -0.07710184156894684, -0.029628653079271317, 0.058253705501556396, -0.06424843519926071, -0.027291668578982353, 0.015048602595925331, -0.01951313577592373, -0.03921632841229439, -0.04661177098751068, -0.03059082292020321, -0.028905238956212997, 0.00820501521229744, -0.010736234486103058, 0.02794494852423668, 0.017642155289649963, 0.0004877217870671302, -0.023847319185733795, 0.023051785305142403, -0.03666747361421585, -0.007434300612658262, -0.02648763917386532, -0.035728078335523605, -0.022317936643958092, 0.01155178900808096, -0.014590801671147346, 0.02742023393511772, -0.021862253546714783, -0.058512404561042786, 0.033138200640678406, 0.042199935764074326, -0.03515088930726051, -0.01446235366165638, 0.0007117526256479323, 0.03390316665172577, 0.040463998913764954, 0.020648851990699768, -0.048670560121536255, -0.04713940620422363, -0.011170079931616783, -0.00031122128712013364, 0.05965496599674225, 0.0454978384077549, -0.035453181713819504, 0.033325403928756714, -0.010956263169646263, -0.02952086180448532, -0.007323840633034706, 0.030557651072740555, -0.006657965946942568, 0.007189817726612091, -0.016047833487391472, 0.000999554293230176, 0.008772592060267925, -0.013716408051550388, -0.046602703630924225, -0.002314732177183032, 0.018349794670939445, -0.004806292708963156, 0.048196159303188324, -0.01807647943496704, -0.018123211339116096, 0.03711273893713951, -0.0434134341776371, 0.009206426329910755, -0.02235829085111618, 0.005002440884709358, -0.041707780212163925, -0.006198023911565542, -0.009238614700734615, 0.033750057220458984, -0.0404832623898983, 0.0026656033005565405, 0.05919241905212402, 0.035171933472156525, -0.005863817874342203, -0.04297506436705589, 0.012438511475920677, 0.00968056172132492, -0.015730159357190132, -0.01868409849703312, 0.10718026757240295, 0.0030425023287534714, 0.0178108811378479, -0.0005116197862662375, 0.07355497777462006, -0.025394516065716743, -0.004197665024548769, -0.009172833524644375, 0.0185194443911314, 0.035627637058496475, -0.0007082647061906755, -0.0002016125654336065, 0.013027354143559933, -0.02511831745505333, -0.03278239071369171, 0.03013554960489273, 0.017258159816265106, -0.029974812641739845, -0.04477756842970848, 0.017544016242027283, -0.04043443500995636, -0.09451012313365936, -0.009998940862715244, 0.02945920079946518, -0.018320851027965546, -0.047532856464385986, -0.039322011172771454, 0.05735224112868309, -0.07720190286636353, -0.008524968288838863, -0.024424048140645027, 0.0015112116234377027, 0.012212992645800114, 0.020477157086133957, -0.0058504934422671795, 0.019405297935009003, 0.0006266362615860999, 0.016994914039969444, 0.00738951563835144, 0.0003544605860952288, 0.03767397254705429, 0.013978483155369759, -0.006286085117608309, 0.04457112401723862, -0.04649580270051956, 0.0029459670186042786, -0.018521104007959366, 0.061052870005369186, -0.001269588596187532, 0.009417224675416946, -0.04375358298420906, 0.015950897708535194, -0.010956226848065853, 0.001023172284476459, -0.014697686769068241, -0.02025311067700386, -0.011087991297245026, 0.03414814919233322, 0.07446517795324326, 0.025015737861394882, 0.029623694717884064, 0.03595488518476486, 0.0006569771794602275, 0.028287813067436218, -0.000031311657949117944, 0.028368433937430382, -0.03561261668801308, -0.011566895991563797, 0.026174306869506836, 0.10513411462306976, -0.02275179699063301, -0.060275595635175705, 0.02590538002550602, -0.047393299639225006, 0.026654887944459915, -0.00801167357712984, 0.08910418301820755, 0.004528378136456013, -0.028049800544977188, -0.009244214743375778, -0.0037083900533616543, 0.027767885476350784, 0.029929403215646744, 0.0060842279344797134, -0.01718984544277191, 0.0005209562950767577, 0.027582254260778427, -0.04056768864393234, 0.050087738782167435, -0.033953599631786346, -0.01100901048630476, -0.004216133616864681, -0.016542566940188408, -0.007457851432263851, 0.012464535422623158, 0.015221720561385155, -0.039002157747745514, -0.032396186143159866, -0.006743263453245163, -0.06065088510513306, 0.026487473398447037, 0.0091455252841115, 0.03323330730199814, -0.04091586917638779, -0.02463783323764801, 0.045245107263326645, 0.04154481738805771, -0.054635144770145416, -0.01107576210051775, -0.01828661561012268, -0.0028418945148587227, -0.012755653820931911, 0.022317657247185707, -0.03159810230135918, -0.025004006922245026, -0.016877107322216034, -0.054022789001464844, -0.05415583401918411, 0.0181259922683239, 0.036443404853343964, 0.034241482615470886, 0.011166319251060486, -0.004644228611141443, 0.04510774835944176, 0.0378061905503273, -0.017522243782877922, 0.06505805253982544, 0.029703421518206596, -0.014723063446581364, -0.02367801032960415, -0.050587259232997894, 0.052387285977602005, -0.037975918501615524, -0.022451279684901237, 0.039529379457235336, -0.04203949123620987, -0.03759688511490822, 0.04454973712563515, -0.05326792225241661, -0.04444260522723198, 0.03753938898444176, -0.09846634417772293, 0.07051956653594971, 0.009865537285804749, -0.033656928688287735, -0.01701570861041546, 0.040829382836818695, -0.018567919731140137, 0.020146898925304413, 0.020343462005257607, -0.023279912769794464, -0.0072029950097203255, 0.07294845581054688, 0.04652637615799904, 0.01568281278014183, 0.005660004913806915, 0.015814367681741714, -0.005345757585018873, -0.008439521305263042, -0.017041387036442757, -0.04730436950922012, 0.0018524711485952139, 0.00753163592889905, 0.03282511606812477, -0.010953066870570183, 0.08093991875648499, 0.01950378529727459, -0.025758180767297745, -0.031019804999232292, 0.016276346519589424, 0.04250532016158104, 0.03403120115399361, 0.0064066085033118725, 0.0182722806930542, 0.004828312434256077, 0.01844836212694645, -0.01069809589534998, 0.02540440298616886, 0.02647947520017624, -0.043529484421014786, 0.011127779260277748, 0.0552784726023674, 0.03758438676595688, -0.05481123551726341, -0.009700939990580082, -0.04447728767991066, -0.0003840123536065221, 0.020530691370368004, -0.02442195452749729, 0.06631702184677124, 0.0016497187316417694, 0.02093055099248886, 0.0010520962532609701, 0.011635689064860344, 0.0018759866943582892, -0.006307722069323063, 0.023221617564558983, -0.013069999404251575, 0.0020629630889743567, 0.1075345128774643, -0.019437531009316444, 0.033225804567337036, 0.05534399673342705, -0.0022894006688147783, -0.003914340864866972, 0.016556715592741966, -0.06503081321716309, -0.05257727578282356, -0.0458352230489254, -0.041128840297460556, -0.02348359115421772, 0.007262236904352903, 0.025818759575486183, -0.061061792075634, 0.025267688557505608, 0.03455529361963272, -0.05184628814458847, 0.07751697301864624, -0.007696398533880711, 0.02163458801805973, 0.022797802463173866, -0.02960783988237381, -0.030093852430582047, -0.04416521266102791, 0.008169014006853104, 0.030080430209636688, -0.028191307559609413, 0.020705286413431168, 0.01988137885928154, 0.045302532613277435, 0.014945531263947487, -0.025426123291254044, 0.017378969117999077, 0.00910766888409853, -0.03897882252931595, -0.01616518199443817, -0.0339091457426548, 0.0013138166395947337, -0.00041876445175148547, -0.07947226613759995, -0.01924062892794609, 0.08219044655561447, -0.050134170800447464, 0.07442767918109894, -0.017161699011921883, 0.03377871587872505, -0.0251141544431448, 0.01849895901978016, 0.006020856089890003, 0.07030967622995377, 0.021101191639900208, 0.049142275005578995, -0.005593794863671064, -0.008421204052865505, 0.0002763159282039851, 0.006225357297807932, -0.05196294188499451, -0.03974088653922081, -0.0365566723048687, -0.03920445218682289, -0.003389968303963542, 0.0019197295187041163, 0.03812594711780548, -0.04598208889365196, -0.05899614840745926, -0.036324385553598404, 0.044867005199193954, -0.014816741459071636, -0.04312952980399132, -0.013408691622316837, 0.0017751929117366672, -0.024061866104602814, 0.02344226837158203, -0.03366835415363312, -0.03176377713680267, -0.05669793114066124, -0.04749821498990059, -0.058896999806165695, -0.04314395785331726, -0.02706487849354744, 0.003094377461820841, 0.018851224333047867, -0.060780156403779984, -0.06019674241542816, -0.03510604798793793, 0.03843611851334572, -0.013461394235491753, 0.08823806047439575, -0.035212788730859756, -0.09193055331707001, 0.05080988258123398, 0.016514765098690987, 0.0361211821436882, -0.037331558763980865, -0.02240428887307644, -0.0188435148447752, 0.0267746914178133, 0.01690353825688362, 0.013704205863177776, -0.00038165930891409516, 0.044049348682165146, -0.0143392663449049, -0.023255730047822, 0.033344779163599014, -0.0016017089365050197, 0.006145231891423464, 0.023298783227801323, -0.04512874409556389, -0.0002647171204444021, -0.043071530759334564, 0.06175261735916138, -0.005958337336778641, -0.04317650571465492, -0.0698307678103447, -0.027942651882767677, 0.03257235139608383, 0.029484761878848076, -0.09324805438518524, -0.056408386677503586, 0.014178574085235596 ]
<p>I am working on a high school project that is related to projectile motion. I am exploring how exactly the position of the center of mass affects the trajectory of a long but thin, javelin-like projectile. I have created a special launching machine that gives each projectile an identical impulse, filmed all flights on a high-fps camera and extracted the position of both tips over time, frame-by-frame using <a href="http://www.cabrillo.edu/~dbrown/tracker/" rel="nofollow">Tracker</a>.</p> <p>The flight distance is ~12m, and the camera's distance is ~10m from the flight path. Consequently, the image is sligtly distorted. It is not too significant but still it would be nice to be able to obtain precise data. I could fix it in Photoshop if it were just one frame but I really cannot proccess <strong>all</strong> my data this way. I have not found any free software that could fix videos but that would probably not be too useful anyway since I do not have sufficient computing power at my disposal to be able to complete the task in reasonable time. Also, I am only interested in the projectile and don't need the whole background to be fixed...</p> <p>Therefore I probably need to find a way to find the correct coordinates using the coordinates I have already obtained. I know exactly what camera I used and so I could look up any specifications if necessary. Also, I know the dimensions of the place the videos were taken.</p> <p>Could you please help me find the way to find (or compute, preferably) the correct coordinates or at least provide me with a link to a source where this is described? I am not sure I can <em>diagnose</em> what type of distortion I am dealing with which made googling even harder.</p> <p>Thank you very much.</p>
g5876
[ 0.08110927790403366, -0.008940298110246658, -0.01643499732017517, 0.013898109085857868, 0.029736699536442757, -0.030831146985292435, 0.006863248534500599, 0.03997061401605606, -0.021463794633746147, -0.030058296397328377, -0.006218832451850176, 0.011602572165429592, 0.04486703500151634, 0.020918691530823708, -0.02309795469045639, 0.01772364042699337, 0.0734701007604599, -0.022197622805833817, 0.019026022404432297, 0.0675540342926979, 0.07923706620931625, -0.00009840446000453085, -0.02358492650091648, 0.00032417962211184204, -0.06177467107772827, -0.002835659310221672, 0.027363425120711327, -0.04061206430196762, -0.062156904488801956, 0.016776930540800095, -0.006775351706892252, -0.008412403985857964, -0.06548676639795303, -0.03819143399596214, 0.01628437452018261, -0.017964651808142662, 0.02893821895122528, -0.029571961611509323, -0.0013371385866776109, 0.03244730457663536, 0.012067765928804874, -0.08152113854885101, 0.0792546197772026, 0.003925770055502653, -0.023328790441155434, 0.028104810044169426, -0.002067107940092683, -0.025058723986148834, 0.0023917967919260263, -0.005117347463965416, -0.07071010023355484, 0.021204540506005287, -0.04537762701511383, 0.00012996546865906566, -0.023872090503573418, 0.02211703360080719, -0.0016129672294482589, 0.003940114751458168, 0.06664896756410599, -0.01558811403810978, 0.012648607604205608, -0.0006501151947304606, -0.03303812816739082, 0.015156055800616741, -0.0006896293489262462, -0.004645107313990593, -0.120684415102005, -0.031182019039988518, -0.018757613375782967, -0.06535691767930984, 0.035498376935720444, -0.02127658575773239, -0.033712081611156464, 0.001941398368217051, -0.09421687573194504, -0.06439688801765442, -0.024685706943273544, -0.025165967643260956, -0.003432879224419594, -0.008610767312347889, 0.02388969622552395, 0.02915329672396183, 0.004355892539024353, -0.03054099902510643, 0.07078598439693451, -0.0029344039503484964, -0.021447818726301193, 0.09515143930912018, 0.002549360506236553, -0.02336954139173031, -0.0092879394069314, 0.07241220772266388, 0.07336793839931488, 0.039847664535045624, -0.005724541377276182, -0.03126911073923111, -0.029848573729395866, 0.09749944508075714, 0.004590225871652365, 0.031288765370845795, -0.038271646946668625, 0.038303885608911514, 0.00034091691486537457, -0.0024766288697719574, -0.037214092910289764, -0.026667699217796326, 0.08318371325731277, -0.0194682739675045, 0.03910486027598381, -0.010283209383487701, -0.04275478422641754, -0.0666760802268982, -0.0041174134239554405, -0.005726173520088196, 0.006050947587937117, -0.02864317037165165, 0.016867240890860558, 0.015418121591210365, 0.002543204929679632, 0.035781193524599075, 0.045748110860586166, -0.04230864718556404, -0.048862554132938385, 0.0326981283724308, 0.020698148757219315, -0.03308522328734398, -0.03598790243268013, 0.0029793432913720608, -0.006507544312626123, 0.0005343559896573424, -0.04192459210753441, -0.026615312322974205, 0.06232772022485733, 0.05683174729347229, -0.015774382278323174, 0.03408609330654144, 0.016098804771900177, -0.005158558487892151, 0.013939833268523216, 0.05137690156698227, 0.002562309615314007, 0.02129049226641655, 0.013656718656420708, -0.01254237163811922, -0.04726404324173927, 0.0035799017641693354, -0.024543698877096176, 0.004414325580000877, 0.06940624862909317, -0.017557650804519653, -0.006706989835947752, -0.011791195720434189, -0.06071212515234947, 0.06764791905879974, 0.03316238150000572, -0.026685308665037155, -0.0024019537959247828, 0.009937368333339691, -0.00046519958414137363, -0.000059816586144734174, 0.009734215214848518, 0.01916763186454773, 0.060023460537195206, 0.010310235433280468, -0.033378247171640396, -0.013987562619149685, 0.0032678223215043545, -0.039540261030197144, -0.010197874158620834, -0.07231506705284119, -0.05175837501883507, -0.012322620488703251, 0.04599399492144585, -0.015234517864882946, -0.0293585117906332, 0.034401386976242065, 0.013046953827142715, -0.005547922104597092, 0.05195778235793114, 0.008406461216509342, -0.01607472449541092, 0.047914013266563416, -0.0064496202394366264, -0.03983849659562111, 0.01160457357764244, 0.019265692681074142, 0.08795056492090225, -0.0148039935156703, -0.004520927090197802, 0.014774324372410774, 0.03903260827064514, -0.016837336122989655, -0.03007856011390686, 0.015975244343280792, -0.014724915847182274, -0.022272443398833275, 0.04630794748663902, -0.04423839598894119, -0.03007591888308525, 0.007743826135993004, -0.02902168780565262, -0.02071995660662651, -0.017579345032572746, 0.08102159947156906, -0.0008901531109586358, -0.014885319396853447, 0.005895127076655626, -0.02063029631972313, -0.083625428378582, 0.04769650474190712, -0.06583434343338013, -0.016265450045466423, -0.002446443308144808, 0.059273526072502136, -0.024445362389087677, 0.049701958894729614, -0.0029255261179059744, -0.002437654882669449, 0.011976792477071285, 0.002806014847010374, -0.006855607498437166, 0.021611759439110756, 0.009840719401836395, -0.006571616977453232, -0.013347244821488857, 0.018797801807522774, 0.01806659996509552, -0.025558630004525185, 0.02623150870203972, 0.028369814157485962, -0.00473079364746809, 0.006914748344570398, 0.01917361281812191, 0.005270965397357941, 0.05095547065138817, -0.01713671162724495, -0.04376187175512314, -0.03080076165497303, 0.0015968350926414132, 0.06148216500878334, -0.010981638915836811, -0.04053135961294174, -0.03021591529250145, -0.07010918110609055, 0.01556261908262968, 0.01696002669632435, 0.07751574367284775, 0.001996035687625408, 0.0080606359988451, -0.02056879736483097, -0.028086720034480095, 0.0446137972176075, -0.0020426001865416765, -0.04227409511804581, -0.016003796830773354, -0.021226689219474792, -0.03794851154088974, 0.037991613149642944, -0.04695950821042061, 0.004721138160675764, -0.06548230350017548, -0.03414959833025932, -0.059837471693754196, -0.020728595554828644, -0.0011941153788939118, 0.03260480612516403, -0.0037845238111913204, -0.01472131721675396, 0.017919374629855156, 0.0020816014148294926, -0.011042897589504719, 0.028568953275680542, 0.056431714445352554, 0.015743287280201912, -0.022913474589586258, 0.024149004369974136, 0.00629038643091917, 0.010156509466469288, -0.01621422730386257, -0.0005035818321630359, 0.032638248056173325, 0.013523772358894348, -0.03297799080610275, 0.01410108245909214, 0.022086378186941147, -0.007084371987730265, -0.05306756868958473, 0.05778886377811432, 0.02399476431310177, -0.020554108545184135, -0.03283429890871048, -0.0016569223953410983, 0.05375177040696144, -0.02112484537065029, -0.020727232098579407, 0.05371079221367836, 0.037315115332603455, 0.04800765588879585, 0.03315391764044762, -0.02800566889345646, -0.001649211160838604, 0.03256931155920029, 0.056318942457437515, 0.03973422572016716, 0.040568072348833084, -0.028044916689395905, -0.03722348436713219, -0.03264410421252251, 0.008615786209702492, 0.012965570203959942, 0.006006139330565929, -0.02466309629380703, 0.0010861079208552837, 0.04587613791227341, 0.035065215080976486, -0.05251692607998848, -0.03854312747716904, -0.00927998498082161, -0.034518592059612274, 0.06575887650251389, 0.009009909816086292, -0.0714540034532547, 0.007814383134245872, -0.01071818545460701, 0.04558654874563217, 0.03743306174874306, 0.01751692034304142, 0.010930294170975685, 0.005766214802861214, 0.009132906794548035, -0.03982595354318619, -0.0260276198387146, -0.011405219323933125, -0.05347061902284622, 0.013815679587423801, -0.011455345898866653, 0.012553559616208076, 0.015045855194330215, 0.04969589784741402, -0.017842169851064682, 0.014038803055882454, 0.07638929039239883, -0.029485248029232025, -0.04398790001869202, 0.022914234548807144, -0.036404404789209366, 0.017896218225359917, 0.01284885685890913, 0.010433205403387547, -0.02147291600704193, 0.0509675033390522, 0.0055814702063798904, -0.001686648465692997, -0.034411538392305374, 0.024472475051879883, 0.08939136564731598, 0.008077665232121944, 0.019837798550724983, 0.003118328982964158, -0.006173950619995594, 0.0016859659226611257, -0.007633044384419918, -0.028921417891979218, -0.026593530550599098, -0.021339306607842445, 0.010532131418585777, -0.03817453235387802, -0.019799131900072098, 0.0016349131474271417, -0.036198172718286514, 0.029909009113907814, -0.040276627987623215, 0.002160286298021674, -0.046946827322244644, -0.034689661115407944, 0.057921405881643295, 0.03313937038183212, 0.02850303053855896, -0.028394795954227448, 0.029708117246627808, 0.059889018535614014, 0.05551816523075104, 0.018869664520025253, 0.036516234278678894, 0.037177879363298416, 0.013970130123198032, 0.035614386200904846, 0.021530184894800186, 0.046655964106321335, 0.003141250228509307, 0.027339451014995575, -0.11300752311944962, -0.01990911364555359, 0.003784635802730918, 0.024663496762514114, -0.025776231661438942, -0.012829522602260113, -0.010190862230956554, -0.02441278286278248, 0.05470805615186691, -0.007909294217824936, 0.04424215853214264, 0.012849928811192513, 0.02935871109366417, -0.05109280347824097, -0.010289675556123257, -0.003632375504821539, 0.026401817798614502, 0.020689258351922035, -0.002071462105959654, -0.023962711915373802, 0.015034396201372147, 0.021853556856513023, -0.07313089817762375, -0.041368234902620316, 0.029351042583584785, 0.024721946567296982, 0.04766443371772766, 0.01291495468467474, -0.0010570600861683488, 0.06244966760277748, 0.06695377081632614, 0.003834719769656658, -0.06379099190235138, -0.0030601019971072674, 0.02398335002362728, -0.02855123206973076, -0.0033442575950175524, 0.08666219562292099, 0.022080278024077415, 0.03723207116127014, -0.0025710093323141336, 0.023773454129695892, 0.04263455420732498, 0.015237619169056416, -0.0123290391638875, 0.010173727758228779, 0.014629030600190163, 0.05718603357672691, 0.04103533923625946, -0.03130168840289116, 0.018053356558084488, -0.003679258981719613, -0.03139510750770569, -0.06678394228219986, 0.026744278147816658, -0.06117546930909157, 0.008634437806904316, -0.04288966581225395, -0.00011436010390752926, 0.02429039403796196, -0.010520854033529758, -0.014254221692681313, 0.048402901738882065, -0.04455691948533058, 0.00766674242913723, 0.008699309080839157, -0.04128434881567955, 0.00011106509919045493, 0.009146296419203281, -0.00021129274682607502, -0.007468977011740208, -0.016155600547790527, -0.05600053444504738, 0.004651585593819618, -0.017249559983611107, -0.0468098446726799, -0.053772784769535065, -0.0025623708497732878, -0.030216969549655914, -0.00596552062779665, 0.019556796178221703, -0.0335233099758625, 0.0021460414864122868, 0.017976026982069016, -0.025081142783164978, -0.047830577939748764, -0.029159097000956535, 0.07278493046760559, 0.009494708850979805, -0.019545413553714752, -0.021685728803277016, -0.01742529682815075, -0.0694282203912735, 0.04382782429456711, 0.03167891129851341, -0.010865351185202599, 0.004883982706815004, 0.06271693110466003, -0.028774498030543327, 0.05747165158390999, -0.0366130992770195, -0.04356461390852928, -0.03285318985581398, 0.032651789486408234, -0.010287783108651638, -0.011393834836781025, -0.015423345379531384, 0.04382039234042168, 0.021175114437937737, -0.04019472748041153, 0.0011915949871763587, 0.02749740704894066, 0.04376568645238876, 0.004350627306848764, 0.03352883458137512, 0.026173457503318787, 0.02268754318356514, -0.040361594408750534, 0.02405417710542679, -0.002260332927107811, 0.039888858795166016, 0.04834796488285065, -0.04588755592703819, -0.009113292209804058, 0.0017430887091904879, 0.029826128855347633, 0.08394177258014679, 0.026153966784477234, 0.007754493039101362, 0.09594110399484634, -0.013963110744953156, 0.042236827313899994, 0.014517618343234062, 0.028813717886805534, -0.03002084232866764, -0.0020360301714390516, -0.01253898162394762, -0.00614857068285346, 0.019464554265141487, -0.06201808899641037, -0.06498333811759949, -0.01893361285328865, -0.060267653316259384, -0.0870690867304802, -0.03807968273758888, -0.02306445501744747, -0.0502193346619606, 0.026063697412610054, -0.0434781052172184, 0.02755492925643921, -0.036799971014261246, -0.009675953537225723, 0.010944243520498276, -0.06218739598989487, -0.02617838978767395, 0.0006515441345982254, -0.06392301619052887, 0.031615857034921646, -0.021183330565690994, -0.012437433935701847, 0.05693795904517174, 0.005930703599005938, -0.037844620645046234, -0.01992117613554001, -0.0009146503289230168, 0.021781859919428825, 0.012676590122282505, -0.056728068739175797, -0.04887792468070984, 0.013827202841639519, -0.05588715896010399, 0.03559667617082596, 0.08287941664457321, -0.01747477613389492, 0.036489374935626984, -0.030109833925962448, -0.0007916106260381639, 0.04881533980369568, -0.0018348293378949165, -0.04269303381443024, -0.03904112055897713, -0.035168685019016266, 0.01639389991760254, 0.04853256791830063, 0.031194545328617096, 0.029052289202809334, 0.02612190507352352, -0.09205754101276398, 0.023988161236047745, 0.010089888237416744, 0.037408147007226944, 0.03352249786257744, -0.034092385321855545, -0.0020077272783964872, 0.04599303379654884, -0.05286574363708496, 0.03697506710886955, 0.004906689748167992, -0.02878108061850071, 0.004322462249547243, -0.004876327700912952, -0.056398846209049225, -0.046232033520936966, -0.04169761389493942, -0.017259351909160614, 0.011308577843010426, 0.04043261706829071, -0.04899578168988228, 0.06194582208991051, 0.018530290573835373, 0.0035909253638237715, 0.013158435001969337, -0.0066473172046244144, -0.030010994523763657, 0.018402133136987686, 0.0341140478849411, 0.03957075998187065, 0.04506506025791168, -0.04608006402850151, -0.02048659697175026, 0.10407354682683945, -0.03499880060553551, 0.044720619916915894, -0.03714687377214432, 0.05053943768143654, -0.0028550587594509125, -0.059990294277668, -0.03187846764922142, -0.052938446402549744, 0.05176635459065437, -0.004064447246491909, -0.04562763124704361, 0.024946492165327072, -0.022817185148596764, 0.003054268890991807, 0.013580601662397385, 0.01719353161752224, 0.021941374987363815, -0.03863057866692543, 0.03989725559949875, -0.006368828006088734, 0.05025412142276764, -0.019072243943810463, -0.044845547527074814, 0.08249624073505402, -0.007481042295694351, 0.08391344547271729, 0.03949980437755585, 0.03495097905397415, 0.02778574638068676, -0.06182534620165825, -0.03712575510144234, 0.0024682199582457542, -0.08650411665439606, -0.014887174591422081, -0.026837704703211784, -0.016173407435417175, -0.01398168969899416, -0.02715415135025978, -0.04065966233611107, -0.004027284681797028, 0.04421134665608406, 0.0021152605768293142, -0.006921472959220409, 0.04714309424161911, 0.003744889982044697, -0.05904381722211838, 0.06256702542304993, -0.07142504304647446, -0.057450853288173676, -0.038913168013095856, -0.04545200616121292, -0.06016308069229126, -0.014986672438681126, 0.022252684459090233, -0.0012017199769616127, -0.0008726828382350504, -0.0375288724899292, -0.0038816342130303383, 0.030359391123056412, -0.0006767105078324676, 0.0005197326536290348, 0.09711222350597382, 0.031384509056806564, 0.023766519501805305, 0.00667464779689908, 0.03887868672609329, -0.07560413330793381, 0.012605363503098488, 0.0007992006721906364, 0.045173436403274536, -0.0204791072756052, 0.002668699249625206, -0.06744423508644104, 0.003999404143542051, -0.005341038573533297, 0.03378725051879883, -0.02344498783349991, -0.0424862876534462, -0.05512735992670059, 0.0528181754052639, -0.01851302571594715, -0.045934390276670456, -0.034125156700611115, -0.03903786092996597, 0.05924345925450325, -0.0035382115747779608, 0.03652734309434891, -0.0063611529767513275, 0.00448599411174655, -0.047754090279340744, 0.00901074055582285, 0.008125814609229565, 0.013514026068150997, 0.04695869982242584, -0.03887280449271202, 0.02552127279341221, -0.018393589183688164, 0.032220564782619476, 0.02803555130958557, -0.009344790130853653, 0.028454214334487915, -0.03003532439470291, 0.020808415487408638, 0.012243893928825855, -0.015869872644543648, 0.0591127835214138, -0.004337213467806578, 0.0011532590724527836, -0.017435066401958466, 0.03425844758749008, 0.005062031093984842, -0.07212775200605392, 0.06492156535387039, -0.04535067081451416, -0.016498856246471405, -0.02944689802825451, 0.06583353877067566, -0.07454948127269745, 0.006078281905502081, -0.027384428307414055, 0.015015996061265469, 0.012780923396348953, -0.0013158164219930768, -0.012831305153667927, -0.04265235364437103, -0.05372042581439018, 0.023887114599347115, -0.016365589573979378, 0.02458496391773224, 0.0006746925646439195, -0.06703203171491623, -0.04283173754811287, -0.00012793643691111356, -0.01007795985788107, 0.05004413053393364, 0.021487722173333168, 0.05759099870920181, -0.03711739927530289, 0.07562592625617981, -0.022971970960497856, -0.009211324155330658, 0.001944235758855939, -0.007950610481202602, -0.0010908698895946145, -0.01123038586229086, -0.0033138329163193703, 0.00849895179271698, -0.018327942118048668, 0.00031328300246968865, -0.056501828134059906, 0.025009702891111374, 0.041368160396814346, 0.00179191492497921, -0.03169380500912666, -0.02606675960123539, 0.006367688998579979 ]
<p>When we have two bodies and a central force acting towards the center of each other, we could treat the whole problem as a one body problem by introducing the relative coordinate. My question is, when you were to calculate the relative coordinate, you are working out the acceleration of a fictitious particle, which does not exist. </p> <p>However, if you work out the coupled differential equations, you would get exact acceleration of both particles. </p> <p>Therefore I think reduced mass is not a reliable method , but I was told that the reduced mass method can get the exact solution as the coupled differential equation. Therefore I think I am wrong, could anyone shed the light on this please?</p>
g5877
[ 0.08826534450054169, 0.0014161469880491495, 0.02436910755932331, -0.0034655053168535233, 0.0588938444852829, 0.01750754937529564, 0.018877487629652023, 0.0754159614443779, -0.01786273904144764, -0.007621995639055967, -0.006349403876811266, 0.02127501741051674, 0.016672413796186447, 0.023806989192962646, -0.016665689647197723, 0.005359330214560032, 0.041923023760318756, -0.0041208635084331036, -0.04275713860988617, 0.026337550953030586, -0.021499117836356163, 0.043504953384399414, 0.011436350643634796, -0.0013534273020923138, -0.055653490126132965, -0.05694855377078056, 0.023660654202103615, -0.007797804195433855, -0.052132803946733475, -0.011981016956269741, 0.04030629247426987, 0.017960114404559135, 0.035822801291942596, -0.015563838183879852, 0.01942606456577778, -0.0327855683863163, 0.052259791642427444, 0.032494477927684784, -0.03530161827802658, -0.0034239646047353745, -0.00007794532575644553, -0.08254489302635193, 0.013802743516862392, -0.03187650069594383, 0.016398586332798004, -0.00266981590539217, -0.008888842537999153, -0.047289442270994186, -0.020433500409126282, 0.01844725012779236, -0.007384670432657003, 0.022206081077456474, -0.014731395989656448, -0.03839755430817604, -0.0016226726584136486, 0.04721652716398239, 0.011311445385217667, -0.015531911514699459, 0.014977649785578251, 0.08502502739429474, -0.020237300544977188, -0.013149412348866463, 0.04464586079120636, -0.05121221765875816, 0.06460889428853989, -0.014235063455998898, -0.017642443999648094, 0.031963735818862915, -0.02534564957022667, 0.008469300344586372, -0.018136216327548027, -0.0461132787168026, -0.0003021755546797067, -0.014082204550504684, -0.027234891429543495, -0.017986899241805077, -0.014113989658653736, -0.03783494234085083, -0.01131511852145195, -0.00024709562421776354, -0.02466755546629429, 0.017629113048315048, 0.08635576069355011, 0.0257185660302639, 0.034967295825481415, -0.0003162634384352714, -0.009847014211118221, 0.02646692283451557, -0.04483939707279205, -0.04378340020775795, -0.004787690006196499, -0.024339158087968826, 0.04417873173952103, -0.013439450412988663, 0.01742980256676674, 0.01726722903549671, -0.01752515882253647, 0.059779342263936996, -0.012682749889791012, -0.039486367255449295, -0.026313873007893562, 0.010173357091844082, 0.010290318168699741, -0.00782564003020525, 0.000775532447732985, -0.033391933888196945, 0.05866508558392525, 0.02594398334622383, -0.012045024894177914, 0.010696225799620152, -0.010166360065340996, -0.08974994719028473, -0.003078653011471033, -0.038431115448474884, -0.012352440506219864, -0.08551910519599915, 0.08473921567201614, -0.018846431747078896, -0.026787150651216507, 0.020687447860836983, -0.07427423447370529, 0.029059968888759613, -0.0005706458468921483, 0.08569124341011047, 0.015678467229008675, -0.03729755058884621, 0.00296570872887969, 0.01798507384955883, 0.023025961592793465, -0.01325896754860878, -0.03315242379903793, -0.017224498093128204, 0.023706475272774696, -0.017242243513464928, -0.06076645478606224, 0.00454841461032629, -0.021385326981544495, 0.02281620167195797, 0.0024810379836708307, -0.009373621083796024, -0.04544072225689888, -0.005449394229799509, -0.004030085168778896, -0.027533704414963722, -0.057149358093738556, 0.006991460919380188, -0.05121602118015289, 0.00244978372938931, -0.014259335584938526, 0.08140204846858978, 0.009520663879811764, 0.05835900828242302, -0.025249280035495758, 0.002572303870692849, 0.044699933379888535, -0.007486032322049141, 0.017681283876299858, 0.0047329021617770195, -0.009671543724834919, -0.020452862605452538, 0.032848767936229706, -0.017193321138620377, 0.055143918842077255, -0.023670384660363197, 0.0032616513781249523, 0.08136986196041107, -0.0527791827917099, -0.043204039335250854, 0.018410712480545044, -0.04467468336224556, -0.08018964529037476, -0.033144399523735046, -0.011898654513061047, 0.09853457659482956, -0.014025231823325157, 0.007753266952931881, 0.02142821066081524, -0.036075036972761154, -0.03535202518105507, 0.03492968901991844, 0.01725875586271286, 0.010000844486057758, -0.004619928076863289, -0.0007912361761555076, -0.011543539352715015, 0.016824232414364815, -0.026070164516568184, 0.0732957050204277, -0.029554836452007294, -0.03455313667654991, 0.0003826719184871763, -0.005459458567202091, -0.0009084218181669712, 0.06098761409521103, -0.024846291169524193, 0.04099779576063156, -0.0023028936702758074, -0.013862640596926212, -0.003361678449437022, 0.02084861509501934, -0.022271286696195602, 0.05274170637130737, 0.0247601717710495, -0.0010736482217907906, 0.028388168662786484, -0.01735318824648857, -0.01107165776193142, -0.029628949239850044, 0.03386504948139191, 0.003608312224969268, 0.005265997257083654, 0.028198804706335068, 0.01114277821034193, 0.0242418572306633, -0.0397372804582119, -0.031221440061926842, -0.003436715342104435, -0.0012015894753858447, -0.03612377867102623, 0.02329716831445694, -0.022460274398326874, -0.018538299947977066, 0.023919329047203064, 0.027358870953321457, 0.01107491459697485, -0.03880056366324425, -0.019279904663562775, -0.030772073194384575, -0.01461106538772583, 0.002512732520699501, -0.043058134615421295, 0.034467000514268875, -0.0004003324138466269, -0.030531372874975204, 0.02487504854798317, 0.012938804924488068, -0.06687986105680466, 0.024404851719737053, 0.010795678943395615, 0.05288771912455559, 0.007875661365687847, -0.058173082768917084, -0.012762589380145073, 0.006994745694100857, 0.047785863280296326, -0.012852375395596027, 0.11020588129758835, 0.0513962097465992, 0.027305493131279945, -0.013799837790429592, -0.04607529938220978, -0.00681341253221035, -0.056815676391124725, -0.06187760457396507, 0.0687398836016655, 0.062213242053985596, -0.05701322853565216, 0.018374210223555565, 0.005335655994713306, -0.011112992651760578, -0.011371057480573654, -0.007995967753231525, 0.002431764965876937, 0.0682658925652504, -0.07491783797740936, 0.02774057164788246, -0.01452785637229681, -0.03518904745578766, 0.025695862248539925, -0.014710447750985622, -0.03949636220932007, 0.05141321197152138, -0.035224445164203644, 0.06009508669376373, -0.0660780519247055, 0.025437135249376297, 0.02420942671597004, -0.034421540796756744, 0.0024184391368180513, 0.030668770894408226, 0.02957461029291153, 0.002346661174669862, -0.007880772463977337, 0.02064673788845539, 0.03348249942064285, -0.018909476697444916, -0.02328489162027836, -0.018576765432953835, 0.017895659431815147, -0.05178874358534813, -0.023601071909070015, -0.014340766705572605, 0.054684873670339584, 0.026736881583929062, 0.02066054567694664, 0.07790524512529373, 0.0614902637898922, -0.005653349217027426, 0.023273427039384842, 0.01507095992565155, 0.023949692025780678, -0.023834040388464928, 0.0023572093341499567, 0.009912786073982716, 0.028844913467764854, -0.007918491028249264, -0.05257774144411087, -0.02028890885412693, 0.0406491756439209, 0.0006615138263441622, 0.0023110019974410534, 0.05906474590301514, 0.013293390162289143, 0.012076352722942829, 0.012144256383180618, 0.00752660958096385, 0.0058600930497050285, -0.051038093864917755, -0.006313864141702652, -0.0018782129045575857, -0.05528448149561882, 0.003407371463254094, -0.0030764350667595863, -0.041507016867399216, 0.009126757271587849, 0.06429964303970337, -0.018895134329795837, 0.06996148079633713, -0.04848990589380264, -0.07871603965759277, -0.007035143673419952, 0.00003626947000157088, -0.014825071208178997, -0.010744004510343075, -0.03452858701348305, -0.07383552193641663, -0.03551564738154411, 0.02664395608007908, 0.03937530145049095, 0.06042071059346199, 0.00605200557038188, -0.05452702194452286, -0.014729413203895092, -0.03089565970003605, -0.005341324023902416, 0.03561835736036301, -0.0004252272192388773, 0.007642949931323528, 0.03433403745293617, -0.047924235463142395, 0.02317889779806137, -0.020074190571904182, -0.02102232724428177, 0.016296301037073135, -0.03962491825222969, -0.018024390563368797, 0.025581302121281624, 0.03190379589796066, -0.08415007591247559, 0.030040886253118515, 0.008300753310322762, -0.01452663168311119, -0.03627574071288109, 0.06562945246696472, 0.022771617397665977, -0.027589349076151848, -0.016712527722120285, 0.0411234088242054, -0.04476328194141388, -0.053853701800107956, -0.05881257727742195, -0.047147486358881, 0.039476100355386734, -0.05330369994044304, 0.05573473498225212, -0.056177668273448944, 0.003634259570389986, 0.001652356470003724, -0.039408572018146515, -0.0001773338735802099, -0.00274640298448503, 0.016406826674938202, -0.027198078110814095, 0.0357462577521801, 0.017475707456469536, 0.01644548587501049, -0.05389956384897232, -0.02899743616580963, 0.08954920619726181, -0.009125758893787861, 0.03156108036637306, -0.049764230847358704, -0.046097636222839355, -0.00008754890586715192, 0.054018620401620865, -0.0011562872678041458, 0.009637245908379555, -0.05929550528526306, 0.034544702619314194, 0.0013507847907021642, -0.018028264865279198, 0.02699853479862213, 0.01353665255010128, 0.03375070169568062, -0.025195682421326637, 0.007414010353386402, -0.017629317939281464, -0.017570873722434044, 0.01910310797393322, 0.06348441541194916, 0.01002714317291975, 0.03939259424805641, 0.04094223305583, -0.02651877887547016, 0.04780401661992073, -0.047661084681749344, 0.025817492976784706, 0.029094694182276726, 0.020838726311922073, 0.035764530301094055, 0.013422546908259392, 0.06837548315525055, -0.06084282323718071, -0.04074397683143616, -0.012181070633232594, 0.07478199899196625, 0.01154266856610775, -0.03182603046298027, -0.00115502392873168, 0.03571109473705292, 0.03842362016439438, 0.012010015547275543, 0.014340674504637718, 0.04092348366975784, -0.028098735958337784, 0.012011369690299034, -0.011374449357390404, 0.03889373317360878, 0.035242389887571335, 0.07865557074546814, -0.016414083540439606, 0.04412524029612541, 0.003904966404661536, -0.018950723111629486, -0.018773430958390236, 0.033429499715566635, -0.027653060853481293, -0.03633726388216019, -0.010660507716238499, -0.047076646238565445, 0.002077534794807434, 0.012661000713706017, 0.010824487544596195, -0.02466353215277195, 0.0097572673112154, 0.012047612108290195, 0.011201806366443634, 0.02956678345799446, -0.059637751430273056, 0.032227251678705215, -0.04508339613676071, 0.02268107607960701, -0.0008912066696211696, -0.0041372994892299175, 0.030914006754755974, -0.013037973083555698, -0.026778746396303177, 0.008888687938451767, -0.03304002061486244, 0.0028001603204756975, 0.017262134701013565, 0.023318370804190636, 0.014788324944674969, -0.05202440917491913, 0.006769533734768629, -0.02862091176211834, -0.012635393999516964, 0.005707591772079468, 0.0682191252708435, -0.023750806227326393, -0.01706864684820175, 0.019568486139178276, -0.02398780919611454, -0.042615123093128204, 0.015063345432281494, 0.03144729509949684, -0.009095106273889542, 0.055275872349739075, 0.03311808034777641, -0.018911167979240417, 0.03344041481614113, -0.00631345808506012, -0.019650490954518318, -0.07790261507034302, 0.0339248850941658, 0.025937912985682487, -0.04479672387242317, -0.046916697174310684, -0.01251225359737873, 0.03316449746489525, -0.07694630324840546, 0.006441897246986628, -0.01735762134194374, 0.0013645421713590622, -0.0019731989596039057, 0.062221284955739975, 0.0823315903544426, 0.012373533099889755, -0.000724142650142312, 0.034522879868745804, -0.02135942131280899, 0.041887205094099045, 0.051049262285232544, 0.00028803927125409245, -0.07499977946281433, 0.009189819917082787, -0.0031475187279284, -0.014348323456943035, -0.0078030796721577644, -0.06792060285806656, 0.07332956790924072, 0.0201856829226017, 0.00429587671533227, 0.029621737077832222, -0.014165150001645088, 0.001494289026595652, 0.01953486166894436, 0.060710255056619644, -0.06900934875011444, -0.007214153651148081, -0.04823770001530647, -0.017913633957505226, 0.019100943580269814, 0.021177401766180992, -0.06252245604991913, -0.05330224707722664, 0.0000581678505113814, -0.013062827289104462, 0.06459159404039383, -0.02724137157201767, -0.04527662321925163, -0.0416346974670887, 0.03274008259177208, 0.058610934764146805, -0.06964592635631561, 0.03748086839914322, -0.04128305986523628, 0.0014307330129668117, -0.0010055259335786104, -0.0715445727109909, -0.07042156159877777, 0.02497141622006893, 0.011058960109949112, 0.006044473499059677, -0.001866357633844018, -0.0035099140368402004, 0.03070145472884178, 0.009986051358282566, 0.02315976843237877, 0.032981108874082565, 0.000039076898247003555, -0.08618771284818649, 0.01963815838098526, 0.023019274696707726, -0.019290423020720482, -0.035937048494815826, -0.00041914399480447173, 0.005397527478635311, 0.020645515993237495, -0.08145029842853546, -0.03955404460430145, -0.056584667414426804, 0.010902667418122292, 0.027407487854361534, 0.07027354836463928, -0.0005530444323085248, -0.00700096320360899, 0.004750511143356562, -0.03282422199845314, 0.04316588118672371, 0.012980547733604908, -0.008846728131175041, 0.012344072572886944, -0.03152020648121834, -0.01053311862051487, 0.02353707328438759, -0.07076797634363174, -0.015744518488645554, 0.04006098955869675, 0.03396610915660858, 0.014654705300927162, -0.001167279900982976, -0.04269835352897644, -0.015074304305016994, -0.07399822771549225, -0.0064958445727825165, 0.00674162432551384, 0.02498609758913517, 0.001229983870871365, 0.05461093783378601, 0.0686027929186821, 0.011752230115234852, -0.0073367999866604805, 0.03662712126970291, 0.05112874507904053, 0.0006646653637290001, -0.019590407609939575, -0.018861861899495125, -0.0184833575040102, -0.03225141763687134, 0.012227596715092659, 0.009937478229403496, 0.03366943448781967, 0.008259950205683708, 0.03989242762327194, -0.06527545303106308, -0.007175064645707607, 0.06873614341020584, -0.0332060270011425, -0.008498672395944595, 0.012345555238425732, -0.029363684356212616, 0.0722012147307396, -0.007201750762760639, 0.036689601838588715, -0.021341441199183464, -0.025075828656554222, -0.02676418237388134, 0.11001277714967728, -0.031843945384025574, 0.03840289264917374, -0.015332887880504131, -0.005679270252585411, -0.011487781070172787, 0.0134535301476717, 0.03544556349515915, 0.018297966569662094, 0.04270901903510094, 0.019022688269615173, 0.038989387452602386, -0.029839716851711273, 0.02343779057264328, 0.0017861617961898446, 0.050107721239328384, -0.11620934307575226, -0.01942095346748829, 0.06177932396531105, -0.001423569512553513, -0.0573149099946022, -0.011266139335930347, 0.004805656615644693, -0.0063509251922369, -0.038628965616226196, 0.04733634367585182, -0.020728526636958122, 0.0007100395741872489, 0.04168650135397911, 0.018815966323018074, -0.04834113270044327, -0.047831643372774124, -0.06129426509141922, -0.029698245227336884, 0.02417626790702343, 0.01360599510371685, -0.03942549228668213, 0.03638768941164017, 0.005839124787598848, -0.015186890959739685, 0.005730513948947191, 0.00863923691213131, 0.019152628257870674, -0.030780134722590446, -0.06956981122493744, 0.032409682869911194, -0.00028494276921264827, 0.03757540136575699, 0.00601048581302166, -0.025568915531039238, 0.025948213413357735, -0.012997794896364212, 0.00018277598428539932, 0.0569721981883049, -0.018147502094507217, 0.007646458689123392, -0.010503695346415043, 0.04567161574959755, -0.023789795115590096, -0.03648541495203972, -0.010132071562111378, -0.04064963385462761, -0.030988967046141624, 0.036599766463041306, 0.008828222751617432, 0.031152714043855667, -0.017888065427541733, -0.035992931574583054, 0.012332461774349213, 0.07463746517896652, -0.0002309465198777616, 0.022643260657787323, 0.05814692750573158, -0.029299627989530563, 0.061670225113630295, 0.04858307167887688, -0.05343366041779518, 0.0036869514733552933, -0.021567391231656075, -0.004345321096479893, 0.017263343557715416, 0.08066314458847046, 0.03368218615651131, 0.030007297173142433, 0.01818910241127014, -0.012654428370296955, -0.014608552679419518, -0.007233195938169956, -0.0492352619767189, 0.06352312117815018, 0.0316891223192215, -0.029433047398924828, -0.04310080036520958, 0.00882547628134489, 0.016600703820586205, -0.05779147148132324, -0.011091488413512707, -0.02682209573686123, -0.030279837548732758, -0.015747809782624245, 0.007991793565452099, -0.041285205632448196, 0.030275361612439156, -0.015366721898317337, 0.008436977863311768, 0.050418343394994736, 0.03298050910234451, 0.006362501997500658, -0.08867087960243225, -0.034474555402994156, -0.04523824527859688, 0.00037963216891512275, -0.029125213623046875, -0.11575791239738464, -0.007182185538113117, -0.01479782722890377, -0.0056967660784721375, 0.008030467666685581, -0.013141386210918427, 0.010011490434408188, 0.05626251921057701, 0.020235281437635422, 0.029268778860569, 0.0201752707362175, -0.13507428765296936, 0.007757814135402441, 0.054882921278476715, -0.07302451133728027, 0.00028755341190844774, -0.02549929730594158, -0.054806899279356, -0.001864295918494463, 0.0017555893864482641, 0.04589831456542015, -0.007399650756269693, -0.011680250987410545, -0.01774350367486477, -0.021351929754018784, -0.01971573568880558, 0.025754645466804504 ]
<p>Assume that you have two bipartite systems $\rho_1^{AB},\rho_2^{AB}$ then I would like to prove the following:</p> <p>$$S(\frac{1}{2}( \rho_1^{AB}+I^A\otimes\rho_2^B))+S(\frac{1}{2}(\rho_2^{AB}+I^A\otimes\rho_1^B)) \geq S(\frac{1}{2}(\rho_1^{AB}+I^A\otimes\rho_1^B))+S(\frac{1}{2}(\rho_2^{AB}+I^A\otimes\rho_2^B))$$</p> <p>where $S$ is the von Neumann entropy, $\rho_1^B=tr_A(\rho_1^{AB}),\rho_2^B=tr_A(\rho_2^{AB})$ and $I^A$ is the maximally mixed state on $A$. It looks like it should pass with some monotony property, any hints or counterexample are welcome. </p>
g5878
[ -0.013163956813514233, -0.03686272352933884, 0.00022773370437789708, -0.0015847759786993265, 0.036955952644348145, -0.03480428457260132, 0.02568996138870716, -0.015014922246336937, 0.011718705296516418, 0.02653234265744686, -0.007415109314024448, 0.011757413856685162, -0.015568522736430168, 0.02530384436249733, -0.026818599551916122, 0.04029116407036781, 0.023176448419690132, 0.017021849751472473, -0.02893250249326229, -0.02556762844324112, -0.06459712237119675, -0.016843268647789955, 0.029075361788272858, 0.00811284314841032, 0.053168393671512604, 0.015062239021062851, 0.04900922253727913, 0.01599358394742012, -0.05185021087527275, -0.002639101818203926, 0.022998403757810593, -0.03257888928055763, 0.009089241735637188, -0.04582376033067703, -0.009161624126136303, -0.004109411966055632, 0.04207000881433487, -0.032779108732938766, 0.023516738787293434, -0.04518335685133934, -0.019495945423841476, 0.001626211334951222, -0.014551919884979725, -0.019267568364739418, -0.005186980590224266, -0.04214834049344063, 0.01704401522874832, 0.041584938764572144, -0.036584872752428055, -0.020789196714758873, 0.01859484426677227, 0.03631569445133209, 0.030314844101667404, -0.024297641590237617, -0.020903445780277252, -0.028471726924180984, -0.0022270504850894213, -0.05767574533820152, -0.028167221695184708, 0.050296634435653687, 0.013876956887543201, -0.04189665988087654, -0.023843975737690926, 0.05238170549273491, 0.00858632754534483, 0.02548077702522278, 0.038374725729227066, -0.02411625348031521, 0.026532385498285294, 0.02205958403646946, -0.024882623925805092, -0.02711007557809353, 0.04497556388378143, -0.022752229124307632, 0.023826386779546738, -0.019003314897418022, 0.03669501096010208, -0.024557936936616898, -0.0012222587829455733, 0.022650260478258133, 0.004884221125394106, -0.06916440278291702, -0.00900992564857006, -0.006169590633362532, 0.0006591007113456726, 0.043717700988054276, 0.06346956640481949, -0.03539449721574783, -0.043805330991744995, 0.064360611140728, -0.007729379925876856, -0.03739246353507042, 0.002494358690455556, 0.024774594232439995, -0.009733919985592365, 0.06430882215499878, -0.009747772477567196, 0.008138430304825306, 0.020380929112434387, -0.018679264932870865, -0.02491062320768833, 0.004609961528331041, 0.029059628024697304, 0.011985396035015583, 0.023549329489469528, -0.015120510943233967, 0.034833189100027084, -0.057088352739810944, -0.04144756868481636, 0.023502947762608528, -0.000216965694562532, -0.05273675546050072, -0.026261065155267715, 0.004371450748294592, -0.022520264610648155, 0.047274742275476456, -0.011365569196641445, -0.021687723696231842, -0.08007431030273438, -0.023854007944464684, -0.024372722953557968, 0.040864355862140656, 0.018966754898428917, 0.042557455599308014, -0.0020731959957629442, 0.07941734045743942, 0.0028312329668551683, 0.013935470953583717, 0.05707458406686783, -0.01276111789047718, 0.02488641068339348, -0.021048910915851593, 0.017963126301765442, -0.03504849970340729, -0.03474712371826172, 0.0020581467542797327, -0.014061465859413147, 0.0020323339849710464, -0.04624718055129051, -0.04208769276738167, -0.061933062970638275, -0.024704134091734886, -0.053353291004896164, -0.005900348071008921, -0.0082401717081666, 0.013811122626066208, 0.010928569361567497, -0.04074626415967941, -0.05340571328997612, -0.004154301714152098, 0.0034822372253984213, 0.06220206618309021, -0.029412979260087013, 0.011284572072327137, -0.05517201125621796, 0.03519013524055481, 0.004882199689745903, 0.017532283440232277, 0.005364954471588135, -0.004775357898324728, -0.04006197303533554, 0.03955833241343498, 0.02637159824371338, -0.003088250756263733, -0.017131518572568893, 0.022733580321073532, 0.04087221622467041, -0.04620221629738808, -0.005993279162794352, -0.1119987890124321, -0.03503203019499779, -0.004610945004969835, -0.0616425946354866, -0.0014046041760593653, 0.03373700752854347, -0.014901355840265751, -0.03887658566236496, 0.005998376291245222, 0.0649666041135788, -0.006482595112174749, -0.017699990421533585, 0.02764006145298481, 0.052964065223932266, 0.044489823281764984, 0.011723102070391178, 0.01604725979268551, -0.06561890989542007, -0.02454359084367752, -0.10227455198764801, 0.043522778898477554, -0.02032504789531231, 0.04444621130824089, -0.003126688301563263, -0.02932308241724968, 0.008805382065474987, 0.03686622530221939, -0.004136691801249981, -0.0621943362057209, 0.022059643641114235, -0.011668717488646507, 0.033837802708148956, 0.0017511730547994375, 0.02846803516149521, 0.0020580976270139217, 0.03293970972299576, 0.025602377951145172, -0.007652719970792532, 0.034564610570669174, 0.021200669929385185, -0.00793006643652916, -0.030725128948688507, -0.05151905491948128, -0.047407329082489014, -0.02746214158833027, -0.0039989841170609, -0.06781203299760818, -0.0033697595354169607, 0.025252819061279297, -0.010628856718540192, 0.0037744955625385046, -0.018883679062128067, 0.016419896855950356, 0.0478626973927021, 0.02402004785835743, -0.03770881146192551, 0.04108289256691933, -0.05279706418514252, 0.015641842037439346, -0.03544863313436508, 0.042126625776290894, -0.019375959411263466, 0.024567149579524994, 0.06340527534484863, -0.02851630002260208, -0.025384511798620224, 0.01727444678544998, 0.016383448615670204, 0.04911474883556366, 0.0329657718539238, -0.013396363705396652, 0.03616832569241524, -0.0365062840282917, -0.029085543006658554, 0.040926493704319, 0.03768952935934067, -0.006450205110013485, -0.00258094840683043, 0.01726062223315239, 0.021936899051070213, 0.04930716007947922, -0.030371427536010742, -0.0019503035582602024, -0.017706789076328278, -0.04974823072552681, 0.0007917372859083116, -0.007184690795838833, 0.01712254248559475, -0.02931770123541355, 0.043848615139722824, -0.022496959194540977, -0.012898506596684456, -0.030695127323269844, -0.03338877856731415, 0.004232462961226702, -0.07067573070526123, 0.03600594773888588, -0.05008632317185402, -0.03606511652469635, -0.01927441731095314, -0.01467196736484766, 0.04805830866098404, 0.03369578346610069, 0.016985028982162476, 0.029063981026411057, -0.0070138853043317795, -0.0037723237182945013, -0.019917702302336693, 0.005627661477774382, 0.021569369360804558, -0.00148178287781775, -0.027088196948170662, 0.03841717541217804, 0.022044548764824867, 0.01400685589760542, 0.03223875164985657, -0.016401689499616623, 0.03817026689648628, 0.08177665621042252, 0.009234461933374405, 0.06976643204689026, -0.020554931834340096, 0.09304524958133698, 0.05471030995249748, 0.030601760372519493, -0.02992589958012104, 0.025715656578540802, 0.02060381881892681, -0.07123902440071106, 0.007135845720767975, 0.031330619007349014, -0.038025520741939545, 0.017517849802970886, -0.010766945779323578, 0.044943977147340775, 0.03509455546736717, -0.02037232182919979, -0.0300835482776165, -0.031695086508989334, 0.0059537324123084545, 0.02036338299512863, -0.02711392566561699, -0.040920715779066086, 0.03276339918375015, -0.042086221277713776, 0.013009813614189625, 0.010829228907823563, 0.018099341541528702, -0.02654292620718479, 0.00595105579122901, 0.0037592872977256775, 0.04285736009478569, -0.03626982122659683, 0.04196586087346077, 0.016370398923754692, 0.020882120355963707, -0.04626147821545601, -0.07120086997747421, 0.05938589572906494, -0.09374796599149704, 0.036616887897253036, 0.012913166545331478, 0.0064146872609853745, 0.04939897358417511, 0.007658183574676514, -0.07148875296115875, -0.024414392188191414, -0.027926022186875343, -0.009158467873930931, 0.011350035667419434, -0.013619571924209595, -0.07023072242736816, 0.02938208170235157, 0.05708411708474159, 0.009511500597000122, -0.0235894788056612, -0.002592191332951188, -0.02618875540792942, 0.01840648241341114, 0.04146197810769081, -0.0079523716121912, -0.0017137920949608088, 0.027398288249969482, 0.08975479006767273, 0.017598532140254974, -0.03298766538500786, 0.020978836342692375, 0.03245292231440544, -0.012099692597985268, 0.058441273868083954, -0.02581736259162426, 0.011004362255334854, -0.006054982542991638, -0.02811201848089695, -0.0013329789508134127, -0.03870429843664169, -0.009912322275340557, 0.014976724050939083, 0.06224736198782921, -0.023569362238049507, 0.0024521234445273876, -0.05839288607239723, -0.033016547560691833, 0.021207576617598534, 0.05180898308753967, 0.0652402713894844, -0.08648727834224701, 0.0525025799870491, -0.0176396481692791, -0.01908736489713192, 0.05256247892975807, 0.056238073855638504, -0.022247102111577988, 0.007590034976601601, 0.028345149010419846, 0.0009183019865304232, -0.008941973559558392, 0.01488602627068758, 0.05306744575500488, 0.003321658354252577, -0.07610796391963959, 0.01679995469748974, -0.006170632783323526, -0.015324837528169155, 0.03792356699705124, 0.015361645258963108, 0.021377142518758774, 0.048538871109485626, 0.0433453731238842, 0.01524352002888918, 0.04877513647079468, -0.020208066329360008, -0.033549144864082336, -0.037589140236377716, -0.03589268773794174, -0.007524639833718538, -0.09571119397878647, -0.006702435202896595, 0.0575442910194397, 0.044452134519815445, -0.014561433345079422, -0.03157036751508713, -0.007482822053134441, 0.053390730172395706, -0.023134276270866394, -0.032687410712242126, 0.008657945320010185, -0.0033942197915166616, -0.015213334001600742, -0.011834673583507538, -0.020350290462374687, -0.09294211119413376, -0.0035071615129709244, 0.01298933383077383, -0.030692733824253082, 0.004858509171754122, -0.007721763104200363, 0.059865064918994904, -0.005974230822175741, -0.044661398977041245, -0.06459107995033264, -0.023927196860313416, -0.003337356960400939, -0.04048090800642967, 0.07799883931875229, -0.0466277115046978, 0.04497961327433586, -0.05292939767241478, -0.007387228775769472, 0.012977644801139832, -0.0018161244224756956, 0.003966195974498987, -0.029499150812625885, 0.0034802183508872986, -0.0012000501155853271, 0.040260717272758484, 0.018167074769735336, 0.04110829532146454, -0.042122844606637955, -0.005774988327175379, -0.043038737028837204, 0.024783354252576828, 0.03440156579017639, 0.04867991805076599, -0.012959635816514492, -0.025161562487483025, 0.00010400326573289931, -0.022603057324886322, 0.09370385855436325, 0.007633219938725233, -0.04766746610403061, 0.02458464540541172, -0.0615650899708271, -0.0030390997417271137, -0.05354899540543556, 0.08199680596590042, 0.04022417590022087, -0.020988963544368744, 0.06202099844813347, -0.04094347357749939, -0.051693085581064224, 0.028124094009399414, -0.017096664756536484, -0.013195956125855446, 0.04220817983150482, -0.0007132604368962348, -0.012416488490998745, -0.07776270806789398, -0.013638495467603207, 0.012355731800198555, 0.060110557824373245, -0.03077218309044838, -0.013963879086077213, -0.030725475400686264, 0.03543168306350708, 0.03126261383295059, -0.01707003079354763, 0.004976880270987749, -0.017237162217497826, 0.006694437470287085, -0.0057791150175035, -0.004783218260854483, 0.09388946741819382, 0.04217665642499924, 0.08136816322803497, 0.005346148740500212, -0.021428542211651802, 0.009077460505068302, -0.02728445455431938, -0.0607340931892395, 0.046736061573028564, -0.11602940410375595, 0.01817038469016552, 0.014540078118443489, 0.08763810992240906, 0.010935099795460701, 0.05606459453701973, 0.0037828905042260885, 0.017903529107570648, -0.008581078611314297, 0.044278617948293686, -0.04078724980354309, 0.014193474315106869, -0.0069716027937829494, 0.022175630554556847, -0.007182168308645487, 0.01452745869755745, -0.03079817444086075, -0.011441299691796303, -0.009170565754175186, -0.09064795076847076, 0.031799979507923126, -0.04636460542678833, 0.003652363084256649, -0.028588708490133286, 0.024598238989710808, 0.04376968368887901, -0.09058372676372528, -0.027372142300009727, 0.012113119475543499, 0.03619368374347687, -0.006034907419234514, -0.03422658517956734, -0.01677030511200428, -0.0473511777818203, 0.06445743143558502, -0.019586285576224327, -0.03801795467734337, 0.01312736701220274, -0.022525306791067123, 0.03162630274891853, -0.0055237109772861, -0.03568637743592262, 0.0023662117309868336, 0.006711140740662813, -0.029577160254120827, -0.002706560306251049, -0.09062301367521286, -0.05039984732866287, -0.038899775594472885, 0.02605222724378109, 0.00542635889723897, 0.004664085805416107, -0.04647347703576088, -0.05019707232713699, 0.02017293870449066, -0.033711425960063934, 0.031549278646707535, -0.018735073506832123, 0.04956419765949249, 0.08709298074245453, 0.013337592594325542, -0.029397401958703995, 0.018125709146261215, 0.019259033724665642, 0.02939596399664879, -0.06337298452854156, 0.024052469059824944, 0.010378425009548664, 0.005775159224867821, 0.05355624109506607, 0.02908925898373127, 0.00825500674545765, 0.09192515164613724, -0.015487237833440304, 0.07697530835866928, 0.038880638778209686, -0.06977297365665436, -0.053624335676431656, 0.014826083555817604, -0.05992235988378525, -0.040055133402347565, -0.022807901725172997, 0.027385961264371872, 0.026358474045991898, 0.013155492953956127, -0.031001003459095955, -0.014819991774857044, 0.005149696487933397, 0.01940062642097473, 0.00278509221971035, -0.019083799794316292, -0.013868412002921104, -0.0292913019657135, -0.0301445834338665, -0.010695516131818295, -0.029315443709492683, -0.03928804397583008, 0.009580531157553196, -0.04431535303592682, -0.014450258575379848, -0.012644140049815178, -0.04637311398983002, 0.0033417632803320885, -0.021314425393939018, -0.025279389694333076, 0.05302167311310768, -0.04720719903707504, -0.030710598453879356, -0.003898527706041932, 0.06465188413858414, -0.019128747284412384, 0.024030623957514763, -0.05028340592980385, -0.016090882942080498, 0.021029697731137276, -0.018953202292323112, -0.012460161000490189, 0.011605578474700451, 0.01133826095610857, 0.034244127571582794, 0.032443054020404816, 0.02182336524128914, 0.01123493816703558, -0.03831913322210312, 0.04824772849678993, 0.030354388058185577, -0.028638632968068123, 0.0006572453421540558, 0.012583654373884201, -0.004567548632621765, 0.06942147016525269, 0.020558709278702736, -0.011983009986579418, -0.019001595675945282, 0.025690199807286263, -0.06402945518493652, -0.0010654991492629051, 0.039888422936201096, -0.010335621424019337, 0.016511492431163788, 0.01341969147324562, 0.10292086005210876, 0.006803138647228479, 0.03836295008659363, 0.052429698407649994, -0.024424955248832703, 0.01904790662229061, 0.016768041998147964, -0.03392130136489868, -0.02090882696211338, 0.03646879270672798, 0.02411925047636032, -0.036932725459337234, -0.015478278510272503, -0.04893313720822334, -0.03862219676375389, 0.0066495188511908054, 0.01117200031876564, 0.06360755860805511, 0.053122907876968384, 0.01582549512386322, -0.012443155981600285, -0.008630645461380482, 0.016635261476039886, 0.009946778416633606, 0.0540771484375, 0.012456264346837997, -0.012332849204540253, 0.036134276539087296, -0.07836402952671051, -0.02457951009273529, -0.03834090009331703, 0.011043587699532509, 0.021421823650598526, -0.010439561679959297, -0.016348235309123993, 0.039586592465639114, 0.030573077499866486, -0.032180238515138626, -0.012704926542937756, 0.06173810362815857, -0.0205994900316, -0.03264006972312927, 0.056589581072330475, 0.01888861134648323, 0.017430946230888367, -0.0029326605144888163, 0.02455071732401848, -0.017865337431430817, 0.02848607674241066, -0.0015500403242185712, 0.012830724008381367, -0.0001702948211459443, 0.03520151227712631, -0.010481621138751507, 0.005579414777457714, -0.00911362748593092, 0.058403246104717255, 0.012794998474419117, -0.02453153394162655, 0.00032181714777834713, 0.039371997117996216, 0.011280503123998642, 0.0322895310819149, 0.026362091302871704, -0.015170346945524216, 0.03247885778546333, -0.011444116942584515, 0.06668908149003983, 0.006235715467482805, -0.01204752642661333, 0.008948233909904957, -0.026188747957348824, -0.03660830482840538, 0.005695562809705734, -0.038782935589551926, -0.07513832300901413, 0.03984411805868149, 0.012867427431046963, -0.03470033407211304, -0.04149264842271805, -0.014188886620104313, -0.07316960394382477, -0.026472577825188637, -0.029661498963832855, -0.09521103650331497, 0.00003830352216027677, -0.023391887545585632, -0.011260010302066803, -0.00455110426992178, -0.037512026727199554, -0.08667321503162384, -0.027255527675151825, 0.014332029037177563, -0.08291762322187424, 0.023988986387848854, 0.008406195789575577, -0.01937858574092388, 0.02019175887107849, 0.06326410919427872, -0.06814607977867126, -0.085163414478302, 0.02928037755191326, -0.0318458154797554, 0.02803925797343254, 0.014993878081440926, -0.02024160884320736, -0.007494363933801651, -0.010761488229036331, 0.017248867079615593, 0.015928365290164948, 0.039706241339445114, -0.05183001607656479, 0.030600029975175858, 0.10051368176937103, 0.030605118721723557, 0.06477855145931244, 0.02882521040737629, 0.03261936455965042, 0.04943447187542915, -0.024411382153630257, -0.014788370579481125, -0.04679630324244499, -0.0014394945465028286, 0.02694218046963215, -0.04608822613954544, 0.0536818690598011, 0.017284229397773743 ]
<p>Laser uses mirrors to reflect photons in order to stimulate atoms to emit photons, but why this is so?. I mean, why does a photon stimulate atoms to produce more photons? If a photon made an atom to produce a photon, is not the first photon absorbed by the atom and therefore there is not total gain in the process?</p>
g5879
[ -0.019773609936237335, 0.02776685543358326, -0.007868094369769096, 0.006051871459931135, -0.00638436246663332, 0.04889765754342079, 0.04299808666110039, 0.059077538549900055, 0.008326086215674877, -0.05505310744047165, -0.0297175794839859, 0.060327377170324326, 0.05294102057814598, -0.00128479627892375, -0.03168225660920143, -0.013516709208488464, 0.0790017768740654, 0.01193698588758707, 0.007148771081119776, 0.033428385853767395, -0.07865546643733978, 0.025218859314918518, -0.04952102154493332, -0.09687067568302155, -0.04197657108306885, 0.022973185405135155, -0.006496852729469538, -0.023559952154755592, 0.004048673436045647, 0.03502742201089859, 0.032395679503679276, -0.003426165785640478, 0.00940910167992115, 0.025137614458799362, 0.04960709065198898, -0.038448456674814224, 0.031046513468027115, 0.0497734472155571, -0.012860734015703201, 0.0010043078800663352, -0.02724268287420273, -0.0052763852290809155, -0.028554320335388184, 0.010342773050069809, -0.019032564014196396, -0.048234276473522186, 0.029842155054211617, 0.0065750787034630775, 0.04088691622018814, -0.0033826828002929688, 0.018570756539702415, -0.015452240593731403, -0.029120543971657753, 0.01764063723385334, 0.06583469361066818, -0.0017104888102039695, -0.06509589403867722, -0.028595972806215286, 0.045133255422115326, -0.038640428334474564, 0.00848057959228754, -0.01106062438338995, -0.0183702502399683, 0.06975964456796646, 0.05664394423365593, -0.007200579158961773, -0.006945055443793535, -0.02109599858522415, 0.02672274224460125, 0.0271310918033123, -0.025427600368857384, -0.001023644581437111, -0.025816960260272026, 0.0010050719138234854, 0.04617767035961151, -0.011345090344548225, 0.03918648883700371, 0.015161324292421341, -0.018621625378727913, 0.021779103204607964, 0.01348088402301073, -0.04112166166305542, 0.002289582509547472, 0.01312312763184309, 0.025100845843553543, 0.040184326469898224, -0.049454428255558014, -0.0378798209130764, 0.02609369531273842, 0.025184916332364082, 0.08375146239995956, 0.05811096355319023, 0.09075573831796646, 0.03798827901482582, -0.05995534732937813, -0.04964464157819748, -0.009233759716153145, 0.007533361203968525, -0.005043191835284233, 0.031177973374724388, -0.015790147706866264, 0.007256701588630676, 0.045679591596126556, 0.0073325010016560555, 0.040413081645965576, -0.008680760860443115, -0.020670274272561073, -0.0060482085682451725, -0.0309594813734293, 0.0032185695599764585, -0.022748036310076714, -0.004265701863914728, -0.0347215011715889, -0.02926613762974739, -0.05286702513694763, -0.016064118593931198, 0.08152507990598679, 0.009155252017080784, -0.004404270555824041, 0.09047441929578781, 0.0551823191344738, -0.009057390503585339, -0.0315248966217041, 0.0041848779655992985, -0.00517862057313323, 0.03299723565578461, 0.020086681470274925, 0.006424448918551207, 0.006872148253023624, -0.008587118238210678, -0.017884641885757446, 0.0368875190615654, -0.05801671743392944, 0.0340852215886116, 0.060787633061409, 0.04076247662305832, -0.0460985042154789, -0.0046278610825538635, 0.013828281313180923, 0.006983124651014805, 0.022981049492955208, 0.021763941273093224, -0.03574584424495697, -0.03489675000309944, -0.028235740959644318, 0.009205716662108898, -0.02537049725651741, 0.03997695446014404, 0.008073904551565647, 0.03616339713335037, 0.017106667160987854, 0.04899824783205986, 0.0784524455666542, -0.02413267455995083, 0.03499050438404083, -0.04244820401072502, 0.031059443950653076, -0.07175751030445099, -0.010392383672297001, 0.03323729336261749, 0.0809919610619545, 0.012202534824609756, -0.0554666742682457, -0.02915218286216259, -0.0430833101272583, 0.03549487516283989, 0.025154657661914825, -0.07944891601800919, -0.0362681970000267, 0.007821033708751202, -0.002111674752086401, 0.032382868230342865, -0.026168132200837135, -0.025723516941070557, 0.036987852305173874, 0.021892227232456207, 0.054931893944740295, -0.006645062938332558, 0.01335497573018074, 0.007623858284205198, -0.03109390288591385, -0.05710046738386154, -0.02215868979692459, -0.049033232033252716, -0.007330181542783976, -0.027234025299549103, -0.05343891680240631, -0.04109777510166168, -0.040589723736047745, 0.02817692421376705, 0.01882336288690567, -0.0325908437371254, 0.015466727316379547, -0.019989725202322006, -0.017116885632276535, -0.025134088471531868, 0.00652138190343976, -0.04587603732943535, -0.0022025436628609896, 0.05848563089966774, -0.03589886426925659, 0.025910213589668274, -0.05531920865178108, -0.05118648707866669, -0.008875655010342598, 0.030206412076950073, -0.027202265337109566, -0.01700611039996147, -0.01730913668870926, 0.0006675622425973415, -0.029113132506608963, -0.02470305562019348, 0.04168698564171791, -0.03289617598056793, 0.013823787681758404, -0.0006290125893428922, -0.04343903809785843, -0.017911002039909363, 0.024783778935670853, -0.007230130955576897, -0.01116392482072115, -0.0006020648288540542, 0.03375852480530739, -0.030736342072486877, -0.04006250202655792, 0.02187442034482956, -0.07327526062726974, 0.013976302929222584, 0.005176665727049112, 0.05587878078222275, 0.012763777747750282, -0.013699951581656933, -0.04009564593434334, -0.06938694417476654, 0.05456351488828659, -0.03855479881167412, -0.014378249645233154, 0.06781702488660812, 0.007483478635549545, 0.003111530328169465, -0.0026236155536025763, -0.07375093549489975, -0.03857588768005371, -0.024269532412290573, -0.053442854434251785, -0.08293652534484863, -0.03004341386258602, -0.013205485418438911, -0.02943240851163864, -0.05746980756521225, 0.03519430011510849, 0.015990236774086952, 0.016741450875997543, -0.06420714408159256, 0.003225109539926052, -0.03996749222278595, 0.02162712998688221, 0.04477677494287491, -0.03581201285123825, -0.020206816494464874, -0.0026289757806807756, -0.0409376285970211, -0.03454650565981865, -0.04012293368577957, -0.03192628175020218, 0.015736853703856468, -0.03312596678733826, -0.022044166922569275, 0.025066448375582695, 0.007257524877786636, -0.04021283984184265, 0.07741230726242065, 0.036029793322086334, -0.011349586769938469, 0.009481683373451233, 0.01383377518504858, 0.008013596758246422, -0.036792028695344925, 0.07848802953958511, -0.06805837899446487, -0.041727565228939056, -0.0037496222648769617, -0.05050702393054962, -0.03901509940624237, 0.023978618904948235, -0.06650407612323761, 0.035901494324207306, -0.020585086196660995, 0.004943686071783304, -0.005330345593392849, -0.03149103745818138, 0.024167140945792198, 0.0018041807925328612, -0.011771618388593197, -0.03644073009490967, 0.010484102182090282, 0.05515722185373306, -0.004369865637272596, 0.0047605703584849834, 0.07494421303272247, -0.00545953493565321, -0.012525530532002449, 0.006343176122754812, -0.009191188029944897, 0.030248306691646576, 0.03113466314971447, -0.011601664125919342, -0.029477622359991074, -0.006477829068899155, 0.057051368057727814, -0.0032051573507487774, 0.02448955923318863, -0.02660277485847473, 0.01496770977973938, -0.04278611019253731, 0.012942568399012089, -0.020244697108864784, -0.008139999583363533, 0.03845054656267166, -0.004210858140140772, -0.052665576338768005, 0.02990926429629326, 0.02306663990020752, -0.06200506538152695, 0.04439390450716019, 0.022357426583766937, 0.014903326518833637, -0.04712112247943878, 0.0011652893153950572, -0.036273643374443054, 0.034916218370199203, 0.002364471787586808, -0.07385976612567902, 0.04141315817832947, 0.01192192267626524, -0.055713362991809845, -0.03996651619672775, -0.005886012222617865, -0.0446205697953701, 0.021635841578245163, 0.008971625939011574, -0.015636077150702477, -0.08722171932458878, -0.019575007259845734, 0.06464073807001114, 0.01682097092270851, -0.05288273096084595, 0.009867100045084953, -0.004502414725720882, 0.0031356005929410458, 0.048458974808454514, 0.029661167412996292, -0.00868617556989193, -0.02600010111927986, -0.035370513796806335, 0.0631236657500267, 0.02459210343658924, 0.016991404816508293, 0.018963133916258812, -0.03488999232649803, 0.0008861591340973973, 0.008819691836833954, -0.0006266993004828691, -0.039798811078071594, -0.03125738352537155, 0.03772994875907898, 0.01911924034357071, -0.01054505817592144, 0.04256507009267807, 0.06479930877685547, 0.0018813427304849029, -0.018428990617394447, 0.0235130712389946, -0.058885011821985245, -0.01653134636580944, -0.014189934358000755, 0.05665731057524681, 0.009645514190196991, -0.04297567531466484, 0.002886795438826084, 0.0036356893833726645, 0.0305265374481678, 0.007229110226035118, 0.026625962927937508, 0.01650340110063553, 0.014605577103793621, -0.017841316759586334, -0.039187200367450714, -0.024583660066127777, -0.03444019332528114, 0.039210472255945206, -0.0172423142939806, -0.02505221962928772, -0.01905803196132183, 0.0002688637177925557, 0.009918340481817722, 0.02036287635564804, -0.028547709807753563, 0.0317353829741478, 0.0037375842221081257, 0.020040297880768776, 0.02586989663541317, 0.0024364537093788385, -0.012325668707489967, -0.024392398074269295, 0.039848342537879944, 0.060170453041791916, -0.011914649978280067, -0.018412679433822632, -0.009835638105869293, -0.014380580745637417, 0.018322449177503586, 0.0015495193656533957, -0.019724328070878983, 0.0009318197262473404, 0.028088610619306564, 0.030922433361411095, -0.022855332121253014, 0.04305844008922577, 0.00827841553837061, -0.06435540318489075, 0.00464649498462677, 0.07431750744581223, 0.03696132451295853, 0.05380623787641525, 0.08255260437726974, 0.03588816151022911, 0.012534883804619312, 0.013352793641388416, -0.05516368895769119, 0.019029464572668076, 0.0100861806422472, -0.011429205536842346, -0.011597617529332638, 0.023399604484438896, 0.04410954564809799, 0.026553703472018242, 0.044212885200977325, 0.026304859668016434, 0.03081958182156086, 0.1112186461687088, 0.003541617188602686, 0.020579202100634575, 0.031168615445494652, 0.031586065888404846, -0.013803265988826752, -0.056654833257198334, -0.05077628046274185, -0.08152475953102112, -0.0028393748216331005, -0.0027794851921498775, -0.004098026547580957, -0.014056014828383923, -0.03307901322841644, -0.002223462797701359, 0.027581116184592247, -0.035133302211761475, 0.06746510416269302, 0.02145574241876602, 0.09542569518089294, -0.021591361612081528, -0.016015365719795227, 0.03727569803595543, -0.012918384745717049, 0.033923812210559845, -0.012212499044835567, -0.008138192817568779, 0.02366580441594124, -0.0329957939684391, -0.022613463923335075, 0.028814444318413734, 0.0346856415271759, 0.021585147827863693, 0.07553713768720627, 0.05711453780531883, -0.06057414039969444, -0.003781725652515888, -0.017400618642568588, -0.0009246707195416093, -0.026623902842402458, 0.028041372075676918, -0.005710597150027752, 0.021638253703713417, -0.018632149323821068, -0.0564754419028759, -0.03759502246975899, -0.050164639949798584, -0.018784746527671814, -0.007257604040205479, -0.06650841981172562, -0.014278460294008255, 0.000320531107718125, -0.02339925989508629, -0.06851468980312347, -0.014022734016180038, 0.04195902496576309, -0.013618228957057, -0.006640263367444277, 0.02978694811463356, 0.040186431258916855, -0.04624424874782562, 0.02019694074988365, -0.061940595507621765, -0.0461370013654232, -0.016239726915955544, -0.0509185716509819, 0.00603784853592515, -0.003857686650007963, 0.026888959109783173, 0.015754777938127518, -0.018972188234329224, -0.06305978447198868, -0.024377495050430298, -0.03726048022508621, 0.05114039406180382, -0.03738680109381676, 0.03471331298351288, 0.02406727522611618, 0.0089041693136096, 0.026496488600969315, -0.0015258886851370335, -0.011119901202619076, 0.04427063465118408, -0.03132931515574455, 0.03910302743315697, 0.038739316165447235, 0.0104396166279912, 0.007320262026041746, -0.04516497999429703, -0.014638387598097324, 0.049496233463287354, 0.05167516693472862, 0.0396500788629055, -0.014936461113393307, 0.017795680090785027, 0.022758515551686287, 0.023242484778165817, 0.03870465233922005, -0.005527470260858536, -0.03688260167837143, -0.03967181220650673, -0.05187883973121643, -0.0030122220050543547, 0.03022625856101513, 0.06837036460638046, -0.013687368482351303, 0.04335921257734299, -0.00180557940620929, -0.014407698065042496, -0.004842220339924097, 0.05641669034957886, -0.03711353987455368, 0.03558957949280739, -0.044634003192186356, 0.015654562041163445, 0.027206584811210632, -0.03235231712460518, 0.026762910187244415, 0.02792270854115486, -0.06994034349918365, 0.021531525999307632, 0.059213850647211075, -0.010916078463196754, -0.039334286004304886, 0.011640367098152637, -0.03176000341773033, 0.013342157937586308, 0.002000036183744669, -0.00746739050373435, 0.02205182984471321, 0.008952907286584377, 0.04207869991660118, -0.016740785911679268, -0.008268443867564201, -0.008529367856681347, 0.05991879478096962, 0.004817797802388668, -0.06204411759972572, -0.03557993844151497, -0.005548122338950634, 0.04822023585438728, -0.03013465367257595, -0.045493315905332565, -0.032952431589365005, -0.007810421288013458, -0.04809634014964104, -0.03397563844919205, 0.040688008069992065, 0.002140480326488614, 0.0058905151672661304, -0.03650861606001854, 0.00006815529195591807, 0.010386013425886631, -0.06403874605894089, 0.026053234934806824, -0.08346550911664963, -0.036253150552511215, 0.021461838856339455, 0.019263070076704025, -0.01637876033782959, 0.04033210501074791, -0.008269472979009151, 0.02183300070464611, 0.018658099696040154, -0.006303595378994942, 0.0071030245162546635, 0.008297070860862732, -0.01718805730342865, 0.047852952033281326, 0.07535746693611145, 0.006054555531591177, 0.026205891743302345, -0.004185589030385017, 0.018290013074874878, -0.035884637385606766, -0.037187360227108, -0.014593198895454407, 0.020479219034314156, 0.02310800924897194, -0.026100365445017815, 0.036855634301900864, -0.04836856946349144, 0.06263315677642822, 0.024241384118795395, 0.04821683093905449, 0.05237552896142006, -0.03698926419019699, 0.0943031832575798, 0.04873145371675491, 0.04477380961179733, -0.03048151545226574, 0.009653331711888313, -0.04134488105773926, 0.04920127987861633, -0.020220346748828888, 0.038602571934461594, -0.04761822894215584, -0.00429318705573678, 0.007024828344583511, -0.014911484904587269, -0.04789423570036888, 0.0011435577180236578, 0.017580479383468628, 0.04025169461965561, -0.012302625924348831, 0.09210850298404694, -0.00747285271063447, -0.011664817109704018, -0.08478065580129623, 0.04529685899615288, -0.07446419447660446, -0.0029641585424542427, -0.028598109260201454, -0.016763215884566307, 0.017831001430749893, 0.00562136247754097, -0.045259468257427216, 0.06085701286792755, 0.013244704343378544, -0.0540790930390358, -0.018888259306550026, -0.010294816456735134, -0.06588104367256165, -0.019396668300032616, 0.07109740376472473, 0.014524249359965324, 0.03320770710706711, -0.0043448214419186115, 0.00034200074151158333, 0.006617582403123379, -0.0016559615032747388, -0.09467007964849472, 0.017849326133728027, 0.032018356025218964, -0.008779298514127731, -0.016895873472094536, -0.010089091025292873, 0.056712839752435684, -0.009569365531206131, -0.032106898725032806, -0.07028371840715408, 0.026179952546954155, 0.0298706516623497, -0.05787824094295502, -0.02059433050453663, 0.04237838089466095, -0.01925426721572876, -0.013698508031666279, -0.0022786296904087067, -0.09967833012342453, -0.02302469313144684, -0.02054862678050995, 0.016163688153028488, 0.02724914625287056, -0.02891518361866474, 0.021979598328471184, 0.04235302656888962, 0.015558408573269844, -0.051025137305259705, -0.009755653329193592, -0.033811312168836594, -0.05273578315973282, -0.011438608169555664, -0.03204592689871788, 0.010070926509797573, 0.010061121545732021, 0.05227604880928993, 0.018414949998259544, 0.05434859171509743, -0.04948151111602783, -0.02943372167646885, 0.0014858690556138754, 0.03937351331114769, 0.061199937015771866, -0.014538452960550785, -0.022014517337083817, -0.014473119750618935, 0.05089092627167702, -0.0050652544014155865, -0.004971651826053858, 0.028200799599289894, 0.001962449634447694, -0.03957159072160721, -0.03683796525001526, -0.04120609164237976, 0.0005287063540890813, 0.04858390614390373, -0.07598571479320526, 0.00955569464713335, 0.012759950943291187, 0.04090580344200134, 0.06048570200800896, -0.0358746275305748, -0.03239820897579193, 0.001878425246104598, -0.025305597111582756, 0.07386750727891922, -0.009633499197661877, 0.03905605524778366, 0.031749796122312546, 0.023528259247541428, -0.041488125920295715, 0.016530482098460197, -0.025683550164103508, 0.005141828674823046, -0.01991693675518036, -0.06967128068208694, 0.005095432512462139, 0.029416026547551155, -0.009374966844916344, -0.06505101174116135, 0.044737718999385834, 0.01686444878578186, 0.04365169256925583, 0.11293230205774307, 0.005064707249403, 0.006487630773335695, 0.07305070012807846, -0.0048767817206680775, -0.03819962218403816, -0.015277006663382053, 0.038820765912532806, 0.006742427125573158, -0.02961323782801628, -0.02060812897980213, -0.014123409055173397, -0.017495915293693542, -0.049877919256687164 ]
<p>This paper was posted to arxiv a couple of weeks ago: <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1309.1067" rel="nofollow">http://arxiv.org/abs/1309.1067</a></p> <p>From the abstract:</p> <blockquote> <p>The effects of Wheeler's quantum foam on black hole growth are explored from an astrophysical perspective. Quantum fluctuations in the form of mini (10^-5 g) black holes can couple to macroscopic black holes and allow the latter to grow exponentially in mass on a time scale of ~10^9 years. Consequently, supermassive black holes can acquire a lot of their mass through these quantum contributions over the life time of the universe.</p> </blockquote> <p>Is this paper at all believable? The thing that immediately bothers me about it is energy conservation. He doesn't have a real theory of quantum gravity, so this is some kind of semiclassical argument based on two theories: GR and quantum mechanics. GR has conservation of (mass-)energy in an asymptotically flat spacetime. Quantum mechanics has conservation of energy. So how can he put these ingredients together to get a prediction that seems to violate conservation of energy?</p> <p>He says,</p> <blockquote> <p>These mini BHs acquire their mass from the huge Planckian vacuum energy and not the BH itself.</p> </blockquote> <p>I don't see how this gives him a free pass on conservation of energy. The vacuum's energy should be a function of its state, and its state isn't undergoing some monotonic change over time.</p>
g5880
[ 0.03767020255327225, 0.0072066159918904305, 0.01658773049712181, -0.009984409436583519, 0.01855596899986267, 0.028046458959579468, 0.015769723802804947, 0.026202281937003136, -0.034087445586919785, -0.02812686748802662, 0.02612127549946308, -0.029981572180986404, 0.015580679289996624, 0.06163693964481354, -0.007751884870231152, 0.0004749972140416503, 0.03272132948040962, -0.032198309898376465, -0.014586446806788445, -0.01604202762246132, 0.017962275072932243, -0.0194968581199646, -0.007826469838619232, -0.006276173051446676, -0.0002664476924110204, 0.008903906680643559, 0.06367439776659012, -0.02032320201396942, -0.0010213095229119062, -0.0035608378238976, 0.03826881945133209, 0.03376731276512146, 0.05100088566541672, -0.026896964758634567, -0.03488089516758919, -0.011613515205681324, 0.016304777935147285, 0.048057671636343, 0.02330680377781391, -0.03641515225172043, 0.03767891973257065, -0.0015719273360446095, 0.004968728870153427, -0.015556965954601765, -0.030680382624268532, 0.006059965118765831, 0.0235284473747015, 0.01499313022941351, 0.03985148295760155, 0.016953395679593086, 0.04624316468834877, 0.007949606515467167, 0.08628079295158386, 0.03233225271105766, 0.02234387770295143, 0.026471294462680817, 0.01202340330928564, -0.04824528098106384, 0.027726853266358376, 0.0049689291045069695, 0.009028621949255466, -0.03546445071697235, 0.03270629048347473, 0.05768285691738129, 0.05310678109526634, -0.011293933726847172, -0.03951120749115944, -0.055494751781225204, -0.03228705748915672, 0.02109411545097828, 0.012453368864953518, 0.009837232530117035, 0.005803097039461136, 0.011459589935839176, 0.0031565874814987183, 0.0820498988032341, -0.006317447405308485, 0.03314964473247528, -0.009653338231146336, 0.025100447237491608, -0.04145205393433571, -0.009785674512386322, 0.01992933638393879, 0.028333067893981934, 0.0481998510658741, -0.01395486481487751, -0.02565770037472248, -0.029870182275772095, -0.04544434696435928, 0.02776292711496353, 0.04720858857035637, -0.014545533806085587, 0.03268260881304741, -0.02352229692041874, 0.006536388769745827, 0.039130911231040955, -0.019798213616013527, 0.033778443932533264, -0.03116886503994465, 0.017859894782304764, -0.060805466026067734, 0.03679940849542618, 0.010003229603171349, -0.0022585440892726183, 0.02491750754415989, 0.011493186466395855, -0.050186820328235626, 0.04581889510154724, 0.037600066512823105, 0.01783512718975544, -0.003068092744797468, -0.08029366284608841, -0.054778147488832474, -0.06058008223772049, -0.07579755783081055, -0.031822320073843, 0.01771507039666176, -0.018729453906416893, 0.005797359626740217, 0.01092299073934555, -0.02039901539683342, 0.017741704359650612, 0.031480953097343445, -0.011001570150256157, -0.040759630501270294, -0.07098772376775742, -0.034938517957925797, -0.01620209403336048, 0.01066599227488041, -0.016745546832680702, 0.013728497549891472, 0.0003966063086409122, 0.019685514271259308, 0.021761566400527954, -0.006602082401514053, 0.03222102299332619, -0.040335576981306076, 0.007411427795886993, -0.021468743681907654, 0.014696693047881126, -0.045602310448884964, -0.007402059622108936, 0.009727857075631618, 0.012970956042408943, 0.034970734268426895, -0.00948284100741148, -0.0019375806441530585, -0.019281204789876938, 0.027983346953988075, 0.03766648843884468, 0.025649789720773697, 0.08308619260787964, -0.04918263480067253, -0.042372629046440125, 0.055965691804885864, 0.09030002355575562, 0.02030148357152939, -0.02573973871767521, -0.048630110919475555, 0.021840598434209824, 0.0675719827413559, -0.03263350576162338, 0.05062822252511978, 0.04566306248307228, -0.00655678566545248, 0.01872497797012329, 0.018139293417334557, -0.08089708536863327, -0.03217160701751709, -0.008218283765017986, 0.0029653459787368774, 0.043748121708631516, 0.012876726686954498, 0.06050582602620125, 0.006695466581732035, 0.03845934569835663, 0.028834130614995956, -0.059344079345464706, -0.00005327769395080395, -0.01287953183054924, -0.0015904429601505399, -0.06451337784528732, 0.02854357846081257, -0.012075705453753471, 0.04599669948220253, 0.023024635389447212, 0.08439132571220398, 0.011295240372419357, -0.0056883846409618855, 0.007377482485026121, -0.07383423298597336, 0.03700951486825943, -0.003713937010616064, 0.018697619438171387, 0.014850107952952385, 0.06013534590601921, 0.02255605347454548, -0.04731005057692528, 0.0008797331829555333, 0.03176645562052727, -0.07626445591449738, 0.04081781581044197, 0.04527207836508751, 0.007037913426756859, 0.039792176336050034, -0.01472780667245388, -0.008651797659695148, -0.0015808423049747944, -0.020708667114377022, -0.050702374428510666, 0.01644096150994301, 0.0016176414210349321, -0.016922445967793465, 0.01678897812962532, -0.027831323444843292, 0.014134473167359829, 0.004323221277445555, 0.021764572709798813, -0.005986352916806936, 0.0091337775811553, -0.034969594329595566, -0.006421142257750034, 0.04685478284955025, -0.015688246116042137, -0.03826616331934929, 0.008148101158440113, -0.014885466545820236, -0.06887299567461014, -0.0525892972946167, 0.029850909486413002, -0.04043743759393692, 0.027371732518076897, 0.03471960127353668, 0.023764751851558685, 0.020045068114995956, 0.07156474888324738, -0.009818360209465027, -0.007049404084682465, 0.010486867278814316, 0.014425634406507015, 0.044398367404937744, 0.012068342417478561, -0.06206931173801422, -0.04691135510802269, 0.030039990320801735, -0.01917658932507038, 0.00048261170741170645, -0.006249947007745504, -0.03004235029220581, 0.013874491676688194, 0.05233845114707947, 0.00854055117815733, 0.013570461422204971, -0.01114123035222292, 0.020123669877648354, -0.014654682949185371, 0.006093185395002365, -0.026383956894278526, -0.02281428873538971, 0.022498946636915207, 0.061325158923864365, -0.01556816603988409, 0.02020048350095749, -0.0009585109655745327, -0.031400274485349655, -0.05376628413796425, -0.035024236887693405, -0.011407159268856049, -0.06194218993186951, 0.0008452124893665314, -0.003131100907921791, 0.03969720005989075, 0.05109162628650665, 0.04526326060295105, -0.016829565167427063, 0.02660360001027584, -0.024721214547753334, 0.008192350156605244, 0.056859340518713, -0.007162642199546099, -0.08691991865634918, -0.013571887277066708, -0.03260795772075653, -0.020087383687496185, 0.04081827402114868, -0.043221451342105865, 0.0035768216475844383, 0.010922458954155445, 0.0059783924371004105, 0.003742927685379982, -0.007680434733629227, 0.05130816623568535, 0.00468018651008606, 0.05955749750137329, 0.009183111600577831, 0.0876520499587059, -0.0018817412201315165, 0.008901706896722317, -0.047602955251932144, 0.016629263758659363, 0.04999089241027832, -0.009288390167057514, -0.0243008341640234, 0.04887428507208824, 0.013454651460051537, 0.036954015493392944, -0.019656451418995857, -0.01740865968167782, 0.007837529294192791, -0.04105720296502113, 0.04236522316932678, 0.013370536267757416, 0.024650683626532555, 0.026349037885665894, -0.03669340908527374, -0.03893958404660225, -0.012835689820349216, -0.03428524732589722, -0.0004274206003174186, -0.03096768446266651, 0.00023394651361741126, 0.036907490342855453, 0.016881274059414864, -0.02084910310804844, 0.011946387588977814, 0.06845415383577347, -0.06697456538677216, -0.03643970191478729, -0.04155867546796799, 0.022793615236878395, 0.023314587771892548, -0.02484375238418579, 0.00891096517443657, -0.01693575643002987, -0.026560116559267044, -0.0606561079621315, -0.009004488587379456, -0.01589556783437729, -0.005931828636676073, -0.02166847698390484, -0.029170358553528786, -0.025524385273456573, 0.015145647339522839, 0.045560333877801895, -0.01556471735239029, 0.035331133753061295, -0.005079307127743959, -0.04617892950773239, -0.010732799768447876, 0.007465632166713476, 0.006419844459742308, -0.015391789376735687, 0.053399257361888885, 0.0037174203898757696, -0.0013449646066874266, 0.06029028818011284, -0.018558671697974205, 0.0030846670269966125, 0.08596586436033249, -0.02718581072986126, -0.05049487203359604, 0.01320806797593832, 0.05525171011686325, 0.004264255985617638, -0.020865051075816154, -0.024606972932815552, -0.009854475036263466, -0.0060248360969126225, 0.03833089768886566, 0.0024455487728118896, -0.017569338902831078, 0.008388861082494259, -0.019768372178077698, 0.018468160182237625, 0.030232500284910202, -0.0600212998688221, 0.05592102184891701, -0.008685908280313015, -0.004676446318626404, 0.0001517126802355051, 0.025621604174375534, 0.0023908375296741724, 0.0151438033208251, -0.004579734522849321, -0.04054364189505577, 0.014094583690166473, -0.02857196144759655, -0.022699683904647827, 0.06445468217134476, -0.003685456234961748, -0.002114570699632168, -0.00471284706145525, -0.00957569945603609, -0.07132355868816376, -0.0015793228521943092, 0.04652963951230049, 0.06507335603237152, -0.023518508300185204, 0.003621641080826521, 0.01440372783690691, 0.004599002655595541, 0.03387372940778732, -0.018921034410595894, 0.00821658130735159, -0.003547393251210451, 0.04269007593393326, 0.0055558159947395325, -0.004103292245417833, -0.0013180110836401582, -0.05788373202085495, 0.06543988734483719, -0.008989698253571987, -0.026607822626829147, -0.030884886160492897, 0.04035494849085808, -0.03978355973958969, 0.02822325937449932, -0.024725712835788727, 0.06364557892084122, 0.028265099972486496, 0.007458491716533899, -0.03697003796696663, -0.015380028635263443, 0.03644159808754921, 0.03097020648419857, 0.0015977165894582868, -0.04778284206986427, 0.001989958342164755, -0.010076094418764114, -0.019567085430026054, 0.08233564347028732, 0.0017313631251454353, -0.009572265669703484, 0.042079851031303406, -0.0756910890340805, 0.06964702159166336, -0.04355353116989136, -0.006356376223266125, -0.0063029187731444836, 0.03306657448410988, 0.12548816204071045, -0.017523931339383125, 0.00026475911727175117, -0.021335838362574577, 0.04806974530220032, 0.015689317137002945, -0.04924009367823601, 0.0015446472680196166, 0.02171233855187893, -0.03605694696307182, 0.0036828273441642523, -0.006631292402744293, 0.08100507408380508, -0.07165925949811935, -0.00402403948828578, -0.030084608122706413, -0.002282271161675453, 0.03271663933992386, 0.07950049638748169, 0.03863558545708656, -0.05690586194396019, 0.005853680428117514, 0.05318666994571686, 0.03725505992770195, 0.01137948501855135, -0.03512364253401756, -0.06436658650636673, -0.011140850372612476, -0.03239157050848007, -0.01132932584732771, -0.04856949672102928, 0.010975643061101437, 0.005031475331634283, -0.01717602089047432, -0.0576506108045578, 0.002503827679902315, -0.044609393924474716, -0.0343330055475235, 0.013159756548702717, 0.005618472583591938, 0.0035956460051238537, 0.01497124508023262, 0.06214291602373123, 0.035576365888118744, 0.03897466883063316, 0.056942809373140335, -0.02495790831744671, 0.012698515318334103, -0.031194675713777542, -0.022680073976516724, -0.0023540144320577383, 0.020368190482258797, -0.014416123740375042, 0.07150810956954956, 0.025645218789577484, 0.0019832735415548086, 0.029791833832859993, -0.030709337443113327, 0.006878362502902746, -0.01950926147401333, -0.05601787194609642, 0.004184491001069546, 0.009750837460160255, -0.0009563411585986614, -0.02990141324698925, 0.018370283767580986, 0.026272408664226532, 0.010832407511770725, 0.026171347126364708, 0.05387675389647484, -0.05307043343782425, 0.04314163327217102, 0.00268527097068727, 0.028569230809807777, 0.055929794907569885, -0.09871277958154678, 0.008506490848958492, 0.01841939426958561, 0.014780593104660511, -0.008151455782353878, 0.006195917259901762, -0.00464658671990037, 0.006565228570252657, 0.02826746180653572, 0.08208156377077103, 0.06427121162414551, -0.07415319979190826, -0.04919431358575821, 0.02449081651866436, 0.03219661861658096, 0.016016801819205284, -0.0536935031414032, 0.059617530554533005, 0.006265228148549795, 0.022628411650657654, 0.047868762165308, 0.0053830076940357685, 0.005845355801284313, 0.04374797269701958, -0.03687674552202225, 0.005630304105579853, 0.007027292158454657, -0.018411453813314438, 0.023711955174803734, 0.04657824710011482, 0.01041917223483324, -0.07970337569713593, 0.024849290028214455, 0.009888430126011372, -0.04826904833316803, -0.0594811737537384, 0.005977869965136051, -0.0034811850637197495, 0.021375859156250954, -0.016512123867869377, 0.006447996012866497, 0.02953459322452545, -0.09027376770973206, -0.012969529256224632, -0.013028272427618504, -0.005316181108355522, 0.058019187301397324, 0.025750117376446724, 0.011216046288609505, 0.05510411038994789, -0.010508209466934204, 0.04200373589992523, -0.05828893557190895, 0.007437567226588726, -0.01961887814104557, -0.045683495700359344, 0.048089850693941116, -0.00870767142623663, -0.02664809674024582, -0.05869358405470848, -0.0638626292347908, 0.007474738638848066, -0.012844622135162354, -0.05790013447403908, -0.040634699165821075, -0.020241737365722656, -0.04377254098653793, 0.06242816150188446, -0.0806279331445694, 0.06100340932607651, -0.02703750506043434, -0.03811156749725342, -0.0015074893599376082, 0.0406271331012249, 0.01827375218272209, -0.020840154960751534, -0.010856544598937035, 0.008722342550754547, -0.009477023966610432, -0.012596013955771923, -0.058502212166786194, -0.027460014447569847, -0.03879276290535927, -0.06526612490415573, -0.10164319723844528, -0.042907554656267166, 0.03784412145614624, -0.038999274373054504, 0.003771893447265029, -0.0016827723011374474, -0.012693767435848713, -0.06033311411738396, 0.031935758888721466, 0.040813881903886795, 0.012757287360727787, -0.03676670789718628, 0.03513770177960396, -0.011487647891044617, -0.02817157842218876, 0.006936943158507347, -0.04241933301091194, 0.023361198604106903, 0.034875091165304184, 0.008651748299598694, -0.02403677999973297, 0.03856019675731659, 0.028547313064336777, 0.015369444154202938, -0.026545103639364243, 0.03891882672905922, 0.003366251941770315, -0.0647490918636322, 0.014466776512563229, 0.0006982294726185501, -0.0028312301728874445, -0.026154225692152977, 0.010430539026856422, -0.032494090497493744, 0.06733241677284241, 0.009430480189621449, 0.03140334412455559, -0.06779034435749054, -0.026287788525223732, -0.010518933646380901, -0.07054408639669418, -0.04750845953822136, -0.010759556666016579, 0.04191996529698372, 0.05831863358616829, -0.03632581606507301, 0.02628123015165329, 0.024732746183872223, 0.07783111929893494, -0.025060424581170082, -0.028767414391040802, 0.0270485021173954, 0.019974922761321068, -0.06209723278880119, -0.047300681471824646, -0.04871842637658119, 0.01005503162741661, -0.06688310205936432, -0.04252846911549568, 0.04405719041824341, -0.06948217749595642, 0.009643680416047573, -0.07274822145700455, 0.01768953539431095, -0.024783965200185776, 0.03475043922662735, 0.01503891684114933, 0.015371503308415413, -0.04816674441099167, 0.036878619343042374, -0.011671237647533417, -0.03330977261066437, -0.0609540231525898, -0.06895697861909866, -0.002813499653711915, -0.05545620247721672, -0.0871400535106659, 0.0055280327796936035, 0.020167842507362366, 0.008259137161076069, 0.029850192368030548, 0.06139067932963371, -0.017607567831873894, -0.04688367620110512, 0.010714982636272907, 0.01046718843281269, 0.050937470048666, -0.007598472759127617, 0.040547359734773636, 0.008751661516726017, 0.02336050383746624, -0.023861242458224297, 0.007662613410502672, 0.00664938660338521, 0.038518622517585754, 0.0064224014058709145, 0.0072523318231105804, 0.010769552551209927, 0.007352543529123068, 0.017191758379340172, -0.011916548945009708, -0.04688321426510811, 0.015228955075144768, -0.0001874294102890417, -0.04879671707749367, 0.04461962729692459, 0.07419974356889725, 0.017960689961910248, -0.05556488409638405, -0.02655212953686714, 0.019638948142528534, 0.07134869694709778, -0.03932936117053032, -0.01633264869451523, 0.021620603278279305, 0.0724155381321907, -0.053285762667655945, 0.002905702916905284, -0.03616590052843094, -0.011547945439815521, -0.09337067604064941, -0.01163589209318161, -0.008232572115957737, -0.06570730358362198, -0.08532477170228958, 0.009501845575869083, -0.051804397255182266, -0.0025935552548617125, -0.0027855336666107178, -0.06425394117832184, 0.03339608386158943, -0.09204525500535965, -0.06940898299217224, -0.033172015100717545, -0.04358775541186333, 0.02539924345910549, 0.013705059885978699, 0.007720904890447855, 0.0063645499758422375, 0.023106353357434273, -0.006633060518652201, -0.023897893726825714, -0.04458706080913544, 0.022848663851618767, -0.02076311595737934, 0.020233942195773125, -0.04854137822985649, -0.06222592666745186, -0.0035588443279266357, 0.011783076450228691, 0.055682577192783356, 0.029997389763593674, 0.013499134220182896, -0.05123584717512131, 0.02465430274605751, 0.02873264253139496, -0.024166887626051903, -0.0014274647692218423, -0.02141430415213108, 0.01149771362543106, -0.0005726295057684183, -0.02141662873327732, -0.003831926267594099, 0.004258974455296993, -0.06869697570800781, -0.016034282743930817, -0.05300399661064148, 0.08462576568126678, 0.03299379348754883 ]
<p>I need to do phase reconstruction from time series data. In doing so, I encountered <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Takens%27_theorem?" rel="nofollow">Takens' embedding theorem</a> and Cao's minimum embedding dimension $d$ by nearest neighbor method. In paper "Optimal Embeddings of Chaotic Attractors from Topological Considerations" by Liebert et al., 1991, says that minimum embedding dimension for reconstruction should be less than $2m+1$. This confused me since I am aware of Whitney's embedding dimension which stated $d=2*m$ where $m$ is the fractal dimension. Then there is Kennel's method of false nearest neighbor. Can somebody please explain to me: </p> <ol> <li>What are the techniques for calculating embedding dimension?</li> <li>Difference between embedding dimension and correlation dimension?</li> <li>What is the technique of proving that a system has finite dimensionality after the signal passes through a filter?</li> <li>Can somebody tell me what is the formula for embedding dimension <ul> <li>should it be Cao's method or Kennel's false nearest neighbor method.</li> </ul></li> </ol>
g5881
[ 0.021747952327132225, 0.022375375032424927, 0.012904114089906216, -0.0277345459908247, -0.028496218845248222, 0.026804106310009956, 0.024556461721658707, -0.003812971990555525, -0.052241869270801544, -0.02685556560754776, -0.030820293352007866, -0.0032887340057641268, 0.020337773486971855, 0.049153875559568405, -0.012024898082017899, -0.0012882528826594353, 0.041411928832530975, 0.005775280762463808, -0.039112307131290436, 0.03257693722844124, 0.04426040127873421, 0.00523824617266655, 0.0339004248380661, -0.02929876558482647, 0.015872357413172722, -0.0014160617720335722, 0.056232839822769165, -0.018157562240958214, -0.013492807745933533, -0.022647323086857796, 0.058272313326597214, 0.010551259852945805, -0.012373026460409164, -0.04877537488937378, 0.00017013355682138354, 0.03222823143005371, 0.006300698034465313, 0.017099199816584587, 0.009894764050841331, -0.03065817430615425, 0.0066329133696854115, 0.017630215734243393, 0.03838033601641655, 0.02997683919966221, -0.07961729168891907, 0.05654238164424896, -0.03143664821982384, -0.030021345242857933, -0.019290493801236153, -0.032034050673246384, -0.01089740265160799, 0.08037534356117249, 0.007615641690790653, 0.02913031540811062, 0.04526815935969353, 0.031265903264284134, 0.04121286794543266, -0.026569359004497528, 0.0618913434445858, -0.01599470153450966, 0.02403743378818035, 0.03164919093251228, -0.03012542612850666, 0.03754430264234543, -0.003911588806658983, 0.005408856552094221, -0.03330109268426895, -0.011764206923544407, 0.04667764529585838, -0.010762449353933334, -0.03203099966049194, -0.01200578548014164, 0.00866181030869484, -0.01187735516577959, -0.01649484969675541, 0.014857656322419643, 0.04698505252599716, -0.013009094633162022, -0.01842699572443962, 0.047278910875320435, -0.027007022872567177, 0.00723026180639863, 0.04974856972694397, -0.0848744809627533, 0.11414410173892975, 0.04607027769088745, -0.019960246980190277, 0.012333421967923641, 0.04123709723353386, 0.001334293861873448, -0.02640753611922264, -0.006731670815497637, 0.03733202442526817, 0.006788014899939299, 0.06875064224004745, 0.04560212045907974, -0.0400865413248539, 0.015606806613504887, 0.017468005418777466, 0.06045690178871155, -0.07469337433576584, 0.010215289890766144, -0.037706680595874786, -0.013375962153077126, -0.0192046370357275, 0.016626808792352676, 0.032359134405851364, -0.004356232471764088, 0.007662605494260788, -0.0009300870005972683, -0.08868672698736191, -0.048788491636514664, -0.011580031365156174, -0.03441277891397476, 0.010533589869737625, 0.06008715555071831, 0.042674724012613297, -0.0000065063495640060864, 0.009598711505532265, 0.024657387286424637, 0.025714123621582985, 0.014043506234884262, 0.03261363506317139, 0.016307231038808823, 0.015712201595306396, 0.0709310919046402, 0.019254038110375404, -0.004303849767893553, 0.01227957010269165, -0.0091306883841753, 0.011644731275737286, -0.04373675212264061, 0.03324137628078461, -0.0036414675414562225, 0.03688214719295502, 0.008038482628762722, -0.018911346793174744, 0.016623228788375854, 0.019766241312026978, 0.07832683622837067, -0.022598279640078545, -0.06677601486444473, -0.004670643247663975, -0.029925333335995674, -0.02266009710729122, 0.025941090658307076, 0.000686086539644748, -0.0174005888402462, 0.030975457280874252, -0.03572649136185646, 0.009904148988425732, 0.10798794776201248, 0.03246719017624855, -0.01872292533516884, 0.014888246543705463, 0.05474114418029785, -0.01590769551694393, -0.02850768342614174, 0.009618767537176609, 0.007458250038325787, 0.003906487952917814, -0.02277611382305622, 0.06165146082639694, 0.02382986806333065, 0.04070764780044556, -0.054620347917079926, 0.0136915547773242, -0.06722249835729599, -0.042948637157678604, -0.07314520329236984, -0.0023851364385336637, -0.006317391060292721, 0.04973088577389717, 0.028808752074837685, -0.03803839534521103, 0.03262728080153465, -0.050202250480651855, -0.06300529092550278, 0.038250669836997986, -0.000027575048079597764, 0.040762487798929214, 0.004696601070463657, 0.003302265191450715, -0.04274700582027435, 0.010423426516354084, -0.03681468591094017, -0.011897552758455276, -0.01475432701408863, -0.040915392339229584, 0.004281498491764069, -0.043431445956230164, -0.025696948170661926, -0.03842286020517349, 0.046271782368421555, 0.026477055624127388, 0.041309695690870285, 0.06456948816776276, -0.04281452298164368, -0.04930276796221733, -0.014525219798088074, 0.040284086018800735, 0.02196796052157879, 0.03430182486772537, 0.039189767092466354, 0.003417572006583214, -0.0016337607521563768, -0.06026744097471237, 0.019718825817108154, -0.060859449207782745, -0.008930595591664314, -0.07563471794128418, -0.02604944445192814, -0.05000361055135727, 0.009769124910235405, 0.027838846668601036, -0.0008591165533289313, -0.005793817341327667, -0.015941407531499863, 0.023146536201238632, -0.019802633672952652, 0.00172242964617908, 0.010186364874243736, 0.059651125222444534, -0.00998502504080534, -0.006376679986715317, 0.036493536084890366, -0.06019732356071472, 0.024517638608813286, -0.018449928611516953, -0.02248421497642994, -0.07267732173204422, -0.07368582487106323, -0.0177975632250309, -0.01569259911775589, 0.040408022701740265, 0.0849764421582222, -0.015856649726629257, -0.02272721193730831, -0.004151581786572933, 0.014957803301513195, 0.03631093353033066, -0.02031327411532402, -0.016424210742115974, -0.03093397431075573, -0.030669769272208214, 0.0013507370604202151, 0.04069226607680321, 0.0016645252471789718, -0.01704416424036026, 0.01758342795073986, -0.03634114935994148, 0.0346800722181797, 0.07501863688230515, -0.06829145550727844, 0.012480772100389004, -0.005076446104794741, 0.00273144175298512, 0.027443677186965942, -0.06279417127370834, 0.00191115599591285, 0.0009063128964044154, 0.010054154321551323, -0.00024680569185875356, -0.03476090729236603, -0.061483532190322876, -0.00473162392154336, -0.016769789159297943, 0.04106440022587776, -0.0207791980355978, -0.0013468022225424647, -0.015919459983706474, -0.012601151131093502, 0.06472251564264297, -0.009814129211008549, 0.02618539147078991, 0.0057512251660227776, 0.02631998620927334, -0.027136819437146187, -0.011386134661734104, -0.033409640192985535, -0.04943334683775902, -0.022364698350429535, -0.050227440893650055, 0.05379790440201759, -0.0510319247841835, -0.04387274384498596, 0.037716805934906006, 0.03976680338382721, -0.055667441338300705, 0.047502145171165466, -0.03195369616150856, -0.003918393049389124, -0.033464208245277405, 0.04978734254837036, -0.022743599489331245, 0.053149037063121796, 0.0010538819478824735, -0.0802355408668518, 0.03529174253344536, 0.07330994307994843, 0.0365184023976326, 0.015165637247264385, -0.003268992993980646, -0.039514753967523575, 0.025627335533499718, -0.015651924535632133, 0.0244413111358881, -0.058453429490327835, -0.06408623605966568, 0.013473797589540482, -0.03876078873872757, -0.00001990849523281213, 0.03907039389014244, -0.02028416469693184, 0.02360367216169834, 0.06030020862817764, 0.020807279273867607, 0.04257338494062424, -0.012420066632330418, -0.011269920505583286, 0.027976371347904205, -0.06636840850114822, -0.00417789351195097, 0.02445683814585209, 0.01123407855629921, 0.014148124493658543, -0.04327826946973801, -0.00010683801519917324, 0.013993085362017155, 0.018887503072619438, 0.006784834433346987, 0.017679763957858086, 0.037293218076229095, -0.04941399022936821, -0.01373316626995802, -0.08197924494743347, -0.09161534160375595, 0.014756579883396626, -0.030406983569264412, 0.035906579345464706, 0.0351841002702713, 0.047414783388376236, 0.0484139509499073, -0.011569736525416374, -0.0076844594441354275, 0.017950305715203285, -0.04497942328453064, 0.03323790058493614, -0.021728867664933205, -0.0286514014005661, 0.01660052314400673, 0.003456729929894209, -0.01801099069416523, -0.05468263849616051, -0.00008601567969890311, 0.0576985701918602, 0.009603491984307766, -0.010896038264036179, 0.05399562790989876, 0.02815285697579384, 0.046074509620666504, -0.03603656589984894, -0.0074664452113211155, -0.012721079401671886, -0.022893846035003662, 0.0014235131675377488, 0.055353984236717224, 0.060753483325242996, 0.0061855623498559, 0.010820250026881695, 0.02413753606379032, -0.031919993460178375, -0.020480211824178696, -0.037203915417194366, 0.0054118032567203045, 0.017014216631650925, -0.011139989830553532, 0.014054704457521439, 0.009869445115327835, 0.01274909172207117, -0.030462900176644325, 0.03374497592449188, -0.027273347601294518, -0.008276990614831448, 0.012247620150446892, 0.015699835494160652, -0.014221791177988052, 0.025813471525907516, -0.04478053003549576, -0.0645153596997261, 0.003003776539117098, 0.03986122086644173, -0.06874389201402664, 0.02088741958141327, -0.04821605607867241, -0.04298679158091545, -0.01071294117718935, 0.0255005843937397, -0.023698147386312485, 0.015570417046546936, 0.027017707005143166, -0.020885510370135307, -0.03227055072784424, 0.0008508341270498931, 0.01254477072507143, 0.011202310211956501, 0.046009622514247894, 0.00971043761819601, 0.017872419208288193, 0.019697170704603195, -0.06297826766967773, -0.0025802438613027334, 0.0036703795194625854, -0.059849124401807785, 0.07482172548770905, -0.022955819964408875, 0.03231498971581459, 0.014884552918374538, 0.04481097683310509, 0.016954191029071808, -0.041934676468372345, 0.037100113928318024, -0.08538608253002167, -0.01784813404083252, -0.05447417497634888, 0.02754135988652706, -0.029662013053894043, 0.045216113328933716, -0.03184381127357483, 0.03336108475923538, 0.015493649989366531, -0.0052924612537026405, -0.015479929745197296, 0.09973545372486115, -0.06466254591941833, -0.029381494969129562, 0.0037979052867740393, 0.0707928016781807, 0.011216348968446255, -0.057444438338279724, 0.007247489877045155, -0.048569947481155396, 0.019605303183197975, 0.013363242149353027, -0.03569188714027405, -0.008373427204787731, 0.004348797257989645, 0.0037201857194304466, -0.037592414766550064, 0.0504855178296566, 0.04028451815247536, 0.044490914791822433, 0.0026421877555549145, -0.01801149547100067, 0.021454986184835434, -0.03522435575723648, -0.004044656176120043, -0.003274013753980398, 0.041431501507759094, -0.016760485246777534, 0.016100002452731133, 0.020918413996696472, -0.03792457655072212, -0.008770818822085857, 0.0071463510394096375, 0.013168900273740292, -0.055244386196136475, -0.02260981872677803, 0.0015619045589119196, 0.08752252161502838, 0.02079620771110058, -0.030393213033676147, 0.00809592567384243, 0.01179011631757021, 0.012252202257514, 0.007447227835655212, 0.0264046061784029, -0.028167614713311195, 0.024340951815247536, -0.05567292869091034, 0.02149556577205658, -0.044559601694345474, 0.01723293773829937, 0.03401998057961464, 0.008108465932309628, 0.024806611239910126, -0.04499509930610657, 0.008005782030522823, -0.0017078799428418279, 0.015620329417288303, -0.013446296565234661, 0.031482063233852386, -0.02381007745862007, 0.005331641994416714, -0.014950417913496494, -0.05828910693526268, -0.007394375279545784, -0.03556827828288078, -0.012721835635602474, -0.055420808494091034, -0.015980420634150505, 0.005525353830307722, 0.026464803144335747, 0.051219381392002106, -0.045268505811691284, -0.0006233857129700482, 0.06739386916160583, -0.01896578259766102, -0.06922776997089386, -0.01661933772265911, 0.01029996294528246, 0.04802655056118965, -0.027621928602457047, 0.007334238849580288, -0.025919292122125626, -0.04814893752336502, -0.0477101132273674, 0.05166548117995262, -0.05722927674651146, -0.02608884498476982, -0.015865100547671318, 0.06106149032711983, 0.07244975864887238, 0.0025132098235189915, 0.015114841051399708, -0.005697858519852161, -0.01641327515244484, -0.04612152278423309, -0.013535679318010807, -0.009352460503578186, -0.0025071536656469107, -0.008329697884619236, -0.0204731747508049, -0.008723625913262367, -0.04615874961018562, -0.005556894466280937, 0.038621675223112106, -0.013153018429875374, 0.027246052399277687, -0.03631379455327988, 0.01178076770156622, -0.04430199787020683, 0.010242030024528503, 0.02518620155751705, -0.04235225170850754, -0.022310685366392136, 0.04308011010289192, 0.006331129465252161, 0.026552993804216385, 0.04147900268435478, -0.07026337087154388, -0.04725257307291031, -0.04280746728181839, -0.0009235044126398861, -0.006038906052708626, -0.0025440326426178217, -0.05537976324558258, 0.05049721896648407, -0.04711310192942619, -0.014677667059004307, 0.00730510801076889, -0.00825648196041584, 0.02372051030397415, 0.06501283496618271, -0.05460647493600845, -0.004592144396156073, 0.016797522082924843, 0.09098254889249802, 0.011198123916983604, 0.023095106706023216, -0.016767369583249092, -0.02414815127849579, 0.036053236573934555, 0.09493178874254227, 0.05713610351085663, -0.023346273228526115, 0.06256969273090363, -0.0971679612994194, -0.003095653373748064, 0.0024916899856179953, -0.0581611730158329, -0.02421778254210949, 0.017530366778373718, 0.022559886798262596, 0.020915422588586807, 0.018232785165309906, -0.013129291124641895, -0.018826063722372055, 0.0018890852807089686, 0.024976903572678566, -0.044074878096580505, -0.004254608415067196, 0.026524510234594345, 0.036163460463285446, 0.026142576709389687, -0.022043541073799133, -0.017904506996273994, 0.020426783710718155, -0.015081181190907955, -0.019478710368275642, 0.008865050971508026, 0.015153000131249428, 0.07628218084573746, -0.024988900870084763, -0.0800619125366211, 0.033246077597141266, 0.027817722409963608, -0.02036386728286743, -0.03551493212580681, 0.02706524170935154, -0.029679926112294197, 0.005564259365200996, -0.000980651704594493, 0.03278838470578194, 0.012881601229310036, -0.07778000831604004, 0.012703138403594494, -0.038531381636857986, 0.028497252613306046, 0.041257038712501526, 0.0172013808041811, -0.006627487018704414, 0.04125704988837242, 0.09408565610647202, 0.021291257813572884, 0.11507277190685272, -0.061753805726766586, -0.010660138912498951, 0.04811805859208107, 0.05174532160162926, 0.06341833621263504, -0.05623270571231842, -0.0013004112988710403, 0.0058944146148860455, 0.009343494661152363, 0.024010231718420982, -0.06771384179592133, 0.05975034087896347, 0.03825673460960388, 0.03897835314273834, -0.021828461438417435, 0.06083807349205017, -0.034516651183366776, 0.0007810848765075207, 0.027884909883141518, -0.027051063254475594, -0.005019175820052624, 0.018377086147665977, -0.00474951509386301, 0.005081227980554104, 0.037154700607061386, 0.04709374159574509, 0.033825766295194626, -0.05451091006398201, -0.06250496208667755, -0.032836753875017166, -0.028234699741005898, -0.04216336831450462, -0.013430762104690075, -0.0011014803312718868, -0.05320601910352707, -0.005560237914323807, -0.09418097883462906, -0.0786784216761589, 0.02242920733988285, 0.02948703058063984, 0.0356338694691658, -0.02680928073823452, 0.02614658884704113, -0.06495018303394318, -0.003186196321621537, -0.05383141711354256, 0.019464317709207535, -0.02022804133594036, -0.002865396672859788, -0.002032677875831723, 0.003986720461398363, 0.022469641640782356, -0.010217384435236454, 0.006096400786191225, 0.04037321358919144, -0.018229054287075996, 0.041279710829257965, -0.03099563717842102, -0.015492458827793598, -0.0014748164685443044, -0.03583785519003868, -0.037093088030815125, -0.03751523420214653, -0.049116067588329315, 0.015303965657949448, -0.012300961650907993, -0.048149075359106064, -0.008019727654755116, 0.021884309127926826, 0.014024355448782444, 0.012685829773545265, -0.004425688646733761, -0.02375967986881733, 0.01693468913435936, 0.0455823615193367, -0.043194353580474854, -0.02199886366724968, 0.007289086002856493, 0.05114768445491791, -0.04824167117476463, 0.019669493660330772, -0.013958798721432686, -0.04673148691654205, 0.03056539222598076, -0.02655155397951603, -0.017158938571810722, -0.0030055271927267313, 0.006819125264883041, 0.01585143432021141, -0.0020123154390603304, 0.01435922458767891, -0.02101714164018631, 0.03224059194326401, -0.023508189246058464, -0.03191017732024193, -0.05591602250933647, -0.013794010505080223, 0.001963797491043806, -0.05035988241434097, -0.06700808554887772, 0.04781365767121315, 0.006471937522292137, -0.015782436355948448, 0.005498081911355257, 0.018065592274069786, 0.0028755702078342438, -0.005854412447661161, 0.030234701931476593, -0.02095591463148594, 0.04478638619184494, -0.04116816073656082, 0.011187597177922726, 0.06184528395533562, -0.03220115974545479, -0.027899120002985, 0.04505413770675659, 0.0385696142911911, -0.08761131763458252, 0.00868366938084364, -0.009600729681551456, -0.10404226928949356, 0.03806178644299507, 0.0364789180457592, -0.03952747583389282, -0.0290931798517704, 0.00038301091990433633, -0.0070024398155510426, 0.03654459863901138, -0.016135770827531815, 0.02179446816444397, -0.0005927065503783524, -0.025043565779924393, 0.005901099648326635, -0.04366864264011383, 0.06271278113126755, 0.014826743863523006, -0.020741578191518784, 0.07590847462415695, 0.008015500381588936, 0.0032667196355760098, 0.013263382017612457, 0.06863676756620407 ]
<p>I read that the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canonical_commutation_relation" rel="nofollow">canonical commutation relation</a> between momentum and position can be seen as the Lie Algebra of the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heisenberg_group" rel="nofollow">Heisenberg group</a>. While I get why the commutation relations of momentum and momentum, momentum and angular momentum and so on arise from the Lorentz group, I don't quite get where the physical symmetry of the Heisenberg group stems from.</p> <p>Any suggestions?</p>
g5882
[ 0.00184384745080024, -0.026614975184202194, -0.03497076779603958, -0.012171939946711063, 0.024349572136998177, 0.03968806937336922, 0.05408477783203125, 0.04743991792201996, 0.004166433587670326, -0.004067256581038237, -0.018743252381682396, -0.035928476601839066, -0.03701434284448624, -0.0013861292973160744, -0.02044503204524517, -0.04088907688856125, 0.021485626697540283, 0.08588514477014542, 0.022840363904833794, -0.04166574776172638, 0.03481271490454674, -0.01505130622535944, -0.008222555741667747, -0.030706200748682022, 0.03643207252025604, 0.02156243845820427, 0.004551805090159178, -0.0656677857041359, 0.015662245452404022, -0.026308493688702583, 0.060287296772003174, 0.03265029564499855, 0.03559522330760956, -0.016682807356119156, -0.00030883040744811296, -0.07713960111141205, 0.02077982760965824, 0.023246532306075096, -0.01811731606721878, 0.02002003602683544, -0.009017460979521275, 0.015731878578662872, -0.028568841516971588, 0.023877965286374092, -0.03468267619609833, -0.014961150474846363, -0.01853872276842594, -0.015350057743489742, -0.06540082395076752, -0.034041035920381546, 0.00862216204404831, 0.0370856337249279, 0.03328591585159302, -0.021505173295736313, 0.05474916100502014, 0.034077029675245285, 0.032659053802490234, 0.07071980088949203, 0.03630324825644493, -0.0018781794933602214, -0.008691797032952309, 0.02163666859269142, -0.0018683256348595023, 0.0659954845905304, 0.02530914917588234, -0.0529579222202301, 0.009448599070310593, 0.032241061329841614, -0.03175138309597969, -0.00272981240414083, 0.02074042335152626, -0.02377660945057869, 0.009719057939946651, 0.03503120690584183, -0.02627972513437271, 0.0058038802817463875, -0.004800150636583567, -0.01550211664289236, 0.024474039673805237, -0.05888349562883377, 0.0024999864399433136, 0.027809591963887215, 0.04433364048600197, -0.002245292766019702, 0.037132345139980316, -0.01551765576004982, -0.032991763204336166, -0.004363000858575106, -0.010288014076650143, -0.05339622497558594, 0.028561990708112717, -0.012471984140574932, 0.050189048051834106, -0.016473162919282913, -0.05140988156199455, 0.0021975054405629635, 0.0006665773689746857, 0.07872763276100159, -0.017027022317051888, -0.0032978039234876633, -0.0150682982057333, 0.06381741911172867, 0.013237840496003628, 0.0016845352947711945, 0.05031691864132881, -0.032408200204372406, 0.01586073450744152, -0.01740317977964878, -0.05359019339084625, 0.031242961063981056, -0.05551297962665558, -0.020875582471489906, -0.02313455380499363, -0.010224656201899052, -0.034280430525541306, -0.04782108962535858, 0.014469108544290066, -0.002564807888120413, -0.016137519851326942, 0.06895794719457626, 0.030054833739995956, 0.0315668024122715, -0.02287699654698372, 0.06235526129603386, -0.021785179153084755, -0.016047922894358635, -0.025456169620156288, -0.0323978066444397, 0.07343070954084396, -0.0422859750688076, 0.030810406431555748, -0.05056559294462204, -0.013753613457083702, 0.06836692988872528, 0.018729407340288162, -0.00423945439979434, 0.010240741074085236, 0.03841684013605118, 0.02638789638876915, -0.042250845581293106, -0.01172435563057661, -0.01605815626680851, -0.001833183690905571, -0.04707672446966171, 0.0011903089471161366, -0.03256012126803398, -0.0031528223771601915, -0.051637519150972366, 0.08009424805641174, 0.02982572838664055, -0.014072876423597336, 0.021255983039736748, 0.010048230178654194, -0.017129382118582726, 0.03426274284720421, -0.03626543655991554, 0.051008425652980804, 0.021659089252352715, 0.06491398066282272, 0.03176235407590866, 0.026970267295837402, -0.0652613639831543, -0.0020494135096669197, -0.016532961279153824, -0.05846993252635002, -0.020728565752506256, 0.019883563742041588, -0.002028130926191807, -0.01236373744904995, -0.08008956164121628, -0.02163929119706154, -0.02527916431427002, -0.04731784760951996, 0.05420437455177307, 0.023784376680850983, 0.06220046430826187, -0.0721832737326622, 0.012753292918205261, -0.0485275574028492, 0.027325890958309174, -0.05158345773816109, -0.03996254876255989, 0.07037083804607391, 0.00988270528614521, 0.013279516249895096, 0.0719786286354065, 0.04708072543144226, 0.027791786938905716, -0.04014717787504196, 0.011059188283979893, 0.012901435606181622, -0.005638487637042999, -0.053947802633047104, 0.012466389685869217, -0.015430230647325516, 0.03216618672013283, -0.06615443527698517, 0.025570929050445557, -0.047368280589580536, 0.042253971099853516, 0.058317746967077255, 0.02131415158510208, 0.0034523233771324158, 0.02607904188334942, 0.024299627169966698, 0.004411098547279835, 0.040892742574214935, -0.03936436399817467, 0.004535576328635216, -0.04184771701693535, 0.0010949072893708944, -0.031644903123378754, -0.00033869766048155725, -0.009017697535455227, -0.02897713892161846, 0.02160266786813736, -0.01983550935983658, -0.016380907967686653, -0.02040334977209568, 0.027711283415555954, -0.021575093269348145, -0.016962695866823196, 0.008007148280739784, 0.017529066652059555, -0.056539878249168396, 0.00976280216127634, 0.023541845381259918, -0.036726467311382294, -0.022959431633353233, 0.008448159322142601, -0.037431132048368454, 0.03704037144780159, -0.017056608572602272, 0.00878214556723833, 0.04016833379864693, 0.029076099395751953, 0.004757433198392391, 0.009578745812177658, 0.015255674719810486, 0.06907057017087936, 0.001862047240138054, 0.004098016768693924, 0.009231481701135635, 0.017965147271752357, 0.06293393671512604, -0.006819091271609068, 0.09079992026090622, -0.023812543600797653, -0.005417895503342152, 0.01071232184767723, 0.056299686431884766, -0.05962202697992325, -0.027114463970065117, -0.04661710932850838, 0.02010909840464592, -0.0515827015042305, -0.04761247709393501, 0.025871295481920242, -0.06126196309924126, -0.03451577201485634, -0.0031156123150140047, -0.065170519053936, -0.011888471432030201, 0.10973693430423737, -0.03918100520968437, -0.01076636090874672, 0.0009093312546610832, 0.024077368900179863, 0.0011662679025903344, -0.024624116718769073, -0.018248915672302246, 0.02580045349895954, -0.001562952296808362, 0.00572690274566412, -0.0523722842335701, -0.07154029607772827, 0.007119699846953154, -0.06385914236307144, -0.0201841089874506, -0.008135464042425156, 0.023333478718996048, 0.08838614821434021, -0.007104929536581039, 0.001850233762525022, -0.0023010065779089928, 0.031109586358070374, -0.010979807935655117, 0.06825872510671616, -0.0033216921146959066, 0.011782334186136723, 0.005036161746829748, 0.014035188592970371, 0.031112411990761757, 0.01065343152731657, 0.01831865683197975, 0.058980196714401245, -0.0017623555613681674, -0.04365130886435509, -0.03969883546233177, 0.04247978702187538, -0.05351157858967781, 0.014746706001460552, 0.029604898765683174, 0.052026133984327316, -0.007513023912906647, 0.05151001363992691, 0.011047727428376675, -0.0030496215913444757, -0.016511110588908195, 0.01084290724247694, -0.06978718936443329, 0.030852586030960083, -0.007095241453498602, 0.019038427621126175, 0.03685056045651436, -0.011034171096980572, -0.03703019395470619, 0.01015683263540268, -0.01653951406478882, -0.04700272157788277, -0.061108872294425964, -0.047777652740478516, -0.017232950776815414, -0.008576137013733387, 0.06732753664255142, 0.025724641978740692, -0.04181668162345886, 0.016510002315044403, 0.026813462376594543, -0.045265138149261475, -0.009966556914150715, -0.0286601223051548, -0.0026911648456007242, -0.011861852370202541, -0.05733707547187805, -0.03331327065825462, 0.011092999018728733, -0.013334611430764198, -0.005759214982390404, -0.11738330870866776, 0.023426473140716553, -0.00479337852448225, 0.027793951332569122, 0.08043231070041656, -0.04035381227731705, 0.0173658337444067, -0.01875198446214199, -0.017315274104475975, -0.004834594205021858, 0.0010747817577794194, -0.04583996534347534, 0.030791640281677246, 0.005108175333589315, 0.012329366989433765, 0.012566964142024517, 0.0031453482806682587, -0.03555406257510185, -0.023760536685585976, 0.00966413039714098, 0.024565689265727997, -0.03557392209768295, -0.019790582358837128, 0.039798375219106674, 0.022038936614990234, -0.02620711177587509, 0.03338644281029701, -0.06345205754041672, 0.016323618590831757, 0.020853258669376373, 0.01967748999595642, -0.0056348224170506, -0.08867942541837692, -0.018690846860408783, -0.020748436450958252, -0.0021584818605333567, -0.02428513392806053, 0.02960232086479664, 0.057231467217206955, -0.05122808367013931, -0.0008553362567909062, 0.019415199756622314, 0.08026880770921707, 0.04788120090961456, 0.05280102416872978, 0.0280939731746912, 0.027102163061499596, -0.04694529250264168, 0.08564022928476334, -0.012404276989400387, -0.0415014773607254, 0.015531540848314762, 0.0034281834959983826, -0.017237864434719086, -0.01654873788356781, 0.011983619071543217, -0.015801575034856796, 0.023536361753940582, 0.020557768642902374, 0.05769595876336098, 0.004396606702357531, -0.0259808711707592, 0.013693800196051598, 0.0029487223364412785, 0.020259348675608635, 0.009899929165840149, 0.08610586076974869, 0.04130169749259949, -0.03662799298763275, -0.024793166667222977, 0.04804702475667, -0.02290254831314087, 0.04770682379603386, 0.03074474446475506, -0.022943634539842606, 0.011938855051994324, 0.03085973486304283, -0.036124661564826965, -0.0421273447573185, 0.04453938454389572, 0.04683699831366539, -0.008612479083240032, -0.0009838700061663985, 0.10512500256299973, 0.017978930845856667, -0.021671850234270096, 0.03896677866578102, 0.0517406165599823, 0.025064611807465553, -0.05090560019016266, -0.032481685280799866, -0.02365325205028057, 0.001896098256111145, 0.00809274148195982, -0.013188114389777184, -0.07468482106924057, -0.00012964893539901823, -0.03595937415957451, 0.08392887562513351, 0.023334676399827003, 0.01740436814725399, 0.08901584148406982, -0.03664466366171837, 0.012624647468328476, -0.04365531727671623, -0.03785978630185127, 0.08159872889518738, 0.0294856745749712, 0.05127348750829697, -0.035688456147909164, -0.021273134276270866, -0.022172510623931885, -0.0126193230971694, -0.01816100813448429, -0.012052209116518497, -0.04060728847980499, 0.010971167124807835, -0.0042402734979987144, -0.012101836502552032, 0.02796804904937744, 0.006808294449001551, -0.0589185506105423, 0.0031404595356434584, 0.018618663772940636, -0.050978511571884155, 0.037027645856142044, 0.003192364005371928, -0.039868079125881195, -0.015646135434508324, -0.029129674658179283, -0.027381185442209244, 0.018413780257105827, 0.011185782961547375, -0.0542866587638855, 0.023180685937404633, 0.04051043093204498, 0.035749226808547974, 0.012024548836052418, -0.04047747701406479, -0.046663589775562286, -0.047450918704271317, -0.023256482556462288, 0.02462352067232132, 0.017874108627438545, -0.030368702486157417, -0.013459078036248684, 0.04994431510567665, -0.030476704239845276, 0.012803586199879646, 0.033460136502981186, -0.008469403721392155, -0.01816360093653202, -0.004898241721093655, 0.01744965836405754, -0.03293123096227646, 0.02873457968235016, 0.01754624955356121, -0.010417591780424118, -0.0247248113155365, 0.007884099148213863, -0.04152778536081314, -0.06203899532556534, 0.03639446943998337, 0.03784530237317085, 0.04452937841415405, 0.012039617635309696, 0.07906991243362427, 0.06337063759565353, 0.04500773921608925, 0.014267107471823692, 0.014387090690433979, 0.006473008077591658, 0.015042735263705254, 0.0015250475844368339, -0.013417447917163372, 0.022534703835844994, 0.021512843668460846, 0.004727354273200035, -0.0637119859457016, -0.021655138581991196, -0.015475028194487095, -0.06990254670381546, -0.030144425109028816, 0.0635375902056694, -0.02873612381517887, -0.027660492807626724, 0.002942522056400776, -0.08471804857254028, -0.006638295482844114, 0.019236719235777855, 0.06666285544633865, -0.014091553166508675, -0.033772241324186325, 0.06000521779060364, -0.03926407918334007, 0.03410797193646431, -0.0579291507601738, 0.020107993856072426, -0.030054494738578796, 0.015222894959151745, 0.050084058195352554, -0.0952865406870842, -0.029014943167567253, -0.026239246129989624, 0.012525700964033604, 0.041263651102781296, 0.023197103291749954, -0.0004892151919193566, 0.010762142948806286, 0.018993990495800972, -0.008047602139413357, -0.02241222746670246, -0.014358146116137505, 0.03501072898507118, -0.0003292587643954903, 0.03600234538316727, -0.01079059299081564, -0.0352187342941761, 0.005966966971755028, -0.042736031115055084, -0.0016292890068143606, 0.017551688477396965, 0.08019033074378967, -0.020749473944306374, -0.034421972930431366, 0.017050152644515038, 0.05043087527155876, -0.03690385818481445, 0.0026550996117293835, 0.07453689724206924, 0.034276966005563736, -0.010601040907204151, 0.04110560938715935, -0.040660422295331955, 0.02396455779671669, -0.008534759283065796, 0.023217087611556053, -0.04009830206632614, -0.05773848295211792, -0.07681358605623245, 0.0014335912419483066, 0.006143111735582352, -0.056660376489162445, 0.011758672073483467, -0.006514384876936674, -0.08277340978384018, 0.036192215979099274, -0.01945682056248188, 0.021878361701965332, -0.01955489069223404, 0.05715448409318924, -0.037953805178403854, 0.05945805460214615, -0.05307425558567047, -0.007679392583668232, -0.006669690366834402, -0.008115404285490513, 0.053853802382946014, -0.014394055120646954, -0.018931465223431587, -0.04474883899092674, 0.06485546380281448, -0.005737639497965574, -0.01845506578683853, 0.059382062405347824, 0.031148280948400497, 0.02020120434463024, -0.007887722924351692, 0.04437906667590141, -0.02581656537950039, 0.0028182121459394693, -0.0017760518239811063, 0.025362156331539154, -0.024247579276561737, -0.02092687599360943, -0.008765739388763905, 0.011385028250515461, -0.010329412296414375, 0.006382398772984743, -0.05137383192777634, 0.03459719195961952, -0.020985541865229607, -0.0239903312176466, -0.02065647579729557, 0.022698719054460526, 0.019812557846307755, 0.05674652010202408, -0.023565150797367096, 0.02258990705013275, 0.029422689229249954, 0.022957755252718925, -0.006984722800552845, 0.0004609815077856183, 0.06405126303434372, 0.03018028847873211, 0.003416891675442457, -0.023170296102762222, -0.0396098755300045, -0.00552434753626585, 0.040032170712947845, 0.0218499843031168, 0.015881486237049103, 0.0030442203860729933, 0.008068795315921307, 0.011096213012933731, -0.04318080469965935, -0.02243686653673649, -0.013561094179749489, -0.027106450870633125, -0.0702614113688469, 0.005082981660962105, 0.029201345518231392, -0.01661100424826145, -0.04349248483777046, -0.0015425033634528518, -0.05397598072886467, -0.024389108642935753, 0.010161146521568298, -0.00041609632899053395, 0.04647306352853775, -0.05216013267636299, -0.04012781381607056, 0.020724713802337646, 0.021616190671920776, -0.056660015136003494, -0.044058967381715775, 0.004832800477743149, 0.05428452044725418, -0.01833806000649929, 0.08779794722795486, 0.027412541210651398, -0.057196617126464844, -0.00415027467533946, 0.019903339445590973, -0.016070393845438957, -0.04961204528808594, 0.05057217925786972, 0.030452148988842964, -0.033709507435560226, -0.05034147948026657, 0.006904944311827421, -0.051172174513339996, 0.058197151869535446, -0.05221426486968994, 0.020321251824498177, -0.05516159161925316, 0.01807752065360546, -0.0035411997232586145, 0.048561740666627884, 0.04701298102736473, 0.006609236355870962, -0.008775963447988033, -0.011127778328955173, 0.015841104090213776, -0.044642914086580276, -0.006282701622694731, 0.0187838077545166, 0.01884632743895054, 0.022590721026062965, 0.0015870226779952645, -0.014882274903357029, -0.011298572644591331, -0.08504380285739899, -0.07169455289840698, -0.00988540705293417, 0.03625504672527313, -0.030578114092350006, 0.027752462774515152, -0.02330813929438591, -0.045247673988342285, 0.0027749708388000727, -0.017991794273257256, -0.02278664894402027, -0.010087980888783932, -0.05267762765288353, 0.041272811591625214, 0.02775379829108715, -0.009394161403179169, 0.05289440229535103, -0.007610809989273548, 0.018917858600616455, 0.03785058110952377, -0.02483728714287281, 0.012165071442723274, -0.038602977991104126, -0.05357830971479416, -0.0459773987531662, 0.05676897242665291, -0.018513044342398643, 0.007050602696835995, 0.03259515389800072, -0.058621276170015335, 0.05158355087041855, -0.02589365839958191, 0.041936300694942474, 0.024739252403378487, -0.04005761444568634, -0.00316269276663661, -0.07734809070825577, 0.053217813372612, 0.015810109674930573, 0.007574974559247494, -0.014884096570312977, 0.02613365463912487, -0.017934322357177734, -0.024886855855584145, -0.03087713196873665, -0.015010185539722443, 0.019214440137147903, -0.025970574468374252, -0.06569261848926544, -0.0019815124105662107, 0.050856057554483414, 0.017030861228704453, 0.011864015832543373, -0.009970472194254398, -0.045361995697021484, 0.008219418115913868, 0.048531461507081985, 0.0469374917447567, 0.013927297666668892, 0.013082494027912617, 0.026143407449126244, -0.014745054766535759, -0.007258953060954809, -0.06124238297343254, -0.03632868453860283, -0.06555302441120148, 0.08896045386791229 ]
<p>When a system has a dopant, how much does the Fermi level shift?</p> <p>For example, say a finite concentration of substitutional dopants replace some bulk atoms, and each has one extra electron. Ignore any changes in geometry. Say we do some DFT calculations that show the charge transfer to be 0.1 between the impurity and the bulk. Will the Fermi energy shift according to the new total number of electrons in the system, or as 0.1*number of electrons?</p> <p>I am thinking the first one, as EF should be related to the total number of electrons in the system. However, with a small charge transfer could we not regard the remaining 0.9 of charge "bound" to the dopant?</p>
g5883
[ -0.011982188560068607, 0.03753263130784035, 0.004361921455711126, -0.020880969241261482, 0.045682962983846664, -0.00639770133420825, -0.019018176943063736, 0.027249261736869812, -0.033144596964120865, 0.009294888935983181, -0.08716315776109695, 0.037820473313331604, 0.014697014354169369, 0.003942833282053471, -0.031964924186468124, 0.017331331968307495, 0.11730366945266724, -0.012050594203174114, 0.030397091060876846, 0.007641651667654514, -0.003023823956027627, 0.021914975717663765, 0.0035156963858753443, -0.06197129562497139, -0.04004032164812088, -0.007932305335998535, -0.01568716950714588, 0.06798084080219269, -0.05765443295240402, 0.005931983236223459, -0.012890438549220562, 0.030752815306186676, 0.021494651213288307, -0.02902963012456894, -0.03799767047166824, -0.04462139680981636, 0.06055138632655144, 0.0184638649225235, 0.04847193509340286, 0.013251103460788727, -0.010317445732653141, -0.03394259512424469, 0.003265504026785493, -0.052173975855112076, -0.0247630812227726, 0.030009498819708824, -0.027524424716830254, 0.03759774938225746, 0.0278007872402668, -0.0214407816529274, -0.037365566939115524, 0.08156093209981918, -0.06683504581451416, 0.05795672535896301, -0.013825706206262112, -0.0165249016135931, -0.007568264380097389, -0.02141755260527134, 0.04246365278959274, 0.032159026712179184, 0.052264340221881866, 0.030546657741069794, -0.0479542501270771, 0.039065487682819366, 0.019635861739516258, 0.05786287412047386, -0.01597891002893448, 0.019836463034152985, 0.004351228941231966, -0.05042678490281105, 0.0013874248834326863, 0.0025069587863981724, -0.018040863797068596, -0.049405429512262344, -0.01931961439549923, -0.020548682659864426, -0.037926897406578064, -0.04837774485349655, 0.03169955685734749, -0.042393192648887634, -0.024630870670080185, -0.03821774199604988, 0.026542462408542633, 0.054771583527326584, 0.06659238785505295, -0.006512307561933994, 0.007633046712726355, 0.04616259038448334, -0.048647940158843994, 0.09158723056316376, -0.03715764731168747, -0.030834147706627846, 0.013438290916383266, -0.00697685033082962, -0.003479800885543227, -0.03485800325870514, 0.012419193983078003, 0.039166729897260666, 0.007375840563327074, -0.06699053943157196, -0.020476944744586945, -0.007493977434933186, 0.003933343570679426, -0.013494323939085007, -0.04465051367878914, -0.007040849421173334, -0.0017930073663592339, 0.005950608290731907, 0.1069561317563057, 0.04725220054388046, -0.026816152036190033, -0.0639561116695404, -0.0181199312210083, -0.030596256256103516, -0.017633192241191864, 0.01392281148582697, -0.0197854395955801, 0.02559194527566433, 0.007846801541745663, -0.008032916113734245, 0.03694223240017891, 0.022403256967663765, 0.02805572748184204, 0.06545757502317429, 0.03911047428846359, -0.05055142194032669, -0.10508739948272705, 0.020497433841228485, 0.012474584393203259, -0.00117601512465626, -0.06315282732248306, -0.04485253617167473, -0.0025580357760190964, 0.014959391206502914, -0.0033301895018666983, 0.00868264865130186, 0.0769638791680336, 0.011631551198661327, -0.009622865356504917, -0.062411896884441376, 0.038943540304899216, 0.025076432153582573, 0.020717520266771317, -0.008590460754930973, -0.022416459396481514, -0.02464684657752514, 0.021134864538908005, -0.003129446879029274, 0.00889780092984438, -0.0026941606774926186, 0.034924864768981934, -0.01775437593460083, 0.004131367430090904, 0.02832888253033161, 0.006643218919634819, -0.021518737077713013, 0.007720178458839655, -0.015712322667241096, 0.027048824355006218, -0.03164900466799736, -0.009565952233970165, -0.006256008520722389, -0.03082524612545967, -0.03634646534919739, -0.02192075178027153, -0.02803758718073368, -0.008753043599426746, 0.01393852848559618, -0.017123671248555183, -0.05157645791769028, 0.010319293476641178, 0.0329691618680954, 0.026040026918053627, 0.009547999128699303, -0.045979514718055725, 0.09028872102499008, -0.009736589156091213, -0.02661796659231186, -0.0006941003957763314, -0.00528350193053484, -0.042938604950904846, 0.020476914942264557, 0.05874181166291237, 0.007896204479038715, 0.04231227934360504, -0.021752802655100822, -0.033937010914087296, -0.029769739136099815, -0.017121316865086555, 0.03588845580816269, -0.007577036041766405, -0.016332054510712624, 0.07567688077688217, 0.001346636563539505, 0.012303471565246582, -0.026416484266519547, 0.07797615975141525, -0.047251202166080475, -0.025855740532279015, -0.07357078790664673, -0.023472219705581665, 0.007965156808495522, 0.005369408521801233, -0.04296092689037323, 0.11953690648078918, -0.032675255089998245, -0.03099675104022026, -0.026229333132505417, 0.021576430648565292, -0.029522310942411423, 0.02334563620388508, -0.027707424014806747, -0.0005236703436821699, 0.036242514848709106, 0.013586478307843208, 0.036473844200372696, 0.03151174634695053, 0.027553528547286987, 0.03754141926765442, 0.03141966462135315, -0.020185772329568863, -0.0019355592085048556, 0.010650563053786755, 0.08156704902648926, 0.03917988762259483, -0.027080338448286057, 0.026662107557058334, -0.012605804018676281, -0.041178446263074875, 0.07444550842046738, -0.07114645093679428, 0.05187937244772911, -0.06355226039886475, -0.03498220443725586, 0.028555212542414665, 0.05258672311902046, -0.029277900233864784, -0.024714726954698563, -0.01580885797739029, 0.033098772168159485, -0.007873015478253365, 0.02379813976585865, -0.0002632430987432599, 0.037619754672050476, 0.00008693298150319606, -0.0232106763869524, 0.003832208225503564, 0.0009044220787473023, -0.023509075865149498, 0.001901008072309196, -0.035314034670591354, -0.02635730616748333, -0.014291292056441307, 0.045438557863235474, -0.04715399071574211, 0.0352155826985836, -0.06363508850336075, 0.01755281537771225, 0.039962101727724075, -0.03983272984623909, -0.011028961278498173, 0.027802137657999992, 0.016986101865768433, -0.0023860132787376642, -0.01871446706354618, -0.016773521900177002, 0.02786022610962391, -0.04709652438759804, 0.018689794465899467, 0.012407965026795864, 0.011801956221461296, 0.05968577042222023, -0.014414631761610508, 0.057644087821245193, 0.05261843279004097, -0.03465471789240837, 0.022178681567311287, -0.018848298117518425, 0.013588122092187405, -0.05330442264676094, -0.06528415530920029, 0.012588324025273323, -0.06914468109607697, 0.05114048719406128, 0.053709328174591064, -0.019220326095819473, 0.06312116980552673, -0.04261532425880432, -0.03213891386985779, 0.027504056692123413, -0.032213594764471054, -0.02304302155971527, 0.060404401272535324, -0.016467219218611717, 0.023818107321858406, -0.013468845747411251, 0.07698535174131393, -0.03578967973589897, -0.028598757460713387, 0.09333450347185135, 0.02643519453704357, 0.01675199158489704, -0.02923857606947422, 0.05080766603350639, 0.03740932419896126, 0.02802867256104946, -0.04528813809156418, -0.027435841038823128, -0.02342994511127472, -0.03582346439361572, -0.0267457515001297, 0.022205309942364693, 0.017628561705350876, -0.03714912012219429, -0.04539525508880615, -0.023351266980171204, -0.021990003064274788, 0.007343117147684097, 0.030974291265010834, -0.08222179859876633, 0.0007993162143975496, -0.027293896302580833, 0.0011240821331739426, -0.022050490602850914, 0.00112980289850384, 0.03820737451314926, -0.04428420215845108, -0.0409146286547184, -0.0349830687046051, 0.05491265654563904, 0.03210102394223213, 0.019466940313577652, -0.08015955984592438, -0.02092195861041546, -0.007575001567602158, 0.005783604923635721, -0.009083336219191551, 0.03398309275507927, -0.010885125026106834, 0.05239197611808777, -0.0479564294219017, 0.02829594910144806, 0.0077781374566257, -0.007476960774511099, 0.029364068061113358, 0.008848411962389946, -0.004992390517145395, -0.0202346034348011, -0.01995762251317501, 0.008220001123845577, 0.03757387027144432, -0.01042163372039795, 0.020173007622361183, 0.07023219764232635, -0.017160771414637566, -0.047900766134262085, 0.02912997081875801, 0.0034750609192997217, -0.026458686217665672, 0.037469662725925446, 0.04442301765084267, -0.08207079768180847, 0.028984004631638527, -0.013625912368297577, 0.008840275928378105, 0.037738800048828125, -0.062304817140102386, -0.016877861693501472, 0.01869187317788601, -0.049373190850019455, -0.05051042139530182, -0.004549868404865265, -0.01470073964446783, 0.06629779189825058, -0.005408735014498234, -0.02951354719698429, 0.05711531639099121, 0.013058552518486977, -0.05057542398571968, -0.022946147248148918, 0.021316619589924812, -0.024825816974043846, -0.0117357037961483, -0.011328483931720257, 0.017651086673140526, -0.06094972789287567, -0.03621094673871994, 0.0087658129632473, -0.006959302816540003, 0.04944143444299698, -0.027835611253976822, -0.00904250517487526, 0.020576130598783493, 0.05152679979801178, 0.05237877741456032, -0.00965082086622715, 0.013223815709352493, -0.03256594017148018, 0.0025911943521350622, 0.03947132080793381, -0.008856300264596939, -0.009431041777133942, -0.034871071577072144, -0.07624582201242447, 0.026490220800042152, -0.007414067164063454, 0.012290650978684425, -0.041277315467596054, -0.07253184169530869, -0.01393098570406437, -0.038718629628419876, -0.02665470540523529, -0.037557587027549744, 0.003058134112507105, 0.0001617725647520274, -0.0020667349454015493, -0.005809977184981108, -0.05031358078122139, -0.048661619424819946, -0.04840637370944023, -0.031660325825214386, 0.0656932070851326, -0.03309619054198265, 0.043437354266643524, -0.01132151298224926, 0.07349153608083725, 0.014097826555371284, 0.044315338134765625, -0.007465346250683069, -0.05519801005721092, -0.04994785785675049, 0.031524572521448135, -0.028794871643185616, -0.025647658854722977, -0.06524085998535156, 0.0020983240101486444, -0.02314211241900921, -0.0047833966091275215, -0.05627156421542168, 0.01606515422463417, 0.0701267346739769, 0.05610296502709389, -0.03995340317487717, 0.0006495114066638052, -0.044155579060316086, -0.01676912233233452, -0.056464459747076035, -0.02620934508740902, 0.014443487860262394, -0.016169151291251183, 0.01590813882648945, 0.032388754189014435, -0.024853521957993507, -0.00440568570047617, -0.03427235037088394, -0.04330175742506981, -0.01752310059964657, -0.031951747834682465, 0.003783160587772727, -0.02757345885038376, -0.039000023156404495, 0.0003233457391615957, 0.02200508676469326, -0.003608986269682646, -0.02466171607375145, -0.00011741265188902617, 0.012091096490621567, 0.02454131655395031, -0.0417359434068203, 0.006113775074481964, -0.0036414414644241333, -0.0023596298415213823, 0.06421388685703278, 0.04910498484969139, 0.07155998796224594, -0.028211837634444237, -0.017028268426656723, -0.022753726691007614, 0.037287067621946335, -0.06203586608171463, -0.030007731169462204, -0.02086453139781952, 0.034695155918598175, 0.028091544285416603, -0.02315874956548214, 0.04778790473937988, -0.022533131763339043, 0.03169862553477287, 0.038710564374923706, -0.0794670432806015, -0.009114173240959644, 0.008344809524714947, 0.022013157606124878, 0.02819722145795822, 0.02774883061647415, 0.05653277412056923, 0.01565384678542614, 0.05369124934077263, -0.0006541304173879325, 0.06761180609464645, -0.0014067076845094562, 0.05833805352449417, 0.02053547278046608, -0.0012471190420910716, 0.012733637355268002, 0.060601409524679184, 0.06134180724620819, -0.04936730116605759, 0.008116290904581547, -0.013793708756566048, -0.019877703860402107, 0.04822976887226105, 0.02495388872921467, -0.04952221363782883, -0.013695615343749523, -0.0008744465885683894, -0.06208501383662224, -0.005891753826290369, -0.006207371596246958, 0.0035257115960121155, 0.008224748075008392, 0.01469880249351263, 0.04300307482481003, 0.00011061264376621693, 0.03175261989235878, -0.020727863535284996, 0.006455575581640005, -0.058773886412382126, -0.021292751654982567, 0.019926385954022408, 0.05481194704771042, 0.022159408777952194, -0.04282063990831375, 0.014663245528936386, -0.02196827344596386, 0.0035649221390485764, -0.03481055796146393, 0.01239513698965311, 0.02383548952639103, 0.061070628464221954, -0.021155698224902153, -0.0013855125289410353, -0.007623227313160896, 0.056627094745635986, -0.010531995445489883, -0.03492371737957001, -0.079493947327137, 0.019865289330482483, 0.015925440937280655, -0.04417620226740837, -0.03501621261239052, -0.03548777475953102, -0.005392871797084808, -0.04165380820631981, 0.049170512706041336, 0.009759041480720043, 0.010387066751718521, -0.01597764901816845, 0.011273879557847977, -0.01821434125304222, 0.009073848836123943, 0.020940151065587997, 0.028534691780805588, 0.002581584732979536, 0.03230718895792961, -0.03366726636886597, 0.008047518320381641, -0.041614580899477005, 0.07759248465299606, 0.019215956330299377, -0.005757603794336319, -0.06937652081251144, -0.02167046256363392, -0.04313474893569946, 0.01184011623263359, 0.015317442826926708, -0.028072455897927284, -0.00832776352763176, 0.008249794133007526, 0.006195609457790852, -0.03414108231663704, -0.0013251688797026873, -0.015851005911827087, 0.04822160303592682, -0.02890637516975403, 0.062057942152023315, -0.01129384059458971, 0.023082558065652847, -0.00175201753154397, 0.006217074114829302, -0.03854682669043541, -0.023265883326530457, 0.029592368751764297, 0.03717466816306114, -0.039334967732429504, -0.04272671788930893, 0.00801933091133833, -0.024976661428809166, -0.002596433274447918, 0.06604963541030884, 0.029677296057343483, -0.0026029986329376698, 0.043856486678123474, -0.04189358279109001, 0.05858650803565979, -0.01999308541417122, 0.03514391928911209, 0.06816410273313522, -0.06342760473489761, 0.05049929767847061, 0.00978485681116581, -0.007753520272672176, 0.023965531960129738, -0.02833125740289688, 0.018479546532034874, -0.01759091205894947, 0.0006661466904915869, 0.03841336816549301, -0.01576492190361023, 0.0032244480680674314, -0.0002024593559326604, -0.06877606362104416, 0.0067862714640796185, -0.0526067279279232, 0.0025628102011978626, 0.05662482604384422, 0.019490307196974754, -0.0034754187799990177, 0.07299641519784927, -0.03455448895692825, 0.03437477722764015, 0.0014782404759898782, 0.0033237801399081945, 0.034841593354940414, 0.0045371283777058125, 0.06612080335617065, -0.021764695644378662, -0.010934663005173206, 0.0018251549918204546, 0.06610149145126343, -0.01443618442863226, -0.009440215304493904, -0.0031984506640583277, 0.06066945195198059, -0.009428158402442932, 0.014910690486431122, 0.041325997561216354, 0.013915718533098698, -0.036701347678899765, -0.028467712923884392, 0.015991365537047386, -0.008653375320136547, -0.04018087312579155, 0.045044682919979095, -0.0633123591542244, 0.0258430615067482, -0.026394348591566086, 0.04213620349764824, -0.0045021167024970055, -0.05217267572879791, -0.043549828231334686, -0.01465547364205122, -0.02287421002984047, 0.050572726875543594, 0.06780697405338287, 0.06569807231426239, 0.04897018149495125, -0.04260604828596115, 0.004409010987728834, -0.000019979135686298832, 0.007065427955240011, -0.02522226981818676, -0.03942809998989105, 0.07326652109622955, 0.04602266103029251, 0.014059008099138737, -0.023350520059466362, 0.03583837300539017, 0.008505711331963539, 0.013536769896745682, 0.03250874951481819, 0.0026753204874694347, 0.06225305423140526, -0.017123322933912277, -0.058548469096422195, 0.03305142745375633, -0.025662166997790337, 0.007211451418697834, 0.02672719582915306, 0.05484001711010933, 0.04497711360454559, -0.07223335653543472, 0.038403723388910294, 0.023155231028795242, -0.0882190391421318, 0.0076819052919745445, 0.014530465006828308, -0.010868602432310581, 0.059698011726140976, -0.018708517774939537, 0.07456208020448685, -0.034280069172382355, -0.04063795134425163, -0.002375883050262928, 0.027895968407392502, -0.012134878896176815, -0.0077942549251019955, -0.014062760397791862, -0.02247782237827778, -0.009467622265219688, 0.07041862607002258, -0.002534161088988185, 0.03659692779183388, 0.01698470115661621, -0.02421734482049942, 0.001907359343022108, -0.010426903143525124, -0.008998272940516472, -0.02714945748448372, 0.06689529120922089, 0.020953452214598656, -0.009132612496614456, -0.010300425812602043, -0.01652061566710472, -0.06912846118211746, -0.03491362929344177, 0.027388012036681175, -0.01738739386200905, 0.030879156664013863, 0.021488551050424576, 0.0074132997542619705, -0.00242421287111938, -0.08141731470823288, -0.060980480164289474, 0.043017178773880005, 0.004284645430743694, -0.008577452972531319, -0.021665187552571297, -0.017418265342712402, 0.013330446556210518, 0.00041606652666814625, -0.05371502414345741, 0.056899212300777435, -0.03437113016843796, -0.02521156147122383, 0.0077313813380897045, -0.011159893125295639, -0.006687460001558065, 0.052900541573762894, 0.029704513028264046, -0.056090183556079865, -0.07565644383430481, -0.021630113944411278, 0.03806840255856514, 0.010261685587465763, -0.002180974930524826, -0.03683943301439285, -0.05151371285319328, -0.024810515344142914, -0.02152053453028202, -0.032024141401052475, 0.03789582848548889, -0.010098226368427277, -0.0010799270821735263, -0.04827261343598366, 0.010963188484311104, 0.016407644376158714, -0.002988048130646348 ]
<p>In classical mechanics you construct an action (involving a Lagrangian in arbitrary generalized coordinates, a Hamiltonian in canonical coordinates [to make your EOM more "<a href="http://books.google.ie/books?id=YkFLGQeGRw4C&amp;pg=PA68&amp;dq=gelfand%20%20calculus%20of%20variations%20%22we%20obtain%20a%20much%20more%20convenient%20and%20symmetric%22&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ei=wvMwUujpDaOV7Aar_oHQDw&amp;ved=0CDwQuwUwAA">convenient &amp; symmetric</a>"]), then extremizing it gives the equations of motion. Alternatively one can find a first order PDE for the action as a function of it's endpoints to obtain the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, &amp; the Poisson bracket formulation is merely a means of changing variables in your PDE so as to ensure your new variables are still characteristics of the H-J PDE (i.e. solutions of the EOM - see <a href="http://www.lcwangpress.com/physics/good-illustrations-de.htm">No. 37</a>). All that makes sense to me, we're extremizing a functional to get the EOM or solving a PDE which implicitly assumes we've already got the solution (path of the particle) inside of the action that leads to the PDE. However in quantum mechanics, at least in the canonical <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canonical_quantization">quantization</a> I think, you apparently just take the Hamiltonian (the Lagrangian in canonical coordinates) &amp; mish-mash this with ideas from changing variables in the Hamilton-Jacobi equation representation of your problem so that you ensure the coordinates are characteristics of your Hamilton-Jacobi equation (i.e. the solutions of the EOM), then you put these ideas in some new space for some reason (Hilbert space) &amp; have a theory of QM. Based on what I've written you are literally doing the exact same thing you do in classical mechanics in the beginning, you're sneaking in classical ideas &amp; for some reason you make things into an algebra - I don't see why this is necessary, or why you can't do exactly what you do in classical mechanics??? Furthermore I think my questions have some merit when you note that <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/69982/">Schrodinger's original derivation</a> involved an action functional using the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. Again we see Schrodinger doing a similar thing to the modern idea's, here he's mish-mashing the Hamilton-Jacobi equation with extremizing an action functional instead of just extremizing the original Lagrangian or Hamiltonian, analogous to modern QM mish-mashing the Hamiltonian with changes of variables in the H-J PDE (via Poisson brackets).</p> <p>What's going on in this big Jigsaw? Why do we need to start mixing up all our pieces, why can't we just copy classical mechanics exactly - we are on some level anyway, as far as I can see... I can understand doing these things if they are just convenient tricks, the way you could say that invoking the H-J PDE is just a trick for dealing with Lagrangians &amp; Hamiltonians, but I'm pretty sure the claim is that the process of quantization simply must be done, one step is just absolutely necessary, you simply cannot follow the classical ideas, even though from what I've said we basically are just doing the classical thing - in a roundabout way. It probably has something to do with complex numbers, at least partially, as mentioned in the note on page 276 <a href="http://books.google.com.vn/books?id=6wSVuWH1PrsC&amp;pg=PA263&amp;dq=%22the%20so-called%20schrodinger%20equation%22&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ei=vDDVUaLhKIjWPZudgPAC&amp;ved=0CDoQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&amp;q=%22the%20so-called%20schrodinger%20equation%22&amp;f=false">here</a>, but I have no idea as to how to see that &amp; Schrodinger's original derivation didn't assume them so I'm confused about this. </p> <p>To make my questions about quantization explicit if they aren't apparent from what I've written above:</p> <p><strong>a)</strong> Why does one need to make an algebra out of mixing the Hamiltonian with Poisson brackets? </p> <p>(Where this question stresses the interpretation of Hamiltonian's as Lagrangian's just with different coordinates, &amp; Poisson brackets as conditions on changing variables in the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, so that we make the relationship to CM explicit)</p> <p><strong>b)</strong> Why can't quantum mechanics just be modelled by extremizing a Lagrangian, or solving a H-J PDE?</p> <p>(From my explanation above it seems quantization smuggles these idea's into it's formalism anyway, just mish-mashing them together in some vector space)</p> <p><strong>c)</strong> How do complex numbers relate to this process?</p> <p>(Are they the reason quantum mechanics radically differs from classical mechanics. If so, how does this fall out of the procedure as inevitable?)</p> <p>Apologies if these weren't clear from what I've written, but I feel what I've written is absolutely essential to my question.</p> <p><strong>Edit:</strong> Parts <strong>b)</strong> &amp; <strong>c)</strong> have been nicely answered, thus part <strong>a)</strong> is all that remains, &amp; it's solution seems to lie in <a href="http://www.mpipks-dresden.mpg.de/~rost/jmr-reprints/brro01.pdf">this</a> article, which derives the time dependent Schrodinger equation (TDSE) from the TISE. In other words, the TISE is apparently derived from classical mechanical principles, as Schrodinger did it, then at some point in the complicated derivation from page 12 on the authors reach a point at which quantum mechanical assumptions become absolutely necessary, &amp; apparently this is the reason one assumes tons of axioms &amp; feels comfortable constructing Hilbert spaces etc... Thus elucidating how this derivation incontravertibly results in quantum mechanical assumptions should justify why quantization is necessary, but I cannot figure this out from my poorly-understood reading of the derivation. Understanding this is the key to QM apparently, unless I'm mistaken (highly probable) thus if anyone can provide an answer in light of this articles contents that would be fantastic, thank you!</p>
g5884
[ 0.0415782667696476, -0.048213422298431396, -0.008997379802167416, -0.02576177753508091, 0.03925512731075287, -0.028360242024064064, 0.0810905247926712, 0.054908446967601776, -0.015138434246182442, -0.002058092737570405, -0.055269449949264526, 0.04967019334435463, 0.022751379758119583, 0.03952808305621147, -0.011456279084086418, -0.053275059908628464, 0.0075646680779755116, 0.051327936351299286, 0.013446819968521595, -0.019502753391861916, -0.025857804343104362, 0.018880095332860947, -0.0020050867460668087, -0.015849143266677856, -0.024677325040102005, -0.05315805599093437, 0.008945065550506115, -0.04472452029585838, -0.003220968646928668, 0.027245545759797096, -0.018641240894794464, -0.023928122594952583, 0.03830660134553909, -0.02264983206987381, -0.030699439346790314, 0.016864541918039322, 0.03623093664646149, 0.011388121172785759, 0.010142124257981777, -0.03560040518641472, -0.016046082600951195, -0.04452963173389435, 0.028050003573298454, 0.007509033661335707, -0.01638418436050415, -0.029094992205500603, 0.02520391158759594, -0.07351209968328476, 0.004351855721324682, 0.027396149933338165, 0.00584530970081687, 0.008370689116418362, 0.040456194430589676, 0.0009214067831635475, 0.05568567290902138, 0.06659072637557983, 0.01435234397649765, 0.010587942786514759, 0.02191663347184658, 0.024939050897955894, 0.04351632669568062, -0.03306366503238678, 0.037320394068956375, 0.04972156137228012, 0.000969057553447783, -0.008558133617043495, 0.008225702680647373, -0.03794817253947258, -0.0339723639190197, 0.02188647910952568, -0.0020329465623944998, -0.07533087581396103, 0.011247841641306877, -0.02215435728430748, 0.01971048302948475, -0.010187926702201366, 0.045390769839286804, 0.0074483491480350494, 0.07044210284948349, -0.04184938967227936, -0.04754100367426872, -0.02609201706945896, 0.04282325133681297, -0.00997073668986559, 0.0508895218372345, 0.044563177973032, -0.006097662728279829, -0.0499592088162899, 0.030345743522047997, 0.0525381937623024, -0.017450964078307152, -0.024851299822330475, 0.05268777534365654, 0.0127391517162323, -0.10332140326499939, -0.028953906148672104, 0.0012369264150038362, 0.09509328007698059, -0.011350739747285843, -0.015978483483195305, -0.031044205650687218, -0.006090237759053707, 0.03715626150369644, -0.016232047230005264, -0.057368215173482895, -0.01173813920468092, 0.04716188460588455, 0.024576997384428978, -0.01677561178803444, 0.053340598940849304, -0.036315396428108215, 0.02328328602015972, -0.033247534185647964, -0.015092275105416775, -0.07195079326629639, 0.007197230588644743, 0.009870040230453014, 0.016005974262952805, -0.050435375422239304, 0.058838456869125366, -0.006355758290737867, 0.0031570757273584604, 0.03703457489609718, 0.04202001541852951, 0.014578599482774734, -0.04459080472588539, 0.009926746599376202, -0.04003197327256203, -0.0004681807477027178, -0.02777024544775486, 0.012677399441599846, 0.016859358176589012, 0.019808528944849968, 0.028409713879227638, 0.0017001796513795853, 0.008918224833905697, 0.0032277076970785856, -0.013893975876271725, 0.02973390370607376, 0.03334476798772812, -0.02489154413342476, -0.012109149247407913, -0.0010700906859710813, -0.019697075709700584, -0.0065905009396374226, 0.03896820545196533, -0.02189638279378414, -0.0022817235440015793, -0.012712876312434673, 0.03899487107992172, -0.03264525160193443, 0.03443875536322594, -0.0015887693734839559, 0.008900633081793785, 0.01596417836844921, 0.033952128142118454, 0.01926019787788391, -0.02379678003489971, -0.005245404317975044, -0.027253642678260803, 0.09445379674434662, -0.050654422491788864, 0.029272569343447685, 0.013017229735851288, -0.022931575775146484, 0.06737112253904343, 0.009738722816109657, -0.049612242728471756, 0.01778547465801239, -0.047961898148059845, -0.03257102891802788, -0.012046878226101398, -0.0450206995010376, 0.02092360332608223, -0.03238225355744362, 0.05257914215326309, 0.034266531467437744, -0.051316093653440475, -0.015604423359036446, 0.00562294153496623, -0.016559962183237076, 0.01646583154797554, -0.020039983093738556, -0.07940901815891266, -0.05599009245634079, 0.049450960010290146, 0.02650344930589199, 0.029619351029396057, -0.013760140165686607, 0.015395287424325943, 0.027474110946059227, 0.000991753418929875, 0.005786131136119366, 0.022311143577098846, -0.027671217918395996, -0.005176761653274298, -0.015213157050311565, -0.025844600051641464, -0.015537329018115997, 0.001786703011021018, 0.025873661041259766, 0.015382060781121254, 0.03523632511496544, 0.008177196606993675, 0.033717699348926544, -0.01053888164460659, 0.018244687467813492, -0.007433831226080656, -0.008149946108460426, -0.02242462709546089, 0.019948463886976242, -0.001484864973463118, -0.014283227734267712, -0.0024555178824812174, -0.0331464484333992, -0.0605694018304348, 0.055385105311870575, -0.017406826838850975, -0.03753309324383736, -0.010849839076399803, -0.02107868529856205, -0.05293598026037216, 0.03776337578892708, 0.01272878423333168, -0.03797207772731781, 0.011710229329764843, 0.005961112678050995, -0.0194539912045002, -0.022607050836086273, 0.06811192631721497, -0.04452203959226608, 0.00398297980427742, 0.01498302910476923, -0.006452112924307585, 0.09225402772426605, 0.03014775551855564, -0.03829556331038475, -0.012459383346140385, 0.07559991627931595, 0.08235723525285721, 0.07419994473457336, -0.010938765481114388, -0.008425557054579258, -0.014807052910327911, 0.03625533729791641, 0.043874166905879974, 0.05350662022829056, 0.005675943568348885, -0.06456959247589111, -0.010030193254351616, -0.046387072652578354, -0.034652646631002426, -0.04303808882832527, -0.07311316579580307, 0.0077865831553936005, 0.008874530903995037, -0.006854220759123564, 0.01109028048813343, -0.01943129673600197, 0.004931115545332432, -0.025947943329811096, 0.05313015729188919, -0.03064371831715107, 0.07947036623954773, -0.03053010255098343, -0.003926955629140139, -0.022192154079675674, -0.052587416023015976, -0.026790598407387733, -0.04713207483291626, -0.06605947762727737, 0.08025407791137695, -0.012300112284719944, 0.03438436985015869, -0.016082322224974632, -0.049565043300390244, -0.02935769222676754, -0.02712901122868061, 0.020108792930841446, -0.009662696160376072, -0.05005872622132301, 0.0023764576762914658, 0.010839932598173618, 0.04243406280875206, 0.005809936672449112, -0.04457918554544449, 0.008035547100007534, 0.03090394288301468, -0.014129082672297955, -0.03148810565471649, -0.005217135883867741, 0.04783821105957031, -0.03670762479305267, 0.007571496535092592, -0.036640290170907974, 0.03464900329709053, -0.05255786329507828, -0.012481234036386013, 0.0015378548996523023, -0.026752132922410965, -0.00930920522660017, -0.022269031032919884, 0.005655662156641483, 0.09858991950750351, 0.007230019196867943, 0.04837542027235031, 0.0251908078789711, -0.01017802581191063, -0.042175330221652985, -0.024582041427493095, 0.02316656894981861, -0.022527990862727165, -0.05646003410220146, 0.0064606876112520695, -0.0007305836770683527, -0.05517103523015976, -0.04145771637558937, -0.046836793422698975, 0.027369599789381027, -0.05400868505239487, -0.042698949575424194, -0.0427369698882103, -0.00013328691420610994, -0.031735051423311234, 0.05749567970633507, 0.03446294739842415, -0.04207480326294899, 0.0036583570763468742, 0.003236155491322279, -0.02022639475762844, 0.023569338023662567, -0.008500738069415092, -0.005142771173268557, 0.006148454733192921, -0.024681413546204567, -0.08373165130615234, -0.04285909980535507, -0.027691250666975975, 0.09238769859075546, -0.05945737659931183, -0.002096633892506361, -0.039758387953042984, -0.013409789651632309, 0.08565214276313782, -0.032846856862306595, -0.05141429230570793, 0.03303522989153862, 0.03442210331559181, 0.01173887588083744, -0.035915814340114594, -0.05760308355093002, -0.017353015020489693, -0.029606154188513756, -0.01289451215416193, -0.014939584769308567, 0.013253005221486092, 0.022129613906145096, 0.0686592236161232, 0.06329812109470367, -0.032115500420331955, 0.0298623014241457, -0.028961636126041412, -0.025098569691181183, 0.05283995345234871, -0.00221506180241704, -0.0035410039126873016, -0.015691226348280907, -0.015942072495818138, -0.0398675873875618, -0.02888799086213112, 0.02586556039750576, -0.0025677925441414118, -0.0023334592115134, -0.0011430255835875869, 0.08102235198020935, 0.02528507076203823, 0.05215303227305412, 0.02615627460181713, -0.007871542125940323, -0.012076047249138355, -0.02644573710858822, 0.02346293441951275, 0.019558938220143318, 0.06381690502166748, 0.07265080511569977, 0.026922404766082764, -0.04178043082356453, 0.02293837070465088, 0.01268528401851654, -0.015538036823272705, 0.03289129585027695, -0.008804365992546082, 0.032293833792209625, 0.005979405716061592, 0.007949046790599823, 0.03778216615319252, 0.021902920678257942, -0.03560304641723633, -0.020531678572297096, 0.021988974884152412, -0.016359249129891396, -0.0035422025248408318, 0.014436759985983372, 0.03809395059943199, -0.014472411945462227, -0.012481821700930595, 0.029980268329381943, -0.05997570976614952, 0.03372673690319061, -0.0590306892991066, -0.009719207882881165, -0.03496912866830826, 0.04164504259824753, -0.06079457700252533, 0.008158702403306961, 0.012963428162038326, -0.0020889698062092066, -0.04026970639824867, -0.0397375151515007, -0.025793734937906265, 0.032618388533592224, 0.05558011308312416, 0.017751816660165787, 0.05189478397369385, 0.06720901280641556, 0.02574646845459938, 0.028551394119858742, -0.00550557766109705, 0.012109016999602318, -0.06785754859447479, -0.03075956180691719, -0.03147038444876671, 0.08376389741897583, -0.018834762275218964, -0.07196982949972153, 0.025228256359696388, -0.050926584750413895, 0.08105451613664627, 0.01140488963574171, 0.04417010769248009, 0.09049195051193237, 0.040736425668001175, -0.020284485071897507, -0.009166042320430279, -0.0038813070859760046, -0.019433461129665375, -0.01751769334077835, 0.0036518725100904703, 0.004756380338221788, -0.03213733062148094, 0.029505200684070587, 0.06858167797327042, 0.02253127284348011, -0.01633051596581936, -0.0220418032258749, -0.02072075381875038, -0.00020134178339503706, 0.00527990935370326, -0.03915352374315262, 0.03680120036005974, -0.06623800098896027, -0.06407313048839569, 0.018074432387948036, 0.06486804038286209, 0.04178627207875252, 0.010456140153110027, -0.07074922323226929, 0.0024427897296845913, -0.003258719341829419, 0.007239080965518951, 0.019019920378923416, 0.024783145636320114, 0.015159391798079014, -0.03204147145152092, 0.008545268326997757, -0.0020050888415426016, -0.02199261263012886, -0.05163809657096863, -0.0009087228099815547, -0.03261423483490944, -0.004376671276986599, 0.023252999410033226, 0.014911143109202385, 0.012097841128706932, 0.009892490692436695, 0.0008298773318529129, -0.015292136929929256, -0.04036540538072586, -0.02011914923787117, -0.0054095895029604435, 0.05786168575286865, -0.03097318299114704, 0.014371329918503761, -0.008943147026002407, 0.004037229344248772, -0.023791808634996414, -0.008919310756027699, 0.005783923901617527, 0.0167339276522398, 0.023286214098334312, -0.04360976442694664, 0.04266934469342232, -0.04795743525028229, -0.013386726379394531, -0.016966789960861206, -0.0319397896528244, 0.09040749073028564, 0.0016669279430061579, -0.04365840181708336, 0.04455586522817612, 0.0719156339764595, -0.016196340322494507, -0.007570249959826469, -0.018007026985287666, 0.03783674165606499, 0.026659568771719933, 0.006683060899376869, -0.024564608931541443, -0.0322415791451931, -0.03880320116877556, -0.007198496256023645, -0.008022414520382881, 0.009229391813278198, -0.03913994878530502, 0.02448488213121891, 0.013760711066424847, -0.06513401865959167, -0.042322464287281036, -0.028265437111258507, 0.10085384547710419, -0.060947127640247345, 0.03432958573102951, -0.014617476612329483, 0.023569272831082344, -0.01733829453587532, 0.031798798590898514, 0.00037857377901673317, -0.029696878045797348, 0.041316308081150055, -0.015751156955957413, -0.014470633119344711, -0.025125082582235336, 0.02260516956448555, 0.03860008344054222, -0.006655155215412378, -0.02666481025516987, -0.023412032052874565, -0.020784545689821243, -0.018781106919050217, -0.05228567495942116, -0.06338357925415039, 0.003986681345850229, -0.03810115531086922, 0.01822086237370968, -0.013485262170433998, 0.0479460209608078, -0.00043005586485378444, -0.06413981318473816, -0.018585525453090668, 0.006447464693337679, 0.02427121438086033, -0.02133123390376568, 0.02166157402098179, 0.016731319949030876, 0.09041056036949158, 0.023835953325033188, 0.017185496166348457, 0.031956955790519714, 0.04570777341723442, 0.0692664384841919, -0.004168549552559853, 0.014499765820801258, 0.03044896014034748, 0.023950932547450066, 0.024311436340212822, 0.037532348185777664, -0.062132276594638824, -0.03060327284038067, -0.06391861289739609, 0.03918648138642311, -0.04297151789069176, -0.026520634070038795, 0.028496652841567993, -0.012942355126142502, -0.05353114753961563, 0.036746274679899216, -0.03220575302839279, -0.030354034155607224, 0.034342795610427856, 0.06914827227592468, -0.009489734657108784, 0.025340421125292778, -0.09274857491254807, -0.017993507906794548, 0.01837637647986412, 0.013624490238726139, 0.06520534306764603, 0.02674413099884987, -0.010542250238358974, -0.01781320571899414, -0.00041362919728271663, -0.011464106850326061, -0.04040813073515892, -0.0164470374584198, 0.027453184127807617, 0.031943514943122864, -0.023583240807056427, -0.019519686698913574, 0.04253891855478287, 0.0020712113473564386, 0.008578036911785603, -0.033946793526411057, 0.019085492938756943, 0.03069741651415825, 0.008651823736727238, -0.01949806697666645, -0.02061721496284008, 0.04648442193865776, 0.033443059772253036, 0.028884857892990112, -0.03206215798854828, 0.00032151874620467424, 0.03556641563773155, -0.01038650143891573, 0.016329877078533173, 0.029303014278411865, -0.006793455220758915, 0.02293788082897663, 0.02329552359879017, 0.00457039475440979, 0.02819281443953514, 0.058508019894361496, -0.023848818615078926, 0.01958458311855793, -0.005842462182044983, 0.034388698637485504, -0.02083372324705124, 0.034484852105379105, 0.013810531236231327, 0.010052707977592945, 0.011432243511080742, 0.008423775434494019, 0.04823474586009979, -0.0016904111253097653, -0.12673000991344452, 0.01159901823848486, 0.010069022886455059, 0.013731587678194046, -0.12008602172136307, 0.02684391476213932, 0.05177277326583862, 0.027679182589054108, -0.04347149655222893, 0.005217366851866245, 0.0334947295486927, 0.018379950895905495, 0.03858628123998642, 0.005915334448218346, 0.041716672480106354, -0.08555904775857925, -0.03632490336894989, 0.022038597613573074, 0.013418830931186676, -0.019208861514925957, -0.0017847521230578423, -0.010802848264575005, -0.012224734760820866, 0.005890002939850092, 0.01040117722004652, 0.01643562503159046, 0.015465166419744492, 0.004354983102530241, -0.023977821692824364, 0.0219085942953825, 0.01480494998395443, -0.0151041429489851, 0.043170731514692307, 0.0361156091094017, -0.02667119912803173, -0.01162013504654169, 0.06602920591831207, 0.036034852266311646, -0.026680609211325645, 0.006045488640666008, -0.07235223054885864, -0.003997208084911108, -0.005591563414782286, 0.025343501940369606, -0.03918275237083435, 0.04904165118932724, 0.011167209595441818, -0.051549218595027924, -0.06167931854724884, 0.07813365012407303, -0.012235737405717373, 0.06352457404136658, 0.044071029871702194, 0.022032734006643295, 0.07618382573127747, 0.02478531189262867, 0.01616237871348858, -0.052002206444740295, 0.017778297886252403, -0.010631218552589417, -0.011319723911583424, 0.04135476052761078, -0.00816406961530447, -0.02872341312468052, -0.06391054391860962, 0.014813131652772427, -0.04637645184993744, -0.002707049483433366, -0.07375103235244751, 0.05351509153842926, 0.02045287936925888, 0.00827624462544918, -0.008280778303742409, 0.046376436948776245, 0.028543539345264435, -0.022950150072574615, -0.042782075703144073, 0.016137247905135155, -0.035439398139715195, -0.08888746052980423, 0.010738971643149853, -0.04136557877063751, 0.03831091150641441, -0.06286957114934921, -0.024402430281043053, -0.006037459708750248, -0.04947635903954506, -0.0655386820435524, 0.004328255075961351, 0.05196639522910118, -0.005350005812942982, -0.02211187034845352, -0.03204194828867912, -0.05526911839842796, -0.006057473365217447, 0.023615850135684013, 0.027485797181725502, -0.08438392728567123, -0.03434132784605026, 0.03248132765293121, -0.025386277586221695, -0.029017943888902664, 0.02936273068189621, 0.0629284605383873, 0.02164597436785698, -0.014918886125087738, 0.014072788879275322, 0.034002382308244705, -0.01903386600315571, 0.019161175936460495, 0.03770901635289192, -0.07255534827709198, -0.005271506495773792, 0.010129895061254501, 0.05584625154733658, -0.013105805031955242, -0.021361196413636208, -0.02109874226152897, 0.010579223744571209, -0.05806413292884827, -0.014224160462617874, -0.05432836338877678, -0.010827608406543732, 0.01662386581301689 ]
<p>I know that under $SU(2) \times SU(2)$, the left-handed electron transforms under $ ( \frac{1}{2},0 ) $ representation and the vector gauge field $A_\mu$ under $ ( \frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}) $.</p> <p>Since the electron transforms under $U(1)$, there must be a represenation under which it transforms. What is this representation? Does it have a name?</p> <p>Apparenly $A_\mu$ does not transform under the same representation, which would mean $e^{\alpha(x) Q} A_\mu$, but instead as $A_\mu + i \partial_\mu \alpha(x)$ ? What representation is this?</p> <p>Of course I realize that the transformation of $A_\mu$ can't be different for the Lagrangian to be invariant, but that shouldn't be used to define the it.</p>
g5885
[ 0.05239778384566307, -0.0226187352091074, -0.03525178134441376, -0.07124460488557816, 0.06641873717308044, 0.007248643320053816, 0.02513483725488186, 0.04348978027701378, -0.044916413724422455, 0.010253693908452988, -0.013312201015651226, 0.033884916454553604, -0.012454098090529442, 0.0006672438466921449, -0.00925009697675705, 0.016252342611551285, 0.10030440986156464, 0.028716882690787315, 0.03307163342833519, -0.032057639211416245, -0.04876710847020149, 0.045973461121320724, 0.044217124581336975, 0.014161720871925354, 0.023739350959658623, -0.002695541363209486, 0.024577999487519264, 0.0030755577608942986, 0.007329866290092468, -0.05706982687115669, 0.005408880300819874, 0.003716693725436926, 0.09860643744468689, -0.014958053827285767, -0.004843779839575291, -0.008320700377225876, 0.03683437034487724, 0.060760077089071274, 0.09349197894334793, -0.03388819098472595, -0.01255970261991024, -0.016765190288424492, -0.02533036842942238, 0.02561832405626774, 0.014480819925665855, 0.026606149971485138, -0.029552731662988663, -0.01040528155863285, -0.040675047785043716, 0.02888960763812065, 0.050447408109903336, 0.004422301892191172, -0.00628708628937602, -0.0023808057885617018, 0.021087393164634705, -0.05437954142689705, -0.012738495133817196, 0.027924949303269386, 0.04523104056715965, 0.03610020875930786, -0.019504398107528687, -0.025404799729585648, 0.011225461028516293, 0.001959182322025299, 0.027354318648576736, 0.0020644711330533028, -0.01565074548125267, 0.02637195959687233, -0.004339295439422131, 0.0032147113233804703, 0.016202930361032486, -0.055262669920921326, -0.005358854774385691, -0.007995127700269222, 0.05621661618351936, -0.03341936692595482, -0.007753849029541016, 0.01990155130624771, 0.003441465552896261, -0.04060128331184387, -0.062266744673252106, -0.012130486778914928, -0.016494709998369217, 0.016649197787046432, 0.05726682022213936, -0.02230139821767807, -0.016443748027086258, 0.04356589913368225, 0.0077516441233456135, 0.011965456418693066, -0.013898204080760479, -0.045299578458070755, 0.041864752769470215, 0.011204269714653492, -0.017069440335035324, -0.025557735934853554, -0.009679464623332024, 0.039943795651197433, -0.10432343184947968, 0.006260791793465614, 0.0037369215860962868, 0.06787066906690598, 0.008650180883705616, 0.0076589216478168964, -0.010019548237323761, 0.03992637246847153, 0.04293255880475044, -0.05997899919748306, 0.021696867421269417, -0.04252973198890686, -0.008933821693062782, -0.006189072970300913, -0.007679084315896034, -0.03165663778781891, -0.0530160516500473, -0.037853118032217026, 0.04541747644543648, -0.016577424481511116, -0.01784384436905384, 0.02623557671904564, 0.03458511829376221, -0.059487514197826385, 0.04913434013724327, 0.04411366954445839, 0.005147715099155903, 0.02341369353234768, -0.033738721162080765, 0.03337761387228966, 0.04833361878991127, -0.02120816893875599, -0.009975133463740349, -0.02067703567445278, 0.005167045630514622, 0.007859770208597183, 0.013654328882694244, 0.023216916248202324, 0.011059479787945747, 0.06143367663025856, -0.010476365685462952, 0.07115116715431213, 0.0036903037689626217, -0.02395125851035118, -0.042581524699926376, 0.009816532023251057, 0.04416690394282341, -0.011054042726755142, 0.019802439957857132, -0.07999974489212036, 0.04161446541547775, -0.012123643420636654, -0.036681823432445526, 0.08911149203777313, 0.013789922930300236, -0.024572521448135376, -0.01607113517820835, -0.05274582281708717, 0.08186012506484985, 0.0028535439632833004, 0.04869665578007698, 0.010037805885076523, 0.0781625360250473, -0.04916436970233917, 0.03821159526705742, 0.0026114352513104677, -0.00755448779091239, -0.003842693753540516, -0.000671634916216135, -0.039711106568574905, 0.015453497879207134, -0.04666988551616669, -0.0036363904364407063, 0.056015729904174805, 0.009820266626775265, 0.03099849633872509, -0.00522193405777216, 0.07672971487045288, -0.043458327651023865, -0.019302906468510628, -0.010360339656472206, -0.020664287731051445, -0.06779808551073074, 0.003041416872292757, 0.01771698147058487, 0.00810543168336153, 0.0024121874012053013, -0.07113098353147507, -0.017990553751587868, 0.08768768608570099, -0.019227122887969017, 0.01877903938293457, 0.01450318843126297, 0.028263801708817482, 0.0071584382094442844, 0.01041210163384676, -0.0018977347062900662, -0.009620221331715584, 0.026682842522859573, -0.04940385743975639, -0.09102219343185425, -0.034644708037376404, 0.048402152955532074, -0.004294679034501314, 0.050311751663684845, -0.0023412604350596666, 0.030817048624157906, 0.014869099482893944, -0.06087963283061981, -0.0006450461223721504, 0.016148559749126434, 0.021096860989928246, 0.016592858359217644, -0.030503101646900177, 0.02991664968430996, 0.007737717591226101, -0.052053067833185196, -0.0568736307322979, 0.015686292201280594, 0.022750552743673325, -0.07765505462884903, 0.013204474933445454, -0.021689556539058685, -0.04257625341415405, -0.0034170150756835938, -0.025871306657791138, -0.047976054251194, 0.05041178688406944, 0.004696127492934465, -0.01483065728098154, -0.053478870540857315, 0.012636544182896614, -0.05108674615621567, 0.01694435626268387, -0.032565612345933914, -0.05158517509698868, 0.02217109687626362, -0.007904697209596634, -0.07356482744216919, 0.023700054734945297, 0.02390749566257, -0.016419900581240654, 0.03293684870004654, -0.00007035905582597479, -0.007074960973113775, 0.00007058040500851348, 0.0501423254609108, 0.0776887908577919, 0.10037785023450851, 0.017402788624167442, 0.013959228061139584, -0.020355040207505226, -0.06575966626405716, -0.03613905981183052, -0.028635533526539803, 0.022009551525115967, -0.04185110703110695, -0.03837045282125473, 0.040197037160396576, -0.057227764278650284, -0.043500013649463654, -0.009430269710719585, 0.018239110708236694, -0.018670281395316124, 0.012107298709452152, 0.03354872018098831, -0.07835749536752701, -0.030719049274921417, 0.04301239550113678, 0.0633486807346344, -0.016732867807149887, 0.003893091809004545, -0.0734580010175705, 0.05772000923752785, 0.008387097157537937, -0.014614632353186607, 0.018512051552534103, -0.06423905491828918, -0.015287765301764011, -0.04577973857522011, 0.0070952740497887135, -0.049873195588588715, 0.044250328093767166, -0.02626226283609867, 0.0527750700712204, 0.0429551787674427, -0.031635038554668427, -0.0427224263548851, -0.025299038738012314, -0.017988817766308784, -0.03056909702718258, 0.06178617477416992, -0.05216269940137863, -0.018621886149048805, 0.012143751606345177, 0.008005502633750439, -0.01261522900313139, 0.018879001960158348, 0.02318686433136463, -0.032622188329696655, -0.013605554588139057, -0.005901928059756756, -0.006193859502673149, -0.02428947202861309, -0.05589757114648819, -0.042975835502147675, 0.06721058487892151, -0.04183785989880562, -0.014963977038860321, -0.02597854472696781, -0.03362959995865822, 0.016054535284638405, -0.0019781182054430246, 0.006808073725551367, 0.02424933947622776, -0.00695812376216054, -0.04932953417301178, -0.04234740510582924, -0.0181767288595438, -0.03841578587889671, 0.015581661835312843, -0.02461167797446251, -0.013124901801347733, -0.0719335526227951, 0.029245389625430107, 0.01447238028049469, 0.01591295748949051, -0.007947363890707493, -0.034738630056381226, 0.049955204129219055, -0.022177252918481827, -0.03008236736059189, 0.0011435362976044416, 0.04422694072127342, 0.03849082067608833, -0.011383852921426296, 0.040214598178863525, -0.0032051594462245703, -0.08905695378780365, 0.042729999870061874, 0.01206097099930048, 0.00947647076100111, -0.03800500929355621, -0.018023338168859482, -0.0354798398911953, 0.071927011013031, 0.05612228065729141, -0.008508565835654736, -0.012946055270731449, -0.02353784255683422, 0.04796157777309418, -0.043771132826805115, -0.027193164452910423, 0.05729213356971741, 0.03417853266000748, 0.02466726116836071, 0.006803049240261316, 0.022278590127825737, -0.016774479299783707, -0.041049279272556305, -0.01707766018807888, 0.0038154078647494316, 0.029471632093191147, -0.043223850429058075, -0.029869230464100838, 0.021458568051457405, 0.000688284111674875, -0.007030216045677662, -0.0004789015802089125, 0.039636146277189255, -0.012887577526271343, 0.027239549905061722, 0.007582591846585274, -0.05486723780632019, 0.003205353394150734, 0.021824035793542862, -0.02063889428973198, -0.10162130743265152, -0.06492999941110611, -0.018693216145038605, -0.011543545871973038, 0.025207586586475372, 0.003286318853497505, -0.03103477507829666, -0.013974460773169994, -0.007561691105365753, 0.05045076459646225, -0.018405796959996223, 0.03176775947213173, 0.03942081704735756, 0.01889965869486332, -0.03809850662946701, 0.01841149479150772, 0.0051657515577971935, -0.011448229663074017, -0.008751818910241127, 0.026568705216050148, -0.03082633949816227, 0.04056665301322937, -0.027544019743800163, -0.019949333742260933, -0.019777141511440277, -0.0019490881823003292, 0.02374245971441269, 0.004597168881446123, 0.0055762105621397495, 0.02707306481897831, 0.031156765297055244, 0.04666320979595184, -0.010700282640755177, -0.009789364412426949, -0.04797396436333656, -0.06308530271053314, 0.016995854675769806, 0.004684031009674072, -0.08526845276355743, -0.0414215587079525, -0.006039030849933624, -0.028831809759140015, -0.04539307579398155, -0.014774375595152378, -0.0017297351732850075, 0.03237784281373024, 0.024847200140357018, 0.04762326925992966, 0.029387328773736954, 0.005696149077266455, 0.04926232993602753, 0.05193007364869118, 0.023917436599731445, -0.0035123941488564014, -0.020464982837438583, 0.035222459584474564, 0.04205689951777458, -0.009000970982015133, 0.008810910396277905, -0.056367963552474976, 0.03320496529340744, -0.05935999006032944, -0.00594335189089179, 0.004340143408626318, 0.04308747127652168, 0.09023372083902359, -0.05523454025387764, 0.01016809418797493, 0.010821661911904812, -0.06635396927595139, 0.0013561873929575086, 0.026231536641716957, -0.01759728603065014, 0.0035176482051610947, -0.021340178325772285, -0.039494894444942474, 0.03233910724520683, -0.046225134283304214, -0.02666935697197914, 0.04507383704185486, -0.04060526564717293, 0.003051805542781949, 0.028744783252477646, 0.04761591926217079, -0.036333005875349045, -0.05031166225671768, -0.02479664236307144, -0.035042356699705124, 0.015771716833114624, 0.013682006858289242, -0.02219528518617153, -0.06433986872434616, 0.08867625892162323, -0.02222697250545025, -0.041444774717092514, 0.0485043041408062, -0.028749072924256325, -0.032239433377981186, -0.02641656994819641, 0.0646035373210907, 0.02509039267897606, 0.014184441417455673, -0.02252713218331337, -0.02109430730342865, 0.0018459050916135311, -0.0308452770113945, -0.06417713314294815, 0.029066558927297592, -0.016597691923379898, -0.053751252591609955, 0.008303897455334663, 0.015819432213902473, 0.0002371875598328188, -0.002746476326137781, -0.049742501229047775, -0.024848926812410355, 0.008018957450985909, 0.011054001748561859, 0.00983478594571352, 0.0084618479013443, 0.03551565483212471, -0.019469713792204857, 0.03393148258328438, 0.02840299904346466, -0.012178917415440083, -0.06658222526311874, -0.00909566879272461, 0.030229516327381134, 0.005907860118895769, 0.011524228379130363, 0.03234154358506203, 0.07319620251655579, -0.014363876543939114, -0.045097678899765015, -0.002456179354339838, -0.0145887341350317, -0.028221894055604935, -0.005195125006139278, -0.012265045195817947, 0.07955378293991089, 0.020880091935396194, -0.02931179106235504, -0.025080403313040733, -0.02117975242435932, -0.0777994841337204, 0.05081764981150627, 0.025974400341510773, 0.02251022681593895, -0.04704388976097107, -0.001678651780821383, 0.0327623188495636, -0.02398640103638172, -0.045491691678762436, 0.02748032845556736, 0.027667270973324776, 0.07227551937103271, -0.0013663622085005045, -0.01669367030262947, 0.027943411841988564, 0.06233256310224533, -0.053003713488578796, -0.03018653765320778, -0.01854535937309265, -0.008842432871460915, -0.01851481944322586, -0.023312291130423546, -0.025280579924583435, 0.027561305090785027, -0.006945462431758642, -0.048281148076057434, 0.05557103082537651, 0.027321701869368553, 0.003427729243412614, -0.04081936925649643, 0.003253963775932789, 0.0078692976385355, 0.0026394440792500973, -0.012064346112310886, -0.05614175647497177, 0.030961763113737106, 0.014229746535420418, 0.018591998144984245, 0.00815968494862318, -0.012549828737974167, 0.008828189224004745, 0.051737427711486816, 0.04429960995912552, 0.04799080640077591, -0.03387616574764252, -0.01177674625068903, -0.02293992042541504, 0.021564804017543793, 0.0017996029928326607, 0.06684660911560059, 0.035141922533512115, 0.015930060297250748, 0.03042135201394558, 0.07405836135149002, 0.0070831552147865295, -0.008771087042987347, 0.045528363436460495, -0.03636392205953598, -0.03203018009662628, -0.022239046171307564, -0.02165481634438038, 0.021005887538194656, 0.003411928890272975, -0.003910243511199951, -0.02997354045510292, -0.06146819517016411, 0.01951075717806816, -0.021574724465608597, -0.007666105404496193, 0.07509443908929825, 0.012858010828495026, -0.028479529544711113, 0.016757957637310028, 0.01441892609000206, 0.011700109578669071, 0.028258148580789566, 0.042364396154880524, -0.030456334352493286, 0.03849175199866295, -0.023318683728575706, 0.04241057112812996, 0.07080588489770889, 0.041098590940237045, 0.02934950776398182, -0.011815792880952358, 0.014121344313025475, 0.06214728206396103, -0.02999884821474552, -0.013076359406113625, 0.038658507168293, 0.029958905652165413, 0.045208774507045746, -0.011967900209128857, 0.002266825409606099, 0.004416760988533497, -0.006381190847605467, -0.02092951536178589, -0.0719272792339325, 0.04995175823569298, -0.03662680462002754, 0.0004873771104030311, -0.004004677291959524, -0.018400808796286583, -0.048589687794446945, -0.008610923774540424, 0.004215348977595568, 0.033250946551561356, -0.012519460171461105, 0.023591339588165283, 0.07528393715620041, -0.07342109829187393, -0.013884086161851883, 0.035166069865226746, 0.028044860810041428, 0.053677309304475784, 0.06716268509626389, 0.027395982295274734, -0.06629504263401031, 0.02558666281402111, -0.02503807656466961, 0.047663863748311996, -0.0090002017095685, 0.05240097641944885, 0.03809525817632675, 0.006737590301781893, -0.045589081943035126, -0.01835116557776928, -0.011659699492156506, -0.013945664279162884, -0.07632680237293243, -0.00978065375238657, 0.03726979345083237, 0.07372085005044937, -0.04579584300518036, -0.02810504101216793, -0.06479956209659576, -0.04373716562986374, -0.003491390263661742, 0.03211676701903343, -0.02669404074549675, -0.01232097577303648, -0.013407436199486256, -0.05429703742265701, 0.021032361313700676, 0.011004547588527203, 0.03584938496351242, 0.004124629311263561, -0.038643717765808105, -0.04318842664361, 0.07437535375356674, -0.011818455532193184, -0.04886195808649063, -0.05955708399415016, 0.0410337932407856, 0.04500265419483185, -0.00012764315761160105, 0.0026260942686349154, -0.01316201314330101, 0.08610037714242935, -0.03482305631041527, 0.0038827720563858747, -0.053883589804172516, -0.010496237315237522, 0.08956491202116013, -0.04677946865558624, -0.061238326132297516, -0.05611181631684303, -0.016338784247636795, 0.009492333978414536, 0.003433265956118703, -0.03092624992132187, -0.004331785254180431, -0.0468166321516037, 0.06606446206569672, 0.0034858223516494036, -0.03522912412881851, 0.0009014985989779234, -0.021621638908982277, 0.016878381371498108, -0.036949120461940765, 0.005208437796682119, 0.05590302497148514, 0.022339586168527603, 0.02942763827741146, 0.042675044387578964, 0.030257822945713997, -0.01112814899533987, -0.011277463287115097, -0.010608146898448467, -0.05786354839801788, -0.04652269184589386, -0.029099784791469574, 0.037134572863578796, 0.031158223748207092, 0.02281298115849495, 0.02330811321735382, 0.004262987989932299, 0.034976083785295486, 0.032475098967552185, -0.015001421794295311, 0.019368482753634453, 0.05126238241791725, -0.028388243168592453, -0.026952913030982018, -0.023645898327231407, 0.035185735672712326, -0.01664750650525093, 0.018249422311782837, -0.034671805799007416, 0.016302606090903282, -0.00029181622085161507, -0.021427039057016373, 0.032357748597860336, -0.012225879356265068, 0.031227439641952515, -0.03299998492002487, 0.04300966486334801, -0.004280733875930309, -0.06885483860969543, 0.006623853929340839, -0.008203634060919285, -0.0025190599262714386, -0.03711863234639168, 0.012448450550436974, 0.06430672109127045, -0.0512651763856411, -0.012000010348856449, -0.009751595556735992, -0.031236682087183, 0.011610548943281174, -0.06992459297180176, 0.013575642369687557, -0.0038457189220935106, -0.013389874249696732, 0.017914827913045883, 0.030233096331357956, 0.007352404296398163, 0.061090268194675446, 0.00964647438377142, 0.005420593079179525, 0.03229103982448578, 0.028201164677739143, -0.0002823969116434455, -0.0052426657639443874, 0.02514694817364216, -0.029203152284026146, -0.10028313100337982, -0.024920335039496422, 0.007450111676007509 ]
<p>As is usually done when first presenting string theory, the Nambu-Goto Action, $$ S_{\text{NG}}:=-T\int d\tau d\sigma \sqrt{-g} $$ ($g:=\det (g_{\alpha \beta})$ is the induced metric on the world-sheet and $T$ is a positive real number interpreted as the string tension), is introduced as the natural generalization of action for a relativistic point particle, which in turn is obviously a correct action as it produces the proper equations of motion (and has a nice geometric interpretation).</p> <p>Not long after the introduction of the Nambu-Goto action, authors tend to introduce the Polyakov action, \begin{align*} S_{\text{P}} &amp; :=-\frac{T}{2}\int d\tau d\sigma \, \sqrt{-h}h^{\alpha \beta}g_{\alpha \beta}=-\frac{T}{2}\int d\tau d\sigma \, \sqrt{-h}h^{\alpha \beta}\partial _\alpha X\cdot \partial _\beta X \\ &amp; =-\frac{T}{2}\int d\tau d\sigma \, \sqrt{-h}h^{\alpha \beta}\partial _\alpha X^\kappa \partial _\beta X^\lambda G_{\kappa \lambda}(X), \end{align*} where $G_{\kappa \lambda}$ is the space-time metric, $g_{\alpha \beta}$ is the induced metric on the world-sheet, and $h_{\alpha \beta}$ is the auxiliary metric on the world-sheet ($h:=\det (h_{\alpha \beta})$). They then usually proceed to show that these two actions are equivalent, in the sense that you can deduce the equations of motion for $S_{\text{NG}}$ given the equations of motion for $S_{\text{P}}$.</p> <p>Now, that's all well and dandy, but that doesn't exactly show how one would actually arrive at the Polyakov action. You can't make it as a theoretical physicist by mindlessly computing things to show you get the right answer; you have to be able to actually, you know, come up with things. Hence, instead of just pulling the Polyakov action out of a hat, it would be nice to know a way of deriving or motivating the action.</p> <p>So then, imagine you are handed $S_{\text{NG}}$ and you set out to come up with an equivalent action that, at the very least, doesn't involve a square-root. How do you come up with the Polyakov action?</p>
g5886
[ 0.05827627331018448, -0.006958849728107452, -0.01422587875276804, -0.024454161524772644, 0.053979407995939255, -0.028489913791418076, 0.0755097046494484, 0.021363386884331703, -0.020303446799516678, -0.009959595277905464, -0.04844660684466362, 0.04515876621007919, 0.010477622970938683, -0.003188790986314416, 0.017251839861273766, -0.01599867083132267, 0.011468397453427315, -0.04138478636741638, -0.017411863431334496, -0.0037885094061493874, 0.020954711362719536, 0.0259038545191288, 0.08098425716161728, -0.02482357993721962, 0.011164206080138683, 0.01760088838636875, 0.0026120461989194155, -0.03543252497911453, -0.012462561018764973, -0.023235397413372993, 0.025886105373501778, 0.0014761085622012615, 0.05400635302066803, 0.007945392280817032, -0.026700658723711967, 0.046030912548303604, 0.07411850243806839, 0.00044014438753947616, 0.020570216700434685, -0.02706901729106903, -0.06324276328086853, -0.004569002892822027, -0.02118467539548874, 0.0678805336356163, 0.004185528494417667, -0.093267522752285, -0.026849888265132904, -0.029728710651397705, 0.008573325350880623, 0.01156750600785017, -0.014217020943760872, 0.05199055001139641, -0.008796295151114464, -0.02993857115507126, 0.06187495216727257, 0.05091985687613487, 0.01481721457093954, -0.023592369630932808, 0.030825765803456306, 0.03135256841778755, -0.04265511408448219, 0.009860307909548283, 0.025277283042669296, 0.03413674980401993, 0.04901936277747154, -0.020787395536899567, -0.044745661318302155, 0.012137063778936863, 0.04579063504934311, -0.01745368167757988, -0.013360541313886642, -0.01703507825732231, 0.02474568970501423, 0.01996784098446369, -0.012880194000899792, 0.012713363394141197, -0.02912238799035549, 0.004233892075717449, -0.029283493757247925, -0.005058924667537212, -0.010403408668935299, 0.007355425972491503, 0.08155421912670135, -0.048097919672727585, 0.08985745906829834, -0.05884762108325958, 0.014163872227072716, -0.014941757544875145, -0.0699237585067749, -0.01324618048965931, 0.031208602711558342, -0.0017100651748478413, -0.001211329479701817, 0.013585995882749557, 0.001822258927859366, -0.033550553023815155, 0.047782108187675476, 0.03277461975812912, -0.012322582304477692, 0.00891334842890501, -0.006864144932478666, 0.017077002674341202, -0.012078327126801014, -0.0037450408563017845, -0.03503676503896713, -0.016119366511702538, 0.052631936967372894, 0.008203777484595776, -0.014273658394813538, 0.008692042902112007, -0.03161304444074631, 0.05982738360762596, 0.0204197708517313, -0.008396116085350513, -0.0283204335719347, -0.07436066120862961, 0.018905116245150566, -0.019123384729027748, -0.032490603625774384, 0.07390058040618896, -0.02833738923072815, 0.03429558873176575, -0.028507938608527184, 0.05185548588633537, -0.004376058932393789, -0.04180259257555008, -0.007333877496421337, 0.03511906787753105, 0.024141542613506317, -0.05269773676991463, 0.06047116592526436, -0.03287862613797188, 0.013542447239160538, 0.047817204147577286, -0.024219602346420288, 0.049124326556921005, -0.023324141278862953, 0.03858683630824089, -0.0073037841357290745, -0.05082425847649574, -0.03246094286441803, -0.022933099418878555, -0.033421628177165985, -0.03819258138537407, -0.006152553018182516, 0.09438926726579666, -0.011037006042897701, -0.014866470359265804, -0.0025997941847890615, 0.018427683040499687, -0.02838018909096718, 0.06589951366186142, 0.012241153977811337, 0.021312540397047997, 0.03708713501691818, 0.038727447390556335, 0.058695144951343536, -0.02562527358531952, 0.0002867219445761293, -0.026638349518179893, 0.10960432887077332, -0.034433942288160324, -0.002503379248082638, -0.02064613811671734, -0.059596311300992966, 0.009702617302536964, 0.02273929864168167, 0.017880504950881004, 0.0038408455438911915, -0.12769541144371033, -0.03823157772421837, 0.04410969465970993, -0.0059530469588935375, 0.015966275706887245, -0.00308975949883461, 0.0679621621966362, -0.05878474563360214, 0.015415304340422153, -0.0054272981360554695, -0.010496879927814007, 0.005446107592433691, -0.06762490421533585, 0.022423408925533295, -0.009088398888707161, -0.010403105989098549, -0.013538073748350143, -0.03425132483243942, 0.03280438855290413, 0.017721127718687057, 0.021571654826402664, -0.008125855587422848, -0.01741621643304825, -0.010796288959681988, 0.05221080780029297, -0.005516293458640575, 0.030105125159025192, 0.005342636723071337, -0.04035193473100662, -0.013864419423043728, 0.026147110387682915, 0.028169766068458557, 0.0061050644144415855, 0.06419719010591507, -0.05458953231573105, 0.027361178770661354, 0.010608917102217674, 0.025740571320056915, -0.03333575278520584, 0.0043435911647975445, -0.026847360655665398, 0.07186735421419144, -0.07848035544157028, -0.01017230935394764, -0.00638229213654995, -0.07518864423036575, -0.043687332421541214, -0.01970057003200054, 0.01875161938369274, -0.039893634617328644, 0.003239790443331003, -0.06749939918518066, 0.02719033695757389, 0.010372120887041092, -0.025835774838924408, -0.02419774979352951, 0.030936598777770996, -0.021873697638511658, -0.04432569444179535, 0.008699272759258747, -0.014845671132206917, -0.09408310055732727, -0.057846758514642715, -0.05692426860332489, -0.030166197568178177, 0.04979058727622032, 0.00013459144975058734, -0.0036704244557768106, 0.01165053155273199, 0.045971669256687164, -0.011217639781534672, 0.03130096569657326, 0.028365537524223328, -0.011674684472382069, 0.032758928835392, 0.006929504685103893, 0.04260268807411194, 0.09491404891014099, 0.006314505357295275, -0.07394575327634811, -0.0035374779254198074, -0.026916593313217163, -0.0546407476067543, 0.04756941646337509, -0.02583315037190914, 0.08863628655672073, 0.02583249844610691, -0.012347646988928318, 0.0210245531052351, 0.021196570247411728, -0.04687117412686348, -0.011899995617568493, -0.00843551941215992, 0.00817306898534298, 0.06631054729223251, -0.006444303318858147, -0.018933868035674095, 0.004417814780026674, -0.0020038168877363205, -0.05211401358246803, -0.029097996652126312, -0.06992189586162567, 0.007034533657133579, -0.03376518934965134, -0.02270301803946495, -0.04723206162452698, -0.020776724442839622, 0.008585912175476551, -0.030620690435171127, 0.011857159435749054, -0.01748226396739483, 0.002034107455983758, -0.006642029155045748, -0.01755893975496292, -0.03652550280094147, -0.010176216252148151, -0.05307392030954361, 0.006702782120555639, -0.05488310381770134, -0.013680758886039257, -0.053637031465768814, 0.008536985144019127, 0.014690427109599113, 0.006184954196214676, -0.012368929572403431, 0.05025436356663704, 0.07146339863538742, -0.003717842511832714, 0.010321883484721184, 0.050924152135849, -0.00039960708818398416, 0.00031824203324504197, -0.058789536356925964, -0.04243193566799164, -0.016834277659654617, 0.02661847323179245, -0.006360748317092657, 0.018048971891403198, -0.05920904874801636, -0.03266066312789917, 0.009745057672262192, 0.05025145038962364, 0.04026956111192703, 0.01503187045454979, -0.027052707970142365, -0.0161094032227993, 0.010402096435427666, -0.004051784984767437, -0.010403982363641262, 0.04296467453241348, -0.0239627193659544, -0.018207093700766563, -0.08767548948526382, 0.04071374982595444, 0.021644556894898415, -0.025660332292318344, -0.03077189438045025, -0.043657343834638596, 0.019982846453785896, -0.030978433787822723, -0.04983875900506973, 0.002565062837675214, -0.005951655097305775, 0.0037107893731445074, 0.00036535668186843395, -0.043580327183008194, -0.04917401820421219, -0.0368959903717041, 0.0030758387874811888, 0.05878201872110367, -0.013679463416337967, -0.03002130798995495, -0.05652979761362076, 0.0009122549090534449, 0.03636719286441803, 0.022251181304454803, -0.004866346251219511, 0.08419881016016006, 0.040963832288980484, 0.03893435001373291, 0.014091715216636658, -0.037642952054739, -0.05920756980776787, -0.019466381520032883, 0.011056444607675076, -0.014409419149160385, 0.03925858065485954, 0.027826962992548943, 0.040487293154001236, 0.055431559681892395, -0.06562082469463348, 0.06345769762992859, 0.016071444377303123, -0.04121933504939079, 0.022267818450927734, 0.03481321781873703, -0.012043538503348827, 0.015035968273878098, 0.04651418328285217, -0.05350565165281296, -0.020249443128705025, 0.10761477053165436, -0.056370776146650314, -0.003960088361054659, 0.0014685740461573005, 0.056922029703855515, 0.014455455355346203, -0.020622899755835533, 0.019750788807868958, 0.017401494085788727, 0.061989929527044296, 0.06384487450122833, 0.002684284234419465, -0.01981036551296711, 0.034979529678821564, -0.004841275047510862, -0.019748710095882416, -0.05525730177760124, 0.025280890986323357, 0.002726013073697686, 0.00733816297724843, -0.006639392580837011, -0.010403960943222046, -0.015927748754620552, -0.041087616235017776, -0.013495114631950855, -0.02033766731619835, 0.03670216724276543, 0.005257916171103716, -0.04091886430978775, -0.01247340813279152, -0.05253121629357338, -0.004173722583800554, 0.024758508428931236, -0.041199926286935806, -0.030435794964432716, -0.01919999159872532, 0.018551873043179512, -0.025961032137274742, 0.029155921190977097, -0.04402771219611168, -0.02700374647974968, 0.014487972483038902, 0.013809742406010628, -0.04976126179099083, 0.018342040479183197, -0.02171303704380989, -0.04316338896751404, -0.002787225414067507, 0.0412270613014698, -0.05139557272195816, 0.0252763032913208, 0.09414546191692352, 0.029446272179484367, -0.03365611657500267, 0.06507513672113419, 0.04996524751186371, 0.0648542121052742, 0.02922402322292328, 0.04511430487036705, -0.06275804340839386, 0.014733890071511269, -0.012030290439724922, 0.050070684403181076, 0.053885746747255325, -0.08990637212991714, 0.07891165465116501, -0.01958516612648964, 0.04356042668223381, 0.05422050133347511, 0.027287103235721588, 0.026435501873493195, 0.013618936762213707, 0.00685149896889925, -0.0020771208219230175, 0.022291211411356926, 0.059811219573020935, -0.059674590826034546, -0.009283228777348995, -0.02379854954779148, 0.021460022777318954, -0.054999273270368576, 0.047298599034547806, 0.043324895203113556, 0.020718449726700783, -0.01586276851594448, 0.0220460407435894, -0.008835531771183014, 0.046824850142002106, 0.014280345290899277, -0.024007078260183334, -0.06361239403486252, -0.04599928855895996, -0.005123605486005545, 0.029885856434702873, 0.004300927743315697, 0.0010073970770463347, -0.06213809922337532, 0.042432256042957306, -0.029873620718717575, -0.00234239362180233, -0.01793915219604969, -0.02254396863281727, 0.0076256925240159035, -0.06879398971796036, -0.03237105906009674, 0.03579051420092583, 0.0026057285722345114, 0.016351571306586266, 0.01356053352355957, -0.018277430906891823, -0.03628009557723999, -0.03672981634736061, 0.029654966667294502, -0.018025608733296394, 0.0057207862846553326, -0.007783771958202124, -0.014652159065008163, -0.027290301397442818, 0.025952648371458054, 0.06288247555494308, 0.0013403657358139753, -0.03605368733406067, -0.01953771337866783, -0.007535768207162619, 0.008283916860818863, 0.013362064026296139, 0.014035556465387344, 0.03739418834447861, 0.015475021675229073, -0.012746765278279781, -0.07837632298469543, 0.023176081478595734, -0.030730677768588066, 0.04878801479935646, 0.01865655742585659, 0.014512001536786556, 0.059069715440273285, -0.004843449220061302, -0.053440384566783905, 0.017209334298968315, 0.04042334854602814, 0.06135070323944092, -0.0362376794219017, 0.032710686326026917, 0.01426293421536684, 0.05185854807496071, 0.030931688845157623, 0.008752746507525444, -0.011272160336375237, -0.004406038671731949, 0.036657001823186874, 0.021006153896450996, -0.023191196843981743, -0.020098986104130745, 0.057397957891225815, 0.001505578518845141, -0.0993461012840271, -0.004469933453947306, 0.015389556996524334, -0.038782279938459396, 0.014279494993388653, -0.0585162527859211, 0.007826329208910465, -0.0019712995272129774, -0.004688095301389694, 0.00607501482591033, 0.011742803268134594, 0.020401425659656525, 0.03910220414400101, -0.004187865182757378, -0.06222951412200928, 0.010938919149339199, 0.04695364087820053, 0.05494954064488411, -0.02329271100461483, 0.03946956619620323, 0.00282594608142972, 0.016342544928193092, -0.022536616772413254, -0.028872931376099586, -0.09568136930465698, 0.012352601625025272, -0.027936087921261787, 0.012666760012507439, 0.020235035568475723, -0.008173029869794846, -0.02027198299765587, -0.057559311389923096, 0.057148516178131104, -0.021988874301314354, 0.011546563357114792, -0.008141763508319855, -0.01717698760330677, 0.02451019361615181, 0.017619889229536057, 0.00542620150372386, 0.004713311791419983, -0.006302237510681152, 0.06841161102056503, 0.0031401459127664566, 0.012744897976517677, 0.041878022253513336, 0.029513442888855934, 0.016883686184883118, -0.007815117947757244, 0.023945199325680733, 0.00037194849574007094, -0.013541101478040218, -0.02401231974363327, 0.06135190650820732, -0.02330557443201542, 0.0010993721662089229, 0.02030932903289795, -0.03674842417240143, -0.037183310836553574, 0.06327683478593826, -0.036745574325323105, -0.026779575273394585, -0.0219154991209507, 0.0511302575469017, -0.031524408608675, 0.015478883869946003, -0.062143731862306595, -0.018770979717373848, 0.013645892031490803, 0.013563886284828186, 0.037736523896455765, 0.005415224935859442, -0.027192745357751846, 0.02325320430099964, 0.0028769539203494787, 0.05262906104326248, 0.03199252486228943, -0.054723404347896576, 0.02975025586783886, 0.004733645357191563, 0.0009545807261019945, -0.01453220285475254, -0.00479279225692153, -0.03400268778204918, 0.008280206471681595, 0.041969820857048035, -0.03444972634315491, 0.03528463840484619, 0.028967181220650673, -0.035094309598207474, 0.016820745542645454, 0.03873710706830025, -0.01960669830441475, -0.04343658313155174, 0.0380496010184288, 0.02807851880788803, 0.0623619519174099, -0.02328009344637394, 0.020993990823626518, -0.010493465699255466, -0.016750335693359375, 0.019769802689552307, -0.010413939133286476, 0.018595268949866295, 0.016339868307113647, -0.0016203282866626978, -0.03957465663552284, 0.07975500077009201, 0.01151270978152752, 0.04345643147826195, -0.03142499551177025, 0.024635272100567818, -0.023755725473165512, 0.021061867475509644, -0.03460916504263878, 0.0014811703003942966, 0.04836806654930115, -0.05377691239118576, -0.0558859221637249, -0.014076353050768375, -0.01342104747891426, -0.00824213307350874, -0.06843538582324982, 0.01198331918567419, 0.016498537734150887, -0.03953208774328232, -0.0635150894522667, 0.009005141444504261, -0.028935924172401428, 0.00893476139754057, -0.00849209912121296, 0.029122166335582733, -0.032564155757427216, -0.03445951268076897, -0.0005807820125482976, -0.002868583658710122, 0.01636572554707527, -0.0033774643670767546, -0.03983389213681221, 0.037763118743896484, 0.001476329518482089, 0.021998919546604156, 0.0106814531609416, -0.0033847785089164972, 0.0191898625344038, 0.03051057457923889, -0.022367767989635468, 0.022728076204657555, -0.016651660203933716, -0.028992945328354836, 0.0434107631444931, -0.019560201093554497, -0.02513856813311577, -0.03679734095931053, 0.0225047804415226, 0.03216461464762688, 0.02214124985039234, -0.04781094938516617, -0.061680473387241364, -0.03523322567343712, 0.014601508155465126, 0.0428435243666172, -0.07285752147436142, -0.009361913427710533, -0.004012976307421923, 0.054623719304800034, -0.032615356147289276, -0.018535694107413292, 0.06818420439958572, 0.006032723933458328, 0.07846406102180481, 0.028351176530122757, 0.0016455973964184523, 0.06698762625455856, 0.03928966820240021, -0.04128522425889969, -0.053197797387838364, -0.021053971722722054, -0.009019564837217331, -0.03758656978607178, -0.02727588824927807, -0.05348540097475052, -0.04026050493121147, 0.014500629156827927, -0.03629179298877716, 0.01571015641093254, -0.04467049241065979, 0.0462939590215683, 0.008190036751329899, 0.015355629846453667, -0.03030167892575264, 0.014404026791453362, 0.041398536413908005, 0.014638151042163372, -0.014227617532014847, -0.01907229609787464, 0.02015349641442299, -0.07465715706348419, 0.030208619311451912, -0.015056461095809937, -0.01096290722489357, -0.05250554531812668, 0.0030106811318546534, -0.0013241658452898264, -0.004852809943258762, -0.04188153147697449, -0.030490323901176453, 0.05400688946247101, -0.013188538141548634, 0.018894651904702187, -0.03427305445075035, -0.07824867218732834, 0.033330246806144714, -0.04264221340417862, 0.019596755504608154, -0.04366108030080795, -0.026903221383690834, 0.01590198092162609, -0.019582269713282585, -0.01588626019656658, -0.00841646920889616, 0.08338651061058044, -0.018985707312822342, -0.0816003829240799, 0.093280129134655, 0.0679505318403244, 0.02957850880920887, -0.03869089484214783, -0.009079120121896267, -0.039434097707271576, 0.0009870893554762006, -0.010103734210133553, 0.058083150535821915, 0.02930944412946701, 0.00922253169119358, 0.018883051350712776, -0.046668507158756256, -0.013150917366147041, 0.0069018094800412655, -0.029065145179629326, -0.023866821080446243, 0.007512069772928953 ]
<p>Conventional horizontal axis wind turbines use lift force generated in the blades to turn a turbine. </p> <p>But what is the mechanics of vertical axis wind turbine? What would be the free body diagram of the blades of a VAWT? </p> <p>Is Vertical axis wind turbine more efficient that a horizontal axis wind turbine?</p>
g5887
[ 0.03114890865981579, 0.046203870326280594, -0.01658596843481064, -0.0009798118844628334, -0.01879850961267948, 0.002524923300370574, 0.03441733121871948, -0.0178288072347641, -0.0077392347157001495, -0.008065775968134403, 0.0017622057348489761, 0.046386875212192535, 0.025880787521600723, -0.05142882838845253, 0.021987810730934143, 0.023383399471640587, -0.05697523057460785, -0.008734618313610554, 0.008078484795987606, 0.037322454154491425, 0.04703665152192116, -0.023676235228776932, -0.04300249367952347, 0.01672532968223095, -0.046789102256298065, -0.01174202375113964, -0.059047117829322815, 0.03172338008880615, -0.015938883647322655, -0.0007489434210583568, 0.006494189612567425, 0.061146825551986694, 0.046291936188936234, 0.007880344055593014, -0.07471192628145218, 0.0172521211206913, 0.024151084944605827, -0.0076043205335736275, -0.01480406429618597, 0.0007382334442809224, -0.026590997353196144, 0.030677160248160362, -0.033543944358825684, 0.021382544189691544, -0.04032541811466217, -0.020613618195056915, 0.010241322219371796, -0.05242041125893593, -0.052771471440792084, -0.05056603625416756, 0.004956751596182585, -0.06927713006734848, 0.025388825684785843, -0.035193637013435364, 0.028604647144675255, -0.02942141704261303, 0.09022165089845657, -0.003275752067565918, 0.0014113157521933317, -0.019708354026079178, -0.04022274166345596, 0.027089407667517662, -0.006559536326676607, 0.0445111021399498, 0.02843739092350006, -0.07443930208683014, -0.019703371450304985, -0.0020188051275908947, 0.05320657417178154, -0.05129414424300194, -0.010437280870974064, -0.050752751529216766, 0.06335794925689697, -0.02135731466114521, -0.0014359483029693365, 0.024089161306619644, -0.04206036776304245, -0.04762105271220207, -0.014237129129469395, -0.037589069455862045, 0.008752016350626945, -0.023747742176055908, -0.037844326347112656, -0.03000221587717533, 0.09240724891424179, -0.0339353121817112, -0.024330386891961098, 0.013592815957963467, -0.009973349049687386, 0.00849427841603756, 0.018059017136693, -0.009674549102783203, 0.025755221024155617, 0.00046601996291428804, -0.07753784209489822, -0.01089597400277853, -0.016683591529726982, 0.03885253518819809, -0.006633859593421221, -0.020247286185622215, 0.005174541380256414, -0.00838780589401722, -0.019038809463381767, -0.02297031879425049, 0.07189826667308807, -0.03319938853383064, 0.04410502314567566, -0.012416644021868706, -0.029726356267929077, 0.007420817855745554, -0.05489038676023483, -0.03051093779504299, -0.015668345615267754, 0.018390681594610214, -0.015539520420134068, -0.004482725169509649, 0.07237442582845688, -0.013270788826048374, 0.048828646540641785, -0.006670750677585602, 0.01602635532617569, 0.05502483248710632, -0.060490164905786514, -0.014005475677549839, -0.059390902519226074, -0.06108812615275383, 0.0010034105507656932, -0.024788469076156616, -0.025958364829421043, 0.00014810760330874473, 0.07962248474359512, -0.0176999494433403, -0.033737778663635254, 0.018278712406754494, 0.10429321974515915, 0.08333656936883926, -0.04665301367640495, -0.037312719970941544, 0.07629476487636566, -0.0075540076941251755, -0.028921451419591904, -0.029091883450746536, 0.018971938639879227, -0.024907853454351425, 0.022688420489430428, 0.02757788635790348, 0.0007163838017731905, -0.00625710329040885, -0.0480877086520195, -0.023085087537765503, 0.001498628407716751, 0.028981627896428108, 0.021163107827305794, -0.057862456887960434, 0.006362212356179953, -0.047654107213020325, 0.032857563346624374, 0.04870224371552467, 0.00019205152057111263, 0.0029371073469519615, 0.025351833552122116, 0.005358509719371796, 0.0665956512093544, -0.010930394753813744, -0.04486936703324318, -0.030476197600364685, -0.02044108510017395, -0.03098725527524948, 0.010375501587986946, -0.001760875340551138, -0.037947967648506165, -0.03815699368715286, 0.05258054658770561, 0.05377812311053276, 0.025668159127235413, -0.003915378823876381, -0.01792128011584282, -0.012403927743434906, -0.0073791490867733955, 0.002689130837097764, 0.013143324293196201, 0.04291504621505737, 0.001072643673978746, -0.01967374049127102, -0.021582087501883507, -0.015199564397335052, -0.02689177542924881, -0.009960480034351349, -0.0017035099444910884, 0.017154617235064507, -0.009974222630262375, 0.03919636830687523, 0.0264140572398901, 0.037362128496170044, -0.03962510824203491, 0.010207464918494225, 0.00025942287174984813, -0.0006748649757355452, -0.009565930813550949, 0.002610851312056184, 0.006416396703571081, -0.01107074785977602, 0.03849831596016884, -0.01378911454230547, -0.020160865038633347, -0.018213368952274323, -0.008593675680458546, 0.0046765669248998165, 0.03387584537267685, -0.03174365311861038, -0.038979947566986084, 0.021926218643784523, 0.06379374116659164, -0.008946413174271584, -0.025209352374076843, 0.018765060231089592, -0.022969352081418037, -0.027892565354704857, -0.06944537162780762, -0.0021050472278147936, 0.08675333857536316, -0.049909647554159164, 0.02579069696366787, 0.01342387218028307, -0.05450263246893883, -0.020952479913830757, 0.006171700544655323, -0.0057392418384552, 0.005854511167854071, -0.036185529083013535, -0.014128899201750755, -0.012502942234277725, 0.02063046395778656, -0.02386733517050743, 0.04370325431227684, 0.040540698915719986, -0.009340669959783554, 0.09799817949533463, 0.019061660394072533, -0.006839278619736433, 0.06795469671487808, -0.04675760120153427, 0.012608842924237251, 0.018913328647613525, 0.048819418996572495, 0.005064832977950573, 0.06281495839357376, -0.03531403839588165, 0.016147641465067863, 0.01719937101006508, 0.006809396203607321, -0.017690464854240417, 0.03958699852228165, 0.07168856263160706, -0.04915742203593254, 0.011162436567246914, -0.003609192091971636, -0.013746264390647411, -0.033086154609918594, 0.020927703008055687, -0.021641939878463745, 0.014955762773752213, -0.009454268962144852, 0.03891109675168991, -0.02461559884250164, 0.026983018964529037, -0.01787048578262329, 0.006177459377795458, -0.03345010057091713, -0.00746732484549284, -0.017921239137649536, 0.014508035033941269, -0.039046648889780045, -0.026065995916724205, -0.05369499698281288, -0.0401662215590477, 0.054114583879709244, 0.062092773616313934, -0.03242543712258339, -0.009109904989600182, 0.03544388711452484, -0.011741855181753635, 0.008042769506573677, 0.03787735849618912, 0.041018206626176834, 0.05626228451728821, -0.03015293926000595, -0.06558705866336823, -0.10132484138011932, 0.016287188977003098, -0.02730076014995575, 0.021802175790071487, 0.0049637905322015285, -0.05949174985289574, 0.006804112810641527, 0.009596800431609154, 0.05713462457060814, 0.03248260170221329, -0.06618726998567581, -0.00729806162416935, -0.07713702321052551, -0.00539100356400013, 0.004198422189801931, 0.042881738394498825, -0.031596530228853226, 0.0026956102810800076, 0.03353842347860336, -0.08803579956293106, 0.023587068542838097, 0.035215284675359726, -0.015208853408694267, 0.017735576257109642, 0.019201137125492096, -0.03132631629705429, -0.0697464570403099, -0.009125234559178352, -0.03618763014674187, 0.0025097501929849386, -0.10284893214702606, 0.029103433713316917, -0.018401317298412323, -0.05137234181165695, 0.027298178523778915, 0.04387293756008148, -0.04917526617646217, 0.029930537566542625, -0.014118516817688942, -0.010822745971381664, 0.009645885787904263, -0.01675761677324772, 0.033002834767103195, 0.032596323639154434, -0.0008857562788762152, -0.01295515801757574, -0.01124827191233635, 0.0051216850988566875, 0.039172977209091187, 0.004996201954782009, 0.020263705402612686, -0.014987143687903881, 0.036651115864515305, -0.06910676509141922, -0.06762922555208206, -0.00013887106615584344, -0.048483956605196, -0.005138021893799305, -0.056457772850990295, -0.0218375101685524, 0.0602613128721714, -0.04339785501360893, -0.02186349593102932, -0.03779947757720947, -0.014032294973731041, -0.027174757793545723, 0.07340782135725021, -0.027294699102640152, 0.04000868648290634, 0.0448419451713562, -0.020638063549995422, 0.03633572906255722, 0.010340429842472076, 0.0235957782715559, -0.015243323519825935, 0.012831761501729488, -0.06721015274524689, 0.038581375032663345, -0.010376563295722008, 0.044186852872371674, 0.020563241094350815, -0.020345475524663925, -0.041015781462192535, 0.007133333012461662, 0.020355504006147385, 0.003550727851688862, -0.03815078362822533, 0.06925046443939209, 0.10903467237949371, 0.009206211194396019, 0.028610700741410255, 0.020531583577394485, 0.06386438757181168, 0.0029929971788078547, 0.011448412202298641, 0.011326676234602928, -0.0451577827334404, -0.026469893753528595, -0.1050952598452568, 0.05538642778992653, -0.009224051609635353, -0.030941175296902657, 0.0007304374012164772, -0.015654046088457108, -0.05806415528059006, -0.04178311303257942, -0.005131770856678486, 0.032851945608854294, 0.026152031496167183, 0.05445270612835884, -0.01046010758727789, 0.031455498188734055, 0.05318472906947136, 0.0370798259973526, -0.01440009567886591, 0.02315334975719452, 0.014477352611720562, 0.06778642535209656, -0.022377928718924522, -0.012799973599612713, -0.0007060372154228389, 0.007216373458504677, 0.0485239215195179, 0.010001422837376595, 0.0005283807986415923, -0.029543215408921242, -0.004787496756762266, -0.007270673755556345, -0.017567867413163185, -0.012482022866606712, 0.026176583021879196, 0.07663878053426743, 0.008076469413936138, 0.035343237221241, 0.03355957195162773, 0.021127276122570038, -0.028005238622426987, 0.07197602838277817, 0.018180979415774345, -0.024684617295861244, -0.07312759757041931, -0.02933702990412712, 0.06992383301258087, 0.00603279285132885, -0.007446082774549723, -0.0373447984457016, -0.005985849071294069, 0.05064413696527481, 0.018810832872986794, 0.024177351966500282, 0.030776843428611755, 0.0035085624549537897, 0.03270158916711807, -0.01980852149426937, -0.04568232223391533, -0.05478382855653763, -0.0545354038476944, -0.009103076532483101, 0.05066762864589691, -0.03833543136715889, -0.007702114060521126, -0.05085930600762367, -0.03708888590335846, 0.00043484708294272423, -0.008192094042897224, -0.08503847569227219, 0.05038149282336235, -0.008316232822835445, 0.011417916975915432, -0.04312912002205849, 0.013778779655694962, 0.006686489097774029, -0.02184467390179634, 0.0385974645614624, 0.05386069416999817, -0.019087878987193108, 0.04088297486305237, -0.022217845544219017, -0.0023145826999098063, 0.0063528819009661674, -0.06733497977256775, 0.0035024078097194433, 0.008588857017457485, 0.0066721620969474316, 0.016953375190496445, 0.09582624584436417, -0.024675797671079636, 0.02466486021876335, 0.011754753068089485, -0.02230260707437992, 0.04628010466694832, -0.0064817131496965885, 0.05269109457731247, 0.0046209972351789474, 0.01208144798874855, 0.0015509279910475016, 0.004543023649603128, -0.057897936552762985, -0.02536243572831154, 0.025553477928042412, 0.015405463986098766, -0.045279912650585175, -0.04425392299890518, 0.026797261089086533, -0.06945708394050598, -0.08904275298118591, -0.0055435230024158955, -0.05529002845287323, -0.017458420246839523, -0.06767170131206512, 0.028234025463461876, 0.0298549123108387, -0.04077882319688797, 0.023748179897665977, -0.0032011696603149176, -0.04396935924887657, -0.0039035577792674303, 0.06211969256401062, 0.04710569605231285, -0.011615104041993618, -0.029853522777557373, 0.07284505665302277, -0.0633409172296524, -0.05333571508526802, -0.004503320436924696, 0.020171020179986954, 0.0374789722263813, -0.0024559227749705315, 0.03340264409780502, -0.01588953100144863, 0.07144319266080856, 0.007662782911211252, 0.019022207707166672, 0.026522722095251083, 0.0013372903922572732, -0.0021198545582592487, -0.0306076779961586, 0.03239454701542854, -0.08385910838842392, 0.010960303246974945, -0.05266561731696129, 0.013396427035331726, -0.013513447716832161, -0.029243187978863716, 0.06205245852470398, 0.037185147404670715, 0.024454353377223015, -0.006341881118714809, 0.04178190231323242, -0.03768428415060043, 0.04306347668170929, -0.01960759051144123, -0.006950863171368837, 0.008858997374773026, -0.02288486808538437, 0.03749135136604309, 0.018748361617326736, -0.04188843071460724, -0.02144996076822281, 0.02322177216410637, 0.009789813309907913, 0.02371135726571083, -0.04120399430394173, 0.026506084948778152, 0.037784356623888016, -0.01049887016415596, -0.06169609725475311, -0.001265882165171206, -0.06325694173574448, -0.05077151581645012, 0.03015405498445034, -0.031088639050722122, 0.02225804701447487, 0.05365179851651192, 0.004901493899524212, -0.024559909477829933, 0.011673547327518463, -0.01576291397213936, -0.00045897692325524986, 0.035118017345666885, 0.07878924906253815, 0.017303183674812317, 0.01175693515688181, 0.05273979902267456, -0.01704905554652214, 0.03854526951909065, 0.018712960183620453, -0.011678333394229412, 0.0013238451210781932, -0.016804635524749756, 0.0002670167596079409, -0.02740653231739998, -0.0011091368505731225, -0.02554275654256344, 0.04548337310552597, -0.00762547692283988, 0.008504445664584637, 0.03631700575351715, -0.07011615484952927, -0.023594096302986145, -0.07638697326183319, 0.04337872937321663, -0.022701257839798927, 0.02589031495153904, -0.018560539931058884, 0.01612026058137417, 0.015075982548296452, 0.0018243726808577776, -0.015720337629318237, 0.07722963392734528, 0.03141919896006584, -0.020185604691505432, 0.04172937572002411, 0.08631594479084015, -0.006854633335024118, 0.009951405227184296, 0.0363527312874794, 0.014866023324429989, 0.013295479118824005, 0.0408039353787899, -0.037466466426849365, -0.05824819579720497, 0.05763011798262596, 0.005362523719668388, 0.0722104161977768, -0.00037652647006325424, -0.030984550714492798, 0.03280937671661377, 0.0023338934406638145, 0.004735385533422232, 0.019665071740746498, 0.052144065499305725, 0.02505434677004814, -0.04998885095119476, 0.016755221411585808, -0.07021753489971161, 0.022687111049890518, -0.0006155283190310001, -0.023140808567404747, 0.011172287166118622, 0.07178559899330139, 0.006316155195236206, -0.03234294801950455, 0.05539528280496597, 0.01843622513115406, 0.07090388238430023, -0.006321025546640158, 0.013554266653954983, -0.04116720333695412, 0.016732381656765938, 0.05011557415127754, 0.01380834262818098, -0.016989799216389656, 0.04536684975028038, -0.014526817947626114, -0.004935144446790218, -0.002184455981478095, 0.020155852660536766, 0.01448713056743145, -0.038747306913137436, 0.018538106232881546, 0.018314877524971962, -0.02458074688911438, 0.03102681413292885, -0.01298714429140091, -0.01627478003501892, -0.0874984934926033, 0.03733697161078453, -0.04063965752720833, 0.022520840167999268, 0.007473780307918787, 0.02195231430232525, 0.0077415574342012405, 0.08208847790956497, 0.06294233351945877, 0.0797753855586052, 0.058747030794620514, -0.02448360249400139, -0.010373559780418873, 0.013706854544579983, 0.03446071594953537, 0.05183921754360199, 0.03481695055961609, 0.02224775217473507, -0.03878272324800491, -0.010650895535945892, 0.009294457733631134, -0.053305212408304214, -0.08638645708560944, -0.03856084495782852, -0.05000962316989899, -0.05809340998530388, -0.03407960385084152, 0.024320410564541817, 0.008451665751636028, 0.06585590541362762, -0.033909521996974945, 0.046613723039627075, -0.010404637083411217, 0.03636504337191582, 0.005991773679852486, 0.007750885561108589, -0.03433694690465927, 0.0028945652302354574, 0.038299310952425, -0.03954311087727547, -0.031072717159986496, 0.0005783275119028986, 0.04223780706524849, 0.006794942542910576, -0.002313271164894104, 0.009167325682938099, 0.054650336503982544, 0.028914164751768112, 0.02723112888634205, 0.01569097861647606, 0.0019523606169968843, -0.024304812774062157, -0.01362540666013956, 0.015739522874355316, -0.02940288744866848, 0.007398501969873905, 0.018637588247656822, -0.04331526532769203, 0.028944576159119606, 0.011162110604345798, -0.08026877045631409, -0.02531270496547222, -0.04089339077472687, -0.021068889647722244, -0.05010253190994263, 0.03876204043626785, -0.010226605460047722, 0.0013971327571198344, -0.017073754221200943, -0.05655300244688988, -0.014199201948940754, -0.002690800465643406, 0.052557144314050674, -0.018445609137415886, -0.021873360499739647, -0.043071601539850235, -0.014894554391503334, -0.0377233512699604, 0.024667147547006607, 0.040480200201272964, -0.05090988799929619, 0.007276811171323061, -0.0019901280757039785, -0.0018674578750506043, -0.026495644822716713, -0.0102757653221488, 0.013455094769597054, 0.018114110454916954, -0.06468026340007782, -0.042723774909973145, -0.011676326394081116, 0.0017213337123394012, -0.0008946519810706377, 0.032222386449575424, -0.016555124893784523, 0.024799270555377007, 0.021924922242760658, 0.028902603313326836, 0.007698563858866692, -0.039782896637916565, -0.017029397189617157, 0.0036582534667104483, -0.01745390146970749, 0.025686465203762054, 0.006057337857782841, 0.03991902992129326, -0.027136558666825294, 0.04586426913738251, 0.007936566136777401, -0.012617149390280247, -0.02730442024767399, 0.0012399819679558277, -0.042897142469882965, -0.0033801656682044268 ]
<p>I would like to know how important the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_censorship_hypothesis" rel="nofollow">cosmic censorship conjecture</a> is? Should a quantum theory of gravity must obey this? It was never rigorously proved in classical GR too. What would be the consequences if it turns out that CCC (weak) does not hold?</p>
g5888
[ 0.025714967399835587, 0.06392848491668701, 0.02479413151741028, -0.005001329816877842, -0.0064457436092197895, 0.019148197025060654, 0.030266154557466507, -0.018261076882481575, -0.07297737896442413, 0.0032490913290530443, 0.021468380466103554, 0.01892484351992607, 0.028612535446882248, 0.034627966582775116, -0.031059622764587402, 0.041761890053749084, 0.030056936666369438, 0.01136956550180912, -0.0022314400412142277, -0.03585074469447136, 0.03886902332305908, -0.024539340287446976, 0.02206522971391678, -0.05454794317483902, 0.003242901526391506, -0.02326648123562336, 0.08649268746376038, -0.08206712454557419, -0.050777290016412735, 0.004329085815697908, -0.0012109302915632725, 0.06070397049188614, 0.013029910624027252, -0.06851660460233688, -0.018111808225512505, -0.03677993640303612, 0.06023562327027321, 0.07936661690473557, -0.011118950322270393, -0.00041638812399469316, -0.007826591841876507, 0.0716736763715744, -0.039009012281894684, -0.025214606896042824, 0.00042087602196261287, -0.030542228370904922, -0.012426657602190971, 0.017430657520890236, 0.0650189146399498, -0.06959862262010574, -0.022134369239211082, 0.042446568608284, 0.030683686956763268, 0.012256517075002193, -0.03074624203145504, -0.029850056394934654, 0.008801090531051159, -0.0241911131888628, 0.024124199524521828, -0.05818590149283409, -0.0003386121243238449, -0.01039684284478426, 0.04085258021950722, 0.011770748533308506, -0.0069312164559960365, 0.03486284986138344, -0.04825592041015625, 0.0056012896820902824, 0.023731742054224014, 0.0519305057823658, -0.03385940194129944, -0.05582842603325844, -0.015114177018404007, -0.02783196046948433, -0.01623491197824478, 0.03688174486160278, 0.02310517244040966, -0.0015888313064351678, 0.010778108611702919, -0.0005530944326892495, -0.06106565147638321, -0.010216780938208103, 0.019821705296635628, -0.043924931436777115, -0.019061261788010597, -0.02581501193344593, -0.04985074698925018, -0.021670665591955185, 0.0319448783993721, 0.044374771416187286, 0.026812465861439705, -0.06787413358688354, -0.0032352616544812918, -0.036559052765369415, 0.08708909898996353, 0.01578773744404316, -0.02261270023882389, 0.07459051162004471, -0.014133374206721783, 0.07008520513772964, -0.02883974276483059, -0.009562532417476177, 0.0037562663201242685, 0.015138025395572186, 0.05752072110772133, -0.03949888423085213, 0.06197613477706909, 0.011404038406908512, 0.03354286774992943, 0.011912806890904903, -0.02507873624563217, -0.01860050857067108, -0.01809094287455082, -0.0038268479984253645, -0.029160967096686363, -0.029361454769968987, 0.06410061568021774, -0.024459417909383774, 0.043077122420072556, 0.039880573749542236, -0.0441913977265358, 0.04076157510280609, 0.033665772527456284, 0.016085287556052208, -0.0877164751291275, -0.01415594108402729, 0.009393141604959965, -0.01429226715117693, 0.021212385967373848, -0.040018703788518906, -0.02762850932776928, 0.017783084884285927, 0.0020578172989189625, 0.08442820608615875, -0.019320936873555183, -0.010597147047519684, 0.06369934976100922, -0.01446840912103653, -0.01858719065785408, -0.052565935999155045, -0.019572418183088303, -0.003024881472811103, 0.08125683665275574, 0.027840537950396538, 0.01859879307448864, -0.039953090250492096, -0.014607373625040054, 0.04731208458542824, 0.021449781954288483, -0.01746569573879242, 0.0006456435658037663, 0.006426421459764242, 0.06118070334196091, -0.034794218838214874, 0.003843634156510234, 0.007587829139083624, 0.019495490938425064, 0.010142919607460499, -0.00013037509052082896, -0.0023213413078337908, 0.024310698732733727, 0.017544979229569435, 0.017271433025598526, 0.004399408586323261, -0.03221725672483444, 0.05268464237451553, 0.006301625166088343, 0.01567280851304531, -0.0592094287276268, -0.059397436678409576, -0.06601117551326752, 0.049735721200704575, -0.02199111133813858, -0.007259702775627375, -0.01673985831439495, 0.04642737656831741, -0.022288182750344276, 0.02163929119706154, -0.0095431013032794, -0.015255820006132126, -0.028742747381329536, -0.010588603094220161, -0.03478379547595978, -0.012543296441435814, 0.00020999787375330925, -0.041322268545627594, -0.014904347248375416, -0.014668949879705906, -0.03826599940657616, 0.004227614030241966, -0.023418165743350983, 0.01876019313931465, -0.02476247400045395, 0.04613741487264633, -0.02698969654738903, -0.01262850221246481, 0.011109056882560253, 0.009561022743582726, -0.012487574480473995, 0.0387236587703228, -0.021595235913991928, 0.046251822263002396, 0.09388050436973572, -0.030102944001555443, -0.010961845517158508, -0.005750051699578762, 0.006357682403177023, 0.010094589553773403, 0.0103203309699893, -0.03505278378725052, 0.06176886707544327, -0.05038949102163315, 0.03551526367664337, 0.025518624112010002, 0.0033057210966944695, -0.0063121686689555645, 0.016422564163804054, 0.008680254220962524, -0.032360419631004333, 0.03939921408891678, -0.031307246536016464, -0.018601814284920692, 0.020449185743927956, -0.02797185629606247, 0.032655682414770126, 0.0053575122728943825, -0.08018097281455994, -0.07989459484815598, 0.010767816565930843, 0.02134053222835064, 0.030064715072512627, -0.014426343142986298, -0.04009358584880829, 0.004608365707099438, -0.017544038593769073, 0.047315485775470734, 0.03076174668967724, 0.005422480404376984, 0.05870627239346504, 0.03355090320110321, -0.008093819953501225, -0.02880598045885563, -0.02642867900431156, -0.048471998423337936, 0.07587922364473343, -0.02790692262351513, -0.027899445965886116, -0.03887514770030975, -0.021072370931506157, -0.0051564923487603664, -0.042114824056625366, -0.010603944770991802, 0.012080090120434761, 0.03596784546971321, 0.008242533542215824, 0.023248519748449326, 0.009049184620380402, -0.0007556340424343944, -0.06452348828315735, -0.032118432223796844, 0.03081664815545082, -0.06331150978803635, 0.007024042773991823, -0.07342849671840668, -0.04385712742805481, -0.004988532047718763, -0.026065215468406677, 0.0191468708217144, -0.024209661409258842, 0.01785852387547493, -0.03169795498251915, 0.024552300572395325, -0.026126839220523834, 0.02140454389154911, -0.04115943983197212, 0.02197817713022232, -0.02079198881983757, 0.03300458565354347, -0.01725488156080246, -0.00821439828723669, -0.011461202055215836, 0.07420682907104492, 0.01996677927672863, -0.024704864248633385, -0.008172151632606983, -0.04211011901497841, -0.08734168112277985, 0.01798221468925476, -0.0015730652958154678, -0.000135832407977432, 0.009543122723698616, 0.05473698675632477, 0.05315227434039116, 0.07662985473871231, -0.027251843363046646, -0.01571994088590145, -0.02383415214717388, 0.02547433227300644, -0.04436614364385605, 0.025579752400517464, 0.03101038746535778, -0.005777609534561634, -0.03099703975021839, 0.041609056293964386, -0.006605983711779118, -0.00776015967130661, 0.004124002065509558, 0.03837469592690468, 0.05284300446510315, 0.00548419589176774, 0.01742495782673359, 0.06902092695236206, 0.06747570633888245, 0.05524272099137306, 0.016680404543876648, -0.01493937335908413, -0.010744672268629074, 0.04303409159183502, 0.01753334328532219, -0.04527690261602402, -0.010172148235142231, 0.04638215899467468, -0.019411487504839897, -0.0031987084075808525, 0.0666813999414444, -0.00806623138487339, -0.03885616734623909, -0.017739374190568924, 0.01158868707716465, -0.03282196447253227, 0.049433622509241104, -0.0039059175178408623, 0.011071113869547844, -0.018844297155737877, -0.054262369871139526, -0.017476681619882584, 0.04344020411372185, -0.008102997206151485, -0.021991437301039696, 0.04413773491978645, -0.06006966158747673, -0.01224429626017809, -0.024160558357834816, 0.021023768931627274, 0.043474629521369934, 0.07396768033504486, -0.005625783000141382, 0.03971436247229576, -0.023128783330321312, 0.013573135249316692, -0.002277588937431574, -0.05140040069818497, 0.05558177828788757, -0.027083948254585266, 0.03386373817920685, 0.03300880640745163, 0.02779078111052513, 0.027025174349546432, 0.04316651076078415, 0.0029336053412407637, -0.002204991178587079, 0.013792190700769424, 0.017947668209671974, 0.05384136363863945, 0.013723592273890972, 0.03762080520391464, -0.044830046594142914, -0.03484972193837166, -0.021000631153583527, 0.03622075170278549, -0.01607447862625122, -0.02688772790133953, -0.006544047966599464, 0.05097541958093643, 0.09085386991500854, -0.03235112503170967, 0.011539341881871223, 0.05369303748011589, -0.030882863327860832, -0.0065826852805912495, 0.014661034569144249, 0.02830263413488865, 0.012875489890575409, -0.046632688492536545, 0.029763774946331978, -0.04479912668466568, -0.03193014860153198, -0.04870924726128578, 0.012078028172254562, -0.05329476296901703, -0.001755446195602417, -0.04411689564585686, -0.0300345066934824, 0.04026778042316437, 0.012044349685311317, -0.0299176424741745, 0.020367775112390518, -0.041898179799318314, -0.0022458573803305626, -0.026435069739818573, 0.05392756313085556, 0.019769709557294846, 0.01989923231303692, 0.03128700703382492, -0.035845231264829636, 0.001978245098143816, 0.01676870509982109, -0.01223119255155325, -0.010034885257482529, -0.005881024990230799, 0.04124587029218674, -0.048549309372901917, -0.06301001459360123, -0.03303144872188568, 0.04938891902565956, -0.012435135431587696, -0.01949194073677063, -0.021951796486973763, 0.022332116961479187, 0.03248303011059761, 0.006285371258854866, 0.09132563322782516, 0.0015703109093010426, -0.017104027792811394, 0.03481978178024292, 0.06256376206874847, -0.02694673091173172, -0.015274728648364544, -0.03396274149417877, 0.01367065031081438, 0.006648175418376923, -0.01545871514827013, 0.04018848016858101, -0.0021251565776765347, 0.01181885413825512, -0.013290027156472206, -0.04200061783194542, 0.050325218588113785, -0.011425136588513851, -0.0020647477358579636, 0.07434552162885666, -0.06571643054485321, 0.017968056723475456, -0.04983021691441536, -0.008032684214413166, 0.06069307029247284, -0.04887800291180611, 0.023265663534402847, 0.0028818047139793634, -0.027762891724705696, 0.031138118356466293, -0.005814030300825834, -0.016273342072963715, -0.0053915223106741905, -0.06447836011648178, 0.03800888732075691, 0.010380501858890057, -0.02000443823635578, 0.03459920734167099, 0.02172093279659748, -0.035496391355991364, 0.01428514625877142, 0.0527229942381382, 0.0362284854054451, 0.04709198698401451, 0.018994560465216637, -0.021051334217190742, -0.010651529766619205, -0.04465202987194061, -0.041960977017879486, -0.003975682891905308, 0.0014097592793405056, 0.055803969502449036, 0.01301791425794363, -0.0896337702870369, -0.01240380946546793, 0.05103928595781326, 0.000736155838239938, 0.01042401697486639, 0.023006442934274673, 0.025298552587628365, 0.0332661047577858, 0.054614532738924026, 0.0016557443886995316, 0.05800721049308777, -0.024135641753673553, -0.05467788875102997, 0.00837406050413847, -0.026343366131186485, -0.004011858720332384, -0.023172983899712563, -0.014877146109938622, -0.01313474215567112, 0.035797808319330215, -0.018544744700193405, -0.021800749003887177, -0.03122173622250557, -0.038465097546577454, -0.030536338686943054, 0.05778449773788452, 0.026320993900299072, -0.016364557668566704, 0.08352497220039368, 0.025594187900424004, -0.045461151748895645, 0.0456465519964695, 0.014459666796028614, -0.006622927263379097, -0.03516156226396561, 0.04956598952412605, -0.03045273944735527, -0.067848801612854, -0.03429156914353371, 0.043039850890636444, 0.06688124686479568, 0.024381937459111214, -0.05534708872437477, -0.023801960051059723, -0.0415964350104332, -0.05952952429652214, 0.04042915254831314, 0.029562830924987793, 0.0045726122334599495, 0.019079241901636124, 0.051323480904102325, -0.042054999619722366, -0.01062250230461359, 0.019132135435938835, 0.0461161769926548, 0.027394648641347885, -0.036276333034038544, 0.005214621778577566, -0.020332014188170433, 0.02502359077334404, 0.06739245355129242, 0.01131716649979353, 0.059517353773117065, 0.0379239022731781, 0.010678507387638092, -0.012785092927515507, -0.034806590527296066, 0.01716512255370617, -0.01301363855600357, 0.038497116416692734, -0.013337171636521816, 0.011144926771521568, -0.03197942674160004, -0.02347239851951599, 0.018981117755174637, -0.0834536999464035, -0.011472911573946476, -0.03782396763563156, 0.005125371739268303, 0.061044178903102875, 0.020242663100361824, -0.0003892769163940102, 0.02502400428056717, 0.0027063554152846336, 0.0054093776270747185, -0.011218586005270481, 0.038681354373693466, 0.1043928936123848, 0.043680403381586075, 0.012745290994644165, -0.015570873394608498, -0.03463704511523247, -0.021336719393730164, -0.03713022544980049, 0.05715767666697502, 0.0009804113069549203, -0.07355459779500961, 0.06857790052890778, -0.04456567391753197, -0.0020176332909613848, -0.018317436799407005, -0.015716755762696266, -0.0712861567735672, -0.04784490168094635, -0.05620698258280754, -0.05691203102469444, 0.023044532164931297, -0.009489502757787704, 0.042088788002729416, -0.08973833173513412, -0.004021028988063335, 0.0004361878091003746, -0.04604573920369148, -0.00750366086140275, 0.050596240907907486, 0.05890464037656784, -0.027865204960107803, -0.057202767580747604, -0.04261191561818123, 0.06816225498914719, -0.03773629292845726, -0.052638206630945206, 0.027203908190131187, 0.0025563042145222425, -0.018468573689460754, 0.01923368312418461, 0.01117399800568819, -0.004546766169369221, 0.035885270684957504, 0.04345995560288429, 0.01582745462656021, 0.02117735520005226, -0.04807016998529434, -0.01208510808646679, -0.002776525681838393, 0.03277071192860603, -0.021285444498062134, 0.07759900391101837, 0.07407636940479279, -0.034803494811058044, -0.041509903967380524, -0.004503339529037476, -0.0034288116730749607, -0.039321158081293106, -0.08760233223438263, -0.013683226890861988, 0.0074612777680158615, 0.008889550343155861, -0.00858733244240284, 0.01941010169684887, 0.02883322164416313, 0.06460218876600266, -0.03832268714904785, 0.01226762030273676, 0.016056088730692863, 0.04271281883120537, -0.02290555089712143, 0.04602837935090065, 0.04255899041891098, -0.01068052463233471, -0.04038640856742859, 0.0002306923270225525, -0.11949020624160767, -0.03913991153240204, 0.015170625410974026, -0.01373747456818819, -0.018525749444961548, -0.01258405577391386, 0.044919297099113464, -0.03718021512031555, -0.09692128747701645, 0.03800658881664276, 0.06034192815423012, -0.01205079909414053, -0.02213558927178383, -0.027991022914648056, -0.033965229988098145, -0.005931495688855648, 0.003576901275664568, -0.045913297683000565, -0.012651785276830196, -0.013536683283746243, -0.0018645585514605045, 0.0028968704864382744, -0.022878006100654602, -0.04731762036681175, -0.05981570854783058, -0.03986075893044472, -0.005470195319503546, -0.0035281311720609665, -0.0270706694573164, 0.0033550644293427467, 0.021394038572907448, -0.07759254425764084, -0.02160455659031868, -0.027218911796808243, 0.013514754362404346, -0.005374257452785969, -0.021413123235106468, -0.029094140976667404, -0.0013928404077887535, -0.08978241682052612, -0.012138094753026962, -0.038184281438589096, 0.04301116615533829, 0.06982557475566864, 0.01874374784529209, 0.02811562269926071, 0.025761693716049194, 0.03245124593377113, -0.03194107487797737, -0.015759462490677834, 0.02804911695420742, -0.04470950737595558, -0.01628701202571392, -0.009086486883461475, -0.010843615978956223, -0.042485177516937256, -0.020057793706655502, -0.020149970427155495, 0.03870365023612976, 0.005027549806982279, -0.002001493936404586, -0.011764883063733578, 0.0207365695387125, -0.007043490651994944, -0.010453346185386181, -0.0007622065022587776, -0.03692108765244484, -0.028875865042209625, 0.019296113401651382, 0.04023739695549011, 0.0015212642028927803, 0.025429025292396545, -0.08411621302366257, 0.03568241372704506, -0.028509654104709625, -0.03667087107896805, -0.039614222943782806, 0.00015811121556907892, 0.0775195062160492, -0.017890598624944687, 0.028042903169989586, -0.017449060454964638, 0.03482932224869728, -0.008375483565032482, 0.022893738001585007, -0.012501557357609272, -0.08974941819906235, -0.01089415978640318, -0.027066124603152275, 0.07229097932577133, -0.006428123451769352, -0.017589615657925606, -0.0011135549284517765, 0.002035824814811349, 0.02162584476172924, 0.015245114453136921, -0.031221097335219383, 0.017888642847537994, 0.020789358764886856, 0.012371990829706192, -0.037014190107584, 0.01879509538412094, -0.006757891736924648, -0.02239539660513401, -0.05113115534186363, 0.018866265192627907, -0.002890843665227294, -0.041300781071186066, -0.021441638469696045, 0.021755985915660858, -0.02734944596886635, 0.0023120874539017677, -0.011757589876651764, -0.04266413673758507, 0.018252627924084663, -0.0036195709835737944, 0.0030162488110363483, 0.03535350412130356, 0.020674696192145348, -0.0030724499374628067, 0.014426805078983307, -0.05504298210144043, 0.03900665044784546, -0.01692129112780094, 0.04933857172727585, 0.01426953636109829, 0.050150830298662186, 0.02116711251437664, -0.05733616277575493, -0.013886194676160812, 0.07372153550386429, 0.024112846702337265 ]
<p>I am conducting an experiment in which the power meter reading of $410\,nm$ narrow bandpass stimulus is noted to be 30 $\frac{\mu W}{cm^2}$ at a distance of 1 inch away from the light source. </p> <p>I wish to convert this to $\frac{\text{photon}}{ cm^{2} s}.$ </p> <p>Can anyone tell me how to do this? </p>
g635
[ 0.0035138283856213093, -0.06952431052923203, 0.0013028117828071117, -0.0529412105679512, -0.01618264615535736, 0.0058766440488398075, -0.004289019387215376, 0.0112809669226408, 0.013631300069391727, -0.03878037631511688, 0.030764522030949593, 0.07692891359329224, -0.020922886207699776, 0.010986589826643467, 0.03731093928217888, -0.006482938304543495, 0.10152507573366165, 0.02117244154214859, 0.02402907982468605, -0.0010332830715924501, -0.007774069905281067, -0.031059710308909416, -0.032920919358730316, -0.057756900787353516, -0.006478136405348778, -0.028750205412507057, 0.0474434420466423, 0.02694234997034073, -0.0338747538626194, 0.056696269661188126, -0.04173784703016281, 0.010585230775177479, 0.01851799339056015, 0.041758108884096146, 0.011541877873241901, 0.036312758922576904, 0.009478064253926277, 0.023771032691001892, 0.0016239951364696026, 0.07366620749235153, 0.0028035868890583515, 0.0034236188512295485, 0.036039773374795914, -0.0017060521058738232, 0.04771147668361664, -0.03713294863700867, -0.04673653468489647, 0.03089257888495922, 0.01272848155349493, -0.008219506591558456, -0.009258144535124302, 0.008933773264288902, 0.03132401034235954, 0.09541311860084534, 0.0452362485229969, 0.015428230166435242, -0.01376449503004551, -0.02747363969683647, 0.07797828316688538, 0.030716760084033012, -0.02510993182659149, -0.02789025753736496, 0.009563547559082508, -0.014492267742753029, 0.012734517455101013, 0.023830046877264977, -0.042769305408000946, -0.04796317219734192, -0.016733217984437943, 0.010355468839406967, -0.007917420007288456, -0.0616820864379406, 0.0034204977564513683, -0.008661698549985886, 0.0492979921400547, -0.06613925844430923, 0.012377619743347168, -0.026183944195508957, 0.002313524717465043, 0.026395777240395546, -0.0021444924641400576, -0.06048069894313812, 0.017839152365922928, -0.06852035969495773, 0.039358969777822495, -0.022090019658207893, -0.03895268961787224, 0.03812341392040253, -0.019069693982601166, -0.0578954741358757, 0.010042206384241581, 0.012154142372310162, 0.08969072997570038, -0.024136517196893692, 0.03855038061738014, -0.010448088869452477, 0.0014226232888177037, 0.01192359160631895, 0.0011190924560651183, -0.05337981507182121, -0.01952287182211876, 0.02138129062950611, 0.0034562551882117987, 0.02131541632115841, -0.0030962564051151276, 0.02046889252960682, -0.011236455291509628, 0.043648529797792435, 0.020424826070666313, -0.06356724351644516, -0.04173709824681282, -0.08183558285236359, 0.014537636190652847, -0.06499600410461426, -0.05763733386993408, -0.03462044149637222, -0.010741340927779675, 0.0389944389462471, 0.0219907034188509, 0.018481282517313957, 0.018531588837504387, 0.005724386312067509, -0.0021268087439239025, 0.03484203666448593, -0.03814110532402992, -0.01261456310749054, -0.021471912041306496, 0.014531013555824757, 0.051196854561567307, -0.01005696039646864, -0.03744249790906906, -0.004430848173797131, -0.02693382278084755, -0.019239597022533417, 0.0018191857961937785, 0.0058580986224114895, 0.06628716737031937, -0.05628028139472008, 0.030919838696718216, 0.040881119668483734, -0.04913880676031113, -0.03832777962088585, 0.011449169367551804, -0.008321350440382957, -0.039637044072151184, 0.007059168536216021, -0.03797295317053795, -0.0014864245895296335, 0.06690248847007751, -0.001928579295054078, 0.02847592905163765, 0.043360207229852676, 0.02270880527794361, -0.03137765824794769, 0.03861439600586891, -0.05023366957902908, 0.045651815831661224, -0.006998992059379816, -0.03431181237101555, -0.02695578709244728, 0.04923433065414429, 0.03263024240732193, -0.008978496305644512, 0.0408601239323616, -0.038586556911468506, -0.020297041162848473, -0.007636285852640867, -0.016122648492455482, 0.0031935744918882847, -0.056438058614730835, -0.04772111028432846, -0.02564891427755356, 0.028493670746684074, 0.004128418397158384, -0.007740507367998362, 0.014487101696431637, -0.015110417269170284, -0.008500399999320507, 0.01341315545141697, 0.008461855351924896, -0.010044504888355732, -0.01887688599526882, 0.006152322515845299, -0.02760191261768341, -0.020881472155451775, 0.03224318102002144, -0.03772254288196564, -0.0018219335470348597, -0.01838192716240883, -0.010749061591923237, -0.054904889315366745, -0.02244318649172783, -0.033412281423807144, 0.03548911213874817, -0.06458457559347153, -0.0016578371869400144, 0.02626955136656761, -0.031448107212781906, 0.021039869636297226, 0.0013533449964597821, -0.03132905066013336, 0.08184006810188293, 0.017440149560570717, 0.006536155939102173, 0.03143297880887985, -0.014516095630824566, 0.010839587077498436, -0.09823676198720932, -0.02015960030257702, 0.03997853770852089, -0.0392962321639061, -0.0018821938429027796, -0.018388532102108, -0.029288802295923233, -0.05303920805454254, -0.026175841689109802, 0.022241050377488136, -0.005610256921499968, -0.006814499851316214, 0.07682313024997711, -0.014751541428267956, 0.08894741535186768, 0.09977341443300247, -0.029940638691186905, -0.0429631806910038, 0.009943472221493721, -0.0052101933397352695, 0.061373237520456314, 0.015638019889593124, 0.004946910310536623, -0.02489599771797657, 0.04443572089076042, -0.03291977569460869, -0.018100416287779808, 0.051362939178943634, 0.02607022039592266, -0.06919898092746735, 0.0402076430618763, -0.001093821250833571, -0.015369098633527756, -0.017330920323729515, -0.02553711086511612, -0.006291933357715607, 0.004415679723024368, -0.030490893870592117, -0.02159220725297928, 0.042354438453912735, 0.028981981799006462, -0.0069826156832277775, -0.052138254046440125, -0.018421432003378868, 0.007664522621780634, 0.0010309737408533692, 0.03996482118964195, -0.025622816756367683, -0.06555143743753433, -0.023642048239707947, 0.01579338312149048, -0.046240828931331635, -0.05214497819542885, -0.053265392780303955, -0.06636404991149902, 0.013709121383726597, -0.010690075345337391, 0.0026554616633802652, -0.016352975741028786, 0.01201007328927517, 0.01577584072947502, 0.041285958141088486, 0.007723068352788687, 0.04807740077376366, 0.01843838579952717, 0.034294337034225464, 0.05396050587296486, -0.009765314869582653, -0.019352180883288383, 0.058361321687698364, -0.009299060329794884, 0.06721002608537674, -0.051429249346256256, -0.043061092495918274, 0.02292044833302498, -0.009572049602866173, 0.013968347571790218, 0.022730767726898193, -0.11191417276859283, 0.004870767239481211, 0.014089547097682953, 0.0058286115527153015, 0.01634201593697071, -0.04384424909949303, -0.02944151870906353, -0.021900901570916176, 0.01701120287179947, 0.02527030184864998, 0.012161712162196636, 0.09494946151971817, 0.0019332850351929665, 0.011783849447965622, 0.04876061528921127, 0.020542476326227188, -0.03544613718986511, -0.029200416058301926, 0.0059433020651340485, -0.03921161964535713, -0.0030433484353125095, 0.05518577992916107, -0.023714246228337288, 0.030104922130703926, -0.008200610987842083, -0.026435434818267822, -0.007730281446129084, 0.06667324155569077, -0.0071351234801113605, -0.06200411915779114, -0.05133940279483795, -0.020414110273122787, 0.001416665967553854, 0.028761474415659904, 0.05694679915904999, 0.03896661475300789, -0.032387834042310715, 0.01676272600889206, -0.011452628299593925, -0.008345217444002628, 0.003749654395505786, 0.005211716052144766, -0.024102618917822838, -0.07017003744840622, -0.039231833070516586, 0.019284289330244064, -0.03067849949002266, -0.024068910628557205, -0.03282708674669266, 0.01124783605337143, -0.0024018040858209133, -0.050848595798015594, 0.06793813407421112, 0.015094153583049774, -0.05476175621151924, 0.0007502652006223798, -0.004152543377131224, -0.08214084059000015, 0.004477683920413256, 0.02146054431796074, -0.005505950655788183, -0.037291157990694046, 0.014406186528503895, -0.027202406898140907, -0.07061438262462616, -0.05241827666759491, -0.007298778276890516, -0.026871617883443832, -0.08550851792097092, 0.012555480003356934, 0.02660250850021839, -0.012028583325445652, 0.06740960478782654, 0.011759815737605095, -0.011697717942297459, -0.04047492519021034, -0.03803376108407974, 0.07937537133693695, 0.0037637706845998764, -0.06255487352609634, -0.0010300981812179089, -0.03468126803636551, 0.03733346611261368, -0.0028515004087239504, -0.010917408391833305, -0.037895869463682175, -0.07001470774412155, 0.025192514061927795, 0.002965670544654131, -0.03029019758105278, -0.045564204454422, 0.014111490920186043, -0.032317351549863815, 0.00656161829829216, 0.05911111459136009, -0.07956475019454956, 0.008002765476703644, 0.007949759252369404, -0.030387282371520996, 0.038728997111320496, 0.0020170987118035555, -0.03669673949480057, -0.04133119434118271, 0.03240314871072769, -0.027002593502402306, 0.03074312023818493, -0.06063052639365196, -0.03617332503199577, 0.020015982910990715, -0.038263387978076935, -0.03666190057992935, 0.03293177857995033, -0.009025839157402515, -0.0554506741464138, 0.08038069307804108, 0.02228369005024433, 0.05370594561100006, 0.014203088358044624, 0.039656467735767365, -0.0769258439540863, 0.04216887056827545, 0.025252901017665863, -0.028260866180062294, 0.010498370043933392, 0.038051288574934006, -0.017188219353556633, -0.054707419127225876, 0.016516759991645813, -0.07366897165775299, -0.00903988815844059, -0.022290775552392006, 0.08343764394521713, -0.019010238349437714, 0.04497881978750229, -0.0038804032374173403, -0.04525104910135269, 0.017221514135599136, 0.018873045220971107, 0.0032505590934306383, -0.00415800092741847, 0.05166928842663765, -0.009542310610413551, -0.005839081946760416, 0.041377779096364975, 0.06707003712654114, 0.05087347701191902, 0.023506496101617813, 0.03193790838122368, 0.019820835441350937, 0.010972718708217144, 0.013025745749473572, -0.008467121981084347, -0.051369376480579376, 0.056436944752931595, 0.05790279433131218, 0.04328210651874542, 0.013430247083306313, -0.026970500126481056, 0.010812606662511826, 0.0016845548525452614, 0.0509306825697422, -0.007135508116334677, -0.001796483644284308, -0.020797159522771835, 0.01557955238968134, -0.01282881572842598, -0.027138730511069298, -0.028564119711518288, -0.034852202981710434, 0.03448370844125748, -0.026859933510422707, -0.006501648109406233, -0.001789759611710906, 0.0628923550248146, 0.024869805201888084, -0.020773867145180702, 0.007261759135872126, -0.05321243405342102, -0.016645435243844986, 0.05235106125473976, 0.02516387216746807, -0.08413230627775192, 0.018665704876184464, -0.0395192950963974, -0.038489021360874176, -0.03634081780910492, -0.04406851530075073, 0.01332131028175354, 0.016426149755716324, 0.022787857800722122, 0.06437502056360245, -0.05111319571733475, -0.03607435151934624, 0.016313759610056877, -0.007056737784296274, 0.03224688023328781, 0.010709655471146107, -0.002028205431997776, -0.027420418336987495, 0.029448067769408226, 0.04358438029885292, -0.06026378646492958, 0.03675900027155876, -0.021680468693375587, -0.0877479761838913, -0.03460603952407837, 0.017381412908434868, -0.012083335779607296, -0.007630860432982445, 0.012853368185460567, 0.041742898523807526, 0.05871007964015007, 0.008362408727407455, 0.013888275250792503, 0.002196767833083868, -0.015160433016717434, 0.017373880371451378, -0.056144531816244125, 0.03787684068083763, -0.024118689820170403, 0.0013994625769555569, 0.008032676763832569, 0.022681906819343567, 0.06864425539970398, 0.056155990809202194, -0.028873829171061516, -0.02025514654815197, 0.03219326585531235, -0.010940102860331535, 0.04843048378825188, 0.043759092688560486, 0.015072654001414776, 0.05261750891804695, -0.0003797532117459923, -0.03406640514731407, 0.0296257883310318, -0.04209600016474724, 0.030375977978110313, -0.013383298180997372, 0.027515364810824394, 0.0020089936442673206, -0.06761270016431808, 0.011429114267230034, 0.02710472233593464, -0.0797305703163147, 0.00609118677675724, 0.016212347894906998, 0.017941344529390335, -0.021218063309788704, 0.008761097677052021, -0.01639333926141262, 0.03720594570040703, -0.012516203336417675, -0.02912873402237892, -0.029459958896040916, -0.038095131516456604, -0.014681416563689709, 0.048839643597602844, 0.013836690224707127, 0.038330525159835815, 0.03060314804315567, 0.036860935389995575, 0.006771516986191273, 0.026842163875699043, 0.03680131584405899, -0.0043388716876506805, 0.007370240055024624, -0.0005232598050497472, -0.03680220618844032, 0.03701627627015114, 0.016808196902275085, -0.0037716201040893793, -0.009287362918257713, 0.011277357116341591, -0.009647581726312637, 0.01583597995340824, 0.01733287051320076, -0.008158622309565544, 0.004293799865990877, 0.014394495636224747, -0.052223753184080124, 0.02781578153371811, 0.04397690296173096, 0.026000848039984703, -0.009214823134243488, -0.05928502976894379, 0.05383928492665291, 0.015216906554996967, 0.028440501540899277, -0.04152752459049225, -0.027740415185689926, 0.12121238559484482, 0.012232706882059574, -0.0021807639859616756, -0.05354176461696625, -0.010916516184806824, 0.022047050297260284, -0.003726748749613762, 0.026759205386042595, -0.06410519033670425, 0.03389931097626686, 0.004263645503669977, 0.06007285416126251, 0.02514578588306904, -0.016767865046858788, 0.003176263300701976, -0.006478837225586176, -0.00008203641482396051, 0.025403833016753197, -0.01890444941818714, -0.07696142792701721, 0.0023982860147953033, 0.018685150891542435, -0.008130384609103203, 0.031149039044976234, 0.04182033985853195, -0.03381883725523949, -0.026094457134604454, 0.029841158539056778, 0.03760030120611191, 0.008525625802576542, -0.040718600153923035, 0.02898925170302391, 0.030490413308143616, -0.00018180566257797182, -0.03834112733602524, -0.033334605395793915, 0.030078567564487457, 0.011684536002576351, -0.00047923612874001265, -0.01762394607067108, 0.04517841339111328, 0.03377791866660118, -0.020139683037996292, -0.016415154561400414, 0.0539819598197937, -0.022031376138329506, -0.004229506477713585, -0.01657261699438095, 0.015043864026665688, 0.08198698610067368, 0.045947059988975525, 0.005244719795882702, 0.04602346941828728, -0.009879221208393574, -0.04122872278094292, -0.018680403009057045, 0.01363329216837883, -0.002407494932413101, 0.023535043001174927, 0.07494858652353287, 0.0397869236767292, -0.007855004630982876, 0.015232742764055729, 0.0320412777364254, 0.008820436894893646, -0.02073412947356701, 0.015982065349817276, -0.014568022452294827, -0.040261462330818176, 0.0386369526386261, 0.008829202502965927, 0.030367331579327583, 0.021508317440748215, 0.0889999270439148, 0.05309809744358063, 0.014128915034234524, 0.02521856129169464, -0.0015971955144777894, -0.006302657071501017, 0.02328493259847164, -0.009197237901389599, 0.01840505376458168, 0.04518357664346695, -0.062369853258132935, -0.0017983762081712484, -0.07806838303804398, -0.0518839955329895, -0.01476321555674076, -0.0003186273970641196, 0.04177737981081009, -0.04189090430736542, -0.06801937520503998, 0.02005305513739586, -0.09972592443227768, -0.007188878953456879, -0.02472209744155407, -0.0175691656768322, -0.006568179000169039, -0.0025602751411497593, 0.033575061708688736, -0.021996069699525833, 0.09363272041082382, -0.04901314526796341, -0.04596107825636864, -0.015762222930788994, 0.00904974713921547, -0.016687709838151932, -0.029260631650686264, -0.0026796949096024036, 0.02065139263868332, -0.047322582453489304, -0.003168208058923483, 0.04747307673096657, 0.02966814860701561, -0.04270240291953087, -0.0251986775547266, 0.02340587042272091, -0.04691452533006668, 0.05777399614453316, -0.05718306452035904, 0.0330391526222229, -0.0025771998334676027, 0.020755264908075333, 0.007745610550045967, 0.0251802746206522, -0.012798644602298737, -0.04994148015975952, -0.022376731038093567, -0.03548533096909523, 0.003811475122347474, -0.05131020396947861, -0.015223200432956219, 0.003879832336679101, -0.06403931230306625, 0.011201988905668259, 0.03146091848611832, -0.04365018382668495, 0.037862639874219894, 0.10636972635984421, 0.011359930969774723, -0.03159608319401741, 0.05080069229006767, 0.05528513714671135, -0.013045751489698887, 0.006340039893984795, 0.015906551852822304, -0.025193732231855392, 0.029915301129221916, -0.010622489266097546, -0.0454559288918972, 0.014658437110483646, 0.0007911900756880641, -0.005104867275804281, -0.04029907286167145, -0.001302200136706233, -0.02518303319811821, -0.019323712214827538, -0.016775304451584816, -0.010905490256845951, -0.01370181329548359, -0.022490493953227997, 0.029302388429641724, 0.010817919857800007, 0.03677405044436455, 0.0006255979533307254, 0.00788459088653326, -0.04438797011971474, -0.005427754484117031, -0.005322989542037249, -0.005042803008109331, -0.03634796664118767, 0.04408909007906914, 0.022913597524166107, -0.036325354129076004, 0.017455806955695152, 0.05579997971653938, -0.05450165271759033, 0.06408660858869553, 0.07207904011011124, -0.05217404291033745, 0.04791443422436714, -0.014032112434506416, -0.00444332929328084, -0.0457734651863575, -0.009143256582319736, 0.013957480899989605, -0.0316859632730484, 0.10481724143028259, -0.010773889720439911, -0.02668941766023636, -0.01099869143217802, 0.006487471517175436 ]
<p>In Jackson's book about classical electrodynamics, this formula comes up: $$q_{lm} = \int \mathrm d^3 x' \, Y^*_{lm}\left(\theta', \phi'\right) r'^l \rho\left(\vec x'\right)$$</p> <p>What does that $^*$ mean?</p>
g5889
[ 0.03047187812626362, 0.003490880597382784, -0.025736302137374878, -0.04837134853005409, 0.058627787977457047, 0.0427805557847023, 0.052854329347610474, -0.023159410804510117, 0.005558541975915432, -0.000007628469120390946, -0.06303352117538452, 0.040758129209280014, -0.011814471334218979, 0.014058424159884453, 0.026389356702566147, 0.014058560132980347, 0.01912429928779602, 0.04624735191464424, -0.0040205419063568115, -0.03074132837355137, -0.048041924834251404, 0.018276505172252655, -0.04613344743847847, -0.026213953271508217, 0.07456263899803162, 0.0020146712195128202, -0.0010682508582249284, 0.02256406657397747, -0.026184290647506714, -0.0138819245621562, 0.009269271045923233, 0.012822099961340427, 0.02981281466782093, -0.0013333638198673725, -0.0272021796554327, -0.0018047565827146173, 0.006603578571230173, -0.023708704859018326, 0.062454644590616226, -0.03058970347046852, -0.02870575152337551, 0.03916989266872406, 0.035585589706897736, -0.008608066476881504, -0.0016729802591726184, 0.010835402645170689, -0.06277727335691452, -0.015860550105571747, -0.0521109402179718, -0.008353712037205696, -0.014858987182378769, 0.029934581369161606, 0.06688369810581207, -0.003234606934711337, -0.014870299957692623, 0.03220021724700928, 0.07503802329301834, -0.03279941529035568, 0.009164117276668549, 0.08471576124429703, 0.0537937767803669, -0.026271233335137367, 0.007766973692923784, 0.007390362676233053, 0.04234352335333824, -0.0026406978722661734, 0.015318774618208408, -0.029415249824523926, -0.046232983469963074, 0.007233933079987764, 0.00008964273729361594, -0.09757237881422043, 0.029323002323508263, 0.00136057217605412, -0.039933301508426666, 0.031737200915813446, 0.045646000653505325, 0.013645682483911514, -0.011538815684616566, -0.05422484874725342, -0.0400238111615181, -0.03229966759681702, -0.002155168214812875, 0.016819633543491364, 0.021953962743282318, 0.015780115500092506, 0.004446173552423716, 0.011419512331485748, -0.02542746812105179, 0.028505679219961166, -0.038677237927913666, -0.05768591910600662, 0.019727185368537903, -0.054109565913677216, -0.0037593438755720854, -0.07043752074241638, -0.002730313455685973, 0.030574653297662735, -0.00397103326395154, -0.027178224176168442, -0.0477336160838604, 0.014324594289064407, 0.016943957656621933, -0.020242964848876, -0.024669256061315536, 0.04311757907271385, 0.05162089690566063, -0.0361836813390255, -0.011124780401587486, -0.04524441435933113, -0.03172340616583824, -0.006336160469800234, 0.008826485835015774, -0.023645978420972824, -0.0021446910686790943, -0.026951737701892853, -0.01381742488592863, -0.05879414826631546, 0.02340972051024437, 0.05539538338780403, 0.013972768560051918, -0.029592029750347137, 0.049599047750234604, 0.01059494074434042, -0.0022157663479447365, 0.0027460441924631596, 0.002816037507727742, 0.03366357833147049, 0.028743434697389603, 0.043832793831825256, 0.06015453115105629, 0.010294491425156593, -0.04104900360107422, 0.017194358631968498, 0.04777422919869423, 0.07700411230325699, 0.013409886509180069, -0.003954876679927111, 0.0011935416841879487, -0.058009132742881775, 0.050364088267087936, -0.03706817328929901, 0.012623275630176067, -0.018324878066778183, -0.005068195518106222, -0.010311011224985123, -0.0002037279773503542, -0.056540440768003464, -0.007947882637381554, 0.004199473187327385, -0.0038494665641337633, 0.07320843636989594, 0.001458700280636549, -0.03033226914703846, -0.0022786364424973726, 0.01697354018688202, 0.004295907914638519, -0.02313142828643322, -0.04257601127028465, 0.014195050112903118, 0.01355817262083292, 0.016808483749628067, 0.0006352423806674778, 0.013011486269533634, -0.04958663135766983, -0.013644501566886902, 0.07700654864311218, -0.11922530829906464, 0.011446108110249043, -0.008389713242650032, -0.01832503452897072, 0.04394357651472092, 0.032841186970472336, -0.022739265114068985, -0.01882513426244259, 0.03702102601528168, -0.02445806749165058, -0.02761220745742321, 0.05425308272242546, -0.01377155352383852, -0.01221784483641386, 0.034361038357019424, 0.02514253370463848, -0.048064738512039185, -0.09817279130220413, -0.02825333923101425, -0.037210576236248016, 0.03426482900977135, -0.013663082383573055, -0.03263861685991287, 0.009401414543390274, 0.06153972074389458, -0.012225676327943802, 0.04388650506734848, -0.020057199522852898, 0.012746864929795265, -0.04737204313278198, -0.05466533824801445, -0.06105821207165718, 0.011672687716782093, 0.019412724301218987, -0.018360408022999763, 0.06046457961201668, 0.0075427088886499405, -0.04367661476135254, 0.036005325615406036, -0.028827087953686714, 0.0026665236800909042, 0.04837268963456154, -0.007219844497740269, 0.027668463066220284, -0.05636347085237503, -0.0018892742227762938, 0.03169827535748482, 0.007344478275626898, -0.054893363267183304, -0.0130590396001935, -0.012205492705106735, -0.044563502073287964, 0.0366380400955677, -0.05720958113670349, -0.05017441138625145, 0.040027424693107605, -0.040544942021369934, -0.004311730619519949, 0.06353969126939774, -0.02831217274069786, -0.04913532733917236, -0.03994877636432648, -0.009103415533900261, -0.05429094284772873, -0.011363635770976543, -0.07520542293787003, 0.009402720257639885, 0.022396551445126534, 0.028305847197771072, -0.046307701617479324, -0.046596962958574295, 0.09481736272573471, 0.023080462589859962, 0.011204586364328861, -0.014454700984060764, -0.003972635138779879, 0.0139221902936697, 0.02539435215294361, 0.0762653723359108, 0.07914206385612488, 0.05377231165766716, -0.04829198867082596, 0.029094982892274857, 0.03325367346405983, -0.013760223053395748, -0.0449405238032341, 0.032316721975803375, -0.0036424463614821434, -0.018976816907525063, -0.09106135368347168, 0.017275117337703705, -0.03844935819506645, -0.011161329224705696, -0.04211452975869179, 0.007141559384763241, -0.018283525481820107, 0.000987910432741046, -0.02711920440196991, -0.009468058124184608, -0.008322211913764477, 0.016922909766435623, 0.011172465048730373, -0.0067414999939501286, -0.04514464735984802, 0.061074525117874146, 0.073328398168087, 0.04511123523116112, -0.010424532927572727, -0.023635007441043854, -0.07294054329395294, -0.04713868722319603, 0.054519400000572205, -0.07590528577566147, 0.008581317961215973, -0.04518476501107216, 0.05263689532876015, 0.07043738663196564, -0.003441372886300087, -0.06902574002742767, -0.02191249653697014, 0.05320596322417259, -0.01660870760679245, 0.003565389895811677, -0.016731221228837967, -0.01102458592504263, 0.015687379986047745, -0.07731003314256668, -0.04479844123125076, 0.04809398204088211, 0.04200251027941704, -0.024324383586645126, 0.0374663807451725, 0.012179414741694927, 0.008530961349606514, 0.0036508606281131506, -0.013979502953588963, 0.003608244936913252, 0.039935000240802765, 0.06962285190820694, -0.020060425624251366, 0.005596695933490992, 0.027366014197468758, 0.005911984480917454, 0.03997151926159859, -0.012228204868733883, -0.04831263795495033, 0.0023494542110711336, -0.08590959757566452, 0.026116499677300453, 0.013838867656886578, -0.028947345912456512, 0.016115305945277214, 0.01392302941530943, -0.04259754717350006, -0.11177366971969604, 0.016538694500923157, 0.012514523230493069, 0.03819199651479721, 0.0031105298548936844, -0.05567875877022743, 0.039682891219854355, 0.028431516140699387, -0.022562263533473015, -0.025634316727519035, 0.02173490636050701, -0.01006969902664423, 0.00229450361803174, -0.04022498428821564, 0.01284006703644991, -0.023826655000448227, 0.05252530425786972, 0.043819643557071686, 0.0013981423107907176, 0.0275094136595726, -0.016150416806340218, -0.029396556317806244, -0.008861429989337921, 0.030440952628850937, -0.049517352133989334, -0.02466416172683239, -0.01895996183156967, 0.06140023469924927, -0.0009680968942120671, -0.017145657911896706, -0.0025003321934491396, 0.0074740564450621605, -0.03517899289727211, -0.01344998087733984, 0.018087269738316536, -0.01884501799941063, 0.028972482308745384, 0.06560535728931427, 0.03817928582429886, -0.018396291881799698, -0.02910621650516987, -0.042472340166568756, -0.011128709651529789, 0.001452533877454698, 0.009371125139296055, 0.024227257817983627, 0.04401295259594917, -0.02580597624182701, -0.031021365895867348, -0.018516795709729195, 0.008630440570414066, 0.01460176520049572, 0.052475761622190475, -0.03393618389964104, -0.07693089544773102, -0.08113691210746765, -0.007818657904863358, -0.04431525990366936, 0.06984704732894897, -0.029749436303973198, 0.04478038474917412, 0.024214811623096466, 0.01717343181371689, -0.006896934472024441, 0.044505245983600616, -0.017518814653158188, 0.011064691469073296, -0.03320043906569481, -0.020853662863373756, -0.026206936687231064, 0.04318634420633316, -0.024642463773489, 0.024990878999233246, -0.02036925032734871, -0.05347028374671936, 0.06064695864915848, 0.019492264837026596, -0.04535520821809769, 0.0009580947807990015, 0.02670247294008732, 0.0013023626524955034, -0.007239808794111013, 0.00521965604275465, 0.01212984323501587, 0.004889443051069975, 0.0641707181930542, -0.04462374746799469, 0.09774425625801086, -0.04667557403445244, -0.028849322348833084, -0.043755289167165756, 0.02736012078821659, -0.03952624276280403, 0.05229516699910164, 0.054178036749362946, 0.043059173971414566, -0.04826485365629196, -0.013412881642580032, 0.004225858952850103, 0.011711519211530685, 0.008293638937175274, -0.00033081771107390523, -0.021610043942928314, 0.027197962626814842, 0.035981789231300354, 0.10273311287164688, 0.04688055068254471, -0.0381607823073864, -0.02861453779041767, 0.03215417265892029, 0.027607765048742294, -0.04258257895708084, 0.04030275344848633, -0.03505857661366463, -0.007343537174165249, -0.06466998904943466, 0.06602165102958679, 0.0006281876121647656, 0.03783320635557175, 0.06539294123649597, -0.033354874700307846, 0.012826687656342983, -0.004999965894967318, 0.0335579439997673, 0.016178317368030548, -0.0372709296643734, -0.007402732502669096, 0.028993062674999237, -0.004334517288953066, -0.03406639024615288, 0.0253765769302845, 0.023993704468011856, -0.003087458433583379, 0.07600173354148865, -0.039861999452114105, -0.019602252170443535, 0.012401500716805458, 0.01164484117180109, 0.004388451110571623, -0.07671882212162018, -0.05552978813648224, -0.002966539701446891, 0.011278337799012661, 0.07819477468729019, 0.007805052679032087, -0.05376113951206207, 0.026844708248972893, -0.05237475410103798, -0.014483928680419922, 0.01513428520411253, -0.004518793895840645, -0.019678520038723946, -0.0455167256295681, -0.04679340869188309, -0.051968351006507874, 0.017138538882136345, -0.007679234258830547, -0.05583702400326729, -0.019072921946644783, 0.019477004185318947, -0.020909488201141357, -0.01138092391192913, 0.03865976631641388, 0.009704045951366425, -0.009140039794147015, -0.015874147415161133, -0.019072197377681732, -0.07801056653261185, 0.04688310995697975, 0.034680966287851334, 0.019027430564165115, 0.06658757477998734, 0.004623213317245245, -0.04923764243721962, 0.042453277856111526, 0.019145535305142403, -0.03476918488740921, -0.05721629410982132, 0.06245112046599388, 0.013040423393249512, 0.01321642566472292, -0.014275085180997849, -0.012672101147472858, -0.020258281379938126, 0.0053703212179243565, 0.001989750424399972, 0.017179902642965317, -0.001539609394967556, -0.0060895998030900955, 0.01422935351729393, 0.012938737869262695, 0.02897363156080246, 0.067020483314991, 0.03979292884469032, -0.0057168700732290745, -0.0494568832218647, -0.004707770422101021, 0.004153447691351175, 0.024187440052628517, 0.0016852309927344322, -0.012382470071315765, -0.002894164063036442, -0.043742310255765915, 0.00731915608048439, 0.04985134303569794, -0.012632211670279503, -0.01880861073732376, -0.009028987027704716, 0.04244986176490784, -0.026600372046232224, -0.009447813034057617, 0.008826452307403088, -0.02858785353600979, -0.0075174178928136826, -0.029256679117679596, 0.02607913687825203, -0.024044359102845192, 0.005108893383294344, 0.03239661082625389, -0.030756214633584023, 0.007135989144444466, 0.013929862529039383, 0.0067176553420722485, 0.01873592659831047, 0.02746117301285267, -0.03519241139292717, -0.034383948892354965, 0.029964301735162735, -0.006958994083106518, 0.01361179444938898, -0.029498377814888954, -0.007188180461525917, -0.001540565863251686, 0.022635819390416145, -0.0037603022065013647, -0.0017776458989828825, -0.01827131025493145, -0.027272770181298256, -0.02595212124288082, 0.023847386240959167, -0.001505153952166438, 0.035622481256723404, 0.03753389045596123, -0.018589796498417854, -0.05410483479499817, 0.032978348433971405, 0.046626538038253784, 0.03655022010207176, -0.022917352616786957, 0.018674302846193314, 0.041696105152368546, -0.003872364992275834, 0.047167371958494186, 0.06424662470817566, 0.0829942524433136, -0.015405828133225441, -0.021141335368156433, -0.005651749204844236, 0.023081552237272263, 0.05063134804368019, -0.024005744606256485, 0.03759915381669998, -0.046263035386800766, 0.011525291018188, 0.04114045202732086, 0.0028735159430652857, -0.014428341761231422, 0.05383223667740822, 0.037664689123630524, 0.002393577480688691, 0.014333242550492287, -0.03959567844867706, 0.023093102499842644, -0.011648579500615597, 0.04647482559084892, -0.002262420253828168, 0.05565588176250458, 0.04631343483924866, -0.031181445345282555, 0.040458545088768005, 0.08136985450983047, 0.06283701956272125, -0.03588641807436943, 0.03999676555395126, -0.02000492252409458, 0.00010052671859739348, -0.07516848295927048, -0.027035240083932877, 0.038239143788814545, 0.037780314683914185, -0.005909361410886049, -0.013876021839678288, -0.018498195335268974, -0.01206393912434578, -0.022110367193818092, 0.0030954580288380384, 0.03607558831572533, -0.03962770849466324, 0.013589021749794483, -0.004966079723089933, 0.02506926842033863, -0.025156572461128235, -0.04168738052248955, 0.06688688695430756, 0.040664561092853546, 0.01958351396024227, -0.0060676466673612595, 0.022248802706599236, 0.02421816997230053, 0.023771114647388458, -0.04667888954281807, 0.00037162870285101235, 0.017139242962002754, -0.012548433616757393, -0.04700056463479996, -0.0007255562231875956, -0.01619468629360199, 0.029385030269622803, 0.029181096702814102, 0.0018307442078366876, 0.04197362810373306, 0.02747579850256443, -0.0653691291809082, -0.03291409835219383, -0.02555921860039234, 0.038772568106651306, 0.020919129252433777, -0.06021837517619133, -0.0034516386222094297, 0.045166365802288055, 0.00923094991594553, -0.025726618245244026, -0.007085607852786779, -0.034631162881851196, -0.038852572441101074, 0.026127295568585396, 0.024582495912909508, 0.014963580295443535, -0.055576276034116745, -0.02324780449271202, -0.018812529742717743, 0.0073454901576042175, 0.05082319304347038, -0.0066280970349907875, 0.001140712178312242, -0.0023067789152264595, -0.03432336077094078, -0.008603346534073353, -0.03391951322555542, -0.016436416655778885, -0.006447233259677887, 0.0019953218288719654, -0.015172942541539669, -0.02769836224615574, -0.0025143888778984547, 0.04881202429533005, 0.021245809271931648, -0.043671537190675735, 0.025534728541970253, -0.014541104435920715, -0.02020282857120037, -0.027740785852074623, -0.037350937724113464, -0.022615551948547363, 0.023400822654366493, 0.03763863444328308, -0.09436054527759552, 0.0043740407563745975, 0.06037788838148117, 0.027948305010795593, -0.07494788616895676, -0.014875423163175583, 0.03845604136586189, 0.029559118673205376, 0.01429848000407219, 0.014769903384149075, 0.11706049740314484, 0.022502705454826355, 0.07000484317541122, 0.05227483808994293, -0.049434930086135864, 0.000704185338690877, 0.06614197790622711, -0.0262397900223732, 0.010580914095044136, -0.014017468318343163, -0.028057876974344254, -0.02544226497411728, 0.008086875081062317, 0.022397682070732117, -0.015178563073277473, 0.05096445977687836, -0.01976037584245205, 0.06691829860210419, 0.05603766441345215, 0.015973467379808426, 0.028080910444259644, 0.01895483210682869, -0.055613014847040176, 0.006288962438702583, 0.011328952386975288, -0.023844311013817787, -0.051802027970552444, -0.07676488161087036, -0.003959049470722675, -0.012128401547670364, -0.0011618388816714287, -0.024525627493858337, -0.001214589225128293, -0.05664561316370964, -0.004284575581550598, -0.022760724648833275, 0.015379933640360832, -0.037016067653894424, -0.01701408252120018, -0.004548448603600264, -0.005014644004404545, 0.06210673227906227, 0.03715012967586517, -0.01956098899245262, -0.04499221593141556, -0.02130948379635811, 0.0019077451433986425, -0.05237085744738579, -0.05053886026144028, -0.024302221834659576, 0.006082985084503889, 0.047939758747816086, -0.014472740702331066, -0.06844448298215866, -0.00940182525664568, -0.03532753884792328, 0.047005195170640945, 0.0915590226650238, -0.020652446895837784, -0.011186867021024227, -0.03314732387661934, 0.015325711108744144, 0.012842937372624874, -0.005994386039674282, -0.08166277408599854, 0.02396119385957718, 0.009125578217208385, 0.028842484578490257, -0.058437034487724304, -0.022715259343385696, -0.018261032178997993 ]
<p>Suppose I set up a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foucault_pendulum" rel="nofollow">Foucault pendulum</a> and observe that it precesses at a rate of 216.528 degrees per day. While I am observing this, a total solar eclipse occurs. Where am I, and what is the date?</p> <p>My professor NEVER went over anything like this, so a shove in the right direction would be awesome. </p>
g5890
[ 0.026597468182444572, 0.04023639112710953, 0.004577125888317823, -0.04939236864447594, 0.03913934528827667, -0.010449541732668877, 0.07182269543409348, 0.014627885073423386, -0.009772834368050098, -0.04720429331064224, -0.010353456251323223, 0.0068430048413574696, 0.050872646272182465, -0.03910094499588013, 0.05372775346040726, 0.004777360241860151, 0.03698112815618515, -0.0001259137352462858, 0.06393606215715408, 0.027149507775902748, -0.01363990269601345, -0.008583612740039825, -0.038963690400123596, -0.004966696258634329, -0.006712063681334257, 0.0034518546890467405, -0.02889731340110302, 0.004047604277729988, -0.021031737327575684, -0.00009122984920395538, -0.04155530780553818, 0.03814583271741867, 0.027234075590968132, -0.01915477216243744, -0.016365371644496918, 0.015787888318300247, 0.012620009481906891, 0.017028601840138435, 0.00862086657434702, -0.01711595617234707, 0.0014309920370578766, -0.015113499015569687, -0.008002832531929016, -0.002963549690321088, 0.05362822860479355, -0.0028694970533251762, 0.014631806872785091, -0.025312237441539764, -0.016352316364645958, -0.022095413878560066, -0.0009007263579405844, 0.035762008279561996, 0.00859166868031025, -0.0007027017418295145, -0.026719605550169945, 0.04387330263853073, 0.059559181332588196, -0.007012351416051388, 0.06149910017848015, 0.03815780580043793, 0.08036459982395172, -0.023596202954649925, 0.035356536507606506, -0.02503400668501854, 0.04084819182753563, 0.06113937124609947, -0.017774201929569244, 0.016861988231539726, 0.04095706716179848, -0.0026559410616755486, -0.05023892596364021, 0.008567243814468384, 0.006472977343946695, -0.04989228397607803, -0.009999330155551434, 0.0015525694470852613, 0.012529163621366024, -0.06016989052295685, 0.012194978073239326, -0.011405564844608307, -0.048530105501413345, 0.05757985636591911, 0.012679262086749077, -0.011967197060585022, 0.0602029524743557, -0.026397282257676125, 0.006161101628094912, 0.069210946559906, -0.013559763319790363, -0.0008999917190521955, 0.0503668375313282, -0.0005680822650901973, 0.07424565404653549, -0.04266563057899475, 0.008744742721319199, -0.05389020964503288, -0.03865555673837662, 0.04940250888466835, 0.023877495899796486, 0.025476928800344467, -0.10272346436977386, -0.04143764078617096, -0.03531034290790558, -0.03678436577320099, -0.013560629449784756, -0.013047460466623306, -0.03373374044895172, -0.01391797699034214, -0.02484203316271305, -0.024442842230200768, 0.0401642806828022, -0.00019802954921033233, -0.047245025634765625, 0.012134288437664509, -0.010775857605040073, -0.004780159797519445, 0.06911797821521759, -0.02176736854016781, -0.0026884169783443213, -0.00239630788564682, -0.001312021748162806, 0.021211275830864906, -0.027105683460831642, 0.09688903391361237, -0.025679271668195724, -0.017460880801081657, 0.035967763513326645, -0.017357362434267998, -0.008902071043848991, -0.004283621907234192, 0.016809945926070213, 0.016233736649155617, -0.024936314672231674, 0.017780916765332222, 0.0015233441954478621, 0.01778748258948326, 0.027024073526263237, -0.011077545583248138, -0.029868099838495255, 0.05234997346997261, 0.03709794208407402, -0.07406909763813019, 0.02139999531209469, -0.05796274170279503, -0.028984786942601204, 0.004154504276812077, -0.026678916066884995, 0.024147847667336464, 0.06598275899887085, -0.003221257822588086, -0.024054894223809242, 0.0303349532186985, -0.029789738357067108, -0.05919384956359863, -0.017660917714238167, -0.07822060585021973, -0.025895772501826286, 0.001333623193204403, 0.04881103336811066, 0.00958351232111454, 0.06159154325723648, -0.014093488454818726, -0.00593278743326664, -0.006351727060973644, -0.0641254335641861, -0.011954983696341515, 0.03253350779414177, -0.023965029045939445, -0.00859038159251213, 0.029962940141558647, -0.07382342964410782, -0.04773638769984245, -0.012439321726560593, -0.013869835063815117, -0.022986186668276787, 0.06385190039873123, 0.008928832598030567, -0.0018746748100966215, 0.05431539937853813, 0.01814192906022072, 0.025200465694069862, -0.024547776207327843, 0.015164876356720924, -0.013790175318717957, -0.03246748074889183, -0.006777292583137751, -0.001103527843952179, 0.04793372005224228, -0.038981929421424866, 0.025675037875771523, 0.01822955161333084, -0.06254108250141144, 0.01027714554220438, -0.013604431413114071, -0.007078887894749641, -0.015536701306700706, -0.003109441604465246, -0.049648381769657135, -0.06954987347126007, 0.040348589420318604, 0.006273922510445118, -0.016783030703663826, 0.017021117731928825, 0.02205554209649563, -0.050996650010347366, 0.030857142060995102, 0.027815058827400208, -0.02114735171198845, -0.013465073890984058, 0.02080797590315342, 0.00659205624833703, 0.021806396543979645, 0.0010971915908157825, 0.07413206249475479, -0.036951832473278046, -0.016186000779271126, -0.02775479480624199, 0.03305729851126671, 0.027407949790358543, 0.008567850105464458, -0.009824610315263271, 0.01927117072045803, 0.019106274470686913, 0.00007472314609913155, 0.027098622173070908, 0.03466496244072914, -0.05977481231093407, 0.014560448937118053, 0.015925725921988487, 0.031101031228899956, 0.01011569518595934, 0.006461217068135738, -0.04056597873568535, 0.01969544216990471, 0.07224689424037933, 0.09189941734075546, 0.005135921761393547, -0.03016933985054493, -0.014333344995975494, -0.00960533693432808, 0.009743495844304562, 0.014800222590565681, -0.04702162370085716, -0.02505744993686676, -0.011453780345618725, -0.01256581675261259, 0.014254823327064514, 0.05204648897051811, -0.005716658663004637, 0.035587187856435776, 0.032976724207401276, -0.03537463769316673, 0.010665147565305233, 0.031004397198557854, -0.02734193205833435, 0.035737186670303345, -0.1075965091586113, -0.024391047656536102, -0.08848512917757034, -0.011383910663425922, 0.02847398817539215, -0.022940853610634804, 0.08624400943517685, -0.006796280387789011, -0.015561615116894245, -0.02906135469675064, -0.03666806221008301, -0.04609385132789612, -0.007701176684349775, -0.03288613259792328, 0.059361401945352554, 0.025437669828534126, 0.05246204510331154, 0.04315396398305893, -0.07228324562311172, 0.0049605402164161205, 0.040124427527189255, -0.035991121083498, 0.0025542923249304295, -0.018134718760848045, 0.003857368603348732, -0.0020476188510656357, -0.011034764349460602, 0.07942672073841095, 0.05662959814071655, -0.032192379236221313, -0.040613386780023575, 0.08715146780014038, -0.03721434623003006, -0.03216996788978577, -0.035439349710941315, 0.023067981004714966, -0.02625112421810627, 0.0671580359339714, 0.004045606590807438, 0.022169020026922226, 0.05854778364300728, 0.020942887291312218, 0.03962108865380287, -0.0020944192074239254, -0.0007362088072113693, -0.025911273434758186, -0.036731451749801636, 0.026748456060886383, 0.05365322530269623, -0.04029564931988716, 0.0431724451482296, -0.020300664007663727, 0.051634933799505234, -0.023265263065695763, 0.0002499059191904962, 0.016239071264863014, 0.0059491731226444244, 0.042687755078077316, -0.036804985255002975, 0.04004453495144844, -0.028416650369763374, 0.007902908138930798, 0.011566737666726112, 0.018206650391221046, 0.003522428683936596, -0.012408406473696232, 0.0397460050880909, -0.010454483330249786, 0.03302159160375595, 0.06546840816736221, 0.013614007271826267, 0.010260434821248055, -0.031343623995780945, -0.029480187222361565, -0.017466507852077484, 0.01638001576066017, -0.03231664374470711, -0.049268707633018494, -0.00023715465795248747, 0.034703247249126434, -0.01480926014482975, 0.059626951813697815, 0.050854407250881195, 0.0723697692155838, -0.06300026178359985, 0.026062199845910072, 0.0008933807839639485, -0.03651252016425133, 0.0438636913895607, -0.024452557787299156, -0.00894145481288433, -0.015451725572347641, 0.05385357141494751, -0.03775270655751228, 0.05088246613740921, -0.010148008354008198, -0.03493829816579819, -0.02642955631017685, 0.015323352068662643, 0.026811886578798294, 0.00040897991857491434, -0.004890254233032465, -0.03400512784719467, -0.046845559030771255, 0.006164977326989174, 0.012342043220996857, -0.021313436329364777, -0.013652936555445194, 0.01592518761754036, 0.012014524079859257, -0.03560546040534973, 0.06223445385694504, 0.02556542120873928, -0.004378214478492737, -0.04427453875541687, -0.02098493091762066, 0.006417003460228443, -0.016081802546977997, 0.016202427446842194, -0.050244517624378204, -0.0019425832433626056, 0.0212616678327322, -0.004452785011380911, 0.06620120257139206, 0.01983068510890007, 0.023074619472026825, -0.025072302669286728, 0.014794227667152882, 0.04497983306646347, -0.02028576284646988, -0.010651050135493279, -0.011688347905874252, -0.02330201305449009, -0.11898372322320938, 0.06781334429979324, -0.053854022175073624, -0.007156579289585352, 0.005227196030318737, 0.027177222073078156, -0.051394857466220856, 0.04690402373671532, 0.03779515624046326, -0.026551486924290657, 0.0002106023021042347, 0.0044441246427595615, 0.0370362289249897, 0.034668296575546265, 0.05405610054731369, -0.04538152366876602, 0.07307248562574387, -0.027223115786910057, -0.01927579566836357, 0.0067167021334171295, -0.0019473342690616846, 0.03234012797474861, -0.017543641850352287, -0.001970082288607955, -0.05388583615422249, 0.0303275678306818, 0.06212393194437027, 0.06824921816587448, 0.0037757137324661016, 0.03933274745941162, 0.012292790226638317, 0.008027547970414162, 0.06276233494281769, 0.04435225576162338, -0.024061882868409157, -0.06881564855575562, 0.052733249962329865, 0.00937239546328783, -0.019055718556046486, -0.011515923775732517, -0.05071669816970825, -0.012335284613072872, 0.043974123895168304, 0.0032415089663118124, 0.01687387377023697, 0.0130001250654459, 0.026574330404400826, 0.023082775995135307, 0.023190593346953392, -0.006090511567890644, 0.043280623853206635, -0.01845410279929638, 0.009333730675280094, -0.013208393007516861, -0.016667870804667473, -0.044686209410429, 0.04904528334736824, 0.003109234618023038, -0.10030312091112137, 0.02297956682741642, -0.025632083415985107, -0.019771289080381393, 0.03034104034304619, -0.05363329127430916, -0.00940222479403019, 0.023536626249551773, -0.024182505905628204, -0.046241406351327896, 0.03175211697816849, -0.054181165993213654, 0.003278487827628851, -0.043488625437021255, -0.03125368431210518, 0.006077110301703215, 0.045272137969732285, 0.011764608323574066, -0.007994305342435837, 0.0237997155636549, -0.024765554815530777, -0.00921719241887331, -0.06253301352262497, 0.030046837404370308, 0.02857774868607521, 0.0009401131537742913, 0.014067319221794605, -0.013118017464876175, -0.023368779569864273, 0.028338389471173286, 0.01881345547735691, 0.09453655034303665, 0.021799573674798012, 0.017699217423796654, 0.04695919528603554, -0.02921249158680439, -0.024603644385933876, -0.022698158398270607, -0.036007899791002274, -0.03196534141898155, -0.043291572481393814, -0.029238644987344742, -0.015233752317726612, -0.01165209524333477, -0.005392066203057766, 0.020147420465946198, -0.029799940064549446, -0.0100802481174469, -0.04252113774418831, 0.04809105768799782, 0.02636251226067543, 0.10279302299022675, -0.04917299374938011, -0.07620535045862198, 0.050064507871866226, -0.03688059747219086, 0.031644854694604874, 0.07289275527000427, 0.050401076674461365, 0.014319293200969696, -0.02149190381169319, 0.035307615995407104, 0.06454826891422272, -0.0015225547831505537, 0.0005082940915599465, -0.04096243157982826, 0.0009935476118698716, -0.005294266622513533, -0.024677151814103127, -0.019764592871069908, 0.018541278317570686, -0.01752403937280178, -0.031238175928592682, 0.04499256983399391, -0.04512256011366844, 0.01035426277667284, 0.0016082082875072956, -0.010449332185089588, -0.05783546715974808, -0.05395335331559181, -0.04435471445322037, -0.009295199997723103, -0.08664686977863312, -0.04964336007833481, -0.014495576731860638, 0.02332965098321438, -0.008802974596619606, 0.008657004684209824, -0.010491560213267803, 0.020822271704673767, 0.030578305944800377, 0.03169964998960495, -0.04724132642149925, -0.02524455636739731, -0.013966861180961132, 0.031275637447834015, 0.01855461858212948, -0.07166574895381927, -0.01627115160226822, -0.04877398908138275, 0.049552369862794876, -0.017672117799520493, -0.008654900826513767, 0.006796954199671745, 0.04879210889339447, 0.022089602425694466, -0.026399726048111916, -0.038540687412023544, 0.054610684514045715, 0.005259824451059103, -0.008601800538599491, -0.08654015511274338, -0.030473018065094948, 0.04763130471110344, 0.022946273908019066, 0.05854841694235802, 0.017446326091885567, 0.0036466969177126884, -0.07621129602193832, -0.014356938190758228, -0.09135067462921143, 0.036400772631168365, 0.06580070406198502, 0.04132300615310669, -0.0438801646232605, -0.09429482370615005, -0.022907612845301628, 0.041261058300733566, 0.0005145210889168084, -0.01914716511964798, 0.024463815614581108, -0.045910678803920746, -0.08854220062494278, 0.017514588311314583, -0.018003199249505997, 0.03264990076422691, -0.01167155522853136, 0.003959463443607092, 0.012926737777888775, -0.042358092963695526, 0.07945049554109573, 0.004719819873571396, -0.0021167912054806948, 0.005180761218070984, 0.023346439003944397, -0.06758663058280945, -0.012418941594660282, -0.011006266809999943, 0.009207854978740215, -0.057891249656677246, 0.016508745029568672, -0.0191816296428442, 0.05704691633582115, 0.016499830409884453, -0.05242317169904709, 0.04633389785885811, 0.0032420929055660963, 0.006331009324640036, 0.0314297080039978, 0.012498338706791401, 0.02676527015864849, 0.02755952812731266, -0.02658839151263237, -0.005890428088605404, 0.041912078857421875, 0.06821461021900177, 0.029723385348916054, -0.04200223088264465, -0.020084243267774582, -0.04142799228429794, -0.02059733308851719, -0.013133823871612549, 0.04327099397778511, 0.0818089097738266, -0.05826561152935028, -0.006651503499597311, -0.02728775143623352, -0.0050773173570632935, 0.004445701837539673, -0.03263537585735321, -0.0090343551710248, 0.07842817902565002, -0.03838792443275452, 0.0190886203199625, -0.014966649934649467, -0.05491327494382858, 0.05310674011707306, 0.005840848665684462, 0.021629102528095245, -0.03926267474889755, 0.033986158668994904, 0.014809899032115936, 0.04081500321626663, 0.03066558949649334, -0.0016016873996704817, -0.02359793707728386, -0.027938228100538254, 0.016989288851618767, -0.05402842164039612, 0.047347843647003174, -0.0333574078977108, -0.037563107907772064, -0.010294247418642044, -0.01010901853442192, -0.05061826482415199, -0.03103667125105858, 0.01813226006925106, 0.04658830165863037, 0.07491049915552139, 0.009612374939024448, 0.01448848471045494, 0.001868726685643196, -0.020140351727604866, -0.018996650353074074, -0.029540764167904854, -0.04787319153547287, 0.0054837362840771675, 0.04251629859209061, -0.005774644203484058, -0.056911781430244446, -0.02684180997312069, -0.028824731707572937, -0.029568936675786972, -0.03590942546725273, -0.023203346878290176, -0.03224524110555649, -0.03533044457435608, -0.0032030316069722176, 0.023091981187462807, 0.0024838943500071764, 0.03556119650602341, -0.02858325093984604, 0.0036135565023869276, -0.006047348026186228, 0.024191703647375107, 0.017051510512828827, -0.030322033911943436, -0.0034551953431218863, 0.00747914332896471, -0.0076249209232628345, -0.0026019273791462183, -0.012091363780200481, -0.03571026772260666, -0.02044278010725975, 0.14096856117248535, -0.03198879212141037, -0.06271971762180328, -0.0126504423096776, -0.03743565082550049, 0.04080791398882866, -0.0706193745136261, -0.02640848606824875, -0.00818144716322422, 0.032683782279491425, 0.007895296439528465, 0.02053022012114525, 0.013843384571373463, 0.025673935189843178, 0.05974641069769859, -0.03876301273703575, -0.04290042817592621, -0.02830665186047554, -0.005190576426684856, 0.020041443407535553, 0.023056890815496445, -0.002617733785882592, 0.0070780618116259575, 0.06301046907901764, -0.0034172357991337776, -0.017382023856043816, 0.01964331790804863, -0.027849482372403145, -0.018863802775740623, -0.02993469499051571, -0.0021399566903710365, -0.015273445285856724, -0.05958947166800499, -0.04651622101664543, -0.005723802838474512, 0.02558962255716324, 0.006311867851763964, -0.008131852373480797, -0.024364398792386055, 0.07829221338033676, 0.03252425417304039, -0.015462427400052547, -0.0420709066092968, -0.0596994049847126, 0.025589823722839355, -0.0013398306909948587, -0.03864477947354317, 0.03417336940765381, 0.0027045225724577904, -0.02693045139312744, -0.03553800284862518, -0.046652283519506454, -0.029086176306009293, 0.012932803481817245, 0.0052316091023385525, -0.03471292555332184, 0.004461444914340973, 0.020582541823387146, -0.0562271848320961, 0.005978924687951803, 0.01808839477598667, -0.057374220341444016, 0.013430223800241947, 0.022108448669314384, -0.032789625227451324, -0.007343426812440157, 0.02011045627295971, 0.042129915207624435, 0.0074157752096652985, -0.016259314492344856, -0.03341032937169075, 0.05797158554196358, 0.03167180344462395, -0.03812643885612488, -0.010413716547191143, -0.023487908765673637, -0.067575603723526 ]
<p>A particle bound in an infinite potential wall at $x=0$ will apply a force on the wall. For a plane wave and imagining it as a fluid bouncing off the reflection wall at $x=0$, find the force in terms of $\phi'(0)$, the derivative of wave function at $x=0$. </p> <p>We know, for a reflecting fluid, $\textrm{force }= \frac{dp}{dt}$, where $p$ is momentum. Classically, $p=mv$. In our case, $v$ is $\hbar k/m$, the velocity of the plane wave. Instead of mass, we have $|\phi|^2dx$, the probability of finding the massive particle in an interval $dx$. So $p= \frac{\hbar k}{m}|\phi|^2 dx$. Then, force $f=\frac{dp}{dt} =\frac{d(|\phi|^2 dx \hbar k/m)}{dt}$</p> <p>By the continuity equation, $\frac{d(|\phi|^2)}{dt}=-\frac{dj}{dx}$, where $j$ is probability current = $\hbar k/m |\phi|^2$. So $f=\frac{dp}{dt}=\left(\frac{\hbar k}{m}\right)^2 \frac{d(|\phi|^2)}{dx} = \frac{\hbar k}{m} 2 \phi \phi' dx$. </p> <p>But for infinite potential, $\phi(0)=0$, so this gives 0. So I have an unwanted $\phi$ and a pesky $dx$ in my problem. I'm stumped for days, I'd appreciate all help. I'm fairly sure I should be getting an answer of force ~ $\phi'(0)^2$.</p>
g5891
[ 0.01899227686226368, 0.06132713332772255, 0.0037795123644173145, -0.034457430243492126, 0.03956068307161331, 0.05830759182572365, 0.04406127706170082, 0.04209129884839058, -0.04743363708257675, -0.03443733602762222, -0.021578099578619003, 0.044121574610471725, -0.05102210119366646, 0.04232824221253395, 0.047214992344379425, 0.005480416119098663, 0.10225067287683487, -0.004698812961578369, -0.011056465096771717, -0.027860740199685097, -0.024217771366238594, 0.023861166089773178, -0.027154630050063133, -0.06127318739891052, 0.07659675925970078, -0.03650985285639763, 0.023931575939059258, -0.047887612134218216, -0.025067580863833427, 0.009061622433364391, -0.004010895732790232, 0.019915271550416946, 0.035359907895326614, -0.03234899416565895, 0.024464745074510574, 0.01428200863301754, 0.004586809780448675, -0.004288043361157179, 0.026110462844371796, -0.03039245866239071, -0.0066418093629181385, -0.008557581342756748, 0.05041315406560898, -0.016478292644023895, -0.0210117157548666, 0.04051157832145691, -0.04593279957771301, 0.014501459896564484, -0.025367747992277145, -0.015340344049036503, 0.006585907656699419, 0.006458659656345844, 0.04275616258382797, -0.03144964203238487, -0.06463456898927689, 0.0655679851770401, 0.025222012773156166, -0.06603843718767166, 0.0033713446464389563, 0.04133746400475502, 0.02328326180577278, -0.02231547050178051, -0.012097657658159733, -0.026154054328799248, 0.040119271725416183, -0.055972788482904434, -0.036704134196043015, 0.03566909581422806, -0.025823932141065598, -0.008275025524199009, 0.002958518685773015, -0.057547591626644135, -0.009985046461224556, -0.0658419132232666, -0.06097268685698509, 0.009955043904483318, -0.02077619917690754, -0.019280076026916504, 0.01639927364885807, -0.00630637351423502, -0.0009820580016821623, 0.012238246388733387, 0.024725498631596565, 0.0477755106985569, 0.0357428714632988, 0.025436311960220337, 0.011927438899874687, 0.005545678082853556, -0.012335550040006638, -0.01016558613628149, -0.057407815009355545, -0.05731980502605438, 0.0019355419790372252, -0.043614909052848816, 0.03124741092324257, 0.005678982939571142, -0.00517676817253232, 0.003926004748791456, -0.037076186388731, 0.0029047688003629446, -0.02094320021569729, -0.00215329066850245, 0.004135682713240385, 0.014831099659204483, -0.004931456875056028, 0.020822636783123016, 0.01782134361565113, 0.07537250220775604, -0.006319744512438774, 0.010833727195858955, -0.0063596065156161785, -0.016726523637771606, 0.01633007638156414, -0.046336837112903595, 0.009234885685145855, -0.03908797353506088, 0.00036471389466896653, 0.042452190071344376, -0.064913809299469, 0.10715030878782272, -0.01794290728867054, 0.00774548901244998, -0.010346157476305962, 0.09161128103733063, -0.04501960799098015, -0.012678790837526321, -0.03128708526492119, 0.05684567242860794, 0.05749131739139557, 0.005901243072003126, 0.01627316139638424, 0.0018017305992543697, 0.035024531185626984, -0.023125851526856422, -0.013126181438565254, 0.0011155548272654414, -0.012155940756201744, -0.010584847070276737, 0.04864012449979782, 0.003573545254766941, 0.016519270837306976, -0.00840186420828104, 0.0009292273316532373, 0.02453542873263359, -0.07851298898458481, 0.023402975872159004, 0.051273882389068604, -0.03419755399227142, 0.03412887454032898, -0.026816677302122116, -0.028431842103600502, 0.017815176397562027, -0.01946394518017769, 0.04471078887581825, 0.05435270816087723, -0.013546508736908436, 0.072127565741539, 0.001755216158926487, -0.06421072781085968, -0.002354716882109642, 0.046704135835170746, 0.03316836804151535, 0.01532235648483038, -0.04645048826932907, -0.0219029039144516, 0.006632944568991661, 0.022220894694328308, -0.02788194641470909, -0.010907097719609737, -0.01709005981683731, -0.05615362152457237, 0.01916022226214409, 0.013820871710777283, -0.024151751771569252, -0.03815983980894089, 0.025040870532393456, -0.05081489682197571, -0.08834505081176758, 0.024740660563111305, 0.04014558717608452, 0.0026754713617265224, -0.012802407145500183, 0.01781308278441429, 0.017669109627604485, -0.019443484023213387, 0.007113494444638491, 0.01875242032110691, 0.0149145582690835, -0.01256015058606863, -0.01621793583035469, -0.049258626997470856, -0.003388065844774246, 0.026452723890542984, 0.016095390543341637, -0.0221979022026062, 0.04792579263448715, 0.05142439529299736, -0.09672509878873825, -0.05248040333390236, -0.026819946244359016, -0.05491630733013153, 0.0686049833893776, 0.06708987057209015, 0.00030137793510220945, 0.030713563784956932, 0.027737729251384735, 0.037982027977705, 0.01217611227184534, -0.019951213151216507, -0.008936800062656403, 0.00983919482678175, -0.055612530559301376, -0.04252730682492256, 0.018022192642092705, -0.02249830961227417, -0.06572020798921585, -0.022307539358735085, 0.040283527225255966, -0.021623052656650543, 0.008017579093575478, -0.028116825968027115, 0.03872458636760712, 0.04141372814774513, 0.00949202198535204, -0.02994382008910179, 0.04991081357002258, -0.031203925609588623, -0.013408668339252472, 0.013266077265143394, 0.07430344074964523, -0.06552917510271072, -0.032183676958084106, 0.0020080090034753084, 0.029463566839694977, 0.038232460618019104, 0.04371176287531853, -0.014932798221707344, 0.009793942794203758, -0.03762861341238022, 0.0056465379893779755, -0.0359773114323616, -0.016244763508439064, -0.021891655400395393, -0.07416598498821259, 0.03262398764491081, -0.009885767474770546, -0.027719084173440933, 0.04874681308865547, 0.07790827006101608, 0.04426409676671028, 0.039659325033426285, -0.03327420726418495, -0.03821945562958717, 0.04964083805680275, 0.017161134630441666, -0.009103896096348763, -0.03342911973595619, -0.0053850761614739895, 0.008705376647412777, -0.06749227643013, -0.04620250687003136, -0.007365413475781679, 0.030591560527682304, 0.07934954017400742, -0.03607579320669174, 0.05083495005965233, -0.04782659932971001, 0.09532957524061203, 0.02910623326897621, 0.005435042083263397, 0.03468279913067818, 0.060034893453121185, 0.029049845412373543, 0.040165409445762634, -0.01594552956521511, -0.03860685974359512, 0.0370233878493309, -0.08150394260883331, 0.04070381075143814, 0.0271371491253376, -0.026349280029535294, -0.0035989563912153244, 0.026758141815662384, 0.032648783177137375, 0.010353307239711285, -0.08095286786556244, 0.02505968138575554, 0.03332022577524185, 0.02946729212999344, 0.020133228972554207, -0.017918001860380173, 0.021973639726638794, 0.0018051416845992208, 0.006057626102119684, -0.02558540739119053, 0.060148999094963074, 0.014302722178399563, -0.023515505716204643, 0.028191497549414635, -0.006057472433894873, 0.004303700290620327, -0.014021066017448902, -0.03147503361105919, 0.014376405626535416, 0.034074656665325165, -0.023619769141077995, -0.006975272204726934, -0.005925881210714579, 0.02430989034473896, 0.0008732727146707475, 0.04149416834115982, 0.07101073116064072, 0.0002111727517331019, -0.027309557422995567, 0.0006061166059225798, 0.010249960236251354, -0.004261396359652281, -0.03518645092844963, -0.028976863250136375, -0.025686318054795265, 0.017744218930602074, -0.046441324055194855, 0.0352628231048584, 0.011972283944487572, 0.014465341344475746, 0.026177765801548958, -0.09643518924713135, 0.06397392600774765, -0.05566293001174927, -0.004315180238336325, 0.06605193018913269, 0.025398507714271545, 0.022654922679066658, -0.04869954660534859, -0.036794792860746384, -0.055637113749980927, 0.010609429329633713, 0.02227839082479477, 0.03284217789769173, 0.008880185894668102, 0.001082352246157825, -0.005508858244866133, -0.016332333907485008, -0.005721532739698887, 0.031312160193920135, -0.016731927171349525, 0.010777851566672325, 0.05172179639339447, 0.00884021632373333, 0.002471014391630888, -0.011858358047902584, -0.036346305161714554, 0.01405814103782177, 0.01748509891331196, 0.0357261560857296, 0.0010139422956854105, 0.013437050394713879, 0.042132195085287094, -0.00009601189231034368, -0.005846980027854443, 0.014894161373376846, -0.027736712247133255, 0.018767185509204865, 0.04500746354460716, 0.04457210376858711, -0.0762123316526413, -0.00033712745062075555, 0.004909792449325323, -0.02678496390581131, -0.030302923172712326, -0.004861289635300636, -0.039625369012355804, 0.02790466509759426, 0.0792221650481224, 0.008573881350457668, -0.03734636679291725, -0.021439438685774803, -0.050990331918001175, 0.012831983156502247, 0.011598998680710793, 0.0182622279971838, 0.04656391218304634, -0.0135120814666152, 0.0378887914121151, 0.0228312686085701, 0.031400710344314575, -0.005707001779228449, -0.025298818945884705, 0.07068749517202377, -0.020926417782902718, 0.03554968908429146, -0.022091716527938843, 0.02400035783648491, 0.0542336031794548, -0.009104530327022076, -0.0345093309879303, 0.00829323474317789, -0.027668284252285957, -0.07200252264738083, -0.02287377417087555, -0.013339539058506489, -0.01120098028331995, -0.01628664694726467, 0.0036009326577186584, -0.016094781458377838, 0.013055413961410522, 0.051559966057538986, -0.002418573945760727, -0.017338043078780174, -0.05179266259074211, -0.018938809633255005, -0.03712749108672142, -0.00917847454547882, -0.021644191816449165, -0.02602735348045826, -0.006309143733233213, 0.027362510561943054, 0.03197597712278366, -0.015972211956977844, 0.022602126002311707, 0.011342402547597885, 0.010264906100928783, -0.03233818709850311, 0.002583870431408286, 0.02116779237985611, -0.01836421526968479, 0.03138389065861702, -0.012976525351405144, -0.004379856400191784, -0.05734756961464882, 0.002846918534487486, 0.008453372865915298, -0.023490600287914276, 0.016766950488090515, -0.03110547922551632, 0.04567297175526619, -0.018066691234707832, -0.023058803752064705, 0.047533150762319565, 0.10238558053970337, -0.02120734564960003, 0.013495000079274178, 0.007217944134026766, 0.03088964708149433, 0.02932753413915634, 0.07910121977329254, -0.01672126166522503, -0.06420956552028656, 0.022253284230828285, 0.03166177496314049, -0.026485472917556763, -0.06463930010795593, -0.015358119271695614, -0.03788267821073532, 0.018191415816545486, -0.041432686150074005, -0.05917956307530403, -0.0037802986335009336, -0.00498322444036603, -0.031836170703172684, 0.014749730005860329, 0.0027356939390301704, -0.0019379339646548033, 0.023427514359354973, 0.02298426255583763, -0.005531118251383305, -0.028026888146996498, 0.04128473997116089, -0.06914494931697845, -0.04609319195151329, 0.021886473521590233, 0.03073439933359623, 0.061564262956380844, -0.010393221862614155, -0.04673483595252037, 0.018872683867812157, -0.004100102465599775, 0.03218470513820648, 0.05285416916012764, -0.04918748512864113, 0.01092783734202385, 0.04554309695959091, -0.0019462918862700462, 0.0005498366663232446, -0.0010625510476529598, -0.01441978570073843, -0.05240590125322342, 0.042753636837005615, -0.02709822542965412, 0.005850634537637234, 0.011591402813792229, 0.017346477136015892, -0.03450405225157738, -0.03300103917717934, 0.05480330437421799, -0.029451336711645126, -0.00181590614374727, -0.008475515991449356, 0.02017507702112198, 0.055328574031591415, -0.02881636656820774, -0.07160543650388718, -0.004825066775083542, -0.025477580726146698, -0.03173987194895744, 0.072088323533535, 0.026815347373485565, 0.006905809976160526, 0.01045552734285593, 0.08137550204992294, -0.002729005180299282, -0.022254623472690582, 0.054739128798246384, -0.011989576742053032, 0.0052827936597168446, 0.012709296308457851, -0.005920476280152798, -0.02305544912815094, -0.04824068769812584, 0.00576357264071703, 0.05227900668978691, 0.011409983970224857, -0.0021887177135795355, -0.015334413386881351, 0.0034341509453952312, 0.0030298910569399595, -0.00783289410173893, -0.02413245663046837, -0.06116959825158119, 0.0395779013633728, 0.0486958883702755, -0.047239769250154495, -0.01882912777364254, -0.012840183451771736, -0.042297013103961945, -0.024825870990753174, 0.001027752528898418, -0.006068581715226173, -0.017996132373809814, -0.05478562042117119, 0.02425631321966648, 0.013821077533066273, 0.04221637174487114, 0.0188688263297081, -0.013259642757475376, 0.046074215322732925, 0.022311696782708168, -0.025695662945508957, 0.028318198397755623, 0.004216304514557123, -0.0026635993272066116, 0.017639106139540672, -0.04480650648474693, 0.003286641091108322, 0.053024131804704666, -0.01390312984585762, 0.007828066125512123, -0.037394195795059204, -0.04493871331214905, -0.03590330109000206, 0.012321819551289082, -0.01576784811913967, -0.01712995022535324, -0.03577282279729843, 0.005497321020811796, -0.013778721913695335, -0.02378707565367222, 0.02340838871896267, 0.014059689827263355, 0.019543910399079323, 0.005199202802032232, 0.058422818779945374, -0.008213357999920845, -0.006401626393198967, 0.06586463749408722, 0.014477324672043324, -0.004418073687702417, -0.03183582425117493, -0.025424879044294357, 0.040450818836688995, -0.043816547840833664, 0.005181151442229748, 0.026207128539681435, -0.0624229721724987, -0.026510441675782204, 0.005000571720302105, -0.006447609979659319, -0.06711510568857193, 0.040192123502492905, -0.04523460939526558, -0.04370850697159767, -0.07092463225126266, -0.040800902992486954, -0.023248935118317604, 0.0035619360860437155, -0.0750257670879364, 0.07089275121688843, -0.04722897335886955, -0.03856164216995239, 0.03472410514950752, 0.007742683403193951, 0.01974315755069256, -0.001797935925424099, 0.018812326714396477, 0.026037752628326416, 0.0014635941479355097, 0.000025324134185211733, -0.018111247569322586, -0.06469392031431198, 0.04248209670186043, 0.053753357380628586, 0.010641389526426792, -0.0340394526720047, -0.025904400274157524, 0.017669571563601494, -0.0742477998137474, 0.0033407791052013636, 0.05978020280599594, 0.014439128339290619, -0.021864062175154686, 0.00013872266572434455, -0.00015228672418743372, 0.023742012679576874, -0.07120770961046219, 0.09462019056081772, -0.0439610555768013, -0.05201457440853119, -0.02768133394420147, 0.028455164283514023, 0.03347127512097359, 0.11184361577033997, -0.0449514240026474, 0.02652163803577423, 0.06356875598430634, -0.044873885810375214, 0.02516024000942707, -0.0431031733751297, 0.04452691972255707, -0.016011757776141167, 0.03786342963576317, -0.03135422617197037, 0.04565691947937012, 0.019365794956684113, -0.015070348978042603, -0.06256011873483658, 0.015418963506817818, 0.01845938339829445, 0.014178730547428131, -0.07310930639505386, -0.027262093499302864, 0.004041059873998165, 0.0032338188029825687, -0.020463483408093452, 0.001046987483277917, -0.0744887962937355, 0.040753286331892014, 0.02089487761259079, -0.057303160429000854, 0.01594051532447338, -0.03273225203156471, -0.004491457249969244, -0.0502518005669117, -0.012084797024726868, 0.015706749632954597, -0.050192978233098984, 0.05248825252056122, -0.021050607785582542, -0.026120774447917938, 0.006838945206254721, -0.019160613417625427, 0.04881663993000984, -0.039253003895282745, -0.09792539477348328, 0.007272121496498585, 0.030347641557455063, 0.0374317467212677, 0.057910412549972534, 0.02869470790028572, 0.04834183678030968, -0.01380559429526329, 0.028310010209679604, 0.01736314781010151, -0.04687578231096268, -0.02756146900355816, 0.02181760035455227, -0.03204350173473358, -0.0006788730388507247, 0.016280340030789375, 0.028124678879976273, 0.016794031485915184, 0.020622268319129944, 0.02983856201171875, -0.0039889314211905, -0.021856563165783882, 0.007258917670696974, -0.03411657735705376, 0.025544142350554466, 0.02762928418815136, 0.0808854028582573, 0.02048526145517826, -0.005572009831666946, -0.0204110536724329, -0.0177909042686224, 0.013209132477641106, -0.030002018436789513, 0.0036538783460855484, -0.03337078168988228, -0.06401098519563675, 0.008070982992649078, -0.0051429918967187405, 0.01954197697341442, -0.004004230722784996, -0.01976165734231472, -0.060845039784908295, 0.01767532341182232, 0.04147284850478172, -0.04185182973742485, 0.0918431505560875, 0.0865488052368164, -0.04379510506987572, 0.019435804337263107, 0.003222018713131547, -0.01853656955063343, -0.08700184524059296, 0.009701243601739407, -0.023558607324957848, -0.04775908961892128, -0.019180892035365105, -0.007882337085902691, 0.07257080078125, -0.05437397211790085, -0.03616335615515709, -0.05698665976524353, 0.009192929603159428, -0.012556427158415318, -0.07055242359638214, 0.014235801994800568, 0.023577550426125526, -0.001147845177911222, -0.01693560741841793, 0.014258041977882385, -0.0185412410646677, -0.014523630030453205, -0.03088741935789585, 0.0043466524221003056, 0.022397585213184357, -0.05926574394106865, -0.0065969484858214855, -0.0016005911165848374, 0.0008975419914349914, 0.03413097932934761, 0.024700064212083817, -0.03499092161655426, 0.020619915798306465, 0.03906497359275818, -0.11570674180984497, -0.01964641362428665, 0.04157296568155289, 0.06619749963283539, -0.0242693442851305, 0.03617684915661812, -0.05028500780463219, 0.004673030227422714, -0.006000686436891556, 0.02574910596013069, -0.054037321358919144, 0.024738315492868423, 0.036905672401189804 ]
<p>In a quantum mechanics, there is the following formula to derive the zero energy $E_0$ of a perturbed Hamiltonian $$H = H_0 + V$$ knowing the zero energy $W_0$ of the free Hamiltonian $H_0$: $$E_0 = W_0 + i\frac{d}{dt}\text{ln}R(t)|_{t\rightarrow\infty(1-i\eta)}$$ The exponential killing the excited states faster than the lowest energy one. However, one needs to suppose a non-vanishing overlap of the two ground states $|\phi_0\rangle$ for $H_0$ and $|\psi_0\rangle$ for $H$. I read that if two have different symmetry they must be orthogonal but I didn't manage to derive why.</p> <p>Let's suppose that $G$ is a symmetry of $|\phi_0\rangle$ then $G|\phi_0\rangle=0$ and $\langle\psi_0|G|\phi_0\rangle=0$ and if $|\psi_0\rangle$ is not invariant under $G$ I still need to have $$G|\psi_0\rangle \propto |\psi_0\rangle$$ to derive $\langle\psi_0|\phi_0\rangle=0$. ($|\psi_0\rangle$ needs to be an eigenvector of $G$ with non-vanishing eigenvalue)</p>
g5892
[ 0.031140636652708054, -0.02459317445755005, -0.008459657430648804, -0.012886444106698036, 0.027555057778954506, 0.015893632546067238, 0.0464712418615818, 0.042159948498010635, -0.024383047595620155, 0.01698954589664936, 0.02764207497239113, 0.0028920758049935102, -0.01204378716647625, 0.03620762750506401, -0.0029846022371202707, 0.01566477119922638, 0.11270806193351746, 0.052240822464227676, -0.02889147400856018, 0.0063901981338858604, -0.06730803102254868, -0.008376705460250378, -0.05882375314831734, -0.024856457486748695, 0.021221259608864784, -0.08797554671764374, 0.02448812499642372, -0.04653051868081093, -0.0625368058681488, -0.011955329217016697, 0.020384807139635086, 0.011337191797792912, 0.04375290125608444, -0.030994191765785217, -0.0034644375555217266, 0.031205328181385994, 0.0692833960056305, 0.015851372852921486, 0.03724478557705879, -0.02443877048790455, -0.013007654808461666, 0.007025124970823526, 0.05644550547003746, -0.011503838934004307, -0.020740598440170288, 0.005827717948704958, 0.027037695050239563, 0.009132683277130127, -0.02517097257077694, -0.017647137865424156, 0.025941889733076096, 0.03535148501396179, 0.0927862748503685, -0.08285950124263763, -0.04707612469792366, 0.006132771261036396, -0.03382774442434311, -0.050146475434303284, -0.004555442836135626, 0.07169711589813232, 0.004622910637408495, -0.04237356036901474, -0.0022648137528449297, 0.03562324121594429, 0.04793025180697441, 0.024742815643548965, -0.054070185869932175, -0.03576164320111275, 0.02647271379828453, 0.007612577639520168, -0.04490245506167412, 0.002706659957766533, -0.05283240228891373, -0.0017712053377181292, -0.023066025227308273, -0.007730087265372276, 0.053088437765836716, -0.029474575072526932, 0.000006920824034750694, 0.010090689174830914, -0.0522565096616745, -0.030790964141488075, -0.03744128346443176, -0.020795807242393494, 0.045119453221559525, 0.028070153668522835, 0.00007217874372145161, 0.003273864509537816, -0.03119160421192646, 0.025253552943468094, 0.03876425325870514, 0.007101206574589014, 0.07332157343626022, 0.009193617850542068, 0.007595115341246128, 0.004307129420340061, 0.0022697453387081623, 0.055018018931150436, -0.022791702300310135, -0.0073310318402945995, 0.00016880476323422045, -0.010453889146447182, -0.012328495271503925, -0.0709669291973114, 0.07118770480155945, -0.03419801592826843, 0.030213000252842903, -0.049360670149326324, -0.018074624240398407, 0.033950839191675186, 0.0018245293758809566, 0.017382120713591576, -0.021642575040459633, -0.08088319003582001, -0.009800342842936516, -0.051643531769514084, 0.06862609833478928, -0.04472159966826439, -0.047011084854602814, -0.004309516865760088, 0.044352252036333084, 0.03371399641036987, 0.01123269833624363, 0.07134570926427841, -0.005290190223604441, 0.023384951055049896, -0.0004975707270205021, -0.035643093287944794, 0.035279788076877594, -0.010338207706809044, -0.002570583950728178, -0.041029490530490875, 0.02132594771683216, 0.07239069044589996, 0.010426759719848633, 0.006534562911838293, 0.03411421552300453, 0.04489397257566452, 0.029791738837957382, 0.04067211225628853, -0.00436238432303071, -0.0511603020131588, 0.002430777298286557, -0.05242517590522766, -0.012931286357343197, -0.030178189277648926, 0.014695169404149055, -0.06252843141555786, 0.04102063179016113, -0.010969709604978561, -0.0028708570171147585, 0.07997068017721176, 0.051645275205373764, 0.03543860465288162, -0.01021583192050457, -0.035046014934778214, 0.025361528620123863, -0.07295697927474976, -0.0005582578014582396, -0.0004216275701764971, -0.0066992673091590405, 0.010332820005714893, 0.04298786446452141, 0.031483203172683716, -0.03658469766378403, 0.015646271407604218, 0.028370091691613197, -0.11366531997919083, 0.005013938527554274, -0.06625685840845108, -0.004280869849026203, 0.014441713690757751, 0.027017252519726753, 0.01066298596560955, -0.00030608108500018716, 0.05310261622071266, -0.037864867597818375, 0.0028473681304603815, -0.008656200021505356, -0.0010590476449579, 0.0330413393676281, -0.02105589210987091, 0.037951622158288956, -0.010906056500971317, 0.003759651444852352, 0.08088689297437668, -0.00965839996933937, -0.016196751967072487, -0.04275907203555107, 0.015676992014050484, 0.007533792871981859, 0.030687807127833366, 0.05247064307332039, -0.01857452094554901, -0.07864047586917877, 0.01434357836842537, 0.048253852874040604, -0.04987349733710289, -0.0220808032900095, -0.0334581658244133, 0.013354177586734295, 0.0262153260409832, -0.014194261282682419, -0.033537428826093674, -0.00618793535977602, 0.0008756188326515257, 0.005189329851418734, 0.0013282436411827803, 0.032902803272008896, -0.0316995307803154, -0.018668917939066887, -0.04414701461791992, 0.002539432141929865, 0.03292756900191307, 0.018014661967754364, -0.013126075267791748, 0.016200292855501175, 0.039943136274814606, -0.048051513731479645, 0.0015620673075318336, 0.00713080819696188, 0.0314769484102726, 0.039957571774721146, 0.022286664694547653, 0.01976933516561985, -0.016356248408555984, -0.04579290375113487, -0.013852798379957676, -0.017903698608279228, 0.021833809092640877, -0.03941253572702408, -0.024259652942419052, -0.005095656029880047, -0.04456138610839844, -0.00824353564530611, 0.05800582841038704, 0.02025766298174858, 0.0465683676302433, 0.05059980973601341, 0.03780252858996391, -0.03019144758582115, 0.007532077841460705, -0.08092645555734634, 0.0199868343770504, 0.059140127152204514, -0.011903644539415836, -0.0056875902228057384, -0.014506321400403976, -0.019449856132268906, -0.0007348205544985831, -0.013778505846858025, 0.03639303892850876, -0.03095020167529583, 0.006515996064990759, -0.0462607778608799, -0.03195551037788391, 0.015901660546660423, -0.03467269241809845, -0.01659885235130787, 0.00679392134770751, 0.03147749975323677, 0.01804518699645996, 0.0004505016840994358, 0.039303142577409744, -0.07133402675390244, -0.013432606123387814, 0.00844390969723463, -0.002354484051465988, -0.02614091895520687, -0.043605025857686996, -0.038641881197690964, 0.12481945008039474, -0.023531952872872353, 0.04161380976438522, -0.008601991459727287, -0.023981282487511635, 0.02180316671729088, -0.024704154580831528, 0.029546696692705154, -0.03961968794465065, -0.08847976475954056, -0.012372982688248158, 0.02221003919839859, 0.05049880966544151, 0.02208413928747177, -0.1281617283821106, 0.007816782221198082, 0.03363848105072975, -0.03484979644417763, 0.0145900659263134, -0.0138707859441638, 0.05777575448155403, 0.025484168902039528, 0.008415511809289455, -0.02403620071709156, 0.015469236299395561, -0.019378313794732094, -0.021311163902282715, 0.01339798979461193, 0.03693222254514694, 0.0058196247555315495, -0.011069106869399548, -0.02101595140993595, -0.002849783981218934, 0.07016290724277496, -0.0620168074965477, -0.016675852239131927, -0.0388316847383976, 0.004129369277507067, 0.03156493231654167, -0.04320996627211571, -0.015825442969799042, 0.009550806134939194, -0.023573022335767746, -0.02184632234275341, 0.01879929192364216, -0.0717572569847107, -0.0805652067065239, 0.02851627767086029, -0.010240346193313599, -0.025012655183672905, -0.006233046762645245, 0.03703045845031738, 0.018002836033701897, -0.031429752707481384, -0.00809077825397253, -0.038658831268548965, -0.021983545273542404, -0.005464439280331135, 0.0306730754673481, -0.04327341914176941, -0.029209569096565247, 0.017689472064375877, -0.01067368220537901, 0.02008134499192238, -0.004412949550896883, 0.00759124755859375, 0.03616320341825485, 0.005939663853496313, 0.027068840339779854, -0.025190364569425583, 0.0003642099618446082, 0.0036887899041175842, 0.03618950396776199, -0.03181590139865875, -0.04037303104996681, -0.04658788815140724, 0.019520632922649384, 0.0010381656466051936, -0.022980056703090668, 0.018449172377586365, -0.005759805906563997, 0.0038790826220065355, -0.044647470116615295, 0.005492432974278927, 0.006534786894917488, -0.004641535226255655, -0.01194271445274353, 0.041437286883592606, 0.0030384401325136423, 0.010411594994366169, -0.00937491562217474, -0.014451848343014717, -0.011872570030391216, 0.014170846901834011, 0.042552120983600616, -0.020888986065983772, 0.010717201977968216, 0.03258020430803299, -0.0279710590839386, 0.017395932227373123, -0.010200096294283867, 0.026800453662872314, -0.050765328109264374, 0.04774206504225731, -0.008588837459683418, -0.014540563337504864, -0.07633903622627258, -0.06022973358631134, 0.01134764589369297, -0.0079290010035038, -0.04606356471776962, -0.0164695642888546, 0.04937068745493889, 0.056634701788425446, 0.015224920585751534, 0.01585596613585949, 0.003368172561749816, 0.05487615242600441, -0.03120916523039341, 0.02272648550570011, 0.008513864129781723, 0.003707414958626032, 0.0700414851307869, -0.024368561804294586, 0.03605372831225395, 0.03442831337451935, 0.013618696480989456, -0.05433077737689018, 0.07616017758846283, 0.005785737652331591, -0.020427875220775604, 0.003258168464526534, -0.021772759035229683, 0.026301879435777664, 0.033150095492601395, 0.03161762282252312, 0.02370828576385975, -0.0008156935800798237, -0.03849869593977928, 0.004179514013230801, 0.006280036643147469, -0.008428774774074554, -0.02073957771062851, -0.009789826348423958, -0.009225322864949703, 0.05074587091803551, -0.05344600975513458, -0.03242870420217514, -0.004131197929382324, -0.01080291997641325, 0.006966724060475826, -0.0007410897524096072, -0.0027317556086927652, -0.007894642651081085, 0.012366468086838722, 0.023366302251815796, -0.03018520213663578, -0.0716857761144638, -0.012666722759604454, 0.04230235889554024, 0.009185116738080978, -0.005507554393261671, -0.012871654704213142, -0.07418256253004074, 0.022966638207435608, -0.06109696626663208, 0.0695708617568016, -0.019783059135079384, 0.05608176067471504, 0.07643374800682068, -0.03537178039550781, -0.038396190851926804, 0.013603825122117996, -0.03102831356227398, 0.013071639463305473, 0.004432601388543844, -0.10582536458969116, 0.014431432820856571, -0.025471748784184456, 0.040661588311195374, -0.022222518920898438, 0.023111870512366295, 0.005945391487330198, -0.016636336222290993, -0.060681525617837906, -0.06976546347141266, 0.06913430243730545, 0.04824543744325638, 0.0397796556353569, -0.029444903135299683, -0.05615999922156334, 0.0376066118478775, -0.009911945089697838, 0.05300477519631386, 0.022283516824245453, -0.06676144897937775, 0.06663842499256134, -0.03992481529712677, -0.041984137147665024, 0.04169141501188278, -0.0062638381496071815, 0.025456609204411507, -0.013617897406220436, -0.013357189483940601, 0.009325802326202393, -0.009412731975317001, -0.036082472652196884, -0.02830698899924755, -0.0183638297021389, -0.04023490846157074, -0.00394067307934165, 0.024625780060887337, -0.008888338692486286, 0.06925902515649796, 0.008801326155662537, -0.02178684063255787, -0.0072063966654241085, -0.028303446248173714, -0.028641661629080772, 0.010364577174186707, 0.04139908403158188, 0.00046398400445468724, 0.0030653858557343483, 0.06670398265123367, -0.011189432814717293, 0.018734265118837357, 0.017303818836808205, -0.045249126851558685, 0.031310074031353, -0.05245409905910492, 0.030910464003682137, -0.04069569334387779, 0.011497486382722855, 0.020202912390232086, 0.021444108337163925, 0.09323683381080627, 0.018912727013230324, 0.022511731833219528, -0.007147660478949547, -0.07987303286790848, -0.031059110537171364, 0.046883199363946915, -0.003549852641299367, 0.0005811635637655854, 0.0032965359278023243, -0.04928009957075119, 0.0028682881966233253, -0.08534394204616547, -0.019643373787403107, 0.009278635494410992, -0.02820044942200184, -0.003743608482182026, -0.031112434342503548, -0.008307388983666897, 0.014618600718677044, -0.016108205541968346, -0.023315008729696274, -0.034098561853170395, 0.04879453778266907, 0.01870156079530716, 0.052875272929668427, -0.013685542158782482, -0.019162295386195183, 0.03559210151433945, 0.0036519027780741453, -0.062063973397016525, -0.008713695220649242, -0.001586994854733348, -0.0194521676748991, -0.005832312162965536, -0.07178044319152832, 0.035145554691553116, 0.062334094196558, -0.045621518045663834, 0.022895941510796547, -0.06432247906923294, 0.010564318858087063, -0.029021717607975006, -0.03714696317911148, -0.04159257933497429, 0.022686667740345, 0.0064269863069057465, 0.03055613301694393, 0.006993275135755539, 0.029743514955043793, 0.07128036767244339, 0.03449450060725212, -0.011209184303879738, 0.02256161905825138, 0.044230032712221146, -0.007709193974733353, 0.03200717642903328, 0.02358478493988514, 0.03692692145705223, -0.00905466265976429, -0.028290919959545135, -0.011829476803541183, -0.01228815782815218, -0.014413334429264069, 0.003150484524667263, 0.011759189888834953, 0.020988503471016884, 0.018903512507677078, 0.06000234931707382, 0.06654340773820877, -0.049619875848293304, -0.04861404001712799, 0.036875054240226746, 0.008975465781986713, -0.05858076736330986, -0.003289108397439122, 0.0008988620829768479, -0.043980494141578674, -0.030183905735611916, 0.012910534627735615, 0.01142475102096796, -0.017935773357748985, 0.08962787687778473, 0.06343568116426468, -0.03774752840399742, -0.05447879061102867, -0.03460036963224411, -0.032171864062547684, 0.0017606709152460098, 0.016120629385113716, -0.026932887732982635, -0.07375728338956833, -0.013494984246790409, 0.025901300832629204, 0.04702969267964363, -0.029455751180648804, 0.05617693066596985, -0.00619127182289958, -0.0006917037535458803, 0.047922246158123016, -0.02564243972301483, -0.07045000791549683, -0.011431303806602955, 0.016020162031054497, 0.022571606561541557, -0.006982401944696903, 0.0237777978181839, -0.0498054064810276, -0.030877405777573586, -0.057104483246803284, 0.03230588510632515, 0.049369651824235916, 0.01429606694728136, 0.04241752624511719, 0.030334170907735825, 0.0004063111264258623, 0.024981753900647163, 0.024215951561927795, 0.05998322740197182, 0.036563217639923096, -0.05579470843076706, -0.04692108556628227, 0.021799424663186073, -0.04596611484885216, 0.0060586510226130486, 0.01881578378379345, -0.03763388842344284, 0.021654203534126282, -0.0032702635508030653, -0.013989299535751343, -0.028528856113553047, 0.03010411374270916, -0.013621604070067406, 0.02625144086778164, 0.017405351623892784, 0.10637663304805756, 0.06419376283884048, -0.009824610315263271, -0.06918063759803772, 0.09258764237165451, -0.03416726365685463, -0.03457129746675491, -0.040329739451408386, -0.009092524647712708, 0.00933574978262186, -0.025925958529114723, -0.024420956149697304, -0.007590172346681356, 0.0022950542625039816, -0.012147760950028896, 0.00859150942414999, -0.008397516794502735, 0.011470598168671131, 0.010084740817546844, 0.015308791771531105, 0.007167527452111244, 0.02393791824579239, -0.00852205790579319, 0.016083426773548126, 0.026102786883711815, 0.016352251172065735, -0.018990876153111458, -0.03767817094922066, 0.02143942005932331, 0.020603151991963387, -0.03951630741357803, -0.064577117562294, 0.003106536576524377, 0.022344037890434265, 0.014148406684398651, 0.00003849686254397966, 0.045584145933389664, -0.005561059806495905, -0.04268653318285942, -0.0006805037846788764, -0.019325237721204758, -0.027167243883013725, 0.02230520360171795, -0.011818374507129192, 0.045612066984176636, 0.052726343274116516, 0.052595458924770355, -0.0349687859416008, 0.025765398517251015, -0.018872100859880447, -0.0027096671983599663, 0.0026394613087177277, -0.005917269736528397, -0.00921572558581829, -0.013614088296890259, -0.0030428068712353706, 0.013990039005875587, -0.03249962255358696, 0.005980012007057667, 0.04803166911005974, -0.06001251935958862, 0.026718029752373695, 0.005884549580514431, -0.039083026349544525, -0.017459427937865257, 0.06956936419010162, -0.05890052393078804, -0.013379968702793121, 0.027409663423895836, 0.01620871014893055, 0.025405695661902428, 0.033906012773513794, 0.015618789941072464, 0.04875393956899643, 0.0035795539151877165, -0.07860593497753143, 0.029628446325659752, 0.03493083640933037, 0.005319913849234581, -0.038516923785209656, -0.04406442120671272, -0.008829450234770775, -0.04033265635371208, -0.044314220547676086, -0.013685924001038074, -0.001733828685246408, 0.051889702677726746, 0.04196308180689812, 0.02155906707048416, -0.03582533076405525, -0.016646817326545715, -0.03190872445702553, 0.05965377390384674, -0.08191583305597305, -0.012271501123905182, -0.0011600253637880087, -0.04351703077554703, 0.011253600008785725, 0.01815907098352909, 0.007348489016294479, -0.06027134135365486, -0.014804859645664692, -0.017427602782845497, 0.01138756051659584, -0.013416148722171783, 0.03430599346756935, 0.01846650242805481, 0.09234102815389633, -0.009028133936226368, -0.029758093878626823, 0.020272146910429, -0.024513928219676018, 0.08546832948923111, 0.09518652409315109, 0.01748926192522049, 0.07423962652683258, -0.019821569323539734, -0.03605005890130997, 0.04168816655874252, -0.005563677288591862, -0.0066345748491585255, -0.018751012161374092, -0.020151782780885696, -0.03998493775725365, -0.05787371098995209, 0.020249487832188606, 0.06629820913076401 ]
<p>I'm having trouble understanding something in one of my text books:</p> <blockquote> <p>Let’s have a look at the implications of each circuit configuration. Figure 3.13 shows the Conventional representation of a parallel circuit. If you assume that the resistance of the wires can be neglected, then the voltage drop across each bulb is equal to the e.m.f. of the source, the dynamo. The Current flowing from the source is divided between each bulb depending on its resistance (remember I = E/R), Removing one of the bulbs would not affect the voltage drop across the other bulb and would therefore not affect the Current in it, although the overall Current from the dynamo would drop as the demand has been reduced.</p> </blockquote> <p>Specifically, the line about removing one of the bulbs not affecting the voltage drop. My understanding is that the sum of voltage drops in a circuit must be equal to the output of the emf, but the way I'm reading the text suggests that if you have three bulbs in a parallel circuit and you remove one of them, the voltage drop remains the same - this is what I don't understand, though. If you a lamp is removed, then that's one less lamp consuming emf. Does it not get redistributed to the other two lamps?</p> <p>Likewise, the text mentions the overall current from the dynamo dropping because demand has been reduced.</p> <p>My initial understanding was that current from an emf is only affected by the emf - not the demands of components further along the circuit, as in this case. What have I misunderstood?</p>
g5893
[ 0.03622809797525406, 0.024401115253567696, -0.004329475574195385, -0.015722161158919334, 0.052590642124414444, -0.0009808380855247378, 0.07086210697889328, 0.050748225301504135, -0.0286298468708992, 0.029085267335176468, -0.05573459342122078, 0.0034587914124131203, -0.002163023455068469, 0.009304562583565712, 0.016801143065094948, 0.046535100787878036, -0.006526460871100426, 0.01622598059475422, -0.005075035151094198, -0.014347201213240623, -0.04394037276506424, 0.0695033147931099, -0.03494452312588692, -0.06349815428256989, -0.026247132569551468, 0.0007837994489818811, 0.013216335326433182, -0.05938171222805977, -0.06272216886281967, -0.012707090005278587, -0.03452552109956741, -0.01064127404242754, 0.043438106775283813, -0.03411684185266495, -0.09868437051773071, 0.020134570077061653, 0.07140231877565384, 0.04427680745720863, -0.021235359832644463, 0.03250126168131828, 0.021381249651312828, 0.06495263427495956, 0.05295034125447273, 0.021553466096520424, -0.020478522405028343, -0.03846750408411026, -0.003133663907647133, -0.016324514523148537, -0.019487082958221436, -0.01964886300265789, 0.0187632255256176, 0.007532445713877678, 0.031512755900621414, 0.013196713291108608, 0.015227013267576694, -0.025892898440361023, 0.014965874142944813, -0.02266155555844307, 0.013491389341652393, 0.03860503435134888, 0.04610974341630936, 0.022261062636971474, 0.01639380306005478, -0.007741556968539953, 0.05069237947463989, -0.0019512814469635487, -0.053047262132167816, -0.007817987352609634, 0.0017340726917609572, -0.004828830249607563, -0.008409067988395691, -0.004571731202304363, -0.02079070545732975, -0.015249408781528473, 0.06460654735565186, 0.015294903889298439, 0.043316107243299484, -0.042943280190229416, 0.019169993698596954, 0.04224628210067749, -0.008312368765473366, -0.04591286554932594, 0.0026023786049336195, 0.06283413618803024, 0.04392404481768608, 0.011963468044996262, -0.0008377474150620401, 0.056545693427324295, -0.040416210889816284, -0.056047264486551285, 0.018308499827980995, -0.07840074598789215, 0.05686765909194946, -0.017195669934153557, -0.02239551953971386, -0.01676754839718342, -0.027099303901195526, 0.013598598539829254, 0.052655525505542755, 0.04610795900225639, -0.02045545168220997, 0.005771226715296507, -0.044707510620355606, -0.043327704071998596, -0.049666907638311386, 0.0021266487892717123, 0.05858134478330612, 0.04798126220703125, 0.02076156809926033, -0.029842473566532135, -0.07584201544523239, -0.10335852205753326, -0.05907326936721802, -0.016646742820739746, -0.080714151263237, -0.08744827657938004, 0.08347418159246445, 0.033105503767728806, -0.01882275566458702, 0.029014037922024727, -0.010154545307159424, -0.006912500597536564, 0.016462236642837524, 0.06405257433652878, -0.009961183182895184, -0.004152065142989159, -0.0170778576284647, 0.04564525932073593, 0.054148443043231964, 0.0059237186796963215, -0.0011034164344891906, -0.055563196539878845, -0.05255194380879402, 0.02702801674604416, 0.01822075806558132, -0.018156755715608597, 0.04919518902897835, -0.00500600365921855, -0.034383878111839294, -0.006411705631762743, 0.04503514990210533, 0.03653664141893387, 0.004299889784306288, -0.04119518771767616, 0.0021494466345757246, 0.02049465849995613, -0.005094274878501892, -0.009325281716883183, 0.04566306620836258, -0.02890593372285366, 0.07761992514133453, 0.033221956342458725, -0.03164017200469971, -0.0737810805439949, 0.02855663187801838, 0.018985565751791, 0.012632307596504688, -0.0777374878525734, -0.03387013450264931, 0.034910645335912704, -0.03041801229119301, 0.026383187621831894, -0.005138963460922241, 0.014679811894893646, -0.04944279044866562, -0.04246147722005844, 0.05735445395112038, -0.02119923010468483, 0.004336308687925339, -0.04308224469423294, -0.04220869764685631, -0.008558766916394234, 0.006469632964581251, 0.05120391771197319, -0.023573746904730797, 0.0379183292388916, 0.09816320985555649, -0.03342580795288086, -0.0005593413370661438, 0.07411215454339981, -0.0372292622923851, 0.031464457511901855, 0.005930142477154732, -0.008846749551594257, -0.007019927259534597, 0.0012980785686522722, -0.060451965779066086, 0.024629123508930206, -0.07092642784118652, -0.011584999039769173, -0.0687168538570404, 0.02990497276186943, 0.024083243682980537, 0.02391207031905651, 0.009690944105386734, 0.0073438482359051704, -0.08195743709802628, -0.01984245702624321, 0.014936949126422405, 0.03276627138257027, -0.024896720424294472, -0.011905784718692303, 0.06165287271142006, 0.05882341414690018, 0.023356106132268906, 0.027842232957482338, 0.003315269248560071, -0.011176329106092453, 0.039215605705976486, -0.08145248144865036, 0.018484488129615784, -0.009083784185349941, 0.0014345080126076937, 0.01817619986832142, 0.021657174453139305, -0.03288685530424118, 0.016443781554698944, 0.005244456697255373, -0.044587135314941406, -0.012839767150580883, -0.044776927679777145, -0.03956649824976921, 0.019477998837828636, -0.04053836688399315, -0.051496729254722595, 0.012552878819406033, -0.004402289167046547, -0.022109203040599823, -0.008168351836502552, -0.03997466340661049, -0.029086561873555183, -0.009867653250694275, -0.022768760100007057, -0.032755181193351746, -0.030352123081684113, 0.07250016927719116, 0.04375636950135231, 0.008858577348291874, -0.005223040468990803, -0.0011140175629407167, -0.0021590122487396, -0.001248153392225504, 0.03430552780628204, 0.02794278785586357, 0.014195374213159084, 0.014056961983442307, 0.08771715313196182, 0.011624304577708244, -0.021274443715810776, 0.024124683812260628, 0.00850652251392603, -0.05387994647026062, 0.01713298074901104, 0.021640093997120857, -0.02316274866461754, -0.026408374309539795, 0.0007130056619644165, -0.006684180349111557, 0.005096923094242811, 0.05839826166629791, -0.043781932443380356, -0.0062570427544415, 0.04116250202059746, 0.04047318547964096, -0.04803020879626274, 0.013101227581501007, 0.006245290860533714, -0.043687861412763596, 0.019066547974944115, -0.004357081837952137, -0.034701522439718246, -0.017702361568808556, 0.006317651830613613, 0.00796380452811718, -0.003462620312348008, -0.023486798629164696, 0.03319653496146202, -0.016277916729450226, -0.02623862214386463, 0.0496906153857708, -0.009102562442421913, 0.034597065299749374, -0.08201121538877487, -0.0525781512260437, 0.007080456241965294, -0.02691486105322838, 0.018450208008289337, -0.06628968566656113, -0.04136916995048523, 0.021199990063905716, -0.06966423988342285, 0.007219555322080851, 0.027152640745043755, 0.004140677396208048, 0.041938476264476776, 0.022399602457880974, -0.030495870858430862, -0.04876371845602989, -0.07888124138116837, 0.023272961378097534, -0.05489649623632431, 0.01784615032374859, -0.020842276513576508, 0.004791951272636652, 0.004026714246720076, 0.05672973021864891, -0.028257079422473907, -0.05728986859321594, -0.007966587319970131, 0.053264230489730835, -0.018510479480028152, 0.01835007406771183, 0.025997266173362732, -0.03783337026834488, -0.048798512667417526, 0.028731627389788628, 0.006835192907601595, -0.021000448614358902, -0.01956305466592312, 0.00410482008010149, -0.003159628016874194, -0.017849862575531006, 0.0003287464496679604, -0.012983888387680054, 0.026116594672203064, 0.037274546921253204, -0.009758854284882545, 0.031562160700559616, 0.03912023827433586, -0.015130766667425632, -0.04341663047671318, -0.023717546835541725, 0.022925207391381264, -0.021404914557933807, -0.021177608519792557, 0.005934502463787794, -0.004354649689048529, 0.04455403983592987, -0.007983016781508923, -0.0003684923576656729, 0.0786072313785553, -0.03653840720653534, -0.042290810495615005, -0.03825969994068146, 0.01926533877849579, 0.016351649537682533, -0.051119063049554825, 0.03160546347498894, 0.02613224647939205, -0.034881945699453354, 0.07447489351034164, -0.018086165189743042, 0.029565561562776566, 0.011126792058348656, -0.0027258547488600016, -0.020709684118628502, 0.00561609398573637, 0.03208429738879204, -0.044751424342393875, 0.025781983509659767, -0.008581360802054405, -0.07357075065374374, 0.03979771211743355, 0.03906412422657013, 0.01595519669353962, 0.016579724848270416, 0.04205989092588425, 0.007218039594590664, -0.01797681674361229, -0.0633411705493927, 0.04984639957547188, -0.00739628029987216, -0.09066400676965714, 0.0428554005920887, -0.019741851836442947, -0.05803634971380234, 0.049855783581733704, 0.07638475298881531, -0.04254810884594917, 0.08217138051986694, 0.0185143630951643, 0.019023774191737175, -0.02060750499367714, -0.0019288923358544707, 0.0632358193397522, 0.013078727759420872, -0.000022815233023720793, 0.02843657322227955, -0.056053951382637024, 0.00882849283516407, -0.030147936195135117, 0.02173520065844059, -0.04894419386982918, -0.031346552073955536, 0.016461815685033798, 0.011325713247060776, 0.010423424653708935, -0.0405283123254776, -0.00445711612701416, 0.09435161203145981, 0.015167457051575184, -0.03644338995218277, -0.031583722680807114, -0.003989994525909424, -0.006068604998290539, -0.05677112564444542, 0.014697527512907982, -0.040693335235118866, 0.03713531792163849, -0.011738776229321957, -0.06583096086978912, 0.02446192316710949, -0.022574469447135925, -0.022417690604925156, 0.025604698807001114, 0.0024141035974025726, 0.06874141097068787, 0.023313447833061218, 0.02043609693646431, 0.01637425646185875, 0.03977473825216293, -0.013768956065177917, -0.07518230378627777, -0.033479779958724976, 0.03289078176021576, 0.02234315313398838, 0.020869748666882515, -0.006072318647056818, 0.008615509606897831, -0.010626745410263538, 0.0011925905710086226, 0.06999621540307999, -0.04294847697019577, -0.01716560125350952, -0.03923198580741882, 0.04196648672223091, -0.05265656113624573, 0.033968470990657806, -0.02296946384012699, 0.11302467435598373, 0.042827870696783066, -0.025579750537872314, -0.04413590580224991, 0.008177302777767181, -0.0014191531809046865, 0.012330944649875164, -0.05400058254599571, -0.022980039939284325, -0.030612662434577942, -0.01725410856306553, -0.024407722055912018, 0.0047336118295788765, 0.02230996824800968, -0.016643164679408073, 0.015904465690255165, -0.008833678439259529, 0.03366559371352196, 0.0028176219202578068, 0.04643775150179863, 0.013072286732494831, -0.001107557094655931, -0.005397174973040819, -0.01700657606124878, -0.011753851547837257, 0.01657039113342762, 0.029891354963183403, 0.0181737020611763, -0.014298176392912865, -0.05463531240820885, 0.01487561035901308, 0.01839721016585827, -0.007337698247283697, 0.01098380982875824, 0.011331595480442047, 0.028396006673574448, -0.02534620650112629, 0.052189555019140244, -0.0651293694972992, 0.028172653168439865, -0.05060450732707977, -0.022986767813563347, -0.052035823464393616, 0.0120259840041399, 0.04000704735517502, 0.013648426160216331, 0.000028830489100073464, 0.004421294201165438, 0.005563793703913689, 0.043136369436979294, 0.03155776113271713, 0.029092835262417793, 0.10567110776901245, -0.04746824502944946, -0.005650403443723917, -0.03372082859277725, 0.028535684570670128, 0.08717484027147293, 0.02143772691488266, -0.0024461932480335236, -0.019074643030762672, -0.019651373848319054, 0.053399547934532166, 0.010703071020543575, -0.03063126839697361, -0.06568652391433716, 0.031448476016521454, 0.0030040412675589323, -0.03908274322748184, -0.02565109357237816, 0.0014900063397362828, 0.022550586611032486, -0.035766176879405975, -0.023645780980587006, 0.031807348132133484, 0.03868897259235382, 0.004759301897138357, -0.0637579932808876, -0.014703541062772274, -0.01956585980951786, 0.015525920316576958, 0.005657552741467953, 0.026295382529497147, -0.00585519103333354, -0.0004370496317278594, 0.022380724549293518, 0.003650548169389367, -0.039135534316301346, 0.053098469972610474, -0.0017882848624140024, 0.062270939350128174, -0.012161708436906338, 0.06487368792295456, 0.0098586305975914, -0.045698605477809906, -0.023173613473773003, -0.02727344073355198, 0.04077095165848732, -0.012723465450108051, 0.055735234171152115, 0.010421630926430225, 0.009154615923762321, -0.0346711091697216, 0.007262449245899916, 0.07613210380077362, -0.024127358570694923, -0.03448318690061569, 0.011976394802331924, -0.08957084268331528, -0.012281159870326519, -0.03427892550826073, 0.018549922853708267, 0.012848791666328907, -0.028773806989192963, 0.04386308044195175, 0.015042899176478386, 0.002118231961503625, 0.04396041855216026, -0.004732083063572645, 0.03468858078122139, -0.061034440994262695, -0.042988818138837814, -0.01698916405439377, -0.005885927006602287, -0.05472605302929878, 0.05534214526414871, -0.0011044250568374991, 0.014759717509150505, 0.037213124334812164, 0.002330509712919593, 0.01893703080713749, 0.05372115597128868, -0.06985989958047867, 0.025698410347104073, 0.0013403129996731877, 0.05133003741502762, 0.020728157833218575, -0.05738331004977226, -0.08043712377548218, 0.0003163305518683046, 0.015364907681941986, -0.03413424640893936, -0.023389847949147224, 0.028771033510565758, -0.01909576542675495, 0.03902063146233559, 0.03890366479754448, -0.04050474613904953, -0.017316069453954697, 0.0014440541854128242, -0.02705727331340313, -0.013984893448650837, 0.031531620770692825, -0.014485093764960766, 0.04201468080282211, 0.04799409583210945, 0.050857409834861755, -0.04507400840520859, 0.07141740620136261, 0.03058655373752117, -0.010340478271245956, 0.02228398062288761, -0.03577178716659546, 0.07628374546766281, -0.08486130088567734, 0.08718707412481308, 0.07248731702566147, -0.06730332970619202, -0.0014663994079455733, -0.06129059940576553, 0.00995741318911314, 0.04057956114411354, 0.01205954235047102, 0.006758451461791992, -0.02865392155945301, 0.004908760078251362, -0.031156308948993683, -0.04434046149253845, 0.002272682962939143, 0.014796627685427666, 0.053987838327884674, -0.011127852834761143, -0.010878442786633968, 0.012115517631173134, -0.03260434418916702, 0.044410549104213715, 0.06359385699033737, 0.017307061702013016, -0.020009586587548256, 0.037279076874256134, 0.05498730391263962, -0.02520800195634365, 0.003629211336374283, -0.04731522873044014, -0.0036472161300480366, -0.005111199803650379, 0.002278759842738509, -0.0338960699737072, -0.005490320734679699, 0.04469273239374161, -0.01373667735606432, 0.01850162260234356, 0.009118354879319668, -0.009990646503865719, 0.05054103955626488, -0.007556648459285498, 0.0009658837225288153, 0.03998316451907158, 0.011182637885212898, 0.013316208496689796, -0.005321484990417957, -0.010661596432328224, 0.0199126023799181, -0.02223285846412182, 0.024491041898727417, -0.006266487296670675, 0.02470541186630726, -0.010491100139915943, -0.002964889630675316, -0.03138365224003792, 0.03292709216475487, -0.052791815251111984, -0.015789605677127838, -0.033940352499485016, 0.040109749883413315, 0.03847302868962288, -0.019010979682207108, 0.029613999649882317, -0.04082409292459488, 0.06638896465301514, -0.009774024598300457, -0.038172487169504166, -0.01930817775428295, -0.0014907188015058637, 0.033804167062044144, 0.010288743302226067, -0.003647928824648261, 0.013954256661236286, -0.014457253739237785, -0.06580185890197754, -0.058047208935022354, -0.04120993614196777, -0.06020357832312584, 0.01445087231695652, -0.08383961021900177, -0.05356008559465408, -0.00801845919340849, -0.05851208418607712, -0.028174949809908867, 0.0328688807785511, -0.011469067074358463, 0.0021519276779145002, 0.026661481708288193, 0.023186998441815376, 0.035991597920656204, -0.006631694734096527, 0.05997563526034355, 0.04173973947763443, -0.043638356029987335, 0.0668230876326561, 0.008620020933449268, 0.04925384745001793, -0.02260541543364525, 0.033015575259923935, -0.00558861531317234, -0.0014977935934439301, 0.044460710138082504, -0.026611769571900368, 0.048843950033187866, 0.035407405346632004, -0.009765983559191227, 0.015839511528611183, -0.026334965601563454, 0.003974404186010361, -0.019621826708316803, 0.006341827102005482, -0.027371596544981003, 0.019481439143419266, -0.005879562348127365, -0.004014723934233189, 0.004877126310020685, -0.019002005457878113, 0.05540383234620094, -0.01891181617975235, -0.005794741678982973, 0.0020828398410230875, 0.003067332785576582, 0.003596911672502756, 0.02262883633375168, -0.03248091787099838, 0.013839805498719215, 0.015169844031333923, -0.0477973073720932, 0.03497694432735443, 0.017381271347403526, 0.002359058242291212, 0.024299459531903267, 0.02115440182387829, -0.016754506155848503, -0.03510360047221184, 0.0038194714579731226, -0.02692459337413311, -0.054959073662757874, -0.0330183245241642, -0.03032800741493702, -0.044906456023454666, -0.0076921782456338406, -0.09836722165346146, -0.017265088856220245, 0.005849071778357029, 0.020004877820611, -0.029005391523241997, -0.0037812197115272284, -0.04064108431339264, -0.0036765357945114374, -0.010660450905561447, -0.012818817980587482, -0.0064279078505933285, 0.002608740935102105, 0.010151075199246407, 0.012108311988413334, -0.06333737820386887, -0.03743781894445419, -0.03464142605662346, -0.007787544280290604, 0.05266378074884415, 0.015292930416762829, -0.007651093415915966, 0.01662226766347885 ]
<p>The Poisson bracket is defined as:</p> <p>$$\{f,g\}_{PB} ~:=~ \sum_{i=1}^{N} \left[ \frac{\partial f}{\partial q_{i}} \frac{\partial g}{\partial p_{i}} - \frac{\partial f}{\partial p_{i}} \frac{\partial g}{\partial q_{i}} \right]. $$</p> <p>The anticommutator is defined as:</p> <p>$$ \{a,b\} ~:=~ ab + ba. $$</p> <p>The commutator is defined as:</p> <p>$$ [a,b] ~:=~ ab - ba. $$</p> <p>What are the connections between all of them?</p> <p>Edit: Does the Poisson bracket define some uncertainty principle as well?</p>
g5894
[ 0.029040517285466194, -0.0027771289460361004, -0.03239694610238075, -0.01025116816163063, 0.08130411803722382, -0.02878548949956894, 0.028881167992949486, 0.008801144547760487, -0.037493325769901276, 0.0103614442050457, -0.09927989542484283, 0.011348040774464607, -0.06456942111253738, -0.049358878284692764, -0.026125404983758926, 0.031027106568217278, 0.04443974420428276, 0.08636511862277985, 0.025740893557667732, -0.02980092726647854, -0.03041117824614048, 0.028226565569639206, -0.05207471549510956, 0.015921592712402344, 0.021073609590530396, 0.01600760407745838, 0.018249157816171646, -0.042858805507421494, -0.02893601544201374, -0.029603414237499237, -0.03585284575819969, -0.01970531977713108, 0.009016932919621468, -0.06992434710264206, -0.014344810508191586, -0.017281243577599525, 0.0356491319835186, 0.0037056433502584696, 0.006396133452653885, 0.027245620265603065, -0.03406008705496788, 0.03040424920618534, 0.029529143124818802, -0.001351547078229487, -0.03346889838576317, 0.035537008196115494, -0.06631626188755035, 0.04093843325972557, 0.02447476238012314, -0.04427076503634453, -0.005687061231583357, 0.05469357967376709, 0.047622766345739365, -0.0001812740374589339, 0.014519033022224903, 0.05226728320121765, 0.05552823841571808, -0.01769419200718403, 0.015541400760412216, -0.03005073592066765, -0.05057639628648758, -0.01897062174975872, -0.04987451061606407, 0.03655460104346275, 0.055689144879579544, -0.004994426388293505, -0.02443631924688816, 0.01196335256099701, 0.018506698310375214, 0.05670583248138428, 0.0662086233496666, 0.0019391265232115984, 0.02863175794482231, 0.0038582072593271732, 0.002788746729493141, -0.033252451568841934, -0.005867987871170044, -0.043481115251779556, 0.08367806673049927, -0.00756811210885644, 0.01093270257115364, -0.07800504565238953, 0.016713591292500496, 0.03491690382361412, 0.016564898192882538, -0.01764872297644615, 0.020084133371710777, -0.009752055630087852, -0.04838544875383377, 0.017764046788215637, -0.02316909469664097, -0.016676882281899452, -0.011534088291227818, 0.0017230827361345291, -0.0014754325384274125, 0.031002894043922424, -0.06900043040513992, 0.014344017952680588, -0.0381162166595459, 0.005782731343060732, -0.00763864116743207, 0.07147926837205887, 0.019130226224660873, 0.016850564628839493, -0.021501971408724785, -0.004238500725477934, 0.022586639970541, -0.04612252861261368, 0.008463247679173946, 0.0245718602091074, -0.04729355499148369, 0.024936970323324203, -0.05300653725862503, -0.06414978951215744, -0.016812533140182495, 0.006840559653937817, 0.039676349610090256, -0.008304805494844913, -0.0018110784003511071, 0.033563561737537384, -0.03189561516046524, 0.00014977561659179628, 0.028057321906089783, 0.06277129799127579, -0.014623011462390423, -0.006025264505296946, 0.016576185822486877, 0.038761213421821594, 0.04199652001261711, -0.01886754296720028, 0.06841542571783066, -0.04624864459037781, -0.02894185110926628, 0.04582138732075691, 0.03140711784362793, 0.01871834509074688, 0.022883448749780655, 0.014127914793789387, 0.00649621756747365, -0.0020147233735769987, -0.05075417086482048, 0.006103124003857374, -0.029713056981563568, -0.0691840648651123, 0.005957537330687046, -0.019308624789118767, 0.025239132344722748, -0.05330372601747513, -0.039820265024900436, -0.01570761948823929, 0.005297725088894367, 0.06659270823001862, -0.07283631712198257, -0.011914432980120182, 0.030113570392131805, 0.004908018279820681, 0.04883928969502449, -0.05869048088788986, -0.008963060565292835, -0.014295240864157677, -0.008858909830451012, -0.02650745026767254, 0.05767583101987839, 0.02986263856291771, -0.03427630290389061, -0.028945647180080414, 0.00015754919149912894, -0.005450647324323654, -0.015127112157642841, -0.02074817568063736, -0.0010577862849459052, -0.0677768811583519, -0.03245360776782036, -0.005063915625214577, 0.09284082055091858, -0.004904026165604591, -0.029041510075330734, 0.0008321956265717745, 0.03574296832084656, 0.02601541019976139, -0.02868081070482731, 0.05849175527691841, 0.04222864285111427, -0.05775778368115425, -0.05309489741921425, 0.011283963918685913, -0.0008223130716942251, 0.02015104331076145, -0.04452186077833176, 0.01636608876287937, -0.010000214911997318, -0.015131316147744656, -0.09079663455486298, 0.021818991750478745, -0.04546790197491646, -0.019479738548398018, -0.012344163842499256, -0.004997498821467161, 0.038078054785728455, -0.03834639862179756, 0.04222259297966957, 0.011472285725176334, 0.034173671156167984, -0.017108280211687088, 0.0806821808218956, 0.014364339411258698, -0.01050611026585102, 0.008270897902548313, -0.07819204777479172, 0.014478125609457493, -0.02020859904587269, -0.07751721143722534, 0.03244438394904137, 0.0005555330426432192, -0.03864319622516632, -0.011855831369757652, 0.05220862105488777, 0.001356940483674407, 0.07622191309928894, 0.008237497881054878, 0.008290504105389118, 0.015501366928219795, 0.005065349396318197, -0.026602262631058693, -0.0341339111328125, 0.048602260649204254, 0.008423366583883762, 0.008287257514894009, -0.028162537142634392, 0.0569169856607914, -0.05886282026767731, -0.01035618782043457, 0.008951006457209587, -0.014662737026810646, 0.01732766255736351, 0.03280799835920334, 0.03467278182506561, 0.01795315183699131, 0.008075532503426075, 0.07223697751760483, 0.010045577771961689, 0.00005748329931520857, -0.007224939297884703, 0.07038217037916183, -0.004951678216457367, 0.005998929962515831, 0.0827643871307373, -0.007987646386027336, -0.008718072436749935, 0.03937012329697609, -0.03016030602157116, 0.012421208433806896, 0.01781824789941311, -0.012884405441582203, 0.002422679215669632, -0.013212720863521099, 0.014966367743909359, -0.028446752578020096, 0.024709122255444527, 0.015036710537970066, 0.026322733610868454, -0.04567257687449455, -0.015837160870432854, 0.07072118669748306, -0.041132114827632904, -0.01979178749024868, -0.01259396132081747, 0.04908643662929535, -0.02910585328936577, 0.010949961841106415, 0.0022109888959676027, 0.04967523366212845, 0.030270643532276154, 0.010092309676110744, -0.020850127562880516, -0.0658181831240654, -0.04506253823637962, -0.05745105817914009, 0.010815953835844994, 0.02508419379591942, -0.0059888665564358234, 0.10082913190126419, -0.028265181928873062, -0.0054841660894453526, 0.032794687896966934, -0.017187025398015976, 0.09163213521242142, 0.044376716017723083, 0.03425810486078262, 0.04714551940560341, -0.009401414543390274, 0.004692510701715946, 0.018437223508954048, -0.01912388578057289, 0.03913971409201622, 0.030555905774235725, 0.029759153723716736, -0.04827158898115158, -0.034220222383737564, 0.01066344790160656, -0.03654983639717102, 0.04924101009964943, -0.030069824308156967, 0.040394753217697144, 0.04024139419198036, 0.07235556095838547, -0.029289867728948593, 0.011703298427164555, -0.05135718360543251, 0.05306301265954971, -0.06492231786251068, -0.008873440325260162, 0.06767192482948303, -0.027795545756816864, 0.03739167004823685, 0.014851188287138939, 0.016280556097626686, 0.004494402091950178, -0.042778052389621735, -0.07632148265838623, -0.002415967406705022, -0.051383331418037415, -0.032412346452474594, -0.0618138462305069, 0.002275932813063264, 0.0018345215357840061, -0.10309242457151413, 0.02296742983162403, -0.07152999937534332, -0.06960734724998474, 0.0056723300367593765, -0.02780882827937603, 0.05465852469205856, 0.029393231496214867, -0.03720401972532272, -0.06982896476984024, 0.05296076089143753, -0.005719650071114302, 0.01986710913479328, -0.0009161871275864542, 0.03032958135008812, 0.005308910738676786, 0.04346202313899994, 0.0036727043334394693, -0.06532131135463715, 0.02207235060632229, 0.044012345373630524, -0.00845886766910553, 0.03926166892051697, -0.015381284058094025, -0.042416051030159, 0.007496860809624195, 0.011232289485633373, -0.0018847802421078086, -0.0010735125979408622, 0.0480131059885025, -0.03008965402841568, 0.01836211234331131, 0.0140125947073102, -0.013494097627699375, 0.02168871834874153, -0.025410344824194908, 0.052535202354192734, 0.07609149068593979, -0.02883528359234333, -0.013894052244722843, -0.018976911902427673, 0.050027746707201004, 0.036148399114608765, -0.03521982580423355, 0.003944328986108303, -0.027362201362848282, 0.02035306952893734, -0.03594592213630676, 0.051224108785390854, 0.017409995198249817, 0.057973090559244156, 0.010745363309979439, -0.008312689140439034, 0.005520735867321491, 0.011406410485506058, 0.030273398384451866, 0.06824036687612534, 0.004055724013596773, 0.018211593851447105, -0.011340796947479248, 0.018650295212864876, 0.0017616983968764544, -0.05786848068237305, -0.04216887056827545, 0.02735091745853424, 0.0049833389930427074, 0.0009698077337816358, 0.0028462663758546114, 0.02924072928726673, -0.017142876982688904, -0.02375849150121212, -0.0013285719323903322, 0.039422545582056046, 0.0011221347376704216, -0.029591932892799377, 0.01307250652462244, 0.008139689452946186, -0.018488503992557526, 0.011339617893099785, -0.009229819290339947, -0.0014497932279482484, -0.020135650411248207, -0.017098380252718925, -0.03357226029038429, -0.03618228808045387, -0.03574695065617561, 0.0061206091195344925, -0.04823512211441994, -0.008120188489556313, 0.00030425487784668803, -0.017628369852900505, -0.005224200431257486, 0.03944701328873634, -0.0025496159214526415, 0.01946510374546051, -0.0015835541998967528, 0.005391316022723913, -0.009973928332328796, 0.023592935875058174, 0.06490996479988098, 0.02356262318789959, -0.046623848378658295, 0.00003172728611389175, -0.02889816276729107, -0.031180091202259064, 0.08745431154966354, 0.018216673284769058, -0.006980485282838345, -0.0396895557641983, -0.007236078847199678, -0.03169601783156395, 0.019701721146702766, -0.021279359236359596, -0.01887889951467514, 0.05319416522979736, 0.024413347244262695, -0.0379258431494236, -0.07104210555553436, 0.06113620847463608, 0.01734255626797676, -0.017318276688456535, 0.00015483048628084362, 0.022323543205857277, 0.013797416351735592, 0.034339796751737595, 0.03434167802333832, 0.01025416236370802, -0.07869850844144821, 0.00047924634418450296, -0.02835865505039692, -0.015321806073188782, -0.016455085948109627, -0.024136807769536972, -0.010371929965913296, -0.024736499413847923, -0.05321785807609558, 0.027013864368200302, -0.00938674621284008, 0.010110391303896904, -0.025114206597208977, -0.07673009485006332, -0.04445517435669899, -0.029087072238326073, -0.003289869287982583, -0.004563453141599894, 0.0212135910987854, -0.0182765182107687, 0.02540070191025734, 0.007594139780849218, -0.010210590437054634, 0.021476954221725464, -0.008395854383707047, 0.02578611485660076, -0.03730599954724312, -0.008350220508873463, 0.02236580289900303, -0.04539109393954277, -0.01945590414106846, -0.028636019676923752, -0.02212570421397686, 0.0014672642573714256, -0.04061458632349968, -0.049637652933597565, -0.007870077155530453, 0.013798420317471027, -0.019362080842256546, 0.10251462459564209, 0.032330431044101715, -0.015226287767291069, -0.032484520226716995, -0.015010900795459747, 0.00260718772187829, 0.06429104506969452, 0.02085200324654579, -0.061807770282030106, -0.019429011270403862, 0.016836125403642654, -0.00872995238751173, -0.014817937277257442, 0.06068720668554306, 0.076351098716259, 0.006999625824391842, 0.0004050693823955953, 0.019750604405999184, -0.011748043820261955, -0.0027752183377742767, -0.009046570397913456, 0.03656711056828499, 0.02766215056180954, 0.039500728249549866, -0.08985913544893265, -0.04968041926622391, -0.05032753199338913, -0.06963688880205154, 0.029739629477262497, -0.012741899117827415, 0.015820961445569992, -0.0226143728941679, 0.006215210538357496, -0.0262971930205822, 0.0031562435906380415, -0.04689702391624451, -0.0005086101591587067, 0.02689344435930252, -0.02903149463236332, -0.004133003763854504, -0.014824147336184978, 0.01766192726790905, -0.008326740935444832, -0.01121186837553978, -0.0627622976899147, -0.005099061410874128, 0.03906027227640152, 0.0184972882270813, -0.01019946951419115, 0.025630973279476166, 0.03409819304943085, 0.04016691818833351, -0.019761914387345314, 0.006073611788451672, -0.028345581144094467, 0.0009864509338513017, -0.008865158073604107, -0.0018545645289123058, 0.017502956092357635, 0.016479315236210823, -0.010627096518874168, -0.04160889983177185, 0.00033933244412764907, 0.040173377841711044, 0.024649033322930336, 0.036834001541137695, -0.006307339761406183, 0.0391840897500515, 0.015531452372670174, -0.010843507945537567, -0.01577829197049141, 0.03257230669260025, 0.025271831080317497, -0.0130162313580513, 0.006673271767795086, 0.04468630999326706, 0.0007384006748907268, 0.05964026227593422, 0.0069983904249966145, -0.021990898996591568, 0.001891914987936616, -0.008697053417563438, -0.0084944237023592, 0.03346608206629753, -0.026588432490825653, -0.08365543931722641, -0.006992860231548548, -0.05632089078426361, -0.002557959873229265, 0.009792684577405453, 0.018283674493432045, 0.0199368204921484, -0.04716414585709572, 0.06640112400054932, 0.005443384405225515, 0.006611451972275972, 0.030076371505856514, 0.03134115785360336, -0.03365468233823776, 0.017656220123171806, -0.013622909784317017, 0.041346821933984756, -0.011849047616124153, 0.021444452926516533, 0.05118158087134361, 0.026908595114946365, -0.060613952577114105, -0.05863069370388985, 0.032828737050294876, 0.004295512102544308, 0.02806447073817253, -0.030378352850675583, 0.024385245516896248, 0.022092755883932114, -0.01199637446552515, 0.003211784642189741, -0.024515118449926376, 0.03755267336964607, 0.06513531506061554, -0.018001098185777664, 0.05647970363497734, 0.03193105757236481, 0.008628441020846367, 0.04367572069168091, -0.09436582773923874, 0.048224952071905136, -0.0841086208820343, 0.016518330201506615, 0.07224418222904205, 0.04444987326860428, -0.09881964325904846, -0.007105539552867413, 0.04538792371749878, 0.07572297006845474, 0.015480388887226582, 0.015334699302911758, 0.005372811574488878, -0.02965976856648922, -0.040850523859262466, -0.01348145492374897, 0.005195988807827234, 0.03778835013508797, -0.04592546448111534, 0.01236664317548275, -0.0938388854265213, 0.05714976042509079, 0.02770768478512764, 0.0442349873483181, -0.00017705005302559584, 0.05311747267842293, 0.008377541787922382, 0.01684233732521534, -0.019551945850253105, -0.003427613992244005, 0.01546874362975359, -0.06862932443618774, -0.03613339364528656, 0.009757166728377342, 0.014281943440437317, 0.030505437403917313, -0.026657285168766975, 0.035387974232435226, -0.04707617312669754, 0.03581281378865242, 0.04110301658511162, 0.0332990363240242, 0.05560644343495369, -0.03248370811343193, -0.001813799375668168, 0.017898177728056908, -0.028304919600486755, -0.035282112658023834, 0.0168253555893898, -0.017648855224251747, 0.04893741011619568, -0.04758748412132263, -0.013057195581495762, 0.010534028522670269, -0.06574541330337524, -0.03368840366601944, -0.010617184452712536, 0.03214855119585991, 0.007898110896348953, -0.011253398843109608, 0.027838148176670074, 0.01050823274999857, -0.002589804120361805, -0.025389468297362328, 0.00950971245765686, 0.012037128210067749, -0.023014774546027184, -0.04990028217434883, 0.008183582685887814, 0.09662191569805145, 0.012278279289603233, 0.02302558161318302, -0.012264840304851532, -0.023282600566744804, -0.01686869189143181, -0.08861150592565536, -0.008465731516480446, -0.019718468189239502, -0.048016007989645004, 0.04473785310983658, -0.020282378420233727, -0.011956502683460712, 0.00941364374011755, -0.03883777931332588, 0.032203175127506256, 0.0016459820326417685, -0.08505964279174805, -0.03877484053373337, -0.018680822104215622, -0.02898394875228405, 0.042980801314115524, 0.021592773497104645, -0.05809417739510536, 0.018434299156069756, 0.07790976017713547, 0.028574714437127113, -0.04756952449679375, -0.03763185068964958, -0.005805235356092453, 0.0003670431615319103, -0.031649958342313766, 0.012495729140937328, -0.044317733496427536, 0.0018203872023150325, 0.03178809955716133, -0.024556245654821396, -0.08481844514608383, -0.04331641644239426, 0.021068256348371506, -0.041118323802948, -0.004918243736028671, 0.0184449702501297, -0.011920355260372162, 0.025164766237139702, -0.08927029371261597, -0.03348899260163307, -0.07644303143024445, -0.006556187756359577, -0.014800183475017548, 0.015553846955299377, 0.05860564112663269, -0.06161649897694588, 0.0046311598271131516, 0.036719247698783875, 0.02553434856235981, -0.025050446391105652, 0.0030998520087450743, -0.039853159338235855, 0.0006045997724868357, -0.06016639247536659, -0.04790413752198219, -0.004952187184244394, -0.010341146029531956, -0.017729349434375763, 0.0049985479563474655, 0.04516452178359032, 0.034588027745485306, 0.04661788418889046, 0.03312332183122635, -0.017993612214922905, 0.023946627974510193, 0.0009028476197272539, 0.07759588956832886, 0.0406307615339756, 0.044764742255210876, -0.050290755927562714, -0.006183437071740627, -0.00006775915971957147, 0.0006733940099366009, 0.011244653724133968, 0.025335734710097313, 0.05345790088176727 ]
<p>I'm working through a problem involving energy conservation. Unfortunately, I cannot calculate the work done by a spring.</p> <pre><code>Before: +------------+ | | | spring | d1 | | +------------+ After: +------------+ | | | spring | | | d2 | | | | +------------+ </code></pre> <p>Given the spring constant, d1, and d2, how can I determine the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Work_%28physics%29" rel="nofollow">work</a> done? Also, please explain how the formula was calculated instead of just posting an answer.</p>
g5895
[ 0.028344089165329933, -0.021272331476211548, -0.013407719321548939, -0.01372415479272604, 0.009361050091683865, -0.0681145116686821, 0.09466754645109177, 0.03931451961398125, -0.0784890428185463, -0.03563009575009346, -0.10576137900352478, 0.022233817726373672, 0.034558337181806564, 0.027176693081855774, -0.016622722148895264, 0.01663537509739399, 0.05760864540934563, -0.0023821156937628984, 0.039906442165374756, -0.0007876757881604135, -0.013817975297570229, 0.0014355048770084977, -0.0022006933577358723, -0.06485766917467117, 0.033656880259513855, 0.017136678099632263, -0.023125745356082916, 0.037226129323244095, -0.09903638064861298, -0.02001231350004673, 0.017468849197030067, 0.006514603737741709, 0.022272855043411255, -0.043274447321891785, -0.041045594960451126, 0.026999985799193382, 0.05441352352499962, 0.04202958941459656, 0.018337294459342957, 0.024578744545578957, -0.02719748765230179, 0.01760822907090187, 0.01504160463809967, 0.0352114737033844, -0.00895461905747652, -0.044158268719911575, 0.0017227771459147334, -0.01783802919089794, -0.02996300533413887, 0.003950027748942375, 0.04582926258444786, 0.07749956101179123, 0.0032043822575360537, 0.009283642284572124, -0.01936332881450653, -0.0037453770637512207, 0.013309190981090069, -0.043470609933137894, 0.07408319413661957, 0.0029966526199132204, -0.0011548560578376055, -0.013763489201664925, -0.0027084355242550373, 0.03173552826046944, 0.03481336683034897, -0.005406892392784357, 0.03744281455874443, -0.06477630138397217, -0.03108314238488674, -0.03883899748325348, -0.019232189282774925, 0.014329461380839348, -0.0010253764921799302, -0.013735254295170307, -0.03523268550634384, 0.02193988487124443, 0.038026656955480576, 0.0522863045334816, 0.02658492885529995, -0.013851952739059925, 0.016238322481513023, 0.006353970617055893, -0.006082931533455849, 0.004436857998371124, 0.04574275389313698, 0.03073805198073387, 0.0022223214618861675, 0.02106345258653164, 0.0011979815317317843, 0.010691503994166851, -0.02683592587709427, -0.016175735741853714, 0.05972680822014809, -0.035664889961481094, -0.007633470930159092, -0.030535738915205002, -0.011468075215816498, 0.08316567540168762, -0.0011951853521168232, -0.02261931262910366, 0.017419343814253807, -0.05949866399168968, 0.0012066622730344534, -0.004973600618541241, 0.022338302806019783, 0.010407563298940659, 0.025592677295207977, -0.01832328550517559, -0.02556893788278103, -0.0015541177708655596, -0.03229515254497528, 0.005196478217840195, -0.023730427026748657, -0.009633414447307587, -0.021376948803663254, -0.09411516040563583, 0.026961710304021835, -0.024827133864164352, -0.0005437281797640026, 0.0196088720113039, -0.02010798268020153, 0.004060139413923025, 0.05170561745762825, 0.038103073835372925, -0.03715505823493004, -0.0001035492168739438, -0.01884778030216694, 0.028655409812927246, 0.034448303282260895, 0.014368590898811817, -0.008652505464851856, -0.04040680080652237, 0.040829624980688095, 0.07522247731685638, -0.03952166065573692, 0.0806010365486145, -0.02319292537868023, 0.049887411296367645, -0.029688112437725067, 0.055865127593278885, -0.005198246333748102, -0.03864795342087746, -0.03725782781839371, -0.024033119902014732, -0.010549754835665226, 0.0643787533044815, -0.05686783418059349, -0.04161684587597847, 0.05002082139253616, -0.0038368392270058393, 0.045064304023981094, 0.07437136024236679, 0.009931395761668682, -0.013335944153368473, 0.04599185660481453, -0.0369352251291275, -0.03299065679311752, -0.0357443131506443, -0.03499745950102806, 0.04174080118536949, 0.03104892559349537, -0.03267938271164894, 0.013898571021854877, -0.03418715298175812, -0.056893929839134216, 0.03234236687421799, -0.03266715630888939, -0.023506106808781624, -0.002536644460633397, -0.07537274807691574, -0.04973113164305687, -0.009793877601623535, 0.02916683629155159, -0.005947480909526348, 0.032713159918785095, 0.047043025493621826, 0.033932432532310486, -0.006599892862141132, 0.004058975260704756, 0.03785892575979233, 0.0017370737623423338, 0.012655493803322315, 0.05789744108915329, 0.011420037597417831, -0.028531163930892944, 0.026269758120179176, 0.019142724573612213, 0.003108094446361065, -0.07714231312274933, -0.07838517427444458, -0.03931049257516861, 0.0005798376514576375, 0.07921929657459259, 0.01687389612197876, -0.018459942191839218, 0.03619425743818283, -0.0006767967133782804, -0.004857854917645454, -0.043138667941093445, 0.029224587604403496, -0.006710351910442114, 0.06304842978715897, 0.03159892186522484, 0.010747254826128483, 0.013873875141143799, -0.0002116177201969549, 0.0136176235973835, -0.023632248863577843, -0.0026749211829155684, -0.02400592528283596, -0.027844907715916634, 0.008197637274861336, -0.005561009049415588, 0.015469418838620186, -0.0005107584875077009, -0.016909565776586533, -0.02908393368124962, -0.02154821716248989, -0.050415992736816406, 0.03438101336359978, -0.07272376120090485, 0.018136024475097656, 0.060343123972415924, 0.013142162933945656, -0.06871018558740616, 0.028195615857839584, 0.02517707273364067, 0.0017212200909852982, -0.033055804669857025, 0.01160107646137476, 0.01903071068227291, 0.016076872125267982, -0.04401702806353569, 0.018954236060380936, 0.011565899476408958, 0.03581606224179268, -0.025500524789094925, 0.026522964239120483, -0.01812749356031418, 0.06629905849695206, 0.014192653819918633, 0.005284919403493404, 0.001304338569752872, -0.0027091950178146362, 0.036792878061532974, -0.0006731389439664781, 0.05290503799915314, 0.027937471866607666, -0.017459535971283913, 0.02716839499771595, 0.034555744379758835, -0.007687333505600691, -0.003404138842597604, 0.008015268482267857, 0.012367511168122292, 0.019720064476132393, -0.03928303346037865, -0.0009754255879670382, -0.04708850011229515, -0.07237369567155838, -0.01407211646437645, -0.009841809049248695, 0.003711974946781993, -0.005484169349074364, -0.03731871023774147, -0.05536826327443123, -0.059813763946294785, -0.020850328728556633, 0.013884540647268295, -0.018354006111621857, 0.014594897627830505, 0.023524880409240723, -0.00804402306675911, 0.0042315139435231686, -0.011805943213403225, -0.03924058377742767, 0.04981159046292305, -0.028494633734226227, 0.022446095943450928, -0.00349982432089746, 0.01872185431420803, -0.008474089205265045, -0.026850508525967598, 0.062195152044296265, 0.0048144212923944, -0.013265653513371944, -0.023636722937226295, 0.014000006951391697, -0.04014839977025986, -0.046058639883995056, 0.029065296053886414, 0.027575694024562836, -0.008556217886507511, 0.013062954880297184, -0.015086800791323185, 0.03941994905471802, 0.04521926864981651, -0.05026880279183388, 0.0038867031689733267, 0.0643894225358963, -0.04223542660474777, -0.05448662489652634, 0.013220851309597492, -0.05989827588200569, 0.002796552376821637, 0.027844125404953957, -0.010368859395384789, -0.023952802643179893, 0.04690541326999664, 0.013509615324437618, -0.04188556224107742, -0.026918187737464905, 0.03124174475669861, -0.035393230617046356, -0.08440397679805756, 0.01609203964471817, -0.005025735590606928, -0.06382878124713898, 0.06603318452835083, -0.019195005297660828, 0.012328623794019222, 0.0044640772975981236, 0.0385155975818634, -0.03666361793875694, -0.03988778591156006, 0.07398766279220581, -0.02561686374247074, 0.03511961176991463, -0.028915060684084892, -0.027377193793654442, 0.009809350594878197, 0.011906899511814117, -0.029805079102516174, -0.06376855820417404, 0.0017708304803818464, -0.06984814256429672, -0.032847631722688675, 0.01394752785563469, 0.018513638526201248, 0.06883376836776733, -0.08592990785837173, -0.009809446521103382, -0.02692360058426857, 0.006146359257400036, -0.0028413350228220224, 0.03299000486731529, -0.011973410844802856, 0.01229866873472929, -0.029112573713064194, 0.006691362243145704, 0.05832330510020256, 0.0028469085227698088, -0.06940462440252304, -0.0006556045264005661, 0.03627203777432442, 0.05660594254732132, -0.043861422687768936, 0.06408721953630447, -0.08554760366678238, 0.009359080344438553, 0.013159886002540588, -0.07539495825767517, -0.024970371276140213, 0.031859543174505234, 0.04197065904736519, -0.02560279332101345, -0.012521693482995033, 0.03487762436270714, -0.017062243074178696, -0.010306078009307384, 0.03250438719987869, -0.022639235481619835, 0.037520136684179306, 0.04662527143955231, -0.013967837207019329, 0.0028460558969527483, 0.049552105367183685, 0.035999856889247894, -0.08236761391162872, 0.01748439483344555, 0.0410352423787117, 0.049684278666973114, -0.042391180992126465, -0.021453602239489555, -0.017342673614621162, 0.02109302021563053, 0.009890323504805565, -0.008317242376506329, 0.03114202246069908, -0.03207530826330185, -0.054382383823394775, -0.014165486209094524, -0.028405357152223587, 0.061486996710300446, 0.015829339623451233, 0.029097167775034904, 0.05537058785557747, -0.02354159951210022, -0.05370192602276802, -0.0046953968703746796, -0.026220116764307022, 0.05233345553278923, 0.01857883669435978, 0.014142261818051338, -0.03171777352690697, 0.0030015395022928715, 0.031989943236112595, 0.0016826038481667638, 0.028563428670167923, 0.01454841811209917, -0.01472274400293827, -0.04045860096812248, 0.01920432597398758, -0.017587624490261078, 0.042171791195869446, -0.0501326248049736, 0.04549606889486313, -0.03403737396001816, 0.013839016668498516, -0.0063231028616428375, 0.04237932711839676, 0.024078020825982094, 0.011893777176737785, -0.041647303849458694, 0.00022016954608261585, 0.09388938546180725, -0.002109678229317069, -0.05744188651442528, 0.01830848678946495, -0.056837599724531174, 0.04557614028453827, -0.0020252771209925413, -0.041704561561346054, -0.00513047631829977, -0.1064520850777626, 0.05210337042808533, -0.053599756211042404, 0.04911758378148079, -0.03405235335230827, 0.005396425724029541, -0.0045592160895466805, 0.0006524103228002787, 0.010993949137628078, 0.02710363082587719, 0.014238838106393814, 0.04120171442627907, -0.05426252633333206, -0.04354921355843544, -0.016171695664525032, 0.007030326873064041, -0.030557896941900253, -0.0019398678559809923, 0.002466092351824045, 0.009825666435062885, -0.009039395488798618, 0.05740733817219734, -0.009427167475223541, -0.049358464777469635, 0.018862882629036903, 0.05543040484189987, -0.058563005179166794, -0.0780930295586586, 0.02597087435424328, 0.04348951578140259, -0.01936078630387783, -0.05145671218633652, -0.002699880627915263, -0.018022211268544197, -0.012276609428226948, 0.02321573719382286, 0.025794869288802147, -0.007467338815331459, 0.0008745731320232153, 0.011015169322490692, 0.0111164515838027, -0.002853862475603819, 0.0296701081097126, 0.00798061303794384, 0.039443228393793106, 0.0451512448489666, 0.0008520425762981176, 0.03059377521276474, -0.033369507640600204, -0.011801734566688538, 0.00213531032204628, 0.024314841255545616, -0.0767102912068367, -0.002183646894991398, 0.01605420745909214, 0.02548433654010296, -0.0009512850665487349, 0.0957455039024353, 0.06663097441196442, -0.03749233856797218, 0.012346229515969753, 0.02400217577815056, 0.035164427012205124, 0.009364322759211063, -0.014365158043801785, -0.014769304543733597, -0.06313487887382507, 0.009538977406919003, -0.03541390970349312, 0.018911592662334442, -0.0008393825846724212, 0.03301827609539032, 0.023766059428453445, 0.01415584422647953, 0.042814914137125015, -0.029740380123257637, -0.024413729086518288, -0.02605118416249752, 0.016061976552009583, 0.013600962236523628, 0.025469955056905746, 0.02774958871304989, 0.019434668123722076, -0.020212626084685326, -0.07479675859212875, -0.01558914128690958, 0.0557488314807415, 0.033901918679475784, 0.05131435766816139, 0.01632794551551342, 0.019819289445877075, -0.06141922250390053, -0.04692532494664192, -0.036677367985248566, 0.0010380108142271638, 0.036718614399433136, 0.007577469106763601, -0.010190366767346859, -0.0685114786028862, 0.019114021211862564, 0.043408699333667755, -0.008283629082143307, -0.028554515913128853, -0.027005014941096306, -0.01944485493004322, -0.02695499360561371, -0.035175785422325134, 0.042327310889959335, 0.062065016478300095, 0.05001562833786011, -0.052675046026706696, -0.06548142433166504, -0.015857448801398277, -0.005169339012354612, 0.011826985515654087, -0.04457572475075722, -0.005055469926446676, 0.056676510721445084, 0.03741923347115517, 0.01763157546520233, -0.003461122512817383, 0.06919057667255402, 0.02780155837535858, -0.06366666406393051, -0.003225896041840315, -0.018078573048114777, 0.00788524653762579, 0.014774434268474579, 0.03182977810502052, 0.03971239924430847, 0.056111890822649, -0.03897979483008385, -0.03186478465795517, -0.015034365467727184, 0.07611961662769318, 0.02496073581278324, -0.020597917959094048, -0.019293643534183502, -0.015491795726120472, -0.00013340340228751302, -0.013754546642303467, 0.039758216589689255, -0.04919402673840523, -0.01401587761938572, -0.024964384734630585, -0.0013095722533762455, -0.030434273183345795, 0.011476321145892143, 0.05353716015815735, -0.01988295651972294, -0.032065942883491516, 0.0161142498254776, 0.014678881503641605, -0.003163181012496352, 0.03187412768602371, 0.03512158617377281, -0.0147654814645648, -0.011113663204014301, -0.022174764424562454, 0.005591397173702717, 0.023710176348686218, 0.005195748060941696, 0.007648388855159283, 0.013160554692149162, -0.018486665561795235, 0.04889586567878723, 0.023889418691396713, 0.018807893618941307, 0.06336068361997604, -0.007335796486586332, 0.05729704722762108, 0.011880181729793549, -0.033550333231687546, 0.025966458022594452, -0.04859723895788193, -0.039191026240587234, -0.0364084355533123, 0.08434570580720901, -0.010312298312783241, -0.00005993630475131795, -0.03226286172866821, -0.016086667776107788, 0.005617791786789894, 0.06065831333398819, 0.027001067996025085, -0.03546687960624695, 0.04336775839328766, -0.02262921817600727, 0.008870886638760567, -0.029065614566206932, 0.022141510620713234, 0.028742685914039612, -0.052653320133686066, 0.015478979796171188, 0.05864683911204338, 0.0049997735768556595, -0.018333101645112038, 0.06668536365032196, -0.035089243203401566, 0.03467996045947075, -0.03490450605750084, 0.03753051161766052, 0.0029210662469267845, 0.04669204354286194, 0.02751857601106167, 0.1019296795129776, -0.01036991085857153, 0.034689415246248245, 0.04653923586010933, 0.024478700011968613, -0.10540855675935745, -0.01165913138538599, 0.029009513556957245, -0.02027015946805477, -0.08012120425701141, 0.03416300565004349, 0.031360361725091934, 0.016278639435768127, 0.008886192925274372, -0.014555145986378193, -0.0022887324448674917, 0.007778466679155827, -0.028128933161497116, -0.00013778558059129864, -0.04435883089900017, -0.055984605103731155, -0.021047262474894524, -0.0710725486278534, 0.055751532316207886, 0.035050101578235626, 0.029119204729795456, 0.0656040757894516, 0.017001604661345482, 0.02423405461013317, 0.017051925882697105, -0.0397803895175457, -0.04120270162820816, -0.0094678346067667, -0.023671863600611687, 0.012677142396569252, -0.016753479838371277, 0.03784133866429329, 0.046986598521471024, 0.012987110763788223, -0.024587245658040047, -0.023983268067240715, -0.04479723423719406, -0.053244102746248245, -0.0806211531162262, -0.060226913541555405, -0.046316321939229965, 0.06432292610406876, -0.06885835528373718, -0.013416859321296215, 0.06025872379541397, 0.07368577271699905, -0.02610214613378048, 0.03916750103235245, 0.027612054720520973, -0.045534390956163406, 0.009086575359106064, -0.009342016652226448, -0.020260656252503395, -0.023643719032406807, 0.014050262980163097, -0.03513967990875244, 0.06614162772893906, -0.023380497470498085, 0.012901724316179752, 0.020530186593532562, -0.06298741698265076, -0.005897435359656811, -0.06534130871295929, -0.01840960420668125, 0.009211644530296326, 0.03128606826066971, -0.03647683560848236, -0.005694592837244272, -0.01663057692348957, -0.008881625719368458, -0.004961910657584667, -0.0004577999352477491, -0.02385416440665722, 0.009368990547955036, 0.0028570257127285004, 0.009278735145926476, -0.035610850900411606, -0.006136851850897074, -0.04522213712334633, -0.01739852875471115, -0.01322378683835268, 0.00570273632183671, -0.06132657453417778, 0.027402572333812714, -0.006188923958688974, -0.0026874328032135963, -0.024435175582766533, -0.055496394634246826, 0.0002469140163157135, 0.04579056799411774, 0.007942001335322857, -0.025369852781295776, 0.008948247879743576, -0.028446758165955544, -0.02784753032028675, 0.045633263885974884, -0.018817473202943802, -0.048255883157253265, 0.004247067030519247, -0.037083398550748825, 0.028750954195857048, -0.055250220000743866, 0.007770041935145855, 0.1241752877831459, 0.03705757111310959, -0.058971237391233444, 0.006598050706088543, 0.0023443540558218956, 0.02352233976125717, -0.012862050905823708, 0.01857486180961132, -0.07121486961841583, -0.019374554976820946, 0.0010660836705937982, 0.02390771545469761, 0.011791580356657505, -0.033812422305345535, 0.03326026722788811, 0.004484707023948431, 0.042153507471084595, -0.02208675444126129, -0.035684917122125626, -0.009516975842416286, -0.0017253949772566557 ]
<p>I am a math guy, so sorry for the naivety. When I peruse the wikipedia I see many "variants" of quantum field theory...conformal quantum field theory, topological quantum field theory, axiomatic/constructive quantum field theory, algebraic quantum field theory, etc. Whether or not these are actually variants of something is unclear to me. I don't really have a specific question, but I was wondering if you guys could help me understand what these different things are and/or point me to somewhere to get a clearer picture. </p>
g5896
[ 0.001466966001316905, 0.019740357995033264, -0.00024813052732497454, 0.02012174017727375, 0.041887179017066956, 0.012570411898195744, 0.019344469532370567, -0.006441580597311258, 0.061696987599134445, -0.021962685510516167, -0.019002722576260567, -0.009710244834423065, 0.01091003604233265, 0.021640226244926453, -0.010279402136802673, -0.06426263600587845, 0.07555945217609406, -0.0027838207315653563, 0.051776811480522156, -0.07255470007658005, 0.019969802349805832, 0.01947627030313015, 0.023668594658374786, -0.0048287673853337765, -0.0736602395772934, -0.015384563244879246, -0.034761883318424225, 0.006318483967334032, -0.016850702464580536, -0.06337364763021469, -0.04280899465084076, 0.005961967166513205, 0.10380503535270691, -0.01816282421350479, -0.00817139632999897, -0.014808986335992813, 0.014126121066510677, -0.021239226683974266, 0.055801257491111755, -0.016391003504395485, -0.019476523622870445, 0.008319990709424019, -0.025133956223726273, -0.034103576093912125, -0.05487233027815819, -0.039538998156785965, -0.009067916311323643, 0.028676988556981087, 0.04089374095201492, 0.044281408190727234, 0.03072931058704853, 0.027451971545815468, 0.051998719573020935, 0.009942242875695229, 0.047647252678871155, 0.02042390964925289, -0.010880101472139359, 0.00043782778084278107, 0.08837516605854034, 0.02013869769871235, 0.013524492271244526, 0.03774649277329445, 0.022677339613437653, 0.049325428903102875, 0.03273196518421173, 0.013499287888407707, -0.02881617844104767, -0.012039548717439175, -0.021153293550014496, -0.0343569852411747, 0.04283113405108452, -0.015709681436419487, 0.0027930387295782566, 0.02314073033630848, 0.013766700401902199, 0.041176509112119675, 0.01596548594534397, -0.0992015078663826, 0.028873873874545097, -0.020132005214691162, 0.014038275927305222, -0.04108775779604912, -0.020410992205142975, 0.040618885308504105, 0.02770988829433918, -0.03395150229334831, -0.0418870709836483, 0.02251541055738926, -0.0044233850203454494, -0.00007219291728688404, -0.0033425947185605764, 0.006148050539195538, 0.03637761250138283, 0.01693939045071602, -0.05589369684457779, 0.0007113452884368598, -0.02327302284538746, -0.0028710549231618643, 0.007514985743910074, 0.0326978974044323, -0.024391084909439087, 0.027282899245619774, 0.08541760593652725, 0.008407682180404663, -0.00112213846296072, 0.0023864780087023973, -0.030346205458045006, -0.02404417097568512, 0.004704002290964127, 0.018500540405511856, -0.06562907248735428, 0.038343723863363266, -0.0034546805545687675, 0.017092391848564148, -0.053540926426649094, 0.008094551973044872, -0.028864189982414246, 0.0010079165222123265, -0.001508254325017333, 0.007583313621580601, 0.01975131779909134, 0.017940212041139603, 0.022908249869942665, -0.04042676463723183, -0.055258456617593765, 0.008902785368263721, -0.027533743530511856, -0.04646999388933182, -0.022895628586411476, -0.03049604780972004, 0.07565780729055405, -0.012853589840233326, -0.01757747121155262, 0.04953719303011894, -0.010844355449080467, 0.042640868574380875, 0.006980048958212137, -0.012558696791529655, 0.05092199519276619, -0.014329382218420506, 0.023385358974337578, -0.06452720612287521, -0.039916668087244034, -0.013904934749007225, 0.04014306887984276, -0.07028432190418243, 0.042104966938495636, -0.011623955331742764, 0.00988435186445713, 0.019942032173275948, 0.03826127573847771, 0.0255222599953413, 0.0011739659821614623, -0.032979611307382584, 0.009167465381324291, -0.01324997004121542, -0.006366582587361336, -0.0313534289598465, 0.014131332747638226, 0.012969514355063438, 0.01823296956717968, 0.03212205320596695, 0.008715425617992878, 0.0027930394280701876, 0.004039268009364605, -0.036043088883161545, 0.06653852760791779, 0.033004533499479294, -0.010115321725606918, 0.004003474023193121, 0.02386276237666607, -0.015486769378185272, 0.002007662085816264, 0.01622142642736435, 0.007918016985058784, 0.04102783650159836, -0.006197978276759386, -0.0010916277533397079, -0.024608708918094635, 0.028793437406420708, -0.09434385597705841, 0.00931493192911148, -0.02735070325434208, -0.004566529765725136, -0.008627133443951607, 0.03751195967197418, -0.043227147310972214, -0.021432368084788322, -0.005638678092509508, 0.047059763222932816, -0.013895769603550434, -0.03420335799455643, 0.016000421717762947, -0.009636882692575455, 0.0052293953485786915, 0.02483414299786091, -0.04774995148181915, -0.008627980016171932, -0.03218023478984833, -0.03838759660720825, 0.034821607172489166, 0.03947291523218155, 0.012928219512104988, 0.029549667611718178, 0.04508274793624878, 0.04301559180021286, -0.05315099656581879, 0.003433732083067298, -0.008590378798544407, 0.014969565905630589, 0.03809862583875656, -0.0381636805832386, 0.0666954517364502, 0.05648546293377876, 0.015876447781920433, 0.012058633379638195, 0.005343154538422823, -0.003135891165584326, -0.02550738863646984, 0.042039040476083755, 0.025918327271938324, 0.009571688249707222, 0.07962926477193832, -0.04277970641851425, -0.02386688068509102, 0.05245697870850563, -0.015722518786787987, -0.032761022448539734, -0.008365746587514877, 0.021279044449329376, -0.030230402946472168, 0.0020899593364447355, -0.025632333010435104, -0.0634821429848671, 0.0350504107773304, -0.0036842627450823784, -0.021242273971438408, -0.04244598373770714, 0.060098737478256226, -0.01777716539800167, 0.0021481274161487818, 0.005422971677035093, 0.06351775676012039, 0.044587746262550354, -0.027572421357035637, -0.027839237824082375, -0.026276525110006332, -0.013113101944327354, 0.0016462677158415318, -0.018420414999127388, 0.005670119542628527, -0.07549937814474106, -0.07925334572792053, -0.009478110820055008, 0.02236773818731308, 0.06291624903678894, -0.011344263330101967, -0.02914535254240036, 0.01846616342663765, -0.015391075983643532, 0.026875033974647522, -0.05122033506631851, 0.00012876527034677565, 0.03718677535653114, -0.00431677233427763, 0.030338702723383904, 0.02740911766886711, 0.05716153234243393, -0.017523299902677536, 0.010258695110678673, -0.023404588922858238, 0.03360750898718834, -0.05147041380405426, -0.012750380672514439, -0.003246359061449766, -0.020616190508008003, -0.0047050598077476025, 0.024989774450659752, -0.012447716668248177, -0.016156800091266632, 0.025173932313919067, -0.0036388980224728584, 0.01461519580334425, 0.0034768020268529654, 0.03348970413208008, -0.020509492605924606, 0.023240700364112854, -0.04073653742671013, -0.03524009510874748, 0.02526022680103779, 0.025038976222276688, -0.01875367760658264, 0.0024307547137141228, -0.0005355766043066978, -0.08128675818443298, 0.0000574873156438116, -0.04166502133011818, 0.0020593502558767796, -0.04216168820858002, 0.09381529688835144, -0.0098187867552042, 0.05113315209746361, 0.012900379486382008, 0.10096468031406403, 0.06614575535058975, 0.04606132209300995, -0.031695734709501266, -0.0213912446051836, 0.01550894882529974, -0.04940614104270935, -0.0574430376291275, 0.030683735385537148, 0.02596932090818882, 0.005900292191654444, 0.014783811755478382, 0.010859414935112, -0.03160586953163147, 0.03692973777651787, 0.046976666897535324, -0.010388837195932865, -0.06489747762680054, -0.022267809137701988, -0.004418552853167057, 0.0026298610027879477, 0.07839595526456833, 0.026152636855840683, -0.052540939301252365, 0.039378903806209564, 0.04413481056690216, -0.08174457401037216, 0.017350148409605026, -0.024185264483094215, -0.016794541850686073, -0.025267047807574272, -0.07214023172855377, 0.010168211534619331, -0.024975400418043137, -0.004661225248128176, 0.04791216924786568, -0.0815698504447937, 0.08085734397172928, 0.036796703934669495, 0.04407515749335289, 0.003989738877862692, -0.006920642219483852, -0.043569013476371765, -0.030909033492207527, -0.016010819002985954, 0.009760909713804722, -0.02301601506769657, 0.016193227842450142, -0.028942877426743507, 0.04707363247871399, -0.014948557130992413, -0.0010037244064733386, 0.04350079223513603, 0.003227659035474062, 0.0386076457798481, -0.0111698554828763, 0.03075353056192398, -0.007436965126544237, -0.037499308586120605, 0.042628489434719086, 0.04819270595908165, 0.00483911344781518, 0.030212493613362312, 0.019077064469456673, -0.05468369275331497, -0.04879871383309364, 0.023033160716295242, 0.023281794041395187, 0.05564001202583313, 0.012456513941287994, 0.0066269938834011555, 0.04429685324430466, -0.02088303118944168, -0.028690775856375694, 0.04022236168384552, -0.0023993649519979954, -0.07326699048280716, 0.005294967442750931, 0.015023714862763882, 0.06336486339569092, 0.02767230197787285, 0.017677066847682, 0.0015358366072177887, -0.01867535151541233, -0.005440307781100273, -0.020969148725271225, 0.019315069541335106, -0.046308089047670364, -0.0018407766474410892, -0.06262026727199554, -0.05174648389220238, -0.027201497927308083, 0.043900541961193085, -0.019114738330245018, -0.007026443257927895, 0.010852501727640629, 0.04975190386176109, 0.06700979173183441, -0.01636616140604019, -0.020964937284588814, 0.015889860689640045, 0.03508444502949715, -0.0692872405052185, 0.023198215290904045, -0.003237141529098153, 0.02140539139509201, -0.06354062259197235, 0.0006176857277750969, -0.020833035930991173, 0.012590446509420872, -0.004002552945166826, 0.02915465459227562, 0.04464748874306679, 0.04008292779326439, -0.04724627360701561, 0.01411361712962389, -0.03378855809569359, -0.002583865076303482, 0.0007773215766064823, 0.03200044110417366, 0.015718894079327583, -0.010145703330636024, 0.03909267857670784, 0.02683405578136444, 0.02366035059094429, -0.007771032862365246, -0.01955971121788025, 0.03968587517738342, 0.05892306566238403, 0.004951482638716698, 0.005820786580443382, -0.04094921797513962, -0.002240291563794017, -0.07215086370706558, 0.04662040248513222, -0.009451018646359444, -0.03338422253727913, 0.0716196596622467, 0.02353532984852791, -0.00566531578078866, 0.00865568034350872, -0.004388588946312666, 0.007545520085841417, -0.10997092723846436, -0.04132423549890518, -0.0001102032620110549, -0.019430650398135185, -0.09119531512260437, 0.07707290351390839, 0.00714560691267252, -0.03231518343091011, -0.012029632925987244, -0.047502171248197556, -0.0034749952610582113, -0.02884771302342415, 0.07699628174304962, 0.04324295371770859, -0.0759052038192749, -0.01973067969083786, 0.031182581558823586, 0.01730835624039173, 0.032968442887067795, 0.0692884624004364, -0.10315432399511337, -0.004700453486293554, -0.07588467746973038, -0.07730285078287125, 0.05667133256793022, -0.020543299615383148, -0.048211414366960526, -0.0348874032497406, 0.03788897022604942, -0.04212004318833351, -0.0027012249920517206, -0.02939767763018608, -0.022215990349650383, -0.03052416443824768, 0.003458348335698247, -0.0448019839823246, 0.009506518952548504, 0.03398089110851288, -0.015771180391311646, -0.02811262384057045, 0.010939640924334526, 0.043928828090429306, -0.028267359361052513, -0.03344593942165375, 0.013749394565820694, 0.014419522136449814, 0.004234387539327145, -0.006092725787311792, -0.015581786632537842, -0.023672964423894882, -0.020067349076271057, -0.0005267424858175218, 0.015501407906413078, -0.0021879123523831367, -0.014369289390742779, 0.02888236567378044, 0.005809644237160683, 0.004670446272939444, -0.02775191329419613, 0.06040073186159134, 0.08900705724954605, -0.04165622964501381, -0.016170881688594818, -0.029165584594011307, -0.02330074831843376, -0.029250668361783028, -0.07274001836776733, 0.0160612054169178, 0.06733458489179611, 0.026585515588521957, -0.04781391844153404, -0.03225294128060341, 0.03282545134425163, -0.025129539892077446, -0.035665322095155716, -0.009355461224913597, -0.008166235871613026, 0.0011954265646636486, 0.07405519485473633, 0.0030335213523358107, -0.06422241777181625, -0.06646592915058136, 0.011262091808021069, 0.05103367939591408, -0.02404754050076008, 0.027974121272563934, 0.02055274322628975, 0.05848228931427002, -0.039008837193250656, 0.05237333104014397, -0.015632610768079758, -0.05114148557186127, 0.07406260818243027, 0.06578229367733002, -0.04077303782105446, -0.006691773887723684, 0.018299998715519905, -0.017107704654335976, 0.05227714031934738, -0.003105954499915242, 0.0437065064907074, 0.026354528963565826, 0.038598909974098206, -0.03441727161407471, -0.09259812533855438, 0.02382001280784607, -0.04164627566933632, -0.08515065163373947, -0.015445378609001637, -0.022943422198295593, -0.09250384569168091, -0.06518211215734482, -0.05118018761277199, 0.027540026232600212, 0.016436822712421417, 0.005451577715575695, -0.01203231979161501, -0.07908356189727783, -0.01382285263389349, 0.0032744561322033405, -0.000928147928789258, -0.00014660284796264023, 0.03832707181572914, 0.0313858836889267, -0.02388409897685051, 0.03464190661907196, 0.013952326960861683, -0.010954193770885468, -0.00011794698366429657, -0.030669348314404488, -0.00759388692677021, -0.032390840351581573, -0.044814299792051315, -0.002276500454172492, 0.016614627093076706, -0.009656927548348904, 0.005638152826577425, -0.07503405958414078, 0.003460580948740244, 0.054917823523283005, -0.06160694733262062, -0.010874258354306221, -0.028188537806272507, 0.056346941739320755, -0.033315908163785934, 0.048221979290246964, -0.05677655339241028, 0.00806157011538744, -0.00825203862041235, 0.00021236416068859398, 0.006855989806354046, 0.02333064377307892, 0.043829191476106644, -0.023146992549300194, -0.019339045509696007, -0.043330322951078415, 0.03761108219623566, -0.013558728620409966, 0.03174898028373718, 0.1385871171951294, -0.025446541607379913, -0.0029165574815124273, -0.012532376684248447, -0.010265928693115711, -0.021272920072078705, 0.020907752215862274, -0.00018064129108097404, -0.028762532398104668, -0.05712079629302025, -0.02665107510983944, -0.04578491300344467, -0.06103791669011116, -0.027566296979784966, 0.016558490693569183, 0.03499932587146759, -0.03446786478161812, -0.01998845674097538, 0.022994305938482285, -0.0059095644392073154, 0.014585139229893684, 0.010278472676873207, 0.009198077954351902, 0.014163886196911335, -0.03898584097623825, -0.009736014530062675, -0.012388262897729874, 0.02855473756790161, 0.010621115565299988, 0.017131725326180458, 0.019431432709097862, -0.03217335045337677, 0.0005843530525453389, 0.0025575682520866394, 0.03574036806821823, -0.044264256954193115, 0.0345296636223793, 0.07254242897033691, 0.01274697482585907, -0.014369483105838299, -0.030537309125065804, -0.0334329828619957, -0.02966497652232647, -0.011040691286325455, 0.003263815538957715, -0.009308413602411747, 0.0258047953248024, -0.04385174438357353, -0.00585774052888155, -0.00778729235753417, 0.020553959533572197, 0.0436176173388958, 0.019712762907147408, -0.043751247227191925, -0.07057515531778336, 0.0101312305778265, -0.04361898452043533, 0.00886521302163601, -0.00891669187694788, -0.03768811747431755, 0.02512557990849018, 0.008797187358140945, -0.014273526147007942, 0.0015800187829881907, -0.007091131992638111, 0.008895674720406532, -0.02044050209224224, -0.03457915037870407, 0.023446302860975266, 0.014910703524947166, -0.045312780886888504, -0.0026799615006893873, 0.029420481994748116, -0.02655595913529396, -0.03139720484614372, -0.02823197841644287, 0.08710844069719315, 0.027290090918540955, -0.015911558642983437, 0.005684686359018087, 0.013701874762773514, 0.007845615036785603, -0.030062008649110794, -0.03329545632004738, 0.01444864273071289, 0.07562249898910522, -0.062287166714668274, 0.026259183883666992, 0.010274572297930717, -0.010481404140591621, 0.03545451909303665, -0.032891761511564255, -0.030963964760303497, 0.021426046267151833, 0.015013727359473705, 0.02721497416496277, 0.0011466683354228735, -0.0021485090255737305, -0.059345539659261703, 0.08999159932136536, -0.037296488881111145, 0.01952267251908779, -0.017793383449316025, -0.0389678068459034, -0.012810049578547478, 0.02035459131002426, 0.007575609255582094, 0.0662006288766861, -0.004100622609257698, -0.015726622194051743, -0.021975619718432426, -0.005979966372251511, -0.012291928753256798, -0.020299337804317474, -0.024104643613100052, -0.009616184048354626, 0.030918292701244354, -0.011124162003397942, -0.03265068680047989, 0.0028766568284481764, -0.001998929539695382, -0.04446437209844589, -0.030852844938635826, -0.0029794517904520035, 0.002283387817442417, 0.022129816934466362, -0.04473497346043587, -0.030642006546258926, 0.03784775361418724, -0.004175230395048857, 0.051147278398275375, 0.013191482052206993, -0.029907219111919403, 0.05319678783416748, -0.04502372443675995, 0.09038752317428589, 0.05308757349848747, 0.016743235290050507, -0.021949540823698044, -0.04292446747422218, -0.018620343878865242, -0.04277807101607323, -0.012787272222340107, 0.047413893043994904, 0.038076192140579224, -0.050310168415308, 0.036221250891685486, 0.025850368663668633, 0.0731360986828804, -0.017786923795938492, 0.01985500566661358, -0.028523152694106102, 0.09457565099000931, 0.055974189192056656, 0.043985962867736816, 0.026848608627915382, 0.0050754607655107975, 0.018814336508512497, 0.012253152206540108, -0.04100407660007477, 0.02206822857260704, -0.036128655076026917, 0.0028427059296518564 ]
<p>Consider a free theory with one real scalar field: $$ \mathcal{L}:=-\frac{1}{2}\partial _\mu \phi \partial ^\mu \phi -\frac{1}{2}m^2\phi ^2. $$ We write this positive coefficient in front of $\phi ^2$ as $\frac{1}{2}m^2$, and then start calling $m$ the mass (of who knows what at this point) and even interpret it as such. But pretend for a moment that you've never seen any sort of field theory before: if someone were to just write this Lagrangian down, it's not immediately apparent why this should be the mass of anything.</p> <p>So then, first of all, what is it precisely that we mean when we say the word "mass", and how is our constant related to this physical notion in a way that justifies the interpretation of $m$ as mass?</p> <p>If it helps to clarify, this is how I think about it. There are two notions of mass involved: the mathematical one that is part of our model, and the physical one which we are trying to model. The physical mass needs to be defined by an idealized thought <em>experiment</em>, and then, if our model is to be any good, we should be able to come up with a 'proof' that our mathematical definition agrees with the physical one.</p> <p>(Of course, none of this at all has anything to do with this particular field theory; it was just the simplest Lagrangian to write down.)</p>
g5897
[ 0.06099143624305725, -0.019447332248091698, -0.01236977893859148, -0.06566464155912399, 0.08037101477384567, 0.029955295845866203, 0.03570479899644852, 0.047109026461839676, -0.05538789927959442, -0.03051251731812954, 0.004500569310039282, -0.012857526540756226, 0.05902634188532829, 0.03745599463582039, 0.010914182290434837, 0.013991838321089745, 0.07156297564506531, 0.010601765476167202, 0.037719547748565674, -0.020667506381869316, 0.0024372038897126913, 0.0033262940123677254, 0.0014055585488677025, 0.004621417261660099, -0.04226117953658104, -0.02165062166750431, 0.06468091160058975, 0.005168663337826729, 0.043806131929159164, -0.04441126435995102, -0.011706851422786713, 0.019595734775066376, 0.0405147410929203, -0.035360924899578094, -0.0538727305829525, -0.03870953992009163, 0.004583117086440325, 0.055199284106492996, 0.011523755267262459, -0.019422242417931557, 0.01840406097471714, -0.009209468960762024, 0.008558709174394608, -0.0021659398917108774, -0.04731398820877075, 0.041031427681446075, -0.0606984980404377, -0.017365122213959694, 0.0023275790736079216, 0.001855015056207776, 0.04994010180234909, 0.028422804549336433, 0.046040721237659454, 0.022264881059527397, -0.007200193125754595, 0.040339525789022446, 0.06058520823717117, -0.01404979731887579, 0.038307033479213715, 0.03074544109404087, -0.002890977542847395, 0.011007067747414112, 0.008953042328357697, -0.001702619600109756, 0.051041025668382645, 0.009602074511349201, -0.06662905216217041, -0.035176992416381836, 0.024136850610375404, 0.013848644681274891, 0.011981881223618984, -0.031168773770332336, -0.0013834888814017177, -0.03935524821281433, 0.03069777600467205, -0.005270482040941715, -0.043082546442747116, 0.009025054052472115, 0.07431522011756897, -0.09318789839744568, 0.019874678924679756, -0.04758710041642189, 0.04101857915520668, 0.038790300488471985, 0.11229511350393295, -0.05597682669758797, -0.059226565062999725, -0.04289959743618965, -0.01181760337203741, 0.024528559297323227, 0.01581014320254326, -0.03380252420902252, 0.015350056812167168, 0.023384585976600647, -0.01021480467170477, -0.04862135276198387, -0.018350495025515556, 0.020267920568585396, -0.05864636227488518, -0.016928527504205704, -0.005231746472418308, 0.03587658703327179, 0.017996182665228844, -0.010870423167943954, -0.01498575322329998, 0.044729262590408325, 0.009536772035062313, 0.04777197539806366, 0.016332436352968216, -0.0053561413660645485, -0.017195630818605423, 0.056408196687698364, -0.0254263523966074, -0.06619869917631149, -0.09634711593389511, -0.057630401104688644, 0.09452877938747406, 0.006689969450235367, -0.029120782390236855, 0.04608050361275673, -0.021654460579156876, 0.014542369171977043, 0.03511838614940643, 0.035791367292404175, -0.052169494330883026, -0.0369684062898159, 0.018098896369338036, -0.013718653470277786, -0.03887872397899628, -0.034130923449993134, -0.009013182483613491, 0.013700383715331554, -0.016903068870306015, 0.03277367725968361, 0.017974281683564186, 0.03996066376566887, -0.04287070035934448, -0.01611609011888504, 0.007261442951858044, -0.012099778279662132, -0.004618305712938309, 0.004204774275422096, -0.022441720589995384, -0.022484077140688896, -0.014458317309617996, 0.04510216787457466, 0.0025694691576063633, -0.029963737353682518, 0.04030732810497284, 0.042430371046066284, 0.015649044886231422, 0.08045872300863266, -0.01314406469464302, -0.018153319135308266, 0.011410009115934372, 0.004973119590431452, 0.018865641206502914, -0.01185921672731638, 0.0068712192587554455, 0.011136225424706936, 0.047445449978113174, 0.006373606622219086, 0.04645928740501404, -0.0064430925995111465, -0.04122086614370346, 0.009982028044760227, 0.01711854338645935, -0.012917986139655113, -0.032828498631715775, -0.05004969239234924, -0.03637004271149635, 0.0338798463344574, -0.012722915038466454, 0.021451681852340698, -0.04916058108210564, 0.018897300586104393, -0.02207658439874649, 0.022093279287219048, 0.034616511315107346, 0.07173579186201096, -0.04925623908638954, -0.04540722072124481, -0.004013383761048317, -0.010074884630739689, -0.07395059615373611, -0.039714738726615906, 0.02524438686668873, 0.06919139623641968, 0.01516860444098711, 0.03318813070654869, -0.018483387306332588, 0.012240441516041756, -0.03173474594950676, 0.10118551552295685, 0.014596926048398018, 0.02326575107872486, 0.028618259355425835, -0.03500651195645332, 0.00383328297175467, -0.02015913650393486, -0.02478303201496601, 0.015548779629170895, 0.0007213830831460655, 0.03592677786946297, 0.018475253134965897, -0.016005175188183784, 0.006872306577861309, -0.02104147896170616, 0.049929238855838776, 0.008533790707588196, 0.023874860256910324, -0.05401376634836197, 0.008585546165704727, 0.04291852191090584, 0.016033219173550606, -0.01951712742447853, -0.012452264316380024, -0.014780564233660698, -0.009159711189568043, 0.01656496897339821, -0.015244469977915287, -0.025095978751778603, 0.06657932698726654, -0.01662415638566017, -0.04377974942326546, 0.028459712862968445, 0.0033420564141124487, -0.017062988132238388, -0.05664166435599327, -0.015779223293066025, -0.02643504925072193, 0.01803096942603588, 0.006971381604671478, 0.021388184279203415, 0.05126292258501053, 0.017208287492394447, -0.03449791669845581, 0.018781406804919243, -0.0030522423330694437, 0.009676939807832241, -0.0006329004536382854, 0.007202876731753349, -0.03550213947892189, -0.010517578572034836, 0.019983235746622086, -0.051573410630226135, 0.026766743510961533, 0.035845108330249786, -0.030908318236470222, 0.017067745327949524, -0.041903771460056305, 0.021508030593395233, -0.023498252034187317, -0.018685726448893547, 0.04562516510486603, -0.04140496253967285, 0.018882816657423973, 0.02237754687666893, -0.04539768025279045, 0.01038587186485529, 0.04511064291000366, -0.08388416469097137, -0.04382122680544853, 0.053825605660676956, -0.1073240339756012, -0.0066382079385221004, -0.06571502983570099, 0.0283342357724905, 0.017865201458334923, -0.019492899999022484, 0.028023775666952133, 0.056621991097927094, 0.06106647104024887, 0.005451168864965439, -0.03136789798736572, -0.04063737019896507, 0.020670976489782333, -0.005715752020478249, 0.0722532719373703, -0.07610448449850082, 0.030990490689873695, 0.04710644856095314, -0.020265089347958565, 0.07300688326358795, 0.05280136317014694, -0.06925696134567261, -0.014715522527694702, -0.025481658056378365, -0.038985904306173325, 0.016170257702469826, 0.021571999415755272, 0.01473322231322527, -0.0004548632132355124, -0.021388771012425423, -0.02329317107796669, 0.07286065071821213, 0.01987474039196968, -0.030443275347352028, 0.0445406399667263, 0.0002476764493621886, 0.0015375171788036823, 0.04151548817753792, -0.015530938282608986, 0.005349484272301197, -0.06148168444633484, 0.0212395079433918, -0.0006619730847887695, -0.008473549969494343, -0.03180437162518501, -0.08060260862112045, -0.005201032385230064, 0.06593626737594604, 0.03053407371044159, 0.007941490970551968, -0.10575023293495178, 0.007929417304694653, -0.006481169257313013, -0.021463098004460335, -0.004312008153647184, -0.04281756654381752, -0.05794840306043625, -0.04685668274760246, 0.028663039207458496, -0.003972241654992104, 0.004118999466300011, -0.02643195539712906, -0.0245897825807333, -0.013666167855262756, -0.078767791390419, -0.09506259858608246, 0.020847590640187263, 0.03040241077542305, -0.052582740783691406, -0.02334938757121563, -0.030209289863705635, -0.013317029923200607, -0.023631200194358826, 0.004916004370898008, 0.06070278584957123, -0.019909251481294632, -0.03950688615441322, 0.028488269075751305, -0.08464100956916809, 0.031111856922507286, 0.008958387188613415, -0.040680594742298126, -0.054035734385252, -0.07177925854921341, 0.063960961997509, -0.05386761948466301, 0.0029834145680069923, 0.035987138748168945, -0.020253930240869522, 0.002006573136895895, -0.010448712855577469, 0.050318412482738495, 0.05744650214910507, 0.014148025773465633, -0.0014078463427722454, 0.014801086857914925, 0.02898641675710678, 0.0011651420500129461, 0.01741897687315941, 0.03917550668120384, -0.014981125481426716, 0.014480631798505783, -0.03539147600531578, 0.006251184735447168, 0.02752937376499176, -0.004039940889924765, -0.0033361269161105156, -0.03536222502589226, -0.011373520828783512, 0.08992001414299011, -0.006789109669625759, -0.011296616867184639, 0.003142093075439334, 0.04141050577163696, -0.045998476445674896, 0.010989470407366753, 0.06256759911775589, 0.021616032347083092, -0.028338415548205376, -0.0035417519975453615, 0.01632256805896759, 0.016866788268089294, -0.047677744179964066, 0.03685533255338669, 0.00624057138338685, -0.019527198746800423, -0.00421652989462018, -0.013123645447194576, -0.015683671459555626, 0.008081076666712761, 0.06311281770467758, -0.016100583598017693, -0.007644505240023136, -0.02659768983721733, 0.015444614924490452, 0.004096719436347485, 0.04078655317425728, 0.028410406783223152, 0.04050639271736145, -0.021124137565493584, -0.005575194954872131, 0.031380366533994675, 0.03697122260928154, -0.061915911734104156, 0.008496529422700405, -0.05850492790341377, -0.004454153589904308, -0.010041589848697186, 0.008236313238739967, -0.04004019498825073, 0.03630897402763367, 0.030843619257211685, -0.011571593582630157, -0.0074729654006659985, 0.02690744586288929, 0.011937347240746021, -0.007962060160934925, -0.005662380252033472, -0.0016988972201943398, -0.0436006598174572, -0.002156465779989958, 0.04628973454236984, 0.06215989589691162, 0.0331190824508667, -0.023505305871367455, -0.04922441765666008, -0.011207505129277706, 0.04008778929710388, 0.0008324140799231827, 0.0028870769310742617, -0.049110621213912964, 0.013529540039598942, -0.09564215689897537, 0.054778166115283966, -0.02470710501074791, 0.05072426050901413, 0.05952838063240051, 0.0010180874960497022, 0.00023508729645982385, -0.02353614568710327, 0.01975470967590809, -0.03207922726869583, 0.02973705530166626, -0.02144472859799862, -0.004406970925629139, -0.010066463612020016, -0.042941976338624954, 0.02368781901896, 0.002520566573366523, -0.05216836556792259, 0.05199410766363144, 0.02334248088300228, -0.055718306452035904, 0.02982599474489689, 0.0032179756090044975, 0.00022358012211043388, -0.03916822373867035, -0.023362774401903152, 0.05005471780896187, 0.03496183827519417, 0.06778854876756668, -0.04047601297497749, -0.06019441783428192, -0.04066574573516846, -0.036980364471673965, -0.03368304297327995, 0.0003537225420586765, 0.013752805069088936, -0.009569743648171425, -0.04604537412524223, 0.04209696501493454, 0.02854188345372677, -0.013840524479746819, -0.036439064890146255, -0.04007594659924507, -0.06416819989681244, 0.034494731575250626, 0.03052571974694729, 0.024393891915678978, -0.06424380838871002, 0.008594600483775139, 0.03808998316526413, -0.019503984600305557, 0.03126144781708717, -0.04265304654836655, -0.04198047146201134, 0.03435605391860008, 0.03231556713581085, -0.006383920554071665, 0.015247773379087448, -0.0385703407227993, -0.00755924079567194, -0.023062920197844505, -0.005181111861020327, 0.017919154837727547, -0.05368628352880478, -0.04733102023601532, 0.03673062101006508, 0.06608017534017563, 0.051413748413324356, -0.005307081621140242, 0.06273767352104187, 0.011908692307770252, -0.061702124774456024, -0.03039371594786644, 0.056856919080019, 0.03838235139846802, 0.007630988955497742, 0.000019363542378414422, 0.016215482726693153, 0.021687189117074013, 0.001667731092311442, 0.029464926570653915, 0.009163345210254192, 0.020789146423339844, 0.01515020988881588, 0.028747322037816048, 0.0061229825951159, 0.031207755208015442, -0.029097095131874084, -0.020116005092859268, 0.01751072332262993, -0.03762446716427803, -0.03628573939204216, 0.0028635587077587843, 0.08051425963640213, -0.0070219323970377445, -0.024800533428788185, 0.06505316495895386, -0.02803405188024044, -0.02405833825469017, -0.02844383381307125, -0.04312220960855484, -0.0013755522668361664, 0.07008027285337448, -0.01069209910929203, -0.01714446395635605, -0.045822978019714355, -0.004606481175869703, 0.01495011430233717, 0.05828310176730156, 0.0752062126994133, 0.051805607974529266, -0.023370085284113884, 0.04949973523616791, -0.038471680134534836, -0.04669371247291565, 0.0012527538929134607, -0.011413494125008583, -0.02509770169854164, 0.001179813756607473, 0.0313049778342247, -0.02689814381301403, 0.00579560874029994, -0.05863737314939499, 0.01149999164044857, -0.024661308154463768, 0.04857150837779045, 0.004466177895665169, -0.006190906278789043, 0.011054392904043198, -0.018430527299642563, 0.07516183704137802, -0.05949118360877037, -0.010248763486742973, -0.03092401847243309, -0.01773315668106079, 0.04490587115287781, -0.003984555602073669, 0.01115639228373766, 0.0241951122879982, 0.04292047768831253, -0.01852049119770527, -0.01117799710482359, 0.020491044968366623, -0.05009862780570984, 0.05451451987028122, -0.001846021506935358, 0.04518916457891464, -0.07292112708091736, -0.0013868599198758602, 0.016511812806129456, -0.04631946608424187, -0.050701599568128586, 0.023267671465873718, 0.02443937212228775, -0.03020036406815052, 0.006646871566772461, -0.06991635262966156, -0.0007850007968954742, -0.02323998138308525, 0.037235550582408905, -0.014790053479373455, -0.08880511671304703, -0.04307871311903, 0.01484084315598011, 0.05763954669237137, 0.013140772469341755, -0.04185836762189865, -0.05179064720869064, 0.013485983945429325, 0.04507111385464668, -0.011715622618794441, 0.029749101027846336, -0.007162192836403847, 0.0025445418432354927, -0.04506383091211319, -0.01401751209050417, -0.00804374273866415, -0.017134172841906548, 0.021428588777780533, -0.024964548647403717, -0.007101995404809713, 0.051205359399318695, -0.058098938316106796, -0.02116880565881729, 0.031048156321048737, 0.01567656919360161, 0.006257900036871433, -0.029303664341568947, 0.014868286438286304, 0.0009501528111286461, 0.027904588729143143, 0.03000420331954956, 0.05586014315485954, -0.015414058230817318, -0.022792305797338486, 0.02372550591826439, 0.02748517319560051, 0.06374993175268173, 0.042141180485486984, 0.029694540426135063, -0.025485141202807426, 0.0625976175069809, 0.055874358862638474, -0.0313558354973793, -0.013312133029103279, 0.0005939531256444752, 0.010650777257978916, -0.0006623029476031661, -0.07020340114831924, 0.016007190570235252, 0.04175587370991707, -0.013084427453577518, -0.047059524804353714, -0.036913998425006866, -0.049410853534936905, 0.009253215044736862, -0.036764875054359436, -0.02227194420993328, -0.03220755606889725, 0.020852722227573395, 0.023376287892460823, 0.06316566467285156, 0.014572949148714542, -0.03097456693649292, -0.07161875069141388, 0.028869682922959328, 0.0382387600839138, -0.04115251079201698, -0.027368592098355293, 0.0462094247341156, -0.009649679064750671, -0.04322127625346184, 0.0402730256319046, -0.00903735589236021, 0.032984502613544464, -0.05995133891701698, -0.008682110346853733, 0.025543084368109703, -0.03166017308831215, -0.015312357805669308, -0.009245079942047596, 0.0606086403131485, -0.032904308289289474, 0.0024983002804219723, -0.009038269519805908, 0.058455973863601685, 0.006291349418461323, 0.03889229893684387, -0.03190853074193001, -0.009870545007288456, -0.04160572960972786, 0.03512045741081238, -0.061847440898418427, 0.020836306735873222, 0.04218335449695587, -0.028786320239305496, 0.06644843518733978, -0.00828260276466608, -0.0143330879509449, -0.05020333454012871, 0.01055525615811348, 0.06021345406770706, 0.03538777679204941, 0.029682841151952744, -0.015541714616119862, -0.04309627041220665, 0.007476376835256815, 0.002187194302678108, 0.04075922816991806, -0.005882622674107552, 0.02839304879307747, 0.018561501055955887, -0.06015561521053314, -0.017106041312217712, -0.027834990993142128, 0.03284167870879173, -0.02079111896455288, 0.027129214257001877, 0.030667418614029884, -0.016371047124266624, -0.0586991123855114, 0.021286211907863617, -0.01514371670782566, -0.06635215878486633, -0.00688547408208251, 0.05253424867987633, -0.035232942551374435, -0.08380834013223648, -0.016239307820796967, 0.02748032473027706, -0.021945353597402573, -0.014444448985159397, 0.0059455884620547295, 0.02468096651136875, -0.04439723491668701, -0.006708658300340176, -0.015577095560729504, 0.0558844730257988, -0.027755925431847572, 0.029019005596637726, 0.013736071065068245, 0.033254265785217285, -0.0030765000265091658, -0.03784724324941635, -0.012420296669006348, -0.03192343935370445, 0.004965250380337238, 0.013996130786836147, -0.029955238103866577, 0.006131759844720364, -0.026019008830189705, 0.05333750322461128, 0.018123235553503036, -0.023112228140234947, 0.005680656060576439, 0.016064560040831566, -0.06390248239040375, 0.024148045107722282, 0.03514264151453972, -0.04348386451601982, 0.005590416491031647, -0.005130656063556671, 0.05098812282085419, -0.006913060322403908, 0.0005543542210943997, -0.02803795412182808, 0.006131784990429878, 0.02761242352426052, -0.049042992293834686, -0.048433661460876465, 0.05741151422262192, 0.037127330899238586 ]
<p>I envision a longitudinal wave as a series of vertical lines like that drawn on the board in an introductory physics class. This image contains no angles. Sound is a longitudinal wave.</p> <p>Some audiovisual references claim that sound is composed of sine waves.</p> <p>I am trying to reconcile how longitudinal waves (no angles) can be composed of sine waves (dependent on angles). What maths or theory explains the relationship?</p>
g5898
[ 0.058786895126104355, -0.03359900042414665, -0.016479061916470528, -0.023805376142263412, 0.05314837396144867, 0.018104152753949165, 0.06608880311250687, 0.023333897814154625, -0.01043059304356575, -0.060848336666822433, -0.045345887541770935, 0.029106004163622856, -0.00766898924484849, 0.045429717749357224, -0.03288217633962631, -0.0045214490965008736, 0.03904451057314873, 0.04417162388563156, 0.005643620155751705, 0.005188272800296545, 0.03149699419736862, 0.025681009516119957, 0.018945960327982903, -0.013841351494193077, -0.02828981541097164, -0.035192202776670456, -0.0030713591258972883, -0.041858479380607605, -0.007990599609911442, -0.015844233334064484, 0.03744533285498619, -0.006332945544272661, 0.04755626618862152, -0.018616272136569023, -0.016713153570890427, -0.04235048592090607, -0.0326007716357708, 0.003861532313749194, 0.03567269444465637, 0.06741336733102798, -0.02334568463265896, 0.016387294977903366, -0.0009645635145716369, -0.034076664596796036, -0.017757976427674294, -0.027431610971689224, -0.022878682240843773, -0.01744442991912365, -0.002770304214209318, 0.021839631721377373, -0.0055354563519358635, -0.03509879484772682, 0.06247454136610031, -0.007197308819741011, -0.03977077081799507, 0.051346298307180405, 0.022140497341752052, 0.028942182660102844, 0.05113798379898071, 0.02297775074839592, 0.01275175716727972, 0.040670525282621384, 0.0169660747051239, 0.037350114434957504, 0.09755133092403412, -0.03828937187790871, -0.04490834102034569, -0.020357264205813408, 0.00006912976823514327, 0.01702009327709675, 0.03967256098985672, -0.06661742180585861, -0.03840142861008644, -0.012626816518604755, -0.028995994478464127, 0.0530100055038929, 0.07615561783313751, 0.009786412119865417, -0.06830663233995438, 0.050124138593673706, 0.037894319742918015, -0.01701485738158226, 0.047779493033885956, 0.044787753373384476, 0.12343735247850418, -0.04480846971273422, -0.008728778921067715, 0.002231994178146124, -0.017240285873413086, 0.044845450669527054, 0.00015264972171280533, 0.03133375570178032, 0.05147842317819595, 0.04858642816543579, -0.04813029617071152, -0.0852055624127388, -0.07234738767147064, 0.0731474757194519, 0.04773246869444847, 0.015445567667484283, -0.0022398035507649183, -0.012113629840314388, 0.020019138231873512, -0.05157594382762909, 0.008758505806326866, 0.0389256589114666, 0.015861641615629196, 0.00497133145108819, -0.022617878392338753, 0.023946324363350868, -0.04021953418850899, -0.05318517982959747, -0.018996763974428177, -0.010357551276683807, -0.025520088151097298, -0.044402144849300385, 0.03240295127034187, -0.023628389462828636, 0.06173871085047722, 0.08727973699569702, 0.0031936168670654297, 0.012609285302460194, -0.010058915242552757, 0.06874198466539383, -0.05418995022773743, 0.0025517793837934732, -0.04222138226032257, 0.009576402604579926, 0.016491835936903954, -0.006879767403006554, 0.037746526300907135, -0.0038171042688190937, -0.010022998787462711, 0.014058281667530537, 0.029929138720035553, 0.019690316170454025, 0.01273044291883707, -0.03862395137548447, -0.015076165087521076, -0.0023852360900491476, 0.022816574200987816, 0.030885180458426476, 0.02571125701069832, -0.0431622713804245, -0.02453053928911686, 0.0032637575641274452, -0.011032190173864365, -0.03259259834885597, 0.03956161439418793, 0.0028136316686868668, -0.05791766196489334, 0.034996140748262405, 0.032411761581897736, -0.014386763796210289, -0.002726757898926735, -0.019361617043614388, 0.021700173616409302, -0.03418845310807228, 0.014389622025191784, 0.004998091608285904, 0.02272426150739193, 0.02467401884496212, -0.030856318771839142, -0.02365691401064396, -0.09876635670661926, -0.08253777027130127, -0.013866801746189594, -0.053067099303007126, 0.0638670027256012, -0.004433921538293362, -0.016720853745937347, 0.038890015333890915, 0.012545289471745491, 0.0579889640212059, -0.023401353508234024, 0.09804780781269073, 0.043290771543979645, -0.033409446477890015, -0.019166797399520874, 0.004995647817850113, -0.036616042256355286, 0.016174007207155228, 0.0020569143816828728, -0.008837949484586716, 0.04330316185951233, -0.005719788372516632, -0.03243141248822212, 0.036246150732040405, -0.07989746332168579, -0.007136815693229437, 0.017712019383907318, -0.059885237365961075, -0.05281822010874748, -0.012469029985368252, 0.01698693260550499, 0.0010523732053115964, 0.029502147808670998, 0.014793433248996735, -0.03289854899048805, 0.06882039457559586, -0.003402293659746647, 0.01755029708147049, 0.06452863663434982, 0.01745389588177204, -0.018986959010362625, 0.05548371374607086, -0.006132578011602163, -0.08069606870412827, -0.0032068395521491766, 0.001524467719718814, -0.045505341142416, 0.00894601084291935, -0.005449932534247637, -0.010081537067890167, -0.026729026809334755, -0.01932254247367382, -0.004391625057905912, -0.024697398766875267, -0.03545071557164192, 0.005483382381498814, -0.026804571971297264, -0.019723854959011078, 0.009312992915511131, -0.050054822117090225, 0.03196978196501732, -0.013161571696400642, -0.01128834392875433, -0.0003709527663886547, 0.03089972585439682, -0.04932110011577606, -0.01419112179428339, -0.02658693864941597, -0.0042875115759670734, 0.0039546373300254345, 0.031100129708647728, 0.038710013031959534, 0.024442685768008232, -0.024037491530179977, -0.0019611241295933723, 0.028654195368289948, 0.00919460691511631, -0.0038559806998819113, -0.040250249207019806, -0.019389530643820763, 0.0556994266808033, 0.010385598056018353, 0.005705187562853098, -0.027558082714676857, 0.004618722479790449, 0.008713996037840843, 0.013231185264885426, -0.05966874957084656, -0.09109093248844147, 0.04683758318424225, 0.016078034415841103, -0.041792161762714386, 0.0039987522177398205, 0.03928479552268982, -0.03933997079730034, -0.03817712888121605, -0.035044752061367035, -0.04153188690543175, -0.021337000653147697, 0.001955666346475482, -0.04926595464348793, -0.044018782675266266, -0.00031286515877582133, 0.020273825153708458, -0.009520122781395912, -0.04741416499018669, -0.014024289324879646, 0.04550517722964287, 0.022958951070904732, -0.01748942956328392, -0.02631780318915844, -0.022438019514083862, 0.027102649211883545, -0.017914852127432823, -0.04818268120288849, 0.0030196274165064096, 0.05054812505841255, -0.00010672798816813156, -0.018165411427617073, 0.037340521812438965, 0.04445509985089302, 0.006947353016585112, -0.010179934091866016, -0.008756080642342567, 0.004379540681838989, 0.07139308750629425, -0.0075855921022593975, 0.043021101504564285, 0.041399288922548294, -0.003290957771241665, -0.008631388656795025, 0.05485168471932411, 0.046344220638275146, -0.013809410855174065, -0.017032289877533913, 0.006983879953622818, -0.07334457337856293, 0.07477224618196487, 0.016600459814071655, -0.048937149345874786, -0.014781263656914234, 0.0037290016189217567, -0.0032913251779973507, -0.07459495216608047, 0.008072472177445889, -0.01162735279649496, 0.01629106141626835, -0.0016768386121839285, 0.053518932312726974, 0.06323051452636719, -0.04320136830210686, 0.007222641259431839, 0.0024613416753709316, 0.015511994250118732, -0.014035473577678204, 0.044842679053545, -0.08242050558328629, -0.008330642245709896, 0.02297855354845524, -0.006674152798950672, 0.0028059217147529125, 0.0032758861780166626, 0.025962306186556816, 0.03933911770582199, -0.11409571021795273, -0.03247534856200218, -0.02349698543548584, -0.05203928053379059, 0.014747526496648788, -0.014084449037909508, 0.08257009088993073, -0.05414840206503868, 0.015762463212013245, -0.012894732877612114, 0.041670773178339005, 0.03189224377274513, 0.028386104851961136, 0.0039648571982979774, -0.0928693637251854, -0.035436756908893585, -0.012979874387383461, 0.006543124094605446, 0.022347023710608482, 0.016274312511086464, 0.0625649094581604, -0.07679014652967453, -0.024731909856200218, 0.023923950269818306, 0.02338417060673237, 0.04530411586165428, -0.00844635721296072, 0.036200061440467834, 0.029276952147483826, 0.03313814103603363, -0.03497534990310669, 0.01733251102268696, -0.05767296254634857, -0.03250034525990486, 0.0023699263110756874, 0.00266607035882771, -0.004133585374802351, -0.012589122168719769, -0.018122388049960136, 0.04035741463303566, 0.02665725164115429, -0.033387523144483566, -0.010270056314766407, -0.06440553069114685, 0.0018124323105439544, -0.011460840702056885, -0.07813283801078796, -0.03262895718216896, 0.011319927871227264, -0.00531280180439353, -0.09527354687452316, 0.028566764667630196, 0.022519974038004875, 0.05536385625600815, 0.05069081485271454, -0.016372118145227432, -0.018853412941098213, -0.00588429206982255, 0.004168808460235596, 0.037707678973674774, 0.0034869809169322252, -0.002184974728152156, 0.023109350353479385, -0.06469769775867462, -0.04999207332730293, -0.07143581658601761, 0.04297149181365967, -0.07277858257293701, 0.009680353105068207, 0.009410601109266281, 0.022260891273617744, 0.05157410353422165, 0.015481767244637012, 0.02253063954412937, 0.01583746075630188, 0.034481704235076904, 0.02844979241490364, 0.03890695422887802, 0.04755370691418648, -0.03955152630805969, -0.037377309054136276, -0.0551886148750782, -0.0366557352244854, -0.035684049129486084, -0.007633226923644543, -0.029826920479536057, 0.0034666273277252913, 0.04739001393318176, 0.0808214470744133, -0.03477385267615318, 0.023458831012248993, 0.0794670507311821, 0.03640623763203621, 0.06991304457187653, -0.003578782081604004, -0.053911469876766205, 0.01336971390992403, 0.05600913614034653, 0.035757653415203094, -0.009730731137096882, -0.011697651818394661, 0.018136179074645042, -0.008356272242963314, -0.020046796649694443, 0.0320589542388916, -0.02850804291665554, -0.06794607639312744, 0.005074015818536282, -0.04201981797814369, 0.05443384498357773, -0.005222667008638382, -0.025456830859184265, 0.01275037694722414, 0.0010179664241150022, -0.01245167851448059, -0.0645776093006134, -0.012821687385439873, 0.038894519209861755, -0.03052712231874466, -0.01463166531175375, -0.06321068853139877, -0.03575596958398819, -0.0473778136074543, 0.011765744537115097, 0.004701718222349882, -0.07408411055803299, 0.013759201392531395, -0.014938844367861748, -0.04959433153271675, 0.008574296720325947, -0.025902241468429565, 0.0012276864144951105, 0.03358577936887741, 0.024702105671167374, -0.002186904428526759, -0.0077130976133048534, 0.04088325798511505, -0.05603617802262306, 0.003959936089813709, -0.06760238856077194, -0.07963835448026657, -0.0011987213511019945, 0.014529761858284473, -0.018123241141438484, -0.003358457935974002, 0.028889093548059464, -0.04758572578430176, 0.027161279693245888, -0.05118005350232124, 0.018099868670105934, -0.06475459039211273, -0.03869938850402832, 0.035726211965084076, -0.053011804819107056, -0.018179621547460556, 0.02964779920876026, 0.020475143566727638, 0.04427219554781914, -0.002708766609430313, 0.06325183808803558, 0.015071740373969078, 0.035446230322122574, -0.017801035195589066, -0.022365976125001907, -0.005963027477264404, -0.013297312892973423, 0.022948255762457848, -0.05084747076034546, 0.01935582235455513, -0.022517574951052666, 0.015508739277720451, 0.022021330893039703, -0.028246380388736725, 0.007198139559477568, 0.031127361580729485, -0.014367876574397087, 0.00812552496790886, 0.06582291424274445, 0.05405181646347046, -0.021682139486074448, -0.03303200379014015, 0.10217628628015518, 0.030605623498558998, -0.03045005351305008, 0.0037921632174402475, 0.04477120190858841, -0.0062788380309939384, -0.06219368055462837, 0.03393932059407234, 0.02870679274201393, -0.014944517984986305, 0.05713064968585968, 0.049295928329229355, -0.006475994363427162, -0.0627472847700119, -0.02897070161998272, 0.005442940164357424, -0.02213636413216591, -0.037067148834466934, -0.04737214744091034, 0.027924004942178726, 0.049712128937244415, 0.005250427406281233, 0.040572747588157654, 0.02769642136991024, -0.012623691000044346, 0.018045708537101746, -0.07217571139335632, 0.004858272150158882, 0.014152688905596733, 0.0037138243205845356, 0.030329113826155663, -0.04836633801460266, 0.053726356476545334, 0.011076146736741066, 0.09263160079717636, 0.056391339749097824, 0.0147634856402874, -0.00569196930155158, 0.019355634227395058, 0.008022518828511238, -0.009914970956742764, -0.047561164945364, 0.016150373965501785, 0.017457537353038788, 0.03475422412157059, -0.04665612801909447, -0.0029603608418256044, -0.02395186759531498, -0.04600267484784126, 0.002458941889926791, -0.017254097387194633, 0.020244302228093147, 0.03518926724791527, 0.002550582168623805, -0.041768014430999756, -0.04259385168552399, -0.006720360368490219, 0.016996363177895546, -0.005591553170233965, 0.05454236641526222, 0.008430944755673409, 0.0014557979302480817, -0.004643858876079321, -0.04716353490948677, 0.03845168277621269, -0.03303443267941475, -0.024616675451397896, -0.03684338554739952, -0.061816681176424026, 0.022709621116518974, -0.00423824368044734, 0.004895529244095087, -0.010657825507223606, -0.012046962045133114, 0.026053879410028458, -0.029718676581978798, -0.03342249244451523, -0.028016552329063416, -0.03625768795609474, -0.010617485269904137, -0.012506932020187378, -0.006384200882166624, 0.002631580922752619, -0.07811392843723297, 0.06735537201166153, 0.06341981887817383, -0.019159050658345222, 0.02943328395485878, 0.05392574891448021, 0.04570634290575981, -0.02175803855061531, 0.039120905101299286, 0.049966491758823395, 0.008442039601504803, 0.05787959322333336, -0.001223627827130258, 0.01404500100761652, -0.034364450722932816, 0.04497933015227318, -0.08150043338537216, 0.005420612171292305, -0.02584403194487095, 0.04052557423710823, 0.003972699865698814, 0.011501947417855263, -0.03200630471110344, 0.02526795119047165, -0.023611199110746384, -0.03257676213979721, -0.06039174273610115, -0.022020971402525902, -0.014856807887554169, -0.02876010164618492, 0.026728391647338867, 0.0104367071762681, 0.012552706524729729, -0.0005245066713541746, -0.038095876574516296, -0.017024140805006027, 0.03195623680949211, 0.024958983063697815, -0.003839801764115691, -0.0043138423934578896, 0.009229845367372036, 0.04820989817380905, 0.0006445076433010399, 0.052645351737737656, -0.008837328292429447, 0.0016812292160466313, 0.051077909767627716, 0.020372044295072556, -0.008703818544745445, 0.015013967640697956, 0.01211612019687891, 0.04477712884545326, -0.03173874318599701, 0.002948749577626586, 0.0125488406047225, -0.06535173207521439, -0.045398786664009094, -0.01873653195798397, -0.005732641089707613, -0.00525594362989068, 0.010879972018301487, -0.00719990162178874, -0.049938224256038666, -0.0029830739367753267, 0.023730574175715446, 0.00613641832023859, 0.049192335456609726, -0.05370887741446495, -0.014993124641478062, 0.003238340374082327, 0.027960415929555893, -0.015048482455313206, -0.036438312381505966, 0.013183255679905415, -0.03255237266421318, -0.03310994803905487, 0.027440113946795464, 0.037219900637865067, 0.03752584382891655, -0.012729872949421406, 0.05233176425099373, -0.026351241394877434, -0.010994596406817436, 0.036535102874040604, -0.015544252470135689, -0.020993642508983612, 0.014562562108039856, 0.0038444881793111563, 0.028472168371081352, 0.07371949404478073, 0.029578564688563347, 0.00449274992570281, -0.0024466183967888355, -0.028675083070993423, 0.03984733298420906, -0.029137616977095604, 0.007926492020487785, 0.014891045168042183, 0.00033257168252021074, 0.011060871183872223, 0.00511024659499526, 0.0020461955573409796, 0.08147715777158737, -0.031179342418909073, 0.058726366609334946, 0.06017988547682762, -0.01623391918838024, -0.0007747670169919729, 0.01034401822835207, 0.001437680097296834, 0.017203446477651596, 0.0217010285705328, 0.008057435043156147, -0.06453100591897964, 0.06434747576713562, -0.04091320186853409, -0.027352502569556236, -0.06462632119655609, -0.0001601544936420396, 0.046818286180496216, 0.00470660999417305, 0.02464420534670353, 0.024527711793780327, 0.01864694245159626, -0.04263295605778694, 0.04966820776462555, -0.04759366065263748, 0.00809962023049593, -0.04593205079436302, 0.012426747009158134, 0.032645657658576965, -0.03370765596628189, 0.025278836488723755, 0.03583091124892235, 0.045985765755176544, -0.006972926203161478, -0.048946794122457504, -0.013150082901120186, -0.05289926379919052, 0.05966800078749657, 0.029957154765725136, 0.005301292520016432, 0.006090337876230478, -0.0013311257353052497, -0.0013052334543317556, -0.005677425768226385, -0.005212798248976469, -0.034762587398290634, 0.041200779378414154, 0.03610440343618393, 0.015119529329240322, -0.0852568969130516, -0.025165360420942307, -0.027542470023036003, -0.026697322726249695, 0.028485093265771866, 0.010349639691412449, -0.019061440601944923, -0.040545083582401276, 0.02359016425907612, 0.029087310656905174, 0.005487275775521994, 0.02223789691925049, -0.0680912658572197, -0.003918354399502277, 0.009034600108861923, 0.04513530433177948, -0.0347086563706398, -0.002919323742389679, 0.047110628336668015, -0.007429956458508968, -0.04435340315103531, -0.03037399984896183, -0.03681604564189911, -0.0516209751367569, -0.0393638052046299 ]
<p>I apologize if this kind of idle theorizing is frowned upon here, but I was wondering if it is possible that the Second Law of Thermodynamics is a consequence of quantum uncertainty. </p> <p>I've heard entropy of a system defined as the number of micro-states that it can have to correspond to the macro-states it has. So that definition makes it sound like entropy is simply losing information. As we know, entropy increases as time goes on. Now this seems contradictory to me; we know more as time goes on, not less.</p> <p>Is it possible that, because you can gain more and more information about a system as time goes on as you can interact with it more that, some information needs to be "hidden" from you. And that this process of losing information is entropy?</p> <p>P.S. I know that what I "know" about any system does not approach the limits set out by the uncertainty principle. But as System A interacts with System B, over time System A's state is more influenced by System B and in that sense System A has gained knowledge of System B.</p>
g5899
[ 0.022056544199585915, 0.018274955451488495, 0.0032845125533640385, 0.004067400470376015, 0.02410046197474003, -0.019404305145144463, -0.017821289598941803, -0.0012694364413619041, -0.03806483373045921, -0.009131068363785744, -0.014988631941378117, -0.01508435606956482, 0.005284938029944897, -0.005094566382467747, 0.012624183669686317, 0.0066264113411307335, 0.09163476526737213, 0.01287988480180502, 0.034849781543016434, 0.01380984764546156, 0.004898764193058014, 0.01671433448791504, -0.010883156210184097, -0.032097768038511276, -0.0441591702401638, 0.010629214346408844, 0.044284068048000336, 0.01394191849976778, -0.02097189426422119, 0.014446495100855827, -0.06531642377376556, -0.025670284405350685, 0.04072193428874016, -0.053302958607673645, 0.006035400088876486, -0.04039480537176132, 0.08475406467914581, -0.033884644508361816, 0.01967296376824379, -0.006349468138068914, -0.02835988439619541, -0.0031068262178450823, 0.0014651448000222445, 0.003625776618719101, -0.021182391792535782, 0.0045426893047988415, 0.00901152566075325, 0.048508234322071075, -0.03350980207324028, -0.058756131678819656, 0.022055769339203835, 0.018304137513041496, 0.0429062619805336, 0.04497348889708519, 0.04750903695821762, 0.012383024208247662, 0.04520251601934433, -0.03305382654070854, 0.05089709535241127, -0.028156466782093048, 0.02562733180820942, 0.027083007618784904, -0.005858319345861673, 0.035589687526226044, 0.0016254998045042157, -0.03355904668569565, -0.03478414937853813, -0.028220072388648987, 0.003726283321157098, 0.03956938907504082, 0.01398360263556242, 0.0034994003362953663, -0.02751704677939415, -0.03987406939268112, 0.037940092384815216, 0.058634236454963684, 0.03746936097741127, -0.014211275614798069, 0.011428561061620712, 0.03647909685969353, -0.06700284034013748, -0.04905565828084946, 0.03486885502934456, -0.028561802580952644, 0.04472023993730545, -0.027988247573375702, -0.0049086627550423145, -0.037978727370500565, -0.001611763029359281, 0.058489229530096054, -0.037082187831401825, -0.026011396199464798, 0.04688985273241997, 0.008501344360411167, 0.010031535290181637, 0.049333356320858, -0.018826810643076897, -0.015915581956505775, 0.015829620882868767, 0.05239218473434448, -0.04032037779688835, -0.035677842795848846, 0.007153479382395744, -0.028089504688978195, -0.021159065887331963, -0.04626641049981117, -0.009032957255840302, -0.05046333745121956, -0.028727762401103973, 0.043398503214120865, 0.01361578144133091, -0.00666251452639699, -0.034263405948877335, 0.004470461048185825, -0.010338745079934597, -0.01755754090845585, 0.07140342146158218, -0.010979576967656612, -0.023317493498325348, -0.043733883649110794, -0.009840469807386398, 0.01391589641571045, -0.010817249305546284, 0.028096795082092285, -0.0021736088674515486, 0.0320332869887352, -0.009517829865217209, -0.021274974569678307, 0.030192149803042412, -0.021635502576828003, -0.00868673250079155, 0.015514927916228771, -0.040611669421195984, 0.07809837907552719, -0.024873346090316772, 0.028658628463745117, -0.02666839212179184, 0.0030403994023799896, 0.001119008520618081, 0.02430533803999424, 0.023729076609015465, 0.01598740555346012, 0.03417828306555748, -0.01952597126364708, -0.028677068650722504, 0.009338988922536373, 0.0034806346520781517, -0.03565815091133118, 0.015623153187334538, -0.04645403102040291, -0.012293793261051178, 0.007959972135722637, 0.01411729957908392, -0.031109949573874474, 0.028750894591212273, 0.014450502581894398, 0.0002933590149041265, 0.011183606460690498, 0.006064339075237513, -0.02676541358232498, 0.027211150154471397, 0.03271811455488205, 0.05612831935286522, -0.02787267416715622, -0.02016073651611805, 0.0037634598556905985, 0.018235618248581886, -0.03213514760136604, -0.04540402814745903, -0.043903134763240814, -0.008183545432984829, -0.008362549357116222, -0.010680046863853931, 0.010024342685937881, -0.008127893321216106, 0.040982965379953384, -0.004531309474259615, -0.00250487239100039, 0.039862390607595444, -0.03372151404619217, -0.06829280406236649, 0.03774556517601013, 0.047132499516010284, -0.029913386330008507, 0.02891736477613449, 0.03595106676220894, 0.02847091108560562, 0.019864637404680252, -0.027169862762093544, -0.026590580120682716, -0.029710212722420692, -0.01905406452715397, -0.01972004771232605, 0.02911168336868286, 0.044125210493803024, 0.0013669676845893264, 0.04327886551618576, -0.006476904731243849, -0.03049454279243946, 0.03497948497533798, -0.0028161974623799324, -0.0006462744786404073, -0.02627098560333252, -0.04329419881105423, 0.008273148909211159, 0.05248545855283737, -0.023230617865920067, 0.024250898510217667, -0.011612105183303356, -0.03221095725893974, 0.061825331300497055, -0.05090756341814995, 0.02074657753109932, 0.0639108195900917, 0.04458213970065117, -0.07724171876907349, 0.05342641472816467, 0.023530157282948494, 0.07764044404029846, 0.024302974343299866, 0.05035904794931412, 0.026506870985031128, 0.08135773241519928, 0.032868921756744385, -0.003818055847659707, -0.001349260681308806, -0.048956651240587234, -0.030944988131523132, -0.0702286958694458, 0.06792248785495758, -0.005155931692570448, 0.021121099591255188, 0.03951641917228699, 0.011122186668217182, 0.001021017786115408, 0.08752594888210297, 0.045890726149082184, 0.0018097737338393927, 0.04336489737033844, 0.0362335741519928, 0.005343538708984852, -0.007677366957068443, -0.026721663773059845, 0.04739799723029137, 0.005824252963066101, -0.030248086899518967, 0.010657662525773048, -0.010411209426820278, 0.03423506021499634, -0.01876058429479599, 0.03359188884496689, 0.012678490951657295, -0.01824628934264183, -0.026211755350232124, -0.00008165876351995394, -0.007833702489733696, -0.005702887196093798, -0.0002982584701385349, -0.014510606415569782, -0.05668614059686661, 0.0562659353017807, -0.036729469895362854, -0.028931543231010437, 0.011089405044913292, 0.026206227019429207, 0.017955271527171135, -0.014690162613987923, 0.028541384264826775, -0.02082357183098793, -0.009715020656585693, -0.02444862574338913, 0.039962317794561386, -0.0487092025578022, 0.04102884605526924, 0.015547435730695724, 0.008191035129129887, 0.013797829858958721, -0.02087445743381977, -0.010843402706086636, -0.037071194499731064, -0.06383218616247177, 0.04729249328374863, -0.08147502690553665, 0.04996784031391144, 0.033820848912000656, -0.03662674501538277, -0.020537063479423523, 0.008717048913240433, 0.038768209517002106, -0.007515964098274708, 0.004109518136829138, 0.04015904664993286, 0.047891587018966675, 0.061071522533893585, -0.0945102795958519, 0.014698294922709465, -0.020836014300584793, -0.03813629969954491, -0.008218935690820217, 0.025606375187635422, -0.00392903620377183, 0.0013114846078678966, -0.015738599002361298, -0.020782165229320526, 0.026145465672016144, 0.0333770215511322, -0.1204274520277977, -0.051959484815597534, 0.03437156230211258, 0.0018026133766397834, -0.06218137964606285, 0.0293748639523983, -0.019014354795217514, 0.007927507162094116, -0.030227435752749443, 0.02532881498336792, -0.04093804210424423, 0.028105946257710457, 0.017627382650971413, 0.021870234981179237, 0.00482007022947073, -0.025924254208803177, 0.021275123581290245, -0.020094120875000954, 0.0761433094739914, -0.012426206842064857, -0.07517123967409134, -0.03058663010597229, -0.05678151175379753, -0.02714400365948677, 0.0071894037537276745, -0.07887333631515503, -0.011665537022054195, -0.015198078006505966, -0.0397622287273407, -0.0171815138310194, -0.025846419855952263, -0.023240268230438232, -0.027346452698111534, 0.04014003649353981, 0.02282005362212658, 0.007328046951442957, -0.04544016718864441, 0.04749264568090439, 0.0052031404338777065, 0.01253334991633892, -0.04033007472753525, -0.0224966611713171, -0.024610476568341255, -0.005968065932393074, 0.07439278066158295, -0.018445122987031937, 0.0025066290982067585, 0.040935225784778595, -0.04900065064430237, 0.09284770488739014, 0.03146163374185562, -0.023288259282708168, 0.010058708488941193, -0.03351861611008644, -0.1069394201040268, -0.09025995433330536, 0.057391878217458725, -0.008175033144652843, 0.01874941773712635, 0.05676591768860817, -0.014847302809357643, 0.025530729442834854, 0.028166189789772034, -0.019861947745084763, -0.01169248390942812, -0.017471104860305786, -0.014973480254411697, 0.018660087138414383, 0.027979349717497826, -0.011152896098792553, 0.09505442529916763, 0.009840746410191059, -0.022618325427174568, 0.03883001208305359, 0.02978130243718624, 0.02211819961667061, 0.015084975399076939, 0.005375197622925043, 0.06498996913433075, -0.02166368067264557, -0.004587580915540457, -0.014827042818069458, 0.001748770009726286, -0.044698555022478104, -0.0378851480782032, -0.006801872979849577, 0.007005457300692797, 0.020832326263189316, 0.025426851585507393, 0.005382470320910215, -0.00775636313483119, -0.012618637643754482, 0.03730860352516174, -0.0004384634376037866, 0.024974117055535316, 0.015424059703946114, -0.0058730063028633595, 0.017576275393366814, 0.0161289032548666, -0.028468934819102287, 0.013233987614512444, -0.003334615845233202, -0.003630445571616292, -0.04707266017794609, -0.02969242073595524, -0.01878795213997364, -0.011610226705670357, -0.02191678062081337, -0.032549288123846054, 0.016454696655273438, -0.014862831681966782, -0.12031286209821701, 0.020893028005957603, 0.07672122120857239, -0.015506851486861706, 0.002266579307615757, 0.0067419023253023624, 0.026682887226343155, -0.07421567291021347, -0.026410093531012535, 0.047742296010255814, -0.04817042127251625, -0.02469947375357151, -0.09245560318231583, 0.0278240367770195, 0.017844747751951218, -0.006788956932723522, 0.011013295501470566, -0.03018518164753914, 0.004195734858512878, -0.038034748286008835, 0.0038782479241490364, -0.03810330852866173, 0.02629907988011837, 0.0011482997797429562, -0.015202606096863747, 0.008955265395343304, 0.011126261204481125, -0.01872306875884533, 0.005460244603455067, 0.0346953347325325, 0.00896207895129919, 0.01557275652885437, -0.007724760100245476, -0.05538063123822212, 0.028231890872120857, 0.020654331892728806, -0.035205334424972534, -0.010762489400804043, 0.0031167531851679087, -0.105641670525074, 0.03502851724624634, -0.00963643193244934, 0.027693437412381172, -0.037385180592536926, -0.026352904736995697, 0.03635891526937485, 0.03724215179681778, 0.02239193581044674, -0.05302094668149948, -0.04644531384110451, 0.031639572232961655, -0.06098726764321327, -0.0046814605593681335, 0.011937598697841167, 0.038707371801137924, 0.024150105193257332, 0.030737774446606636, -0.012251893989741802, -0.061038538813591, 0.010328211821615696, 0.03275178745388985, 0.0627453625202179, 0.011424004100263119, -0.024888763204216957, 0.04562010243535042, 0.03231387212872505, 0.06184292957186699, 0.03812097758054733, -0.0317331925034523, 0.027607906609773636, 0.05193467065691948, 0.01050056703388691, -0.023302389308810234, 0.027381906285881996, 0.07560943812131882, 0.05154958739876747, 0.03710136190056801, -0.06070850044488907, 0.0027851269114762545, 0.01595989242196083, -0.03523729741573334, -0.030283549800515175, -0.0052136923186481, -0.0653730258345604, 0.014451512135565281, 0.03436365723609924, 0.01362922228872776, -0.036236703395843506, -0.017390260472893715, 0.01112519484013319, -0.032288167625665665, -0.05007566139101982, 0.02771442010998726, -0.025131650269031525, 0.02692835032939911, -0.054978616535663605, 0.004309331998229027, 0.0437389612197876, -0.004348570480942726, -0.06060609966516495, -0.0015056886477395892, 0.000455394183518365, -0.034064196050167084, 0.038451340049505234, 0.014809914864599705, 0.024715472012758255, -0.013072808273136616, -0.03723796084523201, 0.02486979030072689, -0.033829621970653534, 0.041449885815382004, 0.01036252360790968, 0.03469589725136757, 0.06286679208278656, 0.04504908248782158, -0.0027683067601174116, -0.013212586753070354, 0.011960592120885849, 0.021961882710456848, -0.014582589268684387, 0.031780824065208435, -0.007617024704813957, 0.08218327164649963, 0.018152320757508278, -0.04682062938809395, -0.016744134947657585, 0.055092595517635345, 0.07999910414218903, -0.05916351452469826, -0.006048398092389107, -0.03724968433380127, 0.03599681705236435, -0.013298307545483112, -0.005218250676989555, -0.01338791660964489, -0.020243601873517036, 0.028316056355834007, -0.05621115118265152, 0.011156152933835983, 0.05068107321858406, 0.06528601050376892, 0.008810190483927727, 0.059260666370391846, -0.005432981997728348, 0.06475230306386948, 0.013622116297483444, 0.02907726541161537, -0.0012108518276363611, -0.03804947808384895, 0.03324975445866585, 0.000021467414626386017, 0.011207475326955318, 0.10429275035858154, 0.04521362856030464, 0.05268969386816025, 0.02703838050365448, 0.015542230568826199, 0.029281387105584145, 0.035004254430532455, -0.057369306683540344, -0.07104791700839996, -0.0297893937677145, -0.025374596938490868, -0.07318989187479019, -0.024936240166425705, -0.00012817926472052932, -0.03151439130306244, 0.03677261620759964, 0.08727536350488663, -0.0070718335919082165, 0.026216337457299232, 0.01725100353360176, 0.043846823275089264, -0.018666284158825874, -0.03864981606602669, -0.016796773299574852, 0.002909198636189103, -0.06023525446653366, -0.005475720856338739, -0.04994310811161995, -0.02980988100171089, -0.019522609189152718, 0.054484087973833084, -0.06282644718885422, -0.0640067607164383, 0.0603053942322731, -0.07266569137573242, -0.03370892256498337, 0.06416601687669754, -0.026445690542459488, 0.01762561872601509, 0.02822073921561241, 0.0009408463956788182, -0.05039190873503685, -0.0347524993121624, 0.008417723700404167, 0.01106330007314682, 0.036939628422260284, -0.0071729980409145355, -0.02744772657752037, 0.0207329411059618, -0.10638836026191711, 0.021167397499084473, 0.026597699150443077, 0.017924172803759575, -0.0350688099861145, -0.014622321352362633, 0.012914025224745274, 0.018662767484784126, -0.019396472722291946, 0.015814241021871567, 0.052155934274196625, 0.06089053675532341, 0.0062124342657625675, -0.030334247276186943, 0.0621844157576561, 0.024079149588942528, -0.023341774940490723, -0.03594794496893883, -0.03385617956519127, -0.007213435601443052, 0.040042001754045486, -0.009347614832222462, -0.007508513983339071, -0.05262437090277672, 0.0015676217153668404, 0.013597136363387108, -0.013512123376131058, 0.026988303288817406, 0.040460750460624695, 0.009930898435413837, -0.045254338532686234, -0.015914656221866608, 0.016308121383190155, -0.012005320750176907, -0.08401982486248016, -0.01685570552945137, -0.0035666748881340027, 0.08213205635547638, -0.06004958972334862, -0.03359057754278183, 0.005917592439800501, -0.02974987030029297, -0.012183252722024918, -0.011631723493337631, -0.007511669769883156, -0.013372570276260376, 0.018579425290226936, 0.06608294695615768, 0.03838985785841942, -0.09367374330759048, -0.02617829665541649, -0.06425222754478455, -0.005690237507224083, -0.06384982168674469, -0.020669125020503998, -0.019127132371068, -0.0034993491135537624, -0.0013349733781069517, 0.009801729582250118, 0.010424465872347355, 0.017311042174696922, 0.018041903153061867, -0.010781105607748032, -0.06611204892396927, 0.06700415164232254, 0.0027349144220352173, -0.01074951235204935, 0.0568767786026001, -0.04503776878118515, 0.013089360669255257, -0.08516767621040344, -0.03657747432589531, -0.036645129323005676, -0.08986566960811615, -0.06233428046107292, -0.015470024198293686, -0.00598325626924634, 0.03442215174436569, 0.0879664346575737, 0.020317288115620613, -0.0051301755011081696, -0.05225034058094025, -0.012678652070462704, 0.016586052253842354, -0.01246800646185875, -0.017085988074541092, 0.023654989898204803, -0.012371650896966457, 0.018232282251119614, -0.014667287468910217, -0.031300224363803864, 0.020649094134569168, 0.029713312163949013, -0.042131390422582626, 0.011023893021047115, -0.02674265019595623, -0.02330494113266468, -0.03508345037698746, 0.0017490347381681204, -0.05215921252965927, 0.0003504842461552471, -0.012570351362228394, -0.054527174681425095, 0.0044060880318284035, -0.04088651016354561, -0.038968276232481, -0.009382515214383602, -0.027580520138144493, 0.019558019936084747, -0.0019617083016783, -0.04049169272184372, 0.01609502173960209, -0.02399805188179016, 0.041257936507463455, 0.0012299291556701064, -0.02871794067323208, -0.00493221590295434, 0.08112815022468567, 0.042349185794591904, 0.009180285036563873, -0.016828628256917, -0.055210791528224945, 0.03356132656335831, -0.04153258726000786, 0.07406585663557053, -0.03268473595380783, 0.04193872958421707, -0.06946445256471634, -0.037422504276037216, -0.036114972084760666, 0.036492034792900085, -0.00920658279210329, -0.011995270848274231, -0.03891871124505997, 0.01912742480635643, -0.01432411465793848, 0.052372656762599945, 0.02702023833990097, 0.017049768939614296, 0.011403988115489483, -0.03156432881951332, 0.05659205839037895, -0.00934242270886898, 0.022386174649000168, -0.035730283707380295, 0.010893180966377258, -0.030679110437631607, -0.015173522755503654, 0.016489960253238678, 0.029215514659881592 ]
<p>It occurred to me in passing that the Lorentz contraction of a black hole from the perspective of an ultra-relativistic (Lorentz factor larger than about 10^16) particle could reduce the thickness of a black hole to less than the DeBroglie wavelength of the particle.</p> <p>It would seem to me that under those conditions the particle would have a non-insignificant probability of tunnelling right through the black hole rather than being adsorbed by it. </p> <p>Is this so? If not, why?</p>
g5900
[ 0.009725229814648628, 0.04024379327893257, 0.02438218705356121, 0.018630361184477806, 0.02825598418712616, 0.039553236216306686, 0.03114243410527706, 0.06227241829037666, -0.02481449581682682, 0.01987154223024845, 0.036406926810741425, 0.013511386699974537, 0.0046374197117984295, -0.027872776612639427, -0.04340147599577904, 0.022935833781957626, 0.024912241846323013, -0.061243947595357895, 0.0002816480409819633, -0.010876034386456013, -0.013687454164028168, -0.029247384518384933, 0.04772472754120827, -0.0723465234041214, -0.03945969045162201, -0.003632292617112398, 0.029636278748512268, -0.021671731024980545, -0.06649921834468842, -0.018361171707510948, 0.035833586007356644, -0.0005316732567735016, -0.03763283044099808, -0.01986284740269184, 0.013600251637399197, -0.04064024239778519, 0.03028987906873226, 0.0378383994102478, -0.017923370003700256, -0.010010856203734875, 0.04872320964932442, -0.003382829250767827, -0.01806076057255268, -0.04344291612505913, -0.011604240164160728, -0.06338894367218018, 0.03430840000510216, 0.021358098834753036, 0.011817239224910736, 0.012406818568706512, -0.02324347198009491, -0.009415180422365665, 0.001315548550337553, -0.0027777894865721464, -0.003835085779428482, 0.010493303649127483, 0.02945551648736, 0.05343154817819595, -0.032530028373003006, 0.09506785124540329, -0.014287966303527355, -0.002755986526608467, 0.05037644878029823, 0.025278495624661446, -0.021087031811475754, 0.005546396132558584, -0.029530661180615425, 0.009513436816632748, -0.031185412779450417, -0.008500874973833561, -0.02185090072453022, -0.03645588085055351, -0.022318214178085327, -0.0026104901917278767, -0.009652728214859962, 0.03086072765290737, -0.07024586200714111, 0.05138278752565384, -0.005338767077773809, -0.02545568160712719, -0.11035922169685364, -0.01354028470814228, -0.03776107355952263, -0.025216763839125633, 0.10501090437173843, 0.010136378929018974, -0.01340764481574297, -0.00460946187376976, -0.017034778371453285, 0.025432633236050606, 0.01416611485183239, -0.05141867324709892, 0.04820527508854866, 0.038334887474775314, -0.001798812998458743, -0.008604591712355614, -0.019177252426743507, 0.00920325331389904, -0.05104033276438713, -0.005606102291494608, -0.002475966466590762, 0.0259683970361948, -0.021263521164655685, 0.027789641171693802, 0.004640883766114712, -0.012748485431075096, -0.05225363001227379, 0.03553779050707817, 0.02778218872845173, 0.043723512440919876, -0.02654140442609787, -0.08541549742221832, 0.02229095622897148, -0.02660537324845791, -0.012632141821086407, 0.018782801926136017, 0.03581348806619644, 0.010863916017115116, 0.008195698261260986, 0.03693658486008644, 0.03443223610520363, 0.0784049853682518, 0.005881684832274914, -0.010480772703886032, -0.002611032221466303, -0.004945308901369572, -0.044460803270339966, 0.03252316638827324, -0.005201536696404219, -0.006322680506855249, 0.05213732644915581, 0.0617307685315609, -0.0043356227688491344, 0.05541586875915527, -0.039670735597610474, 0.027788320556282997, 0.056464627385139465, 0.013217215426266193, -0.052096493542194366, 0.021975865587592125, 0.023403726518154144, 0.01228385604918003, 0.10034942626953125, 0.060244545340538025, -0.03454868867993355, -0.0010036173043772578, -0.020573340356349945, -0.015768755227327347, 0.019187046214938164, 0.005200601182878017, -0.03622116148471832, 0.05162321776151657, 0.012938931584358215, 0.005502664018422365, -0.01830926164984703, 0.0332588367164135, 0.039522938430309296, 0.03418822959065437, 0.03294096514582634, 0.04307632893323898, 0.0346638560295105, -0.015324701555073261, -0.008447625674307346, 0.03159980848431587, -0.06036660820245743, 0.008498197421431541, 0.015754008665680885, 0.0017802863148972392, 0.018006110563874245, -0.02329513058066368, -0.005561204627156258, 0.004535602405667305, -0.0027678071055561304, 0.09499167650938034, 0.013788415119051933, 0.04908163473010063, 0.03544043377041817, -0.020834829658269882, -0.04363640397787094, -0.039258647710084915, -0.001270763110369444, 0.0013746725162491202, 0.00473219295963645, -0.01813649572432041, 0.0012148070381954312, -0.038251135498285294, 0.04621903970837593, 0.008087441325187683, -0.05451274290680885, 0.030914921313524246, -0.055789828300476074, -0.03472605347633362, 0.05007024109363556, 0.018365753814578056, -0.051788926124572754, -0.007462824694812298, 0.043431077152490616, -0.011044727638363838, 0.01301372330635786, 0.05442271754145622, -0.07184840738773346, 0.03008187934756279, 0.01813810132443905, -0.02672526426613331, 0.07316204160451889, -0.051143091171979904, -0.02037421241402626, 0.05779585242271423, 0.002677229233086109, 0.0037492746487259865, 0.0470615029335022, 0.004268738441169262, 0.01043589785695076, -0.020578941330313683, -0.030848737806081772, 0.024724580347537994, 0.004293555859476328, 0.00400678301230073, -0.013864855282008648, 0.05546645447611809, -0.04032905027270317, -0.008166838437318802, 0.04486875608563423, 0.00571410870179534, -0.012000076472759247, -0.005549007561057806, -0.05784108117222786, 0.0030511729419231415, 0.014294533059000969, 0.05542421713471413, -0.023173488676548004, 0.009492743760347366, -0.01302412711083889, 0.016102809458971024, 0.011185966432094574, 0.015068638138473034, 0.007081964518874884, 0.0026461011730134487, -0.02518075704574585, -0.03612932935357094, 0.045555707067251205, -0.032350391149520874, -0.05545458942651749, -0.01468823291361332, 0.07124989479780197, 0.01324334554374218, -0.05941658094525337, -0.023374054580926895, -0.02614394761621952, -0.006595712620764971, 0.03570791706442833, -0.05700698122382164, 0.013031695038080215, -0.014009627513587475, 0.0031297917012125254, 0.018782973289489746, -0.030308125540614128, 0.05301648750901222, -0.04337521642446518, -0.0684974193572998, -0.0009873281233012676, 0.04272068664431572, 0.05165409669280052, 0.015578835271298885, -0.028254026547074318, 0.002956679556518793, -0.06271416693925858, 0.03603769838809967, 0.04806675389409065, 0.049832217395305634, 0.03245536983013153, 0.02725330740213394, 0.001650998368859291, -0.004799902439117432, 0.04740167781710625, 0.008748871274292469, -0.030036356300115585, -0.006982753053307533, 0.015312888659536839, -0.01124971080571413, -0.04289920628070831, 0.05381017178297043, -0.05459291860461235, -0.007039210293442011, 0.00955144502222538, -0.08338534832000732, -0.03004293330013752, -0.007396263536065817, -0.030156217515468597, -0.008807403035461903, 0.020824935287237167, 0.02969864197075367, 0.05243074148893356, 0.05988519638776779, 0.04236738756299019, 0.01564250886440277, 0.010394509881734848, -0.023899607360363007, -0.08097854256629944, 0.03564523160457611, -0.0023180798161774874, -0.012463358230888844, -0.008106868714094162, -0.004405607469379902, 0.003224559361115098, 0.02221960946917534, -0.04657658562064171, -0.001751803094521165, -0.01906537264585495, -0.03275104612112045, -0.03050960600376129, 0.05517317354679108, 0.044033002108335495, 0.057064175605773926, -0.028725365176796913, -0.0712508037686348, 0.006340654566884041, -0.005367869045585394, 0.03423185274004936, 0.032867904752492905, 0.03794931247830391, 0.005792378913611174, 0.00513501837849617, -0.009313835762441158, 0.03145980089902878, 0.01946372352540493, -0.035647857934236526, -0.013538667932152748, -0.05312863364815712, 0.039790499955415726, 0.0009118099696934223, -0.03301488235592842, -0.00360074732452631, 0.06168945133686066, 0.004079840146005154, -0.006545375566929579, -0.044875774532556534, 0.02183857373893261, 0.03632115200161934, -0.009739101864397526, -0.004308152478188276, -0.01944807916879654, -0.03645341098308563, 0.052958894520998, -0.0011510815238580108, 0.04957025870680809, 0.018412016332149506, -0.017642483115196228, -0.019609270617365837, 0.028270535171031952, 0.001641395385377109, -0.03018713742494583, 0.02964026667177677, -0.01374873798340559, 0.0366712361574173, -0.040800660848617554, 0.01700914278626442, 0.047115352004766464, 0.0733102411031723, -0.006963367108255625, 0.017237231135368347, -0.031422656029462814, 0.00535807479172945, -0.016011565923690796, -0.05028313398361206, 0.02109251543879509, 0.023399872705340385, -0.025800462812185287, 0.03170796483755112, 0.05248717591166496, -0.04634416103363037, 0.03183455392718315, -0.014990810304880142, 0.0998087152838707, -0.032654911279678345, 0.002277352847158909, 0.07364221662282944, -0.012631532736122608, 0.028574351221323013, -0.04306374862790108, -0.019873041659593582, 0.02984001301229, 0.0163495521992445, -0.020035872235894203, -0.03414289653301239, -0.03107626736164093, -0.03823157772421837, -0.05274989828467369, -0.026605138555169106, -0.031297363340854645, -0.06679835170507431, 0.03152813762426376, 0.007848205044865608, -0.0381135530769825, -0.03448927402496338, -0.0226373840123415, 0.045501433312892914, -0.06012960150837898, 0.03706986829638481, -0.018264854326844215, -0.012402773834764957, 0.06481412053108215, -0.010782955214381218, 0.0008447730797342956, 0.019622409716248512, 0.00033963206806220114, 0.011539420112967491, 0.032064978033304214, -0.01247994415462017, 0.01983668841421604, -0.029934119433164597, -0.026411160826683044, -0.057761263102293015, 0.003875639056786895, -0.01282345037907362, -0.014573370106518269, 0.0029165095183998346, 0.013506175018846989, -0.04671084135770798, -0.008527977392077446, 0.056203898042440414, 0.007436262909322977, 0.0859735906124115, 0.028094692155718803, -0.030005337670445442, 0.005639363545924425, -0.022360745817422867, 0.05977455899119377, -0.02423686347901821, 0.021803803741931915, 0.02648346684873104, 0.025378214195370674, -0.04872546344995499, -0.04080263152718544, -0.05422960966825485, 0.05090896785259247, -0.04792727902531624, 0.03530202433466911, 0.046651441603899, 0.0688154324889183, 0.022533033043146133, -0.05864454060792923, 0.04149888455867767, -0.020875927060842514, -0.02035476267337799, 0.0066688042134046555, -0.01112479530274868, -0.017637668177485466, -0.05036493018269539, -0.038665808737277985, 0.017682639881968498, -0.0151454396545887, -0.02064741589128971, -0.0633135586977005, -0.019296500831842422, -0.031218675896525383, -0.038841888308525085, 0.07107307016849518, 0.08522280305624008, 0.044173624366521835, -0.07268451154232025, 0.04947880282998085, 0.05847712978720665, 0.04622359201312065, -0.030263852328062057, -0.057665422558784485, -0.029662273824214935, 0.021376073360443115, -0.061879076063632965, 0.046117112040519714, -0.016550766304135323, 0.03645366057753563, 0.010637429542839527, 0.05092788115143776, -0.046128664165735245, 0.024784818291664124, -0.024250714108347893, -0.002929521258920431, -0.03522065281867981, -0.051360104233026505, -0.004096842836588621, -0.028863584622740746, 0.027891594916582108, -0.03099491447210312, -0.03785401210188866, 0.08559038490056992, -0.06769975274801254, 0.07342040538787842, -0.032128192484378815, -0.008384548127651215, 0.02206285484135151, -0.017640139907598495, 0.01566862128674984, 0.04833173379302025, -0.012660535052418709, -0.06948338449001312, 0.04309077188372612, 0.006908483803272247, 0.0006506268982775509, 0.010839422233402729, -0.04532545059919357, -0.030388839542865753, 0.03479868173599243, 0.03184274956583977, -0.041367314755916595, 0.0303652361035347, 0.0004991309251636267, 0.019671691581606865, -0.001275877351872623, 0.04029957950115204, -0.014325771480798721, 0.020349986851215363, -0.0010248308535665274, -0.030230849981307983, 0.059111010283231735, -0.004366545006632805, 0.010925394482910633, 0.032538965344429016, 0.028448214754462242, -0.02187848463654518, -0.01333843544125557, 0.005782808177173138, -0.005847604013979435, 0.018713809549808502, 0.016622694209218025, -0.016942046582698822, -0.04082125425338745, -0.005676406901329756, -0.00853885617107153, -0.02561533823609352, 0.05951137840747833, -0.031376175582408905, 0.04402904957532883, 0.022268135100603104, 0.044762954115867615, -0.0016479898476973176, 0.056205425411462784, -0.015717238187789917, -0.014342893846333027, 0.007006419822573662, 0.012883400544524193, -0.06597921997308731, 0.027175696566700935, 0.09435205906629562, 0.0006997989257797599, 0.019451646134257317, -0.05906234309077263, 0.021221673116087914, 0.019809002056717873, -0.03851206600666046, -0.054088298231363297, -0.04576367512345314, -0.03698261082172394, 0.0011797229526564479, -0.06367679685354233, 0.017305094748735428, 0.04880459979176521, 0.0008796440670266747, -0.022375302389264107, -0.06321301311254501, 0.0606866180896759, -0.033384811133146286, 0.01689067855477333, -0.009915139526128769, 0.003223226871341467, -0.02585878223180771, -0.03595501184463501, -0.04500267654657364, 0.06137241795659065, 0.006005314644426107, -0.07353521138429642, 0.056264158338308334, 0.014713048003613949, 0.03844873607158661, -0.01388904545456171, 0.02362983487546444, 0.01623784750699997, 0.018967915326356888, -0.025197185575962067, -0.008300906047224998, -0.001021702541038394, -0.00813821516931057, 0.01543702743947506, -0.060495346784591675, -0.028744809329509735, -0.013313394039869308, -0.03441432863473892, 0.03759486973285675, 0.02610320970416069, 0.024527573958039284, -0.005333354696631432, -0.04596881940960884, -0.007260398473590612, -0.05331568792462349, -0.06488116830587387, -0.004425885621458292, -0.002705558203160763, -0.07794492691755295, -0.05180884525179863, 0.03616628050804138, 0.01752576231956482, 0.006571611389517784, 0.018944531679153442, 0.02204059064388275, 0.0287067499011755, 0.019728884100914, -0.046562496572732925, 0.009589584544301033, -0.009316480718553066, 0.013206830248236656, 0.008551807142794132, 0.04890996590256691, -0.03453562408685684, -0.01513472106307745, -0.03797435387969017, -0.04592452198266983, -0.04369204863905907, 0.028003856539726257, 0.058445680886507034, -0.04814935848116875, 0.018032029271125793, 0.02081749401986599, -0.054563503712415695, -0.025017503648996353, 0.019869795069098473, 0.011291058734059334, -0.009003625251352787, 0.023629596456885338, 0.01296260952949524, 0.05351043865084648, 0.03778642788529396, 0.0065792016685009, -0.003573188092559576, 0.014291451312601566, 0.042462415993213654, 0.032212164252996445, -0.02387356013059616, -0.005982872098684311, 0.020223522558808327, 0.018397100269794464, -0.042270176112651825, -0.053033169358968735, 0.05925445631146431, 0.009608534164726734, -0.03383457660675049, 0.0019349760841578245, 0.0008431095047853887, 0.03753003850579262, -0.07501877099275589, 0.018750127404928207, 0.033486876636743546, 0.012696530669927597, -0.0230239350348711, 0.003849966684356332, -0.045039061456918716, -0.018138447776436806, -0.05572517216205597, 0.05402747169137001, -0.02615613490343094, -0.06157960742712021, -0.013827956281602383, -0.05967828258872032, -0.033023133873939514, -0.06615037471055984, 0.035169683396816254, 0.0746651291847229, -0.022839505225419998, 0.016063513234257698, -0.02191060036420822, -0.05602124333381653, -0.015119951218366623, -0.0770774781703949, -0.03751475363969803, -0.03210192918777466, -0.030027901753783226, -0.0760873556137085, 0.010544762015342712, 0.020344462245702744, -0.05825522541999817, 0.022671915590763092, 0.04464339837431908, 0.040011584758758545, 0.024478036910295486, 0.032521601766347885, -0.03796285018324852, 0.0070339106023311615, -0.007315656170248985, -0.001060830312781036, 0.022785896435379982, -0.009891239926218987, -0.022941043600440025, -0.007492625154554844, 0.01735452003777027, -0.0013537114718928933, 0.0026679057627916336, -0.034814611077308655, 0.02586277760565281, 0.04110013321042061, 0.03459741920232773, -0.028320878744125366, -0.04944266751408577, 0.021673550829291344, -0.03648628294467926, -0.024658896028995514, 0.05049512907862663, 0.0812569111585617, -0.061488088220357895, 0.01608174480497837, -0.06006518378853798, -0.03708840161561966, 0.03377879038453102, -0.017730718478560448, 0.00772271491587162, 0.013428443111479282, -0.005191828589886427, -0.09726250916719437, 0.022169990465044975, -0.01788361929357052, 0.0020173732191324234, -0.04560525342822075, -0.006339112762361765, 0.03960263356566429, 0.01937468908727169, -0.03351052105426788, -0.026292085647583008, -0.05466241389513016, 0.0010463377693668008, -0.004849729128181934, -0.06634590029716492, 0.009255685843527317, 0.029552757740020752, -0.02161562629044056, -0.09368565678596497, -0.03512025251984596, -0.02793332375586033, 0.02814282663166523, -0.03591659665107727, 0.02460668236017227, -0.01955425553023815, 0.024469688534736633, -0.01374632865190506, 0.023132814094424248, -0.0029826173558831215, 0.010511870495975018, -0.006953125819563866, 0.021767478436231613, -0.019031502306461334, -0.036027926951646805, 0.044325582683086395, 0.05558149889111519, 0.012210650369524956, 0.062376659363508224, 0.004649744834750891, 0.06603676080703735, 0.033722810447216034, -0.06793969869613647, -0.04468356445431709, -0.019480694085359573, -0.04283301159739494, -0.00552443228662014, 0.008489645086228848, -0.007561143022030592, -0.040635932236909866, -0.05675807595252991, 0.0006773851928301156, 0.018194856122136116, 0.030721988528966904, 0.07143111526966095 ]
<p>Page 580, Chapter 12 in Jackson's 3rd edition text carries the statement:</p> <blockquote> <p>From the first postulate of special relativity the action integral must be a Lorentz scalar because the equations of motion are determined by the extemum condition, $\delta A = 0$</p> </blockquote> <p>Certainly the extremeum condition must be an invariant for the equation of motion between $t_1$ and $t_2$, whereas I don't see how the action integral must be a Lorentz scalar. Using basic classical mechanics as a guide, the action for a free particle isn't a Galilean scalar but still gives the correct equations of motion. </p>
g5901
[ 0.0732245221734047, 0.03554636985063553, -0.02108500711619854, 0.04380276799201965, 0.00998337846249342, 0.025981184095144272, 0.06599970906972885, 0.045490290969610214, -0.007397834677249193, 0.03709334135055542, -0.02751166746020317, 0.03578926622867584, -0.014967873692512512, -0.007702624890953302, -0.04585835710167885, -0.03171233832836151, 0.10376859456300735, -0.016171691939234734, -0.020825818181037903, 0.013975544832646847, 0.017892658710479736, 0.038834329694509506, -0.025579459965229034, -0.012128360569477081, 0.0413663312792778, 0.02466134913265705, 0.058776941150426865, -0.05362291634082794, -0.06275182962417603, -0.04108959063887596, 0.044667843729257584, 0.016203580424189568, 0.026356397196650505, -0.010463814251124859, 0.02386898547410965, -0.10148129612207413, 0.06471376866102219, 0.025166120380163193, 0.0021187246311455965, -0.02042711339890957, -0.037633996456861496, 0.01122551690787077, -0.012394511140882969, -0.004046988673508167, 0.020583301782608032, -0.01939854398369789, 0.04432697594165802, 0.010817453265190125, -0.007666120305657387, 0.02376309037208557, 0.0063689881935715675, 0.0032484757248312235, -0.006743189878761768, -0.015986815094947815, -0.03722747415304184, 0.05749380961060524, 0.020288849249482155, 0.018877403810620308, 0.012434710748493671, 0.029346922412514687, 0.010520795360207558, -0.030214963480830193, 0.04016050696372986, -0.004405230283737183, 0.04520409554243088, 0.005315144080668688, -0.0867094174027443, -0.02114221453666687, -0.03270329162478447, -0.025843486189842224, 0.05364310368895531, -0.015222783200442791, -0.006567054428160191, 0.015845060348510742, -0.0238790325820446, 0.014726722612977028, 0.04518498107790947, -0.00018753013864625245, -0.012254803441464901, -0.012929722666740417, -0.06571190059185028, -0.03607650846242905, 0.06918046623468399, -0.014344765804708004, 0.05791490897536278, 0.008970841765403748, -0.02579680271446705, -0.03981158509850502, -0.017306316643953323, -0.007264834363013506, 0.05957191064953804, -0.04744158312678337, 0.056144487112760544, 0.038060132414102554, 0.008405896835029125, -0.02350226417183876, 0.025719089433550835, 0.027171308174729347, 0.014159748330712318, -0.03926653042435646, -0.026571383699774742, 0.045540183782577515, 0.00939123798161745, -0.0006168808322399855, -0.011731518432497978, -0.08930544555187225, 0.06854327023029327, 0.00018941110465675592, 0.004064606502652168, -0.016283554956316948, 0.001290771528147161, -0.004235731903463602, 0.031234394758939743, -0.05662289634346962, -0.03418964147567749, 0.0332673005759716, 0.08774548023939133, -0.007166787050664425, 0.0061552077531814575, 0.03691545128822327, -0.0023200013674795628, 0.056097760796546936, -0.0193542018532753, 0.042987361550331116, -0.0700150653719902, 0.011634314432740211, 0.01833360083401203, -0.004962272476404905, -0.01792207732796669, -0.01895323023200035, -0.00365822552703321, 0.04139916971325874, 0.03272271528840065, 0.008651955053210258, -0.0406319722533226, 0.03149918466806412, 0.010078096762299538, -0.051125094294548035, -0.05544452741742134, -0.02686183527112007, 0.002448802813887596, 0.01354941911995411, 0.013255487196147442, -0.012406649067997932, -0.008835121057927608, 0.020902439951896667, -0.0077111381106078625, -0.03362605720758438, -0.007606548257172108, -0.020697996020317078, 0.01851990818977356, 0.06464660167694092, 0.004397878888994455, 0.036173395812511444, 0.010392727330327034, -0.043139904737472534, 0.016842681914567947, 0.02808583900332451, -0.008607335388660431, -0.008593365550041199, 0.07624834030866623, -0.0017791070276871324, 0.05871574953198433, -0.0053198207169771194, -0.08110950142145157, -0.00981080811470747, -0.0060964105650782585, -0.03687728941440582, -0.0020698008593171835, -0.05469147115945816, -0.05077240988612175, -0.04003304988145828, 0.025176765397191048, 0.04557664692401886, -0.0030093174427747726, 0.03856610506772995, -0.01715417020022869, -0.0034734432119876146, -0.012820813804864883, 0.03472202271223068, 0.01963759958744049, -0.026449760422110558, 0.008826473727822304, -0.02616487257182598, -0.022721629589796066, 0.025365181267261505, -0.023034315556287766, 0.008958579041063786, -0.06223310902714729, -0.03364281356334686, 0.0484464168548584, 0.03138561174273491, 0.04717865586280823, 0.02168068289756775, -0.0482858270406723, 0.02531229890882969, 0.004427502863109112, -0.06445605307817459, -0.03154916688799858, 0.017190193757414818, 0.020860498771071434, 0.06278945505619049, 0.015176068060100079, 0.004243149887770414, -0.012956086546182632, 0.0021163104102015495, 0.01651577278971672, -0.008310152217745781, 0.06053046137094498, -0.04466819763183594, 0.029542284086346626, -0.002534048166126013, -0.020307693630456924, 0.020266560837626457, 0.023284973576664925, -0.09890511631965637, 0.03183520957827568, 0.006083054933696985, -0.03680926561355591, -0.023619238287210464, -0.06303795427083969, -0.018875515088438988, 0.04422694817185402, 0.02102997526526451, -0.014324905350804329, -0.010842250660061836, -0.05689314380288124, -0.030832596123218536, 0.04950784146785736, 0.06254573166370392, -0.02063257247209549, 0.0200521070510149, -0.015021152794361115, 0.006482474040240049, 0.051665641367435455, 0.016427064314484596, 0.04810897633433342, 0.008888398297131062, 0.06270293146371841, 0.017716342583298683, 0.015589636750519276, 0.041899967938661575, -0.04228447377681732, -0.02325996570289135, 0.03333442658185959, 0.017812885344028473, 0.01884331740438938, -0.018736854195594788, -0.07906901836395264, -0.019520459696650505, -0.054761312901973724, -0.031238773837685585, -0.02465350367128849, -0.019179169088602066, 0.020082062110304832, -0.031877100467681885, -0.00799592025578022, 0.04575271159410477, -0.059710659086704254, 0.011960445903241634, -0.01524084061384201, -0.011043348349630833, -0.00860163290053606, 0.06487030535936356, -0.0688139870762825, 0.0029125341679900885, 0.006865641567856073, -0.01827343925833702, -0.04375595971941948, -0.052235279232263565, -0.046946633607149124, 0.018688229843974113, -0.04247240722179413, 0.02170637995004654, 0.016116032376885414, -0.026668306440114975, -0.06746647506952286, -0.04775701463222504, -0.026400333270430565, -0.010992745868861675, -0.013561483472585678, 0.0013536082115024328, -0.012321493588387966, 0.004517931491136551, 0.07142646610736847, -0.01904456689953804, 0.0021770389284938574, 0.008418407291173935, -0.03628642112016678, -0.037426095455884933, 0.027991048991680145, 0.0386991947889328, -0.030261153355240822, -0.03486766666173935, -0.0028463080525398254, 0.04545888304710388, -0.014336374588310719, -0.033040035516023636, -0.05031882971525192, -0.01893896795809269, 0.008143173530697823, 0.019575882703065872, -0.008365187793970108, -0.006969254929572344, -0.025785798206925392, 0.0035030420403927565, -0.0007950727012939751, -0.026881998404860497, -0.00613515404984355, -0.023589609190821648, 0.03031325340270996, 0.04310544580221176, -0.003650445956736803, -0.008752398192882538, -0.05401306971907616, 0.04015965387225151, 0.01200158055871725, -0.01135456096380949, 0.007232499774545431, 0.028856191784143448, -0.07240577787160873, -0.052146997302770615, -0.012381725944578648, 0.007964488118886948, 0.033687908202409744, -0.06005620211362839, -0.010488871484994888, -0.01771647483110428, -0.03970151022076607, -0.004512057173997164, -0.024307213723659515, -0.02533208392560482, 0.003016489092260599, 0.030758675187826157, 0.005125238560140133, -0.0644882321357727, 0.002850622171536088, 0.02087961509823799, 0.027377547696232796, -0.06955170631408691, 0.04175795987248421, -0.07158626616001129, -0.08707370609045029, 0.06734057515859604, -0.002532793441787362, 0.01461074873805046, -0.027516601607203484, 0.03805012255907059, 0.024011390283703804, 0.023101618513464928, -0.04928608611226082, -0.03376514092087746, 0.012166377156972885, -0.0349186509847641, -0.018706418573856354, 0.000176612040377222, 0.07232752442359924, 0.054066870361566544, 0.02281886711716652, -0.0009627689141780138, 0.026163825765252113, 0.02494482509791851, -0.04073280468583107, 0.02199609950184822, -0.013050567358732224, 0.06039394810795784, -0.041312217712402344, 0.006953446660190821, -0.04232176020741463, 0.005638201721012592, 0.057133473455905914, -0.04321347549557686, 0.006428685039281845, 0.013201487250626087, -0.0015761660179123282, -0.013562585227191448, 0.04336799681186676, 0.004616988822817802, 0.014694221317768097, 0.038182180374860764, 0.10449423640966415, 0.049023885279893875, 0.07164298743009567, 0.03934568539261818, 0.01901436038315296, 0.009145204909145832, -0.008548518642783165, 0.04055670648813248, -0.032898712903261185, -0.017945077270269394, 0.019309746101498604, -0.000901725550647825, 0.02722315676510334, 0.019885050132870674, 0.02190397121012211, 0.01622968725860119, 0.09370073676109314, -0.017362311482429504, -0.0019303541630506516, 0.010270418599247932, 0.019496222957968712, 0.013533873483538628, -0.0030536605045199394, -0.0036643086932599545, -0.017893623560667038, 0.019390322268009186, 0.026518020778894424, -0.04738759994506836, 0.022919870913028717, 0.03154953196644783, -0.01898573338985443, -0.002272228943184018, 0.03636873885989189, -0.055347248911857605, 0.0107408557087183, 0.013496766798198223, -0.021526357159018517, 0.0150347501039505, -0.00706909503787756, -0.09008823335170746, 0.0151593629270792, 0.08283913880586624, 0.044627588242292404, -0.04305814951658249, 0.052655041217803955, 0.08877816051244736, 0.08766914159059525, 0.02877086028456688, -0.06406392902135849, -0.07397415488958359, -0.04153742268681526, -0.028310386463999748, -0.01633557677268982, 0.05814787372946739, -0.08876877278089523, 0.04615478962659836, -0.004913743119686842, 0.0778164193034172, 0.016615893691778183, 0.06797350198030472, 0.06795938313007355, 0.02786865644156933, 0.0055105178616940975, -0.0029340714681893587, 0.002661825157701969, 0.0498332679271698, 0.010073011741042137, -0.060953881591558456, 0.009793026372790337, -0.07041672617197037, -0.008785534650087357, 0.01929577998816967, -0.026691528037190437, 0.05890762060880661, 0.02294217236340046, -0.014073486439883709, -0.007012796122580767, 0.06037149205803871, 0.0333157479763031, 0.022330913692712784, 0.021067356690764427, -0.07988206297159195, 0.04891734942793846, 0.05575024336576462, 0.05292026698589325, 0.0064529855735599995, -0.06529642641544342, -0.0071015008725225925, -0.06927922368049622, 0.020210592076182365, 0.03213237598538399, 0.010507209226489067, 0.007022547535598278, -0.011802139692008495, -0.0196002759039402, 0.01861264556646347, -0.02756107784807682, -0.02086728811264038, 0.010774031281471252, -0.0029646065086126328, -0.06450479477643967, -0.017998527735471725, -0.020931845530867577, -0.001554050948470831, 0.062331993132829666, 0.008248771540820599, -0.02470128983259201, -0.04357224702835083, -0.018924441188573837, -0.02537844143807888, 0.02632700279355049, -0.0009160557528957725, 0.004766888916492462, -0.02205493114888668, -0.055017564445734024, 0.018398774787783623, 0.01860639825463295, 0.015560023486614227, -0.012758782133460045, 0.05845685675740242, -0.04220420867204666, 0.0018358154920861125, 0.005166543181985617, -0.016288217157125473, -0.045651551336050034, -0.006002651993185282, 0.036789681762456894, 0.08472663909196854, -0.06229102984070778, 0.01002525258809328, 0.01765325292944908, 0.008196760900318623, 0.05115808919072151, -0.004366313107311726, 0.03709005191922188, 0.03759140893816948, 0.06411855667829514, -0.012231740169227123, 0.007224084809422493, -0.0066956887021660805, -0.005862537771463394, -0.022625232115387917, -0.00002885583307943307, -0.09152431041002274, -0.018990052863955498, -0.013876878656446934, -0.005369996652007103, -0.02236575074493885, -0.010410910472273827, 0.05344543233513832, -0.009241372346878052, -0.03291591629385948, 0.006167927756905556, 0.009938016533851624, 0.0028742493595927954, -0.04935963824391365, 0.01041601225733757, -0.003390927566215396, -0.009676673449575901, -0.04039449989795685, -0.02918752282857895, -0.04106388986110687, 0.0034200104419142008, 0.03790683299303055, -0.022332746535539627, -0.013308566063642502, -0.02210577018558979, -0.014040839858353138, 0.03637995570898056, -0.05711224675178528, -0.036707594990730286, 0.008945904672145844, -0.03852284327149391, 0.00027678892365656793, -0.028500011190772057, 0.039735645055770874, -0.009205118753015995, -0.029179725795984268, 0.02100926823914051, -0.04707474261522293, 0.001984416274353862, 0.02647949941456318, 0.02708519622683525, -0.011568556539714336, 0.022816142067313194, -0.0419650599360466, 0.011458680033683777, -0.07114911079406738, 0.03876931965351105, 0.0050844112411141396, -0.03097529709339142, 0.08267403393983841, -0.02994672954082489, 0.03509984910488129, 0.0008217630092985928, -0.0024598627351224422, 0.006201586220413446, -0.021103285253047943, -0.009709958918392658, 0.03831521049141884, -0.020468130707740784, 0.029060695320367813, 0.018305491656064987, -0.06058661639690399, -0.027022724971175194, -0.026740774512290955, -0.055501095950603485, -0.02336813323199749, 0.015185166150331497, 0.06500479578971863, 0.02805391326546669, -0.01922878623008728, -0.06655370444059372, 0.014054943807423115, -0.003246010048314929, -0.01054297760128975, 0.015510143712162971, -0.0034923444036394358, 0.027051644399762154, 0.030260032042860985, 0.02066888101398945, 0.024380797520279884, 0.006120447535067797, -0.0346490778028965, 0.0489891842007637, 0.00937558338046074, -0.04339997470378876, -0.0073481048457324505, 0.012058595195412636, 0.030366405844688416, -0.02061818726360798, 0.02125062234699726, -0.008190417662262917, 0.0023532574996352196, 0.03027862124145031, -0.057607945054769516, 0.0230718944221735, 0.023020578548312187, -0.021972298622131348, -0.014819320291280746, 0.01582159660756588, 0.08248577266931534, 0.012102329172194004, -0.0001380925823468715, -0.04311669245362282, -0.016939284279942513, -0.01161759253591299, 0.029121076688170433, -0.002910702722147107, 0.029842689633369446, 0.023302972316741943, -0.009807686321437359, 0.0004377404984552413, 0.02539151720702648, -0.016865137964487076, -0.04219059646129608, -0.050135400146245956, 0.04818807914853096, -0.011411086656153202, 0.0366068072617054, -0.059837229549884796, 0.009647762402892113, 0.04558612406253815, -0.06939591467380524, -0.09889568388462067, 0.03240254521369934, 0.041188232600688934, 0.0039007137529551983, -0.08820046484470367, 0.0032997492235153913, 0.023535151034593582, 0.04821924865245819, 0.004054042045027018, -0.02296738512814045, -0.032107122242450714, 0.007855100557208061, -0.011144593358039856, -0.03341037407517433, 0.025670358911156654, -0.06585559248924255, -0.039266861975193024, -0.01037689484655857, 0.020479202270507812, -0.01790286973118782, 0.024044077843427658, 0.05572675168514252, -0.019082099199295044, 0.0064080385491251945, 0.02538454532623291, -0.010948353447020054, -0.025578154250979424, -0.014587138779461384, 0.016039306297898293, 0.01561027579009533, -0.008254202082753181, -0.012373474426567554, -0.01411956362426281, -0.02748863957822323, 0.0021178049501031637, 0.03584904596209526, -0.0010894391452893615, 0.034628525376319885, -0.0041321818716824055, 0.040608398616313934, -0.09946110844612122, -0.010888569988310337, 0.009419704787433147, -0.06496795266866684, -0.002489381702616811, 0.023010078817605972, -0.03261575102806091, 0.005248379893600941, -0.007784615270793438, -0.07319343835115433, 0.009198371320962906, 0.018950143828988075, -0.002816274296492338, 0.051488570868968964, -0.013714712113142014, 0.0021150456741452217, -0.03001113422214985, -0.05804312601685524, -0.03680119663476944, 0.04943719878792763, 0.010748909786343575, -0.025239095091819763, -0.009793814271688461, 0.047770120203495026, -0.05406736955046654, -0.005421433597803116, 0.02462908811867237, 0.049678802490234375, -0.020285392180085182, 0.022995106875896454, 0.04099244251847267, 0.04709568992257118, 0.014659016393125057, 0.018630394712090492, 0.06446690857410431, 0.0042651440016925335, 0.020110517740249634, 0.03399613872170448, -0.01948816329240799, -0.07431939244270325, -0.055118147283792496, -0.08837542682886124, -0.030896568670868874, -0.03522839769721031, 0.02261326089501381, -0.03467363119125366, -0.015525433234870434, -0.04071185365319252, -0.0479317232966423, 0.09746840596199036, -0.04458876699209213, 0.05146213248372078, 0.0016944862436503172, -0.021003279834985733, -0.04412008821964264, 0.0559997633099556, -0.022564293816685677, -0.03289279714226723, -0.01991734839975834, 0.017591768875718117, -0.01543939858675003, -0.04572906345129013, 0.02398916892707348, 0.033581413328647614, 0.024319346994161606, 0.021366925910115242, -0.01054934598505497, -0.003812969895079732, -0.03395558148622513, 0.019206810742616653, 0.009908328764140606, -0.008115239441394806, -0.05397956073284149, -0.018214233219623566, 0.06449813395738602, 0.014359284192323685, -0.025204280391335487, 0.007375643122941256, 0.06962220370769501, -0.014651498757302761, 0.020010890439152718, -0.06323084980249405, 0.00620216503739357, 0.017362482845783234 ]
<p>Let's say we want to freeze a banana. Would it freeze faster if we insert it into an empty freezer, or into one that already contains many frozen bananas?</p>
g5902
[ 0.0546875, 0.09071249514818192, 0.032337624579668045, -0.019557317718863487, 0.004394649062305689, -0.03403977304697037, 0.010682259686291218, 0.020045001059770584, -0.11157441884279251, -0.01207303162664175, -0.04342281073331833, -0.00938533153384924, -0.041940122842788696, 0.028514083474874496, -0.0595017671585083, 0.02975653111934662, 0.04406777024269104, -0.05304086580872536, 0.01853305846452713, 0.08605765551328659, -0.004023990128189325, 0.008158299140632153, 0.027135107666254044, 0.0058032372035086155, -0.05421997979283333, 0.04862014204263687, 0.027521593496203423, 0.0003894100373145193, -0.08277217298746109, 0.04136207699775696, 0.033551331609487534, 0.013986259698867798, -0.03669082745909691, -0.026640094816684723, -0.07169445604085922, -0.07262825965881348, 0.06783587485551834, -0.0008597458945587277, 0.00830345880240202, -0.021507596597075462, 0.010731829330325127, -0.00817106943577528, 0.020581476390361786, -0.03677072748541832, -0.03296097740530968, 0.026632867753505707, 0.032597485929727554, -0.0076217385940253735, 0.01877054013311863, -0.04884283244609833, -0.025863422080874443, 0.0581197552382946, -0.0504569336771965, 0.014906264841556549, -0.034719135612249374, 0.04461739584803581, 0.027223428711295128, -0.006388895213603973, -0.00426750211045146, 0.08067568391561508, -0.03776464983820915, -0.009382758289575577, -0.005824841093271971, -0.03735880181193352, 0.008250518701970577, 0.04378744959831238, -0.007241749670356512, -0.018682438880205154, 0.11771871894598007, 0.02747173048555851, 0.022894708439707756, -0.031207475811243057, -0.021109165623784065, -0.021567825227975845, -0.0017941332189366221, 0.045497164130210876, -0.02222254127264023, 0.06294932961463928, 0.0421709343791008, 0.004266096279025078, -0.033029984682798386, 0.02640066109597683, 0.024027777835726738, -0.00011261567851761356, 0.028608521446585655, 0.006313791032880545, -0.017503362149000168, -0.038560859858989716, -0.02097313106060028, 0.05005687475204468, 0.009465883485972881, -0.02194722555577755, 0.04418522119522095, 0.02392890304327011, 0.010490423999726772, 0.005726495757699013, 0.026546534150838852, 0.05478280410170555, -0.055296022444963455, 0.030514324083924294, -0.01920706033706665, -0.05455819517374039, 0.014678632840514183, -0.015692200511693954, 0.002050343668088317, -0.050950974225997925, 0.04241042211651802, -0.023695703595876694, -0.05680013820528984, 0.04130382835865021, 0.008592620491981506, -0.0321984700858593, -0.052914898842573166, 0.04623120650649071, -0.0342746376991272, 0.06424017995595932, 0.0448978953063488, 0.0017948001623153687, 0.0495838038623333, 0.029475323855876923, 0.08110606670379639, 0.018942100927233696, 0.005056080874055624, 0.01053608488291502, 0.005264291074126959, -0.012219793163239956, 0.008429214358329773, 0.06674083322286606, 0.01939181238412857, -0.04159655049443245, -0.023687295615673065, 0.01761860027909279, -0.0068332781083881855, -0.024785058572888374, -0.014447513036429882, -0.021496791392564774, -0.019906429573893547, 0.008254772052168846, 0.023343300446867943, 0.03171548992395401, -0.0023203077726066113, 0.005091346334666014, 0.007610382977873087, 0.08363490551710129, -0.01626133918762207, 0.037194907665252686, -0.06870045512914658, 0.01919523999094963, 0.0070509337820112705, 0.024363817647099495, 0.01836874522268772, 0.009393240325152874, -0.022111671045422554, 0.016219107434153557, -0.0010950054274871945, 0.014002824202179909, 0.030329369008541107, -0.01266778539866209, 0.0988895371556282, 0.00747848954051733, 0.021733097732067108, -0.02312440425157547, 0.032158493995666504, 0.04697759822010994, -0.02321699634194374, -0.009740815497934818, 0.032187387347221375, -0.04048078507184982, -0.05145536735653877, 0.0002412714675301686, 0.03092624805867672, -0.0013777369167655706, -0.0015110931126400828, 0.03427571430802345, 0.01197989471256733, 0.04376307502388954, 0.024989750236272812, 0.004705340601503849, -0.04110457003116608, -0.04567962884902954, -0.035067230463027954, 0.031248314306139946, 0.006823050789535046, -0.050573430955410004, 0.0024863937869668007, -0.005621019750833511, 0.02258347161114216, -0.0028404335025697947, 0.003995133098214865, 0.0013796238927170634, 0.03628570958971977, 0.005682709626853466, 0.0066110133193433285, 0.04589129984378815, 0.009504891000688076, -0.009375220164656639, -0.0206852238625288, -0.05798802152276039, -0.0030801391694694757, -0.022461319342255592, 0.009525975212454796, -0.05382930487394333, 0.039769113063812256, -0.01638057455420494, -0.010882815346121788, -0.027391603216528893, -0.02826017513871193, 0.0342189259827137, 0.04303866624832153, -0.028085999190807343, 0.04125333949923515, 0.015336770564317703, 0.03798869624733925, 0.08913525193929672, 0.024085452780127525, 0.042847488075494766, -0.018701843917369843, -0.009782342240214348, 0.032096680253744125, 0.04248125106096268, -0.012271715328097343, 0.004480825271457434, 0.002395134884864092, -0.03853077441453934, 0.015506604686379433, -0.07382561266422272, 0.00657307356595993, -0.07087806612253189, -0.02242974191904068, 0.04299774393439293, 0.00036057992838323116, 0.00011426094715716317, -0.04057927057147026, 0.016274621710181236, -0.005626504775136709, 0.07315370440483093, -0.01823890209197998, 0.04535087198019028, -0.015662385150790215, 0.010472720488905907, 0.00983568374067545, 0.03878379985690117, -0.012000874616205692, 0.04593823105096817, 0.012035384774208069, -0.08680218458175659, 0.04534182325005531, -0.04072678089141846, 0.06968124210834503, 0.023790525272488594, -0.01319288369268179, 0.024564474821090698, 0.010589911602437496, -0.04912107065320015, 0.03884495049715042, 0.021099573001265526, 0.003747465554624796, 0.02780367247760296, -0.03702621906995773, -0.01517164520919323, 0.05319357290863991, 0.02232772670686245, 0.025109658017754555, -0.009959219954907894, -0.01431267336010933, 0.0006858643027953804, -0.02632841281592846, -0.025903245434165, 0.040708258748054504, 0.03712433949112892, -0.018251460045576096, -0.021186279132962227, -0.0008185419137589633, -0.029119178652763367, 0.042582590132951736, -0.009652125649154186, -0.020773984491825104, -0.012710263952612877, 0.059134699404239655, -0.026002300903201103, -0.033931978046894073, -0.017816046252846718, -0.03327759727835655, 0.06395449489355087, -0.04890827462077141, 0.022697031497955322, -0.013772278092801571, 0.03786079213023186, -0.014802445657551289, 0.006974054966121912, -0.03628105670213699, -0.013049439527094364, 0.05908448249101639, 0.0034922356717288494, 0.03930402174592018, 0.026804685592651367, -0.00562875485047698, -0.00012228178093209863, 0.008893252350389957, -0.06717953085899353, -0.04706977307796478, 0.016848882660269737, -0.028742646798491478, 0.00020883417164441198, 0.030366741120815277, 0.04241124913096428, -0.05489322915673256, 0.03871572017669678, -0.040263064205646515, -0.05898570269346237, -0.0045579569414258, 0.12678611278533936, -0.052714668214321136, 0.0707826241850853, -0.05706189200282097, -0.07381272315979004, -0.003575961571186781, 0.04781155288219452, 0.016917526721954346, -0.07103338092565536, -0.021889731287956238, -0.031989648938179016, 0.01680542714893818, 0.026994409039616585, 0.015299026854336262, 0.055558256804943085, 0.0005592306260950863, -0.061492275446653366, -0.0131795983761549, 0.020483480766415596, -0.006612609140574932, 0.01744917407631874, -0.042409878224134445, 0.03320545330643654, -0.0012366987066343427, -0.017930353060364723, 0.00873843114823103, -0.011952902190387249, -0.019117778167128563, 0.02325562946498394, -0.03435556963086128, -0.02407115139067173, -0.01214449480175972, 0.0025370148941874504, -0.002571452409029007, -0.02105006016790867, 0.03987099975347519, -0.016214020550251007, -0.037581659853458405, -0.008105214685201645, -0.005929763428866863, -0.03638530895113945, -0.06910260766744614, -0.017259756103157997, -0.03456486761569977, -0.027089903131127357, -0.016952700912952423, -0.00662876944988966, 0.015663111582398415, 0.015310149639844894, 0.04791906476020813, -0.0002244691422674805, -0.000671455345582217, 0.06454098969697952, -0.010996038094162941, 0.053316380828619, 0.01618233323097229, -0.023410409688949585, -0.02528974413871765, -0.038292109966278076, 0.02556479163467884, -0.021847041323781013, -0.02170918695628643, 0.0014271255349740386, 0.027734220027923584, -0.03846434876322746, 0.028402352705597878, 0.03668786212801933, -0.002430151216685772, -0.01935531385242939, 0.009267146699130535, -0.07431082427501678, 0.000002401161736997892, -0.04881579428911209, 0.00831233523786068, -0.012818627059459686, 0.01872112788259983, -0.03466251492500305, 0.0012831921922042966, -0.03768410161137581, -0.02574966661632061, 0.010976595804095268, 0.005924753844738007, 0.032185014337301254, -0.013789054937660694, -0.04995538294315338, -0.002503813011571765, -0.04636139050126076, -0.017279120162129402, -0.022291600704193115, -0.04311447590589523, -0.013005878776311874, 0.012196185067296028, -0.0342281349003315, -0.022420791909098625, 0.003247358137741685, 0.05271851271390915, -0.0862966924905777, -0.04897356778383255, -0.060303956270217896, -0.0583016574382782, -0.004280614200979471, 0.0009872601367533207, 0.00824478268623352, 0.0016353648388758302, -0.03141789138317108, 0.024969840422272682, -0.03574798256158829, -0.054510995745658875, -0.03502670302987099, 0.0027862468268722296, -0.018821053206920624, -0.05157550424337387, -0.0004470350395422429, -0.057301219552755356, -0.004067775793373585, 0.057474005967378616, -0.014034857042133808, -0.0171976238489151, -0.02242615632712841, -0.021209681406617165, 0.0820135846734047, -0.012249907478690147, -0.006685360334813595, 0.0599479153752327, -0.005782483145594597, 0.022637199610471725, 0.003069688333198428, 0.059315573424100876, 0.006170517764985561, -0.03371911495923996, 0.02684260718524456, -0.0006963398773223162, 0.021436242386698723, 0.0017469582380726933, 0.025257257744669914, 0.01795150525867939, -0.02993459440767765, 0.028876235708594322, -0.0037476771976798773, -0.004458598326891661, 0.051191553473472595, -0.07509114593267441, -0.008539240807294846, 0.04914698377251625, 0.026763826608657837, 0.028734415769577026, 0.0130990631878376, -0.012385341338813305, 0.05973167344927788, -0.03462717682123184, 0.015501052141189575, 0.010555701330304146, 0.011139780282974243, -0.017595971003174782, -0.03754247725009918, 0.07288967072963715, -0.04835101589560509, -0.033396441489458084, -0.0002646594657562673, -0.007238439284265041, 0.003771586809307337, -0.0007663680007681251, 0.0882391557097435, 0.05144599825143814, -0.030029727146029472, 0.018164442852139473, -0.00948083121329546, -0.010314444079995155, -0.02957310900092125, -0.06205064058303833, 0.030565259978175163, 0.04660450667142868, -0.058439210057258606, 0.009177560918033123, -0.029339971020817757, -0.05889188125729561, 0.016437480226159096, 0.04814012721180916, -0.00364543660543859, 0.009343818761408329, -0.01055171899497509, -0.02521970123052597, 0.019368348643183708, 0.01809169352054596, 0.0131163215264678, -0.03420534357428551, -0.05086161196231842, 0.01880219392478466, -0.016591398045420647, 0.03156749904155731, 0.021956128999590874, 0.002909812144935131, -0.0780908539891243, 0.02856789529323578, 0.059403397142887115, -0.007731494959443808, -0.02772567793726921, -0.07080452889204025, -0.05251283943653107, -0.011154431849718094, 0.08042418956756592, -0.058590251952409744, 0.013277853839099407, 0.07946095615625381, -0.021050572395324707, -0.04720742627978325, -0.01737210899591446, -0.03379010036587715, -0.02362234704196453, -0.0009426630567759275, 0.04429153352975845, -0.05032612383365631, 0.0030168392695486546, -0.09075246751308441, 0.009294813498854637, -0.01087785605341196, -0.02428567223250866, -0.05782989412546158, -0.08576371520757675, 0.03202412277460098, -0.03745425119996071, 0.03623154014348984, 0.033301349729299545, -0.03207659348845482, -0.029985573142766953, -0.029009278863668442, 0.011445196345448494, 0.08171024918556213, -0.0021708346903324127, 0.028293386101722717, -0.008789368905127048, -0.004264375660568476, 0.009995519183576107, -0.029566053301095963, -0.004375925753265619, -0.002762967487797141, -0.009197822771966457, -0.011001636274158955, -0.026287438347935677, -0.05284404754638672, 0.006578090600669384, 0.009580902755260468, -0.03303822502493858, -0.012066520750522614, 0.033742427825927734, -0.021161120384931564, 0.0475468747317791, 0.0744737982749939, -0.041702501475811005, -0.04150785505771637, 0.002538207219913602, 0.026849837973713875, -0.0686541199684143, -0.020757226273417473, -0.0517604798078537, -0.04486197978258133, 0.010898561216890812, 0.043903935700654984, -0.01909579336643219, 0.029141925275325775, -0.011123234406113625, -0.04100557789206505, 0.035435374826192856, 0.03645719215273857, -0.011469575576484203, 0.050416674464941025, 0.022271592170000076, 0.06546613574028015, -0.024358244612812996, -0.012849695049226284, -0.02143976278603077, -0.015841564163565636, 0.02280818298459053, 0.06740807741880417, 0.07392977923154831, -0.01873062551021576, 0.017822077497839928, -0.010392903350293636, -0.0006386908353306353, -0.007297341246157885, -0.01656280644237995, 0.009033728390932083, -0.02903379686176777, -0.0026035562623292208, 0.07430005073547363, -0.027165375649929047, -0.02631458081305027, -0.014280133880674839, 0.04424431920051575, -0.019553497433662415, 0.023908313363790512, 0.06443256139755249, -0.04287872090935707, -0.09243842959403992, 0.031845513731241226, 0.02121264860033989, 0.03578391671180725, 0.0225188210606575, 0.03391779214143753, 0.016321904957294464, -0.027474908158183098, 0.04249482601881027, -0.03377503901720047, 0.024424578994512558, -0.004097642842680216, 0.014318595640361309, -0.07194976508617401, 0.0222852174192667, 0.04207088425755501, 0.01654520258307457, -0.08947164565324783, -0.017920881509780884, -0.0009949308587238193, 0.01087888516485691, -0.008253057487308979, -0.047859977930784225, -0.021420607343316078, 0.08831270784139633, -0.03562349081039429, 0.02549191750586033, -0.050427451729774475, 0.0329684354364872, 0.03992287814617157, 0.008574262261390686, 0.07653205096721649, -0.0035715128760784864, 0.007917869836091995, -0.08400021493434906, -0.006640349980443716, -0.018121039494872093, -0.0051041580736637115, -0.018933357670903206, 0.09680908173322678, 0.0035430758725851774, 0.05795393884181976, 0.0065109943971037865, 0.04951271042227745, 0.03467877209186554, 0.009287504479289055, -0.07814274728298187, -0.011073170229792595, -0.031576063483953476, -0.006913614459335804, -0.05435445159673691, 0.030453573912382126, 0.004414798226207495, 0.06835118681192398, -0.006596236955374479, -0.008651391603052616, 0.01917700283229351, 0.011644534766674042, -0.014421913772821426, -0.019523996859788895, 0.005554270930588245, -0.0013200257671996951, 0.04397514462471008, -0.005281277000904083, -0.010457981377840042, -0.007992265745997429, 0.023323100060224533, 0.022827498614788055, -0.0002826122217811644, -0.02799978107213974, 0.06365273147821426, 0.008469278924167156, -0.009984573349356651, -0.043979108333587646, -0.012424918822944164, 0.01913285441696644, 0.0006973531562834978, 0.0147981783375144, 0.021038122475147247, 0.024693449959158897, -0.01515489537268877, 0.08689320832490921, 0.045840583741664886, -0.013440155424177647, 0.02122924104332924, -0.0187738798558712, 0.026763932779431343, 0.004792324732989073, 0.056234076619148254, 0.014418299309909344, -0.024951698258519173, -0.005094922613352537, -0.030207807198166847, -0.004958243574947119, -0.012556931003928185, -0.010286950506269932, -0.05152883753180504, 0.04584250599145889, 0.028623290359973907, -0.03475223481655121, 0.02816036343574524, -0.011220798827707767, -0.009021935053169727, -0.007922962307929993, -0.00681748241186142, -0.03495647385716438, 0.009049403481185436, 0.06249544024467468, 0.018232975155115128, 0.058010831475257874, 0.016219837591052055, -0.057133909314870834, -0.056229181587696075, -0.027806099504232407, -0.0053591737523674965, 0.007394539192318916, -0.020190848037600517, -0.0032929249573498964, -0.04134250432252884, -0.004171919077634811, -0.03648511320352554, 0.03885998576879501, 0.02953191287815571, -0.005275244824588299, -0.07292317599058151, -0.032504383474588394, -0.006555736996233463, 0.021726777777075768, -0.002214701846241951, 0.0023658901918679476, -0.03213416785001755, -0.07214803993701935, -0.043817419558763504, -0.00456966320052743, 0.006134374532848597, 0.030217470601201057, 0.00833225343376398, 0.0026258197613060474, -0.033522527664899826, -0.02837124839425087, -0.0038200735580176115, -0.010307754389941692, -0.03068850189447403, 0.034689370542764664, 0.07982367277145386, -0.026051823049783707, -0.04155592620372772, -0.07027225196361542, -0.04964156821370125, -0.015548466704785824, 0.013139674440026283, 0.047690410166978836, -0.03406568989157677, 0.006349315866827965, -0.05387812852859497, 0.04017290845513344, 0.021440710872411728, 0.03847784176468849, -0.0007630684995092452, -0.014907396398484707, -0.01973976567387581, 0.05486232042312622, 0.02465010993182659, -0.015457653440535069 ]
<p>In the Hamiltonian formulation, we make a Legendre transformation of the Lagrangian and it should be written in terms of the coordinates $q$ and momentum $p$. Can we always write $dq/dt$ in terms of $p$? Is there any case in which we obtain for example a transcendental equation and cannot do it? </p>
g5903
[ 0.05630319193005562, 0.009790744632482529, -0.005678021814674139, -0.06897293031215668, 0.030766280367970467, -0.0009648796985857189, 0.03304477408528328, 0.007306816056370735, -0.08157910406589508, 0.010461665689945221, 0.02367892861366272, -0.01172402873635292, 0.010563916526734829, 0.006476468872278929, 0.009475244209170341, 0.023752981796860695, 0.001976806903257966, 0.015845444053411484, 0.042205844074487686, -0.01984315924346447, -0.05255194008350372, 0.005202719010412693, 0.0584634467959404, -0.019374698400497437, 0.021358182653784752, -0.03438166156411171, -0.015522163361310959, -0.0596042275428772, -0.007591125555336475, 0.02383795939385891, -0.0019641821272671223, 0.023169908672571182, 0.015986362472176552, 0.013709078542888165, -0.027574077248573303, -0.0009681608062237501, 0.05152871459722519, -0.03287961706519127, 0.04849345609545708, -0.03875761106610298, 0.04515191167593002, -0.021538978442549706, 0.033350955694913864, -0.00680196937173605, -0.018347464501857758, 0.022509321570396423, -0.02408980391919613, 0.005677440669387579, -0.04926929250359535, 0.028147609904408455, 0.04875394329428673, 0.01717703975737095, 0.018164992332458496, -0.034926362335681915, -0.04382261633872986, 0.10487024486064911, 0.04011337459087372, -0.02440722845494747, -0.00813877210021019, 0.06452803313732147, -0.009486997500061989, -0.053732115775346756, -0.015840977430343628, 0.013474731706082821, 0.07087399065494537, -0.04070015624165535, -0.019992921501398087, -0.010141978040337563, -0.0420692004263401, -0.01027053501456976, 0.02899254858493805, -0.035460617393255234, 0.02238299697637558, -0.03449491411447525, 0.027239447459578514, 0.008815085515379906, -0.014475778676569462, -0.02146364375948906, 0.04243715479969978, 0.009799388237297535, -0.009704294614493847, 0.0015465335454791784, 0.06693213433027267, -0.014748712070286274, 0.047641266137361526, 0.0163120124489069, 0.04540058225393295, 0.04592731222510338, 0.016119349747896194, 0.01204188447445631, 0.014520740136504173, 0.034506626427173615, 0.032781992107629776, 0.05701993405818939, -0.0162432212382555, -0.03557616099715233, 0.021448520943522453, 0.01748514361679554, -0.06500699371099472, -0.032960306853055954, -0.06377643346786499, 0.04462428390979767, -0.030750013887882233, -0.014753413386642933, 0.010166625492274761, -0.023433614522218704, 0.05647829920053482, -0.004079470410943031, -0.008785855025053024, -0.07274974137544632, 0.01804831251502037, 0.014974808320403099, 0.0026880409568548203, 0.069838747382164, -0.05497078225016594, -0.009115636348724365, 0.01637204736471176, 0.002086271531879902, -0.051837217062711716, 0.05545501783490181, -0.020477665588259697, 0.014822627417743206, 0.02844664826989174, 0.08323607593774796, 0.033343151211738586, 0.04270969331264496, -0.08198220282793045, 0.0285757128149271, 0.0496627576649189, 0.0047448244877159595, -0.002928536618128419, 0.0439770445227623, 0.006327427923679352, 0.030670709908008575, -0.007894949056208134, 0.031009867787361145, 0.025049326941370964, 0.02426445484161377, 0.023719361051917076, 0.03665218874812126, 0.03708771988749504, -0.008500754833221436, 0.020741593092679977, 0.009413334541022778, -0.004703764338046312, -0.031842757016420364, -0.019408008083701134, -0.07821827381849289, 0.018368450924754143, -0.006298353895545006, 0.03328376263380051, 0.0058378675021231174, 0.030501799657940865, 0.011994732543826103, 0.009722165763378143, 0.03156735375523567, 0.019821777939796448, 0.0067207831889390945, 0.01868508942425251, -0.03797437995672226, 0.045122914016246796, 0.012915990315377712, 0.017730342224240303, -0.01863713562488556, 0.008464861661195755, 0.019281337037682533, -0.004288202617317438, 0.018651718273758888, -0.06380364298820496, -0.023183519020676613, -0.015829870477318764, 0.027359072118997574, 0.00496351532638073, -0.008935065940022469, 0.02914987877011299, 0.03487979248166084, -0.09583359211683273, -0.005173142533749342, -0.03612874448299408, 0.005213631317019463, -0.00045232533011585474, -0.023184603080153465, 0.04728647321462631, -0.05376235768198967, -0.007571447640657425, 0.05181553214788437, 0.008369358256459236, 0.01948840171098709, 0.005488661117851734, 0.02257167547941208, 0.04264580458402634, 0.06315676122903824, 0.024589383974671364, 0.07588613033294678, -0.004814739804714918, 0.035261865705251694, 0.008653189986944199, -0.010499449446797371, -0.0014603891177102923, 0.05158877372741699, -0.030576199293136597, 0.04720553383231163, 0.04470431059598923, 0.00003455745172686875, -0.010838985443115234, 0.018851138651371002, -0.004176364280283451, 0.035253144800662994, 0.03235362470149994, -0.025335408747196198, 0.052320051938295364, -0.02445037290453911, -0.034491270780563354, 0.005486918613314629, -0.06369827687740326, -0.07165135443210602, 0.005152690690010786, 0.014214204624295235, -0.011114077642560005, -0.02646777220070362, -0.10693217813968658, -0.0446702241897583, 0.022868687286973, 0.026248935610055923, -0.0637507438659668, 0.006053973454982042, -0.031343720853328705, -0.017775729298591614, -0.010599528439342976, -0.03831079602241516, -0.014923091977834702, -0.05140620470046997, -0.017951173707842827, -0.020386716350913048, 0.014249772764742374, 0.044871341437101364, -0.023073403164744377, -0.008539971895515919, 0.06327664852142334, 0.09235435724258423, -0.01167261227965355, -0.040581829845905304, 0.04850486293435097, -0.021305684000253677, 0.027297554537653923, 0.0020042406395077705, 0.03684568405151367, 0.03443535789847374, -0.03056575171649456, 0.011911794543266296, -0.04853855445981026, 0.007205442059785128, 0.011187382973730564, -0.03539114072918892, -0.034996066242456436, -0.01586090959608555, -0.010220563970506191, -0.01427148375660181, 0.0022503798827528954, -0.0042495280504226685, 0.007744099944829941, 0.02908489853143692, -0.036858946084976196, 0.04220307245850563, -0.057325974106788635, 0.019548136740922928, 0.00791992712765932, -0.011896507814526558, 0.032987773418426514, -0.020594239234924316, -0.01854776404798031, 0.0632999986410141, 0.043704286217689514, 0.05573976784944534, -0.02454414963722229, -0.0567261166870594, -0.023879237473011017, -0.04286997765302658, -0.02455681376159191, -0.019488990306854248, -0.03038092516362667, 0.0007902680081315339, -0.03682317957282066, 0.05894283950328827, 0.03424102067947388, -0.0432111993432045, -0.04182565584778786, 0.01672011986374855, 0.006136663258075714, 0.0308561772108078, -0.017173750326037407, 0.011356836184859276, 0.00885564275085926, -0.01715441420674324, -0.0807141363620758, 0.09013133496046066, -0.037625476717948914, -0.031471628695726395, 0.028638681396842003, 0.03731616586446762, 0.011204629205167294, 0.002116469433531165, 0.013053534552454948, 0.10014013200998306, 0.0009176237508654594, 0.010240285657346249, 0.008668632246553898, -0.005314306356012821, 0.008430521935224533, -0.05612652748823166, -0.040040209889411926, 0.028593389317393303, -0.016928961500525475, -0.00968088023364544, -0.004116048105061054, -0.04310139641165733, -0.0011799839558079839, -0.07898873835802078, 0.04770384728908539, -0.027080688625574112, -0.03956306725740433, -0.05592675507068634, -0.001487654517404735, 0.027782859280705452, -0.013233702629804611, 0.017068196088075638, -0.03233341872692108, 0.0037624621763825417, -0.032011840492486954, -0.06524229794740677, -0.025424527004361153, 0.0513136126101017, 0.009015671908855438, 0.00907883606851101, 0.00994226522743702, 0.011739621870219707, -0.04323990270495415, 0.006670878268778324, 0.021493814885616302, -0.032049234956502914, -0.05373865365982056, -0.03099042735993862, -0.06393782794475555, 0.05827850475907326, 0.055418480187654495, -0.0540909580886364, 0.014588472433388233, 0.019269529730081558, 0.0036770603619515896, 0.0031312096398323774, -0.06671865284442902, 0.014141212217509747, 0.05417339503765106, -0.013963357545435429, -0.0022327525075525045, 0.032711680978536606, 0.0594843253493309, 0.06188001483678818, 0.005515730939805508, 0.006200899835675955, 0.012162922881543636, 0.011698806658387184, -0.05286683514714241, 0.046148911118507385, 0.032953549176454544, 0.034085724502801895, -0.0007001232588663697, -0.05918869748711586, -0.028906522318720818, -0.021620891988277435, 0.037826843559741974, -0.01722104288637638, 0.02830362878739834, -0.052628252655267715, 0.03438859060406685, -0.012651410885155201, -0.02826327458024025, 0.001995825907215476, -0.033752232789993286, 0.04497426748275757, -0.031077371910214424, -0.002289203694090247, -0.015623537823557854, -0.002197862369939685, 0.04489493742585182, 0.05116263031959534, -0.027061786502599716, 0.007795526180416346, 0.004645366687327623, 0.005080299451947212, -0.008638049475848675, -0.011391122825443745, 0.00910695269703865, 0.008354823105037212, -0.020695753395557404, -0.046086616814136505, 0.04327673092484474, 0.004879805259406567, 0.007193172350525856, -0.02291877754032612, -0.07076418399810791, -0.04920576140284538, 0.013485711067914963, -0.02457731030881405, 0.025425467640161514, 0.008326638489961624, 0.08094921708106995, -0.012445452623069286, -0.0028137487825006247, -0.04470920190215111, 0.018894009292125702, -0.06506079435348511, 0.0030947576742619276, 0.010742688551545143, -0.01514122262597084, -0.044720470905303955, -0.02006172575056553, -0.07530532032251358, -0.04486704245209694, -0.034609921276569366, 0.08159373700618744, 0.04100501537322998, 0.04438076168298721, 0.04982210695743561, 0.08426551520824432, 0.026092765852808952, 0.08492767065763474, -0.018590431660413742, -0.014503969810903072, 0.003378733526915312, -0.0632387101650238, -0.02625233121216297, 0.023856209591031075, -0.003964299336075783, -0.02700706198811531, -0.041432589292526245, -0.08080225437879562, 0.04860338568687439, 0.025409281253814697, 0.017890622839331627, 0.061372749507427216, 0.0520792230963707, 0.04753929004073143, -0.0022745165042579174, -0.04713078588247299, 0.0467461496591568, 0.03964706510305405, -0.02360745333135128, -0.009486138820648193, -0.04242885112762451, -0.007692220155149698, 0.01012380886822939, -0.031147204339504242, 0.005461588967591524, 0.01442147046327591, 0.03038640134036541, -0.038383256644010544, -0.04125853627920151, -0.032977357506752014, -0.04499927908182144, -0.04180460795760155, -0.04211636260151863, -0.06790374964475632, 0.01767261140048504, 0.0371495857834816, -0.038251884281635284, -0.07594379037618637, 0.03735807538032532, -0.03867485001683235, -0.07117343693971634, 0.03059990145266056, -0.0028443061746656895, -0.016894761472940445, -0.013866855762898922, -0.00913894735276699, 0.00555043900385499, 0.014512625522911549, 0.004837004002183676, -0.01538743358105421, -0.033060889691114426, -0.01903196983039379, 0.02013079822063446, -0.023890510201454163, 0.0201514083892107, -0.020664799958467484, 0.02581862360239029, 0.00341341202147305, -0.03481397032737732, -0.010775381699204445, -0.007339215837419033, -0.019263656809926033, 0.014027063734829426, -0.06853364408016205, 0.023795457556843758, -0.03213286027312279, 0.015289300121366978, -0.03996817395091057, -0.07162672281265259, -0.01602100022137165, 0.018426958471536636, -0.05920102447271347, 0.031061621382832527, 0.019185276702046394, 0.006596143823117018, 0.03003774955868721, 0.026888327673077583, 0.05497077852487564, 0.03962501883506775, -0.06834631413221359, -0.0194805059581995, 0.03896170109510422, 0.027561798691749573, -0.026204833760857582, 0.027867313474416733, -0.018499014899134636, -0.02868209034204483, -0.020882239565253258, -0.007943899370729923, -0.039516184478998184, -0.028090938925743103, 0.03889619931578636, -0.05439729243516922, 0.006277355831116438, -0.047961462289094925, 0.012695498764514923, 0.05078648403286934, -0.04781995341181755, -0.12338362634181976, 0.011314379051327705, 0.05384490266442299, 0.010525579564273357, 0.011393344029784203, 0.02363516017794609, -0.014505865052342415, -0.03756370395421982, -0.033652499318122864, 0.009135078638792038, -0.008166514337062836, -0.04986271634697914, -0.0006315330392681062, -0.027116939425468445, -0.07257115095853806, 0.004147152882069349, 0.0815175399184227, 0.004403437487781048, 0.0031297083478420973, 0.007441169582307339, 0.02002565935254097, -0.014798419550061226, 0.00025022379122674465, -0.048729222267866135, 0.011476834304630756, -0.03827475756406784, 0.012095397338271141, -0.012045631185173988, -0.005433681886643171, 0.016477052122354507, -0.0059712654910981655, -0.051595404744148254, 0.01891595683991909, 0.028358813375234604, -0.03477121517062187, -0.012105719186365604, -0.025290116667747498, -0.01590174436569214, 0.014278728514909744, 0.041433826088905334, 0.01045306958258152, 0.022904550656676292, -0.01342675369232893, 0.02288319729268551, 0.009715783409774303, -0.002864740090444684, -0.0074035306461155415, 0.05441168323159218, -0.00010882189235417172, 0.023078633472323418, -0.04481523856520653, -0.03438654541969299, -0.003812005277723074, -0.026612382382154465, 0.02744949609041214, 0.038127001374959946, -0.041246239095926285, -0.052126139402389526, -0.0002752333239186555, -0.019910654053092003, -0.033313773572444916, -0.04212680459022522, 0.05468257889151573, 0.01331362221390009, 0.034414373338222504, -0.05615640804171562, 0.05970274657011032, 0.02163523994386196, 0.07448296248912811, 0.03290342912077904, -0.008831835351884365, -0.03663855046033859, -0.03931819647550583, 0.057498201727867126, 0.014963244087994099, -0.02037954144179821, 0.041076354682445526, 0.023045452311635017, 0.03438350185751915, -0.017737379297614098, 0.053929414600133896, 0.019145863130688667, 0.006095048505812883, 0.06228422746062279, -0.03543104603886604, 0.019415410235524178, -0.01750539429485798, 0.02431224286556244, -0.03247435390949249, -0.00514588737860322, 0.058952946215867996, -0.004623479675501585, 0.05488036572933197, 0.08218498528003693, -0.005991971120238304, -0.037674449384212494, 0.02943933568894863, -0.005124678835272789, 0.015213963575661182, -0.06556326895952225, 0.02805705927312374, 0.004985881969332695, 0.02218122035264969, 0.01207832433283329, 0.0428362675011158, -0.06101692095398903, -0.045075491070747375, 0.010929807089269161, 0.008680641651153564, -0.04786683991551399, -0.0016698306426405907, 0.006826548837125301, -0.009731934405863285, -0.002651042304933071, 0.041319459676742554, 0.02244199812412262, -0.06597093492746353, -0.013344953767955303, 0.03428233042359352, 0.008207268081605434, -0.05440416559576988, -0.11510922014713287, -0.004828059580177069, 0.06203291192650795, 0.011637098155915737, -0.03800557926297188, 0.029517535120248795, 0.047564007341861725, -0.04887474700808525, 0.009281511418521404, 0.01698419824242592, -0.047200195491313934, -0.019625850021839142, 0.003890941385179758, 0.0037972352001816034, 0.02963506057858467, -0.01737874373793602, 0.027842530980706215, -0.002537294290959835, 0.012401066720485687, 0.012587456963956356, 0.05038611963391304, 0.07417558133602142, 0.07056218385696411, -0.019824044778943062, -0.0024786791764199734, -0.030741579830646515, -0.025967784225940704, 0.019652798771858215, 0.010089912451803684, 0.0618126355111599, -0.022985756397247314, 0.018373902887105942, 0.009509327821433544, 0.0026729616802185774, 0.0026525803841650486, -0.025083007290959358, 0.0019527917029336095, 0.029641009867191315, 0.04369104653596878, 0.009073819033801556, -0.02998233027756214, 0.01235869713127613, -0.029766172170639038, -0.0017743537900969386, 0.031539078801870346, 0.02725144475698471, -0.036461785435676575, 0.026112932711839676, -0.008648470975458622, 0.04715856909751892, -0.01681242696940899, -0.017474330961704254, 0.02163044363260269, -0.03761721029877663, 0.0051985085010528564, 0.024626363068819046, -0.012062668800354004, -0.018224557861685753, 0.05735582113265991, -0.026088977232575417, -0.03904324024915695, 0.016924042254686356, 0.0017084799474105239, 0.027735944837331772, -0.024968702346086502, -0.0043678293004632, 0.040336932986974716, 0.019816746935248375, -0.026536323130130768, -0.012133633717894554, -0.00016477385361213237, -0.05340064316987991, 0.0298993568867445, -0.01427990011870861, -0.06846529245376587, -0.08154062926769257, 0.08833317458629608, -0.02199452929198742, -0.057764243334531784, -0.02127646654844284, -0.005801963619887829, 0.02035750262439251, -0.024650264531373978, 0.04143448919057846, -0.011753355152904987, 0.011361182667315006, -0.03631426766514778, -0.03822112828493118, -0.10059743374586105, -0.0388924665749073, 0.021976446732878685, 0.02530394308269024, -0.06097529083490372, -0.0957632064819336, -0.01683133840560913, 0.06893279403448105, 0.02039717137813568, 0.0298595130443573, 0.018997956067323685, 0.028827913105487823, 0.021724393591284752, -0.014936001040041447, 0.045146211981773376, 0.08018877357244492, -0.014060658402740955, -0.02325277216732502, -0.011714944615960121, -0.05244331806898117, -0.012475133873522282, 0.020804552361369133, 0.012944618239998817, 0.009458565153181553, -0.054777491837739944, 0.016344254836440086, 0.031371839344501495, -0.028266075998544693, -0.03823620453476906, -0.03459588438272476, -0.028683321550488472, 0.046046335250139236 ]
<p>I have been reading and watching videos about this subject for a while now. I just can not seem to grasp the idea. Let's say we have two clocks. I leave one at home and keep one in my pocket. Then, I started running at speed that is close to speed of light to my school then come back to my house. If I compare those two clocks how would they differ in time?</p>
g5904
[ 0.050475943833589554, -0.011660471558570862, -0.005641418509185314, 0.0053432658314704895, 0.04243217408657074, -0.012537340633571148, 0.039671920239925385, -0.005424811039119959, -0.014095599763095379, -0.031817518174648285, -0.002017156220972538, 0.017837706953287125, 0.01833936758339405, 0.004956862889230251, -0.004064458888024092, -0.021044744178652763, 0.04235357791185379, 0.004668025299906731, 0.014310576021671295, 0.002485276898369193, 0.04343278706073761, 0.041843704879283905, -0.04742317274212837, -0.02670792117714882, -0.06184709444642067, -0.04702300205826759, 0.014105034060776234, -0.06624025851488113, -0.09257504343986511, -0.007811884395778179, 0.004918736405670643, -0.018551142886281013, 0.0450332909822464, -0.011722004972398281, -0.0014794518938288093, 0.0038015274330973625, 0.0331394337117672, -0.02357642538845539, -0.044110413640737534, 0.04190364107489586, 0.021780304610729218, 0.02059129811823368, 0.011194637045264244, -0.03483873978257179, 0.053248368203639984, -0.0005568165215663612, -0.026344172656536102, 0.005125102121382952, 0.024344073608517647, 0.003702840767800808, -0.047024570405483246, 0.03666326031088829, -0.01331564411520958, 0.05814357474446297, -0.003741527907550335, -0.05978104844689369, 0.04153691604733467, -0.010368123650550842, 0.0678524449467659, 0.024364618584513664, 0.01720185950398445, -0.04759957268834114, -0.02143963798880577, 0.04217974841594696, -0.007145083975046873, 0.04471271485090256, 0.06875767558813095, -0.05089692771434784, 0.02876199595630169, -0.0019039632752537727, -0.052008215337991714, -0.04427989572286606, 0.004664171952754259, -0.0322130061686039, 0.05045613273978233, 0.04158087447285652, 0.053727034479379654, -0.03153020143508911, 0.010098416358232498, 0.08017734438180923, -0.03920472040772438, 0.01591912843286991, 0.006184399593621492, 0.05318032205104828, 0.008159955032169819, 0.018936915323138237, -0.00960948970168829, 0.0019546332769095898, 0.0120291942730546, 0.06845775991678238, 0.013560755178332329, -0.06035793945193291, 0.07552353292703629, 0.016360394656658173, -0.01601995900273323, -0.003123756032437086, 0.002234261017292738, 0.07338280975818634, 0.02393636293709278, 0.06605124473571777, -0.01110366266220808, -0.05772195756435394, 0.008575725369155407, -0.0017937050433829427, 0.04219121113419533, -0.0659208744764328, -0.018868902698159218, 0.00793621689081192, -0.09843983501195908, -0.012771308422088623, -0.00989469327032566, -0.04319727048277855, -0.0583488754928112, 0.027594130486249924, -0.010229659266769886, -0.024355610832571983, 0.01704247295856476, -0.020685270428657532, 0.016531741246581078, -0.032257553189992905, 0.03002636693418026, -0.021195411682128906, 0.004178809933364391, 0.013342870399355888, 0.02926691062748432, 0.00453973188996315, -0.01017375010997057, -0.009453357197344303, -0.004603469744324684, 0.0322285071015358, -0.014163119718432426, 0.018710415810346603, 0.019004177302122116, 0.010700607672333717, -0.008528375998139381, 0.048919279128313065, 0.047204867005348206, -0.006650256458669901, -0.02294985018670559, 0.02038547210395336, 0.03378676250576973, -0.033261336386203766, -0.021094266325235367, -0.03430233895778656, -0.04044631868600845, 0.057239141315221786, -0.023601533845067024, -0.048221781849861145, -0.03068205900490284, 0.013236411847174168, 0.028760185465216637, 0.007647726219147444, -0.0032530745957046747, 0.028640560805797577, 0.0022193666081875563, -0.012214675545692444, -0.04045158997178078, 0.03682515025138855, -0.005905224476009607, 0.002734531881287694, 0.017931455746293068, -0.05956251174211502, -0.013067695312201977, 0.01969156228005886, -0.04459550976753235, -0.013590925373136997, 0.018093470484018326, 0.012099565006792545, 0.022186793386936188, -0.07234621793031693, 0.0032469823490828276, -0.002965408144518733, -0.006998024415224791, 0.018753107637166977, 0.007453691214323044, -0.0322333462536335, 0.007395390421152115, -0.03805446997284889, -0.017043549567461014, 0.023789282888174057, 0.029879188165068626, -0.04363841563463211, -0.04810359328985214, -0.08525026589632034, 0.011260793544352055, -0.005713718011975288, -0.015435095876455307, -0.04056729003787041, -0.12887968122959137, 0.0004301383742131293, -0.0020837588235735893, -0.05725168064236641, -0.020580502226948738, 0.061588987708091736, -0.03594059497117996, -0.019754910841584206, -0.06422886252403259, 0.0076788850128650665, 0.00253056432120502, 0.026911748573184013, -0.010547139681875706, -0.000325603352393955, 0.03979736194014549, -0.03882317990064621, 0.05821345001459122, 0.0022994985338300467, -0.008578279055655003, -0.0292050801217556, 0.02516980469226837, -0.045623134821653366, 0.03834425285458565, 0.041187915951013565, -0.03913617506623268, 0.009002679958939552, 0.01570417732000351, 0.034417636692523956, 0.030369224026799202, 0.04955989867448807, -0.030472910031676292, 0.01315833255648613, 0.0027075663674622774, -0.04210083559155464, 0.05727104842662811, -0.11066405475139618, -0.0005028090672567487, -0.032796334475278854, -0.04015767201781273, 0.003079739399254322, -0.004754680674523115, 0.0833270475268364, 0.00474034808576107, -0.0017659039003774524, -0.02543896622955799, 0.005380653310567141, 0.007924558594822884, 0.06111754849553108, 0.028746413066983223, 0.009545770473778248, 0.009750858880579472, -0.00021838283282704651, 0.020554563030600548, 0.035910967737436295, 0.006397722288966179, 0.04996836930513382, -0.013108222745358944, -0.06666512787342072, 0.0545327253639698, -0.005789494141936302, -0.018647920340299606, 0.04805101081728935, -0.026315001770853996, 0.0088926050812006, -0.05711623281240463, -0.06116418540477753, -0.013111122883856297, -0.01808050088584423, 0.012457897886633873, 0.007143092807382345, -0.12743325531482697, -0.012442165054380894, -0.009727157652378082, 0.005239906720817089, -0.050788238644599915, 0.05733739957213402, 0.03595418855547905, -0.039451759308576584, 0.03364219889044762, 0.04045504704117775, -0.03593498095870018, -0.053341954946517944, -0.0011941781267523766, 0.008351519703865051, 0.02427911013364792, -0.007636353373527527, -0.042616162449121475, -0.0683099552989006, 0.024054817855358124, -0.04774581640958786, 0.02751491405069828, 0.030689122155308723, -0.005568846594542265, -0.005705614108592272, -0.060711394995450974, 0.03541449084877968, 0.0514194555580616, -0.10071001946926117, 0.017486855387687683, 0.05490802600979805, -0.03531816974282265, 0.036615289747714996, -0.04660588502883911, 0.1035950630903244, 0.036802440881729126, 0.009395645931363106, 0.03920029103755951, 0.08683356642723083, 0.03141423314809799, -0.026731427758932114, -0.002909264527261257, -0.008154796436429024, 0.045981790870428085, -0.025056367740035057, 0.006118306890130043, 0.04190091788768768, 0.046334490180015564, 0.0013678692048415542, -0.04502027481794357, -0.020757591351866722, -0.004469092469662428, -0.02716176211833954, 0.06417147070169449, 0.04445725679397583, -0.011772817000746727, -0.019670138135552406, -0.0054124342277646065, -0.030662238597869873, 0.009024523198604584, 0.020651232451200485, 0.01881728507578373, -0.008194810710847378, 0.032874636352062225, -0.0001589698949828744, -0.025103511288762093, -0.02350224368274212, 0.022221555933356285, -0.038877010345458984, -0.010287011042237282, 0.02336087077856064, -0.04818129912018776, 0.007623428478837013, -0.04590034484863281, 0.03630674630403519, -0.06819161027669907, -0.015047173015773296, -0.006651062052696943, 0.02628771774470806, 0.010062286630272865, 0.025264734402298927, 0.010967795737087727, -0.016105014830827713, 0.047490209341049194, 0.0597560741007328, -0.059229400008916855, 0.04440094903111458, -0.004458218347281218, -0.004453431349247694, 0.03739887848496437, -0.022082258015871048, 0.02754283882677555, -0.004671914037317038, 0.030613774433732033, -0.014560847543179989, -0.026498781517148018, -0.03261825442314148, 0.0595955029129982, -0.034020230174064636, -0.006083404179662466, 0.07549774646759033, 0.021155670285224915, -0.040928374975919724, -0.0044581834226846695, 0.014193709008395672, 0.028546135872602463, 0.005789537448436022, -0.05023105815052986, -0.00034010683884844184, -0.0018727374263107777, 0.02868788316845894, 0.02912111207842827, -0.013611444272100925, -0.038560304790735245, 0.032929833978414536, -0.004686279688030481, -0.007243843283504248, 0.028386596590280533, -0.037205249071121216, 0.05697350576519966, -0.001626293989829719, -0.00833100639283657, 0.017539629712700844, -0.011325482279062271, 0.01816650480031967, 0.005755296442657709, -0.037987858057022095, 0.024907460436224937, -0.06654112786054611, -0.010213712230324745, 0.000642623461317271, -0.020284630358219147, -0.025360016152262688, 0.024202678352594376, -0.06162118911743164, -0.04765227437019348, -0.03172004595398903, 0.046236563473939896, 0.06135185435414314, -0.0008392767049372196, -0.010005245916545391, 0.03623786196112633, 0.003636277513578534, -0.04345228523015976, 0.06054233759641647, -0.0572364516556263, 0.012832578271627426, -0.06942954659461975, -0.01895100623369217, 0.025279926136136055, -0.03169099986553192, -0.03618232533335686, -0.013992654159665108, -0.02926257625222206, 0.009110357612371445, 0.0016192487673833966, -0.01752619445323944, -0.02483980730175972, 0.06013071537017822, 0.03545166552066803, -0.024621376767754555, 0.04176129028201103, 0.03439744561910629, -0.04367508366703987, 0.018066011369228363, 0.011057181283831596, -0.007848115637898445, -0.019980426877737045, 0.05843539908528328, 0.04282665625214577, -0.002268989570438862, -0.007219000719487667, -0.043482210487127304, 0.026963593438267708, -0.006828202400356531, 0.039669010788202286, 0.042243801057338715, -0.011703495867550373, 0.0025023638736456633, 0.00675756111741066, 0.012806055136024952, 0.01395375095307827, -0.012042852118611336, 0.0235593318939209, 0.023990847170352936, 0.03430970013141632, 0.04638494551181793, 0.002707518870010972, 0.04410688206553459, -0.049707431346178055, -0.05331583693623543, 0.001913762534968555, -0.040576670318841934, -0.02270977571606636, 0.08138200640678406, -0.011222400702536106, -0.03722777217626572, -0.09380422532558441, -0.0017394007882103324, -0.027928410097956657, -0.004351851996034384, 0.005245738662779331, 0.00903624389320612, -0.06685459613800049, -0.0054094865918159485, 0.05408262461423874, -0.013661345466971397, -0.013275684788823128, 0.009472210891544819, -0.025959113612771034, -0.053604915738105774, -0.08206146955490112, 0.02441267855465412, 0.01698281802237034, -0.027807077392935753, -0.009234393015503883, -0.007357587572187185, 0.06838922202587128, -0.048473142087459564, 0.003042751457542181, 0.021504485979676247, 0.015601766295731068, -0.029855404049158096, -0.02042078599333763, 0.031068895012140274, 0.042624786496162415, 0.018427636474370956, 0.013096101582050323, -0.008908571675419807, -0.049704667180776596, -0.012929694727063179, 0.0584263950586319, -0.04283647984266281, -0.011008798144757748, 0.006471297238022089, 0.03129652887582779, -0.03318064659833908, 0.007400005590170622, -0.012532725930213928, 0.07023623585700989, 0.056895721703767776, 0.0029234690591692924, -0.04291607066988945, -0.0573812760412693, 0.06638211756944656, 0.004893876146525145, -0.035589609295129776, 0.05476071313023567, 0.07251374423503876, -0.00879439152777195, 0.010605180636048317, -0.015269502997398376, 0.05391314625740051, -0.02219063974916935, 0.028410395607352257, -0.06196838244795799, 0.03201783820986748, 0.04234342649579048, -0.01290425006300211, 0.01912301778793335, -0.04498903825879097, 0.0723266527056694, -0.01800021156668663, 0.004790542181581259, 0.015650182962417603, 0.06485001742839813, 0.05730514973402023, 0.01550999004393816, -0.01507343165576458, -0.06215934455394745, -0.00436661159619689, 0.0150366872549057, -0.02605024352669716, 0.047268327325582504, -0.0067237503826618195, 0.02766745164990425, 0.02301959879696369, -0.019870635122060776, 0.01150834746658802, 0.01583150215446949, -0.05841313302516937, 0.000005636778041662183, 0.02989307977259159, -0.06548267602920532, -0.02887222170829773, 0.028167733922600746, 0.031544409692287445, 0.00027578542358241975, -0.04784202203154564, 0.0010660439729690552, -0.031052855774760246, -0.022296670824289322, 0.040499862283468246, 0.024131877347826958, 0.023343132808804512, -0.004157600924372673, 0.07294049113988876, -0.005429289303719997, 0.014177892357110977, 0.027993040159344673, 0.01843991130590439, -0.04275903478264809, -0.02426082082092762, 0.013653612695634365, 0.03995143249630928, 0.029209569096565247, -0.03377021476626396, 0.07665085047483444, -0.058858536183834076, 0.02979009784758091, -0.023572184145450592, 0.04669846594333649, 0.011172792874276638, 0.057633765041828156, -0.027004104107618332, 0.03422272205352783, -0.045772191137075424, -0.05169127881526947, -0.017241964116692543, 0.016285758465528488, 0.012682175263762474, -0.050052087754011154, -0.03793204203248024, 0.008716314099729061, 0.01523059792816639, -0.034272097051143646, 0.01313081756234169, 0.013592297211289406, 0.028538811951875687, 0.03422049805521965, 0.0419071763753891, 0.06030813977122307, -0.005754741374403238, 0.04309292137622833, -0.022871356457471848, -0.014290139079093933, -0.04898187890648842, -0.0018139445455744863, -0.004335771780461073, 0.02828145958483219, -0.01906001567840576, 0.018149210140109062, 0.04158443585038185, 0.03147856146097183, -0.029168687760829926, 0.033633820712566376, -0.017903849482536316, 0.00631667161360383, 0.074781633913517, -0.008736365474760532, 0.0135017866268754, 0.0402926504611969, -0.006454948801547289, -0.0327347032725811, -0.001195186167024076, 0.03968388959765434, 0.015478348359465599, -0.05042802169919014, 0.04404611885547638, 0.017792386934161186, -0.029991433024406433, 0.03161906078457832, 0.013920077122747898, 0.03811224550008774, -0.01683453656733036, 0.003553611459210515, -0.058839235454797745, 0.0826503336429596, 0.04965986683964729, 0.0012933514080941677, 0.023707496002316475, -0.010496562346816063, -0.025246230885386467, 0.023209957405924797, -0.06629838049411774, -0.015262814238667488, 0.045007262378931046, 0.050266869366168976, 0.025068501010537148, -0.016217343509197235, 0.033728741109371185, -0.052663203328847885, 0.048134759068489075, 0.026128314435482025, 0.030325872823596, -0.02930091693997383, 0.0188275258988142, -0.03601246699690819, -0.0050916289910674095, 0.04915492981672287, -0.027873853221535683, 0.03312467038631439, -0.017346547916531563, -0.04563368484377861, -0.036725182086229324, -0.04111286997795105, 0.025728799402713776, -0.01340364757925272, 0.001167365931905806, -0.022398320958018303, 0.006970750633627176, 0.010143372230231762, -0.06955043226480484, -0.034104302525520325, -0.016977936029434204, -0.04285365715622902, 0.05791351571679115, -0.00008690689719514921, 0.011118588037788868, -0.03815837204456329, -0.07561765611171722, -0.02503199130296707, -0.01497315987944603, -0.028504064306616783, -0.03973863273859024, -0.017025647684931755, 0.017788736149668694, 0.02482612058520317, 0.01998167112469673, -0.034865785390138626, -0.019097652286291122, -0.03042253665626049, -0.08195517957210541, -0.032948777079582214, -0.05582799017429352, -0.011795511469244957, 0.014352884143590927, -0.011330311186611652, 0.11507491022348404, -0.013423630967736244, -0.021636132150888443, 0.04680299013853073, -0.0867086723446846, -0.022288518026471138, -0.021643254905939102, -0.01656547747552395, 0.026653479784727097, 0.011332334950566292, 0.008749761618673801, 0.03221939876675606, -0.011452791281044483, -0.0203239843249321, -0.0007945002289488912, -0.006973936688154936, -0.0006696536438539624, 0.03506637364625931, 0.029101599007844925, -0.019336238503456116, 0.023789862170815468, -0.03687654808163643, -0.024879472330212593, -0.04213688522577286, -0.037739191204309464, 0.06890466064214706, 0.02293071150779724, 0.055453404784202576, 0.0027916983235627413, 0.003946351353079081, -0.07382350414991379, 0.03301865607500076, -0.0062254141084849834, 0.007411659695208073, 0.0018628877587616444, 0.0013689374318346381, -0.060811035335063934, 0.009141560643911362, -0.04289694130420685, -0.014213122427463531, -0.02250213548541069, 0.03858053311705589, -0.0319950096309185, -0.013958645053207874, -0.05792313069105148, 0.015580247156322002, -0.02240712381899357, 0.016972772777080536, 0.0407191701233387, 0.025090066716074944, 0.0631226971745491, 0.04723890870809555, 0.0392853207886219, -0.08802647143602371, 0.0011045869905501604, -0.02909773588180542, 0.0008443825063295662, 0.0007526861154474318, 0.02501731738448143, -0.002853380050510168, -0.0343179777264595, 0.006271966267377138, 0.06038844585418701, 0.028864165768027306, -0.06515203416347504, 0.01017065066844225, 0.04062667861580849, -0.06819329410791397, 0.016479166224598885, 0.05941766873002052, -0.016498183831572533, 0.00003968211603933014, -0.04816180095076561, -0.03213195502758026, -0.0424179881811142, -0.04857083782553673, 0.0028523604851216078, -0.008080394007265568, -0.01167872454971075, -0.0021381687838584185, -0.007192657794803381, -0.02769370563328266, -0.01105492189526558 ]
<p>A bob of mass m = 0.250kg is suspended from a fixed point with a massless string of length L = 25.0cm . You will investigate the motion in which the string traces a conical surface with half-angle θ = 21.0 deg <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/nTGlD.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>So what is the relationship between theta, mass and Tangential speed? An equation and an explanation would be nice as my text book is somewhat lacking when it comes to circular motion it only deals with orbit and im not sure if I can change one of those equations for this problem.</p>
g5905
[ 0.07876724749803543, 0.014675228856503963, 0.020438481122255325, -0.03920677676796913, 0.06519576907157898, 0.006256322842091322, 0.07921980321407318, -0.028411205857992172, -0.006213108543306589, -0.013837601989507675, -0.05548889562487602, 0.03290579095482826, 0.016346726566553116, -0.006110724527388811, 0.03393491730093956, -0.02702302858233452, 0.05566657334566116, -0.031638599932193756, 0.0015467804623767734, 0.08865965902805328, 0.05897941812872887, 0.014336015097796917, -0.01991519331932068, 0.014783496037125587, 0.012633486650884151, 0.007133087143301964, -0.0008704303181730211, -0.010911433026194572, -0.015384005382657051, 0.02973874658346176, 0.03126048669219017, 0.018683144822716713, 0.049502916634082794, -0.028603609651327133, -0.03345465287566185, -0.004591445904225111, 0.002995183225721121, -0.03257778286933899, 0.030820244923233986, 0.03400760889053345, 0.025482237339019775, -0.012780053541064262, -0.0014541170094162226, -0.014334551058709621, 0.013860506005585194, -0.040409330278635025, -0.005557726137340069, 0.01850772090256214, -0.0343816801905632, -0.01909407041966915, -0.058565184473991394, 0.008668594993650913, 0.04696571081876755, -0.040110211819410324, -0.058208025991916656, 0.02525760978460312, 0.08477078378200531, -0.05049886927008629, 0.04043649882078171, 0.05051383003592491, -0.03826387971639633, -0.04030630365014076, -0.03916294872760773, -0.0010680255945771933, 0.029762819409370422, -0.030587326735258102, -0.004018645733594894, 0.016536200419068336, 0.01606723666191101, 0.041193798184394836, -0.022104380652308464, -0.03966343775391579, -0.040331218391656876, -0.04954468086361885, -0.08965150266885757, 0.03519062697887421, -0.0002946578315459192, -0.027429398149251938, -0.05922265723347664, -0.017338432371616364, -0.03148054704070091, 0.027480414137244225, -0.023747768253087997, 0.035101987421512604, 0.058513838797807693, -0.08921266347169876, -0.0059376731514930725, 0.02301761321723461, -0.10351356863975525, -0.021654868498444557, 0.015829721465706825, -0.09324290603399277, 0.040032580494880676, 0.000196318345842883, 0.024208664894104004, -0.015701543539762497, -0.04070943221449852, 0.09573204815387726, 0.026780618354678154, 0.011540166102349758, -0.024427469819784164, -0.0018667314434424043, 0.01906236819922924, -0.0027448604814708233, 0.060015968978405, 0.024226516485214233, -0.0013129622675478458, 0.0068001700565218925, -0.010862049646675587, 0.0019177336944267154, -0.04327544942498207, -0.06623506546020508, -0.02887088432908058, -0.05427465960383415, 0.02022814378142357, -0.042728960514068604, 0.08003044128417969, 0.010480431839823723, 0.06007493659853935, 0.03793869540095329, -0.01551042590290308, -0.036497797816991806, -0.024599039927124977, 0.06054750829935074, -0.0749603882431984, 0.011821816675364971, -0.03315635398030281, -0.017356466501951218, 0.02845757268369198, 0.01926886849105358, -0.002599550411105156, -0.017030920833349228, -0.01344538014382124, 0.051459603011608124, 0.0005485643050633371, -0.008601387962698936, -0.06392495334148407, -0.012352131307125092, 0.004615589044988155, -0.007887519896030426, 0.022230438888072968, -0.05303347110748291, 0.03817842900753021, 0.04413885995745659, -0.03176899254322052, 0.06634054332971573, -0.024138743057847023, -0.02643810585141182, 0.054784856736660004, 0.039229635149240494, -0.04516066238284111, 0.08978060632944107, -0.024246256798505783, -0.04524397477507591, 0.06327635794878006, -0.009495713748037815, 0.016022736206650734, 0.023185519501566887, 0.017925459891557693, -0.040613189339637756, 0.05633365362882614, -0.018250998109579086, 0.06326427310705185, 0.00913826934993267, -0.05265728011727333, -0.003787527559325099, 0.017254728823900223, -0.03285793587565422, -0.05313412845134735, -0.06548251956701279, -0.029617607593536377, -0.006196176167577505, 0.001607418991625309, 0.10659623891115189, -0.01338765025138855, 0.0027255448512732983, 0.008088011294603348, 0.008372250944375992, -0.001810627058148384, 0.020119449123740196, 0.05321519076824188, -0.011540785431861877, 0.012579599395394325, 0.015520895831286907, 0.05707714706659317, 0.034107569605112076, 0.038615670055150986, -0.01230890303850174, -0.0821334570646286, 0.03146883100271225, 0.0070782131515443325, -0.06680672615766525, -0.03896503895521164, 0.02139263227581978, 0.016571616753935814, 0.006501085590571165, 0.06938023865222931, 0.015932081267237663, -0.029178356751799583, 0.0006556172156706452, 0.016239996999502182, -0.020200077444314957, 0.013327112421393394, -0.028201773762702942, 0.0021610339172184467, -0.04723300784826279, 0.047617267817258835, -0.018653251230716705, -0.01680154912173748, 0.022185849025845528, 0.014551234431564808, 0.02187272347509861, -0.018161389976739883, 0.0394069105386734, -0.018590077757835388, 0.01332917157560587, 0.03425201028585434, 0.015935096889734268, 0.0009706067503429949, -0.004194710403680801, -0.013830052688717842, -0.052517641335725784, 0.007971568964421749, -0.06443250179290771, 0.030075596645474434, -0.03890212997794151, 0.015594374388456345, -0.08519160747528076, 0.01138452161103487, 0.059553321450948715, 0.012636294588446617, -0.0019225557334721088, -0.0011851111194118857, 0.01278847549110651, 0.021425042301416397, 0.008575225248932838, 0.06048472598195076, -0.03504108637571335, 0.022421101108193398, 0.013367311097681522, 0.0280411746352911, -0.02458462491631508, -0.004788150545209646, -0.055253688246011734, 0.04200509935617447, -0.022910447791218758, 0.06549924612045288, 0.03553632274270058, 0.009724797680974007, 0.012113653123378754, 0.036442797631025314, -0.022953327745199203, -0.05216718092560768, -0.025465138256549835, 0.05381670221686363, 0.04300093278288841, -0.08570600301027298, 0.03522099554538727, -0.06374229490756989, -0.03711432218551636, -0.040005072951316833, -0.039345432072877884, -0.013080277480185032, -0.015842553228139877, -0.024504533037543297, -0.025710364803671837, -0.026620138436555862, -0.05755174905061722, -0.014926435425877571, 0.01464345958083868, -0.06890186667442322, 0.03219587728381157, 0.006433393806219101, 0.04675302281975746, -0.040649887174367905, -0.019271457567811012, 0.008330813609063625, -0.044659968465566635, -0.028659936040639877, -0.010488982312381268, -0.015190238133072853, -0.024160288274288177, -0.05050934478640556, 0.0467846505343914, -0.018630389124155045, -0.03178306668996811, -0.015854571014642715, 0.03733555227518082, -0.027552084997296333, 0.019918499514460564, -0.004153641406446695, 0.03215715289115906, 0.03327300772070885, 0.026247425004839897, 0.04237007349729538, 0.12774860858917236, 0.012229539453983307, -0.011648138053715229, 0.01756153255701065, 0.0018736219499260187, -0.009092050604522228, -0.004676878917962313, -0.03186677023768425, 0.019427916035056114, -0.025493411347270012, -0.0016880796756595373, -0.012868547812104225, -0.05270199850201607, -0.0049293008632957935, 0.01590682752430439, -0.02605760656297207, 0.02044094167649746, 0.0312688872218132, -0.03654317185282707, -0.010355387814342976, 0.04127706587314606, -0.03704245761036873, -0.0064294710755348206, -0.015196654945611954, 0.04892361909151077, -0.07146532088518143, -0.04929593950510025, 0.016932137310504913, -0.012257796712219715, -0.007862488739192486, 0.0021862329449504614, 0.0011735174339264631, 0.03999854624271393, -0.030760321766138077, -0.053774986416101456, 0.012313169427216053, -0.05275709927082062, 0.010814877226948738, -0.02693158946931362, 0.03224708139896393, -0.056042201817035675, 0.030670834705233574, 0.014395708218216896, 0.02083265408873558, 0.019422532990574837, -0.06443746387958527, 0.009555541910231113, -0.047225527465343475, -0.027073964476585388, 0.042010899633169174, -0.0035970488097518682, 0.028934592381119728, 0.01789786107838154, 0.0016460212646052241, -0.014819118194282055, 0.038799818605184555, -0.011011133901774883, -0.013363322243094444, -0.015148264355957508, -0.003256838768720627, 0.08087262511253357, -0.006833416875451803, -0.018588479608297348, 0.00045688083628192544, -0.04381744936108589, 0.02046181820333004, 0.01946355774998665, -0.016610560938715935, 0.042671333998441696, 0.02253044955432415, -0.0355396531522274, -0.01769409328699112, 0.050872042775154114, 0.011489647440612316, 0.023111622780561447, -0.031068390235304832, -0.056692689657211304, 0.0014710581162944436, -0.029027288779616356, 0.0339602567255497, -0.026151888072490692, -0.0019113377202302217, -0.011449732817709446, -0.010155823081731796, 0.031043943017721176, 0.03910824656486511, -0.02452782168984413, 0.004142832476645708, 0.005298583302646875, -0.003277194919064641, 0.04629696533083916, -0.07921405136585236, 0.013247467577457428, 0.035643450915813446, -0.04801566153764725, 0.013796486891806126, -0.054950106889009476, -0.01065886951982975, -0.09378267079591751, 0.04629069194197655, -0.041066985577344894, 0.032940350472927094, 0.0032048369757831097, 0.023500841110944748, 0.006102751940488815, 0.005753753706812859, -0.012107839807868004, -0.013411012478172779, 0.023877758532762527, -0.029941348358988762, 0.08301497995853424, -0.0029169891495257616, -0.04311813786625862, 0.01667761616408825, -0.05677599832415581, 0.001263258745893836, -0.026471268385648727, -0.002845658687874675, -0.012517555616796017, 0.07193782925605774, 0.04227740317583084, 0.02108319103717804, 0.01373240165412426, -0.05395205318927765, -0.006563928443938494, -0.06651966273784637, 0.01572260819375515, -0.0006239906651899219, -0.034070536494255066, -0.05516158416867256, 0.04639274254441261, 0.07661300897598267, 0.009791753254830837, 0.005889421794563532, -0.01073287520557642, 0.0033695464953780174, 0.02051827497780323, -0.010974859818816185, 0.07224228978157043, -0.03447681665420532, 0.08909149467945099, 0.001829673768952489, 0.05921100825071335, 0.003657778725028038, -0.004476065281778574, 0.05028708279132843, 0.025517253205180168, -0.010882510803639889, -0.030574439093470573, -0.06731383502483368, 0.033989258110523224, -0.0026444026734679937, -0.018730025738477707, -0.029491903260350227, -0.028460396453738213, -0.016042981296777725, 0.0015030192444100976, -0.022491587325930595, -0.03352537378668785, -0.014710512012243271, -0.02849038876593113, -0.009117438457906246, 0.02709038183093071, 0.013281130231916904, -0.042229924350976944, -0.014912908896803856, 0.011836945079267025, 0.04704146087169647, -0.013350659050047398, 0.0629873275756836, -0.04425767809152603, -0.009997083805501461, 0.008596031926572323, -0.013813451863825321, 0.017426535487174988, -0.01025228388607502, 0.040643058717250824, 0.03176730498671532, 0.017926771193742752, 0.006605049595236778, -0.05585285276174545, -0.0025927440728992224, 0.006304376758635044, 0.014564692974090576, -0.03729359433054924, -0.03501206263899803, 0.01509577315300703, -0.0044816662557423115, 0.0005714084836654365, 0.01597362384200096, -0.003234579460695386, -0.04096574708819389, 0.012765547260642052, 0.0035360248293727636, 0.008326693437993526, -0.005381221417337656, 0.02349579706788063, -0.04169296845793724, 0.006510713137686253, -0.0011296800803393126, -0.05111856758594513, -0.021456006914377213, -0.019485045224428177, 0.003371451050043106, -0.005645460914820433, -0.0363621786236763, 0.01631106436252594, 0.0084910299628973, 0.07124625891447067, -0.007793032098561525, 0.07996188849210739, 0.06395869702100754, -0.02263246662914753, 0.011564678512513638, 0.022258074954152107, 0.011534785851836205, 0.08265373110771179, 0.0035170356277376413, -0.025210799649357796, -0.0003446759656071663, 0.005826982203871012, 0.044062454253435135, 0.002789107384160161, 0.0005822100210934877, 0.06884048879146576, 0.05779275670647621, 0.03147632256150246, -0.027507800608873367, -0.0041324482299387455, 0.004816302563995123, -0.0014789877459406853, -0.02665485441684723, -0.027364999055862427, 0.003434621263295412, -0.028507499024271965, 0.011608967557549477, -0.04318256676197052, 0.07324239611625671, -0.026717450469732285, -0.05654367804527283, -0.02458737976849079, 0.05668586492538452, -0.02970200590789318, 0.02910100854933262, -0.04262213036417961, -0.08786355704069138, -0.0349692776799202, 0.07461568713188171, 0.047839127480983734, 0.00855252519249916, -0.022492196410894394, -0.038466956466436386, -0.01646222546696663, 0.011733357794582844, 0.038498152047395706, -0.04864094406366348, 0.011309701018035412, -0.001898840069770813, 0.0030850900802761316, -0.041072484105825424, 0.010428705252707005, -0.046550020575523376, -0.00795641541481018, -0.05580374225974083, -0.023034678772091866, 0.06539063900709152, -0.013587066903710365, 0.11339527368545532, 0.08353538811206818, -0.003515256103128195, -0.021773241460323334, -0.01791665144264698, 0.040091391652822495, 0.0804813951253891, -0.015842869877815247, -0.02388346940279007, 0.03143547102808952, -0.0907149687409401, 0.045345697551965714, 0.00641628447920084, 0.033903807401657104, -0.0226594228297472, -0.02526860125362873, -0.06930182874202728, 0.044757332652807236, -0.011629353277385235, 0.0005572717636823654, -0.006610021460801363, -0.022347712889313698, -0.006810124963521957, 0.014299169182777405, -0.027872439473867416, -0.03351399302482605, 0.017788397148251534, 0.0016702839639037848, -0.022576961666345596, 0.01211543008685112, -0.012988284230232239, -0.039269354194402695, -0.028785618022084236, -0.0006957452278584242, -0.020472222939133644, 0.009193401783704758, -0.023603031411767006, 0.03785376623272896, -0.006936133839190006, 0.00002101856080116704, 0.07155650109052658, 0.02138163149356842, 0.009441912174224854, 0.004721291363239288, 0.022610967978835106, -0.018024060875177383, -0.021079260855913162, -0.00826015044003725, 0.040764570236206055, 0.03992427513003349, 0.013545126654207706, 0.007992015220224857, -0.05651861056685448, 0.02486453950405121, -0.033260781317949295, 0.0015633590519428253, -0.061596859246492386, -0.02145524136722088, 0.02465526945888996, 0.036432988941669464, 0.019068175926804543, 0.004741534125059843, 0.04719730466604233, -0.027635054662823677, -0.01616002805531025, 0.02118826098740101, 0.026924511417746544, -0.016738228499889374, 0.025579718872904778, -0.05161813646554947, 0.031930238008499146, 0.03452131524682045, -0.014698732644319534, 0.06179725378751755, -0.04154377430677414, 0.014642223715782166, 0.06317079067230225, 0.0790795162320137, 0.0741344690322876, 0.02855846844613552, -0.01919359154999256, -0.005014027934521437, -0.05569564551115036, -0.00994877889752388, 0.025245770812034607, 0.06270330399274826, -0.039987023919820786, -0.012096633203327656, -0.02988162636756897, 0.040829263627529144, -0.037229154258966446, 0.022077033296227455, -0.018034186214208603, -0.03665595501661301, -0.0351325161755085, 0.014512225054204464, 0.03222106769680977, -0.039301998913288116, -0.08178167790174484, 0.011666825041174889, 0.03761252015829086, -0.049012456089258194, 0.02588702365756035, 0.04164116457104683, -0.013526850380003452, -0.016039861366152763, -0.0035982769913971424, -0.014234863221645355, -0.0466080866754055, -0.02762315608561039, -0.011594885028898716, -0.0021569293458014727, 0.005431308876723051, 0.0723019614815712, -0.021298808977007866, -0.04707701504230499, -0.056323807686567307, 0.04426001384854317, 0.035380080342292786, -0.0468343049287796, 0.03267696127295494, -0.0034291003830730915, -0.031100714579224586, 0.07029927521944046, 0.00044951672316528857, 0.011738636530935764, 0.056308597326278687, 0.005753449629992247, 0.018111487850546837, 0.08597788214683533, 0.02422073483467102, -0.03395354747772217, 0.048361387103796005, -0.019794534891843796, 0.0020342583302408457, 0.05644315108656883, 0.0330878421664238, 0.004966344218701124, 0.005511948838829994, -0.01784771867096424, -0.012009783647954464, 0.009765771217644215, 0.050162095576524734, 0.034132733941078186, -0.04282139614224434, -0.002019824692979455, -0.04374745115637779, -0.004327625036239624, -0.013010342605412006, -0.029059555381536484, 0.004579737316817045, 0.010001580230891705, 0.012611460871994495, 0.01736479252576828, -0.07698620855808258, 0.055940236896276474, -0.03344184160232544, 0.006159672979265451, -0.03478575125336647, -0.0006125033251009881, 0.006790332030504942, -0.07901836931705475, 0.014352799393236637, -0.05555553734302521, -0.016875693574547768, -0.026930004358291626, -0.002403402701020241, -0.032586757093667984, -0.00007795227429596707, 0.005642601288855076, -0.04615941271185875, -0.0013983560493215919, -0.03326203301548958, 0.02766435779631138, -0.0020825534593313932, -0.05891027674078941, -0.009349899366497993, -0.009161923080682755, 0.022577857598662376, -0.030326038599014282, 0.008278093300759792, 0.009028749540448189, 0.0006322130211628973, 0.030369896441698074, -0.0074225179851055145, 0.023900793865323067, 0.03328337520360947, 0.01696600764989853, 0.03689166158437729, 0.02689945697784424, -0.035907380282878876, 0.02453979291021824, -0.01576460711658001, -0.055237896740436554, -0.004637957084923983, -0.026948263868689537, -0.009668359532952309, -0.010883389972150326, -0.021527698263525963, -0.013830522075295448, -0.014708569273352623, 0.01708883047103882, -0.002332492731511593, -0.01819138042628765, -0.055378034710884094, 0.021883781999349594 ]
<p>I have an elevator accelerating upwards at an acceleration of $a$. A mercury barometer measures the atmoshperic pressure at this point. Will the reading be less than, more than or equal to $76 \ cm$ of $Hg$?</p> <p>I remembered from my class that the pressure in a liquid in an nonintertial frame accelerating upwards at $a$ is $\rho h (g + a)$. So, my first thought was it would be less that $76cm$ of $Hg$. But, then I realized that as you are accelerating upwards, you are hitting the air molecules faster and more often. So, technically, the atmoshperic pressure in our frame of reference should increase. But, then again I thought that air was compressible, so maybe that would skew off the results. What's the correct answer? </p>
g5906
[ 0.037346579134464264, 0.01728546991944313, 0.00866662710905075, 0.019321531057357788, 0.023120641708374023, 0.026805413886904716, 0.05572712421417236, 0.009076341055333614, -0.09250295162200928, -0.004419049713760614, 0.02757120132446289, 0.045547399669885635, -0.03029078245162964, -0.025958623737096786, 0.05216921120882034, 0.01860404573380947, 0.07623559981584549, -0.04445894807577133, 0.041344527155160904, -0.02513035573065281, 0.026138272136449814, -0.01434983592480421, -0.005466626025736332, -0.09005523473024368, 0.014316770248115063, 0.02178218774497509, 0.01979469321668148, -0.029938822612166405, -0.07383003830909729, 0.05209993198513985, -0.025820866227149963, -0.010250916704535484, -0.01575743965804577, -0.024077769368886948, 0.020232457667589188, -0.013277856633067131, 0.046778514981269836, 0.0485684871673584, 0.03540954366326332, -0.07108902186155319, 0.029914960265159607, 0.012718001380562782, 0.028076041489839554, -0.004060452338308096, -0.026435919106006622, 0.00648378673940897, -0.024025825783610344, -0.015614759176969528, -0.04587431997060776, -0.027346352115273476, -0.06151333451271057, 0.05093424767255783, -0.05708983540534973, -0.023499008268117905, -0.055281251668930054, 0.04997917264699936, 0.006253425497561693, -0.01508281845599413, 0.00537618063390255, 0.07666677981615067, -0.028350651264190674, -0.024056734517216682, 0.06615135073661804, -0.016286931931972504, 0.0038851043209433556, 0.034511640667915344, -0.03420613706111908, -0.012599674984812737, -0.03920956328511238, -0.015577407553792, 0.04905443266034126, -0.02158413827419281, -0.05198129639029503, -0.027565859258174896, -0.0634288489818573, -0.006002034060657024, -0.04563746601343155, -0.021382305771112442, 0.08132516592741013, 0.038130853325128555, 0.007215884979814291, -0.008090615272521973, 0.02424497716128826, -0.07621608674526215, 0.011566702276468277, 0.0005453344201669097, 0.01068586390465498, 0.022396456450223923, -0.006697002332657576, -0.0014018372166901827, 0.04019288346171379, -0.02121594175696373, 0.07058711349964142, 0.019108597189188004, -0.023652734234929085, 0.05532335117459297, 0.03110668435692787, 0.06280767917633057, 0.018402494490146637, 0.009353209286928177, -0.0424218587577343, -0.005727831274271011, 0.01483866199851036, -0.018655112013220787, 0.0006910826778039336, -0.028111204504966736, 0.0232962965965271, -0.024260379374027252, 0.0026338216848671436, -0.08279669284820557, 0.010524602606892586, 0.0007268244517035782, -0.09711358696222305, -0.09190469235181808, -0.04326057434082031, -0.04339553415775299, 0.03937540203332901, 0.034885503351688385, -0.015711495652794838, -0.006041666958481073, 0.0397769920527935, 0.08324010670185089, 0.0277472622692585, 0.021497970446944237, -0.020901525393128395, -0.005894743371754885, -0.02415800280869007, 0.03932593762874603, -0.03249324485659599, -0.04027263820171356, 0.0423545204102993, 0.013402285054326057, -0.013385179452598095, -0.022925807163119316, -0.014678556472063065, -0.03716051205992699, -0.03528490290045738, -0.012794981710612774, 0.01357380673289299, 0.07934772223234177, 0.014730353839695454, -0.04715265706181526, 0.005006149411201477, -0.02786293253302574, 0.015389811247587204, 0.004904648754745722, -0.029533693566918373, 0.031218141317367554, 0.04812979698181152, 0.012992281466722488, -0.035812895745038986, 0.04687538370490074, 0.02652738429605961, -0.016987066715955734, 0.01280795969069004, 0.027494799345731735, 0.045302316546440125, 0.016829483211040497, 0.03980863466858864, 0.04527215287089348, 0.068141870200634, -0.039250459522008896, 0.030069589614868164, 0.016704438254237175, -0.0783778578042984, 0.010003230534493923, 0.000930237234570086, -0.008266952820122242, 0.016668254509568214, -0.020447775721549988, -0.066078782081604, -0.013922296464443207, 0.08016850054264069, -0.03723965585231781, 0.0024407904129475355, 0.022225042805075645, 0.0959542915225029, -0.018439345061779022, 0.011025872081518173, -0.0064469086937606335, 0.023018015548586845, -0.02321019023656845, 0.026387063786387444, -0.08027318865060806, -0.015094819478690624, 0.05326366052031517, 0.01142873615026474, 0.0023208525963127613, -0.059793371707201004, 0.018807843327522278, 0.03664683178067207, -0.013829684816300869, 0.006090778391808271, -0.007818736135959625, -0.051107898354530334, -0.017005890607833862, 0.0032532913610339165, -0.020194731652736664, -0.03849215805530548, 0.04275405406951904, -0.037636712193489075, 0.049992065876722336, 0.0014190453803166747, 0.015398813411593437, 0.0703858807682991, 0.030697206035256386, -0.0067831529304385185, -0.05074271559715271, 0.002137066563591361, -0.010724680498242378, 0.009777354076504707, 0.04043121263384819, 0.027690688148140907, -0.004677194636315107, 0.02708665281534195, -0.000795929750893265, 0.022281410172581673, 0.003580008167773485, -0.011368639767169952, 0.022498684003949165, -0.0036791949532926083, 0.012477803975343704, 0.004639903549104929, -0.045977745205163956, -0.05263949930667877, -0.04380091279745102, -0.027700232341885567, -0.012303128838539124, 0.029031161218881607, -0.03796934336423874, 0.008458718657493591, 0.045721471309661865, -0.021665846928954124, -0.057420894503593445, 0.04178217053413391, 0.004951792769134045, 0.0038282477762550116, 0.046651050448417664, 0.040509965270757675, 0.03270037844777107, -0.011859919875860214, -0.03204351291060448, -0.04050610214471817, 0.023829437792301178, 0.017116768285632133, 0.019229771569371223, -0.0046096071600914, 0.03851483762264252, 0.015692977234721184, 0.015498877502977848, -0.050186268985271454, 0.004261036869138479, 0.018957087770104408, 0.0408962108194828, 0.007978670299053192, 0.0013760840520262718, -0.047055434435606, -0.019675906747579575, -0.06816112250089645, -0.011527040973305702, 0.045391473919153214, -0.020794348791241646, -0.0489434078335762, -0.040907829999923706, -0.1055520623922348, 0.024850906804203987, -0.028081556782126427, -0.003931024577468634, -0.010906103067100048, 0.02574446238577366, 0.04631633311510086, 0.05058275908231735, -0.011107067577540874, 0.03423959016799927, -0.008311704732477665, -0.008838105946779251, -0.00032150535844266415, -0.0039126076735556126, 0.03920208662748337, -0.0616639107465744, -0.08740732073783875, -0.0010999072110280395, -0.025063855573534966, 0.01275333110243082, -0.01430312916636467, -0.02838761918246746, 0.007975871674716473, 0.0528734065592289, -0.02180071733891964, 0.03505610674619675, 0.003382149850949645, 0.017578016966581345, 0.011740175075829029, 0.0597456619143486, -0.00559538509696722, 0.027173161506652832, 0.020279211923480034, 0.03876848891377449, 0.024302436038851738, -0.004208680707961321, 0.015676584094762802, -0.07816941291093826, -0.015811756253242493, 0.06389592587947845, 0.027940208092331886, 0.016701359301805496, -0.05917204171419144, -0.04676434025168419, -0.02452395297586918, 0.048633214086294174, 0.021465100347995758, 0.013659111224114895, -0.013910599984228611, 0.011829725466668606, -0.07922691106796265, -0.07150588929653168, 0.03190434351563454, -0.03065682202577591, 0.012653494253754616, 0.030669523403048515, -0.036819420754909515, -0.1217682957649231, -0.0051115406677126884, -0.022243449464440346, 0.026473918929696083, -0.0032517402432858944, 0.03551555052399635, 0.016935355961322784, -0.04423777014017105, -0.05345222353935242, 0.04727800190448761, 0.019495787099003792, -0.02211688831448555, -0.008688785135746002, -0.01816328428685665, -0.042633600533008575, -0.005066910292953253, 0.042943667620420456, 0.00019503565272316337, -0.012083319015800953, -0.00399424321949482, 0.009595255367457867, 0.00010454038419993594, -0.057511407881975174, -0.015173230320215225, 0.023899370804429054, -0.0073036327958106995, 0.02766902931034565, -0.042144015431404114, -0.019185950979590416, 0.05465216562151909, -0.024216054007411003, -0.011624913662672043, -0.03933684900403023, 0.015092413872480392, 0.011063111014664173, 0.0256864782422781, 0.031330931931734085, -0.002209734870120883, 0.0002453180786687881, -0.009992348030209541, -0.015180778689682484, -0.0027889879420399666, 0.06777658313512802, 0.02516639232635498, -0.05143004283308983, -0.0031217297073453665, 0.09269637614488602, -0.01771824061870575, -0.02308765798807144, -0.021113205701112747, -0.011668790131807327, 0.03718124330043793, 0.0120350681245327, 0.035604070872068405, -0.054466117173433304, 0.03955187276005745, -0.02875578962266445, 0.032340578734874725, 0.03015780821442604, 0.056244026869535446, -0.025136686861515045, -0.03705925866961479, -0.016116077080368996, 0.02341303415596485, -0.0209867674857378, -0.02198323979973793, 0.0017805277602747083, 0.004668776411563158, -0.08295277506113052, 0.010125438682734966, -0.04739886149764061, -0.022639097645878792, 0.05762432888150215, 0.001688481424935162, -0.044369228184223175, 0.03078857995569706, 0.003895648056641221, -0.03616134822368622, 0.04100728780031204, -0.017339961603283882, 0.025769144296646118, 0.0028162626549601555, 0.04540802538394928, -0.07689744234085083, 0.055654529482126236, 0.06385699659585953, 0.012748541310429573, -0.02686726115643978, 0.023529134690761566, 0.02515934221446514, 0.0009920585434883833, -0.05473260581493378, -0.06468535214662552, 0.007570833899080753, 0.035113681107759476, 0.023734845221042633, -0.03334991633892059, 0.04127148166298866, 0.006589967757463455, 0.04804808273911476, 0.04733184725046158, 0.059237003326416016, 0.011357061564922333, -0.057474590837955475, 0.06095763295888901, 0.036260150372982025, 0.0015242170775309205, 0.027644118294119835, -0.022760611027479172, 0.007080006878823042, -0.041255317628383636, 0.02493506483733654, 0.0805826410651207, -0.002278630156069994, 0.04219713807106018, 0.09673544019460678, 0.0027431133203208447, 0.05500178784132004, -0.02491634711623192, 0.05908874422311783, 0.020895719528198242, -0.01297411322593689, 0.03467148169875145, 0.06743314117193222, 0.03669034317135811, -0.04673829302191734, -0.029568081721663475, 0.011562732979655266, 0.029014859348535538, -0.0809929221868515, 0.005447886418551207, 0.0146007239818573, -0.006599827669560909, 0.006506274454295635, -0.003335168119519949, -0.030707379803061485, -0.009695096872746944, -0.003106718650087714, 0.03409874066710472, -0.027090877294540405, -0.0061841318383812904, -0.0506775826215744, 0.03978710249066353, 0.03718666732311249, -0.056714531034231186, -0.0504254549741745, -0.02415459416806698, -0.02580941654741764, 0.006248715333640575, -0.0008501087431795895, -0.01410482358187437, 0.007310831919312477, 0.06727763265371323, -0.0044527677819132805, 0.07029707729816437, 0.03023487702012062, -0.017112040892243385, 0.02164255641400814, -0.04797693341970444, -0.01934991590678692, 0.03803912177681923, 0.048114627599716187, 0.03821595013141632, 0.0017282682238146663, 0.022769328206777573, -0.0322573184967041, -0.008888807147741318, 0.032615192234516144, 0.002265044953674078, 0.014328098855912685, 0.03381650522351265, -0.031432632356882095, -0.05149116367101669, -0.07112365961074829, -0.01611119695007801, 0.028004048392176628, -0.03214964643120766, -0.01598820462822914, -0.013290074653923512, -0.09961584210395813, 0.00521727092564106, -0.03972746431827545, 0.0025295643135905266, 0.010861246846616268, -0.012345029041171074, 0.0009930689120665193, -0.008103772066533566, 0.00881609320640564, 0.11944147199392319, -0.02752208150923252, 0.010271970182657242, 0.04155654087662697, 0.04216568544507027, 0.017846351489424706, -0.03891290724277496, 0.0036042805295437574, 0.01917632296681404, -0.04816490784287453, -0.08098597824573517, 0.05273300036787987, -0.04047238454222679, 0.03314298391342163, 0.018657637760043144, -0.033380087465047836, 0.04742669686675072, 0.01679900288581848, 0.0030234402511268854, 0.008648475632071495, 0.00014738486788701266, 0.012019764631986618, -0.015141868963837624, 0.018596431240439415, -0.04163890331983566, 0.0406494103372097, 0.029418621212244034, 0.001485678949393332, -0.00122131931129843, 0.06552188098430634, 0.010189153254032135, -0.09829980880022049, 0.007339552044868469, -0.005509088281542063, 0.05787946283817291, 0.028145866468548775, 0.010375899262726307, -0.08030866086483002, 0.018652601167559624, 0.009765666909515858, 0.0012883680174127221, -0.04902947321534157, -0.006837074179202318, -0.04054345563054085, 0.03315992280840874, 0.00422018114477396, 0.07187226414680481, 0.05348606035113335, -0.018826737999916077, 0.03027985244989395, -0.012573504820466042, 0.0450826920568943, -0.01739192008972168, -0.00008060604159254581, 0.031204206869006157, 0.04104108363389969, -0.05073409155011177, 0.017094552516937256, 0.0060375891625881195, 0.028088266029953957, -0.011916263028979301, -0.04412182793021202, 0.005706729367375374, 0.0030571974348276854, 0.014201526530086994, 0.012976993806660175, 0.04594465717673302, -0.07805278152227402, -0.0001595839421497658, -0.03703312948346138, 0.012093170545995235, -0.06671310216188431, 0.005160517990589142, 0.03103509731590748, -0.03206351399421692, 0.025088563561439514, -0.03729420155286789, -0.028251884505152702, 0.04068782925605774, 0.030059901997447014, 0.022771384567022324, 0.0033186234068125486, -0.008914395235478878, 0.0012183930957689881, -0.01612652838230133, -0.1048266813158989, -0.013306782580912113, -0.002864967565983534, -0.04249504208564758, -0.029491735622286797, -0.009160195477306843, 0.061088960617780685, 0.05914686247706413, 0.02501690573990345, -0.06061854958534241, 0.005804006941616535, -0.018265215680003166, -0.021983260288834572, 0.038625407963991165, 0.03129894658923149, -0.05827726796269417, -0.02272026240825653, -0.01948552206158638, 0.06327082961797714, 0.0021355811040848494, 0.0326552651822567, -0.007621885742992163, 0.050427358597517014, -0.030698545277118683, -0.018077431246638298, 0.005562222097069025, 0.013353826478123665, -0.015665598213672638, 0.00709670502692461, -0.04050882160663605, 0.0493074506521225, -0.012103289365768433, -0.0016072973376139998, -0.006887536961585283, -0.0033195035066455603, -0.01190955750644207, 0.004971934482455254, -0.01102657150477171, -0.03893179073929787, 0.009992999024689198, 0.021318549290299416, -0.0018090603407472372, -0.005663812626153231, 0.021490316838026047, 0.00901747401803732, 0.023421406745910645, 0.007815917022526264, -0.009435757994651794, -0.026724958792328835, 0.02769954316318035, -0.024348819628357887, -0.04130859673023224, -0.01816726103425026, 0.03418992459774017, -0.028188291937112808, 0.002009257208555937, 0.00002279673753946554, -0.06545517593622208, -0.023254727944731712, 0.050729166716337204, -0.039169859141111374, 0.013483005575835705, 0.004447441082447767, 0.02752271294593811, 0.00809740275144577, -0.029965877532958984, 0.022914055734872818, -0.053724661469459534, -0.009479967877268791, 0.0481288768351078, -0.04394680634140968, -0.0045899897813797, -0.012312894687056541, -0.05577904358506203, -0.026966746896505356, 0.01639590784907341, -0.0075521403923630714, -0.00985769834369421, -0.04728350415825844, -0.023769177496433258, 0.017944911494851112, 0.044780220836400986, -0.033937450498342514, -0.04304443672299385, -0.019422942772507668, 0.03083145059645176, -0.009266053326427937, 0.001204713131301105, 0.00524812750518322, 0.002618895610794425, -0.024538451805710793, 0.03705569729208946, -0.019053563475608826, -0.02763102576136589, 0.03435591608285904, -0.059267815202474594, -0.002508957637473941, -0.009203090332448483, 0.039488352835178375, -0.019008172675967216, -0.058750756084918976, 0.05113041028380394, -0.00899502169340849, 0.023659713566303253, -0.05655800551176071, -0.04365209490060806, 0.012808513827621937, -0.003044873708859086, 0.0054865204729139805, 0.01257255207747221, -0.005728620570152998, 0.03408784419298172, 0.050524428486824036, 0.010409553535282612, 0.011106740683317184, 0.038835637271404266, 0.009780560620129108, -0.004025452770292759, 0.006134201772511005, -0.023393241688609123, 0.09716185182332993, -0.02465876378118992, -0.012202277779579163, -0.06376729160547256, 0.015878092497587204, -0.019823521375656128, -0.028904663398861885, 0.01001978013664484, -0.02797723188996315, -0.023063333705067635, -0.025646867230534554, 0.04859186336398125, -0.013600225560367107, 0.01826833374798298, -0.027243539690971375, -0.060076866298913956, -0.032555725425481796, -0.006610710173845291, -0.026718618348240852, 0.03658685088157654, -0.03464706987142563, -0.019900400191545486, 0.014538701623678207, 0.005466966424137354, 0.03656458482146263, 0.015962015837430954, 0.026193158701062202, -0.05957076698541641, -0.0003563479403965175, 0.01162950973957777, 0.07033133506774902, -0.012924243696033955, -0.019322097301483154, 0.014159251004457474, 0.06263519078493118, -0.02909057028591633, 0.0368359237909317, 0.007769155316054821, 0.026936247944831848, 0.03434504568576813, 0.022686505690217018, -0.05180032551288605, -0.0287246722728014, 0.0049626692198216915, -0.07051833719015121, -0.04754549264907837, 0.007970371283590794, -0.005745895206928253, 0.021952353417873383, -0.06334908306598663, 0.0005654442356899381, -0.020161820575594902, -0.0589105486869812, 0.04443215951323509 ]
<p>Now there are two papers</p> <p><strong>The quantum state cannot be interpreted statistically</strong></p> <p><a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1111.3328" rel="nofollow">http://arxiv.org/abs/1111.3328</a></p> <p>(It was discussed <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/17170/consequences-of-the-new-theorem-in-qm">here</a> the consecuences of this "no-go theorem")</p> <p>And this one (two of the authors are the same as the previous paper):</p> <p><strong>The quantum state can be interpreted statistically</strong></p> <p><a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/1201.6554" rel="nofollow">http://arxiv.org/abs/1201.6554</a></p> <p>I would like to note this: <strong>titles give only poor information about the content</strong>, and they seem even maliciously chosen, but the mere existence of the two papers is funny anyway.. </p> <p>The question is : <strong>Which is more general!?</strong></p> <p>From the paper: <em>"Recently, a no-go theorem was proven [21] showing that a $\psi$-epistemic interpretation is impossible. A key assumption of the argument in [21] is preparation independence situations where quantum theory assigns independent product states are presumed to be completely describable by independently combining the two purportedly deeper descriptions for each system. Here, we will show via explicit constructions that without this assumption, $\psi$-epistemic models can be constructed with all quantum predictions retained"</em></p> <p><strong>About being general</strong></p> <p>As I understand the second one just <em>seems</em> more general (because of "less assumptions"), but by no means Newton's dynamics is more general than Einsein's relativity because "it lacks of c=constant assumption". It's weird anyway, because it would mean that if " wavefunction is a real physical object" (a funny phrase from www.nature.com article) would depend on assumptions!, then what kind of realism depend on assumptions?</p> <p>Perhaps a point to discuss (assuming the theorem is well proven) is whether those assumptions have sense, if they come from experiments, or if they are just limiting the scope (toy model), or if those are random assumtions that have no source. </p>
g5907
[ 0.0020238037686794996, 0.024473173543810844, 0.000640688871499151, -0.015922239050269127, 0.008484926074743271, 0.01736614666879177, 0.02562282793223858, -0.003125937422737479, 0.03130638599395752, -0.04449636489152908, 0.017435841262340546, -0.036470815539360046, -0.003009211039170623, 0.006250339560210705, -0.029737548902630806, -0.010772875510156155, 0.05714211240410805, -0.014068296179175377, 0.029959002509713173, -0.01444492768496275, 0.0038803350180387497, 0.001064942334778607, -0.012482772581279278, -0.06929229944944382, -0.017051368951797485, -0.08802606165409088, -0.025258120149374008, -0.0359441339969635, -0.017881248146295547, -0.01272718608379364, 0.027591105550527573, -0.03350682929158211, 0.06929326802492142, -0.017430003732442856, -0.047880809754133224, -0.03803454712033272, 0.038383033126592636, 0.03943922370672226, -0.045325130224227905, -0.007688021752983332, 0.008861906826496124, 0.05115191638469696, -0.012862556613981724, -0.022733207792043686, -0.03801348805427551, 0.032664623111486435, 0.039650626480579376, -0.00009105735807679594, 0.004277766216546297, -0.020919807255268097, 0.019572265446186066, 0.044174108654260635, 0.09799639880657196, 0.03299491107463837, 0.07067062705755234, 0.051665112376213074, 0.026705212891101837, 0.0036641601473093033, 0.045992571860551834, -0.06381235271692276, 0.012956729158759117, -0.018036173656582832, 0.024713264778256416, -0.008519514463841915, 0.03213214874267578, -0.015514221042394638, -0.04717214033007622, 0.012573528103530407, -0.008532771840691566, 0.0013703537406399846, 0.0008547683246433735, -0.03671563044190407, -0.0073288800194859505, -0.013453158549964428, -0.028962265700101852, 0.025260183960199356, 0.004789792932569981, 0.006591375917196274, -0.003988227806985378, 0.04891134425997734, -0.07169517129659653, 0.013605003245174885, 0.04679306223988533, -0.03665204346179962, 0.013180158101022243, -0.02957730181515217, 0.018613679334521294, -0.012327204458415508, 0.06364339590072632, 0.035924553871154785, 0.027775174006819725, -0.03614221513271332, 0.08524183928966522, 0.026777159422636032, -0.0021963808685541153, -0.0007345082121901214, -0.015047247521579266, 0.0005433690967038274, -0.035309936851263046, -0.007987778633832932, -0.08658865094184875, 0.06191058084368706, -0.008592475205659866, -0.05664372444152832, 0.024305032566189766, -0.008642465807497501, 0.020799297839403152, 0.031382326036691666, -0.0238436758518219, -0.01337422151118517, -0.027403874322772026, 0.03672875836491585, -0.02592942863702774, -0.009084171615540981, -0.06067296117544174, -0.026750192046165466, -0.0016802281606942415, -0.03214367479085922, -0.014892682433128357, -0.004744675010442734, 0.02614409662783146, 0.0343722365796566, 0.031802948564291, 0.08843405544757843, -0.06471464782953262, -0.011832580901682377, -0.003113570623099804, -0.004274559672921896, 0.020960679277777672, -0.03357316181063652, -0.006984131410717964, 0.019327932968735695, 0.014933522790670395, 0.0577000230550766, -0.04128142446279526, 0.005384187214076519, 0.014261974021792412, 0.00015018798876553774, 0.007223827298730612, 0.03391696512699127, 0.002902041422203183, -0.03467654436826706, -0.01725071482360363, 0.022936999797821045, -0.005977724213153124, -0.054377466440200806, 0.03381623700261116, -0.0071523855440318584, 0.007304186932742596, 0.03760385140776634, 0.011029785498976707, 0.04788807034492493, -0.04370791092514992, -0.0005745000671595335, 0.016121001914143562, 0.030668025836348534, 0.004464088007807732, -0.027352498844265938, 0.02257186360657215, -0.03573177009820938, 0.06636270880699158, 0.05189359188079834, -0.003280607284978032, 0.03948833420872688, -0.019199257716536522, -0.006798567716032267, 0.025704065337777138, -0.07000720500946045, -0.0029543687123805285, -0.062032680958509445, -0.06170812249183655, 0.0034344836603850126, -0.017435550689697266, 0.021774878725409508, 0.015488320961594582, -0.02938377484679222, -0.020344873890280724, -0.045313093811273575, 0.024111589416861534, -0.0019653267227113247, -0.004096808843314648, 0.03373367711901665, 0.002661750651896, -0.030531713739037514, -0.0033849880564957857, 0.030095979571342468, -0.02153642848134041, 0.017079023644328117, -0.039735738188028336, 0.03263553977012634, -0.054860375821590424, -0.022563111037015915, -0.02633175626397133, 0.028014682233333588, -0.023972757160663605, 0.004905274137854576, 0.034297697246074677, -0.041162218898534775, 0.003361499635502696, 0.03740699589252472, 0.03977470099925995, 0.027887240052223206, -0.04354127123951912, -0.043385863304138184, -0.017485154792666435, 0.010633889585733414, -0.004016770049929619, 0.022020677104592323, -0.029145726934075356, -0.0057673645205795765, 0.06049608811736107, -0.012321588583290577, -0.008124892599880695, 0.024941803887486458, 0.07000783085823059, -0.055497050285339355, 0.02389349602162838, -0.015900271013379097, -0.002012592274695635, -0.047032229602336884, 0.03471212089061737, 0.02822957932949066, 0.045685891062021255, 0.01423881109803915, -0.025758514180779457, 0.03791921213269234, -0.037530988454818726, 0.01575467549264431, -0.04678777605295181, 0.06813142448663712, -0.05299454927444458, -0.06826309114694595, -0.007934113033115864, 0.010541641153395176, 0.07204433530569077, 0.06561455130577087, 0.039243824779987335, 0.0020902701653540134, 0.0497039370238781, 0.05399314686655998, 0.01446552388370037, -0.025660568848252296, -0.05029149353504181, 0.000999407609924674, 0.0345122292637825, -0.026356223970651627, -0.025145050138235092, -0.026642050594091415, -0.02640533447265625, 0.03220951557159424, -0.01908303238451481, -0.025690259411931038, -0.021995726972818375, -0.027178753167390823, 0.024325864389538765, -0.05093226954340935, 0.009870098903775215, -0.005602237302809954, -0.043113477528095245, -0.017211204394698143, -0.0007313890964724123, -0.012368733063340187, -0.004504811484366655, 0.045251667499542236, -0.015426203608512878, 0.013396845199167728, -0.014551248401403427, -0.021781038492918015, -0.046233534812927246, -0.032938577234745026, -0.008641843684017658, 0.05165049806237221, -0.00018311652820557356, 0.07520268112421036, 0.01883281022310257, 0.029982291162014008, -0.027155520394444466, 0.04126826301217079, -0.03243984654545784, 0.00033659834298305213, -0.05781637504696846, 0.01600820943713188, -0.01583210937678814, 0.02207733690738678, 0.027810651808977127, -0.0635211169719696, -0.009879207238554955, -0.06078561022877693, -0.03782786428928375, -0.020380014553666115, 0.024729009717702866, 0.011335399001836777, -0.01968369446694851, 0.09991258382797241, -0.0894591361284256, 0.015893572941422462, -0.05148595944046974, -0.044617895036935806, 0.004427929408848286, 0.02090534009039402, 0.019577162340283394, 0.018464483320713043, 0.0004910387215204537, 0.01151729840785265, 0.05695720389485359, 0.011266585439443588, -0.03726464882493019, -0.02720842882990837, -0.033219460397958755, -0.052429087460041046, -0.004364931024610996, 0.04469624161720276, -0.0371987484395504, 0.002276104176416993, -0.027396444231271744, 0.06885272264480591, 0.0040144287049770355, 0.04419618099927902, 0.023856325075030327, -0.032356031239032745, -0.009077007882297039, 0.01290307380259037, 0.0010601115645840764, -0.0017205128679051995, 0.018241282552480698, -0.0004488290869630873, -0.04961082711815834, -0.008471931330859661, -0.05391128733754158, -0.036460030823946, 0.09115435183048248, 0.03566775098443031, 0.022737741470336914, -0.012633763253688812, -0.05792003870010376, -0.07688276469707489, 0.012667463161051273, 0.02153540961444378, 0.03621748462319374, -0.008122680708765984, 0.02233085036277771, -0.027829844504594803, -0.013019025325775146, 0.05940868332982063, -0.002054244978353381, 0.011421688832342625, -0.02326335571706295, 0.023827800527215004, 0.0491151288151741, -0.0072795674204826355, 0.041671644896268845, 0.021731434389948845, 0.043078258633613586, 0.04080949351191521, -0.055514704436063766, 0.07856626808643341, 0.06941311061382294, 0.034408532083034515, 0.008914800360798836, 0.02300749346613884, 0.005321263801306486, -0.06272905319929123, 0.03418247029185295, -0.029798202216625214, 0.02242257073521614, 0.045393943786621094, 0.02179492451250553, 0.004029842559248209, 0.024479789659380913, 0.010189232416450977, 0.005471858195960522, 0.01563091389834881, 0.00476986076682806, -0.010419073514640331, 0.032617367804050446, 0.012312976643443108, 0.06844785064458847, 0.01435440219938755, -0.04981075972318649, 0.02063250169157982, 0.07280734926462173, 0.07022035866975784, -0.0059272474609315395, 0.010743043385446072, 0.1001218855381012, -0.00005561449870583601, -0.04666949808597565, -0.009839087724685669, -0.04563186317682266, -0.017940742895007133, -0.02416357584297657, -0.011775543913245201, -0.03261110559105873, 0.029717562720179558, 0.006426765117794275, 0.02570492774248123, 0.02654215693473816, -0.04167058318853378, -0.005526683758944273, 0.022506000474095345, -0.026082482188940048, -0.061291079968214035, -0.062385182827711105, 0.008593712002038956, -0.03734758123755455, 0.012732420116662979, -0.013833531178534031, -0.003491629147902131, -0.0337948277592659, -0.04881765693426132, 0.005743155721575022, 0.04012655094265938, -0.04056055098772049, -0.00644018966704607, -0.00840010680258274, -0.030504513531923294, -0.023672005161643028, -0.032530516386032104, -0.020529991015791893, -0.0017938483506441116, -0.0018807174637913704, 0.055143993347883224, 0.03744225203990936, 0.030421515926718712, -0.000831960525829345, 0.04073217511177063, -0.008623918518424034, 0.03820290416479111, -0.032769083976745605, -0.01765061914920807, 0.03296665847301483, -0.04920328035950661, 0.07661549001932144, -0.015278182923793793, -0.031079668551683426, 0.032750897109508514, -0.05614154413342476, 0.05144444480538368, 0.010495553724467754, -0.046418897807598114, 0.03485599905252457, 0.01294916681945324, 0.006749734282493591, 0.026694077998399734, 0.022912316024303436, -0.005115032196044922, 0.0037028954830020666, 0.042959436774253845, 0.01313016191124916, -0.03995811194181442, -0.05718277022242546, -0.02468021959066391, 0.009572573006153107, -0.04107426479458809, -0.02859552763402462, -0.022183170542120934, -0.025330405682325363, 0.07356184720993042, -0.01107232365757227, 0.03410930559039116, -0.06653223931789398, 0.007760750129818916, -0.006722265854477882, 0.07013268768787384, -0.037635739892721176, 0.031827572733163834, -0.10680843889713287, -0.005278011783957481, -0.047035444527864456, -0.03258034586906433, -0.02579936571419239, -0.005059001035988331, 0.0642380341887474, 0.00872459914535284, -0.00667851185426116, -0.03392726927995682, 0.052575189620256424, 0.012028459459543228, -0.028894850984215736, -0.010049466975033283, -0.0026497449725866318, -0.022330470383167267, 0.1059042364358902, 0.04214584827423096, 0.07896621525287628, 0.04272399842739105, 0.02065248228609562, 0.014546933583915234, -0.08866128325462341, -0.0528048500418663, 0.03268790617585182, 0.024076303467154503, 0.01422102004289627, 0.009561344049870968, -0.05970435217022896, 0.013681940734386444, -0.02743234671652317, -0.0006745748687535524, -0.029205061495304108, 0.01751992292702198, -0.053247734904289246, 0.051892876625061035, 0.033230870962142944, 0.0016376393614336848, -0.005360809154808521, -0.03243328630924225, 0.03456530347466469, 0.026072759181261063, -0.009496163576841354, 0.010043168440461159, 0.0290108360350132, -0.009247122332453728, -0.01582890935242176, -0.04679446667432785, 0.015392866916954517, 0.004723240155726671, -0.00324242003262043, 0.016039472073316574, -0.046865999698638916, 0.0014067584415897727, 0.042799968272447586, -0.0014046395663172007, 0.04535260796546936, -0.06722330302000046, 0.0029394379816949368, -0.0066144708544015884, -0.006294565740972757, -0.035939160734415054, 0.03358617052435875, 0.03490547090768814, 0.029197247698903084, 0.0032654108945280313, 0.0028651063330471516, 0.03681439906358719, 0.051371295005083084, -0.025293594226241112, 0.016539862379431725, 0.018301598727703094, 0.03383456543087959, -0.02617831528186798, 0.011583208106458187, -0.002702886937186122, -0.027760837227106094, 0.05717550963163376, -0.01789841800928116, -0.005623441655188799, -0.03504154458642006, 0.013812185265123844, 0.05382771044969559, -0.07909122854471207, -0.005520292557775974, 0.007793063297867775, -0.07792124152183533, 0.016733389347791672, 0.03268430009484291, 0.04511873051524162, 0.018278691917657852, -0.01440325379371643, 0.004377034958451986, -0.006585125811398029, -0.012712112627923489, 0.02268935553729534, 0.06260528415441513, 0.014657015912234783, -0.020370561629533768, 0.032045260071754456, -0.008586172945797443, -0.052585113793611526, -0.05656353384256363, 0.04190000519156456, -0.023848719894886017, 0.03577062860131264, -0.018280381336808205, 0.023283155634999275, -0.029752487316727638, -0.04683507978916168, 0.008725378662347794, -0.02477404661476612, -0.008727123029530048, -0.03225395455956459, -0.03220905363559723, 0.03544527292251587, 0.05196487903594971, -0.04127879440784454, -0.05850314348936081, 0.06710880994796753, -0.05079537630081177, -0.02173864096403122, 0.019057326018810272, -0.01522789429873228, -0.011804038658738136, 0.008907444775104523, -0.034402962774038315, -0.023683372884988785, -0.05356334522366524, -0.013557497411966324, 0.04606311768293381, -0.0550844632089138, -0.04331932216882706, 0.004594859667122364, -0.018795005977153778, -0.03480538725852966, 0.07990705221891403, -0.03349461778998375, -0.0019994706381112337, 0.026861203834414482, -0.022296078503131866, -0.015502631664276123, -0.03427407145500183, -0.015016344375908375, -0.08720932900905609, 0.02810700610280037, 0.010744618251919746, 0.0008237202418968081, 0.012835096567869186, -0.06188185140490532, -0.06032586097717285, 0.00009754967322805896, -0.02827165275812149, 0.006809828337281942, 0.05632986128330231, -0.0107429139316082, 0.03501001000404358, -0.003499304875731468, -0.0047710491344332695, 0.05047055706381798, -0.04841255396604538, -0.01302817277610302, 0.019054347649216652, 0.04771526902914047, -0.034334827214479446, 0.030448582023382187, -0.02167239598929882, 0.03979003056883812, -0.025679785758256912, 0.026433533057570457, -0.07048389315605164, -0.0022167684510350227, 0.05972425639629364, -0.052367761731147766, -0.0023742460180073977, 0.013592704199254513, 0.0525476299226284, 0.01161208562552929, -0.05718802288174629, 0.00840725563466549, 0.03086056560277939, 0.016488298773765564, -0.04767651483416557, 0.03031357191503048, 0.05271298810839653, 0.030293265357613564, -0.0673881396651268, -0.023010889068245888, 0.006735189817845821, 0.06527137011289597, 0.019726483151316643, -0.008158687502145767, 0.03154565393924713, -0.053252577781677246, -0.03726840764284134, -0.046916134655475616, 0.0019494357984513044, -0.024587085470557213, -0.017467673867940903, -0.0009599383338354528, 0.030606381595134735, -0.03531865030527115, -0.05174325406551361, -0.032361313700675964, 0.05206891521811485, -0.07565082609653473, -0.07395291328430176, -0.056079745292663574, -0.006286055780947208, -0.04205036535859108, 0.0502982959151268, 0.04618166387081146, -0.002245590090751648, -0.0073372009210288525, 0.004214493092149496, 0.015244935639202595, 0.03090810775756836, 0.043946780264377594, -0.09435325115919113, 0.009022628888487816, 0.013812522403895855, 0.03656349703669548, -0.06674132496118546, 0.024785008281469345, 0.014297237619757652, -0.05339709296822548, 0.031420156359672546, 0.010579016990959644, 0.02644580788910389, -0.016774768009781837, 0.0028763602022081614, 0.061921682208776474, 0.048093199729919434, -0.03669188916683197, -0.029680613428354263, 0.015051172114908695, -0.0536600761115551, 0.024231545627117157, -0.013435368426144123, -0.026232115924358368, 0.03487655147910118, -0.019102975726127625, -0.02008024789392948, -0.00567638548091054, 0.01380731351673603, -0.022544242441654205, -0.021927231922745705, 0.030260758474469185, 0.0050341482274234295, -0.016146792098879814, -0.0030707085970789194, 0.0007242559222504497, 0.049013491719961166, 0.004362436477094889, 0.008369741030037403, -0.002631348790600896, -0.039559222757816315, 0.00971627701073885, 0.001294333371333778, 0.006566039752215147, 0.006056046579033136, 0.034519221633672714, -0.03731435909867287, 0.03646925836801529, -0.03745843470096588, -0.01579233445227146, -0.056072626262903214, 0.07674281299114227, 0.017147080972790718, 0.08226528763771057, 0.012652293778955936, 0.0160056222230196, -0.03863168880343437, -0.005557144992053509, -0.05680214241147041, 0.018554164096713066, 0.03465672954916954, -0.03265170380473137, -0.015387148596346378, -0.059850629419088364, -0.02161027304828167, 0.04434292018413544, 0.025847915560007095, -0.041157688945531845, 0.03321494162082672, -0.010304544121026993, -0.06587585806846619, 0.048026904463768005, 0.05914928764104843, -0.06503187119960785, 0.027678752318024635, 0.02176063135266304, 0.09768878668546677, 0.040199652314186096, -0.013064307160675526, -0.03148994594812393, -0.01720871776342392, -0.037870414555072784, -0.06331530213356018, -0.03484474495053291, 0.03433109074831009, 0.05359005555510521 ]
<p>I keep hearing this rule that an object must have a bigger size than the wavelength of light in order for us to see it, and though I don't have any professional relationship with physics, I want to learn the explanation for this. Also I may have expressed my question wrong, but I hope you get the idea of what I'm trying to ask. </p> <p>Can you explain this as simple as possible for a non-physics person? </p>
g5908
[ 0.021508892998099327, 0.08437894284725189, 0.006538780871778727, -0.0398762971162796, 0.010239130817353725, 0.00428738771006465, 0.001276219729334116, -0.00032905262196436524, -0.02038179524242878, -0.06964243203401566, 0.03559858724474907, 0.035237446427345276, 0.04385660961270332, 0.009968944825232029, -0.004296230152249336, -0.008682326413691044, -0.005988455843180418, -0.03286805376410484, 0.0015972721157595515, 0.009623290970921516, 0.027820488438010216, -0.039775870740413666, -0.010629781521856785, -0.0833602026104927, -0.1060052439570427, 0.03604443371295929, -0.012385300360620022, 0.00912144873291254, 0.020187433809041977, -0.005784464534372091, 0.031002476811408997, 0.02882225438952446, 0.03441019356250763, -0.025121837854385376, -0.0023761680349707603, -0.007137380540370941, 0.004309183452278376, 0.03440117835998535, 0.022594520822167397, 0.02173910103738308, -0.0038816723972558975, 0.0395626574754715, -0.04124882444739342, -0.053313110023736954, -0.017184684053063393, -0.03675762563943863, 0.03853850066661835, 0.014909764751791954, 0.01215679943561554, -0.05331774428486824, -0.028603235259652138, 0.022740628570318222, 0.033779118210077286, 0.04545863717794418, 0.042245492339134216, 0.00784605834633112, 0.007414710707962513, -0.028668560087680817, 0.08029444515705109, 0.04614907503128052, 0.008575338870286942, -0.0197556484490633, -0.0022233251947909594, 0.05702077969908714, 0.03262649476528168, 0.0009736276115290821, -0.041668470948934555, -0.06363331526517868, 0.03621674329042435, 0.0020176961552351713, -0.009440364316105843, -0.04463638737797737, -0.04957205057144165, -0.0672757476568222, -0.04697328433394432, -0.016809944063425064, 0.0013565330300480127, 0.07841967791318893, -0.02407969906926155, 0.043478596955537796, -0.03392823413014412, -0.01785050705075264, 0.013407670892775059, 0.02084207534790039, 0.006599895190447569, -0.00404149666428566, -0.012477138079702854, -0.05610795319080353, 0.012849757447838783, 0.01623641327023506, 0.05254886671900749, 0.009034593589603901, 0.09603099524974823, 0.07908840477466583, 0.01261557824909687, -0.0067660994827747345, 0.009180945344269276, 0.06655982881784439, -0.024364640936255455, 0.06152608245611191, -0.0005005922284908593, 0.019461970776319504, -0.005354672204703093, 0.04421578720211983, 0.03399474546313286, 0.021048104390501976, -0.030552830547094345, 0.0082208551466465, -0.01812862604856491, 0.0043060737662017345, -0.0581146702170372, -0.006362616550177336, -0.06165965273976326, -0.04586555063724518, -0.06821762770414352, -0.0315929614007473, 0.08945845067501068, 0.006454814691096544, -0.0015338611556217074, 0.08708693832159042, 0.010856088250875473, 0.018591072410345078, 0.043950311839580536, 0.0216800756752491, -0.033370375633239746, -0.035790883004665375, 0.029522106051445007, 0.03764808550477028, 0.03445374220609665, -0.013079292140901089, 0.060475122183561325, 0.023583909496665, -0.01719493977725506, 0.03439464792609215, 0.03275188431143761, 0.06911993026733398, 0.019430728629231453, -0.03250930458307266, 0.00024099936126731336, 0.033903818577528, 0.012214386835694313, 0.0049962555058300495, 0.03611667454242706, -0.04855027422308922, -0.007627726532518864, -0.009987558238208294, -0.0186192374676466, -0.01761985383927822, -0.008467135019600391, -0.007418101653456688, 0.014445891603827477, 0.06206116825342178, 0.02606421336531639, -0.044662587344646454, -0.01920877769589424, -0.04201238229870796, 0.04476018622517586, -0.006931098643690348, -0.003483469830825925, -0.02327723242342472, 0.033986397087574005, 0.023530850186944008, -0.0564458929002285, 0.03875157609581947, -0.07269132137298584, -0.0291599091142416, -0.005657500121742487, -0.06909441947937012, 0.005029892083257437, -0.06462300568819046, -0.058632928878068924, -0.019301526248455048, 0.014615568332374096, 0.060323845595121384, -0.000492580235004425, 0.07188564538955688, 0.02724861539900303, -0.05104877054691315, -0.003951502963900566, 0.035511307418346405, -0.06484638899564743, -0.04551408812403679, 0.010596071369946003, -0.0777096152305603, -0.006487318314611912, -0.006365071050822735, 0.03701404854655266, 0.04103629291057587, 0.010795543901622295, 0.05314882844686508, -0.06261653453111649, -0.085027776658535, 0.04050968587398529, 0.0018511139787733555, 0.03554399311542511, -0.06022168695926666, -0.009349482133984566, -0.02199293114244938, -0.03424231335520744, 0.02170952782034874, -0.02804548479616642, 0.04120444878935814, 0.058186985552310944, 0.023480232805013657, 0.05513259395956993, -0.016236744821071625, -0.05507393553853035, 0.03989715874195099, 0.030699560418725014, -0.02017243765294552, 0.000001947619466591277, -0.04766488075256348, 0.02769666165113449, 0.013547863811254501, -0.03676091507077217, -0.005758996587246656, -0.061026595532894135, 0.015413167886435986, -0.005513796117156744, 0.026807615533471107, 0.011289729736745358, -0.05255429446697235, 0.028295869007706642, -0.03414716571569443, -0.022619174793362617, 0.030404506251215935, -0.029989205300807953, -0.036978427320718765, 0.06788371503353119, 0.032639097422361374, -0.0775940865278244, -0.01925130933523178, -0.02619726024568081, 0.0364881195127964, 0.01933426409959793, 0.024909984320402145, -0.034217771142721176, 0.013958251103758812, 0.050116293132305145, 0.02211965061724186, 0.0023853720631450415, -0.014027037657797337, -0.0016003074124455452, -0.008779454044997692, 0.05667873099446297, -0.050098907202482224, -0.0015258985804393888, -0.015887070447206497, -0.0008213851251639426, 0.03695428743958473, 0.02148936502635479, 0.001871544518508017, -0.0032170177437365055, -0.01744210533797741, -0.008900903165340424, -0.01713332161307335, -0.015766287222504616, 0.056840721517801285, -0.07600823789834976, -0.03185904398560524, -0.01173047348856926, -0.01892978884279728, 0.035087455064058304, 0.03337293490767479, -0.01782124675810337, -0.060328926891088486, -0.04050144553184509, 0.04762978106737137, 0.02022121101617813, -0.0038052909076213837, 0.01073763519525528, 0.04545100778341293, -0.04604112729430199, -0.04247695207595825, 0.02205759845674038, 0.016182923689484596, 0.011272437870502472, -0.03431401401758194, 0.0749843567609787, -0.021621370688080788, 0.004358846228569746, 0.027481485158205032, -0.09022070467472076, -0.0008545605232939124, 0.07409421354532242, -0.049163807183504105, -0.0006489159422926605, 0.00007140170782804489, -0.005888296291232109, -0.01330093014985323, -0.02639663778245449, 0.05041748657822609, -0.03906073048710823, -0.007724977098405361, 0.012796903029084206, -0.0070459782145917416, 0.020318306982517242, 0.06045117974281311, -0.05034054443240166, 0.029418908059597015, 0.013194786384701729, -0.029752351343631744, -0.008373357355594635, -0.04945836961269379, 0.03629448264837265, 0.03388022258877754, -0.04062732681632042, -0.0283780787140131, -0.0454595685005188, -0.0228812787681818, -0.007729721255600452, 0.04568612948060036, -0.008519127033650875, 0.0037807468324899673, -0.04521692544221878, -0.0055902572348713875, -0.02266726829111576, 0.05045706033706665, -0.026733936741948128, -0.049361445009708405, -0.025759683921933174, -0.00392843596637249, -0.018347490578889847, -0.009228121489286423, -0.006134729366749525, -0.05051509290933609, -0.0030881031416356564, -0.03930456191301346, 0.02267964743077755, -0.008290634490549564, 0.008072116412222385, 0.03849141299724579, -0.020972266793251038, 0.004317294806241989, -0.07614735513925552, -0.04737580195069313, 0.004371655639261007, -0.029045943170785904, 0.04401828348636627, 0.0021784070413559675, 0.04395909979939461, 0.016642147675156593, -0.08147706091403961, -0.036422248929739, 0.028211507946252823, 0.05022657290101051, -0.07778339087963104, -0.020601719617843628, -0.007446365896612406, 0.003515164367854595, 0.04012078419327736, 0.029243526980280876, -0.006166163831949234, -0.0701504498720169, 0.0023416948970407248, 0.06092347577214241, 0.042608827352523804, 0.007363495416939259, 0.05574493482708931, -0.08830767869949341, -0.0022752040531486273, -0.01968569867312908, 0.07113124430179596, 0.004522763192653656, -0.016788216307759285, -0.012614940293133259, 0.03958798199892044, 0.0283111073076725, -0.009613839909434319, 0.006859223823994398, -0.025156930088996887, -0.018177438527345657, -0.036543142050504684, 0.044743262231349945, 0.0007196571095846593, -0.03705090656876564, 0.057866230607032776, -0.010968746617436409, -0.019502421841025352, -0.02974037081003189, 0.05862976238131523, 0.06575387716293335, -0.017974261194467545, -0.034663137048482895, 0.0026173025835305452, -0.03383142128586769, -0.022027892991900444, -0.04449936002492905, 0.010463631711900234, -0.03009006381034851, -0.007437015417963266, -0.042836789041757584, -0.03908081352710724, -0.0054170298390090466, 0.015121513977646828, 0.03064274787902832, 0.021916588768363, 0.005099755246192217, -0.03971637785434723, -0.01127737294882536, -0.013909227214753628, 0.077346570789814, 0.03183410316705704, -0.02578253112733364, -0.033452171832323074, 0.044418636709451675, 0.03938911855220795, -0.0017493058694526553, -0.026983927935361862, -0.0014117270475253463, 0.013460297137498856, -0.0018295992631465197, -0.04165042191743851, -0.06592714041471481, -0.00983207207173109, 0.005481462925672531, 0.019880488514900208, -0.0075164781883358955, 0.03443986922502518, 0.0343235544860363, 0.010188711807131767, -0.010293649509549141, 0.010074783116579056, -0.011627878993749619, -0.048458997160196304, 0.06484890729188919, -0.009504665620625019, 0.002697812858968973, -0.06698375940322876, -0.0011184574104845524, -0.013356597162783146, 0.021258844062685966, -0.021765783429145813, 0.033364586532115936, -0.03275415301322937, 0.014194240793585777, 0.003454871941357851, 0.07191141694784164, 0.0012511744862422347, -0.023955779150128365, 0.00656947772949934, 0.009365889243781567, 0.005901917349547148, 0.00981220230460167, 0.030082818120718002, -0.0014038439840078354, 0.04769618436694145, 0.025083597749471664, -0.012073489837348461, -0.019838333129882812, -0.02299979329109192, 0.017162438482046127, -0.0018446837784722447, -0.0519842728972435, -0.006309386342763901, -0.055321116000413895, -0.04512713849544525, 0.03971683606505394, 0.039324961602687836, 0.019845889881253242, -0.05871149152517319, 0.008645892143249512, 0.01365673914551735, 0.05908529832959175, 0.05562906339764595, -0.017330175265669823, -0.06858446449041367, -0.010760289616882801, -0.03808550536632538, 0.05692898854613304, -0.060301754623651505, -0.014418063685297966, 0.032197415828704834, 0.034941524267196655, 0.030378641560673714, 0.03419351950287819, -0.023221004754304886, -0.000872282194904983, -0.007814901880919933, -0.03607020527124405, -0.05138622969388962, -0.020419182255864143, 0.05607975646853447, -0.008174901828169823, -0.00045804554247297347, 0.06831001490354538, -0.02396582067012787, 0.07724948972463608, 0.016261026263237, -0.04805363342165947, -0.016775012016296387, -0.015545536763966084, -0.006219732109457254, 0.06096288561820984, -0.07946871966123581, -0.02865513227880001, 0.012419814243912697, -0.0044735148549079895, -0.0027349565643817186, -0.032085295766592026, -0.017551537603139877, -0.06196068599820137, -0.012599170207977295, 0.03138212859630585, -0.03173253685235977, 0.02296452783048153, 0.08299711346626282, 0.00213418435305357, -0.003616462694481015, 0.0425386056303978, 0.005549158435314894, -0.04424705356359482, 0.02977469190955162, -0.0016581097152084112, 0.044084176421165466, -0.07683642208576202, -0.017903048545122147, 0.054196685552597046, -0.004658627323806286, 0.02578222192823887, -0.048426900058984756, -0.011714745312929153, 0.06677358597517014, -0.05558713153004646, -0.026074886322021484, 0.034273333847522736, -0.0548551045358181, 0.03680156543850899, 0.03379953280091286, -0.029166782274842262, 0.030402325093746185, 0.0234810970723629, 0.013774818740785122, 0.001805159728974104, -0.029646452516317368, 0.008363790810108185, 0.024853134527802467, 0.011777609586715698, -0.01227364968508482, 0.006164365913718939, -0.004356615245342255, -0.013738044537603855, -0.004382011946290731, 0.03671972081065178, 0.019677510485053062, -0.012645912356674671, 0.039558012038469315, 0.02224474959075451, 0.05991368368268013, 0.05594918504357338, -0.007632966618984938, 0.038939278572797775, -0.004579826723784208, -0.01520549412816763, 0.020138345658779144, 0.06022423133254051, 0.007264234125614166, 0.009336840361356735, -0.0029828152619302273, -0.05723388493061066, 0.057991329580545425, -0.0044107260182499886, -0.027196738868951797, -0.03948904573917389, 0.03728155419230461, -0.06256622821092606, 0.006577223539352417, -0.021635867655277252, 0.07175752520561218, 0.047850918024778366, -0.037635624408721924, 0.018483102321624756, 0.013026800937950611, 0.006384217645972967, 0.0026574803050607443, 0.01765822246670723, 0.018587660044431686, -0.050770048052072525, -0.03631552308797836, -0.04249012842774391, 0.0034369088243693113, 0.0506003238260746, -0.05337027832865715, -0.010040060617029667, -0.015166332945227623, 0.020342202857136726, -0.04282350465655327, 0.005145138595253229, 0.03159552067518234, -0.028262168169021606, -0.03297220915555954, -0.018426448106765747, -0.01234973780810833, -0.03351451829075813, -0.006726647261530161, -0.04459475353360176, -0.027522513642907143, -0.0030513047240674496, -0.04857100546360016, -0.006592785473912954, -0.029294950887560844, -0.006342174485325813, 0.028423123061656952, 0.025341346859931946, 0.025528008118271828, 0.07247788459062576, -0.008398337289690971, -0.05645430088043213, 0.06636770069599152, -0.00243999226950109, -0.021436026319861412, 0.03139932453632355, 0.043303411453962326, 0.04033862426877022, -0.014890235848724842, -0.0736151859164238, 0.014935179613530636, -0.002047507092356682, 0.02641567401587963, -0.03658812865614891, 0.03535446152091026, -0.016595859080553055, 0.011981165036559105, 0.0035283267498016357, 0.00790264829993248, 0.037901800125837326, -0.03074847348034382, 0.01840052753686905, 0.05473778769373894, 0.01352943666279316, -0.0059241424314677715, -0.025125565007328987, -0.00022834754781797528, 0.053701821714639664, 0.04641111195087433, 0.07251550257205963, -0.05441466346383095, -0.01802687533199787, 0.012978608720004559, 0.025001160800457, -0.0061747669242322445, -0.0021205940283834934, 0.007566091604530811, -0.00845225527882576, -0.04408258944749832, -0.0025960567872971296, 0.02501671016216278, -0.007134337909519672, -0.03468950465321541, 0.0014805657556280494, 0.014672363176941872, 0.0341125950217247, -0.04803236573934555, 0.00643890630453825, -0.020438725128769875, 0.01307639479637146, -0.040690694004297256, -0.002021273598074913, -0.06809081137180328, -0.0605558305978775, -0.019603684544563293, 0.008806739002466202, -0.05499899014830589, -0.008075152523815632, 0.02559572085738182, 0.03111445903778076, 0.005506449844688177, -0.0210366602987051, -0.07261558622121811, -0.008226514793932438, 0.010383574292063713, 0.006823939271271229, -0.048309605568647385, -0.005233045667409897, 0.01274283230304718, -0.055178068578243256, -0.03332841023802757, 0.042300719767808914, 0.005164549220353365, -0.021527666598558426, 0.026428190991282463, 0.07159777730703354, 0.01072926726192236, 0.024830298498272896, 0.005846722982823849, 0.0038671758957207203, -0.06835106015205383, -0.06288466602563858, 0.02955157868564129, -0.0028040085453540087, -0.044980984181165695, -0.030716968700289726, 0.008495999500155449, -0.04944255203008652, -0.0016245562583208084, -0.017900774255394936, 0.06065720319747925, 0.0032597281970083714, 0.04104697331786156, 0.04849713295698166, -0.03306274488568306, -0.04545288160443306, -0.029251135885715485, -0.07510069012641907, 0.02738500013947487, 0.021999798715114594, -0.0018921304726973176, 0.035087548196315765, -0.031776294112205505, -0.05513051152229309, 0.021806934848427773, 0.026374587789177895, -0.013542539440095425, 0.06810980290174484, 0.029958179220557213, 0.028176065534353256, -0.014953410252928734, 0.026805372908711433, -0.007746793329715729, -0.020562659949064255, 0.008595028892159462, 0.0204036645591259, 0.03943055495619774, -0.044446900486946106, -0.06022027134895325, -0.034808192402124405, 0.07590767741203308, -0.009032215923070908, -0.021862417459487915, 0.04193559288978577, -0.007559977937489748, 0.042423032224178314, -0.029117733240127563, -0.022383976727724075, -0.03493516892194748, 0.03813369944691658, -0.012249830178916454, 0.019995544105768204, 0.005411566235125065, 0.022155936807394028, 0.045410364866256714, 0.035363808274269104, -0.009187815710902214, -0.040735822170972824, 0.01909012533724308, -0.013748271390795708, -0.022619295865297318, 0.011212574318051338, 0.037651389837265015, -0.053867537528276443, -0.01782657578587532, 0.07345777004957199, -0.013361452147364616, 0.07391809672117233, 0.07089225947856903, -0.044394176453351974, -0.00573402876034379, 0.0422733835875988, -0.0539575070142746, 0.008195940405130386, 0.038377631455659866, 0.03705253079533577, 0.0006113275303505361, -0.01934121735394001, 0.06035832688212395, -0.038135647773742676, -0.053651873022317886, -0.01682346686720848 ]
<p>There is a electric dipole which is fixed. So angular momentum isn't conserved. And there is charge $Q$ which has initial velocity $u$.</p> <p>My question is: What is the tangential velocity of the charge $Q$ as a function of $r$ and $\theta$ and beyond that, what is the $r$ and $\theta$ as a function of time?</p> <p>Here is what gives me trouble:</p> <p>I solved question when dipole and charge reversed. Because when they are reversed the dipole becomes aligned all the time along the $r$ axis freely, so I can write down angular momentum conservation equation. But in actual problem we are holding the dipole while it wants to get aligned along $r$ axis. That means we are applying torque to the system, due to that I have one less equation. And I can't solve the problem due to lack of info.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ttUXm.png" alt="Dipole charge attraction"></p>
g5909
[ 0.04884760454297066, 0.007904400117695332, -0.022356290370225906, -0.01676933281123638, 0.09642137587070465, -0.047757841646671295, 0.06709468364715576, -0.019914761185646057, -0.022933997213840485, 0.03506305441260338, -0.05115656927227974, 0.04026179388165474, -0.019508030265569687, -0.0008668489754199982, 0.023446330800652504, 0.009725777432322502, 0.08263086527585983, 0.04035905748605728, 0.023238716647028923, 0.03630717843770981, 0.03057374432682991, -0.02760172262787819, -0.03842489421367645, -0.03566516935825348, 0.010997473262250423, -0.02571815811097622, -0.013010670430958271, 0.028162922710180283, -0.04955257847905159, -0.023536328226327896, 0.021563313901424408, 0.01364580262452364, 0.041710179299116135, -0.033001597970724106, -0.07168256491422653, -0.04143699258565903, 0.02942764014005661, -0.006079573649913073, 0.02890440635383129, 0.0012958276784047484, 0.038268472999334335, 0.005753409583121538, 0.02839009463787079, -0.01022739801555872, 0.05734510347247124, -0.00494661508128047, 0.016673903912305832, -0.01835075579583645, -0.038589395582675934, 0.056823816150426865, -0.01652986742556095, 0.024272993206977844, 0.015206054784357548, -0.03474558889865875, -0.035237643867731094, -0.011509617790579796, 0.02607676014304161, -0.004809792153537273, -0.013300926424562931, 0.06177496165037155, -0.010815135203301907, -0.02467240020632744, 0.0022214665077626705, 0.011182825081050396, 0.07236620038747787, -0.07103478908538818, -0.018282059580087662, 0.0034331774804741144, 0.004442601464688778, -0.00801300723105669, 0.01360632199794054, -0.02587355114519596, -0.0633120909333229, -0.0025182936806231737, -0.018339058384299278, 0.03490889444947243, 0.03602445498108864, -0.061453334987163544, 0.012432507239282131, -0.012314478866755962, -0.08485044538974762, -0.0009110403480008245, 0.03893112763762474, 0.054804664105176926, 0.0858946368098259, -0.024778438732028008, -0.020107988268136978, 0.01867801696062088, -0.04011131078004837, -0.04098718613386154, 0.039338868111371994, -0.06431012600660324, 0.03988535329699516, -0.001870715874247253, 0.013275593519210815, -0.05383601039648056, -0.04933446645736694, 0.06295464187860489, 0.06276843696832657, -0.00498565100133419, -0.030413266271352768, 0.011217251420021057, 0.0016494679730385542, -0.0001633025676710531, 0.029456328600645065, 0.007728137541562319, 0.0011429712176322937, -0.027836106717586517, -0.014682433567941189, 0.009551760740578175, 0.026134682819247246, -0.06497220695018768, 0.0011437657522037625, -0.03983921930193901, -0.030663423240184784, -0.02113007754087448, 0.03849159926176071, -0.07264883071184158, 0.027798380702733994, 0.06929943710565567, 0.00970308855175972, 0.05115843936800957, -0.009354373440146446, 0.05879304185509682, 0.026716958731412888, 0.012131381779909134, -0.04337195307016373, 0.013707108795642853, 0.06680486351251602, 0.02776409685611725, -0.001212377450428903, -0.02099774219095707, -0.02256297692656517, 0.04799919202923775, -0.019470976665616035, 0.013780946843326092, -0.00939641147851944, 0.02104596234858036, -0.033512894064188004, 0.016210854053497314, 0.06326746940612793, -0.029651189222931862, 0.06473874300718307, -0.000012631544450414367, -0.04312676563858986, 0.00014680001186206937, 0.014101912267506123, -0.04672982543706894, 0.07267507910728455, -0.0027268570847809315, 0.01609257608652115, 0.043564844876527786, -0.019980179145932198, -0.011043707840144634, 0.02204343117773533, -0.050368718802928925, 0.08907482028007507, -0.031842272728681564, 0.022067392244935036, 0.03177786245942116, 0.05889212340116501, 0.0007828461821191013, 0.06454505026340485, 0.008297367952764034, -0.05648329108953476, -0.014867926947772503, 0.030132245272397995, -0.022073183208703995, -0.017580438405275345, -0.059399571269750595, -0.014713750220835209, -0.016733208671212196, -0.005453892517834902, 0.051159389317035675, 0.005679447203874588, 0.0003504876221995801, -0.06567691266536713, -0.034100841730833054, 0.013637589290738106, -0.010244295932352543, -0.04232686012983322, 0.012013680301606655, 0.06533271819353104, 0.04828423261642456, 0.0015365883009508252, 0.07826833426952362, 0.00040862889727577567, 0.05262047052383423, -0.0554124116897583, -0.009887121617794037, 0.06684724241495132, 0.0014570250641554594, -0.04731731116771698, -0.002507749479264021, -0.04325485974550247, -0.02643798477947712, 0.005024734418839216, -0.020393356680870056, -0.033399343490600586, 0.03021278977394104, -0.0451778843998909, -0.0018866324098780751, 0.04877919703722, 0.022027119994163513, 0.023908277973532677, -0.054824940860271454, 0.0203879214823246, -0.05225587636232376, 0.0409095473587513, 0.020488962531089783, 0.07104384154081345, 0.03675559163093567, -0.03375605493783951, 0.02822170779109001, -0.03186757490038872, -0.047590259462594986, 0.038976140320301056, 0.05453251302242279, -0.06268145143985748, 0.012694018892943859, -0.05178055539727211, -0.06354211270809174, 0.02156178280711174, -0.02108563855290413, -0.04141358286142349, -0.034506164491176605, -0.008297096937894821, -0.06993202865123749, -0.04600256681442261, 0.014594892971217632, -0.018147466704249382, 0.02568710409104824, 0.0006413108203560114, -0.014018096961081028, 0.05827987194061279, 0.04321957379579544, 0.00047350258682854474, 0.012358500622212887, 0.045490484684705734, -0.04043891653418541, -0.033448927104473114, 0.03741979971528053, 0.023468589410185814, 0.028820376843214035, -0.011919669806957245, 0.013653365895152092, 0.08453387022018433, 0.012312820181250572, 0.02291719801723957, 0.019500158727169037, 0.07117718458175659, -0.02931470051407814, -0.045694272965192795, -0.00795433297753334, -0.03628414869308472, 0.03544136881828308, -0.05329854041337967, 0.06405876576900482, -0.05927317589521408, -0.07139290869235992, -0.02901826985180378, 0.05728118494153023, 0.015287790447473526, -0.0077034286223351955, -0.046407267451286316, -0.01875307410955429, -0.03479282557964325, -0.01014360785484314, 0.040697935968637466, 0.016570935025811195, -0.059104498475790024, 0.08963930606842041, -0.014177185483276844, 0.030175114050507545, 0.007700168527662754, -0.03414718434214592, 0.026595527306199074, -0.06880172342061996, -0.0014396818587556481, -0.030253583565354347, -0.00700628524646163, 0.013636911287903786, -0.008370851166546345, 0.021508313715457916, 0.006613495759665966, -0.05282829329371452, 0.017569685354828835, 0.02484358288347721, -0.02308814227581024, -0.015236381441354752, -0.07370715588331223, 0.05570274963974953, 0.06902189552783966, -0.051415592432022095, 0.05211251229047775, 0.044912584125995636, 0.014946789480745792, -0.05329590290784836, -0.02238381840288639, 0.03801758587360382, 0.024214526638388634, -0.01804066263139248, 0.0036914306692779064, 0.02411647140979767, 0.055732909590005875, 0.03010891005396843, -0.037167027592659, -0.030213652178645134, 0.03340455889701843, 0.0878746435046196, -0.04990577697753906, 0.05946424975991249, -0.039116423577070236, -0.03855729103088379, -0.019879816100001335, -0.006180502474308014, -0.036125168204307556, -0.0722767785191536, -0.008519256487488747, 0.03570840507745743, -0.04776666313409805, -0.08351251482963562, 0.020140577107667923, -0.007034641224890947, 0.008808967657387257, 0.018704844638705254, -0.06775911897420883, 0.047606293112039566, -0.03882865235209465, -0.033958107233047485, 0.02487919293344021, 0.034583866596221924, 0.0384376123547554, -0.04240843653678894, 0.04401914030313492, -0.010386224836111069, -0.009228772483766079, 0.015079145319759846, 0.028118014335632324, -0.023033594712615013, 0.0023756753653287888, -0.03091162070631981, -0.04493753984570503, -0.06860651075839996, 0.02215137891471386, 0.011417370289564133, -0.05296522378921509, 0.016868319362401962, 0.005849927198141813, 0.01630680076777935, -0.009393543004989624, -0.03270915895700455, 0.030474448576569557, -0.02254261076450348, -0.024593980982899666, 0.01646738313138485, 0.03710406273603439, 0.04136241227388382, -0.08144497126340866, -0.02965294010937214, -0.01158314011991024, -0.00983963068574667, -0.013338439166545868, 0.004312385804951191, 0.028452087193727493, -0.03424631804227829, -0.0035745727363973856, 0.028578003868460655, -0.0028931156266480684, -0.024798303842544556, 0.016586603596806526, 0.016122249886393547, -0.023309752345085144, -0.03646242618560791, 0.02945006638765335, -0.04763103649020195, -0.04513219743967056, 0.0005979060661047697, -0.04092693328857422, 0.019694387912750244, 0.008426577784121037, -0.013054301030933857, -0.025789795443415642, 0.019349602982401848, 0.005716030020266771, 0.0914759710431099, -0.018770769238471985, 0.0442979671061039, 0.009270325303077698, -0.0030073351226747036, -0.03382802754640579, -0.006307885516434908, 0.010315108112990856, -0.019375188276171684, 0.011667918413877487, -0.0378510020673275, 0.03495773300528526, -0.08913476020097733, -0.0468754805624485, -0.023338664323091507, -0.0375550277531147, 0.026924462988972664, -0.0005501963896676898, -0.035611364990472794, 0.010854944586753845, 0.06512749940156937, 0.02774030528962612, -0.002840848173946142, 0.003369683865457773, 0.0010124100372195244, -0.044497497379779816, 0.008686953224241734, 0.005086716264486313, -0.014537195675075054, -0.013914006762206554, 0.02764236368238926, 0.03045875020325184, -0.01765434630215168, -0.0391044095158577, -0.02513345144689083, 0.06653788685798645, 0.028951359912753105, 0.04635879024863243, -0.042738474905490875, 0.01522664725780487, 0.023334955796599388, 0.08723504096269608, 0.030673494562506676, 0.01813066378235817, -0.06835290789604187, 0.005575483199208975, -0.004474454093724489, -0.03191956877708435, 0.019345723092556, -0.06488700956106186, 0.025006070733070374, 0.02362767606973648, 0.014401876367628574, 0.0007149128359742463, 0.08489662408828735, 0.05174984410405159, 0.01851041056215763, 0.03201467916369438, -0.029333218932151794, -0.05814741179347038, 0.06413086503744125, -0.0373011939227581, -0.044654104858636856, 0.019513282924890518, -0.044625766575336456, -0.03400580212473869, 0.023989586159586906, -0.07192570716142654, -0.03595256432890892, -0.026651619002223015, -0.010126977227628231, -0.05538567528128624, -0.00029941959655843675, 0.023610634729266167, 0.0019948792178183794, -0.07405170798301697, 0.03742488473653793, 0.024256400763988495, -0.03543888032436371, 0.07070702314376831, -0.05618452653288841, 0.032157160341739655, 0.019129784777760506, -0.04799005761742592, -0.021343527361750603, 0.033655792474746704, -0.004382249899208546, 0.012135791592299938, -0.003488884773105383, 0.010170131921768188, 0.030677976086735725, 0.024740800261497498, 0.048137299716472626, 0.023418685421347618, -0.007919935509562492, -0.05243755504488945, -0.014883528463542461, -0.0005191520322114229, 0.026765570044517517, -0.023464281111955643, -0.043661024421453476, 0.02079779841005802, -0.014496375806629658, 0.012505478225648403, -0.03154684230685234, -0.017553942278027534, 0.006135165691375732, -0.007839689962565899, 0.035934627056121826, 0.01949543133378029, 0.050032757222652435, -0.04354552552103996, 0.038695260882377625, -0.032683175057172775, -0.017101364210247993, -0.0378715842962265, -0.01416700053960085, -0.043966978788375854, 0.05846783518791199, 0.00336836907081306, 0.07123038917779922, 0.04049048572778702, 0.015905646607279778, -0.04427333176136017, 0.03744185343384743, -0.03520176187157631, 0.0681493729352951, 0.05529765784740448, 0.005741146858781576, -0.004418556112796068, -0.006138900760561228, -0.005915899761021137, 0.03231847658753395, -0.04086057469248772, 0.02770053781569004, 0.03142896294593811, 0.01838850975036621, 0.007366538513451815, -0.0567949116230011, -0.005438367370516062, -0.01757708564400673, -0.02897818759083748, -0.02436298131942749, 0.03966124355792999, 0.05153914913535118, -0.0037295904476195574, -0.04746091365814209, 0.035728804767131805, -0.02618544176220894, -0.008796166628599167, -0.019767465069890022, 0.03677907586097717, -0.05908077582716942, 0.0007348508224822581, 0.020530926063656807, -0.02739185094833374, -0.04441484436392784, 0.04067841172218323, 0.013325337320566177, -0.025992142036557198, -0.010092124342918396, -0.023066839203238487, -0.012857649475336075, -0.0232040137052536, -0.02596299536526203, -0.05973956733942032, -0.0008393913158215582, -0.05735629051923752, -0.027281858026981354, -0.036986950784921646, -0.03293512761592865, 0.013839473016560078, -0.035799119621515274, -0.07761341333389282, 0.0036749765276908875, 0.06021448224782944, -0.03750299662351608, 0.05332866311073303, 0.057959578931331635, 0.012553354725241661, -0.005990755278617144, 0.0016181672690436244, -0.015741923823952675, 0.05159955844283104, 0.011296464130282402, -0.016766982153058052, -0.02200913056731224, -0.01589399389922619, -0.0016248892061412334, 0.041407424956560135, 0.03091254271566868, -0.030339384451508522, 0.0302658099681139, -0.045410480350255966, 0.025671236217021942, 0.010980682447552681, -0.02675827592611313, 0.01898149773478508, -0.043945301324129105, 0.022381503134965897, 0.04056961461901665, -0.027380190789699554, -0.04546358436346054, 0.055345360189676285, -0.042231906205415726, -0.02398316189646721, 0.004677348304539919, -0.010675661265850067, -0.026757704094052315, -0.0311887264251709, 0.008363740518689156, 0.010246865451335907, -0.022340107709169388, -0.0353345163166523, 0.037166789174079895, 0.010876353830099106, -0.005586556158959866, 0.005990027450025082, -0.03973035514354706, 0.029685847461223602, -0.008759016171097755, 0.04661856219172478, -0.00011622492456808686, -0.035407744348049164, -0.011402646079659462, 0.00885572750121355, 0.029504524543881416, -0.029176702722907066, -0.013000608421862125, -0.013932542875409126, 0.04623602703213692, -0.0008789505809545517, 0.04026755690574646, -0.04535914584994316, 0.049190741032361984, -0.0002039036335190758, 0.00698509905487299, -0.008029903285205364, -0.025430236011743546, 0.024047445505857468, -0.027585381641983986, -0.02429974637925625, 0.020406760275363922, 0.001100037363357842, -0.009797642007470131, -0.010824824683368206, 0.03023635223507881, -0.07597827911376953, 0.011784610338509083, 0.03676757961511612, 0.0031386413611471653, -0.006040652748197317, 0.023108655586838722, 0.05752220004796982, 0.031695835292339325, 0.027988819405436516, 0.029066842049360275, 0.010724270716309547, 0.006428097374737263, -0.07914446294307709, -0.031975265592336655, 0.041023965924978256, -0.0008702914929017425, -0.04567163437604904, -0.028907230123877525, 0.014048062264919281, 0.01013067178428173, -0.0011053439229726791, 0.029293904080986977, -0.01741090416908264, -0.0034854672849178314, 0.04108278080821037, 0.05034096911549568, -0.0010025986703112721, -0.03071451000869274, 0.01865307241678238, -0.014573254622519016, 0.003506242763251066, -0.017705528065562248, 0.015446138568222523, 0.029488885775208473, 0.0018427472095936537, -0.02253984846174717, 0.02054412290453911, -0.03696231544017792, -0.03236395865678787, -0.006896723993122578, 0.010498548857867718, -0.037445317953825, -0.047551002353429794, 0.0904238298535347, -0.007681598886847496, 0.013021842576563358, -0.012552972882986069, -0.009423721581697464, -0.04545970261096954, -0.01515138614922762, 0.01484618615359068, -0.0038965195417404175, -0.03752078115940094, 0.00371981761418283, -0.024827459827065468, 0.023580268025398254, -0.0005831570015288889, 0.01103723794221878, 0.011748038232326508, 0.07058665156364441, -0.014014065265655518, -0.01508150901645422, -0.004737040493637323, -0.010789807885885239, 0.018862377852201462, 0.027532484382390976, 0.01006639376282692, -0.014937814325094223, 0.03916937857866287, -0.017923476174473763, 0.07412455976009369, 0.051934633404016495, 0.025767989456653595, 0.03542274236679077, -0.04366374760866165, -0.058830376714468, -0.05429578945040703, 0.0669219046831131, 0.01297545712441206, -0.036377474665641785, 0.018714988604187965, -0.014953941106796265, 0.02899244613945484, 0.034568771719932556, -0.038408104330301285, 0.058984480798244476, -0.01811208203434944, -0.0434306375682354, -0.01113799400627613, 0.011617835611104965, 0.028873385861516, -0.06584808230400085, -0.0048919664695858955, -0.04557611793279648, -0.058718934655189514, 0.024213969707489014, 0.011792155914008617, -0.015826715156435966, -0.01283254288136959, -0.02512495592236519, -0.06252297759056091, 0.06584980338811874, 0.010837634094059467, 0.051651615649461746, -0.005093366373330355, -0.028794189915060997, 0.01878197304904461, 0.02452090010046959, -0.006697129458189011, -0.07116509974002838, -0.015082651749253273, 0.0012371870689094067, -0.029975732788443565, -0.005167943891137838, 0.049837615340948105, 0.06547082960605621, 0.0903606116771698, 0.022600427269935608, 0.04265083372592926, -0.0010225792648270726, -0.04972629249095917, -0.008087330497801304, 0.0373309962451458, -0.010648245923221111, -0.009719215333461761, 0.04683991149067879, 0.000402481178753078, 0.007732049096375704, -0.037057679146528244, 0.0011232740944251418, -0.004462660755962133, 0.004829456564038992, 0.03799787163734436, -0.010825083591043949, -0.06791378557682037, 0.014909547753632069 ]
<p>What is the exact reason that normal matter can not exist within an event horizon?</p> <p>I can understand how a super-dense object like a neutron star could accrete mass until its physical radius is less than its Schwarzschild radius and an event horizon forms around it. </p> <p>But why can't the neutron star remain inside the event horizon as it was before the event horizon formed? Aside from the escape velocity at the surface reaching $c$, what actually changed?</p> <p>Why must all matter within an event horizon undergo complete physical collapse to a point?</p>
g208
[ 0.06087781488895416, 0.021134579554200172, 0.02240801230072975, 0.00014849529543425888, 0.02225714735686779, 0.07786346971988678, 0.0035207336768507957, 0.004919240716844797, -0.08839960396289825, -0.040837422013282776, -0.011117272078990936, -0.009938511997461319, -0.0225797388702631, 0.03205220028758049, -0.005256578791886568, -0.002746978309005499, -0.03253293037414551, -0.043024878948926926, -0.00810297206044197, -0.0011705670040100813, -0.018388107419013977, 0.011761967092752457, 0.06510673463344574, 0.018424103036522865, -0.021526239812374115, 0.028043773025274277, 0.00038940293597988784, -0.011822860687971115, 0.03885648399591446, 0.008727682754397392, 0.007676069159060717, 0.03564921021461487, -0.021158572286367416, -0.043343108147382736, 0.06983458250761032, -0.056088533252477646, -0.018481679260730743, 0.02151489071547985, 0.0292733833193779, -0.016858721151947975, -0.012534080073237419, -0.023036982864141464, -0.02291429415345192, -0.08332828432321548, -0.03194687142968178, 0.0010480951750651002, 0.006459983065724373, -0.049028340727090836, 0.012793435715138912, -0.034001242369413376, -0.03840900957584381, 0.035749610513448715, 0.02015569806098938, 0.038809508085250854, 0.013137167319655418, 0.001789382891729474, 0.015946393832564354, 0.03468216955661774, 0.055989157408475876, -0.009796345606446266, -0.014813919551670551, -0.03183779865503311, 0.02162202261388302, -0.007564328610897064, 0.03544308617711067, -0.027905568480491638, -0.08420141041278839, -0.009003926999866962, 0.044686250388622284, 0.026489989832043648, -0.0010521715739741921, -0.04267116263508797, -0.023189276456832886, -0.04973556473851204, -0.02776188962161541, 0.026457911357283592, 0.0013329422799870372, 0.0014316854067146778, -0.007936213165521622, 0.010995263233780861, -0.04892237111926079, 0.014146748930215836, 0.024589883163571358, -0.0016770678339526057, 0.05791342258453369, 0.05714612081646919, 0.003540189005434513, -0.024962224066257477, 0.03384777531027794, -0.0013346216874197125, 0.029915902763605118, -0.010358723811805248, 0.015201925300061703, 0.00016297299589496106, 0.030242830514907837, 0.0003165505186188966, -0.04007517546415329, 0.06236991658806801, 0.006825766991823912, 0.034564416855573654, -0.014685984700918198, -0.024650469422340393, 0.029255997389554977, 0.016399888321757317, -0.008644645102322102, -0.0022438548039644957, -0.03669280558824539, 0.030005302280187607, 0.058312758803367615, 0.02234198898077011, 0.003426122944802046, -0.04367218166589737, -0.043751563876867294, -0.001998125109821558, -0.027173370122909546, -0.015959618613123894, 0.04945642128586769, 0.05595776438713074, -0.0008212770335376263, 0.05207045376300812, -0.01853916049003601, 0.025337792932987213, 0.017702076584100723, -0.03735636919736862, -0.07281558960676193, 0.011552073061466217, 0.06511140614748001, 0.0004259039997123182, 0.02887110598385334, -0.01942785643041134, -0.01489774789661169, 0.018196647986769676, -0.05846388638019562, 0.022835448384284973, 0.0035968832671642303, 0.015094372443854809, -0.019311651587486267, -0.018308430910110474, 0.024579595774412155, -0.04980913922190666, -0.00991408433765173, 0.0058441124856472015, 0.0046354797668755054, 0.002400413854047656, 0.009658055379986763, 0.009985080920159817, -0.014294292777776718, 0.03506947681307793, -0.019041867926716805, 0.02193508669734001, -0.004543812479823828, 0.04584849998354912, 0.004983987659215927, -0.05445284768939018, -0.01872737519443035, 0.043117549270391464, 0.06881546229124069, -0.025070544332265854, -0.030450521036982536, 0.027682391926646233, 0.08804461359977722, 0.010980510152876377, -0.011656518094241619, 0.01843777857720852, -0.04299970716238022, 0.022966112941503525, 0.019906669855117798, -0.0124059421941638, 0.007779403124004602, -0.015093350782990456, -0.047844596207141876, 0.004269705154001713, -0.0226669292896986, 0.11093565076589584, -0.0061418176628649235, -0.018843363970518112, 0.033383261412382126, 0.001451387070119381, -0.008094608783721924, -0.019185863435268402, -0.01395199354737997, -0.017680156975984573, -0.03824295476078987, -0.054631948471069336, 0.03185698390007019, 0.012373724021017551, 0.08935840427875519, 0.052075374871492386, 0.011082479730248451, 0.05658573657274246, -0.005184302106499672, -0.03561583161354065, -0.00022771094518247992, 0.0118436049669981, 0.021327566355466843, -0.030993584543466568, 0.062498971819877625, -0.03521246090531349, -0.07403818517923355, 0.03040066733956337, 0.022353775799274445, -0.022002968937158585, -0.06307805329561234, -0.015739228576421738, 0.03601199388504028, -0.004940773360431194, -0.05345427989959717, 0.04243481531739235, 0.024302083998918533, 0.020783044397830963, -0.006380985025316477, -0.007489056326448917, -0.029643135145306587, -0.026043016463518143, 0.0015673257876187563, -0.01786363124847412, -0.029017891734838486, -0.0018743339460343122, 0.004189472179859877, 0.012814617715775967, -0.06680607050657272, -0.007942530326545238, -0.013602837920188904, -0.050910383462905884, -0.05152159184217453, 0.06348427385091782, -0.018342861905694008, 0.030436016619205475, 0.05530867725610733, -0.02522069402039051, -0.0942106693983078, 0.05089084059000015, -0.06303089112043381, -0.026497622951865196, 0.009994513355195522, 0.007387073710560799, 0.01649617776274681, -0.022378208115696907, 0.008978948928415775, 0.006887341383844614, -0.006038972642272711, -0.028211558237671852, -0.03325163945555687, -0.007992296479642391, 0.006491425912827253, -0.056331995874643326, 0.05153598263859749, -0.05803189426660538, 0.007415199186652899, 0.04861860349774361, 0.029107101261615753, -0.011671315878629684, -0.03279893100261688, -0.05449420586228371, 0.015248136594891548, -0.005945302080363035, 0.012749133631587029, 0.007563450373709202, -0.07056070864200592, -0.04325404763221741, -0.038210850208997726, 0.022270847111940384, 0.02669288031756878, 0.024901477620005608, -0.11089149117469788, 0.010340034030377865, -0.06054152920842171, -0.0073732598684728146, -0.001885474193841219, 0.021329691633582115, -0.007350086234509945, 0.02274726703763008, -0.0020356038585305214, 0.10248510539531708, -0.015507671050727367, 0.0007797603029757738, -0.06785812228918076, 0.04799574241042137, 0.08477716892957687, -0.01633688434958458, -0.03525855392217636, 0.030114172026515007, -0.05665537342429161, -0.07179546356201172, -0.024613870307803154, -0.07658016681671143, -0.0046516950242221355, 0.012008588761091232, -0.01175687275826931, -0.032516639679670334, -0.01436307281255722, 0.020780745893716812, -0.016739496961236, -0.005798547528684139, 0.06835956126451492, 0.03955068439245224, -0.03783746436238289, -0.008064572699368, -0.04581184685230255, 0.03484054654836655, 0.04287192225456238, -0.04670734331011772, 0.007946707308292389, 0.01344270259141922, -0.046852339059114456, 0.06807935982942581, 0.02678108401596546, 0.005898987874388695, -0.023228198289871216, -0.0554933063685894, 0.0007331142551265657, 0.06670130789279938, 0.0013842674670740962, 0.020464546978473663, -0.007835935801267624, 0.0155705027282238, 0.034836944192647934, 0.0433492437005043, 0.012607891112565994, -0.03260071575641632, 0.010603769682347775, 0.04395696893334389, 0.008498715236783028, -0.03223884850740433, 0.020635418593883514, -0.01846199855208397, -0.0698506087064743, -0.03020249493420124, -0.006555624306201935, -0.024774057790637016, -0.021840738132596016, -0.041354741901159286, 0.03240078315138817, 0.04967031255364418, -0.012603129260241985, -0.00716439401730895, -0.01753702014684677, 0.014674835838377476, 0.02606632001698017, 0.0431017242372036, 0.08961058408021927, -0.009814859367907047, -0.006834181025624275, 0.020369233563542366, -0.015504742041230202, 0.027435138821601868, 0.009499636478722095, -0.05866779759526253, 0.014604317024350166, 0.0004286074545234442, 0.06748572736978531, 0.0007873548311181366, 0.05055902898311615, -0.06181685999035835, -0.018757423385977745, -0.02376408316195011, 0.008555724285542965, 0.011833143420517445, 0.011539794504642487, -0.030933653935790062, 0.06277274340391159, -0.04770412668585777, 0.02141570672392845, 0.024748148396611214, -0.0159559678286314, -0.022685794159770012, -0.00002895086981880013, -0.02482708916068077, -0.007381442468613386, -0.0077118538320064545, 0.05917724221944809, 0.031613051891326904, 0.01569993607699871, -0.0010891054989770055, 0.033014994114637375, -0.03183504566550255, 0.022122260183095932, 0.06595882773399353, -0.0405707061290741, -0.03814917057752609, 0.055923476815223694, -0.021492930129170418, -0.023554755374789238, -0.012851664796471596, -0.011518297716975212, -0.05059043690562248, -0.05025065317749977, -0.023629890754818916, -0.04852248728275299, -0.03161310404539108, -0.014947404153645039, -0.1025523915886879, 0.025754984468221664, -0.061608705669641495, 0.007839195430278778, 0.023550700396299362, -0.030742594972252846, -0.00006850774661870673, 0.012754324823617935, 0.02417755499482155, -0.029992226511240005, 0.04457807540893555, -0.005847377236932516, -0.023799678310751915, 0.051929622888565063, 0.017736751586198807, 0.029572611674666405, -0.008323099464178085, -0.0005530109046958387, -0.045312121510505676, 0.08953958004713058, 0.044357918202877045, -0.05117908492684364, 0.008574948646128178, 0.04302707687020302, -0.09774293005466461, 0.07397535443305969, 0.00030269549461081624, 0.029205147176980972, -0.032976601272821426, -0.0001529771543573588, -0.0165090411901474, -0.03804893419146538, 0.049571793526411057, 0.021597038954496384, 0.034191735088825226, -0.024059556424617767, 0.014870714396238327, -0.028391694650053978, 0.08555728942155838, -0.0023815880995243788, 0.004138551652431488, 0.009166447445750237, 0.01741964928805828, -0.06445766985416412, 0.025085221976041794, -0.07337964326143265, 0.03259969502687454, -0.018241049721837044, -0.017605485394597054, 0.027956919744610786, -0.04197388142347336, 0.023792441934347153, -0.044683635234832764, 0.012149674817919731, 0.02771775797009468, -0.02457985281944275, -0.013863945379853249, -0.0782141461968422, -0.03296522796154022, -0.05607355386018753, -0.018505938351154327, 0.015289735980331898, -0.021460961550474167, -0.029619654640555382, 0.01914137601852417, -0.01879287138581276, 0.05985373258590698, -0.031207643449306488, 0.024477282539010048, 0.0010440252954140306, -0.05642537400126457, 0.01761810854077339, 0.018322406336665154, 0.0065458077006042, -0.0032443441450595856, -0.01975184865295887, -0.028208710253238678, 0.041165437549352646, 0.050506941974163055, -0.010198874399065971, 0.035245634615421295, 0.01468626782298088, -0.00838430505245924, -0.008877018466591835, 0.06916707009077072, -0.02400210127234459, -0.052528295665979385, 0.026800885796546936, -0.06091130152344704, 0.017510903999209404, 0.00804823823273182, 0.012846033088862896, 0.03863495960831642, -0.004719502758234739, 0.060175370424985886, -0.03248671069741249, 0.014826998114585876, 0.000506778946146369, 0.017047107219696045, -0.03850601986050606, -0.07434944063425064, 0.02084447629749775, 0.019278544932603836, 0.036066051572561264, -0.053686074912548065, 0.011580850929021835, -0.05248723179101944, -0.04613164812326431, -0.035628542304039, -0.07139060646295547, -0.031770676374435425, 0.005400589667260647, 0.003114479361101985, -0.02751886658370495, 0.038250621408224106, -0.0026949450839310884, -0.01027943380177021, 0.03943381458520889, 0.03765079006552696, 0.0009932252578437328, 0.03723053261637688, 0.01206936128437519, -0.010547487996518612, -0.005038467701524496, -0.01813524216413498, 0.03861439973115921, -0.026921194046735764, 0.02679198607802391, -0.03886517137289047, -0.03951602056622505, -0.004677817225456238, 0.057474251836538315, 0.0074811698868870735, -0.015652921050786972, 0.013422342948615551, -0.05467425286769867, -0.0242006815969944, 0.02961057983338833, -0.009529352188110352, 0.020400015637278557, -0.02151159569621086, 0.006854836829006672, -0.017621105536818504, -0.04132240265607834, 0.0085903974249959, -0.010120795108377934, -0.0184747613966465, 0.02627299353480339, -0.022581756114959717, -0.013590853661298752, -0.0813293606042862, -0.0011296793818473816, 0.049070656299591064, 0.03356758877635002, 0.017532752826809883, -0.013950816355645657, 0.09150577336549759, 0.028923125937581062, -0.07079070806503296, -0.028897812590003014, 0.03794484585523605, -0.008223677054047585, -0.0073818485252559185, 0.021883636713027954, 0.03302925080060959, 0.04225660488009453, -0.025000782683491707, -0.042695894837379456, -0.05807502567768097, -0.016689253970980644, -0.02192634344100952, -0.030757758766412735, 0.031147930771112442, 0.00853127520531416, -0.037066176533699036, 0.01228095032274723, -0.004819908645004034, 0.03593962639570236, -0.012616717256605625, 0.001281537814065814, 0.08193524926900864, 0.01499731745570898, -0.01005331426858902, 0.030088206753134727, -0.005200276616960764, 0.03528236970305443, 0.037269219756126404, 0.0037628915160894394, -0.02086249738931656, 0.03627695515751839, 0.003965407144278288, 0.03180939704179764, -0.060456231236457825, 0.032429199665784836, -0.0391433909535408, -0.03381824865937233, 0.008510005660355091, 0.06286915391683578, -0.04381602630019188, 0.02038811333477497, 0.056006770581007004, 0.027277473360300064, -0.027621164917945862, -0.03817548230290413, -0.012791216373443604, -0.07566659152507782, 0.0019882861524820328, -0.028573468327522278, -0.05088036134839058, -0.019901888445019722, -0.004033154342323542, 0.058993641287088394, 0.04170432314276695, 0.004169360734522343, 0.02024724893271923, -0.021622899919748306, -0.008812785148620605, 0.046378083527088165, 0.01166753564029932, -0.039756253361701965, 0.027737680822610855, 0.005821895785629749, 0.02990124560892582, -0.0395917147397995, 0.03937125578522682, -0.005351455416530371, -0.008981172926723957, -0.0313183031976223, -0.04312002286314964, 0.03413529694080353, 0.010236495174467564, 0.029172969982028008, -0.024031618610024452, -0.0013304653111845255, -0.0048151081427931786, -0.03108135052025318, 0.09629422426223755, 0.04591898247599602, 0.05790829658508301, 0.029769141227006912, 0.0649457722902298, -0.033165816217660904, 0.012118364684283733, -0.03236553817987442, 0.03994905576109886, -0.005129802506417036, 0.00926213525235653, 0.025203417986631393, -0.0668376237154007, 0.059397175908088684, 0.010669677518308163, 0.017829690128564835, 0.009017247706651688, -0.07726934552192688, 0.04000367969274521, 0.060075342655181885, -0.025635596364736557, -0.06502505391836166, 0.04564201831817627, 0.024135399609804153, 0.01297144964337349, 0.006870627868920565, 0.025008032098412514, -0.007639345247298479, 0.0016829653177410364, -0.011218244209885597, 0.05827130004763603, -0.03824444115161896, -0.0493197962641716, -0.03875167295336723, 0.032316867262125015, 0.04043782129883766, -0.0278313048183918, 0.0013761385343968868, 0.009329814463853836, 0.09891661256551743, -0.040826503187417984, 0.054142098873853683, 0.014008761383593082, 0.016154581680893898, -0.008697059005498886, -0.07651305198669434, -0.08659947663545609, -0.021111106500029564, -0.03953683748841286, 0.008551109582185745, 0.051836974918842316, 0.0633988156914711, 0.0007486868416890502, 0.04636957123875618, 0.08221475780010223, 0.04167032241821289, -0.026193195953965187, 0.017656847834587097, 0.0793134942650795, -0.04073889181017876, 0.01254395954310894, 0.03569278120994568, 0.05073951557278633, 0.027898406609892845, 0.07306001335382462, 0.0054748025722801685, -0.029155801981687546, 0.01493343897163868, -0.02648785524070263, -0.04121023789048195, 0.044697120785713196, 0.03832944482564926, -0.048644158989191055, -0.03939323499798775, 0.005995231214910746, -0.023280220106244087, -0.03267097845673561, 0.01704893633723259, 0.05349188670516014, -0.01634347252547741, -0.002026862697675824, -0.04771992564201355, -0.016072118654847145, 0.028998447582125664, 0.043158091604709625, 0.007831964641809464, -0.03553612157702446, 0.021432556211948395, -0.03134632855653763, 0.009743128903210163, -0.0438593365252018, 0.025338267907500267, -0.07508768141269684, -0.007798022124916315, -0.026831133291125298, -0.03234891965985298, -0.02482418157160282, -0.008099574595689774, 0.0008383057429455221, 0.020106101408600807, -0.04039857164025307, -0.016637474298477173, -0.02851906232535839, -0.043594177812337875, 0.06377635151147842, -0.03470337390899658, 0.007298113778233528, -0.048288557678461075, -0.051517464220523834, 0.027912067249417305, -0.036035679280757904, -0.02812253125011921, -0.022196853533387184, 0.00015627859102096409, 0.010700474493205547, 0.028894107788801193, -0.027894923463463783, -0.012142901308834553, -0.03679651394486427, 0.018135756254196167, 0.050048600882291794, 0.011139568872749805, -0.004629375878721476, -0.019161220639944077, -0.0020054555498063564, 0.01357157900929451, 0.038838908076286316, 0.012900643981993198, -0.05592002347111702, -0.013649377040565014, -0.0073714228346943855, 0.008006117306649685, 0.00949626974761486, -0.009688475169241428, 0.06833701580762863, 0.0025028339587152004, 0.00036604623892344534, -0.007912788540124893, 0.047747574746608734, 0.04206719249486923, 0.00007614241621922702 ]
<p>For a while I've been doing research on methods of obtaining conservation laws via the symmetries of differential equations (DEs). I'm presently doing research on identifying financial indicators/phenomena that can be associated with the conservation laws of the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black%E2%80%93Scholes_model" rel="nofollow">Black Scholes problem</a>. </p> <p>I've done some reading on econophysics and quantitative finance but there seems to be lots of contrasting and confusing views on this matter.</p> <p>Any contribution to shed light on this matter will be appreciated.</p>
g5910
[ 0.019084472209215164, 0.05395370349287987, 0.009395483881235123, 0.03366478905081749, 0.045337267220020294, 0.00809673685580492, 0.04817032068967819, 0.05266338586807251, -0.016146158799529076, 0.03834548965096474, 0.008284701965749264, -0.014739936217665672, 0.018844861537218094, 0.017948493361473083, -0.020677609369158745, -0.007177834864705801, 0.008570157922804356, 0.055934254080057144, -0.015143402852118015, 0.0016486813547089696, -0.02096177451312542, 0.005064832046627998, -0.019060589373111725, -0.03926657512784004, 0.02056560292840004, 0.008759287185966969, 0.003514543641358614, -0.03184458240866661, -0.037194814532995224, -0.028141355141997337, -0.003221737453714013, 0.04244227334856987, 0.056676916778087616, -0.02355014719069004, -0.05707022547721863, 0.02584594301879406, 0.025803217664361, 0.014547012746334076, 0.037062887102365494, 0.02133994549512863, 0.04237022250890732, 0.027807116508483887, -0.017787236720323563, -0.0058610206469893456, -0.017820697277784348, -0.01814230903983116, -0.03306202590465546, -0.04078860208392143, 0.01947627030313015, 0.013963013887405396, 0.08477401733398438, 0.022691266611218452, 0.07688304781913757, 0.012640491127967834, -0.04281431436538696, 0.005197579972445965, 0.04138342663645744, 0.019378768280148506, 0.042872317135334015, 0.015264716930687428, -0.027350960299372673, 0.037775345146656036, 0.04216289520263672, 0.04391218349337578, 0.0766637772321701, -0.027927422896027565, -0.017200402915477753, -0.04058501869440079, 0.034531500190496445, -0.0452679842710495, -0.007016511168330908, 0.03473642095923424, -0.003077295608818531, 0.03939373791217804, 0.009150706231594086, 0.04438966512680054, -0.006384043022990227, 0.04913314804434776, 0.0034313222859054804, -0.02218080312013626, -0.11140548437833786, 0.014800532720983028, 0.02408279851078987, 0.12711814045906067, 0.06582906097173691, 0.06656578183174133, 0.014588340185582638, 0.004529906902462244, -0.005261922720819712, -0.0023997961543500423, 0.03688201680779457, -0.05498899519443512, 0.015192161314189434, -0.013937263749539852, 0.018435319885611534, 0.06188146397471428, -0.013983063399791718, 0.03325262665748596, -0.016726095229387283, -0.000019356573830009438, -0.060471151024103165, 0.015356363728642464, 0.007315571419894695, -0.028414258733391762, 0.10474378615617752, 0.015872828662395477, 0.008676132187247276, 0.046903032809495926, -0.05319644883275032, 0.04735521227121353, 0.0013119964860379696, -0.05662451684474945, -0.08452939987182617, 0.0327170304954052, -0.03424586355686188, -0.03749247267842293, 0.0048815105110406876, -0.01971752755343914, 0.02167675457894802, 0.04437819495797157, -0.011671985499560833, 0.0010850379476323724, 0.10290901362895966, 0.010081099346280098, -0.005852063186466694, 0.02265806496143341, -0.005884314887225628, 0.0035447680857032537, 0.05147022753953934, -0.02991599403321743, 0.04477353394031525, -0.006891188677400351, 0.0030461635906249285, 0.044942084699869156, 0.013554183766245842, -0.009926390834152699, -0.023491118103265762, 0.033573348075151443, -0.016765598207712173, -0.027992956340312958, -0.002141280798241496, -0.009840726852416992, 0.023586681112647057, -0.001845923950895667, -0.010383040644228458, -0.055551059544086456, -0.004170147702097893, -0.023082787171006203, 0.019670626148581505, -0.06345271319150925, -0.044185373932123184, 0.05363309010863304, -0.048974595963954926, 0.018917076289653778, -0.022403651848435402, -0.012381228618323803, -0.01605934090912342, 0.012488039210438728, -0.04777441546320915, -0.03993789851665497, -0.0029419600032269955, -0.0483812540769577, 0.026997311040759087, 0.046107564121484756, -0.061417803168296814, -0.0449996180832386, -0.043415386229753494, -0.06020631641149521, 0.012313474901020527, 0.008426208049058914, -0.06376507878303528, 0.028184762224555016, 0.03872453048825264, 0.05733335018157959, 0.019698066636919975, 0.05636864900588989, -0.028785234317183495, -0.03377094864845276, 0.023866990581154823, -0.03736138343811035, -0.008249095641076565, -0.027205558493733406, 0.07752520591020584, 0.04542428255081177, 0.044821470975875854, -0.0032639671117067337, 0.0393257774412632, -0.004962693899869919, -0.045588623732328415, -0.02748713456094265, 0.010713406838476658, 0.0063813114538788795, 0.04192151501774788, 0.006014790385961533, 0.011362452059984207, 0.017747508361935616, 0.004385727923363447, -0.021392054855823517, -0.07096176594495773, 0.03467616066336632, -0.01105430256575346, 0.056130021810531616, 0.059792906045913696, -0.007900760509073734, -0.025428511202335358, 0.0109362518414855, -0.05447140708565712, 0.02449539117515087, 0.002221704227849841, -0.024067237973213196, -0.03927530348300934, -0.065903440117836, -0.000767761142924428, -0.04354249686002731, 0.02136892080307007, 0.03130713477730751, -0.030719613656401634, 0.022694800049066544, -0.02607785165309906, -0.03912639245390892, -0.0675077810883522, -0.01987830176949501, -0.0040261452086269855, 0.07493274658918381, 0.004150337539613247, 0.004712261725217104, -0.022990833967924118, -0.018744077533483505, 0.0024513655807822943, 0.0072160991840064526, -0.035881299525499344, 0.0031486235093325377, 0.007493122015148401, -0.0664428249001503, 0.003373044542968273, 0.07503198832273483, 0.060533467680215836, -0.033141739666461945, 0.007805984932929277, 0.030130697414278984, 0.042792271822690964, 0.025239888578653336, -0.03212076798081398, 0.0566071979701519, 0.046588633209466934, 0.02153107151389122, 0.013916711322963238, 0.05495864525437355, 0.046367302536964417, 0.017464805394411087, -0.008330858312547207, -0.038952235132455826, -0.021768053993582726, -0.02872045338153839, 0.02740424871444702, -0.03514445945620537, 0.02789587713778019, 0.011982162483036518, 0.00007677682879148051, -0.009860376827418804, 0.0063626947812736034, 0.06675034761428833, -0.004395858850330114, -0.010763685218989849, -0.026588493958115578, -0.038206879049539566, 0.03293326869606972, -0.03976590558886528, -0.004850299563258886, 0.03257877007126808, -0.012504716403782368, 0.032854899764060974, -0.06229187548160553, 0.0162308681756258, -0.014967042952775955, -0.05187592655420303, -0.01803220622241497, -0.01923425681889057, -0.02329494059085846, -0.006127026863396168, -0.05664357170462608, 0.004808015655726194, -0.013749617151916027, 0.004991491325199604, 0.05326755717396736, 0.04402955248951912, 0.006119870580732822, 0.0037274190690368414, -0.033773552626371384, 0.06843939423561096, -0.06437015533447266, 0.03963937982916832, 0.003822245169430971, 0.04319923743605614, -0.03081175871193409, 0.001313885673880577, -0.00969645194709301, -0.0711941197514534, -0.00923022348433733, 0.02051500976085663, -0.020146407186985016, 0.0017643769970163703, 0.014557424001395702, 0.03325820341706276, 0.0352143794298172, 0.06461125612258911, -0.02976139262318611, -0.025224504992365837, 0.07741623371839523, 0.024452468380331993, -0.03293367102742195, -0.010523500852286816, -0.02128777466714382, 0.02805100381374359, -0.04952578991651535, 0.02585478685796261, 0.033020760864019394, -0.0017348312539979815, 0.029553573578596115, -0.055481165647506714, -0.026399606838822365, -0.044990602880716324, 0.0440160371363163, -0.01685192808508873, 0.022130217403173447, 0.02309557795524597, -0.07414074242115021, 0.012945257127285004, -0.038196153938770294, -0.030969740822911263, 0.013073268346488476, -0.020148418843746185, 0.043594975024461746, -0.040007248520851135, -0.037929244339466095, 0.020303495228290558, -0.062211163341999054, -0.08648592233657837, 0.013444291427731514, -0.026410192251205444, -0.015531490556895733, -0.06482324004173279, -0.0016350758960470557, -0.03552990034222603, -0.09001058340072632, -0.0021185593213886023, 0.00942183006554842, 0.04832569509744644, 0.041791364550590515, -0.01785276085138321, -0.019673818722367287, -0.03008543699979782, 0.06289850175380707, -0.020938189700245857, 0.0019138638162985444, -0.009537643752992153, 0.04442741349339485, 0.05919875577092171, -0.021058859303593636, 0.08792205899953842, 0.0003649517602752894, -0.0011451925383880734, -0.029972948133945465, 0.03707851469516754, 0.0020361768547445536, 0.007540802005678415, 0.00441180681809783, -0.042073603719472885, -0.009200232103466988, -0.036635372787714005, -0.008812633343040943, 0.09112760424613953, 0.010873673483729362, 0.033886972814798355, 0.005816690158098936, -0.06511364877223969, 0.029382841661572456, 0.024709805846214294, -0.03311765193939209, -0.007377316243946552, 0.015572111122310162, 0.02009992115199566, -0.013314074836671352, 0.021472517400979996, -0.0015634752344340086, -0.0003810568305198103, -0.047474537044763565, 0.004692393355071545, -0.010860104113817215, -0.004204533062875271, 0.006201918236911297, 0.0018504704348742962, -0.00005846757994731888, -0.004166403319686651, 0.03718714788556099, 0.044145241379737854, -0.02176862582564354, -0.008322951383888721, -0.009862539358437061, 0.004179366864264011, 0.02094675973057747, 0.0012723912950605154, 0.02681100368499756, -0.00332191726192832, 0.004800096619874239, 0.0252632275223732, -0.009077210910618305, -0.013192948885262012, -0.013090498745441437, -0.011286226101219654, -0.050469547510147095, -0.02017107605934143, -0.03173691779375076, 0.016205277293920517, 0.005593382753431797, 0.0457349494099617, 0.008516300469636917, -0.03302934393286705, 0.0605020634829998, 0.02879716269671917, 0.05153881758451462, -0.027216248214244843, -0.015998609364032745, -0.05681152641773224, 0.035762764513492584, 0.023529550060629845, 0.027374297380447388, -0.05814381316304207, -0.004576888866722584, -0.013842699117958546, 0.032494209706783295, 0.02126719057559967, -0.0009690450388006866, 0.01193454209715128, -0.08541028946638107, 0.011306170374155045, -0.04787031561136246, 0.008111785165965557, -0.0783921405673027, 0.046507976949214935, 0.10216168314218521, -0.008718965575098991, -0.0031994374003261328, -0.050233036279678345, -0.00031494590803049505, 0.039344191551208496, -0.015059838071465492, -0.028130510821938515, -0.024142682552337646, -0.014932365156710148, 0.015797743573784828, 0.01798941195011139, 0.014093935489654541, -0.06377361714839935, -0.026728399097919464, -0.012021336704492569, -0.05707436800003052, 0.02767227590084076, 0.007855471223592758, 0.045657217502593994, -0.01741694286465645, -0.026906056329607964, 0.03996715322136879, -0.02380499802529812, 0.030693771317601204, -0.044684264808893204, 0.027650434523820877, 0.004824216943234205, 0.013981177471578121, -0.01715180091559887, -0.005752383731305599, 0.00797221064567566, 0.0518513061106205, -0.013526408933103085, 0.036488618701696396, -0.0016152241732925177, -0.00643698126077652, -0.02146461047232151, -0.005646148696541786, -0.054088108241558075, -0.04877671226859093, 0.07170974463224411, 0.08762360364198685, 0.05242607370018959, 0.01900096982717514, -0.020566165447235107, -0.0006282816175371408, 0.008351476863026619, 0.013284089043736458, -0.020364264026284218, 0.028188899159431458, 0.05161990225315094, 0.015936342999339104, 0.006836092099547386, -0.031126054003834724, 0.020862456411123276, 0.06195364519953728, -0.00369504326954484, -0.010131008923053741, -0.02633814327418804, -0.025539405643939972, 0.008959276601672173, 0.016914959996938705, -0.040761761367321014, 0.027733681723475456, 0.009253992699086666, 0.024922797456383705, 0.011409545317292213, 0.03254103660583496, -0.008434277959167957, -0.035876378417015076, -0.027914514765143394, 0.02958686277270317, 0.0021321906242519617, -0.0016138249775394797, -0.05237988755106926, -0.008937087841331959, 0.0015333903720602393, -0.01924443244934082, -0.08530664443969727, 0.029897935688495636, 0.025154363363981247, -0.014400091953575611, 0.012101090513169765, 0.05514172837138176, -0.029969459399580956, -0.08189976215362549, -0.02528039738535881, 0.0032164223957806826, -0.04123615846037865, 0.029978107661008835, -0.021639622747898102, 0.059047337621450424, 0.03153534233570099, 0.04314163699746132, -0.002446485450491309, 0.035028476268053055, -0.023536724969744682, 0.01782235875725746, 0.010559032671153545, 0.007075798232108355, 0.08085346966981888, 0.03133252635598183, 0.05350325256586075, -0.011465010233223438, -0.05304442346096039, -0.03350529819726944, -0.06753146648406982, -0.01960560493171215, -0.03373119235038757, -0.014419589191675186, 0.023528773337602615, 0.003621151437982917, 0.013157800771296024, -0.024359237402677536, -0.013411754742264748, -0.043133124709129333, -0.005382734350860119, -0.0320650152862072, 0.008723685517907143, 0.008123855106532574, 0.05857524275779724, 0.013146486133337021, 0.06470330059528351, -0.028662726283073425, -0.007380472030490637, 0.022454719990491867, -0.002919362857937813, 0.06349961459636688, 0.06755643337965012, -0.052486639469861984, -0.0038229397032409906, -0.018081050366163254, 0.0180383138358593, -0.029038503766059875, -0.027486585080623627, -0.05150497704744339, -0.04097273200750351, -0.0423617921769619, -0.02717435732483864, -0.018088195472955704, 0.029246730729937553, 0.03879794105887413, -0.037521012127399445, -0.09722819924354553, 0.03825043886899948, 0.025133861228823662, -0.005024767015129328, -0.01381645817309618, 0.02257062867283821, 0.0507124699652195, 0.013983621262013912, -0.025852808728814125, 0.008102516643702984, 0.035523053258657455, -0.06230583041906357, 0.02494644559919834, -0.0503484383225441, -0.014693548902869225, -0.052713844925165176, -0.03849279507994652, 0.008869634009897709, 0.024869775399565697, -0.036535199731588364, 0.007031662855297327, -0.025369836017489433, -0.022205248475074768, 0.09821471571922302, -0.024923482909798622, 0.05713614821434021, -0.03795000910758972, 0.062076590955257416, -0.0696730986237526, 0.024672022089362144, -0.009959723800420761, 0.011011864058673382, 0.0013626950094476342, 0.005526183173060417, -0.017925065010786057, -0.024135282263159752, -0.012442560866475105, 0.002570834243670106, -0.045259028673172, 0.006452198605984449, 0.0316363163292408, 0.03595438599586487, -0.05819530040025711, -0.02260691300034523, 0.02330470085144043, 0.06086437404155731, 0.006707574240863323, 0.00386002822779119, 0.004449007101356983, 0.017470164224505424, -0.004296470433473587, 0.004013019148260355, -0.05106982961297035, 0.05013730749487877, 0.043945059180259705, -0.028680605813860893, -0.012664541602134705, -0.006523480638861656, 0.053930725902318954, 0.014338530600070953, -0.024052688851952553, 0.04098988696932793, 0.052782103419303894, -0.0097552090883255, -0.05079595744609833, -0.0018392844358459115, 0.05723690614104271, -0.018732666969299316, -0.05381706729531288, -0.04122717306017876, -0.015405368991196156, -0.045283231884241104, -0.023925064131617546, -0.03721797466278076, 0.014382321387529373, -0.020987169817090034, -0.039474837481975555, 0.011190900579094887, 0.005020333919674158, -0.030933329835534096, 0.0038582340348511934, 0.04021212458610535, 0.019231515005230904, -0.04197072237730026, 0.021489564329385757, 0.03320571035146713, -0.0014595722313970327, -0.041033785790205, -0.02141708694398403, 0.014893134124577045, -0.05195377767086029, -0.0066873449832201, 0.015294305048882961, 0.00957487616688013, -0.0038782034534960985, 0.03514206036925316, 0.06954070925712585, -0.029176093637943268, -0.04381592199206352, -0.027564218267798424, -0.015876783058047295, 0.0395883284509182, 0.022344760596752167, 0.03884993866086006, 0.023574214428663254, 0.050664469599723816, -0.06357044726610184, -0.013316625729203224, -0.03735613822937012, -0.04988657683134079, 0.04181600362062454, -0.007960299961268902, 0.01933300867676735, 0.024573439732193947, -0.03583171218633652, -0.04694105312228203, 0.015586607158184052, -0.017170682549476624, -0.0054631647653877735, -0.025347258895635605, 0.03578225150704384, -0.03391314670443535, -0.0058386861346662045, -0.07537885755300522, -0.028369948267936707, 0.0277006383985281, 0.04176721349358559, -0.050965316593647, 0.003716077422723174, -0.016481049358844757, 0.09596703201532364, -0.048859577625989914, 0.004321795888245106, -0.0859999805688858, -0.07560115307569504, 0.024641845375299454, 0.06185983121395111, -0.018031740561127663, -0.023227080702781677, -0.06406428664922714, -0.027962569147348404, -0.07178669422864914, -0.03772749751806259, 0.014127802103757858, -0.05338691174983978, 0.025672627612948418, -0.03162708133459091, 0.006848249584436417, 0.009079894982278347, 0.014052795246243477, 0.00895163044333458, 0.032264240086078644, -0.0041958182118833065, -0.03881049156188965, -0.06478448957204819, 0.026692723855376244, 0.011538480408489704, -0.0712762102484703, 0.012854780070483685, -0.07247007638216019, -0.04441969841718674, -0.02189161628484726, 0.02372666634619236, -0.017230525612831116, -0.007211899384856224, 0.044794872403144836, 0.027096865698695183, 0.030701041221618652, 0.008305687457323074, 0.012525750324130058, 0.031930189579725266, -0.03891707584261894, -0.05325556918978691, -0.020447511225938797, 0.0029955734498798847, 0.03467193618416786, -0.015388809144496918, 0.0220893956720829, -0.02537566050887108, -0.024039508774876595, -0.007871964015066624, -0.06054612994194031, -0.010133442468941212, 0.047456998378038406 ]
<p>Recently, I was contemplating the beautiful formulation of electromagnetism (specifically Maxwell's equations) in terms of differential forms: $$F=\mathrm{d} A\implies \mathrm{d}F=0 \hspace{1cm}\text{and}\hspace{1cm} \mathrm{d}\star\mathrm{d}F=\mu_0 J $$ I started thinking about the history of this way of looking at things, and realized that I don't know much about it at all. My first question was therefore: Was it known already at the time of Maxwell (or soon after) that electromagnetism could be cast in this geometric form? How was this first introduced and who did it? </p> <p>After consulting Maxwell's treatise, it became clear that at least Maxwell himself was not aware of this formulation. But maybe someone else immediately recognized the geometric formulation once Maxwell published his results... </p> <p>In modern times, one is - at least as a physicist - usually first introduced to the field strength tensor $F$ through the covariant formulation of Maxwell's equation using tensor calculus, where it is defined as $F_{\mu\nu}=\partial_\mu A_\nu -\partial_\nu A_\mu$. When one then learns about differential forms etc. it is then obvious that $F=\mathrm{d}A$ and the geometric formulation follows quite naturally. However, was this also the case historically? Did 'they' come up with the tensor calculus formulation of $F$ first, and did they only then recognize the geometric description? Or was the geometric description discovered first? Another possibility is that it took the introduction of Einstein's general relativity for anyone to realize that fields can be interpreted in terms of geometry.</p> <p>In conclusion, I am interested in a chronological description of the development of the different formulations of electromagnetism, with emphasis on the following points:</p> <ol> <li>Who first came up with the geometric formulation in terms of differential forms?</li> <li>Is it known at all how this person arrived at this? </li> <li>Was the geometric interpretation discovered <em>before</em> tensor calculus became popular, or only after it was know that $F_{\mu\nu}=\partial_\mu A_\nu -\partial_\nu A_\mu$? Was this after the introduction of GR, and was it at all influenced by Einstein's work?</li> </ol>
g5911
[ 0.04687368869781494, -0.016855517402291298, -0.005986948497593403, -0.020260564982891083, 0.056753579527139664, 0.04756952077150345, 0.127335786819458, -0.010259649716317654, -0.061598487198352814, -0.010805615223944187, -0.0201308224350214, -0.024682102724909782, 0.07562264800071716, -0.010363656096160412, 0.02960372157394886, 0.0031426027417182922, 0.006088710855692625, -0.033418938517570496, 0.03775433078408241, -0.050737038254737854, -0.025545421987771988, 0.04141144081950188, 0.051999531686306, 0.001287415623664856, -0.05734873190522194, 0.0035722453612834215, -0.032290391623973846, -0.016445064917206764, 0.002528380136936903, -0.03938676789402962, 0.010741033591330051, 0.03625350818037987, 0.06941403448581696, -0.010773995891213417, -0.009482978843152523, -0.09531642496585846, -0.03476928547024727, 0.0792529284954071, -0.013884523883461952, 0.022342154756188393, 0.02548164501786232, -0.017561130225658417, -0.007576844654977322, 0.012215955182909966, 0.03340039402246475, -0.0013538383645936847, -0.04387098178267479, -0.011940131895244122, -0.032998692244291306, 0.019724490121006966, 0.0035724970512092113, 0.011424321681261063, 0.06044090539216995, -0.06978967040777206, -0.007495923433452845, -0.05743861198425293, -0.01602466218173504, -0.02311553992331028, 0.05980132147669792, -0.028214404359459877, -0.0046393852680921555, 0.03437099605798721, -0.0005303046782501042, 0.015197981148958206, 0.03318854793906212, 0.01113458164036274, -0.015179941430687904, -0.07188693434000015, 0.04752568528056145, -0.0015611215494573116, -0.009215564467012882, -0.05463878810405731, 0.06050993874669075, 0.02878631092607975, 0.07058880478143692, -0.014707636088132858, 0.017324501648545265, -0.015367214567959309, 0.027782291173934937, -0.03765435889363289, 0.0036784231197088957, 0.03264547884464264, 0.04877382144331932, -0.028238445520401, 0.11361511051654816, -0.006793519482016563, -0.0010332259116694331, 0.02530532330274582, 0.021686650812625885, 0.029980292543768883, 0.003614196553826332, -0.009630713611841202, -0.0015640448546037078, 0.0019147222628816962, 0.008525343611836433, -0.060894157737493515, -0.012370910495519638, 0.030348224565386772, -0.0205858051776886, -0.01444458682090044, -0.02473476342856884, -0.016568947583436966, -0.017390694469213486, 0.016733217984437943, 0.01501500979065895, 0.07311233878135681, 0.017019566148519516, 0.012883897870779037, -0.022285468876361847, -0.012184945866465569, -0.027652449905872345, 0.028884407132864, -0.020401731133461, 0.02130952849984169, -0.050617314875125885, -0.04241754114627838, 0.009951531887054443, -0.059544119983911514, -0.011085244826972485, 0.06397435069084167, -0.024497810751199722, -0.027571186423301697, 0.01287165842950344, 0.029467668384313583, -0.010728258639574051, 0.022568978369235992, -0.041307516396045685, -0.014265148900449276, 0.04911887273192406, -0.02007240056991577, 0.024801239371299744, 0.020252596586942673, 0.008299341425299644, -0.010060887783765793, -0.029499175027012825, 0.05603446811437607, -0.004927647765725851, -0.0031684967689216137, -0.025287851691246033, -0.010887491516768932, -0.04790571331977844, -0.047624822705984116, 0.000057164110330631956, -0.0243380106985569, 0.015841135755181313, 0.03350488841533661, 0.011769344098865986, -0.05681692436337471, -0.006681761704385281, 0.04876052960753441, -0.01355257723480463, 0.06689973920583725, -0.032111756503582, -0.00881220679730177, 0.00044491395237855613, -0.006156679708510637, 0.015218431130051613, 0.02069440670311451, 0.014874350279569626, -0.04568525031208992, 0.07462408393621445, 0.032405734062194824, -0.02784273587167263, -0.04734240844845772, -0.004280243068933487, -0.017345895990729332, -0.014131764881312847, -0.0668066069483757, 0.017945023253560066, -0.06643021106719971, -0.0077602444216609, 0.049092572182416916, 0.02013685181736946, -0.029068036004900932, -0.03520679101347923, 0.031359460204839706, 0.03729000687599182, -0.09374170750379562, 0.02836732752621174, 0.026403255760669708, -0.05872289091348648, -0.02770410105586052, -0.025197524577379227, -0.01819952018558979, -0.003777354024350643, -0.0001230451453011483, -0.01840856298804283, 0.008584713563323021, -0.04851406812667847, -0.007894845679402351, -0.053928032517433167, 0.014289303682744503, -0.017487820237874985, 0.08815363794565201, 0.01700354740023613, 0.04355884715914726, 0.016471276059746742, -0.011220408603549004, 0.01855485886335373, 0.12096105515956879, -0.02079230360686779, 0.06099557504057884, 0.028143666684627533, 0.02278231456875801, -0.03790159896016121, 0.02368508093059063, 0.006387291010469198, -0.012225025333464146, 0.09282475709915161, -0.006908506620675325, -0.008784200996160507, -0.04041638597846031, 0.03360489755868912, -0.0335833877325058, -0.019865451380610466, 0.00877300277352333, 0.024867067113518715, 0.022409172728657722, -0.06162865459918976, 0.047579508274793625, 0.006814003922045231, -0.012451812624931335, 0.06134200841188431, -0.009432213380932808, -0.06627582013607025, 0.008353841491043568, 0.007528719492256641, 0.011241784319281578, -0.02249228209257126, 0.028486447408795357, -0.05884932354092598, 0.037163443863391876, 0.014208349399268627, 0.0075014252215623856, -0.015328473411500454, -0.01113545149564743, -0.060953110456466675, -0.07216497510671616, 0.023119041696190834, 0.006218599155545235, -0.012059863656759262, 0.0017899776576086879, 0.051174458116292953, 0.025806495919823647, 0.007180795539170504, -0.03574980050325394, 0.037276431918144226, 0.0013881028862670064, 0.017144115641713142, 0.008766120299696922, -0.010580352507531643, -0.05911354720592499, -0.034215591847896576, -0.04986799880862236, -0.005507364869117737, 0.02490294724702835, -0.05738808587193489, -0.001706895069219172, -0.06550046801567078, -0.01134918350726366, 0.012489835731685162, -0.018872518092393875, -0.015359479002654552, 0.030076047405600548, -0.07247205078601837, -0.04316597804427147, 0.0023513406049460173, 0.01902838423848152, 0.029030049219727516, -0.022334745153784752, -0.00686011603102088, 0.04985335096716881, 0.015228024683892727, -0.05266720429062843, -0.06825275719165802, -0.010642986744642258, -0.023441068828105927, -0.009507997892796993, 0.029134033247828484, 0.016074568033218384, -0.016431480646133423, -0.020152872428297997, -0.011646859347820282, -0.016702599823474884, 0.040761251002550125, -0.08589325845241547, -0.018362291157245636, -0.014866316691040993, -0.0063668666407465935, -0.014000657014548779, -0.039859917014837265, -0.0006240015500225127, 0.015494867227971554, -0.09010610729455948, -0.08021865040063858, 0.04011019319295883, -0.009977350942790508, -0.02140604890882969, -0.028271667659282684, -0.02913176827132702, 0.03206995129585266, 0.000048301793867722154, 0.0006375486264005303, -0.021014899015426636, 0.03865400329232216, -0.0029893661849200726, -0.016016384586691856, -0.007688268553465605, 0.019174084067344666, -0.02155008725821972, -0.07572570443153381, 0.01931236870586872, -0.0336325541138649, -0.010396485216915607, -0.08516113460063934, -0.04944661259651184, 0.033738330006599426, 0.028056316077709198, -0.010173026472330093, -0.0020415603648871183, 0.030943481251597404, 0.009842206723988056, -0.006681526079773903, -0.03363800793886185, 0.07500334084033966, 0.04392287880182266, 0.008644572459161282, 0.02895023114979267, 0.004686516709625721, -0.0032661983277648687, -0.02999085746705532, -0.028358181938529015, -0.014834605157375336, 0.03152545168995857, -0.02328438311815262, -0.019016005098819733, -0.07421411573886871, -0.005851262249052525, 0.00409476226195693, -0.09040148556232452, 0.011268140748143196, -0.006575989071279764, -0.0733979269862175, 0.011797657236456871, 0.056132689118385315, -0.006193214096128941, 0.010666487738490105, 0.013614152558147907, 0.01546559575945139, -0.03400592878460884, -0.014338483102619648, -0.00689274538308382, 0.06221271678805351, 0.05336977168917656, -0.010382312349975109, 0.019995063543319702, 0.06246384233236313, 0.06736889481544495, 0.023897822946310043, -0.01300086174160242, -0.003742189146578312, -0.010577959008514881, -0.004299820866435766, 0.03306978940963745, -0.00002768664671748411, 0.019482076168060303, 0.050112806260585785, 0.020627165213227272, -0.04711460694670677, 0.048628658056259155, 0.012226971797645092, 0.012910382822155952, 0.017488760873675346, 0.04415608569979668, -0.010191011242568493, -0.04190528020262718, -0.047230351716279984, -0.0061164372600615025, -0.024733541533350945, -0.0458657331764698, -0.05655675381422043, 0.07304177433252335, 0.09210804104804993, 0.022224804386496544, 0.0040238164365291595, -0.035237424075603485, -0.006202088203281164, -0.004681095015257597, 0.0023709021043032408, -0.004612750373780727, 0.011390983127057552, 0.0704125165939331, -0.001542884623631835, 0.009454630315303802, -0.021289225667715073, 0.03864492475986481, 0.004619649611413479, 0.00683192303404212, 0.007608687039464712, -0.03894636034965515, 0.006593269295990467, 0.03595055267214775, 0.03222501650452614, 0.027790680527687073, 0.019504887983202934, -0.02476971410214901, -0.015483276918530464, -0.06568301469087601, 0.04672587662935257, -0.034712549299001694, -0.018696513026952744, -0.04688619449734688, -0.009827479720115662, -0.03495658561587334, 0.07786031067371368, 0.03164117410778999, 0.029964853078126907, -0.022119181230664253, 0.03691866248846054, -0.032003968954086304, 0.06944944709539413, 0.04154983162879944, -0.01658131368458271, -0.028910063207149506, 0.08289142698049545, 0.07294662296772003, 0.03156568855047226, -0.0025389911606907845, -0.015184544026851654, 0.03456345200538635, -0.010070225223898888, 0.025100527331233025, -0.04119356349110603, 0.021573973819613457, -0.05403430387377739, 0.004942325409501791, -0.018226981163024902, 0.029570328071713448, 0.03706078231334686, 0.018266497179865837, 0.08844596892595291, -0.007966907694935799, 0.009922998957335949, -0.06640119105577469, 0.001696229912340641, -0.025558803230524063, -0.028295019641518593, -0.007811180781573057, -0.030292220413684845, -0.034953076392412186, -0.0234179999679327, 0.012681638821959496, 0.02195315808057785, 0.03518737107515335, -0.037470124661922455, 0.021553071215748787, 0.00990744773298502, -0.009220424108207226, 0.016417115926742554, 0.047099970281124115, -0.008187108673155308, -0.0016668613534420729, -0.01491251029074192, 0.025063157081604004, 0.029317490756511688, -0.03469410166144371, -0.060769982635974884, 0.022260433062911034, -0.03387570008635521, -0.02244465798139572, 0.01084135938435793, 0.033366695046424866, 0.03305055946111679, -0.07488428801298141, 0.06427024304866791, 0.013323609717190266, 0.004206968005746603, -0.005750503856688738, -0.08159489929676056, -0.01378315407782793, 0.00011684342462103814, 0.017287133261561394, -0.012348498217761517, -0.0012994871940463781, -0.029742151498794556, 0.060726989060640335, 0.020950939506292343, 0.0158381350338459, -0.0292415339499712, -0.03435995429754257, -0.014090942218899727, -0.016624951735138893, 0.01960838958621025, 0.024473516270518303, -0.03348388150334358, -0.007328023202717304, -0.055302150547504425, -0.03847036138176918, 0.008533927612006664, -0.037030186504125595, -0.038461968302726746, 0.025295374915003777, -0.021835187450051308, -0.00038079897058196366, 0.03716672956943512, 0.0547034852206707, -0.007867056876420975, -0.04060285910964012, 0.029399609193205833, 0.011684278026223183, -0.00215905555523932, 0.006158475764095783, -0.047637369483709335, 0.022899875417351723, 0.038962166756391525, -0.0045946999453008175, -0.06415213644504547, 0.05290217697620392, 0.07523521035909653, -0.03617915138602257, 0.03058522194623947, -0.024432793259620667, -0.01591462455689907, -0.004545252770185471, 0.053556714206933975, 0.02402632310986519, -0.07231469452381134, -0.045288585126399994, 0.029182832688093185, 0.018486596643924713, 0.045168615877628326, 0.011487390846014023, -0.0017900735838338733, -0.0324525311589241, -0.0186457596719265, -0.023943692445755005, 0.04782424494624138, 0.009225723333656788, 0.07037904113531113, 0.011857215315103531, -0.07329458743333817, 0.0036835491191595793, 0.039314478635787964, 0.04724835976958275, -0.00790515635162592, 0.010370311327278614, 0.010654179379343987, 0.009054469875991344, 0.050220590084791183, -0.020456282421946526, -0.027327939867973328, -0.026881512254476547, -0.01172261405736208, -0.03793798387050629, -0.024003105238080025, 0.06615867465734482, -0.04397161677479744, -0.026705417782068253, -0.011172892525792122, -0.017524825409054756, 0.06313278526067734, -0.013748359866440296, -0.002962545258924365, -0.028089305385947227, -0.10749965906143188, -0.026705458760261536, 0.08133994787931442, -0.002990854438394308, 0.04245752468705177, 0.06563195586204529, 0.03587613254785538, -0.0015518051804974675, -0.022482534870505333, -0.020882779732346535, -0.0038520917296409607, -0.009050033986568451, -0.010898850858211517, -0.02040766179561615, -0.029502345249056816, 0.03773770481348038, 0.04673607274889946, -0.02045677974820137, 0.04875117540359497, -0.04402151703834534, -0.06737440824508667, 0.07067757844924927, -0.01669931598007679, -0.011413385160267353, -0.0044813272543251514, -0.033703964203596115, 0.03598589450120926, -0.009713677689433098, 0.024057410657405853, -0.019550485536456108, -0.01089982595294714, -0.03261798247694969, 0.06203034520149231, 0.03859974443912506, 0.017273826524615288, -0.0047014313749969006, 0.020959075540304184, -0.006449582055211067, -0.023163478821516037, -0.010297005996108055, 0.07988929003477097, -0.027370167896151543, 0.020931795239448547, -0.05385008454322815, 0.013591117225587368, -0.02946062944829464, 0.05357585847377777, 0.013537322171032429, -0.09674631804227829, -0.013594339601695538, 0.004491222556680441, 0.013682233169674873, -0.011501472443342209, -0.0008495507063344121, -0.0036745581310242414, -0.0608496218919754, 0.00022890444961376488, 0.006476780399680138, 0.023333750665187836, -0.002812966937199235, 0.04633002355694771, 0.004923481028527021, 0.03020774945616722, 0.018591487780213356, -0.01857786439359188, 0.01155985426157713, 0.021384119987487793, -0.022837361320853233, -0.022311855107545853, 0.006834493484348059, 0.00016977886843960732, -0.016295094043016434, 0.02166411094367504, 0.011527616530656815, 0.027076035737991333, 0.0038951432798057795, -0.030864369124174118, -0.05877380073070526, 0.0653458833694458, 0.008449501357972622, -0.00941360555589199, -0.03390045836567879, 0.009800798259675503, -0.010916066356003284, -0.06852846592664719, 0.050928037613630295, 0.0437394417822361, -0.011770040728151798, 0.014762178994715214, 0.0006830655038356781, -0.034099217504262924, 0.030501214787364006, -0.01879090443253517, 0.02499416656792164, -0.04500911384820938, -0.08346404135227203, -0.021618561819195747, 0.026089230552315712, 0.0005343987722881138, -0.012116339057683945, -0.025757303461432457, 0.011611134745180607, 0.027204647660255432, -0.004032589960843325, -0.015180935151875019, -0.025061551481485367, 0.03390805050730705, -0.0464252308011055, -0.008077648468315601, 0.049076229333877563, 0.020675158128142357, -0.0317181721329689, -0.03703509271144867, 0.018169589340686798, -0.008993037045001984, -0.04037495702505112, -0.06548700481653214, 0.021011196076869965, 0.005423042923212051, -0.006743239238858223, -0.03321639075875282, -0.004980635829269886, -0.030721353366971016, -0.00963129848241806, -0.03441622853279114, 0.03304534777998924, 0.003060918068513274, -0.04320620000362396, 0.012079927138984203, 0.009086953476071358, -0.010543912649154663, -0.029107073321938515, 0.02869337797164917, 0.10218705236911774, 0.04231846332550049, -0.01684325560927391, -0.0018832593923434615, -0.011268997564911842, 0.006993740331381559, -0.014684576541185379, 0.005958142690360546, 0.041021090000867844, -0.029622884467244148, -0.009400303475558758, -0.05350695922970772, -0.003353382693603635, -0.0012274687178432941, 0.05818096548318863, 0.03758234530687332, 0.034047454595565796, -0.0022939606569707394, 0.07900325208902359, -0.0213113185018301, -0.02766880765557289, -0.030918799340724945, 0.008363394998013973, -0.008819250389933586, 0.016968708485364914, -0.010579084977507591, -0.09483570605516434, 0.006306047551333904, 0.08503700792789459, 0.0008354178862646222, 0.02988077513873577, 0.03743872046470642, -0.0032231176737695932, 0.04303537681698799, -0.03486834466457367, 0.013262594118714333, 0.03101419471204281, -0.004305893089622259, -0.01489016879349947, -0.03256521746516228, -0.0362674742937088, 0.04923778399825096, -0.03276219218969345, 0.013690418563783169, -0.0560840480029583, -0.006313328165560961, 0.02535049244761467, -0.03347381204366684, 0.025449784472584724, 0.011616316623985767, 0.08562467247247696, -0.023710433393716812, -0.03695840388536453, -0.010380742140114307, 0.006472816225141287, -0.06034989655017853, 0.029184501618146896, 0.04743240401148796, -0.04130009561777115, 0.05504914000630379, 0.023829614743590355, 0.05887472257018089, 0.03024396486580372, 0.011313647963106632, -0.02498629316687584, 0.05423218384385109, 0.035243209451436996, -0.05730919912457466, 0.014618806540966034, 0.04166712239384651, -0.006958713289350271 ]
<p>I learnt that in astrophysical spectroscopy, the emission spectrum of distant stars is used to determine what they're made of. So why is it that our own Sun is emitting the whole spectrum ? (or is that information incorrect)</p>
g5912
[ 0.010130463168025017, -0.0004449848202057183, 0.018044238910079002, 0.005659894086420536, -0.0004275187966413796, 0.009739948436617851, -0.00003840712088276632, 0.02137848734855652, -0.029478108510375023, -0.050586577504873276, 0.03811550885438919, 0.06209062784910202, 0.08535154163837433, 0.011424449272453785, 0.03757495433092117, -0.027404222637414932, 0.01026084367185831, -0.005691073834896088, 0.03734057396650314, 0.0870758593082428, -0.03376644849777222, -0.032084956765174866, 0.01408770214766264, -0.00935465469956398, -0.09217742085456848, -0.04054325446486473, 0.0297170989215374, -0.06297330558300018, 0.06014356017112732, -0.012545578181743622, 0.03291415050625801, 0.022647066041827202, 0.033762700855731964, 0.052292581647634506, -0.04175334423780441, -0.0009962901240214705, -0.00028376185218803585, 0.0021656290628015995, 0.049646876752376556, 0.005044297780841589, -0.022613726556301117, 0.04473761469125748, 0.06897759437561035, 0.03705896809697151, 0.005889633670449257, -0.020333385095000267, 0.0042855264618992805, 0.030388081446290016, -0.006802521646022797, -0.02173677086830139, 0.01660984195768833, -0.061206597834825516, 0.009048010222613811, 0.028687339276075363, 0.017290987074375153, -0.019709523767232895, -0.03287053853273392, -0.03780146688222885, 0.06875841319561005, -0.03754202276468277, 0.012474962510168552, 0.0065452223643660545, -0.01990269310772419, 0.027707139030098915, -0.010243147611618042, -0.049781106412410736, -0.03036549873650074, -0.003429879667237401, 0.005702024791389704, 0.050484549254179, 0.04931116849184036, -0.01920499838888645, 0.017049474641680717, -0.028506139293313026, 0.0074760145507752895, -0.013266942463815212, -0.00045052162022329867, 0.0017669503577053547, -0.0019152213353663683, 0.03403617441654205, 0.02048593945801258, -0.06111648306250572, -0.03237796574831009, 0.02014044299721718, 0.07793965190649033, 0.006731949280947447, -0.03665056452155113, 0.011334877461194992, -0.016167227178812027, 0.005017036572098732, 0.03829896077513695, -0.032196804881095886, 0.0877639502286911, -0.02535131387412548, 0.03306364640593529, -0.014374193735420704, -0.0047010499984025955, 0.037218187004327774, -0.045771274715662, -0.002272910438477993, -0.04691603034734726, -0.005032844375818968, 0.0034712778870016336, -0.0004899851628579199, 0.07309476286172867, 0.013923054561018944, 0.0005755974561907351, -0.028929071500897408, -0.04866096377372742, -0.03196561709046364, 0.018836645409464836, -0.004239761736243963, 0.05731428787112236, 0.015333393588662148, -0.02596033364534378, 0.005941993091255426, 0.07568738609552383, -0.06980570405721664, 0.018361017107963562, 0.03446037694811821, 0.05170309543609619, -0.03111707791686058, -0.00263785058632493, 0.025192242115736008, -0.04026613384485245, -0.010109541937708855, 0.04570196196436882, -0.019218673929572105, 0.016261540353298187, -0.01081402599811554, 0.0038857341278344393, -0.004111060872673988, -0.05551067739725113, -0.008791036903858185, 0.10092174261808395, -0.02321392297744751, 0.025422358885407448, 0.03687020391225815, -0.003097308101132512, 0.027612948790192604, 0.011504859663546085, 0.04246294125914574, -0.01744362711906433, -0.01994284801185131, -0.014467937871813774, 0.07515574991703033, -0.026020165532827377, -0.06282103806734085, 0.003443680005148053, -0.0068327574990689754, 0.05297689512372017, 0.06808745115995407, 0.04554133489727974, -0.03254832699894905, -0.010098487138748169, -0.051429059356451035, 0.023947851732373238, -0.056266140192747116, -0.05305558070540428, 0.022968702018260956, 0.06855475902557373, -0.04408172145485878, -0.014616353437304497, 0.02630569413304329, -0.013933314941823483, 0.013302530162036419, -0.054757583886384964, -0.042920660227537155, 0.012179745361208916, -0.023318398743867874, -0.022717943415045738, -0.016326764598488808, -0.005788368638604879, -0.009663227945566177, 0.021000662818551064, 0.011752840131521225, 0.07633233815431595, -0.02376759797334671, 0.032312773168087006, 0.0829046368598938, 0.022036993876099586, -0.01191980391740799, -0.049637287855148315, -0.024833576753735542, 0.02821122668683529, 0.014045999385416508, -0.03225177899003029, -0.07426803559064865, 0.006540927570313215, 0.03559916093945503, 0.05182598531246185, -0.019724946469068527, -0.004107252694666386, 0.0041884491220116615, 0.02104968950152397, -0.025863271206617355, -0.03865881636738777, -0.022780299186706543, -0.015149487182497978, 0.0013347616186365485, -0.021832002326846123, 0.02095377817749977, -0.03445896878838539, 0.028429172933101654, -0.03252503648400307, 0.05747578665614128, -0.003412350546568632, -0.05498596653342247, 0.062177881598472595, 0.018335819244384766, -0.013440976850688457, -0.016290822997689247, 0.005943818483501673, 0.042346421629190445, -0.0045149317011237144, -0.05485283210873604, -0.05856320634484291, 0.003719745436683297, 0.03712813928723335, 0.011390159837901592, -0.013009777292609215, 0.02075258083641529, 0.05585876479744911, -0.04038945958018303, -0.03251418098807335, 0.07047887146472931, -0.07673860341310501, 0.04840674251317978, 0.004385780077427626, -0.00368207017891109, 0.0133151113986969, -0.08436253666877747, 0.052715759724378586, 0.042892079800367355, -0.009862701408565044, -0.040481068193912506, 0.007494890596717596, 0.007832531817257404, 0.018899843096733093, 0.03124072216451168, -0.02679068222641945, -0.11970105767250061, -0.02344716526567936, 0.004835955332964659, -0.009031992405653, -0.014132262207567692, 0.0298781581223011, -0.019741157069802284, -0.002862148219719529, -0.010207957588136196, 0.01563219353556633, 0.0122828995808959, 0.033670950680971146, -0.012250623665750027, -0.039774879813194275, -0.011827846989035606, -0.006246361415833235, 0.060578227043151855, -0.03135019168257713, -0.008483819663524628, -0.00007806358917150646, -0.08117272704839706, -0.0005103920702822506, -0.02450704015791416, 0.01547994650900364, 0.016906270757317543, -0.0370974987745285, 0.020477117970585823, -0.005022572819143534, -0.04526451602578163, 0.01727369986474514, 0.06644273549318314, 0.04253136366605759, -0.00784267857670784, -0.0179660152643919, 0.05585212633013725, -0.03928498178720474, 0.026140186935663223, 0.05293261259794235, 0.001226983149535954, -0.03620174154639244, 0.016436122357845306, -0.0382632352411747, -0.040509313344955444, -0.011541398242115974, -0.028041940182447433, -0.012659701518714428, -0.0016534781316295266, 0.04962214455008507, -0.00523169431835413, 0.08518020808696747, -0.02815146930515766, -0.014405298978090286, -0.007562916725873947, 0.014792541041970253, 0.03635012358427048, 0.012111920863389969, 0.07338493317365646, -0.04143838584423065, 0.020074116066098213, 0.03127461299300194, 0.0007127746939659119, -0.010913008823990822, -0.026660459116101265, 0.047607820481061935, -0.018110334873199463, -0.0718931183218956, -0.0902654156088829, -0.018524985760450363, -0.035445135086774826, -0.006644342560321093, -0.07253143936395645, 0.0044958400540053844, 0.06173255667090416, 0.017507463693618774, 0.051087357103824615, -0.09451577812433243, -0.022045329213142395, -0.04148416593670845, -0.03465409576892853, 0.034592341631650925, 0.01943793147802353, -0.033348653465509415, -0.02914998307824135, 0.036085084080696106, 0.008127545937895775, -0.02457723580300808, -0.055091310292482376, -0.006708925124257803, -0.09650982171297073, 0.00381402182392776, 0.009060944430530071, -0.009979110211133957, -0.01009619515389204, -0.02877434715628624, -0.015544737689197063, -0.03248750790953636, 0.035401489585638046, -0.003335006767883897, 0.05834150314331055, -0.023237381130456924, 0.018112070858478546, -0.05205371603369713, 0.020018573850393295, -0.02233041636645794, 0.026023631915450096, 0.009802401065826416, -0.05913274735212326, -0.000843219633679837, -0.04266126826405525, 0.012612965889275074, -0.006408842280507088, -0.060486506670713425, -0.03478220850229263, -0.0559147410094738, 0.019095299765467644, 0.01506264228373766, 0.029204459860920906, 0.02883954718708992, 0.004707408603280783, 0.08394242823123932, -0.021046791225671768, 0.01578390784561634, 0.02175583504140377, 0.017311319708824158, 0.023899801075458527, 0.017412910237908363, 0.012661820277571678, 0.06729729473590851, -0.000509172270540148, -0.02124127559363842, 0.023221934214234352, -0.020474648103117943, -0.025636084377765656, 0.04306301474571228, -0.04292001947760582, 0.06204938143491745, -0.013880551792681217, -0.00999319925904274, 0.035793595016002655, 0.048575568944215775, 0.026380687952041626, -0.004143459722399712, 0.0038744104094803333, 0.07186534255743027, 0.03588243946433067, -0.0776432454586029, -0.01937692239880562, -0.01675383746623993, -0.06096428260207176, 0.03881430625915527, -0.11398918181657791, -0.017172958701848984, -0.05609474703669548, -0.04292342811822891, -0.0377984419465065, 0.01598183810710907, 0.016602423042058945, 0.0626872330904007, 0.021687321364879608, -0.015437056310474873, -0.043649204075336456, 0.02699052169919014, -0.040089238435029984, 0.01391520630568266, 0.08781322836875916, 0.009718409739434719, -0.0569644533097744, -0.0010928958654403687, 0.05302495136857033, -0.0007869974942877889, -0.008367178961634636, -0.017496436834335327, 0.022613920271396637, 0.08046746253967285, -0.0009829720947891474, -0.008427225984632969, -0.015311234630644321, 0.023373566567897797, -0.048333339393138885, -0.01804354041814804, -0.050380293279886246, 0.02891373634338379, -0.010892854072153568, -0.0007553558680228889, 0.11875573545694351, 0.013688619248569012, -0.07030447572469711, -0.03241141140460968, -0.004949747119098902, 0.00926243793219328, 0.041045110672712326, 0.02542700618505478, -0.014855940826237202, -0.028789255768060684, 0.05004018545150757, -0.05387480929493904, 0.03880029544234276, -0.0038082697428762913, 0.02706514112651348, 0.049771346151828766, 0.008236352354288101, 0.0013084717793390155, 0.02852317877113819, 0.03899737447500229, -0.04248788580298424, -0.02563020959496498, 0.006959055084735155, -0.10293074697256088, -0.005128268618136644, -0.04569927603006363, -0.010979438200592995, -0.07736118137836456, 0.018586305901408195, 0.02478371560573578, 0.007410711608827114, -0.07013753056526184, 0.001417741528712213, 0.03482476621866226, 0.028855137526988983, -0.02106059156358242, -0.04093708470463753, 0.037865638732910156, 0.04345615953207016, 0.05179797485470772, 0.047444917261600494, -0.0756676122546196, 0.012762823142111301, 0.0023742103949189186, 0.028313763439655304, -0.018326088786125183, 0.015878750011324883, 0.009909741580486298, -0.033276185393333435, -0.052009694278240204, -0.003340856172144413, -0.017364520579576492, 0.020712295547127724, 0.007265329360961914, -0.05129510536789894, -0.008568994700908661, -0.0012708440190181136, 0.07359353452920914, 0.00338427210226655, -0.021121233701705933, 0.06449748575687408, -0.04400902986526489, -0.0105059202760458, -0.029591970145702362, -0.019611015915870667, -0.05412460118532181, -0.038601454347372055, 0.05035232752561569, -0.051114507019519806, -0.026313066482543945, -0.005916047375649214, -0.01893017813563347, -0.028705516830086708, 0.015518885105848312, -0.019910363480448723, -0.03916723281145096, 0.026555178686976433, -0.05750088021159172, -0.018213024362921715, 0.050178054720163345, -0.017071355134248734, 0.05682682991027832, -0.029352083802223206, 0.009121141396462917, 0.015543434768915176, 0.0001975334162125364, 0.019876260310411453, 0.025686774402856827, 0.015964657068252563, 0.0020282866898924112, -0.013984816148877144, -0.01749243400990963, 0.025126870721578598, 0.012309384532272816, -0.011299450881779194, -0.04504650831222534, 0.011203024536371231, -0.03517324477434158, 0.0021554138511419296, 0.03758033737540245, -0.007546300534158945, -0.00002784814205369912, 0.009593228809535503, -0.015404955483973026, -0.05470725893974304, 0.06385605037212372, 0.0858008861541748, 0.03406974673271179, -0.0040686777792871, 0.0461580716073513, -0.0028143234085291624, -0.048653796315193176, -0.003422277979552746, 0.02089121751487255, -0.017925260588526726, 0.004465964622795582, -0.019581886008381844, 0.021243780851364136, 0.00038129749009385705, 0.019059251993894577, -0.025875268504023552, 0.03873675689101219, -0.00468037324026227, 0.00791284441947937, -0.02440262772142887, 0.01575128547847271, 0.10423427075147629, 0.013480049557983875, -0.036794912070035934, -0.020523983985185623, 0.031206203624606133, 0.019930889829993248, 0.012646909803152084, 0.011513539589941502, -0.02707640826702118, 0.012532760389149189, 0.005384704563766718, 0.004573015961796045, -0.04379905387759209, -0.005899970419704914, 0.046222906559705734, 0.017128752544522285, -0.035477280616760254, -0.012690171599388123, 0.0006890447693876922, -0.020518535748124123, -0.0022020102478563786, 0.036350153386592865, -0.03107200190424919, -0.004178614821285009, 0.0182584747672081, 0.025152985006570816, 0.018007701262831688, -0.0023617022670805454, -0.05132419243454933, 0.07286585122346878, -0.03973287343978882, 0.026814401149749756, -0.04671066254377365, -0.01160965021699667, -0.022181056439876556, 0.027484606951475143, 0.0016061069909483194, 0.020018702372908592, -0.009695681743323803, -0.019272038713097572, -0.021553538739681244, 0.005130149889737368, 0.0026670624502003193, -0.009551551192998886, -0.05116629973053932, -0.01053997315466404, 0.01062870118767023, -0.07163748145103455, -0.039182744920253754, 0.013783833011984825, 0.0039506456814706326, 0.10469438135623932, -0.03526537865400314, 0.016802601516246796, -0.03258644416928291, -0.017945893108844757, 0.02222627028822899, 0.011062427423894405, 0.006101140286773443, -0.04354110732674599, -0.0356590673327446, -0.008633805438876152, -0.012868080288171768, 0.006314287893474102, -0.024484815075993538, -0.06635920703411102, 0.0025112901348620653, 0.010162376798689365, 0.018972961232066154, 0.014898372814059258, -0.007923698052763939, 0.027889715507626534, -0.013040164485573769, 0.0399504080414772, 0.07006826251745224, -0.061847131699323654, 0.02947843447327614, 0.018284454941749573, 0.04485917091369629, -0.008656040765345097, 0.012910484336316586, -0.008551465347409248, 0.039113689213991165, -0.0013299775309860706, 0.009221458807587624, 0.003725250717252493, -0.01994597539305687, -0.018428843468427658, -0.00008517904643667862, -0.05223790183663368, -0.010528563521802425, 0.015183785930275917, 0.00297199166379869, -0.033255837857723236, 0.014833560213446617, -0.009669404476881027, -0.0370565727353096, -0.038100291043519974, 0.04174022004008293, 0.024887895211577415, -0.06820154190063477, -0.003577509429305792, 0.014731931500136852, -0.02594856359064579, 0.038128502666950226, 0.010947136208415031, -0.00022857695876155049, -0.0290804635733366, -0.08709359169006348, 0.025280477479100227, 0.026141704991459846, -0.020984141156077385, 0.009294727817177773, 0.01406788919121027, 0.019991610199213028, 0.04816009849309921, -0.053177863359451294, -0.021378906443715096, 0.0058801425620913506, 0.006042417138814926, -0.012804074212908745, -0.0009858537232503295, -0.03562266007065773, 0.016590513288974762, 0.01733861118555069, -0.032218363136053085, 0.03956564888358116, 0.00923981610685587, -0.041384506970644, 0.006250633392482996, 0.016137052327394485, 0.03147592768073082, 0.047814711928367615, -0.007655872963368893, -0.018982993438839912, 0.005784170236438513, -0.029603958129882812, 0.020934587344527245, -0.050776414573192596, -0.0052377935498952866, 0.010728663764894009, -0.01361389085650444, -0.05020049586892128, 0.020786577835679054, 0.009522697888314724, 0.011936505325138569, -0.0558914989233017, 0.015422584488987923, 0.03449004516005516, 0.02648266591131687, 0.0029960887040942907, 0.06810183078050613, -0.028592972084879875, -0.012867790646851063, 0.010114729404449463, 0.020661083981394768, 0.08764719218015671, -0.02088979445397854, -0.03554188087582588, 0.04702240973711014, -0.013361888006329536, 0.05768802389502525, 0.023544475436210632, 0.007179800886660814, -0.014242962002754211, -0.0192424226552248, 0.01450834609568119, -0.024083886295557022, 0.008377856574952602, -0.06292971223592758, -0.006033803336322308, 0.05438977852463722, 0.04729626700282097, -0.012250655330717564, 0.0003087107324972749, 0.0663088858127594, 0.014162067323923111, 0.05894424393773079, -0.039382968097925186, -0.04801731929183006, 0.024538720026612282, 0.03467601537704468, -0.01000705361366272, -0.037998054176568985, -0.014257142320275307, 0.020978854969143867, -0.07009875029325485, 0.008410811424255371, -0.0024303707759827375, -0.03502698987722397, -0.012802203185856342, 0.046250518411397934, -0.05893580988049507, -0.03990672156214714, -0.11037543416023254, -0.02720608562231064, 0.0298989899456501, 0.0230256300419569, 0.02650194801390171, -0.01909102499485016, 0.026557372882962227, 0.026220757514238358, 0.025784345343708992, 0.07385890185832977, -0.025556765496730804, 0.007986955344676971, -0.023875946179032326, -0.03055066242814064, -0.01160235982388258, -0.053971465677022934, 0.031096944585442543, 0.0010504606179893017, 0.0405912809073925, 0.012131331488490105, -0.03889619559049606, 0.011680333875119686, 0.040681540966033936 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/2175/is-it-possible-for-information-to-be-transmitted-faster-than-light">Is it possible for information to be transmitted faster than light?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>imagine this theoretical situation:<br><br> You have make an extremely long piece of steel (or anything really) one end is placed on earth the other is all the way at Alpha Centauri, 4ly away.<br> Here on earth the end is hanging loosely, on Alpha Centauri there is a bell at the end of the rod. Now if you move our end straight in the direction of AC will the bell there ring instantly ? Or will it be slower/same as speed of light.<br><br> If I take make it small scale, for example moving a steel rod with a bell on the end, I can't imagine that there would be a delay, but of course the speed of light is the limit, so what could cause the delay ? Thanks for explanation.<br> My very sketch: <a href="http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/221/steelrod.png/" rel="nofollow">http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/221/steelrod.png/</a></p>
g4
[ 0.037191104143857956, 0.08826686441898346, -0.003316481364890933, -0.04410199075937271, 0.06980258971452713, 0.031851258128881454, -0.004167686682194471, 0.0010433713905513287, -0.05191153287887573, -0.02911943756043911, 0.028852174058556557, 0.04648001492023468, 0.019114023074507713, -0.005457466002553701, 0.04946719855070114, 0.03029656410217285, 0.1731588989496231, -0.02760729379951954, 0.028436604887247086, 0.016432128846645355, 0.04215217009186745, 0.021997321397066116, -0.009719072841107845, -0.023398317396640778, 0.032756540924310684, -0.040697284042835236, 0.00948346871882677, -0.03910626843571663, -0.022228021174669266, -0.05174470320343971, -0.058052703738212585, -0.03911811113357544, 0.033773746341466904, 0.00027683647931553423, -0.022220084443688393, -0.04609348997473717, 0.010149751789867878, -0.02595662698149681, 0.028486892580986023, 0.029579488560557365, -0.027321763336658478, -0.022190295159816742, 0.0007489609997719526, -0.022884191945195198, 0.057750679552555084, -0.006288805045187473, 0.0075749801471829414, -0.0021686989348381758, 0.009455684572458267, -0.03956105187535286, -0.013742257840931416, -0.017937837168574333, 0.02175353653728962, 0.044060271233320236, -0.00222559436224401, 0.007792133372277021, 0.010328762233257294, -0.010559352114796638, 0.095859594643116, 0.03949040547013283, 0.009807163849473, 0.017738820984959602, 0.046106405556201935, 0.006148448679596186, 0.02670973725616932, 0.008634766563773155, -0.023082921281456947, -0.020402664318680763, 0.06092887371778488, -0.015439948067069054, 0.029553493484854698, -0.011904175393283367, -0.014390521682798862, -0.07199561595916748, -0.0017376468749716878, 0.01329135149717331, 0.037407465279102325, -0.003603981574997306, 0.000665989238768816, 0.04362305998802185, -0.07217547297477722, -0.08369956165552139, -0.047921255230903625, -0.02068549022078514, -0.022295743227005005, 0.012418273836374283, -0.038205429911613464, 0.0017645948100835085, 0.002198869129642844, 0.0025868588127195835, 0.024758683517575264, -0.11410101503133774, 0.03962182626128197, 0.008604361675679684, 0.02477697655558586, -0.012574763037264347, -0.05083315446972847, 0.062220487743616104, -0.027613310143351555, 0.04106665775179863, -0.04081816226243973, -0.0365670807659626, -0.02954196184873581, 0.03378009796142578, -0.02446523681282997, -0.04070611670613289, 0.03986015170812607, -0.07519016414880753, -0.05029415711760521, -0.010352253913879395, 0.00002959035919047892, -0.09613819420337677, 0.006005139090120792, 0.01194971613585949, -0.02843211591243744, -0.037218935787677765, 0.07955068349838257, 0.0031218479853123426, -0.02834073081612587, -0.013694987632334232, 0.005615046713501215, -0.028567299246788025, 0.03877269849181175, 0.02032623253762722, -0.027588527649641037, -0.05081592872738838, 0.05545821040868759, 0.04906127601861954, 0.02390148863196373, -0.039182573556900024, -0.054516907781362534, 0.004686555825173855, -0.040166594088077545, 0.03610065579414368, 0.006998029071837664, -0.01925170235335827, 0.029123282060027122, -0.018706338480114937, -0.0075997584499418736, 0.01845220848917961, 0.0232835840433836, -0.05788033455610275, -0.00861897598952055, -0.03444845974445343, -0.060201454907655716, 0.06224417686462402, 0.004502113908529282, -0.0026623529847711325, 0.028516506776213646, -0.02859099954366684, 0.01740887202322483, 0.005688859615474939, -0.021093279123306274, -0.006277680397033691, 0.029778998345136642, 0.03373565152287483, 0.06558696925640106, 0.014403154142200947, 0.008500765077769756, -0.014596492983400822, 0.051032423973083496, -0.001641579088754952, -0.010628269985318184, -0.015770308673381805, -0.013339363038539886, 0.02319592982530594, 0.04636161029338837, -0.015296597965061665, 0.011584190651774406, -0.05768358334898949, -0.07724765688180923, 0.018058162182569504, 0.06340507417917252, 0.0626087486743927, 0.017972713336348534, 0.019571729004383087, 0.07399402558803558, -0.05257044732570648, -0.04765261709690094, -0.0125632518902421, -0.07723979651927948, -0.04881756752729416, -0.01823791116476059, -0.0411531925201416, -0.005070023704320192, 0.003959760069847107, 0.006553268060088158, -0.010575318709015846, -0.05802268907427788, -0.015050864778459072, -0.056148841977119446, -0.06022574007511139, -0.010071467608213425, 0.019834527745842934, -0.04468975588679314, -0.057540301233530045, -0.011102479882538319, 0.002133428817614913, -0.015090104192495346, 0.046746499836444855, 0.04331786185503006, 0.07583411782979965, 0.05164559558033943, -0.012854702770709991, 0.014186721295118332, -0.05201246589422226, -0.013590675778687, 0.005384813994169235, 0.018907902762293816, -0.006471538916230202, 0.08503036946058273, 0.004778791684657335, 0.00573301687836647, 0.05435991287231445, 0.01153858844190836, -0.030894489958882332, 0.0154520059004426, 0.04141537472605705, 0.02594008855521679, -0.0017929738387465477, 0.04744317755103111, -0.011589602567255497, -0.0018841327400878072, -0.02815072424709797, -0.042126938700675964, -0.03466547653079033, -0.03802063688635826, -0.027646051719784737, 0.009776165708899498, 0.010842512361705303, -0.018752675503492355, 0.07185233384370804, 0.004422855097800493, -0.008188034407794476, 0.04053693637251854, 0.057308562099933624, 0.03070884197950363, 0.011125897988677025, -0.008939344435930252, 0.011897975578904152, 0.04020952433347702, -0.02605549432337284, -0.022228825837373734, 0.0020012592431157827, -0.04587369039654732, 0.026541493833065033, 0.030389510095119476, -0.044914599508047104, -0.024126572534441948, 0.030302686616778374, 0.024231448769569397, 0.019997432827949524, -0.023677989840507507, 0.014058565720915794, -0.010253912769258022, -0.04743606224656105, -0.019099215045571327, 0.03238055482506752, -0.07620806992053986, -0.026431862264871597, -0.01776866614818573, -0.015628516674041748, 0.05696523189544678, -0.05853325501084328, -0.03333155810832977, 0.01927565038204193, 0.012210696004331112, 0.007067536003887653, 0.004760377574712038, 0.007939576171338558, -0.0603877492249012, -0.004385092295706272, 0.013377083465456963, 0.033158618956804276, -0.01601468212902546, -0.02431659959256649, 0.01916114240884781, -0.05400056764483452, -0.015717778354883194, 0.011709952726960182, 0.011231848038733006, -0.0028491481207311153, -0.027373889461159706, 0.0043456899002194405, -0.029478268697857857, -0.03955674543976784, -0.04125963896512985, 0.03569081425666809, 0.024073868989944458, 0.038037337362766266, -0.05694158747792244, 0.02186880260705948, 0.0653080865740776, 0.008422658778727055, 0.02436818927526474, 0.09885453432798386, 0.010070426389575005, -0.0038517818320542574, -0.05829210951924324, -0.01074613630771637, 0.009114352986216545, -0.02297029085457325, -0.013557063415646553, 0.056980445981025696, -0.004116349387913942, -0.010063635185360909, -0.05045809969305992, 0.005769966170191765, 0.04348720982670784, -0.0040628984570503235, 0.02418431267142296, 0.039882294833660126, -0.0034892603289335966, 0.028506770730018616, -0.029081987217068672, -0.03872544690966606, -0.009806721471250057, 0.03628512844443321, 0.023896584287285805, 0.053738705813884735, 0.028825931251049042, -0.017315560951828957, -0.017771180719137192, 0.010831558145582676, 0.037251703441143036, 0.008007392287254333, -0.01491217128932476, 0.012032200582325459, -0.04572116211056709, -0.03812998905777931, -0.017975127324461937, -0.00302209728397429, -0.0368557833135128, -0.013008113019168377, -0.04992664232850075, -0.014796461910009384, -0.004661808256059885, 0.09934666007757187, 0.0017090216279029846, 0.07040613889694214, -0.012248466722667217, -0.009767919778823853, -0.04969186708331108, 0.0631064623594284, 0.00977980438619852, 0.006818081252276897, 0.062105994671583176, -0.017101185396313667, -0.0207334216684103, -0.017541080713272095, 0.021111808717250824, 0.04280618950724602, -0.01078387163579464, -0.0322553776204586, 0.015992633998394012, 0.07216694951057434, 0.05350776016712189, 0.026506057009100914, 0.03737415373325348, -0.08323179185390472, 0.008627044968307018, 0.009422795847058296, 0.04985402151942253, 0.008255195803940296, -0.040661539882421494, 0.04642246663570404, -0.018207145854830742, -0.0211089588701725, 0.035558439791202545, 0.014540202915668488, 0.054469864815473557, -0.0006490531959570944, -0.03555101156234741, 0.00891741830855608, 0.0887073501944542, -0.04382924363017082, 0.023377636447548866, -0.025138942524790764, -0.009771976619958878, 0.06182851269841194, -0.02436010167002678, 0.052007000893354416, 0.03373882547020912, -0.05442226305603981, -0.027784151956439018, 0.01730753667652607, -0.0025157162453979254, -0.04516436904668808, -0.04663456231355667, -0.09705910831689835, 0.03993380069732666, -0.08021409064531326, 0.007776219863444567, 0.0008594450773671269, 0.02026069350540638, -0.002024640329182148, 0.020421847701072693, -0.011494631879031658, -0.007031467277556658, -0.005601287819445133, -0.02419719472527504, 0.029201768338680267, -0.010686339810490608, 0.022084439173340797, -0.039345819503068924, -0.005037228111177683, 0.01066848449409008, -0.05462077260017395, -0.04440333694219589, 0.004768079146742821, -0.002178398659452796, -0.057436827570199966, -0.029707645997405052, -0.011302840895950794, 0.04616397246718407, 0.019229698926210403, 0.0295929666608572, 0.003124491311609745, -0.014593499712646008, 0.029977118596434593, -0.013031565584242344, 0.04780445620417595, 0.03440898656845093, -0.0017816760810092092, 0.04791434109210968, 0.03228489309549332, 0.0014137389371171594, -0.03973378986120224, -0.011312863789498806, -0.020634304732084274, 0.03712408244609833, 0.04516183212399483, -0.01505121961236, 0.01862153224647045, -0.004930146038532257, 0.06424969434738159, -0.0013154924381524324, 0.04734503850340843, 0.055250924080610275, 0.043788228183984756, 0.018435999751091003, 0.008278417401015759, 0.07156150788068771, -0.0002036071236943826, -0.0330507718026638, 0.04805934056639671, -0.05044393613934517, -0.028078539296984673, 0.04017968475818634, -0.005841289646923542, -0.05467328801751137, 0.014263039454817772, -0.01645056903362274, -0.04385021701455116, 0.04627220705151558, -0.030121581628918648, -0.024110697209835052, 0.02536017820239067, 0.04241424798965454, -0.01180586963891983, -0.01661021262407303, 0.018387489020824432, 0.006444728467613459, -0.006397935561835766, 0.04334316402673721, -0.003801139770075679, -0.0016279446426779032, -0.048441119492053986, -0.06099725514650345, 0.011148123070597649, -0.003361593233421445, 0.007511639967560768, 0.015385114587843418, 0.051918499171733856, -0.03347204253077507, 0.02263217233121395, -0.016618523746728897, 0.0037642898969352245, -0.0005289511755108833, -0.0016082286601886153, -0.061710845679044724, 0.029109621420502663, -0.00004521118535194546, -0.036830153316259384, -0.008073362521827221, -0.020559607073664665, -0.08745289593935013, 0.04599866643548012, -0.018989430740475655, -0.04574145749211311, 0.0005239633028395474, -0.06761888414621353, -0.04070841521024704, -0.03113345429301262, -0.003227922832593322, -0.029098667204380035, 0.027958383783698082, 0.02993765100836754, -0.06217524781823158, -0.028758104890584946, -0.02456277422606945, 0.021141458302736282, -0.014454586431384087, -0.02418290637433529, -0.030659399926662445, 0.05829726532101631, 0.005824798718094826, 0.029711227864027023, -0.008865952491760254, 0.0431925468146801, -0.02363291196525097, 0.05173720419406891, -0.05115346983075142, -0.020759936422109604, -0.00043521792395040393, -0.04067360609769821, -0.026505427435040474, 0.01006546150892973, 0.018926849588751793, -0.005758082959800959, -0.018222613260149956, -0.010326008312404156, 0.01596939191222191, -0.015623301267623901, 0.0005614164401777089, 0.0193736981600523, -0.027985453605651855, 0.0007830687682144344, -0.02379334717988968, 0.050966594368219376, 0.03864751011133194, 0.04795057699084282, 0.07494521141052246, -0.01177140697836876, -0.012679592706263065, -0.014595619402825832, 0.06486828625202179, -0.03569396212697029, -0.010692519135773182, -0.042790066450834274, -0.0006675815093331039, -0.01482348795980215, 0.05217745155096054, 0.08432747423648834, 0.03275299072265625, -0.03587720915675163, -0.00734478235244751, -0.053200483322143555, 0.03923017904162407, -0.001331310486420989, 0.009965615347027779, 0.0442558191716671, -0.002630511997267604, 0.07893272489309311, 0.0015830834163352847, 0.03348970785737038, 0.0008155395626090467, -0.025474367663264275, 0.01073482260107994, -0.03095734305679798, 0.0625322088599205, 0.01740800403058529, 0.03592243418097496, 0.032938338816165924, -0.017312519252300262, -0.05609167367219925, -0.0004956203047186136, -0.02451454848051071, 0.07167477905750275, 0.09600822627544403, 0.015425152145326138, -0.011011973954737186, -0.021572008728981018, -0.0016088703414425254, 0.011313124559819698, -0.023739300668239594, 0.00216533406637609, -0.01687527820467949, -0.05271865054965019, -0.006005198694765568, -0.05991993844509125, 0.018412621691823006, 0.004297345876693726, 0.016494471579790115, 0.03364984318614006, 0.02376069501042366, -0.009978051297366619, -0.0168839730322361, 0.04099844768643379, -0.0844501256942749, -0.029360933229327202, -0.04603086784482002, -0.06066044047474861, -0.013846791349351406, -0.070204958319664, -0.009224841371178627, -0.01944858580827713, 0.010369264520704746, -0.0008968939073383808, 0.08275792002677917, -0.023170771077275276, -0.059913091361522675, 0.06047935411334038, -0.0035616380628198385, 0.0068518188782036304, 0.031969163566827774, 0.007455528248101473, 0.009408893994987011, 0.06009632349014282, -0.011780728586018085, 0.011350275948643684, -0.003128719748929143, 0.014960032887756824, -0.02440774068236351, -0.030138295143842697, -0.03687026724219322, -0.016296232119202614, -0.07466620206832886, -0.006151400972157717, 0.03441040590405464, 0.02682046964764595, -0.016888318583369255, -0.028839334845542908, 0.0016507527325302362, -0.010631578043103218, 0.018292909488081932, -0.02872944436967373, -0.012370352633297443, -0.03618438169360161, 0.05057486146688461, 0.02656334824860096, 0.027546469122171402, -0.0016473435098305345, 0.03885691985487938, 0.026676399633288383, 0.06379600614309311, 0.021290380507707596, 0.03180992603302002, 0.056244686245918274, 0.048853833228349686, 0.047978464514017105, 0.015949709340929985, 0.004748671781271696, 0.05753142386674881, 0.011790045537054539, 0.003240953665226698, 0.05445818603038788, 0.002677293261513114, -0.038914114236831665, -0.019814658910036087, 0.007500763982534409, -0.0020835844334214926, -0.04198840633034706, 0.011659393087029457, -0.0018925446784123778, -0.050643544644117355, -0.02469746023416519, -0.015322163701057434, 0.007228918373584747, -0.03454435616731644, -0.048027656972408295, -0.0014198976568877697, -0.02055811695754528, -0.007429213263094425, 0.017833439633250237, 0.024916259571909904, -0.015676459297537804, -0.07464532554149628, -0.05486321821808815, 0.003441555192694068, 0.036415062844753265, -0.04212477058172226, 0.01069049071520567, -0.004940223880112171, 0.058232638984918594, 0.06824775040149689, -0.035079196095466614, -0.0684126690030098, -0.048827193677425385, 0.041434627026319504, 0.0028919242322444916, -0.022340865805745125, 0.014776468276977539, 0.007997488602995872, -0.011936160735785961, 0.042890097945928574, -0.036266423761844635, -0.0053638070821762085, 0.015430266037583351, -0.08844388276338577, 0.020044691860675812, 0.04159027338027954, -0.02889310196042061, 0.023920128121972084, -0.0133586460724473, 0.02191288396716118, -0.03824096545577049, 0.0353134460747242, 0.005895004607737064, 0.020145326852798462, -0.03200396150350571, -0.005715809762477875, -0.017745865508913994, 0.01684626005589962, 0.06730788946151733, 0.003721417160704732, -0.026648368686437607, 0.02458261139690876, -0.04626103863120079, -0.03218173235654831, 0.07568353414535522, 0.07225427031517029, -0.05669935420155525, -0.0029335319995880127, -0.01586518995463848, 0.022313201799988747, 0.03427020087838173, -0.0015969756059348583, 0.03555482625961304, 0.02709757536649704, -0.01467828918248415, 0.009108890779316425, -0.08327876776456833, -0.05466199293732643, -0.011672892607748508, 0.028779592365026474, 0.050077442079782486, -0.022204307839274406, -0.0393512062728405, -0.03859684616327286, 0.0437806211411953, 0.015839047729969025, -0.0283341184258461, -0.0015181171474978328, -0.04553534835577011, 0.018332986161112785, -0.036175958812236786, 0.005884858313947916, -0.027217114344239235, -0.025272486731410027, -0.009696262888610363, -0.025460191071033478, -0.02042149193584919, 0.01775621995329857, 0.022003699094057083, -0.014034581370651722, -0.05129723623394966, 0.028700165450572968, 0.006169423460960388, -0.027579117566347122, -0.059937119483947754, 0.06727337092161179, -0.015769341960549355, -0.025881750509142876, 0.02972142957150936, 0.012033086270093918, -0.011297594755887985, -0.014183104038238525, -0.018432410433888435, -0.011896111071109772, -0.025885682553052902, -0.025564992800354958, 0.0033504164312034845, -0.0341118723154068, -0.007080157287418842, -0.031436994671821594, -0.010795975103974342, -0.005514244083315134 ]
<p>I was reading the question <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/80159/why-has-earths-core-not-become-solid">Why has Earth&#39;s core not become solid?</a>, and one of the answers says that </p> <blockquote> <p>The core is heated by radioactive decays of Uranium-238, Uranium-235, Thorium-232, and Potassium-40</p> </blockquote> <p>Why are we not affected by the radioactive emission of the condition below? Is this due to the fact that there is a very thick layer of mantle and crust between us and the core? Or I am wrong and we suffer from it's radiation in everyday life up to some extent?</p>
g5913
[ 0.05402842536568642, 0.020123191177845, 0.022380312904715538, 0.01265223789960146, 0.009487705305218697, 0.047060493379831314, 0.02517426200211048, 0.06597847491502762, 0.0319652333855629, -0.05966389924287796, -0.0035763434134423733, 0.021729158237576485, 0.008935402147471905, 0.02172837406396866, 0.004012070596218109, 0.021138017997145653, 0.052675191313028336, -0.024300415068864822, 0.04579491540789604, 0.037411075085401535, -0.05357109755277634, -0.035130005329847336, 0.03630692884325981, -0.028646444901823997, -0.05259396880865097, -0.012433917261660099, 0.02050621621310711, -0.021759064868092537, 0.05557795241475105, 0.013217577710747719, 0.046733103692531586, 0.00731175160035491, 0.024707825854420662, -0.029039744287729263, 0.027952425181865692, -0.06041179597377777, 0.04540519416332245, 0.014755773358047009, 0.010181725956499577, -0.044898103922605515, 0.01887352205812931, 0.01960880495607853, 0.021525612100958824, 0.021186331287026405, -0.05484174191951752, -0.0058089327067136765, -0.05618225783109665, 0.016610827296972275, 0.037184301763772964, 0.016839541494846344, -0.025146210566163063, -0.04088404402136803, 0.023543350398540497, 0.00793349277228117, -0.004097213968634605, -0.051973454654216766, -0.02101309783756733, 0.03336278349161148, -0.01118337269872427, -0.02920941263437271, 0.00739793898537755, 0.0013302348088473082, 0.048034876585006714, -0.012669713236391544, 0.029869036749005318, -0.028438366949558258, -0.06384125351905823, 0.04911041259765625, 0.013597263023257256, 0.03755609318614006, -0.019071636721491814, -0.025698555633425713, -0.08200116455554962, 0.04332936927676201, 0.03198103979229927, -0.016000734642148018, 0.03517215698957443, 0.011372081935405731, 0.042019303888082504, 0.04532066732645035, -0.02405179850757122, -0.015750112012028694, 0.03125328570604324, 0.029878871515393257, 0.012954231351613998, 0.0030383351258933544, -0.05864887684583664, 0.010265249758958817, -0.001114968559704721, 0.00884898193180561, 0.018916716799139977, -0.0021237607579678297, 0.02619692124426365, -0.016862938180565834, 0.02225758321583271, -0.03622256964445114, -0.019985821098089218, 0.06810329109430313, -0.04392482340335846, 0.03808073326945305, 0.024228410795331, -0.05401516705751419, 0.02100452408194542, 0.0020971240010112524, 0.026941319927573204, -0.038375064730644226, -0.0432022288441658, 0.005941653624176979, -0.01154693216085434, 0.011253769509494305, 0.02509194053709507, -0.01358634140342474, -0.009725058451294899, -0.0014754445292055607, 0.014972155913710594, -0.0038462418597191572, 0.07564098387956619, -0.018170736730098724, 0.034472595900297165, 0.03665193170309067, 0.021861251443624496, 0.05961674451828003, -0.03542276471853256, 0.036349862813949585, -0.036819733679294586, -0.0031154360622167587, 0.0367228239774704, -0.01192312128841877, 0.038460563868284225, 0.01547945011407137, -0.043814513832330704, 0.02984442748129368, -0.06959700584411621, 0.003117911284789443, 0.03818803280591965, 0.06334024667739868, -0.02292991615831852, 0.030971907079219818, 0.014863084070384502, -0.029633229598402977, 0.031751569360494614, 0.09300728142261505, 0.04942687600851059, 0.0166202113032341, -0.021277258172631264, 0.05095469951629639, -0.05177284777164459, -0.0028391287196427584, 0.05892745032906532, 0.07385203242301941, 0.006932752672582865, 0.0033605017233639956, 0.03461245447397232, -0.035099003463983536, -0.011384774930775166, 0.007910522632300854, 0.029606657102704048, -0.015762832015752792, -0.005156875122338533, 0.014891321770846844, 0.004175558220595121, -0.014755351468920708, -0.04739191755652428, 0.023457719013094902, 0.0041075474582612514, -0.0016897155437618494, -0.030437588691711426, -0.02576398104429245, -0.032932840287685394, 0.016010187566280365, -0.030546627938747406, 0.03513349965214729, 0.008339401334524155, 0.07182765752077103, -0.01790626160800457, 0.0006878880667500198, 0.0526936799287796, -0.0072059729136526585, -0.013576161116361618, -0.025958219543099403, -0.03562891483306885, 0.012363618239760399, -0.01967489905655384, -0.049642737954854965, 0.02024972252547741, 0.04686461016535759, 0.007331127766519785, -0.010301850736141205, -0.007882097736001015, 0.02416064590215683, -0.06375712156295776, -0.07999423891305923, 0.01363152265548706, 0.010706473141908646, 0.027554959058761597, -0.026470422744750977, -0.03374665230512619, -0.021640432998538017, -0.005650764796882868, 0.027137786149978638, 0.008731916546821594, 0.014337084256112576, -0.010195126757025719, 0.03762601688504219, 0.040220439434051514, -0.00685307988896966, -0.0018403631402179599, -0.02261192351579666, 0.02236172743141651, -0.04655503109097481, 0.042444951832294464, -0.05563907325267792, -0.051844436675310135, -0.03488602861762047, -0.004723518621176481, 0.04029751196503639, -0.03505948185920715, 0.01929459720849991, 0.009160978719592094, -0.01865837536752224, -0.04459838569164276, -0.0008420910453423858, -0.01935657486319542, 0.030603615567088127, -0.042675312608480453, -0.028688492253422737, -0.010279570706188679, -0.004478155635297298, 0.033560555428266525, 0.015159886330366135, -0.07160034775733948, -0.014332051388919353, 0.0020738833118230104, -0.02538459002971649, 0.009487701579928398, 0.01766389049589634, -0.023321127519011497, -0.04510610178112984, -0.03608759492635727, 0.02756315842270851, -0.036222513765096664, -0.020840194076299667, -0.04679426923394203, 0.013768906705081463, 0.02395210601389408, -0.08897228538990021, -0.0009086965001188219, -0.037411462515592575, 0.024940701201558113, 0.03564035892486572, 0.040280696004629135, -0.03605519235134125, -0.08307872712612152, -0.011182793416082859, 0.029089123010635376, -0.04825352132320404, -0.007308348082005978, 0.07837772369384766, -0.025098850950598717, -0.10383590310811996, -0.03263586387038231, -0.04883367568254471, -0.014611109159886837, 0.03366489335894585, -0.08437058329582214, 0.05483885481953621, 0.0004027336253784597, 0.05539218708872795, -0.01894761435687542, 0.0065408083610236645, -0.02738223783671856, 0.038711950182914734, -0.05502648279070854, 0.06194210425019264, -0.02331308089196682, 0.01771862432360649, -0.003835635958239436, -0.011287666857242584, 0.013817239552736282, -0.018652765080332756, 0.05579876899719238, 0.04752674326300621, -0.010518008843064308, 0.025584351271390915, 0.044401682913303375, -0.028498675674200058, -0.08703538775444031, 0.010513490065932274, 0.02431074157357216, -0.01607557199895382, 0.011234009638428688, -0.002581283450126648, 0.04797227308154106, 0.003364336444064975, 0.01703523099422455, 0.0006952649564482272, 0.03043956123292446, -0.028781708329916, -0.0576399601995945, 0.008869990706443787, 0.04334520548582077, 0.008145767264068127, 0.0014951636549085379, -0.0009177864994853735, -0.07614610344171524, -0.00548647390678525, -0.026386279612779617, -0.06052939221262932, -0.015946149826049805, -0.03871964290738106, 0.016819864511489868, 0.041378170251846313, -0.055403318256139755, 0.05218641832470894, 0.02090027555823326, -0.026104675605893135, -0.0762394368648529, 0.03722107782959938, 0.10961572080850601, -0.02589011937379837, -0.06739059090614319, 0.01613434962928295, -0.017172619700431824, 0.013411585241556168, 0.006707141641527414, 0.0124905314296484, -0.053897880017757416, -0.028423503041267395, -0.047378573566675186, -0.056496426463127136, -0.009656690061092377, -0.009403761476278305, -0.04518573358654976, 0.023975908756256104, -0.10161428153514862, 0.002887382637709379, 0.010732431896030903, 0.02017035335302353, 0.032928694039583206, 0.027381330728530884, -0.014528101310133934, -0.0052163624204695225, -0.045933593064546585, -0.00365573912858963, 0.0028154689352959394, 0.05209650099277496, -0.020205004140734673, -0.05320091173052788, -0.045788101851940155, 0.023330310359597206, 0.06095675379037857, 0.043983396142721176, 0.003455176018178463, -0.024650422856211662, -0.08119873702526093, -0.002856086241081357, 0.004686110652983189, 0.039325498044490814, 0.016682874411344528, -0.027020828798413277, 0.008594529703259468, 0.024859599769115448, 0.05733055621385574, -0.01596022956073284, 0.012829175218939781, 0.052577223628759384, 0.019154243171215057, -0.015136338770389557, -0.003073111642152071, -0.00022159113723319024, 0.01227854285389185, -0.0181385837495327, -0.030383765697479248, 0.0060592880472540855, 0.07241306453943253, 0.02207975648343563, 0.008596068248152733, 0.03493352234363556, -0.04454968497157097, 0.01940307393670082, 0.01759757101535797, -0.036741968244314194, 0.04635947197675705, -0.030522238463163376, -0.011482447385787964, 0.06617186963558197, -0.009466279298067093, -0.020224539563059807, -0.018337175250053406, -0.04153928905725479, 0.054883647710084915, -0.07031513750553131, 0.02877124957740307, -0.010919303633272648, 0.003536256728693843, -0.08300482481718063, 0.021778129041194916, -0.01281216461211443, 0.06041692942380905, 0.044736478477716446, -0.02052140049636364, -0.01651635766029358, -0.022954309359192848, -0.06554972380399704, 0.04593553766608238, 0.029416922479867935, 0.02681555040180683, -0.021421628072857857, -0.01441961620002985, -0.06750931590795517, 0.02268672175705433, 0.0018073661485686898, -0.05929989367723465, -0.013991673476994038, 0.04903986304998398, -0.07967326790094376, -0.022895045578479767, 0.023799529299139977, 0.005147844552993774, -0.04963585361838341, -0.02928919903934002, 0.029972365126013756, -0.0562269389629364, 0.047879450023174286, 0.04012162983417511, 0.045118000358343124, 0.0047082495875656605, -0.05409487709403038, 0.009741293266415596, 0.04416213929653168, -0.026037979871034622, 0.009622089564800262, -0.020672451704740524, 0.0009049747022800148, -0.03548504784703255, -0.0275541041046381, -0.08478491008281708, 0.021682720631361008, -0.06687354296445847, 0.01082268264144659, 0.030890237540006638, -0.031085286289453506, 0.024745525792241096, 0.034060850739479065, -0.016939802095294, 0.0328485481441021, -0.013420597650110722, 0.0085268160328269, -0.015147408470511436, -0.022733116522431374, -0.02181568741798401, -0.041040875017642975, -0.00004712475129053928, 0.0013910593697801232, -0.009468663483858109, -0.05412375181913376, 0.022916032001376152, 0.013465884141623974, -0.0007950319559313357, 0.09549815207719803, -0.06797335296869278, 0.010322481393814087, 0.004843190778046846, 0.02874811924993992, -0.049150094389915466, 0.005025042220950127, -0.043661847710609436, 0.0023494348861277103, -0.010770107619464397, 0.044920824468135834, 0.010759484022855759, -0.01873456872999668, 0.009027278982102871, 0.05033784732222557, -0.02137322723865509, 0.04077070578932762, -0.019315579906105995, -0.020365700125694275, 0.06798410415649414, -0.08130951970815659, 0.003199829487130046, 0.05065583437681198, -0.032360587269067764, 0.00639726547524333, 0.012094089761376381, 0.0926874577999115, -0.0752459168434143, 0.02893347106873989, -0.005636441987007856, 0.013134827837347984, 0.03803776204586029, -0.017308009788393974, 0.06470616906881332, -0.015833862125873566, -0.024874994531273842, -0.011790230870246887, 0.019968705251812935, 0.009398098103702068, -0.03762960806488991, 0.007107991725206375, -0.001609254744835198, -0.009656863287091255, -0.07282327860593796, 0.0747712031006813, 0.04710933193564415, 0.019113119691610336, 0.08067860454320908, 0.007987644523382187, 0.0501728393137455, -0.004347982816398144, -0.014869379810988903, -0.014348957687616348, 0.013979564420878887, -0.021849311888217926, 0.0012685692636296153, 0.027770260348916054, -0.045699819922447205, -0.0218077190220356, 0.0612809881567955, -0.0015282570384442806, -0.07187341898679733, 0.0030079404823482037, 0.05371977016329765, -0.009910201653838158, 0.03676364943385124, -0.03319501504302025, 0.0021484973840415478, 0.06120699644088745, 0.027985544875264168, 0.032948821783065796, 0.03902031108736992, 0.0454300157725811, 0.02103293128311634, -0.01594720035791397, -0.015585882589221, 0.021372081711888313, -0.02984081394970417, -0.0032910096924751997, 0.047566354274749756, 0.01982995495200157, 0.012247413396835327, -0.032223302870988846, -0.001235524076037109, -0.012038055807352066, 0.024575037881731987, 0.017535269260406494, -0.025833144783973694, 0.01894562691450119, 0.06390178948640823, 0.0038259862922132015, 0.0010042316280305386, 0.013258319348096848, 0.030381986871361732, -0.022180957719683647, 0.031204193830490112, -0.004472878761589527, 0.06308375298976898, 0.049344051629304886, 0.02399533987045288, -0.051847293972969055, -0.011368608102202415, 0.03557200729846954, 0.003923060372471809, 0.030450334772467613, 0.08160190284252167, -0.05089021101593971, -0.027332596480846405, -0.06821038573980331, 0.037855587899684906, 0.0010579773224890232, 0.013036830350756645, -0.012995542958378792, 0.0451543815433979, -0.013918859884142876, -0.010967816226184368, 0.04708978161215782, -0.06305531412363052, 0.019175227731466293, 0.03062085434794426, -0.014387581497430801, 0.04131326451897621, -0.08338025212287903, -0.002593274926766753, -0.048113636672496796, 0.05097733065485954, -0.018845632672309875, -0.03236394748091698, 0.0172011386603117, 0.03125351667404175, 0.017990797758102417, -0.00309991673566401, 0.03291262313723564, 0.0015748675214126706, 0.010242781601846218, -0.026695597916841507, -0.05236353725194931, -0.03875008970499039, -0.020204903557896614, -0.025987494736909866, -0.05440483242273331, -0.04098505899310112, 0.03735494613647461, 0.008176260627806187, -0.03950825706124306, 0.03518930822610855, -0.04607268422842026, 0.03771260008215904, 0.019265253096818924, 0.051690515130758286, 0.041223980486392975, -0.016745828092098236, 0.015467135235667229, 0.004291899967938662, -0.01673327386379242, 0.004859092179685831, -0.11125210672616959, 0.00950798112899065, 0.0564027838408947, -0.02773490734398365, -0.04543743655085564, 0.0007372382679022849, 0.005019931122660637, 0.01602163165807724, -0.03275703266263008, -0.003341183066368103, 0.03602646663784981, -0.07568437606096268, 0.05574146285653114, 0.06486683338880539, -0.009052402339875698, -0.04081103205680847, 0.004786116536706686, 0.017188770696520805, 0.0027889760676771402, -0.0016163354739546776, 0.05601204186677933, -0.01863924041390419, -0.054602641612291336, -0.02164737693965435, -0.001195153803564608, 0.023075547069311142, -0.05756760388612747, 0.017071915790438652, -0.03144284337759018, -0.09698262810707092, 0.017996473237872124, 0.006296331062912941, 0.02340063266456127, -0.060713931918144226, 0.024851009249687195, 0.03063886985182762, 0.018315330147743225, -0.01528361439704895, -0.010597048327326775, 0.061853550374507904, -0.03493303060531616, -0.02360396645963192, -0.03856663033366203, -0.021320974454283714, -0.04688278213143349, 0.012751098722219467, -0.029135579243302345, -0.03503172844648361, -0.009787069633603096, 0.02146463468670845, -0.003614491317421198, 0.07498390972614288, -0.012028033845126629, -0.015410864725708961, 0.023844873532652855, 0.0034275564830750227, -0.007442389149218798, -0.01894119195640087, 0.009140084497630596, 0.009051636792719364, 0.024730412289500237, -0.022374380379915237, -0.019006215035915375, 0.08886779844760895, -0.01522346492856741, 0.03964106738567352, 0.00926975067704916, -0.01221940852701664, 0.02445220947265625, 0.013917001895606518, 0.005907554645091295, -0.03562677651643753, -0.012676815502345562, -0.05964778736233711, 0.045149363577365875, 0.023014554753899574, 0.0654304251074791, 0.000668157881591469, 0.01659351773560047, -0.02750604785978794, -0.02891317941248417, -0.00673232926055789, -0.03653309494256973, 0.041661735624074936, -0.055125970393419266, -0.042297180742025375, -0.020272431895136833, 0.0006895870319567621, -0.04244985058903694, 0.03465013951063156, 0.014226865954697132, 0.03634873777627945, 0.04931524395942688, -0.049007728695869446, -0.017283005639910698, 0.05010122433304787, -0.01739422045648098, 0.036211419850587845, -0.012956366874277592, -0.011095266789197922, -0.014911029487848282, 0.021959329023957253, -0.009018272161483765, 0.031498879194259644, -0.06563680619001389, -0.04694226384162903, -0.024092892184853554, -0.04213185980916023, -0.0234743170440197, -0.010417837649583817, 0.03260962665081024, 0.042721133679151535, -0.057814061641693115, 0.01812535524368286, 0.03238137438893318, -0.0029243137687444687, 0.07307986915111542, -0.017396485432982445, -0.027543354779481888, 0.011055857874453068, -0.041775718331336975, 0.055617235600948334, 0.015257172286510468, 0.03335918113589287, 0.01354809757322073, -0.01596866175532341, 0.04738258197903633, 0.01626703515648842, -0.004119277931749821, -0.02121726982295513, -0.009958487004041672, -0.014108247123658657, 0.07326152920722961, -0.012522350065410137, -0.008111320436000824, -0.05413231626152992, 0.009625941514968872, -0.047681547701358795, 0.010351310484111309, -0.04389578849077225, -0.02369014360010624, -0.009196084924042225, -0.007720327936112881, -0.015180403366684914, -0.012441403232514858, -0.02931433916091919, -0.003471569623798132, 0.027373019605875015, -0.0794319435954094, 0.02411918342113495, -0.024870149791240692, 0.02782283164560795, -0.030858121812343597 ]
<p>A particle has two energy states having energies $E_0$ and $E_1$ with degeneracies $g_0$ and $g_1$. The respective probabilities are $p_1$ and $p_2$. What is the entropy in terms of $p_1$, $p_2$, $g_1$ and $g_2$ ? </p>
g5914
[ -0.010588712058961391, 0.0015109350206330419, 0.00581572437658906, -0.04211502894759178, 0.04573772847652435, -0.0008317741448991001, -0.02805001102387905, 0.037435393780469894, -0.05106377229094505, -0.01547311432659626, -0.007792368531227112, -0.0029386677779257298, 0.03513993322849274, -0.04054050147533417, -0.013308153487741947, 0.04488404467701912, 0.06015408784151077, 0.028701258823275566, -0.016409356147050858, 0.040014758706092834, -0.03140001744031906, -0.052919693291187286, 0.00885877013206482, -0.058787751942873, 0.05685003101825714, -0.06726711988449097, -0.008017809130251408, -0.017644736915826797, -0.07478723675012589, 0.004806219600141048, 0.019183553755283356, 0.03471175953745842, 0.037404824048280716, -0.033553242683410645, 0.0009737263899296522, 0.0037558528129011393, 0.07293839007616043, 0.0004102043167222291, 0.026928232982754707, -0.08114291727542877, 0.017186667770147324, -0.019524091854691505, 0.0440068393945694, -0.053259722888469696, 0.003014628542587161, 0.027437906712293625, 0.003815425792708993, 0.00707870302721858, -0.017621124163269997, -0.03256956487894058, 0.041360825300216675, 0.07947476953268051, 0.0505024679005146, -0.023725725710392, 0.037681661546230316, -0.013378364033997059, 0.01201010774821043, -0.02291553094983101, 0.11141728609800339, 0.03150242939591408, 0.04732709005475044, -0.07384834438562393, -0.051792390644550323, 0.027224531397223473, 0.0029001482762396336, -0.0021431304048746824, 0.010403415188193321, 0.01501663401722908, 0.028566554188728333, 0.033913854509592056, 0.0007339624571613967, -0.030422795563936234, 0.019025549292564392, -0.033931128680706024, 0.023962439969182014, -0.0461745448410511, 0.024756494909524918, 0.037888288497924805, 0.018763532862067223, 0.040569256991147995, -0.025346485897898674, -0.017385076731443405, 0.011781292036175728, -0.039320141077041626, 0.00881444662809372, -0.030100902542471886, -0.007290922570973635, 0.03012317791581154, -0.03802572190761566, -0.0008092537755146623, -0.08197294175624847, -0.025551293045282364, 0.028774095699191093, 0.05661787465214729, 0.002265613991767168, 0.016541946679353714, -0.02641604281961918, 0.005631888285279274, -0.027160489931702614, 0.031223703175783157, 0.0017862056847661734, -0.02548966184258461, 0.04252256825566292, -0.015953047201037407, 0.015039456076920033, -0.04733295738697052, -0.025877635926008224, -0.020524777472019196, -0.024421285837888718, 0.007104762829840183, -0.02217382751405239, 0.05992063879966736, 0.02384897507727146, -0.03341773524880409, -0.02262279763817787, 0.000854040146805346, 0.10080567002296448, -0.05634379759430885, -0.016322657465934753, 0.01272341888397932, 0.04127530753612518, 0.03955661132931709, -0.03527931123971939, 0.09236221760511398, 0.005798750557005405, 0.04349337890744209, -0.03132081776857376, -0.03658255189657211, 0.02159385196864605, 0.0025172289460897446, 0.06068730726838112, -0.04060656577348709, 0.031932950019836426, 0.02048816904425621, -0.017839252948760986, 0.03956729918718338, 0.02967882715165615, 0.06439173966646194, 0.003308855928480625, -0.0007203090353868902, -0.028339512646198273, 0.00992052722722292, 0.007159854751080275, -0.03151964396238327, -0.016200494021177292, 0.014847605489194393, 0.013240484520792961, -0.0669756829738617, -0.03593193367123604, 0.020313886925578117, 0.008623866364359856, -0.005509920418262482, 0.006344602443277836, -0.02791387215256691, 0.04225197061896324, -0.009715838357806206, -0.00412565004080534, -0.006437270902097225, -0.013315446674823761, 0.041877202689647675, 0.031527578830718994, 0.012316929176449776, 0.05873033031821251, 0.01415689941495657, -0.027173146605491638, 0.006215004250407219, 0.03843532130122185, -0.05876348167657852, -0.026863912120461464, -0.04815662279725075, 0.025187507271766663, -0.05188111215829849, -0.012392217293381691, 0.049908723682165146, -0.0006220878567546606, 0.01574232243001461, -0.020400043576955795, -0.02787305973470211, 0.04141939431428909, -0.057637233287096024, -0.046896979212760925, 0.029126815497875214, 0.033391084522008896, 0.029573649168014526, -0.002828261349350214, 0.0027060878928750753, 0.009132351726293564, 0.033994924277067184, -0.07619121670722961, 0.027558699250221252, -0.03007121942937374, 0.02147103287279606, -0.027074526995420456, -0.010754700750112534, 0.038321349769830704, -0.015439244918525219, 0.022454340010881424, -0.06304452568292618, -0.02206234075129032, -0.025048594921827316, -0.015363437123596668, -0.04500048980116844, -0.003562741447240114, -0.024730432778596878, 0.07271814346313477, 0.0056615606881678104, 0.05661531537771225, 0.007241643499583006, -0.019363615661859512, -0.017356324940919876, -0.023713093250989914, -0.05882536992430687, -0.008767526596784592, 0.0177476666867733, 0.024991028010845184, -0.05167694762349129, -0.03797994554042816, -0.019923919811844826, -0.015323690138757229, -0.04639877378940582, -0.023133976384997368, 0.06670013815164566, 0.07038511335849762, 0.018147874623537064, -0.025482360273599625, 0.08723372220993042, -0.08168162405490875, -0.0061397068202495575, -0.04687941074371338, 0.03815671429038048, -0.03871113061904907, -0.00225120154209435, -0.008981376886367798, -0.04098081588745117, -0.016705961897969246, 0.028203420341014862, -0.016762293875217438, 0.014521587640047073, 0.006899012718349695, 0.0017739683389663696, -0.01669047400355339, -0.023172622546553612, 0.014193212613463402, 0.015679923817515373, 0.028023505583405495, -0.02853260189294815, 0.036768101155757904, 0.030922934412956238, 0.029128335416316986, 0.06834078580141068, -0.011691797524690628, -0.012797296047210693, -0.06708801537752151, 0.04213742911815643, 0.012149267829954624, -0.021509604528546333, -0.03572675585746765, -0.0044316998682916164, -0.047603946179151535, -0.026338158175349236, 0.01915908046066761, -0.03152085468173027, -0.007310202345252037, 0.008493057452142239, -0.01571797765791416, -0.0023572419304400682, 0.03832342475652695, -0.018942268565297127, 0.01430385559797287, -0.007588905282318592, 0.019434861838817596, 0.09077294170856476, -0.015849469229578972, 0.03970148041844368, 0.01271638460457325, -0.05570438131690025, 0.020948516204953194, -0.028602981939911842, -0.00712388614192605, -0.03107587806880474, -0.031808920204639435, 0.013208708725869656, 0.008225128054618835, 0.0595867820084095, 0.06335314363241196, -0.12568335235118866, 0.00015638480545021594, 0.06482227891683578, 0.01945318467915058, 0.026546616107225418, -0.009591983631253242, 0.023670339956879616, 0.05307743325829506, -0.036741651594638824, -0.01641135662794113, 0.025994498282670975, -0.015827056020498276, -0.017623931169509888, 0.0273478664457798, 0.03690270334482193, -0.04333684593439102, -0.013640834018588066, -0.0064277672208845615, -0.00913817435503006, 0.02157512865960598, -0.003188434988260269, -0.03450087085366249, -0.04410235583782196, 0.03925430402159691, 0.014722313731908798, -0.07519108802080154, 0.06058749556541443, 0.02929343283176422, 0.021420417353510857, 0.0019409825326874852, 0.038398273289203644, -0.007635879795998335, -0.04493772238492966, -0.05523698404431343, -0.03706652671098709, 0.034825026988983154, -0.026322433724999428, 0.04314699396491051, -0.00011849588190671057, -0.0134193804115057, -0.0029537067748606205, -0.03710763528943062, 0.013280745595693588, -0.04676995053887367, -0.010028737597167492, 0.009976440109312534, -0.06306745111942291, -0.01681111566722393, -0.03807432949542999, 0.029142381623387337, -0.003950525540858507, -0.027890881523489952, -0.039707742631435394, 0.03208453208208084, 0.03148442506790161, -0.02818562462925911, 0.04976845532655716, -0.0017421486554667354, 0.01934737339615822, 0.0018260213546454906, -0.03021395392715931, -0.015451665967702866, 0.009164693765342236, 0.015601810067892075, 0.009115338325500488, -0.019574621692299843, 0.017349738627672195, 0.07554543763399124, 0.030064275488257408, -0.023364463821053505, -0.04396688565611839, -0.04223855957388878, -0.05287307873368263, 0.010442950762808323, 0.014983054250478745, -0.011323216371238232, -0.004815385676920414, 0.037612900137901306, -0.004970057867467403, -0.00046540555194951594, -0.037418168038129807, -0.02738230675458908, -0.04408140107989311, 0.03463282436132431, 0.0189310722053051, -0.0032374155707657337, 0.0012641997309401631, -0.010748599655926228, 0.0009509265073575079, 0.02991521917283535, -0.05412778630852699, 0.05895194038748741, -0.018275665119290352, -0.05440051853656769, -0.02604256011545658, 0.019989460706710815, -0.030230190604925156, 0.031983308494091034, 0.021180860698223114, 0.03640715777873993, -0.00029104441637173295, 0.010312879458069801, 0.014712485484778881, 0.0180880818516016, -0.0449187345802784, 0.0045390925370156765, 0.019041476771235466, -0.04273032769560814, 0.030146583914756775, 0.04299714416265488, 0.029172925278544426, 0.057863421738147736, -0.022329948842525482, 0.00792443472892046, 0.04235891252756119, -0.0021621554624289274, 0.02958948165178299, -0.025249779224395752, -0.027637621387839317, 0.012828594073653221, -0.015722353011369705, 0.0009169290424324572, -0.02351602539420128, -0.03976576030254364, -0.017062582075595856, 0.03730576112866402, 0.04237345978617668, 0.035790883004665375, -0.0037357390392571688, -0.05961540341377258, -0.007252169772982597, -0.024163486436009407, -0.019412871450185776, 0.019438570365309715, 0.023403583094477654, 0.027157053351402283, -0.0007239107508212328, 0.011354033835232258, -0.018885238096117973, -0.08898855745792389, 0.04029730707406998, 0.05302083492279053, 0.03228041157126427, -0.046749431639909744, -0.016389116644859314, 0.022355247288942337, 0.008604804053902626, -0.012169775553047657, 0.013900660909712315, -0.03657529875636101, 0.041470807045698166, -0.036308810114860535, -0.01980910450220108, 0.00979557167738676, 0.0005811745650134981, 0.077482670545578, -0.00770192127674818, -0.028132282197475433, -0.00042924564331769943, 0.044241420924663544, 0.028215037658810616, -0.0007417491287924349, -0.0546286404132843, 0.02689342387020588, -0.051002137362957, 0.026912052184343338, -0.010648648254573345, -0.011924360878765583, -0.06538139283657074, -0.005015132948756218, -0.007033484522253275, -0.027713997289538383, 0.04926060885190964, -0.016097599640488625, -0.00017934475908987224, -0.010161724872887135, 0.04220534861087799, 0.035949449986219406, 0.0006280012312345207, -0.013685796409845352, -0.004940393380820751, -0.11193489283323288, 0.059938665479421616, 0.02086297608911991, -0.019851351156830788, 0.00805849488824606, -0.033547673374414444, -0.015312833711504936, -0.015724705532193184, -0.00022920724586583674, 0.011780393309891224, -0.018436625599861145, -0.03236561268568039, 0.03209139034152031, 0.029103701934218407, -0.020786218345165253, -0.014928929507732391, -0.02657521516084671, 0.005370499566197395, -0.004139161668717861, 0.002126777544617653, 0.030711449682712555, 0.019009770825505257, 0.03480559587478638, 0.0029380167834460735, -0.03739035502076149, 0.048977501690387726, 0.03996161371469498, 0.04517914354801178, 0.020642459392547607, -0.018889594823122025, 0.005344478879123926, -0.003731317352503538, 0.0016669923206791282, 0.04373908042907715, -0.08147730678319931, 0.01887456700205803, -0.005380319431424141, 0.017933281138539314, 0.007315139751881361, 0.029702316969633102, 0.06686445325613022, -0.026897501200437546, -0.007104286924004555, -0.016978569328784943, 0.00012655970931518823, -0.004755827132612467, 0.0253763347864151, 0.027440723031759262, 0.030592026188969612, 0.01824238710105419, -0.002485357690602541, -0.01717100664973259, -0.003749975236132741, -0.011992444284260273, 0.10850559920072556, 0.009595093317329884, 0.0383053719997406, -0.023665837943553925, -0.008295276202261448, 0.03263077139854431, -0.09986727684736252, -0.03282030299305916, 0.05608087778091431, 0.07204167544841766, 0.0069915917702019215, -0.012146501801908016, -0.003432647790759802, -0.0029724338091909885, 0.021769460290670395, -0.055792178958654404, -0.08106353133916855, 0.006407313514500856, 0.019446205347776413, 0.031761083751916885, -0.009860710240900517, -0.04175525903701782, -0.019716812297701836, 0.015361810103058815, -0.0526602528989315, 0.0309344120323658, -0.0384625643491745, -0.008269870653748512, -0.04612020403146744, -0.011121280491352081, -0.017881030216813087, -0.04336879774928093, 0.02079852670431137, -0.05401816964149475, -0.0010664646979421377, 0.0243536289781332, 0.09130656719207764, 0.030110692605376244, 0.025977784767746925, 0.010314710438251495, -0.03312305361032486, 0.016685418784618378, 0.04212275147438049, 0.016087554395198822, 0.06848189234733582, -0.05886578932404518, -0.02347126416862011, -0.06510370969772339, -0.025200773030519485, 0.06330917030572891, 0.02052360773086548, 0.008185972459614277, 0.04213111102581024, -0.04822055622935295, 0.06305228918790817, -0.02332448959350586, -0.024813279509544373, -0.08606167137622833, -0.024500995874404907, -0.04008852690458298, -0.022976331412792206, 0.034555237740278244, -0.0145086869597435, 0.013388515450060368, -0.051244478672742844, 0.07432802766561508, 0.0061232661828398705, -0.018045002594590187, 0.03665737435221672, 0.03950051963329315, 0.02240242436528206, -0.028019150719046593, -0.02821868471801281, -0.023348039016127586, -0.06954977661371231, 0.033713020384311676, -0.024520155042409897, -0.024166421964764595, -0.005669677630066872, 0.02036575973033905, -0.007699789013713598, -0.04095950350165367, 0.0263358224183321, -0.021027667447924614, 0.002356944140046835, 0.07895640283823013, -0.03874622657895088, 0.0614701583981514, -0.054038435220718384, 0.05068621411919594, -0.013086078688502312, -0.06055805832147598, 0.030113188549876213, -0.058979082852602005, -0.03376918286085129, 0.0026226071640849113, -0.046440523117780685, 0.03212970867753029, 0.015078160911798477, 0.034293435513973236, 0.033828575164079666, 0.005433879792690277, 0.011122247204184532, -0.07455340027809143, 0.07915900647640228, 0.04186386615037918, -0.03522154316306114, 0.014209079556167126, 0.026825308799743652, 0.0018448993796482682, 0.006642080843448639, -0.018944542855024338, 0.025551969185471535, 0.05685536190867424, -0.02241285890340805, -0.02079205960035324, -0.04424719139933586, 0.05195307359099388, 0.04042859375476837, 0.05037454515695572, -0.00018406930030323565, 0.026582175865769386, 0.029824011027812958, -0.005340627860277891, 0.00012918586435262114, 0.023765336722135544, 0.011685984209179878, -0.015135560184717178, -0.036139972507953644, -0.03377106413245201, -0.04076441749930382, -0.07429426163434982, 0.0006596324383281171, -0.01080281287431717, -0.01721246726810932, 0.07257857173681259, 0.034016530960798264, -0.010401968844234943, 0.052282363176345825, -0.03222940117120743, 0.008823924697935581, 0.01197956595569849, 0.004684504121541977, 0.03502171114087105, -0.021286705508828163, 0.0061050644144415855, 0.0629720613360405, -0.04577798396348953, -0.031887974590063095, -0.07122214138507843, -0.015269692055881023, -0.04524875059723854, -0.09302933514118195, -0.01821255497634411, -0.0814669206738472, 0.00048112886724993587, 0.005215293262153864, 0.03267393633723259, 0.01567976549267769, -0.05499045178294182, 0.01082112081348896, -0.004494671244174242, -0.02606532722711563, -0.018715744838118553, -0.028199028223752975, 0.03969043865799904, 0.012688858434557915, -0.028320077806711197, -0.004691845737397671, 0.025912009179592133, 0.01010103803128004, -0.01677030138671398, 0.029116235673427582, -0.036270517855882645, -0.03771199285984039, -0.02675311267375946, -0.0026231538504362106, 0.08226854354143143, 0.00837953295558691, -0.07753219455480576, 0.04802003130316734, 0.009005104191601276, -0.02144845388829708, 0.023483071476221085, -0.003758284030482173, -0.057111430913209915, 0.06520172953605652, 0.004856629762798548, -0.021619953215122223, -0.00045046163722872734, -0.007654549088329077, -0.04301866888999939, 0.023846358060836792, -0.010420551523566246, -0.04495002701878548, -0.0333070307970047, -0.05747664347290993, 0.05459044501185417, 0.01209352444857359, 0.0506911538541317, 0.031496383249759674, -0.022630495950579643, -0.05200374126434326, 0.024864332750439644, 0.04356630519032478, -0.0684104636311531, -0.00040958088357001543, 0.011180616915225983, 0.0720813125371933, 0.03225407376885414, -0.021292362362146378, 0.028370371088385582, -0.028028268367052078, 0.023315858095884323, -0.04996466264128685, 0.03989015147089958, 0.04541444033384323, -0.050447940826416016, 0.015336423180997372, 0.0447004958987236, -0.01756988652050495, -0.05343722179532051, 0.0439240001142025, 0.005671780556440353, -0.008290937170386314, -0.006493838038295507, -0.04681221768260002, 0.015968777239322662, 0.06977450102567673, -0.024803413078188896, -0.00745861092582345, -0.07375001907348633, -0.022764980792999268, 0.048127222806215286, 0.06415765732526779, -0.014196735806763172, 0.058052726089954376, 0.05998368188738823, -0.01741732843220234, -0.005346192046999931, -0.012416427955031395, -0.024909701198339462, -0.03892719745635986, -0.010666872374713421, -0.016727996990084648, -0.0026161205023527145, 0.013050215318799019, 0.09017567336559296 ]
<p>When I put ice cubes in a glass of water, I find that sometimes they will stick together and form a sort of "bridge" between them as they melt. There is usually a visible line where one ends and the other begins, and they break apart if pushed (but for the most part they stick together if they aren't interfered with). I'm wondering how they form this bridge in the first place if they're melting, and why it stays together. </p>
g5915
[ 0.0059455460868775845, -0.011408921331167221, 0.01696430705487728, -0.028974659740924835, 0.06773331016302109, -0.014208934269845486, -0.003113225568085909, 0.07962126284837723, -0.014450384303927422, -0.01928931474685669, -0.019333060830831528, 0.004197843838483095, -0.054878462105989456, 0.006649035960435867, -0.018527640029788017, 0.04236956685781479, -0.047808077186346054, -0.07367666810750961, 0.003087966237217188, 0.09077097475528717, 0.013962987810373306, -0.030146388337016106, 0.038906559348106384, -0.016322048380970955, -0.10260815173387527, -0.02189667895436287, 0.04510921239852905, -0.0005140212015248835, 0.009790915064513683, 0.0052190725691616535, 0.02105593867599964, 0.05224059522151947, 0.03847305476665497, -0.038724590092897415, 0.003032142762094736, -0.0426444374024868, 0.0002983199374284595, -0.04505288600921631, 0.002279209205880761, -0.06695729494094849, 0.05346483737230301, 0.03799872845411301, -0.042609792202711105, 0.00010897138417931274, 0.05285556986927986, 0.005674834828823805, -0.010542641393840313, -0.0057106525637209415, -0.047740787267684937, 0.035101208835840225, 0.055053889751434326, 0.06726482510566711, 0.024245964363217354, 0.03500926494598389, -0.04127656668424606, 0.01099349558353424, 0.03887215629220009, 0.04920900985598564, 0.044325090944767, 0.021514305844902992, 0.03784399852156639, -0.011151508428156376, 0.010014461353421211, -0.0019498866749927402, 0.06765072047710419, -0.011032224632799625, -0.050185684114694595, 0.05938141420483589, 0.06309910118579865, 0.06345231831073761, -0.04085978493094444, -0.014762365259230137, 0.0190089363604784, -0.018925489857792854, -0.04569818452000618, -0.047161661088466644, 0.024637620896100998, 0.00988850649446249, 0.05448161065578461, 0.007067367434501648, 0.03356919810175896, 0.007035896647721529, -0.01901145651936531, 0.0041311657987535, 0.04128826782107353, 0.04222698137164116, -0.02191946841776371, -0.0243929922580719, -0.08112037181854248, -0.005356402602046728, -0.024265579879283905, -0.02141919732093811, 0.03133412450551987, 0.004794340580701828, -0.0023797203321009874, -0.03464303910732269, 0.016958072781562805, -0.0005047865561209619, -0.024612203240394592, 0.035656996071338654, -0.010897830128669739, -0.011617866344749928, 0.05850730836391449, 0.005090055055916309, -0.015965282917022705, -0.06151825934648514, 0.045311328023672104, 0.00843076128512621, -0.025041814893484116, -0.024003298953175545, -0.02221120148897171, 0.008896507322788239, -0.035529620945453644, 0.006522816140204668, 0.05817008391022682, 0.026181165128946304, 0.010034320876002312, 0.011868101544678211, 0.029387859627604485, -0.018832480534911156, 0.055186424404382706, -0.008179762400686741, -0.05750065669417381, 0.01747562177479267, 0.012721974402666092, 0.010283154435455799, 0.08348947018384933, -0.015173605643212795, 0.018510999158024788, 0.02793816663324833, 0.00013374090485740453, 0.04014350473880768, 0.003633711254224181, -0.012500341981649399, -0.014651111327111721, 0.07215606421232224, 0.011825007386505604, -0.02597479708492756, -0.010271480306982994, -0.055960699915885925, -0.029394546523690224, 0.00733356224372983, 0.009936798363924026, -0.0055600060150027275, -0.011233177967369556, 0.004538379143923521, 0.012357836589217186, -0.021024683490395546, -0.011770162731409073, 0.022951101884245872, -0.02712191641330719, -0.012991930358111858, 0.015786616131663322, -0.04323672875761986, 0.015857039019465446, 0.012443259358406067, -0.000039053255022736266, -0.0519358366727829, 0.07888252288103104, 0.015205654315650463, 0.04694940894842148, -0.07903227210044861, 0.019565973430871964, 0.0522850900888443, -0.07533339411020279, 0.0001317211426794529, 0.034644048660993576, -0.010138215497136116, 0.061991725116968155, 0.01868109405040741, -0.031801290810108185, -0.015332207083702087, 0.00027142875478602946, 0.14409126341342926, 0.041356161236763, 0.017474107444286346, 0.05849015340209007, -0.019740168005228043, 0.05144877731800079, -0.02197190374135971, 0.0011265432694926858, -0.009896895848214626, -0.020487552508711815, -0.031864266842603683, 0.015635138377547264, -0.02443719655275345, 0.04431077465415001, -0.00752608384937048, 0.007760181557387114, 0.05873612314462662, -0.025508148595690727, -0.05538929998874664, -0.009119382128119469, -0.0030223755165934563, 0.04095838591456413, -0.04695064574480057, 0.013285442255437374, -0.07131940871477127, -0.024503691121935844, 0.00953584723174572, 0.014601136557757854, -0.0012172325514256954, -0.0330725759267807, 0.04743677377700806, -0.04534019157290459, 0.012910004705190659, 0.01750275120139122, -0.005662648007273674, -0.0034954166039824486, 0.05051766335964203, -0.026162514463067055, 0.06789647042751312, -0.012427261099219322, -0.050294842571020126, -0.04525318741798401, 0.0072897616773843765, 0.03406565263867378, 0.015646638348698616, -0.038943346589803696, 0.04227672889828682, -0.011297631077468395, 0.003281466430053115, -0.05729009583592415, -0.03061611019074917, 0.012830968014895916, -0.06153462827205658, -0.07173007726669312, 0.0034468327648937702, 0.015717802569270134, 0.00934141967445612, -0.0570044107735157, -0.033012986183166504, 0.0028394211549311876, -0.03277450427412987, 0.007897977717220783, 0.01918698661029339, -0.03989262133836746, 0.03251534700393677, -0.00615901593118906, -0.03382690250873566, -0.017993997782468796, -0.06107661873102188, -0.0631733313202858, -0.005602132994681597, 0.016831543296575546, -0.014562426134943962, 0.05707714706659317, -0.02101542241871357, 0.0032490745652467012, 0.07347685098648071, 0.03579549863934517, 0.020233919844031334, -0.05181414261460304, -0.009069041348993778, -0.007452190853655338, -0.010675519704818726, -0.009348283521831036, 0.03379085659980774, 0.0055762468837201595, 0.01111739780753851, -0.027435967698693275, 0.007284248247742653, -0.036755263805389404, -0.028461195528507233, -0.08238416165113449, -0.017588963732123375, 0.011424017138779163, 0.007877823896706104, 0.025143567472696304, 0.017265893518924713, -0.08628011494874954, 0.02116934396326542, 0.026973020285367966, 0.0010956593323498964, -0.049406711012125015, -0.031862277537584305, -0.07967893779277802, -0.05556657537817955, 0.005863230675458908, -0.016293562948703766, 0.04476773738861084, 0.045758191496133804, -0.07528489828109741, -0.03206806257367134, 0.00765928765758872, -0.04164871200919151, -0.02265283651649952, 0.03444395959377289, -0.000010655897312972229, -0.007165517192333937, -0.0019244103459641337, -0.06188688427209854, 0.03785625100135803, -0.04462116211652756, 0.018368858844041824, -0.0032501567620784044, 0.016391571611166, 0.041477322578430176, -0.05243155360221863, -0.016256999224424362, -0.0073369573801755905, 0.000779205234721303, 0.05203412473201752, -0.00789871346205473, 0.027358461171388626, 0.05162833258509636, 0.01641341857612133, -0.040530648082494736, -0.0322796106338501, -0.024040188640356064, 0.04726319760084152, 0.01934461109340191, -0.014187690801918507, 0.018732821568846703, -0.048483651131391525, 0.007267639972269535, -0.01794440485537052, 0.06947600096464157, 0.062492646276950836, -0.04867802932858467, -0.061945654451847076, 0.005000852979719639, 0.038583431392908096, 0.008949936367571354, 0.017777837812900543, 0.006833747029304504, 0.036586228758096695, -0.030497604981064796, -0.0026016912888735533, 0.027390647679567337, -0.03158394247293472, -0.037977952510118484, -0.046110451221466064, -0.04089830815792084, -0.03545089811086655, 0.002168301260098815, -0.00609988858923316, -0.012372423894703388, -0.00711275776848197, 0.04027922824025154, 0.02103794552385807, 0.029550109058618546, -0.02846303954720497, 0.004128958098590374, 0.03137065842747688, 0.0000285417972918367, 0.0045425682328641415, 0.02223316766321659, 0.017441632226109505, -0.07183399796485901, 0.006220891140401363, 0.006266851909458637, -0.02075042761862278, -0.026961511000990868, -0.027902456000447273, -0.014606904238462448, -0.035919059067964554, 0.006886300630867481, -0.007319115102291107, -0.012887286022305489, 0.05807426944375038, 0.03369608521461487, 0.036447253078222275, 0.04692020267248154, -0.08623293787240982, -0.02002788335084915, 0.024438070133328438, 0.00986494217067957, 0.000610128918197006, 0.011327010579407215, 0.0036095287650823593, 0.02589043602347374, -0.017428873106837273, 0.022626709192991257, 0.002792230574414134, 0.0016224939608946443, 0.019322406500577927, 0.06350723654031754, 0.0581425204873085, 0.01324488129466772, 0.002863761968910694, -0.020646389573812485, 0.048232655972242355, -0.014027399942278862, 0.001850035274401307, -0.02992107719182968, 0.022493936121463776, -0.028649210929870605, -0.03316335752606392, -0.013793257996439934, 0.025611011311411858, 0.016270220279693604, 0.013500123284757137, 0.0096898740157485, 0.0120685501024127, -0.0018605680670589209, -0.07137227803468704, 0.05511089786887169, -0.03611836954951286, -0.03599013015627861, 0.005197588820010424, 0.03309091925621033, -0.05350295081734657, -0.06653133034706116, 0.05590132996439934, -0.022609034553170204, 0.016545426100492477, -0.02843409590423107, -0.001203990774229169, -0.06720032542943954, 0.011231977492570877, 0.004910990130156279, -0.003978867549449205, -0.04725430905818939, 0.019737886264920235, -0.035384587943553925, -0.020668989047408104, 0.005947642493993044, -0.00025590110453777015, -0.05883122235536575, 0.011562608182430267, -0.0095865149050951, -0.012207956984639168, 0.004896905273199081, -0.021742725744843483, 0.0462544783949852, -0.015216407366096973, -0.029015352949500084, -0.005213920492678881, 0.020043499767780304, -0.026668645441532135, 0.03470969200134277, -0.02472556196153164, -0.03263624384999275, -0.025201549753546715, 0.009023871272802353, 0.009743854403495789, 0.007774133235216141, -0.02164609730243683, 0.03174414858222008, 0.014736219309270382, 0.03758777305483818, 0.060019321739673615, 0.033698201179504395, 0.06416067481040955, -0.02044304646551609, 0.004843707196414471, 0.02801532857120037, -0.002874803263694048, -0.04396666958928108, -0.0420900397002697, 0.04599053040146828, -0.039507512003183365, -0.04760178551077843, 0.007280044723302126, -0.04257789999246597, 0.023585671558976173, 0.05961047485470772, -0.02294919453561306, 0.027737807482481003, 0.020531978458166122, -0.04156634956598282, 0.038615960627794266, -0.0007580564124509692, -0.011837971396744251, -0.020458081737160683, 0.024012932553887367, -0.061958104372024536, -0.01708488166332245, 0.018727079033851624, -0.00044344092020764947, 0.10818711668252945, -0.05589098483324051, 0.0879569798707962, 0.020024921745061874, -0.02392006479203701, -0.05493694916367531, 0.042616985738277435, 0.06555003672838211, -0.04451238736510277, 0.027518896386027336, 0.048864543437957764, -0.014164597727358341, -0.0634315088391304, 0.022928830236196518, 0.02447686158120632, -0.05528829246759415, 0.015204844996333122, 0.0158100426197052, -0.008957399986684322, 0.037804149091243744, -0.0376095287501812, 0.02584369294345379, 0.0176432803273201, -0.034207455813884735, -0.07781662046909332, 0.013524839654564857, 0.023997260257601738, 0.06695512682199478, 0.008558349683880806, 0.00792460236698389, -0.028218399733304977, 0.01595679111778736, -0.04670295491814613, 0.03446469083428383, 0.015049627982079983, 0.01632584072649479, -0.046620238572359085, 0.02363620512187481, -0.017062168568372726, -0.00567619176581502, -0.012077001854777336, -0.0290991123765707, 0.05247041583061218, 0.0706806480884552, 0.00934658944606781, -0.05171198025345802, -0.024303540587425232, 0.02946564182639122, 0.018095385283231735, -0.03887148201465607, -0.010860740207135677, -0.06061672419309616, 0.012656474485993385, -0.03210076689720154, 0.02035689912736416, -0.03627581521868706, -0.006625427398830652, 0.04196460545063019, -0.0168377123773098, 0.004346192814409733, 0.009058671072125435, 0.049488525837659836, 0.04997744411230087, 0.008566752076148987, -0.047370195388793945, -0.0745086818933487, -0.0019405815983191133, 0.07098926603794098, 0.043304793536663055, 0.01577066443860531, 0.03740737959742546, -0.03645728901028633, 0.10674554854631424, 0.041546281427145004, 0.009078707545995712, 0.057020626962184906, 0.0054855081252753735, 0.040852271020412445, 0.07363969832658768, -0.0031897765584290028, 0.011510206386446953, -0.016350196674466133, -0.026424391195178032, 0.07839193940162659, -0.0272334273904562, -0.01755725033581257, -0.06373138725757599, 0.02261541597545147, -0.02549639157950878, 0.0180513933300972, 0.0182002242654562, -0.03244581073522568, -0.05772184580564499, 0.016291886568069458, -0.09985510259866714, -0.025994926691055298, 0.05162263289093971, 0.015081558376550674, 0.07174062728881836, 0.04730990156531334, 0.0034813692327588797, 0.02497851848602295, -0.010871252045035362, -0.05066271498799324, 0.051934052258729935, -0.04513093829154968, 0.04669317975640297, 0.014481875114142895, -0.010888717137277126, 0.01442286279052496, 0.02864653617143631, -0.031165558844804764, -0.0279865562915802, -0.021268241107463837, 0.03046288527548313, -0.0358111746609211, 0.019127393141388893, -0.04928527772426605, -0.048824459314346313, -0.041522104293107986, -0.012382271699607372, -0.032039858400821686, -0.013087664730846882, 0.0158780999481678, -0.02841183729469776, 0.049820173531770706, 0.03566082939505577, 0.005824429448693991, -0.001589643070474267, -0.05301268771290779, 0.041318077594041824, 0.047746025025844574, -0.025128133594989777, -0.06665531545877457, -0.029085515066981316, -0.001685957657173276, -0.001387425814755261, 0.023002853617072105, 0.041424792259931564, -0.002566950162872672, 0.03888055682182312, 0.03243646398186684, -0.03358840569853783, -0.017947090789675713, -0.04884273558855057, -0.03187761455774307, -0.05646277964115143, -0.030785631388425827, -0.04072307422757149, -0.01650994084775448, -0.06069374084472656, -0.019061829894781113, -0.040474776178598404, 0.02075669728219509, -0.008791636675596237, -0.012940346263349056, -0.0008033601916395128, -0.010082446038722992, 0.02108081430196762, -0.0012606303207576275, -0.021323204040527344, -0.022784439846873283, 0.000050932612793985754, 0.02147790975868702, 0.031161729246377945, -0.0023097735829651356, 0.03199877217411995, 0.048953454941511154, 0.05036905035376549, 0.023659145459532738, -0.02974262461066246, 0.05039363354444504, 0.05553322285413742, 0.0191048476845026, 0.052101075649261475, -0.0028873055707663298, -0.006211469415575266, -0.03628750890493393, -0.017293035984039307, -0.009709666483104229, -0.049249228090047836, 0.0077640893869102, -0.03058888018131256, -0.04387328028678894, 0.04107024520635605, -0.037199389189481735, -0.024490641430020332, -0.02994387224316597, 0.03392487019300461, 0.004382011946290731, 0.05048884078860283, -0.021168570965528488, 0.02934643253684044, 0.027998996898531914, 0.005626150872558355, 0.045766521245241165, 0.011860654689371586, -0.002922976389527321, -0.011064846999943256, -0.059618812054395676, -0.017221009358763695, 0.03791571408510208, -0.045944467186927795, 0.026267575100064278, 0.013996667228639126, 0.007518102414906025, 0.025632968172430992, 0.0154771963134408, 0.004866099916398525, -0.003346229437738657, 0.05526619032025337, 0.04822626709938049, -0.04769837111234665, 0.017665978521108627, 0.045379262417554855, -0.0006896319100633264, 0.03495129570364952, -0.027054594829678535, -0.033645398914813995, -0.0009437691187486053, 0.027686897665262222, -0.007865591906011105, 0.040842801332473755, 0.009845015592873096, 0.005593408364802599, 0.039039090275764465, 0.014557755552232265, 0.00781561341136694, 0.006531818304210901, -0.021655257791280746, -0.024611055850982666, 0.032527245581150055, -0.0502251572906971, 0.03832558915019035, 0.00009897877316689119, -0.03535442054271698, 0.016812823712825775, 0.026069223880767822, -0.065424844622612, -0.02967779152095318, 0.017325902357697487, 0.07817608118057251, -0.10353827476501465, 0.028824232518672943, -0.04333098977804184, -0.02639547362923622, 0.01675368659198284, -0.04098854213953018, 0.0008978798286989331, -0.04458488151431084, -0.019163448363542557, 0.02350514382123947, -0.06169155612587929, -0.05212690308690071, 0.03322798013687134, 0.04336337745189667, -0.0015491574304178357, -0.07630733400583267, 0.014240475371479988, -0.021438514813780785, 0.03180459514260292, 0.007192166522145271, 0.03585520014166832, -0.021113866940140724, -0.03206627070903778, 0.017606643959879875, -0.013152181170880795, -0.01662612520158291, -0.00023467434220947325, 0.038814663887023926, 0.0066034565679728985, -0.020081691443920135, -0.08204608410596848, 0.017508963122963905, -0.056099437177181244, 0.004366505425423384, 0.024645259603857994, 0.012902243062853813, -0.009178182110190392, -0.06419628113508224, 0.00630734208971262, 0.04547331854701042, 0.008791858330368996, 0.025088556110858917, 0.0026108366437256336, -0.11144861578941345, 0.05202458053827286, -0.01327266450971365, -0.032885581254959106, -0.038159750401973724, -0.004229437559843063, -0.018068652600049973, 0.0630105510354042, -0.019764378666877747, 0.020509326830506325, -0.005414077080786228, 0.004816870670765638 ]
<p>I just wanted to see if I am doing this right. </p> <p>$$\Omega(z) = U(z+\frac{a^2}{z})$$</p> <p>So to find the stagnation point:</p> <p>$$\Omega'(z) = U(1-\frac{a^2}{z^2})=0$$</p> <p>Therefore stagnation points occur at:</p> <p>$z = +/-\sqrt{\frac{a^2}{U}}$</p> <p>These both occur on the x-axis and I see the stagnation occurs on the circle, so I think it's right but not too sure. Thanks!</p>
g5916
[ 0.018411895260214806, 0.014118715189397335, -0.015257403254508972, 0.020123232156038284, 0.0580027811229229, 0.03102249465882778, 0.13193605840206146, 0.010734809562563896, -0.003947142977267504, 0.040870483964681625, -0.038568418473005295, 0.04367245361208916, -0.013991126790642738, 0.009439405053853989, 0.019760699942708015, -0.028023511171340942, -0.010386831127107143, -0.00865733902901411, -0.0250016488134861, 0.00226234900765121, -0.02308943122625351, 0.03866376727819443, 0.07443747669458389, 0.014402570202946663, -0.024886269122362137, -0.006531244609504938, -0.03249506652355194, 0.030705733224749565, -0.021381735801696777, 0.05655153840780258, 0.041170600801706314, 0.03240721672773361, 0.08438809216022491, 0.01568501815199852, 0.039225898683071136, -0.03478626161813736, 0.036516331136226654, 0.034457460045814514, 0.010159585624933243, -0.05195299908518791, 0.01674773544073105, 0.015155508182942867, -0.006634825840592384, -0.015478487126529217, -0.030789684504270554, -0.09301888197660446, -0.07292226701974869, 0.01704316958785057, -0.004769479855895042, -0.0036952560767531395, 0.06876875460147858, 0.05384577065706253, 0.06452162563800812, -0.026225019246339798, 0.008921919390559196, -0.008125499822199345, 0.018297351896762848, -0.01585886999964714, 0.03412768989801407, 0.0492108054459095, -0.013540063053369522, -0.0004777531430590898, 0.04623418301343918, -0.01022376399487257, 0.05421460419893265, 0.004477749578654766, -0.007478933781385422, -0.04920539632439613, -0.03474295139312744, 0.019205205142498016, -0.0008921950357034802, -0.06656179577112198, 0.0023505743592977524, -0.01718786172568798, -0.06853049993515015, 0.020188240334391594, 0.0063808150589466095, 0.0028735066298395395, 0.0014075657818466425, -0.009628892876207829, -0.0035986821167171, -0.02137703448534012, -0.0003064766351599246, 0.030192185193300247, -0.007990275509655476, 0.01050647534430027, -0.01979166828095913, -0.009174687787890434, 0.014118669554591179, -0.03150232508778572, 0.01796199381351471, 0.04645301774144173, -0.05389808490872383, 0.011649217456579208, 0.004411869216710329, -0.009569376707077026, -0.005146564915776253, 0.05649194121360779, -0.018006041646003723, -0.007387475576251745, -0.03223089128732681, 0.04122566059231758, -0.030599577352404594, 0.050581563264131546, -0.004285353701561689, -0.011533785611391068, -0.002555988496169448, -0.01387638971209526, 0.028626009821891785, -0.034677378833293915, -0.00997694581747055, -0.02631494216620922, -0.07655767351388931, 0.011104353703558445, -0.005710674915462732, -0.020144596695899963, 0.019013648852705956, 0.03274243697524071, 0.03966398909687996, 0.044890183955430984, -0.025369424372911453, -0.020509939640760422, 0.0028322574216872454, 0.06858386099338531, 0.02120988629758358, 0.0228407122194767, 0.009170988574624062, -0.021164527162909508, 0.04725036025047302, 0.013765423558652401, 0.05454641208052635, -0.022062640637159348, 0.012061456218361855, -0.015184205025434494, -0.030447551980614662, -0.011381900869309902, -0.028835812583565712, -0.0008254791609942913, 0.06193789467215538, -0.009115763008594513, -0.007076980546116829, -0.01869821362197399, 0.017172249034047127, -0.0023643767926841974, -0.07855147123336792, 0.021093904972076416, -0.023414721712470055, -0.021805457770824432, 0.016300523653626442, -0.016755718737840652, -0.038943927735090256, 0.09684649109840393, -0.030086198821663857, 0.032527126371860504, -0.03797781839966774, 0.022191235795617104, 0.024401962757110596, 0.020472964271903038, 0.025318054482340813, -0.02562149241566658, 0.023857582360506058, 0.04222341254353523, 0.06860101968050003, 0.00047927245032042265, -0.038371432572603226, -0.02500993385910988, -0.035466667264699936, -0.03405464440584183, -0.014979629777371883, 0.044251129031181335, -0.006251561921089888, 0.020498065277934074, 0.03135406970977783, 0.015530326403677464, 0.04492076113820076, 0.03713272884488106, 0.05329577624797821, -0.02910611592233181, 0.08287510275840759, 0.03437494859099388, 0.04358427971601486, -0.053772568702697754, -0.04071991145610809, -0.0012462616432458162, 0.02877904660999775, -0.031639546155929565, 0.027615630999207497, 0.004234963096678257, 0.007622552569955587, 0.01862306520342827, -0.0257197804749012, -0.0763731524348259, -0.028169063851237297, 0.04003721848130226, 0.029441170394420624, 0.04325002059340477, 0.03055736795067787, -0.08420198410749435, -0.011902319267392159, 0.06945926696062088, 0.045684151351451874, -0.027951031923294067, 0.0372636541724205, -0.037769921123981476, -0.020593732595443726, -0.0257257092744112, 0.0025659906677901745, -0.036607734858989716, 0.015138151124119759, 0.05905875563621521, -0.031247250735759735, -0.024894000962376595, 0.004255806561559439, -0.01184534840285778, -0.0044955965131521225, -0.011895453557372093, 0.03956079110503197, 0.061113037168979645, -0.04268135502934456, 0.015031043440103531, 0.06403349339962006, 0.0489710234105587, 0.03262808173894882, 0.007594085764139891, 0.024012012407183647, 0.048461608588695526, -0.03941991925239563, -0.04339831322431564, -0.04029904305934906, 0.025187598541378975, -0.011304344050586224, -0.033339112997055054, 0.019579341635107994, -0.09017707407474518, -0.0017095699440687895, -0.023157591000199318, -0.01611277088522911, 0.016126031056046486, 0.0373503640294075, -0.018442729488015175, 0.0048491680063307285, -0.01918182335793972, -0.0021378358360379934, 0.057891830801963806, 0.038068000227212906, -0.04511469602584839, -0.02053876966238022, 0.04617886245250702, -0.029963476583361626, 0.047675471752882004, 0.06395681202411652, -0.0047660390846431255, 0.014522415585815907, 0.00020044432312715799, -0.0021752191241830587, -0.03981317579746246, 0.009744720533490181, 0.004100251477211714, 0.02209484577178955, -0.014675389975309372, -0.03678034991025925, 0.006946804001927376, 0.03127904608845711, -0.011662843637168407, -0.04596381261944771, 0.024629684165120125, -0.002542597008869052, -0.04270436242222786, 0.02737554721534252, -0.018041865900158882, -0.008343291468918324, -0.0015394726069644094, 0.07519472390413284, 0.06271886080503464, -0.039393093436956406, -0.06835172325372696, 0.003320918884128332, 0.01670595072209835, -0.020219815894961357, -0.005293234251439571, 0.022242534905672073, -0.012253151275217533, 0.004555691033601761, 0.0688440129160881, 0.015958460047841072, 0.04597916081547737, -0.032456863671541214, 0.07868066430091858, -0.07440393418073654, -0.021349653601646423, 0.005106129217892885, -0.005195005796849728, 0.05222582444548607, -0.046845175325870514, 0.058058999478816986, 0.04586924612522125, 0.026989633217453957, -0.04585029184818268, 0.04481889680027962, 0.09060443192720413, 0.030343325808644295, -0.02387239597737789, -0.009028332307934761, -0.0074876444414258, 0.02353820763528347, -0.00014649036165792495, 0.031264737248420715, -0.04895108938217163, 0.0008773535373620689, 0.037670284509658813, 0.02070988528430462, 0.02240091934800148, 0.045994922518730164, -0.0632440447807312, 0.018792008981108665, 0.008572360500693321, -0.005798242520540953, -0.0010983191896229982, 0.015243892557919025, 0.014164485968649387, -0.06235276907682419, -0.033491116017103195, -0.039223868399858475, 0.022794084623456, 0.011091850697994232, -0.0023991880007088184, -0.0690244734287262, 0.032492998987436295, -0.05973802134394646, -0.01976202242076397, 0.0023672725073993206, 0.02323167584836483, -0.01221925113350153, -0.022470779716968536, -0.04574637487530708, -0.03781109303236008, -0.05838757008314133, -0.05499446019530296, -0.0020679468289017677, 0.0035660548601299524, -0.040510766208171844, 0.042297784239053726, 0.07291620969772339, -0.0411306694149971, 0.015748975798487663, -0.024796469137072563, -0.028366418555378914, 0.0615583211183548, 0.018282489851117134, -0.0223564300686121, 0.002988615073263645, -0.06298372149467468, 0.03446833789348602, -0.03292272984981537, -0.01862904243171215, 0.03019232675433159, -0.006346719805151224, 0.01969032920897007, -0.02800249680876732, -0.016334887593984604, 0.03376533463597298, -0.0483502522110939, 0.02971341460943222, 0.021557359024882317, 0.027315974235534668, -0.03857332840561867, -0.011757828295230865, 0.07150701433420181, -0.009981876239180565, 0.0998813733458519, 0.046125221997499466, -0.011870944872498512, 0.03742600232362747, 0.01349876169115305, -0.008463776670396328, -0.05075649917125702, -0.042643334716558456, -0.005799638573080301, 0.008186646737158298, 0.04816187545657158, 0.052243396639823914, -0.006643814966082573, -0.07248616963624954, -0.013337567448616028, 0.0002728095278143883, 0.052639883011579514, 0.006676322780549526, -0.02148168720304966, 0.026855379343032837, -0.03974476084113121, 0.039226990193128586, -0.018799427896738052, -0.010821978561580181, -0.004366246517747641, -0.0063859159126877785, -0.027562348172068596, 0.015493890270590782, 0.05976966768503189, -0.05304662138223648, 0.035588376224040985, 0.021727556362748146, -0.00702631613239646, 0.025472275912761688, -0.03124324046075344, 0.0024030092172324657, -0.012616140767931938, 0.0000769850448705256, -0.007532376330345869, 0.045145485550165176, -0.03279629349708557, 0.006089492700994015, 0.013077301904559135, -0.012827703729271889, -0.030584553256630898, -0.008481760509312153, -0.018810832872986794, 0.002593015553429723, -0.021179087460041046, -0.0031824191100895405, 0.008389871567487717, -0.033528830856084824, 0.010001993738114834, -0.06188850477337837, -0.08886124193668365, -0.03343537449836731, -0.002610113937407732, 0.02407064102590084, -0.02691258117556572, 0.017355069518089294, 0.04781037196516991, -0.034184880554676056, 0.008280610665678978, -0.025824207812547684, 0.0022121386136859655, -0.015624841675162315, 0.028087103739380836, 0.007277015130966902, -0.04656856134533882, 0.009097743779420853, 0.01587916724383831, 0.0068287719041109085, -0.044234614819288254, 0.00970311090350151, -0.009362286888062954, -0.005139654036611319, 0.016629138961434364, -0.06725087016820908, -0.025173423811793327, 0.06806595623493195, -0.029368456453084946, -0.028213994577527046, 0.02325398288667202, 0.09044952690601349, -0.027748536318540573, 0.04972812533378601, -0.05044205114245415, -0.011940657161176205, 0.05292404070496559, -0.023105518892407417, 0.034117188304662704, -0.05687013268470764, -0.057257771492004395, -0.0034933241549879313, -0.0308523066341877, 0.030450202524662018, -0.01809745281934738, -0.055516317486763, 0.0014411060838028789, -0.0180265624076128, -0.015719980001449585, -0.007547870744019747, 0.04547109082341194, 0.05396193638443947, 0.04757601395249367, -0.029607104137539864, 0.00008819204231258482, 0.0273022148758173, 0.028596166521310806, -0.0028363328892737627, 0.0007623648853041232, -0.029822837561368942, -0.027265071868896484, 0.012063482776284218, -0.06380333751440048, -0.04217921197414398, -0.027506180107593536, -0.024608589708805084, -0.04759044572710991, 0.002941091312095523, 0.007510378025472164, 0.020736312493681908, 0.006114979274570942, -0.04970861226320267, -0.03911681845784187, -0.0034682415425777435, -0.026023264974355698, -0.008340781554579735, -0.039528101682662964, 0.0041958331130445, -0.045614954084157944, -0.0714351013302803, 0.012121184729039669, -0.03537168726325035, 0.001724784728139639, -0.01895468682050705, 0.03352783992886543, 0.06664499640464783, -0.03711351007223129, 0.03855479881167412, 0.10766841471195221, 0.013186929747462273, -0.007253587245941162, 0.04450568929314613, -0.0279608815908432, -0.010933107696473598, 0.046750687062740326, -0.03919335827231407, -0.04926525056362152, 0.007250408176332712, -0.037420954555273056, 0.06659015268087387, 0.04307902976870537, -0.08345595747232437, -0.022558679804205894, 0.046220846474170685, -0.0046272967010736465, -0.02041887305676937, -0.03268793225288391, 0.024142274633049965, 0.016938121989369392, -0.01598219946026802, -0.018827160820364952, -0.01371764950454235, -0.01907205767929554, 0.05133631452918053, -0.03221753239631653, -0.057158879935741425, -0.06017967686057091, 0.01737722009420395, -0.07156835496425629, 0.0136248879134655, -0.016008395701646805, 0.02560971863567829, 0.021929116919636726, -0.06147763133049011, 0.00011173250823048875, 0.009342983365058899, 0.05062885954976082, -0.027745425701141357, -0.0027556943241506815, -0.026368901133537292, 0.016513071954250336, -0.011927966959774494, -0.04683329910039902, -0.08560574054718018, 0.054262325167655945, 0.01742829941213131, 0.005166269838809967, -0.013664397411048412, -0.029682643711566925, -0.005740703083574772, -0.06770435720682144, 0.04991670697927475, -0.03447997197508812, 0.04486735165119171, -0.0737982988357544, 0.042741041630506516, -0.00907471589744091, 0.059598129242658615, 0.043059658259153366, 0.06779187172651291, 0.07800385355949402, 0.013095230795443058, 0.037675224244594574, 0.027090592309832573, 0.0462995283305645, -0.05125631019473076, -0.01287413202226162, -0.009184020571410656, 0.02215428091585636, -0.0343782901763916, 0.07777904719114304, 0.04748726636171341, 0.009377343580126762, -0.03440399840474129, 0.04869569092988968, 0.04483669251203537, 0.028960704803466797, 0.0016177196521311998, -0.014791004359722137, 0.02034306526184082, 0.012250669300556183, -0.056135933846235275, -0.008229505270719528, -0.003932487685233355, -0.03648478537797928, 0.026140671223402023, 0.004465498495846987, -0.02873375453054905, -0.003335254965350032, 0.02386256866157055, 0.01610361970961094, 0.040561992675065994, -0.051798783242702484, -0.04117567837238312, 0.011054474860429764, 0.006543038412928581, 0.019416077062487602, 0.019560405984520912, 0.027498485520482063, 0.00648575508967042, 0.09933394938707352, 0.03481021523475647, 0.07380999624729156, -0.01267003733664751, -0.05200914666056633, 0.024404285475611687, -0.013851176016032696, 0.012347203679382801, -0.0036097869742661715, 0.05910075828433037, 0.038954976946115494, -0.0630086287856102, -0.017939399927854538, 0.009158698841929436, -0.04892126843333244, 0.00906476192176342, -0.03289942815899849, -0.026661911979317665, -0.05998148024082184, -0.011807218194007874, -0.019564824178814888, 0.02986365184187889, -0.027143124490976334, 0.0005701831541955471, 0.0023314356803894043, -0.027144739404320717, 0.015940425917506218, 0.0024174286518245935, -0.013834487646818161, 0.013201843947172165, 0.030831363052129745, -0.032476913183927536, 0.02883835881948471, -0.04462216794490814, 0.031144896522164345, -0.005040237680077553, 0.010832597501575947, -0.06247518211603165, 0.009625004604458809, 0.07193637639284134, 0.02317551150918007, 0.0007029949338175356, -0.03508064150810242, 0.0004682266735471785, 0.036811359226703644, 0.028794892132282257, 0.0038286689668893814, -0.007953722029924393, -0.03529573604464531, -0.059862375259399414, 0.04718782752752304, 0.02299230359494686, 0.004029505420476198, -0.03663155809044838, 0.00874149240553379, 0.02345677651464939, -0.006646357011049986, -0.029674122110009193, 0.0034909630194306374, 0.010509776882827282, 0.01580609753727913, -0.04889433830976486, -0.04267797991633415, 0.03259912505745888, 0.0009743093396537006, -0.049315083771944046, -0.008109301328659058, -0.02147044613957405, 0.03907640278339386, 0.042158935219049454, -0.07532522082328796, -0.05829405412077904, -0.06679241359233856, -0.028070267289876938, 0.07730058580636978, -0.00996379368007183, -0.08743347972631454, 0.014287395402789116, 0.013525147922337055, -0.013292494229972363, 0.018681036308407784, 0.01699148491024971, -0.017148161306977272, 0.03960449993610382, -0.05173923447728157, -0.058353956788778305, -0.009539168328046799, -0.016314756125211716, 0.027213752269744873, 0.029041564092040062, -0.004538475535809994, -0.018212510272860527, 0.01615220680832863, -0.04203161224722862, 0.028226343914866447, -0.02170596644282341, -0.008452340960502625, 0.016755539923906326, -0.07168839126825333, -0.0004825339128728956, 0.010594204999506474, -0.05553296208381653, -0.024169771000742912, 0.009020719677209854, -0.012951688840985298, -0.05505790188908577, 0.014559844508767128, 0.049286238849163055, -0.003488623071461916, -0.07895968109369278, -0.08069213479757309, -0.013943958096206188, -0.0963461622595787, -0.026512619107961655, 0.002167773898690939, 0.014114131219685078, -0.011795726604759693, 0.013282467611134052, 0.017634106799960136, 0.012481181882321835, 0.023742200806736946, 0.00691095320507884, 0.0640086904168129, -0.026989854872226715, -0.018702218309044838, -0.04727887362241745, 0.018488267436623573, 0.03571068122982979, -0.005123889073729515, 0.0034343593288213015, -0.02124953083693981, 0.035997599363327026, 0.010897599160671234, 0.018141239881515503, -0.019043076783418655, 0.04245129972696304, 0.03129187598824501, 0.021158374845981598, -0.016422711312770844, -0.0527515783905983, 0.025655407458543777, 0.011531866155564785, -0.03904043510556221, -0.006598103325814009, -0.0037546756211668253, 0.026052774861454964, 0.042752910405397415, -0.017041882500052452, -0.030731717124581337, -0.014357234351336956, -0.04827944561839104, -0.048754360526800156, 0.014383704401552677, -0.024579912424087524, -0.048966582864522934, -0.05254156515002251, 0.004627561196684837 ]
<p>This is a follow-up question on the topic that I opened a few days ago, <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/79924/wilson-loops-as-raising-operators">Wilson Loops as raising operators</a>.</p> <p>The paper </p> <blockquote> <p>Topological Degeneracy of Quantum Hall Fluids. X.G. Wen, A. Zee. <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.58.15717" rel="nofollow"><em>Phys. Rev. B</em> <strong>58</strong> no. 23 (1998), pp. 15717-15728</a>. <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9711223" rel="nofollow">arXiv:cond-mat/9711223</a>.</p> </blockquote> <p>gives a nice derivation of the explicit ground states of the $U(1)$ Chern-Simons Theory on a torus in Section 2 on Abelian Quantum Hall States. </p> <p>In particular Eq. (12) gives the generic form of a ground state $\psi(y) = \sum_{n=-\infty}^{\infty} c_{n} \ e^{i\ 2\pi ny}$. Due to the fact that the theory lives on a torus the ground state manifold is found to be $k$-fold degenerate. </p> <p>My question: Is it possible (by direct calculation) to obtain the relations \begin{align} W(b)|n \rangle &amp;= |n + 1 \text{ mod } |k| \rangle, \nonumber \\ W(a) |n \rangle &amp;= e^{2\pi i n /k} |n \rangle. \end{align} from the previous question? </p> <p>I don't have a particularly strong background in field theory so I am feeling somewhat uneasy when it comes to the explicit evaluation of the Wilson Loop (with its exponentiated gauge field and the path ordering) acting on the constructed state.</p> <p>I am looking forward to your responses.</p>
g5917
[ -0.04546365141868591, -0.009030557237565517, -0.013627375476062298, -0.026832304894924164, 0.039831455796957016, 0.01974518783390522, 0.014209788292646408, 0.03555089980363846, 0.043312299996614456, 0.0013391359243541956, -0.02030346728861332, -0.05289054661989212, 0.0027667665854096413, 0.04033553600311279, -0.010360919870436192, -0.0328153520822525, -0.011269807815551758, 0.02112509123980999, 0.0049629174172878265, -0.10752390325069427, -0.0321783609688282, -0.0412614643573761, 0.043255943804979324, -0.07886189222335815, 0.04401078075170517, -0.04920787364244461, -0.004495610482990742, -0.025773555040359497, 0.007558941841125488, -0.04856137931346893, 0.04164258763194084, -0.0038935982156544924, 0.0487462542951107, -0.005275052972137928, -0.0397782176733017, 0.045466888695955276, 0.08287537097930908, 0.054495926946401596, 0.016901755705475807, -0.04122477024793625, -0.016358574852347374, -0.009089207276701927, 0.05350698530673981, 0.01886548101902008, -0.06478311121463776, 0.015513628721237183, -0.019230971112847328, 0.045705001801252365, -0.043982408940792084, 0.021888701245188713, 0.02320150099694729, 0.06452511996030807, 0.011795111000537872, -0.014458532445132732, -0.0039664218202233315, 0.024593116715550423, -0.010014546103775501, -0.03253302350640297, 0.06186541169881821, 0.06244121119379997, 0.0017707902006804943, -0.050532713532447815, 0.06508628278970718, 0.010070144198834896, 0.013013244606554508, -0.006515768822282553, -0.011286033317446709, -0.007165415212512016, -0.034081168472766876, -0.03113723173737526, -0.002550387755036354, -0.06306299567222595, 0.0206284299492836, -0.005649377126246691, 0.012944377958774567, 0.07318431884050369, 0.03544265776872635, -0.04618249461054802, 0.08150307834148407, 0.02992864139378071, -0.03344030678272247, -0.014615092426538467, -0.003734859637916088, -0.023736780509352684, 0.003463209606707096, -0.03713833913207054, 0.007321465294808149, -0.019150862470269203, -0.015251755714416504, 0.06397628784179688, -0.013624260202050209, -0.009522146545350552, 0.02564220316708088, 0.07262235879898071, -0.007576693780720234, 0.01032991986721754, 0.006957470905035734, -0.031152596697211266, -0.03986171633005142, 0.028805019333958626, -0.03248456493020058, -0.02524504065513611, 0.06042458489537239, -0.02885587327182293, 0.02187308855354786, -0.016246186569333076, -0.0017612790688872337, -0.024740511551499367, -0.039573490619659424, 0.0013897039461880922, -0.0646127462387085, 0.08086396008729935, 0.024347085505723953, -0.033401742577552795, -0.026381950825452805, 0.022084418684244156, 0.030646231025457382, -0.007694108411669731, -0.032614849507808685, 0.02897615171968937, 0.0732581838965416, -0.003156369086354971, -0.027532780542969704, 0.02633458562195301, 0.038753312081098557, 0.0025428931694477797, -0.03905242681503296, -0.05190008133649826, 0.04115734249353409, 0.03944644331932068, 0.06606650352478027, -0.029012348502874374, 0.03315006196498871, 0.05882888287305832, 0.010215182788670063, -0.002942128572613001, 0.0026974359061568975, 0.015058856457471848, 0.05884989723563194, 0.006491613108664751, -0.018035992980003357, -0.07233870029449463, -0.04728472977876663, -0.040417008101940155, 0.002767462283372879, 0.011706049554049969, 0.031230568885803223, -0.04214487597346306, 0.1011907085776329, 0.00036204259959049523, 0.006979061756283045, -0.026281706988811493, 0.0315723717212677, -0.03795144334435463, 0.02357998862862587, 0.04414763301610947, 0.052939750254154205, -0.03892672434449196, 0.002464303048327565, 0.025373095646500587, 0.02001582458615303, -0.025748874992132187, 0.05964832752943039, 0.045580167323350906, -0.02739034779369831, -0.06634325534105301, 0.0227311123162508, -0.058459945023059845, -0.01906752586364746, -0.02360074408352375, -0.005507269408553839, 0.04044162109494209, 0.058444857597351074, 0.03658590093255043, 0.019109809771180153, 0.01372368261218071, -0.05173052102327347, -0.05446301028132439, -0.002145496429875493, -0.007363574579358101, 0.021011672914028168, 0.05779799073934555, -0.02003469131886959, 0.03219505771994591, 0.028626609593629837, 0.040722545236349106, -0.022124940529465675, -0.044004324823617935, -0.0010663223220035434, -0.031617678701877594, -0.029647843912243843, 0.03952132537961006, 0.008336597122251987, 0.06011461839079857, 0.004860823042690754, 0.005819029174745083, 0.024261483922600746, -0.06888726353645325, 0.026294101029634476, -0.015088193118572235, -0.000012600657100847457, 0.0054894681088626385, 0.010649445466697216, -0.0489351786673069, -0.001565061858855188, 0.06167096644639969, -0.0068709938786923885, -0.03861542418599129, -0.0591859295964241, -0.052471935749053955, -0.020558323711156845, -0.004883849062025547, -0.030702048912644386, 0.04954687878489494, -0.05519455298781395, -0.04072386771440506, 0.06141654774546623, -0.02042274922132492, -0.015499376691877842, -0.04302061349153519, -0.009965043514966965, 0.033838506788015366, 0.03090507909655571, 0.02578434906899929, -0.00797787681221962, -0.040457453578710556, 0.014672460034489632, 0.02896176464855671, -0.043079666793346405, -0.04009438306093216, -0.06307462602853775, 0.013537467457354069, -0.0052906000055372715, -0.09722841531038284, 0.02107337862253189, 0.028291886672377586, -0.020727533847093582, 0.018194792792201042, 0.02156340330839157, 0.06979742646217346, -0.01600138656795025, 0.0018890968058258295, -0.008020937442779541, -0.02317301370203495, 0.04224186763167381, 0.021178914234042168, 0.056659236550331116, 0.03964131325483322, -0.03496751934289932, 0.05896160751581192, 0.052265018224716187, -0.011754115112125874, -0.0106362821534276, 0.020307717844843864, -0.01369383279234171, 0.01658468320965767, 0.014179842546582222, -0.01721855252981186, 0.021221118047833443, -0.037228893488645554, 0.042837955057621, -0.0022843019105494022, -0.035902079194784164, 0.02790067531168461, -0.07958094775676727, 0.013269751332700253, 0.019152866676449776, 0.011111755855381489, -0.008007585071027279, -0.0046291593462228775, 0.006200290285050869, 0.025319350883364677, 0.0020437936764210463, 0.05023026838898659, -0.057297587394714355, -0.003325842320919037, -0.02158184163272381, -0.007012475747615099, -0.003060445189476013, -0.009622232988476753, -0.051798634231090546, -0.004399267956614494, -0.05055101960897446, 0.04361681267619133, 0.022058837115764618, -0.06067068874835968, -0.016355546191334724, 0.003992794547230005, -0.001298299292102456, 0.03225322812795639, 0.0002871053875423968, 0.06327740848064423, 0.041970692574977875, 0.06265642493963242, -0.050989676266908646, 0.01931467466056347, -0.04786716774106026, -0.022062718868255615, 0.014157458208501339, 0.12436217069625854, -0.005445410497486591, -0.06029937416315079, -0.0028031538240611553, -0.007429017219692469, 0.015932979062199593, -0.04018457606434822, -0.03616161644458771, 0.021016813814640045, 0.018225351348519325, 0.012105461210012436, -0.013077180832624435, 0.014654523693025112, -0.022545956075191498, -0.023700393736362457, 0.022443527355790138, 0.05334724858403206, -0.018653132021427155, -0.03225775808095932, -0.010416952893137932, 0.016520163044333458, -0.013866666704416275, 0.013973004184663296, -0.008658812381327152, 0.005346441175788641, 0.007016320712864399, 0.01627790555357933, -0.013867623172700405, 0.012440362945199013, -0.014921195805072784, -0.04248511791229248, 0.03165462985634804, -0.06476788222789764, 0.05362026393413544, -0.02527102828025818, -0.025416851043701172, -0.101429782807827, -0.06853590905666351, -0.02132773958146572, 0.0663052499294281, -0.0026482611428946257, -0.024231132119894028, -0.02472536452114582, -0.029402675107121468, 0.022578423842787743, -0.027269208803772926, 0.021497460082173347, -0.06673988699913025, -0.0038607646711170673, -0.002719987416639924, -0.022893954068422318, -0.016487816348671913, -0.000056514407333452255, 0.06472557038068771, -0.01072302833199501, 0.010502239689230919, -0.010731822811067104, -0.01435376238077879, 0.04717017710208893, 0.020051101222634315, -0.02789853699505329, 0.004625021480023861, 0.014052287675440311, 0.00021992427355144173, -0.03251584246754646, 0.012981212697923183, 0.013862344436347485, 0.008950444869697094, 0.004213991574943066, 0.02427009493112564, 0.01475135050714016, -0.0224537905305624, 0.033356986939907074, -0.022678138688206673, 0.026176845654845238, 0.04789629578590393, -0.023429332301020622, 0.015595881268382072, -0.002644633874297142, -0.042096178978681564, 0.0209354255348444, 0.0064614079892635345, 0.008448665961623192, 0.016699157655239105, 0.030774006620049477, -0.05003640055656433, 0.05801412835717201, -0.0689246729016304, 0.016627129167318344, 0.004942888393998146, -0.04918218031525612, -0.04547082260251045, -0.03717494755983353, -0.00841671321541071, -0.01826719380915165, 0.011970494873821735, 0.04751976951956749, 0.06692958623170853, -0.008516282774508, -0.006474876310676336, 0.053840845823287964, 0.034216009080410004, -0.06024090200662613, 0.007232324220240116, -0.03209174424409866, -0.0024161359760910273, 0.010779017582535744, 0.05437150597572327, 0.0026742592453956604, -0.004552422557026148, -0.023691276088356972, 0.02864588052034378, -0.032484132796525955, 0.06695929914712906, -0.04575140401721001, 0.028704963624477386, -0.01719505898654461, 0.0178441870957613, -0.044930700212717056, -0.03714951127767563, -0.025393491610884666, 0.03940412029623985, -0.0022130156867206097, 0.03691857308149338, 0.0008208243525587022, -0.027093179523944855, 0.023203879594802856, -0.08853864669799805, -0.02207968942821026, -0.0220166128128767, -0.024035479873418808, -0.04307268559932709, 0.01904147118330002, -0.0013857848243787885, 0.03488265722990036, -0.05929788202047348, 0.05216865614056587, -0.06232834234833717, 0.012679660692811012, -0.014035039581358433, -0.00047527614515274763, 0.07027207314968109, -0.03414522483944893, -0.02554946020245552, -0.04243643581867218, 0.029118573293089867, -0.03298020362854004, -0.06210145354270935, 0.005174324382096529, 0.019771592691540718, -0.005343684460967779, -0.008199824020266533, -0.027847521007061005, 0.03378916159272194, -0.04561357572674751, 0.0062028104439377785, -0.047526873648166656, 0.05049487203359604, 0.0023858030326664448, -0.013470854610204697, -0.013663877733051777, -0.03333226963877678, 0.016385100781917572, 0.021292943507432938, -0.013068865053355694, 0.047102395445108414, 0.008442348800599575, -0.07756734639406204, 0.06937801092863083, -0.032003145664930344, -0.00043209161958657205, 0.027057165279984474, -0.019645659253001213, -0.005873352289199829, -0.047836750745773315, 0.050956714898347855, 0.019204095005989075, 0.040125396102666855, -0.02384096197783947, -0.022373788058757782, 0.003964331932365894, -0.006414408795535564, 0.006316047161817551, -0.011964530684053898, 0.010076283477246761, -0.013811926357448101, 0.011189214885234833, -0.04351545125246048, -0.015001382678747177, -0.02820361964404583, 0.08023033291101456, 0.052003972232341766, 0.05112891644239426, -0.019700340926647186, 0.03473048657178879, 0.003907785285264254, -0.042305923998355865, -0.01539018377661705, -0.025250039994716644, -0.012244699522852898, 0.04987574741244316, -0.006141347344964743, 0.005878877360373735, -0.024475637823343277, 0.06439802795648575, -0.028225187212228775, 0.03754781186580658, 0.07682754844427109, -0.01225069910287857, 0.035171400755643845, -0.05563899874687195, -0.005811041686683893, -0.03022989071905613, 0.018583884462714195, -0.011901852674782276, -0.006122640799731016, 0.01244182139635086, 0.00035103029222227633, -0.030600957572460175, -0.013943081721663475, -0.06559370458126068, 0.08430390805006027, 0.043896086513996124, 0.055572327226400375, -0.0531812347471714, -0.05406013876199722, 0.06949175149202347, -0.052180107682943344, -0.03817618638277054, -0.03044907934963703, 0.0234641395509243, 0.016224415972828865, -0.0069071887992322445, 0.010604796931147575, 0.021654056385159492, 0.0047394591383636, -0.013196952641010284, -0.029509685933589935, 0.000933877017814666, 0.01778581738471985, 0.0038461373187601566, 0.018873021006584167, -0.02730044722557068, 0.00815078616142273, 0.03197483718395233, -0.0032131990883499384, -0.05874300003051758, -0.04845091328024864, -0.019561385735869408, 0.03541845083236694, 0.019479356706142426, -0.07823805510997772, -0.020586222410202026, -0.0310977790504694, -0.0075696310959756374, -0.01843428984284401, 0.009094580076634884, 0.008778157643973827, -0.018495695665478706, -0.05542566999793053, 0.026981789618730545, -0.0050431531853973866, -0.018855946138501167, 0.03637209162116051, 0.07039734721183777, 0.026351697742938995, 0.07378855347633362, 0.005070179235190153, -0.017101943492889404, 0.07679933309555054, 0.038812074810266495, 0.01970302313566208, 0.01475576963275671, -0.053389668464660645, 0.013011234812438488, -0.035367436707019806, -0.032447148114442825, -0.07595047354698181, -0.0781053677201271, -0.009652160108089447, 0.053230468183755875, -0.09248032420873642, -0.00892884936183691, -0.02373361401259899, -0.0025337126571685076, -0.030987687408924103, 0.029017172753810883, -0.04481269046664238, -0.002237956505268812, 0.060964349657297134, 0.060185737907886505, -0.04645554721355438, 0.03500305861234665, -0.0023233150132000446, 0.016888314858078957, -0.0032887058332562447, 0.06645205616950989, 0.04073084145784378, -0.03364761918783188, 0.011904172599315643, 0.04768557474017143, 0.03738749027252197, -0.03948213905096054, 0.021727653220295906, -0.057338010519742966, -0.001829502172768116, 0.07132954150438309, -0.02490648254752159, 0.048687826842069626, 0.006951448041945696, -0.022214794531464577, 0.017913706600666046, -0.03199366480112076, 0.049589790403842926, 0.020613249391317368, 0.006372794043272734, -0.09953708201646805, 0.010950860567390919, -0.0036567470524460077, 0.026314735412597656, 0.013481511734426022, 0.05594691261649132, 0.025599252432584763, -0.00046154833398759365, -0.0450248084962368, 0.05794842913746834, 0.009531645104289055, -0.00728105241432786, -0.03828224167227745, 0.007261658553034067, 0.014162411913275719, -0.0052682217210531235, -0.010125497356057167, -0.07239439338445663, -0.036659132689237595, 0.03486545756459236, 0.05139778181910515, -0.01473750825971365, 0.003586636856198311, 0.0032686726190149784, 0.05195961520075798, -0.045641664415597916, 0.046675700694322586, 0.05746389180421829, 0.015719860792160034, 0.017447281628847122, -0.05466441810131073, -0.01505055371671915, 0.029562169685959816, -0.08779214322566986, 0.06819714605808258, 0.068117156624794, 0.015741420909762383, -0.02159293182194233, 0.024592556059360504, 0.02496909350156784, -0.009175216779112816, 0.02160678245127201, -0.02290637418627739, 0.0008950269548222423, 0.00879121944308281, 0.02134287916123867, -0.017347538843750954, -0.012001091614365578, 0.015741223469376564, -0.03808858245611191, 0.02692871168255806, -0.012822486460208893, 0.061551257967948914, -0.023880138993263245, -0.04449310898780823, 0.032403238117694855, -0.045956872403621674, -0.05201062560081482, -0.026659591123461723, -0.0006194512243382633, -0.06173607334494591, -0.040454261004924774, 0.019663352519273758, 0.009626206010580063, -0.0012163069332018495, -0.0015504624461755157, 0.03320535644888878, 0.008178912103176117, -0.046229247003793716, -0.023366369307041168, 0.03766358643770218, -0.005131109151989222, -0.043001238256692886, 0.05875856429338455, 0.00888418685644865, 0.05630664527416229, 0.025960035622119904, 0.04233359917998314, 0.0018719574436545372, -0.00017743669741321355, -0.022369535639882088, -0.054554201662540436, -0.030170265585184097, -0.015611336566507816, 0.025270845741033554, 0.049828484654426575, -0.05289429426193237, -0.0662761777639389, 0.012109850533306599, 0.05044490098953247, -0.03597012907266617, -0.009566697292029858, 0.004807888995856047, -0.07769139856100082, 0.02366323582828045, -0.01024581678211689, -0.04792534559965134, -0.06685788184404373, 0.04903620854020119, 0.008464152924716473, -0.02288583293557167, 0.013969330117106438, -0.007343531586229801, -0.011467683129012585, -0.003020571544766426, -0.019659793004393578, -0.014499109238386154, -0.025822356343269348, 0.011079204268753529, -0.039386212825775146, -0.024827199056744576, 0.027459867298603058, 0.02824007160961628, -0.04829443618655205, 0.036667097359895706, 0.007775540929287672, -0.028486590832471848, 0.034532688558101654, -0.010251825675368309, -0.0391673818230629, 0.028721081092953682, -0.0071129947900772095, -0.050879571586847305, 0.01691529154777527, 0.020601460710167885, -0.020832156762480736, -0.007631050888448954, 0.054691676050424576, -0.020512834191322327, 0.02498769201338291, 0.051468368619680405, -0.02636825293302536, 0.026908807456493378, -0.008563399314880371, -0.01812821440398693, 0.051797062158584595, 0.02158966287970543, 0.047048311680555344, 0.02710174024105072, -0.014315159060060978, -0.003625016426667571, 0.01949296146631241, 0.0378190353512764, -0.006654248107224703, 0.03360891714692116, -0.013675865717232227, -0.007485826499760151, -0.026476416736841202, 0.028534336015582085, -0.011698666960000992, -0.016063222661614418, -0.04420888423919678, -0.014811616390943527 ]
<p>Can somebody please provide me with a reference where the method of evaluating the heat kernel for spin-1 fields,i.e. vector laplacians on a 2-sphere is given? Please suggest some references accessible for physicists.</p>
g5918
[ -0.006659418344497681, -0.0069124833680689335, -0.01224247645586729, -0.020659998059272766, -0.018159963190555573, -0.0010379001032561064, 0.06079520285129547, 0.06510947644710541, -0.06196143105626106, 0.06504080444574356, -0.00019699304539244622, 0.0457313172519207, 0.01736840233206749, 0.0096681984141469, -0.004199814051389694, -0.028520997613668442, -0.032917823642492294, 0.03232790529727936, -0.023434828966856003, -0.01391331385821104, -0.053821492940187454, -0.023738762363791466, -0.013700900599360466, -0.011652987450361252, 0.029499325901269913, -0.024364599958062172, 0.006547013763338327, -0.00867442972958088, 0.00006506896897917613, -0.019603203982114792, -0.015041344799101353, -0.038807496428489685, 0.007907118648290634, -0.0638553574681282, -0.04151898995041847, 0.03334837779402733, 0.10077546536922455, 0.042037587612867355, -0.016427883878350258, 0.005899303592741489, 0.04572921618819237, -0.03688100352883339, 0.07107777148485184, 0.07327958196401596, 0.05542759224772453, 0.019517159089446068, -0.013006698340177536, 0.014875784516334534, 0.0028472410049289465, 0.029103713110089302, 0.020612474530935287, 0.005538720637559891, 0.09294037520885468, -0.017555220052599907, -0.0036386188585311174, 0.002723777899518609, -0.05600791424512863, 0.024547290056943893, 0.02639373578131199, 0.028909962624311447, 0.016299067065119743, -0.023582594469189644, -0.07290808856487274, -0.046840693801641464, -0.04258859530091286, 0.0000573473735130392, -0.040896449238061905, -0.005226700566709042, -0.08057628571987152, -0.0074544246308505535, 0.006070773117244244, -0.009549732320010662, 0.059999480843544006, 0.010557777248322964, -0.016002660617232323, -0.043044451624155045, 0.0400041900575161, -0.03586272895336151, 0.031162366271018982, -0.029315771535038948, 0.02187659591436386, 0.021993104368448257, 0.04396383836865425, 0.0119088189676404, -0.0031590356957167387, 0.020469753071665764, -0.03403467312455177, 0.04539260268211365, 0.044324953109025955, -0.014035141095519066, -0.0009716302156448364, 0.0657334178686142, 0.039727192372083664, -0.006313529796898365, -0.004257345572113991, 0.015736518427729607, -0.029611116275191307, -0.034322068095207214, -0.03717614337801933, 0.01850837655365467, 0.012071422301232815, 0.03991397097706795, 0.020288126543164253, -0.0036395126953721046, 0.022611098363995552, -0.018654661253094673, 0.014955100603401661, 0.03988853842020035, 0.004110049922019243, 0.010755511932075024, -0.010408888570964336, 0.05085773766040802, -0.015732690691947937, 0.008488972671329975, -0.035799384117126465, -0.03951794654130936, 0.09264972060918808, -0.06238555163145065, 0.00723765604197979, 0.07837708294391632, 0.029539428651332855, 0.014267119579017162, -0.0031373994424939156, 0.07939758151769638, 0.03867921978235245, 0.017297174781560898, -0.04762803018093109, -0.0029517142102122307, -0.006233165040612221, 0.006562354508787394, 0.035215698182582855, -0.027314726263284683, 0.04207592457532883, -0.018963970243930817, -0.07426024973392487, 0.06853946298360825, -0.0167018361389637, 0.027945823967456818, -0.007939855568110943, -0.04894376918673515, 0.02757628820836544, -0.1040593609213829, 0.0015797415981069207, -0.083356112241745, 0.01810554228723049, 0.032969072461128235, 0.029432637616991997, -0.10381648689508438, 0.013244468718767166, 0.03170870617032051, 0.04629454389214516, 0.060099340975284576, 0.01961226761341095, -0.005335650872439146, 0.03411131352186203, -0.023636406287550926, 0.04967164993286133, 0.020322710275650024, 0.0653369277715683, -0.019078325480222702, 0.0041488646529614925, 0.027712872251868248, 0.052745502442121506, 0.06134903058409691, -0.015200522728264332, 0.01988273859024048, -0.003728346200659871, -0.052297160029411316, -0.0008953363867476583, -0.06291741132736206, -0.009335875511169434, 0.037056419998407364, 0.020754380151629448, 0.01226678118109703, 0.011321820318698883, -0.003773339092731476, -0.015587748028337955, 0.023646075278520584, -0.017368681728839874, 0.035499610006809235, -0.024229710921645164, -0.014538717456161976, 0.02225537598133087, 0.007091027684509754, 0.01836179941892624, -0.0019081922946497798, 0.01354333758354187, 0.03140746057033539, -0.032920289784669876, -0.01637219823896885, -0.05610586330294609, 0.02070755884051323, 0.017332350835204124, -0.036987632513046265, 0.020466070622205734, 0.0530506856739521, 0.05463124439120293, -0.07615268230438232, -0.04639946296811104, -0.00235559931024909, -0.004748391453176737, 0.03033742681145668, 0.03266160935163498, 0.019795775413513184, -0.052972305566072464, -0.010242062620818615, 0.042124927043914795, 0.00739467004314065, 0.03149712085723877, -0.008802334778010845, -0.03236529976129532, -0.00216251565143466, 0.032092027366161346, 0.002013451885432005, 0.029639121145009995, 0.06552043557167053, -0.033880867063999176, -0.002461112104356289, 0.012470683082938194, -0.03314464911818504, -0.03090313822031021, 0.040031932294368744, 0.062465716153383255, -0.003668163437396288, -0.02554934285581112, 0.023753829300403595, -0.04830067232251167, -0.0005925035802647471, 0.046553246676921844, 0.014158661477267742, -0.08693771064281464, -0.0484468974173069, 0.021093524992465973, -0.020357348024845123, 0.0059464857913553715, 0.003080835100263357, -0.033117856830358505, -0.021695973351597786, 0.011572727002203465, 0.0736975148320198, 0.015830976888537407, 0.015788115561008453, 0.007716172840446234, 0.021847913041710854, -0.03270367160439491, -0.023430615663528442, 0.02023140713572502, -0.036261167377233505, 0.022710880264639854, -0.04821908846497536, 0.03870787471532822, -0.03421768918633461, 0.011295825242996216, 0.03862311691045761, 0.010085439309477806, 0.007472924888134003, 0.004339365754276514, 0.0026554949581623077, -0.027690213173627853, -0.056721437722444534, 0.0458204485476017, -0.010660606436431408, 0.013027380220592022, 0.03234691545367241, -0.019750012084841728, -0.025384176522493362, -0.032890573143959045, 0.009607679210603237, 0.049563076347112656, -0.003912977408617735, -0.0013376756105571985, 0.05382692441344261, -0.01955699734389782, 0.019344788044691086, 0.011958520859479904, -0.028007574379444122, -0.02164599485695362, 0.019275860860943794, 0.031002072617411613, -0.041084907948970795, -0.02459876611828804, -0.07843798398971558, -0.00032012612791731954, 0.003025087295100093, 0.04982158914208412, -0.09079266339540482, -0.03657015040516853, 0.020528588443994522, -0.029729526489973068, -0.023832138627767563, 0.03344722092151642, 0.03809794411063194, -0.052212946116924286, -0.03030010312795639, 0.0010474183363839984, -0.012930103577673435, 0.04450927674770355, -0.03610847517848015, 0.0616518072783947, 0.08378471434116364, 0.06373337656259537, -0.03330317884683609, -0.015177269466221333, -0.1085013747215271, 0.02986554056406021, -0.028051862493157387, -0.04281902313232422, -0.11167970299720764, 0.05794530734419823, -0.010398458689451218, -0.025950467213988304, 0.01204578299075365, 0.0162876658141613, -0.012601597234606743, -0.012019525282084942, 0.02253394015133381, 0.00994945503771305, -0.04196659103035927, 0.062214579433202744, -0.02620561793446541, -0.03484820947051048, -0.020062783733010292, 0.043407708406448364, -0.007091644685715437, 0.017327258363366127, 0.01894504390656948, -0.05091581121087074, -0.006594703067094088, 0.01596236415207386, -0.044784415513277054, -0.01665758341550827, -0.02167961746454239, -0.022473430261015892, 0.034409377723932266, -0.06410308182239532, -0.03278268501162529, -0.05483756214380264, 0.0117457564920187, 0.021764062345027924, 0.046332523226737976, -0.09303715080022812, -0.04072665050625801, -0.022915471345186234, 0.0006425073952414095, 0.0013503190129995346, 0.015675345435738564, -0.03906874358654022, 0.03300010785460472, 0.01036930363625288, -0.03449820727109909, 0.009928956627845764, -0.027992676943540573, 0.039990104734897614, 0.011431296356022358, -0.0029436589684337378, 0.006619012914597988, 0.06712370365858078, -0.04120367392897606, -0.0018215657910332084, 0.014126070775091648, 0.002975173993036151, 0.026093831285834312, 0.03897744044661522, -0.00517857214435935, 0.029418911784887314, -0.03707863390445709, -0.02120416797697544, 0.030406324192881584, -0.009314307011663914, -0.02091022953391075, 0.019822323694825172, -0.009416190907359123, 0.03465983644127846, 0.0004188125312794, -0.04049542546272278, 0.025015883147716522, -0.048546355217695236, -0.0048424373380839825, 0.028635283932089806, -0.007133397739380598, -0.011747959069907665, 0.029083237051963806, 0.022446051239967346, 0.05461963266134262, -0.02838132157921791, 0.0518403984606266, -0.006797925569117069, 0.02694213204085827, 0.02493777871131897, -0.06487013399600983, 0.020379357039928436, -0.045557472854852676, -0.008400448597967625, 0.08603231608867645, 0.06560514867305756, -0.025958867743611336, -0.0042906226590275764, -0.04373492673039436, 0.02642209269106388, 0.019985750317573547, -0.0046662515960633755, -0.006065033376216888, -0.011983341537415981, 0.016026316210627556, -0.016824841499328613, -0.00985867902636528, 0.028978701680898666, -0.0011730920523405075, -0.014962551183998585, 0.013245989568531513, -0.03595748543739319, 0.03193560615181923, 0.021432042121887207, -0.0438477098941803, 0.034898966550827026, -0.07080857455730438, -0.00019811485253740102, -0.08177009969949722, 0.03429461643099785, -0.02140265516936779, -0.033921509981155396, -0.06974182277917862, -0.024915236979722977, -0.06055294722318649, -0.050396062433719635, 0.03365987911820412, 0.027252044528722763, -0.03467442840337753, 0.014468838460743427, -0.036385491490364075, 0.0055818818509578705, 0.03172875940799713, -0.0172438845038414, 0.013423508033156395, -0.049452826380729675, 0.03399563208222389, -0.04321460798382759, -0.03778436407446861, -0.08654771000146866, -0.06135592609643936, -0.009649028070271015, 0.010749641805887222, -0.00921227689832449, -0.06598884612321854, -0.005997586529701948, 0.007711282465606928, -0.018536219373345375, -0.024737751111388206, -0.03862018883228302, -0.07965511083602905, -0.01599491946399212, -0.052729588001966476, -0.03478908911347389, 0.03820577263832092, -0.02808736450970173, 0.04536987841129303, -0.012805524282157421, 0.025430336594581604, -0.008879144676029682, 0.02617381513118744, -0.02451716549694538, -0.025921819731593132, -0.028673620894551277, -0.022357948124408722, -0.041297439485788345, -0.002336883684620261, -0.04354282468557358, 0.010116059333086014, -0.010815833695232868, 0.03270088508725166, 0.029332909733057022, 0.03836952894926071, -0.03695710748434067, -0.08475351333618164, 0.02779328264296055, 0.04403386637568474, -0.031113555654883385, -0.007208938244730234, -0.020555997267365456, -0.015271336771547794, 0.007690124679356813, 0.023374853655695915, -0.0028127122204750776, -0.02280977927148342, 0.002066439250484109, -0.013585537672042847, 0.009708731435239315, -0.012170561589300632, 0.006650740280747414, 0.02055894210934639, 0.042203545570373535, 0.05655398219823837, 0.034972451627254486, 0.026615820825099945, 0.030747873708605766, -0.012905155308544636, 0.011013928800821304, -0.05160374566912651, -0.03717593848705292, 0.049453459680080414, -0.007367144804447889, -0.010698423720896244, -0.01834573596715927, 0.02728043869137764, 0.014558372087776661, -0.009297510609030724, 0.05638999491930008, -0.022429343312978745, -0.006615240592509508, -0.03710506483912468, 0.02044382132589817, 0.03403013199567795, 0.025441443547606468, 0.015390079468488693, 0.02572368085384369, -0.009238434955477715, 0.11163555085659027, 0.003279290394857526, 0.03403684124350548, -0.05296484753489494, 0.0358954593539238, -0.043318938463926315, 0.03769759461283684, -0.0111196618527174, 0.04786048084497452, 0.0648246556520462, -0.03755806386470795, -0.03721659630537033, 0.004221103619784117, 0.017613230273127556, 0.009866652078926563, 0.013633519411087036, -0.07419779151678085, 0.037262674421072006, -0.008044935762882233, -0.0311911478638649, -0.036385949701070786, 0.0021697888150811195, 0.009452719241380692, 0.014104497618973255, -0.07365500181913376, -0.027318498119711876, -0.004787391982972622, -0.06004376336932182, -0.07135485857725143, -0.009463358670473099, 0.010676804929971695, 0.00698158098384738, 0.010613921098411083, -0.05532664433121681, -0.0334419384598732, -0.03605371713638306, 0.03966992348432541, -0.04768355190753937, 0.024397652596235275, -0.014534047804772854, -0.012646930292248726, -0.03924311697483063, 0.02521633356809616, 0.055618733167648315, -0.045699819922447205, -0.05410356819629669, 0.043406106531620026, -0.02572941593825817, -0.05217701941728592, -0.021425053477287292, -0.028788933530449867, -0.08588667213916779, 0.03427407518029213, 0.017321418970823288, -0.041953086853027344, 0.0276199858635664, -0.012265153229236603, -0.00726888794451952, -0.0034295457880944014, 0.033011507242918015, 0.014614525251090527, 0.0066976966336369514, 0.008382419124245644, -0.05205454304814339, 0.03570987656712532, 0.03585782274603844, 0.0007771558593958616, -0.005890110041946173, 0.05520975962281227, 0.030014188960194588, -0.01447149645537138, 0.04105029255151749, 0.03307190537452698, 0.03813664987683296, 0.032542675733566284, -0.011361495591700077, 0.015330983325839043, -0.012893610633909702, -0.023037897422909737, -0.01664714328944683, -0.04016229882836342, 0.07806792855262756, -0.02198798395693302, -0.00794587004929781, 0.0423942469060421, -0.057523421943187714, -0.014443159103393555, -0.07227527350187302, -0.0369788333773613, -0.0008235286804847419, 0.005361403338611126, -0.03346531093120575, -0.00042152448440901935, -0.0008407268906012177, -0.03183940798044205, -0.010704063810408115, -0.04729222506284714, 0.004837466403841972, -0.027532797306776047, -0.036078378558158875, -0.008803589269518852, -0.017271487042307854, 0.0038619358092546463, -0.06502538919448853, 0.03283999115228653, 0.0002158966235583648, 0.007116852793842554, -0.08977284282445908, -0.002056701807305217, -0.008621171116828918, 0.007563088554888964, 0.0008783431258052588, 0.04028705507516861, 0.0014955953229218721, 0.04123861342668533, 0.009644703008234501, 0.0038443366065621376, 0.021006861701607704, 0.025570912286639214, -0.025945566594600677, -0.01119570154696703, 0.02612178586423397, -0.026601780205965042, 0.09279005974531174, -0.02378707192838192, 0.00893195066601038, 0.07159584760665894, 0.018247634172439575, -0.035339269787073135, -0.020198604092001915, -0.009127115830779076, 0.03990112617611885, -0.06175806745886803, 0.03686341270804405, 0.04580036178231239, -0.026678701862692833, 0.027205947786569595, -0.00876870658248663, -0.009488343261182308, 0.017203811556100845, 0.05212289094924927, 0.002043486572802067, 0.0012543711345642805, 0.008552517741918564, 0.006391751114279032, 0.01614009588956833, -0.041709497570991516, 0.057867374271154404, -0.04309188947081566, 0.006898956373333931, 0.005256365053355694, 0.04593627527356148, 0.10996225476264954, -0.013903851620852947, -0.00863939430564642, -0.017740299925208092, -0.0573556162416935, 0.037608079612255096, -0.0347774364054203, -0.02043253742158413, 0.027971521019935608, 0.01592559926211834, -0.0014718164457008243, -0.06695977598428726, -0.06432348489761353, -0.007627321872860193, 0.0103608388453722, -0.023257851600646973, -0.027496490627527237, 0.013154334388673306, -0.03035694546997547, -0.02198593132197857, 0.05580247566103935, 0.0655689537525177, -0.04521004483103752, -0.010839331895112991, 0.03218332678079605, -0.032088372856378555, -0.01795482635498047, -0.0065222433768212795, 0.02583373337984085, 0.017113860696554184, 0.018349453806877136, 0.0003792682255152613, 0.04728786647319794, 0.001436020596884191, -0.033685870468616486, 0.006043520290404558, -0.0031606117263436317, 0.001446823705919087, 0.029656782746315002, -0.003970347344875336, 0.004339153878390789, -0.05716995149850845, 0.026814358308911324, 0.010721265338361263, -0.021819088608026505, 0.0030422848649322987, 0.01898369751870632, 0.014374629594385624, -0.017430413514375687, 0.04794742166996002, 0.04903649911284447, -0.003906017169356346, 0.05845089629292488, 0.010094758123159409, 0.06897362321615219, -0.015662696212530136, 0.03775777667760849, -0.0013773419195786119, -0.012245038524270058, 0.0018700503278523684, 0.06358632445335388, -0.014789690263569355, -0.0015965206548571587, -0.018536781892180443, -0.015706051141023636, 0.031311485916376114, -0.001403189031407237, 0.08804044872522354, -0.020428234711289406, -0.0033721309155225754, 0.09859926998615265, 0.006547941826283932, -0.03621264174580574, -0.02457500994205475, 0.07013281434774399, -0.06305903941392899, -0.02968159317970276, 0.02326885052025318, 0.010765321552753448, 0.015726327896118164, 0.07353535294532776, -0.005141892470419407, 0.028114039450883865, -0.011278986930847168, -0.01544644869863987, 0.047445639967918396, 0.029813043773174286, -0.019541161134839058, -0.04997682943940163, -0.03984369337558746, 0.017855515703558922, 0.038850586861371994, -0.041340891271829605, -0.04200497269630432, -0.025564810261130333, 0.05751120299100876, 0.006564402021467686, -0.029888123273849487, 0.003028855426236987, 0.020273860543966293 ]
<p>You can find the symbol of love, the heart, by looking at the motion of a charged particle that's emitted from a hot wire in a specific electromagnetic field. The electric field is directed radially from the wire and has strength $1V/m$ everywhere. The magnetic field $B=1T$ is parallel with the wire axis. If the charged particle has a very small radial velocity with absolutely no velocity parallel to the wire direction when it escapes the wire, find how long the total length it has to travel to come back to the wire in meters?</p> <p>If you plot the orbit of the particle you'll find that it looks like a heart!</p> <p>Neglect the size of the wire. The electric charge of the particle is $1C$ and the mass is $1kg$.</p> <p>I am stuck on how to analyze the motion of the object.</p>
g5919
[ 0.03784674033522606, 0.07148882001638412, -0.02215312048792839, -0.03472874313592911, 0.03580518811941147, 0.012857316061854362, 0.022018348798155785, -0.009673108346760273, -0.015042925253510475, -0.012857581488788128, -0.021084226667881012, 0.07146532833576202, 0.015823185443878174, -0.00255553494207561, -0.007100517395883799, -0.00043208483839407563, 0.03399442508816719, -0.000502323149703443, 0.01756272092461586, 0.04027196764945984, 0.09718313813209534, 0.038026224821805954, 0.02848219685256481, -0.005372363608330488, 0.029538435861468315, 0.004547411110252142, 0.01486412063241005, -0.00827333889901638, -0.050413910299539566, -0.005300894379615784, -0.014478582888841629, -0.009023124352097511, 0.030965188518166542, -0.031438346952199936, -0.033222176134586334, -0.04550177603960037, -0.01798134855926037, 0.05358082801103592, 0.006700490601360798, 0.03414774686098099, -0.0034579166676849127, -0.06598138064146042, 0.03773735091090202, 0.01635783165693283, 0.062164269387722015, -0.04950738325715065, -0.0025495495647192, 0.02688254788517952, 0.018465708941221237, 0.036959532648324966, -0.05908164009451866, 0.05104946717619896, 0.05016111582517624, -0.0039380453526973724, 0.0024087775964289904, 0.05358293652534485, 0.027604885399341583, 0.002607609611004591, 0.05888136103749275, 0.029542667791247368, 0.01616065204143524, 0.03703945130109787, -0.007318120449781418, -0.01207477506250143, 0.041215680539608, -0.0221135001629591, -0.04730810597538948, -0.02698727510869503, -0.019697129726409912, 0.031561341136693954, 0.005857894662767649, -0.06045456975698471, -0.021261446177959442, -0.00020081180264241993, -0.08302248269319534, -0.01409661490470171, -0.0486815981566906, -0.030113864690065384, 0.03841470181941986, -0.013958573341369629, -0.01775520108640194, -0.02970733866095543, -0.0007634132634848356, -0.006668971851468086, 0.04906053468585014, -0.00167555408552289, -0.0067979199811816216, -0.026016321033239365, 0.01963968388736248, -0.014415869489312172, 0.021942537277936935, 0.01696157641708851, 0.08533316850662231, -0.012891419231891632, 0.021814558655023575, -0.07554564625024796, -0.04237084835767746, 0.05444062128663063, -0.0026686403434723616, -0.019232207909226418, -0.05771581083536148, -0.03137650713324547, -0.09215159714221954, -0.0015959817683324218, 0.023678870871663094, -0.011825738474726677, 0.01976366527378559, 0.018969109281897545, -0.020396128296852112, -0.017455441877245903, -0.001521370722912252, -0.10171134769916534, -0.02260083518922329, -0.03474663197994232, -0.051670923829078674, -0.02949986793100834, 0.02142956666648388, 0.001841353252530098, -0.03861243277788162, 0.05112630873918533, 0.005867027677595615, -0.00432992447167635, 0.0004079751088283956, 0.06418754905462265, -0.03852854296565056, 0.016200197860598564, 0.01512146182358265, 0.013488625176250935, -0.01742992363870144, -0.0012267886195331812, 0.03169762343168259, 0.030272025614976883, 0.05327015370130539, -0.0057890936732292175, -0.056963760405778885, -0.0001444275985704735, -0.017103776335716248, 0.013544580899178982, -0.03617767617106438, 0.019660547375679016, 0.017894750460982323, -0.08479088544845581, 0.03837360441684723, -0.05016234144568443, -0.08011654019355774, 0.03794759884476662, 0.029940137639641762, -0.05751190707087517, 0.025680312886834145, 0.002800330752506852, 0.016231881454586983, 0.11330655217170715, -0.010749544017016888, -0.01988084241747856, -0.023026445880532265, -0.038508880883455276, 0.05696268379688263, 0.062095072120428085, 0.005104695446789265, -0.03801026940345764, 0.04631006345152855, 0.00803455151617527, 0.02088095061480999, -0.002932144794613123, -0.03036271035671234, -0.006148401647806168, 0.023414427414536476, -0.02865595370531082, 0.02948926016688347, -0.06569847464561462, -0.04947932809591293, -0.07076096534729004, -0.0068788109347224236, 0.060298942029476166, -0.020493535324931145, 0.01339474692940712, -0.030062951147556305, -0.035566546022892, -0.010309936478734016, 0.021055806428194046, 0.023318573832511902, -0.058415379375219345, 0.09438110888004303, -0.013961237855255604, -0.04176042973995209, 0.003119177184998989, 0.00025491774431429803, 0.035931818187236786, -0.0560891218483448, 0.004797760862857103, -0.0022702589631080627, -0.025074684992432594, -0.02043297328054905, 0.02418890781700611, 0.012096497230231762, -0.030284622684121132, -0.04397675395011902, 0.02315409854054451, -0.013349362649023533, 0.008870149031281471, 0.047369249165058136, 0.03680803254246712, 0.017074167728424072, 0.038215186446905136, -0.013242417946457863, -0.08140094578266144, -0.016746381297707558, 0.008925084955990314, 0.0006783045246265829, 0.02700115740299225, 0.06015152856707573, 0.0062440731562674046, -0.035011276602745056, 0.03126949071884155, -0.04670735448598862, 0.00822184607386589, 0.006246109027415514, -0.030875207856297493, -0.010002704337239265, -0.015846235677599907, -0.04515063017606735, -0.04406522214412689, 0.07407496869564056, -0.10738707333803177, -0.03677060827612877, 0.041671011596918106, -0.01693476177752018, -0.0017525767907500267, 0.016094405204057693, 0.024363787844777107, -0.06532099097967148, 0.061598919332027435, 0.01764705963432789, -0.006174024194478989, 0.02341621369123459, 0.00534551776945591, -0.02706300839781761, 0.010789455845952034, -0.06551621109247208, 0.01950622908771038, 0.008630124852061272, 0.032736413180828094, -0.012252292595803738, -0.01873287931084633, 0.05796081945300102, -0.011601626873016357, 0.03962881118059158, 0.04681098833680153, -0.03807387501001358, 0.022446924820542336, 0.07275118678808212, 0.009712403640151024, -0.00020754071010742337, 0.000012952110409969464, 0.030197983607649803, -0.02923186682164669, -0.06191958487033844, 0.03763630613684654, -0.05783778801560402, -0.039191748946905136, -0.012281108647584915, -0.008704636245965958, 0.020784184336662292, 0.030743220821022987, -0.041366878896951675, -0.05399047210812569, -0.02455037459731102, 0.007324923761188984, 0.03600303456187248, -0.029870063066482544, -0.05005835369229317, 0.022452794015407562, 0.03358364850282669, -0.00016712585056666285, 0.021886348724365234, -0.04564078524708748, 0.05453922227025032, -0.005769411101937294, -0.01704595796763897, 0.008455045521259308, -0.0011295886943116784, 0.020586466416716576, -0.0345180407166481, 0.0028134200256317854, -0.013129227794706821, -0.05104478821158409, -0.011525791138410568, 0.055235106498003006, -0.005560270510613918, -0.03486328944563866, -0.0058027105405926704, 0.035798028111457825, -0.0145115340128541, -0.01957588829100132, -0.032558247447013855, 0.06835579127073288, 0.043391842395067215, 0.03578510880470276, -0.007333145942538977, 0.006443265825510025, 0.0392010360956192, 0.0008561480790376663, -0.02711118943989277, 0.019424721598625183, -0.007121049799025059, 0.03477083891630173, -0.05786542966961861, -0.05970500782132149, 0.01632295735180378, -0.02102218195796013, 0.05317771062254906, 0.015436136163771152, 0.02423313446342945, -0.050331007689237595, 0.0034018310252577066, 0.00931138638406992, -0.05309015512466431, -0.008911936543881893, 0.05688711628317833, 0.08615971356630325, 0.010150276124477386, -0.07707078009843826, 0.038422878831624985, -0.02817290835082531, 0.06821863353252411, -0.0427292138338089, -0.028949430212378502, 0.022844165563583374, -0.017932945862412453, -0.04875299334526062, -0.06353840231895447, -0.04395987465977669, -0.0196223147213459, 0.0016989486757665873, -0.028447432443499565, -0.030869847163558006, -0.003959071822464466, 0.0037098699249327183, 0.017062261700630188, -0.002168581821024418, -0.02044989913702011, -0.007316214498132467, -0.05200972408056259, -0.01670202426612377, 0.012109672650694847, 0.03300320729613304, -0.018753191456198692, 0.006169140338897705, 0.04414474591612816, -0.04799995943903923, -0.0014157877303659916, -0.011422736570239067, 0.02019670233130455, -0.031216314062476158, -0.013876454904675484, -0.005575854796916246, 0.03537262976169586, -0.026292691007256508, -0.015021211467683315, -0.06981600075960159, -0.055758919566869736, 0.010599766857922077, 0.01410877425223589, 0.015553451143205166, 0.005243393592536449, -0.011841770261526108, 0.016715772449970245, 0.02935182675719261, 0.01287349034100771, -0.07374192774295807, -0.03191195800900459, -0.014031424187123775, -0.013522869907319546, 0.034912433475255966, 0.006308277603238821, -0.013795986771583557, 0.0047888485714793205, -0.033047739416360855, 0.007178875617682934, 0.027485206723213196, -0.011971811763942242, 0.02145693078637123, 0.010648779571056366, -0.02013259567320347, 0.0382644459605217, -0.018865058198571205, -0.02191203273832798, -0.015593980439007282, -0.00951699260622263, -0.04470806568861008, 0.030806099995970726, -0.07577256113290787, -0.033362261950969696, -0.012750919908285141, 0.02401653863489628, -0.07107602059841156, 0.06521528214216232, -0.008856762200593948, -0.021968435496091843, -0.03472289815545082, 0.021393608301877975, -0.00045208894880488515, -0.012496767565608025, -0.02009219489991665, -0.006146605126559734, 0.011204201728105545, 0.0035402027424424887, -0.02760222926735878, 0.031292736530303955, 0.015033877454698086, 0.0009814808145165443, 0.03243642300367355, 0.09386532753705978, -0.09955690801143646, 0.037515364587306976, 0.0021526028867810965, 0.0007129888981580734, 0.011752763763070107, 0.056883033365011215, -0.028917420655488968, 0.005885058082640171, 0.011253412812948227, 0.05626993253827095, -0.06659114360809326, -0.07789318263530731, 0.06338103860616684, 0.06732772290706635, 0.05939209833741188, -0.004583288915455341, -0.014790849760174751, -0.01647012308239937, 0.019701719284057617, -0.036660365760326385, 0.010037937201559544, -0.07587175071239471, 0.06060626730322838, 0.011610102839767933, 0.03784340247511864, -0.03274140879511833, 0.05938538908958435, 0.046058572828769684, -0.003692205296829343, 0.012261572293937206, -0.011918576434254646, -0.010221211239695549, 0.01839590258896351, 0.011648565530776978, -0.05554139241576195, -0.09053593873977661, -0.03337586671113968, 0.0038844121154397726, 0.03707156330347061, -0.025518015027046204, 0.047527000308036804, -0.006960258819162846, -0.0007908703410066664, -0.05422370135784149, 0.003532195230945945, 0.015547564253211021, 0.055715784430503845, -0.04706280305981636, 0.018167415633797646, -0.02139497920870781, 0.04464747756719589, 0.013106092810630798, -0.03540484979748726, 0.007440940011292696, 0.002533258870244026, 0.016676854342222214, 0.03977350518107414, -0.018283598124980927, 0.08561912178993225, 0.052391260862350464, -0.0692453533411026, 0.004799137823283672, -0.003390137106180191, -0.032229211181402206, 0.03487774357199669, 0.009407244622707367, 0.011081312783062458, -0.04610731825232506, 0.005765414331108332, -0.041890546679496765, 0.01681504026055336, 0.016802111640572548, 0.018718648701906204, -0.020299311727285385, 0.05007890611886978, -0.015346494503319263, 0.0030461293645203114, 0.0005129939527250826, 0.02660011500120163, 0.06076943501830101, -0.0135126281529665, 0.02601669356226921, -0.06408084183931351, 0.04328617826104164, -0.01342899538576603, 0.01813695766031742, -0.019991334527730942, -0.036520540714263916, -0.01753024011850357, -0.06969942897558212, 0.036944709718227386, -0.02616731822490692, 0.019429046660661697, -0.0036469053011387587, -0.013217456638813019, 0.024660080671310425, 0.0233246348798275, -0.027459094300866127, 0.03424420207738876, 0.02490180917084217, -0.006595781072974205, -0.05362209305167198, -0.021777566522359848, -0.012585286982357502, 0.0522976890206337, 0.036758843809366226, 0.030199797824025154, 0.03583649545907974, -0.004052953794598579, 0.053697433322668076, -0.03760221600532532, 0.06163365766406059, -0.02235841006040573, -0.0193044263869524, -0.020625775679945946, 0.058169443160295486, 0.007822223007678986, 0.013186200521886349, -0.03027014061808586, -0.044062864035367966, 0.013215377926826477, -0.022366369143128395, -0.031035395339131355, 0.04060417041182518, -0.017865771427750587, 0.01984570361673832, -0.01299184001982212, 0.009645869955420494, -0.025197094306349754, 0.012186725623905659, 0.013834766112267971, -0.018613843247294426, 0.01217622123658657, 0.01777874492108822, 0.01892649009823799, 0.009683908894658089, -0.021544266492128372, -0.02113516628742218, 0.040896233171224594, -0.0034481112379580736, 0.03250820189714432, 0.03227667883038521, -0.0026389029808342457, 0.002923291875049472, -0.05060368403792381, 0.004789772443473339, 0.008476669900119305, -0.016101067885756493, 0.014826703816652298, 0.07418348640203476, 0.0329345166683197, 0.06853768229484558, -0.060679566115140915, -0.04098198935389519, -0.020005911588668823, 0.08388449996709824, 0.027007095515727997, -0.03397106006741524, -0.004978065378963947, -0.050868403166532516, 0.023406272754073143, 0.060084015130996704, 0.0023164001759141684, -0.004587450996041298, 0.014212782494723797, -0.05594702810049057, 0.0005161891458556056, 0.004517795983701944, 0.041564151644706726, 0.04311142489314079, -0.049446940422058105, -0.026588886976242065, 0.01303415559232235, -0.042187415063381195, 0.0034085519146174192, 0.0030599322635680437, 0.018913479521870613, 0.0272558331489563, -0.0076344613917171955, -0.02165324054658413, -0.006337001919746399, -0.036764729768037796, -0.04283641651272774, -0.04792344197630882, -0.04092240706086159, -0.028047412633895874, 0.09363254904747009, -0.004778841510415077, -0.015736402943730354, -0.03594043105840683, -0.01642114669084549, 0.020669199526309967, 0.04452819377183914, 0.004570414312183857, 0.00022611560416407883, -0.011061043478548527, -0.03777473792433739, 0.019393090158700943, 0.006556351203471422, -0.043763674795627594, 0.028505835682153702, 0.03167243301868439, 0.012777023948729038, 0.009342317469418049, -0.017401471734046936, 0.0005444558337330818, -0.003525911597535014, -0.03259241208434105, 0.021141817793250084, -0.044075723737478256, -0.02368839457631111, 0.0198819600045681, 0.02025509625673294, -0.030750419944524765, -0.008576318621635437, -0.01457162480801344, -0.009980598464608192, -0.0038054101169109344, 0.032233815640211105, -0.03848319873213768, 0.05416738986968994, 0.07852240651845932, 0.05401576682925224, 0.04501126706600189, 0.07047120481729507, 0.03831115737557411, 0.06127699092030525, 0.044124580919742584, 0.024787412956357002, -0.003309677354991436, -0.0005076627130620182, -0.06001492962241173, -0.0451737679541111, 0.029150214046239853, 0.06526308506727219, -0.03207709267735481, 0.0019462418276816607, -0.014823487028479576, 0.06274005770683289, 0.010581527836620808, 0.016184279695153236, -0.01745525188744068, -0.01162198930978775, 0.027257781475782394, -0.002280759159475565, -0.004545676987618208, -0.09950878471136093, -0.04325298219919205, 0.03254523128271103, 0.0019435373833402991, -0.04225287586450577, 0.04176889732480049, 0.04560583457350731, -0.001630045473575592, -0.0432346910238266, -0.002081298967823386, -0.04495184123516083, 0.0055504594929516315, 0.03327876701951027, 0.004318400286138058, 0.06337922811508179, 0.03088466078042984, -0.0009956465801224113, -0.013915685005486012, -0.015959259122610092, -0.024818718433380127, -0.001555075985379517, -0.04054657369852066, 0.04542655870318413, -0.025788206607103348, 0.01784110814332962, 0.044102735817432404, -0.014658807776868343, -0.06087062507867813, 0.00613586837425828, -0.021078836172819138, 0.03691393509507179, -0.017703458666801453, 0.07546845078468323, 0.012633051723241806, -0.04727543145418167, -0.0018829773180186749, 0.045622412115335464, -0.0024361619725823402, 0.05056479945778847, 0.06234339624643326, -0.0036554564721882343, -0.005921567790210247, 0.021498531103134155, 0.06152457371354103, 0.012733230367302895, -0.009878421202301979, -0.004242768511176109, -0.03409115597605705, -0.036161042749881744, -0.052454620599746704, 0.026338042691349983, -0.013158528134226799, 0.06857520341873169, -0.002828284166753292, -0.004441172815859318, 0.06635022908449173, 0.044114064425230026, -0.0028661927208304405, 0.057730939239263535, 0.006278119049966335, -0.02329864352941513, -0.03055248223245144, -0.03229112923145294, 0.01090271957218647, -0.08102302998304367, -0.006483517587184906, -0.03440551087260246, -0.01868480071425438, 0.03999626636505127, -0.0010700245620682836, -0.044590238481760025, -0.0005881571560166776, -0.032145507633686066, -0.04022675007581711, -0.00887466873973608, -0.06718893349170685, 0.00047665441525168717, -0.04158308729529381, -0.07047756761312485, -0.01272798515856266, 0.007549057714641094, 0.023367712274193764, -0.04438895732164383, -0.03630472347140312, -0.011381431482732296, 0.008001327514648438, 0.02532101422548294, -0.06367801874876022, 0.08760276436805725, 0.08618372678756714, 0.019244858995079994, 0.032879538834095, 0.03683777153491974, -0.023870589211583138, 0.005911880638450384, 0.011962668038904667, 0.01672733761370182, 0.021618638187646866, 0.02486668899655342, -0.03688544034957886, -0.05342579260468483, -0.002483607269823551, -0.06474857777357101, -0.020713375881314278, 0.011518942192196846, 0.02650252729654312, -0.033977385610342026, -0.017612874507904053, 0.03512579947710037 ]
<p>Can anyone give me a quantum mechanical explanation of the theory of valence? (i.e. why atoms bond just enough to have a complete orbital)</p> <p>EDIT: To clarify, I already have an idea of why atoms bond, and the molecular orbit makes sense to me. The problem is that the valence bond theory provides a simple and fairly accurate description for when a molecule is stable. To make this more concrete: why is CH_4 more stable than CH_3 or CH_5. Looking up the former on wikipedia, I see a better way of phrasing the question might be: why are free radicals reactive? (Should I change the title?)</p>
g5920
[ 0.024255290627479553, 0.040296655148267746, -0.02220207266509533, 0.008022261783480644, 0.03325023129582405, 0.033403899520635605, -0.044133614748716354, 0.016426434740424156, 0.011261542327702045, -0.022376567125320435, -0.015232197940349579, -0.0055663082748651505, -0.004574824124574661, -0.033745475113391876, 0.011497347615659237, 0.015533508732914925, -0.017761630937457085, 0.04805207997560501, 0.06955403834581375, -0.024488765746355057, -0.030739009380340576, -0.03651101142168045, -0.06621965020895004, -0.00371799455024302, -0.04929788410663605, 0.013390609063208103, 0.039135970175266266, -0.01673228107392788, -0.000833544007036835, 0.0036279279738664627, 0.012738199904561043, 0.046540290117263794, 0.06842309236526489, -0.031943537294864655, 0.018443364650011063, -0.02477223239839077, 0.022607482969760895, -0.0006342637934722006, -0.006670594681054354, 0.011110342107713223, 0.008407020941376686, -0.02766525000333786, 0.018514515832066536, -0.004267162177711725, 0.006696063093841076, -0.048820748925209045, -0.015006935223937035, 0.005713465623557568, 0.04669202119112015, -0.03766544535756111, -0.03712962195277214, 0.02371031604707241, 0.01593613810837269, -0.028684044256806374, 0.016145901754498482, 0.007127359975129366, 0.01657453179359436, 0.06727677583694458, -0.007486118469387293, 0.006510321516543627, -0.01773500256240368, 0.03730901703238487, 0.04335979372262955, 0.02135826274752617, 0.05256527289748192, -0.062166713178157806, -0.03472822532057762, 0.010190284810960293, 0.04539327695965767, 0.022487327456474304, -0.02094942145049572, -0.06770751625299454, -0.007590836845338345, 0.00950819905847311, 0.047323860228061676, -0.006684604100883007, -0.024837778881192207, -0.01696939952671528, 0.05011088401079178, -0.03076750971376896, 0.0015089274384081364, -0.023374177515506744, 0.028134653344750404, -0.00171819853130728, 0.026989007368683815, -0.0534072145819664, -0.028649473562836647, -0.05741651728749275, -0.04502851143479347, -0.003073201747611165, 0.058869700878858566, -0.020260628312826157, 0.03782808408141136, -0.0012305654818192124, 0.013063240796327591, 0.00794259924441576, 0.008080425672233105, 0.03687707334756851, 0.006674064788967371, -0.05118871107697487, -0.03388689458370209, -0.00903050135821104, 0.0443052276968956, 0.010706261731684208, 0.042889922857284546, -0.046494822949171066, 0.017413616180419922, 0.040513619780540466, 0.015545514412224293, 0.007136106491088867, 0.02540569007396698, 0.047839462757110596, -0.018652645871043205, -0.0266372449696064, 0.034516505897045135, 0.04063403606414795, 0.0894787535071373, -0.0398506261408329, 0.007241939660161734, 0.026207834482192993, 0.0001077750712283887, 0.06506288796663284, 0.007001684047281742, -0.0005811474402435124, -0.004479822237044573, -0.03548625856637955, 0.03541289269924164, -0.01867210678756237, 0.029400385916233063, -0.011650463566184044, -0.0056703765876591206, -0.02936961129307747, -0.04706137627363205, 0.013261130079627037, 0.042904920876026154, -0.001464777858927846, -0.06869190186262131, -0.00008061253174673766, 0.007173680700361729, -0.03257308155298233, 0.03421361744403839, 0.02969735488295555, -0.0014806132530793548, -0.023269932717084885, -0.06745369732379913, -0.012922335416078568, 0.021672356873750687, 0.021136164665222168, 0.0200544074177742, -0.023674560710787773, 0.00225313869304955, -0.014566123485565186, -0.004656107164919376, -0.07830344885587692, 0.022841693833470345, -0.04571644216775894, 0.01126263476908207, -0.00014543438737746328, -0.03490288183093071, 0.051888976246118546, 0.06769311428070068, -0.017288511618971825, -0.06128406524658203, 0.01310244482010603, -0.02885068953037262, 0.03705514967441559, -0.028994951397180557, -0.08081308752298355, -0.06291235238313675, -0.0029117660596966743, 0.02105189673602581, -0.04154098033905029, -0.03549794852733612, 0.0657401755452156, 0.007246054243296385, 0.04369046911597252, 0.03539622947573662, -0.0010293489322066307, 0.05298687890172005, 0.03414928540587425, 0.00664621451869607, -0.03899378329515457, 0.021873319521546364, -0.01965298317372799, -0.03260637819766998, -0.00912199541926384, 0.023619892075657845, 0.00304706790484488, -0.056078482419252396, 0.02207236923277378, 0.03675214201211929, -0.005837158299982548, 0.017603721469640732, -0.010074591264128685, 0.014154035598039627, -0.007197802420705557, -0.031100543215870857, -0.012893171049654484, -0.005043471232056618, -0.01811540313065052, -0.056550532579422, -0.05284787341952324, 0.0169240590184927, 0.03484559431672096, -0.026941101998090744, 0.0199600700289011, 0.014132601208984852, -0.02798568829894066, 0.06618399173021317, 0.0038172483909875154, -0.017826685681939125, 0.06837330013513565, 0.060036856681108475, 0.0523676835000515, 0.006495549809187651, -0.006491548847407103, 0.030860304832458496, 0.02131752111017704, -0.014715530909597874, 0.03195880725979805, 0.034225013107061386, -0.006960803642868996, 0.0045213415287435055, 0.07860186696052551, -0.002248254371806979, 0.050326742231845856, 0.013361104764044285, -0.00044048085692338645, -0.020113090053200722, 0.0020898813381791115, -0.0286212507635355, 0.00814670231193304, -0.049356505274772644, 0.04208950698375702, 0.011003379710018635, 0.04525662213563919, 0.0108585674315691, -0.00124685640912503, 0.00253659812733531, 0.03085467778146267, 0.00681255804374814, 0.03208614140748978, -0.057247430086135864, 0.009696443565189838, 0.014945762231945992, -0.08470094949007034, 0.036347974091768265, -0.04593568667769432, -0.07124383002519608, -0.012514419853687286, 0.007277792319655418, -0.01565174199640751, -0.016471799463033676, -0.007722513284534216, -0.03947719931602478, -0.021459972485899925, -0.055321548134088516, 0.059150777757167816, 0.000019475410226732492, -0.03243516385555267, -0.00022282770078163594, -0.06003177538514137, 0.02174643613398075, -0.0010162867838516831, -0.08147323131561279, -0.01692645251750946, 0.03561091423034668, -0.024806197732686996, 0.020153621211647987, -0.004858503583818674, -0.06934554874897003, 0.10089753568172455, -0.01668448932468891, 0.040631409734487534, -0.033415451645851135, -0.06062442436814308, -0.029570801183581352, -0.01106257550418377, -0.019264455884695053, 0.012513109482824802, 0.03209336847066879, 0.03421621769666672, -0.054035112261772156, 0.02278415486216545, 0.06922747939825058, -0.009707947261631489, -0.0020755219738930464, 0.05164148285984993, 0.10626288503408432, -0.026949845254421234, -0.00501472782343626, 0.03656001761555672, -0.024688202887773514, 0.05303619056940079, -0.01589805632829666, -0.06118721514940262, 0.03708174452185631, -0.010090101510286331, -0.0007279796991497278, 0.02034248411655426, -0.05202334001660347, 0.04419815167784691, -0.012482411228120327, 0.05108178034424782, 0.01762876659631729, 0.01705991104245186, -0.036735981702804565, -0.0017614689422771335, -0.04078526422381401, 0.017054874449968338, -0.06427990645170212, -0.013142863288521767, -0.0663989931344986, -0.007149857934564352, -0.03548327460885048, -0.0031577255576848984, -0.07692687958478928, 0.031193513423204422, 0.03102077916264534, -0.03748762607574463, -0.047720104455947876, -0.029508279636502266, -0.025896327570080757, -0.03635036200284958, 0.04370279982686043, 0.03768262639641762, -0.05762041360139847, -0.06983185559511185, 0.013192207552492619, -0.02344268001616001, 0.0671016052365303, 0.04078099876642227, 0.02482054941356182, 0.011648239567875862, -0.005232738796621561, -0.026397403329610825, -0.023034824058413506, -0.0004444392689038068, 0.021325793117284775, -0.07305209338665009, 0.00414261082187295, -0.027680661529302597, -0.05738450214266777, -0.029810121282935143, 0.02375863306224346, 0.006435522809624672, -0.07756359875202179, 0.0016918020555749536, 0.021734638139605522, -0.047310203313827515, -0.011469810269773006, -0.015336469747126102, -0.02898329310119152, 0.02483706921339035, -0.00036351336166262627, -0.02308613993227482, -0.055074844509363174, -0.00002640897400851827, -0.02473200112581253, 0.009982007555663586, -0.032840143889188766, -0.03333587199449539, 0.022010885179042816, -0.026875218376517296, -0.03364082798361778, -0.00004039837949676439, -0.051168881356716156, 0.019131893292069435, 0.02470199391245842, -0.015699012205004692, -0.06266194581985474, -0.07007952779531479, -0.004955437500029802, -0.03284941613674164, 0.06275900453329086, -0.029324550181627274, -0.027287371456623077, 0.013879903592169285, -0.06857762485742569, 0.022606734186410904, 0.03372545540332794, 0.01150449551641941, 0.026962384581565857, 0.07115162163972855, 0.0130719980224967, 0.011886242777109146, -0.07895820587873459, -0.007850609719753265, -0.04824034497141838, 0.04057685285806656, -0.027123456820845604, -0.0072701843455433846, 0.01653493382036686, 0.004393414128571749, 0.05769319087266922, 0.005133527796715498, -0.034554045647382736, 0.005029771942645311, -0.029057780280709267, 0.02297763153910637, 0.0036137555725872517, -0.015541505999863148, -0.025387372821569443, 0.00532909668982029, 0.05237600952386856, 0.054966434836387634, -0.025353344157338142, 0.003647221950814128, -0.02719797194004059, 0.03999372571706772, 0.02919905260205269, 0.069867342710495, 0.002185507444664836, -0.03706536442041397, -0.015650570392608643, 0.01538899727165699, -0.00869186595082283, -0.04191506654024124, -0.006866794545203447, -0.0063614677637815475, 0.00027673086151480675, 0.052206072956323624, 0.057361308485269547, -0.006192909087985754, 0.026410050690174103, 0.06074051558971405, 0.043714556843042374, 0.006731514818966389, 0.027355356141924858, -0.0356619693338871, 0.07003774493932724, 0.06302138417959213, -0.021765653043985367, -0.01577545702457428, -0.030773505568504333, 0.030266566202044487, 0.004937307443469763, 0.01430930569767952, -0.03244398161768913, 0.034733645617961884, 0.004711152520030737, 0.08420076966285706, -0.025158796459436417, 0.019424449652433395, -0.04490264505147934, -0.011215731501579285, -0.03331255167722702, -0.0180839654058218, 0.037778064608573914, -0.09988689422607422, -0.03133469447493553, 0.0006969636888243258, 0.02626945450901985, 0.027092302218079567, -0.019605720415711403, -0.021787302568554878, -0.0379229411482811, -0.02180619165301323, -0.019837943837046623, 0.0611264742910862, -0.06551364809274673, -0.04843146353960037, 0.05300496891140938, 0.043196581304073334, 0.03326898068189621, 0.015803096815943718, 0.03945597633719444, -0.002767142141237855, -0.10146909207105637, 0.01626417227089405, 0.04261345416307449, 0.004781234543770552, 0.022767893970012665, -0.05142013356089592, 0.04513029009103775, -0.03055223450064659, 0.020075462758541107, -0.010032444261014462, 0.006670935079455376, -0.07378748059272766, 0.0034787317272275686, 0.008294637314975262, -0.0022812089882791042, 0.055976491421461105, 0.022299358621239662, 0.008715215139091015, -0.002472152002155781, -0.006469398271292448, -0.021827636286616325, -0.06670485436916351, 0.01625693030655384, 0.01842440478503704, 0.004412641748785973, -0.012128863483667374, 0.003763319458812475, -0.031428419053554535, 0.022162267938256264, -0.033428844064474106, 0.029615027830004692, -0.0027136593125760555, -0.04003151133656502, 0.002091249916702509, -0.002700614742934704, -0.0377432182431221, -0.014148393645882607, -0.015089319087564945, 0.03763184696435928, -0.062067773193120956, 0.019403623417019844, -0.0449816957116127, -0.026921622455120087, -0.0062903412617743015, -0.006753547582775354, 0.09250358492136002, 0.02200670912861824, -0.015932660549879074, -0.043326836079359055, 0.03367002680897713, -0.0329962894320488, 0.034578509628772736, -0.018246524035930634, 0.04109366238117218, 0.007334885653108358, -0.03300461173057556, 0.02176850475370884, -0.01807844452559948, 0.003580456366762519, -0.0015514252008870244, -0.024934248998761177, 0.0036380579695105553, -0.03182116895914078, -0.052259285002946854, 0.06900773197412491, 0.018747923895716667, -0.03860187530517578, 0.0033157661091536283, -0.06329106539487839, 0.02042390964925289, 0.05068532004952431, 0.022636350244283676, -0.009936124086380005, 0.015467594377696514, -0.05316511169075966, 0.09748196601867676, 0.03074837103486061, -0.011022322811186314, -0.022081930190324783, 0.07724203914403915, -0.0019672024063766003, 0.002176509704440832, -0.0385301299393177, 0.07387087494134903, -0.030536755919456482, -0.08326120674610138, 0.020645665004849434, 0.0893237292766571, -0.02629118412733078, -0.0031231490429490805, -0.011376511305570602, -0.03030538558959961, 0.04876800999045372, 0.020118916407227516, 0.025081928819417953, 0.10084282606840134, 0.06523299217224121, 0.0073912316001951694, -0.031292904168367386, -0.023213740438222885, 0.024153947830200195, 0.024100128561258316, -0.0023717088624835014, -0.03446588292717934, -0.007860823534429073, -0.011803843080997467, -0.01314221229404211, 0.00079687888501212, 0.008970730006694794, -0.029067950323224068, -0.025121893733739853, -0.06321826577186584, 0.03115377202630043, -0.0345359705388546, -0.004594425670802593, -0.07164198160171509, -0.038383156061172485, 0.020504700019955635, 0.027826042845845222, 0.012631046585738659, 0.06058055907487869, 0.030973022803664207, -0.027187570929527283, 0.06571456044912338, -0.001010095584206283, 0.02210661955177784, 0.03162403404712677, 0.04303009808063507, 0.005582090467214584, -0.0009492372046224773, 0.0038165529258549213, -0.02250303141772747, 0.07680165022611618, -0.018485378473997116, 0.0030056394170969725, 0.02106781303882599, 0.024225594475865364, 0.02983264997601509, 0.016043197363615036, 0.01956488937139511, -0.005822123493999243, 0.05448135733604431, -0.026802510023117065, 0.022161193192005157, 0.03996661305427551, -0.02676985040307045, 0.011007767170667648, -0.006648763548582792, 0.03840143606066704, 0.06978091597557068, -0.024316200986504555, 0.01701812818646431, -0.031212972477078438, -0.02068479359149933, 0.021615367382764816, 0.029073959216475487, 0.056068792939186096, -0.0032251409720629454, -0.0024713510647416115, 0.01626376248896122, 0.07454854249954224, -0.017069533467292786, 0.009967079386115074, -0.03904718905687332, 0.0153260612860322, 0.08225887268781662, 0.02371496520936489, -0.01349734514951706, -0.08576563745737076, -0.015396575443446636, -0.006856352556496859, 0.021546954289078712, -0.059763554483652115, -0.03035840019583702, 0.07544206827878952, 0.03327462077140808, -0.06627815216779709, -0.06364734470844269, 0.06687486171722412, -0.08935972303152084, -0.022303538396954536, -0.008206924423575401, 0.02010582759976387, 0.0037288605235517025, -0.03567715361714363, -0.0011521162232384086, 0.0019445869838818908, 0.028206195682287216, -0.05005495250225067, 0.027803413569927216, 0.029150042682886124, -0.0503142774105072, -0.000338448619004339, 0.052341826260089874, 0.012111183255910873, -0.008665237575769424, 0.02951986901462078, 0.02016299031674862, -0.026866400614380836, -0.01975092850625515, 0.03596390783786774, -0.013473255559802055, -0.01273778360337019, 0.007800735998898745, 0.019825326278805733, -0.014158734120428562, 0.011427098885178566, 0.04581339657306671, 0.010781144723296165, 0.004236075561493635, 0.0021283552050590515, -0.013608523644506931, -0.05087525025010109, 0.01386707741767168, 0.03501664102077484, 0.01377368625253439, -0.05209364369511604, 0.026294350624084473, 0.01363811083137989, 0.03934689611196518, -0.06685903668403625, 0.010109051130712032, -0.004982309881597757, 0.003845766419544816, 0.013615545816719532, 0.0013043936342000961, -0.054099902510643005, 0.023351207375526428, -0.020743098109960556, -0.05401989817619324, 0.029009373858571053, 0.0011937395902350545, -0.0029590106569230556, -0.06321854889392853, 0.015250686556100845, -0.0013620174722746015, 0.05393582209944725, -0.04384888708591461, -0.0003158295585308224, -0.02700519934296608, -0.03726135939359665, -0.017769398167729378, 0.011581185273826122, 0.029414711520075798, -0.0033225042279809713, 0.00043410350917838514, 0.01175580732524395, -0.054213836789131165, -0.007937285117805004, 0.02318841964006424, -0.03091202676296234, -0.032217249274253845, 0.048600710928440094, -0.017195546999573708, 0.037784092128276825, -0.005463612265884876, -0.07682882249355316, -0.018103620037436485, 0.041073091328144073, -0.056880295276641846, 0.027472665533423424, 0.09074849635362625, -0.03478681296110153, 0.05183587223291397, -0.05118117481470108, 0.03169824182987213, -0.008977439254522324, 0.0330909788608551, 0.01052669808268547, 0.013256418518722057, -0.007210996933281422, 0.05901748687028885, -0.0056089358404278755, 0.0022204206325113773, -0.05571691691875458, -0.05273842066526413, 0.030501270666718483, -0.04756723344326019, 0.001406200579367578, -0.007971244864165783, 0.07292210310697556, -0.0016830047825351357, -0.031160900369286537, -0.003689830657094717, -0.036137357354164124, 0.02330097183585167, 0.02482396736741066, -0.023981647565960884, -0.017445243895053864, 0.0060803950764238834, 0.020453685894608498, 0.014306634664535522, 0.019803693518042564, 0.07167752832174301, 0.03473714739084244, -0.033942483365535736, -0.0351678691804409, -0.0012235997710376978, -0.05382809787988663, -0.07545064389705658 ]
<p>In general relativity, light is subject to gravitational pull. Does light generate gravitational pull, and do two beams of light attract each other?</p>
g815
[ 0.0040990570560097694, 0.010847970843315125, 0.019478268921375275, 0.02433989755809307, -0.011061660945415497, 0.027373583987355232, -0.02571904845535755, -0.011481061577796936, -0.05207490548491478, -0.024591775611042976, 0.012462166137993336, -0.028706934303045273, -0.03653869405388832, -0.017675181850790977, -0.015096189454197884, 0.026342011988162994, 0.09620435535907745, 0.008401140570640564, 0.037458714097738266, 0.019882602617144585, -0.044737596064805984, 0.007339913863688707, 0.006826495286077261, -0.06508772820234299, 0.024705927819013596, -0.01924319379031658, 0.0030423400457948446, -0.01544970739632845, -0.09607455134391785, -0.016697533428668976, 0.027427786961197853, 0.0034653854090720415, 0.03709213435649872, -0.05936045944690704, -0.04413717985153198, -0.07207351922988892, -0.03922664746642113, -0.00373880285769701, -0.015347380191087723, 0.007699467241764069, 0.008448249660432339, 0.05588901415467262, -0.04590413346886635, -0.048170629888772964, 0.051482733339071274, -0.018932929262518883, 0.00845208577811718, 0.04294198006391525, 0.029710551723837852, -0.00574894156306982, -0.004612816032022238, 0.05098738521337509, -0.004495464265346527, -0.07865000516176224, 0.02323063835501671, 0.03895467519760132, -0.03368433937430382, -0.04422900453209877, 0.04623208940029144, 0.04906996712088585, 0.008836580440402031, 0.02673484943807125, 0.05544426664710045, -0.011326547712087631, 0.0017338915495201945, -0.029117412865161896, 0.014766826294362545, -0.06895915418863297, 0.03314152732491493, 0.006256813183426857, -0.03293599560856819, -0.04557259753346443, 0.038681115955114365, -0.01897953450679779, -0.00756635470315814, 0.025489598512649536, 0.029170336201786995, 0.04017409682273865, -0.03555348515510559, 0.007626469247043133, -0.01217937283217907, -0.0452803410589695, -0.012483170256018639, 0.006715824827551842, 0.0244233887642622, -0.014964663423597813, -0.022991253063082695, -0.02154424600303173, -0.048627931624650955, 0.007631342392414808, 0.06848447769880295, 0.0060979207046329975, 0.06328286975622177, 0.06454309821128845, -0.03332781419157982, 0.003503686049953103, 0.011331707239151001, 0.00704199867323041, -0.009125003591179848, 0.0041505116969347, -0.044520054012537, 0.008004850707948208, -0.028613856062293053, 0.034973207861185074, 0.02535017766058445, -0.04042278230190277, 0.011880116537213326, 0.0008522977004759014, -0.07677291333675385, -0.018507009372115135, -0.05443332716822624, -0.02149822935461998, 0.008403453975915909, -0.058446262031793594, -0.04285145923495293, -0.034955479204654694, 0.057232119143009186, -0.025406790897250175, 0.05458373576402664, 0.03068411350250244, 0.018579475581645966, -0.00028683088021352887, -0.01790139079093933, 0.05674893036484718, 0.010464209131896496, 0.001985945040360093, 0.005530577152967453, 0.0015569542301818728, 0.026457075029611588, 0.008499976247549057, -0.008696682751178741, -0.0787898600101471, 0.009770577773451805, -0.01890791393816471, -0.0069665866903960705, 0.015921512618660927, 0.034287482500076294, -0.01635243557393551, -0.017191043123602867, 0.017635663971304893, -0.04926050826907158, -0.044315095990896225, -0.0013973566237837076, -0.017999881878495216, 0.020813968032598495, 0.06579959392547607, -0.013345831073820591, 0.044413138180971146, 0.06001904606819153, 0.02537100575864315, -0.03158636391162872, 0.051931992173194885, 0.004578510299324989, -0.008444736711680889, 0.02553706243634224, -0.043508850038051605, -0.0066844928078353405, -0.031550612300634384, -0.03275710716843605, -0.014017943292856216, 0.07663503289222717, -0.026575107127428055, 0.03409874066710472, 0.0008254099520854652, 0.005555891431868076, 0.009848933666944504, 0.0011767838150262833, -0.05859716609120369, 0.011338864453136921, -0.016440153121948242, -0.02104744128882885, -0.026285530999302864, 0.002270488068461418, 0.018364321440458298, 0.07517518103122711, 0.014853064902126789, 0.0018329607555642724, 0.03247595205903053, 0.02503119967877865, 0.010200060904026031, 0.016206713393330574, -0.03378094360232353, -0.015015305951237679, -0.005414939019829035, -0.025975743308663368, -0.07453986257314682, -0.0647348165512085, -0.02727968990802765, -0.03252504765987396, -0.0009222454391419888, -0.05663582310080528, -0.004055011086165905, -0.002211007522419095, 0.012678678147494793, 0.02109949104487896, 0.01766667701303959, -0.027271335944533348, -0.047318167984485626, 0.036724336445331573, 0.114139124751091, -0.07184842228889465, 0.05825183168053627, -0.013382324948906898, -0.027634792029857635, 0.011291049420833588, 0.017002902925014496, -0.012430427595973015, 0.0008202450699172914, 0.04092458635568619, -0.0439695306122303, 0.03249729797244072, -0.01156668458133936, 0.07974272221326828, 0.0019096462056040764, -0.07297097891569138, -0.0025794615503400564, -0.04410983994603157, 0.053916774690151215, -0.029131583869457245, 0.04232105240225792, -0.018333816900849342, 0.09307584166526794, -0.002084234729409218, -0.020769352093338966, -0.030010441318154335, -0.024411577731370926, -0.04465213790535927, 0.004600384272634983, 0.015623847022652626, -0.004122637677937746, -0.021794825792312622, -0.004097446799278259, -0.016506152227520943, -0.025975435972213745, 0.020662372931838036, 0.034832246601581573, -0.00441985996440053, 0.029702365398406982, 0.0010629785247147083, 0.010077840648591518, -0.011781061068177223, -0.008118359372019768, -0.0098174549639225, -0.038361795246601105, -0.030003594234585762, -0.019628005102276802, 0.013247027061879635, 0.012633739970624447, 0.026208074763417244, 0.058764275163412094, 0.043295733630657196, -0.016414256766438484, -0.048742346465587616, 0.025521649047732353, 0.00888318195939064, 0.0056457542814314365, -0.005304316990077496, 0.05926147848367691, -0.08329387754201889, -0.001735236495733261, 0.021319428458809853, -0.07650379836559296, -0.006127519533038139, -0.027068117633461952, -0.05826358124613762, 0.010621133260428905, 0.049598511308431625, -0.006604042835533619, 0.008974548429250717, 0.004043459892272949, -0.07630439847707748, 0.03212135285139084, 0.010487373918294907, 0.027710918337106705, -0.022605184465646744, 0.02375420555472374, -0.03691114857792854, -0.03205465152859688, -0.008434009738266468, -0.03343471512198448, -0.012779773212969303, -0.023410862311720848, -0.032093677669763565, 0.005080633331090212, 0.06092638149857521, -0.018957404419779778, -0.02620779536664486, 0.022152848541736603, -0.006710214540362358, 0.05944516882300377, -0.08041892945766449, 0.04910484328866005, 0.05279355123639107, 0.006944150198251009, -0.027391761541366577, -0.03482809662818909, 0.01692628301680088, 0.03471366688609123, -0.04865867272019386, 0.03435724228620529, -0.025334250181913376, -0.06357919424772263, 0.042494937777519226, -0.027981312945485115, -0.015287316404283047, -0.02159235253930092, -0.0542457289993763, -0.08187892287969589, -0.009875651448965073, 0.02162940427660942, -0.011755569837987423, 0.09733119606971741, 0.07289820909500122, 0.02482432685792446, 0.005799558013677597, -0.0055929068475961685, 0.026099026203155518, -0.03193813934922218, -0.049412310123443604, 0.014795246534049511, 0.026268992573022842, 0.01565977744758129, -0.045786503702402115, -0.057284239679574966, 0.01596030592918396, -0.02188222110271454, 0.016206443309783936, 0.0397384911775589, 0.0047639524564146996, 0.030745752155780792, 0.024839114397764206, -0.0570230707526207, -0.033157750964164734, -0.009827321395277977, 0.01957080326974392, -0.013753246515989304, 0.023643270134925842, -0.03104075975716114, 0.05115838721394539, 0.027523348107933998, 0.025093568488955498, 0.02887597121298313, -0.049064356833696365, 0.032939717173576355, -0.010305898264050484, 0.04908269643783569, 0.009320267476141453, 0.025387490168213844, 0.03273998573422432, 0.030378615483641624, 0.040852103382349014, -0.04348301142454147, 0.015874264761805534, 0.002116382122039795, -0.011922293342649937, 0.019539978355169296, -0.01232517696917057, 0.009939789772033691, -0.04308507218956947, -0.020144706591963768, -0.031641118228435516, 0.00696270726621151, 0.0188510250300169, 0.04753396660089493, 0.009895996190607548, 0.018505578860640526, -0.030397022143006325, -0.03512320667505264, 0.012278465554118156, -0.0020122812129557133, 0.016009842976927757, 0.0015483833849430084, 0.0087212473154068, 0.018343230709433556, 0.05289190262556076, -0.045646537095308304, 0.05638747662305832, -0.07954622060060501, -0.0006153839058242738, -0.01651148870587349, 0.02796689234673977, 0.03036397509276867, 0.03838888183236122, 0.05230071768164635, 0.025089066475629807, 0.00924528855830431, -0.04472211003303528, -0.01692916266620159, 0.0038256668485701084, -0.013378431089222431, -0.02193683572113514, -0.02290094643831253, -0.006446849554777145, -0.05804184824228287, -0.001973695820197463, 0.01828707940876484, 0.041334621608257294, 0.055764127522706985, -0.006225678138434887, -0.02565566822886467, 0.009307622909545898, 0.03491523116827011, 0.018609656020998955, -0.07630520313978195, -0.04931456968188286, -0.008142534643411636, 0.04135844111442566, -0.01667202264070511, -0.0058094109408557415, 0.047690507024526596, 0.03372049704194069, 0.0246374923735857, -0.0015017972327768803, -0.012300432659685612, 0.0634683221578598, -0.018289504572749138, -0.022788427770137787, 0.03571559861302376, 0.0694681853055954, 0.025856059044599533, 0.034006912261247635, 0.03616723790764809, 0.015620396472513676, -0.015810526907444, -0.0018243525410071015, 0.0973353460431099, 0.03416401520371437, -0.008811552077531815, 0.0013638644013553858, -0.004091263748705387, 0.004756889306008816, -0.009201335720717907, 0.022460661828517914, 0.008902784436941147, 0.015062603168189526, 0.06947923451662064, -0.03048691526055336, 0.032799702137708664, 0.045443203300237656, 0.028596680611371994, 0.041468389332294464, 0.001849491847679019, 0.00797557644546032, -0.00336688500829041, 0.038040414452552795, 0.04350704699754715, 0.028949417173862457, -0.032329659909009933, -0.023072727024555206, -0.06695763021707535, -0.02035456895828247, -0.051476530730724335, 0.01959945820271969, -0.017522737383842468, 0.009250420145690441, 0.043539050966501236, -0.010712826624512672, 0.05281585082411766, 0.04325516149401665, 0.021257080137729645, 0.00999357271939516, -0.046950582414865494, 0.03666210547089577, 0.006195152178406715, 0.020161312073469162, -0.052420828491449356, -0.03799552842974663, -0.0243667084723711, -0.055614814162254333, -0.02654194086790085, -0.038484517484903336, -0.02320701815187931, -0.001958922715857625, 0.029957938939332962, 0.0004679083067458123, -0.00783360656350851, -0.03018294833600521, 0.018754739314317703, 0.03297484293580055, -0.01851174421608448, -0.020793220028281212, -0.035713642835617065, -0.025548510253429413, -0.057788215577602386, -0.003188482252880931, -0.03221640735864639, 0.020242201164364815, 0.06618890166282654, 0.016394218429923058, -0.09451881051063538, -0.04736071079969406, -0.039854008704423904, -0.028409507125616074, -0.029672201722860336, -0.02690727822482586, 0.019309019669890404, -0.06360217928886414, -0.0015421118587255478, 0.00595238758251071, -0.01579904370009899, -0.02407904714345932, 0.009334973059594631, 0.004918098449707031, -0.008192774839699268, -0.047227006405591965, 0.005732827354222536, 0.003597311908379197, 0.005354928784072399, -0.06083575263619423, 0.06362318247556686, -0.03209599480032921, -0.043265171349048615, -0.03961647301912308, 0.04913196340203285, 0.002503293799236417, -0.03351849690079689, 0.055664144456386566, 0.049467623233795166, 0.028662648051977158, -0.04797600954771042, -0.023396071046590805, -0.026614148169755936, -0.029873035848140717, -0.028079712763428688, 0.02932760864496231, 0.031560078263282776, -0.05742039903998375, 0.04557862505316734, 0.06166166439652443, 0.014598713256418705, 0.0300886407494545, -0.010650365613400936, 0.07871583849191666, 0.021364683285355568, 0.09646397083997726, -0.033207863569259644, 0.015269888564944267, 0.039267245680093765, 0.015268322080373764, -0.010121133178472519, 0.0010332121746614575, -0.04835115000605583, 0.02233906276524067, 0.019593361765146255, 0.04916297644376755, 0.03136430308222771, -0.018151475116610527, -0.03512614220380783, 0.019885260611772537, -0.018203090876340866, -0.0016190886963158846, 0.01728709228336811, 0.0276187751442194, 0.061404384672641754, -0.02362506091594696, 0.016037458553910255, -0.01774163544178009, -0.02466338500380516, 0.003211646107956767, 0.023231349885463715, 0.03575228527188301, 0.055545855313539505, 0.012644855305552483, -0.07987489551305771, 0.03915829956531525, -0.03201096132397652, 0.007181515451520681, -0.07992104440927505, 0.03175744414329529, 0.04538751766085625, 0.03886398673057556, 0.01690961979329586, 0.027898816391825676, -0.04023095592856407, 0.05311042442917824, -0.011965450830757618, -0.009908809326589108, -0.03907482326030731, -0.05542917177081108, 0.013173464685678482, -0.0038085191044956446, -0.011348091065883636, 0.012849899008870125, -0.06835585832595825, -0.0916149839758873, 0.02329380437731743, -0.007020132150501013, 0.00366593012586236, 0.0340566523373127, -0.07705433666706085, -0.021081266924738884, -0.036038242280483246, -0.07054203003644943, 0.010814875364303589, -0.04919867962598801, 0.0028276494704186916, 0.02936294861137867, 0.06442301720380783, 0.022196020931005478, 0.010732559487223625, -0.04282349720597267, 0.04044099152088165, 0.10111358016729355, 0.02993451990187168, 0.0431426465511322, 0.01502158958464861, -0.07986477017402649, -0.022081153467297554, 0.004356498830020428, 0.028526749461889267, -0.04068177938461304, -0.011138960719108582, -0.02190539985895157, -0.0068780481815338135, 0.028811272233724594, -0.03439486026763916, 0.0030844928696751595, 0.005634950008243322, 0.007758968509733677, 0.01074058748781681, 0.02275833487510681, -0.10197978466749191, 0.05488153174519539, -0.061371974647045135, -0.030332449823617935, 0.03067070245742798, -0.059108346700668335, -0.0025740962009876966, -0.01271171122789383, 0.0554991140961647, -0.017031438648700714, -0.022785520181059837, -0.04049677029252052, -0.004718840587884188, 0.02788168005645275, 0.035948555916547775, -0.008659454062581062, 0.08894451707601547, 0.05947963520884514, 0.031129861250519753, 0.021162938326597214, 0.035561613738536835, -0.03975183516740799, 0.012005430646240711, -0.0017100278055295348, -0.02530040591955185, -0.00798992533236742, -0.06856132298707962, -0.0015310706803575158, 0.022455699741840363, -0.04036357253789902, -0.038037799298763275, -0.018028976395726204, 0.002703562844544649, -0.035781510174274445, 0.01245681382715702, -0.03932485356926918, -0.02422274276614189, -0.03754331171512604, -0.09831389784812927, -0.0062725781463086605, -0.007968435063958168, -0.006984225939959288, 0.05682925134897232, -0.05389837548136711, 0.018604621291160583, -0.009633803740143776, -0.028492754325270653, -0.012777208350598812, 0.04665404558181763, 0.0048754713498055935, -0.00598108721897006, 0.0026180141139775515, 0.03233803063631058, -0.03196946904063225, -0.0038662771694362164, -0.04297037422657013, 0.0055942595936357975, 0.0750579833984375, -0.02393353171646595, -0.004231997299939394, 0.06798025220632553, -0.0031204756814986467, 0.04241374135017395, -0.006842749658972025, 0.01981070078909397, 0.028773976489901543, -0.07035118341445923, -0.017014341428875923, -0.04255523905158043, -0.021165624260902405, 0.061792779713869095, -0.0027968906797468662, 0.008725675754249096, -0.04562012106180191, -0.011086712591350079, -0.0045628538355231285, 0.035933248698711395, -0.01885482668876648, -0.0012516678543761373, -0.05852338299155235, 0.03702740743756294, -0.07770063728094101, 0.015126918442547321, 0.04193530231714249, 0.007687833625823259, 0.02373291179537773, 0.0008149028872139752, -0.0022538432385772467, -0.024690214544534683, 0.026947498321533203, 0.08233902603387833, 0.0015988812083378434, -0.004360007122159004, -0.02847311645746231, 0.01111969631165266, -0.005050303880125284, 0.04636029154062271, 0.01453967485576868, 0.003675625892356038, 0.01783582754433155, -0.017465740442276, -0.003349388251081109, -0.04073842987418175, -0.028354451060295105, 0.02953783981502056, 0.07259434461593628, -0.0191971305757761, -0.005421851761639118, -0.007205830421298742, 0.007443924900144339, -0.03193366155028343, -0.04022412747144699, -0.014249909669160843, 0.032491106539964676, 0.027175819501280785, -0.021551907062530518, 0.0031353600788861513, 0.007792406249791384, 0.03320084512233734, -0.0033684701193124056, -0.011289536021649837, -0.014584715478122234, 0.011987333185970783, 0.0667278915643692, 0.013534151948988438, -0.010907871648669243, 0.032387860119342804, 0.05434280261397362, -0.0027420460246503353, -0.02265719510614872, 0.05926164239645004, -0.00539929186925292, 0.025911107659339905, 0.09542565792798996, -0.059565309435129166, -0.05451885983347893, -0.0027592009864747524, 0.03641550615429878, -0.012927398085594177, -0.04976920783519745, 0.01785377413034439, -0.06890200823545456, -0.027556100860238075, -0.029806848615407944, 0.014446022920310497, -0.03674713894724846, 0.05544988811016083 ]
<p>I am trying to solve this simple excercise:</p> <p><strong>Question</strong></p> <p><em>You throw a small coin upwards with</em> $4 \frac{m}{s}$ <em>. How much time does it need to reach the height of</em> $0.5 m$ <em>? Why do we get two results?</em></p> <p><strong>Answer</strong></p> <p>(We get two results for time, because the coin passes the 0.5m mark downwards too.)</p> <p>The equtation I used (for constant acceleration): $x = x_0 + v_0 t + \frac{1}{2} a t^2$</p> <p>These values I know: $x = 0.5m$, $x_0 = 0$, $v_0 = 4 \frac{m}{s}$, $a = -9.81 \frac{m}{s^2}$ So, I get a quadratic equtation which I can solve for $t$. My two results are: $t_1 = 0.15s$ and $t_2 = 0.66s$, however the book has the results 0.804s and 0.013s. What am I doing wrong?</p> <p><strong>Thanks for your help</strong></p>
g5921
[ 0.08769027888774872, 0.04708351939916611, -0.01563732884824276, -0.009697098284959793, 0.03049219213426113, 0.04523647576570511, 0.07009373605251312, -0.026363659650087357, -0.08850882202386856, 0.02033703774213791, -0.07471678406000137, 0.04758850112557411, 0.008955287747085094, -0.013441835530102253, -0.013239131309092045, -0.004147539380937815, 0.08272391557693481, -0.04927589371800423, 0.004293475765734911, 0.012801467441022396, -0.019995668902993202, -0.019084153696894646, -0.04236133396625519, -0.03881605342030525, 0.014679327607154846, 0.014871727675199509, 0.0009186461102217436, 0.034793686121702194, -0.09885714948177338, 0.023776432499289513, -0.014063563197851181, 0.023981910198926926, 0.042856961488723755, -0.014079018495976925, -0.005870708264410496, 0.015378533862531185, 0.06732084602117538, -0.009341482073068619, 0.0034161696676164865, -0.041951172053813934, 0.018276389688253403, -0.10768399387598038, -0.02280033752322197, 0.04133189097046852, 0.013609923422336578, 0.0005487140733748674, -0.04133395105600357, 0.026160234585404396, 0.007593929301947355, -0.0618225559592247, -0.025045081973075867, 0.001065148739144206, 0.052936505526304245, -0.04806660860776901, -0.005015316419303417, 0.051516544073820114, 0.0028995354659855366, -0.02686256915330887, 0.021299760788679123, 0.03645531088113785, 0.016622435301542282, -0.07113125175237656, 0.053403809666633606, -0.05387837067246437, 0.0865115225315094, 0.007054596673697233, 0.017054041847586632, -0.02178545854985714, -0.0362066775560379, 0.01761661283671856, 0.024690771475434303, -0.05314933508634567, -0.01102723553776741, -0.048677485436201096, -0.04143285006284714, 0.0020031272433698177, 0.025964006781578064, -0.025029992684721947, 0.025238076224923134, -0.0021667834371328354, -0.018665459007024765, 0.02594684436917305, -0.005845101550221443, 0.0014426012057811022, -0.002409739885479212, 0.00424086581915617, -0.015570566058158875, 0.058465734124183655, 0.012859371490776539, -0.031521134078502655, -0.006982968654483557, 0.012432240881025791, 0.021639272570610046, 0.03567074239253998, -0.01068939920514822, -0.027597008273005486, -0.0141841359436512, 0.05749638378620148, 0.012967117130756378, -0.0019116452895104885, -0.0109510263428092, -0.00678059970960021, 0.007838522084057331, -0.00433419831097126, -0.005445791874080896, 0.033165186643600464, 0.08182935416698456, 0.04295046627521515, -0.04057462885975838, -0.03167230635881424, -0.00354110193438828, -0.020931426435709, -0.033707182854413986, -0.0840967446565628, -0.07577163726091385, 0.008233360014855862, -0.0005281342309899628, -0.006892520003020763, -0.025907976552844048, 0.014075854793190956, 0.019312573596835136, 0.010855193249881268, 0.08151150494813919, 0.059143126010894775, -0.014986804686486721, -0.051215529441833496, 0.01073022186756134, 0.03422064706683159, -0.005413619801402092, 0.008733482100069523, -0.026701191440224648, 0.023436319082975388, 0.01552558969706297, 0.019242845475673676, 0.014368487522006035, -0.007794140372425318, 0.014318322762846947, 0.0263204462826252, -0.0019522610818967223, 0.010634283535182476, -0.01864245906472206, -0.03638039901852608, 0.004051209427416325, -0.017782285809516907, -0.05927862972021103, -0.02477574534714222, -0.02796846628189087, 0.007433510385453701, 0.009093907661736012, -0.0407906249165535, 0.031285230070352554, 0.06776932626962662, -0.031003713607788086, 0.03341677039861679, 0.03228648006916046, 0.014496841467916965, 0.0455610491335392, -0.01334326434880495, 0.027036456391215324, 0.043211858719587326, 0.0399712435901165, 0.00833499152213335, -0.03070535883307457, 0.020911801606416702, -0.08603652566671371, 0.07213800400495529, -0.005800444167107344, -0.05157275125384331, 0.0102507583796978, 0.012961281463503838, -0.046243906021118164, -0.042866311967372894, 0.04777040332555771, -0.016068188473582268, -0.045199234038591385, -0.011067908257246017, 0.046412814408540726, -0.025466540828347206, 0.02842569909989834, 0.007804715074598789, 0.001961371162906289, -0.024920258671045303, -0.003499795449897647, 0.05817854776978493, -0.01234822440892458, -0.016759421676397324, 0.023646630346775055, 0.012759482488036156, -0.03608236834406853, -0.0256212018430233, 0.010932319797575474, -0.01096042338758707, -0.03395599499344826, 0.01801983267068863, -0.03277040272951126, 0.006852992810308933, 0.04210105538368225, -0.06053071841597557, -0.04030260443687439, 0.022277718409895897, 0.04541335254907608, 0.05493427813053131, 0.049592263996601105, 0.020498624071478844, 0.02903619408607483, 0.0137123828753829, -0.04131407290697098, -0.016915753483772278, -0.01615995541214943, 0.04086838662624359, -0.032697249203920364, 0.011674483306705952, -0.00829375721514225, 0.044829174876213074, 0.032632384449243546, -0.06989189982414246, 0.0403115339577198, -0.0019196042558178306, -0.02090686373412609, 0.04890570789575577, -0.013548493385314941, -0.021794088184833527, -0.010711523704230785, -0.05324968323111534, -0.04422735422849655, -0.009474747814238071, 0.0006686652777716517, -0.013523247092962265, -0.029415830969810486, -0.018090255558490753, -0.062196336686611176, 0.02100548893213272, -0.027640899643301964, -0.056860193610191345, 0.03674528747797012, 0.0072016590274870396, 0.004869044758379459, 0.01793207786977291, 0.026663679629564285, 0.08166302740573883, -0.0066141304560005665, -0.0158415287733078, -0.0153450733050704, -0.030292965471744537, 0.029063666239380836, -0.03133867308497429, 0.03231312707066536, 0.027084941044449806, -0.04004845768213272, -0.034715618938207626, -0.013470446690917015, -0.0022610491141676903, -0.04136065021157265, 0.0219651497900486, -0.06400987505912781, 0.018150582909584045, -0.007386897690594196, -0.01070717629045248, -0.01038597896695137, -0.04319559037685394, -0.027383480221033096, -0.0002625873894430697, 0.020510418340563774, -0.012269171886146069, -0.08803573995828629, 0.004320907406508923, -0.05332409217953682, -0.060977496206760406, 0.016482867300510406, -0.02110101282596588, -0.038149770349264145, 0.033983003348112106, 0.024146201089024544, 0.07033593952655792, -0.03788507729768753, -0.06468404084444046, -0.005272598005831242, 0.016518333926796913, 0.042689062654972076, 0.01755882240831852, -0.014298712834715843, -0.03438669443130493, -0.012261882424354553, 0.052659500390291214, 0.053517453372478485, -0.019872313365340233, -0.006446231156587601, 0.00455571198835969, 0.011771268211305141, -0.020908299833536148, -0.01367468573153019, 0.019367147237062454, 0.037887345999479294, 0.016385972499847412, 0.008257030509412289, 0.050581883639097214, 0.022517461329698563, -0.05089360848069191, -0.0005858229706063867, -0.03847872465848923, 0.004198836162686348, -0.0091144610196352, -0.02620069868862629, -0.020422199741005898, 0.013576125726103783, -0.02513842098414898, 0.007722019217908382, -0.058389950543642044, -0.043318551033735275, -0.03202265128493309, 0.015773143619298935, 0.016922781243920326, 0.01740879938006401, -0.016114385798573494, -0.07565408945083618, -0.036689333617687225, -0.0050204177387058735, 0.0012490388471633196, 0.012021111324429512, 0.009759482927620411, -0.004383235704153776, -0.08613002300262451, -0.0213614534586668, -0.0008606641204096377, 0.013092092238366604, -0.03852939233183861, -0.0013566211564466357, 0.021985609084367752, -0.027912788093090057, 0.013132166117429733, 0.024017438292503357, 0.02679837867617607, -0.001274902606382966, -0.015223516151309013, 0.03252924978733063, -0.05700131878256798, 0.02094428427517414, 0.01597478799521923, 0.006113795097917318, 0.01642553135752678, -0.026989387348294258, 0.019022956490516663, -0.07491052150726318, -0.007628133986145258, -0.009865902364253998, -0.016173891723155975, 0.0019329434726387262, 0.007941904477775097, -0.010721808299422264, -0.02511061541736126, 0.024835243821144104, -0.006737260147929192, -0.028830621391534805, -0.004320778418332338, 0.01238179113715887, -0.0027435394003987312, 0.003508060472086072, 0.043627653270959854, -0.04108520969748497, -0.04302843660116196, 0.0398004986345768, 0.027675127610564232, -0.01264137402176857, 0.07054083049297333, -0.00524017633870244, -0.00778589490801096, -0.023973362520337105, 0.09416107833385468, -0.0068710423074662685, 0.036705974489450455, 0.03853587061166763, -0.026402955874800682, 0.06672225147485733, -0.031189264729619026, -0.026828546077013016, -0.02446071431040764, -0.03354997560381889, -0.011988004669547081, -0.016395203769207, 0.060279179364442825, 0.07186369597911835, -0.014163807965815067, 0.00899378303438425, -0.019595477730035782, -0.014616542495787144, 0.039492182433605194, -0.04768586531281471, -0.05818773806095123, 0.01064648199826479, -0.07247161120176315, 0.05201753228902817, -0.014338082633912563, -0.03458208963274956, 0.04383310303092003, -0.018610626459121704, -0.02266852930188179, 0.0825568363070488, 0.002914252458140254, -0.0682872086763382, 0.00571498554199934, -0.013988100923597813, -0.0016848953673616052, 0.023572104051709175, 0.016403360292315483, -0.0961107611656189, 0.04561915248632431, 0.0012549537932500243, -0.0026578078977763653, 0.004737722221761942, 0.010818622075021267, -0.007825334556400776, 0.011935736052691936, -0.018936531618237495, -0.063225157558918, -0.023036547005176544, -0.036660149693489075, 0.0467243567109108, 0.018634041771292686, -0.04931196570396423, -0.06576915830373764, 0.034003496170043945, 0.07194048166275024, 0.018503690138459206, -0.05136876180768013, 0.015912817791104317, 0.11723408102989197, -0.017762428149580956, -0.005330333486199379, 0.0712340846657753, 0.034531161189079285, -0.022438116371631622, -0.011363741010427475, 0.023026656359434128, 0.03892549127340317, -0.029481880366802216, 0.04250604659318924, 0.031826190650463104, 0.04815813526511192, 0.03214443475008011, 0.05470123514533043, 0.021237317472696304, -0.004352678079158068, 0.010881871916353703, 0.018910985440015793, 0.03210967779159546, 0.03401348739862442, 0.007914758287370205, -0.03367522731423378, 0.009172169491648674, 0.0010644409339874983, -0.006894012913107872, 0.05858353152871132, 0.02502613328397274, 0.0010811621323227882, 0.018887510523200035, -0.036470893770456314, -0.03633825480937958, -0.012589373625814915, 0.05715393275022507, 0.027776088565587997, -0.010959806852042675, 0.00011821778025478125, 0.0007710018544457853, -0.018210364505648613, 0.05189251899719238, -0.052015695720911026, -0.023595213890075684, -0.010193650610744953, 0.024907929822802544, 0.014892186969518661, 0.01072012074291706, -0.010377689264714718, 0.025961903855204582, 0.008862758055329323, -0.002057358156889677, 0.01970694772899151, 0.01895463652908802, 0.03809797018766403, 0.08117701858282089, -0.004588938783854246, 0.0032802110072225332, -0.029668979346752167, -0.013231446966528893, 0.005102384369820356, 0.02835344336926937, 0.04076435789465904, -0.03250271454453468, -0.03752293065190315, 0.054209645837545395, -0.06575843691825867, 0.015229443088173866, 0.0014493040507659316, -0.011039817705750465, -0.038154855370521545, -0.06191376596689224, 0.01494620181620121, 0.023737581446766853, 0.034167882055044174, 0.030237821862101555, -0.030009115114808083, -0.03166836500167847, -0.005162733606994152, -0.01044377125799656, 0.01419643871486187, -0.008622064255177975, 0.036507293581962585, 0.038799986243247986, -0.009171622805297375, 0.024178002029657364, 0.0618571899831295, 0.004615798592567444, -0.02235771343111992, 0.08141430467367172, -0.05104655772447586, -0.04811118543148041, -0.005324403289705515, 0.039375949651002884, 0.03288496285676956, 0.005576331168413162, -0.04985307157039642, 0.1082320585846901, -0.008048183284699917, 0.007789766415953636, -0.02748960629105568, 0.06760869175195694, -0.023045003414154053, -0.029431186616420746, -0.0478842630982399, 0.00880174245685339, 0.02779957465827465, 0.006812325678765774, -0.028083883225917816, -0.06059148907661438, -0.009984128177165985, -0.017780322581529617, 0.005742629058659077, 0.008904778398573399, -0.07860821485519409, -0.04297282546758652, -0.028404029086232185, -0.006257793866097927, -0.022444020956754684, -0.008526025339961052, 0.09399524331092834, -0.009372921660542488, -0.02828635461628437, -0.015790866687893867, -0.03063032776117325, 0.09364543110132217, -0.03367486968636513, 0.027499880641698837, 0.016405167058110237, -0.036910802125930786, 0.02673117071390152, -0.016417862847447395, 0.07252082973718643, -0.031044574454426765, -0.03775961324572563, -0.022434910759329796, -0.023346368223428726, 0.03300131484866142, -0.05702665075659752, 0.0021735739428550005, 0.0729440450668335, 0.02520173043012619, -0.04297540336847305, 0.017951034009456635, 0.05384553223848343, 0.029474938288331032, 0.0354570671916008, 0.031240250915288925, 0.026230214163661003, 0.03914644196629524, 0.027754314243793488, 0.06461579352617264, 0.02332177385687828, -0.020497623831033707, -0.01899736560881138, -0.029573459178209305, -0.005672141909599304, -0.036373745650053024, 0.03833965212106705, 0.00422199722379446, 0.0019945346284657717, -0.006456694565713406, 0.01355453860014677, -0.026567330583930016, 0.0005278413300402462, 0.04331168159842491, -0.042647313326597214, -0.02601528726518154, 0.0008439496741630137, -0.03303901478648186, -0.03785272315144539, -0.03428367152810097, -0.02445756271481514, 0.010712278075516224, -0.02171022817492485, -0.03704454004764557, -0.0034825277980417013, 0.03045595996081829, 0.006528777536004782, 0.03902549296617508, -0.027627117931842804, 0.004116751253604889, 0.04370182007551193, -0.028795374557375908, 0.02135898545384407, -0.012148063629865646, -0.001263759913854301, -0.030288495123386383, 0.06487905979156494, 0.007805833127349615, 0.031246712431311607, -0.03362589702010155, 0.007287430111318827, 0.0721711665391922, -0.021949276328086853, 0.029280170798301697, -0.0713614895939827, 0.027448536828160286, 0.013071977533400059, -0.015516459010541439, -0.07451634109020233, 0.01832565665245056, -0.011275004595518112, 0.03219102323055267, 0.014142111875116825, 0.018820831552147865, -0.03297961875796318, 0.049826331436634064, -0.022283148020505905, -0.02385120280086994, -0.006173573900014162, -0.024241095408797264, 0.06488656252622604, -0.0068273781798779964, 0.07872360199689865, -0.033348988741636276, 0.053257133811712265, -0.018375782296061516, -0.009913305751979351, -0.017493728548288345, -0.024421799927949905, -0.02502698078751564, -0.03632640838623047, 0.04677197337150574, 0.05394425243139267, -0.06097486615180969, 0.006112465634942055, 0.07510785013437271, -0.013473370112478733, -0.04619193822145462, 0.01124295312911272, 0.020168334245681763, -0.0055045513436198235, -0.011402500793337822, -0.0007421446498483419, -0.03343811631202698, -0.02086642012000084, 0.0043085175566375256, -0.020704831928014755, -0.025599077343940735, 0.05178302899003029, -0.0027715996839106083, 0.030832460150122643, -0.05999624356627464, -0.0035322599578648806, -0.017714213579893112, -0.0687892958521843, 0.00012255684123374522, 0.0029944870620965958, -0.08438841253519058, 0.017618101090192795, 0.052951630204916, 0.0188136026263237, -0.06429558247327805, 0.033791158348321915, -0.047660958021879196, -0.05736394226551056, 0.0010468638502061367, -0.028366487473249435, -0.04098400101065636, -0.03136536478996277, 0.01914171315729618, 0.06170601025223732, -0.05421249568462372, -0.028346102684736252, 0.06366134434938431, 0.041635654866695404, 0.018123287707567215, -0.018374387174844742, 0.056960199028253555, 0.009256136603653431, -0.009771199896931648, 0.00290805846452713, -0.028616631403565407, 0.01822635345160961, 0.009730684570968151, 0.015299451537430286, 0.04808707907795906, 0.038940638303756714, 0.04009868949651718, 0.038883209228515625, -0.03219993785023689, 0.02908448688685894, -0.0003468036593403667, 0.02560163289308548, -0.03379620611667633, -0.05691178888082504, -0.005872498266398907, 0.040642958134412766, 0.000834935053717345, -0.03487425297498703, 0.08989842236042023, 0.03879128769040108, -0.02172933891415596, 0.00903283804655075, 0.015817148610949516, -0.03972046077251434, -0.037529073655605316, -0.0009887967025861144, -0.024294525384902954, -0.045900896191596985, -0.04432500898838043, -0.05235305428504944, -0.028355613350868225, -0.018295230343937874, 0.011281254701316357, 0.024408547207713127, 0.011895534582436085, -0.06610190868377686, -0.00010752291564131156, 0.07050696015357971, 0.011297686025500298, -0.026305554434657097, 0.07870730757713318, 0.014790566638112068, 0.0018819032702594995, 0.044026076793670654, -0.047871559858322144, -0.0440712571144104, -0.053525544703006744, 0.04332568123936653, 0.01993631199002266, -0.05718594044446945, -0.0009680520161055028, 0.07126937806606293, 0.02152826078236103, -0.05243704840540886, 0.0217377208173275, 0.0168707687407732, -0.07627987116575241, 0.07995244860649109, 0.01939457841217518, -0.04137956723570824, 0.012626837007701397, 0.022217074409127235, 0.027296841144561768, 0.01168004423379898, -0.07181508094072342, 0.004600957967340946, -0.02379515953361988, -0.009183268062770367, 0.024374553933739662, -0.030365576967597008, -0.010498370043933392, -0.0035046571865677834 ]
<p>So, the Fermi level in crystals is pretty easy to understand. Been using it and talking about it in terms of the highest occupied level forever. However, I'm now reading about disordered systems. A lot of researchers mention the existence of empty states randomly distributed above and <em>below</em> the Fermi level. But isn't the Fermi level necessarily the energy at which all energies below are filled states?</p> <p>EDIT: So I suppose chemical potential is the more correct term to use (instead of Fermi energy) because not at T = 0. Anyways, consider this quote: "the localized gap states near $E_F$ are spread in energy with singly occupied gap states below $E_F$, doubly occupied states lying above $E_F$, and empty states distributed randomly."</p>
g5922
[ 0.014149997383356094, 0.05361513793468475, -0.0037828919012099504, -0.018863379955291748, -0.02364962175488472, 0.018043342977762222, -0.016164682805538177, 0.07151670753955841, 0.027749935165047646, -0.017531927675008774, -0.008999645709991455, -0.024550389498472214, 0.026553960517048836, -0.04047331586480141, -0.059080421924591064, 0.03440142795443535, 0.0849287360906601, 0.011566557921469212, -0.020022859796881676, 0.021124687045812607, -0.04833684489130974, 0.03698205575346947, -0.006281305570155382, -0.004785081371665001, -0.07081495970487595, 0.03790268674492836, 0.004545142408460379, -0.032433751970529556, -0.03274799510836601, -0.04113897681236267, -0.001858855364844203, 0.009219171479344368, 0.06523234397172928, -0.02586294710636139, -0.025589779019355774, 0.026408711448311806, 0.024914085865020752, 0.03801219165325165, 0.012512567453086376, 0.0042879036627709866, -0.03226277977228165, -0.005203762091696262, -0.008735311217606068, -0.06007101386785507, -0.05474196746945381, 0.051804278045892715, -0.061577241867780685, 0.023289529606699944, 0.010566344484686852, -0.024211496114730835, 0.00959634780883789, 0.08910990506410599, 0.059098321944475174, 0.038987159729003906, 0.04263758659362793, -0.023326922208070755, -0.0232086218893528, 0.010820303112268448, 0.030492858961224556, 0.017421439290046692, 0.06967286020517349, 0.01949946954846382, -0.03604276478290558, 0.008694370277225971, 0.062453869730234146, 0.08398833870887756, -0.018747635185718536, 0.05009043961763382, 0.04050673916935921, -0.08901670575141907, -0.005657485220581293, -0.017710186541080475, -0.08685782551765442, -0.04505844786763191, -0.07258813828229904, 0.01655837520956993, 0.03110523894429207, -0.029319994151592255, 0.06261058151721954, -0.01758558675646782, -0.04018477723002434, 0.014938261359930038, 0.03180430456995964, 0.003869688371196389, 0.0948294997215271, -0.0192426610738039, -0.02364054135978222, 0.043792206794023514, 0.001673125196248293, 0.05284822732210159, -0.030475249513983727, -0.026637893170118332, 0.02713163197040558, -0.06415355205535889, -0.011567026376724243, 0.004787839017808437, 0.00037402851739898324, 0.036227643489837646, 0.02239491045475006, -0.049615129828453064, -0.03558860346674919, -0.0397169291973114, -0.002539984183385968, -0.000772593542933464, -0.02411702461540699, 0.040326833724975586, -0.007727182935923338, -0.0661974623799324, 0.017950592562556267, 0.07804620265960693, -0.013834565877914429, 0.0498509481549263, -0.0048522017896175385, -0.016484906896948814, -0.018123608082532883, 0.043247807770967484, 0.05631344020366669, 0.00422039395198226, -0.010511446744203568, -0.0008732944843359292, -0.006830401252955198, 0.1075780913233757, 0.0025707921013236046, 0.04881616309285164, -0.0005033130291849375, -0.0049270871095359325, -0.047105785459280014, -0.016295569017529488, -0.02542726881802082, -0.0010984234977513552, -0.005109397694468498, -0.04196207970380783, -0.05270141363143921, -0.037807971239089966, 0.0009819119004532695, 0.03410596027970314, 0.003850150853395462, 0.020966986194252968, 0.035533346235752106, 0.021173184737563133, 0.007566757965832949, -0.0005246768705546856, 0.004286046139895916, -0.0058150580152869225, -0.027358783408999443, -0.0036090249195694923, 0.0029711963143199682, 0.011163928546011448, 0.014957509934902191, 0.009614923968911171, -0.003846915438771248, 0.012020285241305828, -0.06080521270632744, -0.0631689578294754, -0.007963686250150204, -0.03589268773794174, 0.025750061497092247, 0.005194485653191805, 0.0010188258020207286, 0.03953983634710312, -0.0012527236249297857, 0.03158779442310333, 0.007357606664299965, -0.02080753818154335, 0.012566846795380116, -0.022648470476269722, 0.025827744975686073, -0.0305173397064209, -0.06654205173254013, -0.03623853623867035, 0.005578260403126478, -0.012696019373834133, -0.033736441284418106, 0.023097610101103783, -0.05033324286341667, 0.04781545698642731, 0.01833234541118145, -0.03325800225138664, 0.0695590004324913, 0.016499482095241547, 0.012180257588624954, -0.015624243766069412, 0.047584664076566696, -0.004605751950293779, 0.017823662608861923, -0.011999865062534809, 0.004177262540906668, 0.019906599074602127, 0.02780592069029808, 0.02396003156900406, 0.06514246761798859, -0.006499190349131823, -0.0032400896307080984, 0.022146452218294144, -0.00020255515119060874, -0.04654262959957123, 0.0638999491930008, -0.0228416845202446, -0.022965218871831894, -0.046801671385765076, -0.024223774671554565, -0.050966374576091766, -0.014842311851680279, -0.016771947965025902, 0.06265944242477417, 0.04797397553920746, -0.07615169882774353, 0.022208845242857933, -0.003083566902205348, -0.011413167230784893, -0.05292508378624916, -0.03356052562594414, 0.030424566939473152, 0.03834651783108711, 0.019484369084239006, -0.014879556372761726, -0.03189894184470177, -0.021465066820383072, 0.01545858196914196, -0.025280868634581566, -0.018725799396634102, -0.034094542264938354, -0.016472196206450462, 0.049100760370492935, 0.04814644902944565, 0.013089255429804325, -0.030673539265990257, -0.0031674059573560953, -0.038418397307395935, 0.07309356331825256, -0.061412110924720764, 0.008877526037395, -0.01742377132177353, -0.036371342837810516, 0.030315248295664787, 0.036129727959632874, -0.012152769602835178, 0.0042746406979858875, 0.01389398891478777, 0.012318689376115799, -0.053571224212646484, -0.05111166834831238, -0.019969822838902473, 0.054938435554504395, -0.010493794456124306, -0.0339939258992672, -0.0011266889050602913, -0.02655983157455921, -0.015053115785121918, 0.027734771370887756, 0.030877579003572464, -0.020859336480498314, -0.014669876545667648, 0.007926370948553085, -0.010779607109725475, 0.039949093014001846, -0.014462213031947613, 0.042918611317873, 0.0006206242833286524, -0.03386664763092995, -0.02325884811580181, -0.0667053759098053, 0.044306255877017975, -0.03347594663500786, 0.014879790134727955, -0.03331178426742554, -0.004885539412498474, -0.004547238815575838, -0.003961706068366766, 0.005860255099833012, -0.01689443364739418, 0.09239766746759415, 0.019665533676743507, 0.0021813116036355495, 0.03824087977409363, -0.09553002566099167, -0.02860543690621853, 0.00980350561439991, 0.003082818351686001, -0.041004154831171036, -0.04057232290506363, 0.0028822412714362144, -0.00863319169729948, 0.05189988762140274, -0.013194285333156586, -0.03918347507715225, 0.06236017495393753, -0.07078259438276291, 0.012737908400595188, 0.005563813261687756, 0.030356064438819885, -0.012051211670041084, 0.02771436609327793, 0.041946157813072205, -0.0616564005613327, -0.0003499622689560056, 0.006961209699511528, -0.054361648857593536, -0.047118913382291794, 0.0482514463365078, -0.003925197757780552, -0.026824016124010086, 0.055040132254362106, 0.005269546527415514, 0.025561392307281494, 0.038287922739982605, 0.008715095929801464, -0.023861177265644073, -0.09054354578256607, 0.013140358962118626, -0.05027744919061661, 0.09449803084135056, -0.01968022808432579, 0.022328564897179604, -0.0630708858370781, 0.037129294127225876, -0.06932245194911957, 0.03189248591661453, 0.01559394970536232, -0.06026116758584976, -0.015875956043601036, 0.036566123366355896, 0.006115579977631569, 0.0023779815528541803, 0.013530947268009186, -0.020730717107653618, -0.03259902447462082, -0.04440603032708168, -0.0744013860821724, 0.024774910882115364, 0.051564767956733704, -0.022868888452649117, -0.02985505573451519, -0.00047390800318680704, 0.018832886591553688, -0.06671243160963058, -0.04232152923941612, 0.033516403287649155, 0.07998614758253098, -0.026176216080784798, -0.03284885734319687, 0.05253418907523155, 0.03449901565909386, -0.014937001280486584, 0.026171263307332993, 0.026081440970301628, -0.06417205929756165, 0.0345454141497612, -0.026611095294356346, -0.02530878223478794, -0.01697390154004097, 0.013960248790681362, -0.008933662436902523, 0.013994986191391945, -0.03363882377743721, 0.0006840151618234813, -0.015203947201371193, -0.04466484487056732, 0.061764076352119446, 0.04379270225763321, 0.08486806601285934, -0.07411789149045944, 0.01977011188864708, -0.031104417517781258, -0.018989311531186104, -0.0017029023729264736, -0.05680744722485542, 0.008034883067011833, 0.025489524006843567, -0.00784573145210743, 0.028162570670247078, -0.05397592484951019, 0.03395194560289383, 0.04027840495109558, 0.06144436076283455, -0.01107089314609766, 0.007007142528891563, 0.013167247176170349, -0.0644708052277565, -0.028378669172525406, 0.016509488224983215, -0.0454384870827198, 0.029558435082435608, 0.015523158013820648, 0.0035285328049212694, -0.00981636717915535, -0.05628670006990433, 0.03310404717922211, -0.023158134892582893, 0.02359752543270588, 0.02973327599465847, -0.03047008253633976, 0.0178757905960083, 0.11595216393470764, -0.00006132449198048562, -0.0007764172041788697, 0.03783376142382622, -0.024916531518101692, 0.060013990849256516, 0.0653240755200386, 0.06085449457168579, 0.0005329218111000955, -0.04776328057050705, -0.025284340605139732, 0.009094561450183392, 0.024338165298104286, 0.018240632489323616, -0.03275953605771065, -0.04553312435746193, -0.03946535289287567, 0.01570204831659794, 0.0555046908557415, -0.013353465124964714, -0.008825485594570637, 0.044777318835258484, -0.019185250625014305, -0.04154299944639206, -0.04768683761358261, -0.04013762250542641, 0.03365363925695419, 0.03825003281235695, 0.006237552501261234, -0.024273397400975227, 0.02293459139764309, 0.0111836614087224, 0.0837768167257309, -0.0021376521326601505, 0.01177912950515747, -0.04384424909949303, -0.04078740254044533, 0.009999239817261696, 0.04649578034877777, -0.03725622966885567, -0.032864369451999664, -0.013837652280926704, -0.0357019379734993, 0.006860732100903988, -0.03557446971535683, 0.01368023082613945, 0.08429810404777527, -0.0020209355279803276, -0.02121180295944214, -0.003492482239380479, 0.07256957143545151, -0.021984539926052094, -0.022233569994568825, -0.03965425491333008, -0.004262940492480993, -0.03546297550201416, -0.03797687962651253, 0.011200930923223495, 0.007243120111525059, -0.049964334815740585, -0.03268136456608772, 0.004351727664470673, -0.04547882825136185, -0.07190685719251633, -0.009036273695528507, 0.037204571068286896, -0.0090808579698205, -0.047173693776130676, -0.0666215792298317, -0.017848076298832893, -0.019812775775790215, 0.0221649631857872, 0.035835038870573044, -0.009503076784312725, -0.005852988455444574, 0.009271969087421894, -0.0003608219267334789, 0.0209356602281332, -0.027562526986002922, 0.049812667071819305, 0.008477279916405678, 0.04159841313958168, -0.03920363262295723, 0.0013122790260240436, -0.025896333158016205, 0.016808059066534042, -0.027090976014733315, -0.058415886014699936, 0.03475877270102501, 0.027560776099562645, 0.031814925372600555, -0.058466944843530655, 0.015975674614310265, -0.0545915849506855, -0.005587433930486441, -0.009764515794813633, -0.0487910695374012, 0.03801649808883667, 0.02622782252728939, -0.007450093049556017, 0.011036284267902374, 0.028288643807172775, -0.046474263072013855, 0.03815764561295509, -0.014593652449548244, -0.019603444263339043, 0.011451332829892635, -0.037243276834487915, -0.002278943546116352, 0.01856115646660328, -0.029578400775790215, 0.0336594432592392, 0.03285685554146767, 0.015133766457438469, -0.06596574932336807, 0.009393242187798023, -0.0026077679358422756, 0.05947640538215637, 0.05897729843854904, 0.007924269884824753, -0.004072514828294516, 0.012945177033543587, -0.0395202562212944, -0.02786591462790966, 0.024105118587613106, -0.046198565512895584, 0.0009381155832670629, -0.054609302431344986, 0.008986185304820538, 0.02872929908335209, -0.04866775870323181, -0.025066358968615532, -0.021919623017311096, 0.005309745203703642, 0.00983395054936409, 0.016549909487366676, 0.04008118063211441, -0.0020767399109899998, -0.007275865878909826, -0.02795199677348137, -0.0025488606188446283, -0.01076311245560646, 0.011034383438527584, -0.019795749336481094, 0.005448330193758011, -0.034546393901109695, 0.03871477395296097, 0.04286575689911842, -0.031185738742351532, -0.001208954257890582, 0.023022113367915154, -0.005658875685185194, -0.054534610360860825, -0.06367857754230499, 0.0017454394837841392, 0.027979642152786255, -0.07400880753993988, -0.03192398324608803, -0.015237649902701378, -0.00021228105470072478, -0.017799822613596916, 0.018313826993107796, 0.008838768117129803, -0.022694777697324753, 0.012745295651257038, -0.01585754007101059, -0.05358360707759857, 0.0028423273470252752, 0.0030165023636072874, 0.03678622469305992, 0.03699266538023949, 0.029881775379180908, 0.011391550302505493, -0.01556929387152195, 0.01543621625751257, 0.061345428228378296, 0.028147723525762558, 0.011302695609629154, -0.0020669852383434772, -0.005725065711885691, 0.04245145991444588, 0.027743490412831306, -0.00420841109007597, -0.016067693009972572, 0.03356084227561951, 0.03008856624364853, 0.03440304100513458, 0.0037943830247968435, -0.0048486837185919285, 0.048248693346977234, 0.048550862818956375, 0.009869178757071495, 0.10755384713411331, -0.010403717868030071, -0.039145052433013916, 0.024943653494119644, -0.03228176385164261, -0.009670157916843891, -0.0007876890595071018, -0.03158961981534958, 0.05530592054128647, -0.019595272839069366, -0.005111564416438341, -0.015502259135246277, -0.020060177892446518, -0.06624702364206314, -0.005414947401732206, 0.031239314004778862, -0.010768331587314606, 0.026325415819883347, -0.018988387659192085, 0.032352264970541, 0.017680641263723373, 0.028240013867616653, 0.044983163475990295, -0.08855624496936798, 0.05583295226097107, -0.008092246018350124, 0.01952171139419079, -0.03285013511776924, -0.04764549061655998, 0.014437009580433369, -0.06149066984653473, -0.03333958983421326, 0.07593497633934021, -0.0133832897990942, 0.05832536146044731, -0.014158855192363262, -0.01445803139358759, -0.010799283161759377, -0.02715093083679676, 0.03717002272605896, 0.052216626703739166, 0.010632824152708054, 0.00705035449936986, 0.09978928416967392, -0.0567547008395195, 0.012460337020456791, 0.00011863198596984148, 0.03006872348487377, 0.04724618420004845, -0.04654427990317345, 0.000246899580815807, -0.03759598359465599, -0.00735809188336134, 0.050656404346227646, 0.01883472315967083, -0.006777309346944094, -0.005635573994368315, 0.04823184758424759, 0.05854107439517975, 0.03701230138540268, 0.05186891928315163, 0.048330627381801605, 0.059029992669820786, -0.008920269086956978, -0.01673257350921631, -0.0022714256774634123, -0.025793811306357384, -0.05417424067854881, -0.028862707316875458, -0.061677586287260056, 0.038162462413311005, -0.03126068040728569, 0.04787733405828476, 0.03708932176232338, -0.07114342600107193, -0.012569385580718517, 0.02146225981414318, -0.0005427353898994625, -0.0015359510434791446, -0.03247199207544327, 0.018014300614595413, 0.03870747610926628, -0.02418876253068447, 0.016060860827565193, -0.05388324335217476, 0.02487820014357567, -0.013894537463784218, -0.054059091955423355, -0.023505443707108498, -0.040882062166929245, 0.06155562773346901, -0.04420528560876846, 0.029918227344751358, 0.0020340625196695328, -0.027917902916669846, -0.0030559394508600235, -0.00613768957555294, 0.042708203196525574, -0.03210820257663727, -0.015789251774549484, 0.06980720907449722, 0.01456693559885025, 0.014485361985862255, 0.00298112235032022, -0.025091305375099182, 0.046763207763433456, 0.012986704707145691, 0.04448647424578667, 0.006208186503499746, -0.028629614040255547, 0.003325402969494462, -0.015790902078151703, -0.018640346825122833, 0.02393484301865101, -0.04522848501801491, 0.01533131767064333, 0.004563563037663698, -0.029025848954916, -0.024835560470819473, 0.07643850892782211, -0.012630550190806389, 0.04058736190199852, 0.03288625180721283, -0.051604531705379486, -0.04269864782691002, 0.002846585586667061, 0.0023170222993940115, 0.07575399428606033, 0.029011422768235207, -0.04337925836443901, 0.011838800273835659, -0.00011576860561035573, -0.026691708713769913, -0.041266947984695435, -0.004068602807819843, 0.024526191875338554, -0.03178609535098076, -0.010725517757236958, 0.00411901855841279, -0.021911464631557465, 0.033583808690309525, 0.003619567258283496, 0.06113641336560249, 0.08112666755914688, -0.019057398661971092, -0.01497857179492712, 0.00028870676760561764, -0.013717086985707283, 0.01235784962773323, -0.005559196230024099, -0.011479263193905354, -0.01155478972941637, 0.00873635895550251, -0.021312542259693146, -0.008735932409763336, -0.015285776928067207, -0.0410136841237545, 0.06200716271996498, -0.017310036346316338, -0.0018029111670330167, -0.025074603036046028, -0.033472444862127304, -0.02252318523824215, 0.032341137528419495, 0.04047971963882446, -0.08876142650842667, -0.054556939750909805, -0.003914135508239269, 0.048465657979249954, 0.03789767250418663, -0.044605329632759094, 0.04974334314465523, 0.04800473526120186, 0.0517159067094326, -0.0298260860145092, -0.03610790893435478, 0.013205502182245255, -0.011725813150405884, -0.02925475686788559, -0.03188013285398483, -0.008840572088956833, 0.019866032525897026, -0.012827175669372082 ]